Narratology beyond Literary Criticism
Narratologia Contributions to Narrative Theory/ Beiträge zur Erzähltheorie
Edit...
84 downloads
1455 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Narratology beyond Literary Criticism
Narratologia Contributions to Narrative Theory/ Beiträge zur Erzähltheorie
Edited by/Herausgegeben von Fotis Jannidis, John Pier, Wolf Schmid Editorial Board/Wissenschaftlicher Beirat Catherine Emmott, Monika Fludernik Jose´ Angel Garcı´a Landa, Peter Hühn, Manfred Jahn Andreas Kablitz, Uri Margolin, Matı´as Martı´nez Jan Christoph Meister, Ansgar Nünning Marie-Laure Ryan, Jean-Marie Schaeffer Michael Scheffel, Sabine Schlickers, Jörg Schönert
6
≥
Walter de Gruyter · Berlin · New York
Narratology beyond Literary Criticism Mediality, Disciplinarity
Edited by Jan Christoph Meister in collaboration with Tom Kindt and Wilhelm Schernus
≥
Walter de Gruyter · Berlin · New York
앝 Printed on acid-free paper which falls within the guidelines 앪 of the ANSI to ensure permanence and durability.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Narratology beyond literary criticism : mediality, disciplinarity / [edited] by Jan Christoph Meister ; in collaboration with Tom Kindt and Wilhelm Schernus. p. cm. ⫺ (Narratologia ; 6) Papers presented at a symposium held at Hamburg, November, 2003. Includes index. ISBN 3-11-018352-8 (alk. paper) 1. Narration (Rhetoric) ⫺ Congresses. 2. Discourse analysis, Narrative ⫺ Congresses. I. Meister, Jan Christoph, 1955⫺ II. Kindt, Tom. III. Schernus, Wilhelm. IV. Series. PN212.N42 2005 8081.00114⫺dc22 2005006990
ISBN 3-11-018352-8 ISSN 1612-8427 Bibliographic information published by Die Deutsche Bibliothek Die Deutsche Bibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data is available in the Internet at ⬍http://dnb.ddb.de⬎. 쑔 Copyright 2005 by Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, D-10785 Berlin All rights reserved, including those of translation into foreign languages. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Cover design: Christopher Schneider, Berlin Printed in Germany
Table of Contents
Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
vii
Introduction: Narratology beyond Literary Criticism: Mediality – Disciplinarity Jan Christoph Meister/Tom Kindt/Wilhelm Schernus
ix
On the Theoretical Foundations of Transmedial Narratology . . . . Marie-Laure Ryan The Double Dynamics of Focalization in W. G. Sebald’s The Rings of Saturn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Silke Horstkotte
1
25
Levels of Play and Narration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Britta Neitzel
45
Narrative in Music: The Case of Beethoven’s “Tempest” Sonata . . Douglass Seaton
65
Metalepsis as a Transgeneric and Transmedial Phenomenon. A Case Study of the Possibilities of ‘Exporting’ Narratological Concepts . . 83 Werner Wolf Measuring Narrativity in Literary Texts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 109 Vyacheslav Yevseyev Quantitative Methods in Narratology: A Corpus-Based Study of Motion Events in Stories . . . . . . . . . . . . 125 David Herman The Lydgate Storyworld . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 151 Alan Palmer ‘Selective’ History. Why and How ‘History’ Depends on Readerly Narrativization, with the Wehrmacht Exhibition as an Example . . 173 Daniel Fulda
vi
Table of Contents
The Narratological Fabric of the Gospels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 195 Ute E. Eisen Narrative Discourse and Identities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 213 Michael Bamberg Psychotrauma, Narration in the Media, and the Literary Public—and the Difficulties of Becoming Interdisciplinary . . . . . . 239 Harald Weilnböck The Eye of the Beholder. Narratology as Seen by Social Psychology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 265 Wolfgang Kraus Author Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 289 Contact Addresses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 297
Acknowledgments
The present volume contains revised versions of twelve papers presented at the Second International Colloquium held by the Narratology Research Group, Hamburg University, in November 2003. They have been complemented by an article kindly contributed by David Herman. We appreciate the trust invested in us, the organizers and editors, by the Research Group. Furthermore, we would like to mention our library, the Staats- und Universitätsbibliothek Hamburg Carl von Ossietzky, which made available to us its conference room. This wonderful venue contributed in no small way to the conference’s success. Particular thanks are due to our colleague and co-organizer Malte Stein who unfortunately could not participate in the preparation of this volume. Alastair Matthews translated the introduction into English and also edited, with great competence and his usual attention to detail, some of the articles. Birte Lönneker and Stefanie Thiedig assisted us in correcting and formating the manuscripts as well as in the preparation of the index. Finally, our thanks go to the series editors of ‚Narratologia. Contributions to Narrative Theory’ for publishing our volume in their esteemed series. Jan Christoph Meister Tom Kindt Wilhelm Schernus
Narratology beyond Literary Criticism: Mediality – Disciplinarity
Introduction A glance at the current situation in literary criticism shows that narratology, pronounced dead twenty years ago, is remarkably alive and well. This fact has been noted repeatedly and with understandable self-satisfaction in the recent literature on research into narrative theory. Just how astonishing this rebirth is, however, becomes apparent only when we step back from literary criticism and the humanities to take a wider historical view of the developments in academic and theoretical circles that preceded it. The deeply symbolic year of 1968 marked the fall of the academic ancien régime. Partly in anticipation of this and partly in response to it, a number of new leading disciplines were raised to power in western Europe as sources of hope for the future. However much they may have differed from one another in political purpose (in theoretical circles or beyond), linguistics, political economy, psychoanalysis, and structuralist semiology—to name but a few of the superdisciplines of the time—clearly belonged to one and the same paradigm in terms of how they conceived of themselves: throughout, they sought to reveal universal, ahistorical regularities in human thought and action in their respective fields. In the mid-1970s, however, a new epoch began, in which many disciplines explicitly distanced themselves from the search for universal patterns. The problems of context and historical contingency, previously ignored, were placed at the heart of the new theoretical systems. Some of the oncesupreme approaches could not or would not adapt accordingly; they were either marginalized (e.g. orthodox Marxist political economy) or redefined themselves as disciplines concerned with empirical social data (e.g. linguistic discourse analysis). Others responded by embracing the post-structuralist and subsequent deconstructivist paradigms with open arms. French narratology was one of the fields in which signs of this reorientation could be seen at an early stage. Roland Barthes’s S/Z of 1970 is perhaps the best evidence of this. A fundamental methodological shift, however, did not take place until the mid-1980s. One reason for the delay was the fact that narratology had become international in the meantime.
x
Introduction
When Derrida and Kristeva were leading figures in its homeland, the discussion of narratology in the English-speaking countries was covering an anachronistic combination of theories. Prince disseminated the formalist programme with his Grammar of Stories of 1973, after which some theorists engaged in retrospective reception of the structuralist and formalist classics (see for example Culler’s Structuralist Poetics: Structuralism, Linguistics and the Study of Literature of 1975). Even as this programme was being discovered, however, other writers were considering how it might be reformulated and extended to cover new methods and media. Chatman’s Story and Discourse: Narrative Structure in Fiction and Film of 1978 is an example of this. It combines the most influential Anglo-American, Russian, and French approaches. The delaying effect of this methodological ambivalence becomes clear in the next part of our survey of Anglo-American publications. The first, highly influential American translation of Genette appeared in 1980 (Narrative Discourse). Prince published his definitive formalist classic, Narratology: The Form and Functioning of Narrative, in 1982. At the same time, a second American translation of Genette was published (Figures of Literary Discourse). Finally, Rimmon-Kenan’s Narrative Fiction: Contemporary Poetics of 1983 provided a concise overall picture of what is now known as classical narratology prior to the caesura marked by Peter Brooks’s Reading for the Plot: Design and Intention in Narrative of 1984. In this book, Brooks presents an approach marked by its post-structuralist orientation and the fact that it is argued in terms of the aesthetics of effect and reception. The paradigm shift finally becomes apparent in all its enormity from 1985 onwards when Elain Showalter (The New Feminist Criticism of 1985) and Susan Sniader Lanser (Toward a Feminist Narratology of 1986) begin the project of creating a feminist narratology. With uncompromising radicalism and forcefulness, this project denies the original concept of narratology as the science of narrative universals. This tradition, which has given birth to many of the later new narratologies, has survived to the present day. In the mid-1980s, narratology, which was now showing increasing American influence, began to undergo a process of change marked by two tendencies. First, the turn away from formalism and structuralism meant that the narrative theory used in the study of literature began to draw on a wide range of theoretical paradigms. Second, narratological theories themselves were increasingly formulated and received with a view to particular applications, which could perfectly acceptably lie beyond the study of literature. The study of narratology had become a cross-disciplinary undertaking. Another, unrelated development should also be mentioned here: completely independent of the tradition whose evolution we have traced above, a variety of non-literary disciplines have shown an increasing
Introduction
xi
interest in narrative representation since as long ago as the early 1960s (e.g. socio-linguistic studies in the tradition of Labov and Waletzky). The same is true of the study of folk narrative, which goes back even further into the past. The Narratology Research Group in Hamburg has held two conferences to date on the evolution and refinement of narratology as described above. The first—What Is Narratology?—took place in May 2002.1 Its objective was to reconstruct the development of narratology and discuss the resultant choices open to and consequences facing us when we build and apply text-based narratological theories. The second conference followed in November 2003. The present book is named after its theme: Narratology beyond Literary Criticism. The aim here was to extend our models of and reflection on the development of narratological methodologies in two ways. First, we intended to investigate how narratological methods might contribute to the analysis and interpretation of symbolic representations in media other than the traditional, text-based medium of literature. Second, we asked: what is the position of narratology relative to other disciplines and their methodologies—put simply, where does narratology belong, who does it belong to, and who demands what of it? Mediality The call for papers on this ambitious project, whose objective was to link practical application with metatheoretical methodological reflection, met with a wide international response. Over fifty proposals for papers were submitted, of which only twelve could be selected for presentation at the conference. As the table of contents in this book shows, they dealt with a remarkably wide range of topics, including narrative representation in music, film, therapeutic discourse, computer games, and comics. Deliberately disconnecting the concept of narrativity from textual media proved, it can be seen, an extremely profitable move, and the editors are indebted to the contributors from various disciplines beyond literary criticism. By venturing into a narratological lion’s den, they have made an important contribution to expanding our horizons. In the process, the conventional interpretations and use of several narratological concepts are inevitably undermined at times. Orthodox theorists of literary narrative might consider these concepts sacrosanct, but, in the context of cross-disciplinary dialogue, we should treat this disruption as an opportunity and stimulus 1
Tom Kindt /Hans-Harald Müller (eds.): What Is Narratology? Questions and Answers Regarding the Status of a Theory. (Narratologia. Contributions to Narrative Theory / Beiträge zur Erzähltheorie 1). Berlin / New York 2003.
xii
Introduction
to re-examine our own terminology rather than insisting on canonical definitions. Tolerance and a readiness to learn are desirable not least because the narratology of literary criticism itself contains a large number of conceptual imports and thus tends to extend rather than preserve terminological meanings anyway. A less positive picture presents itself when we consider the second theme of the conference. We had hoped to encourage methodological metareflection on the consequences of deliberately extending narratological methods and their field of application, but, apart from a small number of exceptions, neither the papers nor the discussion lived up to this expectation. This criticism is directed neither at the authors and speakers, nor at the audience, but rather at ourselves, the organizers and editors. We had hoped that it would be relatively easy to turn the debate about the object domain of narratology into one about narratological theory itself on a reflexive metalevel, but this was probably a deformation professionelle typical of literary critics. Such an intention would seem positively hubristic to natural scientists, and it must strike those involved in empirically or historically oriented human and social sciences as somewhat strange at best. In literary narratology, as in most forms of literary theory and criticism, theories are constructed primarily on the basis of reference to particular canonical texts rather than using corpus analysis. That is to say, they have a selective rather than empirical basis. And, when our methods are applied in the context of such selective material, progressing rapidly from analytical description to building theoretical models seems not only acceptable but positively desirable. Crossing so easily from the discourse of data to that of theory, however, cannot but seem unusual when we are working with empirical evidence, as is standard practice for many of the participants in the conference and contributors to this volume who have narratological but non-literary interests. These self-critical remarks can be turned to our benefit. Our attempt to combine discussion of the object domain of narratology with reflection on its methods met with little success. But this need not be a cause for despondency—future narratological discussion should instead attempt to rectify two shortcomings that this failure has revealed. First, it is clear that we must, by means of informed reflection, examine the methodologies and evolution of narratology from a firmly metatheoretical perspective. Second—and this becomes particularly apparent with each new cross-disciplinary application of narratological theorems—the central concept of narratology itself, narrativity, is still not sufficiently well defined. The first essay in this volume makes interesting suggestions in this area. It and other, conceptually varied approaches to providing a more precise definition of our central concept deserve discussion in a context dedicated to this theme.
Introduction
xiii
No narratologist would dispute the fact that narration is a cross-medial phenomenon. However, there have been few attempts to date to engage in a reflexive, metatheoretical discussion on how the phenomenon should be defined conceptually. This may be an important explanation for why present narratological theory contains suggestions for many divergent definitions, most of which are distinctly media-specific in nature (predominantly literary, text-based), and tends not to draw links between them. A brief glance at the numerous more traditional definitions, which derive the concept of narrativity from quasi-material properties of narrating texts, is enough to show the scale of disagreement about the definition of narrativity. Some supporters of this traditional kind of definition refer to the discours level of narratives (e.g. Stanzel or the Genette of the Nouveau discours), others find it more appropriate to elucidate the concept of narrativity using the elements of the histoire level of texts. Those in favour of the latter method are deeply divided over the question of whether the resultant definition should have the character of a formal description in the manner of Prince or be aesthetic and normative in nature, as in Lotman’s tradition. There is also a series of definitions based on the theory that a proper definition of narrativity must make reference to both the plot and mediation levels of texts (e.g. Chatman or the Genette of the Discours). In contrast to these attempts at phenomenological explanation, recent years have seen the proposal of various functional definitions. They operate by identifying the function of narrativity. Their concepts of this function are usually postulated rather than developed by means of argument and can take very different forms in each particular case. These definitions are based, among other things, on the ontogenetic, socio-historical, cognitive, or metaphysical effects of narratives, or how they affect the aesthetics of reception (e.g. Fludernik, Herman, Ryan, Sternberg, Lanser, or Ricœur). Disagreement in the controversy surrounding the concept of narrativity is not, however, limited to the question of what features of artefacts and their functions a definition should be based on. The kind of definition best suited to help us grasp the phenomenon is also disputed. Whereas some treatments attempt to state necessary and sufficient conditions of narrativity, others consider it more appropriate to be guided by the concept of family resemblance or the ideas of prototype theory (Herman). Against the background of this situation (the description of which does not make any claim to be complete), the following question arises: what kind and form of definition of narrativity would be theoretically compatible with a narratology that claims cross-medial relevance for its theory and methodology? Three minimal requirements that such a definition of narrativity must fulfil can be identified.
xiv
Introduction
(1) The definition must be intuitively adequate. A cross-medial definition of narrativity must be valid and meaningful for all media that contain representations and can be intuitively classed as narrating media. (2) The definition must be medium-neutral. A cross-medial definition of narrativity can only stipulate as necessary those criteria and categories that appear as features in all the forms of symbolic representation covered by (1). For example, if musical representations are intuitively classed as potentially narrative, condition (2) prohibits all definitions of narrativity that involve the category of character in the essentialist or mimetic sense of a human agent—this category is not convincingly marked in musical representations. (3) The definition must relate to symbolic material. A cross-medial definition of narrativity must not retreat to capturing narrativity in some linguistic expression (in the sense of Wittgenstein’s language game) lacking reference to material objects. It must be possible to verify the fulfilment or non-fulfilment of the criteria of narrativity as objective structural features of concrete tokens (texts, films, transcripts of speech, musical pieces, etc.) without the criteria becoming essentialist ones as a result. In view of these minimal requirements, one of the most promising chances of developing a cross-medial definition of narrativity would seem to lie, at least at first glance, in functional and logical approaches—in definitions that are, in one form or another, based on feature sets that capture the relationship between cognitive, aesthetic, or other effects typical of narrative on the one hand and the logical structure underlying the phenomenology of all possible narrative realizations on the other. Disciplinarity The various disciplines from beyond literary criticism have very different links with narrativity, which is itself, as we have said, still insufficiently defined and thus can be drawn on only as a pre-theoretical frame of reference. It is completely indisputable that historiography has a narrative character. In the case of music, on the other hand, there will be some disagreement (and such debate can only be profitable) as to whether musicologists can speak of narrativity in music in anything other than a purely metaphorical linguistic expression. Applied narratologies are now emerging across the entire spectrum of academic disciplines, and it would seem to be no more than a matter of time until we find ourselves faced with, say, a mathematical narratology or an inorganic narratology. This somewhat ridiculous prediction is intended to highlight a second and perfectly serious problem:
Introduction
xv
assuming that we do manage to develop a robust cross-medial concept of narrativity, what criteria would we then use to determine the status of the various approaches to and theories about the medium-specific forms of narrative? Are people necessarily narratologists, and are they necessarily doing narratology, if they are dealing with narrative phenomena in their particular fields? In other words, is narratology (4) a superdiscipline whose abstract object is narrativity in all its forms in the different media in which it occurs; (5) an interdisciplinary project in the context of which various individual disciplines can constantly inductively exchange and combine new object- and interest-specific definitions of narrativity; or (6) a formally defined procedure for elucidating its object, possessing interdisciplinary relevance and giving primacy to the category of narrativity in its theoretical system? These possibilities can only be compared with one another if there is agreement regarding the criteria with which they should be evaluated. We would argue that particular consideration should be given to whether the possibilities listed above (which need not be the only ones) are institutionally realistic, cognitively profitable, and theoretically and conceptually plausible. We are inclined to favour the last possibility (6); we find the prospect of a superdiscipline institutionally unlikely, and we feel that the project of interdisciplinary discourse favoured in the present climate displays too much arbitrariness and too little transparency. We do not deny that culturalist and contextualist definitions of our subject matter result in a massive expansion of the object domain of narratology and thus encourage interdisciplinary exchange. On the other hand, a serious methodological problem must also be pointed out, one that featured in the debate about the concept of intertextuality prior to contextualism and culturalism: the concept of context itself still lacks anything approaching a satisfactory theoretical definition. For this reason, the contextualization advocated so widely leads, sooner or later, to a methodological dilemma that threatens to undermine the scientific status of narratology itself. Thus, we suggest, the best future for narratology lies in retaining a critical awareness of the fact that it was originally intended to search for and study universals. The theoretical task facing contemporary narratology is not an easy one: it is easy to see that the phenomenon of narrativity occurs in different media; what we have to do is state what it actually is. It can be disputed whether such a statement should be couched in terms of cognitivism, aesthetics, the logic of representation, or perhaps a synthetic combination of some or all of these frameworks—but this does not change our conviction that a con-
xvi
Introduction
text-sensitive formalism with reformed methods gives narratology a better chance of doing what it is intended to do than does a contextualism with inadequately controlled methods. The six issues we have raised here under the headings of mediality and disciplinarity, and the arguments with which we have responded to them, have two purposes. First, we hope they will indicate the direction that should be taken by the theoretical reflection that we believe to be necessary in narratology. Second, and consequently, we have outlined an overarching set of questions against which the reader can consider the individual contributions gathered together in this book. These are the questions that gave rise to the idea of our conference on narratology beyond literary criticism in Hamburg. We thank all those who, regardless of differences in method and concepts, helped elucidate these questions, whether by writing papers or contributing to the discussion. When editing this volume, as when organizing the conference, we deliberately strove to resist the temptation of enforcing conceptual and methodological standardization. We do not suggest that the following essays speak the same language. But the reader will find nonetheless that they speak about the same thing—even if our picture of it is not yet as clear as it might be. Jan Christoph Meister Tom Kindt Wilhelm Schernus
Hamburg, Göttingen, September 2004
On the Theoretical Foundations of Transmedial Narratology Marie-Laure Ryan (Bellvue, Colorado) 1. Introduction Narratology, the formal study of narrative, has been conceived from its earliest days on as a project that transcends disciplines and media. In 1964, Claude Bremond wrote: [Story] is independent of the techniques that bear it along. It may be transposed from one to another medium without losing its essential properties: the subject of a story may serve as argument for a ballet, that of a novel can be transposed to stage or screen, one can recount in words a film to someone who has not seen it. These are words we read, images we see, gestures we decipher, but through them, it is a story that we follow; and it could be the same story (quoted from Chatman 1978:20).
With its almost exclusive concentration on verbal narrative, and within verbal, on literary fiction, the development of narratology has tended to ignore these statements. The purpose of the present volume is to correct this trend and to replace narratology on the transmedial and transdisciplinary track. But in the meantime, hopefully, our understanding of media has grown more sophisticated. We no longer believe that all media offer the same narrative resources and that all stories can be represented in media as different as literature, ballet, painting and music. Nor do we believe that the migration of a story from a medium to another does not present cognitive consequences. A core of meaning may travel across media, but its narrative potential will be filled out, actualized differently when it reaches a new medium. When it comes to narrative abilities, media are not equally gifted; some are born storytellers, others suffer from serious handicaps. The concept of narrative offers a common denominator that allows a better apprehension of the strengths and limitations in the representational power of individual media. Conversely, the study of the realization of narrative meaning in various media provides an opportunity for a critical reexamination and expansion of the analytical vocabulary of
2
Marie-Laure Ryan
narratology. The study of narrative across media is consequently beneficial to both media studies and narratology. This essay explores the theoretical foundations of transmedial narratology in both their negative and positive components. The negative component describes the positions that are incompatible with transmedial narratology, while the positive component explores the concepts of narrative and of medium that are compatible with the project.
2. Positions Hostile to Transmedial Narratology The main obstacle to the transmedial study of narrative is a position that comes from within narratology itself, namely what I call the language-based, or rather, speech-act approach to narrative. This position (represented by Prince 1987, Genette 1972, and Chatman 1978) defines narrative as an act of storytelling addressed by a narrator to a narratee, or as the recounting of a sequence of past events (Abbott 2002). In these definitions, the condition for being a narrative is the occurrence of the speech act of telling a story by an agent called a narrator. The semantic content of this speech act must be events that already occurred, either actually or in make-believe. This conception of narrative as a language-based phenomenon not only rejects the possibility of visual or musical forms of narrative, it also excludes texts with a language track that do not use an overt narrator, or texts that do not represent events retrospectively. For instance, Gerald Prince writes in his Dictionary of Narratology: ‘A dramatic performance representing many fascinating events does not constitute a narrative, since these events, rather than being recounted, occur directly on stage’ (1987:58). According to this view (which Prince abandons in the second edition of the Dictionary), the transmedial study of narrative is limited to the distinction between oral storytelling and written literary narrative. Some theorists endorse a milder form of this position that uses the speech-act based definition as a metaphorical model for the analysis of non-verbal texts. In contrast to the radical approach, the mild version accepts the possibility of visual or dramatic narratives, but only if these texts can be fitted into the verbal mold. This approach would analyze drama and movies as the utterance of a narratorial figure, even when the film or the play does not make use of voice-over narration. Its advocates include Metz 1974, Chatman 1990, Gaudreault and Jost 1990, and its opponents Bordwell and Thompson 1990. Another position incompatible with the study of narrative across media is the doctrine of radical media relativism. Though I cannot associate it with specific names, it is latent among critics influenced by Saussurian
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
3
linguistics and deconstruction. Radical relativism regards media as selfcontained systems of signs, and their resources as incommensurable with the resources of other media. Just as two languages cannot convey the same semantic values under the doctrine of linguistic relativism, two different media cannot convey similar meanings or use similar devices under the doctrine of medial relativism. This view comes in a strong and a weak form. In the strong form, the signified cannot be separated from the signifier. Since a transmedial concept of narrative presupposes a distinction between narrative meaning and the signs that carry it, the strong interpretation kills in the egg the project of transmedial narratology. In its weaker form, medial relativism accepts common meanings but insists on the uniqueness of the expressive resources of each medium, thereby forcing the theorist to rebuild the analytical toolbox of narratology from scratch for every new medium. This approach ignores the fact that the conceptual tools of verbal narratology are often borrowed from other media: for instance, theme from music, perspective from painting, and camera-eye narration from the cinema. In some cases borrowing seems inevitable: for instance when a medium tries to imitate the effects of another medium, or when two media share a common channel. The alternative to medial relativism is to recognize that theoretical concepts can be either medium-specific, or applicable to several media. Examples of narratological concepts that apply across media are the distinction story / discourse, as well as the notions of character, event, fictional world and metalepsis (Wolf, this volume). On the other hand, montage is a technical concept native to film; but literary critics have borrowed it when language-based narrative began to imitate some of the techniques of the cinema.
