PHILOSOPHY AND ORGANIZATION THEORY
RESEARCH IN THE SOCIOLOGY OF ORGANIZATIONS Series Editor: Michael Lounsbury Recent Volumes: Volume 15: Volume 16:
Deviance in and of Organizations Networks in and around Organizations
Volume 17:
Organizational Politics
Volume 18: Volume 19:
Social Capital of Organizations Social Structure and Organizations Revisited
Volume 20:
The Governance of Relations in Markets and Organizations Postmodernism and Management: Pros, Cons and the Alternative
Volume 21: Volume 22: Volume 23:
Legitimacy Processes in Organizations Transformation in Cultural Industries
Volume 24: Volume 25:
Professional Service Firms The Sociology of Entrepreneurship
Volume 26:
Studying Difference between Organizations: Comparative Approaches to Organizational Research
Volume 27: Volume 28:
Institutions and Ideology Stanford’s Organization Theory Renaissance, 1970–2000
Volume 29:
Technology and Organization: Essays in Honour of Joan Woodward
Volume 30A:
Markets on Trial: The Economic Sociology of the U.S. Financial Crisis: Part A
Volume 30B:
Markets on Trial: The Economic Sociology of the U.S. Financial Crisis: Part B
Volume 31:
Categories in Markets: Origins and Evolution
RESEARCH IN THE SOCIOLOGY OF ORGANIZATIONS VOLUME 32
PHILOSOPHY AND ORGANIZATION THEORY EDITED BY
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS University of Cyprus, Cyprus & Warwick Business School, University of Warwick, UK
ROBERT CHIA University of Strathclyde Business School, Glasgow, UK
United Kingdom – North America – Japan India – Malaysia – China
Emerald Group Publishing Limited Howard House, Wagon Lane, Bingley BD16 1WA, UK First edition 2011 Copyright r 2011 Emerald Group Publishing Limited Reprints and permission service Contact:
[email protected] No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without either the prior written permission of the publisher or a licence permitting restricted copying issued in the UK by The Copyright Licensing Agency and in the USA by The Copyright Clearance Center. No responsibility is accepted for the accuracy of information contained in the text, illustrations or advertisements. The opinions expressed in these chapters are not necessarily those of the Editor or the publisher. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN: 978-0-85724-595-3 ISSN: 0733-558X (Series)
Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Howard House, Environmental Management System has been certified by ISOQAR to ISO 14001:2004 standards Awarded in recognition of Emerald’s production department’s adherence to quality systems and processes when preparing scholarly journals for print
CONTENTS LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
vii
ADVISORY BOARD
ix
INTRODUCTION: WHY PHILOSOPHY MATTERS TO ORGANIZATION THEORY Haridimos Tsoukas and Robert Chia
1
ANALYTIC PHILOSOPHY AND ORGANIZATION THEORY: PHILOSOPHICAL PROBLEMS AND SCIENTIFIC SOLUTIONS Gabriele Lakomski and Colin W. Evers
23
PRAGMATISM: A LIVED AND LIVING PHILOSOPHY. WHAT CAN IT OFFER TO CONTEMPORARY ORGANIZATION THEORY? Bente Elkjaer and Barbara Simpson
55
MACINTYRE, NEO-ARISTOTELIANISM AND ORGANIZATION THEORY Ron Beadle and Geoff Moore
85
MARXIST PHILOSOPHY AND ORGANIZATION STUDIES: MARXIST CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE UNDERSTANDING OF SOME IMPORTANT ORGANIZATIONAL FORMS Paul S. Adler
v
123
vi
CONTENTS
BEYOND UNIVERSALISM AND RELATIVISM: HABERMAS’S CONTRIBUTION TO DISCOURSE ETHICS AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR INTERCULTURAL ETHICS AND ORGANIZATION THEORY Andreas Georg Scherer and Moritz Patzer HERMENEUTIC PHILOSOPHY AND ORGANIZATIONAL THEORY Frank J. Barrett, Edward H. Powley and Barnett Pearce
155
181
PHENOMENOLOGY AND ORGANIZATION THEORY Robin Holt and Jo¨rgen Sandberg
215
ORGANIZING DERRIDA ORGANIZING: DECONSTRUCTION AND ORGANIZATION THEORY Andreas Rasche
251
THINKING BECOMING AND EMERGENCE: PROCESS PHILOSOPHY AND ORGANIZATION STUDIES Ajit Nayak and Robert Chia
281
THEORY AS THERAPY: WITTGENSTEINIAN REMINDERS FOR REFLECTIVE THEORIZING IN ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT THEORY John Shotter and Haridimos Tsoukas
311
TRIANGULATING PHILOSOPHIES OF SCIENCE TO UNDERSTAND COMPLEX ORGANIZATIONAL AND MANAGERIAL PROBLEMS John Bechara and Andrew H. Van de Ven
343
RICHARD RORTY, WOMEN, AND THE NEW PRAGMATISM Barbara Czarniawska
365
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS Paul S. Adler
Department of Management and Organization, Marshall School of Business, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, USA
Frank J. Barrett
Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, CA, USA
Ron Beadle
Newcastle Business School, Northumbria University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
John Bechara
Carlson School of Management, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA
Robert Chia
Department of Management, Strathclyde Business School, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, UK
Barbara Czarniawska
GRI, School of Business, Economics and Law, The University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden
Bente Elkjaer
School of Education, University of Aarhus, Copenhagen, Denmark
Colin W. Evers
University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia
Robin Holt
University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK
Gabriele Lakomski
University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia
Geoff Moore
Durham Business School, Durham University, Durham, UK
Ajit Nayak
University of Exeter Business School, Exeter, UK vii
viii
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Moritz Patzer
Institute of Organization and Administrative Science (IOU), University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
Barnett Pearce
Fielding Graduate University, Santa Barbara, CA, USA
Edward H. Powley
Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, CA, USA
Andreas Rasche
Warwick Business School, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK
Jo¨rgen Sandberg
University of Queensland, Queensland, Australia
Andreas Georg Scherer
Institute of Organization and Administrative Science (IOU), University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
John Shotter
KCC Foundation, London, UK
Barbara Simpson
Department of Management, University of Strathclyde Business School, Glasgow, UK
Haridimos Tsoukas
University of Cyprus, Cyprus; and Warwick Business School, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK
Andrew H. Van de Ven Carlson School of Management, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA
ADVISORY BOARD SERIES EDITOR Michael Lounsbury Alex Hamilton Professor of Business, University of Alberta School of Business, and National Institute for Nanotechnology, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
ADVISORY BOARD Howard E. Aldrich University of North Carolina, USA
Paul M. Hirsch Northwestern University, USA
Stephen R. Barley Stanford University, USA
Renate Meyer Vienna University of Economics and Business Administration, Austria
Nicole Biggart University of California at Davis, USA Elisabeth S. Clemens University of Chicago, USA
Mark Mizruchi University of Michigan, USA Walter W. Powell Stanford University, USA
Barbara Czarniawska Go¨teborg University, Sweden Gerald F. Davis University of Michigan, USA
Hayagreeva Rao Stanford University, USA Kerstin Sahlin-Andersson Uppsala University, Sweden
Marie-Laure Djelic ESSEC Business School, France Frank R. Dobbin Harvard University, USA
W. Richard Scott Stanford University, USA Robin Stryker University of Minnesota, USA
Royston Greenwood University of Alberta, Canada Mauro Guillen The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, USA
Haridimos Tsoukas University of Cyprus, Cyprus and University of Warwick, UK Richard Whitley University of Manchester, UK ix
INTRODUCTION: WHY PHILOSOPHY MATTERS TO ORGANIZATION THEORY Haridimos Tsoukas and Robert Chia The intellectual life of man consists almost wholly in his substitution of a conceptual order for the perceptual order in which his experience originally comes. (James, 1911/ 1996, p. 51) Philosophy is the self-correction by consciousness of its own initial excess of subjectivity y The task of philosophy is to recover the totality obscured by the selection. (Whitehead, 1929, p. 20)
The relentless demand for a better understanding of the world around us and the justification of appropriate human action has been a major motivational impulse in the growth and evolution of modern societies. The need to know what human life is about, what reality is made of and how we should live a rich and fulfilling life has been an abiding preoccupation since the dim and distant dawn of human civilization. One noticeable inexorable trend in this civilizing process has been the gradual shift from an overwhelming reliance on brute force to the cultivation of reasoned curiosity and the consequent development of knowledge as a means of meeting basic survival needs and attaining collectively desired ends. It may be that, as Aristotle famously remarked, human beings have the innate desire to know; however, the particular forms of knowledge generated have varied over time.
Philosophy and Organization Theory Research in the Sociology of Organizations, Volume 32, 1–21 Copyright r 2011 by Emerald Group Publishing Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 0733-558X/doi:10.1108/S0733-558X(2011)0000032003
1
2
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS AND ROBERT CHIA
The form and conception of knowledge we presently rely on to justify our actions has not always been what it is. It, too, has undergone substantial evolution and transformation over the centuries. Michel Foucault (1970), in The Order of Things, notes that each historical epoch brings with it a different conception of what it means to know and that this is itself grounded on the epoch’s experience of order. Thus, Renaissance thought, for instance, relied heavily on the idea of an unending spiral of linked resemblances in both the material and symbolic worlds as its basis for knowledge. Proximity, convenience, analogy and emulation provided the organizing code for the creation of knowledge during this period, so much so that the walnut, which resembles the human brain, was believed to cure wounds of the pericranium. Similarly, signs observed in nature and human signs were believed to be inextricably intertwined so that there was nothing bizarre, for instance, about Paracelsus’s claim that snakes may be repelled by chanting certain Greek words (Foucault, 1970, pp. 27–33). This Renaissance conception of knowledge as deriving from observation of similarities and resemblances, however, was replaced by a Modern consciousness involving the breaking up and analysis of representations and the establishment of causal relations through the principles of identity and difference. Naming, representing, classifying and the establishment of causal relations became the key activities of a knowing mind. Knowledge took on an air of certainty so much so that it became vital to demonstrate the universality and irrefutability of their truth claims; proof was now needed. With this need for proof and justification came the demand for theoretical conjectures that adhered closely to the principles of objective observation, logical rigor in analysis, and transparency and accuracy in representation. Theories came to be recognized as empirically verifiable and intellectually justifiable claims regarding the nature of reality. As Modern consciousness gradually took roots, developed and yielded results, such theoretical representations became no longer unquestioned, selfjustifying starting points (Foucault, 1970, pp. 238–239). Quite the contrary. The Cartesian doubt was eventually turned to the cognizing subject too. What defines the late Modern episteme, in particular, is not the security of a single authoritative representation of things but a confusing proliferation of competing accounts (Foucault, 1970, p. 346); interpretation is now needed. The late Modern episteme ushered in a heightened awareness of a certain historical consciousness and a realization of importance and limitations of perspective in the apprehension of things. Our knowledge is now acknowledged to be incomplete and partial; we recognize an inevitable ‘owing’ in our ‘kn-owing’.
Introduction: Why Philosophy Matters to Organization Theory
3
Conceptual knowledge is ‘forever inadequate to the fullness of reality to be known’ (James, 1911/1996, p. 78). Our concepts are secondary formations ‘inadequate and only ministerial y they falsify as well as omit’ (James, 1911/ 1996, p. 79). What we do in the act of theorizing is to ‘harness up reality in our conceptual scheme in order to drive it better’ (James, 1909/1996, p. 248). This power of framing abstract concepts from the flux and flow of lived experiences is one of our most sublime human prerogatives in that our intellectual journeys into these abstractions enable us to return to the concrete with ‘an increase both of vision and power’ (James, 1909/1996, p. 217), provided that we do not ever forget that these theories and concepts are ‘manmade extracts from the temporal flux’ and allowed to become a ‘tyranny that defeats the end’ it was intended to serve (James, 1909/1996, pp. 218–219). It is this late modernist equation of theory with a partial perspective or ‘viewpoint’ that dominates our contemporary intellectual consciousness and that, thus, accounts for the proliferation of competing perspectives in the social sciences in general and in organization theory (OT) in particular. The etymology of theory is revealing. As Toulmin (1982, p. 239) notes, the word theoros in classical Greece was mainly used to indicate the official delegate who was dispatched from the city-state to attend intercity athletic Games, especially the Olympic Games. He was not meant to take part in those games, only to observe them. Gradually theoros was used to refer to any spectator at the Games, official or unofficial, in contrast with a participant. Eventually, the abstract noun theoria acquired the meaning of spectating, in contrast to participating. With Aristotle, theoria came to refer to the philosopher’s detached intellectual inquiry as opposed to the praxis of the ‘man on the street’ – the carpenter, the farmer, the trader (Toulmin, 1982, p. 239). Theoretical conjectures are in effect ‘organized’ collections of propositional statements making claims regarding the phenomenon under investigation that renders them plausible and logically coherent to a community of inquirers. The impetus for a specific configuration of such propositional statements into a coherent whole derives from deeper, and frequently unexamined, metaphysical presuppositions regarding the nature of reality, our relation to it and the nature of knowledge thus produced. As philosopher of science Harre (1985, p. 16) notes, ‘we have to choose some concepts with which to think about the world, and this amounts to devising or learning a language, and accepting a system of picturing and conceiving the structure of the world’. The world causes us to have beliefs but does not dictate the content of our beliefs (Rorty, 1989, p. 6). It is our ‘system of picturing’ of the world that guides the questions we raise and the explanatory forms we deem plausible.
4
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS AND ROBERT CHIA
In this way, the study of organization is inextricably dependent on the prior organization of mentalities and modes of thought. For some time now, it has been recognized that, especially in the human sciences, there can be no unbiased conceptualizing of human experiences without our implicit reliance on both an existing ‘observational order’ in terms of the types of things we do in fact discriminate and a dominant ‘conceptual order’ in terms of which we do interpret (Whitehead, 1933, p. 183). For Whitehead, observational discrimination ‘is not dictated by the impartial facts. It selects and it discards and what it retains is rearranged in a subjective order of prominence’. It is therefore a key task of human inquiry to urge observation and conceptualizing beyond the boundaries of their ‘delusive completeness’ (Whitehead, 1933, p. 184): a task that necessitates not in asking if a theory is true or false, but in ‘noting its scope of useful application and its failure beyond that scope’ (Whitehead, 1933, p. 257). Theories are tools for interrogating reality and for deriving their practical imports. They are not irrefutable truth claims. As such, it becomes incumbent on scholars of all stripes and persuasion to open themselves to the possibility of alternative, plausible theoretical viewpoints and to engage in a robust critical consideration of the competing perspectives on offer in their own specific field of study. Yet, there is much evidence to suggest that this intellectual openness does not always characterize the world of academia, as particular types of knowledge become accepted as legitimate and are institutionalized. Academic institutions, after all, function as all institutions do: they provide closure to meaning, privileging particular ways of observing, thinking and arguing, and build particular reward systems around them. In that respect, it is only too easy to be seduced by a favourite theory and to dogmatically cling on to that which we are familiar and comfortable with. This is a condition that William James was at pains to warn us of. He notes that a misunderstanding of the status of theories and concepts often led to the denial of the very properties that sensibly presented themselves to us, which the theories were intended to capture, because we remain overly enamoured by the elegance and apparent completeness of the theory itself (James, 1909/1996, pp. 218–219). This tendency to cling on to our own preferred views and to dismiss theories that do not conform to our own operating premises and hence to avoid sustained critical questioning of our own assumptions is widespread in the human sciences. Indeed, it has, at times, led to blatant ridiculing or offhand dismissal by the academic doyens of the establishment. One example of the hostility to provocative plausible accounts that comes
Introduction: Why Philosophy Matters to Organization Theory
5
to mind was the intense reaction to the controversial work of the political philosopher Bloom (1987) in The Closing of the American Mind, when he forcefully argued that modern higher education, in particular, has essentially failed democracy and impoverished the souls of its students. For Bloom the unthinking promulgation of an uncritical relativism has threatened to overwhelm Western democracies and to paradoxically propagate an ‘openness to closedness’ through its refusal to countenance the provision of an intellectual space for the airing of deeply entrenched prejudices. It is in fact an openness that denies the special claim of reason, an openness of ‘indifference’ that obscures awareness of a deeper, more abiding level of ignorance. He points out that, while it took a lifetime of unceasing intellectual labour for Socrates to come to the realization that he was ignorant, ‘Now every high school student knows that. How did it become so easy?’ (Bloom, 1987, pp. 40–43). Ignorance is now no longer construed as an acute and abiding awareness of the existence of a background ‘unthought’ that circumscribes the thinkable, but a mere ‘gap’ in our knowledge. Socrates, on the other hand, was acutely aware of what he did not know and hence always open to the possibility of otherness. Literary critic Johnson echoed this deeper insight on the importance of the ‘unthought’ when she wrote most passionately: ‘Ignorance, far more than knowledge, is what can never be taken for granted. If I perceive my ignorance as a gap in knowledge instead of an imperative that changes the very nature of what I think I know, then I do not truly experience my ignorance’ (1989, p. 16). In other words, it is only when we become painfully aware that it is ignorance of our ignorance, and not simply a gap in knowledge that prevents deep insights into the human condition, we begin to glimpse that illusive realm of complex thinking that characterizes Socratic ignorance. To heighten our awareness of this ignorance of ignorance, Bloom argues forcefully for a return to the Socratic style of learning in which the persistent questioning of conventional wisdom in pursuit of deeper insights becomes a dominant feature of academic life. Bloom cites de Tocqueville as showing that the greatest democratic danger is not so much the threat of novel radical perspectives but ‘enslavement to public opinion’ because of a refusal to openly engage with subjectivities and prejudices. There is, as the German philosopher Hans George Gadamer remarked, an enduring modern intolerance or ‘prejudice against prejudice’. Prejudice and subjectivity are inevitably infused into our understanding and comprehension of life and, as Whitehead points out, it is precisely the task of
6
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS AND ROBERT CHIA
philosophical inquiry to engage in the relentless self-correcting of our own initial ‘excess of subjectivity’. In other words, it is only by allowing the airing of our deeply entrenched subjective prejudices and critically engaging with them that we can then begin to ‘recover the totality obscured by the selection’ (Whitehead, 1929, p. 20). True insight and understanding are only achieved not by avoiding contrary or vastly alien viewpoints, but by confronting them through careful scrutiny for internal paradigmatic coherence and exploring their consequent implications for the world of practical affairs. This is the true task of philosophical inquiry and a task that sets the parameters for this volume. The need for creating a deeper awareness of the ‘unconscious metaphysics’ underpinning our theorizing efforts is particularly acute in OT. Our awareness that such philosophical presuppositions invariably underpin OT was irreversibly heightened more than 30 years ago by the seminal contribution of Burrell and Morgan (1979), in their influential Sociological Paradigms and Organizational Analysis. Burrell and Morgan undertook a significant effort at uncovering the underlying theoretical underpinnings of various competing perspectives on the nature of organizational functioning. According to them, all theories of organization are based on an underlying philosophy and an implicit theory of society so that, as social scientists, organization theorists inevitably make implicit ontological assumptions regarding the nature of reality they are investigating, epistemological assumptions about how we can know with some degree of certainty about that reality and assumptions about whether the social world being investigated is ultimately orderly/regulated or conflictful/changeful in nature. From the resultant set of competing assumptions, Burrell and Morgan developed their typology, consisting of four alternative paradigms for organizational analysis: functionalism, interpretivism, radical structuralism and radical humanism. Burrell and Morgan’s efforts have led the way towards meta-theorizing in OT and to the crucial realization that theories of organization are themselves legitimate objects of analysis in our efforts to understand the phenomenon of organization. As Tsoukas and Knudsen (2003) remarked, when we raise meta-theoretical questions, we begin our journey towards greater reflexive awareness. We begin to realize that our culture, our race, our ideology, our gender, our class, our language and our authority structures (and we might add, our epoch) dramatically affect the validity of our knowledge claims. Exposure to alternative accounts of organizational functioning forces us to reflect on the partiality and inevitable incompleteness of our knowledge claims. They sensitize us to
Introduction: Why Philosophy Matters to Organization Theory
7
the possibility of a realm of tacit knowing and practical understanding that resists logic, linguistic formulation and theoretical explication. If philosophy helps make us self-aware of critical assumptions we tacitly incorporate in our organizational theorizing, how does it happen? What types of philosophical inquiry are conducive to our refining our research practice as organization theorists? There are three ways in which philosophical reflection may find its way to organizational research: ontological, epistemological and praxeological (Tsoukas, 2005, p. 5; Tsoukas & Knudsen, 2005, p. 363). We examine each one as follows: 1. Ontology: Every scientific discipline takes for granted certain key categories, which define the nature of its subject matter and frame its inquiries. The critical questions here are: ‘What are the phenomena we investigate made of? What are their salient properties?’ Or to put it more philosophically, ‘What is the Being of the entities that constitute the object of inquiry?’ (Guignon, 1983, p. 64). Without a tacit understanding of foundational categories that are thought to be constitutive of the salient properties of the object of study, the practice of conducting scientific research cannot even begin. The theoretical frameworks organization theorists develop reflect deep ontological commitments about the nature of reality. By ontologically carving up the world in particular ways, researchers bring out the constitutive elements of the phenomena they explore. Important advances in the social sciences at large, and in OT in particular, come from making fresh ontological distinctions that enable social scientists to approach a particular phenomenon in a new light and, accordingly, design new research programmes. There are numerous such examples in OT. We examine a few below. One of the most important ontological distinctions made in OT is Weick’s (1979, 1995) redirecting of attention from organizations to organizing. Focusing on organizing, Weick has argued that organizations are not readymade entities with predefined properties waiting to be discovered by the researcher, as, for example, the famous Aston studies had assumed (Pugh, 1981), but systems of interaction that become organized. What we label and experience as ‘organizations’ (notice the quotes) are products of human action. Researchers’ task, therefore, is to explain how organization (notice the singular) emerges, to investigate the processes through which collections of individuals are transformed into organized entities and ascribed a singular identity. Accordingly, if ‘organization’ is an emergent phenomenon, so is,
8
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS AND ROBERT CHIA
partially at least, the ‘environment’ with which organizations are deemed to interact with. The environment is partly an organizational creation insofar as it is enacted through the actions organizations undertake: organizations help bring forth the environment they deal with (Weick, 1995). Weick’s ontological move from organizations to organizing has revealed a hitherto almost invisible (in theoretical terms) world: a world of constrained yet evolving interactions, feedback loops, relationships and double interacts. He has brought to our attention the circularity that characterizes much of human action: individuals and organizations partly grapple with problems of their own making. Rejecting the entitarian image underlying the ontology of traditional OT, Weick has enabled scholars and practitioners alike to pay closer attention to questions of novelty, process and agency. The importance of ontological commitments is also highlighted in the ongoing controversy surrounding the nature of strategy. For defenders of rationalist accounts, strategy is an essentially analytical exercise that takes the form of systematic scanning of the environment and the organization, planning for the future and executing the plan. Such a view of strategy assumes a Cartesian split between conception and execution (thinking vs. acting) and an identification of strategy with senior managerial intentionality (Mintzberg, 1994). For those who take a process view of strategy, thinking and acting are closely intertwined, and strategy making is much more intuitive, context-dependent, process-sensitive and emergent than analytical, intended and planned (Mintzberg, Ahlstrand, & Lampel, 1998). Scholars who take a practice perspective on strategy go further by first bringing intentionality under scrutiny and showing how it is constructed through practitioners drawing on particular sociomaterial practices (Jarzabkowski, Balogun, & Seidl, 2007; Johnson, Langley, Melin, & Whittington, 2007; Whittington, 2006), and second by exploring the taken-for-granted background on which organizations tacitly (i.e. non-deliberately) draw, in order to generate the consistencies in action that, looked at ex post facto by scholars, are labelled as realized strategies (Chia & Holt, 2009; Chia & MacKay, 2007). In other words, what strategy is taken to be depends crucially on how intentionality, action and rationality are viewed – all these are metatheoretical issues, susceptible to different philosophical treatments (Tsoukas, 2010). For rationalists, strategy is largely what is intended; it is a plan. For process theorists, strategy is largely contextual and improvisational; it is a pattern. For practice theorists, strategy is what practitioners do, intended or not, planned or improvisational; it is praxis. Clearly, the kind of ontological commitments made concerning the status of intentionality, action and rationality will help define the phenomenon at hand and how it ought to be
Introduction: Why Philosophy Matters to Organization Theory
9
studied. So, for some practice theorists, the idea that a coherent and consistent strategy might emerge non-deliberately rather than through deliberate intention is more plausible than might appear to be the case (Chia & Holt, 2009). Several other examples, illustrating the significance of ontological redefinitions – the change in the ‘system of picturing’ – for the conceptualization of organizational phenomena, can be mentioned. The shift from seeing change as a fait accompli, thus approaching it as a succession of states, to seeing change as immanent in organizations, stemming from actors’ reflexivity as well as their having to accommodate new experiences, has led several researchers to talk about ‘organizational becoming’ (Tsoukas & Chia, 2002) and continuous improvisation (Orlikowski, 1996; Weick, 1998): the move from approaching routines as stable entities to seeing routines as ‘emergent accomplishments’ (Feldman, 2000, p. 613), thus incorporating both stability and change; the redefinition of organizational mind as ‘a propensity to act in a certain manner or style’ (Weick & Roberts, 1993, p. 361), actualized in patterns of behaviour, rather than as a mental entity engaged in information processing; and the reconception of professional competence as constituted by specific ways of being in the world, namely by distinctive ways of engaging in a sociomaterial practice, rather than defined by a set of specific attributes, such as knowledge, skills, attitudes and personal characteristics (Sandberg & Pinnington, 2009), all of them are examples of ontological redescriptions of the relevant phenomenon at hand. What these examples have in common is an underlying performative imagery: organizational change, routines, mind and competence are not viewed as entities or accomplished events (as has traditionally been the case), but as enactments. Insofar as this is the case, we are invited to think the processes through which such enactments are carried out. By changing the underlying ontological imagery, what was previously thought to be already accomplished and stable is now revealed to be context- and processdependent, and unstable. While change and novelty were thought to be properties of the organization, now the organization itself is an emergent property of change. Such an ontological reversal enables fresh questions to be asked and new empirical patterns to be noticed. 2. Epistemology: If ontology is concerned with, to use Aristotle’s phrase, carving up reality at the joints, epistemology is concerned with how we know what we claim to know. If ontological redefinitions lead to positing new imageries, thus enabling new conceptual distinctions to be made, epistemological considerations lead to exploring how our claims to
10
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS AND ROBERT CHIA
knowledge are couched and justified. Typical questions include the following: Should organizational research be aiming at explaining organizational phenomena, predicting them or both? Or understanding them? Are organizational phenomena akin to those studied by the natural sciences? Should we be concerned with explaining the variability of outcomes in terms of the variability of antecedent conditions leading to outcomes or should we be aiming at showing the processes or mechanisms that lead to particular outcomes? If theories are meant to be generalizable, what is meant by this term and how may generalizability be achieved? Are actors’ beliefs and desires needed in order to explain an organizational phenomenon or can they be dispensed with? For the sake of illustration, consider the latter question. The task of organizational researchers has traditionally been assumed to be the discovery of empirical regularities and their subsequent explanation through contingency models (CMs) of explanation of the type ‘If A, then B, in circumstances Z’ (Donaldson, 2001). In a more elaborate form, CMs take the following form: ‘Given any organization X, if X wants to maximize its performance A and X believes that B is a means to attain A, under the circumstances, then X does B’ (cf. Rosenberg, 1988, p. 25). Notice that this general statement connects beliefs and desires to actions. For a CM to be used, both the account of the situation (‘under the circumstances’) and the rational disposition of the actor (‘if X wants to maximize its performance A’) must be governed by objective criteria of application. For contingency theorists, such objective criteria are possible if large populations of organizations are examined, in which, like in a market, actors’ rationality is assumed as a general tendency. Accordingly, there is no need to examine particular actors’ beliefs and desires. Ansoff (1991, p. 459), for example, argued some time ago that ‘the levels of success in organizations which are aligned with the environment were [found to be] substantially higher than in organizations which were out of alignment’. In other words, under norms of rationality, the more aligned an organization is with its turbulent environment, the more successful the organization will be (for similar claims, see Hrebiniak & Joyce, 2001). What particular actors believe and desire is of no consequence in CMs of explanation. For other researchers, however, CMs do not do justice to the contextuality of organizational phenomena, since research findings refer to aggregates, while our research subjects – namely, practitioners – act within specific organizations (Mintzberg, 1991, p. 465). The difference in the levels of reference is crucial. In aggregating, ‘researchers construct homogeneity
Introduction: Why Philosophy Matters to Organization Theory
11
in heterogeneous phenomena’ (Starbuck, 2006, p. 143), whereas practitioners experience the particularity of their own situations. To do justice to the inherent contextuality of organizational phenomena, contextualist forms of inquiry must be pursued, interpretivists argue. CM models require objective criteria of application concerning the situation and actors’ rationality, which, however, are not possible, since an account of the situation and of an actor’s beliefs and desires is actor-dependent, that is to say subjective (Rosenberg, 1988; Bohman, 1991; Tsoukas & Knudsen, 2005, p. 368). An actor’s beliefs and desires cannot be merely read from his/her actions, for the actor may hold quite different second-order or contextdependent beliefs and desires. For example, destroying their farm produce may violate criteria of utility maximization, but doing so may be rational for farmers as a form of protest. Even if a full description of an actor’s beliefs and desires is given, his/her course of action cannot be predicted, since to do so would require an objective description of the situation, which, however, cannot be done independently of attributions of beliefs and desires. As Bohman (1991, p. 27) aptly observes, ‘to say that ‘‘A is in a situation of type C’’ is already to give an interpretation of A’s beliefs and desires, to locate the action in a set of practices and in the larger context of the agent’s other beliefs and desires’. To return to Ansoff’s example, for a contextualist, to what extent an environment is ‘turbulent’ cannot be decided irrespectively of managers’ web of beliefs and desires – it is, at least to some extent, a matter of interpretation. What constitutes ‘turbulent’ to one manager may be perceived as quite ‘passive’ by another. Organizations do not respond to pre-given environments but to environments as perceived and enacted by the organization (Weick, 1995; Tsoukas & Knudsen, 2005, pp. 366–368). In other words, from a contextualist (or interpretive or constructivist) epistemology, what an environment is inevitably depends on socially acquired attitudes, habits of attention and the language chosen to describe it. The language of description, in turn, depends on the interpreter’s historically shaped web of beliefs, desires and predispositions. What actors believe in and desire cannot be reduced to an objective description for, as Rosenberg (1988, p. 44) noted, doing so would risk changing the truth value of the statements involved. Put differently, we cannot substitute synonymous descriptions for intentional states without changing their truth value. Statements that attribute beliefs and desires are irreducibly interpretive (Bohman, 1991, p. 28). Interpretive forms of inquiry tend to be sensitive to process explanations, whereas CM models follow variance models (Van de Ven & Poole, 2005; Tsoukas & Knudsen, 2005; Langley &
12
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS AND ROBERT CHIA
Tsoukas, 2010). Practice theorists go further in showing that social and organizational processes may generate unintended outcomes, both positive and negative, through the everyday actions and interactions of practitioners (de Certeau, 1984; Bourdieu, 1990; Chia & Holt, 2009). Intentionality is not the final word in understanding individual and collective behaviour. 3. Praxeology: If ontology is concerned with the general structure of reality and epistemology is concerned with how scholars formulate and justify their knowledge claims, praxeology deals with how knowledge is related to action and, more specifically, how theory is related to practice. Praxeology is particularly important for the policy sciences, since the latter are, by design, concerned with generating actionable knowledge (Tsoukas & Knudsen, 2003, Part IV). Typical praxeological questions include: What is actionable knowledge? What makes knowledge practical? How is theory related to practice? What types of knowledge are related to what types of practice? What is the structure of practical reason? How can theory inform practice, yet do justice to the novelty the latter may bring about? What is the role of free will (or choice) in explanations of organizational behaviour? How is ethics related to knowledge? Endorsing Lewin’s (1945) classic statement that ‘nothing is more practical than a good theory’, Van de Ven (1989, p. 486) noted that a good theory is one that ‘enlightens the profession of management’. How does it happen? The mainstream view has been that OT, being an applied field, is similar to engineering and, thus, on the one hand, it relates to the social sciences as engineering does to physics, while, on the other hand, it relates to the profession of management much like the engineering sciences relate to the profession of engineers (Zald, 1996, p. 251; Van de Ven, 2007). This was, by and large, Thompson’s (1956/1957), Simon’s (1976) and Barnard’s (1968) view of administrative science; they urged organization scientists to conceive of formal organizations as ‘abstract systems’ (Barnard, 1968, p. 74) – as sets of formal rules operative under norms of procedural rationality – in order to reveal ‘the principles of general organization’ (Barnard, 1976, p. xlvi). The formally validated knowledge organization scientists generate, typically formulated as CM propositional statements, is thought to be turned into similarly structured propositional rules of action to be followed by practitioners. Indeed, as MacIntyre (1985, p. 107) noted, it is the allegedly scientific character of managerial knowledge that legitimates managerial action. On this account, OT is broadly modelled on the natural sciences (McKelvey, 1997). Prediction is symmetrically related to explanation. Time,
Introduction: Why Philosophy Matters to Organization Theory
13
temporality and emergence are not taken seriously into account. Individual and collective histories and the ways by which they can subtly shape tendencies and predispositions play little or no part in the explanatory schemata. Lay knowledge is thought biased and, ideally, ought to be jettisoned in favour of scientifically validated knowledge. Propositional statements are derived from the study of past behaviour, which they are taken to explain; action will be reliably guided (i.e. its consequences predicted) by applying the same propositional statements in the future. Human action is, thus, thought to relate to theory in a technical, instrumental manner. In this context, enlightened action means evidence-based, scientifically validated, instrumental action. Scientific knowledge is seen as leading to particular techniques used to obtain particular results, devoid of any intrinsic ethical commitments. Ethics becomes relevant only in the way knowledge is used, not in how it is constituted (Simon, 1976). By contrast, a poetic (as opposed to instrumental) praxeology (Shotter, 1993; Tsoukas, 2005, p. 5) places emphasis on the internal (rather than external/instrumental) relationship between theory and practice and the transformative character of theories. On this view, individuals and organizations are situated into, and draw on, broader sociomaterial practices, which are constituted by self-interpretations (Taylor, 1985a). Human beings are socially dependent ‘self-interpreting animals’ (Taylor, 1985a, p. 45), not in the weak sense of being able to engage in reflection and interpretation, but in the strong sense of being constituted by social relations and self-interpretation. Notions such as ‘trust’, ‘loyalty’, ‘authority’, etc., are inextricably bound up with the social life of a subject of experience. The language we use to describe our goals, beliefs and desires, worked out in particular sociomaterial practices, defines also the meanings these terms have for us (Taylor, 1985a, p. 71, 1985b, p. 23; Winch, 1958, p. 15). Different vocabularies constitute differently carved up semantic spaces, within which particular notions are located and from which they derive their meanings. Sociomaterial practices are mutually constituted with the vocabularies that describe them: without being enacted in a particular practice, a vocabulary would be incomprehensible; we would be unable to see what it is referring to (an experience we often have with foreign languages). And vice versa: a practice could not exist without the use of a particular vocabulary. Thus, there is an internal relationship between theories and the practices they refer to. As the case of modern finance has shown, the adoption of a theory alters the self-understandings constitutive of a practice and, therefore, it changes the practice (MacKenzie, 2006). If theory is seen as a vocabulary through which important distinctions may be enacted in a sociomaterial
14
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS AND ROBERT CHIA
practice, it is not ‘applied’ by practitioners in the same way a mathematical formula is applied by an engineer; the theory modifies to some extent the distinctions incorporated in a practice, thus altering both the practice and the practitioner. A poetic praxeology, therefore, brings out the doubly transformative character of theories. The latter not only helps alter some self-understandings in a practice but also helps alter actors’ experience of the practice. Moreover, a poetic praxeology sees actors are as being inevitably shaped by the practices they are part of; they oftentimes unreflectively acquire and unconsciously internalize a cultural habitus (Bourdieu, 1990) that subsequently serves to shape their modus operandi in their everyday dealings with the world. Insofar as actors regularly draw on the linguistic resources and traditions of their practice, they often act in a relatively unreflective manner, but nevertheless possess the innate capacity for self-observation and reflexivity, thereby potentially altering their practices to suit particular circumstances. Theories provide further vocabularies to practitioners to articulate in different ways what is only tacitly understood in their practices. The internal relationship of theories and practices indicates that normative questions are already implicated when evaluating theories. As perhaps the fallout from the economic crisis at the end of the first decade of the 21st century, precipitated by the collapse or near-collapse of large financial institutions, has made clear, theories are validated through practice. As Taylor (1985a, p. 111) remarks, ‘[y] because theories which are about practices are self-definitions, and hence alter the practices, the proof of the validity of a theory can come in the changed quality of the practice it enables. Let me introduce terms of art for this shift of quality and say that good theory enables practice to become less stumbling and more clairvoyant’. Conceptions of ethics, effective action and the common good are inevitably joined up and mutually implicated in evaluating theories. Unlike instrumental action, praxis (and, by implication, poetic praxeology) is always already ethically oriented. In conclusion, ontological, epistemological and praxeological questions, and the ways in which they impact organizational theorizing, indicate that philosophical questions are higher-order meta-questions to OT as a scientific discipline concerned with studying empirical organizational phenomena. Philosophical questions are generated from outside the scientific frameworks within which scientists carry out their research practices. They are questions that focus on the frameworks themselves. Of course, scientific practices can normally carry on successfully without ever dealing with such meta-questions.
Introduction: Why Philosophy Matters to Organization Theory
15
However, when scientific practices stumble in their efforts to make sense of the empirical world and to ‘enlighten practitioners’, taken-for-granted ontological categories call for our attention, tacitly accepted ways of understanding come under scrutiny and conventional ways of intervening in the world become unsatisfactory. The very frameworks of scientific inquiry, hitherto tacitly accepted for the practice of scientific research to be carried out (Tsoukas, 2005, p. 324), become questionable and philosophical reflection enters the scene. Philosophical questions are essentially conceptual in character (Block, 1979, p. 450; Winch, 1958; Deleuze & Guattari, 1994), that is, they are questions about the nature of the concepts we use in organizational research to describe and explain organizations (including the concepts ‘describe’, ‘explain’ and ‘organizations’) (cf. Fay, 2000, p. 52). The questions, for example, ‘what is organizational change?’, ‘what is organizational learning (or knowledge)?’ or ‘what is a decision (or strategy)?’, are not empirical questions but conceptual, requiring elucidation. The philosophy of OT, therefore, deals with the study of the conceptual problems in OT. To be concerned with the elucidation of key concepts commonly used in the practice of OT as a scientific discipline is to bring a philosophical orientation to the study of those concepts and move the discussion to the meta-level, to interrogate the very framework within which OT questions are explored. In other words, philosophical analysis helps keep meaning open in a scientific field. Like all institutionalized activities, the practice of scientific research legitimates and takes for granted particular ways of engaging with, observing and talking about the world. Insofar as this is the case, closure of meaning is inevitably brought about. Philosophical inquiry fights that closure. Castoriadis goes even further and associates philosophy with thought itself: the latter is possible only insofar as the former takes place. It is worth quoting him in full (Castoriadis, 1991, p. 21): ‘Philosophy is not about the question: What is Being, or what is the meaning of Being, or why is there something instead of nothing, etc. All these questions are secondary, in the sense that they are all conditioned upon the emergence of a more radical question [y]: What is it that I ought to think (about being, about physis, about the polis, about justice, etc. – and about my own thinking)? This questioning goes on, and has to go on, incessantly, for a simple reason. Any being-for-itself exists and can only exist in a closure – thus also society and the social individual. Democracy is the project of breaking the closure at the collective level. Philosophy, creating self-reflective subjectivity, is the
16
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS AND ROBERT CHIA
project of breaking the closure at the level of thought. But of course, any breaking of the closure, unless it remains a gaping ‘‘?’’ which does not break anything at all, posits something, reaches some results, and, thereby, risks erecting again a closure. The continuation and renewal of reflective activity – not for the sake of ‘‘renewal’’ but because this is self-reflective activity – entails therefore the putting into question of previous results [y]’.
ABOUT THIS VOLUME All chapters in this volume explore connections between certain streams in philosophy and OT. As the titles of the chapters suggest, most authors write about a particular philosopher or group of philosophers that makes up a distinct school of thought, summarize important aspects of his/their work and tease out the implications for OT. The central question authors explore is: ‘what does a particular philosophy contribute to OT?’ Whether addressing this question in historical terms (‘what has been the influence of a particular philosophy on the development of certain OT approaches?’), exploratory terms (‘what benefits to organizational analysis does a particular philosophy bring?’) or a combination of both, the end result is similar: particular philosophical issues, properly explained, are discussed in relation to important questions in OT. The chapters deal with analytical philosophy (Lakomski and Evers), phenomenology (Holt and Sandberg), hermeneutics (Barrett, Powley and Pearce), process philosophy (Nayak and Chia), Derridean deconstructionism (Rasche), MacIntyre and neo-Aristotelianism (Beadle and Moore), Habermasian discourse ethics (Scherer and Patzer), pragmatism (Elkjaer and Simpson), Marxian philosophy (Adler) and the late Wittgenstein (Shotter and Tsoukas). Bechara and Van de Ven do not discuss a particular philosophical approach but several, showing the benefits of philosophical triangulation. Czarniawska, in her personal essay, writes about how Rortyan pragmatism has influenced her life and work. Some chapters are more concerned with one of the three dimensions of philosophical inquiry (ontology, epistemology and praxeology), while others with a combination of them. Thus, Holt and Sandberg, Nayak and Chia, Rasche, and Elkjaer and Simpson deal primarily with ontological issues surrounding the notions of human experience of the world, process, deconstruction and key pragmatist themes, respectively, whereas Lakomski
Introduction: Why Philosophy Matters to Organization Theory
17
and Evers deal with primarily epistemological issues having to do with the role of theories in OT. Beadle and Moore, Barrett, Powley and Pearce, and Adler combine, in different degrees, ontological, epistemological and praxeological issues. Scherer and Patzer focus primarily on praxeological questions arising from Habermasian discourse ethics, and Shotter and Tsoukas deal with epistemological and praxeological issues. As one would expect, there are some overlaps between the different chapters. It is nearly impossible, for example, to write about hermeneutics without implicating its first cousin, phenomenology. Philosophers such as Heidegger are often discussed in the context of both hermeneutics and phenomenology. Similarly, process philosophers draw to some extent on phenomenological analyses – it is difficult to keep them apart. Overlaps do not, however, point to useless redundancy. Even when two chapters discuss the same philosopher, they do so in their own distinctive ways, thus illuminating the issues at hand. Finally, if you detect in this selection of chapters a certain bias towards nonrationalist philosophical accounts, this is indeed the case. We happen to think that this is where most interesting philosophical work is taking place. At the same time, our choice of philosophical schools to include in this volume has been influenced by two considerations. One is the extent to which a particular philosophy has been drawn on or has implicitly provided impetus for the development of organization theories and theorizing, and second, by the availability of philosophically minded organization theorists who would be willing to write about a particular philosophy and OT. As well as philosophical diversity, we wanted to have some geographical and gender balance, always a difficult thing to achieve. We confess that, in an ideal world, we would have liked to have included more philosophers (e.g. Kirkegaard, Sartre, Popper, Deleuze, Adorno, Levinas, etc.) or social theorists and humanities scholars whose work has had interesting philosophical implications (e.g. Bakhtin, Foucault, Luhmann, Varela, Eco, Archer, Latour, Serres, etc.). We beg for the reader’s understanding. Space is limited, while this is only the start, anyway. As far as we know, this is the first time a mainstream OT series has explicitly devoted a whole volume to questions relating to philosophy (rather than merely epistemology) and OT, and we are grateful to Editor-inChief Michael Lounsbury for the invitation. We are pleased that a very good start has been made and that philosophical issues are explicitly placed on the agenda. We hope to continue and hope that others will want to join in.
