Margaret Fuller, Critic
This page intentionally left blank
Margaret Fuller, Critic Writings from the New-York T...
189 downloads
1406 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Margaret Fuller, Critic
This page intentionally left blank
Margaret Fuller, Critic Writings from the New-York Tribune, 1844–1846
Edited by
Judith Mattson Bean and
Joel Myerson
Columbia University Press, New York
C
columbia university press Publishers Since 1893 New York Chichester, West Sussex Copyright © 2000 Columbia University Press All rights reserved Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Fuller, Margaret, 1810–1850 Margaret Fuller, critic : writings from the New York Tribune, 1844–1846 / edited by Judith Mattson Bean and Joel Myerson. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 0–231–11132–0 (cloth : alk. paper) 1. Books—Reviews. 2. American Literature—19th century—History and criticism. 3. Literature—History and criticism. I. Bean, Judith Mattson. II. Myerson, Joel. III. Title. PS2502.B43 2000 809—dc21
99–087879
Casebound editions of Columbia University Press books are printed on permanent and durable acid-free paper. Printed in the United States of America c 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents
topical table of contents acknowledgments xiii introduction xv textual note xli
ix
“Emerson’s Essays” 1 “Thanksgiving” 8 “New Year’s Day” 14 “Miss Barrett’s Poems” 20 “The Liberty Bell for 1845” 28 [Review of Charles Lanman, Letters from a Landscape Painter] 32 [Review of James Russell Lowell, Conversations on Some of the Old Poets] 35 “Edgar A. Poe” 42 [Review of Lydia H. Sigourney, Scenes in My Native Land] 46 “French Novelists of the Day: Balzac . . . . . . . George Sand . . . . . . . Eugene Sue” 54 [Review of Richard Hildreth, The Slave; or, Memoirs of Archy Moore] 65 [Review of The Child’s Friend, ed. Eliza L. Follen] 67 [Review of Anton Schindler, The Life of Beethoven] 71 [Review of Henry R. Schoolcraft, Oneota, or The Red Race of America] 80 “Mr. Hudson’s Lecture on Hamlet” 89 [Review of Theodore Parker, The Excellence of Goodness] 93 “Our City Charities. Visit To Bellevue Alms House, to the Farm School, the Asylum for the Insane, and Penitentiary on Blackwell’s Island” 98 “Writers Little Known Among Us. Milnes . . . Landor . . . Julius Hare.” 105 “Frederick Von Raumer upon the Slavery Question” 116 “ ‘Ertheiler’s Phrase-Book’ ” 117 “Mrs. Child’s Letters” 119 v
vi
Contents
[Review of Charles Anthon, A System of Latin Versification] 121 [Review of Arthur Cleveland Coxe, Saul. A Mystery] 124 “‘American Facts’ ” 126 “Prevalent Idea that Politeness is too great a Luxury to be given to the Poor” 128 [Review of Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass] 131 “Asylum for Discharged Female Convicts” 134 “Story Books for the Hot Weather” 138 “United States Exploring Expedition” 143 [Review of Charles Sealsfield, Tokeah; or the White Rose] 145 “The Irish Character” 146 “Fourth of July” 149 [Review of Anna Cora Mowatt, Evelyn] 152 [Review of Edgar Allan Poe, Tales] 153 “The Irish Character” 155 “Thomas Hood” 161 [Review of Caroline Norton, The Child of the Islands, and John Critchley Prince, Hours with the Muses] 173 “First of August, 1845” 183 “Thomas Hood” 189 “Prince’s Poems” 195 “The Great Britain” 207 [Review of Sylvester Judd, Margaret] 210 [Review of Philip James Bailey, Festus] 211 “The Tailor” 220 “Jenny Lind . . . The Consuelo of George Sand” 227 “The Wrongs of American Women. The Duty of American Women” 233 “Ole Bull” 240 [Review of The Prose Works of John Milton] 245 “Italy” [Alfieri] 252 “The Celestial Empire” 259 “Italy” [Dante] 262 [Review of Caroline M. Kirkland, Western Clearings] 267 [Review of Edgar Allan Poe, The Raven and Other Poems] 271 [Review of Frederick Von Raumer, America and the American People] 277 [Review of Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Poems] 285 “Study of the German Language” 293 “Peale’s Court of Death” 295
Contents
“Books of Travel” 299 [Review of Thomas Carlyle, Oliver Cromwell’s Letters and Speeches] 306 [Review of The Poetical Works of Percy Bysshe Shelley] 317 “1st January, 1846” 323 [Review of Schoolcraft Jones, Ellen; or Forgive and Forget] 333 “Cassius M. Clay” 338 “Methodism at the Fountain” 342 “Publishers and Authors. Dolores by Harro Harring” 350 “The Rich Man—An Ideal Sketch” 359 [Review of Leigh Hunt, Italian Poets] 367 “Consecration of Grace Church” 372 “The Poor Man—An Ideal Sketch” 375 “Instruction in the French Language” 384 “What Fits a Man to be a Voter? Is it to be White Within, or White Without?” 386 “[Robert] Browning’s Poems” 390 “Wiley & Putnam’s Library” 400 [“Age could not wither her . . .” ] 402 “Mistress of herself, though china fall” 406 [Review of Harro Harring, Dolores: A Novel of South America] 410 “Victory” 424 “The Grand Festival Concert at Castle Garden” 426 [Review of Eliza W. Farnham, Life in Prairie Land] 429 [Review of Waddy Thompson, Recollections of Mexico] 431 “Critics and Essayists” 439 [Review of Joel T. Headley, Napoleon and His Marshals] 448 [Review of Nathaniel Hawthorne, Mosses from an Old Manse] 453 [Review of George Sand, Consuelo] 457 [Review of Thomas L. McKenney, Memoirs, Official and Personal] 464 [Review of Charles Brockden Brown, Wieland; or, the Transformation and Ormond; or, the Secret Witness ] 472 [Review of Anna Jameson, Memoirs and Essays ] 476 [Review of Samuel Maunder, The Treasury of History] 481 index
483
vii
This page intentionally left blank
Topical Table of Contents
American Literature “Emerson’s Essays” 1 “The Liberty Bell for 1845” 28 [Review of Charles Lanman, Letters from a Landscape Painter] 32 [Review of James Russell Lowell, Conversations on Some of the Old Poets] 35 “Edgar A. Poe” 42 [Review of Lydia H. Sigourney, Scenes in My Native Land] 46 [Review of Richard Hildreth, The Slave; or, Memoirs of Archy Moore] 65 [Review of The Child’s Friend, ed. Eliza L. Follen] 67 [Review of Henry R. Schoolcraft, Oneota, or The Red Race of America] 80 “Mr. Hudson’s Lecture on Hamlet” 89 “Mrs. Child’s Letters” 119 [Review of Arthur Cleveland Coxe, Saul. A Mystery] 124 “ ‘American Facts’ ” 126 [Review of Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass] 131 “Story Books for the Hot Weather” (for a review of Nathaniel Parker Willis, Dashes at Life with a Free Pencil) 138 [Review of Charles Sealsfield, Tokeah; or the White Rose] 145 [Review of Anna Cora Mowatt, Evelyn] 152 [Review of Edgar Allan Poe, Tales] 153 [Review of Sylvester Judd, Margaret] 210 [Review of Caroline M. Kirkland, Western Clearings] 267 [Review of Edgar Allan Poe, The Raven and Other Poems] 271 [Review of Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Poems] 285 [Review of Schoolcraft Jones, Ellen; or Forgive and Forget] 333 “Wiley & Putnam’s Library” 400 [Review of Eliza W. Farnham, Life in Prairie Land] 429 “Critics and Essayists” (for reviews of Henry T. Tuckerman, Thoughts on the Poets and The Modern British Essayists) 439 ix
x
Topical Table of Contents
[Review of Joel T. Headley, Napoleon and His Marshals] 448 [Review of Nathaniel Hawthorne, Mosses from an Old Manse] 453 [Review of Charles Brockden Brown, Wieland and Ormond] 472 British Literature “Miss Barrett’s Poems” 20 “Writers Little Known Among Us. Milnes . . . Landor . . . Julius Hare.” 105 “Story Books for the Hot Weather” (for reviews of Benjamin Disraeli’s works) 138 “Thomas Hood” 161 [Review of Caroline Norton, The Child of the Islands, and John Critchley Prince, Hours with the Muses] 173 “Thomas Hood” 189 “Prince’s Poems” 195 [Review of Philip James Bailey, Festus] 211 [Review of The Prose Works of John Milton] 245 [Review of Thomas Carlyle, Oliver Cromwell’s Letters and Speeches] 306 [Review of The Poetical Works of Percy Bysshe Shelley] 317 “Methodism at the Fountain” 342 [Review of Leigh Hunt, Italian Poets] 367 “[Robert] Browning’s Poems” 390 “Critics and Essayists” (for reviews of George Gilfillan, Richard Henry Horne, and Thomas Talfourd) 439 [Review of Anna Jameson, Memoirs and Essays ] 476 Cultural and Social Criticism “Thanksgiving” 8 “New Year’s Day” 14 “The Liberty Bell for 1845” 28 [Review of Theodore Parker, The Excellence of Goodness] 93 “Our City Charities. Visit To Bellevue Alms House, to the Farm School, the Asylum for the Insane, and Penitentiary on Blackwell’s Island” 98 “Frederick Von Raumer upon the Slavery Question” 116 “Prevalent Idea that Politeness is too great a Luxury to be given to the Poor” 128 [Review of Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass] 131 “Asylum for Discharged Female Convicts” 134 “United States Exploring Expedition” 143
Topical Table of Contents
“The Irish Character” 146 “Fourth of July” 149 “First of August, 1845” 183 “The Great Britain” 207 “The Wrongs of American Women. The Duty of American Women” 233 “1st January, 1846” 323 “Cassius M. Clay” 338 “The Rich Man—An Ideal Sketch” 359 “Consecration of Grace Church” 372 “The Poor Man—An Ideal Sketch” 375 “What Fits a Man to be a Voter? Is it to be White Within, or White Without?” 386 [“Age could not wither her . . .” ] 402 “Mistress of herself, though china fall” 406 [Review of Harro Harring, Dolores: A Novel of South America] 410 “Victory” 424 [Review of Waddy Thompson, Recollections of Mexico] 431 [Review of Thomas L. McKenney, Memoirs, Official and Personal] 464 European Languages and Literature “French Novelists of the Day: Balzac . . . . . . . George Sand . . . . . . . Eugene Sue” 54 “Frederick Von Raumer upon the Slavery Question” 116 “‘Ertheiler’s Phrase-Book’ ” 117 [Review of Charles Anthon, A System of Latin Versification] 121 “Story Books for the Hot Weather” (for reviews of Eugène Sue’s works) 138 “The Tailor” 220 “Jenny Lind . . . The Consuelo of George Sand” 227 “Italy” [Alfieri] 252 “Italy” [Dante] 262 [Review of Frederick Von Raumer, America and the American People] 277 “Study of the German Language” 293 “Books of Travel” (for reviews of Hermann Heinrich’s and Gustav von Waagen’s works) 299 “Publishers and Authors. Dolores by Harro Harring” 350 “Instruction in the French Language” 384 [Review of George Sand, Consuelo] 457
xi
xii
Topical Table of Contents
Literary Criticism and Genres of Literature [Review of The Child’s Friend, ed. Eliza L. Follen] (children’s literature) 67 “Story Books for Hot Weather” (fiction) 138 “Prince’s Poems” (poetry) 195 “Italy” [Dante] (translations) 262 “Books of Travel” (travel writing) 299 “Publishers and Authors. Dolores by Harro Harring” (publishing) 350 “Critics and Essayists” (essays) 439 [Review of Joel T. Headley, Napoleon and His Marshals] (biography) 448 [Review of Samuel Maunder, The Treasury of History] (history) 481 Music and Art [Review of Anton Schindler, The Life of Beethoven] 71 “Ole Bull” 240 “The Celestial Empire” 259 “Peale’s Court of Death” 295 “The Grand Festival Concert at Castle Garden” 426
Acknowledgments
This project has been supported by a number of scholars and institutions. Assistance in transcribing Fuller’s words from darkened and aging copies of the New-York Tribune was essential to completing the full collection. Support for this work was provided by Texas Woman’s University and the University of South Carolina. We appreciate the work of Camille Langston, Ginger Cotton, Ann Hoff, Lee Davinroy, Chris Nesmith, Ralph H. Orth, and Todd Richardson, who participated in this effort, and especially the work of Michael McLoughlin. Judith Bean wishes to thank especially Sondra Ferstl, Elizabeth Snapp, and Lucyle Hook. Joel Myerson thanks Robert Newman, chair of the English department of the University of South Carolina, for his support. We are also indebted to a number of libraries and their staffs who assisted in the work of examining Fuller’s papers: the Boston Public Library, the Houghton Library of Harvard University, the Massachusetts Historical Society, the New York Public Library, the Blagg-Huey Library of Texas Woman’s University, and the University of South Carolina. We received helpful encouragement and suggestions from many Fuller scholars. Wilma Ebbitt’s 1943 dissertation editing some fifty of Fuller’s texts from the Tribune proved a valuable source of information. We are grateful to Professor Ebbitt, as well as members of the Margaret Fuller Society, and especially Susan Belasco and Robert N. Hudspeth. Our introduction has benefited from suggestions made by Larry J. Reynolds. Susan Heath has edited the work with precision. We owe a special debt to Jennifer Crewe of Columbia University Press, who helped us through the various stages of this project and was instrumental in helping us achieve the final, comprehensive result. Judith Mattson Bean Joel Myerson
xiii
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction
When Margaret Fuller became the literary editor of the New-York Tribune in the fall of 1844, she also embarked on a process of reshaping her identity. Her Tribune essays, like her most famous work, Woman in the Nineteenth Century (1845), can be read not only as cultural critique but also a record of Fuller’s evolving identity. With each column Fuller expressed her sense of self by taking positions that identified her politically and culturally. Before moving to New York City, Fuller lived in Boston, where she participated actively in its culture and identified herself with the progressive and reformist citizens, such as the Reverend William Ellery Channing, Ralph Waldo Emerson, and Amos Bronson Alcott. She initiated an educational experiment by leading seminars (called Conversations) for women and edited the Dial, the Transcendentalists’ literary journal, for two years.1 Although informally educated, she was described as the most brilliant woman in America and one of the leading minds of her time. In Boston her efforts were aimed at interpreting European literature and German literary philosophy, encouraging American literature and art, and developing her own intellectual powers. Her philosophical orientation toward the idealism of the German Romantics such as Herder and Goethe was balanced by her appreciation for classical thought. Although progressive in literary and educational theories, she rejected direct association with “radical” groups such as the abolitionist societies in Boston. Her Tribune essays indicate that her New York experiences transformed her political consciousness and reoriented her perspective. They show that she gained an increased understanding of the opportunities for political action open to women and to intellectuals as she directly considered national political programs and her own role in shaping them through one of the most popular newspapers of the day. Although in the 1840s political endeavor was, by definition, men’s work, Fuller’s columns reveal her growing radicalism and confidence in her political identity. Working for the Tribune brought her into contact with marginalized xv
xvi
Introduction
women, reformers, and political activists and forced her to express her views on the social issues of her day. Her columns became textual acts of identity produced through individualized responses to this sociohistorical context. Reading and writing were recursive processes through which she developed a socially expanded identity. Each political position or literary judgment she asserted situated her in public debates and developed her credibility as a social and literary critic. Through Fuller’s case, we can examine how women, especially in times of national redefinition, recreate for themselves new identities that challenge prescriptive cultural norms against political activism. The 1840s were a decade of reform in which individuals identified themselves in part by their attitudes toward reform itself. Americans were reexamining the principles of democracy and individualism, questioning the relation of the nation as a whole to segments of the population defined by race (African Americans, Native Americans), class (Irish immigrant laborers), and gender (women). American women were active in reforming public institutions despite social expectations that they confine themselves to private life. During 1846–47 alone, the Tribune reported on the public activities of women such as Dorothea Dix, who was petitioning the New Jersey legislature for improved care of the insane; Abby Kelley, who was lecturing against slavery; and Delia Webster, who was imprisoned for allegedly subverting slavery laws in Kentucky (and to whom Fuller refers in the 28 December 1844 Tribune (“New Year’s Day”). Several women advocated reform in Horace Greeley’s newspaper: Harriet Beecher Stowe published antislavery fiction; Maria Chapman and Frederika Bremer argued for abolition. Lydia Maria Child attacked slavery, nativism, and the persecution of women prisoners; Caroline Kirkland spoke out on women’s rights. Catharine Sedgwick worked quietly to educate and assist women prisoners; Ernestine Rose spoke in a public meeting of the New York Prison Association; and Eliza Farnham became the first woman to supervise and reform a women’s prison. Elizabeth Barrett’s poetry inveighed against the plight of poor and working classes in England. Although women could undertake humanitarian reforms and maintain social respectability, direct political involvement (such as lobbying) and public political argumentation was still very risky. Fuller admired the risk-takers and praised them in her columns, reviewing the works of reformist women writers such as Child, Farnham, Sedgwick, and Barrett. In her praise of individual women, Fuller implicitly identifies herself with them and their public work, displaying a redefinition of self as woman. She praises speakers who do not “make phrases or compliments; [nor] slur over the truth.”2 They are
Introduction
xvii
“truth-tellers,” an epithet she often applies to herself. Fuller’s recurring metaphor for acts of protest and reform is the grain of mustard seed. Fuller’s readings link acts of reform to texts and present rationales for social transformation. She writes, for example, in “New Year’s Day” (28 December 1844), that, “While reading a notice of a successful attempt to have musical performances carried through in concert by the insane at Rouen [France], we were forcibly reminded of a similar performance we heard a few weeks ago at Sing Sing” (the New York prison for women). After reporting the European precedent and implying that prisoners should be given the same consideration as the insane, she goes on to describe an organizational meeting of the New York Association for the Benefit of Prisoners as a “happy omen . . . [and] cause for thanksgiving.” Thus her reviews, particularly of other women writers, delineate Fuller’s shift toward political activism. Whether this shift constitutes an extension or rejection of Romantic idealism is debatable.3 Fuller vehemently defends reform activity against the charge of superficial sentimentalism when Carlyle labels proponents of abolishing capital punishment as disgusting Rose-Water Philanthropists or advocates of “Jean-Jacques Philanthropy.” She challenges Carlyle’s habit of ridiculing individuals whose political position differs from his and condemns his indiscriminate categorizing.4 His comments call attention to the significant link between romanticism and reform fever in America. Fuller’s growth as a critic of contemporary American culture was possible because in the Tribune, with its reform orientation, she could “address, not our neighbor, who forces us to remember his limitations and prejudices, but the ideal presence of human nature as we feel it ought to be and trust it will be. We address America rather than Americans.”5 In addressing America, Fuller participated in shaping attitudes toward America’s political conduct. Fuller’s Tribune reviews often omit contextualizing comments and assume acquaintance with the New York political and literary milieu. The Tribune’s place in the political landscape was generally within Whig territory (supporting Daniel Webster and Henry Clay), but it was also associated with reformist papers that generally opposed the Whigs. The Tribune generally opposed political positions of the democrats (supporters of Andrew Jackson and Martin Van Buren), which found favor in William Cullen Bryant’s Morning News. Nevertheless, the reformist aims of Horace Greeley (and Fuller) were occasionally similar to the United States Magazine and Democratic Review. On some issues Fuller aligns herself with the Democratic Review and democrats who sympathized with European revolutions. On slavery and the Texas annexation issue,
xviii
Introduction
she stands with New England Whigs, Greeley, and her friend William Henry Channing. At other times Fuller speaks out individually to bring an issue to public attention. A promoter of associationism, Greeley encouraged Fuller to intensify reformist views and express them with force. He tirelessly covered national political events and supported reform or party work through editorials and excerpts from other periodicals. Greeley’s primary editorial concern was the improvement of prospects for both industry and laborers in America. He assigned Fuller to report on a variety of city events and activities as well as writing literary reviews. Fuller’s first Tribune review appeared just after the Whig presidential defeat of 1844, a political campaign that swamped Greeley’s pages for months and ended with the election of the Jacksonian “Young Hickory,” James Polk. A fierce national division over the Texas annexation issue during the campaign prompted South Carolina to threaten secession and one group in Massachusetts to declare the union dead. The controversy temporarily subsided during 1845 when Texas rejected annexation terms, but when those issues were resolved and Texas was formally annexed in the fall of 1845, war with Mexico erupted in the spring of 1846. Like Greeley, Fuller opposed war with Mexico, not only for antislavery reasons but also from a deeply felt antipathy for the imperialistic impulses of the Manifest Destiny ideology that was used to justify the war. The annexation debate of the 1820s to the 1840s revealed deep cultural tensions. The 1846–48 war with Mexico originated from several causes beyond the expansion of slavery. Indeed, some argue that the strongest supporters of forceful Texas annexation were New York commercial interests who stood to profit from increased trade. Ambition to amass individual fortunes through land speculation was also rampant. A rapidly expanding population of urban poor increased fears of class war, encouraging the annexation of Texas as a safety valve for urban conflict. Yet another factor was anti-Catholic nativism, which provided grounds for opposing Mexican rule of Texas (and, ironically, for the desertion of Irish soldiers from U.S. divisions for service with Mexico). Finally, competition with England for domination in the western hemisphere supported Texas annexation. In New England Whigs rallied to protest annexation because it would increase slave territory. Abolitionism was still an unpopular ideology in New York, and Greeley’s paper expressed a dissenting view. The Tribune featured reports and commentary on antislavery and anti-Texas meetings and on the activities of abolitionists Frederick Douglass, Cassius Clay, and Delia Webster.
