© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational...
98 downloads
897 Views
34MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Metallographer’s Guide Practices and Procedures for Irons and Steels
Bruce L. Bramfitt Homer Research Laboratories Bethlehem Steel Corporation Arlan O. Benscoter Department of Materials Science and Engineering Lehigh University
Materials Park, OH 44073-0002 www.asminternational.org
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Copyright © 2002 by ASM International® All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the written permission of the copyright owner. First printing, March 2002
Great care is taken in the compilation and production of this book, but it should be made clear that NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, ARE GIVEN IN CONNECTION WITH THIS PUBLICATION. Although this information is believed to be accurate by ASM, ASM cannot guarantee that favorable results will be obtained from the use of this publication alone. This publication is intended for use by persons having technical skill, at their sole discretion and risk. Since the conditions of product or material use are outside of ASM’s control, ASM assumes no liability or obligation in connection with any use of this information. No claim of any kind, whether as to products or information in this publication, and whether or not based on negligence, shall be greater in amount than the purchase price of this product or publication in respect of which damages are claimed. THE REMEDY HEREBY PROVIDED SHALL BE THE EXCLUSIVE AND SOLE REMEDY OF BUYER, AND IN NO EVENT SHALL EITHER PARTY BE LIABLE FOR SPECIAL, INDIRECT OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES WHETHER OR NOT CAUSED BY OR RESULTING FROM THE NEGLIGENCE OF SUCH PARTY. As with any material, evaluation of the material under end-use conditions prior to specification is essential. Therefore, specific testing under actual conditions is recommended. Nothing contained in this book shall be construed as a grant of any right of manufacture, sale, use, or reproduction, in connection with any method, process, apparatus, product, composition, or system, whether or not covered by letters patent, copyright, or trademark, and nothing contained in this book shall be construed as a defense against any alleged infringement of letters patent, copyright, or trademark, or as a defense against liability for such infringement. Comments, criticisms, and suggestions are invited, and should be forwarded to ASM International. Prepared under the direction of the ASM International Technical Book Committee (2001-2002), Charles A. Parker, Chair ASM International staff who worked on this project included Veronica Flint, Manager of Book Acquisitions; Bonnie Sanders, Manager of Production; Nancy Hrivnak, Production Project Manager; and Scott Henry, Assistant Director of Reference Publications. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Bramfitt, B. L. Metallographer’s guide: practices and procedures for irons and steels / Bruce L. Bramfitt, Arlan O. Benscoter. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Metallography. I. Benscoter, Arlan O. II. Title. TN690 .B78 2001 669’.951—dc21 2001045910 ISBN: 0-87170-748-9 SAN: 204-7586 ASM International® Materials Park, OH 44073-0002 www.asminternational.org Printed in the United States of America Micrographs on cover: Top, left: Annealed AISI/SAE 1005 steel showing equiaxed ferrite grains photographed using dark field illumination. Marshall’s etch. 200⫻ Top, right: Annealing twins in AISI 347H austenitic stainless steel photographed using differential interference contrast (Nomarski). Electrolytically etched in 60% nitric acid in water. 5 volts, stainless steel cathode. 500⫻ Bottom, left: Partially spheroidized AISI/SAE 1060 steel photographed using bright field illumination. 4% picral etch. 500⫻ Bottom, right: Lath martensite in austenitized and quenched AISI/SAE 1040 steel photographed using bright field illumination. Etched in 2% nital. 500⫻
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
To Joan and Sandy for their enduring patience and encouragement.
iii
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Contents Optical Defects in Objectives .............................................. 118 Types of Objectives.............................................................. 120 Types of Eyepieces .............................................................. 123 The Illumination System...................................................... 126 The Components of the Illumination System ..................... 126 Types of Illumination........................................................... 131 Accessories for the Microscope........................................... 137 The Metallograph ................................................................. 139 Special Procedures for the Metallurgical Microscope ........ 140
Preface ........................................................................................ vi Acknowledgments..................................................................... vii Atlas of Microstructures ........................................................ viii Chapter 1: Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons ................. 1 Steels......................................................................................... 1 Carbon and Low-Alloy Steels ................................................. 2 High-Alloy Steels..................................................................... 9 Cast Irons ............................................................................... 16
Chapter 6: The Expanded Metallographic Laboratory .... 149 The Image Analyzer............................................................. 149 The Electron Microscope..................................................... 152 The X-Ray Diffractometer ................................................... 162 The Hot Stage Microscope .................................................. 164 The Microhardness Tester.................................................... 165 The Hot Microhardness Tester ............................................ 166 Other Specialized Techniques.............................................. 167
Chapter 2: Origin of Microstructure..................................... 23 Microstructural Development Resulting from Heat Treatment............................................................................ 24 The Iron-Carbon Phase Diagram........................................... 24 Kinetics of Phase Transformations........................................ 28 The Microstructural Constituents in Steel............................. 31 Microstructural Development Resulting from Solidification....................................................................... 41 Phase Transformations in Cast Irons..................................... 42 Transformations in a 3% C Cast Iron ................................... 43 General Description of Microstructures in Cast Irons.................................................................................... 44 Commercial Cast Irons .......................................................... 46
Chapter 7: Metallographic Specimen Preparation ............ 169 Information Gathering.......................................................... 169 Sectioning ............................................................................. 170 Mounting .............................................................................. 183 Grinding................................................................................ 198 Polishing ............................................................................... 202 Specimen Storage ................................................................. 211
Chapter 3: Alteration of Microstructure............................... 49 The Intentional Alteration of Microstructure in Steels and Cast Irons .................................................................... 49 The Unintentional Alteration of Microstructure in Steels and Cast Irons .................................................................... 66
Chapter 8: The Art of Revealing Microstructure .............. 215 Etching Response ................................................................. 215 Revealing Microstructure in an As-Polished Specimen ..... 217 Revealing Microstructure by Etching.................................. 219 The Basic Etchants for Carbon and Low-Alloy Steels and Cast Irons .................................................................. 221 The Attack Etchants ............................................................. 222 Picral..................................................................................... 227 Variations of Picral............................................................... 228 4% Picral and 2% Nital ....................................................... 233 Basic Tint Etchants for Carbon and Low-Alloy Steels and Cast Irons .................................................................. 233 General Procedure in Using Tint Etchants.......................... 234 The Common Tint Etchants................................................. 234 The Basic Etchants for Stainless Steels .............................. 236 Attack Etchants for Stainless Steels.................................... 237 Electrolytic Etchants for Stainless Steels............................ 239
Chapter 4: The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory............................................. 87 The Metallographer................................................................ 87 The Metallographer versus the Chemist ............................... 89 The Metallographer’s Workday ............................................. 92 The Metallographic Laboratory ........................................... 103 Safety in the Metallographic Laboratory ............................ 106 Chapter 5: The Metallurgical Microscope.......................... 109 The Microscope.................................................................... 109 The Objective ....................................................................... 112 The Nosepiece ...................................................................... 116 iv
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Alloy steel compositions applicable to billets, blooms, slabs, and hot-rolled and cold-finished bars.................... 308 Chemical compositions for typical low-alloy steels ........... 309 ASTM specifications for chromium-molybdenum steel product forms ................................................................... 310 Nominal chemical compositions for heat-resistant chromium-molybdenum steels ......................................... 310 Compositions of standard stainless steels ........................... 311 Compositions of nonstandard stainless steels ..................... 312 Nominal compositions of wrought iron-base heat-resistant alloys.......................................................... 314 Composition limits of principal types of tool steels ................................................................................. 315 Standard composition ranges for austenitic manganese steel castings..................................................................... 316 Typical compositions for malleable iron............................. 316 Nominal compositions of commercial maraging steels...... 316 Typical base compositions of SAE J431 automotive gray cast irons for heavy-duty service ............................ 316 Chemical compositions and mechanical properties of austenitic manganese steels for nonmagnetic and cryogenic applications...................................................... 317 Composition of selected cast irons...................................... 317 Temperature Conversions..................................................... 318
The Basic Etchants for Coated Steels ................................. 241 Special Etching Procedures ................................................. 241 The Use of the Microscope to Enhance Microstructural Features............................................................................. 242 Chapter 9: Glossary............................................................... 245 Appendix: Tables Helpful to the Metallographer .............. 297 List of ASTM standards that pertain to ferrous metallography ................................................................... 297 List of vendors for metallographic supplies ....................... 298 List of light optical microscope manufacturers .................. 298 Microscope reticle manufacturer ......................................... 298 Scientific imaging products ................................................. 299 Used and/or reconditioned equipment................................. 299 Conversion of average grain intercept length (microns) to ASTM number ............................................................. 300 Chemical polishing solutions............................................... 300 Electroless and electrolytic coatings for edge protection ... 301 Etchants for revealing macrostructures in iron and steel ... 302 Etchants for carbon and alloy steels ................................... 303 Carbon steel compositions ................................................... 307 Free-machining (resulfurized) carbon steel compositions .. 307 Free-machining (rephosphorized and resulfurized) carbon steel compositions................................................ 307 High-manganese carbon steel compositions ....................... 307 High-manganese carbon steel compositions ....................... 307
Index ........................................................................................ ................................................................................ 321
v
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Preface This guide was prepared not only for the beginning metallographer but also for the experienced metallographer who may be looking for alternatives and new approaches to metallographic practice. For the beginning metallographer, little or no knowledge of steels and cast irons is necessary since the first three chapters provide the basic information needed to understand the various types of steels and cast irons available in the commercial world. These chapters also provide examples of the multitude of microstructures that the metallographer will encounter, how these microstructures are created, and how they can be altered by heat treatment and other means. Some metallographers may be working in a small laboratory where no metallurgical support is available. The authors feel very strongly that to be effective, the metallographer must understand as much as possible about the metallurgy of the material he or she is preparing. Without this knowledge, the metallographer can offer little interpretation of the microstructure he or she develops even after applying the best metallographic practices. Also, without a proper background in recognizing metallographic constituents, he or she may produce an artifact through improper specimen preparation that will lead to a totally inappropriate result. Thus, it is important that the metallographer read the first three chapters to obtain a basic understanding of steel microstructures before proceeding to the metallographic techniques chapters. As part of this guide, the authors felt that a metallographer should know some of the history of metallography. In this new century, we have come a long way from the early days of Sorby and Widmanstätten who pioneered what we now know as metallography of steels and cast irons a century and a half ago. Chapter 4 gives a brief history of these early metallographers and defines the identity of a metallographer by comparing the vast amount of information gained from a metallographic analysis to that produced from a chemical analysis. The chapter also describes the types of things that a metallographer will encounter in a typical workday in a large metallographic laboratory in the research department of a large steel company and a small metallography laboratory associated with an iron foundry. Actual metallographic tasks in both situations are described in detail. Chapter 6 discusses some of the tools that are available beyond the typical metallographic laboratory. In today’s world, there has been an explosion in technology to aid the metallographer. Not only can one reveal the microstructural constituents in a steel or cast iron, but also one can determine the chemical analysis of each constituent even on a nanometer scale. To be effective, the metallographer must be familiar with the capabilities of these modern-day instruments. Since this guide concentrates on light (optical) metallography, Chapter 5 has been added to describe in detail how a metallurgical microscope works. This is the instrument located in all metallographic laboratories. The metallographer must have an intimate knowledge of the microscope to use it properly. An understanding of the different types of oculars (eyepieces) and objectives is important so that the microstructure can be revealed in its truest form. Knowledge of the various types of illumination (bright field, dark field, interference contrast, etc.) is important to enhance the image of the microstructural features. The metallographer also must know how to maintain and clean the microscope to keep it in the best condition possible. Specimen preparation procedures were saved for Chapters 7 and 8. The procedures presented in this guide have proven to work effectively to prepare the specimen. However, the authors recognize that other procedures also can work as effectively. This book guides the metallographer through the specimen preparation procedures in a step-by-step manner. Various options are offered, and preferred methods are described in detail. The authors provide a basic understanding of how and why the methods work. As the metallographer becomes more experienced, he or she may develop his or her own adaptations of the procedures presented here. This guide will get the metallographer started with a sound procedure that works. A unique feature of this guide is a separate and complete index of the various steels and cast irons used as examples throughout the book. The index makes the hundreds of micrographs essentially an Atlas of Microstructures, and it precedes Chapter 1. Although this book is for the novice metallographer, an experienced metallographer may find it useful in that dozens of special metallographic tips are scattered through the chapters on specimen preparation and the art of revealing microstructure. This guide could be used as a university or technical school text to accompany the teaching of a laboratory course in metallography. Bruce L. Bramfitt Arlan O. Benscoter
vi
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Acknowledgments The authors wish to acknowledge the reviewers of the various chapters who provided valuable insight for improvement. The list includes L.E. Samuels, Keith A. Taylor, Albert Brandemarte, Samuel Lawrence, Colin McCrindle, and Robert O’Reilly. Special thanks go to Samuel Lawrence, Metallographer at Bethlehem Steel’s Homer Research Laboratories, for his advice and assistance in the chapters on specimen preparation. A very special acknowledgment goes to metallographers Ernie Kozak (deceased) and George Ruyak (deceased) who nurtured and guided one of the authors (AOB) in his early years of metallography at Bethlehem Steel’s Homer Research Laboratories. The various students at Lehigh University who provided specimens and micrographs for this book are also acknowledged. Particular thanks go to the editors at ASM International: Timothy Gall who started this venture and Sunniva Collins, our first editor, who provided us with lots of help and support and who married, had children, and received her Doctorate degree while we were in the process of writing this book. Also, thanks go to Veronica Flint, who through diplomatic prodding and helpful encouragement brought us to the point of completing the book in a somewhat timely manner, and to Nancy Hrivnak for her help and guidance in preparing the book for publication.
vii
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Atlas of Microstructures Steels/irons
Carbon steels AISI/SAE 1005 AISI/SAE 1008 AISI/SAE 1010
AISI/SAE 1015 AISI/SAE 1018
AISI/SAE 1020
AISI/SAE 1025 AISI/SAE 1035 AISI 10B36 AISI/SAE 1040
AISI/SAE 1045 AISI/SAE 1060
AISI/SAE 1070 AISI/SAE 1080
Fig. No.
Cover 7.1 1.2(a) 3.10 4.20 4.21 7.39 3.41 8.31 8.32 8.52 8.53 2.42 3.5 3.42 3.51 3.52 5.35 6.2 6.3 7.4 7.7 7.45 8.9 8.33 2.14 7.14 3.39 3.40 8.37 Cover 1.2(b) 2.6 2.23 3.1 3.3 3.4 3.15 5.64 5.65 3.29 3.30 6.18 Cover 2.15 2.16 2.22 2.41 4.8 4.9 2.1 2.19 2.20 2.21 3.28 3.47 3.55 3.56 3.58 3.59 3.60 4.5 4.6 5.24
Page No.
Steels/irons
Fig. No.
Page No.
6.9 6.11 7.3 7.8 7.41 8.2 8.21 8.38 1.2(c) 2.26 3.48 3.31 3.32 7.6 8.5 1.3 8.34 2.43 7.22 4.14
153 153 171 174 206 218 228 236 4 36 75 67 68, 69 173 219 5 234 42 188 97
0.75%C-3.25% Cr Cr-Mo Ni-Cu-Cr-Mo
6.27 7.15 3.21 4.15 5.41 4.11 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.17 3.19 3.20 2.33 2.34 8.35 8.7 4.11 8.17 3.33 3.34 3.35 3.36 3.37 3.38 6.37 3.45 2.30 2.31 2.32 2.39 3.57 8.26 8.28 7.46 7.47 5.32 8.30 2.39
161 182 63 97 132 96 53 53 54 60 61 62 39 39 235 221 96 226 69 69 70 70 70 73 167 75 37 38 38 41 82 231 232 211 212 126 232 41
Tool steels AISI/SAE A2 AISI/SAE A8
8.12 5.67
224 147
Carbon steels (continued) AISI/SAE 1080
ii 170 4 55 100 100 205 73 233 233 243 243 42 53 74 77 78 128, 129 150 150 172 174 210 222 233 33 180, 181 73 73 235 ii 4 28 35 50 51 52, 53 58 146 147 66 67 156 ii 33 33 35 41 94 95 23, 24 34 34 35 66 75 80 81 83 83 84 91 92 122
AISI/SAE 1095 AISI/SAE 1117 AISI/SAE 1144 AISI/SAE 11L44 AISI/SAE 1213 AISI/SAE 1524 Steel, screw Steel, shot (S-230) Low-alloy steels AISI/SAE 1335 AISI/SAE 4327 AISI/SAE 4340 AISI 52100 AISI/SAE 8630
AISI/SAE 8720 AISI/SAE 8860 AISI/SAE 9425 AISI/SAE 52100 Low-alloy 0.7%C-3%Cr
E660 3%Cr 0.2%C-1%Mn-5%Ni Ni-Cr-Mo
0.23%C-3.4%Ni-1.7%Cr-0.5%Mo 0.5%Mo-B 2.5%Ni-0.4 Nb
viii
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Atlas of Microstructures Steels/irons
Tool steels (continued) AISI/SAE D2 AISI/SAE M2 AISI/SAE W1 Stainless steels AISI/SAE 301 AISI/SAE 303 AISI/SAE 304 AISI/SAE 309 AISI/SAE 316
AISI/SAE 316L AISI/SAE 347H AISI/SAE 410 AISI/SAE 430F Custom 630 Duplex 7Mo Plus Duplex 2205 Very-low carbon steels Interstitial-free Enameling Motor lamination Very-low carbon Low-carbon
Low-carbon (0.02%) Low-carbon (0.04%) Low-carbon cold-rolled
Iron alloys Pure iron Iron-0.2%C Iron-0.4%C Iron-0.6%C
Fig. No.
Page No.
5.46 8.27 1.19 8.22
135 231 15 229
8.45 4.17 4.18 4.19 3.12 8.6 1.11 2.36 3.43 3.44 3.53 3.54 5.47 5.60 8.44 8.46 8.47 7.33 Cover 1.15 2.28 1.13 1.17 8.42 8.43 1.16 8.40 8.48
240 98 99 99 57 220 11 40 74 74 79 79 136 141 239 240 241 197 ii 14 37 12 14 238 239 14 237 241
3.16 8.20 8.55 8.56 1.23 8.39 5.44 7.5 7.18 7.21 8.8 8.13 8.14 8.23 8.24 2.13 2.17 3.11 8.15 8.16
59 227 244 244 16 236 134 173 184 186 222 224 225 229 229 32 33 56 225 226
8.19 2.24 8.10 8.1 8.10 8.10
226 36 223 216 223 223
Steels/irons
Iron alloys (continued) Iron-1.0%C Iron-1.2%C Iron-1.4%C Iron-1.75%C Iron-1.86%C Wrought iron Lancashire iron Meteorite High-strength steels X65 linepipe HSLA
Dual-phase
1/2Mo-B Comp F (MIL-S-23194) Alloy steels Maraging Invar A286 superalloy 1%C-14%Cr 0.93%C-1.45%Mn 0.93%C-14.5%Ni 25%Cr-12%Ni 19%Cr-9%Ni Grinding ball Coated steels Galvalume
Aluminized Type 1 Aluminized Type 2 Nickel plate Enamel ASTM steels ASTM A1 rail
ASTM A 36 structural
ix
Fig. No.
Page No.
7.17 3.49 3.50 2.7 2.18 3.46 5.42 2.27 8.4 8.3 4.4
184 76 77 28 34 75 133 137 218 218 88
1.7 3.13 6.10 6.16 6.28 7.42 1.8 2.38 3.9 7.12 8.18 8.36 8.28 8.29
8 57 153 156 161 207 9 40 55 179 226 235 232 232
1.21 8.41 1.22 1.18 7.26 2.37 8.11 5.36 5.63 7.10
15 238 15 14 192 40 224 129, 130 145 176, 177
6.5 6.6 8.49 8.50 8.51 4.7 4.7 7.1 7.18 7.29 8.55 8.56
151 151 242 242 242 93 93 170 184 195 244 244
1.4 3.55 3.56 4.5 4.6 4.16 1.5 7.11 7.40
6 80 81 91 92 98 6 178 206
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Atlas of Microstructures Steels/irons
ASTM steels (continued) ASTM A 128 Hadfield ASTM A 247 ASTM A 470 rotor ASTM A 514 ASTM A 516 ASTM A 710 ASME steels ASME SA 210 tubing ASME SA 213 T22 tubing Other steels Ancient steel Blister steel Cast irons Gray iron
White iron
Malleable iron
Ductile (nodular) iron
Mottled iron Austempered ductile iron
Fig. No.
Page No.
1.20 1.25 4.22 1.9 2.25 3.61 6.10
15 17 101, 102 9 36 84 153
3.62 1.6 8.25
85 7 230
7.9 4.2
175 88
1.24 1.25 2.48 2.56 3.63 5.13 5.14 1.26 2.45 2.46 2.49 2.54 2.55 3.22 5.17 1.28 2.53 3.23 3.24 3.25 1.30 2.51 2.52 3.26 3.27 4.23 4.24 1.27 2.50 1.31
16 17 44 47 85 115 115 18 43 44 45 47 47 64 117, 118 18 46 64 65 65 20 45 46 65 65 103 103 18 45 20
Microstructures
Microstructures Acicular ferrite Alloy carbides
Alloy layer Annealing twins
Austenite
Austenite/ferrrite Bainite
Bainite/ferrite Bainite/graphite Bainite (granular) Bainite (lower) Bainite (upper) Bainite transformation Banding
Bull’s-eye structure Carburized surface Cementite platelets Central bursts in wire Cold work
x
Fig. No.
2.16 1.19 5.46 7.10 7.26 8.12 8.22 8.27 4.7 1.11 1.18 1.22 2.36 8.44 1.11 1.18 1.20 1.22 2.36 3.12 3.43 3.44 3.53 3.54 5.47 8.44 8.46 5.60 8.47 2.1(b) 2.31 2.32 6.15 7.46 7.47 8.7 3.21(a) 7.15(d) 1.31 2.35 2.34 1.9 2.33 6.33 1.3 2.43 3.1 3.13 3.15 3.19 3.61 6.27 7.4 8.34 8.40 3.26 4.23(a) 3.31 3.32 2.7 2.18 5.17 4.8 3.11
Page No.
33 15 135 176, 177 192 224 229 231 93 11 14 15 40 239 11 14 15 15 40 57 74 74 79 79 136 239 240 141 241 23 38 38 155 211 212 221 63 182 20 39 39 9 39 165 5 42 50 57 58 61 84 161 172 234 237 65 103 67 68, 69 28 34 117, 118 94 56
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Atlas of Microstructures Microstructures
Microstructures (continued) Cold work
Copper precipitates Copper penetration Creep voids Decarburized surface Deformation bands Delta ferrite
Dendritic structure
Dimpled fracture surface Enamel coating Epitaxial ferrite
Equiaxed ferrite
Eutectic carbides Exaggerated grain growth Fayalite Ferrite
Ferrite/austenite
Fig. No.
3.16 5.47 6.36 6.37 7.5 7.11(a) 8.15 8.16 8.32 8.45 8.52 6.10 3.40 3.57 3.28 3.29 3.30 3.12 3.53 5.47 4.19 5.60 8.47 8.48 2.42 7.10 8.50 8.51 8.6 6.19 8.55 8.56 3.10 3.32(e) 3.32(f) 5.44 8.18 8.36 1.2(a) 1.23 2.13 8.8 8.13 8.20 8.27 3.4 6.18 1.13 1.23 2.13 3.11 3.16 5.44 7.5 7.21 8.8 8.15 8.16 8.18 8.20 8.39 8.55 1.16 4.19
Page No.
Microstructures
Microstructures (continued) Ferrite/austenite Ferrite/bainite Ferrite/carbides
59 136 167 167 173 178 225 226 233 240 243 153 73 82 66 66 67 57 79 136 99 141 241 241 42 176 242 242 220 156 244 244 55 69 69 134 226 235 4 16 32 222 224 227 231 52, 53 156 12 16 32 56 59 134 173 186 222 225 226 226 227 236 244 14 99
Ferrite/graphite
Ferrite/pearlite
Ferrite/martensite
xi
Fig. No.
8.40 3.21(a) 2.17 3.17 3.19 8.1 8.13 8.14 8.23 1.28 1.30 3.23 3.48 3.49 4.23 4.24 1.2(a) 1.2(b) 1.3 1.5 1.7 2.6 2.14 2.23 2.42 2.43 3.1 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.13 3.15 3.19 3.52(c) 3.61 3.62 4.20 4.21 6.2 6.27 7.3 7.4 7.9 7.11 7.14(d) 7.29 7.40 8.31 8.32 8.34 8.52 8.53 1.6 1.8 2.16 2.38 3.9 3.10 3.32(e) 3.32(f) 3.52(b) 7.12
Page No.
237 63 33 60 61 216, 217 224 225 229 18 20 64 75 76 103 103 4 4 5 6 8 28 33 35 42 42 50 51 52, 53 53 53 53 57 58 61 78 84 85 100 100 150 161 171 172 175 178 181 195 206 233 233 234 243 243 7 9 33 40 55 55 69 69 78 179
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Atlas of Microstructures Microstructures
Microstructures (continued) Ferrite/martensite Ferrite/martensite/bainite/ pearlite Flow lines Fractured weld Grain boundary carbides
Grain boundary segregation Graphite flakes
Graphite nodules
Graphitic corrosion Graphitization Heat-affected zone Hot cracking (weld) Hot shortness Hydrogen flakes
Inclusions Inclusions Inclusions Inclusions
(CaS) (FeS) (lead) (MnS)
Inclusions (oxide)
Inclusions (slag) Inclusions (TiN) Internal oxidation Lath martensite
Fig No.
Page No.
8.36 8.37
235 235
4.15 4.10 7.45 8.6 2.17 5.36 8.8 8.13 8.14 8.25 3.36 3.38 1.24 2.48 3.63 5.13 5.14 2.52 3.26 3.27 4.22 4.23 4.24 3.63 3.48 3.49 3.50 4.10 8.6 3.39 3.40 3.58 3.59 3.60 3.61 3.62 6.25 3.41 8.5 1.3 1.13 3.33 3.34 3.35 3.42 6.19 7.6 7.39 8.2 8.34 6.25 6.26 7.7 8.3 8.34 8.4 8.54 5.67 7.8 3.30 2.24
97 95 210 220 33 129, 130 222 224 225 230 70 73 16 44 85 115 115 46 65 65 101, 102 103 103 85 75 76 77 95 220 73 73 83 83 84 84 85 160 73 219 5 12 69 69 70 74 156 173 205 218 234 160 160 174 218 234 218 243 147 174 67 36
Microstructures
Microstructures (continued) Lath martensite
Ledeburite
Martensite
Martensite/austenite
Martensite/carbides Martensite/pearlite Meteorite Microcracks Oxide layer Oxide penetration Oxidized surface Pearlite
xii
Fig. No.
2.25 2.28 3.8 3.20 3.32(c) 3.32(d) 3.52(a) 5.35 8.9 8.10 8.17 8.33 8.41 8.42 8.43 1.26 1.27 2.45 2.46 2.49 3.22 1.15 1.17 1.21 2.1(c) 3.17(a) 4.9 7.14(c) 2.37 2.39 2.54 2.55 3.32(a) 3.32(b) 3.46 8.11 7.10 7.26 8.27 2.22 3.33 5.32 4.4 3.46 3.47 7.17 7.22 8.26 6.18 8.26 1.4 2.1(a) 2.19 2.20 2.21 3.56(d) 3.58 4.5 4.6 5.24 6.9 6.11 7.3 7.8
Page No.
36 37 54 62 68 68 78 128, 129 222 223 226 233 238 238 239 18 18 43 44 45 64 14 14 15 24 60 95 181 40 41 47 47 68 68 75 224 176, 177 192 231 35 69 126 88 75 75 184 188 231 156 231 6 23 34 34 35 81 83 91 92 122 153 153 171 174
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Atlas of Microstructures Microstructures
Microstructures (continued) Pearlite Pearlite/bainite Pearlite/bainite/martensite Pearlite/cementite
Pearlite colonies Pearlite/ferrite Pearlite/graphite
Pearlite lamella
Pearlite/martensite Pearlite nodules Phosphorus segregation Plate martensite
Prior austenite grain boundaries
Fig No.
8.21 8.38 3.21(b) 2.1(d) 1.26 1.27 2.7 2.45 2.46 2.49 3.22 5.17 8.22 2.21 8.21 2.15 2.41 7.3 1.24 2.48 2.50 2.51 2.53 2.56 3.24 3.25 3.26 3.63 4.23 4.24 5.13 5.14 2.19 2.20 4.5 4.6 5.13 5.14 5.24 6.9 6.11 5.32 2.22 3.36 2.26 2.27 3.32(a) 3.32(b) 2.37 3.46 3.47 3.56(b),(c) 5.42 7.17 8.10 8.11 3.33 3.36 3.38 3.57 5.41 8.17 8.18 8.25
Page No.
Microstructures
Microstructures (continued) Prior austenite grain boundaries
228 236 63 24 18 18 28 43 44 45 64 117 229 35 228 33 41 171 16 44 45 45 46 47 65 65 65 85 103 103 115 115 34 34 91 92 115 115 122 153 153 126 35 70 36 37 68 68 40 75 75 81 133 184 223 224 69 70 73 82 132 226 226 230
Proeutectoid cementite Proeutectoid ferrite Recrystallized grains Retained austenite
Rusted surface Sensitized stainless steel
Silicon carbide particles Spangle dendrites Spheriodized carbides
Steadite Stress-corrosion cracking Sulfur segregation Surface carbides Surface damage (abrasive wheel) Surface damage (EDM) Surface damage (polishing) Surface damage (shearing) Surface damage (torch-cut) Surface damage (wheel burn on rail) Temper carbon
Temper carbides Temper embrittlement Tempered martensite
xiii
Fig. No.
Page No.
8.28 8.29 8.30 1.2(c) 2.7 2.18 2.15 2.41 7.41 3.16 8.15 2.37 2.38 2.39 3.10 3.32(b) 7.12 8.11 7.46 7.47 3.43 3.44 3.54 8.25 8.44 7.1 8.50 8.51 3.17(b) 3.19(b) 3.48 8.1 2.56 5.14 4.18 4.19 4.16 8.33 7.9 7.10 7.15 7.41 7.42 7.11 7.12 3.51 3.52 7.14 3.55
232 232 232 4 28 34 33 41 206 59 225 40 40 41 55 68 179 224 211 212 74 74 79 230 239 170 242 242 60 61 75 216, 217 47 115 99 99 98 233 175 176 182 206 207 178 179 77 78 180 80
1.28 2.53 3.23 3.24 3.25 8.33 3.45 1.19 2.30 3.20 3.21(c) 3.56(b) 4.11 8.25
18 46 64 65 65 233 75 15 37 62 63 81 96 230
© 2002 ASM International. All Rights Reserved. Metallographer’s Guide: Irons and Steels (#06040G)
www.asminternational.org
Atlas of Microstructures Microstructures
Microstructures (continued) Tempered martensite Tempered martensite/alloy carbides Titanium-molybdenum carbides Veining Vermicular graphite
Fig No.
Page No.
8.33 8.35 1.19 7.10 6.16 6.28 8.19 4.24
233 235 15 176 156 161 226 103
Microstructures
Microstructures (continued) Voids White surface layer Widmanstatten ferrite Widmanstatten structure Wustite
xiv
Fig. No.
Page No.
3.36 3.37 3.57 3.55 3.56 2.14 4.4 6.18
70 70 82 80 81 33 88 156
Metallographer's Guide: Practices and Procedures for Irons and Steels Bruce L. Bramfitt, Arlan O. Benscoter, p1-21 DOI:10.1361/mgpp2002p001
Copyright © 2002 ASM International® All rights reserved. www.asminternational.org
CHAPTER 1
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons STEELS AND CAST IRONS are basically alloys of iron and various other elements in the periodic table. The vast majority of steels and all cast irons contain carbon as a principal alloying element. As a general definition, a steel is an alloy of iron, carbon (under 2% C), and other alloying elements that is capable of being hot and/or cold deformed into various shapes. A cast iron, on the other hand, is an alloy of iron, carbon (over 2% C), and other elements and is not normally capable of being hot and/or cold deformed. A cast iron is used in its cast form. Steels and cast irons are the most widely used and least expensive metallic materials on earth. This Chapter introduces the metallographer to the various types of steels and cast irons and explains how they are classified and defined. The classification includes the plain carbon and alloy steels as well as the gray, white, ductile, and malleable cast irons, beginning with the steels.
Steels There are thousands of different steel compositions currently available around the world. To the beginning metallographer, the variety and terminology may at first be overwhelming. In fact, the way that steels are classified may be quite confusing even to the seasoned metallographer and metallurgist. However, in many cases the steels fall into a limited number of well-defined classes. An attempt is made in this chapter to summarize these classes. More detailed information can be found in the ASM Handbook (Volume 1), the selected references listed at the end of the Chapter, and in the Appendix.
Classification of Steels Generally, the carbon and low-alloy steels come under a classification system based on composition. The higher-alloy steels (the stainless, heat-resistant, wear-resistant steels, etc.) can be classified according to many different systems, including composition, microstructure, application, or specification. The flow diagram in Fig. 1.1 shows very generally how steels are classified. On the left side, they are classified by commercial name or application, and on the right side, by microstructure. The flow diagram may look complicated at first, but this Chapter attempts to explain it. Mostly, the classifications on the left side of the diagram are examined.
The easiest way to classify steels is by their chemical composition. Various alloying elements are added to iron for the purpose of attaining certain specific properties and characteristics. These elements include, but are not limited to, carbon, manganese, silicon, nickel, chromium, molybdenum, vanadium, columbium (niobium), copper, aluminum, titanium, tungsten, and cobalt. The functions of each of these elements and others are listed in Table 1.1. Most steels contain several of these elements, particularly, carbon, manganese, and silicon.
Formal Classification Systems Many nations have their own classification system for steels and cast irons. Because of the complexity of these different classification systems, only those used in the United States are described in this Chapter. The American Iron and Steel Institute (AISI) and Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) System. For many decades, plain carbon, low-alloy steels have been classified by composition using a system devised by SAE and eventually AISI. In this chapter, the steels thus classified have “AISI/SAE” before the steel code number, for example, AISI/SAE 1040 steel. The system is based solely on composition. In the four- or five-digit code designation, the last two or three digits represent the carbon content (three digits for steels with a carbon content of 1.00% and above), and the first two digits represent the compositional class. Thus, in the example of AISI/SAE 1040 mentioned previously, the “10” represents the class of plain carbon steels, and the “40” represents the carbon content of 0.40% C. The AISI/SAE designations and compositions are listed in the Appendix. The American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) System. Another system was devised by ASTM. This system is not based on composition but on the steel product and application, for example, railroad rails, boiler tubes, plate, and bolts. ASTM has devised a system of specifications that contain composition, mechanical properties, and other required characteristics of steels and cast irons. The ASTM system reaches far beyond ferrous materials and includes other materials, such as rubber, cement, wood, fabric, copper, and so on. The American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) devised a similar system, but it is generally limited to boiler and heat exchanger steels and other materials that are covered by the boiler code specifications.
2 / Metallographer’s Guide The Unified Numbering System (UNS). Because of the confusion of different systems, a number of technical societies and U.S. governmental agencies devised what is known as the Unified Numbering System. There is a UNS designation for each steel composition, and it consists of a letter followed by five digits. The system fully incorporates the AISI/SAE system. For example, the UNS designation for AISI/SAE 1040 is G10400. The letter “G” represents the AISI/SAE plain carbon and alloy steels. Other ferrous alloys have different letters, such as “F” for cast irons and cast steels (cast steels can also have the letter “J”), “D” for steels with specific mechanical properties, “S” for heat- and corrosionresistant steels, “T” for tool steels, and “H” for steels with enhanced hardenability. In this book, the AISI/SAE designations are favored only because they are, at the present time, more
Fig. 1.1 Classification chart for steels
widely used than the UNS designations. However, in the reference tables in the Appendix, both designations are listed. In this Chapter, all systems are used where appropriate. For some steels, it may be easier to use the AISI/SAE system, for others, the ASTM system. We first examine the way the steels are classified simply by composition, using the AISI/SAE system. This system has been established for many years and is widely used in industry.
Carbon and Low-Alloy Steels The general category of carbon and low-alloy steels encompasses plain carbon steels, alloy steels, high-strength low-alloy
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons / 3 Table 1.1 Element
Carbon (C)
Manganese (Mn)
Phosphorus (P)
Sulfur (S) Silicon (Si)
Nickel (Ni)
Chromium (Cr)
Molybdenum (Mo)
Copper (Cu)
Cobalt (Co)
Tungsten (W)
Essential and incidental elements in steel and cast iron Function
An essential alloying element in most steels. Added to increase solid-solution strength and hardness as well as to increase hardenability. Dissolves in iron to form ferrite and austenite. Combines with iron to form a carbide (cementite-Fe3C). The carbide is a component of pearlite. An essential alloying element in most steels. Added to increase solid-solution strength and hardness as well as to increase hardenability. A weak carbide former (greater than iron). Counteracts brittleness caused by sulfur (iron sulfide) through the formation of a manganese sulfide (MnS). High levels of manganese produce an austenitic steel with improved wear and abrasion resistance. Usually considered an impurity in most steels. Can be added to low-carbon steels to increase strength and hardness. Improves machinability of free-machining steels. Promotes temper embrittlement. Forms an undesirable iron phosphide (Fe3P) at high phosphorus levels (especially in cast irons) Usually considered an impurity in steel. Added to special steels for improved machinability An essential alloying element in most steels. Added to increase solid-solution strength and hardness as well as to increase hardenability. Is added to molten steel to remove oxygen (deoxidize). As a result of deoxidation, can form silicate stringers (silicon dioxide inclusions). Does not form a carbide in steels. Improves oxidation resistance. Added to special steels to improve electrical and magnetic properties as well as hardenability. Increases susceptibility to decarburization. Promotes graphitization in cast irons An essential alloying element in some steels. Added to increase solid-solution strength and hardness as well as to increase hardenability. Toughens steels, especially at low temperatures. Does not form a carbide in steel. Renders high-chromium stainless steels austenitic An essential alloying element in some low-alloy steels and all stainless steels. Added to slightly increase solid-solution strength and hardness as well as to increase hardenability. Increases resistance to corrosion and high-temperature oxidation. A carbide former (greater than manganese); its carbides improve wear and abrasion resistance and provide high-temperature strength. An essential alloying element in some low-alloy steels and tool steels. Added to increase solid-solution strength and hardness as well as to increase hardenability. A strong carbide former (stronger than chromium). Improves high-temperature properties, including creep strength. Counteracts temper embrittlement. Enhances corrosion resistance in stainless steels Usually considered an impurity or tramp element in most steels, because it promotes hot shortness. Added to some steels for improved corrosion resistance. Added in special steels for increased strength and hardness through heat treating (aging). Very insoluble in iron at room temperature and does not form a carbide An essential alloying element in some steels. Added to increase strength and hardness. Improves hot hardness. Weak carbide former. An important element in some tool steels and heat-resistant steels. Decreases hardenability An essential alloying element in some steels. Added to increase solid-solution strength and hardness as well as to increase hardenability. Strong carbide former; the carbides form hard, abrasion-resistant particles in tool steels.
Element
Vanadium (V)
Columbium (Cb) Niobium (Nb) Aluminum (Al)
Titanium (Ti)
Boron (B)
Nitrogen (N) Lead (Pb) Bismuth (Bi) Tin (Sn) Antimony (Sb) Arsenic (As) Oxygen (O)
Hydrogen (H)
Calcium (Ca)
Zirconium (Zr) Cerium (Ce) Magnesium (Mg)
Function
An important element in microalloyed steels. Added to increase strength and hardness of steel by grain-size control (grain refinement) as well as to increase hardenability. Strong nitride former; also forms a carbide. Minimizes loss in strength during tempering An important element in microalloyed steels. Added to increase strength and hardness of steel by grain-size control (grain refinement) as well as to increase hardenability. Strong carbide former; also forms a nitride An important alloying element in nitrided steels and deep-drawing sheet steels. Added to increase strength and hardness of steel by grain-size control (grain refinement). A common deoxidizer. Forms undesirable alumina inclusions (aluminum oxides). A strong nitride former. Does not form a carbide in steel An important element in microalloyed steels. Added to increase strength and hardness of steel by grain-size control (grain refinement). Very strong carbide and nitride former. Important element to “getter” or tie up nitrogen in steels (protects boron from nitrogen in boron-treated steels). Also a strong deoxidizer. Can combine with sulfur to form titanium sulfides Added to steel to increase hardenability. Enhances the hardenability characteristics of other alloying elements. Added to steel for nuclear reactor applications because of its high cross section for neutrons Added to some microalloyed steels to increase the amount of nitrides required for strengthening or grain-size control (e.g., in a vanadium steel) Insoluble in steel. Added to special leaded steels for improved machinability. Environmentally sensitive Similar to lead. Added to special steels for improved machinability An impurity or tramp element in steel. Promotes temper embrittlement An impurity or tramp element in steel. Promotes temper embrittlement An impurity or tramp element in steel. Promotes temper embrittlement Undesirable in steel. Combines with other elements (manganese, silicon, aluminum, titanium, etc.) to form oxide inclusions that can degrade toughness and fatigue resistance. Usually minimized in steel by deoxidation with aluminum and/or silicon and vacuum degassing Undesirable in steel. If entrapped, can cause crack formation (hydrogen flakes, microcracks, etc.). Usually minimized in liquid steel by vacuum degassing or slow cooling after the austenite-to-ferrite transformation Added to steel for sulfide shape control (combines with sulfur to form rounded, undeformable inclusions). Strong deoxidizer. Forms calcium oxide and calcium aluminate inclusions Added to steel for sulfide shape control (forms rounded, undeformable zirconium sulfides). Strong deoxidizer. Forms zirconium oxide and is a strong nitride former Added to steel for sulfide shape control (forms rounded, undeformable cerium sulfide inclusions). Strong deoxidizer Added to liquid cast iron to nucleate graphite nodules in ductile (nodular) iron
4 / Metallographer’s Guide (HSLA) steels, and a variety of other low-alloy steels. Each of these subcategories is described in the following sections.
Plain Carbon Steels The more commonly used steels are classified according to composition. These steels include the plain carbon steels, with the following general subclasses: Subclass
The microstructures of typical low-carbon, medium-carbon, and high-carbon steels are shown in Fig.1.2(a), (b), and (c), respectively. The low-carbon steel is represented by an AISI/SAE 1010 steel, the medium-carbon steel by an AISI/SAE 1040 steel, and the high-carbon steel by an AISI/SAE 1095 steel. As carbon content increases, the amount of pearlite (the dark etching constituent) increases. Actually, the amount of pearlite increases up to a maximum of 100% at a carbon content near 0.8%. Below
Carbon content (a), %
Low-carbon steels Medium-carbon steels High-carbon steels
Under 0.2 0.2–0.5 Above 0.5
(a) All percentages in this Chapter are weight percent, unless otherwise noted.
AISI/SAE Classification System for Plain Carbon Steels. The plain carbon steels can be further classified by specific composition according to the AISI and SAE designations. As a specific example, the designation AISI/SAE 1040 signifies a mediumcarbon steel with a nominal carbon content of 0.40% and with the following range of composition: Element
Content, %
Carbon Manganese Phosphorus Sulfur
0.37–0.44 0.60–0.90 0.040 max 0.050 max
The AISI/SAE designations for the plain carbon steels are listed in the Appendix.
Fig. 1.2(a) Micrograph of low-carbon AISI/SAE 1010 steel showing a matrix of ferrite grains (white etching constituent) and pearlite (dark etching constituent). Etched in Marshall’s reagent followed by 2% nital. 200⫻
Fig. 1.2(b) Micrograph of medium-carbon AISI/SAE 1040 steel showing ferrite grains (white etching constituent) and pearlite (dark etching constituent). Etched in 4% picral followed by 2% nital. 300⫻
Fig. 1.2(c) Micrograph of high-carbon AISI/SAE 1095 steel showing a
matrix of pearlite and some grain-boundary cementite. Etched in 4% picral. 500⫻
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons / 5 0.8% C, the other constituent in the microstructure is ferrite, as seen in Fig. 1.2(a) and (b). Above 0.8%, the other constituent is cementite, as seen in Fig. 1.2(c). More details about these constituents are found in the next Chapter. Within the AISI/SAE plain carbon steel designations there are five subclasses, namely 10xx, 11xx, 12xx, 13xx, and 15xx. These are broadly based on the following categories of steel composition: AISI/SAE designation
10xx 15xx 13xx (a) 11xx 12xx
Type of steel
Plain Plain Plain Plain Plain
carbon: carbon: carbon: carbon: carbon:
Mn 1.00% max Mn 1.00–1.60% Mn 1.60–1.90% resulfurized resulfurized and rephosphorized
(a) Actually, the 13xx series of steels is classified as low-alloy steels because of the high manganese level. (Generally a steel with an alloying element content above 1.5% is considered a low-alloy steel; above 8% it is considered a high-alloy steel.) However, in the case of the 13xx series, one is basically dealing with a simple extension of the 10xx and 15xx plain carbon steels.
The AISI/SAE 15xx and 13xx series represent high-manganese, plain carbon steels. The higher manganese levels impart higher hardness and strength to the steels. The complete series of AISI/SAE 15xx and 13xx steels are listed in the Appendix. The 11xx series of plain carbon, resulfurized steels contains intentionally added sulfur. The sulfur does not actually alloy with the iron but combines with manganese to form manganese sulfide (MnS) inclusions. The sulfur level is much higher in the 11xx series than the 10xx series of plain carbon steels where sulfur is generally considered as an impurity. The higher sulfur level in the resulfurized steels imparts improved machinability to the steel because of the chip-breaking effect of the manganese sulfides. An example of a resulfurized steel is AISI/SAE 1140 steel, with the following composition:
Element
Content, %
Carbon Manganese Phosphorus Sulfur
0.37–0.44 0.70–1.00 0.040 max 0.08–0.13
For a given carbon content, the manganese levels are slightly higher in the 11xx series than in the previously discussed 10xx series. The higher manganese levels compensate for the higher sulfur levels, because manganese is added to tie up all the sulfur to form manganese sulfides. The AISI/SAE 11xx series of resulfurized steels is listed in the Appendix. The AISI/SAE 12xx series represents resulfurized and rephosphorized, plain carbon steels that are also free-machining steels, with both sulfur and phosphorus as alloy additions. The phosphorus addition increases the strength of the steel and promotes chip breaking during machining operations. In order to limit the strength of the steel, the carbon content is restricted to a level under 0.15%. For example, an AISI/SAE 1213 steel is represented by the following composition:
Element
Content, %
Carbon Manganese Phosphorus Sulfur
0.13 max 0.70–1.00 0.07–0.12 0.24–0.33
Fig. 1.3 shows the microstructure of a typical resulfurized, rephosphorized steel containing manganese sulfides (the oblong, gray particles). The AISI/SAE 12xx series of steels is listed in the Appendix. As has been shown, the AISI/SAE system for classifying the plain carbon steels is quite simple and is based solely on chemical composition. However, many plain carbon and alloy steels are classified according to a much more complex system based on the product application, the chemical composition, and the mechanical properties. This system has been devised by ASTM. The ASTM system consists of a set of detailed specifications for each steel, depending upon how it is used. Thus, there are specifications for plate, strip, sheet, rod, railroad rails, pipe, bolts, wire, nuts, structural shapes, and so on. The system is much different than the AISI/SAE system, and it is only touched on in this Chapter. The ASTM Specification System for Plain Carbon Steels. ASTM has very elaborate specifications for steels that include the type of product (sheet, plate, bar, wire, rail, etc.), the composition limits, and the mechanical properties. The ASTM specifications for iron and steel products comprise six 25 mm (1 in.) thick books weighing over 5.5 kg (12 lb). (The specifications can also be obtained in compact diskette form.) The specification code consists of the letter “A” followed by a number. A partial list of the plain carbon steels according to the ASTM specification system is given subsequently:
Fig. 1.3 Micrograph of a resulfurized, rephosphorized AISI/SAE 1213 steel
showing manganese sulfide inclusions (the gray, oblong particles marked by arrows). The remaining microstructure is ferrite (white etching constituent) and pearlite (dark etching constituent). Etched in 4% picral followed by 2% nital. 200⫻
6 / Metallographer’s Guide ASTM designation
A1 A 36 A 131 A 228 A 307 A 510 A 529 A 570 A 709
Type of steel
Carbon steel, tee rails Structural steel Structural steel for ships Steel wire, music spring quality Carbon steel, bolts and studs, 420 MPa (60 ksi) tensile strength Carbon steel wire rods Structural steel with 290 MPa (42 ksi) minimum yield point Steel, sheet and strip, carbon, hot rolled, structural quality Structural steel for bridges
As examples, two of these ASTM specifications are described in more detail: ASTM A 1 for railway rails and ASTM A 36 for structural steels (structural beams, plate, etc.). ASTM A 1 requires that railroad rails have certain composition limits and a minimum hardness. For example, for a common rail size of 60 kg/m (132 lb/yd) the requirements are:
Carbon Yield point Tensile strength Total elongation (in 50 mm, or 2 in.)
The microstructure of a typical ASTM A 36 structural steel is shown in Fig. 1.5. The microstructure is a mixture of pearlite and ferrite, with some manganese sulfide stringers. The ASTM specifications illustrated previously are rather simple. As the product becomes more critical and the composition more complex, the requirements expand considerably.
Alloy Steels The alloy steels are generally divided into two classes: the low-alloy steels and the high-alloy steels. They are divided according to composition as follows: Type
Carbon Manganese Phosphorus Sulfur Silicon Hardness
0.72–0.82% 0.80–1.10% 0.035% max 0.040% max 0.10–0.20% 269 HB min
The microstructure of a typical ASTM A 1 rail steel is shown in Fig. 1.4. The microstructure is 100% pearlite. ASTM A 36 for structural steels is very different from ASTM A 1 for rail steel in that it specifies only a minimum carbon content and certain tensile properties. ASTM A 36 has the following requirements:
Fig. 1.4 Micrograph of ASTM A 1 rail steel showing the fully pearlitic microstructure. Etched in 4% picral. 500⫻
0.26% max 248 MPa (36 ksi) min 400–552 MPa (58–80 ksi) 21% min
Low-alloy steels High-alloy steels
Alloying elements, %
<8 >8
The AISI/SAE Classification System for Low-Alloy Steels. As with the plain carbon steels, there is an established classification system of AISI/SAE designations for the low-alloy steels. The classification is based on the principal alloying element(s) in the steel. These principal elements include carbon, manganese, silicon, nickel, chromium, molybdenum, and vanadium. Each element, either singly or in combination with other elements, imparts certain properties and characteristics to the steel. The role of each element was described in Table 1.1. The subsequent list gives the breakdown of the AISI/SAE classification for the low-alloy steels:
Fig. 1.5 Micrograph of ASTM A 36 structural steel showing a microstructure consisting of ferrite (light etching constituent) and pearlite (dark etching constituent). Etched in 4% picral followed by 2% nital. 200⫻
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons / 7 AISI/SAE designation
13xx 40xx 41xx 43xx 44xx 46xx 47xx 48xx 50xx 51xx 50xxx 51xxx 61xx 81xx 86xx 87xx 88xx 92xx 93xx 94xx xxBxx xxLxx
Type of steel
1.75% Mn steels 0.25% Mo steels 0.50 and 0.95% Cr-0.12 and 0.25% Mo steels 1.80% Ni-0.50 and 0.80% Cr-0.25 and 0.40% Mo steels 0.40% Mo steels 0.85 and 1.80% Ni-0.20 and 0.25% Mo steels 1.05% Ni-0.45% Cr-0.20 and 0.35% Mo steels 3.5% Ni-0.25% Mo steels 0.28 and 0.50% Cr steels 0.80, 0.88, 0.95 and 1.00% Cr steels 1.05–1.45% Cr steels 1.03% Cr steels 0.60 and 0.95% Cr-0.13 and 0.15% (min) V steels 0.30% Ni-0.40% Cr-0.12% Mo steels 0.55% Ni-0.50% Cr-0.20% Mo steels 0.55% Ni-0.50% Cr-0.25% Mo steels 0.55% Ni-0.50% Cr-0.35% Mo steels 1.40 and 2.00% Si-0.00 and 0.7% Cr steels 3.25% Ni-1.20% Cr-0.12% Mo steels 0.50% Ni-0.40% Cr-0.98% Mo steels Boron steels (“B” denotes boron) Leaded steels (“L” denotes lead)
The composition ranges for the previously mentioned AISI/ SAE low-alloy steels (except for the boron and leaded steels) are listed in the Appendix. There are many low-alloy steels that are not classified under the previously mentioned AISI/SAE system (some of these steels are also listed in the Appendix). Thus, the situation with low-alloy steels becomes much more complicated. For example, HY-80, a steel widely used for high-strength plate and forging applications, is a Ni-Cr-Mo steel but does not have an AISI/SAE designation. This particular steel is covered by a specification designation, ASTM A 543. ASTM has dozens of specifications for low-alloy steels. This system is discussed subsequently.
The ASTM Specification System for Low-Alloy Steels. As with the plain carbon steels, ASTM specifications also cover many of the low-alloy steels. However, as mentioned previously, the ASTM system is driven by the application for the particular steel. The system for low-alloy steels is quite large and is only touched on in this chapter; for example, a fairly common low-alloy steel is 21⁄4Cr-1Mo steel. In the ASTM system there are 13 separate specifications covering this steel, depending on the product form that is manufactured, as shown subsequently: Product form
Forgings Tubes Pipe Castings Plate
ASTM designations
A 182, A 336, and A 541 A 199, A 220, and A 213 A 335, A 369, and A 462 A 217 and A 356 A 387 and A 542
As an example, ASTM A 213 has the title “Seamless Ferritic and Austenitic Alloy Steel for Boiler, Superheater, and Heat Exchanger Tubes.” The standard actually covers 14 different grades of ferritic steels and 14 different grades of austenitic steels. The 21⁄4Cr-1Mo steel is grade T22. Because the grade is used in tubing for boilers and heat exchangers, it is also part of the specification system of ASME. The ASME adopts the ASTM code and places an “S” before it as, for example, ASME SA213 type T22. The ASTM and ASME grade (type) T22 has the following composition: Element
Content, %
Carbon Manganese Silicon Chromium Molybdenum
0.15 max 0.30–0.60 0.50 max 1.90–2.60 0.87–1.13
The microstructure of a typical ASTM A 213 grade T22 steel (ASME SA213 type T22) is shown in Fig. 1.6. It is interesting to note that if the same steel was used for a forging or plate, it may have a different microstructure because of the different specified heat treatment. Even for tubes (ASTM A 213), it can be furnished in the full-annealed, isothermal annealed, or normalized and tempered condition. Each condition would have a different microstructure.
High-Strength, Low-Alloy Steels
Fig. 1.6 Micrograph of ASME SA213-T22 boiler tube steel showing a
microstructure consisting of ferrite (light etching constituent) and a small amount of pearlite (dark etching constituent). Light tan areas are martensite. Etched in 4% picral. 200⫻
Although many of the previously mentioned AISI/SAE lowalloy steels also have high strength and, in some cases, ultrahigh strength (a yield strength above 1380 MPa, or 200 ksi), there is a rather loose class of steels called HSLA steels that do not fit the previously mentioned AISI/SAE classification. Although attempts have been made by AISI, SAE, and ASTM to classify the HSLA steels, the metallographer can easily become confused about these classifications. An attempt is made here to explain the basic classification systems. These HSLA steels are a group of low- and medium-carbon steels that generally use small amounts of alloying elements to attain yield strengths usually above about 345 MPa (50 ksi) in the hot-rolled, cold-rolled, annealed, stress-relieved, accelerated-
8 / Metallographer’s Guide cooled, direct-quenched, or normalized condition. In some cases they are called microalloyed steels because of the small amounts of vanadium, columbium (niobium), and/or titanium that are added for grain refinement and precipitation strengthening. The microstructure of a typical microalloyed steel is shown in Fig. 1.7. The ASTM Specification System. ASTM specifies most of the HSLA steels according to composition, mechanical property requirements, and application. A partial list of ASTM specifications for various HSLA steels is given subsequently (a complete list can be found in the Appendix): ASTM designation
A 242 A 572 A 588 A 656 A 714 A 715 A 808 A 871
Type of steel
HSLA structural steel HSLA columbium (niobium)-vanadium structural steel HSLA structural steel with 345 MPa (50 ksi) minimum yield point HSLA hot-rolled structural V-Al-N and titanium-aluminum steels HSLA welded and seamless steel pipe HSLA, hot-rolled sheet and strip, and sheet steel, coldrolled, high-strength, low-alloy, with improved formability HSLA with improved notch toughness HSLA steel with atmospheric corrosion resistance
Within each ASTM specification, one can find the mechanical property requirements as well as the range of chemical composition allowed. There are numerous other ASTM specifications involving low-alloy steels, depending on the particular application. The SAE Classification System for High-Strength, LowAlloy Steels. The Society of Automotive Engineers has developed
a classification for HSLA steels used in automotive applications. The steels are classified according to minimum yield strength level. The latest SAE classification system for HSLA steels consists of a three-digit code representing the minimum yield strength in ksi. Thus, a code of 080 would represent a 552 MPa (80 ksi) minimum yield strength. In the SAE system, there are usually one or more letters following the three-digit number to describe the chemical composition, carbon level, or deoxidation practice. The composition could be structural quality (S), lowalloy (L), or weathering (W). The carbon content could be low (L) or high (H). The deoxidation practice could be killed (K), killed plus inclusion control (F), or nonkilled (O). For example, SAE grade 080XLK would represent a low-alloy (X), low-carbon (L), killed, inclusion-controlled (K) steel with a minimum yield strength of 552 MPa (80 ksi). (The older SAE J410.c system would have a grade code of 980XK.)
