NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
WILEY SERIES IN
FORENSIC CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY Edited by
Clive R. Hollin Department of Health Sciences, The University of Leicester, UK and
Mary McMurran School of Psychology, Cardiff University, UK Cognitive Behavioural Treatment of Sexual Offenders William L. Marshall, Dana Anderson and Yolanda Fernandez Violence, Crime and Mentally Disordered Offenders: Concepts and Methods for Effective Treatment and Prevention Sheilagh Hodgins and Rudiger ¨ Muller-Isberner ¨ (Editors) Offender Rehabilitation in Practice: Implementing and Evaluating Effective Programs Gary A. Bernfeld, David P. Farrington and Alan W. Leschied (Editors) Motivating Offenders to Change: A Guide to Enhancing Engagement in Therapy Mary McMurran (Editor) The Psychology of Group Aggression Arnold P. Goldstein Offender Rehabilitation and Treatment: Effective Programmes and Policies to Reduce Re-offending James McGuire (Editor) Offenders with Developmental Disabilities William R. Lindsay, John L. Taylor and Peter Sturmey (Editors) New Perspectives on Aggression Replacement Training: Practice, Research, and Application Arnold P. Goldstein, Rune Nens´en, Bengt Daleflod and Mikael Kalt (Editors)
NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Practice, Research, and Application Edited by
Arnold P. Goldstein Syracuse University, New York, USA
Rune Nens´en Barnhemmet Oasen, Aneby, Sweden
Bengt Daleflod Norra Rudbecksgatan 6, Uppsala, Sweden
Mikael Kalt Ungdomsalternativet, Malm¨o, Sweden
C 2004 Copyright
John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England Telephone
C 2004 Copyright
(+44) 1243 779777
Susan Striepling-Goldstein for material by Arnold P. Goldstein
Email (for orders and customer service enquiries):
[email protected] Visit our Home Page on www.wileyeurope.com or www.wiley.com All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise, except under the terms of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP, UK, without the permission in writing of the Publisher. Requests to the Publisher should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England, or emailed to
[email protected], or faxed to (+44) 1243 770620. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the Publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. Other Wiley Editorial Offices John Wiley & Sons Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA Jossey-Bass, 989 Market Street, San Francisco, CA 94103-1741, USA Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, Boschstr. 12, D-69469 Weinheim, Germany John Wiley & Sons Australia Ltd, 33 Park Road, Milton, Queensland 4064, Australia John Wiley & Sons (Asia) Pte Ltd, 2 Clementi Loop #02-01, Jin Xing Distripark, Singapore 129809 John Wiley & Sons Canada Ltd, 22 Worcester Road, Etobicoke, Ontario, Canada M9W 1L1 Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data New perspectives on aggression replacement training : practice, research and application/edited by Arnold P. Goldstein . . . [et al.]. p. cm. – (Wiley series in forensic clinical psychology) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-470-85492-8 (cloth : alk. paper) – ISBN 0-470-85493-6 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Aggressiveness–Treatment. 2. Anger–Treatment. 3. Criminals– Rehabilitation. 4. Juvenile delinquents–Rehabilitation. I. Goldstein, Arnold P. II. Series. RC569.5.A34N39 2004 616.85′ 810651 – dc22 2004005511 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0-470-85492-8 (hbk) ISBN 0-470-85493-6 (pbk) Typeset in 10/12pt Palatino by TechBooks, New Delhi, India Printed and bound in Great Britain by TJ International Ltd, Padstow, Cornwall This book is printed on acid-free paper responsibly manufactured from sustainable forestry in which at least two trees are planted for each one used for paper production.
CONTENTS About the Editors List of Contributors Series Editors’ Preface Preface Acknowledgments
PART I THEORY AND PRACTICE 1 Aggression Replacement Training: The Cognitive-Behavioral Context Clive R. Hollin
page vii ix xi xv xvii
1 3
2 Skillstreaming: The Behavioral Component Arnold P. Goldstein
21
3 Current Issues in Anger Management Interventions with Youth Eva L. Feindler and Kristan Baker
31
4 Moral Reasoning Training: The Values Component John C. Gibbs
51
PART II ESTABLISHED APPLICATIONS
73
5 Application in an Inner-city Elementary School Rob DiFlorio
75
6 Collaboration with Human Services and Schools Mark Amendola and Robert Oliver
87
7 Ungdomsalternativet—The Youth Alternative Ivan Brilje, Mariusz Hermelin, and Mikael Kalt
105
vi CONTENTS
8 The Oasis—A Living Idea Rune Nens´en and Nikolai Hamstein
121
9 A National Dissemination Program James McGuire and Danny Clark
139
PART III ELABORATIONS, EXTENSIONS, AND EVALUATIONS
151
10 ART and Beyond: The Prepare Curriculum Arnold P. Goldstein
153
11 The Peace Curriculum: Expanded Aggression Replacement Training Sara Salmon
171
12 Aggression Control Therapy for Forensic Psychiatric Patients: Development and Preliminary Results Ruud H. J. Hornsveld
189
13 Aggression Replacement Training: A Learning Process for the Whole Family Robert Calame and Kim Parker
197
14 Evaluations of Effectiveness Arnold P. Goldstein
231
15 The ART Trainer as a Scientific Practitioner Bengt Daleflod
245
Epilogue Index
257 259
ABOUT THE EDITORS Arnold P. Goldstein was the Director of the Center for Research on Aggression at Syracuse University, Director of the New York State Task Force on Juvenile Gangs, and co-founder of the International Center for Aggression Replacement Training. He served on the American Psychological Association Commission on Youth Violence and on the Council of Representatives for the International Society for Research on Aggression. A prolific writer, he authored more than 55 books and 100 articles on violence, aggression, delinquency, abuse, and related topics. His work was honored with numerous awards, including the Career Achievement Award from the American Psychological Association’s Committee on Children, Youth, and Families (1996), the Senior Scientist Award from the APA Psychology Division (1996), and the 2002 Devereux Massachusetts Legacy of Caring Award. Just before his death in 2002, Professor Goldstein was nominated for a Nobel Prize. Rune Nens´en is the founder of The Oasis, a residential treatment facility for young people and their families, in Sweden. A qualified social worker, he has many years’ experience in the social services as both a supervisor and program director in cities in southern Sweden. Since 1990 he has primarily worked as the director and Program Director for The Oasis which, over the past decade, has served more than 80 cities in Sweden in offering services to families with young children. In 1997 Rune Nens´en successfully introduced ART at The Oasis as a program for both families and children. Bengt Daleflod is a psychologist specializing in cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy. He started his clinical career in the psychiatric care of children and adolescents, and since 1986 he has been working with incarcerated juvenile delinquents and involved in staff training and supervision. He works within SiS (The National Board of Institutional Care) and is now connected to Sundbo Youth Home in Sweden, where ART is one of the main interventions that has been introduced in working with young offenders. Bengt Daleflod is also an active member of the Swedish Behavioral Therapy Association with a special assignment to work out guidelines for treatment of various psychological disorders. Mikael Kalt was born in Warsaw but has been residing in the city of Malmo¨ in Sweden for the past 23 years. He has a long and extensive experience of working with aggressive and delinquent youth in different settings, ranging from
viii ABOUT THE EDITORS
institutions to community-based projects and schools. Mikael Kalt and his friends and associates Mariusz Hermelin and Ivan Brilje are the co-founders of Ungdomsalternativet (“The Youth Alternative”), a non-government organization working in Sweden with youth at risk in schools and the community and training teachers and youth workers in ART. He is a practicing ART trainer working on a regular basis with youth groups, and is an ART Master Trainer, training staff and new ART trainers.
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS Mark Amendola 3825 Holly Drive, Erie, PA 16510, USA Kristan Baker 66-15 Thorton Place, #1A Rego Park, New York 11374, USA Ivan Brilje Ungdomsalternativet, Jacob Mollersgatan 3, 211 57 Malmo, ¨ Sweden Robert Calame Batshaw Youth and Family Centres, Dorval Campus, 825 Avenue Dawson, Dorval, Quebec, Canada H9S 1X4 Danny Clark National Probation Directorate, Horseferry House, Dean Ryle Street, London SW1P, UK Bengt Daleflod Norra Rudbecksgatan 6, 752 36 Uppsala, Sweden Rob DiFlorio 440 Brattle Rd, Syracuse, NY 13203, USA Eva L. Feindler Director, Psychological Services Center, Long Island University, C.W. Post Campus, 720 Northern Blvd, Brookville, NY 11548-1300, USA John C. Gibbs 1346 Murrell Ave., Columbus, OH 43212, USA
x LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Arnold P. Goldstein (Deceased) c/o Susan Striepling-Goldstein, 129 Nottingham Road, Syracuse, NY 13210, USA Nikolai Hamstein Barnhemmet Oasen, Box 199, Fasanstigen 17-25, 578 24 Aneby, Sweden Mariusz Hermelin Ungdomsalternativet, Jacob Mollersgatan 3, 211 57 Malmo, ¨ Sweden Clive R. Hollin University of Leicester, Arnold Lodge, Leicester LE3 0LE, UK Ruud H. J. Hornsveld Lange Dreef 52, 2285 LA Rijswijk, The Netherlands Mikael Kalt Ungdomsalternativet, Jacob Mollersgatan 3, 211 57 Malmo, ¨ Sweden James McGuire University of Liverpool, Department of Clinical Psychology, Whelan Building, Liverpool L69 3GB, UK Rune Nens´en Barnhemmet Oasen, Box 199, Fasanstigen 17-25, 578 24 Aneby, Sweden Robert Oliver 3951 Shamrock Ct, Erie, PA 16510, USA Kim Parker 1767 Cote St Garitel, Morin Heights, Quebec, Canada J0R lH0 Sara Salmon 430 Tynon Court, Erie, CO 80516, USA
SERIES EDITORS’ PREFACE ABOUT THE SERIES At the time of writing it is clear that we live in a time, certainly in the UK and other parts of Europe, if perhaps less so in other areas of the world, when there is renewed enthusiasm for constructive approaches to working with offenders to prevent crime. What do we mean by this statement and what basis do we have for making it? First, by “constructive approaches to working with offenders” we mean bringing the use of effective methods and techniques of behavior change into work with offenders. Indeed, this view might pass as a definition of forensic clinical psychology. Thus, our focus is the application of theory and research in order to develop practice aimed at bringing about a change in the offender’s functioning. The word constructive is important and can be set against approaches to changing behavior that seek to operate by destructive means. Such destructive approaches are typically based on the principles of deterrence and punishment, seeking to suppress the offender’s actions through fear and intimidation. A constructive approach, on the other hand, seeks to bring about changes in an offender’s functioning that will produce, say, enhanced possibilities of employment, greater levels of self-control, better family functioning, or increased awareness of the pain of victims. A constructive approach faces the criticism of being a “soft” response to the damage caused by offenders, neither inflicting pain and punishment nor delivering retribution. This point raises a serious question for those involved in working with offenders. Should advocates of constructive approaches oppose retribution as a goal of the criminal justice system as a process that is incompatible with treatment and rehabilitation? Alternatively, should constructive work with offenders take place within a system given to retribution? We believe that this issue merits serious debate. However, to return to our starting point, history shows that criminal justice systems are littered with many attempts at constructive work with offenders, not all of which have been successful. In raising the specter of success, the second part of our opening sentence now merits attention: that is, “constructive approaches to working with offenders to prevent crime.” In order to achieve the goal of preventing crime, interventions must focus on the right targets for behavior change. In addressing this crucial point, Andrews and Bonta (1994) have formulated the need principle:
xii SERIES EDITORS’ PREFACE Many offenders, especially high-risk offenders, have a variety of needs. They need places to live and work and/or they need to stop taking drugs. Some have poor self-esteem, chronic headaches or cavities in their teeth. These are all “needs.” The need principle draws our attention to the distinction between criminogenic and noncriminogenic needs. Criminogenic needs are a subset of an offender’s risk level. They are dynamic attributes of an offender that, when changed, are associated with changes in the probability of recidivism. Noncriminogenic needs are also dynamic and changeable, but these changes are not necessarily associated with the probability of recidivism. (p. 176)
Thus, successful work with offenders can be judged in terms of bringing about change in noncriminogenic need or in terms of bringing about change in criminogenic need. While the former is important and, indeed, may be a necessary precursor to offense-focused work, it is changing criminogenic need that, we argue, should be the touchstone in working with offenders. While, as noted above, the history of work with offenders is not replete with success, the research base developed since the early 1990s, particularly the metaanalyses (e.g. Losel, ¨ 1995), now strongly supports the position that effective work with offenders to prevent further offending is possible. The parameters of such evidence-based practice have become well established and widely disseminated under the banner of “What Works” (McGuire, 1995). It is important to state that we are not advocating that there is only one approach to preventing crime. Clearly there are many approaches, with different theoretical underpinnings, that can be applied. Nonetheless, a tangible momentum has grown in the wake of the “What Works” movement as academics, practitioners, and policy makers seek to capitalize on the possibilities that this research raises for preventing crime. The task now facing many service agencies lies in turning the research into effective practice. Our aim in developing this Series in Forensic Clinical Psychology is to produce texts that review research and draw on clinical expertise to advance effective work with offenders. We are both committed to the ideal of evidence-based practice and we will encourage contributors to the Series to follow this approach. Thus, the books published in the Series will not be practice manuals or “cook books”: they will offer readers authoritative and critical information through which forensic clinical practice can develop. We are both enthusiastic about the contribution to effective practice that this Series can make and look forward to continuing to develop it in the years to come.
ABOUT THIS BOOK This is the second book that Professor Goldstein has contributed to our Series. In the Preface to the previous book (Goldstein, 2002) we expressed our sorrow at Professor Goldstein’s untimely death. This book stands as one of Professor Goldstein’s last publications but it also marks the beginning of the continuation of his life’s work. Over his career Professor Goldstein’s work was concerned with understanding aggression and violence and, perhaps more importantly, in finding effective means to change violent behavior. His program Aggression Replacement
SERIES EDITORS’ PREFACE xiii
Training (ART; Goldstein, Glick, & Gibbs, 1998) represents a significant contribution to forensic practice and has influenced the efforts of practitioners all over the world. The growing worldwide use of ART led in 2001 to the formation of the International Center for Aggression Replacement Training (ICART). The beginning of ICART was marked with a conference in Malmo, ¨ Sweden, which attracted over 750 delegates from 20 countries. As noted on the ICART website (www.aggressionreplacementtraining.org), the tasks undertaken by ICART are to provide a forum for the exchange of ART-relevant experiences and data, create an active network of interested professionals, encourage high-quality practice in its use, promote its continued rigorous evaluation, and aid in ART’s growing dissemination as a useful intervention approach. In order to meet these goals ICART sponsors conferences, creates and disseminates the ICART Communicator practitioner–researcher newsletter, and serves as a clearing-house for creative ART practice innovations and developing research findings as they become available. The ICART newsletter is available at the website. The chapters in this book are intended to give a broad flavor of the theory and practice of ART. The opening chapters in the first section look at the broad theory that informs ART and the specifics of the three components— Skillstreaming, emotional control, moral values—of the ART program. Indeed, the latter three chapters bring together the trio of academics, Arnold Goldstein, Eve Feindler, and John Gibbs, who were the originators of the three interventions that currently constitute ART. The second section is then concerned with the application of ART across a range of settings and countries. There are two points that spring to attention when looking at the scope of these chapters and the style of work they encompass. The first point to note lies in the range of settings within which ART has found a home and hence the diversity of client groups with which ART is applied. It can be seen that the chapters build from a focus on the individual offender, then to a variety of settings such as local schools and residential facilities, and finally to the national use of ART in the English and Welsh Probation Service. The second point to note is the absence of a formal structure around the implementation of ART. This “hands-off” approach leads to an interesting clash in the philosophy of program management. The approach adopted by ART, strongly advocated by Professor Goldstein, is based on encouragement and facilitation of the work of practitioners. To engage practitioners and their clients in the ART program is the fundamental aim; once practitioners are engaged then their work can be supported by training, consultancy, and professional networks. This practitionerfriendly “bottom-up” approach can be contrasted with the “top-down” approach evident in some systems, such as the criminal justice system in England and Wales, in which the development and application of programs is very tightly managed. This latter approach is clearly seen in the intricacies of program accreditation (Lipton, Thornton, McGuire, Porporino, & Hollin, 2000) and in discussions of program management (Bernfeld, Farrington, & Leschied, 2001). It is evident that both approaches have their relative strengths and weaknesses: as ART is currently being used with both approaches, it may be that the data will eventually let us know which approach produces the best outcomes. In the third section of the book attention turns to new directions in the development of the ART program. As knowledge and experience accrue, so change should
xiv SERIES EDITORS’ PREFACE
follow: the Prepare and the Peace curricula exemplify this process of program modification and development. The real spirit of ART is that it is always work in progress, never the final word. In the same vein, it is also the case that violent behavior is not the province of any one group, and the extension and modification of ART to new populations, such as forensic patients, is an exciting development. The chapter by Robert Calame and Kim Parker illustrates how evaluation can be built into practice, and the penultimate chapter of the book considers what is currently known about the effectiveness of ART. The final chapter neatly brings the text full circle in looking to the scientist-practitioner model as the basis for progress. The work of researchers, as seen in the opening section, feeds into practice; the work of practitioners, as seen in the second section, tests and contributes to work of theorists and researchers; the culmination of the work of scientists and practitioners leads to increasingly effective practice. As noted above, this book marks an end and a beginning: we hope that readers will learn and benefit and be enthused to use ART in their practice. There will be more work and, as we hope and Arnie had planned, more books just like this one. Clive Hollin and Mary McMurran
REFERENCES Andrews, D. A. & Bonta, J. (1994). The psychology of criminal conduct. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson Publishing. Bernfeld, G. A., Farrington, D. P., & Leschied, A. W. (Eds) (2001). Offender rehabilitation in practice: Implementing and evaluating effective programmes. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Goldstein, A. P. (Ed.) (2002). The psychology of group aggression. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Goldstein, A. P., Glick, B., & Gibbs, J. C. (1998). Aggression Replacement Training: A comprehensive intervention for aggressive youth (rev. edn). Champaign, IL: Research Press. Lipton, D. S., Thornton, D. M., McGuire, J., Porporino, F. J., & Hollin, C. R. (2000). Program accreditation and correctional treatment. Substance Use and Misuse, 35, 1705–1734. Losel, ¨ F. (1995). Increasing consensus in the evaluation of offender rehabilitation? Psychology, Crime, and Law, 2, 19–39. McGuire, J. (Ed.) (1995). What works: Reducing reoffending. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.
PREFACE In the mid-1970s, at the very beginning of the social skills training movement, my colleagues and graduate students and I developed our approach to teaching prosocial behaviors, Skillstreaming. Skillstreaming is the topic of Chapter 2. As efficacy studies of the earliest social skills approaches, including Skillstreaming, became available, it became clear that far too often results shared a quality held in common by all psychological interventions—that is, frequent inadequacy of generalization of gain. Skill acquisition generally did occur; skill transfer to out-of-training settings and skill maintenance over time were clearly less frequent outcomes. Around 1980, I had the good fortune of beginning a series of conversations with Barry Glick, who was at that time the director of an NY State facility for delinquent youth near Syracuse, NY. Our goal was to puzzle through what might optimally be added to Skillstreaming in order to enhance its outcome potency, particularly with regard to generalization. Two additional components seemed to be likely candidates. The first was Anger Control Training to provide trainees with competence in what not to do in the face of provocation. Back then, as now, we viewed Eva Feindler as the US’s leading expert on anger control and sought her out. With her characteristic wisdom and generosity, Eva fully shared her intervention approach and its evaluations with us, and we incorporated it as ART’s second component. Since aggression is so typically a richly rewarded, infrequently punished primarily learned behavior, trainees can know well what to do (from Skillstreaming) and what not to do (from Anger Control Training) and still choose to behave aggressively. We thus felt that a values intervention needed to be ART’s third component, providing in a sense the prosocial motivation to employ the other components’ skills. We first selected Kohlberg’s Moral Education for this purpose and, in later years, replaced this with John Gibbs’ especially well-grounded Social Problem Solving approach. Having thus constituted our intervention, Barry and I then set off on a 10 year multi-study journey to examine whether our hope for its potency matched its reality. Over the course of this period, a half-dozen other investigators at widely distributed locations also came to test the adequacy of ART. The combined results of these several studies, reported in detail in Chapter 14, point to ART as generally quite an effective intervention worthy of further application and continued evaluation. Largely in response to this stream of primarily positive outcomes, a number of developments have occurred. First, ART has been designated as a recommended
xvi PREFACE
program by the US Department of Education, a validated program by the NY State Department of Education, a model program by both the US Department of Justice and the American Correctional Association, and an accredited program by the UK Home Office Probation Unit. Second, a new ART organization has been formed: the International Center for Aggression Replacement Training (ICART). Its purpose is to promote competent application and rigorous evaluation of ART. We invite interested readers of the present book to join us as ICART members. The third result of the frequent demonstration of ART’s efficacy is the wide spread across Europe, North America, and elsewhere in its creative use, energetic training, and continued evaluation. Arnold P. Goldstein
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Arnold Goldstein’s death was as much of a surprise to him as it was to his family, friends, and colleagues. Only a week before his death he was working on this book, as well as planning future works. Fate intervened, however. Clive Hollin, dear friend and colleague of Arnie’s, stepped in and took over the work of bringing this book to publication. Without his efforts, Arnie’s project would never have been completed. The contributors to this volume, as well as the whole of the ICART and ART communities, wish to thank him enormously and say, “Good job.” The pioneers of ART—Goldstein, Glick, and later, Gibbs—created an intervention they thought would be useful. Their own research and rigorous evaluation showed it to be so. Through their efforts and the work of many others, ART has spread far beyond its original test site in upstate New York. Over the years, Arnie began to envision an international ART community of researchers and academics, practitioners and administrators, which resulted in the founding of the International Center for Aggression Replacement Training. I would like to personally thank all of the contributors to this volume for their hard work and support on behalf of ART and ICART. It is as a result of their ongoing efforts that Arnie’s vision has been realized. Susan Striepling-Goldstein, Co-Chairperson, ICART
PART I
THEORY AND PRACTICE Contemporary practitioners—whether they are psychotherapists, educators, social workers, or other professionals—find themselves governed more and more in their work by the fact that we are in an “era of accountability.” Government and private agencies are increasingly and rightly insisting that we—the treatment and intervention professionals—firmly and unequivocally demonstrate that our interventions work. In fact, an ever growing number of such agencies now require such efficacy information in advance, as a precondition to selecting and starting to use any given intervention. Nowhere has the accountability movement taken root more strongly than in the UK, where the Prison Service and the National Probation Service have responded to 20 years of evidence showing clearly that the most effective interventions for chronically aggressive persons are those that seek to both alter aggression-promoting thinking patterns and provide new behaviors to aid the person to deal prosocially with previously provocative events—that is, cognitivebehavior interventions. The national initiatives in the UK have been informed by the author of our first chapter, a person considered to be the UK’s premier forensic psychologist working in the field of offender rehabilitation, who has reviewed in detail the existing evaluation literature on cognitive-behavioral approaches and has recommended those he felt to be of value. Clive Hollin is Professor of Criminological Psychology at the University of Leicester. His opening chapter provides us with the cognitive-behavioral context from which ART grew. The following three chapters bring together the three persons who were the originators of the three interventions that constitute ART. Arnold P. Goldstein and his colleagues at Syracuse University first constituted Skillstreaming; Anger Control Training was developed by Eva Feindler, Professor of Psychology and Director of the Psychological Services Center at Long Island University in New York; and ART’s Moral Reasoning Training—in the form of Social Problem Solving Intervention—was first formulated by John Gibbs, Professor of Developmental Psychology at Ohio State University.
Chapter 1
AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING: THE COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL CONTEXT CLIVE R. HOLLIN Department of Health Sciences, University of Leicester, UK
INTRODUCTION Developed in the 1980s, the first complete publication of Aggression Replacement Training (ART) in 1987, by Arnold Goldstein and Barry Glick, saw the formulation of a multimodal approach to working with aggressive offenders. Utilized on an increasingly wide basis throughout the 1990s, the accumulated outcome evidence shows that ART is an effective method by which to reduce aggressive behavior (Goldstein & Glick, 1996). The latest text offering a revised edition of the program (Goldstein, Glick, & Gibbs, 1998) details and refines the three components that make up ART: these three components, delivered sequentially, are Skillstreaming, Anger Control Training, and Moral Reasoning Training. Skillstreaming involves the teaching of skills that serve to displace the out-ofcontrol destructive behaviors with constructive, prosocial behavior. The skills element of ART teaches constructive social skills in terms of step-by-step instructions to managing key social situations. In keeping with the principles of skills training, the skills are modeled by group leaders and then practiced by offenders. ART addresses a “core” set of social skills relevant to the target group in order to bring about change. Anger Control Training follows the established sequence of establishing Antecedent–Behavior–Consequence (A–B–C) sequences to determine triggers for anger. ART then uses the standard anger management techniques of enhancing self-awareness of internal angry cues, teaching coping strategies, skills training, self-instruction, and social problem solving. Moral Reasoning Training seeks to address issues concerned with a delay in maturing of moral reasoning and the associated egocentric bias. Thus, this part of the program seeks to enhance offenders’ moral reasoning skills and widen their social perspective taking. These aims are achieved through self-instruction training, New Perspectives on Aggression Replacement Training: Practice, Research, and Application. C 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Edited by A. P. Goldstein, R. Nens´en, B. Daleflod, and M. Kalt.
4 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
social problem solving, skills training, and guided peer group social decisionmaking meetings. The aim of this chapter is principally to describe the theoretical underpinnings for ART, then to consider the evidence that speaks to this theoretical base. In looking to theory, there are two dimensions to discuss: first, the broad theoretical position adopted by ART, and, second, the specific theoretical rationale for the three components.
ART: BROAD THEORY This section develops the theme of cognitive-behavioral theory as the bedrock theory on which ART is built. To achieve this aim, an overview of the broad extent of cognitive-behavioral theory is presented. The theme will be developed by suggesting that a cognitive-behavioral approach is one that seeks to locate behavior within a social context, with an emphasis on the reciprocity between the social context and an individual’s functioning. The dovetailing of ART and these theoretical principles will then become clear. There is no doubt that ART has its theoretical base in learning theory: “Aggression is primarily learned behavior, learned by observation, imitation, direct experience, and rehearsal” (Goldstein et al., 1998, p. 3). In its initial formulation as a theory of learning, traditional behavioral theory concentrated on the relationship between the environment and observable behavior (Skinner, 1974). The theoretical position articulated by Skinner was that given the right setting conditions or antecedents (A), then behavior (B) develops through the individual’s experience of the rewarding or punishing consequences (C) delivered by the environment following their actions. In an A–B–C model, the consequences may be rewarding, in which case they increase the frequency, or reinforce the behavior; or aversive, in which case they may decrease, or punish the frequency of the behavior. This deceptively simple model of behavior was applied to the explanation of criminal behavior in the form of Differential Reinforcement Theory (Jeffery, 1965). The use of A–B–C sequences to explain the development of extreme violence is seen in Gresswell and Hollin’s (1992) case study of attempted multiple murder. The advent of social learning theory added to the picture by incorporating more explicitly the role of cognition and emotion into a theoretical account of human aggression specifically (Bandura, 1973) and human functioning generally (Bandura, 1977, 1986). Social learning theory departed from the traditional behavioral position in that, while continuing to acknowledge the role of external reinforcement, it suggests that learning can also take place purely at a cognitive level. Further, Bandura also advanced the concept of “motivation” to supersede reinforcement as the force that develops and maintains behavior. In social learning theory terms, motivation is held to take three forms: external reinforcement in the traditional sense that the term is used in behavioral theory; vicarious reinforcement, where an individual’s actions are based on observing what happens to other people who behave in a particular way; and actions that produce self-reinforcement, as in a sense of personal pride or achievement.
THE COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL CONTEXT 5
Distal antecedents
Early indicators
Developmental processes
Maintenance variables
Biological precursors (e.g. brain dysfunction)
Conduct disorder
School failure
Peers
Psychological factors (e.g. impulsiveness)
Poor parenting
Cognitive style (e.g. hostile attributions)
Opportunities
Environmental factors (e.g. family functioning)
Early aggression
Substance abuse
Socioeconomic deprivation
Figure 1.1 Possible developmental sequence in the etiology of violent behavior (after Nietzel et al., 1999)
While social learning theory retains some degree of overlap with behavior analysis, theorists have increasingly turned their attention to the study of cognition. As social learning theory precipitated interest in the role of cognition within an overarching behavioral framework, the term cognitive-behavioral entered popular usage. Thus, cognitive-behavioral theory increasingly became a focus for a range of researchers, and cognitive-behavioral interventions became a focus for practitioners. With its mixed heritage, from the standpoint of both research and practice, it is difficult if not impossible to give a watertight definition of cognitive-behavioral theory or practice. Kendall and Bacon (1988) have previously noted the problems with attempts to define cognitive-behavioral therapy and to say precisely how it sits alongside traditional behavioral theory and practice. Indeed, Kendall and Bacon suggest that it is preferable to see a cognitive-behavioral approach to practice as a general perspective rather than a single unified theory. It is clear that models of human behavior based on learning have become increasingly complex. This theoretical complexity is seen in the behavioral model of violent conduct developed by Nietzel, Hasemann, and Lynam (1999). This model is based on four sequential stages across the life span (Figure 1.1). At the first stage, there are distal antecedents to violence: Nietzel et al. suggest that these are biological precursors, including genetic transmission and ANS lability, psychological predispositions including impulsivity and deficient problem solving, and environmental factors, such as family functioning and the social fabric of the neighborhood. At the second stage, there are early indicators of violence as the child develops. These first signs include features of childhood such as conduct disorder and poor emotional regulation. Third, as the child matures the developmental processes associated with the intensification of violent behavior come into effect: these processes include school failure, association with delinquent peers, and substance abuse. Finally, as the adolescent moves into adulthood there is a stage at which maintenance variables come into force. These maintaining variables include continued reinforcement for violent conduct, association with criminal peers, and social conditions. The type of model proposed by Nietzel et al. is an excellent example of the application of cognitive-behavioral principles. The model includes social factors,
6 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
environmental forces, and cognitive processes, and is dynamic in speaking to progression and change over the life span. It is evident that ART has its theoretical base in similar territory. Goldstein (1994) described three levels of analysis in the physical ecology of aggression, all incorporating various levels of a person–environment interaction. The macrolevel refers to analysis of violence at a national or regional level; at the mesolevel the analysis of violence is at the level of the neighborhood; and microlevel analysis is at the level of the home, street, public house, and so on. The fundamental point to take from these complex models is that a cognitivebehavioral approach neither has an exclusive focus on the individual, nor does it neglect the possibilities of preventing violence through social and environmental means. However, for those charged with the responsibility of working with offenders, the focus of their day-to-day work lies with the individual. Reviews of the literature show that the history of working with offenders, including violent offenders, is dominated by a single-target approach (Hollin, 1990a). In other words, practice is dominated by trying to change one aspect of the offender’s functioning, such as their social skills or educational achievement. In contrast and in keeping with the more complex models, contemporary practice is concerned with multimodal programs that seek to change several aspects of the offender’s functioning. To its credit, ART was one of the first programs to adopt a multimodal perspective, seeking to change the individual’s thinking, emotion, and action. As discussed in the following sections on each specific component of ART, the theoretical base for this tripartite approach is well established.
SPECIFIC THEORY: SKILLSTREAMING The original social skills model (Argyle & Kendon, 1967) held that socially skilled behavior consists of three related components—social perception, social cognition, and social performance (Hollin & Trower, 1986c). Social perception refers to the ability to perceive and understand verbal and nonverbal social cues and signals; social cognition, in this sense, is analogous to social information processing; and social performance is, of course, observable social action. Thus, the socially competent individual will use all aspects of their social skills to function effectively in their interactions with others and so achieve their social goals. The application of this way of thinking about social behavior with respect to offender populations raises two issues: first, is there any evidence to indicate that offenders have particular difficulties in any specific areas of social ability? Second, is an offender’s level of social skills related to his or her offending?
Social Perception The ability to recognize, understand, and interpret interpersonal cues is central to all social behavior (Argyle, 1983). In a study of social perception in delinquents, McCown, Johnson, and Austin (1986) showed that young offenders had some difficulty in recognizing the emotion expressed in different facial expressions.
THE COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL CONTEXT 7
Similarly, a body of evidence has accumulated to suggest that young people who struggle socially, particularly with respect to aggressive behavior, have difficulties in both the selection and interpretation of social cues (e.g. Dodge, Murphy, & Buchsbaum, 1984; Dodge & Tomlin, 1987; Akhtar & Bradley, 1991). Further, a study by Lipton, McDonel, and McFall (1987) suggested that sexually aggressive men may misperceive social cues in male–female social interactions. The misperception of social cues may in turn lead to misattribution of intent, so that the actions of other people are mistakenly seen as hostile or threatening (Slaby & Guerra, 1988; Lochman & Dodge, 1994; Crick & Dodge, 1996). The manner in which a social encounter is perceived will, in turn, influence the way in which the person deals with a given social encounter.
Social Cognition Following their perception and understanding of other people’s behavior, the individual must decide on a suitable response. This type of decision making requires the ability to generate feasible courses of action, consider potential alternatives and their likely consequences, and make plans towards achieving the desired outcome (Spivack, Platt, & Shure, 1976). Several studies have suggested that some offenders, perhaps particularly younger offenders, may experience difficulties in solving social interaction problems. For example, studies using the Adolescent Problem Inventory have shown that male young offenders typically gave less socially competent responses than non-offenders to a series of social problems (Palmer & Hollin, 1996, 1999). Offenders typically use a more limited range of alternatives to solve interpersonal problems, and rely more on verbal and physical aggression. A similar pattern has been reported for female offenders using the Problem Inventory for Adolescent Girls (Gaffney & McFall, 1981; Ward & McFall, 1986). It is clear that social cognition, including social problem solving, is related to offending behavior. There is a weight of research in the tradition illustrated above that strongly suggests that difficulties in setting social goals, solving social problems, and accurately perceiving social feedback on performance are critical factors in understanding antisocial, including aggressive, behavior (e.g. Ross & Fabiano, 1985; Hollin, 1990a, 1990b; Akhtar & Bradley, 1991; Demorest, 1992; Crick & Dodge, 1994).
Social Performance In a typical study, Spence (1981a) compared the social performance skills of young male offenders with non-delinquent controls matched for age, academic performance, and social background. The delinquents showed significantly less eye contact and speech, but more “fiddling” and gross body movements, behaviors shown to relate to poor observer ratings of social skill (Spence, 1981b). On global ratings of social skill, social anxiety, and employability the delinquent group were rated less favorably than the non-delinquents. In summary, the research suggests that some offenders do experience difficulties with social skills. However, it would be wrong to assume that this is a characteristic
8 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
of all offenders: clearly offenders are a heterogeneous population with a wide distribution of social ability (Veneziano & Veneziano, 1988). Nonetheless, there are offenders with social difficulties and the hypothesis has been formed that there is a link between social ability and offending (e.g. Howells, 1986). If this hypothesis is true, in some cases at least, then remediation of these social difficulties, typically through the use of Social Skills Training (SST), may contribute to a reduction in offending.
SPECIFIC THEORY: ANGER CONTROL A second strand in ART is enabling participants to control their anger. Anger is the emotional state most frequently associated with violent behavior (Blackburn, 1993). Specifically, the concern here is with the experience and expression of dysfunctional anger. Anger is seen to be dysfunctional when the experience and expression of this emotion have a negative consequence for the individuals themselves (for example, dysfunctional anger is associated with poor physical and mental health) or for other people (Swaffer & Hollin, 2000, 2001). It is known that violent acts are committed by people in angry states (Zamble & Quinsey, 1997), and that levels of anger in violent offenders can be greater than those in nonviolent offenders (Hunter, 1993). However, it would be wrong to assume that anger is the main cause of violence or that all violent offenders must be angry. Indeed, some studies suggest that a propensity to anger, in and of itself, does not distinguish violent and nonviolent offenders (Loza & Loza-Fanous, 1999). The point is made that anger management should be seen as a component, rather than the main focus, of work with violent offenders. As with the term “cognitive-behavioral,” there are difficulties in defining the term anger: while anger is said to be an emotion, as Dodge and Garber (1991) state, “Emotion is like pornography: The experts have great difficulty defining it, but we all know it when we see it” (p. 3). Currently, the most influential theory of anger is that proposed by Novaco (1975, 1994). Novaco’s position is close to cognitive-behavioral theory in that anger is understood as a subjective emotional state, involving both physiological and cognitive activity, but which is clearly related to environmental circumstances. According to Novaco, for a person to become angry some environmental event triggers distinctive patterns of cognitive and physiological arousal. Most typically, this trigger lies in the individual’s perception of the words and actions of another person. The physiological processes associated with anger are increased autonomic nervous system activity, such as a rise in body temperature, perspiration, muscular tension, and increased cardiovascular activity. The cognitive processes are complex, beginning with the individual labeling their emotional state as “anger.” Novaco and Welsh (1989) suggest that labeling of an emotional state is a function of the individual’s pre-existing system of beliefs and knowledge, or “schemas.” Schemas serve the useful purpose of speeding up information processing, but have the disadvantage that increased speed can lead to faulty or biased judgments. Novaco and Welsh (1989) identified five information-processing biases in individuals prone to anger: (1) attentional cueing, (2) perceptual matching, (3) attributional
THE COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL CONTEXT 9
error, (4) false consensus, and (5) anchoring effects. These cognitive biases are all concerned with the encoding of external and internal cues and the interpretation and cognitive representation of those cues. Attentional cueing refers to the tendency of people who are prone to anger to see hostility and provocation in the words and actions of other people (Dodge, Price, Bachorowski, & Newman, 1990). Perceptual matching is found when an individual, regardless of the situation, bases their current behavior on how they behaved previously. Thus, if a person has found that a display of anger and violent behavior solves a problem, then when faced with another problem in another context they will become angry and violent. An attribution error occurs when the individual perceives their own behavior as situationally determined, but the behavior of other people as explained by their personality. Thus, I see that my behavior is caused by circumstances (external attribution): so, I hit you because you challenged me in front of my friends and they made me respond. On the other hand, I see that your behavior occurs because you are that type of person (internal attribution): you hit me because you are a bad and violent person. The notion of a false consensus is applied when individuals assume that more people agree with them than is actually the case. This, in turn, inhibits perception and appreciation of the other person’s point of view. Novaco and Welsh (1989) suggest that false consensus is found among those individuals who have problems with anger. Finally, there are anchoring effects so that once an individual has made an initial value judgment, they maintain this position even in the face of contrary evidence. Thus, triggering events precipitate cognitive and physiological process which the individual labels as “anger”; the processing biases noted above may play a role at this stage. The progression from anger to violence depends in large part upon the disinhibition of internal control: disinhibition can come about through a range of factors, including person-specific factors such as high levels of physiological arousal, perception of a low possibility of punishment, and the use of drugs or alcohol. Novaco (1993) advises that anger should be understood in context: that is, situational factors, both physical and social, can influence a person’s experience and expression of anger.
SPECIFIC THEORY: MORAL REASONING The third strand in ART lies in attending to the participant’s level of moral reasoning. The process of socialization is linked with moral development in the theories of both Piaget (1932) and Kohlberg (1964, 1978). In particular, Kohlberg has used his theory to develop an explanation for antisocial behavior and this is therefore of interest here. Kohlberg, like Piaget, argues that moral reasoning develops in a sequential manner as the individual attains maturity. Kohlberg describes three levels of moral development, with two stages at each level. As shown in Table 1.1, at the lower stages moral reasoning is concrete in orientation, becoming more abstract at the higher stages and involving concepts such as “justice,” “rights,” and “principles.”
10 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Table 1.1 Levels and stages of moral judgment in Kohlberg’s theory Level 1: Pre-morality Stage 1. Punishment and obedience: moral behavior is concerned with deferring to authority and avoiding punishment. Stage 2. Hedonism: the concern is with one’s own needs irrespective of others’ concerns. Level 2: Conventional conformity Stage 3. Interpersonal concordance: moral reasoning concerned with general conformity and gaining social approval. Stage 4. Law and order: commitment to social order for its own sake and hence deference to social and religious authorities. Level 3 : Autonomous principles Stage 5. Social contract: acknowledgment of individual rights and the role of the democratic process in deriving laws. Stage 6. Universal ethical principles: moral judgment determined by justice, respect, and trust and may transcend legal dictates.
Antisocial behavior, Kohlberg argues, is associated with a delay in the development of moral reasoning so that given the opportunity for offending, the individual does not have the internal processes to control and resist temptation. A number of recent reviews have examined this basic premise with respect to the empirical evidence (Blasi, 1980; Jurkovic, 1980; Jennings, Kilkenny, & Kohlberg, 1983; Nelson, Smith, & Dodd, 1990). The generally accepted position from the major reviews is that delinquents typically show lower levels of reasoning, i.e., Kohlberg’s Premorality Stages (1 and 2), than their non-delinquent peers. Thus, from a Kohlbergian perspective antisocial behavior is associated, in part, with sociomoral developmental delay. This developmental delay is seen in immature and hedonistic, self-centered, moral judgments. However, as Gibbs (1993) points out, moral reasoning does not function in a vacuum: the individual’s level of moral reasoning should be considered alongside other aspects of their cognition. Specifically, Gibbs suggests that the overlap between theories of social information processing (see above) and moral development are useful in understanding the totality of the processes involved. The bridge between moral reasoning and social information processing is argued to take the form of cognitive distortions (Gibbs, 1993; Goldstein et al., 1998). Cognitive distortions are taken to be “Nonveridical attitudes or beliefs pertaining to the self or one’s social behavior” (Gibbs, 1993, p. 165). These cognitive distortions can function both directly to support the attitudes consistent with sociomoral developmental delay and, in line with Sykes and Matza’s (1957) “techniques of neutralization,” to temper any resulting cognitive dissonance. An example of selfcentered moral reasoning is “If I want it, I take it”: Gibbs calls this type of reasoning a primary distortion. The distorted secondary cognitions that flow from such primary distortions may serve to rationalize the behavior, or to mislabel the behavior. Thus, the reasoning (primary cognitive distortion) that “If I want it, I take it” might be rationalized (secondary cognitive distortion) by blaming others: for example, if owners leave their cars unlocked then they deserve to have them stolen. In aggressive individuals the actions of other people may be seen in a distorted
THE COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL CONTEXT 11
way, typically as having hostile intent, with the inevitable conclusion that “they were asking for it” (Dodge et al., 1990). Mislabeling (secondary cognitive distortion) refers to biased interpretations of one’s behavior: for example, car theft can be explained away as “just a laugh” or “nothing serious.” Aggressive individuals may say that their victims “could have had it worse,” “were not too badly hurt,” or that “no real damage was done” (Gibbs, 1996). These powerful types of distorted thinking are often socially supported and reinforced by the offender’s peer group. The cognitive-behavioral theoretical basis of ART is seen in the techniques for behavior change that are used in the program.
COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL METHODS OF CHANGE As with the broader theory, it is possible to see various levels at which to bring about changes in violent behavior. Initiatives that change one or more components of the interaction between the individual and the environment may bring about changes in the target behavior. Thus, prevention and reduction of violence might be achieved at any of the three levels—macro, meso, and micro—described above. However, at the level of working with the violent individual, the focus is on ways of bringing about behavior change through working with the violent person. With its lineage in operant theory, behavior modification and behavior therapy (Martin & Pear, 1999), and skills training (Trower, Bryant, & Argyle, 1978; Hollin & Trower, 1986a, 1986b), so social learning theory (Bandura, 1977) and cognitive behavior modification (Meichenbaum, 1977) became what is now called cognitivebehavioral theory and cognitive-behavior therapy. A number of techniques have become associated with cognitive-behavioral practice: these techniques include modeling, skills training, self-instructional training, thought stopping, emotional control training, and problem-solving training (Sheldon, 1996). In practice, behavior change techniques are seldom used in isolation: it is more common to see amalgams of techniques in the form of multimodal programs (such as ART). Such multimodal programs might include elements such as problem-solving skills training, social skills training, and emotional control training. Thus, the model of change with such an individualized, cognitive-behavioral approach is that by bringing about change in internal (psychological and/or physiological) states and process, this covert change will, in turn, mediate change at an overt behavioral level. Such overt behavioral change will, in turn, elicit new patterns of reinforcement from the environment, so leading to maintenance of behavior change. What is the evidence that these methods of behavior change can be used to any effect with violent behavior?
COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL METHODS AND VIOLENT BEHAVIOR This section has two components: first, the applicability of cognitive-behavioral methods generally to violent populations; second, to consider specifically the three
12 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
elements of ART—skills training, anger control, and moral development—with aggressive offenders.
General Applicability The issue of the application of cognitive-behavioral methods to offending behavior is amply supported by the meta-analyses (Garrett, 1985; Gottschalk, Davidson, Gensheimer, & Mayer, 1987; Gottschalk, Davidson, Mayer, & Gensheimer, 1987; Losel ¨ & Koferl, ¨ 1989; Whitehead & Lab, 1989; Andrews et al., 1990; Izzo & Ross, 1990; Lipsey, 1992; Antonowicz & Ross, 1994; Cleland, Pearson, Lipton, & Yee, 1997; Pearson, Lipton & Cleland, 1997; Redondo, Garrido, & Sanchez-Meca, 1999) and the syntheses of these meta-analyses (Gendreau & Andrews, 1990; Hollin, 1993, 1994, 1999; Lipsey, 1995; Losel, ¨ 1995a, 1995b, 1996; McGuire & Priestley, 1995; Gendreau, 1996; Cooke & Philip, 2001). Nietzel et al.’s (1999) behavioral model of violence discussed above drew on four sequential stages across the life span, encompassing a range of environmental and individual factors. This model is helpful at a conceptual level, although the developmental pathways themselves are less than fully understood (Loeber & Stouthamer-Loeber, 1998; Tolan & Gorman-Smith, 1998). Nietzel et al. conclude their piece with the comment that: “A major implication of this model is the need for preventative interventions that target multiple risk factors for violence” (p. 59). Similarly, Tate, Reppucci, and Mulvey (1995), in their review of treatment effectiveness for violent juveniles, comment that: “Social-cognitive interventions should be encouraged as a critical component of institutional and community-based programs” (p. 780). Tate et al. followed this comment with the note that “The empirical literature on interventions with seriously violent adolescents is rather limited” (p. 779). With reference to the state of the general literature, including juveniles and adults, Blackburn (1993) made the same point: “Investigations of the effects of behavioral methods on aggressive offending have been few” (p. 379). Lipsey and Wilson (1998) report the findings from a meta-analysis of 200 studies concerned with effective intervention for violent juvenile offenders. The metaanalysis included a wide range of interventions, ranging from restitution programs to wilderness programs, considered according to whether the programs were delivered to institutionalized or noninstitutionalized offenders. Lipsey and Wilson report that for noninstitutionalized offenders the types of intervention that consistently produced positive effects, in terms of a reduction in recidivism, were as follows. (The n is the number of studies included in the metaanalysis, with referenced examples as cited by Lipsey and Wilson: it will be seen that the research base is limited.) As indicated by the midpoint of estimated effect sizes, individual counseling produced a strong effect (n = 8: e.g. Moore, 1987; Bean, 1988; Borduin, Henggeler, Blake, & Stein, 1990), followed by interpersonal skills (n = 2: Chandler, 1973; Delinquency Research Group, 1986), and by behavioral programs (n = 7: e.g. Jesness, Allison, McCormic, Wedge, & Young, 1975; Gordon, Graves, & Arbuthnot, 1987). For institutionalized offenders, interpersonal skills (n = 3: Spence & Marzillier, 1981; Glick & Goldstein, 1987) were followed by teaching family homes
THE COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL CONTEXT 13
(community-based, family-style group homes) (n = 6: e.g. Wolf, Phillips, & Fixson, 1974; Kirigin, Braukmann, Atwater, & Worl, 1982), and by behavioral programs (n = 2: Schlicter & Horan, 1981; Guerra & Slaby, 1990). In summary, it can be seen that there is support from the literature for the use generally of cognitive-behavioral methods with aggressive populations.
Specific Applicability The methods used in ART are traditional cognitive-behavioral methods, based on anger control, problem-solving skills training, and social skills training. There is ample evidence that these methods have been used with good effect with violent offenders (Hollin & Courtney, 1983; Howells, 1986; Henderson, 1989; Marshall, Turner, & Barbaree, 1989; Guerra & Slaby, 1990; Bush, 1995; Hughes, 1996; Hollin & Palmer, 2001; Novaco , Ramm, & Black, 2001; Polaschek & Dixon, 2001; Polaschek & Reynolds, 2001). The development of Moral Reasoning Training, in keeping with Gibbs’ theory of moral functioning, to enhance moral development in violent populations has been reported in the literature (Gibbs, 1993, 1996; Gibbs, Potter, & Goldstein, 1995; Goldstein, Glick, & Gibbs, 1998). The point can be repeated that ART has a research base that supports its effectiveness. Goldstein et al. (1998) cover the range of centers in which ART has been applied, together with the positive outcome evidence from these centers of application (Goldstein & Glick, 1987; Goldstein, Glick, Irwin, & McCartney, 1989; Leeman, Gibbs, & Fuller, 1993; Goldstein, Glick, Carthen, & Blancero, 1994). It is clear that ART represents a major advance in work with violent offenders who have a history that includes a pattern of violence of an interpersonal nature. It can be said with confidence that it is possible to work with some violent offenders and reduce their rates of violent conduct. However, what we know now sets the future research agenda: how might ART develop over the next decade?
RESEARCH AGENDA The literature suggests that ART is at its strongest when used with offenders who have committed acts of interpersonal violence, typically with and against their peers. Such offenders are likely to be of medium to medium-high risk of reoffending and will have reasonable levels of cognitive functioning. Where might we go from here? Domestic violence continues to be an enduring problem and one to which the methods implicit in ART might gainfully be employed (Dobash, Dobash, Cavanagh, & Lewis, 2000). The research that suggests similar predictors of violence in mentally disordered and mainstream offender groups (Bonta, Law, & Hanson, 1998) further suggests that ART, suitably adapted, might well be appropriate for mentally disordered violent offenders. The extension of the target groups and modification of ART might also be widened to those of low intellectual ability who behave in a violent manner (Day, 2001). The configuration of programs for exceptionally high-risk violent offenders, such as those with psychopathic disorder,
14 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
continues to be a challenge to researchers and practitioners (Wong, 2000). The possibilities of utilizing ART in this particular arena have yet to be explored. Finally, as contemporary criminological research begins to address issues specific to the female offender, specialist offender programs for women are being developed (Andrews & Dowden, 1999). The evolution of programs such as ART with respect to the special needs of women would be a welcome step for many practitioners (Bloom, 1999). While a great deal has been achieved in a short period of time, it is clear that much, much more remains to be done.
REFERENCES Akhtar, N. & Bradley, E. J. (1991). Social information processing deficits of aggressive children: Present findings and implication for social skills training. Clinical Psychology Review, 11, 621–644. Andrews, D. A. & Dowden, C. (1999). A meta-analytic investigation into effective correctional intervention for female offenders. Forum on Corrections Research, 11, 18–21. Andrews, D. A., Zinger, I., Hoge, R. D., Bonta, J., Gendreau, P., & Cullen, F. T. (1990). Does correctional treatment work? A clinically relevant and informed meta-analysis. Criminology, 28, 369–404. Antonowicz, D. H. & Ross, R. R. (1994). Essential components of successful rehabilitation programs for offenders. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 38, 97–104. Argyle, M. (1983). The psychology of interpersonal behaviour (4th edn). Harmondsworth: Penguin. Argyle, M. & Kendon, A. (1967). The experimental analysis of social performance. In L. Berkowitz (Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology, Vol. 3. New York: Academic Press. Bandura, A. (1973). Aggression: A social learning analysis. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Bandura, A. (1977). Social learning theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Bandura, A. (1986). Social foundations of thought and action: A social-cognitive theory . Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Bean, J. S. (1988). The effect of individualized reality therapy on the recidivism rates and locus of control orientation of male juvenile offenders. Doctoral dissertation, University of Mississippi. Dissertation Abstracts International, 49, 2370B (University Microfilms No. 88-18138). Blackburn, R. (1993). The psychology of criminal conduct: Theory, research and practice. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Blasi, A. (1980). Bridging moral cognition and moral action: A critical review. Psychological Bulletin, 88, 1–45. Bloom, B. (1999). Gender-responsive programming for women offenders: Guiding principles and practices. Forum on Corrections Research, 11, 22–27. Bonta, J., Law, M., & Hanson, R. K. (1998). The prediction of criminal and violent recidivism among mentally disordered offenders: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 123, 123–142. Borduin, C. M., Henggeler, S. W., Blake, D. M., & Stein, R. J. (1990). Multisystemic treatment of adolescent sexual offenders. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 34, 105–113. Bush, J. (1995). Teaching self-risk management to violent offenders. In J. McGuire (Ed.), What works: Reducing reoffending. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Chandler, M. J. (1973). Egocentrism and antisocial behavior: The assessment and training of social perspective-training skills. Developmental Psychology, 9, 326–333.
THE COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL CONTEXT 15 Cleland, C. M., Pearson, F. S., Lipton, D. S., & Yee, D. (1997). Does age make a difference? A meta-analytic approach to reductions in criminal offending for juveniles and adults. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, San Diego, CA, November. Cooke, D. J. & Philip, L. (2001). To treat or not to treat? An empirical perspective. In C. R. Hollin (Ed.), Handbook of offender assessment and treatment. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Crick, N. R. & Dodge, K. A. (1994). A review and reformulation of social informationprocessing mechanisms in children’s social adjustment. Psychological Bulletin, 115, 74– 101. Crick, N. R. & Dodge, K. A. (1996). Social information-processing mechanisms in reactive and proactive aggression. Child Development, 67, 993–1002. Day, K. (2001). Offenders with mental retardation. In C. R. Hollin (Ed.), Handbook of offender assessment and treatment. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Delinquency Research Group (1986). An evaluation of the delinquency of participants in the youth at risk program. Claremont, CA: Claremont Graduate School, Center for Applied Social Research. Demorest, A. P. (1992). The role of social cognition in children’s social maladjustment. Social Cognition, 10, 211–233. Dobash, R. E., Dobash, R. P., Cavanagh, K., & Lewis, R. (2000). Changing violent men. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Dodge, K. A. & Garber, J. (1991). Domains of emotion regulation. In J. Garber & K. A. Dodge (Eds), The development of emotion regulation and dysregulation. New York: Cambridge University Press. Dodge, K. A. Murphy, R. R., & Buchsbaum, K. (1984). The assessment of intention-cue detection skills in children: Implications for developmental psychopathology. Child Development, 55, 163–173. Dodge, K. A., Price, J. M., Bachorowski, J.-A., & Newman, J. P. (1990). Hostile attributional biases in severely aggressive adolescents. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 99, 385– 392. Dodge, K. A. & Tomlin, A. M. (1987). Utilization of self-schemas as a mechanism of interpretational bias in aggressive children. Social Cognition, 5, 280–300. Gaffney, L. R. & McFall, R. M. (1981). A comparison of social skills in delinquent and nondelinquent adolescent girls using a behavioral role-playing inventory. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 49, 959–967. Garrett, C. J. (1985). Effects of residential treatment of adjudicated delinquents: A metaanalysis. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 22, 287–308. Gendreau, P. (1996). Offender rehabilitation: What we know and what needs to be done. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 23, 144–161. Gendreau, P., & Andrews, D. A. (1990). What the meta-analyses of the offender treatment literature tells us about “what works.” Canadian Journal of Criminology, 32, 173– 184. Gibbs, J. C. (1993). Moral-cognitive interventions. In A. P. Goldstein & C. R. Huff (Eds), The gang intervention handbook. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Gibbs, J. C. (1996). Sociomoral group treatment for young offenders. In C. R. Hollin & K. Howells (Eds.), Clinical approaches to working with young offenders. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Gibbs, J. C., Potter, G. B., & Goldstein, A. P. (1995). The EQUIP program: Teaching youth to think and act responsibily through a peer-helping approach. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Glick, B. & Goldstein, A. P. (1987). Aggression replacement training. Journal of Counseling and Development, 65(7), 356–362. Goldstein, A. P. (1994). The ecology of aggression. New York: Plenum Press. Goldstein, A. P. & Glick, B. (1987). Aggression Replacement Training: A comprehensive intervention for adolescent youth. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P. & Glick, B. (1996). Aggression Replacement Training: Methods and outcomes. In C. R. Hollin & K. Howells (Eds), Clinical approaches to working with young offenders. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.
16 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Goldstein, A. P., Glick, B., Carthen, W., & Blancero, D. (1994). The prosocial gang. Thousand Oaks, CA: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P., Glick, B., & Gibbs, J. C. (1998). Aggression Replacement Training (rev. edn). Champaign, IL: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P., Glick, B., Irwin, M. J., McCartney, C., & Rubama, I. (1989). Reducing delinquency: Intervention in the community. New York: Pergamon Press. Gordon, D. A., Graves, K., & Arbuthnot, J. (1987). Prevention of adult criminal behavior using family therapy for disadvantaged juvenile delinquents. Manuscript, Ohio University, Athens, OH. Gottschalk, R., Davidson II, W. S., Gensheimer, L. K., & Mayer, J. (1987). Communitybased interventions. In H. C. Quay (Ed.), Handbook of juvenile delinquency. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Gottschalk, R., Davidson II, W. S., Mayer, J., & Gensheimer, L. K. (1987). Behavioural approaches with juvenile offenders: A meta-analysis of long-term treatment efficacy. In E. K. Morris & C. J. Braukmann (Eds), Behavioral approaches to crime and delinquency. New York: Plenum. Gresswell, D. M. & Hollin, C. R. (1992). Towards a new methodology for making sense of case material: An illustrative case involving attempted multiple murder. Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health, 2, 329–341. Guerra, N. G. & Slaby, R. G. (1990). Cognitive mediators of aggression in adolescent offenders: 2. Intervention. Developmental Psychology, 26, 269–277. Henderson, M. (1989). Behavioural approaches to violent crime. In K. Howells & C. R. Hollin (Eds), Clinical approaches to violence. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Hollin, C. R. (1990a). Cognitive-behavioral interventions with young offenders. Elmsford, NY: Pergamon Press. Hollin, C. R. (1990b). Social skills training with delinquents: A look at the evidence and some recommendations for practice. British Journal of Social Work, 20, 483–493. Hollin, C. R. (1993). Advances in the psychological treatment of criminal behaviour. Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health, 3, 42–57. Hollin, C. R. (1994). Designing effective rehabilitation programmes for young offenders. Psychology, Crime and Law, 1, 193–199. Hollin, C. R. (1999). Treatment programmes for offenders: Meta-analysis, “what works”, and beyond. International Journal of Psychiatry and Law, 22, 361–372. Hollin, C. R. & Courtney, S. (1983). A skills training approach to the reduction of institutional offending. Personality and Individual Differences, 4, 257–264. Hollin, C. R. & Palmer, E. J. (2001). Skills training. In C. R. Hollin (Ed.), Handbook of offender assessment and treatment. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Hollin, C. R. & Trower, P. (Eds) (1986a). Handbook of social skills training, Vol. 1: Applications across the life span. Oxford: Pergamon Press. Hollin, C. R. & Trower, P. (Eds) (1986b). Handbook of social skills training, Vol. 2: Clinical applications and new directions. Oxford: Pergamon Press. Hollin, C. R. & Trower, P. (1986c). Social skills training: Critique and future development. In C. R. Hollin & P. Trower (Eds), Handbook of social skills training, Vol. 2: Clinical applications and new directions. Oxford: Pergamon Press. Howells, K. (1986). Social skills training and criminal and antisocial behaviour in adults. In C. R. Hollin & P. Trower (Eds), Handbook of social skills training, Vol. 1: Applications across the life span. Oxford: Pergamon Press. Hughes, G. V. (1996). Short and long term outcomes for a cognitive-behavioral anger management program. In G. Davies, S. Lloyd-Bostock, M. McMurran, & C. Wilson (Eds), Psychology, law, and criminal justice: International developments in research and practice. New York: Walter de Gruyter. Hunter, D. (1993). Anger management in the prison: An evaluation. Forum on Corrections Research, 5, 3–5. Izzo, R. L. & Ross, R. R. (1990). Meta-analysis of rehabilitation programs for juvenile delinquents: A brief report. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 17, 134–142. Jeffery, C. R. (1965). Criminal behavior and learning theory. Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science, 56, 294–300.
THE COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL CONTEXT 17 Jennings, W. S., Kilkenny, R., & Kohlberg, L. (1983). Moral development theory and practice for youthful and adult offenders. In W. S. Laufer & J. M. Day (Eds), Personality theory, moral development, and criminal behavior. Toronto: Lexington Books. Jesness, C. F., Allison, F. S., McCormic, P. M., Wedge, R. F., & Young, M. L. (1975). An evaluation of the effectiveness of contingency contracting with delinquents. Sacramento, CA: California Youth Authority. Jurkovic, G. J. (1980). The juvenile delinquent as moral philosopher: A structuraldevelopmental approach. Psychological Bulletin, 88, 709–727. Kendall, P. C. & Bacon, S. F. (1988). Cognitive behavior therapy. In D. B. Fishman, F. Rotgers, & C. M. Franks (Eds), Paradigms in behavior therapy: Present and promise. New York: SpringerVerlag. Kirigin, K. A., Braukmann, C. J., Atwater, J. D., & Worl, M. M. (1982). An evaluation of teaching-family (Achievement Place) group homes for juvenile offenders. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 15, 1–16. Kohlberg, L. (1964). Development of moral character and moral ideology. In M. Hoffman & L. Hoffman (Eds), Review of child development research, Vol. 1. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Kohlberg, L. (1978). Revisions in the theory and practice of mental development. In W. Damon (Ed.), New directions in child development: Moral development. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Leeman, L. W., Gibbs, J. C., & Fuller, D. (1993). Evaluation of a multi-component treatment program for juvenile delinquents. Aggressive Behavior, 19, 281–292. Lipsey, M. W. (1992). Juvenile delinquency treatment: A meta-analytic inquiry into the variability of effects. In T. D. Cook, H. Cooper, D. S. Cordray, H. Hartmann, L. V. Hedges, R. J. Light, T. A. Louis, & F. Mosteller (Eds), Meta-analysis for explanation: A casebook. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Lipsey, M. W. (1995). What do we learn from 400 studies on the effectiveness of treatment with juvenile delinquents? In J. McGuire (Ed.), What works: Reducing reoffending. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Lipsey, M. W. & Wilson, D. B. (1998). Effective intervention for serious juvenile offenders. In R. Loeber & D. Farrington (Eds), Serious and violent juvenile offenders: Risk factors and successful interventions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Lipton, D. N., McDonel, E. C., & McFall, R. M. (1987). Heterosocial perception in rapists. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 55, 17–21. Loeber, R. & Stouthamer-Loeber, M. (1998). Development of juvenile aggression and violence: Some common misconceptions and controversies. American Psychologist, 53, 242– 259. Lochman, J. E. & Dodge, K. A. (1994). Social-cognitive processes of severely violent, moderately aggressive and nonaggressive boys. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 62, 366–374. Losel, ¨ F. (1995a). The efficacy of correctional treatment: A review and synthesis of metaevaluations. In J. McGuire (Ed.), What works: Reducing reoffending. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Losel, ¨ F. (1995b). Increasing consensus in the evaluation of offender rehabilitation? Lessons from recent research syntheses. Psychology, Crime and Law, 2, 19–39. Losel, ¨ F. (1996). Working with young offenders: The impact of the meta-analyses. In C. R. Hollin & K. Howells (Eds), Clinical approaches to working with young offenders. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Losel, ¨ F. & Koferl, ¨ P. (1989). Evaluation research on correctional treatment in West Germany: A meta-analysis. In H. Wegener, F. Losel, ¨ & J. Haison (Eds), Criminal behavior and the justice system: Psychological perspectives. New York: Springer-Verlag. Loza, W. & Loza-Fanous, A. (1999). The fallacy of reducing rape and violent recidivism by treating anger. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 43, 492–502. Marshall, W. L., Turner, B. A., & Barbaree, H. E. (1989). An evaluation of life skills training for penitentiary inmates. Journal of Offender Counseling, Services and Rehabilitation, 14, 41–59.
18 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Martin, G. & Pear, J. (1999). Behavior modification: What it is and how to do it (6th edn). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall. McCown, W. Johnson, J., & Austin, S. (1986). Inability of delinquents to recognize facial affects. Journal of Social Behavior and Personality, 1, 489–496. McGuire, J. & Priestley, P. (1995). Reviewing “what works”: Past, present and future. In J. McGuire (Ed.), What works: Reducing reoffending. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Meichenbaum, D. M. (1977). Cognitive behavior modification. New York: Plenum Press. Moore, R. H. (1987). Effectiveness of citizen volunteers functioning as counselors for highrisk young male offenders. Psychological Reports, 61(3), 823–830. Nelson, J. R., Smith, D. J., & Dodd, J. (1990). The moral reasoning of juvenile delinquents: A meta-analysis. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 18, 709–727. Nietzel, M. T., Hasemann, D. M., & Lynam, D. R. (1999). Behavioral perspective on violent behavior. In V. B. Van Hasselt & M. Hersen (Eds), Handbook of psychological approaches with violent offenders: Contemporary strategies and issues. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Press. Novaco, R. W. (1975). Anger control: The development and evaluation of an experimental treatment. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath. Novaco, R. W. (1993). Clinicians ought to view anger contextually. Behaviour Change, 10, 208–218. Novaco, R. W. (1994). Anger as a risk factor for violence among the mentally disordered. In J. Monahan & H. Steadman (Eds), Violence and mental disorder. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Novaco, R. W., Ramm, M., & Black, L. (2001). Anger treatment with offenders. In C. R. Hollin (Ed.), Handbook of offender assessment and treatment. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Novaco, R. W. & Welsh, W. N. (1989). Anger disturbances: Cognitive mediation and clinical prescriptions. In K. Howells & C. R. Hollin (Eds), Clinical approaches to violence. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Palmer, E. J. & Hollin, C. R. (1996). Assessing adolescent problems: An overview of the Adolescent Problem Inventory. Journal of Adolescence, 19, 347–354. Palmer, E. J. & Hollin, C. R. (1999). Social competence and sociomoral reasoning in young offenders. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 13, 79–87. Pearson, F. S., Lipton, D. S., & Cleland, C. M. (1997). Rehabilitative programs in adult corrections: CDATE meta-analyses. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, San Diego, CA, November. Piaget, J. (1932). The moral judgement of the child. London: Kegan Paul. Polaschek, D. L. L. & Dixon, B. G. (2001). The Violence Prevention Project: The development and evaluation of a treatment programme for violent offenders. Psychology, Crime and Law, 7, 1–23. Polaschek, D. L. L. & Reynolds, N. (2001). Assessment and treatment: Violent offenders. In C. R. Hollin (Ed.), Handbook of offender assessment and treatment. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Redondo, S., Garrido, V., & Sanchez-Meca, J. (1999). The influence of treatment programmes on the recidivism of juvenile and adult offenders: A European meta-analytic study. Psychology, Crime and Law, 5, 251–278. Ross, R. R. & Fabiano, E. A. (1985). Time to think: A cognitive model of delinquency prevention and offender rehabilitation. Johnson City, TN: Institute of Social Sciences and Arts. Schlicter, K. J. & Horan, J. J. (1981). Effects of stress inoculation on the anger and aggression management skills of institutionalized juvenile delinquents. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 5(4), 359–365. Sheldon, B. (1996). Cognitive-behavioral therapy. London: Routledge. Skinner, B. F. (1974). About behaviorism. London: Cape. Slaby, R. G. & Guerra, N. G. (1988). Cognitive mediators of aggression in adolescent offenders: I. Assessment. Developmental Psychology, 24, 580–588. Spence, S. H. (1981a). Differences in social skills performance between institutionalized juvenile male offenders and a comparable group of boys without offence records. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 20, 163–171.
THE COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL CONTEXT 19 Spence, S. H. (1981b). Validation of social skills of adolescent males in an interview conversation with a previously unknown adult. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 14, 159–168. Spence, S. H. & Marzillier, J. S. (1981). Social skills training with adolescent male offenders: Short-term, long-term and generalized effects. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 19, 349–368. Spivack, G., Platt, J. J., & Shure, M. B. (1976). The problem-solving approach to adjustment: A guide to research and intervention. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Swaffer, T. & Hollin, C. R. (2000). Anger and impulse control. In R. Newell & K. Gournay (Eds), Mental health nursing: An evidence-based approach. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone. Swaffer, T. & Hollin, C. R. (2001). Anger and general health in young offenders. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry, 12, 90–103. Sykes, G. M. & Matza, D. (1957). Techniques of neutralization: A theory of delinquency. American Sociological Review, 22, 664–670. Tate, D. C., Reppucci, N. D., & Mulvey, E. P. (1995). Violent juvenile delinquents: Treatment effectiveness and implications for future action. American Psychologist, 50, 777–781. Tolan, P. H. & Gorman-Smith, D. (1998). Development of serious and violent offending careers. In R. Loeber & D. Farrington (Eds), Serious and violent juvenile offenders: Risk factors and successful interventions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Trower, P., Bryant, B., & Argyle, M. (1978). Social skills and mental health. London: Methuen. Veneziano, C. & Veneziano, L. (1988). Knowledge of social skills among institutionalized juvenile delinquents: An assessment. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 15 , 152–171. Ward, C. I. & McFall, R. M. (1986). Further validation of the Problem Inventory for Adolescent Girls: Comparing Caucasian and black delinquents and nondelinquents. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 54, 732–733. Whitehead, J. T. & Lab, S. P. (1989). A meta-analysis of juvenile correctional treatment. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 26, 276–295. Wolf, M. M., Phillips, E. L., & Fixson, D. L. (1974). Achievement place: Phase II (Vol. 1). Rockville, MD: National Institute of Mental Health, Center for Studies of Crime and Delinquency. Wong, S. (2000). Psychopathic offenders. In S. Hodgins & R. Muller-Isberner ¨ (Eds), Violence, crime and mentally disordered offenders. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Zamble, E. & Quinsey, V. L. (1997). The criminal recidivism process. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Chapter 2
SKILLSTREAMING: THE BEHAVIORAL COMPONENT ARNOLD P. GOLDSTEIN Syracuse University, New York, USA
I first entered into the domain of social skills training almost 30 years ago, as I wrote of Structured Learning Therapy (later re-christened Skillstreaming) as a useful intervention for adult psychiatric patients about to be deinstitutionalized after long mental hospital stays (Goldstein, 1973). As social skills training left the status of mere intervention, and became a veritable psychoeducational movement, my colleagues and students and I became more and more heavily involved in its conceptualization and implementation. Over the course of these three decades, we have developed Skillstreaming formats, curricula, and procedures for elderly adults (Goldstein, Hoyer, & Monti, 1979), child-abusing parents (Goldstein, Keller, & Ern´e, 1985), industrial managers (Goldstein & Sorcher, 1974), police officers (Goldstein, Monti, Sardino, & Green, 1978), substance abusers (Goldstein, Reagles, & Amann, 1990), preschool youngsters (McGinnis & Goldstein, 1990), elementary school students (McGinniss & Goldstein, 1984), and, most fully, aggressive, withdrawn, developmentally delayed, or otherwise skill-deficient adolescents (Goldstein & McGinnis, 1997). Across these diverse trainee populations, skill curriculum-delivery procedures have remained essentially constant, and consisted of: (1) modeling (the skill demonstration by the trainers), (2) role-playing (the skill rehearsal by the trainee), (3) performance feedback (by all trainees in the group and the trainers), and (4) generalization training (such as skill homework assignments, to enhance transfer and maintenance). Utilizing this sequence of procedures, Skillstreaming was first employed primarily as a “standalone” intervention and then increasingly as a procedure folded into ART and used as its behavior change, deficit-altering component. In doing so, the extended skill curriculum shown in (Table 2.1) is taught. All of the skills in the curriculum are broken down into their constituent behavioral steps. The steps are the skills. They are what is modeled by the trainers, role-played by trainees, and commented upon in giving feedback. Four adolescent New Perspectives on Aggression Replacement Training: Practice, Research, and Application. C 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Edited by A. P. Goldstein, R. Nens´en, B. Daleflod, and M. Kalt.
22 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Table 2.1 The Skillstreaming curriculum for adolescents Group I: Beginning social skills 1. Listening 2. Starting a conversation 3. Having a conversation 4. Asking a question 5. Saying thank you 6. Introducing yourself 7. Introducing other people 8. Giving a compliment Group II: Advanced social skills 9. Asking for help 10. Joining in 11. Giving instructions 12. Following instructions 13. Apologizing 14. Convincing others Group III: Skills for dealing with feelings 15. Knowing your feelings 16. Expressing your feelings 17. Understanding the feelings of others 18. Dealing with someone else’s anger 19. Expressing affection 20. Dealing with fear 21. Rewarding yourself Group IV: Skill alternatives to aggression 22. Asking permission 23. Sharing something 24. Helping others
25. Negotiating 26. Using self-control 27. Standing up for your rights 28. Responding to teasing 29. Avoiding trouble with others 30. Keeping out of fights Group V: Skills for dealing with stress 31. Making a complaint 32. Answering a complaint 33. Being a good sport 34. Dealing with embarrassment 35. Dealing with being left out 36. Standing up for a friend 37. Responding to persuasion 38. Responding to failure 39. Dealing with contradictory messages 40. Dealing with an accusation 41. Getting ready for a difficult conversation 42. Dealing with group pressure Group VI: Planning skills 43. Deciding on something to do 44. Deciding what caused a problem 45. Setting a goal 46. Deciding on your abilities 47. Gathering information 48. Arranging problems by importance 49. Making a decision 50. Concentrating on a task
curriculum skills are shown in Boxes 2.1–2.4 along with (1) their skill steps, (2) trainer notes provided to help trainers coach trainees, (3) suggested contents for each skill’s modeling displays, and (4) where appropriate, additional comments for trainer guidance. The sequence of procedures employed in carrying out the modeling, role-play, performance feedback, and generalization training processes that constitute Skillstreaming are listed in Table 2.2. Defining the skill is conducted briefly, usually in but a few minutes. Its purpose is orientation to both general meaning and concrete example. The youths who typically are the recipients of Skillstreaming—especially as part of ART—tend to be action-oriented youngsters who do not sit easily for lengthy or abstract lectures or discussions. Defining the skill quickly and with their participation gets them “on board” and ready for the more action-oriented processes of modeling. Trainers proceed to model the skill being taught, taking care to (1) select contents relevant to trainees’ real-life circumstances, (2) clearly depict all of the behavioral steps constituting the skill being modeled, and (3) display a positive outcome, as behaviors which “work” are more likely to be instated.
SKILLSTREAMING 23
Box 2.1 Skill 28: Responding to teasing Steps
Trainer notes
1. Decide if you are being teased. 2. Think about ways to deal with the teasing. 3. Choose the best way to do it.
Are others making jokes or whispering? Gracefully accept it; make a joke of it; ignore it. When possible, avoid alternatives that foster aggression, malicious counterteasing, and withdrawal.
Suggested content for modeling displays School or neighborhood: main actor ignores classmate’s comments when volunteering to help teacher after class. Home: main actor tells sibling to stop teasing about new haircut. Peer group: main actor deals with peer’s teasing about a girlfriend or boyfriend by making a joke of it.
Box 2.2 Skill 30: Keeping out of fights Steps 1. Stop and think about why you want to fight. 2. Decide what you want to happen in the long run. 3. Think about other ways to handle the situation besides fighting.
Trainer notes
What is the long-range outcome? You might negotiate, stand up for your rights, ask for help, or pacify the person.
4. Decide on the best way to handle the situation and do it. Suggested content for modeling displays School or neighborhood: main actor tells classmate that he/she wants to talk out their differences instead of being pressured to fight. Home: main actor resolves potential fight with older sibling by asking parent to intervene. Peer group: main actor goes for help when he/she sees peers fighting on school steps. Comments Prior to teaching this skill, it is often useful to review Skill 26 (Using self-control).
24 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
Box 2.3 Skill 32: Answering a complaint Steps
Trainer notes
1. Listen to the complaint. 2. Ask the person to explain anything you don’t understand. 3. Tell the person that you understand the complaint. 4. State your ideas about the complaint, accepting the blame if appropriate. 5. Suggest what each of you could do about the complaint.
Listen openly.
Rephrase; acknowledge the content and feeling.
You might compromise, defend your position, or apologize.
Suggested content for modeling displays School or neighborhood: main actor responds to neighbor’s complaint about noisy party. Home: main actor responds to parent’s complaint about selection of friends. Peer group: main actor responds to friend’s complaint about returning sporting equipment in poor condition.
Box 2.4 Skill 42: Dealing with group pressure Steps
Trainer notes
1. Think about what the group wants you to do and why.
Listen to other people; decide what the real meaning is; try to understand what is being said. Yield; resist; delay; negotiate. Give reasons; talk to one person only; delay; assert yourself.
2. Decide what you want to do. 3. Decide how to tell the group what you want to do. 4. Tell the group what you have decided.
Suggested content for modeling displays School or neighborhood: main actor deals with group pressure to vandalize neighborhood. Home: main actor deals with family pressure to break up friendship. Peer group: main actor deals with pressure to fight. Following skill definition and modeling, a brief “go-around” is conducted to establish concretely the circumstances constituting each trainee’s current need for the skill—with whom, where, when, and so forth. A role-player (the “main actor”)
SKILLSTREAMING 25 Table 2.2 Skillstreaming training steps 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Define the skill Model the skill Establish trainee skill need Select role-player Set up the role-play Conduct the role-play Provide performance feedback Assign skill homework Select next role-player
is then selected and, using the just-obtained need-for-skill information, an appropriate role-play scene is constructed. A co-actor is chosen and asked to portray the main actor’s real-world other figure; the physical scene is set. In order to facilitate the quality of post-role-play feedback, as well as to maximize group member attention during each role-play, the skill steps are assigned to various members, who are instructed to note how and how well the main actor carried out the given step. The role-play is then conducted, with trainers offering guidance as needed as it unfolds. Immediate re-role-plays are sometimes necessary to assure that each role-play (given that they are rehearsals) ends with a smooth portrayal of the given skill’s steps and in the proper sequence. Feedback by other trainees is provided, further “shaping up” the quality of the skill, and its readiness for real-world use. When such readiness is the case, the trainee is then asked to carry out the skill in his or her own real-world environment, with his/her actual significant others. To maximize the likelihood that homework will in fact be done, trainees are asked to complete a homework contract, called the Homework Report, a completed copy of which is shown in Figure 2.1. The training sequence for that trainee is thus completed, and the next role-player is then chosen. Given the not-infrequent proclivity for youths involved in Skillstreaming and ART programs to act up, not out, and display behavior management challenges during training sessions, I have long urged when possible that two trainers be used to run each session. Trainers optimally will be skilled not only in the Skillstreaming method, group management, and good pedagogy, but also be as acutely attuned as possible to the real-world cultural perspective of the participating youths. An ideal group size is often six to eight, as that is the approximate number of roleplays that can comfortably be completed within a session. Smaller groups, at least initially, are recommended for particularly aggressive trainees. When larger groups are unavoidable, seeking additional adult assistance for both feedback and group management purposes is advised. The frequency of sessions is variable—once per week, twice, or other. Crucial here is to make certain that trainees have ample time and opportunity to complete homework assignments. Since Skillstreaming programs have as their core goal to prepare youths for prosocially skilled real-life functioning, groups should be constituted in such a manner that their parallel to real-life relationships is maximized. The more they are a microcosm the better, which often concretely translates to peers, boys and girls, antagonists, family members, and so forth. Decisions about who should and should
26 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Skillstreaming the Adolescent HOMEWORK REPORT 1 Name:
Date:
Josh
September 15
FILL IN DURING THIS CLASS 1. What skill will you use? Dealing with Group Pressure 2. What are the steps for the skill? 1. Think about what the group wants you to do and why. 2. Decide what you want to do. 3. Decide how to tell the group what you want to do. 4. Tell the group what you have decided. 3. Where will you try the skill? At my locker 4. With whom will you try the skill? My friends 5. When will you try the skill? After school FILL IN AFTER DOING YOUR HOMEWORK 1. What happened when you did the homework?
My friends acted like they sort of understood. 2. Which skill steps did you really follow?
1, 2, and 4. 3. How good a job did you do in using the skill? (check one) Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor
4. What do you think should be your next homework assignment?
Try the skill again with the same friends.
Figure 2.1 Completed Homework Report. Reproduced from Goldstein and McGinnis (1997) Skillstreaming the adolescent—student manual. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Copyright (1997) Goldstein and McGinnis. Reprinted by permission.
not be included in the program at all rest in the final analysis on matters of skill proficiency and deficiency. Those already reasonably competent in the skills to be taught obviously are not in need of training. Those deficient, are. While several avenues of social skill assessment exist, we have relied primarily on behavioral observation (by the youth care worker, teacher, or other “front-line” person working with the youth much of the time) and our Skillstreaming Checklists. The forms shown in Figures 2.2 and 2.3 are segments from the Staff and Student forms of this assessment device.
SKILLSTREAMING 27 Skillstreaming the Elementary School Child TEACHER/STAFF SKILLSTREAMING CHECKLIST Student:____________________________ Class/age:___________________ Teacher/staff:________________________________ Date: _______________ INSTRUCTIONS:
Listed below you will find a number of skills that children are more or less proficient in using. This checklist will help you evaluate how well each child uses the various skills. For each child, rate his/her use of each skill, based on your observations of his/her behavior in various situations. Circle 1 if the child is almost never good at using the skill. Circle 2 if the child is seldom good at using the skill. Circle 3 if the child is sometimes good at using the skill. Circle 4 if the child is often good at using the skill. Circle 5 if the child is almost always good at using the skill.
almost never
seldom
sometimes
often
almost always
Please rate the child on all skills listed. If you know of a situation in which the child has particular difficulty in using the skill well, please note it briefly in the space marked "Problem situation."
1
2
3
4
5
2. Asking for Help: Does the student decide when he/she 1 needs assistance and ask for this help in a pleasant manner?
2
3 4
5
2
3
5
1.
Listening: Does the student appear to listen when someone is speaking and make an effort to understand what is said? Problem situation:
Problem situation: 3.
Saying Thank You: Does the student tell others he/she appreciates help given, favors, and so forth?
1
4
Problem situation:
Figure 2.2 Skillstreaming Checklist—Staff form. Reproduced from McGinnis and Goldstein (1997) Skillstreaming the elementary school child. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Copyright (1997) McGinnis and Goldstein. Reprinted by permission.
In addition to its value as a means of determining levels and locus of perceived skill proficiency and deficiency across the curriculum, the Student Checklist— on which trainees can indicate which skills they feel deficient in, has been used effectively by us to “negotiate the curriculum” with participating youths. Done for motivation-promoting purposes, this is a procedure (using Student Checklist tallies) for jointly determining with trainees which skills are to be taught. It is rare for youths to be empowered in this manner. It is our long-standing impression that such empowerment does indeed enhance trainee motivation to attend sessions, to participate actively, and to use the skills thus learned. Beginning with our earliest use of Skillstreaming, and continuing to the present, we have urged that its outcomes be rigorously evaluated. Several dozen evaluations
28 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Skillstreaming the Elementary School Child STUDENT SKILLSTREAMING CHECKLIST Name:_______________________________________ Date: ___________________ INSTRUCTIONS: Each of the questions will ask you about how well you do something. Next to each question is a number. Circle number 1 if you almost never do what the question asks. Circle number 2 if you seldom do it. Circle number 3 if you sometimes do it. Circle number 4 if you do it often. Circle number 5 if you almost always do it.
almost never
seldom
sometimes
often
almost always
There are no right or wrong answers to these questions. Answer the way you really feel about each question.
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
33
44 5 5
3. Do I tell people thank you for something they have done for me?
1
2
3
4
5
4. Do I have the materials I need for my classes (like books, pencils, paper)?
1
2
3
4
5
5. Do I understand what to do when directions are given, and do I follow these directions?
1
2
3
4
5
6. Do I finish my schoolwork?
1
2
3
4
5
7. Do I join in on class talks or discussions?
1
2
3
4
5
8. Do I try to help an adult when I think he/she could use the help?
1
2
3
4
5
9. Do I decide what I don't understand about my schoolwork and ask my teacher questions in a friendly way?
1
2
3
4
5
10. Is it easy for me to keep doing my schoolwork when people are noisy?
1
2
3
4
5
1. Is it easy for me to listen to someone who is talking to me? 2. Do I ask for help in a friendly way when I need help?
1
Figure 2.3 Skillstreaming Checklist—Student form. Reproduced from McGinnis and Goldstein (1997) Skillstreaming the elementary school child. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Copyright (1997) McGinnis and Goldstein. Reprinted with permission.
of Skillstreaming as a “standalone” intervention have been conducted, as well as now a dozen more as a component of ART. This quite substantial array of efficacy evaluations—conducted across time, venues, investigators, diverse trainees, and diverse cultures—reveals it to be an effective means for effecting skill acquisition. When (and often only when) the Skillstreaming program also sought to involve trainee peers or family, or used other techniques in the training itself which were explicitly designed to maximize transfer and/or maintenance of skill proficiency,
SKILLSTREAMING 29
outcomes beyond mere acquisition, but on to skill generalization, have also been reliably reported.
REFERENCES Goldstein, A. P. (1973). Structured learning therapy: Toward a psychotherapy for the poor. New York: Academic Press. Goldstein, A. P., Hoyer, W. J., & Monti, P. J. (1979). Police and the elderly. New York: Pergamon Press. Goldstein, A. P., Keller, H., & Ern´e, D. (1985). Changing the abusive parent. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P. & McGinnis, E. (1997). Skillstreaming the adolescent—student manual (rev. edn). Champaign, IL: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P., Monti, P. J., Sardino, T., & Green, D. (1978). Police crisis intervention. New York: Pergamon Press. Goldstein, A. P., Reagles, K. W., & Amann, L. L. (1990). Refusal skills: Preventing drug use in adolescents. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P. & Sorcher, M. (1974). Changing supervisor behavior. New York: Pergamon Press. McGinnis, E. & Goldstein, A. P. (1984). Skillstreaming the elementary school child: A guide for teaching prosocial skills. Champaign, IL: Research Press. McGinnis, E. & Goldstein, A. P. (1990). Skillstreaming in early childhood: Teaching prosocial skills to the preschool and kindergarten child—program forms. Champaign, IL: Research Press. McGinnis, E. & Goldstein, A. P. (1997). Skillstreaming the elementary school child: New strategies and perspectives for teaching prosocial skills—program forms (rev. edn). Champaign, IL: Research Press.
Chapter 3
CURRENT ISSUES IN ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS WITH YOUTH EVA L. FEINDLER AND KRISTAN BAKER Long Island University, New York, USA
INTRODUCTION In response to the oft presenting problems of angry outbursts and aggressive behavior in children and adolescents, anger management interventions were developed during the past 15 years by clinicians and educators (Nelson & Finch, 2000). Unhappy with traditional behavior modification approaches, which handle these problems via contingency management and punishment strategies, some looked towards the cognitive-behavioral self-control approach and developed a skills training program to help youth manage their anger experience and use more effective conflict resolution skills. After a brief description of the anger management approach (which is described elsewhere in more detail: see Feindler & Ecton, 1986; Feindler, 1995; Feindler & Scalley, 1998), this chapter will provide a review of more recent applications of anger management and will highlight both clinical and research issues.
The Development of Anger Management Interventions for Youth Across a variety of clinical, educational, and residential treatment settings, youth presenting with conduct and oppositional-defiant disorders have patterns of irritability, anger outbursts, and aggressive behavior that result in poor conflict resolution, poor interpersonal skills, and a host of compliance problems. Although behavior modification strategies have been successfully implemented to provide contingencies that can reduce occurrences of aggressive behavior, especially in a controlled setting, these approaches were somewhat limited. Often when the youth New Perspectives on Aggression Replacement Training: Practice, Research, and Application. C 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Edited by A. P. Goldstein, R. Nens´en, B. Daleflod, and M. Kalt.