Introduction
xix
The related issue of black suffrage emerged when New York State began rewriting its constitution. Fuller responded to both the annexation and black suffrage issues in her columns in essays, reviews, allusions, and metaphors (such as a black cloud hanging over America). Initially, Fuller viewed the Texas debate as contesting only slavery, but her later essays exhibit a larger and more complex understanding of the multiple forces that led to war. In them, she realizes that a war would drastically reconfigure the nation’s population and landscape, leaving a legacy of dispossession and ethnic conflict. Fuller’s essays actively resist American imperialism with attempts to subvert racist American expansionist rhetoric and to legitimate Mexican independence and property rights, while simultaneously exposing Mexican oppression of indigenous people. Fuller’s participation in this debate was significant for another reason: the war with Mexico played a critical role in her disillusionment with America. Before her departure for Europe in the fall of 1846, she began to equate U.S. national policy with European despotism and imperialism. When she maintained her opposition to the war after it was declared, she, like Greeley, was exposed not only to classification as a radical and controversial author but also to charges of disloyalty to America (accusations that Greeley defended himself against in the Tribune). Speaking out on controversial issues had its price; for example, the publishing firm Wiley & Putnam demanded that Fuller withdraw some essays from their forthcoming collection of her critical essays. Thus Fuller’s political essays become significant public acts of identity. Through them she creates the authority, subjectivity, and selfhood that anticipate her European dispatches. The Texas conflict was only one of several struggles over national boundaries and identity. At the root of the Mexican conflict was a dispute over philosophies of history and nationhood. Supporters of the war argued that strife between advanced and primitive peoples was as inevitable as was the victory of the advanced race. Others, who held a more organic theory of history, envisioned peaceful growth and expansion as a benign process in which the youthful, vigorous culture would replace degenerate, older civilizations. However, the mixed population of Mexico posed a conundrum. Was Mexico a Spanish, hence degenerate, older civilization, or an Indian, and thus a primitive civilization; was the United States the most advanced or the youngest civilization? How, in other words, was the United States to act in relation to its southern neighbor? Thus the war with Mexico raised fundamental issues of national identity and history. Through her arguments, analysis, allusions, and extensive quotations, Fuller’s political essays allow modern readers to decon-
xx
Introduction
struct monolithic descriptions of national myths such as Manifest Destiny that neglect opposing voices. What Fuller’s Tribune essays provide, therefore, in addition to an increased understanding of this writer’s work, is an opportunity to reconfigure the parameters within which antebellum American cultural discourse is defined. Her Tribune essays follow the same impulses that now stimulate feminist and postcolonial literary criticism. Philosophically oriented to the comparative approach employed by Goethe and Herder, Fuller’s essays problematize constructions of American imperialism, recreating the dialogue between the American colonizer and the colonized other. These essays also reveal—through example—the redefinition of political discourse as woman’s work. Fuller was at the center of American and New York City attempts to establish new identities independent of British cultural influence. One dominant feature of the discourse of national identity was the polarization of U.S. democracy in opposition to monarchy worldwide. Czar Nicholas of Russia, whose domain was the world’s largest, epitomized European monarchical power. Thus, when the czar met P. T. Barnum’s protégée, Tom Thumb, the “smallest and the greatest personages in existence met” (“General Tom Thumb’s Career,” NYDT 6 July 1844). With every attempted revolt (in Ireland or Poland, for example) or successful effort to gain independence from a monarch (as in South America), the press celebrated the advance of world democracy for America’s “brothers” in liberty around the globe. Napoleon’s place in history provided considerable debate in the periodical press (including that by Greeley and Fuller) and in public lectures, the dominant oral media of the day. Writers revealed their political stances by their interpretations of Napoleon as either despot or brilliant leader. In reviewing contemporary American literature, Fuller practices a democratic criticism that challenges writers to uphold ideals of liberty and equality. Her political essays also argue that America’s principles of liberty and equality are endangered by American materialism, greed, and the desire for continental domination. She directs attention to the relation of dominant American society to the other, contending that American society is founded upon tolerance and upon recognition of universal human rights rather than domination by force. Because Americans wanted to claim the cosmopolitan sophistication of Europe but to reject its monarchical political systems and alleged cultural decadence, ambivalence marked arguments for a unique national identity. Greeley once claimed that European news was becoming less and less important to America, but elsewhere he held up European cities and cultures as the
Introduction
xxi
measure of American growth and success. American insecurities appeared in frequent comparisons and attempts to prove U.S. parity with Europe. With a regular column on city life and many reports on city development, Greeley established a personal and journalistic identification with New York, which he saw as a growing American city in contrast to older European urban centers. Evidence that New York was competitively oriented toward European rather than American cities appeared in the higher frequency of Tribune comparisons of New York with London and Paris rather than with such American cities as Boston, Philadelphia, Washington, or Baltimore. Fuller’s readings of foreignlanguage literature and periodicals assisted in creating a cosmopolitan ethos for the Tribune and for New York City, while her attention to American literature and culture developed the theme of national identity. Interest in European culture and politics was intense despite America’s nationalistic feelings; cosmopolitan New Yorkers recognized the importance of transatlantic exchanges in material and intellectual culture, in people, and in technology. Literary commerce was not limited to the import of European books; publishers’ crews raced out to meet ships before they docked, hoping to scoop competing newspapers and publishing houses for European news and pirated editions of literary works. The Tribune featured full-page displays of European news fresh from steamships and advertisements for the latest installments of French novels. In addition to social and political news, the paper provided columns such as “Glimpses of Europe” (a foreign travel column) and Fuller’s columns of “Items of Foreign Gossip,” gleaned from European periodicals. In her reviews of foreign-language periodicals and literature, Fuller argues for the significance of journalism in literary culture and for the importance of reading literatures of other nations. Parisian newspapers, for example, are praised as illustrating the potential for high standards of journalism.6 Fuller’s translations and criticism of others’ translations assert the importance of international literary exchange. Fuller’s Tribune writing illustrates the potential service of the critic as mediator in a pluralistic, cosmopolitan, literary culture. Mirroring New York life in the 1840s, the Tribune displays a heteroglossia of urban cultures and international dialogue. Daily enmeshed in city life, confronted with contradictory theories of culture and national policy, Fuller’s profession involved discourses of race, gender, class, political power, nationhood, economics, authorship, education, and religion (to name a few). By the mid-1840s New York had become a metropolis, a complex of multiple environments, unknown to each other and perhaps unknowable to any single individual through direct or per-
xxii
Introduction
sonal experience. City life was mediated through the daily press, and the many different environments of the city were represented there.7 Fuller not only wrote for one of the city’s and nation’s most popular papers (circulation two hundred thousand), she also read it and responded to its reports. Fuller’s humanism and background as a critic and translator of foreign literature encouraged her to adopt the role of mediator among classes, ethnic groups, and national literary cultures. Her feminism inclined her to produce feminist criticism (i.e., criticism that is more ethically than aesthetically oriented and that moves toward human change and genuine social improvement). Believing in the socially contingent nature of literature in the tradition of Germaine de Stäel, Fuller read contextually; her aesthetic and social comments were intertwined. Her preference for dialogic, intertextual discourse creates a need on the part of the modern reader for an awareness of Fuller’s cultural milieu. Living in New York increased Fuller’s interest in theories of economics and social class and convinced her of the need for a literature that mediated between classes. By one estimate the richest 1 percent of New York’s population in 1845 owned one-half of the city’s wealth, while the upper 4 percent owned more than four-fifths of the city’s total wealth.8 The problem of poverty was felt to be “a ragged insult to the land of opportunity,” and by 1850 the New York police estimated that three thousand vagrant children lived in the streets.9 Burgeoning immigration, particularly as the Irish famine began, overwhelmed American port cities between 1845 and 1855; New York’s foreignborn population increased from one-third to one-half during those years. One solution was imprisonment; the majority of those sentenced to prison were vagrants. Workhouses were another option; Randall’s Island was used for a children’s farm school, Blackwell’s for a prison and almshouse. New York geography reified the growing divisions, with wealthy New Yorkers building on high ground in mid-island (e.g., Washington Square), while the poor occupied districts near the docks, in the Five Points area, and on the lower East Side. Housing problems contributed to frequent city fires—such as one at the Tribune—and water supply problems continued until the 1842 addition of a new water supply source. Greeley advocated increasing land availability in the east and promoted western homesteading. As an ardent Associationist, he believed that as business prospered, the worker would prosper. To address inadequacies of public assistance, New Yorkers began to organize reform and philanthropic groups such as the Mariners Family Industrial Society and the Association for the Improvement of the Condition of the Poor. The Tribune publicized meetings
Introduction
xxiii
and agendas of groups that advocated land-rent reform, prison reform, postalcost reform, associationism, and temperance. Greeley also campaigned daily for the rights and opportunities of working men and women. A series of articles, “Labor in New-York” (August to October 1845), presented statistical analyses of working conditions and wages for several blue-collar occupations and working women. Fuller wrote essays focusing on the rich and the poor concurrently with this series, and in other essays engaged in the ongoing discourse about growing class divisions. Utilitarianism, or Benthamism, persuasively theorized social, political, and economic aspects of the increasingly industrialized culture. In the Tribune the term political economy referred to utilitarianism. When Fuller refers to its principle, “the greatest good for the greatest number,” her tone suggests ambivalence or opposition.10 Her essays reveal an awareness that utilitarianism seemed democratic but in fact created advantages for dominant groups at the expense of dissenters and social misfits. With the emergence of economics as a science, a sense of social determinism emerged, challenging individualistic ideologies and positing the inevitability of poverty. Utilitarians argued that economic laws were natural laws, an idea that appealed to those who held that the poor were a divinely ordained part of society. In response to the growing appeal of so-called “political economy,” American writers such as Fuller confronted the problem of creating a truly humane and egalitarian society. Although significantly influenced intellectually by contacts with underprivileged women, prisoners, and women reformers, Fuller was not able in New York to transcend class boundaries in a personal sense. Her essays on the rich and poor indicate that, although she expressed sympathy for the imprisoned poor and domestic servants, she had no rebuttal for theories of economic determinism and had not yet questioned the foundations of class relations as she later did in Italy. The theory upon which she relied was an organic model of society that assumed difference but complementarity between mental and manual work, mind and body. A construct similar to one in Catharine Sedgwick’s best-selling novel The Poor Rich Man and the Rich Poor Man (1836) and Edward Everett’s “Lecture on the Working Men’s Party” (1830), the organic model relied upon interdependency rather than competition of classes.11 Nevertheless, contacts with the poor unsettled Fuller’s earlier definitions of self, race, gender, and class, preparing her for a more radical transformation in Europe. She adapted the organic principle to theorize national differences and literature in a pluralistic model, a “beautiful variety in the order of nature,” which assumed that nations possessed individual mental and moral character-
xxiv
Introduction
istics emerging in national literatures.12 Her perspective resembled Herder’s model of the political family as one of diversity and harmony in which the folk express the essential national identity. Fuller’s essays demonstrate her desire to include in the literary culture “the seed of each plant that ever bloomed in the garden of Humanity,” all growths, whether humble and noble.13 Fuller’s pluralistic vision of American culture is illuminated by her cross-cultural thinking; she envisions American culture as receiving not only people but seeds of thought and expression from other nations. Fuller’s New York writing brought her into the busy literary marketplace during the “Golden Age of Periodicals,” and her essays reflect the growing importance of publishers and periodicals. Publishing was stimulated by technological advances, making it more than an activity of elite culture. Literary journalists included Edgar Allan Poe and Walt Whitman, both of whom responded to Fuller’s writing.14 In August 1845 Whitman returned from New York City to Brooklyn to edit the Brooklyn Eagle; he reacted to Fuller’s work as a woman critic and to her calls for an American poet. Poe became the editor of the Broadway Journal as well as publishing his Tales and “The Raven” in 1845. Poe and Fuller met at gatherings of the literati and reviewed each other’s work, engaging in a dialogue marked by polarities of critical theory and practice as well as personal and regional differences. The importance of contemporary periodicals to the literary culture is attested by frequent reviews of periodicals in the Tribune, which regularly previewed The Knickerbocker, the Democratic Review, Graham’s, Godey’s, and others with short notices, extracts, or lists of contents. The Democratic Review established itself as a leader in New York City literary culture and has been cited in histories of magazines for its vigorous political commentary and excellence in literary publications. Although the conservative Knickerbocker presented itself as the ultimate in metropolitan sophistication, its greatest appeal was its literary gossip. The Broadway Journal, under editor Charles F. Briggs, aimed to configure New York as an American Paris. Fuller’s reviews and allusions to Boston’s North American Review exhibit the generally held opinion that it had become stodgy. The Fourieristic Harbinger, published at Brook Farm, received her accolades. Fuller regularly read and alluded to both American and foreign periodicals, such as Blackwood’s and the Liberal Whig Edinburgh Review. Her columns present a dialogue with British and American reviewers who discussed many of the same works and issues. The Democratic Review and its writers became important to Fuller’s thinking about social and literary issues, although she differed from their expan-
Introduction
xxv
sionist stance and acquiescence with slavery. For example, she moved toward their position that literature was a form of social action and that the writer could shape individual and political perceptions. Fuller also supported its enthusiasm for democratic revolutions in Europe and South America and its calls for a distinctive and democratic American literature. The Democratic Review followed the logic that democracy would equalize wealth, that redistribution of wealth would increase leisure among the masses and thus increase the desire for democratic literature and art. Under this theory, intelligence was presumed to be widely distributed in the masses, but the poor were thought to require satisfaction of their material needs before they could be expected to appreciate the refinements of culture. Like Fuller, the Democratic Review called for “a new species of poetry, expressly designed to represent their condition and utter their aspirations, and at the same time to encourage and sustain their endeavors.”15 Fuller expresses hope for a working-class literature in her reviews of works by Thom and Prince, retitled as “Poets of the People” in Papers on Literature and Art in 1846. Fuller’s work at the Tribune challenged her to consider the nature of work: manual work, mechanized work, and the intellectual work of authorship. All forms of intellectual work were challenged by Adam Smith’s popular theories of productive (manual) labor and “unproductive” intellectual labor, of laborers as the producers of wealth versus unproductive consumers of wealth. In a mass-market economy and democracy what was the value of literature—its market and moral value—to the people and to its producers? Fuller’s complex vision considers not only the author’s spiritual needs but the economics and limitations of publisher and public as well. When she insists that America should “at least, pay interest on this rich capital” from the English mind (in a review of Hood’s poetry) or argues for the intellectual property rights of authors (in “Publishers and Authors”), she engages in an international dispute on the nature of authorship and literature.16 Greeley published several articles related to authorial rights and his own admonitions to authors from the publisher’s perspective. Although England adopted a copyright law in 1842, the United States refused to do so, and pirated editions were a mainstay of publishers such as Harper and Brothers, the largest publisher in the country. Both authors and publishers were tempted to claim ideological justification for monetary motivation. American authors and publishers not only contested definitions of literature and the author but also negotiated relationships of author to publisher and publisher to the democratic public. Fuller presents authorship as a political, economic, and intellectual endeavor. She recognizes
xxvi
Introduction
legitimate aesthetic and material motives entailed in the collaborative process of publication. As part of the industrial revolution, print culture was being redefined by science and technology. Utilitarianism and technological advances were described as progressive “signs of the times,” harbingers of the march of civilization that was revolutionizing New Yorkers’ relationships to the rest of the country and the world. Improvements in printing, bookbinding, imaging, and paper production were covered in the Tribune, but the three technological advances that ignited the most public interest were the steamship, the railroad, and the telegraph. Upon the completion of the first telegraph line in 1844, the Tribune hailed it as the “miracle of the annihilation of space.”17 Franchises and construction of new lines were reported with the same degree of excitement granted to leasing space on the information highway of the 1990s. A three-column, front-page etching of the Great Britain demonstrated the general excitement over the arrival of a colossal steamer, the world’s largest and most technologically advanced ocean liner when it went to sea. Impressed with the transformational potential of the new ship, one writer declared that “Steam [travel] destroys nationality.”18 Enthusiasm for technology was also reflected in the number and kinds of patents reported and the space given by the Tribune to each new theory. Chemistry, geology, photography (and pseudosciences such as the water cure and phrenology) promised new and exciting ways of viewing the world and aiding humanity. Greeley provided agricultural columns to bring new methods to the farmer, and Fuller responded to the steamship and new theories in several essays. Changes in the definition of academic knowledge also added to cultural uncertainty. Material aspects of life (e.g., biology and physics) were now subjected to empirical rather than metaphysical analysis. In Boston Fuller’s contemporaries had stressed the spiritual interpretation of phenomena; in New York the empirical was celebrated and new scientific discoveries hailed. The new empirical approach to political and economic realms added weight to the notion that society as a whole, like the phenomenal world, was governed by scientific laws. Although Fuller read scientific theorists and began to analyze material conditions, she also continued to use physical phenomena as organic metaphors for the social, psychological, or spiritual elements of life. Fuller’s organic theory of literature posits the origin of artistic expression from internal impulses that assume their physical forms (genres) by continuously interacting with specific historical and geographic surroundings. Thus, she writes, the impulse for historical expression emerged as historical romances
Introduction
xxvii
in America rather than the poetic epics of Europe. Founded in German romanticism, this theory legitimates a hermeneutics of literary production and, broadly applied, of literary, material and social history.19 For Shelley, one of the poets Fuller most admired, organicism could be used to theorize a protohistoricist criticism. Shelley (as well as Fuller) felt that poems should remain true to their culture, or in Paul Youngquist’s terms, “incorporate their historicity, representing truth not as a formal product but as socio-historical production.”20 More than a theory unique to the Romantic period, this philosophical orientation has been described as one of four basic perceptual frames. Fuller’s concept of the relation of history to genre (or forms) appears in an analogy of literary production to landscape formation. In an 1843 letter to James Freeman Clarke, she discusses the theory of forms and compares the author to a peasant living at the mouth of a constantly changing river. Fuller portrays the river as the stream of history whose force produces constant shifts in boundaries and rich new soil for literature. The writer, like the farmer, sows seeds of inspiration preserved from the literary past into the new soil, or era. With the reformation of the river delta, the farmer must move frequently, but each time finds newly made and enriched soil for his crops. He prospers because “he does not sigh for the forests and cities of the mainland, but uses the peculiar advantages of his own position.” America, she writes, is positioned “in the stress of a great stream of change.” She argues that American writers should emulate the delta farmer, not sighing “for the sacred depths of the slow growing forests” that are “not ours” but resisting the temptation to “stiffen in our innovations” and using language as a “pliant medium [that] should be presented for the ever present spirit, not brittle but plastic” (emphasis hers).21 Searching for literature native to American soil, Fuller praises travel writing such as Willis’s descriptions of American city life, Melville’s novel of travel to the South Pacific, and Kirkland’s tales of the frontier. She reviews many autobiographical texts and asserts their significance as genuine American expression, for in this genre the individual presents a unique self in relation to the historical moment. Fuller also believes that in America the novel has assumed the position of representative national form—a position comparable to the ballad elsewhere. Fuller’s organic metaphors become a way of knowing and of representing processes of culture, of suggesting symbiotic relationships and discussing issues of national identity. Literary criticism and reviewing for Fuller was, as Renée Welleck has described the practice of German romantics, “a strategy of finding the place of a work of art, discovering its proper readers, defining its position in the world
xxviii
Introduction
of poetry.”22 Although Fuller’s modern reputation is that of a radical and exceptional woman, she employed practices of many other periodical book reviewers. Most reviewers were men, according to Nina Baym, but a significant number (perhaps as high as 20 percent) were women, including Sarah J. Hale, Caroline Kirkland, and Ann Stephens.23 Baym’s study demonstrates that book reviewers expressed deference to public judgment as necessary for literary greatness. They presented reviews of works, as Fuller did, for classes of readers based on age, gender, family, and reading goals (for example, pleasure or education) in the early years of the mass market for printed texts. Methods for defining the position of a work of art in the world of literature were the most disputed aspect of reviewing and literary criticism. Critics disagreed about the relative importance of formal literary technique, of biographical influences, of social issues in literature, of nationality, and of a work’s “morality.” Literary critical standards were formal, political, and moral. Although the moral standard became increasingly important, Fuller usually opposed moralistic reviewing and defended writers such as Shelley and Sand against attacks by self-appointed guardians of morality. “Democratic” criticism (examining a work’s political stance in relation to democracy) was important for American literature, but nationalism made critics sympathetic to native genius and reluctant to offend the public by negative criticism. Fuller’s critical practice exemplifies a conviction that aesthetic excellence cannot suffice as the sole criterion by which to evaluate literature. She endeavors to place works within a cultural context, to employ a comparative model, to read texts according to their own imperatives rather than in relation to externally and ahistorically imposed standards, and to see how texts speak to and out of specific traditions and cultures. Fuller reviews a wide range of print and oral performative genres: works of history, fiction, poetry, autobiography, and travel narratives. She searches for the generating impulses of each form and moves away from a hierarchy of genres. Although like Emerson, Fuller envisions American literature led by a bardic poet, she also argues that “poetry is not a superhuman or supernatural gift”; it can be produced by the “humblest minstrels” as well as the “greatest bards.”24 Fuller increasingly seeks “poets of the people” and argues that ballads show “the existence of poetical energy in a nation, as polished court or literary verses never can.”25 Failing to find native ballads, she concludes that the novel takes its place in American culture. Earlier she had written in a journal: “Novels are the ballads of our day. Read them to know the time.”26 While she recognizes and celebrates literary art, she also valorizes popular literature for
Introduction
xxix
“interpreting contemporary minds to each other on a larger scale than actual conversation in words or deeds furnishes.”27 In this essay she argues that popular literature (metaphorically, an oak tree) supports and invigorates literary art (metaphorically mistletoe). She argues that the “common and daily purposes of literature are the most important” and that a healthy popular literature need not be disparaged to exalt literary art. She takes pleasure in introducing readers to little known writers who are valuable as “private companions.” Fuller’s early development into a literary critic consisted of extensive reading and responding in private journals and publishing translations and critical reviews for several periodicals (American Monthly Magazine, Boston Quarterly Review, Western Messenger, and the Dial), in addition to publishing Woman in the Nineteenth Century and Summer on the Lakes in 1843 (1844). Fuller’s early reading provided depth and breadth for her book reviews and criticism. Her extant reading journals (1834 to 1844) provided the basis for comparative readings later, stimulating her growth as a perceptive reader and critic. Through journals she developed critical powers, recorded impressions, and inscribed into memory her thoughts about works of philosophy, poetry, fiction, biography, criticism, and drama. Some private assessments are harsher than her public criticism (as in the case of Longfellow), or more favorable (as in the case of Balzac). Other journal entries attack early Victorian moralists who seek to protect young readers from exposure to worldly experience, such as reading Disraeli’s Vivian Grey. She works out systems for reading and critiques the reading of her contemporaries such as George Ripley.28 She discovers the merits and limits of the comparative method by responding to descriptions of Socrates by Xenophon and Plato and concludes that comparison gives us a “standing point” but that in some cases that point is “behind a wall” because two biographical accounts of the same subject may attend to different aspects of that subject; thus she writes that “the Socrates of Xenophon teaches to act, that of Plato to know and to be.”29 Some journals provide direct background for reviews in the Dial and Tribune, but many more illustrate her extensive reading of American, British, German, French, and Italian literature—often in their original languages. She explores the philosophies of Platonism and contemporary theories such as German romanticism, Simonianism, and utilitarianism. Fuller’s journals also indicate the importance of Coleridge in forming her practice of literary criticism. Reading his works extensively in 1836, she records principles that she practices as critic for the Tribune. Her reading of the romantics is balanced by
xxx
Introduction
her reading of the classical authors, and her early reviews (1836) indicate her consciousness of the critical debate over the alternative merits of the romantic and classical points of view. Her synthesis of these two critical perspectives is the hallmark of her critical approach. Goethe’s importance to Fuller’s literary criticism is evident from Fuller’s journals and her first book, a translation of Eckermann’s Conversations with Goethe (1836), to her later essays. Goethe’s method of reading sympathetically meant to “read a book and let it work upon you, and yield yourself up entirely to its influence, then, and only then, will you arrive at a correct judgment of it.” In Goethe’s essays on literary criticism, he writes that all readers criticize by describing the influence the book has on them. Some of Fuller’s reviews record just this kind of individualized reader response, an extension of her voluminous private reading journals. Another critical principle she favors is that “What is important is to have a soul which loves truth, and receives it wherever it finds it.” A third concept shared with Goethe is that of critic as mediating between cultures, aiding in establishing a world literature: “not that nations shall think alike, but that they shall learn how to understand each other, and, if they do not care to love one another, at least that they will learn to tolerate one another.” In other respects she gradually withdraws from some of Goethe’s strictures. On politics and poetry, he writes “If a poet would work politically, he must give himself up to a party; and so soon as he does that he is lost as a poet; he must bid farewell to his free spirit, his unbiased view, and draw over his ears the cap of bigotry and blind hatred.”30 However, in the politically charged New York culture, Fuller began to see the possibilities for combining literary and political action. Fuller’s nineteenth-century reputation as a critic was based primarily upon her praxis, an integration of theory with practice. As critic and editor of the Dial from 1840 to 1842, Fuller developed a theory of literary criticism based on three approaches to criticism (subjective, apprehensive, comprehensive) and a division of literary works according to the degree of their temporality.31 She proposed adapting one’s critical approach to each work so that standards of excellence differed for works of contemporary social protest and works that aimed to achieve distinction as literary art. In her work for the Dial Fuller generally preferred the “comprehensive” approach that combines understanding for the writer’s aim and method with evaluating and placing a work in relation to literary or social culture. Ideal beauty was a standard used frequently in the Transcendental Dial but less often in the Tribune. Fuller’s Dial criticism included lengthy scholarly essays appropriate for the quarterly peri-
