Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page ii
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page iii
MEN, WOMEN, LOVE AND
Romance
under the covers of the bedroom revolution stephen whitehead
ff
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page iv
First published in Great Britain in 2003 by Fusion Press, a division of Satin Publications Ltd. 101 Southwark Street London se1 0jf uk
[email protected] www.visionpaperbacks.co.uk Publisher: Sheena Dewan © Stephen Whitehead 2003 The right of Stephen Whitehead to be identified as the author of the work has been asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act of 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the publisher. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. isbn: 1-904132-22-7 1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2
Printed and bound in the UK by Mackays of Chatham Ltd, Chatham, Kent
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page v
This book is dedicated to all those women who know they’re not from Venus, who can read maps better than most men, and who relish being part of the bedroom revolution.
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page vi
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page vii
Contents
Acknowledgements Introduction
ix 1
i
Men at the Millennium
25
ii
New Women, Different Women
67
iii
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract
128
iv
How To Find Love
166
Summary
215
Bibliography
222
About the Author
228
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page viii
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page ix
Acknowledgements
The people I should acknowledge first are those many women and men who gave their stories to me, stories which subsequently came to form much of the content and direction of this book.However,anonymity was promised and must be preserved, so all I can say to each and everyone of you is thank you. I learned much from you all. Many of you went on to become close friends, something which proved to be a wonderful, unexpected bonus. One of you in particular was more than just a friend, much more.You were there at the very hesitant beginning, offering me a guiding hand as well as love, affection and encouragement.You did this without fear or favour. Not only were you the inspiration for me deciding to write the book in the first place, for me you exemplified the bedroom revolution.You know who you are. To you, my deep gratitude and thanks. As someone who had only ever written rather dense academic books and articles, I found the initial shift to popular non-fiction writing a little difficult at times. I had to do a lot of practice. (In fact, I still have to!) But it wasn’t just practice that got me through, it was also having draft chapters read by women friends and those who had contributed stories. I cannot overstate how invaluable a service ix
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page x
Men,Women, Love and Romance this was to me during the book’s development.This feedback from those very women who were living out democratic love and new sexual contracts every day of their lives kept me on the right track, helping me avoid slipping into academic terminology and making too many mistaken assumptions about key aspects of the bedroom revolution. My grateful thanks to each of you. I am especially indebted to my friend and colleague Beverely Metcalfe for kindly providing me with useful data on studies done into sex and relationships and also reading draft chapters and commenting on the final manuscript. Many thanks,Bev.My thanks also to Ann Bartholomew for reading a full draft of the final manuscript and providing me with invaluable feedback. But more than that Ann, thanks for letting me down softly and may good fortune accompany you on your own journey. A man who has been an invaluable part of my life for many years is my close friend, Roy Moodley.Thanks Roy, for sharing with me your unique and profound insights into life, love, men and relationships and for encouraging me with this project. My eldest son and best friend Gavin probably knows me better than anyone and he better than anyone appreciates what this book means to me, and, not least, what he means to me.Thank you Gavin, and Caroline, for your love and support. I’ve needed it, as you well know. I’m grateful to all my family for their unquestioning love and support, but especially my sister, Liz.Thanks, Liz, you’re great. To Suwanna Yantraruyaha my very special thanks for not only reading draft chapters, but more importantly for showing me just how quickly feelings of love multiply in
x
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page xi
Acknowledgements virtualtime – and how they can so readily translate to realtime, across all time zones and cultures. Of course, no book gets published without professional help and guidance and I’ve been especially fortunate in this regard to have Amanda Preston of Sheil Land and Associates as my agent. Thanks Amanda, you’ve been superb from start to finish. Finally, a special thank you to Sheena Dewan, Managing Director of Fusion Press, who believed in this book and backed it, and to her editor Charlotte Cole and all the staff at Fusion for their efforts in bringing the book to publication. Stephen Whitehead
xi
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page xii
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 1
Introduction
Are you a lover? Are you in love? Have you ever loved someone, romantically and sexually? If so, then you will have experienced the most wonderful of emotions. But it is equally likely that at some point you will have felt pain: the pain of rejection, the anguish of loss.We are vulnerable in love.Yet knowing this rarely stops us falling in love.We continue to take the risk because love is addictive. It has a buzz like no other. Nothing else can provide us with that unique feeling of ‘being in love’, and the joy of being loved in return. In this respect women and men are exactly the same. They both want to be loved; there is nothing mysterious about this.The sexes are not from different planets.The 60-year-old man who lives alone desires love and affection just as much as the 16-year-old girl going to the disco with her friends. It is the most natural of feelings, the most powerful of emotions. Yet, as this book reveals, love and romance are changing. Relationships between women and men are undergoing profound transformations, far-reaching shifts that affect us all.Yes, we still meet, fall in love, maybe marry, maybe separate, perhaps divorce, and then start all over again.This is a romantic roller-coaster that takes off in youth and, for most, ends only when we do. However, the dawn of the 1
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 2
Men,Women, Love and Romance twenty-first century sees this ride of love offer us new thrills, new excitements, new opportunities for romance, but also greater risks, for it is speeding up, getting faster and more hectic. Men, Women, Love and Romance is about the new roller-coaster of love: understanding it, getting on it, riding it, and getting off it. In exploring how individual women and men feel about their relationships this book acts as a guide through the opportunities and pitfalls of contemporary love and romance. In explaining how women and men are changing, this book will help you find the maximum pleasure in your relationships. In showing how men and women are now finding love and romance in their lives, often in the most unexpected places, this book shows routes to democratic love.
A new gender game Relationships between the sexes have never been more complicated than they are today. It can be argued that modern women in the West have more choices open to them than any women since the beginning of time. Men on the other hand seem bemused and confused at the mixed messages they receive about what it now means to be male. The simple stereotypes that once surrounded gender and sexuality are fast disappearing, and with these changes can come confusion for both sexes. This confusion hits us hardest when we fall in love. Because love does not come with a user manual, we are each forced to ask ourselves what it is we want from our relationships. Unfortunately, the answers are anything but clear. I believe that now, more than ever, it comes down to 2
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 3
Introduction how much we are prepared to compromise our individual needs in exchange for a long-term partnership; how much we are prepared to put another person’s desires before our own. In the end, great love still depends on the sacrifices we’re prepared to make, rather than on those we expect our lover to make. However, today, freedom and a sense of individuality increasingly compete with our desire for love and affection.We ask for commitment, but see our lives as a journey; a journey that, for increasing numbers of women, means freedom to experiment, discover new pleasures, learn about themselves. This new way of being a woman does not sit easily with traditional gender roles. As one of the women I interviewed for this book put it:
Women may want traditional love, they don’t want traditional relationships. As twenty-first century men and women, we are no different from previous generations in wanting happiness and contentment in our lives. However, what is different is that we are caught between these two competing desires – the desire for a pure relationship and freedom to be who we are.This is the essence of the new gender game, and to play it properly we have to become adept at balancing these competing urges.We have to become skilled at following our instincts and feelings, while avoiding unnecessary hurt for others.Today, when we talk of contemporary love, we talk less of self-sacrifice and more of ‘What does this relationship do for me?’ Like Bridget Jones many of us seek that special person who will transform our world, make us complete, understand us, satisfy us, protect us and validate us as worthy human beings. And some of us find that 3
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 4
Men,Women, Love and Romance person.Though what we usually find is that the Holy Grail turns out not to be so perfect as we first thought,and in fact requires constant care and attention in order to keep it pristine.This is partly because our desire for freedom, and for perfection in ourselves and others, forces us to constantly question what we have. We put the relationship under the microscope to see if it’s changing, if we’re changing. In the process the character of love and romance is being transformed. In attempting to be both who we are and who our lover wants us to be, we are now all required to be experts in ‘doing’ relationships. In subjecting them to constant scrutiny, to questioning their value, worth and purity, relationships have become the emotional work of the twenty-first century. They are given targets, appraised and assessed. If they don’t measure up, relationships (and partners) are dismissed, made redundant, replaced by a new one. Our ‘model’ for our pure relationship often comes, not from our own experience of life and love, but from colour supplements and glossy magazines, all telling us what love should be like and how we should do it.And to help us with this task we have a range of ‘experts’ ready to hand – psychoanalysts, psychologists, sexologists, sociologists, therapists, astrologers, counsellors. We are caught in a mix of confusion and reward: confusion because there are no clear signposts to guide us; reward because the opportunities for us to experiment, change, and fashion our lives in new and exciting ways have never been so great. 4
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 5
Introduction
Questions of sex and love When I started researching this book I had a lot of questions I wanted to ask. For example, how are sexual relationships changing between women and men? What are professional, independent women looking for in terms of sex, love and romance? Are younger women interested in love or are they increasingly pursuing pleasure rather than commitment? How do more mature women feel about embarking on new relationships? In what ways do men express their romantic feelings – clumsily, instrumentally or with passion? Do men fake romance or do they feel it as strongly as women? Can men say ‘I love you’ and mean it? Does it mean the same thing as a woman’s ‘I love you’? Where do men and women find love and romance in this new era and what role does new technology play in this quest? Is there a new sexual contract between women and men? These questions were not just of professional interest, they were of real interest to me as a man. I’ve spent over a decade researching women, men and relationships, but my own experiences of being on the love roller-coaster, more often than not intoxicated and shaken by the whole experience, have been equally if not more informing. I have four children aged 5 to 28. I have had these children with three different women, each of whom I loved, and probably still love a little; certainly I have been able to retain some form of friendship with each of my ex-partners. I first married at 21, again at 37, and then had a third partnership aged from 45 to 51. In between all this I’ve had numerous friendships and relationships with women, some casual, some very serious. Love is in my life today. Indeed, it 5
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 6
Men,Women, Love and Romance influences the very writing of this book and has done from the beginning. Apart from giving me countless moments of pleasure, these experiences and relationships have taught me that love is always out there if you’re looking for it. In fact,I have come to relish romantic moments,feeling bereft when they are not in my life. I have, like so many other people, become good at getting by without them when they’re not around, but I know I am not alone in wanting and needing to be enveloped in love. In examining how sex, love and romantic moments might be increased for lovers everywhere, and rekindled in the lives of those who have but distant memories of such emotions, this book emphasises that love and romance is for all, young and old, gay and straight, black and white. Recognising that we live in a time when previous gender stereotypes no longer hold sway, I have found that a new age of love and romance is upon us, affecting not only younger women, but especially women in their forties, fifties and sixties plus.This book suggests that these fortyand fifty-somethings are likely to be the storm-troopers of what is, in effect, a ‘bedroom revolution’, taking up opportunities for love and sex undreamt of by their mothers.
What about romance? Whatever our expectations around love and relationships, one of the things we still expect from our partner, at least some of the time, is romance. We all want to feel special, loved and desired.And we still want that love demonstrated in the old-fashioned way – flowers, chocolates, cards, romantic weekends, the occasional unexpected gift and, most of all,in thoughtful,unbidden words of affection – for 6
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 7
Introduction it is through these moments of thoughtfulness that the flame of desire is kept alive. As is discussed in Chapter 3, foreplay begins in thoughtful actions towards our loved one, not in the bed. Sexual arousal usually takes place long before we remove any clothes. However, the traditional romantic game only worked when both parties followed the stereotypes of masculinity and femininity. Men supposedly learnt the game of love and became skilled at ‘pursuit’, women learnt their role and became adept at being ‘caught’. At a certain level these traditional roles worked, for they gave men a good feeling about their masculinity, while confirming dominant notions of femininity. But as this book reveals, these ideas around masculinity and femininity are being discarded and revolutionised. One of the outcomes of this new gender game may be that romance is dying,with true romantic moments only to be found in novels, films and women’s magazines. Perhaps romance is dead already. I don’t believe so, but it is certainly staggering under the weight of new expectations.This is a pity, for romance is the perfect antidote to seeing love as work, something to be analysed and accomplished in a cold, logical fashion.Without romantic feelings to sustain them our relationships may well stagnate and flounder. Despite the overwhelming interest in gender and sexual relationships, few books discuss ‘men and romance’. One can speculate on the reason for this: that men and romance do not appear to go together. Certainly, it takes two to tango, but it has always been understood that women are the emotional experts – empathetic, in touch with their feelings, loving and supporting. Women remember birthdays, anniversaries, and do the emotional labour so necessary in a loving relationship. Men, on the other hand, 7
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 8
Men,Women, Love and Romance are supposedly the emotionally illiterate ones – laggards in the romance and love stakes.Yet it is increasingly expected of men that they ‘get in touch with their feminine side’, be loving, not just lovers. Is this realistic? Can men find new ways of being masculine which encompass emotional maturity, but which also signal a strong sense of manliness? If men cannot ‘do romance’ and women have turned to careers, personal advancement, singledom and serial sexual relationships (just like men), then surely there is no hope for romance. But more than this, if there is no romance between the sexes, can there be true love? I believe that each of us has the power and skill to find true love and romance in this increasingly complicated world. But in order to do so we have to be honest with ourselves, we have to be clear what our needs and desires are.
The bedroom revolution Like most revolutions, the bedroom revolution began in people’s minds before it progressed to the streets and,in this case, the bedroom.The first signs of it were visible in the sexual and cultural revolution of the 1960s, symbolised by the mini-skirt, topless dresses, Lady Chatterley’s Lover, hippy drop-outs, the Beatles and the Pill. But the 1960s were more about men’s sexual freedom than women’s. Most women had to wait through the 1970s and 1980s before they got to realise sexual liberation. Certainly, as many sexologists told us at the time, women were having more sex, but being a single mother was still a social no-no in the 1960s, women were still restricted academically and economically and most women still saw marriage as their 8
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 9
Introduction ultimate destiny. Sex in the 1960s was about the penis, not the clitoris. If 1963 was the year that ‘sexual intercourse began’, as poet Philip Larkin famously suggested, then it began for men, not women. Lovers have at least two very good reasons to be grateful to twentieth century science: the Pill and Viagra. If we look at the 1990s, we can see that this was the decade of gender change in the second half of the twentieth century,not the 1960s.It was in the 1990s that society woke up to the fact that men have a gender; when questions around women and men, their sexualities, roles and expectations, were opened up to scrutiny, not just in academia, but across society. Not surprisingly, the media played a big role in this social transformation. Males had new models of masculinity to aspire to, such as ‘the lad’, the ‘new man’, the ‘househusband’, ‘downsizing man’ and ‘macho man’. This plethora of male types appeared to many as a crisis of masculinity, with prominent American writer Susan Faludi suggesting that men were ‘stiffed’ as a result of women’s progress into hitherto male-only spheres.As if to emphasise this point, women had ‘alpha girl’, the archetypal successful woman – a female operating high up the social and career escalator: determined, independent, work focused and very sexually confident. Tabloids such as the Sun reinforced these stereotypes, as, in different ways, did Cosmopolitan and Loaded, while broadsheets such as the Guardian discussed their social implications. Through the shops and houseparties of Ann Summers buying a dildo or vibrator became an open, shared experience for millions of women, as did going to the see The Chippendales reveal all.Women 9
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 10
Men,Women, Love and Romance were revelling in the freedom to be explicit about their sexuality and desires.Vaginas assumed a new and powerful symbolism in the female consciousness as characterised by The Vagina Monologues, Eve Ensler’s play that has been touring the States and the UK to packed audiences since the late 1990s.The clitoris is also well and truly out of the closet, and not just for women.As one of my women interviewees noted: For many men the clit has become the mysterious key to a woman’s satisfaction. If they haven’t got it ‘to work’ they no longer feel like good lovers. But representations of traditional romance are far from dead. Old-fashioned romantic movies give us our fix, if only for 90 minutes. One of the most successful films of the 1990s was Titanic, starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet. This story of passionate, youthful, but doomed love touched millions. Here we had traditional romance in full bloom and we lapped it up. Moulin Rouge, although more adventurous and elusive, takes us on a heady musical romantic extravaganza. Shakespeare in Love transforms the Bard into a sexy, modern, highly desirable, and uniquely romantic, male.While Bridget Jones’s Diary appears to offer hope to those modern 30-something women searching for their tall, dark, handsome stranger – their knight in shining armour. However, the new millennium is upon us and the media can no longer get away with portraying women as simple stereotypes. Even James Bond, that archetypal gung-ho male, is confronted with a female ‘M’ and has to learn some political correctness. It is becoming clear that there is no 10
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 11
Introduction one way for modern woman to relate to love and romance, for she is a multiple,complex individual,with a mind of her own. Modern woman might appreciate an hour or two of being absorbed in a ‘weepy’, but when she leaves the cinema or puts down her romantic novel do not assume she is actually going to live out such traditional feminine values. Indeed, for many women their relationship aspirations appear more accurately reflected in the television programme Sex and the City, where sexually predatory Samantha uses men to search for multiple orgasms, not love. Of course, what makes the programme so fascinating is that it is women on the prowl for sex, not men. It is now socially acceptable to treat men as sexual objects, something women have had to put up with for centuries. The Full Monty, for example, amusingly captures women’s newfound confidence in their sexual expression as well as men’s responses to being treated as sexual objects of female desire. Sensing this social turn, the media have discovered a new market for films and books all about a male crisis, with the result of pictures such as Fight Club and American Beauty and books like Fever Pitch and Man and Boy. Each emphasise the point that women have changed and men are struggling to find a new identity. Suddenly women and men, far from being set in fixed stereotypes, seem more complicated, less predictable. Underpinning these changes are some hard facts and they are contained in several major UK surveys of sexual behaviour, published in The Lancet 2001 and 2002 (see Chapter 2).These surveys clearly confirm that women are in the throes of a second sexual liberation every bit as controversial and far-reaching as that of the Swinging Sixties. The research shows a remarkable shift in women’s sexual 11
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 12
Men,Women, Love and Romance behaviour. More women are choosing to have sex with more men than ever before.They are having sex earlier and continuing to be sexually active well into their later years. Consequently, women are having more sexual partners over a lifetime. They are more likely to experiment with same sex relationships. They are much less tolerant of unfulfilling relationships, being the gender that, in the main, instigates divorce.The new woman expects men to satisfy her intellectually and emotionally, as well as sexually. She is instigating, in ways she never has before, the frequency and character of her sexual encounters. In short, the old taboos around women’s sexuality are being confined to the cultural dustbin.As one woman I interviewed put it: I have sexual needs and they’re going to be met. I don’t want a man around all the time, just some of the time, and on my terms. This 33-year-old woman is a full-time student at university. She is single with a young child. She is too busy for a heavy emotionally laden relationship, but she does want sex. Not with just any man, but someone who can be there occasionally without making demands. Someone who is emotionally mature. But, importantly, she intends to retain control of the situation. And that is the key difference: women are gaining control. It is clear to me that the bedroom revolution has, to some degree, turned the tables on men, at least in respect of their relationships with women. Men may still rule the world of work, but even here their behaviours are increasingly open to question and scrutiny. New woman, 12
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 13
Introduction especially if she is educated and middle class, is not the passive woman of previous generations, but a sexually aware individual intent on pursuing her own life and agenda, if need be moving from partner to partner in order to satisfy her emotional and physical needs. This woman realises that she does not need a partner, a husband, to be successful. She is prepared to live on her own, if that is what it takes to be happy.She can and will cope with bringing up children as a single parent, if necessary. In this new era, men have to get used to being a sexual commodity, just like women have had to for centuries; scrutinised, assessed, picked up, put down, loved and, perhaps, ultimately discarded if they do not measure up. Female sexuality used to be associated with feelings of guilt, now it’s associated with feelings of power. So where does this leave men? In Chapter 1 I look at men in the new millennium, and how different types of men are responding to the challenges of this new gender game. It is clear that some men will thrive, but others won’t. Some men, ‘twenty-first century men’, will be empowered and excited by the opportunities available to them.These men will learn much, not least about themselves, from their encounters with new woman. Many other men, those I term ‘traditional men’, will retreat, as they are doing, to the domestic comfort and certainties that come from staying with mum.The football stadiums are full of men in retreat, snuggled up in the comfort blanket of male-dominated sport; in other words, postponing maturity indefinitely. These are the men who appear to be in what some describe as a universal ‘crisis of masculinity’. But be wary of taking 13
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 14
Men,Women, Love and Romance this literally.Not all men are in crisis,and for those that are it is less a crisis of masculinity and more a crisis of adaptation. Such men reveal an inability or unwillingness to move on and instead stumble blindly through this sexual maze.
Women and men: are they different species? The biggest stumbling block to men changing is the idea that men’s gender is their destiny. It is to believe that men’s genes, their hormones or man’s prehistoric desire to be ‘the hunter’ somehow make them who they are and that this is fixed, unchanging.This is patent nonsense. Men are not all alike, they are very different. Men are not a species from Mars, any more than women are a species from Venus. Men’s brains are not hard-wired to be masculine from birth, for the simple reason that there has never been one type of masculinity but many.What it means to be a man in the twenty-first century is a whole lot different from what it meant in the Victorian era, or even in the last century. Not only are men very different from each other, they change over their lifetime. Their experiences of love, family, ageing, sex, relationships and work all contribute to how they will live their lives, how they will feel about themselves and others.Although we may have some inherited predispositions, none of us are simply products of our genes or hormones. Our brain is a muscle which is small and undeveloped at birth and grows as we grow. It grows from being in the social environment, because it is the social environment that triggers responses in us. All brains require external stimuli to thrive, and the type and quantity of stimuli we put into our brains develop them, and, importantly, produce and develop our very identities. 14
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 15
Introduction Testosterone may be a powerful hormone, but it doesn’t stop you cleaning the loo. Rather than believe in simple gender stereotypes, today’s woman is asking more searching questions of men. She is not buying into this idea that men can’t change, that they make natural leaders but can’t clean toilets or iron. She no longer believes in the inevitability of her gender as it was told to her mother and grandmother. And she knows the world is her oyster and she’s going to get her pearl, with or without men.As novelist Kathy Lette warns: If men don’t want to become obsolete, they need to pull up their psychological socks.We only need to find a way to get rid of spiders in the bathroom, light the barbie, kiss our upper eyelids and tell us we don’t look fat in Lycra and we won’t need men at all. I have worked with young women students for over a decade and although I’ve come across many who would not consider themselves feminists as such, I’ve not met one who didn’t have strong opinions about the world, about men – and about their personal futures.The heterosexual female students I’ve encountered may like nothing more than a romantic evening with an attractive male, but they’re just as likely to ditch him if he becomes an emotional burden.Very few are prepared to settle down to a life of marital bliss at 21, not when they can be financially independent, travel the world, and have a varied and interesting sex life to boot. Marriage maybe, children quite probably, but not before they can say,‘I’ve made my mark’.These young women are the beneficiaries of the women’s movement of 15
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 16
Men,Women, Love and Romance the 1970s, though the irony is many don’t want to recognise this because it suggests a non-femininity about them. They’ve been seduced by the tabloid myth that portrays feminists as lesbian man-haters. And this is where women and men are alike. They’re both working through highly complex changes of gender and opportunity, and trying to deal with often conflicting desires of sexuality and identity. The difference is that women are, for the most part, way ahead of men in understanding their place in this new and for them exciting gender game. Author Fay Weldon succinctly captures the similarities of modern women with those early gender pioneers: When today’s young woman says she isn’t a feminist what she means is she isn’t a lesbian and she doesn’t hate men, and she likes to wear make-up and she enjoys a l augh. She is no different from many an early feminist.