3. Defining Narrative In the past ten years or so, the term ‘narrative’ has enjoyed a popularity that has seriously diluted its meaning. Jerome Bruner speaks of narratives of identity, Jean-François Lyotard of the ‘Grand Narratives’ of a capitalized History, Abbe Don of the narratives of interface in computer software, and everybody speaks of cultural narratives, meaning by this not a heritage of traditional stories but the collective values that define a culture, such as belief in free speech in Western societies, or latent stereotypes and prejudices, such as narratives of race, class and gender. The dissolution of ‘narrative’ into ‘belief’, ‘value’, ‘experience’, ‘interpretation’, or simply ‘content’ can only be prevented by a definition that stresses precise semantic features, such as action, temporality, causality and world-construction. A transmedial definition of narrative requires a broadening of the concept beyond the
4
Marie-Laure Ryan
verbal, but this broadening should be compensated by a semantic narrowing down, otherwise all texts of all media will end up as narratives.1 As I have already mentioned, the main problem facing the transmedial study of narrative is to find an alternative to the language-based definitions that are common fare in classical narratology. A useful point of departure is a very sketchy, but fairly uncontroversial definition proposed by H. Porter Abbott: narrative is ‘the representation of an event or a series of events’ (Abbott 2002:12). What makes this definition useful, despite its lack of precision, is that it relies on the medium-free concept of representation. It tells us that narrative is a signifier of a variable nature—the representation—that calls to mind a meaning—or signified—of a fixed nature, the ‘event or series of events’. But I would like to make the prefix re of representation optional, in order to accommodate two kinds of texts: narratives that represent events from a retrospective point of view—events that are already ‘in the book’ of history; and narratives that present events as they occur, as is the case with live broadcasts, computer games, and perhaps even drama and movies. If the transmedial identity of narrative lies on the side of the signified, this means that narrative is a certain type of mental image, or cognitive template which can be isolated from the stimuli that trigger its construction. I propose to define the cognitive template constitutive of narrative through the following features. 1. Narrative involves the construction of the mental image of a world populated with individuated agents (characters) and objects (spatial dimension). 2. This world must undergo not fully predictable changes of state that are caused by non-habitual physical events: either accidents (happenings) or deliberate actions by intelligent agents (temporal dimension). 3. In addition to being linked to physical states by causal relations, the physical events must be associated with mental states and events (goals, plans, emotions). This network of connections gives events coherence, motivation, closure, and intelligibility and turns them into a plot (logical, mental and formal dimension). 1
As Werner Wolf has argued (2003:181f), an example of a definition of narrative that seems too broad for transmedial narratology is Monika Fludernik’s (1996) suggestion that narrative is in essence an expression of human experience, and that plot is not a necessary dimension. I am certainly not questioning the importance given by this definition to human (or anthropomorphic) experience. But if ‘experientiality’ makes plot dispensable, any piece of music that arouses emotions (and don’t they all?), any abstract painting titled ‘War’, ‘Anguish’, or ‘Serenity’, and any lyrical poem would be every bit as narrative as a classical novel, and more narrative than a historical chronicle that focuses on external events.
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
5
This definition consists of hard and fast rules that specify minimal conditions. One of the conditions listed under 2 appears however more controversial that the others: is it necessary for a story to involve non-habitual events, or can it concern fully routine actions, such as the stereotyped scripts which constitute in part our general knowledge of the world? This dilemma points to an area where the issue of narrativity is particularly difficult to disentangle from the issue of what makes a story worth telling. Should a definition of narrative involve aesthetic principles, defined through preference rules, in addition to hard and fast conditions, or should it outline a bare wireframe common to all stories? Some theorists (Bruner 1991) argue that a story must have a point, and that principles of tellability are therefore an integral part of a definition of narrative. Others will reply that there are good and bad stories and that storytelling is not necessarily performed for the sake of entertainment. We may for instance produce narratives as a response to questions from a doctor, a prosecutor, a teacher, or a parent who wants explanations for our behavior, and these stories can satisfy the questioner without fulfilling the felicity conditions that pertain to what Pratt (1977) calls ‘narrative display texts’, such as conversational storytelling or the production of literary fiction. I believe that there is a continuum that runs from strict conditions of narrativity to conditions of tellability, and from tellability to full-fledged aesthetic principles, such as the Aristotelian principles that recommend exposition, conflict, climax, and a resolution brought up by a dramatic turn of events. A definition of narrativity cannot be limited to the great masterpieces of literature, and it must therefore draw a line, however contestable, somewhere between the two poles. This is why I haven’t included precise guidelines under 3 on matters such as coherence, conflict, and closure. Each of the conditions listed above implies the preceding one. We can therefore have non-narrative texts that fulfil (1) only (e.g. the static description of a world, as we find in ethnographic works or in Borges’ “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis, Tertius”), mildly narrative texts that fulfil (1) and (2) (e.g. chronicles of random or unrelated actions, reports of dreams, or certain incoherent stories told by children)2, and fully narrative texts that fulfil all three condition. But we cannot have (3) without (2), unless the
2
For instance this story told by a four-year old boy, reported by Brian Sutton-Smith (1997: 161–62): ‘Once there was a dragon who went poo poo on a house and the house broke then when the house broke the people died and when the people died their bones came out and broke and got together again and turned into a skeleton and then the skeletons came along and scared the people out of the town and then when all the people got scared out of the town then skeleton babies were born and then everyone called it skeleton town […].’
6
Marie-Laure Ryan
actions of (2) are purely virtual (as is the case in novels that focus on the ruminations of Hamlet-like characters who are unable to take action), nor (2) without (1), since there cannot be changes of state, and consequently history, without concrete entities that undergo metamorphoses. The division of my definition of narrative into three components means that the degree of narrativity of a given text cannot be evaluated by simple algorithms, such as computing the proportion of static and active events.3 While all three conditions must be fulfilled for a text to be widely accepted as narrative, individual narrative texts will give variable emphasis to the features specified in the three conditions. With their detailed construction of an imaginary world, science fiction and fantasy over fulfil condition 1, and they often treat the plot as a mere discovery path across fictional space. The demand for action and changes of state that makes up the second condition is the dominant feature of thrillers and adventure stories, while the third condition, by insisting on causal connections and on the mental constructs that render actions intelligible, rules over detective stories and heavily plotted narratives, such as comedies of errors. Neglect of the third condition leads by contrast to the low narrativity of many postmodern novels. While these novels create a world, populate it with characters, and make something happen (though they often take liberties with condition 2), they do not allow the reader to reconstruct the network that motivates the actions of characters and binds the events into an intelligible and determinate sequence. Rather than locating narrativity in an act of telling, the present definition anchors it in two distinct realms. On one hand, narrative is a textual act of representation (or presentation)—a text that encodes a particular type of meaning. The definition remains unspecific as to what type of signifier is used to encode this meaning. On the other hand, narrative is a mental image built by the interpreter as a response to the text. But it does not take a representation proposed as narrative to trigger the cognitive template constitutive of narrativity: we may form narrative scripts as a response to life itself. For instance, if I observe a fight on the subway, I will construct in my mind the story of the fight, in order to tell it to my colleagues when I get to work. To account for the narrative potential of life, I propose to make a distinction between ‘being a narrative’, and ‘possessing narrativity’. The property of ‘being a narrative’ can be predicated of any semiotic object produced with the intent to evoke a narrative script in the mind of the audience. To be more precise, it is the receiver’s 3
This method of assessing narrativity is implicit to Gerald Prince’s discussion of the topic (1982, chapter 5). Also see the contributions by Yevseyev and Herman in the current volume.
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
7
recognition of this intent that leads to the judgment: this text is a narrative, though we can never be sure that sender and receiver have the same story in mind. ‘Having narrativity’, on the other hand, means being able to evoke such a script, whether or not the author of the text intended to do so, and whether or not there is an author (Ryan 2004:9). For instance, if a random pattern of cracks in a rock happened to resemble writing, and if the writing could be read as a story, the pattern of cracks would not be a narrative, but it would certainly possess narrativity by the present definition. The idea that life as well as texts can possess some degree of narrativity does not mean that narrative plots are the sort of thing that are found in the world, a view that Hayden White successfully put to rest. I am rather saying that the cognitive construct typical of narrativity can be a response to affordances and stimuli that originate within the world. Making stories out of life experience is neither picking up ready-made objects that somehow lie out there, nor constructing these objects out of any kind of materials, but finding a fit between what life offers, and the cognitive pattern that we try to fill in. Sometimes life provides adequate raw materials, sometimes it does not, and sometimes the materials are created by the imagination. The fullest realization of narrative occurs when we have a text that is both intended as narrative, and possesses sufficient narrativity to be construed as such. But the properties of being a narrative and having narrativity can be dissociated in a variety of ways. The standard case of dissociation occurs when the story is so poorly presented that the audience cannot reconstrue the proper script, even though it recognizes a narrative intent. In this case the text is a narrative of low narrativity. The opposite case is the already-mentioned case of a life situation that the cognitive subject interprets in narrative terms. The property of being a narrative is much more clear-cut than the property of having narrativity, since it depends on the sender’s intent, but it becomes fuzzy in a number of situations. For instance, what do you call a text that uses narrative scripts in an instrumental way? A sermon or a philosophical text typically resorts to parables and narrative examples on the micro-level, but the global purpose of the text is certainly not to tell a particular story. Computer games present a similar situation: they may use a narrative script to attract the player, but once the player is immersed in the game, he usually forgets whether he is fighting terrorists, car thieves, or evil aliens, or whether he is a terrorist himself. All that matters is winning the game through clever use of resources. The question ‘is it a narrative?’ is even more problematic when the text embodies the artistic intent to both arouse and frustrate narrative desire. Many postmodern texts present themselves as bits of pieces of a narrative image but prevent the reader from ever achieving
8
Marie-Laure Ryan
the reconstruction of a stable and complete narrative script. This explains why narrative theory has never been comfortable with either including or excluding postmodern literature (Ryan 2004:9–10). My endorsement of a cognitively rather than verbally based definition of narrative should not be taken as an unconditional adherence to a position that has recently taken cognitive science, the social sciences, and the humanities by storm. This position proclaims the fundamentally narrative nature of thought, and it equates our never-ending efforts to make sense of the world and of our lives with a process of ‘emplotting’ or ‘storification’. Without denying that storytelling (to oneself or to others) is an efficient way to make life and the world more intelligible, and that the formation of narrative scripts plays an important role in mental life, I believe that there are sense-making operations that do not take narrative form: capturing the laws of physics through an equation such as E=mc2 fails for instance the first and second conditions of my definition, since it produces a timeless law rather than a historical scenario involving individual entities. Sense-making can also result from the drawing of analogies and contrasts between phenomena, rather than from the chronological and causal ordering of individual events. The mental construct that I regard as constitutive of narrative admittedly puts into play cognitive processes that we also use in everyday life, such as focusing thought on certain objects cut out from the flux of perception, a process that also enables us to distinguish discrete states and events; inferring causal relations between these states and events; thinking of events as situated in time; and reconstructing the content of other peoples’ minds as an explanation of their behavior. We resort to these mental operations when we drive a nail with a hammer (acting on the basis of inferred causal relations), when we plan our schedules (temporal ordering), when we make grocery lists (focusing on certain items selected from the wide range of available products), and when we participate in social interaction, especially conversation (reading other people’s minds). Some cognitivists will say that these processes are inherently narrative, and that activating them is an act of storytelling. But this is a rather circular reasoning that leads to entirely predictable results, and that doesn’t explain anything: how could thought produce anything but stories, if it is in essence a narrative activity? I would like to suggest on the contrary that the activation of one or the other of these cognitive processes is not sufficient to produce narratives, because they can operate independently of each other, as my examples suggest. It is only when they all come together and form a reasonably stable mental image that they generate representations that fulfil all the conditions of my definition. Narratives are more than temporary drafts in the theater of the mind, more than transitory firings of neurons in the brain along individual
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
9
pathways; they are solidified, conscious representations produced by the convergence of many different mental processes that operate both within and outside stories.
4. Revisiting the Relations of Language and Narrative The adoption of a cognitive definition may uncouple narrative from verbal expression, but it does not entirely solve the thorny problem of the relation between language and narrative. It seems clear that of all semiotic codes language is the best suited to storytelling. Every narrative can be summarized in language, but very few can be retold through pictures exclusively. The narrative limitation of pure pictures stems from their inability to make propositions. As Sol Worth has argued, visual media lack the code, the grammar and the syntactic rules necessary to articulate specific meanings. A propositional act consists of picking a referent from a certain background and of attributing to it a property also selected from a horizon of possibilities. While language can easily zero in on objects and properties, pictures can only frame a general area that contains many shapes and features. Pictures may admittedly find ways around their lack of propositional ability to suggest specific properties (for instance through caricature), but there are certain types of statements that seem totally beyond their reach. As Worth argues, pictures cannot say ‘ain’t’. Nor, as Rimmon-Kenan observes (1989:162) can they convey possibility, conditionality, or counterfactuality. Werner Wolf is more specific on this issue: ‘pictures do not have at their disposal the means that verbal narratives have for thematizing the presence [= bringing to mind?] of actually absent or virtual realities of the represented world’ (Wolf 2003: 192). Moreover, being limited to the visible, they are unable to express abstract ideas, such as causality. Only language can make it explicit that the queen died of grief over the death of the king, or that the fox stole the cheese from the crow by fooling him into believing something that was not the case (Ryan 2004:10). The narrative limitations of music are even more blatant than those of pictures, because sound waves (or tones and rhythms) are not in themselves semiotic objects. Pure sounds can be used to evoke mental images, some of which may resemble stories, but they possess neither an iconic meaning, as do pictures, nor a context-independent, stable core of signification definable by lexical rules, as does language (Ryan 2004:11). All of these observations seem to support the conclusion that verbal language is the native tongue of narrative, its proper semiotic support. Without denying the unsurpassed narrative ability of language, I would
10
Marie-Laure Ryan
like to defend a more nuanced position. If we define narrative in cognitive terms, it is not a linguistic object but a mental image. While it may be true that only language can express the causal relations that hold narrative scripts together, this does not mean that a text needs to represent these relations explicitly to be interpreted as narrative. Take for example a sequence of seemingly disconnected cinematic images: First you see a man tossing and turning, unable to sleep. Then a mirror breaks. Then a telephone rings.
The film theorists Bordwell and Thompson argue that these images can be constructed into a narrative sequence if the spectator supplies common agents and logical connections. For instance ‘The man can’t sleep because he’s had a fight with his boss, and in the morning is still so angry that he smashes the mirror while shaving; next, his telephone rings and he learns that his boss has called to apologize’ (Richardson 2000:170). The visual track may be unable to explicitate causal relations, but what matters in this case is the spectator’s ability to infer them from the text. Even purely verbal texts, which are perfectly able to say ‘the queen’s grief over the king’s death caused her to die’ usually dispense with such explanations (Ryan 2004:11). One of the major problems faced by transmedial narratology is to reconcile the centrality of language with the original contributions made by other media. Language all by itself can support a wider variety of narratives than any other single-track medium, not just because of its logical superiority but also because only words can represent language and thought. Dialogues and representations of mental life are indeed a major component of narrative. But this does not mean that media based on sensory channels cannot make unique contributions to the formation of narrative meaning. There are, quite simply, meanings that are better expressed visually or musically than verbally, and these meanings should not be declared a priori irrelevant to the narrative experience. The philosopher Kierkegaard claimed for instance that the desire of Don Juan—a desire that doesn’t want to die, and yet doesn’t want to renounce fulfilment—can only be expressed by the music of Mozart. Narrative is not just the wire frame plot captured by summaries, but the expansion of this wire frame into a total imaginative experience, into a spatio-temporal world to which we react intellectually, emotionally and sometimes aesthetically. Verbal narrative certainly offers the most balanced and diverse expansion of the wire frame, but other media can outdo language in their expansion of one of its particular dimensions. For instance, the sound track in a movie conveys certain moods and elicits emotional responses much more powerfully that
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
11
the image and the dialogue can do. I notice for instance that when I cry during movies, it is always in moments when music is playing; and I cry in movies much more easily than I do while reading. 5. Narrative Modes If narratology is to expand into a medium-free theory, the first step to be taken is to recognize other narrative modes than the standard way of evoking narrative scripts: telling somebody else that something happened. I do not take this term of mode in the traditional narratological sense defined by Genette 1972 (who uses it as a rather vague umbrella term for concepts such as frequency, direct and indirect discourse, perspective and focalization), but in a personal sense, to mean a distinct way to bring to mind the cognitive construct that defines narrativity. Let me illustrate this concept of modality through a list of concrete examples. This list, which I regard as open-ended, consists of binary pairs. In each case the left term can be regarded as the unmarked case, because the texts that present this feature will be much more widely accepted as narrative than the texts that implement the right-hand category (discussion of modes from Ryan 2004:13–15). External / Internal: In the external mode, narrative meaning is encoded in material signs; it is textualized. In the internal mode, it is does not involve a textualisation: we can tell ourselves stories in the privacy of our minds (cf. Jahn 2003). Diegetic / Mimetic: This distinction goes back to Plato’s Republic. A diegetic narration is the verbal storytelling act of a narrator. As the definition indicates diegetic narration presupposes language, either oral or written; it is therefore the mode typical of the novel and of oral storytelling. A mimetic narration is an act of showing, a ‘spectacle’. In forming a narrative interpretation the recipient works under the guidance of an authorial consciousness, but there is no narratorial figure. Mimetic narration is exemplified by all dramatic arts: movies, theater, dance, and the opera. But each of these two modes can intrude into a narration dominated by the other. The dialogues of a novel are islands of mimetic narration, since in direct quote the voice of the narrator disappears behind the voice of the characters; and conversely, the phenomenon of voiced-over narration in cinema reintroduces a diegetic element in a basically mimetic medium. Autonomous / Illustrative: In the autonomous mode, the text transmits a story that is new to the receiver; this means that the logical armature of
12
Marie-Laure Ryan
the story must be retrievable from the text. In the illustrative mode, the text retells and completes a story, relying on the receiver’s previous knowledge of the plot. The illustrative mode is typical of pictorial narratives, for instance of medieval paintings of Biblical scenes. Halfway between these two poles are texts that offer a new, significantly altered version of a familiar plot, such as a modern retelling of a classical myth. Receptive / Participatory: In the receptive mode the recipient plays no active role in the events presented by the narrative: he merely receives the account of a narrative action, imagining himself as an external witness. In the participatory mode the plot is not completely pre-scripted. The recipient becomes an active character in the story, and through her agency she contributes to the production of the plot. This mode has been practiced for quite a while in staged happenings, ‘improv’ theater, and scripted role-playing games (e.g. “Dungeons and Dragons”) but it has flourished with the advent of interactive digital media. In many computer games, for instance, the user is represented in the game world through an avatar. By solving problems in the real time of the game session she determines whether the life-story of this avatar will end in success or failure, or how long the avatar will live. Determinate / Indeterminate: In the determinate mode the text specifies a sufficient number of points on the narrative trajectory to project a reasonably definite script. In the indeterminate mode, only one or two points are specified, and it is up to the interpreter to imagine one (or more) of the virtual curves that traverse these coordinates. The indeterminate mode is typical of narrative paintings that tell original stories through the representation of what Lessing calls a pregnant moment. The pregnant moment opens a small temporal window that lets the spectator imagine what immediately preceded and what will immediately follow the represented scene. But a full-blown story normally covers an extended stretch of time, and every spectator will probably imagine the remote past and the remote future in a different way. Literal / Metaphorical: What constitutes a literal or metaphorical narration depends on the particular definition given to narrative. While literal narration fully satisfies the definition, the metaphorical brand uses only some of its features. The degree of metaphoricity of a narrative thus depends on how many features are retained, and on how important they are to the definition. The great advantage of recognizing a metaphorical mode is that it enables narratology to acknowledge many of the contemporary extensions of the term ‘narrative’ without sacrificing the precision of its core definition.
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
13
Here are some examples of what I consider metaphorical types of narrative. If we define narrative as the representation of a world populated by individuated characters, and if characters are intelligent agents, the following relaxations of the definitions should be regarded as metaphorical: scenarios about collective entities rather than individuals (e.g. the ‘Grand Narratives’ of Lyotard, as well as their heirs, the ‘narratives of class, gender and race’ of contemporary cultural studies);4 narratives about entities deprived of consciousness (e.g. Richard Dawkins’ exposition of biology as the story of ‘selfish genes’), and dramatizations that attribute agency to abstract objects. Here is an example proposed by the mathematician Ken Devlin: ‘Mathematicians deal with a collection of objects—numbers, triangles, groups, fields—and ask questions like, ›What is the relationship between objects x and y? If x does thus to y, what will y do back to x?‹ It’s got plot, it’s got characters, it’s got relationships…a bit of everything you can find in a soap opera.’5 In other words, mathematics is a story! This is certainly an extreme case of metaphorical narrative. If we want to stretch the metaphor to its limits, we can apply it to art forms deprived of semantic content, such as music and architecture. In the case of music, the metaphor can be invoked to analyze the structure of the work in terms of narrative effects or narrative functions. Narrative terminology is indeed common in music theory: relations between chords are described as exposition, complication and resolution. Given a specific exposition and complication, only certain chords will provide a satisfactory resolution. In this metaphorical interpretation, all music becomes narrative, while if we use an illustrative interpretation, narrativity is a feature that occurs in only some compositions—those that allude to a narrative through their title, such as the Don Quixote Suite, by Telemann, or the Apprentice Sorcerer, by Paul Dukas. In the case of architecture, a metaphorical interpretation would draw an analogy between the temporality of plot and the experience of walking through a building. In a narratively conceived architecture, the visitor’s discovery tour is plotted as a meaningful 4
5
Does this conception of metaphorical narrative apply to works of history—such as histories of France or of the Mediterranean? On the level of the title, it certainly does: France and the Mediterranean are collective entities deprived of consciousness. But if we look into these works, we notice that they do not narrate the destiny of an allegorical character named ‘France’ (or Marianne) or the Mediterranean, attributing to this character a mind of her own and particular goals. They rather tell the concrete stories of the leaders who shaped the destiny of large numbers of people, or of more anonymous individuals whose story typifies the living conditions of an entire social class. Therefore, while the project of producing the history of a country, region, or community is metaphorical on the macro-level, it is made of multiple literal narratives. If the project remains on the level of general statements about collective entities, it is not narrative. Quoted in The Denver Post, January 9, 2001:2.
14
Marie-Laure Ryan
succession of events. This occurs in Baroque churches, where the visitor’s tour is supposed to reenact the life of Christ.
6. What Are Media? The concept of medium is no less problematic than the concept of narrative. Just as structural linguists face the task of defining the units of the language system, transmedial narratologists must decide what counts as a distinct medium from a narrative point of view. This may seem a strange question: don’t we all instinctively know what media are? And yet, if we ask specialists of different disciplines to propose a list of media, we will receive a bewildering variety of answers. A sociologist or cultural critic will answer: TV, radio, cinema, the Internet. An art critic may list: music, painting, sculpture, literature, drama, the opera, photography, architecture. An artist’s list would begin with clay, bronze, oil, watercolor, fabrics, and it may end with exotic items used in so-called ‘mixed-media’ works, such as grasses, feathers and beer can tabs. An information theorist or historian of writing will think of sound waves, papyrus scrolls, codex books, and silicon chips. A philosopher of the phenomenologist school would divide media into visual, aural, verbal, and perhaps tactile, gustatory and olfactory. In media theory, as in other fields, what constitutes an object of investigation depends on the purpose of the investigator (Ryan 2004:16). Can one subsume all these conceptions of medium under a unified theory? If we look back at the answers of our imaginary informants, we can classify them into three broad categories: semiotic, material-technological, and cultural. The semiotic approach looks at the codes and sensory channels that support various media. It tends to distinguish three broad media families: verbal, visual and aural. It is only our habit of not ranking cuisine and perfume among media—probably because they do not transmit the proper kind of information—that prevents this list from including olfactory and gustatory categories. The groupings yielded by the semiotic approach broadly correspond to art types, namely literature, painting and music, but they extend beyond the aesthetic use of signs; language for instance has both literary and non-literary uses; pictures can be artistic or utilitarian. In its narratological application, the semiotic approach investigates the narrative potential and limitations of a given type of signs. Werner Wolf (2002) asks for instance to what extent sound and pictures are able to narrate, and he ranks the three major media families, or art types, in this decreasing order of story-telling ability: verbal, visual and musical. In a similar vein, Lessing’s ground-breaking study Laocoon investigates the
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
15
differing storytelling affordances of painting, a spatial medium, and poetry, an art form supported by the temporal medium of language. Left by itself, the semiotic approach yields only broad families. To bring further refinement to media theory, we must ask about the materials and the technologies that support the various semiotic types. Within each semiotic group of media, we must distinguish raw material supports, such as clay for pottery, stone for sculpture, the human body for dance, or the human vocal apparatus for music, from supports that are elaborated through technological means. It is further necessary to distinguish technologies of pure reproduction, such as sound recording or xerox copying, from technologies that create new media objects and open new expressive possibilities. Only the latter presents interest for transmedial narratology. Moreover, not all technologies that bring expressive diversity in a media family do so in a narratively significant way. In the sound category, for instance, diversity is created by the various musical instruments developed through the ages, but none of them has significantly increased the limited narrative potential of music. Much more consequential for narrative are the technologies that affect language-based and visual media. In the language category, these technologies correspond to the various ways to inscribe verbal signs (manuscript writing, print, and digital encoding),6 as well as to the various methods of encoding and transmitting spoken language (radio and telephone). In the visual domain, the most narratively significant technologies correspond to methods of capture, such as photography, film, and television. The digital encoding of images has also brought new expressive possibilities, but their narrative impact is questionable. The technological approach not only refines semiotic categories, it also cuts across them and reorganizes media into different families: media of long distance communication, media of the moving image, and above all, ‘old media’ versus ‘new media’. This label of new media may be used in a narrow sense to cover media or submedia that only perform through the computer (VR installations, video games, e-mail, Internet chat, hypertext), and in a wide sense, to describe media that use digital technology as mode of production, but end up being taken out of the computer (digital photography, digital recordings, and films with computer-generated scenes). Technology also regroups semiotic families into multiple-channel media (or ‘multi-media media’) that affect several senses. The classical example of an approach to transmedial narratology based on technological categories is the work of Walter Ong on the impact of the invention of writing on narrative form. 6
This list should also make room for the kinds of objects that support these various modes of inscription: papyrus scrolls, codex books, the computer screen, and space itself for VR technology.
