Polymath of the Baroque: Agostino Steffani and His Music
COLIN TIMMS
OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
P B...
22 downloads
1042 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Polymath of the Baroque: Agostino Steffani and His Music
COLIN TIMMS
OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
P B
Agostino Steffani as suffragan bishop of Münster: oil painting, , by Gerhard Kappers (Bertha Jordaan-van Heek Stiftung, Haus Welbergen, Ochtrup; by permission)
P B Agostino Steffani and His Music C T
1
1
Oxford New York Auckland Bangkok Buenos Aires Cape Town Chennai Dar es Salaam Delhi Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kolkata Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Mumbai Nairobi São Paulo Shanghai Taipei Tokyo Toronto
Copyright © by Oxford University Press, Inc. Published by Oxford University Press, Inc. Madison Avenue, New York, New York www.oup.com Oxford is a registered trademark of Oxford University Press All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Oxford University Press. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Timms, Colin. Polymath of the baroque : Agostino Steffani and his music / Colin Timms. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references (p. ) and index. ISBN --- . Steffani, Agostino, ‒. . Composers—Italy—Biography. I. Title. ML.S T '.— dc
Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper
T S
This page intentionally left blank
P
I first heard of Steffani on a Saturday morning in or , when Philip Radcliffe mentioned his name and played a few bars of his music—on the piano—in one of his famous ‘history’ lectures to music undergraduates at the University of Cambridge. My interest in Italian composers was later encouraged there by Michael Talbot, then working on Albinoni, and at King’s College London by Thurston Dart, who supervised my M.Mus. on Severi and my earliest researches into Steffani. The presence of the latter’s autograph scores in the British Library made him an obvious choice for a Ph.D. dissertation on his chamber duets. I knew little of his operas, solo cantatas, or sacred music when I decided, in the s, to embark on this book: the work that was required to make good these deficiencies explains why it has taken so long to complete. Over the years I have incurred debts of gratitude to many people for assistance, encouragement, or advice. In addition to those named above, I am particularly grateful to Brian Trowell, for continuing supervision and support. The late Alec Hyatt King and especially Oliver Neighbour granted me liberal access to the Royal Music manuscripts in the British Library and to much else besides. Many other librarians, archivists, and curators, in this country, Europe, America, and elsewhere allowed me to examine their holdings in person, answered written enquiries, supplied photographic reproductions, and granted permission for them to be reproduced: I cannot name all of them here but gratefully acknowledge their assistance. Lowell Lindgren drew my attention to a new Steffani cantata and generously shared his discovery of the composer’s letters to Giuseppe Riva. Rebecca Herissone alerted me to the Steffani transcriptions in the Magdalene College partbooks. Other information or material was kindly given or lent by Donald Burrows, Tim Crawford, Victor Crowther, Elizabeth Dunstan, Harry Diack Johnstone, the late J. Merrill Knapp, Pierluigi Petrobelli, Howard Picton, Dorothea Schröder, Marianne Tilch, and Peter Wollny. For assistance of other kinds I am indebted to Andrew Barker, Benedict Benedikz, Eddy Bénimédourène, Irena Cholij, Desmond Costa, Norbert Dubowy, Nigel Fortune, Anna Greig, Rainer Heyink, Anthony Hicks, Ian Ledsham, Andrea Luppi, Monika Pfützenreutter, Paul and Lucia Roberts, Ruth Taylor, Richard Verdi, and John Whenham; I apologize to anyone inadvertently omitted. Jenny Whenham typed the first draft of chapters – ; Michael Talbot read and improved them and chapter ; Duncan Fielden produced the music examples. The research on which this study is based was made possible by financial assistance from many sources. I am grateful to the Italian government and the University
viii
of London for funding research in Italy and the purchase of microfilms, respectively; to the Faculty of Arts, School of Performance Studies, School of Humanities, and Department of Music of the University of Birmingham for travel and research grants; to the British Academy, for overseas conference grants and small personal research grants; to the University of Birmingham, for periods of study leave; to the Arts and Humanities Research Board, for the period of research leave during which the first draft of this book was completed and the research grant that facilitated the inclusion of many music examples and illustrations; to the Handel Institute, for assistance with reproduction fees; and to the Georg-Friedrich-Händel-Gesellschaft and Bärenreiter Verlag for permission to reprint material from Händel-Jahrbuch, ; to colleagues, friends, and family, for patience and support; and to those at Oxford University Press who have assisted in the production of this volume. My greatest debt, however, is to my late wife, Sue, and our children, Naomi and Christopher. For many years Steffani was virtually a member of the family, and sometimes a very demanding one. Sue would have loved to see this book. C. T. Birmingham February
C
List of Abbreviations
xi
A Note on Currencies Introduction
xiii
xv
P I: T L
Castelfranco and Padua, –
Munich –
Court and Chamber Musician Director of Chamber Music
Hanover –
Musical and Operatic Background Kapellmeister Envoyé Extraordinaire
Düsseldorf – Statesman and Bishop Musician
Apostolic Vicar of North Germany – The Provostship of Seltz Problems in Padua Retirement and Return Coda
P II: T M
The Sacred Works Psalmodia vespertina () Early Manuscript Works Sacer Ianus quadrifrons () Later Manuscript Works Doubtful Works
x
The Operas, I: General Survey
Subject and Spectacle Steffani’s Writing for the Voice Aria Technique and Form Instruments and Accompaniments Duets Overtures and Dances Reception
The Operas, II: Case Studies
Music and Drama in Alarico il Baltha Niobe, Amphion, and Max Emanuel Problems in the Revision of Alessandro Ariosto, Mauro, and Steffani: Orlando generoso Arminio: Apologia pro Pasticcio The Question of Tassilone
The Chamber Music
Cantatas for Solo Voice Chamber Duets Canon and Chronology Content and Style Structure Revisions Reception Other Works
Conclusion:
Personality and Achievement
Documents Steffani’s Autobiography () Steffani’s Letter to Giacomo Antonio Stievani () Arrangements for Opera in Munich in
Appendix A:
Appendix B:
Catalogue of Steffani’s Musical Works
Appendix C:
Analyses of Steffani’s Operas
Notes
Bibliography Index
L A
Bibliographical Abbreviations CE DBI DTB Grove MGG NCE Opera Grove RISM
The Catholic Encyclopedia (New York: Robert Appleton, – ) Dizionario biografico degli italiani, directed by Alberto Maria Ghisalberti (Rome: Istituto della Enciclopedia italiana, – ) Denkmäler der Tonkunst in Bayern (= Denkmäler Deutscher Tonkunst, Zweite Folge), vols. (Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel, then Augsburg: Filser, – ) The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians, nd ed., ed. Stanley Sadie and John Tyrrell, vols. (London: Macmillan, ) Die Musik in Geschichte und Gegenwart, ed. Friedrich Blume et al., vols. (Kassel: Bärenreiter, –) New Catholic Encyclopedia (Washington, D.C.: Catholic University of America, –; reprint Palatine, Ill.: Jack Heraty, ) The New Grove Dictionary of Opera, ed. Stanley Sadie and Christina Bashford, vols. (London: Macmillan, ) Répertoire international des sources musicales (Kassel: Bärenreiter, and Munich: Henle, –)
Libraries and Archives Libraries and archives are generally referred to by RISM sigla (which are listed also in Grove); the British Library, for example, is GB-Lbl. Two additional sigla have been devised: D-Mbsa I-Rscge
Munich, Bayerisches Hauptstaatsarchiv Rome, Sacra Congregatio pro Gentium Evangelizatione seu de Propaganda Fide xi
xii
Other Abbreviations and Conventions A B bc bsn C M MS(S) org rec S T va vn Acts/scenes: Clefs: Keys: Dates:
alto bass basso continuo bassoon cantus mezzo-soprano manuscript(s) organ recorder(s) soprano (male or female) tenor viola(s) violin(s) II/ means Act II, scene . G denotes a treble clef, C a tenor, etc. upper case denotes a major key, lower case a minor. Catholic countries employed New Style, which had been introduced by Pope Gregory XIII in , but protestant Hanover and England used Old Style until March and September , respectively; Old Style was ten days behind New in the seventeenth century and eleven days behind in the eighteenth (Hatton, George I, ).
Letters perform various symbolic functions in this book. A poetical rhyme scheme is shown by a run of lower-case letters (for example, abba). Italic letters denote musical forms: lower case (aba) for internal (movement) form, upper case (ABA) for external (work) form. Melodic phrases in a piece of music are labelled in parentheses— (a), (b), etc.—in the text but without parentheses in the tables. Letters in single quotes (‘a’, ‘b’, etc.) refer to the aria types defined in Chapter and shown in Appendix C, Table A.. In quotations from sources, abbreviations, when first used, are expanded, letters added being shown in italic; added words or explanations are given in square brackets. For translations from Latin I am grateful to Desmond Costa and Ruth Taylor; those from French, German, and Italian are my own.
A N C
One cannot study the life of such a cosmopolitan figure as Steffani without considering the relative value of the currencies used in seventeenth- and eighteenth-century Europe. The information that follows is taken largely from the articles on ‘Coins’ and on individual currencies in the first edition of Chambers, Cyclopaedia (), and partly from Fuld, The Book of World-Famous Music. South Germany and Austria used the gold and silver florin (or gulden) and the copper kreuzer and pfennig: there were pfennigs to a kreuzer and kreuzer to a florin. Central and northern Germany also used the silver thaler (‘dollar’ or ‘rixdollar’), which was worth kreuzer; furthermore, the thaler was worth groschen (or pfennigs) in Leipzig and marks (or schillings) in Hamburg or Berlin. The florin (or gulden) was roughly equivalent to shillings sterling, the thaler to s. d. (in Nuremberg) or s. d. (in Hamburg); there were therefore just under . thalers to the pound. Steffani wrote in that thalers were worth about one-third of a pound, or s. d. In Venice the silver ducat (or justin) was worth s. d., that is, just under three-quarters of a Roman scudo; the gold zecchino (sequin) was worth about s., or thalers. It is hard to establish the purchasing power of such amounts. According to de Vries, who shows that exchange rates were relatively stable between and , ‘the daily wage of skilled manual labor in Holland, where wages may well have been the highest in Europe, were usually near guilder per day throughout most of the th and th centuries’ (Economy of Europe, p. x). If a Dutch labourer worked for days, his annual earnings ( guilders) must have been equivalent to £ sterling, or thalers. Steffani’s annual salary as Kapellmeister at Hanover was , thalers, plus expenses of thalers per day. In his employer, Duke Ernst August, paid thalers for a pair of boots with buckles; at the same time, a calf cost thaler groschen, a goose cost groschen, sixty eggs cost groschen, and a pound of beef cost pfennigs (Fischer, Musik in Hannover, ).
xiii
This page intentionally left blank
I
Steffani was a remarkable figure. Born in at Castelfranco, on the Venetian terra firma, he was taken to Germany at the age of thirteen and, apart from three years in Italy, remained there— at the courts of Munich, Hanover, and Düsseldorf — for the rest of his life. He began as a musician — singer, organist, harpsichordist, and composer—but like many other artists became an accomplished courtier and diplomat. Unusually, however, he proved so adept in these roles that at Hanover he was given major diplomatic responsibility and at Düsseldorf was appointed president of the Palatine government. A prominent politician and administrator in middle age, in later years he was essentially a man of the church. Alongside music and diplomacy, and threading through both, he had pursued an ecclesiastical career that culminated in his appointment as bishop of Spiga and apostolic vicar of north Germany. He thus was deeply involved in affairs of church and state at a time of great upheaval in Europe. It would be difficult for one person to write a truly comprehensive account of such a versatile and industrious figure. The emphasis in this book is on Steffani’s musical activities and compositions: his diplomatic and ecclesiastical careers are discussed, but mainly to round out a portrait of the man, gain insight into his character, and thus inform an assessment of his musical works. One justification for this approach, perhaps, is that while his achievements as a diplomat and bishop have been overtaken by subsequent events, his music survives and can still be performed and enjoyed. During his lifetime his musical activities probably helped to smooth his path in public life, while his eminence as a man of affairs lent his compositions a curiosity value that they would otherwise have lacked. He may have been regarded as a phenomenon, but he was widely loved and respected. He was also extremely well known. Today he is little more than a name in the histories of music, and his compositions are largely unknown. The neglect is entirely unjustified: Steffani was one of the finest composers of his age. Alfred Einstein described him as ‘obviously the greatest Italian composer between Carissimi and Scarlatti’;1 for Scarlatti one might substitute Handel. A wonderful melodist and skilled contrapuntist, he also possessed a finely tuned ear for harmony (horizontal as well as vertical), texture, and the sonorities of voices and instruments. Sensuous beauty, elegance, and grace are the hallmarks of his music, which also displays a scrupulous attention to the rhythm, sound, and meaning of words, and to the subtleties of dramatic situation. He made a decisive contribution to the development of opera in Germany and was universally admired for his chamxv
xvi
ber duets, ‘the smoothly finished counterpoint of which even Handel could only imitate but not surpass’.2 In an age when Italian musicians found employment all over Europe, Steffani was one of the most enduring links between his native land and the north—not just Germany, but England as well (he was president of the Academy of Vocal, later named Ancient, Music) — and one of the earliest and most effective channels through which the French style was disseminated in Germany and combined with the Italian to form the musical language of Handel and Bach. In historical terms he was a bridge between the mid- and the late Baroque and between the French and Italian styles, both of which he cultivated on German soil. Handel and Bach are only the greatest of the composers who came under his influence in the early eighteenth century. Information on Steffani began to appear soon after his death: Mattheson listed some of his operas in his chronology of Hamburg productions in Der musicalische Patriot () and praised him in Der vollkommene Capellmeister (); Walther drew on Mattheson for his entry on Steffani in his Musicalisches Lexikon (). But a major milestone was reached with the publication in about of the Memoirs of the Life of Sig. Agostino Steffani, some time Master of the Electoral Chapel at Hanover, and afterwards Bishop of Spiga. Since these predate Mainwaring’s Memoirs of the Life of the Late George Frederic Handel (), they may be regarded as the earliest biography of a composer; unlike Mainwaring’s Memoirs, however, they were anonymous, undated, and printed in large oblong format for binding into manuscripts of their subject’s duets. They were reprinted in in The Gentleman’s Magazine, with a letter identifying their author as John Hawkins. A note in a copy of the Memoirs in the British Library states that they were ‘Probably printed by John Johnson, [Cheap]side, London’.3 According to Walpole, they were published in , but they must have been printed by mid-August , when Hawkins sent a copy to James Harris, a supporter of Handel and father of the first earl of Malmesbury.4 Hawkins’s principal source, as he himself wrote, was ‘Mr Handel, to whose laudable concern for the memory of this great genius [Steffani], as also to that of the truly learned Dr Pepusch, the author of these memoirs is indebted for the greater part of his information’. Hawkins gathered his information in ‘the early part’ of his life5 — that is, probably the s, when he became a member of the Academy of Ancient Music and acquainted with Pepusch (his interest in Steffani may have been quickened by the latter’s association with the academy). Factual details in the Memoirs are occasionally garbled or suspect (the memories of Handel and Pepusch could be unreliable), but the portrait of Steffani that emerges is broadly accurate and sympathetic. The first substantial account of his life in Italian was published in Venice in . Its author, the music theorist, mathematician, and architect Count Giordano Riccati, may have been prompted to write his account by the commendation of Steffani that had appeared in Padre Martini’s Esemplare, ossia Saggio fondamentale ( –), although he did not rely on it. As a native of Castelfranco, he may also have been motivated by local pride, for he made use of local historical information and of the collection of Steffani’s papers in the archives of the Sacra Congregatio de Propaganda Fide in Rome (now known as the Fondo Spiga). Given the nature of these sources, it is understandable that Riccati’s account is rather patchy, but it remains, nevertheless, an original and valuable contribution.
A new era in the history of Steffani studies was opened by Friedrich Chrysander, whose discussion of the composer in his biography of Handel (– ) is still one of the most comprehensive accounts of his life and works. Drawing on archives and libraries in north Germany, Chrysander examined Steffani’s sacred music and chamber duets in some detail and sought to establish his output of operas at Hanover. Discussion of the latter was hampered, however, by the fact that Chrysander knew only two of the scores: Le rivali concordi and La lotta d’Hercole con Acheloo. Access to the Steffani sources in the Royal Music Library was enjoyed by W. G. Cusins, author of the remarkable article on him in the first edition of Grove’s Dictionary. A performer, composer, and Master of the Queen’s Music, Cusins responded enthusiastically and perceptively to Steffani’s works: it was he, not Chrysander, who recognized La lotta as a piece from which Handel had borrowed in Theodora. Further light was shed on Steffani’s life in the decades around . Between and Franz Wilhelm Woker painted a detailed picture of his ecclesiastical career, providing a context for Adolph Tibus’s account () of his period as suffragan of Münster. The background to his achievements as a composer was sketched in histories of music or opera at Munich, Hanover, and Düsseldorf, and Arthur Neisser’s dissertation on his opera Servio Tullio was published in . The same decades witnessed the edition of archival materials relating to Steffani, including correspondence with patrons, and culminated in Einstein’s detailed study () of his Munich years. Acquaintance with his music was encouraged by the publication in , , and of three volumes in the Denkmäler der Tonkunst in Bayern: one contained chamber duets, cantatas, and motets; another, the opera Alarico il Baltha; and the third, extracts from his other operas. The third volume also included an essay by Hugo Riemann on ‘Steffani as Opera-composer’. An assessment of his cantatas, by Eugen Schmitz, followed in .6 Since World War II the volume of research on Steffani has grown significantly. In and Josef Loschelder published extracts from letters in the Fondo Spiga, and five years later William Baxter Jr. completed a dissertation on his life and works. New biographical information was found by Nicoletta Billio D’Arpa (– ); the Fondo Spiga was inventoried by Michael Feldkamp (), and Steffani’s correspondence with Giuseppe Riva was edited (Timms, ; Lindgren and Timms, forthcoming). His operas, too, attracted increasing attention. Gerhard Croll edited Tassilone (), completed a bibliographical study of his life and dramatic works (), produced an essay on his Düsseldorf operas (), and contributed the ‘Steffani’ article to MGG (). Three years earlier, Andrea Della Corte had discussed Alarico and Tassilone; three years later, Philip Keppler investigated Steffani’s Hanover operas, later the subject of a dissertation by Candace Marles (). The political background to these operas had been provided by Georg Schnath in his monumental Geschichte Hannovers (– ), while the artistic context was painted by Heinrich Sievers (, ), Schrewe and Schmidt (), Wallbrecht (), and Schneider (). Two of Steffani’s Hanover operas have been published in facsimile editions — the two that were known by Chrysander. The time is now ripe for an assessment of Steffani’s music in relation to its contexts. The study presented in this volume is partly a work of synthesis, partly the fruit
xvii
xviii
of original research. The biographical chapters are indebted to the findings of earlier scholars, but they also incorporate new material from archives, especially those in Munich, Hanover, and Rome, and the discussion of Steffani’s music is based on personal examination of the scores and librettos. As the first published book on Steffani’s life and music, this volume must serve an introductory purpose. It is hoped that it will increase awareness and appreciation of the composer and his works and stimulate interest in both among scholars, performers, music lovers, and those interested in Italian culture in northern Europe in the years around . It will not be the last word on its subject. As I finished writing, I acquired a copy—too late in one sense — of Claudia Kaufold’s -page book () on Steffani’s diplomatic activity at Hanover. A similar volume could be written on every other phase of his extraordinary career. Letters from Steffani, and documents about him, must be lying, awaiting discovery, in many of the courtly archives of Europe. If his Hanover operas seem likely to yield a crop of new Handel ‘borrowings’,7 the production of La libertà contenta at the Barber Institute, University of Birmingham, in November showed that his stage works have the power to move and entertain a modern audience.8 Further research remains to be done, and it promises to yield important and exciting results.
P I T L
This page intentionally left blank
C P ‒
Castelfranco is a pleasant, fortified town, situated in the fertile plain to the northwest of Venice and marking the intersection of several important routes—from Venice to Bassano, Trent, and Bolzano; from Padua north to Asolo and Belluno; and from Treviso west to Vicenza. Less than kilometres to the north the land begins to rise toward the foothills of the Dolomites; from there the River Lástego flows down via Castelfranco to join the Brenta near Padua. The town is dominated by its handsome castle surrounded by a moat, with its straight walls and imposing tower over the east gate (Fig. .). The fortress was built in – by the comune of Treviso as a defence against the Paduans, who responded by building a similar castle at nearby Cittadella. Almost perfectly square in design, the fortress of Castelfranco had four gates and bridges and eight towers. When it was finished, Treviso sent a colony of one hundred noble families to occupy it, granting them houses and farms free of taxes and charges: hence the name ‘Castelfranco’. During the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, the most turbulent period in its history, the city was dominated by a variety of powers, but in , along with Treviso, it finally came under the jurisdiction of Venice. It remained so until the fall of the Venetian Republic in . Apart from the years –, following the League of Cambrai, and despite the later wars of succession in Spain and Poland, in which Venice was neutral but her territories were traversed by belligerents, these four centuries of Venetian rule were a period of relative peace and stability. The tallest tower of the castle still proudly displays the symbol of Venice, the lion of St Mark, which was brought to Castelfranco by the Venetian patrician Pietro Gradenigo in the sixteenth century. Inside the castle walls, in the centre, stands the cathedral of San Liberale. One of its chapels houses a celebrated painting of the Virgin Enthroned with Saints George and Francis by Giorgione, who was born in the town in about . It is here, in the (then) church of Santa Maria e San Liberale, on July , that Steffani was baptised.1 He was one day old. His parents were Camillo and Paolina de Stievani; there were two godfathers — Gherardo Gherardini and Domenigo Rubini—but apparently no godmother. Steffani never forgot that he was a subject of the Most Serene Republic of Venice. Information on his background is found in a manuscript ‘Catalogo historico cronologico . . . di Castelfranco’, compiled between and by Nadal [Natale] Melchiori,2 an artist who was born there in . ‘Stievani’ was the local dialectal form of the family name, of which the normal spelling would have been ‘Stefani’, with the
. Castelfranco in the eighteenth century (La cinta muraria di Castelfranco): oil painting, studio of Pietro Longhi (Comune di Castelfranco Veneto; by permission)
stress on the first syllable. Agostino inserted an extra ‘f ’ when he settled in Germany, to ensure that this stress would be retained. His ancestors moved to Castelfranco in about from Padua, but more distant forbears can be traced to Venice. In a certain Giulia Fermana (or Perina) Da Ponte left them some houses in the contrada (district) of San Marcuola, in the vicinity of the Ghetto; the deeds later fell into the hands of the Labia family, and Steffani tried to retrieve them when he was in Padua in .3 Shortly after his death in , his cousin, Antonio Scapinelli, archpriest of Castelfranco, drew up a family tree in support of his claim to a share of Steffani’s estate (Fig. .).4 From this it emerges that Agostino’s father married twice. His first wife, Helena, bore a daughter, Helena Perina (born June ) but died in childbirth or shortly thereafter. His second wife, Paolina Terzago, who may have been a cousin, bore seven children, of whom the only ones to reach maturity were her first son, Ventura Giacomo (born January ); her fifth, Agostino; and her only daughter, Ippolita (born July ). Agostino appears to have been named after his closest brother, Agostino Francesco (born December ). Their father probably died in ,5 but their mother lived for a further ten years, attaining the age of seventy-two.6 There is little information on the family’s status or circumstances. Even the occupation of Steffani’s father remains unknown. Hawkins, presumably relaying information from Handel, wrote that the composer’s parents ‘were not distinguished for their rank in life’,7 but the document nominating him as bishop in states that he came from a respectable Catholic family (‘ex Catholicis honestisque parentibus’),8 and Steffani’s autobiographical letter of that year spells out what kind of luxury the word
‒ Gasparo = Paolina Terzago
Giacomo
(1) Helena = Camillo = (2) Paolina Terzago
Angela = Bartolomeo Scapinelli
Helena Perina (b. 29.6.45)
Pietro Giovanni (b. 11.8.49) Ventura Giacomo (b. 2.1.48)
Agostino Francesco (b. 3.12.52)
Francesco Innocente (b. 28.12.50)
Ippolita (b. 19.7.56)
Agostino (b. 25.7.54)
Francesco Domenico (b. 2.9.57)
Antonio Scapinelli (d. 1735), archpriest of Castelfranco
?