32 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
returned to the natural environment or was beyond the control of these contingencies, aggressive behavior and conflict escalation would return. The aggressive behaviors of interest would occur outside of the purview of adults, making it difficult to implement either punishment or response cost strategies, usually part of a more comprehensive behavior management program. These problems with maintenance and generalization of behavior change indicated that self-control skills of aggression management were not being learned, nor were youth gaining skills in appropriate conflict resolution. In fact, children and adolescents merely learned that if you were caught being aggressive you might get in trouble but never learned what to do to manage anger appropriately. Struggling with both clinical and safety issues for those who work with aggressive youth, Feindler and her colleagues developed an approach to treatment that would focus on the emotional arousal often preceding an aggressive outburst. Based upon Novaco’s (1975) early work with adults, anger management technology focuses on teaching skills of arousal reduction with direct emphasis on the physiological and cognitive components of anger. Hypothetically, aggressive behavior is elicited by an aversive “trigger” stimulus which is followed by both physiological arousal and distorted cognitive responses that result in the emotional experience of anger. Children and adolescents who have impulsive, aggressive behaviors in their repertoire often react towards the trigger and fail to solve the interpersonal conflict in an appropriate fashion. Much of the research by both Crick and Dodge (1994) and Lochman and Dodge (1994), who have studied the cognitive reactions of aggressive children, concludes that aggressive cognitions, in particular hostile attributions and expectancies, influence the occurrence of behavioral responses to interpersonal situations. Aggressive youth seem to lack a cognitive processing of the interpersonal problem and instead engage in distorted thinking that intensifies their perceptions of injustice and fuels their rage (Harvey, Fletcher, & French, 2001). Further, these same youth, perhaps due to early family experiences or to an innate physiological dysynchrony, suffer from various aspects of emotion dysregulation (Keenan, 2000). They seem unable to cope with the lower levels of the affective experience of anger in a constructive way. The irritability or annoyance that results from goal blocking or mild interpersonal conflict often gives way to intensified anger and explosive rage. Before the work of Novaco (1975), little was understood about the components of the anger reaction that may be the precursor to the actingout behavior of children and adolescents without the capacity to either verbalize their experience or manage their internal arousal so as to prevent an aggressive episode.
Anger Management Interventions In order to prevent an aggressive response to a triggering stimulus, it is necessary for the youth to manage their anger arousal and process the interpersonal exchange such that a more prosocial response is exhibited (Nelson & Finch, 2000). The anger management treatment protocols focus on the three hypothesized components of the anger experience: physiological responses, cognitive processes, and behavioral responses (Novaco, 1975). If anger reactions comprise heightened physiological
ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS WITH YOUTH 33
arousal, cognitive distortions, impulsive thoughts, and aggressive responding, then the treatment approach must focus on helping young people develop self-control skills in each of these areas. For the physiological aspect, anger management first helps the client to identify the experience of anger, to label the various intensities of the emotion, and to recognize the early warning signs such as a flushed feeling or quickened heart rate. During this component the experience of anger is validated as a normal and frequently occurring emotion that has an intensity range under the youth’s control. Further, clients are asked to identify and track common triggers of their anger by using a self-monitoring assessment called the Hassle Log. Charting daily occurrences of anger (whether handled well or not) helps the youth to recognize idiosyncratic patterns of anger loss and control, and to increase awareness of external triggers and internal physiological and cognitive reactions. Finally, several arousal management skills such as deep breathing, imagery, and relaxation are taught to help the youth reduce the accumulated physiologic tension and to increase their capacity to think through the interpersonal event in a more rational fashion. The cognitive component of anger management emphasizes both cognitive deficiencies and distortions that are characteristic of those with aggressive and impulsive responding to perceived provocation. Specific cognitive problem-solving skills seem missing for aggressive youth. They generate few possible solutions to interpersonal problems as well as limited future consequences for their aggressive behavior. Further, their assumptions, expectancies, beliefs, and attributions are distorted in distinct ways that actually increase their anger experience. In particular, aggressive youth perceive triggering stimuli to be intentional and unjust acts on the part of others, which are direct insults and are meant to be hostile. Their belief is that an aggressive counteraction is the best in terms of outcome and in terms of ego protection and establishment of power in the eyes of others. They expect themselves and believe that others expect them to behave aggressively, but then they do not take responsibility for their actions. In fact, they blame others for their own misbehavior. All of these cognitive distortions combine to confirm that aggression is the only way to resolve a conflict and is therefore completely justified. Cognitive restructuring strategies are used to help the clients identify their distorted thinking styles and to encourage them to substitute a series of selfinstructions that will guide them through effective problem solving. Strategies that assist the youth in examining the irrationality and narrow focus of their cognitions help them to develop alternative causal attributions and a non-aggressive perspective. Youth are encouraged to engage in self-coaching of attributions that protect their sense of self, but also lead them to de-escalate conflict and create “mental distance” from the trigger. This type of cognitive work seems to be the most difficult for aggressive and impulsive youth, but it is probably the most critical element of the anger management intervention. Altering those internal processes will help the youth to better manage their anger experience, rethink their optional responses to provocation, and select a more prosocial behavioral response. The final component of the anger reaction is the behavioral one. Both verbal and nonverbal aggression as well as withdrawal patterns are the most typical responses to interpersonal conflicts and perceived provocation. However, once the youth has achieved competence at managing both their physiological arousal and
34 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
their cognitive process, they will still need to respond to the situation and achieve some level of social competence. What is needed then is training in problem solving, assertiveness, and communication skills related to effective conflict resolution. Certainly, the probability that these skills will be implemented is enhanced when the accompanying emotional arousal is managed effectively. Otherwise, the intense anger often experienced by those with patterns of aggressive responding will disrupt or perhaps prevent the execution of more prosocial skills. In sum, an effective anger management intervention must target each of the hypothesized anger reaction components (physiological, cognitive, and behavioral) and must teach to the skills deficiencies and cognitive distortions most characteristic. Although research has yet to evaluate the “best” sequence, it seems that the arousal management and cognitive restructuring aspects should precede the behavioral skills training. But if they are taken all together the youth will have increased self-control skills as well as more effective interpersonal problem-solving skills.
Training Strategies and Program Characteristics The anger control program originally described by Feindler and Ecton (1986) used a variety of training methods to reach the content objectives described above. The majority of anger management skills were modeled and rehearsed during extensive role-playing using scenarios generated from completed Hassle Logs. The roleplays should be arranged for the youth in such a fashion that graduated exposure to greater levels of provocation and conflict can be matched to better skill attainment. Each treatment session included a variety of graded homework assignments designed to have the clients practice newly acquired skills and to foster generalization to the natural environment. Many of the cognitive restructuring strategies have been transformed into games that participants in group treatment seem quite receptive to (Feindler & Scalley, 1998). Clients are able to learn aspects of problem solving, to develop alternative perspectives, and to generate non-hostile attributions in response to hypothetical conflict situations. Role-play with coaching then helps the youth to practice these improved cognitive responses to problem situations in which they themselves are provoked. Repeated practice once the “package” of skills has been taught seems necessary not only to reinforce the newly acquired responses but also to help the client make the social judgments required to match their response to the perceived trigger to maximize positive outcome. Although a number of anger management programs have been published in a curriculum format (Feindler & Ecton, 1986; Goldstein & Glick, 1994; Feindler & Scalley, 1998; Larson, 1998), there are several variables to consider which may require individualization of the program. Chronological age as well as cognitive level of the client group may determine the emphasis and the content of the cognitive interventions. Younger children and perhaps clients with developmental delays may struggle with the cognitive restructuring strategies and may need greater emphasis on the behavioral skills training. The setting for the anger management program will determine whether group or individual treatment is implemented as well as determine the length of sessions, the number of sessions, and the composition of
ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS WITH YOUTH 35
the group. Clinicians in mental health settings have different choices and different constraints than those working in residential or educational settings (see Feindler & Scalley, 1998 for a complete discussion). Personnel who will implement the program will also differ depending on the setting, thus bringing differing expertise and orientations to the intervention. Finally, in some settings, anger management may serve as an adjunct clinical intervention to other therapies received by clients, while for some it serves as the sole training program for the learning of anger management and aggression control. In some settings, family members may be involved (Feindler, 1995), while for most youth, the treatment is deemed solely for them. Although consideration of all of these program variables as well as the variety of treatment strategies may seem confusing, it certainly highlights the tremendous flexibility found in the anger management technology. Developed in response to critical clinical needs and sustained across 15 years, anger management interventions have evolved and extended to a variety of populations of youth in a variety of settings. A review of published studies in the area of anger management will underscore not just the utility of the approach but also the effectiveness in terms of aggression reduction in youth typically resistant to more traditional forms of therapy. The next section of this chapter will review developments in the anger management field and will highlight clinical issues and new applications.
DEVELOPMENTS IN ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS Assessment of Anger Program evaluation and research on anger management interventions for children and adolescents have been hampered by difficulties in securing reliable and valid assessment tools. Clinical decisions regarding appropriate youth for anger management interventions as well as youth at risk for anger- and aggression-related problems would be enhanced by the identification of relevant and comprehensive assessment strategies. This section will review assessment tools most frequently used and will suggest additional methods.
Self-Report Methods Many clinical researchers have relied on self-report inventories to determine significant change as a result of anger management. The State-Trait Anger Inventory has been used by several researchers (Moore & Shannon, 1993; Musante, Treiber, Davis, Waller, & Thompson, 1999; Whitfield, 1999) and it represents a psychometrically sound tool with a number of relevant subscales. In particular, the Anger Control and Anger Expression subscales seem sensitive to improved anger management skills learned by youth. Other researchers have used the Children’s Inventory of Anger (Sukhodolsky, Solomon, & Perine, 2000b), the Pediatric Anger Expression Scale (Musante et al., 1999) and the relatively new Aggression Questionnaire (Ruchkin & Eisemann, 2000). Snyder, Kymissis, and Kessler (1999) incorporated
36 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
the Anger Content subscale of the MMPI for adolescents in their short-term intervention in a psychiatric hospital setting. Finally, the Conflict Behavior Inventory (Stern, 1999), the Conflict in Relationships Inventory (Wolfe, Wekerle, Reitzel-Jaffe, & LeFebvre, 1998), and the Youth Self Report Inventory (Ruchkin & Eisemann, 2000) have also been included in the self-report assessment of youth with anger-related difficulties. A number of the anger management programs described have included a selfmonitoring assessment strategy as part of the treatment package. Modeled after Feindler and Ecton’s (1986) original Hassle Log, others have created an annoyance journal (Studer, 1996), a “Lost-It-Log” (Dwivedi & Gupta, 2000), an Anger Log (Kellner & Bry, 1999), and other forms of self-assessment. It is clear that selfmonitoring will increase the youth’s awareness of anger incidents and will allow for an inventory of cognitive, behavioral, and physiological components as well as an assessment of anger triggers. All of these are integral goals in the treatment of anger management difficulties. Yet, as an assessment tool, self-monitoring is highly unreliable and the validity of such assessments has yet to be established. Needless to say, the use of self-report methods with adolescent populations is always questionable given their predilection to respond in a socially desirable manner and their difficulties with self-reflective thought required to answer in an accurate fashion. Further, it seems plausible for angry youth to initially deny any experience with explosive behavior and intense anger at the outset of treatment. This mirrors their usual denial that they in fact have difficulties modulating their own emotions and their tendency to blame others for interpersonal problems they experience. In fact, anecdotal evidence from current research we are conducting indicates that only after several sessions of anger management, wherein their internal experience is validated and normalized, will adolescents self-report high levels of anger. Sometimes this results in elevated anger scores at post-treatment when using self-report inventories.
Reports by Others and Program Data To counter these difficulties with the use of self-report data, researchers and clinicians must search for other sources of information on the youth’s anger and aggression problems. Behavior problem checklists, in particular the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL), have been completed by adults who have repeated contact with the youth. In the Larson, Calamari, West, and Frevert (1998) study, the CBCL was completed by direct care staff, as it was in the Nugent, Champlin, and Wiinimaki (1997) study. These authors note that staff members completing the CBCL knew which youths were receiving the treatment program, which surely influenced the results. Additionally, teachers and parents completed the Connors rating scale in the Kellner and Bry (1999) study and the CBCL in the Whitfield (1999) report. Other assessments completed by teachers (Hudley et al., 1998; Sukhodolsky et al., 2000b) and hospital staff (Snyder et al., 1999) have been used to assess the youth’s functioning in the natural environment. Researchers and clinicians are encouraged to incorporate assessment ratings by others in order to determine the generalization of anger management skills to the natural environment.
ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS WITH YOUTH 37
A number of published reports of youth anger management have used already existing program data to evaluate treatment outcome. Formal incident reports and daily rates of antisocial behavior were examined in several studies (Moore & Shannon, 1993; Larson et al., 1998; Nugent, Bruley, & Allen, 1999; Whitfield, 1999). Although these data are easy to collect, especially in residential treatment or special education settings, caution is suggested in the interpretation of changes as reflecting anger management success. Often, these data sources are unreliable as they are collected by a variety of personnel and they represent a wide variety of judgments on the part of paraprofessionals. Further, program data do not directly reflect youth behavior but rather the staff observation, assessment, and recording behaviors.
New Ideas in Anger Assessment There are several new developments in the assessment of youth anger and aggression that look promising in the evaluation of anger management interventions. The cognitive deficits and distortions as well as core beliefs that maintain aggressive behavior patterns require particular focus since the treatment strategies target this directly. Barriga and Gibbs (1996) describe the development and preliminary evaluation of the “How I Think” (HIT) questionnaire designed to assess cognitive distortions. This questionnaire has four subscales: self-centered, blaming others, minimizing/mislabeling, and assuming the worst. Reliability data (test–retest and internal consistency) for this 60-item self-report inventory were very good and the HIT correlated with appropriate subscales of the Youth Self Report Inventory (Externalizing, Aggressive, and Delinquent Behavior subscales). Although the authors report only partial success with the HIT in discriminating between male adolescents at a juvenile correctional facility and those in a public high school, it seems an important addition to the assessment of the cognitive component of anger. Another inventory, Normative Beliefs About Aggression (NOBAGS), was developed to assess cognitions about the acceptability of aggressive behaviors in a variety of social contexts (Huesmann & Guerra, 1997). This revised 20-item selfreport scale is more appropriate for elementary school children but is reliable for a range of ages, for both genders, and across ethnic groups. Research results indicate that children’s beliefs about the appropriateness of retaliation and about general interpersonal aggression correlate with teacher and peer ratings of actual aggressive behavior. Perhaps further development of the NOBAGS will include an adolescent version and future research on the effectiveness of the cognitive component of anger management can include this as an outcome measure. Clearly, a belief system that supports the use of aggression in interpersonal interactions is one of the main targets for intervention. Finally, Feindler and her colleagues (Feindler, Adler, Brooks, & Bhumitra, 1993) developed the Children’s Anger Response Checklist (CARC) to provide a multifocused assessment of each of the hypothesized components of an anger reaction: physiological, cognitive, emotional, and behavioral responses. This self-report measure consists of 10 hypothetical stories to which a child checks off how s/he would respond. Responses are coded according to the following subscales: cognitive aggression, cognitive assertion, cognitive self-blame, cognitive withdrawal,
38 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
behavioral aggression, behavioral assertion, and behavioral passivity. This type of checklist assessment allows for the categorization of a child’s typical response pattern to interpersonal situations, which may help to develop more individualized anger management interventions. Although developed for 8–11-year-olds, particular stories can be used for adolescents. Others have used hypothetical scenarios to assess children’s attributions. Hudley et al. (1998) presented three hypothetical scenarios which resulted in a negative outcome and involved an unnamed peer in accidental or ambiguous situations. Situations included destruction of property, physical harm, and social rejection, all fairly typical anger triggers. Following each scenario, elementary students responded to questions of judgment of intent as well as perceived anger and behavior options. Results from this assessment method suggested that improvements in behavior following an attribution retraining program for aggressive children were related to changes in attributions (Hudley et al., 1998). Finally, Crane-Ross, Tisak, and Tisak (1998) investigated social-cognitive beliefs and values regarding aggression and conventional rule violations in a large population of male and female adolescents (N = 398). Youth were presented with vignettes pertaining to aggressive behavior (e.g. using physical force to stop a classmate from taking the window seat on the bus) and to conventional violations (e.g. leaving the school grounds without permission). Following each of eight vignettes, participants were asked about the legitimacy of the acts, concern about negative self-evaluation, peer approval or rejection, expected rewards, and negative effects on others. These beliefs and values have been hypotheorized as critical in the social reasoning process and as representing the social-cognitive beliefs that mediate the decision to behave aggressively (Harvey, Fletcher, & French, 2001). Results indicate an influential role of each of these beliefs and values on self-reported and peer-reported aggression and rule violations. Again, this assessment method provides a creative way to tap into some of the cognitive correlates of aggressive behavior and should be used to evaluate the effects of cognitive anger management strategies. Lastly, new developments in online assessment of cognitions and emotions may prove helpful as a research tool. The “articulated thoughts during simulated situations” paradigm was used to assess mothers’ and sons’ emotional and cognitive process as they viewed videotaped interpersonal interactions in a study reported by O’Brien, Margolin, John, and Krueger (1991). This laboratory analog assessment method could be extended to the clinical environment if a standard set of angerinducing scenarios were developed and adolescents were required to disclose their thoughts and feelings while viewing the scenes. This online type of assessment allows for more specific evaluation of the cognitive processes evoked in the youth when an anger reaction is triggered. In summary, it is hoped that clinicians and researchers who seek to evaluate the effectiveness of anger management interventions develop a comprehensive assessment approach which includes data from multiple sources. It is recommended that methods other than self-report be used and that targets other than angry feelings be assessed. This will certainly help in our understanding of which components and formats of anger management treatment are effective across a variety of settings and populations.
ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS WITH YOUTH 39
Interventions Across Environments School Contexts Anger management interventions for children and adolescents have become popular in a variety of settings in which a skills-based program is easily incorporated. There are few published research reports on anger management interventions in middle or senior high school settings (see Feindler & Scalley, 1998 for a program description at the high school level). One of the few examples beyond the original anger control program developed by Feindler and her colleagues is the Think First program (Larson & McBride, 1992). This program combines the elements of anger control and social problem solving specifically oriented towards school-related interpersonal aggression. The intervention procedures emphasize the use of prerecorded and in-group videotaping, which helps to demonstrate the use of each anger management skill during an interpersonal conflict. This 10-session program has been used extensively in high school settings, and students receiving treatment were found to manifest significantly fewer suspensions and administrative referrals for disruptive behavior than students in the control group (Larson, 1998). There are several examples in elementary school settings for boys. Sukhodolsky et al. (2000b) evaluated the effectiveness of a 10-session cognitive-behavioral program which focused on affective education about anger experiences, on cognitive and physiological elements of anger triggers and reactions, and on generating and practicing appropriate responses to provocation. The 33 participants between 9 and 11 years of age were referred by teachers and staff due to anger-related problems. Compared to boys receiving a no-treatment play group, the treatment subjects were rated as significantly less aggressive and disruptive by their teachers. However, only the results on the anger control scale from the Pediatric Anger Expression Scale showed change as a result of treatment. The other self-report subscales revealed no significant change, prompting the authors to conclude that the anger management intervention did not affect the phenomenology of angry feelings in the children (Sukhodolsky et al., 2000b) but did influence skills necessary to control aggressive behavior. The Brain Power Program (Hudley et al., 1998), a 12-session attribution retraining intervention, was implemented for aggressive and non-aggressive boys in four urban public schools. Based upon the link between faulty attributions and aggression, this program helps children to recognize accidental causes in peer interactions and to view negative outcomes as a result of accidental and non-hostile cues. Once the typical hostile attribution bias is reduced, the authors predict that subjects will display significantly lower levels of aggressive behavior. Results from the pre- and post-tests on the experimental, attentional, and control groups comprising 168 aggressive boys and 95 non-aggressive boys revealed that treatment subjects achieved and maintained improvements in teacher ratings of self-control. Further, subjects in the attributional intervention displayed reductions of judgments of hostile intent, although these changes were not maintained at follow-up. The authors are to be commended for their analyses of a specific component of the usual treatment package, namely attribution retraining, and for the large-scale evaluation. Unfortunately, the relationship of attributions and anger experiences
40 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
was not evaluated, making this a limited contribution to the anger management literature. Others have reported the extension of anger management programs to special education settings. Dwivedi and Gupta (2000) report on the development and implementation of a “Keeping Cool” group for eight teenage boys with documented emotional and behavioral difficulties. The eight-session program was modeled after Feindler and Ecton (1986) and was implemented by the school psychologist and a special education teacher. Anecdotal feedback indicated that all of the participants became more aware of aggressive triggers and feelings. The only pre-/post-data comparison was on the self-report “Lost It” log, and at post-test students reported use of more appropriate anger management strategies and better self-ratings. Since there were no standardized assessment measures, nor ratings by others, this is just considered a case-study examination in a natural context. Whitfield (1999) reports on a multiple baseline single-subject design across subjects attending an adolescent day treatment program in a public school. Eight male students referred to the author for problems with self-control of disruptive behavior were matched to eight male control subjects. The five basic components of the Feindler and Ecton (1986) program—self-instruction, self-assessment, selfevaluation, arousal management, and adaptive skills development—were incorporated into 12 one-hour individual sessions. All subjects completed self-report measures each week (the Anger Control and Anger Expression subscales of the STAXI and the Self Control Rating Scale) and the staff completed a daily report on aggressive episodes and specific instances of rule violations. Results indicated that patterns of improvement on the self-report measures were noted for four treatment subjects while three students remained unchanged and one showed a pattern of deterioration. Staff daily report data indicated clear improvement for three experimental subjects, patterns of deterioration for three and ambiguous results for two subjects. The author reports that data from all sources were highly variable across the 12 weeks of the study, including the baseline phase, suggesting that many moderating and mediating variables were present and could not be controlled for (Whitfield, 1999). However, the implementation of anger management strategies in this setting using a multiple baseline design and multiple sources of data is to be applauded as an attempt to conduct meaningful clinical research in an applied setting without the assistance of a research team. Another extension of the anger management approach was reported by Kellner and Bry (1999), who worked with adolescents in a day school setting. Seven students (six male, one female) participated in 10 weekly two-hour group meetings. All of the students had received significant scores on the conduct subscale and Connors Teacher Rating Scale, and had multiple psychiatric diagnoses. The treatment program was based on Feindler and Ecton (1986) as well as Goldstein and Glick (1994) and was delivered by two social workers. Parents and teachers completed the Conduct subscale at pre- and post-treatment and results revealed a significant improvement following anger management training. Further, counts of the number of incidents of physical aggression by the subjects were compared for six months prior to and for six months after the intervention. Reductions in physical aggression approached a statistically significant change. Although there was no comparison group, nor did the authors examine changes in the subjects’ self-reported anger
ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS WITH YOUTH 41
experiences, Kellner and Bry (1999) completed a clinically relevant replication of anger management with an adolescent population in need of increased arousal management skills. In summary, there are numerous clinicians in educational settings who are implementing anger management programs with some success. Although the research results are limited by the methodological inadequacies in the studies, all represent attempts at logical extensions of the intervention strategies in natural settings. One other creative use of anger management was a dissertation by Abrams (1999) in which he implemented a six-session program for junior varsity basketball players. This represents an interesting extension to the world of adolescent sports and his positive results may help other coaches to consider anger management skills as part of what their students need to exhibit both in the game and off the court. Of note is the absence of reported interventions in middle and high school settings or in clinical, outpatient settings. Sukhodolsky, Golub, Cromwell, and Orban (2000a) presented data on 26 elementary age boys referred to an outpatient setting for anger-related problems. In small groups, the boys completed either a 10-session cognitive skills or behavioral skills training program. Significant improvements on parent rating scales as well as anger self-report inventories provided evidence for the effectiveness of an anger management intervention in a clinic setting. It is hoped that other youth-based community organizations might incorporate such programming into the services offered for children and adolescents after school hours.
Residential Treatment Contexts The original anger control treatment package described by Feindler and Ecton (1986) was developed for use with adolescents in residential treatment. The effectiveness of an 18-session treatment package for adolescents in a long-term state psychiatric facility was evaluated and results indicated that adolescents receiving treatment increased their use of anger control skills and received fewer consequences for aggressive behavior on the treatment ward when compared to adolescents not receiving the anger management training (Feindler, Ecton, Kingsley, & Dubey, 1986). Synder, Kymissis, and Kessler (1999), faced with the treatment implementation limitations of a short-term psychiatric facility, condensed the anger management treatment into a four-session package to be given in a hospital setting within two weeks. Adolescents (both males and females; N = 50) selected for high levels of anger on the Trait Anger Subscale of the STAXI and based on chart review were randomly assigned to either an anger management or control group. In addition to self-report assessment, teachers and nursing staff completed behavior checklists while the adolescents were hospitalized, and parents completed assessments 4 to 6 weeks after the adolescents were discharged. Results indicated change on all measures, indicating that anger management skills can be acquired in a brief group format and can be generalized out of the treatment session to the general hospital and classroom contexts. Clearly, the “captive audience” factor on an inpatient unit will help adolescents learn the anger management skills quickly, but what will be crucial will be to determine the long-term maintenance of these new skills.
42 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
The majority of published reports of anger management in residential environments focus on less restrictive settings and highlight the ease with which the treatment package can be adapted to the facility’s structure. Larson et al. (1998) examined the implementation of the Think First (Larson & McBride, 1992) program for residents on a unit designated for the treatment of disruptive behavior disorders. In addition to the unit’s behavioral contingency management program, male residents participated in weekly group skills training which included an instructional video to teach a standard set of anger management skills. Larson et al. (1998) also reported training unit staff in the program principles, including direct care staff in group sessions, and instructing staff to prompt residents to use their new skills in real-life situations. Results from a pre/post comparison of staffcompleted CBCLs revealed positive results on the Externalizing and Aggression subscales, although exact scores were not reported. Anecdotal evidence indicated that both residents and staff experienced the Think First program in a very positive way and that anger management skills were learned and reinforced in the natural environment. However, because of the extensive staff involvement and the lack of a comparison no-treatment group, it is difficult to evaluate the effectiveness of the program alone, but this is an example wherein practical issues take precedent over the methodological rigor of clinical research. Another interesting example which echoes the dilemmas inherent to program evaluation is reported by Moore and Shannon (1993). These authors examined the therapeutic impact of the addition of a third-party-delivered anger management program to an already existing behavioral contingency management program for youth living in residential care, Teaching-Family model group homes. The treatment subjects received weekly anger control therapy in a group format across 10 weeks. Unfortunately, results from pre-/post-administration of the STAXI and analyses of program data showed that both treatment and control groups improved over time with no significant differences between groups. The authors concluded that the addition of an expensive third-party-delivered treatment to the already existing program did not improve treatment outcomes for youth referred for anger and aggression (Moore & Shannon, 1993). It may well be that the anger management intervention was too brief to result in change on the dependent measures chosen for the program evaluation. Or perhaps the STAXI and the examination of program data are not appropriate measures of the acquisition of anger management skills. Further, it seems that groups of adolescents living together in congregate care more closely resemble a family dynamic and require a different therapeutic intervention which targets relationship issues in the home. Nugent et al. (1997) also evaluated the effects of anger control therapy with male adolescents living in a group home environment. Although an extremely small sample of boys completed the treatment, the single-case design approach revealed several treatment successes compared to boys not receiving the anger control therapy, which was modeled after Goldstein and Glick (1994). A number of practical issues prohibited this evaluation from meeting the methodological requirements of clinical research. The trainers were direct care staff with limited training in the implementation of anger management and the residents receiving treatment had frequent placement changes so that the group meetings were not standardized. Of
ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS WITH YOUTH 43
note was the increase in acting-out behavior in the treatment group home following the cessation of anger management sessions. Thus, although there were treatment gains, they were not maintained across time (Nugent et al., 1997). Even though anger management intervention seems appropriate for adolescents in residential care, the available research has not yet shown the effectiveness of the treatment and future research with greater methodological rigor is suggested. More recently, Nugent et al. (1999) reported on a field study to test the effectiveness of Aggression Replacement Training on antisocial behaviors of adolescents in a runaway shelter where the average length of stay was three weeks. In a condensed fashion, all adolescents during a two-year period received daily ART sessions in groups ranging from 7 to 10 clients. The outcome data used to evaluate the effects of the program were daily rates of antisocial behavior culled retrospectively from chart review. Although the lack of an experimental design prohibits causal conclusions about ART, weekly rate of antisocial behavior for adolescents in residence decreased during the weeks of ART compared to pre-treatment weeks. Interestingly, there was a greater decrease for females residing at the shelter and they represented 54% of the total sample of 522 adolescents. In sum, the ART program was easily incorporated into this environment and again seems like a logical treatment component. However, further research with multi-component assessment is needed.
The Family Context Another appropriate arena for the application of anger management strategies is the youth’s family. There are numerous developmental influences which, beginning early in their lives, will shape the strategies a youth has to understand and process their experience of anger. Debaryshe and Fryxell (1998) present a model of the development of anger in family and peer contexts and suggests the family as the place where emotional socialization takes place. Family members may function as “emotional coaches” in that they provide models for regulation of anger arousal as well as direct instruction for recognizing and interpreting anger experiences. In addition to the shaping of a child’s behavioral, cognitive, and physiological reactivity to emotional states, the family also provides exposure to interpersonal conflict and experience in conflict resolution (Debaryshe & Fryxell, 1998). It is hoped that most families encourage the development of appropriate emotional control. However, many do not. The families of youth with anger and aggression problems indeed evidence a number of poor parenting practices related to later conduct problems. Clearly, the care-giving environment is crucial to the development of emotion regulation and appropriate anger control. From infancy, parental responsivity and the ability to facilitate the process by which a homeostatic internal state is achieved are critical to the development of self-regulatory skills (Keenan, 2000). Unresponsive parents or those who suffer from their own emotion dysregulation are less likely to assist their child in the development of healthy emotional control. Another oft described aspect of dysregulation of negative emotion is the “difficult temperament” child, who stresses and challenges the unprepared or unskilled parent. Early rating of difficult temperament appears to be related to the development
44 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
of internalizing behavior problems of children (Pope & Bierman, 1999), further indicating that a necessary focus for intervention would be on parents of young and difficult children. Additionally, exposure to family conflict or perhaps maltreatment in the early years influences the development of anger and aggression problems. Howes, Cicchetti, Toth, and Rogosch (2000) conducted in-home observations of structured interactions with 42 maltreating families of preschool children. Families with documented histories of neglect, physical abuse, and sexual abuse were compared to 23 low-income families on indices of affect regulation. Observers coded positive affect, anger, fear, and sadness while the families engaged in a block building task. Results indicated that families with histories of sexual abuse displayed more angry feelings, were more chaotic and less organized around family roles, and had more rigid relationship skills compared to other families (Howes et al., 2000). Clearly, children growing up in this environment will not be able to freely express negative affect and be appropriately reassured. All aspects of affect dysregulation are thus modeled and shaped for the child. Other researchers have focused on the adjustment of adolescents who had experiences of maltreatment as children. Wolfe et al. (1998) examined peer and dating relationships of maltreated (n = 132) and non-maltreated (n = 227) 15-year-olds. Those youth exposed to family maltreatment were seen by teachers as engaging in higher frequencies of aggression and harassment and self-reported more frequent verbal and physical abuse in their current relationships. Wekerle and Wolfe (1998), in a survey of over 300 high school students, concluded that family maltreatment accounted for 13–18% of the variance in males who were physically, sexually, and verbally abusive behavior towards peers. However, this was not the case for female abusive behaviors. A subsequent study by Wolfe, Scott, Wekerle, and Pittman (2001) examined this differential pattern for a large sample of male and female high school students. One third of their sample were considered to have experienced maltreatment in their childhood. The authors examined three domains of current adjustment: emotional distress, delinquent behavior, and dating violence perpetration and victimization. Females who were maltreated displayed greater anger, depression, anxiety, and PTSD symptoms and had higher rates of delinquent behavior compared to non-maltreated females. In contrast, males from maltreating families reported higher rates of threatening and abusive behaviors towards their dates. Perhaps these results reflect gender-based modeling for teens having witnessed domestic violence although the increased delinquency rate for females remains curious. But clearly, exposure to family conflict and anger as well as parenting by adults with poor affect regulation influences the development of angerand aggression-related problems for youth. Eddy and Chamberlain (2000) examined other aspects of the relationship between parenting behaviors and youth aggression. In an investigation of factors mediating the effect of treatment on youth antisocial and delinquent behaviors, the authors examined the family management skills of adolescents in two types of residential care: group care and multidimensional treatment foster care. In particular, parenting behaviors of supervision, discipline, and positive reinforcement of foster parents were examined relative to the extent and context of association with deviant peers by the adolescents in their homes. Results indicated that parenting
ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS WITH YOUTH 45
characterized by firm limit setting, consistent consequences for misbehavior, and close supervision of youths’ activities resulted in fewer antisocial peer contacts. Although this study did not examine the behavior of the youths’ natural parents, the results support the volumes of research already available on the role of parenting and the development of behavior problems. Patterson (1986) has long concluded that inept discipline practices interact with child coerciveness, create family conflict, and result in later patterns of antisocial behavior. DiLalla, Mitchell, Arthur, and Pagliocca (1998) examined 17 youths and their mothers on a number of problem behavior measures in a delinquency intervention program. Results indicated that the aggressive nature of the youths’ referring offenses was related to lax punishment by parents and that high parent ratings of youths’ aggressiveness were related to turmoil in the home and the youths’ positive opinion of delinquent peers. Perceptions of aggressive behaviors as well as delinquent behaviors are related to conflict in the home but not necessarily an overly aggressive style of parenting (DiLalla et al., 1998). In sum, exposure to intense negative affect in a family ill equipped to regulate emotional arousal, as well as exposure to domestic violence, seems to predispose a child to develop problems with anger and aggression. Additionally, there are numerous parenting behaviors that contribute to the development of conduct problems as well as a lack of discipline or parental monitoring (Griffin, Scheier, Botvin, Diaz, & Miller, 1999). But the family can also serve a protective role for the youth especially if family/parent intervention is possible. Interestingly, there are few examples of family anger control intervention in the published literature. Stern and Azar (1998) describe a parent training approach for abusive parents and parents of aggressive youth that incorporate a number of the cognitive strategies contained in anger control training. Their cognitive parenting model focuses on the identification of unrealistic expectations and negative attributional biases as well as on poor problem-solving skills which increase the likelihood of maladaptive and aggressive parenting responses. Their parents and families receive skills training in stress and anger management as well as communication and conflict resolution designed to prevent further aggressive parenting. Stern (1999) presents the first outcome investigation of the role of anger management in the reduction of parent–adolescent conflict. Parent–adolescent dyads (N = 18) experiencing problematic conflict at home were assigned to a conflict management (CM) and conflict resolution (CR) intervention or a CR intervention alone. The CM component was designed to address the affective and cognitive components of parent–adolescent conflict and enhance the likelihood of families avoiding escalating conflict through the use of anger management. The CR component focused more on calm communication, problem-solving, and negotiation skills needed to resolve a conflict. Results from pre/post evaluations on the Conflict Behavior Questionnaire and the Issues Checklist and comparisons on videotaped family discussions of “hot topics” indicated improvements for all dyads. The addition of the conflict management skills seemed only to make a difference in the videotaped discussions, coded for positive and negative intervention behaviors. With the addition of the anger control skills, parents in that condition reduced their negative and insulting behavior and rated their discussions as less emotionally intense. Although the lack of a control group limits the generalizability
46 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
of these results, clearly parents and adolescents involved in angry and coercive conflict can learn to effectively resolve their issues and communicate more positively. Feindler (1995) reports a case study of anger management intervention with an adolescent girl and her family experiencing chronic conflict and temper outbursts. Results from parent measures indicated successful incorporation of anger control strategies by parents and child and represent a possible extension of the treatment methodology to the family context. Certainly, further clinical research on families with anger control difficulties and aggressive interaction styles is warranted. Perhaps the extension of anger management to both parents at risk for maltreatment as well as parents with angry and aggressive children will be an area explored by both clinicians and researchers in the future.
RESEARCH LIMITATIONS Research in the area of adult anger management has been prolific. Numerous studies have been published with college student populations by Deffenbacher and his colleagues. Their work has helped to separate the various components of an anger management cognitive-behavioral approach and has helped to determine which treatment strategies are most effective. Relaxation strategies, interpersonal skills training as well as emotional control strategies have been compared as treatment elements (Deffenbacher, Thwaites, Wallace, & Oetting, 1994). Only Sukhodolsky et al. (2000a) have attempted to conduct a component analysis. Elementary school boys (N = 31) referred for anger- and aggression-related problems received either of two treatment protocols developed to differentially represent cognitive and behavioral components of an anger control program. Following 10 weekly group sessions, results indicated that both protocols appeared effective in reducing selfreported anger and perceived aggression and in improving social competence. The cognitive protocol resulted in improvements in hostile attribution biases while the behavioral protocol resulted in greater anger control skills. Certainly, much more work needs to be done to evaluate the numerous components of any anger management package, and these authors are to be commended for starting work done for years with adult populations. Overall, the research on anger management with youth is quite limited. Most interventions include complete treatment packages in which individual components have not been evaluated and may not be necessary. Further, sequence effects of the various components have yet to be examined. The proliferation of published reports about anger control interventions in various settings underscores both the need for effective programming by those who work with angry and aggressive youth as well as the practicality and effectiveness of a skills-based anger management approach. However, the majority of these applied examples suffer from methodological inadequacies such that the generalization of their results is restricted. Few studies use either control or comparison groups. Most have small sample sizes based upon some clinical criteria never fully articulated. The choice of dependent measures seems somewhat random and the data sources are usually unreliable. Many authors report null results on self-report measures of angry
ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS WITH YOUTH 47
feelings, and fail to include other methods of assessment. In only one study was a 12-month follow-up assessment completed (Hudley et al., 1998), and the treatment gains had disappeared. Clearly, the generalization and maintenance of the newly acquired anger control skills must be further evaluated. Additionally, gender issues in anger management with youth have yet to be addressed. There are few published reports that include female subjects. Except for the Nugent et al. (1999) study conducted at a runaway shelter and the Synder et al. (1999) study conducted at an inpatient psychiatric hospital in which half of the subjects were female, almost exclusively the focus has been on males. Certainly, common clinical knowledge indicates that males present more often with problems related to aggression. However, when we try to examine the links between anger and other emotions such as shame and depression, we may be overlooking a female population in need of anger management skills. Perhaps future researchers will begin to examine the variety of female populations available in clinical and educational settings for youth. Lastly, although many have implemented anger management treatment packages developed by others, few have described or standardized the mechanics of actual program implementation. Across the board, those professionals or paraprofessionals who implement treatment are largely an uncontrolled variable in any attempt at research or program evaluation. Teachers, social workers, guidance counselors, psychologists, and even direct care staff (Larson et al., 1998) have been involved in program implementation yet their training and their treatment methods remain undocumented. It may be time for a look at their training and supervision needs as well as at treatment fidelity across various anger management programs. In summary, the research results from anger management programs indicate that skills acquired lead to reductions in angry feelings, faulty thinking, and aggressive behavior patterns, and to improvements in social competence and problem solving. However, these results should be interpreted with caution as each study reviewed is limited by methodological flaws. Additional clinical research is certainly encouraged as anger management programs are clearly needed across populations and settings. Researchers should be encouraged to work through the obstacles inherent in doing research in applied settings so that the philosophy and technology of anger management can be empirically validated.
SUMMARY Anger management interventions are eagerly sought by a host of professionals who work with youth suffering from problems with anger and aggression. The recent focus on violence prevention, especially in light of school shootings and increases in bullying, encourages us to implement programs with high-risk children as well. And although the methodological deficiencies in the research evaluations of anger management may limit the confidence that some may have in the treatment components, the skills-based approach to assisting youth in gaining emotional control and in using more effective conflict resolution strategies is one of the most helpful approaches available.
48 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
Future clinical application of anger management may focus on youth with other diagnostic impressions. Recent work is beginning to focus on family violence applications. Unregulated anger seems to be a characteristic of violent families (Howes et al., 2000), as is interpersonal aggression. Children who are exposed to family violence and those who are victims of abuse certainly need much education and intervention around the dynamics of conflict in relationships and the management of anger. The dating relationships that emerge during adolescence for these children are characterized by similar patterns of interpersonal anger and aggression (Wolfe et al., 1998). Further, other researchers have just begun to examine children’s experience of shame. Tangney, Wagner, Hill-Barlow, Marschall, and Gramzow (1996) explored the relationship between shame proneness and anger responses in a large sample of youth. Correlational results indicated that shame proneness was directly related to self-reported maladaptive responses to anger, which included malevolent intentions, aggressive thoughts, and self-directed hostility. For boys, shame proneness was also related to teacher reports of aggression. Exactly how the experience of shame may function to increase anger and aggression remains theoretical at this point, but it might be included as an important variable to address not only in the assessment phase but also in the cognitive treatment component. Perhaps shame-based self-statements or anticipation of the experience of shame functions as another type of cognitive distortion that requires interventions. Finally, there are many other clinical populations for whom anger management problems are a related symptom. Youth with obsessive-compulsive behavior patterns often find themselves in a “lock” with either themselves or their family members. This may result in angry outbursts which are much more motivated by anxiety and the need for ritualistic behaviors. Youth with Asperger’s syndrome or those with other developmental disabilities might benefit from the skills training involved in anger management. Although the cognitive strategies may need to be altered to match the developmental level of the client, many specific skills could be taught in a sequence to implement when feeling angry. There also are youth who suffer from various neurological deficits, in particular brain injury, who have an extremely difficult time managing their explosive outbursts. Perhaps anger management skills training could be as beneficial here as it has been for children and adolescents across the board.
REFERENCES Abrams, M. (1999). The effects of an anger management package on male athletes. Dissertation, Long Island University, New York. Barriga, A. Q. & Gibbs, J. C. (1996). Measuring cognitive distortion in antisocial youth: Development and preliminary validation of the “How I Think” questionnaire. Aggressive Behavior, 22, 333–344. Crane-Ross, D., Tisak, M. S., & Tisak, J. (1998). Aggression and conventional rule violation among adolescents: Social-reasoning predictions of social behavior. Aggressive Behavior, 24, 347–365. Crick, N. R. & Dodge, K. A. (1994). A review and reformulation of social information processing mechanisms in children’s social adjustment. Psychological Bulletin, 115, 74–101. Debaryshe, B. D. & Fryxell, D. (1998). A developmental perspective on anger: Family and peer contexts. Psychology in the Schools, 35(3), 205–216.