18
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS AND ROBERT CHIA
REFERENCES Ansoff, I. H. (1991). Critique of Henry Mintzberg’s ‘The design school: Reconsidering the basic premises of strategic management’. Strategic Management Journal, 12, 449–461. Barnard, C. (1968). The functions of the executive (30th anniversary ed.). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Barnard, C. (1976). Foreword. In: H. Simon (Ed.), Administrative behavior (pp. xlvi–xlvii). New York: The Free Press. Block, N. (1979). Philosophy of psychology. In: P. D. Asquith & H. E. Kyburg, Jr (Eds), Current research in the philosophy of science (pp. 450–462). East Lansing, MI: Philosophy of Science Association. Bloom, A. (1987). The closing of the American mind. London: Penguin. Bohman, J. (1991). New philosophy of social science. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press. Bourdieu, P. (1990). The logic of practice. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Burrell, G., & Morgan, G. (1979). Sociological paradigms and organizational analysis. Aldershot, Hants: Gower Publishing Co. Castoriadis, C. (1991). Philosophy, politics, autonomy. In: D. A. Curtis (Ed.), New York: Oxford University Press. Chia, R., & Holt, R. (2009). Strategy without design: The silent efficacy of indirect action. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Chia, R., & MacKay, B. (2007). Post-processual challenges for the emerging strategy-aspractice perspective: Discovering strategy in the logic of practice. Human Relations, 60/1, 217–242. de Certeau, M. (1984). The practice of everyday life. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Deleuze, G., & Guattari, F. (1994). What is philosophy? (G. Burchell & H. Thompson, Trans.). London: Verso. Donaldson, L. (2001). The contingency theory of organizations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Fay, B. (2000). Winch’s philosophical bearings. History of the Human Sciences, 13, 50–62. Feldman, M. (2000). Organizational routines as a source of continuous change. Organization Science, 11, 611–629. Foucault, M. (1970). The order of things. London: Tavistock. Guignon, C. B. (1983). Heidegger and the problem of knowledge. New York: Hackett Pub Co. Harre, R. (1985). The philosophies of science. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Hrebiniak, L. G., & Joyce, W. F. (2001). Implementing strategy: An appraisal and agenda for future research. In: M. A. Hitt, R. E. Freeman & J. S. Harrison (Eds), The Blackwell handbook of strategic management (pp. 602–626). Oxford: Blackwell. James, W. (1909/1996). A pluralistic universe. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press. James, W. (1911/1996). Some problems of philosophy. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press. Jarzabkowski, P., Balogun, J., & Seidl, D. (2007). Strategizing: The challenges of a practice perspective. Human Relations, 60/1, 5–28. Johnson, B. (1989). A world of difference. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. Johnson, G., Langley, A., Melin, L., & Whittington, R. (Eds). (2007). Strategy as practice. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Introduction: Why Philosophy Matters to Organization Theory
19
Langley, A., & Tsoukas, H. (2010). Introducing ‘‘Perspectives on Process Organization Studies’’. In: T. Hernes & S. Maitlis (Eds), Process, sensemaking & organizing (pp. 1–26). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Lewin, K. (1945). The research center for group dynamics at Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Sociometry, 8, 126–135. MacIntyre, A. (1985). After virtue (2nd ed.). London: Duckworth. MacKenzie, D. (2006). An engine, not a camera: How financial models shape markets. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. McKelvey, B. (1997). Quasi-natural organization science. Organization Science, 8, 351–380. Mintzberg, H. (1991). Learning 1, planning 0: Reply to Igor Ansoff. Strategic Management Journal, 12, 463–466. Mintzberg, H. (1994). The rise and fall of strategic planning. New York: Prentice Hall. Mintzberg, H., Ahlstrand, B., & Lampel, J. (1998). Strategy safari. New York: Prentice Hall. Orlikowski, W. J. (1996). Improvising organizational transformation over time: A situated change perspective. Information Systems Research, 7, 63–92. Pugh, D. S. (1981). The Aston Program perspective: The Aston Program of research: Retrospect and prospect. In: A. Van de Ven & W. Joyce (Eds), Perspectives on organization design and behavior (pp. 135–166). New York: Wiley. Rorty, R. (1989). Contingency, irony and solidarity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Rosenberg, A. (1988). Philosophy of social science. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Sandberg, J., & Pinnington, P. (2009). Professional competence as ways of being: An existential ontological perspective. Journal of Management Studies, 46, 1138–1170. Shotter, J. (1993). Conversational realities. London: Sage. Simon, H. (1976). Administrative behavior (3rd ed.). New York: The Free Press. Starbuck, W. H. (2006). The production of knowledge. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Taylor, C. (1985a). Human agency and language (Vol. 1). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Taylor, C. (1985b). Philosophy and the human sciences (Vol. 2). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Thompson, J. D. (1956-57). On building an administrative science. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1, 102–111. Toulmin, S. (1982). The return to cosmology. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Tsoukas, H. (2005). Complex knowledge. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Tsoukas, H. (2010). Practice, strategy making and intentionality: A Heideggerian ontoepistemology for strategy as practice. In: D. Golsorkhi, L. Rouleau, D. Seidl & E. Vaara (Eds), Cambridge handbook of strategy as practice. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Tsoukas, H., & Chia, R. (2002). On organizational becoming: Rethinking organizational change. Organization Science, 13, 567–582. Tsoukas, H., & Knudsen, C. (2003). The Oxford handbook of organization theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Tsoukas, H., & Knudsen, C. (2005). The conduct of strategy research: Meta-theoretical issues. In: H. Tsoukas (Ed.), Complex knowledge (pp. 340–377). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Van de Ven, A. (1989). Nothing is quite so practical as a good theory. Academy of Management Review, 14, 486–489. Van de Ven, A. H. (2007). Engaged scholarship. New York: Oxford University Press.
20
HARIDIMOS TSOUKAS AND ROBERT CHIA
Van de Ven, A. H., & Poole, M. S. (2005). Alternative approaches for studying organizational change. Organization Studies, 26(9), 1377–1404. Weick, K. (1995). Sensemaking in organizations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Weick, K., & Roberts, K. (1993). Collective mind in organizations: Heedful interrelating on flight decks. Administrative Science Quarterly, 38, 357–381. Weick, K. E. (1979). The social psychology of organizing (2nd ed.). Reading, MA: AddisonWesley. Weick, K. E. (1998). Improvisation as a mindset for organizational analysis. Organization Science, 9, 543–555. Whitehead, A. N. (1929). Process and reality. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Whitehead, A. N. (1933). Adventures of ideas. Harmondsworth, Middlesex: Pelican Books. Whittington, R. (2006). Completing the practice turn in strategy. Organization Studies, 27(5), 613–634. Winch, P. (1958). The idea of a social science and its relation to philosophy. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Zald, M. N. (1996). More fragmentation? Unfinished business in linking the social sciences and the humanities. Administrative Science Quarterly, 41, 251–261.
Haridimos Tsoukas is the Columbia Ship Management Professor of Strategic Management at the University of Cyprus, Cyprus, and a Professor of Organization Studies at Warwick Business School, University of Warwick, UK. He has published widely in several leading academic journals and was the Editor-in-Chief of Organization Studies (2003–2008). His research interests include knowledge-based perspectives on organizations, the management of organizational change and social reforms, the epistemology of practice and epistemological issues in organization theory. He is the editor (with Christian Knudsen) of The Oxford Handbook of Organization Theory: Meta-theoretical Perspectives (Oxford University Press, 2003). He has also edited Organizations as Knowledge Systems, Palgrave Macmillan, 2004 (with N. Mylonopoulos), and Managing the Future: Foresight in the Knowledge Economy, Blackwell, 2004 (with J. Shepherd). His book Complex Knowledge: Studies in Organizational Epistemology was published by Oxford University Press in 2005. He is also the author of the book If Aristotle were a CEO (in Greek, Kastaniotis, 2005, 2nd ed.). Robert Chia is professor of management at the University of Strathclyde Business School and Emeritus Professor of Management, University of Aberdeen. He received his PhD in organization studies from Lancaster University and publishes regularly in the leading international journals in organization and management studies. He is the author/editor of four books and a significant number of international journal articles as well as book
Introduction: Why Philosophy Matters to Organization Theory
21
chapters in a variety of management sub-fields. His latest book with Robin Holt, published by Cambridge University Press in October 2009, is entitled Strategy without Design: The Silent Efficacy of Indirect Action. His research interests revolve around the issues of strategic leadership and foresight, complexity and creative thinking, and the impact of contrasting East–West metaphysical mindsets on executive decision making.
ANALYTIC PHILOSOPHY AND ORGANIZATION THEORY: PHILOSOPHICAL PROBLEMS AND SCIENTIFIC SOLUTIONS Gabriele Lakomski and Colin W. Evers ABSTRACT In this chapter, we present a critical assessment of contemporary organization theory variously described as either multiperspectival or fragmented. We argue that analytic philosophy as one of the major tools used for theorizing about organizations has had a major influence on the development of organization theory and largely explains the current state of affairs. At its core, we argue, is a fundamental methodological fissure in analytic philosophy itself: the distinction between descriptive and revisionary methods. The principal focus of descriptive analysis in organization theory is how agents use everyday language in organizational contexts, often by invoking language games. In contrast, revisionary approaches, concerned about the privileging of theories embedded in everyday language, as well as the complexity and ambiguity of ordinary-language use, aim for explicit theory evaluation and greater clarity by recasting ordinary language in formal systems, such as scientific, especially empiricist, theories, characteristic of the mainstream of theorizing about organizations from the 1940s onward. For a number of theoretical and epistemological Philosophy and Organization Theory Research in the Sociology of Organizations, Volume 32, 23–54 Copyright r 2011 by Emerald Group Publishing Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 0733-558X/doi:10.1108/S0733-558X(2011)0000032004
23
24
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
reasons logical empiricism or positivism is no longer a widely held view either in the philosophy of science or in the organization theory. We examine some critical issues regarding logical empiricist epistemological foundations and propose a methodological naturalistic framework that supports the ongoing growth of knowledge in organization theory, naturalistic coherentism. In developing this new conception of science we thus opt for a revisionary methodology, but one that is beholden to neither the traditional logical empiricist/positivist conception of (organization) science nor the relativism and conservatism of postmodernist theory, widely considered to be the successor of positivist organization theory. Keywords: Organization theory; analytic philosophy; naturalistic coherentism; naturalism; descriptive and revisionary methods. Because the world is not a cluster of conjurer’s tricks, conjurers can exist – N. R. Hanson
INTRODUCTION Contemporary organization theory is a field characterized both by a plurality of views and perspectives (e.g., Walsh, Meyer, & Schoonhoven, 2006) on one hand, and by paradigmatic underdevelopment and fragmentation (Pfeffer, 1993) on the other. Explanations for this assessment range from the presumed clash of rival narrative traditions (Reed, 1997) to the claim that science, as a master narrative offering superior knowledge, has ‘‘run out of steam’’ (Burrell, 1997, p. 657). In this chapter, we present a critical assessment of this state of affairs and propose a methodological naturalistic framework that supports the ongoing growth of knowledge in organization theory, naturalistic coherentism. In particular, we argue that analytic philosophy, as one of the major tools used for theorizing about organizations, has had a fundamental influence on the development of organization theory up to the present. Analytic philosophy is usually described as a school of thought being concerned with logical or linguistic conceptual analysis (see Preston, 2006). Part of the reason for the current intellectual diversity in organization theory, we argue, can be found in a fundamental methodological fissure in analytic philosophy itself: the distinction between descriptive and revisionary methods. Another contributing factor is the appropriateness of these tools for two different foci of organizational analysis: the holistic level and the individual level. Roughly speaking, descriptive methods emphasize
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
25
the role of meaning in ordinary discourse. The principal focus of descriptive analysis in organization theory, for example, is how agents use everyday language in organizational contexts, often by invoking Wittgensteinian language games. In contrast, revisionary approaches, concerned about the complexity and ambiguity of ordinary-language use, aim for greater clarity by recasting ordinary language in formal systems, such as scientific theories. Famous classical examples of revisionary approaches in administration and organization theory are the positions advocated by Simon ([1945] 1976), March and Simon (1958), Cyert and March (1963), and Katz and Kahn (1978) whose views of science were that of logical empiricism. It is this type of revisionary conception that formed the mainstream of theorizing about organizations from the 1940s onward and is clearly evident, inter alia, in the mission statement of the flagship in the field, the Administrative Science Quarterly (see Thompson, 1956). Logical empiricism, often simply called positivism, is not a view currently or widely advocated in organization studies. However, Donaldson’s work (1985, 1996, 2005) must be acknowledged here in that it provides a spirited, albeit lonely, defense. In the discussion to follow, we present in broad outline some of the key features of analytic philosophy and its influence in organization studies, raise critical issues regarding logical empiricist epistemological foundations, and discuss the paradigms approach (or P-theory) as the self-proclaimed successor to logical empiricism that is prominent in current organization theory. En passant, we also offer some comments about why we believe postmodernism in organization theory to be deeply conservative and to remain wedded to an empiricist agenda. Our final section outlines naturalistic coherentism as a more productive methodological framework for theorizing about organizations. While it is not the only naturalistic approach to organization theory, it is, we argue, the most consistent and differs significantly, for example, from McKelvey’s ‘‘quasi-natural’’ conception (McKelvey, 1999, 1997, 2002), which maintains a worrying dualism in its premise. In developing this new conception of science we thus opt for a revisionist methodology, but one that is beholden to neither the traditional logical empiricist/positivist conception of (organization) science nor the relativism and conservatism of postmodernist theory.
ANALYTIC PHILOSOPHY IN ORGANIZATION STUDIES The term ‘‘analytic philosophy’’ is usually applied to a philosophical orientation identified with the names of G.E. Moore and Bertrand Russell in
26
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
the early days of the 20th century (Preston, 2006, provides a good overview). Characteristic of Moore and Russell was their belief that natural language was too loose and philosophically imprecise, and that greater clarity of meaning could be achieved if the analysis of language were to be made the methodological core of philosophy. Following Moore, a relatively finegrained descriptive approach to linguistic analysis, often (and for some controversially) described as the ‘‘linguistic turn,’’ characterized one strand of analysis while a revisionary approach, using the formal logic of Russell, came to characterize another strand. Of the five phases identified by Preston (2006), the third is represented by the so-called Vienna Circle. It was a major and sustained attempt to develop a revisionary approach to the analysis of language and is probably best known to theorists of organizations and administrative science. It is associated with philosophers such as Schlick, Neurath, Feigl, Waisman, Carnap, and Hempel, collectively known as the logical positivists. (Feiglis particularly interesting because as well as having been a logical positivist, within a group of scientifically minded philosophers, he saw, first, its weaknesses and explicitly transitioned to logical empiricism, a view more consonant with a realist ontology, and second, he applied this framework to social science.) This Austrian–German philosophical perspective has been championed in the British context by A. J. Ayer whose book Language, Truth and Logic, published in 1936, and continues to be influential in organization theory to this day. It expressed the most extreme form of the revisionist doctrine, categorizing whole continents of human discourse as meaningless. From 1945 until about 1965, the fourth phase can be identified as a rebound to descriptive styles of analysis with the turn to ordinary-language analysis. Amongst the most prominent advocates are [the later] Wittgenstein (1953) and Gilbert Ryle (1949). The later Wittgenstein came to the conclusion that there is no ideal language, and that each language system is like a game that plays by its own rules. Language understood as an intrinsically social phenomenon cannot be studied in abstracto but only in the human communities in which it is embedded and used. Indeed, language games are wholes whose parts, such as utterances, only have meaning in virtue of a role they play within the total form of life of a linguistic community. Hence, meaning is use. Importantly, language does not have to refer, or correspond, to anything at all. It only has to play a role in a form of life. Accordingly, philosophical analysis became a matter of looking at how people routinely use language and seeing the philosophical muddle we get into when we depart from that use. The 1960s saw the beginning of the demise of linguistic philosophy, while leaving intact its legacy of epistemological relativism in the form of Winch’s
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
27
views, and, more powerfully, Kuhn’s views on the paradigmatic nature of large-scale theories. Ironically, while critics external to academic philosophy such as Ernest Gellner in his Words and Things (1959) were attacking descriptive analysis, Kuhn’s work, as well as the works of philosophers of science such as Hanson ([1958] 1971, 1981) and Popper (1959) expressed attacks on the most prominent models of revisionary analysis – those used by logical empiricists in science. And at about this time, Quine launched major attacks on both traditions as they were then conceived. In his classic paper ‘‘Two dogmas of empiricism’’ ([1951] 1963), he first argued against the analytic/synthetic distinction, thus depriving descriptive analysis of recourse to nontrivial claims that were meant to be true purely by virtue of the meaning of their terms. Quine had no problem with sentences such as ‘‘if X is a bachelor then X is a bachelor’’ because it was true by virtue not of the nonlogical terms ‘‘X,’’ ‘‘bachelor,’’ ‘‘is,’’ and ‘‘a,’’ but by virtue of the purely logical terms ‘‘if y then .y’’ His worry was about sentences like ‘‘if X is a bachelor then X is an unmarried adult male,’’ whose truth relies on the meanings of the nonlogical terms. Meaning analysis is too frail a support for logical truth. And, second, through his defence of holism, he denied all the formal machinery of scientific theory formulation any simple way of matching up its statements with a reduction to discrete packets of evidence, such as particular observations. From the sixties to the present day, the philosophical landscape is characterized by philosophical as well as methodological diversity and has spawned many subfields. While the clarification of concepts, by whatever means, can be a useful exercise, it does not independently tell us what the facts about the world are. These need to be supplied by the background assumptions of whatever analysis is undertaken and by the theories being analyzed (e.g., Churchland, in McCauley, 1996, p. 291). We return to this point later. While analytic philosophy, as we saw, is primarily concerned with the analysis of meaning, approaches to meaning, however, have had wider implications, affecting the framing of issues in, for example, metaphysics, ontology, epistemology, and even in logic (Searle, 2003). The important distinction for our purposes, in classifying methods of analysis, is that between descriptive and revisionary methods. (See Strawson, 1992, who applies the distinction to metaphysics.) Roughly speaking, as we noted above, descriptive approaches involve the understanding of meaning as it resides in ordinary discourse. It is language as it is used that is the locus of analysis. Because of the complexity of usage and its contexts, revisionary approaches attempt to answer questions about meaning by examining
28
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
formal systems. Revisionary analysis informed the early Wittgenstein’s Tractatus, lay at the heart of Logical Positivism, and Logical Empiricism, continued with the work of W. V. Quine, and formed the basis of Donald Davidson’s truth-theoretic analysis of meaning. Descriptive analysis flourished as Oxford-style ordinary-language philosophy whose practitioners included Ryle, the later Wittgenstein, Strawson, Austin, and Grice, but was developed much further in intentionalistic theories of meaning, such as speech act theory as proposed by Searle. Because of their differing methodologies, revisionary and descriptive approaches have had a profound effect on the way issues in social science in general and organization studies in particular have been framed. For example, the study of organizations as systems owes much to the revisionary tradition that seeks to cast such knowledge in terms of law-like generalizations. On the other hand, the study of organizations as entities constructed out of meanings, understandings, and interpretations, where these are in turn read off from linguistic representations, as is often the case with Giddens’s work (e.g., The Constitution of Society, 1984) owes much to the descriptive tradition, particularly Wittgensteinian notions of ‘‘rule following.’’ Thus, the logical machinery of revisionary analysis, first used to formulate problems and their solutions within the study of scientific theories, for which it seems more suited, came to be associated with the research project of blurring the distinction between natural science and social science to produce a science of organizations. Its metaphysical focus was realism and it saw good theory as providing a representation of reality in much the way that a good street map provides a good representation of a city’s road system. On the other hand, descriptive analysis, taking its cue from Wittgenstein’s analysis of language games, developed a shift to relativism, best exemplified in Winch’s The Idea of a Social Science and its Relationship to Philosophy (1958), that was later reaffirmed in the work of Kuhn ([1962] 1970) where different worldviews were viewed as different paradigms, each with their own internal standards of justification. As a forerunner to postmodernism, the question of realism was relativized to particular worldviews, as was the matter of whether a good theory can be said to be a representation of the world. The notion of ‘‘good theory’’ had become problematical. This broad-brush overview to analysis has its exceptions. For example, Searle is a critic of relativism in epistemology, and Rorty, a defender of postmodernism, was well schooled in the technicalities of revisionary analysis. But it does provide an orienting context with which to view ideas in organization theory and research. These approaches are sometimes thought to reflect the difference between explaining what goes on in organizations
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
29
and understanding what goes on, with explanation making use of revisionary concepts and understanding making use of descriptive concepts. To see how this works, consider organizational analysis from two different levels. Viewed holistically as a functioning entity, there is a traditional empiricist science perspective that sees organizations as systems (e.g., von Bertalanffy, 1973; Boulding, 1956). Systems theory has its attractions because at that level of generality, it purports to sustain the kind of law-like generalizations demanded by explanations in natural science. Within organization theory, Katz and Kahn ([1966] 1978) are eloquent advocates of the systems view. (For general discussions see Hatch, 1997; Perrow, 1973.) But the task of understanding organizations holistically places demands on concepts to do with culture, with shared ways of interpreting and acting. (A classic statement of these alternatives can be found in Greenfield, 1975. See also the Special Issue of Administrative Science Quarterly, 1983, on culture and organizational analysis.) At the individual level, revisionary analysis often makes use of concepts concerning individual rationality and choice making. Herbert Simon’s Administrative Behavior (1945 and subsequent editions), methodologically committed to logical empiricism, is a case in point, with its thesis about bounded rationality. This highly influential concept carried over into March and Simon’s book Organizations (1958) and Cyert and March’s A Behavioural Theory of the Firm (1963), described as one of most influential management books of all times (Argote & Greve, 2007). Descriptive approaches often favor the study of subjective meanings. (See Hollis, 2003, for further discussion of this taxonomy of issues.) Karl Weick, although far from being the only representative concerned with meaning and meaning making, is an important scholar to mention in this context. Again, the literature is more diverse than this overview implies, but it will nevertheless help in seeing the main areas of difference and philosophical influence. Embedded in the discussion that follows is an argument that the current pluralism, or paradigm proliferation in the field, while usefully opening up new areas for investigation underexplored or simply absent in empiricist organization theory, is nevertheless detrimental to the growth of organization knowledge. In making this claim, we therefore take sides in favor of a revisionary approach, since in our view, the paradigms framework is not a neutral forum for framing discussion about competing views. As a theory that sought to explain the large-scale change of scientific discoveries, paradigms, or simply, P-theory, reflects the influence of descriptive analysis. Furthermore, the assertion that ‘‘science has run out of steam’’ and is no longer a viable contender for defining, explaining, and understanding organizations is in our view based on a mistake. This claim is premised on
30
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
the systematic and ongoing conflation of science with a specific conception of science, logical empiricism, so prominent in the social sciences and education (Evers & Lakomski, 1991, 1996a, 1996b, 2000; Lakomski, 1991); it is this conflation, we argue, that accounts for much of the present-day state of organization theory. Specifically, contemporary approaches to organization theory – from interpretive–hermeneutic to postmodern – define themselves in opposition to ‘‘science’’ by which they mean positivism, which they rightly reject. This antiscience stance entails rebutting or simply denying the fundamental tenets of science, such as representing the social world objectively, a feature nevertheless accepted as appropriate for natural science. As organizational actors are meaning creating beings, the argument goes, the meanings, intentions, and beliefs that guide their actions are not amenable to scientific ( ¼ positivist) methodology (e.g., Tsoukas & Knudsen, 2005; Hatch & Yanow, 2005). The methodology of verstehen is required as it gets at what is hidden from view, that is, at our minds. As Weick (1979) so passionately argues, sense making is of the essence. A further feature of the interpretive as well as postmodern shift is the claim that we are talking about different organizational worlds (in an extreme reading), or that we move in different narratives without the ability to demarcate one from the other, or even considering it important to be able to do so. There is no touchstone, or common ground, between narratives that would allow evaluation, and no objective reality outside of the narrative. Kuhn’s arguments in particular have provided rich ferment for contemporary organization theory. Its strongest expression is arguably Burrell and Morgan’s (1979) famous book Sociological Paradigms and Organizational Analysis that denotes a kind of watershed for organizational theorizing. Furthermore, in keeping with the notion of Kuhnian paradigms, a strong feature of current organization theory is its anti-representationalism (e.g., Chia, 2005; Tsoukas, 1998) that owes much to Rorty’s (1980) scepticism with regard to the possibility of justifying knowledge claims and the specific role he advocates for analytic philosophy as conversation (see his defense of anti-representationalism in Rorty, 1992). This view is often expressed in the language-as-discursive practice argument that eschews any reality independent of language, following the late Wittgenstein, Taylor, as well as Gadamer. We do not believe, however, that it is necessary to give up on representation. Indeed the main form of attack, following Rorty (1980) has come from assuming it is defeated by successfully attacking foundationalist epistemologies. But these attacks are not successful against nonfoundational epistemologies. Moreover, we think the representational power of good
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
31
theories helps to explain their value in abetting people’s navigation through their social worlds at better than chance, or what one would expect from making decisions based on coin tossing. Several moves are involved in making the point. The most important is uncoupling the empiricist version of science from science as understood in contemporary analytic philosophy of science and theory of knowledge. Rather than turning our backs on science, we embrace a postpositivist view of science that is both naturalistic and coherentist. To be quite clear on this point, we are talking about a new conception of science that supersedes traditional empiricism/positivism. The descriptor ‘‘postpositivism’’ is thus not to be read as denoting views alternative, or hostile, to science. The main reason for this combination of positions is that we think that armchair, or a priori, theorizing about the nature and dynamics of knowledge and human information processing is less warranted than theorizing informed by our best, current, science. Moreover, the strategy of using a less warranted epistemology in order to discount a more warranted body of claims such as science gets matters exactly the wrong way around. What we want is for an epistemology to cohere with our best claims to knowledge. This pushes us in the direction of naturalism – appealing to natural science – and coherentism. Coherence criteria for theory choice include both empirical adequacy and what are called superempirical virtues of good theory, such as consistency, simplicity, comprehensiveness, explanatory unity, and fecundity (Churchland, 1985). These criteria are commonly and uncontroversially used to determine the quality of a theory – its virtues. We would claim that these are also the sorts of criteria that are used in interpretive social science and postmodern approaches. That is, interpreting texts, situations, or other people’s minds and behaviors, and being able to sort well-defended statements from those that are not, can be accomplished by applying coherence criteria. Simply put, the general aim is to see how well our beliefs ‘‘hang together’’ (BonJour, 1985), what sense they make, or how well (or poorly) they cohere. In this conception of science that we advocate, we distinguish a coherence theory of evidence that is employed for justification, from a correspondence theory of truth, which we use to read off the nature of the reality being represented. As in our view, the field of contemporary organization theory reflects the progression of philosophical argument in the analytic tradition, especially with regard to the problems of logical empiricism and ordinary-language philosophy, it is necessary to present some of the most important debates to understand how organization theory got to its current state. Obviously, the magnitude and complexities of this task go well beyond the confines of a single chapter, and we have to be content to present broad outlines of
32
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
arguments, supplemented by relevant philosophical references the reader may wish to pursue. Essential to the current argument are (1) an understanding of the nature and problems of foundationalist epistemology as it underpins both traditional and contemporary versions of organization theory; (2) the twin results of philosophy of science: the theory-laden nature of observation, and the underrepresentation of data by evidence (the Duhem–Quine thesis); (3) Kuhnian paradigms, or P-theory, including incommensurability and the conceptual role theory of meaning, followed by some comments regarding postmodernist assumptions and the consequences for organization theory. To begin the discussion, an elaboration of our earlier remarks on analytic philosophy will set the scene.
LOGICAL EMPIRICISM AND THE PROBLEM WITH FOUNDATIONS IN ORGANIZATION THEORY Donaldson’s (2005) defence of organization theory ‘‘as a positive science’’ follows his much debated book In Defence of Organization Theory published in 1985 (see the symposium published in Organization Studies in 1988), followed by his For Positivist Organization Theory in 1996. All of these discussions are the successors of the possibly most famous and influential of all positivist treatments of administrative science, Herbert Simon’s Administrative Behavior. So while the main game in organization theory has shifted, positivism having become a much less prominent player, a player it remains still. This is not the place to rehearse all the major theoretical shifts and developments in the study of organization and organization theory. (See Walsh et al., 2006; Augier, March, & Sullivan, 2005; Tsoukas and Knudsen’s 2005 Oxford Handbook of Organization Theory presents an excellent overview of the main perspectives in contemporary organization theory, especially in Part 1; Starbuck, 2003; also Clegg, Hardy, and Nord’s (1997) comprehensive Handbook of Organization Studies, especially the chapters by Reed, Burrell, Marsden and Townley; Hatch, 1997.) The publication dates of the above positivist discussions serve to indicate the longevity of this tradition in organization theory, especially in the North American context. Despite different emphases in the works referred to, fundamental commitments to empiricism are shared and are subject to the major problems of foundationalist theories of knowledge and conceptions of science, as is shown in the following text.
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
33
Interestingly, one of the most central figures originally part of the Vienna Circle, Herbert Feigl, who gave the Circle’s central doctrines the name of Logical Positivism (Blumberg & Feigl, 1931) later changed his mind following his critique of the more austere logical positivist doctrines of the verificationist theory of meaning and induction. In his 1931 paper on logical positivism, Feigl (Blumberg & Feigl, 1931, p. 287) initially formulated the central problem of epistemology as ‘‘To know the meaning of a proposition is to know what must be the case if the proposition is true.’’ By the application of logic, complex propositions can be broken down into simple or atomic propositions by showing what experiences verify them, that is, make them true. However there is some ambiguity in this formulation for ‘‘experience’’ can be taken to refer to such different items as sense data, the subjective content of our perceptions, or it can refer to physical objects. For a reductive phenomenalism, our claims are true because we have certain kinds of sensations. For an empirical realist they are true because this is the way the world happens to be. Feigl inclined to the latter, realist, view while the logical positivists of the Vienna Circle tended to side with the antirealist phenomenalist view (Feigl, 1974a, 1974b). A second reason contributed to Feigl’s change of heart. He was much taken by Popper’s arguments on the growth of knowledge, which are in part a critique of logical positivism, and encouraged him to publish his insights in a book, LogikderForschung (1934), later expanded and translated as The Logic of Scientific Discovery in 1959. Popper’s attack on the problem of induction was the essence of the fatal blow to logical positivism. The details need not concern us here, but the basic problem, stated by Hume, is the problem of justifying the shift from
To
All observed X are Y All X are Y
The problem is that no finite number of observations can ever confirm, in the semantical sense of verify, a universal statement. For logical positivists this posed a real dilemma as the meaning of a statement was seen as residing in its method of verification. But the law statements of science cannot even in principle be verified as universal generalizations, and so are meaningless. Or at least their meaning depends on the soundness of some principle of induction that Popper (1959, p. 40) claimed does not exist: ‘‘This inference to theories, from singular statements which are ‘verified by experience’ (whatever that may mean), is logically inadmissible. Theories are, therefore, never empirically verifiable.’’
34
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
In the well-known Popperian view, scientific knowledge consists of networks of singular as well as universal hypotheses that imply observations that can be tested (an excellent discussion on empiricism is found in Churchland, 1989, pp. 259–276; also her 2002 text, chap. 6; also GodfreySmith’s (2003) splendid introduction to the philosophy of science). The principle of falsification means that at best hypotheses can be falsified but they cannot be confirmed. Popper’s noninductive, hypothetico-deductive model of the growth of knowledge consists of series of conjectures and refutations, and those theories that survive the most severe tests are accepted as the best for the time being. Although Feigl did not accept Popper’s critique of induction, he did accept the hypothetico-deductive model as a powerful device for hypothesizing physical objects. Feigl’s account of scientific knowledge, method, and theory, written in 1953 (see especially pp. 11–12), is easily recognizable today, in that it has served, and continues to serve as the foundation for research in (educational) administration (Evers & Lakomski, 1991), organization theory and behavior (see Pugh et al., 1963), as well as leadership studies (Lakomski, 2005). Briefly, there are three main elements to empiricist theories: 1. A theory is a hypothetico-deductive structure where less general and singular claims, including expected observations, are deduced from more general claims. 2. Theories are justified by meeting certain conditions of empirical testability. If the deduced states of affairs are actually observed, the theory is confirmed. Otherwise it is disconfirmed. Justifying a theory is a matter of showing it has more conformations and fewer disconfirmations than its rivals. 3. All the theoretical terms of a theory must be able to be given operational definitions, that is, admit of some defining measurement procedure. – Evers and Lakomski (1996b, pp. 383–384). The insights developed by Popper regarding scientific theories as composed of networks of hypotheses, and the principle of falsification, were deepened by W. V. Quine (1960, 1963) who argued that falsification is far more complex than presumed by empiricists. Incorporating Pierre Duhem’s earlier insight that hypotheses can never be tested on their own as they are always embedded in a whole theoretical network in which they figure, Quine, in his attack on the analytic/synthetic distinction, argued that the idea that ‘‘crucial experiments’’ would provide decisive answers as to which hypothesis to eliminate was mistaken. The upshot of this is that interpreting experimental results relies on more than the application of simple logical principles, a fundamental problem
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
35
for empiricists regarding confirmation and explanation. The radical implications of what has come to be known as the Duhem–Quine thesis maintains that ‘‘given sufficient imagination, any theory y can be permanently saved from ‘refutation’ by some suitable adjustment in the background knowledge in which it is embedded’’ (Lakatos, 1977, p. 184; Quine, 1963, pp. 42–43). If correct, Quine thought, it makes little sense to speak of the empirical content of an individual statement – especially if it is a statement at all remote from the experiential periphery of the field. Furthermore it becomes folly to seek a boundary between synthetic statements, which hold contingently on experience, and analytic statements, which hold come what may. Any statement can be held true come what may, if we make drastic enough adjustments elsewhere in the system y Conversely, by the same token, no statement is immune to revision. (Quine, 1963, p. 43)
The direct consequence of the Duhem–Quine thesis for the empiricist theory of meaning is dire in that empirical statements do not have empirical consequences of their own. It is whole theories that have empirical consequences rather than individual terms or sentences. Theoretical terms, importantly, acquire their meaning from within the network of theories and laws in which they figure. Simplified though the argument is, it suffices to indicate the manner in which the empiricist dogma of the presumed sharp distinction between analytic statements, deemed true by virtue of meaning (e.g., ‘‘an unmarried man is a bachelor’’), and synthetic statements, deemed true in virtue of the facts (e.g., ‘‘whales are mammals’’) came to founder. As can also be seen now, it raised substantial problems for what were presumed solid epistemological foundations for science. An essential feature of logical empiricism was the assumption that observation sentences are the secure foundations upon which the edifice of knowledge could be erected. Indeed, the Justified True Belief (JTB) account of knowledge, assumed by logical empiricism, is easily conflated with foundationalism in epistemology because the traditional notion of justification, deriving from Plato, assumes justification takes the form of a regress of reasons, in this case a regress back to empirical foundations (unlike Plato’s regress back to innate ideas) (Armstrong, 1973). Foundationalism (or foundationalist theories of justification) comprises a number of theories of knowledge that assume that there are secure foundations to knowledge from which we can confidently derive all knowledge (for critical discussion, see Williams, 1977). Such foundations were believed to range from sense data, firstperson sensory reports, to observation statements. These had to be secure for if they were not then no knowledge could be derived from them. (For an
36
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
overview see Evers & Lakomski, 1991, 2000, pp. 1–8.) As we saw in the preceding, given that observation sentences themselves contain theoretical terms, and given Quine’s argument that even sentences at the observation level may need to be revised for overall coherence and explanatory power, then observation sentences are not the secure foundation they were believed to be. Therefore, they cannot serve as the bedrock of science since any doubt about the security of the foundations serves to undermine the theoretical superstructure of science built upon it. This realization, further explored by philosophers of science such as Feyerabend (1963), Churchland (1989, 2002), Hanson ([1958] 1971, 1981), and Hesse (1970), is commonly acknowledged as confirming the collapse of the empiricist conception of the structure of knowledge. There is no theory-free way of seeing the world (e.g., Quine, 1951, 1969; Sellars, 1968; Hooker, 1975; Williams, 1977; Quine & Ullian, 1978; BonJour, 1985; Churchland, 1987). As Hanson (1981, pp. 6–7) expressed it, ‘‘People, not their eyes, see. y That Keppler and Tycho do, or do not, see the same thing cannot be supported by reference to the physical states of their retinas, optic nerves or visual cortices: there is more to seeing than meets the eyeball’’ (italics added). In the face of these arguments, the question of how to determine which revisions are justified and which are not is not one that could be answered by empiricism. There are no foundations to knowledge as conceived in empiricism, and the principle of empirical adequacy is insufficient to ‘‘pin’’ any empirical claim. So the philosophical ground was prepared for a new approach to the study of the growth of knowledge.
PARADIGMS AND THEIR POSTMODERNIST COUSINS IN ORGANIZATION THEORY Accepting the results of the Duhem–Quine thesis, Kuhn’s paradigms approach, or P-theory, was formulated specifically as a systematic critique of empiricism, as well as an argument against both logical empiricist and Popperian claims about the growth of scientific knowledge being a rational process. It is this perspective that has increasingly been used to underwrite attacks on objectivity in the sciences, and has furthermore been used to advocate varieties of subjectivism and relativism in organization theory, amongst other disciplines. As noted above, the most famous application of the Kuhnian paradigms perspective in organization theory is Burrell and Morgan’s Sociological Paradigms and Organizational Analysis in 1979. Its impact spread across disciplinary boundaries and it was much admired in educational administration (e.g., Griffiths, 1985), for example.
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
37
Burrell and Morgan identified four paradigms – the interpretive, functionalist, radical structuralist, and radical humanist – that were said to enable the world to be examined ‘‘in terms of four sets of basic assumptions’’ (Burrell & Morgan, 1979, p. 24), each one mapping on to a separate social scientific reality. On this view, A synthesis is not possible, since in their pure forms they are contradictory, being based on at least one set of opposing meta–theoretical assumptions. They are alternatives, in the sense that one can operate in different paradigms sequentially over time, but mutually exclusive, in the sense that one cannot operate in more than one paradigm at any given point in time y. (Burrell & Morgan, 1979, p. 24)
The nature of the relationship between paradigms is clearly oppositional rather than complementary (Evers & Lakomski, 1991, Chap. 9). Looking back to the heated debates their book engendered, Burrell (1997, p. 648) notes somewhat wryly that while the text served to give a voice to all those who opposed the functionalist perspective, it also ‘‘articulated a procrustean approach to stabilizing the field in a somewhat extreme form.’’ Of particular concern to the critics, Burrell notes, was the notion of paradigm incommensurability in the absence of any specified ‘‘translation rules.’’ As late as 1997, he defends the incommensurability thesis that is at the ‘‘very centre of the issue of organizational paradigms’’ (Burrell, 1997, p. 650). His reasons are instructive. Not only are the functionalists offended by paradigm incommensurability, but also all those who ‘‘believe in the values of debate, argument, and compromise’’ y What they ‘‘fail to understand is that one of the few lessons of history, in things epistemological, is that despite the best endeavours of many able minds the dream of translation remains just that’’ (Burrell, 1997, p. 650). And indeed it does, not because of the impossibility of devising translation rules but because it is the very notion of a paradigm that is the problem. As has often been noted, the term ‘‘paradigm’’ has been used freely and often indiscriminately in social science discussions, in part aided by the fact that Kuhn himself used it in at least twenty-two different ways (in his original 1962 text The Structure of Scientific Revolutions), as Masterman (1977) has pointed out. Following various critical discussions, Kuhn published revisions, some substantial as regards his original theory (Kuhn, 1970, 1974; Lakatos & Musgrave, 1977, present many of the central debates). Nevertheless, paradigms remain (strongly) incommensurable (Kuhn, 1962, pp. 109–110). They are claimed to contain within themselves both substantive theories but also the very standards and criteria for their evaluation, that is, paradigmspecific epistemologies. It follows that there is no privileged independent epistemic vantage point from which different paradigms could be assessed.
38
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
Attempting to evaluate the merits of paradigm rivals, Kuhn (1962, p. 150) notes, means that their advocates ‘‘practise their trade in different worlds.’’ Particularly instructive is his view on the transfer of allegiance from one paradigm to another that he describes as ‘‘a conversion experience that cannot be forced’’ (p. 151), and that happens ‘‘like a gestalt switch just because it is a transition between incommensurables’’ (p. 150). So what accounts for the growth of scientific knowledge is, in the end, just a change of heart. There has been much criticism of the paradigms theory, and while it continues to flourish in social science research such as education and organization theory, in contemporary postpositivist philosophy of science the paradigm theory is widely regarded as false (see Suppe´, 1974). The view that paradigm diversity in organization theory is its ‘‘normal state’’ (Burrell, 1997, p. 648) rather than a ‘‘y zoological garden [of organizational theorists] y crowded with a bewildering variety of specimens’’ (Perrow, cited in Marsden & Townley, 1997, p. 659) simply amounts to an act of faith. But now suppose we changed our minds and came to believe the opposite, for example, that the functionalist paradigm is right after all. If so, we would have come by this new view as the result of a conversion experience. The upshot of that is that neither view can be judged to be any better or truer than the other; each incommensurable paradigm is reckoned equally legitimate; any choice is a matter of subjective taste. It follows, inter alia, that the paradigms view is hardly in a position to challenge a competitor, such as a realist view of organization theory. Paradigm or theory choice, in the idiom of contemporary youth, turns out to be a case of ‘‘Whatevery.’’ As Kuhn rightly saw, there is no theory-free way of seeing the world, and interpreting our experience is what we need to do to get around. But he overshot the mark in his conclusion that therefore there is no adequate objective standard of reality, and that all theories are evidentially equivalent, or equally reasonable. Just as there is ‘‘more to seeing than meets the eyeball’’ (Hanson), there is more to evidence than observation (empirical adequacy). As we noted earlier, empirical adequacy is only one epistemic virtue among others that together constitute coherence criteria, which in turn establish global excellence of theory. It is the resultant theory itself that tells us what there is and whether the theory’s sentences match up with posited reality (Quine, 1960). This is an important point that needs emphasizing: the coherence theory of evidence needs to do its work first, and only after it has done that can any correspondence between the theory’s sentences and the posited reality be established. It is in this manner that the coherence theory of evidence is differentiated and separated from a correspondence theory of truth that is not some kind of a priori construct, as stipulated in
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
39
foundationalist theories of knowledge, and apparently accepted as valid by theorists of Kuhnian or postmodern persuasion. It is now possible to see why the theory of paradigms drew too radical a conclusion from the theoryladenness of observation. But there is another serious objection to P-theory regarding incommensurability. On its own account, terms and concepts are paradigm specific, that is, their meaning is determined by the role they play within a network of theories that is specific to a paradigm. In other words, P-theory assumes a conceptual role theory of meaning. So when conceptual schemes and theories differ substantially, it is not possible to compare concepts or terms because they mean different things in each paradigm. Although terms such as ‘‘truth’’ or ‘‘validity’’ are orthographically identical across paradigms, their meaning is equivocal given the different conceptual schemes in which they function. Hence a comparison is not possible. The trouble is that Kuhn entertained an extreme version of the theory. If the meaning of terms and concepts is completely determined by the embedding theoretical framework, that is, by conceptual role, then incommensurable theories cannot be learnt. The key here is a modest and often overlooked evolutionary fact: humans are finite learners who have to begin learning somewhere. We need a ‘‘way in’’ to some complex interconnected vocabulary like a theory. But on Kuhn’s account there is no way of doing that. In order to learn some modest expressions of the theory, P-theory requires that we already understand the whole paradigm and therefore know what conceptual role the expressions play. But we cannot know the whole without first knowing the parts, and it is here that the theory of meaning outruns its own epistemological resources: ‘‘it posits learned antecedents of learning that cannot themselves be learnt’’ (Evers & Lakomski, 1991, p. 230). To put the matter differently, the conceptual role theory of meaning, firstly and correctly, implies a theory of the mind, but, secondly and incorrectly, assumes that the mind possesses superhuman powers. P-theory comes out unknowable on its own account of knowledge, lacks explanatory power in relation to its rivals, and is inconsistent. Of course, one may choose to ignore such lack of theoretical virtues. But it turns out that theorists of any ilk, postmodern ones included, have tended to refrain from playing fast and loose with such virtues as consistency, for instance, since inconsistent arguments sanction just about any conclusion whatsoever and therefore seriously undermine their own points of view. Although we offer different reasons, we side with Pfeffer (1993) that paradigm diversity equals fragmentation and needs to be overcome (also McKelvey, 1997, 1999). But unlike him, we urge continuing debates about
40
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
basic philosophical–epistemological issues for, as we have seen, their foreclosure in the paradigms perspective actively prevents the growth of organization knowledge. This can be seen even more clearly in the diverse collection of perspectives gathered under the heading of postmodern organization theory. Postmodern organization theory, so called, is often described as the most radical version representing the contemporary antiscience (‘‘science’’ ¼ positivism) stance in the social sciences including organization theory. What marks this perspective as extreme is that while Kuhn maintains a notion of empirical justification albeit relative to paradigms, postmodernist theoreticians follow Rorty (1980, chap. 4) who goes further than Kuhn and rejects the very idea of empirical justification altogether. As a result, the conception of theory as representing something real in the world disappears. The shift from Kuhnian paradigms to postmodernism is thus a shift from multiple truths to no truth at all. As we noted earlier, representation disappears, as does the fiction/nonfiction distinction. Like Joseph’s multicolored dream coat, postmodernism is difficult to describe. Indeed, there seem to be as many accounts as there are advocates writing under this banner (see Chia, 2005; Hatch & Yanow, 2005; Deetz, 2003; Gergen, 2003; Alvesson & Deetz, 1997; Hatch, 1997; Marsden & Townley, 1997; Burrell, 1997; Clegg, 1990; Cooper & Burrell, 1988). Despite different emphases, there are a number of shared commitments we take to be characteristic of the postmodern position, such as the philosophy of presence, the rejection of representation, essentialism and foundationalism, as well as the idea of metanarratives. To be added are Foucault’s argument for the power/knowledge nexus, the primacy of discourse, deconstruction, and the so-called ‘‘death of the subject’’ (Baack & Prasch, 1997; Foucault, 1978). Here we want to draw attention only to some problems that betray analytic philosophical roots. (1) Simplifying a complex set of issues the postmodernist position holds that an object only exists for us insofar as we have a word for it and a set of constitutive practices and social relations. Hence, what matters is the relational nature of object construction, rather than the object itself and its properties. Anything can be constructed as many different objects, meaning is never fixed. Language is not, as Rorty (1980) pointed out, ‘‘the mirror of nature,’’ and science is just one story among many, possible ones, without any privileged standing. We might just note the unexceptional fact here that words (and what they denote) first have to be learned. This humble point applies to learning about our social–organizational and natural environments as much as it does to our
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
41
inner states, such as our beliefs, intentions, and purposes. The notion that words, and discourse itself, are just ‘‘given’’ reflects a particular epistemic notion that appears in many guises and includes both the foundationalist notion of knowledge discussed earlier as well as the idea that humans have privileged, that is, unmediated, access to the contents of their own minds (for extended discussion of introspectivism see Churchland, 1988; on the notion of the ‘‘given’’ see Sellars’ 1968, famous critique). However, our knowledge even of the mundane rests on a rich network of background theories, a vast amount of prior knowledge that we first had to acquire. Postmodernism’s theory of mind simply postulates learned antecedents of learning that cannot themselves be learned. (2) The concept of the decentered self is developed in opposition to the Cartesian notion of an autonomous self, a human actor in possession of meanings and intentions, able to make rational decisions; that is, a being with a mind. This ‘‘atomistic view’’ (Chia, 2005, p. 120) has been split asunder in postmodernism as language has displaced the structure of the Cartesian unconscious in its emphasis on textual and discursive fields. It is by means of language that the actor is positioned in the world, and it is the discourses in which actors always find themselves that determine their human subjectivities and identities at any given time in history (Foucault, 1972, 1977, 1980). Constituted thus, the self is decentered and fragmented. As Baack and Prasch (1997, p. 139) declare, ‘‘The ‘atom’ of the human subject, like the atom of physics, has been found not to have a hard shell at all.’’ Let us note for the moment that it is a big leap from ‘‘no hard shell’’ to no shell at all, a leap we address later. The postmodernist thesis that the subject is constructed entirely by discourse, what we might call the strong thesis of discursive construction, we believe to be false. There is, however, nothing objectionable about a weaker version of discursive construction. We gendered beings all grow up in one, or perhaps several, languages, in one or several countries, regions, socioeconomic groups or classes, political systems, and in this way form our identities, or our ‘‘theories of the world,’’ as Quine put it. These in turn both facilitate and set limits to what we know and what we can say. The strong thesis is quite odd in denying any inner dimension, and even more odd in negating a person’s physical body. Such treatment amounts to reducing a human being to ‘‘a creation, construct, or ‘effect’ of social discourses,’’ as Strauss and Quinn (1997, p. 28) put it. This view of the decentered subject does little to overcome the Cartesian notion of the autonomous ‘‘thinking thing,’’ rooted in the primacy of
42
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
language, more specifically the manipulation of the symbol systems of mathematics and logic, that were reckoned the essential feature of being human, and being radically separate from body and world (for critical discussions see Clark, 2001, 1997; Dennett, 1996; Fetzer, 1996; Churchland, 1995). While Descartes at least maintained the distinction between mind, body, and world, albeit in the form of substance dualism (Churchland, 1988), in postmodernism there is no inner dimension and thus no distinction to be maintained; identity, following Foucault, is performance. Better, that is, more coherent ways to explain the postmodernist claim of the decentered subject that acknowledge humans as skilled language users and restore to them their inner domain of feeling, wanting, and thinking, are provided by contemporary neuroscience that is building explanations concerning the plasticity and durability of the mind/brain, and thus the construction of the self over time (e.g., Clark, 2008, 2001; Damasio, 1996; Le Doux, 2002; Lakoff & Johnson, 1999; Churchland, 1993).
