Minorities and Education in Multicultural Japan
This volume examines how Japan’s increasingly multicultural population...
290 downloads
1768 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Minorities and Education in Multicultural Japan
This volume examines how Japan’s increasingly multicultural population has impacted on the lives of minority children and their peers at school, and how schools are responding to this trend in terms of providing minority children with opportunities and preparing them for the adult society. The contributors focus on interactions between individuals and among groups representing diverse cultural backgrounds, and explore how such interactions are changing the landscape of education in increasingly multicultural Japan. Drawing on detailed micro-level studies of schooling, the chapters reveal the ways in which these individuals and groups (long-existing minority groups, newcomers, and the ‘mainstream Japanese’) interact, and the significant consequences of such interactions on learning at school and the system of education as a whole. While the educational achievement of children of varying minority groups continues to reflect their places in the social hierarchy, the boundaries of individual and group categories are negotiated by mutual interactions and remain fluid and situational. Minorities and Education in Multicultural Japan provides important insights into bottom-up policy-making processes and consciously brings together English and Japanese scholarship. As such, it will be an important resource for those interested in education and minority issues in Japan. Ryoko Tsuneyoshi is a Professor of comparative education at the Graduate School of Education, University of Tokyo. Kaori H. Okano is an Associate Professor in the School of Social Sciences, La Trobe University, Australia. Sarane Spence Boocock is an Emeritus Professor of sociology in the Department of Sociology and the Graduate School of Education at Rutgers University.
Minorities and Education in Multicultural Japan An interactive perspective
Edited by Ryoko Tsuneyoshi, Kaori H. Okano and Sarane Boocock
First published 2011 by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016 Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2010. To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk. © 2011 editorial selection and matter, Ryoko Tsuneyoshi, Kaori H. Okano and Sarane Boocock. Individual chapters, the contributor. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Minorities and multiculturalism in Japanese education: an interactive perspective edited by Ryoko Tsuneyoshi, Kaori H. Okano and Sarane Boocock. p. cm. 1. Children of minorities – Education – Japan. 2. Multicultural education – Japan. 3. Multiculturalism – Japan. I. Tsuneyoshi, Ryoko Kato. II. Okano, Kaori H. III. Boocock, Sarane Spence. LC3737.J3M56 2010 371.82900952 – dc22 2009051975
ISBN 0-203-84919-1 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN: 978–0–415–55938–6 (hbk) ISBN: 978–0–203–84919–4 (ebk)
Contents
List of illustrations Acknowledgements Notes on contributors 1
Introduction: an interactive perspective for understanding minorities and education in Japan
vii ix xi
1
KAORI H. OKANO AND RYOKO TSUNEYOSHI
PART I
Long-existing minorities 2
Long-existing minorities and education
27 29
KAORI H. OKANO
3
The schooling of buraku children: overcoming the legacy of stereotyping and discrimination
44
SARANE SPENCE BOOCOCK
4
Schooling and identity in Okinawa: Okinawans and Amerasians in Okinawa
77
NAOMI NOIRI
5
Ethnic Koreans in Japanese schools: shifting boundaries and collaboration with other groups
100
KAORI H. OKANO
PART II
‘Newcomer’ groups 6
The “newcomers” and Japanese society RYOKO TSUNEYOSHI
127 129
vi 7
Contents The ‘new’ foreigners and the social reconstruction of difference: the cultural diversification of Japanese education
149
RYOKO TSUNEYOSHI
8
Schools, communities, and ‘newcomer’ children: a case study of a public housing complex
173
MUTSUMI SHIMIZU
9
(Mis)managing diversity in non-metropolitan public schools: the lack of state-sponsored support for ‘newcomer’ children
191
CHRIS BURGESS
10
The kikokushijo: negotiating boundaries within and without
213
MISAKO NUKAGA AND RYOKO TSUNEYOSHI
11
Concluding remarks: implications for educational research and reform
242
SARANE SPENCE BOOCOCK
Appendix 1 Article 26 of the Constitution of Japan
259
Appendix 2 The Primary School Course of Study Guide 2008 (Shōgakkō Gakushū Shidōyōryō Kaisetsu, Sōsokuhen)
260
Appendix 3 Guide for foreign students to start school (Procedures for entering Japanese schools)
261
Index
263
Illustrations
Figures 1.1 1.2 1.3 6.1 6.2 8.1
8.2 10.1 10.2 10.3 A3.1
Map of Japan and Taiwan, with cities discussed in this book Registered foreigners by nationality, 1989–2008 The number of foreign national students at school, 1991–2006 Number of pupils/students by mother tongue, 1999–2008 Number of children who require instruction in Japanese per school, 1999–2008 The number of participants in the ‘International elective’ subject by ethnic background, Shimofukuda Junior High School, 2000–05 Stand-By-Me newsletter, March 2008 Changes in the number of Japanese school-age children abroad, 1971–2008 Japanese school-age children abroad by place of residence and type of school attended, 2008 Returnees at Hayama Elementary by place of residence abroad, 2000 Guide for foreign students to start school (procedures for entering Japanese schools)
7 9 10 137 137
179 184 214 221 225 261
Tables 1.1 2.1 2.2 3.1 7.1 7.2
The estimated populations of the groups studied in the book Ainu children’s retention rate to upper secondary schools compared with their non-Ainu cohort, 1972–2006 Ainu children’s retention rate to universities compared with their non-Ainu cohort, 1979–2006 Preschools and elementary schools observed, 1995–96 The number of returnees (kaigai kikoku jidō seito) by ward, Kawasaki City, 2001 The number of foreign children by ward, Kawasaki City, 2002
6 34 34 55 159 159
viii Illustrations 7.3 8.1 9.1 9.2
The number of foreign children who require instruction in Japanese language by ward, Kawasaki City, 2002 The ‘International elective’ curriculum, Shimofukuda Junior High School, 2001 Registered foreigners in Japan and Yamagata by number, 1996–2006 Foreign students who need Japanese instruction, showing mother tongue and school level, Yamagata Prefecture, 2007
160 180 197 198
Acknowledgements
The idea of this volume arose when we organised a panel at the Association of Asian Studies annual meeting in Chicago in 2001, entitled, ‘Diversity and the experience of minorities and foreigners in Japanese schools: Toward a multicultural framework’. Gerald LeTendre chaired the panel, and Hidetaka Shimizu was our discussant. Since then we have moved far from our initial interpretation of education in multicultural Japan, as we have continued to research in our specific areas and to discuss our emerging interpretations. Initially, we had identified specific minority groups, laying out their characteristics, and analysed multicultural Japan in terms of the sum of these groups and ‘the Japanese’, as was customary in previous research. We have since moved towards a ‘multicultural interactive framework’. We have also welcomed into our discussion additional contributors who have extensive fieldwork experience in diverse settings. We would like to thank the many educators, administrators and students, from both minority and majority backgrounds, who have responded to each of the chapters. We also extend our appreciation to the following funding sources: Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research (C) 21530873; the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science and the Ministry of Education (Tsuneyoshi); the Japan Foundation Fellowship (which enabled Okano to research at Kobe University for a year) and research grants from La Trobe University (Okano); and the Rutgers Graduate School of Education (Boocock). Last but not least, we would like to thank our editor at Routledge, Stephanie Rogers, and Mark Selden for their assistance in bringing this book to fruition. Ryoko Tsuneyoshi (in Tokyo, Japan) Kaori H. Okano (in Melbourne, Australia) Sarane Boocock (in New Brunswick, USA)
Notes on contributors
Sarane Spence Boocock is an Emeritus Professor of sociology in the Graduate School of Education and the Department of Sociology at Rutgers University. Previously, she was a research scholar at the Russell Sage Foundation, taught at Yale University, University of Southern California, and Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and was a Fulbright Research Scholar in Japan. Her recent research and publications focus on the sociological study of children and childhood, changing patterns of family life, and cross-national comparisons of early childhood care and education. Chris Burgess completed his Ph.D. at Monash University, Melbourne, in March 2004. His thesis, entitled ‘(Re)constructing identities: international marriage migrants as potential agents of social change in a rapidly globalising Japan’, looked at how seventeen women of foreign origin grappled with and made sense of their identities after migrating to Yamagata, northeast Japan. He is currently Associate Professor at Tsuda College, Tokyo, where he teaches Japanese and Australian studies. His research focuses on migration, globalisation and multiculturalism in contemporary Japan. Naomi Noiri is an Associate Professor in the faculty of Law and Letters, University of the Ryukyus, Okinawa, Japan. She researches education for minority students in Japan, Amerasians in Okinawa, and life history interviews in ethnic studies. Her major publications include: ‘Two worlds: the Amerasian and Okinawan’ in Social Process in Hawaii: Uchinanchu Diaspora. Vol.42 (2007), University of Hawaii. Misako Nukaga is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Psychology and Education, Wako University, Tokyo, Japan. Her research interests include multicultural education policy and practices, childcare in migrant families, and children’s identity formation in multicultural social spaces. She has published articles in the International Journal of Japanese Sociology and Journal of Contemporary Ethnography based on her fieldwork at multi-ethnic schools in Japan and America. She recently completed her dissertation in sociology at UCLA on transnational practices among Japanese families in Los Angeles.
xii
Contributors
Kaori H. Okano, Ph.D., is an Associate Professor/ Reader in the School of Social Sciences, La Trobe University, Melbourne, Australia. She researches education and social inequality, multiculturalism, transitions to adulthood, and the impact of globlisation on education. Her major publications include: Young women in Japan: transitions to adulthood (Routledge, 2009), Language and schools in Asia (2006), Pendidikan modern Jepun: Ketaksmaan dan Kepelbagaian (ITNMB, 2004), Education in contemporary Japan (with M.Tsuchiya, Cambridge University Press, 1999) and School to work transition in Japan (Multilingual Matters, 1993). Mutsumi Shimizu is an Associate Professor in the teacher-training course, Tokyo University of Science, Chiba, Japan. She researches the process of adaptation of ‘newcomer’ children in Japan. Her major publications include: Nyūkamā no Kodomotachi (2006), Gaikokujin Seito no tame no Karikyuramu (with Kojima, 2006) and Icho Danchi hatsu! Gaikokujin no kodomotachi no chosen (with Stand-By-Me, 2009). Ryoko Tsuneyoshi is a Professor of comparative education at the Graduate School of Education, University of Tokyo. She has a Ph.D. in sociology from Princeton University. Her research includes cross-national comparisons of schooling, multicultural education, educational reform and fieldwork in educational settings. Major publications include: The Japanese model of schooling: comparisons with the United States (RoutledgeFalmer, 2001), Kodomotachi no mitsu no ‘kiki’ (The three ‘crisis’ of children, Keiso Shobo, 2008) and ‘Kyoiku hokai’ saisei e no puroguramu (Combatting educational failure, Tokyo Shoseki, 1999).
1
Introduction An interactive perspective for understanding minorities and education in Japan Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi
Culturally diverse groups are part of the landscape of all contemporary nationstates. We are now well aware that Japan has been a multi-ethnic and multicultural entity since pre-modern times, as studies have challenged the popular image of homogeneity and advanced what might be called a ‘multicultural Japan’ thesis (see, for example, Lie 2001). In the last two decades in particular, Japanese society has become increasingly diverse, with the arrival of guest workers and various types of foreigner. The aim of this book is to examine the ways in which the rapid diversification of Japanese society has affected the lives of minority children and their peers at school. In the face of this diversification, how are schools providing children with opportunities and preparing them for the adult world?
Beyond the ‘multicultural Japan’ thesis The image of Japan as culturally homogeneous (tanitsu bunka) has been promoted in a wide range of publications and media coverage. It is reflected in Ruth Benedict’s popular book, The chrysanthemum and the sword (1946), in other international bestsellers about Japanese society (Nakane 1970; Vogel 1979), and in statements by Japanese politicians. Scholarship in recent decades has been busy shattering the myth of Japanese homogeneity. A notable example can be seen in the crusade targeting the so-called nihonjinron – a controversial genre depicting what constitutes ‘Japaneseness’. The nihonjinron literature has been attacked by its critics for its alleged assumptions that Japanese society is homogeneous and unique (Mouer and Sugimoto 1986; Befu 2001; Sugimoto 2009). Today, we might even venture to say that the opposite is in vogue, that is, that Japan is a multicultural society, and such assertions find many supporters inside Japan. Challenging the image of Japanese homogeneity, English-language books on multicultural Japan have tended to focus on certain minority groups or on describing Japanese society as consisting of certain relatively independent minority/foreigner groups. Early works of the former category include pioneering work on the buraku people (De Vos and Wagatsuma 1967; Shimahara 1971, 1984) and Koreans (Mitchell 1967; Lee and De Vos 1981). Since the 1980s, studies have enabled us to further understand specific groups, both in an individual sense
2 Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi (see, for example, Shimahara 1971; Siddle 1996; Hicks 1997; Ryang 1997; Weiner and Hanami 1998; Fukuoka 2000; Roth 2002; De Carvalho 2003; Douglas and Roberts 2003; Goodman et al. 2003; Hein and Selden 2003) and collectively (including Mouer and Sugimoto 1986; Maher and Macdonald 1995; Maher and Yashiro 1995; Denoon et al. 1996; Lie 2000; Noguchi and Fotos 2001; Douglas and Roberts 2003; Weiner 2008; Wills and Murphy-Shigematsu 2008). Some works have focused specifically on education (Rohlen 1981; Hawkins 1983; Chapter 4 of Okano and Tsuchiya 1999). Inside Japan, too, while the post-war myth of homogeneity remains influential in popular and official thinking, many scholars and educators no longer find the ‘multicultural Japan’ thesis novel. There are now a fair number of books about multicultural education (tabunka kyōiku) or multicultural coexistence (tabunka kyōsei) (Kobayashi and Ebuchi 1985; Okuda and Tajima 1991, 1993; Watanabe 1995; Hirota 1996; Tanaka 1996; Nakajima 1998; Oguma 1998; Ehara 2000; Ebuchi 2001; Shimizu and Shimizu 2001; Shimizu 2006). There are also studies introducing multicultural education, multilingual education, intercultural education, and multiculturalism/multilingualism in other places, such as the United States (Hirasawa 1994; Tanaka 1996), Canada, Australia (Sekiguchi 1988; Nishikawa et al. 1997), Europe and elsewhere (Sakuma 1993; Hatsuse 1996; Amano 1997). Multicultural education is also discussed in relation to international students (Kurachi 1998) and to wider issues of the internationalization of Japanese society (Tsuneyoshi 1998, 2002). From our analysis of the existing literature on minorities and education in Japan, however, we take two observations as our point of departure. First, there is the tendency to discuss each minority group as a separate entity, placed individually or collectively in dichotomy to the ‘majority Japanese’. This contrast is based on characteristics such as nationality, ‘ethnic background’, ‘caste’, ‘race’, or any combination of them. We suggest that such a dichotomy is increasingly inadequate for understanding the present realities of Japanese society and education. There are now greater internal variations within and between minority/foreigner groups, and the boundaries are contested, as we shall show later in this chapter. This brings us to the second point. The existing literature does not pay sufficient attention to interactions among individuals of diverse cultural backgrounds and inter-group multicultural interactions. Such interactions, latent and manifest, influence how people identified as members of a certain group are treated, as well as the strategies adopted by those individuals who are so categorized. In a period of increasing diversification, boundaries of difference are being constructed and reconstructed through interaction. As Japan’s multicultural landscape becomes more complex as a result of recent immigration, there is growing need to focus on the interactive processes of the changing landscape (Lie 2000; Chan-Tiberghien 2004; Graburn et al. 2008; Willis and Murphy-Shigematsu 2008). One consequence of rapid change is that we often find it difficult to identify minority individuals and groups in terms of the categories already available in the public discourse. Some local governments have responded by creating new terms, such as ‘children with foreign roots’ (to refer to Japanese nationals of
Understanding minorities and education
3
foreign descent, newcomers/old-timers who have taken up Japanese citizenship, foreign nationals). Others choose to redefine the existing terminology and categorization. For example, the term ‘zainichi Korean’ is a legal category that denotes Korean nationals residing in Japan as a result of Japanese colonization of the Korean Peninsula, and was initially used as such. However, in the last two decades, many of them have acquired Japanese nationality, either through naturalization or as a result of mixed parentage. In spite of giving up Korean nationality, many still use the term as an identity category, rather than as a legal term. In view of this, many scholars in Japan and elsewhere follow the inclusive use of the term zainichi Korean.1 Advancing beyond the ‘multicultural Japan’ thesis, we focus on interactions between individuals of diverse cultural backgrounds and among multiple groups. With this emphasis on interactions both visible and latent, we try to de-emphasize a dichotomous framework of minorities versus the ‘majority Japanese’ (for example, a dichotomy between Koreans and Japanese and between burakumin and nonburakumin) and examine how such interactions are shaping the emerging landscape of multicultural Japan. We pose three questions at the outset: 1
2 3
How and why do individuals and groups representing diverse cultural backgrounds interact with one another in a rapidly diversifying Japanese society? To what extent has the diversification of Japanese society changed the lives of minority and majority peoples, and the relations among them? How well does the Japanese education system prepare all children to benefit from, and contribute to, Japanese society?
We uncover an interface among individuals of minority/foreign backgrounds in order to explore how such direct and indirect interrelations have shaped the context in which these groups exist. Before explaining what we mean by multicultural interactions, we clarify some of the main points that this book addresses.
Minorities, culture and education The minorities/foreigners that this book concerns are popularly defined with reference to the ‘majority Japanese’ (an elusive construct, which we discuss below). The popular understanding assumes that minorities and foreigners possess a ‘culture’ rooted in certain characteristics different from the ‘majority Japanese’, and they are considered to be marginalized because of the differences, although the nature of the marginalization and other accompanying features varies greatly (according to, for example, nationality, ethnicity, socio-economic background, physical characteristics). ‘Culture’ does not constitute some essential and primordial disposition, but rather shared ways of interpreting the world that are constantly created and modified in response to changing circumstances.
4
Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi
The boundaries of groups with distinctive cultures are created and redrawn – by the groups themselves in search of what they see as potential benefits, and/or by others (including by governments and (non-governmental organizations (NGOs)) – in changing circumstances. The term ‘newcomers’ emerged to refer to a wide range of peoples who began to arrive in the 1980s, in order to distinguish them from other, long-existing minority groups. A previously more uniform minority group, ‘ethnic Koreans’, now contains important boundaries within it, in terms of Japanese citizenship and whether or not they are ‘newcomers’. Japanese returnee children who have spent several years abroad may be a transient ‘cultural’ group, because, despite facing initial alienation and marginalization owing to their unfamiliarity with Japanese society, many of them settle into mainstream society within several years, assisted by well-resourced parents. The ‘majority Japanese’, against whom minorities/foreigners are often juxtaposed and defined, is an arbitrary and elusive concept. This becomes obvious when we learn that degrees of ‘Japaneseness’ can be measured by various factors, none of which hold up under scrutiny (see Sugimoto 2003). For example, Japanese returnees are likely to be considered closer to the majority Japanese than monolingual, Japanese-speaking, Japan-born, fourth-generation non-citizens of Korean descent; and the latter tend to be considered closer to the majority Japanese than newly arrived, Portuguese-speaking South Americans of Japanese descent or mixed parentage. Many would disagree with this view, and there would be even less consensus on how indigenous peoples such as Ainu are considered in their proximity to the ‘majority Japanese’. We can perhaps visualize the gradations of ‘majority Japanese’ on a continuum, with one end signifying those who would be popularly considered ‘the majority’: able, heterosexual persons born to middleclass parents who are Japanese nationals of ‘Japanese descent’ in mainland Japan. That said, and fully aware of the limitations, we use the term ‘majority Japanese’ as popularly, if vaguely, understood. For this reason, we maintain quotation marks throughout the volume. Used without quotation marks in this book, the Japanese refers to Japanese nationals. The minorities that this volume studies all possess (or claim and are regarded to possess) certain ‘cultures’ or characteristics, and are marginalized from the mainstream society, although the extent and duration of the marginalizations vary. They include: indigenous peoples such as the Ainu, Okinawans,2 descendants of Koreans and Chinese who arrived in Japan during colonial times, buraku people (descendants of former outcast groups), Amerasians (children of American soldiers and local women), South East Asian refugees, immigrants and guest workers who arrived from many Asian countries since the 1980s, so-called returnees from China (women and orphans of Japanese families who left north-eastern China at the end of the war and their descendants), so-called Japanese returnees (children of Japanese families who have returned from a long-term stay overseas) and South Americans of Japanese descent. Those from Europe and North America are not discussed in this book. This is because their children commonly attend international schools rather than mainstream schooling, which is the focus of this study.
Understanding minorities and education
5
These distinctive cultures are popularly considered to derive from race, ethnicity and caste, in combination with socio-economic status. In keeping with current usage, we make the following distinctions on the basis of race, ethnicity, caste and socio-economic status, though it should be noted that these terms have been variously defined and that the boundaries between them are ‘not nearly as sharp and fixed as many people assume’ (McLemore 1994: 11). Race refers more or less to ‘a person’s or a group’s physical heritage, of which skin color, facial features and other characteristics of physical appearance are major indicators’, though which characteristics are noticed and how they are interpreted depends on the context; ethnicity refers mainly to a person’s or a group’s sociocultural heritage, based on such characteristics as common or shared national origin, language, religion, dietary preferences, dress and manners, and other traits that denote a common ancestry; caste refers to membership of a politically created group that does not necessarily have a distinctive physical or sociocultural heritage; outcast groups are defined by dominant members in the society as inferior, even sub-human, and are likely to be ostracized through enforced residential, occupational and social segregation; socio-economic status refers to a person’s or a group’s location in the social hierarchy, generally based on income, amount and type of education, and occupational level and prestige (Boocock and Scott 2005: 148–9, 163–4). As in the discussion about culture, we learn from the constructivist discussions that these categories are fluid, changeable and multilayered (Hall 1996; Jenkins 1997; Barth 1998 (1969); Brubaker and Cooper 2006; Nukaga 2008). The process of boundary-making is inevitably intertwined with social categorization, interpersonal and inter-group interactions, and power. We do not, however, dispense with the terms ethnicity, race, caste and identity altogether. This is because they are useful for understanding the diverse experiences of schooling by minority children, which are strongly affected by structural factors. The educational experiences and outcomes of children of various minority groups have been influenced by, and reflect, their places in a social hierarchy in which resources are unequally distributed (Okano and Tsuchiya 1999; Warikoo and Carter 2009). Keeping these studies of differential educational outcomes in mind, we look at how boundaries are obscured through interactions between individuals of varying backgrounds, and how diversity is created and evolves. Several chapters (Chapters 7, 8 and 10) focus squarely on the social context rather than on any specific group, because the actors from different groups intersect in complex ways. The groups studied in this book and their estimated sizes are provided in Table 1.1. The relevant locations of these groups are shown on the map (Figure 1.1). The data and their complexity are discussed in detail in the chapters that follow. Some of these groups include both Japanese and non-Japanese nationals. While government statistics of non-Japanese nationals comprising these groups are reasonably accurate, those for group members having Japanese nationality are not. This is because the Japanese government does not document information on the descent (heritage) of its citizens. Once a Korean, Chinese or Brazilian national takes up Japanese citizenship by naturalization or
Exact number unknown (3.93–5.70 million or moreo)
Exact number unknown (12,000 returned in 2008m) 2,152,973p
952,595 (including 316,967 Brazilians and 202,592 Filipinos)
593,489 (2007)
606, 889 (2007)
Non-Japanese citizens living in Japana
Notes: a Japan-Hōmushō-Nyūkoku-Kanrikyoku, Japan (2008). b Hokkaidō-chō. (2006) Ainu seikatsu jittai chōsa. Available online at: www.pref.hokkaido.lg.jp/ks/sum/somuka/ainu/jittai.htm (accessed 1 June 2008). c Sjoberg (1993: 152) d Okinawa-ken (2008). e Taira (1997: 142) estimates Okinawans in other parts of Japan to be 300,000. f Chapter 4 in this volume. g Takagi (1991: 281). McLauchlan (2003: 24–30) explains the uncertainty in various statistics regarding buraku people. The government estimates their population to be 1.5 million while the Buraku Liberation League claims 3 million. h Duan, Yaozhong (2005:132). The figure estimated by the Chinese language newspaper with the highest circulation in Japan, Chūbun Dōhō (6 September 2007) is the minimum 100,000. Qiu (2010) estimates, based on Hōmushō statistics, that 73,084 Chinese nationals took up Japanese citizenship in 1989–2008. i Qiu’s (2010) estimation is based on Kōseirōdōshō jinkōdōtai tōkei figures. Also see Qiu (2005). j The figure of 1.2 million is provided by Zenkoku Zainichi Chōsenjin Kyōiku Kenkyūkai, Kyoto (1993: 7). k The estimation by Zainihon Chōsenjin Jinken Kyōkai (2009:72–4), based on Hōmushō data and Kōseirōdōshō jinkkōdōtai tōkei (1 May 2009). Mindan’s figure for the same period is 296,168 naturalized (Mindan, 2010). l Ibid. m MEXT (2010). CLARINET e yōkoso. Available online at www.go.jp/a_menu/shotou/clarinet/220/00/htm. (accessed 10 May 2010). This is the MEXT figure for school-age children who returned during the 2008 school year from abroad, but the total kikokushijo population depends on its definition (see Chapter 10). n Based on the figures in this table, the total number of minority group members would be 5.78 million (minimum) to 7.85 million or more (maximum). Sugimoto (2010: 7, 191–5) suggests the figure to be 6 to 7 million as a conservative estimate, while emphasizing that the number would expand or contract depending upon whether minority groups are defined inclusively or exclusively. Lie (2001: 4) estimates the figure to be 4–5 million. o These minimum and maximum figures are based on the addition, respectively, of all the lowest and highest numbers in the column, Japanese citizens. p The number does not include unregistered foreign nationals.
Totals
n
Children of mixed descent where one parent is a Japanese citizen Japanese returnees
Registered foreigners – excluding Chinese and Koreans Naturalized Japanese citizens
Ethnic Koreansj
Amerasians in Okinawa People of buraku descent Ethnic Chinese
Exact number unknown (133,684 in 1952–2008, excluding ethnic Chinese and Koreansl) Exact number unknown
Exact number unknown (24,000 self-categorized in Hokkaidob; 300,000 in Japanc) Exact number unknown (1.37 million in Okinawa-prefectured; 300,000 in other parts of Japane) Exact number unknownf Exact number unknown (estimated 1.5–3 million)g Exact number unknown (88,123 naturalized 1972–2003h; 55,708 children of Chinese-Japanese marriages 1986–2005i) Exact number unknown (320,232 naturalized 1952–2008; 263,996 Korean-Japanese marriages 1955–2007; 133,253 children of Korean-Japanese marriages 1985–2007k)
Ainu (indigenous)
Okinawan
Japanese citizens
Minority groups
Table 1.1 The estimated populations of the groups studied in the book
Understanding minorities and education
7
Figure 1.1 Map of Japan and Taiwan, with cities discussed in this book
marriage, he or she disappears into the category of ‘Japanese’, with no further reference to ethnic heritage. Children of mixed descent who have one parent who is a Japanese national gain Japanese citizenship at birth, but their numbers are not documented either. The children with dual nationalities have to make a choice at the age of twenty-one (as the Japanese government does not allow dual nationalities).