16
Marie-Laure Ryan
The third important dimension of media is their cultural use. This dimension is not entirely predictable from semiotic type and technological support. In fact, some ways of disseminating information are regarded as distinct media from a cultural point of view, despite their lack of a distinct semiotic or technological identity. Newspapers, for instance, rely on the same semiotic channels and printing technology as books, but ‘the press’ is widely regarded by sociologists as a medium in its own right, on par with the other so-called ‘mass media’ of TV, film, radio and the Internet. By far the majority of media studies have been devoted to cultural use. These studies will ask for instance about the social impact of film violence, Internet pornography, television news reporting, or multi-user computer games. In a study of cultural use, consideration must also be given to the network of relations among media, a network commonly described through the metaphor of media ecology (Heise 2002). For instance, the cultural role of the cinema shifted after the invention of television, though the technology itself did not undergo significant changes. In the pre-television days, movie theaters showed a variety of features: news reels, documentaries, cartoons, and a feature film. They combined reality-based and fiction films in a continuously running show. This diversity and continuous running has been taken over by television, and nowadays movies specialize mainly in the fictional, with a distinct preference for the fantastic, while TV favors reality (or reality-effects), in the form of news, documentaries, and fictional representations of everyday life. It has even turned the real into a spectacle in the increasingly popular genre of ‘reality TV’. The semiotic, the technological and the cultural dimension all affect the narrative potential of media, but they do so to variable extents. Take for instance the case of television, compared to film and to the theater. On the semiotic level TV is not distinct from these other two media: all three involve a visual, a verbal and an (optional) sound channel, and all three enact narrative in the mimetic mode. This mode restricts the use of language to dialogue and subtitles, and severely limits the representations of counterfactual or purely mental events that are such an important part of the novel. In contrast to the theater, which relies mainly on what I have called raw material supports (props, costumes, and the bodies of actors),7 TV and film have a distinctive technological component that allows the capture of moving images by a moveable recording device with variable focal length. This technology opened possibilities unknown to the theater, such as variations in point of view and quick changes of location. While 7
The theater does however present some technological dimensions: lighting systems, the machinery that allows quick changes of stage setting, or the systems that permitted the ‘Deus ex Machina’ effect in the Baroque age.
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
17
the high definition of the image and large screen of the cinema led to an emphasis on setting, travel, and physical action (an emphasis reinforced by the recent development of computer-generated special effects), TV remained limited by the relatively poor quality of its image and by the small size of its screen, features that prevented immersion and prompted McLuhan to call TV a cool medium. These properties predisposed TV to the traditional themes of the theater, namely domestic drama focusing on human interaction, rather than to the visually stunning subject matters favored by the more spectacle-oriented cinema. Thanks to the capability of the technology to broadcast signals twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week, these themes of human interaction stretched into longrunning serials, rather than being condensed into the two-hour action typical of movies and the theater. Because serial narratives require lots of plot to be written in a relatively short time, they employ large teams of scriptwriters, and they favor multiple parallel plot lines with intersecting courses (Thompson 2003:40; all further quotes from the same source). The best settings for long-running TV narratives are therefore public spaces traversed by many characters, such as hospitals, police stations, law firms and prisons (57). In a further contrast to the cinema, TV technology allows the instantaneous transmission of images, a property that led to unique narrative forms, such as the reality show or the live sports broadcast. Many of the distinctive properties of TV narrative however are not due to its technological support exclusively, but to the cultural use of the medium. The habit of financing TV channels with advertising led to a segmented structure in which narrative shows alternate with commercial spots. Moreover, the demands of efficient programming put severe limits on the length of narrative episodes: half hour to one hour for serials, two hours for the broadcast of films made for the large screen. These culturallyimposed conditions put special demands on the script writers. Because the commercial breaks must come at logical stopping places (17), the episodes of one hour TV serials tend to be structured into four acts, each with its own crisis and climax (42). TV serials thus present the epic structure of a loose succession of relatively autonomous episodes on the macro-level, but they adhere to an Aristotelian dramaturgy, with well-defined story arcs, on the micro-level. Because spectators may turn on the TV set at any time during a show—in contrast to film and theater spectators, who must attend the performance from beginning to end—frequent recaps of the action are necessary, and they must be smoothly integrated into the dialogue (63). These narrative features are culturally conditioned, since they facilitate the integration of TV into daily life, but this integration is itself made possible by the continuous stream of information sent to the home by the supporting technology.
18
Marie-Laure Ryan
7. Defining Media from the Perspective of Transmedial Narratology For students of narrative, what counts as a medium is a category that truly makes a difference as to what stories can be evoked or told, how they are presented, why they are communicated, and how they are experienced. Narrative differences may concern three different semiotic domains: semantics, syntax, and pragmatics. In narrative theory, semantics becomes the study of plot, or story; syntax becomes the study of discourse, or narrative techniques; and pragmatics becomes the study of the uses of narrative. On the semantic level, different media favor different variations of the basic cognitive template: for instance, film prefers dramatic narratives shaped according to the Freytag triangle, TV prefers episodic narratives with multiple plot lines, and computer games prefer quest narratives with one plot line, but several autonomous episodes corresponding to the levels to be passed. On the discourse level, media may produce different ways to present stories, which will necessitate different interpretive strategies on the part of the user. For instance, narrative is broken up into distinct frames in comic strips, while it is represented by an image that seems to evolve continuously in film, at least until the next camera take. On the pragmatic level, finally, different media may offer different modes of user involvement and different ‘things to do’ with narrative. An example of these new things to do is the the posting of private diaries on the Internet, a phenomena known as ‘blogging’. With digital media, it is now possible to share narratives of personal experience with millions of strangers. In summary, a medium will be considered narratively relevant if it makes an impact on at least one of these domains. This approach implies a standard of comparison: to say for instance that ‘radio is a distinct narrative medium’ means that radio as a medium offers different narrative possibilities than television, film, or oral conversation (Ryan 2004:18). ‘Mediality’ (or mediumhood) is thus a relational rather than an absolute property. Moreover, the relevance of a given technology for narrative may be subject to change, as people put it to new uses. A case in point is the global positioning system (GPS), a technology that allows people to identify with great precision the latitude and longitude of their current location. Narrative applications of GPS may appear today as unlikely as did the literary use of number-crunching machines fifty years ago, but both ideas have come to pass: computers have notoriously become ‘poetry machines’, and GPS technology has been used to anchor stories in real-world locations. A case in point is 34 North 118 West, a project developed by Jeff Knowlton, Naomi Spellman and Jeremy Hight. In this project, users walk around a district of Los Angeles with a lap-top computer equipped with GPS technology. When they enter certain loca-
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
19
tions, the GPS sends signals that prompt the playing of stories through earphones. Walking around the area thus becomes a treasure hunt for the hidden stories that capture the spirit of the place. I won’t go as far as saying that GPS technology has become a narrative medium, because its role is (so far?) limited to monitoring the transmission of ready-made texts, but its use in 34 North 118 West certainly allows a new thing to be done with narratives, namely linking them to their real-world referent. This example suggests that transmedial narratology should not only pay attention to established and productive narrative media, but also to any kind of technology that affects the narrative experience. For a type of information support to qualify as a narrative medium, it must not only make a difference in the areas of story, discourse or pragmatics, it should also present a unique combination of features. The following list presents an overview of the kind of media features that affect the experience of narrative, besides the semiotic, technological and cultural factors already discussed: – Spatio-temporal extension. Media fall into three broad categories: purely temporal ones, supported by language or music exclusively; purely spatial media, such as painting and photography; and spatio-temporal media, such as the cinema, dance, image-language combinations, and digital texts. One could however argue that oral storytelling and print narrative involve a visual, and consequently spatial component; this would leave only long-distance oral communication such as radio and telephone as a language-supported example of the purely temporal category. – Kinetic properties. A spatio-temporal medium can be static (i.e. combinations of still pictures and text) or dynamic (moving pictures, or media relying on the human body as means of expression, such as dance or the theater). By contrast, all purely temporal media are dynamic, and all purely spatial media are static. – Number of channels. In the spatial category there is only one channel, unless one considers that sculpture and architecture have a tactile dimension. In the temporal category we have either one-channel media (language or music), or combinations of the two temporal media, language and music, in songs and sung forms of poetry. Most media of the spatio-temporal category have multiple channels, but mime and silent pictures use only visual data. Combinations include: image-language (in illustrated books); image-music (in silent films); or image-musiclanguage (in film, the opera, and digital media). – Priority of sensory channels. Thus the opera should be considered distinct from a theater production that makes use of music, even though
20
Marie-Laure Ryan
the two media include the same sensory dimensions and semiotic codes, because the opera gives the sound channel higher priority than the theater. Another issue to resolve for the definition of medium from the perspective of transmedial narratology is the delimitation of medium with respect to genre. Both medium and genre exercise constraints on what kinds of stories can be told, but while genre is defined by more or less freely adopted conventions chosen for both personal and cultural reasons, medium imposes its possibilities and limitations on the user. It is true that we choose both the genre and the medium we work in. But we select media for their affordances, and we work around their limitations, trying to overcome them or to make them irrelevant. For instance, painters introduced perspective to add a third dimension to the flat canvas. Genre by contrast deliberately uses limitations to optimise expression, to channel expectations, and to facilitate communication: for instance, tragedy must be about the downfall of a hero and use the mimetic mode of narrativity; and sonnets must consist of fourteen lines, organized in two quatrains and two tercets with a certain rhyming pattern. These conventions are imposed as what Jurij Lotman has called a second-order semiotic system on the primary mode of signification. Genre conventions are genuine rules specified by humans, whereas the constraints and possibilities offered by media are dictated by their material substance and mode of encoding (Ryan 2004:19). It is not always easy to distinguish genre from medium; but I would like to suggest a criterion based on the old question: what comes first—the chicken or the egg? Let the text be the chicken and genres and media be the egg. With genres, the chicken comes first. Genres originate in innovative texts that create a desire to duplicate their generative formula. With media on the other hand the egg comes first, since a text can only come into existence when the material support for its signs and the technology for their transmission are already in place. Insofar as media are sets of affordances, or possibilities, new media give birth to new forms of text and to new forms of narrative, which in turn may be codified into genres. Far from being narrowly conditioned by the properties of their supporting medium, narratives have developed various ways to handle these properties. First, narrative may go with its medium and take full advantages of its affordances. This would be the case of a computer game in which players manipulate an avatar and create its destiny through their actions. Computer games are so dependent on the interactive nature of their digital environment that they cannot be taken out of the computer. Second, narrative can ignore the idiosyncrasies of the medium and use it purely as a transmission channel. This is what happened when Stephen
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
21
King posted one of his novels on the Internet. The text was meant to be printed, and it took no advantage whatsoever of the artistic resources of a digital support. Third, narrative can actively fight some of the properties of the medium for expressive purposes. For instance, a print narrative with multiple branches subverts the linear reading protocols typical of novels distributed in book form, and it anticipates the possibilities of electronic textuality. Here we can say that the text yearns for another medium. And fourth, a text may expose latent properties in its medium, properties that expand its expressive potential beyond current practice. This happened when postmodern print novels began playing with graphic layout, and made us aware of the spatiality of the print medium, a spatiality that is forgotten when print is considered to be nothing more than the translation of spoken language. The diversity of games that narrative can play with the resources of its medium is one of the many reasons that make the intersection of narratology and media studies, an area still largely unexplored, into a productive field of investigation. References Abbott 2002 Abbott, H. Porter: The Cambridge Introduction to Narrative. Cambridge 2002. Aristotle 1996 Aristotle: Poetics. Translation and introduction by Malcolm Heath. London 1996. Barthes 1977 Barthes, Roland: “Introduction to the Structural Analysis of Narrative.” In: Barthes, Roland: Image-Music-Text. Translated by Stephen Heath. New York 1977. Bordwell / Thompson 1990 Bordwell, David / Thompson, Kristin: Film Art. 3rd ed. New York 1990. Bremond 1973 Bremond, Claude: Logique du récit. Paris 1973. Bruner 1991 Bruner, Jerome. “The Narrative Construction of Reality.” In: Critical Inquiry 18.1, 1991:1–22. Chatman 1978 Chatman, Seymour: Story and Discourse. Narrative Structure in Fiction and Film. Ithaca, NY 1978. Chatman 1990 Chatman, Seymour: Coming to Terms. The Rhetoric of Narrative in Fiction and Film. Ithaca, NY 1990. Dawkins 1976 Dawkins, Richard: The Selfish Gene. New York 1976.
22
Marie-Laure Ryan
Don 1990 Don, Abbe: “Narrative and the Interface.” In: Laurel, Brenda (ed.): The Art of Computer Interface. Redding, Mass. 1990:383–391 Fludernik 1996 Fludernik, Monika: Towards a ‘Natural’ Narratology. London 1996. Gaudreault / Jost 1990 Gaudreault, André / Jost, François: Le récit cinématographique. Paris 1990. Genette 1972 Genette, Gérard: Figure III. Paris 1972. Genette 1988 Genette, Gérard: Narrative Discourse Revisited. Translated by Jane Lewin. Ithaca, NY 1988. Heise 2002 Heise, Ursula K.: “Unnatural Ecologies: The Metaphor of the Environment in Media Theory.” In: Configurations 10.1, 2002:149–168. Jahn 2003 Jahn, Manfred: “‘Awake! Open Your Eyes!’ The Cognitive Logic of External and Internal Stories.” In: Herman, David: Narrative Theory and the Cognitive Sciences. Stanford 2003:195–213. Knowlton / Spellman / Hight (no date) Knowlton, Jeff / Spellman, Naomi / Hight, Jeremy: 34 North 118 West. [Accessed 17 July 2004] Lessing 1984 Lessing, Gotthold Ephraim: Laocoon: An Essay on the Limits of Painting and Poetry. Translation and introduction by Edward Allen McCormick. Baltimore 1984. Lyotard 1984 Lyotard, Jean-François: The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge. Translated by Geoff Bennington and Brian Massumi. Minneapolis 1984. McLuhan / McLuhan / Zingrobe 1996 McLuhan, Marshall / McLuhan, Eric / Zingrobe, Frank: Essential McLuhan. New York 1996 Metz 1974 Metz, Christian: Film Language. A Semiotics of the Cinema. Translated by Michael Taylor. New York 1974. Ong 1982 Ong, Walter J.: Orality and Literacy. The Technologizing of the Word. London 1982. Pratt 1977 Pratt, Mary Louise: Toward a Speech Act Theory of Literary Discourse. Bloomington 1977. Prince 1982 Prince, Gerald: Narratology: The Forms and Functions of Narrative. The Hague 1982. Prince 1987 Prince, Gerald: Dictionary of Narratology. Lincoln, Neb. 1987. Richardson 2000 Richardson, Brian: “Recent Concepts of Narrative and the Narratives of Narrative Theory.” In: Style 34.2, 2000:168–175.
Foundations of Transmedial Narratology
23
Rimmon-Kenan 1989 Rimmon-Kenan, Shlomith: “How the Model Neglects the Medium: Linguistics, Language, and the Crisis of Narratology.” In: The Journal of Narrrative Technique 19.1, 1989:157–166. Ryan 2004 Ryan, Marie-Laure: “Introduction.” In: Ryan, Marie-Laure (ed.): Narrative Across Media: The Languages of Storytelling. Lincoln, Neb. 2004:1–40. Sutton-Smith 1997 Sutton-Smith, Brian: The Ambiguity of Play. Cambridge, Mass. 1997. Thompson 2003 Thompson, Kristin: Storytelling in Film and Television. Cambridge, Mass. 2003. White 1981 White, Hayden: “The Value of Narrativity in the Representation of History.” In: Mitchell, W.J.T. (ed.): On Narrative. Chicago 1981:1–23. Wolf 2002 Wolf, Werner: “Das Problem der Narrativität in Literatur, bildender Kunst und Musik: Ein Beitrag zu einer intermedialen Erzähltheorie.” In: Nünning, Vera / Nünning, Ansgar (eds.): Erzähltheorie transgenerisch, intermedial, interdisziplinär. Trier 2002:23–104. Wolf 2003 “Narrative and Narrativity: A Narratological Reconceptualization and its Applicability to the Visual Arts.” In: Word and Image 19.3, 2003: 180–197. Worth 1981 Worth, Sol: “Pictures Can’t Say Ain’t.” In: Gross, Larry (ed.): Studies in Visual Communication. Philadelphia 1981.
The Double Dynamics of Focalization in W. G. Sebald’s The Rings of Saturn Silke Horstkotte (Leipzig) It is frequently observed that the twentieth century has been a century of images.1 The omnipresence of images in newspapers and magazines, advertisements, film, and video, and on TV, computers, and the Internet has led scholars such as Barbara Stafford (1994) and Martin Jay (1996) to conclude that Western culture is currently undergoing a shift in which the visual medium, traditionally thought to be playing a secondary role as the illustration of text, is emerging as the dominant paradigm of thought. Associated with the new omnipresence of images are new ways of thinking about images and new modes of cultural analysis, which are no longer predicated on the arbitrary and shifting sign relations associated with textuality, but rather on phenomena such as spectatorship and the gaze. This ‘iconic’ or ‘pictorial turn’ has been hailed as a major epistemological shift by Gottfried Boehm (1994) and W.J.T. Mitchell (1994:11–34). Mitchell’s and Boehm’s argument that images do not represent isolated intruders into a textual universe, but rather constitute a new paradigm of thought, may be extended by inquiring into the conception of culture implied by the iconic turn. What happens if we treat culture not as a text, but as a repository of images? Such an iconic conceptualization of culture would require a modified methodology of cultural analysis which would account more closely for phenomena of looking and spectatorship than the traditional methods of textual analysis have done. Furthermore, an iconic methodology of cultural analysis might yield a more interactive concept of the relation between cultural artifacts and their recipients, as the model of a communicative vision developed by Mieke Bal indicates (1996:255–288). Drawing on Norman Bryson’s distinction between the gaze (a mode of vision that denies its historical and embodied nature and thus objectifies the contemplated object) and the glance (an active, engaged and embodied vision), Bal argues for a mode of vision that grants agency to both par1
The research for this article was supported by a fellowship within the Postdoc program of the German Academic Exchange Service (DAAD).
26
Silke Horstkotte
ties—the embodied, looking subject, and the contemplated (cultural) object (cf. Bryson 1983, 1988, 1994). Such a mode of looking would have to involve the subject within the field of vision, for ‘the awareness of one’s own engagement in the act of looking entails the recognition that what one sees is a representation, not an objective reality’ (Bal 1996:264). On the other hand, granting agency to visual objects implies that images ‘can be construed as theoretical objects that ›theorize‹ cultural history’, and that images actively participate in cultural dialogue (Bal 1999:5–7). What could an iconic methodology of cultural analysis look like? While wholly agreeing that cultural theory needs to treat images more seriously, I do not find it particularly useful to simply replace the textual paradigm with a visual or iconic one, thereby exchanging one set of critical buzzwords for another. Such an exchange runs the danger of artificially separating the iconic from the textual paradigm. Yet the interaction between words and visual images is fraught with ambiguities, complexities and contradictions. The ways in which images function in Western culture are inextricably linked with verbal and textual structures and ways of thinking, just as textual analysis cannot do without an intimate knowledge of how images work. In the following analysis, I shall therefore draw on an existing model of textual analysis that can be modified to account for the interaction of textual culture with the new iconic paradigm: the model of narratology. Narratology offers the means to analyze visual as well as verbal works of art and is therefore eminently suited to an inquiry into the relation between visual and textual culture. The kind of narratology I am envisioning here would thus be an intermedial narratology which deals with the analysis of artifacts that explicitly combine verbal and visual discourses. The iconic paradigm need not be restricted to visual artifacts. In fact, literature is one paradigmatic medium in which the exchange between words and images is negotiated. The last fifteen years have seen the publication of an increasing number of textual artifacts that explicitly incorporate or evoke visual material. My research focuses on one such body of texts: literary narratives that use photographs—imaginary or narrated as well as graphically reproduced ones—in order to depict the Second World War and the memory processes involved in its cultural transmission. These are the works of W.G. Sebald, especially The Rings of Saturn (2002b; 1998), The Emigrants (1993; 1996) and Austerlitz (2001; 2002a), as well as László Márton’s Die schattige Hauptstraße (2003); Monika Maron’s Pawels Briefe (2001); Marcel Beyer, Spione (2000); Rachel Seiffert, The Dark Room (2001); Ulla Hahn, Unscharfe Bilder (2003); Stefan Wackwitz, Ein unsichtbares Land (2003); and the recent re-publication of Peter Henisch’s Die kleine Figur meines Vaters (2003), among others. These texts clearly demonstrate the impossibility of strictly separating verbal and visual as-
Double Dynamics of Focalization
27
pects, while at the same time highlighting the representational nature of images. All of them are characterized by highly sophisticated interactions between images and words, or pictorial and verbal discourses, in which images are not cast in the role of subordinate illustrations to the dominant verbal text, but are equal partners of verbality within an intermedial fabric. I have chosen to use the term ‘discourse’, rather than the more common ‘medium’, because images and words are not just different kinds of representation, they also imply separate cultural values and distinct codes, conventions and channels, as well as different sensory, cognitive and affective modes. Hence, this corpus of novels is symptomatic of a type of intermedial discourse that can no longer be adequately described from within the textual paradigm of culture, but which requires a modified, more visually oriented set of interpretive tools. One author who has played a key role for the new literary use of images is the late W. G. Sebald, whose travelogue The Rings of Saturn constitutes my object of analysis in this article. Typically for Sebald’s works, The Rings of Saturn include many graphically reproduced images and photographs which stand in an uneasy, often ambiguous relation with the surrounding verbal discourse. Sebald’s text raises numerous questions, all of which ultimately concern the complex relation of visual and verbal discourses. An analysis of The Rings of Saturn will therefore have to use concepts which—like their object—combine verbal and iconic paradigms. I am thinking here particularly of narratological theories of focalization. In the analysis of linguistic narrative, the concept of focalization is used to refer to the story represented, as opposed to the concept of narration, referring to the representation of a story. Thus, as Gérard Genette and especially Mieke Bal have pointed out, every linguistic narrative contains a focalizor ‘distinguished in function, not identity, from the narrator’ (1997: 163; cf. Genette 1972). Older terms for focalization are ‘perspective’ or ‘point of view’, but these terms are problematic because they do not clearly distinguish between the levels of story (focalization) and text (narration) and can therefore apply to narration as well as to focalization. Through its basis in the notion of perspective, focalization is associated with matters of vision; it is therefore a concept bridging textuality and visuality, and can be fruitfully employed to analyze artifacts that combine the visual and the verbal. Mieke Bal has pointed out that, unlike the older terms ‘point of view’ and ‘perspective’, focalization entails asking ‘not primarily, where the words come from and who speaks them, but what is being proposed for us to believe or see before us’ (1997:224). Thus, focalization refers to the ‘vision through which the elements [of a story] are presented’ rather than to ‘the identity of the voice that is verbalizing that vision’ (Bal 1997:143). Thus, Focalization can serve to conceptualize
28
Silke Horstkotte
the visual aspects inherent in all narrative. On the other hand, it may be used to develop novel approaches toward the interpretation of non-narrative visual artifacts, as Bal has convincingly argued (1997:161–170). Still, what I propose here is not a transmedial narratology in the sense of a set of universal, media-independent tools of interpretation, but rather a series of strategic combinations of models and concepts which differ for each object of analysis. In the following case study, Bryson’s distinction between the gaze and the glance is combined with a concept of focalization that has its roots in Bal’s theory of narratology, which is itself already strongly oriented toward the visual. Since my object of analysis is an intermedial narrative, it is no coincidence that my analytic model draws on authors who are themselves working in the area between visual and textual studies. Focalization is a useful tool towards a communicative conception of vision for several reasons. Firstly, focalization emphasizes the visual nature of reception processes, including the reception of literary works. Secondly, since focalization inevitably colors the reader’s perception of the narrative, it implies a dynamic relation between the artifact (‘what is being proposed’) and its recipients (‘for us to believe or see before us’), or—conversely—between analysis and practice. Furthermore, unlike the terms ‘points of view’ or ‘perspective’, which only indicate a structural position, ‘focalization’ can be used both as a verb (to focalize) and as a subjective noun (focalizor). Thus, the concept of focalization can be used to conceptualize the element of agency inherent in the reception process. Furthermore, focalization stresses the practice and processuality of narrative instead of conceptualizing narrative as a finished product. As an indirect proposal which colors the narrative and thus strongly influences the reader’s perception, focalization is also that aspect of the narrative which most closely ties in with the novel’s reception. Within the dynamic interaction between cultural object and contemplating subject, which can be understood as a relation of framing (Culler 1988; Bal 2002:133–173), a second dynamic can be situated. This concerns the relation between verbal and visual discourses, which mingle to produce the intermedial rhetoric which characterizes The Rings of Saturn. That second, intratextual dynamic may be understood as a performative arrangement, in which the verbal and the visual link up to form a topographic structure—the printed surface of the intermedial text. However, this arrangement is never a final product, since it results from a performative process which occurs at the reception level. Hence, the concept of the performative, as it is used here, implies a dynamics which occurs in time, while at the same time drawing on the spatial positioning of images and verbal text in the printed book. In this sense, performativity is not only a result of agency, but also an aesthetic effect.