PHILOSOPHICAL ANSWERS AND SCIENTIFIC SOLUTIONS: NATURALISM AND ORGANIZATION THEORY In the previous section, we have endeavored to show why the paradigms perspective and its postmodernist successor stand in direct line of descent from the descriptive tradition of analytic philosophy. In this tradition philosophy ‘‘leaves everything as it is’’ as Wittgenstein remarked (Philosophical Investigations, Section 124). Despite its radical pretensions, postmodernism is deeply conservative in that it implies a strong form of epistemological relativism. This relativism, however, is the familiar artifact of taking logical empiricist foundationalist modes of knowledge justification as the only game in town for objectivity, and finding them wanting. Taking our cue from Quine’s work, we have endeavored to demonstrate why this view is mistaken. The theoretical fragmentation in organization theory, we argued, is largely attributable to its continued reliance on both strands of analytic philosophy: the more prominent, descriptive mode via paradigm proliferation, and the less overt, revisionist strand, as continued in Donaldson’s work, for example. Therefore, the cause of theoretical fragmentation is not located in ‘‘the complex, idiosyncratic nature of organizational phenomenon,’’ as McKelvey (1997, p. 35) claims, but in the philosophical, especially epistemological, machinery applied to study it. This is one important way in which we differ from McKelvey. However, as a most outspoken advocate for a naturalistic
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
43
science of organizations, at a time when such a quest is viewed with suspicion, we applaud his concern with a naturalistic approach to the study of organization. At the same time though, we have reason to doubt that he is able to accomplish this in light of his theoretical commitments that are rooted in the same analytic tradition that has given rise to the antiscience perspectives he rightly rejects. McKelvey’s views (e.g., McKelvey, 1999, 2002) on organization theory are complex, wide ranging, as well as controversial and deserve discussion in their own right. For present purposes, however, we restrict our comments to a central distinction in his work that documents a lingering attachment to empiricist doctrine: the distinction between intentionally and naturally caused behavior, which leads him to postulate the study of firms as quasinatural phenomena (McKelvey, 1997, p. 351). This is one major point of difference between his views and the view advocated here, naturalistic coherentism, that eschews any dualism and offers a robustly naturalist rather than an ‘‘as if’’ account of human and organizational behavior. In order to come to grips with what he calls the idiosyncrasy problem characteristic of organizations, McKelvey suggests that organization theorists have to understand better the tension between the intentionally and naturally caused effects, as well as the transition phenomena that link them. What the latter are awaits specification. In generally accepting Campbellian realism and evolutionary epistemology (Baum & McKelvey, 1999; McKelvey, 1999; McKelvey & Baum, 1999), McKelvey’s commitment to naturalism is evident. But in championing Campbell’s perspective, he also appears committed to what is a fundamental tension in the latter’s conception of science. Campbell, the philosopher, steadfastly held on to the analytic–synthetic distinction (Campbell, 1987, p. 165), a hallmark of empiricist science, while Campbell (1988) the social scientist accepts naturalism via his descriptive evolutionary epistemology (see the collection of some of his most important papers in Methodology and Epistemology for Social Science, especially his 1959, 1974, and 1988 articles; also Campbell, 1991; Lakomski, 1993). Holding both positions simultaneously makes Campbell’s position incoherent and his naturalism incomplete. Insofar as McKelvey accepts it, his position suffers the same fate. To see more clearly what the problem is, consider the example of juggling that McKelvey (1997, p. 351) introduces as ‘‘a perfect example of quasi-natural phenomena.’’ The ‘‘natural’’ part of the juggling act is said to set in once the balls have left the juggler’s hands and are in the air where they obey ‘‘well understood Newtonian laws’’ while the ‘‘intentional’’ part lies in the movement of the hands, which are under the (intentional) control of the juggler.
44
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
The claim of intentionality, or more generally, of the nature of mental (internal) phenomena as in principle different from natural, external, phenomena is a complex one, has a long and distinguished history, and does not admit of easy answers (e.g., Godfrey-Smith, 2004; Clark, 2001, chap. 3; Churchland, 1988). Broadly speaking, what is at issue are two sets of facts, as Godfrey-Smith (2004, p. 149) encapsulates them: (1) Facts about wiring and organization of behaviorally complex organisms, and the connections between their wiring and the world around them y (2) Facts about our actual practices of interpretation and ascription of content y How these two sets are connected is an issue to which different answers can, and have been, given. One of the reasons for why we opt for a naturalistic (neuroscientific) rather than folk psychological account of our internal structure is to do with the notion of evidence for nonobservables, such as mental phenomena. In McKelvey’s example, what would possibly count as evidence for the claim that ‘‘the movements of the hands’’ while passing balls from one to the other is attributable to, or caused by, intention? McKelvey’s account of scientific method is in principle incapable of answering this as it relies on the (empiricist) justification logic (including prediction, generalization, and falsifiability, inter alia drawing on Hempel, 1965) with its attendant principle of empirical adequacy that stipulates that evidence ¼ observation. The claim that intentions (or any other mental, folk psychological item) may be the relevant causal agents that ‘‘make’’ the balls move from hand to hand outruns the scientific machinery McKelvey has available to support it. No matter how commonsensical or intuitively true the folk psychological items of beliefs and intentions may appear to be, they don’t stack up in light of current neuroscientific accounts of what goes on in our heads, or minds/brains, as the case is sometimes put. Physical bodies, complete with juggling hands, are enmeshed in and subject to the physical forces that determine the ways they are able to behave, and there is no inprinciple distinction to be drawn between internal states and external behaviors. In other words, the explanation of mental phenomena – the structure of the mind – is not quarantined from a naturalistic scientific account of all human behavior (e.g., Evers & Lakomski, 1991, pp. 130–134). Indeed, the folk psychological account of mental phenomena has been described as a ‘‘radically false account of the cognitive activity of humans y a thoroughgoing misrepresentation of what really takes place inside us’’ (Churchland & Churchland, 1998, p. 40). We are inclined to concur.
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
45
While we agree with the naturalist-realist direction McKelvey pursues, a quasi-naturalistic approach, as briefly discussed, neither redresses paradigmatic fragmentation, nor does it establish a coherent science of organization. It is not surprising that McKelvey finds it difficult to account for ‘‘idiosyncratic organizational events’’ by application of empiricist justification logic. Indeed, idiosyncrasy will not disappear since even same-type organizations differ subtly ‘‘on the ground’’ in their everyday lives. On a thoroughgoing naturalistic theory of science that is not beholden to the tenets of empiricist conceptions of prediction and generalizability and any form of hypothetico-deductive procedure, organizational phenomena generally are studied from the ground up, where generalizations (if and where they can be had) only happen after the event, that is, after empirical work has been done. Importantly, idiosyncrasy is not sidestepped in our approach but is accepted as the unavoidable (normal) condition of organizational life. Building ‘‘empirically corroborated idealized models’’ (McKelvey, 1997, p. 5) avoids the issue in abstracting from the very problem that is in need of explanation. In contrast, naturalistic coherentism, the position we advocate, does offer a way forward in rethinking the issues that gave rise to McKelvey’s anomalous naturalism. Methodologically, the distinction between intentionally caused behaviors and naturally caused behaviors follows the distinction between descriptive and revisionary analysis. We propose a revisionary approach that can deal with intentionally caused behavior. We begin, by considering another distinction that tracks this divide between understanding and explanation. Traditionally, revisionary accounts of explanation have been heavily influenced by Hempel’s covering-law model. On this model, a phenomenon is said to be adequately explained when its description can be logically derived from a statement of some initial conditions, together with a law-like generalization. Thus, you can explain the pot of water boiling at 1001C on your kitchen stove by deriving it from (1) under conditions, C, all water boils at 1001C and (2) conditions C (e.g., the water is at sea level, it contains no impurities, etc.) obtain. Also known as the deductive-nomological, or D-N, model, it eventually came to grief for a simple logical reason. Here’s the problem. Using the D-N model, we can explain the length of a flagpole shadow by logically deducing it from information that includes the length of the flagpole, the position of the sun, the laws of optics, and some trigonometry (Godfrey-Smith, 2003, p. 193). However, the D-N model equally allows us to explain the length of the flagpole from information about the length of its shadow, optics, sun’s position, and trigonometry. Since most people see an asymmetry between
46
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
these cases – you can explain the length of the shadow by appeal to the flagpole’s length, but not the length of the flagpole by appeal to the length of its shadow – the D-N model came to be seen as flawed, or at least in need of further augmentation. But notice that once we move away from logical derivability and toward additional contextual information, for something to count as an explanation looks more like showing how it fits as a claim within some theory, where the criteria for degree of fit are matters to do with overall coherence. Thus, explaining the length of the flagpole would presumably involve consideration of manufacturing specifications and causal processes, whereas explaining the length of the shadow would be simpler and would, more closely, resemble the reasoning in the D-N model. Notice, further, that as we move toward invoking more global considerations in explanation, the distinction between explanation and understanding blurs. We end up with scientific understanding. This is a consequence of a coherentist view of knowledge and its justification. It is revisionary only in the sense that science, where it differs from commonsense understandings, forces revisions on these usual ways of thinking about the world. It is also the source of our naturalism, which is simply scientific naturalism. What then becomes of McKelvey’s intentionally caused behaviors? Our naturalistic response is to follow Dennett’s (1991) advice, at least part of the way. Human behavior, both inside and outside of organizations, is highly patterned rather than largely random. Evidence for nonrandom behaviors exists where we can find a description of the behaviors that is briefer than a description of each individual item of behavior; where we can summarize or compress information about behavior. The most basic, commonsense, or folk-theoretical compression device, is to adopt the ‘‘intentional stance’’ and to see human behavior as deriving from the rational coordination of beliefs and desires. This is an extremely powerful framework for predicting what people will do in many situations. For example, in explaining why X got up and went to the fridge, it suffices for most purposes to say that X desired a beer and X believed that the beer was in the fridge. The main trouble with the intentional stance is that although it is in many cases empirically adequate, it is theoretically shallow. Scientifically minded naturalists want to know more about the causes of beliefs and desires, how they are represented in the brain, what are their causal dynamics as they manifest as rational behavior. The naturalistic coherentist therefore takes an instrumental view of folk-theory, valuing it for its empirical adequacy where it leads to useful predictions of behavior, but seeing its ontology of beliefs and desires as needing to be cashed out in naturalistic terms of the kind that neuroscience is now developing. The distinction between intentionally
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
47
caused and naturally caused behaviors is therefore artificial, pragmatic, and subject to change over time. In ancient times a great many natural phenomena were explained in intentional terms. However, science has gradually dethroned the gods thought responsible for weather, climate, seasons, and the like. Biology dispensed with the ‘‘vital force’’ once thought to be the difference between living and nonliving things, and now neuroscience is beginning to impose its explanatory understanding on ourselves – our thoughts, beliefs, desires, intentions, reasonings, affections, and emotions. Over time, a revisionary language will no doubt emerge for these phenomena too, although whether it passes over into commonsense usage and becomes the new descriptive language is another matter again. It is one of the great strengths of a naturalistic coherentist perspective on methodology that it is able to take advantage of the growth of scientific knowledge rather than to compartmentalize the study of organizations so as to insulate these studies from this source of knowledge.
CONCLUSION In this chapter we have endeavored to map out critically, and in as much detail as was feasible, the contribution of analytical philosophy to the understanding and definition of organization theory and studies. Although philosophy has largely been ‘‘A Connection Untended,’’ as Zelda (1996) observed in his assessment of forty years of ASQ, it has been present from the beginnings of administrative science and organization studies, and has shaped its theoretical and empirical agenda up to the present state. In particular, what has had most impact on the study of organization was the analytical distinction between descriptive and revisionary methods, with the former being characteristic of the understanding of meaning in ordinary discourse, and the latter attending to the complexities of meaning by examining formal systems. As is evident from the literature both analytical approaches still feature in contemporary organization theory. Our solution is to adopt a revisionist approach, following and extending Quine’s double-pronged argument against the analytic/synthetic distinction of classical empiricism and for the theory-ladenness of observation and holism in theorizing. Quine opened the door to more powerful approaches to science in the revisionary tradition, forcing theories to cohere not just with the methods of science but with the content of science as well; such is the consequence of naturalistic coherentist epistemologies. Having the freedom to use knowledge from wherever it can be got, we turn to cognitive
48
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
neuroscience especially that delivers knowledge hand over fist regarding the enormous capacities of the embodied, embedded, and extended human brain (Clark, 2008; Quartz & Sejnowski, 2002; Hutchins, 1996) that, inter alia, is able to acquire language and develop a conception of a self. The advantage we see in such naturalism for organization theory is that claims made for, say, organizational change may not outrun our knowledge of human (and nonhuman) capacities to effect change. If the latter outruns the former, our claims are inconsistent and therefore not justified. This seemingly modest methodological principle exerts a powerful discipline over theorizing while remaining in principle open ended. It has much in common with Dewey’s notion of the ongoing growth of knowledge and adapts Popper’s idea of theory competition. While we have sympathy with Pfeffer’s and others’ request for paradigmatic consensus in the sense of offering a more productive solution to the current theoretical fragmentation in organization theory, we advocate a nondoctrinal, open-ended methodological approach, naturalistic coherentism (Evers & Lakomski, 2000), that supports theory competition (including our own), incorporates the postpositivist superempirical virtues, and remains compatible with the naturalistic constraints imposed by the capacities evolution bestowed upon us. The only commitment initially required is to accept some touchstone, some common ground, whether practical or theoretical, and begin the process of theory evaluation. The theory that satisfies the most number of superempirical virtues is accepted as valid for the time being. Organizational theorizing thus conceived remains principled but open ended, and there is no privileged vantage point from which theory competition is assessed. The proof of the pudding is in the eating, that is in the actual matching up of theories or claims, and no claim or theory is quarantined from the process. It is fair to say that this methodological approach is radically different from any of the approaches we discussed. In our view, it is the one that holds most promise for generating better, more coherent, explanations for organizational phenomena, including the very nature of organization itself.
REFERENCES Alvesson, M., & Deetz, S. (1997). Critical theory and postmodern approaches to organization studies. In: S. R. Clegg, C. Hardy & W. R. Nord (Eds), Handbook of organization studies (pp. 191–218). London: Sage. Argote, L., & Greve, H. R. (2007). A behavioural theory of the firm – 40 years and counting: Introduction and impact. Organization Science, 18(3), 337–349. Armstrong, D. M. (1973). Belief, truth and knowledge. London: Cambridge University Press.
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
49
Augier, M., March, J. G., & Sullivan, B. N. (2005). Notes on the evolution of a research community: Organization studies in Anglophone North America, 1945–2000. Organization Science, 16(1), 85–95. Ayer, A. J. (1936). Language, truth and logic. London: Cambridge University Press. Baack, D., & Prasch, T. (1997). The death of the subject and the life of the organization. Journal of Management Inquiry, 6(2), 131–141. Baum, J. A. C., & McKelvey, B. (Eds). (1999). Variations in organization science. In honor of Donald T. Campbell. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Blumberg, A. E., & Feigl, H. (1931). Logical positivism: A new movement in European philosophy. Journal of Philosophy, 28(11), 281–296. BonJour, L. (1985). The structure of empirical knowledge. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Boulding, K. E. (1956). General systems theory – The skeleton of science. Management Science, 2(3), 197–208. Burrell, G. (1997). Normal science, paradigms, metaphors, discourses and genealogies of analysis. In: S. R. Clegg, C. Hardy & W. R. Nord (Eds), Handbook of organization studies. London: Sage. Burrell, G., & Morgan, G. (1979). Sociological paradigms and organizational analysis. London: Heinemann. Campbell, D. T. (1987). Neurological embodiments of beliefs and the gaps in the fit of phenomena to noumena. In: A. Shimony & D. Nails (Eds), Naturalistic epistemology (pp. 165–192). Boston: D. Reidel. Campbell, D. T. (1988). Methodology and epistemology for social science – Selected papers. In: E. S. Overman (Ed.), Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Campbell, D. T. (1991). Coherentist empiricism, hermeneutics, and the commensurability of paradigms. In: G. Lakomski (Ed.), Beyond paradigms: Coherentism and holism in educational research. Special Issue of the International Journal of Educational Research, 15(6), 587–597. Chia, R. (2005). Organization theory as a postmodern science. In: H. Tsoukas & C. Knudsen (Eds), The Oxford handbook of organization theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Churchland, P. M. (1985). The ontological status of observables: In praise of the superempirical virtues. In: P. M. Churchland & C. Hooker (Eds), Images of science. Chicago: Chicago University Press. Churchland, P. M. (1988). Matter and consciousness. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Churchland, P. M. (1993). A neurocomputational perspective. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Churchland, P. M. (1995). The engine of reason, the seat of the soul. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Churchland, P. S. (1987). Epistemology in the age of neuroscience. The Journal of Philosophy, 84(10), 544–553. Churchland, P. S. (1989). Neurophilosophy: Towards a unified science of the mind/brain. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Churchland, P. S. (2002). Brain-wise. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Churchland, P. M., & Churchland, P. S. (1998). On the contrary. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Clark, A. (1997). Being there: Putting brain, body, and world together again. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Clark, A. (2001). Mindware. New York: Oxford University Press. Clark, A. (2008). Supersizing the mind. New York: Oxford University Press.
50
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
Clegg, S. R. (1990). Modern organizations: Organization studies in the postmodern world. London: Sage. Clegg, S. R., Hardy, C., & Nord, W. R. (Eds). (1997). Handbook of organization studies. London: Sage. Cooper, R., & Burrell, G. (1988). Modernism, postmodernism and organizational analysis: An introduction. Organization Studies, 9(1), 91–112. Cyert, R. M., & March, J. G. (1963). A behavioural theory of the firm. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Damasio, A. R. (1996). Descartes’ error. London: Macmillan. Deetz, S. (2003). Reclaiming the legacy of the linguistic turn. Organization, 10(3), 421–429. Dennett, D. C. (1991). Real patterns. Journal of Philosophy, 88(1), 27–51. Dennett, D. C. (1996). Kinds of minds. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson. Donaldson, L. (1985). In defence of organization theory: A reply to the critics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Donaldson, L. (1996). For positivist organization theory: Proving the hard core. London: Sage. Donaldson, L. (2005). Organization theory as a positive science. In: H. Tsoukas & C. Knudsen (Eds), The Oxford handbook of organization theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Evers, C. W., & Lakomski, G. (1991). Knowing educational administration. Oxford: Elsevier. Evers, C. W., & Lakomski, G. (1996a). Science in educational administration: A postpositivist conception. Educational Administration Quarterly, 32(3), 379–402. Evers, C. W., & Lakomski, G. (1996b). Exploring educational administration. Oxford: Elsevier. Evers, C. W., & Lakomski, G. (2000). Doing educational administration. Oxford: Elsevier. Feigl, H. (1953). The scientific outlook: Naturalism and humanism. In: H. Feigl & M. Brodbeck (Eds), Readings in the philosophy of science. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts. Feigl, H. (1974a). No pot of message. In: H. Feigl (Ed.), Inquiries and provocations: Selected writings 1929–1974. Boston: Reidel. Feigl, H. (1974b). The power of positivistic thinking. In: H. Feigl (Ed.), Inquiries and provocations: Selected writings 1929–1974. Boston: Reidel. Fetzer, J. H. (1996). Philosophy and cognitive science. New York: Paragon House. Feyerabend, P. K. (1963). How to be a good empiricist. In: B. Baumriu (Ed.), Philosophy of science. The Delaware seminar. Newark: University of Delaware Press. Foucault, M. (1972). The archaeology of knowledge. New York: Harper & Row. Foucault, M. (1977). Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison (A.S. Smith Trans.). New York: Random House. Foucault, M. (1978). A history of sexuality (Vol. 1). New York: Vintage Books. Foucault, M. (1980). In C. Gordan (Ed.), Power and knowledge: Selected interviews and other writings (C. Gordan, L. Marshall, J. Mephan & K. Soper Trans.). New York: Pantheon Books. Gellner, E. ([1959] 1979). Words and things. New York: Routledge. Gergen, K. J. (2003). Beyond knowing in organizational inquiry. Organization, 10(3), 453–455. Giddens, A. (1984). The constitution of society. Cambridge: Polity Press. Godfrey-Smith, P. (2003). Theory and reality: An introduction to the philosophy of science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Godfrey-Smith, P. (2004). On folk psychology and mental representation. In: H. Clapin, P. Staines & P. Slezak (Eds), Representation in mind: New approaches to mental representation (pp. 147–163). Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
51
Greenfield, T. B. (1975 [1993]). Theory about organization: A new perspective and its implications for schools. In: T. B. Greenfield & P. Ribbins (Eds), Greenfield on educational administration: Towards a humane science. London: Routledge. Griffiths, D. E. (1985). Theories: Past, present and future. In: D. E. Griffiths (Ed.), Administrative theory in transition. Geelong: Deakin University Press. Hanson, N. R. (1971). Observation and explanation. New York: The Free Press. Hanson, N. R. (1981). Patterns of discovery. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Hatch, M. J. (1997). Organization theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Hatch, M. J., & Yanow, D. (2005). Organization theory as an interpretive science. In: H. Tsoukas & C. Knudsen (Eds), The Oxford handbook of organization theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Hempel, C. G. (1965). Aspects of scientific explanation and other essays in the philosophy of science. New York: The Free Press. Hesse, M. (1970). Duhem, Quine and the new empiricism. In: G. N. A. Vesey (Ed.), Knowledge and necessity. London: Macmillan. Hollis, M. (2003). Philosophy of social science. In: N. Bunnin & E. P. Tsui-James (Eds), The Blackwell companion to philosophy. Oxford: Blackwell. Hooker, C. A. (1975). Philosophy and meta-philosophy of science: Empiricism, popperianism and realism. Synthese, 32, 177–231. Hutchins, E. (1996). Cognition in the wild. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Katz, D., & Kahn, R. L. (1978). The social psychology of organizations (2nd ed.). New York: Wiley. Kuhn, T. S. (1962). The structure of scientific revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Kuhn, T. S. (1970). Postscript – 1969. In: T. S. Kuhn (Ed.), The structure of scientific revolutions (2nd ed., enlarged). Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Kuhn, T. S. (1974). Second thoughts about paradigms. In: F. Suppe´ (Ed.), The structure of scientific theories. Chicago: University of Illinois Press. Lakatos, I. (1977). Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes. In: I. Lakatosand & A. Musgrave (Eds), Criticism and the growth of knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Lakatos, I., & Musgrave, A. (Eds). (1977). Criticism and the growth of knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Lakoff, G., & Johnson, M. (1999). Philosophy in the flesh. New York: Basic Books. Lakomski, G. (Ed.). (1991). Beyond paradigms: Coherentism and holism in educational research. Special Issue of the International Journal of Educational Research, 15(6), 499–597. Lakomski, G. (1993). The incomplete naturalist. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 25(6), 553–567. Lakomski, G. (2005). Managing without leadership. Oxford: Pergamon/Elsevier. Le Doux, J. (2002). Synaptic self. New York: Penguin. March, J. G., & Simon, H. A. (1958). Organizations. New York: Wiley. Marsden, R., & Townley, B. (1997). The owl of Minerva: Reflections on theory in practice. In: S. R. Clegg, C. Hardy & W. R. Nord (Eds), Handbook of organization studies. London: Sage. Masterman, M. (1977). The nature of a paradigm. In: I. Lakatos & A. Musgrave (Eds), Criticism and the growth of knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. McCauley, R. N. (Ed.) (1996). The Churchlands and their critics. Oxford: Blackwell. McKelvey, B. (1997). Quasi-natural organization science. Organization Science, 9, 351–381.
52
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
McKelvey, B. (1999). Self-organization, complexity catastrophe, and microstate models at the edge of chaos. In: J. A. C. Baum & B. McKelevey (Eds), Variations in organization science. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. McKelvey, B. (2002). Postmodernism vs. truth in management theory. In: E. Locke (Ed.), Post: modernism & management: Pros, cons, and alternatives. Amsterdam: Elsevier. McKelvey, B., & Baum, J. A. C. (1999). Donald T. Campbell’s evolving influence on organization science. In: J. A. C. Baum & B. McKelevey (Eds), Variations in organization science. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Perrow, C. (1973). The short and glorious history of organizational theory. Organizational Dynamics, Summer, 2–15. Pfeffer, J. (1993). Barriers to the advance of organizational science: Paradigm development as a dependent variable. Academy of Management Review, 18(4), 599–620. Popper, K. (1959). The logic of scientific discovery (second edition, 1968). New York: Harper and Row. Preston, A. (2006). Analytic philosophy, The internet encyclopaedia of philosophy. Available at http://www.iep.utm.edu/a/analytic.htm Pugh, D. S., Hickson, D. J., Hinings, C. R., Macdonald, K. M., Turner, C., & Lupton, T. (1963). A conceptual scheme for organizational analysis. Administrative Science Quarterly, 8(3), 289–315. Quartz, S. R., & Sejnowski, T. J. (2002). Liars, lovers, and heroes. New York: HarperCollins. Quine, W. V. (1951). Two dogmas of empiricism. Philosophical Review, 60, 20–43. (Reprinted in W. V. Quine. (1961). From a logical point of view. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.) Quine, W. V. (1960). Posits and reality. In: S. Uyeda (Ed.), Bases of contemporary philosophy (Vol. 5). Tokyo: Waseda University Press. Quine, W. V. (1963). From a logical point of view. New York: Harper Torchbooks. Quine, W. V. (1969). Epistemology naturalised. In: W. V. Quine (Ed.), Ontological relativity and other essays. New York: Columbia University Press. Quine, W. V., & Ullian, J. S. (1978). The web of belief (2nd ed.). New York: Random House. Reed, M. (1997). Organizational theorizing: A historically contested terrain. In: S. R. Clegg, C. Hardy & W. R. Nord (Eds), Handbook of organization studies. London: Sage. Rorty, R. (1980). Philosophy and the mirror of nature. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Rorty, R. (1992). We anti-representationalists. Radical Philosophy, 60(Spring), 40–42. Ryle, G. (1949). The concept of mind. London: Hutchinson. Searle, J. R. (2003). Contemporary philosophy in the United States. In: N. Bunnin & E. P. TsuiJames (Eds), The Blackwell companion to philosophy. Oxford: Blackwell. Sellars, W. F. (1968). Science, perception and reality. New York: Routledge. Simon, H. A. ([1945] 1976). Administrative behavior (3rd ed.). London: Collier Macmillan. Starbuck, W. H. (2003). Shouldn’t organization theory emerge from adolescence? Organization, 10(3), 439–452. Strauss, C., & Quinn, N. (1997). A cognitive theory of cultural meaning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Strawson, P. F. (1992). Analysis and metaphysics. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Suppe´, F. (Ed.) (1974). The structure of scientific theories. Chicago: University of Illinois Press. Thompson, J. D. (1956). On building an administrative science. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1(1), 102–111.
Analytic Philosophy and Organization Theory
53
Tsoukas, H. (1998). The word and the world: A critique of representationalism in management research. International Journal of Public Administration, 21(5), 781–817. Tsoukas, H., & Knudsen, C. (2005). Introduction: The need for meta-theoretical reflection in organization theory. In: H. Tsoukas & C. Knudsen (Eds), The Oxford handbook of organization theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. von Bertalanffy, L. (1973). General systems theory (Revised ed.). New York: George Braziller. Walsh, J. P., Meyer, A. D., & Schoonhoven, C. B. (2006). A future for organization theory: Living in and living with changing organizations. Organization Science, 17(5), 657–671. Weick, K. E. (1979). The social psychology of organizing. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. Williams, M. (1977). Groundless belief. Oxford: Blackwell. Winch, P. (1958). The idea of a social science and its relationship to philosophy. London: Routledge. Wittgenstein, L. (1953). In: G. H. von Wright and G. E. M. Anscombe (Eds) Philosophical investigations. (G. E. M. Anscombe, Trans.). Oxford: Basil Blackwell. Zald, M. N. (1996). More fragmentation? Unfinished business in linking the social sciences and the humanities. Administrative Science Quarterly, 41, 251–261.
Gabriele Lakomski is a professorial fellow in the Centre for the Study of Higher Education at the University of Melbourne. Her main research interests are in the philosophy and theory of educational administration, administrative science, and in management and organization studies. She is best known for her critical work on leadership and organizational learning, which issued in her book Managing without Leadership (Oxford: Elsevier, 2005). Her research is based on the most recent scientific understanding of how humans acquire information and learn as developed by connectionist cognitive science. Her research program includes the analysis of knowledge management (KM) as a new tool for managing organizational development and change, which draws on the insights of recent cognitive (neuro)science. A member of the Academy of Management, Gabriele Lakomski is a member of the Academy’s Management Education Division. She was a Senior Editor of Organization Studies, and is a member of a number of editorial boards of education and management journals, including Management Learning. She is currently working on the relation between emotion and cognition and how recent neuroscience might contribute to more realistic accounts of decision making. Colin W. Evers is professor of educational leadership at the University of New South Wales, having previously worked at The University of Hong Kong, Monash University, and the University of Sydney. He studied mathematics, philosophy, and education before taking his PhD in philosophy of education at the University of Sydney. His teaching and research interests are in educational administration, philosophy of
54
GABRIELE LAKOMSKI AND COLIN W. EVERS
education, and research methodology. He has coedited and coauthored six books on educational administration, including Knowing Educational Administration, Exploring Educational Administration and Doing Educational Administration (all written with Gabriele Lakomski and published by Pergamon/Elsevier), and many papers in his areas of research interest. He serves on numerous editorial boards and has also been coeditor of the journal International Studies in Educational Administration, the official journal of the Commonwealth Council for Educational Administration and Management. His main ongoing research project has been the application of a naturalistic, coherentist epistemology to the development of a systematic view of theory in educational administration. Ideas from this research project have been discussed in detail in Special Issues of the journals Educational Management and Administration, Journal of Educational Administration and Educational Administration Quarterly. His most recent research is about leadership.
PRAGMATISM: A LIVED AND LIVING PHILOSOPHY. WHAT CAN IT OFFER TO CONTEMPORARY ORGANIZATION THEORY? Bente Elkjaer and Barbara Simpson ABSTRACT In the past, critics have dismissed American Pragmatism as intellectually naı¨ve and philosophically passe´, but in this chapter we argue that it still has much to offer the field of organization studies. Pragmatism is especially relevant to those organizational scholars who are concerned with understanding the dynamic processes and practices of organizational life. This chapter lays out the historical development of Pragmatism, recognizing the originating contributions of Peirce, James, Dewey and Mead. Although each of these writers developed unique philosophical positions, their ideas are all permeated by four key themes: experience, inquiry, habit and transaction. The interplay between these themes informs a temporal view of social practice in which selves and situations are continuously constructed and reconstructed through experimental and reflexive processes of social engagement. We then use organizational learning theory as an example to illustrate the relevance of these four themes, contrasting the anti-dualistic stance of Pragmatism with the work of Argyris and Scho¨n. Finally we turn to consider Weick’s organizing and Philosophy and Organization Theory Research in the Sociology of Organizations, Volume 32, 55–84 Copyright r 2011 by Emerald Group Publishing Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 0733-558X/doi:10.1108/S0733-558X(2011)0000032005
55
56
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
sensemaking, suggesting that Pragmatism offers three potential foci for further development of these theories, namely continuity of past and future in the present, the transactional nature of social agency and reflexivity in social practices. Similarly we see potential for Pragmatism to productively inform the theorizing of other organizational practices such as identity work, strategy work, emotion work and idea work. Keywords: Pragmatism; practice; organizational learning; sensemaking.
INTRODUCTION Consider what effects, which might conceivably have practical bearings, we conceive the object of our conception to have. Then, our conception of these effects is the whole of our conception of the object. – Charles Sanders Peirce (1878, p. 293)
With these words, Peirce heralded a sea change in the philosophy of human thought and reasoning that not only dominated American philosophy for the ensuing half century or so, but also had profound influence in the practical domains of law, education, politics, religion, social theory and the arts. This statement, which has come to be seen as the originating maxim of Pragmatism, suggests that the meaning of ideas resides in the actions that they lead to rather than in their antecedent causes. This principle was subsequently picked up and further developed by William James, who proposed ‘The ultimate test for us of what a truth means is indeed the conduct it dictates or inspires’ (1898, p. 259). Similarly, John Dewey, whose central interest was the nature of knowledge and knowing, emphasized the consequential character of knowledge as ‘an instrument or organ of successful action’ (1908 [1977], p. 180), while George Herbert Mead’s focus on the social dynamics of meaning-making lead him to suggest that if ‘the gesture of a given human organism y indicate[s] to another organism the subsequent (or resultant) behavior of the given organism, then it has meaning’ (1934, p. 76). In all of these, the explicit link between knowledge (or meaning) and action suggests that ideas are more than mere accretions of past experience, but rather, their importance lies in their projected influence on future experiences. Peirce, James, Dewey and Mead are widely regarded as the originators of classical Pragmatism. They were all committed to finding practical ways of accounting for human conduct and meaning-making in all of its dynamic and social complexity. They sought practical solutions to the myriad
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
57
practical problems that arise in lived human experience. By linking knowledge and action, they departed dramatically from the prevailing rationalism of their philosophical times, which they saw as too abstract and too academic to be of practical value. Not surprisingly then, their ideas were greeted with howls of derision from the more rationalist members of the philosophical community. Famously, G. K. Chesterton (1908, p. 62) wrote ‘Pragmatism is a matter of human needs y and one of the first of human needs is to be something more than a pragmatist’, while Bertrand Russell (1961, p. 782) issued the following warning against Pragmatism: y I feel a great danger, the danger of what might be called cosmic impiety. The concept of ‘truth’ as something dependent upon facts largely outside human control has been one of the ways in which philosophy hitherto has inculcated the necessary element of humility. When this check upon pride is removed, a further step is taken on the road towards a certain kind of madness y this intoxication is the greatest danger of our time, and y any philosophy which, however unintentionally, contributes to it is increasing the danger of vast social disaster.
For the Pragmatists, however, these criticisms simply served to confirm their assertion that what people believe to be true is what they find to be useful. James observed: When the pragmatist undertakes to show in detail just why we must defer [to experience], the rationalist is unable to recognize the concretes from which his own abstraction is taken. He accuses us of denying truth; whereas we have only sought to trace exactly why people follow it and always ought to follow it. Your typical ultra-abstractionist fairly shudders at concreteness: other things equal, he positively prefers the pale and spectral. If the two universes were offered, he would always choose the skinny outline rather than the rich thicket of reality. It is so much purer, clearer, nobler. (1907, p. 68)
As with any frame-breaking shift in thinking, Pragmatism has been exposed to endless reinterpretation, its ‘new wine’ often becoming tainted by the ‘old bottles’ of more established paradigmatic perspectives. Many commentators have suggested that Pragmatism’s day in the sun has long gone (e.g. Thayer, 1982), dismissing it as philosophically passe´ and politically naı¨ ve. Others have associated it negatively with the excessively liberal optimism and economic progressiveness of American big business, while a persistent critique has been that Pragmatism lacks sufficient coherence to be deemed a distinctive doctrine or ‘school of thought’. Indeed, Lovejoy distinguished 13 logically independent meanings of Pragmatism from his reading of Peirce, James and Dewey, concluding that ‘the pragmatist is not merely three but many gentlemen at once’ (1963, p. 1). This confusion was further exacerbated by the originators themselves, who never could quite agree on what to call their way of thinking – after James (1898) coined the term ‘pragmatism’, Peirce set about
58
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
distinguishing his ideas from James by calling his own approach ‘pragmaticism’, which he suggested would be a name ‘ugly enough to be safe from kidnappers’ (1905, p. 105). Meanwhile, Dewey preferred the terms ‘experimentalism’ or ‘instrumentalism’ to capture his notion of ideas as playful instruments for experimental action (1925 [1984]), while Mead adopted ‘social behaviourism’ to label his perspective on Pragmatism. In Lovejoy’s view, this lack of a clear and stable definition, let alone a single unifying label, was a fatal flaw that doomed Pragmatism to philosophical insignificance. It has to be said, however, that the originators of Pragmatism never set out to establish a doctrine or a school of thought. Rather, they saw their ideas as a movement or a turn in philosophy that offers a method of inquiry as an empirically grounded way for accessing fresh insights. This movement continues today, as evidenced by a steady stream of new collections and anthologies that have continued to develop Pragmatist ideas through constructive debate and application to real problems (see, e.g. Haack & Lane, 2006, and the international journal Contemporary Pragmatism). This ongoing inquiry is what makes Pragmatism a living, evolving philosophy that is still very much a work in progress. In this sense, it is no different from other relatively recent developments in philosophy, such as phenomenology or analytical philosophy, which are equally difficult to pin down to a clear and unambiguous doctrine. We suggest, therefore, that there is still much to be gained by revisiting the works of the classical Pragmatists and their legacy. This is particularly so in the field of organization studies, which is in the throes of seeking new and creative engagement with the ways that people conduct themselves in organizations and account for their lived experiences of organizational life. What we aim to do in this chapter is to elucidate those aspects of Pragmatist thinking that are particularly relevant to the field of organization studies. In undertaking this task, we must declare that our specific knowledge of Pragmatism is informed primarily by the works of Dewey and Mead. Although we will, of necessity, write from this position, we do not wish to imply any ranking or prioritization of these writers above the others. They are, in our view, all productively mutually informing, and in many ways it makes little sense to make hard distinctions between their ideas. We also acknowledge that our research interests revolve specifically around issues of organizational learning and creativity, which we will draw upon to illustrate our arguments. We will further argue that Pragmatism has great potential to inform organization studies more generally, especially in the theorizing of organizational practices.
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
59
In the next section we begin by laying down an understanding of the context and influences that contributed to the original development of Pragmatism. Then we move on to elaborate four key themes that, we suggest, can usefully inform understandings of the lived and living aspects of organizations and their members. The practical utility of these themes is then discussed in relation to organizational learning theory, where we consider not only learning as socialization but also learning as creative practice. The chapter then moves on to explore the extent to which the influence of Pragmatism can be seen in contemporary organization theory. In particular, we focus on the groundbreaking work of Karl Weick and suggest ways in which his theories of organizing and sensemaking might be further elaborated using Pragmatist thinking.
THE CLASSICAL PRAGMATISTS IN CONTEXT Pragmatism, of course, did not simply spring out of nowhere. The seeds of its emergence can be traced to Anglo-European traditions of philosophy and literature, stretching from Heraclitus and Aristotle to Descartes, Kant and Hegel. The original Pragmatists were also deeply influenced by the scientific developments of their time, including Darwinian evolution and Einsteinian relativity. The intellectual soil that then nurtured these seeds, and which also gave rise to such literary giants as Ralph Waldo Emerson and Thomas Jefferson, was distinctively American in its theological practicality and democratic common sense. America looked forward to a new world of possibilities and backwards at the class-divided social structures of Europe, which privileged traditions and family ties ahead of actions and abilities. The country’s boundaries towards the West were open and fascinating, while at the same time, industrialization and mass production were transforming society. Philosophically, this period was characterized by a multiplicity of contradictions that set science against religion, positivism against romanticism, intuition against empiricism and the democratic ideals of Enlightenment against the traditions of aristocracy. In this context, Pragmatism served as a consensual method of doing philosophy that sought to transcend these many dualisms (Scheffler, 1974). The common ground occupied by the original Pragmatists was sceptical of absolutes and wholes, and of certainties and finalities. They challenged universalist and foundationalist assumptions, suggesting pluralism and evolutionary emergence as more fruitful explanations of our contingent and changeful world. For them, ‘pure experience’ (James, 1912 [2006], p. 19) was
60
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
the source of practical, actionable knowledge. It is through our experimental and reflexive engagement with each other and the natural and social worlds of which we are a part that over time we affirm habits and uncover new insights to inform our ongoing conduct. By these means, we continuously construct and reconstruct meanings of both our worlds and our selves. These characteristic themes frame Pragmatism as a distinctive system of philosophy, which we denote throughout this chapter with a capital ‘P’, to distinguish it from more common parlance in which pragmatism is simply an everyday matter of getting the job done. A pragmatist in this latter sense is someone who is less concerned with meanings and explanations than with results (at whatever cost). This common ground aside, there were significant and persistent differences between Peirce, James, Dewey and Mead. Each made a unique contribution to the emerging philosophy of Pragmatism, leading to a contest of ideas that is still very much alive in the contemporary literature. Let us now briefly examine the distinctiveness of each of these four originators of Pragmatist thinking. Charles Sanders Peirce (1839–1914) was educated as a chemist and worked for much of his life as a scientist, but it is for his extraordinarily innovative contributions to philosophy and logic that he is best remembered. His intellectual reach encompassed philosophical issues as diverse as scientific metaphysics, theology, cosmology and aesthetics, and he is recognized as the founder of modern semiotics, in which the interpretation of signs provides the medium for meaning-making. Although the breadth of his thinking extends beyond Pragmatism, Talisse (2007) argues that Pragmatism nevertheless lay at the heart of his philosophy. Unlike James, Dewey and Mead, however, Peirce never conceived Pragmatism as a philosophy in its own right. Rather he saw it simply as a method to clarify thinking by clearing away obstacles and diversions along the pathway of meaningful inquiry. As is evident in the Pragmatist maxim with which we opened this chapter, Peirce’s method explicitly connects meaning to the conceivably practical consequences of our actions. It is by reflecting on these consequences that we clarify our meanings. For Peirce then, clear reasoning is a continuously evolving process that is inherently creative and aesthetic (Anderson, 1987). He developed the idea of abduction as a way of distinguishing this spontaneous, creative action from deductive and inductive forms of reasoning. Whereas deduction probes the boundaries of thought within a closed system, and induction structures evidence to support the formation of opinions, the abductive process involves the imaginative creation of explanatory hypotheses, generating alternative ‘may-bes’ in response to ‘what if’ inquiries. Ultimately, he argued that all scientific reasoning is dependent upon abductive processing as this is the only
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
61
possible source of novel ideas (Anderson, 1987). In sum, Peirce’s focus on the consequences of action, the abductive generation of alternative futures and the semiotics of meaning-making processes is his abiding contribution to Pragmatist thinking. William James (1842–1910) also began his career as a natural scientist, receiving his PhD in medicine in 1869. His dual interests in psychology and philosophy led him to holding university chairs at Harvard in both disciplines at different times in his career. His intellectual contributions include Principles of Psychology, which is still regularly cited today, and his Essays on Radical Empiricism, which set out a comprehensive critique of the rationalism that dominated philosophical thinking at the turn of the twentieth century. Throughout his work, however, the threads of Pragmatist thinking are always evident. He is often credited as the founder of Pragmatism, having introduced this term in a lecture he delivered in 1898. Although he openly acknowledged Peirce’s work of 20 years earlier as the source and inspiration for his ideas, it was James rather than Peirce who captivated philosophical imaginations. He extended Peirce’s Pragmatist maxim beyond a method of doing philosophy, to become a complete, systematic philosophy that incorporates its own metaphysics, epistemology and ethics. Within this, the connection between ideas and actions as coconstituting aspects of human conduct represents a radical departure from the prevailing idealist, rationalist and empiricist trends in philosophy. James argued that the process of apprehending alternative futures to inform actions in the present necessarily engages the human mind, both cognitively and emotionally (Barbalet, 2004). In effect, James psychologized Peirce’s original conception of Pragmatism, shifting away from the notion that the meaning of a proposition lies purely in its practical consequences to the view that meanings are a matter of believing them to be true (Talisse, 2007). Peirce was vehemently opposed to this revision of the Pragmatist maxim, arguing that it is empirical experience, not belief, that clarifies meanings (1905). The third of the original Pragmatists was John Dewey (1859–1952), who was strongly influenced by Hegelian thinking in his training as a philosopher. His ideas have been influential in many fields, not least education, where he pursued questions relating to the nature of learning and knowledge, and ethical judgement in the formation of moral ideals. Like Peirce, he saw Pragmatism as a method of doing philosophy rather than a solution to philosophical dilemmas. And like James, he also extended Peirce’s Pragmatism, but in quite a different direction. Specifically, Dewey took the embryonic model of inquiry proposed by Peirce (1877) and developed this into a comprehensive theory that frames inquiry as a continuously unfolding
62
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
social process in which meanings are constructed as people engage with each other (Dewey, 1933 [1986], 1938 [1986]). He made much of the continuity of lived experience that links the past and the future through the actions of the present. Reminiscent of Peirce’s notion of abduction, Dewey argued that critical thinking, or inquiry, is a method of generating working hypotheses or ‘warranted assertabilities’, the consequences of which may be tested through either imagination or concrete action. Whereas Peirce saw an individual’s doubt as the starting point for critical thinking, Dewey insisted that it is doubt in the situation that initiates inquiry (Talisse, 2007). In Dewey’s hands then, Pragmatism became a method to think and act in a creative and insightful manner in social situations. George Herbert Mead (1863–1931) was a close colleague and lifelong friend of John Dewey, and also another foundational contributor to the Pragmatist project. He was a social psychologist whose efforts were directed towards developing a philosophically grounded theory of sociality that incorporated the key concepts of process, emergence and evolution (Mead, 1934). Although his intellectual contributions are often conflated with those of Dewey, his unique legacy lies in the elaboration of Peirce’s ideas about the nature of mind, language and signification in understanding the construction of meanings. He argued that people simultaneously construct both their sense of self and their sense of situation in ongoing, symbolically mediated processes of social engagement. He described these processes as cycles of gestures and responses by means of which we come to understand each other’s conduct, and to better anticipate how others might respond to our own actions (1913, 1925). The self that engages in these gestural conversations is ineluctably social and comprised of two interrelated aspects: the objective ‘me’ is the embodied behavioural norms and values of the social groups to which a person claims membership, and the subjective ‘I’ is a person’s spontaneous, performative response to the social conventions and habits represented by the ‘me’. The ‘me’ permits a reflexive attitude towards the self, while the ‘I’ is the principle of action and impulse that introduces uncertainty and the potential for novelty into the processes of the self. It is in the continuous interplay between these two aspects of the social self that meanings are reinforced and constructed afresh. These dimensions complement and add empirical descriptiveness to Dewey’s notion of critical thinking. From the foundations laid down by these four originators, the Pragmatist project has continued to grow and evolve through the works of other early contributors such as Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jane Addams, Clarence Irving Lewis, Charles Horton Cooley and Mary Parker Follett. More recently, widespread interest was reignited by the publication of Richard Rorty’s
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
63
(1980) Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature. What came to be seen as a neoPragmatist revival has been much criticized by followers of the classical Pragmatists as ‘an idiosyncratic, unorthodox, and, in many estimations, perverse vision of what [P]ragmatism is’ (Talisse, 2007, p. 3). Essentially Rorty abandoned experience, which the original Pragmatists had held to be the very stuff of philosophical theorizing, in favour of language and the linguistic turn, especially as it appears in the French literary tradition of Jacques Derrida. Talisse (2007) argued that Rorty’s provocation has created a veritable industry in philosophy to criticize and correct his ‘misguided’ conception of Pragmatism. Principal amongst Rorty’s critics, Hilary Putnam accused him of a cultural relativism that rejects the notion of truth, seeing it as mere self-deception. By contrast, Putnam, who is more informed by the analytical philosophy of science and technology than by literary criticism, emphasized a commitment to warrantable, justifiable forms of knowledge that emerge through the process of inquiry, which is so central to the Pragmatist agenda. This debate between Rorty and Putnam has served to reinstate Dewey as a legitimate contributor to contemporary philosophical discussion, while also reviving interest in Pragmatism more generally. Increasingly, contemporary philosophers are engaging with the important task of lifting Pragmatism beyond its very American roots by reinterpreting it in the context of more recent developments in European philosophy. So, for instance, in America, Richard Bernstein has extensively reworked Dewey’s ideas on practice, ethics and political theory, Mitchell Aboulafia has brought the thinking of Bourdieu and Habermas to bear on Mead, and Richard Posner has built on Oliver Wendell Holmes’ Pragmatist-inspired writings on jurisprudence, while in Europe Hans Joas has deepened understandings of Mead’s notion of creative action. All in all then, it seems that Pragmatism may still have much to offer in today’s world.
