MEASURING STRESS
This page intentionally left blank
MEASURING STRESS A Guide for Health and Social Scientists EDITE...
126 downloads
8596 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
MEASURING STRESS
This page intentionally left blank
MEASURING STRESS A Guide for Health and Social Scientists EDITED BY
SHELDON COHEN Carnegie Mellon University
RONALD C. KESSLER University of Michigan
LYNN UNDERWOOD GORDON Fetzer Institute
A project of the Fetzer Institute OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS New York Oxford
Oxford University Press Oxford New York Athens Auckland Bangkok Bogota Bombay Buenos Aires Calcutta Cape Town Dar es Salaam Delhi Florence Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madras Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi Paris Singapore Taipei Tokyo Toronto Warsaw and associated companies in Berlin Ibadan
Copyright © 1997 by Oxford University Press, Inc. First published by Oxford University Press, Inc. 198 Madison Avenue, New York, New York 10016 First issued as an Oxford University Press paperback, 1997 Oxford is a registered trademark of Oxford University Press All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Oxford University Press. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Measuring stress : a guide for health and social scientists / edited by Sheldon Cohen, Ronald C. Kessler, Lynn Underwood Gordon. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and indexes. ISBN 0-19-508641-4 (alk. paper) ISBN 0-19-512120-1 (Pbk.) 1. Stress (Psychology)—Measurement. 2. Stress (Physiology)—Measurement. 3. Medicine, Psychosomatic—Research—Methodology. I. Cohen, Sheldon, 1947II. Kessler, Ronald C. III. Gordon, Lynn Underwood. [DNLM: 1. Stress. Psychological, WM 172 M484 1995] RC49.M39 1995 616.9—dc20 DNLM/DLC for Library of Congress 94-13307
1 3 5 7 9 8 6 4 2 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper
SC: To my brother, David L. Cohen RK: To my mother, Jeanne M. Kessler LG: To my parents, Gerald and Marie Underwood
This page intentionally left blank
Preface
In the winter of 1991 Dr. Lynn Underwood Gordon of the Fetzer Institute invited a small interdisciplinary group of scientists working in the area of psychosocial factors in disease and clinical epidemiology to a meeting in Chicago. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss activities the Fetzer Institute might sponsor that would contribute to improving the methodological rigor and overall quality of research examining the connections between mind and body. Issues of measurement have been a challenge for clinical medicine, and those interested in assessing the role of psychosocial factors in health and disease face similar challenges. Precise and valid measurement is essential to the construction of meaningful studies. One product of the Chicago meeting was the suggestion that state-of-the-art techniques for measuring various psychosocial factors were slow to disseminate to the wide interdisciplinary group of investigators working in this area. Particular psychosocial measures are often chosen because of their availability or visibility rather than because they are the most appropriate for answering investigators' specific questions. Although several psychosocial factors thought to influence disease processes were discussed at this meeting, including stress, social support, personality, and coping, there was a consensus that the area of stress was one in which there had been important advances in measurement that had not been adequately disseminated, especially across disciplinary lines. There was also agreement that there is a need for stress concepts to be translated into measurement operations that are accessible to an interdisciplinary group of clinicians and scientists. In popular culture, "stress reduction" has become a goal and is being capitalized upon in a variety of ways, springing from some vague notions of the concept of stress. Many studies indicate that stress can adversely affect our health. Consequently, clarity in the definition of stress and in the expression of that definition in measurement is crucial to designing appropriate and effective stress-reducing interventions. In response to the Chicago meeting, the Fetzer Institute invited the three of us to edit a volume that would provide a broad range of information about stress measurement to both neophyte and seasoned researchers in the area of stress and disease. We decided that the volume should reflect the different interdisciplinary approaches to stress, help to integrate these approaches, and hence provide a product that would be of use to social and medical scientists alike. We felt that the fact that the three
viii
Preface
editors represent three of the primary disciplines, psychology, sociology, and epidemiology, would enable us to create a volume with an integrated and balanced view. We proceeded to invite a group of internationally recognized authors from a range of disciplines to contribute to the volume. In our invitations, we emphasized that we wanted to produce a textlike resource for persons from a range of disciplines, with a range of expertise, and hence that these chapters would be harder to write than most. With the support of the Fetzer Institute, we were able to meet twice with our chapter authors, both before and after writing drafts of their chapters, and bring in a number of consultants to provide feedback on chapters at the second meeting. These procedures helped us to guarantee consistency and quality across the volume and encourage conceptual coherence. The purpose of the volume is to serve as a resource for state-of-the-art assessment of stress in studies of physical and psychiatric illness in humans. We expect that the book will be used primarily as a resource for persons conducting research in this area but also in graduate courses in psychology, psychiatry, sociology, social work, nursing, and epidemiology. The book includes discussions of how stress is conceptualized, the pathways through which stressors might influence the onset and progression of psychiatric and physical illness, the various methods of measuring stress, and how one decides on appropriate measurement. Our major goal in producing the volume was to aid researchers in making decisions about the appropriate measures to use in specific studies. Each chapter provides a conceptual underpinning of the approach it addresses, discusses the important measures within the approach, the kinds of studies each is appropriate for, and the various costs and benefits of using each alternative measure. Our intent is to provide valuable information for audiences with a wide range of expertise: to aid persons without extensive experience but at the same time to provide sufficient information for experts to select state-of-the-art measurement instruments. We are indebted to the Fetzer Institute for its generous support of this endeavor. We express our gratitude to the contributors to this volume, who persevered in the face of editorial onslaught and produced exceptional products in a relatively constrained time frame. Research Scientist Development Awards from the National Institute of Mental Health supported Sheldon Cohen's (MH00721) and Ron Kessler's (MH00507) participation. We thank James House and Alvan Feinstein for their comments during the planning process. We are also indebted to Tracy Herbert, Stan Kasl, Stephen Manuck, and Richard Schulz who served as reviewers, providing exceptional feedback, and who stimulated exciting and challenging discussions about the conceptualization and measurement of stress. We sincerely appreciate their help and note that it is we and not they who are responsible for any errors or misinterpretations. We also want to thank the members of our staffs who have worked so hard in putting this book together—Ruth Dobbins in Kalamazoo, Janet Schlarb and Susan Kravitz in Pittsburgh, and Rose Myers in Ann Arbor—as well as our editor Joan Bossert and the staff of Oxford University Press for their support and professionalism. Pittsburgh, PA Ann Arbor, MI Kalamazoo, MI
S.C. R.C.K. L.U.G.
Contents
Contributors
xii
Part I Conceptualizing Stress and Its Relation to Disease 1. Strategies for measuring stress in studies of psychiatric and physical disorders
3
SHELDON COHEN, RONALD C. KESSLER, AND LYNN UNDERWOOD GORDON
Part II The Environmental Perspective 2. Checklist measurement of stressful life events R. JAY TURNER AND BLAIR WHEATON
29
3. Interview measurement of stressful life events
59
ELAINE WETHINGTON, GEORGE W. BROWN, AND RONALD C. KESSLER
4. Daily and within-day event measurement
80
JOHN ECKENRODE AND NIALL BOLGER
5. Measurement of chronic stressors
102
STEPHEN J. LEPORE
Part III The Psychological Perspective 6. Measurement of stress appraisal
122
SCOTT M. MONROE AND JOHN M. KELLEY
7. Measurement of affective response ARTHUR A. STONE
148
Contents
x
Part IV The Biological Perspective 8. Measurement of stress hormones
175
ANDREW BAUM AND NEIL GRUNBERG
9. Measurement of cardiovascular responses
193
DAVID S. KRANTZ AND JENNIFER J. FALCONER
10. Measurement of immune response
213
JANICE K. KIECOLT-GLASER AND RONALD GLASER
Subject Index
231
Contributors
ANDREW BAUM Department of Psychiatry and Pittsburgh Cancer Institute, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15213. NIALL BOLGER Department of Psychology, New York University, New York, NY 10003. GEORGE W. BROWN Department of Social Policy and Social Science, Bedford College, University of London, London, Great Britain WC1B 3RA. SHELDON COHEN Department of Psychology, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213. JOHN ECKENRODE Human Development and Family Studies, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853. JENNIFER J. FALCONER Department of Medical Psychology, Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, Bethesda, MD 20814. RONALD GLASER Department of Medical Microbiology and Immunology, Brain, Behavior, Immunity and Health Program, College of Medicine, Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210. LYNN UNDERWOOD GORDON Fetzer Institute, 9292 West KL Avenue, Kalamazoo, MI 49009. NEIL GRUNBERG Department of Medical Psychology, Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, Bethesda, MD 20814. JOHN M. KELLEY Department of Psychology, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403. RONALD C. KESSLER Department of Sociology and Institute of Social Research, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48016.
xii
Contributors
JANICE K. KIECOLT-GLASER Department of Psychiatry, Brain, Behavior, Immunity and Health Program, College of Medicine, Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210. DAVID S. KRANTZ Department of Medical Psychology, Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, Bethesda, MD 20814. STEPHEN J. LEPORE Department of Psychology, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213. SCOTT M. MONROE Department of Psychology, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403. ARTHUR A. STONE Department of Psychiatry, SUNY at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, NY 11794. R. JAY TURNER Department of Sociology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5T 1P9. ELAINE WETHINGTON Department of Human Development and Family Studies, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853. BLAIR WHEATON Department of Sociology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5T 1P9.
MEASURING STRESS
This page intentionally left blank
PART I Conceptualizing Stress and Its Relation to Disease This part addresses alternative definitions of stress, pathways through which stress could influence psychiatric and physical disorders, and issues involved in choosing between various levels of stress measurement. We discuss disciplinary differences in the definition and measurement of stress and suggest a unifying model relating various approaches to the study of disease. In particular, we address the roles of environmental, psychological, and biological conceptualizations of stress as contributors to disease. Possible typologies of stress based on temporal characteristics—for example, acute versus chronic stress—are also discussed. Chapter 1 is designed to help investigators formulate questions and begin to choose possible measurement options. The remainder of the volume provides detailed information for choosing specific measures.
1
This page intentionally left blank
1 Strategies for Measuring Stress in Studies of Psychiatric and Physical Disorders Sheldon Cohen, Ronald C. Kessler, and Lynn Underwood Gordon
Stress has long been a major focus among researchers interested in environmental and psychosocial influences on health. However, the way in which the term "stress" has been used in this voluminous literature has not been consistent. Indeed, some commentators have gone as far as to argue that the term stress has so many different meanings that it has become a useless concept (Ader, 1980; Elliot & Eisdorfer, 1982). Although we disagree with this premise, we recognize that there is confusion about the meaning and measurement of stress. This volume attempts to clear up some of that confusion by providing conceptual and practical advice for formulating questions about the relation between stress and disease and for selecting appropriate stress measures to test these questions.
What Is Stress? As noted above, there is disagreement about the meaning of the term "stress." Numerous definitions have been provided, varying in the extent to which they emphasize stressful events, responses, or individual appraisals of situations as the central characteristic of stress (e.g., Appley & Trumbull, 1967; Mason, 1975; McGrath, 1970). We have no illusions that we can resolve the differences among these perspectives in this volume. However, we do see a strong commonality among these approaches that allows them to be integrated in a theoretical model of the role of stress in disease. They all share an interest in a process in which environmental demands tax or exceed the adaptive capacity of an organism, resulting in psychological and biological changes that may place persons at risk for disease. Three broad traditions of assessing the role of stress in disease risk can be distinguished. The environmental tradition focuses on assessment of environmental events or experiences that are normatively (objectively) associated with substantial adaptive demands. The psychological tradition focuses on individuals' subjective evaluations of their abilities to cope with the demands posed by specific events or
3
4
Conceptualizing Stress
experiences. Finally, the biological tradition focuses on activation of specific physiological systems that have been repeatedly shown to be modulated by both psychologically and physically demanding conditions. The following sections provide a brief orientation to these traditions and attempt to distill the central assumptions of each. We then present an organizational model of the stress process that shows how these traditions relate to one another. Our premise is that each tradition focuses on a different stage of the process through which environmental demands are translated into psychological and biological changes that place people at risk for disease. Finally, we discuss the conceptual and practical issues involved in selecting appropriate categories of stress measurement. Once appropriate categories are selected, subsequent chapters of this volume can be consulted to help select measures within each category. Throughout the volume we use the term stress exclusively to refer to the general process through which environmental demands result in outcomes deleterious to health. However, we distinguish between the components of the process by referring to environmental experiences as environmental demands, stressors, or events; to subjective evaluations of the stressfulness of a situation as appraisals or perceptions of stress; and to affective, behavioral, or biological responses to stressors or appraisals as stress responses.
The Environmental Stress Perspective Most evidence on the role of stressors in human disease has derived from interest in stressful life events. Interest in the role of life events in illness began with the work of Adolf Meyer in the 1930s. Meyer advocated that physicians fill out a life chart as part of their medical examination of ill patients (Lief, 1948; Meyer, 1951). Meyer believed that the life events elicited in this way could be shown to have etiologic importance for a variety of physical illnesses. Meyer's ideas were highly influential and led to a substantial body of research which, by the late 1940s, had documented that stressful life events were associated with a variety of physical illnesses (see review by Wolff, Wolf, & Hare, 1950). Although some of this early work was based on inadequate research designs, a number of studies were quite impressive. The work of Wolff and his associates, for example, followed a large sample of telephone operators over many years and documented that illness was much more likely to occur during periods of inordinate demands, frustrations, and losses than at other times (Hinkle & Wolff, 1958). An important advance in this area of research came in 1957 when Hawkins and his collaborators developed the Schedule of Recent Experiences (SRE) in an effort to systematize Meyer's life chart (Hawkins, Davies, & Holmes, 1957). This instrument was used by a great many researchers over the next decade to document associations between stressful life events and heart disease, skin disease, and many others (reviewed by Holmes & Masuda, 1974). In a subsequent modification of the SRE, the Social Readjustment Rating Scale (SRRS), each event was assigned a standardized weight based on judges' ratings of the degree of difficulty required to adjust to the event (Holmes & Masuda, 1974). These weights were called "life
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
5
change units" (LCU). The summing of LCUs associated with reported events allowed for a summary measure of environmental stressors (Holmes & Rahe, 1967). This instrument had an enormous impact on research on the relations between life events and illness, due in large part to the documentation of dramatic associations, such as an effect of stressful life events on sudden cardiac death (Rahe & Lind, 1971). It also had an important conceptual impact on the field in advancing the notion of the life change unit and the conceptual model underlying the creation of this metric, which argued that the effects of stressors operate largely through the creation of excessive adaptive demands. This conception led users of the SRRS to be more concerned with the magnitude of life change than with whether the change was positive (e.g., a promotion) or negative (e.g., a job loss). Beginning in the 1970s, a new generation of stressful life event researchers began to challenge many of the basic assumptions involved in the construction and scoring of the SRRS. New ideas were advanced about the implications of different means of weighting and summing multiple events into cumulative scales (Shrout, 1981). A subjective element was introduced into some modifications of the SRRS by having individuals estimate the stressfulness of their own experiences as a way of generating measures that are more sensitive indicators of event stressfulness than judges' ratings (e.g., Sarason, Johnson, & Siegel, 1978). More drastic differences are reflected in the development of a life event interview in which investigators rate the importance of events while taking into account the context in which they occur (Brown & Harris, 1978). The investigator-based rating is an attempt to estimate the impact of an event in a specific context for the average person, avoiding individual subjective reactions. A major distinction among competing measures of life events in the current literature is between these contextual measures and more traditional checklist measures (Brown & Harris, 1989; Dohrenwend, Raphael, Schwartz, Stueve, & Skodol, 1993). Separate chapters on these two approaches are included in Section II of this volume. New concerns were also raised during this period that existing life event scales may not include an adequate and representative sample of the major events that occur in people's lives. Newer checklists were developed to expand the range of experiences evaluated (Dohrenwend, Askenasy, Krasnoff, & Dohrenwend, 1978). Scales were also developed to assess stressful events in specific populations whose experiences might be different from those represented on the more general SRRS. These included scales for children (e.g., Sandier & Ramsay, 1980), adolescents (e.g., Newcomb, Huba, & Bentler, 1981) and the elderly (e.g., Murrell, Norris, & Hutchins, 1984). The basic assumptions of the SRRS, that the effects of all stressful events are cumulative and mat the change per se is the most important dimension of stressors, were also challenged during the same time period (Paykel, 1974). Some newer lifeevent scales were based on a multidimensional conception of stressors that separately assessed the extent of threat, loss, danger, and other aspects of stressful events (Brown & Harris, 1978). On the substantive side, there has been a continuation of basic research to document the effects of stressful events on a variety of physical and mental health outcomes using newer stressful life event measures (Chapters 2 & 3, this volume).
6
Conceptualizing Stress
There also has been interest in studying the cumulative effects of experiencing two or more stressful life events in the same short interval of time (McGonagle & Kessler, 1990) and the joint effects of experiencing a stressful event in the context of an ongoing chronic stressor in the same life domain (Wheaton, 1990). In addition, there is now considerable interest in studying vulnerability factors—characteristics that make people more or less susceptible to stressorinduced disease. This interest derives from the repeated finding that although environmental stressors are often associated with illness onset, the majority of people confronted with extreme or traumatic stressful events do not become ill (Thoits, 1983). Differential vulnerability to the health-damaging effects of environmental stressors has been documented in a number of investigations (see review by Kessler, Price, & Wortman, 1985). A search for the determinants of this differential vulnerability has become the main focus of researchers interested in the role of life events in illness. In addition, the decade of the 1980s saw a movement away from an earlier tradition of focusing exclusively on the acute health-damaging effects of discrete life events toward an investigation of the long-term health-damaging effects of chronic stressors (Chapter 5, this volume). Work stressors (Neilson, Brown, & Marmot, 1989), marital disharmony (Beach, Sandeen, & O'Leary, 1990), and work-family conflicts (Eckenrode & Gore, 1990) have been the primary areas of investigation in research on chronic stressor effects. In addition, there is a new interest in the cumulative effects of minor daily stressors on both emotional health (Bolger, DeLongis, Kessler, & Schilling, 1989) and physical health (Chapter 4, this volume; Stone, Reed, & Neal, 1987). In all of this work, the researcher attempts to identify characteristics of the environment that promote illness. In the initial stages of this work the focus is on description. As the work evolves, the focus shifts to the processes involved in creating the observed association, the topic of Parts III and IV of this volume. Finally, although stressful events have been studied primarily as risk factors for disease, it is becoming increasingly clear that confronting and adapting to stressful events can result in positive outcomes such as personal growth, reprioritization of life goals, increased feelings of self-esteem and self-efficacy, and strengthening of social networks. A greater emphasis on the benefits of stressful events for successful adaptors is likely in the future and would broaden our understanding of the stress process.
The Psychological Stress Perspective The psychological stress tradition places emphasis on the organism's perception and evaluation of the potential harm posed by objective environmental experiences. When their environmental demands are perceived to exceed their abilities to cope, individuals label themselves as stressed and experience a concomitant negative emotional response. Psychological models of stress argue that events influence only those persons who appraise them as stressful—that is, perceive stress. It is important to emphasize that stress appraisals are determined not solely by the stimulus condition or the response variables, but rather by persons' interpretations of their
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
1
relationships to their environments. That is, the perception that one is experiencing stress is a product of both the interpretation of the meaning of an event and the evaluation of the adequacy of coping resources. The most influential model of the appraisal process has been the one proposed by Lazarus (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984). In the original formulation of his model, Lazarus (1966) argued that an appraisal of a stimulus as threatening or benign, termed primary appraisal, occurs between stimulus presentation and stress reaction. In his later writings, Lazarus (1977, 1981) argued that a situation will also result in a stress reaction if it is evaluated as a harm/loss, threat, or challenge. Primary appraisal is presumed to depend on two classes of antecedent conditions: the perceived features of the stimulus situation and the psychological structure of the individual. Some stimulus factors affecting primary appraisal include the imminence of harmful confrontation, the magnitude or intensity of the stimulus, the duration of the stimulus, and the potential controllability of the stimulus. Factors within individuals that affect primary appraisal include their beliefs about themselves and the environment, the pattern and strength of their values and commitments, and related personality dispositions. When a stimulus is appraised as requiring a coping response, individuals evaluate their resources in order to determine whether they can cope with the situation—that is, eliminate or at least lessen the effects of a stressful stimulus. This process is termed "secondary appraisal." Coping responses may involve actions designed to directly alter the threatening conditions (e.g., fight or flight) or thoughts or actions whose goals are to relieve the emotional stress response (i.e., body or psychological disturbances). The latter group of responses, referred to as "emotionally focused" coping, may be somatically oriented —for example, the use of tranquilizers, or intrapsychic responses such as denial of danger (Lazarus, 1975). If one perceives that effective coping responses are available, then the threat is short-circuited and no stress response occurs. If, on the other hand, one is uncertain that she or he is capable of coping with a situation that has been appraised as threatening or otherwise demanding, stress is experienced. It is important to note that this process of evaluating the demands of a situation and evaluating one's ability to cope not only occurs at the onset of a stressful event but often recurs during the course of the event (cf. Folkins, 1970; Lazarus, 1981). Thus, an event that is initially appraised as threatening may be later reappraised as benign, and coping strategies that are initially found to be lacking may later be found to be adequate. Conversely, events that one initially evaluates as nonthreatening may be later reevaluated as stressful. Although it is recognized that certain events are almost universally appraised as stressful (e.g., the death of a loved one), the impact of even these events can be expected to depend on an individual's appraisal of the threat entailed and his or her ability to cope with it. For example, the death of a spouse for someone with neither family nor friends may be experienced as more severe than the same event for someone with close ties to family and friends. As suggested earlier, appraisals of threat elicit negative emotional responses. They also can elicit a range of other outcomes including self-reported annoyance, changes in health practices such as smoking, drinking alcohol, diet, exercise, and sleeping; changes (usually deficits) in performance of complex tasks; and alterations in interpersonal behaviors (Cohen, Evans, Krantz, & Stokols, 1986). Unfortunately,
8
Conceptualizing Stress
psychological stress models tend to be vague in their predictions of the particular measures that will be affected in any instance, and of the nature of the relations among these outcome measures.
The Biological Stress Perspective The biological perspective focuses on the activation of physiological systems that are particularly responsive to physical and psychological demands. Prolonged or repeated activation of these systems is thought to place persons at risk for the development of a range of both physical and psychiatric disorders. Two interrelated systems that are viewed as the primary indicators of a stress response are the sympathetic-adrenal medullary system (SAM) and the hypothalamic-pituitaryadrenocortical axis (HPA). Although detailed descriptions of these two systems and their relations to each other are beyond the scope of this chapter (see Baum, Singer, & Baum, 1981; Levi, 1972; and Chapter 8, this volume), each is discussed in brief in order to provide a basic understanding of their roles in the stress process. Sympathetic-Adrenal Medullary System Interest in the impact of SAM activation on bodily reactions to emergency situations may be traced to Walter Cannon's early work on the flight or flight response (Cannon, 1932). Cannon proposed that the SAM system reacts to various emergency states with increased secretion of the hormone epinephrine. There is a large body of evidence indicating increased output of epinephrine and norepinephrine in response to a wide variety of psychosocial stressors (Levi, 1972). Other components of the SAM response elicited by stressors include increased blood pressure, heart rate, sweating, and constriction of peripheral blood vessels. It has been claimed that if SAM activation is excessive, is persistent over a period of time, or is repeated too often, it may result in a sequence of responses that culminate in illness. The responses include functional disturbance in various organs and organ systems (cf. Dunbar, 1954) and ultimately permanent structural changes of pathogenic significance at least in predisposed individuals (e.g., Raab, 1971). Particularly culpable in this regard is the secretion of the hormones epinephrine and norepinephrine by the adrenal medulla and/or sympathetic nerve endings. Excessive discharge of these substances is believed to induce many of the pathogenic states associated with the perception of stress including (1) suppression of cellular immune function (e.g., Rabin, Cohen, Ganguli, Lysle, & Cunnick, 1989); (2) hemodynamic effects, such as increased blood pressure and heart rate (McCubbin, Richardson, Obrist, Kizer, & Langer, 1980); (3) provocation of variations in normal heart rhythms (ventricular arrhythmias) believed to lead to sudden death (Herd, 1978); and (4) production of neurochemical imbalances that contribute to the development of psychiatric disorders (Anisman & Zacharko, 1992).
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
9
Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Adrenocortical Axis (HPA) The hormonal responses of the HPA axis were emphasized in Hans Selye's (e.g., 1956, 1974) influential description of a nonspecific (general) physiological reaction that occurs in response to excessive stimulation. Selye argued that pathogens, physical stressors (e.g., shock or noise), and psychosocial stressors all elicit the same pattern of physiological response. This response is said to proceed in a characteristic three-stage pattern referred to as the general adaptation syndrome (GAS). During the first stage of the GAS, the alarm stage, the organism's physiological changes reflect the initial reactions necessary to meet the demands made by the stressor agent. The anterior pituitary gland secretes adrenocorticotrophic hormone (ACTH), which then activates the adrenal cortex to secrete additional hormones (corticosteroids [primarily cortisol in humans]). The hormone output from the adrenal cortex increases rapidly during this stage. The second stage, resistance, involves a full adaptation to the stressor with consequent improvement or disappearance of symptoms. The output of corticosteroids remains high but stable during the resistance stage. Finally, the third stage, exhaustion, occurs if the stressor is sufficiently severe and prolonged to deplete somatic defenses. The anterior pituitary and the adrenal cortex lose their capacity to secrete hormones, and the organism can no longer adapt to the stressor. Symptoms reappear, and. if the stress response continues unabated, vulnerable organs (determined by genetic and environmental factors) will break down. This breakdown results in illness and ultimately death. Selye argued that any noxious agent, physical or psychosocial in nature, would mobilize a similar GAS response. In contrast, critiques of Selye's model suggest that each stressor elicits its own distinct physiogical reactions (Lazarus, 1977; Mason, 1975). These authors agree that there is a nonspecific physiological response to stressors. They argue, however, that the response is a concomitant of the emotional reaction that occurs when situations are appraised as stressful. When conditions are designed to reduce the psychological threat that might be engendered by laboratory procedures, there is no nonspecific reaction to a physical stressor (Mason, 1975). For example, by minimizing competitive concerns and avoiding severe exertion, the danger that young men would be threatened by treadmill exercise was reduced, and the GAS pattern was not found. It is noteworthy that, in Selye's later work (1974, 1980) he acknowledged that there are both specific as well as general (nonspecific) factors in physiological response to a stressor but maintained that the nonspecific response is not always psychologically mediated. He also suggested that the GAS does not occur (or is at least not destructive) in response to all kinds of stressors. For example, he suggested that there may be a pleasant stress of fulfillment and victory and a self-destructive distress of failure, frustration, and hatred. However, there is little empirical evidence to support this position. Since the late 1970s, interest in the biological bases of psychiatric disorders has stimulated an alternative focus on the HPA. Most of this work has pursued the possible role of HPA disregulation in depression. Relatively pronounced HPA activation is common in depression, with episodes of cortisol secretion being more frequent and of longer duration among depressed than among other psychiatric
10
Conceptualizing Stress
patients and normals (Stokes, 1987). However, it is still unclear whether the hyperHPA activation is a cause or effect of depressive disorders. HPA regulation may play a role in other psychiatric disorders as well. For example, anxious patients tend to have higher cortisol levels than normal controls (Sachar, 1975). Other Stress Associated Changes Although hormones of the SAM and HPA are those most often discussed as the biochemical substances involved in stress responses, alterations in a range of other hormones, neurotransmitters, and brain substances have also been found in response to stress and may play an important role in stress influences on health. These include stressor-associated elevations in growth hormone and prolactin secreted by the pituitary gland, and in the natural opiates beta endorphin and enkephalin released in the brain (see Chapter 8, this volume; also Baum, Grunberg, & Singer, 1982). These substances are also thought to play a role in both immune-mediated (Rabin et al., 1989) and psychiatric diseases (Stokes, 1987).