Content, % SAE designation
050XLK 060XLK 070XLK 080XLK
Carbon
0.23 0.26 0.26 0.26
max max max max
Manganese
1.35 1.45 1.65 1.65
max max max max
Other
Cb, V Cb, V, N Cb, V, N Cb, V, N
The AISI Classification System for High-Strength, LowAlloy Steels. The AISI classification for high-strength, low-alloy steels is somewhat similiar to the SAE classification system, except that it does not have a carbon level but includes more strength levels and the dual-phase steels. The dual-phase steels, which contain about 10 to 20 vol% martensite in a matrix of ferrite, have a “D” as part of the designation. Also, dual-phase steels are different from other HSLA steels in that they are not generally classified by minimum yield strength but by minimum tensile strength in ksi. For example, an AISI code of DF090T would be a dual-phase (D) killed steel with inclusion shape control (F) and has a minimum tensile strength (T) of 620 MPa (90 ksi). A typical microstructure of a dual-phase steel is shown in Fig. 1.8. Some HSLA steels have commercial trade names. Recent designations HSLA 80 and HSLA 100 are being used for steels of a very specific steel composition with a minimum yield strength level of 552 MPa (80 ksi) and 690 MPa (100 ksi). In reality, there can be many HSLA 80 and HSLA 100 steels, depending upon composition, thermomechanical treatment, and heat treatment. Thus, there is not a standard classification system that encompasses all high-strength, low-alloy steels.
Other Low-Alloy Steels
Fig. 1.7 Micrograph of a microalloyed 450 MPa (65 ksi) yield strength linepipe steel showing a microstructure consisting of ferrite (light etching constituent), a small amount of pearlite (dark etching constituent), and martensite (gray etching constituent). Etched in 4% picral followed by 2% nital. 500⫻
There are many low-alloy steels that are not designed for just their room-temperature strength properties. These steels have additional properties that are important, such as corrosion or heat resistance and formability. Low-Alloy Steels for High-Temperature Properties. An example of a low-alloy steel that is used for its high-temperature
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons / 9 properties is ASTM A 470 turbine rotor steel. These steels are used in steam turbines for electric power generation and usually contain combinations of nickel, chromium, molybdenum, and/or vanadium. An example of the microstructure of ASTM A 470 rotor steel is shown in Fig. 1.9. Low-Alloy Steels for Improved Corrosion Resistance. There are a number of low-alloy steels that have improved corrosion resistance. These steels usually have additions of copper, nickel,
Fig. 1.8 Micrograph of AISI DF090T dual-phase steel showing a micro-
structure consisting of ferrite (light etching constituent) and a small amount of martensite (dark etching constituent). Etched in 4% picral. 500⫻
or chromium and are called weathering steels. The ASTM specifications cover several of these steels. Low-Alloy Steels with Formability. There are some steels that are designed for optimal formability in sheet-forming applications. One common steel is specified as drawing quality, special killed. This cold-rolled, low-carbon sheet steel has a specified aluminum content. The aluminum combines with nitrogen in the steel to form aluminum nitride precipitates during the annealing process. These aluminum nitride precipitates are instrumental in the development of a specific crystallographic texture in the sheet that favors deep drawing. Another type of steel used for applications requiring optimal formability is interstitial-free steel. In this very-low-carbon sheet steel, the interstitial elements, carbon and nitrogen, are combined with carbide- and nitride-forming elements, such as titanium and columbium (niobium). The steel is rendered “free” from these interstitial elements that degrade formability. Bake-Hardenable, Low-Alloy Steels. Specific sheet steels have been designed to increase strength during the paint-baking cycle of automobile production. These bake-hardenable steels contain elements that develop compounds that precipitate at the paint-baking temperatures. These precipitates harden the steel. Dual-Phase, Low-Alloy Steels. A special class of steels known as dual-phase steels are used in applications where the yield strength of the sheet is increased during the forming process itself. These steels are designed to have a microstructure consisting of about 10 to 20% martensite in a matrix of ferrite. The steels have relatively low yield strength before forming a particular component (e.g., a wheel rim) and develop strength by a process called continuous yielding. The dispersed martensite regions are required for this process. Dual-phase steels were discussed in an earlier section, and a typical microstructure is seen in Fig. 1.8. As mentioned previously, many of the low-alloy steels are classified according to composition, properties, or application. The same is true for the high-alloy steels. Some of the high-alloy steels fall under a classification system described subsequently.
High-Alloy Steels High-alloy steels generally contain more than 8% total alloying elements. These steels include the corrosion-resistant (stainless) steels, the heat-resistant steels, and the wear-resistant steels (tool steels). The stainless steels and the tool steels fall under an established classification system. First the corrosion-resistant steels are examined.
Corrosion-Resistant (Stainless) Steels
Fig. 1.9 Micrograph of ASTM A 470 rotor steel showing a microstructure consisting of tempered upper bainite. Etched in 4% picral. 500⫻
For the corrosion-resistant steels, the system established by the AISI is not based on composition, but on microstructure. Thus, the stainless steels are classified as austenitic, ferritic, austeniticferritic, martensitic, duplex, and precipitation-hardening types, as shown in the flow diagram in Fig. 1.1. Most of the steels are classified by a three-digit designation. The system is not as clearly organized as the AISI/SAE system for plain carbon steels, because the number designations overlap. For example, within the 4xx
10 / Metallographer’s Guide series, 405 and 409 designate ferritic stainless steels, while 403 and 410 designate martensitic stainless steels; within the 3xx series, 321 and 330 designate austenitic stainless steels, and 329 designates a duplex stainless steel. Therefore, the metallographer must be aware that the system for stainless steels is somewhat inconsistent. The basic classification system is discussed subsequently.
Fig. 1.10 Family relationships for standard austenitic stainless steels
Austenitic Stainless Steels. These stainless steels have a microstructure of austenite at room temperature. Thus, they are nonmagnetic. Austenitic stainless steel (such as the popular type 304) has been called 18/8 stainless steel, because it contains nominally 18% Cr and 8% Ni. There are 30 compositional variations in the standard austenitic stainless steels, and a summary of the family relationships is shown in Fig. 1.10. All the
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons / 11 austenitic stainless steels are essentially chromium-nickel alloys. The chromium varies between 15 and 24% and the nickel between 3 and 22%. The family is derived from two basic, general-purpose
Fig. 1.11 Micrograph of AISI 316 austenitic stainless steel showing a
microstructure consisting of 100% austenite. The straight-edged areas (marked by arrows) within the grains are annealing twins. Electrolytically etched in 60 parts nitric acid in 40 parts water, stainless steel cathode, at 6 V direct current. 200⫻
Fig. 1.12 Family relationships for standard ferritic stainless steels
alloys, types 302 and 202. The type 302 grade expands into 26 other types with specific compositional variations to impart particular properties, for example, better weldability, increased strength, increased heat resistance, better corrosion resistance, and improved machinability. The type 202 series is limited to only three grades and was designed to replace nickel, a rather expensive alloying element, with nitrogen and manganese. The corrosion resistance of the austenitic stainless steels is superior to other types of stainless steel. The specific composition ranges for each of the austenitic stainless steels are listed in the Appendix. The microstructure of a typical austenitic stainless steel is shown in Fig. 1.11. Ferritic Stainless Steels. The number of standard grades of ferritic stainless steel is much smaller than the austenitic grades. Fig. 1.12 shows the family relationships for the standard ferritic stainless steels. All the grades are variations on the basic, general-purpose type 430. The ferritic stainless steels are basically chromium steels with chromium ranging between 10.5 and 27%. These alloys deliberately lack high nickel contents, because nickel renders the steels austenitic (as previously mentioned). The ferritic stainless steels are the lower-cost stainless steels, because they contain less alloy, and they do not contain nickel (nickel is more expensive than chromium). The composition ranges of the ferritic stainless steels are listed in the Appendix. The microstructure of a free-machining ferritic stainless steel is shown in Fig. 1.13. Martensitic Stainless Steels. The family relationships of the martensitic stainless steels are shown in Fig. 1.14. The compositional variations all lead from the general-purpose type 410. The
12 / Metallographer’s Guide specific compositional ranges are listed in the Appendix. The martensitic stainless steels are essentially chromium steels with higher carbon content than either the ferritic or austenitic stainless steels. The chromium and carbon contents are balanced to ensure a martensitic microstructure after hardening by heat treatment. These steels are harder than the austenitic or ferritic series of stainless steel and are used for applications such as knife blades. The microstructure of a typical martensitic stainless steel is shown in Fig. 1.15. Duplex Stainless Steels. These steels have a mixed microstructure of ferrite and austenite. There is only one standard type of duplex stainless steel, grade 329, which contains 23 to 28% Cr, 2.5 to 5.0% Ni, and 1.0 to 2.0% Mo. The specific composition is listed in the Appendix. The duplex stainless steels have corrosion resistance similiar to an austenitic stainless steel but possess higher tensile and yield strengths and improved resistance to stress-corrosion cracking. The microstructure of a duplex stainless steel is shown in Fig. 1.16. Precipitation-Hardening Stainless Steels. These steels are mainly chromium-nickel steels with precipitation-hardening elements such as copper, aluminum, and titanium. They can possess either a ferritic or martensitic microstructure. In the classification, the letters “PH”, for precipitation hardening, may appear in the type code. The specific compositional variations are listed in the Appendix. The microstructure of a typical precipitation-hardening stainless steel is shown in Fig. 1.17.
Heat-Resistant Steels These alloy steels are used for elevated-temperature applications. Unfortunately, there is not a basic classification system for
these steels. This is because they include the low-alloy steels as well as the high-alloy stainless steels, tool steels, and iron-base superalloys. In other words, it depends on the elevated-temperature range and the application. At the lower temperatures, the low-alloy steels are adequate, whereas at higher temperatures, the higher-alloy steels are more appropriate. There are four AISI designated steels for elevated-temperature service. They are classified by a three-digit number beginning with “6”. These steels are 601, 602, 603, and 610 and are all medium-carbon, low-alloy steels containing chromium, molybdenum, and vanadium. Many of the heat-resistant steels are considered pressure vessel steels and are covered under the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code. These steels usually contain chromium and molybdenum (sometimes vanadium). The popular 2 1⁄4 Cr-1 Mo steel comes under this family of steels (discussed earlier in this Chapter). Under ASME specifications, the grade codes begin with the letters “SA”, and thus, a 21⁄4Cr-1Mo steel could have a code number SA-387 Gr22. The ASME grade code incorporates the ASTM grade code A 387 grade 22, which is the ASTM specification for 21⁄4Cr-1Mo steel for pressure vessels. Thus, in most cases the ASME grade codes are linked to the ASTM grade codes. A list of ASME compositions can be found in the Appendix. Many of the ferritic, austenitic, martensitic, and precipitation-hardened stainless steels are also used at elevated temperatures. In addition, many variants exist with proprietary names, such as Nitronic 60, Carpenter 18-18 Plus, Lapelloy, Greek Ascoloy, and so on. A list of compositions of the high-alloy, heat-resistant steels can be found in the Appendix. There are also several iron-base superalloys, including Discaloy, Haynes 556, Incoloy 800, and Pyromet CTX-1. A list of the compositions of the iron-base superalloys is also found in the Appendix. The microstructure of a typical iron-base superalloy (heat-resistant steel) is shown in Fig. 1.18.
Wear-Resistant Steels Tool Steels. By far the largest class of wear-resistant steels is the tool steels. There is an AISI classification system for the tool steels that has been in existence for many years. The AISI twoand three-digit codes begin with a letter representing the class of tool steel. The general classes are as follows: Letter
W A O S M T H D L P
Fig. 1.13 Micrograph of AISI 430F free-machining ferritic stainless steel
showing a microstructure consisting of ferrite and globular manganese sulfides (gray constituent). Etched in three parts glycerol, two parts HCl, and one part HNO3. 750⫻
Type of steel
Water-hardening tool steels Air-hardening, medium-alloy, cold-work steels Oil-hardening, cold-work steels Shock-resisting steels Molybdenum high-speed steels Tungsten high-speed steels Chromium high-speed steels High-carbon, high-chromium, cold-work steels Low-alloy, special-purpose tool steels Low-carbon mold steels
Most all of the tool steels contain molybdenum and/or tungsten. Other alloying elements, such as vanadium, cobalt, nickel, and chromium, are also added for certain characteristics. The microstructure of a typical tool steel is shown in Fig. 1.19. A complete list of the composition ranges of the tool steels can be found in the Appendix.
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons / 13 Austenitic Manganese Steels . Another type of wear-resistant steel is the series of austenitic manganese steels. These steels are basically varients of Hadfield manganese steel invented in 1882 by the Englishman Sir Robert Hadfield. These steels contain between 11 and 14% Mn and between 0.7 and 1.45% C. The alloys are austenitic at room temperature and possess a unique combination of toughness and ductility coupled with high workhardening capacity and good wear resistance. Hadfield manganese steels are widely used in applications requiring abrasion resistance, for example, ore crushers. They are classified by ASTM as grade A 128. A list of the compositional variations can be found in the Appendix. The microstructure of a typical Hadfield steel is shown in Fig. 1.20.
Special-Purpose Alloy Steels There are a number of special-purpose steels that do not fit in any of the previous categories. These steels include the magnetic
Fig. 1.14 Family relationships for standard martensitic stainless steels
steels, the ultrahigh-strength steels, the electrical steels, and so on. In this Chapter, some of these special-purpose steels are discussed briefly. Ultrahigh-Strength (Maraging) Steels. The maraging steels (mar-aging represents martensitic aging) can be classified as ultrahigh-strength steels. These steels develop their high strength (above 1380 MPa, or 200 ksi, yield strength) through a precipitation reaction that occurs by an aging-type heat treatment. The steels have a martensitic microstructure. The more common maraging steels contain 18% Ni, 8.5 to 10% Co, 3.3 to 5% Mo, 0.2 to 1.6% Ti, and 0.1 to 0.3% Al. Because of the high cost of cobalt, there are a number of low-cobalt and cobalt-free alloys. The composition of a number of maraging steels can be found in the Appendix. The microstructure of a typical maraging steel is shown in Fig. 1.21. Magnetic Steels. A popular permanent (hard) magnetic steel is Alnico V, which contains 20% Co, 14% Ni, 8% Al, and 3% Cu. There are a number of high-permeability steels, such as Permal-
14 / Metallographer’s Guide loy, which contains 45% Ni, and Permendur, which contains 50% Co. All these steels have very high alloy contents. Nonmagnetic Steels. The austenitic stainless steels and Hadfield manganese steels described previously are nonmagnetic. However, there are specific steels designed to have very low magnetic permeability. These steels usually contain 14 to 30% Mn. These steels can also be used for cryogenic (low-temperature)
applications. The compositions of these steels are listed in the Appendix. Low-Thermal-Expansion Steels. Some steels are designed to have a very low coefficient of thermal expansion. One such alloy is Invar, which contains 36% Ni. Super Invar contains 31% Ni and 4 to 6% Co and has a coefficient of thermal expansion near zero. Another low-expansion alloy, Kovar, with 29% Ni and 17% Co,
Fig. 1.15 Micrograph of AISI 410 martensitic stainless steel showing a
Fig. 1.16 Micrograph of a duplex stainless steel (7Mo Plus) showing a
microstructure consisting of 100% martensite. Etched in Kalling’s No. 1 reagent. 500⫻
Fig. 1.17 Micrograph of a precipitation-hardening stainless steel (Custom
630) showing a microstructure consisting of martensite. Etched in Fry’s reagent. 320⫻
microstructure consisting of ferrite and austenite. The ferrite is the continuous matrix constituent. Electrolytically etched in 10% oxalic acid at 5 V. 200⫻
Fig. 1.18 Micrograph of an iron-base superalloy A286 showing a micro-
structure consisting of austenite. The straight-edged regions are annealing twins. Etched in a solution of 100 ml water, 20 ml HCl, 1 g NH4F HF, and 0.5 g K2S2O5. 200⫻
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons / 15 matches the coefficient of thermal expansion of glass and is used for glass-to-metal seals. The microstructure of a typical lowexpansion steel is shown in Fig. 1.22. High-Thermal-Expansion Steels. The maximum possible coefficient of thermal expansion for a steel is obtained in a steel called Hi-Span-Hi, which contains 29% Ni, 8.5% Cr, 2.4% Ti, 0.4% Mn, 0.4% Si, and 0.4% Al. High-expansion alloys are used
in bimetallic strips for thermally activated switches and thermostats. Electrical Steels. There are very-low-carbon steels that are used for transformer cores and electric motor laminations. All these steels contain silicon (sometimes they contain aluminum). The transformer steels contain 3.25 to 4% Si (some contain 4.5 to 5% Si), and the motor lamination steels contain 0.5 to 1.0% Si
Fig. 1.19 Micrograph of AISI M-2 high-speed tool steel showing a micro-
Fig. 1.20 Micrograph of ASTM A 128 austenitic manganese steel (Had-
structure consisting of tempered martensite and carbides (white etching constituent). Etched in 12% sodium metabisulfite solution. 500⫻
Fig. 1.21 Micrograph of a maraging steel showing a microstructure consisting of martensite. Etched in Kalling No. 1. 200⫻
field steel) casting showing a microstructure consisting of austenite. Etched in 2% nital (5 s) followed by removal of the stain in aqueous 3% EDTA and etching in 20% sodium metabisulfite solution. 64⫻
Fig. 1.22 Micrograph of a low-expansion steel (Invar) showing a micro-
structure consisting of austenite. The straight-edged regions (arrows) are annealing twins. Etched in 4% picral. 200⫻
16 / Metallographer’s Guide (sometimes they also contain aluminum). Carbon is not necessary in these steels and, in fact, is considered detrimental. The microstructure of a typical motor lamination steel is shown in Fig. 1.23. Electrical-Resistance Steels. Some steels with high electrical resistance are used for heating elements in household stoves and industrial ovens and furnaces. One such steel is Kanthal, which contains 25% Cr, 5% Al, and 3% Co. Ohmax is another steel with high resistance and is used for electrical resistors. It contains 20% Cr, 5 to 8.8% Al, and 0 to 5% Co.
refers to the flake graphite that is present. The microstructure of a typical gray iron is shown in Fig. 1.24. Common unalloyed gray cast iron has the following broad range of chemical composition:
Cast Irons The cast irons generally contain more than 2% C and a variety of other alloying elements. They are classified by a rather simple, somewhat archaic system. They are classified by the appearance of their fracture surface, their microstructure, or their properties. Historically, there were two different cast irons: the cast iron that has a gray fracture appearance and the cast iron that has a white fracture appearance. Thus, the names gray iron and white iron evolved. Those irons that have a mixed gray and white appearance are called mottled iron. These names still apply today. Other cast irons appeared over the years and have names associated with a mechanical property, such as malleable iron and ductile iron. More recently, compacted graphite iron and austempered ductile iron have been introduced. This section examines each of these cast irons.
The gray irons have a high silicon content, because silicon (a graphitizer) promotes the formation of graphite during solidification. Gray iron has almost no ductility because of the presence of the graphite flakes. However, it is inexpensive and can be cast into complex shapes. The microstructure of gray iron results from a rather slow cooling rate in the casting process. ASTM has classified the type, distribution, and size of graphite in gray iron according to specification A 247. The flake graphite patterns have been subdivided into five types, as shown in Fig. 1.25. Each type imparts a different characteristic to the properties of the gray iron. For example, type A is preferred for most applications, because it is superior in certain wear applications. An important application is in cylinders of internal combustion engines. ASTM has also classified gray iron by a number of specifications that require certain compositional ranges and mechanical properties. A partial list follows:
Gray Iron
ASTM designation
By far the most common of all cast irons is gray iron. This iron has a gray fracture appearance, because it contains a high volume fraction of graphite flakes (the graphite flakes have a gray appearance). Gray iron is sometimes identified as “FG,” which
Fig. 1.23 Micrograph of a motor lamination steel showing a microstructure consisting of ferrite. Etched in 2% nital. 200⫻
A 48 A 126 A 159 A 278
Element
Content, %
Carbon Silicon Manganese Phosphorus Sulfur
2.5–4.0 1.0–3.0 0.2–1.0 0.002–1.0 0.02–0.25
Type of iron
Gray iron castings Gray iron castings for valves, flanges, and pipe fittings Automotive gray iron castings Gray iron castings for pressure-containing parts for temperatures up to 650 °F
Fig. 1.24 Micrograph of a gray cast iron showing a microstructure con-
sisting of pearlite (gray etching constituent), ferrite (light etching constituent), and graphite flakes (dark constituent). Etched in 4% picral. 100⫻
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons / 17 ASTM A 48 is the general specification for gray cast iron and classifies grades of gray iron according to minimum tensile strength in ksi, as follows: ASTM A 48 class
Minimum tensile strength MPa ksi
Class Class Class Class Class Class Class Class Class
138 172 207 241 276 310 345 379 414
20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
There are no compositional requirements specified in ASTM A 48. The SAE has also classified gray iron for automotive applications by specification SAE J431. There are five grades of gray cast iron included in SAE J431, as follows: SAE J431 grade
Minimum tensile strength MPa ksi
Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade
125 172 207 241 276
G1800 G2500 G3000 G3500 G4000
18 25 30 35 40
As one can see, the grade number is linked to the minimum tensile strength in ksi, as it is in ASTM A 48, but each SAE grade has other requirements. For example, the composition and property requirements for SAE grade G1800 are as follows: Element
Content, %
Carbon (TC) (a) Manganese Silicon Phosphorus Sulfur
3.40–3.70 0.50–0.80 2.80–2.30 0.15 max 0.15 max
(a) Carbon is expressed as total carbon (TC).
Property
Hardness, HB Bend Properties Minimum transverse load, kg (lb) Minimum deflection, mm (in.) Minimum tensile strength, MPa (ksi)
Required value
187 max 780 (1720) 3.6 (0.14) 124 (18)
According to SAE J431, grade G1800 is used for soft iron castings (as-cast or annealed) in which strength is not a primary factor. The other higher-strength grades are used in specific automotive applications. The compositional ranges for the previously mentioned grades can be found in the Appendix.
White Iron If a gray iron is solidified rapidly, white iron results. Graphite flakes are not present in white iron. Instead of graphite flakes, an iron carbide network forms that gives the white appearance on the fracture surface. The microstructure of a typical white iron is shown in Fig. 1.26. The composition range of elements in unalloyed white iron are: Element
Carbon Silicon Manganese Phosphorus Sulfur
Content, %
1.8–3.6 0.5–1.9 0.25–0.8 0.06–0.2 0.06–0.2
The silicon content is lower in white iron to minimize its graphitizing effect. White irons are extremely hard and abrasion resistant. To enhance their abrasion resistance, they are usually alloyed with nickel, chromium, and/or molybdenum. ASTM specification A 532 covers the abrasion-resistant white cast irons. There are ten different white cast irons, according to ASTM A532. These are listed subsequently:
Designation
Class I Type A Type B Type C Type D Class II Type A Type B Type C Type D Type E Class III, type A
Type of white cast iron
Ni-Cr high-carbon Ni-Cr low-carbon Ni-Cr GB (grinding balls) Nickel high-chromium 12% Cr 15% Cr-Mo low-carbon 15% Cr-Mo high-carbon 20% Cr-Mo low-carbon 20% Cr-Mo high-carbon 25% Cr
Fig. 1.25 Types of graphite flakes in gray iron (American Foundryman’s Society-ASTM). In the recommended practice (ASTM A 247), these charts are shown at a magnification of 100⫻. They have been reduced to one-third size for reproduction here.
18 / Metallographer’s Guide Mottled Iron. This type of cast iron is not intentionally produced. It results from a transition between gray and white iron in a casting and is not necessarily a desirable material. The microstructure of a mottled iron is shown in Fig. 1.27.
Malleable Iron Malleable iron is produced by heat treating white iron to break down or decompose the iron carbide into a temper carbon (a form of graphite). Malleable iron is sometimes referred to as TG iron because of the temper graphite present. Usually, white iron is heated to 800 to 970 °C (1470 to 1780 °F) for long periods of time, on the order of 20 h. During this time, irregularly shaped nodules of graphite form. Because of the absence of the hard and brittle carbide constituent, the iron becomes malleable. The microstructure of a typical malleable iron is shown in Fig. 1.28. The typical compositional limits of malleable iron are (wt%): Element
Content, %
Carbon (TC) (a) Manganese Silicon Sulfur Phosphorus
2.2–2.9 0.2–0.6 0.9–1.9 0.02–0.2 0.02–0.2
(a) Carbon is expressed as total carbon, TC.
ASTM has a number of specifications for malleable iron, depending on the microstructure and application. A partial list is given subsequently: ASTM designation
Fig. 1.26 Micrograph of a white cast iron showing a microstructure
consisting of pearlite (gray etching constituent), cementite (light etching constituent), and ledeburite (regions of rounded clusters). Etched in 4% picral. 250⫻
Fig. 1.27 Micrograph of a mottled cast iron showing a microstructure
consisting of pearlite (dark gray etching constituent), cementite (light etching constituent), ledeburite (clusters of small, rounded pearlite particles), and graphite flakes (dark constituent). Etched in 4% picral. 250⫻
A 47 A 197 A 220 A 338 A 602
Type of malleable iron
Ferritic malleable iron castings Cupola malleable iron Pearlitic malleable iron castings Malleable iron fittings and valve parts for railroad, marine, and other heavy-duty service at temperatures up to 345 °C (650 °F) Automotive malleable iron castings
Fig. 1.28 Micrograph of a malleable cast iron showing a microstructure
consisting of ferrite (light etching constituent) and temper carbon (dark gray irregular-shaped constituent). Etched in 2% nital. 200⫻
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons / 19 As an example, ASTM A 220 for pearlitic malleable iron castings has eight grades of malleable iron, depending on minimum yield strength and elongation. The class or grade code is quite unusual and incorporates the minimum yield strength and elongation levels. For example, the grades are listed subsequently:
Grade
40010 45008 45006 50005 60004 70002 80002
Yield strength (min), MPa (ksi)
276 310 310 345 414 383 552
(40) (45) (45) (50) (60) (70) (80)
Tensile strength (min), MPa (ksi)
Hardness, Brinell
Elongation (min), %
414 (60) 448 (65) 448 (65) 483 (70) 552 (80) 586 (85) 724 (105)
149–197 156–197 156–207 179–229 197–241 217–269 269–321
10 8 6 5 4 3 1
More details of the compositional ranges of the malleable irons can be found in the Appendix.
Ductile Iron Ductile iron, also known as nodular iron and spheroidal graphite cast iron, is a cast iron where the graphite is in the form of spheres or nodules. The nodules are not as irregularly shaped as in malleable iron and are formed during solidification, not by heat treatment. The code SG is sometimes used to refer to the spheroidal graphite that is present in ductile iron. ASTM has classified the types of graphite shapes found in ductile cast irons and other irons. Sketches of the ASTM A 247 classification are shown in Fig. 1.29. The ductile irons contain type I graphite (type II being imperfectly formed nodular graphite). Type III would
Fig. 1.29 Typical graphite shapes after ASTM A 247. I, spheroidal graphite; II, imperfect spheroidal graphite; III, temper graphite; IV, compacted graphite: V, crab graphite; VI, exploded graphite; VII, flake graphite
20 / Metallographer’s Guide typify a malleable iron, type IV a compacted graphite iron (described at the end of this chapter), and type VII would typify the flake graphite of a gray iron. The microstructure of a typical ferritic ductile iron is shown in Fig. 1.30. To produce ductile iron, a fairly high-purity cast iron is inoculated with 0.03 to 0.06% Mg or 0.005 to 0.20% Ce. These elements provide nuclei on which the graphite spheroids grow. Because of the shape of the graphite, this type of cast iron exhibits far greater ductility than gray iron. The chemical composition limits of ductile iron are given below (wt%): Element
Content, %
Carbon Silicon Manganese Phosphorus Sulfur
3.0–4.0 1.8–2.8 0.1–1.0 0.01–0.1 0.01–0.03
Ductile irons are classified by both ASTM and SAE according to the application and properties desired. A partial ASTM list is shown subsequently: ASTM designation
A 377 A 395 A 439 A 476 A 536 A 716
Type of ductile iron
Ductile iron pressure pipe Ferritic ductile iron pressure-retaining castings for use at elevated temperatures Austenitic ductile iron castings Ductile iron castings for paper mill dryer rolls Ductile iron castings Ductile iron culvert pipe
Fig. 1.30 Micrograph of a ferritic ductile (nodular) cast iron showing a
microstructure consisting of ferrite (light etching constituent) and graphite nodules (dark gray constituent). Etched in 2% nital. 100⫻
A look at ASTM A 536 shows that five grades are defined according to minimum tensile strength, minimum yield strength, and elongation. In fact, the grade code number incorporates all three properties, as follows:
Grade
60-40-18 60-42-10 65-45-12 70-50-05 80-55-06 80-60-03 100-70-03 120-90-02
Tensile strength (min), MPa (ksi)
415 (60) 415 (60) 448 (65) 485 (70) 555 (80) 555 (80) 689 (100) 827 (120)
Yield strength (min), MPa (ksi)
276 290 310 345 379 415 485 621
(40) (42) (45) (50) (55) (60) (70) (90)
Elongation (min), %
18 10 12 5 6 3 3 2
To attain these various properties, the matrix microstructure varies from ferritic for the lower strengths, to pearlitic for the intermediate strengths, to martensitic for the higher strengths. Further details on the composition of ductile irons can be found in the Appendix. Austempered Ductile Iron. This is essentially a subclass of ductile iron. Austempered ductile irons have the same spherical or nodular graphite as a normal ductile iron, but the matrix is a combination of bainite (acicular ferrite and carbides) and stabilized austenite. The microstructure of a typical austempered ductile iron is shown in Fig. 1.31. The microstructure is obtained by a special heat treatment called austempering. The heat treatment involves austenitizing, followed by a quench and an isothermal hold at a specific temperature (usually obtained by quenching
Fig. 1.31 Micrograph of an austempered ductile cast iron showing a
microstructure consisting of bainite (acicular constituent) and graphite nodules (dark gray constituent). Etched in 2% nital. 500⫻
Introduction to Steels and Cast Irons / 21 into a molten salt bath). ASTM has recently established a specification, A 895, for austempered ductile iron. The specification consists of five grades that incorporate the minimum tensile strength, minimum yield strength, and elongation (similar to the system discussed previously for ductile iron). ASTM A 895 has the following property requirements:
Grade
125-80-10 150-100-7 175-125-4 200-155-1 230-185
Tensile strength (min), MPa (ksi)
Yield strength (min), MPa (ksi)
Elongation (min), %
Hardness, HB
Impact energy, J (ft · lbf)
862 (125) 1034 (150) 1207 (175) 1379 (200) 1586 (230)
552 (80) 690 (100) 862 (125) 1069 (155) 1276 (185)
10 10 4 1 ...
269–321 302–363 341–444 388–477 444–555
102 (75) 81 (60) 61 (45) 34 (25) ...
Note the much higher strength levels attained in austempered ductile iron compared with all the other irons described previously. Applications for austempered ductile iron include gears, automotive crankshafts and universal joints, and other parts requiring wear resistance, and high fatigue and impact strength.
Compacted Graphite Iron
Compacted graphite appears as short, thick flakes similar to type IV shown in Figure 1.29. The iron is also referred to as CG iron because of the presence of compacted graphite. The shape of the graphite is controlled by the addition of minor alloying elements, such as magnesium, titanium, calcium, cerium, and/or aluminum. The basic compositional range of standard elements is as follows (wt%): Content, %
Carbon Silicon Manganese Phosphorus Sulfur
2.4–4.0 1.0–3.0 0.2–1.0 0.01–0.10 0.01–0.03
The basic range of composition is similiar to ductile iron, described previously. Currently, there are no ASTM or SAE specifications for compacted graphite cast irons. One of the largest applications for compacted graphite cast iron is in the manufacture of ingot molds, where the mold life can be extended by 20 to 70% over the life of molds made from normal gray cast iron. SELECTED REFERENCES •
Compacted graphite cast iron has a graphite shape somewhere between the flake graphite found in gray cast iron and the nodular graphite found in ductile iron. Thus, the properties of compacted graphite cast irons are in-between those of gray and ductile iron.
Element
•
J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM Specialty Handbook: Cast Irons, ASM International, 1996 ASM Handbook, Properties and Selection: Irons, Steels, and High-Performance Alloys, Vol 1, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1990
Metallographer's Guide: Practices and Procedures for Irons and Steels Bruce L. Bramfitt, Arlan O. Benscoter, p23-48 DOI:10.1361/mgpp2002p023
Copyright © 2002 ASM International® All rights reserved. www.asminternational.org
CHAPTER 2
Origin of Microstructure EVERY METALLOGRAPHER should know and understand how the various microstructures in steels and cast irons originate. This is because a key part of a metallographer’s job is to interpret what he or she sees under the microscope and to make sound judgments and recommendations based on these observations. A metallograhper is not just an “iron polisher,” as perceived by many people outside the profession. An effective metallographer needs to have a basic understanding of the fundamentals of ferrous physical metallurgy. The basic tenet of ferrous physical metallurgy is that the properties of steels and cast irons are controlled by both microstructure and chemical composition. It is the metallographer’s job to determine and characterize the microstructure, and it is the chemist’s job to determine the composition. This chapter discusses, in an introductory way, some of the basic ferrous physical metallurgy principles that are needed by the metallographer. The discussion focuses on the numerous microstructures that are generated as a result of the phase transformations that occur during both heat treatment (as in steels) and solidification (as in cast irons). The next chapter shows how numerous factors can influence microstructural development and how one can alter microstructure to attain desired properties.
Fig. 2.1(a) Various microstructures formed in an AISI/SAE 1080 steel. A fully pearlitic microstructure. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
As an example of microstructural diversity, Fig. 2.1 shows four different microstructures, all derived from the same steel by increasing the cooling rate, in an American Iron and Steel Institute/Society of Automotive Engineers (AISI/SAE) 1080 steel (a plain carbon steel containing 0.79% C, 0.90% Mn, and 0.25% Si). The microstructure shown in Fig. 2.1(a) is pearlite (a constituent consisting of the two phases, ferrite and cementite. A constituent is a phase or a combination of phases that occurs in a characteristic configuration in a microstructure. A phase is a homogenous and distinct portion of a material system.) The microstructure shown in Fig. 2.1(b) is bainite (a constituent also consisting of the two phases, ferrite and cementite, but with a totally different morphology). The microstructure shown in Fig. 2.1(c) is martensite (a constituent consisting of ferrite supersaturated with carbon). The microstructure shown in Fig. 2.1(d) is a mixture of pearlite, bainite, and martensite. Detailed discussion on each of these constituents can be found in later sections in this chapter. In the next section, it becomes clear as to how the microstructures in Fig. 2.1 originated.
Fig. 2.1(b) A fully bainitic microstructure. 4% picral etch. 1000⫻
24 / Metallographer’s Guide
Fig. 2.1(c) A fully martensitic microstructure. Sodium metabisulfite etch.
phase diagram and the time-temperature-transformation (TTT) diagram, more commonly called the isothermal transformation (IT) diagram. Early 20th century metallurgists, such as Floris Osmond, John Edward Stead, Albert Sauveur, and Henry Marion Howe, established the basic principles of transformation behavior in iron and steel. Early 20th century classic works, such as Metallography and Heat Treatment of Iron and Steel by Sauveur in 1912 (Ref 1), The Microscopic Analysis of Metals by Osmond and Stead in 1913 (Ref 2), and The Metallography of Steel and Cast Iron by Howe in 1916 (Ref 3), were replete with micrographs of microstructures of various irons and steels processed under a wide variety of heat treatment conditions. Also, an understanding of the iron-carbon phase diagram was fairly well developed, as evidenced by the diagrams published in each of the previously mentioned books. In the early 1930s, Edgar Bain and his colleagues developed the concept of the IT diagram that extended our understanding into the realm of the kinetics of phase transformations (Ref 4). The iron-carbon phase diagram and the IT diagram brought the metallography of iron and steel into perspective. From these simple diagrams, one was able to more fully understand the origin of a microstructure observed in the microscope.
1000⫻
The Iron-Carbon Phase Diagram
Fig. 2.1(d) A microstructure consisting of pearlite (dark), bainite (gray), and martensite (white). 4% picral and 2% nitral etch. 500⫻
Microstructural Development Resulting from Heat Treatment Considerable progress has been made in the past several decades to understand ferrous phase transformations. The basis for this understanding came with the evolution of the field of metallography, which led to the development of the iron-carbon
The iron-carbon phase diagram, coupled with the understanding of the kinetics of phase transformations through the IT diagram, were the breakthroughs necessary for the advancement of ferrous physical metallurgy. The phase diagram of today is much the same as that published early in this century. In taking a close look at the iron-carbon phase diagram shown in Fig. 2.2, it can be seen that the diagram is essentially a map of the phases that are stable (or metastable) at a given temperature and carbon content. The diagram represents equilibrium or quasi-equilibrium conditions, which are rarely completely achieved in industrial processes. Before discussing the diagram, we must first understand what a microstructure consists of in steel. Examples of microstructures are given in Fig. 2.1. The term “microstructure” relates to the overall structure, as usually observed in a microscope, which generally consists of one or more discrete phases. These phases are the building blocks of the various constituents that make up the microstructures, and each phase, singly or in combination with other phases, imparts certain properties to steel, for example, hardness, strength, toughness, and ductility, or certain characteristics, such as machinability and formability. This chapter examines the origin of those phases that are commonly observed in the microscope. There are basically only three phases normally present in steels: ferrite, austenite, and cementite (graphite is also a phase found in cast irons and is discussed in the last section of this chapter). A phase, in this case, can only exist according to the iron-carbon phase diagram. Several important features of the iron-carbon phase diagram are discussed here. First, there are two sets of
Origin of Microstructure / 25 phase boundaries superimposed in Fig. 2.2. One set represents the iron-cementite (Fe3C) phase diagram (solid lines), and the other set represents the iron-graphite phase diagram (dashed lines). The reason that there are two sets of phase boundaries is that the stable (equilibrium) phase for carbon in the iron-carbon system is graphite, whereas cementite is a metastable phase. A metastable phase can transform to a stable phase, given enough time. For example, cementite (Fe3C) can decompose with time (generally, very long periods of time) into iron and graphite (carbon). However, for all practical purposes, cementite remains a “stable” phase in steels. The iron carbide (cementite) phase diagram ranges from 0 to 6.7% C, the carbon content of iron-cementite. The iron-graphite phase diagram ranges from 0 to100% C (the diagram in Fig. 2.2 does not extend up to 100% C, because there are no important phases, other than graphite, to consider beyond 6.7% C). When discussing steels, the iron-cementite phase diagram is applicable, and for cast irons both diagrams are applicable. As a very general
rule, steels contain less than about 2% C, and cast irons contain more than 2% C. Although both steels and cast irons at some stage of their history undergo the process of solidification, a discussion of the influence of solidification on microstructure is reserved until the end of the chapter. Most steel products are subsequently hot worked and/or heat treated to alter the cast microstructure and to improve the properties of the steel. On the other hand, cast irons are most often used commercially in the as-cast condition. The various regions or fields in which the phases are stable are shown in Fig. 2.2. For example, the fields for the three basic phases in steel, austenite, cementite, and ferrite, can be located on the iron-cementite phase diagram. Austenite exists over a large phase field extending to just above 2% C and within the temperature range above 727 °C (1340 °F) and below 1495 °C (2713 °F). Cementite exists as a single composition at 6.7% C. Cementite exists up to 1227 °C (2240 °F), which is its melting temperature. The term “ferrite” appears twice on the ironcementite diagram: as delta ferrite at high temperatures of 1394 to
Fig. 2.2 The iron-carbon phase diagram. Solid lines indicate Fe-Fe3C diagram; dashed lines indicate iron-graphite diagram. Source: Ref 5
26 / Metallographer’s Guide 1538 °C (2340 to 2800 °F) and as alpha ferrite at temperatures below 912 °C (1675 °F). In this Chapter, when we mention ferrite in a steel microstructure, we are referring only to the lower-temperature form (if we need to discuss the higher-temperature form, we will call it delta ferrite). As shown in Fig. 2.2, ferrite appears as essentially pure iron. However, as seen in the expanded version of the iron-carbon phase diagram in Fig. 2.3, ferrite can contain up to about 0.02% C. Thus, ferrite can contain only a minor amount of carbon in contrast to austenite, which can contain up to 2.1% C (i.e., up to 100 times more carbon than ferrite). Historically, some of the phase boundaries shown in Fig. 2.3 are labeled as A1, A3, and Acm (the “A” from the French word arret, meaning arrest). If one is cooling a steel, the boundaries become Ar1, Ar3, and Arcm (the “r” from the French word refroidissement, meaning cooling), and if one is heating, the boundaries become Ac1, Ac3, and Accm (the “c” from the French word chauffage, meaning heating). Often, an “e” is used to represent equilibrium, as Ae1, Ae3, and Aecm. Also, in Fig. 2.3 there is a very important point on the diagram at 0.77% C and 727 °C (1340 °F). This point is called the eutectoid point. (The eutectoid point is the composition of a solid phase that undergoes transformation into two or more other solid phases upon cooling.) There is another point at 4.3% C and 1148 °C (2100 °F) on the iron-carbon diagram (see
Fig. 2.3 Portion of the iron-carbon diagram
Fig. 2.2). This latter point represents a eutectic point. (The eutectic point is the composition of a liquid phase that undergoes transformation into two or more solid phases upon cooling.) These transformations are important in steels and cast irons and are described in detail later in this chapter. In Fig. 2.3, steels with carbon contents less than 0.77% are called hypoeutectoid steels, and above 0.77% C, hypereutectoid steels (the prefix hypo means under, and the prefix hyper means over). It must be kept in mind that the iron-carbon phase diagram in Fig. 2.3 represents only iron-carbon binary alloys and does not apply to iron-carbon alloys containing other elements, such as manganese, silicon, nickel, chromium, molybdenum, vanadium, and so on. Any of these elements, if added to an iron-carbon alloy, would expand or contract the phase fields shown in Fig. 2.3. Thus, a ternary or quaternary phase diagram is needed for alloy systems with a total of three or four alloying elements, respectively. Nevertheless, for all practical purposes, the iron-cementite diagram can be used as a basic guide to the origin of microstructure in steels. However, a time scale is not associated with the phase diagram, because the data used to construct the diagram was established at near-equilibrium conditions (extremely slow heating/cooling rates). Departure from near-equilibrium conditions, for example, heating a piece of steel to 1000 °C (1832 °F) and quenching in water, requires an understanding of transformation
Origin of Microstructure / 27 kinetics, which is discussed in a later section on describing the concept of the IT diagram. But first, we must understand the basic phase diagram as it applies to the heat treatment of steel. For pure iron, one must follow the very left side of the diagram in Fig. 2.3. At a temperature above 912 °C (1675 °F), the stable phase of iron is gamma iron, which is a face-centered cubic (FCC) form of iron. Below 912 °C (1675 °F), alpha iron is the stable phase and has a body-centered cubic (BCC) crystal structure. In transforming from gamma to alpha iron or vice versa, the iron has passed through an allotropic change, that is, a change in crystal structure. It is important to understand this allotropic change, because it is an important part of the foundation for phase transformations in steel. The characteristics or properties of gamma iron and alpha iron are very different. The face-centered crystal structure imparts different properties than a body-centered crystal structure. A simplified sketch of the basic FCC unit cell is shown in Fig. 2.4. One can think of it as a cube with an iron atom at each corner and one at the center of each face of the cube. The body-centered unit cell is shown in Fig. 2.5. Here, iron atoms are also at the cube corners, as in the FCC structure, but in the body-centered structure, an iron atom occupies a position at the center of the cube. Of course, a crystal of iron consists of many millions of cells aligned in an orderly array in three dimensions. These crystals are the grains that one observes in the microscope. An important aspect of the allotropic change in iron is the accompanying change in volume. For example, in transforming from gamma iron to alpha iron, upon cooling there is an expansion, and upon transforming back (heating), there is a contraction. This volume change can be detected by sensitive
instruments. In fact, the dilatometer, an instrument found in most steel-related research laboratories, is based on measuring the volume changes that take place during a phase transformation. If we now look at an iron-carbon alloy, we find that the situation is different from pure iron. In an iron-carbon alloy, the FCC phase is called austenite, and the BCC phase is called ferrite (alpha ferrite). The term “austenite” is named after Sir William Chandler Roberts-Austen, an early English metallurgist, and the term “ferrite” is derived from the Latin word ferrum, for iron. The spaces between the iron atoms in the BCC and FCC lattices are called interstitial sites. Carbon atoms have a much smaller atomic diameter than iron and can fit into some of these sites. Thus, carbon is called an interstitial element (another important interstitial element is nitrogen). When an element occupies sites in the iron lattice, the result is called a solid solution. With interstitial elements, the alloy is an interstitial solid solution. When an atom substitutes for an iron atom in the FCC or BCC lattice, a substitutional solid solution forms. Substitutional elements, such as nickel, chromium, and manganese, have atomic diameters similar to iron. Interstitial and substitutional solid solutions form the basis for the design of steels with particular properties and characteristics. To illustrate the phase transformations in an iron-carbon alloy, the cooling paths shown in Fig. 2.3 can be followed. As an example, an AISI/SAE 1040 steel is used. An AISI/SAE 1040 steel contains nominally 0.4% C and some manganese and silicon, but for the moment we will treat this steel as a binary iron-carbon alloy. As one cools this steel very slowly, that is, at equilibrium, from the austenite phase field, for example, starting at 1000 °C (1832 °F), it remains single-phase austenite until 785 °C (1445 °F), the Ar3, at which point the austenite begins to transform to ferrite. Between 785 and 727 °C (1445 and 1340 °F), the Ar1, austenite continues to transform to ferrite. At 727 °C (1340 °F), the remaining austenite transforms through the eutectoid reaction. The ferrite that forms above 727 °C (1340 °F) is called proeutectoid ferrite (the prefix pro meaning before the eutectoid transformation). The eutectoid transformation in this case results in austenite transforming into two separate phases: ferrite and cementite. Thus: Austenite ↔ Ferrite ⫹ Cementite
Fig. 2.4 Face-centered cubic crystal structure (unit cell)
Fig. 2.5 Body-centered cubic crystal structure (unit cell)
Pearlite is the name given to the two-phase constituent of ferrite and cementite that results during slow cooling from this reaction. In fact, many steels and cast irons contain pearlite in their microstructure. An iron-carbon alloy containing 0.77% C is a pure eutectoid alloy; that is, it transforms to 100% pearlite. An example of a microstructure consisting of 100% pearlite is shown in Fig. 2.1(a). This microstructure was produced by very slow cooling of a eutectoid steel. Under very slow heating/cooling conditions, the iron-carbon phase diagram can be used to determine the resulting microstructure. In commercial steels, a fully pearlitic structure is sometimes desirable, as in rail steel and piano wire, because of the hardness, wear resistance (rail), and high strength (piano wire) imparted. Steels with a carbon content under 0.77%, processed to approach equilibrium conditions (slow cooling, etc.), would have ferrite and pearlite microstructures.
28 / Metallographer’s Guide In the 0.4% C steel (an AISI/SAE 1040 steel) described previously, only the austenite remaining at 727 °C (1340 °F) transforms to pearlite. The proeutectoid ferrite that already formed above 727 °C (1340 °F) remains essentially unchanged through this eutectoid transformation. As mentioned earlier, steels to the left of the eutectoid point (carbon content less than 0.77%) are called hypoeutectoid steels, and those above 0.77% C are called hypereutectoid steels. The hypoeutectoid steel described previously would have a microstructure similar to that shown in Fig. 2.6. This steel has a microstructure consisting of about 50% ferrite (white-appearing constituent) and 50% pearlite (dark-appearing constituent). Next, the transformation of a hypereutectoid steel cooling from the austenite phase field at 1000 °C (1832 °F) to room temperature is discussed. As an example, a representative hypereutectoid binary iron-carbon alloy would be iron Fe-1.4% C. From Fig. 2.3, upon cooling from 1000 to 960 °C (1832 to 1760 °F), the microstructure remains 100% austenite. At 960 °C (1760 °F), the Arcm, proeutectoid cementite begins to form. At the eutectoid temperature of 727 °C (1340 °F), the remaining austenite transforms to pearlite through the eutectoid reaction. The microstructure for this hypereutectoid alloy is shown in Fig. 2.7. Here, one can see a pearlite matrix (dark etching constituent) with proeutectoid cementite (the white etching network at the prior austenite grain boundaries). There are also some plates of cementite that grew within the austenite grains during transformation. This is an undesirable structure, because the hard cementite phase at the grain boundaries imparts brittleness to the steel. There are, however, some very useful hypereutectoid low-alloy steels. As is shown in the next chapter, one can attain very desirable properties in hypereutectoid steels when a spheroidized structure is developed by heat treatment. Spheroidization means that the form of
the carbide phase has been changed to small spherical particles uniformly distributed in a continuous matrix of soft ferrite. The next chapter illustrates that microstructural manipulation of this nature is vital to developing commercially useful steels and cast irons. Metallographers must not only understand the origin of microstructures, but must also understand how the microstructure can be altered to a more desirable form.
Fig. 2.6 A hypoeutectoid AISI/SAE 1040 steel showing a ferrite (white
Fig. 2.7 A hypereutectoid Fe-1.4% C binary alloy showing proeutectoid
etching constituent) and pearlite (dark etching constituent) microstructure. 4% picral and 2% nital etch. 800⫻
Kinetics of Phase Transformations It has been shown that the iron-carbon phase diagram is a plot of temperature and composition (carbon content). The transformations that were discussed previously took place at equilibrium conditions. However, in commercial practice, equilibrium is rarely approached. For example, some steels are heated to the austenite phase field and quenched in water to attain certain desired properties. Under these conditions, cooling takes place over a short period of time, and one can no longer use the iron-carbon phase diagram to predict transformation temperatures or the constituents that may form. In fact, as is shown later, in the previously mentioned AISI/SAE 1040 steel, a constituent (martensite) can form that does not contain cementite, as would be predicted by the phase diagram. To predict the effects of nearequilibrium cooling, we need to know something about the kinetics of the transformations concerned, that is, the rate at which they occur at different temperatures. Bain and his colleagues at the research laboratory of the United States Steel Corporation conducted pioneering work on this topic in the 1930s and showed that the transformation kinetics could most easily be summarized in a TTT diagram, also called an IT diagram.
cementite (and cementite needles) at the prior austenite grain boundaries in a matrix of pearlite. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
Origin of Microstructure / 29 An IT diagram for AISI/SAE 1080 steel is shown in Fig. 2.8. The IT diagram has a C-curve shape that is characteristic of the transformation behavior of most ferrous constituents. (Actually the C-curve is an envelope of C-curves, one for each constituent. See Chapter 2 in Ref 8 for further discussion.) The region marked “A” represents austenite, whereas “F” represents ferrite, and “C” represents cementite. The equilibrium eutectoid temperature of 727 °C (1340 °F) is shown as Ae1 on the diagram. Austenite is stable above this temperature. The austenite that exists below the Ae1 is subcritical austenite and is unstable. The left-hand curve represents the time required for the transformation to start at a particular temperature, and the right-hand curve represents the time required for it to finish the transformation. For example, if the steel is held at 400 °C (752 °F), the unstable austenite will start to transform to ferrite and cementite in about three seconds and complete the transformation in about 100 seconds. The tip of the C-curve at the left of the diagram is called the “nose” and represents the temperature at which transformation of austenite to a ferrite and cementite mixture is most rapid. To construct an IT diagram such as that in Fig. 2.8, one heats very thin steel samples to the austenite phase field above the Ae1 and then quickly transfers the specimens into a salt (or lead) pot held at a constant temperature below the Ae1. Thin samples must be used in order to minimize surface-to-center temperature gradients. When quenched in water to room temperature without holding in a salt pot, the specimen transforms to martensite (named after the early German metallographer Adolph Martens). For example, Fig. 2.9 shows a schematic of the cooling path required to form martensite.
Martensite forms in the steel as soon as the specimen is cooled below 210 °C (410 °F), which is shown on the IT diagram in Fig. 2.8 as Ms (martensite start temperature). One-hundred percent martensite has formed when the specimen has been cooled below 100 °C (212 °F), the Mf (martensite finish temperature). Figure 2.1(c) (representing an AISI/SAE 1080 steel) shows the fully martensitic microstructure resulting from this treatment. To determine the rest of the diagram, specimens are held at constant temperatures for a measured amount of time to allow the phase transformation to progress, and then the specimens are quickly quenched in cold water to arrest the progress of the transformation. This process is repeated for several hold times. As specimens are held for several consecutive times, one can follow the progression of transformation and determine the start and finish times at each temperature. An example is shown in Fig. 2.10, where six thin specimens are heated in a furnace at 900 °C (1650 °F) for reaustenitization and then rapidly transferred within a half-second into a salt pot and held at an isothermal temperature of 650 °C (1200 °F). The hold times are 2, 5, 10, 20, 50, and 200 seconds (see arrows). At a hold time of two seconds and water quench, the resulting microstructure would be martensite, because the pearlite transformation does not begin until about five seconds have lapsed. The fully pearlitic microstructure shown in Fig. 2.1(a) would represent the samples transformed at 50 and 200 seconds. Specimens held for 10 and 20 seconds would be pearlite and martensite mixtures, as seen in Fig. 2.1(d). The same process is repeated for other temperatures to complete the IT diagram, for example, six specimens held at 300 °C (572 °F) and then individually removed from the salt pot and quenched
Fig. 2.8 An isothermal transformation diagram for AISI/SAE 1080 steel. A, austenite; F, ferrite; C, cementite; Ms, martensite start temperature
30 / Metallographer’s Guide
Fig. 2.9 An isothermal transformation diagram for AISI/SAE 1080 steel showing cooling path to obtain a fully martensitic microstructure
Fig. 2.10 An isothermal transformation diagram for an AISI/SAE 1080 steel showing cooling path and isothermal treatment at 650 °C (1200 °F)
Origin of Microstructure / 31 into cold water after 10, 100, 200, 500, 1000, and 5000 seconds. Figure 2.11 shows a schematic of the isothermal treatment. Upon metallographic examination of each specimen, we find that after ten seconds, no transformation has taken place at 300 °C (572 °F), but after 100 seconds, a small amount of transformation has begun (the transformation actually starts in about 60 seconds). Metallographic examination of the specimen held for 100 seconds reveals that the transformed component of the microstructure has a different form than pearlite, described previously. It is called bainite (named after Edgar C. Bain). After 500 seconds, the transformation is over 50% complete, and after 1000 seconds, all the austenite has transformed to bainite. A microstructure of fully transformed bainite is shown in Fig. 2.1(b), which represents this AISI/SAE 1080 steel. Thus, from these simple experiments, Bain and his colleagues were able to show that departures from equilibrium can result in transformation products that do not appear on the iron-carbon phase diagram. The IT diagram is actually an oversimplification of the transformation behavior and kinetics of each of the different constituents illustrated previously. (For more detailed information on the link between transformation kinetics and IT diagrams, consult Ref 8 and 9.) Although Bain established the basic understanding of kinetics of ferrous phase transformations by transformations at constant temperature, practical heat treatments are carried out by heating and cooling at various rates. The same concepts developed by Bain can be used to develop continuous cooling transformation (CT) diagrams. These diagrams are constructed by cooling specimens at different rates from the austenite phase field. These rates may simulate air cooling, oil quenching, water quenching, and so on. A CT dia-
gram for an AISI/SAE 1080 steel is shown in Fig. 2.12. It looks somewhat similar to the IT diagram shown in Fig. 2.8 and can, in fact, be related approximately to it. The CT diagram is constructed by cooling specimens at different cooling rates and, by some means, measuring the start and finish of transformation. Metallographic analysis is used to determine the type and amount of each microstructural constituent that has formed. The C-shaped curves connecting the data points in Fig. 2.12 indicate the start and finish temperatures for each constituent, for example, Ps and Pf represent the pearlite start and finish temperatures. For example, in Fig. 2.12, a cooling rate of 750 °C/min (1350 °F/min) resulted in the microstructure of pearlite, bainite, and martensite, shown in Fig. 2.1(d). The cooling curve for this specimen is highlighted in bold on the CT diagram. Upon cooling at this rate, the first constituent that forms is pearlite (the dark etching constituent in Fig. 2.1d), which begins at the pearlite start temperature (Ps). Upon further cooling, bainite (the gray etching constituent) begins to form at the Bs temperature. The bainite in this case (Fig. 2.1d) has nucleated upon the pearlite nodules. The bainite transformation is completed at the Bf temperature. Upon further cooling, the martensite transformation (the light etching constituent) begins at the Ms temperature.