FOUR KEY THEMES IN PRAGMATISM In this section we introduce four key themes in Pragmatism, ‘experience’, ‘inquiry’, ‘habit’ and ‘transaction’, all of which have to do with what it means to be human, and how selves and social situations can be seen as mutually informing and co-constructing dynamics. As such, these themes transcend the conventional separation between individual and organizational levels of analysis. They are deeply interwoven and difficult to tease apart, but we must do so here in order to present them in a readable way.
64
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
Our ultimate intention, though, is to consciously and deliberately bring them together as an integrated whole that offers a complete theoretical description of social practices in organizations. We begin with the notion of experience as both active and passive rather than as a mere accumulation of past actions. Then we move to consider inquiry, in which experimental thinking and action develop ideas and concepts that reconstitute the present situation. Next we turn to habits, which are defined in Pragmatism as dispositions towards specific actions. And finally, we discuss the notion of transaction, which is concerned with the social actions that constitute experience and habit and out of which inquiry is derived. Experience Experience is a consistent theme amongst all of the classical Pragmatists. James (1912 [2006]), for instance, rejected the notion of ‘consciousness’ as too diaphanous to have any meaningful function in the development of philosophical first principles. Rather, he argued for a radical empiricism based on the temporal processes of ‘pure experience’ in which the experiential tissue of life is continuous in time. Similarly, Dewey had already laid down the ideas for his later, more mature notion of experience in his 1896 paper, in which he critiqued the way the reflex arc concept in psychology deals with the relationship between knowledge and action (Bernstein, 1966 [1967]; Dewey, 1896 [1972]). He rejected the possibility of understanding human conduct as a mechanistic sequence of sensation, idea and response, which contrives to separate thinking from doing rather than taking both as ‘functional elements in a division of labor which together constitutes a whole’ (Dewey, 1896 [1972], p. 100). He preferred to talk about ‘organic behaviour’ as a basic unit of conduct in which knowledge and action are inseparable processes. Dewey further argued that Darwin’s theory of evolution demanded a complete reconceptualization of experience, not as a mere accretion of past impressions, but as ‘the intercourse of a living being with its physical and social environment’ (1917, p. 6). He saw experience as the experimental activities of organisms as they adapt to, and within, their environments. That is, experience comprises both the passive effects of situations upon selves and the active influences of selves on situations. Dewey elaborated his distinctive notion of experience as follows (1925 [1981]). Firstly, experience is more than just knowledge, and indeed, if experience is defined in purely epistemological terms, then there is a risk of losing sight of the transactional and social dimensions of experience as
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
65
everyday living. Secondly, he strongly refuted the notion that experience is a purely subjective and private affair, which was a prevalent attitude in philosophical circles after Descartes. Dewey argued that all experience has an objective dimension but that ‘sharing experiences’ must be more than a metaphor because shared objective situations are always interlaced with subjective experiences. Thirdly, experience serves a projective and anticipatory function in linking present actions to future expectations; in other words, we live life forwards by projecting our past experiences into our anticipations of the future. It is this connection to the future that underlies all intelligent activity. Fourthly, emphasizing the temporality and continuity of experience, Dewey claimed that it evolves through a continuous series of situations. And finally, although experience is not primarily an epistemological term, it is not possible to think of experience without reasoning because ideas and concepts will always be part of experience. Mead’s contribution to this theme was firstly to elaborate Dewey’s second point of definition above by arguing that experience is necessarily social. From Mead’s perspective, experience can only be understood in terms of sociality: Meaning y arises in experience through the individual stimulating himself to take the attitude of the other in his reaction[s]. (1934, p. 89)
That is, we gain insight into situations by attempting to see them through the eyes of others. In the absence of such common, or shared, experiences of social situations, social order cannot develop. Like Dewey, Mead emphasized the combination of, and interplays between, both passive and active aspects of experience. Further, he argued that because selves are socially constructed, it is not possible to objectively experience the self without social engagements that offer a mirror to reflect the objective self. Experience, then, is the process of constructing and reconstructing meanings of both selves and situations. Recognizing the importance of these social dimensions, Dewey later regretted the many misunderstandings that his description of experience had engendered. In 1951 he wrote to Arthur Bentley (with whom he authored the book Knowing and the Known, 1949 [1991]) that he would have used the term ‘culture’ had he been able to rewrite his book Experience and Nature (Boydston, 1981 [1925]). Consequently, when we use the notion of experience here, we intend it in this broader sense as clearly social, cultural and historical. Mead’s second contribution to this theme was to recognize experience as a temporal flux that is located in the living present, and is informed by both the interpreted past and the projected future. It is in the now that lives are
66
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
lived and meanings are enacted by drawing on the past to anticipate future consequences. The inherently temporal and narrative qualities of social participation cannot be adequately addressed by theories that see time as a mere succession of discrete moments, or what Bergson (1919) referred to as spatialized time. The ‘veritable mountain of fragments and writings’ (Joas, 1997, p. 167) that Mead left on this subject demonstrates the extent to which his later thinking was directed towards the problem of temporality and how it might be integrated into a comprehensive theory of sociality (see, e.g. Mead, 1932, 1938). The key insight for the purposes of our argument here is that experience is constituted through events that emerge in the present out of the continuity of social actions. As people find themselves located between the past and the future, they are obliged to construct new meanings, reconstruing their histories in order to understand the emergent present. These new understandings are projected forward into the future to anticipate and shape the outcomes of present actions, while at the same time themselves being shaped by these anticipations. Ultimately then, experience arises in the continuous interplay between past and future, which informs and gives meaning to social actions in the living present.
Inquiry Both Peirce and Dewey located a certain sort of logic, which they called ‘inquiry’, at the heart of their respective versions of Pragmatism. Peirce described inquiry in terms of a model of doubt and belief, where doubt signals some form of disruption to thinking and action, while belief is the state of resolution that is gained once doubt has been clarified (1877). It is belief that guides us into habitual actions, while doubt raises uncertainties as to the appropriateness of specific actions. Dewey elaborated the notion of inquiry as a response to a specific type of experience, that which arises as an inevitable consequence of the continuous, self-correcting process that he called ‘the experimental habit of mind’ (1910, p. 55): Inquiry is the controlled or directed transformation of an indeterminate situation into one that is so determinate in its constituent distinctions and relations as to convert the elements of the original situation into a unified whole. (1938 [1986], p. 108)
Dewey argued that inquiry in everyday life has the same structure as scientific inquiry. He saw it as a process that starts with a sense that something is wrong and that the normal course of activity cannot proceed uninterrupted. This invites a phase of deliberation that endeavours to
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
67
understand what it is that is wrong, what is the nature of the obstacle to continuing action and what resistance needs to be overcome. Then there is a phase of analysis and diagnosis of the conditions that are creating the impediment to continuing action, followed by thought experiments in which possible solutions are abductively proposed (Dewey, 1933 [1986]). It is in this process that Mead’s subjective ‘I’ comes into play. This is the spontaneous, performative principle of action that introduces variation and novelty into experience. Without the ‘I’, the self’s habits of mind would be entirely determined and bound by collective norms of conduct. Thus, inquiry involves the probing actions of the ‘I’, which are the source of creative potential in human actions (Joas, 1996). The final phase in the inquiry process is to implement the preferred working hypothesis, the results of which then inform another cycle of inquiry (Dewey, 1938). Mead (1938, pp. 3–25) articulated a very similar model of reflexive thinking that comprises four dynamically interdependent phases: an impulse arrests ongoing action when a difference is perceived between the anticipated results of this action, and the results that actually occurred. In other words, there has been a failure to adequately anticipate the consequences of these actions. Then there is a phase of perception, where this mismatch between anticipation and actuality is explored to reveal the conditions that need to be resolved. This is followed by a phase of manipulation during which alternative hypotheses are formed and evaluated. Mead’s cycle then closes with a phase of consummation, in which modified actions are enacted. These models of Dewey and Mead are complementary, both capturing the temporal interweaving of social agency, reflection and experience, and demonstrating the creative potential for new thinking in all social actions. They challenge teleological assumptions that outcomes of actions are, or can be, predetermined; indeed, in a predesigned world there is no space for the expression of human creativity. Inquiry cannot be reduced to a response to purely abstract thoughts because it is anchored in everyday situations. It is part of life to inquire, mull things over, come to conclusions and make evaluations. We do it all the time whether we are aware of it or not. This is how we learn and become cognizant of our world and who we are in this world.
Habit All four of the original Pragmatists were concerned with habit, especially as it relates to inquiry. Peirce (1878) saw habit as a type of action that is repeated in response to recurring situations. It is when these habitual actions
68
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
are disrupted that inquiry may be invoked. James recognized the social significance of habit, describing it as ‘the enormous flywheel of society, its most precious conservative agent’ (1891 [1952], p. 79). Dewey’s notion of habit can be traced to his critique of the reflex arc (1896 [1972]), where his term ‘organic coordination’ may be read as organic habitual conduct. Later, especially in his Human Nature and Conduct, Dewey unfolds his notion of habit as: ‘‘y that kind of human activity which is influenced by prior activity and in that sense acquired; which contains within itself a certain ordering or systematization of minor elements of action; which is projective, dynamic in quality, ready for overt manifestation; and which is operative in some subdued subordinate form even when not obviously dominating activity. (1922 [1988], p. 31)
Habit may be understood then, as ‘a readiness to act overtly in a specific fashion whenever opportunity is presented y [Thus,] the essence of habit is an acquired predisposition to ways or modes of response (y)’ (Dewey, 1922 [1988], p. 32). In other words, habits are acquired dispositions to respond in certain ways in certain circumstances; they allow us to anticipate our own and other persons’ conduct in a given situation, as well as how a situation may unfold. In Mead’s terms, habits are the dispositions that come to be embodied in that aspect of the self he called the objective ‘me’. As such, habits are expressions of social norms of conduct, but at the same time, they are dynamically emergent, admitting the possibilities of mutability and change over time. This position contrasts significantly with more conventional views of habits as rigid and fixed. Mead’s ‘significant symbols’ are also relevant in the context of habits. He defined significant symbols as actions that call out the same response in the gesturer and the responder: they are ‘y nothing but the stimulus whose response is given in advance’ (1934, p. 181). Habits of behaviour make it easier for others to anticipate our actions in given situations, and as such, they contribute to the construction of sociality. It is sociality that provides the insight necessary to be able to anticipate someone else’s responses to our own actions, and thereby to regulate our own conduct in terms of likely outcomes. Significant symbols, then, allow us to see our actions as others might, and to consciously shape the roles that we adopt in different social contexts. In Mead’s view, all human sociality is based on significant symbols and symbolic behaviours such as habits. Dewey further proposed that customs are habits expressed more or less uniformly within any social group in which members are engaged with the same environmental situations. The socialization of new members into a
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
69
group requires these newcomers to incorporate the group’s customs and established modes of transaction into their own habits of action. It is these customs that guide us in terms of acceptable codes of social behaviour including ethical distinctions between virtue and vice, and aesthetic considerations in social activities. In effect, customs are symbolic forms of action by means of which we can communicate cultural expectations of conduct within social groups. Transaction The notion of the social self as a being that is continuously in the making, in effect a becoming, is central to Pragmatism. Both Dewey (1949 [1991]) and Mead (1934) wrote extensively about the intersubjective processes of social engagement by means of which becoming emerges. This is well illustrated by Mead’s discussion of gestural conversations wherein one person’s gesture calls out a response in another person, which in turn calls out a further response, and so on in an ongoing cycle of communication. It is through these communicative processes that we become socialized to any given group of people, we form mutual expectations of conduct, and at the same time we come to understand both self and situation. The social meaning of any given gesture is reflected in the response that it engenders, and as the cycle of gesture and response proceeds the meanings that we construe are either reinforced, challenged or completely disrupted. In other words, our social interactions may be seen as both expressions of habitual conduct and creative, improvisational processes of making new meanings. In his later writing, Dewey sought to make finer distinctions in this process by differentiating between interactions (actions between entities) and transactions (actions across entities) (Dewey & Bentley, 1949 [1991], pp. 112–115). Bernstein explained this distinction as follows: Transaction is a refinement of interaction. In a transaction, the components themselves are subject to change. Their character affects and is affected by the transaction. Properly speaking, they are not independent: they are phases in a unified transaction. Thus transaction is a more rigorous formulation of the category of the organic which is embedded in Dewey’s earliest philosophic writings. Transaction is a generic trait of existence. (1960, p. xl)
When the relation between self and situation is understood in terms of interaction, this implies physically and mentally separated subjects who interact on the basis of specific regularities or principles by means of which they can influence each other. Alternatively, when selves and situations are
70
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
related to each other on the basis of a trans-actional understanding, they may be seen as mutually constituting aspects of an integrated unity. Dewey’s purpose in making this distinction was to separate this Pragmatist notion from the more common usage of ‘interactionism’ in the literature. Returning to Mead’s work, it is now clear that when he used the term ‘interaction’, he was in fact referring to what Dewey later termed a ‘transaction’. The interactants in a gesture/response cycle both shape and are shaped by their interaction. Rather than constructing meanings between themselves, they actually are the emergent meanings. Mead further argued that in any system of inquiry, transactions are not limited to the intersubjective domain. For instance, transactions between the ‘I’ and the ‘me’ function intrapersonally to construct the social self, and once significant symbols arise in a social situation, they facilitate and mediate an extrapersonal level of transactional engagement and meaning-making. Thus, the notion of transaction challenges the more conventional view of social systems operating at various, more or less discrete levels, by promoting instead an understanding of social practices as the continuously emergent weaving together of social selves and social situations. In the next section, we demonstrate how these four key themes in Pragmatism may be used in developing a transactional approach to organizational learning. Then, in the following section, we explore more broadly how Pragmatism might enrich processual understandings of organizations, such as that offered by sensemaking theory.
PRAGMATISM IN ORGANIZATIONAL LEARNING The literature on organizational learning has for many years contained an unfinished debate on whether organizations are able to learn, or whether individuals must learn before their knowledge is somehow transferred to the organization (Cook & Yanow, 1993). In the early literature, organizational learning was defined as individuals’ acquisition of information and knowledge, and later as analytical and communicative skills (Argyris & Scho¨n, 1996; March & Simon, 1958). Scholarly reaction to this understanding has been to take learning out of the purely cognitive domain of individuals’ minds, locating it instead in the processes of participation in organizational communities of practice (Elkjaer, 2003; Lave & Wenger, 1991). Whereas the former is focused upon mental representations, the latter is concerned with the maintenance of organizational practices, in which learning is associated with socialization and the institutionalization of knowledge (Gherardi, 2000).
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
71
From this perspective, however, it is difficult to understand how organizational learning can be creative, innovative and generative of new knowledge and action. An understanding of learning as participation in communities of practice tends, in other words, to overlook the conservativism, protectionism and the tendency to recycle knowledge in organizations, rather than critically challenging and extending it (Fenwick, 2001). A Pragmatist definition of learning (and organizational learning) encompasses all four of the themes outlined above (experience, inquiry, habit and transaction) to frame learning as a social practice that is both creative and habitual, and in which knowledge is necessarily open-ended and fallible. Learning, then, is the acquisition of more varied and complex predispositions to act, through which the world becomes more differentiated and ‘infused with meaning’ (Biesta & Burbules, 2003, p. 37). In other words, Pragmatism has potential to offer new insights into some of the problems in the current literature on organizational learning by conceptualizing learning as: transactional, encompassing all levels of the learning system, rather than one (individual) and then another (organizational); derived from inquiry in which knowledge and action are continuous and co-constituting rather than knowledge/participation followed by action/ practice; not only about socialization (habit) but also about creative practice, where the two are intertwined in real-time experience. To illustrate the benefits of Pragmatism in understanding organizational learning, we now examine a classical piece within the international organizational learning literature, namely the works of Argyris and Scho¨n, who themselves claim to have Pragmatist roots (Argyris & Scho¨n, 1996; Elkjaer & Wahlgren, 2006). Their central concern with ‘actionable knowledge’ is very much in line with Pragmatism (Argyris, 2003). In our view, however, they depart from Pragmatism by retaining a fundamental dualism between knowledge and action, which, in turn, generates an avalanche of further dualisms. For instance, Argyris and Scho¨n see organizational learning as first and foremost a task of individuals because: Organizational learning occurs when individuals within an organization experience a problematic situation and inquire into it on the organization’s behalf. (1996)
When individuals make an inquiry, it can lead them to modify their understanding of the organization. If this individual learning is to turn
72
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
into organizational learning, it must become part of how other individuals understand the organization in terms of organizational routines and stories. Argyris and Scho¨n resolve the problem of transfer between individual and organizational levels by defining the organization as a political entity in which individuals act and learn on behalf of the organization. In our Pragmatist understanding, the relationship between individual and organization is not guided by individuals’ choices but by the transactional interplay between the two. The meanings attached to individuals and organizations are, therefore, highly interdependent and continuously evolving. This transactional approach draws together subjects (individuals), objects (knowledge) and situations into a mutually constituting, dynamic whole. To see organizational learning as fundamentally transactional is to focus on the interplay between selves and situations rather than treating them as discrete levels in the social system. If these levels are treated separately, then we are left with the intractable problem of having to glue them together again. We propose that learning does not begin with either individuals or organizations, but with uncertainties about the situations in which people find themselves. Responses to these uncertainties are guided by habit and the playful experimentation of social selves exploring new ways of defining and solving uncertain situations. The second major dualism in the Argyris and Scho¨n account of organizational learning is the separation of knowledge and action, whereas Pragmatism sees both as integral aspects of inquiry. Argyris and Scho¨n do use the term inquiry but in a way that holds knowledge and action apart rather than integrating the two together. This interpretation of inquiry is underpinned by their understanding of predispositions to act (i.e. habits) as based upon individuals’ ‘theories of action’, which are mental models or representations of actions. In other words, they see selves as theories of action (knowledge) that then guide the actual actions taken. Argyris and Scho¨n further differentiate between theories of action as ‘espoused’ or ‘theories-in-use’, which are, respectively, those theories of action that can be expressed in words and those that can only be inferred from observation of individuals’ actions. Theories-in-use may remain tacit because they are either indescribable (the individuals who enact them are unable, rather than unwilling, to verbally describe the knowledge embedded in their everyday actions) or undiscussable (any attempt to reveal their incongruity with the espoused theory of the organization would be perceived as threatening or embarrassing and, as such, best kept in the quiet). Again, we think that this focus upon mental models fails to show how knowledge (‘the mental’) is always linked to action, and that knowledge
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
73
encompasses action not as a representation but as a disposition towards certain ways to act. If knowledge is conceived in these representational terms, it becomes difficult to see where creativity comes from (i.e. where is the experimental and instrumental playfulness with different solutions to defined problems?). This cognitivist approach implies that it is within humans rather than between humans (and materialities) that problems are solved and new knowledge is generated. This is very different from the Pragmatist approach that situates learning and knowledge production in transactions between selves and situations rather than within selves and outside situations. In a Pragmatist take on organizational learning, the predispositions to act are habits, which are much more than mere mental models. The cultural and historical dimensions of habit suggest that organizational learning is a situated social practice rather than merely a social technology to be implemented. The notion of habit reminds us of the gradual transition between organizational routines and organizational change; it reminds us that organizational learning may be both reproductive, by producing more of the same or similar experience, and innovative, by producing novel experience. It is precisely in maintaining habit as disposition to act in open-ended and creative ways that experience and inquiry are linked in Pragmatism. Inquiry is ‘how we think’; it is the method through which learning takes place and reasoning is nurtured by guidance (e.g. teaching). Inquiry in a Pragmatist sense cuts across description and normative guidelines because it involves both emotion and judgement. It is initiated by an uneasy situation, an unsettled or disturbed situation (experienced as emotion) that requires resolution (involving judgement), and which, in turn, produces learning. The notion of inquiry also alerts us to the open-endedness of experimental, creative and innovative reasoning. Now turning to the third issue that we highlighted above, the intertwining of socialization and creativity, Pragmatism alerts us to learning (and creation of knowledge) as experimental and instrumental. In other words, it invites us to see ideas and concepts as tools to play with and to use in reasoning. This helps us see how expansion and transformation of organizational routines can happen through inquiry and anticipatory reasoning. To learn in a Pragmatist sense is to infuse uncertain situations with meaning, which involves firstly defining the situation as a problem. This means that learning is a process of constructing selves and situations, resulting in actionable knowledge. In Pragmatism, this creation of meaning can never be predicted by any a priori assignment of power because it is always relative to a situation.
74
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
Organizational learning through inquiry is, in other words, opening learning to the playfulness of how concepts and ideas are intertwined with actions not only in a reflective and backward-looking sense but also in a forward-looking way. Routines and habits (i.e. predispositions to act in certain ways) will always prevail in organizations but Pragmatism stresses how experimental and instrumental ways of using ideas and concepts in a forward-looking, abductive way helps us to see how creativity and innovation are also inherent in organizational learning. Understanding experience as the lived and living processes of selves engaging with the natural and social situations changes the focus from patterns of access and participation in the organizational communities of practice to ways in which participation unfolds (Gherardi, Nicolini, & Odella, 1998). Possible questions to ask then are: Do these ways of participation allow for inquiry into interruptions and challenges of the status quo? Is it possible to maintain an open-ended understanding of solutions to organizational problems? How is it possible to create, recreate and even transform experience? In sum, our Pragmatist version of organizational learning starts from an understanding of organizations as lived and living organisms, which consist of certain habits (i.e. habitual dispositions to act). These are learned through experience by inquiring transactionally into uncertain situations. The trigger for inquiry is a felt uncertainty or tension, which produces experience that sometimes can turn into knowledge (‘warranted assertabilities’) in the sense that it can be communicated through language (signs and symbols), and thus shared. Creativity lies in the abductive orientation towards the future, which is explored by the ‘I’ as it plays with and puts together new ways of engaging with social situations. Argyris and Scho¨n’s view of organizational learning starts from the assumption that action is guided by theories of action, where this appears to be their interpretation of the Pragmatist notions of habit, and inquiry. They do not speak of transaction but ‘interaction’ between individuals and organizations, and mental models appear to have replaced experience. To us this means that it is not possible to understand organizational learning across levels and across the knowledge–action divide, but most importantly it prevents us from understanding socialization and creativity as inherent in all transactions and not to be tied into systems of different loops of thinking. By contrast, a Pragmatist take on organizational learning alerts us to socialization and learning as relational practices; it alerts us to the connection between knowledge and action and to learning as transactional (involving both selves and situations). Pragmatism sees organizational learning as a temporal continuity, having a certain rhythm that is not only
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
75
process or ‘flow’ but also rest and repose. The anticipatory outlook on knowledge and action makes organizational learning creative and nonintentional, and it allows us to transcend the problems associated with the traditional separation of levels of analysis. When initiating organizational learning, we look for disjunctions, relocations and tensions because it is here that we find the seeds of creativity and innovation embedded in the organizational habitual knowledge and actions. This view of organizational learning encompasses emotion, ethics and aesthetics alongside ideas and concepts as mutually informing aspects of experience.
PRAGMATISM, PRACTICE AND SENSEMAKING We now turn to consider what Pragmatism has to offer the wider field of organization theory. Philosophically speaking, there is a fundamental cleavage in the contemporary scholarship of this field that separates entitative and processual orientations towards scholarship and inquiry. This distinction is thoroughly articulated, for instance, by Tsoukas and Chia (2002), who contrasted two distinct ontologies: ‘being’, which locates reality in substances, things and events, and ‘becoming’, which approaches reality through flux, flow and continuity. The limitations of the entitative, or ‘being’, perspective in organization studies were recognized by Weick (1979, p. 44) when he exhorted us to ‘stamp out nouns’. He argued that the language we use shapes the ways in which we think about, and engage with, the organizational world. ‘If students of organization become stingy in their use of nouns, generous in their use of verbs, and extravagant in their use of gerunds, then more attention would be paid to process and we’d learn more about how to see it and manage it’ (Weick, 1979, p. 44). In response to this call to action, there has been a veritable explosion of ‘-ing’ words in the organizational literature, such as organiz-ing, learn-ing, know-ing, do-ing and strategiz-ing. But because gerunds can function as both nouns and verbs, this semantic device has not produced as radical a shift in thinking as perhaps Weick might have hoped. Indeed, this same literature continues to be relatively uncritically peppered with dualistic distinctions between, for instance, individual and collective levels of analysis, or contrasting states of stability and change, revealing the resilience of entitative thinking in organization studies. The adoption of a processual, ‘becoming’ ontology really does require a radical rearrangement of the ways in which we talk about the dynamics of our social world, but in shifting to this alternative position, much of what an entitative view can offer is lost. A more complex approach to organization
76
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
would require us to transcend this dualistic separation between entitative and processual ontologies. Challenging such dualisms was very much part of the Pragmatist agenda. Dewey in particular railed against the artificial separation of body and mind, and knowledge and action, arguing that these dualisms cut across dynamic processes, disrupting their continuity. Both Mead (1932) and Whitehead (see Bakken & Hernes, 2006) argued that a more comprehensive view of society (and therefore organization) must draw upon both verbs and nouns, but without privileging either. This implies a different philosophical paradigm in which the interplay between verbs and nouns produces an ontology of practice (Simpson, 2009) that is located in the lived experience of organization and the ways in which meanings interact with people’s conduct. Working in an alternative paradigm like this implies a shift not only in ontology but also in other philosophical dimensions such as epistemology, metaphysics and ethics. We propose that Pragmatism offers just such a well-elaborated system of philosophy that allows us to understand organization as an ever-changing movement of meanings and actions punctuated by events that signify the socially constructed understandings arising out of the otherwise undifferentiated flux of experience. To illustrate this potential, we now focus specifically on the organizational theorizing of Karl Weick, who is widely regarded as one of the most influential thinkers in contemporary organization studies (Sutcliffe, Brown, & Putnam, 2006). He is best known for his theories of organizing and sensemaking, and is much cited for his provocative, and often counterintuitive, turns of phrase that oblige us to pause, inquire and make new sense from his words. Throughout his very considerable oeuvre, the influence of William James is abundantly evident. Weick’s work is threaded through with James’ imagery of the world as ‘a buzzing, pulsating, formless mass of signals, out of which people try to make sense, into which they attempt to introduce order, and from which they construct against a background that remains undifferentiated’ (Czarniawska, 1998, p. 1). Equally, Weick regularly cites Mead, albeit as seen through the eyes of the symbolic interactionists and the Chicago School more generally (e.g. Blumer, 1969; Goffman, 1969; Strauss, 1956). However, he only rarely cites Dewey, and even less frequently Peirce. It would seem likely then, there may be more that Pragmatism could offer to Weick’s already fertile theorizing. In particular, we consider there are at least three areas for potential development: continuity as the interplay of past and future in the present; the transactional nature of social agency; reflexivity as an explicit element in the theorizing of social practices.
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
77
In many ways, Pragmatism and Weick’s theories are very synergistic, but he deviated from Pragmatism in his basic recipe for sensemaking, which he expressed in his signature question: ‘How can I know what I think until I see what I say?’ (1979, p. 133). That is, we come to know the meaning of our actions only after the event. Meaning is, therefore, constructed retrospectively, or as Weick said ‘[m]uch organizational sensemaking consists of writing histories’ (1979, p. 200). Equally, however, ‘[t]he person is able to understand an event only after imputing both a history and prospects to the puzzling enacted display’ (Weick, 1979, p. 200). In this, Weick hints at the importance of future prospects as part of sensemaking, but although he does discuss ‘future perfect thinking’ (1979, pp. 197–200), this future orientation remains under-theorized and is not integrated into his theories of organizing and sensemaking (see, e.g. Gioia & Mehra, 1996; Patriotta, 2003). By contrast, the Pragmatist maxim with which we opened this chapter (Peirce, 1878) points directly to anticipated future consequences of actions as the source of meaning in the present moment. These future anticipations may be understood in terms of Peirce’s notion of abduction (Anderson, 1987), in which hypothetical actions are projected forward into the future. Past histories are used as resources in constructing these hypotheses, but it is their imagined consequences that inform the actual actions taken in the present moment. Sensemaking, then, may be seen more fully as a continuous process of reconstruing meanings that are drawn simultaneously from the past and the future. It is this interplay between past and future that gives temporal continuity to actions in the living present (Mead, 1932). The abductive possibility of anticipating different and alternative futures eases the bonds of our histories and opens up novel opportunities for further action. Without this future orientation, sensemaking is necessarily constrained to a convergent, retrospective process that perpetually reproduces history. Pragmatists would argue that this denies the inherent creativity of life and living, and without this, our understandings of people’s conduct in organizations will be impoverished. The second area where we think Pragmatism might usefully enhance Weick’s theorizing is by embracing more fully the implications of a transactional, rather than merely interactional, view of social engagement (Dewey & Bentley, 1949 [1991]). Weick (1979, chap. 4) initially defined interacts and double interacts in terms that are consistent with Mead’s (1934) notion of the ‘conversation of gestures’. However, he went on to argue that double interacts are constituted as ‘stable subassemblies’ of interlocked behaviours involving two or more individuals, where these subassemblies are the building blocks of organizational structures. This formulation
78
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
tends to reduce interlocking behaviours to a somewhat mechanistic interpersonal exchange that focuses rather too narrowly on the cognitive and representational aspects of organizing and sensemaking, while denying the creative potential of our social engagements. By contrast, the Pragmatist approach seeks to transcend the entitative distinctions that set cognition and structure apart from bodily sensation and agency, respectively. It emphasizes the social nature of agency whereby the meanings of both selves and situations are co-constructing and immanent within each other. By focusing on actions rather than actors, the transactional perspective offers a more holistic view that is not restricted to any specific level of analysis. Indeed, this capacity to transcend levels of analysis is a defining quality of the Pragmatist notion of transaction, which is also inclusive of emotional and aesthetic actions as well as the influencing dynamics of power in social situations. We suggest that many current topics in organization studies, such as identity work, emotion work, idea work and strategy work, might usefully be elaborated in these transactional terms. Finally we turn to consider reflexivity in organizing and sensemaking. Weick (2006, p. 1731) recently declared ‘Order, interruption, recovery. That is sensemaking in a nutshell’. While this summary statement highlights the key events of sensemaking, it leaves unspoken the human experience of this process. By comparison, Dewey’s more elaborated process of inquiry (1933 [1986]) locates critical reflexivity and human transactions at its centre as it proceeds from habitual action to a disturbance or interruption, and then on to an analysis of the causes of the disruption, the abductive generation of options for further action and finally the selection and testing of a preferred course of action to overcome the immediate causes of the interruption. Reflexivity arises in transactions because it is here that sociality is constructed as we attempt to see the world through the eyes of others. Mead (1925) argued that transactions are the site where the self can appear to itself as an object of reflection and inquiry. Self-awareness is not generated in circumstances where habitual actions continue uninterrupted; rather, it is when unanticipated eventualities demand new meanings that a reflexive response is called out. Every gesture made during this transactional process is made in anticipation of some specific response or outcome, and every response invites reflection on the extent to which the anticipated outcome was realized. This incremental, experimental process of constructing new meanings out of unexpected events is thus dependent upon the human capacity to reflect not only on past events but also on the repertoire of alternative futures that can be creatively imagined. So, for instance, the indigenous Maori people of New Zealand talk about ‘walking backwards into the future’, which means
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
79
that as their lives unfold forwards, they are ever conscious of the function of history not only in shaping their present actions but also in guiding them into the future. This relentless dynamic of anticipation and action is what provides continuity in practice, and it is reflexivity that admits this temporal experiencing of time and the possibilities of change as emergent and evolutionary. In this way, then, Pragmatism demystifies reflexivity, making it a normal and natural part of all social practices. The three themes that have focused our discussion here were prompted by our reading of Weick’s theories of organizing and sensemaking. We do not intend to suggest that our analysis of these theories is exhaustive; it is merely illustrative of the potential for Pragmatism to bring new and subtly nuanced insights into the domain of organization studies. Nor do we intend to suggest that Weick’s ideas are the only ones that might benefit from some Pragmatist insight. We propose that Pragmatism has considerable potential to contribute to better understandings of the social dynamics of organizational practices more generally. In this, we frame Pragmatist thinking as a complete system of philosophy that transcends the common distinctions between entitative and processual ontologies by focusing on practice as the intricate interweaving of social agency and temporality. In this way, the meanings of events and objects in the present moment are inseparable from the continuity of experience, where this experience arises in social transactions.
CONCLUSION Organization theory today is increasingly faced with seemingly intractable problems as scholars struggle to find adequate ways of engaging with the multi-site, multi-cultural complexities of globalized business, and the at best, only partially predictable social dynamics of organizational practices. In this chapter, we have proposed Pragmatism as a way forward that offers a potentially radical alternative to the currently dominant paradigms of organizational scholarship. Entitative and processual philosophies each provide valuable insights into the nature of organization, but equally, each has its own limitations. The Pragmatist alternative seeks to transcend this entitative/processual dualism by understanding organizational practice as the continuous and emergent weaving together of social selves and social situations. Its focus is very much upon the social nature of real-time actions that constitute living and lived experience. This perspective, then, offers a way of approaching ‘how’ and ‘why’ questions that remain difficult to address by more conventional means.
80
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
The distinctiveness of Pragmatism can be traced back to the originating maxim first articulated by Charles Sanders Peirce in 1878. In this, he suggested that the meanings we ascribe to events and actions in the present moment can be understood entirely in terms of the future consequences that we anticipate arising from these events and actions. This future orientation sets Pragmatism apart from philosophies that account for meanings solely in terms of retrospective interpretations of past experiences. Pragmatism recognizes retrospection to the extent that it informs what we imagine will happen next, but it is this future anticipation that actually gives meaning to our actions in the present. In this way, Pragmatism acknowledges the constitution of both agency and structure in social practices, but without privileging either. At the same time, it theorizes the temporal continuity of present moments as both anchored in the past and thrusting into the future. This approach to temporality as a continuously emergent social process of meaning-making invites new ways of engaging with the dynamics of organization. In addition to these broad defining themes, we have identified four theoretical concepts that are potentially very useful to organizational scholars. These four concepts, ‘experience’, ‘inquiry’, ‘habit’ and ‘transaction’, are mutually informing and interdependent aspects of all social practices. Unlike the everyday notion of experience as the knowledge gained from doings, the Pragmatist use of this term relates very specifically to the dynamic relationship between knowledge (or meaning) and action in the conduct of the living present. Inquiry is the social process of critically reflecting upon and questioning the taken-for-granted order, which is every bit as relevant in day-to-day conduct as it is in more specialized forms of knowledge production, such as scientific work. Habit is seen as the predisposition to act in certain ways; inquiry is stimulated when these habitual ways of acting prove inadequate for any given situation. Habits are what makes it possible to live within society, but importantly, the Pragmatists did not see habits as rigidly fixed. Indeed, it is the mutability of habits that admits the possibilities of creative change in social practices. And finally, transactions are the site where the interplay between experience, inquiry and habit is continuously explored and regenerated across all levels of the social system. We have demonstrated the use of these four Pragmatist concepts in the context of organizational learning, suggesting that this field is an obvious target for some fresh theoretical thinking. In particular, we chose to take a closer look at the work of Argyris and Scho¨n because they claimed Pragmatism as the point of departure for their theory of organizational
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
81
learning. We suggest, however, that they have not fully embraced the potential of Pragmatism as their work continues to reflect dualistic distinctions between knowledge and action, and individuals and organization. These constraints limit the extent to which their theory can accommodate the creative as well as the socializing aspects of learning. We then extended our argument to show that Pragmatism offers tools that are much needed in contemporary organization theory. Using Weick’s theories of organizing and sensemaking to illustrate our argument, we proposed that the Pragmatist formulations of continuity, transactional engagement and reflexivity offer useful ways of further developing organizational scholarship. Ultimately though, organization and management studies is an intensely practical domain where practical problems demand practical solutions. To paraphrase Kurt Lewin, we suggest that there is nothing so practical as a good philosophy that provides the intellectual tools to challenge assumptions and to understand issues in new and deeper ways. From its inception, Pragmatism has always been a very practical philosophy, although we acknowledge that its diversity of ideas has created difficulties for scholars who might wish to come to grips with it. Nevertheless, a slow trickle of papers informed by Pragmatist thinking is beginning to emerge in the organizational literature (e.g. Cohen, 2007; Locke, Golden-Biddle, & Feldman, 2008; Weick, 2008), which we see as a positive sign for future developments. What is needed now is a concerted effort to develop methodologies that are true to the principles of Pragmatism, and which can better inform empirical inquiries into the practical problems of organization as a dynamic and emergent process of meaning-making. The experimental, instrumental and anticipatory aspects of Pragmatism as a lived and living philosophy offer a rich vein of inspirational themes, which in our view will reward further exploration and elaboration in the field of organization and management studies.
REFERENCES Anderson, D. R. (1987). Creativity and the philosophy of C.S. Peirce. Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers. Argyris, C. (2003). A life full of learning. Organization Studies, 24(7), 1178–1192. Argyris, C., & Scho¨n, D. A. (1996). Organizational learning II. Theory, method, and practice. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company. Bakken, T., & Hernes, T. (2006). Organizing is both a verb and a noun: Weick meets Whitehead. Organization Studies, 27(11), 1599–1616.
82
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
Barbalet, J. (2004). William James: Pragmatism, social psychology and emotions. European Journal of Social Theory, 7(3), 337–353. Bergson, H. (1919). Creative evolution (A. Mitchell, Trans.). London: Macmillan. Bernstein, R. J. (1960). John Dewey. On experience, nature and freedom. Representative selections. New York: The Liberal Arts Press. Bernstein, R. J. (1966 [1967]). John Dewey. New York: Washington Square Press, Inc. Biesta, G. J. J., & Burbules, N. C. (2003). Pragmatism and educational research. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. Blumer, H. (1969). Symbolic interactionism – Perspective and method. London: University of California Press Ltd. Boydston, J. A. (Ed.). (1981 [1925]). Later works (Vol. 1). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. Chesterton, G. K. (1908). Orthodoxy. New York: John Lane. Cohen, M. D. (2007). Reading Dewey: Reflections on the study of routine. Organization Studies, 28(5), 773–786. Cook, S., & Yanow, D. (1993). Culture and organizational learning. Journal of Management Inquiry, 2(4), 373–390. Czarniawska, B. (1998). A narrative approach to organization studies. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Dewey, J. (1896 [1972]). The reflex arc concept in psychology. In: J. A. Boydston (Ed.), Early works (Vol. 5, pp. 96–109). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. Dewey, J. (1908 [1977]). The bearings of pragmatism upon education. In: J. A. Boydston (Ed.), Middle works (Vol. 4, pp. 178–191). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. Dewey, J. (1910). The influence of Darwin on philosophy and other essays. New York: Henry Holt and Company. Dewey, J. (Ed.) (1917). The need for a recovery of philosophy (Vol. 10). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. Dewey, J. (1922 [1988]). Human nature and conduct. In: J. A. Boydston (Ed.), Middle works (Vol. 14). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. Dewey, J. (1925 [1981]). Experience and nature. In: J. A. Boydston (Ed.), Later works (Vol. 1). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. Dewey, J. (1925 [1984]). The development of American pragmatism. In: J. A. Boydston (Ed.), Later works (Vol. 2, pp. 3–21). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. Dewey, J. (1933 [1986]). How we think: A restatement of the relation of reflective thinking to the educative process. In: J. A. Boydston (Ed.), Later works (Vol. 8, pp. 105–352). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education. New York: Macmillan. Dewey, J. (1938 [1986]). Logic: The theory of inquiry. In: J. A. Boydston (Ed.), Later works, 1925–1953 (Vol. 12). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. Dewey, J., & Bentley, A. F. (1949 [1991]). Knowing and the known. In: J. A. Boydston (Ed.), Later works, 1925–1953 (Vol. 16, pp. 1–294). Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press. Elkjaer, B. (2003). Social learning theory: Learning as participation in social processes. In: M. Easterby-Smith & M. Lyles (Eds), The Blackwell handbook of organizational learning and knowledge management (pp. 38–53). Malden: Blackwell Publishing. Elkjaer, B., & Wahlgren, B. (2006). Organizational learning and workplace learning – Similarities and differences. In: E. Antonacopoulou, P. Jarvis, V. Andersen, B. Elkjaer & S. Høyrup (Eds), Learning, working and living. Mapping the terrain of working life learning (pp. 15–32). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Pragmatism: A Lived and Living Philosophy
83
Fenwick, T. (Ed.) (2001). Sociocultural perspectives on learning through work. New York: Jossey-Bass Publishers. Gherardi, S. (2000). Practice-based theorizing on learning and knowing in organizations. Organization, 7(2), 211–223. Gherardi, S., Nicolini, D., & Odella, F. (1998). Toward a social understanding of how people learn in organizations. The notion of situated curriculum. Management Learning, 29(3), 273–297. Gioia, D. A., & Mehra, A. (1996). Review of ‘Sensemaking in Organizations’. Academy of Management Review, 21(4), 1226–1230. Goffman, E. (1969). Strategic interaction. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press. Haack, S., & Lane, R. (Eds). (2006). Pragmatism, old and new: Selected writings. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books. James, W. (1891 [1952]). Principles of psychology. Chicago: Encyclopedia Britannica. James, W. (1898). Philosophical conceptions and practical results. In: F. H. Burkhardt (Ed.), Pragmatism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. James, W. (1907). What pragmatism means. In: W. James (Ed.), Pragmatism: A new name for some old ways of thinking (pp. 42–81). London: Longmans, Green and Co. James, W. (1912 [2006]). Essays in radical empiricism. London: Longmans, Green and Co. Joas, H. (1996). Creativity of action. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Joas, H. (1997). G.H. Mead – A contemporary re-examination of his thought. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning. Legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Locke, K., Golden-Biddle, K., & Feldman, M. S. (2008). Making doubt generative: Rethinking the role of doubt in the research process. Organization Science, 19(6), 907–918. Lovejoy, A. O. (1963). The thirteen pragmatisms and other essays. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press. March, J., & Simon, H. A. (1958). Organizations. New York: Wiley. Mead, G. H. (1913). The social self. Journal of Philosophy, Psychology and Scientific Methods, 10, 374–380. Mead, G. H. (1925). The genesis of the self and social control. International Journal of Ethics, 35, 251–277. Mead, G. H. (1932). The philosophy of the present. Illinois: La Salle. Mead, G. H. (1934). Mind, self and society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Mead, G. H. (1938). The philosophy of the act. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Patriotta, G. (2003). Sensemaking on the shop floor: Narratives of knowledge in organizations. Journal of Management Studies, 40(2), 349–376. Peirce, C. S. (1877). The fixation of belief. In: H. S. Thayer (Ed.), Pragmatism: The classic writings (pp. 61–78). Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company. Peirce, C. S. (1878). How to make our ideas clear. The Popular Science Monthly, 12(January), 286–302. Peirce, C. S. (1905). What pragmatism is. In: H. S. Thayer (Ed.), Pragmatism: The classic writings (pp. 101–120). Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company. Rorty, R. (1980). Philosophy and the mirror of nature. Oxford: Blackwell. Russell, B. (1961). A history of Western philosophy (2nd ed.). London: Allen & Unwin. Scheffler, I. (1974). Four pragmatists: A critical introduction to Peirce, James, Mead, and Dewey. New Jersey: Humanities Press.
