This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
4peTar.sistere, contradictioaem veram simul Aristotle, Metaphys. iii. 8, p. 1012, b. 24, esse statuebat, et omnia dicebat esse eoiKe 8' 6 jitey 'Upa/cAeiTou Koyos, X4yu?v vera" (Lassalle, p. 83). irdvTO. dvai Kal /xk tlvai, Smavra a.\7)Bri One of the metaphors by which iroiiiv : Aristot. Topic, viii. 5, p. 155, b., Herakleitus illustrated his theory of olov a7a05p Kal KaKov elyai ravrbv, opposite and co-existent forces, was KaSdirep 'UpdK\eir6s (pvo-tv : also Ari- the pulling and pushing of two sawyers stot. Physic, i. 2, p. 185, b. Compare with the same saw. See BernayB, the various HeraMeitean phrases cited Heraclitea, part i. p. 16; Bonn, 1848. in Pseudo - Origen Eefut. Hasres. * Aristot, Physic, viii. 3, p. 253, b. Fragm. ix. 10 ; also Krische, For- 30, els TOvvdvrwv yap ri aAA<^» v nep\ KVKKOV airavra,. Aristot. ' ' Plutarch, Placit. Phil. ii. 20, p. 890.
CHAP. I.
33
HEEAKLE1TUS.
terms, he expressed in a variety of symbolical and metaphorical phrases, among which Fire stood prominent.2 But though Fire was thus often used to denote the principle or ideal process itself, the same word was also employed to denote that one of the elements which formed the most immediate manifestation of the principle. In this latter sense, Fire was the first stage of incipient reality : the second stage was water, the third earth. This progression, fire, water, earth, was in Herakleitean language " the road downwards," which was the same as " the road upwards," from earth to water and again to fire. The death of fire was its transition into water : that of water was, its transition partly into earth, partly into flame. As fire was the type of extreme mobility, perpetual generation and destruction—so earth was the type of fixed and stationary existence, resisting movement or change as much as possibles Water was intermediate between the two. Herakleitus conceived the sun and stars, not as solid bodies, but as meteoric aggregations perpetually SnnandStaI.s dissipated and perpetually renewed or fed, by ex- j^j-^Jjj? halation upward from the water and earth. The ^J o c na a8 ' sun became extinguished and rekindled in suitable measure and proportion, under the watch of the Erinnyes, the satellites of Justice. These celestial ^"KOXJS lights were contained in troughs, the open side of by flrewhich was turned towards our vision. In case of eclipses the * See a striking passage cited from Gregory of Nyssa by Lassalle (vol. i. p. 287), illustrating this characteristic of fire: the flame of a lamp appears to continue the same, but it is only a succession of flaming particles, each of which takes fire and is extinguished in the same instant:—8><mep rb
a Diogen. Laert. ix. 9 ; Clemens Alexand. Strom, v. 14, p. 599, vi. 2,
p . 624. Xlvpbs rpoTral irpuTov B&Xaffaa, 8aAdTT7is Se rb fikv ^jxtav yrj, -rb 5'
5j/a
VOL. I.
D
34
PRE-SOKRATIC PHILOSOPHY.
CHAP. I.
