IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control
IUTAM BOOKSERIES Volume 14 Series Editors G.M.L. Gladwell, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada R. Moreau, INPG, Grenoble, France Editorial Board J. Engelbrecht, Institute of Cybernetics, Tallinn, Estonia L.B. Freund, Brown University, Providence, USA A. Kluwick, Technische Universität, Vienna, Austria H.K. Moffatt, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK N. Olhoff, Aalborg University, Aalborg, Denmark K. Tsutomu, IIDS, Tokyo, Japan D. van Campen, Technical University Eindhoven, Eindhoven, The Netherlands Z. Zheng, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China
Aims and Scope of the Series The IUTAM Bookseries publishes the proceedings of IUTAM symposia under the auspices of the IUTAM Board.
For other titles published in this series, go to http:www.springer.com/series/7695
Marianna Braza Editors
•
Kerry Hourigan
IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control Proceedings of the IUTAM Symposium “Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control”, Corfu, Greece, 18–22 June 2007
123
Editors Marianna Braza Institut de Mécanique des Fluides de Toulouse Unité Mixte de Recherche CNRS 5502 Allée du Prof. Camille Soula 31400 Toulouse France
[email protected]
Kerry Hourigan Monash University Division of Biological Engineering Clayton VIC 3800 Australia
[email protected]
ISSN 1875-3507 e-ISSN 1875-3493 ISBN 978-1-4020-9897-0 e-ISBN 978-1-4020-9898-7 DOI 10.1007/978-1-4020-9898-7 Springer Dordrecht Heidelberg London New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2009928840 c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009 No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Preface
This Volume is the Proceedings of the IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and Their Control held in Corfu, Greece, 18–22 June 2007. This was the second IUTAM Symposium on this subject, following the symposium in Toulouse, in April 2002. The Symposium consisted of single plenary sessions with invited lectures, selected oral presentations, discussions on special topics and posters. The complete set of papers was provided to all participants at the meeting. The thematic sessions of this Symposium are presented in the following:
Experimental techniques for the unsteady flow separation Theoretical aspects and analytical approaches of flow separation Instability and transition Compressibility effects related to unsteady separation Statistical and hybrid turbulence modelling for unsteady separated flows Direct and Large-Eddy Simulation of unsteady separated flows Theoretical/industrial aspects of unsteady separated flow control
This IUTAM Symposium concerned an important domain of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics nowadays. It focused on the problem of flow separation and of its control. It achieved a unified approach regrouping the knowledge provided from theoretical, experimental, numerical simulation and modelling aspects for unsteady separated flows (incompressible and compressible regimes) and included efficient control devices to achieve attenuation or suppression of separation. The subject areas covered important themes in the domain of fundamental research as well as in the domain of applications. These themes received a great deal of impetus from international research groups, including research Institutes and industrial companies especially in Aeronautics in various countries and associating leading Government Programs. This symposium brought together scientific communities working on the problems related to the understanding of the prediction and control of unsteady, separated flows. The meeting addressed physical aspects of the dynamics of unsteady separation, as well as the state-of-the-art of modelling approaches, especially at high Reynolds numbers. The understanding of the physical mechanisms of the unsteady separation dynamics is a cornerstone for the purpose of efficient turbulence modelling of unsteady separated flows, a challenging issue in a number of engineering
v
vi
Preface
applications including aeronautics, aeroelasticity, space and land vehicles. A round table discussion took place on Monday 18th June 2007 between the IUTAM symposium participants and those of the symposium “Hybrid RANS-LES methods”, 17–18 June addressing the main problems between theoretical aspects and applications domain with respect to the Symposium’s theme. Attended this Symposium were scientists working in the experimental investigation of unsteady separated flows and those working in the numerical simulation and turbulence modelling of these flows, stimulating discussion and advancing the knowledge of the related physical mechanisms. In this way, the symposium contributed to a better insight of this important category of flows from a fundamental and applied research point of view, by means of a synergy between the three main approaches: theoretical, experimental and prediction methods. The main objectives of this symposium were fulfilled. Among the invited 17 Key-Note speakers, two were devoted to provide the major outcomes from the European research programs in aeronautics, dealing with unsteady separated flows, the DESIDER (Detached Eddy Simulation for Industrial aerodynamics) and the UFAST (Unsteady effects in Shock wave induced separation). Seventy-six oral presentations and six poster sessions were included in this Symposium. A best-poster award was attributed to S.C. Luo, T.T.L. Duong and Y.T. Chew of the National University of Singapore, Singapore for their poster, “Flow separation of a rotating cylinder” by the Scientific Committee during the gala dinner held in the Achilleion Palace and Museum of Corfu. The significant outcomes of this symposium are the following : Advances in the physical knowledge of the unsteady separated flows are achieved by means of the Particle Image Velocimetry (especially the three-component PIV and time-resolved PIV as well as simultaneous combination of both), that provides a detailed