84
BENTE ELKJAER AND BARBARA SIMPSON
Simpson, B. (2009). Pragmatism, Mead, and the practice turn. Organization Studies, 30(12), 1329–1347. Strauss, A. M. (Ed.) (1956). The social psychology of George Herbert Mead: Selections from his works. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Sutcliffe, K. M., Brown, A. D., & Putnam, L. L. (2006). Making sense of organizing: In honor of Karl Weick. Organization Studies, 27(11), 1573–1578. Talisse, R. B. (2007). A pragmatist philosophy of democracy. New York: Routledge. Thayer, H. S. (Ed.) (1982). Pragmatism: The classical writings. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company. Tsoukas, H., & Chia, R. (2002). On organizational becoming: Rethinking organizational change. Organization Science, 13(5), 567–582. Weick, C. W. (2008). Issues of consequence: Lessons for educating tomorrow’s business leaders from philosopher William James. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 7(1), 88–98. Weick, K. E. (1979). The social psychology of organizing. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company. Weick, K. E. (2006). Faith, evidence, and action: Better guesses in an unknowable world. Organization Studies, 27(11), 1723–1736.
Bente Elkjaer (BA, MA and PhD) holds a chair in organizational and workplace learning at the School of Education, Aarhus University, Department of Learning, which she is also the current head of. She has within her research taken a special interest in developing a theoretical perspective on organizational learning inspired by American Pragmatism (particularly the works by John Dewey), which she has called the ‘third way’. Further, Bente Elkjaer was for five years (2005–2009) the editor-inchief of Management Learning, and she is also the head of the Doctoral School of Organizational Learning (DOCSOL) at the university. Barbara Simpson (BSc, MSc (Hons), PhD (Auckland)) is a senior lecturer in organization studies in the University of Strathclyde Business School, Department of Management. Her research, supervision and teaching interests revolve around the topics of organizational change, innovation and creativity, which she approaches from a constructivist orientation that seeks to uncover the dynamic nature of organizational practices. In this context, she has drawn particular inspiration from the classical Pragmatist philosophers, especially George Herbert Mead. Her work is published in Organization Studies and Organization.
MACINTYRE, NEO-ARISTOTELIANISM AND ORGANIZATION THEORY Ron Beadle and Geoff Moore ABSTRACT In this chapter, we set out to demonstrate how organizational theory and analysis can benefit from the work of the distinguished philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre. In the first part of the chapter we show how MacIntyre’s conception of how rival traditions may move towards reconciliation has the potential to resolve the relativist conclusions that bedevil organization theory. In the second part, we show how MacIntyre’s ‘goods–virtues– practices–institutions’ general theory provides a framework for reconciling the fields of organization theory and organizational ethics. In the third part, we provide a worked example of these two strands to demonstrate the implications of MacIntyre’s philosophy for organizational analysis. We conclude with a research agenda for a distinctively MacIntyrean organization theory. Keywords: MacIntyre; neo-Aristotelianism; organization theory; organization analysis; hermeneutics; Bristol Royal Infirmary.
Philosophy and Organization Theory Research in the Sociology of Organizations, Volume 32, 85–121 Copyright r 2011 by Emerald Group Publishing Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 0733-558X/doi:10.1108/S0733-558X(2011)0000032006
85
86
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
INTRODUCTION The inclusion of a work on Alasdair MacIntyre in this volume is appropriate not least because MacIntyre has always taken organizations seriously as objects of philosophical attention. How then can organizational analysis benefit from his work? To answer this question we make two distinct but mutually supporting cases. First that MacIntyre shows how organization theory need not draw relativist conclusions from hermeneutic premises and second that MacIntyre’s ‘goods–virtues–practices–institutions’ framework overcomes the division between organization theory and organizational ethics. We proceed in three parts. Firstly, we will contextualize MacIntyre’s project in relation to a philosophical tradition whose impact upon organization theory is indubitable – hermeneutics. This case will involve a consideration of MacIntyre’s use and transformation of hermeneutics through his conception of tradition. Secondly, we will review MacIntyre’s ‘general theory’ of goods, virtues, practices and institutions. This part will include a brief comparison with ‘old’ institutional theory (Selznick, 1996; Stinchcombe, 1997) and introduce the concept of ‘reasons for action’. In the third part, we will draw together these strands to demonstrate the difference between MacIntyrean organization analysis and an alternative hermeneutical/institutional approach through a worked example – Karl Weick and Karen Sutcliffe’s analysis of the Bristol Royal Infirmary (BRI) as a culture of entrapment (2003). A conclusion will present a case for a research agenda for MacIntyrean empirics in organization studies.
PART ONE: PRACTICES – HERMENEUTIC AND MACINTYREAN MacIntyre in Context One way of locating Alasdair MacIntyre’s philosophical project is in relation to the recovery of Aristotelian practical philosophy in the neoAristotelianism of the twentieth century. Whilst the incautious reader may see MacIntyre only in terms of his proximity to this movement, more can be learned if we also attend to his disputes with it. From Heidigger onwards neo-Aristotelian practical philosophy has influenced philosophical genres from literary criticism to political philosophy. It is a tradition that seeks to rescue Aristotelian texts both from what it sees as their errors, particularly their metaphysical theoria and from the later historicism through which
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
87
Aristotle is seen through the lens of modern philosophical figures or concepts (Knight, 2007, p. 89). In place of a universalizing theoria of being is juxtaposed a philosophy of praxis in which it is the living activity of human beings that both creates and delimits human understanding. From such a premise Heidegger renders Aristotle as the philosopher of praxis and nothing else – for there is nothing else. Figures including Strauss, Arendt and Gadamer extend this reduction of the Aristotelian tradition to variants of practical philosophy whilst the unhappy relation of such projects to anything that can be reasonably labelled Aristotelian is a case made by Riedel’s teleology in one way, and Ritter’s institutionalism in another (Knight, 2007, pp. 92–93). According to Knight such neo-Aristotelianism is inherently conservative whether in its hermeneutic or more explicitly political form, in three ways. Firstly its exclusion of theoria bounds all practical judgments in the ethos of the present – thus removing the basis for radical critique or action; secondly its institutionalism provides philosophical grounds for a permanent elite and thirdly its celebration of praxis involves a denigration of production (ibid., pp. 100–101). By contrast MacIntyre recovers both Aristotle’s practical and theoretical philosophy through his notion of tradition, overcomes the division between praxis and production through his distinctive conception of practice and provides a critique of institutions qua institutions in his general theory of ‘goods, virtues, practices and institutions’. MacIntyre thus rejects all three neo-Aristotelian positions whilst assimilating many of the insights of neoAristotelian hermeneutics. The prudence of introducing the implications of Alasdair MacIntyre’s work through its relationship to hermeneutics has already been argued (Smith, 1999, p. 327) but if our summary of Knight’s argument is accurate then this also accounts for its relationship with neo-Aristotelianism. This project is aided by the prodigious quantities of MacIntyre’s work about and in conversation with hermeneutics. Having been producing philosophical material for over 55 years, MacIntyre has, since the 1981 publication of After Virtue,1 developed an Aristotelian and subsequently Thomistic account of moral philosophy. His uniqueness in this endeavour is in his association of the Aristotelian and Thomistic traditions with Marxism. This combination, described by Knight as ‘Revolutionary Aristotelianism’ (Knight, 2007) might have little chance of success given that the only thing that Marxists and Thomists can agree about is their mutual incompatibility. And yet MacIntyre remains one of the great figures of twentieth century moral philosophy, the subject of a veritable mini-industry of publications (Murphy, 2003; D’Andrea, 2007; Knight, 2007; Blackledge & Davidson,
88
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
2008), with an international academic society devoted to pursuing his project2 and use of his work made across the social sciences. The Self-Images of the Age, The Self-Images of Organization Theory In Alfred Hitchcock’s 1972 thriller ‘Frenzy’ the psychopathic leading character visits Duckworth’s London Bookshop. The camera pauses over the window display of multitudinous copies of Against the Self Images of the Age, a collection of 1960s essays by Alasdair MacIntyre (1971). Legend has it that this shot was deliberate. MacIntyre’s title for the collection reflects his ongoing concern with the intimacy of the relationship between agents’ behaviour, self-understandings and the social structures they inhabit. In line with the hermeneutic tradition, he holds that it is an error, but an important error, to believe that the idioms and theoretical insights upon which our selfimages depend, constitute a neutral representation of some external reality:3 there is no way for the historian or social scientist to locate himself outside some tradition of interpretation, the very language he speaks and writes is so shaped by tradition that he cannot evade it’. (MacIntyre, 1980, p. 177)
The narratives through which agents understand their lives are profoundly affected by the extent of their participation in and commitments to particular tradition-informed social practices, those which enable agents to answer questions such as ‘What are you doing?’ and ‘Why are you doing that?’ Intelligible answers to such questions are available only to those who share narrative traditions. MacIntyre’s definition is disarmingly simple: A living tradition y is an historically extended, socially embodied argument, and an argument precisely in part about the goods which constitute that tradition. Within a tradition the pursuit of goods extends through generations, sometimes through many generations. Hence the individual’s search for his or her good is generally and characteristically conducted within a context defined by those traditions of which the individual’s life is a part, and this is true both of those goods which are internal to practices and of the goods of a single life. (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 222)
How does this differ from the hermeneutic understanding of our boundedness by historically situated interpretations? The hermeneutic tradition maintains that Understanding can never really be grounded because it is itself the ground, the floor on which we are always already standing. (Grondin, 2003, p. 284)
For hermeneutics our inability to move beyond language dissolves the distinction between truth and rational justification. Hence for Gadamer we must ‘get away from objectivist naı¨ vete´ and destroy the illusion of a truth
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
89
that is separate from the standpoint of the one doing the understanding’ (2001, p. 46) and for Habermas the limits of any radical intent involve the creation of spaces for ideal speech acts involving the recognition that we cannot move beyond speech to any notion of truth.4 In Organization Theory, leading authorities such as Burrell and Morgan (1979), Smircich (1983), Martin (1992) and many others offer us collections of paradigms distinguished by ontological and epistemological assumptions between the merits of which we may rationally offer no argument. The differences between paradigms are so fundamental as to entail mutual exclusivity (Burrell & Morgan, 1979, p. 25) and thus the argument entails relativism. Even Tsoukas and Cummings’ (1997) sympathetic call for neoAristotelianism in organization studies shares this perspectivist–relativist position. Neo-Aristotelianism merely provides a ‘helpful’ (p. 672) turn in the project of thinking differently (p. 676) about organizations, particularly those in which a certain type of phronetic work predominates (pp. 663–668). They recognize that their claims will have force only for those who share ‘the assumption that thinking differently is something that management theory takes to be important’ (p. 676, emphasis retained). As to why this is important and why its helpfulness provides a reason for action, Tsoukas and Cummings can provide no answer. From a MacIntyrean perspective their reduction of neo-Aristotelianism to just another set of methods and foci for empirical research is intimately related to their inability to make a case for any method in terms of truth. Tsoukas and Cummings’ Foucauldian project misrepresents the nature of MacIntyre’s claims, not least of which are those that address the implications of Aristotelianism for truth and for its relationship to method. As Porter (2003, p. 46) notes, for MacIntyre, beyond the perspectivist and relativist positions ‘there is a third alternative, the possibility that the development of traditions, both internally and in relation to one another, can itself be considered to be a genuinely rational process that, if it goes well, moves in the direction of an ever-fuller grasp of reality’. So, for MacIntyre, arguments towards conclusions, such as those of Tsoukas and Cummings towards the conclusion that organization studies would benefit from a re-appropriation of neo-Aristotelianism, are intelligible only if arguments as such can be construed as better or worse, and this is intelligible only in the context of movement towards or away from some perfectable understanding (MacIntyre, 1990b). Reames summarizes MacIntyre’s position well: The metaphysical good norms all traditions, and hence in a sense one might want to say that it transcends traditions. But because the good would be perfectly understood in a
90
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE perfected tradition, and because such a perfected tradition is already the telos of traditional rationality itself, there is no need to posit some sort of mysterious source of extra- or non-traditional rationality. In other words, what is required is a distinction between metaphysics and epistemology: the metaphysical good as such norms all traditions (and indeed all thought and action), but we can only think about the good and come to know it in and through traditions. (1998, p. 443, emphasis retained)
For MacIntyre, unlike other realists,5 the pragmatic refutation of relativism (i.e. what is the status of the claim that there is no truth?) is correct but insufficient in its neglect of the truths to which relativism itself points: relativism y is one of those doctrines that have been refuted a number of times too often. Nothing is perhaps a surer sign that a doctrine embodies some not-to-beneglected truth than that in the course of the history of philosophy it should have been refuted again and again. Genuinely refutable doctrines only need to be refuted once. (1987a, p. 385)
What are the truths to which relativism points? The first is the limits that our historic situatedness imposes on our claims to truth. MacIntyre agrees that we do not have the resources a priori to judge, for example, between such constructions as objectivity and subjectivity in their relation to ontology, but this does not entail that we could never so judge, and it is this latter error into which the perspectivism so prevalent in organization studies falls. In contrasting his own position to Gadamer’s, MacIntyre argues: to have become aware of the historically conditioned character of our philosophical enquiries and interpretations is not to have escaped from it. There is no standpoint outside history to which we can move, no way in which we can move to some presuppositionless stance, exempt from the historical situatedness of all thinking y It is not incompatible, however, with a recognition of this truth to argue that a great deal turns on the nature of our awareness of the contingencies of our historical situatedness and that a certain kind of standpoint outside history, can transform our relationships to that history. (2002, p. 158)
If, as he argues in line with hermeneutics, agents’ understandings are constituted within traditions of language and practice, it is also true (and in this he departs from hermeneutics and from relativism) that we may distinguish intelligibly between claims made for truth within the traditions which shape language and practice over time. This effort enjoins us to engage in two distinct but related types of conflict: those with critics and enemies external to the tradition who reject all or at least key parts of those fundamental agreements, and those internal, interpretative debates through
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
91
which the meaning and rationale of the fundamental agreements come to be expressed and by whose progress a tradition is constituted. (MacIntyre, 1988, p. 12)6
It is only if MacIntyre can show that conflicts of the former type are resolvable that we have grounds to reject the type of incommensurability that constitutes the self-image of so much contemporary organization theory. The challenges of this task are difficult to underestimate however. MacIntyre holds, alongside hermeneutics, that traditions are the bearers of the substantive rationalities on which intelligibility and judgment depend (MacIntyre, 1987a, 1987b, 1987c, 1988). We cannot turn to a system of rationality through which to decide between the claims of traditions because rational justification is itself tradition constituted. We can only claim that we have reason to believe in quarks, for example, by seeing how the argument for their existence has gone so far and judging the evidential and theoretical claims made in their favour against those standards by which we judge such claims, standards that themselves have a history against which to judge whether they are the best standards against which to judge. The intelligibility of our claims is also such that what is intelligible at an earlier point in a tradition may become unintelligible – the tradition may suffer an ‘epistemological crisis’ (Porter, 2003, p. 47) – or at least bear a significantly different meaning later on (MacIntyre, 1986, p. 76): For an individual either to be or to appear to be rational is then for that individual to participate in the norm-governed transactions and relationships of a particular institutionalised social order. Hence ‘‘rational’’ is not a predicate to be applied to individuals qua individuals but only to individuals qua participants in particular social orders embodying particular conceptions of rationality. (MacIntyre, 1987b, p. 4)
The intimate relationship between intelligibility in everyday exchange and adherence to some tradition of judgment and enquiry is no small point.7 Not to be understood is a form of social death that befalls those who step outside some tradition of rationality or whose social circumstances bring them into the milieu of an alien tradition. MacIntyre maintains that it is only the ability of one tradition to provide better understandings of those conflicts and failings of other traditions than they can provide for themselves that enables us to judge (by historically established traditional standards) its rational superiority (MacIntyre, 1988). This can happen only through learning the language and rationality of the other tradition against which one aims to make one’s claims. As Porter comments, ‘We might say that, on MacIntyre’s view, the necessity for standing outside of any tradition whatever is obviated by the possibility of standing within two traditions at once in order to move between them in a comparative assessment of their
92
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
claims’ (Porter, 2003, p. 53). Without such a ‘second first language’ (MacIntyre, 1988, pp. 370–388, 403) the prosecution of such an argument is as fruitless as relativists hold – but theirs too is not a position from nowhere. This argument can barely be made in such abstract terms as we have used and in and of itself will convince no one. We instead require narratives that demonstrate the ways in which encounters between traditions turn out. For this reason, MacIntyre constructs precisely such narratives (1967, 1988, 1990a, 2007) and in his intellectual biography of Edith Stein (2004a) recounts the conversions of Stein and a number of her phenomenological associates (Reinach, Rosenzweig and Luka´cs). Conversions require those who undertake them to understand at least two traditions (despite sometimes more and less permeable and precarious boundaries between them) and the always open possibility that they might be brought together in the foundational acts and testaments of some new tradition. Examples include (supremely for MacIntyre), Aquinas’s creative combination of Christian doctrine and Aristotelian teleology and MacIntyre’s own creative assimilation of both the Marxist analysis of capitalist society and the historic and hermeneutic turn in philosophy within Thomism. MacIntyre suggested in his contribution to the Festschrift for Gadamer’s 100th Birthday that ‘modern Thomism only exhibited an awareness of the historical and hermeneutic turn in philosophy relatively late in its history’ (MacIntyre, 2002, p. 157). The modern Thomist whose life work has best exhibited this turn, is MacIntyre himself. As Lutz (2004, pp. 28–29) argues, MacIntyre’s own history of creative engagement with traditions itself constitutes an argument for such engagement. Let us summarize the case we have made so far. Against what Knight (2008) terms the conservative phenomenology of practices maintained by hermeneutics which claims that: philosophy is a human experience that remains the same and that characterises the human being as such, and that there is no progress in it, but only participation (Gadamer, 1986, p. 6)
and against its adherents in organization theory, stands MacIntyre’s progressive notion of practices and the traditions which co-constitute them. These include but are not limited to philosophical traditions that provide us with the schemes of rational justification which enable us to move towards truth. These traditions can attempt to demonstrate their rational superiority over their rivals, however, only if they are capable of maintaining dialogue with them such that learning might result (MacIntyre, 1988, p. 388, 2002, p. 166) in the same way that an agent can learn only by being accountable,
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
93
thereby ‘rendering him or herself vulnerable to dialectical refutation’ (MacIntyre, 1990a, p. 200).
Implications for Research Methods If the foregoing argument is well founded we should not be surprised to learn that a set of philosophical commitments unite MacIntyrean and hermeneutic attitudes towards research methods. The intimacy between social structures, social roles (particularly when conceived as distinctive characters)8 and the tradition-constituted framework through which notions as fundamental as agency and context are understood provides distinctive boundaries around the conduct of research. McMylor summarizes this well: The key to MacIntyre’s argument, for the sociologist in particular, lies in the view that there is no such thing as ‘‘behaviour’’ that can be identified independently of intentions, beliefs and settings. (2009, p. 4)
In Chapters 6–8 of After Virtue, MacIntyre argues from this position to critique both the idea of social science and the bureaucratic rationality whose claims it attempts to legitimize.9 However, this is liable to cause some confusion in readers, as Higgins observes: It may be MacIntyre’s special distinction to strike half of his readers as an old fashioned universalizing metaphysician (since he defends a version of tradition and teleology) while striking the other half as a dangerous relativist. (2004, p. 35)
Such readings err by maintaining conventional usage of both terminology and the constructs through which elements of that terminology (e.g. ‘tradition’ and ‘relativism’) are to be inter-related. For MacIntyre however tradition is an evolving set of debates and relativism is (among other things) a falsely derived epistemological conclusion from empirical observations. Nevertheless methodological limits are incontestable from what has remained almost unchanged in MacIntyre’s writings on epistemology and the conduct of enquiry10 and these point to the centrality of considerations of intelligibility, narrative, social structure and agency. In earlier collaborative work one of us described these limits in terms of a series of systematic exclusions (Coe & Beadle, 2008, p. 10): enquiries which do not relate themselves (including the possibility of critically relating themselves) to a tradition-constituted community of enquiry;
94
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
enquiries seeking to create law-like generalizations through the testing of hypotheses about causation through measurement of a defined list of variables;11 enquiries which do not report their findings in a narrative form; enquiries which exclude agents’ self-understandings in attempting to account for their behaviour; enquiries which exclude either features of institutions (structure) or the agency of subjects in their explanations; enquiries which do not recognize the ineliminable presence of the enquirers’ judgments in the accounts they present. The success of our enquiries depends on our ability to account for the limits imposed by both social structure and the self-understandings which social structures characteristically exhibit. Ruling out only ‘positivist conceptions of observability and verifiability’ (MacIntyre, 2004b, p. 6) whilst encouraging other forms of empirical research offers a wide range of choice for researchers in the MacIntyrean tradition. Both primary and secondary work is allowable, participant and non-participant observation, and even the presumption against positivist hypothesis testing does not preclude quantitative work as such. When we consider the empirical work that has specifically cited MacIntyre as its inspiration, an emphasis on ‘thick descriptions’ created through narrative is evident. These include Smith (1999), Dunne (1993) and Erben (2000) in education studies, Williams’ (1984) biographical narratives with the chronically sick, Coe’s biographical narratives exploring conflicts between goods at a major music venue (Coe & Beadle, 2008), Crockett’s (2008) structured interviews with entrepreneurs, Finchett-Maddock’s (2008) ethnography of squatting, Salter’s (2008) ethnography of alternative media, Nicholas’s (2008) auto-ethnographic reflections Eucharistic ceremonies and Dungeons and Dragons, Beadle’s (2003) circus auto-ethnography and follow-up storytelling narrative (Beadle & Ko¨nyo¨t, 2006; Beadle, forthcoming), Moore’s (2009) use of Crockett’s framework in his study of Alliance Boots and his study of churches as organizations (forthcoming), Beabout’s (2008) work on management in monasteries, Dawson’s (2009) master-narratives of British healthcare and Martin’s (2009) narratives of organizational identity. Some of this work promises empirical applications of a distinctively MacIntyrean organization theory. How would such a theory work and what does it offer organization studies? In Part Two, we consider MacIntyre’s ‘general theory’ of goods, virtues, practices and institutions and consider
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
95
briefly its relationship with ‘old’ institutionalism. In Part Three, we will illustrate this discussion with a worked example to show the impact of a distinctively MacIntyrean reading of a case study that exemplifies hermeneutic work in organization studies.
PART TWO: MACINTYREAN ORGANIZATION THEORY Goods, Virtues, Practices and Institutions Having shown what constitutes demonstrable victories and defeats for traditions and the importance of these encounters for a defensible account of rational justification, we now move to outline the tradition which MacIntyre claims to have demonstrated superiority through engagement with its rivals, that of the virtues (2007). In After Virtue MacIntyre provides his definitive account of their essential features – goods, virtues, practices and institutions.12 We began the first part of this chapter by distinguishing between the hermeneutic and MacIntyrean understandings of practice. In this part, we begin again with practice, for it is in the relationship between our participation in social practices and the discovery of our good, but also in the essential institutionalizing of such practices, that MacIntyre’s potential contribution to organization theory lies. For MacIntyre a practice is: Any coherent and complex form of socially established cooperative human activity through which goods internal to that form of activity are realized in the course of trying to achieve those standards of excellence which are appropriate to, and partially definitive of, that form of activity, with the result that human powers to achieve excellence, and human conceptions of the ends and goods involved, are systematically extended. (2007, p. 187)
Four central concepts inhere in this definition. Firstly, practices are social and co-operative activities. Secondly, the outcome of engagement in practices is the achievement of internal goods. MacIntyre later identifies internal goods with both the excellence of the products that result from the practice, such as ‘the excellence in performance by the painters and that of each portrait itself’ (2007, p. 189), and the perfection of the individuals in the process of such production (1994, p. 284). Thirdly, these standards of excellence have ‘been determined by the historical community of practitioners’ (Kallenberg, 2003,
96
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
p. 21) – ‘practices always have histories’ (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 221). So, fourthly, practices are systematically extended (are ‘transmitted and reshaped’ (ibid., p. 221)) through traditions comprising the successive rounds of internal conflict about, amongst other things, its own standards of excellence. Practices are widespread, indeed it could be argued that we spend much of our lives in them, since they include inter alia ‘arts, sciences, games, politics in the Aristotelian sense, the making and sustaining of family life’ (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 188). The virtues find their essential place in this schema because their deployment is the sine qua non for the achievement of the goods internal to practices: A virtue is an acquired human quality the possession and exercise of which tends to enable us to achieve those goods which are internal to practices and the lack of which effectively prevents us from achieving any such goods. (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 191)
Goods internal to practices include not only the generation and delivery of genuinely excellent products or services, but also the deployment of the virtues themselves – first to attain these goods and later, as desires are transformed, the exercise of the virtues becomes constitutive of the agent’s own good; the virtues thus become both means and ends and hence undermine that distinction. When developed in this way, virtues that find their initial constitution within practices find wider and wider applications within agents’ lives considered as a whole such that their self-image becomes a narrative quest for the good. Goods internal to practices, however, are not the only kind of goods and MacIntyre contrasts them with goods external to particular practices such as status, money and power. When achieved these are ‘always some individual’s property and possession. [They are] characteristically objects of competition in which there must be losers as well as winners’ (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 190). With internal goods, however, although there is competition in one sense, this is competition to excel and so benefits all members of the community engaged in the practice (ibid., pp. 190–191). In order for internal goods to be realized it is clear that practices need to flourish. To do so, however, they require institutions. And institutions are: characteristically and necessarily concerned with y external goods. They are involved in acquiring money and other material goods; they are structured in terms of power and status, and they distribute money, power and status as rewards. Nor could they do otherwise if they are to sustain not only themselves, but also the practices of which they are the bearers. For no practices can survive for any length of time unsustained by institutions. Indeed so intimate is the relationship of practices to institutions – and
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
97
consequently of the goods external to the goods internal to the practices in question – that institutions and practices characteristically form a single causal order in which the ideals and the creativity of the practice are always vulnerable to the acquisitiveness of the institution, in which the cooperative care for common goods of the practice is always vulnerable to the competitiveness of the institution. In this context the essential feature of the virtues is clear. Without them, without justice, courage and truthfulness, practices could not resist the corrupting power of institutions. (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 194)
MacIntyre’s description of institutions and their relationship with practices can be applied in almost any context, including those to which MacIntyre refers generically as ‘productive crafts’ (MacIntyre, 1994, p. 284). The particular practice may be fishing, or producing beef or milk, or architecture, or it may be, as we shall discuss below, providing services such as medicine. The common feature, however, is that all such activities fall within MacIntyre’s definition of a practice as ‘any coherent and complex form of socially established co-operative human activity’. But all such practices are institutionalized and MacIntyre provides both a warning and some exemplification as follows: ‘Practices must not be confused with institutions. Chess, physics and medicine are practices; chess clubs, laboratories, universities and hospitals are institutions’ (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 194). A key point for organization studies, then, emerges – that, whatever the mode of institutionalization (a point we will return to below), any organization may be re-described as a practice–institution combination.13 But this leads us to another important point in MacIntyre’s framework: the making and sustaining of forms of human community – and therefore of institutions – itself has all the characteristics of a practice, and moreover of a practice which stands in a peculiarly close relationship to the exercise of the virtues y. (2007, p. 194, emphasis added)
In other words, there is a second practice in any organization which is the practice of making and sustaining the institution. And hence those who have, in one sense, outgrown the core practice and now represent the institution that houses it, also have the same opportunity to exercise the virtues through engaging with that second practice.14 Fig. 1 represents an organization as a core practice situated within an institutional framework in which the smaller circle labelled ‘P’ is the practice of making and sustaining the institution.15 Both the practice at the core of the practice–institution combination and the practice of making and sustaining the institution that houses it have to be managed.16 Fig. 2 (based upon Moore, 2008) shows managerial engagement with both. Managers’ participation in the core practice declines with progression in organizational hierarchies, a distancing which potentially undermines both their achievement of the internal goods of the core practice and the
98
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
P
INSTITUTION Concerned with the achievement of external goods
PRACTICE Concerned with the exercise of virtue and the achievement of internal goods
Fig. 1. An Organization Represented as a Practice–Institution Combination Together with the Secondary Practice of the Making and Sustaining of the Institution.
relative attention such goods receive within decision-making. The compensating factor for managers, however, is their engagement with the practice of making and sustaining the institution from which they may, through the exercise of appropriate virtues, gain the internal goods thereby available. The Virtuous Organization Following this, we can identify various features of a virtuous organization and, associated with this, the responsibilities particularly of senior management for ensuring that these features exist and are nurtured. The first requirement of a virtuous organization, in conformity with Aristotelian teleology, would be that there is a good purpose for the particular practice– institution combination that it comprises. Secondly, the institution would be aware that it is founded on and has as its most important function the sustenance of the particular practice that it houses and following from this the organization would encourage the pursuit of excellence in that practice whatever that may mean for the particular practice in question. Thirdly, it would focus on external goods (such as survival, power, profit, reputation or success) as both a necessary and worthwhile function of the organization, but only to the extent necessary to the sustenance and development of the practice. Which particular virtues would characterize virtuous organizations? Although we might consider a wider list it is clear that justice, courage and truthfulness (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 194, cited above) are the sine qua non
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
99
Core practice
Institutional practice
Increasing level of management Increasing concern with ends Decreasing concern with means
Fig. 2.
The Relationship of Different Levels of Management with the Core Practice.
of MacIntyre’s schema, together with the virtues of integrity and constancy (MacIntyre, 1999b, pp. 317–318) which refer to their consistent application across practices and over time. The virtuous organization would require courage in order to resist the corrupting power of institutions with which it relates and to minimize the effects of the environment on its character where these might be damaging.17 It would require justice in order to distribute external goods appropriately, to weigh its own advantage with that of the wider community, to foster its own excellence through (for example) an allocation of roles that ensures that those who are truly best at particular tasks are appointed to do them, and to generate internal harmony through ensuring that subordinates accept the justice of their place (Klein, 1988, p. 60). Solomon’s (1992) emphasis on trust (by which we should infer the virtue of both offering trust to others and being trustworthy oneself) contains within its definition the necessity of truthfulness for organizational conduct. Such virtues would find their institutional embodiment in a number of features (Moore, 2005b). These are the development of a power-balanced structure that would ensure that the views and desires of particular constituencies are not privileged over those of others, and decision-making systems and processes that enable rational critical dialogue to have the effect of countering biases and enabling the questioning of the hitherto unquestioned (MacIntyre, 1999b, p. 313). While to some extent outside of its control, the encouragement of a supportive culture will also be a feature of the character of a virtuous organization.18
100
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
For our purposes here more needs to be said about two of these requirements of the virtuous organization. In relation to purpose MacIntyre is clear, as we noted above, that the virtues enable the achievement of a person’s telos of eudaimonia (2007, p. 148) at the individual level. But this telos always needs to be re-evaluated (2007, pp. 218–219) because it is only partially known – and hence what MacIntyre calls a narrative quest (a storied exploration) is involved (MacIntyre says that ‘the good life for man [sic] is the life spent in seeking for the good life for man, and the virtues necessary for the seeking are those which will enable us to understand what more and what else the good life for man is’ (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 219)). This narrative quest is necessarily communal and historically extended, a point made well by McCann and Brownsberger: y the normative character of MacIntyre’s definition of a social practice y is secured within a larger account of the moral life as a whole. There must be some telos to human life, a vision anticipating the moral unity of life, given in the form of a narrative history that has meaning within a particular community’s traditions; otherwise the various internal goods generated by the range of social practices will remain disordered and potentially subversive of one another. Without a community’s shared sense of telos, there will be no way of signifying ‘the overriding good’ by which various internal goods may be ranked and evaluated. (1990, pp. 227–228)
Translating this to the organizational level, we are left with an empirical question in judging the goodness of purpose of a particular organization. And the goodness of purpose is the extent to which the internal goods of the practice at the core of the organization contribute to the overriding good of the community and the extent to which there is a continuing debate within the organization as to what the community’s good is and how goods internal to practices contribute to it. The second requirement that we need to explore further here is the interrelationship between internal and external goods. MacIntyre makes the point that we must rank such that goods internal to practices (goods that are valued for their own sake) should be prioritized. External goods should be valued only insofar as they enable the achievement of internal goods (MacIntyre, 1988, p. 35). But this does not mean that external goods are not goods (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 196). This also leaves us with an empirical question as to the extent to which an organization prioritizes between the practice and the institution or, in other words, prioritizes between internal and external goods. But we should note that the virtuous organization is not one which prioritizes internal goods to the exclusion of external goods, but one that maintains an appropriate balance between them.
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
101
Preconditions for Virtuous Organizations In previous work (Moore & Beadle, 2006), we have identified three preconditions for such virtuous organizations. Space precludes a detailed consideration of these here, but in summary they are as follows. The first precondition is the presence of virtuous agents at the level of both the practice and the institution, for without agents who possess and exercise the virtues the practice itself would no longer be fostered internally through the pursuit of excellence, and at the institutional level the corruption of the institution and the consequent distortion of the practice would seem to be inevitable. This is particularly the case for those agents who hold decisionmaking authority in the institution. But the presence of such agents at both practice and institutional (managerial) level is clearly insufficient to guarantee the presence of organizational virtue. The second precondition for a virtuous organization is the mode of institutionalization which distributes both decision-making authority and decision criteria within institutions. It is clear that the same practice may be institutionalized in different forms and MacIntyre notes that, ‘practices are often distorted by their modes of institutionalization, when irrelevant considerations relating to money, power and status are allowed to invade the practice’ (MacIntyre, 1994, p. 289). In other words, we would expect that different institutional forms will support to different extents (and possibly even exclude, though see further below) the practices which they house. The third precondition for a virtuous organization relates to the environment in which it is situated. It is clear that MacIntyre regards organizations as open systems that are both affected by other organizations and able (in both positive and negative ways) to compartmentalize themselves from them. It is apparent therefore that a particularly significant factor in any organization’s ability to maintain and exercise the virtues is the extent to which the environment is more or less conducive to the practice it houses. MacIntyre warns: ‘We should therefore expect that, if in a particular society the pursuit of external goods were to become dominant, the concept of the virtues might suffer first attrition and then perhaps something near total effacement, although simulacra might abound’ (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 196). Hence, we would expect that an unconducive environment, and in particular one that was focused to too great an extent on external goods, would threaten organizational virtue. Empirical questions also arise from this discussion of the three preconditions for organizational virtue, for example: the extent to which one or another precondition predominates, whether strength in one can offset weakness in another and the extent to which the preconditions are mutually reinforcing.
102
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
MacIntyrean and Institutional Theory, and Reasons for Action The ‘goods–virtues–practices–institutions’ framework points to two central and symbiotically related tensions inhering in organizational life: those between practices and institutions; and those between the pursuit of goods internal to practices and the pursuit of external goods. The common goods of the practice cannot survive for any length of time unsustained by successful institutional pursuit of external goods, but practices are also and always vulnerable to the competititveness and acquisitiveness of the institution which houses them. In capitalist business organizations institutionalized in the AngloAmerican mode MacIntyre has argued that such vulnerability is endemic, to the extent that the institution has, in effect, ‘won’ over the practice – its justification is the pursuit of external goods – such that ‘much modern industrial productive and service work is organized so as to exclude the features distinctive of a practice’, and in such a way that this type of activity is ‘at once alien and antagonistic to practices’ (MacIntyre, 1994, p. 286). Despite this, however, the counter argument has been made (Moore, 2005b) that all business activities, irrespective of their form of institutionalization, must contain the vestiges of a practice and the virtues to some degree, for if they did not – that is, if the institution had ‘won’ so completely that the virtues had suffered ‘something near total effacement’ (MacIntyre, 2007, p. 196, cited above) – then the institution would have, in effect, killed itself from the inside by failing to sustain the practice on which it itself is founded. In other words, while in Anglo-American capitalist forms of business organization the practice may be potentially and continually under threat from the acquisitiveness and competitiveness of the corporation, it still exists.19 This counter argument, of course, suggests that MacIntyre is overly pessimistic in his assessment. Similarly, Keat (2008b) has argued that in other forms of capitalism, notably in ‘coordinated’ market economies such as Germany and Japan, industrial organization is such as ‘to be highly conducive to the internal goods and standards of excellence central to MacIntyrean practices’ (ibid., p. 77). And Moore (2002) notes that it may be necessary for institutions to observe and take corrective action when the practices that they house become so introverted and self-satisfied that they no longer set out to achieve ‘those standards of excellence which are appropriate to, and partially definitive of, that form of activity’ – as we shall see in Part Three.
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
103
Hence, in a variety of forms the essential and unavoidable tension between practices and institutions persists and plays out as a similar drama. MacIntyre highlights the tension as follows: the ability of a practice to retain its integrity will depend on the way in which the virtues can be and are exercised in sustaining the institutional forms which are the social bearers of the practice. The integrity of a practice causally requires the exercise of the virtues by at least some of the individuals who embody it in their activities; and conversely the corruption of institutions is always in part at least an effect of the vices. (2007, p. 195)
The tensions between practices and institutions are evidenced in a wide range of organization theory with ‘old’ institutional theory (a distinction from ‘new’ institutionalism outlined in Selznick, 1996) demonstrating particular sensitivity both to its features and to its own value commitments in ways which appear to us to be particularly resonant of MacIntyre’s framework.20 Selznick’s summary is especially revealing in this regard. The aim of the ‘old institutional theory’ is nothing less than: the quest for more effective and humane cooperative systems, including better ways of delegating responsibility and insuring accountability. (Selznick, 1996, p. 276)
Stinchcombe (1997, p. 17) similarly argues that ‘the trouble with the new institutionalism is that it does not have the guts of institutions in it. The guts of institutions is that somebody really cares to hold the organization to the standards and is often paid to do just that’.21 It is in and through organizations so conceived that practitioners, possessing and exercising the virtues within the core practice (and, for managers, within the institutional practice), realize the internal goods available and so are enabled on their narrative quest towards their true telos. These are organizations, as Stinchcombe puts it, with guts. Mapping the terminology of the old institutionalism onto MacIntyrean categories is problematic (a reading of Selznick, 1992, particularly Part 3, is instructive in this respect) but it is clear that they share similar concerns. MacIntyre’s use of the term institution is not identical with either old or new institutional theory,22 because his identification of the practices–institution nexus offers a new way of conceptualizing organizations (and, indeed, practice–institution combinations more generally). In identifying the embeddedness of social relations in practices, in defining the essential relationship between practices and virtues and in identifying institutionalization as one more practice, MacIntyre opens up organizations as essentially moral spaces – locations of moral action by moral agents operating both
104
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
individually and collectively. This identification offers to the ‘old’ institutional theory a philosophical foundation which will provide, amongst other things, a surer underpinning of its critique of ‘new’ (or as Stinchcombe (1997, p. 2) alleges ‘Durkheimian’) institutionalism in its failure to acknowledge its own value orientation. As we have seen there are potentially wide variations in the ways in which we might undertake distinctively MacIntyrean organizational analysis, but if the foregoing argument is correct none of these could ignore the ‘for the sake of’ (MacIntyre, 1988, p. 131) relationship in respect of reasons for action. Rational action is always accountable such that answers to ‘Why did you so act?’ questions (ibid., p. 131) take the form of a recounting of deliberations (which may have been implicit at the time of action itself) in which the actor moves from a notion of the good to be pursued to a (series of) judgment(s) about which actions best move the agent towards that good. Divorce action from the concept of the good and action is divorced from rationality and hence intelligibility: The application of the concept of intelligibility thus presupposes the application of the concept of a good, and a good reason is most adequately specified as a reason for doing something which will be or achieve some good. (MacIntyre, 1986, p. 75)
Our ability to provide reasons for action is learned, however, and one of the important features of modes of institutionalization is therefore the extent to which those who inhabit them may learn to become intelligible so that they can offer answers not only to questions such as ‘Why did you do that?’ but also to such questions as ‘Why is the reason you gave for doing that a good reason?’ It is in this latter type of question that the importance of both being able to distinguish between reason-affording arguments and the relevance of different types of context becomes apparent. These abilities are fostered by some and undermined by other institutional arrangements and participation in practices is itself the sine qua non for developing the ability to reason adequately.23 Institutions may present agents operating within them with formal statements of purpose, schematics for decision-making and informal routines (some of which we may call cultural) to direct their members in their decision-making and these to varying extents determine both a range of intelligible reasons and intelligible actions. MacIntyre’s own work on organizations (particularly 1964, 1977 and 1979a) has focussed on formal decision-making in which utilitarianism dominates such routines as Cost– Benefit Analysis and Job Evaluation. His critiques here as elsewhere (1967, pp. 207–208, 1999b, pp. 325–327) emphasize the reliance of such routines on
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
105
a series of denials and in particular the denial of reasoning about ends.24 Managers in such contexts bind their reason within the confines of institutionally determined purposes; borrowing from Hegel, MacIntyre’s (1964) paper describes this as ‘the spiritual zoo’ in which managers ‘live in separate cages and choose not to ask why there are bars or what lies outside them’ (1964, p. 13).25 It is not only utilitarian decision-making routines that impact upon organizational agents’ reasoning abilities. MacIntyre cites a number of studies emphasizing cultural power vested in authoritative figures and peer groups that disable agents’ abilities to report their reasons for action (1986, p. 72). He notes that none of these studies involved individuals ‘engaged in or developing the abilities acquired in practices’ (ibid., p. 72), an open invitation for empirical work to be undertaken involving just such individuals. Distinctively MacIntyrean empirics, holding to a notion of the organization as an essentially moral space, attempts to determine the relationship between reasons for action directed towards the achievement of goods internal and/or external to practices. In one example of such work, a decision to elongate the interval between two halves of a circus performance was determined to have been taken for the sake of optimizing the earning potential of the interval despite the damaging consequences of this to the achievement of goods internal to the practice of the circus arts (Beadle & Ko¨nyo¨t, 2006, p. 134). It is not only, however, in the relative weight given to the pursuit of internal and external goods that we can judge the extent to which the practice–institution combination is being held in an appropriate balance. It is of considerable importance to the virtues that to be moved by appropriate reasons for action is also to be able to give an adequate account of those reasons for action. It is only inasmuch as we are moved to action by the power of the good reasons themselves that we become practitioners whose desires are appropriately ordered. Such practitioners are able not only to practice but also to account for their reasons for action and therefore to become those from whom others can learn within the practice. Contrariwise, not only is it the case that our failures as moral agents are failures to be guided by the right reasons26 and that our inability to account for our decisions is a sure sign of our failure as moral agents, but also that practice–institution combinations which do not require us to participate in the type of reasoning in which we are mutually accountable themselves fail in one of their principal educative tasks. As we saw above it is only through a certain type of constrained conflict that traditions develop and it is only through engaging with the critical and argumentative resources of our traditions that individual practitioners can come to know what they are doing.
106
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
A central question for MacIntyrean organizational analysis will therefore be the extent to which practice–institution combinations encourage the types of participative enquiry through which we learn how to give, receive and question accounts in ways that extend our understanding of the goods at which we aim and thereby enable us to take better decisions. Sometimes these may be difficult decisions such as withdrawing ourselves from a sports team when we have a minor injury or admitting to error or lack of knowledge. It is in our failures to recognize that we have good reasons as practitioners to be moved by reasons for action which guide the practice, whether through pride, lack of understanding, venality and so on, that we fail. Systems of mutual accountability, in which such reasons are unacceptable within the accounts we routinely give of our actions, are critical institutional protections from the weaknesses and errors of practitioners themselves. In the first part of this chapter we showed how MacIntyre is both a friend and critic of the hermeneutic endeavour. In the second, we outlined his schema for understanding organizations and made some arguments for its proximity to the ‘old’ institutionalism, which led to a discussion of reasons for action. In the third part, we attempt to demonstrate how a MacIntyrean analysis would alter organizational analysis conducted within the hermeneutic/institutionalist tradition. The purpose for conducting this exercise would not be served by choosing a poor example of this form of work. Instead, we choose what we consider to be a very good example of such.
PART THREE: MACINTYREAN ORGANIZATIONAL ANALYSIS: A REWORKING OF WEICK AND SUTCLIFFE ON THE BRISTOL RVI The ‘Bristol Babies’ case, as it came to be known, is that of a preventable tragedy. It concerned the conduct of the paediatric cardiac surgery programme at the BRI, a teaching hospital in the south west of England, between 1981 and 1995. By the end of this period mortality rates rose to become significantly higher than the national average. A number of attempts by outside professionals, whistleblowers and parents to raise concerns about the unit and the hospital were met with denial and a refusal to investigate by senior managers. Eventually, following press and public outcry, the unit’s work was suspended and, following a lengthy and detailed public enquiry (Secretary of State for Health, 2001), a number of surgeons and senior managers were dismissed from their posts and subsequently
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
107
removed from their profession (‘struck off ’) by the General Medical Council.27 The Inquiry claimed that hospital management operated a ‘club culture’28 (thereby using Handy’s, 1985 nomenclature) in which data that should have been used to establish significant weaknesses in the programme went unused and the status and relationships of senior surgeons, senior managers and bureaucrats at the Department of Health enabled them to go unchallenged. One factor in this was the decision to designate BRI as one of nine Supra Regional Service (SRS) centres largely on grounds of geography rather than clinical expertise (which was identified as being poor in some respects), the physical layout of the hospital (which was detrimental to good care) and the case load (BRI’s low case load was considered inadequate to maintain sufficient expertise) (Weick & Sutcliffe, 2003, pp. 74–75). One example of this unchallenging attitude was a Department of Health official who, having received a dossier of evidence detailing poor practice and avoidable deaths among infants, merely telephoned the Hospital’s Chief Executive, received a verbal assurance and took no further action.29 The combination of surgical practices which had not been updated in line with the development of procedures elsewhere and institutional forces that prevented effective questioning meant that mortality rates (and those of permanent brain injury following procedures) remained steady in the unit despite halving elsewhere over the decade from the mid-1980s. Parents believed that up to 150 children suffered death or serious injury over the period in question.30 A further factor in the organizational context was a CEO whose managerial attitude to clinical care was one of ‘hands-off’, if not downright abdication: ‘You fix it’ (Weick & Sutcliffe, 2003, p. 78). His dismissal of the concerns of principal internal whistleblower, the anaesthetist Dr. Stephen Bolsin, was similarly on the grounds that this was ‘a clinical matter’ (ibid., p. 76). Despite the threat he perceived to his own career, Dr. Bolsin, explained his actions in the following terms: In the end I just couldn’t go on putting those children to sleep, with their parents present in the anaesthetic room, knowing that it was almost certain to be the last time they would see their sons or daughters alive.31
Weick and Sutcliffe (2003) interpret the Public Inquiry’s 530-page report through an hermeneutic of enactment in which social structures persist as a result of ‘a cultural mindset about risk, danger, and safety that was anchored by a process of behavioural commitment that shaped interpretation, action and communication’ (ibid., p. 74). They refer to this as ‘cultural entrapment’.