A Unifying Model of the Stress Process The perspectives represented by the three traditions discussed earlier can be viewed as emphasizing different points in the process through which objective environmental experiences can influence disease. A model integrating these approaches is presented in Figure 1.1. The sequential relations between the central components of the model (dark arrows) can be described as follows. When confronting environmental demands, people evaluate whether the demands pose a potential threat and whether sufficient adaptive capacities are available to cope with them. If they find the environmental demands taxing or threatening, and at the same time view their coping resources as inadequate, they perceive themselves as under stress. The appraisal of stress is presumed to result in negative emotional states. If extreme, these emotional states may directly contribute to the onset of affective psychiatric disorders. They may also trigger behavioral or physiological responses that put a person under risk for psychiatric and physical illness. This model implies that each sequential component of the stress process is more proximal to and hence more predictive of the illness outcome. For example, a disease-relevant biological stressresponse measure should be a better predictor of a disease outcome than measures of stressful life events or perceived stress. We thought it important that the model also represent the possibility that environmental demands can put persons at risk for disorder even when appraisal does not result in perceptions of stress and negative emotional responses. This is represented by the arrow directly linking environmental demands to physiological or behavioral responses. For example, it has been argued that the process of coping itself (even when it is successful and environmental demands are appraised as benign) may directly result in physiological and behavioral changes that place persons at risk for disease (Cohen et al., 1986; Cohen, Tyrrell, & Smith, 1993). We want to emphasize that this is a heuristic model designed to illustrate the
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
11
Figure 1.1 A heuristic model of the stress process designed to illustrate the potential integration of the environmental, psychological, and biological approaches to stress measurement.
potential integration of the environmental, psychological, and biological approaches to stress measurement. The model is primarily unidirectional (flowing from environmental demands to disease) and does not include all possible pathways linking these concepts. We identified two of many possible feedback loops (dashed lines) to illustrate the potential role of feedback in the model. One of the loops suggests that emotional states may alter appraisals. For example, depressed affect may result in negatively biased views of either the threat posed by stressors or the adequacy of one's own resources. The other loop suggests that physiological arousal may alter appraisals and emotional responses: For example, persons may mistakenly attribute arousal that was elicited by exercise, drugs, or nonrelevant emotional responses to a stressor (Schachter & Singer, 1962). The exclusion of alternative paths is not intended to reflect hypotheses about their existence. Historically, the environmental, psychological, and biological traditions have each focused on a specific part of the model, thus often ignoring other parts. For example, sociologists and epidemiologists have addressed the question of whether life events increase disease risk but usually ignore the psychological and biological pathways through which this influence might occur. Psychologists have focused on the role of appraisal and emotional response in disease risk, with less emphasis on the environmental causes of these states and the biological pathways responsible for links between psychological states and disease. Finally, biological stress researchers have focused primarily on the links between stressors and hormonal and cardiovascular response, and between these responses and disease risk, without concerning themselves with the psychological pathways through which stressors might influence biological states.
12
Conceptualizing Stress
How Could Stress Influence Disease? We have provided a generic model of the stress process. In this section, we elaborate the implications of the generic model for physical and psychiatric illness. Our hope is that this presentation of how various conceptions of stress can influence illness will help generate appropriate questions and, consequently, the selection of measures and research designs.
Stress and Physical Illness In general, stressors are thought to influence the pathogenesis of physical disease by causing negative affective states (such as anxiety and depression) which in turn exert direct effects on biological processes or behavioral patterns that influence disease risk (see Cohen et al., 1986; Krantz, Glass, Contrada, & Miller, 1981). The primary biological pathway linking emotions to disease is thought to be hormonal. Hormonal responses associated with stressful experiences include elevations in the catecholamines epinephrine and norepinephrine secreted by the adrenal medulla, in cortisol secreted by the adrenal cortex, in growth hormone and prolactin secreted by the pituitary gland, and in the natural opiates beta endorphin and enkephalin released in the brain (see Baum, Grunberg, & Singer, 1982). A number of these hormones have been implicated in the pathogenesis of cardiovascular disease (Herd, 1986) and diseases involving the immune system including cancer, infectious diseases, and autoimmune diseases (Cohen & Williamson, 1991; Laudenslager, 1988; Rabin et al., 1989). Emotionally induced responses of the cardiovascular system such as increased heart rate and blood pressure have also been implicated in the development of cardiovascular disease and of immune changes that might alter susceptibility to immune-mediated disease (Herbert et al., 1994; Manuck et al., 1992). As discussed earlier, emotional responses are not always required for stressful events to influence disease processes (Cohen, Tyrrell, & Smith, 1993). The effort involved in actively coping with a stressor may also alter many of the same biological processes influenced by the emotional response and hence influence the development of disease independently of the emotional response (Cohen et al., 1986). Behavioral changes occurring as adaptations or coping responses to stressors may also influence disease risk. For example, persons exposed to stressors or viewing themselves as under stress tend to engage in poor health practices. They may smoke more, drink more alcohol, eat poorly, exercise less, and sleep less (e.g., Cohen & Williamson, 1988; Conway, Vickers, Ward, & Rahe, 1981). Smoking, drinking alcohol, and poor diets have been established as risk factors for a range of different physical illnesses. Both stressors and negative affect have also been associated with failure to comply with medical regimens. Such failure could result in more severe and longer-lasting illness, either because undesirable behaviors aggravate existing problems or because failure to perform desirable behaviors (e.g., following medication regimens) results in disease progression. Other stressor-elicited behaviors—for example, unsafe sexual practices or poor hygienic practices—could also increase exposure to infectious agents.
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
13
Stress and Illness Behaviors Stress may also influence behaviors that appear to be manifestations of a disease state. Of particular interest is the role of stress in recognizing and acting on symptoms. The recognition and reporting of symptoms, and seeking of medical care often indicate underlying pathology. However, stress and other psychological factors can independently influence these behaviors (Cohen & Williamson, 1991). Because appraised stress often triggers physiological arousal, people under stress may be more (possibly overly) attentive to their internal physical states (Pennebaker, 1982). Stress may also facilitate the labeling of sensations as symptoms because people are reminded (in cognitive parlance, a schema is triggered) of previous times when stress was associated with symptoms or simply because they believe that stress triggers symptoms. Alternatively, stressors or stress appraisals may result in physical sensations whose causes are mistakenly attributed to disease symptoms rather than the stressor (e.g., Mechanic, 1972; Schachter & Singer, 1962). Labeling symptom constellations as disease may similarly be activated by stress-disease schemas. For example, it is widely believed that stressors cause the recurrence of oral herpes. Under stress, a minor oral lesion that would be ignored under nonstressful conditions may be defined as disease recurrence. Reports of symptoms and illness are also ways to avoid stressful situations (Mechanic, 1977). The prototypical example is the child who reports symptoms to avoid attending school on an especially stressful day (playing ill). Finally, stressors or stress appraisals may influence the decision to seek medical care when persons label themselves as ill. The perception of stress could interfere with deciding whether it is necessary to seek care, increasing care-seeking for minor symptoms or decreasing careseeking for serious ones. Persons under stress may also seek medical care unnecessarily because medical providers are viewed as persons to whom one can confide problems. Stressors could also decrease care-seeking because the time demands of many stressors make such visits inconvenient (Schulz, Visintainer, & Williamson, 1990).
Stress and Psychiatric Illness As noted above, most models of the relations between stress and physical illness postulate an intervening link through negative affective states such as anxiety and depression. But how is it that stressors cause these affective states, particularly those that are so extreme and enduring that they are considered disorders in their own right? There are two broad perspectives on this question. One holds that stressful experiences are sometimes so extreme that they naturally lead to enduring fear or sadness. This is the notion, for example, underlying the diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder, a disorder defined by the American Psychiatric Association as one in which there is enduring distress related to recurrent recollections of a traumatic event that is so far "outside the range of usual human experience . . . that (it) would be markedly distressing to almost anyone" who experienced it (American Psychiatric Association, 1987:250). The second perspective holds that stressful
14
Conceptualizing Stress
events lead to psychiatric disorder only in the presence of some preexisting personal vulnerability. A number of different vulnerability factors have been postulated for different disorders. Some of these are thought to be environmental in origin (U.S. Congress Office of Technology Assessment, 1992). For example, some researchers believe that exposure to abnormal parental attachment behaviors early in life can lead children to develop disturbed interpersonal styles which persist throughout their lives and create vulnerability to depression (Kessler & Magee, 1993). This vulnerability is thought to be triggered by stressful experiences associated with interpersonal loss, such as death of a loved one, divorce, or forced residential relocation. Other vulnerabilities are thought to be biological in origin. For example, there is evidence consistent with the possibly that HPA abnormalities are involved in vulnerability to depression (Anisman & Zacharko, 1992; Checkley, 1992) and that these HPA abnormalities may be under genetic control (Checkley, 1992).
Temporal Characteristics of Stressors, Appraisals, and Stress Responses One of the most challenging issues in the measurement of stress is the characterization of the temporal course of stressors, appraisals, and stress responses. Most of the discussion of the role of stress duration focuses on the chronicity of stress. Although the terms "acute" and "chronic" stress are used liberally in the literature, there have been few attempts (for an exception, see Brown & Harris, 1989) to set even arbitrary standard cutoffs delimiting acute from chronic durations. Our own view is that such cutoffs should be attempted only in the context of considering the implications for a specific outcome. For example, 3 months of persistent stress might prove important in risk for depression, and prove inconsequential for a disease that develops over years such as coronary artery disease. Assuming we were correct about the implications of these durations, it might be appropriate to define 3 months of persistent stress as "chronic" in the study of depression, but it would be uninformative to call 3 months of stress chronic in the study of heart disease (see Cohen & Matthews, 1987; Cohen, Kaplan, & Manuck, 1994). A view of temporal characteristics of stress consistent with the process model discussed earlier is proposed by Baum and his colleagues (Baum, Cohen, & Hall, 1993). They categorize stress duration through the use of a 2 x 2 x 2 matrix that crosses duration of event exposure (i.e., event present for short or long duration), duration of perceived threat (i.e., appraised threat or demand present for short or long duration), and duration of stress responding (i.e., behavioral, emotional, or physiological stress responses present for short or long duration). This procedure suggests a more sensitive approach to understanding the role of stress duration. For example, consider the difference between a persistent stressful event that is no longer appraised as stressful or responded to with a stress response, and a stressful event that has terminated but continues to be appraised as stressful and responded to with a stress response (e.g., traumatic experiences). Other work highlights some of the complexities of this issue by emphasizing the importance of temporal characteristics other than duration such as continuousness or
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
15
repetitiveness. The following classification of stressful events (from Elliott & Eisdorfer, 1982) provides an indication of the complexity of this issue: (1) acute time-limited events (e.g., awaiting surgery); (2) stressful event sequences—when one event initiates a series of different events that occur over an extended period of time (e.g., bereavement or being fired from a job); (3) chronic intermittent stressful events—events that occur periodically (once a week, once a month, or once a year; e.g., sexual difficulties or conflicts with neighbors); and (4) chronic stress conditions—situations that may or may not be initiated by a discrete event (e.g., being disabled, chronic job stress). The temporal course of events, stress appraisals, and stress responses have multiple implications for understanding the risk for disease. For example, one can ask how long an exposure, appraisal, or response is required to alter a disease process. Does persisting exposure result in a greater impact or in habituation? Are stress responses maintained over long periods, or do response mechanisms fatigue or trigger feedback mechanisms? What roles do repetitiveness and interval between repetitions play in these processes? Also of interest is the role that chronic stressors play in moderating the effect of more acute stressors. Unfortunately, there are few domains in which we know very much about the temporal role of stress. It is hoped that future longitudinal research addressing specific questions about the temporal course of stress will begin to provide us with a better understanding about how these issues should be treated.
Matching Measures, Designs, and Research Questions The choice of appropriate stress measures depends on the disease (or stage of disease) under study, on the specific question posed by the investigator about the relation between stress and disease, and on other methodological and practical issues. Although we discuss each of these criteria separately, all three criteria need to be optimized if the most appropriate measure is to be selected.
Matching the Temporal Courses of the Stress Measure and Disease Choosing an appropriate stress measure requires investigators to be informed about the disease outcome they are studying. Of particular importance is an understanding of the temporal course of the disease or disease stage under investigation (Cohen, Kaplan, & Manuck, 1994; Cohen & Matthews, 1987). Take, for example, the possible role of stressors in coronary artery disease (CAD). Atherosclerosis (occlusion of the coronary arteries) does not occur suddenly, over a few weeks or months, or even over several years. Instead it develops over decades. What kind of stressor measure would be most appropriate in studying the potential impact of stressors on CAD? Answering this question requires the investigator first to specify plausible pathways through which stressors might influence the development of the disease. Logically, there are two primary ways in which stressors could play a part in a
16
Conceptualizing Stress
disease with this course of development. First, a traumatic stressful event or events might trigger behavioral or biological processes that contribute to the onset of a disease process. After this process is set into action, the disease could then develop over many years. In this case, the trigger could occur at any time in the life course. Testing this assumption would require a technique that allows for reporting and timing of traumatic events over several decades, such as appropriately adapted event interviews or checklists. Second, long-term exposure to a chronic stressful experience might facilitate the development of disease during stressor exposure. Exposure to a chronic stressor might result in permanent or at least long-term psychological, biological, and behavioral responses that alter the progression of the disease. This hypothesis assumes exposure to chronic stressor(s) and hence requires measurement of chronic stressor experiences. Alternative types of measures include event interviews focusing on chronic experiences and scales designed to assess specific chronic stressors such as marital discord, unemployment, and disability. Obviously, measures assessing acute stressful events such as daily events, or acute stress perceptions or stress responses such as perceived stress, and negative affect measures would be inappropriate in testing either of these hypotheses. An alternative example is the role of stressors in triggering heart attacks (myocardial infarctions). The assumption in this case is that sudden and acute stressful experiences trigger coronary events (Cohen, Kaplan, & Manuck, 1994). Here, acute measures of life events, perceived stress, and negative affect would be appropriate, whereas chronic strain measures covering months or years would be inappropriate. Other models are possible, and these are intended only as examples. Our point is that investigators need to understand enough about the course of a disease outcome to be able to generate hypotheses about the duration and timing of stressor, appraisal, or stress-response exposure required to influence disease onset or progression. With this information, they can choose a stress measure with a temporal span that matches that of the disease process. Different hypotheses may imply very different types of measures as well as different research designs.
Posing a Specific Question About the Relations Between Stress and Disease The most important issue in designing a research study is to state clearly the question an investigator wants to answer. The more specific the question, the more guidance it provides for choice of instruments and study design. Global questions— for example, What role do stress-related physiological responses play in overall health?—are important. However, a specific question—for example, Does increased heart rate responsivity mediate the relationship between environmental stressors and the development of cardiovascular disease?—is required for the development of a research protocol and selection of appropriate instruments. The model in Figure 1.1 suggests a variety of questions one might ask about the relation between stress and disease. In this section, we give examples of some of these questions and of the types of measures one would use for each. When studying the relation between environmental demands and health, the
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
17
focus is on characterizing the environment or environmental/social changes that influence the onset or progression of disease. As discussed earlier, the majority of research in this area has focused on stressful life events. Event characteristics can include the type or domain of events, the magnitude of events, the temporal characteristics of events, or the nature of relations between combinations of events. Part II of this volume addresses different approaches to assessing environmental demands including checklist life event measurement (Chapter 2), interview measurement of stressful events (Chapter 3), daily and within-day event measurement (Chapter 4), and chronic stressor measurement (Chapter 5). Life event measures, whether checklist or interview, are generally used to assess the cumulative impact of events over a prolonged period (ranging from 3 months to a life-time, although these measures most often span a period of 6 months to 2 years). Sophisticated versions of these measures can also provide additional information about the context in which the events occurred to aid in determining the potential impact of the events. For example, in the case of a natural disaster, some people will lose all of their possessions and perhaps even some of their loved ones, whereas others will suffer only minor property loss or be fortunate enough to avoid any loss whatsoever. One would expect this variability to influence the stress perceptions and responses. The sensitivity of event measurement can be improved to the extent that a measurement technique allows this kind of information to be obtained. Chronic stressor measures generally assess the impact of individual stressors that last for prolonged (but often unspecified) periods—for example, enduring economic, work, or marital problems. Although such measures can focus solely on environmental events, they also include assessments of long-lasting appraisals or affective responses to specific environmental characteristics. Finally, daily and within-day event measures are generally used to assess the cumulative impact of the events that occur during a single day. Most of these events (or hassles) are so small that they would not be considered contributors to perceived stress and stressresponses when the other, more chronic approaches to event measurement are employed. Daily event measures have many of the same characteristics of major event measures. For example, they can be used to examine the importance of specified domains of events and to elicit information about the meaning and impact of individual events. They are generally employed in studies of the role of very acute (simultaneous or 1- or 2-day lag) changes in health. However, if administered over long periods of time, they can also be used to assess persistent difficulties and nagging day-to-day problems that continue for long periods of time. As discussed earlier, appraisals refer to the psychological interpretation of events as demanding, threatening, or challenging as opposed to benign (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984). The study of stress appraisal focuses on what are often termed vulnerability factors—the nature of persons and their contexts that make them more or less vulnerable to stress-induced disease. For example, variables such as social support and feelings of control that are thought to contribute to adaptive capacities and hence to protect persons from the pathogenic effects of stressful events are thought to act by short-circuiting the appraisal of stress. Alternatively, variables like type A behavior pattern are thought to increase vulnerability to stressful eventinduced disease by accentuating stressor appraisal (Cohen & Edwards, 1989). One
18
Conceptualizing Stress
can also address whether the type of (or reason for) appraisal plays a role in disease risk. For example, events can be viewed as stressful because of the excessive demands they represent, potential bodily or psychological harm, or because of a high level of challenge (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984). Like stressor measures, measures of appraisal may also assess cumulative perceptions of stress combining responses to multiple events or may assess responses to specific individual events. Measurement of stressor appraisal is discussed in Chapter 6. Environmental demands that are appraised as stressful are generally thought to influence disease risk through negative emotional responses. Although this association is commonly accepted, there are many interesting unanswered questions about the role of emotion in the stress process. For example, do different stressors produce different emotions? Do the same stressors produce different emotions in different people? Are certain types of emotional response associated with certain types of biological responses or diseases? Do positive and negative emotional responses have the same or opposite effects on biological responses and disease risk? There are several alternative approaches to categorizing emotions that are represented by different measurement techniques. For example, emotions can be categorized on the basis of valence (positive or negative), level of associated arousal, or emotional states such as anxiety, depression, and anger. Choice of the appropriate scale should be based on how close a specific breakdown approximates the question about emotional response that the investigator is concerned with. For example, a study of the role of stress in depressive disorder may focus on a measure of depressed mood, whereas a study of emotion as a pathway linking events to immunity or physical disease may require an assessment of the whole range of emotions. A discussion of the different approaches to the measurement of emotional response to stress is presented in Chapter 7 of this volume. Similar questions can be asked about physiological responses to stress. Do different stressors have similar influences on responses of the cardiovascular, endocrine, and immune systems? Do the same stressors produce different physiological responses in different people? Do different kinds of appraisal produce differential physiological responses? Endocrine and cardiovascular measures have traditionally been used as biological indicators of stress. As discussed earlier, a variety of hormones have been found to be altered by stressors, appraisals, and negative affective responses, and these hormones have been implicated in the pathogenesis of a wide range of mental and physical disease outcomes. However, there are tremendous differences in the characteristic response of different hormones and in their potential importance for specific disease outcomes. One important response characteristic that is essential in choosing a hormonal measure is the temporal course of the response. Some hormones respond quickly or return to baseline quickly, whereas others have a delayed response or slow recovery. Chapter 8 discusses issues in choosing hormone measures. Cardiovascular measures also differ in their importance as potential precursors of different cardiovascular disorders and in their sensitivity and course of response. These measures are discussed in Chapter 9. Immune measures have not traditionally been viewed as indicators of stress. In fact, it is only recently that stressors, appraisals, and negative affect have been closely tied to immune response (see reviews by Herbert & Cohen, 1993a; 1993b). We include a
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
19
chapter on immune response here because of the increased interest in the role of stress associated immune changes in physical and psychiatric disorders (Rabin et al., 1989). Individual immune measures differ substantially in both their associations with other categories of stress measures, and their implications for disease susceptibility. Chapter 10 discusses these differences and suggests appropriate criteria for choosing immune measures. Up to now, our discussion has focused primarily on the questions that can be asked within each of the traditional perspectives. However, our hope is that the model we have presented will encourage broader views of the stress process. In particular, it suggests the possibility of studies integrating multiple perspectives. At the simplest level, one could test the basic assumptions of the model. For example, do stressful events that result in perceptions of stress increase disease risk through changes in biological responses and health practices? Studies combining perspectives have the potential to answer many of the most important questions about the role of stress in disease.
Methodological and Practical Considerations We feel that it is inappropriate to discuss measurement as if it were the most important issue in designing studies of the relation between stress and illness. We consider appropriate and unbiased sampling, study designs that maximize the ability to make causal inferences, and appropriate statistical analyses equally important criteria for any study (e.g., Cohen et al., 1986; Kessler, 1987). Our choice, in this volume, to focus on measurement is based on our perception that the literature has failed to deal adequately with issues involved in the appropriate selection of stress measures and that compendia of available instruments are lacking. Our focus on measurement, however, does not imply that we feel that measurement is more important than any of these other considerations. Good measurement does not compensate for weak or poor study design. Because of limitations of space and our desire to maintain a coherent focus on measurement, we cannot adequately address the issues involved in designing studies of stress and disease. However, there are design issues that influence the choice of a measure and hence need to be raised in this context. The central concern is the importance of the interplay of the stress measure and the outcome. We introduced this problem earlier in the discussion of the need to match the temporal courses of the stress measure and the disease. However, there are other issues as well. A common problem is the use of stress and outcome measures that assess closely related if not identical concepts. This overlap (or confounding) is often a problem in studies of psychiatric symptoms since measures of symptoms and stress appraisal often include similar if not identical items (Dohrenwend & Shrout, 1985). Similarly, stressful life event scales often include serious illness and hospitalization as events. These (and other) items overlap with outcome measures assessing serious physical or psychiatric illness (Rabkin & Struening, 1976). The possibility of this type of bias is maximized in cross-sectional designs, and minimized in prospective designs where a stress measurement is used to predict changes in the outcome from the point
20
Conceptualizing Stress
of measurement to a follow-up. It can also be minimized by selecting stress measures that are not confounded with an outcome or by carefully removing items from a scale that are potentially confounded with an outcome. This last procedure must be done with great care since dropping items may alter the psychometric characteristics of the scale or bias the domain that the scale assesses. For example, removing hospitalization decreases the overlap of the life event and disease measures, but also results in the omission of a potentially important and impactful stressful event. Another problem is the potential for shared response biases that occur when the same type of measurement method is used to assess both stress and outcome. Take, for example, paper-and-pencil self-reports. These types of measures are influenced by a range of idiosyncratic response biases such as responding positively and avoiding extreme responses. If this method is used in assessing both stress and outcome, the relation between these measures will be artificially inflated because it will reflect the identical bias tendencies picked up by both measures. This problem can be avoided by using different methods—for example, a paper-and-pencil stress measure and biological or behavioral outcome. Realistically, practical limitations and limited resources often prevent the use of measures of stress that one would choose based solely on the conceptual and methodological issues discussed earlier. Primary among these considerations is the amount of time required from subjects. Studies employing multiple measures, those conducted over the phone, and those with samples to whom there is limited access or among whom there is limited interest, often require stress measures that take a minimal amount of time. As a consequence, interview measures and detailed selfreport measures may not be appropriate in these cases. Cost of administration is another important consideration. For example, although interview measures of stressful events provide more sensitive measurement of events and their contexts, they require hours of effort by trained personnel, including the interview process itself as well as labor-intensive coding of materials. Choices based on the cost and time of instrument administration require the researcher to balance these constraints with the need for measurement accuracy.
Moderators of the Relation Between Stressors and Disease Risk Correlations between life events and illness have rarely risen above .30, suggesting that life events may account for less than 10 percent of the variance in illness. A number of investigators have proposed that relations between stress and illness vary with preexisting vulnerability factors (see reviews by Cohen & Edwards, 1989; Cohen & Wills, 1985; Kessler & McLeod, 1985). That is, differences in social support systems, skills, attitudes, beliefs, and personality characteristics render some persons relatively immune to stress-induced illness and others relatively susceptible. Although this book does not directly address the issues of moderation, interest in moderation does have implications for the choice of stress measurement. As we noted earlier, moderators are often thought to act through their effects of
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
21
stress appraisal. For example, a person may not view potentially threatening events as stressful if they believe that their social network will aid them in coping. However, moderators could act at any stage in the stress process. For example, social networks may enforce norms about both emotional and behavioral responses to events that are appraised as stressful. By specifying the point in the stress process where moderation is thought to occur, one can choose the type of stress measure most likely to demonstrate moderation. Again, the choice of the appropriate assessment tool depends on the questions under consideration.
Purpose and Organization of the Book The purpose of the proposed volume is to serve as a resource for state-of-the-art assessment of stress in studies of physical and psychiatric illness in humans. Our major goal in producing the volume is to aid researchers in making decisions about the appropriate measures to use in specific studies. In this chapter we provided a broad conceptual overview of stress and its relation to psychiatric and physical disorder. We have addressed the conceptualization of stress and how environmental, psychological, and biological approaches can answer different questions about the stress process. The overall theme of this chapter and of the volume is that the measures one selects should reflect the kinds of questions being asked and research designs employed. In Parts II through IV of the volume, we address three broadly defined types of stress measurement: environmental demands, psychological stress, and biological stress. We do not attempt to cover all the measures that might broadly be construed as falling in these categories. Instead we choose those that we believe will be of interest to the broadest possible audience. For example, we do not discuss measures of physical environment such as noise and air pollution, behavior changes such as deficits in task performance, or maladaptive coping responses such as smoking and drinking, or alternative biological stress responses such as skin conductance, eye movement and pupillary diameter, or muscle tension. The exclusion of these measures does not imply that they are not as important as or more important than those we discuss. It merely reflects our decision to address a few of the most central categories of measures in depth rather than try to cover all possible measures superficially. Each chapter provides a conceptual underpinning of the approach it addresses, discusses the important measures within the approach, the kinds of studies suited to each, and the various costs and benefits of using each alternative measure. The purpose of these chapters is to aid researchers in making decisions about the appropriate measures to use in specific studies. Questions addressed in each chapter include: What kinds of questions about the relation between stress and illness can be answered using this kind of measure? Under what conditions would an investigator use one version of a measure versus another? What are the kinds of study designs in which this particular measure works well? What are the logistical issues that must be considered in using this measure? What is known about the psychometrics of these kinds of measures (and, when appropriate, specific measures)? Are these measures population sensitive, and are appropriate measures available for different
22
Conceptualizing Stress
populations? What are the key references for finding the measures, the psychometrics, and instructions for use? Our intent is to provide valuable information for audiences with a wide range of expertise; to aid persons without extensive experience, but at the same time to provide sufficient information for experts to select state-of-the-art measurement instruments.