trough was for the time reversed, so that the dark side was turned towards us; and the different phases of the moon were occasioned by the gradual turning round of the trough in which her light was contained. Of the phenomena of thunder and lightning also, Herakleitus offered some explanation, referring them to aggregations and conflagrations of the clouds, and violent currents of winds.6 Another hypothesis was often ascribed to Herakleitus, and was really embraced by several of the Stoics in later times—that there would come a time when all existing things would be destroyed by fire {eKirupcocni), and afterwards again brought into reality in a fresh series of changes. But this hypothesis appears to have been conceived by him metaphysically rather than physically. Fire was not intended to designate the physical process of combustion, but was a symbolical phrase for the universal process; the perpetual agency of conjoint destruction and renovation, manifesting itself in the putting forth and re-absorption of particulars, and having no other reality except as immanent in these particulars.0 The determinate Kosmos of the present moment is perpetually destroyed, passing into fire or the indeterminate: it is perpetually renovated or passes out of fire into water, earth—out of the indeterminate, into the various determinate modifications. At the same time, though Herakleitus seems to have mainly employed these symbols for the purpose of signifying or typifying a metaphysical conception, yet there was no clear apprehension, even in his own mind, of this generality, apart from all symbols: so that the illustration came to count as a physical fact by itself, and has been so understood by many.d b Aristot. Meteorol. ii. e. p. 355, a. Plato, Republ. vi. p. 498, c. 1 1 ; Plutarch, De Exilio, c. 11, p. 604 A . ; Plutarch, De Isid. et Osirid. c. 48, p. 370, E . ; Diogen. L. ix. 10; Plutarch, Placit. PMos. ii. 17-22-24-28, p. 889-891; Stobfeus, Eclog. Phys. i p. 594. About the doctrine of the Stoics, built in part upon this of Herakleitus, see Cicero, Natur. Deor. ii. 46 ; Seneca, Qusest. Natur. ii. 5, vi. 16. c Aristot. or Pseudo-Aristot. De
Mundo,
e/c •KO.VTWV ev
teal <•£
ivbs
irdvTa. d See Lassalle, Herakleitos, vol. ii. s. 26-27, p. 254-258. Compare about the obscure and debated meaning of the Herakleitean iK-rriputns, Schleiennacher, Herakleitos, p. 10H ; Zeller, Gesch. der Philoa. vol. i. p. 477-479. The word SiaKSfffiriats stands as the antithesis (in the language of Herakleitus) to iKirvpoxns. A passage from Philo Judfflus is cited by Lassalle,
CHAP. I.
HERAKLEITUS.
35
The line between what he meant as the ideal or metaphysical process, and the elementary or physical process, is not easy to draw, in the fragments which now remain. The like blending of metaphysics and physics—of the abstract and notional with the concrete and sen- His doctrines sible—is to be found in the statements remaining K Z from Herakleitus respecting the human soul and n°anknow-u" human knowledge. The human soul, according wisdom re,. ° ° t o h i m , w a s a n effluence o r o u t l y i n g rp o r t i o n of t h e , TT . ll n i v e r s a l 6 — t h e h r e — t h e p e r p e t u a l m o v e m e n t o r
sided in the universal Keason—tadividual
T_P
Reason is
_t* t •
A
life oi things.
i *
As such, its nature was to be ever worthless.
in movement: but it was imprisoned and obstructed by the body, which represented the stationary, the fixed, the particular—that which resisted the universal force of change. So long as a man lived, his soul or mind, though thus confined, participated more or less in the universal movement: but when he died, his body ceased to participate in it, and became therefore vile, " fit only to be cast out like dung." Every man, individually considered, was irrational:f reason belonged only to the universal or the whole, with which the mind of each living man was in conjunction, renewing itself by perpetual absorption, inspiration or inhalation, vaporous transition, impressions through the senses and the pores, &c. During sleep, since all the media of communication, except only those through respiration, were suspended, the mind became stupified and destitute of memory. Like coals when the fire is withdrawn, it lost its heat and tended towards extinction.8 On waking, it recovered itsSymposion, full communication Plutarch, p. 644. ye/ciSes illustrating the Herakleitean movement from ideal unity into totality KOTrpiwv eK^A^T^Tepot. Plutarch, Placit. Philos. i. 23. "Hpdof sensible particulars, forwards and backwards—o Se yovoppo^s (\6yos) in K\eiT05 Tjp€fj.iav Kal (TrdtTip e/c TWV 8\o?y K6
Kal fis
K6
avdyav, hvrtptv !
ecrr! yap TOVTO T£IV vtKpObv.