108
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
Drawing on the institutional theorists Salancik and Pfeffer’s (1978) notion of ‘behavioural commitment’ in which ‘behaviour becomes an undeniable and unchangeable aspect of the person’s world, and when he makes sense of the environment, behaviour is the point on which constructions and interpretations are based’ (Weick & Sutcliffe, 2003, p. 77), actors in these positions generate rationalizations which work only because they are regarded as culturally appropriate (ibid., p. 78). They cite as an example of this the Inquiry’s finding that at BRI explanations for poor performance were about case complexity rather than poor practices and these ‘tenacious justifications’ made it harder to learn, discontinue current practice and concentrate on evidence that supported rather than detracted from their position (ibid., p. 79). Drawing on Salancik and Pfeffer once more, the work of the surgical teams is characterized by high autonomy, visibility and irrevocability, whose combination required the creation of rationales for practices. When the rationales were put to the test they were found to be unsupportable, but for too long they persisted because ‘layers of bureaucrats above the surgical unit, people who had some say in the original choice to designate BRI as a centre of excellence, find their own judgments in jeopardy. The unintended consequence is that the whole chain of decision makers comes to support an explanation that makes it difficult for an underperforming unit to improve or to stop altogether’ (ibid., p. 80). Behavioural commitments thus entrap cultures through institutional processes of rationalization and protection. Weick and Sutcliffe draw three lessons from this. Firstly that those at the bottom of organizational hierarchies feel less pressure ‘to justify and construct acceptable errant reasons for errant actions’ (ibid., p. 80) because they were not involved in the choices that have led to them but, because they are dealing with those most affected, they are under immediate pressure to respond on behalf of the institution: ‘People at the bottom are torn between justification and candor’ (ibid., p. 81). Institutional support for candor and learning rather than justification and concealment will have a greater impact amongst those at the bottom of the institution because they are also not tempted to justify their own involvement in prior choices. Secondly, the professional autonomy of surgeons and CEOs ‘works against learning’ (ibid., p. 81). Justifications become self-perpetuating at higher levels. Thirdly, justificatory interpretation worked as it did due to the combination of autonomy, visibility and irrevocability in the ‘committing context’ (ibid., p. 82) and hence, ‘Accelerated learning, in this view, is more likely when the committing context itself is weakened’ (ibid., p. 82).
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
109
They recommend two lessons for hospitals. Firstly that acceptable reasons for action should centre on a notion of learning in which fallibility and vulnerability are acknowledged and secondly that hospitals should deliberately weaken the ‘committing context’ of choice, visibility and irrevocability so that ‘people are not forced to justify inadequate performance’ (ibid., p. 82). In its place acknowledged interdependence can moderate behavioural commitment to enable problems to be identified, errors acknowledged and decisions changed: Thus choice is reframed as a collective responsibility, such that the buck stops everywhere. Publicity is reframed as a collective commitment to provide constructive feedback to one another in order to improve performance. Irrevocability is reframed as a collective responsibility to identify escape routes, contingency plans, and to mentally stimulate potential interventions in order to spot potential traps. When choice, publicity and irrevocability are treated as collective responsibilities necessitated by task interdependence, this spreads responsibility but it does not diffuse it y Dogma precludes learning, and it precludes improvement. This is what happened at BRI and it need not happen again. (ibid., p. 83, emphasis retained)
Weick and Sutcliffe’s article is an excellent example of the use of institutional theory informed by hermeneutic commitments, whose focus on the relationship between systems of interpretation and action is (to these authors) persuasive. In respect of institutional processes and their effects a MacIntyrean analysis would differ only in nomenclature. Where Weick and Sutcliffe write of choice, visibility and irrevocability, a MacIntyrean analysis would write of the balance of power in institutional structures and the systems and processes through which decisions are taken. How, then, would a MacIntyrean analysis differ? Firstly, a MacIntyrean analysis would identify the goods internal to the practice (in this case of medicine), what its purpose is held to be in the tradition which constitutes it and thus what good reasons for action must be if they are to serve these goods. This is not just a matter of language, for in the MacIntyrean view hospitals derive their point and purpose from and only from the proper practice of medicine. By contrast, point nine of the Synopsis of the Inquiry Report found that ‘vulnerable children were not a priority’ (Secretary of State for Health, 2001). What is absent from Weick and Sutcliffe’s study, but notably not from the Inquiry report, the submissions of the affected families and the subsequent actions of the General Medical Council, were the ways in which the surgeons themselves failed as practitioners in their ability to reason adequately towards this proper purpose. A further element of a MacIntyrean analysis would have drawn particular attention to the social and co-operative nature of any
110
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
engagement in practices (the ‘interdependencies’ noted in Weick and Sutcliffe’s conclusion (2003, p. 83)), elements that were missing from the way the two key surgeons behaved in relation to their teams (ibid., p. 75). Attention to these issues would have sent early warning signals that all was not well. Secondly, a MacIntyrean analysis would draw a sharper distinction between the institution (the hospital) and the practice than Weick and Sutcliffe offer. Whilst agreeing with the examples given of the ways in which particular forms of institutionalization can undermine learning by corrupting the reasons for action that are legitimate within the practice, a MacIntyrean analysis would also consider the responsibilities of the institutional managers themselves for not providing systems and processes adequate to protect against poor performance; as noted above, it is partly their responsibility to identify ‘best practice’, potentially by comparison with other similar units, and this they signally failed to do. A MacIntyrean analysis would also suggest that, just because a particular organization has a good purpose, this does not prevent it from constructing a ‘mode of institutionalization’ which is less than supportive of organizational virtue. Weick and Sutcliffe’s conclusions address ways in which hospitals might create and support such systems, but their purpose is implicit – if we regard organizations as essentially moral spaces then it is clear that the institutional failures they describe were also moral failures exaggerated by an inadequate mode of institutionalization. Thirdly, the actions of the principal whistleblower, Dr. Bolsin, in resisting institutional pressure to conform, cannot be adequately theorized with the resources Weick and Sutcliffe have at their disposal because these neglect the critical role played by individual agency. Equally, the contrasting actions of the CEO in abandoning any responsibility for the core practice are highlighted by a MacIntyrean account. Such an account, within which individual virtue and vice always merits consideration, and in which the ‘standards of excellence’ of the practice and their systematic extension are always to the fore, is better equipped to provide an adequate explanation. In asking the ‘for the sake of what?’ questions of these two practitioners in relation to their reasons for action, it would identify and encourage the virtue inherent in Dr. Bolsin’s actions and his implicit concern for the internal goods of the practice, and it would identify and discourage the ‘for the sake of the institution’ approach of the CEO in which short-term expediency was privileged over a proper concern for the core practice. Fourthly, a MacIntyrean analysis would draw attention to the environmental setting. The decision to designate BRI as a SRS centre despite its
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
111
lack of expertise, the failure then to put in place systems to monitor and support its development and the implication of bureaucrats above the surgical unit in the unit’s explanations, all suggest that the environment was not conducive to organizational virtue. A MacIntyrean analysis would have identified the moral hazard inherent in the organizational environment and, again, sent warning signals much earlier in the saga. It is the use of distinctively moral and evaluative language that separates such analysis from the contemporary space of academic discourse in which technicist neutrality is at home. A MacIntyrean analysis cannot but attempt to bridge and thus critique the disciplinary boundaries between organizational analysis and organizational ethics. The former without the latter is devoid of what Stinchcombe calls ‘guts’; the latter without the former is reduced to wishful thinking. McMylor (2001, p. 23) argued that MacIntyre’s neglect by sociologists reflected his opposition to the dominant liberal assumptions of their practice, including the fact/value distinction and the academic authorial voice. The same argument could be made of much organization theory. What then are the prospects for a distinctively MacIntyrean organization theory?
PART FOUR: CONCLUSION – AN AGENDA FOR MACINTYREAN ORGANIZATION THEORY In Part One of this chapter we outlined both the family resemblance and distinctiveness of MacIntyre’s project from that of philosophical hermeneutics. In Part Two, we provided the outline of a distinctively MacIntyrean organization theory and suggested resemblances to the tradition of ‘old’ institutional theory. In Part Three, we illustrated both these resemblances and distinctions through the example of Weick and Sutcliffe’s study of the Bristol Babies case. Does any of this matter, however? Is there any evidence that MacIntyre’s framework is being used by organizational scholars and what does MacIntyrean scholarship have to do to demonstrate its potential? What we do not lack is critical engagement with MacIntyre’s ideas in the literature. In organization theory a special edition of Organization on MacIntyre’s work appeared in 1995 (Vol. 2:2) and in 2006 a special edition of Organization Studies on organizations and virtue (Vol 27:3) contained significant consideration of his work. Within business ethics debate has been joined around MacIntyre and markets (Horvarth, 1995; Dobson, 1996, 1997; Wicks, 1996, 1997; Dawson & Bartholomew, 2003; Keat, 2000, 2008a, 2008b), in management studies the Weberian character of MacIntyre’s
112
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
understanding of the manager has received attention (Anthony, 1986; Mangham, 1995; Brewer, 1997; Du Gay, 1998; Tester, 2000; Beadle, 2002; Holt, 2006; Moore, 2005b, 2008) and a variety of professional literatures have witnessed cases being made for their elevation to the status of ‘practice’ (Lambeth, 1990 for journalism, Sellman, 2000 for nursing, Leeper & Leeper, 2001 for public relations). Finally Beadle and Moore have debated whether business itself can be considered a practice (Moore, 2005a; Beadle, 2008b). What is more encouraging in our view (and more importantly MacIntyre’s, 2008a), is the development of empirical applications of his work (see section ‘Implications for Research Methods’ above for examples). Throughout this chapter we have indicated a wide range of empirical questions that arise and through which his particular blend of hermeneutics, tradition and ethics can be realized. But of all of these possibilities, where might a prioritized agenda for MacIntyrean research lie? We may be able to construct a range of classificatory schema through which to describe such work in terms of methods, subjects (critical or appreciative), storytelling genres, attempts to exemplify the virtues and attempts to test the relationships associated with them and so on, but any attempt to prioritize between categories would be fruitless because it would either rest on methodological commitments that undermine the breadth of work that can be legitimately undertaken under his auspices or it would presume a relationship between genre and quality that is itself unsustainable. In contrast, MacIntyre has suggested that what is important about such studies is their ‘directedness’ (2008a, p. 6); the work must be judged by its purposes in the same way as its objects are to be judged. The principal arbiter of directedness is the extent to which we can draw lessons for practice (ibid., p. 6). We cannot anticipate the success of our endeavours but the adoption of a MacIntyrean framework would fall hopelessly into the void of self-contradiction without an awareness of its own purpose. This then becomes the sine qua non of distinctively MacIntyrean research. Amongst the possibilities that this rejects is any suggestion that a chapter such as this, or empirical work supporting MacIntyre’s contentions, will convince those whose work is framed by other traditions. But such is not its purpose. This observation is pertinent because the condition of organization studies reflects closely the conditions whose critique is the object of After Virtue. This is of a contemporary social order in which distinctively moral utterance exhibits a cleavage between meaning and use such that its characterization as emotivism appears warranted. Debate is rationally interminable, viewpoints abound, reason as conceived and practiced is incapable of resolving any substantive matter and yet at the same time the
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
113
standards to which appeal is made are held to be independent of those by whom appeal is made. In organization theory we need look no further than our text books, journals or even this volume to witness the same. The most convincing texts are those that present difference most cogently. In seeking to overcome, rather than to accept or enjoy this kaleidoscope (Tsoukas & Cummings, 1997), MacIntyre writes a particular genre of history, one which reconstructs the past to explain the fragmentation of the present. To apply such methods to organization studies would require a similar historic reconstruction, of the type which engaged the mind of that great early institution theorist Tom Burns in the final years of his life.32 In the absence of such an undertaking, our purpose in this chapter has been to invite readers unfamiliar with MacIntyre to seek him out. Inasmuch as our representations of his work have failed to meet the standards and meanings of the original, as they surely have, the error is ours, but inasmuch as this chapter encourages readers to consider or reconsider the work of Alasdair MacIntyre himself, the credit is his.
NOTES 1. We will hereafter cite from the third edition published in 2007. 2. The International Society for MacIntyrean Enquiry (http://www. macintyreanenquiry.org 3. For example, MacIntyre demonstrates how different idioms used by translators of Homer in the sixteenth, eighteenth and twentieth centuries transform its meaning before remarking that, ‘Each translator uses an idiom familiar in his own time, the presupposition of whose use is some contemporary well-articulated account of the determinants of action and of the corresponding psychology imputed to the agent’ (MacIntyre, 1988, p. 17). 4. See Breen (2007) for a MacIntyrean critique of Habermas in the context of work organization. 5. Rand is one philosophical realist against whose Aristotelianism MacIntyre’s has been contrasted (Beadle, 2008a). 6. MacIntyre (2006, p. viii) has attested to his debt to Kuhn’s notion of scientific paradigms for the development of this conception. However the use to which Kuhn’s notion has been put in social science, as a motif for criterionless choice, is to be rejected. 7. In answer to a question at the Second International Conference of MacIntyrean Enquiry at St. Meinrad, Indiana in 2008, the theologian and sometime collaborator of MacIntyre’s, Stanley Hauerwas argued that the best argument against relativism was ‘Try living it’. The different traditions of substantive rationality to which relativists must point to make their arguments are always themselves universalizing traditions (MacIntyre, 1987b, p. 18). 8. See MacIntyre (2007, pp. 28–29).
114
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
9. The argument has a long pedigree in his work – see MacIntyre (1973) for example. 10. See especially Turner (2003), D’Andrea (2007, pp. 165–197), MacIntyre (1973, 1979b, 1990c, 2004b [1958], pp. 1–38). 11. MacIntyre does not rule out hypothesis testing as such but the results of such testing fall into the general limits that social enquiry must understand itself as working within, such that their results must take the form of ‘characteristically and for the most part y’ (MacIntyre, 2004b, p. 14). 12. This account is supplemented but not amended in later work which clarifies its inherent metaphysics (MacIntyre, 1999a, 2008c). 13. It is worth noting here that drawing this equivalence between organizations and practice–institution combinations does not preclude non-organizational examples of practices being institutionalized. The making and sustaining of family life (one of MacIntyre’s example practices) is institutionalized through arrangements such as marriage (often referred to as an institution of course), taxation and other fiscal allowances, and cultural mores which support it, without it being in any sense an organization. 14. MacIntyre’s condemnation of the character of the distinctively modern and hence emotivist manager (2007, pp. 25–29) has been widely discussed (Anthony, 1986; Mangham, 1995; Brewer, 1997; Beadle, 2002; Moore, 2008) but less attention has been paid to the argument that decision-making in practice–institution combinations requires management of a specific kind. 15. It is quite likely that many institutions will house more than one practice. Universities as institutions, for example, house parts of many practices in all the different subject areas which are represented. It is also possible for practices to extend beyond particular organizations so that the organization houses only a part of the practice – the practices of physics and medicine, for example, are housed only partly inside universities. For simplicity, however, we assume here a single practice within any particular institution. 16. A similar point arose in debates over both business (Beadle, 2008b) and teaching with MacIntyre’s argument that teaching is ‘not a practice, but a set of skills and habits put to the service of a variety of practices. The teacher should think of her or himself as a mathematician, a reader of poetry, an historian or whatever, engaged in communicating craft and knowledge to apprentices’ (MacIntyre & Dunne, 2002, p. 5). See also Dunne and Hogan (2004) for a series of rejoinders. 17. It must therefore resist the very processes of environmental influence to which new institutional theory points. 18. See Moore (2005b) for more on the distinction and relationship between organizational culture and character. 19. For a somewhat polemical argument that even Anglo-American capitalism need not be antithetical to the pursuit of internal goods through practices, see Dobson (2009). 20. There is a keen debate as to whether institutional theory is itself hermeneutic. Both Stott (1987) and Jennings and Greenwood (2003, p. 199) offer evidence for the hermeneutic roots of institutional theory though both Lok and Willmott (2006) and Weick (2003) are heavily critical of new institutional theory’s neglect of language and interpretation. Nevertheless we cite Weick and Sutcliffe’s (2003) use of Salancik and Pfeffer’s (1978) institutional account of ‘behavioural commitment’ in Part Three below. 21. There are parallels here with Granovetter’s (1985) notion of ‘embeddedness’.
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
115
22. We have noted briefly in previous work (Moore & Beadle, 2006, pp. 380, 384) the relationship of ‘new’ institutional theory to MacIntyrean organization theory, particularly in relation to the environmental precondition for organizational virtue. 23. MacIntyre’s fullest account of the conditions that are required for our development into independent practical reasoners is contained in Dependent Rational Animals (1999a). 24. MacIntyre’s analysis of this weakness in institutional decision-making has recently been echoed in his critique of rational decision theory as an account of individual decision-making (2008b). 25. We discuss both the effects of and responsibility for such compartmentalization in Beadle and Moore (2006). 26. It is important to note here that it is the narrative ordering of our lives that enables us to choose between practices – that is should one engage in the practice of writing an academic paper in preference to collecting one’s child from school? In a useful supplement to the discussion in After Virtue (2007), MacIntyre (1986) shows how we learn standards of reasoning within practice but must move beyond practice to the narrative ordering of goods in our lives considered as a whole. None of this negates the role of good reasons within practices as those generated by and through the tradition informing the practice and that have application to all practitioners qua practitioners. If in the course of setting up rigging on a boat or in a circus tent I have a good reason for checking the ropes, then so does everyone else setting up rigging. 27. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/special_report/1998/05/98/the_bristol_heart_babies/ 115367.stm; date accessed 21 April 2009. 28. Point 8 within the summary (Secretary of State for Health 2001). 29. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/1218149.stm; date accessed 21 April 2009. 30. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/special_report/1998/05/98/the_bristol_heart_babies/ 149666.stm; date accessed 21 April 2009. 31. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/532006.stm; date accessed 21 April 2009. 32. Tom Burns is the organizational scholar to whom MacIntyre makes most frequent reference (e.g. 2007, p. 106) The manuscript of this unfinished work, which also references MacIntyre, can be found at http://www.tomburns.org.uk/manuscript. html.
REFERENCES Anthony, P. D. (1986). The foundation of management. London: Tavistock. Beabout, G. (2008). Would the New St. Benedict need a manager? From Weberian bureaucrat to wise steward. Paper presented at the Second Annual Conference of the International Society for MacIntyrean Enquiry, St. Meinrad Indiana, July. Beadle, R. (2002). The misappropriation of MacIntyre. Reason in Practice, 2(2), 45–54 (the journal has subsequently been renamed Philosophy of Management). Beadle, R. (2003). The discovery of a peculiar good. Tamara – Journal of Critical Postmodern Organization Science, 2(3), 60–68. Beadle, R. (2008a). Rand and MacIntyre on moral agency. Journal of Ayn Rand Studies, 9(2), 1–23. Beadle, R. (2008b). Why business is not a practice. Analyse and Kritik, 30(1), 227–241.
116
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
Beadle, R. (forthcoming). On the Difference between Circus and Non-Circus Lives. In: Y. Carmeli (Ed.). Between Center and Periphery: The Circus as Modernity in a Nutshell. Lanham, MD: University Press of America/Hamilton Books. Beadle, R., & Ko¨nyo¨t, D. (2006). The man in the red coat: Management in the circus. Culture and Organization, 12(2), 127–137. Beadle, R., & Moore, G. (2006). MacIntyre on virtue and organization. Organization Studies, 27(3), 323–340. Blackledge, P., & Davidson, N. (Eds). (2008). Alasdair MacIntyre’s engagement with Marxism: Selected writings 1953–1974. Leiden: Brill. Breen, K. (2007). Work and emancipatory practice: Towards a recovery of human beings’ productive capacities. Res Publica, 13, 381–414. Brewer, K. B. (1997). Management as a practice: A response to Alasdair MacIntyre. Journal of Business Ethics, 16(8), 825–833. Burrell, G., & Morgan, G. (1979). Sociological paradigms and organizational analysis. London: Heinemann Educational Books. Coe, S., & Beadle, R. (2008). Could we know a practice-embodying institution if we saw one? Philosophy of Management, 7(1), 9–19. Crockett, C. (2008). MacIntyre: From transliteration to translation. Philosophy of Management, 7(1), 45–66. D’Andrea, T. (2007). Tradition, rationality, and virtue: The thought of Alasdair MacIntyre. Aldershot: Ashgate. Dawson, D. (2009). Conflicting stories of virtue in UK healthcare; bringing together organisational studies and ethics. Business Ethics: A European Review, 18(2), 95–109. Dawson, D., & Bartholomew, C. (2003). Virtues, managers and business people: Finding a place for Alasdair MacIntyre in a business context. Journal of Business Ethics, 48(2), 127–138. Dobson, J. (1996). The feminist firm: A comment. Business Ethics Quarterly, 6(2), 227–232. Dobson, J. (1997). MacIntyre’s position on business: A response to Wicks. Business Ethics Quarterly, 7(4), 125–132. Dobson, J. (2009). Alasdair MacIntyre’s Aristotelian business Ethics: A critique. Journal of Business Ethics, 86(1), 43–50. Du Gay, P. (1998). Alasdair MacIntyre and the Christian genealogy of management critique. Cultural Values, 2(4), 421–444. Dunne, J. (1993). Back to the rough ground: ‘Phronesis and ‘techne’ in modern philosophy and in Aristotle. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press. Dunne, J., & Hogan, P. (2004). Education and practice: Upholding the integrity of teaching and learning. Oxford: Blackwell. Erben, M. (2000). Ethics, education, narrative communication and biography. Educational Studies, 26(3), 379–390. Finchett-Maddock, L. (2008). An anarchist Wetherspoons or virtuous resistance? Social centres as MacIntyre’s vision of practice based communities. Philosophy of Management, 7(1), 21–32. Gadamer, H. G. (1986). The idea of the good in Platonic-Aristotelian philosophy (C. Smith, Trans.). New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. Gadamer, H. G. (2001). Gadamer in conversation, reflections and commentary – Edited and translated by Richard E. Palmer. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. Granovetter, M. (1985). Economic action and social structure: The problem of embeddedness. American Journal of Sociology, 91(3), 481–510. Grondin, J. (2003). Hans-Georg Gadamer: A biography. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
117
Handy, C. (1985). The Gods of management. London: Pan Books. Higgins, C. (2004). MacIntyre’s moral theory and the possibility of an aretaic ethics of teaching. In: J. Dunne & P. Hogan (Eds), Education and practice: Upholding the integrity of teaching and learning. (pp. 35–47). Oxford: Blackwell. Holt, R. (2006). Principles and practice: Rhetoric and the moral character of managers. Human Relations, 59(2), 1659–1680. Horvarth, C. M. (1995). Excellence v effectiveness: MacIntyre’s critique of business. Business Ethics Quarterly, 5(3), 499–531. Jennings, D. P., & Greenwood, R. (2003). Constructing the iron cage: Institutional theory and enactment. In: R. T. Westwood & S. Clegg (Eds), Debating organization: Point and counterpoint (pp. 195–207). Oxford: Blackwell. Kallenberg, B. (2003). The master argument of MacIntyre’s After Virtue. In: N. Murphy, B. Kallenberg & M. Nation (Eds), Virtues and practices in the Christian tradition. Christian ethics after MacIntyre (pp. 7–29). Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press. Keat, R. (2000). Cultural goods and the limits of the market. London: MacMillan. Keat, R. (2008a). Ethics, MacIntyre and markets. Analyse and Kritik, 30(1), 243–257. Keat, R. (2008b). Practices, firms and varieties of capitalism. Philosophy of Management, 7(1), 77–91. Klein, S. (1988). Is a moral organization possible? Business and Professional Ethics Journal, 7(1), 51–73. Knight, K. (2007). Aristotelian philosophy: Ethics and politics form Aristotle to MacIntyre. London: Polity Press. Knight, K. (2008). Practices: The Aristotelian concept. Analyse and Kritik, 30(1), 317–329. Lambeth, E. (1990). Waiting for a new St. Benedict: Alasdair MacIntyre and the theory and practice of journalism. Business and Professional Ethics Journal, 9(1–2), 97–108. Leeper, R., & Leeper, K. (2001). Public relations as ‘practice’: Applying the theory of Alasdair MacIntyre. Public Relations Review, 27(4), 461–473. Lok, J., & Willmott, H. (2006). Review of institutional theory: Language and discourse analysis: A comment on Phillips, Lawrence and Hardy. Academy of Management Review, 31(2), 477–480. Lutz, C. (2004). Tradition in the ethics of Alasdair MacIntyre: Relativism, Thomism and philosophy. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield. MacIntyre, A. (1964). Against utilitarianism. In: S. Wiseman (Ed.), Aims in education (pp. 1–23). Manchester: University of Manchester Press. MacIntyre, A. (1967). A short history of ethics. London: MacMillan. MacIntyre, A. (1971). Against the self-images of the age. London: Duckworth. MacIntyre, A. (1973). Ideology, social science and revolution. Comparative Politics, 5, 321–342. MacIntyre, A. (1977). Utilitarianism and cost–benefit analysis. In: K. M. Sayre (Ed.), Values in the electric power industry (pp. 217–237). Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press. MacIntyre, A. (1979a). Corporate modernity and moral judgment: Are they mutually exclusive? In: K. E. Goodpaster & K. M. Sayre (Eds), Ethics and the problems of the twenty first century (pp. 122–135). Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press. MacIntyre, A. (1979b). Social science methodology as the ideology of bureaucratic authority. In: M. J. Falco (Ed.), Through the looking glass: Epistemology and the conduct of enquiry, an anthology (pp. 42–58). Washington, DC: University Press of America. MacIntyre, A. (1980). Contexts of interpretation: Reflections on Hans-Georg Gadamer’s truth and method. Boston University Journal, 26, 173–178.
118
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
MacIntyre, A. (1986). The intelligibility of action. In: J. Margolis, M. Kruasz & R. M. Burian (Eds), Rationality, relativism and the human sciences (pp. 63–80). Lancaster: Kluwer Academic Publishers. MacIntyre, A. (1987a). Relativism, power and philosophy. In: K. Baynes, J. Bohman & T. McCarthy (Eds), After philosophy: End or transformation? (pp. 385–411). Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press. MacIntyre, A. (1987b). Practical rationalities as forms of social structure. Irish Philosophical Journal, 4, 3–19. MacIntyre, A. (1987c). Can one be unintelligible to oneself ? In: C. McKnight & M. Stchedroff (Eds), Philosophy in its variety: Essays in memory of Francois Bordet (pp. 23–37). Belfast: Queen’s University of Belfast. MacIntyre, A. (1988). Whose justice? Which rationality? London: Duckworth. MacIntyre, A. (1990a). Three rival versions of moral enquiry. London: Duckworth. MacIntyre, A. (1990b). First principles, final ends and contemporary philosophical issues. Aquinus lecture 54 (Reprinted in A. MacIntyre, 2006, pp. 143–179). Milwaukee, WI: Milwaukee University Press. MacIntyre, A. (1990c). Individual and social morality in Japan and the United States: Rival conceptions of the self. Philosophy East and West, 40, 489–497. MacIntyre, A. (1994). A partial response to my critics. In: J. Horton & S. Mendus (Eds), After MacIntyre (pp. 283–304). Cambridge: Polity Press. MacIntyre, A. (1999a). Dependent rational animals – Why human beings need the virtues. London: Duckworth. MacIntyre, A. (1999b). Social structures and their threats to moral agency. Philosophy, 7(4), 311–329. MacIntyre, A. (2002). On not having the last word. In: J. Malpas, U. Arnswald & J. Ketschner (Eds), Gadamer’s Century: Essays in honor of Hans Georg Gadamer (pp. 157–172). Cambridge, MA: MIT. MacIntyre, A. (2004a). Edith Stein. A philosophical prologue 1913–1922. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield. MacIntyre, A. (2004b [1958]). The unconscious: A conceptual analysis – Revised edition. London: Routledge. MacIntyre, A. (2006). The tasks of philosophy: Selected essays (Vol. 1). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. MacIntyre, A. (2007 [1981]). After virtue (3rd ed.). London: Duckworth. MacIntyre, A. (2008a). How Aristotelianism can become revolutionary: Ethics, resistance and utopia. Philosophy of Management, 7(1), 3–8. MacIntyre, A. (2008b). Conflicts of desire. In: T. Hoffman (Ed.), Weakness of will from Plato to the present. Catholic University of America Press. MacIntyre, A. (2008c). What more needs to be said? A beginning, although only a beginning, at saying it. Analyse and Kritik, 30(1), 261–281. MacIntyre, A., & Dunne, J. (2002). Alasdair MacIntyre on education: In dialogue with Joseph Dunne. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 36(1), 1–19. Mangham, I. (1995). MacIntyre and the manager. Organization, 2(2), 181–204. Martin, F. (2009). The organization, moral identity and organizational effectiveness. Presented at the 10th International Conference on HRD Research and Practice Across Europe: Complexity and Imperfection in Practice, Newcastle Business School, June.
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
119
Martin, J. (1992). Cultures in organizations. Three perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press. McCann, D., & Brownsberger, M. (1990). Management as a social practice: Rethinking business ethics after MacIntyre. The Annual of the Society of Christian Ethics, 223–245. McMylor, P. (2001). Classical thinking for a Postmodern World: Aladsdair MacIntyre and the moral critique of the present. In: K. Flanagan & P. Jupp (Eds), Virtue ethics and sociology: Issues in modernity and religion (pp. 21–50). London: Palgrave. McMylor, P. (2009). Sociology and morality: On the possibility of a unified MacIntyrean philosophical anthropology for the human sciences. Paper presented at the Third Conference of the International Society for MacIntyrean Enquiry, University College Dublin. Moore, G. (2002). On the implications of the practice-institution distinction: MacIntyre and the application of modern virtue ethics to business. Business Ethics Quarterly, 12(1), 19–32. Moore, G. (2005a). Humanizing business: A modern virtue ethics approach. Business Ethics Quarterly, 15(2), 237–255. Moore, G. (2005b). Corporate character: Modern virtue ethics and the virtuous corporation. Business Ethics Quarterly, 15(4), 659–685. Moore, G. (2008). Re-imagining the morality of management: A modern virtue ethics approach. Business Ethics Quarterly, 18(4), 483–511. Moore, G. (2009). Virtue in business: Alliance boots and an empirical exploration of MacIntyre’s conceptual framework. Paper presented at The Association for Practical and Professional Ethics Annual Conference, Cincinnatti, March. Moore, G. (forthcoming). Churches as organisations: towards a virtue ecclesiology for today. International Journal for the Study of the Christian Church. Moore, G., & Beadle, R. (2006). In search of organizational virtue in business: Agents, goods, practices, institutions and environments. Organization Studies, 27(3), 369–389. Murphy, M. (2003). Alasdair MacIntyre. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Nicholas, J. (2008). Eucharist and dragon fighting as resistance: Against commodity fetishism and scientism. Philosophy of Management, 7(1), 93–106. Porter, J. (2003). Tradition in the recent work of Alasdair MacIntyre. In: M. Murphy (Ed.), Alasdair MacIntyre (pp. 38–69). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Reames, K. (1998). Metaphysics, history, and moral philosophy: The centrality of the 1990 Aquinus Lecture to MacIntyre’s argument for Thomism. The Thomist, 62, 419–443. Salancik, G. R., & Pfeffer, J. (1978). A social information processing approach to job attitude and task design. Administrative Science Quarterly, 23(2), 224–253. Salter, L. (2008). The goods of community? The potential of journalism as a social practice. Philosophy of Management, 7(1), 33–44. Secretary of State for Health. (2001). Bristol Royal Infirmary Inquiry Final Report. The Report of the Public Inquiry into children’s heart surgery at the British Royal Infirmary 1984– 1995, Learning from Bristol. Presented at Parliament by the Secretary of State for Health by Command of Her Majesty, July 2001. Crown Copyright 2001. Available at http:// www.bristol-inquiry.org.uk Sellman, D. (2000). Alasdair MacIntyre and the profession of nursing. Nursing Philosophy, 1(1), 26–33. Selznick, P. (1992). The moral commonwealth. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Selznick, P. (1996). Institutionalism: Old and new. Administrative Science Quarterly, 41, 270–277.
120
RON BEADLE AND GEOFF MOORE
Smircich, L. (1983). Concepts of culture and organizational analysis. Administrative Science Quarterly, 28(3), 339–358. Smith, R. (1999). Paths of judgment: The revival of practical wisdom. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 31(3), 327–340. Solomon, R. (1992). Ethics and excellence. Cooperation and integrity in business. New York: Oxford University Press. Stinchcombe, A. L. (1997). On the virtues of the old institutionalism. Annual Review of Sociology, 23, 1–18. Stott, W. R. (1987). The adolescence of institutional theory. Administrative Science Quarterly, 32, 493–511. Tester, K. (2000). Weber’s alleged emotivism. British Journal of Sociology, 50(4), 563–573. Tsoukas, H., & Cummings, S. (1997). Marginalization and recovery: The emergence of Aristotelian themes in organization studies. Organization Studies, 18(4), 655–683. Turner, S. P. (2003). MacIntyre in the province of the philosophy of the social sciences. In: M. Murphy (Ed.), Alasdair MacIntyre (pp. 70–93). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Weick, K. (2003). Enacting an environment: The infrastructure of organizing. In: R. T. Westwood & S. Clegg (Eds), Debating organization: Point and counterpoint (pp. 184–194). Oxford: Blackwell. Weick, K., & Sutcliffe, K. (2003). Hospitals as cultures of entrapment: A re-analysis of the Bristol Royal Victoria infirmary. California Management Review, 45(2), 73–85. Wicks, A. C. (1996). Reflections on the practical relevance of feminist thought to business. Business Ethics Quarterly, 6(4), 523–532. Wicks, A. C. (1997). On MacIntyre, modernity and the virtues: A response to Dobson. Business Ethics Quarterly, 7(4), 133–135. Williams, G. (1984). The genesis of chronic illness: Narrative reconstruction. Sociology of Health and Illness, 6(2), 175–200.
Dr Ron Beadle is Reader in Organization and Business Ethics at Newcastle Business School, Northumbria University, UK. His collaborative work with Geoff Moore has provided a heuristic for a distinctly MacIntyrean approach to organization theory. He has published empirical applications of theoretical defences and MacIntyre’s work in Organisation Studies, Analyse and Kritik, Culture and Organization, Philosophy of Management, Tamara – Journal of Critical Post-Modern Organization Science and the Journal of Ayn Rand Studies. He is on the editorial board of Philosophy of Management and the executive of the International Society for MacIntyrean Enquiry. Geoff Moore is Professor of Business Ethics at Durham Business School, Durham University, UK. His collaborative work with Ron Beadle has provided a heuristic for a distinctly MacIntyrean approach to organization theory. He has published on the application of MacIntyre’s work to organizations in Business Ethics Quarterly and Organization Studies and has made various other contributions to business ethics and Fair Trade, in
MacIntyre, Neo-Aristotelianism and Organization Theory
121
Philosophy of Management, Journal of Business Ethics, Business Ethics: a European Review, Journal of Strategic Marketing and Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal. He is on the editorial boards of Business Ethics Quarterly, Journal of Business Ethics and Business Ethics: a European Review and is on the Executive Committee of the International Society for Business, Economics and Ethics, as well as being a member of the International Society for MacIntyrean Enquiry.
MARXIST PHILOSOPHY AND ORGANIZATION STUDIES: MARXIST CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE UNDERSTANDING OF SOME IMPORTANT ORGANIZATIONAL FORMS Paul S. Adler ABSTRACT This chapter aims to how Marx’s ideas and subsequent Marxist-inspired scholarship have contributed to the analysis of the various forms of work organization. It summarizes Marx’s basic philosophy, theory of history, and critique of political economy; it distinguishes more critical and more optimistic variants of Marxist theory; and it then shows how these ideas have been used in the analysis of key organizational forms, contrasting Marxist versus non-Marxist approaches and critical versus optimistic versions of Marxism. Keywords: Marxism; dialectical materialism; historical materialism; organization form.
Philosophy and Organization Theory Research in the Sociology of Organizations, Volume 32, 123–153 Copyright r 2011 by Emerald Group Publishing Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 0733-558X/doi:10.1108/S0733-558X(2011)0000032007
123
124
PAUL S. ADLER
INTRODUCTION It is hardly obvious that Karl Marx, a philosopher, economist, and revolutionary activist who died a century and a quarter ago, should have much relevance to organization studies today. Surely, the skeptic says, too many important features of contemporary organizations postdate Marx. On closer inspection, however, it is clear that organizations today share many fundamental features with organizations of Marx’s time. In particular, we still live with a basically capitalist form of society and enterprise. Even so, the skeptic retorts, social science has surely advanced since Marx. Here too, the skeptic is off the mark: social sciences find continuous nourishment in their classics (Alexander, 1987), and Marx figures prominently among the classics that continue to inform both social science in general and organization studies in particular (Adler, 2009b; Marens, 2009). Since Marx’s time, the general matrix of Marxist theory has not remained fixed in doctrinaire rigidity: numerous variants of the basic theory have emerged (Anderson, 1979; Burawoy, 1990). This chapter’s goal, however, is to highlight the most basic and enduring of Marx’s insights, and to show how they have contributed to the analysis of the various forms of work organization.1 The following sections discuss, in turn, Marx’s basic theory, Marxist contributions to our understanding of organization forms, and finally Marxism’s critics. My survey is limited to English-language publications and focuses on organization studies construed rather narrowly, ignoring Marxist work in contiguous fields of research such as accounting (on Marxist-related work here, see, e.g., Bryer, 1999; Tinker, 1999) or marketing (Lee & Murray, 1995).
MARXISM: KEY IDEAS Marx’s ideas can be grouped under three headings: philosophy (‘‘dialectical materialism’’), history (‘‘historical materialism’’), and economics (‘‘critique of political economy’’). The following sections review them briefly in turn.
Dialectical Materialism Reading Marx is sometimes exhilarating – his prose can be very compelling, especially as polemic; but contemporary readers can also find long passages excruciatingly opaque. This opacity is often the effect of Marx’s commitment
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
125
to dialectics as form of reasoning and presentation. The dialectical form is disconcerting to the unfamiliar reader; but it is rewarding once its assumptions are understood (see Ollman, 2003 for a particularly clear exposition of Marxist dialectics). Marx inherited and adapted the dialectical approach from Hegel. Hegel saw history as the progressive emergence of the Spirit (German: Geist), which can be understood either as the God-essence of the universe or as humanity’s understanding of itself. The Spirit evolves as a function of the contradictions among the key ideas governing successive periods (Zeitgeists): a thesis provokes the emergence of an antithesis, and the conflict between them eventually yields a synthesis. This synthesis abolishes the thesis and antithesis, but also conserves what was valid about them. The notion that the objective world embodies contradictions is rather foreign to the Anglo-American intellectual tradition: we often assume that contradictions obtain only between logical propositions, not between real things. However, this dialectical approach provides a fruitful heuristic device for characterizing the development of systems over time, especially social systems. Marx retained the ‘‘rational core’’ of Hegel’s dialectics, but turned it on its head, arguing that it is contradictions in the real world of human interaction that explain the evolution of ideas rather than vice versa. This mode of reasoning is visible right from the start of Marx’s magnum opus, Capital. Here Marx argues that the ‘‘germ’’ of capitalism – the inner core whose unfolding contradictions explain capitalist development – is the ‘‘commodity.’’ Marx uses this term to refer to any product or service produced for sale rather than for direct use. Commodities embody a contradictory unity of use-value and exchange-value. Unity because each pole of this contradiction presupposes the other: for the product to be created in the first place, the producer must believe it has exchange-value – power for the seller to command a determinate amount of money or goods in exchange; and to generate this exchange-value for the seller, the product must have use-value – usefulness to the purchaser. Contradictory unity because the two poles oppose each other: their disjointedness can put them in conflict with each other, and this in at least two ways. First, the producer anticipates the exchange-value of the product, but does not know until she reaches the market if this hope will be realized or if, on the contrary, the use-values that were consumed in producing the commodity will be wasted: pursuit of exchange-value can destroy use-value, for example, when new houses cannot be sold even at the builder’s cost, and when automobiles must be sold at a loss to move them off the lot. Second, when production is oriented to exchangevalue, there are many socially important use-values that will remain unmet,
126
PAUL S. ADLER
for example, clean environment, health care for all, and food and shelter for the homeless. This real contradiction embedded in the commodity form shapes both the structure and the historical trajectory of capitalism in multiple ways, of which I will discuss a few below. The notion of real contradiction has reappeared in mainstream organization studies as a kind of ‘‘paradox’’ (Lewis, 2000; Poole & van de Ven, 1989). The Marxian version locates the conflict that is at the heart of paradox in the real world, whereas many others use the notion of paradox to refer exclusively to theoretical conflicts created by inadequacies in our theories about the world. We should note in passing that among Marxists there is some debate as to whether the concept of real contradiction is of much use, or even preserves validity, in the study of the natural domain as compared to the social domain. Ollman (2003) offers a nuanced assessment, suggesting that the dialectical form of causality subsumes more ‘‘common sense’’ forms of causality as special cases, and that the dialectical form has proven powerful in analyzing social structures, most notably capitalism, but has proven less unhelpful in the natural sciences. In his ontological commitments, Marx’s dialectical materialism puts him in opposition both to ‘‘vulgar’’ materialism, which accords ideas no causal efficacy, and to ‘‘idealism,’’ which sees the world as driven entirely by ideas or, in the extreme versions, as composed only of ideas. Marx’s view is more consistent with ‘‘critical realism’’ as developed by Bhaskar (1975) and others (Brown, Fleetwood, & Roberts, 2002; Fleetwood & Ackroyd, 2004). Marx distinguishes between the knowledge that we have of the world and the knowledge-independent world around us. While all knowledge is provisional, the aim of science, including social science, is to discern the underlying forces that give shape to this latter, knowledge-independent world. These forces may not be immediately visible in the empirical world around us, but that fact does not negate their reality: invisible gravity explains the apple’s visible fall from the tree; the real contradictions hidden within the commodity form contribute to the persistence of economic cycles and crises. Science should aim to offer an account of the mechanisms that generate the more visible, empirical manifestations of these underlying forces. Marx thus has a ‘‘stratified’’ ontology, in which scientific explanation follows a path that ascends from the abstract, deepest, less visible structures to the visible, concrete, empirically observed world. In this, Marx is radically opposed to empiricism, which sees science as limited to discerning patterns in the visible world. And he is no less radically opposed to strong forms of social constructivism common in the discursive universe of postmodernism, for which the very pursuit of objective knowledge is illusory if not worse.
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
127
Notwithstanding Marxism’s rejection of strong social constructivism, dialectical materialism embraces the social nature of knowledge. Mainstream management scholars often contend that politics should not enter into processes of knowledge creation: they believe that value-neutral objectivity is the hallmark of proper scientific work and that advocacy would undermine that objectivity. Marx argues that there are no facts without theories: our access to the knowledge-independent world is always mediated by our existing concepts, and in a class-divided society, these mediating concepts are shaped (at least in part, and even if only unconsciously) by political value considerations. To adopt the standpoint of the dominant elite inevitably encourages the development of theories that legitimize and naturalize the status quo: such theories cannot penetrate deeply into the structures that give rise to this domination. The Marxist argument is that the view ‘‘from below’’ has greater potential to generate more complete and more objective knowledge – knowledge that raises consciousness about exploitation and helps movement toward emancipation. This idea has been taken up and generalized by feminist scholars: as Harding puts it, research should begin with the concrete circumstances and lived experiences of the ‘‘systematically oppressed, exploited and dominated, those who have fewer interests in ignorance about how the social order actually works’’ (1991, p. 150). In a social world of exploitation and domination, we can learn more about deep structures and how they can be changed by adopting the standpoints of the subaltern (see also Adler & Jermier, 2005; Harding, 2004; Wedel, Shore, Feldman, & Lathrop, 2005).