Antonio Scapinelli Doctor of Medicine, known 1713 and 1718 Bartolomeo Scapinelli Doctor of Law, 1731
.
Steffani’s immediate family in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries
‘honestus’ could imply.9 Melchiori included the family in a register of those ‘who were, and are, of good standing in the generality of the citizens (‘cittadini’) and accustomed to enter the councils of the community’.10 If the cittadini of Castelfranco belonged to the layer of society immediately below the patriciate, as did those of Venice, the Steffani were probably a professional family and reasonably well off. This was evidently the case with the Terzago, and apparently with the Scapinelli, with whom, also, the Steffani were related by marriage: Antonio’s cousin, another Antonio, was a doctor of medicine and was elected ‘cavalier di comun’ at the first attempt in ; his son Bartolomeo graduated as a doctor of law at the University of Padua in . It was with Ventura and Agostino, however, that the Steffani achieved distinction. Melchiori’s account of the family is concerned almost exclusively with these brothers. Like Agostino, Ventura studied music as a boy; in , at about nineteen years of age, he published a book of poetry. At some stage he was adopted by his wealthy maternal uncle Marc’Antonio Terzago, ‘collaterale’ (treasurer or chief cashier) of Padua, whose surname he used throughout his distinguished career and whose fortune he inherited. How much money Ventura possessed is not known, but when Venice attempted to raise funds to finance the War of Candia (– ), his friends tried in vain to persuade him to purchase noble status at a cost of , Venetian ducats. Like his younger brother, he also served two electors of Bavaria as librettist, secretary, and counsellor; Steffani set four of his librettos. In Ventura himself was appointed ‘collaterale’ of Padua, whither he returned in to discharge his responsibilities ‘con prudenza e splendore’.11 He died of a fever at Brugine on October at the age of forty-five.12 Agostino assumed, since Ventura did not marry,
that he would be his brother’s principal heir, but he seems to have inherited little of his fortune.13 Though Castelfranco saw his birth, Padua is the place that Steffani came to regard as his home town (‘patria’). An ancient city and the see of a bishop, Padua had long been an important religious, cultural, and commercial centre. In addition to the Giotto frescoes in the Scrovegni chapel (the Madonna dell’Arena, built in ), the city could boast one of the oldest universities in Europe and the famous Basilica del Santo. At the university, founded in , Prosdocimus de Beldemandis had taught music in the fifteenth century and Galileo had been professor of mathematics for eighteen years ( –). Dante, Petrarch, Bembo, and Tasso had been counted among its students, who in the seventeenth century numbered roughly ,. The basilica is the shrine of St Anthony, a Franciscan friar and priest, celebrated for the eloquence of his preaching, who died at Padua in at the age of thirty-six. Building began in and continued into the fifteenth century; bronzes for the high altar and a choir screen of marble were furnished by Donatello. The choir itself, the ‘cappella’, was officially established in ; two great organs were completed in , and a third was added in . Secular music was encouraged in the sixteenth century by a variety of learned academies and in the seventeenth by Pio Enea degli Obizzi, a local nobleman and generous patron of the arts.14 Opera came to Padua, in the shape of Domenico Gabrielli’s Mauritio, at the relatively late date of . Steffani was sent to school in Padua and there made a number of life-long friends. Riccati’s statement that his first studies were undertaken ‘in patria’ with teachers maintained by the comune15 may refer to his early years in Castelfranco, but the composer himself informs us that he studied in Padua ‘with many other boys’.16 Among these was the young Count Girolamo Frigimelica Roberti, who as a poet was to write librettos for Carlo Francesco Pollarolo, Alessandro Scarlatti, and Caldara and to become principe of the Accademia dei Ricovrati in Padua, and as an architect designed villas in Padua, Vicenza, Modena, and Stra. Steffani recalled their childhood in a letter of : ‘I should be all the more sensible of such a dear memory, for neither the passing of fifty years, nor the distance of a thousand miles, nor the horrible parapet of the frozen Alps has been able to make me forget the consideration with which Your Most Illustrious Lordship honoured me at the beginning of my adolescence’.17 Another schoolfriend, Angelo Maria De’ Lazzara, became a canon of the Basilica del Santo; on March Frigimelica Roberti wrote to Steffani from ‘la stanza del nostro Signor Abbate Lazara’ in Venice.18 Melchiori says that Steffani maintained a palace (‘teneva di continuo palaggio’) in Padua, but this seems unlikely: in he stayed in Ca’ Contarini and in the palace of Frigimelica Roberti, who was then in Modena,19 before finding accommodation of his own. It was also in Padua that Steffani embarked in earnest on his musical education and career. From October to July , when he was between the ages of ten and thirteen, he was a treble in the choir of the Basilica del Santo.20 The cappella during this period comprised about sixteen singers, three violinists, two players of the viola and one or two of the violone, one bassoonist, and three organists; in and there was also a theorbist. The maestro di cappella was Antonio Dalla Tavola, who had published a collection of Masses for three to eight voices and continuo (Venice, )
‒ and composed the music for L’amor pudico, an equestrian ballet devised by Pio Enea degli Obizzi and performed in Padua in .21 Dalla Tavola was highly regarded at the Santo as a musician and organizer of musical events. When he died in , he owned over two hundred manuscript compositions and about one hundred printed collections of music, including works by such north Italian composers as Costanzo Porta, Giovanni Croce, Monteverdi, Alessandro Grandi, and Giovanni Rovetta, and the Roman Orazio Tarditi. He presumably introduced Steffani to some of this repertory, as well as to the rudiments of music: the hexachords and solmization, the church modes, and the intricacies of mensural notation. Such experience as a choirboy was decisive for Steffani’s development as a composer: it explains why his works are nearly all vocal and how he became such a master of melody. His talent was clearly prodigious. He must have shown before going to Padua that he had a promising voice and an aptitude for music, as well as a high level of general intelligence. At his audition for the cappella of the Santo he sang with ‘vivacity’ and to the ‘great satisfaction’ of all present. Even at the age of ten, he was paid at a relatively high rate. During some months of his employment, he and a falsettist, Anselmo Marconi, were the only sopranos available, although there should have been four, which was the average number of singers in each of the other voice ranges. He must, therefore, have had a strong voice, possibly a beautiful one, with accurate intonation and a reliable technique. That he was better than the average choirboy of his age is suggested by the fact that he was frequently asked to sing on special occasions elsewhere—for example, in Ferrara on the feast of the Finding of the Holy Cross (May , at the request of ‘Marchese Obizi’ [probably Pio Enea], and May ), in Vicenza (May ), in Monselice on the feast of St James (July and ), and at two churches in Padua, the Eremitani (August and May ) and the Gesuiti (Good Friday, ). There may have been other such occasions, for he was often recorded as absent. At the ages of eleven and twelve he also sang in opera in Venice. The opportunity for this arose from the presence at the basilica of Carlo Pallavicino, who was roughly twenty years older than Steffani and about to make his name as an opera composer. Pallavicino has long been known as an organist in Padua from December to August , prior to his appointment as vice-Kapellmeister at Dresden, but it is now known that he was active at the Santo from as early as , first as a treble, then from , after his voice had broken, as a tenor. During carnival he sang in an opera in Venice, and in late February he was appointed third organist in Padua, a new post entitled ‘organista ai concerti’. In January he wrote to the ‘Presidenti dell’Arca’, the governors of the basilica, requesting permission to take Steffani, Antonio Viviani (bass), and Nicolò Piva (violin) to Venice, to appear in an opera of his own composition; he promised that they would be back in Padua for the celebration of the ‘Santissima Lingua’, the feast of the Translation of the Tongue of St Anthony, on February. Permission was granted, and the threesome presumably took part in the première of Pallavicino’s first opera, Demetrio, at the Teatro San Moisè; Steffani probably sang one of the two ‘young’ roles — Aurilla, the daughter of Demetrio, or Zerbillo, a page22 —and thus became familiar at an early age with the musical style and the world of Venetian opera.
His performance must have made a good impression, for in the following December one of the ‘presidenti’, Ubertino Descalzo, acting on behalf of the podestà (the Venetian governor) of Padua, Carlo Ruzini, asked his colleagues to allow Steffani to sing in Venice again, in an opera during the forthcoming carnival. Permission was granted, as before, but this time the prodigy did not arrive back in time for the ‘Santissima Lingua’ and was consequently suspended from duty. Apologizing to the ‘presidenti’, he insisted that he had wanted to honour his commitment but had been prevented from returning by a very important person (‘sogetto riguardevole’): maybe a nobleman had so enjoyed his performance in the theatre as to command him to sing again, possibly on more than one occasion and possibly in private. Steffani asked to be reinstated in his post, and his request was granted on account of his long and good service (‘longa servitù et buon servitio’). The episode suggests that, even at the tender age of twelve, he had a good idea of his own worth, could see that the authorities at the basilica needed him, and knew how to elicit the desired response from his superiors—a skill that would prove useful in later life. The last document relating to him at the Santo is a simple statement of his leaving to enter the service of the elector of Bavaria: ‘. Luglio [Agostino da Castelfranco] Andò a servir l’Altezza Serenissima del Duca di Baviera’. Hawkins conjectured that Steffani had, ‘in his infancy, been a singer in the choir of some neighbouring cathedral church, or chapel’ and asserted that the youngster ‘had not served above two years in the choir, when a nobleman of Germany, who had been at Venice to be present at the diversions of the carnival, happened, upon some public occasion, to hear him sing, and was so pleased with his voice and behaviour, and those signs of genius, which by this time he began to discover, that upon application to the chapel-master, he procured his discharge from the choir, and took him to Bavaria, the place of his residence’.23 This account, which presumably was passed on by Handel, is confirmed by Steffani in his autobiographical letter of July to Count Antonio Maria Fede, the Tuscan and Palatine diplomatic resident in Rome during the Saxon’s years in the city: ‘I was taken to the first [court] as a boy by the late Elector Ferdinand Maria who, when I was presented to him in Padua, where I studied with many other boys, was attracted by a certain something about me — to what end I do not know — and, having taken me to Munich with him, placed me in the care of Count Tattenbach, his then master of the horse’. 24 Elsewhere in this letter Steffani claimed to have served the Bavarian court for twenty-two years, which, since he left there in , would mean that he arrived in . Ferdinand Maria had planned to go to Italy that year, but his visit was postponed to . The electoral party left Munich on April, travelled via Trent and Verona, reached Padua on May, and arrived in Venice on May.25 On June they left again for Padua, where they stayed, in the Castello Cattaio, until July; during these five weeks they went to Mass and Vespers at a number of local churches, including the Basilica del Santo. It is probably here that they heard Steffani sing, not on the stage in Venice and not during carnival.26 His statement that he was presented to the elector in Padua is unequivocal and credible, but the idea that he did not know why the elector was interested in him is a self-effacing fiction reflecting the fact that,
‒ when he wrote this letter, he was on the verge of nomination as a bishop and anxious to conceal his musical past. That the electoral party travelled back to Munich via Castelfranco lends further weight to the accounts of both Steffani and Hawkins. Before taking the boy to Munich, the elector presumably wanted to consult his parents. The latter must have been apprehensive: Agostino was very young, and they could not know what would become of him in a foreign land. But they may also have felt honoured and excited: at Munich he would receive a good Catholic education, make contacts at court, and have far greater opportunities for advancement than he would, as their younger son, at home. The offer could hardly be refused, and five years later Steffani’s father evidently felt that the family had been right to accept it.27 The party continued its journey with little delay, travelling via Bassano, Trent, Bressanone (Brixen), Innsbruck, and Tegernsee. They reached Munich on Monday, July , Steffani’s thirteenth birthday.
M ‒
Munich must have made an immediate impression on the thirteen-year-old Steffani.1 Founded in the twelfth century by Henry the Lion, duke of Saxony and Bavaria, who fortified an ancient monastic settlement (‘Mönche’ [Ger.]: monks) that had grown up on the banks of the River Isar, the city had been the seat of the ruling Wittelsbach dukes for more than four hundred years and capital of Bavaria for over a century. The elevation of the duchy to an electorate—the eighth in the so-called Holy Roman Empire—in had made the Wittelsbachs one of the most powerful dynasties in Europe (an elector was one of the small number of German princes entitled to take part in the election of the emperor). The prestige of the Wittelsbachs was displayed in the splendid buildings of the electoral residence (‘Residenz’: Fig. .), which were enlarged and improved in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries and housed a magnificent library and art collection. Music at the court had flourished in the later sixteenth century under Orlande de Lassus, with whom both Andrea and Giovanni Gabrieli had come to work, but the establishment had been reduced on the accession of Maximilian I in . During the Thirty Years’ War (–) Munich had been occupied by Gustavus Adolphus of Sweden, and the population of the city had fallen from , to ,; it had recovered by . After the war, however, the chapel had been restored and the foundations laid for Munich’s illustrious tradition of opera. North of the Alps only Vienna and Paris, and possibly Dresden, could rival Munich in the later seventeenth century as a place where the talents of a musical and intelligent Italian youth could be developed. The cultural orientation of the court during this period reflected political and geographical factors. The Wittelsbach electors were hungry for power and anxious to be regarded as rivals of the Austrian Hapsburgs; they bolstered their position by repeatedly entering into alliance with the French. On the other hand, when Vienna was threatened by the Turks, Bavaria came to her aid. The Wittelsbachs were sandwiched between Hapsburgs and Bourbons, the Empire and France, but lacked the power to stand up to either. Their position was reflected in, and reinforced by, the electors’ marriages: Maximilian I and his grandson Maximilian II Emanuel espoused Austrians in and , respectively, while in Ferdinand Maria, Steffani’s patron, married Henrietta Adelaide of Savoy, a cousin of Louis XIV (Figs. . and .). During the second half of the century the Wittelsbachs adapted and erected buildings in the Munich Residenz and in the city and its environs.2 In preparation for Ferdinand Maria’s wedding celebrations, Maximilian I converted a granary into an
‒
. The electoral residence (‘Residenz’) in Munich: engraving, ca. , by Michael Wening (Münchner Stadtmuseum; by permission)
opera house, a development completed in . Ferdinand Maria expressed gratitude (and relief ) at the birth of Maximilian Emanuel in by commissioning the construction, just outside the Residenz, of an enormous new church dedicated to Cajetan, a founder of the Theatine order and patron of Bavaria since ; the church was inspired by that of Sant’Andrea della Valle in Rome and built between and (the façade was added in the s). Construction had scarcely begun before the elector started work on a magnificent new summer residence, the Nymphenburg palace, in the country to the west of the city. St Cajetan (the ‘Theatinerkirche’) and the Nymphenburg palace were both being built when Steffani arrived. Seven years later the Residenz was damaged by fire; the process of restoration extended over thirty years—the last five of Ferdinand Maria’s life ( –) and the first quarter-century of his son’s reign. Maximilian II Emanuel also instigated the building, on the north side of Munich, of the miniature Lustheim palace, modelled on the Palazzo Madama in Rome, and the extensive palace of Schleißheim, which was inspired by Versailles. French cultural influence grew stronger than Italian in the eighteenth century, predominating in the work of the two François Cuvilliés, father and son. Munich was one of the first places north of the Alps where Italian opera was embraced.3 Drama with music had been known there for a very long time: medieval school dramas had been followed by the Latin plays of the Jesuits, who had been invited to settle by Albrecht V in ; Italian commedia dell’arte, with music by Lassus, had been presented in on the wedding of Duke Wilhelm and Renée of Lorraine; and
. Elector Ferdinand Maria of Bavaria: oil painting, ca. , studio of Stefano Bombelli (Residenzmuseum München, Foto BSV; by permission of the Bayerische Verwaltung der staatlichen Schlösser, Gärten und Seen)
a five-hour comedy with four changes of scene had been sung in the Residenz in February . But it was Ferdinand Maria and Henrietta Adelaide who introduced opera. Only sixteen when she married, Henrietta was an amateur singer, guitarist, and poet, and, having been brought up in Turin, essentially Italian in outlook. In , the year of his accession, Ferdinand Maria appointed as court chaplain and harpist an Italian, Giovanni Battista Maccioni, who both taught the young electress to play the harp and collaborated with her on a number of librettos. Two years later, for a visit of Emperor Ferdinand III, Maccioni wrote the words and music of a dramatic cantata, L’arpa festante, that laid the foundations for the history of opera in Munich.
‒
. Electress Henrietta Adelaide: oil painting, ca. , studio of Stefano Bombelli (Residenzmuseum München, Foto Schmidt/Nietmann [BSV]; by permission of the Bayerische Verwaltung der staatlichen Schlösser, Gärten und Seen)
The cultivation of opera, ballet, and music in general was strongly encouraged by the elector and electress, and especially by Henrietta Adelaide, who attracted numerous Italian musicians, literati, architects, painters, and craftsmen to the court. Dramatic works were performed, from , in the converted granary, the earliest large, free-standing theatre building in Germany. Known at first as the ‘Comœdihaus’ and later as the ‘Salvatortheater’, it was inaugurated as an opera house by La ninfa ritrosa, composed possibly by the court singer Pietro Zambonini. Oronte, the first opera by the Kapellmeister, Johann Caspar Kerll, was produced in . In the next ten years, and in most decades after Steffani’s arrival, there was at least one new opera a year.
Only three of the librettos name Kerll as composer, but he probably wrote about eight. The birth of Maximilian Emanuel in was celebrated by a threefold musicodramatic extravaganza: a ‘drama regio musicale’ Fedra incoronata (opera), a ‘drama guerrieroso’ Antiopa giustificata (tourney), and a ‘drama di foco’ Medea vendicativa (fireworks display).4 Having returned to Italy in , Maccioni assisted, as Bavarian agent in Rome, in the recruitment of Kerll’s successor, Ercole Bernabei, who, together with his son Giuseppe Antonio, composed all the Munich operas and tourneys between and . Munich’s achievements in opera during the third quarter of the century would bear comparison with those of any city other than Venice. Information on the court’s musical establishment may be gleaned from the ‘Besoldungsbücher’—annual ledgers recording payments to court employees of all kinds.5 The entries in each book are grouped according to administrative department. Musicians appear under two headings—‘Musicanten’ and ‘Instrumentisten und Trometer’ (or ‘Trombpetter’, etc.—the spelling varies). One might assume that the ‘Musicanten’ were singers, but the categories are not entirely separate: the instrumentalist and singer Johann Christoph Pez appears as a ‘Musicant’,6 while the ‘Cammer Musicus und Harpfenist’ (harpist) Diego Calvani is listed among the ‘Instrumentisten’. When Kerll became Kapellmeister in , the musical establishment comprised nineteen singers, three organists, seventeen instrumentalists, and fifteen to twenty trumpeters.7 The figures were very similar in , when Kerll was succeeded by Ercole Bernabei, although by then there were slightly more singers and marginally fewer instrumentalists. Eleven of the ‘Musicanten’, including Bernabei and Steffani, were Italians; two of the ‘Instrumentisten’ were harpists, one a lutenist, and another a cornettist; none of the musicians was a woman. During the s, increases in some areas were largely offset by reductions in others, but there was also a significant change: between and , the period of Steffani’s Munich operas, the number of bowed string instrumentalists rose from three to eight.8 The ledgers also indicate the relative value attached to the various posts and their incumbents. The extremes are represented by the Kapellmeister (, florins per annum) and the choirboys ( florins each). An exceptionally high salary of florins was paid to a small number of selected ‘Musicanten’ described as ‘first-class’ (‘di prima Classe’),9 but most instrumentalists, including trumpeters and string players, received between and florins; a court organist could count on . Salaries were paid quarterly; a pro rata payment was calculated precisely when an employee arrived or left during a quarter, and his wife or heir normally received his salary for the quarter in which he died. Many musicians regularly received an ‘addition’—an extra payment or a fee for some special duty. Franz Zeiller was given florins extra in and – for teaching the ‘discantist’ Alexander Hackh or Hagge the viola da gamba;10 the organist Georg Zellner received florins for tuning keyboard instruments;11 Johann Carl Seyringer earned florins for maintaining the instrument room, for copying scores and parts, and for stringing theorboes and violins.12 Zambonini and d’Ardespin were among a number of musicians employed also as valets (‘Cammerdiener’) at a salary of florins per annum. Some musicians were given supplementary rations of bread, beer, or wine (in addition to staple fare), or were allotted extra
‒ money for them. Italians were occasionally helped with the expense of travelling to or from their native land, and the ‘violist’ (or violinist) Dominicus Mayr was enabled to visit Paris.13 The impression conveyed by the ledgers is that Munich valued its musicians and treated them fairly and generously. Steffani was fortunate to be at a court where he would be well looked after and given opportunities to contribute to a distinguished musical and operatic tradition.
Court and Chamber Musician On his arrival in July the thirteen-year-old Steffani was placed in the care of Count Gottfried Wilhelm of Rheinstein and Tattenbach, a chamber counsellor (‘Kammerrath’) and Master of the Horse. Although the court was Catholic and the electress Italian, and despite the presence of Italian musicians and artists, Steffani must have found the language and customs of Munich entirely foreign, even if also somewhat exciting or fascinating. In addition to some German, the count presumably taught him about the life and history of the court. Having been recruited as a singer, Steffani doubtless put his talent to good use. He is not listed as a salaried musician during his first year, nor is there any evidence that he was a member of the orchestra.14 Nevertheless, in early he was given florins for the New Year and ‘the other thing’. Einstein suggested that this ‘other thing’ was an appearance on November in Kerll’s tourney Le pretensioni del sole, in which the role of Aurora was sung by the ‘gratioso et gratiosissimo Soprano’ Agostino.15 It is not certain that Steffani was the singer in question, but he had been a treble in Padua and there was no other Agostino at Munich who could have taken the part. Be that as it may, his musical ability became so apparent that, after a year, Count Rheinstein and Tattenbach was reimbursed his expenses16 and Steffani was transferred into the care of the Kapellmeister. From July to October —between the ages of fourteen and seventeen— Steffani was given organ lessons (and board and lodging) by Kerll, for which the latter received the considerable sum of florins per annum on top of his salary.17 From the same date Steffani was appointed a court and chamber musician (‘Hof- und Cammer Musico’) and granted a daily allowance of one and a half measures of wine and two loaves.18 He presumably was given a general education and required to perform musical duties, but there is no documentary evidence of either. He may have been expected to sing in the chapel choir, which was only a little larger than that in the Paduan basilica, but he was never listed as one of the ‘Cantorey Knaben’, who were all German. He was doubtless an ambitious and diligent pupil, and fortunate in having such an eminent teacher. Kerll, who had been a pupil of Giovanni Valentini in Vienna and of Carissimi, and possibly Frescobaldi, in Rome, was one of the finest organists, harpsichordists, and composers of his day. That Steffani made excellent progress and became an accomplished performer is suggested by his subsequent activity as an organist and by later reports of his harpsichord playing. In addition to keyboard performance, Kerll probably taught him figured bass and counterpoint and gave him his first instruction in composition.
A further indication of Steffani’s progress is the fact that, after just over two years with Kerll, his salary was raised to florins per annum.19 That by the age of sixteen he was earning the same as the court organist is a sure sign of the esteem in which he was held. His salary remained at this level for four years. During the same period, however, he was also given an annual allowance for clothing and linen. In autumn he submitted a request for a long list of items, including a coat of Dutch wool, breeches, a waistcoat, silk stockings, two hats, a sword, eight shirts, four vests, six bed-covers, and six night-caps.20 Before an answer could be given, the chamberlain’s and tailor’s offices were asked for estimates of the costs, and a statement was drawn up of the expense of maintaining Steffani during the previous year (Table .).21 A similar statement was drawn up for , when the total, excluding gratuities from the elector, amounted to florins, of which clothing and linen accounted for over . Steffani must have needed new clothes, for he was in his mid-teens and probably growing fast. Nevertheless, the treasury was concerned about the cost of maintaining him and the scale of his demands. After due deliberation, it was decreed that as from October he should be given an annual allowance of florins, paid in quarterly instalments, with which to purchase all his clothing and linen.22 Steffani’s request reveals something of his character during his teenage years. He presumably felt that he needed, deserved, or maybe had a right to the clothing and other items that he listed, and he was willing to ask for them outright. That his petition was cast in the first person singular, however, rather than the third, betrays a degree of brashness or arrogance, suggesting that he had not yet acquired the modesty and diplomacy characteristic of his maturity. His request also implies that he was socially and financially ambitious. Such ambition could have been fired by the example of Kerll, on whom the emperor had conferred a title of nobility in and Ferdinand Maria had bestowed the status of counsellor, and may help explain why relations between Steffani and his teacher came to an end. Musical considerations may also have played a part, for Kerll’s progressive ideas on composition created such friction between him and other musicians in Munich that he resigned in and moved to Vienna. Although Steffani was by this time in Rome, his relationship with Kerll does not appear to have improved. The latter’s name is conspicuously absent from the preface to his former pupil’s first publication, and .