References Ader, R. (1980). Psychosomatic and psychoimmunological research. Presidential Address. Psychosomatic Medicine, 42, 307-321. American Psychiatric Association. (1987). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (rev. 3rd ed.). Washington, DC: Author. Anisman, H., & Zacharko, R. M. (1992). Depression as a consequence of inadequate neurochemical adaptation in response to stressors. British Journal of Psychiatry, 160, 36-43. Appley, M. H., & Trumbull, R. (Eds.). (1967). Psychological stress: Issues in research. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts. Baum, A., Cohen, L., & Hall, M. (1993). Control and intrusive memories as possible determinants of chronic stress. Psychosomatic Medicine, 55, 274-286. Baum, A., Grunberg, N. E., & Singer, J. E. (1982). The use of psychological and neuroendocrinological measurements in the study of stress. Health Psychology, 1, 217-236. Baum, A., Singer, J. E., & Baum, C. S. (1981). Stress and the environment. Journal of Social Issues, 37, 4-35. Beach, S.R.H., Sandeen, E. E., & O'Leary, K. D. (Eds.). (1990). Depression in marriage. New York: Guilford Press. Bolger, N., DeLongis, A., Kessler, R. C., & Schilling, E. (1989). The effects of daily stress on negative mood. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 57, 808-818. Brown, G. W., & Harris, T. O. (1978). Social origins of depression: A study of psychiatric disorders in women. London: Tavistock. Brown, G. W., & Harris, T. O. (1989). Life events and illness. New York: Guilford Press. Cannon, W. B. (1932). The wisdom of the body. New York: W. W. Norton. Checkley, S. (1992). Neuroendocrine mechanisms and the precipitation of depression by life events. British Journal of Psychiatry, 160, 7-17. Cohen, S., & Edwards, J. R. (1989). Personality characteristics as moderators of the relationship between stress and disorder. In R.W.J. Neufeld (Ed.), Advances in the investigation of psychological stress (pp. 235-283). New York: Wiley. Cohen, S., Evans, G. W., Krantz, D. S., & Stokols, D. (1986). Behavior, health and environmental stress. New York: Plenum Press. Cohen, S., Kaplan, J. R., & Manuck, S. B. (1994). Social support and coronary heart disease: Underlying psychologic and biologic mechanisms. In S. A. Shumaker & S. M. Czajkowski (Eds.), Social support and cardiovascular disease (pp. 195-221). New York: Plenum Press. Cohen, S., & Matthews, K. A. (1987). Social support, type A behavior and coronary artery disease. Psychosomatic Medicine, 49, 325-330. Cohen, S., Tyrrell, D.A.J., & Smith, A. P. (1993). Negative live events, perceived stress, negative affect, and susceptibility to the common cold. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 64, 131-140. Cohen, S., & Williamson, G. M. (1988). Perceived stress in a probability sample of the
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
23
United States. In S. Spacapan & S. Oscamp (Eds.), The social psychology of health (pp. 31-67). Newbury Park, Cal.: Sage Publications. Cohen, S., & Williamson, G. M. (1991). Stress and infectious disease in humans. Psychological Bulletin, 109, 5-24. Cohen, S., & Wills, T. A. (1985). Stress, social support and the buffering hypothesis. Psychological Bulletin, 98, 310-357. Conway, T. L., Vickers, R. R., Ward, H. W, & Rahe, R. H. (1981). Occupational stress and variation in cigarette, coffee, and alcohol consumption. Journal of Health & Social Behavior, 22, 155-165. Dohrenwend, B. S., Askenasy, A. R., Krasnoff, L., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1978). Exemplification of a method for scaling life events: The PERI Life Events Scale. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 19, 205-229. Dohrenwend, B. P., Raphael, K. G., Schwartz, S., Stueve, A., Skodol, A. (1993). The structural event probe and narrative rating method (SEPRATE) for measuring stressful life events. In L. Goldberger & S. Bresnitz (Eds.), Handbook of stress: Theoretical and clinical aspects (2nd ed., pp. 174-199). New York: The Free Press. Dohrenwend, B. P., & Shrout, P. (1985). "Hassles" in the conceptualization and measurement of life stress variables. American Psychologist, 40, 780-785. Dunbar, H. F. (1954). Emotions and bodily changes; a survey of literature on psychosomatic interrelationships, 1910-1953 (4th ed.). New York: Columbia University Press. Eckenrode, J., & Gore, S. (1990). Stress between work and family. New York: Plenum Press. Elliott, G. R., & Eisdorfer, C. (Eds.). (1982). Stress and human health: Analysis and implications of research; a study by the Institute of Medicine, National Academy of Sciences. New York: Springer. Folkins, C. H. (1970). Temporal factors and the cognitive mediators of stress reaction. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, 14, 173-184. Hawkins, N. G., Davies, R., & Holmes, T. H. (1957). Evidence of psychosocial factors in the development of pulmonary tuberculosis. American Review of Tuberculosis and Pulmonary Diseases, 75, 768-780. Herbert, T. B., & Cohen, S. (1993a). Depression and immunity: A meta-analytic review. Psychological Bulletin, 113, 472-486. Herbert, T. B., & Cohen, S. (1993b). Stress and immunity in humans: A meta-analytic review. Psychosomatic Medicine, 55, 364-379. Herbert, T. B., Cohen, S., Marsland, A. L., Bachen, E. A., Rabin, B. S., Muldoon, M. F., & Manuck, S. B. (1994). Cardiovascular reactivity and the course of immune response to an acute psychological stressor. Psychosomatic Medicine. Herd, J. A. (1986). Neuroendocrine mechanisms in coronary heart disease. In K. A. Matthews et al. (Eds.), Handbook of stress, reactivity and cardiovascular disease (pp. 49-70). New York: Wiley. Herd, J. A. (1978). Physiological correlates of coronary-prone behavior. In T. M. Dembroski, S. M. Weiss, J. L. Shields, S. G. Haynes, & M. Feinleib (Eds.), Coronaryprone behavior (pp. 129-136). New York: Springer-Verlag. Hinkle, L. E., Jr., & Wolff, H. G. (1958). Ecologic investigations of the relationship between illness, life experiences and the social environment. Annals of Internal Medicine, 49, 1373-1388. Holmes, T. H., & Masuda, M. (1974). Life changes and illness susceptibility. In B. S. Dohrenwend & B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressful life events: Their nature and effects (pp. 45-72). New York: Wiley. Holmes, T. H., & Rahe, R. H. (1967). The social readjustment rating scale. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 11, 213-218.
24
Conceptualizing Stress
Kessler, R. C. (1987). The interplay of research design strategies and data analysis procedures in evaluation of the effects of stress on health. In S. V. Kasl & C. L. Cooper (Eds.), Stress and health: Issues in research methodology (pp. 113—140). New York: Wiley. Kessler, R. C., & Magee, W. (1993). Childhood adversity and adult depression. Psychological Medicine, 23, 679-690. Kessler, R. C., & McLeod, J. D. (1985). Social support and mental health in community samples. In S. Cohen & S. L. Syme (Eds.), Social support and health (pp. 219-240). New York: Academic Press. Kessler, R. C., Price, R., & Wortman, C. (1985). Social factors in psychopathology: Stress, social support, and coping processes. Annual Review of Psychology, 36, 531-572. Krantz, D. S., Glass, D. C., Contrada, R., & Miller, N. E. (1981). Behavior and health. (National Science Foundation's second five-year outlook on science and technology). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. Laudenslager, M. L. (1988). The psychobiology of loss: Lessons from humans and nonhuman primates. Journal of Social Issues, 44, 19-36. Lazarus, R. S. (1966). Psychological stress and the coping process. New York: McGrawHill. Lazarus, R. S. (1975). A cognitively oriented psychologist looks at biofeedback. American Psychologist, 30, 553-561. Lazarus, R. S. (1977). Cognitive and coping processes in emotion. In A. Monat & R. S. Lazarus (Eds.), Stress and coping (pp. 145-158). New York: Columbia University Press. Lazarus, R. S. (1981). The stress and coping paradigm. In C. Eisdorfer, D. Cohen, A. Kleinman, & P. Maxim (Eds.), Models for clinical psychopathology (pp. 177214). New York: Spectrum. Lazarus, R. S., & Folkman, S. (1984). Stress, appraisal, and coping. New York: Springer. Levi, L. (Ed.). (1972). Stress and distress in response to psychosocial stimuli. New York: Pergamon Press. Lief, A. (Ed.). (1948). The commonsense psychiatry of Dr. Adolf Meyer. New York: McGraw-Hill. Manuck, S., Olsson, G., Hjemdahl, P., & Rehnqvist, N. (1992). Does cardiovascular reactivity to mental stress have prognostic value in postinfarction patients? A pilot study. Psychosomatic Medicine, 54, 102-108. Mason, J. W. (1975). A historical view of.the stress field, Part 2. Journal of Human Stress, I, 22-36. McCubbin, J. A., Richardson, J., Obrist, P. A., Kizer, J. S., & Langer, A. W. (1980). Catecholaminergic and hemodynamic responses to behavioral stress in young adult males. Paper presented at the Twentieth Annual Meeting of the Society for Psychophysiological Research. McGonagle, K. A., & Kessler, R. C. (1990). Chronic stress, acute stress, and depressive symptoms. American Journal of Community Psychology, 18, 681-705. McGrath, J. E. (Ed.). (1970). Social and psychological factors in stress. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston. Mechanic, D. (1972). Social psychologic factors affecting the presentation of bodily complaints. New England Journal of Medicine, 286, 1132-1139. Mechanic, D. (1977). Some modes of adaptation: Defense. In A. Monat & R. S. Lazarus (Eds.), Stress and coping (pp. 244-257). New York: Columbia University Press. Meyer, A. (1951). The life chart and the obligation of specifying positive data in psychopathological diagnosis. In E. E. Winters (Ed.), The collected papers of Adolf Meyer,
Measuring Stress in Psychiatric and Physical Disorders
25
Vol. 3: Medical teaching (pp. 52-56). Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press. Murrell, S., Norris, F., & Hutchins, G. (1984). Distribution and desirability of life events in older adults: Population and policy implications. Journal of Community Psychology, 12, 301-311. Neilson, E., Brown, G. W., & Marmot, M. (1989). Myocardial infarction. In G. W. Brown & T. O. Harris (Eds.), Life events and illness (pp. 313-342). New York: Guilford Press. Newcomb, M., Huba, G., & Bentler, P. (1981). A multidimensional assessment of stressful life events among adolescents: Derivations and correlates. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 22, 400-414. Paykel, E. S. (1974). Life stress and psychiatric disorder: Applications of the clinical approach. In B. S. Dohrenwend & B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressjul life events: Their nature and effects (pp. 135-149). New York: John Wiley. Pennebaker, J. W. (1982). The psychology of physical symptoms. New York: Springer-Verlag. Raab, W. (1971). Cardiotoxic biochemical effects of emotional-environmental stressors— fundamentals of psychocardiology. In L. Levi (Ed.), Society, stress, and disease (Vol. 1, pp. 331-337). London: Oxford University Press. Rabin, B. S., Cohen, S., Ganguli, R., Lysle, D. T., & Cunnick, J. E. (1989). Bidirectional interaction between the central nervous system and the immune system. CRC Critical Reviews in Immunology, 9, 279—312. Rabkin, J. G., & Struening, E. L. (1976). Life events, stress and illness. Science, 194, 1013-1020. Rahe, R. H., & Lind, E. (1971). Psychosocial factors and sudden cardiac death: A pilot study. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 15, 19-24. Sachar, E. J. (1975). Twenty-four hour cortisol secretion patterns in depressed and manic patients. Progress in Brain Research, 42, 81. Sandier, I., & Ramsay, T. (1980). Dimensional analysis of children's stressful events. American Journal of Community Psychology, 8, 285—302. Sarason, I. G., Johnson, J. H., & Siegel, J. M. (1978). Assessing the impact of life changes: Development of the life experiences survey. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 46, 932-946. Schachter, S., & Singer, J. E. (1962). Cognitive, social and physiological determinants of emotional state. Psychological Review, 69, 379-399. Schulz, R., Visintainer, P., & Williamson, G. M. (1990). Psychiatric and physical morbidity effects of caregiving. Journal of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 45, P181-P191. Selye, H. (1956). The stress of life. New York: McGraw-Hill. Selye, H. (1974). Stress without distress. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott. Selye, H. (1980). Stress, aging, and retirement. Journal of Mind and Behavior, 1, 93-110. Shrout, P. E. (1981). Scaling of stressful life events. In B. S. Dohrenwend & B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressful life events and their contexts (pp. 29-47). New Brunswick, NJ: Neale Watson Academic Pub. Stokes, P. E. (1987). The neuroendocrine measurement of depression. In A. J. Marsella, R.M.A. Hirschfeld, & M. M. Katz (Eds.), The measurement of depression (pp. 153-195). New York: Guilford Press. Stone, A. A., Reed, B. R., & Neale, J. M. (1987). Changes in daily event frequency precede episodes of physical symptoms. Journal of Human Stress, 13, 70-74. Thoits, P. A. (1983). Dimensions of life events that influence psychological distress: An evaluation and synthesis of the literature. In H. B. Kaplan (Ed)., Psychological stress: Trends in theory and research (pp. 33-103). New York: Academic Press.
26
Conceptualizing Stress
U.S. Congress, Office of Technology Assessment (September 1992). The biology of mental disorders (OTA-BA-538). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. Wheaton, B. (1990). Life transitions, role histories, and mental health. American Sociological Review, 55, 209-223. Wolff, H. G., Wolf, S. G., Jr., & Hare, C. C. (Eds.). (1950). Life stress and bodily disease. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins.
PART II The Environmental Perspective The environmental perspective focuses on a stimulus-based definition of stress. The goal is to discover the objective environmental conditions that promote stress and lead to disease. There is considerable disagreement regarding the characteristics that define objective conditions (stressors) that place people at risk for disease, and different measurement methods reflect various positions as to the importance of some characteristics versus others. Characteristics receiving the most attention and reflected in common measurement techniques include the amount of change created by the stressor, the extent to which the stressor leads to loss or threat of loss, and the extent to which the stressor and its resolution are under the control of the respondent. Traditional measurement of environmental conditions has also focused on events with different magnitudes of importance and different temporal characteristics. For example, stressful life events represent major changes that range from short-term to enduring; daily events are more minor day-to-day conditions; and chronic events tend to be important and enduring events. Part II addresses the measurement of environmental stress. Chapter 2 reviews the voluminous literature on checklist measures of life events, whereas Chapter 3 reviews the more recent and circumscribed literature on interview measures of life events. The decision as to which type of life event measure to use is critical, as the two types generally represent different conceptions of what constitutes a stressful experience and perform quite differently. Checklist measures are much easier to administer but are generally less predictive of illness outcomes. Interview measures require the use of more highly trained interviewers, long personal interviews, and elaborate coding schemes to distinguish subjective components from more objective contextual information. This added effort pays off in more powerful prediction of illness outcomes, but it is not clear how large this advantage is in particular cases. Chapter 4 discusses measures of daily and within-day events. This is a comparatively new area of investigation for stress researchers, but one that is gaining increasing attention as evidence accumulates that these microstressors are important determinants of both minor acute-onset illnesses and acute flareups of more serious chronic conditions. Chapter 5, finally, addresses the mea27
28
The Environmental Perspective
surement of chronic stressors. Some types of chronic stressors, such as frequent arguments with spouse, have long been part of life event checklists. However, recent research has shown that these measures need to be considered separately, as they are more important than life events in explaining the onset and course of chronic health problems. The separate measurement of chronic stressors can also help interpret the effects of life events on more acute illness outcomes because these effects are often mediated by the exacerbation of chronic stressors or potentiated by the contexts created by chronic stressors. Unfortunately, there are substantial methodological problems associated with obtaining objective measures of chronic stressors. Chapter 5 reviews these problems, summarizes domain-specific measures that have overcome these problems, and discusses prospects for future developments of more satisfactory broad-based measures of chronic stressors.
2 Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events R. Jay Turner and Blair Wheaton
As noted in the preceding chapter, epidemiological research on the significance of social stress for health and well-being can be traced to the 1930s. However, the onset of the continuing preoccupation among epidemiologists with the role and significance of life stress followed Holmes and Rahe's (1967) publication of the Social Readjustment Rating Scale (SRRS). This instrument elaborated the Schedule of Recent Experiences (Hawkins, Davies, & Holmes, 1957) by employing a panel of judges to rate the amount of adjustment they thought each event would typically require. In retrospect, the most crucial effect of this innovation may have been its contribution to the face validity of the checklist approach. The availability of normatively generated differential weights overcame the counterintuitive necessity of treating events that seemed of very different severity as though they were equally relevant to health and well-being. Whatever the nature of the advance embodied in the SRRS, its publication was followed by a huge outpouring of research, and it became the best known and the most widely used approach to measuring life events. The conceptualization that initially informed the checklist approach in general, and the procedure for weighting each experienced event in particular, posited that one's level of experienced stress was embodied in the cumulative amount of change or readjustment brought about by events occurring in one's life (Holmes & Rahe, 1967). The idea that the amount of change is the event property that is responsible for the stressful impact of life events was based largely on Selye's (1956) contention that stress is comprised of nonspecific biological change elicited in response to environmental events and that even relatively small changes occurring in close succession can influence susceptibility and thus disease. The contention that it is change per se, whether positive or negative in nature, that matters, was also forcefully argued by Barbara Dohrenwend (1973). She, along with her colleagues, saw stressful life events as "objective occurrences of sufficient magnitude to bring about changes in the usual activities of most individuals who experience them" (Dohrenwend, Krasnoff, Askenasy, & Dohrenwend, 1982). This conceptualization continues to inform the work of this distinguished team of stress researchers and is clearly reflected in their recently published measure of eventful stress, referred to as the Structured Event Probe and Narrative Rating, or SEP29
30
The Environmental Perspective
RATE, method (Dohrenwend, Raphael, Schwartz, Stueve, & Skodol, 1993). Notably, this measure considers change as only one of a number of stimulus and contextual characteristics of the event that must be considered, reflecting the elaboration of thinking in life event research over the last 25 years. The major alternative conceptualizations emphasize not change per se, but a range of issues, including the quality of the experience in terms of undesirability (Paykel, Prusoff, & Uhlenhuth, 1971; Paykel, 1979), contextual threat (Brown, 1981, 1989), and personal control over occurrence of the event (Dohrenwend et al., 1993). As described in Chapter 3, contextual threat is estimated by means of detailed analyses based on interview probes and ratings of independent judges rather than checklist procedures. In contrast, life event checklists (either in questionnaire or interview format) remain the dominant method employed by those who view undesirability as the most relevant issue and who believe that stress cumulation has a generic demand component quite apart from content differences among events. On the basis of a substantial body of research, the majority of life event researchers have come to focus upon undesirable change assessed with lists containing putatively negative events. Over the 25 years since the publication of the SRRS, there has been an active debate over its adequacy and over alternative approaches to measuring life events and to evaluating their stress-engendering properties. Nearly a decade ago Sandier and Guenther (1985) were able to list 15 critical reviews of stressful life event methodology, and similar commentary has continued to appear (e.g., McQuaid et al., 1992; Miller, 1989; Moos & Swindle, 1990; Newcomb, Huba, & Bentler, 1986; Raphael, Cloitre, & Dohrenwend, 1991). However, the checklist method has evolved in response to criticism, and a substantial array of different life event scales have been developed. Zimmerman (1983) provides a listing of 16 published and two unpublished life event inventories, and several more have appeared since (e.g., Barnett, Hanna, & Parker, 1983; Dohrenwend et al., 1993; Swearingen & Cohen, 1985). It is clear, in addition, that many other "hybrid" mixtures of existing inventories are used regularly in research. Zimmerman (1983) is among those who believe that the more recently developed inventories have overcome many of the central criticisms of the checklist method, a view that has been contested by others (e.g., Brown, 1981; Monroe, 1982a, 1982b; Raphael et al., 1991). Despite several clearly justified criticisms and associated questions about the reliability and validity of resulting scores, the various published and unpublished life event inventories collectively represent the traditional, and still dominant, research procedure for estimating variations in stress exposure. A substantial preponderance of the now massive literature assessing the linkage between social stress and health is based upon checklist measures of life stress. It is this literature that has compellingly indicated a reliable association between life stress and the occurrence of both psychological distress and psychiatric disorder (Kessler, Price, & Wortman, 1985; Myers, Lindenthal, & Pepper, 1975; Paykel, 1978; Tausig, 1982; Thoits, 1983). Similarly, on the basis of a large number of studies in which checklists have been employed, most authorities (e.g., Barrett, Rose, & Klerman, 1979; Dohrenwend & Dohrenwend, 1974; Jenkins, 1976; Minter & Kimble, 1978) have deemed the weight of evidence to indicate that people exposed to stressful life events are at
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
31
greater risk for physical health problems. For example, Jemmot and Locke (1984) report that individuals exposed to high levels of life stress (as measured by life events) experience "greater degeneration of overall health, more diseases of the upper respiratory tract, more allergies, a greater incidence of hypertension and a greater risk of sudden cardiac death and coronary diseases than do people who have been exposed to a low degree of life stress" (Jemmot & Locke, 1984:79). The significance of life stress has also been reported in relation to tuberculosis, diabetes, arthritis, cancer (Holmes & Masuda, 1974), accidents (Selzer & Vinokur, 1974), athletic injuries (Bramwell, Wagner, Masuda, & Holmes, 1975), and poor academic performance (Lloyd, Alexander, Rice, & Greenfield, 1980). One conclusion that seems to follow from the consistency with which relationships are observed between event accumulations and distress and disorder is that whatever the shortcomings of the method, event inventories yield estimates of stress exposure that are meaningful. There are essentially two challenges to this conclusion. One is that observed associations are an artifact of operational confounding arising from the fact that many event checklists, perhaps the majority historically, have included items that are themselves symptoms, or indicators, of physical or mental illness or distress, or logical consequences of these problems. The issue is considered below in relation to "event selection." Here we simply note that although some research has suggested that measurement confounding or contamination may account for the persistent association between life event measures and both physical (Schroeder & Costa, 1984) and psychological health (Thoits, 1981), many more studies have demonstrated that the relationships at issue persist, and are little attenuated, when confounded items are removed from consideration (Billings & Moos, 1982; Grant, Sweetwood, Yager, & Gerst, 1981; McFarlane, Norman, Streiner, Roy, & Scott, 1980; Mueller, Edwards, & Yarvis, 1977a; Sandier & Block, 1979; Tausig, 1982). The second challenge has to do with the possibility of what could be termed "causal confounding," in fact, the possibility of causal reciprocity with outcome variables. Concern that illness or distress also produces either a real or artifactually higher number of reported events has been a continuing theme of the life events literature. This issue needs to be clarified before we proceed. First, the possibility that illness also causes stress exposure does not question the causal status of stress with respect to illness; it simply complicates the proper estimation of this causal impact. The same could be said for other possible variables that act as background confounders related to both stress exposure and later illness: to state the obvious, their impact must be controlled either statistically, or by design. Second, evidence from longitudinal studies consistently suggests that if one controls for prior or baseline distress or mental health, life events have a net impact on change in distress or mental health over time (Aneshensel & Frerichs, 1982; Eaton, 1978; Myers, Lindenthal, & Pepper, 1974; Turner & Noh, 1988; Turner & Roxburgh, in press). Thus, at least with respect to mental health, two essential criteria of causality are supported in the literature: (1) statistical association and (2) temporal or logical precedence. The most important remaining issue is the possibility of spuriousness in the effect of life events on health outcomes. It is much more difficult to establish this criterion, but it is fair to say that the literature is replete with examples of attempts to
32
The Environmental Perspective
control for confounding factors in the events-illness relationship and yet precious few examples that actually refute this relationship. Thus, although less than definitive, we believe the evidence is suggestive of the plausibility and even the likelihood that the experience of stressful events is causally implicated in observed variations in health risk. In this chapter we provide information and make recommendations relevant to fashioning an appropriate life event inventory. The major issues examined include: 1. The definition of events and the distinction between events and other possible sources of social stress. 2. Event selection and the relevance of, and effects on findings of, content differences and number of events comprising the inventory. The significance of the content issue is also considered in relation to age and cultural variations in study populations. 3. Use of change versus presumed undesirability as a basis for defining events to be included on inventories. 4. Operational confounding in event measures. 5. The importance of comprehensiveness of event lists. 6. The effects of variation in role occupancy on event score totals. 7. Time frames for studying eventful stressors. 8. The advisability of, and alternative approaches to, event weighting. 9. Reliability concerns. The final section presents a summary of our recommendations regarding event checklists and evaluates their adequacy for estimating variations in exposure to social stress. We also comment on some promising innovations that have been applied within event inventories, and argue that a more encompassing checklist procedure can provide dramatically better estimates of stress exposure than event inventories have so far provided. Our discussion assumes throughout that "checklists" refer in fact to both interview-derived and self-administered inventories (since the lists used are often the same), and that inventories form the core starting point of contextually scored measures.
Defining and Selecting Life Events Since negative change, or rather, the undesirable demand or threat accompanying change, is generally assumed to represent a basis for the experience of stress, we suggest that the universe of eventful stress is uniquely characterized by discrete and, in principle, observable environmental and social changes. These changes are potentially threatening because they precipitate the need for adjustment in identity or life routines and are sufficiently important in their potential impact that they cannot be interpreted or treated as relatively routine exigencies of daily life. This definition specifically excludes minor events that are more precisely considered hassles or irritants, insidiously developing life conditions that could be considered stressful, and more enduring or chronic problems. Our approach recognizes the worth and the necessity of separating sources of
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
33
stress as distinct factors in the stress process. A basic question is, when does an event stop being an event? The essential components of our definition of event stress are the facts of (1) discreteness, (2) observability in principle, and (3) a self-limiting time course (for the event, not necessarily the consequences). Thus, when considering the effects of job loss, we consider job loss the event and any resulting financial strain a separate, chronic stressor, in part caused by the job loss. Note that financial strain can have other causes, and thus it cannot be considered "part" of the event of job loss. In the case of divorce, we would treat any ensuing role overload due to single parenthood a separate stressor, not part of the "event." To fold such consequences into the event would be a mistake for two reasons: (1) It would disallow the separate predictive and explanatory role of other forms of stress; and (2) whether chronic stress follows from the event is an empirically contingent matter and not a necessary part of the process of the event. Some job losses are not followed by financial strain because the spouse goes to work; some divorces do not lead to role overload because a new relationship starts, and so on. It is clear that the occurrence of some "events" can signal the onset of enduring difficulties that may eventually have independent stress-evoking potential. The question of the health significance of an event, relative to other sources or types of stress, has yet to be convincingly answered; however, it is plausible that some portion of the well-established relationship between life events and health derives from associated difficulties or strains consequent to the occurrence of the event. The above definition, like that previously quoted from Dohrenwend et al. (1982), emphasizes the goal of assessing differences in exposure to social and environmental stress rather than differences in the experience of events based on their personally attributed meanings. Since research subjects self-report events occurring in their lives, there is inevitably a subjective element. However, many stress researchers view the central properties of events as relatively objective in nature. These properties include whether or not the event occurred, to whom the event occurred, and when the event occurred. In our opinion, there are heuristic advantages to conceptualizing life events as objective or quasi-objective phenomena because failure to do so tends to confound differences in exposure to events of stress-evoking potential with differences in vulnerability to such events. It is not suggested that the individuals' perception and appraisal of experienced events are unimportant. Indeed, we see the personal experience of stress as a joint function of the nature and severity of the event and of the individual's capacity (perceived and real) to handle it in both emotional and practical terms. This latter element, which reflects vulnerability differences that condition the rate at which exposure to stressors is translated into distress or illness, has usually been indexed in terms of such factors as prior experience, possession of relevant coping skills, and availability of personal and social coping resources, deary's (1981) position on this issue is appropriate: "An attempt should be made to keep the assessment of ... events separate from the assessment of various mediating factors and other processes contributing to illness" (p. 311). Only when a clear distinction is maintained between the relatively objective estimation of level of exposure to eventful stressors and reactions to eventful stressors can the respective significance of exposure and vulnerability be evaluated and the potential of inter-
34
The Environmental Perspective
vention efforts in these two domains be estimated. It is important to note that this distinction is jeopardized by efforts to weight inventory items differentially on the basis of respondent reports of the severity or stressfulness of experienced events. It is evident that the assessment of life events by checklist is hardly a standardized procedure. In terms of item content, a substantial number of different lists have been generated and employed in research but none stands out as definitively superior to the others. Moreover, as several reviewers seem to imply (Cleary, 1980; 1981; Monroe, 1982a; Zimmerman, 1983), a specific definitive list of appropriate events that can be applied across a range of study populations cannot be specified and should not be recommended. Obviously, lists that attempt general comprehensiveness will include items that are not relevant to particular target populations. Examples include items like "retirement," "started menopause," and "spouse died," which are quite irrelevant within an adolescent or young adult population, and items like "failed a grade in school" and "started work for the first time" are of unlikely significance for the elderly. That the inclusion of events that are irrelevant to many respondents is, in most instances, inevitable is demonstrated by the fact that even within a relatively homogeneous population, individuals vary substantially with respect to their occupancy of social roles, and the relevance of many events is tied to role occupancy. It seems clear that the rational requirement that "events listed in a life events inventory must be ones for which the individuals in a study population would be at risk in the time span over which the study respondents would be required to report" (Hurst, 1979:18), can seldom be achieved in general, and never be achieved within general population studies. Given this circumstance, it seems crucial to ensure that the event list incorporates a reasonable and balanced representation of events that are of potential relevance to respondents occupying differing constellations of role sets. Beyond this requirement, appropriate item content of a selected or devised inventory depends upon the nature of the population and of the outcomes being studied. A primary consideration in this regard, of course, is the age or life stage of the target sample. Recognition of the importance of this dimension has led to the development of checklists tailored specifically for children, adolescents, and elderly populations (see Appendix for examples). In addition, despite early reports indicating that the meaning of events in terms of the adaptation required is consistent across nationalities, cultures, races, and income levels (Holmes & Masuda, 1972; Masuda & Holmes, 1967a, 1967b) evidence that the perceived stressfulness of events differs from culture to culture (Askenasy, Dohrenwend, & Dohrenwend, 1977; Dohrenwend, Krasnoff, Askenasy, & Dohrenwend, 1978; Hough, Fairbank, & Garcia, 1976), suggests that event lists should be tailored to the cultural group and, indeed, to whatever other specific subgroup may be the focus of the investigation (Hurst, 1979). In this connection, the recommendation seems appropriate that events selected from other inventories, based on their apparent relevance, be supplemented by events nominated by representatives of the target group itself, from their own experience and that of others they know (Dohrenwend et al., 1978). As Monroe (1982a:438) has noted, this kind of approach has the disadvantage that it does not allow stress score comparisons across diverse populations; however, "the advan-
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
35
tages in terms of instrument sensitivity and relevance suggests its utility over more 'standardized' procedures." This problem is ameliorated somewhat by one feature of the literature that should be mentioned in reference to event selection. Despite the fact that there are many variants of life event inventories in existence, it is now apparent that content differences do not result in major differences in the magnitude of relationships, at least with respect to well-known mental health outcomes. Whether this is true for physical health outcomes is less clear. In other words, in using life events to predict mental health, concerns about moderate content differences between one inventory and another are probably misplaced, as long as the major events are included. Such events are also likely to be the common core of many inventories.