The actors in this book What we call long-existing minorities (as distinct from newcomers) in this book include Ainu, Okinawans, buraku people, and ethnic Koreans and Chinese whose ancestors arrived before the end of the Second World War. These groups were mainly created by the deliberate policies of the state (e.g. the caste system,
8 Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi colonization and forced labour) and have been structurally marginalized in Japanese society. Although granted Japanese nationality, they held an inferior status to the mainstream Japanese, which restricted their entitlements. An exception is the ‘overseas Chinese’, who arrived to set up their own businesses. These days, the members of these groups are outwardly indistinguishable from the ‘majority Japanese’ in terms of physical appearance, language use and social interaction. All groups were subject to a pre-war schooling system that imposed assimilation. This led many to abandon their own language and to internalize the dominant Japanese view that they are inferior (Okano and Tsuchiya 1999: 110–40). Postwar ‘democratic’ schooling did not recognize the special needs of these groups, except to provide extra resources to buraku people and the Ainu so that they could catch up with the majority Japanese (See Chapter 2). Below, we briefly explain the various categories of minorities that this book examines, as detailed discussion follows in the overview chapters (Chapters 2 and 6). The first identifiable populations are the indigenous peoples of Hokkaido (the Ainu or Moshir), and the Okinawans. They were annexed in the late nineteenth century (Murphy-Shigematsu 2002) and now reside in their regions of origin and as a diaspora in metropolitan cities. The post-war US occupation of Okinawa until 1972 and the continuing existence of US bases since Okinawa’s return to Japan created another minority – the children of US servicemen and local women, popularly called Amerasians (see Chapter 4), who have counterparts around the world. Also discussed are those who are commonly called the ‘oldcomer’ ethnic Koreans and Chinese. They are the descendants of former colonial subjects who were brought or came voluntarily to Japan, some in pursuit of further education and employment, others as forced labour, during Japan’s colonial occupation of those territories. An interactive perspective, however, leads us to emphasize the diversity that is contained within a single category of ethnicity, as well as the variations in interaction patterns that surround it. The so-called ethnic ‘newcomer’ Koreans or Chinese who came to Japan for economic reasons in recent years as guest labourers, as well as those who married Japanese, are indicative of the diversification of ethnic categories that is occurring in Japan. With the increase in citizenship in recent years, there are said to be almost as many Japanese nationals of Korean (or mixed Korean) descent as Korean residents. The identification of nationality with ethnicity, a long-held assumption in post-war Japan, is therefore contested. Internal differences among those of Korean descent are also observed in terms of generation, affiliation with North and South Korean organizations, regions of residence and social class. As the official categorization continues to be based on nationality (not ethnicity), the number of Korean nationals has declined in recent years. The percentage of registered foreigners who are Korean nationals declined from 50 per cent in 1994 to less than 28 per cent in 2007 (see Figure 1.2), but the number of Japanese nationals of Korean descent increased in the same period. Another major category is the buraku people, descended from the outcasts of the feudal system. The institutional caste system was abandoned in the late
Understanding minorities and education
9
Figure 1.2 Registered foreigners by nationality, 1989–2008 Source: Immigration Bureau of Japan, Ministry of Justice, Japan (2009) Heisei 20-nenmatsu genzai ni okeru gaikokujin tourokusha tōkei ni tsuite. Online. Available: www.moj.go.jp/PRESS/090710-1/ 090710-1.html (accessed 10 September 2009).
nineteenth century, but prejudice and marginalization persist in employment and marriage. Civil rights movements initiated by buraku organizations have resulted in improvements in terms of living conditions and educational achievements of their young. Buraku activism has served as one prototype of human rights-oriented reform, as has the Korean movement in Japan (see Chapter 3). In addition to these long-existing minorities, we also discuss the new inflows that have diversified Japanese society since the 1980s. With the expansion of Japanese companies abroad, increasing numbers of Japanese families worked abroad and eventually returned with their school-age children, who became the kikokushijo (Japanese returnees). They are discussed in Chapter 10, alongside the ‘new’ foreigners. Returnees from China (war-displaced Japanese and their families from China) and Indo-Chinese refugees have formed small but identifiable groups in certain localities, which have often become increasingly multicultural with the emergence of new entrants. Japan’s economic boom also brought inflows of foreign labour from Asia and South America. A turning point for one group of foreign labourers was the implementation of the revised 1990 immigration law, which opened the door for descendants of Japanese migrants to South America to work in Japan legally as unskilled labour. South Americans make up the fastest growing group of ‘newcomers’. The South American Nikkeijin are the descendents of Japanese who left for South America in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, backed by a government policy to alleviate Japan’s overpopulation at the time. The revision of the immigration law, allowing these South Americans to work legally as unskilled labour, created an exception to the general rule that the Japanese
10 Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi government does not officially accept unskilled migrant workers. Japanese language classrooms have been erected for the Nikkeijin, but low achievement, dropping out and other educational problems are fast becoming marked in the Nikkei community (see Chapter 6). The major characteristic of ‘new’ foreigners is that they have come mostly as voluntary labour or immigrants, rather than populations recruited through direct colonization – though there are plenty of cases of exploitation, by brokers and employers. They are also more likely to come and go than the long-existing minorities. Some ‘newcomers’ remain in Japan permanently, including the Indo-Chinese refugees; others originally intended to return to their home countries with substantial savings after a few years working in Japan, but have ended up being long-term residents. Many are new to the country and do not speak Japanese. Thus, the service provided by schools to this population tends to focus on language assistance and adaptation to Japan. Again, the figures broken down by nationality obscure the diversity within a single nationality category. Figure 1.3 shows the number of foreigners in government schools; this number includes Japan-born ‘oldcomers.’ This brief illustration of minority diversity presents a picture of uncertain, complex and shifting categories. These categories and boundaries are constructed and negotiated by different agents, from authoritative institutions such as the national government at one end to the minorities (the categorized) and laypersons at the other, leaving local governments and NGOs somewhere in between, each with different degrees of power with which to impose their own categorizations on public discourse.
Figure 1.3 The number of foreign national students at school, 1991–2006 Note: Data were as of 1 May in each year. Bold and italicized numbers indicate the total numbers of students in each year. Source: Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology, Japan (2009) Kōritsugakkōni shūgaku suru gaikokujin jidōseito no suii. Online. Available: www.mext.go.jp/b_menu/shingi/chousa/ shotou/042/houkoku/08070301/009/002.htm (accessed 10 September 2009).
Understanding minorities and education
11
The national government employs two main categorizations, based on (a) citizenship/nationality (and the legal status of residents) and (b) the requirement of assistance in Japanese language instruction. By providing figures on the number of registered foreigners (Figure 1.2) and the number of foreign children in government schools (Figure 1.3) through its classification scheme, the national government has framed the discussion on diversity in schools. Some local governments have chosen to create other categorizations, such as long-term residents (rather than permanent residents) and children with foreign roots (for Japanese citizens of ‘foreign’ descent, including fourth-generation ethnic Koreans). Or, at the school level, some educators use the term ‘students in the international class’, for example, to refer to Japanese returnees and ‘newcomers’. Non-government organizations may also create a category simply through the organization’s name. These terms have become official to differing degrees, in the sense that they become legitimate in the public’s perception. For example, the expression tabunka kyōsei (multicultural coexistence) emerged among residents in Kobe after the 1995 earthquake, when volunteers and activists discussed how to assist ethnic minority survivors; and an NGO, which started as the Foreigners’ Earthquake Information Center (Gaikokujin Jishin Jōhō Sentā), adopted the name Tabunka Kyōsei Sentā (Multicultural Coexistence Centre) (Takezawa 2008: 32–5). There are currently many organizations that have tabunka kyōsei in their names.3 The term tabunka kyōsei is now widely adopted in local and national government documents.4 However, exactly what is meant by the term tabunka kyōsei varies and is dependent on the interpretations of respective organizations. ‘Japanese’ laypersons use lay categories to refer to minority groups such as ‘residents in the eastern part of XYZ housing complex’ or ‘people from over there’ (mukō no hito). And, of course, the categorized themselves negotiate their own boundaries, as groups and as individuals. With all these agents involved, categorizations remain situational, but the negotiations about categorization do not occur on a level playing field. There are always differences in power. We see in the following chapters how this process plays out in schools.
Multicultural education and multicultural society in the Japanese context What is the dominant Japanese understanding of multicultural education? Although it is naturally diverse, as is the case elsewhere, we can identify some trends by looking at the terminology used in the nation-wide discourse. After briefly discussing multicultural education in the anglophone West, we analyse the Japanese debate in the global context. So-called multicultural education emerged when minorities questioned white, mainstream hegemony in anglophone industrialized countries (Banks 1994, 1997, 2001; Gollnick and Chinn 1998). ‘Multicultural’ education replaced the hitherto prevalent approaches of ‘assimilation’ and ‘integration’ for dealing with diverse student populations, because assimilation and integrative approaches promoted cultural adaptation to the mainstream while remaining unconcerned about the mono-cultural nature of the curriculum. Cultural pluralism, which underpins multicultural education, on the other hand, celebrates diversity as a positive asset
12 Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi for education of the young as a whole and advocates maintenance of the diverse cultures and heritages of different groups. This includes the addition of diverse minority perspectives and content to curriculum and after-school clubs, and the active promotion of teachers of diverse ethnic backgrounds. Under the broad banner of multicultural education, approaches to address diverse student populations varied in different countries (see Grant and Lei 2001). In all cases, support for multicultural education initially came from ground-level practitioners and minorities who questioned the fairness of an assimilationist approach, and it was subsequently taken up by local authorities. Canada and Australia are widely considered to have been most interventionist, in that federal legislation was enacted to enforce cultural pluralism in education. Over time, multicultural education has evolved into different forms, reflective of local context, and has come under closer scrutiny. Vocal critics of cultural pluralism and multicultural education have come from two directions. On one hand, conservative critics (for example, Schlesinger, 1992) have expressed concern that the ‘racial/ethnic’ elements of the curriculum have gone too far, to the extent of destabilizing national unity and distracting students from ‘core studies’. On the other hand, radical (that is, anti-racist) critics have accused multicultural education of not going far enough, as it leaves unchanged the place of the dominant culture in the curriculum, along with the structurally unequal relations within and outside schools (see, in the UK, Troyna 1993; Gillborn, 1995; in the US, Giroux 1993; McLaren 1995; Apple 1996; in Australia, Rizvi 1993). They charge, for example, that ‘benevolent multiculturalism’ advocates respect for the lifestyles of minority children but limits their access to opportunities (Gibson 1984). Worse still, it is said simply to appease minorities, in a form of palliative care, while doing little to enable minority children to learn to negotiate with dominant groups and to succeed in mainstream society (Bullivant 1986: 42). These radical critics’ arguments are persuasive, but they rarely spell out concrete alternatives to the practice of liberal multicultural education. Critiques of liberal multicultural education have evolved into debate about ‘critical multicultural education’, which continues to-date (Kanpol and McLaren 1995; May 1999; Ladson-Billings and Gillborn 2004). Multicultural education is a complex concept that is multidimensional and dynamic and involves a diverse range of practices specific to local circumstances. It cannot be expected to deliver the desired outcome in the short term and instead is likely to evolve in many different ways (Nieto 1999). These debates illuminate two central elements of multicultural education. One is the celebration of cultural diversity in a society and globally. The other is the pursuit of equity by individuals of diverse cultural backgrounds and the promotion of universal human rights. Understanding of equity varies, however: some argue for equal educational opportunity, while others go further, seeking changes to the existing system in order to achieve equal educational outcomes. These two elements of multicultural education are relevant to understanding what we see in Japan. As is explained later, the long-existing minorities initially demanded opportunities for better life chances in order to escape from discrimination (the
Understanding minorities and education
13
equity and human rights elements), while education in districts with many ‘newcomers’ initially tended to emphasize the celebration of cultural difference (the former of the central elements). Current practice in districts across Japan encompasses both elements, but initial differences remain observable in terms of emphasis. Japanese terminology for multicultural education can generally be divided into three clusters. The first cluster centres on ‘international understanding education’ (kokusai rikai kyōiku), the umbrella term for education related to intercultural/ multicultural issues in Japan. This is used in such a flexible way today that it can contain almost anything. One line of practice with a long history, which we call ‘Olympic-style international understanding education’, adheres to the framework of the nation-state. In this context, inter-‘national’ understanding is just that – promoting understanding between Japanese and people of other nations, Olympic style, by learning about other nations, engaging in international exchange and inviting foreign visitors to talk about their country. This framework assumes that the ‘foreigners’ and ‘the Japanese’ are mutually exclusive. In general, the ‘foreigners’ whom Japanese nationals should get to know and coexist with in international society are assumed to be either in their own countries, or visiting Japan temporarily as guests. The framework of the nation-state assumes internal homogeneity within the country, and the perspective is outward looking. This line of thought is not the one we assume in this book, although ‘Olympicstyle’ international understanding has its strengths. Even less central to our discussions are the types of international understanding activity that focus on the acquisition of English. A prime example is the English activities (eigo katsudō) that have become very popular in Japanese primary schools with the introduction of the integrated studies period, which are practised as part of ‘international understanding’ (kokusai rikai). Besides, the assumption of internal homogeneity in the ‘Olympic-style’ international understanding has long been challenged in districts with a concentration of long-existing minorities or foreigners, such as the buraku population, Ainu and Koreans. Backed by activism, such districts remind the Japanese of something that most of them may be unaware of – the existence of minorities and foreigners within Japan who are permanent members of Japanese society. The second cluster of terminologies related to multicultural education includes ‘egalitarian/equity education’ (dōwa kyōiku), ‘emancipation education’ (kaihō kyōiku), ‘ethnic education’ (minzoku kyōiku) and the umbrella term, ‘human rights education’ (jinken kyōiku). These have emerged in districts where many longterm minorities reside. Activists in these districts have all advocated strong anti-discrimination messages and argued for the protection of human rights. Over the years, human rights education has to come to include other groups that suffer discrimination, for example, the disabled and women (Sakai et al. 1998; Ebuchi 2001). These categories favour education with a strong emphasis on the social equity and human rights elements of multicultural education. The third cluster of terms relates to the academic translation of multicultural education, tabunka kyōiku, and multiculturalism, tabunkashugi. We emphasize
14 Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi that these terms are academic constructions that scholars in the field have employed (see Kobayashi and Ebuchi 1985; Nakajima 1998; Ehara 2000; Watado and Kawamura 2002). Japanese practitioners, schools, local governments, communities and NGOs prefer different terminology, such as ‘multicultural coexistence’ (tabunka kyōsei), ‘society for multicultural coexistence’ (tabunka kyōsei shakai) and ‘education for multicultural coexistence’ (tanbuka kyōsei kyōiku), when discussing internal diversity and the need to accommodate returnees and foreigners within their schools and communities. ‘Multicultural coexistence’ is most often adopted by schools or districts that have large populations of overtly different cultures. Typically, the new multicultural districts in this category have a concentration of so-called ‘newcomers’, such as foreign workers, Indo-Chinese refugees and spouses of Japanese. Some of these districts have little history of human rights activism by long-existing minorities. Districts with long-existing minorities have also taken up the terminology of multicultural coexistence (see Chapter 7). The three clusters of terms are not necessarily mutually exclusive. The relative emphasis of these three approaches varies, depending on districts and communities. For example, buraku activism, the zainichi Korean movement and the antidiscriminatory human rights messages they convey intersect with the calls for multicultural coexistence actively pursued in districts experiencing inflows of ‘newcomers’. Researchers of long-existing minorities/foreigners have made efforts to link, for example, dōwa education and multicultural education as human rights education (Sowa 2000), or to place the ‘oldcomer’ Koreans at the centre of concepts of multicultural education in Japan (Nakajima 1993). Indeed, education for multicultural existence in districts such as Osaka and Kawasaki (see Chapters 2 and 7), which have active buraku and/or Korean movements, follows this pattern, because the long-existing minorities/foreigners have set the tone. The chapters in this book each focus on how diversity is played out and evolving in key districts. In a book such as this, which examines the evolving landscape of diversity in Japan, it is especially important to come down to the local level. Compared with states that have adopted a multicultural framework at the national level, the Japanese education system has shown relatively little interest in addressing the needs of a diverse student population at the national level. It is the local governments, education boards, individual schools and communities that have taken initiatives to manage and benefit from diverse populaces, particularly in the areas where large minority/foreign populations live (see Chapter 7). Prefectural, metropolitan and municipal government policies for the education of minority groups attest to this (Okano 2006), as do the individual chapters to follow. It is at this level that visions of homogeneity have given way, and various actors are interacting daily, constructing a complex picture of multicultural Japan.
An interactive perspective Multicultural interactions occur both between individuals of diverse groups and between groups. In areas where there are few people from the same group,
Understanding minorities and education
15
interactions in the community or the school are more likely to be understood as personal affairs. In those districts with a concentration of people associated with a certain minority category, there is likely to be a more group-based set of interactions. The visibility of multicultural interactions varies from the most direct and overt to the most indirect and latent. Interactions may be explicit and direct, as in the case of direct, face-to-face interactions. They may be explicit but indirect, as in the case of activists for ‘newcomer’ rights modelling themselves on the longexisting minorities’ activism, without having much direct interaction with the latter. Or multicultural interactions may be latent and indirect, in a manner that even the players themselves are not conscious of, seen, for example, in local policy implementation. Multicultural interactions occur at diverse sites. To facilitate our analysis, we tentatively distinguish between three types of multicultural interactive space: (A) spaces unintended for such interactions but where, nonetheless, interactions occur; (B) spaces deliberately designed for such interactions; and (C) policy spaces. In Type A spaces, although not created for multicultural interactions, shared needs, recategorizations and the like bring members of different groups together, most often by the increase or incorporation of a new minority group into a space that was formally created for and occupied by another. There are many examples of this. Japanese as a second language (JSL) classes in schools were initially created for Japanese returnees, but now serve two culturally different groups – Japanese returnees from local schools abroad and ‘newcomer’ foreign children with little Japanese language proficiency – if both are in the same school. The Japanese returnees were the first population to emerge as a target of remedial assistance and ‘adaptation’ (later to be replaced by a less assimilationist approach), but the model was later applied to the ‘newcomer’ children, albeit with an emphasis on the acquisition of Japanese language. Though these groups are dissimilar, they meet and interact in a common institutional space as a result of their overlapping needs and a recategorization that combines both ‘newcomers’ and returnees under the umbrella category of ‘internationalization’ (see Chapters 6 and 10). Another example is local schools in neighbourhoods with public housing complexes (kōei jūtaku). These complexes tend to have a mixture of culturally different, low-income populations. When a certain ethnic/national group becomes concentrated in a particular public housing complex, ethnic shops and restaurants tend to sprout. These spaces also start to meet the ethnic needs of the new entrants. We see this across Japan. Icho Housing, a prefectural housing complex in Kanagawa prefecture near a former settlement centre for refugees, is home to a large number of Indo-Chinese refugees, Chinese returnees and Nikkeijin (see Chapter 8). In Toyohashi City (Aichi prefecture), the Iwata Public Housing Complex is home to many Brazilians, who arrived to take up unskilled jobs in the automobile industry. In Ikebukuro in central Tokyo, many ‘newcomers’ reside in old wooden apartments that used to house single Japanese workers (Okuda and Tajima 1991). The Shinryōdai prefectural housing complex in Kobe City has a concentration of Chinese returnees, leading a local school to offer bilingual
16 Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi JSL-Mandarin classes. In the eastern parts of Osaka prefecture, numerous small factories and cheap housing (both private and public) have attracted a large number of Indo-Chinese refugees, Chinese returnees and South East Asian guest workers. Such residential compositions are subsequently reflected in the increased number of minority children in local government schools. In a similar manner, free, community-based, adult Japanese literacy classes offer spaces where old minorities meet the ‘new’ minorities/foreigners, and ‘new’ minorities/foreigners meet each other. Districts with a concentration of Koreans have long offered Japanese literacy classes to first- and second-generation Koreans in their old age. Although many elderly Koreans speak Japanese fluently, some lack reading and writing skills as a result of leaving school prematurely owing to poverty and bullying. As the population of ‘new’ foreigners surged, these classes often experienced increased enrolments of these ‘newcomers’, such as Asian brides wanting to learn daily Japanese, as is the case in Kawasaki (see Chapter 7). Recognizing different needs, the public centre in Kawasaki separated classes and extended their resources. Where resources are abundant, the services can expand. Where they are lacking, the ‘newcomers’ can be regarded as competitors for limited resources. ‘Newcomers’ not only take places in Japanese literacy classes (shikiji gakkyū) initially set up for the Koreans, but also in similar classes for the other long-existing minority, the buraku population, many of whose members also missed out on formal schooling in their youth (Akuzawa and Enoi 1992: 131–2). We see a similar pattern at the evening junior high school, initially established for Japanese who were forced, by poverty, to abandon compulsory schooling for immediate employment. Enrolments went down as the society became gradually more affluent, but the school has now become a multicultural site comprising such diverse populations as returnees from China, elderly, firstgeneration Koreans and young Japanese students with day-school attendance problems. For the ‘newcomers’, the institution offers a place to study Japanese. For non-attending Japanese students (futōkō), it provides a second chance to receive schooling. Though their purposes differ, both come from the margins of Japanese education. Type B interactive space is that deliberately designed for multicultural interaction. Some spaces had such intentions from the start; others, although initially created for one particular group, later reinvented themselves to include other groups and now see the target population as being multicultural. Most players in such spaces are non-profit organizations (NPOs), NGOs and local civil movements. For the NGOs operating in districts where diversity is already a given condition, the target population might be multicultural from the start. Such organizations often have names such as ‘centre for multicultural coexistence’, which immediately signals a multicultural focus. The annual nation-wide meetings of ethnic schools, the Multi-ethnic Education Forum (Tabunka Kyōsei Foramu), which began in 2005, for example, targeted all minority groups from the outset. International schools in Japan might be said to offer such a space from their inception and differ from mainstream schools and schools associated with a certain ethnicity or nationality. Some schools, such as the Tokyo Metropolitan
Understanding minorities and education
17
Kokusai High School, have been established in order to foster multicultural interaction. In many cases, however, local activist organizations and NGOs in support of a specific group interact with those of another group or decide to absorb the interests and concerns of another group by expanding the boundaries of its target population. This can result in empowerment of the organization or, alternatively, create internal conflicts. We see examples in the teachers’ professional organization for the education of Koreans deciding to take up the concerns of the ‘newcomers’ and renaming itself by replacing ‘Koreans’ with ‘foreign nationals’ (see Chapter 5); or in the Okinawan civil movement, which started in order to obtain Japanese citizenship for Amerasian children (who had held no nationality without paternal recognition). It later gained wider support, in particular from those who married foreign nationals (including ‘oldcomer’ Koreans and Chinese), and became a civil movement to replace the system of patrilineal inheritance of Japanese citizenship to children with a bilateral inheritance (see Chapter 4). One of the impacts of the revised Nationality Law was a sudden increase in Japanese nationals of (mixed) Korean and ‘newcomer’ descent. Buraku activism, which has waged the most powerful challenge to mainstream Japanese society to date, influenced how Korean activism took up their human rights issues (see Chapters 3 and 5). As established, long-existing, minority activism focused on human rights, rather than cultural diversity, the centres of such activism (including Kawasaki and the Kansai region) responded to ‘newcomers’ with a human rights-based discourse. This contrasts with most cases, where the discourse on the ‘newcomers’ tends to revolve around social problems (such as high Asian foreigner crime) or in education, intercultural themes of getting to know a different culture rather than human rights (see Chapter 10). This process of a space expanding its target population and becoming more inclusive is also observed in institutional spaces now designated for multicultural interaction. The local junior high school described in Chapter 8 created a multicultural space (class) in order to bring together foreigners (and children with foreign parents) and ‘majority Japanese’ in the same classroom. First, it brought Indo-Chinese and ‘majority Japanese’ together, and later diversified to include South Americans and returnees from China. Schools are designated by the locality or the ministry to cater for diverse student populations. These schools and others have special spaces for these students (for example, kokusai kyōshitsu) and develop the kind of curriculum that capitalizes on a diverse student population for the benefit of all students. Many metropolitan governments (including Kawasaki, Osaka, Kobe and Hiroshima) run a ‘centre for coexistence’ (a community centre designed to promote the harmonious coexistence of foreign nationals and Japanese). Many of them were initially created in response to the activism of long-existing minority groups, but later adapted to accommodate the needs of ‘newcomers’ as well (see Chapter 7). Type C interactive space is policy-making and implementation, where policies regarding minorities are addressed at national, local and school levels. Here, too, we see similar processes of an initial policy expanding its target population. The
18 Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi policy framework guiding the education of Japanese returnees – language acquisition, adapting to Japan and, later, encouraging the child to maintain positive aspects acquired abroad – served as a major model to accommodate the returnees from China, as well as the JSL population. The Ministry of Education’s (MEXT) amended regulations for non-attending students later began to be applied to Amerasian children who refused to attend mainstream schools, in favour of the Amerasian school, an alternative school established by the community, which now allows Amerasian children to complete compulsory schooling without attending a mainstream school (see Chapter 4). Another central policy interaction involved the MEXT’s 2003 controversy over treatment of graduates of ethnic schools. Initially, it announced that it would allow respective national universities the discretionary power to grant eligibility for university entry to graduates from a list of ethnic or special schools (including international schools and some Brazilian ethnic schools), but excluded North Korean schools, despite their being the largest in number. The MEXT later included them, after professional organizations, intellectuals and the North Korean schools protested this decision. At the local government level, policies for one group expanded, or served as a reference for another. For example, policies regarding the education of Korean residents began to include ‘newcomer’ children, in the name of ‘foreign nationals’. The local policies were initially created for Koreans, based on those already existing for burakumin in Osaka in the 1970s. The human rights education units within local education boards collectively address the issues of buraku and Korean children (see Chapter 5). The nature of interactions can vary; individuals and groups may interact superficially without many mutual interests. This can be the case when people of diverse backgrounds first find themselves together in a place for a shared purpose, for example, at a local seminar on schooling. After the seminar, they may not meet again. Continuous interactions in a space can lead individuals and groups to cooperate and collaborate when they perceive a benefit in terms of instrumental gains and emotional support. On the other hand, interactions may involve conflictual relations, for example, when minority groups compete among themselves for limited resources. We are interested to see how the spaces of multicultural interactions are evolving. What are the consequences for those involved? How does adopting a multicultural, interactive perspective assist us to understand Japanese society? Specific questions that we ask are: What are the policies and practices regarding respective minority groups at the national, local and school levels? How has the education system served minority/foreign children, by promoting their life chances on one hand and cultural maintenance on the other? What are the sites where groups interact with one another? How, and by whom, are these sites chosen or created? In what ways do multicultural actors interact on the continuum of conflict– indifference–solidarity? What is the impact of such interactions on group boundarymaking, group and individual identities, and access to life chances (or power)? Schooling, as the centre of multicultural interplay for children, provides a special opportunity to explore these questions. Public schooling is an arena in which
Understanding minorities and education
19
interactions between multicultural actors inevitably occur, as individuals from diverse cultural backgrounds are brought together artificially, and where families, educators and communities debate what is best for children. People of minority backgrounds may live quite separately from the ‘majority Japanese’ and those of other minority backgrounds, and they may rarely encounter each other directly, but schools bring the different populations together. Moreover, schools are designed to ‘educate’ in a group situation and, as such, necessitate intersection between what are considered the boundaries of groups. As sites of this interaction, schools are subject to diverse expectations. At the national policy level, the state is not responsible for providing education for foreign nationals (although this has been challenged by civil activist groups, on the basis of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child) (see Chapters 2, 6 and 8). From the position of the central government, remote from the everyday activities of the classroom, the distinction between a Japanese national and a ‘foreigner’ may be apparent. However, for educators, once foreign children are admitted to school, they are part of a class and in this sense are equal members requiring their attention. Thus, teachers encountering such diversity are led to respond to the individual needs of these populations at the grass-roots level (see Chapter 8). We have tried to make distinctive contributions in this book. First, we adopt a multicultural interaction framework to understand changes taking place in Japanese society that increasingly cannot fully be understood in isolation. Second, this book documents some of the initial stages of a society responding to a rapidly changing, multicultural landscape in certain locations. Many anglophone, post-industrial countries experienced this process earlier in history, when circumstances differed greatly from the present globalized world. Third, in examining what occurs at the local grass-roots level, the book provides insights into bottom-up policy-making processes and complements the existing literature of educational policy-making at the centre (see, for example, Schoppa, 1991; Hoods, 2001). Fourth, the book consciously brings together English and Japanese scholarship in the area and tries to bridge the gap between them. Lastly, our focus, schooling, is an extremely important arena for studying these processes because of the unique place it occupies in society. Schools are one of the few public institutions and spaces where children of various backgrounds in a neighbourhood are together on a daily basis for an extended period of time, involving all children of compulsory education age. It is where young people are socialized and prepare themselves for the adult world. Schools are expected to provide all children with opportunities to develop their potential. What schools teach is widely considered ‘legitimate’ by the public. What occurs in schools is expected to reflect the society and is a prism of social change. It is a place where many types of adult have an invested interest as parents, as members of the community, as policymakers and as educators. Thus, almost any problem pertaining to children is translated into an education problem. Our focus on the interplay among members of different groups, the reconstruction of boundaries and the consequences for individuals in Japanese schooling assists us to understand
20
Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi
the multicultural changes occurring in contemporary Japanese society. With this focus, we explore concrete multicultural approaches that schools can pursue to help maximize the benefits that minority children gain from education.