See Schleiermacher, Herakleitos, reiov 56£ris kratpos, n6pov Kal x p y p. 522 ; Sext. Empir. adv. Mathem. avvt\v, Kal %v rb irav Kal irdvra a/xoifSfj viii. 286. tladyav—where icipos and xp'W"™'"? £ The passage of Sextus Empiricus are used to illustrate the same ideal (adv. Mathem. vii. 126-134) is curious antithesis as SiaK<{
130. T) €Tn\zvoi8ei
Kal (ppevripes—TOVTOV Si] rbv \6yov, Kad' 'HpaK\eirov, Si
D2
Bt?ov j
36
PRE-SOKRATIC PHILOSOPHY.
CHAP. I.
with the great source of intelligence without—the universal all-comprehensive process of life and movement. Still, though this was the one and only source of intelligence open to all waking men, the greater number of men could neither discern it for themselves, nor understand it without difficulty even when pointed out to them. Though awake, they were not less unconscious or forgetful of the process going on around them, than if they had been asleep.h The eyes and ears of men with barbarous or stupid souls, gave them false information.1 They went wrong by following their own individual impression or judgment: they lived as if reason or intelligence belonged to each man individually. But the only way to attain truth was, to abjure all separate reason, and to follow the common or universal reason. Each man's mind must become identified and familiar with that common process which directed and transformed the whole : in so far as he did this, he attained truth: whenever he followed any private or separate judgment of his own, he fell into •k The highest pitch of this severance of the indierror." (TTraaavTes voepol ywiptBa, KOX ii> fi€i> conceived in one and named together iinyois XrjOaioi, Kara 5e zytpffiv irahiv •—the physical inhalation of air—the <E[i
fXOVrjS
T7JS
KCIT& b.VIXTTVO^\V
TFpOS
Tvepiexov, as he conceives it, seems to
ipvazois a(jo^Ofx4vj)s olovel ru>bs plCys, denote, not any distinct or fixed local XWpicr0eiy 5e a7ro/3aA\€i r)v irp6repoif region, but the rotatory movement or e?Xe p-vi]\i.QVi.K.y]v Ivva^xiv iv Se eypr/yo-circulation of the elements, fire, water, p6
simile about coals brought near to, or removed away from, tho fire. The Stoic version of thia Herakleitean doctrine, is to be seen in Marcus Antoninus, viii. 54. MIJK«'TI pivov
—cited from Herakleitus by Aristotle. De Anima, i. 2. h Sextus Empiricus (adv. Math. vii. 132) here cites the first words of the treatise of Herakleitus (compare also hipi, Aristotle, Ehet. iii. 5). \6yov TOSSE
(Tvinrvetv Ttf Trepie'xoVTi a\\' rf$7} Kal (TVfj.(ppove?y TQ TT€- MVTOS d|w€T0! yiyvovTcu Si/flponroi Kal pik%ovTt irdvTa voeptp. O# yhp Trpi(T$(u r) uKovirai Kal aKovaavTts TO $TTOV 7} yoepa Suva/us TTOLI/TTJ K^vrai •wpwTov—roils Se aWovs ai>0pw7rous Kal Sioire<^>oiT7)Ke T$ OTracrai fiov\o^ivif, \av8dvei HKOGU eyepfleVi-es iroiovaiv, tfirep 7} aepci>8r}s T
' Sext. Empiric, ib. vii. 126, a citaThe Stoics, who took up the doc- tion from Herakleitus. k trine of Herakleitus with farther abSext. Emp. ib. vii. 133 (the words straction and analysis, distinguished of Herakleitus) lib 8e? e-Trco-flai Tip and named separately matters which he
37
HERAKLEITUS.
CHAP. I.
vidual judgment was seen during sleep, at which time each man left the common world to retire into a world of his own. By this denunciation of the mischief of private judgment, Herakleitus did not mean to say that a man ought to think like his neighbours or like the public. -M .
i -i.