Democratic love These changes in the pattern of gender and sexual relationships suggest that we have to look upon women and men, not as different beings from different planets, but as individuals with particular desires and needs. Very similar in many ways, but ultimately unique in their detail and character make-up. No two people are identical and as this book emphasises, there are as many differences between women and between men as there are between women and men.Therefore, we have to debunk the idea that only by women ‘surrendering’ to men can society resolve men’s supposed ‘male crisis’. I suggest the new millennium will see increased pressures for democracy in relationships, with 16
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 17
Introduction women and men only maintaining successful relationships through active partnership, discussion and emotional literacy. While recognising that the new millennium brings particular pressures, especially over work, career expectations, ageing, and managing multiple roles, not least those connected with childcare, it is clear that the demise of traditional gender values has the potential to benefit us all. However, as most parents know to their cost, when children arrive so too do traditional gender roles. As US researchers Carolyn and Philip Cowan report: It’s not just that couples are startled by how the division of labour falls along gender lines. But they describe the change as if it were a mysterious virus they picked up when they were in the hospital having the baby. As any couple with children will tell you, children do shift the landscape upon which a relationship has been built.But this does not necessarily mean that the shift need be for the worse and that relationship is then under threat. It all comes down to a willingness to accommodate change, both in ourselves and in others. It comes down to a recognition that although we meet and fall in love as one person, over time we change, and so too does the relationship. Traditional gender values do not allow for that shift.They assume women and men to be fundamentally different at their core, with gender being the rock upon which this difference is fixed – something unchanging over a lifetime. This is a dangerous fiction. With traditional gender roles there is no democracy, for they were devised in an age when men’s views held sway and women maintained their presence in the home.This is something most couples now 17
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 18
Men,Women, Love and Romance struggle with.That is, they believe in equality, but also subscribe to the notion of fundamental gender differences.As gender researcher Susan Maushart explains: Research consistently shows that the vast majority of men and women are committed to equality in marriage. It also shows that most are astonishingly ineffectual at achieving it. Rather than seek biological explanations for how we behave, we have to recognise cultural and social aspects as key influences on our gender and sexuality. If you still doubt this, look at how women have changed in the past four or five decades. From journeying into space to diving the depths of the ocean, from climbing Everest to sailing the world alone, sisters are doing it for themselves. Every woman who runs a company, runs a marathon or runs a family is a model for other women.And many women are doing all three! How many men could? These models of femininity are much more powerful than our genetic coding or hormonal make-up. They are visible, alive and immediate.They carry a clear message:‘If I can do it, then so can you.’ Unfortunately, many men have yet to grasp the implications of all this. Democratic love cannot work for those men who have an understanding of women that is rooted in the Victorian, or Elizabethan, age. If we can put aside simplistic ideas about biology being destiny, then we can better come to terms with the enormous changes afoot in this new millennium.These changes 18
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 19
Introduction will be challenging, not least because they offer us much less certainty about our roles,while requiring us to be more willing to discard out-dated stereotypes. Remember, we hang on to stereotypes because they are simplistic and therefore comforting, not because they are insightful.Yet the rewards will be enormous if men, as well as women, can move forward in their thinking and become more enlightened about their gender identity. What we have here is a real opportunity for what I term democratic love, with both partners sharing every aspect of their union, openly, frankly and sensitively, but importantly, retaining their unique individuality. Many couples are already doing this, and very successfully, though I recognise that they may well yet be a minority. As Hazel, a 42-year-old divorced single parent and occupational therapist, wryly notes: Like most women I’m looking for someone I can be equal with and ditto.That’s the difficult bit. But despite it being a challenge, women like Hazel will not, indeed cannot, settle for anything less than democratic love.Their self-dignity and intelligence won’t allow it. For they understand what being equal in a relationship really entails. It means both parties being at the core of the relationship, neither one occupying central place to the exclusion of the other.It means both parties being skilled at emotional literacy, able to feel and express their emotions, fears and desires in a sensitive, but structured manner. It means thinking before acting, learning from past mistakes, listening as well as talking, and not assuming that the other person is always wrong – or right.But perhaps most importantly, democratic love means respecting our partner’s right 19
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 20
Men,Women, Love and Romance to have their own special life journey, one not determined or inevitably centred around us.
Summary The dawning of the twenty-first century has seen a new gender game emerge, and women are leading it.They are asking more of themselves and of their relationships.They are more likely to subject their relationships to scrutiny than their mothers or grandmothers.They are less tolerant of second-best relationships, and of abusive and emotionally damaging relationships. In this bedroom revolution, women are increasingly aware of the opportunities to experiment and construct new sexual contracts. They are more demanding both of themselves and their partners, not least because life is now seen as a very special journey and only likely to come around once. For both women and men, serial sexual relationships are no longer taboo but seen as part and parcel of one’s individual life journey.We are living healthier and for longer, our sex lives no longer automatically going into limbo once we reach a certain age. And if our libido does flag then we haveViagra,that blue pill of pleasure,to get us back up again. Yet both women and men still yearn for true love, relationships which are pure and lasting.And central to love is romance, that feeling of being special and unique to another person. Despite the transformations wrought by the bedroom revolution, romance remains the oxygen of love. But traditional romance works best with traditional gender roles, and they’re disappearing fast. So where does that leave us? It leaves us with many choices but fewer 20
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 21
Introduction rules. It leaves us playing a gender game no longer controlled by men. It means men having to change and adapt – or retreat. For those couples that play this game well, the reward will be democratic love, with no one party playing second fiddle to the other, and with a solid relationship from which to weather the storms of change. For those men who don’t understand this new game – or choose to ignore it – they’ll quickly get sidelined, picked up, put down, discarded by increasingly choosy women. Or, if they are really lucky, a woman will come along who feels sorry for them and decides to take them on, regardless of the baggage they are carrying. A woman, maybe, like TV personality, Melinda Messenger: I have no problem with British men. There is something endearing about desperation and hopelessness.
7 love questions To find out if you are a Democratic Lover, enlightened and adventurous and part of the new gender game, here are seven questions to ask yourself (and your loved one): 1. Do I see myself as central to the relationship or do I put my partner’s needs first? 2. When we have a disagreement, can my lover and I reach an amicable conclusion or does one of us always feel silenced by the other? 3. Have I retained my individuality in the relationship, or have I lost it? 4. Would my lover support me if I wanted to go off in a 21
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 22
Men,Women, Love and Romance completely different direction with my life? Would I support my lover if their life journey took them on a new, unfamiliar, route? 5. Do I constantly judge my lover? 6. Have my lover and I come to a joint, negotiated decision about how we share work roles around housework, childcare, and bringing income into the household? 7. Is my lover my best friend? How did you score? 1. To be a democratic lover you should not see yourself central to the relationship, but then, neither should you put your partner’s needs first, at least not all the time. There are three parties to every relationship – you, your partner and the relationship itself. Remember, the relationship exists only because, and so long as, the two of you are lovers.Therefore it is unique in its own right, with an energy and character all of its own. 2. Democracy thrives on discussion, not on silence, so don’t be afraid of disagreements with your lover. However, disagreements must be settled and if either partner feels silenced by the other then democratic love is not happening. 3. Lovers can suffer the experience of being emotionally crushed and stifled in relationships, especially if one partner is oppressive of the other. When this happens we lose a sense of our individuality. Retaining individuality is the key to democratic love for it is through this that we flourish and mature, and therefore our capacity to love and be loved flourishes too. 4. This is a key question for all lovers in the new millen22
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 23
Introduction nium, especially women. The life choices open to women are increasing and many are pursuing them in ways that men always have done.This can put a strain on relationships which appear democratic on the surface, but in reality are still rooted in traditional notions around gender roles. Sometimes, it might be necessary for the relationship to die in order for the individual to pursue their life journey. But such a break up can often be avoided if both parties are truly honest with each other about their feelings and expectations. After all, life journeys are better shared. If you feel your lover would not support you if your life journey took you to new horizons, then that suggests there may be a democratic deficit in your relationship. 5. It is very easy to fall into the habit of judging others. Indeed, it’s something most of us do at some time, in one form or another. However, to constantly subject your lover to judgements about their behaviour and actions is to claim superiority over them. It is to suggest that your moral or intellectual position is above theirs, and that cannot be a good basis for a democratic relationship. Rather than judge, try to understand why they acted in the way they did.Talk, listen, reflect.This way you’ll learn more about them – and yourself. 6. Twenty-first century lives are busy lives, especially for couples juggling domestic, work and childcare responsibilities. If one partner is doing most of the juggling then that is not democratic love.The issue of roles and responsibilities in a relationship should be agreed on at the outset. But remember, such duties should always be open to democratic renegotiation. 7. Friendships tend to last longer than relationships, not 23
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 24
Men,Women, Love and Romance least because they are less effort and more likely to be democratic. The emotional and physical commitment in a friendship is usually much less than in a relationship. But democratic love does need a basis of friendship to really flourish, for friendship can see you through the tricky times and those periods when companionship is more important than, for example, sexual relations.We should see our lovers as our best friends, not just as sexual objects or means to security and a comfortable lifestyle.
24
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 25
chapte r 1
Men at the Millennium
While I was doing the research for this book, interviewing women of all ages and backgrounds, one theme recurred in virtually every interview. It was about men’s maturity or, more precisely, their lack of it. I lost count of the number of women who complained that ‘men never grow up, they stay little boys all their lives’. One woman said to me:‘I like to have a man around now and again but not permanently. I’ve already got children.’ It was as if these women were despairing of finding emotionally sorted men who didn’t retreat into denial when faced with difficulties in a relationship, men who could contribute to the emotional and physical labour of a relationship. Not surprisingly, as a man, there were times when I found these comments hard to take. Nevertheless, when I looked around me and reflected on how I’d sometimes been in relationships, when I went back to the research I’d done on men and masculinities and when I heard the stories of these women, then I knew they were only too right in what they said. In general terms, these women were being cuttingly accurate in their appraisal of the state of many men. Recognising this, I accept that some women reading this book will think to themselves: ‘Where are the men worth getting on the romantic roller-coaster with?’ 25
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 26
Men,Women, Love and Romance However, although this is a pertinent question, I also know that not all men are emotionally stunted and locked in patterns of denial. I know that men can change for the better. I know of many couples in long-term relationships who are not only clearly in love, but have the maturity, experience and capacity, as a couple, to live their lives in democratic love and friendship, and are doing so. Most men are in their late thirties before they really grow up. Many others stay teenagers all their lives. Yet despite the profound consequences of the bedroom revolution for many men, women are not engaged in a battle with them. Most heterosexual women see men as central to their lives – although not necessarily essential. They know only too well that men have the capacity to bring them either joy or anguish, pleasure or pain. Most heterosexual women yearn for a loving relationship with one man, a democratic love that will survive whatever problems they may face as a couple;a lifetime love,bringing with it fulfilment and contentment. But it is not easy. Despite not wanting conflict, relationships too often come to resemble a battlefield, with man on one side and woman on the other. Democratic love won’t necessarily remove conflict. What it will do is allow relationships to develop based on equality not inequality, thus removing one of the fundamental flaws in the old gender game. However, for this to happen men have to change for democracy only works if all parties sign up to it.So although women may be leading the bedroom revolution, men are central to its very success.Yet how many men are aware of what their partner now expects from a relationship? How many are prepared 26
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 27
Men at the Millennium for the give and take of democratic love? In order to answer these questions we need to look at men, and their masculinities, more closely.We need to ask:‘what is a man?’ There is a popular assumption that men and women are fundamentally different, even to the extent that they talk a different language. But is this really so, or is it that many men don’t want to hear what women have to say? Are men really from a ‘different planet’ to women? Of course they’re not, it’s just that each of us experiences Earth a little differently. We are all unique, and it is that uniqueness which makes us special. After all, is it not that special something that we fall in love with? Romance thrives on difference for in our love we see someone who is beyond compare. But that is not to say that many men do not exhibit similar patterns of behaviour.If we look closely,but put away stereotypes, we can see some of the primary ways in which men relate to the world – and to love and romance. In explaining why traditional ways of being a man are so incompatible with democratic love, this chapter will explore the different ways men do relationships and romance. Perhaps you will recognise yourself, or your partner, here.
What are traditional and twenty-first century masculinities? One of the most powerful gender myths is the idea of a single, unchanging femininity or masculinity. Research by sociologists and psychologists reveals how our identity is fluid and changing, not fixed from birth. Once we 27
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 28
Men,Women, Love and Romance recognise this then we can no longer talk of masculinity as being the same thing for all men. Masculinity is multiple and contrasting.And while masculinity is the name we give to men’s behaviour it is not rooted in biology but in culture and social experience. We are the sum of our life experiences, not the sum of our DNA. Men are not genetically programmed to wear suits and ties any more than women are genetically programmed to wear high-heeled shoes. Men are not genetically programmed to hate ironing, any more than women are genetically programmed to enjoy it. Men are not genetically programmed to be unfaithful. Women are not genetically programmed to love, honour and obey. Men are not genetically programmed to rape. Women are not genetically programmed to submit.To believe otherwise is to be trapped in dated ways of thinking.We have to move on from believing our identities are simply products of our genes. Importantly, we have to take responsibility for the way we are in relationships. It is precisely because masculinity is not rooted in nature that makes it so interesting – and potentially dangerous. So the good news is that our gender is not our destiny.Who we are at 20 is not who we will be at 40.At no stage are our life patterns predictable or set in stone.We change, and our sense of gender and sexuality also changes. But there is a danger to masculinity, and that is the assumption of superiority which has historically come with it. 28
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 29
Men at the Millennium To be a man, especially in traditional societies, is to be considered superior to women. Being male in most countries continues to carry a life advantage in terms of wealth, educational opportunity, career advancement, lifetime earnings and, as a consequence, a sense of power and potency. Of course, not all men benefit in quite the same way, but all men do benefit from their association with the category man/male. So we can understand why men want to appear masculine – there is an advantage to them in doing so.And because our identities are not assumed in nature we have to develop them in our social and cultural settings.This alerts us to the added benefit to appearing masculine for men – it gives them a sense of identity as members of the male species. It enables them to join an enormous club, entry into which is beholden on, first, having a penis, and, second, demonstrating appropriate masculine behaviour. Males are not born men, they have to learn what it means to be a man in the culture they are born into. A key aspect of traditional masculinity concerns control. For centuries men have been expected to master their environments. Consequently, many men will confront when that control is threatened, and resist attempts to explore any self-weakness.This desire to control seeps into every aspect of men’s lives, both at work and home, but it is particularly insidious when applied to relationships. For control implies power over others – and self. Men’s ability to control situations, events, circumstances, people, self, environment, remains central to traditional notions of 29
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 30
Men,Women, Love and Romance masculinity. Men are supposed to be rational, reasoned, unemotional,distant.This idea has a long history,but is particularly apparent in the notion of man as architect and overseer of his environment, whether at work or home. Certainly, for most men the ability to control everyday situations is very limited, but nevertheless, few men will admit to not being in control, to not being masters of their particular world.This appears to them as weakness. It does not indicate masculine power. And if masculinity is about anything, it is about power over one’s environment, one’s self and others. Not surprisingly, as will be discussed below, traditional notions of masculinity do not sit easy with notions of romantic intimacy. Another important element of traditional masculinity concerns man as provider. Despite the fact that the male breadwinner family is becoming extinct in the West, many people, women and men, still buy into the idea that men are genetically programmed to be the hunter, the provider, the protector of family. Indeed, it is the very absence of opportunities for most men to be sole breadwinners in the twenty-first century that leads some to conclude that this is one of the main reasons for a crisis in masculinity.This idea would hold up if there was not the overwhelming evidence to show that men can very easily live in dual earner families or indeed in families where the woman is the main or only breadwinner.Men do not suddenly become depressed if they are not the major breadwinner. Some men might, but that is not because the condition flies in the face of their biology,it is because they have failed to move on as individuals.They have failed to change as the world around them has changed. One thing we do know from biology is that failure to adapt to one’s environment is a deadly mistake for any species. 30
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 31
Men at the Millennium Men who cannot play the new gender game, who cannot adapt to democratic love, are in danger of becoming evolutionary jetsam – the dodos of the new millennium. However, it would be altogether too simplistic to suggest that traditional masculinity is always a bad thing, or is, indeed, rejected by women. Far from it.We can see traditional masculinity alive and well in the character of James Bond, whether played by Sean Connery, Roger Moore or Pierce Brosnan. Even in his late sixties, Connery projects an image of the unbending, strong, virile yet sensual man. He appears as a man in control of self, confident, sophisticated, at ease in any social or physical situation. The masculine imagery which Bond/Connery emits is highly traditional yet packaged in a very modern way. And many women find it sexually attractive, not least because it appears both compelling and dangerous, and, as singer Alanis Morissette admits: Women, occasionally, despite themselves, are drawn to the frisson of dangerous men. We can see a similar, younger, version of Bond’s traditional masculinity in the actor Tom Cruise, with his masculine image perhaps best personified in the Mission Impossible films.Always in control, always one step ahead, very physical, Cruise’s character in Mission Impossible works hard to embody a potent, heterosexual masculinity. It is not surprising that Cruise takes great exception to any allusion to gayness in his character. More radical examples of traditional masculinity are apparent in hardcore rappers such as 31
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 32
Men,Women, Love and Romance Ice Cube,actors such asVinnie Jones and footballers such as Roy Keane. For such men in real life, their embodiment as males is central to who they are as individuals.They present themselves as tough, strong, highly competitive, even aggressive. Their relationships with women may well be informed by a simplistic Madonna–Whore syndrome where women are positioned in stereotypical good and bad roles. Despite its appeal to many men, this form of masculinity remains, foremost, an uncompromising, rigidly limited way of being a man. Traditional masculinity should not be seen as the only masculinity available to men, nor as the only way in which men are likely to behave. An individual’s behaviour is a complex mix of patterns. But, for many men, traditional masculine ideas remain highly compulsive. Most men have some masculine model in their heads.They may not follow it obsessively, but they do carry it around with them as a marker, a sort of code by which they understand what a ‘proper man’ is and does. Apart from being a model, this masculine marker can also be heavy baggage, with many men constantly anxious about whether or not they actually measure up to what they perceive to be some ideal form of masculinity,whether typified by a muscular body,success in business, success with women or just a fast, flashy car. However, one of the benefits of the bedroom revolution is that it has made it okay for men not to act out laddish behaviour, even though it still remains fashionable, if not compulsory, for many men to behave like this when in allmale groups. Consequently, while traditional masculinity is probably still the dominant masculine model in most societies, we are seeing shifts away from this,especially in the West.There 32
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 33
Men at the Millennium are signs of change in men; the messages from women are getting through to them. More men do not put their own sexual pleasure before that of their partner. More men are househusbands, more men are involved in childcare, more men recognise that they are equal to women, not better, not worse, just equal. It is the rare man who considers it somehow reflects badly on him if his wife works, or if she earns more than him – as many do. The old-fashioned patriarchal male, the man who considers himself head of the household, rooster in his farmyard, is fast becoming an anachronism – the exception rather than the rule. As new research into men and masculinity, undertaken by the communications agency, Publicis, shows: Increasing numbers of younger men, especially, appear very comfortable with their masculinity and their place in the world.They are happy to be on an equal footing with women. What we are seeing here are the first signs of a new form of masculinity emerging in men – twenty-first century masculinity. It is a way of being a male that does not fear women, does not fear the sexuality of gays or lesbians, does not fear its own emotional depths.It is a state of being that is comfortable with women and their achievements, both in and out of the home. Men who exhibit such attitudes and behaviours do not need women as an adornment, as a jewel to reflect on them.They do not need women in order to protect them, or to adopt a paternalistic attitude towards them.Women are partners, not chattels. It is a masculinity which can still be highly sexual, but not aggressively so. Twenty-first century masculinity continues to signal a 33
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 34
Men,Women, Love and Romance strong physical presence, but it is a masculinity which also has a soft side,sometimes mistakenly interpreted as passivity. An example would be David Beckham, quite an aggressive character on the football field, but also sufficiently comfortable with his sexuality to wear feminine-type clothes and be seen as an active, caring father. Men who display modern twenty-first century masculinity have dismissed the outdated thinking around men which suggested that to be a man you have to be in control of your emotions at all times, you have to be ‘buttoned down’, always strong. Importantly, twenty-first century masculinity is comfortable with intimacy and the display of emotion as love.
Why men are afraid of intimacy If romance is the oxygen of love, then the essence of romance is intimacy, for the romantic moment is first and foremost an intimate engagement. However, true romantic intimacy is not the arid, desperate, functional type so vividly captured in the film Intimacy. It is immersion in another person, often without condition or constraint. True romantic intimacy requires that both parties put aside their preoccupation with self and turn to the other for love, acceptance and approval. And this is one reason why romance is such a turn-on for most women. For romance flies in the face of traditional notions of masculinity. It is about letting go, being in the moment with another person, loving and giving without condition, without fear. In the true romantic moment, women and men are necessarily equals, neither one wishing to overpower or dominate the other. 34
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 35
Men at the Millennium Certainly, traditional notions of romance are, for men, still imbued with dominant ideas of manliness. For example, the notion of a virile man ‘sweeping a woman off her feet’, or the woman in need of a strong man’s protection in the threatening world, the woman waiting for the ‘right man’ to come along as a knight in shining armour.These gendered notions assume a paternalistic approach to women. But the very act of being emotional and intimate, exhibiting feelings for another, acts which are absolutely essential to romantic love, preclude the dominant masculine preoccupation with self, competition, and denial of emotion. Romance is not to be undertaken as an instrumental act. One reason why those men who have placed a lock on their emotions and feelings are not good at romance is that such men have assumed that they always have to be rational, reasoned, and cold and calculating if necessary, that is if they are to exhibit dominant masculine traits.They can do romance, but only if they try really hard. But because it is often undertaken as a conscious effort they inevitably tend to forget the rules, and slip back into ‘traditional mode’. At that point their partners wonder what is going on, and start prompting them to ‘be romantic’ again. But it is often too late by then.The moment is lost. We can only be truly intimate with another when we put aside our preoccupation with self. What is happening in this situation is that such men are afraid of intimacy. They are unsettled by the exposure and threat that comes with allowing oneself to grant control to another. That is the risk of romance, but it is also the frisson which gives romance and love its unforgettable taste.Unfortunately, 35
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 36
Men,Women, Love and Romance from an early age,most males are told not to expose need and weakness, not to cry, not to ‘be soft’.As young men they are told it is okay to desire members of the opposite sex, desire, that is, as sexual conquest. But such desire is not the same thing as letting go, unlocking one’s inner emotions, giving and loving.So we can see that men can have sexual desire and need without ever slipping the anchor of traditional masculinity.As will be discussed below, many men can appear to be romantic, but in fact what they are doing is playing a role, often in a very instrumental fashion. It is no surprise that often the men most attractive to women are those who can also display an easy femininity, while retaining an air of masculine sexual presence.We can see this masculine–feminine ambivalence in past romantic icons such Don Juan, Casanova, Rudolph Valentino and Rock Hudson.In today’s world,it is equally apparent in ‘boy bands’ and teenage pop idols such as Will Young. Whether they are gay (as with Will Young and Rock Hudson) or straight, such men encapsulate a blurring of the gender divide.This is particularly attractive to many women, for it appears safer, less threatening than overt, unmitigated macho behaviour.Those men who have strings of lovers are often anything but traditionally masculine in either appearance or manner.They have something else, an elusive quality which transcends dominant, hard, masculinity, without losing its sexual signals. The ‘Casanovas’ of this world do not hate women, but desire them in a way that transcends sexuality. Many men have never really understood that to love women you have to like them.And to like them you have to be comfortable with femininity, and not see it as something strange, mysterious and to be avoided.As Vicki Woods of the Evening Standard puts it: 36
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 37
Men at the Millennium Men, [like Sam Mendes] who actually like women, who nurture them and cherish them and make them believe they are the only person in the room, are devastating, heart-stopping and almost mandatory. Women can’t resist them. When we are in love we experience an exhilaratingly vivid period in our lives.Yet it can also be a time of deep insecurity and uncertainty. For some, it can be a time of painful, unresolved passion. And yet this is the only way to experience romantic love; not attempting to avoid its consequences but to be engrossed in it fully and without hesitation. For it is precisely this uncertainty, mixed with aching desire and need, which renders it such a compelling, unique experience. If we try to deny the consequences of love, or control the situation, as so many men do, then we inevitably damage both the relationship and limit our capacity for emotional feeling. It is much better just to allow oneself to drift in love. Accept its pleasures, and its pains.To do otherwise is to place a lock on our emotions, and thus on our capacity to love freely and fully. There has to be a letting go in love; being in the moment, being thoughtful but playful, considerate towards the other, but always with an undercurrent of sexuality. It is a unique experience in the human condition, which is one reason why it is so compelling and why we miss it when it is gone.