Cost of Steffani’s maintenance in
Specification How much the Court and Chamber Musician Agostino Steffani costs per year To the Kapellmeister, for subsistence and tuition 11⁄2 measures of wine and loaves daily Clothing from the tailor’s department Linen from the chamberlain’s office
fl. fl. , kr. fl. fl.
Total for the year
fl. , kr.
‒ in September , when Steffani was back in Munich, he persuaded the treasury to withhold payment of florins that were due to Kerll; only when Steffani stated that he had received satisfaction from Kerll, in December , was the money released.23 The two men also appear to have been reconciled in August , when Steffani witnessed the attestations of several Roman composers in respect of Kerll’s Litanies for six voices.24 It is not known whether Steffani had fallen out with Kerll by autumn , but on October, after three and a quarter years with him, he was transferred into the care of a treasury official and valet named Augustin Sayler. An experienced and trusted courtier, Sayler was presumably expected to take the Italian teenager in hand, in exchange for expenses of florins per quarter.25 Meanwhile, arrangements were made for Steffani’s musical education to be continued elsewhere. After exactly a year with Sayler, at the beginning of October , the young musician was sent to Rome, ‘there, in accordance with your [the elector’s] most gracious wish and command, to perfect himself further in his art’.26 If asked where he would most like to continue his education, Steffani might well have answered ‘Rome’. The Eternal City in the later seventeenth century afforded unparalleled opportunities for a young musician to study and practise his art, hear a wide range of works by other composers, observe the most accomplished performers in Italy, and come into contact with wealthy princes of church and state, vying with each other in their patronage of the arts. An army of choirmasters, organists, and singers were employed in the city’s churches, of which many were being rebuilt or refurbished in Baroque style. As the bulwark of the Counter-Reformation, Rome was inevitably the bastion of the stile antico, but it also resounded to sacred works for two or more choirs and others for a handful of solo voices. Although opera had initially been staged in private or semi-private theatres, a public opera house, the Tordinona, was inaugurated in and remained open for four years. The oratorio and secular cantata were flourishing more abundantly in Rome than anywhere else at the time, along with the kind of orchestration that was to lead to the concerto grosso. In the early s Carissimi, Stradella, Pasquini, Corelli (from at least ), and Alessandro Scarlatti—some of the greatest Italian composers of the period—were all to be found in Rome. Steffani was to be there for a year and three-quarters. His travel and subsistence expenses were paid by the Munich exchequer, and on Friday September he was sent crowns extra to help with the cost of an illness.27 He may have travelled in the company of Matteo Salvietti, a ‘first-class’ chamber musician who had been in Munich since 28 but was now leaving, or of the eminent Theatine preacher Padre Agostino Bozzomo. On October , apparently, Ferdinand Maria wrote to Bozzomo, saying that he was glad that he had arrived safely in Rome, grateful for the news that he had sent about Steffani, and hopeful that the young musician would return to Munich.29 The latter appears to have travelled via Castelfranco, for on October his father wrote to the elector, thanking him for all that he had done for his son.30 This was probably Steffani’s first visit home in five years, and his family appears to have been pleased with his development. He arrived in Rome bearing a letter of introduction from Electress Henrietta Adelaide to Cardinal Paluzzo Altieri.31 She could hardly have chosen a more presti-
gious patron for her protégé. A cardinal since , Altieri experienced a meteoric rise to power after the election of the Altieri Pope Clement X in .32 Then, or soon after, Paluzzo was made archbishop of Ravenna; vicar of Rome; chancellor to the pope; secretary of briefs; prefect of the Congregation of Propaganda; protector of the Santa Casa at Loreto; protector of Ireland and of the Augustinian, Carmelite, and Dominican orders; legate of Avignon and Urbino; and governor of Tivoli. Within a very short time, he had become ‘the most considerable person’ (‘il più riguardabile soggetto’) in Rome, with an annual income of over , scudi. Assisted by generous subsidies from the pope (, scudi per month for six years), he made the Palazzo Altieri one of the grandest residences in the city. It is not known whether he responded to Henrietta Adelaide’s request for patronage of Steffani, but he certainly took an interest in other musicians, and his brother Gaspare was a patron of Stradella.33 Steffani could have served him as a singer, harpsichordist, or composer and may have been introduced by him to fashionable Roman society. Steffani’s teacher was to be Ercole Bernabei, whom Munich presumably had approached in advance via Maccioni.34 A pupil of Orazio Benevoli, and possibly of Stradella, Bernabei was one of the most distinguished church musicians in Rome. In the s and s he had been organist at San Luigi dei Francesi and maestro di cappella at San Giovanni in Laterano, and from he had assisted each year in the performance of oratorio at San Marcello. Although he had published a book of secular works (Concerto madrigalesco) in , most of his music was liturgical and composed in the stile antico or the polychoral idiom. In June , largely through the influence of Queen Christina of Sweden, Bernabei succeeded Benevoli as director of the Cappella Giulia at the Vatican. He was thus at the pinnacle of his career when Steffani went to him for lessons. He may have given his young pupil further instruction on the organ, but the focus was on composition. As a musician in Rome it was perhaps inevitable that Steffani should have become a member of the Congregazione dei Musici di Roma, an organisation that had been founded in the late sixteenth century and was to develop, as the Congregazione (later Accademia) di Santa Cecilia, into one of the most important musical institutions in the city. In the seventeenth century it tried to establish a monopoly of the profession, which only papal singers were not required to join. The members provided music on a regular basis in the church in which the organisation was housed at the time, and they mounted an annual celebration of the feast of St Cecilia ( November), the patron saint of music. Steffani was given the task of visiting the sick and had to minister to his teacher; he also composed a polyphonic antiphon setting, Triduanas a Domino, for St Cecilia’s day in .35 This piece, three psalm settings, and another sacred work (Sperate in Deo), all from the same period, are preserved in a manuscript in the Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge (Mu MS ), most of which appears to be in Steffani’s hand. In Rome he seems also to have written the secular solo cantata Occhi miei, lo miraste, which survives in a contemporary Roman manuscript (D-HVs, Kestner vol. ). But the principal fruit of his study with Bernabei was his Psalmodia vespertina volans octo plenis vocibus concinenda (Rome, ), a printed collection of thirteen vesper psalms, with Magnificat, scored for two choirs and organ. Since the dedication to the Bavarian elector and elec-
‒ tress is dated January, the settings must have been composed in , probably before the Fitzwilliam pieces. An undated payment from Munich of fl. kr. , ‘in order that in Rome he may have various musical things copied out’,36 may refer to the preparation of fair copy for the printer. Steffani paid tribute in the preface to the example set by his teacher, ‘whose style I pride myself on imitating not in part but totally’.37 At the same time, however, he referred to the rapid progress he had made in composition. That he wrote so much in little over a year suggests that he had started to compose during his time with Kerll and makes the omission of the latter’s name from the preface very pointed; it could also explain why Steffani was ill in September . While it seems that he had indeed made rapid progress, to state this twice, in both preface and dedication, was immodest and immature. But then, as he proudly proclaimed on the title page, he was only nineteen. A vivid impression of his character at this age is conveyed by the following epigram, with double acrostic, which appeared at the beginning of the Psalmodia: Augeat Augustine augusta sorte, Ut merito debet praemia, fama, Germine ab Herculeo iam germen germinat. Virtus virtutem; lumen, & inde, Sors tua nunc virtus est; dum fati aemula Tanti operis luci, gloria maior Inclita si peperit iuventus germina; NOmini & augustum firmat, et auget
Suprema Tibi Edit Faces Floret Adest Nomen Opus.
[May your reputation increase, Agostino, with a noble destiny / As it owes you deservedly outstanding rewards. / From a Herculean seed now a shoot is sprouting. / Excellence produces excellence, light and then torches. / Your destiny is excellent now; / while, a rival of fate, it flourishes, / Greater glory attends the light of such a great work, / If youth has brought forth its celebrated seeds. / Reputation attends a name, establishes it as noble and increases its work.]
This is an extremely self-conscious creation, marked in structure and style by a profusion of literary conceits. The epigram is an example of ring composition with a chiastic structure, ‘augeat . . . augusta’ returning at the end as ‘augustum . . . auget’; these same words, and ‘germine . . . germen germinat’, exemplify the device of paronomasia; line exhibits polyptoton (‘virtus virtutem’), and lines – (‘nomen / nomini’) display both polyptoton and traductio.38 Then there is the double acrostic. The author clearly possessed an admirable command of Latin and rhetorical figures of speech and was highly skilled in the composition of verse; he was also very conscious of his poetical talent and Steffani’s musical ability and itching to exhibit them both. If the epigram was written by the composer himself, as seems likely, it displays exuberance, arrogance, and unawareness of the impression that ostentation might make—all signs of youth. Steffani’s return to Munich was bound up with the appointment of Bernabei as Kapellmeister there. As soon as Kerll resigned and moved to Vienna, in , Maccioni was ordered to try to find a replacement in Rome.39 He first approached
Giuseppe Corsi (‘il Celano’), a pupil of Carissimi who had been maestro di cappella of several Roman churches; but he declined. On August Maccioni recommended Giuseppe Spoglia, who was ‘young, well-born, placid, God-fearing, and amenable, to the extent of being capable of becoming maestro di cappella’; but Ferdinand Maria was afraid that he might be too young or would lack the authority to direct a Kapelle of temperamental individuals and so advised Maccioni to look for somebody older. The latter then proposed Bernabei. The elector approved, advising Maccioni in autumn to conduct negotiations without the knowledge of Steffani, who, as an ambitious young man, might have set his sights on the appointment and might ‘with some art entertain his master on the subject’.40 Inevitably Steffani discovered what was afoot. Just as negotiations were drawing to their close, in March , he told Bernabei, wrongly, it seems, that the salary on offer was less than what Kerll had been paid. Whether Steffani thought he was right or wrong, whether he was trying to protect his master’s interests or attempting to scupper the negotiations, the elector’s caution had been well-placed. Fortunately, Maccioni was able to reassure Bernabei, who resigned from the Cappella Giulia on April; he also reported that Bernabei planned to set off for Munich about May and that his pupil wanted to return with him and act as his interpreter. The elector agreed and hoped that they would leave as soon as possible. They travelled via Venice, where Steffani received scudi for expenses, presumably visited Castelfranco, and eventually reached Munich on July.41 Steffani had come a long way in less than two years. After his return to Munich, Steffani became active as a court organist. It is uncertain, however, when he was appointed to such a post. He is described as a ‘court and chamber organist’ (‘Hof und Cammer Organisten’) in a decree dated July ,42 and Woker suggested that his appointment took effect on March ,43 but Steffani had already described himself as ‘musico-organista’ to the elector and electress of Bavaria on the title page of his Psalmodia vespertina (). This was probably not an empty boast. There had been two organists at Munich in –, when the composer was in Rome, and there were three from to at least , when he left Munich for good; between and , however, there was only one organist on the books at a time—Georg Zellner to and André Rauscher from .44 It is tempting, therefore, to suggest that Steffani was appointed second organist from the date of his return and that he assisted first Zellner then Rauscher. Maybe one player was responsible for the court chapel and the other for the tiny ‘Rich Chapel’ or ‘Secret Chamber Chapel’, originally the private oratory of Maximilian I. Steffani may also have helped Bernabei write music for chapel services. Hawkins stated that he composed ‘several masses, motets, kyries, magnificats, and other essays in the church style, which . . . were occasionally performed in the chapel at Munich’;45 some such music may have survived in his Sacer Ianus quadrifrons (), but if Hawkins was right, a considerable amount has been lost. He also wrote that ‘the direction of his [Steffani’s] musical studies . . . was committed to Sig. Ercole Bernabei, then chapel-master to the elector of Bavaria’,46 but there is no evidence of formal tuition continuing in Munich. Soon after returning, Steffani asked the elector for a further increase in his emoluments.47 The reason he gave is that his family would soon be joining him in Munich and would add significantly to his expenses, but he presumably felt also that his grow-
‒ ing experience, and activity as an organist, should be more amply rewarded. His request was approved: from July his salary was doubled to florins, and he was also given an annual allowance of fl. kr. for wine and beer and a daily supplement of two rolls and two loaves.48 His salary, which remained at this level until , was now twice that of the official court organist and nearly half that of the Kapellmeister. Despite his standing, however, and the fact that he was now twenty-one years old, he was apparently still in the custody of Augustin Sayler, for on September the latter was granted florins to enable Steffani to make a journey.49 The payment suggests that the latter returned to Italy that autumn, perhaps to make arrangements for his parents’ removal. His father transferred to Munich in ; his mother, brother, and sister moved there in early .50 His half-sister, Helena Perina, was placed in a convent (‘Monastero delle Zitelle’) in Padua; she later moved in with a family named Franchini and died in . Steffani’s sister, Ippolita, entered the Convent of the Visitation in Munich, with whose first four members he had first crossed the Alps; she was Mother Superior in and two years later met Durastanti. Steffani’s brother, Ventura Terzago, was initially employed as a replacement for the court poet Domenico Gisberti, who had returned to Venice in . He was appointed on a temporary basis from April to provide ‘certain compositions’; his salary was florins per annum.51 After a year his appointment was confirmed and his salary increased to florins.52 On July , however, after making a visit to his ‘patria’ to put his affairs in order, Terzago succeeded Carlo Begnudelli Basso as a privy councillor and secretary, with a salary of florins.53 In this capacity he made several further journeys to Italy—to Rome in early and to Venice in and . In spite of these additional responsibilities, however, he wrote the librettos of virtually all the Italian operas and tourneys performed in Munich between and (Table .).54 He may also have adapted Apolloni’s La Dori, first set by Cesti (Innsbruck, ), for Giuseppe Antonio Bernabei in : he certainly wrote a new prologue and signed the dedication. The arrival of Steffani’s family may have prompted Ercole Bernabei to consider the position of his own two musical sons, Giuseppe Antonio and Vincenzo, with whom Steffani had presumably become acquainted in Rome. Giuseppe Antonio was .
Librettos by Ventura Terzago
Date
Title
Genre
Composer
Alvilda in Abo Enea in Italia Giulio Cesare ricovrato all’ombra L’Ermione Il litigio del cielo e della terra conciliato dalla felice Bavaria Marco Aurelio Solone Audacia e rispetto Servio Tullio Erote ed Anterote
Opera Opera Tourney Opera Tourney Opera Opera Tourney Opera Tourney
G. A. Bernabei G. A. Bernabei G. A. Bernabei G. A. Bernabei E. Bernabei Steffani Steffani Steffani Steffani E. Bernabei
about five years older than Steffani and had succeeded his father as maestro di cappella of San Luigi dei Francesi and organist for the oratorios at San Marcello. In he was invited to follow his father to Munich and serve as vice-Kapellmeister.55 Maccioni approved, reporting that he was counted in Rome ‘amongst the foremost virtuosi, both as a keyboard player and as a composer for church, chamber, and theatre’ and that his artistry was combined with a fear of God, ‘for he is a good priest’. On April Bernabei sent the Bavarian elector an example of his recent work, a motet for four basses, and requested permission to dedicate a collection of such pieces to him. The book is not known to have been published, but the composer arrived in Munich on June. His brother Vincenzo, an outstanding keyboard player about six years younger than Steffani, was appointed a court organist in .56 The appointment of Giuseppe Antonio as vice-Kapellmeister had implications for Steffani’s career. These may have struck him as bleak at the time, but with hindsight he may have regarded the appointment as a blessing in disguise. Bernabei was immediately given a significantly higher salary than Steffani (, florins), commissioned to set Terzago’s librettos, and assured of succeeding his father as Kapellmeister. Steffani doubtless felt angry and hurt at being passed over in this way, and the episode clearly caused friction between him and the Kapellmeister’s son. This may be one reason why Ferdinand Maria sent Steffani abroad for a second period of study. That his destination on this occasion was Paris may have been due partly to the fact that Henrietta Adelaide, a cousin of Louis XIV, had died in . Steffani probably left Munich soon after July , when he was granted florins ‘ex gratia for a certain purpose’;57 if, as seems likely, he went straight to Paris and left there in May , he could have spent as long as nine months in the French capital. This period was of vital importance for his personal and musical development and for his future career. In culture as in politics, France was one of the most powerful forces in Europe. Patronage of the arts was not dispersed, as in Rome, among a multitude of aristocrats, prelates, and foreign residents but concentrated overwhelmingly on the court of Louis XIV. Every branch of cultivated activity—including architecture, drama, music, dance, manners, and dress—was governed by the concept of ‘good taste’ (‘bon goût’) that emanated from the king himself. The influence of French style was felt throughout Europe, but nowhere more strongly than in the neighbouring courts of western Germany and the Low Countries; England and Italy were not unaffected. For Steffani to be sent to the fountainhead of French culture was a natural step. Other musicians from Germany had gone there recently, including Georg Muffat, Johann Fischer, Johann Caspar Ferdinand Fischer, and Johann Philipp Förtsch, all of whom had been there in the s or s but left, and Johann Sigismund Kusser, who studied with Lully for six years between and ; Kusser may have met Steffani in Paris before going on, in the s, to stage his operas in Hamburg and elsewere in Germany. Italians, too, went to Paris: the bass viol player and composer Theobaldo di Gatti moved there in about and remained, as a naturalized French citizen, for the rest of his life; the composer Paolo Lorenzani arrived there only weeks after Steffani and stayed for nearly twenty years. Very little is known of Steffani’s activities in Paris. The musical life of the court in – was completely dominated by Lully, who was then at the height of his
‒ powers. Together with Colbert Lully had prevented the performance of Italian music for over ten years, making room for his own tragédies lyriques, ballets, comédies-ballets, and sacred music. The only stage work by him to have been premièred during Steffani’s visit is Bellérophon, a tragédie that was first performed at the Académie Royale de Musique on January ; Steffani may have been present, for ‘all Paris was there’.58 Even if he was not, he may have attended a later performance and certainly became familiar with Lully’s musical style—his overtures, dances, orchestration, and rhythmic conventions. He may also have attended the comédie italienne and met the Venetian actress, singer, and poet Brigida Bianchi (–), who lived in Paris from about . Six of his chamber duets are settings of poems by her that were published in Paris in and . If he found the texts in her books, he is more likely to have done so in Paris than anywhere else.59 Steffani does not appear to have purchased the volumes, for they are not in the ‘registro’ of his library drawn up in . This catalogue does, however, include over forty French titles published before , which he could have acquired in Paris; most of them are historical or biographical works, including memoirs, but there also are editions of Montaigne and Paul Scarron.60 All that is known for certain about Steffani’s sojourn in Paris is that he played before the king, presumably on the harpsichord. The evidence for this appears in a report of his visit to Turin, where he stopped on his way back to Munich. The court of Savoy may have taken a special interest in a musical visitor who had known Henrietta Adelaide in Bavaria. On May , the Bavarian resident, Johann Bartholomäus Schalck, wrote as follows to Ferdinand Maria: Agostino Steffani, Your Electoral Highness’s court musician, has arrived in Turin in the past few days. I have presented him to Madama Reale [Marie Jeanne Baptiste of Savoy-Nemours, regent of Savoy – ] and told her at length of his virtù. She therefore desires to hear him at the next opportunity. In France he had the honour of playing before the king. Yesterday he played to Cardinal [d’Estrées]; his skill and dexterity were admired by the entire assembled company. As soon as Madama Reale has heard him, he will immediately set out on his journey in order to be back in Munich as soon as possible.61 A week later the diplomat wrote: Yesterday Agostino Steffani . . . was heard by Madama Reale in the Camera di Parada. His elegant and delicate playing was approved by the entire court, and Madama Reale said to him two or three times: ‘Vous jouez fort bien, vous jouez parfaitement bien’. He will now begin his journey as soon as possible and most dutifully instal himself at home again.62 These are the only known accounts of Steffani’s playing. The earlier report suggests that he was detained in Turin so that ‘Madama Reale’ could hear him. Both draw attention to the dexterity and delicacy of his style and imply that the quality of his fingerwork was exceptional. In addition to the organ he must have studied the harpsichord and possibly also the clavichord. What music he played in Paris or Turin is a matter of speculation. Since he left no keyboard works of his own, he may have per-
formed music by one of his teachers—Kerll is the obvious candidate; perhaps in Paris he had studied the works of the clavecinistes; perhaps he simply improvised. Be that as it may, while Steffani entertained his hosts in Turin, Ferdinand Maria died in Munich. If the former was unaware of his patron’s demise, the latter may never have known how effective an ambassador his court and chamber musician could be.