1
I n Reasonn,VheSa
.
did not mean
his view the public were wrong, collectively as well J
*
the
Reason of
most men as
as individually. The universal reason to which he «is, but as it J
ought to be.
made appeal, was not the reason of most men as it actually is, but that which, in his theory, ought to be their reason:m that which formed the perpetual and governing process throughout all nature, though most men neither recognised nor attended to it, but turned away from it in different directions equally wrong. No man was truly possessed of reason, unless his individual mind understood the general scheme of the universe, and moved in full sympathy with its perpetual movement and alternation or unity of contraries.11 The universal process contained in itself a sum-total of particular contraries which were successively produced and destroyed: to know the universal was appears in the Platonic losophers. £WOV(TLV ol TroKKol OJS ISiav 6Xin one, to know these contraries and toIt recognise them as 0VTes
tp(>6vq(nv'
T] " 8 ' %(TTLV
OVK ItAAo
Tt
Timfeus, c. 20, p. 47 0.
Tb Ktvovfijitvov TI£ Kivovfj.tva) yiyvcoaAA.' e|^77j(7is TOV Tfiirov TTJS TOV irdvros 5toLKTJO'eats' Sib tca.8'
5o7*e0a. 1 Plutarch, De Superstit. c. 3, p. 166, C. See also the passage in Clemens Alexandr. Strom, iv. 22, about the comparison of sleep to death by Herakleitus. m Sextus Empiricus misinterprets the Herakleitean theory when he represents it (vii. 134) as laying down
7} *ye eTriffT^jUT]
jU77Pii€i ws <j>€po/j.4yoLS
TOIS irpdy/xao'iv €7rofj.4vr]s Trjs ^ X ^ s Trjs afctas \6yov, real oi/Te aTroAeiTrofi(vr)s ovre irpodeovaris. A remarkable
passage from the comment of Philoponus (on the treatise of Aristotle De Anima) is cited by Lassalle, ii. p. 330, describing the Herakleitean doctrine,
5iCt TUVTQ 4K T7/S avadv[Ald(TGWS
—Ta Koivi] (paivSfieva, s n a r a , us &F auTTjc eXeyev (Herakleitus) TS>V yap Tip Kotvq <paiv6p.eya \6ytf>, ra 5e tear* irpay/j-aTuv iv Kivr)ff^i ovTav Se7y Kcd iSiav eKaffTiji, xj/euSij. Herakleitus de- TO yivuffKov TO: Trpdy/xaTa 4v Kiv^aei nounces mankind generally as in tivai, tva ffv ij.ira.pdd zov (X.VTO?S avT0?s error. Origen. Philosophum. i. 4 ; i
—also Simplikius ap. Lassalle, p. 341, Diog. Laert. ix. 1. n The analogy and sympathy be- 4v [AZTafioAy yh.p (Ture^er T O OVTO, inrOTLdz/j.el'Os o 'Hpafc\etTO? ; Kal TO tween the individual mind and the cosmical process—between the know- yvoxTojx^VQV aitTa TTJ iiratyy] yivaxTKDV, ing and the known—was reproduced ffvv€TT€
38
PRE-SOKRATIC PHILOSOPHY.
CHAP. I.
transient, but correlative and inseparable, manifestations, each implying the other—not as having each a separate reality and each excluding its contrary.0 In so far as a man's mind maintained its kindred nature and perpetual conjoint movement with the universal, he acquired true knowledge ; but the individualising influences arising from the body usually overpowered this kindred with the universal, and obstructed the continuity of this movement, so that most persons became plunged in error and illusion. The absolute of Herakleitus stands thus at the opposite Herakleitus pole as compared with that of Parmenides: it is s'te'poie'tom" absolute movement, change, generation and destrucparmemdes. ^ ^ — negation of all substance and stability," except as a temporary and unbecoming resistance of each successive particular to the destroying and renewing current of the universal. The Eeal, on this theory, was a generalisation, not of substances, but of facts, events, changes, revolutions, destructions, generations, &c, determined by a law of justice or necessity which endured, and which alone endured, for ever. Herakleitus had many followers, who adopted his doctrine wholly or partially, and who gave to it developments which he had not adverted to, perhaps might not have acknowledged^ It was found an apt theme by those who, 0 Stobseus, Eclog. Phya. p. 5 8 ; " Of absolute rest, Nature gives us and the passage of Philo Judseus, no evidence. All matter, as far as cited by Sclileiermaoher, p. 437; as we can discern, is ever in movement: well as more fully by Lassalle, vol. not merely in masses, as in the planeii. p. 265-267. (Quis rerum divinar. tary spheres, but also molecularly, or hseres, p. 503, Mangey), ev yap TO throughout its intimate structure. e£ aiiipinv TWV evavrioiv, ov Tfj.t]6^vros Thus every alteration of temperature yvwpifj-a Ta ivdvTi
CHAP. I.