Why men confront and deny We should not assume from men’s fear of intimacy that they cannot love.They love very deeply.They can love with 37
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 38
Men,Women, Love and Romance a passion and intensity every bit as strong as a woman’s. Men are not incapable of love, of emotional intimacy or of letting go. It is just that many find it hard, and when it does surface they can become embarrassed by it, so to avoid this they often try to suppress it or manage it at a distance. Exhibiting emotion, at least the sort of emotion that comes with intimate relationships, goes against many men’s sense of masculine identity, their learnt manliness. From an early age, men see around them vivid and powerful images of maleness. From distant, work-focused fathers to powerful, irresistible images of Superman and similar media/comic heroes. Even now, in this more enlightened age, countless numbers of boys grow up failing to recognise that gender barriers are coming down. Just ask an eight year old what he wants to be when he grows up. The answer is more likely to be a footballer, fireman, policeman, soldier, than it is to be a nurse, care assistant, beauty therapist, teacher or dancer.The fact is that today’s boys, when adults, are very likely to be working in the education or care professions, for they are the growth industries of the new century. So males are often caught in this trap of needing and desiring to love, but also wishing to deny need for another, caught as many are in this state of mind which strongly suggests to them what men can do, what men are, and what men should expect of themselves. Probably more than any other setting,it is sport that provides the major social arena for men in denial. Sure, the 2002 World Cup was wonderful, exciting and compulsive viewing, but, as the Observer columnist, Barbara Ellen, writes, sport is increasingly becoming a comfort blanket for men and their maleness, a place where ‘lost boys’ can, temporarily, shut out the modern world – and modern woman: 38
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 39
Men at the Millennium For certain kinds of heterosexual men sport remains their single most effective and enduring ‘happy pill’, the only one they’ll ever need … But doesn’t this say something sour and desperate about modern life, and modern man? This conflict within men between wanting to appear heavily masculine and wanting to experience feminine intimacy, can make them very insecure around strongminded, intelligent women. Many men, despite giving out all the signs of being strong and secure, can quickly sexually droop – and get very defensive as a result – when faced with a stronger-minded female.Their traditional masculine posturing is revealed as shallow and inadequate when faced with a woman who is, mentally, always several steps ahead of them. As one of my interviewees, Jane, (a post-doctoral researcher), put it: Many times I’ve found I’ve had to switch my brain off so the bloke can get an erection. What we have here is the inherent flaw in gender. On one hand, we assume it to be a basic piece of who we are, yet on the other, just how we perform and present our gendered selves depends on the social and cultural world in which we are located, and that is a constantly moving entity. Once we recognise this paradox, then we hold the key to why men confront and deny. Research by psychoanalysts has shown that virtually all confrontation and denial stems from a sense of defencelessness, exposure and uncertainty.When faced with your own inadequacies it is often easiest just to deny or confront. Anyone who has experienced intimate sexual relationships 39
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 40
Men,Women, Love and Romance will recognise the pattern. The hurtful things are usually those that are closest to the truth, most telling of who we are. But they can also be the aspects of ourselves we would prefer not to have exposed to light, which tells us that the most critical gaze is invariably our own, not others. It is a rare person who says, when confronted with their own failings, ‘thank you, I needed to know that’. Instead, we deny, get angry and seek to return the favour by pointing out to the other person just what their weaknesses are. Such battles and confrontations are, alas, the stuff of relationships. Surely it is not possible to be in a relationship without, at some stage, experiencing this. For many, this stage can last for years,for others,it may never finish.Yet the hurtful things can, sometimes, be just what we need to reflect, to move on, to positively change. However, for men raised to believe in their ability to master and control, with honed skills of self-management and presentation – men with locked emotions – this moment of being faced with critical questions is highly dangerous and most threatening. For, unlike traditional notions of femininity, traditional ideas of masculinity do not suggest reflection, exposure of self and feelings. So it is easier for such men to attack, rather than face the questions and associated self-analysis; endure long, drawn-out silences rather than talk openly with their loved one of their fears and anxieties. Certainly, many men do face profound questions of self, they go down this path of self-discovery, perhaps motivated by some unresolved inner crisis. There are countless numbers of men in self-help groups, going through precisely this type of exploration, and doing it well, though not necessarily without some pain. But such explorations 40
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 41
Men at the Millennium work precisely because they are anonymous. They are undertaken with others who have also reached this juncture in their life. Or they are done on a one to one with an ‘anonymous other’, such as a counsellor. In these situations all are deemed equal in their inadequacies. No one is more privileged than another.There is safety in this anonymous meeting place of other ‘damaged selves’ or with the ‘professional’ who listens but does not judge. But this is not the case in close, intimate, sexual relationships – just the opposite. For in this meeting place of two lovers there is a long history, one of love, romance, intimacy, deep emotion, but also of expectations not met, of aspirations unresolved and perhaps of broken trust. Such a meeting place of minds is anything but anonymous. For those who know us most intimately are also those who know our weaknesses, our Achilles’ heel. They invariably know us better than we know ourselves for they have studied us at close hand, in countless situations, in our highs and lows.Through their love for us, so have they come to understand us, to see us. They are our other half, our alter ego. As they move on as individuals, increasing numbers of women are moving out. Women who do fall in love with traditionally masculine men should be aware that that which attracts them – apparent inner strength, resolve, determination, instrumentality, control, rationality, management of self – are precisely the characteristics most likely to damage the relationship. Such ways do not sit easily with the emotional roller-coaster that inevitably accompanies love, romance and sexual intimacy. That is why women in such relationships usually end up 41
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 42
Men,Women, Love and Romance doing the emotional labour of the relationship – dealing with their own emotions and feelings, while also ‘protecting’ their partner from his; opting for a quiet life and long silences, rather than the emotion of change. But, as I discuss in the next chapter, in the bedroom revolution increasing numbers of women are forsaking such situations and seeking romance elsewhere. When lovers fight they break the greatest taboo of romance, they break the illusion of perfection. The moments of love are, then, the moments when we are most vulnerable, dangerously exposed.We may not feel it at the time, but in the state of romantic love our lives are being lived out in a slightly unreal world, one where daily activities and concerns are of no account to us as we float several feet off the ground, seeing the world around us in rich colour and fascinating, if surreal, detail. So anything that punctures or intrudes on this state of mind is particularly threatening, especially if it comes from the very focus of our love – our lover. In the moment of confrontation between lovers they let in the ‘real world’. Instead of being preoccupied with each other, immersed in intimacy, they are forced to face the reality of the self and the fact that perfection is unattainable, merely a temporary illusion we must learn to recognise and walk away from. Yet it is precisely in that moment of putting down the expectation of perfection that the possibilities of real romance open up. Such a romance is not based on fantasy, but deep and lasting desire for what is accepted as an imperfect other. 42
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 43
Men at the Millennium
How men do sex, love and romance What follows are descriptions of some of the key ways in which men may approach sex, love and romance. In presenting such a list, I am not suggesting that it is exhaustive of men’s possibilities for intimacy, love and emotion. Far from it. A list that encompassed all men’s emotional– romantic possibilities would be impossible to write.Also, I am not suggesting that men are naturally predisposed to engage in one or another type of approach to romance. Individual men may engage in several of these approaches to romance during the course of their lives – though hopefully coming to see that democratic love is the only way forward for them. What I am saying is that these are the four main ways in which men approach or relate to romance, and that they are closely connected to types of masculinity now apparent at the beginning of the twentyfirst century. Finally, although I am writing this from a heterosexual man’s perspective, I am yet to be convinced that the ways of being romantic detailed below are any less relevant for gay men’s relationships. 1. the traditionalist
All this women’s lib stuff just denies women’s nature. If God hadn’t wanted women to be homekeepers and men to be providers he wouldn’t have made them different. These are biological facts. (Bernard)
The traditionalist can be a man of any age. He could be the laddish young man, wearing the latest designer gear. He could be the middle-aged leathered biker on his ‘mean machine’. He could be the suited businessman. In other 43
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 44
Men,Women, Love and Romance words, it is not necessary to be a member of the older generation to be a male traditionalist. They come in all ages, sizes, classes and ethnic groups. However, unlike the chameleon-like instrumentalist (below), the traditionalist is easier to spot. Most experienced women would only require one brief meeting, or, perhaps, a relaxed evening meal, with the traditionalist to recognise his attitudes towards women. For he sees nothing wrong with his opinions and sees them as the norm, which is why he usually doesn’t attempt to hide them, or not very well. Indeed, he may well wear his views on his sleeve, as a symbol of his ‘independent mind’.The traditionalist takes pride in being just that, conservative, unchanging and masculine in the most obvious, but increasingly dated, way. Having been exposed to his ideas about gender, the woman is able to proceed or not, knowing what she is getting involved with. In short, there are few illusions about the traditionalist. Which is one of their good points: what you see is what you get. Aged 55, Bernard runs his own business, a typical selfmade man. He has been married for thirty years and claims to have always been faithful to his wife. He sees romance as being important for his wife, but less so for him: I have had to work hard all my life. Nothing came easy. I left school at 16 and got married four years later. Jane and I have worked together to build up this business. What can I tell you about romance? I guess I am romantic. I always remember her birthday and our wedding anniversary. Last year we went to Venice for a week. It’s easier now the kids have left home. Jane doesn’t complain. She knows that we have to put the business first. She has
44
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 45
Men at the Millennium money in her pocket, which she didn’t have when we started out. The days of passion between us have gone, sure, but what we have now is very comfortable. I expect Jane to look after herself, to stay attractive. She does aerobics. We go to a lot of business functions so she gets to show off a bit, her jewellery, that sort of stuff. I do look at other women, all men do, but there is too much at stake. Thirty years is a long time. Men want someone at home, someone who will support them. Romance doesn’t pay the bills.
Many women find the blunt honesty of the male traditionalist quite attractive.When it is mixed with some physical prowess, perhaps a macho attitude, it can appear quite virile, compelling and sexy. Traditionalists are often attracted to the type of women who might be seen as a trophy wife.That is, someone who can assume their place in his strictly gendered world without upsetting his mates – ideally, making his mates somewhat envious of him. However, the traditionalist does not really understand women, he tends to see them as different beings, elusive, mysterious, exotic, talking a different language. He puts them on pedestals, or sees them as underlings – secretaries, cleaners and tarts. Most of his perceptions of women are framed in this simplistic world where women come in two categories – Madonna or Whore. He will invariably seek to marry a woman whom he has first put on a pedestal. Some traditionalists keep their woman there, untouchable, pure, unsullied. Other traditionalists find a masochistic pleasure in exposing what they come to see as the subsequent ‘feet of clay’ of their woman. In other words, they work to demolish whatever pedestal they have constructed for their 45
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 46
Men,Women, Love and Romance woman, being hurt in the process by what they may perceive to be her ‘failings’. Either way, pedestal or not, the real person behind the woman often remains hidden for the traditionalist. He can live his whole life with a woman without ever truly knowing her. In romantic terms, traditional man can fulfil many women’s expectations. He will want to pay for those romantic weekends and meals (which many women may welcome!), and he will remember the flowers and cards (usually).The more well-heeled traditionalist will make it a point of honour to spend lots of money on his romantic attachments. After all, it reflects well on him, the potent, successful male. However, the traditionalist is unlikely to be very imaginative about romance, seeing it as the province of the female, and, thus, outside his ‘natural remit’ as a man. Underneath the traditionalist’s romantic display and macho bravado is a man who is both afraid of romance and the intimacy that comes with it. He is unlikely to be a man in touch with his feelings so don’t expect him to write long, emotional, love letters. His initial exuberance and enthusiasm is likely to slip once the relationship becomes established. In short, romance does not come ‘naturally’ to the traditionalist, he will have to work at it. However,over time,many can be trained to be thoughtful and considerate. A mix of reward and punishment usually works well. But, then, most women know this already, for they have had long experience managing traditionally minded men.They understand that while he sees himself as strong and unbending, which he is on the surface, underneath he is pliable, vulnerable, unsure, even innocent. A further difficulty is that the emotional labour under46
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 47
Men at the Millennium taken by women who have traditional men as lovers inevitably intrudes on the bedroom.You cannot compartmentalise it. What often happens is that the woman ends up having to massage and protect the deep insecurities at the heart of the traditional male. For example, she must never imply poor sexual performance on his part. She must be careful how she makes him consider and recognise her physical needs. She must try to educate him about her body without it appearing to suggest a lack of skill. Few of these men appreciate that sexual technique is not something we are born with, we have to learn it.And, like all other skills, the more we practise, the better we get. Also, there will be times when we are not so skilled, when our technique fails us. We may be tired, emotionally upset, physically exhausted.What is more, both women and men have sexual cycles, times of the month or year when they are more sexually aroused than others. But perhaps the most important aspect of good sex is the ability to be able to communicate and respond to each other’s needs, to listen and learn, and to accept that each of our partners is different. All this needs explaining to the traditional male. He has to learn to stop seeing his sexuality as an arena of performance, a place where he must measure up every time he makes love. He must also learn that sexual experimentation, especially with a loving partner, is absolutely essential if one is to sustain a long-term relationship. In short, sex is just like intimacy, love, and romance – it works best with the traditional man when he has a patient, considerate partner. Someone who recognises his inner weaknesses and vulnerabilities and helps him move on from this state to achieve some deep and lasting confidence, 47
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 48
Men,Women, Love and Romance but without him becoming aware that this is what is happening. So as long as the woman is prepared to put in this effort and engage in the romantic moments as a traditional female stereotype, then few problems will arise with the male traditionalist. Indeed, when both parties are traditionalist, then it makes for a much easier relationship all round. However in the new gender game, more and more new women are finding that they are uncomfortable with traditional gender roles; traditional roles and democratic love don’t mix. In which case, it is likely that traditional men will increasingly be sleeping alone.
2 . the confused male Just what do women want from men these days? It seems as if nothing we do is right. All the rules have changed.Women have it all now. It’s a difficult time to be a man, not knowing whether to be courteous and risk being considered old-fashioned, or to treat women like men. (Trevor) When I was a teenager you knew what women wanted, what they expected from a man. I got married with those expectations quite clear in my mind. Now I am not so sure any more.You’re expected to be a modern man, a new man, but it just feels like pressure to change. It can feel very stressful at times. (Jack) I don’t think women are happy today.They seem the ones who are confused. On one hand they want a steady relationship, yet on the other they appear to want the sexual freedom that men have always enjoyed.Where this leaves men I just don’t know. (Peter)
48
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 49
Men at the Millennium Most of us, men and women, prefer stability in our lives, not constant change. In this respect one can have a lot of sympathy with those men who are finding difficulty in adjusting to women’s changing expectations and modern notions of masculinity. The bedroom revolution has not gone unnoticed by men, and many are trying to change and adjust.The problem is that there are no clear signposts for them, no clear open avenues to follow. Each man has to find his own way through what seems like a gender maze, sometimes with a partner to aid him, often without. As anyone who has been in a maze will know, there invariably comes a moment of total disorientation, quickly followed by panic – a moment when what you thought was a wellplanned approach turns out to be a dead end.You have to start again, but this time fearful of slipping into total confusion, lost forever.Trapped in this state in the gender maze, you strongly sense that the world is moving on and you are slowly being left behind. Part of you desperately wants to move out of the shadows and into this new world, but part of you tries to hold on to those traditional values and ideas you grew up with.Which way to go? Which path to take? When you think you have the answer it turns out to be going nowhere,so which way now? That is what it is like to be a confused male in the twenty-first century.You know there is a way out of this maze, but progress seems ever so slow. The confused male may be from any background. So while we cannot always visibly identify such men, they are marked by deep insecurities, lack of confidence in their emotional resources, and with an unnerving ability to misread emotional signals, especially those from their partners. However, they are invariably intelligent men, 49
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 50
Men,Women, Love and Romance thoughtful and sensitive.They recognise that women have changed and that it is now their turn.They are just not sure how to go about it. They need guidance. Of course, few would ever admit this – that would be altogether too threatening. But these men are brave in a way, for they are trying to understand about democratic love, how to play this new gender game, but without the help of other men. They are very alone.There are few clubs for these men to join, places where they can come together with other confused males to work through their particular angst. And anyway, rather than admit to other men that they may be confused, it is much easier to opt for the weekly football match or baseball game where, for a blissful few hours, they can put all these strange transformations behind them, and join other men in a very public celebration of oldfashioned masculinity in action. Trevor is a senior manager in the NHS. He is in his late forties, and has been married for over 20 years. He is an intelligent, reflective man who yearns for romance in his life. He is just not sure how to get it: My marriage is like everyone else’s.You know, the passion goes after a while. I spend a lot of time at work, meetings and so on. There is a lot of pressure, but I enjoy it, and Margaret does her own thing. Since the kids went to university we’ve started to have the occasional separate holiday. Maybe Margaret sees someone while she’s away, I don’t know.Actually, I don’t want to know. But romance is still very important to me. I think about it, and what it would be like to be in love like that, like I was once. I miss not having it in my life. Sometimes I’ve paid for escorts, you know,for the sex,but also the companionship.I know
50
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 51
Men at the Millennium this is just functional, but there was one who I really got close to.We went out for meals,not just the sex.It felt very romantic, we talked and talked.We definitely connected. If I hadn’t been married, maybe something could have come of it. I respect women, though I don’t always understand them. Margaret and I are still okay together, but there is nothing between us,romantically.There was once, but we drifted, like most couples. Maybe one day it [romance] will come back into my life. I’m not sure how!
You might not expect a man so caught between conflicting ways of relating to women to be a good lover,to be sexually confident in bed. But this is not necessarily the case. The confused male is often less confused in bed than out of it. One of the reasons for this is because our brain is our largest sexual organ; we acquire our stimuli from the world around us – smell, vision, hearing and touch. The more sensitive we are to the world we inhabit, so the more likely that we will be sensitive to those nearest and dearest to us – our lovers. Of course there are exceptions to every rule. But when the confused male is caught up in love, then expect him to be attuned to the needs and desires of his lover. He is a man trying to gain purchase on some quite major personal and social transformations, and those moments in bed, or wherever, can be just the time when he can be simultaneously dominantly masculine while also sensitive, yielding and exposed.The mix of these two, contrasting, elements in his life can make for extreme erotic encounters. For in the union of sexual intercourse so the divides of our gender become blurred, our senses heighten beyond stereotypes of behaviour to transport us to a land of sensual pleasure and abandonment. 51
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 52
Men,Women, Love and Romance Jack is a policeman. He is in his early fifties and is contemplating retirement.He is in his second marriage and has three grown-up children. Jack has seen many changes in gender relationships over the past three decades but finds some of these shifts rather bewildering and disconcerting: When I first went into the police force, nearly 30 years ago, most of the women were working in administration, you know secretaries, back-up staff.There were few actually on the beat, or as detectives. Now we have women at the most senior levels in the force.This is a good thing. I’m all for women having a career. But there are times it seems to be going too far the other way. By that I mean we men seem to be the ones who are discriminated against. In the police we are constantly being bombarded with new equal opportunities initiatives and I have to say it does seem like political correctness gone mad. My own career has been very challenging and highly stressful,and I couldn’t have done it without having my wife at home supporting me. Now women want to be earning as much as men, and trying to bring up kids.They can’t have it all. Something has to give.
The confused male may have problems, but he is capable of deep love,particularly towards a partner who he feels understands him, and is able and willing to support him, even mother him a little.Intelligent enough to know that misogynistic attitudes are increasingly off-putting for a lot of women, but not confident enough to explore other ways of being a man, the confused male hovers in some middle space,desperately trying to learn the rules of this new gender game.This man is not a womaniser, he would be very loyal 52
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 53
Men at the Millennium and true, not least for fear of the consequences if he wasn’t. He might flirt,but it doesn’t feel right for him,he’s just practising a form of masculinity which he thinks is expected of him. What he really wants is stability, certainty, direction – and love. If none of this is forthcoming, the confused male can easily slip into victim mode, especially when a relationship breaks up. He often lacks the inner resources to move on,a factor so essential in dealing with the grief invoked by a lost relationship. Instead, he can slide into almost pathological despair, angry at women, confused by what he sees as mixed messages from them about sex and gender, and frustrated at his own inability to work his way out of the maze. Secretly, he hankers for the old gender game, when things were much simpler, clearer and less confusing. Peter is computer programmer. He is in his late thirties and is divorced. He has a ten-year-old son who he sees every other weekend, and a girlfriend. Up until my divorce I used to support women’s lib. Now I’m not so sure.The divorce was very traumatic and I felt I got the worst of the deal, what with only having limited access to my son and having to pay maintenance to my ex-wife. The courts are definitely biased against men. Now I am much more wary of getting into a serious relationship with a woman. My girlfriend and I have a good relationship, but I won’t be asking her to marry me. I don’t think I am confused as a man, but I do admit to being a little angry at women sometimes. I even feel harassed by the expectations and demands of women today.We hear so much about their needs, their problems, but not so much about how difficult it is to be a male. Look at what’s happening in the schools, with boys
53
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 54
Men,Women, Love and Romance underachieving.There has to be a reason for this. I’ve discussed this with my girlfriend, explaining to her that men today don’t have the certainties enjoyed by their fathers and grandfathers. She’s much more optimistic for the future than I am. But then she would be.
Despite the emotional difficulties that surround him, the confused male does romance very well, at least in the beginning of a relationship. He is in his element at this stage in the romantic game, for this is a time when it is okay for him to act manly, to play out some dominant masculine role. Both partners value and expect it. He can buy the meals, buy the flowers, but also allow his tenderness and sensitivity to come to the fore, both in words and deeds. He can be attentive, and at times a little macho. He is a genuinely considerate man, and that in itself is a particularly attractive quality.And these characteristics fit well into the early stages of a relationship, that time when we pay most attention to how we present ourselves, both in language and dress.We care because we are unsure of the other, of ourselves. So we work that bit harder.The rewards for this are usually great: great sex, great passion, great love, but also great illusion.As we tiptoe around the other person’s feelings, we still don’t really know them, or them us. But that is fine, for there is the unstated knowledge that we are in the early stages of the game of love, and it is going to take time. The confused male is less confused during this stage of love, for he is clear about what is expected of him romantically. And because romantic engagements and moves have traditionally relied on a strict division of gender roles, the confused male gets to be the man he thinks he is, the man he thinks his partner wants. 54
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 55
Men at the Millennium Bliss. So long as nothing changes. But it always does. And in relationships what changes most often is that which we are attracted to becomes that which we find most difficult to live with. What the confused male wants is the security and certainty of long-term love and commitment – with the woman he married. But the woman he married does not stay static for ever. She moves on, and in the past decades lots and lots of women have been striding out for themselves in terms of education, employment and sexuality. In the process, they have been leaving behind a lot of bewildered men.
3. the seductive instrumentalist Love and romance is the ‘great game’. Some get good at it, some never learn the rules. (Andrew)
There is a type of male who has obviously noticed that increasing numbers of women are ‘up for it’, but they use this knowledge to their own ends. For such men the dominant message of masculinity is ‘never let your guard down’, always keep one eye on the main chance and never emotionally expose yourself to others. Such men adopt an instrumental, often competitive, approach to relationships of all types. Rather than just enjoy the process of the relationship they are constantly looking for the payoff. It is not within the remit of this book to suggest why certain men are like this, beyond that is the powerful messages contained in dominant notions of manliness. It is worth being aware that quite often it may not so much be sex or material gain that is being pursued here, but love.The seductive instrumentalist may well want to be loved, but cannot return such love with the unmitigated 55
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 56
Men,Women, Love and Romance commitment it demands. Their instrumental engagement with love is rooted in a deep fear of intimacy.They live in a world of control, rationality, checks and balances – a place where nothing gets done without a reason. As this book reveals, a lot of men do not take such an instrumental approach to relationships. Not all men constantly police their movements, their words and their feelings. Not all men consciously embark on a strategy of pursuit when faced with the affections of another. Not all men fear or avoid emotional exposure and intimacy. However, enough do to make the seductive instrumentalist a common character in romantic relationships. One such character is Andrew, a 41-year-old solicitor. Married, with one young child, Andrew admits to having had numerous affairs, most of which have been brief and functional. His view of romance is equally succinct: The thing is,I understand women.I know that the modern woman is looking for it [sex] just as much as I am. Of course, they won’t admit it, but women are like that.They want the romantic bit, but really what they want is good sex.And I am good at sex.You can tell with women.They give off signals, it’s in their face, the way they approach you. Once I get the message then I start to pursue them. It doesn’t always work, but that’s part of it, the chase, if you like.Romance is just the name we give to the pursuit of sex. I guess it started after our daughter was born. My wife went off sex and I have always been randy. In this job you come across lots of women, but I stay off the secretaries, they talk too much.You have to learn to say ‘I love you’ as if you mean it.Women always want that. Sometimes I do mean it when I say it, but then I get bored.