ANGER MANAGEMENT INTERVENTIONS WITH YOUTH 49 Deffenbacher, J. L., Thwaites, G. A., Wallace, T. L., & Oetting, E. R. (1994). Social skills and cognitive-relaxation approaches to general anger reduction. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 41(3), 386–396. DiLalla, L. F., Mitchell, C. M., Arthur, M. W., & Pagliocca, P. M. (1998). Aggression and delinquency: Family and environmental factors. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 17(3), 233–246. Dwivedi, K. & Gupta, A. (2000). “Keeping cool”: Anger management through group work. Support for Learning, 15(2), 76–81. Eddy, J. M. & Chamberlain, P. (2000). Family management and deviant peer association as mediators of the impact of treatment condition on youth antisocial behavior. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 68, 857–863. Feindler, E. L. (1995). Ideal treatment package for children and adolescents with anger disorders. In H. Kassinove (Ed.), Anger disorders: Definition, diagnosis, and treatment (Chapter 10). Washington, DC: Taylor & Francis. Feindler, E. L., Adler, N., Brooks, D., & Bhumitra, E. (1993). The Children’s Anger Response Checklist (CARC). In L. VandeCreek, S. Knapp, & T. L. Jackson (Eds), Innovations in Clinical Practice: A source book. Sarasota, FL: Professional Resource Exchange. Feindler, E. L. & Ecton, R. B. (1986). Adolescent anger control: Cognitive behavioral techniques. New York: Pergamon Press. Feindler, E. L., Ecton, R. B., Kingsley, D., & Dubey, D. R. (1986). Group anger-control training for institutionalized psychiatric male adolescents. Behavior Therapy, 17, 109–112. Feindler, E. L. & Scalley, M. (1998). Adolescent anger-management groups for violence reduction. In K. C. Stoiber & T. R. Kratochwill (Eds), Handbook of Group Intervention for Children and Families (pp. 100–118). Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon. Griffin, K. W., Scheier, L. M., Botvin, G. J., Diaz, T., & Miller, N. (1999). Interpersonal aggression in urban minority youth: Mediators of perceived neighborhood, peer, and parental influences. Journal of Community Psychology, 27(3), 281–298. Goldstein, A. P. & Glick, B. (1994). Aggression replacement training: Curriculum and evaluation. Simulation and Gaming, 25(1), 9–26. Harvey, R. J., Fletcher, J., & French, D. J. (2001). Social reasoning—a source of influence on aggression. Clinical Psychology Review, 21, 447–469. Howes, P. W., Cicchetti, D., Toth, S. L., & Rogosch, F. A. (2000). Affective, organizational, and relational characteristics of maltreating families: A systems perspective. Journal of Family Psychology, 14, 95–110. Hudley, C., Britsch, B., Wakefield, W. D., Smith, F., DeMorat, M., & Cho, S.-J. (1998). An attribution retraining program to reduce aggression in elementary school students. Psychology in the Schools, 35(3), 271–282. Huesmann, L. R. & Guerra, N. G. (1997). Children’s normative beliefs about aggression and aggressive behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 72, 408–419. Keenan, K. (2000). Emotion dysregulation as a risk factor for child psychopathology. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 7, 418–434. Kellner, M. H. & Bry, B. H. (1999). The effects of anger management groups in a day school for emotionally disturbed adolescents. Adolescence, 34, 645–652. Larson, J. D. (1998). Managing student aggression in high schools: Implications for practice. Psychology in the Schools, 35(3), 283–295. Larson, J. D., Calamari, J. E., West, J. G., & Frevert, T. A. (1998). Aggression management with disruptive adolescents in the residential setting: Integration of a cognitive-behavioral component. Residential Treatment for Children and Youth, 15(4), 1–9. Larson, J. D. & McBride, J. A. (1992). Think First: Anger and aggression management for secondary level students. Long Beach, CA: Long Beach Unified School District. Lochman, J. & Dodge, K. A. (1994). Social-cognitive processes of severely violent, moderately aggressive and non-aggressive boys. Journal of Counselling and Clinical Psychology, 62, 366– 374. Moore, K. J. & Shannon, K. K. (1993). Brief report: The development of superstitious beliefs in the effectiveness of treatment of anger: Evidence for the importance of experimental program evaluation in applied settings. Behavioral Residential Treatment, 8(2), 147–161.
50 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Musante, L., Treiber, F. A., Davis, H. C., Waller, J. L., & Thompson, W. O. (1999). Assessment of self-reported anger expression in youth. Assessment, 6(3), 225–233. Nelson III, W. M. & Finch, Jr, A. J. (2000). Managing anger in youth: A cognitive-behavioral intervention approach. In P. C. Kendall (Ed.), Child and Adolescent Therapy: CognitiveBehavioral Procedures, 2nd edn (Chapter 4). New York: Guilford Press. Novaco, R. W. (1975). Anger Control: The Development and Evaluation of an Experimental Treatment. Lexington, MA: D.C. Heath & Co. Nugent, W. R., Bruley, C., & Allen, P. (1999). The effects of aggression replacement training on male and female antisocial behavior in a runaway shelter. Research on Social Work Practice, 9(4), 466–482. Nugent, W. R., Champlin, D., & Wiinimaki, L. (1997). The effects of anger control training on adolescent antisocial behavior. Research on Social Work Practice, 7(4), 446–462. O’Brien, M., Margolin, G., John, R. S., & Krueger, L. (1991). Mothers’ and sons’ cognitive and emotional reactions to simulated marital and family conflict. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59, 692–703. Patterson, G. (1986). Performance models for antisocial boys. American Psychologist, 41, 432– 444. Pope, A. W. & Bierman, K. L. (1999). Predicting adolescent peer problems and antisocial activities: The relative roles of aggression and dysregulation. Developmental Psychology, 35, 335–346. Ruchkin, V. V. & Eisemann, M. (2000). Aggression and psychological problems in juvenile male delinquents versus controls in Russia: Alternative ways of “letting off steam”? Aggression and Violent Behavior, 5(2), 217–225. Snyder, K. V., Kymissis, P., & Kessler, K. (1999). Anger management for adolescents: Efficacy of brief group therapy. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 38(11), 1409–1416. Stern, S. B. (1999). Anger management in parent–adolescent conflict. American Journal of Family Therapy, 27, 181–193. Stern, S. B. & Azar, S. T. (1998). Integrating cognitive strategies into behavioral treatment for abusive parents and families with aggressive adolescents. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 3(3), 387–403. Studer, J. (1996). Understanding and preventing aggressive responses in youth. Elementary School Guidance and Counseling, 30, 194–203. Sukhodolsky, D. G., Golub, M. A., Cromwell, E. N., & Orban, L. (2000a). Techniques that work best: Dismantling child anger-control interventions (preliminary data). Poster presented at the 108th annual convention of the American Psychological Association, Washington, DC. Sukhodolsky, D. G., Solomon, R. M., & Perine, J. (2000b). Cognitive-behavioral, anger-control intervention for elementary school children: A treatment-outcome study. Journal of Child and Adolescent Group Therapy, 10(3), 159–170. Tangney, J. P., Wagner, P. E., Hill-Barlow, D., Marschall, D. E. & Gramzow, R. (1996). Relation of shame and guilt to constructive versus destructive responses to anger across the lifespan. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 70, 797–809. Wekerle, C. & Wolfe, D. A. (1998). The role of child maltreatment and attachment style in adolescent relationship violence. Development and Psychopathology, 10, 571–586. Whitfield, G. W. (1999). Validating school social work: An evaluation of a cognitivebehavioral approach to reduce school violence. Research on Social Work Practice, 9(4), 399–426. Wolfe, D., Scott, K., Wekerle, C., & Pittman, A. L. (2001). Child maltreatment: Risk of adjustment problems and dating violence in adolescence. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 40(3), 282–289. Wolfe, D., Wekerle, C., Reitzel-Jaffe, D., & LeFebvre, L. (1998). Factors associated with abusive relationships among maltreated and nonmaltreated youth. Development and Psychopathology, 10, 61–85.
Chapter 4
MORAL REASONING TRAINING: THE VALUES COMPONENT JOHN C. GIBBS The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA
Moral Reasoning Training is the values component of ART. Youth with moral values are more likely to choose to use prosocial or at least balanced social behaviors (Skillstreaming, behavioral component) and to inhibit the use of putdowns, threats, or assaults (Anger Control, affective component). But what does it mean to have moral values? I remember talking about values in the late 1980s with Joey, a 15-year-old at Clearbrook Middle School in Columbus, Ohio, a special school for juveniles with behavior problems. I was impressed with Joey’s apparent earnestness and sincerity as he emphatically affirmed the importance of moral values such as keeping promises, telling the truth, helping others, saving lives, not stealing, and obeying the law. “And why is it so important to obey the law?” I asked Joey. “Because, [pause] like in a store, you may think no one sees you, but there could be cameras!” he replied. His other explanations were similar: keeping promises to others is important because if you don’t they might find out and get even; helping others is important in case you need a favor from them later; and so forth. The more I heard Joey justify or explain his moral affirmations, the less impressed I became. If motivating the use of prosocial, self-controlled, and other moral behaviors were simply a matter of encouraging the favorable evaluation of moral values, Moral Reasoning Training would be the easiest component of ART. Like Joey, many behavior-problem youth—especially incarcerated youth who would like to impress a judge enough to secure an early release—evaluate moral values as important (Gregg, Gibbs, & Basinger, 1994). But “having” moral values means not only affirming them but also understanding the deeper reasons for their importance. Joey did not have moral values in this deeper sense. This chapter discusses Moral Reasoning Training for antisocial youths like Joey. “Not having moral values in a deeper sense” means developmental delay in moral reasoning. If you think Joey’s moral reasons sounded immature for a 15-year-old, New Perspectives on Aggression Replacement Training: Practice, Research, and Application. C 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Edited by A. P. Goldstein, R. Nens´en, B. Daleflod, and M. Kalt.
52 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
you are right. The moral judgment of many antisocial youths is developmentally delayed, especially in their conceptions of the law (Gregg et al., 1994; Barriga, Morrison, Liau, & Gibbs, 2001). Moral Reasoning Training remedies this developmental delay and thereby establishes the foundation for moral behavior. Moral Reasoning Training takes time, but it is fun partly because the youth especially like these meetings (at least that has been our experience). And there is evidence that Moral Reasoning Training does motivate the use of moral behaviors in the long run. In one study, we found a remarkable “sleeper effect”: incarcerated participants who gained the most in moral judgment were the ones least likely—twelve months after release—to have recidivated (Leeman, Gibbs, & Fuller, 1993)! The key to remedying developmental delay in this values component of ART lies in giving antisocial youth opportunities and encouragement to take the perspectives of other persons. Mature and accurate perspective-taking should help the youths not only directly but also indirectly by enhancing the social and moral climate of their peer group. I will highlight the perspective-taking opportunities entailed in Moral Reasoning Training procedures, and will conclude by describing a group-development tool that should be used to establish a climate of caring moral ideals for ART group work.
DEVELOPMENTALLY DELAYED MORAL JUDGMENT If moral judgment development has to do with taking the perspectives of others, then we should not be surprised that antisocial youths tend to be immature or delayed in moral judgment. One of our studies showed that homes low in nurturance and perspective-taking (that is, that use power-assertive rather than inductive discipline; Hoffman, 2000) have children who are low in empathy, empathy-based guilt, and prosocial behavior (Krevans & Gibbs, 1996). At its extreme, power assertion means erratic and senseless physical abuse, often accompanied by other forms of abuse as well as neglect. If you came from such a home, you might think only about protecting yourself and surviving instead of taking anyone else’s perspective. You might be quick to threaten and hit if that is what you saw all the time at home (see Kazdin, 1995). And you might start thinking that everybody “has it in for you” so you had better hit first (we will term such thinking “cognitive distortion”). Of course, not all aggression stems from home histories of abuse and neglect, with their attendant privations of perspective-taking, models of violence, and stimuli for distorted thinking. Also involved can be biological factors like volatile temperaments in the parent or child or both. Finally, despite these environmental, cognitive, and biological risk factors, the youth (and their parents) are still accountable for their decisions and behavior. These caveats noted, we will focus in this chapter on understanding and remedying the lack of social perspective-taking in aggression and other antisocial behavior. The paucity of perspective-taking opportunities leads to moral judgment developmental delay in two interrelated senses: first, delay means a prolonged immature or superficial moral judgment stage; and second, delay means a persistent and pronounced egocentric bias that consolidates into what we call self-serving thinking errors or cognitive distortion (e.g. Gibbs, Potter, & Goldstein, 1995; Barriga, Landau,
MORAL REASONING TRAINING 53
Stinson, Liau, & Gibbs, 2000). First, let us consider delay as prolonged immaturity in stage of moral judgment. Antisocial youths’ reasons for the importance of moral values are often superficial. We interpret these superficial reasons in stagedevelopmental terms, following from Lawrence Kohlberg’s (1984) still-influential model of moral judgment development. Our (e.g. Gibbs, Basinger, & Fuller, 1992; Gibbs, 2003) adaptation of Kohlberg’s (1984) model of moral judgment development is depicted in Box 4.1. In our adaptation, Stages 1 and 2 moral judgment is immature or superficial, whereas Stages 3 and 4 moral judgment is mature or profound. To say that an early stage is superficial is to say that it is confounded, that it misses an underlying moral reality because that reality is confused with something else, something immediately salient or “on the surface.”
Box 4.1 The stages of moral judgment development Immature moralities: Stages 1 and 2 Stage 1: Power—“might makes right” r Morality is whatever big or powerful people say that you have to do. If you are big or powerful, whatever you say is right, and whatever you want to do or get is fair. r If you do not get punished for what you did or no one powerful saw it, whatever you did was OK. It is wrong if you do get punished; the punishment makes it wrong. r Physical damage or other obvious injury—but not psychological suffering—is noticed and acknowledged to be wrong. r Spouting of cliches (“You should never tell a lie”) without much understanding of them or obedience to them. r Critique: Does not understand the moral reasons for rules. Has trouble with reciprocity if it requires taking more than one perspective at a time. Best at taking the perspective of someone physically powerful.
Stage 2: Deals—“you scratch my back, I’ll scratch yours” r Morality is exchange of favors (“I did this for you, so you’d better do that for me”) or of blows (misunderstanding of the Golden Rule as “Do it to others before they do it to you,” or “pay them back” if they have done it to you). r You should ask or figure, “What’s in it for me?” before you help or obey others. r The main reason for not stealing, cheating, etc. is that you could get caught. r May assert that nobody (even those in legitimate positions of authority) should “boss anybody around.” People should mind their own business. Since everybody has their own point of view as to what is right, everybody should have the right to think and do whatever they want. r May suggest that you should “set things right” if somebody gets more than you do.
54 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
r Critique: Has trouble understanding the ideal of mutuality in a relationship. Also, tends to be self-centered: better at detecting how others are unfair to him or do not do things for him than how he (or she) is unfair to others or does not do things for others. Mature moralities: Stages 3 and 4 Stage 3: Mutuality—“treat others as you would hope they would treat you”
r In r r r r
mutual morality, the relationship itself becomes a value: “trust” and “mutual caring,” although intangible, are real and important. People can really care about other people, can have trust in them, can feel part of a “we.” You should try to understand if your friend is acting hostile or selfish. You should try to make a good impression so that others understand you are a well-intentioned person and so that you can think well of yourself. Critique: Stage 3 thinking can entail caring about the preciousness of human life. However, Stage 3 thinkers can care so much about what others think of them that they turn into “moral marshmallows” in difficult situations.
Stage 4: Systems—“are you contributing to society?”
r Morality of interdependence and cooperation for the sake of society: society r r r r
cannot make it if people do not respect others’ rights and follow through on their responsibilities. Honoring your commitments is a sign of character. If you are in the position of a judge, teacher, or some other social authority, you should uphold consistent and fair standards (but also consider extenuating circumstances). In difficult situations, retaining integrity and self-respect may mean becoming unpopular. Critique: Stage 4 thinking can entail appeals to moral law and to respect for rights and responsibilities as the basis for society. However, Stage 4 societal morality should be considered more as a supplement to than a replacement for Stage 3 interpersonal morality.
Moral reality has to do with mutual caring, respect, or trust—what Piaget (1965) called “ideal reciprocity [or] do as you would be done by” (p. 323)—whether on the scale of interpersonal relationships (Stage 3) or social systems (Stage 4). The immature stages are superficial insofar as they confuse such moral ideals with physical power (Stage 1) or pragmatic deals (Stage 2). Stage 2’s pragmatism is illustrated in Joey’s prescription to obey the law against stealing because you might not be careful enough if you break it. Or, have you heard “Don’t do the crime if you can’t do the time”? That is also Stage 2, morality as pragmatic exchanges or deals. But again, the underlying, real, unconfounded, intrinsic morality is not a matter of deals but of ideals. The interpersonally mature, profound, or ideal thinker asks,
MORAL REASONING TRAINING 55
“How would you feel if someone stole from you?” (Stage 3). The societally mature, profound, or ideal thinker suggests: “You’ve got to have certain understandings in things that everyone is going to abide by or else you could never get anywhere in society. . . . chaos will ensue, since each person will be following his or her own set of laws” (Colby et al., 1987, p. 375). Remember, the incarcerated youths in our study who started to develop that kind of deeper, ideal moral understanding were likely to be the ones who did not recidivate.
Delay as Persistent and Pronounced Egocentric Bias/Cognitive Distortions Besides being superficial, immature reasons are egocentric or self-centered. In fact, the superficial and egocentrically biased aspects of developmental delay are functionally related: after all, a superficial reason focuses on something immediately salient like jail or getting caught by a camera—and what could be more salient than the immediate desires or impulses of the one who is concerned about such possible consequences? As we would expect, these two aspects of moral developmental delay—superficial judgment and self-centered bias—are highly correlated (Barriga et al., 2001). This egocentric, me-first, me-only bias is a natural feature of thought and behavior in childhood. In distributive justice tasks, young children will often allocate the most candy bars for themselves, and if you ask them why, they may unabashedly explain, “because I want them,” or “because I like this kind of candy bar” (Damon, 1977). According to Thomas Lickona (1983), the young child thinks: “What’s fair is whatever I want.” Normally, egocentric bias declines with social experience and cognitive development as children’s understanding becomes more profound or ideal (as noted) and they increasingly see their self-interest in light of the welfare of others. “Declines” is the verb here, not “disappears”: all of us continue to have some egocentric bias. Socially balanced or coordinated perspectives are not always actualized in daily life. Even as mature adults, “we experience our own points of view more or less directly, whereas we must always attain the other person’s view in more indirect ways. . . . We are usually unable to turn our own viewpoints off completely when trying to infer another’s viewpoint” (Flavell, Miller, & Miller, 1993, p. 181). “Not turning one’s own viewpoint off completely” is an understatement in the case of antisocial youths, whose egocentric bias—given their paucity of perspectivetaking opportunities at home and elsewhere—typically remains at the pronounced levels characteristic of childhood. Egocentric bias for these youths tends to consolidate into a self-serving worldview or approach to life, in particular a cognitive distortion. Cognitive distortions are inaccurate ways of attending to or interpreting experience. They have been called “faulty beliefs” (Ellis, 1962, 1977) and “thinking errors” (Yochelson & Samenow, 1976, 1977). There is something faulty or erroneous about such thinking. After all, “fairness” is a balance between two or more people, not an imbalanced or self-focused view that says “whatever I want is what’s ‘fair.’”
56 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
Box 4.2 Four categories of cognitive distortion (thinking errors) with examples Self-centered (primary) Self-centered thinking means that your opinion and feelings are more important than the opinions and feelings of other people. You may not even consider how another person might feel about things. Self-centered thinking can also mean that you think only about what you want right now and do not think about how your behaviors will affect you in the future. Examples: If I see something I like, I take it. Rules are mostly meant for other people. When I get mad, I don’t care who gets hurt. If I lie to people, that’s nobody’s business but my own. Minimizing/mislabeling (secondary) Minimizing means that you think your problems or behaviors are not as bad or wrong as they really are. You tell yourself and other people that your problems are not a big deal. Minimizing also means that you think your wrong behaviors are OK because a lot of other people do the same things. It also means that you think your bad actions do not cause any real harm to anyone (example: you do not think that selling drugs causes any harm to anyone even though it really does). Mislabeling means that you put a good label on your wrong behavior to try to make it look right (example: you describe making a drug delivery as “helping out a friend” when really it is against the law and can harm other people). Mislabeling can also mean that you describe other people with bad names so it will seem OK to hurt them (example: he was a “snitch” so he deserved to get “jumped”). Additional examples: Everybody lies. It’s no big deal. Laws are meant to be broken. People need to be roughed up once in a while. If you know you can get away with it, only a fool wouldn’t steal. Blaming others (secondary) Blaming others means that you do not take responsibility for your own behavior but instead you blame other people for your mistakes that are really your fault. It can also mean that you blame your behaviors on things such as drugs or alcohol or being in a bad mood. Examples: If someone is careless enough to lose a wallet, they deserve to have it stolen. People force me to lie when they ask me too many questions.
MORAL REASONING TRAINING 57
I lose my temper because people try to make me mad. If people don’t cooperate with me, it’s not my fault if someone gets hurt. Assuming the worst (secondary) Assuming the worst means that you think that only bad things can happen to you and that you cannot do anything about what happens to you. It also means that you or other people will not be able to change and make improvements. Assuming the worst about other people means that you think everyone is always out to get you (example: if someone bumps into you in the hall you assume he did it on purpose instead of thinking it was an accident). Additional examples: If I don’t steal it, somebody else will. I might as well lie, people aren’t going to believe me anyway. I can’t help losing my temper a lot. You can’t trust anybody; hurt them before they hurt you. Note: Definitions courtesy of the Lubbock County, Texas Detention Center. Examples from Gibbs, Barriga, & Potter (2001).
We call the primary cognitive distortion “self-centered” (see Box 4.2). The selfcentered distortion has been called an attitude of entitlement, something like: “Because I want to do it, I am entitled to,” “Because I desire something, that makes it mine” (Yochelson & Samenow, 1976, 1977), or, simply, “the world owes me” (Redl & Wineman, 1957). (One common variant among violent offenders— something like “Because I was abused, the world owes me or I can abuse others”— is also a distortion.) Redl and Wineman gave as an example of self-centered distortion the responses of a youth who had stolen a cigarette lighter and was confronted: His only defense seemed to be, “Well, I wanted a lighter.” When further challenged, “Yes, you wanted a lighter but how about going to such lengths as to steal it from someone?” he grew quite irritated. “How the hell do you expect me to get one if I don’t swipe it? Do I have enough money to buy one?” . . . The act · · · was quite justifiable to him . . . “I want it, there is no other way, so I swipe it—just because I want it.” (pp. 154–155)
Self-centered distortion also comes up in the early weeks of Moral Reasoning Training. I remember one of our group members at a juvenile correctional facility who seemed to consider that he had sufficiently justified his having stolen a car with the explanation: “I needed to get to Cleveland.” Other group members, reflecting on their shoplifting and other offenses, have recollected that their thoughts at the time concerned whether they could do what they wanted and get away successfully. (The middle school student Joey was not locked up yet, but his concern with surveillance cameras fits right in here.) Note that the only perspective these juveniles took was their own; spontaneous references to the victims of the offenses were totally absent.
58 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
The primary cognitive distortion of self-centered is especially clear in groups of aggressive male juveniles. Such youths have been described as “fixated at a level of getting their own throbbing needs met, regardless of the effects on others” (Carducci, 1980, p. 157). Their self-centered attitude comes out plainly when we use the following vignette (actually part of our version of Anger Control Training in our expanded version of ART called EQUIP): Gary is in the kitchen of his apartment. Gary’s girlfriend, Cecilia, is angry at him for something he did to hurt her. She yells at him. She pushes his shoulder. Thoughts run through Gary’s head. Gary does nothing to correct the errors in his thoughts. Gary becomes furious. He swears at Cecilia. A sharp kitchen knife is nearby. Gary picks up the knife and stabs Cecilia, seriously wounding her. (Potter, Gibbs, & Goldstein, 2001, p. 56)
We (Gibbs et al., 1995; Potter et al., 2001) ask the aggressive juveniles: “What thoughts do you think ran through Gary’s head?” Among the most popular answers are these, suggestive of self-centered distortion: “Who does she think she is? Nobody hits me. I wear the pants around here. I do what I want. How dare she touch me!” Such cognitive distortions correlate highly with actual assault (e.g., Barriga & Gibbs, 1996; Liau, Barriga, & Gibbs, 1998; Barriga et al., 2000). Real-life Cecilias are at risk for serious harm from real-life Garys.
Secondary Cognitive Distortions Especially when we ask about the thoughts that ran through Gary’s head after he stabbed her, we hear answers like: “I taught her!” “She hated me and was going to leave me!” and “She was the one who was careless enough to leave out that knife.” We call these distortions, respectively: minimizing/mislabeling (for example, the stabbing was an educational service), assuming the worst (for example, about Cecilia’s intentions), and blaming others (for example, a victim such as Cecilia). These distortions (see Box 4.2) are “secondary” to or supportive of the primary distortion (self-centered): specifically, after the Garys of this world stab the Cecilias, the Garys—unless they are outright psychopaths—often do begin to experience empathic distress, guilt, or negative self-evaluation. That negative affect is something they try to pre-empt, “neutralize” (Sykes & Matsa, 1957), or rationalize away. One 17-year-old delinquent, reflecting back upon his burglaries, said: “If I started feeling bad, I’d say to myself, ‘tough rocks for him. He should have had the house locked better and the alarm on’” (Samenow, 1984, p. 115). Well, at least he started to feel bad and had to do something about it. Redl and Wineman (1957) suggested that we find encouragement in delinquents’ use of such neutralizing distortions; after all, a youth truly without empathy or conscience would not need any neutralizations because there would be nothing to neutralize!
REMEDYING THE DEVELOPMENTAL DELAY The rationale for remedying antisocial youths’ moral developmental delay is straightforward. To the extent that their developmental delay and antisocial
MORAL REASONING TRAINING 59
behavior stem from a paucity of social perspective-taking opportunities, then Moral Reasoning Training should provide an enriched, concentrated “dose” of such opportunities to stimulate them to “catch up” to an age-appropriate or mature level of moral judgment. As others’ perspectives are considered in their own right, superficial judgments give way to the construction of more ideal and intrinsically moral understanding, which can motivate moral behavior. At the same time, egocentrically biased or self-centered and rationalizing judgments give way to more balanced, non-defensive, accurate moral perceptions and interpretations. More accurate perception of others typically means more empathy for others. It can also mean more empathy-based guilt if one has harmed others, instead of getting rid of that guilt the way the 17-year-old burglar did by blaming his victims. And it means, in the future, more anticipatory empathy-based guilt when one thinks of aggressing against others (Hoffman, 2000). In short, perspective-taking promotes ideal reciprocity and empathy—and thereby the use of the Skillstreaming and Anger Control components in daily life.
Problem Situations in the Social Decision-Making Meeting Moral Reasoning Training provides concentrated social perspective-taking opportunities through “social decision-making” meetings. In these meetings, participants must give defensible reasons for their problem-solving decisions in the face of challenges from developmentally more advanced peers and group leaders (e.g., Gibbs, Arnold, Ahlborn, & Cheesman, 1984). A Stage 1- or Stage 2-thinking participant— who may usually dominate peers—may lose in a challenge from a more mature peer and may accordingly experience an inner conflict or “disequilibration” that could stimulate a more mature moral understanding. This challenge process is cultivated through certain structured questions and through the “phases” that characterize the course of a good meeting (to be discussed shortly). Although we may refer to the goal of the meeting as the making of mature moral decisions, remember that our concerns go deeper than the decisions per se. Just as “having moral values” means “understanding the deeper reasons for the importance of moral values,” “making moral decisions” means “making decisions based on mature moral reasons.” Although we are concerned of course that the group achieve responsible social decisions and values, we are more fundamentally concerned with the maturity of the reasons used by the group to support or justify those responsible decisions and values. In social decision-making meetings, the group strives to develop mature moral reasons, decisions, and values pertaining to specific problem situations. We depart from the common practice in moral education of using moral dilemmas, which can be genuinely problematic and may not have “right” answers. In contrast, our problem situations generally do have right or responsible answers—for instance, deciding to try to persuade a friend against stealing a car (see “Alonzo’s problem situation,” Box 4.3). The problem is that the right answer might not be immediately apparent (for example, resisting the car theft and ride may not be favored if the ride is mislabeled or misconstrued as “doing fun things with a friend”). Similarly, problem situations in which the right answer is to tell on a friend (for example, if
60 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
the friend is dealing in drugs or talking about plans to shoot people at school) may be experienced as dilemmas because the peer norm against “ratting” or “narking” is so strong. Box 4.3 Sample problem situation Date: Your name: Alonzo’s problem situation Alonzo is walking along a side street with his friend Rodney. Rodney stops in front of a beautiful new sports car. Rodney looks inside and then says excitedly, “Look! The keys are still in this thing! Let’s see what it can do! Come on, let’s go!” What should Alonzo say or do? 1. Should Alonzo try to persuade Rodney not to steal the car? should persuade/should let steal/can’t decide (circle one) 2. What if Rodney says to Alonzo that the keys were left in the car, that anyone that careless deserves to get ripped off? Then should Alonzo try to persuade Rodney not to steal the car? should persuade/should let steal/can’t decide (circle one) 3. What if Rodney says to Alonzo that the car’s owner can probably get insurance money to cover most of the loss? Then should Alonzo try to persuade Rodney not to steal the car? should persuade/should let steal/can’t decide (circle one) 4. What if Rodney tells Alonzo that stealing a car is no big deal, that plenty of his friends do it all the time? Then what should Alonzo do? should persuade/should let steal/can’t decide (circle one) 5. What if Alonzo knows that Rodney has a wife and child who will suffer if Rodney is caught, loses his job, and goes to jail? Then should Alonzo try to persuade Rodney not to steal the car? should persuade/should let steal/can’t decide (circle one) 6. Let’s say the car is your car. Alonzo is Rodney’s friend, but Alonzo is also your friend. Alonzo knows it’s your car. Then should Alonzo try to persuade Rodney not to steal the car? should persuade/should let steal/can’t decide (circle one) 7. In general, how important is it for people not to take things that belong to others? very important/important/not important (circle one)
MORAL REASONING TRAINING 61
8. Let’s say Alonzo does try to persuade Rodney not to take the car, but Rodney goes ahead and takes it anyway. Alonzo knows Rodney’s in bad shape from being high—he could have a serious accident and someone could get killed. Then what should Alonzo do? contact the police/not contact the police/can’t decide (circle one) Source: From Potter et al. (2001). EQUIP program implementation manual. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Copyright (2001) Potter, Gibbs, and Goldstein. Reprinted by permission
The 12 problem situations, derived from various sources, are used both in ART and in our expansion of ART, the EQUIP Program (Gibbs et al., 1995; Potter et al., 2001). The settings represented by the situations range from the home to the school or correctional facility to the workplace. The situations are designed to stimulate discussion helpful to promoting a more mature understanding of the reasons for moral values or decisions such as telling the truth, keeping promises, not stealing or cheating, having honest peer and family relationships, resisting drugs, and preventing suicide. Each situation depicts an adolescent with a problem, typically one created by someone else with a problem (an effective way to induce a non-defensive discussion). The problem situations’ potential to stimulate perspective-taking is promoted through their associated discussion questions. In Alonzo’s problem situation (see Box 4.3), question 6 stimulates the group participants to take the perspective of the prospective victim (“Let’s say the car is your car”)—a question that, ironically, recruits the self-centered bias against itself! Other questions stimulate group members to consider possible adverse consequences for the prospective thief (question 8) and his family (question 5). Still other questions stimulate the removal of impediments to perspective-taking by planting secondary cognitive distortions such as blaming others (question 2), and minimizing/mislabeling (questions 3, 4) for group members to identify and correct. By the way, we are often asked how youths can learn the cognitive distortion categories in the first place, and now we have a good answer. It is called EQUIPPED for Life (Horn, Shively, & Gibbs, 2001), a recently developed board game. We are finding that EQUIPPED for Life is a relatively easy and even fun way for participants to learn the four (one primary, three secondary) thinking error categories. Participants also learn the link between these errors and their destructive consequences, and how to replace the errors with accurate thoughts and constructive responses. Participants who have played the EQUIPPED for Life game seem to do particularly well in identifying and challenging the thinking errors planted in our problem situation probe questions.
Phases of the Social Decision-Making Meeting Besides the stimulation from discussion questions, challenges to take others’ perspectives are also cultivated through the format of the meeting, specifically its four
62 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
phases: Introducing the Problem Situation, Cultivating Mature Morality, Remediating Developmental Delay, and Consolidating Mature Morality. These four phases are described in the second edition of Aggression Replacement Training (Goldstein, Glick, & Gibbs, 1998) as well as in our EQUIP program publications (Gibbs et al., 1995; Potter et al., 2001). I will try to communicate some sense of these four phases, with an emphasis on how they promote perspective-taking. Before getting into the phases, however, I should note two things you can do to fully actualize the perspective-taking potential of the social decision-making meeting. First, you can obtain moral judgment stage scores for each participant; the best way to do this is to use our Sociomoral Reflection Measure—Short Form (SRM—SF; see Box 4.4; Gibbs, Basinger, & Fuller, 1992; Basinger, Gibbs, & Fuller,
Box 4.4 SRM—SF 1. Think about when you’ve made a promise to a friend of yours. How important is it for people to keep promises, if they can, to friends? Circle one: very important important not important Why is that very important/important/not important (whichever one you circled)? [This format is also used for the remaining questions.] 2. What about keeping a promise to anyone? How important is it for people to keep promises, if they can, even to someone they hardly know? 3. What about keeping a promise to a child? How important is it for parents to keep their promises to their children? 4. In general, how important is it for people to tell the truth? 5. Think about when you’ve helped your mother or father. How important is it for children to help their parents? 6. Let’s say a friend of yours needs help and may even die, and you’re the only person who can save him or her. How important is it for a person to save the life of a friend? 7. What about saving the life of anyone? How important is it for a person (without losing his or her own life) to save the life of a stranger? 8. How important is it for a person to live even if that person doesn’t want to? 9. How important is it for people not to take things that belong to other people? 10. How important is it for people to obey the law? 11. How important is it for judges to send people who break the law to jail?
1995). Second, you can have the prospective group members individually work through the given problem situation and its probe questions. As the group leader, you then collect the responses and organize them in a matrix or chart. Include a row at the bottom that lists the majority decisions. A sample chart for Alonzo’s problem situation, based on answers I collected some years ago, is provided in Figure 4.1. Note that most of the decisions are responsible (try to persuade not to steal), although some are “can’t decide,” and some are negative (let steal). Based on this pattern, you can prepare yourself with some helpful guesses: for example, that mature moral reasons will tend to go with responsible decisions; that Steve—a
MORAL REASONING TRAINING 63
Name
Question Number 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Jay
a b
P
P
P
P
P
P
Ic
CDd
Vince
P
P
P
P
P
P
Ve
CD
Marty
P
P
CD
P
P
P
V
CD
Steve
P
P
P
P
P
P
V
C
Juan
CD
S
S
P
P
P
I
CD
P
P
I
C
P
P
I
D
S? P? P Group decision outcomes
P
I?
CD?
P
I
CD?
P
Bill
P
Mike
P
CD
Group decision
P?
S?
Group decision
P
P
P P
P
P P
P
P
Figure 4.1 Response to Alonzo’s problem situation. Notes: a Should let steal b Should try to persuade not to steal c Important d Can’t decide e Very important Where two answers are given, the second represents the participant’s changed decision following group discussion.
consistently responsible decider and who had scored Stage 3 in moral judgment— should especially be called on to help cultivate mature morality; that Jay may try to dominate with pragmatic reasons and irresponsible decisions; that Bill could go either way, etc. At the start of the meeting, it may be important to remind the group of certain ground rules, like: never put down or threaten anyone; listen to what others have to say; stay on the subject; and never talk to anyone outside the group about what is said in the meeting. At the close of the meeting, you should conduct an evaluation using our checklist (Box 4.5), which is organized according to the four phases.
Phase 1: Introducing the Problem Situation To have an effective social decision-making meeting, all group members must understand clearly what the problem situation is and how it relates to their lives. You can ask what the problem situation is, why it is a problem, whether problems like this actually happen, and so forth. In Florida several years ago, I watched appreciatively as a gifted teacher working with a group of mentally low-functioning, conduct-disordered boys communicated a problem situation by having some volunteers from the group act out the situation. I would recommend such a role-play if there is any question as to whether the group understands the problem situation.
64 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
Box 4.5 Equipper’s Review and Self-evaluation Form: Social Decision Making Equipper Session/problem situation
Date Group
In general yes no 1. Did group members follow the ground rules (concerning listening, confidentiality, etc.)? yes no 2. Were all group members interested and involved? If not, list the names of uninvolved group members:
yes no 3. Did you find some constructive value in every serious comment made by a group member? yes no 4. Did you maintain a normal voice volume and speak in a respectful rather than threatening or demanding tone? yes no 5. Did you maintain a balance between criticism and approval by using the “sandwich” style of constructive criticism (in which a critical comment is preceded and followed by supportive ones)? yes no 6. Did you use the “ask, don’t tell” intervention as much as possible?
For the session In the various places, did you . . . Phase 1: Introducing the problem situation yes no 1. Make sure the group understood the problem situation (e.g., “Who can tell the group just what Jerry’s problem situation is? Why is that a problem?)? yes no 2. Relate this problem situation to group members’ everyday lives (e.g., “Do problems like this happen? Who has been in a situation like this? Tell the group about it”)? Phase 2: Cultivating mature morality yes no 3. Establish mature morality as the tone for the rest of the meeting (e.g., eliciting and listing on the easel pad reasons for each positive majority decision)?
MORAL REASONING TRAINING 65
yes no 4. Support and relabel the “should” as strong (e.g., “Yes, it takes guts to do the right thing”)? Phase 3: Remediating moral developmental delay yes no 5. Use more mature group members and their reasons (Phase 2) to challenge the hedonistic or pragmatic arguments of some group members? yes no 6. Create role-taking opportunities in other ways as well (e.g., “What would the world be like if everybody did that?”, “How would you feel if you were Bob?”)? Phase 4: Consolidating mature morality yes no 7. Make positive decisions and mature reasons unanimous for the group (e.g., “Any objections if I circle that decision as the group decision/underline that reason as the group’s number one reason?”)? yes no 8. Praise the group for its positive decisions and mature reasons (e.g., “I’m really pleased that the group was able to make so many good, strong decisions and back them up with strong reasons”, “Would the group like to tape this sheet onto the wall?”)? Post-meeting yes no 9. Did you make notes regarding the session and individual group members? Source: From Potter et al. (2001) EQUIP program implementation manual. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Copyright (2001) Potter, Gibbs, and Goldstein. Reprinted by permission
Phase 2: Cultivating Mature Morality Once the group understands the problem situation and accepts it as relevant, Moral Reasoning Training proper can begin. Your aim in this phase is to cultivate a group atmosphere of mature morality comprising responsible decisions and mature moral reasons for those decisions. The makings of such a climate are typically available from the group members (at least from the majority). On Alonzo’s problem situation (Box 4.3), for example, note that a majority of the group decided responsibly on questions 1 and 4 through 7 (Figure 4.1). Your job is to actualize the group’s positive potential in order to render mature morality prominent and to set the tone for the remainder of the meeting. Ask group members (such as Steve, in the example) who indicated responsible decisions about their reasons for those decisions, and write down those reasons on an easel pad or chalkboard.
66 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
Persuade
Important
Help your friends not get in trouble
Put yourself in the other ’s position
Rodney needs to think about his family Bible says stealing is wrong Could be your car
You get locked up
Rodney might get caught, in trouble, shot, killed, or in a wreck
Hurts trust I ’ve been robbed— it sucks ‚ You d feel bad, scared, angry, guilty
Let steal, Not important It ’s not important for people not to steal You’d be a big shot Lots of fun Exciting Now you can drive, get money, booze, girls, whatever you want
Figure 4.2 Alonzo’s problem situation: reason for social decisions
In the example, Alonzo’s problem situation, then, you would ask Steve and other responsible-decision group members about the reasons for their decisions (“should try to persuade Rodney not to steal the car” for questions 1 and 4, 5 and 6, “important” or “very important” for question 7, and, if feasible, “contact the police” for question 8 [“contact the police” is such a difficult option for these kids that sometimes we have just skipped discussion of this question]). I wrote down a whole host of group members’ reasons for “Persuade” and “Important” (see Figure 4.2). As might be expected given developmental delay, the prevalent tone of these reasons is pragmatic and self-centered. But not entirely, however—notice the mature perspective-taking in some of the reasons: that Rodney should think about his family; that you should put yourself in the other’s position and not steal; that stealing hurts trust; and that you’d feel guilty if you stole. To cultivate a mature moral climate, I paid particular attention to these reasons for not stealing and trying to persuade Rodney not to steal the car. Without my even saying anything, one group member spotted the blaming others thinking error in question 2 and said: “Everyone’s careless at one time or another. That doesn’t mean you deserve to get your car stolen.”
MORAL REASONING TRAINING 67
Phase 3: Remediating Moral Developmental Delay Your having successfully cultivated a mature moral atmosphere means that you are in a position to take on directly the problem of developmental delay. In other words, the group focus on mature reasons for moral decisions provides a crucial bulwark against the pragmatic influence of negative-deciding group members. To some extent, you have already started dealing with the developmental delay problem simply by not emphasizing the pragmatic among the reasons for the responsible decisions and not calling on the negative deciders. These negative group members cannot be put off forever, however. Having built up the mature reasons of the positive deciders, it is now time to invite the negative deciders to explain their reasons. Record those reasons on a flip pad or chalkboard (see Figure 4.2 sample). The pragmatic group members will sometimes argue that their reasons and decisions are more realistic and honest and hence more compelling. For example, Alonzo’s joining Rodney to “see what this baby can do” and have fun is superior because, after all, that is what Alonzo is actually most likely to do. Invite members of the majority—especially the mature reasoners—to respond to this pragmatic argument. What do the group members in the majority think of it? When I asked this question in the meeting on Alonzo’s problem situation, several group members responded that the argument was self-centered, that those group members were not thinking of the people who would be hurt. There are at least two things you can do to help the group counter such attack and thereby remedy developmental delay. First, you can relabel—or, as my co-author and EQUIP implementation specialist Bud Potter (Potter et al., 2001) says, rightlabel—the pragmatic “would” and moral “should” arguments. That is, you can counterattack the euphemistic labeling of the antisocial would as “only realistic” and “what you want” with a positive characterization of the should: “That’s true, it would take real guts for Alonzo not to give in to what he feels like doing and instead do what a lot of people might not be strong enough to do—the right thing.” Second, you can recognize that part of the problem is that developmentally delayed youth tend to be mentally concrete. Accordingly, you can make moral ideals concrete for them by appealing to a place where people do try to do the right thing. I will describe this technique in my conclusion.
Phase 4: Consolidating Mature Morality Once mature morality has been cultivated and defended, it needs to be consolidated and made as inclusive as possible. The group’s mature morality is consolidated— and the group’s culture becomes more positive and cohesive—as you seek consensus for positive decisions and mature reasons. As the pragmatic group members— feeling positive pressure—begin to defer to and even embrace mature morality, it is time to invite them to join the majority position. The goal in this final phase is to convert as many of the positive majority positions as possible into official, even unanimous, group decisions. Refer to the bottom row of the chart and ask: “Is the group ready to all agree that Alonzo should try to persuade Rodney not to steal
68 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
the car? Any objections if someone comes up and crosses out the question mark and circles that as the group’s decision?” Some group members at this point may change their decision, which you or a group volunteer can indicate on the chart (see Figure 4.1). For example, without any prompting from me, Jay, Vince, and Bill made changes to responsible decisions, shifting the majority decision in the reponsible direction (see Figure 4.1). Similarly, identify several mature reasons and suggest that, unless there is an objection, the group may ask someone to underline those reasons as “the group’s top reasons” for their positive decisions (see the italics in Figure 4.2). If you are not entirely successful, don’t worry; a stalemate can be developmentally stimulating, too. In any event, the group should be praised or encouraged at the conclusion of the social decision-making session.
THE EQUIP PROGRAM Cultivating a Caring Group Cultivating a mature morality in the social decision-making meeting is part of the larger need to cultivate a culture of caring among the youth participating in the Moral Reasoning Training and other components of ART. With the concentrated dose of perspective-taking opportunities it offers for remedying moral developmental delay, Moral Reasoning Training does facilitate the capacity to experience greater empathy, have moral values in a deeper (ideal reciprocity) sense, and make mature moral decisions. As we noted at the beginning of the chapter, Moral Reasoning Training can motivate youth to choose to use prosocial and inhibitory skills. I do not think Moral Reasoning Training can fully make this motivational contribution, however, unless the youths participating in the ART group become a positive, caring “culture.” I learned this point back at Clearbrook, where I gradually realized that the students were not really motivated to change; their participation in (what we came to call) social decision-making meetings was often half-hearted and sometimes downright resistant. To turn this situation around, I did two things. First, I came up with a technique by which the group could grasp moral ideals and discover their common prosocial values (more on that shortly). Second, I discussed the motivational problem with a colleague in the field, Bud Potter. Through comparing notes with Bud, I came to realize that I was up against a youth “culture” in which caring for and helping others was considered “uncool” or sissy and actively discouraged. Curiously, Bud was having the opposite problem: As an expert in the Positive Peer Culture (PPC; Vorrath & Brendtro, 1985) group techniques, Bud was having success in motivating problem youth to try to help one another change, but was realizing that they did not have the skills to be effective at it. In other words, Bud needed ART just as I needed PPC! The upshot of this story is that Bud and I and Arnie Goldstein got together to adapt and integrate Positive Peer Culture, ART, and techniques to correct criminogenic thinking errors. The result was what we call the EQUIP Program (Gibbs et al., 1995; Potter et al., 2001). In our program, Moral Reasoning Training is called “Equipping with Mature Moral Judgment.”