The Microstructural Constituents in Steel In the previous section, the discussion was centered on how a constituent can form, but did not describe the morphological features of the constituents. Examples of some of these features are shown subsequently.
Fig. 2.11 An isothermal transformation diagram for an AISI/SAE 1080 steel showing cooling path and isothermal treatment at 300 °C (572 °F)
32 / Metallographer’s Guide
Fig. 2.12 A continuous cooling transformation diagram of an AISI/SAE 1080 steel. Eight cooling rates are shown, with data points representing transformation temperatures.
Ferrite. One of the most common phases in steel is ferrite. The term was derived from the Latin word ferrum, meaning iron. A micrograph of low-carbon steel with a fully ferritic microstructure is shown in Fig. 2.13. This structure in the micrograph consists of hundreds of individual ferrite grains separated by grain boundaries, shown as the dark borders of each grain. Each of these grains is a single crystal of ferrite. A grain or crystal of ferrite has a BCC crystal structure. A grain boundary separates a ferrite grain of one crystal lattice orientation from a ferrite grain of another
Fig. 2.13 Microstructure of ferrite in a 0.02% C steel. Marshall’s etch. 500⫻
orientation. The microstructure shown in Fig. 2.13 is typical of a very-low-carbon steel. The microstructure or morphology is equiaxed, meaning that the grain dimensions are approximately equal in all directions (equal axes). It is also called polygonal ferrite, which implies that ferrite forms as an array of polygons. Ferrite can have many other morphological forms. Ferrite exists as a phase in the constituents pearlite and bainite, which is discussed later. A form of ferrite other than its polygonal form is acicular ferrite, sometimes referred to as Widmanstätten ferrite. The term “Widmanstätten” was named after Aloys Joseph Franz Xavier Beck von Widmanstätten, a 19th century Austrian museum curator, who observed and studied microstructures found in polished and etched meteorites. The morphology of Widmanstätten ferrite is shown as the light etching constituent in Fig. 2.14. It appears needlelike in the two-dimensional plane of polish, but in three dimensions, the morphology is lath or platelike. The steel in Fig. 2.14 is AISI/SAE 1025 (the dark etching constituent is pearlite). In steels, ferrite usually forms at prior austenite grain boundaries during cooling from the austenite phase field. The grainboundary form of ferrite is called proeutectoid ferrite and occurs in hypoeutectoid steels. Figure 2.15 shows proeutectoid ferrite (the white etching network phase) in a plain carbon AISI/SAE 1060 steel. The dark etching matrix is pearlite. There are different morphologies of grain-boundary ferrite, with the two most common being a blocky, somewhat equiaxed form and an acicular, or needlelike, form somewhat similar to Widmanstätten ferrite. The blocky form is shown previously in Fig. 2.15, and the acicular grain-boundary form is shown in Fig. 2.16. In this microstructure, the needle-like white etching phase is ferrite, and the gray etching matrix is martensite. The acicular ferrite (shown with arrow) has grown from the prior austenite grain boundaries.
Origin of Microstructure / 33 Cementite is iron carbide, that is, a compound of iron and carbon, Fe3C. The name cementite comes from cementation steel, which was an early process used to produce high-carbon steel through carburization, by which carbon is absorbed into the steel by packing it in charcoal and heating to a high temperature. In steels, cementite is never present as 100% of a microstructure. It can be present as a precipitate in ferrite; as a grain-boundary constituent at the junctures of ferrite grains in low-carbon steels; as a continuous grain-boundary phase (proeutectoid cementite) in high-carbon, hypereutectoid steels; as spherical particles in a
Fig. 2.14 A form of ferrite called Widmanstätten ferrite in a coarse-grained AISI/SAE 1025 steel. 4% picral etch. 100⫻
Fig. 2.16 Acicular form of ferrite nucleated at prior austenite grain
boundaries in an AISI/SAE 1060 steel. Matrix is martensite. 2% nital etch. 500⫻
spheroidized steel; or associated with ferrite as a constituent of pearlite, bainite, and tempered martensite. Figure 2.17 shows a micrograph of cementite as a grain-boundary phase in a lowcarbon steel. The cementite generally forms at the junctures of ferrite grains. The matrix is ferrite. In the previous example (using picral as an etchant), the cementite etches as a light gray phase. Figure 2.18 shows proeutectoid cementite or grain-boundary cementite (light grayappearing grain-boundary phase) in a hypereutectoid steel. The matrix is pearlite.
Fig. 2.15 Proeutectoid ferrite (white etching network) at the prior austen-
ite grain boundaries in an oil-quenched AISI/SAE 1060 steel. Dark etching constituent is pearlite. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
Fig. 2.17 Cementite (arrows) at ferrite grain boundaries in a batchannealed 0.04% C sheet steel. Marshall’s etch. 500⫻
34 / Metallographer’s Guide Cementite is a hard and brittle compound. Some steels and cast irons depend on the presence of cementite to impart wear resistance, for example, in steels for railroad rails and ball bearings and in alloy cast irons for rolls. A number of steels are designed to contain a minimal amount of cementite, for example, very-low-carbon automotive sheet steels. These latter steels need ductility and formability, and the presence of cementite tends to degrade these properties. Pearlite is a constituent that contains both ferrite and cementite. According to the iron-carbon equilibrium diagram, the carbon content of pearlite is 0.77%. Pearlite forms through the eutectoid reaction, as described earlier. Figure 2.19 shows a micrograph of pearlite. After etching with 4% picral, the cementite appears as a light gray phase, and the ferrite is white. This is because of the surface relief developed by the chemical etching process. As is explained in Chapter 5, surface relief influences the amount of light that is reflected away from the objective of a metallurgical microscope. The more light that is reflected away, the darker the image. Pearlite generally has a distinctive lamellar or alternating platelike morphology. The alternating plates of cementite and ferrite are shown more clearly in the higher-magnification view in Fig. 2.20 (this photo was taken on a scanning electron microscope). By volume, pearlite consists of about 13% cementite and 87% ferrite. The lamellar structure of pearlite arises from the side-by-side growth (or coupled growth) of the two phases during transformation from austenite. The pearlite transformation depends on diffusion of carbon in the austenite (or movement of carbon in the iron lattice) during the eutectoid reaction. Thus, pearlite forms through a diffusional process. A region of pearlite having a single growth orientation (i.e., with all the lamella aligned in the same general direction) is called
a pearlite colony. Many pearlite colonies can be seen in Fig. 2.19, which illustrates a microstructure consisting of coarse pearlite. Many more colonies appear in Fig. 2.21, which illustrates a microstructure consisting of very fine pearlite. “Fine” and “coarse” usually refer to the spacing between the lamella. The spacing is called the interlamellar spacing. During transformation, many colonies nucleate and grow within a single prior austenite grain, and because each colony has a different crystallographic orientation, they reflect light at different angles in the microscope, giving rise to the variation in appear-
Fig. 2.19 Coarse pearlite in an AISI/SAE 1080 eutectoid steel. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
Fig. 2.18 Proeutectoid cementite (white etching phase) at the prior aus-
tenite grain boundaries in an Fe-1.4% C binary alloy. Matrix is pearlite. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
Fig. 2.20 Scanning electron microscope (SEM) micrograph of pearlite. 5000⫻
Origin of Microstructure / 35 ance shown in Fig. 2.21. Usually, pearlite nucleates and grows as a nodule (spherical shape) originating at a prior austenite grain boundary or the juncture of prior austenite grain boundaries. A pearlite nodule contains many pearlite colonies. Looking closely at Fig. 2.21, many pearlite nodules can be seen. The nodular pattern can be more easily seen in Fig. 2.22, where the nodules are still isolated from one another. This micrograph was obtained from an AISI/SAE 1060 steel that was interrupted in its cooling process while transforming to pearlite by quenching quickly to
Fig. 2.21 Fine pearlite colonies in an AISI/SAE 1080 steel. 4% picral etch.
room temperature. This means that initially, at a fairly slow cooling rate, austenite was transforming to pearlite, as evidenced by the pearlite nodules. Upon quenching, the remaining austenite transformed to martensite (light etching matrix), leaving the nodules at their point of interrupted growth. In a steel having a fully pearlitic microstructure, as in Fig. 2.21, it is difficult to distinguish the individual nodules. Pearlite is most often seen in plain carbon steels as a constituent associated with ferrite, as seen in the hypoeutectoid AISI/SAE 1040 steel in Fig. 2.23, which shows a typical microstructure of ferrite (light etching regions) and pearlite (dark etching regions). Steels with fully pearlitic microstructures, as shown in Fig. 2.21, are used for applications requiring wear resistance. A fully pearlitic AISI/SAE 1080 steel (eutectoid steel) takes advantage of the strength and hardness of pearlite. However, pearlitic steels lack toughness and formability. Music wire is also made from a fully pearlitic steel. Pearlite, because of its lamellar structure consisting of soft ferrite and hard cementite, when drawn into fine wire, develops a very high tensile strength. Music wire is the strongest metal commonly available. Although pearlitic structures can be useful in a limited number of applications, many modern steels are designed to minimize the amount of pearlite in the microstructure, because it tends to degrade toughness. Martensite is a constituent that forms during rapid cooling (quenching) of steel. It is different from the pearlitic transformation in that the martensitic transformation does not depend on diffusion of carbon in the austenite and is thus a diffusionless transformation. The interstitial carbon atoms in solid solution in the parent austenite before transformation are “trapped” in the martensite lattice. Carbon steels with a fully martensitic structure are generally hard and have very little ductility in the as-quenched condition.
500⫻
Fig. 2.22 Pearlite nodules in a partially transformed water-quenched AISI/SAE 1060 steel. Matrix is martensite. 4% picral etch. 250⫻
Fig. 2.23 Pearlite (dark) associated with ferrite (light) in an air-cooled AISI/SAE 1040 steel. 4% picral and 2% nital etch. 800⫻
36 / Metallographer’s Guide In the light microscope it is usually difficult to resolve the fine microstructural details of martensite. Because of the fine microstructure, martensite is studied using an electron microscope. In carbon steels, there are two types of martensite: lath martensite and plate martensite. An example of lath martensite in an Fe-0.2% C alloy is shown in Fig. 2.24. Note that in the micrograph of lath martensite the laths have grown in different orientations. Each orientation has a different etching response and reflects light at different angles in the microscope, thus giving the different shades of gray. All the laths with a single orientation comprise what is called a “packet.” In the micrograph in Fig. 2.24, the packet size is very coarse (a packet is outlined by arrows). A lath would be one of the subunits within the packet. An example of lath martensite in an as-quenched commercial alloy steel is shown in Fig. 2.25. This microstructure represents a more typical fine packet size. An example of plate martensite is shown in Fig. 2.26. This microstructure represents a commercial water-quenched AISI/ SAE 1095 steel and has a small martensitic plate size. Lath martensite forms in lower-carbon steels (under 0.6% C), and plate martensite forms in higher-carbon steels (above 1.0% C). Mixed lath and plate martensite can form between 0.6% and 1.0% C. Other than their lath and plate morphologies, plate martensite differs from lath martensite by its unique midrib within each plate, as seen in Fig. 2.27. Not all martensitic steels contain carbon. In fact, the SAE 410 martensitic stainless steel shown in Fig. 2.28 is almost carbonfree. Many of the carbon-free martensites have some degree of ductility when compared with carbon-bearing martensites. In iron-carbon alloys, the crystal structure of martensite is body-centered tetragonal (BCT), with a unit cell configured as shown in Fig. 2.29. Basically, the unit cell is a distorted BCC cell. In steels containing carbon, the lattice distortion is due to carbon
atoms that occupy certain positions (in the interstices between the larger iron atoms, as shown in Fig. 2.29). Because of their location, they stretch the cell in one direction. In martensitic iron-carbon alloys, the carbon is trapped during transformation, leaving the lattice supersaturated with carbon. This is different from a steel that is slow-cooled, such as in the case where ferrite
Fig. 2.25 Lath martensite in an as-quenched commercial ASTM A 514
steel (0.13% C, 0.62% Mn, 0.29% Si, 0.5% Mo, 0.054% Al, 0.036% Ti, and 0.0019 %B). 2% nital etch. 500⫻
Fig. 2.26 Plate martensite in an AISI/SAE 1095 steel (0.97% C, 1.05% Mn,
Fig. 2.24 Lath martensite in an Fe-0.2% C binary alloy. A packet of laths is outlined with arrows. 2% nital etch. 500⫻
0.25% Si, and 0.20% Cr). Unetched areas are retained austenite. Sodium metabisulfite etch. 1000⫻. Courtesy of S. Lawrence, Bethlehem Steel Corporation
Origin of Microstructure / 37 forms. Ferrite, having the normal BCC lattice, cannot contain much carbon in solid solution (less than 0.002% C at room temperature). This means that during slow cooling, the carbon diffuses into the remaining austenite, eventually forming iron carbide (cementite) along with the ferrite. If martensite is heated or tempered, the trapped carbon will precipitate and eventually form iron carbide. The microstructure of a steel with a fully tempered martensitic structure is shown in Fig. 2.30. In the tempered martensite shown previously, the acicular appearance of the martensite is still evident. The small black particles in the microstructure are cementite. Essentially, the
lattice has changed from the BCT crystal structure to the BCC crystal structure during tempering, because the carbon atoms are removed from the lattice, thus relieving its distortion. The tempering process restores ductility to a martensitic steel, but with a sacrifice in strength. The effect of tempering is discussed in detail in the next chapter. Because as-quenched martensite has
Fig. 2.27 Plate martensite showing the characteristic midrib morphology
Fig. 2.29 Body-centered tetragonal crystal structure of martensite in iron-
Fig. 2.28 Martensite in a SAE 410 stainless steel. Vilella’s etch. 500⫻.
Fig. 2.30 A fully tempered martensite in a 0.2% C, 5% Ni, and 1% Mn
(arrow) in an Fe-1.86% C binary alloy. 2% nital etch. 1000⫻
Courtesy of K. Luer, Lehigh University
carbon alloys
steel. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
38 / Metallographer’s Guide very little ductility, it is almost exclusively found commercially in the tempered condition. One application of an untempered martensitic steel is in razor blades. In this case, the martensite imparts high strength and hardness, which allows the blade to maintain a sharp cutting edge. Bainite. When some steels are cooled at intermediate cooling rates, for example, between water quenching and air cooling, a constituent known as bainite can form. During etching in 4% picral, bainite appears in the light microscope as a dark etching, acicular constituent, as seen in Fig. 2.31. It is dark etching because it contains a dispersion of small carbide particles that provide surface relief from preferential attack by the etchant when observed in the microscope. As is seen later in this chapter, bainite appears so similar to tempered martensite that they can only be distinguished by observation in the electron microscope. There is also some untempered martensite in the micrograph in Fig. 2.31. In this sample, the untempered martensite etched much lighter than the bainite, because it does not contain carbides and hence, has a different etching response. The formation of bainite, like pearlite, involves diffusion of carbon in the austenite during transformation. Another bainitic microstructure representing a different steel than the steel in the previous micrograph is shown in Fig. 2.32. Note that the microstructure is somewhat similar to martensite (see Fig. 2.24) in that they both have an acicular morphology. However, if one could resolve the structure in the light microscope (usually an electron microscope is required), substantial differences would be found. This is because the slower cooling rates during the bainite transformation allow carbide precipitaton, as opposed to no diffusion during the martensitic transformation where the carbon atoms remain dissolved in the lattice. Thus, bainite has the normal BCC lattice of ferrite. Bainite
also differs from pearlite in that it does not form the lamellar morphology characteristic of pearlite. One form of bainite (called lower bainite) does, however, have a microstructure very similar to tempered martensite. In fact, in the light microscope, lower bainite is indistinguishable from tempered martensite. However, at higher magnifications in the transmission electron microscope (TEM), distinctions can generally be made, because the carbides in tempered martensite usually precipitate in a multivariant Widmanstätten-like pattern. In bainite, the carbides do not generally have this pattern and form at discrete locations at a single variant or specific angle (between 55° and 65°) to the major axis of the acicular ferrite. The discrete morphology of the carbides also distinguishes between what is called upper and lower bainite. The terms upper and lower bainite were first applied to the microstructures that develop during IT. The terms are also applied to bainite that transforms during normal continuous cooling. Upper bainite is the term attributed to bainite formed between 400 and 550 °C (752 and 1022 °F) and that contains carbides aligned along the ferrite lath boundaries. Figure 2.33 represents upper bainite produced by IT of a commercial low-alloy AISI/SAE 8720 steel at 425 °C (797 °F). Lower bainite, on the other hand, forms between 250 and 400 °C (482 and 752 °F) and contains carbides within the acicular ferrite laths (or plates) and not at the boundaries. Figure 2.34 represents lower bainite in an AISI/SAE 8720 steel that has transformed isothermally at 325 °C (617 °F). In most real-world processes, steel does not usually transform isothermally but transforms over a range of temperature (i.e., oil quenching, air cooling, etc.). However, the basic morphologies described previously are still found as a result of continuous cooling. Unfortunately, the structures that develop during continuous cooling are not as easily classified as those that form during
Fig. 2.31 Bainitic microstructure (dark etching constituent) in a 0.3% C,
Fig. 2.32 Bainitic microstructure in a low-carbon alloy steel (0.3% C,
0.8% Mn, 0.26% Si, 1.05% Cr, 1.07% Mo, and 0.25% V steel. The lighter etching constituent is martensite. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
0.62% Mn, 0.2% Si, 2.73% Ni, 0.23% Cr, and 0.5% Mo). 4% picral ⫹ HCl etch. 500⫻
Origin of Microstructure / 39 IT. The microstructures that develop during continuous cooling often consist of mixed upper and lower bainite, and many times, retained austenite is found instead of carbides at the acicular ferrite boundaries (Ref 10). Another form of bainite is so-called “granular” bainite, which consists of acicular ferrite and discrete islands or regions of retained austenite and/or martensite (sometimes called the M-A constituent). The term originated from a description of its granular appearance in the light microscope. An example of this form of
Fig. 2.33 Upper bainite in an AISI/SAE 8720 steel isothermally trans-
bainite is shown in Fig. 2.35. Generally, this form of bainite is found in alloy steels (e.g., Ni-Cr-Mo steels) that have been cooled at slow-to-intermediate cooling rates. Because of the higher alloy content in these steels, the pools of austenite can be stable at room temperature or partially stable with some portion of the austenite transformed to martensite. Because of the mixed and rather complicated bainitic microstructures that develop during continuous cooling, Bain’s experiments focused only on constant temperature transformation in order to develop uncomplicated microstructures. Work is currently underway to sort out the microstructures that have been termed bainite in continuously cooled steels (Ref 10). Bainitic steels are important because of their high strength and good toughness balance. Commercially, bainitic steels are used for nuclear reactor components, pressure vessels, large steam turbine rotors, and numerous other applications. Austenite. Although not commonly seen in plain carbon steels at room temperature (as evidenced in the iron-carbon phase diagram), austenite is the parent phase of ferrite, cementite, pearlite, bainite, and martensite. Austenite has a FCC crystal structure, as represented in Fig. 2.4. In most steels, austenite is a high-temperature phase and generally exists only above about 700 °C (about 1300 °F). However, some steels, for example, the austenitic stainless steels (e.g., AISI 304 and AISI 316 stainless steels), are 100% austenite at room temperature. Figure 2.36 shows a micrograph of austenite found in an AISI 316 austenitic stainless steel. In some plain carbon steels and many alloy steels, some austenite can be retained at room temperature, if the steel is quenched (usually in water or iced brine) from the austenite phase field. In some alloy steels and cast irons, if there is a sufficient carbon and alloy content in the austenite, it is stable at room
Fig. 2.34 Lower bainite in an AISI/SAE 8720 steel isothermally trans-
Fig. 2.35 Granular bainite in a 0.2% C, 0.3% Mn, 3% Ni, 1.5% Cr, and
formed at 425 ºC (797 ºF) for 90 s. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
formed at 325 ºC (617 ºF) for 100 s. 4% picral etch. 800⫻
0.4% Mo steel. 4% picral etch. 800⫻
40 / Metallographer’s Guide temperature. When examined in the microscope, retained austenite usually appears as a white etching constituent, because it has a different etching response than most other constituents. In many cases, retained austenite is not desirable in a steel. This means that the steel must be further heat treated (tempered) or cooled to very low temperatures to transform the retained austenite. In some steels, retained austenite is desirable, because it may impart an added degree of ductility to the steel. The following micrographs show retained austenite in a variety of steels. In Fig. 2.37, retained austenite (white) is seen between plate martensite (dark, needlelike constituent) in a high-carbon, low-alloy steel. Islands of retained austenite as well as islands of martensite can exist in a matrix of ferrite in a dual-phase steel (a steel used in some limited automotive applications). Generally, a dual-phase steel is produced by cooling from the two-phase, austenite plus ferrite region. Some of the austenite transforms to martensite upon cooling, while some of the austenite is retained. The term “dual-phase steel” was coined to describe a type of steel that contains both ferrite and martensite (however, in reality it is a tri-phase steel, with both martensite and austenite, the M-A constituent, existing as regions within the ferrite matrix). In this type of steel, the retained austenite is desirable, because it promotes enhanced ductility. Figure 2.38 shows an example of a dual-phase steel. The small, white, rounded regions (arrows) are retained austenite, and the dark regions are martensite. The matrix is ferrite. Figure 2.39 shows about 15% retained austenite (small, white, rounded areas indicated by an arrow) in a matrix of martensite. In all these cases, the austenite phase, because of its higher carbon content and/or higher alloy content, is stable at room temperature. However, it is sometimes possible to transform the
Fig. 2.36 Austenite grains in an AISI/SAE 316 austenitic stainless steel. Straight-edged regions are annealing twins. 4% picral and HCl
etch. 500⫻
retained austenite to martensite by cooling the steel well below room temperature, for example, in liquid nitrogen. This subcooling process is actually carried out in industry, for example, large-diameter, quench-hardened steel rolls are cooled in liquid nitrogen to transform retained austenite to martensite. However, many other applications do not require such extreme hardness in a steel, and tempering can be performed. To transform the retained
Fig. 2.37 Retained austenite (white etching phase) in a water-quenched
0.93% C-1.45% Mn steel. Gray etching phase is plate martensite. 2% nital etch. 1000⫻
Fig. 2.38 A dual-phase sheet steel (0.11% C, 1.4% Mn, 0.58% Si, 0.12%
Cr, and 0.08% Mo) showing small regions of retained austenite (see arrows indicating white areas) and martensite (dark etching constituent) in a matrix of ferrite. 12% aqueous sodium metabisulfite etch. 1000⫻
Origin of Microstructure / 41
Fig. 2.39 Retained austenite (arrow indicating small, rounded, white
areas) in a 0.16% C, 1.8% Mn, 0.7% Ni, 0.75% Cu, 2% Cr, and 0.3% Mo steel. Dark matrix is martensite. Etched in a solution of 10 g sodium thiosulfate and 3g potassium metabisulfite in 100 cm3 of water (Beraha’s etch). 1000⫻
Fig. 2.40 A drawing of a dendrite
austenite, for example, the steel is heated to 600 °C (1112 °F) for several hours and cooled to room temperature.
Microstructural Development Resulting from Solidification In the previous sections of this chapter, microstructural development focused on steels experiencing a cooling process, that is, the steel was reaustenitized and cooled to room temperature. Most steels used commercially are heat treated to obtain a desired microstructure for specified mechanical properties. However, all commercial steels undergo a solidification process (the transformation from the liquid state to the solid state) during the initial stage of their manufacture. The solidified, or as-cast, microstructure is generally destroyed through mechanical deformation (hot deformation) and subsequent heat treatment. In all the microstructures shown in the previous sections of this chapter, the as-cast microstructure is no longer evident. The main reason for the elimination of the as-cast microstructure is that it imparts three undesirable attributes: (a) directionality of properties because of the alignment of the dendrites (crystals with a “treelike” branching pattern); (b) coarse microstructures; and (c) micro- and macrosegregation of the elements contained in the steel (carbon, manganese, sulfur, phosphorus, etc.). First, we must look at the dendritic structure of steel. A dendrite is shown schematically in Fig. 2.40. The main “trunk” of the dendrite is called the primary arm, and the other branches or arms are secondary and tertiary arms.
Fig. 2.41 As-cast microstructure of an AISI/SAE 1060 steel. Pearlitic matrix
with ferrite in the prior austenite grain boundaries. 4% picral
etch. 32⫻
Figure 2.41 shows a representative as-cast microstructure of AISI/SAE 1060 steel. The microstructure consists mainly of pearlite (dark etching constituent) and some ferrite (light etching constituent). Note that the overall microstructure has a directionality and that ferrite has formed a network around the pearlite. The ferrite has actually nucleated and grown on prior austenite grain boundaries that formed at the last stage of solidification as dendritic boundaries (the boundaries formed by the impingement
42 / Metallographer’s Guide of two or more dendrites). It is interesting to note that a dendritic pattern is not obvious in this microstructure. This is partly because the microstructure is a result of transformations that took place upon cooling in the solid state after solidification. If one takes the same piece of as-cast steel and reaustenitizes and cools it slowly to room temperature, the microstructure in Fig. 2.42 results. Here, we can see that the carbon has been redistributed and has concentrated into the regions between the secondary dendrite branches or arms to form pearlite. This condition is an example of microsegregation and is generally undesired in steels. A consequence of microsegregation is banding, which is shown in an AISI/SAE 1524 steel in Fig. 2.43. Banding occurs upon hot rolling of carbon steels that usually contain high manganese levels. Banding can be minimized by homogenizing heat treatments, which allow enough time to redistribute the manganese by diffusion. Although most steels are not used in their as-cast condition, cast irons are almost exclusively used in their solidified and undeformed state (possibly with some subsequent heat treatment to optimize the microstructure). The following section describes the microstructural development of these commercially important materials. Various forms of cast iron have been used for over 2000 years for household utensils, stoves, water pipe, cannons, farm implements, and so on. As a class of metals, cast irons are generally inexpensive and are fairly common, because they have lower melting temperatures than most steels and are thus easy to melt and cast. There are a number of different types of cast iron that are widely used today for numerous applications. They are generally classified according to their microstructure, for example, gray iron, for its gray fracture appearance due to the presence of graphite flakes in the microstructure; white iron, for its white
Fig. 2.42 Annealed condition showing dendritic structure of the as-cast AISI/SAE 1020 steel shown in Fig. 2.41. 4% picral etch. 32⫻
fracture appearance due to the presence of cementite (iron carbide and no graphite); and ductile iron or nodular iron, for the presence of graphite in the form of nodules instead of flakes. Each of these types of cast iron is discussed later in the chapter. In order to understand the origin of the numerous, fairly complex microstructures that form in cast irons, we need to first understand the phase transformations that take place during both solidification and subsequent cooling to room temperature.
Phase Transformations in Cast Irons To understand the phase transformations in the various cast irons, we must examine the iron-carbon phase diagram. Actually, because most cast irons contain either graphite (pure carbon) or iron carbide (cementite), we must understand the iron-carbon phase diagram with respect to carbon in the form of either graphite or cementite. The phase diagram shown earlier in Fig. 2.2 can be roughly divided into two parts: cast irons for carbon levels above 2% and steels for carbon levels below 2%. Thus, for all the cast irons, the eutectic portion of the phase diagram must be considered. The Iron-Graphite and Iron-Cementite Phase Diagrams. As shown previously, Fig. 2.2 represents the iron-carbon phase diagram, with phase boundaries for both iron-graphite and ironcementite. The iron-cementite phase boundaries are indicated as solid lines, and the iron-graphite phase boundaries are indicated as dashed lines. For steels, the iron-cementite phase boundaries are more applicable, but for cast irons, both sets of phase boundaries are applicable. For example, to describe the transformations that take place in gray and nodular cast iron, the iron-graphite phase diagram is appropriate, and for transformations that take place in white iron, the iron-cementite phase diagram is appropriate. It
Fig. 2.43 An AISI/SAE 1524 steel showing the condition of banding. Dark
bands are pearlite, and light bands are ferrite. 4% picral etch.
200⫻
Origin of Microstructure / 43
At this carbon content, we are dealing with a hypoeutectic cast iron. We follow a cooling path from solidification to room temperature, using the appropriate phase diagram. The iron-cementite phase diagram is shown in Fig. 2.44. Tracing the solidification path in Fig. 2.44 (or Fig. 2.2) for a binary Fe-3% C alloy, one can see that solidification begins with the formation of primary austenite at 1300 °C (2372 °F). This is the point where the liquidus temperature is crossed upon cooling. The liquidus is the temperature where the solid phase begins to form upon cooling. Cooling from 1300 to 1148 °C (2372 to 2100 °F), the austenite continues to grow generally in the form of dendrites. At 1148 °C (2100 °F), the eutectic temperature, the remaining liquid transforms through the eutectic reaction to a mixture of austenite and cementite as:
pearlitic areas are portions of the austenite dendrites (that transformed to pearlite upon cooling to room temperature). One can also estimate that at a point just below 1148 °C (2100 °F), the total microstructure will consist of about 20% cementite and 80% austenite. However, in continued cooling from 1184 to 727 °C (2100 to 1340 °F), the proportions of austenite and cementite in the total microstructure will change to 38% cementite and 62% austenite. The additional 18% cementite grew at the expense of both the primary austenite dendrites and the austenite in the ledeburite and appears as a continuous rim of cementite surrounding each austenite region. The rim around the primary austenite dendrites can be seen (see arrows) in Fig. 2.46 (a rim can also be seen in Fig. 2.45). Upon cooling to room temperature, the primary austenite and the austenite contained in the eutectic constituent must transform. Depending on the cooling rate and alloy content, the austenite could transform to either pearlite, bainite, or martensite. The resulting cast iron would be white iron free of graphite. Figure 2.45 represents a white cast iron where the austenite has transformed to pearlite. The iron-graphite phase diagram is shown in Fig. 2.47. For an Fe-3% C alloy, the solidification begins the same as previously mentioned, with the formation of primary austenite crystals between 1300 and 1154 °C (2372 and 2110 °F). However, according to Fig. 2.47 (or Fig. 2.2), at the eutectic temperature of 1154 °C (2110 °F), the eutectic reaction would be:
Liquid ↔ Austenite ⫹ Cementite
Liquid ↔ Graphite ⫹ Austenite
This eutectic constituent, called ledeburite (named after Karl Heinrich Ledebur, a noted 19th century German professor of metallurgy), should contain about 48% cementite and 52% austenite by volume. The morphology of ledeburite can be seen in the central region of Fig. 2.45 as the cluster of small, rounded particles. The white etching continuous phase in the ledeburite shown in Fig. 2.45 is cementite, and the darker etching phase is pearlite (transformed from the eutectic austenite phase). The large
The eutectic of graphite and austenite does not have a name, as in the case of ledeburite. In continued cooling from 1154 to 738 °C (2110 to 1360 °F), the graphite would grow at the expense of the surrounding austenite.
must be kept in mind that while using these binary diagrams, commercial cast irons usually contain over 1% Mn and/or Si, and these and other elements will shift the phase boundaries. In this section, we take a closer look at these phase diagrams, especially the hypoeutectic side (carbon content less than eutectic composition) of each diagram, because the vast majority of cast irons contain less than 4.3% C.
Transformations in a 3% C Cast Iron
Fig. 2.45 The eutectic constituent ledeburite (center of photo with small,
Fig. 2.44 The iron-cementite phase diagram
elongated and rounded particles) in a pearlitic white cast iron (3.21% C, 0.32% Mn, and 0.47% Si). White-appearing area is cementite. 4% picral etch. 500⫻.
44 / Metallographer’s Guide Just below the eutectic temperature of 1154 °C (2110 °F), about 2% graphite and 98% austenite would be present in the microstructure. However, at room temperature, up to 4% graphite and 96% transformed austenite would be present. Figure 2.48 represents the solidified microstructure resulting from the previous eutectic reaction. In Fig. 2.48, the austenite transformed to pearlite, while the graphite remained stable in the form of flakes. This is called a pearlitic gray iron and is the most common form of gray cast iron. If the cooling rate was extremely slow, the carbon in the austenite,
instead of forming cementite in the pearlite, would diffuse to and precipitate around the graphite flakes and leave a matrix of ferrite. This structure would represent ferritic gray iron. Because of the ferritic matrix, this type of iron would have a lower strength but higher ductility than pearlitic gray iron.
General Description of Microstructures in Cast Irons Gray Cast Iron. The distinguishing microstructural characteristic of gray cast iron is the presence of graphite in the form of flakes, as shown in Fig. 2.48. In this micrograph, the flakes (dark gray) are surrounded by a matrix of pearlite. The matrix of an as-cast gray iron can also consist of 100% ferrite, 100% pearlite, or various mixtures of pearlite and ferrite. In addition, the matrix of heat treated gray iron can consist of other transformation products, such as martensite and bainite. In the pearlitic gray iron shown in Fig. 2.48, the graphite flakes are rather long. Gray cast irons can have flakes of various lengths and of different morphologies. These morphologies are discussed in more detail in Chapter 1. Gray cast iron usually contains between 1 and 3% Si, because silicon promotes the formation of graphite, that is, silicon is a graphitizer. In Fig. 2.48, the graphite flakes appear separated, but if observed in three dimensions, the flakes would be interconnected. The three-dimensional array would encompass what is called a cell. The flakes impart a degree of brittleness to this form of cast iron. Therefore, gray cast iron is generally not used in applications where critical parts are subjected to impact or bending stresses. However, the flakes also impart a degree of damping capacity (the
Fig. 2.46 Pearlitic white cast iron (3.21% C, 0.32% Mn, and 0.47% Si)
showing the rim of cementite (note arrows) that formed upon cooling around the primary dendrites of austenite (now pearlite). 4% picral etch. 500⫻
Fig. 2.48 Pearlitic gray cast iron (3.22% C, 0.77% Mn, and 1.98% Si). Elongated, dark particles are graphite flakes. 4% picral etch.
Fig. 2.47 The iron-graphite phase diagram
500⫻
Origin of Microstructure / 45 ability of a material to absorb vibrations). Gray cast iron is very useful as frames or bases in all kinds of heavy machinery. Gray iron, because of the soft graphite flakes, is easily machinable. White Cast Iron. As seen in Fig. 2.49, the microstructure of white cast iron is entirely different from gray cast iron. In this microstructure, there are no graphite flakes present. The larger, dark gray, rounded areas in Fig. 2.49 consist of pearlite. The aligned array of these rounded areas is a result of the original dendritic structure that formed during solidification. Each large, rounded patch of pearlite formed between a branch or arm of a dendrite. The white continuous phase in Fig. 2.49 is cementite, and the regions containing the small, rounded pools are the eutectic constituent called ledeburite. Another view of ledeburite is shown in Fig. 2.45 and 2.46. The eutectic constituent consists of cementite (white) and pearlite (dark). The eutectic formed during solidification as cementite and austenite (discussed previously). These rounded regions within the ledeburite can also be martensitic, depending on the alloy content of the cast iron and the cooling rate during transformation. Because of the large amount of the continuous cementite phase, white cast irons are usually brittle, very hard, and difficult to machine. In fact, the high hardness makes white cast iron very useful for applications requiring wear and abrasion resistance, for example, rolls and ore/rock crushing machinery. Mottled Cast Iron. When a cast iron consists of a mixture of gray and white iron, the cast iron is called mottled cast iron, because of its mottled or speckled appearance in a fractured surface. Figure 2.50 shows an example of the microstructure of mottled iron. Note the presence of graphite flakes in a matrix of pearlite, that is, the gray iron microstructure, adjacent to a continuous network of cementite, pools of ledeburite, and rounded regions of pearlite, that is, the white iron microstructure. Gener-
Fig. 2.49 Pearlitic white cast iron (3.21% C, 0.32% Mn, and 0.47% Si). 4% picral etch. 250⫻
ally, a mottled microstructure is found as a transition microstructure between gray iron and white iron in a casting. Mottled iron is not a desirable form of cast iron, particularly from the viewpoint of machinability, where, for example, in a gray iron, hard spots are introduced by the presence of patches of white iron. Ductile (Nodular) Cast Iron. The nodular or spherical form of graphite in ductile cast iron is shown in Fig. 2.51, which illustrates a pearlitic ductile iron. In producing ductile cast iron, the liquid is inoculated with magnesium or cerium. These elements form compounds in the liquid cast iron that act as nuclei for the
Fig. 2.50 Mottled pearlitic cast iron. Gray iron at upper left and white iron at lower right of photo. 4% picral etch. 250⫻
Fig. 2.51 Pearlitic ductile (nodular) cast iron (2.95% C, 0.36% Mn, 2.75%
Si, and 0.09% Mg). Dark, rounded particles are graphite. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
46 / Metallographer’s Guide graphite. Without these nuclei, the graphite would form as flakes. Because of the nuclei, the graphite grows in a radial pattern to form spheres, an example of which is shown in Fig. 2.52. As in gray cast iron, the matrix of ductile iron can consist of a variety of different constituents. The nodular form of the graphite imparts a high degree of ductility to this type of cast iron. Ductile iron is used in applications requiring ductility and toughness, where gray or white cast iron cannot be used.
Malleable Cast Iron. Malleable iron cannot be produced as-cast and is produced only by heat treating white cast iron at temperatures and times that are sufficient to decompose the cementite into carbon (graphite). These heat treatment cycles are generally about 870 to 925 °C (1600 to 1700 °F) for 15 to 24 hours. The characteristic microstructure of malleable iron is shown in Fig. 2.53. In this example, the irregular-shaped dark areas are called “temper carbon,” a form of graphite, and the matrix is pearlite. Represented in Fig. 2.53 is pearlitic malleable cast iron. The temper carbon is formed by the decomposition of the cementite in the original white iron by the following reaction: Fe3C ↔ 3Fe ⫹ C
Graphite is the stable form of carbon in cast irons and steels, whereas cementite is metastable, which means that with sufficient time and temperature, cementite will eventually revert to graphite. Because of the rounded form of the temper carbon, the properties of malleable iron are somewhat similar to ductile cast iron. There is more discussion of malleable iron in the next chapter.
Commercial Cast Irons Because all commercial cast irons contain fairly large amounts of manganese, silicon, and other alloying elements, the phase diagrams discussed previously can only be used as a rough guide to transformation behavior. It has been shown that silicon and phosphorus have a strong effect on shifting the eutectic composition. The following equation can be used to approximate the eutectic composition in terms of a carbon equivalent value: Fig. 2.52 A graphite nodule in a ductile (nodular) cast iron. Unetched. 500⫻
Fig. 2.53 Pearlitic malleable cast iron (3.21% C, 0.32% Mn, and 0.47% Si). Dark areas are “temper carbon.” 4% picral. 500⫻
Carbon equivalent (CE) ⫽ % Total carbon ⫹ (% Si ⫹ % P)/3
Thus, for a cast iron with 2.6% C, 1.0% Si, and 0.2% P, the CE value would be 3.0%, which would be a hypoeutectic cast iron (hypoeutectic if below the equilibrium value of 4.3% C in Fig. 2.2). The additional elements not only shift the eutectic composition and eutectic temperature, but they also have other profound effects on microstructural development. Manganese, chromium, molybdenum, and vanadium are carbide stabilizers, which means that they promote the formation of stable, iron-rich carbide, that is, cementite containing these elements in solid solution. Silicon, aluminum, nickel, and copper, on the other hand, are graphitizers, which means that they promote the formation of graphite. Thus, having manganese, chromium, molybdenum, or vanadium would favor the iron-cementite phase diagram, and silicon, aluminum, nickel, and copper would favor the iron-graphite phase diagram. Thus, proper control of these elements is essential if one desires a gray cast iron or a white cast iron. Just as important as composition is the cooling rate during solidification and subsequent cooling during the solid-state transformations. As in the case of steels, the proper combination of composition and cooling rate can determine a particular microstructure in cast iron. Thus, gray irons usually contain substantial amounts of silicon and are solidified rather slowly. For white irons, the silicon content is
Origin of Microstructure / 47 usually lower than that in gray irons, and one or more of the carbide stabilizers are present. Also, white cast irons are solidified more rapidly and are usually cast in thin sections or are cast in molds containing chills. Foundry molding practices can be tailored to give fast or slow cooling rates during solidification and solid-state transformation. Unfortunately, there are only a few continuous CT diagrams for the cast irons, but the same principles of continuous cooling in
Fig. 2.54 Plate martensite transformation in the primary austenite dendrites of an alloy (Ni-Hard) white cast iron (2.95% C, 0.63% Mn, 0.73% Si, 3.08% Ni, and 2.17% Cr). 4% picral etch. 500⫻
Fig. 2.55 Additional formation of plate martensite in the same sample of Ni-Hard cast iron shown in Fig. 2.54 after cooling in liquid nitrogen. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
steels still apply to cast irons, especially in controlling the matrix microstructure. The graphite and the cementite phases are controlled mostly by solidification (except for malleable iron, where the graphite is controlled by heat treatment). In cooling below the eutectic temperature, the austenite can decompose into pearlite, ferrite, martensite, or bainite, depending mainly on cooling rate and on the composition of the austenite. Gray cast irons, in general, have a pearlitic matrix at slow-to-moderate cooling rates and a ferritic matrix at very slow cooling rates. In white cast irons, the austenite decomposes by either a pearlitic, bainitic, or martensitic transformation. An example of the structure observed after a martensitic transformation in a commercial alloyed white cast iron (called Ni-Hard) is shown in Fig. 2.54. The martensite is plate martensite, due to its high carbon content. In this micrograph, the martensite was tempered at about 100 °C (212 °F), which caused it to appear darker after etching. The gray regions between the plates of martensite are retained austenite. This retained austenite would transform if the cast iron was cooled to a very low temperature (this alloy has a martensite finish temperature below room temperature). The same field of view shown in Fig. 2.54 of the Ni-Hard cast iron is shown again in Fig. 2.55 after being subcooled in liquid nitrogen. Note that much of the retained austenite has transformed to more plate martensite, as evidenced by the white needles of freshly formed (untempered) plate martensite. There is a fairly large amount of retained austenite still existing in this microstructure. One way to change the microstructure of cast iron is through heat treatment by reaustenitizing and cooling at a specified rate. The next chapter deals with various ways to alter the microstructure of cast iron. Also, in commercial cast irons, several impurity elements may be present, often at levels much higher than in steels. The major impurities are sulfur and phosphorus. As in steels, manganese is added to tie up the sulfur in the form of manganese sulfide
Fig. 2.56 The eutectic constituent steadite (see arrow) in a pearlitic gray cast iron. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
48 / Metallographer’s Guide inclusions. Phosphorus, on the other hand, is not tied up by manganese and forms a eutectic constituent called steadite, named after John Edward Stead, a noted 19th century English metallurgist. The eutectic consists of iron and iron phosphide, Fe3P, and is formed through the following reaction: Liquid ↔ Fe ⫹ Fe3P
An example of the constituent, steadite, is seen in Fig. 2.56 as a region containing a cluster of small iron phosphide particles. The microstructure shown in Fig. 2.56 represents a pearlitic gray cast iron containing high phosphorus. REFERENCES 1. A. Sauveur, The Metallography and Heat Treatment of Iron and Steel, Sauveur and Boylston, Cambridge, Mass., 1912 2. F. Osmond and J.E. Stead, The Microscopic Analysis of Metals, Charles Griffin and Co., London, 1913
3. H.M. Howe, The Metallography of Steel and Cast Iron, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1916 4. E.S. Davenport and E.C. Bain, Trans. AIME, Vol 90, 1930, p. 117–144. 5. Properties and Selection: Irons, Steels, and High-Performance Alloys, Vol 1, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1990 6. G.V. Raynor and V.G. Rivlin, Phase Equilibria in Iron Ternary Alloys, The Institute of Metals, London, 1988 7. V. Raghavan, Phase Diagrams of Ternary Iron Alloys, Part 1, ASM International, 1987 8. G. Krauss, Steels: Heat Treatment and Processing Principles, ASM International, 1989 9. L.E. Samuels, Optical Microscopy of Carbon Steels, American Society for Metals, 1980, p. 41–58 10. B.L. Bramfitt and J.G. Speer, Metall. Trans. A, Vol 21, 1990, p. 817–829
Metallographer's Guide: Practices and Procedures for Irons and Steels Bruce L. Bramfitt, Arlan O. Benscoter, p49-86 DOI:10.1361/mgpp2002p049
Copyright © 2002 ASM International® All rights reserved. www.asminternational.org
CHAPTER 3
Alteration of Microstructure IN THE PREVIOUS CHAPTER, it was shown how a great variety of microstructures can be formed in steels and cast irons. It was learned that cooling rate and composition play important roles in determining the type of microstructure that is produced. Accordingly, the same steel can have different microstructures, depending on the way the steel is processed. It is important to understand the principles in the previous chapter in order to get more meaning from the information and examples given in this chapter. A particular microstructure can be altered, either intentionally or unintentionally. It is the metallographer’s task to prepare a specimen, examine it in the light microscope, and in many cases, interpret the microstructure. Many times, the metallographer (and metallurgist) must diagnose what may have happened to the steel or cast iron, based on its microstructural details, and, in turn, explain why the steel or cast iron is exhibiting abnormal behavior. The first section provides examples of how microstructure can be intentionally altered during heat treatment, solidification, and deformation (hot and cold working). These treatments are considered intentional alterations, because they are meant to achieve a specific goal, for example, to soften the steel, to strengthen the steel, to increase surface hardness, and to produce a more ductile cast iron. In many cases, a steel or cast iron must be heat treated for a second time to return it to its original microstructure and properties. Remember, here we use terms “microstructure” and “properties” synonymously. That is, processing and composition determine the microstructure that in turn dictates the properties of the material. From the metallographer’s viewpoint, the golden rule is that microstructure influences properties. Knowing this link can be very useful in making recommendations about intentionally retreating a steel or cast iron component to restore properties. In the second section, some specific examples are shown to illustrate what can go wrong through unintentional changes in microstructure, for example, the loss of carbon from the surface of the steel by the process known as decarburization or the buildup of brittle carbides on the grain boundaries of an austenitic stainless steel by the process known as sensitization. Unintentional changes can usually relate to a process that has gone out of control. The metallographer (and metallurgist) must be aware of these unintentional microstructural alterations and be able to recognize them when they have taken place. Also, the metallographer and metallurgist should know what needs to be done to change the microstructure back to a normal condition. In some cases, the unintentional changes are not reversible, for example, a steel in the burned condition or with hydrogen damage cannot be
salvaged. However, many times, a simple heat treatment can restore the microstructure and properties. This chapter provides a basis to assist the metallographer and metallurgist in making rational decisions that can save time and money in the workplace.
The Intentional Alteration of Microstructure in Steels and Cast Irons As shown in the previous chapter, one of the easiest ways to change a microstructure is through heat treatment. Many steel and some cast iron products are heat treated to achieve specific properties, such as a particular hardness level or tensile strength. Marked changes in microstructure can even take place by simply heating a steel to various temperatures and cooling to room temperature. The cooling rate from these temperatures can have a profound effect on the resulting microstructure and properties. Some of these simple heat treatments are discussed subsequently. This portion of the chapter is structured so that each heat treatment is used to achieve a specific purpose or goal. Sometimes microstructures can be intentionally altered by processes other than heat treatment, as in the case of cold working of steel and inoculation of liquid iron. These processes are also discussed subsequently.
Goal: Produce a Uniform Microstructure Normalizing. A normalizing heat treatment is designed to produce a uniform microstructure. Normalizing also produces a finer grain size and improves machinability. To illustrate the effect of normalizing, a hot-rolled, 19 mm (0.75 in.) diameter bar of AISI/SAE 1040 steel is used. The microstructure of the original hot-rolled bar is seen in Fig. 3.1. In the micrograph (longitudinal view), it can be seen that the microstructure is obviously nonuniform and consists of alternating bands of pearlite and ferrite. In a plain carbon steel, the bands of pearlite contain higher carbon and manganese contents than the ferrite bands. This compositional “banding” is a result of the chemical segregation that occurred during solidification. (The solidification took place when the molten steel was cast into a mold, such as a water-cooled copper mold of a continuous casting machine found in a high-productivity steel plant. The cooling rate during solidification and the composition largely dictate the amount of segregation that develops.)
50 / Metallographers’ Guide
Fig. 3.1 Microstructure of a typical as-rolled AISI/SAE 1040 steel bar consisting of bands of ferrite (light) and pearlite (dark). 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 200⫻
In the previously mentioned AISI/SAE 1040 steel, the hotworking process from the as-cast state to the final rolled bar was insufficient to destroy this segregation. The hot-rolling process merely stretched out the compositional segregation into elongated bands. Sometimes, this type of microstructure is undesirable, because banding produces anisotropic (directional) properties. For example, the strength and notch toughness measured parallel to the bands may differ significantly from the strength and notch toughness measured perpendicular to the bands. However, for many applications, these differences are so small that banding is not considered a problem. The simplest way to eliminate pearlite banding is to reheat the steel to an appropriate normalizing temperature and air cool to room temperature. Most normalizing temperatures are specified as being about 55 to 80 °C (100 to 150 °F) above the upper critical temperature (Ac3). This is represented as the shaded band shown in the iron-carbon equilibrium diagram in Fig. 3.2. Actually, an equilibrium diagram is not the correct way to indicate normalizing temperatures, because we are not dealing with equilibrium conditions. However, this representation is used because most metallographers/metallurgists are familiar with the iron-carbon equilibrium diagram. The actual recommended heat treating temperatures for a specific steel can be found in the references
Fig. 3.2 Iron-carbon equilibrium diagram showing region (shaded) of typical normalizing temperatures
Alteration of Microstructure / 51 listed at the end of this chapter. For AISI/SAE 1040, the specified normalizing temperature range is 860 to 900 °C (1575 to 1650 °F). The microstructure of the normalized AISI/SAE 1040 steel bar is shown in Fig. 3.3. This microstructure was produced by heating the steel to 900 °C (1650 °F) for one hour, followed by air cooling. Note that the microstructure is very uniform and consists of a fine ferrite grain size and regions of pearlite. The banding has disappeared. During the heat treatment, the carbon was redistributed in the austenite, that is, the carbon diffused from the banded pearlite regions, which transformed to austenite along with the ferrite and distributed itself uniformly in the austenite. Remember from the previous chapter, for a 0.4% C steel at a temperature of 900 °C (1650 °F), carbon is completely soluble in austenite. The air cooling provided a rapid enough cooling rate to prevent the carbon from returning to the banded regions where manganese and other segregated alloying elements still reside. If the steel was cooled slowly, the carbon would have had time to diffuse back to the compositional bands. The only way to remove the compositional bands is to subject the steel to a high-temperature, long-time homogenization treatment described in the following section. This treatment allows the manganese, which is a substitutional alloying element in the iron lattice, to diffuse. (A substitutional element is one that can replace an iron atom in the face-centered cubic or body-centered cubic lattices [see Chapter 2].) Carbon, being an interstitial alloying element, can diffuse far more easily than manganese, because it can move in the interstices between the iron atoms in the crystal lattice. It is important to follow the recommended temperatures of each type of heat treatment found in the Handbooks. There are metallurgical reasons why these temperature ranges are specified. For example, let’s look at what happens to the microstructure of the same hot-rolled bar of AISI/SAE 1040 steel when heated to
Fig. 3.3 Microstructure of a typical normalized AISI/SAE 1040 steel bar showing uniformity of ferrite (light) and pearlite (dark). 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 200⫻
five different austenitizing temperatures ranging from 840 to 980 °C (1550 to 1800 °F) and subsequently air cooled to room temperature. Figure 3.4 shows the microstructure produced by air cooling from these five temperatures. In heating to temperatures between 840 and 940 °C (1550 and 1725 °F), the resulting microstructure is uniform and consists of small pearlite colonies in a matrix of ferrite. This range covers the specified range for normalizing an AISI/SAE 1040 steel of 860 to 900 °C (1575 to 1650 °F). The result of heating at temperatures above 980 °C (1800 °F) is that the microstructure is drastically different and consists of some extremely large grains containing pearlite with a grain boundary network of proeutectoid ferrite. The question is, why the sudden change in microstructure? The answer is that there is a sudden growth of the austenite grains that takes place between 955 and 980 °C (1750 and 1800 °F). It actually begins to take place just below 955 °C (1750 °F), as shown in Fig. 3.4. In this micrograph, one can see the beginning of large austenite grains (now pearlite) that have absorbed the smaller grains. At 970 °C (1775 °F), the grain-coarsening process is more advanced. The exaggerated growth of the austenite grains is due to the dissolution of small aluminum nitride precipitates that were pinning the grain boundaries (the particles are much too small to be seen in the light microscope and must be examined in the transmission electron microscope). Once the particles dissolved upon heating, the grain boundaries were free to move. The AISI/SAE 1040 steel, shown in Fig. 3.4, was aluminum killed, and during the cooling of the original hot-rolled bar, the aluminum nitride particles precipitated on the austenite grain boundaries before the austenite transformed into ferrite and pearlite. In a steel that was not treated with aluminum or other nitride former, for example, titanium, the exaggerated grain growth would take place at lower temperatures because of the lack of the pinning action of the aluminum nitride precipitates. Because of the drastic microstructural changes that can take place upon heating, heat treatment guidelines should always be followed for a particular steel. As in the case of normalizing, the 860 to 900 °C (1575 to 1650 °F) range specified for a AISI/SAE 1040 steel allows some safety to avoid the problem of excessive grain growth. Homogenizing. A heat treatment called homogenization is carried out to eliminate or minimize the compositional segregation discussed previously, that is, banding in a steel. This treatment is seldom used, because it requires high-temperature treatments that take place for an extended period of time. Compositional segregation in a steel product can be traced back to the dendritic solidification process. During dendritic solidification, alloying elements, for example, manganese and chromium, are rejected from the growing dendrites. These alloying elements end up in liquid pools between the dendrite arms and between adjacent dendrites (a portion of the manganese and chromium will also be in the dendrites themselves). The resulting microstructure will reveal these regions, called microsegregation and macrosegregation. Microsegregation is represented by the segregation of alloying elements between the dendrite branches or arms. Macrosegregation is considered bulk segregation that usually takes place at the front of the growing dendrites and is therefore located toward the center of the cast shape. Figure 3.5 shows a dendritic
52 / Metallographers’ Guide microstructure in a continuous-cast AISI/SAE 1020 steel slab. One can see that the interdendritic areas and the areas between the dendrite arms consist of pearlite. The subsequent hot-working processes simply distort these and other segregated regions into elongated bands oriented along the rolling or forging direction (see Fig. 3.1). During the hot-working process, the steel is not at a high temperature long enough to diffuse substitutional alloying elements, such as manganese and chromium. The manganese and chromium atoms are of similar size to the iron atom and can only move about the lattice at high temperatures. To move a substantial distance, the steel must remain at this high temperature for an
extended time. An example of a homogenization treatment is given for an AISI/SAE 8630 steel that contains substitutional elements, manganese and chromium. The starting material is an as-rolled, 25 mm (1 in.) diameter bar that has the banded microstructure shown in Fig. 3.6. After heat treating the bar at a temperature of 1090 °C (2000 °F) for 120 hours, the microstructure shown in Fig. 3.7 was developed. The grain size is much coarser in the homogenized sample, because no effort was made to normalize the sample after the homogenization treatment. It is important to notice that in the homogenized condition, the compositional banding is eliminated. The proof is in the fact that
Fig. 3.4 Microstructure of a series of AISI/SAE 1040 steel bars heat treated at different temperatures. (a) At 840 °C (1550 °F). (b) At 940 °C (1725 °F). (c) At 955 °C (1750 °F). (d) At 970 °C (1775 °F). (e) At 980 °C (1800 °F). 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 100⫻
Alteration of Microstructure / 53 this bar was furnace cooled from 1090 °C (2000 °F), allowing ample time for the carbon to diffuse back to manganese- and chromium-rich bands, if they were still present. This means that the manganese and chromium also diffused and were thus redistributed in the iron matrix. Obviously, a five-day (120 hour) heat treatment at 1090 °C (2000 °F) is an expensive route to achieve homogenization. Most industrial processes do not use such treatments. A more economical way is to minimize segrega-
Fig. 3.4 (continued) (e) At 980 °C (1800 °F). 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 100⫻
Fig. 3.6 Microstructure of an as-rolled AISI/SAE 8630 steel bar. Longitudinal plane of polish showing banding of pearlite (dark etching constituent). 2% nital and 4% picral etch
tion during the solidification process. This can be done by decreasing the cross section of the casting (decreasing the solidification distance), increasing the cooling rate during solidification, or using a grain refiner to promote the nucleation of many independent crystals during solidification. These methods will produce finer dendrite arm spacings and shorter diffusion distances. The shorter diffusion distances mean less time is needed for homogenization.