Introduction
xxxi
odicals but less useful for the Tribune. In the Dial she undertook little social criticism, focusing rather on aesthetic issues until her groundbreaking essay, “The Great Lawsuit,” on woman’s position in 1843; but in the Tribune her political and social criticism frequently appeared. At the Tribune Fuller applied and extended her theory of criticism; she expressed increased faith in the potential for literary production by the people, and she relied more on criticism designed to nurture a diverse American literature by adapting her criteria to the work’s perceived aim or function (apprehensive criticism). The convention of authorial prefaces encouraged critics to consider the author’s announced aims. Fuller responded regularly to such prefaces, finding in them grounds for critique when the author seems (as Poe does) to be deliberately insincere or (as Kirkland does) to be playing lip service to conventional femininity. Fuller’s reputation as a critic, recognized formally with the publication of Papers in Literature and Art (1846), had begun with reviews of her translation of Goethe. Her creative and critical writing for the Dial (1840–1844) was reviewed in periodicals such as the New Yorker, the Knickerbocker, Godey’s, and the New York Tribune, where she enhanced her reputation as a literary and social critic. Her major works, Summer on the Lakes, in 1843 (1844), and Woman in the Nineteenth Century (1845) were widely reviewed in American periodicals as well as in some British periodicals. With its progressive arguments for women’s rights, Woman sold well and contributed to the perceptions that Fuller was a radical cultural critic. Stimulated by the hope of publishing a collection of her best essays, Fuller sent a proposal in early 1846 to Evert A. Duyckinck, the advisory editor for Wiley & Putnam’s Library of American Books, writing that, “Among the earlier pieces there is not one that has not excited a good deal of interest in this country and many of them have in England. I judge of this from the correspondence and acquaintance they have brought me.”32 Wiley and Putnam agreed to publish a collection of her essays, but the resulting volumes differed greatly from Fuller’s proposal. She was asked to omit controversial or lengthy essays, and her proposed collection was cut in half for publication, obscuring her political critique and the range of her work as a critic. Focused on literary criticism of British and American literature, Papers received wide critical attention and sold well, with three printings by 1852. Though the book was highly praised by some reviewers, her analysis of American literature incited negative reactions, including satirical sketches by Poe and James Russell Lowell. One of its essays, “American Literature,” synthesized many ideas expressed
xxxii
Introduction
in the Tribune and courageously evaluated the merits of individual writers. Contemporary periodical reviews praised her criticism for its independence, balance, and high aesthetic standards. Fuller’s Preface to Papers alludes to the omission of “more than half the essays I had proposed on the subject of English literature, the greater part of those on Art, and those on continental literature and of a miscellaneous kind entirely.” Among essays omitted from her initial plan, for example, were literary review essays on Goethe, French novelists, and Italian poets, and cultural essays on “The Ideal Rich Man,” “The Ideal Poor Man,” and “Politeness.” Her preface indicates that if she had been advised earlier of the volume’s length restrictions she would have chosen differently to “do more justice to the range and variety of subjects which have been before my mind during the ten years that . . . I have written for the public.”33 Noting that the selection presented in Papers included some of her earliest and crudest as well as some of her latest essays, she expresses hope that at a future date a more complete selection will be published. After the publication of Papers Fuller continued to feel that her design for the book had been ignored at the cost of her literary and political reputation. From London Fuller wrote to Duyckinck that It is a real misfortune to me that Mr. Wiley took the course he did about my miscellanies; the vols [sic] have been kindly recd [sic] but every one mentions their being thin; the arrangement, too, that obliged me to leave out all I had written on Continental lite[rature] was very unfortunate for me. I have reason to feel daily how much use it would have been to me if these essays and others of a radical stamp were now before the readers and that a false impression has been given here of the range and scope of my efforts.34
For the remainder of the nineteenth century, editors of Fuller’s works continued to minimize her criticism of continental literature and her radical political critique. Fuller’s Tribune essays are distinctive in many respects, while maintaining continuity with her earlier and later works. Their unique nature arises from the new location, audience, and media. In the Tribune she writes for multilayered New York and national audiences rather than a highly educated literati. Fuller, like Greeley, was persuaded that the newspaper could be a powerful force for democracy by educating the people and making opportunities available to all. Her style develops increased directness and power in some columns but retains her characteristic dialogic structure and occasionally complex syntax. Her reviews blur the lines of public and private discourse; some columns,
Introduction
xxxiii
for example, seem to be letters to the many friends with whom she no longer keeps in regular contact. To her brother she writes that she has embarked on a new and noble career, a public career as distinguished from her earlier role of private friend, and that in her new role she will be communicating with everyone in print.35 Part of the significance of these columns is that they are her primary form of expression for 1845 to 1846. Hints of her personal life appear infrequently: her friendships with Lydia Maria Child and William Henry Channing, her admiration for Greeley, her brief romance with James Nathan, and her involvement with Harro Harring’s lawsuit. Despite her perception that she addresses her friends, her essays rarely assume the private tone of writing for an imaginary individual friend—such as Child assumes in her Letters from New York; rather, they typically address New York, Europe, and America in a public voice, often aiming to educate readers about new or foreign works or to engage in cultural criticism. At the Tribune Fuller explored the full range of the essay as a genre: the character sketch, parable, prose epistle, journalistic essay, periodical essay, hortatory essay, and book review. Stylistically diverse and wide-ranging in topic, Fuller’s literary reviews take three forms common to the professional practice of her day: the literary critique combined with a sociopolitical essay; the aesthetic discussion focusing on features of the text and the author; and the brief notice, with a short evaluative description of a work. These three types correspond to functions Fuller believed were served by literary critics: the discussion of important issues about which contemporary authors were concerned; the use of aesthetic judgment and the cultivation of standards for measuring excellence; and the encouragement of literary production by bringing books to the public notice.36 While her feminist critical essays are relatively well known, the less familiar Tribune essays illuminate Fuller’s critique of American imperialism and exhibit her skill in multiple modes of criticism. The titles or announced subjects of Fuller’s review essays often are only the starting point for discussion of broader ideas, as illustrated by the review of Italian writers Alfieri, Cellini, and Dante in “Italy”;37 its central concern is not Italian literature but the state of American society. According to a contemporary reviewer, Fuller’s reviews created “a broad common ground on which all cultivated readers might meet” and expressed “an eager reverence for truth.”38 Fuller’s Tribune columns also make lively reading today because of her flexibility of tone and control of language. While she can be earnest and serious, she also exercises her wit and keen sense of humor. Directly addressing readers and authors, Fuller creates dialogues and
xxxiv
Introduction
encourages responses. She engages directly in spirited debates with writers such as Thomas Carlyle but shifts to indirect critique of Whig political figures such as Waddy Thompson. Dialogues are also created through excerpts from reviewed works, followed by Fuller’s responses. Liveliness and humor are achieved with shifts between formal and colloquial language, as when she describes Leigh Hunt’s writing about Dante, first in formal terms then as “the fly buzzing the lion and blaming him for eating up the great ‘wild Beastesses’ and other atrocities of which his flyship has no taste as not being in his line.”39 To a remarkable extent she adopts the imagery or tone of the writers she is reviewing and occasionally parodies them. Narratives of reading individualize these reviews as she engages in what was termed “subjective criticism.” With intimate tone and elaborate detail she recalls early readings with friends in the woods or her first reading of Shelley (as a fireside enchantment at Christmas). Reviews such as these, differing from her earnest or jeremiadic essays, ultimately create a very human Fuller whose delight in literature originates in a sense of play and pleasure, manifested earlier as collections of meaningful passages copied into journals or recited among groups of readers. These autobiographical moments resemble letters and recall the foundations of her mature critical engagement with literary discourse. Fuller’s characteristic use of numerous extracts from the books she is reviewing illustrates many of her critical principles. Lengthy quotations, she explains, acquaint readers with books too expensive to buy, especially foreign books or philosophical or historical works. In this manner she accommodates class differences in access to literary works. Providing samples of the writer’s style or treatment of a subject, Fuller also demonstrates her desire to encourage readers who are independent and discriminating and allows them to comprehend her judgments. Extracts create the multivocality that is characteristic of Fuller’s style; many reviews become mosaics of quotations or intertextual dialogues. Her multivocal political essays create space for the voices of the other, such as the Mexican, the Indian, or the political exile. She might use, for example, the full speech of a Choctaw Chief from treaty negotiations or the words of Mexican leader Santa Anna. Fuller employs these textual designs along with metaphor and logical analysis to critique stereotypical representations and subvert popular ideologies. Her framing remarks might borrow images or phrases taken from the original work and depend upon the presence of the extract for appropriate interpretations. Fuller also makes strategic use of excerpts to juxtapose popular perceptions with the gritty facts of actual behavior—a “legitimate style of aggression” particularly notable in moments of
Introduction
xxxv
social satire.40 In some cases excerpts allow Fuller to draw authority from others’ personal experience in order to argue implicitly for the same position herself. Fuller’s practice as a feminist writer and critic increased the cultural authority and literary possibilities of other American women through thoughtful reviews, reliance on their works as resources, and recognition for their achievements. In reviews of American women writers Fuller challenges nineteenth-century notions of gender and genre. In “Books of Travel” she reviews six narratives by men and argues that the best travel books in their “observation of particulars and lively expression” are written by women.41 Whereas Poe and others assert that women are suited to the genre of poetry, Fuller argues that women should not be limited to the role of “poetess” but can author diverse genres. Although Fuller does not attribute sentimental poetry entirely to women writers, she considers the tendency of women to write in that style an all-too-frequent problem. Fuller’s critique of sentimental poetry in her review of Elizabeth Barrett’s work has specific reference to conventional elegiac lyrics; she admires Barrett for replacing sentimentalism with “personal feeling . . . enlightened by Reason, [and] ennobled by Imagination.” These reviews indicate her appreciation of the expression of authentic emotion but her skepticism of poetry “adorned by the flowers of feeling.”42 Fuller’s literary criticism does not grant women poets gender exemption from negative criticism; rather, she speaks in the “spirit of truth.” Fuller seeks to nurture American writers—including women—intellectually and to educate American readers in order to achieve “the ripening of a new and golden harvest” for which she feels she will not be present.43 Her critical strategies are designed to encourage women writers and to engender a rich, culturally responsive American literature. The Tribune essays illustrate not only Fuller’s “love of truth and the power to speak it” (as Emerson described it) but also her important contribution to the acceptance of women as critics of literature and society.44 Contemporary critical practices evident in her reviews include searching for women writers of talent, classifying and ranking writers in relation to other writers, and considering the personality and life of writers in conjunction with their works. Women writers were entering the profession in ever increasing numbers, challenging notions of authorship, gender, and genre. Some Fuller reviews participate in an ongoing debate over women’s potential for literary art and the appropriate subjects and manner for women’s literary expression. Fuller’s reviews show that the nineteenth century encouraged “a sense of tra-
xxxvi
Introduction
dition . . . among women based on their membership in a separate sexual caste” not along the nationalistic lines advocated by male writers of the period.45 Further study comparing Fuller’s work to that of other women reviewers will be useful in establishing the range of approaches to criticism of women’s literature by women in the nineteenth century. While America redefined itself in terms of utilitarianism, imperialism, and industrialism, Fuller redefined herself as a woman reformer, an egalitarian, socially conscious citizen with an inclusive definition of citizenship. Responding to literature and the social problems of the 1840s, she gained the power of self-expression and chose positions that made her an articulate critic of American and European culture. This selection of Fuller’s Tribune essays, focusing on her criticism of literature and culture, seeks to bring together a representative group of her essays with emphasis on previously uncollected and out-of-print materials. However, some reflective essays are included to present her exploration of the essay as a genre. Minimal representation has been accorded to her investigative reporting, much of which has already been reprinted. The essays have been selected both for their individual merit as works of criticism (length and complexity of thought) and with attention to the subjects of the reviews. Fuller reviewed a wide range of texts in the print culture of her day including belles lettres, popular literature, gift books, history, biography, travel writing, textbooks, pamphlets, public reports, and periodicals. This extraordinary breadth offers students and scholars a unique opportunity to understand the interrelationship of diverse types of texts at a specific historical moment. The arrangement of these essays is chronological with a second, topical table of contents provided for flexible use in the classroom. The chronological order will be useful for readers studying Fuller’s development as a writer. The topical organization, though it is limited by Fuller’s practice of integrating social and literary criticism in most of her essays, is provided to facilitate comparisons with her contemporaries’ writing on major issues of the era. The topics listed here are broad categories only; as the subject index suggests, additonal topics and themes will emerge through close examination of the essays. The essays in this volume are complemented by the complete set of Fuller’s Tribune essays, as well as “American Literature,” available in a searchable electronic format that provides access to all of the essays and their accompanying notes. The selection in this book aims to represent most of the genres Fuller reviewed. While her reviews recognize national literatures, they also include
Introduction
xxxvii
works by differing national writers. Because of her significance as a literary critic, major emphasis is given to Fuller’s reviews of American and British works. Her efforts to encourage international intellectual and cultural dialogue are presented through her reviews of European literature. Additional reviews of foreign–language periodicals and Fuller’s translations may be found on the CD-ROM edition. Fuller’s sociopolitical criticism in occasional essays and reviews addresses such issues as the national condition and policies, race, gender, class, progress, and technology; selected criticism of the fine arts is included to indicate her approach to fine arts and performances. Fuller’s extensive quotations from the texts under review have been selectively cut where excerpts are largely appended as examples and do not support the argument of the review; they are retained when feasible where they constitute her efforts to give voice to groups or individuals who challenged dominant ideologies. These essays may be read from many perspectives. They may be read in dialogue with other early critics such as Poe, allowing for a reassessment of their critical practice or read in relation to the history of women’s literature. They allow readers to examine Fuller’s evolving literary and political positions toward issues such as nationality in literature. Those positions continued to develop in her expatriate years when she recast the relation of American art in general to the use of American subjects in art. Bridging the gap in modern publication between Woman and the European dispatches, these essays allow readers to understand the full range of Fuller’s work, her reception and reputation as a critic. Notes 1. For a recent biographical study of Fuller in New York, see Joan Voh Mehren, Minerva and the Muse (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1994). On Fuller’s earlier life, see Charles Capper, Margaret Fuller: An American Romantic Life—The Private Years (New York: Oxford UP, 1992). 2. Margaret Fuller, “Thanksgiving,” New York Daily Tribune (NYDT hereafter) 12 December 1844. 3. Scholars debating this issue include Christina Zwarg, Feminist Conversations: Fuller, Emerson and the Play of Reading (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 1995); Bell Gale Chevigny, “Foreword to the Revised Edition,” in The Woman and the Myth: Margaret Fuller’s Life and Writings (Boston: Northeastern University Press, 1994), and Julie Ellison, Delicate Subjects: Romanticism, Gender, and the Ethics of Understanding (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 1990). 4. See Fuller, rev. of Carlyle’s Cromwell, NYDT 19 Dec. 1845. 5. Fuller, “American Literature: Its Position in the Present Time and Prospects for the Future,” in Papers on Literature and Art (New York: Wiley & Putnam, 1846), 2:140.
xxxviii
Introduction
6. Fuller, rev. of Courrier des Etats Unis, NYDT 7 June 1845. 7. Thomas Bender, New York Intellect: A History of Intellectual Life in New York City, from 1750 to the Beginnings of Our Own Time (New York: Knopf, 1987), 156. 8. Edward Pessen, “The Egalitarian Myth and the American Social Reality: Wealth, Mobility, and Equality in the ‘Era of the Common Man,’ ” American Historical Review 76 (October 1971): 989–1034. See pp. 1022–23 for statistics. 9. Edward K. Spann The New Metropolis: New York City, 1840–1857 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1981), 70, 262. 10. Fuller, rev. of Le Franco-Americain, NYDT 23 May 1846. 11. On Edward Everett’s 1830 “Lecture on the Working Men’s Party,” see Nicholas K. Bromell, By the Sweat of the Brow: Literature and Labor in Antebellum America (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1993), 24. 12. Fuller, “Italy,” NYDT 13 November 1845. 13. Fuller, rev. of A System of Latin Versification, NYDT 12 May 1845. 14. For responses of Poe and Whitman, see Joel Myerson, Margaret Fuller: An Annotated Secondary Bibliography (New York: B. Franklin, 1977); Myerson, “Supplement to Margaret Fuller: An Annotated Secondary Bibliography,” Studies in the American Renaissance 1984, ed. Myerson (Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1984), 331–85; Myerson, Margaret Fuller: An Annotated Bibliography of Criticism, 1983–1995 (Westport, Conn.: Greenwood, 1998). Some contemporary responses to Fuller’s essays have been reprinted in Myerson, Critical Essays on Margaret Fuller, (Boston: Hall, 1980). 15. [William A. Jones], “Poetry for the People,” Democratic Review 13 (1843): 268. 16. Fuller, rev. of Prose and Verse by Thomas Hood, NYDT 9 August 1845; “Publishers and Authors,” NYDT 3 February 1846. 17. “The Magnetic Telegraph—Its Success,” NYDT 27 May 1844, p. 1. Several subsequent stories refer to the “miracle of the annihilation of space” and record the extension service in the region north of Washington to New York and Boston. When hostilities with Mexico began in May 1846, the Tribune prefaced news with headlines: “BY ELECTRIC TELEGRAPH,” indicating that the telegraph had been extended to New York. 18. “Life in Paris,” NYDT 16 August 1844, p. 1. 19. One of her earliest reviews as a critic had been a review of German literature (in American Monthly July 1836). Heinrich Heine in “The Romantic School” had described the theory of organic forms or genres in relation to literary history: “beginning with the primitive human emotions, following them as they developed in the various epochs and finally assumed artistic form. . . . In the hearts of a nation’s writers there already lies the image of its future.” See Heinrich Heine: Selected Works, trans. and ed. Helen M. Mustard (New York: Random House, 1973), 239–40. 20. Paul Youngquist, “Romanticism, Criticism, and Organicity,” Genre 27 (1994): 183– 208. Youngquist demonstrates the continuity of the metaphor of organicity through nineteenth- and twentieth-century criticism. He concludes that “however dead it may appear, the organic metaphor lives on in contemporary criticism . . . as a representational strategy” (204), whether in positive terms or negative.
Introduction
xxxix
21. Fuller, The Letters of Margaret Fuller (Letters hereafter), ed. Robert N. Hudspeth, 6 vols., (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1983–94), 6:342. 22. Renée Welleck, A History of Modern Criticism: 1750–1950—The Romantic Age (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1965), 2:87. 23. Nina Baym, Novels, Readers, and Reviewers: Responses to Fiction in Antebellum America (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 1984), 21. 24. Fuller, rev. of Poems by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, NYDT 10 December 1845. 25. Fuller, rev. of The Nubian Slave by Bela Marsh, NYDT 24 June 1845. 26. Fuller, quoted by permission, “1840 Journal,” Margaret Fuller Papers, Ms. Am. 1086 (3), Houghton Library, Harvard College. She makes the same point in a review of Ellen by Schoolcraft Jones, NYDT 10 Jan. 1846. 27. Fuller, “English Writers Little Known Here. Milnes . . . Landor . . . and Julius Hare,” NYDT 4 March 1845, p. 1. 28. Apparently quoting from her reading, Fuller supports, “The overcoming of deriving your whole pleasure passively from the book itself which can only be effected by excitement of curiosity or some passion. Force yourself to reflect on what you read paragraph by paragraph and in a short time you will derive your pleasure, or an ample portion of it, at least, from the activity of your own mind. All the rest is picture sunshine.” Quoted by permission, “S. M. Fuller’s Bouquet,” Margaret Fuller Papers, Ms. Am. 1086, Houghton Library, Harvard College. 29. Fuller, quoted by permission, “Journal D,” Margaret Fuller Papers, Ms. Am. 1086, Houghton Library, Harvard College. 30. Johann Wolfgang Goethe, Goethe’s Literary Essays, ed. J. E. Spingarn (New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1921), 141, 256, 92, 253 [“judgement of it,” 141; “it finds it,” 256; “tolerate one another,” 92; “blind hatred,” 252]. 31. Fuller, “A Short Essay on Critics,” Dial 1 (July 1840): 134. 32. Fuller to Evert Duyckinck, 5 February 1846, Letters 4:184–85. 33. Fuller, “Preface,” in Papers, v, vi. 34. Fuller to Evert Duyckinck, 30 October 1846, Letters 4:234–35. 35. Fuller to Richard Fuller, 2 March 1845, Letters 4:184. Her shift toward public use of personal experience was protested by Caroline Sturgis who detected a veiled reference to herself; Fuller defended her use and the role of public woman. See Fuller to Sturgis, 13 March 1845, Letters 4:59–60. 36. Fuller’s book reviews include discussion of moral, social, and political principles; biography, history, and plot summaries; and excerpts and assessments of merits and blemishes. Critics such as Poe and those of Blackwood’s extended formalistic analysis into “Tomahawk criticism.” Quarterlies such as the Democratic Review used books as starting points for discussing issues they raised; the North American Review presented lengthy essays surveying a field or group of authors; and many journals offered superficial appreciative essays. 37. NYDT 13 November 1845, p. 1. 38. “Miss Fuller’s Papers on Literature and Art,” United States Magazine and Democratic Review 19 (Sept. 1846): 198; repr. in Myerson, Critical Essays, 40. 39. Fuller, rev. of Leigh Hunt’s Italian Poets, NYDT 18 February 1846. 40. Ellison has also asserted that “Quotation and allusion constitute the mature public
xl
Introduction
style of the heterogeneous subject” of Fuller’s letters and Woman and that “The tactics of quotation both accentuate cultural differences and create a feeling of sameness—as diversity is blurred by the identical textual status of discursive bits” (Delicate Subjects, 282–83). 41. The proportion of travel books by women was relatively small (35 of 691 published in America between 1800 and 1868). Mary Suzanne Schriber, “Julia Ward Howe and the Travel Book,” New England Quarterly 62 (1989): 269. 42. Fuller, “Miss Barrett’s Poems,” NYDT 4 January 1845. 43. Fuller, “American Literature,” Papers 2:125. 44. R. W. Emerson, Memoirs of Margaret Fuller Ossoli, ed. R. W. Emerson, W. H. Channing, and J. F. Clarke (Boston: Phillips, Sampson, 1852), 1:303. 45. Cheryl Walker, The Nightingale’s Burden: Women Poets and American Culture before 1900 (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1982), 23, 26.
Textual Note
This edition of Margaret Fuller’s writings in the New-York Tribune prints annotated texts for 88 of the 250 pieces she published in the New-York Tribune between 7 December 1844 and 8 August 1846.1 All 250 pieces are included in the electronic edition. Of these, only 38 (or about 15 percent) have been reprinted in twentieth-century editions. The other 212 texts are in a hard-tolocate and hard-to-read newspaper. We hope that our edition will assist new scholarship on Fuller by presenting for the first time in a modern edition the nearly two years of her creative output in the Tribune. After her death, Fuller’s writings were collected by her brother Arthur (with occasional help from Horace Greeley) as Woman in the Nineteenth Century, and Kindred Papers (1855), At Home and Abroad (1856), and Life Without and Life Within (1860). Unfortunately, he chose very selectively from the materials available, “improved” his sister’s writing by revising what he thought ungraceful style, and deleted what he considered irrelevant (or “inappropriate”) examples and passages. Our edition presents Fuller’s texts as she wrote them for publication in the New-York Tribune. These texts, written under the pressure of deadlines and set by compositors who may not have always been able to read Fuller’s handwriting, and for a medium that does not encourage leisurely proofreading, are nevertheless surprisingly free of error. Our textual policy is simple: we print the texts as they appeared in the Tribune. Emendations have been made in cases of obvious typographical errors or misspellings, or when clarity of thought is disturbed. All emendations are reported by placing a superscript “n” in the text immediately following the word emended (as in “wordn”), with a description of the original reading provided in the footnotes. No attempt has been made to regularize Fuller’s spelling and punctuation practices, or to modernize archaic spellings. The text is as close to Fuller’s intentions as is possible. Some typographical features, such as the use of large and small capitals in the first word(s) of an article have been changed to regular upper- and lowercase letxli
xlii
Textual Note
ters; however, we have retained large and small capitals appearing within an article because they may represent an effort at emphasis. We have not attempted to standardize accent marks in non-English words. Most of Fuller’s book reviews begin with some publication information for the work under consideration; we have moved this to the notes, where a complete bibliographical citation is provided to the edition Fuller used. We follow the Tribune’s erratic practice of placing material quoted from the texts under review in either text-size type or extract-size type. Notes by Fuller are included in our notes, labeled as such. We have placed in brackets any titles we have supplied for essays or reviews. Fuller’s writings in the Tribune begin with a paragraph indent; here, for stylistic reasons, we begin the first paragraph flush left. Also for stylistic reasons, the general layout of Fuller’s articles in this volume differs slightly from how they originally appeared in the Tribune. Like most mid-nineteenth-century book reviewers writing in an age when books were relatively quite expensive, Fuller was usually generous in quoting from the texts under review. As scholars have recently discovered, her decisions about which portions of the texts to include and which to omit often constitute as strong a critical statement as do her own words.2 For this reason, and because so many of the works Fuller reviews are now hard to locate, we have printed the extracts unless the works of the writer are easily available in modern editions (such as those by Robert Browning or Frederick Douglass). Our annotations provide complete bibliographical information for the book(s) under review, and information about the sources of texts that Fuller quotes, people or books she mentions, and other information that helps place the work within its historical context. For critical studies of Fuller’s works or the people she wrote about and/or knew, readers are invited to consult the bibliographies by Joel Myerson.3 Notes 1. To the items listed in Joel Myerson, Margaret Fuller: A Descriptive Bibliography (Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1978), 113–38, we have identified and added a review of Harro Harring’s Dolores: A Novel of South America, published in the New-York Daily Tribune, 25 April 1846. Also, because of its importance, we have printed in an appendix of the electronic edition Fuller’s “American Literature; Its Position in the Present Time, and Prospects for the Future” from her Papers on Literature and Art (1846). Because Fuller nearly always signed her pieces with a star or asterisk (“*”), we have been reluctant to add unsigned essays in the Tribune to her list of writings solely on the basis of shared similarities in style and subject matter. The review of Harring’s Dolores is the sole exception. In our work, we have identified as “possibly” by Fuller a translation from the Deutsche Schnellpost on 29 March 1845; a review of Poems by “Amelia” on 18 April 1845; translations from George
Textual Note
xliii
Sand on 24 April 1845 and from Madame de Stäel on 13 May 1845; items of foreign gossip on 8 August and on 23 August 1845; and brief comments on and extracts from advance sheets of Charles Burdett’s Wrongs of American Women on 10 September 1845. Information about the reprintings of individual Tribune essays may be found in Myerson’s bibliography (above) or his “Supplement to Margaret Fuller: A Descriptive Bibliography,” in Studies in the American Renaissance 1996, ed. Myerson (Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1996), 187–240. 2. See, for example, Stephen Mailloux, “Misreading as a Historical Act: Cultural Rhetoric, Bible Politics, and Fuller’s 1845 Review of Douglass’s Narrative,” in Readers in History: Nineteenth-Century American Literature and the Contexts of Response, ed. James L. Machor (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1993), 3–31. 3. See Myerson, Margaret Fuller: An Annotated Secondary Bibliography (New York: B. Franklin, 1977); “Supplement to Margaret Fuller: An Annotated Secondary Bibliography,” in Studies in the American Renaissance 1984, ed. Myerson (Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1984), 331–85; and Margaret Fuller: An Annotated Bibliography of Criticism, 1983–1995 (Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1998).