EMPEDOKLES.
39
taking a religious or poetical view of the universe, dwelt upon the transitory and contemptible value of particular existences, and extolled the grandeur or power of the universal. It suggested many doubts and debates respecting the foundations of logical evidence, and the distinction of truth from falsehood ; which debates will come to be noticed hereafter, when we deal with the dialectical age of Plato and Aristotle. After Herakleitus, and seemingly at the same time with Parmenides, we arrive at Empedokles (about 500- Empedokies 430 B.C.) and his memorable doctrine of the Four -hisdoctrim the four Elements. This philosopher, a Sicilian of Agri- elements, f°^ gentum, and a distinguished as well as popular- "Sling minded citizen, expounded his views in poems, of forces' which Lucretius" speaks with high admiration, but of which few fragments are preserved. He agreed with Parmenides, and dissented from Herakleitus and the Ionic philosophers, in rejecting all real generation and destruction.3 That which existed had not been generated and could not be destroyed. Empedokles explained what that was, which men mistook for generation and destruction. There existed four distinct elements—Earth, Water, Air, and Fire—eternal, inexhaustible, simple, homogeneous, equal, and co-ordinate with each other. Besides these four substances, there also existed two moving forces, one contrary to the other—Love or Friendship, which brought the elements into conjunction— same subject, would be recognised aa paradoxes merely in appearance, and not in reality, if we had his own explanation. Thus he says (p. 282) " the pure and the corrupt, the drinkable and the undrinkable, are one and the same." Which is explained as follows: " The sea is most pure and most cornipt: to fish, it is drinkable and nutritive; to men, it is undrinkable and destructive." This explanation appears to have been given by Herakleitus himself, 0ciAa
to each predicate, there remains no contradiction at all. r Lucretius, i. 733. " Carmina quinetiam divini pectoris ejus Vociferantur, et exponunt prsclara reperta: Ut vix hmnana videatur stirpe creatus."
|
» Empedokles, Frag. v. 76-83, ed. Karsten. $u
*i5
40
PRE-SOKEATIC PHILOSOPHY.
CHAP. I.
Enmity or Contest, which separated them. Here were alternate and conflicting agencies, either bringing together different portions of the elements to form a new product, or breaking up the product thus formed and separating the constituent elements. Sometimes the Many were combined into One; sometimes the One was decomposed into Many. Generation was simply this combination of elements already existing separately—not the calling into existence of any thing new: destruction was in like manner the dissolution of some compound, not the termination of any existent simple substance. The four simple substances or elements, (which Empedokles sometimes calls by names of the popular Deities—Zeus, Here, Aidoneus, &c), were the roots or foundations of every thing.' From the four elements, — acted upon by these two construction forces, abstractions or mythical personifications,— mos'from03 Empedokles showed how the Kosmos was conmentslnd structed. He supposed both forces to be pertJoTand"0" petually operative, but not always with equal action of love efficacy : sometimes the one was predominant, The Kosmos sometimes the other, sometimes there was equilibrium between them. Things accordingly pass unmade. through a perpetual and ever-renewed cycle. The complete preponderance of Love brings all the elements into close and compact unity, Enmity being for the time eliminated. Presently the action of the latter recommences, and a period ensues in which Love and Enmity are simultaneously operative; until at length Enmity becomes the temporary master, and all union is for the time dissolved. But this condition of things does not last. Love again becomes active, so that partial and increasing combination of the elements is produced, and another period commences—the simultaneous action of the two forces, which ends in renewed empire of Love, compact union of the elements, and temporary exclusion of Enmitv." • Erap. Fr. V. 55.