Contributing chapters The book is divided into two parts. Part 1 covers the long-existing minority/ foreigner groups, and Part 2, ‘newcomer’ groups. Part 1 begins with Okano’s overview of the long-existing minorities in Japanese society. The chapters that follow it each provide detailed analysis of a particular minority group, with a view to how that group is situated in relation to other minority/foreigner groups and to Japanese society in this period of increased diversification. Specifically, in Chapter 3, Boocock focuses on the burakumin and their endeavours to end discriminatory practices through education. Such dōwa education efforts have paved the way for other human rights education. In Chapter 4, Noiri shows how Amerasians in Okinawa (in a sense, double minorities, as Okinawa itself is marginalized in Japanese society) have organized to better their education. This has had an impact on other unlikely groups, such as non-attending students and those children of mixed marriages, on a larger scale. In Chapter 5, Okano describes how the Korean movement for equality in educational opportunity has evolved, benefitting from the buraku movement, while at the same time providing an existing framework in some districts for ‘newcomers’. The framework within which the ‘oldcomer’ Korean population has been discussed – human rights, lack of citizenship and cultural maintenance in particular – provides a model for understanding the ‘newcomers’. The other framework is the discourse of ‘internationalization’ alongside the returnees in Part 2. In Part 2, Tsuneyoshi presents an overview of ‘new’ minorities/foreigners in Chapter 6. In Chapter 7, she takes the example of Kawasaki, an urban district in Japan with a concentration of Koreans that is experiencing so-called internal internationalization with the emergence of the returnees and the ‘newcomers’, and she shows how the increase in diversity is pressuring existing boundaries of difference and how the society is responding. In Chapter 8, Shimizu presents a case study of one of the most famous ‘newcomer’ districts for Indo-Chinese refugees. Using an action-research approach, she illustrates how the successions of ‘newcomers’ – Indo-Chinese refugees, returnees from China and the Nikkeijin – have created a mutually dependent, multicultural landscape. In Chapter 9, Burgess studies an example of a well-known initiative in Japanese rural communities to recruit Asian wives. Ironically, such organized recruitment has ‘internationalized’ the most unlikely places – farm communities that are losing their youth to the cities. In Chapter 10, Nukaga and Tsuneyoshi examine the Japanese returnees in relation to other minorities. This group, though not a minority in the popular sense of the word, is deliberately included in this volume as it is a representative group associated with ‘internationalization’ in the Japanese context (others being the international students and the ‘newcomers’) and has served as a major reference point for how the other ‘international’ groups are addressed.
Understanding minorities and education
21
The chapters in this volume collectively present a vision of Japanese society that is not a sum of different groups situated against the ‘majority Japanese’, but a vision in which such groups interact both directly and indirectly, constantly rewriting their boundaries and jointly constructing an evolving multicultural Japan. We offer this vision, drawing on our detailed observations of the microlevel practices of schooling and the surrounding districts that children experience daily. It is these children who will be Japan’s next generation of adults.
Notes 1
2
3
4
For example, see Harajiri (1998: 5); Park (1999: 236); Kim (1999:6); Hester (2008:145); and John Lie (2008:169). This is partly because the terms ‘Korean–Japanese’ (kankokukei/ chōsenkei nihonjinn) and ‘Japanese national Korean’ (nihon kokuseiki kankokujin/ chōsenjin/ korian) have not yet gained popular currency. A more generic term, zainichi gaikokujin (foreign residents in Japan), is a legal and official category denoting all foreigners residing in Japan; but in this case the term is not inclusive of those who have gained Japanese citizenship. The notion of indigenous peoples remains tenuous. So does who constitutes Japan’s indigenous peoples and ‘Japanese’ (Oguma 1998). In 2008, the Japanese government officially acknowledged as indigenous the Ainu people, who resided in Hokkaidō before the modern Japanese state annexed the land. This recognition came after a series of Ainu lobbying and subsequent to its alliance with the international organization of indigenous peoples. To date, Okinawans do not hold such an official status. Kodomo Tabunka Kyōsei Center (its English name is Multicultural Children’s Centre): www.hyogo-c.ed.jp/~mc-center/; Tabunka Kyōsei Sentā (Tokyo, Kyoto, Osaka, Hyogo): www.tabunka.jp/; Shinjuku Tabunka Kyōsei Puraza (its English name is Shinjuku Multicultural Plaza): www.shinjukubunka.or.jp/tabunka/japanese/index.html For example, see www.pref.gunma.jp/cts/PortalServlet;jsessionid=8ED5C954911 E273E03FA8FFC260B1EAA?DISPLAY_ID=DIRECT&NEXT_DISPLAY_ID=U000 004&CONTENTS_ID=4170 (Gunma prefecture), and www.soumu.go.jp/menu_news/ s-news/2006/060307_2.html (Sōmu-shō).
References Akuzawa, M. and Enoi, Y. (1992) ‘Uchinaru kokusaika to kyōiku jissen no kadai (internal internationalization and educational practice)’, in T. Sakai (ed.) Kokusai Rikai to Kyōiku Jissen: Ajia, uchinaru kokusaika, kyōshitsu (International Understanding and Educational practice), Tokyo: Emti Shuppan. Amano, M. (1997) Doitsu no Ibunkakan Kyōiku (intercultural education in Germany), Tokyo: Tomagawa Daigaku Shuppan. Apple, M. (1996) Cultural politics and education, Buckingham: Open University Press. Banks, J. A. (1994) Multiethnic education: theory and practice, 3rd edn, Boston: Allyn and Bacon. –––– (1997) Educating citizens in a multicultural society, New York: Teachers College Press. –––– (2001) Cultural diversity and education: foundations, curriculum and teaching, Boston: Allyn and Bacon. Barth, F. (ed.) (1998 (1969)) Ethnic groups and boundaries: the social organization of culture difference, 2nd edn, Long Grove, Ill: Waveland Press. Befu, H. (2001) Hegemony of homogeneity: an anthropological analysis of nihonjinron, Melbourne: Trans Pacific Press.
22 Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi Benedict, R. (1946) The chrysanthemum and the sword: patterns of Japanese culture, Boston: Houghton Mifflin. Boocock, S. S. and Scott, K. A. (2005) Kids in context: the sociological study of children and childhoods, Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield. Brubaker, R. and Cooper, F. (2006) ‘Beyond “identity”’, Theory and Society, 29: 1–47. Bullivant, B. (1986) ‘Towards radical multiculturalism: resolving tensions in curriculum and educational planning’, in S. Modgil, G. Verma, K. Mallick and C. Modgil (eds), Multicultural education: the interminable debate, Lewes: Falmer Press. Chan-Tiberghien, J. (2004) Gender and human rights politics in Japan: global norms and domestic networks, Stanford: Stanford University Press. De Carvalho, D. (2003) Migrants and identity in Japan and Brazil: the Nikkeijin, London: Routledge. Denoon, D., Hudson, M., McCormack, G. and Morris-Suzuki, T. (eds) (1996) Multicultural Japan: palaeolithic to postmodern, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Douglas, M. and Roberts, G. (eds) (2003) Japan and global migration: foreign workers and the advent of a multicultural society, Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press. Duan, Y. (2005) ‘Henyōsuru nihon no kajinshakai’ (‘Changes in the Chinese-Japanese community in Japan’), in Yamashita, K. (ed.), Kajin shakai ga wakaru hon (The ChineseJapanese community in Japan), Tokyo: Akashishoten. Ebuchi, K. (ed.) (2001) Kyōsei no Jidai o Ikiru (In the age of coexistence), Tokyo: Hōsō Daigaku Kyōiku Shinkō-kai. Ehara, T. (ed.) (2000) Tabuka Kyōiku no Kokusai Hikaku (International comparisons of multicultural education), Tokyo: Tamagawa Daigaku Shuppan. Fukuoka, Y. (2000) Lives of young Koreans in Japan, Melbourne: Trans Pacific Press. Gibson, M. (1984) ‘Approaches to multicultural education in the United States: some concepts and assumptions’, Anthropology and Education Quarterly, 15: 94–119. Gillborn, D. (1995) Racism and antiracism in real schools, Buckingham: Open University Press. Giroux, H. A. (1993) Living dangerously: multiculturalism and the politics of difference, New York: Peter Lang. Gollnick, D. M. and Chinn, P. C. (1998) Multicultural education in pluralistic society, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill, an imprint of Prentice Hall. Goodman, R., Peach, C., Takenaka, A. and White, P. (eds) (2003) Global Japan: the experience of Japan’s new immigrant and overseas communities, London: RoutledgeCurzon. Graburn, N. H. H., Ertl, J. and Tierney, R. K. (eds) (2008) Multiculturalism in the new Japan: crossing the boundaries within, New York and Oxford: Bergahn Books. Grant, C. A. and Lei, J. L. (eds) (2001) Global constructions of multicultural education: theories and realities, Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Hall, S. (1996) ‘Introduction: who needs “identity”?’, in S. Hall and P. du Gay (eds), Questions of cultural identity, London: Sage. Harajiri, H. (1998) ‘Zainichi’ toshiteno Korian (Koreans as ‘zainichi’), Tokyo: Kōdansha. Hatsue, R. (ed.) (1996) Esunishiti to Tabunkashugi (Ethnicity and multiculturalism), Tokyo: Dōbunkan. Hawkins, J. N. (1983) ‘Educational demands and institutional response: dōwa education in Japan’, Comparative Education Review, 27(2): 204–26. Hein, L. and Selden, M. (eds) (2003) Islands of discontent: Okinawan responses to Japanese and American power, Lanham, MD: Rowan & Littlefield. Hester, J. T. (2008) ‘Datsu Zainichi-ron: An emerging discourse on belonging among ethnic Koreans in Japan’, in N. H. H. Graburn, J. Ertl and R. K. Tierney (eds), Multiculturalism in the new Japan: crossing the boundaries within, New York: Berghahn Books.
Understanding minorities and education
23
Hicks, G. (1997) Japan’s hidden apartheid: the Korean minority and the Japanese, London: Ashgate. Hirasawa, Y. (1994) Amerika no Tabunka Kyōiku ni Manabu (Learning from multicultural education in America), Tokyo: Meiji Tosho. Hirota, Y. (ed.) (1996) Tabunkashugi to Tabunka Kyōiku (Multiculturalism and multicultural education), Tokyo: Akashi Shoten. Hokkaidō-chō (2006) Ainu seikatsu jittai chōsa (Socioeconomic Survey of Ainu People), vol. 2008, Sapporo: Hokkaidō-chō. Hoods, C. (2001) Japanese education reform: Nakasone’s legacy, London: Routledge. Japan-Hōmushō-Nyūkokukanri-kyoku (2008) Heisei 19-nendomatsu Genzai ni okeru Gaikokujin Tourokusha Tōkei ni tsuite (Statistics on Registered Foreigners in 2007), Tokyo: Hōmushō. Jenkins, R. (1997) Rethinking ethnicity: arguments and explorations, London and Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Kanpol, B. and McLaren, P. (eds) (1995) Critical multiculturalism: uncommon voices in a common struggle, Westport, CT: Bergin & Garvey. Kim, T. Y. (1999) Aidentitī Poritikusu o koete: Zainichichōsenjin no esunishitī (Beyond identity politics: the ethnicity of Korean residents in Japan), Kyoto: Sekaishisōsha. Kobayashi, T. and Ebuchi, K. (1985) Tabunka kyōiku no hikaku Kenkyū: kyōiku ni okeru bunkateki dōka to tayōka (A comparative study of multicultural education), Tokyo: Kyūshū Daigaku Shuppankai. Kurachi, A. (1998) Tabunka kyōsei no kyōiku (Education for multicultural coexistence), Tokyo: Keisō Shobō. Ladson-Bellings, G. and Gillborn, D. (eds) (2004) The RoutledgeFalmer reader in multicultural education, London: RoutledgeFalmer. Lee, C. and De Vos, G. (eds) (1981) Koreans in Japan, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Lie, J. (2001) Multiethnic Japan, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Lie, J. (2008) ‘The end of the road? The post-zainichi generation’, in S. Ryang and J. Lie (eds), Diaspora without homeland: being Korean in Japan, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. McLaren, P. (1995) Critical pedagogy and predatory culture, New York: Routledge. McLauchlan, A. (2003) Prejudice and discrimination in Japan: the buraku issue, Lewiston, New York: Edwin Mellen Press. McLemore, S. D. (1994) Racial and ethnic relations in America, 4th edn, Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon. Maher, J. and Macdonald, G. (eds) (1995) Diversity in Japanese culture and language, London: Kegan Paul International. Maher, J. C. and Yashiro, K. (eds) (1995) Multilingual Japan, Clevedon, UK: Multilingual Matters. May, S. (ed.) (1999) Critical multiculturalism: rethinking multicultural and antiracist education, London: Falmer Press. Mindan (Korean Residents Union in Japan) (2010) Tōkei. Online. Available: www.mindan. org/toukei.php (accessed 13 May 2010). Mitchell, R. H. (1967) The Korean minority in Japan, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Mouer, R. and Sugimoto, Y. (1986) Images of Japanese society, London: Kegan Paul International.
24 Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi Murphy-Shigematsu, S. (2002) Amerasian no Kodomotachi: shirarezaru minoriti mondai (The Amerasian children), Tokyo: Shūeisha. Nakajima, T. (1993) ‘Nihon no tabunka kyōiku to zainichi kankoku/chōsenjin kyōiku’, Ibunkakan Kyōiku, 7: 69–84. –––– (ed.) (1998) Tabunka kyōiku: kyōsei no tame no kyōikugaku (Multicultural education), Tokyo: Akasho Shoten. Nakane, C. (1970) Japanese society, London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson. Nieto, S. (1999) The light in their eyes: creating multicultural learning communities, New York: Teachers College Press. Nishikawa, N., Watanabe, K. and McCormack, G. (eds) (1997) Tabunkashugi Tagengoshugi no genzai: Kanada, Osutoraria, soshite Nihon (The present state of multiculturalism and multilingualism: Canada, Australia and Japan), Tokyo: Junbun Shoin. Noguchi, M. G. and Fotos, S. (eds) (2001) Studies in Japanese bilingualism, Clevedon: Multilingual Matters. Nukaga, M. (2008) ‘The underlife of kids’ school lunchtime: negotiating ethnic boundaries and identity in food exchange’, Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, 37: 342–80. Oguma, E. (1998) Nihonjin no kyōkai: Okinawa, Ainu, Taiwan, Chōsen, shokuminchi shihai kara fukki undō made (Boundaries of Japanese people) Tokyo: Shinyosha. Okano, K. (2006) ‘The global–local interface in multicultural education policies in Japan’, Comparative Education, 42(2): 473–91. Okano, K. and Tsuchiya, M. (1999) Education in contemporary Japan: inequality and diversity, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Okinawa-ken (2008) Okinawaken no Gaikyō (A snapshot of Okinawa), Vol. 2008, Naha: Okinawa. Okuda, M. and Tajima, J. (eds) (1991) Ikebukuro no Ajia-kei Gaikokujin: shakaigakuteki jittai hōkoku (Foreigners from Asia in Ikebukuro), Tokyo: Meken. –––– (1993) Shinjuku no Ajia-kei Gaikokujin: Shakaigakuteki jittai hōkoku (Foreigners from Asia in Shinjuku), Tokyo: Mekon. Park, I. (1999) Zainichi toiu Ikikata: Sai to Byōdō no Jirenma (Living as a zainichi: a dilemma between differences and equaltiy), Tokyo: Kodansha. Qiu, Xiaolan (2005) ‘1990 nendai igo nihon ni okeru kakyō kajin kyōiku no dōkō to tenkai: shinseiki terebi chūbun gakkō o chūshin ni’ (‘Trends in the education of ethnic Chinese in Japan since the 1990s’), Gakujutsu Kenkyū, 53: 29–41. —— (2010) Personal Communications. 17th and 23rd April 2010. Waseda University, Tokyo. Rizvi, F. (1993) ‘Children and the grammar of popular racism’, in McCarthy, W. (ed.) Race, identity and representation in education, New York: Routledge. Rohlen, T. (1981) ‘Education: policies and prospects’, in C. Lee and G. De Vos (eds), Koreans in Japan, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Roth, J. H. (2002) Brokered homeland: Japanese Brazilian migrants in Japan, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Ryang, S. (1997) North Koreans in Japan, Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Sakai, Y., Sato, M., Hamada, S. and Kurosaki, I. (eds) 1998 Kyōsei no kyōiku (Education of coexistence), Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten. Sakuma, K. (1993) Igirisu no Tabunka/taminzoku Kyōiku: Ajiakei gaikokujin rōdōsha no seikatsu/bunka/shūkyō (Multicultural/multiethnic education in the United Kingdom), Tokyo: Kokudosha. Schlesinger, A. (1992) The disuniting of America: reflections on a multicultural society, New York: W.W. Norton and Co. Schoppa, L. J. (1991) Education reform in Japan: a case of immobilist politics, London: Routledge.
Understanding minorities and education
25
Sekiguchi, R. (ed.) (1988) Kanada tabunkashugi kyōiku ni kansuru gakusaiteki kenkyū (An interdisciplinary study of multicultural education in Canada), Tokyo: Tōyōkan Shuppansha. Shimahara, N. (1971) Burakumin: a Japanese minority and education, Martinus Nijhoff. –––– (1984) ‘Toward the equality of a Japanese minority: the case of burakumin’, Comparative Education, 20: 339–53. Shimizu, K. and Shimizu, M. (eds) (2001) Nyūkamā to kyōiku (Newcomers and Education), Tokyo: Akashi Shoten. Shimuzu, M. (2006) Gaikokujin seito no tameno karikyuramu: gakkō bunka no henkaku no kanōsei o saguru (Curriculum design for foreign students: the possibility of transforming school culture), Tokyo: Sagano Shoin. Siddle, R. (1996) Race, resistance and the Ainu of Japan, New York: Routledge. Sjoberg, K. (1993) The return of the Ainu: cultural mobilization and the practice of ethnicity in Japan, Chur, Switzerland: Harwood Academic. Sowa, S. (2000) Jinken kyōiku to shite no ‘dōwa’ kyōiku to tabunka kyōiku (dōwa education and multicultural education as human rights education), Tokyo: Akashi shoten. Sugimoto, Y. (2003) An Introduction to Japanese society. Second edition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. –––– (ed.) (2009) The Cambridge companion to modern Japanese culture, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. —— (2010) An Introduction to Japanese Society. Third edition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Taira, K. (1997) ‘Troubled national identity: the Ryukuans/Okinawans’, in M. Weiner (ed.), Japan’s minorities: the illusion of homogeneity, London: Routledge. Takagi, M. (1991) ‘A living legacy of discrimination’, Japan Quarterly, 38(3): 283–90. Takezawa, Y. (2008) ‘The great Hanshin-Awaji earthquake and town-making towards multiculturalism’, in N. H. H. Graburn, J. Ertl, and R. K. Tierney (eds), Multiculturalism in the new Japan: crossing the boundaries within, New York: Gerghahn Books. Tanaka, K. (1996) Tabunka kyōiku no sekaiteki chōryū (Global trends in multicultural education), Tokyo: Nakashiya Shuppan. Troyna, B. (1993) Racism and education, Buckingham: Open University Press. Tsuneyoshi, R. (1998) ‘Nyūkamā no kodomo to nihon no kyōiku (Newcomer children and Japanese education)’, in M. Sato (ed.) Kokusaika jidai no kyōiku (Education in an age of internationalization), Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten. –––– (2002) ‘Kyōiku no kokusaika to tayō na ‘tabunka kyōiku: Nichibei no kyōshitsu kara (The internationalization of education and diverse models of multicultural education)’, in T. Kajita (ed.), Kokusaika to Aidentiti (Internationalization and identity), Tokyo: Mineruva Shobo. Vogel, E. (1979) Japan as number one: lessons for America, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Vos, G. and Wagatsuma, S. (1967) Japan’s invisible race: caste in culture and personality, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Warikoo, N. and Carter, P. (2009) ‘Cultural explanations for racial and ethnic stratification in academic achievement: a call for a new and improved theory’, Review of Educational Research, 29(1): 366–94. Watado, I. and Kawamura, C. (eds) (2002) Tabunka kyōiku o hiraku: maruchikaruchuraku na nihon no genjitsu no nakade (Promoting multicultural education), Tokyo: Akashi Shoten. Watanabe, M. (ed.) (1995) Dekasegi Nikkei Burajirujin (Japanese Brazilian labourers in Japan), Tokyo: Akasho Shoten.
26 Kaori H. Okano and Ryoko Tsuneyoshi Weiner, M. (ed.) (2008) Japan’s minorities: the illusion of homogeneity, 2nd edn, London: Routledge. Weiner, M. and Hanami, T. (eds) (1998) Temporary workers or future citizens? Japanese and U.S. migration policies, New York: New York University Press. Willis, D. B. and Murphy-Shigematsu, S. (eds) (2008) Transcultural Japan: at the borderlands of race, gender, and identity, New York: Routledge. Zainihon Chōsenjin Jinken Kyōkai (2009b) ‘Shiryō’, Jinken to Seikatsu, 29: 72–80. Zenkoku-zainichi-chōsenjin-kyōiku-kenkyūkai-Kyoto (1993) Zainichi no ima Kyōto-hatsu (Koreans in Japan), Kyoto: Zenkoku-zainichi-chōsenjin-kyōiku-kenkyūkai-Kyoto.
Part I
Long-existing minorities
2
Long-existing minorities and education Kaori H. Okano
This chapter opens Part 1 on ‘long-existing minorities’ by locating these groups in Japan’s modern history and in contemporary society, where they coexist with ‘new minorities’. By ‘long-existing minorities’, we mean minorities whose origin predates the end of the Second World War. The aim is to provide an overview as an aid to a better understanding of the specific groups discussed in the following chapters. We begin with the background social circumstances and describe the individual groups – indigenous Ainu, Okinawans, people of buraku descent, ethnic Chinese and ethnic Koreans. As Chapters 3–5, in Part 1, cover Okinawans, burakumin and Koreans in detail, in this chapter I provide a more expanded illustration of Ainu and ethnic Chinese. When modern nation-states started emerging in Europe, they came with an idealized notion of a state comprised of homogeneous people, but in reality many European nation-states contained peoples of diverse backgrounds. This was also the case with Japan. The geographical and territorial entity now called Japan had been inhabited by peoples of diverse backgrounds since pre-modern times (e.g. Macdonald 1995; Denoon et al. 1996; Maher and Weiner 1997; Oguma 1998; Lie 2000). Opening its door to the world in the mid nineteenth century, Japan allowed into port cities Chinese merchants and workers whose descendants remain ‘overseas Chinese’ (kakyō) to date. The subsequent creation of the modern Japanese state politically incorporated the indigenous peoples of Hokkaido (the Ainu) and Okinawans as Japanese subjects. As the Japanese empire expanded its territory, people living in the Korean Peninsula and Taiwan also became imperial subjects, some of whom migrated to, or were mobilized for labour in, mainland Japan. I must emphasize at the outset that the exact number of individuals of these minority groups is uncertain, in particular in the case of the long-existing minority groups that Part 1 examines. This is because the Japanese census does not collect information on descent from Japanese citizens, unlike in some countries where the census seeks self-categorization of a person’s ethnic background. We know the population of self-proclaimed indigenous Ainu in Hokkaido, but many Ainu reside outside Hokkaido. Similarly, we know the population of Okinawa prefecture, but many people of Okinawan descent live outside Okinawa. Once a Korean, Chinese or Taiwanese national takes up Japanese citizenship, he or she is absorbed into the category of ‘Japanese’. His or her descendants are ‘the Japanese’.
30 Kaori H. Okano The lack of concrete data on diversity among Japanese citizens has had two outcomes. One is that discussion of domestic diversity is framed in the discourse of ‘foreigners in Japan’ (zainichi gaikokujin). For example, when the media discuss increasing ethnic diversity, they list the number of registered foreign nationals and their nationalities. Ethnic schools are called ‘schools for foreigners’ (gaikokujin gakkō) (that is, Korean, Chinese, Brazilian, Peruvian), even though these schools also accommodate many Japanese nationals of varying heritage (Okano 2008: 5–20). As the majority of ‘long-existing minorities’ are Japanese citizens (including indigenous peoples), such discussions make the presence of diversity among Japanese citizens more invisible in public discussions. Some local governments, including in Osaka prefecture, acknowledge the existence of Japanese citizens of minority descent and have begun to use expressions such as ‘children with foreign roots’ (gaikoku ni rūtsu no aru jidō) and ‘children with special relationships with foreign countries’ (gaikoku to tokubetsuna kankeino aru jidō). But again, the reference point is ‘foreign country’. The modern system of state education has had a profound impact on longexisting minorities: it has effectively forced children to abandon the languages and cultures of their parents, to learn to see the world in ways determined by the mainstream Japanese (including that they occupy an inferior status), and to conform to what has long been considered the ‘Japanese way’ (including nationalist ideology). Assimilation was imposed by the central government. However, at certain historical times, minorities themselves have actively promoted assimilation, as in the case of Okinawans. Resistance to this assimilation was countered by the establishment of ethnic schools, rather than by challenges to mainstream schooling. A challenge to mainstream schooling came from buraku activism, which demanded ‘fair’ treatment of their children, anti-discrimination measures and human rights. Gaining inspiration from radical buraku activism, both Koreans and Ainu later started to make similar demands. All these groups were marginalized, both in terms of institutions (such as employment and schooling) and interpersonal interactions, in many different ways. But minority groups began to mobilize themselves against this marginalization before the Second World War. Buraku activism emerged in the earliest stages and was able to achieve the greatest progress, through alliance with political parties on the left and the radical measures it took in the 1970s, thereby setting examples for other groups to follow. Indeed, both Ainu and ethnic Korean activism, separately, have adopted similar tactics since the 1980s. Buraku activism also targeted mainstream schooling as one of the most significant ways to challenge the status quo. Although these movements forged alliances with the left, ethnic Chinese activism has taken a different route, perhaps owing to differences in the class composition of this community, as I explain below.