Historical Materialism In The German Ideology (originally published in 1845), Marx and his lifelong collaborator Engels mark their distance from Hegel and the Young Hegelians. They advance three main ideas. First, human action is constrained and enabled by its historically specific conditions: generic transhistorical theorizing is therefore a poor foundation for social science. Second, the ideas we work with, including abstract theoretical ones, are conditioned by our own historical context. And finally, because people must produce in order to live, the sphere of production is primary relative to the sphere of thought and culture. While the last of these ideas, expressing Marx’s materialism, is eternally unfashionable in intellectual circles, it does have counterparts in several streams of nonMarxist social science. The second idea is less common. And the first contrasts strikingly with most contemporary social science, where theory is considered more advanced precisely to the degree that it is based on ostensibly timeless
128
PAUL S. ADLER
features of human nature, of dyadic interaction, or of larger collectivities. Marx begins with the opposite assumption because he sees human nature as largely socially determined and therefore relatively plastic. The Communist Manifesto (originally 1848), the Preface to the Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy (1859), the Grundrisse (1857), and Capital (1867) further articulate Marx’s historical materialism. (See Cohen (1978) for a particularly clear exposition of historical materialism.) If production is primary and if human production is by nature collective rather than individual, then the most basic structure of society is its ‘‘mode of production.’’ (Concrete societies often embody residues of earlier modes alongside their dominant mode: for example, capitalism is dominant in India today, but coexists with feudalism.) Modes of production are defined by two sets of relations. ‘‘Forces of production’’ are humanity’s relations with the natural world, composed of material ‘‘means of production’’ (equipment, technology, raw materials) and human productive capacities (skills, etc.). ‘‘Relations of production’’ define the distribution across social categories (‘‘classes’’) of rights to ownership and control over these means of production. In the capitalist mode of production, for example, capitalists own the means of production and compete in product markets to sell their commodities, and workers own nothing but their labor power and compete in the labor market to earn a wage. On top of this ‘‘base’’ of forces and relations of production sits a ‘‘superstructure’’ of culture, religion, law, and government. This superstructure is the means by which the ruling class maintains its domination and attempts to moderate its internal conflicts. Marx’s materialism leads him to see causality flowing mainly upward, from forces to relations of production, and from base to superstructure, but he acknowledges the importance of downward causal paths, especially in shorter term and for more localized settings. Marx is famous for the Communist Manifesto’s assertion that ‘‘The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggle.’’ There is little specifically Marxist about a perspective on history that highlights conflict and struggle: Marxism is distinctive in (a) privileging class conflict where much non-Marxist history devotes more attention to international and intraclass conflict among factions within the ruling class, (b) seeing this class conflict as taking different forms depending on the structure of the prevailing relations of production, and (c) seeing the direction and scope of this conflict as shaped by the real contradiction between the relations and forces of production. The broad sweep of human history can be understood as the dialectical progression of successively more productive modes of production. In the European region, this progression was from primitive communism to slavery, feudalism, and then capitalism. This progression is dialectical insofar as the
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
129
emergence of a new structure is the result of the internal contradictions of the old. Class struggle between the exploiting and exploited classes is the motor of this progression; its overall direction is set by the vector of advancing forces of production. When the prevailing relations of production are no longer able to support the further advance of the forces of production, class conflict intensifies and the old class structure is eventually overthrown, allowing a new mode of production to emerge in which human productivity can develop further. Capitalism is distinctive in this sequence of modes of production because its characteristic relations of production greatly intensify pressures to develop the forces of production. In comparison, all previous modes are far less technologically dynamic. On the other hand, however, these capitalist relations of production simultaneously fetter the further development of the forces of production. This contradiction prompts Marx to predict as inevitable the emergence of a new form of society – communism – that would transcend the contradictions of capitalist society, preserving the positive historical achievements of capitalism (such as advanced technology and freeing the individual from the shackles of ascribed status), while abolishing private property in the means of production and freeing society from the anarchy of market-coordinated, profit-driven production.
Critique of Political Economy Capitalism as a mode of production emerges from small-scale commodity production when labor too becomes a commodity. This happens through a process of violent dispossession that deprives workers of alternative ways to access consumption or production resources, and that thus forces workers to exchange their capacity to work for a wage as if this capacity too were a commodity produced for sale on a market. Capitalist relations of production are therefore defined by two more specific relations: a relation of competition among commodity-producing enterprises and the wage relation subordinating workers to managerial authority in the enterprises that employ them. Marx’s analysis of the capitalist economy takes the form of a ‘‘critique of political economy.’’ Consistent with the philosophical premises discussed above, Marx argues that the economic base of capitalist society engenders a distinctive set of ideas about itself – a spontaneously generated ideology that he calls the ‘‘fetishism of commodities.’’ This ideology imputes causal powers to commodities and to their money equivalents, when commodities and money are in reality mere manifestations of underlying human activity.
130
PAUL S. ADLER
To give an everyday example: we often say that ‘‘the market’’ obliges a firm to cut production schedules and lay off workers. Marx argues that this locution makes a fetish of the market in the following sense: in capitalist society, we are alienated from each other; instead of collectively planning our production, we have put into place an anonymous mechanism – ‘‘the market’’ – which now constrains production and employment decisions; it is true that individual capitalists must submit to this mechanism, but behind the mechanism and explaining its apparent causal power lies the structure of capitalist relations of production. This fetishism is not merely a subjective illusion or error, but a (false) understanding of ourselves that is engendered by the social structure itself. A serious scientific account of the capitalist economy must penetrate below the level of surface appearance – where the market appears as a self-equilibrating and self-perpetuating mechanism – to reveal the historically contingent character of this capitalist social structure. It must therefore take the form of a critique of this spontaneous ideology. And this critique must encompass the more theoretically elaborated form of this ideology known in Marx’s time as ‘‘political economy’’ and today as ‘‘economics.’’ (See Foley (1986, 2006) for a particularly clear exposition of Marx’s economic views.) Marx builds on and critiques classical political economists such as Ricardo. He follows Ricardo in arguing that tastes, supply, and demand do not determine the price of a commodity (as argued current economic theory), but only influence its fluctuation around an objectively determined value. This value is determined by the socially necessary labor time invested in the product’s production. Note that, contrary to a popular misconception, this ‘‘labor theory of value’’ is not a normative theory but an analytic one: Marx is not arguing that value should be based on labor input; on the contrary, he is adamant that use-values typically also require a host of nonlabor contributions; his theory aims to explain how exchange-value works as the principle governing capitalist exchange. Marx develops his theory of the capitalist economy on the simplifying assumption that all products exchange at their values. (Marx goes on later to explain how prices also reflect different industries’ capital intensities, and how innovation allows producers to derive temporary ‘‘super profits.’’) If all products exchange at their values, we are immediately confronted with a puzzle: where do profits come from?2 This puzzle was the stumbling block for all prior theories of political economy, including Ricardo’s. To understand profit, Marx argues, we need to find a commodity that somehow creates value even as it is being used up. This special commodity is labor power. Firms pay workers a wage in exchange for the use of their ability to work – their labor
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
131
power. In principle if not always in practice, firms pay workers the value of this service, which is determined, as is the cost of any commodity, by the socially necessary labor time required to produce it, which is expressed in the cost of the daily consumption required for workers and their families as well as in their expenses for training and education. The employment contract specifies that in exchange for this wage, workers will make available their labor services for a specified period. The gap between the value of labor power (the part of the working day necessary to cover the worker’s wage, say four hours) and value produced by the expenditure of labor power (the product is sold on the market at a price that reflects the full eight hours work in the day – abstracting for now from the role of nonlabor costs) is a measure of exploitation. Given the level of productivity attained by the forces of production in the capitalist phase of historical evolution, it only takes a few hours in the working day for workers to produce the equivalent of their wages (‘‘necessary labor time’’), and employers can appropriate the value produced in the rest of the working day (‘‘surplus labor’’ and thus ‘‘surplus value’’) with which to pay both the nonlabor inputs and investors’ profit. Note that Marx characterizes these relations of production as ‘‘exploitation’’ not because the worker does not receive the wages representing the full value of the day’s labor: on the contrary, Marx celebrates the great progress in productivity that allows for the creation of surplus, just as he honors the need to reinvest that surplus. He sees this as exploitation because control over the surplus is in the hands of the capitalist, not the whole collectivity. And even if an individual capitalist were inclined to share control (indeed, even if the firm is run as a workers’ cooperative), the implacable constraint of market competition on product, labor, and capital markets obliges the firm to pursue every avenue for maximizing surplus – without regard to workers’ welfare – and to redirect this surplus to areas with greatest profit potential – without regard to social utility. In Marx’s account, exploitation is not an exceptional state of affairs, a departure from the norms of competitive market relations, but on the contrary, a fundamental, defining feature of the capitalist form of production even in its more competitive variant. The distinction between labor and labor power was, according to Marx, his great discovery. The resulting theory of the origin of capitalist profit is rather straightforward and intuitive. But to reach this insight, we need to penetrate the fetishism of commodities, and in particular to see the distinctive social relation hidden behind the commodity labor power: we need to recognize that in order for labor power to present itself as a commodity on a labor market, masses of people have been deprived of any alternative access to consumption or production goods, and have been forced to sell their
132
PAUL S. ADLER
creative powers in exchange for wage by subordinating themselves to the alien authority of the capitalist. Alienation in Marx’s theory – unlike most of the sociology that cites him – is thus not just a subjective state of mind, but first and foremost an objective feature of the social structure. Marx identifies two generic strategies for increasing surplus value. First, firms can extend and intensify the working day and can force more members of each family into the labor force. This generates what Marx calls the ‘‘absolute’’ form of surplus value. Second, employers can respond to competitive pressures by technological and organizational innovations that reduce necessary labor time. This generates the ‘‘relative’’ form of surplus value. When capitalism first establishes itself, firms usually leave the technology of production unchanged, and exploitation takes the form of increasing absolute surplus value. The resulting contrast in hours and intensity of work between traditional village life and early factory life has been documented in numerous scholarly and literary accounts (Thompson, 1963). This is what Marx (1977, Appendix) calls the formal subordination of labor to capital: it is merely formal because the underlying labor process is as yet unchanged, still relying on traditional techniques. As capitalism consolidates, the negative social externalities of excessive working hours and child labor prompt political action by both workers and enlightened capitalists, resulting in new laws and regulations. These restrictions increase incentives for firms to accelerate technological innovation, and as a result, relative surplus value becomes progressively more important, and we see the emergence of the real subordination of labor to capital as the labor process itself is progressively reshaped by the introduction of new production techniques. This shift represents the historical unfolding of the basic contradiction of the capitalist production process, a contradiction which itself reflects the contradiction between the two poles of the commodity form. On the one hand, the production process is a labor process, in which use-values in the form of work skills and effort, tools, and materials are combined to create new use-values. On the other hand, and simultaneously, it is a valorization process in which these use-values appear in the form of exchange-values – monetary wages, inventory costs, and capital investment – that are combined to create money profit (see Bottomore, 1991, pp. 267–270; Marx, 1977, Appendix; Thompson, 1989). Marx summarizes the real contradiction between the labor process and the valorization process as follows: If capitalist direction [of work] is thus twofold in content, owing to the twofold nature of the process of production which has to be directed – on the one hand a social labor
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
133
process for the creation of a product, and on the other hand capital’s process of valorization – in form it is purely despotic. (1977, p. 450)
The more conventional reading of Marx interprets this passage to mean that the technical imperatives of the labor process are subsumed or displaced by the social imperatives of valorization. The dialectical reading recalls that in Marx’s Hegelian discourse, content (here: the social labor process) and form (the valorization process) can be in a relation of real contradiction with each other. (The real contradiction between form and content, appearance and essence, is a common theme in Marx’s work. Geras (1971) explains the pitfalls of interpreting socially contingent forms as the true substance as well as the pitfalls of the converse illusion of seeing forms as a mere illusion.) On the one hand, valorization pressures drive capitalists to upgrade the capabilities of the labor process by ‘‘socializing’’ the production process, by integrating a widening spectrum of specialized skills into the ‘‘collective worker’’ – the community of more or less specialized workers as well as technical and managerial staff, cooperating to produce use-values. But, on the other hand, these same valorization pressures simultaneously drive capitalists to intensify their exploitation of employees in order to expand the capital invested in their firm, and this pressure breaks the collaborative fabric required for the effective functioning of the collective worker. The contradictions of the capitalist production process do not disappear with the shift from absolute to relative surplus value and from formal to real subordination – they deepen as socialization progresses. Marx’s analysis was not limited to the production process. Marx was one of the precursors of national accounting in his study of the distribution of economic activity between producer goods and consumer goods industries, and between sectors that produce new value and those that merely redistribute a fraction of the value already created (personal services, financial services, advertising and sales, real estate). He argued that competition between capitalists tends over the long period toward oligopoly. In his more mature writing, he argued that workers’ real wages would probably rise over the longer term. He argued that cyclical crises are an inevitable feature of capitalist development, periodically throwing masses of workers into misery and destroying productive capacities. He saw environmental crises too as inevitable in such a system. He argued that the imperatives of the capital accumulation process would drive the capitalist system to expand imperialistically, becoming increasingly global and creating interimperialist rivalries, wars, and massive social disruption, but also driving important positive changes for the working populations of
134
PAUL S. ADLER
the dominated countries as these workers are drawn out of precapitalist forms of despotism. He showed that capitalist development requires and stimulates the emergence of increasingly sophisticated credit and financial markets – and thereby multiplies opportunities for fraud (on the contemporary relevance of Marx’s analysis of finance, see Marens, 2009). Marx predicted – accurately – that as capitalism develops, government would play an increasingly important role in both directly assuring key services such as education and infrastructure and regulating the private sector. He was, however, skeptical that any degree of formal political democracy could change the fact that in a class-divided society, government, like the rest of the superstructure, reflects and reinforces the power asymmetry that defines the basic relations of production.
THE SCOPE OF MARXIST THEORY By comparison with other social theories, Marxism has several attractive features. First, it offers a broad historical perspective. For those anxious to understand how a better world might be possible, it is important to understand the historical specificity of capitalism and its distinctive forms of organization so as to highlight the implausibility of the notion (as advanced by, e.g., Fukuyama, 1992) that capitalism could be the ‘‘end of history.’’ Second, Marxist theory offers depth in its analysis of social life. It reveals the role of the social relations at the heart of the economic process. It has a rich conception of power that includes the possibility of ‘‘false consciousness’’ (Lukes, 2005): this concept may be slippery, but no serious discussion of power can ignore the corresponding reality. It has a rich theory of psychology (Cole, 1996; Se`ve, 1978). Third, Marxist theory does not deny the importance of the sphere of ideas and culture, but renders changes in this sphere more intelligible by highlighting their connections to changes in the material base of society. No critical point of view on society can be insensitive to the power of material interests in shaping discourse (as argued by, e.g., Eagleton, 1991). Finally, for scholars in organization studies, Marxist theory has the considerable advantage of embedding the analysis of organizations in a theory of the broader structures of society. It thus draws our attention, for example, to the possibility that the promising advances at the ‘‘leading edge’’ of capitalist development may coexist with – or even presuppose – the superexploitation of those at the lagging edge (e.g., Thompson, 2003).
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
135
Nevertheless, Marxist approaches to organization studies face major hurdles. One hurdle stands out as particularly challenging: Marxists’ difficulty in acknowledging real progress under capitalism. Marxist scholarship is partisan: it is constantly seeking to highlight the problems of capitalism and to show why these problems cannot be satisfactorily resolved without fundamental change in social structure. This partisanship tends to blind Marxists to the progressive effects of continued capitalist development. Marx himself was eloquent on these progressive effects. Capitalism accelerates productivity growth, which tend to bring higher material standards of living to working people and not only to the ruling class. It accelerates technological changes that facilitate travel and communication: these technologies bring people closer in their social lives and facilitate their struggles for emancipation. The imperialist expansion of capitalism pulls masses of people out of precapitalist exploitation into capitalist exploitation: for a young person drawn out of feudalistic exploitation in rural Pakistan into a factory, even a sweatshop, in Islamabad, that represents a considerable expansion of freedom. This imperialist expansion breaks down narrow regional, ethnic, and national boundaries, and as a result people around the globe come to recognize more of their common humanity. As women are drawn into the wage-earning workforce, they are progressively pulled out of the bonds of patriarchal family dependence: this trend is encouraged by the commodification of functions such a food production and by the direct socialization of other functions such as health care and child education. As capitalist industry becomes more automated, it needs more educated workers, and as a result, average education levels rise, and with this rise, workers develop a broader understanding of the world and they master tools for changing that world. Most of these progressive effects are due to what I referred to above as the socialization of production. This socialization makes capitalist relations of production increasingly obsolete and precarious: obsolete because productivity advances are increasingly a function of collaboration rather than competition and exploitation, and precarious because working people become increasingly better equipped to take over the leading role in society from individual capitalists and from the blind mechanism of the market. This analysis motivates Marx’s optimism that the passage from capitalism to a superior mode of production is inevitable, even if this passage proves to be a long time coming and even if the path to the emergence of this new mode of production is arduous. This socialization tendency is in a relation of real contradiction with the valorization imperative that characterizes capitalist production. Valorization
136
PAUL S. ADLER
both stimulates and retards socialization. Focusing on the latter, retarding effect, many Marxists argue – with considerable merit – that the positive effects of capitalist development are often chimerical. Where these positive effects have more substance and durability, Marxists often ignore them, asserting – accurately enough – that they already receive far too much attention from capitalism’s apologists. Where they pay attention to these positive effects, Marxists often denounce their unevenness – which is indeed scandalous – without acknowledging that the aggregate effects are progressive. The credibility of Marxist theory, the plausibility of Marx’s optimism, and the effectiveness of Marxist partisanship are impaired unless Marxism can account for capitalism’s positive effects, and unless it can show that these positive effects do not undermine the central Marxist thesis that capitalism’s basic contradictions cannot be remedied without replacing capitalism with a superior form of society. The challenge for Marxist social theory is therefore to ‘‘walk on both legs’’ – the optimistic leg reflecting socialization’s progress and the critical leg reflecting the enduring limits posed to socialization by valorization constraints. The concept of real contradiction helps Marxists meet this challenge – to acknowledge capitalism’s progressive effects while maintaining and continually renewing Marxism’s critical side. However, in the history of Marxism, there is an enduring tension between those who emphasize its critical side and those who emphasize its optimistic side.
MARXIST PERSPECTIVES ON SOME ORGANIZATIONAL FORMS This section reviews contributions by Marxists to the analysis of some key organizational forms. Space limitations preclude a comprehensive or detailed review, but within each subsection I identify the main arguments and distinguishing features of Marxist versus non-Marxist approaches and of critical versus optimistic versions of Marxism. The Historical Imperative Marxist theory encourages organizational studies to put contemporary organizational forms into historical context. As discussed above, Marx analyzed the transition in forms of organization from handicraft to manufacture to large-scale industry and toward automation, and underlying this transition, Marx identified the shift from absolute to relative surplus
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
137
value. His analyses of these various configurations have proven inspirational to many scholars in analyzing the evolution of forms of organization. More recent Marxist-inspired work in organization studies has built on this foundation, focusing on mutations in the nature of management control. Edwards (1979a) summarizes the main trajectory in the United States as a path from simple control, to technical control, to bureaucratic control. In Edwards’ account, simple and technical control correspond, respectively, to Marx’s absolute and relative surplus value, and the bureaucratic form is a more elaborate regime of relative surplus value that emerges in response to challenges to the legitimacy of technical control by dividing workers against each other and adding a normative layer. Others (e.g., Barker, 1993; Simpson, 1985) argue that bureaucratic control is increasingly being replaced by more internalized forms of control. Edwards and most other critical Marxists present this sequence as one that consolidates ever-greater management control. In a more optimistic Marxist vein, Hirschhorn (1984) and Adler (2001) argue that over the last century or so, evolving forms of management control have become progressively more socialized, encompassing a progressively broader range of human capacities and of business activities. Building on Barley and Kunda’s (1992) study of management journals that revealed alternating periods of focus on normative and rational controls, Adler (2003) argues that normative controls in the form of ‘‘industrial betterment’’ that began emerging in the 1880s relied on relatively primitive psychological mechanisms compared to the sophistication and subtlety of the personal and interpersonal processes invoked by the ‘‘human relations’’ approaches that emerged in the 1920s, and even more so compared to the ‘‘organization culture’’ approaches that emerged in the 1980s. Rational controls in the form of Taylor’s scientific management that emerged in the first decade of the 20th century focused on individual workstations and their interrelations, and since then rational controls have progressively enlarged the sphere of activities under conscious control (rather than ex post market coordination) to encompass entire, complex, internally differentiated organizations under the doctrine of ‘‘systems rationalization,’’ and then beyond the firm to suppliers and customers in the more recent period of outsourcing and business process reengineering.
Bureaucracy Bureaucracy plays a key role in this historical trajectory, and any discussion of bureaucracy must contend with Weber’s (1978) classic account.
138
PAUL S. ADLER
Mainstream sociology interprets Weber’s analysis of bureaucracy in two main ways. More conservative theorists read Weber as celebrating the efficiency of this form of organization. More critically oriented theorists highlight Weber’s discussion of bureaucracy as a form of domination legitimated by appeals to instrumental efficiency: they critique Parsons’ translation and interpretation of Weber on bureaucracy, arguing that Herrschaft should be understood as domination, not leadership or authority (Weiss, 1983). Recent organization theory has highlighted the noneconomic factors that encourage the diffusion of bureaucracy (DiMaggio & Powell, 1983); this has become part of a broad culturalist turn of neoinstitutionalism. Relative to these approaches, the Marxist tradition has been more alert to the specific role of bureaucracy in capitalist production. In Wright’s (1974) critical Marxist account, bureaucracy is prevalent not because of its efficiency but because it is effective as a form of domination appropriate to exploitative capitalist production relations (see also Clawson, 1980; Edwards, 1979b; Marglin, 1974). In the optimistic Marxist account, bureaucracy has a dual nature: as part of the forces of production, it is a powerful social organizing technology that enables the effective functioning of the collective worker; as part of the relations of production, it is a coercive mechanism of exploitation; since bureaucracy embodies this real contradiction, the experience of bureaucracy is typically ambivalent (Adler, 2006). The growing complexity and size of firms along with their progressive bureaucratization has meant considerable growth in the number of managers. On the Marxist account, managers play a contradictory role: on the one hand, they are agents of capitalist exploitation, and on the other, they are coordinators of a complex division of labor and part of the collective worker. Depending on their position in the hierarchy, one or other aspect will be more important; but Marxist theory highlights the extent to which all managers are agents of valorization. On the critical Marxist account, the growth of the management category represents a tendency to ever-more comprehensive management control over workers (Gordon, 1996). Optimistic Marxists suggest that we should also consider the socialization implied by this growth in coordinating capability. Van der Pijl (2004) draws an optimistic Marxist portrait of the senior managers in the private and public sectors of global capitalism, and the dual pressures they are under, as agents of both socialization and exploitation. A key issue in the study of bureaucratic forms has been the role of bureaucracy under socialism. Weber was pessimistic concerning the emancipatory potential of socialism, fearing it would necessarily rely on bureaucracy
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
139
to an even greater extent than capitalism does, and that socialism would therefore engender even greater alienation. According to Lenin, the organization of socialist production would require bureaucratically structured administration, not only because a suitably redesigned bureaucratic form would support democratic administration, but also because in the preliminary, socialist phase of the transition to full communism, class struggle would continue, and bureaucratic structuring would allow the socialist regime to control its enemies and avoid production sabotage. To make this instrument more suited to new, revolutionary ends, Lenin, like Marx, took inspiration from the Paris Commune of 1871, and recommended that the tasks of government and bureaucratic administration be simplified so that they can be performed by every literate person rather than only by specialized functionaries, that officials be elected and recallable, and that they be paid wages comparable to other workers. Hearn (1978) argues that Mao’s cultural revolution sought to create a form of bureaucracy that avoided the risks of technocratic domination by a combination of ‘‘politics in command’’ and the ‘‘mass line’’ – a set of processes that empowered lower-level functionaries and the citizenry at large (‘‘the masses’’) in their relations with the bureaucracy. More recently, a new round of reflection on these issues has been stimulated by a series of volumes edited by Wright as the ‘‘real utopias project’’ (http:// www.ssc.wisc.edu/Bwright/RealUtopias.htm). This project has some strong Marxist roots and addresses in a far more nuanced way the role of bureaucracy in a superior form of social organization.
Taylorism and Scientific Management A vast literature has grown up around the history of scientific management, its effects in specific organizations and its diffusion within US manufacturing (Nelson, 1980, 1992), its transfer overseas (Guillen, 1994), and its use in the public sector (Schachter, 1989). Taylorism is often vilified in mainstream organization studies for its dehumanizing effects. The Marxist approach has seen Taylorism as more than a (possibly ill-conceived) management technique: Braverman (1974) argues that Frederick Taylo’s scientific management provides the template for capitalists’ exploitation of labor; it is management’s program of real subordination made explicit. If, in the critical Marxist analysis, Taylorism is an offensive against workers, the optimistic Marxist view starts with empirical observations such as those by Nelson (1980) and Kelly (1982), who show that Taylor’s scientific management brought improvements in pay and conditions for
140
PAUL S. ADLER
many workers. Jacoby (1985) documents the rapprochement between the scientific management movement and the labor movement after World War I. Nyland (1998) discusses the strong leftist leanings of many of the key figures in the movement. Adler (1995) thus argues that scientific management represents a step toward greater socialization, since it created tools for designing work processes – tools that are neither the privately held tacit know-how of craft workers nor assertions of arbitrary power by foremen, but engineering models subject to verification and challenge by workers.
Lean Production Lean production has given rise to a sizable literature, some of it Marxist in inspiration (Adler, 1995; Babson, 1995a, 1995b; Elger & Smith, 1994, 2005; Smith, 2000). Much Marxist analysis has focused on lean production’s intensification of work effort, through eliminating unproductive pores in the work-day and further rationalizing workers’ movements. It is seen as an extension of Taylor’s scientific management. Quality circles are often a part of the lean production model, and these have been subjected to Marxist critique as manipulative efforts (Grenier, 1988). Optimistic Marxists add that lean production makes some important steps toward socialization. Teamwork has been systematized, as have relations between teams (Delbridge, Lowe, & Oliver, 2000). Lean production brings under planful control upstream (supplier) and downstream (customer) relations. Workers typically receive more training in the logic of the production system and in systematic improvement techniques (Adler, 2007; Kenney & Florida, 1993). Lean production, in this perspective, is a nice illustration of how contradictions deepen with capitalism’s advance, in particular the contradiction involved in the firm’s need for workers who are simultaneously dependable and disposable (Hyman, 1987).
Knowledge Management Knowledge management has recently become a popular theme in management literature. Marxist scholars have insisted that in reality very few knowledge workers can produce anything of economic value without access to means of production controlled by others, that only few occupations allow employees to use much of their knowledge, and that relatively few organizations invest substantially in employee learning. For the main part,
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
141
contemporary management is a direct descendant of scientific management in its effort to ensure that the key repositories of knowledge come under greater management control, even at the cost of productive efficiency. Some proponents of knowledge management decry this shortsightedness (Brown & Duguid, 1991, 2000; Davenport & Prusak, 1998), but few organizations appear willing to endow the collective worker with enough self-direction to develop comprehensive working knowledge (Jaros, 2004; Prichard, Hull, Chumer, & Willmott, 2000). Optimistic Marxists are more enthusiastic about even modest steps by management toward recognizing the power of knowledge. They see the real, albeit modest, growth in knowledge intensity of jobs as the embodiment of Marx’s prognosis of an increasingly ‘‘social individual’’ (Adler, 2001). In this, the optimistic strand builds on the assumption that all work, even the most routine, involves at least some knowledge: this may be tacit (Kusterer, 1978), but it is often collective (Spender, 1996). Lave and Wenger’s work on the concept of ‘‘community of practice’’ (Lave & Wenger, 1991; Wenger, 1998) has helped bring Marxist ideas to a wider audience, most notably the community of practice as the collective worker, and practice itself as the primary locus of knowledge.
Professions and Professional Firms There is considerable debate in both sociology and organization studies over whether the professions are destined to strengthen or weaken as capitalism advances. The stakes for the credibility of Marxist theory are high: Marx argued that the traditional middle class of small business would be destroyed by capitalist development, but acknowledged that new middle-class positions were constantly being formed as capitalist development created the need for more technical and management experts. If this latter trend were to predominate, and if these new categories formed a distinct new middle class, and if this new class developed interests distinct from and opposed to the working-class’s interests, then Marx’s basic argument about the future of capitalism would be seriously challenged (Boreham, 1983; Carchedi, 1977; Derber, 1983; Derber, Schwartz, & Magrass, 1990b; Johnson, 1977; Larson, 1980; Meiksins & Smith, 1996; Walker, 1979; Whalley, 1986; Wright, Costello, Hachen, & Sprague, 1982). The growth of such a new class has been predicted by many observers. Bell (1973), for example, argued that professions will gradually supersede corporations as the dominant organizing principle in society. Against this
142
PAUL S. ADLER
professionalization thesis, other observers point out that professionals themselves have been dragged under the capitalist juggernaut. Some, such as Haug (1973) and Rothman (1984), see a process of deprofessionalization due to increasing market rivalry between professions, the diffusion of expertise, and rising levels of public education and skepticism toward experts. Others (e.g., Derber, Schwartz, & Magrass, 1990a; McKinlay & Stoeckle, 1988) argue a more explicitly Marxist proletarianization position that highlights professionals’ progressive subordination to hierarchical and market rationality. Yet others follow Freidson’s diagnosis (1984) that there is little empirical support for the idea that professionalism’s distinctive features have eroded, but there is much evidence that regulation within professions has become more rationalized and formalized. Adler, Kwon, and Heckscher (2008) argue that capitalist development does indeed challenge the professions: the traditional ‘‘liberal’’ independent professional and their small-scale partnerships are being replaced by more hierarchically organized large-scale organizations. However, in an optimistic Marxist register, they also argue that professional work still requires a strong professional community – the effective production of these complex use-values requires a robust collective worker – and that the nature of this professional community is evolving toward a new, more advanced form that Marx might celebrate as prefiguring communism’s ‘‘free association of producers.’’ Contingent Work Marxist theory offers some useful lenses for studying the proliferation of ‘‘nonstandard’’ employment arrangements – part-time, interim, and contract work, the growing instability of regular employment, and the trend toward outsourcing (Kalleberg, Reskin, & Hudson, 2000; Osterman, 2000; Rogers, 1995; Smith, 1998, 2001). Empirical analysis reveals that contingent work has different effects and meanings for different workers: for some, it amounts to semi-unemployment, and for others, it is a wellestablished niche in specialized labor market (Barley & Kunda, 2004). Critical Marxists have shown how these new forms of work fragment existing collectivities. They undermine – often deliberately – the modest countervailing powers that some workers have managed to establish; they are particularly effective against unions. The loss of permanent status inflicts economic and psychological costs. From the optimistic Marxist point of view, contingent work appears to be in some cases a reflection of the deepening social division of labor, as activities are aggregated to form into new industries (e.g., engineering, food, or janitorial services). While economic
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
143
insecurity is often a source of real anxiety and suffering, in some cases, the ability to exercise choice in assignments is experienced as real freedom. This kind of flexibility has some positive progressive content, even if it takes an exploitative form. Network Organization Marxists have, since Marx, predicted growing concentration and centralization in industry, and therefore a tendency toward the domination of industries by large, bureaucratized oligopolistic firms (Baran & Sweezy, 1966). In this, they have been joined by writers from other, non-Marxist starting points, such as Galbraith (1967) and Schumpeter (1942). The rise of the ‘‘network’’ form – linking smaller, more focused firms in highly adaptable customer– supplier relationships – therefore represents a challenge to conventional thinking. Looking within organizations too, many observers argue that stable bureaucratic structures are giving way to flexible internal networks. Marxists have responded to this challenge in two main ways. Critical Marxists have focused on the power asymmetries prevalent in these networks, arguing that in practice these networks are neither idealized markets of voluntary exchange between equals nor warm solidaristic relationships between peers, but instead structures of domination (Fields, 2004; Harrison, 1997). Optimistic Marxists have argued that these networks, insofar as their distinctive mechanism is trust rather than competition or authority, represent a genuine, if partial, socialization of capitalist relations of production (Adler, 2001). Engestro¨m (2008) uses Marxist ‘‘cultural–historical activity theory’’ to explore the ‘‘knotworking’’ involved in continuously negotiating the crossorganization collaborations that mark the network form.
Families and Households The family is also an organizational form undergoing considerable change. The rise of single-parent households and the increasing involvement of women in the wage-earning workforce have deeply transformed the family. Cala´s and Smircich (2006) outline a broad spectrum of feminist approaches to organization studies. Their discussion of ‘‘socialist feminism’’ summarizes some of the key debates and insights associated with the Marxist tradition within feminism. (The earlier literature is reviewed by Thompson (1989), Hartmann (1981), and Vogel (2008).) A key contribution of feminist work to the Marxist project has been to challenge simplistic accounts of the relation between the realms of
144
PAUL S. ADLER
production and those of reproduction. Feminists have argued that the production process presupposes a reproduction process, that women and men play different roles in these two processes, and that these differences are interrelated. This interrelation is important for understanding not only the structures of family and nonwork life but also the role of gender within production relations (Acker, 2000; Acker & Van Houten, 1974; Cockburn, 1991; Game & Pringle, 1984; Kanter, 1977; Reskin & Ross, 1992; Smith, 2002; Wajcman, 1998). Within this broad field, feminist work has had a particularly fruitful dialogue with Marxism in the study of technology and the organization of both wage work and domestic work (Wajcman, 2004).
And Many More y There are many other organizational forms that space limitations preclude me from discussing: multidivisional, multinational, and conglomerate types of corporations; unions (craft, industrial, associational, partnerships with management); government agencies; political parties (electoral, network form); military organizations; volunteer organizations; open-source software communities; churches; mission-based organizations; cooperatives; feudal organizations; slavery-based organizations; prisons; etc. In most of these, Marxist ideas have had some impact, and in some areas, substantial.
MARXISM’S CRITICS Criticisms of Marxism come in many variants. Some criticisms are hastily dismissive. Buss (1993), for example, assumes that Marxist theory stands or falls by the record of the former socialist countries, and asserts that so many other theorists have decided it is wrong that it must be wrong. Donaldson (1985) is surely correct that much of what passes for Marxist organization studies is indistinguishable from left Weberianism, but he is surely wrong when he asserts that because Marxism is mainly concerned with broader social structures and history, it can have nothing to say about the specific issues at the organization level. The more substantive criticisms attack on a variety of fronts. An important current of criticism argues against Marxist theory’s focus on class as a collective actor in history, and in favor of methodological individualism. There is no denying the attraction of deriving generalizable results from parsimonious assumptions about individuals. Recent years have even seen the
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
145
emergence (then disappearance) of a small school of rational choice Marxists. Two problems arise for methodological individualism. First, in order to make the mathematics of aggregation work, these assumptions about human nature must be extremely simplistic and unrealistic. Second, there is no good theoretical reason to privilege the microlevel over the aggregate levels: causality goes both up from the individual and down from the collectivity, evolutionary biologists have made a strong case for the survival advantages of solidaristic altruism. Marx’s materialism is a common point of attack. Many scholars want to accord ideas and culture primacy. Adler and Borys (1993) argue that this is a debate that can be usefully joined, since the Marxist argument for materialism concerns primarily the longer-term and larger-scale transformations. On the Marxist view, local and short-term phenomena may well be primarily caused by ‘‘superstructural’’ factors, even as these factors are shaped by material ones over the broader spaces and the longer term. Discourse thus plays an important role in social change, but it is itself materially conditioned (see also Cloud, 1994, 2001). Marxism is often criticized as a deterministic theory. The criticism is hard to evaluate, since Marx offers no specific time frame for its predictions (Desai, 2002). Moreover, Marx’s predictions themselves are rather soft: they are formulated as trends, and are usually stated along with counteracting forces. At root, this criticism seems to be directed against any theory that prioritizes structure over agency as an explanatory principle. Against this criticism, Marxists respond simply that people make history, but not under conditions of their own choosing; that those conditions limit the options open and resources available for action; and that as a result, although agency may be a powerful explanatory axis for local outcomes of small groups, it cannot provide an explanation for broad historical trends. More specifically, Marxism is often attacked for its technological determinism. Critical Marxists shy well clear of technological determinism, focusing on the role of class interests in shaping technology’s trajectory (Noble, 1984). Optimistic Marxists by contrast embrace a soft form of technological determinism (Adler, 1989): they allow that capitalist relations of production accelerate the rate of technological change and that they encourage some directions of technology development at the expense of others, but they argue that there is a transhistorical, ‘‘anthropological’’ imperative driving the development of technologies that improve the productivity of labor, and that no ruling class has a durable interest in fostering the sustained regression of productivity. They argue that the natural world powerfully constrains the vectors of technological innovation
146
PAUL S. ADLER
that can satisfy this imperative, and they thus reject the ‘‘strong social constructionist’’ thesis that would explain technology’s overall direction of development by reference to social structures alone. Many feminists, students of race and ethnicity, and other sociologists who study organizations more empirically find that at this level of analysis identities and projects are more powerful than class structure in explaining change. They are surely correct to criticize doctrinaire Marxists who refuse to accord nonclass dimensions of structure any relevance, but this leaves entirely open the question of the relative importance of these nonclass factors in determining the broader, longer-term sweep of history. Some critics engage this latter debate and argue that social class as Marx analyzed it has receded in importance as a dimension of social structure. These critics argue that the emergence of the ‘‘new social movements’’ reflects a deep transformation of capitalism. Clearly we need good theories of social movements, and clearly Marxism offers only a modestly useful starting point for such theory. However, it is not clear that these social movements will assume ever-greater importance relative to the class dimensions of social identification and social conflict. Major surges in worker militancy, whether in the 1930s or 1960s, were preceded by predictions quite as confident as those we have heard in recent years that class conflict had permanently disappeared. Ritzer and Schubert (1991) argue that there has been a progressive divorce of various post-Marxisms from Marxist thought. The Nietzschean mood has set many scholars to a deep skepticism concerning any ‘‘laws of history’’ such as Marx advances, and Nietzschean poststructuralism has joined forces with a wide range of mainstream theories to assert a greater role for contingency and path dependence in history. This debate is hard to join: it is difficult to see how dialogue can bridge such different theoretical tastes. On the other hand however, this divorce may be a generational phenomenon: the first generation of post-Marxists sought to define their distinctiveness by attacking Marxism, while scholars today appear more eager to find some common ground, whether it be between Marxism and postcolonialism (e.g., Frenkel & Shenhav, 2003, 2006; Prasad, 2003), Foucault and Frankfurt School critical theory (Willmott, 2003), and Foucault and Marxist labor process ideas (e.g., Sewell, 1998).
IN LIEU OF A CONCLUSION The relevance of Marx for organization studies appears to wax and wane in inverse proportion to the apparent durability of the capitalist order. With
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
147
rise of worker militancy in the advanced capitalist world and the surge of national liberation movements in the Third World in the 1960s, a generation of scholars emerged for whom Marx’s ideas constituted the basic intellectual matrix. With the waning of the workers’ and national liberation movements since the 1970s and the demise of the socialist bloc since the 1990s, Marxism lost much of its appeal for scholars in organization studies as in other fields. More recently, as the capitalist order came under threat from new waves of worker mobilization and from financial crises originating in the United States and the United Kingdom, Marx reappears on the agenda. The future of Marxist organization studies appears bright.
NOTES 1. This chapter is complementary to Adler (2009a). It shares a similar overall structure, but focuses on philosophy and forms of organization rather than on topics in organization theory. 2. Current economic theory assumes that tastes, supply, and demand determine price; that at equilibrium all ‘‘factors of production’’ are paid a price reflecting their marginal productivity; that this is true too of capital; and that profit is therefore determined by the marginal productivity of capital. While this understanding of profit sounds plausible at a microeconomic level, it has proven to be entirely wrongheaded at the aggregate, macroeconomic level – indeed, it is a nice example of fetishism. A famous debate in the 1960s between Marxist-inspired economists at Cambridge, UK, led by Joan Robinson, and mainstream economists in Cambridge, MA, led by Paul Samuelson, ended in the victory of the former, acknowledged by the latter, in arguing that the profit rate could not be derived from any such supply and demand process, but was itself a function of the aggregate rate of exploitation. Graduate economics education today simply ignores the whole issue, and proceeds oblivious to the resulting incoherence of the neoclassical synthesis (Cohen & Harcourt, 2003).
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Earlier drafts benefited from research assistance from Jade Lo and from comments by Michael Burawoy, Richard Delbridge, Steve Jaros, Martin Kenney, David Levy, Richard Marens, Mark Mizruchi, Craig Prichard, Mick Rowlinson, Paul Thompson, and Matt Vidal, even if there is much with which they still disagree.
148
PAUL S. ADLER
REFERENCES Acker, J. (2000). Gendered contradictions in organizational equity projects. Organization, 7(4), 625–632. Acker, J., & Van Houten, D. R. (1974). Differential recruitment and control: The sex structuring of organizations. Administrative Science Quarterly, 19(2), 152–163. Adler, P. (1995). ‘Democratic Taylorism’: The Toyota Production System at NUMMI. In: S. Babson (Ed.), Lean work: Empowerment and exploitation in the global auto industry (pp. 207–219). Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press. Adler, P. S. (1989). Socio-dets and techno-dets: Determinants of diffusion and implementation patterns of automated machine tools. Journal of Engineering and Technology Management, 6, 161–185. Adler, P. S. (2001). Market, hierarchy, and trust: The knowledge economy and the future of capitalism. Organization Science, 12(2), 215–234. Adler, P. S. (2003). Towards collaborative interdependence: A century of change in the organization of work. In: B. E. Kaufman, R. A. Beaumont & R. B. Helfgott (Eds), Industrial relations to human resources and beyond: The evolving process of employee relations management (pp. 353–399). Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharp. Adler, P. S. (2006). Beyond hacker idiocy: A new community in software development. In: C. Heckscher & P. S. Adler (Eds), The firm as a collaborative community: Reconstructing trust in the knowledge economy (pp. 198–258). New York: Oxford University Press. Adler, P. S. (2007). The future of critical management studies: A paleo-Marxist critique of labour process theory. Organization Studies, 28(9), 1313–1345. Adler, P. S. (2009a). Marx and organization studies today. In: P. Adler (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of sociology and organization studies: Classical foundations (pp. 62–91). New York: Oxford University Press. Adler, P. S. (Ed.) (2009b). The Oxford handbook of sociology and organization studies: Classical foundations. New York: Oxford University Press. Adler, P. S., & Borys, B. (1993). Materialism and idealism in organizational research. Organization Studies, 14(5), 657–679. Adler, P. S., & Jermier, J. M. (2005). Developing a field with more soul: Standpoint theory and public policy research for management scholars. The Academy of Management Journal, 48(6), 941–944. Adler, P. S., Kwon, S.-W., & Heckscher, C. (2008). Professional work: The emergence of collaborative community. Organization Science, 19(2), 359–376. Alexander, J. C. (1987). The centrality of the classics. In: A. Giddens & J. Turner (Eds), Social Theory Today (pp. 11–57). Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Anderson, P. (1979). Considerations on Western Marxism. London: Verso. Babson, S. (1995a). Lean production and labor: Empowerment and exploitation. In: S. Babson (Ed.), Lean work: Empowerment and exploitation in the global auto industry. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press. Babson, S. (1995b). Whose team? Lean production at Mazda U.S.A. In: S. Babson (Ed.), Lean work: Empowerment and exploitation in the global auto industry. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press. Baran, P., & Sweezy, P. (1966). Monopoly capital: An essay on the American economic and social order. New York: Monthly Review Press.
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
149
Barker, J. R. (1993). Tightening the iron cage: Concertive control in self managing teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 38, 408–437. Barley, S. R., & Kunda, G. (1992). Design and devotion: Surges of rational and normative ideologies of control in managerial discourse. Administrative Science Quarterly, 37(3), 363. Barley, S. R., & Kunda, G. (2004). Gurus, hired guns, and warm bodies: Itinerant experts in a knowledge economy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Bell, D. (1973). The coming of post-industrial society: A venture in forecasting. New York: Basic Books. Bhaskar, R. A. (1975). A realist theory of science. London: Verso. Boreham, P. (1983). Indetermination: Professional knowledge, organization and control. Sociological Review, 31, 693–718. Bottomore, T. B. (Ed.) (1991). A dictionary of Marxist thought. London: Blackwell. Braverman, H. (1974). Labor and monopoly capital: The degradation of work in the twentieth century. New York: Monthly Review Press. Brown, A., Fleetwood, S., & Roberts, M. (2002). Critical realism and Marxism. London: Routledge. Brown, J. S., & Duguid, P. (1991). Organizational learning and communities of practice: Toward a unified view of working, learning, and innovation. Organization Science, 2(1), 40–57. Brown, J. S., & Duguid, P. (2000). The social life of information. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Bryer, R. (1999). A Marxist critique of the FASB’s conceptual framework. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 10(5), 551–589. Burawoy, M. (1990). Marxism as science: Historical challenges and theoretical growth. American Sociological Review, 55(6), 775–793. Buss, T. F. (1993). Marxism is wrong, and thankfully, dead. Academy of Management Review, 18(1), 10–11. Cala´s, M. B., & Smircich, L. (2006). From the woman’s point of view ten years later: Towards a feminist organization studies. In: S. R. Clegg, C. Hardy, T. B. N. Lawrence & W. Nord (Eds), The Sage handbook of organization studies (2nd ed., pp. 284–346). London: Sage. Carchedi, G. (1977). On the economic identification of social classes. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Clawson, D. (1980). Bureaucracy and the labor process. New York: Monthly Review Press. Cloud, D. L. (1994). The materiality of discourse as oxymoron: A challenge to critical rhetoric. Western Journal of Communication, 58(3), 141–163. Cloud, D. L. (2001). Laboring under the sign of the new: Cultural studies, organizational communication, and the fallacy of the new economy. Management Communication Quarterly, 15(2), 268–278. Cockburn, C. (1991). In the way of women: Men’s resistance to sex equality in organizations. Ithaca, NY: ILR Press. Cohen, A., & Harcourt, G. (2003). Retrospectives: Whatever happened to the Cambridge capital theory controversies? The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 17(1), 199–214. Cohen, G. A. (1978). Karl Marx’s theory of history: A defense. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Cole, M. (1996). Cultural psychology: A once and future discipline. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.
