NARRATING AFRICA
CHILDREN’S LITERATURE AND CULTURE VOLUME 9 GARLAND REFERENCE LIBRARY OF THE HUMANITIES VOLUME 2121
...
180 downloads
1355 Views
922KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
NARRATING AFRICA
CHILDREN’S LITERATURE AND CULTURE VOLUME 9 GARLAND REFERENCE LIBRARY OF THE HUMANITIES VOLUME 2121
CHILDREN’S LITERATURE AND CULTURE JACK ZIPES, Series Editor
CHILDREN’S LITERATURE COMES OF AGE Toward a New Aesthetic by Maria Nikolajeva REDISCOVERIES IN CHILDREN’S LITERATURE by Suzanne Rahn REGENDERING THE SCHOOL STORY Sassy Sissies and Tattling Tomboys by Beverly Lyon Clark WHITE SUPREMACY IN CHILDREN’S LITERATURE Characterizations of African Americans, 1830–1900 by Donnarae MacCann RETELLING STORIES, FRAMING CULTURE Traditional Story and Metanarratives in Children’s Literature by John Stephens and Robyn McCallum THE CASE OF PETER RABBIT Changing Conditions of Literature for Children by Margaret Mackey LITTLE WOMEN AND THE FEMINIST IMAGINATION Criticism, Controversy, Personal Essays edited by Janice M.Alberghene and Beverly Lyon Clark IDEOLOGIES OF IDENTITY IN ADOLESCENT FICTION by Robyn McCallum NARRATING AFRICA
CHILDREN’S LITERATURE AND CULTURE iii
George Henty and the Fiction of Empire by Mawuena Kossi Logan
NARRATING AFRICA GEORGE HENTY AND THE FICTION OF EMPIRE
MAWUENA KOSSI LOGAN
GARLAND PUBLISHING, INC. A MEMBER OF THE TAYLOR & FRANCIS GROUP NEW YORK AND LONDON 1999
This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2004. Copyright © 1999 by Mawuena Kossi Logan All rights reserved Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Narrating Africa: George Henty and the fiction of empire/by Mawuena Kossi Logan. p. cm.—(Garland reference Library of the humanities; vol. 2121. Children’s literature and culture; vol. 9.) Based on the author’s dissertation. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-8153-3275-0 (alk. paper) 1. Henty, G.A. (George Alfred). 1832–1902—Knowledge—Africa. 2. Henty, G.A. (George Alfred), 1832–1902—Political and social views. 3. Children’s stories, English—History and criticiam. 4. Adventure stories, English—History and criticism. 5. English fiction—African influences. 6. Boys—England—Books and reading. 7. Imperialism in literature. 8. Africa—In Literature. 9. Narration (Rhetoric) I. Title. II. Series: Garland reference of the humanities. Children’s literature and culture; v. 9. PR4785.H5Z75 1999 823'.8–dc21 99–11196 CIP ISBN 0-203-90501-6 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN 0-203-90594-6 (Adobe eReader Format)
ISBN 0-8153-3275-0 (Print Edition)
To my mother and father, to all my family, relatives, and friends
This page intentionally left blank.
Contents
Preface Introduction
x xiv
CHAPTER 1 Africa and Europe: The Historic Encounter and Its Legacy 3 Africa before the Atlantic Slave Trade 3 The Atlantic Slave Trade 4 Abolition: Humanitarianism or Capitalism? 9 Colonization and the Image of Africa 15 “Race” and Pseudoscience 19 CHAPTER 2 Pre-Henty: Juvenile Novels and the British Empire Defoe and the Adventure Novel: Robinson Crusoe The School Story: Thomas Hughes’s Tom Brown’s Schooldays Captain Marryat’s Masterman Ready W.H.G.Kingston’s In the Wilds of Africa Ballantyne’s Black Ivory CHAPTER 3 To Africa With Henty: The Socio-Cultural Background Romance and Imperialist Wars: From the School to the Battlefield History, Ethnography, and Persistent Stereotypes Henty: The Favorite Boys’ Author The Henty Hero
25 30 36 41 47 52 64 71 74 77 80
CONTENTS ix
CHAPTER 4 To Africa with Henty: The Gold Coast and the Sudan By Sheer Pluck The Dash for Khartoum With Kitchener in the Sudan
84 85 93 102
CHAPTER 5 To South Africa with Henty The Young Colonists With Buller in Natal, or a Born Leader With Roberts to Pretoria
111 113 120 127
CHAPTER 6 Henty’s Literary Compatriots: Rider Haggard and Joseph Conrad King Solomon’s Mines Heart of Darkness
137 139 151
CHAPTER 7 Conclusion: Legacy and Impact of NineteenthCentury Juvenile Literature
165
Works Consulted
187
Index
197
Preface
Say it loud I’m Black and proud Say it loud I’m Black and proud…. —James Brown
“Why is it necessary for someone to write a song that celebrates Black pride?” Growing up in a country that did not call for the affirmation of Black pride, I used to ask myself this question. In the 1970s, we danced to James Brown’s music without any serious thought of why or how he came to sing “I’m Black and proud.” Although I was familiar with the history of the Black diaspora, segregation, Jim Crow, lynchings, and racism were not part of our everyday reality and vocabulary—they were foreign. It was not until I came to the United States, first in the summer of 1985 as a camp counselor, and in 1988 to study, that I began to understand and appreciate the import of James Brown’s lyrics: the need for the affirmation of Black pride. I came to realize that it was—and still is—necessary to articulate that pride, because “I’m Black and proud” was necessitated by the way racism was affecting the lives of African Americans. Unlike the writers of empire discussed in this book—writers who proclaimed the white supremacy myth—James Brown neither spoke of Black “superiority,” nor White “inferiority.” My work on Henty’s African novels is a step toward understanding the essence of James Brown’s “I’m Black and proud”—an essence designed to counter works such as Henty’s. My sojourn in the United
PREFACE xi
States has led me to the realization that Henty’s ideas (myths) are still prevalent; it then becomes expedient to “deconstruct” these myths since they touch everyone’s life, directly or indirectly. My critique of Henty’s novels was partly motivated by my desire to understand from a social, historical, literary, theoretical, and cultural perspective the ways in which the myths of yesterday are perpetuated. Prior to the advent of television, books were the vehicle through which those myths were conveyed: the adventure story that told of the “jungle” and “desert” islands steaming with cannibals, seems to hold the key to unearthing, analyzing, and assessing twentieth-century racial stereotyping vis-à-vis Africans and people of African descent. Chapter 1 historicizes British overseas empire-building, its precursors, legacy, and impact on the image of Africans reflected both in nineteenth-century juvenile literature and twentieth-century attitudes and policies. Chapter 2 discusses Henty’s predecessors as well as the role their juvenile novels and public institutions (such as the public school system and the Boy Scouts) played in perpetuating racial myths and ideologies which advanced the British imperialist cause. In chapter 3, I address the socio-cultural background of Henty’s novels set in Africa and focus on the ways in which writers of empire, anthropologists, and ethnographers rewrote and distorted the history of Africa, thereby perpetuating racial stereotypes. Chapter 4 is a critique of Henty’s three novels set in West and North-East Africa. In chapter 5, I focus on the three South African novels; chapter 6 discusses Henty’s literary compatriots, Rider Haggard and Joseph Conrad. The concluding chapter evaluates the impact and legacy of the fiction of empire on twentieth-century attitudes to race relations. It focuses on the effects of the colonial encounter and wars both on the colonized and the colonizer in an effort to undermine Henty’s glorification of these wars, and to highlight the ways in which similar narratives distorted, rewrote, and romanticized the history of the colonized. I hope this project will open new avenues in literary history and in the study of reading responses in the young. Ideally, reading materials for young adults will be less readily taken for granted—materials that play a crucial role in the education of the young in the multicultural world of the twentieth century and beyond. I believe prejudice is taught and can be unlearned if we can identify juvenile literature as one of the ways in which society teaches values, assumptions, and prejudices. Writing or undertaking a project is a community effort. I am
xii NARRATING AFRICA
indebted to the community of professors, scholars, and friends who gave assistance during the dissertation phase of this book. My sincere and special thanks go to my supervisor, Professor Florence Boos, for her commitment, patience, and guidance, and to Professor Donnarae MacCann for her unceasing assistance. I am grateful to Professors Jack Zipes, Teresa Mangum, Frederick Woodard, and Jeff Cox for their timely remarks and suggestions. I would also like to thank Jacque Roethler, secretary of the African American World Studies Program, and Vicky Dingman, graduate secretary of the Department of English for their help. This project might not have been possible without the help and assistance from my uncle Gabriel Hope Akator, and Professors Nadou Lawson and Rosemary Yaco at my home institution in Togo, Université du Benin. I am equally indebted to the late Dr. Darwin Turner and the late Professor Jonathan Walton. My special thanks go to my extended family and my friends who, in their unique ways, directly or indirectly, made a contribution to this project. Namely, I would like to thank Konan Amani, Pamela Dautremont, Anita Gonzalez, and Ingrid Wehrle-Ray for their support and words of encouragement.
This page intentionally left blank.
Introduction
[C]olonialism is not simply content to impose its rule upon the present and the future of a dominated country. Colonialism is not satisfied merely with holding a people in its grip and emptying the native’s brain of all form and content. By a kind of perverted logic, it turns to the past of the oppressed people, and distorts, disfigures and destroys it. —Frantz Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth
Imperial relations may have been established initially by guns, guile and disease, but they were maintained in their interpellative phase largely by textuality…. [A]s an operation of discourse [colonialism] interpellates colonial subjects by incorporating them in a system of representation…. The children who read The WaterBabies1 in England in the 1860s were not just being entertained with a pleasing fantasy narrative, but being instructed in the ‘innate’ hierarchies of race and nation. It is when children of the colonies read such texts and internalize their own subjection that the true work of colonial textuality is done. —Chris Tiffin and Allan Lawson, De-Scribing Empire
Fiction, to be sure, is a social product but it also produces society…. It plays a large part in the socialisation of
INTRODUCTION xv
infants in the conduct of politics,and in general gives symbols and modes of life to the population. —Joan Rockwell, Fact in Fiction
In Racialised Barriers: The Black Experience in the United States and England in the 1980s, Stephen Small argues that “identifying and combating racialised hostility was made more difficult in the 1980s due to the fact that each country shared a focus on the use of antidiscrimination laws in the field of policy as the mechanism for diffusing social conflict and breaking down patterns of disadvantage and discrimination” (Small 12–13). Although discrimination and disadvantage are partly rooted in economic conditions and require strict antidiscrimination legislation, as Small points out, they are also embedded in notions of binary oppositions, notions of “White superiority” and “Black inferiority,” and consolidated informally through fiction for young adults. “Identifying and combating racialised hostility” may become even more difficult when it has been informally inoculated through fiction and at a tender age. This book is, first and foremost, a critique of the colonialist discourse that ironically purports to bring “law and order” to “uncivilized” blank corners of the world where “tribal” wars supposedly reigned. Instead of “law and order,” we could say that it was European “tribal” wars that led to the formal partition and conquest of Africa in the nineteenth century—wars that still continue today in industrialized, therefore “civilized,” nations in various, but not so obvious, forms. The study focuses on George Henty’s African novels as a prototype of the literature that emerged with the rise of British imperialism—the literature that legitimized the deeds of the British empire, better known today as the “fiction of empire.” More specifically, my work aims at evaluating the role of nineteenth-century juvenile literature in the systematic construction and perpetuation of stereotypes vis-à-vis Africans and people of African descent. This is not to say that the conception of these stereotypes was synchronistic with the advent of nineteenth-century juvenile literature, but to stress that the image of the African as barbarian, savage, or inferior being, resulting from the activities of the Atlantic Slave Trade and early Victorian explorers and missionaries, had become commonplace by the mid-nineteenth-century in juvenile literature. This image won further popularity among Victorians from all walks of life through the adventure story. It is my con-
xvi NARRATING AFRICA
tention that in order to understand the present, one has to decode the past. In other words, the cultural, economic, and political hegemony of Europe and the United States over Africa has a legacy deeply rooted in nineteenth-century ideologies and theories of imperialism, colonialism, “race,” and the repercussions of the Atlantic Slave Trade. In an attempt to dismantle the myths and stereotypes endemic to colonialist discourse, I intend to critique the literature from different perspectives (historical, cultural, anthropological, philosophical, literary). My theoretical approach is “postcolonial” in that it entails critical reading practices that take into account the contexts and conditions (social, political, historical, economic, cultural, and philosophical) that enable the production, reception, and import of literary texts. According to Helen Tiffin, postcolonial counter-discursive strategies involve a “mapping of the dominant discourse, a reading and exposing of its underlying assumptions, and the dis/mantling of these assumptions from the cross-cultural standpoint of the imperially subjectified ‘local’“ (Helen Tiffin 23). While acknowledging the restrictiveness of definitions, Bart Moore-Gilbert defines postcolonial criticism as “a more or less distinct set of reading practices…preoccupied principally with the analysis of cultural forms which mediate, challenge or reflect upon the relations of dominance and subordination—economic, cultural and political—between (and often within) nations, races or cultures, which characteristically have their roots in the history of modern European colonialism and imperialism and which, equally characteristically, continue to be apparent in the present era of neocolonialism” (Moore-Gilbert 12). These definitions are broad enough to encompass my theoretical approach; but what does the term postcolonial connote? In “How Post-Colonial Is African Literature” Niyi Osundare notes the inadequacy of the term postcolonial: does it mean “beyond-colonial, past-colonial, after-colonial, free-from-colonial, anti-colonial, or simply not-colonial?” (Osundare 207). Granted the differences among the cultures of the colonized peoples, and granted the different colonial practices utilized by various colonizers, it would be unrealistic to think that the colonial experience of an Australian or a New Zealander is identical with that of a Nigerian or a Senegalese, even though there are definite similarities. To do this would amount to oversimplification. More importantly, can we really talk about a postcolonial era when the colonial structures, institutions, and ideologies that were oppressive to the realities of the African people remained intact in the wake of decolonization, and
INTRODUCTION xvii
when the West still controls the economies of the newly independent nations? As Osundare puts it, “we need a new dictionary of contemporary literary terms” because “to apply the term post-colonial to the real situation in Africa today is to be plainly naive or majestically futuristic, no matter what the degree of metaphoric extension we are prepared to grant that term” (Osundare 208). It is equally naive to assume that these labels are in themselves the carriers of “truth,” or the key to a better and in-depth analysis of the texts we intend to critique. Referring to Heart of Darkness: A Case Study In Contemporary Criticism (Murfin), a book on Conrad’s Heart of Darkness, Osundare argues that instead of new insights, the critics do not discuss the dehumanization of Africans, but “simply join Conrad in a ‘poststructuralist,’ ‘post-colonialist’ voyage down the Congo, they too being ‘wanderers on a prehistoric earth,’ surrounded by ‘black shadows,’ black bones,’ cannibals splashing around and pushing, appalled by the ‘smelly mud’ of the Congo—several miles, several centuries away from ‘the tranquil dignity’ of the Thames. To them, too, Africa is nothing more than a ‘wild and passionate uproar’“ (Osundare 210). In short, to term the writing that challenges racist assumptions in colonialist discourse as postcolonial underestimates the various activities— besides writing and prior to the coining of that term—that forced colonial powers out of those colonized countries. What about the “unlettered” men and women who carried out an armed struggle against the British in Kenya during the so-called Mau Mau crisis? How do the “once-colonized” peoples feel about their new label? As Ama Ata Aidoo, the Ghanaian novelist and playwright suggests, “colonialism has not been posted anywhere at all…. Ask any village woman how postcolonial her life is” (quoted in Chreachain 5–6). Because of the ambiguity implied in the term postcolonial, and because one of the objectives of this project is to resist the distortion of African history by the West, adopting such labels will defeat my purpose. Naming is an important undertaking in many cultures, including those of the West. I think this is why we have Victorian Falls in Tanzania, or Boulevard François Mitterand in Togo. As Osundare remarks, names tell stories; they can liberate and imprison. Names can even be self-fulfilling (Osundare 208). Among the Ewe people and many African cultures people do care about the names they give their children who are expected to live up to the repute of their names. I do not believe that Africans are that comfortable with their new names, be they “Third World,” “developing country,” or “postcolonial,”
xviii NARRATING AFRICA
because these names essentially connote those racist assumptions we intend to dismantle. Can we talk about post-colonialism when a contender for the Republican presidential nomination in 1996, Pat Buchanan, echoed the nineteenth-century colonial mentality in reference to immigration? He argued: I think God made all people good, but if we had to take a million immigrants in, say Zulus, next year, or Englishmen, and put them in Virginia, what group would be easier to assimilate and would cause less problems for the people of Virginia?”2
Buchanan may have forgotten that between the seventeenth and midnineteenth centuries, Zulus were among those shipped to the United States as slaves, and during that time there had been no question as to whether the Zulus could be assimilated or if they “would cause less problems for the people of Virginia.” In fact, Buchanan’s comments are reminiscent of those of a British M.P., Enoch Powell, who believes that “all men are equal” but “equal in the sight of God.” It is quite interesting that in the 1970s this M.P. would argue that “the law of Christ knows nothing of the British Empire, knows nothing of nations and nationalities at all” (Powell 88–89). Again, like Buchanan, he may have forgotten that the British Empire was built on a so-called divine mission to “civilize” the rest of the globe. Like Buchanan, Powell views the immigration issue in the United Kingdom as constituting “the threat of the future:” [T]he problem of race relations in this country—how I hate that expression ‘race relations’!—the problem (I would rather say) of the consequences of Commonwealth immigration in this country, is not how this present million and a quarter get on with this present fifty million, but how we can prevent that million and a quarter attaining a size which, linked with their concentration, will be intolerable and unmanageable. (Powell 93)
Although there have been some breakthroughs in pointing out the damage done by the (mis)representation of people of Africa and of African descent, race relations—a term Powell hates with intensity— have not gotten better, and colonialist and imperialist ideologies are with us dressed in a different garb called postcolonial. Wole Soyinka, the Nigerian dramatist, novelist, and critic points out in Myth, Literature and the African World:
INTRODUCTION xix
We [Africans] have been blandly invited to submit ourselves to a second epoch of colonisation—this time by a universal-humanoid abstraction defined and conducted by individuals whose theories and prescriptions are derived from the apprehension of their world and their history, their social neuroses, and their value systems. (Soyinka x)
“Postcoloniality” as a socio-political and cultural condition of Africa is a farce. Today, the cultural hegemony of Europe and the United States over the rest of the world informs us that the economic and cultural productions of Africa are still controlled by the “former” colonizers through language. As Tiffin and Lawson have argued, “imperial relations may have been established initially by guns, guile and disease, but they were maintained in their interpellative phase largely by textuality” (Tiffin and Lawson 3). So, welcome aboard. But before we visit Crusoe’s island, or cruise with Marlow (with Conrad telling him how to steer the boat along the Congo), or visit Haggard’s mines in search of gold, or before we make “The Dash for Khartoum” “By Sheer Pluck” with “The Young Colonists” “True to the Old Flag” with Henty as a war correspondent, let us ask ourselves how “post,” “posted,” or “past” are the colonial experiences narrated by these authors, or how “post” are Powell’s and Buchanan’s comments. The connection between literature for the young and other aspects of social life applies to all historical epochs. Guy Arnold, one of Henty’s recent biographers, looks closely at the “general concept of White superiority” in his works, and notes how that concept persists in modern times. He tells of the formation of a Henty Society in Great Britain in 1977—an indication of Henty’s enduring reputation. But it is not surprising that century-old children’s books continue to be promoted. The political messages of Henty’s African novels are part of the background for new political debates revolving around South African apartheid. The British dialogue over apartheid is particularly noticeable because Great Britain, in 1989, was at odds with other members of the British Commonwealth over the issue of economic sanctions. It is not important to take up the details of the Kuala Lampur Commonwealth conference here, but only to note that debates over British policies toward South Africa were still, in the 1980s, linked to nineteenth-century policies over European empire-building and maintenance.3 Likewise, some of the conflicts that plague the world today are closely related to European empire-building. For instance, the 1885 arbitrary partition of Africa in Berlin (commonly
xx NARRATING AFRICA
referred to as the Scramble for Africa) in the absence of African representatives, and without regard to Africans’ ethnic and religious affiliations, helped engender many subsequent conflicts, the most recent being the civil war in Somalia. Similar arbitrary divisions in the Middle East created years-long conflict between Egypt and Israel, and more recently, between Iraq and Kuwait. The present warfare between factions in Northern Ireland is the result of the initial British attempt at colonization as early as the sixteenth century. One could go on citing examples of the impact and legacy of European colonial endeavor. To understand such a long-lasting phenomenon, we need to consider the historical background to British overseas empire-building, its precursors, legacy, and impact on attitudes and policies. We need to examine the logistical connections between the rise of capitalism and the abolition of slavery in Britain. We need to explore the degree to which missionaries, explorers and traders, who first wrote about the African continent, were ultimately less concerned with the salvation of the so-called heathens, than they were with the pacification of the Africans in order to assume the exploitation of the resources of the continent and to create consumers for European markets. In this first chapter, I shall historicize British empire-building with such factors in mind. NOTES 1. The Water-Babies (1863) is a children’s adventure story by Charles Kingsley (1819–1875). It relates the adventures of Tom, a chimney-sweep who falls into a river and becomes a water-baby. The novel condemns child labor, deplores working-class sanitation, but more importantly it “reworks Darwin’s evolutionary theory to accommodate Kingsley’s ‘muscular Christianity’“ (Chris Tiffin and Allan Lawson 177). According to Jo-Ann Wallace, the unabridged Macmillan edition of The Water-Babies contains passages such as: “whether you have found Vendale or not, you will have found such a country, and such a people, as ought to make you proud of being a British boy,” or “[Tom] was not a bit frightened. Why should he be? He was a brave English lad, whose business is to go out and see all the world.” She argues, that “the intended middle-class, male, child reader” of The Water-Babies is “clearly being prepared for his role in managing less fully developed Others, whether working classes of his domestic environ-
INTRODUCTION xxi
ment or the native Others of the colonies.” The above passages and other similar ones are deleted in the Puffin edition (Chris Tiffin and Allan Lawson, De-Scribing Empire: Post-colonilism and Textuality 171–81). 2. Quoted in the New York Times, 25 Mar. 1996: Section A, p.15. 3. The Commonwealth dispute at the Kuala Lampur conference was sparked by Prime Minister Thatcher’s disapproval of economic sanctions against South Africa and a communique to that effect, although she had already signed the communique prepared in conjunction with the forty-nine Commonwealth members recommending sanctions. In February 1990 Great Britain removed the ban against new investments, despite opposition from the E.E.C. (European Economic Community). Another race-related dispute concerns entry of British passport holders into the British Isles from Hong Kong. The Thatcher government proposes that 50,000 (out of 3.5 million) be admitted and that they be “key” people exclusively—those in law, commerce, medicine, and colonial administration. Such specific “status” tests are rarely imposed upon White immigrants (SeeChristian Science Monitor 27 Oct. 1989:4, 19 Dec. 1989:3, and 28 Feb. 1990:4).
NARRATING AFRICA
This page intentionally left blank.