This page intentionally left blank
Margaret Fuller, Critic
This page intentionally left blank
Emerson’s Essays
At the distance of three years this volume follows the first series of Essays, which have already made to themselves a circle of readers, attentive, thoughtful, more and more intelligent, and this circle is a large one if we consider the circumstances of this country, and of England, also, at this time.1 In England it would seem there are a larger number of persons waiting for an invitation to calm thought and sincere intercourse than among ourselves. Copies of Mr. Emerson’s first published little volume called “Nature,” have there been sold by thousands in a short time, while one edition has needed seven years to get circulated here. Several of his Orations and Essays from “The Dial” have also been republished there, and met with a reverent and earnest response.2 We suppose that while in England the want of such a voice is as great as here, a larger number are at leisure to recognize that want; a far larger number have set foot in the speculative region and have ears refined to appreciate these melodious accents. Our people, heated by a partisan spirit, necessarilyn occupied in these first stages by bringing out the material resources of the land, not generally prepared by early training for the enjoyment of books that require attention and reflection, are still more injured by a large majority of writers and speakers, who lend all their efforts to flatter corrupt tastes and mental indolence, 1. Essays: First Series had been published on 20 March 1841. Fuller comments on the present review in a letter to Emerson: “Your book I have read quite through . . . but will not mar the effect by a few inadequate words. It will be a companion through my life. In expression it seems far more adequate than the former volume, has more glow, more fusion. Two or three cavils I should make at present, but will not, till I have examined further if they be correct” (Letters, 3:243). 2. Perhaps fifteen hundred copies of Nature sold between 1836, when it was published, and 1844; there was no British edition. Both Man the Reformer (1842) and The Young American (1844) were reprinted separately in England from the Dial, and other Dial essays were included with addresses in Nature; an Essay. And Lectures on the Times (1844) and Orations, Lectures, and Addresses (1844) for British publication. necesarily [ necessarily
1
2
“Emerson’s Essays”
instead of feeling it their prerogative and their duty to admonish the community of the danger and arouse it to nobler energy. The aim of the writer or lecturer is not to say the best he knows in as few and well-chosen words as he can, making it his first aim to do justice to the subject. Rather he seeks to beat out a thought as thin as possible, and to consider what the audience will be most willing to receive. The result of such a course is inevitable. Literature and Art must become daily more degraded; Philosophy cannot exist. A man who feels within his mind some spark of genius, or a capacity for the exercises of talent, should consider himself as endowed with a sacred commission. He is the natural priest, the shepherd of the people. He must raise his mind as high as he can toward the heaven of truth, and try to draw up with him those less gifted by nature with ethereal lightness. If he does not so, but rather employs his powers to flatter them in their poverty, and to hinder aspiration by useless words, and a mere seeming of activity, his sin is great, he is false to God, and false to man. Much of this sin indeed is done ignorantly. The idea that literature calls men to the genuine hierarchy is almost forgotten. One, who finds himself able, uses his pen, as he might a trowel, solely to procure himself bread, without having reflected on the position in which he thereby places himself. Apart from the troop of mercenaries, there is one, still larger, of those who use their powers merely for local and temporary ends, aiming at no excellence other than may conduce to these. Among these, rank persons of honor and the best intentions, but they neglect the lasting for the transient, as a man neglects to furnish his mind that he may provide the better for the house in which his body is to dwell for a few years. When these sins and errors are prevalent, and threaten to become more so, how can we sufficiently prize and honor a mind which is quite pure from such? When, as in the present case, we find a man whose only aim is the discernment and interpretation of the spiritual laws by which we live and move and have our being, all whose objects are permanent, and whose every word stands for a fact. If only as a representative of the claims of individual culture in a nation which tends to lay such stress on artificial organization and external results, Mr. Emerson would be invaluable here. History will inscribe his name as a father of the county, for he is one who pleads her cause against herself. If New-England may be regarded as a chief mental focus to the New World, and many symptoms seem to give her this place, as to other centres the characteristics of heart and lungs to the body politic; if we may believe, as the
“Emerson’s Essays”
3
writer does believe, that what is to be acted out in the country at large is, most frequently, first indicated there, as all the phenomena of the nervous system in the fantasies of the brain, we may hail as an auspicious omen the influence Mr. Emerson has there obtained, which is deep-rooted, increasing, and, over the younger portion of the community, far greater than that of any other person. His books are received there with a more ready intelligence than elsewhere, partly because his range of personal experience and illustration applies to that region, partly because he has prepared the way for his books to be read by his great powers as a speaker. The audience that waited for years upon the lectures, a part of which is incorporated into these volumes of Essays, was never large, but it was select, and it was constant. Among the hearers were some, who though, attracted by the beauty of character and manner, they were willing to hear the speaker through, always went away discontented. They were accustomed to an artificial method, whose scaffolding could easily be retraced, and desired an obvious sequence of logical inferences. They insisted there was nothing in what they had heard, because they could not give a clear account of its course and purport. They did not see that Pindar’s odes might be very well arranged for their own purpose, and yet not bear translating into the methods of Mr. Locke.3 Others were content to be benefited by a good influence without a strict analysis of its means. “My wife says it is about the elevation of human nature, and so it seems to me,” was a fit reply to some of the critics. Many were satisfied to find themselves excited to congenial thought and nobler life, without an exact catalogue of the thoughts of the speaker. Those who believed no truth could exist, unless encased by the burrs of opinion, went away utterly baffled. Sometimes they thought he was on their side, then presently would come something on the other. He really seemed to believe there were two sides to every subject, and even to intimate higher ground from which each might be seen to have an infinite number of sides or bearings, an impertinence not to be endured! The partisan heard but once and returned no more. But some there were, simple souls, whose life had been, perhaps, without clear light, yet still a search after truth for its own sake, who were able to receive what followed on the suggestion of a subject in a natural manner, as a 3. Pindar (ca. 522–443 b.c.), the greatest of the Greek lyric poets; John Locke (1632–1704), English philosopher and founder of the sensationalist school.
4
“Emerson’s Essays”
stream of thought. These recognized, beneath the veil of words, the still small voice of conscience, the vestal fires of lone religious hours, and the mild teachings of the summer woods. The charm of the elocution, too, was great. His general manner was that of the reader, occasionally rising into direct address or invocation in passages where tenderness or majesty demanded more energy. At such times both eye and voice called on a remote future to give a worthy reply. A future which shall manifest more largely the universal soul as it was then manifest to this soul. The tone of the voice was a grave body tone, full and sweet rather than sonorous, yet flexible and haunted by many modulations, as even instruments of wood and brass seem to become after they have been long played on with skill and taste; how much more so the human voice! In the more expressive passages it uttered notes of silvery clearness, winning, yet still more commanding. The words uttered in those tones, floated awhile above us, then took root in the memory like winged seed. In the union of an even rustic plainness with lyric inspirations, religious dignity with philosophic calmness, keen sagacity in details with boldness of view, we saw what brought to mind the early poets and legislators of Greece— men who taught their fellows to plow and avoid moral evil, sing hymns to the gods and watch the metamorphoses of nature. Here in civic Boston was such a man—one who could see man in his original grandeur and his original childishness, rooted in simple nature, raising to the heavens the brow and eyes of a poet. And these lectures seemed not so much lectures as grave didactic poems, theogonies, perhaps, adorned by odes when some Power was in question whom the poet had best learned to serve, and with eclogues wisely portraying in familiar tongue the duties of man to man and “harmless animals.” Such was the attitude in which the speaker appeared to that portion of the audience who have remained permanently attached to him.—They value his words as the signets of reality; receive his influence as a help and incentive to a nobler discipline than the age, in its general aspect, appears to require; and do not fear to anticipate the verdict of posterity in claiming for him the honors of greatness, and, in some respects, of a Master. In New-England he thus formed for himself a class of readers, who rejoice to study in his books what they already know by heart. For, though the thought has become familiar, its beautiful garb is always fresh and bright in hue. A similar circle of like-minded the books must and do form for themselves,
“Emerson’s Essays”
5
though with a movement less directly powerful, as more distant from its source. The Essays have also been obnoxious to many charges. To that of obscurity, or want of perfect articulation. Of ‘Euphuism,’ as an excess of fancy in proportion to imagination, and an inclination, at times, to subtlety at the expense of strength, has been styled. The human heart complains of inadequacy, either in the nature or experience of the writer, to represent its full vocation and its deeper needs. Sometimes it speaks of this want as “under-development” or a want of expansion which may yet be remedied; sometimes doubts whether “in this mansion there be either hall or portal to receive the loftier of the Passions.” Sometimes the soul is deified at the expense of nature, then again nature at that of man, and we are not quite sure that we can make a true harmony by balance of the statements.—This writer has never written one good work, if such a work be one where the whole commands more attention than the parts. If such an one be produced only where, after an accumulation of materials, fire enough be applied to fuse the whole into one new substance. This second series is superior in this respect to the former, yet in no one essay is the main stress so obvious as to produce on the mind the harmonious effect of a noble river or a tree in full leaf. Single passages and sentences engage our attention too much in proportion. These essays, it has been justly said, tire like a string of mosaics or a house built of medals. We miss what we expect in the work of the great poet, or the great philosopher, the liberal air of all the zones: the glow, uniform yet various in tint, which is given to a body by free circulation of the heart’s blood from the hour of birth. Here is, undoubtedly, the man of ideas, but we want the ideal man also; want the heart and genius of human life to interpret it, and here our satisfaction is not so perfect. We doubt this friend raised himself too early to the perpendicular and did not lie along the ground long enough to hear the secret whispers of our parent life. We could wish he might be thrown by conflicts on the lap of mother earth, to see if he would not rise again with added powers. All this we may say, but it cannot excuse us from benefiting by the great gifts that have been given, and assigning them their due place. Some painters paint on a red ground. And this color may be supposed to represent the ground-work most immediately congenial to most men, as it is the color of blood and represents human vitality. The figures traced upon it are instinct with life in its fulness and depth. But other painters paint on a gold ground. And a very different, but no less natural, because also a celestial beauty, is given to their works who choose for
6
“Emerson’s Essays”
their foundation the color of the sunbeam, which nature has preferred for her most precious product, and that which will best bear the test of purification, gold. If another simile may be allowed, another no less apt is at hand. Wine is the most brilliant and intense expression of the powers of earth.—It is her potable fire, her answer to the sun. It exhilarates, it inspires, but then it is liable to fever and intoxicate too the careless partaker. Mead was the chosen drink of the Northern gods. And this essence of the honey of the mountain bee was not thought unworthy to revive the souls of the valiant who had left their bodies on the fields of strife below. Nectar should combine the virtues of the ruby wine, the golden mead, without their defects or dangers. Two high claims our writer can vindicate on the attention of his contemporaries. One from his sincerity. You have his thought just as it found place in the life of his own soul. Thus, however near or relatively distant its approximation to absolute truth, its action on you cannot fail to be healthful. It is a part of the free air. He belongs to that band of whom there may be found a few in every age, and who now in known human history may be counted by hundreds, who worship the one God only, the God of Truth. They worship, not saints, nor creeds, nor churches, nor reliques, nor idols in any form. The mind is kept open to truth, and life only valued as a tendency toward it. This must be illustrated by acts and words of love, purity and intelligence. Such are the salt of the earth; let the minutest crystal of that salt be willingly by us held in solution. The other is through that part of his life, which, if sometimes obstructed or chilled by the critical intellect, is yet the prevalent and the main source of his power. It is that by which he imprisons his hearer only to free him again as a “liberating God” (to use his own words).4 But indeed let us use them altogether, for none other, ancient or modern, can more worthily express how, making present to us the courses and destinies of nature, he invests himself with her serenity and animates us with her joy. “Poetry was all written before time was, and whenever we are so finely organized that we can penetrate into that region where the air is music, we hear those primal warblings, and attempt to write them down, but we lose ever and anon a word, or a verse, and substitute something of our own, and thus 4. Emerson famously uses the phrase “liberating God” to describe “The Poet” in Essays: Second Series.
“Emerson’s Essays”
7
miswrite the poem. The men of more delicate ear write down these cadences more faithfully, and these transcripts, though imperfect, become the songs of the nations.” “As the eyes of Lyncæus were said to see through the earth, so the poet turns the world to glass, and shows us all things in their right series and procession. For, through that better perception, he stands one step nearer to things, and sees the flowing or metamorphosis; perceives that thought is multiform; that within the form of every creature is a force impelling it to ascend into a higher form; and following with his eyes the life, uses the forms which express that life, and so the speech flows with the flowing of nature.” Thus have we in a brief and unworthy manner indicated some views of these books. The only true criticism of these, or any good books, may be gained by making them the companions of our lives. Does every accession of knowledge or a juster sense of beauty maken us prize them more? Then they are good, indeed, and more immortal than mortal. Let that test be applied to these; essays which will lead to great and complete poems—somewhere. Review of Ralph Waldo Emerson, Essays: Second Series (Boston: James Munroe, 1844). New York Daily Tribune, 7 December 1844, p. 1; reprinted, New-York Weekly Tribune, 14 December 1844, p. 2.
makes [ make
Thanksgiving
Canst thou give thanks for aught that has been given Except by making earth more worth heaven? Just stewardship the master hoped from thee; Harvests from Time to bless Eternity.
Thanksgiving is peculiarly the festival day of New-England. Elsewhere, other celebrations rival its attractions, but in that region where the Puritans first returned thanks that some among them had been sustained by a great hope and earnest resolve amid the perils of the ocean, wild beasts and famine, the old spirit which hallowed the day still lingers, and forbids that it should be entirely devoted to play and plum-pudding. And yet, as there is always this tendency; as the twelfth-night cake is baked by many a hostess who would be puzzled if you asked her, “Twelfth night after or before what?” and the Christmas cake by many who know no other Christmas service, so it requires very serious assertion and proof from the minister to convince his parishioners that the turky and plum-pudding, which are presently to occupy his place in their attention, should not be the chief objects of the day. And, in other regions, where the occasion is observed, it is still more as one for a meeting of families and friends to the enjoyment of a good dinner, than for any higher purpose. This, indeed, is one which we want not to depreciate. If this manner of keeping the day be likely to persuade the juniors of the party that the celebrated Jack Horner is the prime model for brave boys, and that grand parents are chiefly to be respected as the givers of grand feasts, yet a meeting in the spirit of kindness, however dull and blind, is not wholly without use in healing differences and promoting good intentions. The instinct of family love, intended by Heaven to make those of one blood the various and harmonious organs of one mind, is never wholly without good influence. Family love, I say, 8
“Thanksgiving”
9
for family pride is never without bad influence, and it too often takes the place of its mild and healthy sister. Yet where society is at all simple, it is cheering to see the family circle thus assembled, if only because its patriarchal form is in itself so excellent. The presence of the children animates the old people, while the respect and attention they demand refines the gaiety of the young. Yes, it is cheering to see, in some large room, the elders talking near the bright fire, while the cousins of all ages are amusing themselves in knots. Here is almost all the good, and very little of the ill, that can be found in society, got together merely for amusement. Yet how much nobler, more exhilarating and purer would be the atmosphere of that circle if the design of its pious founders were remembered by those who partake this festival! If they dared not attend the public jubilee till private retrospect of the past year had been taken in the spirit of the old rhyme, which we all bear in mind if not in heart— “What hast thou done that’s worth the doing, And what pursued that’s worth pursuing? What sought thou knew’st that thou shouldst shun, What done thou shouldst have left undone?”
and a crusade been vowed into the wild places of the bosom, which should take for its device, “Lord, cleanse thou me from secret faults”—“Keep back thy servant also from presumptuous sins”—would not that circle be happy as if music, from invisible agents, floated through it—if each member of it considered every other member as a bequest from heaven—if he supposed that the appointed nearness in blood or lot was a sign to him that he must exercise his gifts of every kind as given peculiarly in their behalf—that if richer in temper, in talents, in knowledge, or in worldly goods, here was the innermost circle of his poor—that he must clothe these naked, whether in body or mind, soothing the perverse, casting light into the narrow chamber, or, most welcome task of all! extending a hand at the right moment to one uncertain of his way. It is this spirit that makes the old man to be revered as a Nestor,1 rather than put aside like a worn-out garment. It is such a spirit that sometimes has given to the young child a ministry as of a parent in the house. But, if charity begin at home, it must not end there; and while purifying the
1. Nestor, according to Greek legend, was the King of Pylus, one of the Argonaut explorers, and a counselor to the Greeks before the Battle of Troy.
10
“Thanksgiving”
innermost circle, let us not forget that it depends upon the great circle, and that again on it; that no home can be healthful in which are not cherished seeds of good for the world at large. Thy child, thy brother are given to thee only as an example of what is due from thee to all men. It is true that, if you, in anger, call your brother fool, no deeds of so-called philanthropy shall saven you from the punishment; for your philanthropy must be from the love of excitement, not the love of man, or of goodness. But then you must visit the Gentiles also, and take time for knowing what aid the woman of Samaria may need.2 A noble Catholic writer, in the true sense as well as by name a Catholic, describes a tailor as giving a dinner on an occasion which had brought honor to his house, which, though humble, was not a poor house. In his glee, the tailor was boasting a little of the favors and blessings of his lot, when suddenly a thought stung him. He stopped, and cutting away half the fowl that lay before him, sent it in a dish with the best knives, bread, and napkin, and a brotherly message that was better still, to a widow near, who must, he knew, be sitting in sadness and poverty among her children. His little daughter was the messenger. If parents followed up the indulgences heaped upon their children at Thanksgiving dinners with similar messages, there would not be danger that children should think enjoyment of sensual pleasures the only occasion that demands Thanksgiving. And suppose while the children were absent on their errands of justice, as they could not fail to think them, if they compared the hovels they must visit with their own comfortable homes, their elders, touched by a sense of right, should be led from discussion of the rivalries of trade or fashion to whether they could not impart all that was theirs, not merely one poor dinner once a year, but all their mental and material wealth for the benefit of all men. If they do not sell it all at once, as the rich young man was bid to do as a test of his sincerity, they may find some way in which it could be invested so as to show enough obedience to the Law and the Prophets to love our neighbor as ourselves. And he who once gives himself to such thoughts will find it is not merely moral gain for which he shall return thanks another year with the return of this day. In the present complex state of human affairs, you cannot be kind unless you are wise. Thoughts of amaranthine bloom will spring up in the
have [ save 2. Jesus’ conversation with the woman of Samaria, who recognizes him as a prophet, is in John 4:1–29.
“Thanksgiving”
11
fields plowed to give food to suffering men. It would, indeed, seem to be a simple matter at first glance. “Lovest thoun me?”—“Feed my lambs.” But now we have not only to find pasture, but to detect the lambs under the disguise of wolves, and restore them by a spell, like that the Shepherd used, to their natural form and whiteness. And for this present day appointed for Thanksgiving, we may say that if we know of so many wrongs, woes, and errors in the world yet unredressed; if in this nation recent decisions have shown a want of moral discrimination on important subjects, that make us pause and doubt whether we can join in the formal congratulations that we are still bodily alive, unassailed by the ruder modes of warfare, and enriched with the fatness of the land; yet on the other side, we know of causes not so loudly proclaimed why we should give thanks. Abundantly and humbly we must render them for the movement, now sensible in the heart of the civilized world, although it has not pervaded the entire frame. For that movement of contrition and love which forbids men of earnest thought to eat, drink, or be merry, while other men are steeped in ignorance, corruption and wo; which calls the King from his throne of gold, and the Poet from his throne of Mind to lie with the beggar in the kennel, or raise him from it; which says to the Poet, “You must reform rather than create a world,” and to him of the golden crown, “You cannot long remain a King unless you are also a Man.” Wherever this impulse of social or political reform darts up its rill through the crusts of selfishness, scoff and dread arise and hang like a heavy mist above it. But the voice of the rill penetrates far enough for those who have ears to hear. And, sometimes, it is the case that ‘those who came to scoff remain to pray.’ In two articles of reviews, one foreign and one domestic, which have come under our eye within the last fortnight, the writers who began by jeering at the visionaries, seemed as they wrote to be touched by a sense that without a high and pure faith none can have the only true vision of the intention of God as to the Destiny of Man. We recognized as a happy omen that there is cause for thanksgiving and that our people may be better than they seem, the meeting last week to organize an Association for the benefit of Prisoners. We shall not, then, be wholly Pharisees.3 We shall not ask the blessing of this day in the mood of “Lord, I
thous [ thou 3. Pharisees, an ancient Jewish sect that strictly observed religious and secular laws. The term is popularly used to describe people who are self-righteous.
12
“Thanksgiving”
thank thee that I, and my son, and my brother, are not as other men are,—not as these publicans imprisoned there,” while the still, small voice cannot make us hear its evidence that, but for instruction, example, and the “preventing God,” every sin that can be named might riot in our hearts. The prisoner, too, may become a man. Neither his open nor our secret faults, must utterly dismay us. We will treat him as if he had a soul. We will not dare to hunt him into a beast of prey, or trample him into a serpent. We will give him some crumbs from the table which grace from above and parent love below have spread for us, and, perhaps, he will recover from these ghastly ulcers that deform him now. We were much pleased with the spirit of the meeting. It was simple, business-like, in a serious, affectionate temper. The speakers did not make phrases or compliments; did not slur over the truth. The audience showed a ready vibration to the touch of just and tender feeling. The time was evidently ripe for this movement. We doubt not that many now darkened souls will give thanks for the ray of light that will have been let in by this time next year. It is but a grain of mustard seed, but the promised tree will grow swiftly if tended in a pure spirit; and the influence of good measures in any one place will be immediate in this province, as has been the case with every attempt in behalf of the insane. While reading a notice of a successful attempt to have musical performances carried through in concert by the insane at Rouen, we were forcibly reminded of a similar performance we heard a few weeks ago at Sing Sing.4 There the female prisoners joined in the singing of a hymn, or rather choral, which describes the last thoughts of a spirit about to be enfranchised from the body; each stanza of which ends with the words, “All is well;” and they sang it—those suffering, degraded children of society—with as gentle and resigned an expression as if they were sure of going to sleep in the arms of a pure mother. The good spirit that dwelt in the music made them its own. And shall not the good spirit of religious sympathy make them its own also, and more permanently? We shall see. Should the morally insane, by wise and gentle care, be won back to health, as the wretched bedlamites have been, will not the angels themselves give thanks? And will any man dare take the risk of opposing plans that afford even a chance of such a result? Apart, then, from good that is public and many-voiced, do not each of us 4. An account of the “performance” at Sing Sing is in the 20 December 1844 New-York Daily Tribune, p. 1.