Director of Chamber Music The electorate of Ferdinand’s son, Maximilian II Emanuel (Fig. .), brought major advances in Steffani’s career as a musician and courtier. Although Max Emanuel is remembered above all as a soldier—he helped defeat the Turks at Vienna in , at Ofen (Budapest) in , and at Belgrade in —he was also exceedingly interested in the arts and an extremely generous patron. Steffani had known him and his sister Violanta Beatrice since they were children. Both were active lovers of music. Max Emanuel, who had studied with Kerll, d’Ardespin, and maybe Steffani, played the flute, guitar, and bass viol (not only in private) and also sang as a tenor.63 Having known him for so long, Agostino may have been hoping for special consideration. This could not come at once, for the son and heir was only seventeen, and Ercole and Giuseppe Antonio Bernabei had been asked to compose the three dramatic works that would mark the two major court events of —Max Emanuel’s attaining the age of majority and his sister Maria Anna Christina’s marriage to the dauphin Louis of France.64 Steffani’s position vis-à-vis Giuseppe Antonio was reviewed by Max Emanuel later that year. An undated chit among the Steffani papers in Munich—showing that his salary ( florins) plus allowance for wine and beer (fl. kr. ) amounted to fl. kr. less than Bernabei’s salary (fl. ,)—clearly relates to this process.65 As a result of the review Steffani was appointed from January to the new post of director of chamber music (‘Camer Music Director’), with a total salary (‘all in’) identical to that of the vice-Kapellmeister. If the appointment put the twenty-six-yearold Steffani in charge of part of the court’s musical life, the decree also confirmed Bernabei as his senior in the musical hierarchy:66 the arrangement was designed to reward both men and create equilibrium. But it did not work. It was now Bernabei’s turn to feel jealous and aggrieved, and these feelings must soon have been intensified—in February, when Steffani’s first opera, Marco Aurelio, was produced; in October, when it was revived; and in , when Steffani composed a serenata for the wedding of Countess Preysing.67 The opera, based on the life of the Roman emperorelect Marcus Aurelius, is concerned with the attitude of a man in authority to his duties and his wife: it may have been intended as an object lesson for the new elector, who was beginning to contemplate marriage. The influence of the director of chamber music around this time may be illustrated by the experience of August Kühnel, an outstanding bass viol player at the court of Zeitz.68 Kühnel visited Munich in , was liked by the elector and the musicians, and, despite being a Lutheran, was offered a post from September for a year at the exceptionally high salary of , florins;69 his name and salary were en-
‒
. Elector Maximilian II Emanuel of Bavaria: oil painting, after Joseph Vivien () (Residenzmuseum München, Foto BSV; by permission of the Bayerische Verwaltung der staatlichen Schlösser, Gärten und Seen)
tered into the ledger for .70 Soon after his appointment, however, he seems to have gone back to Zeitz to arrange for the removal of his family, and on February his payment at Munich was stopped. The reason for this appears to have been his religion, which Steffani had led him to hope would not prevent his appointment. Kühnel wrote to him but received no reply. On September he wrote to a court secretary, enclosing a further letter to Steffani, who had promised to respond; but again no answer was forthcoming. The reason for Steffani’s silence is apparently that he was waiting to see whether Max Emanuel would marry Princess Eleonore Erdmuthe of Eisenach, who was a Lutheran; the implication is that if this marriage went ahead,
Kühnel would be permitted to take up his appointment. Steffani may not have done anything wrong, but he does not emerge from this episode with credit. The most important point, however, is that as director of chamber music he had authority to engage and dismiss musicians. In fact, he may have started doing this before his new appointment took effect: the travel expenses from Rome ( florins) of the court and chamber musician Francesco Cagliaroli, who was appointed on July , were first paid by Steffani, then reimbursed to him.71 Steffani’s rivalry with Bernabei and his treatment of Kühnel were undoubtedly related to the fact that he had recently been made a priest. Bernabei, a priest himself, must have regarded Steffani’s ordination as a further threat, while Kühnel was apparently a victim of the latter’s religious zeal. The earliest reference to Steffani as a priest dates from November , when he was also described as the ‘court and chamber musician and organist, and faithful and well-beloved Agostino Steffani’.72 On his claim for Cagliaroli’s travel expenses he signed his name as ‘D. A. Steffani’: the ‘D.’ (for ‘Don’) suggests that he was a priest when he submitted the claim, which, though undated, must have originated in the summer of . Perhaps he was ordained around July, his twenty-sixth birthday. The path to the priesthood must have begun about ten years before, however, and we may assume that he was trained by the Theatines, to whom the spiritual life of the colony of foreign artists in Munich had been entrusted since the period of Lassus.73 The Theatine order, or Congregation of Regular Clerics, had been founded in by Giovanni Pietro Carafa, bishop of Chieti (Theate), Gaetano di Thiene (Cajetan), and others.74 Carafa, later Pope Paul IV, was the first superior, but the brotherhood owed much to Cajetan, its superior from . In an age of widespread corruption, it was dedicated to asceticism and apostolic work under vows of chastity, obedience, and absolute poverty. Although it was eventually eclipsed by the Jesuits, founded in , the Theatine order spread throughout Italy and across most of Europe during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, building churches, oratories, and hospitals. They collaborated in the foundation of the Urban College in Rome, under the auspices of the Congregation for the Propagation of the Faith, and were the first to establish papal missions overseas. The presence of the Theatines in Munich was consolidated by the building of the Theatinerkirche, which was commissioned on Max Emanuel’s birth in and consecrated on his thirteenth birthday.75 During its construction, in , Cajetan was canonized. Steffani’s ordination marked the beginning of a long and distinguished career in the church. He did not voluntarily espouse the Theatine ideal of poverty, but during the last quarter of his life he was responsible for much of the missionary work of the church in north Germany. In the early s Max Emanuel made representations in Rome in the hope of securing him a benefice. On December he informed his diplomatic resident, Abbate Pompeo Scarlatti, that he had received the papal bull appointing Steffani abbot of Löpsingen, a small parish in the county of OettingenWallerstein, north of Augsburg;76 the parish was protestant, but the benefice had remained in Catholic hands and was held as a sinecure alternately by the chapter of Augsburg Cathedral and the count of Oettingen. The appointment of Steffani and his retention of office were not achieved without struggle. The cathedral chapter was
‒ angry at being deprived of the income and implored Max Emanuel to find him a different benefice elsewhere. On September , by which time Steffani had left Munich, Prince Albrecht Ernst von Oettingen appealed to him to resign on the ground that the benefice had traditionally been held by somebody with a seat (‘fixam sedem’) in the area. Steffani resisted all calls for his resignation, however, and between and , when he was nominated bishop, defiantly signed himself ‘Abbate di Lepsing’. But the aggravation continued: in he informed the prince that he had held the benefice for twenty-five or twenty-six years—‘a bit long for people who would like to succeed me: unable to take it away from me, they try to torment me’; in he sought help from the imperial vice-chancellor, Friedrich Karl von Schönborn, because his income from the abbacy was being reduced.77 The reason for his tenacity, of course, is that the benefice was a valuable source of income—in – it brought him a total of , thalers—out of which, however, he had to pay a pastor for providing religious services. In the early s Max Emanuel also gave Steffani his earliest opportunity as a diplomat. The confidence placed in him suggests that he had acquired the necessary abilities and experience. He was familiar with Italian, German, French, and Latin and blessed with sharp powers of observation and comprehension. In addition to music he had studied theology and presumably philosophy, history, and mathematics; he had travelled in Italy, Germany, and France, acquired the polished manners of courtly society, and shed, one assumes, the brashness or arrogance of his teenage years. On November he was given the staggering sum of , florins, and on August a further ,, ‘for certain reasons and favours’:78 the size of these sums, which were similar to the Kapellmeister’s annual salary, and the vagueness of the records suggest that the ‘reasons and favours’ were secret and that he was already undertaking diplomatic missions. His main diplomatic responsibility at Munich was to assist with the negotiations preceding the elector’s marriage. An account of his role is found in his letter of July to Count Fede: All Upper Germany knows that at the court of Bavaria I enjoyed the honour of the most intimate confidence of the present, most unfortunate prince, so that, to give Your Most Illustrious Lordship an idea, in the delicate affair of his first marriage this Lord used only Count Friedrich von Preysing, Canon of Salzburg, to see the princess of Eisenach, who later died as electress of Saxony, and me to examine the princess of Hanover, who died as queen of Prussia. My star at that time had such powerful influence at the Bavarian court that I, and I alone, resisted for eight months on end the entire council of state of the imperial court, and that of the elector, both of whom wanted to give to him as wife the Archduchess Maria Antonia, whom he then married because the princess of Hanover, tired of waiting for decisions from Munich, was given to the present king of Prussia, the then widowed electoral prince of Brandenburg.79 Although Steffani’s ‘I, and I alone’ is exaggerated, for Preysing, at least, was also involved, his account is otherwise substantially correct. A match between the elector and
Princess Sophie Charlotte was much desired, not least by Hanover and the pope. Negotiations began in earnest in . Around the end of the year the Hanoverian agent, Abbate Lodovico Ballati, was in Munich and Steffani was in Hanover. Steffani returned to Munich with a gold chain weighing a pound and a half and singing the praise of the princess, but the affair dragged on through . In September Max Emanuel covered himself in glory at the siege of Vienna; in the following month Duchess Sophie of Hanover informed Ballati that ‘poor Steffani is begging Signor Ortensio [Mauro] to get this response agreed’. But it was not to be: Sophie Charlotte was given to Friedrich, electoral prince of Brandenburg, in , and Max Emanuel married Maria Antonia in the following year. Steffani may have been on the wrong side on this occasion, but he had discharged his responsibility with dignity and aplomb and won the affection of the Hanoverian court, including that of Sophie Charlotte, who became the most passionate admirer of his music, and of Mauro, his future librettist. Between and , when he finally left Munich, Steffani was kept busy with composition, suffered a couple of illnesses, and made recuperative visits to Italy. On March Johann Jaecklin, the court printer, was ordered ‘to print the motets that he [Steffani] had composed’.80 They were published as Sacer Ianus quadrifrons, tribus vocibus vel duabus qualibet praetermissa modulandus toward the end of the following year. Dedicated to Max Emanuel on November , the collection paid tribute to the multitalented elector. Some of the motets celebrate his triumph over the Turks and must have been composed after September ; others could have been written rather earlier, though presumably after Max Emanuel’s accession. As Steffani explained in the preface, the book contains forty-eight motets in twelve. Each of the dozen is scored for three voices and continuo, of which any voice may be omitted (si placet); every motet can be performed in four ways and counted as four different pieces: hence the ‘four-fronted Janus’ of the title. The twenty-month delay in the publication of the motets was probably due to a variety of factors, including Steffani’s preoccupation with dramatic works. No new opera had been performed at Munich since : Terzago had been busy with politics and may not have had time to write librettos, and his brother had been engaged in diplomatic activity. In carnival , however, two new works were produced— the opera Solone and the tourney Audacia e rispetto—both with music by Steffani.81 Although the scores are lost, the librettos survive. The opera was based on the life of the Athenian legislator and poet Solon (ca. –ca. B.C.). The librettist, Terzago, had taken the subject not from Plutarch but from Les amours des grands hommes, a popular work by Marie Catherine Hortense Desjardins (Madame de Villedieu), first published in Paris in .82 He admitted to reducing ‘a most famous wise man of Greece to treading the boards of Bavaria in the shape of a lover’83 and claimed that the moral of the opera was twofold: that it is futile to try to resist the inevitable; and that the more the amorous passion takes hold, the more it is to be feared.84 The Baroque tourney, which was descended from the medieval tournament, was a stylized equestrian contest preceded by a musical introduction; it flourished mainly in northern Italy, Paris, Vienna, and Munich.85 The libretto of Audacia e rispetto, Prerogative d’Amore disputate in Campo di Marte is attributed to Terzago, but his name does not appear in the wordbook.86 The subject of the dispute was whether boldness or defer-
‒ ence is more useful to a lover in winning the heart of his beloved. Three carriages entered the arena from different sides: that in the centre was Cupid’s; Audacia amorosa, on the right, was accompanied by Merito and Confidenza; Amorosa rispetto, to the left, was attended by Costanza and Segretezza. The carriage of Audacia was followed by a squadron of seventeen unmarried knights, including the elector and the counts of Tattenbach and Sanfré; that of Rispetto led a train of seventeen married ‘cavalieri’, among them Maximilian and Felice von Preysing. As well as the names and titles of the horsemen, the wordbook gives details of the décor, accoutrements of the carriages and horses, and costumes and arms of the riders. As the carriages approached each other, there was a ‘sinfonia strepitosa’ of harpsichords, trumpets, kettledrums, and as many other instruments as possible.87 In the middle of the arena the carriages formed a semi-circular stage on which the principal characters sang the dispute to a recitative, two arias, and a duet—all in operatic style. The carriages then departed, leaving the arena to the horsemen, while ‘sweet harmony’ gave way to the ‘noisy sound of trumpets and drums’.88 Challenges were exchanged, and the tournament began—three courses with each of five weapons (lance, spear, ball, pistol, and sword). When it was over, the carriages returned, and in a concluding aria Cupid awarded a prize to each squadron, on the ground that in love a man must possess both ‘audacia’ and ‘rispetto’. The publication of Steffani’s motets was delayed also by illness. During the first half of he applied to the elector for permission and financial assistance ‘to try both the air and the doctors of Italy’.89 He had been suffering for eight months from catarrh and dizziness, and all the remedies that he had tried had proved ineffective. He hoped that the elector would help by rewarding him, as promised, ‘for the music I provided for the last two operas’, and suggested travelling back to Munich together with ‘those two singers’. The elector granted his request, and on June awarded him florins for his operas and visit.90 The date of the award helps to ‘place’ his request, which is not dated; it also confirms that the two ‘operas’ in question were Solone and Audacia e rispetto and suggests that ‘quelle due cantatrici’ with whom he might return would be coming from Italy to sing in the opera the following year.91 It is not certain that Steffani visited Italy in , but having received financial assistance he presumably did so between July and September. Riccati asserted that he was appointed that year as a tenor in the choir of the Basilica del Santo at Padua,92 but although he had diligently examined the ledgers of the basilica with the ‘most erudite’ Count [Giovanni] Domenico Polcastro, he had found no record of Steffani’s appointment. He sought to explain this by supposing that the latter had been in post for only a few months before the princes of Brunswick and Hanover, passing through Padua in , had taken him into their service. Chrysander claimed to have seen archival evidence that Steffani was in Hanover in but did not cite it.93 It cannot be stated too strongly that the composer did not enter Hanoverian service before , nor via the route described by Riccati, whose account is a distorted echo of Steffani’s recruitment by Munich. It is true, however, that Duke Ernst August of Hanover visited Padua in , and among his retinue was Ortensio Mauro. When Steffani was in Padua in the s, he met people who remembered seeing Mauro nearly forty years earlier. On July he wrote to his old friend:
. . . Padua, where you left a memory that should satisfy you. There are some people who still remember seeing you, and remember it with pleasure. They are not very numerous, however, for I myself have only a few friends left there from those days—Count Francesco Cittadella, Count Girolamo Frigimelica, Abbot Lazara (who remembers seeing you in in the house of a [certain] Tiepolo whom I do not know), the counts Zacco; and there the litany ends.94 The letter is regrettably vague about whether Steffani himself visited Padua in : it implies, but does not make clear, that he did. If he was in the area, he may have gone also to Venice: at the time of his ordination, if not before, his father had given him a house in the Ghetto, the money having come from his rich uncle, Marc’Antonio Terzago.95 Assuming that Steffani did go to Italy in , he probably returned to Munich by early October, when Max Emanuel introduced his new bride to the court. In December the elector made further representations to Rome, in the hope that Steffani could be found a benefice in the Veneto: he cited his subject’s Venetian citizenship, good character, and twenty years of faithful service, as well as his desire to return to Italy, poor health, and need for a cure.96 The Bavarian resident in Rome, Abbate Pompeo Scarlatti, promised to assist, and the elector’s fourteen-year-old brother, Prince Joseph Clemens, who in was to become archbishop of Cologne, also weighed in, with a recommendation dated February to Cardinal Pietro Ottoboni senior: he hoped that Steffani would be able, by Easter, to seek a remedy for his illness, ‘which currently confines him to bed’. Given that the composer still needed a cure, Einstein conjectured (in the absence of evidence) that he went to Italy in .97 Be that as it may, it seems safe to assume, since he remained active for over forty more years, that his illness, though persistent, was not serious. The symptoms of which he complained suggest that he was exhausted, presumably through overwork: in – he had been involved in the elector’s marriage negotiations, protracted and probably stressful; in – he had composed twelve motets, an opera, and a tourney. It is hardly surprising that after carnival he needed a cure. Steffani had little time for rest, however, for his motets needed seeing through the press and he had to compose the opera for . This carnival would be the first since Max Emanuel’s marriage on July to the sixteen-year-old Archduchess Maria Antonia, and the most lavish that Munich had seen. The union had brought together the houses of Bavaria and Austria, as had that of Maximilian I and Maria Anna exactly fifty years before, and was laden with historical and political significance. The wedding had been celebrated in Vienna,98 but extravagant festivities were planned for Munich, where preparations for the couple’s arrival were in hand.99 Coaches and clothing had been ordered from Paris, carpets and furniture from Turin; decorators, actors, and tourney organizers were being recruited in Italy. The couple entered the city on October. At the Isartor a triumphal arch had been erected, and on the Marienplatz stood two thrones joined by rigging that supported a trumpeter. To the sound of trumpets and drums, supper was served in the Residenz on a new golden dinner service, valued by the Abbé Lantery at , scudi. The party then
‒ attended a play at the Jesuit college. On October there was a tourney followed by a fireworks display, and later that month there were further Jesuit plays and Italian comedies. The elector spent much of the autumn on his favourite pastime, hunting, but returned to the Residenz for the birthdays of the empress (on November) and the dowager Queen Maria Anna of Spain (on December). According to Lantery, who feared that the court now spent more in a quarter than it had under Ferdinand Maria in a year, the birthday of the Electress Maria Antonia (on January) was celebrated with unprecedented splendour.100 The principal dramatic entertainment in carnival was Steffani’s opera Servio Tullio, which was premièred on January. The subject, Servius Tullius, flattered the elector by comparing him with the sixth king of ancient Rome and thus, indirectly, with the emperor.101 The libretto, with a eulogistic prologue, was written by Ventura Terzago and published in separate Italian and German editions. These included thirteen plates by the court engraver Michael Wening, two of them showing the interior of the Salvatortheater, the others depicting the sets for the opera (Figs. . and .). The latter were designed, together with the machines, by the Venetian stage designers Gasparo and Domenico Mauro. The ballets at the ends of the prologue and acts were devised by François Rodier, the court choreographer and dancing master, who had
. The Salvator theatre in Munich: engraving by Michael Wening from the libretto of Steffani’s Servio Tullio () (Deutsches Theatermuseum, Munich; by permission)
. Stage design by Gasparo and Domenico Mauro for Steffani’s Servio Tullio (): engraving by Michael Wening from the libretto of the opera (Deutsches Theatermuseum, Munich; by permission)
previously collaborated with Steffani on Marco Aurelio and Solone, and were performed by twelve courtiers (six men and six women) whose names and titles appeared in the wordbook. The music for the ballets was composed by Melchior d’Ardespin, a cornettist at Munich from and director of the court orchestra from .102 The opera was more ambitious and extravagant than any seen in Munich before and remained unsurpassed for some decades. Lantery described it as a ‘marvellous success’, ‘something truly magnificent in every respect’.103 The production cost , florins, nearly twenty-five times the salary of the composer, and , florins were spent on opera over the year as a whole. Servio Tullio was expensive, but news of it spread across Europe, strengthening the position of Steffani and Munich on the operatic map of the continent. Carnival did not end with this opera. On February there was a tourney, Erote ed Anterote (libretto by Terzago, music by Ercole Bernabei), devised by a Count Sagramosa from Verona.104 Later that month Joseph Clemens and other members of the court took part in a production of Racine’s Andromaque, and on February the first performance was given of a new opera by Giuseppe Antonio Bernabei, Ascanio in Alba.
‒ The period from then to Holy Week was spent on further hunting. In May the electoral couple went to Vienna; in the summer Max Emanuel helped to liberate Ofen (Budapest) from years of Turkish occupation, and in October he returned to Munich with Maria Antonia for a further round of hunting, sledging, comedies, and games. Steffani’s next opera, Alarico il Baltha, cioè L’audace re de’ Gothi, was premièred on January , the electress’s eighteenth birthday, and celebrated her husband’s successful summer campaign. Two days later, however, Max Emanuel set off, without his unloved wife, to enjoy the carnival in Venice. The libretto of the opera, on the life of Alaric I (ca. – ), king of the Visigoths, was the first written for Munich by Luigi Orlandi. Terzago had been sent to Italy with , florins in to recruit singers for the forthcoming production.105 Orlandi, a Mantuan, was appointed secretary and poet in his absence, and he remained at the court for ten years. His wife Angela was engaged as a singer and apparently took part in the performance. The orchestra was strengthened for the occasion by the appointment of new players from France.106 The casts of Steffani’s Munich operas cannot be reconstructed, unfortunately. The names of the singers do not appear in the wordbooks, and only a handful of the musicians on the court payroll can be identified with confidence as singers. Steffani’s suggestion that he travel back from Italy in the company of two singers, and Terzago’s latest mission to the peninsula, suggest that some cast members, at least, were recruited ad hoc. This may explain why no women are listed as musicians in the ledgers;107 it was certainly the case with the Austrian soprano castrato Clementin Hader, a member of the imperial Hofkapelle from , who sang at Munich in and (in Servio Tullio and Ascanio in Alba), entered service there in , doubtless appeared in Steffani’s Niobe, regina di Tebe (), and later sang for him in Hanover.108 If salaried singers were, however, employed in the casts of Steffani’s operas, they presumably were drawn from the musicians ‘di prima Classe’. The names of those in this category between and are listed in Table .. With the possible exception of Maculinus, who was described as old in , all of these musicians were Italian. Since Zambonini had possibly composed La ninfa ritrosa () and appeared in Kerll’s L’Erinto (),109 he too must have been old, though it was only in that he was raised to first class. ‘Antonino’ Pio had sung in Venice in , Pietro Lemoles ‘di Messina’ in Naples in , and Giovanni Battista Moratelli in Venice in ;110 the last may have been related to Sebastiano Moratelli (–), Kapellmeister to the Wittelsbach Elector Johann Wilhelm at Düsseldorf. There appear to have been links with Hanover, too. Gottin or Cottin (or Codin)—the name appears in all forms— may be the bass ‘Cottini’ who had belonged to the Hanover Schloßkapelle in the late s, sang opera in Italy in the s and in – , was salaried at Modena (as Antonio Pietrogalli, detto Cottini) from to , and was appointed at Munich on November .111 Navara was possibly the bass of that name employed at Hanover in the late s,112 and Giovanni ‘Augustino’ Granara sang there in the s (Giovanni ‘Battista’ Granara appeared in Palermo in 113). One wonders whether ‘Lutti’ was the alto and composer Antonio Lotti, who may have been born in Hanover and whose whereabouts in the s are virtually unknown. Other musicians who may
.
Munich musicians ‘di prima Classe’, –
Name
’81
’82
’83
’84
’85
’86
’87
’88
Pietro Zambonini Thomas Maculinus Vincenzo Venturi (S) Joseppe Barberio (A) Dario Mancini Pietro Lemoles Caspar Dormiglia Phillipp Pantono (T) Antonio Pio Joann Francesco Navara Antoni Gottin or Cottin Antonio Lutti Alexander Gerardini Joann Augustin Granara Johann Baptista Moradelli Johann Baptist Granara (A) Giovanni Giacomo Rivardini
x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x
x x
x x
x x
x x
x x
x x
x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x
x x
x x
x x
x
x
x
x x x
x x x
x x x
x x
Total per year
11
11
10
12
13
13
13
x x x x x x x x 13
: An ‘x’ indicates employment, but the Granaras, Moradelli, and Rivardini were appointed too late to sing in the carnival of their first year. The voice types of Venturi and Barberio are given on f. , and that of Pantono on f. , of D-Mbsa, FS.