CHAPTER 1
Africa and Europe The Historic Encounter and Its Legacy
AFRICA BEFORE THE ATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE It is a paradox that in the fifteenth century, when Europe was about to embark on its sea voyages of explorations and conquest, Africans, who were far from being backward would be chained and shipped to the New World as slaves. According to historians Roland Oliver and J. D. Fage, “[i]n pre-historic times—at least through all the long millennia of the Paleolithic or ‘Old Stone Age’—Africa was not even relatively backward: it was in the lead” (Oliver and Fage 14). These historians contend that until the late nineteenth century African peoples were organized into states and communities powerful enough to deter invaders and migrants from overseas. They state that “[t]he real reason why the Europeans did not go inland and seize the gold mines of West Africa or Southern Rhodesia (present-day Zimbabwe), for example, was that the Africans there were already well enough organized to exploit these resources themselves. It was in large measure the progress already made by the Africans in earlier centuries that enabled them to resist the modern age for so long” (Oliver and Fage 14). Michael Craton in his Sinews of Empire notes that medieval European traders and commentators, hesitant to concede that African kingdoms were powerful and sophisticated enough to deter intruders from penetrating into West Africa, often cited geographical and climatic reasons (Craton 15). In her recent book Race in North America, Audrey Smedley points out that during the Middle Ages, Muslim travelers (who knew more about the geography of the world than their European counterparts) left“excellent descriptions of great states, from the empire of Mali in West Africa to those of India and China” (Smedley 3
4 NARRATING AFRICA
43). Among these Muslim travelers was Al-Idrisi, geographer and cartographer of the early twelfth century, one of the first geographers to reveal that the world was round (Smedley 43). This evidence of the sophistication of West African kingdoms and empires leaves us with questions as to how the Atlantic Slave Trade, also referred to as the Triangular Trade, succeeded in taking hold of that very part of Africa that was once outside European invasion and gaze. Why did Africans sell their kin? What was the force behind the slave trade that changed the image of Africans? To answer these questions we must turn to events in the history of the Atlantic Slave Trade. THE ATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE The traffic in slaves that the English came to dominate in the seventeenth century was initiated by the Portuguese who carried a party of African captives to Lisbon in 1441; by 1495 they had already established a small trade in slaves from Guinea. On the island of Sao Tome, long before Columbus landed in the West Indies, Portuguese settlers had developed a sugar cane industry which utilized African slaves from the nearby coast (Craton 4). In fact the English began trading in African slaves in 1560 when John Hawkins “plundered, stole and kidnapped hundreds of people from the West Coast of Africa.” In 1567 the Queen herself, Elizabeth I, invested in Hawkins’s slaving endeavors (Smedley 72–73). The royal family became openly involved in the trade in 1663 with the formation of the Company of Royal Adventurers of England in Africa (Ofosu-Appiah 24). Later Francis Drake, Hawkins’s cousin, made a fortune through the pillage of Spanish vessels (Smedley 73). The building of the British Empire may have begun with the ascendance of Queen Elizabeth in 1558 to the throne, at the age of twentyfive. English society of the fifteenth, sixteenth, and seventeenth centuries experienced significant social, economic, and religious turmoil. Queen Elizabeth’s reign began as the nobility had started to decay and the “common people had fallen into a state of such disorder that the villages and towns were thronged with idle tramps and vagabonds, and the roads with highwaymen” (Story 4). The dissolution of the monasteries and the disappearance of the old nobility as a consequence of the Wars of the Roses worsened living conditions: small tenants had been evicted and had gone to increase the number of those seeking employment in trade and adventure—activities that came to dominate
AFRICA AND EUROPE 5
the era. The reduction in religious commitments also contributed to the spirit of adventure and trade. Ships were being built, companies were formed, and most importantly gunpowder had been invented in the mid-fourteenth century. This brought about a change in the art of war: the old armorclad knight gave way to fire arms (Story 10–12). It is worth noting that it was at the end of the fifteenth century (1494) that the Pope divided all the newly “discovered, yet unexplored ‘heathen’ lands of the world between Spain and Portugal,” and this arbitrary division provided a stimulus to adventure worldwide (Smedley 44). The sixteenth century marked the emergence of a bourgeois class: a class of merchants engaged in overseas trade, and bankers, artisans, and industrialists came into being with a lifestyle of material consumption. Individualism, private property, and the accumulation of wealth became dominant cultural values (Smedley 45–47). Alan Macfarlane remarked that capitalist ideology (individualism, wage labor, land commoditization, geographic and social mobility, and a setback in kinship ties and arranged marriages) had already taken hold of the English as early as the thirteenth century (Smedley 49). Thus capitalism and mercantilism had begun to take shape prior to the British trade in African slaves. These socio-economic changes within English society, plus the English awareness of profitable colonial enterprises held by the Spaniards and Portuguese, their newly acquired taste for sugar and spices, and the spirit of adventure that began to dominate the English mind were the main motives behind the British involvement in the Atlantic Slave Trade (Smedley 72). This period, dominated by an emerging capitalist and mercantile class, also witnessed a decline of the aristocracy since titles could now be bought with money. The accumulation of wealth became the determining factor of one’s status in society. These changes not only gave birth to the Industrial Revolution, they also accounted for the cruel and inhumane treatment of African slaves, considered as property in the New World. Michael Craton notes: A man, therefore, becomes the standard of prices. A slave is a note of hand that may be discounted or pawned; he is a bill of exchange that carries himself to his destination and pays a debt bodily; he is a tax that walks corporately into the chieftain’s treasure, (xx)
6 NARRATING AFRICA
Meanwhile, the English maritime technologies had supplanted those of Spain and Portugal. The English confirmed their control over the seas and later the lands in North America when they defeated the Spanish Armada in 1588 (Smedley 62). By this time in Africa, the glories of the Old World had been forgotten: the three empires of Ghana (eleventh century), Mali (thirteenth century), Songhai (fourteenth century), and other kingdoms had collapsed in the wake of civil wars and outside invaders; it therefore became much easier for slave traders to wage war against communities whose captives were shipped to North America and the Caribbean. During the early 1600s, the demand for labor in the newly conquered North American territories prompted the English to look to Africa after attempts to enslave the indigenous American peoples and to coerce downtrodden women, men, and children from the streets of Liverpool and Bristol into servitude had failed (Smedley 102). Previous attempts had been made to colonize and enslave the Irish people as early as 1169. The Irish resistance to English colonization and enslavement in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries angered many Britons who spoke of the “wild” Irish. William Thomas maintained that the Irish people were “unreasonable beasts who knew neither God nor good manners” (Smedley 56). According to Smedley, the English perception of the Irish was concretized into an image embodied in the term savage. To the English, the savage was wicked, “heathen,” barbarous, someone who was “given to lying, stealing, treachery, murder, and double-dealing” (Smedley 60). The irony, here, is that the English had used treachery, murder, barbarous acts, and double-dealing successively in Ireland, North America, and Africa to coerce the indigenous people into submitting to English authority. The Irish experience with the English speaks to the fact that the skin pigmentation of the Africans did not cause slavery and, therefore, their degradation. But as we shall see, skin pigmentation marked the Africans as a distinct group, easy targets. Historian Eric Williams in his classic Capitalism and Slavery argues that it was slavery that caused the degradation of the African, and consequently led to racism since unfree labor in the New World was brown, white, black, yellow, Catholic, Protestant, and pagan (Williams 7). Besides, in the New World, it was more convenient for European enslavers to impose permanent slave status on the Africans who, besides being thousands of miles away from home, were unprotected by any laws. For instance, the poor and homeless of the streets of Liverpool and Bristol, and the Irish who were shipped
AFRICA AND EUROPE 7
off to the West Indies as indentured servants, some of whom were convicts at home, were protected by the laws of their countries (Smedley 105). Smedley remarks that the degradation of the African is “best understood in the broadest historical context, encompassing economic and material explanations along with cultural-historical ones,” namely the English “belief in their own superiority, which already bordered on racism fed by a newfound and sometimes fanatical Anglo-Saxonism” (Smedley 101–102) But to what extent can we hold Africans accountale for the Atlantic Slave Trade? Does servitude in Africa justify the Atlantic Slave Trade? Given the difference between African servitude and chattel slavery in the New World, the European excuse for slavery is insupportable. Basil Davidson argues that the slave as property had no equivalence in Africa. What Arabs and Europeans termed slave, he argues, could literally be translated as ‘abid, but the ‘abid in Africa also held a position of high responsibility and served as agents of inland kings. According to Davidson, Europeans could not understand how slaves in Africa had so much authority and could command the “disposal and even the consumption of considerable wealth” (Huggins et al. 59–62). Olaudah Equiano makes the same distinction between slavery in Africa and the Atlantic Slave Trade. In his autobiography The Life of Olaudah Equiano, Equiano, who was a slave both in West Africa and the West Indies, argues that a slave in Africa is not a subhuman, but is instead comparable to an indentured servant: the slave (usually a prisoner of war) worked for his master for an agreed number of years and was then free to go back to his people or to stay in that community. Equiano describes the condition of servitude among the Ibo of Nigeria: “they were only prisoners of war, as such among us as had been convicted of kidnapping, or adultery, and other crimes as we esteemed heinous” (Equiano 7). In retrospect, one can argue that since plantation or chattel slavery was unknown to sub-Saharan Africa, African collaborators could not have fathomed the devastating implications of their involvement in the trade. This argument does not, in any way, nullify the African agency regarding the trade in humans. But we should not forget that Africans never crossed the Atlantic with a shipload of slaves for sale and that their active participation neither happened overnight nor without European manipulation. The Guinea Coast of West Africa had long been dominated by kingdoms and states that traded in gold, ivory, and spices with European countries—a trade that later turned into commerce in humans. African
8 NARRATING AFRICA
leaders usually signed contracts with European merchants who were given land on the coast to build trading centers. As the demand for labor in the New World increased, so did the demand for slaves. Initially, the slaves were prisoners of war, criminals, or people who had sold themselves into servitude to pay off their debts, but as time wore on and the demand for slaves became even greater, European nations devised means whereby slaves could be easily appropriated, besides kidnapping (Ofosu-Appiah 20–23). The introduction of firearms enhanced the availability of slaves at the early stages of the Atlantic Slave Trade. Historian Philip Curtin maintains that “it is possible, in fact, that the availability of firearms set off a gun-slave cycle in which an African state used the arms to capture more slaves, to buy more arms, and so on—forcing African states to take up slave raiding in selfprotection, since guns could only be bought with slaves” (Huggins et al 89). As early as 1567, John Hawkins made an alliance with the king of Sierra Leone, and as a result, a company of Africans and English mercenaries raided a neighboring town of about ten thousand inhabitants; Hawkins was able to set out for Spain with 470 captives1 (Davidson, The African Slave Trade 82–83). A frequently cited defense of the Atlantic Slave Trade was that the “heathen” received the blessings of Christianity in the New World. Since all Africans could not be transported to North America and the Caribbean for salvation, proponents of this theory rationalized that they could “save” a few who would return to the “heathen” lands as missionaries. But history informs us that the Africans were meant to be slaves for life. It is quite obvious that this “improvement” was a smoke screen to enslave Africans for labor.2 Marimba Ani notes that Europeans still practiced, until the eleventh century, what Christians would later call pagan religions (Ani 166). But amazingly, it is Europe that would spearhead the “salvation” of the “heathen” souls in Africa in the mid-nineteenth century. Why should a people who had persecuted Christians (Jesus et al.) and then become Christians themselves, enslave and kill others in order to convert them? Ani’s comments are illuminating: she asserts that Christianity was suited to the European utamaroho (that is: character, attitude, aesthetic in a collective sense), because pagan Indo-European culture was violent, aggressive, xenophobic, and individualistic. Ani maintains that pagan Europeans, unlike European Christians, did not use religion as an excuse for expanding their territories, and perhaps this is why paganism was considered backward by European imperial powers in the wake of the so-
AFRICA AND EUROPE 9
called civilizing mission. Christianity offered a solution to backwardness by being violent in the name of God (Ani 166–7). This perspective is an interesting one in that Christianity has always been associated with civilization, and progress, and one wonders if violence was considered a prerequisite for a civilized society. Who is the God that cannot convey his or her message peacefully? It is not surprising that at the height of Christian missionary work Africans, especially subSaharan Africans, found it difficult to understand the brotherhood Christianity preaches, and many refused to be converted. The salvation theory in relation to the slave trade and colonization is untenable. All Europe needed was ammunition. Undoubtedly the Atlantic Slave Trade strengthened the British economy,3 but as time wore on people were drawn into fighting against the trade for different reasons. Despite the economic benefits of slavery, and thereby the strong opposition to antislavery movements, the “peculiar institution” did come to an end by the mid-nineteenth century in Britain. But the trade created a degrading set of conditions that did not disappear with abolition and emancipation. How then was the slave trade and chattel slavery abolished and colonization substituted? ABOLITION: HUMANITARIANISM OR CAPITALISM? The Emancipation Bill of 1833 put an end to both the Atlantic Slave Trade and slavery in Britain and her colonies. This bill resulted from different, and sometimes conflicting, ideas and ideologies. In retrospect we are led to ask why Britain decided to emancipate the Africans after centuries of enslavement. Had the slave suddenly acquired a higher status that would call for his or her emancipation? Did the aristocratic Whig government discover a compelling reason to collaborate with the Evangelicals to pass the bill? (Kriegel 423). Humanitarianism was obviously at work, but beyond it, other forces seemed to be instrumental in the passing of the bill. In the late eighteenth century for example, England was dealing with a hungry and homeless Black population. In 1786 the Committee for the Relief of the Black Poor (a humanitarian committee) was established to relocate London’s Black population in the West African country of Sierra Leone due to their worsening living conditions (Sheldon Harris 43–44). As early as 1601, Queen Elizabeth I, concerned with the increasing number of Blacks in London (some of whom were ex-slaves), issued a royal proclamation ordering all “blackamoores” out of the kingdom.
10 NARRATING AFRICA
By 1772 fifteen thousand Blacks were confirmed to be living in London, a number that increased as ex-slaves in the United States who had fought on the losing British side were transported to Britain at the end of the American War of Independence. The social conditions of these Blacks produced a humanitarian initiative inspired by Granville Sharp to repatriate London’s poor Blacks to Sierra Leone as an agricultural community, with the help of the British government. Repatriation never solved the problem because the idea attracted very few Blacks. Those who went were later abandoned, and their freedom was curtailed by the fact that the slave trade was still in full swing. The Black presence in London brought about a host of concerns, namely the fear of miscegenation associated with the alleged bestial sexuality of the African, and the threat free Blacks posed to limited job opportunities4 (Walvin 8–12). Giving shape and direction to the humanitarian initiative, Sharp took it on himself to speak against the slave trade and to defend runaway slaves, in particular, James Somerset.5 Another philanthropist, John Wesley wrote Thoughts Upon Slavery (1774) which had a large circulation, and turned a body of Methodists against the trade in humans. After visiting a disease-ridden slave ship and seeing for himself the mistreatment of the slaves, James Ramsey, a naval surgeon, decided to campaign against slavery. With the publication of “Essay on the Treatment and Conversion of African Slaves in the British Colonies” in 1784, Ramsey joined the ranks of humanitarians such as William Wilberforce, William Dickson, and the Quaker abolitionists. In 1783 British Quakers formed the Committee of London Meeting and Sufferings and presented to Parliament a petition to end the trade (Davis, The Problem of Slavery in the Age of Revolution 353). In 1786 Thomas Clarkson published “An Essay on the Slavery and Commerce of the Human Species” which won him a prize at Cambridge. In this essay Clarkson argued that the slave trade was not profitable because of the loss of thousands of seamen and that commerce in commodities would yield two or three times the returns of the Atlantic Slave Trade. Raw materials, he noted, could be bought at a cheap price in Africa. He also observed that slavery was immoral, and that the creation in the colonies of a “self-sustaining labor force” that would consume British produce was more necessary than the slave trade (Davis, The Problem of Slavery in the Age of Revolution 353). But on the whole, Clarkson approached the issue of slavery as a “problem of morality and natural jurisprudence” (Drescher 565). When abo-
AFRICA AND EUROPE 11
litionism became a national political movement, Clarkson published another essay, “Essay on Impolicy of the African Slave Trade,” which was “responsive” to the antiabolitionists’ main argument that the slave trade was beneficial to the nation. In 1791 the Abolitionist Society presented a document before the House of Commons: “Abstract of Evidence before the House of Commons.” This document expressed the concerns of Clarkson’s two essays: it stressed the inhumane treatment of slaves in Africa, during the Middle Passage, and in the Caribbean, but put less emphasis on the economic aspect of the issue than did Clarkson’s essays (Drescher 565–66). Why did Clarkson choose to be “sensitive” to the opposition’s claims? Why should the Abolition Society decide to focus on the humanitarian question? Drescher argued that “Clarkson’s own passage from morality to policy is subject to the usual reservations about all such putatively ‘representative’ writers” (Drescher 565). As for members of the Abolition Society, they believed “Britons should be ruled by moral sensibilities and British subjects should be deterred from further blood-guilt” (Drescher 574–75).6 Whatever the abolitionists’ intentions were, as a result of these arguments, more than five hundred localities in England and Scotland responded by formulating their appeals to Parliament. These petitions relied heavily on humanitarian reasons (Drescher 562). The antislavery debate rested largely on moral grounds, and Evangelical philanthropists became active in the abolitionist cause. The Evangelicals considered the abolition of slavery as the duty of the true Christian.7 Their emphasis on individual salvation and un worthiness of humans clashed with the Whig’s quest for esteem and honor. In 1805 William Wilberforce, an outstanding Evangelical, wrote: “Honor is, in fact, the God of idolatry; and where the character is formed on this basis, there is too general a deep and real, though, perhaps, a disguised contempt for that lowliness of which our blessed Saviour exhibited so bright a specimen, and which the Apostles so strongly enforce on all his followers” (Kriegel 428–29). The pursuit of honor and esteem was viewed by the Evangelicals as a worldly aspiration, and therefore selfish, but both groups collaborated toward the antislavery legislation bill. By appealing to liberty, both Whigs and Evangelicals were able to come to an agreement about slavery. The Whigs considered themselves as the party of liberty and subscribed to change. The difference between the Whigs and the Evangelicals resided in how each group
12 NARRATING AFRICA
defined liberty. For Evangelicals, liberty meant the salvation of the souls of the slaves, whereas the Whigs saw liberty as a prerequisite for the subordination of the emancipated. In other words, the Whigs believed slaves were incapable of “dignified obedience” and had to be uplifted to that level. Liberty, in this regard, meant the “individual’s willing acceptance of a hierarchical social order presided over by generous men of rank and honour” (Kriegel 440–50). To the Whigs, abolition was an improvement of the human condition rather than the “salvation of souls.” Because the Whigs identified themselves as the party of liberty, Evangelical James Stephen appealed to them to join hands with the Evangelicals in the emancipation struggle, with Evangelicals “awaiting the judgment of God, [and] the Whigs that of posterity,” the bill was passed in 1833 (Kriegel 450). Whatever their differences, both Evangelicals and Whigs agreed on one thing: that abolition would transform slaves into obedient and cheerful laborers whose needs would be met by working for their exmasters. It is worth noting that some abolitionists were aristocrats whose power depended on the maintenance of the status quo (Davis, “Reflections on Abolitionism and Ideological Hegemony” 800). As members of the landed elite, abolition would not appear to serve their interests. But changes in the social structure help explain this contradiction. With the increase in industrialization, Blacks in England become more isolated because the paternal protection that aristocratic households offered them as a route to assimilation gave way to a laissezfaire attitude. In this new society of individual liberty and selfadvancement, slavery became the symbol of the forces that inhibited self-assertion (Lorimer 31–32). The aristocrats were already losing power to the nouveaux riches as a result of industrialization (because land became less valuable). Therefore they decided to fight for abolition since the ex-slave would eventually need their protection and patronage for economic survival: the slave master (aristocrat) hoped to become the boss, since the ex-slave, without assets, was to become his servant (sharecropper). But emancipation transformed the newly freed slaves into wage-laborers who now worked under the patronage of the nouveaux riches. Thus the antislavery struggle began to take on economic and social dimensions depending largely on the emergence of capitalism. David Davis makes a connection between capitalism and abolitionism when he notes how capitalism forced the rising bourgeois middle class to attack slavery because abolition would upset the social
AFRICA AND EUROPE 13
hierarchical order to their advantage (Davis, “Reflections on Abolitionism and Ideological Hegemony” 802). His assertion implies that by attacking slavery, the members of the middle class could further diminish the power of the landed elite—power which depended on slave labor and which had begun to decline with industrialization. John Ashworth makes a similar connection between capitalism and the rise of humanitarian movements that opposed slavery. Capitalism, he argues, is a “general commodity production,” which includes not only markets but also wage labor and a class of wage-laborers. When wage labor emerged in the Industrial Revolution, it spurred the pursuit of self-interest. But self-interest was socially threatening because the wage-laborer lacked the incentive to uphold the classical notion that citizens should place community interests above the personal. The wage-laborer was likely to “sell out the nation for gain” in winning the economic race (Ashworth 821–22). For the wage-laborer, family and home became the source of support for “morality and social order” in a changing society. And if the family was a source of support, the slaves had no support because the slave had no “home” and was not like the wage-laborer in regard to freedom. In this scheme of things, slavery began to appear as a more hideous institution because it did not offer the independence of the wage-laborer (Ashworth 821–22). It can be argued that slavery began to be considered more hideous because of concerns connected with industrialization in general, and the system of wage labor in particular. It is not surprising that humanitarian movements began to be born, and a group of influential individuals joined the fight against slavery. While abolitionists rejected slavery, they also downplayed the lot of the working class, since abolition did not improve the conditions of the wage-laborer in England, but rather worsened it because the newly freed slaves and the wage-laborer had to compete with one another in the job market. As the antislavery debates became more heated, problems at home continued to threaten the nation. If the importation of slaves were to continue indefinitely, how was the nation going to take care of these unwanted Africans dying of cold and hunger in the streets of London? It was then in the nation’s best interest to put an end to the trade, find means to accommodate the already existing Blacks, and look for solutions to the unemployment that started to gnaw at the nation since “man-power” was being replaced with machines. Blacks living in England were to be repatriated to Africa.