Change Events Versus Negative Change Events As noted earlier, there is a continuing debate about whether it is change or undesirability that is relevant to the experience of stress. The resolution of this issue requires a criterion against which to evaluate these alternatives, but the selection of the best criterion in itself merits prolonged debate. However, since the purpose of this volume is to consider measurement strategies for assessing the significance of life stress for physical and mental health, we follow the lead of researchers with similar interests (e.g., Mueller et al., 1977b; Myers et al., 1974; Ross & Mirowsky, 1979; Vinokur & Selzer, 1975) in accepting power to predict the dependent variable as the relevant criterion. This standard, of course, was suggested in Selye's (1976:78) definition of a stressor as "that which produces stress" and has been explicitly or implicitly adopted within many conceptualizations of the stress process (e.g., Pearlin, Lieberman, Menaghan, & Mullan, 1981; Rabkin & Struening, 1976). Since we have no means of directly assessing the experience of stress (biologically defined) in field settings, reports or other indices of distress or illness must be taken as both reflections and consequences of the experience of stress. Kahn and Quinn (1970:51-52, quoted in Ross & Mirowsky, 1979) providing a succinct commentary on the issue, describe stressors as a stimulus situation, the properties of which are response inferred. . . . The problem with this definition of stress is its apparent circularity. . . . The solution to this circularity is not to abandon completely the notion that stress is response-inferred, but to regard it as defined by the response of a whole class of organisms rather than by the responses of a particular individual.
Based on the conclusion that stressfulness is effectively indexed by the distress or illness response of collectivities of individuals, considerable evidence on the change versus undesirability issue has accumulated. From a review of 17 studies that examined the relationships of desirable and undesirable events to measures of psychological distress, Zautra and Reich (1983) observed a consistent pattern of clear positive relationships with negative events in contrast to weak and contradictory findings with respect to positive events. Moreover, in those studies that did find
36
The Environmental Perspective
positive events to be associated with increased distress, the relationship could no longer be observed when differences in negative events were taken into consideration. Evidence suggesting the dominant significance of negative compared to positive events as risk factors for distress and illness has been consistent across a range of study populations, dependent variables, and event inventories (e.g., Mueller, Edwards, & Yarvis 1977a, 1977b; Ross & Mirowsky, 1979; Vinokur & Selzer, 1975), and we see no basis for not taking both these findings and their practical implications seriously. However, we cannot with confidence conclude that ostensibly positive life changes play no role in either elevating or conditioning stress experiences, because the mechanisms involved may be more complex than research has so far been able to reveal. Our recommendation from available evidence is that the limited time and space considerations that characterize most questionnaires and interviews require that the content of life event checklists be restricted to events that are presumptively undesirable in nature, and that questions on events normally considered as positive be excluded.
Confounding of Events with Outcomes The issue of operational confounding was referred to earlier in relation to the suggestion that such confounding might account for the persistent but modest associations observed between event scores and various health outcomes. We indicated that the weight of evidence is reassuring on this matter, revealing that confounded events make only a small contribution and that the relationship quite generally persists when clearly confounded and questionable events are excluded from consideration. However, although it is not a viable competing hypothesis, it is nonetheless an issue of significance when selecting from available checklists or assembling events for one's own list. The problem of employing events that are themselves indicators or symptoms of illness or adaptational problems when assessing the health-stress relationship has been repeatedly raised in relation to the SRRS as well as other checklists. It has even been suggested that 39 of the 43 events contained in the Holmes and Rahe (1967) scale could be viewed as symptoms or consequences rather than precipitants of illness (Hudgens, 1974). Dohrenwend and Dohrenwend (1974, 1978), having considered the issue in some detail, concluded that events included in the typical inventory are of three types: (1) those that are confounded with the subject's psychological functioning; (2) those that reflect physical illness; and (3) those that are independent of the subject's physical and psychological health status. In their view, the question of the etiologic significance of eventful stress could best be addressed by restricting consideration to the third category of fateful or adventitious events. Although Zimmerman (1983) has forcefully argued that many of the problems that have led to criticism of the SRRS have been corrected in subsequent instruments, he also notes that a number of more recent scales have failed to exclude some obviously confounded events. Our own view is that regardless of how minimal the impact may be on observed relationships to health status, no event should be included that may directly reflect, in a measurement sense, an individual's physical
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
37
or mental health status. To emphasize "in a measurement sense" is to say that events that are confounded purely because the probability of their occurrence is affected by health status should be—indeed, need to be—included. As noted earlier, causality can occur validly in both directions. The fact that the occurrence of a life event may be partially determined by a prior disorder does not disqualify this event, at a further stage of the event-disease dynamic, from having causal impact on later disorder. Such causal reciprocity, if it exists, should be explicitly investigated, not r oved from consideration. In discussing such events, Shrout (1981:35) has noted: Since these events themselves presumably add to the stress a person experiences, there exists a feedback loop between life events and health status. Clearly, the inclusion of such events . . . would result in the overestimation of the causal impact of stress on illness, yet the elimination of such events . . . would result in the underestimation of stress and consequently the underestimation of the causal impact of stress.
The fact is, however, that inclusion of such events does not lead to overestimation if causal reciprocity is properly modeled or controlled as part of the analytical process (Kessler, 1983). Thus, inclusion of such events is justified. At the same time, we also believe that in the area of measurement confounding per se, there is little evidence of confounding in the event lists now commonly used for mental health status, although care must be exercised in choosing events to avoid confounding with physical health status.
Comprehensiveness of Event Lists It is clear that the Holmes and Rahe (1967) checklist, and most subsequent inventories, contain only a sampling or subset of potentially stressful life events. One problem with this approach is that item sampling theory as it is applied to test construction has not been, and cannot be of much assistance. This means first and foremost that there is no basis for defining a universe of relevant events. As far as we know, no investigator has reported a selection procedure in which every possible event of stress-evoking potential had an equal chance of selection, and few would claim to have identified the full range of events from which a representative sample could be drawn. More importantly, the development of an events checklist is conceptually distinct from test construction because the items are s cifi lly not alternative estimates of a single underlying construct, characteris , experience. Since it is not necessarily the case that the experience of one eve increases the likelihood of another, there should be no expectation that event inv tories display internal reliability as estimated by Cronbach's (1951) alpha. On the contrary, high coefficient alpha val es and high correlations between individual items, rather than constituting a desirable circumstance, may signal problems with item redundancy, as Pugh and colleagues (1971) have noted, or of both item redundancy and causal dependency among items, as Cleary (1981) has suggested. On the other hand, there are grounds for anticipating nonzero or even modest intercorrelations, among at least a subset of eventful stressors. This expectation is
38
The Environmental Perspective
associated with a perspective recently enunciated by Pearlin (1989), who effectively argued the need for attention to the structural contexts of people's lives. In his view, stressful occurrences and circumstances are among those experiences that are rooted in these contexts, and thus, there is a basis for assuming that variations in exposure to stressors arise substantially out of contemporary and developmental conditions of life. Expressing a similar position, Aneshensel (1992) has called for a conceptual reorientation away from the view of stress as an isolated risk factor and toward its consideration as a link in a chain that begins with social conditions and ends with differences in risk for distress and illness. She draws a distinction between systemic stressors and random stressors. Random stressors are those that are not embedded in social location or social experience over the life course, they occur with roughly equal probability across the various social groups that are known to differ in their risk for mental and physical health problems. Events such as "friendship ended," "miscarriage," or "family member dies" are relatively independent of most social statuses. Although such stressors are important as predictors of health risk, they are not helpful in explaining established linkages between social conditions and such risk. Systemic stressors are those that are tied to social location and/or social group experience, and thus are directly relevant to understanding what ties health to the social conditions of life. Obviously, events such as losing a job, foreclosure of a loan, going on welfare, being assaulted or robbed, and divorce tend to be linked to one's location in the social system. To the extent that risk for some portion of listed events is associated with ongoing conditions of social life, intercorrelations among such items will be observed. This means that such intercorrelations have a substantive rather than measurement meaning, and should be interpreted as such, perhaps indicating as well internal causal sequences among sets of events. From a conceptual perspective, the central basis for preferring a comprehensive approach has been clearly described by Shrout (1981:34), who notes that life event lists must be complete because if any event that adds to stress is not included, our estimate of stress for persons who experience that event will be inaccurate. From this perspective, the notion of a "sample of life events" is misapplied to research on stress. Since life events are largely independent of one another, we cannot make any inferences about some life events based on information about others for a given person.
In Shrout's opinion, failure to include relevant events may result in substantial error in estimates of stress exposure, and such error may produce a significant underestimation of the relationship between stress exposure and health outcomes. We agree that there is no theoretical or logical basis for excluding items for which there is evidence that risk for distress or illness is elevated among those exposed, regardless of how rarely the event occurs in the target population. Moreover, we subscribe to the view that a relatively comprehensive approach is advisable for studies that aspire to improve measurement or focus on the intricacies of the stress process. However, for those interested in straightforward estimation of the effect of eventful stress, considered as an aggregate total, our advice is quite different. We suggest a list of 30 to 50 reasonably prevalent events drawn from extant
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
39
checklists and supplemented as necessary to ensure relevance and appropriateness for the population being studied. This recommendation is based on the apparent absence of any compelling evidence suggesting that longer, more comprehensive lists yield substantially different findings, and considering practical data acquisition requirements associated with time, costs, and respondent burden. In other words, despite the seemingly obvious truth of Shrout's position, evidence seems to suggest an empirical "upper limit" to associations of eventful stress and health outcomes, as if there exists a core of potent items that are most relevant and a similar proportion of "dead weight" items regardless of the length of the inventory. The tension between the need for comprehensiveness and practicality can be reduced somewhat by regular use of follow-up questioning after a given checklist about other important events that have happened over the target time period. We have found that about half of the responses to this kind of follow-up are codable and recognizable as life events, whereas the other half are clearly symptoms, daily hassles, or chronic stressors. Investigators can choose to supplement their life event totals with these postcoded events and compare results with the predefined list. We find that this practice either allows quite rare events to have an impact or reveals events that are essentially replicated in the inventory but are worded slightly differently. We also suggest that an open-ended question cannot be used in place of specific event lists, because of the increased chance of differential recall bias and increased coding unreliability in open-ended answers. A conservative approach would be to use an open-ended question only as a supplement, and to code only an event that is likely to be mentioned with equal probability by most respondents who have actually experienced the event.
Role Occupancy and Event Exposure Problems in interpretation of the effects of event totals due to variation in role occupancy are rarely mentioned in the literature (recent exceptions include Raphael et al., 1991, and Aneshensel, 1992). We wish briefly to point out why such problems require consideration. When, for example, respondents do not work, by definition they are not at risk for conflict with the boss, or being demoted or being fired; they are not at risk for divorce or other relationship difficulties if they are unmarried or have no partner, and only those with children can experience difficulties with, and the difficulties of, their children. As a result, respondents in fewer social roles are likely to have lower stressful event scores. The implications of this confounding are not entirely clear, but one argument is that respondents with more role occupancies (worker, partner, parent, etc.) are in those roles because of generalized social competence, and as such, life event totals will be confounded with social competence. If this is the case, the problem is that this is a positive correlation, but social competence will be negatively correlated with distress/disorder. This combination implies a suppressor (i.e., negative) component in the otherwise positive correlation between events and health problems, thereby reducing the size of this positive correlation. This possibility has rarely been considered. Fortunately, this possibility can be investigated by counting and con-
40
The Environmental Perspective
structing either role occupancy (as in a count of roles) or role configuration measures (Thoits, 1987), and adjusting for such confounding in the estimation of impacts of events on health outcomes. In longitudinal studies, if one wants to control for "at risk" status in assessing the effects of events, it is important to remember that role occupancy should be coded from the beginning of the observation period, not at the end. Thus, for example, if the interest is in the effects of widowhood, one must use baseline status and select a group of married respondents.
Event Timing, Interval, and Duration Although most studies on the health effects of eventful stress have employed a 1-year time frame for the occurrence of relevant events, the maximum lag time considered has varied from a few weeks to several years. Aside from convenience in questioning respondents, the original rationale for the 1-year time frame appears to have been the assumption that the effects of increased stress tend to become manifest in about a year's time (Holmes, 1979; Holmes & Masuda, 1974). However, as Monroe (1982a) has observed, the evidence for this assumption is limited and methodologically questionable (Dohrenwend et al., 1978). Moreover, most of the events obtained on the basis of a 1-year interval will have occurred within a time frame less than 1 year before the outcome of interest. Evidence suggesting the appropriateness of alternative time frames appears split, pointing to intervals on both sides of the 1-year standard. Thus, Brown and Harris (1978) reported that the lag time between the experience of events and the onset of clinically significant depression appeared to be less that 6 months. Consistent with this and other evidence (Murphy & Brown, 1980), Turner and Roxburgh (in press) found, from a three-wave panel analysis, that the effects of eventful stressors were limited to a 6-month interval. In contrast, investigations employing 2, 4 and 5-year time frames (Eaton, 1978; Thurlow, 1971; Wyler, Masuda, and Holmes, 1971) have reported higher correlations than many studies that have considered shorter periods. If forced to suggest a single time-frame boundary, we see a minimum of a 1-year reference period as appropriate with respect to most events that are typically assessed using the checklist strategy. It is long enough to obtain a reasonable estimate of variations in exposure to recent life events, and short enough to avoid the substantial decline in the ability of respondents to recall events that appears to occur beyond the 1-year time frame. A more general recommendation, however, is that the appropriate time frame will necessarily depend on the nature of the outcome and the inherent causal lag of events for that outcome. In addition, one can investigate the decline in event reporting as a function of months and develop cut-points for a time frame based on the results. It is important to recognize that the problem of reliability of reporting or remembering, and the conclusion that stressors may be very time limited in their effects, cannot be applied equally to all events that may be experienced. For example, it would rarely be the case that a subject would not remember, or fail to report in response to specific questions, that his or her parent had died, or child had died, or
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
41
parents had divorced; that he or she had served in combat, or had been physically or sexually assaulted, or had been abused as a child. There is evidence that a number of traumatic events or circumstances such as these are relevant to mental health and that the duration of their effects is closer to lifetime than to 6 months or 1 year (Rutter, 1989). For example, a substantial body of evidence suggests the possible long-term psychiatric significance of parental loss (e.g., Faravelli, Ambonetti, & Pallanti, 1986; Tennant, 1988), perhaps through the well-established risk factor of maternal lack of care (Birtchnell, 1988; Parker & Hadzi-Pavlovic, 1984). Research also indicates the significance for adult mental health of childhood experiences of parental conflict and divorce (Lauer & Lauer, 1991; McLeod, 1991) and of physical or sexual abuse (Brown & Anderson, 1991; Bryer, Nelson, & Miller, 1987). Kessler and Magee (1993) have recently reported on the long-term relationships between eight forms of childhood adversity and adult depression. They found seven of the eight to be directly associated with early onset of depression. In this study, early trauma is related to adult depression because it has a relatively immediate effect on mental health which either has stability through the life course or is recurrent in terms of episodes. Several rather dramatic and severe events such as the death of a child or the untimely death of one's spouse have, of course, often been incorporated in event lists. However, the rarity of such events within the 6 months or 1 year covered by the typical inventory has inevitably masked their potential health significance. Thus, there are a range of events that, presumably, can be reliably measured and that can have significant mental health consequences despite their occurrence years or even decades earlier. These twin facts argue strongly for the systematic inclusion of lifetime experience of such events as part of the effort to assess differences in exposure to eventful stressors. Within several studies in our ongoing research program we have incorporated a supplementary checklist of 20 lifetime events or traumas. In addition to ascertaining whether each event had been experienced, subjects are asked their age at first and last occurrence. Preliminary analyses reveal the majority of these major lifetime events to be associated with significant elevation in risk for a lifetime diagnosis of major depressive disorder. Both the available research literature and our own experience justify the recommendation that a separate list of lifetime events or traumas be added to inventories of recent events. Checklist events for which there is evidence of long-term health effects should be transferred to the lifetime traumas list to avoid a temporal sample that is limited to a single year. Analyses should consider both the direct health effects of lifetime traumas and the extent to which they may condition the impact of more contemporaneous stressors.
Duration of Recent Life Events As the present volume explicitly acknowledges, it is well recognized that both discrete life events and relatively enduring problems are relevant to distress and illness. As Pearlin and colleagues (Pearlin, 1983; Pearlin et al., 1981) have suggested, the experience of eventful stress may alter the meanings of existing strains,
42
The Environmental Perspective
generate new strains, or magnify existing strains. Alternatively, the impact of recent events may be amplified in the presence of chronic stress (Brown & Harris, 1978; Paykel, 1978). The testing of such ideas, however, must confront the problem of conceptually and operationally disentangling eventful stressors from events that signal the onset of an enduring source of stress. Some occurrences of a given event may be discrete or time-limited in nature, whereas other occurrences of the same event may represent the beginning of a long-term difficulty. One strategy for distinguishing such important differences is that applied by Turner and Avison (1992; Avison & Turner, 1988), who obtained information for each reported event on when it ended as well as when it had occurred. Analyses confirmed their suspicion that life event checklists routinely provide information on differences in exposure to more typically enduring, as well as more discrete, stressors. They found that the majority of all events reported by their large community sample (n = 1561) to be discrete in nature, with nearly 70 percent beginning and ending in the same month, and more than 76 percent lasting less than 3 months. However, a substantial proportion were more chronic, with 19.3 percent spanning 10 months or longer. It is important to note that although events that intuitively seem more enduring (e.g., problems with children, problems with one's parents, and financial difficulties) were substantially overrepresented among long-lasting events, the majority of occurrences of each of these were reported to have been time-limited or discrete in nature. Moreover, none of the 31 negative events assembled by these investigators from established lists were found to be uniformly experienced as either discrete or chronic stressors. Thus, it is clear that no reported association between checklist scores and health outcomes reflects the effects of purely discrete events. Having distinguished discrete from enduring stressors reflected in checklist responses, Avison and Turner (1988) were able to show that both have important independent effects on psychological distress, and that a more effective estimate of an individual's burden of stress at a given point in time is achieved by considering both recently occurring events and the enduring stressors to which the individual is still subjected—a concept we have referred to in our research as the "operant burden" of stress (Turner, Wheaton, & Lloyd, in press). Since it appears that events are salient in terms of their stress-evoking potential for varying periods of time, and that such variations are relevant to health outcomes, effective measurement requires information about the onset and conclusion of the stressful experiences tapped by event checklists. We strongly recommend the inclusion of probes to obtain this important information on all reported events. As detailed elsewhere in this volume, there is substantial basis for attaching significance to chronic stress (e.g., Liem & Liem, 1978; Ross & Huber, 1985) and to support the contention that it may be of primary significance for mental health (Pearlin & Lieberman, 1979; Wheaton, 1991). The research just reviewed leaves little doubt that enduring stress is a part of what is reflected in associations of checklist scores with health outcomes and that it is possible to distinguish its contribution. However, it is equally clear that an event checklist, regardless of whether probes are included to identify continuing stressors, is too limited and too narrow in content to provide even a remotely adequate estimate of an individual's recent or ongoing exposure to chronic stressors. Wheaton (1991) has recently of-
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
43
fered a 51-item inventory that assesses a wide range of role-related and roleunrelated chronic stressors. Elsewhere we have shown that when scores from this inventory are combined with the burden of stress estimated from the events checklist, the variance in depressive symptomatology and in major depressive disorder accounted for by stress exposure is about 21/2 times greater than has typically been reported in the literature (Turner et al., in press). Our point is not to recommend one or another approach to measuring chronic stress; that is the task of a separate chapter. It is rather that, because conventional event inventories estimate exposure to eventful stressors and partially estimate exposure to more continuing forms of potentially stressful experience, checklists for measuring social stress are clearly incomplete unless they incorporate a separate sampling of items addressed to the general domain of chronic stress.
Event Weighting Despite the considerable attention paid to differential weighting of events in the literature, the issue is still not settled, and we believe that some attention to this issue is still necessary. There are many types of weighting, but the two most common are "objective" ratings of the change, or importance, or seriousness, of events by "judges," selected in random samples of defined populations, in purposive samples of individuals who have experienced the event being weighted, or by expert panels, and "subjective" ratings assigned by individuals to their own events and considered at the individual level only. Perhaps the basic difference between the two is the level of aggregation of the weight: Objective weights reflect an average assigned by a group of raters; subjective weights involve self-reporting by individuals as to how serious the event was to them. Despite repeated and widespread attempts to prove otherwise, the best conclusion from the existing research concerning the effectiveness of differential weighting using current approaches is that weighted indices do not generally increase the correlation with outcomes, whether using objective or (surprisingly) subjective weights (Monroe, 1982a; Sandier & Guenther, 1985; Zimmerman, 1983). On the other hand, as nicely pointed out by Zimmerman (1983), the use of unweighted indices puts the life event literature in the absurd position of implying no differences in impact potential across events. It is not generally realized that different weighting schemes have implicitly contrasting goals. Averaged "objective" weights derived from samples of raters are attempts at capturing differences in the characteristics of events that imply differences in impact potential that apply across individuals (Thoits, 1983), whereas subjective weights attempt to capture differences in the impact potential associated with variations in the "meaning" of an event, across individuals. Forced to choose, we prefer the former logic. There is nothing inherently wrong with specifying group-averaged weights, with the understanding that all they can capture, all they should capture, is the average differences in impact potential. Concern about subjective weights most often centers on the issue of confounding of events with outcomes when events are subjectively weighted. First we note
44
The Environmental Perspective
that in longitudinal data, it may be possible to take into account this kind of confounding by controlling for time 1 health status, when using time 1 or time 2 events to predict outcomes at time 2. The effect of health status on event scores is partialed out of the effect of events on later health, and thus the bias is reduced. But our concern with subjective weights applies to quite another issue: the confounding of stress exposure with differential vulnerability to stress, in other words, the confusion of stress with coping. We contend that the weight attached by a respondent to an event will be largely a function of his or her capacity, real or perceived, to resolve that event in emotional or practical terms. The stress process model argues appropriately that such capacity is a function of coping skills and of the availability of social and personal resources. Thus, subjective ratings confound the effects of stress mediators with those of stress exposure and should therefore be discouraged even in prospective studies and studies on physical health status. A preferable approach is to allow the issue of differences in impact potential to be conceptualized, albeit indirectly, via the specification of coping resources and use of coping strategies. These factors should be considered as separate factors in the explanation of health outcomes, and the ways in which these factors combine with stress events to predict outcomes should be investigated as part of estimating the correct model (e.g., additive burden vs. interactive stress-buffering). Returning to the issue of objective weights, it may be the case that the whole issue has been laid to rest prematurely. Over 10 years ago, a series of publications provided both advice and clues that at least one approach to weighting—regressionbased weighting in which the effects of individual events are weighted in the total index by their effects on the outcome—did provide much larger correlations with outcomes than other approaches (Ross & Mirowsky, 1979; Shrout, 1981; Tausig, 1982). There are basic objections to this approach: that it is atheoretical, and that it leads to nongeneralizable weights. We believe these criticism to be at least potentially misleading in one crucial respect, although correct in other respects. Shrout (1981) shows that the correlation between weighted and unweighted indices is directly a function of the standard deviation of the weights, relative to the mean of the weights. He argues further that regression-based weighting is an attractive approach, but requires very large samples. This is indeed one method of arriving at a set of stable weights, but it is also possible simply to report weights across studies and attempt to replicate results for "more" versus "less" severe events, roughly categorized. The latter approach, of course, assumes that the populations used are comparable. This does not advocate the use of specific weights per se; we concur with the weight of opinion that this is not a reasonable goal (Ross & Mirowsky, 1979). Rather, we believe that it is possible to find subsets of events that regularly surface across studies as the essential predictors. Following Shrout and others, we believe the point is more to identify and remove events from inventories that currently are in use but in fact are creating a "suppression" effect in correlations with health outcomes. In effect, this amounts to developing a cutoff for the importance of events—for example, its general statistical association across samples— and giving such events a weight of one, and others that rarely (if ever) have relevance a weight of zero.
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
45
The question is whether this approach will make any difference. The results using regression-based weighting are promising; that is, the differences in effects of events using this approach versus others is substantial. For example, Ross and Mirowsky report a correlation of .46 with distress symptoms compared to . 19 using the now standard undesirable count score. In our own data, derived from two separate studies in Toronto, we have found that the traditional variance explained by the unit-weighted count method of approximately 10 percent increases to about 20 to 26 percent, using either regression weighting (i.e., stepwise selected individual events) or bivariate correlations as the selection mechanism. Similar results have been obtained in other studies using the same event selection approach (N. Lin, 1993, personal communication). The point here is not the significance of this increase; all are very significant at the .0001 level or beyond. The point is that we would never keep items in a measure if we knew that such items were acting as suppressors. Despite the fact that the two inventories employed in our Toronto studies do not entirely overlap in item content and that the two distress measures used were different, there is some cross-validation of selection items: 85 percent of the events selected in one study appear in the list selected in the other study; and if we take the other study as the baseline, 75 percent of its selected events appear in the first study. These results suggest some potentially important possibilities. There may be a core of quite universally important events in the areas one might expect, such as deaths of intimates, relationship problems, financial crises, welfare dependency, assault victimization, and job demotions. Correspondingly, there may also be a large class of events, perhaps over 50 percent in most lists, that have little association with health outcomes for most people. If this is the case, this "dead weight" in life events scales needs to be specified and removed, and there is a need for cumulative evidence across studies about likely candidates. The problem posed by these deadweight events is that they may significantly reduce correlations with outcomes, offering a new interpretation of the classic concern with the modest association of life events with health outcomes (Rabkin & Struening, 1976; Thoits, 1983). The problem with the criticism that regression-based weighting results are not generalizable is that it prevents finding out whether in fact they are. If the literature had taken proper note of the Ross and Mirowsky (1979) findings, and of the suggestion of Shrout (1981) and Tausig (1982) that some events should be zeroweighted, the existing literature might already contain the required information. If regression weighting is used, we suggest that results be reported separately for traditional and any constructed indices based on the sample at hand. Note that any regression-weighted index built from results in the same sample is likely to build in some overspecificity due to "capitalizing on chance." Even if some of the increase in impact between traditional unit-weighted counts and regression-based weighting is due to chance, the size of the increase suggests that there are real differences in impact captured by selection of subsets of events. We need to be careful about two issues in removing events from lists. First, events may have only indirect effects on health outcomes through the occurrence of other consequent events. Thus, the fact that an event does not have a direct impact
46
The Environmental Perspective
does not mean that an event is unimportant. Second, events can still have important conditional impacts in subpopulations of interest, even if their relevance in general populations is minimal. Thus, if one is studying the elderly, it is wise to retain "retirement," even if it has no impact in general populations.