“Thanksgiving”
13
know, in private experience, much to be thankful for? Not only the innocent and daily pleasures that we have prized according to our wisdom; of the sun and starry skies, the fields of green, or snow scarcely less beautiful, the loaf eaten with an appetite, the glow of labor, the gentle signs of common affection. But have not some, have not many of us cause to be thankful for enfranchisement from error or infatuation; a growth in knowledge of outward things, and instruction within the soul from a higher source. Have we not acquired a sense of more refined enjoyments; clear convictions; sometimes a serenity in which, as in the first days of June, all things grow, and the blossom gives place to fruit? Have we not been weaned from what was unfit for us, or unworthy our care? and have not those ties been drawn more close, and are not those objects seen more distinctly, which shall for ever be worthy the purest desires of our souls? Have we learned to do any thing, the humblest, in the service and by the spirit of the power which meaneth all things well? If so we may give thanks, and, perhaps, venture to offer our solicitations in behalf of those as yet less favored by circumstances. When even a few shall dare do so with the whole heart—for only a pure heart can “avail much” in such prayers—then all shall soon be well. New-York Daily Tribune, 12 December 1844, p. 2; reprinted, New-York Weekly Tribune, 14 December 1844, p. 1. The Tribune for 3 December 1844, p. 2, reported progress in the formation of a society whose object would be “to promote the highest welfare of the inmates of our prisons, and to provide for them homes and employment when they are set at liberty” (“Association for the Benefit of Prisoners”), and on 7 December 1844, p. 2, the paper reported that the Association for the Reform of Prisons and Their Inmates, known generally as the New York Prison Association, was founded (“Prison Reform Meeting”).
New Year’s Day
It was once a beautiful custom among some of the Indian tribes, once a year, to extinguish all the fires, and, by a day of fasting and profound devotion, to propitiate the Great Spirit for the coming year. They then produced sparks by friction, and lit up afresh the altar and the hearth with the new fire. And this was considered as the most precious and sacred gift from one person to another, binding them in bonds of inviolate friendship for that year, certainly; with a hope that the same might endure through life. From the young to the old it was a token of the highest respect; from the old to the young, of a great expectation. To us might it be granted to solemnize the new year by the mental renovation of which this ceremony was the eloquent symbol! Might we extinguish, if only for a day, those fires where an uninformed religious ardor has led to human sacrifices; which have warmed the household, but, also, prepared pernicious, more than wholesome, viands for their use. The Indian produced the new spark by friction. It would be a still more beautiful emblem, and expressive of the more extended powers of civilized men, if we should draw the spark from the centre of our system and the source of light by means of the burning glass. Where, then, is to be found the new knowledge, the new thought, the new hope, that shall begin a new year in a spirit not discordant with ‘the acceptable year of the Lord?’ Surely, there must be such existing, if latent—some sparks of new fire, pure from ashes and from smoke, worthy to be offered as a new-year’s gift? Let us look at the signs of the times, to see in what spot this fire shall be sought—on what fuel it may be fed. The ancients poured our libations of the choicest juices of Earth, to express their gratitude to the Power that had enabled them to be sustained from her bosom. They enfranchised slaves, to show that devotion to the Gods induced a sympathy with men. Let us look about us to see with what rites, what acts of devotion, this modern Christian nation greets the approach of the New Year; by what signs she 14
“New Year’s Day”
15
denotes the clear morning of a better day, such as may be expected when the eagle has entered into covenant with the dove! This last week brings tidings that a portion of the inhabitants of Illinois, the rich and blooming region on which every gift of nature has been lavished to encourage the industry and brighten the hopes of man, not only refuses a libation to the Power that has so blessed their fields, but declares that the dew is theirs, and the sunlight is theirs, that they live from and for themselves, acknowledging no obligation and no duty to God or to man. One man has freed a slave,—but a great part of the nation is now busy in contriving measures that may best rivet the fetters on those now chained, and forge them strongest for millions yet unborn. Selfishness and tyranny no longer wear the mask; they walk haughtily abroad, affronting with their hard-hearted boasts and brazen resolves the patience of the sweet heavens. National Honor is trodden under foot for a National bribe, and neither sex nor age defends the redresser of injuries from the rage of the injurer. Yet, amid these reports which come flying on the paper wings of every day, the scornful laugh of the gnomes, who begin to believe they can buy all souls with their gold, was checked a moment when the aged knight of the better cause answered the challenge—truly in keeping with the ‘chivalry’ of the time,—“You are in the wrong, and I will kick you,” by holding the hands of the chevalier till those around secured him. We think the man of old must have held him with his eye, as physicians of moral power can insane patients;— great as are his exploits for his age, he cannot have much bodily strength, unless by miracle. The treatment of Mr. Adams and Mr. Hoar seems to show that we are not fitted to emulate the savages in preparation for the new fire.1 The Indians knew how to reverence the old and the wise. Among the manifestos of the day it is impossible not to respect that of the Mexican Minister for the manly indignation with which he has uttered truths, however deep our mortification at hearing them.2 It has been observed for the
1. Samuel Hoar (1778–1856), after being sent to Charleston, South Carolina, in 1844 by the state of Massachusetts to prepare a test case on behalf of some imprisoned Massachusetts free Negro seamen, was declared an emissary of a foreign government and expelled from the city; John Quincy Adams (1767–1848), sixth president of the United States, also represented his hometown of Quincy, Massachusetts, in the House of Representatives from 1831 until his death. 2. The border dispute between the United States and Mexico climaxed with the annexation of Texas in March 1845 and the arrival of an American force under Zachary Taylor on the disputed land
16
“New Year’s Day”
last fifty years that the tone of diplomatic correspondence was much improved as to simplicity and directness. Once, diplomacy was another name for intrigue, and a paper of this sort was expected to be a mesh of artful phrases, through which the true meaning might be detected, but never actually grasped. Now here is one where an occasion being afforded by the unutterable folly of the corresponding party, a Minister speaks the truth as it lies in his mind, directly and plainly, as man speaks to man. His statement will command the sympathy of the civilized world. As to the State papers that have followed, they are of a nature to make the Austrian despot sneer, as he counts in his oratory the woolen stockings he has got knit by imprisoning all the free geniuses in his dominions.3 He, at least, only appeals to the legitimacy of blood; these dare appeal to legitimacy, as seen from a moral point of view. History will class them with the brags of sharpers, who bully their victims about their honor, while they stretch forth their hands for the gold they have won with loaded dice.—“Do you dare to say the dice are loaded? Prove it; and I will shoot you for injuring my honor.” The Mexican makes his gloss on the page of American Honor. The girl in the Kentucky prison on that of her Freedom.4 The delegate of Massachusetts on that of her Union. Ye stars! whose image she has placed upon her banner, answer us! Are not your Unions of a different sort? Do they not work to other results? Yet we cannot lightly be discouraged or alarmed as to the destiny of our Country. The whole history of its discovery and early progress indicates too clearly the purposes of Heaven withn regard to it. Could we relinquish the thought that it was destined for the scene of a new and illustrious act in the great drama, the Past would be inexplicable, no less than the Future without hope. Last week, which brought us so many unpleasant notices of home affairs, brought also an account of the magnificent telescope lately perfected by the
that summer. Fuller also refers to Manuel C. Rejon’s “The Mexican Manifesto Against the Annexation of Texas,” which she admires for the forthright rhetoric of the Mexican diplomat, which is a point-bypoint rebuttal of arguments for the annexation of Texas (reported in the Tribune, 13 December 1844, p. 1). 3. Rejon was treated with much disrespect in responses leaked by government officials to the press. 4. The Tribune of 20 December 1844 reports that the abolitionist Delia Webster was jailed in Lexington, Kentucky, on suspicion of assisting three slaves to escape. She remained incarcerated for months, and periodic reports about her appeared in the Tribune. with, [ with
“New Year’s Day”
17
Earl of Rosse.5 With means of observation, now almost divine, we perceive that some of the brightest stars, of which Sirius is one, have dark companions, whose presence is, by earthly spectators, only to be detected from the inequalities they cause in the motions of their radiant companions. It was a new and most imposing illustration how, in carrying out the Divine scheme, of which we have as yet only spelt out the few first lines, the dark is made to wait upon and, in the full result, harmonize with, the bright. The sense of such pervasive analogies should enlarge patience and animate hope. Yet, if offences must come, wo be to those by whom they come, and that of men, who sin against a heritage like ours, is as that of the backsliders among the Chosen People of the elder day. We too have been chosen, and plain indications been given, by a wonderful conjunction of auspicious influences, that the ark of human hopes has been placed for the present in our charge. Wo be to those who betray this trust! On their heads are to be heaped the curses of unnumbered ages! Can he sleep, who in this past year has wickedly or lightly committed acts calculated to injure the few or many—who has poisoned the ears and the hearts he might have rightly informed—who has steeped in tears the cup of thousands—who has put back, as far as in him lay, the accomplishment of general good and happiness for the sake of his selfish aggrandizement or selfish luxury—who has sold to a party what is meant for mankind? If such sleep, dreadful shall be the waking. Deliver us from evil. In public or in private it is easy to give pain—hard to give pure pleasure; easy to do evil—hard to do good. God does His good in the whole, despite of bad men; but only from a very pure mind will He permit original good to proceed in the day. Happy those who can feel that during the past year, they have, to the best of their knowledge, refrained from evil. Happy those who determine to proceed in this by the light of Conscience. It is but a spark; yet from that spark may be drawn fire-light enough for worlds and systems of worlds, and that light is ever new. And with this thought rises again the memory of the fair lines that light has brought to viewn in the histories of some men. If the nation tends to wrong, there are yet present the ten just men. The hands and lips of this great form may be impure, but pure blood flows yet within her veins—the blood of the noble bands who first sought these shores from the British isles and France for 5. William Parsons, third Earl of Rosse (1800–67), Irish astronomer and telescope builder. veiw [ view
18
“New Year’s Day”
conscience sake. Too many have come since for bread alone. We cannot blame—we must not reject them, but let us teach them, in giving them bread, to prize that salt, too, without which all on earth must lose its savor. Yes! let us teach them, not rail at their inevitable ignorance and unenlightened action, but teach them and their children as our own; if we do so, their children and ours may yet act as one body obedient to one soul, and if we should act rightly now, that soul a pure soul. And ye, sable bands, forced hither against your will, kept down here now by a force hateful to Nature, a will alien from God; it does sometimes seem as if the Avenging Angel wore your hue and would place in your hands the sword to punish the cruel injustice of our fathers, the selfish perversity of the sons. Yet, are there no means of atonement? Must the innocent suffer with the guilty? Teach us, oh All-Wise! the clue out of this labyrinth, and if we faithfully encounter its darkness and dread, and emerge into clear light, wilt Thou not bid us ‘go and sin no more?’6 Meanwhile, let us proceed as we can, picking our steps along the slippery road. If we keep the right direction, what matters it that we must pass through so much mud? The promise is sure: Angels shall free the feet from stain, to their own hue of snow, If, undismayed, we reach the hills where the true olives grow. The olive-groves, which we must seek in cold and damp, Alone can yield us oil for a perpetual lamp. Then sound again the golden horn with promise ever new; The princely deer will ne’er be caught by those that slack pursue; Let the ‘White Doe’ of angel hopes be always kept in view. Yes! sound again the horn—of Hope the golden horn! Answer it, flutes and pipes, from valleys still and lorn; Warders, from your high towers, with trumps of silver scorn, And harps in maidens’ bowers, with strings from deep hearts torn, All answer to the horn—of Hope the golden horn!
There is still hope, there is still an America, while private lives are ruled by the Puritan, by the Huguenot conscientiousness, and while there are some who can repudiate, not their debts, but the supposition that they will not
6. “Afterward Jesus findeth him in the temple, and said unto him, Behold, thou art made whole: sin no more, lest a worse thing come unto thee” (John 5:14).
“New Year’s Day”
19
strive to pay their debts to their age, and to Heaven who gave them a share in its great promise. New-York Weekly Tribune, 28 December 1844, p. 1; reprinted, New-York Daily Tribune, 1 January 1845, p. 1.
This page intentionally left blank
Miss Barrett’s Poems
What happiness for the critic when, as in the present instance, his task is, mainly, how to express a cordial admiration; to indicate an intelligence of beauties, rather than regret for defects! We have read these volumes with feelings of delight far warmer than the writer, in her sincerely modest preface, would seem to expect from any reader, and cannot hesitate to rank her, in vigor and nobleness of conception, depth of spiritual experience, and command of classic allusion, above any female writer the world has yet known. In the first quality, especially, most female writers are deficient. They do not grasp a subject with simple energy, nor treat it with decision of touch. They are in general most remarkable for delicacy of feeling, and brilliancy or grace in manner. In delicacy of perception, Miss Barrett may vie with any of her sex. She has what is called a true woman’s heart, although we must believe that men of a fine conscience, and good organization will have such a heart no less. Signal instances occur to us in the cases of Spenser, Wordsworth and Tennyson.1 The woman who reads them will not find hardness or blindness as to the subtler workings of thoughts and affections. If men are often deficient on this score,n women, on the other hand, are apt to pay excessive attention to the slight tokens, the little things of life. Thus, in conduct or writing, they tend to weary us by a morbid sentimentalism. From this fault Miss Barrett is wholly free. Personal feeling is in its place; enlightened by Reason, ennobled by Imagination. The earth is no despised resting place for the feet, the heaven bends while above, rich in starry hopes, and the air flows around exhilarating and free. 1. Edmund Spenser (ca. 1552–99), English poet best known for The Fairie Queene (1590); William Wordsworth (1770–1850), British poet and a cofounder with Coleridge of the Romantic movement; Alfred, Lord Tennyson (1809–92), named poet laureate of England in 1850 to succeed Wordsworth. score; [ score,
20
“Miss Barrett’s Poems”
21
The mournful, albeit we must own them tuneful, sisters of the lyre might hush many of their strains at this clear note from one who has felt and conquered the same difficulties. perplexed music. “Experience, like a pale musician, holds A dulcimer of patience in his hand: Whence harmonies we cannot understand Of God’s will in his worlds the strain unfolds, In sad perplexed minors. Deathly colds Fall on us while we hear and countermand Our sanguine heart back from the fancy land; With nightingales in visionary wolds. We murmur—‘Where is any certain tune, Or measured music in such notes as these?’ But angels, leaning from the golden seat, Are not so minded; their fine ear hath won The issue of completed cadences; And smiling down the stars, they whisper—sweet.”
We are accustomed now to much verse on moral subjects, such as follows the lead of Wordsworth and seeks to arrange moral convictions as melodies on the harp. But these tones are never deep, unless the experience of the poet, in the realms of intellect and emotion, be commensurate with his apprehension of truth. Wordsworth moves us when he writes an “Ode to Duty,” or “Dion,” because he could also write “Ruth,” and the exquisitely tender poems on Matthew, in whom nature “—for a favorite child Had tempered so the clay, That every hour the heart ran wild, Yet never went astray.”2
The trumpet call of Luther’s ‘Judgment Hymn’ sounds from the depths of a nature capable of all human emotions, or it could not make the human ear
2. William Wordsworth, “Matthew,” ll. 1–4.
22
“Miss Barrett’s Poems”
vibrate as it does.3 The calm convictions expressed by Miss Barrett in the sonnets come with poetic force, because she was also capable of writing ‘The Lost Bower,’ ‘The Romaunt of the Page,’ ‘Loved Once,’ ‘Bertha in the Lane,’ and ‘A Lay of the Early Rose.’ These we select as the finest of the tender poems. In the ‘Drama of Exile’ and the ‘Vision of Poets,’ where she aims at a Miltonic flight or Dantesque grasp—not in any spirit of rivalry or imitation, but because she is really possessed of a similar mental scope—her success is far below what we find in the poems of feeling and experience; for she has the vision of a great poet, but little in proportion of his plastic power. She is at home in the Universe; she sees its laws; she sympathises with its motions. She has the imagination all compact—the healthy archetypal plant from which all forms may be divined, and, so far as now existent, understood. Like Milton, she sees the angelic hosts in real presence; like Dante, she hears the spheral concords and shares the planetary motions.4 But she cannot, like Milton, marshal the angels so near the earth as to impart the presence other than by sympathy. He who is near her level of mind may, through the magnetic sympathy, see the angels with her. Others will feel only the grandeur and sweetness she expresses in these forms.—Still less can she, like Dante, give, by a touch, the key which enables ourselves to play on the same instrument. She is singularly deficient in the power of compression. There are always far more words and verses than needed to convey the meaning, and it is a great proof of her strength, that the thought still seems strong, when arrayed in a form so Briarean clumsy and many-handed.5 We compare her with those great poets, though we have read her preface and see how sincerely she deprecates any such comparison, not merely because her theme is the same as theirs, but because, as we must again repeat, her field of vision and nobleness of conception are such, that we cannot forbear trying her by the same high standard to see what she lacks. Of the “Drama of Exile” and other poems of the same character, we may say that we shall never read them again, but we are very glad to have read them once, to see how the grand mysteries look to her, to share with her the conception and outline of what would, in the hands of a more powerful artist, have come forth a great poem. Our favorite, above anything we have read of 3. Martin Luther (1483–1546), famous German prelate. 4. John Milton (1608–74), English poet and political writer; Dante Alighieri (1265–1321), Italian poet and Christian humanist. 5. So-called after Briareus, a Greek legendary monster with one hundred arms.
“Miss Barrett’s Poems”
23
hers, is the “Rhyme of the Duchess May,” equally admirable in thought and execution, in poetic meaning and romantic grace. Were there room here, it should be inserted, as a sufficient evidence of the writer’s high claims; but it is too long, and does not well bear being broken. The touches throughout are fine and forcible, but they need the unison of the whole to give them their due effect. Most of these poems have great originality in the thought and the motive powers. It is these, we suppose, that have made “The Brown Rosarie” so popular. It has long been handed about in manuscript, and hours have been spent in copying it, which would have been spared if the publication of these volumes in America had been expected so soon. It does not please us so well as many of the others. The following, for instance, is just as original, full of grace, and, almost, perfectly simple:6 How sweetly natural! and how distinct is the picture of the little girl, as she sits by the brook. The poem cannot fail to charm all who have treasured the precious memories of their own childhood, and remember how romance was there interwoven with reality. Miss Barrett makes many most fair and distinct pictures, such as this of the Duchess May at the fatal moment when her lord’s fortress was giving way: “Low she dropt her head and lower, till her hair coiled on the floor. Toll slowly And tear after tear you heard, fall distinct as any word Which you might be listening for. “Get thee in, thou soft ladie!—here is never a place of thee.” Toll slowly “Braid thy hair and clasp thy gown, that thy beauty in its moan May find grace with Leigh of Leigh.” She stood up in bitter case, with a pale yet steady face, Toll slowly Like a statue thunderstruck, which, though, quivering, seems to look Right against the thunder-place, And her feet trod in, with pride, her own tears i’ the stone beside. 6. “The Romance of the Swan’s Nest” is quoted in full here.
24
“Miss Barrett’s Poems”
Toll slowly Go to, faithful friends, go to!—Judge no more what ladies do, No, nor how their lords may ride.”7
and so on. There are passages in that poem beyond praise. Here are descriptions as fine of another sort of person from lady geraldine’s courtship. Her foot upon the new-mown grass—bareheaded—with the flowing Of the virginal white vesture, gathered closely to her throat; With the golden ringlets in her neck, just quickened by her going, And appearing to breathe sun for air, and doubting if to float,— With a branch of dewy maple, which her right hand held above her, And which trembled a green shadow in betwixt her and the skies,— As she turned her face in going, thus she drew me on to love her, And to study the deep meaning of the smile hid in her eyes. For her eyes alone smiled constantly: her lips had serious sweetness, And her front was calm—the dimple rarely rippled on her cheek: But her deep blue eyes smiled constantly,—as if they had by fitness Won the secret of a happy dream, she did not care to speak.
How fine are both the descriptive and critical touches in the following passage: “Ay, and sometimes on the hill-side, while we sat down in the gowans, With the forest green behind us, and its shadow cast before; And the river running under: and across it, from the rowens, A brown partridge whirring near us, till we felt the air it bore— There, obedient to her praying, did I read aloud the poems Made by Tuscan flutes, or instruments, more various, of our own; Read the pastoral parts of Spenser—or the subtle interflowings Found in Petrarch’s sonnets—here’s the book—the leaf is folded down! Or at times a modern volume—Wordsworth’s solemn-thoughted idyl, Howitt’s ballad-dew, or Tennyson’s god-vocal reverie,— Or from Browning some “Pomegranate,” which, if cut deep down the middle, Shows a heart within, blood-tinctured, of a veined humanity. 7. Barrett, “The Rhyme,” ll. 285–300.
“Miss Barrett’s Poems”
25
Or I read there, sometimes, hoarsely, some new poem of my making— Oh, your poets never read their own best verses to their worth, For the echo, in you, breaks upon the words which you are speaking, And the chariot-wheels jar in the gate through which you drive them forth. After, when we were grown tired of books, the silence round us flinging A slow arm of sweet compression, felt with beatings at the breast,— She would break out, on a sudden, in a gush of woodland singing, Like a child’s emotion is a god—a naiad tired of rest. Oh, to see or hear her singing! scarce I know which is divinest— For her looks sing too—she modulates her gestures on the tune; And her mouth stirs with the song, like song; and when the notes are finest, ’Tis the eyes that shoot out vocal light, and seem to swell them on. Then we talked—oh, how we talked! her voice so cadenced in the talking, Made another singing—of the soul! a music without bars— While the leafy sounds of wood lands, humming round where we were walking, Brought interposition worthy-sweet,—as skies about the stars. And she spake such good thoughts natural, as if she always thought them— And had sympathies so ready, open-free like bird on branch, Just as ready to fly east as west, which ever way besought them, In the birchen wood a chirrup, or a cock-crow in the grange. In her utmost lightness there is truth—and often she speaks lightly; And she has a grace in being gay, which mourners even approve; For the root of some grave earnest thought is understruck so rightly, As to justify the foliage and the waving flowers above.”
We must copy yet one other poem to give some idea of the range of Miss Barrett’s powers:8 If it be said that the poetry, the tragedy here is in the facts, yet how rare is it to find a mind that can both feel and upbear such facts? We have already said, that, as a poet, Miss Barrett is deficient in plastic energy, and that she is diffuse. We must add many blemishes of overstrained and constrained thought and expression. The ways in which words are coined or forced from their habitual meanings does not carry its excuse with it. We find no gain that compensates the loss of elegance and simplicity. One practice which has already had its censors of using the adjective for the noun, as in 8. “The Cry of the Children” is quoted in full here.
26
“Miss Barrett’s Poems”
the cases of “The cry of the Human,” “Leaning from the Golden,” we, also, find offensive, not only to the habitual tastes, but to the sympathies of the very mood awakened by the writer. We hear that she has long been an invalid, and, while the knowledge of this increases admiration for her achievements and delight at the extent of the influence,—so much light flowing from the darkness of the sick room,—we seem to trace injurious results, too. There is often a want of pliant and glowing life. The sun does not always warm the marble. We have spoken of the great book culture of this mind. We must now say that this culture is too great in proportion to that it has received from actual life. The lore is not always assimilated to the new form; the illustrations sometimes impede the attention rather than help its course; and we are too much and too often reminded of other minds and other lives. Great variety of metres are used, and with force and facility. But they have not that deep music which belongs to metres which are the native growth of the poet’s mind. In that case, others may have used them, but we feel that, if they had not, he must have invented them; that they are original with him. Miss Barrett is more favored by the grand and thoughtful, than by the lyric muse. We have thus pointed out all the faults we could find in Miss Barrett, feeling that her strength and nobleness deserve this act of high respect. She has no need of leniency, or caution. The best comment upon such critiques may be made by subjoining this paragraph from her Preface: “If it were not presumptuous language on the lips of one to whom life is more than usually uncertain, my favorite wish for this work would be, that it be received by the public as a deposit, ambitious of approaching to the nature of a security for a future offering of more value and acceptability. I would fain do better, and I feel as if I might do better: I aspire to do better. In any case, my poems, while full of faults, as I go forward to my critics and confess, have my life and heart in them. They are not empty shells. If it must be said of me that I have contributed unworthy verses, I also, to the many rejected by the age, it cannot, at least, be said that I have done so in a light or irresponsible spirit. Poetry has been as serious a thing to me as life itself; and life has been a very serious thing; there has been no playing at skittles for me in either. I never mistook pleasure for the final cause of poetry; nor leisure, for the hour of the poet. I have done my work, so far, as work; not as mere hand and head work apart from the personal being, but as the completest expression of that being to which I could attain; and, as work, I offer it to the public, feeling its faulti-
“Miss Barrett’s Poems”
27
ness more deeply than any of my readers, because measured from the hight of my aspiration, but feeling also that the reverence and sincerity with which the work was done should protect it in the thoughts of the reverent and sincere.”