56
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 57
Men at the Millennium Andrew’s instrumental approach to romance is the very antipathy of love and anything but romantic. The seductive instrumentalist presents a predatory pursuit of the other using the cover of romantic love as camouflage.The aim is to achieve yet another sexual conquest, or to have yet another person fall in love with him. He will be well versed at demonstrating romantic love – flowers, letters, weekends in Paris, remembering anniversaries, treating the other person as special and unique. He will be skilled at giving the appearance of feeling to his actions and behaviour and thus can be highly seductive, dangerously so – for the ‘victim’ of his attentions may not see the sting until it is too late. The instrumentalist is also a chameleon, in that he will blend in to whatever surroundings his love pursuit demands. For example, he could be the public school gentleman,the academic,the poet,the banker,the politician.In fact, at some point in time he is likely to be all of these, for he is especially skilled at adopting different personas – enhancing different sides of his personality in order to seduce women. His real skill, then, is in not revealing himself to anyone. The instrumentalist is likely to be comfortable with new technology. He will demonstrate some knowledge of most forms of communication, understanding only too well that the mobile phone and email are both essential tools in the armoury of the ‘cheating heart’. So, having achieved their aim of sexual conquest, just what type of sex will the seductive instrumentalist be good at? First, it is important to recognise that the process, the chase, seeing the strategy succeed is for them of equal if not more importance than sex itself.These men may be 57
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 58
Men,Women, Love and Romance somewhat addicted to sex, to chasing sex, but that does not necessarily make them good lovers. To be a good lover a man must not put his own needs first. Instead, he must appreciate how his needs are irrevocably connected to the enjoyment experienced by his lover. He must relish pleasing his lover, devoting time and attention to her physical and emotional needs and taking time to enjoy intimate moments without hindrance and without concern over his sexual performance. Only this way can good sex really be achieved.The problem is,however,that despite his apparent success with women the seductive instrumentalist has never really found himself comfortable with femininity and with the earthy sexuality that women can exude. He desires it because he sees it as a challenge, a way of feeling good about himself as a man. But when faced with it, he often crumbles, becomes unsure.That is why the seductive instrumentalist so often disappoints in bed, although you can expect him to be well versed in the techniques and mechanics of sex, for he will have had plenty of practice. So enjoy it at this level – orgasms to order, not orgasms of exultant passion. In short, the instrumentalist is first and foremost a smooth seducer. However, this in itself may not inevitably be of concern to the person they are pursuing. Indeed, that person may enjoy being pursued, while being well aware that their pursuer has other, more basic, agendas.Also, many women are well able to handle this type of man, being ‘up for it’ just as much as they are.The danger is in falling in love with such a man.To fall for such a person, a man not only with a lock on his emotions, but who seeks to engineer emotional expression for his own ends, is to risk serious hurt. 58
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 59
Men at the Millennium
4 . the democratic male I don’t see myself as a ‘new man’. I hate that label. I’m no different from many other men. Just because I clean the loos in our house I don’t consider myself a wimp.Who’s bothered, just so long as the job gets done? (James) Yes, things have changed between men and women, but they had to. I don’t see any problem with a woman earning more than me. In fact my present girlfriend earns nearly twice my salary. But what the hell, that’s progress. When I date a woman we very rarely talk about money, but we nearly always end up talking about relationships. It’s much more interesting! (Mike)
There are no ‘new men’ out there.That notion was never more than an interesting but over-simplified tabloid take on the different ways of being a man that became apparent in the 1990s. But we can identify a group of men who have either moved on from traditional masculine values, and understand the meaning of democratic love, or, being of the younger generation, have grown up naturally seeing women as equals, not as an exotically different and strange species. Quite often, such men have mothers who have pursued careers, or sisters who are every bit, if not more, qualified and successful as they are. Importantly, their partners will be comfortable with the bedroom revolution and well able and prepared to voice their needs and desires. Such men can be described as ‘democrats’ in so much as they are comfortable with what women have achieved and feel that none of this threatens their sense of masculinity. For them, this is how gender relationships are in the new millennium: women and men as partners, sexual or 59
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 60
Men,Women, Love and Romance otherwise. It is a given. Theirs is a modern, twenty-first century, masculinity. James is a 34-year-old self-employed architect. He is in a long-term relationship with a writer.They have one child from his partner’s previous relationship: There was never any chance that I would be traditional in my views.You see, my mother had always been keen to promote positive female role models.We weren’t a traditional family, but we were very close. Claire is my best friend as well as my lover.We won’t get married, but we do love each other. Sometimes we just take off for a weekend, maybe Norfolk, or to a European capital. I think romance is best when it is spontaneous. Neither of us are workaholics, so we make time for each other.We tend to share housework roles, but I must admit I don’t like cooking, but then Claire hates cleaning the house, which I do.We both work from home a lot, so that helps. I think men are changing, but it is slow going. I used to go down the pub once a week, you know, for the quiz nights. But I’ve stopped doing that now. I just get fed up with the sexist banter that goes on across the bar.
Whether gay or straight,the Democratic Male offers the best hope for positive change in gender relationships. He may well have issues to resolve in his life, particularly concerning work roles,perhaps childcare,and trying to generally achieve a balanced life amid all the demands on his time from loved ones and work responsibilities. But at least he is able to talk about them with some degree of openness and honesty. And in this respect he carries few of the unresolved anxieties of traditional man. The heterosexual Democratic 60
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 61
Men at the Millennium Male is likely to prefer women’s company to men’s, or enjoy it equally with men’s,and will be capable of resolving most of the concealed sexual tensions in respect of his many platonic friendships with women. He can be quite competitive, focused on work and material success, and quite boyish when it comes to sport and sexual escapades. Do not expect him to be naïve in terms of sexuality and sexual explorations. He is not an innocent. He can be a bit naughty at times.In that respect he is like all men – an often confusing mix of multiple masculinities in action. Where he is different, especially from Confused Man and the Traditionalist, is that he is a man who is emotionally literate, comfortable with exposing his most intimate emotions and thoughts, revealing of himself to others, and who is flexible enough in his attitudes towards sex and romance to be an equal player in the new gender game. Mike is a building surveyor. He is aged 29, single and lives alone. He has had two serious relationships since leaving university and is currently dating a solicitor. If you ask me what is the biggest difference between my generation of males, and that of my father, I reckon I can sum it up in one sentence: I use face and hand cream, my father would die before he would. I know it sounds pretty basic, but I often think how modern males, especially the younger ones, feel about themselves as men, comes down to how comfortable they are doing things that women always have.The rules have changed, there’s no doubt about it.The women I date don’t want to hear you talking about sport all night, they want someone who can relate to them as individuals, not as stereotypes.The biggest change for me probably occurred during my time
61
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 62
Men,Women, Love and Romance at university.You couldn’t help but see that women students had a different approach to sex and marriage.They are much more confident, outgoing, and realistic about what they want from a relationship. And very frank in expressing their needs! I have as many if not more women friends as men friends, platonic relationships that have no sexual undercurrents. I like my mates, but I am just as comfortable, if not more so, with women.
In terms of actual romance, the Democratic Male can be both traditional and modern. He will assume a sharing of the cost of meals, nights out, holidays and so on. He won’t expect to be the only one to come up with the romantic weekends, being well aware that his partner is equally capable of organising such surprises. But he will buy her flowers, and simple, thoughtful gifts that indicate his deep feelings for her. He will be happy with long conversations, often deep into the night, and lingering intimate moments which may or may not lead to sex. Sex and romance for the Democratic Male is more spontaneous than for traditional men. There are no set rules for him and his partner to follow; they work it through for themselves, doing what feels right for them, when it feels right for them.They are comfortable with the bedroom revolution. They are not fighting change.They are the change.
Where are men going now? It is clear from the above account of men and masculinities that we are at a fascinating, if not unique moment in gender relationships.We are in the midst of a new gender game and it is uprooting our old ideas about how men – 62
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 63
Men at the Millennium and women – should behave. Like any social revolution some will be more comfortable than others with that of the bedroom, and the democratic love it is ushering in.We can see quite clearly that many men are not responding well to the new expectations of women – it is altogether too threatening to who they think they are as men. Expect such men to go into denial or retreat, all the while complaining loudly that ‘women have it all’. For these men a bleak future looms, a future where they increasingly seek solace in those traditional male pastimes of work, sport and male bonding. But, like the dodo, there can be no retreat from environmental reality. It is either adapt or perish. For other men, those out of the gender maze, it is clear they have comfortably adapted to twenty-first century masculinity. Indeed, they exemplify it. Those men still struggling to understand and come to terms with these changes will eventually have to ask themselves the following questions: 1. Do I have the emotional capacity to change or am I more comfortable being trapped in out-dated ways of being a man? 2. Am I in retreat or denial, feeling confused and threatened by the new-found confidence of sexually aware women? 3. Can I cope with being at the periphery, not at the centre, of a woman’s world? 4. Do I have a gender, and if so what is its name? These questions are fundamental to modern, twenty-first century masculinity, for in asking them of himself each man is recognising he must change and adapt. 63
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 64
Men,Women, Love and Romance Whatever the changes going on between individual women and men, what is certain is that romance between the sexes will continue. Indeed, there is every possibility of it being heightened as a result of having relationships founded on equality and sexual openness. For many men, such personal change will come from waking up to the fact that they have to change or get left behind. However, we should not presume a crisis of masculinity here. Rather, what we have is a disrupting of a particular type of masculinity – traditional masculinity. This masculinity, while still dominant in many relationships, is being questioned and thrown into confusion as a consequence of the bedroom revolution. As more people come to see that democratic love is attainable, then we can expect many more changes around men. We can expect more men to become comfortable expressing their emotional selves to loved ones and others. We can expect more men to engage in intimate relationships for their own sake, not for instrumental gain.We can expect a heightening of the romantic possibilities between women and men, but based on gender equity, not inequity. We can expect many more men to come out of the gender maze, a little shaken, certainly, but generally intact and ready to make their own particular contribution to the new gender game. Here are two sets of questions about men; one for men to answer, and one for their partners to answer. They are designed to give men some insights into their sense of masculinity, and women some points of discussion with their male lovers. In answering them you may well get a sense of how well you are playing the new gender game, how much you are part of the bedroom revolution and how close you 64
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 65
Men at the Millennium are to twenty-first century masculinity – and being a democratic lover!
10 questions on men, for men 1. Which individual men, living or dead, do you most admire, and why? 2. How would you feel if your boss was a woman? If your boss is a woman, how do you feel about this? 3. What is the most romantic thing you have ever done? 4. Does romance turn you on, sexually? 5. Do you share the housework with your partner? 6. If you had a choice to date any woman in the world, for one night only, who would it be? Why that choice? 7. What do and don’t you like about women? 8. What do and don’t you like about men? 9. Which jobs do you think are unsuited for women and why? 10. Which film do you think most captures the mind set of twenty-first century man – Fight Club or Billy Elliot?
10 questions on men, for women 1. Which individual man does your husband/partner/ boyfriend admire most? 2. Would he feel comfortable working for a boss who was female? 3. What is the most romantic thing he has ever done? 4. Who would your husband/boyfriend/partner most like to date if he had the choice of any woman in the world? 5. Given the choice, who would your partner prefer to spend an evening with:Tom Cruise or Nicole Kidman? 6. Does your partner expect to be ‘rewarded’ with sex if 65
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 66
Men,Women, Love and Romance he is romantic towards you? 7. Does he see women as equal to men in every respect? 8. Does he share in the housework? 9. Does your partner know you in every way? 10. How would you categorise your man? Is he a Seductive Instrumentalist, a Traditionalist, a Confused Male, or a Democratic Lover?
for both Having answered these questions as best you can, you might now consider discussing them, and what they mean, with your partner. This should not form the basis of any ‘critical engagement’ (ie argument!) but might help you both explore and think about some of the hidden but important intimacies in your relationship. For these intimacies, these ways in which we know and love our partner, hold the clue to both our long-term love prospects and possible future difficulties within the relationship.
66
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 67
chapte r ii
New Women, Different Women
Women have traditionally been seen as the gender that wants to be romantic, that wants to be wooed. Men, on the other hand, have been seen as the gender that does the wooing, sometimes with aplomb, sometimes clumsily. Woman surrenders to man, eventually. Or in other words, man pursues woman with woman demurring, though not too much to put him off completely. While recognising that women have often been the ones doing the choosing, this not too subtle double act seems to have gone on throughout history. And why not? It worked for our parents, and countless generations before them. But what about us, the men and women of the twenty-first century? How accurate and appropriate are these rules of romance today? In order to answer that question we need to look at the experiences of women in love or seeking sexual and romantic attachments with men. Only this way can we get some sense of the dramatic changes in women’s sense of their sexuality and new-found confidence to play the gender game. But first, we have to find out where these new aspirations of millennium woman came from. We have to find out just what it is that drives the change in ‘New Woman’. 67
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 68
Men,Women, Love and Romance
The dreams of New Woman If you ask many people what the differences are between women’s and men’s experiences of modern life, they will say that men seem confused and women seem on the ascendancy.Yet why do so many people believe this to be so? Why has it become commonplace to suggest that women now have it all and that men are in crisis? If there is one straightforward answer to this complex question it probably concerns choice. Simply put, twenty-first century woman has more choices open to her, many of which impact on areas of life previously assumed to be the sole province of men.Yes it helps if she is educated, middle class and able to earn a decent wage, but, then, this is precisely the position of millions of Western women today. What the bedroom revolution has done is to open up choices for women. It has made it okay for women to exercise personal choice and to aspire to different lifestyles from those experienced by previous generations of women. Whether contained in the pages Cosmopolitan, the lives of female pop stars such as Madonna or the gender studies course at the local university, the message to women has been ‘this is what men have, you can have it too’. As the new millennium dawns, we can see women have taken up this message with enthusiasm.Yes,there are many unresolved issues for women faced with multiple choices in how to live their lives, but in believing they can be financially, sexually and emotionally independent of men, so women have ushered in the greatest, most profound revolution ever. Our dreams come true only if we believe in them. To believe in them we first must believe in ourselves. 68
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 69
New Women, Different Women The first step on this journey of change was for women to believe that things could be better for them than it was for their mothers and grandmothers. It was to challenge the old gender ideas that said women should find a man, marry him, and then spend the remainder of their days looking after his needs and those of her children: be faithful unto death; love, honour and obey.This is the reason why marriage is in decline, indeed why it is one of the first casualties of the new gender game – because increasing numbers of women no longer want it. More precisely, they no longer need it.Women have come to realise that being stuck in a boring, loveless marriage is not for them. As novelist Jeanette Winterson puts it, writing in the Guardian: Marriage isn’t for life any more – life is too long. Marriage is for love. Many women now see marriage not as an aspiration, but as a trap. Rather than walk down the aisle, they hang back, asking themselves: ‘Why promise life-long commitment when I’m not sure what I’ll want, or who I’ll be, in ten or more years’ time?’ Marriage used to give women some status as wives. It offered them a level of security and social position denied them as spinsters or single mothers, and, because up until the late 1970s most families were headed by male breadwinners, wives got an important financial benefit also. But there was precious little freedom for women who signed up to traditional marriage, because marriage was never designed to give women freedom. Marriage has been the most persistent and powerful social institution ever, but it has never been democratic. Any democracy for wives has had to be fought for. 69
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 70
Men,Women, Love and Romance Since the 1970s, women have woken up to the fact that marriage is not all it’s cracked up to be.They’re now deserting it in droves. By 2021 a third of all British couples will be unmarried, with many preferring to be ‘semi-detached couples’ or LATS.These ‘live apart togethers’ are rewriting the script on commitment and togetherness, sharing love but not households. By contrast, marriage is good for men. It always has been. For one thing, married men live longer than single men.Which is not surprising, because most married men get a regular sexual partner, a mother for their children, a full-time homeworker, and someone to nurse them when they need it. Not only do many men get all this from their marriages, they also now have someone who can pay the mortgage. Many women have spotted that marriage is not an arrangement made in heaven, it’s an arrangement invented by men, for men. And women have noticed a further anomaly in marriage – sexual fidelity. The sexual fidelity that comes with monogamous marriage is a male invention – meant to keep women at home, preferably fully occupied with childcare and domestic duties. It is rooted in a past age where women were tied to the house, allowed no power or influence in the public world of men; their sexuality hidden, rendered invisible or unclean by puritanical beliefs – something in need of control. Any power women had came from being the ‘hand that rocked the cradle’. But while marriage effectively kept wives at home, husbands enjoyed the freedom to roam, to stray beyond the confines of the marital bed, to the extent that in many countries the ‘mistress’ has become a social institution in its own right. But the wives didn’t stray, at least not openly. They were trapped by marriage vows, lack of 70
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 71
New Women, Different Women economic freedom, and the guilt that comes with notions of being a ‘good wife and mother’. No, women were not allowed the sexual leeway that men assumed to be their birthright as males. In many countries they still aren’t. New Woman is exercising choice in every area of her life, but especially maternity. She is having fewer children and later, and is increasingly likely to have them outside marriage. One in five women born since 1960 is childless. What we are dealing with here are myths of femininity which, while still powerful, don’t have the same resonance for modern woman as they did for her mother and grandmother. For example, the old idea that women must stay virgins for their husbands-to-be, that is, if they are not to be seen as sluttish, and therefore left on the shelf, seems bizarre today. While getting married at 20 and staying faithful to this one sexual partner for the rest of one’s life is not an option many women are choosing in the modern age. Sexual fidelity as a compelling social code of behaviour is now consigned to the cultural scrap heap.Yes, many, if not most women may well prefer to be in an exclusive, loving relationship with one man. But being in a sexually exclusive relationship is now a lifestyle choice for women – at some points in their lives they’ll want it, and at other times they won’t. Research into changing patterns of sexual behaviour, published in The Lancet in 2001, proves this point about monogamy. It showed that a quarter of all women under 30 first had sexual intercourse when they were under 16. Fifteen per cent of women will have had ten or more 71
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 72
Men,Women, Love and Romance sexual partners by the time they reach 24. For women aged 25–34 the proportion with ten or more partners rises to 23 per cent. Seventy-five per cent of all women have, so far in their lives, had two or more sexual partners. In the 1950s, 60 per cent of women had sex for the first time to the man to whom they were engaged or already married. Today, that figure is only 1 per cent.This is not a generation of women that believes in the purity of virginity. The dreams of New Women are to have the social, sexual and economic freedoms long enjoyed by men, while still retaining their sense of femininity.And this is precisely what many millions of women now have.They have come to realise that it is very sexy to have power, to be able to exercise choice in one’s life about relationships, sexuality and lifestyle. Men have long known the aphrodisiacal quality which comes with having freedom to roam. Now women have tasted it too. Divorce used to be taboo in China. Now nearly 2 million Chinese get divorced every year, a figure that’s rapidly increasing. Like their counterparts in the West, it’s mostly women who are opting for divorce. But there is a price for all this.Nothing comes free.The first dilemma confronting New Woman is that most men are hardly changing at all. Many men are still rooted in the past, unable or unwilling to come out of their masculine comfort zones of work and sport and into this new world. This has left women with some uncomfortable choices. Does she settle for what she knows to be second best in a man, or does she keep hoping for a more enlightened, emotionally mature male to come into her life and love her 72
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 73
New Women, Different Women in a committed relationship, maybe one that will produce children? Second, in being sexually adventurous does she risk losing the chance for a long-term relationship? If she has multiple sexual partners does this mean men will still see her as ‘easy game’ and therefore choose not to pursue her in a romantic, and committed, fashion? What is more, having come to enjoy sexual adventures, does she become a little addicted to the excitement they offer her? As my interviews with women show, they’ve not lost the desire for long-term committed love, but many are now caught between wanting to be treated in a traditionally romantic way by men, and wanting the freedom to pursue their own life journey, not reliant on any man. New Women may be more like their fathers when it comes to pursuing sex, but they’re still their mothers’ daughters when it comes to wanting love and romance. In the following three sections I look at a number of different women, aged from 25 to 63, all of whom were interviewed for this book. Their comments about love, relationships, sex and romance reveal something of women’s changing ambitions and expectations, now apparent not just in Britain but across the world.Although there is a 40 year age gap between the youngest and eldest, these women have one thing in common:They are all part of the twenty-first century bedroom revolution. These women have shaken off many of the gender stereotypes that constrained previous generations of women. They don’t necessarily buy into strict moral or social codes which might inhibit their sexual expression, freedom of choice and pleasure.They still want to appear feminine and 73
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 74
Men,Women, Love and Romance attractive for men, but equally, if not more, important is feeling attractive to themselves.They are confident individuals, engaged in their own life journeys and not totally reliant on any man. Significantly, they are not financially dependent on men. For these women, some of whom have been in traditional relationships in the past and come out of them by choice, there can now only be democratic love. Anything else is temporary and to be dipped in and out of as the fancy takes them – just like men in fact.
Twenties – playing the market Female, feisty and forward – that’s the twenty-something woman of the modern age. The twenties used to be the decade when girls became women, when they took on the responsibilities of life: work, marriage and motherhood. Not any more. Now the twenties are for experimentation and having fun. Young women are more likely to travel the world for a year or so than they are to settle down to marital bliss.They are more likely to be committed to their education and a career than they are to a partner. By the time they get to 30 the majority of women will have had three or more sexual partners. And if they are in a settled relationship the chances are it’s as a LAT (living apart together) or as a cohabitee.Women, and men, are using the twenties to find out about themselves, release their sexuality and discover the world. Most, especially the educated ones, are deferring having children till much later in life, if at all, preferring to enjoy the freedom which comes as a DINKY couple (double income no kids), or as a SINTY (single no ties). 74
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 75
New Women, Different Women The handbag of a twenty-something woman is just as likely to carry a condom as it is lipstick. The advertisers have come to recognise the power of the twenty-something woman. They are the target audience for most women’s magazines where a relentless diet of nocommitment sex is the message. Not surprisingly, sexuality now informs the self-image of those in this age group.Are they having enough sex? Is it good sex? Are they sexy? These questions are poured over and analysed to exhaustion. By the time they reach their late teens, young women must have learnt many of the tricks of sex and romance if they are to compete in this sexual marketplace.They must display a sexual confidence far beyond their years. It is now not possible to walk down a High Street without being hit by the message that sex is out there for young women to partake in and enjoy. Even Marks and Spencer, the archetypal purveyor of pragmatic British lingerie, now markets Agent Provocateur underwear. From late night ‘adult’ films on Channel 5 to the ubiquitous condom machine in the ladies, the message to the twenty-something woman is ‘be sexually available’. But, paradoxically, there is a countermessage – that marriage is still the end-game.The hype and media coverage given to the weddings of Posh and Becks, and Madonna and Guy, suggest that marriage is still the ultimate validation of love and romance for many twentysomething women. Similarly, the British TV soaps rarely let a heterosexual romance continue for long without bringing in the sound of wedding bells. So the media has mixed messages for the twentysomething woman. Be sexually active, even predatory, but don’t forget that what you really want in the end is marriage 75
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 76
Men,Women, Love and Romance to a steady, reliable, loving and hopefully romantic man – a relationship that not only lasts but also produces children. This paradox of being a twenty-something woman is vividly captured in the accounts of two women described below, Dawn and Julie. Each woman reveals how she engages with sex, romantic liaisons, and expectations of love. They also highlight the conflicting desires many women have to be sexy, available and ‘orgasmic’, yet also maternal and traditional.
dawn Dawn is aged 25, a journalist on a regional of newspaper. After finishing university Dawn returned home to live with her parents. Although quite successful in her chosen career, Dawn does not see it as the most important thing in her life. She has many friends of both sexes and enjoys socialising, which for her means visiting clubs, discos and bars in her home city. Since losing her virginity at 14 she has had many boyfriends and lovers, plus ‘lots of sexual encounters’. Her one heavy relationship lasted a year. I asked her about monogamy. My girl friends and I don’t tend to use that word so much. I see it more as loyalty. But then, there’s been many times when I’ve not been faithful to a boyfriend. I can be very loyal, but it depends on how deep the relationship is. I can get bored quite quickly with men.