Indigenous Ainu, and Okinawans Ainu and Okinawans both see themselves as indigenous peoples of Japan; just like other indigenous peoples in the first world, they experienced internal
Long-existing minorities and education
31
colonization, were dispossessed of their land, were mobilized as cheap labour and remain marginalized to this day.1 Such perceptions resulted from their participation in global indigenous peoples’ movements that emerged in the 1980s. Until forty years ago, they saw themselves quite differently. The Ainu people were perceived as a ‘dying race’. The trajectories of Ainu and Okinawan peoples since their integration into the Japanese state share many features with other indigenous peoples around the world, one of which is the role played by the state education system. As Chapter 4 closely examines Okinawans, here I offer a brief examination of Ainu people. The population of the self-claimed Ainu people in Hokkaido was approximately 24,000 in 2006 (Hokkaido-chō 2007). There are said to be many more people of Ainu descent in other parts of Japan, but the number is unknown, as the national census does not collect such data. The existence of Ainu organizations in metropolitan cities suggests a significant number of people of Ainu descent living outside Hokkaido. Active interactions between the ‘majority Japanese’ and Hokkaido Ainu began in the fifteenth century when many medieval fiefdoms fought over mainland territories. Trading settlements were created by ‘majority Japanese’ from the mainland in the southern part of Ezogashima/Hokkaido around that time. After a series of conflicts between these settlements and the Ainu, agreement was reached between the most powerful family and the local Ainu. This family was later to rule the Matsumae domain, a minor fiefdom of the Tokugawa regime in Tokyo (then called Edo), when the Tokugawa family consolidated its rule over the Japanese archipelago. Under this regime (which lasted 250 years), a large part of what is now called Hokkaido remained ‘foreign land’ (Ezochi – literally, barbarian’s land). The Matsumae domain profited from trading with the Ainu in the resource-rich land. Alarmed by Russian expansion southwards in the late eighteenth century, the Tokugawa regime annexed Ezochi and placed it under its direct control, later granting it to the Matsumae domain. This resulted in Ainu resettlement and forced labour mobilization. With the establishment of the modern Japanese state in the mid nineteenth century, Ezochi formally became a part of the Japanese state. The Kaitakushi (Development–Colonization Commission 1869) was to oversee the ‘development’ of what the state regarded as a terra nullius, rich in natural resources. A large number of migrants from the mainland settled in Hokkaido, which was then systematically ‘developed’. Ainu people (who until then had depended for their livelihood on the forests and waterways) were forced to resettle and seek employment as cheap labour for the migrants. Informed by the social Darwinist view of ‘race’ prevalent at the time, the government enacted the Hokkaido Native Protection Act (Dojin hō) in 1899. It was expected that Ainu people would become small farmers and ‘Japanese citizens’. To this end, the authorities provided Ainu children with what they believed was required for Ainu lives – rudimentary education in Japanese literacy and numeracy. With the Native Protection Act came the Rules on Native Education (Dojin Jidō Kyōiku Kitei). Ainu children initially attended ‘native Ainu schools’, separate from schools for children of mainland migrants, and received a shorter
32 Kaori H. Okano and lower level of school education. They also gradually lost their Ainu language and sense of identity (Ueno 2005: 293). Later, Ainu children were schooled with non-Ainu children, but records suggest that Ainu children suffered bullying and discrimination from both classmates and uninformed teachers. Such experiences, and family poverty, often led to children dropping out of school early (Ueno 2001: 46). This in turn meant that Ainu people were restricted from bettering themselves in mainstream society. It was not that Ainu people passively accepted their situation: activists took up the poor state of Ainu in the 1920s and 1930s, which resulted in the creation of the first Ainu organization, the Ainu Association (Ainu Kyōkai) in 1930. It operated with an assimilationist framework, in cooperation with local government. The Association renamed itself the Utari Association in 1961, since by then Ainu people felt that the term ‘Ainu’ had acquired a derogatory meaning. Ainu people were divided about what roles it should play, and debate continued among them. At the outset, the Utari Association, along with the government, saw welfare measures as central to solving the problems of Ainu people. The subsequent government’s measures to address Ainu issues also centred on welfare measures. In 1961, the Utari special welfare project was implemented to improve living conditions, and employment and education levels. When it was subsequently found that Ainu living conditions remained inferior to those of non-Ainu, another welfare package, the First Hokkaido Utari Welfare Measures, was implemented, at a cost of 12 billion yen over the period 1971–80 (Siddle 1996: 33). These measures resembled the ten-year Special Measures for Regional Improvement for buraku people (1969, and renewed in 1979 and 1989), as Ainu activists gained inspiration from what the Buraku Liberation League had achieved. The Utari Welfare Measures are still being implemented, having been repeatedly renewed since their initial implementation in 1971 (renewals took place in 1981–7, 1988–94, 1995–2001, 2002–8) (Hokaidō-chō-kankyōseisaku-bu 2008). Education has been considered one of the pillars for improvement of Ainu lives, and the measures taken have provided financial assistance to Ainu children to attend upper secondary schools and tertiary institutions. Ainu activism underwent significant changes in the 1970s. Young Ainu activists no longer accepted that assimilation and working within the government institutional structure (that is, the Utari Association) formed the most effective course of action. Influenced by left-leaning students, buraku and human rights movements at the time, they wanted to assert their Ainu identity and so created new organizations, such as the Ainu Liberation League and an urban-centred Tokyo Utari Association. The activists not only gained inspiration from the Buraku Liberation League (BLL), but also adopted the BLL’s strategies of an uncompromising stance, confrontation and denunciation (Siddle 1996: 38, 29). They were also able to gain support from political parties on the left (the Japan Socialist Party and the Japan Communist Party), which enabled their activism to be seen as a mainstream civil movement. In the field of education, concerned teachers began to take the issue of teaching Ainu children seriously and produced a guidebook in 1982, entitled ‘Discussing
Long-existing minorities and education
33
minorities in Japan with students: the current situation and guides for teaching’ (Hokkaido-kōtōgakkō-kyōshokuin-kumiai (Hokkaido High School Teachers Union) 1982). Furthermore, the Research Association for Ainu Education was established within the Hokkaido Education Board in 1983, in response to lobbying by the Utari Association. First, the Association saw problems with some of the depictions of Ainu in school textbooks and readers, and it debated what should be taught, both in the classroom and in teacher training courses. Second, it also began to see ignorance, among teachers, of the reasons behind the bullying of Ainu students and their truancy. The Research Association involved academics and practitioners and produced two publications to guide teachers in the teaching of Ainu history in primary and middle schools (in 1984) and in senior high schools (in 1991) (Ueno 2001: 46–7). The 1980s saw Ainu activists connecting with other human rights movements in Japan, based on a shared concern for the human rights of minorities. Ainu activists attended buraku meetings (Siddle 1996: 39) and made alliances with indigenous people’s movements in other countries. They attended the Third World Conference of Indigenous People in Australia in 1981. As a globally recognized indigenous people, Ainu participated in the opening ceremony of the UN International Year of the World Indigenous Peoples in 1992. Such recognition and participation fostered Ainu self-perceptions as a culturally distinct group with a specific history of colonization and a distinct set of rights. This global alliance gave them a means to challenge domestic marginalization in the global arena, appealing to international covenants (Sjoberg 2006). Educational participation among Ainu children has increased over the years and in particular since the series of Utari Welfare Measures were instituted in 1971. Ainu children’s retention rates to upper secondary schooling (that is, beyond compulsory schooling) are gradually catching up to those of their non-Ainu counterparts, with a 5 per cent gap remaining in 1999 and 2006. However, there remains a significant difference in rates of entry into universities – in 2006, less than 18 per cent of Ainu students went on to university, whereas nearly 40 per cent of non-Ainu students took up tertiary study (see Tables 2.1 and 2.2). The difference can be explained by the relative poverty of Ainu families. The same 2006 survey on Ainu living conditions reports that 38.4 per cent of Ainu families receive the government living protection allowance (seikatsu hogo) for low-income families, compared with 24.6 per cent of non-Ainu families. Ainu parents want their children to receive education: for example, 43 per cent of parents want their children to complete tertiary education, and 45 per cent senior high school. The gap between parental aspirations and children’s achievements may be due to the children’s negative experiences with schooling, such as bullying and discrimination, which not only affect academic performance but also alienate them from school (Ueno 2005: 295). It may also be due to a relative lack of rolemodel adults who have built their careers on success at school. If the series of welfare measures have been addressing Ainu children’s access to life chances in the mainstream society through financial assistance and making school a more comfortable place for them, how and to what extent has cultural
34
Kaori H. Okano
Table 2.1 Ainu children’s retention rate to upper secondary schools compared with their non-Ainu cohort, 1972–2006 Year
1972
1979
1986
1993
1999
2006
Ainu (%) Non-Ainu in the same township (%)
41.5 78.2
69.3 90.6
78.4 94.0
87.4 96.3
95.2 97.0
93.5 98.3
Source: Hokkaidō-chō, Kankyōseikatsu-bu (2006) Heisei 18-nendo Hokkaidō Ainu seikatsu jittai chōsa hōkokusho, Sapporo: Hokkaidō-chō.
Table 2.2 Ainu children’s retention rate to universities compared with their non-Ainu cohort, 1979–2006 Year
1979
1986
1993
1999
2006
Ainu (%) Non-Ainu in the same township (%)
3.8 31.1
8.1 27.4
11.8 27.5
16.1 34.5
17.4 38.5
Source: Hokkaidō-chō, Kankyōseikatsu-bu (2006) Heisei 18-nendo Hokkaidō Ainu seikatsu jittai chōsa hōkokusho, Sapporo: Hokkaidō-chō.
maintenance or revitalization been addressed? I would suggest that very little has been done, but the 1997 Ainu Culture Act (Law for the Promotion of the Ainu Culture and for the Dissemination and Advocacy for the Traditions of the Ainu and the Ainu Culture) offers the potential to progress these goals (Siddle 2006). The vast majority of Ainu children speak Japanese as their first language. Those wanting to learn the Ainu language must attend classes organized outside school. The number of students is increasing, in part owing to the new Ainu Culture Act and to a general ethnic revitalization. The 2006 survey suggests that a significant number of Ainu maintain an interest in learning the Ainu language. The debates on the new Act and the Ainu’s identification with global indigenous peoples’ movements have domestically promoted public recognition of Ainu, which has prompted more schools to include aspects of Ainu culture and issues in subjects across the curriculum – in history, civics, Japanese, arts and social studies (Ueno 2001: 45). With the introduction of a compulsory integrated study subject in 2002 under the national curriculum reforms, more students are likely to learn about Ainu issues, in particular in schools in Hokkaido and in schools that adopt themes such as human rights, diversity and globalization (Ueno 2005: 299). The homepages of the Ainu Bunka Shinkō Kenkyū Kikō (The Foundation for Research and Promotion of Ainu Culture), the Hokkaido Education Board and the Hokkaido Utari Association all offer a wide range of relevant teaching materials. Ainu people have not mobilized themselves for the education of the young, as the burakumin and ethnic Koreans have done. The buraku civil movements have centred on improvement of material conditions and human rights without asserting ‘differences’. The ethnic Koreans fought for access to both education and life chances in mainstream society, focusing on their lack of citizenship, and for
Long-existing minorities and education
35
cultural maintenance through the provision of ethnic education, offered in separate ethnic schools and in government schools. Though they have established themselves as Japan’s indigenous people, it remains to be seen what Ainu people decide they want for their children’s education and what strategies they devise to achieve them. They now have more resources than ever before. People of Okinawan descent (the topic of Chapter 4) currently reside across Japan. The population in Okinawa prefecture, formally called the Ryukyu Islands, was 1.37 million in 2008 (Okinawa-ken 2008). The exact extent of Okinawan diaspora in other parts of Japan is not known, although we know that a large number of Okinawans live in Osaka’s Taisho ward and in nearby Amagasaki City in the Hyogo prefecture. There are also associations of Okinawan people (Okinawa kenjinkai) in many prefectures, and we know that many Okinawans left for South America as migrants, some of whose descendants have now returned to Japan as guest workers. Okinawa was once the independent kingdom of Ryukyu. The kingdom maintained trading relationships with China, South East Asia and mainland Japan. In the early seventeenth century, when the Tokugawa regime established its rule over most of the Japanese archipelago, one of the minor fiefs at the southern tip of Kyushu, the Satsuma domain (han), absorbed the Ryukyu Islands. The Satsuma domain deliberately maintained these islands as a kingdom in order to benefit from its trade with China and South East Asia. The Meiji government officially annexed the kingdom in 1879 (at about the same time that the Ainu faced a similar fate in the north) and adopted an assimilationist policy. The modern system of education ensured that locals learned Japanese and the imperial ideology. Although the locals initially saw little value in this imposed assimilation and resented it, Japan’s victory over China in 1894 led them to see some desirability in an alliance with Japan. Local leaders (including school teachers) then began an assimilation movement from below, in the belief that it would eventually benefit the local population. Okinawans were actively involved in Japan’s colonization of Taiwan as Japanese subjects. The end of the Second World War saw the Ryukyu Islands come under American rule, which meant that the Okinawans’ post-war trajectory was quite different from that of the Ainu. Local teachers were unhappy with what they saw as the American occupation authority’s lack of enthusiasm for schooling (although it tried to design an Okinawa-centred curriculum) and the widening gap in academic achievement and subsequent life chances between Okinawan and mainland children. Teachers again initiated an assimilation education movement and demanded that Okinawan children receive the same education as mainland children. Thus, American rule heightened their grass-roots desire to become ‘Japanese’. With the continued existence of many US bases on the island after its return to Japan in 1972, Okinawans have developed an identity distinct from ‘majority Japanese’, in which they see themselves as victims of the state policies and the attitudes of the majority. Okinawa’s post-war experience has produced another minority, Amerasians (the children of American soldiers and local women). Chapter 4 examines both Okinawans and Amerasians in more detail.
36 Kaori H. Okano
People of buraku descent People of buraku descent (the topic of Chapter 3) are estimated to number 3 million and to maintain 6,000 communities across the country. The origin of the burakumin dates back to medieval times, when they were engaged in certain occupations popularly considered undesirable, for example, tanning and leatherwork, and lived in specified areas. With the hereditary class system institutionalized by the Tokugawa regime in the early seventeenth century, these groups of people were treated as outcasts, located at the bottom of the hierarchy. The class system was abolished in 1871 by the Meiji government as part of modernization initiatives, at around the same time that both Ainu and the Okinawans were formally incorporated into the Japanese empire. Despite this, buraku marginalization continues to this day. During the post-war period, the BLL pursued the elimination of discrimination against burakumin and improvement in their social and material conditions. In response to activism, the government implemented the ten-year Special Measures for Regional Improvement in 1969, to improve housing, employment, education and welfare. This was renewed in 1979 and 1989 for two more decades. The 1969 measures put Dōwa Education programmes (literally, egalitarian education), which had been pursued by the BLL, on the national agenda and had the national government fund it. It has been popularly held that buraku people do not form an ethnic group, as they cannot be identified by outwardly distinctive features associated with what is commonly understood to be ethnicity, such as language, religion or dress. Do burakumin then possess a distinctive ‘culture’? If we understand ‘culture’ to be a package of values, beliefs and ways of seeing the world, as well as distinctive characteristics such as language use, activities and customs, then we can say that they have a distinctive ‘culture’, which has developed as a result of their historical experiences of specific material and social conditions (including poverty and limited occupational opportunities) and exclusion from mainstream society. This includes particular diet, language use and marriage patterns, for example, as documented by Wagatsuma and De Vos (1984). In relation to institutional schooling, burakumin have tended to see schooling in a negative light. For example, schooling was considered to be a luxury before the Special Measures raised their living conditions, because the young needed to earn a living rather than attend school. School learning and qualifications were considered to be irrelevant or unnecessary, as burakumin faced discrimination in the mainstream employment market and eventually gained jobs in their own communities. Schooling was also alienating and oppressive, with frequent bullying. It is because of the distinctive nature of buraku culture that one of the buraku community preschools (studied in Chapter 3) adopted a particular philosophy to make school more conducive to children’s learning. Buraku activism, however, has not asserted a particular buraku ‘culture’. It has continuously adopted the universal language of human rights since the beginning of their activism in the early twentieth century, arguing that they deserve equal treatment because they are also ‘Japanese’.
Long-existing minorities and education
37
Ethnic Chinese There are important divisions between ethnic Chinese residing in Japan. As in other parts of the world, a distinction exists between Japanese nationals of Chinese descent (called kajin) and those who are citizens of the People’s Republic of China (PRC) or Taiwan (called overseas Chinese, kakyo) (Guo 1999: 7). There are no reliable data for the number of kajin, for reasons already mentioned. Among Chinese residents themselves, a further distinction is made between old ethnic Chinese (rō-kakyō) and new ethnic Chinese (shin-kakyō). The latter arrived in Japan after Japan’s normalization of relations with the PRC in 1972 (Guo 1999: 9) and display greater internal variations than old ethnic Chinese – ranging from established, professional, permanent residents to illegal workers. ‘Newcomer’ Chinese are examined in more detail in Part 2. Chinese traders had resided in port towns in Japan since the sixteenth century. Under the Tokugawa regime’s isolationist policy, Chinese traders were allowed to reside in Nagasaki, the only port open to the outside world, from the beginning of the seventeenth century. With the opening of Japan to the West in 1853, Europeans started to arrive in several ports designated for international trading. As employees of these European traders, more Chinese workers arrived, which in turn led to chain migration through family and provincial reunions. At the same time, long-established Chinese traders in Nagasaki moved to other port cities in pursuit of expanded opportunities. The ethnic Chinese population in Japan has fluctuated over time, responding to ‘push’ and ‘pull’ factors. These included Japanese government policy, and economic conditions and employment opportunities in both countries. For example, the Sino-Japanese War (1894–5) led to a reduction in the number of resident Chinese. The Japanese authorities initially discouraged unskilled labour migration for fear of opium use among the Chinese, which resulted in the relatively middleclass nature of the Chinese community (Vasishth 1997: 125). Japan’s colonization of Taiwan in 1895 increased the Taiwanese population in Japan, from 2,400 in 1922 to 7,000 in 1942 (Tsurumi 1984: 125). The Taiwanese received Japanese schooling at modern schools established by the colonial authorities (Tsurumi 1977), and some of these graduates went on to universities in Japan. During and prior to the Second World War, forced labour conscripts arrived from Korea and north-eastern China, although to a lesser extent than those from Taiwan. There is significant evidence of exploitation of Chinese labourers during this time. After the end of the Second World War, both Taiwanese and Chinese were repatriated by the occupation authority. About half of the 28,000 Taiwanese decided to remain in Japan. In 1948, the total number of Chinese residents was 34,000, of which 40 per cent were of Taiwanese descent (Vasishth 1997: 131). Compared with other countries, there has always been a relatively large proportion of Taiwanese among Chinese residents of Japan. The Taiwanese were more educated and did not face Japanese language problems, which meant that they were able to enter a wider range of occupations in post-war Japan (Vasishth 1997: 132–3).
38 Kaori H. Okano When Japan normalized its relations with the PRC in 1972, a large number of Taiwanese took Japanese citizenship. When the PRC began to allow its citizens to study and work in Japan, the number of ‘newcomer’ Chinese increased rapidly, changing the internal composition of the overseas Chinese community. In 1974, those from Taiwan numbered 24,000 and accounted for just over half of the Chinese residents in Japan. The corresponding figures are 33,000 and 48 per cent in 1984, and 39,000 and 13 per cent in 1997 (Guo 1999: 60–1). By 2001, almost four in five Chinese residents in Japan were newcomer Chinese from the PRC (Qiu 2004a: 128). The increasing dominance of these among Chinese residents in Japan was brought about by, not only a large number of new arrivals, but also an increase in the number of Chinese marrying Japanese nationals. Almost 90 per cent of Chinese marriages are with Japanese citizens, and their children are born with Japanese citizenship (Qiu 2004a: 128). Chinese children had two options for schooling – mainstream Japanese schools and full-time ethnic schools. The first modern, ethnic Chinese school was established by Chinese merchants in Yokohama in 1897, before the government of Qing China established its own school system in 1901, modelled on the modern system of education in Meiji Japan (Yen 2002: 178–9). The school was also the first modern, overseas Chinese school in the world and was later a model for overseas Chinese schools in South East Asia (Qiu 2004a: 128). Similar schools were subsequently established in Kobe, Osaka, Tokyo and Nagasaki, and numbered ten by the end of the Second World War. After the war, the schools replaced provincial languages with Mandarin Chinese as the medium of instruction, creating a sense of solidarity in Chinese communities. The division of the PRC and Taiwan led most schools to choose affiliation, except for the Kobe ethnic Chinese school, which made a conscious decision to accommodate both. The 1970s saw a decline in the demand for Chinese schooling, with many residents taking up Japanese citizenship. Currently, five schools operate as full-time ‘ethnic’ schools, offering locally relevant curricula (including Japanese and English), with Mandarin as the medium of instruction. In 1948, about 70 per cent of school-age Chinese residents attended one of the ethnic Chinese schools (Qiu 2004b: 216). The current figure is 10 per cent; the great majority of Chinese children attend mainstream Japanese schools (Qiu 2004b: 225). There have been few studies on ‘old Chinese’ children at mainstream schools. I suspect that this is partly because they perform well, and because the transition from ethnic Chinese middle school to mainstream high school has been a smooth one for many. In recent years, ethnic Chinese schools have gained a reputation for providing a more rigorous academic education (especially given the opportunity to learn three languages) than local government schools and have attracted non-Chinese children. The nature of ethnic Chinese schools has changed over the years, in particular from the 1990s, when ethnic Chinese communities became more diverse. Studies of five Chinese schools suggest that they all see their mission as teaching Chinese language and academic achievement comparable with mainstream Japanese schools, as well as the promotion of trilingualism (Chinese, Japanese and English),
Long-existing minorities and education
39
and an ‘international education’, something akin to that offered by Englishmedium international schools (Qiu 2004b: 216–22). Since the 1990s, the predominance of old Chinese among the student population has changed; for example, the majority of the Yokohama Chinese school enrolment is newcomer Chinese children, which has prompted it to institute JSL classes. The number of students with no Chinese background also increased, accounting for 22 per cent and 11 per cent of students in schools in Yokohama and Kobe, respectively (Qiu 2004a: 128–9). Old ethnic Chinese (who arrived before 1972) have established a network of organizations. There are thirty-seven main organizations for those from the mainland, represented by a peak national body. Most of them exclude those who have taken Japanese citizenship. Old ethnic Chinese from Taiwan are represented by thirty-four major organizations and a peak national body, which also welcome naturalized members. Among them, the Kobe Chinese organization (Kobe Kakyō Sōkai) is an exception in that it accommodates members regardless of their origins (Guo 1999: 68). Other than these, there exist many other associations based on such features as provinces of origin, occupations and commerce. Newcomer Chinese generally do not have meaningful interaction with these old ethnic Chinese and their organizations (Vasishth 1997: 135–6; Guo 1999: 212), and they depend on NGOs and NPOs established for newcomers. So, we have old ethnic Chinese who are established, educated and relatively wealthy on the one hand and, on the other, newcomer Chinese with little Japanese language proficiency who face challenges similar to newcomers from other parts of the world. Interactions such as occur between old Chinese and newcomer Chinese deserve further study.
Ethnic Koreans Like ethnic Chinese, ethnic Koreans exhibit internal variations. A major division exists between ‘old-timer’ Koreans, who are the descendants of those who arrived in Japan before the end of the Second World War as imperial subjects, and ‘newcomer Koreans’, who arrived during the post-war period. ‘Old-timer’ ethnic Koreans were granted special permanent residency, but an increasing number of them are now Japanese citizens. Korean residents in Japan number 600,000, and an almost equal number of Japanese citizens of Korean descent are said to live in Japan. Although a small number of Koreans lived as artisans working for pre-modern domains in Japan, the number of Korean arrivals jumped after Japan’s colonization of the Korean peninsula in 1910. A large number of peasants, having had their land taken by the colonial authorities, migrated to Japan to work in low-paid employment in factories, mines and construction work during the country’s rapid industrialization (Weiner 1994). Later, from 1939, labour conscription led to further Korean immigration. Their predominantly working-class background distinguished them from ethnic Chinese migrants. Korean children attended Japanese schools, but, with the end of the war, many ethnic schools sprang up in order to prepare them for repatriation to Korea. Those
40
Kaori H. Okano
families who decided to remain in Japan had the choice of sending their children to either North Korean ethnic schools or mainstream schools. Since the early 1990s, almost 90 per cent of school-age Korean children attend mainstream schools. As Chapter 5 reveals, studies of Korean students in mainstream schools suggest that their experience of schooling has become quite comfortable, but that the national policies do not address the needs of Koreans who do not outwardly display ‘difference’. It is at the level of local government that policies are developed to address ethnic Korean needs. In recent decades, these policies have been adjusted to address the needs of newcomer minority children as well.