Double Dynamics of Focalization
29
The dynamic model appears to harbor more analytic potential than static concepts of image-text relations such as illustration or ekphrasis, which are premised on the secondary and subservient role of pictorial discourse (cf. Boehm 1995; Krieger 1992). Through the concept of focalization, the exhibitory strategies of Sebald’s intermedial ‘image-’ or ‘iconotext’ may be conceived of as active gestures, rather than fixed combinations of text and image (Mitchell 1994; Wagner 1995, 1996). Within the theory of intermediality developed by Peter Wagner, ‘iconotext’ refers to ‘an artefact in which the verbal and the visual signs mingle to produce rhetoric that depends on the co-presence of words and images’ (Wagner 1996:16). Thus, an iconotext does not simply combine two separate media, but is a truly intermedial fabric in which the two media are inseparably bound up with each other, even if they never blur or merge entirely. Instead of looking for distinct ‘messages’ dictated by each of the two media, the analysis of iconotexts would therefore have to ask what sort of functional features textual and pictorial discourse employ within the communication of cultural object and contemplating subject. In The Rings of Saturn, the respective functions of photography and verbal discourse are intimately bound up with the model of cultural memory developed by the anonymous homodiegetic narrator. Sebald’s book is a somewhat disjointed account, in ten chapters, of the narrator’s walking tour through Suffolk, on which the narrator is confronted ‘with the traces of destruction, reaching far back into the past, that were evident even in that remote place’ (RS 3 / 11).2 The narrator visits many ‘relics of an earlier age’ (RS 90 / 112) and meets numerous refugees, diasporic and exilic characters. As in the novels of Thomas Bernhard, one of the key influences in Sebald’s writing, the narrative agent is mainly a reflecting consciousness, rather than acting person. The narration takes place in retrospect and is shot through with references to the narrator’s present situation, and with recollections from his earlier past, as well as embedded, intradiegetic narratives detailing the history of the visited buildings and landmarks. A large number of these intradiegetic narratives concern the natural disasters that have plagued the region since times immemorial—towns swallowed by the sea (RS 155 / 187), the destruction of the environment—and the ensuing economic decline, which prompts the narrator to imagine himself ‘amidst the remains of our own civilization after its extinction in some future catastrophe’ (RS 237 / 282). This short quotation already indicates that the perspective of the narrator colors not only the extradiegetic narrative, but also the intradiegetic historical digressions. Thus, the internal focalizor of 2
RS = The Rings of Saturn. Page numbers refer to the English translation of The Rings of Saturn first, and to the German original second.
30
Silke Horstkotte
the represented stories is embedded within the function of the narrator, the agent responsible for the stories’ representation. The dominance of reflective and recollective parts of the narrative can be illustrated through a tentative statistic. Counting the sub-headings in the book’s table of contents, intradiegetic references to the destruction of the region account for about 12 % of the narrative, only slightly less than the story of the walking tour itself (with around 15 %). Approximately 18 % of the narrative is concerned with references to forgotten genocides and other mass disasters of history: the slaughter of 700,000 Serbs, Jews and Bosnians by the Croatian Ustasha (RS 97f / 119–121); the mass suicide of the Taipingis in 1853 (RS 141 / 169); the Chinese famine of the 1870s (RS 150 / 181); and the Irish Troubles (RS 214f / 255f), to name but a few. By far the largest part of the narrative—roughly 40%—consists of intertextual and other cultural references which have no direct connection with the narrator’s journey: references to Thomas Browne, especially to his essay on urn burial (RS 19–26 / 29–39); to the fiction of Jorge Luis Borges (RS 67–71 / 87–91); the biography of Joseph Conrad (RS 104–122 / 127–149); and to Rembrandt’s Anatomy Lesson of Dr. Tulp (RS 12–17 / 22–27), among other things. These references establish the main concern of the narrator: the construction of a texture of allusions to cultural history, to paintings (Rembrandt, Ruysdael) and to literary works (by Browne, Borges, Joseph Conrad, Goethe, Benjamin, Hölderlin and others), as well as references to Sebald’s other work, especially to The Emigrants (RS 86 / 106). The verbal narrative of The Rings of Saturn functions as a repository of cultural memory, and the narrator as its curator. His thoughts when reading the old log in the Sailors’ Reading room can be taken as programmatic in this respect: ‘Every time I decipher one of these entries I am astounded that a trail that has long since vanished from the air or the water remains visible here on the paper’ (RS 93 / 116). Like the old log book, The Rings of Saturn preserve the traces of a long-vanished past in visible form. This visible preservation of the past, in which the reproduced photographs act both as historical relics and as memory triggers, is premised on the idea of archaeological strata as a model for memory, which the narrator develops in interaction with Thomas Browne’s essay on urn burial (1658). According to this model, the past is not ‘another country’, but is co-present with the here and now: it is simply buried at a deeper layer. The Suffolk landscape which the narrator traverses is full of such material, visible memories: for instance, the ruined or half-ruined manor houses; cemeteries; or the wells of the vanished town Dunwich, which are still visible at low tide at the bottom of the sea (RS 155–157 / 187–189). The concept of memory developed by the narrator is topographical rather than temporal in orientation and relies on memorial objects as
Double Dynamics of Focalization
31
triggers for individual recollection. In the introduction to a volume of essays about material memory, Marius Kwint has convincingly argued that ‘objects form records: analogues to living memory, storing information beyond individual experience. Entering us through the senses, they become history, like the fragments that speak to the palaeontologist or geologist’ (Kwint 1999:2). But it is not only single objects that store, trigger, and shape the cultural memory The Rings of Saturn seek to preserve. Taken together, the individual objects constitute a topography of memory which is physically present in the Suffolk landscape, and which is also mirrored in the spatial arrangement of photography and verbal discourse within the printed text of the novel. By ‘spatial arrangement’, I do not refer to Joseph Frank’s ‘spatial form’ (1963), which dealt with the space-logic in modernist literature, but to the actual, visible arrangement of text and image in the printed book—the second part of the double dynamic described above, which forms the basis of the novel’s performative interaction with its readers and spectators. The images in Rings of Saturn should not be confused with actual photographs, since the latter are characterized by social uses, visual and material qualities quite distinct from those of photographic reproductions. Reproductions of the kind Sebald employs are copied from material photographs in a process called ‘screening’, which leads to substantial changes in the visual appearance of the images. For instance, screening accounts for the bad quality of many images in The Rings of Saturn (e.g. the photographs on pp. 97 / 120 and 103 / 125). Furthermore, the quality of the reproductions differs considerably between the various available editions of Sebald’s book. However, despite the significant differences between material and reproduced photographs, the images in The Rings of Saturn elicit many of the responses and affective reactions that are characteristic for interactions with actual photos. Nevertheless, it is important to keep in mind that the vision presented in the photos, i.e. their focalization, may be significantly influenced by changes in the photos’ reproduction. Moreover, while the reception of material photographs is premised on the mechanism of the ‘reality effect’, Sebald’s imaginative integration of photographic reproductions with verbal discourses foregrounds the representational nature of images.3 With the exception of Bal’s work, narratological theory has by and large neglected visual, spatial, and topographical structures. Werner Wolf expresses a broad consensus among narratologists when he describes 3
On the ideology of the ‘reality effect’, cf. Barthes (1982). Van Alphen (1997) has discussed the implications of this term for photographs, particularly in the context of discourses of memory and trauma. Cf. also my article on Sebald’s The Emigrants (2002).
32
Silke Horstkotte
narrating, the basis on which narrativity rests, as the representation of rudiments of an imaginable world, in which at least two different actions or states are centered on the same anthropomorphic characters, standing in a potentially meaningful, but not a necessary relation to each other (Wolf 2002:51). Even though Wolf points out that the basic units of a narrative have to be connected through more than mere chronology—i.e. that the connection between two events has to be motivated—chronology remains at the basis of his argument. Wolf concedes that images receive temporality through their reception process, which occurs in time (Wolf 2002:54), yet he assigns a low degree of narrativity to images, arguing that different media participate in narrativity to varying degrees. He then posits a ‘scale of narrativity’ characterized by the successively decreasing ratio of narremes (the constituent factors of narrativity inherent in a work of art, especially in a work of literature) to a narrativisation practiced by the recipient, which is characteristic of the reception of images (Wolf 2002:95f). The argument that poetry is temporal, and the graphic arts spatial, has a venerable tradition, dating back to Lessing’s Laocoon and beyond. However, W.J.T. Mitchell has persuasively argued that ‘works of art, like all other objects of human experience, are structures in space-time, and that the interesting problem is to comprehend a particular spatial-temporal construction, not to label it as temporal or spatial’ (Mitchell 1986:103). From a narratological point of view, whether literary texts can be described as spatial depends on which level of the narrative structure we focus on: the level of text, story, or fabula (Bal 1997).4 An analysis of Sebald’s iconotext has to concentrate on the layer of text, since this is the structural level occupied with representation, on which the photographs are situated and where visuality comes into play. It is also the surface on which the performative interaction with the reader / spectator occurs, while story and fabula are not part of the printed text, but constitute constructions of the reader. Temporality is an important element of the fabula (duration) and an integral aspect of the story (sequential ordering), but plays a subordinate role on the level of text, where it is restricted to the reception, which occurs in time. Space, on the other hand, is of supreme importance to the analysis of text, since it is on the level of text that the spatial arrangement of images and verbal discourse is situated.5
4
5
Bal’s model is more useful for my analysis than Genette’s (1980), since she conceptualizes the layer of representation as text (aesthetic product), rather than narration (enunciating act). Moreover, Bal treats focalization, which is my main interest in this article, more concisely than Genette does. On spatial structures in postmodern literature cf. also Bal (2003).
Double Dynamics of Focalization
33
The spatial arrangement of The Rings of Saturn is inspired by Thomas Browne’s “The Garden of Cyrus” (1658), which the narrator paraphrases at some length. In this essay, Browne described the ‘patterns which recur in the seemingly infinite diversity of forms’ (RS 19 / 31), paying special attention to the so-called ‘quincunx’, a pattern Browne saw repeated throughout animate and inanimate nature and which Sebald has reproduced in The Rings of Saturn (RS 20 / 31). Not only does the narrator set out to find these hidden patterns in the Suffolk landscape, but the novel as a whole constitutes such a spatial pattern through the ways in which photography and verbal text are arranged on the printed page. The arrangement of verbal discourse and photography transports a variety of meanings which have to be inferred by the reader / spectator, since the photographs are rarely explicitly mentioned in the verbal discourse. In Bal’s terms, the photos initiate a communication with the reader / spectator which situates the reader in a field of vision. The visual presence of the photographs compels the reader to actively engage with the novel’s topographic arrangement and to formulate an interpretation that integrates the verbal and visual discourses into a meaningful whole. In the reception process, the photos function as focalizing agents which color the reader’s reception of the verbal discourse and which therefore enter into a dialogue with the focalization of the verbal narrative. For instance, the photograph reproduced on p. 155 / 187 can be understood to represent the perspective of the narrator, which he describes immediately below the image: ‘It was as if I had been walking for hours before the tiled roofs of houses and the crest of a wooded hill gradually became defined.’ In narratological terms, the internal focalizor of this passage is embedded in the function of the homodiegetic narrator. Intriguingly, the photographic reproduction shows a wooded hill above a small scattering of houses in the background, suggesting that the focalizor of the photograph and that of the verbal narrative are identical. However, the verbal text does not make any explicit reference to the photograph. Hence, the relation between the pictorial and verbal parts of the iconotext, and thus the identification of the verbal and visual focalizors, rests entirely on the spatial proximity of image and verbal description. Combined with assumptions about the evidentiary character of photography, the photo’s positioning may be taken to indicate that the photograph functions as a visual illustration of the verbal text. Yet such a relation is nowhere made explicit in the verbal discourse and therefore constitutes an interpretive act of the reader / spectator. As a result, we must carefully distinguish between the visible iconotext of The Rings of Saturn, and the image-text relations constituted by the reader, which belong on the level of story.
34
Silke Horstkotte
Like the verbal discourse, the photographs reproduced in The Rings of Saturn are colored by focalization. Thus, we are dealing here with a double process of focalization, in which the performativity of the two focalizing agents of Rings of Saturn—the internal focalization embedded in the homodiegetic narrator, which is present in the creation of a fabric of allusions to literary and cultural history and in the interpretations the narrator gives to this history, and the complementary focalization of the photographs, which directs the ways in which the reader / spectator understands the verbal discourse—is inextricably linked with the interpretative agency of the reader / spectator. The distinction between focalizor and narrator is crucial in narrative. In visual art, however, it is not always possible to clearly discriminate between a narrative agent and the represented perspective. In an iconotext like The Rings of Saturn, this facilitates the identification of the visual focalizors with the focalizor of the verbal narrative, and, ultimately, with the narrator; especially since in photography, the photographer—the agent of the vision represented in the photo—cannot be represented within the photograph. In this, photos crucially differ from paintings, which can contain internal focalizors in the shape of characters looking into the represented space. This tendency to identify the two focalizors adds to the general difficulty of interpreting photographic images. Mitchell has convincingly argued that images are generally read differently from verbal texts. While text is read like a graduated thermometer, where every mark has a fixed value, a picture is normally ‘read’ in something like the way we read an ungraduated thermometer. Every mark, every modification, every curve or swelling of a line, every modification of texture or color is loaded with semantic potential. … The image is syntactically and semantically dense in that no mark may be isolated as a unique, distinctive character (like a letter of an alphabet), nor can it be assigned a unique reference or ‘compliant’ (Mitchell 1986:67).
At the same time, pictures acquire meaning to a large extent through the verbal discourses framing them, and through their usage in actual interaction. Photographs in particular are necessarily incomplete and context-dependant. Victor Burgin (1986:58) has therefore concluded that photography is not a purely visual medium but ‘a complex of exchanges between the verbal and the visual.’ In The Rings of Saturn, as I have indicated, these exchanges are premised on the spatial arrangement of verbal and visual discourses. Like the semantic potential of the image itself, the arrangement of visual and verbal discourses is also dense and polyvalent. In the passage preceding the reproduction of Roger Casement’s signature (RS 134 / 162), the spatial positioning of pictorial and verbal discourses strongly influences the semantic
Double Dynamics of Focalization
35
operation of the iconotext. Casement’s biography represents one of the many intradiegetic narratives intruding into the narrator’s account of his walking tour. Intriguingly, the narrator’s interest in Casement stems from a documentary film about Casement and Joseph Conrad which he missed almost completely when he fell asleep in front of the TV. The narrator then sets out to reconstruct this unseen film through a narrative account of Casement’s and Conrad’s lives. Roger Casement, a member of the Anglo-Irish ascendancy, met Joseph Conrad in the Congo, where Casement served as a British consul. He first became notorious for a report he wrote about the exploitation of the black population of the Congo under Belgian colonial rule—another historical catastrophe that the narrator tries to wrest from the threshold of cultural amnesia by including it in his narrative. Later, Casement became an advocate for Irish Home Rule; the Irish Troubles, too, are a recurring issue throughout The Rings of Saturn. In 1915, Casement traveled to Germany on a secret mission, determined to secure German help for the planned Dublin Easter Rising. However, his attempt remained unsuccessful, and Casement was returned to Ireland. At the time of the Easter Rising, he was already imprisoned in the Tower of London awaiting trial. Casement’s fate is intimately bound up with questions of mediation, and of authenticity and forgery, making it paradigmatic for the function of verbal and visual discourses in The Rings of Saturn. For Casement’s trial ultimately did not concern his participation in the planning of the Easter Rising, but rested on the contested authenticity of his diary: In order to preempt any petitions for pardon that might have been made by persons of influence, excerpts from what was known as the Black diary, a kind of chronicle of the accused’s homosexual relations found when Casement’s home was searched, were forwarded to the King of England, the President of the United States, and the Pope. The authenticity of this Black Diary, kept until recently under lock and key at the Public Records Office in Kew, was long considered highly debatable … But since the release to general scrutiny of the diaries in early 1994 there has no longer been any question that they are in Casement’s own hand (RS 131–34 / 159–62).
This passage of the verbal narrative is interrupted by the two-page reproduction of a handwritten diary page, presumably from Casement’s diary—since The Rings of Saturn do not include a list of illustrations, the reader / spectator cannot be entirely certain of this. This diary page is highly suggestive for my line of inquiry because it subverts the opposition between visual and verbal discourses and thus clearly indicates that images are just as much part of the text as the verbal narrative. After all, the diary page is both a visual reproduction and a verbal text. As an autographic source, it also represents a more embodied form of writing than the conventional
36
Silke Horstkotte
typesetting of the verbal narrative.6 Such an embodied writing has consequences for the reception process. While the modern norm of silent reading has come to be regarded as a purely cognitive act, the deciphering of handwriting is much more closely associated with vision and looking, hence, with activities that involve not only the mind, but also the body of the recipient. The reproduction of Casement’s handwriting therefore draws attention to the visual and embodied nature of all reception processes. Equally suggestive as the diary page itself is its relationship to the reproduction of Casement’s signature one page later (RS 134 / 162). First of all, the signature seems to confirm that the Black Diary was indeed written by Casement himself. Immediately following the reproduced diary pages, the signature may be understood as a signature to the diary—even though there is a passage of intervening verbal discourse between the two reproductions, as well as a long time gap in the dates (the diary is dated 1903, the signature, 1916). Secondly, the presumed relation between Casement’s diary and his signature raises questions about notions of authorship and authority, as well as about the relation between the autographic and the allographic, which concern the connection between the two facsimile reproductions and the verbal narrative. The establishment of such a connection rests entirely on the specific positioning of the verbal and iconic texts. The crucial importance of this spatial arrangement becomes obvious when one compares the German and English editions of The Rings of Saturn. In the German original, Casement’s signature is inserted into the verbal text directly after the last sentence quoted above. In the English translation, however, the signature has been moved to the end of the paragraph, which also concludes the entire chapter. The changed positioning of the signature is significant because it invites a different reading of the preceding narrative. By placing the signature at the end of the chapter, it comes to resemble the signature under a letter or document, thereby bestowing a high degree of authority upon the preceding account of Casement’s life, his trial, sentencing and execution: the authority of the writer’s signature. Thus, the placement of the signature in the English translation might be taken to suggest that Casement himself has authorized the preceding account of his life. The differences between the German original and the English translation point to a fundamental problem when analyzing iconotexts: it is not always clear whether the arrangement of verbal and visual discourses is part of the text (and thus controlled by the narrator), or if it touches
6
The aesthetic implications of handwriting have been discussed by Sonja Neef (2000).
Double Dynamics of Focalization
37
upon the paratextual, which lies outside the scope of the narrator, since it concerns the material production of the book, upon which even the writer may have limited influence. Obviously, this is especially problematic in the case of the translation. One result of this ambiguity concerning the positioning of images is that the borders of the iconotext dissolve, since there is no overarching authority guaranteeing its unity of meaning. However, if the unity of the text is put under erasure, the text itself can no longer be clearly distinguished from its dynamic interaction with the reader / spectator. The third semantic field implied by Casement’s signature (both through its positioning and through the inclusion of the date) is that of a tombstone or epitaph—thereby highlighting, once again, the narrative’s function as a material repository of memory. And finally, since the last sentence of the chapter mentions the exhumation of Casement’s remains in 1965, the positioning of the signature establishes a strong connection between Casement’s body of writing and his mortal body. Thus, the inclusion of photographs stresses the spatial and visual dimensions of the text, which tend to be overlooked in narratological analyses, while simultaneously foregrounding the interpretive agency of the reader / spectator. Specifically, the photographic reproduction of handwritten sources draws attention to the embodied nature of writing, which engages the whole body of the reader / spectator by freeing it from the constraints of a purely cognitive conception of reading. Although spatial structures are most obvious in the arrangement of visual and verbal discourses, they also play a prominent role within the verbal narrative. The narrator’s journey does not adhere to the structural model of a sequence of events in time, but is shaped as a topography of places visited. Even the various historical digressions are connected through analogy and association rather than through temporal causality. The analogy between the Belgian colonial rule in the Congo and the Irish struggle for Home Rule, for instance, is predicated on an associative logic which subordinates chronology to a memorial topography constructed by the narrator, and which is therefore closely related to the intermedial arrangement of the iconotext. If The Rings of Saturn is a text about journeys and space, it is also a meta-topographic text that exposes the technique of iconotextual arranging as the structural principle of its narrative. The narrator’s dream about the maze at Somerleyton which he believes ‘had been created solely for me’ and which ‘represented a cross-section of my brain’ can be read as a self-conscious reference to the spatial arrangement of the iconotext (RS 173 / 206). Topographical thinking is also responsible for the narratorial strategy of ‘going the wrong way’ (RS 84 / 105), and for the recurring re-
38
Silke Horstkotte
presentations of exterritorial and fantastic space. One such fantastic place is Somerleyton palace, which not only demonstrates the spatial structure of time, but at the same time highlights the unreality of space itself, since it seems to open up into several incommensurable dimensions at once: There are indeed moments, as one passes through the rooms … at Somerleyton, when one is not quite sure whether one is in a country house in Suffolk or some kind of no-man’s-land, on the shores of the Arctic Ocean or in the heart of the dark continent. Nor can one readily say which decade or century it is, for many ages are superimposed here and coexist (RS 36 / 49).
Here, both time and space appear to be composed of numerous layers of reality, and indeed, the picture of Somerleyton reproduced in the novel looks less like an English country house than like an utterly fantastical Kubla Khan’s palace (RS 34 / 47). Following Tzvetan Todorov’s famous definition of the fantastic (1973), the superimposition of many times and spaces may be understood as a fantastic structure. Stanley Cavell has summed up Todorov’s argument as follows: the fantastic is linked to ‘such ideas as that of the imaginary journey, especially in quest of the self; and such ideas as that of being on some boundary or threshold, as between the impossible and the possible; and ideas of the confrontation of otherness; and of some adverse relation to the modern scientific sensibility’ (Cavell 1988:183). The narrative of The Rings of Saturn confirms this pattern in a number of ways. The foregrounding of topographic structures and the association with a wide range of historical events lends a strongly imaginary quality to the narrator’s journey; indeed, the quotation comparing the maze at Somerleyton to the narrator’s own brain reveals his journey as a ‘quest of the self’. Boundaries and thresholds play a central part in this strange internal journey, as does the confrontation of otherness. Many of the places the narrator visits serve as thresholds into another, or indeed into numerous other, dimensions. The neglected and dust-covered Ashbury House in Ireland, which the narrator had visited on a former occasion, is another example of fantastic space. The sad state of the Ashbury mansion is the result of one of the many historical catastrophes touched upon in The Rings of Saturn: the Irish civil war, which, while freeing the country from British colonial rule, also dealt the deathblow to an entire social class. The Ashburys are some of the last members of the former Anglo-Irish ascendancy still living in their Big House. This gives them a ghostly and strangely exterritorial appearance, and turns their half-ruined mansion into a fantastic threshold that also threatens to dissolve the narrator’s consciousness: ‘Whenever I rested on that bed over the next few days, my consciousness began to dissolve at the edges, so that at times I could hardly have said how I had
Double Dynamics of Focalization
39
got there or indeed where I was’ (RS 210 / 250). The imaginary dissolution of time and space then leads the narrator to fantasize about yet another terrible site of destruction: ‘what I saw in my mind’s eye was … a battlefield somewhere in Lombardy over which the vultures circled, and, all around, a country laid waste by war’ (ibid.). However, the intrusion of exterritorial states is not restricted to the narrator’s consciousness; for instance, Mrs. Ashbury also mentions the ‘feeling’, after her marriage, that she was ‘completely out of this world’ in Ashbury House (RS 214 / 255). Moreover, the Ashbury house is linked not only with exterritorial, but also with supernatural modes of making sense of experience: because nobody wants (or can afford) to buy the mansion, the surviving Ashburys remain ‘tied to it, like damned souls to their place’ (RS 219f / 262). The motive of exterritorial and fantastic space introduces a mythical dimension into the narrative—a historical depth that is laden with symbolism. The Suffolk landscape acquires depth not only because it is composed of archaeological strata, but also through this fantastic double-structure, which rests almost entirely on the subjective perception of the narrator. The juxtaposition of disasters from different regions and eras of history indicates that the narrator searches not only for specific historical relics, but also for ‘fundamental patterns of human behaviour’ (RS 159 / 191)—the cultural equivalent of Browne’s quincunx. The topography of The Rings of Saturn is a memorial and imaginative construction, rather than a realistic representation of space. The fantastic dimension of the narrative dissolves not only the borders between various historical periods and geographies, but also the thresholds of time and space. Traveling emerges as a movement which challenges the distinction between space and time. The narrator’s journey is marked by fantastic disjunctions of time: he uses a guidebook ‘published shortly after the turn of the [twentieth] century’ (RS 42 / 57) and encounters people ‘dressed in the style of the Thirties’ (RS 43 / 57f). Frequently, the narrator even has the impression that the people he meets belong to a different time and space altogether, as in this description of Lowestoft beach: ‘It is as if the last stragglers of some nomadic people had settled there, at the outermost limit of the earth, in expectation of the miracle longed for since time immemorial, the miracle which would justify all their erstwhile privations and wanderings’ (RS 51f / 68). This is no more than a figment of the narrator’s imagination, for in the next sentence, he concedes: ‘In reality, however, these men camping out under the heavens have not traversed faraway lands and deserts to reach this strand. Rather, they are from the immediate neighbourhood …’ (RS 52 / 68). Nevertheless, the first image is so striking that the two explanations remain side by side—a distinctly fantastic structure: this undecidability, which hovers ambiguously between
40
Silke Horstkotte
rationalistic and supernatural modes of making sense of experience, is a key issue in Todorov’s definition of the fantastic. The undecidability of the fantastic is conspicuous in the narrator’s encounter with what initially appears to be a couple making love on the beach: ‘A couple lay down there, in the bottom of the pit, as I thought: a man stretched full length over another body of which nothing was visible but the legs, spread and angled’ (RS 68 / 88). As so often in The Rings of Saturn, this realistic impression quickly gives way to the narrator’s fantastic and uncanny associations: ‘In the startled moment when that image went through me, which lasted an eternity, it seemed as if the man’s feet twitched like those of one just hanged’ (ibid.). Even stranger than the association with a hanged man is the following comparison with a two-headed sea monster, which soon takes on a reality of its own in the eyes of the narrator. ‘Misshapen, like some great mollusc washed ashore, they lay there, to all appearances a single being, a many-limbed, two-headed monster that had drifted in from far out at sea …’ (ibid.). Characteristically for The Rings of Saturn, the narrator’s highly subjective and imaginative vision is connected with a catastrophic view of (natural) history, for this great beast is perceived to be ‘the last of a prodigious species, its life ebbing from it with each breath expired through its nostrils.’ At first, the misshapen beast is just a simile (‘like some great mollusc … they lay there’). As the narrative progresses, however, the rhetorical trope turns into a subjective reality, and the narrator becomes confused about what he has or has not seen. He seriously considers the possibility that he really saw a sea monster on the beach: ‘Before I reached the town, the first drops of rain were falling. I turned to look back down the deserted stretch I had come by, and could no longer have said whether I had really seen the pale sea monster at the foot of the Covehithe cliffs or whether I had imagined it’ (RS 69). Intriguingly, the initial sight of a couple making love on the beach has now been completely displaced by the fantastic vision of a sea monster. This progressive move away from rationalistic and towards supernatural and imaginative ways of making sense of experience is then linked to Borges’s story “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius”, an important intertext for The Rings of Saturn, and to Borges’ narrator’s attempt to create secondary and tertiary worlds. Not only does the narrator of Rings of Saturn here explicitly align himself with a highly fantastic mode of storytelling, but also with a meta-fictional form of narrative that corresponds closely with his own strategies. The narrator’s walk on the Covehithe beach reveals focalization as a performative process that closely implicates the reader. The vision of the internal focalizor constantly evolves: from the description of a couple on the beach, through the comparison with a great sea beast, which is then
Double Dynamics of Focalization
41
turned into a real sight, towards an utterly fantastic perspective in which both possibilities become equally strange. This alienating change of perspective highlights the strongly visual qualities of the verbal narrative. At the same time, it leads to the recognition that what the reader sees is a representation, not a reality. The meta-fictional and openly artificial aspects of the verbal narrative reflect on the status of the reproduced images, which resist conventional ways of seeing. There is nothing ‘authentic’ or ‘evidentiary’ about the photographs in The Rings of Saturn, with their unfocused, often grainy appearance, their maddeningly uncertain provenance and their highly suggestive, yet entirely implicit relationship with the verbal discourse. Instead of illustrating the verbal text and visually confirming its message, the photographs enable the reader / spectator to adopt a fantastic double vision that closely corresponds to the focalization embedded in the homodiegetic narrator. In this fantastic mode of seeing, time and space open up into multiple dimensions, words and images merge, and nothing is what it seems. The fantastic mode of storytelling, with the resulting, topographically structured iconotext, enables a new concept of focalization. This is a focalization which does not rigidly control the reader’s gaze, but allows it to remain mobile and to roam freely across the topographic terrain. The double focalization inherent in the combination of verbal and visual discourses always offers the reader several alternative choices how to interpret the relation between the different parts of the iconotext. At the same time, this topographic and fantastic principle enters into the verbal narrative itself, as in the passage on the Covehithe beach. The topography of the iconotext thus emerges as a field in which the reader / spectator can choose to follow different paths. With the mobile gaze, this mode of reception involves the whole body of the reader / spectator, not just his or her cognitive capacities. Characteristic of W.G. Sebald’s works, the topographical model developed in The Rings of Saturn offers an alternative to the problematic view that conceptualizes visual art in static opposition to verbal narrative and relegates the visual domain to the illustration of verbal texts. Instead, the Rings establish a communicative relation between embodied subject and contemplated object that is predicated on the interactive vision of the ‘glance’.