Reliability Concerns Reliability is a concern in that most studies report test-retest correlations for reports of events in the same period in the .4 to .7 range for test-retest intervals of 6 months or more (Neugebauer, 1981; Zimmerman, 1983). Some observers point out that the shorter time period is suspect, since the respondent may remember his or her earlier answer. Thus, the reliability as measured by test-retest correlations appears quite problematic. Some studies of reliability also assess the relevance of event characteristics, salience, and recency on consistency of reporting, and others use specific techniques during probing about events to increase recall accuracy (Brown & Harris, 1978). We do not wish to dispute the fact that reliability of event reporting is a problem, for some types of events and lengths of recall. Rather, we question the use of testretest correlations based on total event scores. This practice allows a score of 2, constituted by reporting a job loss and a divorce, to be consistent with a later of score of 2 after reporting an assault and a family member dying. The reliability of the total is important, but it is better to achieve that reliability by investigating the consistency of reporting individual items on inventories. Just as we suspect that events vary widely in their natural stress potential, we suspect that they also vary in their reliability. We are more likely to achieve greater reliability, if we pay attention to the differential reliability of items, rather than total scores. A recent study by Kessler and Wethington (1991) offers a new approach and more hopeful evidence about the reliability issue. They reason that traditional approaches to measuring reliability, like test-retest correlations, share the common problem of taking all errors to be equally problematic. But in the case of life events, inconsistencies are likely to result predominantly from failure to report events that occur and less often from the reporting of fictitious events. Based on this reasoning, the authors develop a new measure of reliability that does not count the presence of a report by only one rater necessarily as an error. Rather, the reliability is estimated using the probability of either of two raters reporting an event compared to an estimated number of true events assuming independent reporting across raters, much as one can infer all cells in a 2 x 2 table, given information about some cells. In addition, Kessler and Wethington use a range of techniques to improve reliability overall, including (1) cues to improve memory; (2) wording questions in such a way as to define the realm of events; and (3) a life events calendar which helps date onset and offset of events. These efforts result in substantially higher reliabilities than are usually reported in the literature, often above .80 for important events. Of course, the logic of multiple informants applies to multiple reports from the same informant over time. This method depends essentially on the idea that underreporting is more typical than imagined events, an assumption that may hold more clearly for discrete,
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
47
serious events within the last year than for childhood or more ongoing events without clear onset or offset.
Conclusions Our major recommendations can be summarized as follows: 1. We advocate the specification of events as a separate realm, distinguished from other sources of and types of stress, so that the importance of different types of stress can be compared and distinguished from both prior circumstances and associated consequences. 2. We do not advocate the use of one specific published list over others; rather we think that many different variations of lists are roughly equivalent in their operation. 3. The tailoring of events to fit the risk status of populations is recommended, as long as there is a core of commonly important events that tend to supersede cultural differences as well. 4. The literature justifies exclusion of clearly positive events and suggests focus on negative events. 5. Events that are direct measurement indicators of physical or mental health status or of other forms of stress (i.e., chronic) need to be removed, but events that are only causally affected by health status should be retained. 6. A "middle-range" of from 30 to 50 items seems both optimal in terms of predictive power and efficient in terms of use of time and space. 7. We believe that problems due to lack of comprehensiveness can be corrected to some degree by the use of an open-ended follow-up to the regular inventory for the purpose of eliciting unusual events. 8. Variation in role occupancy should be examined and incorporated as a control in estimating life event effects. 9. A minimum of a 1-year time frame should be used in asking about events, with longer periods justified for more severe or the most objectively verifiable events. 10. Information about the time course of each event should be gathered; 11. We agree with the emphasis in the literature that unweighted indices are as useful as any, but we also encourage separate analysis of selected events based on associations with outcomes and the effect of removing events that act as suppressors. 12. We believe that the reliability issue is somewhat misspecified in the literature and support the investigation of the consistency of reporting for individual items, following the techniques suggested by Kessler and Wethington (1991). We have assumed throughout that the study of life events is the study of only one form of stress exposure. Many forms of contextual factors may modify and shape the consequences of life events. It is important to realize that these factors that form the context of the occurrence of life events are not subservient in an overall model of health; they exist also as independent sources of health risk, quite apart from their
48
The Environmental Perspective
implications for the impact of life events. It is possible to include "context" in a number of ways in studying the effect of events. Even beyond those already mentioned, it is important to note that the array of other players in the stress process— prior chronic stress, the state of preexisting coping resources, concomitant events within and across social roles, to name a few examples—should also be seen as providing this contextual information. The difference between this approach to specifying context and other approaches is that the contextual effects of these factors become part of the process of estimating the optimal model for prediction of health status, both as separate factors and as conditioners of the impact of life events. Our approach to the application of life events involves the following irony: We advocate better totalities through careful attention to the individual parts. The tendency to treat the event total as an unassailable whole probably has had unfortunate consequences for the life event literature. At the same time, we do not believe that the traditional reliance on a summed score of life events—in some form—should be or will be supplanted by other approaches entirely. It is important to see that consideration of life events as a total score represents a specific piece of the stress argument, namely that there is a generic demand component to stressful occurrences that can be captured only by purposely adding up events despite content differences. In fact, before we "throw out the baby with the bath water," we need to remember that the implicit reason for counting and adding up stress exposure totals was exactly to specify the overall effects of demand, quite apart from the differences in content of stressors. Problems due to ignoring this content do suggest other approaches, such as the study of individual events, but, to turn the issue around, studying individual events does not capture the impact of total exposure either. This fact implies, we believe, that the effect of event totals can and should be considered as a background issue even in studies of the effects of individual events, such as divorce, widowhood, or job loss. This assumes, of course, that the specific event under study is removed from the remaining stress exposure total. Still, aggregate event stress exposure is meant to stand for the level of other sources of demand for adjustment apart from this event and, thus, is part of the contextual reality the individual faces in addition to the event of interest.
References Aneshensel, C. S. (1992). Social stress: Theory and research. Annual Review of Sociology, 18, 15-38. Aneshensel, C. S., & Frerichs, R. R. (1982). Stress, support and depression: A longitudinal causal model. Journal of Community Psychology, 10, 363-376. Askenasy, A. R., Dohrenwend, B. P., & Dohrenwend, B. S. (1977). Some effects of social class and ethnic group membership on judgements of the magnitude of stressful life events: A research note. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 18, 432-439. Avison, W. R., & Turner, R. J. (1988). Stressful life events and depressive symptoms: Disaggregating the effects of acute stressors and chronic strains. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 29, 253-264. Barnett, B.E.W., Hanna, B., & Parker, G. (1983). Life event scales for obstetric groups. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 27 (4), 313-320.
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
49
Barrett, J. E., Rose, R. M., & Klerman, G. L. (Eds.), (1979). Stress and mental disorder. Newyork: Raven. Billings, A. G., & Moos, R. H. (1982). Psychosocial theory and research on depression: An integrative framework and review. Clinical Psychology Review, 2, 213-237. Birtchnell, J. (1988). Depression and family relationships: A study of young married women on a London housing estate. British Journal of Psychiatry, 153, 758-769. Bramwell, S. T., Wagner, N. N., Masuda, M., & Holmes, T. H. (1975). Psychosocial factors in athletic injuries. Journal of Human Stress, 1, 6-20. Brown, G. R., & Anderson, B. W. (1991). Psychiatric morbidity in adult inpatients with childhood histories of sexual and physical abuse. American Journal of Psychiatry, 148, 55-61. Brown, G. W. (1981). Contextual measures of life events. In B. S. Dohrenwend & B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressful life events and their contexts (pp. 187-201). New York: Prodist. Brown, G. W. (1989). Life events and measurement. In G. W. Brown & T. O. Harris (Eds.), Life events and illness (pp. 3-45). New York: Guilford. Brown, G. W., & Harris, T. O. (1978). Social origins of depression. New York: Free Press. Bryer, J. B., Nelson, B. A., & Miller, J. B. (1987). Childhood sexual and physical abuse as factors in adult psychiatric illness. American Journal of Psychiatry, 144, 1426-1430. Cleary, P. J. (1980). A checklist for life event research. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 24, 199-207. Cleary, P. J. (1981). Problems of internal consistency and scaling in life events schedules. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 25(4), 309-320. Cronbach, L. J. (1951). Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests. Principles of Educational Psychological Measures, 18, 132-165. Dohrenwend, B. S. (1973). Life events as stressors: A methodological inquiry. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 14, 167-175. Dohrenwend, B. S., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (Eds.), (1974). Stressful life events: Their nature and effect. New York: Wiley. Dohrenwend, B. S., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1978). Some issues in research on stressful life events. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 166, 7-15. Dohrenwend, B. S., Krasnoff, L., Askenasy, A. R., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1978). Exemplification of a method for scaling life events: The PERI life events scales. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 19, 205-229. Dohrenwend, B. S., Krasnoff, L., Askenasy, A. R., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1982). The psychiatric epidemiology research interview life events scale. In L. Goldberger & S. Breznitz (Eds.), Handbook of stress: Theoretical and clinical aspects. New York: Free Press. Dohrenwend, B. P., Raphael, K. G., Schwartz, S., Stueve, A., & Skodol, A. (1993). The structured event probe and narrative rating method for measuring stressful life events. In L. Goldberger & S. Breznitz (Eds.), Handbook of stress (pp. 174-199). New York: Free Press. Eaton, W. W. (1978). Life events, social supports, and psychiatric symptoms: A re-analysis of the New Haven data. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 19(2), 230-234. Faravelli, C., Ambonetti, A., & Pallanti, S. (1986). Depressive relapses and incomplete recovery from index episode. American Journal of Psychiatry, 143, 888-891. Grant, I., Sweetwood, H. L., Yager, J., & Gerst, M. S. (1981). Quality of life events in relations to psychiatric symptoms. Archives of General Psychiatry, 38, 335-339. Hawkins, N. G., Davies, R., & Holmes, T. H. 1957. Evidence of psychosocial factors in the development of pulmonary tuberculosis. American Review of Tuberculosis and Pulmonary Diseases, 75, 768-780.
50
The Environmental Perspective
Holmes, T. H. (1979). Development and application of a quantitative measure of life change magnitude. In J. E. Barrett, R. M. Rose, & G. L. Klerman (Eds.), Stress and mental disorder. New York: Raven Press. Holmes, T. H., & Masuda, M. (1972). Psychosomatic syndrome: When mothers-in-law or other disasters visit, a person can develop a bad, bad cold. Or worse. Psychology Today, 72-73. Holmes, T. H., & Masuda, M. (1974). Life change and illness susceptibility. In B. S. Dohrenwend & B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressful life events: Their nature and effects (pp. 45-72). New York: Wiley. Holmes, T. H., & Rahe, R. H. (1967). The social readjustment rating scale. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 11, 213-218. Hough, R. L., Fairbank, D. T., & Garcia, A. M. (1976). Problems in the ratio measurement of life stress. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 17, 70-82. Hudgens, R. W. (1974). Personal catastrophe and depression: A consideration of the subject with respect to medically ill adolescents, and a requiem for retrospective life-event studies. In B. S. Dohrenwend & B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressful life events: Their nature and effects (pp. 119-134). New York: Wiley. Hurst, M. W. (1979). Life changes and psychiatric symptom development: Issues of context, scoring and clustering. In J. E. Barrett (Ed.), Stress and mental disorder (pp. 17-36). New York: Raven Press. Jemmott, J. B., & Locke, S. E. (1984). Psychosocial factors, immunologic mediation, and human susceptibility to infectious diseases: How much do we know? Psychological Bulletin, 95(1), 78-108. Jenkins, D. C. (1976). Recent evidence supporting psychologic and social risk factors for coronary disease. New England Journal of Medicine, 294, 987-994, 1033-1038. Kahn, R., & Quinn, R. (1970). Role stress: A framework for analysis. In A. McLean (Ed.), Mental health and work organizations (pp. 50-115). Chicago: Rand McNally. Kessler, R. C. (1983). Methodological issues in the study of psychosocial stress. In H. Kaplan (Ed.), Psychosocial stress: Trends in theory and research (pp. 267-341). Academic Press: New York. Kessler, R. C., & Magee, W. J. (1993). Childhood adversities and adult depression: Basic patterns of association in a U.S. national survey. Psychological Medicine, 23, 679-690. Kessler, R. C., Price, R. H., & Wortman, C. B. (1985). Social factors in psychopathology: Stress, social support, and coping processes. Annual Review of Psychology, 36, 531572. Kessler, R. C., & Wethington, E. (1991). The reliability of life event reports in a community survey. Psychological Medicine, 21, 723-738. Lauer, R. H., & Lauer, J. C. (1991). The long-term relational consequences of problematic family backgrounds. Family Relations, 40, 286-290. Liem, R., & Liem, J. (1978). Social class and mental illness reconsidered. The role of economic stress and social support. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 19, 139-156. Lloyd, C., Alexander, A. A., Rice, D. G., & Greenfield, N. S. (1980). Life events as predictors of academic performance. Journal of Human Stress, 6, 15-25. Masuda, M., & Holmes, T. H. (1967a). Magnitude estimations of social readjustments. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 11, 219-225. Masuda, M., & Holmes, T. H. (1967b). The social readjustment rating scale: A cross cultural study of Japanese and Americans. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 11, 227-237. McFarlane, A. H., Norman, G. R., Streiner, D. L., Roy, R., & Scott, D. J. (1980). A
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
51
longitudinal study of the influence of the psychosocial environment on health status: A preliminary report. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 21, 124-133. McLeod, J. (1991). Childhood parental loss and adult depression. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 35, 205-220. McQuaid, J. R., Monroe, S. M., Roberts, J. R., Johnson, S. L., Garamoni, G. L., Kupfer, D. J., & Frank E. (1992). Toward the standardization of life stress assessment: Definitional discrepancies and inconsistencies in methods. Stress Medicine, 8, 47-56. Miller, T. W. (1989). Life-event scaling: Clinical methodological issues. In T. Miller (Ed.), Stressful life events: International Universities Press Stress and Health Series, Monograph 4 (pp. 105-121). University Press. Minter, R. E., & Kimble, C. P. (1978). Life events and illness onset: A review. Psychosomatics, 19, 334-339. Monroe, S. M. (1982a). Life events assessment: Current practices, emerging trends. Clinical Psychological Review, 2, 435-453. Monroe, S. M. (1982b). Assessment of life events: Retrospective versus concurrent strategies. Archives of General Psychiatry, 39, 606-610. Monroe, S. M. (1982c). Life events and disorder: Event-symptom associations and the course of disorder. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 97(1), 14-24. Moos, R. H., & Swindle, R. W., Jr. (1990). Stressful life circumstances: Concepts and measures. Stress Medicine, 6, 171-178. Mueller, D. P., Edwards, D. W., & Yarvis, R. M. (1977a). Stressful life events and psychiatric symptomatology: Change or undesirability. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 18, 307-316. Mueller, D. P., Edwards, D. W., & Yarvis, R. M. (1977b). Stressful life events and community mental health center patients. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 165, 16-24. Murphy, E., & Brown, G. W. (1980). Life events, psychiatric disturbance, and physical illness. British Journal of Psychiatry, 136, 326-338. Myers, J. K., Lindenthal, J. J., & Pepper, M. P. (1974). Social class, life events, and psychiatric symptoms: A longitudinal study. In B. S. Dohrenwend & B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressful life events: Their nature and effects (pp. 191-205). New York: Wiley. Myers, J., Lindenthal, J., & Pepper, M. (1975). Life events, social integration and psychiatric symptomatology. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 14, 412-427. Neugebauer, R. (1981). The reliability of life events reports. In B. S. Dohrenwend and B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressful life events and their context (pp. 85-107). New York: Prodist. Newcomb, M. D., Huba, G. J., & Bentler, P. M. (1986). Life change events among adolescents: An empirical consideration of some methodological issues. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 174(5), 280-289. Parker, G., & Hadzi-Pavlovic, D. (1984). Modification of levels of depression in motherbereaved women by parental and marital relationships. Psychological Medicine, 14, 125-135. Paykel, E. S. (1978). Contribution of life events to causation of psychiatric illness. Psychological Medicine, 8, 245-253. Paykel, E. S. (1979). Causal relationships between clinical depression and life events. In J. E. Barrett (Ed.), Stress and mental disorder (pp. 71-86). New York: Raven Press. Paykel, E. S., Prusoff, B. A., & Uhlenhuth, E. H. (1971). Scaling of life events. Archives of General Psychiatry, 25, 340-347. Pearlin, L. I. (1983). Role strains and personal stress. In H. B. Kaplan (Ed.), Psychosocial stress: Trends in theory and research (pp. 3-31), New York: Academic Press.
52
The Environmental Perspective
Pearlin, L. I. (1989). The sociology study of stress. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 30, 241-256. Pearlin, L. I., & Lieberman, M. A. (1979). Social sources of emotional distress. In R. G. Simmons (Ed.), Research in community and mental health 1, (pp. 217-248). Greenwich, CN: JAI. Pearlin, L. I., Lieberman, M. A., Menaghan, E. G., & Mullan, J. T. (1981). The stress process. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 22, 337-356. Pugh, W., Erickson, J. M., Rubin, R. T., Gunderson, E.K.E., & Rahe, R. H. (1971). Cluster analyses of life changes. II. Method and replication in Navy subpopulations. Archives of General Psychiatry, 25, 333-339. Rabkin, J. G., & Struening, E. L. (1976). Life events, stress and illness. Science, 194, 1013-1020. Raphael, E. G., Cloitre, M., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1991). Problems of recall and misclassification with checklist methods of measuring stressful life events. Health Psychology, 10, 62-74. Ross, C. E., & Huber, J. (1985). Hardship and depression. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 26(4), 312-327. Ross, C. E., & Mirowsky, J. (1979). A comparison of life-event weighting schemes: Change, undesirability, and effect-proportional indices. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 20, 166-177. Rutter, M. (1989). Pathways from childhood to adult life. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 30, 23-51. Sandier, I. N., & Block, M. (1979). Life stress and maladaptation of children. American Journal of Community Psychology, 7, 425-440. Sandier, I. S., & Guenther, R. T. (1985). Assessment of life stress events. In P. Karoly (Ed.), Measurement strategies in health psychology (pp. 555-600). New York: Wiley. Schroeder, D. H., & Costa, P. T. (1984). Influence of life event stress on physical illness: Substantive effects or methodological flaws? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 46, 853-863. Selye, H. (1956). The stress of life. New York: McGraw-Hill. Selye, H. (1976). The stress of life (rev. ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill. Selzer, M. L., & Vinokur, A. (1974). Life events, subjective stress, and traffic accidents. American Journal of Psychiatry, 131, 903-906. Shrout, P. E. (1981). Scaling of stressful life events. In B. S. Dohrenwend & B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressful life events and their contexts (pp. 29-47). New York: Prodist. Swearingen, E. M., & Cohen, L. H. (1985). Measurement of adolescents' life events: The junior high life experiences survey. American Journal of Community Psychology, 13, 69-85. Tausig, M. (1982). Measuring life events. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 23, 52-64. Tennant, C. (1988). Parental loss in childhood: Its effect in adult life. Archives of General Psychiatry, 45, 1045-1050. Thoits, P. A. (1981). Undesirable life events and psychophysiological distress: A problem of operational confounding. American Sociological Review, 46(1), 97-109. Thoits, P. A. (1983). Dimensions of life events that influence psychological distress: An evaluation and synthesis of the literature. In H. B. Kaplan (Ed.), Psychosocial stress: Trends in theory and research (pp. 33-101). New York: Academic Press. Thoits, P. A. (1987). Gender and marital status differences in control and distress: Common stress versus unique stress explanations. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 28(1), 7-22.
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
53
Thurlow, H. J. (1971). Illness in relation to life situation and sick role tendency. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 15, 73—88. Turner, R. J., & Avison, W. R. (1992). Innovations in the measurement of life stress: Crisis theory and the significance of event resolution. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 33, 36-50. Turner, R. J., & Noh, S. (1988). Physical disability and depression: A longitudinal analysis. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 29, 263-277. Turner, R. J., & Roxburgh, S. J. (in press). Psychological adjustment and the mothering role: A longitudinal assessment of the significance of life stress and social support. In P. J. Leaf (Ed.), Research in community and mental health. Turner, R. J., Wheaton, B., & Lloyd, D. (in press) The epidemiology of social stress. American Sociological Review. Vinokur, A., & Selzer, M. L. (1975). Desirable versus undesirable life events: Their relationship to stress and mental distress. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, 32, 329-337. Wheaton, B. (1991). The specification of chronic stress: Models and measurement. Presented at the Society for the Study of Social Problems Annual Meetings, August, 1991. Wyler, A., Masuda, M., & Holmes, T. H. (1971). Magnitude of life events and seriousness of illness. Psychosomatic Medicine, 33, 115-120. Zautra, A. J., & Reich, J. W. (1983). Life events and perceptions of life quality: Developments in a two-factor approach. Journal of Community Psychology, J, 121-132. Zimmerman, M. (1983). Methodological issues in the assessment of life events: A review of issues and research. Clinical Psychology Review, 3, 339-370.
Appendix 1 Life Event Inventories
1. Children Childhood Life Events and Family Characteristics Questionnaire. Byrne, C. P., Velamoor, V. R., Cernovsky, Z. Z., Cortese, L., & Losztyn, S. (1990). A comparison of borderline and schizophrenic patients for childhood life events and parent-child relationships. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 55(7), 590-595. Children's Life Event Questionnaire, 1989. Deutsch, L. J., and Erickson, M. T. (1989). Early life events as discriminators of socialized and undersocialized delinquents. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 17(5), 541-551. Divorce Events Schedule for Children. Sandier, I. N., Ramirez, R., & Reynolds, K. D. "Life stress for children of divorce, bereaved, and asthmatic children. Paper presented at the American Psychological Association convention, Washington D.C., August 1986. Referenced in Roosa, M. W., Beals, J., Sandier, I. N., & Pillow, D. R. (1990). The role of risk and protective factors in predicting symptomatology in adolescent and self-identfied of alcoholic parents. American Journal of Community Psychology, 18(5): 25-741. General Life Events Schedule for Children. Sandier, I. N., Nolichuk, S., Brauer, S. L., & Fogas, B. (1986). Significant events of children of divorce: Toward the assessment of a risky situation. In S. M. Averback & A. Stolberg (Eds.), Crisis intervention with children and families (pp. 65-87). New York: Hemisphere. The Children of Alcoholics Life-Events Schedule. Roosa, M. W., Sandier, I. N., Gehring, M., Beals, J. & Cappo, L. (1988). The children of alcoholics life-events schedule: A stress scale for children of alcohol abusing parents. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 49(5), 422-429. Yamamoto, K. (1979). Children's ratings of the stressfulness of experiences. Developmental Psychology, 15, 581-582.
2. Adolescents Adolescent-Family Inventory of Life Event Changes. McCubbin, H. I., Patterson, Bauman, E., & Harris, L. (1981). Adolescent-family inventory of life event changes. Madison, Wis.: University of Wisconsin. Referenced in Carty, L. (1989). Social support, peer counselling, and the community counsellor. Canadian Journal of Counselling, 23(\), 92-102. Adolescent Life Change Event Scale. Hussey M., & Ingle, M. (1977). The development of a life change event scale for adolescents. Unpublished Master's thesis, University of Cincinnati. Modified by Yeaworth, R., York, J., Hussey, M., Ingle, M., & Goodwin, T. 1980. The development of an adolescent life changes event scale. Adolescence, 15, 91-97. Adolescent Life Experiences Survey. Towbes, L. C., Cohen, L. H., & Glyshaw, K. (1989). Instrumentality as a life-stress moderator for early versus middle adolescents. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 57(1), 109-119. 54
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
55
Adolescent Perceived Events Scale. Compas, B. E., Davis, G. E., Forsythe, C. G., & Wagner, B. M. (1987). Assessment of major and daily life events during adolescence: The Adolescent Perceived Events Scale. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 55, 534-541. Burke, R. J., & Weir, T. (1978). Sex differences in adolescent life stress, social support, and well-being. Journal of Psychology, 98, 277-288. Coddington, R. D. (1972a). The significance of life events as etiologic factors in the diseases of children-I. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 16, 7-18. Also Coddington, R. D. (1972b). The significance of life events as etiologic factors in the diseases of children-n. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 16, 205-213. Coddington, R. D. (1979). Life events associated with adolescent pregnancies. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 40, 180-185. Junior High Life Events Survey. Swearingen, E. M., & Cohen, L. H. (1985). Life events and psychological distress: A prospective study of young adolescents. Developmental Psychology, 21, 1045-1054. Gad, M. T., & Johnson, J. H. (1980). Correlates of adolescent life stress as related to race, SES and levels of perceived social support. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology (Spring), 13-16. Modification of Life Experiences Survey by Sarason et al. (1978). Gersten, J. C., Langner, T. S., Eisenberg, J. G., & Simcha-Fagan, O. (1977). An evaluation of the etiologic role of stressful life-change events in psychological disorders. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 18, 228-244. High School Social Readjustment Scale. Tolor, A., Murphy, V., Wilson, L. T., & Clayton, J. (1983). The High School Readjustment Scale: An attempt to quantify stressful events in young people. Research Communication in Psychology, Psychiatry and Behavior, 8, 85-111. Kaplan, H. B., Robbins, C., & Martin, S. S. (1983). Antecedents of psychological distress in young adults: self-rejection, deprivation of social support, and life events. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 24: 230-244. Life Events Checklist. Johnson, J. H., & McCutcheon, S. M. (1980). Assessing life stress in older children and adolescents: Preliminary findings with the life events checklist. In I. G. Sarason & C. C. Spielberger (Eds.), Stress and anxiety (Vol. 7, pp. 111-125). Washington, D.C.: Hemisphere. Life Event Scale for Adolescents. Coddington, R.D.,& Troxell, J.R. (1980). The effect of emotional factors on football injury rates: A pilot study. Journal of Human Stress, 6, 3-5. Life Stress Inventory. Cohen-Sandier, R., Berman, A. L., & King, R. A. (1982). Life stress and symptomatology: Determinants of suicidal behavior in children. Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry, 21, 178-186. Newcomb, M. D., Huba, G. J., & Bentler, P. M. (1981). A multidimensional assessment of stressful life events among adolescents: Derivation and correlates. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 22, 400-415. Warrick Life Events Checklist. Warrick L. (1987). Evaluation to Flinn Foundation school leased health care program for pregnant and parenting teens, 1986-1989. Tucson, AZ: Flinn Foundation. Wright, L. S. (1985). Suicidal thoughts and their relationship to family stress and personal problems among high school seniors and college undergraduates. Adolescence, 20(79), 575-580.
3. Adults Barnett, B.E.W., Hanna, B., & Parker, G. (1983). Life event scales for obstetric groups. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 27(4), 313-320.
56
The Environmental Perspective
Block, M., & Zautra, A. (1981). Satisfaction and distress in a community: A test of the effects of life events. American Journal of Community Psychology, 9, 165-180. Hough, R. L., Fairbank, D. T., & Garcia, A. M. (1976). Problems in the ratio measurement of life stress. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 17, 70-82. Interview Schedule for Events and Difficulties. Brown, G. W., & Harris, T. O. (1978). Social origins of depression. New York: The Free Press. Junior High Life Experiences Survey. Swearingen, E. M., & Cohen, L. H. (1985). Measurement of adolescents' life events: The junior high life experiences survey. American Journal of Community Psychology, 13, 69-85. Life Change Inventory. Costantini, A. F., Braun, J. R., Davis, J., & Iervolino, A. (1974). The life change inventory: A device for quantifying psychological magnitude of changes experienced by college students. Psychological Reports, 34, 991-1000. Life Crisis History. Antonovsky, A., & Kats, R. (1967). The life crisis history as a tool in epidemiological research. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 8, 15—21. Life Events Inventory. Cochrane, R., & Robertson, A. (1973). The life events inventory: A measure of the relative severity of psychosocial stressors. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 17, 135-139. Life Events Inventory (Questionnaire Form). Tennant, C., & Andrews, G. (1976). A scale to measure the stress of life events. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 10, 27-32. Live Events Questionnaire (Short and Long Forms). Horowitz, M. J., Schaefer, C., Hiroto, D., Wilner, N., & Levin, B. (1977). Life event questionnaires for measuring presumptive stress. Psychosomatic Medicine, 39, 413-431. Life Events Questionnaire-II. Cooley, E. J., Miller, A. W., Keesey, J. C., Levenspiel, M. J., & Sisson, C. F. (1979). Self-Report assessment of life change and disorders. Psychological Reports, 44, 1078-1086. Life Experiences Survey. Sarason, I. G., Johnson, J. H., & Siegel, J. M. (1978). Assessing the impact of life changes: Development of the Life Experiences Survey. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 46, 32-46. Paykel, E. S., Pursoff, B. A., & Uhlenhuth, E. H. (1971). Scaling of life events. Archives of General Psychiatry, 25, 340-347. Psychiatric Epidemiology Research Interview for Life Events. Dohrenwend, B. S., Krasnoff, L., Askenasy, A. R., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1978). Exemplification of a method for scaling life events: The PERI Life Events Scale. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 19, 205-229. Recent Life Change Questionnaire. Rahe, R. H. (1975). Epidemiological studies of life change and illness. International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 6: 133-146. Review of Life Events. Hurst, M. W., Jenkins, C. D., & Rose, R. M. (1978). The assessment of life change stress: A comparative and methodological inquiry. Psychosomatic Medicine, 40, 126-141. Social Readjustment Rating Scale. Holmes, T. H., & Rahe, R. H. (1967). The Social Readjustment Rating Scale. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 11, 213-218. Social Readjustment Scale for Children. Coddington, R. D. (1972a). The significance of life events as etiologic factors in the diseases of children I. A survey of professional workers. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 16, 7—18. Social Readjustment Scale for Children. Coddington, R. D. (1972b). The significance of life events as etiologic factors in the diseases of children II. A survey of a normal population. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 16, 205-213. Structured Event Probe and Narrative Rating Method. Dohrenwend, B. P., Raphael, K. G., Schwartz, S., Stueve, A., & Skodol, A. (1993). The structured event probe and
Checklist Measurement of Stressful Life Events
57
narrative rating method for measuring stressful life events. In L. Goldberger & S. Brenitz (Eds.), Handbook of stress (pp. 174-199). New York: Free Press.