Education and long-existing minorities All long-existing minority groups have been incorporated into the modern Japanese state as marginalized groups. Except for the early Chinese merchants, the incorporation was imposed. Although some people migrated from the Korean peninsula, Taiwan and north-eastern China to Japan, it was because they lost their livelihoods after the colonial authorities had expropriated their land. Despite divergence in the processes of incorporation, there are shared characteristics among the long-existing minorities. For a start, all now have Japanese as their dominant language. Language is not a barrier in the educational and employment spheres. There has not been the pressing need to adapt to the ‘Japanese lifestyle’, as there is for new minorities. Furthermore, all groups maintain long-established associations and social networks to meet the needs of the community and promote their interests. In terms of legal entitlement to education, however, the position of foreignnational Korean children differs from that of the other long-existing minority children (Ainu, Okinawans and buraku) who are Japanese citizens. There is continuing debate over foreign nationals’ entitlements to education and the national government’s duty to provide it. On one hand, the post-war Japanese constitution, in employing the term kokumin (literally, Japanese citizens) refers exclusively to Japanese citizens in relation to education (Article 26), which has led to an interpretation that foreign nationals are not entitled to education and that the government has no duty of provision. Such an interpretation is not, however, conveyed in the English language version of the Constitution provided on the government homepage (Appendix 1). This translated version is misleading, in particular in light of recent civil movements that have demanded that the term kokumin be replaced with nanibito (people) in order to ensure every child’s entitlement to education, regardless of his or her nationality. It was because of this constitutional restriction on the education of foreignnational Korean children that, in 1953, 1965 and 1991, the national government issued circulars regarding their education (see details in Chapter 5). The current legal stance, which derives from the 1965 circular, is that foreign-national children are entitled to the same free education and financial assistance as Japanese children. In the 1991 circular, the ministry softened its prior insistence that government schools not provide any special treatment based on ethnicity and
Long-existing minorities and education
41
acknowledged the value of after-school ethnic classes for Koreans (which had long existed in schools in Osaka). It also stated that this would also apply to newcomer foreign-national children, for the first time drawing a link between ‘oldtimer’ Koreans and newcomer children in education. We see a further change in the ministry's position in the new Primary School Course of Study (announced in 2008 but yet to be implemented), when it acknowledged the benefits that they bring to learning in mainstream classes (see Appendix 2). There are several important matters to highlight in relation to education and long-existing minorities. The first concerns the roles of long-established minority groups’ associations and networks. These associations have long taken initiatives to promote the education of their children in negotiation with local and national governments and other interest groups. Interactions among these associations have a basis in a shared language of human rights. A large number of the NGOs and NPOs that have emerged in more recent years accommodate multiple groups, including new minorities. In this increasingly complex picture of activism, we ask, what roles do each of the long-existing minorities’ associations and activist groups play, both independently and collectively, in promoting children’s education? The second point is the relative emphasis on access to life chances, or cultural maintenance/revitalization. These groups’ earlier concerns about schooling have leaned more towards improving access to life chances in mainstream society than to cultural maintenance/revitalization. Seeing their children receive ‘inferior’ schooling and the gap in achievement in education and employment relative to the mainstream, they pursued improvement through scholarships, affirmative action, government funding and special educational programmes. They also challenged what they considered inappropriate and discriminatory practices at mainstream school. Cultural maintenance and revitalization were left to ethnic schools (operating outside the mainstream schools), which were available from pre-war times for ethnic Chinese and from the late 1940s for ethnic Koreans. Later initiatives, influenced by identity politics in the 1970s, involved asserting their differences and arguing for cultural maintenance through mainstream schooling. More parents began to lobby mainstream schools (which now accommodate 90 per cent of school-age children of Chinese and Korean descent) to address the special needs of their children and to educate ‘majority Japanese’ children about diversity. The fact that educated minority young people increasingly choose to assert their minority identity rather than deliberately ‘passing’ as mainstream Japanese suggests intergenerational change. Third, Ainu and Okinawans now possess greater potential than ever to assert the special status of indigenous peoples and their distinctive entitlements, by forging alliances with the global indigenous peoples’ movements and citing international conventions. How indigenous minority groups strategically align with other long-existing minorities to promote their interests remains to be seen. Interactions of this kind have occurred, such as an Ainu representative giving a speech at a buraku conference and the broadcasting of Hokkaido Ainu radio programmes in regular timeslots on Kobe’s multilingual FM radio. Buraku
42 Kaori H. Okano activism has provided inspiration and guidance for practical strategies to Ainu and Korean activism. Korean organizations have conducted educational seminars on indigenous peoples and burakumin. The potential for collaboration among individual groups to have an impact on mainstream schooling deserves attention. The next three chapters illustrate the contemporary situations of three longlasting minority groups: burakumin, Okinawans and ethnic Koreans. We also see how these groups with a long-standing presence in Japan have interacted with each other before and since the arrival of newcomers.
Note 1
As mentioned in the previous chapter, the notion of indigenous peoples remains tenuous. So does the issue of who constitutes Japan’s indigenous peoples and the ‘Japanese’ (Oguma 1998). Although the Ainu people are now officially recognized as indigenous by the Japanese government, Okinawans do not currently hold such a status.
References Denoon, D., Hudson, M., McCormack, G. and Morris-Suzuki, T. (1996) Multicultural Japan: palaeolithic to postmodern, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Guo, F. (1999) Zainichi kakyō no aidentitei no henyō: Kakyō no tagenteki kyōsei (The changing identity of Chinese in Japan: their multidimensional acculturation), Tokyo: Toshindo. Hokkaidō-cho (2007) Keizaiteki shakaiteki chii no kōjō o hakarutameno sōgōtekina sesaku no suishin. Available online at www.pref.hokkaido.lg.jp/ks/sum/soumuka/ainu/ suishinhousaku.html (accessed 4 June 2007). Hokkaidō-chō-kankyōseisaku-bu (2008) Heisei 18-nendo Hoddaidō Ainu seikatsu jittai chōsa hōkokusho. Available online at www.pref.hokkaido.lg.jp/ks/sum/somuka/ainu/ jittai.htm. (accessed 10 June 2008). Hokkaidō-Kōtōgakkō-kyōshokuin-kumiai (Hokkaido High School Teachers Union) (1982) Seito to tomoni kangaeru nihon no shōsū minzoku: sono genjō to shidō no tebiki (Discussing minorities in Japan with students: the current situation and guides for teaching), Sapporo: Hokkaidō-Kōtōgakkō-kyōshokuin-kumiai. Lie, J. (2000) Multiethnic Japan, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Maher, J. and Macdonald, G. (1995) Diversity in Japanese culture and language, London: Kegan Paul International. Oguma, E. (1998) Nihonjin no kyōkai: Okinawa, Ainu, Taiwan, Chōsen shokuminchi shihai kara fukki undō made (The boundaries of Japanese), Tokyo: Shinyosha. Okano, K. (2008) ‘Interactions amongst ethnic minority groups in schooling in Japan: the global–local interface’, in T. Hamashita, P. Kent, A. Iwatani and A. Uya (eds), Changing identities and networks in the globalising world, Afrasian Centre for Peace and Development Studies, Ryukoku University. Okinawa-ken (2008) Okinawa-ken no gaikyō, Okinawa-kencho, Naha. Qiu, X. (2004a) ‘Kakyō kajin kyōiku no henyō ni kansuru ichi kōsatsu: Nihon to indoneshia o chūshin ni’, Waseda Daigaku Daigakuin Kyōikugakukenkyūka Kiyō, 11 (March): 127–37.
Long-existing minorities and education
43
–––– (2004b) ‘Nihon shakai niokeru kakyō kyōiku no jittai nitsuite: Zen-nissei kakyōgakkō o chūshin ni’, Waseda Daigaku Daigakuin Kyōikugakukenkyūka Kiyō, 12 (September): 215–26. Siddle, R. (1996) Race, resistance and the Ainu of Japan, New York: Routledge. –––– (2006) ‘The making of Ainu moshiri: Japan’s indigenous nationalism and its cultural fictions’, in N. Shimazu (ed.), Nationalisms in Japan, London: Routledge. Sjoberg, K. (2006) ‘Redefining the past, taking charge of the present, appropriating the future: the Hokkaido Ainu case’, in B. Sautman (ed.), Cultural genocide and Asian state peripheries, New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Tsurumi, P. (1977) Japanese colonial education in Taiwan 1895–1945, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. –––– (1984) ‘Colonial education in Korea and Taiwan’, in R. Myers (ed.), The Japanese colonial empire 1895–1945, Princeton: Princeton University Press. Ueno, Masayuki (2001) ‘Ainu minzoku o meguru kyōiku ni kansuru ichikōsatsu’, Waseda Daigaku Daigakuin Kyouikugaku Kenkyūka Kiyō, 9: 45–56. –––– (2005) ‘Ainu minzoku to kyōikuken no hoshō nitsuiteno kōsatsu’, Waseda Daigaku Daigakuin Kyouikugaku Kenkyūka Kiyō, 13: 293–303. Vasishth, A. (1997) ‘A model minority: the Chinese community in Japan’, in M. Weiner (ed.), Japan’s minorities: the illusion of homogeneity, London: Routledge. Wagatsuma, H. and De Vos, H. (1984) Heritage of endurance: family patterns and delinquent formation in Japan, Berkeley: University of California Press. Weiner, M. (1994) Race and migration in imperial Japan, London: Routledge. –––– (1997) Japan’s minorities: the illusion of homogeneity, London: Routledge. Yen, C. (2002) The ethnic Chinese in East and Southeast Asia: business, culture and politics, Singapore: Times Academic Press.
3
The schooling of buraku children Overcoming the legacy of stereotyping and discrimination Sarane Spence Boocock You know, I am poor in school performance. Because my grandpa and grandma didn’t go to school, and my pa and ma barely graduated middle school. I am their child. So, I can’t be smart in school. Buraku ninth grader I am a buraku person and I am not proud of my position. But I hope to be more proud after listening to other buraku people. Knowing about people in weaker positions and doing something for them is important for us. As a burakumin I can relate to other minorities and I can understand their position . . . I would like everyone to know about my worries for my future but I fear that I will be discriminated against. Buraku middle-school student Buraku kids can’t concentrate. Elementary school principal Buraku liberation begins and ends in education. Buraku Liberation Research Institute (Buraku Kaihō Kenkyūjo)
The buraku people, or burakumin, constitute one of Japan’s largest discriminated against minority group.1 Like indigenous peoples discussed in this book, the buraku people are neither newcomers nor oldcomers—their residence in Japan parallels that of majority Japanese. Nor are they a distinct racial or ethnic group— they do not differ from majority or mainstream Japanese in skin color, facial features, or any other characteristics of physical appearance, nor do they share a distinctive language, religion, or other characteristics of sociocultural heritage. Yet, as George De Vos, the American anthropologist who conducted some of the first in-depth studies of buraku communities, has pointed out, “nonvisible features can be used with equal force to segregate off a portion of a society as essentially inferior, or in religious terms, ‘impure’” (De Vos and Suarez-Orozco 1990: 171). Many social scientists regard burakumin as members of a politically created caste, or outcaste, group, though some (for example, Shimahara 1984) argue that, lacking a distinctive culture, contemporary burakumin do not meet all criteria of
The schooling of buraku children 45 outcaste status. Racial, ethnic, and caste definitions and classifications can, of course, be highly subjective, and boundaries between groups are rarely clear and fixed. Failing to find a “neat and simple” definition, the author of a review of research on buraku origins and issues concluded that the “only consistent identifying feature of burakumin is that they are discriminated against” (Su-LanReber 1999: 4). Not surprisingly, the educational accomplishments of buraku children, the subject of this chapter, reflect their status as members of a group that was for centuries treated as a pariah sub-population. Thus, I’ll begin with a brief overview of the history of the buraku people and the most pressing problems that continue to impede their social mobility and wellbeing. The next section contains a review of educational trends, including efforts by government agencies and buraku activists to reform the Japanese educational system and statistics tracing the scholastic progress of buraku children compared with that of their counterparts in other groups, majority and minority. This review will serve as background for my discussion of findings from a long-term research project conducted in one of Osaka’s largest buraku communities. My assignment was to study the preschools attended by buraku children and the transition from preschool to elementary school. Although my small sample of schools precludes systematic data analysis and generalization, the data offer glimpses into school life as it is experienced by students that point to some of the sources of the persisting inequalities in the Japanese educational system and the factors that promote or hinder children’s academic performance. In the discussion that ends this chapter, I’ll consider the implications of my research for educational policy and practice in an increasingly diverse society.
Historical overview The history of the buraku people is long and complicated, and there appears to be no single, agreed-upon explanation of their origins, though it is clear that they have suffered from ostracism and severe discrimination since at least the beginning of the Tokugawa period (1603–1868), when they were designated as eta (literally, abundant filth) and/or hinin (non-human), assigned to occupations that not only placed them at the bottom of the social hierarchy, but were considered polluted and polluting because they involved direct contact with blood, death, or dirt (for example, butchering, leather work, grave digging, and sewage removal). Excluded from mainstream society, these outcastes were also subject to government regulations prescribing their place of residence (usually segregated slums, villages, or settlements), clothing and hair styles (to distinguish them from “real” or “human” Japanese), freedom of movement, and relations with others (for example, exchanges of money and goods had to be managed in such a way as to preclude physical contact). Even after the Meiji government, in the Emancipation Edict of 1871, abolished the status of eta and declared them emancipated “new commoners” (Shin-Heimin), and they came to be known by the less derogatory if euphemistic appellation Buraku-min (literally, people of the buraku, or village),
46
Sarane Spence Boocock
they continued to be regarded as inferior to “real” Japanese, and discrimination continued almost unabated.2 Though spontaneous protests erupted from time to time, organized resistance by buraku activists did not emerge until the twentieth century. The Suiheisha (Levelers Society) was created in 1922 with the aim of achieving full emancipation by exposing all forms of discrimination. A highly controversial tactic introduced by Suiheisha was denunciation and retribution (kyūdan tōsō), which forced perpetrators of hate speech and injurious acts toward burakumin to apologize and offer compensation. After World War II, new organizations arose that tended to favor a “tactical shift from individual retaliation to attack on the broader issues of social and economic inequality,” by gaining government support for improved living conditions and elimination of specific discriminatory practices in housing, education, and employment (Shimahara 1984: 341). Since the 1990s, buraku activists have been lobbying for a comprehensive national law on buraku rights and cooperating with international organizations and networks fighting for minority rights worldwide. It should be kept in mind, however, that the buraku liberation movement is not encompassed in a single monolithic organization, but is more accurately viewed as a collection of organizations that share a commitment to ending discrimination against buraku people but are highly diverse in: •
•
•
ideology: disagreements continue to arise over whether anti-buraku discrimination should be broadly or narrowly defined, and should be viewed as a caste-based or class-based problem; strategy: disagreements continue to arise over whether it is more advantageous to work through regular government channels and seek legal remedies to specific problems or to use more aggressive tactics and seek “a transformation of Japanese society that will liberate all oppressed Japanese” (Su-Lan Reber 1999: 34); membership: organizations differ considerably in the social status of members, the number of non-buraku members, and the political affiliation of members (some welcome members who also belong to communist or socialist parties, others explicitly exclude them).3
The status of burakumin today Although anti-buraku discrimination has been officially abolished, and widely held beliefs about the inferiority of burakumin have been discredited by scientific research since the 1970s, prejudice is difficult to eradicate. A New Zealand scholar who engaged in extensive ethnographic research in a buraku community in Osaka argues that the belief that there is something inherently “wrong” with burakumin and something shameful about having buraku ancestry remains strong and continues to be transmitted from one generation to the next among many mainstream Japanese and some burakumin as well (McLauchlan 2002: 91–2). Another scholar concluded that “discrimination has not so much disappeared as taken on new, more subtle forms” that continue to relegate burakumin to inferior
The schooling of buraku children 47 social status and limit their opportunities (Monnet 2001: xi). Among the constraints on social mobility and wellbeing, often referred to collectively as buraku mondai, the following are perhaps the most tenacious. Living conditions Many buraku communities today bear little physical resemblance to the ghettoes of the past (see, for example, the photographs of dilapidated housing and unkempt inhabitants, and verbal descriptions of drunkenness and violent behavior in De Vos and Wagatsuma’s Japan’s invisible race (1967), an ethnographic study conducted during the 1960s). Since passage of the Special Measures Laws of 1969, substantial infusions of government funds into designated buraku communities have produced impressive improvements in housing and communal facilities— though, at the end of the twentieth century, approximately a thousand buraku communities had yet to be officially recognized as such and thus become eligible for financial assistance. Still, the visibility of improved living conditions in many communities has generated resentment and claims of reverse discrimination, especially among less affluent majority Japanese who have not benefited either from Japan’s rapid economic growth or from minority entitlements, and these entitlements are now being phased out (Kitaguchi 1999: Chapter 6; Su-Lan Reber 1999: 46–7; McLauchlan 2002: 91–2, 2003: 36–7). Employment Though employment rates and wages have gone up since the 1970s, buraku adults are still twice as likely as majority adults, to work in dangerous, insecure and dirty areas of demolition and construction, more than twice as likely to be unemployed, only half as likely to work for the “bigger and better” companies with 300 or more employees on the payroll, only half as likely to receive promotion, and almost forty per cent less likely to be earning above national average pay rates. (McLauchlan 2002: 88) Their wages may have gone up, but so have everyone else’s, the latter usually more. They’re still more likely to be hired on a “last on, first off” basis, and the ratio of buraku welfare recipients to non-buraku welfare recipients has remained about 6:1 since the 1970s (McLauchlan 2003: 53–4, 62). Marriage On the one hand, the number of mixed marriages increased steadily and substantially throughout the twentieth century, from around 3 percent of all buraku marriages in 1919, to 34 percent in 1963, and 57.5 percent in 1993, with marriages between non-buraku men and buraku women averaging two to three times those
48 Sarane Spence Boocock between buraku men and non-buraku women. On the other hand, surveys taken during the 1980s and 1990s indicated that acceptance of such marriages was far from universal: a 1993 study of mixed marriages in Kyoto prefecture showed, for example, that a third of these marriages had been opposed by parents, siblings, and/or other relatives, and that only about two-thirds of the couples visited their parents regularly after the marriage (McLauchlan 1999: 8–10). Burakumin may experience rejection from other minorities as well as from majority Japanese. A buraku parent interviewed by McLauchlan (2003: 139) recalled receiving a phone call from the parents of a Korean man their daughter was dating, who told them, “I’m sorry to say this but we are quite proud of our Korean ancestry so we would never allow our son to marry a buraku girl.” An indicator of the persistence of anti-buraku discrimination in employment and marriage is the extensive availability and use of chimei sōkan, directories listing the names and addresses, and sometimes occupations and other background information, of burakumin throughout Japan. Though illegal since 1969, chimei sōkan continue to be compiled and to be used by corporations and families for background checks of potential employees and marriage candidates (Su-Lan Reber 1999: 13). Family and temple registers are also used to screen potential marriage candidates, though this too is illegal. Since the late 1990s, ordinances prohibiting businesses from using discriminatory criteria when hiring new employees have been passed in Osaka and in several prefectures, though it is too soon to assess their effectiveness (McLauchlan 1999: 7). Discriminatory acts and attitudes Investigations of anti-buraku discrimination in the Osaka area carried out in the late 1990s showed an increase in the total number of discriminatory public statements, as well as threatening graffiti, posters and stickers, and harassing telephone calls, letters and Internet messages. A report published in the Buraku Kaihō Shimbun included photographs of graffiti and posters with the following messages: “Burakumin cause AIDS,” “Drop atomic bombs on burakumin neighborhoods,” and “Die eta filth.” Remarks posted on the Internet included: “Kill all the buraku people” and “Put buraku people into poison gas cells and liquidate them.” Though the reports concluded that incitement to abuse of burakumin has been increasing in many parts of Japan, it is unclear from the evidence available whether there has been an actual increase in discriminatory acts or an increase in the reporting of such acts as a result of recent legal prohibitions (Ishikawa 2001; McLauchlan 2003). In a 1993 nationwide survey of some 24,000 people that included questions designed to measure mainstream attitudes toward buraku and awareness of buraku mondai, it was found that over a third of the respondents were unaware that buraku people and communities were politically created, though awareness varied by region (from 95 percent in the Kinki region, to 73 percent in the Kantō region, to only 41 percent of those living in Hokkaidō and Tōhoku). About 10 percent of majority Japanese claimed never to have come into contact with a buraku
The schooling of buraku children 49 person, and a similar proportion believed that burakumin differ racially from other Japanese. When asked how they would react to learning that a close neighbor came from a buraku community, nearly all (88 percent) claimed, “I wouldn’t care and I would preserve our close relationship,” but less than half said that they would “respect the will of my child” if that child were to marry someone from a buraku community. Ironically, residents of regions with the highest proportion of residents who were well informed about buraku issues had the most negative attitudes toward intermarriage—knowledge per se did not appear to erase prejudice. Finally, only about one-fourth of the respondents felt positive toward teaching about buraku issues in schools (Su-Lan Reber 1999: 39; Akuzawa 2003; McLauchlan 2003: 12). If many mainstream Japanese are unaware of buraku mondai, many others believe (or prefer to believe) that they will eventually solve themselves or simply disappear, as a result of social change and greater tolerance of diversity, and as burakumin become more like “real” Japanese. The view that the buraku problem is best left alone is encapsulated in the often-quoted phrase: Neta ko wa sono mama (Don’t wake a sleeping baby). The implication is that further discussion of the inequalities suffered by burakumin and further actions designed to rectify them “only serve to perpetuate a problem which, if ignored, would disappear” (Neary 1997: 63). Coping with buraku mondai Faced with the limitations and stresses associated with their minority status, burakumin have tended to adopt one of the following strategies: •
•
•
Strategy 1: Stay in the buraku community and seek security among relatives and friends (“self-segregation” or “protective cocoon” strategy). Among the buraku residents interviewed by McLauchlan (2003) and Shimahara (1995), the most common reasons for staying there were variations of the following: “I feel safe,” “I belong here,” “We have a community where close relations are maintained,” or “I could make my way on the outside, but it is so much easier here.” Su-Lan Reber (1999: 57) found that: “Many parents do not want their children to enter the outside world for fear that they will have to face the harsh realities of discrimination.” Strategy 2: Embrace buraku identity and take an active part in the liberation movement for full emancipation (“activist” or “tōsō” (struggle) strategy). Buraku activist groups are generally concerned with improving social as well as material conditions, though, as noted above, there are disagreements between groups over the most effective tactics to combat discriminatory practices and attitudes. Strategy 3: Abandon buraku identity and relocate someplace where people don’t know or don’t care about one’s former identity (“passing” strategy). McLauchlan (2003: 26) believes that the numbers of burakumin who have passed successfully into mainstream society are substantial and increasing
50
Sarane Spence Boocock rapidly, though he acknowledges that, given the secrecy associated with this strategy (people attempting to pass are by definition reluctant to reveal their identity to potential employers or marriage partners, or to researchers), the data needed to test this claim do not exist. A second form of passing is emigration to another country, where the disadvantages suffered in their home country may decrease or disappear altogether. John Ogbu points to the relative success of burakumin in the United States as an example of the benefits of voluntary migration: “no longer overwhelmed by the traditional prejudice and discrimination associated with caste status, (buraku immigrants) have as much opportunity as the other Japanese immigrants to improve their social and occupational status through individual efforts” (Ogbu 1978: 320). He goes on to argue that this finding discredits theories that attribute the gaps between burakumin and mainstream Japanese to genetic or cultural differences. This argument is, however, weakened by the fact that it is based primarily upon a single study carried out in the 1960s, with a very limited sample (Itō 1967).4
Given the lack of comparable empirical evidence, one can only speculate on the numbers of burakumin who have chosen each of these strategies and their relative effectiveness. Since the 1980s, moreover, the status of burakumin has been further complicated by increasing within-group social stratification, which has bifurcated many buraku communities into a two-tiered class structure, with a few at the top who have been able to advance by taking advantage of new economic, educational, and occupational opportunities, and a much greater number, some very poor, at the bottom who lack the economic or cultural capital to advance (Ikeda 2001; Hawkins 1989). Dōwa education Under the slogan “Buraku liberation begins and ends in education,” the BLL has sought a variety of reforms under the general rubric of dōwa education.5 Originally conceived as a vehicle for eliminating discrimination and poverty by informing children about their own history, as well as enhancing their cognitive abilities and social skills, dōwa education today is an umbrella concept covering a wide range of educational initiatives, by governmental agencies as well as by the buraku liberation movement, though the two institutions tend to define the problem somewhat differently and propose somewhat different solutions. Government policies and programs have generally focused on: • •
improving facilities and services and schools attended by buraku children, including assigning additional teachers to provide compensatory education; distributing curricular materials about buraku history and government measures to overcome discrimination against burakumin (though these materials are generally offered in special classes for buraku children, rather than being required for all students);
The schooling of buraku children 51 • •
providing financial aid to buraku students; supporting community activities for buraku children and youth.
For the buraku liberation movement, dōwa education is defined more broadly, from attaining parity in education achievement and in rates of enrollment in secondary and post-secondary educational institutions, to the ultimate goal of “democratizing the whole society to attain true equality of opportunity for buraku and other oppressed populations” (Hirasawa and Nabeshima 1995: 3; italics added). All schools, including but not limited to, those attended by buraku children should: • • • •
•
develop the learning capacities of all students and ensure that all achieve the level of literacy expected of citizens of a highly developed industrial nation; deepen students’ knowledge about the history of the buraku people and the nature of anti-buraku discrimination; cultivate caring and cooperative relations among children; develop human rights awareness and sensitivities among children so that they regard the issue of eradicating discrimination, not as someone else’s responsibility, but as their own concern; promote community involvement in setting the school agenda.
Embedded in dōwa goals and teaching practices is the concept of inclusiveness. All minority students, not just buraku students, are to be enabled to succeed in school, and all students, not just minority students, are to be sensitized and informed about the history and extensiveness of discrimination and ways to fight it. Achievement of these objectives clearly requires fundamental changes in teaching principles and practices and in curriculum. Thus, buraku activists in one school district demanded district-wide adoption of a set of texts, compiled and edited by Buraku Kaihō Dōmei, containing readings on a broad range of human rights issues and including poems and essays authored by buraku children. Many dōwa educators are opposed to any form of tracking that divides children on the basis of test scores or other so-called “objective” measures of ability or merit, or that separates children with physical or mental disabilities from their age mates, arguing that multiple intelligences and diverse potentials of students should be acknowledged and accommodated in all classrooms (Hawkins 1989: 205; Hirasawa and Nabeshima 1995: 21–2, 59–60). In the next section, we’ll turn to a brief consideration of the major shifts in educational outcomes since the introduction of dōwa education.
Educational trends: progress and problems As educational opportunities for buraku children have opened up nationwide, there have been concomitant improvements in their educational performance. At the same time, they continue to lag behind majority Japanese students on virtually all measures of academic attainment and achievement, to manifest more
52 Sarane Spence Boocock psychological and behavior problems, and to be negatively stereotyped by other kids, as well as by teachers and other adults. Educational enrollment The overall picture is of improved school attendance, with total years of schooling and levels of literacy increasing with each successive generation of buraku children. Yet the rate of persistent, long-term absenteeism among buraku children is almost twice the national averages from primary through junior high school. Overall, the entry of buraku children into senior high school is close to that of the mainstream, 91.8 percent, compared with over 96 percent for the non-buraku samples, but high school drop-out rates, although declining since the 1970s, remain two to three times as high as for majority children. Similarly, access to higher education has improved considerably, but still only half as many buraku as non-buraku students (about 20 percent and 40 percent, respectively) advance to university or college.
Educational achievement Here, too, there has been significant progress since the 1970s, to the extent that: “Average discrepancies in statistics in educational achievement between burakumin and mainstream society are mostly well below 10 percent.” At the same time, “there are almost no recorded situations where the statistics for buraku education surpass, or even match those of mainstream society” (McLauchlan 1999: 16). Moreover, the discrepancy between buraku and majority students becomes greater as they progress through the school system—analysis of data from three large-scale projects carried out during the 1990s in the Osaka area showed that, the higher the grade, the greater the gap in test scores and other performance indicators (Neary 1997: 70–1; Ikeda 2001; McLauchlan 2003: 38–43). Emotional problems Although the achievement gap remains stubbornly resistant to recent efforts to erase or at least reduce it substantially, differences between buraku and majority students on indicators of low self-esteem, high anxiety and other emotional disturbances, and negative relationships with teachers and classmates, all significantly greater among buraku children at the elementary school level, became less evident at the middle school level and insignificant by adolescence. Moreover, the correlation between self-esteem and academic achievement, also substantial at the elementary level, was no longer significant among middle school students. Ikeda attributes the buraku adolescents’ relatively high self-esteem to peer group support that may “nullify the negative effects of their school experience” (Ikeda 2001: 89–91).