have sung in opera at Munich, though their salaries were less than ‘first-class’, include the bass Dominico Christoph Ristorini (– ), Georg Del Ponto (– ), and Francesco Cagliaroli (– ). Carefully preserved, ironically, are the names of ten instrumentalists from the city and parish of Munich who reinforced the court orchestra for the opera in .114 These players may have been recruited by Johann Christoph Pez, a musician formerly at St Peter’s and the Jesuit school who had joined the court on May . On March Max Emanuel authorized payment of the instrumentalists for their part in the recent opera and ballets. The request gives the dates and places of rehearsals of the opera and of the performances of both kinds of work, the names of the players (but not their instruments), and the amounts due to them for each rehearsal ( fl.) and performance ( fl.). The document thus gives detailed information on the mounting of opera and ballet in seventeenth-century Munich and on the schedule of the carnival. The players in question attended four opera rehearsals in the Residenz (on , , and November and December ) and three in the Salvatortheater ( and December and January ); the performances took place on , , and January and February.115 The same ten musicians also played for five ballets in the HerkulesSaal of the Residenz—on and January, and February, and March. None of the works is named, but the opera must have been Niobe, which is unusually richly scored and makes exceptional demands of the orchestra; the ballets,
‒ which cannot be identified, may have been social balls. Among the other diversions of carnival was a tourney, La gloria festeggiante, for the electress’s birthday, and a ‘componimento dramatico’, Diana amante, first performed on February; the words of both were by Orlandi, and the music was by Giuseppe Antonio Bernabei.116 Orlandi also wrote the libretto of Niobe, Steffani’s first opera based on Greek legend; the source was Ovid’s Metamorphoses, book VI, of which the composer (in , at least) had an Amsterdam () edition. Like his first opera, Marco Aurelio, his last opera for Munich survives in autograph manuscript. This is not true of the lost Solone and Audacia e rispetto or of Servio Tullio and Alarico, of which only scribal copies are known. In , probably in the spring, the court bookbinder, Mathias Kayser, was paid florins for work done for Steffani;117 the score of Niobe may have been part of the job. That Steffani’s operas were highly valued by the electoral family is shown by the letters of Max Emanuel’s sister, Violanta Beatrice. Long after the composer had moved to Hanover, and she to Florence as the bride of Grand-Prince Ferdinando De’ Medici, she remembered the music that she had heard at Munich in her teens. It had clearly made a lasting impression. Her letter to Steffani of January ends with this persuasive postscript: ‘I go to the opera, but I assure you that I no longer hear Servio Tullio or Alarico, nor anything like them—and that without idling, I still have a very vivid memory’.118 Those words were written by a woman who in Tuscany had heard operas by Perti, Gabrielli, and others and was a prominent patron of singers.119 Several years earlier, on August , she had praised Steffani’s musical style and asked him to send her a copy of the arias from his first Munich opera: If I were the only one to applaud your massive (‘massiccio’) and florid style, I could perhaps be mistaken; but no work that has come from your pen is sung without my hearing it echoed on full choir by the entire court, which resounds to your virtue. Thus I should be pleased if you would accordingly send me some of those duets that were sung at table in Bavaria—the aria that begins ‘Crede ogn’un che sia pazzia’, the other beginning ‘Bel tempo addio’, and the arias from Marco Aurelio.120 Violanta Beatrice appears to have assumed that Steffani had scores of his Munich works with him in Hanover, but the fact that his last three Munich operas are now in Vienna, not London, suggests that this may not have been the case. Since ‘Crede ogn’un che sia pazzia’ is the second verse of the aria for soprano solo in Oh! che voi direste bene, her letter also proves that Steffani composed chamber duets at Munich. ‘Bel tempo, addio’ probably denotes the duet of that name by Giuseppe Antonio Bernabei.121 It is tempting to think that Steffani left Munich because he was not appointed Kapellmeister on the death of Ercole Bernabei in December . If he still wanted the post, he must have been disappointed, but it is doubtful whether he did. He had known for seven years that Bernabei would be succeeded by his son, so Giuseppe Antonio’s appointment on January should have come as no surprise. The position of director of chamber music had been created specially for Steffani and was in many ways more prestigious. It had brought him into frequent and intimate contact with the electoral family, and he had enjoyed both the confidence of Max Emanuel and the admiration of Violanta Beatrice. He had also composed nearly all the new
Italian operas for the carnivals of – . In fact, he had become such a prominent figure in the musical establishment that he was described as vice-Kapellmeister in the treasury ledgers for – , when the post was still held by Giuseppe Antonio Bernabei.122 That he was appointed Kapellmeister at Hanover does not mean that he would have enjoyed the same position in Munich. As Hawkins explained, ‘in the courts of the protestant princes in Germany, the place of chapel-master is little more than a sine-cure’;123 but in Catholic courts the Kapellmeister was responsible for the music required in the ceaseless round of liturgical observance. From this point of view it seems that Steffani had enjoyed the best of Munich’s musical and social worlds. The reason for his departure was given by the composer in two later letters. In he wrote to Count Fede: ‘I left that court [Munich] in bad grace because of an offence (‘aggravio’) committed upon my only brother by Count von Sanfré, who owed all his fortune to me alone’.124 Ten years later, on March , he informed Count Girolamo Frigimelica Roberti that ‘the wrong (‘torto’) inflicted upon my late brother, of blessed memory, by one who owed to me alone all his fortune and greatness compelled me to leave it [the court], even, to tell you the truth, in rather bad odour’ (‘di assai mala grazia’).125 Count Anton Franz Maximilian von Sanfré was a gentleman of the chamber and, from , lieutenant of the ‘Guardia de Trabanti’ and lieutenant colonel of the infantry; he became senior court marshal in and died at the battle of Höchstädt in . What he did or said to Steffani’s brother is unknown, but it was serious enough for the whole family to leave Munich in May . By then it was a foregone conclusion that Steffani would enter the service of Duke Ernst August of Hanover. He had become acquainted with the duke and with Duchess Sophie in , when he had visited their court in connexion with the possible marriage of Max Emanuel to their daughter, Sophie Charlotte. He had made a good impression on them, and they on him, and had formed friendships with Mauro, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, and others. Such contacts were kept alive during the mids, including possibly at Hanover or Padua in . However, Ernst August did not attend the première of Servio Tullio, as has been suggested, because he had already reached Venice by January ,126 and it is not known whether he visited Munich on his way back to Hanover in August. Around Easter Leibniz visited Munich to gather material on the history of the house of Brunswick. When he had difficulty in gaining admission to the electoral library, he turned to Steffani for assistance: So I applied, of course, to the Bibliotecario; but when he gave me to understand that nobody would be admitted without the express authorization of his most gracious elector and lord, I did not hesitate, so that difficulties might perhaps be obviated, to appeal through Mr Agostino Stephani, a priest and electoral Capellmaster who had formerly been to Hanover and had at every opportunity expressed great vénération for our most gracious lordship, for His Electoral Highness’s most gracious permission, which, moreover, was immediately received.127 Apart from the fact that Leibniz regarded Steffani as Kapellmeister, the episode speaks volumes for the latter’s influence at court. The historian was grateful and im-
‒ pressed, for in April he wrote to the Hanoverian minister Franz Ernst von Platen and to Duchess Sophie, informing them that he had been assisted by Steffani, his brother (Terzago), and Baron Scarlatti.128 Count von Sanfré’s offence must have been committed soon after this and may have prompted Steffani to ask Leibniz about the possibility of an appointment at Hanover. An agreement was reached very quickly, for on / May Sophie was able to inform Sophie Charlotte that ‘Signor Steffani is not happy where he is; he’ll be coming to serve the duke. It is still a secret, for he has not taken leave of his master’.129 He evidently took his leave as these words were being written. He later described his departure—to Fede—as ‘unsought and sour’ (‘inaspettata e brusca’), and in a sense it was. All the same, he was treated with exceptional generosity. A decree of May reveals that in view of his twenty-one years’ faithful service he would be paid to the beginning of July (the end of the current quarter) and given a gratuity equal to three years’ salary (, florins).130 Out of this, at his own request, his debts of , florins were paid. The remaining , florins were sent to Venice by bill of exchange, along with florins for bank charges.131 A handsome gratuity of this kind was normally awarded on retirement, not on appointment to another court; for this reason the decree was careful to state that Steffani had leave to go ‘to Italy and elsewhere’. He went to Venice in May to pick up his gratuity; he presumably travelled with Terzago, who, at his own request and on the recommendation of the elector, had been appointed ‘collaterale’ of Padua the previous September,132 and with his mother, who returned to Padua to live with her older son (Terzago), who was now forty years of age. Steffani’s father had probably died at the end of ; his sister, Ippolita, remained in her convent at Munich.133 Einstein suggested that Steffani again met Ernst August in Venice, but although Marc’Antonio Ziani dedicated L’inganno regnante () to the duke, the latter did not return there after his spectacular visit of .134 Steffani’s decision to move to Hanover was apparently confirmed by two Venetians, Girolamo Molino and Count Lucio Della Torre, who frequented Ernst August’s palazzo on the Grand Canal.135 This decision marked the end of the first, eventful phase of Steffani’s remarkable career. For Ferdinand Maria he had sung, played the organ and harpsichord, composed music for chapel and chamber, and also trained for the priesthood; under Max Emanuel he had in addition composed and directed opera, acquired his first benefice, and gained experience in secret diplomatic negotiation. He was now well equipped to face the challenges that would confront him in Hanover.
H ‒
During his fifteen years at Hanover Steffani worked mainly in the secular fields that he had begun to cultivate in Munich. He was engaged as Kapellmeister to compose and direct the court opera but became increasingly involved in diplomatic affairs. Diplomacy eventually predominated, forcing him to abandon the opera, though he still composed and revised his chamber duets. His musical and diplomatic activities were interrelated. Duke Ernst August regarded opera as a symbol of power and an instrument of propaganda, using it to demonstrate the wealth and importance of his house. A knowledge of the political background is therefore essential to a full appreciation of Steffani’s work as a composer.1 Brunswick had been part of the duchy of Saxony under Henry the Lion, the twelfth-century duke of Saxony and Bavaria and founder of Munich, but had become an independent duchy in . During the Thirty Years’ War ( – ) it was split into two—Brunswick-Wolfenbüttel (the senior branch) and Brunswick-Lüneburg (the junior); Ernst August’s father, Georg, was duke of Brunswick-Lüneburg ( – ). In an attempt to provide for his four sons Georg further divided his duchy: the dukes of Lüneburg-Grubenhagen (senior) resided at Celle, those of CalenbergGöttingen (junior) at Hanover. The town of Hanover emerged from the war in better condition than many other places in Germany, for trade and manufacturing had continued (Fig. .). A census of , when a poll tax was levied to fund a battalion in defence of the Empire against the Turks, reveals that the population was then ,, of whom , lived in the Altstadt (old town) and , in the Neustadt on the opposite side of the inlet of the River Leine; there were seven French Huguenot families and five Jewish. Hanover was only half the size of Munich, and its duke did not compare in importance with the Bavarian elector (nor his palace in scale or style with the Munich Residenz2). Ernst August’s principal political objective was to secure the elevation of Hanover to an electorate, the ninth in the Empire. The Lüneburg dukes had aspired to this prestigious status since the raising of Bavaria in . To attain an electorate, however, Ernst August had first to reunify the duchy and establish the principle of primogeniture. As the youngest son of the junior branch of the house (see Fig. .), his hope that he or his son might eventually govern the reunified duchy betokens considerable ambition and determination. His older brothers helped to make his dream come true. Christian Ludwig died childless in , and Johann Friedrich followed him, without male heir, in . When Ernst August became duke of Hanover that year, only Georg
‒
. Hanover in the early nineteenth century (Blick durch die Köbelinger Straße auf Rathaus und Marktkirche): oil painting, , by Domenico Quaglio (Historisches Museum Hanover; by permission)
Wilhelm, duke of Celle, remained. In the brothers visited Heidelberg, en route to Venice, and Georg Wilhelm agreed to marry the elector’s sister Sophie. In Italy, however, he changed his mind and persuaded Ernst August to take his place. In they signed a convention in which Georg Wilhelm agreed never to marry; as a result the duchy would eventually be reunified, and Ernst August’s prospects immediately appeared more attractive. Sophie was one of the most intelligent, cultured, and well-connected noblewomen in Europe. As the youngest daughter of the Winter King and Queen (the Elector Palatine Friedrich V and Elisabeth, daughter of James I of England), she was in the line of succession to the English throne. Her wit and humanity are evident in her voluminous correspondence. She was a perceptive observer of human nature and had clear views; if occasionally impulsive, she was never less than genuine. She had already seen Ernst August in Holland. ‘Everybody liked him, but since he was the youngest of three [recte four] brothers he was not considered suitable for a marriage.’3 At Heidelberg in ‘we played the “guitarre” [lute(?)] together,’ she wrote, ‘and he
.
The Principal Members of the House of Brunswick-Lüneburg ca. –
‒ displayed the most beautiful hands; he danced magnificently. He sent me pieces of music and thus initiated a correspondence with me which I, however, broke off, because I feared that my friendship with him would be misinterpreted.’ Her fear proved unnecessary, for they were married on October , and their relationship proved a personal and a dynastic success (Figs. . and .). Three years later Ernst August became prince-bishop of Osnabrück. Since the Peace of Westphalia () this bishopric had alternated between Catholic and Protestant rulers, the latter being provided by the Lüneburg dukes. Ernst August held this office—and received the income — for the rest of his life, combining it from with the duchy of Hanover. At first, he and his family resided in Iburg. There were already two children (Georg Ludwig, later king of England, and Friedrich August), but there were eventually seven, Sophie Charlotte (born ) being sandwiched between three older and three younger brothers. In the mid-s they moved into a new castle at Osnabrück. An impression of their household is given in Samuel Chappuzeau’s L’Allemagne, ou Relation nouvelle de toutes les Cours de l’Empire (): The court of Wolfenbüttel appeared to me the most serious, the court of Celle the most cheerful, the court of Hanover the most correct [‘reguliere’], and the court of Osnabrück the most elegant [‘galante’]; but all, in general, are beautiful and magnificent, because all these princes spare nothing in sustaining the glory of their house. . . . The bishop of Osnabrück and the dukes of Celle and Hanover have for several years maintained an excellent troupe of French actors [‘comédiens’] with luxurious costumes, who play their parts admirably. And when their three bands of violins are together, one can call them ‘la bande des vingtquatre’, for they are mostly French and among the best masters in the profession.4 As duke of Hanover, Ernst August pursued his ambition with determination and political acumen. A potential difficulty had arisen in , when Georg Wilhelm had fathered a daughter, Sophie Dorothea; his ‘marriage of conscience’ to the mother, Eléonore d’Olbreuse, was legalized in . By producing a daughter, he had created the possibility of a marriage with Ernst August’s eldest son, Georg Ludwig, which, on the duke of Celle’s death, would reunite the two branches of the family; by marrying Eléonore, Georg Wilhelm had broken his agreement with Ernst August and surrendered his right of succession to the duchy. The marriage of Sophie Dorothea to Georg Ludwig was not essential to Ernst August’s design, but desirable, and it happened in . Legal provisions concerning the duchy and right of succession were drafted in the same year. The emperor accepted them in in exchange for military aid against the Turks; Georg Ludwig and his brother Friedrich August went as volunteers to the siege of Vienna, the former returning in time for the birth of his son, Georg August. Ernst August unveiled his constitutional arrangements to his family in , after Sophie Charlotte’s marriage to electoral Prince Friedrich of Brandenburg, and set off in the spring for carnival in Venice. He now began to step up his campaign for an electorate. In and Georg Ludwig and Friedrich August again supported the emperor against the Turks; in
. Duke (later Elector) Ernst August of Hanover: oil painting, , by Jacques Vaillant (Fürstenhaus HerrenhausenMuseum; by permission of H.R.H. the Prince of Hanover)
their younger brother Maximilian Wilhelm led a contingent of Hanoverian troops in Venetian pay. When Louis XIV invaded the Empire in , triggering the Nine Years’ (or Palatinate) War, four of Ernst August’s sons rallied to the cause, commanding Hanoverian forces in the south and west, and in and auxiliaries were supplied to the German electors and the Maritime Powers. Such measures eventually brought the desired result. In December , in exchange for further military aid and support of Austria in imperial elections and the Spanish succession, Hanover was raised to the Ninth Electorate; at a ceremony in Hanover in March , Ernst August finally donned the electoral cap. Steffani played an important part in the negotiations that led to this moment.5 The intention to raise Hanover to the status of electorate had been announced to the existing electors by Emperor Leopold I in September . It had initially been met with approval but later encountered opposition. Difficulties were created by Trier, Cologne, the Palatinate, and especially Württemberg, all of whom objected to the prospect of protestant Hanover becoming an Imperial Standard-Bearer. Steffani was
‒
. Electress Sophie of Hanover: oil painting, ca. , by Andreas Scheitz(?) (Historisches Museum Hannover; by permission)
charged by Ernst August with trying to negotiate an agreement. As he explained to Count Fede in : Having attached myself, then, to the court of Hanover, the whole world saw how I was placed there, and they saw it from two circumstances: first, that wherever there was something important to be done, I was seen to be running there; second, that those princes confided to me their innermost secrets without ever exacting from me the merest shadow of an oath, as is usual in all the courts of Germany.6 Steffani secured the electorate by surrendering the status of standard-bearer in exchange for a promise that Hanover would become imperial treasurer in ; in addition, Ernst August had to guarantee freedom of worship to Catholics and allow the construction in Hanover of a Catholic church and school, conditions with which Steffani sympathized and which he may have proposed.7 Steffani thus repaid the trust placed in him by Ernst August, who rewarded him, according to Hawkins, with a
salary of , thalers.8 If his role in these negotiations was his first significant achievement as a diplomat, for Hanover the electorate was an important step on the path to the English throne. Ernst August and Sophie did much to improve the court buildings at Hanover, namely the Leineschloß (Fig. .). Some old structures were demolished, the Rittersaal was hung with a series of family portraits and coats of arms, organized by Leibniz, and an opera house was built. The palace was described by John Toland in : The Apartments of the Palace are very fine, and richly furnish’d. It was in old Time a large Monastery, but so well metamorphos’d since, that no Footsteps remain of the Original. There is a pritty Theatre with handsom Lodges for all Qualitys; for no body pays Mony that goes to a Play there, the Prince, as in som other Courts of Germany, being at all the expence to entertain the Town as well as the Court. But the Opera-house in the Castle is visited as a Rarity by all Travellers, as being the best painted and the best contriv’d in all Europe. The Elector’s Chappel is also finely painted, and certainly nothing can be in greater Order and Method than whatever belongs to his Highness.9 In the s and s Ernst August and his predecessor also extended the residence at nearby Herrenhausen. Here the court spent almost half the year, from May to October, returning to Hanover on Sundays and feast days. Ernst August also stayed there during the winters of – and – , when he was terminally ill, and Sophie retired there after his death. Toland continued:
. Hanover, the Leineschloß in the seventeenth century (Historisches Museum Hannover; by permission)
‒ He [Elector Georg Ludwig] spends much of his Time at Hernhausen, which is a Country-house about an English Mile and a half from Hanover. The Garden is delicat indeed, the Water-works great and noble, the Basins and Fountains extremely large, the Wilderness curiously contriv’d, and deck’d with a perpetual Verdure; the Walks are made firm enough with a sort of Gravel they get out of the River; the Orangery is counted one of the largest in all Europe; there are beautiful Cascades, and there is a perfect Theatre excellently cut out into green Seats, the dressing-rooms for the actors being so many Bowers and Summer-houses on each side, the whole set off with many fine Statues, most of ‘em gilt, and an excellent Water-work just behind.10 The character of the Hanoverian court owed much to the presence there, from , of the philosopher, mathematician, historian, and court librarian, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz. Although, in his opinion, in most of Germany there was ‘among the nobility, bent on the pleasures of hunting and the table, no intellectual curiosity, no elegant and polite conversation, no intermediate class between the scholars and the masses’,11 the situation was much better at Hanover, especially after the arrival of Sophie in .12 As a young woman at Heidelberg, Sophie had been influenced by the scholar and diplomat Baron Ezechiel von Spanheim, and in Hanover, according to the library records of the s and s, she read Molière, Rabelais, Descartes, and Spinoza.13 She was, or became, interested in philosophy, history, literature, music, and art; theology she discussed with Gerard Wolter Molanus, abbot of nearby Loccum. Although she was a protestant, she was broad-minded and tolerant; Italian Catholics, French Huguenots, Jews, and even Turks, captured on campaign, rubbed shoulders at Hanover with Germans.14 Toland found the court in general ‘extremely polite . . . the best, both for Civility and Decorum’, and more sober than any other that he knew.15 The cultural orientation, as previously at Osnabrück, was predominantly French: as the Mercure galant reported in , ‘the court of Hanover, which follows all the fashions of that of France, imitates it also in its divertissements’.16
Musical and Operatic Background The ‘divertissements’ mentioned above were probably French comedies, a regular form of entertainment at court,17 but the word could also refer to ballet or instrumental music. As far as singers are concerned, the tradition was to employ Italians.18 Ernst August’s predecessor, Johann Friedrich, and the latter’s wife Benedikte Henriette, daughter of Edward, prince palatine, were both Catholics with French leanings, but Johann Friedrich was also a frequent visitor to Venice and a lover of Italian church music and opera. His Kapellmeister at Hanover between and was Antonio Sartorio; the Kapelle comprised seventeen musicians, including the gamba player Clamor Heinrich Abel and the violinist Nicolaus Adam Strungk (both of whom were organists and composers, too), and the organist Johann Anton Coberg. Sartorio was succeeded by Vincenzo De Grandis, who had joined the Kapelle in ; the establishment was still about the same size in , when there was also an organ builder
and a lute maker on the books.19 The repertory included Orazio Tarditi’s Messa e salmi for four voices, op. (), Masses in four and five parts by Bonifazio Graziani, and motets for two to five voices by Henry Du Mont.20 Soon after the accession of the protestant Ernst August, most of the singers in the Kapelle were dismissed, and music for services was provided thereafter by boys. De Grandis left to become maestro di cappella at Modena, but Abel, Strungk, and Coberg were retained, Strungk as court and chamber composer from Easter . Coberg was made responsible for the musical education of the ducal family, teaching Sophie Charlotte to play the harpsichord; in – , at the age of fifteen, she enchanted the French court with her playing, and in later life she called Coberg twice to Berlin. He also taught Ernst August’s granddaughter, Sophie Dorothea (born ), and Caroline of Ansbach, who, as a ward of the elector of Brandenburg, was brought up in Berlin by Sophie Charlotte. He may also have taught Ernst August, whose initials appeared, with the date , in a manuscript of French clavecin music, now lost.21 In Ernst August also reorganized the court orchestra, appointing JeanBaptiste Farinel as concertmaster (‘maître des concerts’). Apart from a period in Osnabrück between and , Farinel remained at Hanover until , when he became George I’s agent in Venice. Six other Frenchmen and three Germans were appointed alongside him, making an ensemble of ten players in all. Some of these had been with Ernst August in Osnabrück and moved with him to Hanover. Here there were also eight trumpeters and two drummers. The relative importance of these musicians is suggested by the salaries they earned: Farinel received thalers per annum, the other Frenchmen each, the trumpeters and drummers . On Steffani’s arrival in the ensemble was modest in size and almost entirely French. The string players, in addition to Farinel, were presumably Valoix, Vezin, Bertrand, and Le Comte; Babel, Barrey, and Heroux were described as oboists, but Babel was probably the bassoonist who fathered the harpsichordist William Babell.22 Only Coberg and the organ builder, Vater, were German. Farinel went to Osnabrück in , but when he returned, in , at an increased salary of thalers, the ensemble was strengthened by the appointment of Thielke (viola da gamba) and Giuseppe Pignietta (lute), each on a salary of thalers. By the time Georg Ludwig succeeded to the electorate in , there were at least seventeen instrumentalists on the payroll—seven string players (including François Venturini, a Walloon23), Clemente Monari (bass viol or violone), three or four ‘oboists’, half a dozen Germans, Charles Ennuy (Anna Maria Ennuy had married Venturini in ), and Federico Lotti (born in , brother of the composer Antonio) —and when Handel became Kapellmeister in the orchestra had grown to nineteen. Under the leadership of Farinel the orchestra at Hanover enjoyed a high reputation. Mattheson praised his careful attention to tuning.24 Farinel first tuned his own violin, bowing rather than plucking the strings, then gave the tunings, one string at a time, to the second player, who did exactly the same, passing the notes to the next player, and so on, until the whole ensemble was perfectly in tune. Mattheson marvelled at the resulting blend and considered this method superior to that of Hamburg, where all the players tuned at once, holding their instruments under their arm. He also reported that when Ernst August’s sister, Sophie Amalie, queen of Denmark-
‒ Norway, visited Herrenhausen in , ‘the French violinists performed, as usual, really excellently, and through the entire evening meal Farinel had them play the airs of the celebrated Lully, which amazed everyone by their euphonious sound’.25 Mattheson’s report also indicates the kind of repertory favoured at court. Lully was immensely popular: dances from his dramatic works could be bought in manuscript at the Hanover bookshop.26 During the queen’s visit the thirteen-year-old Sophie Charlotte appeared in June in the title role of La chasse di Diane, a comédie-ballet with music by members of the establishment.27 Long after her marriage and removal to Berlin, Hanover enjoyed comédie-ballets and suites of dances from them. The three parts of Abel’s published collection of dances ( –) were reprinted at Brunswick in , and much of Strungk’s music was composed in the s and s. Some of the court repertory survives in manuscript in Darmstadt.28 Twelve anonymous orchestral suites (D-DS, MS ) were copied at Hanover in by Charles Babel, who later edited two volumes of Trios de différents autheurs (Amsterdam, [], []). Six French cantatas for soprano and instruments (DS, MS , and ), copied in about , predate by over a decade the earliest such works in Parisian prints. There is also a collection of twelve ‘concerts’ (DS, MS ), mostly singlemovement works alternating trio and tutti sections and resembling Venturini’s Concerti da camera (Amsterdam, ca. ), and another of Italian solo cantatas (DS, MS ). Pieces by Farinel, ‘Valloy’ [Valoix], and Venturini were transcribed for recorder in the first decade of the eighteenth century (D-HVl, MS IV. ). Since Farinel and the French style continued to influence music at Hanover during this period, the orchestra constituted an important bridge from Lully to Handel and Telemann. Carnival celebrations were introduced to Hanover in . They were modelled on those of Venice, to which Ernst August and his brothers were such frequent visitors that they rented a palace on the Grand Canal and boxes in several theatres; the duke, who made seven visits, the last in , became one of the most lavish patrons of music in the city, eventually employing his own Venetian cappella, including the singers Antonio Borosini and Nicola Paris, with Antonio Giannettini as maestro.29 The celebrations at Hanover took a variety of forms, among them ballet, comedy, banquet, masquerade, Wirtschaft, and finally opera. A Wirtschaft was a kind of masque in which the nobility ‘dressed down’ as peasants and farmers. It consisted essentially of a ball, punctuated by feasting and short theatrical scenes; partners for dancing were chosen by lot, and the entertainment was controlled by a host and hostess, normally the ducal couple. The Wirtschaft was very popular with both townsfolk and the court, attracting visitors from far and wide.30 Italian opera came to Hanover rather later than to the Catholic (and more southerly) courts of Vienna, Dresden, and Munich, and there were only six productions before Steffani arrived (Table .).31 It has been suggested that Orontea was preceded by earlier examples,32 but this is not supported by evidence. That this work was performed in is clear from the printed libretto; that it was the first of its kind is proved by a manuscript inventory of properties for Alceste, drawn up in , which refers to ‘the stock of costumes belonging to the first opera, Orontea’.33 This and the next four productions were local adaptations of works written originally for Venice. The gap between and reflects the fact that, during the early years of his
.