Fig. 3.5 A dendritic microstructure in a continuous-cast AISI/SAE 1020 steel showing pearlite (dark etching constituent) in the interdendritic regions and between the dendrite arms. 4% picral etch. 50⫻
Fig. 3.7 Microstructure of the AISI/SAE 8630 steel bar after a homogenization heat treatment. 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 100⫻
54 / Metallographers’ Guide
Goal: Produce a Higher Hardness Quenching. Centuries ago, craftsmen knew that quenching a “red hot” sword in water or into the fleshy parts of a “Nubian slave” would produce high hardness and a better cutting edge. The process was finally understood at the end of the 19th century when metallurgists began looking at steel samples under the light microscope. A steel that has been quenched in water contains a constituent known as martensite. As-quenched martensite, in medium- and high-carbon steels, has a very high hardness, that is, 60 to 65 HRC. An example of an as-quenched fully martensitic AISI/SAE 8630 steel is shown in Fig. 3.8(a) and (b). In this example, lath martensite has formed. (As discussed in Chapter 2, there are two common forms of martensite: lath martensite and plate martensite. Lath martensite forms in low- to medium-carbon steels, and plate martensite forms in high-carbon steels. For example, as carbon content increases in a plain carbon steel, plate martensite begins to form at about 0.6% C, and above about 1% C, the as-quenched microstructure will be all plate martensite (between 0.6 and 1% C, there will be a mixture of lath and plate martensite). These carbon percentages can change with alloying.) Martensite is certainly one way to achieve high hardness in steel. Razor blades are an example of a product having an as-quenched martensitic microstructure. However, in carbon steels, as-quenched martensite lacks ductility and therefore has limited commercial usefulness. Therefore, martensitic steels are used in the tempered condition, because tempered martensites have some ductility. Tempered martensitic steels are used in many products. Tempering is discussed in an upcoming section, because it is a process to increase ductility and toughness. Intercritical Annealing. Generally, heat treatment is not carried out in the intercritical region, that is, between the Ar1 and Ar3
temperatures, because the austenite transformation from ferrite and pearlite upon heating is not completed, that is, only a portion of the microstructure at the intercritical temperature will be austenite and the remainder untransformed ferrite. However, one form of heat treatment takes advantage of this partial transformation to austenite. The process is called intercritical annealing to produce what is known as a dual-phase steel. Dual-phase steels, developed in the 1970s, became noteworthy for special automotive applications requiring high strength and good formability. One such application is in producing automotive wheel rims and wheel discs. An example of a typical dual-phase microstructure is shown in Fig. 3.9. The microstructure consists of regions or islands of martensite in a matrix of ferrite, hence the term “dual-phase steel.” The martensite formed as a result of quenching a steel sheet from the intercritical (two-phase) region where the microstructure at the annealing temperature was approximately 15% austenite and 85% untransformed (original) ferrite. The austenite is rich in carbon, and during quenching, the austenite transformed to martensite, and the ferrite remained essentially unchanged. Usually, the presence of martensite in an automotive sheet is undesirable (except in very special high-strength applications). However, in the case of a dual-phase steel, the martensite is embedded in a soft ferrite matrix, and the martensite provides a continuous source of dislocations during forming of the part. A source of dislocations is needed to promote continuous yielding behavior, that is, lack of a yield point, during forming in the stamping operations. This means that the deformed areas of the sheet actually strengthen due to a process known as work hardening. Normal high-strength automotive sheet will deform by a process of discontinuous yielding and will have limited workhardening capability. A steel with discontinuous yielding will produce a yield point during the tensile test, and a steel with
Fig. 3.8 Microstructure of a quenched AISI/SAE 8630 steel bar consisting of lath martensite. 2% nital etch. (a) 500⫻ and (b) 1500⫻
Alteration of Microstructure / 55 continuous yielding will produce a smooth or “round house” stress-strain curve. Discontinuous yielding can create Lüders lines in a sheet, which, for exposed parts, is objectionable. The amount of martensite in the microstructure of a dual-phase steel is controlled by the annealing temperature and the carbon content of the steel. The greater the percentage of martensite, the higher the tensile strength of the sheet. However, more martensite also means lower ductility. The metallographer should be able to recognize a dual-phase microstructure and determine if it received the proper heat treatment. Many times, dual-phase steels will contain retained austenite in addition to the martensite. Retained austenite can provide an added degree of ductility during a deformation process as it transforms to additional martensite. Figure 3.10(a) shows an intercritically annealed AISI/SAE 1010 steel that contains martensite (dark etching constituent) and retained austenite (light gray etching constituent) in a matrix of ferrite. During forming, the austenite would transform to martensite by a process called strain-induced transformation. If examined with differential interference contrast (this technique, called Nomarski, is described in Chapter 5), as in Fig. 3.10(b), the same microstructure reveals a region surrounding each area of martensite and retained austenite. This region is “new” ferrite that formed during cooling, that is, the new ferrite grew into the austenite regions that were present at the intercritical temperature. The new ferrite is thought to be a simple extension of the ferrite already present and is thus referred to as epitaxial ferrite, because it formed epitaxially (growing on a material of identical crystal structure and similar interatomic spacing) on the existing ferrite lattice. Cold Working. If a steel is rolled at room temperature, or at a temperature below the recrystallization temperature of ferrite, the steel will increase in hardness. The deformation introduces a high density of dislocations. Dislocations are defects in the body-
centered cubic lattice, for example, a dislocation could be created by a missing plane of atoms. Figure 3.11 shows the microstructure of a cold-rolled, low-carbon steel sheet that has been cold rolled 30, 50, 70, and 90% (measured by the percent change in final thickness from the original thickness). As the sheet lengthened, the degree of elongation of the ferrite grains increased in
Fig. 3.10 Microstructure of an intercritically annealed AISI/SAE 1010 steel
Fig. 3.9 Microstructure of a typical dual-phase steel bar consisting of
martensite (dark) in a matrix of ferrite (light). 2% nital etch. 1000⫻
bar consisting of (a) martensite (dark etching constituent) and retained austenite (gray etching constituent) in a matrix of ferrite in bright-field illumination and (b) the same field of view in differential interference contrast (Nomarski). Note the formation of “epitaxial” ferrite (see arrows) surrounding the martensitic areas. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
56 / Metallographers’ Guide proportion to the amount of cold reduction. The ferritic microstructure was thus altered by the deformation process. Note that the elongated ferrite grains contain dark etching regions. These dark regions represent deformation bands that contain a high density of dislocations. The dislocations cannot be resolved in the light microscope and thus can only be observed in the transmission electron microscope. The deformation-induced dislocations increase the hardness of the steel. However, steels are rarely used in the cold-worked condition, because they lack ductility and formability. Steels in the cold-rolled “full-hard” condition are used in limited applications, such as steel strapping for banding
cargo and freight shipments. Another form of cold-rolled sheet is duo-reduced tinplate. Usually, steels in the cold-rolled condition are annealed (see the subsequent section on recrystallization annealing) to enhance ductility and formability. Cold-rolled steels can be stress relieved at temperatures of about 315 to 425 °C (600 to 800 °F) before use. There are commercial sheet steels called stress-relief annealed steels that are essentially steels in the cold-worked condition that have been stress relieved just enough to provide some ductility, but not enough to drastically lower strength. The process is also called recovery annealing, where the metallurgical process of
Fig. 3.11 Microstructure of a cold-rolled, low-carbon steel sheet. Cold-worked (a) 30%, (b) 50%, (c) 70%, and (d) 90%. Marshall’s etch. 500⫻
Alteration of Microstructure / 57 recovery takes place. Recovery is an intermediate stage between cold work and recrystallization. During the recovery process, most of the dislocations that were induced by deformation can move, interact, and cancel each other. The remaining dislocations can regroup to form subgrain boundaries within the ferrite grains themselves. The dislocations in subgrain boundaries can only be seen in the transmission electron microscope.
Fig. 3.12 Microstructure of a cold-worked AISI 304 stainless steel rod at
(a) a near-surface region and (b) at the center. Differential interference contrast (Nomarski). Etched in 60 parts nitric acid in 40 parts water, stainless steel cathode, 5 V for 10 s. 800⫻
Another example of the use of cold working to harden and strengthen a steel is in the case of an austenitic stainless steel. Because austenitic stainless steels are fully austenitic from room temperature up to their melting point, they cannot be hardened by quenching, as in the case of a plain carbon or low-alloy steel. Therefore, austenitic stainless steels are generally cold worked to achieve a higher strength. Cold-worked austenitic steels can be found in numerous applications. An example of a cold-worked steel can be seen in the 9.5 mm (0.375 in.) diameter AISI 304 austenitic stainless steel rod shown in Fig. 3.12. Note that the cold work is delineated by numerous deformation bands within the austenite grains. The degree of cold work is much greater near the surface region (Fig. 3.12a) than at the center of the rod (Fig. 3.12b). Also note that the deformation bands can occur at three specific orientations within each grain. These orientations represent the {111} planes of the austenite crystal lattice, where deformation (or slip) along these planes can take place more easily. The center of the rod has fewer locations of deformation, because there is a deformation gradient from the surface inward. This leads to uneven deformation and surface-to-center variation and is one of the disadvantages of using cold working as a strengthening mechanism in thicker sections. The metallographer should be able to recogonize a cold-worked condition in both plain carbon and austenitic stainless steels. In many cases, a cold-worked condition is not desired, and proper metallographic procedures will reveal the extent of cold working. In some cases, the metallographic preparation process itself can introduce cold working into a sample. This produces an “artifact,” or false microstructure, that will mislead the metallographer in analyzing the microstructure. More about artifacts can be found in Chapter 7.
Fig. 3.13 Microstructure of a hot-rolled, high-strength microalloyed steel
plate with elongated pearlite bands (dark constituent) in a ferrite matrix. 4% picral followed by 2% nital. 500⫻
58 / Metallographers’ Guide
Fig. 3.14 Iron-carbon equilibrium diagram showing region (shaded) of annealing temperatures
Fig. 3.15 Microstructure of an annealed AISI/SAE 1040 steel bar consist-
ing of bands of ferrite (light) and pearlite (dark). Longitudinal section. 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 500⫻
Precipitation Hardening. A very popular way to increase hardness and strengthen a steel is through a mechanism known as precipitation hardening or precipitation strengthening. The steel is processed in such a way as to allow precipitates to form during cooling, during hot deformation, or during a subsequent aging treatment. Once the precipitate nucleates and grows, the surrounding matrix is locally hardened, because the precipitates take up more volume in the iron matrix. Precipitates can also form during tempering of low-alloy steels and give rise to what is termed “secondary hardening.” These precipitates are usually alloy carbides of chromium, molybdenum, and vanadium. The tempering heat treatment usually involves a temperature below the lower critical temperature (A1). The precipitation process also is an important step in the strengthening of maraging steels, where, after quenching, a precipitate (an intermetallic compound) forms in the martensite during an aging heat treatment (usually at 425 °C (800 °F) for two hours). A similar process is also involved in precipitationstrengthened stainless steels. Another example of precipitation strengthening is a process involving carbide- and nitride-forming elements (columbium (niobium), vanadium, titanium, aluminum, etc.). These carbonitride particles precipitate in austenite during hot rolling or forging.
Alteration of Microstructure / 59 The small precipitates restrict austenite grain-boundary movement and thus provide grain refinement. This process is described subsequently. Thus, the metallographer should be aware of the role of precipitates in altering the microstructure of steel. The light microscope can be used to observe clues about the precipitation process, but an electron microscope is often necessary to observe the precipitate itself. An analytical electron microscope, such as a scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM), is vital to
identify the chemical composition of individual precipitate particles. Grain Refinement. Precipitates also inhibit dislocation and grain-boundary movement, thus producing a fine grain size that promotes higher hardness and strength of the steel. Precipitates can also prevent recrystallization of austenite during hot rolling, a process that allows the austenite grains to elongate along the rolling direction. When the flattened austenite grains transform to ferrite, the flattened grains restrict the growth distance and thus
Fig. 3.16 Microstructure of cold-rolled, interstitial-free steel sheet that has been annealed for 1 min at (a) 649 °C (1200 °F), (b) 676 °C (1250 °F), (c) 704 °C (1300 °F), and (d) 732 °C (1350 °F). Marshall’s etch. 400⫻
60 / Metallographers’ Guide
Fig. 3.17 Microstructure of (a) an as-quenched AISI/SAE 8630 steel bar and (b) a fully spheroidized structure consisting of spheroids of cementite in a matrix of ferrite. 4% picral etch. 1000⫻
the size of the new ferrite grains. The fine ferrite grains provide higher hardness and strength. An example of the results of this process is shown in Fig. 3.13, which represents a hot-rolled plate steel that was “microalloyed” with the element columbium (niobium). The columbium (niobium) combined with carbon and nitrogen to form columbium carbonitride, Cb(C,N), precipitates. During hot rolling, austenite recrystallization was retarded, and elongated grains developed. Some evidence of the elongated austenite grains can be seen in the microstructure shown in Fig. 3.13. The final ferrite grain size is controlled largely by the thickness of the prior austenite grains. Strain Aging. One such strain-aging treatment would be the paint-bake cycle for automobile outerbody panels. In this process, called bake hardening, not only is the paint cured, but the steel itself increases in hardness and strength.
Goal: Produce a Lower Hardness
Fig. 3.18 Iron-carbon equilibrium diagram showing region (shaded) of spheroidizing temperatures
Annealing. This heat treatment is generally used to soften a steel or cast iron. The austenitizing temperatures used are not as specific as in the case of normalizing, but are limited to temperatures that avoid the exaggerated grain growth seen in Fig. 3.4. Annealing temperatures can range from 840 to 900 °C (1550 to 1650 °F). Annealing temperatures for plain carbon steels are
Alteration of Microstructure / 61 shown as a shaded band on the iron-carbon equilibrium diagram in Fig. 3.14. Recommended annealing temperatures for various steels can be found in the references at the end of the chapter. For an AISI/SAE 1040 steel, the annealed microstructure is seen in Fig. 3.15. Annealing has softened the steel, but did not produce a uniform microstructure, as in the case of normalizing (Fig. 3.3). The differences between annealing and normalizing are due to the cooling rate of the steel after the austenitizing treatment; in annealing, the steel is slow cooled, usually furnace cooled, and in normalizing, the steel is cooled at a faster rate, generally, by forced air cooling or static air cooling. The slower cooling process allows for carbon diffusion. Many times, an annealed microstructure will be banded if the starting microstructure was banded. Annealed microstructures are not as uniform or as fine-grained as a normalized microstructure. Recrystallization Annealing. Annealing can also be used to soften a cold-worked steel and is a very important step in the production of cold-rolled steel sheet. For example, automotive sheet steels for outerbody panels are produced by cold rolling (rolling at room temperature) to obtain the desired sheet thickness, followed by either batch or continuous annealing. As described in the section on cold working, a cold-rolled steel has limited ductility and cannot be easily formed into contoured parts. The annealing process for steel sheet is called recrystallization annealing. New ferrite grains (recrystallized grains) are formed from the elongated cold-worked ferrite grains. Figure 3.16(a) shows the microstructure of a cold-rolled, interstitial-free (IF) sheet steel after annealing at 650 °C (1200 °F) for one minute. (Interstitial elements, such as carbon and nitrogen, have a much smaller atom size than iron, and the atoms can reside in special positions within the iron lattice (in the interstices). “Interstitial-free”steel is a term used to describe a steel in which carbon and nitrogen are almost completely removed from the iron lattice in the form of carbides or nitrides. Commercially, titanium or columbium (niobium) are added for this purpose.) This treatment illustrates the very early stage of recrystallization. The arrows show the small recrystallized grains that have nucleated. After one minute at 675 °C (1250 °F) (Fig. 3.16b), more recrystallized grains are shown in the microstructure, and after annealing one minute at 705 °C (1300 °F), the cold-rolled IF steel shows that recrystallization is almost complete, with some evidence of the original cold-worked grains remaining (Fig. 3.16c). Figure 3.16(d) shows a fully recrystallized microstructure that occurred after annealing for one minute at 730 °C (1350 °F). In the fully recrystallized condition, this IF steel will have excellent formability, and strain aging will be absent, because the carbon and nitrogen interstitial elements are tied up as carbides, nitrides, or carbonitrides. The metallographer must be able to recognize cold-worked and recrystallized microstructures, especially in monitoring sheet steel annealing processes. Spheroidizing. To develop the softest possible condition, a steel is usually given a spheroidizing treatment. This kind of treatment is used to enhance machinability. The term “spheroidizing” means that the cementite constituent is converted to spheroids, or rounded particles, in a matrix of ferrite. An example of a fully spheroidized microstructure of AISI/SAE 8630 steel is
shown in Fig. 3.17(b). Note the small, rounded particles of cementite in the micrograph. The hardness of this steel is 82 HRB, which is well below the hardness of 97 HRB of the same steel in the normalized condition. To alter the microstructure to a spheroidized condition, the steel is heated for a fairly long time (10 to 15 hours) at a temperature just above and then just below the lower critical (A1) temperature. This is indicated by the shaded band on the iron-carbon equilibrium diagram, shown in Fig. 3.18. The fairly long treatment time allows dissolution or breakup of the
Fig. 3.19 Microstructure (b) of a spheroidized AISI/SAE 8630 steel bar
produced from the original banded microstructure shown in (a). 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 1000⫻
62 / Metallographers’ Guide cementite lamella in pearlite. The carbon is then redistributed by the diffusion process, and rounded particles are formed. For a uniform distribution of cementite particles, it is recommended that the steel be in the quenched condition before spheroidizing, that is, the steel should have a martensitic microstructure (see Fig. 3.17a). The martensitic microstructure has a uniform distribution of carbon dissolved in the iron lattice, and the microstructure is usually very fine and thus contains numerous nucleation sites for
the new carbides. With martensite present, the process does not depend on the dissolution of the cementite lamella in pearlite, and thus spheroidization can take place in a much shorter period of time. An example of a spheroidized microstructure produced from a bar of AISI/SAE 8630 steel with an as-rolled ferrite/pearlite microstructure (Fig. 3.19a) is shown in Fig. 3.19(b). Note the uniform distribution of carbides in the microstructure from the martensitic bar and the nonuniform distribution of carbides resulting from the ferrite/pearlite bar, even though both steels were heat treated at 700 °C (1290 °F) for 20 hours and air cooled. In the latter case, one can see where the pearlite bands existed. Tempering. Generally, a steel that has been quenched is subsequently tempered to provide some softening and ductility as well as stress relief. Tempering is a subcritical treatment, where the part is heated to temperatures generally ranging from 260 to 650 °C (500 to 1200 °F) and air cooled to room temperature. During the tempering process, carbides begin to precipitate from the carbide-free martensitic microstructure. An example of a quenched and tempered AISI/SAE 8630 steel is shown in Fig. 3.20(a) and (b). The original steel in the as-quenched condition was shown in Fig. 3.8(a) and (b). The tempering temperature was 650 °C (1200 °F), and the tempering time was 2.5 hours. If the tempered microstructure is compared with the quenched microstructure, it can be seen that the tempered microstructure does not reveal the sharpness of the lath boundaries of the quenched steel, and the microstructure contains many small, dark particles barely resolvable at 500⫻. The picral etchant that was used darkened the carbides in the tempered steel. During tempering, the carbon that was in solution in the martensite precipitated as carbides. The hardness of the steel shown in Fig. 3.20 is 35 HRC, which is much lower than the 63 HRC hardness of the as-quenched steel.
Goal: Produce a Hardened Surface
Fig. 3.20 Microstructure of tempered lath martensite in an AISI/SAE 8630 steel bar. 2% nital etch. (a) 500⫻ and (b) 1500⫻
Carburizing. In some applications, hardness is only needed at the surface of a part, for example, a gear where only the wear surfaces of the teeth are hardened, or a motor shaft where the surface requires wear resistance and the core requires toughness. An inexpensive way of surface hardening is carburizing, where carbon is allowed to diffuse into the surface of a component that is heated to temperatures between 840 to 955 °C (1550 to 1750 °F). Pack carburizing is a process where the carbon can be provided by “packing” or burying the part in a carbon-rich substance, for example, charcoal. Gas carburizing provides the carbon from a carbon-rich gas, for example, methane (CH4), and liquid carburizing is a process where the part is submerged in a molten salt bath containing a carbon-rich liquid. An example of the microstructure of a carburized surface is shown in Fig. 3.21, which represents the surface of a large AISI/SAE 4340 cast steel gear in the as-received, carburized, and heat treated conditions, respectively. This example is somewhat unique, because the steel is in the as-cast dendritic state, and the diffused carbon produces different microstructures within and outside the dendrites. The starting microstructure (Fig. 3.21a) consists of alternating regions of upper bainite and mixed upper bainite, pearlite, and ferrite. The lower bainite regions represent the dendrites, and the upper bainite/pearlite/ferrite regions repre-
Alteration of Microstructure / 63 sent the interdendritic areas. This is not the normal microstructure for carburizing, due to the segregation in the steel. The carburized microstructure (Fig. 3.21b) consists of alternating regions of pearlite in the dendrites and upper bainite in the interdendritic regions. The gear received a final heat treatment of austenitizing, quenching, and tempering, and the resulting microstructure is martensitic and is shown in Fig. 3.21(c). Even after heat treatment, there is some evidence of the original dendritic structure.
However, the heat treatment has produced a fairly uniform martensitic microstructure that will provide the hardness required at the surface of the gear.
Goal: Produce a More Ductile Cast Iron Malleabilizing. One of the most striking ways of intentionally altering microstructure is the process of producing malleable iron
Fig. 3.21 Microstructure of an AISI/SAE 4340 cast steel gear in the (a) as-cast condition consisting of dendrites of bainite (gray etching constituent) and
interdendritic regions of ferrite (light etching constituent) and pearlite (dark etching constituent), (b) carburized condition with pearlite (dark) and bainite (gray), and (c) quenched and tempered condition with martensite. 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 40⫻
64 / Metallographers’ Guide from white cast iron. As discussed in Chapter 2, white cast iron forms through the eutectic reaction of: Liquid → Cementite ⫹ Austenite
Also, because many cast irons are hypoeutectic, some of the liquid transforms to primary austenite. Both the eutectic austenite and the primary austenite transform at lower temperatures to ferrite plus cementite, or essentially pearlite (adding more cementite to the microstructure). Of course, with rapid cooling, the austenite could transform to martensite and/or bainite. An example of the microstructure of white iron is shown in Fig. 3.22. In this microstructure, the eutectic, called ledeburite, is shown as the region of small globules of pearlite (once austenite) in a matrix of cementite. The primary austenite can be seen as the larger pearlitic regions and associated cementite. The large amount of cementite renders white cast iron very brittle. Although white iron has many uses, early investigators found that through an extended heat treatment, the cementite can decompose into graphite and ferrite. The result is malleable iron. The microstructure of malleable iron can be seen in Fig. 3.23, where most of the carbon that was present in the cementite has formed irregular-shaped graphite particles called “temper carbon.” In this microstructure, the matrix is ferrite, which means that the remaining carbon diffused from the austenite into the temper carbon particles. If carbon diffusion is not fully complete, as in Fig. 3.24, a pearlitic malleable iron is produced. Thus, Fig. 3.24 shows a pearlitic malleable iron with rims of ferrite around the temper carbon in a matrix of pearlite. Because of its appearance, this type of microstructure is called “bull’s-eye” malleable iron. The heat treatment must be closely monitored to avoid incomplete malleabilization where large regions of undis-
Fig. 3.22 Microstructure of a white cast iron. Light etching constituent is
cementite, and the darker etching constituent is pearlite. The small pearlite globules surrounded by cementite in the center of the micrograph are a eutectic called ledeburite. 4% picral etch. 250⫻
sociated cementite still remain. Such a case is shown in Fig. 3.25, where gross cementite pockets (the rounded regions unattacked by the etch) still exist. The heat treatment process involves three important steps: (1) the nucleation of temper carbon during heating to the annealing temperature of 900 to 970 °C (1650 to 1780 °F); (2) the holding at the annealing temperature for an extended time (up to 20 hours, depending upon thickness and composition) to enhance the growth of the temper carbon by the conversion of the carbides to graphite; and (3) cooling as rapidly as practical to 740 to 760 °C (1360 to 1400 °F), a temperature regime below the critical temperature range. At this latter stage, called second-stage malleabilization, the remaining carbon in the austenite diffuses to the temper carbon particles. Manipulation of this second stage can produce a fully ferritic matrix, a fully pearlitic matrix, a ferritepearlite, that is, the bull’s-eye microstructure, or a martensiticpearlitic matrix (produced by quenching after the first-stage anneal). The metallographer must be able to disinguish malleable iron by the appearance of the graphite. The graphite is easily distinguished from the graphite flakes formed in gray cast iron. The irregular-shaped graphite in malleable iron is also distinguished from the rounded graphite nodules of ductile (nodular) iron discussed in the next section. Malleable iron is an extremely important member of the cast iron family because of its desirable mechanical properties. Since the early 1700s, malleable iron has provided the foundryman with a way to produce a nonbrittle form of cast iron that has been used in thousands of applications. Malleable iron is used in many automotive parts, such as transmission gears, connecting rods, steering gear housings, and universal joint yokes, and in those
Fig. 3.23 Microstructure of a malleable iron consisting of “temper carbon,” a form of graphite, in a matrix of ferrite. 2% nital etch.
200⫻
Alteration of Microstructure / 65 parts that require machinability and cold forming. Today, malleable iron is being replaced by nodular or ductile iron (discussed subsequently), because the extended heat treatment is no longer necessary. Inoculation. Another interesting example of intentionally altering the microstructure of a cast iron is the process of inoculation of the liquid iron. Inoculation is a process where a substance
is injected into a liquid bath. As we learned in the previous chapter, cast irons are usually associated with graphite flakes, as in gray cast iron, or cementite, as in white cast iron. By simply inoculating the liquid with magnesium (or cerium), the classic forms of gray and white cast iron are altered during solidification to produce a cast iron with nodules of graphite, as shown in Fig. 3.26. This type of cast iron is known as ductile cast iron or nodular
Fig. 3.24 Microstructure of a malleable iron consisting of “temper car-
Fig. 3.25 Microstructure of a malleable iron with an incomplete mallea-
bon,” a form of graphite, surrounded by ferrite in a matrix of pearlite. 2% nital etch. 200⫻
blization heat treatment. Large, rounded, light etching areas (arrows) are undissolved cementite. 2% nital etch. 500⫻
Fig. 3.26 Microstructure of a ductile iron showing graphite nodules (gray)
Fig. 3.27 Microstructure of a graphite nodule in ductile iron showing the
with rims of ferrite (white) in a matrix of pearlite. 4% picral etch.
100⫻
internal structure of the nodule radiating from the central nucleus. Polarized light. Unetched. 500⫻
66 / Metallographers’ Guide cast iron (the term “ductile iron” is preferred internationally). In the example shown in Fig. 3.26, the nodules are surrounded by a rim of ferrite in a matrix of pearlite. Some people refer to this microstructure as bull’s-eye ductile iron because of its appearance (as described previously for malleable iron). Other important ductile iron microstructures can have a fully ferritic matrix, a fully
pearlitic matrix, a ferritic-pearlitic matrix, a martensitic matrix, or a bainitic matrix. The latter two microstructures are developed through heat treatment. The ferritic and pearlitic microstructures can be formed in the as-cast condition or through heat treatment. At the very center of each nodule is a small particle of a complex magnesium (cerium) compound that provided the nucleation site for the growth of the graphite in the liquid. Figure 3.27 shows the graphite radiating from the central nucleating point. This micrograph was taken with polarized light to show the internal structure of the graphite nodule. The shape of the graphite cannot be altered by heat treatment once it has formed (other than being dissolved at high temperature or enlarged by carbon diffusion from the matrix). However, as mentioned previously, the matrix can be intentionally altered by heat treatment. The mechanical properties of the ductile iron would greatly depend on the type of matrix present. The metallographer must be able to intrepret the microstructure of ductile irons and understand the origin of the microstructure. Ductile iron is very useful for such parts as automotive crankshafts and universal joints, as well as industrial gears and valve and pump bodies.
The Unintentional Alteration of Microstructure in Steels and Cast Irons Quite often, a metallographer is confronted with a situation where the microstructure of a steel or cast iron component has been altered by a process that has gone out of control or by a heat treatment that was incorrectly carried out. Recognition of an unintentionally altered microstructure is an important first step in
Fig. 3.28 Microstructure of an AISI/SAE 1080 steel bloom showing exces-
sive decarburization along (a) the bloom surface and a shallow crack and (b) a magnified view at the crack tip. Note that ferrite has nucleated on the prior austenite grain boundaries. 4% picral etch. (a) 40⫻ and (b) 100⫻
Fig. 3.29 Microstructure of an AISI/SAE 1045 steel billet showing a
decarburized layer of uniform thickness (a zone of complete decarburization) consisting of columnar grains of ferrite. The microstructure below decarburized layer is ferrite and pearlite. 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 32⫻
Alteration of Microstructure / 67 finding a solution to a problem. This section of the chapter illustrates some examples of unintentionally altered microstructures that are fairly common. What caused the altered microstructure is discussed in order to give the metallographer some guidance in problem solving. The types of altered microstructures are broadly classified as being altered by improper heat treatment or as being altered by handling or in service.
Microstructures Altered by Improper Heat Treatment Decarburization is the loss of carbon from the surface of a steel or cast iron component. Many times during heat treatment, the surface of a part loses carbon by a reaction with oxygen
Fig. 3.30 Microstructure of an AISI/SAE 1045 steel billet showing (a) a
large oxidized crack in the decarburized zone and (b) internal oxidation along a small crack (see arrow in a). 2% nital and 4% picral etch. (a) 32⫻ and (b) 500⫻
contained in the heat treating furnace atmosphere (oxygen is present in air, carbon dioxide, and water vapor). Hydrogen can also decarburize steel or cast iron. Just heating a steel or cast iron in air will cause some decarburization. However, detrimental decarburization usually requires an extended time in an oxygenrich atmosphere. For example, excessive decarburization in an AISI/SAE 1080 steel bloom is shown in Fig. 3.28(a). This steel bloom was heated to 1275 °C (2330 °F) in a gas-fired furnace for six hours. Note the high volume fraction of ferrite at the bloom surface and along the surface of the small crack. Also note that the ferrite penetrates deeper into the steel, as shown in the magnified view in Fig. 3.28(b). The ferrite occurs along the prior austenite grain boundaries. Below the grain-boundary ferrite, the microstructure is 100% pearlite. Grain boundaries provide an ideal path for diffusion of oxygen into the steel. In this example, carbon was removed from the bloom surface and crack surface during the six hours at temperature. Upon transformation of the austenite during cooling, ferrite formed in those areas of carbon depletion. This condition of decarburization is not desired, because the surface hardness is much lower than the expected hardness for an AISI/SAE 1080 steel. Most heat treating shops prevent decarburization by heating steels and cast irons in a endothermic gas atmosphere where most of the decarburizing agents, that is, oxygen, have “reacted” before the gas enters the furnace. Another form of decarburization is shown in Fig. 3.29. In this case, hot-rolled AISI/SAE 1045 steel billets were slow cooled
Fig. 3.31 Microstructure of an improperly carbonitrided AISI/SAE 1117
steel shaft showing various layers below the treated surface. The layers “A” through “E” are shown at higher magnification in Fig. 3.32. 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 40⫻
68 / Metallographers’ Guide from the austenite phase region over a period of several days to prevent surface cracking and to remove hydrogen by diffusion (the hydrogen originated in the steelmaking process). As a result of the very slow cooling process, the carbon diffused from the surface in a uniform layer. This condition was due to the slow cooling rate through the austenite-to-ferrite transformation region where accelerated diffusion of carbon occurs. At these temperatures, the diffusion of carbon in ferrite is more rapid than diffusion of carbon in austenite. Also, the incentive for carbon diffusion is greatly increased, because the solubility of carbon in ferrite is very low compared to that in austenite. Thus, there is a high incentive (called
driving force) for carbon to leave. In a sense, the transformation to ferrite controlled the carbon diffusion process, and one can see that columnar ferrite grains formed perpendicular to the surface during this transformation process. At the interface between the equiaxed ferrite/pearlite region and the columnar ferrite surface region, the billet was cooled from a temperature too low for effective diffusion, and the process stopped. As in the case shown in the first example, this condition is not desirable, because the surface hardness will be well below that of an AISI/SAE 1045 steel. The metallographer should have little problem recognizing decarburization in a medium- or high-carbon steel. Many times,
Fig. 3.32 Magnified view of the various layers in the carbonitrided AISI/SAE 1117 steel shaft in Fig. 3.31. (a) Outer layer of retained austenite and plate
martensite (needlelike constituent), (b) a layer of plate martensite and some retained austenite, (c) a layer of fine lath martensite, (d) a layer of coarse lath martensite, and (e) the core of ferrite and pearlite in bright field and (f) in Nomarski (arrows point to epitaxial ferrite). (a), (b), and (c) sodium metabisulfite etch and (d), (e), and (f) 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 800⫻
Alteration of Microstructure / 69 the metallographer is required to measure the depth of decarburization in a steel part. The ASTM standard E 1077 describes the proper procedures. In the case shown previously in Fig. 3.29, the measurement would be fairly easy and would involve measuring the depth of the zone of complete decarburization. However, in the case shown in Fig. 3.28, the measurement is a little more difficult, because it includes the measurement of the partial
decarburization zone into the depth where the proeutectoid ferrite eventually disappears. Internal Oxidation. During heat treatment, exposure of steel or cast iron to an oxygen-rich atmosphere for a long time and at a high temperature can cause oxygen to penetrate austenite grain boundaries and react with carbon and other elements, such as silicon, manganese, and aluminum, that are contained in the steel
Fig. 3.32 (continued) (e) the core of ferrite and pearlite in bright field and (f) in Nomarski (arrows point to epitaxial ferrite). (e) and (f) 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 800⫻
Fig. 3.33 A manganese sulfide stringer (dark gray) appearing as a “pearl
necklace”-type morphology (see long arrow) at a prior austenite grain boundary in a 0.7% C-3% Cr steel forging exposed to 1170 °C (2500 °F) for 1.5 h. Pearlite (the dark etching constituent) has nucleated on the sulfide particles. The matrix is plate martensite (note the microcracks—see stubby arrows). 4% picral and HCl etch. 500⫻
Fig. 3.34 A SEM micrograph of a fracture surface of the 0.7% C-3% Cr steel forging in Fig. 3.33 showing a manganese sulfide dendrite.
2000⫻
70 / Metallographers’ Guide or cast iron. Figure 3.30(a) shows a condition of internal oxidation that occurred when a small surface crack formed on the surface of an AISI/SAE 1045 steel billet that was exposed to an oxygen-rich atmosphere for an extended time at 1260 °C (2300 °F). The enlarged view in Fig. 3.30(b) shows a region of small, spherical particles around an oxidized grain boundary extending from the surface crack. Electron probe microanalysis results reveal that these spherical particles are Si-Mn-Al oxides that formed by oxygen reacting with the silicon, manganese, and aluminum in
the steel. These elements are less noble than iron, that is, they oxidize in preference to iron, because they have a higher affinity for oxygen than iron. (The term “less noble” means that the elements have more negative potential than iron on the electromotive series of elements. These elements will oxidize in the presence of iron. Elements more noble than iron are copper, gold, and platinum.) This condition is called internal oxidation (selective oxidation), because the oxidation process took place
Fig. 3.36 Microstructure of the same steel in Fig. 3.35 showing voids
(rounded, black regions—see arrows) that formed at the junctures of the prior austenite grain boundaries. White-appearing areas at the grain boundaries indicate phosphorus segregation. 4% picral and HCl etch. 100⫻
Fig. 3.35 (a) A manganese sulfide dendritic array in the 0.7% C-3% Cr
forging steel exposed to 1170 °C (2500 °F) for 1.5 h and (b) type II manganese sulfide inclusions in an as-cast ASTM A36 steel slab. Unetched. 1000⫻
Fig. 3.37 A SEM micrograph showing a void in the fracture surface of the steel shown in Fig. 3.36. Note the rounded features.
Alteration of Microstructure / 71 internally in the steel as opposed to surface oxidation where an oxide scale forms. Internal oxidation is commonly found when steel is exposed for extended times to an oxygen-containing atmosphere at temperatures above 1200 °C (2200 °F). Grain boundaries and surface cracks enhance the flow of oxygen from the steel surface to the interior regions. The metallographer should be able to determine if a steel has internal oxidation. In some cases, a composition check by the microprobe may be needed to confirm that the particles contain manganese, silicon, or other elements less noble than iron. If internal oxidation is found, it usually means that a heat treatment process may be out of control, that is, the steel was exposed to an excessive temperature for an extended period of time. Improper Carbonitriding. An example of an improperly carbonitrided surface is shown in Fig. 3.31 which represents a quenched AISI/SAE 1117 steel shaft (this is a resulfurized steel that contains a high density of manganese sulfide inclusions for improved machinability). This steel shaft has been carburized at 955 °C (1750 °F) for 5.5 hours to a carbon potential of 0.80, that is, with a case of 0.80% C, followed by nitriding in ammonia (NH3) for 45 minutes at 845 °C (1550 °F). In this example, the diaphragm on the gas cylinder of the ammonia tank ruptured, causing a much higher concentration of ammonia gas in the furnace for the entire treatment. Because of the excess concentration of ammonia, the steel shaft developed a very high level of nitrogen (along with carbon) at the surface, and retained austenite was produced. The presence of retained austenite means that the nitrogen and carbon content decreased the martensite start (Ms) temperature to a point well below room temperature. In Fig. 3.31, one can see many distinct microstructural zones from the carburized surface inward. The actual outer surface zone consists of retained austenite, appearing as the white nonetching constituent in Fig. 3.32(a). The retained austenite has a hardness of 298 HK (Knoop). There are also many voids that developed on the austenite grain boundaries. These voids are the result of excess molecular nitrogen (N2) that formed as gas pockets at the austenite grain boundaries. The next layer consists of retained austenite and plate martensite, with a hardness of 640 HK (also shown in Fig. 3.32b). The plate martensite appears as the dark, needlelike constituent in this figure. The next inner zone consists of fine lath martensite (Fig. 3.32c), with a hardness of 742 HK. The next layer consists of coarser lath martensite (Fig. 3.32d), with a hardness of 511 HK. The core consists of ferrite and pearlite (Fig. 3.32e), with a hardness of 192 HK. An interesting feature of the core microstructure, shown in Fig. 3.32(e) is the evidence of epitaxial ferrite (discussed previously), as revealed by differential interference contrast (Nomarski) in Fig. 3.32(f) (see arrows). This indicates that the shaft was exposed for a period of time to temperatures within the intercritical region. From the previously mentioned hardness values, it is obvious that the surface is far too soft, due to the presence of retained austenite. Although stresses in service may transform the surface austenite to martensite, this is evidence of a very poor carbonitriding practice. This process is not aimed at producing retained austenite at the surface. If the amount of austenite is in excess of 50%, not only will the hardness be lower, but the bending fatigue
resistance will be significantly lowered. The skilled metallographer should be able to identify the retained austenite in a carburized part and make recommendations about the carburizing heat treatment. Many times, a simple microhardness measurement is all that is needed, as shown previously. However, if further confirmation is required, x-ray diffraction can easily detect the presence of retained austenite. Exposure to Excessively High Temperatures. On occasion, steels are heated to temperatures that are too high, and the result can be very deleterious to mechanical properties. The terms that are used to describe the condition of a steel that has been exposed to excessive temperatures are “overheating” and “burning.” These are rather subjective terms, but they are widely used in industry. In this section, we consider overheating and burning as simply different degrees of exposure to high temperature; overheating is essentially the first stage of microstructural alteration, and burning is the second, more severe, irreversible stage. In normal heat treating operations where standard practices and procedures are followed, the steel will not become damaged. However, if there is an accidental temperature excursion in the heat treating furnace, the steel could be affected. Also, in forging operations where alloy steels are heated to rather high temperatures, that is, above 1315 °C (2400 °F), there is a danger of overheating/burning taking place. If overheating takes place, the steel may be salvaged by an additional low-temperature heat treatment. However, if burning takes place, it is not reversible, and the steel must be scrapped. When a steel has experienced overheating/burning, there are important microstructural changes that have occurred, which, in a way, leave classic internal markers or identifiers for the metallographer to recognize. The example that we use, a 0.7% C-3% Cr steel forging heated to 1315 and 1370 °C (2400 and 2500 °F) for 1.5 hours, will have these identifiers. These include manganese sulfide dissolution, segregation at austenite grain boundaries, incipient melting of lower-melting constituents, and voids that form at grain-boundary junctions (triple points). Instead of attempting to distinguish between overheating and burning, we examine the previously mentioned alterations of microstructure. First of all, it is important to understand what happens when a steel is exposed to excessively high temperatures. In nearly all cases, the material at and near the austenite grain boundaries is affected; for example, manganese sulfides change morphology, and phosphorus segregates to the grain boundaries. For example, the exposure to high temperature causes manganese sulfide stringers to dissolve in the austenite. During the initial stage of exposure, the manganese sulfide stringers appear to break up into a “pearl neckace”-type morphology, seen in Fig. 3.33. This breakup is usually associated with the manganese sulfide stringer dissolving in the surrounding austenite. However, is this really what happened? When viewed in three-dimensions, this may not be the case. For example, when the sample is fractured and examined in the scanning electron microscope (SEM), one can see dendrites of manganese sulfides, an example of which is shown in Fig. 3.34. In this SEM micrograph, there is a primary dendrite arm (the main stem aligned left-to-right in the micrograph), with a number of secondary arms aligned perpendicular to the primary arm. If the metallographer happened to section the specimen through the secondary arms, the resulting microstructure would
72 / Metallographers’ Guide reveal a necklace-type morphology, shown in Fig. 3.33. Thus, the metallographer can sometimes be deceived by examining only one plane of a given sample. The dendrites can occur when regions at and around the austenite boundaries melt as a result of the excessive temperature. The melting takes place because these regions contain a higher level of alloy concentration and lowermelting constituents, such as manganese sulfide. This incipient melting process is called liquation. These regions were the locations of the last liquid to solidify during the initial solidification process, for example, during continuous casting. Once melting has taken place, the manganese sulfides can solidify upon cooling, as the dendritic morphology shown in Fig. 3.34. Also in Fig. 3.33, the manganese sulfide particles have nucleated pearlite (dark etching constituent), and the plate martensite matrix (gray etching constituent) contains microcracks (see arrows). Microcracks, which form when two or more martensite plates strike each other during transformation, are discussed in an upcoming section. These latter microstructural changes are not necessarily the result of the excessive temperature, because these changes can also occur during normal heat treatment. Another view of a possible manganese sulfide dendritic array can be seen in Fig. 3.35(a) for the same 0.7% C-3% Cr steel. There is similarity between these manganese sulfide dendrites formed during liquation and subsequent solidification, and eutectic manganese sulfide colonies (called type II sulfide inclusions) that form during solidification of a steel casting. For example, the manganese sulfide inclusions in Fig. 3.35(b) represent type II sulfides that formed in a continuous-cast ASTM A36 steel slab. In this case, the last liquid to freeze contained a higher concentration of manganese and sulfur, and the liquid solidified as a eutectic of manganese sulfide and iron. In a continuous-cast slab, this morphology will be altered into stringer-type inclusions during the hot-rolling process. However, in the case of the steel forging described previously, the manganese sulfide colonies are in their final form and will not be further altered by hot deformation. Thus, this morphology, which is deleterious to mechanical properties (particularly notch toughness and fatigue), will render the steel forging useless, and it must be scrapped. This condition is usually associated with the term “burned steel.” Another deleterious burned condition created by excessively high temperatures is shown in Fig. 3.36, where voids have formed at grain-boundary junctions (triple points) in the previously mentioned forging steel heated to 1370 °C (2500 °F). In this micrograph, there are four voids that can be identified by their rounded features (see arrows indicating two of the larger voids). When examined in the SEM, the rounded features become more evident, as shown in Fig. 3.37. This irreversible condition was created by localized melting that resulted in shrinkage porosity or entrapped hydrogen gas. This condition is unacceptable, and the part must be scrapped. A more subtle microstructural alteration that occurs during excessive heating is caused by sulfur and phosphorus segregation at the austenite grain boundaries. The white-appearing grain boundaries in Fig. 3.36 would indicate segregation. An example of grain-boundary segregation is shown at higher magnification in Fig. 3.38. Sometimes this condition is difficult to detect in the light microscope, and special etching procedures may have to be
used to reveal the segregation. However, these etching techniques are, at times, unreliable. Here, the SEM can be useful. The fracture surface of a steel with phosphorus or sulfur segregation will reveal intergranular austenite grain surfaces similar to those found in temper embrittlement (described in an upcoming section). A simple heat treatment can eliminate the segregation. Hot shortness is a term used to describe grain-boundary separation that can create a rough surface condition in hot-rolled and forged steel. In many cases, hot shortness results in surface cracks that do not heal during the hot-rolling process. Internal grain-boundary separations can also be created from low-meltingpoint inclusions. Hot shortness is caused when impurities or residual elements in the steel are liquid at hot-rolling temperatures. Two common examples of hot shortness are caused by copper, which is molten above 910 °C (1670 °F), and iron sulfide, FeS, which is molten above 1190 °C (2170 °F). Copper enters the steelmaking process through scrap and thus is a potential problem in electric furnace steelmaking operations. The copper from the scrap cannot be removed in the steelmaking process and thus is carried through into the final product. Many ASTM specifications limit residual copper to 0.40%. Even at this level, problems of hot shortness can exist. The mechanism for hot shortness caused by copper starts in the formation of oxide scale on the steel surface. Scale forms during continuous casting and during reheating in soaking pits and reheat furnaces. Because copper is more noble than iron on the electromotive series, it cannot be oxidized in the presence of iron. Therefore, as the scale grows on the steel surface, the copper remains behind and accumulates at the scale/steel interface. Many times, the copper will alloy with other noble elements, such as nickel, tin, arsenic, and antimony. All these elements are impurities in the steel (although in some steels, nickel may be added as an alloying element). The liquid alloy has a tendency to penetrate grain boundaries that are exposed at the scale/steel interface. Because the alloy is molten at rolling temperatures, the grain boundaries easily separate to form surface cracks, allowing more scale to form in the crack. In steels that contain copper as an alloying element, for example, ASTM A710, nickel is added in quantities at least 50% of the copper content to prevent hot shortness. The nickel increases the melting point of the copper, and the copper-nickel alloy that forms becomes part of the scale during scale growth. Thus, when the steel is hot rolled, the copper-nickel alloy is removed along with the scale. Figure 3.39 shows surface cracks on an AISI/SAE 1035 steel bloom that were caused by an excessive copper level in the steel. This form of hot shortness can be controlled by lowering the copper content of the steel, that is, using a scrap charge that is lower in copper. In the light microscope, the copper can be seen in its elemental form as reddish “fingers” extending along grain boundaries, as shown in Fig. 3.40. In this micrograph, one can see also a few of the copper droplets at the scale/steel interface. Many times, to identify the copper at the scale/steel interface, the electron probe microanalyzer can be used to provide x-ray maps of the copper concentration. The second source of hot shortness is due to the presence of iron sulfides. Iron sulfides can develop in a steel if the manganese level is insufficient to combine with all the sulfur present in the steel. Historically, one of the main reasons for adding manganese to
Alteration of Microstructure / 73 steel was to combine with sulfur in the form of manganese sulfide, MnS, to prevent hot shortness. Without sufficient manganese, the sulfur would combine with the iron and create iron sulfides. Iron sulfide has a much lower melting point than manganese sulfide and thus remains liquid at rolling temperatures. Also, iron sulfides are more brittle than manganese sulfides and degrade the mechanical properties of the steel. Manganese sulfides, on the other hand, are easily deformed at rolling temperatures and are not as deleterious to mechanical properties.
Internal hot shortness can be created by the presence of iron sulfides. Iron sulfides have a lighter gray appearance than manganese sulfides, as shown in Fig. 3.41. In this micrograph, taken from a normal AISI/SAE 1015 steel casting, the iron sulfide constituent surrounds a manganese sulfide particle. The dove gray color of a normal manganese sulfide inclusion can be seen in Fig. 3.42 for comparison. In Fig. 3.41, small cracks can be seen in the brittle iron sulfide rim, and the rim has separated from the steel matrix. The iron sulfide has formed around (nucleated on) the manganese sulfide, because it was liquid when the manganese sulfide was solid during the solidification process. Upon heating to
Fig. 3.38 Microstructure of segregation along a prior austenite grain
Fig. 3.39 Macrograph of an AISI/SAE 1035 steel showing surface cracking
boundary in the 0.7% C-3% Cr steel shown in Fig. 3.36. 1000⫻
due to a hot-shortness condition caused by copper. 2⫻
Fig. 3.40 Microstructure of the steel shown in Fig. 3.39 with elemental
copper along grain boundaries (see arrow). This is a condition known as hot shortness. Note: the micrograph is out of focus, because the ferrite matrix was chemically attacked by the etch, thus leaving the focused copper in relief. 2% nital etch. 500⫻
Fig. 3.41 Microstructure of an AISI/SAE 1015 casting showing iron sulfide surrounding a manganese sulfide inclusion. Unetched. 2000⫻
74 / Metallographers’ Guide hot-rolling temperatures, the iron sulfide would remelt and create an internal flaw. This condition can lead to internal cracking. Because they are undesirable in steel, a metallographer must be able to identify iron sulfides. However, with modern steelmaking technology, it is quite rare to see iron sulfides in steel. Sensitization. Stainless steels rely on their chromium content to prevent corrosion. Generally, about 12% Cr is needed for this task. One example of unintentional microstructural alteration that
Fig. 3.42 Microstructure of an AISI/SAE 1020 cast bloom with a normal
manganese sulfide inclusion. Note the color difference of iron sulfide in Fig. 3.41. Unetched. 1000⫻
Fig. 3.43 Microstructure of an AISI/SAE 316 stainless steel showing
sensitization. Note the chromium carbides at the austenite grain boundaries. The steel was exposed to 675 °C (1250 °F) for 12 days. HCl/HNO3/H2O etch. 1000⫻
has serious consequences for a stainless steel is the result of exposure to temperatures in the range of 425 to 870 °C (800 to 1600 °F). During exposure, chromium carbides form at the grain boundaries and deplete the regions near the boundaries of chromium. The longer the exposure, the greater the depletion of chromium, until eventually the level drops below 12% locally, and corrosion along grain boundaries can result. The process of chromium loss is called sensitization. An example of sensitization in an AISI 316 austenitic stainless steel sheet is shown in Fig. 3.43. In this micrograph, the austenite grain boundaries are “decorated” with chromium-rich carbides (Cr,Fe)23C6. This stainless steel sheet was exposed to 675 °C (1250 °F) for 12 days. A more severe example of sensitization is shown in Fig. 3.44, where the same AISI 316 stainless steel sheet was exposed to 730 °C (1350 °F) for two months. Here, the chromium carbides have precipitated on annealing twins in addition to the austenite grain boundaries. Because of the long-term exposure, large chromium carbides have also formed. The metallographer must be aware of the possibility of a sensitized condition in a stainless steel that has been exposed to an elevated temperature. In the early stages, it is very difficult to detect the carbides at the grain boundaries, and careful observation at high magnification is required. It is important to know that the condition of sensitization can be eliminated by another heat treatment at temperatures above 870 °C (1600 °F), where all the carbides dissolve in the austenite. A typical treatment is heating a sensitized stainless steel to 980 °C (1800 °F) for four hours, followed by rapid cooling. Temper Embrittlement. If an alloy steel is slow cooled from above 595 °C (1100 °F), it may become embrittled. The specific embrittlement temperature range is about 375 to 575 °C (710 to 1070 °F). Indications of embrittlement are evident in the Charpy
Fig. 3.44 Microstructure of an AISI 316 stainless steel showing severe
sensitization. Exposed to 730 °C (1350 °F) for two months. HCl/HNO3/H2O etch. 1000⫻
Alteration of Microstructure / 75 V-notch impact test, where very low values of toughness are recorded. The embrittlement takes place at the austenite grain boundaries. Phosphorus segregation to the austenite grain boundaries is usually attributed as the cause of the problem. An easy way to detect temper embrittlement is to observe the fracture surface of a broken Charpy bar or other fractured surface in the SEM. An example of such a fracture surface can be seen in Fig.
Fig. 3.45 A SEM micrograph of the fracture surface of a 3% Cr steel
showing intergranular fracture, indicating a condition of temper embrittlement. 500⫻
Fig. 3.47 Microstructure of an AISI/SAE 1080 steel showing a microcrack
at the center of the micrograph (see arrow) in a martensite plate. 12% sodium metabisulfite tint etch. 1000⫻
3.45. This example is a 3% Cr steel. Many of the austenitic grain boundaries can be seen as the flat, faceted surfaces in the SEM micrograph. This type of fracture is called intergranular fracture. In this case, phosphorus has accumulated on the austenite grain boundaries and created a weakness in the bond between the austenite grains. In most chromium-bearing steels, an addition of 0.5 to 1.0% Mo is sufficient to eliminate the problem. The
Fig. 3.46 Microstructure of a 1.4% C steel showing numerous micro-
cracks (dark lines) in the martensite plates. The white-appearing constituent is retained austenite. 12% sodium metabisulfite tint etch. 500⫻
Fig. 3.48 Microstructure of a cold-drawn and spheroidized AISI/SAE 1095
steel bar showing regions of graphite (elongated, dark bands). 4% picral etch. 1000⫻. Courtesy of S. Lawrence, Bethlehem Steel’s Homer Research Center
76 / Metallographers’ Guide molybdenum changes the activity of phosphorus in the steel (austenite) and minimizes its ability to segregate to the grain boundaries. Microcrack Formation. When higher-carbon steels (above about 0.6% C) are rapidly cooled from the austenitic state, plate martensite can form. Plate martensite differs from the lath martensite that forms in lower-carbon steels. The differences have been described in Chapter 2. One problem with plate martensite is that it is very brittle. When two or more martensite plates strike
each other during transformation, the plates can crack at the point of impingement. The result is a microcrack. An example of numerous microcracks that have formed in a 1.4% C steel is shown in Fig. 3.46. In this micrograph, one can see the small cracks in the martensite plates. These cracks can grow to larger cracks when a component with microcracks is used in service, especially under a cyclic loading environment. Cyclic loading will eventually lead to a fatigue failure. A microcrack can also be seen in Fig. 3.47, representing both lath and plate martensite in a
Fig. 3.49 Microstructure of a 1.2% C steel that has formed graphite (dark etching constituent), or “graphitized,” after exposure to 700 °C (1290 °F) for (a) 190, (b) 375, and (c) 565 h. 4% picral etch. 500⫻. Courtesy of B. Lindsay and A.R. Marder, Lehigh University
Alteration of Microstructure / 77 quenched AISI/SAE 1080 steel rod containing centerline segregation (a region of higher hardenability enhancing the formation of martensite). In this figure, the few martensite plates can be seen (arrows). Whenever a metallographer observes plate martensite in a microstructure, he or she should carefully look for microcracks, because their presence will be an important indication of a potential problem. If microcracks form, the part may have to be scrapped. It is possible that a component with microcracks can be salvaged by annealing for an extended period of time to allow healing of the cracks. This treatment, however, does not always work. Graphitization of Steel. It is obvious that cast irons contain free graphite. However, it is also possible for a steel to contain graphite. An example of graphite formation in steel is shown in Fig. 3.48, where the graphite is shown as dark, elongated particles. This steel is AISI/SAE 1095 that has been annealed, hot rolled, and spheroidized. However, the spheroidization treatment was extended too long, and the cementite (Fe3C) phase decomposed to pure carbon (graphite) and iron. This graphitization process occurs when a steel is held for long times at temperatures just below the lower critical temperature (A1). The optimal temperature range for graphitization is between 600 and 700 °C (1110 and 1290 °F). Graphitization can also occur in steam power plant components that are exposed to elevated temperatures for extended periods of time. Graphitization is not desirable, because the regions of graphite are very soft and provide locations of weakness within the steel. The development of graphite in a 1.2% C steel is shown in Fig. 3.49. This steel was given a spheroidizing heat treatment at 700 °C (1290 °F) for 190, 375, and 565 hours. At 190 hours (Fig. 3.49a), very small regions of graphite begin to form on cementite
Fig. 3.50 Microstructure of a 1.2% C steel that was graphitized after
exposure to 700 °C (1290 °F) for 190 h, then heat treated at 980 °C (1800 °F) to dissolve the graphite. Note void (dark region) in center of micrograph. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
particles. At 375 hours (Fig. 3.49b), more graphite forms, replacing some of the cementite particles, and at 565 hours (Fig. 3.49c), all the cementite particles have decomposed into graphite. This latter treatment is unusually long, but illustrates the graphitization process. The only way to remove graphitization is to retreat the steel in the austenite regime to dissolve the graphite and to redistribute the carbon uniformly in the steel. From the iron-carbon equilibrium diagram shown in Fig. 3.2, one can see that carbon is very soluble in austenite. Once the graphite dissolves in the austenite, the steel can be cooled to room temperature. Figure 3.50 shows the result of reversing the graphitization process by reheating the 1.2% C steel at 980 °C (1800 °F) for two hours. The dark, rounded region in the center is a void. One of the results of dissolving the graphite into austenite is the development of voids, because of differences in specific volume between graphite and austenite.