150
PAUL S. ADLER
Davenport, T. H., & Prusak, L. (1998). Working knowledge: How organizations manage what they know. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Delbridge, R., Lowe, J., & Oliver, N. (2000). Shopfloor responsibilities under lean teamworking. Human Relations, 53(11), 1459–1479. Derber, C. (1983). Managing professionals: Ideological proletarianization and post-industrial labor. Theory and Society, 12(3), 309–341. Derber, C., Schwartz, W., & Magrass, Y. (1990a). Power in the highest degree: Professionals and the rise of a new Mandarin order. New York: Oxford University Press. Derber, C., Schwartz, W. A., & Magrass, Y. (1990b). Power in the highest degree: Professionals and the rise of a new Mandarin order. New York: Oxford University Press. Desai, M. (2002). Marx’s revenge: The resurgence of capitalism and the death of statist socialism. London: Verso. DiMaggio, P. J., & Powell, W. W. (1983). The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Sociological Review, 48(2), 147–160. Donaldson, L. (1985). In defense of organization theory: A reply to the critics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Eagleton, T. (1991). Ideology. An introduction. London: Verso. Edwards, R. (1979a). Contested terrain: The transformation of the workplace in the twentieth century. London: Heinemann. Edwards, R. C. (1979b). Contested terrain: The transformation of the workplace in the twentieth century. New York: Basic. Elger, T., & Smith, C. (Eds). (1994). Global Japanization? London: Routledge. Elger, T., & Smith, C. (2005). Assembling work: Remaking factory regimes in Japanese multinationals in Britain. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Engestro¨m, Y. (2008). From teams to knots. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Fields, G. (2004). Territories of profit: Communications, capitalist development, and the innovative enterprises of G. F. Swift and Dell computer. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Fleetwood, S., & Ackroyd, S. (2004). Critical realist applications in organisation and management studies. London: Routledge. Foley, D. K. (1986). Understanding capital: Marx’s economic theory. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Foley, D. K. (2006). Adam’s fallacy: A guide to economic theology. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press. Freidson, E. (1984). The changing nature of professional control. Annual Review of Sociology, 10, 1–20. Frenkel, M., & Shenhav, Y. (2003). From Americanization to colonization: The diffusion of productivity models revisited. Organization Studies, 24(9), 1537–1561. Frenkel, M., & Shenhav, Y. (2006). From binarism back to hybridity: A postcolonial reading of management and organization studies. Organization Studies, 27(6), 855–876. Fukuyama, F. (1992). The end of history and the last man. New York: Free Press. Galbraith, J. K. (1967). The new industrial state. New York: Houghton Mifflin. Game, A., & Pringle, R. (1984). Gender at work. London: Pluto. Geras, N. (1971). Essence and appearance: Aspects of fetishism in Marx’s capital. New Left Review, 65(1–2), 69–85. Gordon, D. (1996). Fat and mean: The corporate squeeze of working Americans and the myth of managerial ‘‘downsizing.’’ New York: Free Press.
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
151
Grenier, G. J. (1988). Inhuman relations: Quality circles and anti-unionism in American industry. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Guillen, M. (1994). Models of management: Work, authority, and organization in a comparative perspective. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Harding, S. (1991). Whose science? Whose knowledge? Thinking from women’s lives. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Harding, S. (2004). The feminist standpoint reader. New York: Routledge. Harrison, B. (1997). Lean and mean: Why large corporations will continue to dominate the global economy. New York, NY: Guilford Press. Hartmann, H. (1981). The unhappy marriage of Marxism and feminism: Towards a more progressive union. In: L. Sargent (Ed.), Women and revolution (pp. 1–41). Boston, MA: South End Press. Haug, M. (1973). Deprofessionalization: An alternative hypothesis for the future. Sociological Review Monograph, 20, 195–211. Hearn, F. (1978). Rationality and bureaucracy: Maoist contributions to a Marxist theory of bureaucracy. The Sociological Quarterly, 19(1), 37–54. Hirschhorn, L. (1984). Beyond mechanization. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Hyman, R. (1987). Strategy or structure? Capital, labour and control. Work Employment Society, 1(1), 25–55. Jacoby, S. (1985). Employing bureaucracy: Managers, unions, and the transformation of work in American industry, 1900–1945. New York: Columbia University Press. Jaros, S. J. (2004). Jacques’s (2000) call for a knowledge theory of value: Implications for labour process theory. Electronic Journal of Radical Organization Theory, 8. Johnson, T. J. (1977). Professions in the class structure. In: R. Scase (Ed.), Industrial society: Class, cleavage and control. London: Allyn & Unwin. Kalleberg, A. L., Reskin, B. F., & Hudson, K. (2000). Bad jobs in America: Standard and nonstandard employment relations and job quality in the United States. American Sociological Review, 65(2), 256–278. Kanter, R. M. (1977). Men and women of the corporation. New York: Basic. Kelly, J. E. (1982). Scientific management, job redesign and work performance. New York: Academic Press. Kenney, M., & Florida, R. (1993). Beyond mass production: The Japanese system and its transfer to the U.S. New York: Oxford University Press. Kusterer, K. (1978). Know-how on the job: The important working knowledge of ‘‘unskilled’’ workers. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Larson, M. S. (1980). Proletarianization and educated labor. Theory and Society, 9(1), 131–175. Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Lee, R., & Murray, J. (1995). A framework for critiquing the dysfunctions of advertising: The base–superstructure metaphor. Advances in Consumer Research, 22, 139–143. Lewis, M. W. (2000). Exploring paradox: Toward a more comprehensive guide. Academy of Management Review, 25(4), 760–776. Lukes, S. (2005). Power: A radical view (2nd ed.). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. Marens, R. (2009). It’s not just for communists any more: Marxian political economy and organization theory. In: P. S. Adler (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of sociology and organization studies: Classical foundations (pp. 92–117). New York: Oxford University Press.
152
PAUL S. ADLER
Marglin, S. (1974). What do bosses do? Review of Radical Political Economy, 6, 33–60. Marx, K. (1977). Capital (Vol. 1). New York: Vintage. McKinlay, J. B., & Stoeckle, J. D. (1988). Corporatization and the social transformation of doctoring. International Journal of Health Services, 18, 191–205. Meiksins, P., & Smith, P. (Eds). (1996). Engineering labour: Technical workers in comparative perspective. London: Verso. Nelson, D. (1980). Frederick W. Taylor and the rise of scientific management. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press. Nelson, D. (Ed.) (1992). A mental revolution: Scientific management since Taylor. Columbus, OH: Ohio State University Press. Noble, D. (1984). Forces of production: A social history of industrial automation. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. Nyland, C. (1998). Taylorism and the mutual-gains strategy. Industrial Relations, 37(4), 519–542. Ollman, B. (2003). Dance of the dialectic: Steps in Marx’s method. Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press. Osterman, P. (2000). Work reorganization in an era of restructuring: Trends in diffusion and effects on employee welfare. Industrial & Labor Relations Review, 53, 179. (Cornell University). Poole, M. S., & van de Ven, A. H. (1989). Using paradox to build management and organization theories. Academy of Management Review, 14, 562. (Academy of Management). Prasad, A. (2003). Postcolonial theory and organizational analysis: A critical engagement. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Prichard, C., Hull, R., Chumer, M., & Willmott, H. (Eds). (2000). Managing knowledge: Critical investigations of work and learning. London: Macmillan. Reskin, B. F., & Ross, C. E. (1992). Jobs, authority, and earnings among managers: The continuing significance of sex. Work and Occupations, 19(4), 342–365. Ritzer, G., & Schubert, J. D. (1991). The changing nature of neo-Marxist theory: A metatheoretical analysis. Sociological Perspectives, 34(3), 359–375. Rogers, J. K. (1995). Just a temp: Experience and structure of alienation in temporary clerical employment. Work and Occupations, 22(2), 137–166. Rothman, R. A. (1984). Deprofessionalization: The case of law in America. Work and Occupations, 11(2), 183–206. Schachter, H. L. (1989). Frederick Taylor and the public administration community: A reevaluation. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Schumpeter, J. A. (1942). Capitalism, socialism, and democracy. New York: Harper & Row. Se`ve, L. (1978). Man in Marxist theory and the psychology of personality. Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities Press. Sewell, G. (1998). The discipline of teams: The control of team-based industrial work through electronic and peer surveillance. Administrative Science Quarterly, 43(2, Special issue: Critical perspectives on organizational control), 397–428. Simpson, R. L. (1985). Social control of occupations and work. Annual Review of Sociology, 11, 415–436. Smith, R. A. (2002). Race, gender, and authority in the workplace: Theory and research. Annual Review of Sociology, 28, 509–542. Smith, T. (2000). Technology and capital in the age of lean production. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
Marxist Philosophy and Organization Studies
153
Smith, V. (1998). The fractured world of the temporary worker: Power, participation, and fragmentation in the contemporary workplace. Social Problems, 45(4), 411–430. Smith, V. (2001). Crossing the great divide: Worker risk and opportunity in the new economy. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Spender, J.-C. (1996). Making knowledge the basis of a dynamic theory of the firm. Strategic Management Journal, 17(Winter special issue), 45–62. Thompson, E. P. (1963). The making of the English working class. London: Victor Gollancz. Thompson, P. (1989). The nature of work (2nd ed.). London: Macmillan. Thompson, P. (2003). Disconnected capitalism: Or why employers can’t keep their side of the bargain. Work Employment Society, 17(2), 359–378. Tinker, T. (1999). Mickey Marxism rides again. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 10(5), 643–670. van der Pijl, K. (2004). Two faces of the transnational cadre under neo-liberalism. Journal of International Relations and Development, 7, 177–207. Vogel, L. (2008). Historical-critical dictionary of Marxism: Domestic-labour debate. Historical Materialism, 16, 237–243. Wajcman, J. (1998). Managing like a man: Women and men in corporate management. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press. Wajcman, J. (2004). Technofeminism. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press. Walker, P. (Ed.) (1979). Between labor and capital. Boston, MA: South End Press. Weber, M. (1978). Economy and society. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Wedel, J., Shore, C., Feldman, G., & Lathrop, S. (2005). Toward an anthropology of public policy. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 600(1), 30. Weiss, R. M. (1983). Weber on bureaucracy: Management consultant or political theorist? Academy of Management Review, 8(2), 242–248. Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. New York: Cambridge University Press. Whalley, P. (1986). Markets, managers, and technical autonomy. Theory and Society, 15(1/2), 223–247. Willmott, H. (2003). Organization theory as a critical science? Forms of analysis and ‘‘new organizational forms.’’ In: H. Tsoukas & C. Knudsen (Eds), The Oxford handbook of organization theory (pp. 88–112). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Wright, E. O. (1974). To control or to smash bureaucracy: Weber and Lenin on politics, the state, and bureaucracy. Berkeley Journal of Sociology, 19, 69–108. Wright, E. O., Costello, C., Hachen, D., & Sprague, J. (1982). The American class structure. American Sociological Review, 47(6), 709–726.
Paul S. Adler is currently Harold Quinton Chair in Business Policy at the Marshall School of Business, University of Southern California. He received his PhD in economics and management at the University of Picardie, France. His research and teaching focus on organization design, with a particular focus on technical, professional, and manufacturing operations.
BEYOND UNIVERSALISM AND RELATIVISM: HABERMAS’S CONTRIBUTION TO DISCOURSE ETHICS AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR INTERCULTURAL ETHICS AND ORGANIZATION THEORY Andreas Georg Scherer and Moritz Patzer ABSTRACT Ju¨rgen Habermas is one of the most important authors in contemporary philosophy. In this chapter, we analyse his contribution to the philosophical debate on universalism and relativism and consider its implications for organization studies and organizations operating in an intercultural environment. We briefly describe the critique of a universal concept of reason that has been forwarded by sceptical and postmodern philosophers. As a response to this critique, we outline the contribution of discourse ethics and analyse the theories of Ju¨rgen Habermas and his colleague Karl-Otto Apel. We explore the justification of discourse ethics and point out some problems in its argumentative logic. In the light of this critique, we outline some characteristics of an intercultural ethics that is based on constructivist philosophy and point to some encouraging prospects on the Philosophy and Organization Theory Research in the Sociology of Organizations, Volume 32, 155–180 Copyright r 2011 by Emerald Group Publishing Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 0733-558X/doi:10.1108/S0733-558X(2011)0000032008
155
156
ANDREAS GEORG SCHERER AND MORITZ PATZER
consolidation of the debate between relativistic and universalistic philosophers. Keywords: constructivism; critical theory; discourse ethics; intercultural ethics; relativism; universalism.
INTRODUCTION The aim of this chapter is to analyse Ju¨rgen Habermas’s contribution to the philosophical debate on universalism and relativism, and to consider its implications for organization studies and organizations operating in an intercultural environment. What is at issue in these discussions is whether and in what way a universal justification of reason and rationality can be achieved in the light of the pluralism of existing norms, values and lifestyles in the social world. Proponents of a universalistic perspective argue in the tradition of Kant and the Enlightenment, stressing the idea of a unity of practical reason. In contrast, proponents of a relativistic perspective are sceptical of this idea of a universal conception of reason and advocate a pluralism of cultures and forms of social life. Hence, the label ‘relativism’ stands for the understanding that concepts of reason and rationality are historically and culturally contingent, and cannot be justified trans-culturally or applied to radically different cultures (see Habermas, 1994, p. 135 ff.). The critics of a universalistic perspective formulate two reservations: (1) the advancement of a universal concept of reason represents an act of domination of a particular perspective and leads to an unjustifiable suppression of the pluralism of cultures and forms of life (e.g. Foucault, 1980) and (2) the validity and acceptability of a theoretical or philosophical claim can only be judged within the particular set of rules of the culture and form of life in which it is embedded (e.g. Lyotard, 1984, 1992; Rorty, 1989, 1990). The fact that these philosophical disputes have not yet been resolved is of relevance for social theory and practice. It is also relevant for our understanding of the role of organizations in society (e.g. Crane, McWilliams, Matten, Moon, & Siegel, 2008; Donaldson, 1989; Donaldson & Dunfee, 1999; Scherer, 2003; Scherer & Palazzo, 2007, 2008; Scherer & Smid, 2000; Steinmann & Scherer, 1998a). This is especially apparent in situations where culturally heterogeneous conceptions of morals, norms and orientations clash with each other and where no procedures or rules contributing to the resolution of these conflicts and acceptable to all parties involved are available. In the social world, individuals have at their disposal
Habermas’s Contribution to Discourse Ethics
157
shared meanings, established routines, and common norms that are the result of a common practice of life and contribute to the peaceful coordination of actions within their own cultures (see Giddens, 1984). However, agents from radically different cultures often do not have such a source of commonly accepted social rules and may therefore have radically different perspectives on how solutions to conflicts may be reached. Globalization can be understood as the process of intensification of economic and social exchange across national borders (e.g. Beck, 2000; Giddens, 1990; Scherer & Palazzo, 2008). This process increases the number of confrontations between actors and organizations from different cultural and national backgrounds. These conflicts often occur in regions beyond the reach of the regulations and enforcement mechanisms of the rule of law state (e.g. in failed states where regulations are weak and authorities are corrupted) and in areas where there is no shared understanding of norms and morals among individuals of different cultures (e.g. concerning the issues of seniority, gender, equality, etc.). In cases where there is no such common ground of shared social norms, disputes on appropriate behaviour may lead to power games and conflicts may remain unresolved (e.g. Gergen, 1995, p. 520 f.; Scherer, 2003; Wieland, 1997). Is there a universal concept of reason and in what way can it be helpful in resolving these kinds of conflicts? In the following we describe the critique of a universal concept of reason that has been forwarded by sceptical and postmodern philosophers. As a response to this, we both outline the contribution of discourse ethics and analyse the theories of Karl-Otto Apel and Ju¨rgen Habermas. Habermas and his Frankfurt colleague Apel developed an interesting alternative to the relativistic position. We analyse the justification of discourse ethics and also point out some problems in its argumentative logic. In the light of this critique, we outline some characteristics of an intercultural ethics that is based on constructivist philosophy and point to some encouraging prospects on the consolidation of the debate between relativistic and universalistic philosophers.
THE ‘UNITY OF REASON’ AND ITS CRITIQUE IN POSTMODERN PHILOSOPHY Two distinctive features characterize the postmodern epoch: (1) the decline of the nation state and (2) the critique of universal reason, described as follows: (1) On the one hand, postmodernity denotes the end of modernity and the decline of the power of the nation state as the main regulatory
158
ANDREAS GEORG SCHERER AND MORITZ PATZER
institution. Modernity is characterized by the belief in reason as initiated by the Enlightenment (objective reason replaces the pluralism of subjective or religious belief), by the establishment of the modern nation state system with the Peace of Westphalia (through the monopolization of power and the taming of internal and external conflicts), by the progressing secularization (with the growing division of state and religion) and later by the industrialization, bureaucratization and democratization of the countries of the Western world. The development of modern society led to the capitalist system of free and open markets and the democratic rule of law state as the most advanced institutions for a reasonable self-organization of the citizens, promoting individual freedom, safety and solidarity in the pursuit of happiness and prosperity (see Beck, 2000; Habermas, 2001e; Scherer, 2003, p. 11 f.; Zu¨rn, 1998). Today, in the course of the globalization process, the nation state is increasingly overstrained in its attempts to moderate the outcomes of the economic, political and social systems. Since the nations state’s powers of enforcement remain territorially bound, while organizations expand their activities beyond these borders, the nation state is increasingly losing its political steering capability (see Scherer & Palazzo, 2008, p. 416 ff.; Beck, 1992, 2000; Habermas, 2001e; Scherer, 2003). (2) On the other hand, the postmodern epoch stands for a pluralism of rationalities, meanings and cultural heuristics. This represents a mindset that rejects the idea of a universal justification of social norms. We will refer to this mentality as ‘postmodernism’. This scepticism has diverse sources (see, e.g. MittelstraX, 1989; Welsch, 1997), but can broadly be grouped around methodical and political motifs. The former, methodological aspects, rest on insights gained from the historic turn in the philosophy of science (see, e.g. Andersson, 1994; Lakatos & Musgrave, 1970). Kuhn (ibid., 1962) has shown that scientific progress cannot be perceived as a linear process of knowledge accumulation, but is characterized by the interplay of normal phases and scientific revolutions. Such revolutions are often the result of approaches standing outside of the traditional paradigm, and, hence, appear ‘irrational’ by established scientific rules. Feyerabend (ibid., 1975, 1978) took these results as the premise to propose that science itself had lost its privileged role in the process of rational knowledge creation. Science merely becomes a source of orientation among other forms of expression such as art, music or religion. The acknowledgement of this development was reinforced by the efforts to establish alternative paradigmatic foundations within the various disciplines of the social sciences as a reaction to the critique of
Habermas’s Contribution to Discourse Ethics
159
the naturalistic model of explanation. Burrell and Morgan, for example, have identified four social paradigms holding incommensurable beliefs on the concept of man, the concept of knowledge and how society is stabilized or changed (1979). In organization studies there is an ongoing dispute on the role of paradigms and the possibility of trans-paradigmatic standards of research. In the meantime, the view has been widely accepted that the universal validity claim of reason could not be upheld in the light of methodological and philosophical restrictions of inherently incommensurable social paradigms (Scherer, 1998; Scherer & Steinmann, 1999). Building on these methodological and philosophical reasons, some authors (e.g. Lyotard, Foucault, Derrida and others) developed a political programme. It is their understanding that the pluralism of existing practical orientations should be preserved and not be subdued by the formulation and enforcement of a unified concept of rationality. Knowledge about what is right or wrong is embedded in different autonomous language-games and social practices. Trying to establish a meta-discourse that embraces all of theses languagegames would be an unjustifiable dogmatic imposition of a moral concept of right or wrong and true or false (e.g. Lyotard, 1984). The social motif of postmodernism is thus one of the democratic pluralisms (see Schreyo¨gg & Koch, 1999, p. 7). Over recent years these considerations have found their way into the social sciences (e.g. Boje, Gephart, & Thatchenkery, 1996; Calas & Smircich, 1997, 1999; Hassard & Parker, 1993; Holtbru¨gge, 2001; Kilduff & Mehra, 1997; Schreyo¨gg, 1999), where they have had a profound influence on the reception and interpretation of the impact of globalization on social and economic phenomena (e.g. Clegg & Gray, 1996; Gergen & Whitney, 1996; Holtbru¨gge, 1996). The call to acknowledge the pluralism of rationalities stresses the need to transcend the idea of unity in favour of an idea of difference: In this phase of thought, which characterizes the current sociological thinking about globalization, there is a realization that convergence is neither necessary nor desirable; that individual entities differ greatly across national societies, as well as within them; that culture is critical; and that convergence is less likely and less productive than divergence. These themes become characteristic of postmodernism. (Clegg & Gray, 1996, p. 299)
Such a postmodern orientation for society as a whole and organizations in particular feeds hopes for a successful inclusion of the strategic and moral implications of a global community, with multinational organizations assuming political responsibility by simultaneously pursuing different strategies in heterogeneous contexts (see, e.g. Holtbru¨gge, 1996). Still, these hopes are confronted by apparent difficulties inherent in a postmodern
160
ANDREAS GEORG SCHERER AND MORITZ PATZER
perspective. Postmodernism seems to be helpful by contributing to a reflection of existing social structures and a critique of situations of power and dependency (Scherer & Palazzo, 2007). It appears, however, that postmodernism is not capable of making statements about the direction of the future social development. It is very tolerant of the pluralism of language-games and of existing social routines, and it lacks a normative-ethical guidance on how and in what directions conditions must be changed (see Willmott, 1998, p. 93). Furthermore, postmodern philosophy still has to deal with its internal conceptual problems (see Norris, 2000, p. 34 ff.). It remains unspecified in what way the pluralism of life forms must be dealt with in order to avoid having one paradigm dominating the others (Welsch, 1997, p. 37). The question of how a peaceful cooperation or at least a coexistence of radically different perspectives is feasible remains unanswered. A normative social theory that could provide an understanding for a fruitful interaction between perspectives or a successful integration of differences into a progressive development of the social world would then be necessary (see Scherer, 1999, p. 204). Yet, this normative orientation does not exist in postmodern philosophy, nor is it desired by its proponents (see critically Giddens, 1994; Norris, 2000). This has immediate consequences for international management and organization theory, since its culturally connoted challenges cannot be overcome in the absence of a normative reference point. Furthermore, as the idea of proactive intervention rests on a modern epistemology (see Clegg, 1990), ‘postmodernity (y) could be of no obvious practical use to organizers since it would be aimed at illustrating the limits of their projects’ (Parker, 1992, p. 10). The need for an adequate response to these problems makes a critical modern philosophy necessary, as proposed by the programme of discourse ethics.
DISCOURSE ETHICS AND ITS MODES OF (INTERCULTURAL) JUSTIFICATION For the engagement in questions of intercultural conflicts in organization studies and international management, the programme of discourse ethics (Apel, Habermas) offers helpful insights, which not only have found their way into general business ethics (e.g. French & Granrose, 1995; Ulrich, 1986, 2008; Lo¨hr, 1991; Steinmann & Lo¨hr, 1994) but have also been employed in the justification of an intercultural business ethics (see Gilbert, 1998, 2003; Karmasin, 2002).
Habermas’s Contribution to Discourse Ethics
161
Discourse ethics represents a consensual ethics, in which only those norms and actions can claim legitimacy that have been subjected to an ideal discourse and when a non-coercive consensus by all affected has been achieved (see Gottschalk-Mazouz, 2000; Tugendhat, 1993). Originating in German philosophy, various concepts for its justification, showing up significant differences, have since evolved. The three decisive concepts are transcendental pragmatics, developed by Apel (1976c, 1988), universal pragmatics developed by Habermas (1995a, 2001a, 2001b, 2003a, 2003b) and the constructivist philosophy of the Erlangen School (culturalism) (e.g. Hartmann & Janich, 1996, 1998; Hartmann & Lange, 2000; Kambartel, 1989b; Lorenzen, 1974), with Habermas’s understanding taking the middle ground. Transcendental pragmatics is a universal concept that refers to the culturally invariant conditions of communication as the ‘locus of unity’. It stands for a strong notion of justification (‘ultimate justification’ or foundationalism) that has been the object of critique due to its fundamentalist position and its cultural insensitivity. Universal pragmatics is also based on the conditions of communication. It understands these not as culturally invariant, but sees them as rooted in the shared life-world. The question of discourse ethics’ cultural transitivity has been analysed more closely in the culturalistic approach that has proposed a higher sensitivity for the cultural roots of language. Although the latter does not present a fully developed programme, it develops decisive amendments to both transcendental and universal pragmatics.
Apel: The Transcendental-Pragmatic Variant of Discourse Ethics Karl-Otto Apel’s transcendental pragmatics represents a universal concept of ethics, forwarding a strong notion of justification. It claims to provide the ultimate justification (Letztbegru¨ndung) of ethical principles, thereby providing absolute validity for its procedure of norm evaluation (e.g. Apel, 1976c, 1988; see also Bo¨hler, 1985, 1998; Ho¨sle, 1994; Kuhlmann, 1985). Apel considers the conditions of communication and tries to explain ‘what we must necessarily always already presuppose in regard to ourselves and others as normative conditions of the possibility of reaching understanding; and in this sense, what we must necessarily always already have accepted’ (Apel, 1976b, op. cit.; Habermas, 1976, pp. 21–22). Apel’s concept of discourse ethics represents an ethics that is procedural as well as oriented towards principles, argumentation and consensus. This means that it must be understood as a procedural concept to evaluate and justify norms and actions. The evaluation itself does not rely on material criteria or
162
ANDREAS GEORG SCHERER AND MORITZ PATZER
norms (e.g. ‘You shall not steal!’), but rests on a procedure of the evaluation of any material contents. Furthermore, the design of this procedure is derived from ultimately justified principles that guarantee for the rationality of the procedure as well as the validity of its results. The medium by which the evaluation and justification is performed is that of argumentation among equal participants in a discourse. Thereby, discourse ethics is not based on a monological reflection, differing to Kant’s concept of practical reason as delineated in his categorical imperative (see Kant, 1788), but rather stresses the importance of an inter-subjective communication. Lastly, the criterion for the validity of norms or the justification of an action is the consensus, that is, unanimous agreement by the participants in the process of argumentation. The outlined concept of a transcendental-pragmatic discourse ethics upholds the notion of a universal reason that can transcend the historiccontingent morality of local life forms in order to enable a peaceful coexistence between different cultures. This concept of discourse ethics provides a procedural notion of justice and claims universal validity. The procedural principles of discourse ethics can support the rational analysis of any actions, social rules, morals or particular concepts of a ‘good life’ (see Apel, 1997; Scherer, 2005). The (ultimate) justification of transcendental pragmatics is illustrated by the argumentative concept of retorsion ( performativer Selbstwiderspruch; see Apel, 1976a, 1976c, 1987). It represents the contradiction between the content of an assertion and the action of making an assertion (see Apel, 1996, p. 22; Tugendhat, 1993, p. 166 f.). For example, a sceptic who puts forth the argument ‘There is no universal claim!’ is making a universal claim, and by making this assertion, contradicts its content. This argumentative concept is not only employed to test factual assertions, but should also serve to reconstruct the rules of argumentation in fictional debates with potential sceptics. Apel and his colleagues argue that any participant in an argumentation who makes an assertion must assume that this assertion can be tested according to an implicit set of universal rules of argumentation. These rules apply to each participant in an argumentation since an argumentative rejection of the rules would be a self-contradiction (see Bo¨hler, 1985, 1998). This means, in conclusion, that every argumentation anticipates the condition of a discourse ethics that establishes the consensus as the ultimate criteria of validity in an ideal communicative community (see, e.g. Apel, 1976c, p. 358 ff.). Thereby, the transcendental-pragmatic conception rescues a unified and universal notion of reason, since anyone who argumentatively challenges this idea of communicative reason automatically makes use of it.
Habermas’s Contribution to Discourse Ethics
163
Habermas: The Universal-Pragmatic Variant of Discourse Ethics The universal-pragmatic variant of discourse ethics is a cornerstone of Habermas’s research programme. As the most influential living member of the ‘Frankfurt School’, he has committed himself to provide the rational foundations for a critical social analysis and theory of society. He stands in the tradition of critical theory as outlined by Horkheimer and Adorno, who founded the ‘Frankfurt School’ in the 1920s and 1930s, focusing on the multidisciplinary and critical analysis of modern social conditions, in particular those of modern capitalism (for critical theory’s history see Alvesson & Willmott, 1996, pp. 67–89; Held, 1980; Rush, 2004; Scherer, 2009; Wiggershaus, 1994). Critical theory was developed for the revitalization of the ideas of the Enlightenment and to provide knowledge in order to strengthen individual autonomy and civic liberties (see Scherer, 2009). It rejects the claims of valuefree knowledge generation through the social sciences and assumes that social patterns are embedded in specific historical and cultural contexts (see Horkheimer, 1937; Horkheimer & Adorno, 1947a, 1947b). While Horkheimer and Adorno were not able to justify their normative reference point of critique, Habermas sought to reconstruct the normative foundations of critical theory by basing critique upon the possibility of undistorted communication that, he argued, is built into the very structure of language. In his universal pragmatics Habermas analyses the use of communication skills that humans deploy in engaging in social relations (ibid., 1976). Building on the linguistic philosophy of Charles S. Peirce and the speech analytic philosophy of John L. Austin (1962) and John Searle (1969), Habermas suggests that a speaker raises four validity claims in the act of any utterance: firstly, the meaningfulness of what the speaker says; secondly, the truth of the assertion; thirdly, the legitimacy of the actors’ utterance; and lastly, the sincerity of the speaker. Although they can be challenged, thereby becoming the object of the process of argumentation, they must be understood as part of a universal structure of communication. Herein Habermas sees the relevant basis for social analysis and hence critical theory (see Scherer, 2009). Its normative core is represented by the notion of an ideal speech situation and its conditions. Habermas proposes that participants of a communication presuppose that their claims can be assessed and verified (or falsified) in an open discourse under ideal conditions. They do this regardless of the fact that actual communication is systematically distorted and usually does not satisfy the ideal conditions. Yet this ‘counter-factual assumption’ is routinely made by discussants since efforts of communication would otherwise fail. These
164
ANDREAS GEORG SCHERER AND MORITZ PATZER
conditions of a free and transparent discourse that are characterized by Habermas as ‘the freedom of access, equal rights to participate, truthfulness on the part of participants, absence of coercion in taking positions and so forth’ must be understood as ‘unavoidable presuppositions of argumentation’ (1995b, p. 56). Only the ‘unforced force of the better argument’ (Habermas, 1995b, p. 23) can secure the participants’ motivation to reach a consensus on what is true or false and right or wrong. Communication thereby becomes the ultimate reference of reason and rationality. Within discourse ethics it hinges on two fundamental principles: the principle of universalization (U) and the principle of discourse (D). The principle of universalization (U) addresses the validity of a norm. The validity of a norm is only given if all those who are affected can consent to it or agree to their consequences. This implies the need for consensus among those affected. The principle of discourse (D) addresses the characteristics of the process in which such a consensus might be achieved. It states that the agreement by all affected must be achieved through an open and free (practical) discourse in order to base the agreement on the power of the better argument. Habermas defends what he calls a ‘correctly understood universalism’ against postmodern scepticism towards the unity of reason and against the reproach that universalism would assimilate heterogeneity, levelling cultural differences. Such a mistrust appears unjustified to him, since a ‘correctly understood community’ does not constitute itself through concrete material norms, but rather through the ‘negative idea of abolishing discrimination’ (Habermas, 2001c, p. xxxvi). The idea of such a community should not be understood as a homogenous collective. The ‘inclusion of the other’ rather stresses the community’s openness for actors that are mutually foreigners and remain foreigners (Habermas, 2001c, p. xxxv ff.). With this concept Habermas presents a variant of discourse ethics that is more sensitive towards cultural differences, distancing itself from the ‘lingering foundationalism’ of Apel’s philosophy (see Habermas, 1995b, p. 79). Habermas does not claim ultimate justification as he considers the philosopher to be embedded in the argumentative praxis of a specific sociocultural life form. The philosopher can partially distance himself or herself from the social world in which he or she is embedded. However, the philosopher cannot peel off his or her cultural and historical legacy in favour of the perspective of a neutral observer from outside the social world (see Habermas, 1995b, p. 81 ff.). In contrast to the transcendental-pragmatic concept, Habermas does not derive his rules of argumentation from a transcendental reflection on the
Habermas’s Contribution to Discourse Ethics
165
necessary conditions of argumentation, but rather reconstructs them from the general structures of communication within a life-world. The conditions and structures of communication form a background that cannot be transcended (see Habermas, 1994, p. 139 ff.). Consequently, the philosopher still can reflect on the validity of the presuppositions of communication, but he cannot assume a priori that these presuppositions will never lose their function with changes in the underlying sociocultural life form (see Habermas, 1995b, p. 83 f.). The formulated principles can, hence, only claim validity in relation to the specific life form in which they are embedded and its continued existence. They represent the most advanced status of such a reconstructive effort, yet they must be understood as principally open to revision and learning (see Habermas, 2003a, p. especially 10 ff.; Scho¨nrich, 1994, p. 146 f.). Habermas thereby settles for a weak transcendental justification, stressing the factual validity of conditions of rational discourses (see Habermas, 1995b, p. 83 ff.). Within our life form we have no functional equivalent for rational argumentation at our disposal (see Habermas, 2001b, p. 15 ff., 2003a, 2003b). Consequently, Habermas points out that we pragmatically have no choice but to understand the rules of argumentation as a regulative idea in our pursuit of orientation. Such a justification of the discourse ethics does not abandon a normative–critical perspective but rather justifies a universalistic validity claim for a procedural moral principle that is compulsory for all subjects capable of speech and action. It does this without the danger of the fundamentalistic claim of an ‘ultimate’ justification. In Habermas’s understanding, Apel’s claim of infallibility appears unjustified and unnecessary (Habermas, 1995b, p. 83 ff.).
Critique of the Universal Concepts of Discourse Ethics We cannot discuss here all problems and points of critique that have been forwarded against the universal concepts of discourse ethics as proposed by Apel and Habermas (see, e.g. Scherer, 2003, p. 305 ff.; Stansbury, 2009, p. 42 ff.; Steinmann & Scherer, 1998b, p. 48 ff.; Tugendhat, 1993), but will present five central objections from a culturalistic perspective: (1) the strategic implementation of the conditions of an ideal communicative community, (2) the latent objectification of members of alien forms of social life, (3) the neglect of the constitutive influence of the life-world on the rules of argumentation, (4) the narrow concept of pragmatism and (5) the disregard of the material content of the rules of argumentation.
166
ANDREAS GEORG SCHERER AND MORITZ PATZER
(1) Since the conditions of real communications do not match with those of the ideal discourse ethics, it becomes necessary to establish and enforce these ideal principles in practice; otherwise, no rational agreement can be reached. This appears to be especially true for intercultural contexts where actors with different world views collide. With the claim of ultimate justification und validity of the transcendental pragmatics according to Apel, this enforcement must be considered as an ‘emancipatory anticipation’ (emanzipatorischer Vorgriff ), which may even legitimately make use of strategic means in order to assist communicative reason (see Apel, 1988, p. 247 f., 1992, p. 35 ff.; Bo¨hler, 1995, p. 242 f.). Consequently, all means that aim to establish an ideal communicative community would be considered legitimate. This implies that the focus within intercultural conflicts would shift from the justification of the formal rules of argumentation to their efficient implementation. As it becomes unclear in which way an equal and mutual recognition in the sense of the ‘inclusion of the other’ could be possible in such a strategic mode of action, this position carries the threat of a dogmatic posture towards alien cultures, thereby discrediting itself. (2) Although discourse ethics calls upon the inclusion of others as equal partners in the process of rational argumentation, this inclusion appears to be linked to the quality of their assertions and not necessarily to the person per se. In admitting all arguments and excluding aspects that do not take the form of arguments (Bo¨hler, 1991, p. 161), the universal concepts of discourse ethics have to clarify the concept of an ‘argument’ more thoroughly. Yet, this is not unproblematic, since it is controversial what assertions qualify as arguments. The concept of argumentation itself becomes the object of the discussion, since one cannot assume the existence of a transcendental understanding of argumentation (Gethmann, 1987; Lueken, 1992). Especially in intercultural conflicts one may expect the existence of radically different concepts of argumentation that are mutually incommensurable. This assumption appears plausible in the light of the influence that the individuals’ socialization has on his or her capability to participate in the process of rational discourse (see, e.g. Banerjee, 2003, and his case study on Aborigines whose arguments were considered irrational in an Australian court). Argumentation itself is an object of specific processes of socialization (see Cohen & Arato, 1995, p. 376 ff.; Kambartel, 1989c, p. 34 ff.; Schneider, 1994, p. 22 ff.). Habermas, whose conception exhibits stronger pragmatic foundations than Apel’s, appears to recognize this problem, however without acknowledging its gravity to the full extent (Lueken, 1992, p. 223 ff.). The
Habermas’s Contribution to Discourse Ethics
167
remaining fundamental character of the conceptualization of argumentation prohibits the recognition of radically different forms of social life and their exponents as equal interaction partners. Instead, they become objects in the strategic enforcement of a universal concept of argumentation. (3) The universal concepts of discourse ethics, especially transcendental pragmatics, attribute the concept of argumentation with a status independent of the life form’s practice. As the concept of rational argumentation itself is excluded from critical assessment (see Apel, 1976c, p. 405 ff., 1987, p. 172 ff., 1989), the question of the evolution of the rules of argumentation remains open. This perspective neglects the constitutive effect of the practice of argumentation on the meaning of the concept of argumentation and the design of its rules. Following Wittgenstein’s later philosophy of language, Kambartel and Schneider argue that the pragmatic turn in philosophy suggests that a sensible preoccupation with the meaning of concepts such as argumentation, reason or rationality is only possible once the use of the word has already been established in practice (see Kambartel, 1989a, 1989c, 1991; Schneider, 1992a, 1992b). The meaning of argumentation is not determined by rules that exist before practice, but rather through a continuous and stable use of the concept in the life form’s practice: ‘The meaning of a word is its use in language’ (Wittgenstein, 1953, y 43). (4) In the light of this critique, some authors suggest that the universal concepts of discourse ethics are based on too narrow an understanding of pragmatics (e.g. Gethmann, 1987, p. 272; Kambartel, 1992; Lueken, 1992, p. 223 ff.; Schneider, 1994). Discourse ethics overemphasizes the role of theory and derives the principles of argumentation from a particular theoretical perspective on language instead of reconstructing the characteristics of argumentation from actual practice (e.g. Schneider, 1998; Wohlrapp, 1998b). In order to explain this objection, Lueken distinguishes between a partially pragmatic (partialpragmatisch) and a fundamentally pragmatic approach ( fundamentalpragmatisch). A partially pragmatic approach is characterized by an understanding of pragmatics as a discipline of philosophy of language (besides syntax or semantics) that is concerned with the use of symbols in the act of speech. The existence of these symbols and items is implicitly assumed to be unproblematic. In contrast to this, a fundamentally pragmatic approach focuses on existing patterns of action within the life form from which it highlights and reconstructs the objects of analysis (see Lueken, 1992, p. 223 f.). The latter perspective stands for a bottom-up approach,
168
ANDREAS GEORG SCHERER AND MORITZ PATZER
whereas a partially pragmatic approach conceptualizes theories about practice from a top-down perspective. This would mean that the universal discourse ethics imposes its principles on the actual practice, instead of reconstructing them reflexively from the latter (see Lueken, 1992, p. 223 ff.), thereby making the validity of the universal claim dependent on the prevailing language theory. (5) Lastly, the apparent neglect for the material content of the rules of argumentation has been an object of critique. It refers to the question of whether it is feasible to separate the formal aspects of argumentation from the various material ideas of a ‘good life’ within the heterogeneous life forms. With the formal concept of rational argumentation forming the roof under which the different life forms interact and settle their disputes, it seems necessary to link these rules of argumentation to the underlying life forms. At this point Habermas insists on the universality of the grammatical role of concepts such as truth, rationality or justification, regardless of their differing interpretation in the various life forms (Habermas, 1994, p. 138, 1995b, p. 103 ff.). With this perspective the scope of the developed concept of argumentation becomes an empirical question (see McCarthy, 1993). Yet, it is doubtful that a universal historical community of language exists, assuming the same concepts of truth, rationality and justification. This becomes obvious in the consideration of the increasing pluralism of life forms, the tendencies of individualization in society, and the rise of different forms of fundamentalism and religious extremism. In the light of these problems concerning the justification of discourse ethics, we highlight some aspects of a culturalistic foundation that provides additional insights on the antagonism of relativism and universalism and the feasibility of an intercultural ethics (for organizations).
Culturalism as an Alternative Mode of Justification Culturalism has evolved from the methodical constructivism of the so-called ‘Erlangen School’ during the 1980s and 1990s (see Lorenzen, 2000; Hartmann & Janich, 1996, 1998; Hartmann & Lange, 2000). Its different variations do not constitute a coherent philosophical programme, but rather present an assembly of fragments. Beyond minor differences, culturalism also shares two insights with the methodical constructivism that have led to the linguistic-pragmatic turn in philosophy (see Lorenzen, 1989, p. 31 f.) On
Habermas’s Contribution to Discourse Ethics
169
the one hand, they stress that every reference to the world is only feasible through language (linguistic turn). As a consequence, problems of truth or justification must be understood and examined as problems of their linguistic properties (see Janich, 1996, p. 28). On the other hand, practice becomes the methodical starting point in forming theories (practical turn). As a consequence, the analysis of language goes beyond mere semantics and is linked to the processes of its practical use. In critical debates with sceptic perspectives, methodical constructivism upholds the notion of the feasibility of justification, making the actual practice the methodical starting point of theory building. It is based on the insight that humans do possess capabilities to master their lives more or less successfully, even before they apply any scientific theories. Since practice is not always successful, theorizing becomes necessary in order to amend problems. And yet, since practice does not always fail, it becomes possible to build on these successful practices and routines as the ultimate condition and starting point of science. In this sense, methodical reflection represents a stylized reconstruction of actual practices. In the 1980s Paul Lorenzen (see Lorenzen, 1985, 1987, 1989) developed the premise of a theory of political knowledge to help post-traditional societies to strengthen peace. He proposes a consistent justification of ethical-political knowledge that is based on the practical efforts to secure social peace existing in post-traditional societies in the practice of law-making and argumentation in political institutions (see also Gethmann, 1992; Habermas, 2003a, p. 47 f.). According to Lorenzen, it is the task of ethical politics to mitigate the conflicts that arise within the pluralism of heterogeneous life forms in post-traditional societies through law-making and administration. The ‘pluralism of incompatible highest ends’ is supposed to be transformed into a ‘plurality of mutually compatible life forms’ in order to stabilize peace (Lorenzen, 1987, p. 233 f.). In contrast to a manual practice that represents the basis for the technical sciences, the lawmaking deliberation represents a verbal practice of argumentation. Lorenzen thereby continues the constructivist programme by making (at least partly) successful political practice as the starting point of a discourse ethics. This differs from the universalistic conceptions of Apel and Habermas that focus on the analysis of conditions of language in a world without institutions, instead of reconstructing the practice of peaceful argumentation within and outside political institutions. Likewise, Kambartel (1989b, 1991, 1998) underlines the need to overcome the notion of a theoretical, criterial concept of reason. He insists that we do not follow a universal principle of rationality in our use of reason. We are
170
ANDREAS GEORG SCHERER AND MORITZ PATZER
rather participants in a specific situation wherein we produce judgements and orientations. We learn the use of reason by deploying different criteria in order to obtain reasonable orientation as participants of a specific, shared culture in which we are embedded throughout our childhood and onwards. Therein we learn to handle conflicts in a reasonable way. Hence, we are not born as reasonable beings, but rather become such through socialization, education and self-reflection (see Kambartel, 1989c). In consequence, Kambartel deems it necessary for philosophical and scientific writings on reason to be based on this ‘culture of reason’, since the argumentation would otherwise lose its rigour and miss the meaning underlying the notion of reason. This notion cannot be gained at the philosopher’s desk, but requires practical embeddedness in a specific situation.
CONCLUSION: ON THE POSSIBILITY OF AN INTERCULTURAL ETHICS Discourse ethics in general, and Habermas’s ‘universal pragmatics’ in particular, has had a profound impact on management and organization theory. Herein the legitimate use of power has been subject to critical analyses, with foci on organization studies as an academic discipline (see Steffy & Grimes, 1986), strategic management (see Alvesson & Willmott, 1995; Scherer & Dowling, 1995; Shrivastava, 1986), the question of stakeholder inclusion (e.g. Deetz, 1995; Smith, 2004), the possibilities of responsible leadership (Maak & Pless, 2006a, 2006b) or, lastly, the facilitation of moral decision making in organizations (see Stansbury, 2009). This also applies to Habermas’s later work on the role of law and democracy in modern society (see Habermas, 1996, 2001d, 2001e), wherein he softens the conditions of his Universal-Pragmatic ideal speech situation in favour of the idea of public deliberation as the expression of communicative rationality and the search for legitimate decision making (Scherer & Palazzo, 2007). Palazzo and Scherer have employed these arguments to reflect on the conditions of corporate legitimacy (see Palazzo & Scherer, 2006) as well as the civic role of multinational corporations in society in the light of globalization (see Scherer & Palazzo, 2007, 2008; Scherer, Palazzo, & Baumann, 2006). Discourse ethics’ contribution to organization theory can be further highlighted with regard to our initial problem of the antagonism between relativism and universalism. It provides the grounds for an intercultural ethics whose characteristics will be conclusively defined. A discourse ethics
Habermas’s Contribution to Discourse Ethics
171
that is informed by a culturalist perspective features (1) a principal openness towards alien perspectives, (2) the acknowledgement of the cultural embeddedness of all moral orientations, (3) the pragmatic reduction of the scope of its justification and (4) an understanding for the mutual relativity of formal and material ethics. (1) Ethical norms and the moral acceptability of actions cannot be assessed with the help of external criteria. Rather this assessment process is understood as a process of learning by the opponents of an ethical conflict. The opponents may apply their respective moral norms but once they realize that they do not mutually accept the norms of the other, they are left with nothing but to learn from each other. The principal openness for alien perspectives allows an intercultural ethics to engage in such a learning process with the moral orientations of other cultures. This learning process can be characterized by the three-stage model of communicative cultural integration as proposed by Wohlrapp (ibid., 1998a): in the first step actors have to submit themselves to the ‘experience’ of the alien as something beyond the familiar experience. Whereas this may be related to the exchange with a different culture as well as with actors of the shared life-world, this first encounter is primarily descriptive. In the second step the actors strive to achieve an ‘understanding’ of the experienced unfamiliarities. This is only feasible if the unfamiliar is recognized as a behaviour or action that corresponds with the respective actor’s own conduct. The latter thereby poses as an identification foil that makes the articulation of the differences possible. Beyond this reflective engagement a third step is needed that aims to ‘produce peaceability’. The latter can only be realized in actual interaction, wherein the actors have to distance themselves from their accustomed peculiarities. The act of transcending the latter rests on the insight that these attitudes have to be subjected to discussion in order to allow a mutually peaceful coexistence (see Wohlrapp, 1998a, p. 58 ff.). Such a learning process must be understood as principally open with regard to its initial and final situations, as it cannot be determined from the outset who has to learn from whom. For the conflict of heterogeneous moral concepts, this means that neither can one assume the existence of an initial preference for a specific moral nor is it possible in theory to anticipate the final solution of the conflict. The guiding orientation of this learning process is the question whether one moral norm is sufficient to address and solve the current conflict (see Lueken, 1992). As long as there is no consensual solution to such a conflict