42
Silke Horstkotte
References Alphen 1997 Alphen, Ernst van: Caught by History: Holocaust Effects in Contemporary Art, Literature, and Theory. Stanford, CA 1997. Bal 1996 Bal, Mieke: Double Exposures: The Subject of Cultural Analysis. London / New York 1996. Bal 1997 Bal, Mieke: Narratology. Introduction to the Theory of Narrative. 2. ed. Toronto 1997. Bal 1999 Bal, Mieke: Quoting Caravaggio: Contemporary Art, Preposterous History. Chicago 1999. Bal 2002 Bal, Mieke: Travelling Concepts in the Humanities: A Rough Guide. Toronto 2002. Bal 2003 Bal, Mieke: “Critique of Voice: The Open Score of Her Face.” In: Pderi, N. (ed.): Travelling Concepts III: Memory, Narrative, Image. Amsterdam 2003:91–114. Barthes 1982 Barthes, Roland: “L’effet de réel.” In: Barthes, Roland: Litterature et réalité. Paris 1982. Beyer 2000 Beyer, Marcel: Spione. Köln 2000. Boehm 1994 Boehm, Gottfried: “Die Wiederkehr der Bilder.” In: Boehm, G. (ed.): Was ist ein Bild? München 1994:11–38. Boehm 1995 Boehm, Gottfried: “Bildbeschreibung. Über die Grenzen von Bild und Sprache.” In: Boehm, G. / Pfotenhauer, H. (eds.): Beschreibungskunst – Kunstbeschreibung. Ekphrasis von der Antike bis zur Gegenwart. München 1995: 23–40. Browne 1658 Browne, Sir Thomas: Hydriotaphia, urne-burial: or, A discourse of the sepulchrall urnes lately found in Norfolk = Together with The garden of Cyrus, or, The quincuniall, lozenge, or net-work plantations of the ancients, artificially, naturally, mystically considered/with sundry observations. London 1685. Facsim. ed, The Noel Douglas replicas. London 1927. Bryson 1983 Bryson, Norman: Vision and Painting. The Logic of the Gaze. London 1983. Bryson 1988 Bryson, Norman: “The Gaze in the Expanded Field.” In: Forster, H. (ed.): Vision and Visuality. San Francisco 1988:87–114. Bryson 1994 Bryson, Norman: “Art in Context.” In: Bal, M. / Boer, I. (eds.): The Point of Theory: Practices of Cultural Analysis. New York 1994:66–78.
Double Dynamics of Focalization
43
Burgin 1986 Burgin, Victor: The End of Art Theory: Criticism and Post-Modernity. Atlantic Highlights, NJ 1986. Cavell, Stanley 1988 Cavell, Stanley: “The Fantastic of Philosophy.” In: Cavell, S. (ed.): In Quest of the Ordinary. Lines of Skepticism and Romanticism. Chicago 1988:181–188. Culler 1988 Culler, Jonathan: Framing the Sign: Criticism and Its Institutions. Norman, Okl. 1988. Frank 1963 Frank, Joseph: “Spatial Form in Modern Literature.” In: Frank, J.: The Widening Gyre: Crisis and Mastery in Modern Literature. New Brunswick, NJ 1945:3–62. Genette 1972 Genette, Gérard: Figures III. Paris 1972. Genette 1980 Genette, Gérard: Narrative Discourse: An Essay in Method. Translated by J.E. Lewin. Ithaca, NY 1980. Hahn 2003 Hahn, Ulla: Unscharfe Bilder. München 2003. Henisch 2003 Henisch, Peter: Die kleine Figur meines Vaters. Salzburg / Wien 2003. Horstkotte 2002 Horstkotte, Silke: “Pictorial and Verbal Discourse in W.G. Sebald’s The Emigrants.” In: Iowa Journal of Cultural Studies (2), 2002:33–50. Jay 1996 Jay, Martin: “Vision in Context: Reflections and Refractions.” In: Brennan, T./Jay, M. (eds.): Vision in Context: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives on Sight. New York 1996:1–12. Krieger 1992 Krieger, Murray: Ekphrasis. The Illusion of the Natural Sign. Baltimore 1992. Kwint, Marius 1999 Kwint, Marius: “Introduction: The Physical Past.” In: Kwint, M. / Breward, C. / Aynsley, J. (eds.): Material Memories. Oxford / New York 1999:1–16. Maron 2001 Maron, Monika: Pawels Briefe. Frankfurt / Main 2001. Márton 2003 Márton, Lászlo: Die schattige Hauptstraße. Wien 2003. Mitchell 1986 Mitchell, W.J.T.: Iconology. Image, Text, Ideology. Chicago 1986. Mitchell 1994 Mitchell, W.J.T.: Picture Theory: Essays on Verbal and Visual Representation. Chicago 1994. Neef 2000 Neef, Sonja: Kalligramme. Zur Medialität einer Schrift, anhand von Paul van Ostaijens “De feesten van angst en pijn”. Amsterdam 2000. Sebald 1993 Sebald, W.G.: Die Ausgewanderten. Vier lange Geschichten. Frankfurt / Main 1993.
44
Silke Horstkotte
Sebald 1996 Sebald, W.G.: The Emigrants. Translated by M. Hulse. London 1996. Sebald 1998 Sebald, W.G.: The Rings of Saturn. Translated by M. Hulse. London 1998. Sebald 2001 Sebald, W.G.: Austerlitz. München 2001. Sebald 2002a Sebald, W.G.: Austerlitz. Translated by A. Bell. London 2002. [Original edition: London 2001.] Sebald 2002b Sebald, W.G.: Die Ringe des Saturn. Eine englische Wallfahrt. 5. ed. Frankfurt / Main 2002. [Original edition: Frankfurt / Main 1995.] Seiffert 2001 Seiffert, Rachel: The Dark Room. London 2001. Stafford 1994 Stafford, Barbara: Artful Science, Enlightenment Entertainment and the Eclipse of Visual Education. Cambridge, MA 1994. Todorov 1973 Todorov, Tzvetan: The Fantastic: A Structural Approach to a Literary Genre. Translated by R. Howard. Ithaca, NY 1973. Wackwitz 2003 Wackwitz, Stefan: Ein unsichtbares Land. Familienroman. Frankfurt / Main 2003. Wagner 1995 Wagner, Peter: Reading Iconotexts: From Swift to the French Revolution. London 2003. Wagner 1996 Wagner, Peter: “Introduction: Ekphrasis, Iconotexts, and Intermediality – the State(s) of the Art(s).” In: Wagner, P. (ed.): Icons – Texts – Iconotext. Essays on Ekphrasis and Intermediality. Berlin / New York 1996:1–40. Wolf 2002 Wolf, Werner: “Das Problem der Narrativität in Literatur, bildender Kunst und Musik: Ein Beitrag zu einer intermedialen Erzähltheorie.” In: Nünning, V. / Nünning, A. (eds.): Erzähltheorie transgenerisch, intermedial, interdisziplinär. Trier 2002:23–104.
Levels of Play and Narration Britta Neitzel (Tampere)
1. Introduction Writing an article for this collection of conference papers puts me in an unfamiliar position. Most of the audiences that I have addressed in recent years have had a reasonable or better understanding of the concepts of story, narrative, and narration, but little knowledge of narratology, being familiar with computer games instead. I now find myself in the opposite situation—I can be certain that my readers know a lot about narratology, but I am not sure how familiar they are with computer games. When reading the abstracts for the papers presented at the conference, I was lulled into a false sense of security by the secondary literature cited in them. False, because I am not really a narratologist at all (I have always associated narratology with literary theory) but a student of media studies who uses narratology to analyse certain aspects of computer games. I would also describe myself as someone interested in the uses of narratology beyond literary theory and in the outer extremes of the range of phenomena covered by the concepts of narrative and story. Accordingly, this contribution uses narratology to analyze some aspects of computer games. Departing from a position in media studies that is interested in inter- or transmedial structures it will focus on the scope of a narratology applied outside the borders of literary studies, and my contribution will moreover address the question of the borders of narratives and stories themselves. The best way to observe and examine borders and borderline cases of narrative phenomena is to compare narratives with phenomena that do not normally have anything in common with them. Games are one such example. Both narratives and games have a long cultural heritage and a central function in the dynamics of culture (see, for example, Barthes 1983 and Huizinga 1950). Narration is a widespread and long-established framework for organizing the world in a certain way. Narratives recount actions. When telling a story, a narrator or author (I return to this distinction below) selects certain events that take place in the (or a) world and
46
Britta Neitzel
arranges them in ‘a chronological cause and effect chain’, as Bordwell (1985: 49) describes the story.1 When this act of organizing the world leads to a particular ending the narration makes sense (see Luhmann 1985). Play and games are based on another concept. To play is to perform certain actions to which are ascribed the attributes of freedom, ambivalence, relative unity, and a special temporal structure and relationship to reality, all of which differentiate them from other sequences of actions (see, for example, Scheuerl 1990, Huizinga 1950, and Caillois 1967). Most of these attributes can be assigned to play because of the features that separate them from the (rest of the) world. These features can take the form of spatial and temporal restrictions; rules that permit or prohibit certain activities; and, in some cases, fictive worlds shared by the players. What games do, we might say, is provide the conditions under which play is possible.2 Playing games, therefore, does not give order to the (or a) world; instead, it constructs new or different worlds in which actions can be performed. Authoring a game means putting in place the rules or conditions of such a world in which play can take place. Playing in itself does not lead anywhere (it does not, for example, progress towards an end); instead, it is self-sufficient and can take place again and again in endless cycles of repetition. Narratives on the one hand and play and games on the other present us with opposing concepts. The former concerns the recounting of actions, the latter the actions themselves. They also appear to have different chronological structures. Stories are based on linear chronology, whereas play has a circular structure.3 Computer games are, as the term suggests, games. Unlike other games, however, they depict the actions that are performed in them. They have a layer that presents the actions, and because of this they could potentially have narrative qualities. There is no doubt that applying narratological methods to computer games presents narratology with a challenge; to it this article responds. I begin by discussing some general aspects of the way (computer) games change narrative structures in the first section before considering some narratological models that can be applied to computer games despite the obvious differences between games and narratives. 1
2
3
Bordwell uses the term ‘fabula’ as introduced and used by the Russian Formalists. But ‘fabula’ and ‘story’ are synonymous in the respect I use them here. For a comparison of narratological terms see Neitzel (2000:59–75). Theorists who support an idealistic concept of play would question this statement because they consider play to be independent of games. Consideration of the debate within play theory concerning such topics is beyond the scope of this article. This is something of an oversimplification with respect to stories and play alike—it is possible for narratives to deviate from chronological order, and play can be directed in a certain direction by setting goals to be attained.
Levels of Play and Narration
47
In doing so my aim is not to provide an overall narratological analysis of computer games, but rather to expose some of the methodological points which I consider crucial to a narratological analysis of computer games. In the second section of this article, I use examples from real computer games to examine how narratological models can be applied to computer games despite the obvious differences between games and narratives. Thus, my overall aim will be to highlight some of the crucial areas where the narratological analysis of computer games ceases to be straightforward, the application of narratological methods should arguably be reconsidered, and other methodologies may well be more appropriate. But I also hope to show that, if we proceed carefully, some narratological terms and models can be applied to computer games in fruitful manner. 2. Computer Games and Narrative Levels Computer games affect each of the three levels that narratologists have identified in literary narratives. They are recapitulated in brief below. (1) The level of the discourse (discours) is ‘the narrative statement, the oral or written discourse that undertakes to tell of an event or a series of events’ (Genette 1980:25). Since most computer games now employ graphics, the discourse level has changed from one of textual to visual presentation.4 Such a change affects the temporal relations between story and discourse and has been widely discussed in film studies (see, for example, Bordwell 1985, Chatman 1978, Gunning 1991, Jost 1989, and Gaudreault 1984; 1989). (2) The level of narration (narration) is ‘the event that consists of someone recounting something: the act of narrating taken in itself’ (Genette 1980:25). This level is affected by the way in which the player takes part in a game. In computer games, the recipient (that is: the player) is presented not only with an interpretive task, as in the case of literary texts, but also with exploratory and configurational tasks (Aarseth 2001). As stated above, the author does not lay down a fixed sequence of events but provides in the program a range of possibilities on the basis of which certain events are selected by the player. (3) The participation of the player also affects the level of the story (histoire), which is ‘the succession of events, real or fictitious, that are the subjects of this discourse, and to their several relations of linking, opposition, repetition, etc.’ (Genette 1980:25), because the actual sequence of events is determined during the course of the game. 4
Text adventures (e.g. Zork) are examples of the use of textual presentation.
48
Britta Neitzel
In the remainder of this article, I ignore computer games that self-evidently lack a story (e.g. most sports games, flight simulators, and abstract games like Tetris). I concentrate instead on games that appear to be narrative because they include a protagonist who has to overcome certain obstacles. Even here, however, I concentrate not on the level of the story and the potentially different story structures but primarily on the discourse level and how it relates to the other levels. It is on the discourse level that the differences between narratives and games are most apparent. 3. The Level of Discourse in Non-Literal Narratives The visual layer which most modern computer games employ has important implications for the discourse level. It raises once more the distinction between showing and telling, which as been long been discussed since it was first introduced by Plato (1991). In the Politeia (Republic), Plato says of the dramatic mode (the mode of showing) that the narrator is concealed so that it seems that events are happening in the here and now. In the narrative mode, on the other hand, it is possible to identify a narrator who recounts events. We encounter this distinction and its associated problems again when dealing with film. A film shows pictures in which a spectator can see things happen. There is no overt narrator. Gaudreault (1984) introduced the term ‘monstration’ to reflect the impression that films nonetheless have the ability to narrate. The monstrator records the images of a film. In contrast to drama, on which earlier discussions were based, the events presented by a film do not happen while the film is being shown. They are recorded beforehand. Thus, according to Gaudreault, narration is also present in films. The narrator arranges the pictures after the monstrator has taken them. The editing performed by the narrator gives a film chronological freedom: it allows time-shift effects, the rearrangement of chronology, and omissions to occur. Faced with the same problem, Gunning (1991:19–21) developed another model to describe filmic narration. He introduced the concept of the narrator system, which has three levels. (1) The pro-filmic level contains everything that is exposed to the camera to be filmed. It includes such things as actors, lighting, set design, and the choice of setting. This is the level where basic decisions are made: ‘as narrative discourse the pro-filmic embodies a series of choices and reveals a narrative intention behind the choices’ (Gunning 1991:19).
Levels of Play and Narration
49
(2) The level of the enframed image involves the composition of the image, the camerawork, and the resultant shots. (3) The editing level is where the shots are selected and arranged. Treating the narrating entity in a film as a system is sensible for two reasons. First, it accounts for the technical components of a film rather than referring to an anthropomorphic narrator who speaks from a particular point of view with a particular distance and voice. Second, it allows us to include all the technical levels of film in our analytic model. Even though the above system was developed for describing filmic narration, it also allows us to identify the differences between the kinds of narration found in different kinds of non-verbal media. A drama, for example, relies primarily on the first of Gunning’s levels: the content is acted out by the actors. Neither the second nor the third level is explicitly present, but they are in a sense subsumed under the first one: the frame of the stage has an effect analogous to that of enframing, and montage / editing can be performed by dividing the play into scenes and acts. 4. The Level of Discourse in Computer Games Like animated films, computer games do not use photographic images and because of that they lack a pro-filmic level.5 Scenes, actors, lighting are computer generated. The program creates a world in which certain characters can perform certain actions. It also determines the physical laws of this world as well as the point of view from which it can be perceived. Also the editing level is seldom found in computer games6: the diegetic actions take place while the game is being played and thus simultaneously with the non-diegetic actions performed by the player. Additionally, the diegetic actions and events are displayed in real time. Nothing happens before the game is played. What Tomashevsky (1965) would call the plot, the actions as they appear in the text, cannot be recorded before the game is played. In contrast to films, there is no ‘time lapse’ (Gaudreault) between what happens and the presentation of it. Even if the program defines a world, its laws, and a range of possible actions before the game is played, 5
6
In this respect, computer games resemble most verbal narratives. In both cases, the events that take place have no real antecedents (something that is the concern of semiotics rather than this article). Some computer game genres are an exception. Classic graphic adventures represent discrete rooms rather than continuous space. Time shifts can occur when moving between these rooms. Furthermore, cut scenes (prearranged scenes used mainly to link two levels and provide narrative information) use editing, although it should be noted that in such scenes the player is a spectator without the ability to play.
50
Britta Neitzel
actions that might have narrative qualities, do not take place before they are displayed on the monitor. Story, and discourse, including plot, appear simultaneously with the act of playing. The three levels of narrative can be easily distinguished in verbal narration, but in computer games they influence one another and are less clearly separated. To separate these levels, the story of a computer game must be conceptualized as a construction of a recipient,7 either after the game is played or before it is played. Thereafter, the three levels can be separated: The diegetic actions in the game world (the story actions), the audiovisual presentation of these actions (the plot actions) on discourse level and the production of these actions by the non-diegetic activities of a player. In verbal narration, the sequences of story and narration are always linked by a temporal relation. According to Genette (1980:215–217), we can distinguish ‘subsequent narration’ (an event occurs in the story before it appears in the narration), ‘prior narration’ (e.g. prophecies), ‘simultaneous narration’, and ‘interpolated narration’. The most frequent form is subsequent narration: something happens first and is narrated afterwards. Since in computer games the realization of the events in the story depends on the act of playing (or narration), narration in computer games is not a matter of simultaneous narration as found, for example, in live television broadcasts. We are dealing instead with interpolated narration, in which ‘the story and the narrating can become entangled in such a way that the latter has an effect on the former’ (Genette 1980:155). Computer games differ from novels with interpolated narration, however, in that the real actions that produce a computer game and leave traces in the discourse take place simultaneously with the discourse and plot. It should now be clear how important it is to consider whether playing computer games is comparable with storytelling or is better understood as a set of actions performed under certain conditions, as is the case with other types of games. Computer games differ from other games, however, in that if the sequence of actions can be interpreted as a story, that story is one that happens now but not here, for the events occur somewhere else (i.e. in the virtual world of the game). Moreover, players know that the ending and all the possible routes through the game have been determined in advance by the program; all that is required of them is to find the ending during the game. Actions in computer games depend on the player’s activities. So, unlike films or literary works, the narrativity of computer games cannot be analysed without considering the process of play itself. The process of 7
The concept of the story as a construction of the recipient was introduced by Todorov (1966) and is also employed by Bordwell (1985).
Levels of Play and Narration
51
playing a game is necessary if a narrative is to emerge. The player authors the narrative of a game (this does not, however, mean that the player is the author of the game as a whole). Two questions are raised by the player’s contribution to the possible narrativity of computer games and the simultaneity of the three levels in them: how can the actions of the story be separated from the discourse, and how can authorship be described in the case of computer games? 5. Story, Plot and Narration in Computer Games The first of the above questions can be approached using the text adventure game Zork (1972) as an example. As the term ‘text adventure’ suggests, Zork employs text as its only form of representation. It begins by displaying the following statement: West of House You are standing in an open field west of a white house, with a boarded front door. There is a small mailbox there.
To play the game, the player has to enter commands. For example: >go to house
When a command is executed, the program responds to the player immediately. For example: >go to house It’s here! >open door the door cannot be opened >go east The door is boarded and you can’t remove the boards. >go north North of House You are facing the north side of a white house. There is no door here, and all the windows are boarded up. To the north a narrow path winds through the trees. >go east Behind House You are behind the white house. A path leads into the forest to the east. In one corner of the house there is a small window which is slightly ajar. >open window With great effort, you open the window far enough to allow entry.
52
Britta Neitzel
>enter Kitchen Score: 10 You are in the kitchen of the white house. A table seems to have been used recently for the preparation of food. A passage leads to the west and a dark staircase can be seen leading upward. A dark chimney leads down and to the east is a small window which is open. On the table is an elongated brown sack, smelling of hot peppers. A bottle is sitting on the table. The glass bottle contains: A quantity of water. >go west Living Room You are in the living room. There is a doorway to the east, a wooden door with strange gothic lettering to the west, which appears to be nailed shut, a trophy case, and a large oriental rug in the center of the room. Above the trophy case hangs an elvish sword of great antiquity. A battery-powered brass lantern is on the trophy case.
After picking up the lantern, collecting the rope and knife in the attic, and taking the garlic inside the brown sack, the player takes the sword, removes the rug, and goes underground through a concealed trapdoor. The troll encountered en route can be killed by typing ‘kill troll with sword’. After this explicit performative act has been carried out, the player is able to enter a confusing maze of rooms.8 When playing the game, the player chooses certain routes between the rooms, with the result that a network of rooms and routes between them comes into being. In the course of the game, the ‘you’ addressed by the program follows certain routes, examines objects, and fights potential enemies. In this way, the world of Zork is examined and a sequence of actions that can be called a plot unfolds. The program itself, on the other hand, contains object definitions, databases, and algorithms that do not present a story but define a range of possibilities and enable potential sequences of events. In a computer game, the distinction between the events of the story and the events of the narrating is not a chronological one but one between potentiality and actuality. To describe the different levels of which computer games consist, I propose distinguishing between the commands typed by a player (e.g. ‘go west’) as fictional acts of narration and the act of typing as the real process of narration. The imagined moves made by the ‘you’ constitute the events of the story.9 8
9
Zork has 191 different rooms and 211 manipulable objects. The dictionary of Zork contains 908 words, with which 71 actions can be described (see Lebling/Blank/Anderson 1979). As can be seen from the example, in Zork there are very few descriptions of events; descriptions of states are far more frequent. Each command and its result, that is a description of the next room, are displayed on the screen. Movements and other actions are not displayed or described; they exist only in the player’s imagination.
Levels of Play and Narration
53
The process of selecting from among the possible routes and objects can, like a process of verbal narration, be understood as a process of making sense. According to Luhmann, sense is a ‘selective relationship between system and environment’ (1985:34), which means that a selection and actualisation is made of that, given as a possibility. The non-selected possibilities do not disappear completely but remain in the background as non-actualised possibilities. In computer games, this background is the program. If the term ‘narration’ is to be applied to computer games, its definition must be modified so as to read as follows: the act of narration is the selection and arrangement of events by the player. In a text adventure like Zork, it is relatively easy to separate the commands given by the player from the room descriptions. This becomes more difficult when we consider the visual presentation used in graphic adventures. In the evolution of the latter type of games, the commands of the player have coalesced with the movements of the avatar;10 it has become less and less common for the commands to be an observable part of the discourse level. In the game Blade Runner (Virgin Interactive, Westwood 1997), for example, the player points at a place on the screen to which the avatar then goes.
Figure 1: Blade Runner
10
An avatar is a character controlled by a player in a game.
54
Britta Neitzel
Silent Hill (Konami 1999) has a mixed command structure. While the avatar moves though space in the game in real time, the actions of collecting objects still show a clear command structure. This overt structure dissolves more and more in action adventures such as the Tomb Raider series of games (Core, Eidos 1996–2003).