Microstructures Altered during Cutting/Machining Many times, the microstructure of a steel or cast iron is unintentionally altered during a cutting operation using an oxygen-acetylene torch. The microstructural alteration could be detrimental. This section shows examples of how a microstructure can be altered simply by cutting the steel. Improper Cutting. Many steel products are cut to a specific size or length by an oxygen-acetylene or plasma-arc cutting torch. However, this practice may not always be the best procedure. Let’s look at an example of a plasma-arc-cut steel plate. Figure 3.51 shows the microstructure at the cut surface of an AISI/SAE 1020 steel plate. The dark surface region is 100% lath martensite, as shown in Fig. 3.52(a). Adjacent to the lath martensite surface
Fig. 3.51 Microstructure of a plasma-arc-cut surface of an as-rolled
AISI/SAE 1020 steel plate showing surface damage (top). Regions “A”, “B”, “C” are shown at higher magnification in Fig. 3.52. 2% nital and 4% picral etch. 100⫻
78 / Metallographers’ Guide region is a region of lath martensite and ferrite, as shown in Fig. 3.52(b). The base microstructure is shown in Fig. 3.52(c). The lath martensite layer has a hardness of 349 HK (35 HRC), whereas the base steel has a hardness of 165 HK (80 HRB). This hard layer at the surface may cause problems in machining the material. Residual stresses will also develop, because of the formation of a martensitic layer in a ferritic-pearlitic component. These stresses and the higher hardness level can be reduced by a stress-relief heat treatment. In a higher-carbon steel, the martensite would be in the form of plate martensite, which would have a tendency to form
microcracks during transformation (as shown in a previous section on microcracks). Microcracks form when martensite plates impinge on one another. This condition would be unacceptable, because the microcracks would create larger cracks during service. Improper Machining. Machining can induce cold work into the surface layers of a part. An example is shown in Fig. 3.53(a), which represents the surface layer of a 13 mm (0.5 in.) diameter bar of AISI 316 stainless steel. The surface layer consists of a high density of mechanical twins that were induced during machining.
Fig. 3.52 Microstructure of the affected layers in the plasma-torch-cut AISI/SAE 1020 steel plate in Fig. 3.51 showing (a) lath martensite at the surface, (b) lath martensite and ferrite just below the surface, and (c) ferrite and pearlite of the base steel. 4% picral etch. 500⫻
Alteration of Microstructure / 79 The microstructure at the center of the bar is shown in Fig. 3.53(b). Here, the microstructure contains only a few twins. In an effort to remove the mechanical twins at the surface layers, the bar was heat treated at 800 °C (1470 °F) for 0.5 hours. Unfortunately, the mechanical twins were not removed, and the bar was inadvertently sensitized, as shown in the high-magnification micrograph in Fig. 3.54. Sensitization was discussed in the section “Microstructures Altered by Improper Heat Treatment.” In this micrograph, one can see carbides that formed at the grain boundaries and twins. A very high magnification in the light
microscope was necessary to reveal this sensitized condition. This is a caution to the metallographer who could miss the subtle features if only a cursory examination is used. This is a unique sample in that not only is the surface cold worked, but the remaining bar is sensitized. The only way to salvage this material would be to anneal the steel to remove both the cold work and the sensitized condition.
Microstructures Altered under Service Conditions In many cases, the original microstructure is altered in service. When steels and cast irons are exposed to high temperatures, oxidation and corrosion processes produce microstructural changes that can adversely affect the properties of the material. Also, deformation and friction can create high temperatures in steel. These temperatures can alter microstructure. The metallographer must be aware of the effects of these service conditions on microstructure. A few examples are given in this section to illustrate some of these changes. Friction Effects. A metallographer examining a specimen taken from a railway track should expect to find a fully pearlitic microstructure. However, sometimes the pearlitic microstructure is unintentionally altered in an unusual manner in service. For example, the running surface of a rail (the surface in contact with the railway wheel) can be heated into the austenitic range by the friction of a seized or slipping locomotive wheel rubbing along the rail surface. This can take place during slippage, where the locomotive wheels are turning, but the train does not move. Also, severe friction could occur if the locomotive wheel is stationary during emergency breaking, with the wheels sliding along the track. The surface damage to the rail is termed a “wheel burn.”
Fig. 3.53 Microstructure of a machined AISI 316 stainless steel bar
showing (a) deformation bands at the surface and (b) annealing twins at the center. Electrolytic etch of 10% oxalic acid in water, stainless steel cathode, 6V, 10 s. 200⫻
Fig. 3.54 A sensitized condition found in the central region of the AISI
316 stainless steel bar in Fig. 3.53. Note the carbides on the grain boundaries and annealing twins. Electrolytic etch of 10% oxalic acid in water, stainless steel cathode, 6V, 10 s. 1500⫻
80 / Metallographers’ Guide Upon cooling from the austenitic field, the microstructure that forms is not pearlite, because the cooling rate is very high due to the self-quenching effect of the underlying steel. Martensite and bainite layers form from the austenite. There is also retained austenite contained within the martensite layer. An example of a wheel burn is shown in Fig. 3.55. At this low magnification, the microstructural constituents are not resolved, but one can see a shallow, nonetching white layer at the surface, several surface cracks due to the thermal stresses, and a dark layer followed by a light etching layer and a gray layer. The thin white layer and a portion of the dark etching layer are shown in Fig. 3.56(a). The white layer has been the focus of many metallurgical investigations, and its identity is controversial. It is usually considered as martensite. In some cases, it may be highly deformed ferrite. In the example shown in Fig. 3.56, the white layer is martensite. The dark etching layer in Fig. 3.56(a) and the region just below is tempered martensite, as shown in Fig. 3.56(b). The light etching regions within the martensite are retained austenite. The light etching region below the tempered martensite is as-quenched martensite and mixtures of as-quenched martensite and pearlite, as seen in Fig. 3.56(c). The dark etching constituent is the base pearlitic microstructure (see Fig. 3.56d). This example shows the
Fig. 3.55 Microstructure of a “wheel burn” condition on a railroad rail
(eutectoid steel) showing the surface “white layer” and other layers. These layers are shown at higher magnification in Fig. 3.56. 2% nital etch. 32⫻
metallographer the complexity of microstructures that can develop within one sample. This is why it is important to understand the origin of microstructures in steels and cast irons. This basic understanding is vital to metallographic interpretation. The previous example is a case where the light microscope has reached the limit of resolving power, and an electron microscope is necessary to add to the interpretation through higher magnification and resolving power. Void Formation during Creep. When steel and cast iron components are exposed to a stress or load for a long period of time at an elevated temperature, a process known as “creep” can take place. Generally, the stress is well below the normal yield strength of the material. Metal flow takes place by mechanisms related to grain-boundary sliding and void formation at grain boundaries. An example of the beginning of the creep process is shown in Fig. 3.57. The alloy is a 0.28% C, 2.5% Ni, 1 % Cr, 1% Mo steel that was held at 565 °C (1050 °F) under a stress of 210 MPa (30 ksi). Voids can be seen nucleating and growing at grain boundaries in Fig. 3.57(a). In Fig. 3.57(b), the voids begin to link up, and in Fig. 3.57(c), they form separations along grain boundaries. Once this grain-boundary separation occurs, the material will begin to fail at an accelerated rate. Under these conditions, it took about 5000 hours to develop the stage of extensive grain-boundary separation. Creep occurs in parts such as rotors in steam-powered generators and in the blades of aircraft gas turbine engines. Once in the final stages of creep, the parts are prone to fail in a catastrophic manner. Special techniques are used to monitor the life of parts that are exposed to environments that promote creep. One of these techniques is field metallography, where a small area of the part is polished and etched while the part is still in service. Field metallography is used when the part or a sample cannot be brought to the metallographic laboratory. Hydrogen Damage. Damage due to hydrogen gas can occur under many circumstances. Hydrogen can be picked up in steels through the steelmaking process where the liquid steel is exposed to moisture from the furnace/ladle/tundish refractories, from exposure to humidity in the air, and from moisture in alloying additions. Also, in cast steels and cast irons, sand binders and cores containing hydrocarbons can break down to form hydrogen gas upon exposure to molten steel and cast iron. Hydrogen can also be absorbed into steel by exposure to acids and electrolytic plating processes. Hydrogen can also enter a weld from moistureladen electrodes. Thus, hydrogen can come from many sources, and if hydrogen damage is found in a steel, the metallographer may have to find clues to determine the source of hydrogen. Hydrogen, being the smallest element, is easily absorbed in the iron lattice as elemental hydrogen (H⫹). To eliminate this form of hydrogen, it can be easily diffused from the steel under controlled conditions, for example, vacuum degassing of liquid steel and slow cooling from an elevated temperature, for example, 540 °C (1000 °F), immediately after rolling or forging (not allowing the component to cool to room temperature first). However, when the hydrogen atoms combine into the molecular form (H2), diffusion is almost impossible, and hydrogen is thus trapped inside the steel. Once inside the steel, hydrogen prefers to reside at a surface such as an inclusion interface, for example, a manganese sulfide. At
Alteration of Microstructure / 81
Fig. 3.56 Microstructure of the various layers of the rail steel in Fig. 3.55. (a) The white layer at the surface (unattacked by the etchant), (b) tempered plate martensite, (c) as-quenched plate martensite and pearlite (dark), and (d) pearlite base microstructure. 4% picral etch. 1000⫻
82 / Metallographers’ Guide these sites, sufficient hydrogen gas pressure can create a separation at the steel/inclusion interface. As the component is stressed, the separation can extend into a crack. Hydrogen “flakes” or cracks form in this manner. An example of hydrogen flakes in an AISI/SAE 1080 steel bar is shown in Fig. 3.58. From these micrographs, it is evident that hydrogen cracks can more easily be detected in a sample in the unetched condition (Fig. 3.58a) than in the etched condition (Fig. 3.58b). Many times, the etched micro-
structure can obscure the cracks, because there are so many other features present. Also, differential interference contrast (Nomarski) can be very helpful in locating cracks. Note the vast improvement in the same AISI/SAE 1080 steel shown in both bright-field (Fig. 3.59a) and differential interference contrast (Fig. 3.59b). One way to detect hydrogen damage is in the fracture appearance of through-thickness tensile specimens. If hydrogen flakes are present, “fisheyes” appear on the fracture
Fig. 3.57 Microstructure of a Ni-Cr-Mo steel held at 565 °C (1050 °F) under a load of 210 MPa (30 ksi), showing (a) initial void formation at the austenite grain boundaries, (b) void linkup, and (c) separation of an austenite grain boundary. 4% picral and HCl etch. 500⫻
Alteration of Microstructure / 83 surface. Fisheyes are shiny, rounded regions that have developed by internal cracks caused by hydrogen damage. These regions were there before the tensile fracture took place. An unusual example of a decarburized region surrounding a hydrogen flake in an AISI/SAE 1080 steel can be seen in Fig. 3.60. In this case, the component was heat treated after the hydrogen crack formed. Here, exposure to 870 °C (1600 °F) for five hours allowed the hydrogen gas to react with the carbon in the steel to form methane gas (CH4). The result was carbon depletion
(decarburization) along the crack surface, seen as the white nonetching constituent in Fig. 3.60. An example of severe hydrogen damage is shown in Fig. 3.61(a), representing an ASTM A516 steel plate. In this micrograph, one can see cracks that developed by grain-boundary separation along the banded regions. Usually these cracks are not noticed until the part is in service, where it is exposed to some kind of stress, that is, thermal or mechanical stress. Under continued stress, the part usually fails as the crack or cracks grow
Fig. 3.58 Hydrogen flakes (cracks—see arrows) found in an AISI/SAE
Fig. 3.59 Another example of a hydrogen flake (crack) in an AISI/SAE
1080 steel bar in the (a) unetched and (b) etched condition. 4% picral etch. 1000⫻
1080 bar showing (a) the crack in bright-field illumination and (b) in differential interference contrast (Nomarski). Unetched. 1000⫻
84 / Metallographers’ Guide in length. Also, as atomic hydrogen diffuses into the steel, it forms molecular hydrogen that cannot leave, because in its molecular state, the diffusivity is extremely low. As hydrogen diffusion continues, the molecular hydrogen begins to form gas pockets that are under very high pressure. In the previous example, one can see in the the enlarged view of Fig. 3.61(b) that the gas pressure actually expanded the cracks and plastically deformed the regions between cracks (note the bending of the ferrite/pearlite bands between the two expanded cracks). Once a hydrogen-related crack forms, the process is irreversible, and the part must be taken out of service before catastrophic failure occurs. Another form of hydrogen damage can occur in service from electrochemical corrosion reactions. Such a reaction can occur in steel boiler tubes exposed to high temperature and high-pressure steam. Water can react with iron at high temperature to create atomic hydrogen (as opposed to molecular hydrogen, H2) and iron oxide. The atomic hydrogen can easily diffuse into the steel boiler tube and cause damage. One form of damage occurs when hydrogen can combine with the carbides (cementite) in the steel to form methane gas, CH4, which can cause internal grain-boundary separation similar to the hydrogen flakes described previously. An example of this type of damage is illustrated in a SA 210 boiler tube exposed for hundreds of hours to superheated steam at 360 °C (675 °F) under a pressure of 18 MPa (2.6 ksi). Figure 3.62(a) shows the microstructure of the boiler tube in its original condition, and Fig. 3.62(b) shows the result of the methane damage. The damage is in the form of grain-boundary separation created by the increased pressure developed by the reaction of hydrogen with cementite. The methane gas is in molecular form, and the molecules are too big to easily diffuse in the steel. Note
the dissolution of the pearlite colonies adjacent to the cracks caused by the reaction of the hydrogen with the iron carbide. Once grain-boundary separation occurs, the strength of the tube will decrease, and the tube will eventually fail. Corrosion Effects. Corrosion is generally thought to affect only the outer surface layer of a part. This is not always the case. For example, as in the case of a gray cast iron, corrosion can penetrate into the interior of a component, for example, an underground water pipe, due to the connectivity of the graphite flakes. An
Fig. 3.60 An internal hydrogen flake (crack) in an AISI/SAE 1080 steel bar
that was exposed to a temperature of 870 °C (1600 °F) for 5 h. The crack surface was decarburized (white area surrounding crack) by the reaction of the hydrogen with the carbon in the steel. Pearlite matrix. 4% picral etch. 1500⫻
Fig. 3.61 Microstructure of an as-rolled ASTM A516 steel plate showing
hydrogen flakes along the pearlite bands. 2% nital and 4% picral etch. (a) 50⫻ and (b) 400⫻
Alteration of Microstructure / 85 example is shown in Fig. 3.63(a). Here, corrosion products can be found surrounding the flake graphite and graphitic cells (a cell is a connected network of graphite flakes). Figure 3.63(b) shows the corrosion product and graphite flakes at higher magnification. The penetration of corrosion, in a way, proves that the graphite flakes are interconnected.
Corrosion engineers often call this type of corrosion “graphitization,” which, to a metallurgist, is obviously incorrect, because the graphite was present before the corrosion took place. What has happened in this case is selective leaching of the iron matrix around the graphite flakes. In very severe cases, the entire outer skin of the corroded pipe or component is graphite, with all the
Fig. 3.62 Microstructure of an ASME SA 210 steel tube consisting of (a) ferrite (light etching constituent) and pearlite (dark etching constituent) and (b) a hydrogen-damaged region showing cracks (arrows) at the pearlite/ferrite interfaces. 4% picral etch. 1000⫻
Fig. 3.63 Microstructure of a gray cast iron water pipe with corrosion penetrating below the surface along graphite flake networks (cells) (see arrows). (a) unetched, 50⫻ and (b) 4% picral etch, 500⫻
86 / Metallographers’ Guide iron leached from the surface. From a corrosion viewpoint, the graphite and iron act as a galvanic cell, where the graphite is the cathode and the iron is the anode. Because of the galvanic action, corrosion is enhanced next to the graphite flakes. In a previous section in this chapter, the term “graphitization” has been shown to be the formation of graphite during a long-term exposure of a carbon steel to temperatures between 315 and 370 °C (600 and 700 °F). SELECTED REFERENCES •
Atlas of Microstructures of Industrial Alloys, Vol 7, Metals Handbook, 8th ed., American Society for Metals, 1972
• • • •
• •
The Heat Treaters Guide—Standard Practices and Procedures for Steel, American Society for Metals, 1982 Heat Treating, Vol 4, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1991 G. Krauss, Principles of Heat Treatment, 2nd ed., ASM International, 1993 Properties and Selection: Irons, Steels, and High-Performance Alloys, Vol 1, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1990 L.E. Samuels, Optical Microscopy of Carbon Steels, American Society for Metals, 1980 H. Thielsch, Defects and Failures in Pressure Vessels and Piping, Reinhold Publishing, 1965
Metallographer's Guide: Practices and Procedures for Irons and Steels Bruce L. Bramfitt, Arlan O. Benscoter, p87-107 DOI:10.1361/mgpp2002p087
Copyright © 2002 ASM International® All rights reserved. www.asminternational.org
CHAPTER 4
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory MATERIALS PLAY A MAJOR ROLE in the world economy and in the development of nations. This is particularly true of metals, with steels and cast irons being the most widely used. Metals not only enhance our life-style, but have become a necessity of modern life. Science and engineering, particularly in the areas involving metal, ceramic, polymeric, electronic, and superconducting materials, have advanced rapidly and will continue to outpace technology as a whole. In this swirl of activity, a metallographer is vital to our basic understanding of the link between microstructure and the properties of these materials. By understanding microstructure and its origin, one can begin to develop a basis on how to achieve specific properties tailored for a particular engineering application. For example, an application for an earth-moving shovel in mining requires a steel with very high tensile strength and hardness, combined with a high degree of wear resistance and some toughness. What optimal microstructure would provide these properties? This book provides a beginning to the basic understanding of the development of microstructure and gives instructions on how to employ proper techniques to reveal microstructure, that is, the techniques of metallography. In this book we, of course, restrict our attention to the metallography of iron and steel.
ing wrought iron, wrought iron armor plate, and blister steel. He found that the samples had definite microstructural features. A copy of Sorby’s 1864 macrograph of blister steel can be seen in Fig. 4.2. This macrograph, taken at 9⫻, shows distinct grain boundaries. This discovery was significant, because it eventually led to the realization that microstructural features imparted certain properties to steel. The development of ferrous physical metallurgy, and physical metallurgy in general, depended on this important link.
The Metallographer What is a metallographer? In general terms, a metallographer is a person who has the skill to properly prepare a specimen of a metal or alloy in order to allow examination and interpretation of its microstructure. In this technological age, the term “metallographer” is becoming somewhat of a misnomer, because today it covers not only metals but ceramics and the other materials mentioned previously. The term at some time in the future may be changed to “materiallographer,” but for the moment, the term “metallographer” is still in place. The field of metallography, which involves the study of the microstructure of metals, is almost a century and a half old. It all began with Henry Clifton Sorby on July 28, 1863. Sorby, whose photograph can be seen in Fig. 4.1, was an English geologist, petrographer, and mineralogist who was the first person to examine polished and chemically etched metal samples under the microscope. His samples included Swedish wrought iron, Bowl-
Fig. 4.1 Henry Clifton Sorby, the father of metallography
88 / Metallographer’s Guide In Sorby’s day, the examination of structure was limited by the fairly low magnification of the light (optical) microscope. (In this book, we prefer the term “light” microscope to “optical” microscope, because light is the source of radiation or illumination of the specimen. Other microscopes, such as an electron microscope, depend on electrons as the source of radiation, and these microscopes still use an “optical” system of magnetic lenses to obtain an image.) We can assume that in the 1860s, microscopes allowed a magnification of only a few hundred times. Sorby’s microscope, purchased in 1861 from Messrs. Beck, had a maximum magnification of about 400⫻. A sketch of the microscope is shown in Fig. 4.3. Most microscopes of the day were for biological studies, and Sorby needed a microscope using reflected light. Sorby modified Beck’s microscope with an additional small mirror inclined at a
45° angle, as shown by the letter “g” in the lower right of the sketch. This mirror allowed light rays to reflect from the sample in normal reflected illumination as opposed to the oblique illumination in Beck’s parabolic mirror, “f” in the lower left of the sketch. Sorby’s mirror not only increased the amount of light reflected back into the objective “a,” it also improved the resolving power of the microscope. Resolving power and light-gathering ability are discussed in much greater detail in Chapter 5. Although etching was used at least four centuries before Sorby etched his specimens, it was only used for macroetching to bring up the damask patterns of swords and various pieces of armor, as well as the structure of polished meteorites. In 1808, Alos von Widmanstätten, a geologist and museum curator in Vienna, and his co-worker Carl von Schreibers etched various meteorites to show the outstanding crystalline patterns (these patterns are now called Widmanstätten structure). An excellent example of their work is shown in Fig. 4.4 which shows the structure of the etched Elbogen iron meteorite that fell in 1751. The meteorite was polished and deeply etched with nitric acid. After rinsing in water and drying, printer’s ink was rolled on the etched surface, and the sample was pressed onto a piece of paper. The direct transfer is seen in Fig. 4.4. Sorby cut and polished his specimens to remove all “traces of roughness.” After polishing, he used extremely dilute nitric acid to etch his specimens. He actually followed the progress of etching in order not to overetch the specimen. Widmanstätten and
Fig. 4.2 The first macrograph of the microstructure of steel, Sorby’s 1864 macrograph of blister steel. Etched in very dilute nitric acid. 9⫻
Fig. 4.4 A macrograph of the Elbogen iron meteorite prepared in 1808 by Fig. 4.3 A sketch of Beck’s microscope with Sorby’s flat mirror (g)
Widmanstätten and Schreibers using heavy etching in nitric acid to outline the structure in relief. The macrograph was made by rolling printer’s ink over the sample and then transferring the inked specimen onto paper.
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory / 89 Schreibers etched specimens that could be viewed with the naked eye, but Sorby was the first to etch specimens and observe the microstructure with a microscope. This was the beginning of metallography. It is sad that the constituent Sorbite, named to honor Sorby, was simply very fine pearlite unresolved in the light microscopes at the end of the 19th century. Because it was not a new constituent, the term “Sorbite” didn’t survive. The term “pearlite” survived to this day and is actually connected to Sorby, because he described the “pearly constituent” as having the appearance of mother of pearl. Today, with electron microscopes we examine the structure of materials at over 1,000,000⫻ magnification. As newer instruments are developed, the metallographer is able to probe deeper and deeper into the fine structure of metals. However, even with the sophisticated instruments available, the first and most important stage of a metallographer’s investigation is still in the use of the light microscope to examine the general microstructure. In bypassing the light microscope and going directly to the electron microscope, many metallographers have been misled in their intrepretation of the structures they observe. Thus, the first rule in metallography is to examine the microstructure in a light microscope (usually 50 to 1000⫻) and then, if required, move up to higher magnifications with the scanning electron microscope, transmission electron microscope, or scanning transmission electron microscope. The metallographer must be able to prepare a specimen of iron or steel with the proper metallographic procedures to reveal the true microstructural features in the specimen. It is important that the metallographer understand the metallurgical aspects of the iron or steel sample that is being prepared. Often, an unskilled person will employ improper techniques and unknowingly create a false “structure” or artifact in the specimen that will lead to a misinterpretation of the microstructure. (We use the term “artifact” as a generic term for a false microstructure, that is, the appearance or creation of a “microstructure” that is not the actual microstructure of the steel or cast iron. An example is an unintentional water stain on the specimen surface.) False information can be very costly if wrong decisions are made based on poor sample preparation. An example is if a critical step in a manufacturing process was varied in the wrong direction because of the misinterpretation of an artifact induced in a metallographic specimen. Chapter 7 discusses a number of examples of artifacts that have been introduced into metallographic samples of iron and steel.
The Metallographer versus the Chemist An example to show the importance of a metallographer is illustrated using a simple situation. A small manufacturing plant orders 12 mm (1⁄2 in.) diameter American Iron and Steel Institute/ Society of Automotive Engineers (AISI/SAE) 1040 barstock in truckload quantities to fabricate brackets. One particular week, the plant was experiencing difficulty in machining, bending, and welding the brackets. In one case, the bars were much too hard and cracked when bent into the 90° bend required, and these same bars were very difficult to machine, and were wearing the cutting
tool at an unacceptable rate. At the other extreme, some of the bars were difficult to machine, because they were too soft and clogged and broke several cutting tools. The foreman decided to trace the bars back to the truck shipments and found that three truckloads were delivered the same week, but each load was from a different supply warehouse. To determine what was possibly different in the three shipments, the foreman gave a sample of bar from each of the different shipments to a chemist for a complete chemical analysis, and an identical set of samples to a metallographer. After drilling chips from each bar and conducting a “wet” chemical analysis, the chemist determined the chemical composition of the steel and found that the three samples consist of the following composition: Composition, %
Carbon Manganese Phosphorus Sulfur Silicon Nickel Chromium Molybdenum Copper Aluminum
Sample 1
Sample 2
Sample 3
0.39 0.72 0.013 0.018 0.21 0.015 0.026 0.010 0.23 0.021
0.41 0.70 0.015 0.014 0.23 0.027 0.028 0.014 0.18 0.018
0.40 0.68 0.010 0.016 0.22 0.002 0.005 0.002 0.05 0.023
The chemical analysis shows that three samples have similar composition. From these analyses, the steel is AISI/SAE 1040, thus showing that the shipments were of the correct grade of steel. The analysis reveals a lot of information about how the steel was manufactured. For example, the steel from all three shipments is silicon-aluminum killed. Samples 1 and 2 contain a fairly high level of residual (tramp) elements, such as copper. The level of residual elements indicates that the steel was produced by the electric furnace steelmaking process, which uses steel scrap as the melting source. Steel scrap can consist of crushed automobiles, which contain copper wires, zinc alloy die castings, and so on. Sample 3 was produced from a basic oxygen furnace (BOF), where the levels of copper, nickel, chromium, and molybdenum are much lower, because BOF-based steel is produced from the liquid iron of a blast furnace. The blast furnace uses iron ore, coke, and limestone as the raw materials to make iron. Generally, these residual elements are not present in these raw materials. However, some residuals can be picked up if some scrap is melted in the BOF. From all this information, it is impossible to tell anything about the specific properties of the steel bars, for example, hardness, tensile strength, and so on. However, in the reference Engineering Properties of Steel, one finds that AISI/SAE 1040 steel can have the following range of properties: Hardness Yield strength Tensile strength Total elongation (in 2 in.) Reduction in area
149 to 529 BHN 50 to 85 ksi (50,000 to 85,000 psi) 70 to 130 ksi (70,000 to 130,000 psi) 17 to 35% 45 to 70%
From these wide ranges of properties found in the handbook, we do not know if the steel bars are hard, soft, or ductile. These
90 / Metallographer’s Guide specific properties depend on the processing history and condition of the steel. For example, were the steel bars received in the as-hot-rolled condition or heat treated, for example, austenitized and water quenched? Thus, the chemist can provide very important information about chemical composition that will give clues about the steel, but the information is very limited in its usefulness in the prediction of properties. In fact, as seen subsequently, the chemical information can sometimes lead to the wrong conclusions about the steel. The metallographer, on the other hand, after sectioning, polishing, etching, and examining samples of the same three steels under the microscope, reports that each steel bar has a different microstructure and thus, different properties and characteristics. Following is what the metallographic analysis revealed. Sample 1. Details about these constituents are described in Chapter 2. A skilled metallographer would recognize that this bar is in the hot-rolled condition, because of the banded microstructure where the pearlite constituent appears in bands running parallel to the rolling direction of the bar. Banding is common in hot-rolled steels and is caused mainly by manganese segregation during the solidification process (the carbon diffuses to the manganese bands to form pearlite upon cooling from the hotrolling temperature). The segregation pattern elongates during the hot-rolling process. The metallographer determines by standard quantitative microscopy procedures outlined in ASTM E 562 that the bar is 50% ferrite and 50% pearlite. The ferrite constituent is equiaxed (not elongated, but equal dimensions in all directions), and from standard grain size measurements according to the three-circle method in ASTM E 112, has an average grain size of 21 microns (ASTM number 6). From these proportions of 50% ferrite and 50% pearlite, the metallographer can estimate that the steel has a carbon content close to 0.4% and that the steel is hot-rolled AISI/SAE 1040 (the chemical analysis is important for this information). This carbon content can be calculated by using the lever rule and the iron-carbon equilibrium diagram described in Chapter 2. The lever extends along the eutectoid horizontal line of the iron-carbon diagram from 0.02 to 0.77% C. With the fulcrum of the lever at the unknown carbon content of “X,” the right side of the lever (the amount of ferrite) is 0.77 ⫺ X, divided by the entire length of the lever, or 0.77 ⫺ 0.02, as shown: 0.77% C ⫺ X% C ⫻ 100% ⫽ 50% (ferrite) 0.77% C ⫺ 0.02% C
By solving this equation, X ⫽ 0.4% C. It must be pointed out that this is only an estimate, because the percentages of ferrite and pearlite can change, depending on processing parameters such as cooling rate from austenite to ferrite and pearlite. The austenite grain size before transformation can also vary the amount of ferrite and pearlite in a microstructure, because a large grain size has fewer sites for nucleation of ferrite (and vice versa for a fine grain size), which can alter the percentage transformed. However, in this example where the bar was hot rolled followed by air cooling, the estimate of 0.4% C is reasonable. From the previously mentioned handbook, an AISI/SAE 1040 steel in the as-rolled condition would have the following approximate properties:
Hardness Yield strength Tensile strength Total elongation (in 2 in.) Reduction in area
150 BHN 50 ksi (50,000 psi) 75 ksi (75,000 psi) 30% 60%
Sample 2. The microstructure of this sample consists of martensite. This microstructure indicates that the bar was austenitized and rapidly cooled (probably water quenched) to room temperature. From close examination of the microstructure, the steel does not appear to be tempered (softened by heat treatment between 425 and 650 °C, or 800 and 1200 °F) and is thus in the as-quenched condition. This steel will be much harder and stronger than the steel represented by sample 1. The metallographer, by knowing the aim chemical analysis, can estimate the properties from the previously mentioned handbook as: Hardness Yield strength Tensile strength Total elongation (in 2 in.) Reduction in area
500 BHN 95 ksi (95,000 psi) 130 ksi (130,000 psi) 17% 45%
Sample 3. The metallographer reveals that this bar has an abnormal microstructure. The bar is heavily decarburized, which means that during processing at high temperature, the carbon in the steel was allowed to diffuse out of the surface layers of the bar into the surrounding atmosphere. Decarburization can be caused by improper furnace atmosphere practice during heat treatment. Because of the severe decarburization, approximately the outer 1⁄4 of the cross section of the bar is ferrite, and the microstructure at the central region of the bar is 100% pearlite. The center of the bar represents the original microstructure, because it was unaffected by the decarburization phenomenon. This means that the original bar was actually AISI/SAE 1080 (a fully pearlitic steel with 0.75 to 0.88% C), not AISI/SAE 1040 (0.37 to 0.44% C), as indicated by the chemist. The loss in carbon by the severe decarburization lowered the overall carbon content (the bulk carbon content) of the bar to about 0.40%. Thus, the chemical analysis information alone would have been misleading in this case. However, coupled with a metallographic analysis, a great deal of relevant information can be obtained about the steel. Based on the previously mentioned chemical and metallographic analyses, logical decisions can be made concerning the properties and processing history of the steel bars. The plant foreman knew that each sample came from a different truckload of bars from three different steel suppliers. All the bars were ordered to a specification mandating a standard silicon-aluminum killed, AISI/SAE 1040, as-rolled bar stock. The analysis by the chemist indicates that the three shipments would meet the AISI/SAE 1040 chemical analysis specification. However, the foreman knew that the bars had different properties. Only by conducting a metallographic analysis was it determined why the bars are different. The information from the metallographic analysis explained why the bars were cracking and breaking cutting tools. The bracket manufacturing process employs steps that run the material through normal, closely controlled forming/machining/welding
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory / 91 operations designed and optimized around a hot-rolled AISI/SAE 1040 steel. In this example, the 12 mm (0.5 in.) diameter bar stock is cold sheared into 254 mm (10 in.) lengths, threaded at one end, bent 90° at a position 100 mm (4 in.) from the threaded end, and welded at the other end to a large steel tank. First, the bars from each supplier behaved very differently during cold shearing. The martensitic bar (steel 2) would damage the shear blade and be unable to be sheared. The bending operation would also eliminate the martensitic steel, because the bars would crack and break during bending. Machining the threads on steel 2 would also be difficult using tooling setup for a softer steel. Also, the heavily decarburized bars (steel 3), having a very soft surface, would machine much differently than an AISI/SAE 1040 steel. Because of the softer surface, the machined threads would also be very weak in service. The welding characteristics of each of these three steels would also be very different. However, if a metallographer examined the samples from each shipment before processing, the foreman would realize that the steels were different and that two out of the three shipments did not meet the specifications of a hot-rolled AISI/SAE 1040 steel. This example is not meant to downgrade the role of the chemist, because in most cases, knowing the chemical composition is very important. But the composition of the steel in combination with the microstructure provides much more information for an accurate decision to be made about the properties and characteristics of the steel. The main point in the previous example, in contrasting chemical and metallographic information, is that both are important, but the metallographic information about the microstructure is of utmost importance in understanding the properties and characteristics of the steel. This means that the metallographer must be able to prepare a sample of the steel to reveal its microstructure. A skilled and educated metallographer can interpret the microstructure to assist others in the proper course of action. The interpretation of microstructure requires a sound knowledge of ferrous physical metallurgy. Many metallographers leave this interpretation to metallurgists/metallurgical engineers. However, the authors feel that to be more effective, a metallographer should have some knowledge of structure-property relationships. The field of metallography has rapidly progressed since the 1950s to the point where all major steel manufacturing and fabricating companies use some kind of metallographic analysis in quality-control procedures. Metallographic data is sometimes indispensable. Many product specifications are written with metallographic standards, such as minimum grain size, maximum inclusion size/distribution (microcleanliness), maximum depth of decarburization, and so on. The modern-day metallographer must not only know how to properly prepare a specimen and interpret its microstructure, but also how to quantitatively measure the metallographic features found in each specimen. Most times, these measurements can be made with the aid of a simple metallographic microscope with a scale of measurement installed in an eyepiece, or by projecting the image on a ground glass screen. In larger operations, where thousands of repetitive measurements are made, a computer-assisted image analysis system is used. In this case, the specimen is automatically scanned using a
special mechanized stage on the microscope. Hundreds of measurements are made and stored in the microprocessor. The system is programmed to give data on the number, volume fraction, size and distribution of the particles, and phases in the microstructure. Many times, a metallographer is needed to assist in programming such systems, because of his or her knowledge of various microstructural characteristics that the image analysis system will measure. The modern-day metallographer must also have some proficiency in metallography beyond the light microscope. The light microscope, in using reflected light to illuminate the specimen, is limited in resolving power, so that the useful magnification is generally under 1000⫻. In fact, special procedures and highquality lenses are needed to achieve 1500⫻. This magnification limit is very restricting for some fine microstructures. For example, as described in Chapter 2, pearlite is a constituent in steel consisting of alternating plates or lamella of soft ferrite (nearly pure iron) and hard cementite (iron carbide). This microstructure is mostly unresolved at these magnifications. For example, the microstructural details of fine pearlite in a sample of rail steel (AISI/SAE 1080), taken on a light microscope, are shown in Fig. 4.5. One can see evidence of discrete pearlite colonies, due to the differences in the reflectivity of light from the different orientations of the colonies (the chemical etching process attacks each colony, exposing a different reflection plane to the incident light of the microscope). However, at this magnification, one cannot discern the fine details of the individual cementite and ferrite lamella. Figure 4.6 shows the same sample at a magnification of 10,000⫻, taken on a scanning electron microscope (SEM). This magnification can be easily obtained on a SEM that employs reflected electrons instead of reflected light. Scanning electron microscopes are now common in many industrial and university metallographic laboratories. A skilled metallographer must prop-
Fig. 4.5 Microstructure of a fully pearlitic steel rail. 4% picral etch. 1000⫻
92 / Metallographer’s Guide steels in the form of rod, wire, plate, forgings, structural shapes, hot- and cold-rolled sheet, rail, bar, and castings. Some of the steel samples are from experimental studies, but a large portion of samples are from failed parts and from the companies’ existing commercial products. Samples are submitted with as much documentation as possible, for example, chemical composition and details of prior heat treatment and processing. Although metallographers may tend to specialize their expertise in particular types of samples, such as coated steels, in this laboratory they prepare samples in rotation as they are submitted. To be specific, the metallographic submissions on one particular working day included the following nine examples. The actual metallographic techniques used with each of these examples are described in order to give the reader an idea of the work required. Chapters 7 and 8 provide much more detail on metallographic technique than can be described here.
Fig. 4.6 A SEM micrograph of a fully pearlitic microstructure of a steel rail. 4% picral etch. 10,000⫻
erly prepare a specimen for SEM analysis. In addition to the very useful SEM, many other instruments are available to analyze the microstructure. In fact, these instruments, including the SEM, can provide data on the chemical composition of the individual phase or particle in a microstructure. The electron probe microanalyzer (EPMA, or simply “microprobe”) is the ultimate instrument to provide chemical composition. These instruments and others are discussed in detail in Chapter 6.
The Metallographer’s Workday In order to have some idea of what a typical metallographer does in a particular workday, the following examples are presented of a metallographer working as part of a team of metallographers in a research laboratory of a large steel company, and a metallographer working alone at a small iron foundry.
The Metallographer’s Workday at a Research Laboratory of a Large Steel Company In the United States, the major steel corporations have research/ technology departments with up to 100 or so employees. To support a staff of this size, a typical metallographic laboratory employs one to three full-time metallographers, not including supporting personnel who operate the specialized instruments, such as a SEM, EMPA, or x-ray diffractometer. In this example, a metallographic laboratory with three metallographers was selected. These metallographers can each process well over 1000 samples a year. All three metallographers work closely with physical and process metallurgists as well as corrosion and welding engineers. Although this is a steel research laboratory, the metallographers must also have the skills to prepare samples of nonferrous metals, for example, copper used in blast furnace tuyeres to zinc coatings on steel. However, ever, about 98% of the samples submitted to the laboratory are
Submission 1 is two lots of steel sheet, coded “1” and “2,” with an aluminized coating. Work Required. Determine if the aluminized coating is type 1 or type 2 and measure the overall coating thickness and the thickness of the alloy layer at the interface between the aluminum coating and the steel. A type 1 coating contains about 9% Si, whereas a type 2 coating is essentially pure aluminum. Specimen preparation is as follows. • •
Sectioning: Hand shear three samples 8 ⫻ 25 mm (0.30 ⫻ 1.0 in.) from each lot. Mounting: The samples will be mounted in epoxy. First, make a sandwich of the six samples, using thin strips of doublebacked tape placed at each end of each strip (this procedure is described in Chapter 7). The tape will keep each specimen apart and allow epoxy to fill the gap. It is important to make a sketch of the samples showing how they were stacked. Place the sandwich with the required face down onto the bottom of a cup-shaped mold. Place a 30 mm (1.17 in.) diameter, 25 mm (1 in.) high plastic cylinder (mold) around the sandwich (center the sandwich in the mold). Place two steel nuts in the mold, at both sides of the 25 mm (1 in.) dimension of the sandwich. These nuts will help keep the polished surface of the sandwich flat during grinding and polishing. Place a “V” marker insert on one side of the sandwich to orient how the specimens were stacked according to the sketch. The marker can be a bent piece of sheet or other material. Thoroughly mix the epoxy according to the manufacturer’s instructions. This should be carried out under an exhaust hood. In this particular case, heating the liquid epoxy container in a beaker of warm water will reduce the viscosity and allow better filling of the gaps between the specimens. After filling the mold with the epoxy mixture to just cover the sandwich, place the mount in a vacuum chamber to remove excess air bubbles. The bubbles appear as a foam forming on the top surface of the mount. Allow air to enter the chamber, and repeat the evacuation several times. Remove mount from the chamber and fill the cylinder with the remaining epoxy mixture. Allow the mount to cure according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory / 93 •
•
Grinding: Measure the height of the sample. Silicon carbide grinding paper will be used, starting with 120-grit paper. The wheel rotation will be 300 rpm. During the wet grinding operation, remove approximately 1 mm (0.040 in.) from the surface of the mount. This will remove any deformation induced from shearing the specimen. Continue wet grinding with successively finer-grit papers, 240, 320, 400, 600, 12 μm, and 8 μm, rinsing the specimen in running water after each paper. Rotate the specimen 90° between each paper, so that it can be seen if the scratches from the previous grind are removed. After the first grind on the 120-grit paper, only 15 to 20 seconds is usually required per paper. In this case, it is important to end the last grinding step on 8 μm paper, with the grinding scratches parallel with the 25 mm (1 in.) length of the specimens. This will minimize rounding of those edges of the specimen with the coated layer. The mount should then be cleaned by swabbing with cotton under running water, followed by flushing with alcohol and drying. Check the surface of the specimen in the microscope to ensure that there is no rounding of the edges of the coating. If rounded, the mound should be reground, starting at 600 grit until flat. Polishing: The specimens will be polished using an aqueous 1 μm alumina (Al2O3) solution on a napless cloth. First, use a stationary wheel or flat surface while rotating the mount until all the parallel scratches from the last grinding step are removed. If staining occurs by a galvanic reaction using the aqueous alumina solution, change the pH of the water to 7 or replace the water with ethylene glycol. Clean by swabbing with cotton under running water, and flush the specimen with alcohol and dry. Second, polish the specimen using a stationary wheel or flat surface with an aqueous 0.3 μm alumina solution on a low-nap cloth (e.g., rayon ) for 90 seconds. Rinse with cotton swabbing, and flush with alcohol and dry. Third,
•
•
•
polish on a stationary low-nap cloth with aqueous colloidal solution of 0.04 μm silica (SiO2) for two minutes. Polishing on a low-nap or napless cloth will minimize rounding of the edges of the specimens. Etching: Etch the specimen in 2% nital for 15 to 20 seconds and rinse in running water. Flush the specimen with alcohol and blow dry. Observation: The etched specimens were examined in a light microscope equipped with a measuring reticle. From this scale, the coating thickness can be measured by rotating the scale so that it is perpendicular to the coating thickness. Results: After examining the etched specimens in the microscope, it was revealed that the aluminized coating on lot 1 was type 1, with an average coating thickness of 15 μm. Figure 4.7(a) shows a representative field of the coating on the steel surface. The microstructure reveals particles of silicon (dark gray needles) in an aluminum matrix and an alloy layer (light gray region between steel and coating) about 5 μm thick. Cracks can be seen in the brittle alloy layer in Fig. 4.7(a). For lot 2, the coating thickness averaged 25 μm, and the alloy layer averaged 10 μm. A representative microstructure is shown in Fig. 4.7(b). The coating of the sample in lot 2 is type 2.
Submission 2 is a defective 1 mm (0.040 in.) diameter AISI/SAE 1070 steel wire. Work Required. Determine the cause of wire failure during service. Specimen preparation is as follows. •
Sectioning: Cut four pieces of wire to a length of 12 mm (0.50 in.) and four pieces of wire to a length of 18 mm (0.70 in.). Include an 18 mm (0.70 in.) length of wire with the fracture surface.
Fig. 4.7 Micrograph of a steel sheet with (a) type 1 and (b) type 2 aluminized coating. 2% nital etch. 1000⫻
94 / Metallographer’s Guide •
•
•
Mounting: Place the four longest wires in a parallel array on a flat magnetic surface covered with aluminum foil or on a flat surface of double-backed tape. Leave a 3 mm (0.12 in.) spacing between each wire. Center a 30 mm (1.17 in.) diameter by 25 mm (1 in.) high plastic cylinder (mold) around the wires. If using aluminum foil, use quick-drying cement to secure the mold in place to prevent the mold from moving. Prepare an epoxy mixture and pour the mixture into the cylinder until a depth of 20 mm (0.80 in.) is reached. Allow the epoxy to cure in accordance with instructions. Drill four holes slightly larger than the wire diameter into the cured mount. The holes should be about 2 mm (0.080 in.) from the end of each wire. Place the four short wires in the holes, with the cut surface of each wire extending out of the holes (this ensures that the cutting damage will be removed during grinding). Fill the remaining cavity of the mold with epoxy. To lower the viscosity of the epoxy mixture, it is recommended that the epoxy mixing container be heated by placing it in warm water (about 50 °C, or 120 °F). Place the mount into a vacuum chamber to remove any air bubbles surrounding the wires in the holes. The epoxy will fill any gaps remaining when brought back to atmospheric pressure. Allow the mount to cure. Grinding: Wet grind the surface of the mount on 400-grit silicon carbide paper until all the epoxy from the second pouring has been removed. Use wheel speed of 300 rpm. Then grind the mount on 600-grit silicon carbide paper until the center of the four longer wires has been revealed. Use the ends of the short wires to judge the diameter. Polishing: On a rotating wheel, polish (150 rpm) the specimens with 6 μm diamond paste or spray on a very-low-nap or napless cloth. Use heavy pressure until all the 600-grit
•
•
•
Submission 3 is a failed weld in a 12 mm (0.50 in.) steel plate. Work Required. Determine the cause of the failed weld. Specimen preparation is as follows. •
• •
•
Fig. 4.8 Microstructure taken at the center of a fractured AISI/SAE 1070
steel wire. Fracture is associated with a central bursting condition. Unetched. 50⫻
scratches are removed. Clean the specimen by swabbing with cotton in flowing water, followed by an alcohol rinse and blow dry. Continue the polishing operation on a rotating wheel with an aqueous 0.3 μm alumina solution on a low-nap cloth for 60 to 120 seconds. Use firm pressure. Clean the specimen by swabbing with cotton under flowing water, and flush the specimen with alcohol and blow dry. As the last polishing step, use a 0.04 μm colloidal silicon dioxide slurry on a mediumnap cloth for 15 seconds (stationary surface). Use firm pressure. Clean the specimen by cotton swabbing under flowing water, and flush with alcohol and blow dry the specimen. Etching: First observe the polished specimens without etchng. If defects are found in the wires, photograph the areas of importance. Etch the specimens in 4% picral. Rinse the specimen in running water, followed by an alcohol rinse and blow drying. Observation: As mentioned previously, examine the specimens in both the unetched and etched conditions. Sometimes etching will obscure a defect. Results: Upon examination in the unetched condition, the wire with the fracture surface had a condition called central bursting, as seen in Fig. 4.8. This condition can develop in the cold-drawing process used to produce the wire. However, once the wire specimen was etched, it was determined that the central bursts were created by regions of hard martensite along the centerline of the wire. These martensite regions can be seen in Fig. 4.9(a) and (b). The martensite regions, because of their hardness, did not flow through the drawing die as easily as the matrix, thus causing a rupture.
Sectioning: Remove a 15 mm long by 10 mm (0.60 by 0.40 in.) section from each side of the fractured weld, using a water-cooled abrasive cut-off machine. Use a medium-hardness aluminum oxide wheel. Mounting: Not necessary Grinding: Wet grind each specimen, starting with 320-grit silicon carbide paper. Then continue wet grinding on 400- and 600-grit papers, rotating the specimen 90° after each paper. The specimen should be rinsed in running water after each paper. Polishing: Polish each specimen on a rotating wheel (150 rpm) with 6 μm diamond paste or spray on a very-low-nap cloth until all scratches from the last grind are removed. Clean the surface with a cotton swab under running water, followed by an alcohol rinse and drying. Polish each specimen on a rotating wheel with aqueous 0.3 μm alumina solution on a low-nap cloth for two minutes. Clean the specimens by cotton swabbing under running water, followed by rinsing in alcohol and blow drying. Polish the specimens in an aqueous 0.04 μm silicon dioxide slurry for 45 to 60 seconds on a stationary flat surface using a low-nap cloth. Clean by swabbing with cotton
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory / 95
• •
under running water, followed by an alcohol rinse and blow drying. Etching: Etch the two specimens in 2% nital. Rinse the specimen in running water, rinse in alcohol and blow dry. Observation: Place two specimens together at the fracture, using a leveling device and clay. Examine the weld in the microscope.
•
Submission 4 is a heat treated AISI/SAE 52100 steel bearing race. Work Required. Determine why material did not meet the hardness specification of 700 Knoop required by the customer. Specimen preparation is as follows. •
• •
•
Fig. 4.9 Micrograph taken at the fracture of an AISI/SAE 1070 steel wire
showing hard regions of martensite that caused the rupture of the wire. Picral etch. (a) at 100⫻ and (b) at 200⫻
Results: It was observed that the failure occurred along the heat-affected zone (HAZ) of the weld and not in the weld fusion zone, as seen in Fig. 4.10.
Sectioning: Cut two specimens 12 mm (0.50 in.) in length on a water-cooled abrasive cut-off machine, using a soft alumina blade. Mounting: Mount one specimen in epoxy. Grinding: Wet grind the specimen, starting with 240-grit silicon carbide paper. Then continue wet grinding on 320-, 400-, and 600-grit papers, rotating the specimen 90° after each paper. The specimen should be rinsed in running water after each paper. Grinding time for each paper is about 15 to 20 seconds. Polishing: Polish the specimen on a rotating wheel (150 rpm) with 6 μm diamond paste or spray on a very-low-nap cloth until all scratches from the last grind are removed. Use heavy pressure while polishing. Clean the surface with a cotton swab under running water, followed by an alcohol rinse and blow drying. Polish the specimen on a rotating wheel (150 rpm) with a 1 μm diamond paste or spray on a low-nap cloth for 90 seconds, using heavy pressure. Clean the specimen by cotton swabbing under running water, followed by rinsing in alcohol and blow drying. Polish the specimen in an aqueous 0.04 μm silicon dioxide slurry for 45 to 60 seconds on a stationary flat surface, using a medium-nap cloth for 45 seconds, using firm pressure. Clean by swabbing with cotton under flowing water, followed by a rinse in alcohol and blow drying.
Fig. 4.10 Macrograph of a fractured weld showing through the heataffected zone (HAZ). 3% nital etch. 5⫻
96 / Metallographer’s Guide • •
•
Etching: Etch in 4% picral. Rinse the specimen in flowing water, followed by an alcohol rinse and blow drying. Hardness measurement: Make hardness measurements (Knoop) of the specimen. Use 500 gram load with a 15 second hold time. Results: The specimen cut from the original lot of steel had an average Knoop hardness of 730. This converts to a Rockwell hardness of 60 Rc. The microstructure is martensite, as seen in
Fig. 4.11(a). To reconstruct what may have happened to achieve a much lower hardness, another piece of the bearing race was sectioned from the same sample, but was removed using a cut-off wheel without water cooling. That specimen was prepared in the same manner described previously. The specimen had a similar microstructure to the first specimen, as seen in Fig. 4.11(b). However, the second specimen had an average Knoop hardness of only 326 (Rc 32). Thus, it was concluded that the original parts met the hardness specification and that the low reading achieved by the customer was created by improperly cutting the specimen from the bearing race. Submission 5 is a grade S-230 chilled cast iron shot. Work Required. Determine the particle shape of the shot. Sample preparation is as follows. • •
•
•
Sectioning: Not required Mounting: Mix a small amount of shot with an epoxy mixture. Place a solid aluminum cylinder inside a 30 mm (1.17 in.) hollow plastic cylinder (mold), leaving enough depth to pour the liquid into the mold for a layer of about 2 mm (0.080 in.) thick (see Fig. 4.12). Place mold into a vacuum chamber and evacuate to remove air bubbles. Allow the epoxy to cure according to the instructions from the manufacturer. Grinding: Remove the aluminum cylinder and attached cured epoxy/shot mixture from the mold (see Fig. 4.13). Wet grind the epoxy/shot mixture, starting on 400-grit silicon dioxide paper. Rinse the specimen in running water. Rotate the specimen 90° and wet grind on 600-grit silicon carbide paper. Again, rinse the specimen in running water. Polishing: Polish the specimen on a rotating wheel (150 rpm) with 6 μm diamond paste or spray on a napless cloth, for example, nylon. Clean the specimen by swabbing with cotton in flowing water, followed by an alcohol rinse and drying. Polish the specimen on a rotating wheel, using an aqueous solution of 0.3 μm alumina on a low-nap cloth. Clean the specimen by swabbing with cotton under flowing water, followed by rinsing in alcohol and blow drying. Polish in a
Fig. 4.11 (a) Martensitic microstructure with a Knoop hardness impression
of AISI/SAE 52100 bearing race at a Knoop hardness of 730 and (b) the same material improperly cut using an abrasive wheel without water cooling at a Knoop hardness of only 326. 2% nital etch. 1000⫻
Fig. 4.12 Photograph of mold and aluminum cylinder insert used for preparation of a shot specimen. 1⫻
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory / 97
• • •
vibratory polishing machine for one hour, using an aqueous 0.04 μm silica solution, using a napless or low-nap cloth (woven wool). Clean the specimen with cotton under flowing water, followed by an alcohol rinse and blow drying. Etching: Not required Observation: Examine the specimen in a microscope and take several photographs of the shot morphology. Results: A typical example is shown in Fig. 4.14. The shot is in the form of fairly uniformly rounded particles.
• • • • •
Sectioning: Cut a 12 mm (0.50 in.) thick slice from the rail. Mounting: Not required Grinding: Surface grind one side of the cross-sectional surface of the rail. Use the finest grinding wheel available. Polishing: Not required Etching: A normal metallographic etch will not be applied. A technique similar to etching, called sulfur printing, will be used to produce a pattern of the segregation that occurs during
Submission 6 is a small section AISI/SAE 4340 forging. Work Required. Examine the flow lines to estimate the effectiveness of the forging operation. Specimen preparation is as follows. •
• •
• •
• •
Sectioning: Remove a 12 mm (0.50 in.) cross-sectional slice from the forging, using a water-cooled abrasive cut-off machine with a bonded alumina wheel. Mounting: Not required Grinding: Wet grind on 320-grit silicon dioxide paper, followed by wet grinding on 400- and 600-grit silicon dioxide papers. Rinse the specimen in running water, and rotate the specimen 90° after each grind. Polishing: Not necessary Etching: Etch the specimen in a solution of three parts water, two parts sulfuric acid, and one part hydrochloric acid. Heat the solution to 76 °C (170 °F) before etching. After etching, rinse the specimen in flowing water, followed by an alcohol rinse and blow drying. Observation: The flow lines in the specimen can be observed without a microscope. Results: Figure 4.15 shows the flow lines in the cross section of the forged specimen.
Fig. 4.14 Micrograph of grade S-230 chilled cast iron shot. Unetched. 160⫻
Submission 7 is a railroad rail. Work Required. Determine the chemical segregation pattern in the rail cross section. Specimen preparation is as follows.
Fig. 4.13 Photo shows a thin layer of epoxy with powder metal bonded to
an aluminum slug. This technique has many advantages over an all-epoxy mount.
Fig. 4.15 Macrograph of a steel forging showing flow lines. Etched in
three parts water, two parts sulfuric acid, and one part hydrochloric acid. 1.25⫻
98 / Metallographer’s Guide solidification. Soak a bromide-type photographic paper (for example, Kodak AZO F3 fiber-based photographic paper, Eastman Kodak Corporation) in a 2% solution of sulfuric acid for two to five minutes. Remove the paper from the solution and allow the excess solution to drain away. Place the emulsion side of the paper on the ground surface of the rail. Quickly remove any air bubbles from underneath the paper with a roller or sponge. Hold the paper flat with one hand while rolling or sponging to prevent movement. Allow the image to develop over a time period of between three to ten
• •
minutes (generally five minutes, depending on the sulfur content of the steel). Carefully peel the paper from the rail. Rinse the paper in water, and place the paper in a solution of photographic fixer (for example Kodak Rapid Fixer, Eastman Kodak Corporation) for about ten minutes. Rinse the paper in water for about a half-hour to remove the fixer, and allow the paper to dry. Observation: A microscope is not required to observe the image. Results: The sulfur print will reveal a pattern of sulfur distribution in the rail. Figure 4.16 shows the result. The sulfuric acid attacks the manganese sulfides in the steel and produces hydrogen sulfide gas. The hydrogen sulfide gas reacts with the silver bromide in the paper to form silver sulfide. The brownish image is a result of the silver sulfide reaction.