Of the greatest of Grecian sages it was said that he acquired such power over the lower orders of nature, through his purity and intelligence, that wild beasts were abashed and reformed by his admonitions, and that, once, when walking abroad with his disciples, he called down the white eagle, soaring above him, and drew from her willing wing a quill for his use. We have seen women use with skill and grace the practical goose-quill, the sentimental crow-quill, and even the lyrical, the consecrated feathers of the swan. But we have never seen one to whom the white eagle would have descended; and, for a while, were inclined to think that the hour had now, for the first time, arrived. But upon full deliberation, we will award to Miss Barrett one from the wing of the sea-gull. That is also a white bird, rapid, soaring, majestic, and which can alight with ease, and poise itself upon the stormiest wave. Review of Elizabeth B. Barrett, A Drama of Exile: and Other Poems, 2 vols. (New York: H. G. Langley, 1845). New-York Daily Tribune, 4 January 1845, p. 1; reprinted, New-York Weekly Tribune, 18 January 1845, p. 2; Papers on Literature and Art, 2:22–30. Elizabeth Barrett Browning (1806–61), English poet, married her fellow poet Robert Browning (1812–89) in 1846. Fuller and her family later spent time with the Brownings in Florence.
The Liberty Bell for 1845
This Annual is published, as usual, in Massachusetts, for the benefit of the Anti-Slavery Fair. As frontispiece, it has a portrait of wendell phillips, one of the most eloquent leaders of the party, etched by J. Andrews from a Daguerreotype by Southworth, which presents a fac-simile of his keen intellectual expression.1 The face corresponds entirely with his style of oratory. The writers show their usual clearness and full possession of their ground. Even these pieces, which have little merit in point of talent, please by their distinct enunciation of principles. Elizabeth Pease, a valued English friend to the cause, observes, “Although to but few it may be given to be the voices of the world, to startle mankind by the enunciation of some new and earnest thought, or even to act on the universal mind by bringing to light some long concealed gem from the treasury of Truth, yet, to all of us belongs the power of determining of what voices we will be the echo—to what principles we will lend the influence of our example and the advocacy of our lips.”2 And to this responsibility the writers before us have been faithful, so that their words are the echoes of individual conscience, individual mind. They seem happy in the consciousness which Lowell thus finely expresses: “Love, Faith, and Peace, Thy lilies three, Bloom on a single heart’s frail stem That dares Truth’s unpaid bondmaid be;— Father! what lack we, having them? Though Unbelief’s bleak winter freeze, Thy quiet sunshine fences these.”3 1. Wendell Phillips (1811–84), reformer, orator, and abolitionist; Joseph Andrews (1806–73), Boston engraver; Nathaniel Southworth (1806–58), miniaturist. 2. Elizabeth Pease (1807–97), English woman’s rights and antislavery reformer. 3. “The Happy Martyrdom,” by James Russell Lowell (1819–91), poet, critic, and editor of the National Anti-Slavery Standard.
28
“The Liberty Bell for 1845”
29
One of the most interesting features of the book consists in the contributions of the men of color. These not only compare very favorably with those penned by white hands, but—when we see such rapid progress as in the case of Douglass, who was “only six years since a fugitive from a Southern cornfield”—are the most unanswerable arguments in favor of the capacities of the African race.4 Their claims need no argument. A sketch by Edmund Quincy, ‘Philip Catesby,’ is written with much skill and feeling.5 The following letter from Miss Bremer will be read with interest by all classes, and is the best comment on the book and cause of which it is a symbol:6 fredrika bremer on slavery Stockholm, 25th August, 1844 My Dear Mrs. Chapman—Just returned from a tour in one of the northern provinces of my country, (Dalarna, the mother-province of our Liberty,) I hasten to answer your letter from Boston of the 22d February, and am very sorry not to have been capable of answering it before. For that letter and the valuable present that accompanied it, I offer you my sincere thanks. It grieves me indeed not to be able to offer more, and to join in your honorable efforts in a great and sacred cause. O! readily do I lift my voice and join in the universal chorus which is raised on earth by Christianity, for the Liberty of Man—for the Abolition of Slavery. But when you, dear Mrs. Chapman, desire me to take a solo-part in the great concerto for that Abolition, I shrink back, from the very natural feeling that my voice is not strong, not good enough for such a part, and that this effort is not needed, and cannot add an iota to the benefit of the cause. It is my firm opinion (and that has been ratified to me by some here residing Americans) that the principle of the freedom of man and the injustice of Slavery is fully recognized in the United States; (as it necessarily must be, by every man and nation who possesses common
4. Frederick Douglass (1818–95), abolitionist and journalist, whose autobiography Fuller would review in the Tribune on 10 June 1845. 5. Edmund Quincy (1805–77), reformer, abolitionist, and author. 6. Fredrika Bremer (1801–65), Swedish novelist and feminist.
30
“The Liberty Bell for 1845”
sense and confesses Christianity,) and that the question there now is not, if Slavery be just or justifiable, but “in what manner and how shall we make Slavery cease?” That is the question. And only he that could show how this liberation can be effected, to the true good of the enslaved as of the slave-holding population in America, would be the true and chief promoter of a cause, for the success of which the great Republic must sigh as for her own moral and spiritual liberation. If such a light, if such a wisdom was given to me, O! then, believe me, I would not draw back in showing it; in taking my part in the glorious drama of liberation; yea, though I should break my neck in the attempt to break the chain that chains the black man to his brother the white man, and a great and rising nation to the king of darkness! But for more able and powerful hands this glorious work is reserved. It is a work for the Genius of America! Out of her own bosom must rise the thought, must spring the word which will give liberty to her enslaved children. And that word—how should America not find it? How can she be untrue to her principal mission in the world? Is not the genius of America called upon to be on earth the missionary of God, to proclaim the freedom of man in the name of the Redeemer? Look at her origin and history! Spiritual Freedom!—was the watchword of those one hundred Puritans who fled to the desert and planted there the tree of liberty which now shadows over the Republic of the United States, and of which the unbloody laurels were so richly blessed by God. Political Freedom!—was the banner under which America rose to its national self-control and greatness. Human Freedom! spiritual and political freedom for every soul redeemed by God, is the great truth still left for America to pronounce and to make real in her realm. Great may be, in the present state of things, the difficulties which prevent the achievement of that great work; still it is the belief of all friends of America here, that her genius will rise superior to all difficulties; that, inspired by the God of freedom and grace, the United States will one day, not far off, unite to break the chains of Slavery and make their enslaved brothers partake of the blessed lot of the free. And then the blessing of the eternal Redeemer will, in tenfold measure, descend on the then truly free and glorious Republic of North America. For the speedy arrival of that day, let me, in my corner, humbly hope and pray, and so at least unite in spirit and heart with you and the noble minds of your people.
“The Liberty Bell for 1845”
31
Accept dearest Madam, of my hearty good wishes and kind thanks. Respectfully yours, FREDRIKA BREMER. P.S.—I need hardly say, my dear Madam, that if my letter seems to you good for publication, you may dispose of it as you like. And pray excuse all the sins I may have committed against your language. Review of The Liberty Bell by Friends of Freedom (Boston: Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Fair, 1845). New-York Daily Tribune, 7 January 1845, p. 2; reprinted, New-York Weekly Tribune, 18 January 1845, p. 2.
[Review of Charles Lanman, Letters from a Landscape Painter]
This is a very pleasing book, and, if the “Essays for Summer Hours” resemble it,1 we are not surprised at the favor with which they have been received, not only in this country but in England. The writer, Mr. Lanman, is by profession a Landscape Painter, by pastime a fisherman of the speckled trout that serve as decoy to the most beautiful inland scenes, or of the larger fish that serve as excuse for passing the day on the boldest crags of the sea-shore. Thus business and pleasure have combined to lead him, during the months of fine weather, to many of the finest scenes, and these are described with grace, force, and a youthful glow of feeling, that make us very willing to be his companions, even where the mind least needs companionship. This is a genuine sort of writing, as the record, in the evenings or rainy days, of what one has seen and enjoyed in the bright full hours. Nor are these the fancy-sketches of those hunters after the picturesque and poetic, of whose farsought delights, and far-fetched analogies we are so weary. They are familiar, free, showing a power of manly discrimination and manly thought, yet agreeably varied by touches of boyish fun. We do not make extracts, because, though there is material for many good ones, they will all be seen to more advantage in connection with the whole, as the charm of the book lies in the stamp of living character upon it, as a whole. We are interested in the criticisms passed by Mr. Lanman on painters, which express his own ideas of this art, and by some sketches of persons such as of the Lilly, and his friends, the “Lions of Burlington.”2 It is very pleasing to 1. Lanman had published Essays for Summer Hours in 1841. 2. Among the literary lions at Burlington, Vermont, home of the university, were; John H. Peck (1785?–1862), a prominent merchant and public figure; Ezra Meech (1773–1856), a lumber baron and farmer who served in the state legislature; Joseph Torrey (1797–1867), professor of moral and intellectual philosophy at the University of Vermont; and Lilly Lanard, a sixteen-year-old girl known as a lover of nature and poetry.
32
[Review of Letters from a Landscape Painter]
33
read the account of Mr. Marsh’s mind, as given by the catalogue of his possessions.3 When Fonthill Abbey was sold, the public got a better transcript of the mind of Beckford,4 in the inventory of the treasures there accumulated, than from any thing he ever wrote. That inventory was a poem. And it pleases us to see a poem, not so splendid but altogether surprising for this scene and time, in the inventory of Mr. Marsh’s possessions. It must be a large piece of clear amber that could exercise such attraction. If Professor Torrey has translated Schelling on the “Relation of the Arts of Design to Nature,” has he published the translation?5 We have never seen it; yet surely, so valuable an addition to this department of literature should not be slow to find its way into print. Mr. Lanman is, we believe, very young, and, as these essays have awakened in us a friendly expectation, which he has time and talent to fulfil, we will, at this early hour, proffer our counsel on two points. 1st. Avoid details so directly personal, as to emotion. A young and generous mind, seeing the deceit and cold reserve which so often palsy men who write, no less than those who act, may run into the opposite extreme. But frankness must be tempered by delicacy, or elevated into the region of poetry. You may tell the world at large what you please, if you make it of universal importance by transporting it into the field of general human interest. But your private griefs, merely as yours, belong to yourself, your nearest friends, to Heaven and to nature. There is a limit set by good taste, or the sense of beauty, on such subjects, which each, who seeks, may find for himself. 2d. Be more sparing of your praise; above all of its highest terms. We should have a sense of mental, as well as moral honor, which, while it makes us feel the baseness of uttering hasty and ignorant censure, will also forbid the hasty and extravagant praise, by which we cannot abide. A man of honor wishes to utter no word by which he cannot abide. The offices of poet, of hero-worship, are sacred, and he who has a heart to appreciate the excellent, should call nothing excellent which falls short of being so. Leave yourself some incense worthy of the best; do not lavish it on the merely good. It is better to be too cool, than extravagant in praise; and, though mediocrity may be elated, if it can draw to itself undue honors, true greatness shrinks from the least exagger3. George Perkins Marsh (1801–82), president of the University of Vermont. 4. William Beckford (1759–1844), English author and collector, whose estate at Fonthill was known for its extravagances. 5. There is no evidence that Joseph Torrey published his translation of the work by Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph von Schelling (1775–1854), German philosopher.
34
[Review of Letters from a Landscape Painter]
ation of its claims. The truly great are too well aware how difficult is the attainment of excellence, what labors and sacrifices it requires, even from genius, either to flatter themselves as to their works, or be other than grieved at idolatry from others; and so with best wishes, and a wish to meet again, we bid farewell to the Landscape Painter. Review of Charles Lanman, Letters from a Landscape Painter (Boston: James Munroe, 1845). New-York Daily Tribune, 18 January 1845, p. 1; reprinted, New-York Weekly Tribune, 25 January 1845, p. 2. Title supplied. Charles Lanman (1819–95), public official, travel writer, and landscape painter.
[Review of James Russell Lowell, Conversations on Some of the Old Poets]
“Hail, bards of mightier grasp! on you I chiefly call, the chosen few, Who cast not off the acknowledged guide, Who faltered not, nor turned aside; Whose lofty genius could survive Privation, under sorrow thrive.”1
By prefixing to his work these lines from Wordsworth, Mr. Lowell indicates his standard as to the hopes and destiny of the Poet. It is a high one; and in its application, he shows great justness of feeling, delicacy of perception, comprehensive views; and, for this country, an unusual refinement and extent of culture. We have been accustomed to hear Mr. Lowell so extravagantly lauded by the circle of his friends, that we should be hopeless of escaping the wrath of his admirers, for any terms in which our expressions of sympathy could be couched, but for the more modest and dignified tone of his own preface, which presents ground on which the world, at large, can meet him. With his admirers, we have often been reminded of a fervent Italian who raved at one of our young country-women as “a heartless girl,” because she would not go to walk with him alone at midnight. But Mr. Lowell, himself, speaks of his work as becomes one conversant with those of great and accomplished minds. “I am not bold enough to esteem these essays of any great price. Standing as yet only in the outer porch of life, I cannot be expected to report those higher mysteries which lie in the body unrevealed in the body of the temple. Yet, as a child, when he has found but a mean pebble, which differs from ordinary only so much as by a stripe of quartz or a stain of iron, calls his companions to behold his treasure, which then also affords matter of delight and wonder; I 1. “Lines Written in a Blank Leaf of Macpherson’s Ossian,” ll. 53–58, by William Wordsworth.
35
36
[Review of Conversations on Some of the Old Poets]
cannot but hope that my little findings may be pleasant and haply instructive to some few.”
We are thus presented with the agreeable opportunity of responding “pleasant and instructive to many;” for we feel that this book will be a pleasure and advantage to the many who do not receive it at the hands of a coterie. The form of dialogue affords the author great advantage. It is easy and animated, and, though contrast of character, and sustained mental pictures of the speakers, to the extent that we find in Landor’s Pentameron,2 for instance, would add to our enjoyment, yet we are content in its use, merely as a free and various mode of expressing the writer’s own views. It is even more rare to meet a great Critic than a great Poet. True criticism, as distinguished from petty cavil and presumptuous measurement, on the one hand, and encomiums, based merely on personal sympathy, on the other, supposes a range and equipoise of faculties, and a generosity of soul which have as yet been rarely combined in any one person. The great Critic is not merely the surveyor, but the interpreter of what other minds possess; he must have a standard of excellence, founded on prescience of what man is capable of; he must have, no less, a refined imagination and quick sympathies to enter into each work in its own kind, and examine it by its own law, so that he may understand how certain faults are interwoven, in growth, with certain virtues; he must have a cultivated taste, a calm, large, and deep judgment, and a heart to love everything that is good, in proportion to its goodness. In some of these traits the English mind has thus far shown itself so deficient, that there is very little valuable criticism extant in that language, in proportion to the number of attempts. The English, as a nation, have attempted to criticize by tradition, outward rule, or habitual taste, and have, by an inadequate notion of the purposes and means of criticism, failed of its best uses.—Most essays in this kind by English writers are records of the habits and prejudices of the age or the writer; their value is merely historical. Amid honorable exceptions, Coleridge stands foremost,3 but, very generally, a verdict passed in the English speech, has failed of confirmation by the sense of the civilized world. And some critiques whose interest still endures, for the interest of the thoughts they embody, no longer have any value as applicable to the
2. Walter Savage Landor (1775–1864), Romantic poet, published Pentameron in 1837. 3. Samuel Taylor Coleridge (1772–1834), English poet and philosopher, and, with Wordsworth, founder of the Romantic movement.
[Review of Conversations on Some of the Old Poets]
37
subject, for the years, as they pass, have brought a measure better proportioned to its size than contemporary mind could furnish. Mr. Lowell belongs to the generous school, who deal more in affirmations than in negations, who have not the poor desire to sum up the merits of the subject, but are rather anxious to express the value received to themselves. His way of looking at greatness is reverent without extravagance, or the taint of mere temporary emotion; his doubts and exceptions are well-considered; and his homage is honorable to its objects and to himself. But let us hear in his own words how he would look at the Poet. “Nature should lead the true poet by the hand, and he has far better things to do than busy himself in counting the warts upon it, as Pope did. A cup of water from Hippocrene, tasting, as it must, of innocent pastoral sights and sounds, of the bleat of lambs, of the shadows of leaves and flowers that have leaned over it, of the rosy hands of children whose privilege it ever is to paddle in it, of the low words of lovers who have walked by its side in the moonlight, of the tears of the poor Hagars of the world who have drank from it, would choke a satirist. His thoughts of the country must have a savior of Jack Ketch, and see no beauty but in a kemp field. Poetry is something to make us wiser and better, by continually revealing those types of beauty and truth which God has set in all men’s souls; not by picking out the petty faults of our neighbors to make a mock of.” * * * * * “Asmodeus’s gift, of unroofing the dwellings of his neighbors at will, would be the rarest outfit for a satirist, but it would be of no worth to a Poet. To a satirist the more outward motives of life are enough. Vanity, pride, avarice— these, and the other external vices, are but the strings of the unmusical lyre? But the Poet need only unroof his own heart. All that makes happiness or misery under every roof of the wide world, whether of palace or hovel, is working also in that narrow yet boundless sphere. On that little stage the great drama of life is acted daily. There the Creation, the Tempting, the Fall may be seen anew. In that withdrawing-closet, Solitude whispers her secrets, and Death uncovers his face. There sorrow takes up her abode, to make ready a pillow and a resting-place for the weary head of love, whom the world casts out. To the Poet nothing is mean, but every thing on earth is a fitting altar to the Supreme Beauty.”
There are passages of free humor and good sense which agreeably relieve this high strain, and which we should like to quote, in juxtaposition with the preceding, had we room. On the topics of the day, Mr. Lowell expresses himself with clear good sense, and in a worthy spirit. He shows such plain reason
38
[Review of Conversations on Some of the Old Poets]
for the faith that is in him that the dullest conservative cannot say it is a blind enthusiasm that has joined him with the Movement party. He well expresses the grounds of such a faith. “He (the Poet) knows that the whole power of God is behind him, as the drop of water in the little creek feels that it is moved onward by the whole weight of the rising ocean.” As to his Poets, the comments on Chaucer are feeling and discerning, and the extracts well-chosen and well-placed. On leading characteristics of Chapman he has seized with great force.4 Some things are admirably thought and said of this Poet. The following remarks, upon Ford please us well:5 “His plots raise him, and carry him along with them wither they please, and it is generally only at their culminating points that he shows much strength; and then it is the strength of passion, not of reason. Indeed, I do not know but it should rather be called weakness. He puts his characters’ insinuations where the heart that has a drop of blood in it finds it easier to be strong than weak. His heroes show that fitful strength which grows out of intense excitement, rather than healthy muscular action; it does not rise with difficulty or danger they are in, and, looking down on it, assert calmly the unsurpassable sovereignty of the soul, even after the flesh is overcome, but springs forward in an exulting gush of glorious despair to grapple with death and fate. In a truly noble bravery of soul, the interest is wholly the fruit of immortality; here is the Sodom-apple of mortality. In the one case we exult to see the infinite overshadow and dwarf the finite; in the other, we cannot restrain a kind of romantic enthusiasm and admiration at seeing the weak clay so gallantly defy the overwhelming power which it well knows must crush it. High genius may be fiery and impetuous, but it can never bully and look big; it does not defy death and futurity, for a doubt of its monarchy over them never over flushed its serene countenance. “john.—Shakespeare’s characters seem to modify his plots as they are modified by them in turn. This may be the result of his unapproachable art; for art in him is but the tracing of nature to her primordial laws; is but nature precipitated, as it were, by the infallible test of philosophy. In his plays, as in life, there is a perpetual seesaw of character and circumstance, now one uppermost, now the other. Nature is never afraid to reason in a circle. We must let her assume her premises, and make our deductions logical accordingly. The actors in Shakespeare’s dramas are only overcome by so much as they fall
4. George Chapman (ca. 1559–1634), English poet, dramatist, and translator of Homer. 5. John Ford (1586?–1640?), English dramatist.
[Review of Conversations on Some of the Old Poets]
39
below their ideal, and are wanting in some attribute of true manhood. Wherever we go with him, the absence of a virtue always suggests its presence; the want of any nobleness makes us feel its beauty the more keenly. “philip.—But Ford’s heroes are strong only in their imperfections, and it is to these that whatever admiration we yield them is paid. They interest us only so far as they can make us forget our quiet, calm ideal. This is the very stamp of weakness. We should be surprised if we saw them show any natural greatness. They are morbid and unhealthy, for, in truth, what we call greatness and nobleness is but entire health; to those only who are denaturalized themselves does it seem wonderful; to the natural man they are as customary and unconscious as the beating of his heart, of the motion of his lungs, as is necessary. Therefore it is that praise always surprises and humbles true genius; the shadow of earth then comes between them and their starry ideal with a cold and dark eclipse. In Ford’s characters, the sublimity, if there be any, is that of a defiant despair. ***** “A contemporary thus graphically describes him: “Deep in a dump John Ford was alone gat. With folded arms and melancholy hat.” A couplet which brings up the central figure on the title-page to the old edition of the “Anatomy of Melancholy” very vividly before our eyes. His dependence on things out of himself is shown also in his historical play of ‘Perkin Warback,’ in which, having no exciting plot to sustain him, he is very gentlemanly and very dull. He does not furnish so many isolated passages which are complete in themselves, a quality remarkable in the old dramatists, among whom only Shakespeare united perfectness of the parts with strict adaptation and harmony of the whole. A play of Shakespeare’s seems like one of those basilican palaces whose roof is supported by innumerable pillars, each formed of many crystals perfect in themselves.”
But presently, when Mr. Lowell criticises in detail Ford’s tragedy of ‘The Broken Heart,’ in his remarks upon the beautiful scene between Orgilus and Penthea, he seems quite undiscerning as to the feelings of Penthea and the motives which induce her to act as she does. Also in what he says of Calantha’s “saving up her heart-break, as it were, until it can come in with proper effect at the end of the tragedy”; though there is some truth in his remarks, he seems to leave out of sight the main-spring of the character, a greatness which Ford had the soul to feel was proper to the heroic character, and which very unheroic persons have been able to feel through him; the property, I mean, of
40
[Review of Conversations on Some of the Old Poets]
being unexpectedly equal to anguish and horror, in proportion to their assault. The mind of Calantha rose instantaneously to the occasion, and like the Roman, when the drop too much came in the cup, she gave no groan, but folded the robe over her breast, and “died smiling.” Indeed, we should dispute many of Mr. Lowell’s criticisms in detail, and are seldom entirely pleased with them; but newspaper limits do not allow of such an examination. Neither does he challenge it; he does not profess to give the results of long acquaintance through varied moods, which, with books as with living acquaintances, can alone enable us to give even as just an estimate as our imperfections permit, the sum total of our best judgment,— “All the false values gone.”
But he offers the flowing mood of the day, and he who does not value it as clarified criticism, may find his profit in it for the companionship of stimulus and suggestion. He says very well, “We do not agree, nor should we be pleasant companions if we did. This would be a dull world indeed if all our opinions must beveln to one standard; when all our hearts do, we shall see blue sky and not sooner.”6
Two points he seems to labor unnecessarily. If he addresses a very ignorant audience, he talks too finely for them; if a cultivated one, he will find such truths recognized far more distinctly than he states them. 1st. That the principles which pervade the Fine Arts are identical, and that nothing but partial organization prevents any man who traces them in one from tracing them in all. The subject is one of such profound interest that the discernment of new analogies is always interesting. It pleases us to hear Architecture called “frozen music,”7 or to know that the dimensions of a pillar may be estimated by the tension of chords, but it is merely that we take pleasure in the application of recognized principles; recognized, we mean, by all the thinking part of the world now. 2d. In what he says of metres, Mr. Lowell does not do justice to the poetic facts. The reasons he gives are inadequate. It is true, as he says, that the mind (bend?) [ bevel See note 6 6. The Tribune reading of “(bend?)” is probably a compositor’s query about Fuller’s handwriting; Lowell’s text has “bevel.” 7. Emerson calls architecture “frozen music” in the “Discipline” chapter of Nature.