14 NARRATING AFRICA
In 1786 abolitionists including Granville Sharp, Thomas Clarkson, Henry Thornton, and a member of the British Parliament, William Wilberforce, founded the Society for Effecting the Abolition of the Slave Trade. They also formed the aforementioned Committee for the Relief of the Black Poor, and took up a proposed plan drawn by a botanist, Dr. Henry Smeathman. The latter had visited Sierra Leone and had proposed an agricultural settlement for London’s poor Blacks and Whites. On April 8, 1787, under the auspices of Captain T. Bouldon Thompson, 411 immigrants left for Sierra Leone. The settlers arrived on May 10, and after negotiating for land with King Tom of the Sierra Leone Peninsula, the immigrants were given two hundred square miles of coastal land (where they erected the British flag) in exchange for about fifty-nine British pounds worth of goods such as beads, iron bars, tobacco, and rum. Unfortunately problems began to besiege the settlers: eighty-six of them died four months after they arrived in Sierra Leone, and the same number had died earlier during the voyage to the colony. Malaria and dysentery claimed the lives of some; the remaining began to starve, knowing nothing about tropical agriculture. Moreover, English seeds could not adapt to the climate in the colony. Ensuing these problems, some of the settlers began to trade their belongings for food with the neighboring ethnic groups and later began to work on slave ships and for European slave traders! (Alie 50–53) The abolitionists appealed without success to the British government for financial assistance to revitalize the Sierra Leone settlement. In 1790 they formed the St. George’s Bay Company, chartered as the Sierra Leone Company the following year. Henry Thornton, a banker, became its chairman. The company’s objective was to eradicate slavery in the colony and to promote Christianity, commerce, and Western civilization. From 1796 the British government started making annual contributions to the company, and by 1798 this amount rose to ten thousand pounds per year. Interestingly enough, the same year, Britain set up a naval base intended to secure her shipping activities in West Africa. The British took total control of the colony and transformed it into a Crown Colony in 1808 (Alie 54–63). The Sierra Leone experience should be seen as a test case on the part of the British to formally colonize Africa, because the settlers (among whom were few Whites) were to promote, and be ruled by, English culture and laws. As early as 1792, 1200 Nova Scotian Blacks who had fought for the British in the American War of Independence,
AFRICA AND EUROPE 15
asked to be repatriated to Sierra Leone where they hoped to have access to land that was promised them for fighting on the British side. And, in 1796, 550 Jamaica Maroons—who had revolted against their enslavement by the British and had been deported to Nova Scotia— requested and obtained their transfer to Sierra Leone in hopes of building a better life in the Crown Colony (Alie 55–61). It is not surprising, then, that in 1884, at the partition of Africa in Berlin, Sierra Leone officially became a British colony. Hence, colonization schemes began to be drawn (now that the repatriation endeavors were in the hands of the British Crown) even before the emancipation bill was passed. As Eric Williams argues in his Capitalism and Slavery, abolition and the creation of Sierra Leone as a haven for the freed slaves were not purely altruistic, but were motivated by economic and social imperatives. Williams contends that, although the humanitarianism of the abolitionists was unquestionable, Britain could not have passed the emancipation bill if it had not lost its slave-owning territory, the United States, due to the American War of Independence, or if the slave trade had not produced the necessary capital for British industrial takeoff (Williams 179). It is no coincidence, then, that about fifty years after slavery had been abolished in the British colonies, the Berlin Conference made it possible for European countries to occupy land in Africa on a so-called legal basis. The subjugation of Africans at the end of the nineteenth century by European nations should therefore be seen as a logical development of the latter’s previous activities —the trade in humans. Thus, colonization and its practices further reinforced the negative image of Africa already established, in large, by the Atlantic Slave Trade. COLONIZATION AND THE IMAGE OF AFRICA [T]he white savages of Europe are overrunning the dark savages everywhere the European nations are vying with one another in political burglaries. [Europe has] entered upon an era of social cannibalism in which the stronger nations are devouring the weaker. —Herbert Spencer (quoted in Pieterse 120–21)
Britain’s involvement in Africa in the mid-nineteenth century, which I
16 NARRATING AFRICA
call the “return,” needed justification. We are led to conclude from the above discussions that colonization came as part of the abolition program. The abolition program entailed further involvement in Africa, and the Sierra Leone venture was the start. Slavery was deemed morally wrong and economically deficient, so the British, this time, had to use different tactics to justify their “concern” for Africans. The gospel (according to the British) and pseudo-scientific doctrines were major components of this strategy. When we look at the early Victorian explorers, we notice they were frequently missionaries. In 1857 David Livingstone, one of the pioneers in this domain, published Missionary Travels and took the Victorian reading public by storm. The account of these missionaries and explorers raised British interest to a new level. Even Dickens who disliked “evangelical types” exempted Livingstone when he said the latter had carried “into desert places the water of life” (Brantlinger 186–95). Livingstone thought commerce and Christianity were the only means to “civilize” Africans, since slavery continued after its abolition in England. Major Victorian scholars and writers also subscribed to this type of reasoning, among them Charles Dickens and Thomas Carlyle. These Victorian writers’ views on slavery, its abolition, the emancipation of the slaves, and the colonization of Africa are of crucial importance because their writings reflected and shaped public opinion, and sometimes they influenced parliamentary decisions vis-à-vis the colonies. In his essay “The Niger Expedition,” Charles Dickens tells of the initiative taken by Great Britain to urge African chiefs along the coast of West Africa to end the slave trade and, consequently, to introduce “among these pagans the true doctrine of Christianity.” Obi Osai, a local chief, did not keep his promise to substitute the slave trade with commerce in commodities such as ivory, cotton and indigo for cloth, cowries, and beads (Dickens 46), an indication that Africans (or their chiefs) were to be held responsible for the continuation of the trade. We are led to conclude that, because they were heathens, savages, and uncivilized, these chiefs and their collaborators were unaware of the degradation of their own people (caused by the trade), and that Christianity would ultimately “civilize” and lead them toward abolition. The problem with this interpretation is that it disregards the fact that the trade could only be eradicated if and when those who owned the slave ships decided to stop the traffic. In his novel Bleak House, Dickens, perhaps unconsciously, summarizes the motives of the English philanthropists of the century. In this novel, Mrs. Jellyby’s interest in
AFRICA AND EUROPE 17
Africa is threefold: the “cultivation of coffee berry—and the natives— and the happy settlement, on the banks of African rivers, of our superabundant home population” (Dickens, Bleak House 82). In fact the superabundant home population, I would argue, includes the homeless and poor Blacks in England. The cultivation of coffee, which is a cash crop, is definitely not for the benefit of the Africans, and the “cultivation” of “the natives” reinforces the assumption that Africans needed European civilization and culture to make them human. It therefore becomes difficult to think that this program, to which Mrs. Jellyby (and by extension English philanthropists) is devoted to the point of ignoring her parenting responsibilities, is purely altruistic. Thomas Carlyle, a prominent author and critic, preceded Dickens in expressing similar views, particularly in his essay “The Nigger Question” (1849).8 Carlyle wrote his essay at a time when British plantation owners in the West Indies faced problems as abolitionists secured the end of British participation in the Atlantic Slave Trade in 1807 and the emancipation bill in 1833. The newly freed slaves either demanded higher wages or bought their own small farms. As a result the cost of sugar in the West Indies climbed, and the British labor system was in chaos: the Chartists threatened violence if their demands were not met. Both Carlyle and Dickens ridiculed Evangelical Christianity and philanthropy, given the problems affecting the national economy due to the abolition of slave labor. In “The Nigger Question,” Carlyle’s contempt for Africans is illustrated by a character of the author’s imagination, Quashee, who embodies all the stereotypical characteristics of the lazy, indolent, pumpkin-eating African. Carlyle believed that it would be total folly to emancipate “the West Indies into a Black Ireland; free indeed, but an Ireland, and Black!” (August 7). He maintained: I have come to the sad conclusion that SLAVERY, whether established by law, or law abrogated, exists very extensively in this world, in and out of the West Indies; and in fact, that you cannot abolish slavery by act of parliament, but only can abolish the name of it, which is very little. If the Wisest Man were at the top of society, and the next-wisest next, and so on till we reached the Demerara Nigger (from whom downwards, through the horses, etc., there is no question hitherto), then were this a perfect world, the extreme maximum of wisdom produced in it. (August 14–15)
It is clear that Carlyle adhered to the theory of the “chain of being” in
18 NARRATING AFRICA
vogue at that time. Besides Mill’s response to Carlyle, another anonymous essay appeared in the December 8, 1849, issue of TheInquirer. In this essay, “Mr. Carlyle on the Negroes,” the author outlined certain facts that are worthy of attention: Mr. Carlyle might, at this day, have been a naked Pict, disputing with swine for acorns, and showing even less of a higher nature than Quashee squatting on a Jamaican waste, but for the inheritance of arts, and laws, and literature, which his forefathers derived from the Romans. The Northern barbarians received the impulse from Rome; Rome from the Etruscans and the Greeks; the Greeks from Egyptians or the Phoenicians. In the earliest antiquity there were dark-skinned Africans amongst those “dead but sceptred sovereigns who still rule our spirits from their urns.” (August 55)
The author of the above quotation highlights the impact Carlyle’s essay could have on “race” relations not only in England but also the United States, by adding that in the United States “whatever precedes from Carlyle’s pen is read with avidity” (August 55). The image of Africans as barbarian, uncivilized, and pagan is as old as the Atlantic Slave Trade and plantation slavery in the New World. The pervasiveness of these stereotypes during the Victorian period was intended to justify England’s “return” to the continent through imperialist ideologies. Patrick Brantlinger, in his essay “Victorians and Africans: The Genealogy of the myth of the Dark Continent,” argues that great Victorian explorers such as David Livingstone and Henry Stanley, along with the evolutionary doctrines of Darwin, helped fortify what became known as the “myth of the Dark Continent” (Brantlinger 186). Historian Philip Curtin asserts that the popular image of Africa was clearly established by the 1850s: “It was found in children’s books, in Sunday school tracts, in the popular press. Its major affirmations were the ‘common knowledge’ of the educated classes. Thereafter, when new generations of explorers or administrators went to Africa, they went with a prior impression of what they would find” (Curtin xxi). According to Oliver and Page, the notion of Africa as the Dark Continent is a narrow European idea which became popular “because Africa was the last continent to be open to the gaze of the outside world…” and because the Africans had already made enough progress in earlier centuries to resist the modern age for such a long time (13–14). In an editorial foreword to A Short History of Africa, Ronald Segal points out:
AFRICA AND EUROPE 19
While the centers of European culture flourished, decayed, and sprouted in turn empires in Africa rose, ruled, resisted, and succumbed. Scholars studied and disputed in Timbuctu as in Paris, and what the Italians accomplished with pigment, the artists of Benin achieved in bronze. The cultures were different, but only on the horizontal. The vertical, the separation into superior and inferior, was a product of conquest. (Oliver and Page 10)
While it is true that conquest prompted by socio-economic conditions in England contributed largely to the negative image of Africa, one must hasten to add that pseudoscientific doctrines and race theories were also crucial factors. RACE AND PSEUDOSCIENCE Theories about race began to gather momentum during the Victorian era to explain the so-called inferiority of the nonwhite. Race classifications were in vogue as early as the first half of the eighteenth century when, in 1738, Swedish botanist Carolus Linnaeus assigned all mankind to the species Homo sapiens (“Wise Man”). Linnaeus then divided the human species into the following varieties: The Americanus (American Indian) he characterized as tenacious, contented, free, and ruled by custom; the Europaeus (European) is alleged to be light, inventive, and ruled by rites; the Asiaticus (Asian) is described as stern, haughty, stingy, and ruled by opinion. Finally, he characterized the Afer (African) as cunning, slow, negligent, and ruled by caprice (Dunn and Dobzhansky 109). It is evident that he based this classification on continent of origin and on alleged mental capabilities. The problem with this classification is that slow, stingy, and contented people can also be found in that part of the world inhabited by the Europaeus. In other words, this classification is biased and self-serving. In 1775 a German scholar and founder of anthropology, Otto Blumenbach, chose to divide the human species into five varieties according to skin color; to each variety he gave the name race: Caucasian or White; Mongolian or yellow; Ethiopian or Black; American or red; Malayan or brown (Dunn and Dobzhansky 110). Although Blumenbach did not base his classification on intellectual faculty, when we combine the two (Linnaeus’s and Blumenbach’s) it becomes easy to attribute to the White race superior mental faculties and inferior ones to Blacks. Consequently, the empire builders of Victorian England relegated Black or darker people to an inferior status, and thereby,
20 NARRATING AFRICA
were able to justify their “civilizing” mission. These race classifications remained dormant until the mid-nineteenth century when the British began their colonization schemes. Brantlinger points out that between 1790 and 1840 major writing about Africa was antislavery propaganda. The image of the African then was the romanticized “noble savage.” For example, in his poem “The Slave Trade Abolished” James Grahame writes: In that fair land of hill, and dale, and stream, The simple tribes from age to age had heard No hostile voice…(quoted in Brantlinger 189)
But that Utopian image predates the introduction of traits of “civilization”: avarice, treachery, murder, warfare, and slavery (Brantlinger 189). Marlow, in Conrad’s Heart of Darkness, tells us that Africa is “not a blank space any more. It had become a place of darkness” (Conrad 71). Brantlinger capitalizes on Marlow’s remark to point out that Africa had become dark because “Victorian explorers, missionaries, and scientists flooded it with light [that] was refracted through an imperialist ideology that urged the abolition of savage customs in the name of civilization” (Brantlinger 173). According to Michael Banton and Jonathan Harwood, the science of race climaxed during the mid-nineteenth century when a variety of classifications emerged and raised questions as to motives. Since a classification is a tool, they argue, it would be difficult to assert the appropriateness or validity of any classification, not to mention that of race, unless we know what is to be done with it (Goldberg 64). Lucius Outlaw, in his article “Toward a Critical Theory of Race,” argues that race can be defined partly geographically, partly culturally, and partly politically (Goldberg 1990:68). In a word race is a trope, a social formation, used by Victorians to justify their overt “civilizing” mission. The covert mission is summarized in Conrad’s Heart of Darkness: “To tear treasure out of the bowels of the land was their desire, with no more purpose at the back of it than there is in burglars breaking into a safe” (99). The stereotypes associated with Africans and the justification of England’s presence in Africa continued to be enforced not only by the early explorers, pseudoscientific doctrines, and selfserving theories, but also by various writers of popular literature, among them the famous boys’ writer George Henty. George Henty was among the most influential Victorian juvenile authors, a writer
AFRICA AND EUROPE 21
who was highly selective and deliberate about the images of society that he presented to the young. In one of Henty’s African novels, By Sheer Pluck: A Tale of the Ashanti War (1884), an English naturalist, Mr. Goodenough, “instructs” Frank (the hero) with a pseudoscientific description of West African peoples: They are always laughing or quarreling. They are good-natured and passionate, indolent, clever up to a certain point, densely stupid beyond. The intelligence of an average negro is about equal to that of a European child of ten years old…. They are fluent talkers, but their ideas are borrowed…. Living among whites their imitative faculties enable them to attain a considerable amount of civilization. Left alone to their own devices they retrograde into a state little above their native savagery. (117–18)
Henty’s comments on the West African personality (that is, according to him, West Africans are the most indolent of all Africans), raise the question about the role of stereotypes. In other words, why do we create stereotypes? Quoting Jack Levin, Sander Gilman argues in his Difference and Pathology (1985) that we cannot function in the world without stereotypes because “they perpetuate a needed sense of difference between the ‘self and the ‘object,’ which becomes the ‘Other’ (18). Gilman opines that stereotypes are necessary because their creation is a “concomitant of the process by which all human beings become individuals” (17). Our sense of self and the world begins during infancy when the self is “split” into a “good” self and a “bad” self, between the “good” and “bad” object. Given that there is no real rupture between the “bad” self and the “good” self, his argument continues, an imaginary line must be drawn in order for the self to be able to cope with the “contradictions present in the necessary integration of ‘bad’ and ‘good’ aspects of the self (17). However, herein lie the origins of stereotypes. In stereotyping, we project our anxieties, our loss of control of the object, onto the “bad” self, which, “with its repressed sadistic impulses, becomes the ‘bad’ Other, and the ‘good’ self/object becomes the antithesis to the flawed image of the self, the self out of control” (20). In short, stereotypes attest to our inability or failure to deal honestly with ourselves (the “bad” self), in that the “bad” Other is essentially a projection of the “bad” self. Gilman distinguishes between pathological and nonpathological stereotyping. While the latter gives us an ephemeral control of our environment and is discarded when anxiety is surmounted, the patho-
22 NARRATING AFRICA
logical personality lacks the ability to distinguish the individual from the stereotyped group or class, and therefore maintains a rigid line of difference found in the stereotype (18). Following this line of thought, the stereotypes one finds in Henty’s works should be viewed (at least today) not only as pathological, but also as contagious because they have not been discarded after their immediate use in justifying European domination of Africa. In other words, the persistence and reshaping of nineteenth-century racial stereotypes on the eve of the twentiethfirst century attest to the pathological and contagious nature of stereotypes. Because Henty maintains this rigid line between the self and the Other in his writings, a critical reading of his juvenile novels should reveal more about the “bad” self (British), masked as the “bad” Other (Africans), since it would be naive to assume that the self is endowed exclusively with the “good,” and the Other the “bad.” As a pedagogical tool, juvenile literature in European history reflected the values, attitudes, and fantasies of the adult world. The following chapter discusses the advent of juvenile literature, its development, and its role in the building of the British empire. I shall discuss specific works of writers who predate Henty to show how the development of nineteenth-century juvenile literature was concomitant with the imperialist mission. NOTES 1. There is a linkage here between this European manipulation of the scene during the Atlantic Slave Trade and what became known in 1993 as Operation Restore Hope in Somalia. European countries had previously sold arms to Somalia prior to the civil war; in the wake of political and ideological disagreements that could have been settled amiably, factional groups resorted to the arms they had been encouraged by the manufacturers to purchase for national defense purposes. After much damage has been done and much ammunition has been sold, “humanitarians” from Europe and the United States went into Somalia to disarm the people they had armed to the teeth in the previous years, and we all praise their humanitarian objectives! This point is not to stipulate that the availability of arms justifies the civil war in Somalia, but to call to mind the continuing Western interference and manipulation of the African scene. 2. Christianity did not originate in Europe, but was appropriated by
AFRICA AND EUROPE 23
Europe since all the monotheistic religions (Judaism, Christianity, and Islam) originated in what is known today as the Middle East. In fact Christianity was introduced into Ethiopia as early as the fourth century, prior to its advent in Europe (Ullendorff 11). 3. As historian Michael Craton notes, “[c]ertain facts are inescapable. Slavery was the basis of the most valued part of British mercantilist empire which, in a latter era and under a different covenant, came to cover 30 percent of the world’s land area. British slavery by any account has had a decided, if indirect, influence on a large portion of the modern world” (xxi). Therefore, British policymakers thought that the abolition of slavery was “incoherent with the Interest and Policy of Great Britain, that from the Silence of the Planters it may be concluded, they place such Confidence in the Wisdom of the British Senate as renders any serious Opposition unnecessary” (quoted in Craton xxi). 4. The concerns of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries were not confined to the living conditions of the free, poor, Black population, but included the English working class. The deplorable plight of this class is reflected in this anonymous poem of the era, “Two Weavers.” Ironically, in this poem, the English working class is in worse shape than the African slave: “Now these are a few o’ the ills which I think, Have driven auld Britain to misery’s brink, And made her free sons, once intrepid and brave, To envy the lot o’ the African slave; Poor Britain! how sadly thy glories decline….” 5. In 1771 James Somerset, who was brought from Virginia to England, deserted his master. He was arrested and taken to court. Although Sharp never appeared in court, he urged Somerset to reject any compromise offer of manumission, since English laws prohibited slavery on English soil. The decision of the court set Somerset free and granted freedom to any slave brought to England. 6. Ironically, although Clarkson and the Abolition Society thought slavery was morally wrong, they also emphasized that its elimination would damage England’s economy. The sugar cane planta-
24 NARRATING AFRICA
tions in the West Indies were deemed crucial to economic wellbeing at home (Drescher 562). 7. Since the reign of King Henry VIII (1509–1547), the Church of England had been the official established church of the nation until 1830 when it underwent reforms. These reforms include the admission of Dissenters (nonconformist churches or sects) and Roman Catholics to Parliament. Besides, reforms in Parliament led the latter to legislate for the church, and the Anglican Church lost its role in national politics. As a result of these divisions within the church and as an antidote to the growing religious indifference of the masses, a religious revival occurred: Evangelicalism began to take shape (Altholz, Victorian England 1837–1901 155). 8. In December of 1849, an anonymously authored essay appeared in Fraser’s Magazine entitled “Occasional Discourse on the Negro Question.” Because of the racist content of the article, it was condemned by many, including John Stuart Mill, who knew that Carlyle was the author of the offensive essay. Mill responded to this article, also published anonymously, in the next issue of Fraser’s Magazine and entitled it “The Negro Question.” Carlyle expanded on his original article and published it in pamphlet form with a more offensive title, “Occasional Discourse on the Nigger Question,” which he later called “The Nigger Question.” Carlyle’s essay is an example of Victorian writing that helped perpetuate the myth of Black inferiority, and consequently shaped modern attitudes toward Africans and their descendants.
CHAPTER 2
Pre-Henty Juvenile Novels and the British Empire
It is now recognized that juvenile literature acts as an excellent reflector of the dominant ideas of an age. The values and fantasies of adult authors are dressed up in fictional garb for youthful consumption, and the works thereby become instrumental in the dissemination and perpetuation of particular clusters of ideals, assumptions and ambitions. —John MacKenzie, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature
Popular fiction is one of the ways by which society instructs its members in its prevailing ideas and mores, its dominant role models and legitimate aspirations. It both reflects popular attitudes, ideas and preconceptions and it generates support for selected views and opinions. So it can act—sometimes simultaneously—as a form of social control, directing the popular will towards certain viewpoints and attributes deemed desirable by those controlling the production of popular fiction, and as a mirror of widely-held popular views. —Jeffrey Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature
Today the popularity of children’s literature obfuscates the fact that concepts of childhood and literature for children are relatively recent. Throughout Western Europe, the beginning of the seventeenth century brought a new understanding of the notion of childhood, thereby creat25
26 NARRATING AFRICA
ing new cultural institutions (for example, the school system) and new classes of readers (children and young adults). Until then children had been considered as adults in miniature, having few special needs and interests. Toys and dress, previously shared by both adults and children, became the child’s after they had been simplified and altered. In England literature specifically directed toward children and young adults was hardly written until the end of the eighteenth century. Its advent was occasioned by the Evangelicals’ concern to purify and pacify the youth of an urban and industrialized society through religious teachings. Moralists and pedagogues within the church began to nurture the idea that not only were children different from adults, but also innocent; they should be isolated from the corrupt and corrupting circle of adults. Thus children were to be safeguarded, protected, and educated through books deemed appropriate to their special pedagogic requirements. This new perception of the child provided the framework for children’s literature1 which began to flourish at breathtaking speed, coinciding with the period of British notions of empire-building during the second half of the nineteenth century. This rapid growth was magnified by advances made in printing technology and the spread of educational opportunities (Shavit 3–7). By the end of the nineteenth century, literature for the young had taken on new dimensions and directions. While not confined to empire-building, juvenile literature became one of the vehicles for the dissemination and inculcation of imperialist concepts and ideologies— a far cry from its original purpose. John Mackenzie’s argument in Imperialism and Juvenile Literature—that juvenile literature is reflective of the adult society that produces it—establishes a connection between the content of juvenile literature and the practice of empirebuilding. Juvenile literature offered a site for the “dissemination of particular clusters of ideas, assumptions, and ambitions” of the Victorian people, for example, the extension of the British empire at the expense of Africa and other nonindustrialized nations. Jeffrey Richards argues in his introduction to Imperialism and Juvenile Literature that between 1850 and 1950 imperialism became the “dominant ideology,” transcending class and party divisions: Britain was saturated in the ethos and attitudes of empire. They infused plays and books and, later, films. They informed school textbooks. They inspired paintings, prints and engravings. They filled newspapers and magazines. They figured in advertisements and packaging. The
PRE-HENTY 27
impact was arguably greater than that of any previous dominant ideology because its pre-eminence coincided with the rise of the mass market and mass media. (Richards 2)
Consciously or unconsciously, this ideology was inescapable in that it permeated Victorian society in all walks of life. But how did this come about? This chapter sets out to explore the various connections among literature for young readers in Victorian England, the public school system, and British imperialism. In other words, I shall examine the role of nineteenth-century juvenile literature and public institutions in perpetuating racial myths and ideologies which advanced the British imperialist cause. Our specific frame of reference will be Daniel Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe, Thomas Hughes’s Tom Brown’s Schooldays, Frederick Marryat’s Masterman Ready, W.H.G. Kingston’s In the Wilds of Africa, and R.M.Ballantyne’s Black Ivory. Since its advent, juvenile literature had essentially been didactic, although it also had a role as entertainment. In Boys Will Be Girls, Claudia Nelson asserts that although “entertainment may have formed the limbs” of juvenile literature, “didacticism remained its backbone” (1). In 1788 Mrs. Trimmer published Fabulous Histories: Designed for the Instruction of Children Respecting Their Treatment of Animals. This book, dedicated to Princess Sophia, was described in its introduction as “a series of fables.” It stressed moral and Christian values suitable for children. Between 1792 and 1796, Mrs. Barbauld and Dr. Aiken wrote and published Evenings at Home or The Juvenile Budget Opened, subtitled “Consisting of a Variety of Miscellaneous Pieces for the Instruction of Young Persons.” Like Fabulous Histories, Evenings at Home contains a mixture of stories, moral and religious teachings, and facts. Maria Edgeworth’s The Parents’ Assistant or Stories for Children appeared in 1796, and Mrs. Sherwood published her History of the Fairchild Family in 1818. All these nursery classics have one main objective: to protect, discipline, and teach good manners and morals (Musgrave 21–23). By midcentury, it became evident that these nursery classics no longer met the needs of a juvenile audience, as imperialism was becoming the order of the day. Thomas Arnold, headmaster at Rugby, wrote in 1842: “Childishness in boys, even of good abilities, seems to be a growing fault, and I do not know to what to ascribe it, except to the greater number of exciting books of amusement like Pickwick or Nickleby” (quoted in Musgrave 24). Arnold’s observation alludes to