Submission 8 is a broken 6 mm (0.24 in.) diameter AISI/SAE 303 stainless steel bolt (see Fig. 4.17). Work Required. Determine the cause of failure. Specimen preparation is as follows. •
• •
Fig. 4.16 Sulfur print of a steel rail showing regions of sulfur segregation. 1⫻
•
•
•
• Fig. 4.17 Photograph of a broken AISI/SAE 303 stainless steel bolt. 2.5⫻
Sectioning: Cut a 12 mm (0.50 in.) thick slice from the fractured end of the bolt, using a low-speed, gravity-feed saw with a diamond blade. Mounting: Mount the bolt section in epoxy, using normal procedures described previously. Grinding: Using a belt sander with 80-grit silicon carbide paper, grind under water until about 1/3 of the cross section is removed. Continue grinding, using 120-grit silicon carbide paper. Rotate the specimen 90° between each grind, and rinse in flowing water. Stop just prior to the midpoint of the cross section. Continue wet grinding on 240-, 320-, 400-, and 600-grit papers until the midpoint is achieved. Rinse with cotton under running water, rinse in alcohol, and blow dry. Polishing: Polish the specimen on a low-nap cloth on a rotating wheel (150 rpm) with 6 μm diamond paste or spray. Polish until the scratches from the 600-grit grind are removed. Clean with cotton under flowing water, rinse in alcohol and blow dry. Polish on a low-nap cloth on a rotating wheel (150 rpm) with 1 μm diamond paste or spray for two minutes. Clean with cotton under flowing water, rinse in alcohol and blow dry. On a stationary wheel or flat surface, polish the specimen on a napless cloth for 20 seconds, using an aqueous colloidal solution of 0.04 μm silica. Clean with cotton under flowing water, rinse in alcohol and blow dry. Observation: Before etching, observe the polished specimen in the microscope. Figure 4.18 shows an unetched region at the root of one of the threads of the bolt. The corrosion seen at the root of the thread is called stress corrosion. Etching: Electrolytically etch the specimen in a solution of 10% oxalic acid and 90% water at 5 volts for 10 to 20 seconds, using a stainless steel cathode. Rinse the specimen in flowing water, followed by an alcohol rinse and blow drying. Results: In the etched condition, the stress-corrosion condition and cracking is seen following regions of delta phase, which is
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory / 99 aligned longitudinally along the axis of the bolt. Figure 4.19 shows the cracks along the delta phase stringers. Submission 9 is a 2.5 mm (0.10 in.) thick hot-rolled AISI/SAE 1010 steel sheet for hot water heater tanks. Work Required. Measure the ferrite grain size and the amount of pearlite at the center of the sheet. Specimen preparation is as follows. •
•
•
•
Fig. 4.18 Stress-corrosion cracking found at the root of a thread on the fractured bolt shown in Fig. 4.17. Unetched. 32⫻
•
•
•
Fig. 4.19 The stress-corrosion cracks in Fig. 4.18 are shown following
delta ferrite stringer in the austenite matrix. Electrolytically etched in 10% oxalic acid solution at 5 V. 200⫻
•
Sectioning: Using an abrasive cut-off machine with an alumina-bonded blade, cut a 12 mm ⫻ 18 mm (0.50 ⫻ 0.70 in.) sample from the plate. The 18 mm (0.70 in.) length should be parallel to the rolling direction of the plate (this is the longitudinal plane). Mounting: Mount the specimen longitudinal face down in a Bakelite (Union Carbide Corporation) mount, using standard procedures. Grinding: Wet grind the specimen using 320-, 400-, and 600-grit silicon carbide papers. Between each paper, rotate the specimen 90°, and rinse the specimen in flowing water, followed by an alcohol rinse and blow drying. Polishing: Polish the specimen on a rotating wheel (150 rpm), using a low-nap cloth with 6 μm diamond paste or spray. Polish until all the 600-grit scratches are removed. Clean the specimen with cotton in flowing water, rinse with alcohol and blow dry. Polish for two minutes on a rotating wheel (150 rpm), using a low-nap cloth with 0.3 μm alumina. Clean with cotton in flowing water, rinse with alcohol and blow dry. Continue polishing on a stationary wheel or flat surface for 30 to 45 seconds, using a low-nap cloth with aqueous colloidal solution of 0.04 μm silica. Clean the specimen with cotton in flowing water, rinse with alcohol and blow dry. Etching: Etch the specimen in 4% picral plus a few drops of 17% zepherin chloride (a wetting agent). Flush with running water, rinse with alcohol and blow dry. Observation and measurement: The microstructure is shown in Fig. 4.20. The picral etchant only attacks the pearlite colonies or carbides, thus allowing the measurement of the volume fraction of these constituents. Using the procedure described in ASTM E 562, measure the percentage of pearlite in the specimen. Use a 100-point reticle placed in one of the eyepieces (oculars) of the microscope. The ocular must have the ability to adjust the image of the reticle to coincide with the image of the microstructure. (Reticles can be custom-made and purchased from suppliers such as Klarmann Ruling, Inc., Manchester, New Hampshire.) Count the number of points of the grid that fall on top of a pearlite patch (count only a half if the point falls on an edge of the patch). Divide the total counts by 100, and the volume fraction is obtained. In this example, the volume fraction of pearlite is 0.068, or 6.8%. Etching: In order to measure the ferrite grain size, the same etched specimen must be etched in 2% nital (do not repolish to remove the picral etch). Figure 4.21 shows the final microstructure. Observation and measurement: Using the three-circle method described in ASTM E 112, measure the ferrite grain size. This
100 / Metallographer’s Guide procedure can be carried out using a three-circle reticle located in an adjustable-focus ocular. The total number of grainboundary intersections with the three circles must be counted. The total length of the three circles is 500 mm (20 in.). Because pearlite is present in the microstructure, each area must be considered as only a single grain boundary if it is intersected by one of the circles. To calculate the ferrite grain size, the following formula is used:
Grain size (microns) ⫽ (500 millimeters) minus (the percentage of pearlite times 5) divided by (the average number of grain boundaries intersected by three circles per field of view) divided by (the total magnification) multiplied by (1000 microns per millimeter). In this example, the ferrite grain size is 10.8 μm. This converts to an ASTM grain size number of 9.8. From the previous nine submissions, one should have an idea how the metallographer must plan each job at the beginning. The cutting and the mounting procedures must be carefully chosen, so as not to disturb or alter the microstructure. The selection of the specimen orientation with respect to the rolling or forging direction must be considered up front, so that the proper plane is examined. The metallographer must have a basic knowledge of grinding, polishing, and etching procedures, so that the sample is prepared properly the first time and the correct information is obtained. Without this basic knowledge, a metallographer may introduce an artifact into the sample. An artifact is not an actual part of the original microstructure and misleads the metallographer into obtaining false information.
The Metallographer’s Workday at a Small Iron Foundry
Fig. 4.20 Microstructure of AISI/SAE 1010 steel showing ferrite-pearlite
microstructure. Etched in 4% picral to enhance pearlitic areas for percent pearlite measurement. 500⫻
Fig. 4.21 Microstructure of AISI/SAE 1010 steel showing ferrite-pearlite
microstructure. Etched in a solution of equal parts 2% nital and 4% picral to reveal both the patches of pearlite and the ferrite grain boundaries for grain size measurement, using ASTM E 112 standard. 500⫻
An example of a small metallography laboratory is in an iron foundry that manufactures pearlitic ductile cast iron (nodular cast iron) crankshafts with a limited number of sizes and shapes. Ductile cast iron (discussed in Chapters 1 and 2) is produced by inoculating molten iron with magnesium. The magnesium provides nuclei on which graphite nucleates and grows into spheroids. Because of the spheroidal morphology, ductile iron has superior strength and ductility, compared to conventional gray cast iron where the graphite is in the form of flakes. In this foundry, one metallographer handles all the sample preparation for routine quality control. For example, two test blocks (also called keel blocks) are selected, representing the beginning and end of the pour of each heat produced. The test blocks are produced according to ASTM specification A 395 for microstructure and SAE specification J434 for hardness. Therefore, the test blocks are sent to the metallographic lab for examination of the nodular graphite and matrix microstructure and hardness testing. There are approximately 260 to 380 crankshafts cast for each 1000 kg (2200 lb) heat of iron. Eight heats are cast during each eight-hour shift. A single metallographer working the day shift can prepare 48 test block samples sent to the laboratory, representing the production of each 24-hour day. The laboratory is small but fully automated with automatic grinding and polishing equipment. For example, six samples can be ground and polished simultaneously in a matter of minutes. After polishing, the metallographer must examine each specimen in the microscope to rate the distribution and the size of the nodular graphite particles. Rating is done using ASTM A 247 comparison charts, which consist of six standard photographs at 100⫻, showing ranges of graphite shape and size. For example, the ASTM A 247 plate III used by this foundry is shown in Fig. 4.22. Note that the graphite nodules are sized from size 3 (large nodules) to size 8 (small nodules).
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory / 101
Fig. 4.22 ASTM A 247 Plate III method for evaluating the microstructure of nodular graphite in iron castings. Graphite size: magnification 100 diameters. Courtesy of ASTM
102 / Metallographer’s Guide
Fig. 4.22 (continued) ASTM A 247 Plate III method for evaluating the
microstructure of nodular graphite in iron castings. Graphite size: magnification 100 diameters. Courtesy of ASTM
In addition to a metallographic analysis, six Brinell hardness readings are taken on each test block. A designated area on each block is surface ground to remove any decarburization and surface roughness. The average values must meet a minimum specified hardness, acccording to SAE specification J434 for automotive ductile (nodular) iron castings. This SAE specification is used because the crankshafts are intended for automotive applications, and ASTM specification A 536 for ductile iron castings does not have a hardness specification. If any of the six hardness measurements are below the minimum level of hardness or outside the acceptable range for nodular graphite size and distribution, the metallographer must notify the quality-assurance manager, who in turn will make a decision about the disposition of the crankshafts from that particular heat. In some cases, more crankshafts may be sampled and tested from the same heat. As examples, the results of two test block samples are given. The two test blocks represent two different ferritic-pearlitic ductile iron heats. Microstructure is as follows. Test Block 1. Figure 4.23 shows the microstructure of the ferritic-pearlitic ductile iron test block in the etched condition. The microstructure indicates that the matrix is pearlite with halos of ferrite arround the graphite nodules. This halo formation, called a bull’s-eye microstructure, is typical of an as-cast ferriticpearlitic ductile iron. The nodules are spherical and fairly randomly distributed. The graphite would be rated as type 1, size 4, and falls within the specified acceptable limits. Test Block 2. This test block is also an as-cast ferritic-pearlitic ductile iron and should be similar to the microstructure of test block 1. However, as seen in Fig. 4.24, the matrix is pearlite, but the graphite has a different morphology than test block 1. Much of the graphite is nonspherical and has a degenerate form called “vermicular” graphite. The graphite shape and size would fall outside the acceptable limits. The nonspheroidal graphite is the result of “fading” during the pouring of the heat. During fading, the magnesium level in the liquid iron, between the time it was added to the time the iron solidified, decreased to the point where the inoculation was ineffective. The elapsed time between adding the magnesium and pouring the heat must be closely controlled. Obviously, something happened during this process in casting this heat. Because of the fading, the crankshafts from this heat will be rejected. Vermicular graphite differs from nodular graphite and appears to grow by a different mechanism. Hardness is as follows. Test Block 1. This casting is a ferritic-pearlitic ductile iron and must meet the SAE J434 specifications of grade D5506, which has a hardness range of 187 to 255 HB. This grade would typically have a yield strength (if measured) of 379 MPa (55 ksi) and total elongation of 6%. This casting has an average hardness of 235 HB and is within specification. Test Block 2. This casting is also a ferritic-pearlitic iron, with an average hardness of 303 HB. This level of hardness means that the hardness is higher than the top of the range for grade D5506 and therefore, does not meet the specification. The metallographer in this particular job is not faced with the variety of materials submitted in a large research laboratory or
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory / 103 failure analysis laboratory. However, the metallographer must know the basic skills of sample preparation, microstructural interpretation, and hardness testing. The previous examples illustrate the basic skills that are necessary for a metallographer. The next section examines the metallographic laboratories in which these procedures can be carried out.
The Metallographic Laboratory
Fig. 4.23 Representative micrographs of ferrite-pearlite ductile cast iron
Fig. 4.24 Representative micrographs of the ferritic-pearlitic cast iron test
test block 1. (a) Note the ferrite halo around the graphite nodules. The matrix is pearlite. 4% picral etch. 100⫻. (b) Same specimen unetched to compare with ASTM A 247, plate III, in Fig. 4.22. 100⫻
To be effective, a metallographer must have the proper tools and equipment. In the Appendix, there is a list of companies that sell metallographic equipment and supplies. To describe the setup of a metallographic laboratory, two examples are used: a basic laboratory associated with a small manufacturing plant, a foundry, or a heat treating shop employing a single metallographer, similar to
block 2. (a) Note the degenerate form of graphite called “vermicular” graphite. 4% picral etch. 100⫻. (b) Same specimen unetched to compare with ASTM A 247, plate III, in Fig. 4.22. 100⫻
104 / Metallographer’s Guide the small foundry laboratory described previously; and a full-scale laboratory associated with a research department of a major steel company, with a team of two to four metallographers (also described previously). These are probably the extreme examples of a metallographic laboratory. Most laboratories fall somewhere in between. It is recognized that there are obviously physical size constraints and financial restraints that impact the setup of a particular laboratory. However, the following examples may be useful as a guideline.
A Basic Metallography Laboratory All metallographic laboratories, no matter what their size, are broken down into three basic areas: the specimen preparation area, the polishing/etching area, and the observation/photographic area. Ideally, the areas should be separated by walls or partitions, because of potential contamination problems. For example, it is mandatory that the dust and debris generated in the sample preparation area, where specimen cutting and grinding take place, be kept away from the polishing and observation areas. In a basic laboratory, it is recommended that the preparation area be in a separate, well-ventilated room. Also, the observation microscope/ metallographs and other delicate optical instruments in the observation area must be protected from the fumes from etching solutions (usually acids) in the etching area. Therefore, the etching area must be well ventilated, usually with a fume hood, and should be separated from the microscopes by a wall and door. Thus, before any equipment is purchased, make sure that the allocated laboratory space is adequate to partition the three areas. The work flow in the laboratory is very important for optimal efficiency. The details of each area are described subsequently. The Specimen Preparation Area. Samples submitted to the metallographic laboratory should be of a manageable size. As was described with the nine submissions in a previous section in this chapter, the metallographer must know the history of the sample in order to be able to perform an effective job. For example, if the steel has been quenched, the metallographer must avoid any heating of the sample during cutting or mounting. Heating will cause the sample to temper and thus alter the original microstructure. In the preparation area, heating can be caused by the cutting operation or by mounting the specimen in a thermosetting plastic in the mounting press. In the previous example, the specimen must be cut under water or flooded with water and mounted in a cold-setting plastic. These procedures are described in detail in Chapter 7. The sample preparation area must have the equipment to cut or shear a metallographic specimen from the submitted piece. Usually, the specimen should be small enough to fit into a 25.4 or 31.8 mm (1 or 1.25 in.) diameter mount. The equipment in this area includes a band saw and/or a hack saw. Also, an abrasive cut-off machine is useful to obtain a damage-free flat surface. For sheet specimens, a small shear is necessary. After the piece is cut to specimen size, a small belt sander is useful to remove rough edges and saw marks. A sink should be nearby to rinse the specimen of cutting debris.
As discussed in Chapter 7, mounting the specimens can take place in many ways. Usually, the metallographic laboratory has a mounting press to mount the specimen in a thermosetting or thermoplastic mounting compound. The mounting press can be either manual or automatic. In laboratories that deal exclusively with sheet products, the specimens can be mounted in a steel clamp, eliminating the need of the mounting press. Also, a mounting press may not be necessary if all the mounting is done with a cold mounting compound. Some cold mounting compounds, such as epoxy, require a fume hood, because many of these compounds are toxic. Once the specimen (or specimens) is mounted, it must be identified, usually by scribing an identification code on the reverse side of the mount. A small, hand-held electric scriber is useful for this purpose. If a transparent mount is used, the specimen identification can be embedded within the mount. The next step in preparing the mounted specimen is grinding, to provide a flat surface. The grinding operation could take place in the preparation area or in its own area, because of the grinding debris and dust that is generated. Grinding can be done by a hand grinding device, by rotating wheels, or by an automatic grinding/ polishing machine. Either way, the specimen must be ground flat through several consecutive grinding papers, usually starting at 120 grit and ending at 600 grit. Grinding is usually done wet. In most laboratories using hand grinding procedures, three or more consecutive and adjacent rotary wheels are in place, each wheel with a different interchangeable grinding paper, for example, 120-, 240-, 320-, 400-, and 600-grit papers. The Polishing/Etching Area. This area must be kept free of dust and is thus separated from the preparation area by a wall. All specimens entering the polishing area should be cleaned to remove any dust and particles. Manual or automatic polishing can be used. Manual polishing requires one or more rotating wheels, each with a different polishing cloth and polishing compound. For example, one wheel would be fitted with a low-nap cloth with a 6 μm diamond paste, and one wheel would be fitted with a low-nap cloth with a 1μm diamond paste. Another one would use a medium-nap cloth with a 0.3 μm alpha aluminum oxide (alumina) slurry. A fourth wheel would use a medium nap-cloth with a 0.04 to 0.06 μm silicon dioxide slurry. Details of polishing are found in Chapter 7. If automatic polishing is used, the same configuration of rotating wheels are used. In automatic polishing, three or more mounted specimens are polished simultaneously in a special holder. Special care must be taken if both grinding and polishing are carried out on the same machine. A sink should be nearby to rinse each specimen or specimen holder after each polishing step. Near the sink, there should be a ventilated etching area. A fume hood is usually required in the etching area. The freshly polished specimens are etched, rinsed, and dried with a heated-air blow dryer. The Observation/Micrography Area. In this area, one needs a metallurgical microscope. Microscopes are described in detail in the next chapter. For a basic metallographic laboratory, the microscope can also have a camera attachment for photographing the microstructure through the lenses of the microscope. The basic laboratory can use instant (e.g., Polaroid, Polaroid Corporation)
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory / 105 film or a digital camera to avoid the necessity of a dark room for developing and printing cut film. Thus, for a small laboratory, this microscope with camera attachment would suffice for routine micrography. If necessary, a macrocamera, also using instant film, may be required to photograph larger specimens and parts. Near the observation area, the metallographer should maintain a desk and files. Samples can be submitted in the office area so that they can be cataloged. It is important to have a submission form that has the date, name of submitter, number of samples, type of material, composition, specimen history, and what needs to be done. The submission form is the document that is filed for future reference. The office area should have a location for the storage of specimens and records.
A Full-Scale Metallographic Laboratory This type of laboratory is set up to provide full metallographic services, including publication-quality micrographs, extensive quantitative measurements, and so on. This laboratory is equipped for routine and nonroutine metallographic analysis and is usually adjacent to an image analysis system, a SEM, an EPMA, an x-ray diffractometer, and a transmission electron microscope (TEM). For analytical electron microscopy, a scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) may be required. Although some of these specialized instruments have their own specimen preparation facilities, most depend on support from the metallographic laboratory. The use of these instruments is described in Chapter 6. The Specimen Preparation Area. In the preparation area, a band saw, an automatic hack saw, a shear, a drill press, a grinding wheel, a vice, and an abrasive cut-off machine are available. A full-scale laboratory will have a belt grinder to dress specimens. A diamond saw is useful in sectioning samples without inducing deformation. Usually, more than one automated mounting press is needed, because different materials/jobs are being prepared simultaneously by different metallographers. Also, different mounting materials are required, depending on the sample being mounted. A hand-operated mounting press allows the metallographer some flexibility in adjusting and controlling mounting temperature and pressure. In addition to thermosetting and thermoplastic mounting materials, some specimens require epoxy-type mounting. These materials require a mixing area and a fume hood to exhaust the toxic fumes generated from these organic compounds. A small oven should be inside the hood to cure the materials, if required. Also, a vacuum bell jar is needed to remove bubbles and provide good bonding between the mount and specimen. In the preparation area, there should be a sink to rinse specimens and to cool mounting press pistons and cylinders between cycles. Grinding is accomplished by an automatic grinding/rough polishing machine. This type of machine can maintain a high level of productivity in the laboratory and prevent any bottleneck in hand grinding and rough polishing. Although automatic preparation is available, a set of rotating grinding wheels should also be in the grinding area. The Polishing/Etching Area. In the polishing area, only a limited number of polishing wheels are necessary. These may be set up for the finest alumina and silica polishing compounds and
the finest diamond paste. The selection depends on what is being polished and what will be done with the specimen. For example, alumina (aluminum oxide) or silica (silicon dioxide) would never be used if the specimen was being prepared for the SEM or EPMA, where a qualitative or semiquantitative chemical analysis of inclusions in the specimen is required. This is because many inclusions from the steelmaking process contain complex oxides of aluminum and silicon, and contamination from the polishing compound would make their identification difficult. An ultrasonic cleaner should be available to remove polishing debris from the specimen after polishing. The polishing area should also have equipment for electrolytic polishing/etching located within a hood, because some materials, such as Hadfield steel and certain stainless steels, require electrolytic procedures. A hot-air blow dryer is nearby to dry the specimens just after etching and rinsing in alcohol. Acid storage and flammable-material storage cabinets are installed near the hood and sink area. These cabinets should be ventilated to the outside of the laboratory. Premixed etchants can be stored in these cabinets. Some premixed nonflammable and nonexplosive etchants can be temporarily stored on a shelf inside the fume hood. The Observation/Micrography Area. In a full-scale laboratory, the observation room is separated from the micrography room (with digital cameras, a micrography room is not necessary). This is because of the various people using both areas simultaneously; one room requires darkness, the other full lighting. The observation room contains two or more metallurgical microscopes for general observation of the polished and etched specimens. The microscopes can be used to carry out manual grain size or other simple quantitative measurements by having the eyepieces/oculars retrofitted with graduated scales. These microscopes can also be used to quickly examine the prepared specimen before proceeding to the micrography area. One of the microscopes should be equipped with an instant film (e.g., Polaroid) camera attachment or digital camera, if a quick micrograph is needed. Also, a digital camera with a television monitor should be attached to one of the microscopes to allow more than one person to observe the microstructure of the prepared specimen. Wet film micrography can be done on a metallograph in a separate room. However, with the recent advances in digital photography, a metallograph may not be necessary. A macrocamera setup is needed to take photographs at 1⫻ to 20⫻. The macrocamera is ideal for photographing fractures and in documenting the regions where specimens were cut from a larger piece. The metallograph and the macrocamera can use either instant film, 35 mm film, 4⫻5 in. sheet film, or a digital camera. The 35mm and 4⫻5 in. sheet film require separate adjacent darkroom facilities. One darkroom should be used for film loading and film development and a second darkroom for printing. Separate rooms are necessary, because one metallographer may be printing while another may be developing negatives. Interconnecting light-sealed doors are used between the darkrooms. The developing and printing rooms require sinks and good ventilation. The print-developing room should be set up with both manual and automatic development, washing, and drying equipment. A refrigerator should be nearby to store film and darkroom chemicals.
106 / Metallographer’s Guide Many metallographic laboratories have replaced their film development facilities by using digital cameras mounted on a microscope. Near the observation area, an image analysis system is located. Depending on the size of the system, a separate room may be required. The image analysis system, used for automatic quantitative measurements, consists of a microscope, with special automated stage, a video camera mounted on the microscope, and a video monitor to observe the image being measured. The associated computer is usually located in an inconspicuous area. Another portion of the metallographic laboratory should be set up as an office area for the metallographers and for storage of records, specimens, prints, and negatives. Each metallographer should have his or her own dessicator to store polished and/or etched specimens overnight while they are being prepared. A specimen submission table should be in the office area, and a completed submission form should accompany each specimen or group of specimens. Other equipment that can be part of a full-scale metallographic laboratory includes a microhardness tester for measuring hardness traces across regions of a metallographic specimen or measuring the hardness of individual constituents in the microstructure, a Rockwell or Vickers hardness tester for conducting bulk hardness, and possibly a hot hardness tester for measuring hardness at high temperatures. This hardness testing equipment may be in a separate room near the metallographic laboratory. Also, a hot stage accessory for a microscope is useful in studying changes in microstructure on heating and cooling. The hot stage setup should also include a video camera to record microstructural changes that take place upon heating and cooling.
Safety in the Metallographic Laboratory As with any laboratory containing toxic, flammable, corrosive, and explosive chemicals, as well as moving machinery, certain precautions are necessary to protect both the metallographer and the equipment. Some of the important safety issues are briefly mentioned subsequently. In the specimen preparation area, safety glasses must be worn for eye protection. Safety guards must be placed on the band saw and hack saw for protection against accidental injuries. The cut-off machine must be totally enclosed with a safety shield to protect the metallographer from flying shards of the cut-off wheel, in the event the wheel bursts while rotating at high speed. Usually, these machines cannot be started unless the shield is in position. When mounting specimens, especially using cold mounting compounds such as epoxy, proper ventilation is mandatory to protect the metallographer from exposure to the toxic fumes. A hooded area is needed for this purpose. Also, the organic compounds should not come into contact with skin, because the chemicals can be absorbed into the body through the skin. Latex gloves must be worn when handling these chemicals. Moderate precautions must be taken with the thermosetting plastic mounting materials, particularly in avoiding the breathing of dust generated during the
handling of the various powders. Good ventilation would be prudent in the entire mounting area. Precautions should be taken around the mounting presses, because they operate under fairly high pressure and at temperatures of about 150 °C (300 °F). Protective gloves must be worn to prevent burns during handling the hot components of the presses and hot mounted specimens. The belt grinder must have the proper safety shields in place, and extreme care must be taken when grinding a mounted sample by hand. A shield must also be in place to prevent a sample/mount from flying across the preparation room, if a sample is accidentally released while in contact with the moving belt. In the specimen grinding area, the metallographer must take precautions to prevent accidental injury incurred by contact with the moving parts of the automatic grinding/polishing machine or with rotating manual grinding wheels. During manual grinding, a mount or specimen can accidentally fly free of a spinning wheel and cause injury. Shielding can be used for protection. It is important to remove rings from one’s finger while working with rotating equipment. In the polishing/etching area, the same precautions as previously mentioned apply when operating automatic or manual polishing equipment. The most dangerous operations in this area involve the mixing of chemicals, the use of electrolytic polishing/ etching equipment, and the etching of metallographic specimens. In etching, the metallographer stores, mixes, and handles various chemicals, including hydrochloric acid, nitric acid, picric acid, phosphoric acid, potassium ferrocyanide, and so on. References at the end of the chapter offer further details about the safety procedures used for handling these and other chemicals commonly found in the metallographic laboratory. Safety glasses or a face shield must be worn when using and mixing most chemicals. The metallographer must understand the toxic, flammable, corrosive, and explosive nature of each chemical used and must be aware of the proper mixing precautions of the various chemicals employed in etching. This information is located at the “right-toknow” stations located at the entrance to the metallographic laboratory. Here you will find a book containing a materials safety data sheet (MSDS) for each of the chemicals and materials used in the laboratory. Always consult the MSDS if you are not sure about the chemical or substance you are using. You can obtain an MSDS directly from the manufacturer of the chemical or material being used. In addition to proper handling of acids and flammable chemicals, it should be pointed out that two common chemicals used for etching steels are potentially highly dangerous (most chemicals are potentially dangerous). Picric acid, in the form of its characteristic yellow crystals, if allowed to dry out during storage or in a beaker, becomes a powerful explosive. Picric acid is always stored wet. Just the friction and static electricity involved in simply unscrewing the lid or cap of a bottle containing picric acid, which has become dry from long-term storage, can cause an explosion that could seriously harm and possibly kill the metallographer. Many people do not realize that picric acid was used as an explosive before the invention of dynamite. However, picric acid has been successfully and safely used for over 90 years as an etchant for iron and steel specimens. With proper precautions
The Metallographer and the Metallographic Laboratory / 107 taken, picric acid is a safe and vital part of the metallographic laboratory. Picric acid is always stored in a special metal cabinet, and frequent examination of the moisture content must be monitored. If picric acid becomes dry, special precautions must be used to remove the material from the laboratory. The other dangerous chemical is methyl alcohol (also called wood alcohol or methanol), which, up until recent times, was commonly used for the basic ingredient in the most widely used etchants for steel—picral and nital. Methyl alcohol was also used in rinsing excess water from an etched specimen after rinsing in water. It is well known that methyl alcohol is highly toxic to humans, especially if taken internally, for example, by drinking. However, the alcohol is quickly and easily absorbed through the skin and has the same toxicity effect as if drinking the liquid. It is important to note that methyl alcohol can, for the most part, be replaced in the metallographic laboratory by ethyl alcohol. Ethyl alcohol has very little toxicity by absorption through the skin or by simply breathing the fumes. Many modern laboratories have eliminated methyl alcohol and have substituted ethyl alcohol in its place. It must be kept in mind that denatured ethyl alcohol has some concentration of methyl alcohol. Thus, many metallographic laboratories use pure ethyl alcohol (200 proof). Other chemicals are also dangerous; for example, mixing perchloric acid with other acids can cause an explosion from the heat generated during mixing. Perchloric acid mixtures must be kept cold during use and used only in special hoods equipped with wash-down capabilities. It should be remembered that it is no longer permissible to dispose of chemical waste “down the drain.” A modern laboratory has provisions for the proper storage and disposal of hazardous and toxic waste. Another point to remember is to buy only the quantities of chemicals that will be needed in the short term. Procuring large amounts of chemicals, because it is more economical, is no longer a rule of thumb. The shelf life of the chemicals must be considered, as well as the potential dangers involved in storing bulk chemicals. In general, the shelf life of most chemicals should be no more than five years. Many times, it costs far more to dispose of chemicals through a waste disposal company than it does to purchase them. Of course, smoking and/or eating should never be allowed in the metallography laboratory. This is not only because of the presence of flammable chemicals in the polishing/etching area, but the tars from the smoke coat the delicate lenses of the microscopes and delicate metallographic equipment. “No Smoking” signs should be visible throughout the metallography laboratory. Also, flammable chemicals should be stored in a specially designed and well-ventilated safety cabinet.
Other than smoking, there are only a few precautions to observe when in the observation/photographic area. One serious danger with metallographic equipment is in the handling and use of high-pressure zenon lamp bulbs. Special handling is required in replacing this type of bulb. Gloves must be worn at all times, not only to protect the hand, but to prevent fingerprints on the quartz bulb, which can cause premature failure during use. A face shield must also be worn when handling these bulbs. In the photographic areas, the dark room chemicals should be handled properly and spills cleaned up immediately. These chemicals, although toxic, are not usually life threatening under normal use. A metallographic laboratory should also be equipped with an eye rinse facility, in the event that chemicals are splashed into the metallographer’s eyes. A water shower should be nearby in case of a serious chemical spill on clothing and body. Type A, B, and C fire extinguishers must be placed in or near the preparation area and the polishing/etching area, in case of a fire from flammable liquids or other sources. A fire alarm station should be in or nearby the metallography laboratory. A safety cabinet with a fireproof blanket to smother a clothing fire, as well as fully stocked first-aid supplies and special absorbent materials for chemical spills must be in or near the metallographic laboratory. Some industrial laboratories have a chemical spill team that is trained to deal with any kind of chemical spill or gas leak. If a chemical spill team is not viaible, at least someone in the metallographic laboratory should be trained in first aid and chemical spill procedures. A good rule to remember is—if you are not familiar with a chemical or substance, always check for the toxicity and explosive and flammability level before proceeding. This information must be available to the metallographer. Today’s metallography laboratories usually have this information in the form of MSDSs. SELECTED REFERENCES • • • • • •
Engineering Properties of Steel, American Society for Metals, 1982 Prudent Practices for Handling Hazardous Chemicals in Laboratories, National Academy Press, Washington, D.C. N.I. Sax, Dangerous Properties of Industrial Materials, Reinhold Book Corporation, New York C.S. Smith, A History of Metallography, University of Chicago Press, 1960 C.S. Smith, A Search for Structure—Selected Essays on Science Art, and History, MIT Press, 1981 C.S. Smith, Ed., The Sorby Centennial Symposium on the History of Metallurgy, Metallurgical Society Conferences, Gordon & Breach Science Publishers, 1965
Metallographer's Guide: Practices and Procedures for Irons and Steels Bruce L. Bramfitt, Arlan O. Benscoter, p109-148 DOI:10.1361/mgpp2002p109
Copyright © 2002 ASM International® All rights reserved. www.asminternational.org
CHAPTER 5
The Metallurgical Microscope THE METALLOGRAPHER’S most important tool is the metallurgical microscope. Every metallographic laboratory has at least one metallurgical microscope for observing microstructures. This microscope is different from the conventional microscope, which uses transmitted light for transparent material, for example, stained biological specimens. Metallographic specimens are opaque to light, and therefore, a metallurgical microscope needs a source of reflected light. This source of light is discussed in the following sections. Both kinds of microscopes are commonly called optical microscopes. This term is not used in this book, because it is more appropriate to use the name of the source of the incident “beam” being used to illuminate the specimen. For example, a controlled beam of light is used in both the metallurgical and biological microscopes. Thus, they are called light microscopes or light optical microscopes. If a beam of electrons is employed, the microscope would be called an electron microscope, and if a beam of ions is employed, it is called an ion microscope. Electron microscopes are valuable tools for the metallographer and are discussed in the next chapter. When discussing microscopes, one is entering a field of physics called optics, and many terms, concepts, and mathematical expressions are used that are generally unfamiliar to the metallographer. This chapter describes only those items that are necessary for the metallographer to develop a basic understanding of the microscope. Some of the basic terms described in this chapter include resolving power, the virtual image, bright- and dark-field illumination, numerical aperture, focal length, image contrast, depth of field, and spherical and chromatic aberration. For more detailed technical descriptions, there are several references listed at the end of the chapter. The metallographer must obviously know the basics of the microscope in order to use it properly. These are sophisticated scientific instruments, and the metallographer must have the required working knowledge in order to obtain the optimal benefit from the microscope. The modern-day metallographer is very involved with metallographic interpretation and must fine-tune the microscope to obtain the ultimate image for accurate microstructural interpretation. Also, a metallographer may be in the position to recommend or purchase a microscope or metallograph (a dedicated microscope with built-in camera for taking micrographs). A full understanding of the various features of a metallurgical microscope is necessary in order to intelligently procure this type of instrument. These features include such things as apochromatic objectives, hyperplane oculars, vertical illuminators, counting reticles, widefield
oculars, polarization filters, field diaphragms, interferometers, and tungsten-halogen lamps. This chapter discusses all these features. In addition to developing a basic understanding of the metallurgical microscope, the metallographer must also develop a basic understanding of methods to record the microstructural image. The latter part of this chapter is devoted to the metallograph, a metallurgical microscope that is dedicated to micrography, that is, recording the microstructure. First, the metallographer must understand the microscope.
The Microscope The term “microscope” is derived from the Greek words mikros (small) and skopein (to see). The words were combined and given a Latin form by Giovanni Faber, a Roman scientist, in 1625. The microscope is thus an instrument that can see small things. The Dutch eyeglass maker, Zacharias Janssen, has been credited with developing the principles of the compound microscope in 1590. In the mid-1600s, Anthony Van Leewenhoek, a Dutch amateur scientist, was the first to observe microscopic life in pond water and has been called the father of the microscope. He constructed a simple microscope (not a compound microscope) with a power of 270⫻, which, at the time, was the most powerful microscope ever built. An early example of a compound microscope is seen in Fig. 5.1. This type of microscope was used by Robert Hooke, an English microscopist, in 1665. Although the microscope has been used for over 300 years, it was only in the latter part of the 19th century that the microscope was first used for observing metals. As mentioned in Chapter 4, Sir Henry Clifton Sorby, the father of metallography, used the microscope to observe the microstructure of a polished and etched steel specimen.
The Basic Metallurgical Microscope In this book, only the metallurgical microscope is discussed. Examples of this type of microscope are seen in Fig. 5.2 and 5.3. There are two types of metallurgical microscopes: the upright and inverted microscope. In the upright microscope (Fig. 5.2), the specimen is positioned below the objective, and in the inverted microscope (Figure 5.3); the specimen is upside down above the objective. Each type of microscope has advantages and disadvantages, some of which are listed subsequently:
110 / Metallographer’s Guide Upright microscope
The beam of light can be seen on the specimen surface. The specimen must be leveled in order to maintain focus while moving specimen. x-y movement not limited by stage (entire specimen surface can be observed) Polished specimen surface does not contact stage surface Specimen thickness generally limited by distance between objective and stage Limited stage weight capacity Specimen surface can be scribed with a circle while on the stage for special identification (special scribing device needed)
Inverted microscope
Difficult to see the beam of light on the specimen surface Leveling of the specimen is not required. x-y movement not limited by stage opening (diameter of hole limits the area of specimen to be seen) Polished surface may contact the stage surface (potential for scratches) Ideal for large specimens Usually built with ample weight capacity Scribing not possible
address the differences between manufacturers or describe any particular manufacturer’s design. However, the basic features common to all metallurgical microscopes are described subsequently.
The Mechanical System The mechanical system includes those components that are required for moving the specimen beneath or above the light beam and for focusing the image of the microstructure. The stage is a movable flat platform that supports the specimen. A top view of a typical stage on an upright microscope can be seen in Fig. 5.4. On the stage, one can see the specimen directly below the objective of the microscope. All stages have mechanical movement in two horizontally perpendicular directions. This allows the metallographer to move the specimen from left to right
The basic upright metallurgical microscope shown in Fig. 5.2 consists of many important components (the same components are on the inverted metallurgical microscope). These components can be roughly divided into having three main functions: the mechanical system, the optical system, and the illumination (light) system. All these systems are supported and aligned by the stand, the structural frame or body of the microscope, as shown in Fig. 5.2. This microscope has a far different appearance than microscopes of the past. The older metallurgical microscopes were simply adaptations of the standard biological microscope. Up until a few decades ago, most microscope manufacturers produced the standard upright tube-type microscope. Because the metallographer requires a microscope with reflected light, special attachments were made to fit onto the standard microscope. Today, microscope manufacturers make dedicated metallurgical microscopes that meet the special needs of the metallographer. Each manufacturer has its own unique design and special features. This book does not
Fig. 5.2 An upright metallurgical microscope
Fig. 5.1 A sketch of an early 17th century microscope used by Robert Hooke in 1665
Fig. 5.3 An inverted metallurgical microscope
The Metallurgical Microscope / 111 (x-movement) and front to back (y-movement). Coaxial knurled knobs, that is, one knob within the other, are used to make these horizontal adjustments. These knobs can be seen in the center of Fig. 5.5. The amount of x- and y-movement of the stage can be measured by graduated scales along the edge of the stage. These scales are shown along the edges of the stage in Fig. 5.6. Some stages also allow rotation of the specimen. This is generally the case for an inverted microscope. Also, as described subsequently, all metallurgical microscope stages have a third, up-and-down z-motion that is used for coarse and fine focus of the specimen.
Some metallographers use the scales on the stage to obtain a rough measure of the thickness of certain features in the specimen, such as the thickness of a coating or the length of a crack. The scale is usually calibrated in 0.1 mm divisions. For more accurate measurements, an eyepiece reticle is used. The reticle is a graduated scale within the eyepiece that can be focused along with the image of the microstructure. Reticles are discussed later in this chapter. The Coarse- and Fine-Focus Knobs. On older tube-type microscopes, the coarse- and fine-focus knobs adjusted the barrel of the tube up and down, and the stage was at a fixed vertical position. On modern-day microscopes, the upward and downward movements of the stage are controlled by coaxial knurled knobs easily
Fig. 5.5 Coaxial knurled knobs used to move stage in x- and y-directions Fig. 5.4 The stage of an upright metallurgical microscope with a mounted specimen directly beneath the incident beam of light
Fig. 5.7 Coaxial knurled knobs for fine (small, inside knob) and coarse Fig. 5.6 Scales on the stage that indicate the amount of x- and y-motion
(large knob) focus. Note the graduated scale on the fine-focus knob, which indicates the amount of vertical (z-axis) movement.
112 / Metallographer’s Guide accesssible to the metallographer. In metallurgical microscopes, these are the coarse- and fine-focus knobs similar to those shown in Fig. 5.7. For coarse focus, the large-diameter knob is used, and for fine focus, the small-diameter knob is used. Most microscopes have sets of knobs on both sides of the microscope stand for both right- and left-handed operators. In Fig. 5.7, the fine-focus knob has a graduated scale from 0 to 180, with each increment representing a movement of 0.001 mm. The metallographer can use the graduations on the fine-focus knob to measure depth of a feature within a specimen. For example, the depth of a pore can be measured by magnifying the pore so that both its edge and bottom are in the field of view. With the field aperture of the light source fully open, the metallographer first focuses on the edge of the pore and records the graduated location on the barrel of the fine-focus knob. The knob is then moved to focus on the bottom of the pore. By subtracting the location at the bottom of the pore from that at the top of the pore, the depth is determined. Generally, the graduations on the fine-focus barrel are 0.001 to 0.005 mm, depending on the microscope manufacturer. This procedure is described in more detail in the section “Special Procedures for the Metallurgical Microscope” at the end of this chapter. Also, the proper way to focus the microscope on a specimen is described in that section.
The Optical System
Magnification. The main function of the objective is to create a magnified image. This magnified “real” image is created within the tube length of the optical system at a point called the image plane of the eyepiece. Figure 5.8 shows a simplified ray diagram of a metallurgical microscope. In this diagram, the reflected light from the specimen passes through the objective in the form of a magnified image of the specimen. This magnified image is projected onto the image plane of the eyepiece (called the real image). At this point, the image is again magnified by the eyepiece and observed through the lens of the human eye. What the eye actually sees is an image called the virtual image. The virtual image appears about 250 mm (10 in.) from the eye (see Fig. 5.9). The image is inverted, because each time the image passes through a lens system, that is, through the objective, through the eyepiece, and through the lens of the eye to the retina, the image is inverted. Many metallurgical microscopes are purchased with a set of 5, 10, 20, 50, and 100⫻ objectives. A 40 or 60⫻ objective can be used in place of the 50⫻ objective. Some microscopes can be purchased with objectives as low as 1⫻ and as high as 200⫻. The symbol “⫻” is a shortened way to represent the number of times in diameter the image is magnified, that is, 50⫻ means 50 times the diameter, or 50 times magnification. Most modern-day objectives have the magnification boldly engraved on the barrel, as shown in Fig. 5.10. This is a 100⫻ bright-field objective with a
The optical system consists mainly of an objective (the lens assembly close to the object or specimen) and an eyepiece or ocular (the lens assembly close to the eye). They are called lens assemblies, because each objective and eyepiece contains more than one lens element, that is, compound lenses. Some objectives contain up to 14 different lenses. Older microscopes are constructed with a fixed distance between the objective and the eyepiece, called the mechanical tube length. The tube length is measured from the top of the tube to the last thread of the objective, that is, at the point where the unthreaded portion of the objective meets the microscope or nosepiece. Each microscope manufacturer has a fixed tube length that generally varies between 160 and 250 mm. For this reason, most objectives could not be interchanged between microscopes of different manufacturers. However, more and more manufacturers are developing infinity-corrected objective lenses that depend less on tube length. These lenses are discussed in a later section.
The Objective The objective is the most important component of the optical system, because it defines the quality of the magnified image. For this reason, the metallographer, when purchasing a microscope and particularly a metallograph, should always obtain the best objectives possible, even if some other feature of the microscope needs to be sacrificed because of cost. The objective lens controls six important properties of the optical system of a microscope. These are the magnification, numerical aperture, resolving power, depth of field, working distance, and light-gathering capability.
Fig. 5.8 Sketch of the ray diagram for the typical upright metallurgical
microscope showing the location of the human eye, the eyepiece, the real image, the objective, and the polished specimen
The Metallurgical Microscope / 113 numerical aperture (discussed subsequently) of 0.90. Other markings indicate that the objective is to be used “dry.” This means that it is used with air between the tip of the objective and the specimen (the normal situation). Some objectives cannot be used in air, as in the case of an oil-immersion objective, where a special oil is placed between the tip of the objective and the specimen. The oil-immersion objectives provide more resolving power than a dry objective. The oil-immersion objective is discussed later in this chapter. Also in Fig. 5.10, the number “210” indicates that this objective must be used in a microscope with a tube length of 210 mm, and the “0” indicates that the objective is not corrected for a cover slip or cover glass (a thin, glass sheet that is placed on top of the specimen in a biological microscope). If a cover slip is necessary, the objective will indicate its required thickness in millimeters instead of a “0.” Cover slip correction is discussed later. The final magnification in the microscope is usually the magnifying power of the objective times the magnifying power of the eyepiece. For example, a 100⫻ objective with a 10⫻ eyepiece yields a total magnification of 1000⫻. This assumes that the tube factor is 1⫻. Some older microscopes can have tube factors greater or less than 1⫻ (a range from 0.8 to 1.25⫻). The tube factor is usually engraved on the microscope tube. A tube factor is necessary when there is an intermediate lens in the light path between the objective and the eyepiece. Newer microscopes that use infinity-corrected objectives have a special built-in tube lens (discussed later), and a tube factor is not necessary.
Magnification can be achieved by any combination of objectives and eyepieces that produce the required magnification. For example, for a magnification of 250⫻, the metallographer may choose any of the following combinations: Objective
10⫻ 25⫻ 50⫻
Eyepiece
25⫻ 10⫻ 5⫻
Even though the magnification of each combination is identical, the quality of the image produced is different. As discussed previously, the objective defines the quality of the image, and in the three examples listed previously, for the best quality image, the metallographer should usually choose the objective with the highest magnification (numerical aperture), in this example, the 50⫻ objective with the 5⫻ eyepiece. With this combination, most of the total magnification is obtained with the 50⫻ objective, and the higher-power objective will also have the greatest resolving power (discussed subsequently). Numerical Aperture. As can be seen in Fig. 5.10, there are other words and numbers engraved on the barrel of the objective. These include the type of lens and the numerical aperture (NA). The objective shown in Fig. 5.10 has a NA of 0.90. The NA is a measure of the light-gathering ability of the objective lens
Fig. 5.10 Photograph of a 100⫻ bright-field objective with a numerical
Fig. 5.9 Sketch of the same ray diagram in Fig. 5.8, but showing the location of the virtual image
aperture of 0.90. The “dry” indicates that the objective is used without oil between the objective lens and the specimen; the “210” indicates the required 210 mm tube length of the microscope; and the “0” indicates that the objective is used without a cover slip (cover glass).
114 / Metallographer’s Guide assembly. The higher the number, the greater the amount of light collected. Mathematically it is represented by the formula: NA ⫽ sine ␣
where ␣ is the aperture half-angle of the most tilted (oblique) light rays entering the objective lens, and μ is the refractive index of the medium (i.e., air where μ ⫽ 1.0) in front of the lens. In Fig. 5.11, which is a schematic representation of light rays being reflected from the specimen to the objective lens, the aperture half-angle ␣ is shown as 18°. From the previous equation, this objective would have a NA of 0.30. Figure 5.12 has been included to further illustrate the importance of the light-gathering ability of an objective. In these figures, ray diagrams represent objectives with a NA of 0.70 (Fig. 5.12a) and a NA of 0.25 (Fig. 5.12b). In both cases, the objectives are assumed to be correctly focused on the specimen. In Fig. 5.12(a), the aperture half-angle is 45°, and all seven reflected rays pass through the objective lens. In Fig. 5.12(b), with a aperture half-angle of 15°, only three of the seven rays pass through the objective lens. In both figures, the angular relationship of the seven rays are identical. Therefore, the objective in Fig. 5.12(a) has the greatest light-gathering ability and thus, the highest NA. With air having a refractive index of 1.0, the maximum practical NA is about 0.95. However, when a special oil is placed between the lens and the specimen, the NA can be increased to 1.40. Most oils that are supplied by microscope manufacturers have a refractive index of 1.515, which matches the refractive index of the glass in the lens. Special objectives, called oil-immersion objectives, are used with oil. With this almost-perfect matching, the specimen is actually coupled to the lens, and the lens can gather more reflected light. This is discussed subsequently in the subsection “Oil-Immersion Objective.” Resolving Power. The higher the numerical aperture, the greater the resolving power or resolution of the microscope.
Resolving power is the ability of the objective to distinguish features that are closely spaced. The resolution can be determined by the following formula: d ⫽ (0.61 )/NA
where d equals the distance between two points or lines being resolved and is the wavelength of the light from the illumination source (i.e., tungsten-filament lamp, etc.). Thus, the resolving power is larger when the NA is large and the wavelength of the light is short. With a good oil-immersion lens (high NA), the limit of resolution is about 0.2 μm. To show the effect of NA on the quality of a microstructural image, Fig. 5.13 shows micrographs of the same field of pearlite in a gray cast iron taken with 40⫻ 0.55 NA and 0.65 NA objectives. Both micrographs were taken at the same magnification of 600⫻. Note the sharper image in Fig. 5.13(b), the micrograph taken with the 0.65 NA objective, especially the resolution of cementite lamella in the pearlite (see arrows). Filters can also be used to enhance the resolving power of an objective. For light, the shorter wavelengths are at the violet-bluegreen end of the spectrum, and the higher wavelengths are at the orange-red end of the spectrum. The wavelength of the light beam can be controlled by filters and the actual light source itself. Figure 5.14 shows coarse pearlite in a pearlitic gray cast iron. The
Fig. 5.11 Sketch of an objective and a specimen showing the cone of light
that can enter the objective lens from reflection from the specimen; ␣ is the half-angle and is used to calculate numerical aperture. The working distance is indicated as the distance between the bottom of the lens and the top of the specimen.
Fig. 5.12 Sketches showing two different objectives with half-angles of (a)
45° and (b) 15° and numerical apertures of 0.70 and 0.25,
respectively
The Metallurgical Microscope / 115 micrographs in Fig. 5.14 were taken without a filter and with a green filter. Note the improved resolution of the pearlite in Fig. 5.14(b), the micrograph taken with the green filter (see the arrow). Useful magnification is a term that applies to resolving power. In the microscope, magnifying an image beyond the resolving power of the lens system produces a magnified image but no further detail in the image. The magnification range up to the point of optimal detail is useful magnification (also called significant or meaningful magnification). Any magnification above this point is called empty magnification. From theory, empty magnification is pro-
duced above a magnification of 1000 times NA. Therefore, using this rule, an objective with a NA of 0.95 would produce a useful magnification limit of 950⫻, and from experience, most metallographic work is conducted at or below a magnification of 1000⫻.
Fig. 5.13 Micrographs of pearlitic gray cast iron taken with 40⫻ objec-
Fig. 5.14 Micrographs of pearlitic gray iron taken (a) with and (b) without
tives of different numerical apertures. Micrograph (a) taken with an objective with NA ⫽ 0.55 and micrograph (b) taken with NA ⫽ 0.65. Note the better resolution in (b) (see arrows). The white constituent is ferrite, the lamellar constituent is pearlite, and the dark gray flakes are graphite. 4% picral etch. 600⫻. Courtesy of J. Wright, Lehigh University
a green filter. Note the improved resolution in the micrograph taken with the green filter (see arrows). The light gray speckled constituent is steadite (iron phosphide eutectic), the lamellar constituent is pearlite, and the dark gray flakes are graphite. 4% picral etch. 600⫻. Micrographs by J. Wright, Lehigh University
116 / Metallographer’s Guide Depth of Focus. Another important property of an objective lens is depth of focus (also called depth of field), which is the maximum amount of vertical movement of the stage or objective without any noticeable change in focus on the specimen. The depth of field is inversely proportional to the square of the NA as seen in the following equation: μ Depth of field ⫽ ⫾ 2NA2
where μ is the index of refraction of the medium between objective and specimen, for example, μ ⫽ 1 for air; and is the wavelength of the light (mm), for example, green ⫽ 548 nm. This means that an objective with a lower NA will allow a greater depth of focus. Thus, for rough or heavily etched surfaces, a low NA lens must be used. Working Distance. The working distance is the distance between the tip of the objective lens and the specimen, as illustrated in Fig. 5.11. The working distance decreases as the power of the objective increases and generally, as the NA increases. For example, the working distance of a 10⫻ objective may be about 10 mm, whereas the working distance of a 100⫻ objective may be less than 0.5 mm. With short working distance objectives, the metallographer must take extreme care in order to avoid damaging the tip of the objective by chipping, cracking, or scratching the glass lens by contact with the specimen. Some objectives with short working distances are spring loaded, which allows the bottom portion of the objective to retract into the objective barrel if the tip is inadvertently pressed against the specimen. This is a safety feature to minimize damage to the exposed objective lens. However, there is no reason to ever touch the specimen surface with the objective lens. As is seen later in this chapter, there are specially designed objectives with long working distances. For example, a long working distance objective is required when observing a specimen through a glass or quartz window of a hot stage (a special attachment that heats the specimen under vacuum or inert gas). Basic Characteristics of the Objective. The following basic rules apply to all objective lenses (within their class). As magnifying power increases: • • • •
5.15 shows a nosepiece with five objectives. The objectives are mounted in progressive rotational order. As the metallographer rotates the nosepiece, there are obvious mechanical stops built into the nosepiece that allow for proper optical alignment with the beam of light. This alignment with the optical axis means that the objective is parcentric. During rotation of a nosepiece with five objectives, the first objective in rotation might be the 5⫻ objective, followed by the 10⫻ objective, the 20⫻ objective, the 50⫻ objective, and finally, the 100⫻ objective. The nosepiece mounted on a microscope shown in Fig. 5.16 is rotated clockwise, looking at the nosepiece from the specimen, to achieve the
Fig. 5.15 A typical nosepiece from a metallurgical microscope. This nosepiece accomodates five objectives.
Working distance decreases Lens diameter decreases Field of view decreases Depth of field decreases As NA increases:
• • •
Resolving power increases Useful magnification increases Light-gathering increases
The Nosepiece For convenience, most metallurgical microscopes have a rotating nosepiece where three or more objectives are mounted. Figure
Fig. 5.16 Nosepiece mounted on a typical upright metallurgical microscope
The Metallurgical Microscope / 117 previously mentioned order of magnification. When the nosepiece is rotated from objective to objective, the field remains in approximate focus. This is known as being parfocal. The only adjustment may be to slightly adjust the fine-focus knob. However, the central features of the microstructure remain centered. Of course, the field is much larger at the lower magnifications. This is shown in Fig. 5.17 where the same field is photographed after
rotation of the nosepiece to 5, 10, 20, 50, and 100⫻ (using a 10⫻ eyepiece). In this example, a white cast iron is shown with a dominant feature of massive cementite platelets (white constituent). The rotating nosepiece is an important advantage in metallography, because the metallographer can quickly find the area of interest at low magnification and then rotate the nosepiece to a higher magnification for better detail of the features in the field. In
Fig. 5.17 Micrographs taken of the same field of a white cast iron by rotating a five-objective nosepiece through (a) 5⫻, (b) 10⫻, (c) 20⫻, (d) 50⫻, and (e) 100⫻. The white constituent is cementite, and the dark constituent is pearlite. 4% picral etch. Final magnification (a) 50⫻, (b) 100⫻, (c) 200⫻, (d) 500⫻, and (e) 1000⫻
118 / Metallographer’s Guide fact, this should be normal procedure when examining a specimen for the first time. Always scan the specimen at low magnification, that is, using the 5⫻ objective, to find the field of interest and then rotate the nosepiece to progressively higher magnifications. It is not advisable to rotate directly from a 5⫻ objective to a 100⫻
objective, because changing the magnification from 50⫻ to 1000⫻ is too large a change. Also, there may be a chance of hitting the specimen with the lens of the highest magnification objective (the longest objective with the shortest working distance), especially if the objective is not fully screwed into the nosepiece. This loosening of objectives can actually happen when the nosepiece is rotated by using the objectives as a handle instead of properly using the knurled ring on the nosepiece for rotation. If the metallographic laboratory has more than one microscope, always place the objectives in the same rotational order in the nosepiece. This simple procedure will prevent damage to the expensive higher-power objectives with the very short working distances.