MORAL REASONING TRAINING 69
It is hard to classify EQUIP. When I got together with Goldstein, we (Goldstein et al., 1998) called EQUIP an “ART Plus Significant Others” program, where the significant others can be peers or family. But then I must say that when Bud and I presented EQUIP at Larry Brendtro’s Positive Peer Culture conference in South Dakota a few summers ago, we went along with calling EQUIP the way Larry saw it, namely as a “PPC Plus Psychoeducation” program! And both are true: the two intervention approaches complement each other. EQUIP gives youth in PPC groups psychoeducational helping skills thanks to (our adaptation of) ART. Reciprocally, EQUIP gives ART groups a positive environment of significant others thanks to (our adaptation of) PPC. And EQUIP gives to both programs an emphasis on the correction of thinking errors, thanks to our adaptation of the work of cognitivebehaviorists like Aaron Beck (1999), Kenneth Dodge (e.g., Dodge & Schwartz, 1997), and Samuel Yochelson and Stanton Samenow (1976, 1977). You should definitely consider using EQUIP if you are implementing ART in a long-term residential facility where you have an opportunity to develop an effective culture of caring—as Arnie (Goldstein et al., 1998) put it, “to capture a major portion of the youth’s environment and turn it in a prosocial direction” (p. 203). If you can expand the prosocial context by including the youth’s post-release peer and family environment, so much the better. Outcome evaluation studies (see Goldstein et al., 1998, chapter 8) document that cultivating a caring social environment to whatever extent feasible results in an enhancement of ART’s effectiveness.
Concluding Comment Besides my exchange with Joey, I remember another meaningful exchange from my work in the late 1980s at Clearbrook. I directly asked a group member named Calvin (who was also 15, like Joey): “How should you feel when you steal something? Should you feel guilty?” Calvin emphatically rejected the question: “Man, you show me a thief who feels guilty,” he asserted, “and, man, I give you everything I own.” I was finding such concrete, pragmatic rejections of the “should” or moral ideals as irrelevant to be a distressingly common stance among antisocial youth and a major impediment in Moral Reasoning Training. Fortunately, thanks to a problem situation I had been developing with the group, I had an answer for Calvin: “But you could be on Planet B, Calvin,” I said. “Remember? Planet B people do care and feel bad when they hurt someone. It’s the planet most of the guys selected. And I know that this group has got the strength to be a group that cares, like the people on Planet B.” Other group members—and then even Calvin—assented: caring is not irrelevant, “out of this world,” or unrealistic if the world is like Planet B, a place we can grasp and remember through a story. We now call the Planet B exercise “The Martian’s Adviser’s Problem Situation,” and it sets the group tone for the EQUIP version of Moral Reasoning Training. It reads as follows: A man from Mars has decided to move to another planet. He has narrowed his search down to two planets, Planet A and Planet B. Planet A is a violent and dangerous place to live. People just care about themselves and don’t care when they hurt others. Planet B is a safer, more peaceful place. People on Planet B do
70 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING care about others. They still have fun, but they feel bad if they hurt someone. Planet B people try to make the planet a better place. You’re the Martian’s adviser. Which planet should you advise him to move to? Planet A/Planet B/can’t decide (circle one)
It is remarkable how much this one exercise can contribute to the motivation of an ART group to use its prosocial and inhibitory skills. Moving to the prosocial planet, Planet B, is typically the majority decision. In fact, when group members make their decisions on this problem situation individually and privately prior to the group meeting—the private circumstances reduce the salience of social norms against caring as “uncool”—the majorities approach unanimity. Hence, through this exercise, a group of cynical or antisocial youths can discover that they do after all share values of caring and prosocial behavior. When asked for reasons for their decision, many group members appeal to the respective planet descriptions: there’s not as much violence on Planet B, it’s safer, it’s more peaceful, people have fun without hurting others, and—especially pertinent to motivating youth to care—people want to help one another, work to make things better, and feel bad and apologize if they do hurt others. On one occasion, we found poignant a reason added pensively by one of the young group members for going to Planet B: “Parents spend more time with their kids.” Of course, given the pervasiveness of moral developmental delay, some group members do choose and argue for Planet A. On one occasion, some group members suggested that Planet B is a “goody goody” place, and that on Planet A “There’d be lots of drugs and booze and sex” and “Nobody’d be sticking their nose in your business.” A Planet B decider countered that there was still fun on Planet B, and that freedom on Planet A isn’t worth it if everybody minding their own business means that people are getting hurt and hurting others. You may find it easy to make Planet B the official group decision, and caring intentions the top reason. Be prepared to help the group, though, if it falters in responding to challenges such as that no one interferes on Planet A. Keeping in mind what Moral Reasoning Training is all about, you can provide a perspective-taking opportunity: “What if someone you did care about—say, a parent or brother or sister or close friend—was going to commit suicide? Would you just let them do it, because after all, don’t stick your nose in their business? And no one else would care, either. That’s what Planet A is like.” More briefly, you can ask what the basic thinking error is on Planet A. (The answer is: self-centered.) With this assistance, the group majority may prevail and even become unanimous in the choice of Planet B. These prosocial values are not just for the Martian, of course, but for the members of the group. You should encourage your group to make their group a Planet B. It is important to emphasize that every (or almost every) group member would prefer, not only for the Martian but for him- or herself, a world that is safer, more trusting, more caring. But because their common individual preference can easily be undone by that adolescent “caring is uncool” norm, you must work to “make caring fashionable,” as Vorrath and Brendtro (1985) put it. Remember “right labeling” and ask: “Where are the truly strong people? On planet A or on planet B?” Right labeling can support a “you can make it happen here” appeal to the group:
MORAL REASONING TRAINING 71 What kind of group do you want this group to be—Planet A or Planet B, negative or positive? If Planet B is what the group wants for itself, have group members been living up to it? The group can make it happen, but it will not unless the group practices what it preaches. That’s tough work, but this group has what it takes to make itself a Planet B.
Planet A and Planet B can become therapeutic tools or “handles” for the group. The terms provide handles for contrasting groups: Planet A as a shorthand term for a collection of self-centered, rationalizing, and superficial individuals who neither trust nor care about each other; or Planet B as a shorthand term for a community of mutually caring persons who have moral ideals and who are striving toward responsible thinking and acting. Such handles make it easier for youths who are otherwise concrete and pragmatic thinkers—like Calvin—to grasp moral ideals. The new vocabulary is quite useful in later ART group sessions. Instead of simply asking how things have been going, you can ask whether the group has slipped back toward Planet A or has continued to progress toward Planet B. I conclude with a hypothetical reply to Calvin: Dear Calvin, I did show you that day a thief who feels guilty, on Planet B. But you don’t have to give me everything you own. Yes, I “won” that day, but I wasn’t the only winner with my successful Planet B counter-challenge to you. You also won as you said Yes to caring. The group won as they discovered common positive values, corrected thinking errors, and gained moral ideals. The winners would include, over ten years later, practitioners who may now also help youth with Planet B and the positive skills of Aggression Replacement Training or EQUIP. The winners include all of us who can now make concrete our ideals of caring in advice to a Martian, and strive toward making Planet B our home, too, right here on this Earth. Thanks, John Gibbs
REFERENCES Barriga, A. Q. & Gibbs, J. C. (1996). Measuring cognitive distortion in antisocial youth: Development and preliminary validation of the “How I Think” questionnaire. Aggressive Behavior, 22(5), 333–344. Barriga, A. Q., Landau, J. R., Stinson, B. L., Liau, A. K., & Gibbs, J. C. (2001). Cognitive distortion and problem behaviors in adolescents. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 27, 36–56. Barriga, A. Q., Morrison, E. M., Liau, A. K., & Gibbs, J. C. (2000). Moral cognition: Explaining the gender difference in antisocial behavior. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 47, 532–562 Basinger, K. S., Gibbs, J. C., & Fuller, D. (1995). Context and the measurement of moral judgment. International Journal of Behavioral Development, 18, 537–556. Beck, A. T. (1999). Prisoners of hate: The cognitive basis of anger, hostility, and violence. New York: HarperCollins. Carducci, D. J. (1980). Positive Peer Culture and assertiveness training: Complementary modalities for dealing with disturbed and disturbing adolescents in the classroom. Behavioral Disorders, 5, 156–162. Colby, A., Kohlberg, L., Speicher, B., Hewer, A., Candee, D., Gibbs, J., & Power, C. (1987). The measurement of moral judgment, Vol. 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
72 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Damon, W. (1977). The social world of the child. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Dodge, K. A. & Schwartz, R. (1997). Social information processing mechanisms in aggressive behavior. In D. M. Stoff, J. Breiling, & J. D. Maser (Eds), Handbook of antisocial behavior (pp. 171–180). New York: John Wiley & Sons. Ellis, A. (1962). Reason and emotion in psychotherapy. New York: Lyle Stuart. Ellis, A. (1977). Rational-emotive therapy: Research data that support the clinical and personality hypothesis of RET and other modes of cognitive-behavior therapy. Counseling Psychologist, 7, 2–42. Flavell, J. H., Miller, P. H., & Miller, S. A. (1993). Cognitive development (3rd edn). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Gibbs, J. C. (2003). Moral development and reality: Beyond the theories of Kohlberg and Hoffman. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Gibbs, J. C., Arnold, K. D., Ahlborn, H. H., & Cheesman, F. L. (1984). Facilitation of sociomoral reasoning in delinquents. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 52, 37–45. Gibbs, J. C., Barriga, A. Q., & Potter, G. B. (2001). The How I Think questionnaire. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Gibbs, J. C., Basinger, K. S., & Fuller, D. (1992). Moral maturity: Measuring the development of sociomoral reflection. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Gibbs, J. C., Potter, G. B., & Goldstein, A. P. (1995). The EQUIP program: Teaching youth to think and act responsibly. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P., Glick, B., & Gibbs, J. C. (1998). Aggression Replacement Training: A comprehensive intervention for aggressive youth (rev. edn). Champaign, IL: Research Press. Gregg, V. R., Gibbs, J. C., & Basinger, K. S. (1994). Patterns of developmental delay in moral judgment by male and female delinquents. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 40, 538–553. Hoffman, M. L. (2000). Empathy and moral development. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Horn, M., Shively, R., & Gibbs, J. C. (2001). EQUIPPED for life [game]. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Kazdin, A. (1995). Conduct disorders in childhood and adolescence (2nd edn). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Kohlberg, L. (1984). Essays on moral development: The psychology of moral development. San Francisco, CA: Harper & Row. Krevans, J. & Gibbs, J. C. (1996). Parents’ use of inductive discipline: Relations to children’s empathy and prosocial behavior. Child Development, 67, 3263–3277. Leeman, L. W., Gibbs, J. C., & Fuller, D. (1993). Evaluation of a multi-component group treatment program for juvenile delinquents. Aggressive Behavior, 19, 281–292. Liau, A. K., Barriga, A. Q., & Gibbs, J. C. (1998). Relations between self-serving cognitive distortions and overt vs. covert antisocial behavior in adolescents. Aggressive Behavior, 24, 335–346. Lickona, T. (1983). Raising good children. Toronto: Bantam. Piaget, J. (1965). Moral judgment of the child (M. Gabain, trans.). New York: Free Press (original work published 1932). Potter, G. B., Gibbs, J. C., & Goldstein, A. P. (2001). EQUIP program implementation guide. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Redl, F. & Wineman, D. (1957). The aggressive child. Glencoe, IL: Free Press. Samenow, S. E. (1984). Inside the criminal mind. New York: Random House. Sykes, G. M. & Matza, D. (1957). Techniques of neutralization: A theory of delinquency. American Sociological Review, 22, 664–670. Vorrath, H. H. & Brendtro, L. K. (1985). Positive Peer Culture (2nd edn). New York: Aldine. Yochelson, S. & Samenow, S. E. (1976). The criminal personality, Vol. 1: A profile for change. New York: Jason Aronson. Yochelson, S. & Samenow, S. E. (1977). The criminal personality, Vol. 2: The change process. New York: Jason Aronson.
PART II
ESTABLISHED APPLICATIONS ART appears to be an effective intervention with a variety of trainees and in a variety of contexts. From its initial applications in delinquency centers and then schools, it has since also found a comfortable home in a variety of community and family agencies. The chapters which follow share these diverse applications, nicely illustrating the manner in which creative clinicians, teachers, and others prescriptively shape their work in order to fit the particular, individualized needs of their ART trainees. Competent ART trainers know the ART procedures well, are skilled in delivering their content, are able to manage their (sometimes acting-out) trainee groups well, are comfortable with and even enjoy working with adolescents and younger children, are models of prosocial behavior themselves whenever they interact with trainees, and help ART’s benefits generalize. Who the ART trainers are (race, gender, professional credentials), in my view, matters very little. While we have long urged that the foregoing several competencies are necessary to make for a skilled ART trainer, just how those several competencies are to be acquired is and should remain an open matter. Stated otherwise, while we hope that all ART trainers will show high levels of knowledge of the method, good teaching and group management skills, and so forth, we also believe that such abilities can be acquired via a variety of trainer-training approaches. In the opening chapter of this section, Rob DiFlorio looks at the use of ART in a school. Rob is the vice-principal of a very challenging and unusually successful inner-city elementary school in Syracuse, NY. Those of us who have watched him in action a number of times have seen him turn challenge into opportunity, turn aggression into a positive learning experience. The use of ART in schools is also the concern of Mark Amendola and Robert Oliver from Erie, Pennsylvania. Mark directs a large, multi-site, and very successful community agency called Perseus House. Robert is the Principal of the Collegiate Academy, a very special school for special youngsters in Erie. Their community-based ART work is of such especially good quality that they frequently receive visitors from Europe, Australia, and elsewhere to see their exemplary efforts first hand. The widespread use of ART in community settings, together with training ART practitioners, has been the creative effort of Mikael Kalt, Mariusz Hermelin, and Evan Brilje and their fine organization, The Youth Alternative, which began in Malmo¨ and has since spread throughout Sweden and beyond. In their chapter they discuss the challenges of working across a range of settings. The chapter by Rune Nens´en and Nikolai Hamstein of Barnhammet Oasen, in Aneby, Sweden, describes
74 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
their very talented use of ART in a family center context, one in which the ART group is often all the members of a given family. The final chapter by Danny Clark of the UK Home Office and Professor James McGuire of the University of Liverpool reflects on the issues in organizing and delivering a national dissemination of ART by the National Probation Service in England and Wales.
Chapter 5
APPLICATION IN AN INNER-CITY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL ROB DIFLORIO Consultant, Syracuse, New York, USA
In today’s schools, it is not uncommon to hear conversations about raising students’ academic standards. The push for national and state assessments has bombarded parents, teachers, administrators, and all school personnel. In today’s fast-paced, multimedia, Internet society, it is essential to believe and stand behind the “ethos of raising the standards.” However, as we plunge into this next century of higher-order thinking and higher academic achievement, we must not forget the sole purpose of education; that is, creating democratic, peaceful human beings who will contribute to our society. The purpose of teaching our children reading, writing, and arithmetic is not to show how well we do or how well we are doing as a school or school district, but rather to instill the knowledge and values to assist our children to contribute in some positive form to our society.
DISCIPLINE AND DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOR The challenge of continually increasing academic standards is never going to disappear. Unfortunately, this challenge will never be met until we face the most difficult task set in front of us each day, the task of teaching the aggressive and disruptive student. Susan Striepling summed up today’s schools when she stated that the days of children sitting quietly with hands folded in front of them, waiting for the lesson to begin, are long gone (Goldstein & Conoley, 1997). As many of us know, disruption and violence have invaded far too many of our schools. Fighting, cursing, name calling, pushing, shoving, assaults, beatings, insubordination, and weapons have become routine features in some of our schools. Interestingly, violence and disruptive behavior are no longer “urban problems” as evidenced by recent data that demonstrate major concerns in rural and suburban schools; nor are New Perspectives on Aggression Replacement Training: Practice, Research, and Application. C 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Edited by A. P. Goldstein, R. Nens´en, B. Daleflod, and M. Kalt.
76 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
they confined to any social, economic, cultural, or ethnic groups (Goldstein, 1996, 1999a; Goldstein & Conoley, 1997). Today, teachers nationwide are spending more time each day dealing with and controlling the “disruptive child.” Every day students, parents, educators, and others voice concerns about the hostility that plagues our society. While schools remain one of the safest havens for many students, the threat of disruption and violent acts is on everyone’s mind. Just the thought that something could happen in school not only distracts from the educational process, but also provokes fears. Recent school shootings have once again raised the resolve of parents and politicians to do something about these dreaded and horrific events. For many educators, there is nothing new in these demands. The Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup Polls (2000) throughout the years have established that the biggest problem facing public schools today is safety: lack of discipline, fighting, gangs, violence, and drugs have been at the top of the list year after year. Many public school educators have historically seen the conventional, mild misbehavior from the past turn into the aggressive, violent behavior of today. American public education has seen many changes in the twentieth century. In more recent years, one of the most shocking changes has been in elementary schools. Elementary schools are beginning to discover significant increases in the number of behavior violations that occur on a daily basis. However, as we are all aware, the intensity of discipline and behavioral problems has increased so dramatically that no comparisons can be made between what existed then and what exists today. The most frightening data note that the greatest increase in crime and inappropriate behavior is occurring at the elementary school level (Goldstein, Harootunian, & Conoley, 1994; Dahlberg, 1998). While today’s elementary schools are dealing with discipline and behavioral concerns on a much more concentrated and intensified level, the profound increase in social isolation and lack of a sense of belonging have placed intervention skills above those of academic achievement (McGinnis & Goldstein, 1997). The question then arises as to where this behavior comes from and what we should do about it. Some researchers link it to various aspects of a child’s life: from home, school, television, video games, or the street or play area. Goldstein (1999b) indicates that disruptive and aggressive behavior is learned from the child’s total environment and is no different from the learning of any other behavior, whether positive or negative. What then do elementary teachers do about the aggressive and disruptive child? Since anger is one of the most common and powerful emotions experienced by children and is often the culprit behind difficulties children have expressing feelings and controlling their impulses, they continue to find that it is easier to allow their anger to get control of them instead of controlling their anger (Stephens, 1995). Thus, when a teacher is confronted with this anger their most frequent response is reactive, by using what some practitioners call the “Pavilion method”: when you break our rules you will be sent to the Principal’s office. He or she will then send you to detention, to in-school suspension, or if the behavior was severe enough, you will be sent home for out-of-school suspension. Although this method of reactive school discipline may have worked in the past where spitballs and gum chewing were the most severe behavior, it has been proven to be ineffective where fistfights, assaults,
APPLICATION IN AN INNER-CITY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 77
verbal abuse, and other violent acts take place. There is a critical need to have a proactive school-wide approach that focuses on targeted aggressive behaviors and utilizes the strength of teachers and their teaching skills. Not only do school-wide approaches need to be consistent from year to year but a sense of resiliency needs to be instilled in every member of staff in order to prevent them from adopting a defeatist attitude when faced with the overwhelming task of changing behavior.
DELAWARE ACADEMY Delaware Academy is an N-6 elementary school located on the Westside of the City of Syracuse and has over 700 students attending. It is also located in one of the poorest sections of the city and was recognized in 1994 by US News and World Report as the 12th most impoverished neighborhood of the nation’s urban centers. In the 2000–01 school year, Delaware Academy had a diverse student population coming from various racial, ethnic, and cultural backgrounds: 75% constituted various minority groups, 32% had limited English-speaking skills, and 27% were identified as having a disability. Nearly all students at Delaware Academy received a free or reduced-cost lunch and resided in neighborhoods that have extremely high rates of poverty, drug abuse, violence in the streets, and one-parent families. During the 1999–2000 school year only 25% of Delaware students met state standards while the other 75% were considered to be academically at risk or students in need of highly specialized academic skill development. Delaware Academy has the highest suspension rate of all elementary schools in the Syracuse City School District. The number of out-of-school suspensions in the 1999–2000 school year was 690 and there were 586 in-school suspensions. The total number of instructional days lost during this 1999–2000 school year due to disciplinary action was 1,534. The major causes for suspension of students at Delaware Academy are disruptive behavior, such as disrespectful, uncooperative behavior, failure to comply with a reasonable request, use of verbal and abusive language, verbal harassment of a student, and verbal harassment of staff.
Aggression Replacement Training at Delaware Academy It was after the incident in Colombine, Colorado, where two students entered their high school and began killing and wounding classmates and others that American public schools really began to take a long hard look at what is occurring at home. Schools throughout the nation became seriously alarmed and no longer ignored the present status of their schools’ students’ behavior and the potential for violence. A dramatic revolution was occurring in America. Schools in the Syracuse City School District were no different than the nation’s schools. They too developed school committees and various organized groups, which alerted the Syracuse Board of Education to review and modify its security practices. The real problem, however, rested with the ever-growing incidence of aggression in schools.
78 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
Delaware Academy sprung into action by developing a special group of staff entitled the Social Emotional Committee (SEC). The charge of this committee was to find suitable ways on a school-wide basis to begin to decrease the significant increases in student disciplinary actions and to find suitable approaches that would have a lasting and impressionable effect throughout an elementary child’s school career. To further emphasize the importance of the task of the committee, Daniel Goleman’s books, Emotional Intelligence (1995) and Working with Emotional Intelligence (1998), became required reading and assisted in inspiring the committee to choose a simple, practical, organized approach in helping children control their aggressive behaviors. Further, the books primarily researched and substantiated that the emotional health and the necessity for children to receive instruction on social skills will eventually increase academic achievement. Goleman’s research on the importance of how to get along with others is a crucial element in the workplace today. According to Goleman (1998), “A survey of American employers reveals that more than half the people who work for them lack the motivation to keep learning and improving in their job. Four in ten are not able to work cooperatively with fellow employees, and just 19 percent of those applying for entry-level jobs have enough self-discipline in their work habits” (p. 12). In a national survey of employers, reported by Goleman, specific technical skills are now less important than the underlying ability to learn on the job. Of seven major traits that employers wanted in new employees, only the basic academic skills of reading, writing, and arithmetic were of importance. Listening, oral communication, adaptability, personal management, confidence, group and interpersonal effectiveness, cooperativeness, teamwork, and skills at negotiating disagreements were of paramount concern to the people who would eventually be hiring Syracuse City school graduates. Thus, Daniel Goleman’s work helped outline for the committee the reality in today’s fast-paced, multimedia society where children are being judged by different rules and regulations. The committee recognized that to enter our societal workplace requires more than just good academic skills but also depends on how well people can get along with others and accept criticism. While the Social Emotional Committee’s major goal was to look at the whole child in terms of their academic well-being, significant high-level forms of aggression were continuing to rise at Delaware Academy. During the school year 1998–1999, Delaware Academy implemented its first year of Success For All (www.successforall.net), a research-based reading program from Johns Hopkins University. This program had been successful in 48 states in both rural and urban areas, and the staff at Delaware opted to implement the program to begin to intervene in the cycle of academic failure. Along with Success For All, being a reading program focusing primarily on academics, it also has a component of social skills training called “Getting Along Together.” The program focuses on teaching the cooperative learning standards which, according to Success For All, are: practice active listening, help encourage each other, everyone participates, explain yourself and tell why, and complete tasks. The program, “Getting Along Together,” teaches the cooperative learning standards in a systematic way. One important component to this curriculum is the three hand signals that are used throughout the school. These hand signals are the zero noise signal, the active listening signal, and the 123 lining up signal. These
APPLICATION IN AN INNER-CITY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 79
signals were to be taught in every classroom so any staff member could use them in order to maintain good classroom, playground, and cafeteria control. While the three hand signals were presented in general form, the staff at Delaware Academy devised specific procedures on how to successfully implement the signals. Further, Delaware staff incorporated an added procedure entitled “resistance” into the existing procedures to assist teachers and other staff to respond successfully when students were being uncooperative and unruly. The three hand signal procedures were carefully and simply written so that any working staff at Delaware would be capable of meeting their expectations (Box 5.1). Box 5.1 Hand signal procedures “Zero noise” signal Steps: 1. Teacher raises full hand straight in the air without talking. 2. Students raise their hand with ZERO NOISE. Suggestion: Auditory signal to get students’ attention:
r Clapping r Counting r Bells/chimes etc. Resistance:
r Affirmation (catching them being good) r Re-teach r Reward system (stickers, points, stars, etc.) r Look at student r Teach students to give each other visual cues r Proximity “Active listening” signal Steps: 1. Teacher holds fingers straight up in the air in a V formation. 2. Students: a. Look at the speaker. b. Sit up straight. c. Hands on lap or table. d. No talking/mouth closed. Resistance:
r Affirmation (catching them being good) r Re-teach
80 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
r Reward system (stickers, points, stars, etc.) r Look at student r Teach students to give each other visual cues r Proximity “Lining up” Signal Steps: 1. Teacher holds one finger in the air and says “One, gather your things.” Students should gather material; put items in desk, etc. 2. Teacher holds two fingers in the air and says, “Stand and push in your chair.” Students stand up straight and push in their chairs. 3. Teacher holds three fingers in the air and gives directions of where the students should move to; SFA, line up at the door, etc. Students follow directions and move to their designated area. Resistance:
r Affirmation (catching them being good) r Re-teach r Reward system (stickers, points, stars, etc.) r Look at student r Teach students to give each other visual cues r Proximity It was evident after the first year of implementing Success For All that teachers were still finding difficulty in teaching the cooperative learning standards. The Social Emotional Committee concluded that even though the use of the Johns Hopkins’ “Getting Along Together“ curriculum was implemented, there was a greater need to focus more intensively on teaching social skills in order for the cooperative learning standards to be implemented effectively. The Social Emotional Committee, made up of 12 people and including an administrator, social workers, teachers, reading facilitators, and teaching assistants, decided to attend a workshop given by Dr Arnold Goldstein based on Aggression Replacement Training (ART). Upon completion of the conference, the Delaware committee returned to school with enthusiasm and confidence that ART would greatly assist by reducing the aggressive behaviors that existed in the school environment. This excitement was conveyed to other staff at the school and the seeds of integrating ART into the regular school day were planted at Delaware Academy. Thus, shortly after the ART conference with Dr Goldstein in February 2000, three of the teachers who attended the conference decided to implement and pilot skills training in their classroom. Each of these teachers chose various social skills from McGinnis and Goldstein (1997). After two months of using ART, the teachers returned to the Social Emotional Committee and explained their successes with their children. They further emphasized that by adopting ART social skills
APPLICATION IN AN INNER-CITY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 81
Skillstreaming (behavioral component) Teaches what to do the skills curriculum
Anger Control Training (emotional component) Teaches what not to do reduces anger, aggression
In all classrooms 30 minutes per week during classmeeting
Small groups 45 minutes per week
Moral Reasoning Training (the values component) Teaches why to use the skills increases prosocial motivation
Small groups 45 minutes per week
Figure 5.1 Aggression Replacement Training model for Delaware Academy
training school-wide, they could considerably change the behavioral climate of the school and teach students the social skills needed in order to implement the cooperative learning standards that are so important to Delaware’s Success For All reading program. At the same time a whole-school approach was being discussed, the Social Emotional Committee wanted to also provide an additional focus on those who were presenting severe behavior problems, particularly those who were aggressive in a physical, harmful manner. The committee suggested that teachers could identify small groups of students who fall in this category of high-level aggression to teach the Anger Control Training and Moral Reasoning part of ART. The groups were to be broken down by both age and gender. Students would be taught for 45 minutes with 6 students per group (Figure 5.1). It was determined that due to a lack of staff it would be very difficult for any teacher to commit their time to teach Anger Control Training and Moral Reasoning to the small groups of high-level aggressive students. However, with close-knit ties to the community at large, Delaware Academy staff made a connection with the Onondaga Pastoral Counseling Center and requested their assistance. The Center responded by providing a counselor with the purpose of teaching the groups of identified high-level aggressive students along with those having a long history of sexual, physical or emotional abuse. The majority of children in the Anger Control Training groups were often suspended for aggressive and violent behaviors such as destruction, throwing objects, fighting, hitting, punching, etc. Frankly and unfortunately, the students were easily identified. The children ranged from second to sixth grade. A Delaware teaching assistant was assigned to the group to assist the counselor in teaching, following up with students after sessions, and helping to transfer the learned skills into the everyday situations they faced. Maintenance of the sessions proved to be an integral and essential part of the small group sessions. In late spring 2000, the Social Emotional Committee provided the entire faculty with the pilot successes being attained in both the small groups using Anger Control Training and Moral Reasoning and the Skillstreaming being piloted in the three teachers’ classrooms. Recognizing the significance of what was occurring, the entire Delaware staff asked to speak with Dr Goldstein to gain a more comprehensive understanding of ART. Shortly after Dr Goldstein’s inclusive presentation of ART to the staff, the committee incorporated for the first time ART into the existing rules and regulations
82 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
of the pupil behavior code at Delaware Academy. In its deliberations to include ART in the existing behavior code, the staff selected 10 Skillstreaming skills that would not only reinforce the existing “Getting Along Together” curriculum, but also provide a structured framework and process for teaching social skills. The ten skills that were selected by the committee from the ART curriculum are listed in Box 5.2. Box 5.2 Ten selected Skillstreaming skills, 2000–01 school year 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Listening Asking for help Saying thank you Following instructions Apologizing Expressing your feelings Showing understanding of another’s feelings Dealing with your anger Using self-control Responding to teasing
To further strengthen and support the implementation of ART, a summer 2000 training in-service was held for staff training. The session included all disciplinary data, in-school suspensions, out-of-school suspensions, and a common definition of aggressive behaviors that occur regularly in the school. The purpose of clarifying definitions of aggressive behavior was to establish a common language for all staff to communicate effectively. The rationale for giving teachers data on disciplinary behaviors was extremely important because it supported Delaware teachers’ personal beliefs that the amount of aggressive incidents occurring during the school year was extremely high for Delaware Academy. Furthermore, it validated the need for a sense of urgency that ART would be useful in helping them to start focusing more on teaching prosocial skills to students. During the summer training session, approximately 40 teachers attended the ART sessions. Data were reviewed for both academic achievement and behavioral information. There was always an emphasis on the importance of maintaining student control to accomplish student achievement. Model Skillstreaming lessons were taught and reviewed as well as teaching strategies for the social skills. A student video was made that demonstrated to students what all three hand signals meant and the importance of obeying the signal when a staff member gave it. The video was to be presented and demonstrated to students and, more importantly, to be used in the in-school suspension room as an additional tool for reinforcing the signal rules. The video was also to model to students a better approach to antisocial behavior and to teach the value of social skills instead of just accepting some type of punishment for misbehaving. The approach of taking reactive discipline such as in-school suspension or other school suspensions and turning it into a proactive and positive learning situation by teaching prosocial skills made for quality teaching and learning. The summer workshop also included a review of the 10 social skills
APPLICATION IN AN INNER-CITY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 83
selected to be taught in the 2000–01 school year, which were once again scrutinized for student adaptability. This summer training outlined for teachers an implementation plan that would occur during the 2000–01 school year. The implementation plan dictated that for the first 21/2 weeks of school, students would learn the first four Skillstreaming skills selected for at least a half-hour each day. The four skills selected were listening, asking for help, saying thank you, and following instructions. For the remainder of the school year teachers would then teach the remaining social skills at least a minimum of a half-hour per week. As the 2000–01 school year began and implementation of Skillstreaming skills was taught, teachers became more convinced that the teaching of social skills training in their classroom reduced the amount of aggressive behavior. In short, the more instruction in Skillstreaming skills, the greater reduction of aggressive behavior. For some teachers, the results were so profound that they began to teach Skillstreaming for the first 15 minutes every morning of every day. In these classrooms there was less aggressive behavior and more time being spent on instructional activities on a daily basis. During the month of March, a refresher was provided to all staff in order to maintain enthusiasm for the program, re-teach the Skillstreaming skills, and to continue to emphasize that achievement will not occur if social skills are not operating appropriately. Another aspect of the March workshop concentrated on making reactive discipline proactive using practical applications of ART. Since student discipline is generally reactive, ART uses the reactive situation as a proactive learning situation. For example, a child strikes another child, disrupts the classroom, and is sent out of the classroom for some type of disciplinary action. At Delaware Academy, whatever the antisocial behavior, a prosocial behavior will be taught utilizing a repertoire of Skillstreaming skill responses. For example, Roberto is a second grader who exhibits a high level of antisocial behavior and is often sent to a timeout room for interrupting the class by yelling and not following directions. While in the timeout room, Roberto would be taught the Skillstreaming skill, “Following Directions.” Roberto role-plays the skill with the timeout teacher and the next time Roberto is not following directions his teacher can remind Roberto to practice the skill before he starts to exhibit a higher level of aggression.
RESULTS The results of using ART to teach proactive disciplinary behaviors at Delaware Academy have proven the program to be effective. Teachers have incorporated and interwoven each curriculum into their daily teaching, with continued positive reinforcement being provided by all support and administrative staff. Quality time is being devoted to encouraging students to use more effective methods to control their anger and to behave in an appropriate manner. Efforts are beginning to pay off for the staff and administration at Delaware Academy. The number of out-of-school suspensions decreased dramatically, as did the number of instructional days lost in 2002 to disciplinary action. Table 5.1 demonstrates the results for 2000–2001 compared to 1999–2000.
84 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Table 5.1 Delaware Academy’s discipline record Disciplinary event In-school suspension days Out-of-school suspension days Out-of-school informal hearings Out-of-school formal hearings Total days lost
1999–2000
2000–2001
586 690 48 210
407 149 45 220
1534
821
Box 5.3 Anger control training—case study A 12-year-old girl had numerous out-of-school and in-school suspensions. After attending Anger Control Training classes she had no out-of-school or in-school suspensions that school year. This child reported that the Anger Control Training classes she attended had “changed her life.” She reported that as she gained more control over her anger, her life at home and in school improved. She stated that, “I get along with my brothers and sisters now, and my mother and me hardly even get mad at each other. When I feel like I’m getting mad I start doing all the things in my Anger Control Training class and things get better, not worse.”
The anger control training groups have also proven to be extremely successful. Box 5.3 is an example of a 12-year-old student who was on the verge of being excluded from school and began attending the anger control training groups. To enhance further our efforts to work with aggressive children, Delaware Academy has received a major grant from the State of New York Violence Prevention Program for a three-hour extended day program. The program serves 150 kindergarten through sixth grade students each school day and is composed of three equal, one-hour strands: one hour dedicated to academics, another to the arts, such as music, dance, drama, etc., and a third strictly dedicated to social skills, including Aggression Replacement Training. The academic strand, comprising three prominent faculty members from Syracuse University along with five graduate students and ten undergraduates, operates on a student–tutor ratio of 10 to 1. The social strand is under the direction of Syracuse University Center for Research on Aggression and is supported by business, community, and parent groups. The enrichment strand will vary and will include City School District personnel. The Office of Professional Development at Syracuse University will share administrative responsibilities and will design and consult on program professional development modules. While we are still far from our school goals, we nonetheless believe we have come a long way in reducing the number of aggressive incidents due to the efforts
APPLICATION IN AN INNER-CITY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 85
of the Aggression Replacement Training program. We also believe that future school years will show more promising and exciting results and will, we hope, meet our goal of providing children of Delaware Academy skills for success in life.
REFERENCES Dahlberg, L. (1998). Youth violence in the United States: Major trends, risk factors, and prevention approaches. American Journal of Preventative Medicine, 14, 259–272. Goldstein, A. P. (1996). Violence in America: Lessons on understanding the aggression in our lives. Palo Alto, CA: Davis Black. Goldstein, A. P. (1999a). Low level aggression: First steps on the ladder to violence. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P. (1999b). The Prepare Curriculum: Teaching prosocial competencies. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P. & Conoley, J. C. (1997). School violence intervention: A practical handbook. New York: Guilford Press. Goldstein, A. P. & Glick, B. (1987). Aggression Replacement Training: A comprehensive intervention for aggressive youth. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P., Harootunian, B., & Conoley, J. C. (1994). Student aggression: Prevention, management and replacement training. New York: Guilford Press. Goleman, D. (1995). Emotional intelligence. New York: Bantam Books. Goleman, D. (1998). Working with emotional intelligence. New York: Bantam Books. McGinnis, E. & Goldstein, A. P. (1997). Skillstreaming the elementary school child. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Rose, L. C. & Gallup A. M. (2000). The 32nd Annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup Poll of the public’s attitudes toward the public schools. Phi Delta Kappan, 82, 41–66. Stephens, A. B. (1995). Conflict resolution: Learning to get along. (Research report ISBN-0-87652215-0.) Arlington, VA: American Association of School Administrators.
Chapter 6
COLLABORATION WITH HUMAN SERVICES AND SCHOOLS MARK AMENDOLA AND ROBERT OLIVER Erie, Pennsylvania, USA
What does it take for a community and its human service providers to structure and engage in partnership relations? As we endeavor to design policy and implement programs that will effectively and cost-efficiently meet the needs of high-risk youth and their families, it is imperative to develop partnerships and relationships that transcend cooperation and become collaborative in nature. This chapter outlines the incorporation of Aggression Replacement Training in a community-based collaborative program in the USA. The collaboration is a county-wide effort with a local school district, a private provider, offices of juvenile probation and child welfare, and supported by the Office of Human Services. The National Assembly of National Voluntary Health and Social Welfare Organizations defines collaboration as: The process by which several agencies or organizations make a formal sustained commitment to work together to accomplish a common mission. Collaboration requires a commitment to participate in shared decision-making, and allocation of resources related to activities responding to mutually identified needs. (Bruner, 1990, p. 4)
While inter-agency cooperation has grown over the past two decades, it has often been limited by agency turf issues as well as the fear of who owns the “program” and ultimate accountability for measurable outcomes. Collaboration is set apart from both cooperation and coordination. Until recently the literature has provided little separation between coordination, cooperation, and collaboration. These terms have been, for the most part, ill defined and used interchangeably. In collaborative relationships, all partners own the project, and thus responsibility is shared. Cooperation has been typically an intra-agency function, while coordination and collaboration refer to inter-agency. Elder and Magrab (1980) offer a definition of
New Perspectives on Aggression Replacement Training: Practice, Research, and Application. C 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Edited by A. P. Goldstein, R. Nens´en, B. Daleflod, and M. Kalt.
88 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
coordination as cooperative efforts within an agency and collaboration as coordinated efforts across agencies. Webster’s New World Dictionary defines collaborate as “To work together, especially in some literary, artistic, scientific undertaking.” Kagan (1991) delivers a more specified definition and identifies collaborations as “Organizational and inter-organizational structures where resources, power, and authority are shared and where people are brought together to achieve common goals that could not be accomplished by a single individual or organization independently.” Risk-taking behaviors may occur with collaboration and a quality of apprehension may still exist between entities. The challenge of collaboration is to join together with like or unlike organizations for a common cause and to work toward goals that would not normally be achieved without the collective efforts of each other. As noted, and as consistent with our experience, Kagan (1991) emphasizes three dimensions as central to effective collaboration: 1. Resources: the ability to share resources and combine them into a concerted effort provides partners with the opportunity to be more efficient and effective in service delivery. Resource sharing is particularly advantageous in the areas of personnel, training, and operational strategies. The ability to make joint use of resources creates an environment conducive to improving the quality of service delivered, as resource limitations often restrict solo ventures to deliver services. 2. Power: power represents the ability to “do” something in a persuasive manner. People are the stronghold of organizations, and personalities that productively utilize power can create opportunities that enable collaborations to exist. A combination of individuals who are extraordinary in this capacity may form partnerships that are extremely powerful. In this regard, it is critical to develop relationships among those individuals who possess the skills creatively to anticipate the community environment and respond in a manner that is proactive. 3. Authority: authority is the state of having permission to take specific final actions within the framework of moral and ethical constraints. Authority that is shared permits a culture of consensus building. Communication with partners and staff is critical for daily operations. Toward this end, to the extent that they may hinder the development of effective collaboration, traditional hierarchical systems of vertical communication may have to be modified or even abandoned. This requires a paradigm shift of traditional organizational structures and engagement in a boundary-less (horizontal) system that permits free flow of communication from within and through each level (see Table 6.1). Effective communication is the main ingredient for success. The ability of partners effectively to express needs in an environment of trust is the primary step for collaborative viability. Also, communication that is connected among partners assists with breaking down communication barriers. Regularly scheduled management meetings may facilitate this process. Decisions should be made through consensus building which includes key personnel. This may take more time than the traditional process of organizational structures but assures staff involvement and compliance with policy and procedure through staff empowerment. Intraagency collaboration is encouraged to improve work processes and communication
COLLABORATION WITH HUMAN SERVICES AND SCHOOLS 89 Table 6.1 Organizational structure Boundary-less
Hierarchical
1. Communication is interconnected 2. Decisions are made through consensus building 3. Accountability is an expressed expectation 4. Intra-agency collaboration is encouraged 5. Training and skill development are critical for program integrity and performance appraisal
1. Communication is dictated top-down 2. Decisions are made by the “boss” 3. Fear of mistakes directs employee misperformance 4. Departmental competition breeds mistrust 5. Control and manipulation are used as motivators
patterns. Finally, attention to and implementation of staff training for skill development enhance facilitator confidence and proficiency. This collaborative process of maximizing resources of human service agencies and schools is best described through the application of concepts.
COLLABORATION WITH HUMAN SERVICES AND SCHOOLS A model example of collaboration is the Collaborative Intensive Community Treatment Program (CICTP) located in Erie, Pennsylvania. The CICTP is a collaborative effort that has incorporated numerous partners to achieve the ultimate goal of residential diversion of male and female adolescents within a community setting. Program ingredients will be reviewed in terms of agencies involved in the collaboration and staffing patterns. We also will describe the program interventions in terms of the types of activities and how they are delivered. This chapter will outline the development and structure of this project.
GUIDING PRINCIPLES OF COLLABORATION The application and implementation of collaborative principles, which will be outlined, were helpful in the development of collaborative continuum in Erie, Pennsylvania. 1. Mission and vision are the birth of any program. Erie county had been experiencing significant gaps in alternatives to residential treatment for adolescents. This created an opportunity to assess and critically evaluate the current delivery system of residential care in the community. The vision of the developers of the program was to create a system that would allow adolescents who were in need of residential care to remain in the community, and, most importantly, with their families. The vision was to create a service that would replicate residential care
90 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
yet provide adequate supervision so they did not need 24-hour residential surveillance. This would also provide a mechanism for the early reintegration of those youth in facilities in need of aftercare support upon return to the community. 2. Strategic leadership forms and moulds successful measures. The need to have key strategic leaders involved in the formation of this project was critical. County representatives, who were able to make policy and administrative decisions, were solicited for their input from the initiation of the project. Their views and opinions helped shape the direction of the initiative. If we had not had their endorsement, it would have never moved forward. 3. Customer relationships are one of the most important factors in the project formation. All collaborators had professional relationships that were customer focused. Each trusted the integrity of the other and felt confident and comfortable that dialog shared was open and honest. Feedback was solicited and encouraged, as seen by continued meetings that focused on what goals were to be accomplished and how they were going to be implemented. 4. Alliance of partners creates a culture that solidifies lines of communication. As the project developed there was a need for frequent communication between key leaders. This created an alliance that assured program integrity. All partners served as quality control administrators as we problem-solved and reviewed alternatives on a daily basis. This process also fostered additional trust among partners. 5. Responsibility and accountability become the core of quality control. To develop a program that would be a viable alternative to residential placement, the supervisory team focused on team accountability and responsibility. Shared supervision assisted in multiple ownership of the program. No one group or agency owned the program but rather the collaborators were responsible for the project, which increased the opportunity for successful implementation. 6. Comprehensiveness of service is critical to produce a service that would meet the needs of referred individuals. To provide a program that would operate seven days a week was the request of county customers and truly in the best interest of the clients. 7. Decision making and consensus building involve all levels of staff. In order to make program decisions that were practical, it was important to involve staff at all levels. We met with supervisory staff in regularly scheduled meetings but we also met with program staff and collaborators to solicit their feedback and opinions regarding decision making. We then collated the data and evaluated central themes that could be used for continuous quality improvement. This process took time, but the final results were effective due to staff participation. 8. Accountability and responsibility are functions of all collaborators. All collaborators were involved in the delivery of the program and no one agency or group owned the project. This led to mutual ownership of the program and increased the investment of all collaborative partners. It also brought to the table different views of supervision and accountability that improved program maintenance. 9. Cross-system communication and consensus building originated and were sustained by the partners. The inclusion of multiple partners brought together multiple systems that in and of themselves communicated on a very superficial level. The cross-system communication efforts improved the communication patterns of all parties and helped develop an increased awareness of the barriers that each group experienced. What then transpired was an increased level of trust and
COLLABORATION WITH HUMAN SERVICES AND SCHOOLS 91
respect that ultimately broke down any preconceived beliefs that may have been erroneous due to lack of communication. 10. Team performance of all members is interdependent. Roles were clearly defined and each partner understood the specific tasks that were to be achieved. The private provider was responsible for clinical implementation, the school district was responsible for fiscal administration, and the county partners were responsible for quality control. All collaborators were responsible for day-to-day program implementation and operation. 11. Program modification is critical to ongoing operations. The ability continuously to evaluate the program and develop modifications as necessary was key and continues to be vital to program development. We maintain open lines of communication to modify the program. Flexibility and creativity are concepts that all partners embrace. This continuous quality improvement is what assists in maintaining the program. 12. Collaboration increases problem solving through the expertise of the partners. By bringing to the table multiple partners with experience in multiple disciplines, we developed a leadership team that had well over 20 years of experience in their respective roles. This group was well versed in problem-solving techniques and strategies to eliminate barriers. This would not have been accomplished at this level if the program had been operated by one group. 13. Value congruence assisted the development of the project. It was necessary for the collaborators to reach consensus regarding professional values and belief systems. We did this by discussing initial program goals and objectives. It became evident that we generally agreed on what should be accomplished and how it should be done. If we could not have reached this agreement, it would have been extremely challenging to further the project. 14. Problem solving and conflict resolution should be incorporated into the team operation. Central leadership should take an active role in solving problems but needs to empower staff to independently resolve conflict. One method used is a suggestion box at each site that gives the staff the opportunity to submit suggestions and solutions to problems. A second, more formalized, method is the use of supervisory meetings to solicit feedback from staff. Consensus building is the preferred approach to problem solving. 15. Ease of delivery of service for staff and clients was important for program implementation. The ability to deliver a service that was user friendly for both the staff and clients was an agreed-upon value early in the project development. To meet comprehensively the needs of the clients, it became necessary to develop a competency-based model that would be practical and efficient. Goldstein’s Aggression Replacement Training model best met our needs.