28 NARRATING AFRICA
juvenile literature as a distinct genre of entertainment—an evolving nineteenth-century concept. Although Defoe had already published Robinson Crusoe (1719), it was not intended for children or young adults. William Bryce argued in his Half-Hours with Famous Writers for Boys, that Defoe did not write Robinson Crusoe for boys of eight to fifteen, nor did he write it for the young man of twenty-one. Defoe was a middle-aged man, Bryce asserted, and he wrote the novel for middle-aged men like himself (Bryce 5). While this may be true, the novel became and remains a boys’ novel, and as we shall see, Robinson Crusoe became the model for the adventure story during the second half of the nineteenth century. In 1857 Thomas Hughes published his classic, Tom Brown’s Schooldays, and revitalized the school story that aimed at moral maturity (Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature 174). While Hughes concerned himself with boyhood and manhood in school and at home, late nineteenth-century writers concentrated on boyhood and manhood in exotic settings. When Defoe wrote Robinson Crusoe in 1719, the English were beginning to dominate the seas, adventure was in vogue, and the Atlantic Slave Trade was in full swing. By 1840 England had already abolished the slave trade in its territories, and colonization schemes were beginning to emerge. Arnold’s complaint— that “childishness in boys seems to be a growing fault” in juvenile literature—coincided with revival and adaptations of Robinson Crusoe, a story that embodied the spirit of adventure, conquest, and empire. With the advent of the late-nineteenth-century adventure story,2 juvenile literature which had once catered to both boys and girls became essentially boys’ literature (Musgrave 45). In the second half of the century the fictional adventure tale coexisted with the school story in works by writers such as Ballantyne, Marryat, Kingston, and Henty (Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature 174). Defoe’s adventure tale, Robinson Crusoe, and Hughes’s school story Tom Brown’s Schooldays can serve as our frame of reference when we critique the works of these writers of empire, not because Robinson Crusoe was the very first English adventure novel (although it has been considered such), or Tom Brown’s Schooldays the first school story, but because both works had an unprecedented impact on the writers under discussion in this chapter. When Robinson Crusoe first appeared,3 it had an instant and enduring appeal, and was soon translated into many languages. JeanJacques Rousseau in Emile (1762) deemed it essential for growing
PRE-HENTY 29
boys. Karl Marx in Das Capital (1867) used it to explicate economic theory (Drabble 836). In addition to their Bibles, missionaries took copies of Robinson Crusoe with them to the colonies (Martin Burgess Green, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire 212). Robinson Crusoe became everyone’s “bible,” whether they were economic theorists, missionaries, education theorists, or of course, writers of empire. In Tom Brown’s Schooldays, Hughes advocated what became known as “muscular Christianity”—a combination of Christian values, physical courage, self-reliance, school loyalty, love of sport, and patriotism— which altered the public school ethos. Hence, in Tom Brown’s Schooldays one can see the seeds of Kingston’s, Marryat’s, and Ballantyne’s evangelicalism and patriotism—values that gave way to Henty’s aggressive militarism later in the century. Robinson Crusoe is clearly an eighteenth-century novel, but crucial to our understanding of the nineteenth-century adventure novel. Like most adventure novels, Defoe’s is a romance, but when put into a historical perspective it reveals images and messages of interest to the study of imperialism. What is adventure? How does it relate to British notions of empire? The Random House College Dictionary defines it as an undertaking that involves risk, an “unforeseeable danger.” This definition suggests that the survivor would have to use wit, leadership, endurance, and survival skills in order to overcome the dangers associated with adventure. In Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire, Martin Green relates the role of adventure stories in the age of imperialism: the adventure tales that formed the light reading of Englishmen for two hundred years and more after Robinson Crusoe were, in fact, the energizing myth of English imperialism. They were, collectively, the story England told itself as it went to sleep at night; and in the form of its dreams, they charged England’s will with the energy to go out into the world and explore, conquer, and rule. (3)
While acknowledging that “the Robinson Crusoe story, and the adventure story as a whole, has been racist,” Green also maintains that, unlike “most adventures [which] carry signs of anti-imperialism as a way to enlist readers’ sympathy,” Robinson Crusoe is among the few that “carry anti-imperialist signs that are as convincing….” In The Robinson Crusoe Story, Green describes Robinson Crusoe as an “antiimperialist story, on the side of self-help, not hierarchy, of the adventurous individual, not of official authority” (15–23). Green’s reading only tells part of the story, and I intend to argue that Robinson Crusoe
30 NARRATING AFRICA
is anything but anti-imperialist inasmuch as it contains the seeds of the fiction of empire: racial hierarchy, material acquisitiveness, and allegedly cannibalistic natives. DEFOE AND THE ADVENTURE NOVEL: ROBINSON CRUSOE (1719) Here de white man beat de Black man Till he’s sick and cannot stand. Sure the black man [will] be eat[en] by white man! Will not go to white man land.4
Born in London in 1660, Defoe attended Morton’s academy for Dissenters with hopes of becoming a minister. But after his marriage he became instead a hosiery merchant and failed terribly at trade ventures. Becoming heavily indebted, he took to writing pamphlets5 (An Essay Upon Projects in 1697 and The Shortest Way with Dissenters in 1702, a pamphlet for which he was fined, imprisoned, and pilloried). In this pamphlet, Defoe, a Dissenter himself, ironically called for a “total and savage suppression of dissent.” Defoe later produced about 560 books, pamphlets and journals, wrote for and edited The Review from 1704 to 1713 (Drabble 262), and was “engaged in political propaganda and semipolitical intrigue” (Green, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire 68). Defoe was the government agent sent to Edinburgh to mediate the Union of England and Scotland. This union, Defoe thought, was not only an extension of the empire, but also produced an improvement of Scottish life, albeit it faced strong Scottish opposition (Green, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire 68). Despite his versatility, Defoe’s most popular work has remained Robinson Crusoe. The narrative is partly based on Alexander Selkirk’s story6 with which Defoe was probably familiar. Robinson Crusoe is a story of a man who defies his parents and goes to sea only to be cast away on an unidentified island between Brazil and the coast of Guinea where he gradually learns to survive by accumulating goods and growing crops; ultimately he becomes the “king” of the island. After fifteen lonely years, Crusoe finds human footprints, and later human bones, that alert him to possible cannibalism on the island. When the cannibals come back, Crusoe saves one of their victims, names him Friday,
PRE-HENTY 31
and gives him the role of the submissive and faithful slave. Crusoe undertakes to teach Friday English and to convert him to Christianity. The next time the “savages” return to the island, their victims include a Spanish sea captain and Friday’s father, whom Crusoe and Friday rescue. The captain offers to take Crusoe and Friday back to England where a fortune awaits Crusoe. Crusoe sells his sugarcane plantation in Brazil, gets married, and plans to revisit the island. In The Rise of the Novel, Ian Watt provides us with a sociohistorical interpretation of Robinson Crusoe. He relates Crusoe’s acquisitiveness and pursuit of property to the rise of “economic individualism” of which Adam Smith and others before him have spoken (Watt 63–64). As discussed in the previous chapter, this rise of the capitalist bourgeoisie was the main determining factor in the quest for adventure and conquest of the “blank spaces” of the globe. From such a perspective, Robinson Crusoe is more than just a romance. The novel reflects the socio-economic trends of the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. Crusoe’s pursuit of money or wealth, Watts argues, is indicative of the “profit and loss book-keeping which Max Weber considered to be the distinctive technical feature of modern capitalism” (Watt 63). In fact, when Crusoe accepts money from a Spanish steward to alleviate his financial difficulties, he records the following in his notebook: “I could hardly refrain from tears while he spoke; in short I took 100 of the moidores, and called for a pen and ink to give him a receipt for them” (Defoe 316). In Guinea Crusoe realizes that he could purchase not only gold (which Defoe considered to be of an intrinsic value), elephant tusks, and “Guinea” grains, but also slaves for work on the plantations in Brazil. As Watt points out, the “hypostasis of economic motive logically entails a devaluation of other modes of thought, feeling, and action: the various forms of traditional group relationship, the family, the guild, the village, the sense of nationality—all are weakened (Watt 64). The “devaluation of other modes of thought, feeling, and action,” the devaluation of Friday’s culture and belief system, is exemplified in the way Crusoe undertakes to erase Friday’s past (which apparently amounts to nothing but cannibalism) and to convert him. This erasure recalls the erasure and distortion of the history and culture of the colonized. The novel takes on cultural significance when we see Friday as the fictional rendition of the “noble savage”7 of the Enlightenment era. As such, Friday’s enslavement and the consequent killing of the indigenous people of the island are justified by their alleged cannibal-
32 NARRATING AFRICA
ism. Needless to say that it was this idea of the noble savage that partly kept the Atlantic Slave Trade alive throughout the seventeenth, eighteenth, and nineteenth centuries, and later fueled British notions of empire-building. The idea of the noble savage, closely related to the motif of cannibalism, deserves our attention. Since primitivism has been associated with a lost paradise, the subjugation of Africans and other nonWestern peoples (thought to be primitive) could not have been effectively articulated had Europe maintained the so-called nobility of the savage paradigm. The cannibalism motif counteracted this nobility and made slavery and colonization a justifiable and justified cause. As Jan Pieterse puts it, “cannibalism in a single shorthand icon represented the other side of paradise” (Pieterse 117). It is noteworthy that in antiquity and the Middle Ages, tales of “man-eating” people referred to Europe itself. During the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries these narratives became known as tales of cannibalism through the corruption of the term Caribals, or the denizens of the Caribbean islands. Pieterse asserts that in the age of imperialism “Scottish missionaries, Bible in hand [turned] directly against the Romantic poets and their idyllic images of life in the tropics” by alleging that the indigenous people were cannibals (Pieterse 117). Hence Crusoe, armed with his Bible and gun, sets out to turn “cannibals” into “cornbread and cattleflesh eaters” (Defoe 200) because “if they [cannibals] were given the chance they would devour us [Europeans]…” (Pieterse 121). Crusoe’s survival, and his consequent enslavement of Friday, depend on his possession of a gun and tools of modern technology; he thus becomes the king of the island by subduing the alleged cannibals. It is with the sound of the gun that Crusoe announces his arrival on the island; it is also at the sight of the gun that Friday falls to his knees to worship Crusoe. It is the gun that keeps Crusoe alive and paves the way for Friday’s conversion: empire-building and conquest required not only the gun, but also, as we shall see, the Bible. Let’s recall that in 1719, when Defoe published Robinson Crusoe, notions of empire, conquest, and race had already begun to take shape in the consciousness of the British people. Hence, Friday abandons his “savage” ways as soon as he begins to associate himself with Crusoe. He becomes a Christian, an indication of his adoption of “civilized” ways—the only way, the British thought, Others could elevate themselves to humanity. Friday is a “native”; he is described thus:
PRE-HENTY 33
He was a comely, handsome fellow, perfectly well made, with straight, strong limbs; not too large, tall and well-shaped…. He had the sweetness and softness of a European in his countenance too, especially when he smiled. His hair was long and black, not curled like wool; his forehead very high and large…. The color of his skin was not quite black, but very tawny; and yet not of an ugly, yellow, nauseous tawny as the Brazilians and other natives of America are, but of a bright kind of a dun olive color, that had in it something very agreeable, although not easy to describe. His face was round and plump; his nose small, not flat like the negroes; a very good mouth, thin lips, and fine teeth well set, and white as ivory (Defoe 180).
Friday is the Other, a stereotype of what the Other is supposed to be. In Desire and Contradiction: Imperial Visions and Domestic Debates in Victorian Literature, Daniel Bivona reminds us that the Other is also the Self. He argues that in a Nietzschean sense “the values one identifies with the ‘civilized’ are nothing more than those which have been appropriated as one’s own (Bivona 91). That Friday is Christianized does not surprise us since we are led to view his conversion as a blessing: although he now belongs to Crusoe, Friday has won, by his conversion, the “status” that enables him to serve and sacrifice his life for Crusoe. In Crusoe’s words, “I dare say he would have sacrificed his life for the saving of mine, upon any occasion whatsoever” (Defoe 183). Friday promises to convince his people to put an end to their cannibalism and take on the ways of the White man. Until he is “saved” by Crusoe, Friday has been a “savage,” a nameless cannibal about to be devoured by other savages; rescued by Crusoe, he becomes “my savage,” (Crusoe’s), and finally, Friday. Naming is associated with ownership and identity; thus, Friday’s humanity is called into question when he is objectified as a savage or as Crusoe’s slave. Renamed, he becomes a “civilized” person and Crusoe’s possession. Friday’s identity, his culture and beliefs, are thus easily undermined and dismissed in order for his enslavement to take place. In colonial discourse, it is at this point in time that Friday’s history or the history of his people begins: he becomes a Christian armed with a gun, and he participates in eliminating cannibalism on the island. What is interesting here is that Friday apparently has an idea of God, a Creator, who “lived beyond all…much older than the sea and the land.” Despite the indication that Friday and his people believe in a Supreme Being, Crusoe dismisses that fact and proceeds to indoctrinate him. It is obvious that Crusoe is not as interested in Friday’s con-
34 NARRATING AFRICA
version to the ways of the Lord as he is in his conversion to the ways of the British people. Otherwise, the question arises: what makes Crusoe’s God different from Friday’s? It is quite erroneous to think that the socalled animistic religions are not embedded in the notion of a Supreme Being, the concept of God. But like the uncorrupted noble savage, “the savage became a good Christian, a much better than I” (Defoe 196–97). And, when Friday expresses his desire to go back to his nation, Crusoe becomes apprehensive because the latter believes Friday might regress8 into savagery: “Friday, do not you wish yourself in your own country, your own nation? [as opposed to Crusoe’s kingdom on the island]?” “Yes,…I be much glad to be at my own nation.” “What would you do there?…Would you turn wild again, eat men’s flesh again, and be a savage as you were before?” “No, no; Friday tell them to live good; tell them to pray God; tell them to eat cornbread, cattleflesh, milk, no eat man again.” (Defoe 200)
Friday refuses to go back to his people unless he is accompanied by Crusoe, who is afraid of becoming a victim of cannibalism. But Friday assures him that there is nothing to be concerned about because “[y]ou [Crusoe] do great deal much good. You teach wild mans to be good, sober, tame mans; you tell them know God, pray God, and live new life” (203). Thus, Friday becomes a living proof of the wonders of British culture and civilization: he represents the British people’s ability to turn savages into humans, Christians, and “cornbread and cattleflesh” eaters—an example for Others to imitate. The island does not belong to Crusoe, whether or not its inhabitants are really cannibals. But the alleged cannibalism of its denizens compels Crusoe to claim the island by restoring law and order. Not only does Robinson Crusoe foreshadow imperialist tendencies, it can also be read as a proslavery document. After being rescued by Crusoe, and because he does not speak English, Friday, kneeling down before Crusoe, “kissed the ground, and laid his head upon it, then taking me by the foot, set my foot upon his head. This, it seems, was in token of swearing to be my slave forever” (Defoe 178). Friday’s gestures, could have meant “I owe you my life” or “I thank you.” But since Crusoe never returns to this incident to clarify what Friday meant when he knelt down, the reader is left with Crusoe’s interpretation of Friday’s gestures: that Friday swears to be his slave for life—a defining characteristic of slavery. Friday’s inability to speak Crusoe’s language dur-
PRE-HENTY 35
ing their initial contact renders him voiceless and makes him vulnerable since Crusoe has to speak for him and interpret his gestures. Paradoxically, Friday’s acculturation, his ability to speak Crusoe’s language later in the novel, gives him no power, but instead enslaves him; in fact Friday is able to serve Crusoe more efficiently, to obey his orders—”dig” and “fetch.” Thus, Friday’s acculturation should be seen as a situation wherein Crusoe (the colonizer or enslaver) lets Friday (the colonized or slave) gain access to Crusoe’s culture (i.e. language, religion) in order to better serve him. Africans taken to the Americas and the Caribbean islands were meant to be slaves for life. Written at the height of the Atlantic Slave Trade, Robinson Crusoe endorsed the theory of noble savage and helped reinforce the plantation myth: the myth of the happy slave. Another illustration of this idea can be seen in Xury, also Crusoe’s slave. Although Crusoe is unwilling to sell Xury, the latter pleads to be sold, just as Friday vows to be Crusoe’s slave for life. Even if Crusoe were to have any misapprehensions about either enslaving or killing the natives, his Britishness would supposedly entitle him to make the island a habitable environment by eliminating cannibalism. He is unable to contain himself as he witnesses the “horrid spectacle”: “All my apprehensions were buried in the thoughts of such a pitch of inhuman brutality, and the horror of the degeneracy of human nature, which, though I had heard of often, yet I never had so near a view of before. In short, I turned away my face from the horrid spectacle” (Defoe 152). Robinson Crusoe is also a romance. In Anatomy of Criticism, Northrop Frye notes three main stages of a romance: the journey, a crucial struggle, and an exaltation of the hero—stages that are identifiable in Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe. But Robinson Crusoe is also associated with empire, frontier, exploration—terms that connote a hero, a protagonist with whom the reader identifies. Young adults, regardless of their nationality or ethnicity, often identify with Crusoe, but when they become more aware of the tale’s cultural implications, the nonwhite juveniles tend to identify with Friday. This seems particularly true when I recall the first time I read this work. From our ongoing discussion, it is clear that even if Robinson Crusoe “carries antiimperialist signs,” as Green claims, these are far from being convincing. While Robinson Crusoe sets the tone for the English adventure novel and functions as a blueprint for conquest and colonization, Tom Brown’s Schooldays exemplifies the school story that teaches Chris-
36 NARRATING AFRICA
tian values and “manliness”—the necessary prerequisites for the “empire boys.” THE SCHOOL STORY: THOMAS HUGHES’S TOM BROWN’S SCHOOLDAYS (1856) Thomas Hughes was born in 1822, attended Thomas Arnold’s Rugby (1833–1842) where he became captain of the cricket and football teams, read for the bar at Lincoln’s Inn and at Oxford, and later moved to Wimbledon where he and his wife shared a house with his Christian Socialist friend John Ludlow. At Wimbledon Hughes wrote Tom Brown’s Schooldays (under the pseudonym An Old Friend) during his summer vacation of 1856. During the course of writing Tom Brown’s Schooldays, he lost his beloved daughter, Evie, to scarlet fever—an event that may have contributed to the changed tone in the second part of the novel written after Evie’s death. Although Hughes was interested in social reform, Tom Brown’s Schooldays was Hughes’s way of mentoring his eight-year-old son, Maurice, he was about to send to school: “Thinking over what I should like to say to him before he went to school, I took to writing a story, as the easiest way of bringing out what I wanted” (quoted in Musgrave 48–49). Besides fulfilling Hughes’s immediate aim, Tom Brown’s Schooldays speaks to changes and reforms in the educational system in Victorian England. In many societies, and for a long time, the family had been the only educational institution; but the advent of the school system gave birth to many societal changes. In Victorian England the switch to educate children largely outside the home occurred in the first half of the nineteenth century. Formal education, then, meant private, expensive preparatory and secondary schools, or schools provided by some charity and limited to the education of boys. Vivian Ogilvie defines the public school as an “aristocratic or plutocratic school which is wholly or almost wholly a Boarding School,…under some form of more or less public control,…‘non-local’…independent of the State and of local government (Ogilvie 7). Public schools at the turn of the century were marked by violence, immorality, and rebellions that had to be contained by the law enforcement officers (Musgrave 42). But Arnold transformed the public school into a community where the pupils were to be Christianized or reformed. From the 1830s, the demand for “public schools,” as these schools came to be known, increased in view of
PRE-HENTY 37
greater financial security and the willingness to educate boys. This demand for public schools can be partly attributed to reforms at Rugby, the English public school that gained respect under Thomas Arnold between 1828 and 1842. Among his reforms was “the assurance that the headmaster would have complete independence in all matters of school discipline and school routine”; he also endeavored to “make the school far more a corporate unit” that should be preserved and encouraged, and where ruthless pupils faced dismissal. The prefect system was also an Arnoldian “invention” which allowed some administrative matters to be handled by senior boys (Newsome 40– 41). Arnold was able to convince the Victorian people of the effectiveness of public schools in attaining high social status and a sound education (Musgrave 42). Although the reforms Thomas Hughes endorses in Tom Brown’s Schooldays are not exactly what Arnold had accomplished, Hughes’s work bears resemblance to the essential reforms Arnold brought to Rugby. In Happiest Days, Jeffrey Richards argues that the “transformation” we see in Tom Brown’s Schooldays, of an “ordinary, headstrong boy into a responsible, mature, committed adult, chivalrous, Christian and concerned,” is in “accordance with Arnold’s emphasis on instilling moral and religious principle and gentlemanly behavior” (Richards, Happiest Days 63). We should also note that in Tom Brown’s Schooldays athleticism is as important as intellectual development, but Tom, the protagonist, never reaches the intellectual stage, whereas Arnold emphasized intellectual development above all. John Raymond de Symons Honey, in his Tom Brown’s Universe: The Development of the English Public School in the Nineteenth Century, asserts that Arnold himself acknowledged the need for change at Rugby (46–47). The connection among Arnoldian reforms of the public school system, the British empire, and juvenile literature becomes pertinent given the fact that the “empire boys” were educated in these schools where their duty to empire was of prime importance and where life itself was becoming an adventure. Whatever the similarities between Arnold’s theory of public schools and Hughes’s Tom Brown’s Schooldays, the latter “recalls, records and mythifies the Rugby of Dr. Arnold, creating a selective image of Arnoldianism” (Richards, Happiest Days 24). But Hughes also incorporated into his work concepts that were crucial to him: the ideals of Christian Socialism, Carlyle’s idea of work and hero-worship, and English nationalism (Richards, 24). Jeffrey Richards notes:
38 NARRATING AFRICA
With the passing of time the religious element of the second half of the book, which was Hughes’s avowed object in writing it, was downgraded in favour of the games-playing and character formation of the first half, which were adduced in support of the later nineteenth-century cults of athleticism and imperialism. For Tom Brown is more than just a school story: it is a mirror of the changing nature and structure of Victorian values…. Arnold’s concept of “Godliness and Good Learning” is passed through the filter of Hughes’s commitment to muscular Christianity, and this in its turn feeds into the games mania and Empire worship of later decades. (Happiest Days 24)
This shift of emphasis, as Richards’ statement shows, is indicative of the changing values and preoccupations of the Victorian people in view of the receding religious faith. Tom Brown’s Schooldays is largely autobiographical, evoking Hughes’s days at Rugby under its renowned headmaster.9 It condemns the bullying that had hitherto prevailed in the public schools and celebrates family values, patriotism, physical courage, self-reliance, love of sport, and what became known as “muscular Christianity”10 (Drabble 481). As Michael Philip notes in his unpublished dissertation, Cultural Myth in Victorian Boys’ Books by Marryat, Hughes, Stevenson, and Kipling, Hughes was troubled by the “new cultural paradigms that threaten” society, and believed that whatever the problems of the age might be, these could be remedied through an appeal to Victorian values and ideals of the gentleman—”one who has been born and then trained into good sportsmanship, common sense, and unostentatious but sincere religious feelings” (Philip 93). But Tom Brown’s Schooldays also contains the early seeds of imperialism. Hughes had once declared in Boston, Massachusetts: “I am before all things an Englishman—a John Bull, if you will—loving Old England and feeling proud of her” (quoted in Richards, Happiest Days 50). In the opening pages of Tom Brown’s Schooldays, the narrator tells of the Brown family: For centuries, in their quiet, dogged homespun way,…[they] have been subduing the earth in most English counties, and leaving their mark in American forests and Australian uplands. Wherever the fleets and armies of England have won renown, there stalwart sons of the Browns have done yeoman’s work. (Hughes 4)
Tom Brown, the protagonist of Tom Brown’s Schooldays, is the son of a country squire. After a few years spent in a private school, he is sent to Rugby where he meets his friend, Harry East, and a ring of bullies
PRE-HENTY 39
including Flashman. Tom defeats the bullies through his good and virtuous behavior, but becomes a delinquent partly because of his lack of religious faith and partly because of the strict school code of conduct. When Dr. Arnold, the school headmaster, puts the sickly but devout Arthur under his care, both boys become “accomplished” citizens prepared for their duty toward the Empire. Thus, Hughes fulfills his doctrine of muscular Christianity when he has Arthur teach Tom the virtues of Anglicanism, and Tom train Arthur in matters of sportsmanship. The spirit of conquest “struck the right chords later in the century when imperialism had become the dominant ideology, and the public schools were the nurseries of imperial administrators and officers” (Richards, Happiest Days 50). Hughes’s heroes function within the context of empire. In fact, at the end of Tom Brown’s Schooldays, Harry East leaves to join a regiment in India, and the schoolmaster tells Tom: “Perhaps ours is the only little corner of the British Empire which is thoroughly, wisely, and strongly ruled just now” (Hughes 352)—a strong suggestion that the expansion of the British empire depends on people such as Tom and Harry. According to Richards, “Rugby itself contributed those imperial heroes lauded by Hughes, William Hodson and William Cotton Oswell, as well as the doctor’s son, William Delafield Arnold, who became Director of Education in the Punjab” (Richards, Happiest Days 50). Hughes was a heroworshiper, following in the footsteps of Victorian writers such as Thomas Carlyle (Richards, Happiest Days 50). In 1843 Carlyle wrote: Man is created to fight; he is perhaps best of all definable as a born soldier, his life “a battle and a march” under the right General. It is forever indispensable for a man to fight: now with Necessity, with Bareness, Scarcity, with Puddles, Bogs, tangled Forests, unkempt Cotton—now also with the hallucinations of his poor fellow Men. (Carlyle 163–64)
Hughes wrote biographies of famous heroes such as David Livingstone and Alfred the Great. He referred to William Hodson, who died in action during the so-called Indian Mutiny in 1857, as a “glorious Christian soldier and Englishman.” Hughes eulogized his countrymen who lost their lives: “In all her long and stern history, England can point to no nobler sons than these, the heroes of India in 1857” (quoted in Richards, Happiest Days 46). The public school was not the only “nursery” for imperial adminis-
40 NARRATING AFRICA
trators; the Boy Scouts also produced these “glorious Christian soldiers and Englishmen.” In his Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire Martin Green writes: The Boy Scouts and the public schools are examples of those institutions of large cultural effectiveness which did not operate through books, and which were hardly at all expressed or reflected in serious literature. (212)
Colonel Baden-Powell, who launched the Boy Scouts, views the “spirit of practical discipline” as essentially British: Your Englishman…is endowed by nature by the spirit of practical discipline…. Whether it has been instilled into him by his public school training, by his football and his fagging, or whether it is inbred from previous generations of stern though kindly parents, one cannot say (quoted in Ellis, The Social History of the Machine Gun 101–02).