4. Aged Geriatric Social Readjustment Rating Scale. Amster L., & Krauss, H. (1974). The relationship between life crises and mental deterioration in old age. International Journal of Aging and Human Development, 5, 51-55. Inventory of Small Life Events (modified for the elderly). Zautra, A. J., Guarnaccia, C. A., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1986). Measuring small life events. American Journal of Community Psychology, 14, 629-655. Louisville Older Person Event Scale. Murrell, S. A., Norris, F. H., & Hutchins, G. M. (1984). Distribution and desirability of life events in older adults: Population and policy implications. Journal of Community Psychology, 12, 301-311.
Appendix 2 Sampling of Critical Reviews of Stressful Life Event Methodology Brown, G. W., & Harris, T. (1978). Social origins of depression. New York: Free Press. Cleary, P. A. (1981). Problems of internal consistency and scaling in life event schedules. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 25, 309-320. Dohrenwend, B. S., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1978). Some issues in research on stressful life events. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 166, 7-15. Hurst, M. W. (1979). Life changes and psychiatric symptom development: Issues of context, scoring and clustering. In J. E. Barrett (Ed.), Stress and mental disorder, (pp. 17-36). New York: Raven Press. McQuaid, J. R., Monroe, S. M., Roberts, J. R., Johnson, S. L., Garamoni, G. L., Jupfer, D. J., & Frank, E. (1992). Toward the standardization of life stress assessment: Definitional discrepancies and inconsistencies in methods. Stress Medicine, 8, 47— 56. Miller, T. W. (1989). Life events scaling: Clinical methodological issues. In T. Miller (Ed.), Stressful life events. International Universities Press Stress and Health Series, Monograph 4, (pp. 105-121). Universities Press. Monroe, S. M. (1982). Life events assessment: Current practices, emerging trends. Clinical Psychology Review, 2, 435-453. Moos, R. H., & Swindle, R. W., Jr. (1990). Stressful life circumstances: Concepts and measures. Stress Medicine, 6, 171-178. Neugebauer, R. (1981). The reliability of life event reports. In B. S. Dohrenwend & B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressful life events and their context (pp. 85-107). New York: Prodist. Newcomb, M. D., Huba, G. J., & Bentler, P. M. (1986). Life change events among adolescents: An empirical consideration of some methodological issues. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 174(5), 280-289. Paykel, E. S. (1983). Methodological aspects of life events research. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 27, 341-352. Perkins, D. V. (1982). The Assessment of stress using life event scales. In L. Goldberger & S. Breznits (Eds.), Handbook of stress: Theoretical and clinical aspects (pp. 320-332). New York: Free Press.
58
The Environmental Perspective
Rabkin, J. G., & Struening, E. L. (1976). Life events, stress and illness. Science, 194, 1013-1020. Raphael, E. G., Cloitre, M., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1991). Problems of recall and misclassification with checklist methods of measuring stressful life events. Health Psychology, 10, 62-74. Sandier, I. N. (1979). Life stress events and community psychology. In I. G. Sarason & C. D. Spielberger (Eds.), Stress and anxiety (Vol. 6, pp. 213-232). New York: Hemisphere. Sarason, I. G., deMonchaux, C., & Hunt, T. (1975). Methodological issues in the assessment of life stress. In L. Levy (Ed.), Emotions—Their parameters and measurement (pp. 399-509). New York: Raven Press. Tausig, M. (1982). Measuring life events. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 23, 52-64. Tennant, C., Bebbington, P., & Hurry, J. (1981). The role of life events in depressive illness: Is there a substantial causal relation? Psychological Medicine, 11, 379-389. Thoits, P. A. (1983). Dimensions of life events as influences upon the genesis of psychological distress and associated conditions: An evaluation and synthesis of the literature. In Howard B. Kaplan (Ed.), Psychosocial stress: Trends in theory and research (pp. 33-103). New York: Academic Press. Zimmerman, M. (1989). Methodological issues in the assessment of life events: A review of issues and research. Clinical Psychology Review, 3, 339-370.
3 Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events Elaine Wethington, George W. Brown, and, Ronald C. Kessler
A critical component of establishing the overall relationship between environmental stressors and individual health and well-being is the utilization of a comprehensive, reliable, and valid measure of stressful life events and difficulties. Two methods of life events measurement predominate: checklist measures (see Chapter 2, this volume) and intensive personal interview measures, which use qualitative probes in order to specify more precisely the characteristics of life events believed to produce stress. These two sorts of measures have evolved from different, although not mutually exclusive, theories of what constitutes stress. As a concomitant to their origins in different theories of stress, these measures have also been shaped in response to different research questions and paradigms. Checklist methods were informed by a theoretical perspective on stress which asserts that the magnitude of social and environmental change bringing about a need for readjustment is the basis of experienced stress (see Chapter 2, this volume, for a review). The early development of personal interview methods that use qualitative probes, however, was driven by a perspective which assumed that social and environmental changes (and anticipations of those changes) which threaten the most strongly held emotional commitments are the basis for experienced severe stress, and that it is severe stress which threatens health (Gorman & Brown, 1992). Other interview measures have since been developed that are based on the changereadjustment paradigm (e.g., Dohrenwend, Raphael, Schwartz, Stueve, & Skodol, 1993); these are all distinguished from the checklists, however, by their use of qualitative probes. There are other critical differences between checklist and personal interview measures of life events. The life change-readjustment paradigm assumes that positive as well as negative changes are related to the experience of emotional stress; interview methods, however, consistent with their focus on the most emotionally arousing stressors, are designed to elicit reports of negative events. Checklist methods yield a summary score of the stressfulness of changes experienced over a period of time (usually a year), whereas interview methods are designed to elicit reports of specific events that may have triggered an onset of a severe physical or mental illness. In regard to this latter point, checklist measures tend to (but not solely) use 59
60
The Environmental Perspective
continuous symptom or "mood" measures as outcomes. Interview measures tend to utilize as outcomes, onsets of clinically significant mental disorder or physical illness—for example, depression or gastrointestinal attacks. The aim of this chapter is to acquaint readers with the circumstances in which the use of personal interview methods is appropriate; the relative strengths and weaknesses of available personal interview methods; and the logistics and costs of fielding an interview study. It is not the intent of this chapter to argue that personal interview methods are necessary in all cases for measuring exposure to stressors. Personal interview methods are not efficient for correlational or prospective studies, where the purpose is to establish that there is a relationship between environmental stress and a general measure of symptoms. In such instances, the greater expense of using interview measures is not justified. However, there are instances in which the use of personal interview methods is more suited to a particular research question.
Rationale for the Personal Interview Versus Checklist Approach The use of the intensive personal interview technique is particularly critical when the relative timing of exposure to a stressor and the onset of an illness is necessary to address a research question. For example, if an investigator is interested in the relationship between experiencing a stressor and the subsequent onset of panic disorder, then both the timing of the events and the onset of panic must be carefully (and independently) dated. Precise dating is necessary not only to establish the relationship of stress exposure to onset, but also to identify the aspects of the stressful experience that affect onset. In general, self-administered checklists cannot equal the precision of an interviewer trained to elicit aspects of events critical to examine these research questions (Cannell, Miller, & Oksenberg, 1981). Studies of illness onset, course, and recovery often require such precise dating of event and illness onset/offset. Checklist methods also seem to be more prone to "telescoping," or the misdating of distant events into a more recent time period (McQuaid et al., 1992; Raphael, Cloitre, & Dohrenwend, 1991). Checklist methods, moreover, are probably not as effective as more intensive personal interviewing in communicating the importance of accurate answers to the respondents (Cannell et al., 1981). In addition, the faceto-face interview with qualitative probes facilitates the use of memory aids to improve event recall and accurate dating (such as calendars, visual representations of important events of the preceding year, and well-timed reminders of personally salient dates). Such aids have been shown to provide substantially better information than can be collected through relatively unassisted self-report (Sobell, Toneatto, Sobell, Schuller, & Maxwell, 1990). This more accurate timing of event onset and offset, moreover, makes it possible to distinguish and date a series of related events and difficulties, which may be required in a study addressing whether exposure to multiple events is more related to onset than exposure to a single event (Brown & Harris, 1978; McQuaid et al., 1992; Raphael et al., 1991). Interview measures of life events, however, are most widely promoted for their methods of establishing more precisely the degree of severity in stressor exposure.
Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events
61
Studies of responses to checklist measures have found that many respondents report relatively minor events in response to questions that are designed to elicit only severely stressful events (Dohrenwend, Link, Kern, Shrout, & Markowitz, 1990), such as reporting the death of someone relatively distant as the death of someone "close"; or reporting a broken toe as a serious injury, even when it had no impact on one's life besides short-term pain and inconvenience. In experiments with interview measures of life events, Kessler and Wethington (1991) have found that many people report objectively trivial events in response to questions that were thought to emphasize more than adequately the serious nature of the stressful events that were sought. Reporting minor events as severe, moreover, may be related to the respondent's health status at the time of interview (Bebbington, 1986): Distressed people are more likely to remember negative events than happy people (Fiedler & Stroehm, 1986). Interview measures of life events, moreover, use a different system for rating the severity of life events. Checklist measures have generally (although not universally) applied "normative life change" or "readjustment" weights—a numerical value preassigned to every event reported or the sum of the number of events experienced over a given period (see Chapter 2). If the event description is relatively more inclusive (e.g., "serious illness"), the life change unit weight may be a poor fit to the severity of the actual event prompting the report. Specifically, a recurrence of cancer arguably has a different impact than a bout of influenza, both of which could prompt a yes answer to "serious illness." Studies comparing checklist to interview methods have confirmed that variability of this sort occurs when subjects respond to checklists. Raphael et al. (1991) and McQuaid et al. (1992) demonstrated that respondents to checklists report experiences to life event questions that do not match the researcher's intent. Furthermore, respondents are known to report minor or even positive events in response to questions that were designed to elicit only highly negative and undesirable events (McQuaid et al., 1992). Event list comprehensiveness has also been a critical issue in the debate between the use of checklist and personal interview methods. Self-report event lists have been criticized for lacking coverage of singular and rare events that may be among the most distressing (Brown, 1981), although more comprehensive checklist methods have been developed in response to this criticism (Zimmerman, 1983). Personal interview methods allow for more flexibility in event elicitation and recording, as well as self-nomination of stressors not evoked by direct questions about domainspecific events and transitions (Brown & Harris, 1978; Dohrenwend et al., 1990). Interview measures of life events also allow for more effective probing of event reports, an important means of reducing measurement error. An interviewer trained in study procedures can probe to determine if the event reported indeed "matches" the intent of the question and should be counted as a stressor of that type (McQuaid et al., 1992; Raphael et al. 1991). In addition, probing of event responses also allows investigators to determine whether events are connected to one another or whether the same event is mentioned more than once in response to separate questions (Kessler & Wethington, 1991; McQuaid et al., 1992). The latter is useful in order to counter the tendency of some respondents to "overreport" their exposure by mentioning the same event more than once. Finally, interview methods have yielded some different insights into a number of
62
The Environmental Perspective
critical issues in stress research, primarily because trained interviewers can elicit more detailed descriptive information about variations in event severity over time, and about linkages among related events and difficulties. Interview measures have been used to explore (1) the relationship among alleviation of environmental stressors, illness course, duration, and recovery (e.g., Brown, Adler, & Bifulco, 1988); (2) the sorts of stressors that are associated with different types of disease onset (e.g., Bebbington et al., 1988; Harris, 1991); (3) and the interaction of individual vulnerability and life history with recent stressors to produce onset of illness (Brown, Bifulco, & Harris, 1987).
Applications of Interview Measures of Life Events Interview measures of life events are extremely expensive in comparison to checklist methods. Given their expense, the use of interview methods for measuring life events is most appropriate for field studies or retrospective or longitudinal casecontrol studies where the relationship of stress exposure to the onset of very serious illness is being investigated (e.g., Katschnig, 1986), and where exposure to life events is of primary interest to the researcher (Cooke, 1985). In such studies, the major research questions entail establishing the relationship of environmental stressors to mental or physical illness in the community. In these studies as well, a maximally comprehensive measure of stress exposure is necessary. The reason is that the focus in such studies is not on one particular event or transition that many people experience, and explaining variations in people's responsiveness to it, but on establishing the etiology of particular disorders or illnesses, particularly the role of stressful events. Although personal interviewing methods have also been used extensively in studies of adjustment to one stressor, such as divorce, unexpected unemployment, or widowhood, this chapter will not review such studies, because our emphasis here is on comprehensive measures of stressor exposure. The intention is not to urge, even inadvertently, that researchers abandon intensive studies of one crisis in favor of a comprehensive stressor measurement approach. In a specific crisis study, the comprehensive stressor measures described here would be poor substitutes for the sort of fine-grained examinations of individual variation and adaptation that are typical in such studies.
Choosing an Appropriate Measure The following section critically evaluates a number of interview measures of life events. The review is confined to those measures that have been used more than once, or that are readily available for replication by researchers other than their developers. The criteria for evaluation include (1) reliability (if reported); (2) comprehensiveness of event coverage; (3) falloff in reports of events over a 1-year event recall period; (4) the relationship of stressor exposure, as estimated by this interview method, to onset of illness; (5) the dimensions by which stressors are rated in order
Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events
63
to evaluate their "stressfulness"; (6) illnesses and disorders to which the measure has been applied; (7) populations in which the measure has been used, including cultural groups; (8) strengths of the method and its potential for future development; and (9) major criticisms that have emerged. For several of the reviewed measures, not all of this information is available. Interview methods are presented as follows: Because of its earlier development, the Brown and Harris Life Events and Difficulties Schedule (LEDS) is described first. It is followed by reviews of a number of interview life-event rating measures that do not reproduce the event rating system used in the LEDS (e.g., the SEPRATE: see below and Dohrenwend et al., 1993). Finally, interview measures that are shortened or more structured versions of the LEDS are reviewed, including a structured form of the LEDS under development (the SLI: see below and Wethington, Kessler, & Brown, 1993) and interviews that use checklists to reduce interviewing time.
The Life Events and Difficulties Schedule The most widely used personal interview method is the Life Events and Difficulties Schedule (LEDS: Brown & Harris, 1978). The LEDS is a semi-structured survey instrument, appropriate for use in a community sample as well as with patients, assessing a wide variety of stressors. The interview consists of a series of questions asking whether certain types of events had occurred over the past 12 months (or longer) and a set of guidelines for probing positive responses. Interviewers are given a great deal of latitude in deciding whether more intense probing is required for ascertaining whether an event is likely to have been severe in emotional impact, or not. To that end, only general guidelines (brief reminders about important objective dimensions) are given for probing, since the interview is designed to resemble conversation rather than a standard survey. The aim of the interviewing method is to construct a narrative or "story" of each event (Gorman & Brown, 1992). Once an event is mentioned, the interviewer asks questions about objective circumstances surrounding the event, such as: What led up to the event? What followed it? Interviewers also follow up on spontaneous comments made by the respondents, including mentions of other events occurring at the same time, or what may be a technically "wrong" answer—for example, a parent's sudden death reported in response to a question about serious illness of a family member. The purpose of the probes is to gather enough information to rate the long-term contextual threat of discrete events (a death) or severity of chronic difficulties (several months of unemployment). The rating of long-term contextual threat is the key component of the LEDS method, as the experience of a "severely" threatening event or presence of a severe chronic difficulty ("marked" in LEDS terminology) is hypothesized to pose a risk for the onset of physical or mental illness. Rating the degree of threat for specific sorts of events and difficulties has been developed and documented over the several decades in which the LEDS has been used. The documentation for the ratings is contained in dictionaries produced by Brown,
64
The Environmental Perspective
Harris, and their colleagues.1 These dictionaries, which are made available to those who are formally trained in the use of the method, consist of several thousand examples of rated life events and difficulties, grouped by life domain (marital, work-related, financial), type of event or difficulty (argument, separation, ongoing marital problems), and level of rated severity (4 categories for events, and 7 for difficulties). In addition to the examples, the dictionaries also document how events are classified by type and the sorts of information the interviewer needs to establish in order to assign contextual threat ratings to each type of event. The critical element of rating long-term contextual threat is collecting objective information in order to estimate the long-term implications of an event or difficulty for important plans, concerns, and purposes of the respondent, taking into account other current circumstances and relevant life history information. Aspects of life history and context that are relevant are documented in the life event and difficulty dictionaries. The general rule guiding event severity ratings is that the interviewer must determine whether the event affected the life plans or commitments of the respondent, and use the dictionary guidelines to assess those aspects of context that must be established in order to estimate the level of emotional arousal likely to have resulted. In many instances, however, the interviewer can rely on the event or difficulty having a specific rating in the LEDS dictionaries. The event list in the LEDS consists not only of questions about probable negative events, but also of role transitions (births, promotions, graduation from school) and situations that may have involved a severe emotional reaction, but are not typically defined as events in checklists. An unusual feature of the LEDS are questions such as dealing with important revelations about other people's character, breaking or getting bad news, making difficult decisions, disappointments, and finding presumptive negative events working out much better than expected. There are three main stages of life-event rating: (1) assessment of the likely emotional arousal (positive or negative) associated with the reported event; (2) a rating of general contextual threat, which has a very high threshold for the highest rating of severity; and (3) ratings of specific aspects of threat, such as its degree of loss (of a person, object, or idea), danger (the future probability of loss), frustration of goals, challenge, intrusiveness into daily routine, and positiveness (e.g., relief, or getting a fresh start on life). Events are rated for both their positive and negative aspects. Difficulties are rated for their intrusiveness into daily routine and their threat to the quality of other life roles, such as work. The interviews average about one hour to complete in a general population sample, with a range from 30 minutes to well over 2 hours. After the interviewer completes the interview, he or she then constructs written narrative descriptions of each event or difficulty. Interviewer are trained to edit out the respondent's subjective reactions and emotional responses to the event, so that they cannot confound the event contextual rating. The event descriptions are then presented to a panel of raters, blind to the illness status of the respondent, who discuss the appropriate rating to assign the event or difficulty. Although in the earlier years of LEDS development, most events and difficulties were brought to these panels for discussion and rating, the availability of the detailed event and difficulty dictionaries ratings has routinized a significant proportion of the panel rating.
Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events
65
In addition to long-term contextual threat, a number of other dimensions are coded and rated for each event. These dimensions include type of event (e.g., illness, change in interaction); the person whom the event primarily affected or "focus" (including a "joint" category for events that happened to another but that are likely to have had an emotional impact on the respondent); the amount of threat reported by the respondent; and "independence," which is the probability that the event or difficulty could have been brought about by erratic behavior caused by the respondent's illness. The LEDS dictionaries also document the rules for determining these ratings. The LEDS appears to be very reliable. One-year falloff in event reporting for severe events is about 1 percent per month (Brown & Harris, 1982), although the falloff for nonsevere and minor events is notable. Because the occurrence of a severe event (or presence of an ongoing severe difficulty) is found to be related to illness onset in their community studies (e.g., the estimated odds ratio ranges from 7 to 13 over a number of studies of depression; see Paykel, 1978; Surtees & Duffy, 1989), these investigators have argued that their method is more reliable than checklist measurement methods (e.g., Punch & Marshall, 1984). The LEDS is an evolving instrument, with numerous studies now in progress to expand its reach to populations and illness onsets other than those that were the focus of its early development (schizophrenic patients and British working-class women). The LEDS has subsequently been used with adolescents (Monck & Dobbs, 1985) and the American elderly, with a new LEDS dictionary being developed for the latter (see note 1). A number of LEDS studies have been conducted in racial minority groups in England and Africa (for a review of the cross-cultural studies, see Brown & Harris, 1989b). Neither the LEDS nor LEDS-like methods, however, have been used with children. In addition to studies of schizophrenia and onsets of depression, the LEDS has been used in studies of anxiety, appendectomy, abdominal pain, menstrual disorders, multiple sclerosis, myocardial infarction, and dysphonia (for a review, see Brown & Harris, 1989a). The LEDS has experienced criticism for its rating and interview methods. The most frequent and persistent criticism is that too much "context" is included in the ratings of contextual threat. Specifically, there is a long-standing controversy over whether its ratings of the magnitude of contextual threat muddle the distinction between the magnitude of event severity and the individual's "social" vulnerability to a stressor (Dohrenwend et al., 1993; Tennant, Bebbington & Hurry, 1981), thereby inflating estimates of event impact. An example makes this criticism clear. A death event can vary a great deal in severity in the LEDS rating scheme, from "below threshhold" for classification as an event to the highest category of severity. The severity rating depends, in part, on the reliance the person placed in the deceased as a confidant, and the number of alternative confidants available. Severity ratings for deaths also depend on other contextual factors that make a death more or less emotionally meaningful, such as closeness of kinship, quality of the predeath relationship, and frequency of contact the years before death (Brown, 1989). However, the inclusion of a social network vulnerability factor in the rating does confound concepts that some researchers may wish to keep separate (Tennant & Bebbington, 1978). The majority of event and difficulty ratings are less influenced by factors related to social vulnerability than is the death example; for instance, ratings
66
The Environmental Perspective
of health events are based on objective contextual factors such as the life threat or disability posed by the illness, and its impact on work and other life routines (Brown, 1989). Similarly, ratings of work losses are based not on social vulnerability but rather on objective factors such as the unemployment rate, supply of jobs comparable to the one lost, and the proportion of family income lost. Brown and his associates have continued to elaborate their measures of social vulnerability risk factors over time, and to a degree have met some of the criticism regarding the level of confounding between event severity and social vulnerability (Bebbington, 1986). This has been done through the development of separate interview measures of important social vulnerability factors such as commitment to role domains where events may arise, self-esteem, quality of social support, and conflict among social roles (Self-Evaluation and Social Support Schedule: Brown & Harris, 1989b). Nor, it should be noted, are all social vulnerabilities included in event ratings. Some aspects of social vulnerability, such as separation from a parent in childhood, are not included in event and difficulty ratings, but are measured and analyzed as additional risk factors for the onset of illness. The LEDS has not come into general use, and has only recently been used in the United States. A number of European and American researchers have developed alternative instruments; some of them are structured-question elaborations of the life events checklist with contextual probes (e.g., Kessler & Wethington, 1991; Paykel, 1983; Wittchen, Essau, Hecht, Teder, & Pfister, 1989), whereas others are elaborations of the magnitude of "life change" rating systems (Dohrenwend et al., 1993). Other researchers have fielded shortened or modified versions of the LEDS (e.g., Costello & Devins, 1988; Miller et al., 1989; Wethington, Kessler, & Brown, 1993). There are two explanations for why researchers have sought alternatives to the LEDS. The first is that many researchers are deterred by the cost and complexity of using the semi-structured LEDS interview. Important questions remain about the logistics of combining LEDS methods with the standardized methods of community epidemiological research, including the required 8 days of interviewer training in London or Pittsburgh (see note 1), the complicated rating scheme, and periodic retraining necessary in order to maintain consistent quality of interviews. Respondent burden is also an issue. Interviews are much lengthier than those required for checklist measures of life events (Katschnig, 1986). They also require a level of self-disclosure some respondents and interviewers find uncomfortable. The expense of the panel rating method, moreover, has been viewed as a significant deterrent. The second reason is that some researchers prefer to make a stricter distinction between magnitude of change brought about by the event and vulnerability, an aim more compatible with the change-readjustment paradigm underlying checklist research methods (see Chapter 2). Recently, moreover, a few investigators have reported that the contextual rating system used in the LEDS may be no more predictive of illness onset that a carefully applied life-change unit rating scheme applied to events reported in a face-to-face interview (e.g., Faravelli & Ambonetti, 1983; Katschnig, 1980, 1986). In addition, within-respondent comparisons of events reported to life-change measures and to a LEDS interview suggest that the two methods yield different event reports (Katschnig, 1980; McQuaid et al., 1992),
Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events
67
both of which could be related to onset of illness (Katschnig, 1980). At the time of this review, these questions remain to be more thoroughly investigated.
Alternative Interview and Rating Systems for Life Events The Standardized Event Rating System The Standardized Event Rating System (SEPRATE: Dohrenwend et al., 1993) is an alternative life-event interview and rating system, using a magnitude of "life change" rating system.2 The SEPRATE, derived from the PERI life-events checklist (Dohrenwend, Krasnoff, Askenasy, & Dohrenwend, 1978) consists of a series of yes/no questions regarding 84 types of events or difficulties that may have occurred and been severely stressful. Each "yes" answer is probed with a number of structured questions, designed to fit a variety of circumstances. Although probes are provided, interviewers are not confined to the exact wordings as written. The purpose of the probes is twofold: to provide a narrative description of each event or difficulty, and to produce a standardized assessment of separate aspects of situations thought to produce experienced stress. These assessments include magnitude of change brought about by the event, desirability of the event (from the average, or "normative" perspective), disruptiveness to daily life routines, threat to life, independence from the respondent's own (possibly) disordered behavior, and "fatefulness" (occurring independently of the respondent's behavior and beyond his or her control to avert) (Dohrenwend et al., 1990). After the interview is completed, an editor composes a narrative description of each event or difficulty reported. These descriptions differ from those done using the LEDS method, in that they are stripped of any material that might be used to infer "social vulnerability" to especially severe effects from the given stressor. This is done in order to prevent this sort of vulnerability from being inadvertently included in the rating of the event (Dohrenwend et al., 1990). Each event is then rated independently by two raters on the dimensions listed previously (Shrout et al., 1989). It is important to note that not all event context is stripped from the narrative. Indeed, many of the contextual factors taken account of in the LEDS are reproduced by the SEPRATE, such as the life-threatening or disabling aspects of an illness, the length of an unemployment episode, and the objective likelihood of being able to replace a lost job with one paying as well (Dohrenwend, 1993, personal communication). Dohrenwend and associates have conducted a reliability study comparing the SEPRATE to their previously developed PERI normative life-event rating checklist (Shrout et al., 1989). Falloff for severe events is relatively modest (Raphael et al., 1991). The relative risk of onset of depression associated with "fateful" life events occurring in the previous 12 months is 1.50, and 3.38 for events determined to be both "fateful and highly disruptive" to life routines. The odds ratio associated with fateful and disruptive events is approximately double that estimated by use of the PERI checklist method in the same study (Shrout et al., 1989). Both the rate of falloff and the case-control odds ratio estimated for onset appear
68
The Environmental Perspective
somewhat unfavorable compared to the LEDS. However, it should be noted that the estimated odds-ratio provided by Dohrenwend and associates may have been driven down by including events and onsets reported to have occurred nearly 3 years before the interview, a longer than usual recall period. Indeed, a small case-control study (less than 25 subjects) fielded by Mazure and Bruce (M. Bruce, 1993, personal communication) indicates that the estimate of relative risk using the SEPRATE is comparable to the LEDS over a recall period more typical of studies of illness onset. It is also the case that rating dimensions are not as fine-tuned in the SEPRATE (see also below), perhaps leading to underrating of the potentially severe events. There is also the possibility that the SEPRATE is measuring a set of stressful experiences different from that which the LEDS typically evokes (see Katschnig, 1980). Theoretical refinement of event rating, combined with a shorter recall period, has produced odd-ratio estimates comparable to the LEDS (Dohrenwend, 1994, personal communication). The SEPRATE is somewhat less comprehensive than the LEDS. The list of events and difficulties is less extensive in it as well as in other interview methods, reviewed below, that have been developed more directly from the LEDS. In particular, questions regarding important revelations about other people's character, bad news, decisions, and disappointments—an innovative feature in the LEDS—are not included. Questions such as these yield a number of severe events (Brown & Harris, 1978). Like the LEDS, the SEPRATE technique has been successfully adapted for use in a different culture (Dohrenwend, 1993, personal communication). It has been used in Israel, where a different list of events and difficulties was utilized, although the rating dimensions remained the same. (These different events and difficulties reflected Israeli experience with war and terrorist activities.) The SEPRATE has been used primarily with adult community samples and with patients. It is unclear whether the use SEPRATE interview may result in cost savings compared to the LEDS; however, not all information is available for comparison. In one study using the SEPRATE, interview length ranged from 60 to 90 minutes (Lennon, Dohrenwend, Zautra, & Marbach, 1990). Time estimates for narrative production, coding, and rating, however, are not available on a per interview basis. Training in the method is extensive, and (like the LEDS) effective use would require that investigators consult with the developers of the SEPRATE (Dohrenwend, 1993, personal communication). Other Interview Measures Other qualitative probe elaborations of event checklists have also been fielded by a number of investigators. These systems include the Detroit Couples Study Life Events Method (Kessler & Wethington, 1991); the Munich Events List (Wittchen et al., 1989); the Paykel Life Events Interview (Cooke, 1985; Paykel, 1983); and the Henderson, Byrne, and Duncan-Jones (1981) List of Recent Experiences. There are probably others that have escaped the detection of this review. Fairly high reliabilities have been reported for some of these methods (although evaluations must be tempered because calculations of reliability are not consistent).
Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events
69
Falloff using these systems is also relatively modest for severe events. The use of these interviews, moreover, may result in significant cost savings. The Detroit Couples Study Life Events Method. Like the SEPRATE, this interview is a checklist life event measure, with semi-structured probes administered after an event is reported. An offshoot of this interview was utilized in the National Survey of Health and Stress (Kessler, 1990). Several features of the LEDS were included in its development. Acute, discrete events are differentiated from chronic difficulties. In addition to standard queries about domain-specific events, questions related to event "meaning" (e.g., revelations about the character of others, disappointments, situations turning out better than expected, and upsetting news) were adopted from the LEDS (Kessler & Wethington, 1991). A number of features were incorporated into the design of the study in order to improve recall and accurate dating of life events. The features include concrete wordings of life event questions, contextual cues (arranging event questions by domain and embedding them in sections including other sorts of questions about that domain), multiple frames of reference (e.g., questions about learning something negative about the character of another person in addition to questions about difficulties "getting along" with someone), and memory aids (a life event calendar and calendar review to correct dates). Four category stress severity ratings were assigned, based on the "loss" and "danger" long-term contextual threat ratings from the LEDS. However, the ratings were more similar to life-change event ratings than LEDS contextual threat ratings, since the interview did not collect sufficient contextual information to reproduce the latter. A detailed analysis of event reports in the Detroit Couples study showed that this interview measure has acceptable psychometric properties overall, with some intriguing exceptions (Kessler & Wethington, 1991). The design of the study (husbands and wives interviewed from the same couple) made it possible to calculate reliability estimates for events rated as severe. The average reliability of reports was .64 for husbands and .68 for wives. However, inspection of reliability within event types showed that events that have the potential to be embarrassing, such as criminal activity and martial separations, were less reliably reported than other events. It is difficult to imagine that such a pattern reflects a common tendency to forget about embarrassing events. A more likely interpretation is that the occurrence of these events was consciously concealed. In addition, a comparison of husband and wife reports shows that personal events were consistently reported more accurately than events that occurred to one's spouse. The 2 to 3 percent monthly falloff rate for event reports, moreover, was lower than the 5 percent monthly falloff for a checklist reported by Punch and Marshall (1984), but greater than that reported for the LEDS (Brown & Harris, 1982). The overall results, though, from the Detroit Couples Study are not as impressive as those obtained with the LEDS. The relative risk of onset of depression associated with severe events in the previous 12 months is 2.43 (odds ratio) compared to the range of 7 to 13 reported for the LEDS (see Paykel, 1978). It should be
70
The Environmental Perspective
noted, moreover, that the estimate is also less than that obtained by the SEPRATE. Nevertheless, the more structured methods of the interview may have resulted in a significant cost-saving. The average interview lasted 78 minutes. Coding time for the interview, including detailed coding of the life events, was less than 2 hours. Conventionally trained survey interviewers and coders were used, and only 1 day of special training was necessary for each group. Most significantly, 1755 interviews were conducted in a 41/2-month period, and the coding of all events was accomplished in 2 months, a pace that could not even be approached using the LEDS. It is important to note that methods such as these were developed specifically for a large-scale community survey. The measures used in the National Survey of Health and Stress (Kessler, 1990), an offshoot of the Detroit Couples Study, were applied in a sample of 8,000 representative of Americans, including ethnic minorities, aged 15 to 54. The Munich Events List. The Munich Events List (Wittchen et al., 1989) is a threestep personal interview procedure. The interview consists of 85 life event descriptions, which are concretely specified. In the first step, the interviewer and respondent read the event descriptions together, with the respondent deciding whether such an event had occurred over the recall period. In the second step, the interviewer asks questions to assess the relevant context of the events already reported. In the third step, respondents rate the impact of each incident subjectively; then the interviewer rates the events on a number of objective dimensions, including whether the event involved gain or loss, was primarily positive or negative in its impact, could have been averted by the victim, or might have been brought on by the subject's mental condition or disordered behavior. There is also an objective severity rating scale, conceptually more similar to a life change-readjustment unit measure than the severity ratings used in the LEDS. Subjective and objective ratings of severity are correlated at .67 (Wittchen et al., 1989). Reliability estimates were calculated in a test-retest analysis, by event type and/or severity. The investigators reported nearly perfect concordance for severe events such as deaths (kappa not reported), with lower agreement for less severe incidents (kappa = .74). Falloff was also estimated to be near zero for the severest events (0.36% per month, vs. 1% per month for the LEDS). Data have not been reported with which to calculate the 12-month risk of depression or other illness onset associated with severe events. No data are available on the relative costs involved in fielding this interview, which has been used only in Europe. Samples have been small (Wittchen et al., 1989). The Paykel Brief Life Event List. Paykel's life event interview (1983) has been used in a number of studies. This interview consists of 63 life event and difficulty questions, and can be administered in an average of 30 to 40 minutes (Cooke, 1985). Once an event or difficulty has been reported, the interviewer uses semistructured probes in order to obtain more objective information and to estimate its emotional impact on the subject. Events and difficulties are dated, and it is determined whether they occurred before or after illness onset. They are also evaluated
Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events
71
for their independence from the subject's illness status, whether the victim could have averted the event, respondent-reported negative and positive impact of the event, and objective contextual severity of impact, a measure adapted from the LEDS (Paykel, 1983). Interviewers are given 3 weeks of intensive training in rating events, and all events are rated by two independent raters. (It has not been reported how much the double-rating system reduces production time per interview.) Inter-rater reliability of dimensions rated using this method appears to be adequate, ranging from .95 for specific event occurrence to .76 for objective negative impact (Paykel, 1983). In Cooke's replication (1985) inter-rater agreement on objective severity of impact (kappa = .64) is just within adequate range. The instrument has been used with adult community samples and patients. Henderson, Byrne, and Duncan-Jones List of Recent Experiences. The LRE (Henderson et al., 1981; Steele, Henderson, & Duncan-Jones, 1980) is a personal interview method based primarily on the Tennant and Andrews (1976) life events scale. Probes administered after event responses are designed to date the event, distinguish discrete events from reports of chronic situations, obtain a brief description of the experience, and obtain ratings reflecting the respondent's judgment regarding severity of impact. A separate staff rates events. Most of the ratings are based on the life-change weights developed by Tennant and Andrews (1976). However, for rare or unusual events for which no life-change weights are available, event weights are calculated by averaging the subjective impact reports of all sample members who reported that type of event. This averaging method is intended to reduce the confounding between subjective retrospective accounts of events and the respondent's mood. Specific data about falloff in reporting severe events and question reliability are not available for a 12-month recall period, although 10-day test-retest reliability estimates are very good, estimated at .89 to .94 for the scale score, and .70 for specific events (Steele et al., 1980). The relative risk of onset of depression or other psychological disorder associated with severe events also cannot be calculated, since this study used a scale of "neurotic symptoms" as its outcome. However, the relative risk of experiencing a high level of neurotic symptoms among those reporting a high score on the life event scale (vs. a low level) was 2.88 (Henderson et al., 1981). The measure has been used only with adults. Summary of Alternative Measures Although the use of alternative interview measures of life events would substantially reduce the costs of conducting life event interviews, the present state of research on these instruments does not recommend their use without qualification. For example, the expectation that more structured life-event interviews would reduce interviewer and rating time is not necessarily fulfilled. The SEPRATE, which is one of the most highly developed of the alternative systems, requires extensive editing and expert rating upon its conclusion (Dohrenwend et al., 1993). Expert rating, as well as the preparation of event descriptions, requires a substantial investment of time that may be no less than that required to field the LEDS. The Paykel Brief Life Events List
72
The Environmental Perspective
requires as much interviewer training as does the LEDS (Cooke, 1985); moreover, reliability estimates for the measure that maximally reduces interview costs are also disappointing (Kessler & Wethington, 1991). Some alternative methods, however, do have their strengths. The Detroit Couples Study method, which does not require extensive interviewer training, is clearly the most compatible with existing community survey methods in the United States. The SEPRATE has several useful rating dimensions and is compatible with a widely accepted theory of the stress process. Falloff estimates for the Paykel Brief Life Events List and the Munich Life Events Inventory rival those reported for the LEDS. Unfortunately, there is no research yet published that directly compares these methods and weighs their theoretical and logistical costs and benefits.
Shortened Versions of the LEDS Miller and Salter (1984) are perhaps best known for their conclusion that there is no "shortcut" for rating the severity of life events with the precision of the LEDS. Yet they also concluded that better life-event rating could be achieved through the use of more detailed standardized probing, rather than through continued reliance on unstructured probing. In response to this statement, a number of investigators have attempted to improve the LEDS interview method by modifying its interview techniques, primarily by structuring probes for event, which would both shorten the time it takes to administer the interview and determine the event ratings. Such structuring, if demonstrated to reproduce the event ratings produced by the LEDS, would substantially reduce its costs. Three revisions of the LEDS are reviewed in the following sections. The Structured Life Events Inventory The Structured Life Events Inventory (SLI: Wethington, Kessler, & Brown, 1993) was designed as a more structured version of the open-ended LEDS.3 The purpose of creating the structured version was to experiment with ways to reproduce Brown and Harris's contextual threat ratings, while also using interviewing techniques more consistent with conventional American survey techniques (e.g., the Detroit Couples Study). Another purpose of structuring the LEDS was to reduce the amount of time necessary in order to produce contextual threat ratings, as well as to cut the amount of necessary training time. The SLI resembles traditional survey interviews more than it does the LEDS, but it still differs significantly from them as well. Consisting of a series of questions designed to elicit events, the SLI provides instructions for the interviewers to probe some of the responses in an extemporaneous, conversational manner, that is, to follow the lead of probe questions that are suggested in the interview, but not necessarily to read the questions verbatim. As does the LEDS, the SLI requires interviewers to make research judgments while they are interviewing. Interviewers are told that the purpose of the probing is
Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events
73
to estimate the objective severity of an event or difficulty reported by the respondent. During the interview, interviewers make judgments about the severity of the event or difficulty the respondent is reporting, and record their summary judgment regarding severity in the interview, along with a detailed description of the situation. Because both of these tasks require fairly precise knowledge about the event or difficulty, as well as some understanding of some of the important aspects of the respondent's life that may increase the event's severity, care has been taken to assist the interviewers in making correct judgments. Time-consuming probing of events and difficulties that are of low-moderate or less severity, as well as failing to detect potentially severe events and difficulties, are errors that can greatly reduce the quality of the data. Although this set of interviewer tasks and judgments may initially seem very challenging, and very difficult to train and supervise, the investigators tried to reduce the burden on the interviewers in several ways—primarily by reducing reliance on memory. A training manual was produced that described the general principles used to make judgments about event and difficulty severity. The conventionally trained survey interviewers were given 3 days of training. Exercises based on examples reported in the LEDS dictionaries were used to teach the interviewers how to make judgments. Interviewers were also trained in probing techniques. In order that training time be reduced, the interview schedule contained as many instructions as feasible to make it possible for determining severity. This was done so that interviewers would not have to memorize a great deal of specific information about what sorts of events and situations are rated as severely stressful, or less. In the interview design, two major strategies were utilized. The first principle was to begin probe sequences with questions designed to screen out as quickly as possible events that were not likely to be severely stressful. For example, reported financial difficulties were not probed if respondents had not had to deplete their savings, sell or skip payments on their major possessions, or go without medical care and necessities such as food and clothing for the family. If events were determined not to reach threshold for severity, the interviewer was instructed to skip to the next question sequence. The second design principle was to produce for each question sequence a series of optional probes that were sensitive to contextual variations that make an event severe or not. An example of this principle is the question and probe sequence for respondent pregnancy: Did this pregnancy have any negative impact on your career or job plans for the future? (Optional: (Will you be/Were you) able to keep your job? (Will you be/Were you) forced to cut back on your work hours? [IF YES] (Is/Was) this your choice or someone else's decision? (Did you have/Will you have) to turn down a promotion, transfer to a less demanding job, or put your career plans "on hold" in any way? [IF YES] (Is/Was this your choice, or someone else's decision?) In addition to the sequence excerpted, there are also questions about whether there were difficulties with the father or other family member during the pregnancy, financial or housing problems, near miscarriages, or other medical emergencies involving either mother or baby. Each includes a set of optional probes to gather information about potentially severely stressful circumstances surrounding the event.
74
The Environmental Perspective
In order to examine interviewer judgment and maintain consistency, all interviews are then examined and rerated by an expert rater, trained in the LEDS method. Ratings for long-term contextual threat, event type, independence from respondent illness, and focus are assigned to the events, based on interviewer ratings and other information from the interview. The SLI was fielded in an experimental study in 1992. This study was designed to examine the reliability and validity of the structured version, in comparison with the original semi-structured method. A sample of 243 community-dwelling residents were interviewed, half with the SLI and half with the original LEDS. Fortyone of the respondents were interviewed twice, using both methods. The LEDS interviewing and weekly panel consensus meetings were supervised by an expert investigator trained by Brown and Harris. Results from this comparison study, although still under review, are promising. The average SLI interview production time (including interviewing, coding, and rating) was 9 hours, compared to 16 hours required for the LEDS. SLI interviewers can conduct more interviews per week (8) than LEDS interviewers (3-4). In addition, SLI interviewers were able to reliably distinguish events of severe long-term contextual threat from more minor events. In addition, the risk of depression onset associated with severe events and difficulties (3 months prior to onset) was similar for the LEDS and SLI in this study, with the LEDS having a slight advantage. Nevertheless, much work still needs to be done on the SLI. Between-interviewer rating reliability was not perfect. The LEDS appears to be superior to the current SLI in eliciting and rating difficulties. In order to improve the SLI, development of a second experimental test is underway. Costello's Two-Stage Screening Method Costello (1982) and Costello and Devins (1988) have experimented with a two-stage screening method in order to reduce LEDS interviewing and rating time. Reasoning that some of the discrepancies found between self-administered checklist and personal interview techniques were due to discrepancies in how events were defined, the investigators developed a checklist based on the LEDS. Event and difficulty descriptions were worded to reflect contextual circumstances that increase severity ratings. Study participants were asked to fill out a screening checklist. Within a week of completing the screening, participants were interviewed in their homes by LEDStrained interviewers who were blind to the checklist results. The investigators then compared severe events and difficulties reported from the two methods. The interview and checklist methods were highly consistent when a severe event or difficulty had not occurred. However, the two techniques were not as consistent when such an event had occurred; only 27 percent of those indicating a "severe" event or difficulty on the checklist were rated as having experienced a severe event or difficulty of that type in the subsequent interview. These results indicate, though, that a checklist method could be used to screen for events at the beginning of a
Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events
75
personal interview, and that the subsequent LEDS administration could be shortened. Such shortening would save considerable interviewing and rating time. The Edinburgh Version of the LEDS Miller and associates (Miller et al., 1986) have also fielded a shortened version of the LEDS. As recommended by Costello (1982), this interview uses a selfadministered checklist screening procedure, with the interviewer probing only those events checked on the list. A panel then assigns ratings based on the LEDS system. In a study using this method, the relative risk of onset of psychiatric disorder (depression or anxiety) is estimated at 2.40 for those who experienced any severe event and 3.21 for those who experienced a severe event or difficulty (Surtees et al., 1986). Falloff rates for event recall appear to be very similar to the LEDS (Surtees et al., 1986). This methods appears to have shortened interview and rating time, although per-interview time estimates have not been published.
Future Directions It is traditional to end such a review with a call for further research. There is a need for more research comparing the interview methods themselves, and more attention to documenting the costs of different personal interview methods. More critical, though, are guidelines to help researchers make judgments about which of the methods reviewed is appropriate for their projects.
Choosing the Appropriate Method Two critical criteria are necessary for judging the appropriateness of an interview method: (1) its suitability to answer the primary research questions of the study, and (2) practical limitations. Several unresolved issues that have circumscribed use of personal interviews based on the LEDS still remain. The first is that the rating system, although clearly defined and documented, confounds some event severity ratings with social vulnerability factors. Many have argued (e.g., Dohrenwend et al., 1993) that these dimensions should be kept strictly separate. The second issue is that the costs of administering any personal interview measure are high in comparison to a checklist. A number of researchers have therefore sought alternatives in order to keep costs down. The third issue is interviewing logistics, over and above study costs. Studies utilizing the LEDS have employed relatively small samples (usually 400 or less). Interviewers require extensive training. Post-interview rating and attendance at weekly panel meetings limit the number of interviews that can be completed per week; as a result, interviews take place only over long periods of time, or a very large number of interviewers must be hired and trained. Even if the panel method is not used to rate events and difficulties, as in the SLI (Wethington et al., 1993) and
76
The Environmental Perspective
the Brief Life Event List (Paykel, 1983), interviewers must be closely supervised and periodically retrained. Some progress has been made in addressing the confounding issue of rating, primarily through the development of the SEPRATE. It is still unclear, though, whether the SEPRATE represents a significant cost savings over the LEDS, or reduces the logistical problems that make the LEDS less practical to apply in larger sample surveys. The ready availability of the LEDS dictionaries, the longer time in which the LEDS has been used, and its ready application to diverse populations (e.g., adolescents and other cultural groups)—all these advantages may outweigh the confounding issue of rating in some researchers' eyes. Significant progress has also been made in reducing cost and logistical problems, primarily through the development of shortened or more standardized versions of the LEDS (Cooke, 1985). Questions still remain, however, about their replicability and reliability, since none has been used as extensively as the LEDS. Acknowledgments The development of this chapter has been supported by grants from the MacArthur Foundation Research Network on Successful Midlife Development to Ronald C. Kessler and USDA Hatch (321-7419) to Elaine Wethington. The authors wish to thank Sheldon Cohen, Stanislav Kasl, Bruce Dohrenwend, Bruce Link, and Martha Bruce for their comments and contributions to this chapter.
Notes 1. Training for the LEDS is conducted by Tirril O. Harris at Royal Holloway and Bedford New College, 11 Bedford Square WC1, UK; and also by Dr. Ellen Frank, University of Pittsburgh, Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, Bellefield Tower, 3811 O'Hara Street, 8th floor, Pittsburgh, PA, 15213, USA. 2. Training for the SEPRATE is available through a staff supervised by Dr. Bruce Dohrenwend, New York State Psychiatric Institute, Box 8, 722 West 168th Street, New York, NY 10032, USA. 3. Inquires about use of the SLI should be directed to Dr. Elaine Wethington, Department of Human Development and Family Studies, G63 Van Rensselaer Hall, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA.
References Bebbington, P. (1986). Establishing causal links: Recent controversies. In H. Katschnig (Ed.), Life events and psychiatric disorder: Controversial issues (pp. 188-200). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Bebbington, P. E., Brugha, T, MacCarthy, B., Potter, J., Sturt, E., Wykes, T, Katz, R., & McGuffin, P. (1988). The Camberwell Collaborative Depression Study. I. Depressed probands: Adversity and form of depression. British Journal of Psychiatry, 152, 754-765. Brown, G. W. (1981). Contextual measures of life events. In B. S. Dohrenwend & B. P. Dohrenwend (Eds.), Stressful life events and their contexts (pp. 187-201). New York: Prodist.
Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events
77
Brown, G. W. (1989). Life events and measurement. In G. W. Brown & T. O. Harris (Eds.), Life events and illness (pp. 3-45). New York: Guilford. Brown, G. W., Adler, Z., & Bifulco, A. (1988). Life events, difficulties, and recovery from chronic depression. British Journal of Psychiatry, 752,487-498. Brown, G. W., Bifulco, A., & Harris, T. O. (1987). Life events, vulnerability, and onset of depression: Some refinements. British Journal of Psychiatry, 150, 30-42. Brown, G. W., & Harris, T. O. (1978). Social origins of depression: A study of depressive disorder in women. New York: Free Press. Brown, G. W., & Harris, T. O. (1982). Fall-off in the reporting of life events. Social Psychiatry, 17, 23-28. Brown, G. W., & Harris, T. O. (1989a). Life events and illness. New York: Guilford. Brown, G. W., & Harris, T. O. (1989b). Summary and conclusions. In G. W. Brown & T. O. Harris (Eds.), Life events and illness (pp. 439-482). New York: Guilford. Cannell, C. F., Miller, P. V., & Oksenberg, L. (1981). Research on interviewing techniques. In S. Leinhardt (Ed.), Sociological methodology (pp. 389-436). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Cooke, D. J. (1985). The reliability of a brief life event interview. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 29, 361-365. Costello, C. G. (1982). Social factors associated with depression: A retrospective community study. Psychological Medicine, 12, 329-339. Costello, C. G., & Devins, G. M. (1988). Two-stage screening for stressful life events and chronic difficulties. Canadian Journal of Behavioral Science, 20, 85-92. Dohrenwend, B. S., Krashnoff, L., Askenasy, A. R., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1978). Exemplification of a method for scaling life events: The PERI life events scale. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 19, 205-229. Dohrenwend, B. P., Link, B. G., Kern, R., Shrout, P. E., & Markowitz, J. (1990). Measuring life events: The problem of variability within event categories. Stress Medicine, 6, 179-187. Dohrenwend, B. P., Raphael, K. G., Schwartz, S., Stueve, A., & Skodol, A. (1993). The structured event probe and narrative rating method for measuring stressful life events. In L. Goldberger & S. Breznitz (Eds.), Handbook of stress: Theoretical and clinical aspects (pp. 174-199). New York: Free Press. Faravelli, C., & Ambonetti, A. (1983). Assessment of life events in depressive disorders: A comparison of three methods. Social Psychiatry, 18, 51-56. Fiedler, K., & Stroehm, W. (1986). What kind of mood influences what kind of memory?: The role of arousal and information structure. Memory and Cognition, 14, 181-188. Punch, D. P., & Marshall, J. R. (1984). Measuring life stress: Factors affecting fall-off in the reporting of life events. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 15, 453-464. Gorman, D. M., & Brown, G. W. (1992). Recent developments in life-event research and their relevance for the study of addictions. British Journal of Addiction, 87, 837849. Harris, T. O. (1991). Life stress and illness: The question of specificity. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 13, 211-219. Henderson, S., Byrne, D. G., & Duncan-Jones, P. (1981). Neurosis and the social environment. New York: Academic Press. Katschnig, H. (1980). Measuring life stress: A comparison of two methods. In R. Farmer & S. Hirsch (Eds.), The suicide syndrome (pp. 116-123). London: Croom Helm. Katschnig, H. (1986). Measuring life stress: A comparison of the checklist and panel technique. In H. Katschnig (Ed.), Life events and psychiatric disorders: Controversial issues (pp. 74-106). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
78
The Environmental Perspective
Kessler, R. C. (1990). The National Survey of Health and Stress. Ann Arbor, MI: Survey Research Center, University of Michigan. Kessler, R. C., & Wethington, E. (1991). The reliability of life event reports in a community survey. Psychological Medicine, 21, 723-738. Lennon, M. C., Dohrenwend, B. P., Zautra, A. Z., & Marbach, J. J. (1990). Coping and adaptation to facial pain in contrast to other stressful events. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 59, 1040-1050. McQuaid, J., Monroe, S. M., Roberts, J. R., Johnson, S. L., Garamoni, G. L., Kupfer, D. J., & Frank, E. (1992). Toward the standardization of life stress assessment: Definitional discrepancies and inconsistencies in methods. Stress Medicine, 8, 4756. Miller, P. McC., Dean, C., Ingham, J. G., Kreitman, N. B., Sashidharan, S., & Surtees, P. G. (1986). Life events and long term difficulties in a sample of Edinburgh women, with some reflections on the concept of independence. British Journal of Psychiatry, 148, 686-696. Miller, P. McC., & Salter, D. P. (1984). Is there a short-cut? An investigation into the life event interview. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 70, 417-427. Monck, E., & Dobbs, R. (1985). Measuring life events in an adolescent population: Methodological issues and related findings. Psychological Medicine, 15, 841-850. Paykel, E. S. (1978). Contribution of life events to the causation of psychiatric illness. Psychological Medicine, 8, 245-253. Paykel, E. S. (1983). Methodological aspects of life event research. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 27, 341-352. Raphael, K. G., Cloitre, M., & Dohrenwend, B. P. (1991). Problems with recall and misclassification with checklist methods of measuring stressful life events. Health Psychology, 10, 62-74. Shrout, P. E., Link, B. G., Dohrenwend, B. P., Skodol, A. E., Stueve, A., & Mirotznik, J. (1989). Characterizing life events as risk factors for depression: The role of fateful loss events. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 98, 460-467. Sobell, L. G., Toneatto, T, Sobell, M. B., Schuller, R., & Maxwell, M. (1990). A procedure for reducing error in reports of life events. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 2, 163-170. Steele, G. P., Henderson, S., & Duncan-Jones, P. (1980). The reliability of reporting adverse experiences. Psychological Medicine, 10, 301-306. Surtees, P. G., & Duffy, J. C. (1989). Binary and rate measures of life event experience: Their association with illness onset in Edinburgh and London community surveys. Journal of Affective Disorders, 16, 139-149. Surtees, P. G., Miller, P. McC., Ingham, J. G., Kreitman, N. B., Rennie, D., & Sashidharan, S. P. (1986). Life events and the onset of affective disorder: A longitudinal general population study. Journal of Affective Disorders, 10, 37-50. Tennant, C., & Andrews, G. (1976). A scale to measure the stress of life events. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 10, 27-32. Tennant, C. & Bebbington, P. (1978). The social causation of depression: Critique of the work of Brown and his colleagues. Psychological Medicine, 8, 565-575. Tennant, C., Bebbington, P., & Hurry, J. (1981). The role of life events in depressive illness: Is there a substantial causal relation? Psychological Medicine, 11, 379-389. Wethington, E., Kessler, R. C., & Brown, G. W. (1993). Training manual and technical report for the structured life events inventory. Ithaca, NY: Life Course Institute, Cornell University.
Interview Measurement of Stressful Life Events
79
Wittchen, H., Essau, C. A., Hecht, H., Teder, W. & Pfister, H. (1989). Reliability of life event assessments: Test-retest reliability and fall-off effects of the Munich Interview for the Assessment of Life Events and Conditions. Journal of Affective Disorders, 16, 77-91. Zimmerman, M. (1983). Methodological issues in the assessment of life events: A review of issues and research. Clinical Psychology Review, 3, 339-370.