While at university, Dawn rented a house and advertised for five male flatmates. It was during this period that she was particularly promiscuous. 76
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 77
New Women, Different Women I chose these five blokes very carefully, knowing I wouldn’t even snog any of them. I certainly didn’t have any intention of fucking them. It would have got too complicated. But I did get it on with their mates, and other blokes I met, especially those who came out with us on the piss. My flatmates used to joke about seeing new blokes come down for breakfast.They called them my ‘breakfast pals’. It was a bit of a joke when we went out – like ‘Who’s going to be your breakfast pal tonight?’ But in the end, some of my flatmates got a bit sick of seeing different breakfast pals every morning!
Dawn recognises herself as something of a sexual predator. She admits to pursuing men she fancies, being quite determined to get them into bed if the mood takes her. If she’s out with her work friends and they bring along some new bloke to join them for the night out, they’ll always warn her if he’s taken.Yet despite the sexual urges she undoubtedly feels, and responds to, Dawn does sometimes feel pressures to be in a settled relationship. Sex and love has come in waves for me. I’d be seeing one person, then someone else would get interested and so it went on.They’d all come along at once and I’d not know which one to choose so I’d try them all out, but then it’d get a bit messy. I’ve seen loads of men. I’ve been a bit slaggish at times. But then I’ve thought, Oh God! It’s time to settle down. It was when I was feeling like this that John came along.
John has, so far, been the big love of Dawn’s life. She met him when she was 23 and they were together for a year. It 77
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 78
Men,Women, Love and Romance was during Dawn’s relationship with John that she came closest to marriage. Six months into the affair she nearly asked him to marry her, on 29 February of a leap year, but she didn’t go through with it. ‘I didn’t have the guts,’ she recalled.Although at the time very much in love with her boyfriend, the relationship fizzled out during the next six months. I asked her why. John was getting more and more involved in his work and I guess I felt neglected. I was fed up, sick of it.We weren’t going out. Not only was there no romance in my life, we weren’t having sex very often either. I loved him but wanted more.I was involved at that time in a work project with a group of people. I clicked with someone on the project and that was it. For the final few months of my relationship with John I was having sex on and off with different people. I’m really glad I didn’t ask him to marry me. It seemed a good idea at the time, but my lifestyle was changing. I like to be out and about, with the lads, my blokey mates, talking dirty and whatever. Having a few beers and a laugh. I couldn’t do that with John.
Dawn’s parents have been married for over 30 years and are still together. She sees their relationship as a model for her, but is torn between wanting to be in such a loving, committed and exclusive partnership, and wanting to pursue her own life journey, which inevitably, for her, means having different lovers. She’d like to have children ‘sometime in the next ten years’, and would prefer to be married when she does. But she doesn’t sense any ‘biological clock’ ticking. At least, not yet. I asked what was the appeal of marriage for her. 78
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 79
New Women, Different Women Because I want a big wedding! I want a big party! I want to have the full traditional stuff, be the centre of attention. All that. But it’s also because I want to be loyal like my mum.And marriage is about loyalty.Also,I definitely want to have kids, lots of kids. I’m quite a traditional girl like that. I want to be married when I have children. But if I was married now I know I couldn’t be faithful to one person for the rest of my life. Definitely not. I still feel too young for that sort of commitment. I’d like to have a companion for life. But I’m not sure what kind of partner or husband I’d like.
For Dawn, there are two types of men, the ‘nice boys’, and the ‘bad boys’. She finds both types attractive, but recognises that she is constantly pulled between wanting to fuck the bad boys and wanting to settle down with a nice boy. I go from bad boys to nice boys.When I’ve been a bit slaggish it’s been with the bad boys, you know, the ones you can’t really trust.The bad boys are the ones who are likely to be unfaithful. But they attract me, because you feel like you’ve got to work a bit harder with the bad boy, to keep him. It’s the chase. I like the chase. I like knowing that he’s mine but I have to keep working at it to keep him. But I haven’t met the bad boy that I’d be happy with yet. The nice boys are the ones that dote on you.They’re the ones that like the quiet life. You can trust the nice boys. But I like to be out and about. My ex-boyfriend, John, was a nice boy. He was faithful. He couldn’t be anything but. He did love me. I think the nice boys are a bit predictable. I like the strangers, they’re more of a challenge I guess. Sometimes I think a traditional wedding
79
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 80
Men,Women, Love and Romance with a nice boy would be ideal, but then I still want to shag about everywhere!
(Dawn has recently embarked on a relationship with a 50 year old, the oldest man she’s ever been out with. She describes him as ‘experienced, mature, romantic – but nicely naughty’.) julie
Julie is aged 28. She is a successful self-employed interior designer and owns her own house. Julie got married at 22, but after two years the marriage ended and she is now divorced. There were no children. Since her early teens she had been very focused on both her education and her career. It wasn’t until she went to university that she had her first sexual relationship, with a man she was to marry. She was 18. It was during her marriage that she came to sense that she was missing out on ‘lots of fun’. My work has always been my life. I’ve had to be so determined to succeed. It’s not been easy. But I’ve always known I wanted to be an interior designer. I seem to have a natural aptitude for it. Paul, my husband, was always very supportive, but maybe I got married too young, though I did love him. I’d never had another lover, only him, and things started to change for me when I got a chance to go abroad to work for a year, after university. He came with me, but it introduced me to a different lifestyle, and different types of men. I came to realise that although I enjoyed what I had, it wasn’t enough. Maybe I was being selfish, or greedy, I don’t know.
80
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 81
New Women, Different Women After a year abroad, Julie returned to the UK to set up her business. Paul came with her but by this time she’d started to have the occasional fling. At first, she managed to keep them secret,but eventually Paul came to realise that her nights away on business were not always what they seemed. I’d be in a hotel somewhere, on business, and there’d be some bloke I’d meet in the bar. Sometimes it would be completely innocent, but every now and again I’d end up in bed with them.Although I felt guilty, I liked it. It gave me a sense of freedom.I never intended to hurt Paul,I just realised I wasn’t cut out for an exclusive relationship. At least not at my age.
After establishing her new business and getting divorced, Julie chose not to settle down with any one partner, but to ‘play the field’ for a while. She occasionally responds to newspaper personal ads and has dated several men she’s met through that medium. Every so often she meets someone through work who she fancies, and dates him for a while. But she is not looking for a larger commitment from a man. The thing is, I start to feel trapped by it all. I love my home, I’ve got a successful business.Yet part of me wants my freedom, and part of me doesn’t. Given my hectic job, I relish coming home to the peace and quiet of an empty house. But then there’s times when it’s lovely to wake up next to a man in your bed. I just don’t want the whole thing to become expected and routine.
81
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 82
Men,Women, Love and Romance I asked Julie what attracted her to certain men. She identified criteria that she usually goes through at the beginning or fairly early on in the relationship. I look at a bloke – is he attractive? Is he attractive visually? I’m big on eyes, if he’s looking at me and making eye contact, good thing. If he’s smiling, looks like he’ll have a laugh, that’s good. If he’s a miserable git, just out to pose, then sod off! If he’s wearing nice clothes,that would tell me that he’s in a good job. He has to be intelligent and mature, and I usually end up with blokes about ten years older than me.Attractive isn’t about being good looking, it’s about the way they act. For me, an attractive man is someone who looks a bit naughty. Someone who has that sparkle in their eyes which suggests they like sex.That’s important. Plus a nice sized thing! Size is important to a woman!
Given her sexually adventurous lifestyle, I asked Julie whether she had any regrets about having been married and divorced, by the time she was 25. No, no regrets at all. My family were very traditional and maybe I’d just accepted that marriage was what you did if you met someone you loved.Also, I was too busy studying and getting my career on-line to be bothered about sleeping around. When I think about it, I reckon you’d be pretty sad if you ended your life never having got married. I’m glad I did. I do regret having been unfaithful in my marriage, not because it ended the marriage, but the damage it did to the trust.
And children? 82
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 83
New Women, Different Women That’s not on the cards for me for a while. I have too much to do in my life. I want to build up the business and get financially secure before I think about having children.There’s plenty of time. I look at my friends who’ve got kids and I think, Oh no, I couldn’t cope with that! I know I would if I had to, but not just yet.Whether or not I get married again we’ll have to see. I see no reason why I should. I’d like the father to play a major role in the upbringing of any children but that doesn’t mean being a married couple. I’ve done that, got the t-shirt as they say, why repeat it?
I asked both Dawn and Julie about romance, having it or not having it in their lives. Their responses were very similar. Romance was important when they were embarking on relationships with a man, but not so important if they were just out on the prowl for a sexual encounter.Yet, although each woman could be sexually predatory, they did relish being pursued by a man, receiving cards, love letters, flowers. Dawn recounted how she once burst into tears after receiving flowers at work, sent by John. It had been his way of making up with her after a row.Yet, as she recounted, she went off and had affairs mainly because she felt he was neglecting her:‘In the end, the flowers were not enough. I needed more from him – I needed his attention.’
Thirties – juggling love, children and career For both men and women the gateway to adulthood is not 16, 18 or 21. It’s 35.Before that we’re still discovering who are we are. 83
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 84
Men,Women, Love and Romance By the time they reach their mid-thirties most women are set on distinct paths of career, family and long-term relationships.It is the decade from which to lay foundations for the rest of one’s life, whether it be further study, pursuing a career or being a wife/partner and parent. It can be an exciting and fulfilling decade, a period of both consolidation and personal development.The big questions can no longer be ignored:Who am I? What am I? What do I want from my life? Who will be my soulmate through life? Do I need one? This decade is a time of major decisions and complicated lifestyles, with many women having to juggle conflicting and multiple roles as mother, wife/partner and careerist. For such women, while romantic desire doesn’t disappear altogether, it gets shelved for a while, brought out on special occasions, though rarely to the extent that it interferes with their career, or being a ‘responsible’ wife and mother.Those women not in heavy relationships may well be assessing boyfriends as prospective long-term partners or even possible fathers for a yet to be conceived child. Many single (and married) women will hear no biological clock ticking at all, being quite content to pursue a challenging and rewarding career, or merely an unattached lifestyle. For others, the thirties is a decade of serial monogamy, a stream of relationships, sexual adventures and romantic attachments. For over-stretched mothers of young children, starved of leisure and free-time, any romantic love life is likely to be intermittent and temporary, but no less enjoyable for that. For thirty-something single mothers, their real love is saved, not for the roguish male sexual predator, portrayed by Hugh Grant in About A Boy, but for their children. Copping off is great, but there is 84
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 85
New Women, Different Women nothing as intense, emotional or satisfying for a mother as when her young child cuddles up to her, and whispers in her ear ‘I love you Mummy.’ For women, having a child is like suddenly being plunged into a volcanic eruption. For men, it is more like being caught in a strong wind. One gets permanently changed, the other gets ruffled. Whether married, single, a LAT, careerist or dedicated mother, the thirty-something woman is the living embodiment of the feminist aspiration to ‘have it all’ – financial independence, sexual confidence, family, love and longterm relationships.The choices open to this age group are multiple and expanding. However, nobody ‘has it all’, there are always sacrifices to make, prices to pay. For example, recent research undertaken in the US shows that 42 per cent of high-salary women are childless, though only 14 per cent said they didn’t want to have children. Careerminded women in their mid-thirties will put in ludicrous hours in the office, just like men have had to for years – the difference being that male managers usually have kids and a wife at home to look after them.For those ambitious, but also maternal, thirty-something women working in highly competitive male-dominated work places, becoming pregnant may be wonderful, but it’s certainly not going to help their career. While those women moving towards their late thirties, and not interested in either marriage or children, may well have to cope with the puzzled looks of their parents wondering whether or not they’ll ever have a grandchild to spoil or a traditional wedding to splash out on. 85
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 86
Men,Women, Love and Romance In the US today, one third of women earn more than their husbands. For most, their thirties are when they establish these careers. Despite often being pulled in different directions, what the thirty-something woman is doing is exercising choice and living out the consequences – something that can be very exhausting! Her sexual libido may well be in overdrive, but so may her career ambitions and/or her maternal instincts. She may relish being in a long-term partnership, settled with a family, but does she really see herself as ‘mum at home’ for the next 20 years? If she’s decided to take the career path, and leave her children in the hands of others, can she handle any subsequent feelings of guilt? Should she feel guilty anyway? Is her life journey now planned out by 35, as it was for her mother, or will it have some twists and turns, challenges and excitements for her to face? How would she cope if it did? Something of the sexual and emotional maelstrom surrounding many thirty-something women is captured in the words of Rachel and Sheila.
rachel Rachel is aged 35. She’s a single mum with a 12-yearold boy. Rachel left school at 18 with good qualifications, but chose not to go on to university. Instead, she started work, eventually finding herself involved in a very intense relationship with Simon who was 15 years older than her. By the time she was 23 she was married to Simon and had a young baby to care for. Although she started out loving her husband, she came to find the relationship too stifling. She had money, a house, a child and a husband. But, as she says: 86
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 87
New Women, Different Women I felt my life had stopped somehow. I had all this but where was I going? I wasn’t happy. The love had gone from the relationship. In fact, it had started to feel quite oppressive for me.When I met Simon I was so innocent really. My childhood hadn’t been that happy and marriage to Simon seemed to offer me the security and family life I craved. But eventually that security became a trap. He was quite a jealous type. He wanted to know all my movements, where I was, who I was with. At times I felt a prisoner in my own home.
Rachel’s situation was made more difficult by the fact that she had a very poor relationship with her mother (her father had died when she was a child). She felt unable to confide her feelings to anybody. But as her marriage deteriorated so her determination to move on grew. Eventually, she packed her bags and went, taking her five-year-old son with her. She was 28. Once her son was settled at school, Rachel decided it was time to get back into studying. She went to college to do media studies as a mature student. She loved it.What is more, she met a man who was to help her move on even more – intellectually, sexually and emotionally: her tutor. I remember the first time I heard him give a lecture. I just thought My God, who is that! He had this presence and I knew then I’d have to get to know him better. I’d not been in a sexual relationship since leaving Simon. I’d lost a lot of confidence during my marriage, but I was slowly getting it back. I guess going to college, and being around mature students, many like myself, gave me back my selfbelief. It was a great time.
87
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 88
Men,Women, Love and Romance Rachel recognised there was a danger in being attracted to another older man, someone who, in her words, was ‘no innocent’. But the budding affair was for her a way of validating her womanhood and sexuality. She felt she was owed whatever pleasure it might bring. He didn’t have a chance really. I could tell he was attracted to me, but to be fair to him he tried to keep a professional distance. One afternoon I was having a tutorial in his office and I came over to his chair and knelt by him, ostensibly to show him some of my work, but it was electric.There was a real sexual presence between us. But he shied off.Told me it was getting too close for comfort. He was right! But it was inevitable we’d sleep together. We first had sex three weeks later.At my place. It had been a few years since I’d slept with a man. It felt so good. I felt like a teenager. I acted like a teenager, though I had the libido of a 30-year-old woman!
What particularly attracted Rachel to her tutor was the fact that he was already in a relationship and didn’t want anything too serious.This suited Rachel fine – the last thing she wanted was another heavy relationship, at least not while her new life was starting to take off.The other attraction was that she trusted him. He was sensitive to her needs and understood her situation. It wasn’t just the sex, though that was great, it was the intellectual connection I felt with him. He was mature and he made me feel good about myself. For a while he was not just my occasional lover, he was my best friend. I was going through a time when I still had a lot of
88
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 89
New Women, Different Women emotional hang-ups to deal with and he helped me enormously. Of course, I could never trust him to be faithful, but that wasn’t part of the agreement. I could trust him not to deliberately hurt me.That was more important for me.
The affair with her tutor drifted on for another 18 months, long after Rachel had given up studying. She started a new career in advertising and life was good. It was time to move on again. I was ready for the big one. No more clandestine meetings with my ex-tutor. So I started replying to one or two lonely hearts adverts and very quickly found David. He was divorced and had a child. He had a softness and gentleness to him which attracted me. We hit it off immediately. But this time I had the confidence to handle any hurt that might come out of the relationship. He was not as worldly-wise as my ex-tutor, so I knew I could handle him okay. It’s a good relationship. He’s romantic and very loving.We’re still together.
(Rachel is currently back at university, doing a part-time MA. She and David recently bought a house together. She doesn’t want any more children.)
sheila Sheila is aged 37. After leaving college she did a variety of jobs before applying to be an air steward with a major international airline. After a lengthy interview process she was accepted on to their training programme, eventually working on long-haul flights. It was a job she’d always 89
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 90
Men,Women, Love and Romance wanted and she loved doing it, though at times it was ‘absolutely knackering’. When she was 28 she married Scott, a hairdresser with his own salon.Although her work often took her away for days or weeks at a time, their lifestyle gave them many material comforts. For a few years they lived this hectic, but nevertheless satisfying life as a DINKY couple.Then, aged 32, she found herself pregnant. This was completely out of the blue. I’d had a nasty miscarriage some years before and at the time the doctor had told me the chances of me conceiving again were pretty remote. Scott and I had discussed having children, but neither of us were that keen to start a family.What with our jobs, and my medical history, we’d sort of put this idea out of our minds.Also, I guess we were a little selfish, we were enjoying our lifestyle too much.
Their lifestyle changed with the arrival of Joshua. Scott continued to run his salon, but for Sheila things were different. Being an air stewardess is not just a job, it’s a way of life. You get into the routine of travel, airports, hotels, exotic locations, so though it’s hard work, I never found it boring. Unexpectedly finding myself pregnant brought me down to earth quicker than any 747 I can tell you! … When we were expecting Joshua I’d had this idea of being a part-time mum, paying for childcare and returning to work.This idea held until he was born, and then it started to crumble.What was the point of me working just so I could pay someone else to have the enjoyment of being with my son? It didn’t make sense.
90
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 91
New Women, Different Women With Sheila at home full-time with Joshua, and Scott absorbed in his business, their married life took on a different character from before. As a first-time mother, nothing prepares you for the impact of a baby. He was so small and vulnerable. He needed me and I wasn’t at all sure I could cope. Scott was good, but as a mother you tend to feel responsible much more than the man does.The nights were terrible at first, what with colic and breast-feeding. And looking back now I do believe I suffered from mild post-natal depression. My family, especially my mother, rallied round, but for over 18 months everything felt too much. It was a real struggle.There were many times when I resented having this baby to look after constantly. I was missing the freedom I’d had in my job.
Sheila and Scott’s life as a DINKY couple had been hard work but glamorous. Nights out in good restaurants, visits to the theatre, weekend city breaks, holidays abroad and an enjoyable, satisfying sex life. Under these circumstances, romance and love came fairly easily. However, like countless numbers of other couples dealing with being first-time parents, they were having to adjust to a new reality. Our sex life took a hammering after Joshua was born. There were many reasons, some medical, some emotional, but the end result was the same – little or no sex for weeks at a time. I just wanted to be held, cuddled – and then sleep! After Joshua I started to put on weight and I felt, well, unattractive really. I know I wasn’t but I’d been so used to keeping in trim, being slim, and buying size 10
91
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 92
Men,Women, Love and Romance clothes that it came as a shock. We had some bad rows during this time. It was a very stressful period.What with less money, and Scott working flat out. Looking back, I was quite bitter at having given up my career. What’s more, I didn’t feel Scott really understood what I was going through.
By the time Joshua was three, Sheila and Scott’s relationship had been forced to undergo some major changes. Sheila took a part-time job as a hotel receptionist, ‘just to get out of the house’, and they put Joshua into nursery for four days a week.Also, Scott agreed to go with Sheila to the relationship counselling organisation Relate, where many of the issues that were troubling their relationship got aired and discussed.This proved a turning point. I guess it’s taken us four years to get ourselves sorted out. Having Joshua has been the best thing that’s happened to me, and to Scott, but going from air stewardess to mum, in less than six months,proved tricky to say the least! It’s possible I could get back into my career, but, to be honest, I don’t think I will.Though I miss it, my old job would be too demanding. Scott and I have had to reform our relationship. We’ve had to take time out for each other, get some romance back into our lives. Having eight hours’ sleep at night has been a good start!
I asked Sheila what she’d learnt about herself during the past five years. Interesting question! I don’t know really [long pause] I think I’ve learnt not to expect too much from myself. I’d
92
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 93
New Women, Different Women always been a perfectionist, still am, but you cannot impose that on children, or relationships.You’ve got to go with the flow. Be flexible. I’ve also learnt that I can be a good mother, but it takes time and only by doing it can you learn it, but you get there. I still feel very guilty at times about having Joshua in childcare when I’m at home by myself. But I needed some life back. You see other couples come to grief when kids arrive, but Scott and I have been okay. But we’ve had to work at it.
(While completing this book, Scott rang me to tell me he and Sheila were expecting their second child. They were both ‘absolutely delighted’.)
Forties, fifties, sixties and beyond – freedom at last In this section I draw on interviews with six women: Linda, Pam, Sarah and Allison, all in their forties, Bridget in her fifties and Liz in her early sixties.As the stories of these women reveal: Ageing no longer withers us, it makes us stronger. It also wakes us up to life’s opportunities. Time was when being 42 was considered middle aged.The 55 year old had only retirement to look forward to, and the 60 year old was,well,old.How dated these stereotypes seem today. Such assumptions about age have been kicked into touch, helped along by high profile sex icons such as Rod Steward, Sean Connery, Mick Jagger and David Bowie, and Liz Hurley, Madonna, Jerry Hall, Catherine Deneuve and Joan Collins. But one doesn’t have to be a media star, or a 93
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 94
Men,Women, Love and Romance multi-millionaire, to feel, and be, sexy at 40, 50 or 60. Increasing numbers of people working out at your local fitness centre are 40 plus, many of them women. It’s no rarity to be a 45-year-old woman, dressed in shorts and a tshirt and pounding a treadmill – and feeling physically and mentally good about oneself as a result. Neither is it a mental aberration to want love and romance, and to experience sexual desire – and orgasms – in your fifties, sixties and seventies. On the contrary, it is clear that as we get older not only are we behaving younger, we’re relishing it! The twenty-first century is going to be a good time to be forty plus. People in this age group produced the Swinging Sixties and far out Seventies, decades which have had an enormous impact on modern culture and living. These are the generations that changed the rules. Now, they have produced a new revolution, this time around love, sex and romance. Of course, much of this change is to do with health and longevity.As we learn more about our bodies, and how to look after them, so we are turning back the years. As we realise that life is for living and we only come round once, so we are spurred on to new adventures. In our later years we are returning to youth, but now armed with confidence borne of maturity and experience of life. It’s a potent combination. The fitness boom that took off in the mid-1980s has certainly helped. Like millions of others I joined in, in my case taking up running, and I’ve done regular exercise ever since. The result is that at 52 I can run further and faster than I could at 25; my resting heart rate is lower, my blood pressure is lower, and I’m generally stronger. I’m not overweight, and my muscles are toned. But ageing well is not just about fitness.When my 28-year-old son and I go 94
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 95
New Women, Different Women shopping we buy almost identical trainers. We have very similar tastes in shirts, trousers and jackets.We listen to the same music.We sometimes go on holiday together. He and I are growing older together, but as friends with very similar tastes, rather than as father and son, generations apart,as I experienced with my father.But it is not just men doing this. My sister, Liz, frequently goes shopping for clothes with her 20-year-old daughter, Sarah, and often joins her on nights out in town. My sister is 47, but for her that doesn’t mean endless evenings in watching TV. Her children are adults now and for the first time in her life she has the time, and the money, to enjoy life. Like many women of her generation, Liz is now a FFOKS (forty, fit and free of kids), and she is enjoying every minute of it – proving that, for many, our life stories are not ending when we reach 40, they’re just beginning. Actress Andie MacDowell, 43, captures the mood of this generation of women: I feel I’m much sexier now than I was in my thirties. I even look hotter, and it’s because I feel safe. I am so much more secure. I don’t feel vulnerable any more. Up until the latter part of the twentieth century the typical 40-something woman was seen as settled, domesticated, married; more likely to wear an apron than a thong, more likely to use a ladle than a dildo. Locked into middle age and a comfortable, but often restricting domestic routine, she was preparing herself for finally vacating the wonderful, exciting world of sex and romance. Indeed, for many such women, especially if their marriage had lasted 20 years or more, love and romance were already distant memories, to be recaptured only in Catherine Cookson novels read at 95
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 96
Men,Women, Love and Romance bedtime or in glossy films.What is more, the fifties and the menopause loomed, and women weren’t supposed to be sexy and alluring in their fifties. But all this is fast becoming history for women of all ages. Zelda Curtis, a 78-year-old widow, quoted in the Observer, proves this point: I’m delighted to say I still have an active sex life. At the end of the day we are all sexual beings, right up until rigor mortis sets in. As the stories below reveal, the modern 40-plus woman increasingly craves sexual excitement, experimentation, freedom and importantly romance. Her sexual desire is not lessened; on the contrary, it has heightened as the years go by. Moreover, if she cannot find those special moments with her husband she is increasingly likely to seek them elsewhere.The 40-plus woman is listening to the messages given to the twenty-somethings and saying, ‘this is my time, for me, and I am not going to waste it’.These are ‘new model’ women, no longer inhibited by the inexperience and insecurities of their twenties and thirties, but confident, financially independent and desirable. They are the true beneficiaries of the feminist – and fitness – revolution. Not only do many have the bodies of women decades younger, they have the sexual magnetism that only comes with age and experience. Increasingly, women in their forties are emerging out of the dated gender/age stereotypes in ways not available to those in their twenties and thirties.The combination of free time, sexual experience, self-knowledge and sexual desire is very powerful. And many women in their fifth and sixth decades have all this. For these ‘new model’ women, FFOKS such as Linda, Pam, 96
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 97
New Women, Different Women Sarah, Allison, Bridget and Liz, sex and romance, and freedom of choice, are not only desirable, they are essential parts of their lives. Research shows that post-menopause women are happier, healthier, and have better sex lives than when they were younger.
linda Linda is aged 44. She is married with three children. She and her husband, Mike (also aged 44), run their own business, a franchised retail outlet.They have been married for 23 years. Linda has always enjoyed sex, but it wasn’t until she was nearing her forties that the desire for a more exciting sex life really started to grow in her. It’s not that I don’t love my husband, I do, but as every married couple knows, the routine of sex with the same person can become such a turn off. Mike is not unattractive, but his sex drive seemed to diminish as he got older, while mine got stronger,especially as the children got more independent and generally easier.When you’re busy producing kids it’s usual not to see yourself as a sexual person, which is quite ironic really when you think about it!