Both the Boy Scouts and the public schools were crucial to the maintenance of British colonial possessions abroad. At the close of the Boer War, Colonel Baden-Powell, in collaboration with Kipling’s advice, created what became known as the Boy Scouts, “to save England from the softness and the degeneracy threatening it” (Green, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire 211). Both institutions provided the empire boys with the necessary patriotism, tools, and ammunition to serve the empire. It was an era that marked the beginning of the militarization of the public school. The militarization of public schools did not take place overnight. As Martin Green reminds us in The Adventurous Male: Chapters in theHistory of the White Male Mind, “adventure and patriotism were only ideological themes that surrounded (and no doubt permeated) the educational work,” but the end of the nineteenth century saw other public institutions (the Boy Scouts, the Boys’ Brigade, the Empire Youth Movement, the Navy League, the Legion of Frontiersmen, the National Service League, the Girls’ Patriotic League, the League of Empire, the British Empire Union) that began to “organize and institutionalize adventure for boys in the Anglo-Saxon countries.” (80). Green also points out that the militarization of the public schools should not be taken for granted, and that Thomas Arnold, the education theorist of the Victorian public school, might have been shocked had he lived long enough to witness this change (80). But granted
PRE-HENTY 41
Arnold’s patriotism and the fact that the militarization of the public school was perceived as in the interest of the British empire as a whole, there is, in reality, nothing surprising about these changes, since Arnold himself had sown the seeds of change during his tenure at the school. Arnold and Hughes were among the most influential contributors to the overall change in public school curricula, because their theories began to be applied nationwide. As early as 1871, military drill was introduced as an “alternative activity” in the Elementary School Code and gained increased acceptance during the last decade of the nineteenth century (Mangan, “Benefits Bestowed”? 40–41). When, in 1878, the Education Department “directed HMIs to excite interest in the Colonial and Foreign Possessions of the British Crown,” the burden of the empire was becoming popular: In former ages the burdens of Empire or of the State fell on the shoulders of a few; now the humblest child to be found on the benches of a primary school will in a few years be called on to influence the destinies not only of fifty-four millions of white, but of three hundred and fifty millions of coloured men and women, his fellow subjects, scattered throughout the five continents of the world—Earl of Meath, “Duty and Discipline in the Training of Children.” (quoted in Mangan, “Benefits Bestowed”? 40)
The Elementary School Code of 1882 “included information on British colonies and dependencies” as part of geography lessons in standard 6. An “alternative syllabus for the upper standards, with special emphasis on the imperial link,” was introduced by the Code of 1890 (Mangan, “Benefits Bestowed”? 41). These ideas—of patriotism, adventure, and empire—also embedded in Robinson Crusoe, gradually found their way into juvenile books. Captain Marryat’s sea adventure, Masterman Ready (1841), is an example of this genre. As Michael Philip aptly remarks, the school in Tom Brown’s Schooldays “has been made to work like the voyage [in Marryat’s sea adventures], as an alternative reality where cultural and maturational problems can be worked out” (Philip 107). CAPTAIN MARRYAT’S MASTERMAN READY (1841) Captain Frederick Marryat is arguably the first boys’ writer of Victorian England who sought to revive the spirit of Robinson Crusoe com-
42 NARRATING AFRICA
bined with the ethos of the early school story. After twenty-four years at sea in the Royal Navy, Marryat retired in 1829 and began to write. Although he initially aimed at an adult audience, his work soon became famous among boys. He published his first novel, an adult one, The Naval Officer: Or Scenes and Adventures in the Life of Frank Mildmay (1829). Mr. Midshipman Easy was published in 1836, followed by other adventure tales set in Africa: The Mission, or Scenes in Africa (1845) and Little Savage (1848). Masterman Ready (1841) was Marryat’s first juvenile tale, and in spite of its Evangelical didacticism and its teachings about empire and discipline, the novel was at odds with the imperial frame of mind of the time. That is, Marryat predicted, uncharacteristically, the eventual decay of the British empire (Green, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire 216). Arguably, more than any single writer, Marryat helped to create the naval tradition. In 1805 a particular series of events seemed to have decided the course of Marryat’s career. The battle of Trafalgar, Nelson’s victory and death, and the consequent impression of Nelson’s state funeral on the young Marryat led him to go to sea (Warner 14– 22). In September of 1806 Frederick’s father, Joseph, secured his son a place on the Imperieuse under captain Thomas Cochrane. Oliver Warner stipulates in his Captain Marryat: A Rediscovery that only an influential member of Lloyd’s and former member of Parliament could have assured his son’s reception aboard the Imperieuse. Joseph Marryat was a member and Chairman of the Committee of Lloyd’s, an association of English insurance underwriters founded in 1699. He was also a Colonial Agent for the West Indian Islands of Grenada and Trinidad, member of Parliament for Horsham and later for Sandwich, and a frequent speaker in Parliament on colonial issues. Lloyd’s popularity with the navy was well known. This organization had established a Patriotic Fund in order to “animate the brave men engaged in the defence of their country, to provide for the widows and orphans of those who fall, and to reward those who distinguish themselves in his Majesty’s service” (Warner 17–23). Frederick Marryat, therefore, was born into a family with a history of British colonial involvement which later informed his works. Marryat wrote Masterman Ready at the suggestion of his children who had enjoyed Wyss’s Swiss Family Robinson.11 Instead of continuing the tale where Wyss left off, as suggested by his children, Marryat chose to write another tale à la Wyss. The similarities between Robinson Crusoe on the one hand, and The Swiss Family Robinson and Masterman Ready on the other are numer-
PRE-HENTY 43
ous, but one difference is striking and worthy of note: unlike Robinson Crusoe, the central figure in both Masterman Ready and The Swiss Family Robinson is a family, not an individual (Green, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire 215). Masterman Ready tells of the Seagrave family bound for Australia on the Pacific. Caught in a storm in the Indian Ocean, the crew abandons ship, and the Seagrave family and Ready, a British sailor, have to survive on an isolated island. Mr. Seagrave is a colonial settler who expects to make a fortune for his family in Australia. Mrs. Seagrave, careworn, is aided by Juno, a Black nanny, who helps take care of her four children, William, Thomas, Caroline, and Albert. Following an attack on their camp by the natives, Ready dies in battle, but the captain of the Pacific, cured of his injuries, arrives just in time to rescue the Seagraves. When the family reaches Australia, Mr. Seagrave, a surveyor by profession, finds prosperity, Tom joins the army, Caroline marries a clergyman, and Albert becomes a commander in the navy. In this narrative Ready, an ordinary seaman with fifty years of experience, functions as a masterman by instructing the Seagraves (of aristocratic background) in “practical arts of survival” on the island. Thus, Marryat “introduces the principle of hierarchy even into the wilderness and adventure setting” (Green, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire 215). In this hierarchy, Juno is arguably relegated to the bottom of the social ladder, while the Seagraves occupy the top. Ready, a lower-class Englishman, views his plight (social rung) as Godordained when he says: “I am an old man with few wants, and whose life is of little importance now…. All I wish to feel is that I am trying to do my duty in that situation into which it has pleased God to call me” (Marryat 75–76). Ready’s comments suggest an unequivocal acceptance of one’s social status, whether one is of the aristocracy (the Seagraves), of the lower class (Ready himself), or a servant (Juno). This hierarchy is reminiscent of the Aristotelian formulation of the Great Chain of Being and the popular Victorian idea of predestination. Masterman Ready is essentially an adaptation of Robinson Crusoe. Susan Maher notes in her article “Recasting Crusoe: Frederick Marryat, R.M.Ballantyne and the Nineteenth-Century Robinsonnade,” that Marryat transforms Crusoe’s soul-searching and “quest for selfhood into Ready’s didactic oral history” (171). As Maher aptly points out, unlike Crusoe, Ready is a “saved” man, a “born-again” at the time of the wreck, and therefore need not undergo any major transformation or soul-searching. The major transformation in the novel involves the
44 NARRATING AFRICA
setting, the island of the castaways; that is, the transformation of the wilderness into a “mini-colony” or settlement for the Seagrave family. This transformation of the island into a settlement echoes and foreshadows British acquisition of new colonial territories toward the end of the nineteenth century. The island, then, becomes a blueprint for the test of survival and for future conquest and colonization, and provides an illustration of the white man’s burden: the duty of the British to bring light into godforsaken dark corners of the world. Paul Elmen reinforces this idea of transformation when he states in William Golding that those “savage corners of the earth would succumb to the attraction of the cult of the gentleman, and that in time the jungles of the world would be ridden in as safely as Regents Park” (quoted in Maher 171). William, who is twelve at the time of the wreck, takes to the old sailor, Ready, who instructs him in matters of survival, while Mr. Seagrave lectures him on the “nature of a colony.” The dialogue between William and his father sheds light on British colonial history: it relates how the English came to dominate the seas after the Spaniards, the Portuguese, and the Dutch: “At that time, now more than 300 years ago, England was not the powerful nation which she now is, and had comparatively few ships; neither could the English, in enterprise, be compared to the Spanish and Portuguese nations…. My dear boy, you know very well that a man is born, arrives at manhood and strength, grows old, decays, and dies. As it is with man, so it is with nations. The Portuguese were then in their manhood as a nation; but other nations rose up in strength; and among others the Dutch, who were the first to dispute with the Portuguese the commerce of the Indies: gradually they wrested their colonies from them, and carried on trade in their stead. Then the English forced their way there, seized upon the since held possession (Marryat 115–16).”
“Tell me,’“ William inquires, “‘why are England and other nations so anxious to have what you call colonies?’“ Using the analogy between a child and its parents, Mr. Seagrave explains to his son the interdependency between a colony and the so-called mother country: “‘In infancy, the mother country assists and supports the colony as an infant; as it advances and becomes vigorous, the colony returns the obligation: but the parallel does not end there…. As soon as the colony has grown strong and powerful enough to take care of itself, it throws off the yoke of subjection, and declares itself independent’“
PRE-HENTY 45
(Marryat 116). Mr. Seagrave cites the example of the United States which, once a colony of Great Britain, had become one of the most powerful nations. “But is it not very ungrateful of a colony to leave the mother country, which has protected it so long, as soon as it no longer requires its assistance?” “It may at first appear to be so; but on reflection, we must decide otherwise: the mother country has been more than repaid for what it has done for the colony long before the colony is able to throw off its dependence; and after a certain time, the rights assumed by the mothercountry become too onerous to bear: you must not treat a grown-up man as you would a child.” “Now, father, answer me another question. You said that nations rise and fall; and you have mentioned the Portuguese as proof. Will England ever fall, and be of no more importance as Portugal is now?” “We can only decide that question by looking into history; and history tells us that such is the fate of all nations. We must, therefore, expect that it will one day be the fate of our dear country…. Recollect that when the Roman empire was in the height of its powers, Great Britain was peopled by mere barbarians and savages. Now Rome has disappeared, and is only known in history, and by the relics of its former greatness, while England ranks among the highest nations. How is the major part of the continent of Africa peopled? by barbarians and savages; and who knows what they may become some future day?” “What! the negroes become a great nation?” “That is exactly what the Romans might have said in former days. What! the British barbarians become a great nation? and yet they have become so.” “But the negroes, father,—they are blacks.” “Very true; but that is no reason to the contrary. As to the darkness of the skin, the majority of the Moors are quite as black as the negroes; yet they were once a great nation, and, moreover, the most enlightened nation of their time, with a great many excellent qualities, full of honour, generosity, politeness, and chivalry. They conquered and held the major part of Spain for many hundred years; introduced arts and science then unknown, and were as brave and heroic as they were virtuous and honorable.” (Marryat 116–18)
Despite his condescending tone,12 not only does Mr. Seagrave teach his son—and by extension the British youth—the nature of empires in general, and the rise of the British empire in particular, he also predicts its inevitable fall. Mr. Seagrave’s acknowledgment that it is the plight of all nations or empires to grow and decay may have been the basis for Martin Green’s argument that, although Masterman Ready
46 NARRATING AFRICA
reflects “the early Victorian mood, full of the vigor of English Puritanism,” it was not in accordance with the imperial mindset, and was consequently supplanted by “something almost opposite” (Green, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire 216). Likewise, Joseph Conrad, in Heart of Darkness (1902), hints at the rise and fall of ancient empires when he writes that River Thames (England) had once been one of the dark places on earth, but when the Romans came, “light came out of this river since.” Marryat and later Conrad attempt to demonstrate that Romans brought light to the English but became a forgotten race while the English rose to prominence. But, does this intimation apply to the Dark Continent? Following this line of thought, could Africans also rise to probity with the advent of the British, bearers of the “torch of enlightenment”? It seems to be impossible, at least for William, to fathom the fall of the British empire and the rise of Black people to prominence. William is distressed by his father’s insinuation that the British empire will also fade away and be surpassed by other races, probably Africans. He retorts: “What! the negroes become a great nation?… But the negroes, father,—they are blacks.” It is noteworthy that William is cognizant of the incapability of Black people to become a great nation, but remains ignorant about the fact that the earliest and greatest civilizations were not European. Mr. Seagrave convinces his son that skin pigmentation is irrelevant, and cites the Moors13 who preceded the Romans and the British in building great civilizations. In Africans and Their History, historian Joseph Harris opined that “if Plato, Eudoxe, and Pythagoras remained in Egypt for thirteen to twenty years, ‘it was not only to learn recipes’“ (26). The Senegalese historian and writer Cheik Anta Diop contends: It remains…true that the Egyptian experiment was essentially Negro, and that all Africans can draw the same moral advantage from it that Westerners draw from Graeco-Latin civilization, (quoted in Harris 26)
What most writers of the century often failed to teach their readers, whether juvenile or adults, was that in Africa, the Middle East, and Asia great nations and civilizations have existed, reigned, and collapsed before the Romans and the English. History teaches us that the civilizations that built the pyramids in Egypt and Sudan were neither Roman nor English. Although Michael Philip notes Marryat’s carelessness with “historical and geographical fact,” and his occasional
PRE-HENTY 47
distortions,14 Marryat was among the few writers of the nineteenth century to notice that civilizations and cultures are not static, and to predict the decline of the British empire. Hence, despite the strong Christian didacticism found in Masterman Ready, it was not a typical novel of the Victorian era vis-à-vis imperialism. But race stereotyping is constant in the characterization of Juno—the contented servant, the source of comic relief, the retainer who is devoid of all human qualities except unswerving loyalty. Both her garbled English and her appearance signify that she is viewed as a perpetual alien (despite all the father-to-son lectures on nationhood). Even when she injures herself in order to protect the family infant, she is the brunt of derision: “‘She saved the child, and I fear, hurt herself.’ “‘I thump my head very bad,’“ said Juno smiling. “‘Yes, it’s lucky that you have a good, thick, woolly coat over it,’ replied Captain Osborn, laughing” (Marryat 7). In conformance with Marryat’s Christian themes, the captain adds, “‘Never mind, Juno, you are a good girl.’“ But the white supremacist implications remain. The middle and late nineteenth century saw a change in juvenile literature when it became, to some degree, “captured by the aristomilitary” caste. Adventure came to replace the fable, focusing on the greatness, not the decline, of empire; the “virtues taught were pluck, dash, lion-heartedness, not obedience, duty, and piety” (Green, Dreams of Adventure, Deeds of Empire 220). Kingston, Ballantyne, and Henty dominated this period in juvenile literature associated with empire. W.H.G.KINGSTON’S IN THE WILDS OF AFRICA (1871) Kingston was a popular boys’ writer who wrote and published over one hundred books between 1850 and 1880. The Kingston’s Magazine for Boys (1859) was to greet “the young men of Great Britain, Ireland, the British colonies, and the United States of America” (Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature 174). The story has been told of young servants of empire who frequently asked themselves: “What would Kingston think about what I am doing now. Am I measuring up to his standards” (quoted in Imperialism and Juvenile Literature 48). Born in 1814 in London, Kingston was one of eleven children of a family of English gentry. His ancestors were “Fellows of the Royal Society, members of Parliament, justices of the peace, dons and admirals.” He spent his childhood in Regent’s Park and in Portugal where
48 NARRATING AFRICA
his father had business interests and where he began writing adult romances with a Gothic tint. He returned to live in England in 1844, and became interested in emigration issues. Kingston became a member and later honorary secretary of the Colonization Society for which he wrote “manuals and publicity pamphlets.” He also edited the Colonial Magazine between 1849 and 1852 (Bratton 115–16). Colonization at its embryonic stage following the emancipation bill (1833), was necessitated by socio-economic factors. Jacqueline Bratton states in The Impact of Victorian Children’s Fiction that Kingston deemed the colonies as “fields of endeavour for working men of the lower and middle classes, and the men themselves, and their wives and families, as being in urgent need of cultivation by Christian missionaries” (116). As secretary of the Colonization Society, Kingston saw to it that SPCK (Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge) tracts, prayer books and Bibles were supplied to ships to facilitate “ministration at the dockside and on the voyage.” He also aided the SPCK in producing a “practical manual” on emigration (Bratton 116). While Marryat’s heroes strive to (and always do) acquire material wealth in the colonies or in the course of their adventures, Kingston’s return penniless, “but infinitely richer having learned to fear God, to worship Him in his works, and to trust to His infinite mercy” (Bratton 117). This is the case of the hero of Peter the Whaler (1851), Kingston’s first boys’ book. Kingston, although an advocate of emigration, emphasizes the perils and dangers of life in Australia in The Gilpins and Their Fortunes (1864). Oftentimes in their writings, proponents of emigration in the 1840s and 1850s denote the sharp disparity between the “squalid” urban settings of England, from which the hero usually escapes, and “new worlds of freedom and opportunity where hard work brings its just rewards, free of the overcrowded slums and limited prospects of English working life” (Mackenzie 86). In the 1860s writers began to realize that the optimistic tone of their stories could mislead readers and would-be settlers if they did not point out the dangers of colonial life. The Gilpins and Their Fortunes and In the Wilds of Africa (1871) marked a shift in imperialist writing for boys, and in this shift, “the idyllic vision of England became semiotically important as the inspiration and justification of empire” (MacKenzie 87). In other words: The tension between Old England, its beauty and cultivated fertility, its security, its beloved associations with family or sweetheart left behind,
PRE-HENTY 49
and the new lands of promise, which are exciting, but also hard and masculine, dangerously unfamiliar, lawless and lonely, is a deep structural polarity in the fiction of the second half of the nineteenth century (MacKenzie 87).
In the Wilds of Africa, our specific reference, is another Robinsonnade, and bears resemblance to Marryat’s Masterman Ready. It relates the dangers and perils of life in the colonies, as well as its benefits and rewards from a British perspective. The narrator, Andrew, an accountant in his father’s firm, goes to sea after his father’s business has collapsed. The family retires to a modest cottage in Cheshire, leaving Andrew and his two brothers no choice but to “seek their fortunes in the world.” Before Andrew leaves on his first expedition, his father counsels him: “Recollect that you were bought with a price and are not your own. You have no business to follow your own fancies, or to gratify any of the propensities fallen nature possesses,…. God has given you a body, but ever remember that he has given you a mind to regulate that body…. Therefore, Andrew, read the Bible daily for guidance; go daily to the throne of grace for enlightenment and direction, that you may keep your high principles bright and ever fit for action.” (Kingston 16)
Andrew and the Hyslop family leave aboard the Osprey, en route for South Africa. Captain Stanley Hyslop (a relative of Andrew), is accompanied by his two daughters, Kate and Isabella, and his two younger brothers, David and Leonard. Hyslop is a retired military officer going to settle in the Cape Colony (South Africa) where his parents live. David is a surgeon by profession, relocating to practice in South Africa. The Osprey is bound for the Cape of Good Hope to land passengers and to trade in palm oil, beeswax, gold dust, and ivory in exchange for goods from Manchester and Birmingham. Also aboard are Terence O’Brien, an Irishman who is going to settle in the Cape Colony, and a Portuguese, Senhor Silva. As the sea becomes turbulent, the crew abandons ship and makes it ashore in a tiny boat only to be murdered by the natives who have the reputation of killing European slave traders. Peter Timbo, who is familiar with the people of the Cape, is not surprised that the crew is attacked because “de white man make them slaves, and so when dey catch de white men dey kill them” (Kingston 43). The castaway passengers, like Crusoe, remain on a nearby island where they battle not only with wild animals, but also
50 NARRATING AFRICA
with “hostile natives.” The Hyslops and Andrew eventually survive and become colonists in the Cape. Conquest, colonization, and immigration are the main themes of this book. Timbo is a character that reveals British involvement in colonization schemes and in the abolition of the Atlantic Slave Trade. In an attack on his village by slave raiders, Timbo is kidnapped and sold to Portuguese slave traders, but he is rescued by a British patrol ship. After serving a few years on the British ship, he is discharged at the Cape where he later meets the Hyslop family and becomes a servant to Captain Hyslop. Timbo is indebted to the British not only for their active role in the abolition struggle, but also for his conversion to Christianity: “Ah, Massa Andrew, we nebber know as kind God does what is good for us. I bery sorrowful when slaver people carry me off from my home in Pongo country. I t’ink I go to die, dat dere was no God to look after poor black fellow. I know only of Fetish. Den I get among white men, and I see and hear much dat is bad, and still I t’ink dere is no God. Den years pass by, and I hear of the merciful Saviour, who die for me; and I say, ‘Dat is just what I want,’ and I learn to be Christian.” (Kingston 19)
Timbo is a convert, a new man, owing to his contact with Western civilization, and as the novel progresses, he eventually becomes a missionary among his people while still in the service of Captain Hyslop. The above quote reiterates the theory that Christianity was the cure for slavery and the Atlantic Slave Trade, as though the British or Christians had never been involved in the trade in humans. But Senhor Silva explains to the castaways that the natives’ hostility toward the White man is a result of the latter’s previous treacherous dealings with Africans: “When we have shown them that we are friends, and desire to do them all the good in our power, we, I hope, shall find them faithful; but they have become so debased by their intercourse with the white people, and especially, I am sorry to say, with my countrymen, who often deal treacherously with them, that they cannot be depended on. They in return, as might naturally be supposed, cheat and deceive the whites in every way. The sin, I confess lies at the door of the more civilized race, who ought to have set them a good example.” (Kingston 86)
Although Senhor Silva does not perceive the inhabitants of the Cape as civilized, he aptly points out that the people have become debased
PRE-HENTY 51
as a result of their “intercourse with the white people, and especially… with my countrymen.” It is important to highlight the fact that Senhor Silva is a Portuguese, and by emphasizing that the Portuguese intercourse with Africans has debased the latter, Kingston shows his attempt to condemn the Portuguese continuation of the trade when the British had already abolished it. This device also allows the narrator to applaud British initiative in the abolition and to legitimize their presence in Africa. But, if European contact with Africa has debasing consequences on the latter, as Senhor Silva claims, what prevents the civilized from setting a good example for the savage? Andrew is a David Livingstone when he comments: “Nearly all the negro tribes on this part of the coast have the spirit of trade strongly implanted in them; and I cannot help thinking that it is so for the purpose of ultimately bringing about their civilization, which the nefarious slave trade has so long retarded. That trade is one of the sins which lies at England’s door, and she should endeavour to make amends for the crime, by using every means in her power for the spread of Christianity and civilization among the long benighted Africans” (Kingston 113).
While it is true that the slave trade left an indelible scar on the continent and its diaspora, it would be misleading to assume that colonization was meant to compensate for the cultural, physical, and psychological damage. Rather, the introduction of Christianity and European culture into Africa (especially in sub-Saharan Africa) became a cure for European socio-economic problems. For example, by adopting a European mode of life, Africans became consumers of European goods and stimulated European economy. Colonization was also one of the ways Europe was able to get rid of its unwanted citizens. The so-called amends for the crime (colonization, in this case) are more destructive than beneficial to Africans, granted the psychological and physical scars colonization left on the continent. How can one speak of amends when slavery is replaced by colonization? Andrew’s recognition that “that trade is one of the sins which lies at England’s door” becomes hollow if colonization and European civilization become substitutes for slavery. We are also led to believe that colonization would not have been necessary if the natives were not heathens or cannibals. In In the Wilds of Africa a village chief has to require British assistance to fight neighboring villages: “Unless you white men will help us, we cannot hope
52 NARRATING AFRICA
to oppose them…. It is said that they eat up all the enemies they kill” (Kingston 167). Here, again, anarchy, heathenism, and cannibalism are used to legitimize British intervention. Additionally the Africans are described as physically inferior, a pattern in nineteenth-century novels that Kingston sustains. He uses his description of Timbo to suggest a permanent and inevitable outsider status: He had thick lips, a huge flattish nose, and somewhat high head, covered with thick curling wool, now beginning to show signs of turning grey…. [F]rom the way his master treated him,…it was evident that he must be a worthy man, notwithstanding his want of personal attractions. (Kingston 19)
Notwithstanding these phenotypic “flaws,” Timbo is valued for the cultural work he can perform for the British. He begins his missionary activities among the natives: Timbo had set off to Kabomba, in the hope, as he said, of telling the natives about the Bible, showing them how much superior is the white man’s religion to their foolish idolatry. They had listened more readily than he had expected; and his great wish now was to return there at some future day with missionaries, who might teach them to read about the matter themselves. (Kingston 483)
In this novel Kingston’s message of colonization is transparently clear. Despite the hostile natives the castaways decide to settle in the Cape as previously planned. Andrew sends a message to the British youth, emphasizing perseverance and faith in God within the context of overseas empire and emigration: “I may say of myself and of all friends indeed, that ‘whatsoever our hands find to do, we do it with all our might’ humbly endeavouring to serve God in our daily walk in life, and thereby enjoy that true happiness which even in this world can be obtained by those who know the right way to seek it” (560). Ballantyne’s Black Ivory further develops this missionary message as well as the themes of emigration and slavery. BALLANTYNE’S BLACK IVORY (1873) Robert Michael Ballantyne was the son of a Scottish newspaper owner whose brother printed Sir Walter Scott’s novels. Because Scott at this stage of his writing career was not willing to admit authorship,
PRE-HENTY 53
Robert’s father was given the task of copying the novels. Scott’s financial problems involved the Ballantynes as well, and Robert, at the age of sixteen, had to leave school. He became apprenticed to the Hudson’s Bay Company, and was sent to Canada where he spent several years in remote areas, trading in fur with Indians. When he returned to Scotland, he began to work as a junior partner in a printing company, and in 1848 he published his memoirs with the Hudson’s Bay Company, Hudson’s Bay. The death of his father and sister probably turned him toward religious endeavor: he formed a Bible-reading class, and became an Elder of the Free Kirk. It was at the suggestion of the Edinburgh publisher Nelson that Ballantyne began to write for a juvenile audience, after he had produced a juvenile story about North America which proved very successful. He wrote The Young FurTraders (originally entitled Snowflakes and Sunbeams), and before its publication in 1856, Ballantyne had already given up his job and resolved to make a living from writing, painting, and lecturing on his North American experiences (Carpenter & Prichard 1984:42). The success of The Young Fur-Traders led to other juvenile books including Coral Island and Black Ivory. In my discussion I’ll focus on Black Ivory. In his books Ballantyne devised a pattern that he was to follow throughout his writing career. Stuart Hannabuss, in his article “Ballantyne’s Message of Empire” comments on this pattern in a telling manner: The central narrative thread was the episodic and often picaresque adventure of a tenderfoot hero, whose manly courage and good moral sense, coupled with much coincidence and occasional authorial intervention, took him safely through a series of adventures, usually pitted against overtly characterised enemies, usually assisted by obviously good men like missionaries and whimsical (and, by modern standards, racist or paternalistic) caricatures of Irish, black or other personalities (quoted in Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature 55).