DEVELOPMENT RATIONALE Conceptualization and Formation The rationale for the development of the CICTP was formulated in response to the county’s escalating costs associated with increased residential placements of youth. To complicate the matter, in 1996 the federal government determined that
92 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
counties no longer would be eligible for federal Title IV-A dollars, which helped subsidize room and board for placements. In Erie County, this decreased amount totaled $2 million. This reduction created a projected deficit and a serious fiscal problem for county representatives. The School District of the City of Erie and Perseus House, Inc., a local not-for-profit organization, had developed coordinated and cooperative agreements but had not taken the risks that collaborative ventures assure. Administrators from both entities were impressed with the development of the Erie–Warren Project which had been implemented four years earlier. The Office of Mental Health/Mental Retardation (MH/MR) developed the Erie– Warren Project in response to escalating costs associated with state hospitalization of the chronically mentally ill. The county proposed to the state that if the state would allocate the same dollars to the county that it was expending for hospitalization, Erie County could replicate, for a majority of the population, similar services. The MH/MR office, in collaboration with numerous local providers, developed and implemented a viable plan for the transition of these clients to return to the community. This was a lesson learned regarding the redefinition of resources and the reallocation of existing dollars. The Erie School District and Perseus House, Inc. administrators had experience in both residential and community-based therapeutic settings for adolescents. They believed that there was a significant percentage of adolescents who could be diverted from residential care if similar supports were available in the community. They also felt strongly that there was a group of clients who were in placement who may have been able to reintegrate into the community earlier than anticipated if this service were available. Focus had to be on supervision, intervention, and the inclusion of the family in the treatment plan. This was the initial stage of collaborative conception and formation, which was dictated by both community crisis and a gap in service. The Erie School District and Perseus House, Inc. met on numerous occasions to develop the program curriculum. This process included a series of meetings that evolved over a period of two years. Perseus House, Inc.’s Executive Director and the Erie School District’s Supervisor of Student Assistance Programs explored issues relevant to the project, including financial restraints, clinical considerations, staffing patterns, educational requirements, supervision, and program structure. Vision, mission, and objectives were discussed fully. It is important to note that we had extensive dialog regarding the mission of the program—what we wanted to achieve, how we were going to move forward, and whom we needed to include in key discussions were reviewed. In regard to initial structural formation, Perseus House was responsible for fiscal administration and clinical supervision, and the School District was responsible for the physical plant site, transportation, and maintenance. Once a viable program description had been developed, both organizations met with local county representatives, including the Chief Probation Officer and the Director of Children and Youth Services. The first meeting was encouraging due to their response. The representatives felt that there was a need for such a program, but there was an air of apprehension and uncertainty. County officials suggested specific program modifications. They stated that this project would need the approval
COLLABORATION WITH HUMAN SERVICES AND SCHOOLS 93
of the court. We discussed strategies that would assist in our presentation to the court. We also requested that the county utilize only existing dollars that were currently allocated for residential programming. If we could stem the tide of escalating placement costs, then the mission of the project would be fulfilled. In this first meeting we also discussed goals and objectives of the program. The two agreed-upon initial goals of the program were and continue to be: (a) reduction of the clinical and behavioral need for residential placement and (b) reduction of the escalating fiscal and administrative burden assumed by the referent agencies. Concern was also raised regarding “turf” issues and who would be responsible for each specific component of the project. There were and continue to be numerous providers of human services in Erie County. The question we needed to address was how we were going to access existing services. One method we used was to meet with numerous providers and engage in articulation agreements that would share case management and related ancillary services. Probably one of the toughest barriers we still continue to encounter is that of “turf” and the protective nature of human services. Our view is that there certainly are multitudes of problems to deal with and this is much too challenging for any one group to take on individually. Ultimately, we are all trying to achieve the same goal: to improve the lives of those with whom we are in daily contact. Not only did we review service delivery, but there was extensive dialog regarding types of clients eligible for this program. The further we discussed program mission, goals and objectives, the population that could benefit became clear. The population that would have normally entered residential placements and had some family resources was the best group to try as a pilot. Furthermore, by utilizing a resource management approach, there would also be a resource available in the community to provide early reintegration from residential facilities.
Collaborative Development The program description was reworked and presented to county officials once again. This was met optimistically as we moved into the stage of collaborative development. With the support of Family Court and the President Judge, we initiated the development of the program. Program collaborators included the Office of Juvenile Probation and Children and Youth, the County MH/MR Office, the Erie School District, and Perseus House, Inc. It is significant to note that this was not the first collaborative effort of this group. It was preceded by the development of School-Based Probation, After-School Student Support, the Family Center, Alternative Education Programming, and Delinquency Prevention Programming. The CICTP would be an important addition to this collaborative continuum. The intention of the program was not only to add to the continuum but to integrate with the extensive services offered by existing programs. As the collaborators initiated planning meetings, it became evident that there was a developing mutual bond. All partners discussed the potential merit of such a program, which fueled motivation. Ideas were brought to the table that were at least considered and discussed in an atmosphere of trust and confidence. Weekly meetings were held at rotating sites. We joined with a local university to conduct our
94 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
literature search on similar programs. They were also involved in the determination of parameters for our outcome study. A primary issue was the qualifications of staff who would be hired. We agreed that the most qualified personnel would be hired. We then proceeded to identify and recruit those individuals we knew “fit the bill.” We also placed an advertisement in a local newspaper for case managers. We had 160 applications for 5 full-time positions and 70 part-time positions. Initial screenings were conducted and then a team comprising collaborators interviewed the final candidates.
Collaboration Implementation The next stage was implementation, which is the “how” of the partnership. It was vital to all partners that the program, as planned, be delivered in a consistent manner. Teams were developed with counselors, teachers, recreational therapists, and team leaders. Key collaborative administrators provided staff training regarding program delivery. The full-time case management staff, with the clinical director, developed and packaged the curriculum. The partners met with all staff who were new to the program. Upon the start of the program, administrative staff modeled the delivery of program services and provided feedback to administrative staff through direct observation. We also used general logs to communicate effectively from team to team.
PROGRAM PHILOSOPHY The CICTP provides intervention services for both delinquent and dependent youth. The program incorporates the philosophical framework of the Balanced Approach and Restorative Justice model developed by the Federal Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency. The focus of the model is on developing balanced, community-based systems that utilize restorative sanctions and processes and related approaches to effect change in the juvenile justice system. The four guiding objectives of the model are accountability, community protection, competency development, and balance. Over the past six years, the Erie County Office of Juvenile Probation has experienced increasing referrals for delinquent behaviors. The Chief Probation Officer and collaborators have embraced the Balanced Approach and Restorative Justice model. Antolik (1995) perceived the implementation of the Restorative model as essential to his department’s transition to a balanced and restorative justice approach. The Balanced and Restorative Justice Project of the Federal Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention has developed model systems for community supervision of delinquents based on the balanced approach mission (Bazemore, 1992; Maloney, Romig, & Armstrong, 1988) and the restorative justice philosophy (Umbreit, 1989; VanNess, 1990; Zehr, 1990). These model systems are viewed as catalysts for changing the current juvenile justice system. The balanced approach for the juvenile justice system differs from traditional approaches through prescribed outcomes, concrete performance measures, and
COLLABORATION WITH HUMAN SERVICES AND SCHOOLS 95
evaluation through measurable improvements. Prescribed outcomes for competency development, accountability, and community protection are focused on the three primary clients of the juvenile justice system: offenders, victims, and the community. This conceptual framework emphasizes three programming priorities: 1. Accountability. Through restitution and community service, offenders gain awareness of the impact of their actions on victims; it requires offenders to make amends for their actions. 2. Community protection. A continuum of sanctions provides for consequences for noncompliance. 3. Competency development. Education, work experience, and community service promote the development of skills that demonstrate that offenders are capable of productive, competent behavior. The balanced approach is individualized and is based on the offense committed and the needs and risks of the offender. Restorative justice (Zehr, 1990) is based on three values and assumptions: 1. Offenders, victims, and the community roles are included in the response to crime. 2. The response has complementary roles for government and local communities. 3. Offenders are held accountable through accepting responsibility for their actions and repairing the harm caused by their offenses. Restorative justice is focused on the broad relationships between offenders, victims, and the community (Lawrence, 1991; Zehr, 1990). Zehr (1985) viewed this approach as a paradigm shift from retributive justice (punishment, vengeance, deterrence) to restorative justice (mediation, empowerment, reparation). Philosophically, restorative justice provides an alternative that is neither punitive nor lenient in its focus. This model was a driving force in program development. First, the CICTP emphasizes accountability through monitoring and providing opportunities for restitution to victims and through ongoing viable community service projects. Second, community protection is provided through a seven-dayper-week continuum of intermediate, community-based surveillance and sanctions. Third, competency development is the focus of all program components. The ultimate goal is to develop clients who are capable of productive, competent behavior. Finally, balance is achieved through the program by tangible benefits gained by the community, the victim, and the offender.
DESCRIPTION OF AGENCIES The School District of the City of Erie is an urban district that serves 12,500 students. The school population lives in one of the highest areas of poverty per capita. The district has been innovative and creative in the development of programming for at-risk youth. The primary benefit of the district’s participation in the partnership is related to fiscal concerns. When a student is court-ordered to a residential facility,
96 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
the home district is responsible for the cost of education. Typically those costs are more than it would incur if the students resided at home. There would be cost savings if students could receive similar residential services and still remain in the community. Aside from the cost savings, the district has always been interested in the provision of services that may benefit their students. The Juvenile Probation Office is responsible for disposition of all referrals for delinquent behavior. The benefit for this office’s collaborative involvement is that this is a viable alternative to residential treatment, which would help with the escalating expense of residential placement. Perseus House, Inc. is a not-for-profit organization that provides residential and community-based programming for males and females, grades k-12, with drug and alcohol, mental health, and behavioral problems. The benefit to Perseus House, Inc. as a collaborative partner was development of the ability to increase and improve the agency’s continuum of services.
STAFFING PATTERNS The CICTP operates seven days a week with students who are engaged in clinical, educational, and behavioral intervention through two distinct programmatic structures. The first is the Deferred Placement option. At disposition, placement has been recommended and is deferred to the CICTP. The second option is Community Reintegration, where the adolescent returns from placement approximately 45 days earlier than the average residential stay. The training and program focus has been, and will continue to be, inclusion of the family in the prescribed treatment and implementation of Aggression Replacement Training. Twenty-five local social service agencies are represented with a variety of proficiencies. This multi-trained and talented group of staff truly reflects a melting pot of disciplines which enhanced the treatment team. It would be difficult for any non-profit organization to duplicate similar staffing patterns with full-time staff without significant expenditures. The staff configuration is a unique design not typical of residential or community-based programming. There is a total of 40 staff employed, 12 full-time and the remaining 28 employees part-time. The full-time staff includes three case managers, a community service coordinator, an aftercare specialist, and support staff. The case managers provide non-traditional case management, which entails non-traditional hours and group facilitation of Aggression Replacement Training. They provide supervision and sanctions throughout the week. The decision to hire part-time staff was developed through consensus building, and an effort to contain costs related to full-time benefits. It was determined that in order for the program to be successful, it would need to be staffed by the most seasoned veterans. We developed a schedule that would accommodate part-time positions and still maintain program continuity. We were also able to allocate hourly rates that were higher than typical per-diem rates, thus attracting qualified staff. It is important to note that key administrative staff from all collaborators participated in the development of the program. They also provided the primary supervision, which has increased investment in program success. Communication
COLLABORATION WITH HUMAN SERVICES AND SCHOOLS 97
between partners occurs on a daily basis, which also improves attention to daily detail. All partners embrace a holistic approach to client intervention as the program provides a comprehensive multimodal treatment model. This agreed-upon vision was developed through consensus and mutually determined collaborative goals.
PROGRAM OBJECTIVES Program objectives were developed in conjunction with the consensus of all collaborators. We had lengthy dialog regarding specific short-term objectives designed to meet our long-range goals: 1. To provide an opportunity for youth to remain in the community. 2. To use community resources to address and reduce behavioral problems and therefore divert residential placement. 3. To provide an atmosphere through which problem solving and individualized treatment planning can be undertaken by the client, the family, and referring agency to reduce the possibility of further behavioral problems. 4. To increase the potential for successful completion of educational goals. 5. To increase involvement of the family with the client to address behavioral problems which could lead to residential placement. 6. To provide cost-efficient intervention other than residential placement, group homes or institutions. 7. To provide for early reintegration of youth currently in placement, reducing placement by an average of 45 days. 8. To reduce the potential for future referrals to the court and therefore reduce the rate of recidivism. The outcome measures chosen to evaluate the decided-upon goals have had a direct impact on cost savings for residential expenses. The following are measures that we have utilized to assess program effectiveness: 1. 2. 3. 4.
Stabilization of growth in Erie County residential placements. Shortening length of stay regarding residential days. Decrease in dollars spent on residential placements. Recidivism rate that is the same or lower than current residential treatment facilities utilized by Erie County.
PROGRAM INTERVENTIONS Case Management The program is designed to provide a continuum of services to clients seven days per week. Clients attend the Alternative Education Program (AEP) from 10:00 a.m.
98 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
until 6:00 p.m. daily, Monday through Thursday. The Deferred clients attend a sitespecific class at a local educational institution. The Reintegration clients attend AEP at their home school. The therapeutic component for both Deferred and Reintegration clients occurs Friday from 3:30 p.m. until 8:00 p.m., Saturday from 10:00 a.m. until 7:00 p.m., and Sunday from 9:00 a.m. until 3:30 p.m. A key component of the program is case management services. Case managers are responsible for tracking each client throughout the week to coordinate services. The case managers are full-time employees who primarily focus on assisting the client and family attain treatment goals. They ensure client participation in programs from the continuum that meet their needs. The case managers facilitate the Skillstreaming curriculum to enhance program continuity. The case managers also act as brokers and link clients with necessary community resources. They are responsible for providing ongoing coordination of all required services at home, in school, and during the weekend components of the program. They are the glue that holds the program together. The case managers monitor compliance with the AEP and compliance with Individualized Treatment Plans (i.e. house arrest status, curfew, etc.) through home visits and phone contacts. Curfew phone checks are provided randomly seven days per week.
Clinical Components The clinical program was designed by a group of key program collaborators with the intent of replicating residential treatment services. The behavioral component was designed by a selected group of team leaders and collaborative administrative staff. This process occurred over a period of two months and a series of eight meetings. Two teams were divided up based on staff expertise and then developed the behavior management system for approval by the full group. The clinical component was evolved, with general agreement from the planning group, with a philosophical framework of the achievement of competency development for both clients and their families. The primary clinical focus is Aggression Replacement Training expounded by Goldstein, Glick, and Gibbs (1986).
AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING (ART) ART was initiated in 1987 with three major components of Skillstreaming, the behavioral component, Anger Control Training, the emotion targeted component, and Moral Reasoning, the cognitive component. Goldstein and Glick (1987) describe the first of three underlying rationales that guide ART principles, which is the importance of multimodal interventions: Behavior change in our view may result from interventions which are explicitly targeted on overt behavior, or which seek to diminish emotional responses which inhibit use of behaviors already in the person’s behavioral repertoire, or which provide information about the consequences of alternative behaviors. Behavioral, affective and cognitive interventions each in these differing ways possess potential for altering overt behaviors. Which, and how many of
COLLABORATION WITH HUMAN SERVICES AND SCHOOLS 99 these alternative intervention routes will correspond to any given youngster’s channels of accessibility will obviously vary from youngster to youngster. We believe, however, that it generally will prove efficacious to take more than one route simultaneously. The source and maintainers of aggression are diverse and multi-channeled, so must the remediation be. Skillstreaming is our behavioral intervention; Anger Control Training is affective in its substance; Moral Education is cognitive in nature. Guided by our multimodal philosophy, it is our hypothesis that these interventions yield superior outcomes to those resulting from single-channel interventions. (p. 18)
The second rationale is the development and implementation of a constructive treatment strategy that is described by Kazdin (1975): The constructive treatment strategy refers to developing a treatment package by adding components to enhance therapy . . . With the constructive approach the investigator usually begins with a basic treatment component that is relatively narrow or circumscribed in focus. Research is conducted that adds various ingredients to the basic treatment to determine what enhances treatment effects. As research continues, effective components are retained and a large treatment package is constructed. (p. 87)
Finally, Goldstein and Stein (1976) describe the development, application, and evaluation of ART as incremental prescription building: An incremental prescriptive strategy [is] one in which partial or tentative prescriptions are replicated, combined, and empirically examined in such a manner that one can ascertain whether the percent of outcome variance accounted for is, as predicted, progressively increasing. Klett and Moseley (1963) champion a similar incremental strategy. They propose a prescription-building process in which (a) active treatment ingredients are identified, (b) their weighing visa` -vis outcome variance is determined, (c) ingredients are combined into new sets and combinations, and (d) the new prescriptive combinations are offered, reweighted and so forth. (p. 19)
This multi-pronged approach fits with the intention and goals of the CICTP regarding competency development. The collaborators were also already familiar with utilizing ART throughout a variety of programs ranging, with extremely positive outcomes, from intensive residential services to community-based programming. The ART curriculum is delivered weekly to both the clients and parents. (We will describe the parent component later in this chapter.) With the client we choose the skill of the week; however, with the parent group the curriculum is negotiated as a tool of engagement. The groups have open enrollment and are selected by clinical indication. The following is a list of the various program interventions that have been incorporated into the program. 1. Skillstreaming: intervention with specific skill curriculum of prosocial behaviors systematically implemented with small groups, utilizing: a. modeling; b. role-playing; c. performance feedback; d. transfer training.
100 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
2. Anger Control Training: a 13-week curriculum that is designed to teach selfcontrol of anger. Each client is trained to respond to specific “hassles” with a chain of behaviors that include: a. identifying triggers; b. identifying cues; c. use of reminders; d. use of reducers; e. use of self-evaluation. 3. Moral Reasoning: a set of procedures designed to raise the young person’s level of fairness, justice, and concern with the needs and rights of others. 4. Psychoeducational: an intervention designed to provide psychoeducational curriculum (e.g. HIV/AIDS, hygiene, stress, etc.) to small groups. 5. Drug and alcohol education: an intervention designed to provide drug and alcohol education to develop each client’s understanding of educational themes, e.g. the disease concept, biological impact of addictive behaviors, self-esteem, etc. 6. Communication/peer feedback: an intervention designed to develop each client’s ability to communicate effectively with peers and adults. Peer feedback provides the opportunity for praise, reinstruction, and related feedback through the use of positive peer culture. 7. Recreational therapy/creative arts: an intervention designed to teach cooperative, non-competitive assertive skills in a social environment through the development of prosocial leisure-time skills. 8. Systematic progressive relaxation: an intervention involving the understanding and development of biophysical dimensions of problems and coping strategies. It incorporates muscle relaxation training and guided imagery as a strategy for stress and anger reduction. 9. Victim impact empathy training: an intervention designed to increase each client’s ability to understand and empathize with the human consequences of crime. 10. Cultural sensitivity: an intervention designed to assist clients in the development of awareness and respect for similarities and differences among diverse groups. 11. Life skills training: an intervention designed to teach basic skills that may be applicable in daily living. 12. Victim/offender mediation: provides a forum for victims to question the offender and reach a mutual agreement to determine how restitution will be paid. Both the case managers and clinical staff deliver all interventions throughout the week. 13. Parent training: the primary focus of treatment is inclusion of the family in the treatment plan. Community-based settings tend to increase the opportunity for parent engagement because of physical proximity of parents to the program. We have also requested that the judiciary order parents to participate in the program. We utilize a structural family approach as we help families identify boundaries, strengths, and behavioral strategies to address their children’s behavior. This approach also may help parents, in a non-threatening manner, to evaluate their interactions with their sons or daughters. Parents attend weekly parent training groups that are both educational and supportive in nature. A unique feature of the parent training
COLLABORATION WITH HUMAN SERVICES AND SCHOOLS 101
program is that parents also participate in Skillstreaming, and, twice monthly, they role-play relevant skills with their children in the group. We have seen success utilizing this strategy and have received feedback that although parents were initially intimidated, they found the role-play and feedback extremely productive. The components of the Parent Training Program are as follows: 1. Skillstreaming with parent. 2. Skillstreaming with parent and child. 3. Parent-to-parent drug and alcohol awareness: a group intervention designed to train participants in the skills, attitudes, and abilities they may need to aid their children through the adolescent years without significant drug and alcohol use. 4. The Power of Choice (Michael Pritchard, 1997): a group intervention designed to help empower people to make healthy decisions in their lives. 5. Parent support: a group intervention designed to provide an opportunity for parents to share experiences and problems and to develop parenting strategies from open discussions and feedback. The weekend educational program also focuses on competency development, specifically in the areas of reading, math, technology, and study skills. Psychiatric assessment is available to all clients as well as psychological evaluation and diagnostic study.
COMMUNITY SERVICE Clients participate in viable community service projects to develop behavior that is productive and competent with the ultimate goal of community reparation. All projects are developed, implemented, and supervised by the Community Service Coordinator. The main goal is to develop empathy and understanding of the human consequence of victimization, utilizing community resources to develop competency, accountability, and community protection. Many of the clients are court-ordered to perform community service hours. Equipment and supplies are provided through public grants and private donations. We provide project sites seven days per week. Many of the projects include United Way’s Student Day of Caring, Neighborhood Watch Clean Ups, Nursing Home Visits, and Earth Day. The development of the Summer Earn and Learn Program has also flourished from the collaboration. It was initiated in 1996 as an effort to combine summer school with restitution and the community service program. Initial partners were the Erie School District and Erie County Juvenile Probation. In 1997, the concept expanded through collaboration with the Greater Erie Community Action Center and the CICTP.
AFTERCARE Each client has an individualized aftercare plan that is developed in conjunction with the client, family, and referring agent. The plan is implemented and supervised
102 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
by the aftercare specialist. The aftercare specialists act as brokers, coordinators, and advocates for the client and the family. Their main focus is one of coordination and connection with the client and indicated community resources.
COLLABORATIVE DEVELOPMENT The development of the CICTP program was thought to be the culmination of collaboration in Erie County. Actually, it was a step in the collaborative development of services for youth. As services for youth increased, fragmentation became evident as providers operated in various directions. Through the leadership of the collaborators within the CICTP, a system was developed that would address the issues of incorrigibility and system fragmentation. Upon examination of resources available to youth in Erie County, it became evident that the population of youth usually described as incorrigible was being referred to programs within community-based and residential settings. Although this is a population of youth for which delinquency charges may or may not have been filed, they had engaged in behavior that was dangerous to themselves and others and out of the reasonable control of educators, their parents, and other responsible authorities. In addition to being harmful to themselves and others, their behavior undermined a sense of civility and good social order necessary for the community and its citizens to reach their potential. In the absence of an effective response to this population, their behavior will deteriorate, other youth may be pulled into their influence, and the sense of public order will be strained. In Erie County there was and continues to be a strong need to best serve the youth within a constellation of collaborative community services that are designed to achieve specific outcomes for each of the definable “incorrigible” populations: 1. Serious and repetitive delinquent youth: this group of youth receives services through the delivery of traditional delinquent services. Although this group is not merely incorrigible, they may require the services of the Community Youth Services Center at the time of re-entry to school and community. 2. Less serious delinquent youth: these groups of youths receive services in the traditional delinquent system and the collaborative community system. 3. Chronically incorrigible youth: this is the most directly specified target population for the Community Youth Services Center. These youths have violated school district policy, have chronic behavior problems, are often truant, have violated drug and alcohol policies, or have been expelled from school. 4. At-risk youth: this refers to elementary youth who are exhibiting behavior that places them at high risk for later delinquency, including early and persistent antisocial behavior, academic failure, ineffective parental supervision, association with antisocial delinquent peers, drug and alcohol use, or extreme economic deprivation. In response to this identified incorrigible population, Perseus House, Inc., in collaboration with the City of Erie School District, Sarah A. Reed Children’s Center,
COLLABORATION WITH HUMAN SERVICES AND SCHOOLS 103
Erie County Offices of Juvenile Probation and Children and Youth, and the Erie County MH/MR Office, developed the Community Youth Service Center. The Center benefits youths from age 10 to 18 years, who typically fall into the category of either incorrigible or delinquent, and/or have a psychiatric diagnosis. The constellation is managed by a collaborative management team, which uses a results-based management model supported by objectively gathered fiscal information that is analyzed to assure that effective, cost-efficient, flexible, and responsive services are provided. The management committee includes a representative from each of the collaborative partners. Families of clients benefit as they have the opportunity for a single point of entry for referral, assessment, and parent training that previously had been fragmented. The Erie community has benefited as there are coordinated, cohesive, initiatives designed to refer, assess, and/or treat identified youth referred to the program. The collaborative management team developed goals, objectives, methods, and outcome measures. This process included assessment of the current system of service delivery and evaluation of community needs. Consensus building was a tool used to determine the need and appropriate measures to take to solve the problem of fragmentation. Program interventions were designed similar to the CICTP, which include a multi-pronged approach with extensive program evaluation. Howell (1997) echoes this approach in defining a comprehensive strategy towards juvenile justice and youth violence: Treatment programs found to be most effective were characterized by multimodal services, more intensive services (contact hours, duration, and intensity), and services more closely monitored by research teams, which resulted in better implementation. (p. 170)
SUMMARY The development of the CICTP was a process that focused primarily on relationship building. This included the fostering of trust with collaborators to develop solutions to community problems that broke the traditional mode of problem solving. To develop and maintain it, it was necessary to think beyond the traditional methods of analysis, identification, and solution building. Partners were able to shift from typical problem-solving paradigms to a creative model that focuses on resource reallocation. The Collaborative Intensive Community Treatment Program is a good example of how human service agencies and schools can collaborate and incorporate Aggression Replacement Training effectively to solve community problems.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors would like to acknowledge the work of Tom Antolik, Tom Gamble, Paula Laughlin, and Nick Viglione for their pivotal participation in the development and implementation of programming.
104 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
REFERENCES Antolik, T. (1995). Erie County Juvenile Probation Annual Report. Erie, PA: Author. Bazemore, G. (1992). On mission statements and reform in juvenile justice: The case for the balanced approach. Federal Probation, 56(3), 24–34. Bruner, C. (1990). Improving children’s welfare: Learning from Iowa. Denver, CO: National Conference of State Legislatures. Elder, J. O. & Magrab, P. (1980). Coordinating services to handicapped children—A handbook for interagency ccollaboration. Baltimore, MD: Paul H. Brookes. Goldstein, A. P. & Glick B. (1987). Angry Youth—Reducing Aggression. Corrections Today, 49, 38–42. Goldstein, A. P., Glick B., & Gibbs, J. (1986). Aggression Replacement Training: A comprehensive intervention for aggressive youth. Champaign, IL: Research Press. Goldstein, A. P. & Stein, N. (1976). Prescriptive psychotherapies. New York: Pergamon Press. Howell, J. (1997). Guide for implementing the Comprehensive Strategy for Serious, Violent, and Chronic Juvenile Offenders. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention. Kagan, S. (1991). United we stand. New York: Teachers College Press. Kazdin, A. (1975). Behavior modification in applied settings. Homewood, IL: Dorsey. Klett, C. J. & Moseley, E. C. (1963). The right drug for the right patient. Report No. 54. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office. Lawrence, R. (1991). Reexamining community corrections models. Crime and Delinquency, 37(4), 436–449. Maloney, D., Romig, D., & Armstrong, T. (1988). Juvenile probation: The balanced approach. Juvenile and Family Court Journal, 39(3), 23–32. Pritchard, M. S. (1997). Peace Talks [video]. San Francisco, CA: Heart Land Media (distributed by the Bureau for At-Risk Youth). Umbreit, M. S. (1989). Victims seeking fairness, not revenge toward restorative justice. Federal Probation, 53(3), 52–57. VanNess, D. W. (1990). Restorative justice. In B. Galaway & J. Hudson (Eds), Criminal justice, restitution, and reconciliation (p. 163). Monsey, NJ: Willow Tree Press. Zehr, H. (1985). Retributive justice, restorative justice. Akron, PA: Mennonite Central Committee. Zehr, H. (1990). Changing lenses: A new focus for crime and justice. Scottsdale, PA: Herald Press.
Chapter 7
UNGDOMSALTERNATIVET—THE YOUTH ALTERNATIVE IVAN BRILJE, MARIUSZ HERMELIN, AND MIKAEL KALT Ungdomsalternativet, Malm¨o, Sweden
Based upon many years of practical experience with aggressive youth and our reflection upon those experiences, we offer in this chapter the story of our professional and personal journey, a journey in which Aggression Replacement Training (ART) plays a major role. In 1997, we created Ungdomsalternativet (The Youth Alternative), as a way of helping young people find alternative ways of dealing with their problems. The primary intention in developing Ungdomsalternativet was to train the youth in alternatives to aggressive behavior and improve their ability to interact with others. The important goal was to provide the community’s social services with alternatives to expensive institution placements, and to actively involve youth at risk and positively influence their decisions and actions in order to promote a better future for themselves and the community. The schools in the community were also in need of new and effective methods of managing behavior. The best way to achieve all these goals was to work with research-based and effective methods such as ART, combined with long-time experience of working with aggressive youth in various settings. Promoting and implementing ART, not only by working directly with youngsters, but through information and training of trainers, as well as developing a simple and accessible system to make ART available to teachers and youth workers around the country, was also an important goal. The ultimate goal was, and still is, to integrate ART in early stages of education, making it a part of the primary school curriculum.
THE YOUTH INSTITUTIONS The three of us had worked previously with aggressive youngsters, particularly those so advanced in their violent, criminal careers that they have had to spend New Perspectives on Aggression Replacement Training: Practice, Research, and Application. C 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Edited by A. P. Goldstein, R. Nens´en, B. Daleflod, and M. Kalt.
106 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
time in the state youth institutions. We worked in one of the oldest and largest institutions in Sweden located in Lund in the south of the country, just across the bridge from Copenhagen. In recent years, there has been a significant shift in the institutional clientele towards more violent and aggressive youths. Some young people committed brutal and violent crimes; many were addicted to drugs or alcohol and their felonies were often committed under the influence. The majority of institutional clients (over 70%) were of the so-called “second generation immigrant” background. The majority of these “immigrant” youngsters were born and raised in Sweden, where the immigrant population is estimated at approximately 20% of the total populace. These adolescents were often difficult to handle within the confines of institutional walls. We worked with dedication and enthusiasm, trying to influence them as best we could. We explained to them what society expected, to help them make that all-important decision to change their lives and transform themselves into “good law-abiding citizens.” Unfortunately for both them and us, our efforts often failed. The methods we were using were not effective in teaching alternative behaviors. So the youths kept returning to the institutions after committing new crimes, showing an inability to adapt to the laws and rules of society, regardless of the amount of time spent in the institution and the efforts of caring people around them. The professional patience and tolerance of the staff and the lack of consequences, no matter how badly they behaved, made the time in the lock-up easy and predictable. The institutional therapy did not have a positive influence or teach the youth alternative ways of dealing with real-life problems. The majority of the young people were not motivated to change or to be “treated.” In the secure unit for extremely aggressive boys where we worked, an 18-year-old boy was admitted with a record of extreme violent crime and drug addiction. It was challenging to keep him from escaping and hurting himself or someone else: we relied on personal experience and the relationship that we were eventually able to establish. However, this youth brought forth something that changed the way we looked at our role in the lives of the young people we worked with. Whenever we attempted to persuade him to change or think about his future he would reply, “I must only do one thing— I must die. The rest I can do if I want to!” What we said or did mattered little as long as he was not ready and willing to listen. The best way to help him was to offer him alternatives to the violent behavior with the understanding that he had the power and control to make choices and also to accept consequences. Until recently, institutions in Sweden did not provide programs that actively offered these alternatives; indeed, the long stay in the institution could even reinforce the negative behavior. After the clients were released or went home on a short leave, the problems often started again as the young people were not able to resist the pressures or handle the situations of everyday life at school, home, or in the street. They simply did not know what alternatives there were, or they became so enraged they could not think of alternatives, so old, well-rehearsed patterns of behavior came to the fore. Many young people went through a number of consecutive placements over several years of their short lives, after which they were supposed to be “socially readapted.” There were few community-based programs offering them support and continuation of the “social training” once they re-entered society,
UNGDOMSALTERNATIVET—THE YOUTH ALTERNATIVE 107
but institutional therapy is costly and a burden to the limited financial resources of the social services. The teenagers are aware of this, saying: “If they gave me all the millions they spent on me here, I wouldn’t cause any more trouble.” Perhaps it is a shame no one ever considered this approach. Placing young delinquents in institutions for a limited period of time is, in many cases, unavoidable for the sake of their own security and well-being, as well as for society. A law has been introduced recently enabling Swedish courts to sentence young offenders (under the age of 18 years) to time-limited institutional therapy instead of prison terms. Once this law had been passed, the number of cases quickly soared higher than expected and is still growing, placing even more responsibility on youth institutions to provide treatment methods and effective ways of implementing them. The State Institution Board decided recently to include ART in the institutional therapy, which will not only improve the quality of youth treatment, but also increase the personal security and work satisfaction of the staff.
THE COMMUNITY PROJECTS Why do costly institution placements bring about so little change, and what, if anything, can be done differently? We felt frustrated with the results and conditions of our work, and many of our colleagues expressed similar feelings. The situation called for radical changes: either give in or do something different. The solution involved both! One of the strategies was to meet the youngsters earlier, when the first signs of trouble appeared and their young age left them more open to influence. It seemed also natural to meet them on their “home ground,” to experience the conditions they lived in, to meet their parents, siblings, and peers, and to watch them interact in everyday situations. Eventually we began to work for schools and the community-based projects administered by the social services in Malmo¨ and surrounding communities. Our job was to meet the youth at risk, keep in touch with their parents and teachers, and together provide increased control and guidance for our clients. The idea was to keep the youngsters occupied, help them develop new interests and hobbies, and find new friends and role models. We discovered that working to these new premises and in different environments was both challenging and rewarding. The youngsters “chose” to work with us, instead of being “forced” to do it. No one wanted to be sent away to an institution, so meeting with us became a last chance for many young people. Most cases worked out really well and we were able to help the youth avoid the trauma of leaving their friends and family. The social authorities and the parents saw advantages with our work in that they were able to fulfill obligations towards the clients, provide control and care, and save money on expensive institution placements. We developed a good working relationship with local police, school counselors, and social authorities in Malmo, ¨ which proved very useful. We also got to know all the “boys in the hood” and, even more importantly, they got to know us. Working in both youth institutions and in the community inspired new ideas about how the two should work together. The unavoidable institutional placements should be shorter and more meaningful, more resources and efforts should
108 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
be invested in preventive work in schools and the community, and new intervention methods should be introduced in both institutions and the community. Further programs started in institutions should be continued in the community with, importantly, a unified approach from the different youth workers and authorities involved. A unified approach avoids young people taking advantage of professional differences and continuing their destructive behaviors without experiencing swift and serious consequences.
¨ SCHOOLS IN MALMO Working within the community also gave us an opportunity to observe what the young people experienced before they came to the youth institution. After working in a number of elementary schools in Malmo¨ we concluded that the problems there were serious and often started at a very young age. It seemed as if we had only seen the “tip of the iceberg” while working in the isolated environments of the institutions. The teachers were often overworked and frustrated; many expressed feeling “burned out” or said that they were on the verge of quitting the profession. In some schools there was a feeling of constant crisis and helplessness. The teachers spent most of their time in the classroom addressing disciplinary problems, while the academic achievements of the students were suffering. Some schools seemed to be taken over by young delinquents, terrorizing students and staff alike. These young people were not there to study, but to cause trouble, and to intimidate or impress their peers. Unfortunately, they often succeeded in being role models for younger children and were surrounded by a circle of “hangers-on.” At times the schools needed to call the police or hire security personnel to maintain order, and the social authorities became involved in order to send the troublemakers away to a special school or institution. Unfortunately the young people who did go away were quickly replaced by other pupils. Schools would therefore hire special educators or social workers to take care of the most disturbing students, and keep them occupied or separated from the rest of the school population. However, the long-term goals of such interventions were often not clearly defined and therefore seldom fulfilled expectations. These projects were expensive and, as a result, time limited and had no significant impact on the school-wide environment. However, it must be said that some of them were at times successful and provided both the troubled students and the ones remaining in their classes an opportunity to study in a more serene environment. The positive reinforcement of getting all the attention in the classroom was withdrawn and replaced by positive attention and support in smaller groups. The high adult to student ratio and matching the special qualifications of the staff with the problems of youth was a good, although costly, solution. In recent years, several primary schools in Malmo¨ decided to address these problems in a different, longer-term manner, sending teachers and counselors to ART trainer workshops and initiating school-based ART programs. The teachers and counselors, trained and supervised by ART master trainers from Ungdomsalternativet, work with age groups ranging from grade 4 to 9 years. The interest in these
UNGDOMSALTERNATIVET—THE YOUTH ALTERNATIVE 109
more permanent and effective solutions to school problems is increasing, and it is necessary to train many more trainers and secure the cooperation of the rest of the school staff in order to make ART a whole-school system of violence prevention. Currently, six elementary or special schools in Malmo¨ have finished their first year of working with ART and plan to expand the program into the next school year. All of them are satisfied with the results and have become models for similar efforts in Malmo¨ and around the country. It is important that these programs continue to receive the necessary long-term support and are well documented and evaluated. We are convinced that these efforts will be introduced to many other schools in Malmo¨ and elsewhere. We are prepared to train and coach many new ART trainers and participate in new ART projects in schools, where Aggression Replacement Training is certainly most needed and effective.
¨ MALMO—THE MULTICULTURAL CITY Malmo, ¨ Sweden’s third largest city, is also the most ethnically diverse. One in four inhabitants of the city are of an immigrant background; recent data indicate that 52% of youngsters aged 19 and under are of immigrant parents (41% in Stockholm). This ethnic and cultural mixture gives the city its multicultural identity and continental flavor appreciated by residents and visitors alike. The recently opened bridge connection to Copenhagen has influenced the character of the city even more, making it a part of a large city conglomeration. However, as is often the case, as well as the positive effects this development is also a source of growing social problems. In some districts of the city, the immigrant population today reaches 90%, with almost corresponding unemployment numbers. This ethnic diversity is reflected in the variety of cultures represented and languages spoken in local schools, and is often associated with problems such as school violence, high crime rate, and poor academic results. The clear over-representation of youth with immigrant backgrounds in youth institutions is also one of the consequences of the multiethnic infusions. The youngsters referred to as “second generation immigrants” present a challenge to the system of institutional care, schools, and social services. Society, represented by the police, social workers, teachers, and courts, is often looked upon with suspicion by these youngsters (as well as their parents), confirming the attitude common to antisocial youth. We frequently hear young people justifying their antics by saying “They (the establishment, teachers, police, etc.) are racists, they are my enemy and are responsible for my behavior.” The young people’s level of motivation to actively participate in “therapy programs” and to identify with available role models is consequently very low. The rewards that society “is supposed to provide” for improved social behavior, such as higher education, job opportunities, and high social status are not present or seem unachievable. Addressing these problems requires political, economic, and social changes as well as working directly with individuals and their families. Frequent media reports about youth violence, robberies, and gang-related fights, as well as the status of the city’s elementary schools (placing three of them on the top ten list of worst-performing schools in the country), initiated local discussions about how
110 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
to improve the situation. Daily reports of youth violence have finally come to the attention of local politicians, and the discussions on how to make Malmo¨ a safer city will certainly continue. It was not a coincidence that the first international ART conference was held in Malmo¨ in September 2001.
OUR FIRST CONTACT WITH ART We owe much of our experience and knowledge of how to cope professionally with extremely aggressive and antisocial youth to our time in the youth institutions. This experience gave us the drive to search for alternative solutions and methods beyond the limitations of the institutional walls. ART was one such solution we found, a scientifically validated method that matched our own experiences. The first contact with Dr Goldstein was at a workshop in Sundbo, the youth institution north of Stockholm. Attending Dr Goldstein’s workshops in different locations in Sweden and in the USA provided us with information about the background, theory, applications, and results of the program. However, we could not picture ourselves working with ART as we lacked the skills, experience, and confidence. This initial experience later inspired us to develop our own ART trainer-training program in order to help others overcome the initial difficulties. The workshops in Sweden provided us with an opportunity to meet other people interested or working with ART, such as Rune Nens´en and the staff of Oasis in Aneby, and Bengt Daleflod, responsible for ART at the Sundbo Youth Instituion. These networks inspired and encouraged us to continue with our efforts, and to expand beyond Sweden in our professional links. In the USA we have links with Taberg, a state youth facility, and Aaron Gregory and his staff working with extremely aggressive boys. This residential facility, with 24 aggressive teenagers from tough New York neighborhoods, has not had one fight during the past three years. The proactive behavior, encompassed in a firm and respectful approach towards youth and each other, together with the ART program, had produced these impressive results. In Erie, Pennsylvania, we have links with Mark Amendola, director of the local youth agency, Perseus House, and with Bob Oliver, the head of a large school district in Erie. Perseus House has developed over the years and now works closely with the community, businesses, and schools within the district. It later became one of the models for establishing our own organization, Ungdomsalternativet. The ideals and models of behavior spread instantly through media channels: action movies, computer games, and hip-hop music are sources of inspiration to youth the world over. Unfortunately, fast and easily accessible communication does not only spread positive ideals or models of behavior. It has been said that European countries, including Sweden, follow in the footsteps of social problems and juvenile delinquency development in the United States. Moreover, the role models of antisocial behavior spread by mass media play a significant part in its development. A recent addition to the Swedish crime scene is the appearance of organized, criminal youth gangs such as the Original Gangsters and the Albans. The American
UNGDOMSALTERNATIVET—THE YOUTH ALTERNATIVE 111
gangs serve as role models for these organizations and their rivalry for territory and profits evolves into regular gang wars, terrorizing the population at large. This “unexpected” development has taken the Swedish police and authorities by surprise. These observations, together with documented experience of successful intervention strategies such as ART, made us confident that what worked in the United States should prove equally effective back home. Therefore we decided to dedicate time and effort to introducing ART in Malmo¨ schools and community youth projects. We have visited our friends in the United States on several occasions and through numerous workshops and extensive practice we have achieved the status of ART Master Trainers.