Italian opera at Hanover before Steffani’s arrival
Date
Title
Librettist
Composer
February
Orontea
July February June
Orontea (?) Alceste Alceste
Helena rapita da Paride Paride in Ida
Nicolo Montalbano, after Cicognini As above Ortensio Mauro, after Aureli As above, with prologue by Valenti Valenti, after Aureli
Antonio Cesti or Francesco Lucio As above Matthio Trento, after P. A. Ziani As above, with prologue by P. A. Fiocco Giovanni Domenico Freschi (?)
Nicola Nicolini
Luigi Mancia
reign, Ernst August was preoccupied with dynastic and political affairs, spent large sums of money on troops, and frequented the carnival in Venice. As the decade progressed, he realized that he could make as great an impression by mounting productions in Hanover. If Paride in Ida exposed the court’s limited theatre facilities, it must also have persuaded the duke to place opera on a new footing. He already had a fine orchestra and a poet capable of writing librettos; what he needed was a new opera house and a first-rate Kapellmeister. The poet was (Bartolomeo) Ortensio Mauro.34 Born in Verona in or and educated in Padua, Mauro had served the house of Brunswick since at least . His first appointments seem to have been as Italian secretary to Georg Wilhelm and then, from or , Johann Friedrich. In he became a secular priest (abate), and from , possibly earlier, he assisted Ferdinand von Fürstenberg, prince-bishop of Münster and Paderborn. According to Fischer, it was when Fürstenberg died, in , that Mauro entered the service of Ernst August, but a letter from Sophie to her brother Karl Ludwig reveals that her husband had taken him on by April .35 Mauro enjoyed the affection and respect of the whole court, especially his collaborator Steffani, and of the Catholic community in Hanover; he occasionally was given diplomatic responsibility, and in old age could write to George I as a friend. He died on September , in his nineties, and was buried in St Clement’s, a church that Steffani had built.36 Paolo Rolli expressed an interest in succeeding him, and Stefano Benedetto Pallavicini composed a sonnet in his memory.37 Mauro played an important part in the cultural life of the court. Having adapted Alceste (), he wrote the librettos of Steffani’s Hanover operas and doubtless of his Amor vien dal destino, which, although it was premièred in Düsseldorf, clearly originated in Hanover. He may have written the libretto of Paolo Magni’s Amfione (Milan, ),38 certainly penned that of Ariosti’s Atys, o L’inganno vinto dalla costanza (Berlin, ), and apparently sketched the plot and recitative of Ariosti’s one-act opera Le fantôme amoureux (Berlin, ).39 His earliest poem apparently dates from , when he wrote about a visit to the silver mines in the Harz mountains. He composed verse for the Wirtschaft at Celle in and ‘a kind of serenade’, with roles for Bacchus, Cupid, and Venus, in .40 That he wrote the words of eight Italian chamber duets by Carlo Luigi Pietragrua,41 a musician at Düsseldorf from to , lends weight to
‒ Hawkins’s statement that he supplied the texts of some of Steffani’s duets and of twelve composed by Handel at Hanover.42 He also wrote poetry in Latin and French: on September Just Christoph Böhmer, abbot of Loccum, informed the theologian Christoph August Heumann that he had collected Mauro’s songs (‘carmina’) and considered them worthy of publication — particularly the Latin, ‘which for acuity of sentiment and elegance of diction are scarcely inferior to the compositions of the ancient poets’.43 Twenty-eight of Mauro’s Latin poems were published posthumously in – ; most of these were reprinted, along with two ‘new’ ones, in .44 The theatre that had housed the six operas of – had been designed by Girolamo Sartorio and built for Johann Friedrich in –.45 An intimate court theatre (‘Komödiensaal’ or ‘Schloßtheater’) seating , it was ideal for French comedy but inadequate for Italian opera, lacking modern scenery and machines: when opera was produced there in , , and , the theatre was adapted on each occasion by the supervisor of buildings, Brand Westermann.46 A purpose-built opera house would obviate this problem, discourage the duke from spending carnival in Venice (the cost of which had risen sharply and attracted criticism), and enhance Hanover’s artistic and political status, especially if it opened before the new theatre in Brunswick. A site was bought, with building permission, in December ,47 and the new Wolfenbüttel theatre was considered as a possible model.48 The principal architect was Johann Peter Wachter, master builder at Heidelberg, but construction work appears to have been supervised by Westermann. This entailed the removal of the court library, which was accomplished by May, during Leibniz’s visit to Munich.49 The stage equipment and machinery were entrusted to Johann Oswald Harms, the greatest stage designer in north Germany, who was paid at Easter and left in June of the following year. Though not completely finished, the opera house opened in January , a year before the new Rathaus theatre in Brunswick. It was finally completed in May ; the cost amounted to , thalers between June and June , and , thalers in – .50 Although the opera house was demolished in , details of its construction and machinery can be seen in the drawings of the Hanover architect Johann Friedrich Junge, published in (Figs. . and .).51 The building as a whole was rectangular, but the auditorium inside was semicircular. There were four tiers of boxes, and the seating capacity was , (the eighteenth-century ‘Cuvilliés-Theater’ in Munich, which still stands, accommodates ). The luxurious interior was described in by Countess Maria Aurora von Königsmarck to Queen Ulrika Eleonora of Sweden:52 The place where it [the opera] is performed could be called the ‘golden house’. The boxes in which the court sits are decked throughout with glittering gold sculptures, the rich wall-coverings being of golden material with velvet stripes as red as fire. When these boxes are lit by white candles and filled with so many bejewelled princesses and other well-bred ladies, the sight is enough to transport one out of one’s senses. . . . The theatre is built in a very noble style, the stage is broad, and the perspectives are wondrously beautiful.
. Hanover opera house: plan by Johann Friedrich Junge, from Johann Friedrich von Penther, Vierter Theil der ausführlichen Anleithung zur Bürgerlichen Bau-Kunst (Augsburg, ) (GB-Lbl, . h. ; by permission of The British Library)
Assessments of the house were based both on its beautiful auditorium and scenery and on its miraculous machines. The sets could be changed very quickly to create striking transformations of scene, a facility that Mauro and Steffani were quick to exploit. Palmieri told Sophie in that the theatre was better than that in Brunswick; two years later Benedikte Henriette informed her that it surpassed the one in Vienna.53 No sooner had the opera house been opened than work began on the construction of the charming garden theatre at Herrenhausen. The cultivation of such a theatre, to designs by Westermann and Martin Charbonnier, inevitably took a few years, yet the project was completed in .54 Although the layout made use of perspective, unprecedented in a garden, there is no evidence that the theatre staged opera. Even if it did, it is unlikely to have accommodated either of Steffani’s one-act pastoral works: it would not have been ready for La lotta d’Hercole con Acheloo in , and the performances of Baccanali in took place in chilly February and November.
Kapellmeister Steffani is the composer whom Ernst August engaged to create opera worthy of an electorate. Having wrapped up his affairs in Munich, Steffani went to Venice in May and was in Hanover by June.55 The Hanoverian minister Albrecht Philipp von
‒
. Hanover opera house: cross-section by Johann Friedrich Junge, from Johann Friedrich von Penther, Vierter Theil der ausführlichen Anleithung zur Bürgerlichen Bau-Kunst (Augsburg, ) (GB-Lbl, . h. ; by permission of The British Library)
dem Bussche informed Leibniz that ‘our music is beginning to grow, and the Kapellmeister Steffani, from Munich, has already arrived’;56 he was just under thirty-four years of age. The nature of his appointment is clear from the first reference to him in the court accounts: between Whitsun and Whitsun ‘the Kapellmeister Stephani’ was granted thalers and groschen for paper for operas,57 presumably Henrico Leone and La lotta d’Hercole con Acheloo. Details of his emoluments appear in a later document: ‘To Abbot Stephani, as Kapellmeister, [by order dated] February , thalers per month, therefore , thalers per year, are most graciously assigned. These sums are paid, during the life of the very blessed Lord, from the Osnabrück moneys, but after these cease the thalers per month will be paid to Abbot Stephani by the treasury as a salary in addition to his daily thalers’.58 The high level of his remuneration is a sign of the esteem in which he was held. His salary was more than double that of Farinel, while his subsistence allowance, which amounted to , thalers per annum, raised his income by over five times as much again. At first, his salary was paid from Ernst August’s revenue as prince-bishop of Osnabrück, but after the duke’s death it was paid, like the allowance, by the court exchequer. Ernst August met virtually all the cost of the opera from his Osnabrück funds, so there is no sign of this expenditure in the court accounts. Moreover, since the Osnabrück ledgers are lost,
there is no way of knowing how much he spent on these ‘magnificent and expensfull diversions’ (Evelyn);59 according to the English envoy, Sir William Dutton Colt, the opera had cost as much as two regiments.60 Steffani’s period as Kapellmeister was the heyday of Baroque opera at Hanover (Table .). Although he retained the title until he left in ,61 he did not perform all the duties of the post after ; from he was increasingly involved in diplomatic activity, and from he was constantly absent from court. Pietro Torri was appointed temporary Kapellmeister for carnival , and in the following year the opera was managed by Count Francesco Palmieri.62 Apart from , at least one new three-act opera was performed every year from to ; in some years (– ) there was also a revival of the previous year’s work, in others ( and ) a new one-act piece. That Steffani composed the first six of the eight full-length works is clear from his autograph scores. The penultimate opera was probably by Torri, the last certainly by the Luigi Mancia who in had written Paride in Ida. Neither of the one-act works survives in autograph score, but Steffani’s hand is suggested by other evidence. There was no opera in , following the death of Ernst August in January, and the theatre remained closed for many years. The heyday was brief, the seasons were short, and the repertory was small, but the performances ravished the ear and the eye. The Hanover opera was the talk of the Empire, and Steffani was right at the heart of it. The idea for an opera on Henry the Lion ( – ), duke of Saxony and Bavaria, goes back at least to the spring of , when Leibniz visited Munich to investigate the history of the Guelphs. On / May the Hanoverian minister Otto Grote ad .
Italian opera at Hanover during Steffani’s period as Kapellmeister
Date
Title
Acts
Libretto
Music
January Summer February February
Henrico Leone La lotta d’Hercole con Acheloo La superbia d’Alessandro Orlando generoso Il zelo di Leonato Le rivali concordi Orlando generoso La libertà contenta Le rivali concordi I trionfi del fato Baccanali I trionfi del fato Baccanali Briseide La costanza nelle selve
b
Mauro Mauro Mauro Mauro
Steffania Steffani Steffania Steffania
Mauro
Steffania
Mauro
Steffania
Mauro Mauro
Steffania Probably Steffani
Palmieri Mauro
Probably Torri Mancia
February , February , February Carnival November February Summer a Steffani’s b Plus
autograph score survives. prologue. La superbia d’Alessandro was revised as Il zelo di Leonato ().
‒ vised him to return without delay, ‘because, among other things, his highness is inclining to have an opera produced on the history of Henry the Lion, at which your presence and opinions could be very necessary’.63 Three months later Ortensio Mauro told Leibniz that ‘her highness is going with the whole court to the Brunswick fair; she is leaving me here to get on with the opera Henry the Lion, which embarrasses me greatly, never having written one before’.64 Mauro had adapted the libretto of Alceste (), but Henrico Leone is the first opera of which the words are entirely his own. As Sophie informed Leibniz on / September , ‘the piece about Henry the Lion is being written by Signor Ortensio. I believe this subject was chosen [by Ernst August] so that posterity does not forget all the states that once belonged to this house’.65 Preparations for the performance gathered momentum during the autumn. For assistance the court turned naturally to Modena, where Giannettini had been maestro di cappella since : on October he agreed to the temporary release of Antonio Borosini (tenor) and Giuseppe Galloni (violin).66 The composition of the opera was finished before the end of the year (the autograph is dated ), and on January Sophie told Leibniz that beautiful voices were reviving the memory of Henry the Lion.67 The dates of the general rehearsal and first performance are revealed in a letter from Giannettini to the Modenese secretary and poet Giovanni Battista Giardini:68 I have just received a letter of January from Borosini, which informs me that they were having to hold the general rehearsal of their opera on the th in order then to perform it on the th, and that the elector and electress of Brandenburg, the landgrave of Hesse-Kassel, the princess of Friesland, and all the other members of the house of Brunswick were present in Hanover for the occasion. Electress Sophie Charlotte and her husband had arrived as early as January, perhaps to attend rehearsals.69 The first performance was a gala occasion. It inaugurated Ernst August’s new opera house, marked the début of his new Kapellmeister, and, most important, celebrated the th anniversary of one of Henry the Lion’s most courageous exploits, the raising of the siege of Bardowick (). The history of Henry the Lion was not unknown in Steffani’s day. It had been codified in Heinrich Göding’s extended poem Eine schöne alte Histori von einem Fürsten und Herrn, Herrn Hertzogen zu Braunschweig und Lüneburgk . . . in gesangs weis gerichtet (), and information was to be found in Heinrich Meybaum’s Braunschweigische und Lüneburgische Chronica (Magdeburg, );70 the tombs of Henry and his wife were in Brunswick Cathedral, as they are to this day. Nevertheless, Henry had not previously been used as the subject of an opera and was not to appear in another for a hundred years.71 No expense or effort was spared in ensuring that the audience was as conscious as the duchess of the political significance of the event. The printed libretto included French and German translations of the ‘argomento’ and scene-by-scene synopses in both languages. There was also a separate, anonymous pamphlet, in German only,
entitled Gantz kurtzer Bericht und Inhalt der Historie von Hertzog Henrich dem Löwen Und der OPERA Vorinn Er wird fürgestellet Zu Hanover Anno . While the ‘Bericht’ outlines the historical background, the ‘Inhalt’ duplicates both the wordbook’s lists of characters, sets, machines, and dances, and the synopses. The ‘Bericht’ begins, however, with a defence of opera and music in general, prompted, perhaps, by the debate on the morality of opera that had been triggered by the opening of Hamburg’s Gänsemarkt theatre in . Leibniz had expressed the opinion in the early s that opera was a powerful medium, capable of working for good or ill.72 The defence in the ‘Bericht’ states that ‘it is truly far better to raise one’s spirit in a seemly manner with pleasant music, comedy, and opera than to pay a damnable visit and sacrifice to Bacchus and Venus. Nothing in the world will be found that could give mankind greater earthly acceptable satisfaction, and be more permissible, than music’.73 If the Hanoverians did not always live up to such lofty sentiments, this statement suggests that they at least thought about their pleasures and encouraged intellectual activity. The production of Henrico Leone was presumably designed by du Cormier, who had succeeded Girolamo Sartorio as stage designer in and was soon to be followed by Tommaso Giusti: no Steffani opera was designed for Hanover by Harms.74 Like Verdi’s Otello, the opera begins with a storm at sea. As the orchestra repeats the second section of the overture, a four-part chorus sings ‘Cieli, aita, pietà’.75 The curtain rises on Henrico and his servant in a storm-tossed boat. Despite the apparent hopelessness of their situation, Henrico is defiantly optimistic, expressing his confidence in the vigorous ‘Tra le braccia de la morte’.76 By launching this aria with a trio for two oboes and bassoon, Steffani exploits, in the first bar of the first aria in his first Hanover opera, the most distinctive strength of the court orchestra. Henrico’s confidence is not misplaced: as (to a sinfonia) his ship breaks up and his servant drowns, he is plucked from the waves by a griffon and lives to fight another day. Thus right from the start the marvellous theatre machinery was on display. That the work made the desired impression is suggested by a ‘Eulogy of the Most Serene House of Brunswick-Lüneburg and of the grand opera Henry the Lion’ in the wordbook of the ‘pastorale héroique’ Europe (Celle, February ), which begins with this poem:77 Des plus fameux Héros de la race Guelfique Dans un riche appareil et par des vers pompeux Un de ses illustres neveux, Prince puissant et magnifique, A fait représenter les exploits glorieux: Ce spectacle a ravi les esprits et les yeux. [Of the most famous heroes of the house of Guelph, / In rich and lofty verse, / One of its illustrious sons, / A powerful and magnificent prince, / Had the glorious exploits acted on stage: / This spectacle ravished the spirit and the eye.]
The cast of Henrico Leone is somewhat uncertain, despite the survival of evidence: ‘When, in , Italian operas were performed again at Hanover, the singers were as follows. Men: Nicol. Pani, Severo Francioni, Ant. Cottini, Nicolini, Augustino Granara, Nicolini Grationini, Mutio Maria Tallaoni. Women: Victoria’.78 Most of
‒ these singers can be identified. ‘Nicol. Pani’ was the celebrated soprano Nicola Paris from Naples, who had belonged to Ernst August’s cappella in Venice in and been described as a ‘famous swan’ of the duke;79 he may have sung at Hanover from to , for when he appeared in Italy in –, he was ‘detto di Brunsvic’.80 Severo Frangioni was an alto in the choir of St Mark’s, Venice, from July to December ;81 he could have sung at Hanover from to . Antonio Cottini may be the bass ‘Cottini’ — and Tallaoni the tenor ‘Mutio’ — who had belonged to the Hanover Schloßkapelle in the late s82 and sung for Steffani at Munich;83 he may have worked at Hanover on several occasions during the s, before making further appearances in Italy in –.84 Augustino Granara is presumably the ‘Joann Augustin Granara’ who was at Munich from to 85 and the ‘Granara’ who appeared as Bacco in Baccanali, a limited soprano role: since he was already in Hanover in , he may have sung in all of Steffani’s Hanover operas. Nicola Gratianini, bass, had also been a member of the Schloßkapelle and appeared in Orontea and Alceste ();86 he may have been the Nicolò Francesco Grazianini who sang in Milan in 87 and was described by Quadrio as a ‘virtuoso’ of the elector of Cologne who had begun to flourish in the s.88 ‘Victoria’ was presumably the notorious Vittoria Tarquini, known as ‘la Bombace’ or ‘Bambagia’, who made her début in Venice in . On January , three weeks before the première of Henrico Leone, she married Farinel in Copenhagen.89 She sang in Naples in – and then in Tuscany;90 in Sophie repeated a rumour that Handel was her lover.91 The gap in her career suggests that she may have sung in Hanover from to . ‘Nicolini’ is hard to identify, for the name was a common diminutive, but he was not the great alto Nicola Grimaldi, who would have been only fifteen years of age.92 Marles convincingly argues that the nickname refers to Nicola Remolini, a regular singer at Hanover until .93 It is difficult to allocate these eight singers to the nine roles in the opera. The one person who is known to have appeared, Antonio Borosini, is not in the list. Borosini had moved to Modena in or , having sung in the choir of St Mark’s, Venice, since ; in – he appeared in five operas in Italy.94 He seems to have sung at Hanover in , , , , and . If both he and ‘Mutio’ were available, there were two singers for the one tenor role. It is possible that Borosini was a replacement for ‘Mutio’, in which case, however, the complement falls back to eight. The ninth singer was possibly the Signora Cettareli to whom, in early , Ernst August’s agent in Venice gave ‘ ducats to be set against her fee’.95 If the foregoing account is correct, the cast of Henrico Leone may have lined up as follows: Henrico Leone Metilda Almaro Idalba Lindo Errea Eurillo Ircano Demon
Soprano Soprano Tenor Soprano Soprano Alto Alto Bass Bass
Nicola Paris Vittoria Tarquini or Signora Cettareli Antonio Borosini Signora Cettareli or Vittoria Tarquini Nicola Remolini Severo Frangioni Augustino Granara Antonio Cottini/Nicola Gratianini Nicola Gratianini/Antonio Cottini
There can be no question about Borosini as Almaro or about Paris, the best castrato available, as Henrico. If the two largest female roles were taken by women, Metilda and Idalba were sung by Tarquini and Cettareli (or vice versa). The bass parts may have been shared by Gratianini and Cottini or doubled by one of them. Although he was known as a soprano, Granara could have managed the alto role of Eurillo, leaving Frangioni as Errea and Remolini as Lindo. The majority of these singers were presumably chosen by Steffani. He must have worked with Cottini and Granara in Munich; may have heard Borosini at St Mark’s in ; and perhaps engaged Cettareli, Frangioni, Paris, and Tarquini when he visited Venice in May .96 He may not have met Gratianini or Remolini before moving to Hanover, but if the cast list above is correct, neither of these singers was risked in a prominent part. The composer presumably cast all his Hanover operas himself: most of his singers were engaged in Italy or borrowed from Munich, Dresden, or Vienna, and many were at their peak when they sang for him. Since the preceding list of singers refers to a year not a work, it is possible that some of them appeared in La lotta d’Hercole con Acheloo, a ‘divertimento drammatico’ performed in the summer of .97 The subject of this one-act opera is the contest between Hercules and Acheloüs for the hand of Deianeira; the source is Ovid’s Metamorphoses, book IX. The hero is known in the libretto and scores by his alternative name, Alcide; ‘Hercole’ appears only in the title of the wordbook and of two later scores (GB-Lbl, RM . h. and ), which could have been modelled on it. The opera may originally have been entitled ‘La lotta d’Alcide con Acheloo’, the name being changed to ‘Hercole’ when the libretto was printed. The cast comprises two sopranos (Alcide and Deianira) and two altos (Eneo [Oeneus] and Acheloo): it is tempting to see Paris and Tarquini in the (larger) soprano roles, with Frangioni and Granara as the altos. The wordbook names neither poet nor composer, but Mauro and Steffani’s involvement is implied by a letter of January/ February from Sophie to Leibniz: ‘P. S. Your library has been converted into a theatre where the most beautiful operas in the world have been presented. Signor Ortensio writes the verses for them, and Signor Steffani, who was previously with the elector of Bavaria, the music’.98 The ‘operas’ must have included the new one for and at least one of those from the previous year, of which La lotta was the more recent. If anybody other than Mauro and Steffani had written them, Sophie would surely have said so. The composer’s role is confirmed by a contemporary manuscript catalogue of Hanover operas99 and by Mattheson’s list of operas performed in Hamburg. Item in this list, ‘Heinrich der Löwe’, names Steffani as composer and ‘Fideler’ as translator.100 The next entry reads: ‘Alcides. Wie hervorgehende’ (‘Alcides: as above’): Mattheson considered Steffani responsible for an opera about Alcides, and the only such opera by him is La lotta. This is not, however, the ‘Alcides’ that was given in Hamburg.101 The new opera in was La superbia d’Alessandro, which Sophie’s letter implies was performed in late January or early February. This is an ambitious work, intended to reinforce the impression created by Henrico Leone. It is also unusual among Steffani’s operas in having a prologue and a very high number of ensembles: five duets, three
‒ trios, a quartet, and two sextets. The action is based on the story of Alexander the Great at Oxydraca and begins with his daring assault on the city. The plot is explained in a ‘Dichiaratione del Soggetto dell’Opera per le Dame’ in the wordbook, which also gives scene-by-scene synopses in French and German and lists of sets, machines, extras, and dances, all in three languages. A letter of Ernst August reveals that the soprano Rosane Santinelli (‘Rosana’) was engaged from Dresden for the season and performed with ‘approbation’;102 according to Fischer, she was a sister of Farinel and the wife of one Santi Santielli.103 It is assumed that such singers as Paris, Granara, and Remolini took part, but because the voice type of one of the roles is uncertain, it would be impossible to reconstruct the complete cast.104 The carnival of was more ambitious again. On this occasion the new opera, Orlando generoso, was accompanied by a revival of the previous year’s work. The innovation was noted by Leibniz105 and furnished a pattern for the next two carnivals: an account of the performances in suggests that the new opera was presented first and the revival second. Leibniz also confirms that the librettist of Orlando generoso was Mauro.106 It is his and Steffani’s first opera based on a ‘modern’ literary source — Ariosto’s romantic epic Orlando furioso— and the first Italian opera in which Orlando’s love, madness, and recovery are the principal concern. The work includes more duets than La superbia d’Alessandro and more arias than any other of Steffani’s Hanover operas, and the overture is the first by him to incorporate Lully-style trios for oboes and bassoon. The revival of Alessandro occasioned extensive revision, including omission of the prologue, and the expansion of the role of Leonato resulted in a new title, Il zelo di Leonato. Singers for the season may have been recruited by Steffani in April , when, according to Fischer, he was in Venice.107 On November/ December, Princess Eberhardine Sophie wrote to Margravine Sophie Louise that ‘this carnival Ferdinando also will sing in Hanover; at the same time two other female singers have arrived who should be extremely good, so that the opera will be much better than it was last year’.108 Ferdinando Chiaravalle was an experienced alto who had sung in Mantua, Modena, and Venice in – and maybe at Hanover in Mancia’s Paride in Ida (); he sang in the Hanover carnivals of , (possibly), , , and , and in Berlin for Sophie Charlotte. One observer described him as incomparable: ‘he has everything necessary for performance in a theatre; he is tall and well built, his face is pleasant, and he has a marvellous understanding of the stage’.109 Leibniz wrote that in Ariosti’s Atys, o L’inganno vinto dalla costanza () ‘Mr Ferdinando a paru le plus avantagieusement du monde’.110 The doubling of the number of carnival operas at Hanover coincided with the intensification of Ernst August’s campaign for an electorate. The addition of a second opera enhanced the attraction of the festivities and impressed the court’s visitors and guests. At the same time, however, it put extra pressure on those involved in producing the works. It is not known why Farinel left Hanover in , but one wonders whether his departure for Osnabrück was related to the heavier schedule. In his Memoirs of Steffani, Hawkins included an anecdote suggesting that the Hanover opera was not always sweetness and light:
This latter trust [the management of the opera], however agreeable it might be to his inclination, was the occasion of great uneasiness to him [Steffani]; for whether it was owing to the ignorance, or petulance, of the persons employed to sing, it was, frequently, with great difficulty they could be prevailed on to study their parts, so as to do justice to the composer; and, even when their condescension was greatest in this respect, so many feuds and jealousies were continually arising among them, that an illustrious audience were frequently disappointed of their entertainment. This particular is, in some degree, verified, by what is related of the elector’s son, the late K[ing] George the first, who, upon some such occasion as this, prevailed on our author to resign his charge, for a short time, to him; imagining, perhaps, that his rank and quality might give him a better title to command this set of people, than even the great merit of their manager; but he was soon convinced of the difficulty of the undertaking, for in a few days he quitted it, and left them to themselves, declaring, that he could, with much more ease, command an army of fifty thousand men, than manage a company of opera singers.111 Whoever ‘related’ this episode, it presumably contains a grain of truth. No date was given by Hawkins, but the introduction of a new schedule and the departure of Farinel suggest that it may have occurred during rehearsals for carnival . Hawkins also implies that the difficulties were confined to the singers, but if Vittoria Tarquini was involved, she may have departed and taken her husband with her. Be that as it may, preparations went ahead for the following year. Farinel was replaced by Galloni,112 who had played in Henrico Leone, and by / November Leibniz could write: ‘Here an Italian opera is being prepared; when everything is ready, we shall see the courts of Celle and Wolfenbüttel’.113 The new opera, Le rivali concordi (Fig. .), was based on the Greek legend of the Calydonian hunt; that Mauro wrote the libretto is confirmed by the manuscript catalogue of Hanover operas. The wordbook () includes a French ‘argument’ and German ‘Einhalt’, but synopses in those languages were published separately, as they had been for Orlando generoso.114 Borosini returned to sing the role of Giasone, and that of Ruggiero in the revival of Orlando, which was transposed for him, but the casts are otherwise uncertain. The revival also entailed the transposition of the title role, substitution of eight arias, and addition of two new ones. The last performance of the season took place on February/ March. On the following day Sophie wrote to Count Luigi Ballati: ‘Peace has been made between him [Maximilian II Emanuel of Bavaria] and the duke [Ernst August of Hanover], whom he saw the day before yesterday and then at Celle. . . . Yesterday we saw the opera for the last time, which succeeded very well, to the glory of the librettist, the singers, and Abbot Steffani. For my part, I sometimes fall asleep, but that’s a secret. I do not wish to appear in bad taste’.115 Her letter suggests that Le rivali concordi was intended to celebrate an agreement between the elector and the duke. Mauro, Steffani, and the musicians were surely the principal architects of Hanover’s operatic success, although the carnival expenditure of , thalers presumably helped.116 The audience, incidentally, must have been unusually quiet and attentive: it is hard to imagine anyone nodding off in the public theatres of the time.117
‒
. Beginning of aria ‘A che serve la bellezza’ from Le rivali concordi (), Act II, scene , in Steffani’s hand (GB-Lbl, RM . k. , f. ; by permission of The British Library)
The carnival of was even more extravagant. The first since the raising of Hanover to the ninth electorate, it marked this historic development in uniquely magnificent style. Over a period of six weeks, the court and its guests enjoyed a daily succession of balls, banquets, masquerades, operas, Wirtschaften, and plays, including Corneille’s Nicomède, Molière’s Festin de Pierre, and Lully’s Psyché. The courts of Celle and Brandenburg were again in attendance, but not that of Wolfenbüttel: after the senior branch of the house stayed away,118 piqued, perhaps, by the Lüneburgers’ political success. An account of the season was given in March by Countess Aurora von Königsmarck to Queen Ulrika Eleonora of Sweden. The celebrations began in January with a Wirtschaft, of which a wordbook, unusually, survives,119 and ended in late February with another. The operas, also, were staged in this month, which began in the following way: February French comedy; dinner; ball February Lunch; dance; two French comedies; dinner February ‘On Friday February the elector gave dinner with Tafelmusik. After dining, their lordships stayed together, seeking to entertain themselves with conversation or games. At six o’clock we went to the Italian opera ‘La liberté contentée’. After the opera there was supper at court, after which we retired.’120
La libertà contenta was performed on and February, the revival of Le rivali concordi four days later: ‘on th of the month the duchess of Ostfriesland arrived. The opera ‘Les deux rivales concordés’ began at six o’clock and lasted till eleven. After supper their lordships retired’.121 The revival was repeated on February, at least; the wordbook is undated, but as before, the process entailed revision (substitutions, an added scene, and a modified ending). The libretto of La libertà contenta, by Mauro,122 is based on the life of the dissolute Athenian commander Alcibiades. The wordbook is decorated by crowns, a new typographical feature displaying Hanover’s pride in its recent elevation; one copy includes an extra printed sheet with a prologue in which Mars, in a stage machine, praises the elector of Brandenburg.123 Mauro does not name his sources because, as he states at the end, ‘les grecs, dont on parle, sont assez connus dans l’Histoire’. The ultimate authority is Plutarch, whose works were in Steffani’s library,124 but there is a chapter on Alcibiades in Madame de Villedieu’s Les amours des grands hommes (Paris, ), the source of the composer’s Solone (). Alcibiades was also the subject of a tragedy by the French playwright and librettist Jean Galbert de Campistron ( – )125 and of Aureli’s Alcibiade, of which Marc’Antonio Ziani’s setting (Venice, ) was revived at Verona in , when it was dedicated to Anton Ulrich of BrunswickWolfenbüttel.126 But La libertà contenta does not dwell on history or politics. Instead it explores other matters with which Hanover was becoming more and more preoccupied: fidelity and promiscuity, or love and lust. This opera surpasses all others by Steffani in dramatic concentration and musical richness. Although the action is complex, the requirements are modest: a cast of seven (no deities), few sets, no machines, and no supernatural interventions. There are several comic episodes, including a wonderful nocturnal garden scene (from which Handel borrowed), but these hardly disguise the opera’s more serious purpose. As in Così fan tutte a century later, the music transcends the apparent triviality of the subject to probe the heart of human affairs, and it does so in ways which, for its period, are as sublime and as successful as Mozart’s. Some of the singers in the season are mentioned in Countess von Königsmarck’s letter: ‘Nothing can be compared with the splendid and well-appointed costumes or with the beauty of the voices. It is sufficient to say that Clementino, Ferdinando, Nicolini, Borosini, Salvadore, and “la Landini” performed an opera together to prove that one could not hear anything more delightful, more harmonious, or even more angelic’.127 Clementino was the soprano castrato Clementin Hader, now ennobled as von Hadersberg, who had sung for Steffani in Munich. He may have appeared at Hanover in , for now he was keen to return; since this depended on a request from Ernst August to the elector of Saxony, he may have been at Dresden later that year.128 In , also, he was called to Brussels by Maximilian II Emanuel of Bavaria,129 and in November he was proposed by Count Philipp Christoph von Königsmarck, the brother of Aurora and an officer in the Hanoverian army, as a possible teacher for the daughters of Sophie Dorothea of Celle.130 Hader also sang at Hanover in and . ‘Ferdinando’, ‘Nicolini’, and Borosini are familiar figures; since Borosini was employed at Vienna from , Steffani presumably renewed his acquaintance with him when he went there for negotiations about the electorate.131
‒ ‘Salvadore’ is unknown, but Maria Landini was a soprano, born in Hamburg, who served Queen Christina of Sweden in Rome and returned to Germany after Christina’s death in . Landini must have been in Hanover by mid-, when she, Clementino, and Nicolini were loaned to Celle; she also sang at Hanover in , when she married an actor named Chateauneuf,132 and in .133 For Hanover also tried to recruit Margherita Salicola from Dresden;134 Rosane Santinelli was offered instead, but it is not known whether she went. Steffani was now thirty-eight years old and at the pinnacle of his musical and diplomatic career at Hanover. He had played a crucial role in the negotiations leading to the electorate—though he would have more to do on this score — and composed and directed the operas to celebrate the event. That isolated movements from Le rivali concordi and La libertà contenta survive in many manuscript collections is a sign that these operas made a powerful impression and became known far and wide — and quickly, for the latter was never revived. These successes were not followed up in . A letter from Sophie to a court official implies that carnival was celebrated at Hanover as usual that year,135 but there is no evidence that any opera was performed: the electress does not mention one, and no Hanoverian libretto or score bears the date. The absence of opera in may have been due to the Königsmarck affair.136 By Prince Georg Ludwig, the future George I, had taken as mistress Countess (Ehrengard) Melusine von der Schulenburg, later duchess of Kendal. In the early s, too, his wife Sophie Dorothea had embarked on a passionate affair with Count Königsmarck, her lover from March . Although they tried to keep their relationship secret by writing in code, using nicknames, and expressing their feelings in quotations from Mauro’s librettos, they were inevitably found out. On the night of / July Königsmarck was murdered in the palace. Shortly afterward the enormous sum of , thalers was settled on Nicolo Montalbano, a Venetian who had served Ernst August since and adapted the libretto of Orontea. Königsmarck’s body was dumped in the River Leine, Sophie Dorothea’s marriage was dissolved, and she was banished to the castle of Ahlden for the remaining thirty-two years of her life. The count’s disappearance was completely hushed up, because it could have jeopardized Hanover’s rise to the electorate (still a sensitive issue).137 Although no opera was performed there in , Steffani may have composed one. Amor vien dal destino resembles his Hanover operas more closely than those for Düsseldorf, where it was premièred in . Riemann recognized Mauro’s hand in the libretto,138 which comprises three acts and an ‘introduzione’ rather than the five acts typical of Pallavicini. Unlike Steffani’s other Düsseldorf operas, this one survives in an autograph score (GB-Lbl, RM . h. – ) that includes added folios in the hand of his later copyist, Gregorio Piva, suggesting that the opera was written for Hanover and adapted for Düsseldorf. It could, however, have been intended for or , rather than . Like I trionfi del fato (), Amor vien dal destino is based on the story of Aeneas in Italy. Its central figure is Turnus (hence the original title, Il Turno, in the autograph), but the theme of the opera is the inevitability of fate. Since the role of fate is made clearer in I trionfi del fato, especially in the revised version, this appears to be the later work. The reverse, however, is implied by the fact that Amor vien dal destino is more satisfactory as a drama than even the revised version of I trionfi del fato. The
evidence of the music is no more conclusive. The tenor role of Aeneas looks as though it was composed for Borosini (resembling his parts in Henrico Leone, Le rivali concordi, La libertà contenta, and I trionfi del fato), but Borosini did not go to Hanover in . If he withdrew at a late stage and no replacement was available, he may have put paid to the production. Alternatively, if Amor vien dal destino was ready for but not performed, it could have been staged in , obviating the need for a new opera then. The elaborate lute part in the opening scene suggests that the work was composed after the appointment of Pignietta in . Since it could not have been written for , the year of Briseide, it may have been intended for , when, for some unknown reason, there was no carnival opera at Hanover, or for , when the death of Ernst August in January kept the curtain down. In Steffani published a short dissertation entitled Quanta certezza habbia da suoi principii la musica et in qual pregio fosse perciò presso gli antichi. It was written in response to a letter from a ‘Marchese A. G.’ in defence of a proposition that he, Steffani, had advanced at an ‘assemblea’ in Hanover in September .139 Steffani’s correspondent could conceivably have been the Marquis Angelo Gabrielli from Rome who was in Hanover in –.140 ‘A. G.’ had asked whether music was a science and held in greater esteem by the ancients than it was at the time of writing. Steffani’s reply, which runs to seventy-two pages, attempts to prove that music is a science of which the purpose is to move the passions by means of sound: Music is ordained, therefore, to move, correct, change, and calm the passions of the mind. But by what power? Oh, this is the point! By the power of harmony. Now, since there is no harmony without interval, and no interval without notes, let us first consider what a note is and how a musician regards it. . . . ‘A note is a sound’s fall, suitable for song, on to a single pitch’.141 Steffani claims, in line with Pythagoras, that the passions are caused by proportional relations between the four humours, and he illustrates the power of music by reference to ancient Greek history and the Bible. Having summarized various definitions of sound from Antiquity to Zarlino, he invokes such authorities as Aristotle, Aristoxenus, and Boethius to explain how the science of music is grounded in arithmetic. He regarded this science as a speculative art, not merely a practical activity: I am sure that anybody who has a desire to be a musician, not contenting himself with being a composer, singer, or instrumentalist, could attempt it with the greatest of ease. I say this in order to encourage young people not to let this wonderful science perish in misery and not to be satisfied with acquiring a grasp of its surface. 142 According to Joscelyn Godwin, ‘in his praise of the Senary, supported by many symbolic examples, and his conviction that the whole world is harmonious, Steffani belongs firmly in the Renaissance tradition. His book could have been written just as well years previously’.143 Quanta certezza represents a more thorough exposition of ideas that Steffani had published in the dedication of his Sacer Ianus quadrifrons (). There he had described music as the pre-eminent mathematical science, the purpose of which was ‘to excite,
‒ calm, suppress, moderate, in a word to rule and govern the various movements of the soul’,144 and there, too, he had illustrated music’s power by citing examples from ancient history and the Bible. His dissertation may be seen also as part of a contemporary debate on the nature of music and music theory — a struggle between conservative ‘scholastics’ and progressive pragmatics. A German translation, by Andreas Werckmeister, was published in and reprinted in ,145 and from this a definition of musical theory was quoted verbatim by Johann Heinrich Buttstett in his Ut, mi, sol, re, fa, la, tota musica et harmonia aeterna (Erfurt, ).146 Buttstett’s treatise was an attack on the modern approach advocated by Mattheson in Das neu-eröffnete Orchestre (), but most of his arguments were soon demolished in Mattheson’s Das beschützte Orchestre (). In his secular compositions, at least, Steffani was a modern, but in his writings he was unequivocally conservative. He was doubtless inclined in this direction by his education, which, to judge by Quanta certezza, included classics, music, and theology. His treatise shows that there was interest in this debate at Hanover and is a sign of the intellectual activity that flourished at the court under the influence of Sophie and Leibniz.147 Irrespective of the views that it presents, it evokes the context in which Steffani was fortunate to work. The subtitle of Quanta certezza reveals, incidentally, that by the author was an Apostolic Prothonotary. This had been an extremely high office: in later Antiquity the seven regional notaries were the supreme palace notaries of the papal chancery; in the Middle Ages they were often promoted direct to the cardinalate. A distinction was made in the sixteenth century between honorary prothonotaries, with some of the former privileges, and titular prothonotaries, who held a corresponding position in the administration of the episcopal ordinariate or in the collegiate chapter. Sixtus V ( – ) increased their number to twelve, whereupon they declined in importance, almost disappearing by the time of the French Revolution.148 Steffani was presumably a titular prothonotary with responsibility for certain aspects of church administration in north Germany. The date of his appointment has not been found. The carnival of was the only one at Hanover during the Baroque period when both of the operas were new. There could be no revival from , because there had been no opera that year; La libertà contenta () had not been revived, but its subject would have been unsuitable after the murder of Königsmarck. The new operas were I trionfi del fato and Baccanali. The festivities were curtailed, however, by the death on December of Queen Mary of England. On January Count Ernst August von Platen wrote that ‘we shall go into grieving for her on the day after tomorrow and have the carnival entertainments stopped, except for the opera, which will be performed a couple more times for the love of the electress of Brandenburg, who will stay here some weeks’.149 It is understandable that opera should be the last thing to be sacrificed, for doubtless much time, money, and effort had been spent on preparations, yet to proceed with performances, especially of such a playful piece as Baccanali, was to fly in the face of convention and show little sympathy or respect. That the Hanoverians did so shows how keen they were to please Sophie Charlotte and, perhaps, her husband, the elector of Brandenburg. An indication of the schedule of the carnival was written into a copy of the
printed Baccanali libretto: ‘Saturday — grand opera; Sunday — comedy; Monday — masques and revels; Tuesday—pastoral; Wednesday—comedy; Thursday—opera’.150 The ‘grand opera’ was I trionfi del fato, the comedy probably a spoken French play, and the pastoral Baccanali. If this pattern was repeated, it may represent the schedule as originally planned; if not, it may be the timetable of the curtailed festivities arranged in the wake of Queen Mary’s demise, an exceptional circumstance that might explain why the schedule was written down at all. The libretto of I trionfi del fato is attributed to Mauro in the manuscript catalogue and his authorship is confirmed by a copy of the wordbook bearing the inscription ‘donum auctoris Domini Abbatis Hortensii Mauri’.151 It is an elaborate tale in which gods intervene in human affairs, manipulating emotions and affecting behaviour. The opera suggests that humans are less in control of their feelings, and less responsible for their actions, than they like to believe, and thus helps to explain and excuse human behaviour, perhaps even to exonerate its agents. If this interpretation is correct, the subject and its treatment appear to have been carefully chosen for the first Hanover opera since Königsmarck’s murder. The work may even have helped the court come to terms with this brutal event, which had severely shaken the ruling house so soon after its rise to the electorate. The wordbook survives in two forms, one entitled I trionfi del fato, the other I trionfi del fato o Le glorie d’Enea. The latter is a radical revision of the former which appears, nevertheless, to have been completed and performed during carnival . On May the Journal de Hambourg reported: There has recently been printed a book entitled I Triomphi del fato, o le Glorie d’Enea. Drama da recitarsi nel Theatro Elettorale d’Hanover, in quarto, (The Triumphs of Fate, or The Glories of Aeneas, &c). It is a dramatic work that was staged at Hanover and formed one of the principal entertainments of the last carnival there. It was called the grand opera to distinguish it from a pastoral that was played in its turn and which also was performed entirely to music.152 Taken together, the words of von Platen and this report suggest that the death of Queen Mary caused performances of the first version to be suspended, creating time in which it was revised. The alterations are more radical than those to any other Steffani opera. The action is made more convincing by the renumbering of scenes, and less reliant on machinery (the sets were painted by Giusti, who also used the story of Aeneas as the theme of his cycle of frescoes in the gallery building at Herrenhausen153). The music is more compact, varied, and atmospheric. Over a dozen arias are omitted, two are substituted, and six are added, one of them in lieu of a duet. Another duet is replaced. The coro is slashed from eighteen bars to seven, of which five are instrumental. The gods retain the same number of arias as they had in the first version, but all the principals lose at least one. The effect of the changes is to strengthen the position of the three central characters, Aeneas, Dido, and Lavinia. While I trionfi del fato was staged in the opera house, Baccanali was performed, according to the libretto and score, ‘nel picciolo theatro elettorale d’Hanover’, perhaps the small theatre used for opera in Johann Friedrich’s day. As its title suggests, this one-
‒ act pastoral is a festive entertainment in light-hearted mood. The libretto, attributed to Mauro in the manuscript catalogue, blends the ancient and relatively modern. After the opening scene, the action unfolds on Mount Parnassus, but most of the characters are nymphs and shepherds from the Arcadia of the Italian Renaissance. The influence of Tasso’s Aminta () is clear, and the games of ‘Oracle’ and ‘Blind Man’s Buff ’ (scenes –) can be traced back to Guarini’s Pastor fido ().154 One sign of the playful atmosphere is the prominence of dancing, which is called for on five occasions (two dances each time); the joyful mood is enhanced by major keys in the overture, the dance music, and two-thirds of the vocal numbers. There is no documentary evidence on who composed Baccanali, but the music is entirely characteristic of Steffani’s style. I trionfi del fato and Baccanali were revived in November to celebrate the marriage of Charlotte Felicitas, eldest daughter of Johann Friedrich, to Rinaldo III of Modena.155 Their union was of great historical significance. Leibniz had discovered that the houses of Brunswick-Lüneburg and Este were both descended from the same eleventh-century couple: Margrave Adelbert Azzo II and his wife Kunigunde.156 The marriage of Rinaldo and Charlotte Felicitas reunited the two branches of the family after an interval of years. Coming soon after the rise to the electorate, it added to Hanover’s sense of dynastic pride. The marriage, by proxy, took place in midNovember.157 Preliminary negotiations had been conducted by Giovanni Morselli da Carpi, a Modenese tenor who had sung in Johann Friedrich’s Schloßkapelle in – 158 and was secretary to his wife Benedikte Henriette from to . Rinaldo was represented in Hanover by his plenipotentiary, Marquis Sigismondo D’Este. The journey to the church was accompanied by trumpets and drums; inside there was ‘musique auff der Tribüne’, followed by a motet, and after the ceremony a salute of guns.159 The court kept open house for the rest of the day, and there was dancing all night. Operas, balls, comedies, and ‘other diversions’ helped pass the time before the departure for Modena. There are two sources of information on singers in opera at Hanover in . The following appears in the memoirs of the court chamberlain Friedrich Ernst von Fabrice: Elector Ernst August had once engaged Nicolini, Ferdinando, Valeriani, and Diamantia, in short all the most notable singers, male and female, that there were in Italy on exorbitant fees, and had the most beautiful stage designs painted. I remember that in my youth I was in one of these operas and that I never saw anything more magnificent than a set of the Elysian Fields, or another in which Turnus and more than Moors fought against just as many Romans. 160 ‘Valeriani’ presumably means Valeriano Pellegrini, a soprano castrato in the papal chapel from to who sang in Cardinal Ottoboni’s concerts in – and in Steffani’s Tassilone (Düsseldorf, ).161 ‘Diamante’ was the celebrated Bolognese soprano Diamante Maria Scarabelli, well known in Italy from to ;162 she could not have appeared at Hanover in , however, for she sang that year in Venice, Turin, Lodi, and Bologna.163 Other problems, also, are raised by this memoir. Aside
from the impossibility of people fighting on stage, the only Hanover opera of this period to feature the Elysian Fields or Turnus is I trionfi del fato, which does not call for Moors. Furthermore, Fabrice does not state that the singers mentioned took part in the opera to which the set belonged. All in all, the memoir is not very helpful. The cast of Baccanali was written into the same wordbook as the carnival schedule: Atlante [B] Bacco [S] Driade [S] Celia [S] Clori [S] Aminta [S] Tirsi [A] Fileno [S] Ergasto [S]
}ninfe
}
pastori
Ruggiero [Fedeli] [Augustino] Granara Hamburghese Dianina [Maria] Landini Nicoletto Ferdinand [Chiaravalle] Nicolino [Remolini] Clementino [Hader]164