[Review of Conversations on Some of the Old Poets]
41
rises from prose into poetic measure quite naturally, as from speech to song, when it has something to express above the level of the lower necessities of life. It is true that rhythm cannot more easily be disengaged from the poetic thought expressed in it than the skin from the pulp of the grape. But this is not merely because it holds it together “in a compact and beautiful form.” Metres themselves are actually something apart from the thought they are destined to convey. They are the music of that thought; its more or less perfect organization. Madame de Stael was not wrong in receiving a high delight from the mere cadence of verses that she did not understand.8 As the same thought is expressed in all Gothic Cathedrals, but with peculiar force in that at Cologne, so may the same thought be expressed with equal distinctness in two metres, but with more force in one than the other. Just so two faces may look on you with love and you may translate the meaning of either look—Love—but one will be full-fraught with soul, and will express the beauty of love, the other not. The charms of metres are subtle and more deeply grounded than the obvious meaning of the words; their analysis is not impossible, but it requires as clear a knowledge of the laws of harmony, i.e. of proportion, as delicate a sense of the subtle efficacy of thoughts, i.e. of spiritual gradation, as the analysis of what are more strictly styled musical compositions does; therefore, while many men are too dully organized to feel their power, a larger proportion of those who can feel cannot render a reason. Let us put from us, once for all, the vulgar frivolity of assuming that that does not exist for which we cannot yet render a reason. Let us hear, with joyous hope, deep calling unto deep, where our steps may not yet venture. It is needless to recommend Mr. Lowell’s book to general reading, as the extensive popularity of his Poems has made his name a sufficient passport. Review of James Russell Lowell, Conversations on Some of the Old Poets (Cambridge: John Owen, 1845). New-York Daily Tribune, 21 January 1845, p. 1; reprinted, New-York Weekly Tribune, 25 January 1845, p. 1. Title supplied. Lowell would later caricature Fuller in his A Fable for Critics (1848) as Miranda, with an “I-turn-the-crank-of-the-Universe air”. 8. Madame de Staël (1766–1817), French novelist and social critic.
Edgar A. Poe
Graham’s Magazine, February 1845. This number of Graham’s Magazine has a likeness of Edgar A. Poe, with a critique upon that critic and a brief outline of his career thus far, by James Russell Lowell.1 This article is frank, earnest, and contains many just thoughts, expressed with force and point. We quote the following: “Talent may make friends for itself, but only genius can give to its creations the divine power of winning love and veneration. Enthusiasm cannot cling to what itself is unenthusiastic, nor will he ever have disciples, who has not himself impulsive zeal enough to be a disciple. Great wits are allied to madness only inasmuch as they are possessed and carried away by their demon, while talent keeps him, as Paracelsus did, securely prisoned in the pommel of his sword. To the eye of genius, the veil of the spiritual world is ever rent asunder, that it may perceive the ministers of good and evil that throng continually round it. No man of mere talent ever flung his inkstand at the devil.” * * “In judging of the merit of an author, and assigning him his niche among our household gods, we have a right to regard him from our own point of view, and to measure him by our own standard.—But in estimating his works, we must be governed by his own design, and, placing them by the side of his own ideal, find how much is wanting.”
Among the poems quoted from Mr. Poe, before unknown to ourselves, two please us so much, that they must be inserted here. The first must have been copied, on every side; yet we may introduce it to the eye of some whom it might otherwise escape;
1. The article on Poe in the February 1845 Graham’s Magazine by James Russell Lowell has been widely reprinted.
42
“Edgar A. Poe”
the haunted palace. In the greenest of our valleys, By good angels tenanted, Once a fair and stately palace— Radiant palace—rear’d its head. In the monarch Thought’s dominion— It stood there! Never seraph spread a pinion Over fabric half so fair! Banners yellow, glorious, golden, On its roof did float and flow, (This—all this—was in the olden Time, long ago,) And every gentle air that dallied, In that sweet day, Along the ramparts plumed and pallid, A winged odor went away. Wanderers in that happy valley, Through two luminous windows, saw Spirits moving musically, To a lute’s well-tuned law, Round about a throne where, sitting (Porphyrogene!) In state his glory well befitting, The ruler of the realm was seen. And all with pearl and ruby glowing Was the fair palace door, Through which came flowing, flowing, flowing, And sparkling evermore, A troop of Echoes, whose sweet duty Was but to sing, In voices of surpassing beauty, The wit and wisdom of their king. But evil things, in robes of sorrow, Assail’d the monarch’s high estate. (Ah, let us mourn!—for never morrow Shall dawn upon him desolate!) And round about his home the glory
43
44
“Edgar A. Poe”
That blush’d and bloom’d, Is but a dim-remember’d story Of the old time entomb’d. And travelers now, within that valley, Through the red litten windows see Vast forms, that move fantastically To a discordant melody, While, like a ghastly rapid river, Through the pale door, A hideous throng rush out for ever, And laugh—but smile no more.
But, to us, still more interesting is the poem written at the age of fourteen,2 of such distinguished beauty in thought, feeling, and expression, that we might expect the life unfolded from such a bud to have the sweetness and soft lustre of a rose: to helen. Helen, thy beauty is to me Like those Nicéan barks of yore, That gently, o’er a perfum’d sea, The weary, way-worn wanderer bore To his own native shore. On desperate seas long wont to roam, Thy hyacinth hair, thy classic face, Thy Naiad airs have brought me home To the glory that was Greece And the grandeur that was Rome. Lo! in yon brilliant window-niche How statue-like I see thee stand! The agate lamp within thy hand, Ah! Psyche, from the regions which Are Holy Land!
A person of fine perceptions, and unacquainted with the writings of Mr. Poe, observed, on looking at this head of him, that the lower part of the face 2. The story, started in 1831 by a magazine editor, that Poe wrote “To Helen” at the age of fourteen, is unfounded.
“Edgar A. Poe”
45
is that of the critic, cold, hard, and self-sufficient; while the upper part, especially the brows, expresses great feeling, and tenderness of feeling. We wish the “Psyche” had taken him far enough in that “Nicéan bark,” to give the expression of the upper part of the face a larger preponderance than we find in his reviews of the poets. New-York Daily Tribune, 24 January 1845, p. 1; reprinted, New-York Weekly Tribune, 1 February 1845, p. 2. Edgar Allan Poe (1809–49), poet, short-story writer, and journalist. Not only did Fuller and Poe joust in print (see the sketch of her in his “Literati of New York City” series in the August 1846 Godey’s Magazine and Lady’s Book), but she personally helped to retrieve letters written him by a female friend.
This page intentionally left blank
[Review of Lydia H. Sigourney, Scenes in My Native Land]
This is a book that will have a permanent value as a traveling companion. It is written in a very plain and natural manner, and with good taste and feeling, giving, with regard to the places described, just those leading facts that the visitor desires to know. Those which relate to Monte-Video—Huguenot Fort—the Charter Oak at Hartford—the Moravian settlements at Bethlehem and Nazareth—and the story from the Vale of Wyoming, were the most interesting to ourselves. We extract a part of Huguenot Fort as a fair specimen of the book:
huguenot fort, At Oxford, Massachusetts. I stood upon a breezy hight, and marked The rural landscape’s charms; fields thick with corn, And new-mown grass that bathed the ruthless scythe With a forgiving fragrance, even in death Blessing its enemies; and broad-armed trees Fruitful, or dense with shade or crystal streams That cheered their sedgy banks. But at my feet Were vestiges that turned the thoughts away From all this summer beauty. Moss-clad stones That formed their fortress, that in earlier days Sought refuge here, from their own troubled clime, And from the madness of a tyrant king, Were strewed around. Methinks, yon wreck stands forth Is rugged strength once more, and firmly guards From the red Indian’s shaft, those sons of France, Of purple vintage, found but welcome cold 46
[Review of Scenes in My Native Land]
From thee, my native land! The wintry moan Of wind-swept forests, and the appaling frown Of icy floods. Yet didst thou leave them free To strike the sweet harp of the secret soul, And this was all their wealth. For this they blest Thy trackless wilds, and ’neath their lowly roof At morn and night, or with the murmuring swell Of stranger waters, blent their hymn of praise ––––– Green Vine! That mantlest in thy fresh embrace Yon old, grey rock, I hear that thou with them Didst brave the ocean surge Say drank thy germ The dews of Languedoc? or slow uncoiled As infant fibre, ’mid the fruitful mould Of smiling Rouseillon? or didst thou shrink From the fierce footsteps of a warlike train, Brother with brother fighting unto death, At fair Rochelle? Hast thou no tale for me? ––––– Methought its broad leaves shivered in the gale, With whispered words. There was a gentle form, A fair, young creature, who at twilight hour Oft brought me water, and would kindly raise My drooping head. Her eyes were dark and soft, As the gazelle’s, and well I knew her sigh Was tremulous with love. For she had left One in her own fair land, with whom her heart From childhood had been twined. Oft by her side, What time the youngling moon went up the sky, Conquering with silvery beam their woven bower; He strove to win her to the faith he held, Speaking of heresy with flashing eye, Yet with such blandishment of tenderness, As more than argument dissolveth doubt With a young pupil, in the school of love. Even then, sharp lightening quivered through the gloom Of persecution’s cloud, and soon its storm
47
48
[Review of Scenes in My Native Land]
Burst on the Huguenots Their churches fell, Their pastors fed the dungeon or the rack; And ’mid each household-group, grim soldiers sat, In frowning espionage, troubling the sleep Of infant innocence. Stern war burst forth; And civil conflict on the soil of France Wrought fearful things. The peasant’s blood was plowed In, with the wheat to be planted, while from cliffs That overhung the sea, from caves and dens The hunted worshippers were madly driven, Out, ’neath the smiling sabbath skies, and slain, The anthem on their tongues. The coast was thronged With hapless exiles, and that dark-haired maid, Leading her little sister in the steps Of their afflicted parents, hasting left The meal uneaten, and the table spread In their sweet cottage, to return no more. The lover held her to his heart, and prayed That from her erring people she would turn To the true fold of Christ, for so he deemed That ancient Church, for which his breast was clad In soldier’s panoply. But she, with tears Like Niobe, a never ceasing flood, Drew her soft hand from his, and dared the deep. And so, as years sped on, with patient brow She bare the burdens of the wilderness, His image, and an everlasting prayer Within her soul. And when she sank away, As fades the lily when the day is done, There was a deep-drawn sigh, and unpraised glance Of earnest supplication, that the hearts Severed so long might join, where bigot zeal Should find no place. She hath a quiet bed Beneath you turf, and an unwritten name
[Review of Scenes in My Native Land]
On earth, which sister angels speak in heaven. ––––– Vine of Rousaillon! Tell me other tales Of that high-hearted race, who for the sake Of conscience, made those western wilds their home? How to their door the prowling savage stole, Staining their hearth-stone with the blood of babes, And as the Arab strikes his fragile tent Making the desert lonely, how they left Their infant Zion with a mournful heart To seek a safer home? Fain would I sit Beside this ruined fort and muse of them Mingling their features with their humble verse, Whom many of the noblest of our land Claim as their honored sires. On all who bear Their name, or lineage, may their mantle rest, That firmness for the truth, that calm content With simple pleasures, that unswerving trust In toil, adversity and death, which cast Such healthful leaven ’mid the elements That peopled this New World. ––––– When Louis XIV, by the revocation of the Edict of Nantz, scattered the rich treasure of the hearts of more than half a million of subjects to foreign climes, this Western World profited by his mad prodigality. Among the wheat with which its newly broken surface was sown, none was more purely sifted than that which France thus cast away. Industry, integrity, moderated desires, piety without austerity, and the sweetest domestic charities, were among the prominent characteristics of the exiled people. Among the various settlements made by the Hugueno’s, at different periods upon our shores, that at Oxford, in Massachusetts, has the priority in point of time. In 1686, thirty families with their clergyman, landed at Fort Hill, in Boston. There they found kind reception and entertainment, until ready to proceed to their destined abode. This was at Oxford, in Worcester County, where an area of 12,000 acres was secured by them from the township of eight miles square which had been laid out by Governor Dudley. The appearance of the country, though uncleared, was pleasant to those who counted as their chief wealth, “freedom to worship God.” They gave the name
49
50
[Review of Scenes in My Native Land]
of French River to a stream, which, after diffusing fertility around their new home, becomes a tributary of the Quinabaug, in Connecticut, and finally merged in the Thames, passing on to Long Island Sound. Being surrounded by the territory of the Nipmug Indians, their first care was to build a fort, as a refuge from savage aggression. Gardens were laid out in its vicinity, and stocked with the seeds of vegetables and fruits, brought from their own native soil. Mills were also erected, and ten or twelve years of persevering industry, secured many comforts to the colonists, who were much respected in the neighboring settlements and acquired the right of representation in the Provincial Legislature. But this tribe of Indians by whom they were encompassed, had, from the beginning, met with a morose and intractable spirit their proffered kindnesses. A sudden, and wholly unexpected incursion, with the massacre of one of the emigrants and his children, caused the breaking up of the peaceful little settlement, and the return of its inmates to Boston. Friendships formed there on their first arrival, and the hospitality that has ever distinguished that beautiful city, turned the hearts of the Huguenots towards it as a refuge, in this, their second exile. This reception, and the continuance of their names among the most honored of its inhabitants, proved that the spot was neither ill chosen, nor uncongenial. Here, their excellent pastor, Father Pierre Dulle, died in 1715. His epitaph, and that of his wife, are still legible in the “Granary Burying Ground.” He was succeeded by Mr. Andrew LeMerier, author of a history of Geneva. Their place of worship was in School street, and known by the name of the French Protestant Church. About the year 1713, Oxford was resettled by a stronger body of colonists, able to command more military aid; and thither, in process of time, a few of the Huguenot resorted, and made their abode in those lovely and retired vales.
Some pleasing anecdotes follow of traditions related to the author by descendants of these Huguenot families. In mentioning visits during childhood to the burial-place of the Mohegans near Norwich, these interesting particulars were given of the last rest of “the last of the Mohegans.” Seated there, as we returned from school at the close of a summer-day, loaded with our books, and sometimes with the baskets which had contained our noon-repast, we read the simple inscriptions on the rude grave-stones, and listened to the moan of the cataract, as it stole, softened by distance, to that solitary and not uncongenial recess. One of these epitaphs used especially to attract our attention. It was com-
[Review of Scenes in My Native Land]
51
posed at the request of the Indians, by Dr. Tracy, a highly respected physician, whose philanthropy was often called into exercise, for the red-browed race. “Here lies Samuel Uncas, the second and beloved son of his father, John Uncas, who was the grandson of Uncas, Grand Sachem. He died July 31st, 1741, in the 28th year of his age. For beauty, wit, and sterling sense, For temper mild, and eloquence, For courage bold, and things waureegan He was the glory of Mohegan, Whose death hath caused great lamentation, Both to the English and the Indian nation.” The term ‘waureegan,’ in the language of our Indian neighbors, signifies ‘good things,’ or praiseworthy conduct. Some writers have translated it as ‘good tidings,’ or costly apparel; but this is not conformable to the usage of the Mohegans. Over another mossy stone, the little critics sometimes paused, thinking that the close of its inscription possessed wonderful force and simplicity. “In memory of young Seasar Jonus, who died April 30th, 1749, in the 28th year of his age. And he was cousin to Uncas.” The latest interment in this royal cemetery, was that of Mazeen, about twenty years since, the last man in whose veins flowed the royal blood of Mohegan. He was in the 28th year of his age, and deeply mourned by his people. That tribe, in all conveyances of land to the white people, strenuously reserved this sacred sepulchral ground.
The coincidence of all these deaths in the 28th year of the age has an air somewhat Homeric and solemn. The following particulars are related of Samuel Wyllys,1 the gentleman who owned the ground on which the Charter Oak grew: “By his virtuous and dignified deportment, he acquired great influence over the Indians, whose wigwams were thickly planted in the great meadows toward the south-east, and along the margin of Connecticut river. When their midnight carousals arose to such a point that a quarrel might be apprehended, he often stilled their uproar, and sent them affrighted to their homes, by a few words uttered from his open window through a speaking-trumpet in the name
1. Samuel Wyllys (1632–1709), Connecticut magistrate, owned the ground on which grew the Charter Oak, so called because it once held the state’s constitution when that document was threatened.
52
[Review of Scenes in My Native Land]
of their Great Spirit. Such was the security and confidence in the honesty of the people, in which that honorable and wealthy family dwelt, that till within sixty years, a large silver cup was left unharmed by a well, for the accommodation of all, who in passing through the premises might wish to taste of its waters.”
That is a romantic picture of Hon. Mr. Wyllys bidding the Indians, scattered over the broad meadows, good night, through his speaking-trumpet. In contrast with the love of ravage which distinguishes the American settler and which makes the marks of his first passage over this land, like those of corrosive acid upon the cheek of beauty, rather than that smile of intelligence which would ensue from the touch of an intelligent spirit, Mrs. S. observes: “It seems almost a wickedness, wantonly to smite down a vigorous healthful tree. It was of God’s planting, and in its veins is circulating the life which He has given.”
We have often marveled to see the Reformers who weary every one by their protest against violence done to life in the animal kingdom, coolly hewing down and heaping on the hearth trunks that half a century had been required to rear, trunks of trees, the home of birds, and the fairest monuments of earth’s devotion. We suppose that the hatred of our people for trees is from a feeling that they are symbols of a wilderness to be conquered; and inherited from a time when each was a shield or hiding place for an Indian foe. But it is time that the barbarous form of this prejudice should give place. With it contrast the Old English feeling: “The reverence of our ancestors, in England, for trees, is well known. It is not uncommon in some of their parks, to observe by a clump of fine trees, a stone monument, recording when and by whom it was planted; thus coupling the name of the founder with these masses of umbrageous foliage which deepen as ages pass by.”
We may be sure, if we do not resume some of this old Druidical veneration for trees, no oak will bear for us the sacred mistletoe, emblem of the purest thoughts. The mention of a taste for art, as developed in the creation of scarecrows at Fonda and Johnstown, is pretty:
[Review of Scenes in My Native Land]
53
“Something of the kind is often seen in New-England among planted fields or loaded cherry trees, but not worthy to be compared with these in device or execution. Here were parti-colored pennons, broad white flags, long ropes hung with bright tin filings, and braided wisps of straw, flapping in every breeze; stuffed boys, with one foot raised as in the act of ascension; men in full vigor, brandishing the semblance of a fowling-piece, or some other nondescript weapons; aged sires, with uplifted brow, in an attitude of supplication. Surely some incipient Chantry must ennoble this region!”
It is, indeed, pleasing to see among our people some of the Greek spirit that leads to turn the common occasions of life to themes of fancy, and something like a love of creation. We marked several parts of this book for comment, but our limits, at present, forbid this.—Only one thing we must speak of,—the apologetic tone for hours passed in the contemplation of natural beauty, and the assumption of calling such a person as the hermit of Niagara “erring brother,” because he sequestered some part of his life to this purpose. We have no patience with all this sort of remark, which so strongly marks a gross materialist tendency in our time and place. Mrs. Sigourney does not share it, but is so often conversant with those who do, that she is led to speak of those pure natural enjoyments, meant by Heaven for a great means of education to man for his proper place in his universe in this dubious or apologetic tone. Let those “erring brethren” apologize who spend their lives in gossip, or money-making; not those who think it worth while to devote some hours to sympathy with the glories that surround them. Is it such a fault, then, to take a little time from the service of Mammon? What do you mean by your “social duties?” What are they good for, except to educate the soul to worship? This mania as to “social duties,” is so fostered among us that for any one to pass a day alone in contemplation of the most sublime work of the Great Spirit is enough to make him pointed or jeered at as “crazy” or (more deadly stigma, it would seem,) “peculiar.” My friends! angels and poets are peculiar; and to be gregarious is not the way to be social. Good society can only be composed of intelligent and devout men. Review of Lydia H. Sigourney, Scenes in My Native Land (Boston: James Munroe, 1845). New-York Daily Tribune, 28 January 1845, p. 1; reprinted, New-York Weekly Tribune, 1 February 1845, p. 1. Title supplied. Lydia Howard Huntley Sigourney (1791–1865), poet and lady of letters.
French Novelists of the Day: Balzac . . . . . . . George Sand . . . . . . . Eugene Sue
This thirteenth number of the “Wandering Jew,” just published by Winchester,1 has delivered us from our anxieties as to the objects of Jesuit persecution, though by a coup de main clumsier than is usual even with Sue. Now, we have matters arranged for a few months more of contest with the Society of Jesus, but we think our author must depend for interest during the last volume, no longer on the conduct of the plot, but on the portraiture of characters. It is cheering to know how great is the influence such a writer as Sue exerts, from his energy of feeling on some objects of moral interest. It is true that he has also much talent and a various experience of life; but writers who far surpass him here, as we think Balzac does, wanting this heart of faith, have no influence, except merely on the tastes of their readers. We hear much lamentation among good people at the introduction of so many French novels among us, corrupting, they say, our youth by pictures of decrepit vice and prurient crime, such as would never, otherwise, be dreamed of here, and corrupting it the more that such knowledge is so precocious—for the same reason that a boy may be more deeply injured by initiation into wickedness than a man, for he is not only robbed of his virtue, but prevented from developing the strength that might restore it. But it is useless to bewail what is the inevitable result of the movement of our time. Europe must pour her corruptions, no less than her riches, on our shores, both in the form of books and of living men. She cannot, if she would, check the tide which bears them hitherward; no defenses are possible, on our vast extent of shore, that can preclude their ingress. We have exulted in premature and hasty growth; we must brace ourselves to bear the evils that ensue. Our only hope lies in rousing, in our own community, a soul of goodness, a wise aspiration, that shall give us strength to assimilate this unwholesome food to better substance, or 1. The Wandering Jew, translated by H. W. Herbert, was published by J. Winchester in nineteen parts between 1844 and 1845.