As with many people who go through long periods of being ‘sexually dormant’, or not seeing themselves as sexually attractive to others, Linda experienced what is known as a ‘critical incident’ in her life that made her re-evaluate who she was and what her possibilities were. Linda’s critical incident changed her perceptions of herself, and did it quite unexpectedly and completely. 97
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 98
Men,Women, Love and Romance A young man, in his late twenties, used to come in the shop quite regularly and he’d look at me in a way I’d stopped recognising as being to do with sexual interest. Then one day he was telling my husband that he’d just broken up with his girlfriend and I overheard him say that the problem was there were so few attractive, mature, young women in the area. He told Mike that he thought he was very fortunate to have a wife like me, someone who was attractive and also mature. He joked with him about where did he find me as he’d start looking there.
Although fairly innocent at the time,this young man’s comments took Linda aback. For probably the first time in her adult life she felt the potential of her mature feminine sexuality, not just as a means of reproduction, but as a vehicle of pleasure, excitement and satisfaction. A long-time friend had been badgering Linda to join her and her friends for Friday nights out.After this incident Linda agreed. At first I’d just sit in the bar, having a drink and a laugh with the girls, but occasionally you’d see men looking at you and you’d think, oh, he’s nice, so you’d smile back. That’s how it started. I didn’t go with lots of men, just the occasional man, now and again. But I always kept it totally on my terms, there was never any danger of me getting too emotionally involved with anyone. I was looking for uncomplicated sex. After a while it becomes so easy. Maybe you give something off when you’re looking for sex. I’ve often wondered about that!
I asked Linda how she felt about herself after embarking on these sexual adventures. 98
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 99
New Women, Different Women It’s been quite amazing really. My whole outlook on life has completely changed. I suddenly realised that I wasn’t just a mum, I was my own person. I suppose I realised I could do it. It’s fun! What’s more, I’ve discovered I can separate sex from intimacy.Women aren’t supposed to be able to do that.
Did she see herself as very different from other women, especially her mother? I’m not sure I’m that different from other married women of my age, many of my married girlfriends have men they see on the side. But I am completely different from my mother! I can distinctly recall, when I was about ten, this man chatting my mother up. I was with her at the time. He suggested they went swimming together. She was absolutely horrified! As soon as she got home she told my dad about this man who’d had the effrontery to do this. I remember feeling vaguely unsettled by the whole thing.
Have all her encounters with men been somewhat emotionally distant? No, not all. In fact, I’ve now got a regular boyfriend who’s also married,but in a very sexless relationship.We see each other probably once a week. I’m very close to him. He’s very special. I love our time together.At first he found the sex a little difficult, not having been used to being with someone who enjoyed the physical side of life as I do. But now he’s very active! The sex is lovely, though sometimes it’s nice just to lie together and cuddle. He texts me every
99
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 100
Men,Women, Love and Romance night, to tell me he loves me, which is really great … Once a month we treat ourselves to a day in a good hotel, and just spend it in bed together. It’s like having a secret world that nobody else can mess around with. I’d really miss it if it wasn’t there. It’s quite addictive you know.
I asked Linda how men coped with her being such a free spirit, sexually and emotionally. Not very well many of them! They seem to expect me to be more demanding of them, you know, wanting to see them all the time, and I don’t. As far as I’m concerned that’s it. Or they expect to have some rights over me. No chance! I have control of the situation. I don’t want anything else from them … Men are having a tougher time of it these days. I think a lot of them are flummoxed by women like me! You know, when we look at them the way they’ve been used to looking at women. Many blokes still think it’s down to them to make the first move. Not any more it isn’t.
pam Pam is aged 45. She is divorced, with two children in their late teens, and runs her own secretarial supply agency. She was married for ten years and then, in her mid-thirties, she met Steve who she subsequently moved in with.They lived together for seven years but it proved to be a turbulent relationship. When I interviewed her she had been living on her own, with her two children, for about ten months. I knew within a couple of years of living with Steve that I needed to get out of the relationship but it wasn’t that
100
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 101
New Women, Different Women easy. I’d left my husband for him and I didn’t want the emotional and physical upheaval of moving yet again, not when I had my two kids to consider. Steve has a good job and with my income we lived well. We had a beautiful house and money was not a problem.The problem was I didn’t love him, though he doted on me. He was very emotionally dependent on me. In fact, although he was ten years older than me, he was really very immature. I suppose you’d call him an emotional retard, and that’s not putting it too strong, believe me!
As their relationship deteriorated, so Steve resorted to emotional blackmail in order to keep Pam with him.This included threatening suicide, to the point that he actually harmed himself on several occasions. His heavy drinking got worse – it tended to be his response to the increasing number of rows he and Pam were having. I begged him to get help, see a counsellor or someone, but he wouldn’t. He was just in total denial about the state of our relationship. I did feel a sense of responsibility but what can you do if your partner is completely emotionally incompetent and unable to see how damaging his behaviour is? At times it was like living with three kids – and me the only adult in the house!
Despite the pressures, Pam remained faithful to Steve until the very end of the relationship, when she had a brief holiday romance. We were on holiday in Bermuda, and I was learning to dive, which I love.The diving instructor was a real hunk,
101
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 102
Men,Women, Love and Romance but I never gave him any more thought until one of the other women divers, who I’d befriended, said to me, ‘Tony [the instructor] really has the hots for you, you know that don’t you?’Well, to be honest, I didn’t, but then I thought, well, maybe she’s right. It just was so good to think that I might still be fanciable. I was in my forties and I’d begun to think that those days had gone for me! One evening I was sat outside on the beach and Tony walks past. He comes up, we start chatting and he says,‘So you are here on your own with the kids?’ I say,‘No, but I may as well be.’ He says,‘Where is he?’ I reply,‘Propping up the bar or asleep.’ Later that evening we go for a long walk.We made love in the surf. Fantastic.The rest of the fortnight was just wonderful, I can tell you.
Just six months after that holiday, Pam moved out with the children. She was aware it was probably not a good idea to rush into another relationship, so she settled into her new home saving her emotional energies for the aftermath of the split. Eventually, Steve stopped phoning her, threatening to kill himself, and Pam’s life began a new, more peaceful, cycle. I felt ready to move on. The fling with Tony certainly helped me, but I was unsure as to how I’d meet new men. I was too old for the night clubs, and in my job you don’t meet that many single blokes. So I decided to try an Internet friendship site, as some of my friends had done. I chose date.com, really because it was free to initially enrol on it! For the first week or so I just trawled the site, and then I took the plunge, got myself a proper profile, put a couple of photos of me on it and waited. The response
102
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 103
New Women, Different Women was amazing. I got hundreds of enquiries from men all over the world. Although a lot of them were complete no-hopers, there were some really interesting blokes out there.I started email relationships with a few and just took it from there. I was looking for an honest, open, steady relationship, but with a man who wouldn’t use me as an emotional prop. I had no intention of living with anyone, certainly not for a while.What I did want was some fun! Which I got. Quite a lot of it in fact.
(I kept in touch with Pam as the book was progressing. A couple of months after the interview she met someone through the website and had begun a steady relationship with him. However, she was very much enjoying her freedom as a forty-something player in the new gender game. As she put it, ‘getting out of my relationship with Steve was like being let out of a cage’.)
sarah Sarah is aged 47. She is married, with two teenage children, and works for a large publishing house. She and her husband Gordon have been married for 21 years. Sarah was 43 before she embarked on an affair – with Alan, a divorced man. Prior to this she’d never been unfaithful to her husband, in fact her only other sexual experience was with a boyfriend she had while at university. Sometimes, if you are really lucky, you meet someone very, very special.And I did. I wasn’t aware of looking for it. But it happened none the less.We met through work, though he doesn’t work with me, in fact he lives in the Midlands. We had cause to telephone each other over a
103
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 104
Men,Women, Love and Romance publishing matter, then exchanged some emails, and it just grew from there. It wasn’t simply about not loving Gordon, I do. And I often feel guilty because he’s a great husband and father, but Alan brings out another side of me, a very sexual side that had never really been present in my life. But equally important is the romance of it all. I love having his emails every day, his special words of love, which are just for me. Just knowing that he is in my life, and thinking of me, is enough. I know there can never be any more, because I won’t leave my family, but I don’t want to imagine what life would now be like without Alan in it.
Although Sarah had never contemplated being unfaithful before, she found that she was quite good at concealing it from her husband and her family.Apart from weekly telephone calls and emails at night,there was the mobile phone by which to keep in contact with her lover. Because of the physical distance between them, Sarah and Alan couldn’t meet up that often. Nevertheless, they were both able to arrange occasional business trips which meant nights away. Sometimes it seems like my whole life is suspended between these intermittent times when Alan and I are together. It’s a form of emotional torture, but it’s also exquisite and beautiful. Our few nights together, alone in each other’s arms,with no one else about,no telephones to interrupt,these have been some of the happiest times of my life.I will never forget them, no matter what happens in the future. I know I am putting my marriage at risk, but I am very careful.Gordon suspects nothing.Alan brings out a side of me which my family never see.When Gordon and I have
104
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 105
New Women, Different Women sex,usually on a Saturday night,it’s just sex.I very rarely have an orgasm.Sex with him feels like a duty almost.When Alan and I make love it’s like nothing I’ve ever experienced. But he’s not just my lover,he’s my best friend.
I asked Sarah how she copes with being away from Alan for weeks, sometimes months, at a time. We each have little things, non-descript things which no one would ever suspect were symbols of love, but which we have given to each other, as indicators of our love for each other.We carry these items around with us, or have them close to us when we’re at home or work. For example, very early on in our relationship we exchanged different coloured ribbons, red for me, blue for him. If ever we break up then the other must send their ribbon back.This is how we will say goodbye, if we ever do. But most of all there are the emails.These keep our love alive. His emails tend to be longer than mine, and I keep them all, saved away in an anonymous email address.When we email we don’t use our normal names. I call him my Celtic Warrior, I am his Saxon Queen.You see, we have this romantic idea that we met 1000 years ago, and our love has gone on and on all this time, with us occasionally meeting in future lives.
Did she ever think, when she was in her thirties and looking after young children, that an affair like this would happen to her? Never! I don’t think I ever went seeking it. My marriage was stable, I was in a good job, the children were growing
105
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 106
Men,Women, Love and Romance up fine. But then, there are other things in life beyond paying the mortgage. Maybe I reached a certain age and decided that this was my one chance for real happiness, fulfilment, before old age took over. My love for Alan is so strong it sometimes frightens me. I have never felt like this for my husband. It’s an obsession almost. But I can control it.
allison Allison is aged 41.She is a nurse and lives with her husband, Mike, and their two children aged 14 and 17.Allison’s story is a little different from those of the other women discussed here, not least because she is in a very settled and loving relationship and is not looking for sex and romance outside her marriage. However, Allison’s story does illustrate the power of the bedroom revolution and its capacity to bring about changes in women’s lives, not just romantic ones, but deep and lasting lifestyle shifts. Allison has a job-share and this gives her time both with her family and for herself. It is this freedom that she most relishes, especially now the children are growing up and becoming more independent. However, like most of the women I interviewed, Allison does feel very restless at times, though for her this does not manifest itself in a desire for a sexual relationship outside of marriage. Mike has only ever been the love of my life. Sure, we’ve had difficulties at times, but there has never been the sense that we would ever split up. He has his own business, and this is doing well, which is good because it’s enabled me to work just part-time. But for some years now I’ve had a real fear of being trapped in routine. I didn’t feel it so
106
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 107
New Women, Different Women much when the kids were younger, I guess because I was too busy being a mother and putting them first. But now they are older I have a strong desire to travel and experience new things. Over recent years I have tried to deal with this sense of restless by going on holiday with some of my women friends and doing very active things, especially in my leisure time.For example,I do rock-climbing, I’ve run half-marathons, I’ve walked across the Peruvian mountains, I’ve gone trekking in West Africa, and this summer I went on a sailing holiday to Majorca where I gained qualifications for sailing and navigation. But the sense of restlessness does persist and it’s got stronger recently.
I asked how Mike felt about her desire for adventure. How was their relationship coping? Surprisingly well, actually.We have a good sex life and we make sure we take time out together. For example, since the children were very young we’ve always had occasional weekends away together, just the two of us. It replenishes our batteries. I think this has given us a good foundation from which to ensure we can overcome any rocky times. He’s a very understanding man, and we’ve stayed in love with each other. I’ve never really desired any other man but Mike. When Mike was building up his business and the children were very young this was a hard time for us, but we got through. I suppose one of our philosophies has been to share responsibilities but to always respect the other person’s right to have a life outside of the marriage. That way we each keep a sense of freedom and independence, but without it damaging the fabric of the
107
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 108
Men,Women, Love and Romance relationship.So twice a week I get to do my rock-climbing at the local leisure centre, and go off to the Lakes for a climb with my friends when the chance arises. I also have one holiday a year by myself or with my women friends. It helps that I come from a large family, most of whom live fairly close by, so we always have baby-sitters on hand, and at short notice if there’s an emergency.
So given this good balance that you and Mike have managed to achieve, what makes you still feel restless? This is difficult for me to explain, but it’s been building up for some time, though I’ve only recently recognised it for what it is.The fact is I hate feeling trapped in routine, and I’ve started to feel trapped recently. It’s not the relationship, that’s fine, it’s that I have this strong sense of adventure, of the need to travel, and passing 40 was a watershed I think. I’ve started looking at Voluntary Service Overseas work, as a nurse. I’m particularly interested in going to South America, or to Australia and South East Asia.
But how will you manage to do this and be with your family? Well, the fact is I won’t! It will require me to be away for say six months at least, but if I don’t do it during my forties I’m afraid the chance will be lost.I have good qualifications so I can always get a job nursing when I return to the UK, and my qualifications and experience mean that I can get work overseas, more or less where I want. Obviously I am concerned that my children will be okay,
108
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 109
New Women, Different Women but I trust Mike and he wants me to do this. Some might say I was being selfish, but I don’t see it like that.This drive in me won’t go away and I must be true to myself.
So what are your plans? Well, I’m not sure exactly when this will happen, but hopefully within the next two years I will take six months out and work abroad, maybe nine months. Mike will stay at home and look after the children, though our eldest, Susan, will probably be at university by then so that will make it easier for him. In the end, I know I have the opportunity to do these things and I want to take it. I will be ever grateful to Mike for understanding and appreciating this need in me and I will encourage him to do his thing when he’s ready. On a practical level, I’ve kept myself fit and I’m very confident of being able to handle most situations that might arise while I was abroad. But if I went with an organisation like the VSO then I wouldn’t exactly be on my own anyway.
Your relationship seems a very modern and democratic one.Am I right? I suppose it is. But it just evolved during our 20 years of marriage, we didn’t sit down and discuss it at the outset. Anyway, we were both very young when we married and when the children came along we had other priorities over and above our own needs. But I do appreciate what I have in this relationship.Without Mike to support me it would be virtually impossible for me to do the things I want to, or to have experienced those things I already
109
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 110
Men,Women, Love and Romance have. It’s a question of mutual respect and accommodation.That’s the basis of our marriage and hopefully it will continue.
bridget Bridget is aged 53.She is a university librarian and lives with her 19-year-old daughter. From the time she studied at university in the late 1960s, Bridget has always seen herself as very liberal minded and with a young outlook on life. She lost her virginity at 17, since when she estimates she’s had around 50 sexual partners.When she was 18 and at university, Bridget formed a very close relationship with an older man, a Jordanian. This relationship lasted throughout the time she was at university and was one of the loves of her life. When aged 26, Bridget married Ron, a teacher. The marriage lasted for over 20 years. However, after several years of matrimonial life Bridget started to feel restless. I started being occasionally unfaithful when I was in my mid-thirties. I liked the stability that marriage gave me, but I didn’t like the routine. Maybe I’ve got a low boredom threshold, but I didn’t find marriage to Ron very stimulating. He was, is, an intelligent man, and we connected that way, but not physically.With Ron sex was very predictable – always in the dark, certain areas you never touched, no licking or anything that he thought was ‘unclean’ sexually. In fact, the sex was never very good. It got to the point where we were having it just a few times a year. Pretty bad really! And always I had to initiate it, which became tedious to say the least. He was a very repressed man. Basically, I was bored, sexually and emotionally. I didn’t have lots of lovers, just different
110
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 111
New Women, Different Women people,with long gaps between them.It was opportunism really, when the right man and the right moment coincided, it happened.
When she was 45, Bridget and Ron got divorced, he citing her adultery. So began a period of sexual experimentation, occasional emotional connections, some intense relationships and some casual sexual encounters. How does she feel about this change in her lifestyle? It has not always been easy, but it’s not been boring! After my marriage ended I went to live with a man, someone I’d been having a relationship with, but it was a disaster. He was the complete opposite of my ex-husband as far as sex was concerned,and that was good,but once I started living with him I found out he was a real control freak and I couldn’t handle that at all. I left after ten weeks. I’ve been on my own ever since.This was the low point of all time. Horrendous. I felt quite alone. I was really quite depressed by it, but eventually I got over it … It took me a long time to get used to being on my own. I’d never been on my own really. But after a while I started to find my feet and I got control back over my life. It’s been a long, sometimes difficult, but fascinating journey. Fortunately, I’ve always been able to work and be financially independent.
I asked Bridget what it felt like to be a sexually active woman in her early fifties, at this point in the twenty-first century. Sometimes it’s okay and sometimes it’s bloody hard work! I suppose it depends on what sort of day I’m having! I’ve
111
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 112
Men,Women, Love and Romance never been naïve, and that’s helped. I sometimes think I was born with a cynical outlook on life, so I don’t have too high expectations. But I won’t allow myself to be messed about by men. The problem is there aren’t that many interesting men out there. A lot of them are Neanderthals, emotionally stunted. So as a woman you have to be careful about the sort of compromises, if any, that you’re prepared to make. I like men’s company, and I like sex (I’ve never been into women), but you want more than that. There are attractions to being in an exclusive relationship, but I need to be with a man who is intelligent and interesting. I haven’t got the patience to sit through small talk that doesn’t excite me. I start making excuses about having to go!
How and where do you meet men? I’ve met quite a few men through newspaper lonely hearts columns, and occasionally at work. I usually go for professional men, academics, doctors, that sort of thing.At least they tend to be interesting to talk to. The point of some of these relationships is not necessarily sex, with some the stimulation I receive is as much intellectual. So what’s happened over the past few years is that I don’t have any one man, I tend to have several on the go at any one time, some platonic relationships, some sexual. Some of the men live near to me, a few are in other parts of the country.They come to visit me, or I them. I have found this works best. So I don’t have a regular partner, but a number of different men that I see at various times. It’s not always ideal, but it’s certainly better than being in a boring marriage. I have choice and I have control and I’ve
112
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 113
New Women, Different Women come to a time in my life when these are more important. As far as monogamy is concerned then I could do that with the right man, but I think women increasingly want monogamy when they’re having children, but they’re less keen as they get older, certainly if they’re in a boring, unstimulating relationship. For me, the idea of eventually settling down with just one man still has some appeal. I don’t fancy going into old age living alone.
I asked Bridget what her parents thought of her changed lifestyle? My father died when I was a teenager, and I miss him terribly. Unfortunately, I’ve never had a close relationship with my mother. She has a much more dated view of marriage. She thinks that once you’ve made your marriage bed you should lie in it, come what may. I don’t. But then, I do understand where she’s coming from. Women, especially those of my mother’s generation, got used to having their identities and opportunities stifled by men.That’s changing. I’ve not allowed that to happen to me. liz
Liz is aged 63. She has had three marriages: the first when she was in her twenties, the second in her mid-thirties, and the third when she was aged between 44 and 55. She has one son, aged 29.Although she retired three years ago, Liz keeps herself very fit and active. She has a wide circle of friends and is an enthusiastic member of her local operatic society. She admits to having been stage-struck most of her life. I asked her about her current love life. 113
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 114
Men,Women, Love and Romance Well, there’s my long-time friend, Graham, he’s in his late sixties and I see him most weeks. He’s married but there’s nothing there if you know what I mean. He always brings me flowers or chocolates (bad for my figure!) and takes me out for a drink or a meal. Sometimes he just wants a cuddle, it’s his age you know! But he stops over quite regularly.We’ve known each other for a number of years now and it’s nice, but he knows I see other men sometimes.
I asked Liz who else she’s been seeing recently. Two other men, who I met through an introduction agency. And then back last autumn there was Rick. Sexy Rick! Liked him very much, though I don’t see him so often now. I’d not used an introduction agency before, it wasn’t cheap, but one of my friends recommended it, so I gave it a try. They arranged several dates for me, mainly with older men, but at least the men were well turned out. Quite well off some of them. What happened was they’d invite me out for dinner and we’d take it from there. I met Michael and Roy that way and I still see them occasionally. I cannot settle with just one man, I need the variety! I think I wear them out! Michael’s divorced, has been for years, and Roy is a widower. They’re both lovely men,you know,thoughtful and all that.I avoid men who are looking for someone to take care of them, that can be a problem with men in their late sixties, early seventies, who have always had a wife to hand and who suddenly find themselves living on their own for the first time in their lives. I don’t see myself as an unpaid carer to some pensioner! I need to be able to come and go in my own home.
114
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 115
New Women, Different Women What attracts you to a man? He has to be clean and well-dressed. I hate scruffy men, especially older men who’ve gone to pot a bit. I look after myself and I expect them to. I also like men to spoil me a little. Send me flowers, remember my birthday. Roy is good that way. Whenever he comes round to my place he’ll bring wine and flowers. I have to find a man sexually attractive.There has to be something about them that gets my juices flowing. I used to be a real goer in my youth [laugh] and I’ve only got worse, or better(!), as I’ve got older.A lot of older men can’t keep up with me, which is why Rick was so special.