TeWapct
u Zeller, Gesch. Philos. vol. i 525-528, ed. 2nd.
EMPEDOKLES.
CHAP. I.
41
This is the Empedoklean cycle of things," divine or predestined, without beginning or end: perpetual substitution of new for old compounds,—constancy only in the general principle of combination and disso- ^ lution. The Kosmos which Empedokles undertakes to explain, takes its commencement from the period of complete empire of Love, or compact and undisturbed union of all the elements. This he conceives and divinises under the name of and°meteoroSphserus—as One sphere, harmonious, uniform, logy' and universal, having no motion, admitting no parts or separate existences within it, exhibiting no one of the four elements distinctly, " instabilis tellus, innabilis unda"—a sort of chaos/ At the time prescribed by Fate or Necessity, the action of Enmity recommenced, penetrating gradually through the interior of Sphserus, " agitating the members of the God one after another,"z disjoining the parts from each other, and distending the compact ball into a vast porous Emp. Frag. v. 91, Karst.
%v ^]v anavTa. &s (priffiv, (Empedokles).
<£uecr#a TT6.\LV
epos n\dov'
or, ijj jutec yiyvovrat
re KaX ov crtftiaiv e/nr
7J 6e TaS' aXX Krjyei, Tavrri $' aih> Hatriv aKivrjra Kara KVK\OV. KOX yap (cat mzpos qv T€ Kal e
TOUTWP ajLt^oTe'pwj' (Love and Discord) KeivuKTtTal airireTOS axutv.
These are new Empedoklean verses, derived from the recently published fragments of Hippolytus (Hser. Eefut.) and printed by Stein, v. 110, in his collection of the Fragments of Empedokles, p. 43. Compare another passage in the same treatise of Hippolytus, p. 251. y Emped. Fr. v. 59. OIJTW? apfj-ovtrj^ TTVKLVW Kpv$ ea-njptKTat trtpalpos KVKAoTe'pijs, fxoviy TT£piyriOe'C yaiuv.
Plutarch, De Facie in Orbe Lunte, e. 12. About the divinity ascribed by Empedokles to Sphserus, see Aristot. Metaphys. B. 4, p. 1000, a. 29. •ycfcp €/c TO6TOU
(^petKOus) T^A
VXT)V i 8eos (i.e. Sphserus). fi.7] ^\v TO ve^Kos Iv rois
Ei yap
irpdyfj.acFL, %v
See Preller, Hist. Philos. ex Fontibus Contexta, sect. 171, 172, ed. 3. The condition of things which Empedokles calls Sphserus may be illustrated (translating his Love and Enmity into the modern phraseology of attraction and repulsion) from an eminent modern work on Physics :—• " Were there only atoms and attraction, as now explained, the whole material of creation would rush into close contact, and the universe would be one huge solid mass of stillness and death. There is heat or caloric, however, which directly counteracts attraction, and singularly modifies the results. It has been described by some as a most subtile fluid pervading all things as water does a sponge : others have accounted it merely a vibration among the atoms. The truth is, that we know little more of heat as a cause of repulsion, than of gravity as a cause of attraction: but we can study and classify the phenomena of both most accurately." (Dr. Arnott, Elements of Physics, vol. i. p. 26.) 2 Emp. Fr. 60-70, Karst. yvia fooio
42
PEE-SOKRATIC PHILOSOIHY.