THE ALTERNATIVE SCHOOL PROJECTS One of the earliest ART projects we got involved in was the alternative school project Trappen in Roseng˚ard, Malmo. ¨ The primary schools of the district sent “difficult” students to Trappen for a period of time, but in some cases the schools were reluctant to take them back. We introduced ART to Trappen, and it soon became the most important part of their program alongside school education, sports, and other activities. Trappen was a unique and innovative project. It offered an opportunity not only for the twice-weekly ART sessions, but also for transfer coaching and facilitating the use of trained skills in real life. The teachers knew from their experience that clearly defined rules and consequences were needed, so that dealing with conflict situations provided an excellent opportunity for transfer coaching. Some youngsters, with problems outside of school, were assigned individual transfer coaches from Ungdomsalternativet, who were able to observe and monitor their behavior as well as assist them in transferring the trained skills. The transfer training and the “homework” were thus taking place not only throughout the whole school day, but also during the free-time activities. Further, contact between staff and parents was established. Our collaboration with Trappen as ART trainers, transfer coaches, and consultants has been rewarding and successful, and parents, teachers, and social authorities alike appreciate the project. Thanks to the competent and dedicated leadership and personnel, and to the well-run ART program, Trappen received publicity, hosted visitors, and is now a model for school projects elsewhere in the country. It plays a significant role in promoting ART in Sweden.
THE ART SCHOOL ALTERNATIVE The alternative schools are one of the solutions to the school problems described previously. The number of these special schools, at both the elementary and secondary level, is growing. However, the number of students who are in need of such programs is growing at an even faster rate. This increasing need not only opens the field to the emergence of many alternative schools, but also raises questions as to their role and primary objective. Are they to function as permanent solutions for
112 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
some students? If so, we would need many more of these costly projects. Can we develop a routine of sending maladjusted children to these programs for a limited period of time and for a specific purpose? Such a purpose, for instance, could be to improve their social and problem-solving skills and their ability to control anger, so enabling them to re-enter mainstream education. However, some students show a significant improvement in their social skills level and overall behavior, but are still not able to rejoin their ordinary schools. The unchanged environment of the school and the lack of positive reinforcement provided for the newly trained skills mean a return to the previous role of a troublemaker. Our experiences from Trappen and the expertise and dedication of our new coworker David Kiliba helped us to develop our own alternative school project for aggressive boys. It consists today of five students and three teachers, and we plan to expand to the optimal number of eight students in the next school year (making it an ideal ART group). The teachers and ART trainers work continually on improving the program. It is based on ART and social training (transfer), combined with individual tutoring in chosen primary school subjects, sports, and other activities. It involves active fact-finding through visiting museums and libraries and using the Internet. The typical features of our approach are high teacher to student ratio, skillful ART trainers combining youth, flexibility, and experience, warm, respectful relations between the trainers and the trainees, rules that are few in number and clear and simple, respected by teachers and students alike, individual attention to students and immediate reinforcement of social skills, and close collaboration with parents and social authorities. The goal of the program is to prepare the students for reentering the mainstream school system, to prevent institution placements, and to train future junior ART trainers (the last being of special importance). The program is presented to youth as a possibility to become skillful, successful, and respected by becoming a role model and a junior ART trainer, not as a permanent exclusion, a punishment or therapy (an opportunity many of our students considered lost or unachievable at school). The average period of training in the ART school alternative varies from one school term to one full year. The students attending the school alternative are not only those causing problems in their classes but are also at risk for an institution placement. Therefore, the program is being co-financed by social services and the school districts from which the students come. We continually report the progress of our students to their respective parents, teachers, and social workers. This coalition decides on the duration and content of individual programs for each student. The schools also support providing teaching materials and professional advice. The waiting list for our alternative school is growing.
OUR OWN TRAINING: START ART in Trappen and our school alternative provide an opportunity to practice leadership and supervising skills, improve the procedures and routines of training, and deal with all kinds of disciplinary and motivational problems. These experiences
UNGDOMSALTERNATIVET—THE YOUTH ALTERNATIVE 113
helped us later develop our ART trainer-training program. Modeling and acting in the role-plays also made us realize our own personal social skills deficiencies, especially in the field of conflict resolution and anger management. Sometimes there was little difference in the behavior of the adults and the youth—both seemed to be in need of social training. (Recent research in Swedish primary schools indicates that 6% of students feel they are being bullied by the teachers whereas only 4% feel they are being bullied by other students!) “Live the way you teach” became our motto and the key to our successful ART approach. In order to achieve this goal we have regular START (Staff Training ART) once a week, during which we concentrate on our own social skills and anger control as well as resolve problems and conflicts. In the beginning of our ART implementation we became aware that Swedish translations and descriptions of social skills (the steps) were often too long and difficult for our youth, which inhibited their performance in role-playing and prevented active participation. We solved this problem by translating the steps together with our youth. The language used is familiar to the trainees and helps them understand the instructions. We use the first person to make the steps more personal and direct. For those with reading problems we read the instructions or ask questions while directing the role-plays. Simplifying the steps, without compromising their content, was important to the tempo and fluency of the training sessions. Translating the steps also made the participants feel involved and at the same time familiar with the social skills instructions. For moral reasoning, we used similar procedures, designing new moral dilemmas together with our students. The everyday-life situations reflect problems close to our young people’s reality. The more they recognize the situations and relate to them, the livelier the discussions. We recommend these and similar innovative procedures to ART facilitators in order to adapt ART to their particular youth groups, making training interesting, understandable, and involving. Active participation of the trainees, acknowledging their potential and ability to learn, and adjusting the program to the age and social skill levels of the group made a significant difference. Working with aggressive, hyperactive youngsters in various environments helped us also to realize the importance of group rules and routines. The rules we chose together with the trainees are simple and few in number, and the consequences of breaking them are clear and not negotiable. The rules are as follows: come on time; listen; raise your hand when you want to speak; and participate. These rules stand for showing respect, and the consequences of breaking them are explained and repeated at the beginning of every training session. For example, not coming on time results in non-attendance. We strictly enforce this rule, which supports the training of planning ahead skills and eliminates time-consuming explanations. Most of our youth are very skillful at creatively explaining the reasons for their behavior (coming late) and do not need additional training in this skills area. The consequences of breaking other rules vary from apologizing to the group, to showing respect by leaving the training. It is important to mention that all rules apply equally to the trainees and the trainers. This rigid and predictable structure helps reduce disruptive behavior and allows high levels of activity, tempo, and participation, so making ART an interesting and involving experience. The social skills sessions are also more efficient and interesting if they allow the trainees the
114 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
freedom of “showing off” their social skills and improvising the role-plays based on recent events in their lives. ART may sometimes prove difficult to “sell” to the youth who require it the most. The obstacles appear in the form of low motivation and resistance. However, the problems can sometimes equally depend on our own lack of confidence, inexperience, fears or habits. Working with ART makes us aware that we need to re-examine and perhaps change the ways we act and react in our relationships with our respective colleagues and students. ART provides an excellent tool for these personal changes. We often use role-playing and feedback in resolving our own, “grown-up” conflicts and problems within the organization. It provides us with opportunities to improve our coaching skills and at the same time with the experience of being a trainee. The results of such training are indeed remarkable and definitely worth the effort. “START” with ART by living the way you teach! In addition to a respectful and trusting relationship between trainers and trainees, successful ART programs require safe environments. It is desirable that everyone involved in ART, especially the trainers and transfer coaches, is adequate at performing the social skills and displaying anger management, and not only during the training sessions, but also in real-life situations: this ability comes with time and training. The extreme youngsters we deal with are highly sensitive to our sincerity and credibility; if they sense we doubt what we teach, or fail to produce the skills in real life, there is no way we can convince them that ART is good for them. The more confident the trainer, the better the results. The trainertraining program provides an excellent start to building up such competence and confidence.
THE TRAINER-TRAINING/APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM Our trainer-training program, developed in consultation with Dr Goldstein and in collaboration with colleagues and partners within ICART, is a six-month part-time course. It involves seven days of group training, two days of ART trainer-network meetings, and 15 training sessions practice (each session consists of two 45-minute classes). After completion of the course and passing the theoretical and practical exams, the ART Trainer Certificate is issued. The program is being used to train ART trainers in Sweden, Norway, and Poland, and is a part of a university postgraduate ART course at the Ragaland College in Norway. We hope that this program will become one of the models for training ART trainers elsewhere and set a standard for training programs across Europe. The sixmonth, part-time program is primarily designed for teachers, youth counselors, social workers, and personnel with experience of working with aggressive youth. It may, however, equally suit others without formal education, but with similar experience and leadership skills. The program for schools and youth agencies starts with a one-day workshop for the entire staff. Everyone involved plays an important role in ART, as a role model, trainer or a transfer coach. It is absolutely crucial that the skills acquired in training are reinforced when actually displayed in real-life situations. The workshop provides information about the goals, training procedures, and duration of
UNGDOMSALTERNATIVET—THE YOUTH ALTERNATIVE 115
the program together with instructions in how everyone can be supportive. It also makes the staff aware of what personal and professional skills and qualities are required to become a successful ART trainer. The one-day workshops provide an opportunity to discuss problems and, it is hoped, agree upon common solutions. It is our experience that these workshops are useful and appreciated, and result in several staff volunteering for our trainer-training program. The future ART coaches bring to our workshops their experiences and expertise. The practical exercises aim at training leadership skills and strengthening their competence and confidence to initiate and maintain ART programs. Someone once said, “Tell me and I will forget; show me and I will remember; let me do it and I will learn.” The trainer-training program is designed to let the participants do most of the learning and work, emphasizing practical skills and leadership training. The theoretical segment consists of self-studies of ART literature and answering related questions during the course and at the final exam. The program is a result of our trial and error experiences over the years and it has been tested in training ART coaches within our organization. The opinions and ideas of our young trainers together with our previous experiences have helped to develop the program and keep it up to date. We teach only what we have experienced first hand, either with youth groups or in coaching young trainers. The seven-day training program starts with a four-day get-together. (These first four days can sometimes be divided into two meetings within a fortnight, giving the participants a chance to digest new information and reflect on the practiced skills.) During these days we concentrate on leadership skills, presentation of ART to youth, and ways of motivating the participants, rules, training, and feedback procedures, modeling, role-playing, and documentation. We practice and conduct exercises in two of the ART components, social skills and anger control. After this initial meeting the training continues at home (workplaces), where each candidate is required to conduct 15 training sessions as a head coach and send the documentation to us for evaluation. This section of the program allows the participants time to gather valuable experience, and to initiate and evaluate ART programs as well as discuss them with colleagues and make plans for the future. These experiences are exchanged and discussed during the first day of the following two-day gathering, which is predominantly devoted to finding solutions to any problems that occurred and refreshing the role-playing and modeling skills. Trainees exchange their experiences with each other and receive coaching and advice from experienced master trainers. The trainer manual is our course literature (in addition to the ART book) and contains exercise instructions together with useful hints, based on our experience and reflecting our personal approach to ART. In some cases, this approach needs to be modified by trainers to suit their target groups, as for example with younger children, school classes, and large groups, or youth with lesser skill deficiencies. The training offers a solid foundation on which to build successful ART programs. The exercises aim to improve behavior management skills, to show what motivates the youth, how few rules are needed, what personal and professional qualities the ART trainer should display, and how to keep the tempo and flow in the role-plays and feedbacks. Thus, the exercises are designed to resemble the actual training procedure, with two participants acting as coaches and the rest playing the parts of trainees.
116 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
One of the opening exercises is, for example, answering questions such as: Who am I? Why do I enjoy working with youth? Why do people like me? What am I good at? What would I like to train (develop) more? The participants receive feedback to help them become aware of their body language, overall impression, and what can be done differently. It makes the future ART trainers aware of how they can improve their skills by training and what level of active involvement and participation is required of them throughout the course. At the same time, it is an introduction to the training and evaluation procedures used during training. This and many other exercises have been designed to help participants feel at ease with performing in front of the group (modeling) and become familiar with training procedures (role-playing, feedback). The trainees team up in pairs for most of these exercises, preparing for the roles of main coach and assisting ART coaches. In some cases they have time to prepare, in others they have to improvise (a skill often needed in real-life ART), and comments from the observers are first allowed during the feedback. We attempt to play down our role as coaches throughout the workshop, limiting our engagement to instructing the exercises and giving feedback, thus modeling the trainer behavior we recommend in youth groups. Most of the training time is devoted to practicing skills, the same way as should be done in actual training. We call this important rule 25–75, meaning that the trainers should take no more then one-quarter of the training time for instructions, feedback, motivation or managing disciplinary problems. The remaining three-quarters of the time should be devoted to role-playing and feedback by the trainees, making them feel involved and maintaining their interest and energy levels. Our motto is: Of a good leader, who talks little, When his work is done, his aim fulfilled, They will say, “We did this ourselves” (Tao Te Ching)
We model this approach in our trainer workshops. Difficult as it may be at times, we practice giving short instructions and asking relevant questions, so encouraging and allowing the students to do all the talking and acting. Minimizing our active participation as coaches and role models has, in our experience, given the best results both with youth groups and in trainer training. We know from the positive feedback that this makes our trainer training an active and stimulating experience. The positive feedback confirms the even greater need for practical exercises in preparing for work with actual ART groups. The three criteria for successful completion of the trainer training are: (1) participation in seven days of group training and exercises, (2) 15 documented sessions as ART trainer (main coach), and (3) passing of a written test and demonstration of leadership skills during the final day. The trainer workshops inspire new ideas for our ART youth groups and vice versa. For example, we often switch roles of trainees and coaches in our youth groups (as we do in our trainer workshops), particularly when concentration and participation levels are low. The role changing provides a challenge and responsibility and is, in our experience, an efficient way of strengthening the motivation of participants and the efficacy of training. This strategy not only allows the youth to
UNGDOMSALTERNATIVET—THE YOUTH ALTERNATIVE 117
model the alternative behaviors for each other, but also increases the likelihood of these skills being used and accepted (transferred) in real-life situations. Over the years, Ungdomsalternativet has trained over 200 ART coaches in Sweden and a number of facilitators and master trainers in Poland. These coaches in turn develop and implement their trainer-training program on the basis of ours. We see a growing demand for ART trainers in schools and youth agencies, as well as qualified and experienced master trainers who can train new coaches and supervise the programs. Developing a master trainer program and standards for active trainers (with at least one year’s ART experience) will help further promote the method and maintain a high standard of trainer education. ART trainers who completed our training and have long experience of working with youth groups expressed a desire to partake in such master trainer courses. The majority of ART trainers who completed our training program are currently involved in different ART projects and are reporting positive results. We maintain close contact with them within the ART trainer network and encourage the exchange of ideas and experiences by organizing network meetings twice a year. We also act as consultants supervising several ART school projects currently in progress in Malmo’s ¨ primary schools. The Ungdomsalternativet coaches conduct workshops, seminars, and presentations on ART and related subjects for schools, youth care institutions, the mass media, and social authorities.
JUNIOR ART TRAINERS One of the obstacles new ART trainers encounter is persuading the young people they work with to participate in the training. To counter this apathy, talking about the young people’s personal development, respect for others, improved school results, making parents happy, and staying out of arguments are often successful. From our experience, presenting ART as an opportunity of becoming a junior ART trainer and a role model for others has proved to be most effective. This approach helps introduce new trainees to ART and gives those who have trained for some time the motivation to proceed, and it gives the most impatient or restless participants a chance to act, show off their skills, and model the behavior for others instead of initiating discussions that sometimes serve the purpose of avoiding the training. What is more, it allows them to start the training from their actual social competence level and train purposely to achieve concrete goals. The young people we work with are often better at doing things than talking about them, so that letting them take over the role of trainer both displays their ability to perform social skills and helps them accept critical feedback. This in turn increases their motivation to participate in training. ART provides young people with a second chance of becoming good at something positive. Becoming a junior ART trainer inspires motivation to work hard and is an important, achievable goal. At the end of the day, it does not matter if the goal is actually achieved; the benefits of training are still there. The youth at risk of going away to institutions often complain that they are forced to participate in ART, so their attitude toward training is consequently very negative. We respond to that situation by giving them positive motivation and describing
118 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
tangible goals they can achieve through training, and becoming a junior ART trainer is one such important goal. It has helped many of our trainees stay with the program for over two years. The most experienced junior ART trainers conduct the training sessions as main or assisting coaches, act as positive role models and motivators, and help us present ART and train professionals during our trainer-training courses. Their feedback and modeling serve as an eye opener to many, and help relieve the doubts and anxieties sometimes displayed by future ART facilitators. The more competent the trainers are at displaying social skills and anger management in realistic situations, the more positive response they get in training. We believe that most of the youth are often just as skillful in displaying these qualities (at least in role-plays) as “professional trainers,” given the opportunity and encouragement. The young people’s modeling, role-playing, and respecting the rules is an example to others, enhances transferring of skills into real-life situations, and increases their acceptance among peers.
THE SIX-MONTH FULL-TIME ART TRAINING PROGRAM Both research and experience confirm that the more youth can identify with role models, the stronger their influence. The most significant role models for teenagers are often their peers, or older youngsters sharing similar backgrounds, experiences, and problems. Since the majority of the youth we work with are from ethnic minorities, it is also desirable and beneficial if we can match those minorities among our staff. By that we mean not only matching their nationality, language or religion, but even more importantly by sharing common experiences of being (or regarding themselves as) outsiders and underdogs in the society. Young role models that youth can look up to and identify with will make it easier to “sell” positive and prosocial ideas to their younger colleagues. It is important that we reach out and involve these role models, help them become skillful ART trainers and, via training and supervision, assist them in their work with youth at risk. By doing this, we also help these young people. Some of them, unemployed or undecided about their choice of vocation, find a meaningful and rewarding occupation and become aware of a myriad of possibilities in education and employment while at the same time developing their own qualities and helping others. Ungdomsalternativet has developed a six-month full-time training/apprenticeship program, offering young unemployed and motivated youth an opportunity to study and practice under supervision to become ART trainers. The schools and social services often express the need for people capable of working with difficultto-reach, aggressive youth. These young ART trainers and role models can help teachers and youth workers, hold ART sessions, and act as transfer coaches by positively influencing younger children at school and during free-time activities. From our personal experiences, they not only make the training more realistic and acceptable to the adolescents, but also increase the chances that the trained social skills will be used outside of ART classes. We have been very successful in working with young ART trainers within our organization and strongly believe in this model. The first two youth ART trainers who successfully completed our six-month program received employment as ART trainer and teacher assistant in one of the special
UNGDOMSALTERNATIVET—THE YOUTH ALTERNATIVE 119
schools in Malmo. ¨ This educational project is supported by the state employment agencies and received recognition and funds from the European Union supporting its development. The program effectively involves and influences both aggressive youth and the young people entering the workforce, helping in integration of both groups in society.
THE YOUTH ALTERNATIVES ART is about role-playing, modeling, positive reinforcement, and transfer, but most of all it is about choices and alternatives. “I didn’t have a choice, I had to hit him,” or “He made me so angry I didn’t know what to do”: how often do we hear these and similar explanations from our youth? In stressful situations, under group pressure from peers, responding to provocation, they often feel as if they have no choice. It’s about “respect,” “keeping face,” and teaching the provoker a lesson (“so he won’t do it again!”). “Do you really think that fighting is wrong?” “Didn’t you ever fight yourself?” “Wouldn’t you fight if someone attacked your family?” These are frequently asked questions. The best answer we can come up with is: “Yes, I did fight,” or “Yes, I would defend my family,” but in most everyday-life situations I have choices and alternatives. “Choice” and “alternative”—these two words are very often used in our ART groups. If someone gets into a fight (which happens now and then), they typically say, “I chose to hit him because I couldn’t control my anger and choose the right alternative!” not “I had to hit him because he made me mad!” The ART trainees also ask and discuss: “What can I do differently in a similar situation next time around?” The significant difference is not only in the choice of vocabulary, but also in understanding what is happening, analyzing the reasons as well as accepting the responsibility for the choice of action. Having a choice, being “in control,” and avoiding the same mistakes gives the youth a feeling of confidence and competence. Being “rewarded” for choosing the right alternatives further reinforces that feeling and, with time, it is hoped, makes “good behavior” a habit. Our youth coaches help the youngsters make these choices by providing alternatives through modeling and role-playing, being good role models, and reinforcing positive behavior. From our experience, it does not have to be more difficult than that! Realizing and confirming the youth’s potential, showing a good example, paying attention, reacting to antisocial behaviors, and rewarding changes works miracles. We often expect “well-trained” aggressive children to change quickly and permanently, but unfortunately in most cases this does not happen. The most important and lasting change we can accomplish is that our youngsters know and feel they have a choice. We have been involved in this work for almost four years now and the organization has gradually grown, attracting new co-workers and creating new ideas and projects. Today, we work directly with youth at risk in Malmo, ¨ through ART programs in schools and communities and in our special school project. We also work with older youth, training them to become ART trainers, supervising their work, and opening new possibilities of employment. We train and supervise professional youth workers and teachers throughout the country and abroad through our
120 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
trainer-training workshops. Our training program is part of a postgraduate ART course at a university in Norway and is a model for similar courses in Sweden and Poland. We are involved in nationwide and international ART networks, exchanging experiences with our friends and colleagues in the United States and Europe. We are developing training procedures and educational materials, improving our methods of training, and sharing information about ART with others. We document and evaluate our own efforts and encourage evaluations of ART programs elsewhere. This has all happened in a short period of time, and motivating and rewarding ourselves has been a most important part of our experience. Working with often vulnerable young people stimulates our own personal and professional skills and “recharges” our energy reservoirs. Rewarding ourselves (a social skill that many of us need to practice!) and enjoying every little success (catching ourselves being good) are important components of that process. We strongly believe that we need to feel good, positive, and satisfied within our private and professional lives before we can help others and make a real difference. “Sacrificing” our own well-being for others seldom works in the long run. We would like to share this simple advice with our professional colleagues: take good care of yourselves and each other and make a serious attempt at “Living the way we teach!” ART has profoundly developed our personal and professional skills over these past years. Our performance as role models and trainers has improved dramatically since we started practicing as ART trainers. So has our ability to interact with others within and outside of the organization. We are more aware of our behavior towards each other and what influences it has on our young followers. Only by experiencing hands-on training can we be successful in changing the behavior of our youth. Only by living the way we teach can we ask and expect them to follow in our path.
Chapter 8
THE OASIS—A LIVING IDEA RUNE NENSE´ N AND NIKOLAI HAMSTEIN Barnhemmet Oasen, Aneby, Sweden
INTRODUCTION The Oasis, located in Aneby, southern Sweden, was founded by Rune Nens´en, a social worker with experience of public social services. For the past ten years, The Oasis has been a residential and treatment facility providing shelter and services for children aged 0–13 years, as well as for families with young children. Swedish law permits children to be removed from the home and placed in foster care when home/family conditions are deemed to be a threat to the children’s welfare. The Oasis offers an alternative to foster care, whereby children, and often the entire family, are invited to move to The Oasis for an extended period of evaluation and intervention. Beginning in 1991 with 13 beds, the organization has constantly grown and developed. Today The Oasis consists of a family unit and a children’s unit, with a total of 48 beds. The children’s unit is located on a beautiful farm five kilometers outside of Aneby. A preschool and primary school have also been founded within the framework of The Oasis organization; however, in some cases children attend the local public schools. Working in cooperation with the social services of more than 80 cities in Sweden, The Oasis has dealt with a large number of referrals with different needs and backgrounds. The Oasis has invested in highly competent personnel, with long experience of social evaluation and treatment. Fundamental to the daily work of The Oasis are a holistic approach to each individual, respect for each client, professional behavior, scientifically sound methods, and an adequate level of decisiveness.
PROGRAM DESCRIPTION The facility provides several different services, depending on the referring agency inquiry, such as assessments/investigations or more long-term treatment. An New Perspectives on Aggression Replacement Training: Practice, Research, and Application. C 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Edited by A. P. Goldstein, R. Nens´en, B. Daleflod, and M. Kalt.
122 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
individual treatment plan is always established for each child or family throughout the length of stay in The Oasis program. The assessment can be done from a social, medical, psychiatric, and/or psychological perspective according to the specifics of the referral. This may include a total responsibility for The Oasis to assess a child or parent/child, or it may mean that The Oasis provides parts of the assessment. The treatment takes place in a home-like setting with an emphasis on the holistic approach to the individual. A case manager is also assigned to the child, or family, throughout the length of stay. The goal is to improve the relationship between child and parent, or careprovider/fosterparent, i.e. an adult significant to the continued development of the child. In the effort to improve and strengthen relationships, as well as change behavior, ART, which includes Skillstreaming, anger control training, and moral reasoning, is a very successful tool. ART is therefore used both within the family and in parent groups. Criteria for placements vary. Common to all placements is that the relationship between parent and child is dysfunctional in some way, i.e. inability or social problems, with the result that the parents cannot adequately care for their child. Families with social and/or psychological problems, developmental disabilities, or young mothers with newborn babies have priority in The Oasis program. Thus, The Oasis is also a treatment facility for children aged 0–13 years without parents. Depending on the specifics of the referral, The Oasis program may include a period of assessment for a child as well.
PURPOSE OF THE OASIS PROGRAM The purpose of The Oasis program is to be a resource for agencies when they need a residential treatment program or a period of assessment within a residential program for children aged 0–13 or for a parent and child together. This is at times due to high-risk situations, and other times it is impossible to assess the situation unless a 24 hour/day observation takes place. The Oasis has “round-the-clock” staffing, which enables emergency placements. The purposes of The Oasis program for families and children are to:
r assist and support families with specific needs (in crises); r rehabilitate and establish a functioning and positive influence within the family relationship by utilizing ART, among other intervention methods;
r prevent families from separation when there are possibilities for them to stay together;
r during a period of assessment make sure that families with specific needs receive the most helpful treatment for a positive change of their life situation;
r provide agencies with a written report on issues which are included in the treatment plan and requested from referral agencies;
r work according to The Oasis ethical values and Swedish law; r work with parent and child during a process of separation when separation is necessary;
r establish a long-term treatment plan, emphasizing the ART curriculum, for children who are in The Oasis program without parents;
THE OASIS—A LIVING IDEA 123
r strive toward ART generalization by supporting and training foster parents when a child is ready to move from The Oasis to a foster home;
r work together with the foster parents during the time of change and separation for the child.
GOALS DESCRIPTION OF THE OASIS PROGRAM Service Concept The staff’s work shall be founded on a holistic approach to each individual, scientific theory, and tested experience. Evaluation shall be impartial, objective, and thorough, describing the individual’s needs in accordance with the holistic approach. Observation and treatment shall be carried out in such a way that the individual’s own resources and initiatives are put to use for the description of the individual’s need of help/support in accordance with the social services law. Evaluation always involves treatment, where ART has become a primary tool.
Scientific Theory The theoretical foundation for The Oasis evaluation and treatment is both a psychodynamic and cognitive perspective. The actual evaluation and treatment work is carried out in a home-like setting (environment therapy). Environment therapy is a model of society at large, but on a small scale and in safe and secure surroundings, which takes into consideration and develops the individual’s social, physical, and psychological needs.
Proven Experience The organization shall strive for constant development through regular continued education and work-related guidance. Continued education shall regard the organization’s field as well as current related laws.
Holistic Approach The total needs and resources of each individual shall be seen and identified. This approach is taken into consideration when employing personnel, so that relevant professional categories, such as social workers, nurses, child care workers, preschool teachers, teachers, office personnel, psychiatrists, child psychologists, and maintenance and housekeeping personnel are available.
Relationships The personnel shall make an effort to establish good relations with clients even in difficult situations. Personnel are obliged to professional secrecy. Clients shall
124 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
Board Rune Nensén CEO and chairman of the board
Samuel Fransson
Ewa Jungbeck
Kajsa Samuelsson
Director, children’s unit
Director, family unit
Director, assessment
Figure 8.1 The organization of The Oasis
be informed that journals are kept and told how information is treated. Personnel shall actively inform clients of their rights. Personnel shall not in any way take advantage of clients’ dependent situation. Personnel shall respect and support the individual’s right to personal integrity and self-determination.
Locale An important goal for The Oasis has been to provide practical and pleasant locales for the work at hand. Provision of an environment which is as home-like as possible aids in achieving a positive treatment result.
ORGANIZATION The Oasis (Barnhemmet Oasen AB) was in 1991 officially granted permission to operate a private residential treatment facility for care and shelter. A board of professionals leads The Oasis, and Rune Nens´en is chairman of the board and CEO for The Oasis. As shown in Figure 8.1, there is a director for each unit, as well as a director for the evaluation work. The Oasis employs more than 80 personnel. The Oasis leadership group meets regularly in order to discuss relevant questions regarding the evaluation and treatment work. In addition, a morning meeting is held on a daily basis, where those in charge of different areas of the organization can discuss important issues and make relevant decisions. Service-mindedness and decisiveness characterize the work of The Oasis. The staff are The Oasis’ most important resource. The Oasis personnel are aided in their evaluation and treatment work by hired consultants within different areas of expertise. This enables the referring agency to receive service of higher competency according to the individual needs of each client and the specifics of the referral.
CLIENTELE During its first 10 years of existence, The Oasis received more than 200 families of varying sizes and backgrounds. Families with children, and preferably young children, make up The Oasis’ main target group. The following is a description
THE OASIS—A LIVING IDEA 125
of the families’ size, background, etc. based upon our data between 1991 and 2001. More than one-half of the families have only one parent (most often the mother), whereas the others consist of living-together relationships or marriage. Family size varies from one to seven children per family. More than 80% of the families are Swedish, while the others are immigrants or Swedes with immigrant backgrounds. The average age of adult clients is 35 years for men and 30 years for women. The average age of child clients is five years. The average treatment period since the Oasis began is four to five months. Contact with families may be voluntarily with the support of the social services law, or compulsory as families are legally required to take part in The Oasis program.
Diagnosis at the Time of Admission More than 50% of the clientele is made up of individuals with some form of social incapacity. Examples of other problems which have warranted treatment include physical and/or mental abuse, psychological illness, mental handicap, and sexual abuse.
Treatment Results Approximately one-half of the families have been able to move home with their children, with or without support in the home, after their stay at The Oasis. In nine out of ten cases, the social services and courts of law heed the recommendations of The Oasis evaluation.
INSTITUTIONAL CARE 2001 AND ONWARD It appears that the social services have a growing tendency to wait longer before placing clients in institutions. This delay means that The Oasis becomes involved in cases very late, when a family’s and/or a child’s problems have increased and become more complex. Beginning evaluation and treatment at a late stage always makes practical care more difficult, and achievement of good results takes much longer. Politicians and decision makers often have the incorrect notion that hesitating to make the decision to evaluate/treat a family in an institution can save money. The evaluation and treatment period simply becomes longer and more expensive for those families who are forced to wait. In the worst possible case, the failure to act promptly might mean that a family in crisis would have their children taken from them for social care or placement in a foster home, perhaps even for the rest of their life. Seen from this perspective, it is both more humane and economical to begin care and treatment as early as possible.
CASE MANAGEMENT During evaluation at The Oasis, the child’s and the family’s situation, both past and present, are described. This work can also be seen as a process whereby alternatives
126 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
to earlier problem-solving methods are tested and evaluated. In this context, ART for families is an important method of intervention. Through ART, families are encouraged and supported in their attempt to use alternative, more successful ways to relate to themselves and others.The goal of the evaluation process with a holistic approach is to gain a clear understanding of the family’s/individual’s future possibilities. The holistic approach demands a broad competency. The development of the organization during the past ten years has been influenced by experience, which has created greater and new areas of competency. Certainly the future of the Oasis will be characterized by continued development through more finely tuned evaluation methods, increased competency, and use of relevant research material.
EVALUATION TASK The task of evaluation is formed by the referring agency at the start of the evaluation process and can vary from case to case. The planned evaluation tasks are often preceded by study visits and careful planning. Other evaluation tasks are acute, and admission to The Oasis happens before task planning can occur. The referring agency’s inquiry is always presented to The Oasis in writing. The most common subjects for evaluation of parents in The Oasis program regard parental capacity: this might involve which roles exist in the family, parents’ relationships to their children, the parents’ capacity for showing emotion or setting limits, interaction between parents and between parents and children, parental capacity to put children’s needs before their own needs, and suggestions for future solutions.
EVALUATION The treatment personnel’s gathering of data makes up an important part of the family’s/child’s social description. Moreover, a description of the parent’s own life history is written by the evaluator, using the K¨alvesten method while interviewing during the case evaluation. A social worker responsible for a given case coordinates other evaluation inputs in the case. Doctors and nurses at The Oasis take responsibility for the medical aspect of the evaluation. For each case, an examining psychiatrist at The Oasis also makes a report. Children are judged according to different tests performed by The Oasis child psychologist. Such judgments make up an important part of the foundation for a holistic approach to the case. Preschool teachers at The Oasis own preschool have unique opportunities to observe the children and thereby contribute to the evaluation process. An average evaluation takes approximately three months. A team of personnel with different areas of expertise meet each week in order to share information regarding each case. This eventually results in a comprehensive case picture and determination of how the case work should best continue. In order to gain a comprehensive understanding of each case, the different areas of expertise constantly interact with each other and communication in conjunction is of extreme importance to a successful evaluation period. Most of those who are being processed at The Oasis for an evaluation would rather not be there and parents
THE OASIS—A LIVING IDEA 127
are very aware of their grave situation. For these reasons, the situation demands great respect, but also complete honesty and unveiling of relevant problem areas. Continued openness and communication with parents and children regarding the evaluation process is important during the entire evaluation period.
ADMISSION An admission meeting is led by the social worker responsible for evaluation together with a case contact person, who will thereafter be the link between The Oasis personnel and the referring agency for the duration of the evaluation period. During the admission meeting parents are informed of the following: that parents remain responsible for their children during their stay at The Oasis; about the case contact person and how this system can be of assistance; the weekly and daily schedules; details about time off, visits, and possible restrictions; matters of privacy/professional secrecy; the evaluation process and any other information that is required. All information is also presented to the family in writing together with the names of the social worker responsible for their case and their contact person, as well as an invitation to an in-school meeting at the preschool if relevant. The most important part of the admission meeting is summed up by the question “Why did you come here?” In more than half of all cases the client’s answer is “I/we didn’t want to come here, but the social worker wanted us to.” The next question is naturally “Why do you think the social worker wanted you to come here?” Sometimes this question is answered very concretely, while in other cases the clients may need more detailed questions in order to give a clear answer. Some clients maintain that the evaluation and stay at The Oasis are unnecessary; others say that they have never understood how their parental capacity is deficient, even though they have had a long history of contact with different support personnel. In conjunction with this clarification it is often suitable to allow the referring agency to explain the situation and questions involved. Directness, honesty, and clarity regarding the case situation are important for the parents’ understanding, the prevention of later surprises or confusion, and the improvement of communication during the evaluation period. At this point, many parents are able to express their fears of parental insufficiency and loss of their children. Here it is important to maintain a professional stance, not making promises, but giving hope that improvement of parental capacity is always possible, and that The Oasis personnel are devoted to assisting in such an improvement. Parents are also informed that no evaluation report leaves The Oasis before it is thoroughly discussed by the responsible social worker together with the parents. This occasion provides an opportunity to correct possible misunderstandings or to add their own opinions about certain occurrences. The admission meeting therefore has the purpose of getting the family’s/child’s evaluation period at The Oasis off to a good start by creating personal contact, giving hope for the evaluation, clarifying the task ahead by asking questions, recognizing the parents’ own level of understanding regarding problems and possibilities, recognizing the parents’ own level of motivation, providing a foundation for how The Oasis personnel should plan the evaluation period, and determining
128 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
the evaluation period’s duration, as well as planning treatment conferences. In the event that the admission meeting is preceded by an acute and/or chaotic event, the family/child should have the opportunity to receive crisis support before questions about the possible evaluation take shape.
ASSESSMENT STRUCTURE Social Content Everyday life at The Oasis provides unique possibilities to notice how parents and children deal with different situations. Besides support and counsel, the staff’s most important task is to observe what parents and/or children do, as well as how their personalities are expressed. The staff’s collective observation creates an understanding of the family/child and forms the basis for ideas about how a positive development can be achieved. Observations are made on a daily basis and noted in a diary. Personnel are provided with regular continued education regarding objective observational skills. It is extremely important that the theme of objectivity is kept in focus, since different personnel understandably do not have the same ideals of how parents should or should not behave. Observation of parents and/or children in different situations does not occur passively. In reality, the personnel contribute to the development of positive interaction and make observations thereby. Consequently, no evaluation visit is regarded to be entirely for evaluation, but also for interaction, influence, intervention, and a certain measure of personally tailored approach from the personnel. Typically, the observations would include the following: practical routines such as meals, sleep, bed times, good-night stories, and homework; expression of feelings within the family and individually; setting of limits within the family; predictability within the family; how interaction within the family functions; how identity, self-understanding, and defense mechanisms are expressed in the family; family patterns; and other subjects specific for the evaluation task. Daily routines at The Oasis are made up of a firm structure, the value of which cannot be over-emphasized. Relationships between clients and personnel are also established, with all the implications of making acquaintance, testing, and separation. Within the frames of these relationships, the client can regress, express himself/herself, imitate, and eventually relate to the personnel. Parallel to the daily routines, an inventory of parents’ lives and interaction is made by the social worker responsible for each case. Everyday situations become the topic of evaluation meetings, providing possibilities for greater understanding. Other practical problems, which arise during the program, can also be given immediate attention.
Psychiatric Content The Oasis psychiatrists meet with the parents as soon as possible after admission, which most often means during the clients’ first week at The Oasis. The psychiatric assessment is made after several meetings, based partially on the information
THE OASIS—A LIVING IDEA 129
regarding everyday behavior, which is presented each week during an overall treatment conference. Some parents show no personality disturbances, and assessment meetings are limited to one or two. The resulting psychiatric assessment contributes to the final overall assessment, and is presented as a separate attachment to the final evaluation report.
Medical Content The Oasis doctors examine parents and, if necessary, each child as a part of admission. In some cases, a doctor’s certificate is required for forced-care application. Other reasons for medical examination include suspected child abuse, anorexia, sexual abuse, allergies, and asthma. During the evaluation visit, The Oasis doctors are available three days per week for emergency care. The physician can either give medical care or refer clients to other medical experts. Nurses are also available every weekday. Maternity examinations are made at the local maternity clinic. The availability of medical professionals is also of great assistance in the case of psychosomatic illnesses. The medical assessment of possible illnesses, handicap, etc. and their consequences makes up an important part of the final overall assessment.
Child Psychological Content The Oasis child psychologists make developmental assessments, personal evaluation tests, family relations tests, etc., according to the inquiries of the referring agency. The child psychologist meets the youngest children together with their parents and explains the purpose of the meeting. When tests are completed (parents are present during tests) and results available, the child psychologist goes through the results together with the parents. Older children take tests in the absence of their parents. However, parents are kept informed both before and after testing. The child psychologist also performs therapy for the purpose of treatment.
School Content The Oasis preschool has its own local, experienced personnel, with preschool teachers and recreation leaders responsible for preschool activities. The preschool is open for three hours each morning all year round and comprises five rooms for different activities, such as arts and crafts, reading, playing, water games, and use of computers. The children mainly range in age from three to six years, and the number of children varies from three to eight, with an average of five. The preschool’s program is made up of personal development through the use of motor skills, language, and social, everyday behavior. We have noticed that children need limited stimulation in order to develop properly so the locales are simple and the activities limited and adjusted to a somewhat slower pace. The preschool teacher always writes a personal statement, which is attached to the main evaluation. This statement describes the child’s motor-skill development, language and speaking development, social skills, as well as parents’ contact with
130 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
the preschool personnel. The preschool provides a good opportunity to see how the children interact with other children and adults. In each case, the parents have an in-school meeting before the child begins preschool. Parents are responsible for getting their child to preschool and providing suitable clothes and a snack. At the conclusion of the child’s preschooling, information is given to the parents regarding the preschool teacher’s statement for the main evaluation. Each child celebrates a “graduation ceremony” upon conclusion of their stay, and takes with them a folder full of their own creative work at the preschool. The Oasis preschool provides a unique opportunity for stimulation and development of children during their evaluation visit. The older children go to the local public schools, which are in the same neighborhood as The Oasis. After several years of cooperation with the public schools, parents and teachers of other children have learned that The Oasis children need this school as part of their routine, which remains stable, even when it seems difficult to gain a perspective on other parts of life. For school children aged 7–13 years and with special needs and/or learning disabilities, The Oasis provides, in cooperation with the city of Aneby, a small school located at the children’s unit, Karlsborg. There, a specialist teacher and two assistants are responsible for the work. In-school and conclusion meetings are conducted together with the parents and responsible evaluator. This often provides an opportunity for contact with former or future teachers. The schools’ specialist teachers meet with The Oasis evaluation personnel on a regular basis. Once per year the public schools’ teachers are invited to The Oasis where they are provided with relevant information and given the chance to discuss problems which may have arisen during the school year. Statements from the preschool and grade schools make up an important part of the final overall assessment.
THE FINAL PHASE OF THE EVALUATION When all areas of competency have contributed with their conclusions, results are discussed and woven together to form a clear understanding from a holistic point of view. Continued individual planning is based on this overall assessment. The final assessment is made approximately two weeks before the end of the threemonth period, which is the normal length of an assessment period. Parents in the program go through the assessment together with personnel from the different areas of competency, and in the final phase, together with the social worker responsible for the case. At this point parents are given the opportunity to clear up possible misunderstandings, add to the assessment, ask questions, or agree with the assessment. Once the parents have seen the assessment, it is sent to the responsible social worker from the referring agency, where all parties are prepared for the final assessment conference. In cases where the family moves back home, the social worker is given a short time to create resources for extra support if necessary. It is, however, important that the final assessment conference not only sums up the assessment period, but also serves as a hopeful new start regarding possibilities for change which lie ahead for the family. A special afternoon farewell party for the family is also of great importance.
THE OASIS—A LIVING IDEA 131
In cases where the final assessment recommends that the children be separated from the parents, entirely different processes are set in motion. This assessment recommendation almost always causes a crisis for the parents, typically expressed through tears, anger, despair, and chaotic questioning. Through years of experience, The Oasis personnel have gained a valuable understanding of crisis reactions, and the entire staff is thoroughly prepared when such assessment recommendations are presented. It is extremely important that the parents receive care, however, within reasonable limits. It can often be tempting to try to comfort a parent, since identification as a parent may be strong. Therefore, it is important to be there for the parents, but to keep reality in perspective. After a while, when the acute crisis phase has passed, parents begin to question the competency of the staff, accuse them of heartlessness, and finally ask, “What happens now?” For many parents the legal process is extremely difficult to understand. If the responsible social agency decides to sue for forced custody, The Oasis personnel assist the parents with legal information and support surrounding negotiations. In such difficult situations, it is important that where the family has older children, they are informed and given an informal opportunity to react and ask questions. It is not unusual for children to feel a great responsibility for their parents, and have strong bonds of loyalty to them. Smaller children can also show reactions when parents, for obvious reasons, cannot function normally. When the responsible social worker informs us that a foster home has been appointed, the foster parents and natural parents normally meet first in an attempt to introduce cooperation. The natural parents need a great deal of support for such a meeting. The in-school process continues for a couple of weeks, according to an individually tailored plan, which counts on the constant involvement of the parents. Cooperation between the foster and natural parents as well as good schooling are essential conditions if the child is to have a peaceful and secure experience in the foster home. Periods of school should be followed by a period of frequent visits, which can later be adjusted to a more normal, regular visitation. It is also important for many children that the natural parents are taken care of and receive different kinds of support, since the child can no longer take care of the parents him/herself. From the child’s point of view, it is important that the parents receive help. For some parents, an assessment recommendation of separation between parents and children comes as a combination of sorrow and relief. For a long time, they have lacked the strength to be good enough parents. They have given this signal themselves by refusing to respond to open care assistance. Some parents even feel more satisfied with themselves as parents when they are parents for limited periods of time. Assessment work can be done in many different ways, and each family is unique. Personnel at The Oasis are often amazed at the amount of support many parents, despite lack of resources, can give their children in a foster home.