Figure 2: Tomb Raider 1
Figure 3: Half Life
Levels of Play and Narration
55
The command structure is completely hidden in action games. Third-person and first-person shooters not only depict moving and shooting in real time; the avatar also picks up objects by moving over them.11 But while the elements of the plot and the elements of the narration fuse more and more, it is still possible to distinguish between elements of the story and elements of the discourse. The reason for this is that the games specify a possible complete story. In Tomb Raider, for example, Lara Croft is given the task of finding an ancient artefact called the Scion, which she has to obtain for her client, Jacqueline Nadla. Lara goes to Peru, where she searches for and finds the Scion. She realizes that Nadla is evil and defeats her with the Scion. Lara then sails into the sunset on her opponent’s yacht. This story can be actualised12 by the walking, running, and jumping of the avatar, leading to the creation of a plot. As Certeau puts it, ‘the act of walking is for the urban system what the utterance (the speech act) is for language or for formulated statements’ (Certeau 1980:189). Metaphorically speaking, then, computer games use movements to tell stories. There are several reasons for adopting this view: (1) The actions of movement are different each time the game is played. This means that they involve the plot rather than the story. (2) Games do not list movement actions in their score tables. Movements affect only the time taken to complete a level. This is a measure of performance and represents narrative rather than story time. (3) Textual commands such as ‘go west’ and their visual equivalents are performative symbolic acts. They designate actions, but they are not the actions themselves. In narratological terms, computer games transform the actions of the (real) act of narration—in the case of the computer game: pressing buttons—into plot actions. In terms of play theory: a game is played. This becomes clear by a short glance at other types of games. When playing, players perform actions that are not taken seriously; they are merely pretending. This is most apparent when an actor pretends to be somebody else in a role-playing situation. The same applies to play-fighting—the people involved are only pretending to fight. People who play must always be aware of the
11
12
Many computer games involve exploring an unknown space and/or solving a task in an unfriendly environment. It follows that making movements in order to explore the environment, shooting enemies, and collecting objects that might help solve problems are very common actions. Of course a player must not follow this story-line but can do other things with the avatar, e. g. practicing swimming or jumping skills.
56
Britta Neitzel
fact that they are playing. If an actor playing Hamlet believed himself to be Hamlet, he would be schizophrenic. Thus, play is always a combination of two systems, the world of play and the real world, which is referred to and negated in the process. Play is contradiction: a playful action is and simultaneously is not a certain action. Or as Gregory Bateson (1955:41) describes play: ‘›These actions, in which we now engage, do not denote what would be denoted by those actions which these actions denote.‹ A playful nip denotes the bite, but it does not denote what would be denoted by the bite.’ These two levels are separated in computer games: outside the computer, a player in the real world presses buttons or keys while the screen displays actions in a fictional world. So, as far as play is concerned, pressing buttons does not mean pressing buttons but, for example, shooting monsters. Play and narrative, then, have in common that they deal with levels of reality and fictionality, but they do so in different ways: while narratives separate the two levels, play fuses them.
6. Narrative Situations In computer games, the real actions of narration are transformed into fictive plot actions. And these fictive plot actions are displayed in a certain way in a discourse. Narratology can be very helpful when it comes to describing the result. Narrative situations are one example of how narratological models can be applied to computer games. My description of narrative situations is based on that of Genette (1980), and employs a distinction made by him in his discussion of narrative mood. He shows that the categories of perspective and voice should not be confused. According to Genette, perspective or point of view describes the visual angle from which the story is seen in the discourse, and provides an answer to the question of who sees. Voice, on the other hand, concerns the narrator and the relation between narrator and story, thus providing an answer to the question of who speaks (cf. Genette 1980:162). Adapting the separation of the two questions to the analysis of computer games is unproblematic as far as the category of point of view is concerned: it can be employed without difficulty. Our understanding of voice, however, needs to be modified. I propose reformulating the question behind it as ‘who acts?’ instead of ‘who speaks?’, for the events in a computer game are not told but acted out, as described in the preceding section of this article. Accordingly, using point of view as a terminological model, the category of voice can be redesignated as that of point of action.
Levels of Play and Narration
57
6.1 Point of View Perspective and point of view, or focalization, as Genette calls this category of mood, concern the extent of the information that the discourse reveals about the narrated world. Genette defines three kinds of focalization: (1) zero focalization, or a non-focalized story, is found when a story has an omniscient narrator; (2) internal focalization occurs when a story is told from the point of view of a character; and (3) external focalization occurs when the point of view concentrates on the actions of a character without anything about the feelings of that character being revealed. Apart from cases in which characters speak (uncommon even today), all knowledge in computer games is acquired through the things that can be seen in them (i.e. through visual perspective defined by spatial factors affecting the field of vision). This perspective affects the player’s distance from the virtual world. There are three kinds of perspective on the virtual world; they correspond roughly to Genette’s triad of focalization types. (1) Subjective perspective (internal focalization) is dominant in firstperson shooters, in which an avatar is not displayed and there is simply a hand or weapon at the bottom of the screen instead (see figure 3). The space that should contain the body to which the hand belongs as well as the eyes belonging to that body is empty. The image on the screen represents the field of vision of an avatar that players have to imagine. As part of this imagination they provide the avatar with their own body and seeing eyes. The diegesis is therefore not self-contained but extends beyond the monitor to the player. (2) Action adventures (e.g. Tomb Raider) visually display an avatar capable of seeing. For example, Lara Croft looks inside the caves of Qualopek before she enters them. The avatar is followed by a virtual camera and is usually seen from behind in the game (see figure 4). The player can also switch to ‘look mode’, in which the avatar can look in various directions. This point of view is linked to the movements of the avatar; it is not a substitute for the viewpoint, rather a case of viewing-with. In reference to Mitry (1998: 218), I should like to call it semi-subjective perspective. It is equivalent to external focalization in Genette’s framework. (3) The third kind of perspective in computer games, the objective point of view (zero focalization), is the oldest and most varied. The objective point of view presents from the outside a space in which actions take place. The virtual world cannot be viewed from any point inside it. This kind of point of view was used in the early computer games of the 1970s (see fig. 5).
58
Figure 4: Lara Croft
Figure 5: Space Invaders
Britta Neitzel
Levels of Play and Narration
59
Graphic adventures, too, employ the objective point of view. They present an avatar in the space in which it performs its actions. The avatar does not have a perspective of its own on things. An especially clear indication that this is the representation of a space-for-action, is the use of ‘takes’, which sizes correspond exactly with the sector of the virtual world that can be manipulated.13 Likewise, simulations and strategy games employ the objective point of view in showing from above the space in which actions take place. Recently, games that allow the point of view to change have become increasingly common. The point of view in computer games influences the feeling of distance that the player has to the virtual world. While in games employing the subjective point of view the diegesis seems to be open, the semi-subjective and objective point of view provide a greater self-containment. 6.2 Point of Action The point of action describes the position where actions can originate and the way in which they can be performed in the fictional world. This position can be located inside or outside the diegesis, allowing us to distinguish between intradiegetic and extradiegetic points of action accordingly. It is clear that an intradiegetic point of action is present when a game depicts an avatar that is inside the diegesis and initiates the action. An intradiegetic point of action is also created when a role in the diegesis is assigned to the player, even if this role is not represented by an avatar. This is the case in Civilization (Microprose, Activision 1996), for example, in which the player chooses a ruler character who controls the lives of his subjects. An extradiegetic point of action is present when the player does not adopt such a role, as is the case in Myst (Broderbund, Cyan, 1993) and Tetris (1987). If, instead of focusing on the origins of actions, we look at their destinations, or goals, we can make a distinction between centred and distributed points of action. Distributed points of action allow an action to be initiated in multiple locations in the virtual world, as in simulations and strategy games, for example. Team sport games also operate on this principle. Centred actions can only be executed in a single location. This terminological addition allows us to differentiate between strategy games and action games: while the point of action is intradiegetic in both genres, it is distributed in one and centred in the other. A third distinction covered by the concept of point of action is that between direct and indirect actions. Depending on how the commands 13
Here the origin of graphic adventures in text adventures becomes clear. In Zork, for example, we have seen that it is always a particular part of the world that is described.
60
Britta Neitzel
are carried out, the structure of commands can or cannot be discerned on the computer screen. In Tomb Raider, for example, every keypress instantly leads to Lara performing an action, whereas in graphic adventures the player clicks on certain objects or characters so that the avatar then approaches them to examine or address them. As mentioned above, some adventures, such as Grim Fandango (Funsoft, Lucas Arts 1998) and Silent Hill (Konami 1999) combine indirect and direct points of action, whereas newer games tend to employ the direct mode. Indirect points of action are also found in simulations and strategy games. In some games, an indirect point of action is included in the diegesis: in Command and Conquer (Virgin Interactive, Westwood 1996), for example, the troops acknowledge their orders by saying ‘yes sir!’14 7. Authorship In this final section, I suggest a narratological approach to describing the authorship of narrative computer games. In computer games, the player determines the order of a concrete sequence of events in the course of playing the game. The player is responsible for creating the plot. Only the plot is affected by the exploratory and configurational functions of the player that are essential to all games. The player chooses from the possibilities that the program makes available and transfers them to the process of play, and so places a text-space in a time. By constantly inputting information throughout the game, the player prompts the computer to process the sequence of events. It is only in the course of play that possible plots are realized, individual objects combined, and actions produced and arranged in a chronological order. The program itself does not contain a chronological sequence of events; rather, it specifies possible sequential and causal relations by means of algorithms, object definitions, and databases. Any potential narrative only comes into being during the game and not before, for only then are chains of actions formed. A game can only be considered a narrative when it is actually played. Hence, the process of playing and the actions of the player are integral parts of a game and any possible narrative associated with it. This leads to a concept of shared authorship. Because players carry out the narrative 14
In more precise terms, the difference between direct and indirect points of action can be understood as one of modality, for it describes primarily the relative distance between story (when present) and discourse. An indirect point of action increases the distance and thus facilitates the process of distinguishing between them.
Levels of Play and Narration
61
actions, they could be described as co-authors, for it is ultimately they who determine what takes place. However, such a description would give too much importance to the role of the player, for it implies that the player has the same importance as the programmer. Instead, I propose borrowing the term ‘implied author’ from literary theory in order to describe the function of the player as an author implied by the game. The term ‘implied author’, originally introduced by Wayne C. Booth, refers to an authority created by a text that is superior to the narrator and spans the entire text. Analogously, the implied author in a computer game is a necessary condition for the game to be a series of events, to be a narrative. It is implied by the game. Using the term ‘implied author’ also has the advantage of reflecting how many players view their involvement in computer games: they see themselves as the source of the symbolic actions that take place. The implied author is not solely responsible for the production of the game narrative. Another entity, the implied creator, as I shall call it, has primacy over the implied author. The implied creator is responsible for forming the virtual world, responsible that is, for the setting, the characters, and what happens in that world. The properties determined by the implied creator also include the characteristics of avatars (e.g. their appearance and how they perform actions) and the restrictions and obstacles that constrain actions in the game. The implied creator makes the initial selection from the mass of conceivable possibilities by making a subset of them available as choices in the program. The implied author then selects from them in a second process of selection. Summarizing the above, we can outline a system, resembling Gunning’s filmic narrator system, of the four levels of representation identifiable in computer games: (1) the world design (the rules of the virtual world), for which the implied creator is responsible; (2) the visual design (the presentation of the virtual world), for which the implied creator is responsible; (3) the plot design (the arrangement of action), for which the implied author is responsible; and (4) the chronological design (the temporal relation between story and discourse), for which the implied creator is responsible. When we consider these levels of representation, it does not seem feasible to apply to computer games the model of narrating entities that has established itself in the study of literature. The four levels described above are much more closely related to the system of cinematic discourse developed by Gunning. Unlike films, however, computer games have something that
62
Britta Neitzel
introduces an anthropomorphic element into the system: the implied author represented by an avatar. 8. Conclusion Using narratological methods to describe computer games provides insights into their structure. It also illustrates the limits of narratological methods and contributes to the description of differences between different media and between the wider cultural concepts of narrative and the game. Finally, it shows us that some features of computer games defy narratological description. References Aarseth 1997 Aarseth, Espen J.: Cybertext. Perspectives on Ergodic Literature. Baltimore / London 1997. Barthes 1983 Barthes, Roland: “Introduction to the Structural Analysis of Narratives.” In: Barthes, Roland: Selected Writings. Oxford 1983. Bateson 1955 Bateson, Gregory: “A Theory of Play and Fantasy. A Report on Theoretical Aspects of the Project for Study of the Role of the Paradoxes of Abstraction in Communication.” In: Psychiatric Research Reports 2, 1955:39–51. Bordwell 1985 Bordwell, David: Narration in the Fiction Film. London 1985. Caillois 1967 Caillois, Roger: Le jeux et les hommes. Le masque et le vertige. Paris 1967. Certeau 1988 Certeau, Michel de: Die Kunst des Handelns. Berlin 1988. Chatman 1978 Chatman, Seymour: Story and Discourse. Narrative Structure in Fiction and Film. Ithaca / London 1978. Chatman 1990 Chatman, Seymour: Coming to Terms. The Rhetoric of Narrative in Fiction and Film. Ithaca / London 1990. Gaudreault 1984 Gaudreault, André: “Narration et monstration au cinema.” In: Hors Cadre 2, 1984:87–98. Gaudreault 1989 Gaudreault, André: Du littéraire au filmique. Système du récit. Paris 1989. Genette 1980 Genette, Gérard: Narrative Discourse. An Essay in Method. Oxford 1980.
Levels of Play and Narration
63
Gunning 1991 Gunning, Tom: D.W. Griffith and the Origins of American Narrative Film. The Early Years at Biograph. Urbana / Chicago 1991. Huizinga 1950 Huizinga, Johan: Homo Ludens. A Study of the Play Element in Culture. Boston 1950. Jost 1989 Jost, François: L’œil – caméra. Entre film et roman. Lyon 1989. Lebling / Blank / Anderson 1979 Lebling, David P. / Blank, Marc S. / Anderson, Timothy A.: “Zork: A Computerized Fantasy Simulation Game.” In: IEEE Computer, 12.4, 1979:51–59, see also: (02.03.04). Luhmann 1985 Luhmann, Niklas: “Sinn als Grundbegriff der Soziologie.” In: Habermas, Jürgen / Luhmann, Niklas: Theorie der Gesellschaft oder Sozialtechnologie – was leistet die Systemforschung? Frankfurt / Main 1985:25–100. Mitry 1998 Mitry, Jean: The Aesthetics and Psychology of the Cinema. London 1998. Neitzel 2000 Neitzel, Britta: Gespielte Geschichten. Struktur- und prozessanalytische Untersuchungen der Narrativität von Videospielen, Diss., Weimar 2000. http: // www.db-thueringen.de / servlets / DerivateServlet / Derivate-2063 / Dissertation.html. Plato 1991 Plato: Der Staat. Stuttgart 1991. Scheuerl 1990 Scheuerl, Hans (ed.): Das Spiel. 11th edition, Weinheim / Basel 1990. Todorov 1966 Todorov, Tzvetan: “Les catégories du récit littéraire.” In: Communications 7, Vol. 8, 1966:125–151. Tomashevsky 1965 Tomashevsky, Boris: “Thematics.” In: Lemon, Lee T. / Reis, Marion J. (eds.): Russian Formalist Criticism. Four Essays. Lincoln / London 1965:61–95.
Computer Games Blade Runner Developer: Virgin Interactive. Publisher: Westwood 1997. Civilization Developer: Microprose, Publisher: Activision 1996 Command and Conquer Developer: Virgin Interactive. Publisher: Westwood 1996. Grim Fandango Developer: Funsoft. Publisher: Lucas Arts 1998. Half Life Developer: Valve. Publisher: Sierra 1998. Myst Developer: Broderbund. Publisher: Cyan 1993.
64
Britta Neitzel
Tetris Developer: Alexey Pazhtnov 1985. Silent Hill Developer and publisher: Konami 1999. Space Invaders Developer: Taito. Publisher: Midway 1978. Tomb Raider Developer: Core. Publisher: Eidos 1996–2003. Zork Developer and publisher: Infocom 1972.
Narrative in Music: The Case of Beethoven’s “Tempest” Sonata* Douglass Seaton (Tallahassee) 1. Introduction Critical theory in music has recently begun to consider the possibility of musical narrative. Doubts have been raised about musical narrativity on the basis of music’s supposedly abstract material, the impossibility of a past tense in music, repetition in musical forms, and other grounds.1 Nevertheless, narrativity can be demonstrated even in purely instrumental musical works, and indeed it constitutes a defining factor for musical Romanticism. * 1
See the appendix to this article including a sound file at For a brief survey of this literature, see Maus (2001). Maus concludes by saying that ‘The exploration of instrumental music as narrative remains a tantalizing, confusing, problematic area of inquiry’ (642). In an earlier article Maus reviews a variety of different approaches to this issue by musicologists who have attempted narratological investigations (1997). The three main objections to a narratological approach to music are represented by Jean-Jacques Nattiez, Carolyn Abbate, and Peter Kivy. Nattiez (1990) is really talking about what I call plot, and he presumes that in order to be narrative music must represent a story either in the real world or in a verbal medium. Although his argument rests on the assumption that music is essentially abstract and therefore necessarily non-referential, one need not find this problematic in terms of musical plots. Musical events are real events—in an important sense more real than the events referred to in a fictitious story—and they raise and sometimes frustrate real expectations in the listener. A brief consideration of musical plot appears in my discussion below, and its applicability will be demonstrated with the sonata to be considered in this essay. Carolyn Abbate (1989; expanded 1991) discusses the problem of narrativity in music on the basis of music’s having no past tense. Her point is that literary narrative typically depends on the past tense in order to distinguish the (present) telling of a story from the (past) action that it reports. Peter Kivy (2002:chap.8) objects strenuously to the possibility of musical narrativity on the grounds that he finds it impossible to reconcile the inherent use of repetitions in common musical forms with the absurdity of such repetitions in a story. Two objections might easily be raised to this line of reasoning: (1) we need not—indeed, should not—carry the presuppositions of narrative in one medium into the understanding of
66
Douglass Seaton
A major weakness in previous discussions of musical narrative has been a too close dependence on the assumption that narrative per se belongs to literature. In fact, the idea of narrative in music does not depend on the imitation of literature, any more than the reverse.2 The present discussion will argue that, entirely apart from literary content, a musical work can satisfy the two requirements of narrative that transcend artistic medium: plot and voice. Plot is established in instrumental music of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries by the definition of character through rhythmic / melodic identities and the articulation of action through harmonic patterns of stability, rising tension, climax, resolution, and dénouement. Voice—the narrative persona—is created in various ways, sometimes embodied in musical forms but often, too, in verbal cues, in musical behaviors surrounding the performance and hearing of a work, or in reception. This essay will first review the means and techniques by which music of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries was able to enact plot, and it will suggest how listeners have encountered the narrative voice in musical works. In order to demonstrate how these principles work in practice, it will then consider a work that has troubled listeners and commentators for two hundred years, Beethoven’s 1802 Piano Sonata in D Minor, op. 31 no. 2, commonly known as the “The Tempest”.
2
narrative in another, and (2) neither time nor event order is necessarily unidirectional in verbal narrative, so that it is already obvious that narrative need not be bound by any assumption that events and time operate in plots as they do in direct life experience. The fact that narrativity in music has not necessarily been set aside by these objections is represented by William Kinderman (1992:esp. 141–44), who explicitly takes issue with Abbate’s and Nattiez’s arguments, though he does not offer a clear definition of narrativity. He is particularly concerned with effects that allow the music of Beethoven’s Piano Sonata op. 110 to ‘transcend a linear temporal succession’, and thus may also imply an answer to Kivy’s worry about repetition. Kinderman also insists, and rightly so, on an understanding of musical narrative unencumbered by the peculiar constraints of any literary medium. Werner Wolf (2002) provides a very helpful discussion of these and other issues by a scholar from outside the field of musicology. Among other problems of musical narrative that Wolf addresses is music’s non-referentiality, which he ultimately does not find sufficient to prevent musical works from being regarded as narrative (77–83). Abbate betrays the limits of her perspective when she writes that ‘literary theories of narrative suggest ways in which music cannot narrate’ (1989:228). My point here is that narrative in one medium need not employ the means or even necessarily adopt the assumptions of another. The present essay will insist on an understanding of narrative that is conscientiously not constrained by literary theories.
67
Narrative in Music
2. Methodological Principles We must first turn then to the issue of plot expressed in music.3 In simple terms, we can take as a definition that we have a plot in any action in which characters become involved in a sequence of events in which tension arises and is resolved. Now, as it happens, in the eighteenth century musicians began to employ a new way of describing musical ideas—rhythmic / melodic units—no longer according to their ‘affect’, as in the past, but according to ‘character’. Furthermore, the musical theme of a piece was no longer referred to as ‘subject’ but as ‘motive’, suggesting that it represented some sort of motivation, whether conscious or instinctive. Thus, a musical passage might be identified as ‘military’ or ‘amorous’, ‘aristocratic’ or ‘rustic’, and even ‘masculine’ or ‘feminine’; of course, such characterizations are not all mutually exclusive, so that a theme might be both aristocratic and amorous, or a musical idea might first appear as lyrical and return as heroic. At the same time, Enlightenment composers began to adopt an approach to long-range harmonic contour in substantial movements of musical works, which produced the principle that became known (long after the fact) as ‘sonata form’ (see Diagram 1). Conventional designation
Plot contour
Harmonic level
Musical material
Typical thematic character
Introduction (optional)
Prologue
Leading to tonic
O – opening
Anticipatory
Part I – Exposition Section 1
Stable situation
Tonic
P – theme(s) associated with principal key
Affirmative, forceful
Increasing tension
Modulatory
T – theme(s) associated with harmonic transition
Active
Contrasting situation
Dominant (or relative major)
S – theme(s) associated with secondary key K – theme(s) associated with closing
Contrasting to P, often lyrical Affirmative, often “stock” character
Rising action to climax
Unstable
Development of previous material; new material (N) may be introduced
Unpredictable
Section 2
Part II Section 3 – Development
Section 4 – Reprise
Resolution
Arrival of tonic
P
As in exposition
Dénouement
Tonic
(T), S, K
As in exposition, except that all characters are in stable position
Diagram 1: Sonata form as plot 3
The understanding that eighteenth- and nineteenth-century music depends upon the concept of plot is heavily indebted to Charles Rosen’s magisterial study The Classic Style: Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven. Rosen does not speak of plot but of drama—i.e. an action presented without an evident narrator—but the point is the same. Rosen formulates the difference between the musical presuppositions of the Baroque and the Enlightenment very clearly in his statement that ‘Dramatic sentiment was replaced by dramatic action’ (1971:43).
68
Douglass Seaton
Fundamentally, the principle is fairly straightforward. A movement must begin by establishing a home key or tonic. The music then modulates, rising into another key (usually the key of the fifth scale degree or dominant, or in minor keys the third scale degree or relative major), which creates a heightening of tension. This setting up of the movement’s fundamental opposition is often referred to as ‘exposition’. A more or less extended period of harmonic instability, sometimes called ‘development’ (although development in a general sense may occur at any point in the form) eventually leads to a moment of climactic anticipation. The return of the tonic provides harmonic resolution, restoring stability. Crucial to this musical plan is the coordination between the different musical themes, with their respective characters, and the harmonic events. The result of this concinnity is that the themes either motivate or experience the harmonic progress of the music; in other words, they are legitimately ‘agents’ or ‘patients’ in the work. Standard functions, each with its own character, include the following: Opening themes, the point of which is to create anticipation at the beginning of the action. These tend to be fragmentary and open-ended, perhaps even unsettled in character. They are frequently external to the harmonic plan and thus not involved in the plot. Principal themes, which establish the tonic key of the movement both at the beginning and at the moment of resolution. Themes in this position are likely to be strongly rhythmic and bold in character. Transition themes, which destabilize the key and move toward the contrast key. We expect such themes to be lively and active. Secondary themes, which is to say, themes associated with the secondary key, which serve to stabilize the secondary key and to contrast with the character of the principal theme. Often, secondary themes are lyrical and long-breathed. Closing themes, which confirm the secondary key. Closing themes tend to be formulaic and predictable in character. Of course, one of the fascinating things about listening to any given piece is the interplay between the characters and their roles within the overall plan. Generally, however, the form tends to assign a controlling, active role to the principal theme or character, because it has the responsibility of establishing the main key at the beginning and marking the return of that key at the resolution. The rest of the themes (or characters) are eventually brought from their original harmonic level into the main key, so that especially the character associated with the secondary key seems to assume a more passive role. The way in which all of this plays out in
Narrative in Music
69
any given work will, of course, be specific to the piece, just as any plot in any artistic medium is specific, and that is what holds our interest. It is not at all necessary, I hasten to emphasize, to translate pieces of music into verbal or pictorial stories. This has, of course, been done many times, sometimes more and sometimes less amusingly. The point here is that the musical characters and musical shaping of tension in a work are at the same time entirely specific and refer to nothing else. Naturally, we communicate about musical works in words. We can do this in great detail by using the technical terms of music analysis, but that approach inevitably sacrifices the immediacy of the character and the experiential contour of tensions and resolutions that we perceive directly in hearing the music. We can also describe music in metaphors or assign names to the characters (identifying a heroic theme as Promethean, for example), but that either brings too much external baggage to the character or fails because the metaphor or name means something different to anyone with whom we share such fantasies.4 For this reason I do not intend here to tell a story based on a Beethoven sonata but rather simply to let the music express its own character and enact its own plot. So plot is not the exclusive property of literature or even of verbal media; it belongs equally to music, and not merely as a kind of borrowing from literature into music that requires us to translate musical characters and actions into quasi-literary ones. Indeed, plot itself might properly be regarded as the quintessential Enlightenment way of conceiving experience, manifesting itself either in literature or in music—or in any other form—a principle that transcends medium. The sonata form meets all the criteria for plot, and some other musical forms may do so as well. But I have not so far made the case for musical narrative. Merely enacting a plot will make a musical work dramatic, corresponding to a play enacted on the stage, not narrative, like a novel. And, indeed, most musical movements of the eighteenth century are better regarded as dramatic than as narrative.5 When we move toward the nineteenth century, the issue of narrative begins to come into play. And the reason for this is obvious: to the Romantic imagination it became important to establish the subjective mind or spirit from which an artistic manifestation emerged. As Susan McClary (1997:24) has rightly observed: ‘during the nineteenth century virtually 4
5
John Neubauer (1997) discusses the ‘emplotment’ of musical works by various writers, representing various degrees of such metaphorical story telling. Fred Everett Maus (1991) raises the important issue here of the difference between action and discourse, but he also concludes that it is difficult to give any identity to a narrator in music. In the end, Maus is inclined to accept the concept of drama in music but to be skeptical about narrative.