CHAP. I.
mass. This mass, under the simultaneous and conflicting influences of Love and Enmity, became distributed partly into homogeneous portions where each of the four elements was accumulated by itself—partly into compounds or individual substances, where two or more elements were found in conjunction. Like had an appetite for Like—Air for Air, Fire for Fire, and so forth: and a farther extension of this appetite brought about the mixture of different elements in harmonious compounds. First, the Air disengaged itself, and occupied a position surrounding the central mass of Earth and Water: next, the Fire also broke forth, and placed itself externally to the air, immediately in contact with the outermost crystalline sphere, formed of condensed and frozen air, which formed the wall encompassing the Kosmos. A remnant of Fire and Air still remained embodied in the Earth, but the great mass of both so distributed themselves, that the former occupied most part of one hemisphere, the latter most part of the other.a The rapid and uniform rotation of the Kosmos, caused by the exterior Fire, compressed the interior elements, squeezed the water out of the earth like perspiration from the living body, and thus formed the sea. The same rotation caused the earth to remain unmoved, by counterbalancing and resisting its downward pressure or gravity.6 In the course of the rotation, the light hemisphere of Fire, and the comparatively dark hemisphere of Air, alternately came above the horizon: hence the interchange of day and night. Empedokles (like the Pythagoreans) supposed the Sun to be not self-luminous, but to be a glassy or crystalline body which collected and reflected the light from the hemisphere of Fire. He regarded the fixed stars as fastened to the exterior crystalline sphere, and revolving along with it, but the planets as moving free and detached from any sphere.0 He supposed the alternations of winter and summer to arise from a change in the proportions 1 Plutarch ap. Euseb. Prfep. Evang. j De Ccelo, ii. 13, 14; iii. 2, 2. T V yriv i. 8,10; Plutarch, Placit. Philos. ii. 6, b*h TTJS SIVIJS Ttp^itv, &0. Empedokles p. 887 ; Aristot. Etlric. Xic. viii. 2. called the sea ISpara TSJJ yr/s. Emp >> Emped. Fr. 185, Karsten. aiefy Fr. 451, Karsten ; Aristot. Meteor, ii. 3! a
CHAP. I.
43
EMPEDOKLES.
of Air and Fire in the atmospheric regions: winter was caused by an increase of the Air, both in volume and density, so as to drive back the exterior Fire to a greater distance from the Earth, and thus to produce a diminution of heat and light: summer was restored when the Fire, in its turn increasing, extruded a portion of the Air, approached nearer to the Earth, and imparted to the latter more heat and light.4 Empedokles farther supposed (and his contemporaries, Anaxagoras and Diogenes, held the same opinion) that the Earth was round and flat at top and bottom, like a drum or tambourine: that its surface had been originally horizontal, in reference to the rotation of the Kosmos around it, but that it had afterwards tilted down to the south and upward towards the north, so as to lie aslant instead of horizontal. Hence he explained the fact that the north pole of the heavens now appeared obliquely elevated above the horizon.e From astronomy and meteorology Empedoklesf proceeded to describe the Earth, its tenants, and its furniture ; Formation of
how men were nrst produced, and how put together, the Earth, of x
i.
o
Gods, men,
All were produced by the Earth: being thrown animals, and up under the stimulus of Fire still remaining within it. In its earliest manifestations, and before the influence of Discord had been sufficiently neutralized, the Earth gave birth to plants only, being as yet incompetent to produce animals.8 After a certain time she gradually acquired power to produce animals, first imperfectly and piecemeal, trunks without limbsyeyparpadv and limbs without e | apx?)s o, Tt trunks; ztrriv tUvi Zeller, Gesch. Phil. i. p. 532-535, 2nd ed. : Karsten—De Emped. Philos. p. 424-431. The very imperfect notices which remain, of the astronomical and meteorological doctrines of Empedokles, are collected and explained by these two authors. ' Plutarch, Placit. Philos. ii. 8 ; Schaubach, Anaxag. Pragm. p. 175; Compare the remarks of Gruppe (Ueber die Kosmischen Systeme der Griechen, p. 98) upon the obscure Welt-Gebaude of Empedokles. 1 Hippokrates—Tlepl apxains l-nrpmrjs —c. 20, p. 620, v. i. ed. Littre. Kadiirep fl &K\oi ol irepi rpvoios
dpwiroSy Kal (Jirws iyevero
"npSyrov, Kal
'6ITUS £vveirdyTi.