Black Ivory: A Tale of Adventure Among the Slavers in East Africa (1873) is a story about the Atlantic Slave Trade. It chronicles the adventures of Harold Seadrift and a sailor from his father’s ship, Disco Lillihammer, into the interior of the east coast of Africa where they come face to face with the realities and atrocities of the trade in humans. Harold’s adventure turns into an antislavery crusade as he witnesses the inhumanity of the slave trade which is still carried out
54 NARRATING AFRICA
by the Portuguese and Arabs. With the help of his African friends, Harold rescues hundreds of captives, including an African chief, Kambira, and his wife, Azinté. He also visits the Seychelles where a camp has been erected to care for the rescued slaves. Back at the Cape, Harold announces his engagement to Alice Gray, only daughter of the late Sir Eustace Gray, who leaves his daughter a fortune “next to nothing.” Harold makes plans to visit England, come back, and settle down with his family at the Cape. Meanwhile, Kambira, Azinté, and their son Obo find jobs respectively as head gardener, cook, and page-inwaiting within the Harold Seadrift circle. Black Ivory is essentially a sea adventure story, a Robinsonnade, that turns into an antislavery endeavor. Harold Seadrift’s dreams of adventure in Africa materialize when his father charters a ship for the purpose. Before he sets on his adventure into the “wilds of Africa” his father counsels him thus: “Harold, my boy, here is a chance for paying a visit to the land you’ve read and talked so much about, and wished often to travel through. I have chartered a brig, and shall send her out to Zanzibar with a cargo of beads, cotton cloth, brass wire, and such like: what say you to go as supercargo? Of course you won’t be able to follow in the steps of Livingstone or Mungo Park, but while the brig is at Zanzibar you will have an opportunity of running across the channel, the island being only a few miles from the main, and having a short run up-country to see the niggers, and perchance have a slap at a hippopotamus. I’ll line your pockets, so that you won’t lack the sinews of war, without which travel either at home or abroad is but sorry work, and I shall only expect you to give a good account of ship and cargo on your return—Come, is it fixed?” (Balllantyne 3).
But when faced with the cruelties of Arab and Portuguese enslavers, his adventure turns into missionary work.15 Harold and Disco come into contact for the first time with what the Arab slave trader Yoosoof refers to as “Black Ivory”: “In what sort of goods do you trade?” “Ivory. Some be white, an’ some be what your countrymans do call black.” “Black!” “Yees, black. White ivory do come from the elephant—hims tusk; Black Ivory, do come…from the land everywheres. It bees our chef artikil of trade.” “Indeed! I never heard of it before.”
PRE-HENTY 55
“No?…. You shall see it much here.”
The novel, besides being a tale of adventure, develops other themes that require our attention. Like In the Wilds of Africa, Black Ivory exposes the inhumanity of the Atlantic Slave Trade and applauds the British role in its abolition. In Black Ivory, Harold and Disco, both Englishmen, illustrate British abolitionist and colonial motives; as Disco contends: “[T]here’s only one way to cure it,…and that is, to bring the Portuguese and Arabs to their marrow-bones; put the fleet on the east coast in better workin’ order; have consuls everywhere with orders to keep their weather-eyes open to slave-dealers; start two or three British settlements —ports o’ refuge—on the mainland; hoist the Union Jack, and, last, but not the least, send ‘em the Bible.” (Ballantyne 415–16)
The narrator acknowledges the fact that the British are not altogether blameless in regard to slavery and the Atlantic Slave Trade. Ballantyne’s approach to and understanding of slavery and the slave trade follow those of David Livingstone years earlier; in fact, reference is made throughout the book to Livingstone, and his work in East Africa. In the preface to Black Ivory, Ballantyne states that his goal is to give a “true picture” of the slave trade as it exists on the east coast of Africa. He acknowledges his indebtedness to Rev. Charles New, an interpreter to the Livingstone Search Expedition. Hence, the novel is thoroughly footnoted to attest to the veracity of the information it contains. Ballantyne claims: “I have selected from the most trustworthy sources what I believe to be the most telling points of ‘the trade,’ and have woven these together into a tale, the warp of which is composed of thick cords of fact; the woof of slight lines of fiction, just sufficient to hold the fabric together” (Ballantyne iii). According to his biographer, Eric Quayle, Ballantyne became interested in the subject of slavery after reading a report of an antislavery meeting held in Leeds (Quayle 261). He later decided to write Black Ivory in condemnation of the trade—as an antislavery document. But a closer look at the novel reveals the true objectives behind both the passing of the emancipation bill and British pioneering efforts to abolish the trade. Despite Ballantyne’s objective, Black Ivory avoids British accountability for the trade, and puts the blame primarily on the Arabs (the Sultan of Zanzibar) and the Portuguese. He portrays Africans as defenseless savages and the British as benevolent saviors.
56 NARRATING AFRICA
It is almost impossible for someone without familiarity with the history of the Atlantic Slave Trade to appreciate Britain’s active involvement and domination of the trade at one point in time, not to mention the fact that Queen Elizabeth herself had financed slave-ship expeditions. In his Africans and Their History historian Joseph Harris asserts that in order for the British to start colonization, encourage settlements of British citizens on the African continent, and promote European culture through Christianity, they had to make Africa safe by encouraging, even initiating, the abolition of the Atlantic Slave Trade which might have otherwise jeopardized their newly found colonization and exploitation schemes (91). Colonization was slavery in different garb. In spite of its condescending tone, Black Ivory gives a sociohistorical interpretation of the “peculiar institution.” The African agency regarding the trade is aptly viewed in the following terms: [F]athers do not, indeed, sell their own children, or husbands their wives,…but chiefs and head men are by no means loath to get rid of their criminals in this way—their bad stock, as it were, of black ivory…. Meanwhile he [the slave trader] takes up his quarters near some tribe, and sets about deliberately to produce war. He rubs up old sores, foments existing quarrels, lends guns and ammunition, suggests causes of dispute, and finally gets two tribes to fight.” (Ballantyne 182–83)
Although the narrator, here, is referring to the methods of Arabs and Portuguese slave traders, it is without question that the British had previously used the same strategies in securing slaves in Africa. Black Ivory reveals a pattern characteristic of nineteenth-century “fiction of empire”: it advocates colonization, and negates or denigrates African culture so as to justify the so-called need to impose British culture. This pattern is evidenced in Black Ivory: Africans are constantly referred to as savages even if their names are known. The narrator points out that “savages have no literature,” since they “cannot read or write therefore, and have no permanent records of the deeds of their forefathers…. Neither have they any religion worthy of the name. This is indeed a serious evil, one which civilized people of course deplore…” (Ballantyne 168). It is clear that the narrator mistakes illiteracy for lack of literature, since historically, the people he refers to have their poets, musicians, and griots. In Black Ivory Makompa illustrates the existence of oral literature (orature) in the ditty he composes to praise the deeds of the British:
PRE-HENTY 57
De English come to see, Yo ho! Dat werry good for we, Yo ho! No’ take us ‘way for slaves, Nor put us in our graves, But set the black mans free…(Ballantyne 250)
While the content of Makompa’s ditty is an acknowledgment of British benevolence, and an affirmation of the white man’s burden, by creating the character of Makompa, the author contradicts his claim that the people have no literature. The alleged lack of literature and religion justifies the “civilizing mission” of Victorian England. It is also interesting to point out that in Black Ivory, the author ironically attempts to dismantle the myth of the savage. A conversation between Harold and Disco attests to this attempt: “The savages, as we call ‘em, bores holes in their lips an’ sticks rings into ‘em. The civilized folk, as we call ourselves, bores holes in their ears an’ sticks rings into ‘em. W’eres the difference? that’s wot I want to know.” “There’s not much difference in principle,…but there’s great difference in appearance. Ear-rings hang gracefully; lip-rings stick out horribly.” “H’m! it appears to me that that’s a matter o’ taste, now. Howsoever, I do admit that lip-rings is wuss than ear-rings…but as I said before, so I says again, it’s all in the principle w’ere it lies…. It is my opinion that there ain’t no such thing as savages—or if you choose to put it the other way, we’re all savages together.” (Ballantyne 194–196).
Notwithstanding these discussions and musings between Harold and Disco on the semantics of the term savage, the “civilizing mission” still takes place. Harold begins telling Bible stories to the natives, instead of his usual Robinson Crusoe tales and its adaptations. He prescribes two remedies to the problem of slavery: There must be points or centres of refuge for the oppressed on the mainland of Africa, and there must be the introduction of the Bible. The first is essential to the second. Where anarchy, murder, injustice, and tyranny are rampant and triumphant, the advance of the missionary is either terribly slow or altogether impossible. The life-giving, soul-
58 NARRATING AFRICA
softening Word of God, is the only remedy for the woes of mankind, and, therefore, the only cure for Africa. To introduce it effectually, and along with its civilisation and all the blessings that flow therefrom, it is indispensable that Great Britain should obtain, by treaty or by purchase, one or more pieces of land there to establish free Christian negro settlements, and with force sufficient to defend them from the savages, and worse than savages—the Arab and Portuguese half-caste barbarians who infest the land. (Ballantyne 389–90).
As the above quote indicates, conquest and colonization through the teachings of the Bible remain the main objectives in Ballantyne’s Black Ivory: “it is indispensable that Great Britain should obtain, by treaty or by purchase, one or more pieces of land there to establish free Christian negro settlements, and with force sufficient to defend them from the savages.” The negro settlements recall the repatriation schemes advocated by various abolitionist movements to rid England of its Black population after emancipation. The narrator nevertheless concedes how the natives have come to distrust the White man. On one of their missions to teach the gospel, Harold is told: What the white man says may be true, but the white men seem to tell lies too much. The men who killed our warriors, burned our villages, and took women and children away, came to us saying that they were friends; that they were the servants of the same people as the white man Livingstone, and wanted to trade with us. When we believed and trusted them, and were off our guard, they fired on us with their guns. We know not what to think or believe. (271)
As indicated in this statement, nineteenth-century writers were sometimes ambivalent about the civilizing mission. But all the novelists discussed in this chapter played a role in the building and maintenance of the British empire by perpetuating existing myths about Africans. Moreover, Hughes’s muscular Christianity and Defoe’s emphasis on adventure, emigration, and colonization had a strong impact on juvenile literature, which became more and more aggressive and ethnocentric in temperament. Although Thomas Arnold, the education theorist, might have been appalled at the militarization of the public schools, by the 1880s this militarization became the norm, and public schools became a breeding ground for the young empire-builders we will encounter in George Henty’s novels. But unlike Marryat, Henty did not believe in the rise and fall of empires. With the exception of By Sheer Pluck, the religious or missionary component of the civilizing
PRE-HENTY 59
mission (found in Marryat, Kingston, and Ballantyne) is absent in Henty’s juvenile books set in Africa. Henty sustained the idea that the British had a “divine” mission to “civilize” the world through military might (guns), but not necessarily through evangelicalism (the Bible). The next chapter is an analysis of the socio-cultural background to Henty’s juvenile books set in Africa—novels that combined both the elements of adventure and the school story with a military tint. NOTES 1. Fred Inglis distinguishes children’s literature from that of adults by the following characteristics: (1) In books specifically written for children the protagonists are children, people like themselves; (2) children’s literature, he argues, is less concerned with “probability in plot and circumstance” than adult novels; (3) children’s books are usually, but not necessarily, shorter than adult novels; (4) the story is marked by “its conscious limitation of formal intricacy”; (5) the syntax is simple, and (6) there is a simplification (but not a superficial treatment) of moral issues (Inglis 101–02). Ruth MacDonald, while in agreement with Inglis, adds three characteristics of her own. She notes that the tone in children’s literature is optimistic, the writing is presented in an active way, and the form of narrative often includes time travel, initiation into adulthood, and the rise and fall of fortune (14). 2. The adventure story of the nineteenth century owes its popularity to the growing influence of popular fiction. In the context of the 1830s, the term popular fiction referred to the literature that the masses of the English people could buy cheaply. In her Popular Fiction 100 Years Ago, Margaret Dalziel defines popular fiction as “books and magazines that are read purely for pleasure by people to whom pleasure is incompatible with the expenditure of intellectual or emotional effort” (1). This definition speaks to the primary objective of popular fiction, that is, it aims at entertainment rather than reform or education. At the beginning of the century, Cobbett published some cheap periodicals advocating a series of political programs, but after a while these ceased to appear. In 1825, the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge was founded to provide cheap literature without any religious or political bias. In 1832 for the first time, three cheap weekly periodicals appeared, and their success testified to the demand for cheap literature. For
60 NARRATING AFRICA
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
the most part, these periodicals tended to attack the existing state of affairs and the world known to the readers, rather than create the Utopian world usually associated with fictional adventure (Dalziel 23). Beginning in 1841 and continuing for ten years, Edward Lloyd, a businessman, published cheap periodicals and novels appearing in penny weekly parts (hence the name “penny dreadfuls”) which in the 1860s were directed toward the juvenile public and dealt with adventure, violence and crime (Dalziel 23). The first edition of Robinson Crusoe appeared on April 25, 1719, when its author was fifty-eight. The second edition came out seventeen days later; twenty-five days later a third, and the fourth on August 8. It was then serialized in the Original London Post, being the first serial in the English language. This 1793 anonymous poem by an African slave attests to how slavery was perceived as a form of cannibalism. But as Jan Nederveen Pieterse noted in his White on Black (1992), this “counteraccusation from the standpoint of the colonized” or enslaved received little or no attention in the West (Pieterse 120). It is worth pointing out that whether cannibalism in this poem is used as a metaphor for slavery or as an allegation, the poem was a response to a real brutality meted out to Africans, whereas the cannibalism Africans are often accused of in European writings about Africa is baseless. He became so indebted that a newspaper carried the following advertisement offering fifty pounds reward for his arrest: “A middle-sized, spare man, about forty years old, of a brown complexion, and dark-brown coloured hair, but wears a wig; a hooked nose, a sharp chin, grey eyes, and a large mole near his mouth” (Bryce 6). Alexander Selkirk (1676–1721) was born in Fife. At the age of twenty-seven he ran away to sea. In 1704, having quarreled with his captain, he requested to be put ashore on the uninhabited island of Juan Fernandez where he remained until 1709 when he was rescued by Woodes Rogers, commander of a privateering expedition (Drabble 836). This idea was apparently popularized by Montaigne’s 1580 essay “On Cannibals”—the notion that “primitive” peoples were morally superior to “civilized” peoples of Europe. The Bible helped foster this notion by providing the image of the primitive as pure and uncorrupted before the Fall of Man. (Beckson and Ganz 215).
PRE-HENTY 61
8. I shall develop this idea of regression into savagery in chapter 6 in relation to Haggard’s King Solomon’s Mines and Conrad’s Heart of Darkness. 9. Although he admired Arnold’s character, he was at odds with some of his politics. 10. In Tom Brown at Oxford (1861), Hughes defines “muscular Christian” in these terms: “[A]s far as I know, the least of the muscular Christians has hold of the old chivalrous and Christian belief, that a man’s body is given him to be trained and brought into subjection, and then used for the protection of the weak, the advancement of all righteous causes and the subduing of the earth which God has given to the children of men” (see Thomas Hughes, Tom Brown at Oxford 99). 11. Johann David Wyss, a Swiss pastor, wrote The Swiss Family Robinson (1812–1813) in German. It was translated into English the following year. An adaptation of Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe, it is a story of a family wrecked on a desert island. 12. The child-parent metaphor in colonial discourse has been discussed by many theorists, including Homi Bhabha. In The Location of Culture, Bhabha discusses T.B.Macaulay’s essay in which the latter argues that the Directors of East India Company gave orders (to colonial administrators) which simply meant that the latter should “be the father and the oppressor of the people…” (quoted in Bhabha 95). The authors of The Empire Writes Back also argue that the “parent-child” metaphor sanctions colonial discourse, in that it emphasizes “age, experience, roots, tradition, and…[a]bove all…final authority in questions of taste and value” (Ashcroft et al. 16). This is particularly important when we consider terms such as mother-country to designate the colonizer’s relation to the colonized. Whether the colonizer is seen as the father or the mother of the child, the colonized individual is—and remains—a child. Whereas a child matures, becomes adult and autonomous, the child in colonial discourse (the colonized or “native”) never matures, but remains a child in need of protection, surveillance, and control. 13. To negate any Black contribution to world civilization, Europe treated, and still treats, Egypt as separate from Africa. Hence Shakespeare’s Othello is a Moor, not African. 14. Philip also discussed Marryat’s use of America as an “analogue for the undeveloped person (the repulsive child).” Apparently, he
62 NARRATING AFRICA
was unpopular in the United States because of his “cockiness and condescension,” and was “threatened with lynching and burnt in effigy” (82). 15. Unlike Harold (who goes to Africa as an adventurer but becomes a missionary), Livingstone was a missionary who became an explorer. Livingstone believed that the introduction of commerce and Christianity would deter Africans from participating in the trade in humans.
This page intentionally left blank.
CHAPTER 3
To Africa with Henty The Socio-Cultural Background
More even than the Indian books, Henty’s African stories highlight his attitudes to race, to empire and to his general concept of white—and British—superiority. —Guy Arnold, Held Fast for England
Colonialism conceptually depopulated countries either by acknowledging the native but relegating him or her to the category of the subhuman, or simply by looking through the native and denying his/her existence. These were necessary practices for invoking the claim of terra nullius upon which the now-disputed legality of imperial settlement (as opposed to “invasion”) was based. Only empty spaces can be settled, so the space had to be made empty by ignoring or dehumanizing the inhabitants…. Inscribing the natives as primitive and unable to make use of the natural resources around them allowed first the biblical parable of the ten talents, and then the Darwinian theory of natural selection to justify their dispossession as part of the plan of Destiny. —Chris Tiffin and Allan Lawson, De-Scribing Empire
It is crucial to stress, at the outset, that the apparent civilizing mission undertaken by the British government in the mid-nineteenth century did not convince all its citizens of the importance of maintaining colonies abroad, and consequently drew a great deal of anti-imperialist 64
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 65
sentiment. Not until the Great Depression (1873–1896) did it become clear that the real mission of imperialism was not to “civilize the savages” of India and Africa but to redress the slagging British economy. The period of the Great Depression coincided with the age of this new imperialism, and brought proponents and opponents of the issue of colonization together. Advocates of colonization became increasingly prominent as they became more convinced that colonization would be the only way out of the economic stagnation resulting from German and American competitors, and other political and social embarrassments of the day (Ausubel 81). As the depression wore on, former opponents of overseas territorial occupation became its supporters. For instance, before he became prime minister, Benjamin Disraeli wrote to Lord Derby: “Leave the Canadians to defend themselves; recall the African squadron; give up the settlements on the west coast of Africa; and we shall make a saving which will, at the same time, enable us to build ships and have a good Budget” (quoted in Ausubel 83). But a few years later in his Crystal Palace address in 1872, Disraeli condemned Liberals for having viewed the colonies solely from an economic standpoint, thus totally ignoring “those moral and political considerations which make nations great, and by the influence of which alone men are distinguished from animals” (Ausubel 84). In fact during his ministry he oversaw the annexation of Fiji, the purchase of shares of the Suez Canal, the proclamation of the Queen Empress of India, British protection of Turkey under Russian expansionism, the acquisition of Cyprus, and the defeat of the Zulus in South Africa. The Great Depression was still under way by the end of Disraeli’s term (1874–1880), when publicists began to convince the British from all walks of life that the survival of their country depended on colonial expansion. Referring to John Robert Seeley’s The Expansion of England (1883), Herman Ausubel argued that the colonies “offered land for the landless and the prospect of wealth for those in financial distress” (85). Seeley had maintained that England needed the colonies where the “surplus population” could relocate and “continue to be Britons.” Seeley also predicted that in fifty years the United States and Russia would become “super powers,” and surpass countries like Germany and France (Ausubel 85). After the publication of The Expansion of England in 1833, James Anthony Froude, a prominent historian of the Tudors, conceived the idea of a Commonwealth of Oceana that would link the United Kingdom, Canada, South Africa, Australia, and New Zealand.