The schooling of buraku children 53 Behavior problems In recent years, the phenomenon of gakkyū hōkai (breakdown of classroom order resulting from students refusing to follow rules or instructions, fighting among themselves, and insulting, threatening, or even assaulting their teachers) has been increasing throughout Japan, affecting as many as 10 percent of elementary and middle schools in some regions. Although gakkyū hōkai is now viewed as a national problem, buraku students, especially boys, account for a disproportionate amount of disruptive and delinquent behavior in and outside of school. In one of the two elementary schools where I did fieldwork in 1996, buraku students had collectively defied their teachers, creating such chaos in one fifth-grade class that the teacher, a man with many years of teaching experience, was forced to turn over the class to another teacher in the middle of the school year (Ikeda 2001: 84). Discrimination (sabetsu) and stereotyping (kimetsuke) Buraku children today are unlikely to experience the kind of rejection that was still fresh in the memory of a woman now in her thirties. Arriving at school the day after her buraku origins had been revealed to a non-buraku classmate, she found that: My desk had been pushed into the corridor and all my pencils and things had been tipped out on the teacher’s desk. From that day on, I was teased until I became completely isolated. I was never prevented from going to school as such, but I really hated it . . . I would leave home each day and say I was going to school, but I didn’t go. (McLauchlan 2003: 127) While such blatant, overt discrimination may be largely a thing of the past, more subtle forms persist. Shimahara (1980, Chapter 4) and McLauchlan (2003, Chapter 5) both report examples of teachers’ reluctance to participate in dōwa or other human rights education programs. I was unprepared for the extent of stigmatizing of buraku kids by teachers and administrators and their readiness to shift the blame for students’ school failures to their homes and communities. Within the first few minutes of our introductory meeting with the principal of an elementary school in which about 40 percent of the students were burakumin, we were told that the problem with the buraku children was that they run around a lot, make too much noise, and can’t concentrate. Among the non-buraku teachers and day care personnel I interviewed, the most frequent complaints were that parents (or grandparents) spoiled the kids, failed to provide adequate supervision and discipline, didn’t feed them properly, let them stay up too late and watch too much television, and didn’t get them to school on time. Poor childrearing was also attributed to the parents’ drinking too much and spending too many evenings in karaoke bars.
54 Sarane Spence Boocock Buraku leaders are more likely to view continuing discrimination rather than shortcomings in buraku families and culture as the source of school problems. Kimetsuke (stereotyping), a key concept in dōwa educational theory, came up often in my conversations with dōwa educators and researchers, who believe that it is an important factor in children’s personal development and relations with others, that it begins in infancy, and that it explains buraku kids’ greater likelihood of being discriminated against and their greater likelihood both to be bullied and to bully other kids. Another indicator of continuing discrimination is ekkyō (literally “going beyond the border”), the tendency of majority parents to transfer their kids to schools with few or no buraku or other minority students, a phenomenon that continues despite passage of a law requiring children to attend their neighborhood schools. Finally, it is worth keeping in mind that, even in a rich society such as Japan, problems associated with poverty remain and are not evenly distributed, and that buraku children are still more likely than majority children to suffer from malnutrition and a variety of other health problems that interfere with their school performance (Hirasawa and Nabeshima 1995). Ikeda reminds us, however, that, owing to the growing status gap among burakumin, variations in all educational outcomes are as great among buraku students as are the differences between buraku students and majority students: “In spite of the fact that discrimination persists, we commit the error of oversimplifying the present state of buraku children and youth if we do not take social diversification into account” (Ikeda 2001: 79).
The Kanda Project6 The Osaka metropolitan area is home to the largest concentration of buraku people in Japan (about 12 percent of the total population of Osaka) and relatively large numbers of several other minorities as well. Most of the following discussion is based upon an in-depth study of one of Osaka’s largest buraku communities. In physical appearance, Kanda does not differ noticeably from neighboring communities, and a visitor unfamiliar with the area’s history might not be aware that they were in a formerly segregated, outcaste community. Government subsidies in support of housing, employment, education, community facilities, and health care have raised the standard of living, though average household income remains somewhat lower than that of the surrounding majority communities. In the 1990s, a relatively high proportion of burakumin were employed in the public sector, and more than half the residents lived in public housing units that could be passed on from one generation to their children, an entitlement not available to non-buraku public housing residents. There is a well-established local branch of the BLL, which maintains close relationships with the schools in the community, as well as offering a variety of recreational and educational activities for children and their families. Despite various forms of government support to the dōwa preschools and the elementary school in Kanda, the academic performance of the buraku students
The schooling of buraku children 55 continued to be lower than that of their non-buraku counterparts, and they also accounted for a disproportionate number of behavior problems, including the incident mentioned earlier in which a fifth-grade teacher lost control of his class and was forced to quit midyear. In an effort to address the difficult educational problems they were facing, Kanda educators and officials of the BLL local office sought the advice of Professor Hiroshi Ikeda and colleagues at Osaka University, which had since the 1980s been a center for research on the education of buraku and other Japanese minority children, resulting in a collaborative project between the university and the community. A small group of researchers at the Rutgers University Graduate School of Education, headed by Nobuo Shimahara, joined the project during the late spring and early summer of 1995 and 1996. As a member of the Rutgers research team, I focused on early childhood care and education and the transition from preschool to elementary school. Table 3.1 lists the sites where my observations were made. Schools that had been designated as dōwa schools or programs and were thus eligible for government entitlements enabling them to hire extra staff and maintain smaller class sizes are indicated with a b. In my first year of fieldwork, I spent several hours a day, three or more days a week, in Preschool A, a dōwa hoiku-sho (day care center) in which all of the children currently enrolled were burakumin. For purposes of comparison, I made Table 3.1 Preschools and elementary schools observed, 1995–96 Preschoolsa
Elementary schoolsa
Preschool A: Kanda Dai-2 Hoiku-shob Ages: 3–5 Buraku enrolment: almost 100%
School A: Kanda Elementary Schoolb Grades: 1–6 Buraku enrolment: about 40%
Preschool B: Kanda Yōchien Ages: 3–5 Buraku enrolment: 5% or less
School B: Tomita Elementary School Grades: 1–6 Buraku enrolment: 5% or less
Preschool C: Kanda Dai-1 Hoiku-shob Ages: 0–2 Buraku enrolment: almost 100% Preschool D: Shiawase Hoiku-shob Ages: 0–5 Buraku enrolment: almost 100% Preschool E: Tokiwa Yōchienb Ages: 5 Buraku enrolment: 100% Preschool F: Hotaru Hoiku-shob Ages: 0–5 Buraku enrolment: 5–10% Notes: a All names of schools and communities are pseudonyms. b Designated dōwa educational programme.
56
Sarane Spence Boocock
briefer observations at Preschool B, a yōchien (kindergarten) in the same community that was not a dōwa preschool but that enrolled children of the same age range as Preschool A, including a few buraku children.7 I also visited Kanda’s dōwa day care center for children from infancy through age two (Preschool C). In my second year of fieldwork, I focused upon the two first-grade classes at Kanda Elementary School (School A), where some of the children I had observed in Preschool A the previous year were now enrolled. For comparison, I spent several days in an elementary school (School B) in a neighboring community. I also visited three preschools elsewhere in the Osaka area, chosen to provide variation in the proportion of buraku children enrolled and the extent to which the curriculum and modes of teaching incorporated dōwa educational principles and practices. At the end of the second year, I revisited the Kanda day care centers and met with their staff to exchange ideas about strengthening their programs. In both years, I also interviewed teachers and caretakers, school principals and preschool directors, and community leaders. Background information about buraku educational issues and dōwa early childhood care and education was obtained through interviews and informal conversations with staff members of the Buraku Liberation Research Institute, in Osaka, and through use of their library. Daily life in two preschools McLauchlan notes that buraku children are more than twice as likely as their majority counterparts to be placed in hoiku-sho, a difference he attributes to a higher proportion of dual-working parents among burakumin, but that is also undoubtedly because, unlike majority Japanese, they are entitled to enroll their children in government-subsidized day care even if both parents are not employed outside the home (another buraku entitlement now being phased out). This was certainly the case in Kanda, where nearly all of the kids in the dōwa day care program were buraku and nearly all the kids in the kindergarten were non-buraku. McLauchlan goes on to argue that, by attending full-day hoiku-sho rather than the more expensive, though mainly half-day, yōchien, buraku kids are “thereby missing out on the Japanese kindergarten emphasis on curriculum and formal learning” (McLauchlan 2003: 39; italics added). While my observations in these two preschools did not allow a systemic test of McLauchlan’s supposition, it did stimulate me to explore what children gain and lose in each type of preschool. Kanda Dai-2 Hoiku-sho (Preschool A) was a two-storied, L-shaped building that occupied a corner lot of a quiet residential street a couple blocks from Kanda’s main thoroughfare. The ground floor contained, in addition to classrooms, the administrative offices and a kitchen where the children’s lunches were prepared. On the second floor was a gymnasium, large enough to hold the entire student body and staff, and storage and laundry rooms. The building and grounds were surrounded by a fence with a single entrance gate. The space between the building and the entrance provided a large outdoor play area. At the outer corner of the property, surrounded by another metal fence with a padlocked gate, was
The schooling of buraku children 57 the swimming pool, essentially a large wading pool, where each class went for about thirty minutes on days when the weather permitted. As a dōwa preschool, Kanda Dai-2 Hoiku-sho received extra public funding that enabled it to have a high teacher-to-child ratio. In 1995, there was one class each of three-year-olds (twenty-five children), four-year-olds (twenty-four children), and five-year-olds (twenty-one children), each of which had two fulltime hobo-san. Two of the six hobo-san were burakumin. A few blocks away and bordering on Kanda Elementary School was Kanda Yōchien (Preschool B), a single-storied, L-shaped building. From the administrative office at one end near the building entrance, a corridor led to the gymnasium/ all-purpose room, and past that a right turn led to a row of classrooms. Like Preschool A, Preschool B had one class each of three-, four-, and five-year-olds, but here class size was between thirty and thirty-five children, with a single teacher for each class. Preschool B now enrolled “a few” buraku children, though there has apparently been no systematic effort on the school’s part to recruit more. In contrast to my Rutgers colleagues observing in Kanda Elementary School, who often returned from a day of fieldwork disheartened by what they saw, my days at the preschools were enjoyable as well as engrossing. For the most part, the daily routines I observed were familiar, similar to those I had seen elsewhere in Japan and in other nations as well. As I spent more time in Preschools A and B, however, I began to notice differences in the two environments, particularly with respect to: 1.
2.
the relative emphasis placed upon good interpersonal relationships (taijin kankei) and harmonious group life (shūdan seikatsu), as opposed to preparing children to succeed academically in school (junbi kyōiku); the relative effort devoted to avoiding all forms of discrimination (sabetsu) and stereotyping (kimetsuke) and including all children in the daily routines of preschool life.
Shūdan seikatsu versus junbi kyōiku The general atmosphere at Dai-2 Hoiku-sho could be characterized as warm, cheerful, and comfortable. “Correct” or “good” behavior was seldom taught in a formal way; rather, the hobo-san drew upon what seemed an endless repertoire of singing games and other enjoyable ways to teach personal habits such as brushing teeth and changing clothes. They often played with the kids rather than just supervising their play, and they orchestrated the lengthy day by alternating periods of vigorous physical activity with interludes of quiet play, listening to stories, and rest (each child had her own futon and blanket and changed into pajamas for a post-lunch nap). Little time was spent in disciplining children. Kids were not scolded for mishaps such as spilling paint or food; in most cases they cleaned up after themselves with little or no adult supervision. Fights were rare, and I saw no temper tantrums or bullying (ijime), the latter acknowledged to be a problem in Kanda Yōchien as
58
Sarane Spence Boocock
well as in the elementary school. Crying children received prompt attention and comforting, with no effort to identify and punish a culprit. In most of the activities I observed, there seemed to be greater emphasis on having a good time with one’s classmates than on developing specific physical or cognitive skills. For example, the daily sessions at the “swimming” pool began and ended with a few minutes of free play, during which most of the kids simply milled about in the water screaming happily. There was no formal swimming instruction. Hobo-sans sometimes provided informal coaching on arm or leg movements, but I never saw a child actually swim more than a few tentative strokes. Group activities might require children to work in pairs or teams—for example, walking across the pool and back holding hands with a partner, or joining with teammates to retrieve colored plastic disks thrown into the pool by a hobo-san— but none required actual swimming, and there were no winners or losers. Kids who were awaiting or had finished their turn were led by the hobo-san in yelling encouragement to the kids in the water and applauding them when they completed their task. The sessions sometimes ended with a brief ritual—for example, in one class, children and hobo-san joined hands and circled in the water, chanting in unison and ending with a cheer. Most of the arts and crafts periods I observed were informal. Children were seldom given a topic or any technical instruction. For example, in one drawing session in the age-four class, children picked up a sheet of paper from a pile and chose their own workspace, some at tables, others on the floor, a few on a bench in the hall outside the classroom. One boy circulated with a can of magic markers that were shared by all. Most of the girls drew pictures of girls, some with detailed renderings of facial expressions, clothing, and jewelry, a few showing considerable skill. Most of the boys’ drawings were more rudimentary renderings of spacecrafts, military vehicles, and explosions. Finished drawings were taken to a hobo-san, who wrote the artist’s name on the drawing and usually said something like “Well done,” but did not provide further comment or evaluation. The children appeared to be enjoying themselves, and many chatted as they worked. No one complained about the limited resources, and there was no squabbling over space or materials. By comparison, at Kanda Yōchien (Preschool B), the priorities seemed to be reversed. Though the director of Kanda Yōchien denied that they engage in junbi kyōiku, in the class for five-year-olds that I observed, the teacher led her thirtythree students through a series of counting songs and chants, during which kids were called upon to form groups of varying numbers. She then displayed and discussed a series of colorful paintings, which, I later learned, had been created by the kids working in han (more or less permanent classroom groups of five or six children who worked together on numerous tasks). Each of the paintings illustrated an episode from an obake (ghost) story that had been read to the class, and the children were preparing to use the paintings in a re-enactment of this story at an all-school assembly. The difference in expectations and levels of accomplishment was evident when the five-year-olds from Kanda Yōchien visited their age-mates at Dai-2 Hoikusho, and each of the two classes provided an entertainment for the other. While
The schooling of buraku children 59 both groups performed routines that involved vigorous bodily movements done in time to recorded music with a disco beat, the yōchien performance was longer, involved more complicated moves, and had the kind of polish that suggested it had been thoroughly rehearsed. The hoikyu-sho kids were more self-conscious about performing before an audience, some seemed barely familiar with the routine, and a few dropped out before the end. Although good group life was also a stated goal of Kanda Yōchien, I observed more misbehavior and less attention to the quality of interpersonal relations than in Preschool A. During classroom clean-up times, shifts from one activity to another, and passage to and from assembly, there was a lot of pushing and shoving and a few fights. The all-school assembly where the five-year-old class re-enacted the obake story was chaotic: the room was so noisy it was difficult to hear what was going on. Kids in the back of the room talked and fooled around throughout the program, and roughhousing by several pairs of boys had to be broken up by an adult staff member. Though I did not myself observe any instance of ijime, when I asked the director whether bullying was a problem, she said that it happened and that it was usually directed against a child who cried a lot, had an unusually small or weak body, or was otherwise “different.” Avoiding stereotypes, encouraging inclusiveness The effects of downplaying gender differences, a basic principle of dōwa education, were especially evident on the few occasions when I could compare Preschool A kids and Preschool B kids directly, for example, on the day the Preschool B five-year-olds visited Preschool A. During a period of outdoor play, I stationed myself near the sandbox area where a group of about fifteen kids from both preschools were constructing an ambitious mountain landscape surrounded by a moat, under the supervision of a hobo-san, a buraku woman who is a wellknown lecturer and writer about dōwa early childhood care and education as well as a full-time caretaker-teacher at Preschool A. At first, boys and girls alike dug vigorously and took pleasure in using the hose to spray each other as well as to fill the moat, but the girls from the yōchien soon withdrew to one side of the sandbox, where they sat down in pairs or small groups and spent the rest of the time creating play meals using some of the sandbox toys as dishes. I asked the hobo-san whether the girls and boys she taught engaged in the cross-sex avoidance and teasing that is reported in research on American preschools and elementary schools (for example, Paley 1984; Thorne 1993; Scott 2002, 2003). She seemed puzzled by the question and could not recall any such incidents. When I later asked the director of Preschool B the same question, she acknowledged that boys and girls tended to play separately, and characterized girl–boy relations from about age four as “exclusionary.” Some other practices designed to avoid gender stereotyping were more subtle, and I might have missed them had they not been pointed out to me by Professor Ryoko Kimura, a specialist in gender studies who accompanied me on several preschool visits. For example, at Kanda Dai-2 Hoiku-sho, the toothbrushes, cups,
60 Sarane Spence Boocock and other personal items provided by the school were all of the same color, rather than differentiating girls’ and boys’ items by color. At role call, children’s names were called in alphabetic order, instead of all boys’ names being called before girls’ names, as was formerly the custom in most Japanese classrooms. Sex segregation at lunchtime was avoided by assigning kids to tables that mixed girls and boys. During outdoor free play, I observed no instances of groups of one sex teasing or chasing kids of the opposite sex or calling them names. Older boys tended to chase each other, grouping and regrouping constantly, though they did not prevent girls from joining them. I frequently saw boys jumping rope with girls. The dōwa principle of inclusiveness meant, among other things, that the entire group, children and adults alike, were responsible for the wellbeing of all group members. During my second year of fieldwork, I observed two striking examples of the application of this principle to teaching practice. The first occurred during a visit to Hotaru Hoiku-sho (Preschool F), which had been identified by the specialist in dōwa preschool education at the Buraku Liberation Research Institute as the best preschool in Osaka at which buraku children were enrolled. (Ironically, Hotaru Hoiku-sho, a dōwa preschool that had “integrated,” now enrolled more non-buraku than buraku children.) When I entered the age-four class, the kids were seated in a circle engaged in the morning “conversation,” except for one little girl who was crying. Getting no response to her asking what was wrong, the hobo-san (a twenty-one-year-old woman in her first year of teaching) went to sit behind the girl, putting her arms around her. She then asked the group why they thought their friend was crying and what they might do about it. A number of suggestions were offered. One boy went to the sink, wet a towel, brought it back, and wiped the crying girl’s face. Finally, two girls suggested that their classmate might feel better if she could play in her favorite place and, with the hobo-san’s permission, they led her off to the play-house corner. The crying stopped almost immediately, and the rest of the group was released to their various activities. I was impressed by the skill with which a relatively inexperienced teacher involved the whole group in seeking a solution to the problem, encouraging them to empathize with an unhappy friend while making no effort to establish blame. Children with disabilities were few in number in any of the preschools I observed. At Preschool A, government funds provided for an assistant to aid in the care of a girl in the age-four class who was not able to walk or speak and a special buggy that enabled her to accompany her classmates on their daily round of activities. At nap time, the children in charge of laying out the futons and blankets placed hers in the center of the group so that she would be surrounded by her classmates during their rest period. The most impressive efforts at inclusiveness that I witnessed occurred during a visit to Preschool E, a yōchien for thirty-six five-year-olds located in an old and still largely segregated buraku neighborhood. As the rainy weather did not permit outdoor play, the kids were engaged in free play in the gym/multipurpose room, which had been turned into a kind of open classroom with a variety of play areas. Immediately upon the arrival of a very small girl whose disabilities have severely retarded her physical
The schooling of buraku children 61 development, two of her classmates came up to her, took her by the hand, and, talking all the while, led her to the “store” they had organized in one corner of the room. A little later, a teacher supervising play on the gymnastic equipment laid the girl gently on the trampoline, and several boys who had been jumping vigorously took turns bouncing gently so that she might share in their play without fear or injury. At no time during the morning was she without companions. Over lunch, I complimented the director and teachers on their success at integrating the girl into the daily life of the yōchien. They looked pleased and agreed that they have worked hard to accomplish this. The director said that, even though the girl does not speak yet and they don’t know whether she understands what is said to her, they feel that they can at least communicate with her emotionally. She also emphasized that all the students benefited from being a playmate to a disabled classmate. Summary of findings Though similar in many respects, the preschools I observed differed in the weight given to socializing young children to treat each other decently and play together harmoniously, versus preparing them for the next stage of their educational careers, where cognitive skills and the ability to work independently would be required. It’s difficult to assess the extent to which the differences I observed reflect differences in (a) curriculum and modes of teaching; (b) class sizes and student-to-teacher ratios (much higher in the yōchien); and/or (c) composition of the student body. While nearly all of the children enrolled in the Kanda Hoikusho were buraku whose parents were employed in working-class or low-level civil services occupations, the few buraku children enrolled in the yōchien generally came from higher-status families; their parents were more likely to have middleclass occupations and incomes and less likely to identify with, or associate much with, the buraku community in Kanda.8 Daily life in two elementary schools Kanda Elementary School (School A), my primary research site in 1996, is a threestory building housing two classes each for grades 1–6, plus administrative offices, a teachers’ room with a desk for each teacher (a desk was also made available to me for the duration of my fieldwork), a large gymnasium, a number of multipurpose rooms (for meetings as well as for music and other special classes), and a kitchen where the lunches for students and their teachers were prepared (to be wheeled to each classroom and distributed by a pair of students assigned to the task). Though considerably larger than the Kanda preschools I had studied the previous year, the building was similar in construction and general appearance. The school grounds contained playing fields and several playground areas equipped with slides, swings, jungle gyms, and parallel bars. Most of my time in School A was spent in the two first-grade classes, each of which had a total enrollment of twenty-eight students, with eleven buraku children
62
Sarane Spence Boocock
in one class and nine in the other. As in the previous year, I also visited a second school in the vicinity for comparative purposes. Tomita Elementary School (School B) enrolled a small number of buraku children but had not been designated as a dōwa school or program. As Preschool A is a feeder school for School A, I was able to observe how some of the kids I had gotten to know in the Dai-2 Hoiku-sho age-five group were getting along in first grade. Although only a few blocks separated Preschool A and School A, in many ways they seemed worlds apart, and it appeared that the transition from preschool to elementary school was not going smoothly for some of the buraku children. By the third month of first grade, when I began my observations, a few of the boys were already considered to have serious behavior problems. The girls, who had seemed so lively and sociable at Dai-2 Hoiku-sho, were now virtually silent and frequently inattentive in class. Although many factors may have contributed to the striking differences between life in preschool and life in elementary school, it seems noteworthy that, for most of the buraku kids, entering first grade at School A meant encountering for the first time: 1. 2. 3.
an unchallenging curriculum, with mainly isseijugyō (whole-class) and drillfocused modes of teaching; a frequently chaotic learning environment (gakkyū hōkai), requiring considerable time to be devoted to disciplining students; awareness of their status as members of a minority group that is not well regarded by many majority Japanese.
As we’ll see, School A also differed from School B with regard to these three factors—indicating that they are not universal or inevitable aspects of elementary school life. Curriculum and teaching methods Although a government-approved, uniform curriculum for all Japanese elementary schools is mandated by the Ministry of Education, comparisons of Kanda Elementary School and Tomita Elementary School revealed striking differences in curriculum and modes of teaching and classroom management. My notes on School A contain frequent references to the “barebones” curriculum, lack of stimulating tasks, and slow pace of instruction. The Kanda first graders spent much of the day seated at their desks facing front, being drilled on a pair of hiragana (phonetic characters of the Japanese syllabic alphabet) and a pair of numbers. In both classes, the teachers worked hard to make their presentations clear and lively, and they sometimes enlisted a student to assist them in pantomiming a word or picture that used that day’s hiragana or numbers, but the students’ role was largely passive—they answered questions when called upon, worked individually in workbooks or on handouts from the teacher, and waited for their written work to be checked. Boys frequently broke the class rule against shouting answers without
The schooling of buraku children 63 being called upon or got into trouble for fighting or horsing around. The girls, who rarely misbehaved, received less of the teacher’s attention. The lessons were boring, and time dragged. I often had a hard time staying awake. In general, I saw little use of the much-vaunted Japanese practice of smallgroup (han) work, with the exception of a project in which students working in teams jointly created a large mural of the sea featuring a variety of fish and underwater plant life. This was one of the few occasions when most of the kids seemed thoroughly involved in their work, and their obvious pride in the outcome (the mural was incorporated into class discussions for several days and then hung in the hall) made me wonder why more of their class work was not structured in this way. As part of the effort to reduce the gap in academic competence between buraku children and non-buraku children, a director of dōwa education was employed at Kanda Elementary School. Though a few buraku students were now in the top third of their class, the school had not succeeded in narrowing the gap overall, and the director took issue with those: who suggest that when we maintain the same level of gap it is an accomplishment of the school. It is extremely difficult to say what the school has accomplished through dōwa education. I can say that perhaps buraku children’s school achievement would have deteriorated without our efforts. I cannot really suggest that buraku children have gained significantly in terms of school achievement. (Shimahara, interview with Director of dōwa education, Kanda Elementary School, July 25, 1995) All they could claim to have done, she concluded, was to maintain the status quo. Just a few blocks away, the first graders at Tomita Elementary School, which enrolled a small number of buraku children whose identity was not known to all the school personnel, were enjoying a far richer educational environment. By the time of my visits, they had learned all of the hiragana and were already reading stories (when I left in early July, the Kanda first graders had not yet progressed from simple, mainly two-syllable, words to sentences, let alone stories). In one class, the students recited the entire hiragana syllabary in the form of a song, after which four of them were asked to stand up and, one by one, repeat the song solo. At the end of each solo, the teacher asked the rest of the class for its assessment of the performance, and only after it agreed that the song had been correctly rendered did she give the signal to applaud the singer. During my second visit to School B, the other first-grade class was in the midst of a reading lesson on two stories of three or four pages each. For the first story, the teacher had individual students read a passage aloud, emphasizing that they should speak loudly (ōkina koe de) and clearly (hakkiri) and asking those who spoke softly or inaudibly to repeat the passage. The second story was acted out by the students. One scene called for a monkey character to leave the room and come back carrying a large ring of keys. This pantomime appeared to be a favorite
64 Sarane Spence Boocock with the students, and they were allowed to repeat it several times with different kids in the monkey role. The teacher took time to work individually with a handicapped boy (who was also assigned a classroom aide) on his part in the pantomime and gave him a big hug when he performed it successfully. The lesson ended with a dictation exercise in which the student and teacher roles were reversed—students read out sentences from the monkey story, and the teacher wrote them on the board. Finally, he asked me to tell the class the English words for some of the words in the story and had the students repeat them after me ōkina koe de. Chaotic classrooms (gakkyū hōkai) The buraku children who had attended a dōwa preschool moved from an environment in which good behavior and pleasant interpersonal relations were the norm to an environment in which students disrupted their classes, bullied and fought each other, and left the classroom or school building without permission. Owing to its reputation as a “difficult” school, few of the teachers at Kanda Elementary School had chosen to teach there; in the past years, three teachers had taken leave from the school in the middle of the academic year owing to fatigue and stress. Although student misbehavior was not considered as problematic in the lower grades as the higher ones, in both first-grade classes I observed, considerable class time was spent maintaining order and disciplining students. In both classes, the noise level was sometimes high enough to give me a headache, and fights occurred almost daily among boys (most, though not all, buraku). Both first-grade teachers impressed me as hard-working and committed professionals, but they seemed to lack effective strategies for dealing with the problems they confronted, and both looked exhausted by the end of the school day. The school’s director of dōwa education regularly patrolled the school corridors and sometimes dropped in to the class I was observing. She generally hovered behind the back row of seats, stepping in to monitor the behavior of boys who were not sitting correctly or paying attention and occasionally to break up a fight. The misbehavior of a few children and the disproportionate amount of teacher time and attention directed to them caused me for some time to overlook the fact that most of the children were behaving well—if behaving well is defined as not making trouble. Indeed, I was impressed, though also saddened, by the stoicism with which they endured the long school day and repetitive tasks set for them. On one particularly discomforting occasion, the female teacher spent half an hour trying (unsuccessfully) to get one boy to confess to hitting another boy and calling him insulting names, throughout which the other children sat in silence, almost motionless, staring into space. The atmosphere was palpably different in School B, where almost no class time was spent disciplining students—perhaps because there were frequent breaks throughout the day during which the kids were allowed to let off steam by running up and down the corridors, yelling, banging on an old upright piano, and joking
The schooling of buraku children 65 with the teachers. I saw no fights, and the kids returned to their classrooms after each break with scant adult intervention. Awareness of minority status From being virtually 100 percent of the enrollment in the dōwa hoiku-sho in Kanda, the buraku children who entered Kanda Elementary School now constituted a minority, albeit a sizeable one. Parents interviewed by Shimahara (1995) believed that their children had not encountered the kinds of prejudice they themselves had experienced. At the same time, they worried that kids today lacked confidence in themselves as buraku and courage to fight discrimination. One parent recalled that her children not only concealed their identity, but discouraged their parents from attending parent–teacher meetings at their school for fear they would reveal their buraku origins. Kanda as a community was criticized, by BLL officials as well as by school personnel, for allowing its children “to stay wrapped in the cocoon of the community,” and thereby failing to prepare them for the world outside. Research in other buraku communities has documented the difficulties kids experience when they leave the cocoon. Okano and Tsuchiya (1999: 127) found that buraku children living in segregated villages or neighborhoods may be unaware of anti-buraku attitudes and discrimination until they enter schools, where for the first time they “come into direct contact with the dominant culture.” Bondy (2004) posited a discontinuity between life in buraku communities where the liberation movement has been especially active and residents have become accustomed to subsidized housing, guaranteed jobs, and other affirmative action perks, and mainstream Japanese educational institutions, which are unlikely to embrace buraku liberation goals and values. Similarly, Nishida (1992) concluded that the kind of upbringing that enables buraku kids to “acquire a positive identity within a protective setting” may render them more vulnerable to discrimination once outside that setting—and may, eventually, motivate them to take the “easier” path of passing into majority society. From his in-depth studies of ninth-grade buraku boys, Ikeda proposed a more nuanced conceptualization of their social development and educational performance. In contrast to Ogbu’s cultural reproduction theory, which postulates that children of an “involuntary minority” develop an “oppositional culture” that is an inevitable outgrowth of their cultural background, Ikeda’s reinvention theory underscores the diversity, or non-homogeneity, among buraku boys (as among burakumin generally), which he views as an inevitable result of the increasing social differentiation between and within buraku communities. As their economic conditions and social environment have changed, including the appearance of class stratification based on income, solidarity within the buraku community has gradually broken down. Social consciousness among buraku people has accordingly begun to diverge, and likewise, the response of the buraku youth to school culture has varied as well. (Ikeda 2001: 82)
66
Sarane Spence Boocock
A typology developed by Ikeda classified boys according to the following four categories: 1.