This is one of the most ancient allusions to Empedokles, recently printed by M. Littre, out of one of the MBS. in the Parisian library. s Emp. Er. v. 253, Kar. robs fj.lv irvp a.v€Tr€[J.Tr' edekov
&c. Aristot.,
or
irpbs
e
6fj.oiov
Pseudo - Aristot.
itctirQai,
De
Plantis, i. 2. dire ir&Xtv b 'Efj.T^SoKkrjs, Hrt TCL (pVTa %Xov(fl ytVtGlV 4f K6(f[A.Cp ^Karrw^vcff Kal ov reAeioi Karh T^V v avTOv' ravrrts 5e trvfj.-
p i ,
(while it is in course of
being completed) ov yevvarai £woi>.
44
PEE-SOKEATIC PHILOSOPHY.
CHAP. I.
next, discordant and monstrous combinations which did not last, such as creatures half man half ox; lastly, combinations with parts suited to each other, organizations perfect and durable, men, horses, &c, which continued and propagated.11 Among these productions were not only plants, birds,fishes,and men, but also the "long-lived Gods."' All compounds were formed by intermixture of the four elements, in different proportions, more or less harmonious.* These elements remained unchanged: no one of them was transformed into another. But the small particles of each flowed into the pores of the others, and the combination was more or less intimate, according as the structure of these pores was more or less adapted to receive them. So intimate did the mixture of these fine particles become, when the effluvia of one and the pores of another were in symmetry, that the constituent ingredients, like colours compounded together by the painter,™ could not be discerned or handled separately. Empedokles rarely assigned any specific ratio in which he supposed the four elements to enter into each distinct compound, except in the case of flesh and blood, which were formed of all the four in equal portions; and of bones, which he affirmed to be composed of one-fourth earth, one-fourth water, and the other half fire. He insisted merely on the general fact of » Emp. Frag. v. 132, 150, 233, 240, Galen, Comm. in Hippokrat. De ed. Karst. Homin. Nat. t. iii. p. 101. See Karsten, De Emped. Phil. p. 407, and JTOA^OL /ley aft$i7rpo(T(ijjra (cat ajxfyitTTepv' kyevovTO, Emp. Fr. v. 15.1). /3ouyec7J avSpoTrpojpa, &c. Galen says, however (after Aristot. OuAo^ueis fief Trpvyra. TVJTOt \f)ovQS c£av Gen. et Corr. ii. 7, p. 334, a. 30), that e'reAAoc, &c. this mixture, set forth by Empedokles, Lucretius, v. 834; Aristotel. Gen. is not mixture properly speaking, but Animal, i. 18, p. 722, b. 20 ; Physic, ii. merely close proximity. Hippokrates 8, 2, p. 198, b. 32 ; De Ccelo, iii. 2, 5, p. (he says) was the first who propounded 300, b. 29; with the commentary of the doctrine of real mixture. But Sirnplikius ap. Schol. Brand, b. 512. Empedokles seems to have intended • Emp. Fr. v. 135, Kar. a real mixture, in all cases where the k Plato, Menon. p. 76 A . ; Aristot. structure of the pores was in symGen. et Corr. i. 8, p. 324, b. 30 eeq. metry with the inflowing particles. ' E/ 5 { aperafih.-fiTuii' fif rwv Oil and water (he said) would not mix TCTrdpcw <noi~)(z!iGiV riyetro yiyveaQaitogether, because there was no such T^JU TKV avvBiriav (rcofidrcov
tSias icpacreis (Theophrastus, De Sensu
CHAP. T.
EMPEDOKLES.
45
such combinations, as explaining what passed for generation of new substances—without pointing out any reason to determine one ratio of combination rather than another, and without ascribing to each compound a distinct ratio of its own.