Optical Defects in Objectives Microscope manufacturers strive to produce the perfect objective. This is almost impossible, because even if the glass lens is ground to perfection, there are errors or aberrations that are present due to the inherent nature of refraction when light passes through air and into a glass lens, and due to the different wavelengths within the visible light spectrum. Therefore, all lenses need to be corrected for these aberrations so that the metallographer will observe a near defect-free image of the microstructure, that is, an image that is as close as possible to the actual microstructure. In order to understand how these aberrations arise, the metallographer must understand how light interacts with a lens. In most cases, we are dealing with convex lenses where the lens surfaces are curved outward, as seen in Fig. 5.18(a), as opposed to concave lenses where the lens surfaces curve inward, as seen in Fig. 5.18(b). The convex lens is a magnifying lens that is necessary to produce the highly magnified image observed in the microscope (most compound objectives contain both convex and concave lenses). When a beam of light travels through air and then through the glass lens, the speed of the beam of light decreases. The speed change creates a phenomenon called refraction. A simple example of refraction is observed when a pencil is placed into a container of water, as seen in Fig. 19. The portion of the pencil in the water appears to bend at an angle to the portion of the pencil in the air above the water. In a lens, this bending of light, or refraction, is
Fig. 5.17 Micrographs taken of the same field of a white cast iron by
rotating a five-objective nosepiece through (a) 5⫻, (b) 10⫻, (c) 20⫻, (d) 50⫻, and (e) 100⫻. The white constituent is cementite, and the dark constituent is pearlite. 4% picral etch. Final magnification (a) 50⫻, (b) 100⫻, (c) 200⫻, (d) 500⫻, and (e) 1000⫻
Fig. 5.18 Sketches of a (a) convex and a (b) concave lens
The Metallurgical Microscope / 119 the feature that makes the lens work. However, refraction can create aberrations. Because the beam of light (called white light) is composed of various primary colors (red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet), the colors observed in a rainbow, and each color has a different wavelength, the speed of each color is slowed at a different rate as it passes through the glass. For example, red has a wavelength of 656 nm, green a wavelength of 548 nm, blue a wavelength of 486 nm, and violet a wavelength of 405 nm. These differences in wavelength can be seen when a beam of light passes through a prism and the beam splits into its primary colors. This effect creates two kinds of lens aberrations: chromatic aberration and spherical aberration. Chromatic aberration is created by the different refraction angles (different wavelengths) of the various colors of the light beam passing through the lens. Axial (longitudinal) chromatic aberration is illustrated in Fig. 5.20 where light rays passing through a convex lens separate into blue, yellow-green and red colors along the optic axis. This aberration must be corrected, because all the colors should have one common focal point and not a separate focal point for each color. The lens designer must
Fig. 5.19 A photograph of a pencil immersed in a dish of water showing
correct for this disparity in focus. There is also a lateral (transverse) chromatic aberration, where the light of one color has a greater magnification than another color. Without correction, the image as seen in the microscope will have color fringes. Spherical aberration is created by the different bending angles of the light rays as they pass through a convex lens. This is illustrated in Fig. 5.21. The light rays entering the outer diameter of the lens (the thinnest part of the lens) are called marginal rays. These rays have a different focal point than the axial rays that enter and exit the central portion of the lens (the thickest part of the lens). The lens must be corrected in order to create one common focal point. Coma is another lens defect that produces comet tails on images of points in the specimen. It is more pronounced in those light rays that pass through the lens further away from the lens axis. Coma can be corrected by grinding the proper surface curvature of the lens. Astigmatism is a lens defect that creates lines in the image from points in the specimen. The word astigmat means “not a point,” and, as with coma, it can be corrected by grinding the proper curvature. Curvature of field is a serious defect in images produced by convex lenses. In the metallurgical microscope, the image must be as flat as possible so that the center of the image is in as sharp a focus as the outer edges. Curvature of field creates blurred outer edges. It is very difficult to design an objective without having some degree of curvature of field, and thus, these specially designed objectives are very expensive. In some microscopes, the curvature of field created in the image of the objective can be corrected by the eyepiece. Distortion is another defect that cannot be tolerated in the metallurgical microscope. The image created by the objective can bow in or out at the outer edges. In other words, if examining a square grid of perpendicular lines, the grid at the center (axis) would represent the proper spacing, but near the edge of the image, the lines become curved and no longer represent the true grid spacing. This can be seen in Fig. 5.22 where it is greatly exaggerated. Distortion is produced by a lens having a different magnification at the central axis than at the outer edges of the lens. Most modern metallurgical microscopes have been corrected for
the effect of refraction of light, that is, the apparent bending of the pencil in water due to a difference in refractive index between water and air
Fig. 5.20 Sketch of a ray diagram of light passing through a convex lens
with chromatic aberration. The rays passing through the outer portion of the lens split into different focal lengths of blue, yellow-green, and red light because of the different wavelengths.
Fig. 5.21 Sketch of a ray diagram of light passing through a convex lens
with spherical aberration. The rays passing through the center of the lens (axial rays) have a different focal point than the rays passing through the edge of the lens (marginal rays).
120 / Metallographer’s Guide
Fig. 5.22 Sketch of a distorted image. (a) Barrel-type image and (b) pincushion-type image
parallax, which eliminates distortion. Therefore, it is very rare to see distortion in modern microscopes.
Types of Objectives The selection of an objective can be quite confusing for the beginning metallographer. This is because there are many different types of objectives. Some have corrections for various lens aberrations. These corrections, discussed previously, include spherical aberration, coma, astigmatism, distortion, and chromatic aberration. Some of these same aberrations can be found in the lenses of the human eye, and eyeglasses are used to correct for these errors. Some objectives have glass lenses; some have lenses made from calcium fluoride (fluorite). Lens designers even use different types of glass, for example, flint glass or crown glass. Some objectives are produced for exceptional flatness of field, some are produced with a longer focal length, and others are produced for dark-field applications. The metallographer should be familar with the various types of objectives available for the microscopes in the metallographic laboratory. Some of these objectives are briefly described subsequently. Achromatic Objective. This is the most commonly used and least-expensive objective for the metallurgical microscope. The objective is partially corrected for chromatic aberration (discussed previously) by correcting for two colors, usually green and red. This means that the red and green colors of the spectrum of light are brought into the same focal point. An achromatic objective, or simply an “achromat,” is also partially corrected for spherical aberration for one color, usually the green color or the yellowgreen color. Therefore, when using an achromat, it is best to use a green or yellow-green filter to take into account this later correction. Because they are only partially corrected, they are not
suitable for color micrography but are well suited for black and white micrography. An advantage of the achromatic objective is that it has a larger working distance than the more highly corrected objectives, for example, the apochromatic objective. This is because there are fewer lens elements in the objective. A larger working distance provides for more clearance between the tip of the objective and the specimen surface. With a larger clearance, there are fewer chances of chipping, scratching, and cracking the exposed lens. Some objectives are spring loaded to minimize such damage. An achromatic objective is generally not identified with a code or symbol engraved on the barrel of the objective, whereas most all the other objectives have special identification. Semiapochromatic (Fluorite) Objective. These objectives, called fluorites, employ fluorite instead of glass for the lens elements. Fluorite is the mineral fluorspar (calcium fluoride) and can be ground into lenses from either natural or synthetic crystals. These fluorite objectives are more expensive than the achromats. They are corrected for chromatic aberration for two colors, the red and blue or the red and green colors, and are corrected for spherical aberration in two colors. This means that these objectives can be used for color micrography as well as black and white micrography. Usually these objectives are identified by a “Fl” or “Fluor” symbol that is engraved on the barrel. Apochromatic Objective. These objectives are more expensive than the achromats and fluorites, because they are more highly corrected. Therefore, these are the finest objectives available and are particularly suited for higher-magnification metallography. They are chromatically corrected for three colors, the primary colors red, blue, and green, and spherically corrected for at least two colors, generally green and blue. This means that an apochromatic objective will perform best with a green or blue filter. These objectives are used for color micrography. They are also very suitable for black and white micrography. Apochromatic objectives usually have higher NAs than the achromatic and fluorite objectives and thus have the potential for higher resolving power. Generally, these objectives are only used for magnifications of 500⫻ and above. Even though these objectives are chromatically corrected for three colors and spherically corrected for two colors, they are still not optimally corrected. Further corrections of the apochromatic objective can be made by the proper selection of a compensating eyepiece. Therefore, when using apochromatic objectives for optimal correction, it is important to couple the objective with the compensating eyepiece of the same microscope manufacturer. Generally an apochromatic objective is identified with an “Apo” engraved on the barrel. One manufacturer uses “CF,” or chromatic-free, on the barrel of their apochromatic objective. All the aberrations have been corrected for in the objective, and they do not depend on the eyepiece for additional corrections. This type of objective is ideal for chargecoupled device (CCD) digital cameras that do not require an eyepiece. Plano Objective. The plano objectives are corrected for flatness of field and therefore are sometimes called flat-field objectives. The previous three types of objectives are generally not corrected for flatness of field unless they are engraved plan-achromatic, planfluorite, or plan-apochromatic. If the objec-
The Metallurgical Microscope / 121 tive is engraved with just “plano,” “plan,” or “pl,” it is a plan-achromatic objective. A plan-apochromatic objective may be engraved as “Pl apo.” The plan-apochromatic objective is very expensive and is the most highly corrected objective available for the microscope. These expensive objectives may not be needed for a microscope that is only used for observation, because the metallographer can accept some curvature of field and simply focus and refocus on the field of interest. However, if the instrument is used for micrography, a plano objective will produce the flatness of field necessary for the entire micrograph. Phase Contrast Objective. When the optical system is functioning under phase contrast conditions (transmitted light), special phase contrast objectives are used with a special vertical illuminator (condenser). A phase contrast objective may have “Phaco,” “Ph,” “DL,” or “DM” engraved on the barrel of the objective. Phase contrast illumination is not used for specimens of steel or cast iron but is widely used in transmitted light for biological specimens. Strain-Free Objective. For ferrous specimens, differential interference contrast, or the Nomarski technique, is more commonly used than phase contrast (previously mentioned). In this case, a strain-free objective is used, and this objective may be engraved with an “N” for Nomarski. Differential interference contrast is discussed later in this chapter. Also, strain-free objectives are used for interference illumination, described later in this chapter. These objectives can be engraved with an “IK” for interference contrast, “NIC” for Nomarski interference contrast, “DIC” for differential interference contrast, “POL” for polarized light, or “Pol. Interf.” for polarization interference contrast. A
Fig. 5.23 Photograph of a 40⫻ dark-field objective (left) and a 40⫻
bright-field objective (right). Both objectives have a numerical aperture of 0.65, a required tube length of 210 mm, and are used dry. In the dark-field objective, note the annular opening around the central objective lens for the incident light path.
strain-free lens may also be engraved with the letters “SF” for strain-free. Dark-Field Objective. Most objectives are produced for bright-field illumination. Bright field is the normal operating illumination of the metallurgical microscope, where the incident light passing through the objective is perpendicular to the specimen surface. However, there are certain applications where dark-field illumination is required. In these cases, the incident light radiates from the objective at oblique angles to the specimen surface. The dark-field objective illuminates the specimen with a 360° circle of light around the periphery of the objective barrel, thus allowing only the reflected light to pass through the glass lenses of the objective. Dark-field and bright-field objectives are shown in Fig. 5.23. Note the annular opening surrounding the central lens of the dark-field objective (left). This circular opening allows the illumination light to pass around the outer portion of the objective (just inside the objective barrel) while the reflected light passes through the lens of the objective. More details on dark-field illumination can be found later in this chapter. A dark-field objective usually has a “D,” “DF,” or “BD” engraved on its barrel and is larger in diameter than a bright-field objective, as seen in Fig. 5.23. Long-Working-Distance Objective (Quartz Corrected). Special objectives with a long working distance are produced for hot-stage microscopy. The long working distance is necessary, because the objective must be kept at a safe distance from the heated specimen. Generally, the working distances range from 6 to 16 mm. Also, these objectives may be corrected for quartz. This is because there is usually a clear quartz window between the specimen and the objective. As described previously, these objectives are corrected for the quartz window. An objective used for the hot stage may display an “H” (hot) or “L” (long working distance) engraved on the barrel. Sometimes the barrel of the objective will be engraved with the word “Quartz.” Oil-Immersion Objective. Special oil-immersion objectives are designed to give the highest resolution obtainable with a light microscope. These objectives are used with a drop of special oil that is placed between the tip of the objective and the specimen. The oil has the same refractive index as the glass used in the objective lens (μ ⫽ 1.515). Because the NA is determined by the refractive index and aperture half-angle of light entering the tip of the objective (explained previously in the section “Numerical Aperture”), an oil-immersion objective can have a much higher NA than a dry objective. In all the other objectives described previously, the light must pass through air with a refractive index of unity (μ ⫽ 1). In passing from the glass lens with μ ⫽ 1.515 into air with μ ⫽ 1.0, the rays of light are bent by the phenomenon of refraction (see Fig. 5.19). This also occurs when the same light is reflected off the specimen back through air into the glass lens of the objective. This bending of light causes a portion of the light to be lost. If the bending of light is eliminated, very little light is lost, and therefore, most of the light passes to the specimen and back through the lens. Earlier in this chapter it was mentioned that the more light gathered by the objective, the higher the NA. Oilimmersion objectives can have a NA up to about 1.40. The upper limit for dry objectives is NA ⫽ 0.95. Oil-immersion objectives at
122 / Metallographer’s Guide 160⫻ are available for high-resolution requirements. Figure 5.24 shows a comparison of the image produced with an oil-immersion objective (NA ⫽ 1.3) and a dry objective at the upper limit of NA (NA ⫽ 0.95). Both micrographs were taken at the same magnification of 1300⫻. In this fully pearlitic microstructure, one can see the improved resolution using the oil-immersion objective.
Fig. 5.24 Micrographs of an AISI/SAE 1080 steel showing the same field of
pearlite taken with (a) a dry objective of NA ⫽ 0.90 and (b) and oil-immersion objective of NA ⫽ 1.30. Note the improved resolution in the micrograph taken with the oil-immersion objective. 4% picral etch. 1300⫻. Courtesy of S. Lawrence, Bethlehem Steel Corporation
Generally, oil-immersion objectives are only rarely used, because they are not required for the vast majority of metallographic specimens. Oil-immersion objectives require special care and must be cleaned after each use. The special procedure used for an oil-immersion objective can be found in the procedures section at the end of this chapter. An oil-immersion objective is usually engraved with “Oil,” “Oel,” or “HI” (homogeneous immersion). Also, any objective with a NA greater than 1.0 is usually an oil-immersion objective. Infinity-Corrected Objectives. Newer metallurgical microscopes have objectives that are “infinity” corrected. In a conventional microscope, the rays of reflected light emerging from the back lens of the objective lens are not parallel. With an infinitycorrected objective, the reflected light rays emerging from the back lens of the objective are parallel (projected toward infinity). To use these objectives, a tube lens is mounted in the path between the objective and the eyepiece (above the vertical illuminator). This lens brings the parallel rays from the objective into convergence (focus) onto the focal plane of the eyepiece diaphragm (described in the section “Types of Eyepieces” later in this chapter). The advantage of an infinity-corrected lens is that the light rays are parallel when passing through the vertical illuminator (bright-field reflected mirror) region of the microscope tube. This means that optical components, that is, polarizers, can be inserted into the column of parallel light rays without introducing optical errors (aberrations) and at an exact magnification of 1⫻. Some infinity-corrected objectives have the symbol “⬁” engraved on the barrel. These objectives are less restricted to a fixed tube length of the microscope and in some special microscopes, allow movement of the objective rather than the stage for focus. Retractable Objectives. Some objectives with a short working distance are spring loaded to prevent damage to the exposed lens of the objective when inadvertently pressed against the specimen. (Note that there is no circumstance where any objective should physically touch the specimen.) A spring-loaded assembly allows the bottom part of the objective to retract into the objective barrel. This type of objective may be useful for students who are not familiar with a metallurgical microscope. Experienced metallographers have less need for this feature. Cover-Glass-Corrected Objectives. It must be remembered not to mix objectives and eyepieces of different microscope manufacturers and even from different microscopes of the same manufacturer. Generally, when a metallurgical microscope is purchased, the set of objectives and eyepieces will only be used for that model of microscope. This is because of different tube lengths, tube factors, and other basic characteristics of the microscope. It should also be pointed out that the objectives for a biological microscope should not be used on a metallurgical microscope. This is because the objectives for the biological microscope are corrected for a cover glass (also called cover slip). The cover glass is a thin glass sheet that is placed over the biological specimen (blood stain, biopsy tissue slice, etc.). The standard cover glass thickness is 0.17 mm (other thicknesses are available). One way to distinguish a cover-slip-corrected objective from an uncorrected objective is by “0.17” engraved on the barrel of the objective. For example, in Fig. 5.25 a cover-glass-corrected
The Metallurgical Microscope / 123 eyepieces, as seen in Fig. 5.27. In a metallographic laboratory with many people using the microscope, the metallographer should remember his or her unique interpupillary distance so that the binocular attachment can be reset each time the microscope is used. Some microscopes have another eyepiece adjustment called the diopter scale, as seen in Fig. 5.28. This adjustment compensates for differences in focus of the left and right eyes. In Fig. 5.28, the diopter is set at the zero position. The metallographer should know his or her unique diopter settings.
Fig. 5.25 Photograph of two objectives. The objective on the left, marked
“170/-,” is for a tube length of 170 mm to be used without a cover slip (cover glass). The objective on the right, marked “170/0.17,” is for a tube length of 170 mm but must be used with a 0.17 mm thick cover slip.
objective is shown on the right, where one can see the cover glass thickness alongside the tube length as “170/0.17.” The 10⫻ uncorrected objective at the left in Fig. 5.25 has a dash, “-”, next to the tube length. The dash means with or without cover glass. The 100⫻ cover-glass-corrected objective in this photograph is an oil-immersion lens (“Oel”) with a NA of 1.30. The uncorrected objective is a dry objective with a NA of 0.25. Some microscope manufacturers engrave a “NCG,” “NC,” or “0” on the objective to indicate no cover glass.
Types of Eyepieces The eyepieces or oculars of the metallurgical microscope are not as complex as the objectives. The function of the eyepiece is to magnify the image produced by the objective. Therefore, the image of the microstructure is magnified twice: first by the objective and then again by the eyepiece. Thus, a 20⫻ objective would magnify the image 20 times, and a 10⫻ eyepiece increases the magnification to 200 times (assuming no other lenses are between the eyepiece and the objective). This final image in the eye appears as a “virtual image” at a distance of about 250 mm (10 in.) from the eye (as shown in Fig. 5.9). Eyepieces usually are manufactured with magnifications of 5, 6.3, 8, 10, 12.5, 20, 25, and 30⫻. The magnification is engraved on the top ring of the eyepiece. For most metallographic work, the 10⫻ eyepiece is appropriate. The eyepiece fits into the eyepiece tube of the microscope. Many metallurgical microscopes have two eyepieces that fit into a binocular attachment to the main tube of the microscope, as seen in Fig. 5.26. The image from the objective is split into the two eyepieces by a prism. With two eyepieces, there is less eye strain for the operator. The eyepiece tubes are adjusted for the correct interpupillary distance, that is, the distance between the pupils of one’s eyes. For most people, this is between 60 and 70 mm. Usually, an interpupillary scale is located between the two
Fig. 5.26 A binocular attachment for a metallurgical microscope
Fig. 5.27 A binocular attachment showing the interpupillary scale (between the eyepieces)
124 / Metallographer’s Guide In addition to a binocular, many metallurgical microscopes have a trinocular tube arrangement, where the third tube is used for mounting a ground-glass screen, video camera, or photographic camera attachment, as shown in Fig. 5.29. In purchasing a microscope, always select the types of objectives first, then select the eyepieces that match these objectives. One cannot mix objectives and eyepieces and expect optimal performance from the microscope. In addition to the magnification being engraved on the top ring of the eyepiece, some eyepieces have a field number engraved on the ring. The field number specifies the specimen area that will appear in the field of view. For example, an eyepiece may have the number 18 engraved near the magnification number. This is the field number. If the field number is divided by the objective magnification, the result will be the diameter of the field of view on the specimen. For example, at 100⫻, if the field number is 18, then the field of view on the specimen will be 0.18 mm in diameter. Wide-field eyepieces have field numbers of 25 to 32. Simple eyepieces are constructed, generally, with two glass lenses. The top lens near the eye is called the eye lens and the inner lens is called the field lens. The lenses are planoconvex, which means that one surface is flat and the other convex or curved outward. There are three basic types of eyepieces: the Huygenian eyepiece, the Ramsden eyepiece, and the compensating eyepiece. These are described subsequently. The Huygenian Eyepiece. This is the least expensive and most commonly used eyepiece. The Huygenian eyepiece consists of a planoconvex eye lens and a planoconvex field lens with the convex sides of both lenses facing downward. The lens was designed by Christian Huygens, a 17th century Dutch scientist. Between the two lenses there is a fixed circular opening or diaphragm where the magnified image from the objective is
projected. A schematic representation of the cross section of a Huygenian eyepiece is shown in Fig. 5.30. The diameter of the diaphragm determines the circular size of the field that is observed
Fig. 5.29 A trinocular arrangement for an upright metallurgical micro-
scope. In addition to the binocular eyepieces, there is a close-coupled device attached to the camera port of the microscope.
Fig. 5.28 A binocular attachment showing the diopter scale at the base of one of the eyepieces
Fig. 5.30 Sketch of the cross section of a Huygenian eyepiece
The Metallurgical Microscope / 125 in the eyepiece. Also, special measuring micrometer discs or grids (called reticles or graticules) can be placed on the diaphragm. These scales and grids thus appear as if they are superimposed on the microstructural image. Simple Huygenian eyepieces are somewhat self-corrected for lens aberrations, because many of the aberrations in the eye and field lenses cancel each other. Some manufacturers produce more highly corrected Huygenian eyepieces that contain two-part (doublet) or three-part (triplet) eye lenses. These are multiple lenses that are bonded together as one lens. In general, Huygenian eyepieces are used with the lesser-corrected, lower-power achromatic objectives of 5⫻ to 40⫻ magnification. This type of eyepiece should not be used with the higher-power achromatic objectives or any of the fluorite, apochromatic, or plano objectives. These objectives require eyepieces of special correction. The Huygenian eyepiece usually can be recognized by the lack of any identification on the top eyepiece ring. The corrected eyepieces have identification letters or symbols. The Ramsden Eyepiece. The Ramsden (or orthoscopic-type) eyepiece differs from the Huygenian eyepiece in that the convex portion of the field lens faces upward and the circular diaphragm is positioned below the field lens. A schematic representation of a cross section of a Ramsden eyepiece is shown in Fig. 5.31. With the diaphragm below both lenses, the quality of the image of any measuring scale or grid is better than with the Huygenian objective. Otherwise, the Ramsden eyepiece suffers with the same limitations as the Huygenian eyepiece. Many Ramsden eyepieces contain four lens elements: two in the eye lens and two in the field lens. These eyepieces can be used for medium-power observation. The Hyperplane (Compensated) Eyepiece. Compensated eyepieces may be of either the Huygenian or Ramsden type. They have doublet or triplet eye lenses and are more highly corrected for chromatic aberration and curvature of field. This type of eyepiece can be used with the more powerful, higher-magnification achromatic objectives and the more highly corrected fluorite, apochromatic, and plano objectives. These special compensated eyepieces should be matched with the corrected objectives when
Fig. 5.31 Sketch of the cross section of a Ramsden eyepiece
the microscope is purchased. They are usually engraved with “comp,” “K,” or “C” on the top ring of the eyepiece. The eyepieces used with flat-field objectives may be engraved with “plano-comp” or “plan-comp.” The Wide-Field or Wide-Angle Eyepiece. Some eyepieces are manufactured to produce a wider field of view (larger diameter of view on the specimen) and are engraved with a “WF” or “S.W..” They consist of many lens elements. They are engraved with a field number that, when divided by the objective magnification, specifies the diameter of the field of view on the specimen (in mm). At 100⫻, the diameter of the field of view of a standard eyepiece is about 0.18 mm. Special wide-field eyepieces can increase the field of view to 0.32 mm by using a larger diameter eyepiece with a higher field number (in this case, a field number of 32). The High-Point Eyepiece. Most modern metallurgical microscopes have high-point eyepieces. High-point, or high-eyepoint oculars, are produced for metallographers who must wear eyeglasses. Although the metallurgical microscope will allow the metallographer who normally wears eyeglasses to view the microstructure without wearing the eyeglasses, some eye aberrations, such as astigmatism, cannot be corrected by the optical system of the microscope. People who are farsighted or nearsighted can use a metallurgical microscope with or without eyeglasses. In the high-point eyepiece, the eye lens is elevated to allow a larger distance between the eye lens and the eye. This extra space of about 25 mm (1 in.) allows ample room for the eyeglasses. Some high-point eyepieces are inscribed with an “H.” The Adjustable Eyepiece. When using a binocular attachment to the metallurgical microscope, at least one eyepiece should be adjustable. This means that one eyepiece should have a focusing eye lens. The focusing eyepiece can be adjusted to compensate for people who do not have perfect 20/20 vision. The use of the adjustable eyepiece is explained in the section “Procedure to Personalize the Microscope for Viewing.” Measuring Eyepieces. Some eyepieces contain special measuring scales called reticles (or graticules). When viewed through the eyepiece, these scales are superimposed on the image of the specimen. Generally, the barrel of the eyepiece will rotate in order to bring the scale into the same focus as the field of view. An eyepiece with a graduated linear scale is normally used. A reticle scale is important when measuring the length or diameter of a feature in the microstructure. These eyepiece scales must be calibrated with a stage micrometer (see the section “Special Procedures for the Metallurgical Microscope” at the end of this chapter). One such eyepiece scale is called an eyepiece micrometer. Some elaborate eyepieces have a movable vernier scale for making measurements. These are called filar measuring eyepieces. Special reticles with circular or square grids can be used to determine the volume fraction of a particular constituent or a grain-size measurement. The Photoeyepiece. For micrography, the normal observation eyepiece is not used. In this case, a photoeyepiece or projector lens is placed in the trinocular port of the microscope. The photoeyepiece projects the image from the objective to the film plane of the camera. These lenses are generally of low magnifi-
126 / Metallographer’s Guide cation (1.5 to 8⫻), because the image projected onto the film is subsequently enlarged during the photographic process (as in the case of a 35 mm camera). The film plane can also be at a fixed distance, for example, 250 mm, from the photoeyepiece.
The Illumination System Another very important part of the metallurgical microscope is the system that provides light to the specimen. Although it is the part of the microscope that the metallographer can do the most to control microscope performance, it is also the most overlooked part of the microscope. This is probably due to a lack of understanding of how to control and adjust the illumination system for peak performance. If the illumination system is not optimized by the metallographer, the properties of the optical system, particularly the properties of the objectives, will not be properly used. For example, the metallographer may purchase the most expensive plan-apochromatic objectives available for the microscope. These objectives may have a NA of 0.95. However, in order to use the NA of the objective, an intense beam of optically centered light must be available to fill the backside of the lens. If the beam is off-center or not properly focused, the objective will not function the way it is designed to function and the metallographer will not obtain the full benefit of the high-resolution objective. Figure 5.32 shows an example of how an improperly adjusted illumination system can affect microstructural image quality. The micrograph in Fig. 5.32(a) was taken with no filter, a misaligned light source, and an aperture diaphragm that was opened too wide. Sharpness and quality improvement can been seen in the micrograph in Fig. 5.32(b), which shows the same field taken with a green filter, correctly aligned light source, and a properly adjusted aperture diaphragm. The next section describes the various parts of the illumination system on most metallurgical microscopes. A later section describes the procedures used to control the illumination system for optimal results.
The Components of the Illumination System
Fig. 5.32 Micrographs of a 0.75% C-3.25% Cr steel with an improperly
and properly aligned illumination system. Micrograph (a) was taken with no filter, a wide-open aperture diaphragm, and misaligned light source. Micrograph (b) was taken with a green filter, correctly adjusted aperture diaphragm, and properly aligned light source. Note the improved clarity in micrograph (b). Pearlite nucleating on a prior austenite grain boundary in a matrix of martensite. Vilella’s etch. 1000⫻
The standard upright biological microscope has a substage condenser as part of the illumination system (some older microscopes use a detached lamp and mirror system). The light is thus transmitted through the specimen from below. However, because the metallurgical microscope uses opaque specimens, this type of system cannot be used. The light must pass vertically through the objective to the specimen. The light is then reflected from the specimen back through the objective to the eyepiece or ocular. Figure 5.33 shows a very simplified schematic representation of a typical illumination system. The system consists of a light source, a condenser lens, an aperture diaphragm, a field diaphragm, a second condenser lens (field lens), and the half-mirror or illuminator. This optical system is termed “Kohler illumination” and produces high-intensity and uniform illumination on the specimen. August Kohler, a German scientist, developed the system in the early 1890s. The part of the system that includes the two diaphragms and the mirror is called the vertical illuminator.
The Light Source For the metallurgical microscope, the source of light should be bright, steady, and collimated (controlled as an intense single
The Metallurgical Microscope / 127 beam of light). In older microscopes and metallographs, carbon arc lamps were used, because they produce light of high intensity. The arc was generated as the two carbon rods touched and then developed a small space between them. A major problem was that the space between the rods could not be controlled sufficiently to produce constant illumination. There was flickering of light, because the arc wandered about the end of the rod, and because the rods had a fairly rapid consumption rate. These lamps are no longer in use, because they provided an unstable source of illumination, especially for micrography. Many technological advances have been made in the past two decades to develop high-intensity, stable light sources. The metallographer has many options to choose from for the metallurgical microscope. Tungsten-Filament Lamps. Low-cost, tungsten-filament incandescent lamps (bulbs) were common years ago as a light source for the metallurgical microscope. That is particularly true for the simple metallurgical microscope that is used mainly for observation. These lamps use a low voltage (6 or 12V) and can be purchased at various wattages. The level of intensity is controlled by a transformer with a variable rheostat. The intensity of light is suitable for most ordinary black-and-white micrography. However, for high-magnification and polarized-light metallography, very long exposure times are required. For such work, a brighter source of light is required (see subsequent paragraphs). Tungsten-filament lamps operate at color temperatures between 2700 and 3200 K. “Color temperature” is a term used in photography, for example, a color temperature of 3200 K is the same as the light color produced by a camera flashbulb. One problem with tungsten-filament bulbs is the buildup of tungsten on the inside surface of the glass bulb with extended use. This buildup will decrease the intensity of the light produced and is particularly a problem in micrography, because the color temperature gradually decreases. If the bulb surface is darkened, it should be replaced. Tungsten-Halogen Lamps. The tungsten-halogen lamp has essentially replaced the simple tungsten-filament lamp described previously. The tungsten-halogen lamp employs a tungsten filament in a halogen gas. The halogen gas is usually iodine, but other halogens, such as chlorine or bromine, can be used. The main
Fig. 5.33 Schematic of a ray diagram of a basic illumination system for a metallurgical microscope
advantage of the tungsten-halogen bulb is that tungsten from the filament is not deposited on the inside of the glass bulb. The tungsten atoms that evaporate from the filament collide and combine chemically with the halogen gas atoms. The gas then deposits the tungsten back onto the filament. This means longer life of the filament, and the lamp is self-cleaning (never darkens). Lamp life is about 50 hours. These lamps can also operate at higher voltages and can produce maximum light output. For these reasons, this type of lamp has replaced the lower-cost tungstenfilament lamp in many metallurgical microscopes. Some older microscopes can be upgraded with a new lamp housing and transformer. The tungsten-halogen lamp is also called a quartz-halogen or quartz-iodine lamp, because quartz is used instead of glass for the bulb. Some bulbs are made from a high-silica glass called Vycor (Corning Glass Works). Quartz and Vycor have high melting temperatures compared with glass and can thus be used at higher temperatures. Also, the wall of the bulb can be closer to the filament, and thus, tungsten-halogen bulbs can be made smaller than a conventional tungsten-filament bulb. The metallographer is cautioned never to touch the quartz (or Vycor) surface, because any fingerprint will result in a short lifespan of the bulb. When skin oils contact a quartz surface, the quartz will undergo a crystallization process, which will change the affected region from transparent to translucent. This crystallization (devitrification) will weaken the quartz, and the bulb will soon fail at this region. Tungsten-halogen lamps generally operate at 6 V and can be purchased at 10, 20, 50, 80, 100, 150, and 250 W capacity. Some lamps can operate at higher voltages; check the manufacturer’s recommendations. Most tungsten-halogen lamps operate at a color temperature of 3200 K. Xenon Arc Lamps. Very stable, high-intensity illumination can be provided with a xenon arc lamp. However, the xenon arc lamp is an expensive source of illumination. The light is of daylight quality (color temperature of 6400 K), which is an advantage when using daylight-type color film for micrography without filters. The quartz bulb is designed so that an arc is produced between two tungsten electrodes. The lamp requires a special direct current power source, and the atmosphere within the bulb is xenon gas (an inert gas) under high pressure. Xenon arc lamps usually operate at high wattages (75, 150, and 450 W). The color temperature of a typical zenon arc lamp is 6400 K, and these lamps are ideal for color daylight film. The metallographer must be very careful in handling the pressurized bulb, and gloves and safety glasses or face shield should be worn in case of an explosion. Care must also be taken not to touch the glass bulb, because any fingerprint on the quartz surface will result in a short lifespan of the bulb (as described in the subsection “Tungsten-Halogen Lamps”). Replacement bulbs are very expensive. These lamps also emit some ultraviolet and infrared light, and the metallographer must make certain not to be exposed to direct light. Mercury Arc Lamps. The mercury arc or mercury vapor lamp is not commonly used for metallographic purposes but can provide what is called a high-intensity monochromatic source of light (sodium vapor lamps can also do this). This means that the
128 / Metallographer’s Guide source of light is at a particular wavelength. For example, the mercury arc lamp emits very bright light at wavelengths of 546, 435, and 365 nm. Because of their precise wavelengths, these lamps are useful for interferometry (discussed later in this chapter). However, because of the discontinuous light spectrum, a mercury arc lamp is a problem in color micrography. The lamps require their own direct current power source, are expensive, and have a tendency to flicker. The mercury arc lamp takes about ten minutes to reach full intensity and cannot be turned on again until the bulb has cooled to room temperature. These lamps emit some ultraviolet light, and care must be taken to shield the metallographer’s eyes from direct exposure. The mercury arc bulbs are under high pressure and should be handled with care (gloves and safety glasses or face shield must be worn). Zirconium Arc Lamps. As with the xenon arc lamp, the zirconium arc lamp provides a stable, high-intensity source of light for the metallurgical microscope. The intensity is not as bright as a tungsten-halogen or xenon lamp but is sufficient for most micrography (color temperature of 3200 K). The zirconium arc lamp also requires its own direct current power source, making the system quite expensive. The same precautions as the xenon arc lamp in handling and exposure to ultraviolet light must be maintained. Zirconium arc lamps are not commonly used for metallography. The Lamp Housing. The lamps mentioned previously are surrounded by a lamp housing, which shields the surroundings from extraneous light. The housing allows for cooling by louvers or radiation fins. An example of a lamp housing can be seen in Fig. 5.34. In some cases, there is a reflective device (partialhemispherical mirror) located in back of the lamp. This reflector directs the back light of the lamp toward the optical system. In most metallurgical microscope lamp housings, there are adjustment knobs to allow the metallographer to vertically and laterally center the light source (the procedure for centering the light source is discussed in the section “Special Procedures for the
Metallurgical Microscope”). These knobs can be seen in Fig. 5.34 (arrow).
The Collector Lens Just in front of the lamp housing is the collector lens or lamp condenser lens (sometimes called field condenser or lamp collector). There actually may be more than one lens element in the collector lens. The main purpose of the collector lens is to collimate a light beam from the light source to the aperture diaphragm. The collector lens also provides even illumination of the specimen.
The Aperture Diaphragm With the collector lens forming a collimated light beam on the aperture diaphragm (also called the aperture iris diaphragm or aperture stop), the aperture, which the metallographer can open and close, controls the resolution, contrast, and the amount of light to the specimen. Actually, for optimal conditions, the aperture diaphragm should maintain a beam of light that fills about 75% of the back lens of the objective. This way, the full potential of the objective NA is used. Too small an aperture opening will reduce resolution, and too large an opening will cause haziness of the entire field. This is shown in Fig. 5.35 where the same field is viewed with the aperture diaphragm at too large and at too small an opening compared with the correct opening. Note that with a large opening, the field is fuzzy and thus has poor contrast. With the small opening, the field is sharpened, but certain fine features
Fig. 5.35 Micrographs of a water-quenched AISI/SAE 1020 steel with a
Fig. 5.34 A simple lamp housing for a metallurgical microscope. Note the adjustment knob (arrow).
fully martensitic microstructure. (a) Taken with fully open aperture diaphragm, (b) taken with a closed-down aperture diaphragm, and (c) taken with a properly set aperture diaphragm. Note the improved clarity of the structure with the properly set aperture diaphragm. 2% nital etch. 500⫻
The Metallurgical Microscope / 129 are missing. The correct aperture setting shows a much clearer martensite microstructure. It is important for the metallographer to understand how to properly adjust the aperture diaphragm. Proper adjustment is discussed in the section “Special Procedures for the Metallurgical Microscope.”
The Field Diaphragm The field diaphragm (also called the field iris diaphragm or field stop) controls the field of view of the specimen. The diaphragm, which opens and closes, prevents glare caused by stray light in the
Fig. 5.36 Micrographs of a cast 25% Cr-12% Ni heat-resistant HH steel
Fig. 5.35 (continued) (b) taken with a closed-down aperture diaphragm, and (c) taken with a properly set aperture diaphragm. Note the improved clarity of the structure with the properly set aperture diaphragm. 2% nital etch. 500⫻
with grain-boundary carbides showing (a) an unfocused field diaphragm, (b) a focused field diaphragm, and (c) the focused field of view. When the field diaphragm is in focus, the field of view on the specimen is in focus. Electrolytic etch (60 ml nitric acid in 40 ml water, stainless steel cathode). 400⫻
130 / Metallographer’s Guide system. The image of the field diaphragm can be seen on the specimen when the specimen is in focus. It is important to remember that when the field diaphragm is in focus, the specimen is in focus. This can be seen in Fig. 5.36. In this series of micrographs, the field diaphragm is out of focus when the specimen is out of focus, and the field diaphragm is in focus when the specimen is in focus. The microstructure consists of primary carbides in a cast 25% Cr-12% Ni heat-resistant grade HH steel. Generally, for best results, the field diaphragm is opened just beyond the field of view. Proper adjustment of this diaphragm is discussed in the section “Special Procedures for the Metallurgical Microscope.”
The Condenser Lens There is another lens, also called the field lens, located just beyond the field diaphragm. It is the purpose of this condenser lens and the objective itself to image the field diaphragm onto the surface of the specimen. This feature should not be used as a brightness control. Instead, judge the image quality and adjust the intensity by the rheostat on the light source, or use filters.
the illumination system of a metallurgical microscope. This critical component is the main feature that distinguishes the metallurgical microscope, using reflected light, from the biological microscope, using transmitted light. There are various types of illuminators. The Glass Reflector. One form of illuminator is a very thin glass plate or disc that is mounted at a 45° angle to the incident light beam. The front of the plate generally has a lightly mirrored surface. If it has a fully mirrored surface, it will not allow the reflected light from the specimen to pass up the tube of the microscope to the eyepiece, and thus, the metallographer will not see the image. If the plate is not mirrored, a large portion of light from the collimated beam will travel straight through the glass, and very little light is reflected down onto the specimen. Even in a properly designed illuminator, it is estimated that only about 10 to 25% of the original beam at the aperture diaphragm passes to the eyepieces. Thus, when using a plane glass illuminator, the light source must be of high intensity. The Prism Reflector. In some microscopes, a right-angle prism reflector is used to direct the light beam 90° down to the specimen. Although almost 100% of the light reaches the specimen, this type
The Illuminator The purpose of the illuminator is to direct the light beam 90° down the microscope tube to the back lens of the objective. A schematic representation of the illuminator is shown in Fig. 5.37, where the light from the light source is reflected toward the objective. The light is represented by the two parallel rays at the right side of the sketch. The illuminator must also allow the beam reflected from the specimen to pass through with minimal absorption and distortion. Thus, the illuminator is a critical part of
Fig. 5.36 (continued) Micrographs of a cast 25% Cr-12% Ni heat-
resistant HH steel with grain-boundary carbides showing (a) an unfocused field diaphragm, (b) a focused field diaphragm, and (c) the focused field of view. When the field diaphragm is in focus, the field of view on the specimen is in focus. Electrolytic etch (60 ml nitric acid in 40 ml water, stainless steel cathode). 400⫻
Fig. 5.37 Sketch of a ray diagram showing reflective mirror mounted in the microscope tube above the objective
The Metallurgical Microscope / 131 of illuminator has a serious drawback, in that the light reflected from the specimen back through the objective cannot pass through the prism on its way to the eyepiece. To solve this problem, the prism is offset about halfway into the incident light beam so as to deflect some of the light beam to the specimen while allowing ample free space to allow the reflected beam to pass the prism. This means that only half of the objective lens is being used for the incident light and one-half for the reflected light. With this arrangement, there is some loss in resolution. Also, because the prism is off-center, some of the light entering the objective is at an angle. This produces oblique illumination of the specimen, which may not be desirable for all circumstances. Because of the drawback of the prism illuminator, it should only be used with low-magnification objectives. The Bright-Field/Dark-Field (BD) Reflector. Many modern metallurgical microscopes use a thin glass plate reflector that has a mirrored outer ring and clear center. The outer ring reflects light from the light source down to the outer rim of the back objective lens. The clear center of the reflector allows almost full transmission of the reflected light from the specimen to the eyepieces. Because the reflector is at a 45° angle to the light beam, the clear region is elliptically-shaped on the glass surface. However, the ellipse appears circular to the reflected light from the specimen. This reflector is used both for bright-field and dark-field illumination.
would appear dark in bright-field illumination appear bright in dark-field illumination. This is accomplished by producing incident light at an angle to the specimen, as seen in the ray diagram in Fig. 5.39. In this schematic representation of dark-field illumination, the scratch on the specimen surface reflects light into the objective, and the remaining light is reflected at an angle and never passes through the objective. In order to produce incident light at an angle to the specimen, a special dark-field objective is required. In this objective, light rays are directed in a circular area only around the inside periphery of the barrel, and the incident light is excluded from the normal central area of the objective, that is, as in the normal bright-field objective. The annular opening can be seen in the dark-field objective in Fig. 5.23. To produce the ring of light, a dark-field stop in the illuminating system eliminates the light in the central portion of the beam, as shown in the sketch in Fig. 5.40. The illuminator (reflecting mirror) also has a clear elliptical center, so that any light in the center of the beam passes through the clear portion of the glass and is not reflected downward toward the objective. The outer portions of the elliptical mirror reflect the light beam to the annular path of the dark-field objective. Dark-field illumination is ideal for observing grain boundaries, scratches, and pores on the specimen surface. For example, Fig. 5.41 compares an etched specimen of quenched American Iron
Types of Illumination The metallurgical microscope is a remarkably versatile instrument, and the more the metallographer knows about the microscope illumination system, the more tools that become available to achieve the perfect image. Not only can the metallographer magnify the image of the microstructure to 1000⫻ and beyond, but the image can be enhanced by special optical techniques that produce different types of illumination on the specimen. The normal type of illumination in the microscope is called brightfield illumination, which provides an image of reflected light from the specimen. This bright-field image is quite appropriate for representing microstructural details and has been used for most of the micrographs in this book. However, on occasion, certain features in the microstructure need to be enhanced beyond what can be done with bright-field illumination. Some of the more common types of illumination are described subsequently. Bright-Field Illumination. In bright-field illumination, most of the light that passes through the objective to the specimen is reflected back through the objective to the eyepiece of the microscope, as seen in the ray diagram in Fig. 5.38. Those specimens with features that are at an angle to the incident beam of light (as shown in Fig. 5.38) appear dark, because the light reflected from these features does not pass back through the objective. Therefore, in etched specimens, grain boundaries appear dark, because the light is reflected away from the objective lens. This is why etching is so important in revealing microstructural features in a specimen. Dark-Field Illumination. Dark-field illumination is essentially the opposite of bright-field illumination, that is, those features that
Fig. 5.38 Sketch of a ray diagram showing bright-field illumination. Note
that light rays impinging on a scratch on the specimen surface are reflected away from the objective lens, while the other rays are reflected back through the lens. Thus, the scratch appears dark, while the remaining surface is bright.
132 / Metallographer’s Guide and Steel Institute/Society of Automotive Engineers (AISI/SAE) 4340 steel in both bright-field and dark-field illumination. The microstructure is lath martensite. The prior austenite grain boundaries are more clearly seen in dark-field illumination than in bright-field illumination. The dark-field technique is very useful
for metallographic interpretation, and most metallurgical microscopes are equipped with the necessary dark-field attachments. Because most of the incident light to the specimen is reflected away from the objective lens during dark-field illumination, the
Fig. 5.39 Sketch of a ray diagram showing dark-field illumination. Note
that light rays impinging on a scratch on the specimen surface are reflected through the operative lens, while the other rays are reflected away from the lens. Thus, the scratch appears bright, while the remaining surface is dark.
Fig. 5.41 Micrographs of a water-quenched AISI/SAE 4340 steel with a
Fig. 5.40 Sketch of a ray diagram for typical dark-field illumination. Note
the special dark-field stop that restricts the light path to an annular ring of light, and the special reflecting mirror that reflects that annular ring of light to the outer ring of the objective.
fully martensitic microstructure. Micrograph (a) was taken in bright-field illumination, and micrograph (b) was taken with dark-field illumination. Note the clarity of the prior austenite grain boundaries in the dark-field micrograph. 1% picric acid in water with a few drops of sodium tridecylbenxene (wetting agent). 500⫻
The Metallurgical Microscope / 133 aperture and field diaphragms should be fully open and the lamp intensity increased. Oblique Illumination. Somewhat similar to dark-field illumination is oblique illumination, where the rays of incident light are decentered, or off-center, from the bright-field position. This means that the incident light strikes the specimen at an angle in one direction only, as opposed to dark-field illumination, which strikes the specimen at an angle as a 360° circle. Oblique illumination can be produced by deliberately decentering the aperture diaphragm. This technique is used to show relief on the
Fig. 5.42 Micrograph of a water-quenched Fe-1.75% C binary alloy
showing plate martensite in a matrix of austenite. Micrograph taken with oblique illumination. The martensite plates, because of their surface relief, are shadowed by the oblique light source. 2% nital etch. 500⫻
Fig. 5.43 Sketch of a ray diagram for an illumination system for polarized
light. The polarizer filter is placed between the second condenser lens and the illuminator, and the analyzer filter is placed above the illuminator.
specimen surface. An example of the use of oblique illumination is shown in Fig. 5.42. Polarized Light. Although a technique not widely used for steels and cast irons, polarized light can reveal crystallographic orientation differences in the specimen. To produce polarized light, a polarizer must be placed in the light path between the light source and the objective, and an analyzer must be placed in the light path between the mirror and the eyepiece. There are no differences between the polarizer and analyzer, they are just given different names to differentiate their roles. A schematic representation is shown in Fig. 5.43. The polarizer and analyzer are filters that allow only certain directions of light waves to pass through the filter. These filters present parallel optical slits to the light beam. When the light passes through the filter, only one orientation of light waves can pass through. As an example, in Fig. 5.43, the polarizer allows only that component of light wave oriented in a direction perpendicular to the plane of the specimen to pass through, and the analyzer allows only that component of light wave that is parallel to the plane of the specimen to pass through. The polarizer and analyzer filters can be rotated, and when they are crossed, that is, when the slits are perpendicular (90°) to each other, the field of view becomes dark. At this point, the specimen is rotated perpendicular to the incident beam. If no change in reflection occurs, the material is considered isotropic, and if changes occur, the material is considered anisotropic. Isotropic means that the material has equal characteristics (mechanical properties, refractive index, etc.) in all directions (x-, y-, and z-axes). The body-centered cubic and face-centered cubic metals, such as iron and copper, are isotropic and do not respond well to polarized light. On the other hand, the hexagonal metals titanium, zirconium, magnesium, and zinc are anisotropic and respond well to polarized light. Many minerals and oriented polymers, as well as common sugar, are anisotropic. Therefore, polarized light is much more useful for these anisotropic materials that are not cubic by nature. However, polarized light can be used on steels that have been tint etched. A tint etch deposits a chemical residue on the surface of each grain in the specimen. The residue itself can have an orientation that is anisotropic. For example, Fig. 5.44 illustrates the use of polarized light on a very-low-carbon electrical steel containing silicon that was tint etched with one of Baraha’s tint etchants. The bright-field image is seen in Fig. 5.44(a), and the same field under polarized light is shown in Fig. 5.44(b). Note the clarity of the grains in the polarized image. More about the use of tint etches is discussed in Chapter 8. Differential Interference Contrast (Nomarski). This technique is used in most modern bright-field microscopes. In this technique, a polarizer is placed between the light source and the vertical illuminator (mirror), and an analyzer is placed between the vertical illuminator and the eyepiece, as with polarized illumination described previously. For differential interference contrast (also called differential phase contrast), the polarizers must be crossed (at 90° to each other). A special prism, called a Wollaston prism, is placed between the vertical illuminator and the objective, as shown in Fig. 5.45. This prism divides the polarized light beam into two beams of incident light. The split beams have a slight lateral separation when they illuminate the
134 / Metallographer’s Guide specimen surface. After being reflected back through the objective, the two beams are recombined by the prism and pass through the analyzer to the eye. The slight displacement of the beams at the specimen surface produces the differential contrast. Differential interference contrast works only when the surface of the
specimen has uneven surface features or if there is a difference in index of refraction in coated surfaces. To show the effect of differential interference contrast, a series of micrographs have been taken at crossed polarization and two positions of moving the Wollaston prism. Figure 5.46(a) shows the flat, as-polished surface of the D2 tool steel specimen under normal bright-field illumination. The only features that are noticeable are five small inclusions. The same field of view under differential interference contrast can be seen in Fig. 5.46(b). In this micrograph, large carbide arrays can be seen along with fine carbides dispersed within the grains. Because this specimen was not etched, the relief shown in Fig. 5.46(b) is caused by polishing. The carbides, being harder than the matrix, did not abrade away as much as the matrix, and thus the carbides are in higher relief than the matrix. There is a danger of confusion in using this technique. For example, by moving the Wollaston prism too far out of alignment, the image can be reversed, as seen in Fig. 5.46(c). Here, the carbides appear as depressions in low relief with respect to the matrix, thus creating a false image. In using differential interference contrast, the metallographer must be fully aware of the characteristics of the material that is being examined. If there is uncertainty, the metallographer can verify if the relief is high or low by using an alternate technique, such as oblique illumination.
Fig. 5.44 Micrographs of a very-low-carbon electrical steel with a fully
Fig. 5.45 Sketch of a ray diagram of differential interference contrast
ferritic microstructure taken under (a) bright-field illumination and (b) polarized light. Beraha’s etch (3 g potassium metabisulfite and 10 g sodium thiosulfate in 100 ml water). 200⫻
illumination (Nomarski) in a metallurgical microscope. Note the polarizer and analyzer for polarized light and the Wollaston prism to split the light beam.
The Metallurgical Microscope / 135 Another example of the use of differential interference contrast can be seen in Fig. 5.47. This is an example of cold-worked AISI 316 stainless steel that has deformation twins. Note the excellent contrast of the deformation twins in the micrograph using differential interference contrast (Fig. 5.47b) when compared with the micrograph taken in bright-field illumination (Fig. 5.47a).
This technique is also called Nomarski, named after G. Nomarski who developed the technique in the 1940s. More details about this technique and other phase contrast and interference techniques can be found in the selected references at the end of this chapter. Interference Illumination. Some advanced metallurgical microscopes have special optical accessories called interferometers.
Fig. 5.46 Micrographs of an as-polished D2 tool steel taken in (a) bright-field and (b) differential phase contrast. Note the carbides in (b) in high relief
compared with the matrix. In (c), the same field taken after moving the Wollaston prism slightly out of alignment. Note in (c) that the carbides are in low relief (as pits), giving a false image. Unetched. 500⫻
136 / Metallographer’s Guide These interferometers (e.g., polarization interferometers), either double-beam or multiple-beam, produce interference fringes on the specimen surface. For example, Fig. 5.48 shows a series of parallel interference fringes on a flat, polished surface of steel. With everything properly aligned, the spacing between the fringes
is one-half the wavelength of the light being used. Thus, in this case where a green filter is used, the wavelength is 548 nm, and the spacing between fringes is 274 nm. Any change in surface flatness, for example, a grain boundary or a scratch, produces a change in the fringe spacing and direction. A simple way to visualize this effect is by noting the shadows of electric power lines or telephone wires produced by the sun. These shadows change direction and spacing as they cross from a flat surface to a hill or depression. For example, on a totally flat surface, such as the outside wall of the building, the shadows would appear as straight, parallel dark lines. As the shadows cross a recessed window in that wall, the shadows would change direction and spacing at the recessed surface and change direction and spacing again along the flat window surface itself, and so on. Another way of visualizing interference fringes is by observing the constant elevation contour lines on a topographical map. At a flat surface, the elevation contour lines are spaced far apart. At a cliff along a stream bed, the elevation lines are closely spaced. Therefore, the observer can visualize the hills and valleys on the surface of the earth shown in the map. The spacing between the lines can be used to determine the steepness of the hill or valley with respect to a reference elevation, for example, sea level. Thus, interference illumination is usually used to examine very small height changes on a specimen surface. Some interferometers can measure height differences as small as 30 nm. To illustrate the effectiveness of interference illumination, the same polished specimen shown in Fig. 5.48 contained a scratch that was examined with and without interference illumination, as seen in Fig. 5.49. The micrograph in Fig. 5.49(a) was taken in bright-field illumination to show the scratch. The scratch was produced by a small diamond-pointed tool. The micrograph in
Fig. 5.47 Micrographs of a cold-worked AISI 316 stainless steel sheet
taken with (a) bright-field illumination and (b) differential interference contrast illumination. Note the excellent clarity of surface relief in the differential interference contrast illumination. Electrolytic etch (10% oxalic acid in water, stainless steel cathode). 400⫻
Fig. 5.48 Micrograph showing interference fringes on a flat, polished specimen surface. Unetched. Taken with a green filter. 500⫻
The Metallurgical Microscope / 137 Fig. 5.49(b) was taken in interference illumination (the same illumination in Fig. 5.48). Note in Fig. 5.49(b), the interference fringes changed direction and spacing along the sidewall of the scratch. From these changes, the metallographer can then calculate the depth of the scratch with respect to the polished surface by measuring the the number of fringes on the scratch sidewall with
respect to the number of fringes of known spacing on the flat surface. More details about the use of this important technique can be found in the references.
Accessories for the Microscope Bertrand Lens. Some advanced metallurgical microscopes are equipped with an auxiliary lens, called a Bertrand lens, that focuses the aperture diaphragm within the tube of the microscope. Without a Bertrand lens, the image of the aperture diaghragm is small and difficult to accurately adjust, because the eyepiece is removed from the tube of the microscope. However, if the metallographer uses a Bertrand lens, the eyepiece remains in place, and the image of the aperture is enlarged and in focus, making adjustments to the aperture diaphragm much easier. An example of the image produced by a Bertrand lens is shown in Fig. 5.50. In this micrograph, the larger circular area is the light passing through the back lens of the objective. The aperture diaphragm is shown as the eight-sided opening. Note that in this example, only about 75% of the light from the objective passes through the aperture diaphragm. This is the recommended aperture opening to allow for the full potential of the NA of the objective to be obtained. See the section “Special Procedures for the Metallurgical Microscope” at the end of this chapter for instructions on the use of the Bertrand lens to adjust the aperture diaphragm. Scribe. On occasion, the metallographer will need to permanently mark an area on the specimen surface for further evaluation by another instrument, that is, the scanning electron microscope or electron probe microanalyzer. The scribe device screws into one of the objective locations in the nosepiece of the microscope. Figure 5.51 shows an example of a scribe before mounting on the
Fig. 5.49 Micrographs of a scratch on the same polished specimen in Fig.
5.48 in (a) bright field and (b) the same scratch under interference illumination. Taken with a green filter. Unetched. 500⫻
Fig. 5.50 Micrograph of the image of the eight-sided aperture diaphragm and back of the 5⫻ objective (the light gray circular image) through a Bertrand lens mounted in the microscope tube. Note the aperture diaphragm is closed down about 25%.