How did you meet Rick? Well, it’s a bit naughty really. I’d had to get a firm of builders in to do some work on my house and Rick came along to do it. He was here for about a week. A very fit man as they say! But the problem was he is only in his early forties, so I didn’t think I had any chance with him. Just to see him with his sleeves rolled up, perspiring, really got me going, I can tell you! Also, he was married. Throughout the week I’d tried to give off the right signals without being pushy, but I didn’t think I was getting anywhere.You know, bringing him cups of tea, but dressed in something that flattered my figure, a lot of eye contact. Nothing too obvious or provocative – a lady has to have some dignity you know! Anyway, towards the end of the week he was looking particularly down and I asked him what the matter was. He didn’t want to say at first but eventually, after sitting down in my lounge with a coffee,
115
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 116
Men,Women, Love and Romance he opened up. Basically, it was the usual thing, wife at home, busy looking after children and no time for him. They’d not had sex together for a couple of months.We talked for over an hour and, having had three marriages myself, I’d had some experience of these situations, which he seemed to appreciate. He finished the work that week and that was it. But then, a few days later, he turned up one evening, out of the blue, just to say thank you for listening to him and with a large bunch of flowers for me! Naturally I was delighted to see him. I invited him in for a coffee but as I remember we only got as far as the doorway to the lounge and he had me up against the wall, kissing me very passionately.There was a lot of pent-up passion there, for both of us! We had sex in the hallway, and then later in my bedroom, a more lingering session. It was so good. I’ll never forget the image of him lying on my bed,naked,after us having sex.Me thinking, my God, it’s all my birthdays rolled into one! He was like a vision from heaven. Beautiful, fit, lean body. I was in my element, I can tell you.
How did the relationship with Rick progress? We continued to see each other on and off for about three months. I had to be careful because I started to get quite attached to him. He was spoiling me for other men – being younger, fitter, and better in bed than most of the men I was seeing. But I was realistic. I knew it wouldn’t last, it was just a case of making the most of it.As you get older you learn to take the opportunities as and when they arise. I still keep in touch with him, and he rings me now and again. I’ve invited him to my next show, in
116
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 117
New Women, Different Women which I have a starring part! I hope he’s able to come. My girlfriends would be so envious if they saw us together.
What women really want We certainly live in changing times, especially around sex and gender relationships. It is no surprise that some men, especially those who are confused and traditional, see women as being unsure as to what they want given the range of choices now available to them. In fact, some suggest that having all these choices is in itself a bad thing for women. For example, one prominent male academic has recently claimed that women have been ‘miseducated’ into believing they could ‘have it all’. Some believe that what women really want is to be ‘submissive’ and to ‘surrender’ into the arms of a man who will protect them and care for them. It has been said that all thirty-something single women really are like Bridget Jones – confused, anxious, lonely and desperate. I think not. Anyone who really understands the New Woman knows that none of these assumptions or stereotypes are true, and nor are they desirable as aspirations. New Women are the stronger species. Not only are they now doing it for themselves, they’re succeeding. Sure, one can understand why some may see women as being torn between a) a biological clock that tells them they should have children, preferably in a committed relationship, and b) a desire to make their own way in the world, financially and emotionally independent of any man. But the women I meet, those I have loved, those who are my friends and colleagues, those I interviewed and who revealed so much of themselves and their lives for this research, these 117
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 118
Men,Women, Love and Romance women are not confused. They may find having so many choices sometimes difficult.They may not always strike the right balance between love,work and family.Their male soulmate may take some time to show himself among the population of males.And they can get extremely frustrated at the emotional immaturity of men and men’s propensity to go into denial when faced with relationship difficulties.But they know what they want and what they need in their lives.Sure, they have to make compromises at times.Yes,they sometimes have to make accommodations with men that they’d rather not have to. And certainly those who are mothers do have very strong feelings of putting their children first. But it is men,not women,who are confused. From my experience and research, the prime movers in this new gender game are not women in their twenties, though they will be beneficiaries. It is women aged 40 and over, the ones rejecting stereotypes of age and sexuality. These women are neither nostalgic for what was, nor too regretful for what might have been. For they are looking to a future which offers them new possibilities and opportunities for life and love.Women such as Linda, Pam, Sarah, Allison, Bridget and Liz are part of a new, and powerful, sexy generation. Although very different, they exemplify what it means to be a New Woman.The over forties may have a career, but they likely established it while in their thirties. They may well be going through a divorce or separation, but they’ll come out of it okay, for they have the skill to network with other women, and to stand on their own two feet. They may well have children, but these children are usually older, more independent. As FFOKS, these women have that unique combination which those in their twenties and thirties don’t yet have – youth and 118
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 119
New Women, Different Women experience. They wear the t-shirt and it says ‘been there, done that, now let’s get on with life’. When we are in love age means nothing, the years fall off us to reveal our inner youth.Whatever our age, we are teenagers. The dream of modern woman was to find her place beyond the confines of the matrimonial bedroom or the kitchen, to discover the thrill of love,romance and adventure,to experience heart-stopping sexual passion,to be a free,independent spirit. This dream is now an expectation for increasing numbers of women of all ages, classes and cultures. New Woman can love with honesty and commitment just like women always have, but she is also strong enough to walk away when that honesty disappears, when trust gets broken, or, quite simply, when the passion, and orgasms, dry up. But there is one dream that still eludes countless women. It is the dream of being in a loving, committed relationship with a man who is not threatened by the fact that she is every bit, if not more, his equal: a man who appreciates that in order for her to live her dream she may well need to strike out on her own journey. Such a man will be strong enough in his masculinity to be caring, compassionate, thoughtful, emotional, and yet still be very, very sexy. Some women,many women even,may have such democratic love and passion in their lives, but I also know from my research that many do not.As one woman said to me: So far as love with an emotionally sorted man is concerned, I’ve learnt to travel in hope rather than in expectation. 119
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 120
Men,Women, Love and Romance
Tips for women riding the romantic roller-coaster As a woman, are you on the ride of love or merely intrigued by it? Are you about to take the plunge and join the bedroom revolution or are you still hesitant about what all this might mean for you? Well, whether you are up there riding high, or about to step on, here are twelve tips to help you get the most out of the experience. 1. the re lationship coach
Before you plunge into the game of love, try and ensure you have a very close woman friend to hand,someone who might act as a sort of ‘relationship coach’ to you. I know one 35-year-old woman who has this support and she’s found it to be invaluable in helping her decide her moves in the gender game. She just talks to her friend, usually informally over a coffee, and tells them what’s going on in her love life, and what she’s thinking of doing next. The relationship coach might offer direct advice, or might sometimes just be a sounding board, someone who listens rather than advises. Your relationship coach should be someone who knows you very well and with whom you can share those little intimate secrets without it becoming risky for either of you. So obviously there needs to be mutual respect and a lot of trust between you. 2. don ’t be too cynical !
Although it might be tempting, don’t assume all men are either bastards or Neanderthals! As one woman said to me, ‘Are there any normal males who aren’t complete geeks, or should I just take up knitting for the over forties?!’ Let me assure you there are plenty of ‘normal males’ out there, just 120
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 121
New Women, Different Women don’t expect them to come knocking on your kitchen door (well, they might!), instead you have to go out and find them.This book will show you some of the ways to finding love and romance, but there are many others, and each of us has their own unique life journey to follow as well as particular preferences for finding love. But if you start the journey cynical of men, then it’s probably going to end in tears.
3.
settling for frie ndship
Don’t go into every new encounter with a man expecting that this is going to be ‘the big one’.Chances are it isn’t.But just because you’re not planning the next 50 years together doesn’t mean the experience is wasted – far from it. Recognise that many ended relationships still have the potential to go on to become strong lasting friendships, something we all need in our lives (see tip 11, below). So if you both get on well, but it’s unlikely to lead to long passionate nights in Venice or setting up home together, then settle for being good friends. It works. Many of the women interviewed for this book have retained long-lasting friendships with men, sometimes with occasional sex thrown in, long after the initial encounter. 4. about being hone st
Remember, honesty is a good policy but sometimes it can be hurtful and destructive. Sure, if you are single and dating then it is best to be honest about whether you are seeing more than one person. But if you are in a relationship, married perhaps, and you begin an illicit relationship with a man,then you know you have to keep it secret otherwise the consequences will be very damaging for everybody. But can 121
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 122
Men,Women, Love and Romance you keep such a secret from your partner, not just for a week or two but maybe for months, even years? If you think you can’t, or if you don’t want to be put in that position, then don’t go down that road in the first place.However,from my own experience, and that of many of the women interviewed, there can come a time when one realises a relationship isn’t right and it must end. In this case you have to accept it and be prepared to move on. In the final analysis, the person you should be most honest with is yourself.
5.
the log istics of re lationships
How sorted is your life? Do you have the time and energy to give to a full-blooded relationship? This is something to really think about before you start playing the gender game. Many of the women I interviewed, especially those in their thirties and early forties, have children to look after as well as homes to manage and full-time jobs.That is a lot of commitment and responsibility! If you’re too busy with other things in your life,say looking after children or building a career, then play the gender game for fun and thrills, not lasting love. If you are already in a relationship then there is the added problem of managing the emotional turmoil and free-time restrictions. Whatever your situation, it’s a good idea to think about the actual time you can give to a relationship before you embark on one.What are the childcare arrangements like with your ex? Do you have weekends free or the occasional evening? Can you get a babysitter on a fairly regular basis? What about your own leisure activities – salsa dancing, yoga, exercise classes – which of these would you be prepared to sacrifice for love, and which would you not? Finally,once you reach a certain stage in your life, probably around the late thirties, it’s likely 122
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 123
New Women, Different Women that most of the men you meet will also have some level of childcare commitment to attend to, so weekends can get pretty crowded for everybody!
6 . beware the holiday syndrome Once you’ve started a relationship it’s natural to want to spend more time with your lover and the most obvious way of doing this is by going on holiday. Family, friends, work and, not least, children, get left behind for a few days and off you go to that romantic island in the sun.Well, fine. But be aware that such occasions can be very fraught. A lot of budding love affairs come to grief in the sun.Travel is stressful at the best of times, and throw in heightened expectations, not a few nerves, and the inevitable bottles of Chianti, and you can see you have a potent mix. New lovers are more likely to suffer here than those who are in longstanding relationships, because they are still learning about each other and so are more likely to experience disappointment. And another tip: never take your lover to places that trigger nostalgic memories in you of other men, other romances. It is far better for you both to go somewhere new – that way whatever happens it will always be your memories, your experience and no one else will intrude.
7. don’t give up Perseverance is one quality you’ll need to play the gender game. It won’t always go swimmingly for you.You’ll meet men who leave you wondering if they are all ‘complete geeks’,and at times you’ll reflect on whether it’s all worth it.It is.The advantage of age is that it brings experience; it makes us more confident and sure of who we are and what we want and don’t want.The disadvantage is that the more experiences 123
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 124
Men,Women, Love and Romance we have the more likely we are to have been hurt.And let’s face it, only a masochist keeps going back for more hurt! But you can mitigate any bruising to your heart by picking yourself up, dusting down your ego, believing in your inner (and outer) beauty, and going back on the ride. It’s a bit like horse riding.You get thrown a few times,but you keep getting back on otherwise you’ll never get back on again. 8. be pre pare d for change
Whatever your experiences of sex, love and romance, you can always learn something new. In fact, isn’t that what life is about – learning from experience? But as we learn so we change, and so do those we love. Go with the flow of change in your life, especially the changes that come with new relationships and loves. When two people meet and fall in love a third party comes into the frame – the relationship itself.We are likely to be a slightly different person with different people. One lover will bring out certain behaviours and traits in us, with another lover we’ll be subtly different again. And the relationship is undergoing constant change itself.So enjoy the variety! That’s the point about the romantic roller-coaster – it should never be boring nor predictable! 9. heart, head and instinct
Every so often a situation will arise in your life concerning love and sex that will require a quick decision. Do I have a fling with my scuba diving instructor? Do I respond to that personal ad? Do I reply to that flirtatious email sent by the hunk in personnel? No one can give you the right answer here – not even your relationship coach! But what you have to weigh up is whether you’re going to let your heart 124
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 125
New Women, Different Women or your head have sway. If it’s your head then you’ll be rational, planned, reasoned and logical.You’ll balance the pros and cons, you’ll assess the risks, plan a strategy, measure the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. Very impressive. However, by the time you do all this you’ll either be too knackered to be bothered or completely confused! On the other hand, if you let your heart have its way then all you’ll be concerning yourself with is date, time and place! My own way through this conundrum has been to believe that there are larger influences around us that we cannot weigh up and measure, but which are nevertheless potent and powerful. So there are times you have to go with your instinct – and instinct is neither heart nor head. It is a little bit of each. Get in touch with your instinct and let it decide. It will usually be the right answer. 10. no illusions, no holy g rail
Whatever may be going on for you emotionally, it’s important to try to keep your feet firmly on the ground when you’re playing the gender game. Illusions may be comforting, but they also can be very dangerous. Let me give you an example. One woman I interviewed had a friend, in her early twenties, who got totally obsessed with a man. This woman told her friends that she and this man were going to marry, buy a house, and have children. She talked about her wedding plans. She even went so far as to say what their children would look like, whether they’d be a boy or a girl, and what they’d be called. She was convinced that this man loved her, and that they were going to live an idyllic life, happy ever after. However, this man had little interest in her.They did have three or four dates, but the ‘relationship’ was over in less than a month.Admittedly,this is an extreme 125
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 126
Men,Women, Love and Romance example of illusion getting confused with reality. But we’ve all done it at some point in a relationship. That is, we’ve stopped seeing what’s really going on – or chosen not to! This is not a stance to be recommended, as reality will out in the end. So remember, don’t go looking for the Holy Grail of a relationship, it doesn’t exist. 11. clo sing and continuing
Let’s face it, sooner or later most couples break up. It’s a fact of life. No point pretending otherwise. How many people do you know who’ve only had one relationship in their life and it’s still going strong years later? Not many. But breaking up need not be all bad.There is a skill to it that is well worth cultivating. First, recognise that both parties have a position. Give each other the opportunity to voice your feelings about closing the relationship.This should not be done angrily or with recrimination, but should be undertaken with mutual respect. If you can’t do it face to face, use email or a letter.Whatever way suits you, it’s really important to get your inner feelings out, and writing them down, even if you never send the email,really helps.While writing this book a relationship of mine came to an end.The relationship had been going for just six months when we came to recognise that the underlying difficulties in it were not going to be resolved.We needed to make a break. Closure didn’t happen overnight, it took at least six weeks, during which time we went away, came back, went away. In the end we agreed on a month-long split during which we sought to resolve our feelings. I guess we had a certain emotional dependency on each other which we needed to wean ourselves off.We communicated during this time but never met. At the end of the month we sent each other a 126
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 127
New Women, Different Women long email, telling of our feelings for each other but why we felt we had to move on. For us, like many couples in this situation, staying friends was really important.That was our aim, that was our closure. It worked for us. Unless you feel angry and bitter about the relationship try to part with an au revoir, not a goodbye. 12. no failure s, only expe rie nce s
Relationships finish, people move on. But try not to see ended relationships as failures.Most relationships have a life span of their own and trying to artificially extend this life is not only going to be terribly hard work, it’s going to be emotionally draining for both of you. So know when to let it go, recognise when the time is right to move on. I always get slightly irritated when people talk of ‘failed marriages’, failed relationships. Is a ‘successful’ marriage or partnership one that lasts a lifetime? I don’t think so. It is one where both parties feel equal, loved and delight in expressing that love to each other. If these feelings last a lifetime fine, but people change and love changes also.This is something we cannot stop and nor should we try to – that way lies oppression of ourselves and others. Instead, recognise that divorce or separation can be the closure on a successful marriage or partnership. It can signal the ending of a successful relationship, but one which changed as the couple did. Sure, learn from the experience, but in looking back on it be generous not only to your ex-lover, but, most importantly, to yourself. And, of course, men might find these tips useful as well.
127
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 128
chapte r iii
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract
Doing democratic love From the research undertaken for this book, and my own experiences of love, it is apparent to me that relationships today must be based on democratic love – that is if they are to survive and thrive.With democratic love both parties make a pledge to work together for the sake of the relationship while also recognising the unique individuality of the other. Individuality is key in the modern age, for, as discussed in the Introduction, we are each increasingly seeing our lives as a journey, one with exciting possibilities, many shifts and turns, but which we must pursue if we are to be true to ourselves. This means that long-term committed relationships become a real balancing act. They require not only a high degree of self-awareness by each party; they require us to balance our desire for freedom and choice with the selflessness that sustains a relationship. This paradox raises different issues for men and women. For men it requires them to put down outdated assumptions about masculinity, femininity and women’s roles both at home and work. It requires them to adopt a more modern form of masculinity, one which exhibits sensitivity 128
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 129
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract and affection, but also, importantly, recognises women to be equal to men in every respect. For women, it requires them to be brave and take on the opportunities now afforded them in this new age. It requires them to balance more traditional notions of femininity (eg being a ‘good mother’) with the modern femininity now being expressed by women such as those described in this book. From research being undertaken in almost every society, not just in the West, it is clear that there is now a massive desire on the part of women for democratic rights both at home and at work. The extent and depth of this burgeoning revolution has become clear to me from my own travels abroad. In the past eighteen months I’ve travelled extensively in South East Asia and spoken to men and women from different countries about how they feel about their relationships. I’ve seen the same trends whether it be in China, Singapore, Thailand or Malaysia. That is, women, especially educated women, are less inclined to settle for a relationship that puts them at the periphery. They are now much more likely to go into a relationship expecting to share every aspect with their partner. In terms of traditional Asian cultures this signals the beginning of a profound and far-reaching revolution in gender attitudes and expectations. Not surprisingly, many men still find this reality difficult to grasp. But there can be no turning back from democratic love – it has a momentum of its own. During my research I came across several couples who appear to have established a condition of democratic love in their relationships. One such couple is Valerie, 38, and Brian, 42.They have been married for eight years and have a son, aged seven.Valerie tells their story: 129
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 130
Men,Women, Love and Romance
valerie Can you tell me about the time before you met Brian? For a long time in my twenties I didn’t see any man. I felt pretty asexual actually. I’d had a relationship in my late teens that went on for about eight years. He was a much older man and at times I found it quite difficult to be who I was. So I guess when that ended I wanted time out of a relationship – to find myself again.When I felt ready, that is confident to be able to withstand the ups and downs of a relationship, I responded to a personal ad in a national newspaper and it was Brian. He was living on his own, divorced, and having quite a good time as a single bloke. We formed a relationship and it’s gone on from there.
What makes the relationship with Brian so special? There are no secrets between us. He knows everything about me, about my past, my weaknesses and my little idiosyncrasies. He’s my best friend as well as my lover.There is real humour and fun in our relationship.We share every intimacy.There’s a lot of tenderness and kindness between us.
Can you give me some examples? He is a very loving and caring guy.With Brian, romance is usually unexpected. For example he bought me this ring completely out of the blue. Or he’ll do really totally meaningless, everyday things that are so loving. Like last year, at a time I was feeling very low and miserable, he would email me at work. He knows I love puppies and he’d send me emails with loads and loads of pictures of
130
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 131
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract puppies on them with messages such as ‘don’t feel wough’! That’s so lovely. He’s a very tender man. He’ll stroke my hair if I’m feeling down, and say something like ‘it’ll be okay’. He’s also very patient and never judges me. If something or someone has upset me, and I’m dwelling on it a bit, he won’t say ‘pull yourself together woman’, we’ll just talk about it but without him losing patience with me. I think we all like to feel wanted and loved, and Brian has a way of doing that with me which is so natural.
How did you decide to get married? After we’d been going out for a while I warned him that if he ever asked me to marry him then I would leave him! So he never did. And I got a bit pissed off! I decided he was too nice to let go so I asked him to marry me!
What have you learnt from this relationship? I’ve come to love Brian more as we’ve been together. I’ve changed as a person.I’m a lot more patient and less selfish. Many other things that I didn’t like about relationships, like compromise, listening to someone, putting someone else first, I’ve found I can do. I suspect I was very selfish before Brian. I like myself better now. I’ve really learned to love him, and in a much, much deeper way.
What about your sex life? To be honest, sex is not so important for me. I’ve gone for long periods without having sex. For me to have sex it must be with someone I love, not just any man. I know
131
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 132
Men,Women, Love and Romance some people can sleep around, but I can’t. I’d rather not have sex than to go with someone who means nothing to me.With Brian our sex life has got better the longer we’ve been together.At first I found the sex a little difficult, as it brought back very bad memories of my first relationship when I was with a very controlling man who played mind games with me. Now there is a lot of passion in our relationship, and it is immensely satisfying. For me, I must be comfortable, sexually, in the relationship, otherwise too many inhibitions creep in and it starts to affect the intimacies between you and your partner.
As Valerie’s account reveals, couples cannot expect to just walk into democratic love without first being prepared to accommodate and compromise. Valerie and Brian both have their own individual lives, histories, and expectations, and like all couples they’ve found that the real skill is in making these differences work for the relationship rather than allowing them to pull the relationship apart. It takes two to do democratic love. In talking to women for this book it became clear to me that one of the drivers behind democratic love, and women’s changing attitudes, is sexuality. For most couples, sex is the glue that holds it all together. Indeed, for many, the search for romance is also the search for perfect sex – the ultimate orgasm, the heart-stopping, exquisite union of emotions and bodies. In this respect sex and romance have their own self-sustaining synergy.They are also alike in that they can be extremely addictive, compelling and mostly irresistible. Yet, as is discussed in the next chapter, sex is increasingly losing any mystery it once had, becoming instead the most successful commercial enterprise of the 132
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 133
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract Internet age. But does this mean we have to give up on intimate, free, loving and emotional attachments? Is sex simply another bodily activity we undertake when the need takes us? Does the avid and relentless commercialisation of sex indicate a loss of intimacy between individuals? In this chapter I suggest that the dismantling of sexual mystery is not necessarily problematic for relationships. On the contrary, it signals that we are capable of being more honest and open about our desires and needs: relationships founded not on mystery and tradition, but on open, often explicit, new sexual contracts between couples.
Old and new sexual contracts All contracts are based on a power balance and this rule applies no less to sexual contracts.The old sexual contract reflected a fundamental power imbalance between men and women. Its starting point was the belief, firstly, that men owned women. But it was also implicit that men want sex more than women. It rested on the idea that men were wracked by insatiable sexual urges, and women had to become skilled in dealing with and accommodating these powerful desires or else fall prey to them. This notion enabled women to withhold sexual favours,if they chose to do so, which gave them some leverage in their relationships – and many did this in order to have some control or even improve their lives.There was an exchange in the old contract.Women said, mostly, I want to be engaged, married, have children, commitment, love and to be protected. Men took on these roles and responsibilities in exchange for regular sex, meals and clean clothes. But although it worked in a fashion, the old sexual contract put women in 133
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 134
Men,Women, Love and Romance the position of giving or granting sexual favours in exchange for other services: a form of marital prostitution. It also assumed women to be sexually passive. In fact, it put women themselves in the position of denying that they needed and wanted sexual pleasure. The new sexual contract is quite different. Its starting point is not differences between the sexes in terms of sexual needs and desire, but the recognition that women like sex just as much as men. It accepts the fact that women’s libidos are as strong if not stronger than most men’s and acknowledges that women have almost identical expectations of sexual satisfaction to men. Now women go into a relationship expecting if not demanding that their sexual needs be met, and certainly not expecting to grant them as a favour. Many may well still be looking for the long-term commitment that their mothers and grandmothers sought, but now they also expect that the man will service their sexual needs as well as their emotional ones.What is more,New Woman is much more ruthless at playing the new gender game than her predecessors; social and sexual confidence enables her to cut to the chase in a way that many men find quite disconcerting.As recent UK research reveals, there is a ‘new-found steel’ in women’s attitudes: Ambitious ‘Noughties woman’ is sassy, smart and sharp. She has little desire to uphold old-fashioned values and doesn’t care who she shocks. Today our expectations around sexual satisfaction are much higher than previous generations. Sex is not only important in terms of pleasure, it increasingly defines who we are and how we see the world.Without sexual pleasure life can seem 134
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 135
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract dull and mundane.When sex goes out of a relationship so too, usually, does love and romance – to be quickly followed by one or other of the partners in the relationship. ‘Dissatisfaction with my sexual life’ is one of the main reasons given by women for separation and divorce. The sexual contracts that define democratic love are not fixed for the duration of a relationship, but constantly reworked as individuals change. Only in this way can love and romance be sustained, for in the new gender game the sexual needs and desires of individuals are under constant revision, as are the relationships they are in. As a consequence, sexuality is now political in a way it was never understood to be by previous generations. As newspaper columnist Susan Maushart puts it: Who does what in bed – and how often – has become as fraught an issue as the housework. Welcome to the politics of intimacy.