2.
3.
4.
Delinquent boys, who are often truant from school, are likely to be members of gangs that engage in reckless or deviant behavior (e. g., speeding on motorcycles), and do not aspire to go on to senior high school. Corner boys, who are more interested in and better at sports than academics, do not openly rebel against school and teachers but may harbor ill feelings toward them. College boys, who perform well in school and intend to go on to college, are generally from relatively affluent families and do not socialize much with other buraku boys, either at school or in the community. Liberatory boys, who are active in the children’s group activities at the buraku community center (often their parents work for or are otherwise active in the BLL), do not excel academically but attend school regularly and do not engage in disruptive behavior.
While granting their shared history of oppression as a “common denominator” for all buraku kids, Ikeda maintains that: It is only one of the essential attributes that influence their social perspectives. Their identities are not mere reflections of their history and their community culture. Instead, their self-concepts are relatively autonomous, created through their encounters with school culture. Minority youth reinvent themselves in their own ways. (Ikeda 2001: 95; italics added) While Ikeda’s typology focused on the school experiences of buraku boys, my observations indicated that girls too were affected by their shift from majority to minority status. If the boys tended to respond to their new environment with disruptive behavior, the girls became more passive. They talked less than the boys in class and made no trouble during the tedious classroom drills, even when they had already mastered the material covered (it was only when I accompanied the class on a trip to the local library that I discovered that several of the girls knew how to read). The discussion periods that ended the school day (owari-no-kai), supposedly led by the student monitors, one male the other female, for that week, tended to be male dominated, especially in the class with a male teacher. In one owari-no-kai, the girl monitor, one of the smaller kids in the class, strove to give girls who raised their hands a chance to speak, but her voice was drowned out by boys who spoke out of turn or simply ignored her. The teacher overlooked most of the boys’ violations of the class rule against speaking out of turn and, on one occasion, called on a boy after the girl monitor had already recognized a girl—in effect taking over the monitor’s role as well as over-ruling her decision. Teachers and other school personnel did not appear to notice either the accomplishments of individual girls or their disengagement from classroom life.
The schooling of buraku children 67 For example, when I asked about a buraku girl who did outstanding art work, finished most seatwork assignments ahead of her classmates (and thus spent a fair amount of time waiting for the rest of the class to catch up), and clearly outperformed them on the playground apparatus (she was the only one who could jump over a row of barrels or swing across the parallel bars quickly, rhythmically and without pause), they did not seem much interested. The most thoughtful response I received was from a buraku official who acknowledged that, although dōwa ideology emphasizes equality for everyone, in fact, women remain subordinate to men in the liberation movement as well as in Japanese society, and that school life undoubtedly reflects this. The resilience of stereotypical beliefs Some recent ethnographic research in American elementary schools documents stereotyping of African American and Latina children similar to the stereotyping of buraku children I observed in Kanda. In one California elementary school, Ann Ferguson (2000) found the low-track classes in which the African American boys were routinely placed mind-numbingly boring. Students never initiated activities, and the tasks assigned were simplistic and repetitive, encouraging rudimentary levels of thinking and allowing no creative efforts by the students. The teachers’ low expectations, negative stereotyping, and disrespectful treatment of many of these boys set them apart from other students on a path that led inexorably toward school failure. In another school, Amanda Lewis (2003) found that Latina girls were also stereotyped, in the opposite direction from the African American boys, but, she felt, with equally damaging consequences. Lewis’s description of the Latina girls’ demeanor also seems applicable to the buraku girls in Kanda Elementary School: Latinas expressed their alienation from school as silently as African American boys did loudly. In many ways their silence was just as potent and destructive as the negative attention black boys got: these girls’ needs still were not recognized or addressed [and their] silence went beyond good behavior to a particular kind of nonparticipation, a pattern that did not receive much attention because the girls were not interrupting or getting in anyone’s way. (Lewis 2003: 80) According to Ferguson, the school personnel she studied used stereotyping to create “a powerful seamless story that reinforced a ‘natural’ connection between certain groups of children and certain outcomes,” a story, she adds, that was based more on hearsay than on first-hand evidence (Ferguson 2000: 45). I heard similar stories about the buraku children of Kanda. Like their counterparts at the preschool level, teachers and administrators at Kanda Elementary School tended to explain the academic problems of the buraku students in terms of cultural deficits in their families and communities. Again and again, I was told about parents who did not value education, who spoiled
68
Sarane Spence Boocock
their children, and who failed to take responsibility for their misbehavior. By keeping its children “wrapped in the cocoon of the community,” Kanda failed to offer them sufficient inducements to become self-reliant. Evidence that contradicted the “seamless story” tended to be overlooked. For example, upon examining the sign-in sheets for parents’ visiting day, I discovered that all first graders except one sick child were represented by at least one relative, usually the mother, though a few fathers and grandparents were also in attendance, and several younger brothers and sisters accompanied their parents or grandparents. As far as I could tell, the adults not only attended visiting day but also stayed to the end (mid-afternoon), certainly not an indicator of parental disinterest and irresponsibility. Summary of findings Like the preschools I observed in 1995, the elementary schools I observed in 1996 differed in curriculum, classroom organization, modes of teaching, and composition of the student body. In first-grade classes with relatively high proportions of buraku students from relatively low-status families, there was more rote learning, less time in han activities, more disorderly behavior, and more time spent on disciplining students than in first-grade classes with relatively fewer buraku students. Clearly, the transition from preschool to first grade was not a smooth one for many of the buraku children of Kanda, and a disproportionate number of boys already had serious learning and behavior problems. Interviews with teachers and other school staff at Kanda Elementary School revealed that many held low expectations for buraku children and attributed their low achievement to deficient upbringing. The emphasis on happy group life that was the centerpiece of dōwa educational and recreational programs was also viewed by some as problematic. A thoughtful assessment of the continuities and discontinuities experienced by buraku children moving from a dōwa preschool into a mainstream elementary school was provided by the director of dōwa education: From the time they are born they are placed in the daycare center, the school, and the Youth center. In other words, they are constantly in group settings. [Because] they are together in the same setting for a long time, they seem to develop common characteristics, which are reflected in their behavior when they are enrolled in first grade. These characteristics are both positive and negative. For example, a good characteristic is that because they know each other they readily offer assistance to each other when it is needed . . . they are very sensitive, friendly and affectionate [hito natsukoi]. [On the other hand, they] tend to lack confidence in defining their own self and abilities [jiko ninshin] [and] have difficulty deciding how to behave as individuals. (Shimahara, interview with director of dōwa education, Kanda Elementary School, July 25, 1995)
The schooling of buraku children 69
Discussion How could two elementary schools just a few blocks apart provide such profoundly different educational environments, with commensurate differences in outcomes? And why did extensive preschool experience, which is positively correlated with subsequent school success in virtually all nations for which data are available (Boocock 1998), not seem to reap similar benefits for the buraku children of Kanda? Explanations for these differences tend to emphasize one of the following: (1) inadequate parenting; (2) systemic or societal inequalities; or (3) outmoded or ineffective teaching practices. Inadequate parenting Many of the people interviewed in connection with the Kanda Project viewed the buraku children’s lack of school success as a buraku problem—that is, as caused by shortcomings in buraku homes and communities. Parents did not socialize their children adequately and failed to take sufficient responsibility for their educational performance. The solution according to this perspective is kateino kyoikuryoku, or greater parental responsibility and accountability. In keeping with this perspective, a manual advising parents on how to improve their parenting skills, produced by the Kanda branch office of the BLL, was being distributed in the summer of 1996. Similar arguments have been made in the United States and other countries in support of efforts to abolish or scale back affirmative action programs and to shift responsibility for children’s achievement and wellbeing “back to the family.” Empirical evidence on the effectiveness of these initiatives is scarce. Evaluations of “Responsible Parenthood” and other intervention programs targeted primarily at low-income and minority families have indicated that the most effective programs are too costly to reach most of the parents who might benefit from them, and, furthermore, that policies designed to enforce parental “involvement” and “accountability” are unlikely to have the desired results as long as they (a) sidestep the thorny issue of the vast differences in families’ social resources and power, and (b) fail to accommodate alternative forms of “involvement”—in particular, the kinship networks through which many working- and lower-class families exchange information and assistance (Lareau and Shumar 1996; Ambert 1997). Systemic inequalities Critics of the kateino kyoikuryoku approach are likely to point to the detrimental effects of inequalities in the educational system. Just as Thomas Rohlen (1983) found a clear rank ordering of Japanese high schools that was strongly associated with the composition of the student bodies, so differences in the quality of preschools and elementary schools attended by buraku children tended to reflect differences in students’ social backgrounds. Thus, the academic problems of Kanda first graders cannot be understood without taking into account that the
70
Sarane Spence Boocock
elementary school they attend is at or near the bottom of the educational ladder, at least in part because a substantial and growing proportion of the students’ parents are both buraku and lower- or working-class. By comparison, Tomita Elementary School enrolled more students from higher-status families, and the buraku children who attended, though few in number, were likely to benefit from the higher educational expectations and outcomes characteristic of a school higher up on the educational ladder. Solutions based upon a systemic or contextual perspective would require addressing the great inequalities in social status and the distribution of social capital in Japanese society and, increasingly, among burakumin themselves. It would also require attacking the stereotyping that underlies anti-buraku discrimination; in particular, discrediting the “seamless stories” many educators and policymakers tell themselves and each other to explain buraku students’ failure to close the academic achievement gap. Until then, disproportionate numbers of buraku children will continue to suffer a kind of double jeopardy when they enter the mainstream educational system. Coming from families that possess less of the educational, occupational, income, and other kinds of social capital that are associated with school success, they will continue to be relegated to schools low on the educational ladder, where the unchallenging curricula and monotonous modes of instruction will dampen their academic aspirations and accomplishments and narrow their future opportunities. If they are not likely to encounter the overt discrimination experienced by their parents, buraku kids are also unlikely to escape the more subtle, less visible forms of discrimination still pervasive enough in the culture of their schools to make them reluctant or unwilling to reveal their identity as burakumin.9 Ineffective teaching A third way of explaining the differences between the two elementary schools is that they embody two divergent pedagogical models. Tomita Elementary School fits in most respects what has come to be known as the Japanese model of schooling. As explicated by Tsuneyoshi (2001, Chapter 2) and C. Lewis (1995, Chapters 3 and 4), this is first and foremost a “whole child” or “child-centered” model, the most important elements of which are: •
• •
•
equal importance of academic and non-academic pursuits (the latter to include not only art and music classes, but “civic” activities such as class meetings, lunch and cleaning duties, and school-wide activities such as Arts Day, Tanabata Festival, and overnight field trips); group—especially han, or small group—activities as the heart of classroom life; a spirit of communalism that engenders a sense of belonging or “togetherness” (issei-taisei), close, empathic interpersonal relations (omoiyari), and ‘voluntary cooperation’ (jihatsuteki no kyoryoku); individual behavior governed by the values of friendliness, helpfulness, persistence, and responsibility.
The schooling of buraku children 71 In combination, these elements can be expected to create “eager, motivated learners and caring, responsible citizens” in a system that “is likely to connect all children positively to schooling” (Lewis 1995: 71–2). Lewis acknowledges that this model of schooling gives way to “monotonous lectures and authoritarian control” in many Japanese middle schools, a shift that appeared to have occurred much earlier in Kanda Elementary School, which bears less resemblance to the Japanese ideal than to the daily grind model of schooling proposed by Philip Jackson (1968). Like the American elementary school students on which Jackson based his model, the Kanda first graders sat for long periods of time listening to their teacher, doing repetitive deskwork, or simply waiting—to have their work checked; for the teacher to finish disciplining someone; for school to be over. Not surprisingly, Jackson concluded that the most useful quality a student can acquire is patience, a quality that many Kanda first graders seemed to have mastered within the first few months.10 From this perspective, the solution would be greater adherence to the Japanese model of schooling, allowing more children—especially minority children—to benefit from the “whole child” approach to education. Thus, it seems ironic that the dōwa educational principles and practices that seem most congruent with the Japanese ideal of schooling are viewed as part of the problem. The director and other staff members of the Kanda office of the BLL we interviewed felt that the original purpose of dōwa day care—to provide total care in a safe, pleasant group setting for children from deeply impoverished homes, who might otherwise have to accompany their parents while they labored at physically draining jobs in substandard, often dangerous workplaces for substandard pay—no longer coincided with the needs of children and their families. They favored a shift in focus, with less emphasis on group life, more emphasis on preparing children to adapt to the more cognitively oriented and highly competitive educational settings that are viewed as a necessary prelude to success in contemporary Japan. This shift in orientation was evident in my 1996 revisits to the Dai-2 Hoikusho, where a year-long effort to revise the curriculum had resulted in more activities designed to strengthen children’s cognitive competence (gakuryoku) and self-awareness (shisei). In the four-year-old class, the hobo-san went around the room accompanied by a cute doll who tapped kids on the head as a signal for them to carry chairs to one side of the room and arrange them in three rows. She then led them briskly through a twenty-minute lesson on colors and shapes—holding a batch of colored papers behind her back and bringing them out one at a time, asking: Is this an orange circle? Is this a yellow square? And so on. To the kids’ delight, she purposely misidentified some of the papers—for example, holding up a red circle, asking, “Is this an orange square?”, and allowing them to shout out the correct answer. Each child was also assigned a “personal” color and shape and given a notebook with her name and logo on the cover. The children’s response to these new “lessons” certainly contradicted the pervasive stereotype of buraku children as uninterested in learning and unable to concentrate well enough to master academic tasks. Moreover, the addition of
72 Sarane Spence Boocock school readiness activities seemed to have been accomplished without foregoing other important aspects of dōwa education—in particular, its emphasis on cultivating caring and cooperative relations among young children, qualities that often seemed to be missing in Kanda Yōchien and Kanda Elementary School. Buraku activists, among the first to challenge the “official” vision of Japan as an ethnically homogeneous society, were also pioneers in showing how diversity could be accommodated in the schools. Curricula developed by dōwa educators provided the first teaching materials designed to deepen students’ awareness of the extent of discrimination suffered by various oppressed peoples in Japan and to show how it could be eradicated. Whether an educational model originated by and for descendants of an outcaste minority group that is still held in low regard by many Japanese can enter the educational mainstream and be applied to the educational problems of other minority children remains to be seen.
Acknowledgements Support for this research from the Japanese Ministry of Education and the Rutgers Graduate School of Education is gratefully acknowledged. During the project that is the main source of empirical data for this chapter, I was privileged to work with two renowned scholars, both of whom did pioneering research on the buraku people. Professor Nobuo Shimahara, a Rutgers colleague and friend of many years, has been an invaluable source of advice and encouragement since the mid 1980s when I began my first studies of early childhood care and education in Japan. Accompanying him on informal walks through Kanda as well as on our more formal school visits afforded me an unparalleled opportunity to observe a master ethnographer at work. Professor Hiroshi Ikeda, under whose leadership Osaka University became a center of research on the education of Japanese minority children, and who initiated and oversaw every aspect of the Kanda Project, ensured that our research group was welcomed in the community and given free access to the schools. Professor Ikeda’s untimely death in 2004 was a great loss to the field. This chapter is dedicated to both of them.
Notes 1 The exact number of buraku people is unknown, with current estimates ranging from 1 million to over 3 million. These discrepancies stem from multiple causes that are themselves related. First, population estimates depend upon who is doing the counting. Government estimates tend to be considerably lower (less than half on average) than those made by buraku organizations, and, according to McLauchlan (2002): “Both sides could be equally accused of using those statistics which best suit their own agenda” (84). Second, there is no consensus about who is a buraku, and definitions can be vague; for example, those people “who are believed to be burakumin by nonburaku people,” or, more inclusively, those people who were born, brought up and living in buraku; those who were not from burakumin family but came to live in buraku in the recent past; or those who are living outside buraku but have blood relationship with burakumin. (Hirasawa and Nabeshima 1995: 5)
The schooling of buraku children 73
2
3 4
5
6 7
Note that the latter definition implies not only a fluctuating membership but also a contamination effect—you can become buraku just by living in close proximity with burakumin. Third, an unknown but believed-to-be substantial and growing number of burakumin have sought to better their life chances by “passing” into mainstream society, in Japan or elsewhere. The status of burakumin has been compared to that of other minorities whose subordinate social position has been justified on the grounds of their alleged physical, mental, or cultural inferiority, such as Korean-Japanese or African-Americans. In origins and the descent-based discrimination they have experienced, the buraku people of Japan are probably most comparable to the Untouchable castes of India, Bangladesh, and Nepal, now often referred to as Dalit, Harijan, or other alternative terms thought to be less insulting, more morally neutral. Though not a distinct racial group, Indian Untouchables, like their Japanese counterparts, have been defined as permanently polluted people largely as a result of the “unclean” work they perform, such as butchering, skinning animal carcasses, tanning leather and making shoes, removing human waste, washing clothes, and preparing bodies for cremation—basically the same kinds of defiling occupation associated with burakumin and their social ostracism. Legislation that abolished segregation in public schools and established caste-based quotas for admission to some federally financed university programs and some jobs in the public sector has enabled a few Untouchables to rise to middle-class status, but disproportionate numbers remain at the lowest levels of their society (Mendelsohn and Vicziany 2000, Chapter 1). It is also noteworthy that, of the twenty nations identified in an international review as practicing “descent-based caste discrimination,” only two—Japan and India—called for exclusion of this topic from the deliberations of the 2000 International Convention on Elimination of Racial Discrimination (Human Rights Watch 2001; Gill 2004). For fuller accounts of buraku origins and history, including the movement for buraku liberation, see Shimahara 1980, 1984; Buraku Kaihō Kenkyūsho 1991; Kitaguchi 1999; Okano and Tsuchiya 1999; Su-Lan Reber 1999; Ikeda 2001; McLauchlan 2002, 2003. Similar findings have been reported with regard to Korean-Japanese, who, like burakumin, are discriminated against in Japan and whose kids do poorly in Japanese schools, but whose accomplishments in the US equal or surpass those of other Americans (for example, Lee 1991). The term “dōwa” combines the two kanji for “same” (dō) and “harmony” (wa). Dōwa education is generally translated as equalitarian or assimilation education. Some buraku activists prefer the term “Kaihō Kyōiku” (liberation education) (Hawkins 1989: 195, 210; Hirasawa and Nabeshima 1995: 2). The name of this community is a pseudonym, as are the names of all the schools and preschools discussed in this chapter. Hoiku-sho, which are under the authority of the Ministry of Welfare, offer full-day care for the infants and young children of working parents. Yōchien, under the authority of the Ministry of Education, combine elements of American nursery schools and kindergartens. Most are half-day programs, though many now have optional afternoon activities. Both kinds of facility may be public or private; all that meet government licensing standards are eligible for government support. Most yōchien teachers and hoiku-sho caretakers (known as hobo-san) are credentialed professionals who have graduated from a demanding two-year training program and are paid at levels comparable with other civil service employees. Although day care was originally intended for the children of poor or working-class families, and nursery schools for children from middle- or upper-class families, in recent years, the educational component of the former has been expanded, and the social class distinctions between the two types of preschool have diminished if not disappeared. (For more comprehensive discussions on the Japanese preschool system, see Boocock 1991; Peak 1991; Holloway 2000.)
74 Sarane Spence Boocock 8 Similar patterns have been found in recent American research. For example, a major finding of an ethnographic study comparing family life, childrearing practices, and academic achievement in an affluent suburb and a lower-income one is that social class explained more of the differences than race—that is, higher-income African American families were more similar to higher-income White families than to lowerincome African American families (Larau 2003). 9 Mendelsohn and Vicziany reached similar conclusions regarding the extent to which educational equity for outcaste groups has been achieved in India: Even now that desegregation of the schools is substantially complete, it is not possible to conclude that all school-based discrimination against Untouchables has disappeared. There remain serious questions about equal treatment in terms of the appropriateness of the curriculum and the sensitivity and diligence of teachers towards their Untouchable students. And there is also the matter of how caste Hindu children treat their Untouchable class fellows. Do they play with them in the schoolyard? And, if the discriminatory attitudes of adults are enacted by their children, is this from the earliest years of schooling or only later once they have thoroughly learnt the culture of Untouchability? There is insufficient research on these questions [but] clearly, in many respects India is still far away from possessing an appropriately democratic and rigorously non-discriminatory system of education. (2000: 126) 10 I do not mean to imply that schools with high proportions of buraku or other minority children are the only ones to deviate from the Japanese model of schooling. A Japanese writer who attended a mainstream fourth-grade class for several months found himself counting the minutes until recess when he could get a drink of water, play tag with his “classmates,” and regain enough energy “to endure the next 45 minutes in class.” In contrast to Lewis’s upbeat analysis, Jiro (1999) concluded facetiously that: “It is really due to the incredible patience of children that the Japanese educational system has somehow survived to this day” (85).
References Akuzawa, M. (2003) Dōwa education and reforms in human rights education in Japan: access, content, and what’s beyond, Osaka: HuRights Osaka. Ambert, A.-M. (1997) Parents, children and adolescents: interactive relationships and development in context, New York: Haworth Press. Bondy, C. (2004) “Hide and seek: gaining a buraku identity and the process of passing.” Paper presented at Japan Studies Graduate Seminar Series, Japan Cultural Center, University of Hawaii, November 4, 2004. Boocock, S. S. (1991) “The Japanese preschool system,” in E. R. Beauchamp (ed.), Windows on Japanese education, New York and London: Greenwood Press, pp. 97–125. –––– (1998) “Long-term outcomes in other nations,” in W. S. Barnett and S. S. Boocock (eds), Early care and education for children in poverty: promises, programs, and longterm results, Albany, NY: State University of New York Press, pp. 45–76. Buraku Kaihō Kenkyūsho (Buraku Liberation Research Institute) (1991) The reality of buraku discrimination in Japan, Osaka: Buraku Kaihō Kenkyūsho. De Vos, G. A. and Suarez-Orozco, M. (1990) Status inequality: the self in culture, Newbury Park, CA: Sage. De Vos, G. A. and Wagatsuma, H. (1967) Japan’s invisible race, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
The schooling of buraku children 75 Ferguson, A. A. (2000) Bad boys: public schools in the making of black masculinity, Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press. Gill, T. (2004) “Executive Summary,” International Consultation on Caste-Based Discrimination, Kathmandu, Nepal, November 29 to December 1. Hawkins, J. N. (1989) “Educational demands and institutional response: Dōwa education in Japan,” in J. J. Shields (ed.), Japanese schooling: patterns of socialization, equality, and political control, University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press, pp. 194–211. Hirasawa, Y. and Nabeshima, Y. (1995) Dōwa education: educational challenge toward a discrimination-free Japan, Osaka: Buraku Kaihō Kenkyūsho. Holloway, S. D. (2000) Contested childhood: diversity and change in Japanese preschools, New York and London: Routledge. Human Rights Watch (2001) “Racial discrimination and related intolerance,” in Human Rights Watch World Report 2001, New York: Human Rights Watch, pp. 1–13. Ikeda, H. (2001) “Buraku students and cultural identity: the case of a Japanese minority,” in N. K. Shimahara, I. Z. Holowinsky, and S. Tomlinson-Clarke (eds), Ethnicity, Race, And Nationality In Education: A global perspective, Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum, pp. 77–96. Ishikawa, Y. (2001) “Rights activists and rights violation: the burakumin case in Japan.” Paper prepared for Global Conference against Racism and Caste Based Discrimination, New Delhi, India, March 1–4, 2001. Itō, H. (1967) “Japan’s outcastes in the United States,” in G. A. De Vos and H. Wagatsuma (eds), Japan’s invisible race, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, pp. 200–21. Jackson, P. (1968) Life in classrooms, New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston. Jiro, S. (1999) “Grownups should listen to kids,” Japan Quarterly, 46: 83–8. Kitaguchi, S. (1999) An introduction to the buraku issue: questions and answers, trans. A. McLauchlan, Folkenstone, Surrey, UK: Curzon Press. Lareau, A. (2003) Unequal childhoods: class, race, and family life, Berkeley: University of California Press. Lareau, A. and Shumar, W. (1996) “The problem of individualism in family-school policies,” Sociology of Education, Extra Issue: 24–39. Lee, Y. (1991) “Koreans in Japan and the United States,” in M. A. Gordon and J. U. Ogbu (eds), Minority status and schooling: a comparative study of immigrant and involuntary minorities, New York and London: Garland, pp. 131–67. Lewis, A. (2003) Race in the schoolyard: negotiating the color line in classrooms and communities, New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press. Lewis, C. C. (1995) Educating hearts and minds: reflections on Japanese preschool and elementary school education, New York: Cambridge University Press. McLauchlan, A. (1999) “Introduction,” in S. Kitaguchi, Nyumon Buraku Mondai: Ichimon ittō, Osaka: Japan Library, pp. 1–38. –––– (2002) “Mainstream attitudes towards burakujumin,” New Zealand Journal of Asian Studies, 4: 84–118. ——(2003) Prejudice and discrimination in Japan: the buraku issue, Lewiston, NY, Ontario, Canada, and Lampeter, Wales: Edwin Mellen Press. Mendelsohn, O. and Vicziany, M. (2000) The Untouchables: subordination, poverty and the state in modern India, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Monnet, J. (2001) “Introduction,” in S. Sumii, My life: living, loving, and fighting, trans. Ashi Translation Society, Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan, Center for Japanese Studies, pp. ix–xix.