66 NARRATING AFRICA
Froude defended his thesis by focusing on the decline of Britain’s economic position: In the multiplying number of our fellow citizens animated by a common spirit, we should have purchasers for our goods from whom we should fear no rivalry; we should turn in upon them the tide of our emigrants which now flows away, while the emigrants themselves thrive under their own fig tree, and rear children with stout limbs and colour in their cheeks, and a chance before them of human existence, (quoted in Ausubel 85)
Politicians also displayed interest and hope for the future in the acquisition of colonial space. After serving as prime minister in the Conservative governments of 1885 and 1886–1892, Lord Salisbury declared in the House of Lords in 1895, immediately before his third term, that it was the duty and responsibility of the English government to facilitate access to fertile regions like Uganda: “You must open the path,” he said, “it is for you to enable our people to get there. It is for you to enable capital to be invested and commerce to be extended” (quoted in Ausubel 87). In 1895 Joseph Chamberlain became secretary of state for the colonies primarily because he “desired to see whether there may not be room for still further developing our resources in these new countries and for opening up British markets” (quoted in Ausubel 87). Chamberlain’s desire was to see Britain protect and maintain its colonial territories and to extend those possessions. Consequently during his tenure numerous colonial projects were undertaken: road and railroad building in West Africa, research in tropical medicine and colonial agriculture, access to “development” loans, and the Boer War was fought with assistance from Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, which were already part of the British empire (Ausubel 88). But all this could not have happened, and with efficacy, without the infamous Berlin West African Conference of 1884–1885, which paved the way for further European involvement in Africa. Without taking up the history of the conference in its entirety, it is nevertheless important to stress some of its key elements and antecedents. The conference took place in Berlin between November 15, 1884 and February 26, 1885. It was summoned and chaired by Germany, and attended by every European power (with the exception of Switzerland) as well as the United States. Among these powers, five were of real influence: France, Germany, Great Britain, Portugal, and the International Association of the Congo—an ambiguous body
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 67
(not having any legal representation) which was used by King Leopold of Belgium to mask his colonial ambitions (Crowe 11). The conference and its subsequent outcome—the partition of the African continent—came as a result of both the continuing Industrial Revolution and the great power rivalry among European nations. This partition, they thought, would ease the tensions and quarrels among these nations whose representatives congregated in Berlin to decide the fate of the continent. Beyond the professed rationale for the new imperialism—notably the civilizing mission—the reasons for European colonial enterprise in Africa are easily discernible. Economic constraints and national competition for prestige increased European interest in Africa, and triggered rivalry among these European nations—rivalry exemplified in the race between Henry Morton Stanley (Britain) and Savorgna de Brazza (France) to reach the so-called Stanley Pool in 1880 (Chamberlain 25). Europeans, namely the Portuguese, Dutch, British, and French, had established and long maintained trading posts on the coast of Africa between the sixteenth and early nineteenth centuries, but were unable to have access to, or control over the hinterland except in the case of South Africa and Angola (Maddox, Colonialism and Nationalism in Africa xi). The British had come very close to possessing a colony in West Africa with the Sierra Leone experiment1 in 1787 when the colony was founded. But in general, British interest in Africa declined somewhat in the years following this embryonic colonial venture. Supposedly, the Niger Experiment of 1841–1842 was the British attempt to expand trade in commodities that would replace the trade in humans (Chamberlain 20–21). Philip Curtin and K.O.Dike argue that, like the Sierra Leone venture, the Niger experiment was also a failure because the expedition suffered heavy mortalities during its activity (Chamberlain 21). But we need to remind ourselves that the experiment was perhaps doomed to fail from the beginning, partly because slave labor was still in existence in the United States, Brazil, and the Caribbean: as long as there was a demand for slaves, clandestine trade would and did result. Despite the ill-fated Niger experiment, British interest in Africa grew in the 1840s partly as a result of literary publications, mainly travel narratives such as J.Smith’s Trade and Travel in the Gulph of Guinea (1851), whose chapter titles are quite telling: “Human Sacrifice,” “Nailing Prisoners,” “Jack Ketch,” “Decapitation,” “Cooking and Eating Human Flesh,” “King Pepple
68 NARRATING AFRICA
Eats King Amacree’s Heart” (Chamberlain 22). But other forces were equally at work. The last quarter of the nineteenth century saw an overwhelming expansion of European colonization. In Europe the birth of two nationstates in 1870–1871, Germany and Italy, was among the changes that would later lead to the summoning of the Berlin West African Conference by Bismarck. France and Britain were already great powers and had control over certain regions in Africa soon to be their colonies. Since national prestige was an important factor in European imperialism, nationalists in Germany and Italy felt their countries should also acquire colonies, given that they could afford it financially and militarily. Meanwhile, France had been defeated in the war against Prussia, the dominant state in Germany. To regain prestige and make up for her lost provinces, and to prevent Italy from gaining control of the Mediterranean, France occupied Tunis (Tidy and Leeming 1). In addition, in order to protect their assets in India, the most important part of the British empire, Britain needed full monopoly over the Suez Canal (completed in 1869) and the sea routes around the Cape of Good Hope between Britain and India (Maddox, Colonialism and Nationalism in Africa xii). Consequently, when Arabi Pasha, the Egyptian ruler, was defeated at the battle of Tel-el-Kebir, the British government took control of Egypt in 1882. Britain also prevented other European countries from acquiring colonies along the banks of the Nile by occupying the Sudan, Uganda, and Kenya (Tidy and Leeming 1). In central Africa in the 1870s, Portugal, although the weakest European power, began to lay claims on the regions it had had contact with through trade and slavery (Maddox, Colonialism and Nationalism in Africa xii). After the founding of the Society for German Colonization in 1884, Germany created protectorates in Togo, the Cameroons, and Tanganyika (Tidy and Leeming 5). And King Leopold II of Belgium, unable to find support for his colonial endeavors, used his personal wealth to “carve a private empire out of central Africa,” the so-called Congo Free State, later a Belgian colony (Maddox, Colonialism and Nationalism in Africa xii). In the late nineteenth century European awareness of the economic possibilities of Africa also increased. The discovery of the largest diamond and gold fields in South Africa, a region under British control, raised issues of territorial claim (Maddox, Colonialism and Nationalism in Africa xiii). Europeans were also aware of the possibility of, and interested in obtaining through middle men from the interior an
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 69
enormous amount of rubber, ivory, peanuts, and cloves for European markets. Also among the raw materials in demand was palm oil, used in ships’ engines and sewing machines, as well as for the manufacture of soaps and candles (Crowe 12). Thus trade disputes among these European nations became commonplace. Historians Tidy and Leeming relate European militarism to the rivalry that led to the scramble for territory. They contend that since few battles occurred in Europe during the last quarter of the nineteenth century, European military officers who aspired to promotion and glory sought it in colonial wars, which were generally less dangerous than wars in Europe due to the lack of modern weapons among Africans and colonial peoples (Tidy and Leeming xx). For instance French military officers such as Bugeaud, Faidherbe, De Brazza, and Gallieni became legendary heroes for having fought colonial wars in Africa. Likewise, Wolseley, Kitchener, and Luggard were British men of arms who led British troops into various African states and communities where they hoisted the Union Jack and became celebrities. The Berlin West African Conference, then, was intended to ease all trade disputes, but later extended to include other topics such as “legal” occupation by European powers of the whole continent. As Maddox has noted in his introduction to Colonialism and Nationalism in Africa, the conference divided up spheres of influence between the interested powers and laid ground rules for annexation. While the image of diplomats in striped pants blithely drawing lines on blank maps with rules and compasses is appealing, spheres of influence generally recognized existing commercial or political interests and final boundaries were usually fixed later. The conference established “effective occupation” as a standard by which claims could be judged that in turn set off the final scramble to establish outposts, collect dubious treaties with presumed African rulers, and build infrastructure such as ports and railroads, (xiii)
With the exception of the United States, all the powers present at the conference signed and approved the final decisions contained in a General Act. The First Basis dealt with the “establishment of freedom of commerce in the basin and mouths of the Congo River”; the Second Basis gave these nations “freedom of navigation on the Congo and Niger”; the Third dealt with “effective [territorial] occupation.” The question of the so-called internal slave trade received lukewarm support and resulted in the “insertion of a vague clause in the final act.”
70 NARRATING AFRICA
The abrogation of liquor traffic was brought up by Britain, but dismissed mainly by Germany on “account of the vested interests” (Crowe 102–03). This is what happened on paper in Berlin, and the fate of the continent was thus decided by representatives of the major powers of the European community (except Switzerland). Ironically the International Association of the Congo present at the conference had nothing to do with an African representative, because there was none (Crowe 5). On the ground, Europeans encountered resistance from African states: smaller states and territories were easily conquered, but the larger ones fought battle after battle mainly between 1870 and 1890. Various African rulers who rejected British rule, for instance, were arrested and deported to other British colonies far from their countries. For instance King Prempeh I of the Ashantis (Ghana), Bai Bureh of Sierra Leone, and Mukama Kabarega of Bunyoro were all deported to the Seychelles,2 where some of them died or were allowed to return only after years in exile, “and after the divide-and-rule principle had deprived [them] of a constituency” (Maddox, The Colonial Epoch in Africa 33–34). This method of banishing African rulers from their people and government was very effective, for the British rapidly filled the political vacuum created by their involuntary absence. The British converted these African leaders to Christianity while they were in exile; some received British education along with their children, since it was thought that Christianity and British education would make the deportees and their offspring more docile than their parents had been (Maddox, The Colonial Epoch in Africa 34). To preface the discussion of Henty’s juvenile books with the Berlin West African Conference is to recall African resistance to the partition; it is also to place Henty’s juvenile books within their historical contexts, since it was African resistance to European (British in this case) domination that provided the site of conflict within which Henty’s novels are inscribed. Thus, the conference and the subsequent African resistance to it are crucial to the critique of Henty’s works, in that these works are based on the “accounts” of the war correspondent that Henty was. Henty covered the Abyssinian campaign, the FrancoGerman war, the Turco-Servian war, the so-called Ashanti and Zulu wars, the Anglo-Boer war, and several other wars mainly involving British interests. It is not surprising that late-nineteenth-century juvenile literature romanticized these imperialist wars after the militarization of the English public schools had been achieved earlier in midcen-
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 71
tury. What, then, are the relations among juvenile literature, imperialist wars, and the public school? ROMANCE AND IMPERIALIST WARS: FROM THE SCHOOL TO THE BATTLEFIELD If imperial conquest on the grand scale could [thus] be encoded in a (Divine) comedy, the campaigns and battles which were its necessary constituent were more often imagined as romance, with the focus on the role of the individual hero…. [T]he central dynamic of romance is dialectical, in the form of a conflict between the hero and his adversaries; the hero’s task, or adventure, is part of a larger quest, which ends with his success and recognition. Again, as in comedy, light triumphs over darkness, virtue over vice, as the hero transcends the limits of the ordinary world. The hero and his people are associated with order, vigor and youth, while the forces opposing him are savages, locked in confusion and darkness. (MacDonald, “A Poetics of War” 26)
The connection Robert MacDonald makes between imperial wars, games, and romantic adventure is a pertinent one. MacDonald argues in his article “A Poetics of War: Militarist Discourse in the British Empire, 1880–1918” that the public school code of “playing the game” could seem to be incompatible with the realities of war in the trenches. MacDonald tells the story of the military officer who would kick a football toward the enemy line when attacking, just to show the courage of the British (17). But a closer look at the nature of the nineteenth-century public school reveals interesting similarities. From our discussion of Thomas Hughes’s Tom Brown’s Schooldays in the previous chapter, it is obvious that the public schools taught British boys the necessary patriotism, tools, and ammunition to serve the empire. These public schools, coupled with the Boy Scouts, were paramount in creating the so-called empire-builders, also known as Men of War. Describing a rugby game, Hughes wrote: “My dear Sir, a battle would look much the same to you, except that the boys would be men, and the balls iron” (Tom Brown’s Schooldays 89). Here, Hughes was mak-
72 NARRATING AFRICA
ing a connection between war and sport that was part and parcel of the nineteenth-century public school curricula. Boys would be called to duty in the empire, to fight for and maintain the empire. But, unlike the games played at Rugby, the battle for which the schoolboys were being prepared was a “justified” battle—against the forces of evil, against savages, and against darkness. Though of a previous century, ideologically Crusoe could have been one of Arnold’s students at Rugby. Crusoe was not, and did not become, a colonial military officer but he never forgot his duty as an Englishman, that is, to bring order into an environment where chaos once reigned. The rugbyplaying boys in Tom Brown’s Schooldays became not only the empirebuilders of Henty’s juvenile books, but also British colonial officers such as Baden-Powell, Sir Garnet Wolseley, and General Gordon (MacDonald, “A Poetics of War” 26) The discourse of playing the game functioned as a discourse of difference: it set the English apart from other nations and nationalities, women, and the underprivileged, and as MacDonald puts it, “at the bottom, the mystique of a code cannot be analyzed by its believers, but only taken on faith. If you do not understand, you do not belong to the privileged group” (19). It follows that, to be a member of the privileged group, one needs to play the game, and that includes the use of the language and iconography of chivalry that describes war in a sacred mode. In juvenile and popular literature, successful fights were called “hot work,” unsuccessful ones were referred to as “desperate work”; soldiers found themselves in “tight spots” and “hot corners.” MacDonald asserts that referring to killing as work, or to danger as tight, had to be read as a “signal in the language of class and gender superiority,” and “to call war a game was the ultimate euphemism, a provocative assertion of caste power” (19). Baden-Powell, founder of the Boy Scouts, intimated that officers from other countries “envy and admire that spirit of sport and adventure which pervades the British officers as a class…. Many foreign nations have sought to instill the British characteristics into their own manhood, but in doing so they have tried to force that which will not grow naturally,…they cannot get their boys to take to cricket and football and other games that ours take to as naturally as ducklings to water” (quoted in MacDonald, “A Poetics of War” 20). Hence games were naturally English, and Englishmen were also the best players.3 While the significance of “militant imperialism was conveyed
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 73
through such topoi as ‘playing the game,’ ideology was activated through narrative”: The plots of war stand at the center of the symbolic order. The framing narrative of imperialism, the ur-plot, was that of conquest: first came the traders and missionaries; the natives resisted or “rebelled”; then came the army to conquer and pacify. Subsequently more settlers arrived, and the country prospered, given the benefits of “civilization”— new crops, a new economy, a new political and legal structure. (MacDonald, “A Poetics of War” 23)
The war of conquest, supposedly waged for the benefit of humanity, could not have been mean-spirited since it was meant to bring order to a chaotic setting. In Prester John (1910) John Buchan “[strikes] the note of comedie transformation” with these words: “it would do your heart good to see the garden we have made out of the Klein Labongo glen,” says one of the characters in this adventure novel (MacDonald, “A Poetics of War” 23). The making of this garden required, among other things, the British soldier trained in the public school. There seems to be a close connection between the schoolmaster and rebellious pupil, and the relationship between the colonizer and the colonized. On the one hand, the schoolmaster represents the imperial British soldier, and the subjugated, or soon-to-be conquered peoples come close to the disobedient pupil whom the headmaster has the right to discipline through punishment (MacDonald, “A Poetics of War” 25) The war of conquest was presented to the reader as evidence of British superiority, benevolence, and virility; but it also belonged to the motif of war-as-lesson. In “The Lesson,” Kipling, referring to the Boer War, illustrates this “lesson:” “We have an Imperial lesson; it may make us an Empire yet!” (quoted in MacDonald, “A Poetics of War” 25). This narrative, and the like, belonged to the “symbolic creation of order in the name of English superiority,” and as Sir Charles Napier remarked of Sind, “we have no right to seize [it], yet we shall do so, and a very advantageous, useful and humane piece of rascality it will be” (MacDonald, “A Poetics of War” 25). War or conquest as “(Divine) Comedy” rationalizes the barbarous and destructive nature of war; the narrative thus relies on the technique of the romance, and focuses on the role of the individual hero whose “task or adventure is part of a larger quest, which ends with his success and recognition,” and, as in comedy, “light triumphs over darkness, virtue over vice”
74 NARRATING AFRICA
(MacDonald, “A Poetics of War” 26). Thus the building of the British empire relied not only on educational institutions such as the public school, but also on romantic narrative, both of which broadly disseminated imperialist themes and goals. Can we also delineate Henty’s juvenile books as historical novels because they depict actual battles fought between the British and the peoples they later colonized? Some critics such as Crewdson contend that Henty’s works are history texts (Crewdson 97), but Henty’s novels are only historical in the sense that the author uses historical events as background, not in the sense that his accounts of the African people and their traditions are accurate. Although we are told Henty did not transcribe the novels himself, and that for historical information he relied on the London Library, in his novels he always had room to comment on the culture, characteristics, and “personality” of Africans. Was Henty an ethnographer, a historian, or a combination of both? HISTORY, ETHNOGRAPHY, AND PERSISTENT STEREOTYPES The war story can be viewed as a retelling of a romance by the journalist, historian, novelist, or poet. Henty, the most prolific writer of this genre, was also a journalist, a miner, and, to some critics, a historian. Although William Crewdson had asserted that “those who read [Henty’s] books gained far more knowledge about famous battles and foreign lands than they ever could from a history or geography lesson at school” (97), it is quite easy to dismiss Henty as a historian. Despite references in his juvenile books to wars of conquest, some of which he reported on as a correspondent, Henty had little historical evidence to support his comments on the personalities and cultures of the people he encountered. In the Union Jack, a periodical he edited, Henty boasted that although his aim in writing tales was to entertain, his young readers “may rely upon the information in them to be trustworthy and genuine” (quoted in Butts 6). Contrary to Henty’s claims, Denis Butts asserts in his article “Writing to a Formula: G.A.Henty, Historical Novelist or Reporter?” that Henty’s account of the Peninsular Campaign is not “merely inaccurate in detail—describing British attacks upon Spanish allies which never took place—and in exaggerating the lengths of the journeys marched by the infantry,” but also Henty fails to tell his “lads,” as he calls them, why the French army (despite their
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 75
number and strength) was defeated (Butts 6). As Bhupal Singh points out in A Survey of Anglo-Indian Fiction, “when history comes into contact with fiction, when fact clashes with fancy and when race prejudice and pride blur the vision, the complexity of the task increases beyond the powers of ordinary story-tellers” (quoted in Butts 6). Butts further describes Henty’s myopic and inaccurate vision of history when he points out that Henty “can think only in terms of racial stereotypes,” and that he “looks at Empire from the point of view of the British officer and settler, and rarely, if ever, from any other viewpoint” (Butts 6). Henty is also viewed by some critics as an ethnographer. In Africa in English Fiction, 1874–1939, G.D.Killam dates ethnographic fiction from 1874, the year of the Wolseley campaign in the Gold Coast (present-day Ghana) on which Henty based By Sheer Pluck. Killam affirms that Henty did not invent the image of the savage he described in his works, but perpetuated an older one: Addressing themselves to a general public caught up in the enthusiasm of the overseas venture in Africa, they knew what their readers wished to read and to that taste they catered. Thus the generality of authors adhere strictly in their treatments of the African setting to an image of Africa which was in large part formed before they came to write their books, (x)
The British empire did not become the main subject matter for nineteenth-century-fiction writers until travel writers, anthropologists, and historians had laid down the pattern for representing non-Western peoples. Perhaps these travel writers, historians, and anthropologists (ethnographers in particular) thought they had an understanding of the mores and customs of the people they wrote about, but their writings only undermined the integrity of the people and cultures they came into contact with, and perpetuated already-existing biases and myths. In The Savage in Literature, Brian Street points out that a group of scientists began to study the information contained in the travelers’ tales, and as a result the Ethnological Society was founded in 1843. The Society later collected and made available for future travelers information as to what to expect or look for in the course of their travels. Most of these representations or accounts, Street argues, tell more about the Victorian people themselves than about the savages they intend to represent (3). These (mis)representations seem to be the norm among many nineteenth-century European colonizing powers.
76 NARRATING AFRICA
For instance in 1851, the following article was published by the Societé de Géographie de Paris regarding the Niam-Niam people of Central Africa: They all had tails, about forty centimeters long and perhaps two or three in diameter; this organ is smooth; among the cadavers there were those of many women who were formed in the same fashion; aside from this, they were the same as other negroes; they were absolutely naked…. Manuel was in the advance party and saw many of these people killed; he examined the cadavers, measured the tails, and he can conceive of no doubt concerning their existence, (quoted in Miller 4)
The author of this article, Francis de Castelnau, claimed that the information contained in his article came from Manuel, a slave who had previously taken part in a raid on the Hausas into the Niam-Niam territory. The tails (“belonging” to the Niam-Niam) turned out to be “leather ornament[s] representative of tails” (Miller 4). The above quote is a telling example of the limitations of representation; it also attests to the limited knowledge, or lack thereof, of writers describing cultures and people they knew little about. While de Castelnau remains the author of the above article, his misrepresentation of the Niam-Niam could easily be overlooked because he distanced himself from the information by using Manuel as the real witness to people with tails. Manuel’s status (we are told he is a slave) is crucial to the unveiling of de Castelnau’s strategic representation, in that one is led to believe this story coming from a native, (a non-European) rather than from an ethnographer, who could be discredited as being an outsider. The limitations of classical ethnographic writing fashioned after the tradition of “participant observer,” James Clifford argues, has led to experimentation with other forms of ethnographic writing: dialogic ethnography and polyphonic ethnographic writing. The shortcomings of the former lies in the fact that, although there is dialogue between two individuals, the ethnographer still controls the representation of that dialogue. While polyphonic ethnographic writing (inspired by Mikhail Bakhtin’s theory of heteroglossia) encourages multiple voices and direct quotations, it still remains deficient in that it “confirms the ‘virtuoso orchestration’ of various discourses by a single author” (Spurr 188). Clifford aptly points out that “textual embodiment of authority” remains a problem in ethnographic description and interpretation (54). Hence, Francis de Castelnau, writing from a vantage point
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 77
of authority, (mis)represented the Niam-Niam people because of what Clifford refers to as “multiple subjectivities and political constraints” (25)4 that are beyond his control, although he appoints Manuel to be his mouthpiece. Obviously other types of writing face the same problems found in ethnographic representation. David Spurr argues that, like ethnography, journalistic writing is “a direct response to the experience of a specific cultural or historical actuality,” and thereby may embody cultural and personal biases (189). Oftentimes we tend to think that journalistic writing would be free of bias since it is considered to be a firsthand account of events and situations. The battlefield reports Henty incorporates in his novels do not escape this “virtuoso orchestration of various discourses by a single author” found in journalistic and ethnographic writings. The correlations between the imperial writer, the anthropologist, the ethnographer, and the historian become clear when one notes how they all joined in the empire-building endeavor. Henty might have been fully aware that he was a propagandist, not a historian, when he wrote in The Boys’ Own Paper which he had once edited: To endeavour to inculcate patriotism in my books has been one of my main objects, and so far as it is possible to know, I have not been unsuccessful in that respect. I know that many boys have joined the cadets and afterwards gone into the Army through reading my stories, and at many of the meetings at which I have spoken officers of the Army and Volunteers have assured me that my books have been effectual in bringing young fellows into the Army…. (quoted in Arnold 63)
Patriotism was what Henty inculcated in his books, a prerequisite for the heroes of his fiction. Before we turn to these books, it will be useful to take a glance at both Henty—the favorite boys’ author—and the Henty hero. HENTY: THE FAVORITE BOYS’ AUTHOR Born in 1832 at Trumpington, near Cambridge, George A.Henty was an Englishman whose life spanned the Victorian era. During the late 1800s Henty was among the major promoters of empire expansion and the notion of a white man’s burden. Henty was not only one of the most prolific boys’ authors of the Victorian era,5 he was also one of the earliest and most influential ones. His attitudes and writings reflect “what he considered to be the virtues which had made and would keep
78 NARRATING AFRICA
Britain great” (Arnold 3). In the preface to St. George for England, a novel published in 1885, Henty wrote: “The courage of our forefathers has created the greatest empire in the world around a small and in itself insignificant island; if this empire is ever lost, it will be due to the cowardice of their descendants” (5). Henty was certain that the British empire would forever be the dominant world power. In an interview, he arrogantly stated that his books had “helped to foster the imperialist spirit” (quoted in Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature 74). He frequently claims in the prefaces of his novels that his main object is not directed so much toward fiction writing as toward teaching boys history in an acceptable way. His sense of what was acceptable, however, did not stem from historical research, nor even from a credible technique as a historical novelist.6 For the historical and geographical background information that would be inserted into the tales, Henty made use of the London Library and a paid assistant. Henty instructed his helper: “I’ll leave you to yourself today. Boil down the official report of the Battle of So-and-So, or this passage of So-and-So’s book” (Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature 21). Patrick Dunae points out that Henty’s sources were “often biased, even by contemporary standards” (Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature 21 But the young reader had no awareness of biases and inaccuracies. Readers defended him even when they could look back with the benefit of adult hindsight. Responding to a criticism of Henty as a jingoist, Bernard G.T.Hawkes stated in 1908: “I think many young men will be with me when I say that I learnt far more history by reading Mr. Henty’s tales than I ever had crammed into me at school” (Arnold 23). The “knowledge” that such a reader as Bernard Hawkes did acquire was actually a perspective or an attitude about non-English nations as presented by a member of the British upper classes. Henty’s early years were a blend of physical trauma and economic comfort. He was a confirmed invalid at birth and was frequently confined to his bed during his childhood in Canterbury, where his father was a mine owner. He attended a dame school and began reading, in his own words, “voraciously”—romance, adventure, everything he could get his hands on. At ten, he was sent to a London boarding school; at fourteen, he went to Westminster (Arnold 4)7 school; at twenty, he went to Cambridge, but dropped out as he collapsed at the end of his first year following three weeks of intensive study. He retired to his father’s coal mine in Wales, and when he returned to
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 79
Cambridge shortly after, he was offered a job in the Commissariat Department of the army. He left Cambridge for good and for more that twenty years pursued a career as a military man and war correspondent.8 He covered the Abyssinian campaign, the Franco-German War, the Turco-Serbian War, and others for the London Standard. In September of 1873, he followed Sir Garnet Wolseley to the Gold Coast (present-day Ghana) where he met H.M.Stanley, the famous Victorian explorer sent by the New York Herald to look for David Livingstone (Arnold 4–10). Henty set eight of his adventure stories in Africa including an episode in Through Three Campaigns. These stories cover the Wolseley campaign in the Gold Coast (1873–1874), By Sheer Pluck: A Tale of the Ashanti War; the bombardment of Alexandria in 1882, fictionalized in A Chapter of Adventures; the expedition to relieve Gordon (1884–1885), The Dash for Khartoum; an expedition in Omdurman (1898), With Kitchener in the Soudan; the so-called Zulu War of 1879 and the first Anglo-Boer War of 1881, The Young Colonists, and the first and second Boer Wars (1899–1902), With Buller in Natal and With Roberts to Pretoria (Arnold 114). One wonders if Henty wrote these novels of empire because he truly believed in an innate superiority of his people or because he set out to make money. William Allan remarks that before writing boys’ books became his career, Henty sought other ways to subsidize his income on the Standard. One way he did it was to recover “tin from broken or disused utensils.” His house was therefore “filled with a bad smell… engendered by efforts to melt off the tin from baser metal with the assistance of a compound of a chemical sort invented by the operator” (Allan 77). Was it the nostalgia of his schooldays and his military career that drove him to write? As I shall show later, his writings reflect the attitudes, anxieties, and aspirations of the Victorian people. But Henty also influenced his society and even encouraged nineteenth-century negative attitudes towards race and gender. The Times obituary notice observed that “Mr. Henty was stiff in opinions, somewhat dogmatic in manner, and lately inclined to liberal views in politics and religion” (quoted in Allan 99). While the majority of Victorians thought that “if any father, godfather, clergyman or schoolmaster is on the look out for a good book to give a boy who is worth his salt, then he cannot do better than turn to Henty,” a handful, such as Dr. Gordon Stables (who also published with Blackie, Henty’s publisher) “noted with repugnance, the presence of that ‘stiff dogmatic old pagan George Henty’“ (Allan 97).