Sexual myths and how women are dismantling them How and why has the new sexual contract emerged? Well, the possibilities for its emergence began with the dismantling of sexual myths during the second half of the twentieth century. The myths were powerful and potent, and had long influenced the minds of numerous generations of men and women.They went something like this: • Men have stronger sexual urges than women. • Women are programmed to want children and 135
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 136
Men,Women, Love and Romance everything they do sexually is geared towards this aim. • Sex in marriage is a duty women should perform (NB ‘wife rape’ was legal in the UK until 1991). • Women are not naturally promiscuous, unless, that is, they are ‘sluts’. • Men cannot do monogamy, it is not in their ‘nature’. • Both women and men become less sexually active as they get older. • Women go off sex after having children. • Men go sexually off their wives after they’ve given birth. Yet despite the fact they limit our horizons, myths do have a certain comfort in them. They give us a set of rules and expectations around how we should behave. By providing some structure to our lives they become social codes that go largely unchallenged and are replicated in countless lives. Sexual myths are especially effective in this way. But if you believe that your sexual desires are somehow dirty, then it’s hardly going to help you achieve orgasmic pleasure. If you see sex as a duty then you are hardly going to want to be sexually experimental. And if you think that all men are serial shaggers and cannot be trusted, then you can say goodbye to much chance of a long-lasting loving relationship. If you enjoy a certain sex act then indulge it, always remembering the golden rule of not behaving in an aggressive or coercive manner towards others while doing so. The sexual revolution of the new millennium is more liberating than that of the 1960s,simply because it is being driven by women and not by men.What we have here is a fundamental shift in how we approach sex and sexuality, an opening up of 136
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 137
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract any number of closets, not just one or two. In losing its mystery sex is acquiring an openness and frankness which can only be healthy for individuals and society as a whole.As recent research has revealed, countless numbers of women during the twentieth century never experienced truly satisfying orgasmic sex. Sexual pleasure was considered a need of the man, with the woman performing her marital duty.This was true of women from all social groups, though especially the middle and working classes. Now sexual pleasure is considered a fundamental part of any relationship,more than that even, it is becoming a leisure activity. As Dr Beverley Metcalfe,researcher into gender and identity,puts it: Sex is becoming just another recreational activity. There is evidence of an increase in multi-partner sex, group sex, threesomes. At this rate, by the end of this century we’ll all be swingers. Below are six women who illustrate all that is best about the bedroom revolution and the sexual and personal freedom it offers.The accounts of Jane,Carol, Linda,Diane, Janice and Sarah reveal how each, in her own way, is dismantling sexual myths. In my interviews with these women I asked each of them the same questions around sex and sexuality.These are their answers.
jane (33, engaged to be married.) How many lovers have you had? Not sure, over 50 definitely, but mainly one-night stands.
Have you ever had same-sex relationships? 137
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 138
Men,Women, Love and Romance Yes, several. I like a woman’s touch on my body. I know more and more women are trying bisexuality and finding it offers something extra in their sex lives. It’s not that they’re not having relationships with men, it’s like dessert rather than main course if you know what I mean.
Where did you meet your present lover (her fiancé)? Through an on-line dating agency. I’d gone out with loads of men who’d contacted me through the agency,but Brad and I hit it off immediately.
How liberal are you in sexual matters? Very. For example, while I won’t be unfaithful to Brad with a man, I do occasionally have a woman friend of mine over for the night. She and I have been occasional lovers for a number of years and I don’t see any reason to give her up. Brad knows about her, in fact we’ve been thinking of maybe having a threesome.
Have you ever had a threesome? Yes,a few times,and foursomes,with both men and women. Though not with Brad,though we’ve talked about it.
What has been your most erotic experience? Difficult. I think my most erotic experiences have been threesomes with a woman and a man. I remember one experience I had with two men who I met while on holiday some years ago. It was just a spontaneous thing,
138
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 139
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract nothing planned and that made it very erotic.The three of us were out walking one evening, on the beach, and we had sex. I like having sex outdoors and sex in a public place such as lifts or trains can be pretty erotic.
Is there any sexual activity you’ve not tried? Not many. I regularly use sex toys, both by myself and with partners. I’ve done the swinging scene, but found some of the clubs a bit seedy.You know, one woman and six men wanking off on her. I’m not into anal stuff. But I do like tying up, a bit of bondage can be fun.
How would you describe your sexual relationship with Brad? As open, really. There isn’t much we don’t discuss. He knows what I like, he knows what I need. Sometimes that means sexual penetration, other times it means playing adult games, but most of the time it means feeling close and intimate – touching, caressing, foreplay. He’s probably not as sexually adventurous as I am. He’s not had as many lovers as me, but he’s a good lover. I don’t feel I need anyone else. But when I do, I tell him.
What sort of sexual contract have you with Brad? I suppose it’s one where we both recognise we have sexual and physical needs, and they may not always coincide. It’s based on mutual trust, so if he wanted to go with someone else I’d rather he told me than keep it from me. I do the same with him.
139
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 140
Men,Women, Love and Romance
carol (41, married for 18 years. has a lover.) How many lovers have you had? Not many, about eight.
Have you ever had same-sex relationships? No.
Where did you meet your present lover? (Not her husband.) We met through work. It started out as an email relationship and grew from there.
How liberal are you in sexual matters? Much more so than I used to be. With my lover we’ve done most things and it’s been an education for me I guess.We’ve felt we could trust each other, and the sexual chemistry has been right for experimentation. I was ready for it after 18 something years of at times fairly mundane marriage.
Have you ever had a threesome? Yes, once. My lover and I went away to London for a few days and on one of the evenings we booked an escort to come to our hotel bedroom. She was very attractive and the three of us had an interesting hour! I must admit that I couldn’t get so excited with her being around and my
140
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 141
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract lover having sex with her as well as me. But it was something we tried and I’m not sure we’ll do it again.
What has been your most erotic experience? On one of our trips away, my lover and I had sex on a train. Not the most comfortable of places, but the threat of being discovered added to it a bit.To be erotic it doesn’t have to be physical. I can be highly aroused hours before meeting my lover,especially if we’ve been passing erotic emails back and forwards between us for a few weeks.Then when we do actually kiss and touch each other it’s like series of mini explosions in my pants! At the moment my most erotic experiences are when I meet my lover, preferably in a city hotel and we can spend the day together,in bed.It’s not just the actual being with him that is so good – it’s the waiting, building up the tension,sometimes over several days,before we can actually meet.That is quite erotic.We do this about once a month and it’s the highlight of my life.
Is there any sexual activity you’ve not tried? With my husband, many! With my lover, very few! I’ve found I like being tied up, gently, and spanked, not so gently! That can be very arousing.Sometimes we use a sex toy in those situations, a vibrator.We’ve tried anal sex and enjoyed it. But it’s really just pushing back our boundaries a little, and discovering what works for us. Phone sex with my lover is another little pleasure I have in life.
How would you describe your sexual relationships with your husband and your lover? 141
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 142
Men,Women, Love and Romance Well, quite different as you’d expect! My husband and I make love, but not that often. It’s become fairly ordinary and although there is warmth and affection there, it doesn’t make the earth move any more. Our sex is fairly routine. We don’t do oral on each other, and mostly it’s him who has the orgasm,not me.With my lover it’s totally different. But then we only see each other once every six weeks or so, so it’s not surprising really as our relationship has not had a chance to get routine. Nevertheless, it’s not just that.When my lover and I make love we can spend an hour just being erotic with each other. Bathing together, playing touching games in public places, watching porn movies in hotel rooms if the fancy takes us. So the sex comes from that period of intense arousal. My lover and I love to experiment, it’s part of our relationship.
What sort of sexual contract do you have with your lover? It’s a mix of honesty, truthfulness and a desire to please each other, sexually. If this means experimenting then that’s fine, just so long as we each know what the boundaries are. We talk about sex and our relationship quite a lot. We know each other very well. There’s a lot of comfort in it.
janice (48, married since she was 20 years old. has had several lovers in the past five years.) How many lovers have you had? Well, until I was 43 only one, my husband, but in the past five years there have been another four.
142
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 143
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract Have you ever had same-sex relationships? No, it doesn’t interest me at all.
Where did you meet your lovers? Mainly they’ve lived within the area, or I’ve met them when I went out with the girls on Friday nights.One man I met through work.
How liberal are you in sexual matters? Until I was in my mid-forties, not very liberal at all, or experienced for that matter, though I’d had three children. I find my sex life has got better since I started smoking pot. I find it really relaxes me if I smoke a joint before sex.
Have you ever had a threesome? No! I’d be much too frightened.
What has been your most erotic experience? I like sex in public places,cars,the countryside,that sort of thing. The most erotic sex has been with the men who have been my lovers. Some of them have been fantastic lovers, very sexy and arousing. One of the men I saw liked me to dress up, in leather stuff especially, which he bought for me.That was really sexy. He was into bondage so he’d get me to wear handcuffs with crotchless leather pants. We’d play all sorts of games in an afternoon, round at his
143
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 144
Men,Women, Love and Romance house or in a local hotel. The thing is, I’d get wet just imagining us doing it, so by the time we actually met and started I’d be raring to go! He posted some stuff of me on the Internet, to a sex site, but my face was hidden, thankfully!
Is there any sexual activity you’ve not tried? Until I was in my mid-forties I’d had a very sheltered life and it was reflected in my lack of sexual experience. Since I started having the occasional fling with men I’ve felt more able to experiment and try new things. It’s become a bit addictive – now if it wasn’t there in my life I’d really miss it. So all this has helped me be more adventurous, sexually. I’m a much more sexually confident person than I was in my thirties. Now if a man wants me to do something then I’m more inclined to go along with it. Or I’m just as likely to tell him of my fantasies, and what I’d like.
How would you describe your sexual relationships with your husband and your lovers? I love my husband very much.There is no way I will ever leave him. I honestly believe that we will be together for the rest of our lives. But I’ve come to need more in my life, especially sexually. Since the children left home I’ve had more time on my hands and I’ve wanted to find out more about life.The sex with Ronnie [her husband] has always been nice, but rarely earth-shattering. But it’s safe and secure and that’s important as well.We have sex about once a fortnight, sometimes less.You cannot compare that with the sex I’ve had with other men.That has been much
144
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 145
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract more exciting, though rarely secure because you always fear being found out.But,then,that’s part of the attraction – the illicit side of it.
What sort of sexual contract do you have with your husband? One where he doesn’t refuse me sex too often! He works very hard and I’ve found that if he’s really relaxed and we have the house to ourselves, then that is when we can have some good times in the bedroom. But it doesn’t happen often enough for me.
linda (44, married for over 20 years. has a lover.) How many lovers have you had? If you count serious lovers, probably about four. The number of men I’ve had sex with is probably over 20.
Have you ever had same-sex relationships? Not relationships as such, but I’ve had sex with women.
Where did you meet your present lover? (Not her husband.) We met in a bar in the town. It was a girls’ night out and we got talking. I’d been seeing a couple of men, nothing serious, but Michael asked me out and our relationship got started pretty quickly after that.
145
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 146
Men,Women, Love and Romance How liberal are you in sexual matters? Since about five years ago, when I started having affairs, very liberal. I enjoy sex and can see nothing wrong with having fun so long as nobody gets hurt. I cannot go into middle age with my libido switched off! In fact,once I got into my late thirties it seemed to go into overdrive!
Have you ever had a threesome? Yes. I forget how we started it, but I joined in with a couple I know.We met several times. It was really good. I’m not really into women as such, but I found that with this couple I could relax and let myself go. We kept the relationship going for about six months.
What has been your most erotic experience? There’s been many! I once had a lover who insisted on me not wearing knickers whenever we met. Sometimes we’d go to the cinema and he’d finger me while the film was on. Or we’d be standing in a public place and his hand would be up my skirt and his fingers inside me. I once made love with my husband on the banks of Lake Windermere in the Lake District.It was summer,of course! I had a loose skirt on and I just sat astride him while my skirt covered us. I don’t think people could see.We had sex a couple of times that day, in different parts of the Lakes.
Is there any sexual activity you’ve not tried? I think I’ve tried most things at some time or another.
146
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 147
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract Women have said to me that they wouldn’t do this or that with a man, but I just think how can you say that unless you’ve tried it? I was in my late thirties before I ever used a vibrator. Now I wouldn’t be without one! And I’ve found porn to be a turn-on, so long as I am watching it with a lover, not on my own.That way it’s part of our sex life.
How would you describe your sexual relationships with your husband and your lover? Surprisingly good, with both. My husband and I have always enjoyed sex and we’ve tried most things. But with my lover there’s not just the sex, there is real love between us. When I was in my twenties I’d little experience of sexual pleasure, I was 23 before I had my first orgasm, so perhaps I’m a late starter. But with the right man, someone you can trust, then sex assumes different proportions in your life. It’s the physical and emotional stuff all rolled into one.
What sort of sexual contract do you have with your husband and lover? With my husband it’s based on being there for him, sexually and other ways. With my lover it’s based on mutual emotional and physical needs. So I suppose the contracts, as you put it, are quite different. Maybe I’ve wanted a new contract, but I can only get it with my lover. Or maybe it’s just materialised through our love for each other. I’m not sure.
147
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 148
Men,Women, Love and Romance
diane (34, has been in a steady relationship for 7 years. she’s not married.) How many lovers have you had? I lost my virginity at 15, since then I’ve had about 16 lovers, but I’ve always been faithful to Tony.
Have you ever had same-sex relationships? Once, when I was at university. She was a girl friend and it became sexual for a while.We still keep in touch though we don’t have sex now. She’s a good friend. She is actually more lesbian than bi, while I’m basically straight.
Where did you meet Tony? On a blind date, actually. It was set up by a friend of mine and Tony was the date. I’d had a longish relationship during my final year of studying but nothing heavier than that. Tony and I decided to live together after about six months.
How liberal are you in sexual matters? I’d like to think I was, though I’m not sure when I hear what some of my friends get up to!
Have you ever had a threesome? This is a recurring fantasy with Tony and I. It’s something we really get off on at times, though we’ve never actually
148
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 149
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract done it. I did once. Many years ago. But it was just a oneoff thing. I’d been seeing this bloke, we went on holiday and met up with another couple. One night the four of us had some sex play in the hotel bedroom.Weird really, but exciting nonetheless.
What is your most erotic experience? Tony and I play this game. It involves tying up and blindfolding me. I’ll be naked, probably in the bedroom and I won’t be allowed to move. Sometimes he’ll leave me like that for an hour and then he’ll come into the room and have sex with me, or put ice cream on me and lick it off. Or he’ll spank me while he’s making love to me. These games don’t happen all the time, we’ve got to be in the mood. But they are very arousing.
Is there any sexual activity you’ve not tried? Well, I’m certainly not into pain! Neither am I that keen on anal sex. Actually, I’ve never tried it, mainly because I once went out with a bloke who tried to force me and it put me off after that. I’ve done most other things and found them okay, in fact more than okay!
How would you describe your sexual relationship with Tony? Tony is the best lover I’ve ever had. I don’t feel the need for anyone else.We’ll talk about sex and quite openly,even with other couples. I think this just makes for a more relaxed experience. If I had a particular fantasy that I wanted to live out then I’d tell him. Maybe I will at some
149
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 150
Men,Women, Love and Romance point, who knows.We make love several times a week and either one of us can initiate it.
What sort of sexual contract do you have with Tony? I don’t see it as a contract, it’s just a sort of arrangement that’s evolved during our relationship. If I had to say exactly how it worked I’m not sure I could. I suppose it is based on trust, respect and love. But also on a recognition that we both have sexual needs, not just one of us.
sarah (45, divorced, single mum.) How many lovers have you had? Over 100,most when I was in my twenties and early thirties.
Have you ever had same-sex relationships? No. It’s never interested me.
Where do you meet men? Recently I’ve been using a dot.com friendship site. I prefer it to personal columns in newspapers because the site profiles have photos of men so you can see who you’re communicating with early on.
How liberal are you in sexual matters? I’m quite shy actually, so I have to be relaxed to let myself go with a man. However, once I do I’m dynamite!
150
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 151
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract Have you ever had a threesome? No never.Though it is a fantasy.
What is your most erotic experience? I find all sex erotic. I’m a very sexual animal. I lost my virginity at 15 and since then I don’t think I’ve gone more than two weeks without sex. I get turned on very easily, especially visually. I’m good at massage and with that I can make a sex session last ages. I think three hours is my record. Sex is a fundamental part of my life. I multiple orgasm when a man’s inside me. My record is 20 in one session! What I also find quite arousing is swapping notes about men with my women friends. We do it all the time. Describing men, describing sex with them, describing their bodies and how they performed. In fact, when I was younger we even swapped men sometimes!
Is there any sexual activity you’ve not tried? Well, there must be, but I cannot think of one just at this moment.
How would you describe your last serious relationship, sexually? Like most relationships it started well, though it deteriorated through his drinking.We were together for six years and I was faithful throughout that time. We had regular sex but I didn’t feel close to him. I couldn’t stand the smell
151
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 152
Men,Women, Love and Romance of alcohol on his breath. He’d come to bed late at night looking for sex, and we’d have sex, but I never kissed him.
What sort of sexual contract would you want in an exclusive relationship? One that gives me lots of love and passion!
Jane, Carol, Linda, Diane and Sarah have different lives, different experiences and different relationships with men.Yet they do have one commonality.That is they are largely free of most, if not all, of the sexual myths which were so prominent up until fairly recently. However, models of the old sexual contract still exist. For example, I came across one woman, Maggie, who had evolved a fairly commercial sexual contract with her husband: Although we have a good relationship, sexually and otherwise, there are sex acts I prefer not to do. This proved to be a bit of a problem when we first got married. At one point I was afraid Tim and I would split up over it. But we managed to resolve it. I’m not sure the way we’ve resolved it would suit everybody, but it suits us. Basically, he pays me to do certain things. We will be making love, and he might ask me to suck him, or to allow him have different types of sex with me, and we’ll agree, beforehand, a rate for it. It might be a meal out, or money, or a new dress. Actually, I think he finds it quite sexually arousing. It’s a sort of sex game we have and to be honest I get turned on by it as well – being the whore.
152
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 153
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract
Men responding to the New Woman So women are developing new, and sometimes not so new, sexual contracts with their partners. But how do men feel about women’s capacity to be open and explicit about their sexual needs and desires? I interviewed four men, Roy, Graeme, Simon and David, to get their perspectives and to hear them tell of their encounters with ‘new woman’.
roy Roy is aged 39. He has been divorced for five years and lives alone. He’s had a number of girlfriends over the past few years, but nothing serious. He recounted a recent experience with a woman he’d met through work. We’d been in touch through work for some time, maybe six months. I hadn’t thought of her as a potential partner until we met up at my place of work and went out for a drink that evening. Still nothing happened at that time, but it got me thinking! Eventually, I invited her over to stay with me when she was next in the city. She did.The first night we talked and drank wine, and then went to bed – separate bedrooms. I lay there in my bed, thinking about her being in the room just across the corridor. I got this erection! So I thought, fuck this! I got out of bed, went to her room, knocked, she let me in and I stood there, in front of her, stark naked with an erection. I can’t remember what I said exactly, but it was on the lines of ‘look what do you say we do something about this’! She thought it was wonderful the way I’d come across like that.So original she said! It was great.But what put me off was that she proved to be so sexually assertive in bed.
153
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 154
Men,Women, Love and Romance Wanted me to do all sorts! She wanted anal sex and there was no way I was doing that! Her explicitness took me back a bit. I felt used a bit I suppose.
As with many men, the bedroom revolution appears to have caught Roy by surprise. To be faced with a woman who knows her own mind, knows what she wants sexually, and virtually almost demands it, well, that is a new experience for him. But he’ll adapt. He’ll have to.
simon Simon is aged 55. He is an accountant, married and has three grown-up children. Although his marriage fell on rather barren times he had never been unfaithful, that is until recently. It was last spring, and I’d gone alone to attend a friend’s wedding. It was late in the evening at the reception, and I saw this beautiful red-haired woman,about 40,standing at the bar. She just looked at me, very hard, and I couldn’t help but stare back. I’d never felt anything like it. I had this strong sense that she wanted to talk to me. So I did something I’ve never ever done before, I went up and talked to her, had a drink with her. Then we had a dance. We danced through to the early hours. It was wonderful. I don’t know what happened, maybe I got carried away with the music, drink and excitement of it all, but when it came time to leave she rang for a taxi and asked me what I was doing. I just came out with it. I said, ‘I’m coming home with you aren’t I?’To my utter amazement she said, ‘Yes, you are.’And that was it. I made arrangements to go back up to see her a week later, on the pretence of it being
154
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 155
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract a business trip. I stayed the weekend with her. It was a fantastic time. The sex was the best ever. But she’s a very independent woman and I know I have to be a little cautious. She’s never been married and she’s had lots of lovers. I know I have to be careful because I’m not that experienced in the ways of love, but I feel I just have to go with this. I’m addicted to it I guess. I’m trying to let her decided how the relationship develops, she’s very much in control of what’s happening. But I don’t want to give her up.
From being initially hesitant and unsure, Simon shows all the signs of coming to terms with the assertive attitude of New Woman. He is right to tread carefully, but his instincts are telling him to go with the moment, and not to expect to control either the process or the outcome.
david David is aged 39 and has been married for five years.He has no children. I guess I’d come to assume I would never get married, and then I met Elaine.We met through work, we are both in the same department. I’d always admired her, but it had never come to anything.And anyway,for a long time I was seeing someone else and enjoying that relationship, though it wasn’t going anywhere. And then, one day, Elaine asked me out. No hesitation, very direct, just asked me out. I was surprised really. I found her to be the most remarkable woman. She’d been in a very damaging relationship in her early twenties, come out of that and not had any relationships since. So she was very cautious
155
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 156
Men,Women, Love and Romance about the sort of man she would get involved with. I reckon she’d spent a lot of time weighing me up before she decided to take the plunge. I am glad she did. I’m not really that confident with women, but with Elaine it’s different.There is a real strength with her and she’s good fun. After a few months she moved in with me and then we decided to get married. It was just something which evolved for us.We are good friends and have a real laugh together. Another thing I really like about Elaine is that she’s not traditional in her views. Many of the women I’d previously been out with, especially when I was in my twenties, were very traditional, and expected me to take the lead in most things.The women wanted me to do the pursuing, and I liked it because it was a bit of challenge, a conquest. But with Elaine she sort of conquered me! When I met Elaine I’d been through a lot of difficulties, especially with illness in my family. I’d moved back home to live with my mother. I’d never been in love before and wasn’t expecting it to happen to me. Sure, I’d liked the women I’d been out with, but there was always something that happened which put me off them. Men are programmed to respond to attractive women, but that was not what made me ask them out. It was usually after I got to know them a bit and they got more interesting. With Elaine, I was interested in her from the outset, but it needed her to make the first move. Now she’s my best friend and I couldn’t envisage life without her.
David is one of those men who has, in a way, been rescued by a new woman. He was drifting in relationships, returning to live once again with his mother, and then a woman 156
Men,Women,Love,Romance txt
16/5/05
2:46 pm
Page 157
Democratic Love:The New Sexual Contract came along who took him out of that and into the drama and excitement of a full and loving relationship. He seems to be thriving on it.
graeme Graeme is aged 34. He is a social worker and is engaged to be married. Neither have been married before. I met Sandy when I was on a training course. She was on the course with me. We hit it off immediately and although we didn’t date while we were on the course, I phoned her later and we started a relationship shortly after that. At first the relationship was fairly straightforward, and then she told me she was bisexual and that she had women friends she liked to keep in touch with. I realised from the outset that some of these relationships were sexual.This took some getting used to on my part. At first I just couldn’t understand what it was that her girlfriend gave her that I couldn’t. To be honest, I think my male ego was very bruised at first, but I’ve come to terms with the situation. In fact, I now think it’s rather sexy. I don’t think any of my previous girlfriends were bi, but they may have been. Since I started seeing Sandy I’ve become very aware that