70
Douglass Seaton
all cultural enterprises in Europe aspired to the condition of narrative.’6 Thus we need to deal with the issue of voice in music. At the outset we should acknowledge that the establishment or discovery of narrativity in music does not rely on conventional principles as conveniently as does plot. In addition, as mentioned earlier, the narrative voice may be identified audibly in the musical work itself or externally. Music-internal evidence for the narrative persona may be of several types, and I shall list here only three: A particular idiom that governs the work, essentially a recognizable rhetorical manner that can be attributed to a certain kind of speaker. Establishment of the narrative persona’s identity by quotation of or allusion within the piece to a specific repertoire of music. Intrusion into the piece’s plot of some music that clearly does not participate in the action, often a passage that serves as commentary. This is the kind of instance that we will observe here. Extramusical identification of the narrative persona also operates in a number of ways, sometimes under the composer’s control but also determined by historical information or reception history: ‘Paratextual’ verbal cues, such as the attachment of titles or programs to musical works. Conventions of performance, which, for the nineteenth century, would include the appearance of the conductor on the podium in front of the orchestra or the solo recital pianist seated in profile on the stage. Posterity’s identification of the persona with the composer, at least as the composer is known or understood by the conventional wisdom generated by biography (and sometimes by autobiography). We shall also have the opportunity here to observe an instance of this. Regardless where and how it takes place, however, the perception of the persona, a voice that we identify as speaking through the music, renders the musical experience Romantic. The listener responds to her or his awareness of this voice by expecting and seeking to know the persona as the subjectivity behind the musical expression. 6
McClary is, to be sure, more interested in the issue of a totalizing master plot than in the subjectivity that concerns us here; nevertheless, the validity of her statement extends to narrative voice, as well as to plot. This is the motivation for the impulse toward narrativization that has led to many arbitrary and farfetched programs applied to music by romanticizing commentators. On this subject, see Wolf (2002:83–94). The real existence of this impulse toward narrativization also provides, however, the justification for musicology’s seeking and studying the narrativizing aspects of the actual historical experience of music listeners in the nineteenth century.
71
Narrative in Music
3. Demonstration (I)—establishing narrative by music-internal analysis With the preceding discussion to serve as methodological background, we can now turn to Beethoven’s “Tempest” Sonata, which turns out to be a particularly interesting and instructive example. As has been discussed by many previous analysts, the sonata’s first movement employs the standard plot resources commonly identified as sonata form, but it also departs from the norm to create an analytically vexed situation in which the functions of character within the plot remain uncertain.7 Moreover, beyond its peculiar thematic and harmonic plot outline, the movement introduces a striking passage of recitative, a musical idiom ‘extra-generic’ to the piano sonata (see Diagram 2). Conventional designation
Plot contour
Harmonic level
Musical material
Thematic character Measure Numbers
Introduction? Exposition?
Unstable
Leading to D minor
O?/P?
Anticipatory
1–20
Part I – Exposition (continued?) Section 1
Immediately increasing tension
Only momentarily in D minor, than modulatory
T?/P?
Bold
21–41
Contrasting
A minor
S
Mercurial
42–55
K
Stern
55–92
Section 2
Part II Rising action Section 3 – Development to climax
Section 4 – Reprise
Unstable
Development of O?/P? Anticipatory T?/P? Bold K Stern
93–98 99–121 122–142
Resolution?
Arrival of D minor, immediately destabilized
O?/P? Recitative
Anticipatory Declamatory
143, 149–154 144–48, 155–171
Dénouement
D minor
S
Mercurial
172–185
K
Stern
185–225
Diagram 2: Form of first movement of Beethoven, Piano Sonata in D Minor, op. 31, no.2 “The Tempest”
The most provocative feature of the sonata’s first movement is its failure to produce a proper theme in the principal key. The opening passage is not set off as a mere introduction (as in Beethoven’s “Pathétique” Sonata, op. 13, for example), but in style it does resemble an introduction more than a first theme (or character) of a sonata plot. Confusing the situation still
7
For a helpful discussion of the “Tempest” Sonata, see Timothy Jones (1999:103–108). Jones largely adopts the analysis of the movement by Janet Schmalfeldt (1995:37–71). A detailed description of the compositional process of op. 31 no. 2 is provided by Barry Cooper (1990:177–96).
72
Douglass Seaton
further, a new idea begins at the close of this passage, clearly in the tonic key, D minor, with a motive surging boldly out of the bass and answered by a turning figure in a high register, supported by a vibrating accompaniment. This, however, also turns out not to constitute a proper principal theme but to move directly into the process of modulation. Its material does not serve to stabilize the key of D minor but only to destabilize the harmony with each new gesture. Thus the sonata begins in ambiguity—indeed, it has no proper beginning. After a clearly introductory passage there follows immediately a clearly transitional one. What ought to constitute a defining feature of any sonata movement, the stable theme in the principal key, simply does not appear at all.8 Once past this first uncertainty, the movement progresses more or less conventionally for a while. There comes a reasonably stable theme in the secondary key (in this case A minor) and a close in that key. The second part of the form opens with a developmental passage featuring, as we would certainly expect, the tonally unstable transitional material of the first part. Now the listener who approaches this movement with the expectations of the conventions of a sonata plot anticipates that its ambiguity will be cleared up at the moment of plot resolution (the reprise), when one or the other of the elements from the beginning must appear in some stable form to take on the normal and necessary function of reestablishing the stability of the music’s home key. If what at first appeared as introductory gestures really constituted the principal-key thematic material, then it ought to reemerge as the defining material for the restoration of the tonic. On the other hand, if the material that led so quickly into harmonic instability now comes to be understood as the beginning of the sonata form proper, then it ought to reappear in a tonally stable form here, now that no modulation is necessary. And so we may expect the return of the key of D minor to resolve the problem of clarifying the roles of the dramatis personae that the movement presented at its outset.
8
This ambiguity has been debated repeatedly in the history of analyses of this movement. For example, Adolf Bernhard Marx (1902 [1859]:142–144) manifests no doubt that the first twenty measures are introductory and that the principal theme begins in m. 21. Hugo Leichtentritt (1948:162–163) concurs. On the other hand, Ludwig Misch (1950:42–55) adamantly insists that the first measures constitute the principal theme, and the passage beginning in m. 21 is transition. Misch’s analysis simplifies the structural problem in the movement by disregarding the introductory character of the opening. He likewise describes the interrupting recitative that appears at mm. 144–158 and 155–171 as an ‘intensification’, misrepresenting its character as well.
Narrative in Music
73
But it does not. The opening passage does return, but it leads directly into a passage that comes from another world entirely, a recitative. This leads far afield, to the key of F minor, which in turn side-slips to another distant key, F-sharp minor. Then the music skips abruptly ahead to the secondary idea, now finally resolved into D minor. The rising bass motive never returns at all. As Janet Schmalfeldt puts it (1995:70), ‘the beginning of the recapitulation has the effect of obfuscating rather than clarifying the design at the beginning of the exposition.’ In short, then, the question that we have had throughout the course of the movement remains open, even when we might have thought it must be answered.9 And what of that recitative? Here we encounter one of those remarkable moments that shift the level of the discourse.10 Recitative does not belong to the world of the action of an instrumental sonata but to the genre of opera; it is a specifically vocal style, ‘extra-generic’ to the piano sonata.11 As such, it cannot properly constitute a part of the sonata form at all. Rather, it takes the part of an outside voice, indicating or highlighting precisely the crucial moment in the plot enacted by the rest of the music.12 It functions to draw our attention to the fact that, though we may have formulated a certain kind of question about the music, we will not
9
10
11
12
See Carl Dahlhaus (1980). In general, Dahlhaus’s concern, in contrast to my own here, is to demonstrate the coherence of the form rather than its essential disruption. The “Tempest” Sonata recurs frequently in Dahlhaus’s writings as a work of special interest. Dahlhaus hits the nail on the head when he points out that the ‘paradoxical relationship to the traditional model is actually part of the formal idea of the work’ (1991:169). In his survey of music in the nineteenth century this sonata is represented as symbolic of one side of the fundamental dichotomy of early Romantic musical aesthetics (1989: 13–15). Robert Hatten (1991) offers an excellent discussion of levels of discourse in music, with special reference to Beethoven. Lawrence Kramer (1998) also regards the recitative as external to the action—parergon—a position that corresponds to some extent with mine in the present discussion. He finds in this movement, and in the sonata taken as a whole, the legitimation of ‘the human subject in its own interiority.’ He does not pursue very closely the significance of the specific position of the vocal intrusion in the plot of the sonata’s first movement. Carl Czerny, who knew Beethoven quite well, says that the recitative ‘must sound like one complaining at a distance’; see Badura-Skoda (1970:43). Marx wrote: ‘Der erste Teil war still geworden, fast bis zum Verstummen; der zweite hebt mit jener ersten Largo-Frage wieder an, die, aus der Tiefe dringender emporgeworfen, in feierlicher Dreizahl ertönt und vergebens der lösende Antwort harrt. Streng vielmehr und ohne Zwischenrede tritt der Hauptsatz wieder an, dringt scharf empor, versinkt wieder zur Tiefe und bringt da . . . die Largo-Frage zurück. Ist sie noch nicht verstanden? es fehlte ja kaum etwas, als das Wort! — Und auch das soll nicht fehlen: aus dem Largo tritt ein Rezitativ hervor, — die Rede, die Musik wird; die Musik, die Rede werden möchte, um endlich verstanden und erhört zu werden’ (Marx 1902 [1859]: 144).
74
Douglass Seaton
receive an answer in the form in which we expect it. While we thought that we had understood how to follow the action of the movement, we must now understand that the meaning of this work goes beyond resolving a problem that the music poses. Instead, we learn that at times we encounter a mind that does not intend to give answers to the questions with which it confronts us. Entering at the moment when tension might be resolved and uncertainties clarified, this intruding ‘voice’ has the effect of commentary on the plot itself, constituting a level of discourse that stands outside the movement’s main action. It serves the function of a narrative voice, interrupting the action in this case explicitly in order to refuse the listener’s desire for clarification. Recognizing this work thus as narrative, though always without any dependence on literature, becomes the only way to expose the real nature of this music. 4. Demonstration (II)—Identifying Narrative Voice by Extramusical Means Musicological narratology may also seek insight beyond the work itself. Equally as intriguing as the “Tempest” Sonata’s first movement is another narrative about the sonata, the report of Beethoven’s sometime secretary Anton Schindler in his highly unreliable memoir of the composer (Biographie von Ludwig van Beethoven, appropriately published in English not as Biography of Ludwig van Beethoven but under the title Beethoven as I Knew Him), which forms the source of the reference to Shakespeare’s The Tempest in relation to op. 31 no. 2. Reporting to the composer the impression made by both this D-minor Sonata and the F-minor Sonata, op. 57, in a gathering of Carl Czerny’s, Schindler asked Beethoven to give him the key to the music. Beethoven’s reply was ‘Just read Shakespeare’s Tempest’ (1966:406).13 Although impossible to verify as factual, Schindler’s story engages the Dminor Sonata narratologically on two levels. First, it contributes to the mythology of Beethoven’s persona, which has undergirded since Beethoven’s 13
The original text reads as follows: ‘Eines Tages, als ich dem Meister den tiefen Eindruck geschildert, den die Sonaten in D moll und F moll (Op. 31 und 57) in der Versammlung bei C. Czerny hervorgebracht und er in guter Stimmung war, bat ich ihn, mir den Schlüssel zu diesen Sonaten zu geben. Er erwiderte: ›Lesen Sie nur Shakespeare’s Sturm.‹ Dort also soll er zu finden seyn; aber an welcher Stelle? Frager, lese, rathe und errathe!’ (Schindler 1970 [1840]:pt. 2, 221). The English edition translates ‘in der Versammlung bei C. Czerny’ as ‘Carl Czerny’s playing’, although the German only suggests a gathering at Czerny’s home or organized by him. Czerny need not have been the performer of the two sonatas on this occasion.
Narrative in Music
75
own time an assumption that the narrative voice in Beethoven’s music is that of the composer himself. It further suggests (possibly in Beethoven’s own mind, if Schindler’s report has any basis in an actual event) a connection between the ‘composer’s voice’14 and the character of Prospero in Shakespeare’s play, which turns out after all to offer a hermeneutic clue to the recitative’s intrusion into the music of the sonata. Assuming that Beethoven actually did say, ‘Just read Shakespeare’s Tempest’, Schindler obviously did not understand what the composer was saying, but he urged his readers to probe the subject: ‘Questioner, it is for you to read, to ponder, and to guess’ (1966:406). As a matter of history, Beethoven’s remark really has led commentators to speculate about how the music of op. 31 no. 2 reflects Shakespeare’s The Tempest. Arnold Schering (1934:80–86), to cite just one notorious instance, tried to link all three movements with the characters and action of the play, and Josef Pembaur (1915:3–4) contrived similar detailed programs for both op. 31 no. 2 and op. 57.15 Donald Francis Tovey suggested, although tongue in cheek, that ‘it will do you no harm to think of Miranda at bars 31–38 of the slow movement’ (1948:128).16 Certainly one could argue that the minor key and animated motion make the first movement sound stormy.17 There are several problems with this approach to relating Beethoven’s statement to the music. For one thing, there is no clear sense in which the structure of the music suggests the action of the play. One can only be left with a sense that the general character of tempestuousness or of feminine grace might emerge from various passages in the sonata. This would, of course, be equally true of any number of Beethoven sonatas. In fact, as Schindler’s story makes clear, the composer’s allusion to The 14
15
16
17
The allusion here recognizes Edward T. Cone’s landmark study The Composer’s Voice (1974), to which musicological narratology is greatly indebted for its groundbreaking consideration of persona in music. Michael Heinemann (1991) lists several of the other early writers who also discussed the question of the relationship of sonata to play. Tovey’s point is not to encourage this, of course. Immediately preceding this he writes ‘[w]ith all the tragic power of its first movement the D minor Sonata is, like Prospero, almost as far beyond tragedy as it is beyond mere foul weather’; and he continues, ‘but people who want to identify Ariel and Caliban and the castaways, good and villainous, may as well confine their attention to the exploits of the Scarlet Pimpernel when the Eroica or the C minor Symphony is being played.’ Tovey’s own treatment of the movement (1948:128–131) is purely descriptive of the musical events. See Owen Jander (1996). Actually, Jander rejects any connection between op. 31 no. 2 and the Shakespeare play, instead attempting to place the music into the Enlightenment tradition of musical depictions of stormy weather and the human response to it. The self-evident problem with this argument is that without the reference to the play there would be no reason to make a particular association between stormy weather and this music as opposed to any other Beethoven sonata movement.
76
Douglass Seaton
Tempest must apply as much to the F-minor Sonata op. 57 as to op. 31 no. 2, and one might argue that op. 57 is even more tempestuous. The name became attached to op. 31 no. 2 only because op. 57 already had its own name, “Appassionata”. We might, however, take Beethoven’s comment in quite a different way—a way that Schindler seems not to have understood. Beethoven’s statement, even if it was a direct response to Schindler’s question, need not have answered that question in its own terms. Let us reconsider the exchange in this way. Schindler asks Beethoven for the key to the sonatas, and Beethoven retorts that he should go read The Tempest. What might Beethoven have meant, if not simply that the sonata told the story of or was inspired by Shakespeare’s play? Central to The Tempest is Prospero’s relationship to the other characters. The former Duke of Milan, he lives on a desert shore in isolation from the world. He came there as a consequence of his earlier withdrawal from everyday affairs into his own world of magical studies, having first entrusted his dukedom to his brother, who then usurped Prospero’s position, treacherously conspired with the rival King of Naples, and cast Prospero asea in a leaky boat with only his books and his infant daughter. In act 1, scene 2, Prospero explains his history: … being so reputed In dignity, and for the liberal arts Without a parallel; those being all my study, The government I cast upon my brother And to my state grew stranger, being transported And rapt in secret studies … I thus neglecting worldly ends, all dedicated To closeness, and the bettering of my mind With that which, but by being so retired, O’er-prized all popular rate, in my false brother Awaked an evil nature, and my trust, Like a good parent, did beget of him A falsehood in its contrary as great As my trust was, which had indeed no limit, …
What can this have to do with Schindler’s question? We might suppose that Beethoven’s response (not answer) to the naive question intended to draw a parallel between the composer and Prospero.18 Not unlike Prospero, 18
Theodore Albrecht (1992) actually does suggest that Beethoven may have had in mind a parallel between himself and Prospero, but he argues that what the composer referred to was the fraternal strife between Prospero and Antonio, which in many respects paralleled difficulties regarding business matters between Beethoven and his brother Karl. He does not suggest any connection to the music or its expressive content, nor give much rationale for the composer’s remark as a response to an inquiry about particular sonatas.
Narrative in Music
77
Beethoven had withdrawn into his own art, leaving the common world behind. Also like Prospero, the composer had little patience for the petty questions of small minds. To tell Schindler to read The Tempest was not an attempt to explain the music but rather a way to indicate the futility of such a conversation. In other words, Beethoven’s reference to The Tempest does not relate directly to the action in the music of the two sonatas about which Schindler asked—still less to the D-minor Sonata in particular—but to the place of the music in the experience of the composer on the one hand and his interlocutor on the other.19 It is not, in fact, unreasonable to think of the character of the magician in The Tempest as a model for the position of Beethoven in Schindler’s anecdote. From this point of view, Beethoven’s response to Schindler’s request does not appear to be a direct answer to the question as it was asked. Instead of giving Schindler an explanation of the sonata’s content, Beethoven’s answer simply indicates that Beethoven, like Prospero, sees himself as different from others, a figure isolated by his own unwillingness to trouble himself with the petty interests and naive questions of duller intellects. 5. Synthesis Understood thus, Beethoven’s response to Schindler shares a viewpoint with the first movement of op. 31 no. 2. In both cases the issue turns out to lie beyond the immediate question that Beethoven’s listener poses. In both cases the response, refusing to be drawn into the realm of thinking in which the question is asked, speaks from an outside position that at worst we do not comprehend at all and at best takes us by surprise. The first movement of the “Tempest” Sonata brings to the fore the experience of levels of discourse. The movement’s plot, peculiar as it is, takes place on one level, the level of the Classic sonata form. The interrupting recitative comes as a voice from another world, a voice that speaks in a different idiom, and a voice that draws attention to and at the same
19
Among his list of ten possible relationships between The Tempest and op. 31, no. 2, Heinemann (1991) includes a somewhat similar point to the one that I am making here: ‘Das beliebte Motiv romantischer Autoren der Abgeschiedenheit des Künstlers von seiner Welt, konkretisiert in der Metapher der Insel, auf der der Komponist als Einsiedler in die Welt der Musik versunken erscheint, findet sich auch in Shakespeares Sturm. Dabei korrespondiert die Gestalt des Prospero, der die Faden der Handlung zu jedem Zeitpunkt in der Hand hält, mühelos mit dem Komponisten Beethoven’ (Heinemann 1991:302). Heinemann does not note any correspondence between this observation and the music of the sonata.
78
Douglass Seaton
time denies us a solution to the questions that trouble conventional expectation. Whose voice? We must, of course, steer away from the idea that it is Beethoven’s voice in an externally biographical sense. It is a fictional voice created for this movement and this meaning. To identify it, however, we can turn, perhaps ironically, to Schindler’s dubious memoir. Given its refusal to belong to the world around it, its focusing of attention at the point where the commonplace question fails, and its insistence on its superior position, we must regard it as a voice of isolated genius. To name it we can hardly do better than to call it a ‘Prospero voice’ or, more generally, an ‘exiled genius voice’. 6. Conclusion As this brief discussion has demonstrated, it is quite legitimate to establish definitions and models to support the possibility of musical narrative parallel to but independent of literature. A music-theoretical analysis of the “Tempest” Sonata’s first movement illustrates how narrativity can operate within a musical work. The examination of a story about the composer (in this case a presumably fictitious story) demonstrates how mythology comes into play as a determinant of authorial persona for a musical narrative. In this case, admittedly a somewhat remarkable one, the return from that story to the music, finally, hermeneutically connects the extramusically constructed narrative voice to the ‘voiced’ passage within the music. The “Tempest” Sonata, both in its tones themselves and in its history (or fictional afterlife, if we prefer), thus offers a lesson in musical narrativity. To the extent that this demonstration can serve as a model, of course, it can do so only in broad terms. Each musical work will have its own plot and narrative persona. The process of narrative analysis will differ from work to work, and the hermeneutic insights offered by music-historical or other extramusical evidence will vary widely.20 Nevertheless, this sonata demonstrates that narrativity as a principle does transcend the boundaries of artistic medium. Further, narratological method, still not well established in musicology, has much to offer to the future study of music, especially 20
Lawrence Kramer (1991) rejects structuralist approaches to narrativity in music and instead offers some examples of the hermeneutic work performed by narratological study of music. While I clearly find more to justify the discovery of narrative in analysis than Kramer does, we would certainly agree that narratological approaches are more likely to help us deal with music that lacks structural coherence than to demonstrate coherence, as well as that narrative thinking offers social and cultural or epistemic and self-reflective insights (or insights that combine any or all of these).
Narrative in Music
79
that of the nineteenth century. Musicologists thus have much to learn from our colleagues who work in narratology within other specific fields and from those who contemplate it more generally. References Abbate 1989 Abbate, Carolyn: “What the Sorcerer Said.” In: 19th-Century Music 12.3, 1989:221–230. Abbate 1991 Abbate, Carolyn: Unsung Voices: Opera and Musical Narrative in the Nineteenth Century. Princeton, NJ 1991. Albrecht 1992 Albrecht, Theodore: “Beethoven and Shakespeare’s Tempest: New Light on an Old Allusion.” In: Beethoven Forum 1, 1992:81–92. Cone 1974 Cone, Edward T.: The Composer’s Voice. Berkeley / Los Angeles 1974. Cooper 1990 Cooper, Barry: Beethoven and the Creative Process. Oxford 1990. Badura-Skoda 1970 Badura-Skoda, Paul (ed.): Carl Czerny: On the Proper Performance of All Beethoven’s Works for the Piano, with excerpts from Czerny’s Memoirs and Anecdotes and Notes about Beethoven. Wien 1970. Dahlhaus 1980 Dahlhaus, Carl: “Zur Formidee von Beethovens d-moll-Sonate opus 31, 2.” In: Die Musikforschung 33.3, 1980:310–312. Dahlhaus 1987 Dahlhaus, Carl: Ludwig van Beethoven und seine Zeit. Laaber 1987. Dahlhaus 1989 Dahlhaus, Carl: Nineteenth-Century Music. Translated by J. Bradford Robinson. Berkeley / Los Angeles 1989. Dahlhaus 1991 Dahlhaus, Carl: Ludwig van Beethoven: Approaches to His Music. Translated by Mary Whittall. Oxford 1991. Hatten 1991 Hatten, Robert: “On Narrativity in Music: Expressive Genres and Levels of Discourse in Beethoven.” In: Indiana Theory Review 12, 1991:75–98. Heinemann 1991 Heinemann, Michael: “Lesen Sie nur Shakespeares Sturm!” In: Musica 45.5, 1991:301–302. Jander 1996 Jander, Owen: “Genius in the Arena of Charlatanry: The First Movement of Beethoven’s ‘Tempest’ Sonata in Cultural Context.” In: Alm, Irene/McLamore, Alyson / Reardon, Colleen (eds.): Musica franca: Essays in Honor of Frank A. D’Accone. Stuyvesant, NY 1996:585–630. Jones 1999 Jones, Timothy: Beethoven: The “Moonlight” and Other Sonatas, op. 27 and op. 31. Cambridge 1999.
80
Douglass Seaton
Kinderman 1992 Kinderman, William: “Integration and Narrative Design in Beethoven’s Piano Sonata in A-flat Major, Op. 110.” In: Beethoven Forum 1, 1992: 111–145. Kivy 2002 Kivy, Peter: Introduction to a Philosophy of Music. Oxford 2002. Kramer 1991 Kramer, Lawrence: “Musical Narratology: A Theoretical Outline.” In: Indiana Theory Review 12, 1991:141–162. Kramer 1998 Kramer, Lawrence: “Beethoven’s Tempest Sonata: Musical Meaning and Enlightenment Anthropology.” In: Beethoven Forum 6, 1998:31–65. Leichtentritt 1948 Leichtentritt, Hugo: Musikalische Formenlehre. 3rd edition, Leipzig 1948. Marx 1902 Marx, Adolf Bernhard: Ludwig van Beethoven: Leben und Schaffen. Leipzig 1902. Maus 1991 Maus, Fred Everett: “Music as Narrative.” In: Indiana Theory Review 12, 1991:1–34. Maus 1997 Maus, Fred Everett: “Narrative, Drama, and Emotion in Instrumental Music.” In: Journal of Aesthetics and Art History 55.3, 1997:293–303. Maus 2001 Maus, Fred Everett: “Narratology, narrativity.” In: Sadie, Stanley (ed.): The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians. 2nd edition, vol. 17, London, 2001:641–643. McClary 1997 McClary, Susan: “The Impromptu That Trod on a Loaf: or How Music Tells Stories.” In: Narrative 5.1, 1997:20–35. Misch 1950 Misch, Ludwig: “Das ‘Problem’ der d-moll Sonate von Beethoven.” In: L.M.: Beethoven-Studien. Berlin 1950:42–55. Nattiez 1990 Nattiez, Jean-Jacques: “Can One Speak of Narrativity in Music?” In: Journal of the Royal Musical Association 115, 1990:240–257. Neubauer 1997 Neubauer, John: “Tales of Hoffmann and Others: On Narrativizations of Instrumental Music.” In: Lagerroth, Ulla-Britta / Lund, Hans / Hedling, Erik (eds.): Interart Poetics: Essays on the Interrelations of the Arts and Media. Amsterdam 1997:117–36. Pembaur 1915 Pembaur, Josef: Ludwig van Beethovens Sonaten op. 31 Nr. 2 u. op. 57. München 1915. Rosen 1971 Rosen, Charles: The Classic Style: Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven. New York 1971. Schering 1934 Schering, Arnold: Beethoven in neuer Deutung. Leipzig 1934.