ART AT THE OASIS ART was first introduced at The Oasis in 1997 and has since grown in importance as an intervention method in the daily treatment work. The entire Oasis staff has been thoroughly educated in ART’s procedures and theoretical foundation. However, only certain personnel are designated group trainers for interpersonal
132 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
skillstreaming, anger control training, and moral reasoning. Group trainers have also taken the ART master course led by Professor Goldstein. ART is carried out in both the children’s unit for students enrolled in The Oasis school and in the daily treatment work, and in the family unit for families and for parent groups.
ART in the Family Unit Many of the families who come to The Oasis family unit arrive exhausted as a result of the situations they have been living in. The evaluation period is normally around three months in duration. However, most clients remain at The Oasis even after their evaluation period, while good feasible alternatives for the families are worked out. ART is a useful tool in both seeking the degree of change potential in the family, and in teaching new social skills. Many of the parents who have stayed with us at The Oasis have lacked clarity and limits in their own upbringing, which has in turn affected how they raise their own children. The goal of ART at the family unit is to give the clients new and better possibilities to mature and improve contact with their children and their surroundings. At the family unit we work with both adult/parent groups and with whole families. The parents begin in an ART group a week or so after admission and continue for their entire length of stay. Work with whole families begins within a few weeks of their admission. First it is important to observe the family for some time, gaining insight into how they function and what their needs are.
Family ART We have discovered that training with the whole family is a good forum for working with the problems specific to the family. During ART the family meets and works together with their own weaknesses and strengths. Before we start a group, the parents first fill out a checklist, estimating how adept they and the children are in using different social skills. Children can also fill out such checklists to the extent they are able to do so. Our starting point is then the family’s possibilities, and training begins in areas which the family is willing to change. Motivation to take part in the entire training session is increased, since they themselves have influenced the choice of social skill. After each training session participants are given a token, a star: accumulation of tokens after several ART sessions results in a reward for either the individual or the whole family.
BETTER COMMUNICATION One positive result of working with families is that they seem to discover a new language for communicating with each other. They gain knowledge of each others’ feelings, learn to wait their turn, and generally how to solve everyday conflicts. Training sessions with families vary a lot from family to family depending
THE OASIS—A LIVING IDEA 133
on specific conditions such as age, family size, and problem areas. However, the framework is the same and covers all three parts of ART, social skills training, anger control, and moral reasoning. Sessions take place regularly each week for the duration of the family’s stay at the family unit. Depending on the family’s situation, sessions range from a half-hour to an hour in length. In between sessions, families are given the task of practicing those skills which have been taught in the training sessions. This is done with the help of homework sheets. If the day’s session includes social skills training, then the session begins by going through the previous week’s homework. Secondly, the ART trainer introduces a new skill, and the family discusses its meaning, if they have heard of it, and how well they use it. The family and the ART trainer then discuss what they have done in different situations and how they can use the skill in order to do things differently. Role-playing is used in front of the trainer to practice for a similar situation. The whole family or relevant individuals take part in role-playing. Family members often play themselves, using the mode of expression that they would use in everyday situations. Afterwards the ART trainer goes through how well each step was used, giving feedback to all the participants.
ROLE-PLAYS ARE IMPORTANT Role-plays are made up almost entirely of situations from the family’s everyday life. Training to make a situation turn out differently and experiencing the resulting feelings and treatment is of great value for many families who are used to accumulated unsolved conflicts. At times some parents resist taking part in the training, wanting only the children, whom they consider to have the problem, to participate. We try to motivate the parents to be a part of the training by stressing the fact that the parents know the child best and can therefore influence the child to a high degree. The family is a living organism in which all parts affect each other. This means that if one part changes, something happens in the entire organism. It also means that families who make use of what they have learned in family ART become more dynamic. The father who learns to breathe deeply and find alternatives to his anger has an effect not only on himself, but the entire family. Taking part in ART as a family enables the family members to remind each other of what they have learned during the week, increasing the chances of generalization occurring in real life.
EXAMPLES OF FAMILY ART Some time ago we concluded family ART training with a family of five who had participated for approximately six months. The first sessions were concentrated on getting the three children, two of whom were boys diagnosed with DAMP (Deficits in Attention Motor Control and Perception) and ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder), to sit still with us in a circle on the floor. The parents were extremely tired of all the conflicts and outbursts of rage which had splintered the family. We began, therefore, with simple exercises which encouraged them to trust each other and relax and take time to think, in order to create unity in
134 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
the group. After a few weeks, we began to present the fundamentals of anger control and Skillstreaming, all on a very basic and easy level. We practiced the same exercises week after week, adding new skills little by little, while training anger control. During one of these sessions the mother in the group told how she had one afternoon been very irritated with one of her sons for not obeying her. The boy then said, “You have to do ART now! You have to breathe deeply!” On another occasion one of the sons, after being provoked by his brother, ran out onto the balcony shouting “I can’t breathe! I need some air!” When he returned to the rest of the family, he was calm. During the period in which the family regularly participated in training, we could see how the frequency of negative, aggressive behavior decreased, while the family, and mostly the parents, learned to reward positive behavior, which in time became more common. Mattias (false name), eight years of age, arrived at The Oasis with both of his parents a year or so ago. The family was desperate, since Mattias, with a high level of aggression and DAMP, had taken over the family and steered it completely. At home he had made enemies of most people and had difficulties with the social codes. He was very smart and self-focused, and saw no need to learn anything when the ten-week anger-control program began for him and his family. Most important at the outset was to observe what caused Mattias’ extreme anger, how he dealt with it, and what the consequences were. At first, the boy could not see anyone but himself while having an outburst of rage. What he knew was that he became exhausted after the outbursts. Mattias turned out to be very sensitive to external triggers, and we spoke often about these in order to find anger reducers that suited him. The weeks passed and little by little Mattias began to be aware of those around him during his outbursts of rage. In order to keep the reminders available to Mattias and his parents, the family chose to cut them out and keep them in their pockets. Wherever they were, they could quickly produce the reminders in case an outburst of rage seemed to be on its way. After approximately seven weeks, Mattias began to respond to the training: he had learned alternatives to anger outbursts and was now and again successful in using them; he had also begun to notice that others around him reacted negatively to his anger, his friends left him, and his parents were tired and sad. This discovery also led in part to a reduction in the frequency of outbursts and his parents felt that they now had a calmer son. They too had learned how to help their son when outbursts of rage came. Due to the fact that the whole family had taken part in ART, the parents also had learned to communicate in a new way, rather than express anger toward one another.
Adult/Parent Groups At the family unit, all admitted adults participate in an ART group once per week. Each group consists of approximately six to eight parents. Since parents stay at The Oasis for a limited period, it is impossible to have “locked” or “closed” groups. In order to facilitate the participation of as many as possible in an ART group, The Oasis has chosen to allow new group members to enter existing groups. New members often adjust quickly in the group, and the other group members can explain
THE OASIS—A LIVING IDEA 135
what ART is and what it has meant to them. Parents who participate in the groups are often very different from each other; however, they do have in common the fact that they are parents. For this reason sessions often have to do with better communication with their children, and being a good role model. However, ART also gives training in how to handle situations which earlier were considered difficult: the ART sessions consist of three parts, skillstreaming, anger control training, and moral reasoning. Skillstreaming leads to good discussions and role-play illustrates the parents’ everyday life together with their children in their surroundings. On one occasion we practiced the skill “getting ready for a difficult conversation.” It had been requested by a woman who always walked away from meetings with her social worker when they did not agree. The woman role-played the skill during a session, and the group discussed how one could deal with difficult conversations. A week later the woman had a new meeting with her social worker, and due to her preparation in ART, she was able to remain throughout the entire one-hour meeting. Dynamics in a group often arise when parents dare to open themselves up and talk about difficulties and strengths within the family. In order for this to occur, there must be an atmosphere of security and trust within the group. Therefore, in parallel with the three components of ART, we work with alternative group exercises from Goldstein (1999). With the help of these exercises group members express their feelings about each other and practice encouraging one another, which in turn leads to a strengthened group feeling.
Moral Reasoning Many of the parents who come to The Oasis are morally immature in many ways. Moral judgment is motivated by selfish gain. The moral reasoning which is practiced as a part of ART therefore provides a good basis for improvement of morals among the adults. In the group context, each individual thinks through his/her own moral reasoning, examining dilemmas which often are relevant for them. The discussion leader tries to steer the conversation toward a collective conclusion, with the goal of decreasing egocentricity.
THE SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES We see a clear and concrete change of behavior in those children who are admitted to The Oasis. ART, as well as other types of social reinforcement, plays a large part in this change (see Box 8.1). For example, a child who has often had outbursts of rage, even resulting in physical violence, shows clear progress after a period of ART treatment. We have noted that a large majority of these children have fewer and less intensive outbursts. With the help of what ART “checklists,” we can compare and measure how the child’s social ability increases and how the child’s language improves. Indeed, swear words and vulgar sexual references decrease as the child learns alternative forms of expression. The word “respect” is a word
136 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
that the children eventually learn to use in expressing their dissatisfaction with something. Box 8.1 Student examples Johan: Long-term progress Johan is 9 years old when he arrives at The Oasis children’s unit, Karlsborg, because of his very aggressive behavior in both the home and other contexts, such as in school and among friends. Johan’s behavior consists of regular outbursts of aggression as well as other types of aggressive actions which have resulted in considerable material damage. At Karlsborg Johan begins training in basic social skills, while also participating in a ten-week anger control course. Moral reasoning sessions also become a regular part of Johan’s training. At first only small steps of progress are noticed, and Johan has a tendency rather to increase his aggressive behavior. Johan’s trainer and other personnel work consistently to encourage him when he behaves correctly. The treatment strategy is to give as little attention as possible when Johan acts in a non-desirable way. Each day Johan is given reminders and encouragement to practice his training in skillstreaming, anger control, and moral reasoning. Step by step we are able to see progress and how the frequency and intensity of his aggressive behavior decrease. After two years of treatment at The Oasis, Johan moves to an institution. Reports from them indicate that Johan has continued to make use of much of what he learned in ART. In the first months after the move, Johan calls The Oasis every week, telling us how he is doing and his thoughts regarding continued use of ART. Mikael: Catching teachable moments (taken from ART trainer/personnel notes from an ART session) Mikael (false name) is 11 years of age and participates in the ART session and is very enthusiastic. In the session “Knowing your feelings” Mikael gives several suggestions as to which feelings one can experience, such as fear, worry, and sorrow. He begins to cry when the conversation begins to deal with parents and what we can feel toward them. Personnel comfort Mikael, who is allowed to leave the session for a while in order to talk in peace and quiet with one of the trainers. The trainer encourages Mikael, pointing out that what he has just done was to express his feelings. The trainer asks Mikael to reflect on what made him begin to cry. At this point Mikael describes what he is feeling. He also explains how it feels OK to cry in front of others, and that it is an adequate way to express what he is feeling in this situation. This is an example of how to catch teachable moments, and to carefully make use of ART components, even in emotionally tense situations. Martin: Exercising control Martin (false name) becomes angry due to a misunderstanding between himself and a staff member. The conflict gets out of hand, and Martin becomes
THE OASIS—A LIVING IDEA 137
violent. Personnel are forced to lay Martin on the ground to prevent him from hurting himself or others. Martin has participated in an anger control course and is well aware of what he should do in this situation. In other words, Martin has the knowledge of what to do; however, the question is whether or not he has the will to use it. With support from the personnel who are holding and speaking calmly to him, encouraging him to use what he has learned, the answer to this question is “yes.” After only five minutes, personnel suggest that Martin walk a few meters away, and that personnel will come and talk with him once he has calmed down. Martin walks to an apple tree a few meters away. Martin takes several deep breaths. After a few minutes personnel go to Martin, and together they speak calmly about the incident. Personnel encourage and commend Martin for so quickly gaining control over himself. Besides a reduction in aggression, we can also see progress in the following areas:
r Children lacking in self-confidence, who have not normally greeted by shaking hands, begin to do so, as well as introduce themselves.
r Personnel, social services workers, teachers, and parents have noticed that children have improved their ability to have eye contact in different situations.
r Children develop a greater ability to converse and exchange thoughts and feelings with others. learn to be more conscious of what they feel, and dare to describe different specific emotions. Children learn to better understand how others feel in certain situations. We have noted that children’s empathetic ability increases throughout ART training. We have also seen that children develop a greater ability to deal with stress. This leads in turn to increased patience and a capacity to deal with irritation.
r Children r r
ART and the rest of the program in the children’s unit is connected to a token economy. A token economy is a motivation system designed to encourage and reinforce desired behavior. It is based on the premise that behavior is primarily steered by its immediate consequences, and if the consequences can be changed, then the behavior will also be influenced. In the token economy, participants receive immediate feedback in the form of tokens when they exhibit desirable behavior. It is important in a token economy that the rules are clear and that expectations of participants are clear and specific, not unclear and diffuse.
GENERALIZATION Generalization means that we also work with the children’s parents and other networks, even when these are not admitted to The Oasis for treatment. This wider work is carried out in order to share knowledge and understanding of what the child is learning through the treatment. Visiting the child’s home or having the parents or contact persons visit The Oasis for training together with the child is how this is done concretely. Generalization provides a more lasting treatment result after the period at The Oasis.
138 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
The child’s development is often a key to changing a destructive family pattern. Our starting point is always an individual treatment plan, which also implies taking into consideration the family’s/parents’ conditions, and training primarily with what the parents themselves wish to work on. ART in family or parent groups becomes dynamic, since all the individuals in a system are influenced when a child begins to change his or her behavior. A vitally positive change resulting from skillstreaming is when family members become better at listening to each other: communication within the family improves so that problems can be solved more easily using the new alternatives, which are practiced in the ART training sessions. The will and ability to change often exist within the individual, and with the new skills they have been taught, parents have tools with which they can influence their own and their children’s situations positively.
SUMMARY The Oasis offers specialist services for young people and their families. The use of ART within this setting has proved to be an important component of the work of the staff both in terms of their professional development and in terms of the effectiveness of the service they offer.
REFERENCE Goldstein, A. P. (1999). The Prepare Curriculum: Teaching prosocial competencies (rev. edn). Champaign, IL: Research Press.
Chapter 9
A NATIONAL DISSEMINATION PROGRAM JAMES MCGUIRE1 AND DANNY CLARK2 1 2
University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK National Probation Directorate, London, UK
The focus on Aggression Replacement Training (ART) is happening at an opportune time, and there are several excellent reasons for this. First, there is a large volume of primary studies now available in the field of offender treatment. The general trends within it are such that we hope that the once dominant belief that “nothing works” to help offenders change and to reduce criminal recidivism can now be laid to rest. Second, work on a number of specific programs, of which ART is a prominent example, has consolidated to a remarkable degree. Many issues, from the nature of the program itself to aspects of delivery, implementation, and evaluation, have been solidly addressed, though we fully acknowledge that this is still only a beginning and much more work remains to be done. Third, the nature of practice in many services, including prisons, probation, and youth justice, has been significantly influenced by these types of developments. There are now new kinds of partnerships between researchers and practitioners that have been and will continue to be of considerable benefit to both. Finally, in a number of countries, including the UK, the development of structured programs has been adopted as an element of policy, with the result that new resources are available which even a few years ago were very difficult to obtain. In this chapter we would like to outline the way in which ART has been piloted, evaluated, and is now being disseminated in criminal justice services in the United Kingdom. To date, this has not occurred on a particularly large scale, but is now approaching a point that could be called “lift-off” in terms of level of interest and activity. But first we need to set this in a wider context, as it forms part of a larger-scale initiative and is one element of a major change in government policy, entitled the Crime Reduction Programme. This is a major strategy by HM Government working through the Home Office (the equivalent of a ministry of justice in other countries) to develop and implement an approach to crime prevention that is firmly evidence based.
New Perspectives on Aggression Replacement Training: Practice, Research, and Application. C 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Edited by A. P. Goldstein, R. Nens´en, B. Daleflod, and M. Kalt.
140 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
BACKGROUND RESEARCH It is beyond the scope of this chapter to carry out a review of relevant background evidence relating to what has been called “what works.” But recent integrative reviews of the field show that there are in the region of 2,000 primary studies in which some form of intervention, such as a structured program, has been compared with a no-treatment control group. Since 1985 there has been a total of 42 metaanalyses covering different portions of this literature (McGuire, 2001, 2004). There is also a general consensus among researchers concerning interpretation of the trends within it (Gendreau, 1996; Sherman, Farrington, Welsh, & MacKenzie, 2002; Hollin, 1999), though it is useful to be reminded that there are also limitations that should be constantly borne in mind (Losel, ¨ 2001). It is often forgotten, however, that some of the “treatments” that have been investigated do not consist of programs of education, training, or therapy of any type. They have been designed to test the expectation that additional sanctions— more intensive punishment—will reduce reoffending. That is a widespread lay view concerning how to change offenders’ behavior, based on the idea of deterrence. While this probably has an impact on some offenders, in some places at some times, there is no evidence that it works on a systematic basis as a central pillar of criminal justice (McGuire, 2002). Much more positive findings are obtained when the effects of interventions with certain ingredients are examined. These have loosely been called “programs” though precise definitions of these vary and there can be sizable diversity in the exact nature of the activities involved (McGuire, 2000). But with a fairly high level of consistency, certain identifiable features emerge as more likely to secure reductions in reoffending. Effective programs have a sound theoretical rationale based on evidence from psychology and criminology. They involve assessment and allocation of offenders in terms of risk levels. They focus on dynamic risk factors associated with reoffending, and they employ cognitive-behavioral methods adapted in a way that is responsive to the needs of a particular target group. However, as in any other applied field there are no guarantees of a successful outcome in any given case. It remains vitally important, therefore, that in every instance possible, the use of any program should be subject to monitoring and evaluation processes. One difficulty is that when reporting the average effects obtained from reviews of offender treatment, all these studies are often bundled together. The apparent overall mean effect size is reduced by the zero or negative effects from experiments on sanctioning. Even so, the impact of interventions on recidivism is still comparable with effect sizes found in many other areas, and which are firmly established as valuable courses of action (McGuire, 2002). Selection and implementation of programs containing the factors previously listed is usually linked to larger, and sometimes very impressive, outcomes.
IMPACT ON PRACTICE AND POLICY Many criminal justice agencies now have an expectation that the kinds of services they provide should be based on theory and evidence concerning the factors
A NATIONAL DISSEMINATION PROGRAM 141
that influence offending behavior, and which if effectively addressed in intervention programs may be likely to reduce it (Vennard, Sugg, & Hedderman 1997; Goldblatt & Lewis, 1998). The move towards what is known as “evidence-based practice” has been occurring in parallel in a number of fields for more than a decade. In medicine and healthcare generally, the advent of an evidence-based approach is often traced to the influence of Cochrane (1979), a British epidemiologist who identified a marked need to examine whether medicine and related health research fields could genuinely claim to have sound empirical foundations. As he pointed out, even in medicine, where there is considerable investment in research, there was no systematic record of the outcomes of interventions: it simply did not exist. During the mid-1980s, a paper by Mulrow (1987) examined a series of review articles published in medical journals over a 12-month period (June 1985 to June 1986). Mulrow found major shortcomings in the manner in which reviews were conducted and reported. As a result of comments and findings such as these, the international Cochrane Collaboration was created in 1993. This is a worldwide network of researchers and reviewers coordinated through a series of sites in different continents. The task it has set itself is to locate, evaluate, and integrate the results of well-designed intervention studies (usually randomized controlled trials). The available set of outcome studies, assembled as the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, contains more than a quarter of a million entries. These have been made accessible to researchers and other users through the Cochrane Library, accessible via the Internet. There is also now a parallel innovation, focused not on health but on the fields of educational and social interventions, including correctional services. The recently created Campbell Collaboration had its inaugural international gathering in February 2000 and its first conference in April 2001. Even prior to its formal launch, members of the Collaboration had assembled a sizable database, entitled the Social, Psychological, Educational and Criminological Trials Register (Petrosino, Boruch, Rounding, McDonald, & Chalmers, 1999). In summary, then, across many fields of endeavor there is now a standard philosophy, encapsulated in the phrase evidence-based practice, that is regarded as a cornerstone of the process of consolidating and synthesizing scientific knowledge. It has become a virtual prerequisite of the design and delivery of services and of consultation with practitioners and policy makers. It is also a benchmark for identifying unanswered research questions and for signaling the necessary next steps for research work.
DEVELOPMENTS IN THE UK In 1996, the prison service (England and Wales) embarked on a major initiative to increase the number of prison establishments providing programs and activities designed to reduce rates of recidivism following release. Prison service objectives have for some time been managed in terms of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), which are measures of the achievement of core tasks of the service. The provision of programs designed to reduce recidivism has been included as an indicator of
142 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
this kind (KPI-7). To establish a process for quality control of the programs that would be delivered as part of it, two independent specialist panels were appointed. One was given the job of accrediting programs for sex offenders, while the other dealt with general offending behavior programs. These panels published sets of Accreditation Criteria for evaluating the rationale, design, and delivery of prisonbased interventions. Programs designed to meet these criteria, and which have been accredited as doing so by the consultative panels, are now in use in more than 70 of the 150 penal institutions in England and Wales. The introduction of these processes into the prison service in England and Wales from 1996 onwards has been described in more detail by Lipton, Thornton, McGuire, Porporino, and Hollin (2000). Similar developments have occurred in the Scottish Prison Services and in the Correctional Services of Canada, and it may be that such initiatives will also be pursued by prison services in several other countries. To sustain an initiative of this kind is a substantial undertaking. It has involved the deployment of significant additional resources. It has entailed an extensive program of staff training events, creation of a system of monitoring and audit, and associated mechanisms for administration and information management, both within individual prisons and on a service-wide scale. For example, all sessions of cognitive-skills programs are to be videotaped for scrutiny by external assessors (on a sampling basis). Procedures have been put in place for the systematic evaluation of programs in both the short and longer term. The research findings outlined earlier have also had a marked impact on community agencies for offenders, principally the probation service (and, more recently, youth justice services too). During 1997–98 in England and Wales, the Probation Inspectorate, which monitors the working standards of probation nationally, conducted a focused or “thematic” inspection to examine the extent to which probation staff employed practices based on research evidence. The main report on this work (Underdown, 1998) proposed a series of new initiatives to extend the usage of evidence-based practice in probation work. This subsequently led to the selection of a number of programs designated as Pathfinder projects that were earmarked for further development. In late 1999, a new accreditation process was established to operate jointly for prison and probation services. It was envisaged that programs satisfactorily meeting pre-appointed criteria would be delivered at a large number of sites, and by the end of 2003 more than 10,000 offenders would have attended such programs. To have a program accredited for use in prison or probation settings, a proposal must be submitted to the Correctional Services Accreditation Panel, which, like its predecessor in the prison service, consists of independent experts and consultants. The submission should include copies of all relevant materials such as a description of the program’s theoretical rationale and evidence base, session manuals, staff training manuals, assessment and evaluation measures, and ideally, some preliminary indications of effectiveness. These are then judged against a pre-agreed set of accreditation criteria that define the minimal requirements for approval of a program (Home Office Probation Unit, 1999). The criteria stipulate that the following specifications must be met.
A NATIONAL DISSEMINATION PROGRAM 143
1. Model of change. There should be a clear, evidence-based theoretical model underpinning the program which explains how it is proposed it will have an impact on factors linked to offending behavior. 2. Dynamic risk factors. Program materials should identify factors linked to offending, specified in the model, and which if changed will lead to a reduction in risk of reoffending. The program contents should reflect these objectives. 3. Range of targets. Multimodal programs with a range of treatment targets have yielded the largest effect sizes in research reviews. Program manuals specify an appropriate range of targets and the nature of their interrelationships. 4. Effective methods. The methods of change utilized in the program should have empirical support concerning effectiveness and be coordinated in an appropriate way. 5. Skills oriented. Programs targeting skills that will enable offenders to avoid criminal activities have yielded higher effect sizes in outcome studies. The skills targeted by the program should have explicit links to risk of reoffending and its reduction. 6. Intensity, sequencing, duration. The overall amount of programming (numbers of contact hours), the mode of delivery of sessions, and total program duration should be appropriate in the light of available evidence, the program’s objectives and contents, and the risk level of the targeted offender groups. 7. Selection of offenders. The population of offenders for whom the program is designed should be explicitly and clearly specified. There should be agreed and realistic procedures for targeting and selection, and for exclusion of inappropriate referrals. 8. Engagement and participation. This criterion refers to the principle of responsivity. Information should be provided concerning how this will be addressed, and how offenders will be encouraged and motivated to take part in and adhere to the program. 9. Case management. In prison settings, offenders are allocated a Personal Officer with responsibility for overseeing their individual sentence plans. On probation, they are supervised by a Case Manager. To be effective, programs should be inter-linked with these processes, and guidelines provided for implementation within services. 10. Ongoing monitoring. In order to safeguard the integrity of a program and the treatment methods used, procedures should be in place for collection of monitoring quality-of-delivery data, and systems established for review of this and for taking action on the basis of it. 11. Evaluation. Finally, program materials should include assessment and evaluation measures and a framework for evaluation of its overall delivery, and short-term and long-term impact. With regard to each criterion, a programme may score 0 (not met), 1 (partially met), or 2 (fully met). Some of the criteria (items 1, 2, 7, 9, 10, and 11) are mandatory: in other words, it is essential that the requirements be fully met. To be accredited, a program must achieve a minimum score of 19/22 points, including full marks on all mandatory items.
144 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
In addition to program accreditation, each location in correctional services (such as an individual prison, probation office, or other unit) must also satisfactorily meet criteria for site accreditation. This is part of a process of certifying program and treatment integrity at that site. Systems for collecting information on quality of delivery (program integrity) must also be in place, and the data so collected made available for an annual site audit. Audit reports are then scrutinized by both correctional agency staff and members of the independent accreditation panel. The annual site audit itself is a time-consuming task. However, the fact that results of the site audit have a direct impact on KPIs through a system of weighting completions ensures that managers in correctional settings take the process seriously. The annual audit encompasses four areas: 1. Managerial commitment to program delivery. Are appropriate resources made available to run the program? Is the institution/setting supportive of program delivery? 2. Monitoring of attendance and completions. Are the right offenders selected for the program? Are the majority of offenders completing the program? 3. Staff training and support. Are all staff delivering the program competent and experienced? Is consistency of staff maintained within the program? 4. Program integrity. This is primarily checked through video monitoring. Staff are judged against a series of criteria related to adherence to the program content and to style of delivery, which should include prosocial modeling and Socratic questioning. In addition, all offenders attending the program complete a battery of psychometric tests before and after the program, which allows immediate response to the program to be monitored. Research is now demonstrating the value of this approach. A study by Rosie Travers of the Prison Service Long-Term Evaluation Unit compared establishments’ audit results with the mean levels of change offenders showed on the pre- and post-program psychometric tests. The study included over 75 prison establishments and covered a three-year period (Travers, 2001). It demonstrated there was a strong correlation between quality of program delivery judged from the videos and mean changes for offenders on the psychometric assessments. This proves the value of internal audit. There are also preliminary results from the prison service implementation of accredited programs. However, whilst one study found a 14% reduction in subsequent recidivism (Friendship, Blud, Erikson, & Travers, 2002), results from other evaluations to date have been less positive (Cann, Falshaw, Nugent, & Friendship, 2003; Falshaw, Friendship, Travers, & Nugent, 2003). Many of the programs which are currently being developed in both prison and probation settings employ methods of cognitive skills training, or other work along similar lines. The theoretical model they draw from is that of cognitive social learning theory or some variant of it, and the methods they employ can broadly be characterized as “cognitive-behavioral,” though this can cover a wide range of activities.
A NATIONAL DISSEMINATION PROGRAM 145
ART AS AN ACCREDITED PROGRAM Some of the programs that have achieved accredited status through the foregoing process were developed by local practitioners in adult probation services; others have been imported. The most extensive usage of ART in England and Wales has occurred in Wiltshire, a predominantly rural county approximately 100 miles west of London, with a generally dispersed population in villages and medium-sized towns, and one larger center (Swindon) that is more industrial. The distinctive feature of ART, of course, is that it is an adapted version of the program initially developed by Arnold Goldstein for younger offenders. That work has been extensively documented in a number of publications since the late 1980s (Goldstein & Glick, 1987, 2001; Goldstein, Glick, Carthan, & Blancero, 1994). The program as implemented in Wiltshire entails 18 sessions, each in two parts lasting 55 minutes with a short break in between. The rate of delivery is one or two sessions per week. Program sessions are multimodal and combine the familiar three elements, Skillstreaming, self-control training, and training in moral reasoning, into an integrated design. Each of the elements constitutes eleven 55-minute sessions. There is a specially adapted program manual but, unlike the pattern with other programs, there are no hand-out materials or homework exercise worksheets. These are steadfastly avoided, apart from a credit-card-sized prompt of anger management for offenders to take away. The focus is on live, in-session activity. The program has now been running for almost four years and owes its origins to some internal reviews conducted by Wiltshire Probation Service in the period 1996–97. This followed an analysis of local Pre-Sentence Reports (PSRs), which are provided for courts in cases seen by probation staff. The review identified a need for new programs in several key areas focused on specific offending patterns. In particular, it was found that violent offences accounted for approximately one-third of all PSRs, indicating a need for a program focused on this type of offending. Development of the ART program followed attendance by Wiltshire probation staff at a workshop delivered by Professor Goldstein prior to the 1996 “What Works” conference held in Manchester. The program was then established in 1997. There was some correspondence and consultation with Professor Goldstein, and advice has also been obtained from Professor Gibbs regarding moral reasoning training. Given the North American origin of the original program and its content, cultural context and style, considerable work was required to adapt materials for use in the UK. Clearly, it would have been advantageous for the service to have been able to consult more extensively with the external experts, but this was not feasible. Wiltshire, in organizational terms one of the country’s smaller probation areas, allows the possibility of frequent and regular contacts between staff groups at different sites. In general, there have been no serious access problems between staff at different levels either upward or downward in the line management hierarchy. In addition, the staff group involved during the initial development period remained fairly stable with few changes of personnel. These patterns afforded a number of advantages for a service seeking to import a program from elsewhere. They are important elements identified by Gendreau, Goggin, and Smith (1999) contributing to effective implementation of new initiatives.
146 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
The program is delivered at two sites in the towns of Swindon and Trowbridge at a rate of 6–10 deliveries per annum, with 6–8 offenders per group, predominantly in evening sessions as a high proportion of offenders are in employment. A maximum of eight participants is preferred to allow time for skills practice, which is a key ingredient of the program. The staff team includes four probation officers, three specialized group-work assistants, and four experienced part-time staff. All staff members are involved in program delivery. The service also runs a range of other programs. However, as the development sequence for programs unfolds, some may be discontinued, with additional staff being allocated to ART. There is an emphasis, in annual program planning, on both continuity of staff per program and adherence to a delivery timetable. Two practitioners per session are involved in running the program. Though not always feasible it is intended to achieve a gender balance and mixture of grades and prior experience among tutors. To ensure cohesiveness of delivery, as far as possible staff are also allocated as “reserves” for program sessions. There are regular supervision sessions for all staff, formal and informal debriefings, and material from live observation of sessions is utilized in supervisory work. There is also a review week twice per year which incorporates both training events and a review of staff competencies, and discussion of any issues arising from the program work, such as difficult incidents occurring in groups. One problem this has raised is the sizable number of program participants who have committed domestic violence. This is understood to be associated with a different pattern of risk factors from those targeted by ART. This had led the referral pattern to change with the advent of a program focused on this type of offense. Possibly the largest single drawback of this mode of adopting a program was that staff who instigated the process trained themselves to run it. This involved a thorough examination of materials provided for the program. Subsequently new staff were trained by existing staff. The team has also provided training externally, to practitioners in six other probation service areas. For each new member of staff there is a lengthy induction process evolving from observational work and limited experience of session input, through adoption of an increasingly active role, to coleadership. However, some staff saw this overall format as inadequate, and would have preferred more formal training and perhaps less emphasis on learning “on the job.” The staff team has more recently completed staff training manuals and other materials required for accreditation. The introduction of a new program in the manner we have described has not of course been without some difficulties. One of them is selection of offenders for the program, with only an estimated 60% of referrals viewed as genuinely appropriate. A large proportion of the remaining 40% have committed offenses of domestic violence, as mentioned above. Nevertheless, there is a significant waiting list for ART, and for this to be manageable it is envisaged that the frequency of programs may have to increase. One major problem faced by all community correctional services with respect to structured programs is that of attrition. Offenders are court-mandated to attend programs, which are made integral parts of a community sentence. The consequences of non-attendance may include being returned to court, which in turn might result in an offender being sent to prison. Despite this, on many programs
A NATIONAL DISSEMINATION PROGRAM 147
the number of offenders who attend all sessions and make it through to the end is sometimes very low. However, completion rates for ART have varied between 65% and 75%, which in relative terms is perceived as very satisfactory. In different areas of the UK, the factors influencing program “drop-out” vary widely. In Wiltshire, travel problems in a large rural county play a part in this, as public transport facilities are limited, particularly in the evenings. Participants are brought to program sites by a combination of staff effort and the use of taxis. Although this program receives a high rate of referral for women offenders, given their much lower rate of violence, the absolute number of female clients remains low and they constitute only one or two members of some groups. As Wiltshire has a very low proportion of members of ethnic minorities, the number of black offenders seen is also very low. The Wiltshire ART program was considered by the then Joint Accreditation Panel in March 2000. Despite the fact that the program is based on work with a proven track record in North America, changes were required by the Joint Accreditation Panel before accreditation was finally achieved in March 2001. The revisions included:
r introduction of catch-up sessions for offenders who missed parts of the program; r identification of arrangements to practice skills outside the program, with family members, friends or, if necessary, with the case manager;
r individual pre- and post-group sessions with the case manager to provide motivational enhancement and reinforcement of the program work; selection criteria to ensure offenders attending the program were the most suitable, specifically excluding those with a history of domestic violence and those whose aggression was entirely instrumental; sequencing of ART with other cognitive-behavioral programs for high-risk generic offenders (e.g. those with multiple types of offenses and high risk of reconviction); revised arrangements for women offenders to avoid single placements and to make the material more responsive; teaching of core social skills for all offenders.
r tighter r r r
These changed requirements demonstrate the rigors of the accreditation process.
MONITORING AND EVALUATION The use of the ART program in Wiltshire, as well as in those other areas to which it is being “rolled out,” is being evaluated as part of a national research project (Hollin et al., 2001). The first phase of this activity involved preliminary visits to the probation areas and sites where programs are being implemented and this chapter has been partly based upon that work. The objectives of these visits were to conduct interviews with key staff, to assemble relevant documentation, and to specify and check upon the availability of a wide range of types of data to be collected and analysed as part of the project as a whole. The data being collected are both quantitative and qualitative, and focus both on the outcomes of programs as well as aspects of implementation and process. This is, therefore, a multi-layered
148 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING
approach in which evaluation is seen from a number of interrelated perspectives (Stecher & Davis, 1987; Posavac & Carey, 1997). Offenders’ participation in the Wiltshire ART program is closely monitored. Records are kept of all sessions attended and absences are communicated speedily to case managers. A final report is prepared on each participant, documenting levels of attendance, punctuality, and factors established as contributing to offending behavior, and requiring monitoring in terms of future risk. Reports are despatched efficiently and reliably to offenders’ case managers. For monitoring of program integrity, the program manager directly observes two sessions per program delivered. Staff retain written records of session planning and feedback, and these materials are used in supervision sessions, which occur four times per program. At the time of writing, resources were not available for videotape recording but this will be introduced gradually for all programs. Preliminary information is now available concerning the ART program’s impact on reoffending, after a follow-up period of one year. Sugg (2000) has provided some analysis of a series of 295 offenders who went through the program in the period up to September 1999. Of this group, a total of 230 could be traced through the Offenders Index, a national database of criminal history information, although a further 77 were excluded as they were still on probation orders. Of the 153 remaining, 113 (74%) completed their orders successfully. Their risk of reoffending was assessed using the Offender Group Reconviction Scale, Version 2 (OGRS-2). This is a static prediction instrument developed by Home Office researchers and validated on fairly large samples (Taylor, 1999). It yields a two-year predicted rate of reconviction, which for ART completers was 34.6%. The OGRS2 score of non-completers—the remainder of the sample whose probation orders were revoked or breached—was higher than for completers. This suggests that ART in the form adapted by Wiltshire is more suitable for medium-risk than high-risk offenders. Follow-up data are shown in Figure 9.1. The reconviction rate for program completers after one year was 20.4%. This compared with a figure of 65% for those whose probation order had been revoked. The ART group was also compared with a retrospective matched sample of offenders sentenced to other court disposals, including
Percent reconvicted
70 60 50 40
Predicted
30
Actual
20 10 0 ART
ART Revoked
Comparison
Figure 9.1 Reconvictions at one-year follow-up
Comparison Revoked
A NATIONAL DISSEMINATION PROGRAM 149
community service orders and combination orders. The one-year reconviction rate for those who completed these orders was 34.5%. There were no differences between the reconviction rates of those who had these other types of order revoked, and those placed on ART whose orders were revoked (65% and 60%, respectively). Comparing the reconviction rates of those who completed their orders, however, shows a sizable reduction in favour of ART (20.4% as against 34.5%). Two caveats should be borne in mind when considering these results. First, the Offenders Index is known to have some internal inaccuracies (Friendship, Thornton, Erikson, & Beech, 2001), which are in a gradual process of being remedied. But it can be reasonably assumed that in the present case they would probably arise with corresponding frequency in both the ART and comparison samples. Second, in other research differences between experimental and control samples at one year have disappeared by the end of year two, and only further follow-up will resolve this issue in the case of the Wiltshire cohort. Overall, however, these results can be viewed as very positive, and if sustained will demonstrate a significant long-term impact of participation in ART. As the ART program is gradually disseminated to other areas, there are also additional developments within Wiltshire itself. They include an extension of structured learning materials to cover additional sessions, especially in a manner that can be used in a “booster” or follow-up format. In addition, there is a possibility in future of a program variant of involving significant others, which in Wiltshire’s case would entail sessions that included both offenders and their spouses or partners. In the future, we may be able to provide much larger-scale evidence of ART’s effectiveness.
REFERENCES Cann, J., Falshaw, L., Nugent, F., & Friendship, C. (2003). Understanding “What Works”: Accredited cognitive skills programmes for adult men and young offenders. Findings 226. London: Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate. Cochrane, A. L. (1979). 1931–1971: A critical review, with particular reference to the medical profession. In Medicines for the Year 2000. London: Office of Health Economics. Falshaw, L., Friendship, C., Travers, R., & Nugent, F. (2003). Searching for “What Works”: An evaluation of cognitive skills programmes. Findings 206. London: Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate. Friendship, C., Blud, L., Erikson, M., & Travers, R. (2002). An evaluation of cognitive-behavioural treatment for prisoners. Findings 161. London: Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate. Friendship, C., Thornton, D., Erikson, M., & Beech A. R. (2001). Reconviction: A critique and comparison of two main data sources in England and Wales. Legal and Criminological Psychology, 6, 121–129. Gendreau, P. (1996). Offender rehabilitation: What we know and what needs to be done. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 23, 144–161. Gendreau, P., Goggin, C., & Smith, P. (1999). The forgotten issue in effective correctional treatment: Programme implementation. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 43, 180–187. Goldblatt, P. & Lewis, C. (1998). Reducing offending: An assessment of research evidence on ways of dealing with offending behaviour. Home Office Research Study No.187. London: Home Office. Goldstein, A. P. & Glick, B. (1987). Aggression Replacement Training. Champaign, IL: Research Press.
150 NEW PERSPECTIVES ON AGGRESSION REPLACEMENT TRAINING Goldstein, A. P. & Glick, B. (2001). Aggression Replacement Training: Application and evaluation management. In G. Bernfeld, D. P. Farrington, & A. Lescheid (Eds), Offender rehabilitation in practice: Implementing and evaluating effective programmes (pp. 121–148). Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. Goldstein, A. P., Glick, B., Carthan, M., & Blancero, D. (1994). The pro-social gang: Implementing aggression replacement training. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Hollin, C. R. (1999). Treatment programmes for offenders: Meta-analysis, “What Works”, and beyond. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 22, 361–371. Hollin, C. R., McGuire, J., Palmer, E., Bilby, C., Hatcher, R., & Holmes, A. (2002). Introducing Pathfinder programmes into the Probation Service: An interim report. Home Office Research Study 247. London: Home Office. Home Office Probation Unit (1999). What Works Initiative: Crime Reduction Programme. Joint Prison and Probation Accreditation Criteria. London: Home Office. Lipton, D., Thornton, D., McGuire, J., Porporino, F., & Hollin, C. R. (2000). Programme accreditation and correctional treatment. Substance Use and Misuse, 35, 1705–1734. Losel, ¨ F. (2001). Evaluating the effectiveness of correctional programmes: Bridging the gap between research and practice. In G. Bernfeld, D. P. Farrington, & A. Lescheid (Eds), Offender rehabilitation in practice: Implementing and evaluating effective programmes (pp. 67– 92). Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. McGuire, J. (2000). Defining correctional programs. Forum on Corrections Research, 12, 5–9. McGuire, J. (2001). What works in correctional intervention? Evidence and practical implications. In G. Bernfeld, D. P. Farrington, & A. Lescheid (Eds), Offender rehabilitation in practice: Implementing and evaluating effective programmes (pp. 25–43). Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. McGuire, J. (2002). Criminal sanctions versus psychological interventions with offenders: A comparative empirical analysis. Psychology, Crime and Law, 8, 183–208. McGuire, J. (2004). Understanding psychology and crime: perspectives on theory and action. Buckingham: McGraw Hill/Open University Press. Mulrow, C. D. (1987). The medical review article: state of the science. Annals of Internal Medicine, 106, 485–488. Petrosino, A. J., Boruch, R. F., Rounding, C., McDonald, S., & Chalmers, I. (1999). A Social, Psychological, Educational and Criminological Trials Register (SPECTR) to facilitate the preparation and maintenance of systematic reviews of social and educational interventions. Background paper for the Cochrane Collaboration meeting, School of Public Policy, University College London, July. Posavac, E. J. & Carey, R. G. (1997). Programme evaluation: Methods and case studies (5th edn). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Sherman, L. W., Farrington, D. P., Welsh, B. C., & MacKenzie, D. L. (Eds) (2002). Evidence-based crime prevention. London and New York: Routledge. Stecher, B. M. & Davis, W. A. (1987). How to focus an evaluation. Newbury Park, CA: Sage. Sugg, D. (2000). Wiltshire Aggression Replacement Therapy (ART): One-year reconvictons and targeting. Unpublished report, Research Development and Statistics Directorate, Home Office, London. Taylor, R. (1999). Predicting reconvictions for sexual and violent offences using the revised offender group reconviction scale. Research Findings No. 104. London: Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate. Travers, R. (2001). A comparison of intermediate psychometric measures and programme delivery quality at HM Prison establishments. Paper presented to the Joint Prison and Probation Offending Behaviour Programmes Accreditation Panel, March, Oxford. Underdown, A. (1998). Strategies for effective offender supervision: Report of the HMIP What Works project. London: Home Office. Vennard, J., Sugg, D., & Hedderman, C. (1997). Changing offenders’ attitudes and behaviour: What works? Home Office Research Study No. 171. London: HMSO.
PART III
ELABORATIONS, EXTENSIONS, AND EVALUATIONS In this third and final part the theme of elaborations to ART is taken up with two chapters that look at ways in which the essentials of ART can be advanced. These are the Prepare Curriculum, by Arnold P. Goldstein, and the Peace Curriculum, by Sara Salmon, which both offer ways in which ART can be expanded and enhanced to reach a wider range of targets for change. Alongside elaborations of the program, some innovative practitioners have sought to extend ART into new areas of practice. Ruud Hornsveld works in The Netherlands and his creative format and evaluation of ART in a forensic setting prescriptively reflects the particular qualities and research requirements necessary when working with such clients. Robert Calame and Kim Parker describe their work at the Batshaw Youth and Family Centre in Quebec. Alongside their innovative practice, they have set up a field evaluation of their work. Outcome research in such a setting demands careful and rigorous attention to the unique characteristics which follow from a family focus. The work reported in this chapter does, indeed, reflect such a careful and rigorous attention to detail. It is through evaluation that programs such as ART will stand or fall. There are as of this date 16 completed