The cast presumably relates to carnival , rather than November, although some of the singers may have appeared in both seasons. The Venetian bass, composer, and viola player Ruggiero Fedeli worked in various German courts between and , when he died, and in – he conducted a correspondence with Steffani that sheds light on music at Kassel.165 ‘Hamburghese’ may have been either ‘Engel.’ Benedikte Direnberg or Sophie Gutjahr, two German singers in Hanoverian records for ; the latter, a ‘virtuosa di S. A. E. Madama l’Elletrice’ [Sophie Charlotte], sang in Berlin in .166 Fischer suggested that ‘Dianina’ was borrowed from Celle, but she too was a protégée of the electress.167 Having studied in Turin and sung in northern Italy in – , Diana Aurelia went to Berlin after marrying the librettist Pietro D’Averara, sang in both operas at Hanover in carnival , and returned to Italy in the summer. The identity of ‘Nicoletto’ is uncertain. The wedding of Charlotte Felicitas and Rinaldo D’Este was marked also by an Accademia per musica, performed, according to Fischer,168 on November. The libretto was by Francesco Palmieri, a poet and musician, born at Pisa in , who served Queen Christina of Sweden in Rome, joined the Arcadian Academy in (as Telgone Craneo), was in Hanover in the mid-s, and died in Berlin in .169 The piece was a large-scale dramatic cantata, or serenata, such as frequently was used in this period to celebrate a noble wedding, birthday, or similar occasion. The five characters—Fato, Giunone, Clio, Gloria, and Amore — share fifteen arias, two duets, and a closing ensemble. The music is lost and the composer unknown, but Steffani must be regarded as a candidate. There are further links between the composer and Modena. The only seventeenth-century manuscript of his six solo cantatas with instruments is in the Biblioteca Estense; he probably gave it to Francesco II between and .170 Steffani also presented a scribal copy of music from Le rivali concordi (I-MOe, Mus. G. ), in which he wrote: ‘Pour / Son Altesse / Serenissime / Monseigneur le Duc de Modene’. The word ‘Monseigneur’ indicates that he gave it to Rinaldo when the latter was a cardinal. The gift therefore dates from between September , when Rinaldo became duke, and March , when he gave up holy office: perhaps it should be linked
‒ to his forthcoming marriage, or perhaps Rinaldo had seen Le rivali concordi in or . One copy of the undated [] version of the libretto (I-Mb) bears the date ‘’ in manuscript on the title page, but there is no other evidence that the opera was revived for the wedding celebrations in Hanover or Modena.171 Steffani enjoyed the trust of both courts: in he was asked to accompany Charlotte Felicitas’s sister, Wilhelmine Amalie, to Modena, where she was to marry Joseph of Austria.172 Over twenty years later Steffani wrote with affection of Modena, ‘where I have the good fortune to be known’.173 Only one opera was given at Hanover in carnival , and it is unlikely that Steffani composed it. One manuscript of Briseide attributes the words to Palmieri and the music to Pietro Torri.174 When the libretto was criticized by Mauro, Palmieri turned to Leibniz for support; in his judicious (and helpful) reply, the latter referred to ‘your opera’.175 The attribution of the music is less easily confirmed, but the evidence is compelling. Unlike Steffani’s three-act Hanover operas, Briseide does not survive in his autograph and was not revived in Hamburg. He is unlikely to have been satisfied with a plot that is hard to follow because liaisons des scènes ‘virtually do not exist’,176 or to have composed a score so different from those of his previous Hanover operas: over three-quarters of Briseide’s arias are in da capo form, and seven are based on ostinatos, figures that are exceptional for him. The hand that wrote out the working score of Briseide appears in no other copy of a Hanover opera. This score is not in London, with Steffani’s autographs, but in Munich. When the Bavarian Elector Max Emanuel set up court in Brussels in , he took musicians with him and appointed Torri ‘maître de chapelle’. Steffani was in Brussels in the mid-s and probably recommended Torri as temporary Kapellmeister at Hanover for carnival . Torri was paid thalers, two-thirds of Steffani’s salary as Kapellmeister, and his wife was given four medals.177 For these considerations Torri is more likely to have composed his own opera than to have directed a work by somebody else. Fedeli, Chiaravalle, Borosini, ‘Clementino’, ‘Rosane’, and ‘Diana’ returned to sing Briseide, along with the newcomers ‘Frenelly’, Caterina Taelli, and the female ‘Torafly’.178 Torri himself may have taken the score to Munich when he returned there with the elector in . The last Italian opera at Hanover during Steffani’s period as Kapellmeister was La costanza nelle selve, a ‘favola pastorale’ with music by Luigi Mancia that was performed in the summer of .179 The libretto was versified by Mauro, but ‘it was a lady at court, endowed with singular talent, who selected the subject and laid it out and, to obey the sovereign commands of one who has absolute authority over me, prepared me to have it performed on the stage in nothing other (I can say) than my rhymes’.180 The ‘lady at court’ was Sophie Charlotte, whose mother wrote from Herrenhausen on / August: ‘There is little joy here, for his highness [Ernst August] is not getting better. He has been to Hanover once, to please my daughter, to see her ‘pastorale’, but came back home again weaker, which drove all pleasure away’.181 It seems that the performance took place in July during the visit of Tsar Peter the Great and that the cast included Chiaravalle: on July Sophie Charlotte wrote that she had ‘regaled him [the tsar] with music, to see what face he would make, and he said that he liked it, and especially Ferdinando, whom he is rewarding, like the ‘messieurs’ of the court, with a glass’.182 The cast may also have included Re-
molini and Direnberg, both of whom were paid in Hanover in May .183 Palmieri had been manager of the opera since the previous year and was trying to tie up loose ends: Ernst August had died on January, and the opera house had immediately been closed. That it did not re-open after the statutory year of mourning was due to several factors. Georg Ludwig (Fig. .) did not have the Osnabrück income with which his father had financed the opera. Compared with him, he was more thrifty and less interested in such entertainment. Toland noted that he was ‘not addicted much to any Diversions besides Hunting’,184 and in Elisabeth Charlotte of Orléans described him as ‘so froid that he turns everything to ice’.185 In addition, Georg Ludwig was beset almost immediately by the problem of the Spanish succession and soon after by the Great Northern War. Nevertheless, he continued to celebrate carnival, and the festivities attracted many visitors. Opera was replaced, in a sense, by an increased emphasis on French comedy and on German plays and actors.186 Instrumental music reached a peak of development. Farinel had returned from Osnabrück in and remained until . He and Steffani appear in to have instructed the teenaged Johann Ernst Galliard, from Celle, in composition; Hawkins saw a sonata for oboe and two bassoons with this note in Galliard’s hand: ‘I composed this air at Hanover and played it at Mr Farinelli’s serenade on June ’.187 That year the orchestra was augmented by five new oboists from Berlin, whom Mattheson considered ‘the most excellent band of oboists’.188 It was by visiting Hanover and Brunswick that Telemann became familiar with the styles of Italian opera and French instrumental music and with works by Steffani, Rosenmüller, Corelli, and Caldara that served him as models.189
Envoyé Extraordinaire By the time Georg Ludwig succeeded to the electorate, Steffani had ceased to act as Kapellmeister and had been absent from Hanover for some years on diplomatic service. In he had been appointed Hanoverian ‘envoy extraordinary’ to the Bavarian court in Brussels, and from his responsibilities had been increased by the problem of the Spanish succession, which was becoming complex and urgent. His failure to persuade Maximilian II Emanuel of Bavaria to align himself with the emperor rather than with Louis XIV precipitated a major personal crisis in . Fortunately, during this period he had maintained his interest in music and corresponded with two of his patrons. Thus it was that from the depths of despair he was rescued by immersion in his chamber duets and encouragement from Sophie Charlotte. The raising of Hanover to the Ninth Electorate had not been unopposed.190 Emperor Leopold I had reached his decision without adequate consultation, and his announcement had provoked a hostile reaction from existing electors, who felt that their position would be weakened. Opposition was provoked also by the conditions: Ernst August was to supply , troops to the emperor, vote for the Hapsburg candidate in imperial elections, and help create a tenth electorate for the Austrian house. German electors and princes were encouraged by Louis XIV to resist these demands.
‒
. Georg Ludwig, elector of Hanover and King (George I) of Great Britain: oil painting, after , after Godfrey Kneller (Historisches Museum Hannover; by permission)
They disrupted the Diet, which did not function between and , and continued to resist until , forcing Hanover to cling to the emperor. The most outspoken opponents were Anton Ulrich of Brünswick-Wolfenbüttel, Christian V of Denmark (as duke of Holstein), and Max Emanuel of Bavaria. Objections had to be resolved before the electoral dignity could be conferred. It was to seek an agreement with Max Emanuel that Steffani was sent to Brussels. The elector had moved there as governor of the Spanish Netherlands in and set up court in great splendour. Steffani was ideally equipped for his new role. He had known Max Emanuel as a boy, had served him as director of chamber music, and was acquainted with members of his court. He was given a warm welcome on arrival:
But notwithstanding the fact that I might have left the elector [of Bavaria] most displeased by my unexpected and sudden departure [from Munich], when I was sent to him a few years later in the capacity of envoy extraordinary from the court of Hanover, I was received with such praise and with such honours, in view of all Brabant and then of all Bavaria, that I remained attached to his person for seven years, to June in the year in which he rushed into occupying Ulm on September. 191 Steffani was attached to the court in Brussels until March , then in Munich until summer .192 The phrase ‘seven years’ may relate to his increased responsibilities from mid-, after which date he also spent much time in The Hague; from late to early he evidently paid a diplomatic visit to the court of Lorraine, in Nancy. His name appears regularly in the Hanover treasury accounts for the s— not as Kapellmeister but as envoy to Brussels, not for music but for commissions and dispatches.193 He had a private secretary — Johann Friedrich Holste to October , Franz Justus Barckhausen from August 194 — and he received postal and travel expenses, but he could not afford to rent a flat in Brussels, living instead in what he described as ‘miserable lodgings’.195 Little progress can have been made in negotiations on the electorate before Steffani, Max Emanuel, and most of Europe became embroiled in the matter of the Spanish succession.196 Carlos II was in poor health, had no direct heir, and was not expected to produce one. His death would mark the end of the Spanish Hapsburgs. Spain was the richest and most populous kingdom in Europe, and the succession to the throne was of crucial importance to the balance of power. For most European states, the Spanish succession was the principal concern of foreign policy from about on. Max Emanuel had two reasons for taking a close interest. His wife, Maria Antonia, was the daughter of Margarita Teresa of Spain and niece to Carlos II. Carlos’s father, Philip IV, had willed that, if he died without heir, the inheritance should pass to Margarita Teresa, his younger daughter, and then to her grandson. Her grandson was Joseph Ferdinand, electoral prince of Bavaria and son of Maria Antonia, who had died giving birth to him in . Max Emanuel soon considered remarriage: in Steffani was involved in an unsuccessful attempt to unite him with a daughter of the Palatine Countess Benedikte;197 two years later Max Emanuel took as bride Teresa Kunegunda Sobieska, daughter of King Jan (John) III of Poland. There were two other claimants to the Spanish throne. One was Louis the dauphin of France, the son of Carlos’s older sister Maria Teresa, wife of Louis XIV. The other was Emperor Leopold I, who claimed it as grandson of Philip III. Although each of these candidates was stronger than the infant Joseph Ferdinand, both Louis and the emperor solicited the support of Max Emanuel, who tried to take advantage of their rivalry. He aimed to strengthen his position in the Netherlands and dreamt of a day when the Wittelsbachs might supplant the Hapsburgs as the dominant dynasty in Germany. With this in mind, he inevitably sided with the French, who saw Munich and Vienna as rivals for control of the south of the Empire. In this he was joined by his brother Joseph Clemens, prince-archbishop of Cologne. Bavaria and
‒ Cologne were France’s main allies in the struggle that followed; the emperor’s were the British and the Dutch. The late s was a period of intense diplomatic activity aimed at averting a European war. The first fruit, a partition treaty (), was not acceptable to all parties. Carlos then made a will bequeathing the inheritance to Joseph Ferdinand. When the latter died in , the succession became a straight contest between France and Austria. A second partition treaty () also encountered problems, so Carlos made another will ( October). This time he left the inheritance to the dauphin’s second son, Philip, duke of Anjou, with the proviso that if he or his younger brother declined it, the bequest would pass to Austria. When Carlos died on November, Philip of Anjou became Philip V of Spain. Louis XIV had accepted the will but reserved the right to claim the inheritance if Philip should die without heir. To this end he started to build up his army and flex his military muscles. In early he took control of the Spanish Netherlands: Max Emanuel signed a treaty of alliance with him on March and returned to Munich soon after. The Dutch had recognized Philip in February , and the British did so in April, but they looked to the emperor for a lead in opposing the French. In the summer of Leopold I attacked and defeated French forces in Italy. France hoped for further support from German princes, but their funds were now running low. At the same time the opposition came together in a coalition, formalized in the Treaty of Grand Alliance ( September ). During the winter of – Austria, Britain, and the United Provinces were joined by several German powers, including Brandenburg (in return for the status of a kingdom: Prussia), Hanover, the Palatinate, Münster, Hesse-Kassel, Mainz, and Trier. By May Bavaria and Cologne were the only major German states allied with the French: Saxony was preoccupied with the Great Northern War, and others remained neutral. Steffani’s role in these developments was to try to persuade Max Emanuel to ally himself with the emperor rather than with Louis XIV. In his efforts to bring pressure to bear on the elector he visited a large number of German courts, especially in the Rhineland and the Palatinate. From he corresponded with the Palatine elector, Johann Wilhelm, and between and frequently visited him in Düsseldorf; during the same period he also undertook missions to Cologne and Trier.198 In the autumn of , after Max Emanuel’s return, Steffani was sent to Munich, and in the following nine months he made strenuous efforts — including a visit to Vienna — to persuade the elector to change his allegiance. Although he doubtless was doing his duty as a servant of Hanover, he must also have felt some personal involvement in his increasingly desperate mission. His previous and his present master were about to lock horns, and his personal loyalties must have been severely strained. On May Austria, Britain, and the United Provinces simultaneously declared war on France and her allies. The following month Steffani left Munich for Hanover. During the next ten weeks he travelled tirelessly to Koblenz, Bonn, Düsseldorf, Munich, and Vienna in a last-ditch attempt to force Max Emanuel to change his mind. His efforts were fruitless. On September the elector laid siege to the imperial city of Ulm, tricking it into surrender, and in the same month the emperor declared war on ‘Philip of Anjou’. Max Emanuel may have won his first battle, but he did not
win the war. The turning point was his defeat at the battle of Blenheim (), after which he was sent back to Brussels, the allies recovered Ulm, and the Austrians governed Bavaria until hostilities ceased. The French, and Max Emanuel, suffered further defeats at Ramillies (), Lille (), and Malplaquet (), before signing the Peace of Utrecht () with the British and Dutch. The emperor made peace at Rastatt in , and in the following year Max Emanuel returned to Munich for good. Steffani was devastated by the failure of his mission, which precipitated the most serious personal crisis of his career. He was pained by the terrible fate which, even in , he could see would overtake Max Emanuel, whom he had known for thirty-five years, and he was tormented by a sense that his years of diplomatic activity — his countless journeys, meetings, letters, and discussions — had all been in vain: he had nothing to show for this prodigious expenditure of time and effort. From the depths of disappointment and despair two positive outcomes emerged. He sought consolation in music and he resolved never again to become so deeply embroiled in secular politics: if he wished to pursue a public career — and he had much to offer in such a role—he would do so as a man of the church. During his years as a diplomat Steffani had entered into the social life of Brussels and maintained his interest in music. His closest friend there was Countess Marie-Thérèse of Egmont, by whom he was frequently entertained and with whom he kept in contact after his departure; he and the Hanoverian minister Hans Kaspar von Bothmer spent the evening of / May with her in .199 Two days later they were with the ‘first lady’ of the Low Countries, the countess of Soissons, née Olimpia Mancini, a niece of Mazarin who had been a mistress of Louis XIV.200 In Brussels Steffani could also enjoy and perhaps contribute to the musical life of the Bavarian court. Max Emanuel was accompanied by members of his Munich Kapelle, including Torri; summoned the soprano Clementin Hader; borrowed musicians from Louis XIV in ; and patronized the singer Madame Maupin (who became his mistress), the viol players Hilaire Verloge, Marin Marais, and Antoine Forqueray, the violinist Jean-Jacques-Baptiste Anet, the oboist Jacques Loeillet, and the harpsichordists Louis-Nicolas Clérambault, Jeanne Dandrieu, Elisabeth-Claude Jacquet de la Guerre, and Louis Marchand. He cultivated chamber music and opera. Between and he had nine of Lully’s tragédies lyriques directed by Pietro Andrea Fiocco; some were given a new prologue in honour of the elector, and some of the productions may have been witnessed by Steffani. The latter may have provided, or authorized the provision of, materials for the Hamburg productions ( – ) of his Hanover operas, but he was not involved in the performances. During the s Steffani also corresponded with Max Emanuel’s sister Violanta Beatrice (Fig. .), wife since of Ferdinando De’ Medici. Her letters reveal unbounded admiration for the composer and his music, and they include personal reactions to his style. Her enthusiasm for Servio Tullio and Alarico il Baltha, and her request for some duets and the arias from Marco Aurelio, have already been noted.201 In she thanked him for some ‘ariette francesi’ that he had sent her, which she found to be ‘in the usual good taste with regard both to words and to music’. The ‘ariette’ were presumably by Steffani and in the French style, but the words could have been in Italian: they may have been selected, as we shall see, from his latest opera, Orlando generoso.
‒ In the following year Violanta Beatrice thanked him for sending her further musical works. On June she penned the following intriguing compliment: Signor Abbate, In all the departments of your great genius you express the character of your profound goodness and refined taste, but in these latest pieces of music, sent to me from Rome by Count Bernardi, you have made the light of your talent shine forth much more brightly and judiciously. Thus, having occasion to find them entirely consonant with my spirit, I derive from them a great deal of pleasure, to my complete satisfaction. I am supported in this by the considered opinion and unequivocal applause of those who hear them, and particularly of Casini, who plays them with his great respect and commitment. You should measure the size of the space in your study that you have chosen for the portrait of me, which I will send you in accordance with the same and with your design.
. Violanta Beatrice of Bavaria: oil painting, – , by Georg Desmarees (Residenzmuseum München, Foto Weiss/Mayr [BSV]; by permission of the Bayerische Verwaltung der staatlichen Schlösser, Gärten und Seen)
Giovanni Maria Casini had been first organist at Florence Cathedral since ; he was to become Violanta Beatrice’s chaplain in and her maestro di cappella in . The ‘pieces of music’ could have been vocal, but since Casini was one of the best Italian organists of the period, it is possible that they were for keyboard: indeed, this letter provides the strongest known evidence that Steffani composed keyboard music, now lost. Count Bernardi is also linked to the composer, but not to Violanta Beatrice, in the following year. On May Flavio Lanciani, in Rome, prepared a bill for copying, among other things, some ‘ariettas from Brunswick, given [to me] by Count Bernardi’: ‘Se riveggio’; ‘Due scogli’; ‘La natura’; ‘Solo haurai [Sol havrà da me disprezzi]’; ‘Bambino che [c’hai] l’ali’; ‘Timea, bella Timea’; ‘Piante fiori’; ‘Noue [Notte] amica’; ‘I tuoi danni [vanni]’; ‘Ciò che il Cielo’.202 The anonymous ‘ariette’ occur in the same order in Steffani’s La libertà contenta, which had been premièred at Hanover in February. The majority of the items are arias, but ‘Timea, bella Timea’ is a recitative preceding a duet (‘Il mio cor si strugge e sface’); perhaps the latter was included as well. Since Lanciani was in the service of Cardinal Pietro Ottoboni Jr in , these pieces may have been performed at one of his celebrated concerts. The bill also suggests, retrospectively, that the ‘ariette francesi’ of had been taken from Steffani’s most recent opera. In January Violanta Beatrice had praised him and his music, returned to the question of the portrait — an eloquent token of affection — and thanked him for some ‘other’ duets that cannot be identified: Signor Abbate, I found your musical compositions to be in keeping with your gracious genius that produced them. Nothing but beauty and spirit can spring from your brilliant vein; nothing but richness of ideas and nobility of working-out can be generated by your precious style. When I have returned to Florence from the country of Pisa and Livorno, I will think again about sending you the said portrait. Meanwhile, I commend the thoughtfulness you showed me in [sending] the other duets, of which I shall give you a more precise and particular account in due course. The portrait was mentioned again in her letter of August : having received the measurements of Steffani’s study, she proposed that he hang it in his kitchen, where it might frighten away stray dogs, a humorous suggestion indicative of her easy relationship with the composer. A marvellous letter of January returns to the subject of his musicianship: Signor Abbate, In my thoughts I have been [with you] in the company of the most serene electresses of Brandenburg and Brunswick. . . . Truly, I should gladly have been there in person to share in that harmony which the spheres themselves might envy. You will have allowed your genius to dance at the harpsichord, or in singing or in musical compositions. Most beautiful concert! Incomparable director! I am pleased that in the midst of your more serious and weighty preoccupations you allow to blaze for a moment a lightning flash of your ideas in relation to music, which owes you so much.
‒ For myself, I derive an extraordinary pleasure from this and bless the opportunity of having accustomed my ears to such an agreeable thing. Meanwhile, I thank you for the kind trouble that you have taken for me. Only two further letters from this correspondence are known. On October Violanta Beatrice informed Steffani that she was composing a ‘commedia’203 — whether spoken or sung is not clear — and on July she mentioned some books of music which she was having copied in Florence before returning them to him. This sporadic correspondence coincides with the period when she needed him most — between her departure from Munich and the establishment of her cappella in Florence—and when he was in renewed contact with her brother. It suggests that when Steffani was at the height of his powers as Kapellmeister at Hanover, his arias were sung in Florence and Rome. Her letters evince enormous respect and affection for the composer and his works, and show the kind of intimacy that could exist between a patron and a musician in this period. An even more intimate relationship is revealed in his correspondence with Sophie Charlotte (–; see Fig. .). In the s the electress returned to Hanover to see his operas and began cultivating Italian music in Berlin.204 The mainstays of her establishment were Chiaravalle and Ariosti, the latter from to . Others who worked there for short periods include Pistocchi and Torelli (both – ), Fedeli (), and Giovanni Bononcini ( – ); Corelli dedicated his solo sonatas, op. (), to the electress. Chamber music, vocal and instrumental, was her staple fare, but in she built a small theatre and put on a three-act ‘pastorale eroica’, Il Filindo.205 Seven further stage works were performed in –.206 Seventeen of Sophie Charlotte’s letters to Steffani survive, and five of his to her.207 They are a wonderfully rich source of information. The mutual warmth and affection of the writers leap from every page: her direct, personal prose and large, distinctive hand—no time for punctuation or capitals — reveal an expansive, responsive, even impulsive nature. The letters fall into three broad groups according to date and subject. Her first letter ( February ) was written soon after the death of her father, Ernst August, when she turned to Steffani as a friend. The others in this group furnish approximate dates of composition for five of his duets. On July she thanked him for one that he had sent her and desired to know ‘the beautiful things you are making’.208 Einstein identified this duet as Crudo Amor, morir mi sento, which in a manuscript formerly in the Singakademie, Berlin, was inscribed ‘Per la Elettrice de Brandebourg . . . Poesia di Sua Altezza Serenissima’:209 the words of Crudo Amor were evidently written by Sophie Charlotte herself. A year later, on August , she thanked the composer for three further duets that he had expressly ‘made for me’. It is clear from his letter of November , quoted below, that one of these was Placidissime catene; the other two were undoubtedly Che volete, o crude pene and Inquieto mio cor, copies of which occur consecutively in many manuscripts, some being inscribed ‘Per la Ser.ma Eletrice de Brandenburg’.210 The following year Sophie Charlotte visited Max Emanuel in Brussels in connexion with Brandenburg’s imminent emancipation to a kingdom. In the early s, it should be recalled, Steffani had been involved in negotiations about a possible mar-
. �