Narrative in Music
81
Schindler 1966 Schindler, Anton Felix: Beethoven as I Knew Him. Translated by Constance S. Jolly and edited by Donald W. MacArdle. Chapel Hill 1966. Schindler 1970 Schindler, Anton Felix: Biographie von Ludwig van Beethoven. 4th edition, Münster 1871; repr. Hildesheim 1970. Schmalfeldt 1995 Schmalfeldt, Janet: “Form as the Process of Becoming: The BeethovenHegelian Tradition and the ‘Tempest’ Sonata.” In: Beethoven Forum 4, 1995:37–71. Tovey 1984 Tovey, Donald Francis: A Companion to Beethoven’s Pianoforte Sonatas. London 1984. Wolf 2002 Wolf, Werner: “Das Problem der Narrativität in Literatur, bildender Kunst und Musik: Ein Beitrag zu einer intermedialen Erzähltheorie.” In: Nünning, Vera / Nünning, Ansgar (eds.): Erzähltheorie transgenerisch, intermedial, interdisziplinär. Trier 2002:23–104.
Metalepsis as a Transgeneric and Transmedial Phenomenon A Case Study of the Possibilities of ‘Exporting’ Narratological Concepts1 Werner Wolf (Graz) 1. Introduction: The Currently Increasing Export of Narratological Concepts into other Disciplines Narratology is a thriving discipline which has contributed many concepts and technical terms to literary studies, and, furthermore, is a discipline that deals with one of the most fundamental and general activities of ‘man [as] the story-telling animal’ (Swift 1992:62). In view of this it is hardly surprising that narratological terms and concepts which originally referred to narrator-transmitted verbal storytelling (embodied for many scholars in print-mediated fiction)2 have frequently—and in the past few decades increasingly—been ‘exported’ to other theories and fields of knowledge. Thus, ‘metafiction’ and ‘mise en abyme’ have by now become widely-used notions that are also encountered, for instance, in art history (Stoichita 1997:158), whilst ‘story’ has been discussed in drama theory (Pfister 1977: chap. 6.1.1.2), ‘point of view’ is employed in film theory (Hickethier 2001: 130), and the terms ‘narrating voice’ and ‘plot’ have also been used in musicological discussions of instrumental music (Abbate 1991:19; McClary 1997:29). Some of these ‘exports’ are obvious and unproblematic; others, however, seem less so. Thus, it is, for instance, problematic, when the ‘story-discourse’ opposition is promoted to a general dichotomy in the interpretation of lyric poetry, as I once heard in a lecture by a colleague of mine, or when the notion of ‘narrative situations’ is not only applied to films (see Hickethier 2001:130) but also to pictures (see Mosthaf 2000: chap. 2.6.1).
1
2
My thanks for careful proof-reading are once again due to Ingrid Pfandl-Buchegger and Sarah Mercer. Recently, the often exclusive focus on literary fiction has, however, been criticized; cf. Fludernik 1996, and Harald Weilnböck’s contribution to the present volume.
84
Werner Wolf
The current export of narratological notions is a process which has certainly not come to an end yet. Considering the debatable exports, but also generally speaking, it is therefore high time to ask under what circumstances such notional transfer makes sense in the first place. I propose to do this in the following, using the example of ‘metalepsis’, i.e. paradoxical transgressions between (onto-)logical levels suggested by works of various media. I have chosen this phenomenon because research has so far largely ignored its transgeneric and transmedial3 nature and, as a consequence, has neglected the relevance of the corresponding term beyond the realm of narratology. In fact, since its first introduction into contemporary narratology by Gérard Genette (1972:243–251), this term and parallel designations that refer to the same phenomenon have continued to be employed almost exclusively4 with reference to literature, and what is more, to fiction as a specific literary genre. This can be seen in the treatment of the subject by, for example, David Lodge, who speaks of ‘short circuit’ (1977:239–245), David Herman (1997) and others,5 and it was only in the recent ‘Colloque International: la métalepse aujourd’hui’ held in Paris in November 2002 that a remarkable number of papers dealt with non-fictional topics. 2. Conditions for a Fruitful Export of Narratological Concepts Before proposing some conditions that render the application of narratological terms and concepts beyond verbal storytelling fruitful and meaningful, I would like to outline the framework or the preconditions within which I will put forward my proposals. 3
4
5
‘Transmediality’, as I define it, is a subform of ‘intermediality’ (‘intermediality’ designates all kinds of relationships between different media). The distinct quality of ‘transmedial phenomena’—or a transmedial perspective—is the fact that similar phenomena occur in more than one medium and that a possible origin in one medium and an ‘intermedial transposition’ from this origin into another medium is either uninteresting or unknown (see Wolf 2002a:18f). Thus, the imitation of an ‘epic’ narrator in ‘epic’ drama is best regarded not as transmediality but as a case of intermedial ‘transposition’ (since the origin in narrative fiction is clear and illuminating for the export domain); in contrast to this, the origin of ‘metalepsis’, as I will argue, may be verbal fiction, but as it occurs in so many media independently of fiction, the classification as a ‘transmedial’ phenomenon seems to be more appropriate. Among the exceptions must be mentioned as one of the earliest and most recent studies that have attempted to widen the scope of the application of ‘metalepsis’: Douglas Hofstadter’s Gödel, Escher, Bach (1980), Marie-Laure Ryan’s “Logique culturelle de la métalepse, ou: la métalepse dans tous ses états” (forthcoming) and Genette’s brand-new book Métalepse (2004, which appeared after the completion of the manuscript of the present essay). Cf., e.g., Nash 1987:94, McHale 1987 (‘Strange loops, or metalepsis’ [119–121], ‘Shortcircuit’ [213–215]), Wagner 2002, and Malina 2002, who claims that ‘metalepsis inevitably operates within the terms of narrative’ (133).
Exporting Narratological Concepts
85
In accordance with the focus of the present volume I shall only discuss concepts that historically or essentially derive from narratology. This means that my remarks do not extend to notions such as ‘polyphony’ or ‘framing’ that stem from other disciplines (in these two cases from musicology and art history or cognitive psychology), nor can I include transmedial phenomena whose conceptualization has no clear narratological origin, such as ‘character’, ‘event’, ‘closure’, ‘suspense’, etc. Another precondition is my assumption of an at least pragmatically justified differentiation of genres, media and concomitant theoretical discourses. This assumption deserves to be mentioned in the face of deconstructive tendencies among some scholars who are unhappy with ‘essentialist’ distinctions between the media (cf. Goodman 1968; Prieto 2002:60f). As a consequence, such deconstruction would also blur the boundaries between narratology and other disciplines and render the question of the ‘export’ of concepts across disciplinary boundaries futile. Finally, a third precondition concerns the mode in which I propose to conceptualize at least some, if not all of the notional ‘export candidates’: if one wants to consider the exportability of narratological notions beyond the realm of narratology, it is helpful not to start from an overly rigid conceptualization. In particular, one should avoid a conceptualization that would lead to a simple, binary inclusion-exclusion mechanism. Instead, it is advisable to conceive of the phenomenon under consideration along the lines of prototype theory. This implies, first, that one should describe typical features or constituents of the phenomenon as discussed in narratology, preferably using examples which scholars in the field have repeatedly regarded as prototypical. This prototype then would provide a basis that permits a comparison with phenomena outside verbal narratives, which, as a result, could be pronounced to be more or less similar to the prototype. In contradistinction to an approach that would yield binary results (‘yes—no’), this prototypical approach allows us to describe certain phenomena as ‘more or less’ like the prototype, according to the recognizability of more or fewer of its typical features in the object under discussion. In many cases it will depend on the respective frames and intentions of the theorist to what extent he or she accepts deviations from the prototype, while still being willing to use the original concept and term. Lest this opening-up of terminology be viewed as a first step in a direction where finally ‘anything goes’, let me hasten to add the following: While I do think that using the same concepts and terms in an inter- or transdisciplinary context inevitably requires some readiness to allow for a certain breadth and in many cases metaphoricity in their use, this certainly does not mean that I hereby advocate a terminological permissiveness or carelessness. In particular, I do not advocate a dismissal of ‘appropriateness’
86
Werner Wolf
or ‘adequacy’ in favour of ‘surprise’ and ‘cognitive dissonance’ as criteria for the use of terminology, as has been suggested in a similar discussion in a musico-literary context (Prieto 2002:51). So, within this framework, what are the conditions and potentials that enable us to meaningfully employ narratological terminology and concepts for phenomena that can be found in fields other than verbal storytelling?6 I would like to propose the following four criteria: 1. First of all, there is the question of the export-facilitating potential of the phenomena under consideration. Depending on the intensity of their links with the genre of narrator-transmitted stories and the verbal medium, phenomena can be located on a continuum between two poles, a continuum which represents the range of their export potential: On the one hand there are phenomena that are more genre- or mediaspecific, such as the narrator who tells a story, phenomena that are intrinsically related to the defining core of verbal storytelling. Consequently, the corresponding concepts will possess, in their substance, an export potential that extends, but is also restricted, to genres and media that involve narrating voices in the constitution and transmission of their storyworlds.7 On the other hand there are phenomena that are rather more transgeneric and ‘transmedial’. Their conceptualization may have originated in narratology, too, but it is characteristic of them to have only a loose or accidental connection with verbal narratives. The corresponding terms are, therefore, in principle also exportable to areas beyond verbal storytelling and even to non-narrative fields. ‘Metalepsis’ is an example of the latter, trans-narrative type with an extended export potential. 2. For both types of phenomena a clear narratological conceptualization and description of typical features is a precondition of a meaningful export in which the exported concept remains recognizable. As is well-known, the lack of such clarity is often a deplorable reality in our discipline, extending even to its most basic notion, ‘narrative’.8 Yet, clarity does not mean over-restrictiveness: in accordance with what has been said above, as long as terminological precision is not impaired, the conceptualization should be sufficiently flexible so that the notion under consideration retains the maximum of the export potential it may have.
6
7
8
In a semiotic framework ‘term’, ‘concept’ and ‘phenomenon’ correspond to ‘signifier’, ‘signified’ and ‘referent’ respectively. Thus, a concept such as ‘narratorial agency’ that focusses on the narrating voice can be exported from verbal storytelling to ‘epic’ drama, to the ballad as a narrative sub-genre of poetry or—with some restrictions—to the ‘voice over’ in film, but not to painting. For an illuminating attempt at clarifying narrativity as a transmedial phenomenon see Ryan’s contribution to this volume; cf. also Wolf 2002b and 2003.
Exporting Narratological Concepts
87
3. Another condition refers to the formal appropriateness of the narratological concept for the target phenomenon in the import domain: Such an appropriateness can be assumed if there is a high degree of similarity between a typical phenomenon in the export domain for whose identification the concept was originally used, i.e. verbal narratives, and the phenomenon in the import field for which an application of the concept and corresponding term is being considered. This similarity can be analysed by comparing the distinctive features of both phenomena. With a view to the afore-mentioned prototypical approach, it should be noted that ‘similarity’ is here a matter of degree in the equivalence between the characteristic traits of the two phenomena. The result of such a comparison will quite frequently not be a verdict of ‘appropriate’ or ‘inappropriate’ but of ‘more or less appropriate’, and opinions may differ as to where to draw the line for a conceptual export. At any rate, some ‘cognitive dissonance’ and metaphoricity should be permitted, and in some cases of apparent surface dissimilarity the possibility of a deep-structural convergence should also be considered. The degree of similarity will not only depend on individual phenomena as such but also on the medial or generic contexts in which they appear. Clearly, narrative genres and media outside verbal stories will present more favourable conditions for the import of narratological concepts than non-narrative genres and media. (It should go without saying that here, as elsewhere in my remarks, ‘narrative’ is not restricted to verbal stories nor to narrative fiction, but extends to other genres and / or media as well, such as drama, the comic strip, film, or certain [series of] pictures.) 4. A final export condition is the heuristic value of the exported notion for the use in the import field. While the manifold possibilities of what may constitute a ‘heuristic value’ elude holistic description, because they depend too much on individual cases and interests, it can generally be said that, given the afore-mentioned conditions, it greatly contributes to the justification of a notional export if no adequate term has as yet been coined in the theory of the import domain. Until recently it appears that this was for instance the case for what nowadays is being described as ‘mise en abyme’ in art history. The use of this originally narratological term can fruitfully highlight practices of embedding pictures in pictures, which Victor Stoichita (see 1997) has described as a frequent feature of what he calls ‘meta-paintings’. A similar fruitfulness can be claimed for the export of ‘metalepsis’, as I hope to be able to show. Even where, in some cases, an ‘indigenous’ terminus technicus is already in use for a given phenomenon in an import field, it can still be illuminating to borrow from narratology in order to highlight, e.g., a common range of functions of the designated phenomenon or a stylistic or other similarity
88
Werner Wolf
among media in a given epoch. This is, for example, the case for some nineteenth-century instrumental music, for whose technical analysis there exists a panoply of musicological terms. However, in some cases (including the second movement of Beethoven’s fourth Piano Concerto; see Wolf 2002b:86–93) the application of narratological terms, and even if it is only the term ‘narrative’, can shed light on cultural contexts and musical effects that would elude a strictly musicological analysis. As the enumeration of ‘export conditions’ for the use of narratological notions in fields other than verbal stories may seem both too theoretical and too vague for the reader, I propose to test them in at least one casestudy, the case of ‘metalepsis’. 3. The Case of ‘Metalepsis’ 3.1 Typical Features of Narrative ‘Metalepsis’ The notion ‘metalepsis’ has occasionally occured in rhetoric since Antiquity—albeit with rather imprecise meanings.9 In contrast to this, and as already mentioned, the first extensive discussion of ‘metalepsis’ in the sense that is relevant here can be found in Genette’s research, more precisely in his influential treatise Figures III (1972:243–251). Thus, metalepsis as explained in the following is clearly an originally narratological concept. Unfortunately, Genette himself does not really provide an explicit formal definition of ‘metalepsis’ (nor does he do so in his 2004 monograph on metalpsis). Yet, his description of the phenomenon, which was based on some examples from the field of ‘high-brow’ narrative fiction,10 as well as subsequent research (in particular Herman 1997, Wagner 2002 and Ryan forthcoming11) enable us to present a clear notion of narrative metalepsis and its typical features as a starting point for the consideration of its export. Thus, a central export-facilitating condition (no. 2 in the above catalogue) is fulfilled. By way of illustration of these typical features let me briefly analyse one of the especially pertinent examples given by Genette (cf. 1972:244) as a 9
10
11
Hollander/Fletcher, in their entry on ‘metalepsis’ mention ‘Quintilian (8.6.37) and later rhetoricians’, in whose writings ‘metalepsis’ appears as ‘an obscure and minor trope, variously defined, ›a change from one trope to another‹, often moving through an associative chain’ (1993:759). He mentions, among other examples, the metaleptic classic, Julio Cortázar’s short story “Continuidad de los parques” (1956, “Continuity of Parks”), and some passages from Sterne’s Tristram Shandy (for one of these see below). Cf. also Lodge 1977:239–245, Genette 1983:58 f. (where he rephrases his 1972 description of metalepsis without substantial alterations), and McHale 1987:119–121, 213–215.
Exporting Narratological Concepts
89
prototypical instance: It is an episode in Laurence Sterne’s novel Tristram Shandy (1768), where the narrator Tristram, owing to his constant digressions, despairs of ‘get[ting] my father and my uncle Toby off the stairs [of Shandy Hall], and [...] put[ting] them to bed’ (IV / 13, p. 285). Tristram’s solution to the problem is to call for a ‘chairman’ who should ‘step into [a] bookseller’s shop, and call [...] a day-tall critic’ (ibid.) to help him with his story. This proves to be successful indeed, since at the end of the chapter Tristram is able to address the critic as follows: ‘– So then, friend! You have got my father and my uncle Toby off the stairs, and seen them to bed? [...] Here’s a crown for your trouble’ (287). In deducing characteristic traits of metalepsis from this example and previous research, it should be noted that I am here only dealing with the ‘genuine’ type of metalepsis, which Ryan has called ‘ontological metalepsis’ as opposed to ‘rhetorical metalepsis’ (see Ryan forthcoming and note 19, below). Further, in accordance with the afore-mentioned condition of formulating, where possible, narratological concepts in a flexible, exportfacilitating way, I shall take care to avoid unnecessary restrictions that would not be justified by the phenomenon under consideration. On the basis of these conditions four typical features of metalepsis can be distinguished: 1. the occurrence of metalepsis within artefacts, or—with a view to drama—performances that represent possible worlds in Ryan’s sense (1991);12 as the example of Tristram’s autobiography shows, such possible worlds can be of a narrative nature; yet, as the further traits of metalepsis will reveal, metalepsis is not essentially linked with narrativity, and so a restriction to storyworlds would seem unnecessary; 2. the existence of, or reference to, recognizable, logically distinct levels13 or possible (sub)worlds within these artefacts or performances; these levels or (sub)worlds usually differ ontologically from each other and can be distinguished—as frequently happens in works involving a mise en abyme14—by 12
13
14
This trait excludes some of Ryan’s quasi-metaleptic examples (see 2003), taken from logic and mathematics, from the core of metalepsis, as they do not occur in representations of possible worlds. It is advisable to include ‘level’ as an alternative to ‘possible (sub-)world’ in the traits of metalepsis in order to account for ‘impossible’ triangles, which represent (and therefore are representational!) three dimensions (spatial levels) in the manner of a möbius-‘strip’ so that one can visually follow a paradoxical move from one spatial level to another without having crossed an ‘edge’. There are in fact points of contact between mise en abyme and ‘metalepsis’: The first applies to the majority of metalepses (i.e. those that involve a hierarchical structure of levels, as opposed to parallel possible worlds, see below, note 16): such metalepses always also imply an at least formal mise en abyme, e.g. the recursive appearance of a novel within a novel, a play within a play, a picture within a picture, or a film within a film (such embeddings will also frequently appear in the examples discussed below).
90
Werner Wolf
the opposition ‘reality vs. fiction’15 or ‘actual present vs. evoked past’16 (in our example, the difference is between the diegetic world of the past, in which the story of Tristram’s father and of his uncle Toby’s unfolds, and the extradiegetic ‘present’ world of Tristram as narrator—a world in which we are also asked to imagine the existence of the chairman and the critic); again, these levels or (sub)worlds can include narrative levels, but are not limited to them;17 3. an actual transgression between, or a confusion and contamination of, the (sub)worlds involved (in our case the main transgression resides in the effect which the extradiegetic critic has on the diegetic story);18 4. the paradoxical nature of this transgression or confusion with reference to a ‘natural’ or conventional belief in the inviolability, in ‘normal’ life and ‘normal’ fiction, of the (sub)worlds or levels involved.19 This viola-
15
16
17
18
19
The second point of contact is a special kind of mise en abyme, which Dällenbach has called ‘réflexion paradoxale’ (‘un fragment censé inclure l’oeuvre qui l’inclut’; 1977:38, 51), and to which Ryan has also drawn attention (see Ryan forthcoming). It should, however, be noted, that mise en abyme and metalepsis are nevertheless distinct: for the two cases of contact just mentioned are incidental and not necessary traits of the phenomena involved (there are also non-hierarchical metalepses between parallel worlds, and there are non-paradoxical mises en abyme). In addition, representationality is a distinct trait of metalepsis, but not of mise en abyme, since mise en abyme can also occur in recursively embedded purely geometrical forms that do not represent anything. ‘Fiction’ as used here (in its non-generic sense), covers two meanings: fiction as ‘artefact’ (which I call ‘fictio’) and ‘fiction’ as ‘invention without direct reference to reality’ (which I call ‘fictum’; see Wolf 1993:38f). In most cases the distinctness of the levels or possible (sub)worlds involve a ‘vertical’ hierarchical relation, which may be visualized by ‘stacks’ (cf. Ryan forthcoming); yet, Wagner (2002:247) has pertinently pointed out that in some cases such possible (sub)worlds may also be parallel universes that cannot normally have any contact with each other (e.g. two fictional hypodiegetic novels by different diegetic fictional authors) and that therefore metalepsis can also operate in a lateral or horizontal direction. I here differ from Wagner 2002, who—from a point of view restricted to fiction—speaks of ‘niveaux narratifs’ as the common denominator of metalepsis (243). Nash (1987:54) unduly restricts ‘metalepsis’ to a ›leap‹ between histoire and discours’, which is an even narrower conception than Genette’s. Genette, again from a purely fiction-centred perspective, speaks of ‘[une] intrusion du narrateur ou du narrataire extradiégétique dans l’univers diégétique (ou de personnages diégétiques dans un univers métadiégétique, etc.) ou inversement [...]’ (1972:244). Curiously, one of his examples (cf. ibid.), the reference to chapter I/4 of Tristram Shandy, where the extradiegetic narrator asks the—equally extradiegetic (!)—fictional reader to ‘Shut the door’ (38), does not fulfil the criterion of transgression. Genette calls this ‘un effet de bizarrerie’ (1972:244) and links it to ‘[un] mépris de la vraisemblance’ (245). Wagner is right to specify that the awareness of the metaleptic paradox depends on ‘une norme particulière qui, pour ancienne qu’elle soit puisqu’elle remonte à l’Antiquité, ne saurait prétendre ni à l’éternité ni à l’universalité [...] la mimésis [...]’ (237). At any rate it is the paradoxical, implausible nature of an ‘impossible’ transgression which forms what Ryan (forthcoming) calls ‘ontological’ metalepsis—as opposed to a ‘rhetorical’ variant, which can be rendered plausible (e.g. if a narrator, in the act of storytelling, is shown to be emotionally affected by happenings of his or her story).
Exporting Narratological Concepts
91
tion of normal expections, as a rule, is the result of an intentional act and usually serves as an indicator of the fictionality of the represented world in its entirety.20 Thus, according to the convention of regarding fictional narratives as if they were ruled by the same laws that apply to factual storytelling and actuality, it would be impossible that a narrator and a helper of his can interfere with happenings which occurred in a storyworld of the past, as is in fact suggested in the episode from Sterne’s Tristram Shandy. The paradox involved in (ontological) metalepsis often has a startling or also comic effect, which is the main reason why it occurs so frequently in ‘experimental’ texts (such as Sterne’s famous novel) that lay bare their fictionality, but also in comedies, ever since Greek Antiquity (as ‘parabasis’ and ‘out-of-character’ addresses to the audience). Taking these four traits together, ‘metalepsis’ may be defined as a usually intentional paradoxical transgression of, or confusion between, (onto)logically distinct (sub)worlds and / or levels that exist, or are referred to, within representations of possible worlds. It will be noted that, in accordance with my previously mentioned classification of ‘metalepsis’ as a notion that does not involve the essence of narrativity, I have not restricted ‘metalepsis’ in this definition to narratives, let alone print-mediated fiction, but permit an inclusion of a wider class of artefacts and performances, namely representations and performances of possible worlds. Although for historical reasons part of a novel was used as an illustration, there is in fact no need for a restriction to narratives, since none of the typical traits of metalepsis requires the existence of a context with a temporal, causal and teleological dimension that distinguishes narratives from other forms of representation, such as descriptions. 20
There are, however, interesting borderline cases. One of them was highlighted during the discussion following the presentation of Ute E. Eisen’s paper at the conference whose proceedings are published in the present volume. If one, in the spirit of her paper and contribution to this volume, applies the narratological notion of metalepsis to the Bible, the so-called ‘we passages’ in Acts present a problem. If Acts is regarded as a sequel to the gospel according to St Luke, a curious inconsistency in the presentation of the narrator occurs: according to the preamble of the gospel, it is told by a heterodiegetic narrator; in contrast to this, the we-passages in Acts (16, 10–17; 20, 515; 21, 1–18; 27; 28, 1–15 [I am grateful to Ute E. Eisen for precise information]) betray a homodiegetic narrator. At first glance, this ‘inconsistency’ could be regarded as an (unwitting) metalepsis that points to the fictionality of the represented storyworlds (provided one accepts the unity of the two texts). When we take a closer look at the text, this possibility can, however, be rejected: after all, the participation of the narrator in his story only refers to the travels of St Paul and not to Christ’s life (as narrated in the gospel), and there is no reason why the author of Acts should not be heterodiegetic with reference to Christ’s biography (as recounted in the gospel), yet homodiegetic with reference to a part of the story of the Apostles (as recounted in Acts), which took place at a later period.
92
Werner Wolf
Admittedly, the four traits of metalepsis which have emerged from a discussion of the export-conditions nos. 1 and 2, namely from the nature of the phenomenon and the conceptualization of the narratological concept, allow a number of variants (nothing has, for instance, been specified concerning the direction of the transgression—whether it procedes from ‘above’ or from ‘below’, or in a lateral direction—, how frequently it can occur, etc.). However, the purpose of this paper, which aims to show the exportability of ‘metalepsis’ from its home-domain, the analysis of ‘highbrow’ written fiction, to other genres and media, precludes the detailed description of a typology of metalepsis.21 In the following, I propose to illustrate this exportability by first focussing on export condition no. 3, the formal appropriateness of using the term ‘metalepsis’ for various phenomena in domains further and further removed from the home domain. A