138 / Metallographer’s Guide nosepiece of a metallurgical microscope. At the tip of the scribe is a carbide or diamond point that is offset from the optical axis. The tip is lightly touched to the specimen surface and is rotated to encircle the area of interest. The diameter of the circle can be adjusted by selecting the proper number on the barrel. The proper procedure for using the scribe can be found in the section “Special Procedures for the Metallurgical Microscope” at the end of this chapter. Stage Micrometer. A stage micrometer is a glass or metal slide that has been accurately engraved with a calibrated scale. An example of the image of a stage micrometer is shown in Fig. 5.52. The slide is placed on the stage of the microscope and is used to calibrate the magnification of the microscope through the objectives and eyepieces of the microscope. The procedures used for calibration are described in detail in the section “Special Procedures for the Metallurgical Microscope” at the end of this chapter. Reticles (Graticules). If the metallographer needs to make quantitative measurements of the features in the microstructure during observation on the microscope, a reticle eyepiece can be used. Reticles are small glass disks with graduated scales and grids that are located in one of the eyepieces of the microscope. The scales can be used to measure grain size, coating thickness, particle diameter, and so on. Eyepieces can be purchased with specific grids and scales, or the metallographer may order special
or custom-made reticles to be inserted into the eyepiece. A micrometer eyepiece (described previously in the subsection “Types of Eyepieces” and in the section “Special Procedures for the Metallurgical Microscope” at the end of this chapter) is an eyepiece with a graduated linear scale. An example of a reticle scale is shown in Fig. 5.53. Filar Eyepiece. A filar eyepiece, or filar micrometer, is used for accurate linear measurements of microstructural features (about 1 μm accuracy). These eyepieces have a screw-micrometer attachment (similar to a machinist’s micrometer) that is rotated for the measurements. Within the eyepiece, there is a movable cross hair that is connected to the micrometer movement. There are also digital filar eyepieces that are automated for direct digital readout or printout of the measurements. Leveling Device. With an upright metallurgical microscope, a device to level the specimen for observation on the stage is
Fig. 5.52 Micrograph of a stage micrometer. 40⫻
Fig. 5.51 Photograph of a scribe device for the upright metallurgical
microscope. The device fits into an objective port on the nosepiece. Note the offset diamond tip that is rotated to produce a scribed circle around the feature on the specimen surface.
Fig. 5.53 An example of eyepiece reticle scale
The Metallurgical Microscope / 139 required. Most microscope manufacturers supply a leveling device with their upright microscopes. The device is described in detail later in this chapter in “Procedure to Properly Level the Specimen on an Upright Microscope.” Lens Tissue. The metallographer should always keep an ample supply of lens tissue in order to clean dust from the eyepiece and objective lenses. Also, a sheet of lens tissue can be used to protect the polished specimen surface in a leveling device. Lens tissue is a lint-free, thin paper specially made for this purpose. Before using lens tissue, it is recommended that the lens be dusted with a burst of air from a rubber bulb or from a pressurized can of air or carbon dioxide (never use Freon gas [E.I. Du Pont de Nemours, Inc.]) Video Monitor. A video monitor, attached to a video camera on the trinocular port of the microscope, can be used to show the image of the microstructure to one or more observers. Video monitors also come with video printers that can print the image seen on the monitor. Camera Attachment. Metallurgical microscopes with a trinocular port are designed for a camera attachment (see Fig. 5.29). What the metallographer observes through the binocular eyepieces can be photographed on a 35 mm camera or instant film camera by a prism that splits the image. There are also attachments for cut film photography. Some microscopes may use a mirror that the metallographer uses to rotate the image from the binocular to the trinocular port. In addition to conventional photographic cameras, there are a number of electronic devices that can be attached to the trinocular port to capture an image. These include CCD (charge-coupled device) cameras that can provide a digital image to a video monitor or a computer.
metallograph is seen in Fig. 5.54. Most metallographs are inverted microscopes with built-in photographic capability. The metallograph shown in Fig. 5.54 has a 35 mm camera mounted in a pocket on the side and a rectangular ground glass viewing screen at the lower front facing the metallographer, as shown in Fig. 5.55. The viewing screen can be removed to allow a film holder to be positioned in its place. Figure 5.56 shows the electronic shutter speed control system for photography. Because all of the principles described in this chapter for the metallurgical microscope apply to the metallograph, no further description is needed here. Many modern metallurgical microscopes are equipped with excellent camera accessories, and a metallograph may not be needed for many metallographic laboratories. The camera accessories include not only 35 mm and instant film cameras, but also digital cameras that connect to a
The Metallograph The micrographs in this book were produced on a special microscope called a metallograph. This instrument is a metallurgical microscope that is dedicated to taking micrographs. A typical
Fig. 5.54 Photograph of a metallograph
Fig. 5.55 A close-up view of the 35 mm camera and ground glass screen on the metallograph in Fig. 5.54
Fig. 5.56 A view of a electronic shutter speed control for the metallograph in Fig. 5.54
140 / Metallographer’s Guide video monitor or printing device. With the swirl of technology development in digital processing, common film micrography is being replaced by digital micrography. However, many metallographers still prefer the unexcelled resolution of a photographic print to a digitally produced image.
•
Special Procedures for the Metallurgical Microscope Procedure to Properly Level the Specimen on an Upright Microscope. One of the drawbacks of the upright microscope is that the specimen must be level (perpendicular to the light path) for observation and micrography. Most manufacturers of upright microscopes provide a leveling device when the microscope is purchased. An example of a typical leveling device is shown in Fig. 5.57. This device has two flat, parallel circular platens. The bottom platen is stationary, and the top platen is spring mounted and moves vertically. The procedure to properly level a specimen is described in the steps that follow: •
Step 1: Place a small mound of stiff clay (Plasticine) on the center of a small, rectangular metal plate or glass slide. Place the mounted or unmounted specimen on top of the clay mound and center the assembly on the bottom platen of the mounting device, as shown in Fig. 5.57.
•
•
Procedure to Level a Large Specimen with Uneven Surface. On occasion, the metallographer will have to place a large specimen or a specimen with an uneven surface on the stage of an upright microscope. An example can be seen in Fig. 5.58, which shows a specimen of an AISI 316 stainless steel sheet with an uneven surface (the sheet has a test weld). For this kind of specimen, the normal leveling procedure described previously cannot be used. The following multistep procedure is recommended: • •
• •
•
•
Fig. 5.57 A device used to level metallographic specimens on clay for the upright metallurgical microscope
Step 2: Place a folded, lint-free piece of microscope lens tissue on top of the specimen. Alternatively, if the specimen is mounted, an oval-shaped metal ring (usually aluminum) can be carefully placed on the mount itself without touching the specimen. This oval ring can be easily made by partially compressing a circular aluminum ring, making sure that the shorter opening dimension is always greater than the typical specimen size. For a 31 mm (1.25 in.) mount, a 31 mm (1.25 in.) diameter ring should be compressed to about 25 mm (1 in.). Step 3: With the lens tissue or oval ring in place, slowly push the top platen downward toward the specimen until contact is made. Then press hard on the top platen to deform the clay and level the specimen. Step 4: Slowly release the top platen and remove the lens tissue or oval ring. The specimen is now firmly attached to the clay and slide. Remove the assembly from the leveling device and place it on the microscope stage. When placing the assembly on the stage, always make sure that the stage has been lowered sufficiently to easily allow the specimen enough clearance to not contact the objective. It is advisable to always have the lowest magnification objective (the shortest objective) in position in the nosepiece.
Step 1: Place the specimen on an ample amount of clay on a small metal plate and place on the microscope stage. Step 2: Remove one of the objectives from the nosepiece of the microscope. Align the nosepiece opening over the specimen. Step 3: Closedown both the aperture and the field diaphragms. Step 4: Without looking into the microscope, approximately level the area of the specimen to be observed, using the the alignment of the beam of light from the nosepiece opening, as shown in Fig. 5.58. Step 5: Center the light in the field of view as accurately as possible by slightly tilting and rotating the specimen on the clay mount. When the field diaphragm is seen and uniformly illuminated as best as possible, shown in Fig. 5.59, the plane of the specimen should now be perpendicular to the light beam. (Note that it is difficult to obtain perfect, uniform illumination, because of the uneven specimen surface.) Step 6: Rotate the nosepiece so that one of the low-power objectives is over the specimen. Focus the specimen. The metallographer can then rotate the nosepiece to the highermagnification objectives. Figure 5.60 shows the microstructure of the weld in the specimen. This technique shows that a large and uneven specimen can be observed and photographed even up to a magnification of 1000⫻.
The Metallurgical Microscope / 141 Procedure to Use an Oil-Immersion Objective. As mentioned earlier in this chapter, the oil-immersion objective is used to obtain a high-magnification image with excellent resolution. Oil-immersion objectives have NAs above 1.0, generally between 1.2 and 1.4 NA. Because oil is required between the nose of the objective and the specimen surface, a special procedure is required as follows: •
•
•
•
Step 1: Place the leveled specimen on the stage of the microscope. Center and focus the field of interest first with a lower-magnification objective (usually the 10⫻ objective), and then focus with the oil-immersion objective (usually 100⫻). Once the field is in focus, turn the nosepiece back to the low-magnification objective. Step 2: Place a drop of oil (special oil supplied from the manufacturer, which has a refractive index to match the refractive index of the objective glass lens) in the center of the lighted region on the specimen. Step 3: Turn the nosepiece from the low-magnification objective directly to the oil-immersion objective. This prevents the other intermediate magnification objectives from touching the oil drop. Step 4: Focus the field with only the fine-focus knob. The oil will form a bridge between the objective and the specimen.
•
•
•
Step 5: When finished with the observation, lower the stage, remove the specimen, and turn the oil-immersion objective toward you. Step 6: Clean the oil from the tip of the objective first with a dry, lint-free lens tissue. Then place a few drops of ethanol (ethyl alcohol) on a clean, lint-free lens tissue and clean the tip of the objective with a gentle circular motion. A commercial lens cleaner can also be used. Dry the tip of the objective with a clean, lint-free piece of lens tissue. Step 7: Clean the specimen as in step 6.
Fig. 5.59 Micrograph of the field diaphragm in view. Large specimen in
Fig. 5.58 is moved by hand in order that the field diaphragm is in focus (objective is not in nosepiece, as shown in Fig. 5.58).
Fig. 5.58 A large, unmounted sheet of AISI 316 stainless steel with a test
weld placed on the stage of an upright metallurgical microscope. The specimen rests on a large ball of clay. Note that the objective is missing from the nosepiece, exposing the specimen surface to the light beam.
Fig. 5.60 Micrograph of the delta ferrite (dark) in the welded area of the
AISI 316 stainless steel specimen in Fig. 5.58. Electrolytic etch (10% oxalic acid in water, stainless steel cathode). 1000⫻
142 / Metallographer’s Guide Procedure to Clean the Microscope Lenses. The metallographer must, on occasion, clean exposed surfaces of the objective and eyepiece lenses to remove dust and airborne films. (Note that if these lenses need to be cleaned internally, the microscope manufacturer should be notified.) These glass surfaces should be treated with utmost care. The following procedure is recommended: •
•
Step 1: Clean dust from the lens surface by gently brushing the surface with a camel-hair brush or blowing the dust from the surface with a rubber bulb (ear syringe). Step 2: Clean films from the glass surfaces with a clean, lint-free lens tissue dampened with a few drops of ethanol (ethyl alcohol). Use a gentle circular motion.
microstructural feature using an eyepiece reticle with a graduated linear scale. Before making such a measurement, the scale must be accurately calibrated. This is done by using a calibrated stage micrometer in combination with the reticle eyepiece. The procedure is as follows: •
•
Precautions: Never touch the glass lens surface with the fingers. Never smoke around a microscope, because the airborne tars create a dark film on the glass surfaces. Always keep microscopes in a dust-free, smoke-free, and acid-free environment. • Procedure to Maintain a Clean, Dust-Free Microscope Environment. The microscope should always be protected from dust by placing a dust cover over the microscope when not in use. The microscope manufacturer will usually supply a dust cover. If not, a dust cover can be a simple plastic bag that completely covers the microscope down to the table. Always keep the microscope in a smoke-free room, because tars from the smoke will form on the lens surfaces. Also, make certain that the microscope is in a room away from the acids used in etching. Acids can damage the delicate parts of the microscope. Procedure to Calibrate an Eyepiece Reticle Scale. Many times, the metallographer will need to make a measurement of a
•
•
Step 1: Place a stage micrometer on the stage of the microscope or metallograph. A stage micrometer consists of a closely spaced graduated scale inscribed on a slide. Figure 5.52 shows an example of a stage micrometer scale magnified to 50⫻. Remember, to ensure accuracy, the stage micrometer must be traceable to the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) or a similar organization. Step 2: Place the eyepiece with the reticle scale in one of the ports of the binocular eyepiece attachment or in the tube of the microscope. The metallographer can also use a special reticle scale called an eyepiece micrometer. The eyepiece micrometer has a ruled reticle with a graduated linear scale similar to the scale on the stage micrometer shown in Fig. 5.52. Step 3: Focus on the stage micrometer using the lowest-power objective. Rotate to a higher-power objective if required. Step 4: Bring the image of the stage micrometer into coincidence with the reticle scale in the eyepiece. Fig. 5.61 shows an example of the image of a stage micrometer (the scale at the right) and the reticle scale (the scale at the middle of the field of view). (Note that this is not the same stage micrometer shown in Fig. 5.52). Line up the two scales until they are parallel, as shown in Fig. 5.61 and align the “0” of the two micrometer scales, as shown. In this stage micrometer, one small division equals 0.01 mm (100 divisions ⫽ 1 mm). Step 5: As shown in Fig. 5.61, count the number of divisions on the stage micrometer scale that match the full 100 divisions on the eyepiece reticle scale. In this example, 100 divisions on the eyepiece scale equal 122 divisions on the stage micrometer. Therefore, 122 divisions equal a length of 1.22 mm. From the following equation, calculate the length of each division on the eyepiece scale:
Eyepiece scale division ⫽
Fig. 5.61 Micrograph of a stage micrometer scale (right) and an eyepiece
micrometer scale (center) as seen through an eyepiece. Note that the “0” position of the stage micrometer scale coincides with the “0” position of the eyepiece micrometer scale. Courtesy of E. Leitz GmbH
Length of stage micrometer divisions No. of divisions on eyepiece reticle scale
Thus, each eyepiece scale division ⫽ 1.22 mm/100 divisions ⫽ 0.0122 mm per division, or 12.2 μm per division (1 mm ⫽ 1000 μm). This means that everything that is magnified by this objective-eyepiece combination on this microscope is 1.22⫻ greater than actual. Thus, a 5⫻ objective with a 10⫻ eyepiece would have a magnification of 5 ⫻ 10 ⫻ 1.22 ⫽ 61⫻. • Step 6: Repeat steps 3 and 4 for each objective. • Step 7: Prepare a table of eyepiece scale (or eyepiece micrometer) calibrations and magnification corrections for each objective-eyepiece combination for each microscope in the metallographic laboratory. A similar procedure can be used to calibrate a filar measuring eyepiece. A filar eyepiece has a moveable cross hair on the linear
The Metallurgical Microscope / 143 eyepiece scale. The moveable cross hair is adjusted by rotating a micrometer barrel attached to a graduated vernier scale (similar to a machinist’s micrometer) mounted outside the eyepiece. The cross hair is placed at the extreme edge or “0” division of the stage micrometer scale image, as seen in the eyepiece of the microscope. This “0” position should coincide with the “0” position on the graduated micrometer barrel scale. The cross hair is then moved to the next division on the stage micrometer scale, and the graduated position on the micrometer barrel scale is noted, and so on. Similar procedures can be used to calibrate digital filar eyepieces and other electronic devices (e.g., cross-hair movement of lines on a monitor screen). Procedure to Determine the Magnification of a Micrograph. When micrographs are produced through the optical system of a microscope or metallograph, it is not always guaranteed that the assumed magnification will be achieved on the micrograph. The actual magnification at the film plane in the camera attachment or film holder should be physically measured to ensure the magnification of the micrograph. The following procedure is recommended: •
• •
•
Step 1: Place a stage micrometer on the stage of the microscope or metallograph. A stage micrometer consists of a closely spaced graduated scale inscribed on a slide. For ensured accuracy, the stage micrometer must be traceable to NIST or a similar organization. An example of a magnified image of a stage micrometer photographed at 50⫻ is seen in Fig. 5.52. There are two scales on this stage micrometer. In the large main scale at the left, each division is 0.1 mm apart, and with 20 divisions, the total length of the larger scale is 2 mm. In the small scale at the right, the smallest divisions are 0.01 mm apart (the total length of the smaller scale is 0.2 mm). Step 2: After carefully focusing the image of the micrometer, adjust the microscope and produce a micrograph. Step 3: Using the larger scale on the micrograph in Fig. 5.52, measure the length between the 20 divisions. The stage micrometer length is 2 mm. Use an accurate engraved ruler with a millimeter scale (do not use a cheap plastic ruler found in some desk drawer). In this case, the distance measured on the micrograph between the 20 divisions in the larger scale is 100 mm. Step 4: To determine the magnification, divide the measured length from the micrograph by the length of the divisions in the actual stage micrometer: Magnification ⫽
task, but an inexperienced person can easily damage the objective lens as well as gouge the specimen with the tip of the objective. Never allow the objective to touch the specimen during focus, and never allow the specimen to touch the tip of the objective when placing the specimen under the objective. The experienced metallographer should not let an inexperienced person use the microscope without first instructing that person on the proper procedure to focus the microscope. The recommended procedure is as follows. For an inverted microscope: •
•
•
•
•
•
Measured length on micrograph Measured length on micrometer
In this case, the magnification equals 100 mm/2 mm, or 50⫻. The same procedure can be performed on the ground glass screen of the camera attachment of the microscope or metallograph and also on the screen of a video monitor. Procedure to Properly Focus the Microscope on the Specimen. Obviously, focusing the microscope appears to be a simple
Step 1: Without the specimen on the stage, rotate the nosepiece so that the objective with the lowest magnification (shortest objective) will be under the specimen. This is usually the 5⫻ objective. Step 2: Place the specimen on the stage. When doing this, make sure that the tip of the objective is well below the stage opening, so that the objective lens will not be damaged. Step 3: While looking at the objective tip, move the stage downward (or upward if the stage is fixed and the nosepiece moves up or down) with the coarse-focusing knob until the objective tip is close to but not touching the specimen. (Note: never lower the specimen toward the objective, or vice versa, while looking into the eyepieces.) Step 4: While looking into the eyepieces, raise the stage until the specimen is in focus. Close down the field diaphragm until it can be seen through the eyepieces, and focus on the edge of the field diaphragm. When the field diaphragm is in focus, the specimen is in focus. Step 5: Once in this focused position, move the stage in the xor y-direction, and if the specimen image moves, everything is proper. However, if nothing moves, the focus may be on dirt or dust on the eyepiece or objective lenses, particularly for a polished, featureless specimen. Many times, the inexperienced person is deceived by focusing on the dirt instead of the specimen itself. For ease of focus on a highly polished specimen, align the specimen so that the light beam is about half-on and half-off the specimen (look at the specimen and light beam without looking into the microscope). By looking into the eyepieces, very slowly adjust the coarse-focus knob to bring the edge of the specimen into reasonable focus. Use the fine-focus knob to obtain proper focus of the specimen edge. Step 6: Once proper focus is achieved, the nosepiece can be rotated to the objective with the next highest magnification (do not go directly from 5 to 100⫻ without intermediate focus at the other objectives). As a rule, keep in mind that the coarseor fine-focus knobs should be used only for the 5 and 10⫻ objectives. For 20⫻ and above, to prevent damage to the objective lens and damage to the specimen, only use the fine-focus knob because of the short working distance of the higher-power objectives.
For an upright microscope: •
Step 1: Without the specimen on the stage, rotate the nosepiece so that the objective with the lowest magnification (shortest
144 / Metallographer’s Guide
•
•
•
•
•
objective) will be over the specimen. This is usually the 5⫻ objective. Step 2: Place the leveled specimen on the stage. When doing this, make sure that there is ample room between the specimen and the tip of the objective. To ensure this, fully lower the stage. Step 3: While looking at the objective tip, move the stage upward with the coarse-focusing knob until the objective tip is close to but not touching the specimen. (Note: never raise the stage toward the objective while looking into the eyepieces, because the specimen can impact the objective and cause damage to the lens). Step 4: While looking into the eyepieces, lower the stage until the specimen is in focus. Close down the field diaphragm until it can be seen through the eyepieces, and focus on the edge of the field diaphragm. When the field diaphragm is in focus, the specimen is in focus. Step 5: Once in this focused position, move the stage in the xor y-direction, and if the specimen image moves, everything is proper. However, if nothing moves, the focus may be on dirt or dust on the eyepiece or objective lenses. Many times, the inexperienced person is deceived by focusing on the dirt instead of the specimen itself, particularly for a polished, featureless specimen. For ease of focus on a highly polished specimen, align the specimen so that the light beam is about half-on and half-off the specimen (align the specimen and light beam without looking into the eyepieces). Then, by looking into the eyepieces, very slowly adjust the coarse-focus knob to bring the edge of the specimen into reasonable focus. Use the fine-focus knob to obtain proper focus of the specimen edge. Step 6: Once proper focus is achieved, the nosepiece can be rotated to the objective with the next highest magnification (do not go directly from 5 to 100⫻ without intermediate focus at the other objectives). As a rule, keep in mind that the coarseor fine-focus knobs should be used only for the 5 and 10⫻ objectives. For objectives at 20⫻ and above, to prevent damage to the objective lens and the specimen, only use the fine-focus knob, because of the short working distance of the higher power objectives.
Procedure to Personalize the Microscope for Viewing. Every person does not have perfect 20/20 vision. Some people wear eyeglasses to correct for vision errors such as astigmatism or nearsightedness. Also, the spacing between the eyes can vary from person to person, depending on facial bone structure. Therefore, a microscope must be adjusted or “personalized” to obtain the optimal magnified image for each person. The following step-bystep instructions should be taken each time the metallographer uses a microscope. If the metallographer is the only one using the microscope, this procedure needs to be done only once. However, in a laboratory where more than one person is using the same microscope, personalized adjustments need to be conducted by each person. In the following procedure, an upright microscope is assumed: •
Step 1: Turn on the microscope light source and place a leveled specimen on the stage.
•
•
•
•
•
•
Step 2: Rotate the nosepiece, allowing for ample clearance of the specimen, so that the lowest power objective is over the specimen. Step 3: Without looking into the eyepiece, rotate the coarseadjustment knob so that the tip of the objective is fairly close to the specimen (about 3 mm, or 0.125 in., clearance). Step 4: While looking into the eyepiece, lower the stage away from the objective. (Note: never raise the stage toward the objective while looking into the eyepieces.) If observing an as-polished specimen, it is easier to focus by having the light beam half-on the specimen and half-on the mount, or if the specimen is unmounted, half-on the specimen and half-off the edge. While looking at the specimen from the side (not through the eyepieces), the beam of light can be seen illuminating the specimen. Continue to move the stage away from the specimen until the image is in focus. If the specimen is highly polished, an alternate procedure is to close down the field diaphragm until it can be seen. Move the stage downward until the edge of the field diaphragm is in focus. If the diaphragm is in focus, the specimen is in focus. Step 5: In a binocular microscope, adjust the eyepieces to take into account the distance between the pupils of your eyes, called the interpupillary distance. By slowly moving your head back and forth and adjusting the interocular distance, a single circular field should appear, as if the circular fields of both eyepieces merged into one field. Once adjusted, remember the interpupillary distance for future reference. Step 6: Adjust each eyepiece for each eye at a magnification of 500⫻. Some microscopes allow adjustment of one eyepiece; some microscopes allow both to be adjusted. With the former, close the eye over the adjustable eyepiece and rotate the fine focus for the eye over the fixed eyepiece. Then, close that eye and adjust the other eyepiece for focus. Do not adjust the fine focus for that eye, but adjust the eyepiece itself. Now the images in both eyepieces are in focus. During this process, changes can be made to the aperture diaphragm for optimal imaging, remembering the rule that for high magnification, the field-stop iris is closed down, and at low magnifications, the iris is opened up. Some eyepieces have a diopter scale at the bottom of each eyepiece, as seen in Fig. 5.62. Before starting step 6, set the diopter mark at zero for each eyepiece. After completing this step, note the diopter number for future reference. Step 7: Adjust the field diaphragm so that it is just out of sight in the field of view. This can be done by closing the diaphragm until one can see it at the outer edge of the field. Then, slowly open the diaphragm until it just disappears from the field of view. Now the field diaphragm does not have to be further adjusted; the microscope can now be used for observation.
Procedure to Center and Focus the Light Source. When purchasing a new microscope or when changing the light source (bulb), the metallographer must center and focus the light source before using the microscope. If the lamp is not centered, the light will not be evenly distributed on the specimen. This is particularly important for micrography. This can be seen in Fig. 5.63 which
The Metallurgical Microscope / 145 represents pearlite on austenite grain boundaries in a cast 19% Cr-9% Ni heat-resistant grade HF steel. The micrograph shown in Fig. 5.63(a) was taken with an off-center halogen light source. The light source was centered for the micrograph shown in Fig. 5.63(b). The differences can be seen in the sharpness of the carbide lamella in some of the lamellar colonies (see arrows). To center and focus the lamp, follow the instructions supplied from the microscope manufacturer. Each microscope is different, and therefore, the manufacturer’s instructions are important to
follow. Some microscopes allow for centering and focusing on a portable screen or on the wall of the laboratory. However, in most microscopes, the procedure is done inside the microscope tube. In all cases, the lamp must be centered and focused through the condenser lens, aperture diaphragm, and field diaphragm system, as follows: • •
•
•
•
• Fig. 5.62 Photograph of a binocular attachment showing diopter scale at the base of one of the eyepieces
Step 1: Fully open the aperture diaphragm. Step 2: For this procedure, a highly reflective specimen is needed. This can usually be achieved by placing a polished but unetched metallographic specimen on the stage. Step 3: Focus on the specimen. For easier focusing, close the field diaphragm and obtain a clear, sharp image of the diaphragm. Once the diaphragm is in focus, the specimen is in focus. Step 4: Remove the eyepiece from the observation tube. If the microscope has a binocular, remove one of the eyepieces. Look into the empty tube to see the bright, circular image at the back side of the objective. This circle is created by the light from the specimen coming back through the lenses of the objective. This step can also be performed through the trinocular tube of a microscope. If possible, the diffusion filter must be removed. Step 5: Adjust the screws on the lamp housing in order to move the lamp forward and backward in the optical axis until an image of the filament of the lamp can be clearly seen in the circle of light on the back lens of the objective. At this point, tighten the screws in this position. Step 6: Adjust the screws that move the lamp side to side and up and down until the image of the filament is centered on the back lens of the objective. The light should now be focused and centered.
Fig. 5.63 Micrographs of lamellar carbide colonies on an austenite grain boundary in cast 19% Cr-9% Ni heat-resistant HF steel. In (a) the light source is
not centered, and in (b) the light source is centered. Note the improved sharpness of the carbide lamella in (b) (see arrows). Electrolytic etch (60 ml nitric acid in 40 ml water, stainless steel cathode). 500⫻
146 / Metallographer’s Guide •
Step 7: Replace the eyepiece in the eyepiece tube.
Procedure to Adjust the Aperture Diaphragm. It is very important to adjust the aperture diaphragm for optimal performance of the microscope. The resolution, contrast, and depth of focus are all affected by the aperture diaphragm. One should always follow the procedures outlined in the instruction manual that was included with the microscope when it was purchased. In general, the following steps are usually performed: • •
•
Step 1: Place a metallographic specimen on the stage in order to obtain a focused, highly reflective surface. Step 2: Remove the eyepiece from the observation tube or one of the eyepieces from the binocular tube. By looking into the tube, one will see a small circle of light at the back lens of the objective (created by the light returning back through the objective from the reflectivity of the specimen). (An alternate method to step 2 is described subsequently, using a Bertrand lens. This lens magnifies the circle of light for more accurate adjustment.) Step 3: Close down the aperture diaphragm until one can see the outer edges of the diaphragm at the periphery of the circle of light. In other words, the image of the aperture diaphragm is now visible on the circle of light. Now adjust the image of the aperture until it is about 70 to 80% of the original circle of light (70 to 80% of the diameter). With this amount of area, the aperture diaphragm is properly adjusted.
• • •
Procedure to Measure the Depth of a Depression in the Specimen. There may be instances when the metallographer will be required to measure the depth of a pore, crack, or other depression on the surface of a metallographic specimen. The following procedure can be followed (the example is a hemispherical depression): •
• • •
Important note: Remember to adjust the aperture diaphragm every time a different objective and different sample are used. The light intensity will need adjusting as the aperture is adjusted. Procedure to Adjust the Aperture Diaphragm Using a Bertrand Lens. Some advanced metallurgical microscopes have a special lens, called a Bertrand lens, mounted in the tube of the microscope (actually, the lens is moved in and out of the optical axis, as needed). With the Bertrand lens in the light path, the eyepiece of the microscope does not have to be removed from the tube (as in step 2 of the previous procedure), and by simply focusing, the metallographer can observe the edge of the aperture diaphragm very clearly with an enlarged view. Figure 5.50 shows an example of the image created by a Bertrand lens. Note the light gray outer circle; this is the outer image of the cone of light from the back of the objective. The eight-sided image is the aperture diaphragm. In this example, the aperture diaphragm is closed about 25% (see step 3 of the previous procedure). Procedure to Adjust the Field Diaphragm. The field diaphragm determines the size of the illuminated area on the specimen surface with relation to the field of view that the metallographer observes through the eyepieces. Proper adjustment will decrease light flare in the image and improve contrast. For micrography, the proper adjustment of the field diaphragm is vital. Adjustment of the field diaphragm is quite easy, as indicated in the following steps: •
Step 1: Place a metallographic specimen on the stage of the microscope.
Step 2: Bring the microstructure into focus. Step 3: Close down the field diaphragm until it is seen at the outer edge of the field of view. Step 4: Open the field diaphragm until it just disappears from view. At this point, the field diaphragm is properly adjusted. During micrography, if the image is projected onto a ground glass screen, close down the field aperature until it is just outside the film format markings on the screen.
Step 1: Place the leveled specimen on the stage of the microscope. Upon observation, make sure that the top edge and bottom of the feature are in the same field of view, as seen in Fig. 5.64. This is important so that the stage does not have to be moved in the horizontal x- and y-directions. (Note in this micrograph that the out-of-focus disk in the black region is the reflected light from the bottom of the depression.) Step 2: Choose the highest-magnification objective possible in order to provide the smallest depth of field. Step 3: Open the aperture diaphragm to its largest diameter, in order to reduce the depth of field. Step 4: Focus on the edge of the feature, as seen in Fig. 5.64, and record the reading on the fine-focus knob scale. An example of the scale on the fine-focus knob can be seen in Fig.
Fig. 5.64 Micrograph of the top edge of a hemispherical depression in an
AISI/SAE 1040 steel. The microstructure consists of ferrite (white constituent) and pearlite (dark constituent). Note the small circle of reflection from the bottom of the indentation. 2% nital etch. 200⫻
The Metallurgical Microscope / 147 5.7. Check the manufacture’s instructions for the microscope to determine the dimensions of the scale increments. These increments are usually 0.001 mm (1μm). • Step 5: Focus on the bottom of the feature, as seen in Fig. 5.65,
Fig. 5.65 Micrograph of the bottom surface of a hemispherical depression
in an AISI/SAE 1040 steel. The microscope is focused on the small, circular area in this micrograph, which contains a manganese sulfide inclusion. 2% nital etch. 200⫻
•
and record the reading on the fine-focus knob. In this micrograph, one can see a manganese sulfide inclusion at the bottom of the depression. Step 6: Subtract the two measurements to calculate the depth
Fig. 5.66 Scribing device mounted in one of the ports of the nosepiece.
Before scribing, the specimen should be firmly mounted in clay on a glass or metal slide on the microscope stage.
Fig. 5.67 Micrographs of a small titanium nitride inclusion in A8 tool steel. (a) Surrounded by three circular scribe marks and (b) a closer view of the inner circle showing the inclusion (see arrow). Vilella’s etch. (a) 50⫻ and (b) 300⫻
148 / Metallographer’s Guide of the feature. The depression in this example has a depth of 116 μm. The same procedure can be used to measure the height of a surface feature. Procedure to Scribe a Selected Region on the Specimen Surface. It may become necessary for the metallographer to mark a feature in the microstructure for further analysis by another instrument or to revisit the feature at some other time. One procedure is to use a scribe, which physically “plows” a permanent circle around the area of interest. Figure 5.51 shows a scribing device that replaces an objective in the nosepiece of a metallurgical microscope. The procedure to scribe a circle around the area of interest is as follows: •
•
• •
•
•
•
Step 1: Remove one of the objectives from the nosepiece of the microscope. Screw the scribing device into that location, as shown in Fig. 5.66. It is best that the scribing device is next to the objective being used to select the field of interest. Step 2: Place the specimen on the microscope stage. Make sure that the specimen will not move on the microscope stage. One way to ensure this is to push the specimen (mount) firmly into Plasticine (clay), using a leveling device. The Plasticine should, in turn, be firmly attached to a glass or metal slide. Step 3: Select the feature or area of interest, and center it in the field of view. Step 4: Rotate the nosepiece so that the scribe is centered over the specimen. At this point, the metallographer cannot see the field of view, because the scribe replaced the objective, but the scribe should be parcentric with the observation objective. Step 5: Select the diameter of the circle by selecting the appropriate number on the scale on the barrel of the scribe (see manufacturer’s instructions about the scale dimensions). The scribe shown in Fig. 5.51 can produce circles from 250 to 4000 μm in diameter. Step 6: While watching, carefully raise the stage until the specimen makes direct contact with the diamond tip of the scribe. The tip is usually spring loaded, and as soon as there is a slight movement of the tip of the scribe, there is contact with the specimen surface. Step 7: Gently rotate the knurled ring on the scribe in order to rotate the diamond tip (the tip is off-center from the optical axis). The tip will “plow” a circle or semicircle around the
feature. Typical scribe marks are shown in Fig. 5.67. The micrograph in Fig. 5.67(a) shows three concentric scribed circles, and the micrograph in Fig. 5.67(b) shows the inner circle around an area that includes a small titanium nitride inclusion (see arrow) in an A8 tool steel. The diameter of the large circle is 1498 μm, the diameter of the middle circle is 764 μm, and the diameter of the small circle is 262 μm. Many times, the first circle is too large, and the metallographer must make one or more smaller inner circles to “zero in” on the feature. • Step 8: After scribing, carefully lower the stage away from the tip of the scribe. • Step 9: Rotate the nosepiece to the lowest-magnification objective, focus, and view the selected area and the circle. If the circle is too large, repeat steps 3 to 8 by selecting a smaller radius on the scribe (step 5). If the circle is too small, select a larger radius on the scribe. This method can be used to scribe many features on a specimen surface. Different diameter circles or different semicircular shapes can be used for identification of each feature. SELECTED REFERENCES General references • • • •
J.G. Delly, Photography through the Microscope, Eastman Kodak Company, 1988 R.C. Gifkins, Optical Microscopy of Metals, American Elsevier Publishing Company, Inc., 1970 Metallography and Microstructures, Vol 9, ASM Handbook, American Society for Metals, 1985 Metallography, Structures and Phase Diagrams, Vol 8, Metals Handbook, 8th ed., American Society for Metals, 1973
Microscope manufacturer booklets • • •
M. Abramowitz, “Microscope Basics and Beyond,” Vol 1, Olympus Corp., 1985 M. Abramowitz, “Optics: a Primer,” Olympus America Inc., 1994 F. Restivo, “A Simplified Approach to the Use of Reflected Light Microscopes,” Leco Corp., 1991
Metallographer's Guide: Practices and Procedures for Irons and Steels Bruce L. Bramfitt, Arlan O. Benscoter, p149-168 DOI:10.1361/mgpp2002p149
Copyright © 2002 ASM International® All rights reserved. www.asminternational.org
CHAPTER 6
The Expanded Metallographic Laboratory MANY METALLOGRAPHIC LABORATORIES of today are rather sophistcated, with tools that go well beyond the simple light microscope. For example, a scanning electron microscope (SEM) is quite useful in conducting failure analysis. An image analysis system can be justified when large numbers of grain size and volume fraction measurements are required. Chapter 4 introduced the basic equipment required for typical large and small metallographic laboratories. These laboratories are designed to include facilities for sample preparation and microscopes for observing and photographing microstructures. Chapter 5 introduced and described the use of the metallurgical microscope. The microscope is known as a “light” microscope, because it employs light as the source of illumination of the specimen. These microscopes are commonly called “optical” microscopes, but in this book the authors identify the microscope by the type of illumination used. The first stage in any metallographic analysis involves the observation of the microstructure in a light microscope or a light stereomicroscope before going to other instruments. This is extremely important, because there are numerous cases where key information was missed because the light microscope was bypassed. Once the specimen is examined in the light microscope, in many cases it is desirable to go beyond the light microscope to gather further information about the chemical composition of the microstructural constituents, the amount (volume fraction) of each constituent in the microstructure, finer details of the morphology of the various constituents present in the sample, and the hardness of the constituents. There are a number of specialized instruments available for the metallographer to use as tools to gather additional key information on characteristics of the microstructure being analyzed. Some of these instruments are microscopes that use electrons as a source of illumination instead of light; some are instruments that use x-rays. This chapter describes these instruments in terms of how they can be used to gather important information about a microstructure. Also, the limitations of each instrument are described. If additional information is needed on these instruments, several references have been included at the end of the chapter for further reading.
The Image Analyzer Many metallographic laboratories have an image analyzer as part of the observation/photographic facilities. As the name
implies, the specimen image is “analyzed” according to its geometric features. This technique cannot give you a chemical analysis of the constituents in the microstructure, but it can measure the volume fraction, size, shape, and distribution of each constituent in the microstructure. The instrument is simply a light microscope equipped with a moving specimen stage and a video scanner that records the image of a particular location or field in the specimen. Information obtained from the scanned image is digitized, and many analytical functions are performed by a computer. A typical image analyzer setup is shown in Fig. 6.1. The specimen is moved according to a programmed sequence of steps so that the camera can record the features of the microstructure at each position. Hundreds of individual fields are digitally recorded for each specimen and stored in a computer. The components in the microstructure are distinguished from each other by their different levels of gray, with white and black levels being the extremes. For example, in a typical American Iron and Steel Institute/Society of Automotive Engineers (AISI/SAE) 1040 steel, the pearlite constituent would have a darker gray level than the ferrite constituent. Before the specimen is analyzed, a gray
Fig. 6.1 A typical image analyzer setup showing light microscope with
camera attachment at the left, video monitor in the center, and microprocessor with command monitor at the right. The microstructure displayed on the center monitor is the AISI/SAE 1020 steel shown in Fig. 6.2.
150 / Metallographer’s Guide threshold level is established for each constituent. The instrument can then distinguish each constituent and make accurate measurements of its shape, size, and distribution. Many fields are automatically analyzed in the same manner to obtain a meaningful statistical population that accurately characterized that constituent. As an example, the constituents in a simple microstructure are measured. An annealed specimen of AISI/SAE 1020 is chosen for the example, its microstructure being shown in Fig. 6.2. For the analysis, the specimen was moved in a preset pattern on the microscope stage so that 100 different fields of view were analyzed. The digitized image of a typical field displayed on the monitor is shown in Fig. 6.3. After completing the collection of data and allowing the computer time to analyze the data, the following information was obtained about the constituents in this AISI/SAE 1020 specimen: Volume percent pearlite Volume percent ferrite Average ferrite grain diameter ASTM grain size
⫽ ⫽ ⫽ ⫽
20% 80% 19.4 μm 8.1
One can also obtain the statistical error in the measurements and have the computer print a plot of the data as a histogram, pie chart, and so on. The obvious advantages of the image analysis system are the speed and accuracy of the measurements. The previous analysis of 100 different fields took about five minutes, whereas in the same period of time, only about five fields could be measured by manual techniques. Thus, 20 times more data can be collected
and analyzed by automated image analysis (this is continuing to improve as computers become faster). Another advantage is that there is less fatigue of the metallographer. One disadvantage is the cost of an image analysis system. The additional cost can be justified if large amounts of quantitative information are needed on a routine basis. An example would be in evaluating cleanliness of steels for quality control in a production environment. The analysis would yield quantitative information on the number, type, size, and distribution of nonmetallic inclusions in production samples as well as give a microcleanliness rating for the specimen analyzed. Some image analysis systems are programmed to give the steel an ASTM E 45 ranking for sulfides, silicates, aluminum oxides, and globular oxides. Many production metallographic laboratories have image analysis capability for routine quality control. The Digitizing Pad. Another instrument that can be used for image analysis is the digitizing pad. This is a low-cost option for the laboratory that cannot afford a full-scale computerized image analysis system. A digitizing pad is a semiautomatic electronic device that allows the metallographer to interact with a specimen through a light microscope or with a micrograph of the specimen to collect data on microstructural details, such as areas, lengths, point counts, maximum diameters, distances between constituents, and so on. The information can be collected and analyzed in a personal computer. A photograph of a digitizing pad attached to a light microscope can be seen in Fig. 6.4. The device can be used in two different ways. One is to lay a micrograph to be analyzed on the pad and move the electronically sensitive cursor by hand about the metallographic features to be measured. This procedure
Fig. 6.2 Micrograph of AISI/SAE 1020 steel shown on the video monitor in
Fig. 6.1. Pearlite is the gray-appearing constituent, and ferrite is the white-appearing constituent. Marshall’s reagent was specifically used to delineate the ferrite grain boundaries for image analysis. The pearlite is etched brown by Marshall’s reagent as opposed to a picral or nital etch, which produces a darker pearlite. 400⫻
Fig. 6.3 A closer view of the digitized image of the microstructure of the AISI/SAE 1020 steel that was shown on the video monitor in the center of Fig. 6.1.
The Expanded Metallographic Laboratory / 151 is shown in Fig. 6.5. The other way is to view a metallographic specimen through a light microscope. The cursor is still moved by hand on the “empty” pad. However, the cursor and microstructural image are superimposed in the view seen in the microscope. The merger of the microscope image and the cursor, shown in Fig. 6.6, takes place by means of a “drawing” tube. In Fig. 6.4, the drawing tube is attached to the right side of the microscope.
Fig. 6.4 Digitizing pad setup with a light microscope attached to the pad
The advantage of the digitizing pad, other than its lower cost, is that the metallographer can collect data on microstructural features that have very little gray-level difference. Also, less training is needed to operate a digitizing pad, and a “perfectly” prepared sample is not absolutely necessary, because the human eye can overlook irregularities that are not part of the microstructure. As is seen later in Chapter 7, the specimen preparation for an automatic image analyzer must be closely controlled in order to prevent inaccurate measurements. Sample Requirements. It must be pointed out that the metallographic specimens for an image analyzer must be more carefully prepared than for manual measurements. In manual measurements (including the digitizing pad device described previously), the human eye can compensate and adjust for minor irregularities in microstructure, but removal of scratches and other artifacts is absolutely necessary in a specimen prepared for image analysis. Relief (constituents of differing height) caused by overetching of constituents also should be minimized. Also, because the image analyzer depends on the distinction between differing gray levels of the constituents being measured, special etching techniques may be needed to distinguish the various constituents so that they intentionally have differing gray levels. For grain-size measurements, the specimen must be etched to reveal all the grain boundaries; otherwise, the measurement will be in error. The specimen of AISI/SAE 1020 shown in Fig. 6.2 was etched in Marshall’s reagent to highlight the ferrite grain boundaries without creating unacceptable relief in the specimen. Marshall’s reagent and other etchants used for image analysis are described in Chapter 8. More detailed information on image analysis and specimen preparation for image analysis can be found in the references at the end of the chapter.
(or tablet) at right. The drawing tube (horizontal tube) is attached to the right side of the microscope. A printer is shown at the left.
Fig. 6.6 The image of the cursor superimposed on the field of the Fig. 6.5 Digitizing pad with a micrograph of a Galvalume (BHP, Ltd.) coating on a low-carbon steel. The movable cursor is shown.
microstructure. This image was taken through the light microscope to illustrate what the metallographer would observe if a specimen on the microscope stage was being measured.
152 / Metallographer’s Guide
The Electron Microscope There are several different types of electron microscopes used for metallographic analysis. The more common electron microscopes include the transmission electron microscope (TEM), the SEM, and the electron probe microanalyzer (EPMA). Another electron microscope, used mainly in a research environment, is the scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM). A description of these four electron microscopes is given subsequently. First, we must understand why electron microscopes are important tools for metallographic analysis. This is because the properties or characteristics of electrons are different than those of light used in the light microscope. Metals are opaque to light but are transparent to electrons, at least to a limited extent. Thus, electrons can penetrate a steel sample, and, if it is thin enough, it can become transparent. Therefore, with electrons as the source of illumination on a steel sample, a metallographer can see the internal microstructure of that sample. Moreover, electrons have a much shorter wavelength (about 0.0037 nm) than light (about 1000 nm), and, as a consequence, the theoretical resolving power in the electron microscope is thousands of times greater than the light microscope. This means that magnifications in the hundreds of thousands of times are quite common, and very small features can be observed in the sample that cannot be seen in a light microscope (e.g., precipitates as small as 2 nm in diameter). Electrons also interact with the atoms in the steel sample in a number of ways, and, as a result, additional useful information can be generated. In fact, the different electron microscopes mentioned previously are designed to take advantage of these electron/ metal interactions. The various interactions are shown schematically in Fig. 6.7. For example, the primary electrons (the electrons in the electron beam) interact to generate x-rays that have energies and wavelengths that are uniquely characteristic of the elements contained within the sample. These x-rays can be collected within the microscope to provide information about the chemical com-
Fig. 6.7 A sketch showing some of the different types of electrons and x-rays generated by the interaction of the primary incident electron beam with the specimen in the electron microscope
position of the constituents in the sample. The primary electrons also interact to generate other electrons, called secondary electrons, which can provide topographical information about the surface features of the sample. Other interactions include backscattered electrons, Auger electrons, and, photons. The results of some of these interactions as used in the various electron microscopes are discussed subsequently. First, the basic electron microscope, the TEM, is described.
The Transmission Electron Microscope When people think of an electron microscope, they usually think of the TEM. This instrument has been used since the middle of the 20th century to examine the “fine” microstructural details of steels and cast irons. Because the electrons can penetrate thin foils of specially prepared samples, discoveries were made by transmission electron microscopy in the late 1940s and early 1950s that led to major advances in our understanding of the fundamentals of physical metallurgy. Confirmation of the presence of dislocations in the late 1940s was a key breakthrough needed to understand how metals plastically deform and work harden. The electron microscope was also used to make major advances in our understanding of precipitation and dislocation strengthening of metals and alloys. The TEM employs the same optical principles of the light microscope. Instead of a bright light source, it uses a beam of electrons that is focused by means of magnetic fields that act as “lenses,” similiar in principle to the glass lenses of the light microscope. Figure 6.8 shows a typical TEM. The top of the microscope contains the filament, or source of electrons. A high voltage, usually over 100,000 volts, accelerates the electrons emitted by the filament down through the series of magnetic condenser and objective lenses toward the specimen (located about two-thirds of the way down the column). The image of the electrons as they pass through the specimen can be seen on a phosphorescent screen located below the specimen. The windows located at the bottom of the column are used to observe the image on the screen. A camera is located beneath the screen to photograph the image. It must be remembered that the TEM is only useful for examining very thin specimens. The higher the accelerating voltage of the microscope, the thicker the specimen that can be examined. Generally, two types of specimens are employed: a thin foil or a surface replica. A thin foil is prepared from a bulk sample and prepared to develop a wafer-thin specimen. A replica is prepared from the surface of an etched specimen or fracture surface. The techniques used to prepare these thin foils and replicas are discussed later in this section. In the TEM, the image that is observed is the result of transmitted electrons. Thus, the internal microstructure of a thin section of a metal can be seen, consisting of dislocations, precipitates, grain boundaries, and subgrain boundaries. Figure 6.9 shows a transmission electron micrograph taken of a thin foil of a pearlitic steel. The cementite lamella in the pearlite can be seen, as well as dislocations (the dark lines) in the ferrite. If the micrograph is examined closely, the top and bottom surfaces of
The Expanded Metallographic Laboratory / 153 the cementite lamella can be seen. The through thickness of the lamella is shown as the lighter midsection. The lines running
almost perpendicular to the lamella are subgrain boundaries. Figure 6.10 is a transmission electron micrograph taken from a thin foil of a high-strength, low-alloy (HSLA) steel showing round copper precipates in a matrix of ferrite. Also seen are arrays of dislocations and grain boundaries. Figure 6.11 shows a transmission electron micrograph of a replica of the surface of the same pearlitic steel shown in Fig. 6.9. In this micrograph, taken at
Fig. 6.10 Transmission electron micrograph of a thin foil showing numer-
ous copper precipitates in a hot-rolled, high-strength, low-alloy (HSLA) steel (0.1 C, 0.5 Mn, 1.4 Cu, and 1.0 Ni). Dislocations aligned in a low-angle grain boundary can also be seen. 61,500⫻. Courtesy of K.A. Taylor, Bethlehem Steel Corporation
Fig. 6.8 A transmission electron microscope
Fig. 6.9 Transmission electron micrograph of a thin foil of AISI/SAE 1080
pearlitic steel. The top and bottom surfaces of the cementite lamella can be seen. 15,000⫻
Fig. 6.11 A transmission electron micrograph of a two-stage, shadowed
surface replica of AISA/SAE 1080 pearlitic steel showing a boundary between two pearlite colonies. Specimen etched for 10 s in 2% nital followed by 20 s in 4% picral. 4,000⫻
154 / Metallographer’s Guide a prior austenite grain boundary, one can see the cementite lamella in relief. One disadvantage of the standard TEM is its lack of capability to give the metallographer direct compositional information of the constituents in a microstructure. The SEM, EPMA, and STEM described subsequently have this important capability. However, in the TEM, one can obtain key information about the constituents based on their crystal structure. For example, iron at room temperature has a crystal structure that is called body-centered cubic (BCC). This means that the atoms of iron are in an array of cubes, with atoms at the cube corners and one at the center of each cube. Figure 2.2 in Chapter 2 shows a schematic representation of the BCC unit cell. A grain of ferrite (or iron) consists of millions of BCC unit cells all stacked in an orderly array or lattice. When a primary electron beam in the TEM penetrates this crystal lattice of BCC cells, the beam is diffracted. The angle the electron beam is diffracted is determined by the spacing of the atomic planes in the lattice. The spacing of the atomic planes of iron is unique, because it is based on the distance between the iron atoms in the unit cell. The interatomic spacings of the planes, called “dspacings,” are thus characteristic of each element. These spacings can be measured by the TEM because of the diffraction process. Because the lattice is unique to the particular atomic element in the specimen, electron beams that are diffracted from the specimen lattice can be collected on a photographic film. The resulting spots exposed on the film can be used to identify the particular element present in the sample. The collection of spots is called an electron diffraction pattern. For example, Fig. 6.12 is an electron diffraction pattern for BCC iron (ferrite). Each bright spot in the
photograph indicates the junction where a beam of diffracted electrons, each from a different atomic plane, passed through the photographic emulsion. By measuring the spacing of all the spots on the diffraction pattern with respect to the primary beam (large center spot) and knowing the geometric details (i.e., the camera constant) within the microscope chamber, a microscopist can establish that this pattern is characteristic of BCC iron. If the primary beam is focused on a cementite (Fe3C) particle, it would yield a different electron diffraction pattern unique to cementite, which has an orthorhombic unit cell and thus, a different set of d-spacings. Thus, in a somewhat tedious and indirect way, compositional information can be obtained about the constituents in a particular microstructure. However, the TEM is not normally thought of as an analytical instrument, and other electron microscopes, such as the SEM, EPMA, and STEM, are available for such purposes. Specimen Requirements. Specimens are usually in one of two forms: a thin foil produced from a wafer that is machined from the bulk sample, or a “replica” of the sample surface. To prepare a thin foil, one must obtain a thin section, generally less than 0.5 mm thick, from the sample of interest. This thin section can be cut with a precision wafering machine or by cutting a thicker section and surface grinding the section to the desired thickness (wafer). The thin foil is made by electrolytic thinning of the wafer. The resulting thin foil is on the order of 50 to 200 nm thick. Care is taken to remove all mechanical damage (cold work) created during the cutting operation. Using a special device, the foil is further thinned until a tiny hole appears in the foil. It is the knife-edge thin area around the hole that is actually used for observation in the microscope. One such device, a jet thinning unit, is shown in Fig. 6.13. In this device, a hole is produced in the
Fig. 6.12 An electron diffraction pattern of body-centered cubic iron
taken from a region in a thin foil representing a single grain. Large white spot is the primary beam, and the surrounding spots are the diffracted beams, each representing a different crystallographic plane in the iron lattice. This particular pattern indicates that the grain is orientated with a cube face perpendicular to the primary beam. Courtesy of K.A. Taylor, Bethlehem Steel Corporation
Fig. 6.13 A jet thinning device for preparing thin foils. Source: South Bay Technology Corporation
The Expanded Metallographic Laboratory / 155 foil by the impingement of “jets” of electrolyte on the opposing surfaces at the center of the thin foil. The applied voltage and jet flow is stopped when the first indication of a hole is detected with a photocell device. Another thinning technique is called ion milling, or ion bombardment thinning. In this device, a beam of energetic, positively charged ions, such as argon (Ar⫹), is used to thin the specimen. The technique is extremely slow but produces a smooth surface without grain-boundary etching or etching around particles and precipitates. However, some “damage” can occur in the specimen because of the ion bombardment. Replicas are prepared by different techniques. One type of replica, called a surface or carbon replica, is produced from a specimen as prepared for light microscopy. The specimen surface is coated with a cellulose acetate film (e.g., collodion) to produce a negative impression of the surface features. Then the plastic film is stripped from the specimen surface and coated with a layer of carbon (about 10 to 20 nm thick). The carbon-coating process takes place in a vacuum evaporator unit. A photograph of a typical vacuum evaporator is seen in Fig. 6.14. The plastic is then removed (dissolved) from the carbon replica by a solvent. Before the replica is observed in the microscope, it is usually shadowed with carbon or a heavy element to enhance the topographical features of the surface. The shadowing takes place in a vacuum chamber where atoms of the heavy element are evaporated or
Fig. 6.14 A vacuum evaporator used for depositing carbon on the surface
of a metallographic specimen as the first step in preparing surface replicas. Source: Denton Vacuum, Inc.
“sputtered”onto the surface at an oblique angle to the plane of the replica. Thus, when observing in the microscope, you are not looking at the actual sample but a replica of the surface of the sample. Surface replicas are useful for observing details of surface features in the specimen. Examples of the features in a surface replica are seen in Fig. 6.11 and 6.15. Another type of replica is called an “extraction” replica. The metallographic specimen is etched beforehand to put particles and carbides in relief. In an extraction replica, a carbon film is deposited on the surface of the etched specimen. The carbon film itself is not physically stripped from the specimen surface, but etched or “floated” away from the surface so that those particles physically attached to the deposited carbon film will be extracted from the specimen. An example of the features in an extraction replica can be seen in Fig. 6.16. The dark particles represent titanium-molybdenum carbides and are images of precipitates in a microalloyed steel. The “halos” around the particles are the result of the etching and film deposition technique used. Further details on these and other specimen preparation techniques can be found in references at the end of the chapter.
The Scanning Electron Microscope The most versatile electron microscope is the SEM. A typical SEM is shown in Fig. 6.17. A major difference between the SEM and TEM is that in the SEM, the stationary electron beam is not transmitted through a thin specimen, but the electron beam scans an opaque specimen surface. Thus, the SEM is used to observe and characterize surface features over large (or small) areas of the specimen. The primary electron beam interacts with the specimen surface to produce secondary electrons, backscattered electrons,
Fig. 6.15 Example of a carbon surface replica of a bainitic steel shadowed with carbon. 5000⫻
156 / Metallographer’s Guide and x-rays. With detectors mounted just above the specimen, these electrons and x-rays can be collected and analyzed to provide important information about the specimen surface. Subsequently, we look at each interaction. The backscattered electrons are those electrons that are scattered from the specimen surface and can be collected as the primary beam scans the specimen surface. The collected backscattered electron image of the specimen surface is displayed on a cathode ray tube (CRT) and can be photographed. There is some electron energy loss during the backscattering process. The higher the atomic number of the elements in the sample, the greater the degree of backscattering (less energy loss). This means that
elements with higher atomic numbers, such as iron with an atomic number of 26, will appear brighter on the backscattered electron image on the CRT than elements with lower atomic numbers, such as oxygen with an atomic number of only 8. An example of a backscattered electron image of oxide scale penetration into the surface of an AISI/SAE 1045 steel is shown in Fig. 6.18. The steel appears as the light gray constituent, and the oxide appears as two darker gray constituents. Note that, because of its higher atomic number (i.e., the higher density), the steel appears brighter than
Fig. 6.18 A SEM backscattered electron micrograph of oxide scale pen-
etration on the surface of an AISI/SA