76 Sarane Spence Boocock Neary, I. (1997) “Burakumin in contemporary Japan,” in M. Weiner (ed.), Japan’s minorities, London: Routledge, pp. 50–78. Nishida, Y. (1992) “Identity in identity politics: analysis of life histories of buraku people,” Soshiorojī, 37: 3–19. Ogbu, J. (1978) Minority education and caste: the American system in cross-cultural perspective, New York: Harcourt-Brace. Okano, K. and Tsuchiya, M. (1999) Education in contemporary Japan: inequality and diversity, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Paley, V. (1984) Boys and girls: superheroes in the doll corner, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Peak, L. (1991) Learning to go to school in Japan, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Rohlen, T. P. (1983) Japan’s high schools, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Scott, K. A. (2002) “You want to be a girl and not my friend? African-American girls’ play activities with and without boys,” Childhood, 9: 397–414. –––– (2003) “In girls, out girls, and always Black: African-American friendships,” Sociological Studies of Children and Youth, 9: 179–207. Shimahara, N. (1980) Oppressed Japanese: burakumin, Tokyo: Yachiyō Press. –––– (1984) “Toward the equality of a Japanese minority: the case of burakumin,” Comparative Education, 20: 339–53. ——(1995) Interviews with Buraku parents (July 7) and Director of Dōwa Education, Kanda Elementary School (July 25). Su-Lan Reber, E. A. (1999) “Buraku mondai in Japan: historical and modern perspectives and directions for the future,” Harvard Human Rights Journal, 12: 1–59. Thorne, B. (1993) Gender play: girls and boys in school, New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press. Tsuneyoshi, R. (2001) The Japanese model of schooling, New York and London: RoutledgeFalmer.
4
Schooling and identity in Okinawa Okinawans and Amerasians in Okinawa Naomi Noiri
Okinawa is currently one of Japan’s 42 prefectures and consists of numerous small islands located in the southernmost part of the country. Prior to their annexation by Meiji Japan in the late nineteenth century, the islands formed an independent kingdom, the Ryūkyū kingdom, which had its own language and culture and an independent trading relationship with China. Okinawa was thus internally colonised by modern Japan and shared its plight with another indigenous people, the Ainu of northern Japan. The indigenous people of Okinawa were forced to assimilate to mainland Japan under the pre-Second World War government. The area suffered greatly in the Battle of Okinawa at the end of that war, and, even after Japan regained sovereignty, remained under the rule of the US occupation, which developed extensive military bases on the islands. Even after Okinawa’s return to Japan in 1972, its people remained marginalised in Japanese society and have maintained a strong Okinawan identity, as distinct from Japanese. Okinawans are thus a minority group in Japan. Within this minority group, however, there exists a further minority group, Amerasians, who are children of American soldiers (including ex-soldiers) and local women – a direct consequence of the US bases that are disproportionately concentrated in Okinawa. This chapter focuses on these two minorities: Okinawans and Amerasians in Okinawa. The aims of this chapter are threefold. First, it examines how schooling, until recently, has acted as a powerful tool to marginalise Okinawans in Japan; how and why this process was assisted and/or countered by local grass-roots activism; and how the process has influenced the formation of an ambivalent Okinawan identity. Second, the same questions are asked about Amerasians in relation to the Okinawan society. Third, the connections between the two groups, as well as the implications for other minorities, are uncovered, and the possibility of schooling as a source of empowerment is explored. I contend that pre-war Okinawa internalised the imposed Japanese state ideology, and that schooling played an important role in this process. Although the pre-war assimilation was initially enforced from above, locals later learned to accept it, and furthermore willingly promoted it, through education. Okinawans under the post-war US rule initiated their own grass-roots activism to promote assimilationist education, which they saw as necessary for integration into mainland Japan. In this process of promoting assimilation to mainland Japan, first
78
Naomi Noiri
imposed and later voluntary, Okinawans seem to have internalised Japan’s view of Okinawa as marginalised, and developed ambivalent identities. Later, after Okinawa’s return to Japan, locals were sympathetic to ‘stateless’ Amerasians, who were excluded from Japanese citizenship, and organised a grassroots activism to ensure that all mixed-race children obtained Japanese citizenship. When this was achieved, however, interest in Amerasian children diminished, despite their continued marginalisation in schooling and beyond. This drove concerned parents to establish the AmerAsian School of Okinawa specifically for Amerasian children. Bureaucratic difficulties faced by these parents reveal the attitude of the Okinawa Department of Education, as well as the notion of ‘difference’ that official discourse adopts. I consider the accommodation of Amerasians in local schools to be one of the most challenging tasks faced by Okinawa’s government schools, and that such coexistence is most likely to be achieved once local people reflect on their own experience of marginalisation, both past and present, both institutionalised and otherwise, and relate this to that of Amerasians. In revealing the intra-group diversity of Okinawans, this chapter underscores the changing nature of Okinawan identity over time, in response to political and social circumstances. The study is important in that it reveals another, seldom examined aspect of Japanese schooling. Although Okinawa recently emerged as a much-discussed topic, and various aspects of Okinawan society have been studied (e.g. Johnson 1999; Nakasone 2002; Hein and Selden 2003; Hook and Siddle 2003), the schooling experienced by Okinawans (including Amerasians in Okinawa) has received scant attention. For example, the pre-war assimilation policy in education was studied by Rabson (1999), and Allen’s ethnography of an outer Okinawan island community (2001) mentions a considerable autonomy that local education boards maintained from the central ministry. This chapter shows how schooling has historically responded to perceived ‘differences’, what the consequences of this were, and how grass-roots activism has influenced schooling processes. It thus assists us to understand current educational policies and practice in responding to newly defined differences brought by immigrant children and to long-standing differences maintained by older, culturally distinct groups of indigenous people and ethnic Koreans/Chinese. This chapter begins by examining how Okinawans experienced modern schooling over three distinct phases: subordination to pre-war Japan, the US occupation, and after Okinawa’s return to Japan. Second, it studies Amerasian children’s experience of schooling during the latter two phases in relation to that of other Okinawans, including the effective civil movement to save ‘stateless children’. Last, the discussion shifts to the continuing marginalisation of Amerasian children, even after the civil movement ensured Japanese citizenship to all Amerasian children,1 and to the process leading to the establishment of the AmerAsian School. The connection between the two minority groups in question is explored in terms of their shared experience and the potential this implies.
Schooling and identity in Okinawa
79
Schooling under Japanese colonial rule: the first subordination The existence of a single shared language has long acted as a powerful justification for the claim that Japan is an ethnically homogeneous nation-state (Yoshino 1992: 24–5). Linguistics studies, however, suggest that the Ryukuan language is not so much a dialect as a separate language, and that the difference between the Japanese language and the Ryukuan language is like that between German and English and between French and Italian (Matsumori 1995: 20). Contemporary young Okinawan people do not have functional knowledge of the Ryukuan language. The shift in their language use was swift. Kawai, an author born in 1950, recalls that the generation before hers was able to think in the Ryukuan language and write in the Japanese language, but that generations younger than hers are no longer able to even think in the Ryukuan language (Kawai 2003). This section examines two of the factors that contributed to the language loss: schooling and identity (others being government and patriarchy). The annexation of the Ryūkyū kingdom to mainland Japan was not a sudden action by the expansionist Japanese state; it occurred gradually from the beginning of the seventeenth century. At that time, in mainland Japan, many fiefdoms, after a period of fighting among themselves, finally came under the rule of the family located in Tokyo. Fiefdoms became domains (hans), maintaining relative autonomy in their internal management but expected to be loyal to the Tokugawa family. In 1609, the Satsuma domain (the present Kagaoshima prefecture located at the south end of Kyushu Island) placed the Ryūkyū islands under its rule. Prior to this, the Ryūkyū kingdom was an independent entity that maintained an emissary relationship with China. The Tokugawa Shogunate successfully ruled the country until modern Japan emerged in the mid nineteenth century. The Satsuma domain kept the name of the Ryūkyū kingdom and let it continue its trade with China. This was a strange arrangement in that the kingdom maintained loyalties to both Satsuma and China until its integration into modern Japan, but served the interests of the Satsuma domain, which wanted to exploit the taxation potential of the Ryūkyū kingdom’s trade. Iha (1928: 28–31) suggests that this was the beginning of the Okinawans’ ambivalent identity. The Satsuma authorities maintained a deliberate policy of keeping indigenous Okinawans distinct from mainland Japanese by prohibiting them from adopting Japanese-sounding names and wearing Japanese clothes, although some locals wanted to assimilate. The Satsuma authorities even took the Ryūkyū king and his servants, dressed in Chinese-looking clothes, to the capital, Edo, in order to display the Satsuma’s power to the Shōgun. The Ryūkyū people became confused about their identity in relation to Chinese and Japanese (Iha 1928: 29). They had a more favourable feeling towards China, which only wanted a voluntary emissary relationship; China had no intention of annexing the islands by fighting against the Satsuma. After losing the Opium War in 1840, China had no power do to so, in any case. After modern Meiji Japan was established in the mid nineteenth century, the Ryūkyū kingdom remained under the control of Kagoshima prefecture
80 Naomi Noiri (previously Satsuma), a new local administrative unit. Its integration into modern Japan was considered too costly for the few perceived benefits to be gained by such an action (Oguma 1998:20). In 1879, the Ryūkyū kingdom was officially integrated into Japan and became the Okinawa prefecture. The Japanese government then started seeing the Ryūkyū Islands as geopolitically important. Okinawans were thus unilaterally made ‘Japanese’ subjects by the Japanese government in order to serve its expansionist interests in Asia, in particular the colonisation of Taiwan. The central Japanese government established primary and middle schools and teachers’ colleges in Okinawa in order to promote ‘Japanese’ modern schooling. It realised that many locals did not understand the standard Japanese language and the notion of the emperor, and was concerned that this might threaten national security. Teachers’ colleges were given photographs of the emperor and the empress. Students were taught the ideology of the divine emperor and loyalty to this, as well as standard Japanese language. The authorities wanted locals to cultivate a Japanese identity. Initially, Okinawans saw little value in schooling provided from above. They mocked schools, and few were willing to send their children to learn standard Japanese, which was seen as locally useless. Their reluctance was reflected in the school attendance rate in the 1880s: only 3 per cent, compared with the national average of 40 per cent. As the people still sought their spiritual foundation in China and disliked Japan for dissolving their kingdom, China’s defeat in the SinoJapanese War in 1894 had a profound influence on Okinawan identity. At that point, people realised that they could no longer depend on China in reviving their own kingdom. Meanwhile, the patriotism of the Japanese Empire reached the islands. By 1901, primary school attendance had reached 70 per cent, and 90 per cent in 1906 (Ōta 1976: 79). The Japanese authorities continued to adopt the policy of assimilation and of deliberately not nurturing leaders among local inhabitants; the same policy was later applied to other colonised peoples, such as in Taiwan. Higher education institutions were not established in Okinawa (teachers’ colleges were not considered higher education at the time). Even though some locals successfully learned to be assimilated by believing in the imperial ideology and speaking perfect standard Japanese, the rulers of Okinawa were nevertheless dispatched from mainland Japan. Okinawans could not become members of parliament until 1912, and even after that could not become prefectural governors. Okinawans were forced to become ‘Japanese’, but were to be discriminated as ‘Okinawans’, a contradiction that led to identity confusion. The government discouraged indigenous language and cultural practices. School authorities considered the local language a shameful, primitive dialect and prohibited its use; students who spoke the local language were given a card called a ‘dialect placard’ (hōgenfuda) to place around their necks as a punishment (Yamashiro and Sakuda 1983: 404–5), a similar tactic in relation to a minority language to that adopted in France (Giordan 1987 (1984)). Local cultural practices were also denigrated as barbaric under the slogan ‘Improve Customs Movement’
Schooling and identity in Okinawa
81
(fūzoku kairyō undō). When national conscription started, Okinawan males were instructed to abandon their traditional hair style (Iha 1928), and the traditional custom of tattooing women’s hands was also prohibited. It was an imperial policy to control the bodies of its subjects: namely, men were to be able soldiers and women to be producers of soldiers. Okinawans initially resisted what they considered to be a discriminatory educational policy from above. For example, local students were outraged when the Syuri Middle School Japanese principal removed English from the school curriculum on the grounds that English was a luxury for the locals, who, he claimed, should first learn the standard Japanese language. Students boycotted classes and demanded the principal’s removal, which resulted in the subject’s return to the curriculum (Kerr 2000: 442). The principal and students involved in the boycott were also removed from the school. On the other hand, Okinawans gradually learned to see value in assimilation, especially after Japan’s victory in the Sino-Japanese war, which made locals favour Japan over China. Noting that Okinawans in mainland Japan suffered from discrimination, at least partly because of their dialect, some Okinawans began to think that mastering standard Japanese might bring fairer treatment and better life chances (Rabson 1999). This led to what I call a voluntary assimilation movement initiated by local teachers. The bottom-up assimilation movement led to Okinawans’ transferring their own oppressive experience onto Taiwan, which became a Japanese colony in 1895. In relation to Taiwan, Okinawans held superior power as the ruling Japanese. The Japanese government promoted Okinawans, an old ruled people, to colonise the Taiwanese, a new ruled people, by sending Okinawan teachers, government officials, army officers and police officers there (Matayoshi1990). It seems that the Empire used Okinawans as disposable foot soldiers of colonial governance in Taiwan. Okinawans were still looked down on by the Japanese and the Taiwanese in Taiwan. This status of ‘double minority’ (Arasaki 2000: 38) contributed to identity conflicts for many Okinawans. Meanwhile, Okinawan government officers were sent to areas where local resistance against Japanese colonialism was strongest and where they faced heavy casualties. Okinawans volunteered for the mission of transforming local Taiwanese, whom they considered less civilised than themselves, into Japanese subjects. They believed that ‘Okinawa along with Taiwan was the important south gate to the Empire’, a phrase that emphasised the unique contributions that the two could make to the Empire. Events during the Second World War also troubled Okinawan identity. On landing, the American army found many civilian dead – forced to commit suicide by the Japanese army. Twice as many Okinawans as Japanese soldiers were killed in the Battle of Okinawa (James and Tamamori 1995).
Schooling under the US occupation: the second subordination The US occupation remained on the island even after Japan regained sovereignty in 1951. The American army shared the Japanese authorities’ view that Okinawans
82
Naomi Noiri
were distinct from the Japanese people (Tozzer 1996: 4); General MacArthur mentioned that Okinawans were not against the American occupation of Okinawa, unlike Japan, as they were not ‘Japanese’ (Nakano 1969: 4). The USA gained Pacific islands formerly under Japanese rule as its trust territories; in gaining Okinawa it acquired extensive military bases from the Far East to the Pacific. The fortification of Okinawa was subsequently important in the Cold War and during the Vietnam War. The US Military Government of the Ryūkyū Islands became the US Civil Administration in 1950. American commissioners dominated the administration, decision-making and judiciary. A letter from the Far East Command to the Ryūkyūs Command in 1950 proclaimed that ‘the Ryukyuan people will be guaranteed, as far as is consistent with the military occupation, the basic liberties of democratic countries’ (Gekkan Okinawasha 1983: 54). In the early 1950s, the American Army started taking over land in order to build military bases. Locals were forced to agree to rent their lands to the Army below market price, ‘equivalent to one bottle of coke for twenty years rental’ (Nakano and Arasaki 1976: 75). Local farmers had no choice but to work as construction workers or employees of the base, or alternatively to become small-shop owners serving American soldiers. With American products entering Okinawa without duty, manufacturing industry did not develop. Thus Okinawa’s unique state of heavy economic dependence on the bases soon emerged and has remained to the present. The American authorities had no intention of making Okinawa a US territory and granting its people American citizenship. Okinawans were therefore neither American nor fully Japanese. The self-governing body’s police officers could not charge an American soldier who failed to stop at a traffic light and killed a young Okinawan boy.2 Okinawans were not granted voting rights and could not travel freely to mainland Japan. They thus experienced a process whereby Okinawa became dependent on the US bases. This affected their identity formation. As for schooling for locals, the American authority in Okinawa showed little enthusiasm, in contrast to mainland Japan where the American GHQ was keen to establish a democratic system of schooling. The 1945 announcement by the US authority in Okinawa merely mentioned that the new schooling would promote local language, history and art. Education policies formed a part of the ‘disassimilation’ campaign that military intelligence and propaganda embarked on in order to convince Okinawans that they were not Japanese (Rabson 1999: 145). Radio programmes in the Ryūkyūan language were funded but soon discontinued owing to the lack of Ryūkyūan-speaking broadcasters. The 1946 Primary School Act passed by the US military government suggested that schools teach American and Okinawan culture and celebrate Okinawans’ achievements. The curriculum in the same year included the history of Okinawa and oriental and occidental history centred on Okinawa (Okinawa-ken Kyōiku Iinkai 1977: 23). The emphasis on the unique nature of Ryūkyū culture was seen by locals as an American attempt to justify the separation of Okinawa from Japan. Many Okinawan teachers resisted the ‘Ryuky-ization’ campaign. Many teachers also left teaching owing to inadequate salaries.
Schooling and identity in Okinawa
83
The American authority’s wish to consolidate their rule in the islands by separating Okinawans from Japanese was also seen in its attempt to produce proAmerica elites in Okinawa. The US authority established the system of offering scholarships to local youth to study in America, and created local elites who were preferentially appointed to the government in Okinawa on their return. It was often said: ‘Unless you studied in the US, you go nowhere in this government.’ The University of the Ryūkyūs, established in 1950, was also aimed at producing proAmerican elites (Yamashiro and Sakuda 1983: 125). In contrast to the poor conditions of local primary and secondary schools, the university provided free education in English through American lectures, with American books donated by the government as texts. Graduates of this university, however, later played crucial roles in Okinawa’s civil movement to demand a return to Japan. Primary and secondary schools, which the American authority showed little interest in, had to be rebuilt by local people. In 1946, ninety primary schools were operating, with 65,000 students. Because facilities had been destroyed during the war, teachers and students sat on the beach, substituting the sand for a blackboard. One year later, the number of students had increased to 156,000, but the old, prewar system of eight years in primary and four years in senior high school was still in operation. It was only in 1948 that the new system of six–three–three (three years in primary, three years in middle school and three years in senior high school) was introduced, following the mainland practice (Warner 1972: 43). The place of English was extensively debated in the curriculum for these schools. It looked as if the American rule was to be permanent. However, lengthy discussion resulted in the decision that the medium of instruction would be Japanese, and that English would be a compulsory subject from grade 1 (Okinawaken Kyōiku Iinkai 1977: 42–3). Why was this? First, local teachers were dissatisfied with the American Army’s policy of funding education only for proAmerican elites, and with what the teachers understood to be a policy of divide and rule by strengthening Ryūkyūan consciousness. Second, local teachers realised that the new system of education in mainland Japan was well funded, that the occupation authorities on mainland Japan showed much more enthusiasm for rebuilding the education system, and that Okinawa would benefit more from following the Japanese system. In 1959, the Okinawa Association of School Principals took a consensus request to the American Army that Okinawan schooling follow the mainland Japanese practice and that schools raise a Japanese flag (which the US authority prohibited at the time) and have the same national events as Japan. Although the request was rejected, local educationalists started studying the new schooling system of mainland Japan. Local movement for assimilationist schooling: ‘Kokumin kyōiku’ Local teachers thus became determined to promote assimilationist Japanese schooling. This was called ‘Kokumin kyōiku’ and involved cultivating an awareness of being a Japanese citizen in, and teaching standard Japanese language to, their students. A question emerges from this: Why did Okinawans so desperately
84 Naomi Noiri want mainland Japan’s schooling for their children? This is surprising when we recall that locals felt betrayed by Japan – they had been left under US rule despite the war casualties that they had suffered and their pre-war display of loyalty. Who were the main players in this movement, and what did they achieve in the end? The most significant reason was that the American Army, which in theory liberated them from Japan, did not show interest in local schooling, which, locals believed, led to poor academic performance by their young people. In the 1950 academic performance test, the Okinawan primary school mathematics average mark was less than 50 per cent, and the middle school English test average mark was just over 50 per cent. Okinawan government officials listed three reasons for the poor performance: increased use of dialect; decreased interest in Japanese culture due to different lifestyles; and inadequate facilities (Warner 1972: 86–7). The 1952 meeting of school principals also proposed an emphasis on standard Japanese and two other major goals: construction of school buildings and the establishment of an education act (Okinawa-ken Kyōiku Iinkai 1977: 57–8). Some local teachers took the risk of illegally sailing to Japan in order to study the new 6–3–3 system of schooling and to bring home textbooks. This movement later came to involve teachers in a wider civil movement, the ‘Return to Japan’ movement. The movement’s insistence on raising the Japanese flag at schools had two purposes. One was to request the Japanese conservative party in power to provide financial resources for educational facilities. The other was to stabilise Okinawan identity, which teachers feared suffered from confusion under the US rule of the islands. The Okinawa Teachers’ Union encouraged parents to raise the Japanese flag on New Year’s Day and bought from mainland Japan a large quantity of flags to sell to parents. The most important task for educationalists in Okinawa at the time was to establish something equivalent to the Fundamental Education Law (1947), which was in force in mainland Japan, and to declare that Okinawan schooling should follow the Japanese legislation. Drawing on the preamble to the Fundamental Education Law, the Okinawa Teachers’ Union drafted its own version of the law and submitted this to the US commissioner. It was rejected twice because of the wording ‘We as Japanese citizens’. Undeterred, Chobyo Yara, the union president, took the matter to the CIA headquarters, and in 1958 the Okinawa Fundamental Education Law was established (Okinawa-ken Kyōiku Iinkai 1977: 140). This was extremely significant for the ‘Return to Japan’ movement. Yara later recalled: ‘I thought that the Japanese government would have no choice but to acknowledge the Law which described Okinawans as being “Japanese citizens”’ (Yamashiro and Sakuda 1983: 668). It was a public announcement, both to the Japanese government and to the American authority, of Okinawans’ wish to return to Japan. Yara later became the first Okinawa prefectural governor after its return to Japan. At the classroom level, teachers encouraged the use of the standard Japanese language and cultivated the idea that students were Japanese. The 1957 primary school curriculum guidelines for Japanese stated that all students should be able to speak standard Japanese by the end of grade 2, and that grade 3 students should
Schooling and identity in Okinawa
85
learn to notice infantile expressions, dialect and unacceptable accents in their speech.3 Teachers conducted surveys of standard Japanese language use among students and attempted to discourage the use of ‘unacceptable expressions’. Dialect placards, which had been used during pre-war times, re-emerged in classrooms (EDGE 2002: 69). Okinawan children learned to speak standard Japanese, even with some ‘unacceptable’ dialectical expressions. Some children learned to be silent or avoid communication altogether for fear of disgracing themselves with their ‘unacceptable’ expressions (EDGE 2002: 52). Such examples suggest that assimilationist schooling was more severely imposed, not by the Japanese authority as during the pre-war period, but by local Okinawan teachers themselves. These teachers believed that standard Japanese language would enable Okinawan children, not only to develop Japanese identity, but also improve their academic performance to the level of mainland Japanese children. The assimilationist schooling movement connected to the ‘Return to Japan’ movement was abandoned in the late 1960s. By then, the Japanese government had revealed concrete directions regarding Okinawa’s return to Japan, including the prospect that American bases would remain after the return. Okinawans’ wish that they would obtain the peace and prosperity enjoyed by mainland Japanese was shattered. The Okinawa Teachers’ Union decided to drop from its educational tasks the cultivation of Japanese identity and the promotion of the standard language. However, the legacy of a fifteen-year assimilationist education remained: a generation that no longer spoke the Ryūkyūan language. ‘Catch up with mainland Japan’ narrative and victimhood identity Okinawa returned to Japan in 1972. The return was made possible by Japan’s rapid economic growth and partly by the US’s failed involvement in Vietnam. The US wanted an affluent Japan to shoulder the military cost of maintaining the US bases. Okinawans who had wished that the post-war Japanese constitution would remove the US military bases were disappointed. Seventy per cent of the US military bases in Japan remained in Okinawa. Okinawa had 22,720 US soldiers in 2007 (Okinawa-ken-kichi-taisaku-ka 2007). The Japanese government employed a narrative emphasising the ‘gap between Okinawa and the mainland’ and justified measures to bring Okinawa to mainland standards. The three Okinawa Promotion and Development Plans enabled the central government to provide special financial resources until Okinawa had achieved development equivalent to mainland Japan. These measures could be seen as the government’s attempt to compensate Okinawa for being required to accommodate a disproportionate number of US bases. Okinawa prefecture has received $350 billion through this channel, which has, nevertheless, not achieved the goal (Arasaki 2000: 93). Okinawa’s unemployment rate remains twice the national average, and the prefecture has the lowest income level in the country. As long as the gap exists, however, the government will provide financial resources.
86
Naomi Noiri
Okinawans themselves contributed to fostering the gap narrative while also attempting to close the gap. The first Okinawa Prefectural Department of Education after Okinawa’s return to Japan set out to achieve academic performance equivalent to that in mainland Japan (Motohama 2002: 25–9). Although this was immediately criticised by the Okinawa Teachers’ Union for being biased towards narrow academic achievement, the goal was widely accepted. Teachers and students shared the view that Okinawans were poor academic achievers, as measured by uniform criteria such as retention rates or nationally available scores, and assessed their progress in terms of the extent to which they narrowed the gap. This resembled the post-war assimilationist schooling discussed above. I would suggest that teachers’ and students’ efforts stemming from this narrative quite inadvertently contributed to the maintenance of an Okinawan inferi