54
“French Novelists of the Day”
55
cast off its contaminations. A mighty sea of life swells within our nation, and, if there be salt enough, foreign bodies shall not have power to breed infection there. We have had some opportunity to observe that the worst works offered are rejected. On the steamboats we have seen translations of vile books, bought by those who did not know from the names of their authors what to expect, torn, after a cursory glance at their contents, and scattered to the winds. Not even the all but all-powerful desire to get one’s money’s worth, since it had once been paid, could contend against the blush of shame that rose on the cheek of the reader. It would be desirable for our people to know something of these writers and of the position they occupy abroad; for the nature of their circulation, rather than its extent, might be the guide both to translator and buyer. The object of the first is generally money—of the last, amusement. But the merest mercenary might prefer to pass his time in translating a good book, and our imitation of Europe does not yet go so far that the American milliner can be depended on to copy any thing from the Parisian grisette, except her cap. One of the most unexceptionable and attractive writers of modern France is de Vigny.2 His life has been passed in the Army, but many years of peace have given him time for literary culture, while his acquaintance with the traditions of the Army, from the days of its dramatic achievements under Bonaparte,3 suppliesn the finest materials both for narrative and reflection. His tales are written with infinite grace, refined sensibility, and a dignified view. His treatment of a subject shows that closeness of grasp and clearness of sight which are rarely attained by one who is not at home in active as well as thoughtful life. He has much penetration, too, and has touched some of the most delicate springs of human action. His works have been written in hours of leisure; this has diminished their number but given him many advantages over the thousands of professional writers that fill the coffee houses of Paris by day, and its garrets by night. We wish he were more read here in the original: with him would be found good French, and the manners, thoughts, and feelings of a cosmopolite gentleman. We have seen, with pleasure, one or two of his tales translated into the pages of the Democratic Review. But the three who have been and will be most read here, as they occupy the
2. Alfred Victor, Count de Vigny (1799–1863), French poet, dramatist, and novelist. 3. Napoleon Bonaparte (1769–1821), French general and ruler. supply [ supplies
56
“French Novelists of the Day”
first rank in their own country, are Balzac, George Sand, and Eugene Sue. Balzac has been a very fruitful writer, and as he is fond of juggler’s tricks of every description, and holds nothing earnest or sacred, he is vain of the wonderful celerity with which some of his works, and those quite as good as any, have been written. They seem to have been conceived, composed and written down with that degree of speed with which it is possible to lay pen to paper. Indeed, we think he cannot be surpassed in the ready and sustained command of his resources. His almost unsurpassed quickness and fidelity of eye, both as to the disposition of external objects, and the symptoms of human passion, combined with a strong memory, have filled his mind with materials, and we doubt not that if his thoughts could be put into writing with the swiftness of thought, he would give us one of his novels every week in the year. Here end our praises of Balzac; what he is, as a man, in daily life, we know not.n He must originally have had a heart, or he could not read so well the hearts of others; perhaps there are still private ties that touch him. But as a writer, never was the modern Mephistopheles, “the spirit that denieth,” more worthily represented than by Balzac. He combines the spirit of the man of science, with that of the amateur collector. He delights to analyze, to classify; there is no anomaly too monstrous, no specimen too revolting, to ensure his ardent, but passionless scrutiny. But then—he has taste and judgment to know what is fair, rare and exquisite. He takes up such an object carefully and puts it in a good light. But he has no hatred for what is loathsome, no contempt for what is base, no love for what is lovely, no faith in what is noble. To him there is no virtue and no vice; men and women are more or less finely organized; noble and tender conduct is more agreeable than the reverse, because it argues better health; that is all. Nor is this from an intellectual calmness, nor from an unusual power of analyzing motives, and penetrating delusions merely; neither is it mere indifference. There is a touch of the demon, also, in Balzac; the cold but gayly familiar demon, and the smile of the amateur yields easily to a sneer, as he delights to show you on what foul juices the fair flower was fed. He is a thorough and willing materialist. The trance of Religion is congestion of the brain; the joy of the Poet the thrilling of the blood in the rapture of sense; and every good not only rises from, but hastens back into, the jaws of death and nothingness: a rainbow arch above a pestilential chaos! Thus Balzac, with all his force and fulness of talent, never rises one moment not, He [ not. He
“French Novelists of the Day”
57
into the region of genius. For genius is, in its nature, positive and creative, and cannot exist where there is no heart to believe in realities. Neither can he have a permanent influence on a nature which is not thoroughly corrupt. He might for a while stagger an ingenuous mind which had not yet thought for itself. But this could not last. His unbelief makes his thought too shallow. He has not that power which a mind, only in part sophisticated, may retain, where the heart still beats warmly, though it sometimes beats amiss. Write, paint, argue, as you will, where there is a sound spot in any human being, he cannot be made to believe that this present bodily frame is more than a temporary condition of his being, though one to which he may have become shamefully enslaved by fault of inheritance, education, or his own carelessness. Taken in his own way, we know no modern tragedies more powerful than Balzac’s “Eugenie Grandet,” “Sweet Pea,” “Search after the Absolute,” “Father Goriot.” See there goodness, aspiration, the loveliest instincts, stifled, strangled by fate, in the form of our own brute nature—The fate of the ancient Prometheus was happiness to that of these who must pay for ever having believed there was divine fire in Heaven, by agonies of despair, and conscious degradation, unknown to those who began by believing man to be the most richly endowed of brutes—no more! Balzac is admirable in his description of look, tone, gesture. He has a keen sense of whatever is peculiar to the individual. Nothing in modern romance surpasses the death-scene of Father Goriot, the Parisian Lear, in the almost immortal life with which the parental instincts are displayed. And with equal precision and delicacy of shading he will paint the slightest by play in the manners of some young girl. “Seraphitus” is merely a specimen of his great powers of intellectual transposition. Amid his delight at the botanical riches of the new and elevated region in which he is traveling, we catch, if only by echo, the hem and chuckle of the French materialist. No more of him!—We leave him to his suicidal work. An entirely opposite character, in every leading trait, yet bearing traces of the same influences, is the celebrated George Sand. It is probably known to a great proportion of readers that this writer is a woman, who writes under the name of and frequently assumes the dress and manners of a man. It is also known that she has not only broken the marriage bond, and, since that, formed other connections independent of the civil or ecclesiastical sanction, but that she first rose into notice through works which systematically assailed the present institution of marriage and the social bonds which are connected with it.
58
“French Novelists of the Day”
No facts are more adapted to startle every feeling of our community; but, since the works of Sand are read here, notwithstanding, and cannot fail to be so while they exert so important an influence abroad, it would be well they should be read intelligently, as to the circumstances of their birth, and their tendency. George Sand we esteem to be a person of strong passions, but of original nobleness and a love of right sufficient to guide them all to the service of aims. But she fell upon evil times. She was given in marriage according to the fashion of the old regime; she was taken from a convent where she had heard a great deal about the law of God and the example of Jesus, into a society where no vice was proscribed, if it would wear the cloak of hypocrisy. She found herself impatient of deception, and loudly called by passion: she yielded; but she could not do so, as others did, sinning against what she owned to be the rule of right, and the will of Heaven. She protested; she examined; she assailed. She “hacked into the roots of things,” and the bold sound of her axe called around her every foe that finds a home amid the growths of civilization. Still she persisted. “If it be real,” thought she, “it cannot be destroyed; as to what is false, the sooner it goes the better; and I, for one, had rather perish beneath its fall than wither in its shade.” Schiller4 puts into the mouth of Mary Stuart these words as her only plea: “The world knows the worst of me; and I may boast that, though I have erred, I am better than my reputation.” Sand may say the same. All is open, noble; the free descriptions, the sophistry of passion are, at least, redeemed by a desire for truth as strong as ever beat in any heart. To the weak or unthinking the reading of such books may not be desirable, for only those who take exercise as men can digest strong meat. But to anyone able to understand the position and circumstances, we believe this reading cannot fail of bringing good impulses, valuable suggestions, and it is quite free from that subtle miasma which taints so large a portion of French literature, not less since the Revolution than before. This we say to the foreign reader. To her own country Sand is a boon precious and prized, both as a warning and a leader, for which none there can be ungrateful. She has dared to probe its festering wounds, and if they be not past all surgery, she is one who, most of any, helps toward a cure. Would, indeed, the surgeon had come with quite clean hands! A woman of Sand’s genius, as free, as bold, and pure from even the suspicion of error, might have filled an apostolic station among her people. Then with what force had 4. Johann Christoph Friedrich von Schiller (1759–1805), German philosopher.
“French Novelists of the Day”
59
come her cry, “If it be false, give it up; but, if it be true, keep to it—one or the other!” But we have read all we wish to say upon this subject, lately uttered just from the quarter we could wish. It is such a woman, so unblemished in character, so high in aim, and pure in soul, that should address this other, as noble in nature, but clouded by error, and struggling with circumstances. It is such women that will do such justice. They are not afraid to look for virtue and reply to aspiration, among those who have not ‘dwelt in decencies for ever.’ It is a source of pride and happiness to read this address from the heart of Elizabeth Barrett: to george sand. A Desire. Thou large-brained woman and large-hearted man, Self-called George Sand! whose soul, amid the lions Of thy tumultuous senses moans defiance, And answers roar for roar, as spirits can: I would some mild miraculous thunder ran Above th’ applauded circus, in appliance Of thine own nobler nature’s strength and science, Drawing two pinions, white as wings of swan, From the strong shoulders, to amaze the place With holier light! that thou to woman’s claim, And man’s, might join, beside, the angel’s grace Of a pure genius sanctified from blame; Till child and maiden pressed to thine embrace, To kiss upon thy lips a stainless fame.
to the same. A Recognition True genius, but true woman! dost deny Thy woman’s nature with a manly scorn, And break away the gauds and armlets worn By weaker women in captivity? Ah, vain denial! that revolted cry Is sobbed in by a woman’s voice forlorn:— Thy woman’s hair, my sister, all unshorn, Floats back disheveled strength in agony,
60
“French Novelists of the Day”
Disproving thy man’s name, and while before The world thou burnest in a poet-fire, We see thy woman-heart beat evermore Through the large flame. Beat purer, heart, and higher, Till God unsex thee on the spirit shore; To which alone unsexing, purely aspire.
This last sonnet seems to have been written after seeing the picture of Sand, which represents her in a man’s dress, but with long, loose hair, and an eye whose mournful fire is impressive even in the caricatures. For some years Sand has quitted her post of assailant. She has seen that it is better to seek some form of life worthy to supersede the old, than rudely to destroy it, heedless of the future. Her force is bending towards philanthropic measures. She does not appear to possess much of the constructive faculty, and, though her writings command a great pecuniary compensation, and have a wide sway, it is rather for their tendency than their thought. She has reached no commanding point of view from which she may give orders to the advanced corps. She is still at work with others in the trench, though she works with more force than almost any. In power, indeed, Sand bears the palm above any of the Novelists. She is vigorous in conception, often great in the apprehension and the contrast of characters. She knows passion, as has been well hinted, at a white heat, when all the lower particles are remoulded by its power. Her descriptive talent is very great, and her poetic feeling exquisite. She wants but little of being a poet, but that little is indispensable. Yet she keeps us always hovering on the borders of the enchanted fields. She has, to a signal degree, that power of exact transcript from her own mind of which almost all writers fail. There is no veil, no half-plastic integument between us and the thought. We vibrate perfectly with it. This is her chief charm, and, next to it, is one in which we know no French writer that resembles her, except Rousseau,5 though he, indeed, is vastly her superior in it. This is, of concentrated glow. Her nature glows beneath the words, like fire beneath the ashes, deep;—deep! Her best works are unequal; in many parts written hastily, or carelessly, or with flagging spirits. They all promise far more than they perform; the work is not done masterly; she has not reached that point where a writer sits at the
5. Jean Jacques Rousseau (1712–78), French philosopher and one of the founders of romanticism.
“French Novelists of the Day”
61
helm of his own genius. Sometimes she plies the oar; sometimes she drifts. But what greatness she has is genuine; there is no tinsel of any kind, no drapery carefully adjusted or chosen gesture about her. May Heaven lead her, at last, to the full possession of her best self, in harmony with the higher laws of life! We are not acquainted with all her works, but among those we know, mention “La Roche Mauprat,” “André,” “Jacques,” “Les Sept Cordes de la Lyre,” and “Les Maitres Mosaistes” as representing her higher inspirations, her sincerity in expression, and her dramatic powers. They are full of faults; still they also show her scope and aim with some fairness, which those readers who chance at first on such of her books as “Leone Leoni,” may fail to find, or even such as “Simon” and “Spiridion,” though into the imperfect web of these are woven threads of pure gold. Such is the first impression made by the girl Fiamma as she appears before us, so noble, with the words “E l’onore;” such the thought in “Spiridion” of making the apparition the reward of virtue. The work she is now publishing, “Consuelo,” with its sequel “Baroness de Rudolstadt,” exhibit her genius poised on a firmer pedestal, breathing a serener air. Still it is faulty in conduct, and showsn some obliquity of vision. She has not reached the Interpreter’s house yet. But when she does, she will have clues to guide many a pilgrim whom one less tried, less tempted than herself, could not help on the way. Eugene Sue is a writer of far inferior powers, on the whole, to Sand, though he possesses some brilliant talents that she wants. His aims and modes are more external than hers;n he is not so deeply acquainted with his own nature, or with that of any other person. Like her, he began life in a corrupt society—struggled, doubted, half despaired; erred, apparently, himself, and feared there was no virtue and no truth; but is conquering now. We observe, in a late notice of Sue, that he began to write at quite mature age, at the suggestion of a friend. We should think it was so; that he was by nature intended for a practical man, rather than a writer. He paints all his characters from the practical point of view. As an observer, when free from exaggeration, he has as good an eye as Balzac, but he is far more rarely thus free, for, in temperament, he is unequal and sometimes muddy. But then he has the heart and faith that Balzac wants, yet is less enslaved by emotion than Sand, therefore he has made more impression on his time and place than either. We refer now to his later works; though show [ shows her’s; [ hers;
62
“French Novelists of the Day”
his earlier show much talent, yet his progress, both as a writer and thinker, has been so considerable that those of the last few years entirely eclipse his earlier essays. These latter works are the “Mysteries of Paris,” “Matilda,” and the “Wandering Jew,” which is now in course of publication. In these, he has begun and is continuing a crusade against the evils of a corrupt civilization which are inflicting such woes and wrongs upon his contemporaries. Sue, however, does not merely assail, but would build up. His anatomy is not intended to injure the corpse, or, like that of Balzac, to entertain the intellect merely. Earnestly he hopes to learn from it the remedies for disease and the conditions of health. Sue is a Socialist. He believes he sees the means by which the heart of mankind may be made to beat with one great hope, one love; and instinct with this thought, his tales of horror are not tragedies. This is the secret of the deep interest he has awakened in this country that he shares a hope which is, half unconsciously to herself, stirring all her veins. It is not so warmly out-spoken as in other lands, both because no such pervasive ills as yetn call loudly for redress, and because private conservation is here great, in proportion to the absence of authorized despotism. We are not disposed to quarrel with this; it is well for the value of new thoughts to be tested by a good deal of resistance. Opposition, if it does not preclude free discussion, is of use in educating men to know what they want. Only by intelligent men, exercised by thought and tried in virtue, can such measures as Sue proposes be carried out; and when such Associates present themselves in sufficient numbers, we have no fear but the cause of Association, in its grander forms, will have fair play in America.6 As a writer, Sue shows his want of a high kind of imagination by his unshrinking portraiture of physical horrors. We do not believe any man could look upon some things he describes and live. He is very powerful in his description of the workings of animal nature; especially when he speaks of them in animals merely, they have the simplicity of the lower kind with the more full expression of human nature. His pictures of women are of rare excellence, and it is observable that the more simple and pure the character is, the more justice he does to it. This shows that, whatever his career may have yet yet [ yet 6. François Marie Charles Fourier (1772–1837), French social thinker, whose idea on association (large communities called “phalanxes” in which each person had assigned roles) influenced the American communitarian movement. The experiment at Brook Farm (1841–47), for example, revised its constitution in 1845 to become the Brook Farm Phalanx.
“French Novelists of the Day”
63
been, his heart is uncontaminated. Men he does not describe so well, and fails entirely when he aims at one grand and simple enough for a great moral agent. His conceptions are strong, but in execution he is too melodramatic. Just compare his “Wandering Jew” with that of Beranger.7 The latter is as diamond compared with charcoal. Then, like all those writers who write in numbers that come out weekly or monthly, he abuses himself and his subject; he often must; the arrangement is false and mechanical. The attitude of Sue is at this moment imposing, as he stands, pen in hand— this his only weapon against an innumerable host of foes, the champion of poverty, innocence and humanity, against superstition, selfishness and prejudice. When his works are forgotten, and for all their strong points and brilliant decorations, they may ere long be forgotten, still the writer’s name shall be held in imperishable honor as the teacher of the ignorant, the guardian of the weak, a true Tribune for the people of his own time. To sum up this imperfect account of their merits, I see De Vigny, a retiring figure, the gentleman, the solitary thinker, but, in his way, the efficient foe of false honor, and superstitious prejudice. Balzac is the heartless surgeon, probing the wounds and describing the delirium of suffering men for the amusement of his students. Sand a grand, fertile, aspiring, but, in some measure, distorted and irregular nature. Sue a bold and glittering crusader, with endless ballads jingling in the silence of the night before the battle. They are much right and a good deal wrong; for instance, all, even Sand, who would lay down her life for the sake of truth, will let their virtuous characters practice stratagems, falsehood, and violence; in fact, do evil for the sake of good. They still show this taint of the old regime, and no wonder! La belle France has worn rouge so long that the purest mountain air will not, at once, or soon, restore the natural hues to her complexion. But they are fine figures, and all ruled by the onward spirit of the time. Led by that spirit, I see them moving on the troubled waters; they do not sink, and I trust they will find their way to the coasts where the new era will introduce new methods, in a spirit of nobler activity, wiser patience, and holier faith than the world has yet seen. Will Balzac also see that shore, or has he only broken away the bars that hindered others from setting sail? We do not know. When we read an expression of such lovely innocence as the letter of the little country maidens to their Parisian brother (in Father Goriot), we hope; but presently we see him sneering behind the mask, and we fear. Let Frenchmen speak to this. They 7. Pierre Jean de Béranger (1780–1857), French lyric poet.
64
“French Novelists of the Day”
know best what disadvantages a Frenchman suffers under, and whether it is possible Balzac be still alive, except in his eyes. Those, we know, are well alive. To read these or any foreign works fairly, the reader must understand the national circumstances under which they were written. To use them worthily, he must know how to interpret them for the use of the Universe. New-York Daily Tribune, 1 February 1845, p. 1; reprinted, New-York Weekly Tribune, 22 February 1845, p. 2. Honoré de Balzac (1799–1850), prolific French novelist; George Sand, Baroness Dudevant (1804–76), French author whose personal life scandalized Paris; Eugène Sue (1804–57), French novelist.
[Review of Richard Hildreth, The Slave; or, Memoirs of Archy Moore]
—“Leave wringing of your hands; peace: sit you down: And let me wring your heart; for so I shall, If it be made of penetrable stuff; If damned custom hath not brazed it so, That it be proof and bulwark against sense.” Hamlet.1
This narrative is written with a vigor, power of conduct in the plot, and in sketches of character, that would have given the author a high rank throughout this country, as a novelist, had not his theme been one calculated to waken hostility in many readers and fear in more. History will class it as one of the most remarkable and interesting productions of our time. It will not be forgotten, for the same allowance is to be made for the earnest devotion of the writer to the cause of an injured race, and for the necessity of bringing forward the principal features of abuse in order to develop his plan, with less interval of repose, and less alleviation from good than exists in fact. Still the picture, as a whole, is true to the life, and it not only is, but seems, true, for the writer is, evidently, raised above the need of pleading a cause and his determined convictions are based on knowledge. The tone is noble; in its calm, but heart-felt, respect for the claims of man reminding us of Godwin.2 With all its feeling, it is still more an intellectual expression. Passion, woe, distortion, and sophistry are seen, but seen from the intellectual point of view, and thus the sketch is made with a strong and steady hand, and shows the educated eye of manhood. Such productions have results upon the world, such as fierce invective and mechanical arrangements for the expression of opinion never can.
1. Hamlet, act 3, scene 4. 2. William Godwin (1756–1836), English philosopher and miscellaneous writer, brought the spirit of the French Revolution to Britain.
65
66
[Review of The Slave; or, Memoirs of Archy Moore]
Review of Richard Hildreth, The Slave; or, Memoirs of Archy Moore, 5th. ed., two volumes in one (Boston: Jordan, Swift and Wiley, 1845). New-York Daily Tribune, 4 February 1845, p. 1. Title supplied. Richard Hildreth (1807–65), historian and novelist, published the first edition of The Slave in 1836.
[Review of The Child’s Friend, ed. Eliza L. Follen]
There is no branch of literature that better deserves cultivation, and none that so little obtains it from worthy hands as this of Children’s books. It requires a peculiar development of the genius and sympathies, rare among the men of factitious life, who are not men enough to revive, with force and beauty, the thoughts and scenes of childhood. It is all idle to talk baby-talk, with malice prepense, and to give shallow accounts of deep things, thinking thereby to interest the child.—He does not like to be too much puzzled, but it is simplicity he wants and not silliness. We fancy, their angels, who are always waiting in the courts of our Father, smile, somewhat sadly, at the ignorance of those who would feed them on milk and water too long, and think it would be quite as well to give them a stone. There is too much among us of the French way of palming off false accounts of things on children to do them good, and showing nature to them in a magic lantern, “purified for the use of childhood,” and telling stories of good little girls, and sweet little girls, or brave little boys; oh! all so good! or so bad! and, above all, so little, and every thing about them so little!—Children, accustomed to move in full-sized apartments, and converse with full-grown men and women, do not need so much of this baby-house style in their literature. They like, or would like, if they could get them, better things much better. They like the “Arabian Nights,” and “Pilgrim’s Progress,” and “Bunyan’s Emblems,”1 and Shakspeare, and the “Iliad” and “Odyssey;” at least, they used to like them; and, if they do not now, it is because their taste has been injured by so many sugar-plums. The books that were written in the childhood of nations suit an uncorrupt childhood now. They are simple, picturesque, robust. Their moral is not forced, nor is the truth veiled with a well-meant, but 1. John Bunyan (1628–88), English nonconformist preacher and writer, published his Pilgrim’s Progress, an allegory of Christian life, in 1678, and Divine Emblems, or Temporal Things Spiritualised in 1686.
67
68
[Review of The Child’s Friend]
sure-to-fail, hypocrisy. Sometimes they are not moral at all, only free plays of the fancy and intellect. These, also, the child needs, just as the infant needs to stretch its limbs, and grasp at objects it cannot hold. We have become so fond of the moral that we forget the nature in which it must find its root; so fond of instruction, that we forget development. Where ballads, legends, and fairy-tales are moral, the morality is heart-felt; if instructive, it is from the healthy common sense of mankind, and not for the convenience of nursery rule, nor the “peace of schools and families.” O that winter! freezing, snow-laden winter, which slowly ushered in our eighth birthday.2—There, in the lonely farm-house, the day’s work done, and the bright wood fire a’ in a low, we were permitted to slide back the panel of the cupboard in the wall; most fascinating object still in our eyes, with which no stateliest alcoved library can vie; and there saw, neatly arranged on its two shelves, not, praised be our natal star! Peter Parley nor “A history of the good little boy that never took anything that did not belong to him;” but—the “Spectator,” “Telemachus,” “Goldsmith’s Animated Nature” and the “Iliad.”3 Forms of gods and heroes more distinctly seen and with eyes of nearer love then than now!—Our true Uncle, Sir Roger de Coverley,4 and ye, fair realms of Nature’s history whose pictures we tormented all grown persons to illustrate with more knowledge—still more, how we bless the chance that gave to us your great realities which life has daily helped us—helps us still, to interpret, instead of thin and baseless fictions that would, all this time, have hampered us although only with cobwebs. Children need some childish talk, some childish play, some childish books. But they also need, and need more, difficulties to overcome, and a sense of the vast mysteries which the progress of their intelligence shall aid them to unravel. This sense is naturally their delight, as it is their religion, and it must not be dulled by premature explanations, nor subterfuges of any kind. There has been too much of this lately. Miss Edgeworth is an excellent writer for children.5 She is a child herself as
2. Fuller spent the first part of 1818 living with her grandmother at Canton, Massachusetts. 3. Samuel Griswold Goodrich (1793–1860), editor and children’s writer, is said to have published over one hundred volumes under the name “Peter Parley”; the Spectator (1711–12, 1714), a topical English periodical edited by Joseph Addison (1672–1719) and Richard Steele (1672–1729); Telemachus, the son of Odysseus and Penelope, appears in the Odyssey; Oliver Goldsmith (1730?–74), poet, novelist, dramatist, and essayist, published History of the Earth and Animated Nature in 1774. 4. Sir Roger de Coverley, a character created as one of the supposed authors of the Spectator. 5. Maria Edgeworth (1767–1849), English novelist and writer for children.
[Review of The Child’s Friend]
69
she writes, nursed anew by her own genius. It is not by imitating but by reproducing childhood that the writer becomes its companion. Then, indeed, we have something especially good, for “Like wine, well-kept and long; Heady; nor harsh, nor strong; With each succeeding year is quaffed A richer, purer, mellower draught.”6
Miss Edgeworth’s grown people live naturally with the children; they do not talk to them continually about angels, or flowers, or blue riband, but about the things that interest themselves.—They do not force them forward nor keep them back. The relations are simple and honorable; all ages in the family seem at home under one roof and sheltered by one care. “The Juvenile Miscellany,” formerly published by Mrs. Child, was much and deservedly esteemed by children.7 It was a healthy, cheerful, natural and entertaining companion to them. “The Child’s Friend” is edited by Mrs. Follen, a lady admired and loved by a large circle of personal friends, best known to the public at large by a memoir of her husband worthy in its tone of the beauty of its subject. No task could have been more difficult: few have been fulfilled with such delicacy.—We think this periodical for children is, in some degree, obnoxious to the censure of too monotonously tender a manner, and too constant attention to the moral inference. We should prefer a larger proportion of the facts of natural or human history, and that they should speak for themselves. There are many good things in the work, and it is calculated to lead the child into the region of worthy resolve and liberal views. Among the contributions from other hands, we would notice a translation of Goethe’s excellent tale of “Ferdinand” and a story called “The Little Expecter,” which, if it betray too great a degree of intellectual consciousness for the free flow of fairy