80 NARRATING AFRICA
Some critics praised him as “The high priest of adventure story writers” and “The Boys’ Dumas,” while to some, his stories were too predictable, and always aimed at the upper- or middle-class. While editor of the Union Jack Henty once received a letter from a boy who wanted to know why he published “such rotten articles”! (Crewdson 96). In his George Alfred Henty: The Story of an Active Life George Man ville Fenn, a friend of Henty’s and a contemporary boys’ writer, uncritically lauds his friend’s activities as war correspondent, writer, and soldier. Guy Arnold, a more recent Henty biographer, describes Fenn’s book as a “flat” work about a “recently passed heroic figure for boys and the picture he draws is not unlike that of one of Henty’s own boy heroes in his many novels—though one that takes the story right through death” (Arnold 3). Fenn paints the acceptable image of Henty, but as William Allan points out, “the outlines of Henty’s personality were blurred even in his own lifetime by the character he created for his heroes,” and at the end of his life, he “came to seek in his novels a simplicity and heroism he no longer found in life” (Allan 72). Whether Henty was seeking in his novels the “heroism he no longer found in life,” or believed in the invincibility of the British empire, one thing is certain: through his writings he brought his stone to the edifice of the British empire. THE HENTY HERO Although hero worship has apparently been present as a familiar cultural norm, mostly in Europe, it essentially became a nineteenthcentury phenomenon (Houghton 305). Carlyle refers to it as a “basis of all possible good, religious or social, for mankind” (123). Nineteenth-century hero worship had its roots in the “cult of enthusiasm, the notion of the superior being, the revival of Homeric mythology, and Victorian nationalism”—nationalism that brought with it the glorification of English heroes, namely those of the Napoleonic and Crimean Wars, and the great Elizabethans (Houghton 306–24). In Rider Haggard and the Fiction of Empire, Wendy Katz notes that “Anglo-German tensions, along with unstable relations with Ireland, India, Egypt and South Africa, had elicited sympathy for the idea of both the heroic man… and an heroic society.” In other words, as Britain seemed to lose control of its colonial possessions, it became expedient to revive the cult of hero worship in order to maintain the
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 81
image of the “greatest empire.” Heroes in literature, Katz maintains, “were imaginary reflections of a society interested in soldiers, athletes, and sheer physical power” (58– 59). Writing at this juncture of Britain’s imperial history, Henty made it a point to endow his heroes with the attributes required to sustain the empire. Henty’s choice of his hero—the imperial hero—is a never-changing one. Oftentimes he is a boy of about fourteen, a son of a widow, middle-class, who had to make his way in the world of adversity, the world of “hostile natives” as A.P.Thornton puts it in his article, “G.A. Henty’s British Empire.” Thornton contends that the heroic emphasis in Henty’s books increased toward the last decade of the nineteenth century to counter the anti-imperialist sentiment during the South African War (99). The heroic emphasis in Henty’s works exemplifies Geoffrey Hartman’s assessment of the hero as a proffered solution to a problem of an era (299), which for the late nineteenth century was the possible decline of the British empire, underscored by increasing antiimperialist sentiment. Henty’s heroes are predictable: early in his juvenile books, he established the “manly,” straightforward type who “could give and take punishment (taking without complaint although more usually he seemed to be giving it), fearless, never lying, [and] resourceful” (Arnold 31). Henty’s “accessible and predictable” heroes invite the reader to “project himself into the character and thereby to take a personal interest not only in the details of battles and campaigns but in the hero’s ultimate success…and the manliness of the hero will become the manliness of the reader” (Nelson 107). Almost all of Henty’s youthful heroes develop strong physiques, probably a detail with autobiographical associations, because as a child Henty was bedridden, but grew up to be “large and powerful” through training in a variety of sports (Arnold 31). Besides providing the hero with an outlet for “the exercise of aggressive impulses” inhibited by an “industrial society located on a small island,” the colony also equips the hero with material possessions such as land, treasure, and commercial benefits (Clark 47). Henty’s apparent approach to wealth in The Young Carthaginian (1887) seems superficially anticapitalist: “With wealth comes corruption, indolence, a reluctance to make sacrifices, a weakening of the feeling of patriotism” (38). Oftentimes, however, Henty’s heroes (after their “ordeals” in the colony, either as soldiers fighting for the cause of their country, or as settlers who become involved in the war of con-
82 NARRATING AFRICA
quest) return with enough money to live happily ever after. For instance in By Sheer Pluck, Frank Hargate, the hero, returns to England with an ample fortune that enables him to attend medical school and to become a high-ranking physician. In fact Guy Arnold, a Henty biographer, contends that although in his juvenile books Henty was inclined to inculcate leadership and “manliness,” as he saw them, he was equally preoccupied with assuring his young readers that his heroes could win fortune, success, recognition, and titles (66). Roy Turnbaugh argues that in Henty’s novels “personal advancement is made to coincide exactly with the demands of duty” (736). Possibly because of his obsession with the greatness of the British empire, his white supremacist views, and his concern that the British empire might disintegrate, Henty sought to impart his belief in the advantages of imperialist enterprise to his young readers. As a consequence, his plots are monotonous, his settings are always the battlefield, and his hero a sort of “‘portrait-robot,’…qui…est un peu toujours le même” [who…is a little redundant].9 The next chapter is a critique of three of Henty’s books set in west and north-east Africa, and based on British military campaigns in the Gold Coast and the Sudan: By Sheer Pluck, The Dash for Khartoum, and With Kitchener in the Soudan. NOTES 1. Blacks (newly freed slaves in the British West Indies and Britain, and those who fought on the British side during the American War of Independence in 1776) were sent to Sierra Leone to settle there. Although this experiment was partially a failure, it played a role in the development of British thinking about the possibilities of a real colony in Africa; see chapter 1 on the Sierra Leone venture. 2. An island off the coast of South Africa used essentially as a prison. 3. Baden-Powell would have been disappointed that the British national football team did not even make it to the 1994 Olympic Games even though they invented the game centuries ago. 4. David Spurr points out in The Rhetoric of Empire that those constraints include the “professionalization of anthropology as a discipline, its coincidence with European colonialism, and its position within universities, museums, and foundations” (188). 5. Out of a record of ninety-four novels published between 1871 and 1906 only about a dozen were written for adults and several for girls including Girl of the Commune and Dorothy’s Double.
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 83
6. Henty scholars point out that he probably never put a pen to a paper. Patrick A.Dunae has provided a vivid picture of his method: “…[he] would recline his massive frame on a sofa and begin to dictate: settings, character sketches, plot outlines… Griffith [his principal assistant], seated stiffly at a desk, would rapidly record the narrative” (Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature 20). Henty once told his interviewers: I do not write any of my books myself. I get a man to do them for me—an amanuensis, of course; it all comes out of my head, but he does all the actual writing. I never see any of my work until it comes to me from the printers in the shape of proof sheets. My amanuensis sits at the table, and I sit near him, or lie on the sofa, and dictate the stories which I publish” (Fenn 316). 7. It is worth noting that Henty’s Westminster days proved to be beneficial to him later in life because it was at Westminster that he took boxing (to defend himself against boys who ragged him after he declared he wrote poetry), rowing, and wrestling. These activities fortified and transformed the sickly boy into a muscular man (Arnold 4). 8. Henty married and had two sons and two daughters. 9. André Rault, in “George Alfred Henty, Romancier de la Jeunesse,” asserts that the model Henty uses for his hero never changes, regardless of the historical events that shape his narrative; see Home, Sweet Home or Bleak House?: Art et Littérature Victorienne (Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1985).
CHAPTER 4
To Africa with Henty The Gold Coast and the Sudan
The courage of our forefathers has created the greatest empire in the world around a small and in itself insignificant island; if this empire is ever lost, it will be due to the cowardice of their descendants. —George Alfred Henty
One measure of a society is its ability to instill in its people the willingness to die—for their king, their country, their gods, their honor. This the Asante did, and it is no small achievement that its people were so steadfast for so long. —Robert B.Edgerton
While in the above quote Henty was referring to the British people, Edgerton’s comments suggest the Ashantis’ devotion to, and belief in, their people and empire. Edgerton’s quote could also be used to comment on the Victorian-Edwardian frame of mind regarding the British empire. The longest and most effective resistance to the British conquest of Africa took place on the west coast. Between 1807 and 1900 the Ashantis (Asante) of present-day Ghana fought battle after battle in attempts to maintain their sovereignty and dignity. Needless to say, the British were attracted to the enormous amount of gold that was to be found in the Gold Coast (modern-day Ghana). When Thomas Edward Bowdich, the scientific observer for the parliament-chartered African Company of Merchants, visited Kumasi in the early nine84
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 85
teenth century and was invited to dine with the Ashanti king, Osei Bonsu, he was highly impressed. He observed: “…dinner was served on a large table under four scarlet umbrellas. The plates were gold, the knives, forks, and spoons were silver.” Later he wrote: “…we never saw a dinner more handsomely served, and never ate better” (quoted in Edgerton 22–23). Between the twelfth and fifteenth centuries, and to the east of modern Ghana, three Empires (Ghana, Mali, and Songhay) rose and fell. The nineteenth-century Ghana bore resemblance to the old empire not only in wealth, but also in military capability and government bureaucracy. When the Portuguese arrived at Elmina in 1471, they became restive at the sight of the “flecks of gold that sparkled in the streams” (Edgerton 14). Europeans from the Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark, Portugal, Spain, and Prussia in search of gold, ivory, and slaves began to build forts (castles) along the coast. Trade disputes eventually erupted, not only among these European nations, but also between the Ashantis and the Fantis. The Ashantis had previously extended their empire at the expense of other neighboring kingdoms such as the Denkyira, Fante, Dagomba, and Gonja peoples (Edgerton 5). Under auspices of the African Company of Merchants, Thomas Bowdich signed a treaty with King Osei Bonsu, guaranteeing “peace and free trade” (Edgerton 72). The conflicts between the Ashantis and the Fantis stemmed mainly from the latter’s reluctance to grant the Ashantis access to the coast for trade activities. The British took sides with the Fantis (who did not pose any military threat to the British) against the Ashantis. It is worth pointing out that most, if not all, British campaigns in Africa were fought with Black troops from either the West Indian Regiment (British colonies) or Africans from neighboring communities who had been manipulated into fighting on the British side (Edgerton 74). The Wolseley campaign of 1873–1874, on which Henty based By Sheer Pluck, was one of the most thunderous battles between the Ashantis and the British. BY SHEER PLUCK (1884) By Sheer Pluck gives the late-twentieth-century reader a view of how Africans were perceived by Victorians. Henty conveys this through plot, setting, and characterization. Frank Hargate, the protagonist, is a young Englishman, the only son of a military officer and a naturalist who had died fighting in New Zealand when Frank was a little boy.
86 NARRATING AFRICA
Frank loves nature and is determined to take over his father’s occupation later in life. After his mother’s death when he is fifteen, Frank becomes lonely with only his six-year-old sister as companion. He moves to London, and after a few months of job hunting, he meets Mr. Goodenough, an excellent naturalist, who is about to lead an expedition to Africa in search of specimens of natural history. Mr. Goodenough and Frank embark for West Africa, where they eventually take part in the so-called Ashanti Wars of 1873–1874. Frank is, by birth, a gentleman, despite his “want of pocket money” (10). He was never ashamed of his financial situation. Henty wrote: “It was understood… that Frank Hargate’s people were poor,…but I do not believe that a boy is one whit the less liked, or is ever taunted with his poverty, provided he is a good fellow” (9). Henty uses a railway porter Frank meets in London to make his point about the innate gentlemanliness of the British people: “I don’t know how it is, but a gentleman looks like a gentleman, put him in what clothes you will. I could have sworn to your being that if I’d never seen you before. I can’t make it out, I don’t know what it is, but there’s certainly something in gentle blood, whatever you may say about it. Some of my mates are forever saying that one man’s as good as another. Now I don’t mean to say they ain’t as good; but what I say is, as they ain’t the same. One man ain’t the same as another any more than a race-horse is the same as a cart-horse. They both sprung from the same stock, at least as they says; but breeding and feeding and care has made one into a slim-boned creature as can run like the wind, while the other has got big bones and weight, and can drag his two ton after him without turning a hair. Now, I take it, it’s the same thing with gentle folks and working men. It isn’t that one’s bigger than the other, for I don’t see much difference that way; but a gentleman’s lighter in the bone, and his hands and his feet are smaller, and he carries himself altogether different. His voice gets a different tone. Why, Lord bless you, when I hears two men coming along the platform at night, even when I can’t see’em, and can’t hear what they says, only the tone of their voices, I knows just as well whether it’s first-class or a third door as I’ve got to open as if I saw ‘em in the daylight.” (80–81)
Henty’s heroes are all sons of gentlemen and by extension gentlemen themselves. Jeffrey Richards contends that in the nineteenth century, “it was perfectly possible to tell a gentleman by his accent, his physique, his manner, his carriage,” regardless of his clothing. In Henty’s world, he argues, these attributes are not acquired, but in the blood of a select few British men (Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 87
Literature 84). This line of thought is made manifest in the porter’s speech on gentlemanliness, which is usually measured against lowerclass manners and the alleged barbarity of the natives. Stereotypes about Africans begin to emerge as the setting shifts from England to the west coast of Africa. While en route, Frank asks the old naturalist if they will hire men in Sierra Leone for their expedition. To this, Mr. Goodenough responds: “‘Certainly not, Frank. The negroes of Sierra Leone are the most indolent, the most worthless, and the most insolent of all Africa’“ (112). After dismissing the idea that Sierra Leonians could be of any help to them, Mr. Goodenough proceeds to give Frank a brief history of the different ethnic groups in West Africa. He describes what he believes is typical: “They are just children. They are always laughing or quarreling. They are good-natured and passionate, indolent, but will work hard for a time; clever up to a certain point, densely stupid beyond. The intelligence of an average negro is about equal to that of a European child of ten years old. A few, very few, go beyond this, but these are exceptions, just as Shakespeare was an exception to the ordinary intellect of an Englishman. They are fluent talkers, but their ideas are borrowed. They are absolutely without originality, absolutely without inventive power. Living among whites their imitative faculties enable them to attain a considerable amount of civilization. Left alone to their own devices they retrograde into a state little above their native savagery.” (117–18)
Henty himself completes this image: The natives of Africa are capable of great exertion for a time, but their habitual attitude is that of extreme laziness. One week’s work in the year suffices to plant a sufficient amount of ground to supply the wants of the family…. For fifty-one weeks in the year the negro simply sits down and watches his crops grow. To people like this time is of absolutely no value. Their wants are few…. Such people are never in a hurry. To wait means to do nothing. To do nothing is their highest joy. (268–69)
Of course, both Mr. Goodenough and the narrator derive their speeches from the social Darwinism of the nineteenth century. Frank has received his first lesson on the people among whom he is going to live for some time. This lesson is short but effective as indoctrination, and when his mentor tells him they will pay their respects to the king, Frank retorts: “‘Do you mean to say that there is a king in that
88 NARRATING AFRICA
wretched-looking village?’“ To this, Mr. Goodenough replies: “‘Kings are as plentiful as peas in Africa, but you will not see much royal state’“ (122). Frank not only begins to sense his superiority as an Englishman, but he also begins to see himself as the bearer of the torch of enlightenment to the heart of darkness. Later, when Mr. Goodenough and Frank are on one of their expeditions, the latter perceives no physical difference between a Black baby and a monkey. One day, in pursuit of a butterfly, Frank is unable to find his way back to the rest of the group and comes across a group of baboons carrying off a baby which he mistakes for a baboon since the baby is wearing a string of beads, “the only attire which a Negro child wears until it reaches the age often or eleven years old” (156). Even before this incident, Frank, like all his compatriots, feels he is born entitled to the socalled white man’s burden. It is becoming clear that it will be his duty to civilize the brutes of Africa after Mr. Goodenough has given him an account of the lives of the people. His attitude, if he is to believe what the old man tells him, will be condescending, paternalistic, and racist. This condescension was by no means an exclusively British trait. Henty uses, in By Sheer Pluck, the same assumptions that pervaded European and American thought. History informs us that even White abolitionists in the United States, although they were committed to their cause, seldom believed in equality between Black and White; their commitment was founded on the notion that Blacks should be taken care of—a myth that infected both antislavery and proslavery forces. Henty links American and British experience in his novel by introducing the character, Sam, an ex-slave from the American South. After several weeks in Africa, the protagonists meet Sam, the chief of an unusually tidy village. This encounter is used by the author as proof that what Mr. Goodenough has said about “uncolonized” (uncorrupted) Africans is accurate—that only contact with European culture produces “progress:” “[Frank and Mr. Goodenough] were struck as they approached by the far greater appearance of comfort and neatness than generally distinguish African villages. The plots of plantations were neatly fenced, the street was clean and well kept” (172). The reader, as well as Frank, might be surprised since this type of cleanliness has not been attributed to the African. Everything becomes clear, however, when we learn that Sam was African-born some sixty years earlier in this village and then spent many years in slavery. At seventeen Sam was himself involved in the selling of war captives to English, Portuguese, and Spanish slave traders, but after he was cap-
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 89
tured, he was sent to Cuba. In his attempt to escape, he was resold into slavery in Virginia, but eventually reached Canada through the channels of the Underground Railroad. He resided there for ten years. When Frank and Goodenough meet him, he is back in his African village and is a new man. He has abandoned all his African “savagery,” and his English friends are impressed by this progress, seen in the orderliness of his village. Henty, in these scenes, is subtle in letting us see the “superiority” of the British people, using Sam as his mouthpiece. Sam’s life story becomes crucial in supporting the white-supremacy myth that Henty, by using this device, is implicitly promoting: the inferiority of the Black race is not mere prejudice, but an acknowledged fact among Blacks themselves. The ex-slave tells Frank and Mr. Goodenough that his village, like the other villages in that region, was dirty and filthy when he left it more than fifty years ago: ‘My fader was de chief of dis village, just as I am now, but de village was not like dis. It was not so big, and was bery dirty and bery poor, just like the oder nigger villages’ (175). The village Frank and Mr. Goodenough arrived at that day was relatively clean and rich, thanks to Sam. Through his travels— during which he learned hygiene among other things—Sam was able to reform his village. What Mr. Goodenough was telling Frank about how Africans would “retrograde into a state little above their native savagery” (118) when left on their own becomes credible when Frank hears the old ex-slave’s story. While Africa apparently represented retrogression in Henty’s thought, slavery and colonization represented progress; a defense of slavery is a noticeable feature of this author’s fiction, and, as in a number of nineteenth-century novels, that defense finds expression in the plantation myth. By Sheer Pluck is imbued with this myth—this idealization of master and slave relations. Sam tells Mr. Goodenough and Frank that slavery was not that bad in Cuba, provided one had a good master (which was usually the case, in Sam’s opinion). Few masters were cruel, says Sam, but slaves were lazy: ‘Dose who work well not bad treated, plenty ob food and a piece of ground to plant vegetables and a raise fowl for ourselves’ (179). Sam was never physically abused by his master because he was not lazy, but when his master went home to Spain, the overseer made life difficult for everybody on the plantation: ‘Den de massa go home to Spain, and leab overseer in plantation. Bery bad man dat. Before, if nigger work well he not beaten. Now he beaten wheder he work or not’ (180). Blaming the
90 NARRATING AFRICA
overseer for the brutality on plantations was characteristic of this period; if there happened to be any cruelty, either the slaves were lazy (as was considered natural with the Negro) or the overseer was meanspirited. Besides keeping the white-supremacy myth alive, this lengthy American interlude in By Sheer Pluck is a means to justify a wrong done to a people. Slavery had been abolished prior to the publication of Henty’s book; yet it was used in the narrative to suggest that whites were the people chosen to enlighten an inferior race. It is not surprising that Henty’s works were popular in the United States. The exslave, Sam, compares slavery in the United States with that of Cuba, and his comparison makes the American plantation almost Edenic: “Well, Sir, work bery much de same on plantation in Virginia and Cuba, but the slabe much merrier in ‘Merica…Slabes all treat bery kind, work not too hard. At night dance and sing bery much…. Sam jus’ as happy as man could be. Sometime when der an party, Sam come into the house to help at the table, dat how Sam know how to do tings proper.” (186)
Sam had only two criticisms of Southern slavery: masters left their plantations in the hands of overseers, and slave families were often broken up when plantations changed hands or suffered bankruptcy. But his general assessment was positive. He explains: “Me trabel a good deal, and me tink dat no working people in de world are so merry and happy as de slabe in a plantation wid a good massa and missy. Dey not work so hard as de white man. Dey have plenty to eat and drink,…when dey are sick dey are taken care ob, when dey are ole dey are looked after and hab noting to do. I have heard people talk a lot of nonsense about the hard life of de plantation slabe. Dat not true, sar, with a good massa.” (189)
But if the plantation was the best place for Blacks why did Sam prefer to come back to Africa when he had the choice to live as a free Black in the United States? There are two ways to answer this question. We can argue that either the plantation happiness Sam talks about is a myth, or, as Henty would like us to view it, Sam decided to come back home to Africa in order to impart to his people the knowledge and civilization he had acquired. In the latter case, Sam can be equated with a White missionary going to Africa on his “civilizing” mission;
TO AFRICA WITH HENTY 91
the only difference here is that the missionary role is played by an African among his peers. This brings us to the issue of colonization and repatriation of the emancipated Blacks both in England and the New World. Just after the Civil War in the United States, in 1865, a shipload of Bajans emigrated to Liberia under the auspices of the American Colonization Society (Martin 9). Sierra Leone was appropriated in order for England to relocate its ex-slaves. Henty might have been a colonization advocate in that he has Sam come back to Africa ‘to teach dese poor niggers here de ways ob de white man,…de ways ob de Lord’ (204). The irony is that the ways of the White man—equated here with the ways of the Lord—tend to be the enslavement of other races. Jeffrey Richards, in his critique of the Henty novels about Africa, interprets the interlude about Sam as a case of British ambivalence. On the one hand, Britain took great pride in its own abolition of slavery in the empire and its support of American abolitionists. On the other hand there was an assumption of Black inferiority and of the need for constant supervision of Blacks (Richards, Imperialism and Juvenile Literature 94–95). Henty’s abrupt switch to a proslavery position, says Richards, was probably the result of Britain’s new status in Africa as a colonial power, and the developing class hierarchy within England as industrialization accelerated (95). But whatever the reasons, Henty’s position in the 1800s seems clear. He returns repeatedly in Sam’s story-within-a-story to the alleged benefits of the American slave system, and in his novel With Lee in Virginia (1890), he concludes with an explicit, unambivalent political message: A few [liberated slaves] wandered away, but their places were easily filled; for the majority of the freed slaves very soon discovered that their lot was a far harder one than it had been before, and that freedom so suddenly given was a curse rather than a blessing to them. (384)
Besides his usefulness in Henty’s appraisal of slavery, Sam provides a means of commenting upon African personality, of perpetuating another invalid assumption. When Sam returns to his village, he persuades the people to keep the village clean by promising them goods he has obtained in the New World. Like a child, the African does not want to take any responsibilities unless he or she is promised gifts! Europeans have always claimed that Black people lacked responsibility and initiative. This can be seen in the manner in which Frank
92 NARRATING AFRICA
interacts with the Ashantis. In By Sheer Pluck, Frank and Mr. Goodenough were guests of the Ashanti king before the war broke out. When Mr. Goodenough dies, Frank is held captive by the Ashantis and forced to fight on their side against the British. It is then that he becomes friend and adviser of the Ashanti war general Ammon Quatia. The Ashantis are taken by surprise by the Fantis one day when everybody is asleep, including the general. When the guards wake up, they are confused and do not know what to do. It is Frank who helps save the troops: ‘The guards had been standing irresolute, not knowing what side to take, but the example of the young Englishman decided them. They fired their muskets…’ (195). Frank, who had never had any military training and was, at that time, about seventeen, takes the initiative in driving the enemy away. This is another indication in the novel that Blacks need supervision, since whatever their age, they are childlike and incompetent. Frank’s astuteness, on the other hand, so impresses the Ashanti war general that the youth is given a valuable gold necklace. The Gold Coast was attractive to many European colonial forces because of its wealth in gold, and this was one of the driving forces behind the atrocities perpetrated against Africans and other peoples. This quest for riches is obliquely presented in the story. After Frank and the British troops have driven the inhabitants from an Ashanti town, they proceed to search all the houses, especially those of the chiefs. They conclude that the Ashantis have no knowledge of comfort or luxury (“the houses were filled with dust and litter”), but they nevertheless find valuable things to appropriate: gold masks, silver plates, gold cups. Moreover, “it was believed that a large amount of treasure was located at the kings tombs, and the prize-money would not have been unwelcome” (250). While the wealth of Africa was coveted, so-called backwardness was derided. For example, lack of mechanical know-how was a topic introduced into By Sheer Pluck as comic relief. This subject was developed into a slapstick scene of the type already well known to the nineteenth—and early—twentieth-century audiences through vaudeville and the minstrel theater. Mr. Goodenough promises the denizens in an African village that the White man will show them strange things if they can control their excitement and screams. At night Mr. Goodenough show