4 Daily and Within-Day Event Measurement John Eckenrode and Niall Bolger
In this chapter we review methods that assess stressful experiences at the daily level, primarily through self-reports using some form of daily diary or record. Although other forms of self-recording devices are available to measure bodily states, such as blood pressure (see Chapter 10), these techniques are less relevant to the assessment of exposure to stressors or the cognitive or behavioral responses to stress and, as such, will not be emphasized here. There are compelling reasons why a researcher may choose to assess stressful experiences and related constructs such as coping at the daily level (Stone & Shiffman, 1992; Verbrugge, 1980). Measurement at the daily level affords the researcher with the equivalent of a behavioral science microscope. By recording the details of human thoughts, feelings, and actions, diaries have a resolving power that cannot easily be achieved through the use of standard interviews or questionnaires. For stress researchers, this resolving power can be used to tackle important theoretical problems such as the nature of chronic stress, the mechanisms through which major stressors exert their effects, and the role of personality and social structure in the stress process. Traditionally, to measure chronic and acute stressors, stress researchers obtained retrospective reports stretching back over months and years. Such methods are prone to a variety of recall biases that limit their accuracy. Although they are not applicable to all types of stress research, diary designs can be used prospectively to study chronic and acute stressors over periods of weeks and months. Furthermore, as theories of stress focus increasingly on intervening processes and mechanisms (Kessler, Price, & Wortman, 1985), the value of methods that can tap into everyday thoughts, feelings, and actions increases. Finally, the prospective nature of diary data helps to address some of the causal ambiguity inherent in retrospective survey data.
Short History of Daily Life Event Research Wheeler and Reis (1991) have recently reviewed the history of methods of selfrecording of everyday life events. Additional historical references for the use of 80
Daily and Within-Day Event Measurement
81
health diaries are provided by Verbrugge (1980). Excellent summaries of available methodologies for the daily assessment of stressful events have been published by Stone, Kessler, & Haythornthwaite (1991) and Stone and Shiffman (1992). Suls and Martin (1993) also provide a brief history of daily recording methods. What is clear from these reviews is that daily methods, while not playing a prominent role in behavioral science research, have enjoyed a rather long history and are becoming increasingly popular. The latter is evidenced by the appearance of two recent special issues of journals devoted to research using daily reports and self-recording methods (Journal of Personality 59:3, 1991; Annals of Behavioral Medicine 15:1, 1993). Some of the early uses of daily records or diaries were in consumer expenditure surveys, studies of food consumption, and time use surveys (e.g., Sudman & Ferber, 1971; Szalai, 1972). Verbrugge (1980) reports even earlier uses of diaries in health studies, beginning with the Baltimore Morbidity Survey from 1938 to 1943 (Downes & Collins, 1940). In such early health studies, the diary was used primarily as a memory aid when researchers conducted interviews about illness episodes. More recent health studies have also used diaries, including the National Medical Care Expenditure Survey, in which respondents keep a diary of medical expenses. As Verbrugge (1980) points out, these health studies have included diaries primarily as a methodological check on the accuracy of data on health-related episodes and behaviors collected with more conventional interviews, questionnaires, or health records. Compared to these other methods, diaries generally yield higher incidence rates for acute and chronic conditions (Verbrugge, 1980). In the field of psychology, Wheeler and Reis (1991) point to several trends that fueled an interest in methods to assess everyday experience. The renewed interest in inner experience in the 1960s along with the appearance of research instruments designed to assess momentary psychological states (e.g., the Nowlis Mood Adjective Checklist; Nowlis, 1965) have led to many studies that have explored the stability of mood over several days, the correlates of changes in mood, and the relation of mood changes to more major changes in physical or psychological health status (see Chapter 7). Research and therapy based on behaviorist theories has also generated an interest in assessing daily experience. Research on psychological disorders, such as depression has benefited from examining the behavioral correlates of positive and negative mood states on a daily basis (e.g., Lewinsohn & Libet, 1972; Lewinsohn & Talkington, 1979). In the therapeutic context, diaries have served as a method for identifying behaviors that may be the focus of treatment and for evaluating the effectiveness of treatment strategies. In this tradition, the assumption was that the act of recording everyday thoughts, feelings, and behaviors may itself modify behavior (see Duncan, 1969). The reactive nature of these techniques, although viewed as a strength among the behavioral therapists, remains a source of concern among researchers using these methods primarily as a data collection tool. Personality psychologists have also recognized the value of assessing daily experiences as a way to explore stability and change in personality constructs over time (e.g., Epstein, 1979, 1980). Csikszentmihalyi and his colleagues (e.g., Csikszentmihalyi, Larson, & Prescott, 1977) have utilized the "experience sampling method" (ESM) to tap into subjects' (usually adolescents') thoughts or behaviors at
82
The Environmental Perspective
random intervals over several days. An electronic paging device is used as the signal for the subject to record (see Hormuth, 1986, for a review of these methods). These methods have been valuable in documenting the prevalence and stability of psychological states (e.g., negative affect; Larson & Ham, 1993) as well as behaviors (e.g., time studying) and in exploring the co-occurrence of these states and behaviors (e.g., Wong & Csikszentmihalyi, 1991). One of the earliest uses of the diary method in stress research was a study by Meyer and Haggerty (1962) in which families kept diaries of stressful family events, that were then related temporally to the outbreak of streptococcal infections. This was followed by a community-based study by Roghmann and Haggerty (1972, 1973) in which a large sample of adults kept daily diaries of stressful events, illnesses, and the use of health services. These studies established some of the first links in the literature between minor daily stressors and health-related outcomes. Studies in the early 1980s by Eckenrode and colleagues (Caspi, Bolger, & Eckenrode, 1987; Eckenrode, 1984; Gortmaker, Eckenrode, & Gore, 1982); and by Verbrugge as part of the Health in Detroit Study (e.g., Verbrugge, 1985), used a simple, open-ended question or an abbreviated checklist to record stressful events, and then related these daily measures to mood, illnesses, or health behaviors. At about this time, several other research groups began exploring daily stressors and their relation to psychological or physical health outcomes. Mirroring the earlier development and widespread usage of the Schedule of Recent Experiences (SRE: Holmes & Rahe, 1967), the measures of daily stressors typically involved checklists. Lewinsohn and associates developed the Pleasant Events Schedule to explore the relationship between depression and levels of daily positive experiences and activities (Lewinsohn & Libet, 1972), as well as its counterpart, the Unpleasant Events Schedule (Lewinsohn & Talkington, 1979). Emerging from their transactional view of the stress process, Lazarus and his colleagues began to explore the nature of everyday stressors as a complement to major life events. This research group produced the 117-item Hassles Scale and the 135-item Uplifts Scale which originally were used as monthly measures (Kanner, Coyne, Schaefer, & Lazarus, 1981) but were also adapted for use as a daily measure (DeLongis, Folkman, & Lazarus, 1988). Although there has been some controversy concerning the extent to which the Hassles Scale is confounded with mental health outcomes (see Dohrenwend, Dohrenwend, Dodson, & Shrout, 1984; Lazarus, DeLongis, Folkman, & Gruen, 1985), its popularity has served to focus the attention of stress researchers on small life events. It has also served as the basis for the development of other measures that assess hassles generally or in specific domains, such as the Parenting Daily Hassles Scale (Crnic & Greenberg, 1990). The early 1980s also saw the development of checklist measures specifically designed to be used on a daily basis. Stone and associates developed the Assessment of Daily Experience (ADE) measure (Stone & Neale, 1982). This 66-item scale included both positive and negative experiences distributed across five major domains (e.g., work-related activities, leisure activities). The current version, the Daily Life Experience (OLE) checklist, contains 78 items (Stone, Neale, & Shiffman, 1993). In addition to engaging in extensive piloting studies to generate scale items, these researchers have also reported concordance data between husband and
Daily and Within-Day Event Measurement
83
wife couples as a way to address validity issues. Such checklist measures are reviewed in more detail below. Currently, researchers are adapting these earlier efforts to address a range of theoretical issues in stress research. As more researchers have utilized daily approaches to the assessment of stressful experiences, discussions of methodological and analytic issues in daily studies have also become more commonplace (e.g., Jaccard & Wan, 1993; Kenny, Kashy, & Bolger, 1993; Stone, Kessler, & Haythornthwaite, 1991; West & Hepworth, 1991).
Research Questions That Can Be Addressed with Daily Event Measures Daily event measures can be used to address a wide range of research questions. We list some of the major ones below and give examples of studies in each case. Note that we assume that the measures are used in a daily diary design—namely, a longitudinal design that involves repeated assessments of daily stressors over the course of a single day, over multiple days, or both. The daily data that are collected in such designs can be aggregated over days to obtain person-level stress measures, such as the total number of days on which work conflicts occurred. Such stress measures may be less prone to recall biases than retrospective reports covering that same time period, but it is questionable whether the costs of using diary data in this way outweigh any benefits in reducing measurement error. A much better use of diary data is to preserve the longitudinal nature of the data by keeping the analysis at the level of the person-day. Analyses at the daily level can examine temporal relationships between daily stressors and daily outcomes, while still allowing the researcher to examine individual differences in these processes. We discuss data analysis issues later in this chapter. The first and most obvious use of daily event measures is to document people's exposure to stressors. In studies of work stress, for example, researchers may be interested in knowing how often workers are exposed to various types of daily problems such as work overloads and interpersonal conflicts with co-workers, supervisors, or subordinates. A recent study by Bolger et al. (1989) found that work overloads and work conflicts differed dramatically in their prevalence. Workers complained of being overloaded with work on 1 out of every 3 days, whereas they complained of having work conflict only once a month. It is commonly believed that negative events can have a cascading effect such that "one bad thing leads to another." A second use of daily event measures is to investigate this belief by studying the interrelationships between daily events over time. For example, one way in which the management of work and family roles creates distress is that stressful events in one domain lead to stressful events in the other domain (Bolger, DeLongis, Kessler, & Wethington, 1989). A third use of these measures, and the one that has received the most research attention, is to study the impact of daily events on physical and mental health. Initial work demonstrated associations between summary measures of daily events and psychological distress (Kanner et al., 1981). This work has been expanded to
84
The Environmental Perspective
examine the emotional impact of specific categories of daily events (Bolger, DeLongis, Kessler, & Schilling, 1989; Stone, 1987). For example, the Bolger et al. (1989b) study mentioned earlier found that work conflicts are the most distressing of all daily events, whereas the much more common work overloads were not very distressing. Progress has also been made on understanding the relationship of daily events to physical symptoms (DeLongis, Coyne, Dakof, Folkman, & Lazarus, 1982; DeLongis et al., 1988). A fourth type of question that can be addressed using daily event measures is the extent to which daily events make up the elements of chronically stressful experiences (see Chapter 5). For example, daily event measures can permit investigators to identify the discrete events (overloads, conflicts) that make up a chronically stressful marriage or occupation. Consistent with this idea, Eckenrode (1984) has shown that daily events are predicted by measures of chronic stress. Daily events are also predicted by measures of major life events. This is thought to occur because major life events affect health outcomes, in part through increasing daily problems (Eckenrode, 1984; Kessler, Price, & Wortman, 1985). Therefore, a fifth use of daily event measures is to assess the extent to which they mediate the effects of major life events. For example, in a study of low-income mothers, Eckenrode (1984) showed that major life events predicted subsequent daily events which, in turn, predicted daily distress. Pearlin and colleagues (1981) demonstrated that the effects of major work disruptions such as unemployment include chronic role strains and thereby increased depression. As noted above, daily events are likely to be the key elements of chronic stress. More generally, a fruitful area of research is the extent to which daily events mediate the effects of personality and social variables on disease. For example, daily events have been shown to explain partially the effects of personality variables, such as neuroticism, on daily distress (Bolger & Schilling, 1991) and physical symptoms (Larsen & Kasimatis, 1991). Finally, as is the case of major events, people differ in the extent to which they are emotionally and physically affected by daily stressors. Researchers have begun to explore personality and social variables that modify the impact of these stressors. For example, the effects of daily stressors have been shown to depend on selfesteem (Campbell, Chew, & Strachey, 1991; DeLongis et al., 1988), neuroticism (Bolger & Schilling, 1991; Larsen & Kasimatis, 1991), and social support (Caspi, Bolger, & Eckenrode, 1987; DeLongis, Folkman, & Lazarus, 1988). All of the above questions can be answered within a data-analytic framework variously known as the multi-level model, the mixed model, the hierarchical linear model, and the covariance components model. The essential feature of these models is that they recognize that diary data have two random components: one due to the sampling of persons (or couples, families, etc.), and the other due to the sampling of repeated measurements within persons (e.g., days). To make correct inferences from diary data, both of these sources of variance need to be considered. Using statistical models that fail to take both random components into account (e.g., conventional regression and ANOVA models) can produce very misleading results. Kenny, Kashy, and Bolger (1993) provide an overview of analysis approaches to diary data and explain in detail why it is necessary to use multi-level analytic
Daily and Within-Day Event Measurement
85
models. Guidance on diary data analysis is also provided by West and Hepworth (1991) and Jaccard and Wan (1993). Software for correctly analyzing these data is available mostly in specialized programs such as HLM (Bryk & Raudenbush, 1992), ML3 (Prosser, Rasbash, & Goldstein, 1991), GENMOD (Mason, Anderson, & Hayat, 1988). MIXREG (Hedeker, 1993), and VARCL (Longford, 1986). Equivalent programs are also available within standard statistical packages: MIXED is available as part of SAS software, and 5V is available as part of BMDP software. All these programs use a multiplestep Maximum Likelihood approach to estimation and testing. Kenny, Kashy, and Bolger (1993) describe a simpler, one-step Weighted Least Squares approach that can be carried out using SAS's GLM program. Choosing an Appropriate Measure It is useful to categorize methods used in daily stress assessment as an aid to researchers who are considering using a daily approach. Such a taxonomy will also be useful in pointing out the limitations of this review, which is focused primarily on a subset of all possible methods. Wheeler and Reis (1991) describe three generic types of daily self-report methods: (1) interval-contingent recording; (2) signal-contingent recording; and (3) event-contingent recording. Suls and Martin (1993) added a fourth category to this scheme, continuous recording, which will not be discussed here since it is less relevant to stress research. Although interval-contingent recording has been by far the most frequently used method in stress research, we describe both signalcontingent and event-contingent methods because of their potential benefit to researchers in this field.
Interval-Contingent Recording In this method, data are collected at regular intervals, determined ahead of time by the researcher. Typically the time interval has been a day, although shorter and longer time periods have been used. The respondent will usually report on events that have occurred since the last self-report, although specific research questions may require that events covering a shorter period of time between recordings be assessed. For example, in her study of work stress and marital interaction among air traffic controllers and their spouses, Repetti (1989) had respondents complete daily diaries that asked them to report on marital behavior for that evening, since the research question concerned the effects of the work day on subsequent marital interactions.
Signal-Contingent Recording This method involves having respondents record their experiences whenever signaled by the researcher. Typically, the interest is with what the respondent is experi-
86
The Environmental Perspective
encing at the precise moment they are signaled. As such, the time period covered is very brief. A good example of this method is the Experience Sampling Method (ESM) developed by Csikszentmihalyi and Larson (Csikszentmihalyi & Larson, 1987; Larson & Csikszentmihalyi, 1983). In their work, electronic "beepers" worn by respondents are used to signal the recording period. Respondents may be signaled several times a day, at random or during prespecified times. These methods may be particularly useful in recording inner experiences, such as mood, that may fluctuate often during the day, and thus be subject to recall biases if assessed several hours or days later.
Event-Contingent Recording This method requires respondents to make a report every time a predetermined event has occurred. For example, in research with the Rochester Interaction Record (Wheeler & Nezlek, 1977) and the Iowa Communication Record (Duck, 1991), respondents are instructed to use diaries or logs to answer questions about social interactions as they occur. Depending on the research question being addressed, the event may be a predictor variable, such as an argument with a spouse, or an outcome variable, such as a headache or other physical symptom. Since the events in question may occur at any time, the length of time between records varies. Such an approach is well suited to events with a well-defined beginning and ending, such as an argument, but is less appropriate for experiences that may be less temporally defined, such as feeling sad.
Comparing Methods Each of the methods described above has distinct advantages and disadvantages. Choosing a method requires the researcher to consider the nature of the stressor to be assessed and the research questions or hypotheses to be tested. There are also important logistical considerations in choosing a method. Sometimes, limitations of a given method can be overcome by combining different methods within the same study. Interval-contingent methods are useful in documenting the amount of exposure an individual has to particular types of stressors or in assessing overall exposure levels in a given period of time. For example, a researcher may be interested in the number of arguments between spouses over a particular time period (e.g., a week, a month). As Stone et al. (1991) point out, the frequency with which records are kept (several times a day, once a day, once a week), as well as the total number of recording periods (e.g., 30 consecutive days, 6 consecutive months) should be based on an understanding of the stressor in question, the temporal relationship between the stressor and relevant outcomes, and a consideration of the statistical power needed for the analyses to be conducted. For example, as noted above, Bolger et al. (1989b) found that work conflicts were reported only about once every month. If a researcher was interested in the relationship between work conflict and
Daily and Within-Day Event Measurement
87
mental health, it would clearly be inadequate to ask respondents to keep a daily diary for a total of one month, since this would yield an average of only one incident. However, a reliable estimate of instances of work overload, a much more common stressor for many people, may well be achieved with a daily diary kept for one month. The nature of the outcome in question is also an important consideration in determining the length of time respondents should be asked to keep diaries. For example, if mood is the outcome of interest, daily recordings for 3 or 4 weeks will usually yield sufficient variability in mood scores to allow the investigator to explore the temporal relationship between a daily stressor such as work overload and changes in mood. However, rarer discrete outcomes such as absenteeism and utilization of health services would require that the study be lengthened to allow for enough of these events to occur. There are two potential problems with interval-contingent methods. The most obvious is that respondents may be recording the data several hours or days after the event in question took place. This makes these methods susceptible to forgetting and biased recall (Suls & Martin, 1993; Wheeler & Reis, 1991). This problem is greater for continuous phenomena that vary considerably over relatively short time periods (e.g., mood, amount of perceived work stress, levels of concentration) than discrete events with a well-defined time of onset (e.g., argument, exercise, headache). Having respondents record information at more frequent intervals may help solve this problem, but may have the undesirable effect of overburdening the respondent. Diary studies often instruct respondents to complete the diaries at the end of each day. An advantage to this practice is that respondents get accustomed to a regular routine of completing the diaries, making it less likely for them to forget to complete the record (although telephone reminders and daily collection of diaries help reduce this problem). It is also logical in terms of having respondents summarize their day. However, some research questions might dictate completion of the diaries at times other than the end of the day. For example, a work stress study may want respondents to complete the diary immediately after work; or a study investigating physiological changes related to myocardial ischemia may want recording to occur toward the end of the morning since there is evidence that there is a higher incidence of ischemia in the morning hours (Krantz et al., 1993). However, a potential problem with using any fixed time interval for recording daily, weekly, or, monthly data may occur if the phenomenon being measured tends to have a regular cyclical pattern. For example, more undesirable life events tend to be reported on weekdays, compared to weekends (Stone et al., 1985). As such, estimating the prevalence of such events based on a daily diary completed once a week for several weeks may be biased if always completed on either a weekday or a weekend. Signal-contingent methods effectively eliminate the recall problem by having respondents immediately record their thoughts, feelings, or behaviors when they are signaled by the researcher. Since the respondents can be signaled at any time, this method may also eliminate the potential bias introduced by having the respondents complete the diaries at the same time of day or day of week. For assessing frequently occurring activities, as well as inner psychological and physiological states, signal-contingent methods would appear very useful. Studies using these methods
88
The Environmental Perspective
have been particularly useful in documenting how various groups of people spend their daily lives, and as well as how inner psychological states co-vary with certain activities. For example, Csikszentmihalyi and Larson (1984) report that, among students, studying tends to be associated with negative mood, especially among low achievers. There are at least two disadvantages to signal-contingent methods (Suls & Martin, 1993; Wheeler & Reis, 1991). First, because they are designed to assess immediate experience versus recall over a longer time period, they are impractical as a way to study infrequently occurring events or stressors. For example, if the research question concerns the relationship between arguments and physical symptoms, ESM-type methods would be unlikely to sample enough episodes of arguments to allow for a meaningful analysis. However, if the researcher is interested not in investigating a particular class of stressor, but, rather in assessing whether any stressor was occurring at that time, then ESM methods would be more feasible. Chronic stressors rather than acute stressors are more likely to be assessed with this method. This is especially true if samples of individuals susceptible to the chronic stressor in question are studied. For example, Williams et al. (1991) studied the relationship between juggling multiple roles and mood in a sample of working mothers using ESM methods. The second major disadvantage of signal-contingent methods is that they are more intrusive than other methods since respondents have no control over when they will complete the records. As such, they may be signaled at times when it is inconvenient to fill out the data form (e.g., in class, at dinner, feeding the baby, in the shower, jogging). Some ESM studies allow respondents to turn off the signal devices when they do not want to be disturbed. For both reasons, respondents will not respond to a certain percentage of signals; thus some data will be missing. For example, Larson (1979), using an adolescent sample, reported that one-third of the signals were missed. Other studies with adults and children report a rate of missed signals of between 15 and 20 percent (e.g., Csikszentmihalyi & Graef, 1980; Larson & Lampman-Petraitis, 1989). Although we found no data on this issue, it seems logical to assume that the ability of respondents effectively to tolerate the intrusiveness of these methods would decrease as the level of disorganization and stress in their lives increased. If so, missing data may not be random in the sample studied. Pilot testing with high-risk samples is necessary to ensure that respondents can use these methods effectively. Event-contingent methods, like signal-contingent methods, overcome problems with forgetting and selective recall by having respondents complete a record every time a particular type of event occurs. Unlike signal-contingent methods, these methods also can be used to study events with varying frequencies. The event that triggers the record could be either a predictor variable (e.g., stressful interpersonal interactions) or an outcome variable (e.g., asthma attacks, drug use). These methods are particularly useful for studying the immediate circumstances surrounding specific acute stressors or discrete outcomes. They are less feasible for studying chronic stressors since time of onset is not likely to be well defined (although some chronic stressors have an acute onset). Advances in the technology of physiological measurement will also expand the range of bodily conditions that could trigger a record (e.g., increased blood pressure or heart rate).
Daily and Within-Day Event Measurement
89
Event-contingent approaches require that respondents be well trained in the definition of the event to be studied. Most events involving social interaction, for example, will vary considerably in intensity and duration. For instance, a study of work stress may require respondents to complete a record every time they experience conflict with a supervisor. In such a study, clear instructions regarding the researcher's definition of "conflict" would need to be given to respondents to prevent them from being overly exclusive or inclusive. Even with extensive training, it is helpful to have respondents provide some open-ended descriptive information about the event so that the researcher can confirm that the incident being recorded meets the study definitions. An alternative approach, advocated by Stone, Kessler, & Haythornthwaite (1991), is to have interviewers who are trained to probe for relevant events make daily phone calls to respondents. An interesting variant of the event-contingent approach was a study conducted by Bolger (Bolger, 1990; Bolger & Eckenrode, 1991) in which college students preparing for a medical school admission test kept daily diaries for 21/2 weeks before and 21/2 weeks after the exam. The stressful event, the exam, was therefore preselected by the researcher. The diary data could then be used to assess the students' psychological states and coping responses leading up to the exam. These data were particularly useful in documenting differences in the adjustment of the students to this stressor as a function of social integration and personality characteristics, measured prior to the diary period. This is an example of how diary methods can be used to study the impact of major as opposed to minor stressors. This approach is, of course, feasible only with events that can be anticipated. Since they involve intensive self-monitoring of behavior over several occasions, all the methods described here are potentially reactive in nature. But this may be particularly true of event-contingent methods, depending on the amount of control the respondent has over the event in question. For example, if the event involves a behavior such as smoking or substance use, or a type of social interaction over which the respondent has some control, such as an argument with a spouse or child, completing a record every time such an event occurs may cause the behavior to change over time. This may contribute to the commonly observed pattern of response decay over time in diary studies (Stone et al., 1991; Verbrugge, 1980), although it is often difficult to determine whether a decrease in the rate of reporting events over time is due to fatigue, or to changes of feelings or behaviors resulting from the task. This uncertainty may be partly resolved by debriefing respondents after the diary-reporting period of the study is completed, asking them directly about the diary task and changes in their behavior over time. The diary period may also be shortened to prevent fatigue or sensitization. However, this may require a larger number of subjects to compensate for the loss of statistical power due to reducing the number of days.
Specific Daily Stress Measures For each of the methods reviewed above, there are a variety of approaches to eliciting information about daily stressors, ranging from single open-ended questions (e.g., Eckenrode, 1984) to structured checklists (e.g., Stone & Neale, 1982).
90
The Environmental Perspective
The choice of approach depends on the focus of the study, the mode of data collection (e.g., paper-and-pencil diaries versus daily phone calls), and the circumstances and tolerance of the population being studied. We concentrate on checklist approaches here, although we first briefly discuss open-ended methods since they may be more suitable for some researchers. An open-ended method was used by Eckenrode (1984) in a study of low-income women and children using a neighborhood health center in Boston (see also Caspi, Bolger, & Eckenrode, 1987; Gortmaker, Eckenrode, & Gore, 1982). In this study, these women were asked to complete a one-page diary at the end of each day for 28 days. The single question regarding stress was: "Did anything go wrong today in the house, with the children or others in the household, at work, or elsewhere?" If a respondent answered "yes," she were then asked to describe what happened. Such responses could then be classified into discrete categories. This diary was a modification of a diary used by Roghmann and Haggerty (1972), who asked three separate open-ended questions, beginning with the stem question "Did anything go wrong today?" and then varying the domain ("at work or in the house"; "with the school or the children"; "getting along with friends, relatives, husband"). More recently, Emmons (1991) had undergraduate subjects keep a daily diary (completed twice a day) in which they were asked to list four events or thoughts, two that contributed to negative mood and two to positive mood. Coders then categorized events into categories (e.g., achievement, interpersonal). As Stone et al. (1991) point out, there are both advantages and disadvantages to such an open-ended approach. Simple, open-ended questions are easy for respondents to understand and to complete in little time. This may be attractive in studies where stress is not the major focus of the study and where time is limited. If phone interviews are used rather than paper-and-pencil diaries, open-ended questions can also establish a more conversational style and greater rapport with respondents. If combined with probes for various domains of stress, the resulting data can then be coded by the researcher into discrete categories of stressful events. There are also several disadvantages to open-ended approaches. In paper-and pencil versions, they require respondents to write out a description of the events. The amount of detail provided by respondents will vary greatly, leading to potential problems in classifying responses. Recall is also more likely to be biased by personality traits or transient mood states when an open-ended versus a structured format is used, although for minor stressors, the amount of recall error with diaries will generally be much lower than with retrospective interviews. Finally, open-ended questions will tend to underestimate the total exposure of respondents to stressors on a given day. If the researcher is interested in knowing only whether any stressor occurred that day, these methods may be adequate. However, if the research question requires a more complete assessment of all stressors occurring that day, other approaches, such as the checklist methods described below, are more appropriate. As an alternative to open-ended questions about stressful events, some studies have used brief global ratings of perceived stress levels. For example, in a study of the relationship between daily stress and recurrence of genital herpes simplex, Rand and colleagues (1990) had respondents complete a Daily Stress Questionnaire which asked them to indicate on a 4-point Likert scale how much stress they felt that day in
Daily and Within-Day Event Measurement
91
six areas (e.g., physical health, financial, relations with family). Watson (1988), in a daily study of the correlates of negative and positive affect, asked college students, "How much stress (e.g., because of hassles, demands) were you under today?" Responses were recorded on a 5-point Likert scale (1 = felt very slightly or not at all; 5 = felt very much). Such approaches may provide convenient summary measures of perceived stress at the daily level, and may be a practical alternative to more comprehensive assessments of daily events when the amount of space devoted to stress assessment in the diary is very limited. However, these approaches may sample only a small portion of potentially stressful experiences, or measure stress at such a global level so as to preclude analyses that differentiate between types of stressors. Global assessments of perceived stress also tend to confound the objective exposure to stressors with the respondent's reaction to them (e.g., distress), a problem similar to that faced by the assessment of major life events (see chapters