physical analysis of the unsteady separation and of the detached flow around fixed and moving body configurations. A considerable number of theoretical, numerical and experimental studies were devoted to the instability, transition and control of unsteady separation, including also the physics of compressibility. Among these aspects, the instability and transition related to VIV (Vortex Induced Vibrations), wall rotation effects and dynamic stall were an important issue in the topic, as well as analytical approaches that are able to capture and evaluate the separation. Configurations of cylinders in tandem, of elliptical cross-section cylinders, of oblate freely rising bodies, of impulsively starting motion around bluff bodies and of flows around curved or tappered cylinders and spheres were considered. An original issue of the Symposium related to this topic was the numerical study of flexible bodies leading to very complex wake structure in the context of fluid-structure interaction. A detailed insight of the sensitivity to external disturbances has been presented for separated boundary layers, leading edge separation on slender airfoils at incidence, separation associated with wall jets and in channels enforced by suction. Asymptotic analysis in the limit of large Reynolds number proved that the marginalseparation equations govern these vastly different situations. A novel separating shear layer scaling has been deduced from the unsteady motion and first analytical and numerical results were produced, representing the rotational/irrotational
Preface
vii
interaction of the separating shear layer with the external potential flow. Furthermore, amplitudes causing bubble bursting have been evaluated and found to increase with increasing forcing frequencies, as observed experimentally. The transverse instabilities in separating boundary layers have been studied, based on the perturbed Navier–Stokes system using Floquet theory. The stability and sensitivity of separated flows past freely moving disks, orbiting cylinders and in lid-driven cavities have been investigated, as well as the axisymmetric absolute instability of swirling jets. New analytical approaches in 2D and 3D and Navier–Stokes simulations have been presented for flows in vascular vessel bifurcations involving wall flexibility, and the role of separation associated with the longer or shorter length scales has been studied. The influence of 3D parturbations in the stability of 3D separated flows have been analytically studied for subsonic and supersonic flows, as well as the receptivity of separated boundary layers to external sound waves. Compressibility effects on unsteady separation were investigated by experimental, theoretical and numerical approaches, for transonic and supersonic flows. In particular, the unsteady shock-boundary layer interaction (SBWLI) and consequent separation have been analysed. The Proper Orthogonal Decomposition, POD, approach had a significant impact in analysing the organised modes yielded from SBWLI. The buffeting phenomenon was the object of a number of successful presentations. Efficient Reduced order modelling (ROM) for compressible and incompressible flows have been also presented. The organised mode development due to the compressibility effects and generation of B´enard-von K´arm´an instabilities interacting with buffet modes and their control have been studied in detail. The analysis of these effects is an important outcome of the Symposium, contributing to the fundamental research of compressibility phenomena arising in aeroelasticity. Significant advances in the flow physics of unsteady separation have been also achieved by using Direct Numerical Simulation, (DNS), and Large Eddy Simulation, (LES), in the low and moderate Reynolds number ranges. A number of DNS studies have analysed the unsteady separation and instability modes around bluff bodies and wings, as well as separation in biomechanical flows (aneurysms). Concerning turbulence modelling, in the context of LES, the regularisation subgrid modelling approach and the Variational Multi-Scale approach (VMS) have been investigated, as well as applications of LES and DNS for SBWLI analysis. Considerable achievements in the prediction of high-Reynolds number unsteady separated flows have been made by using the Detached Eddy Simulation, (DES) and adapted/modified statistical turbulence modelling approaches in the context of Unsteady Reynolds Averaged Navier–Stokes, (URANS), for both academic unsteady flows around bodies as well as flows around real aircraft configurations. Advanced statistical turbulence modelling was presented, sensitive enough to capture the coherent structures (OES, Organised Eddy Simulation) and involving the anisotropic eddy-viscosity concept. In the context of hybrid approaches, the embedded hybrid RANS-LES, the hybrid RANS-VMS (Variational Multi-Scale) and the Detached Eddy Simulation (DES) using among other models algebraic-stress modelling for the RANS part were investigated. Among the configurations considered, the Boeing 777 Nose-Gear Cavity, wing-body junction flows, dynamic stall wings as well as
viii
Preface
cavity flows including those of the stratospheric observatory (infrared astronomy – American-German research program SOFIA) were presented. The control of flow separation has been achieved by using electromagnetic forcing, plasma actuators, piezoelectric actuators and surface plasma. Vortex shedding control has been achieved by synthetic jets and Vortex Generators (VGS) and spanwise sinusoidal perturbation (SPPM). Efficient passively controlled studies by means of LES have been presented, concerning transonic cavity flows, as well as passive drag control of turbulent wakes. Biomimetic flows around fish and natural flyers have been studied and optimised by flow control. Flow control of unsteady separation in bluff bodies undergoing VIV has been achieved by small vibrating rods, active/passive ventilation methods, and rotational control. Small rotating rods have been also used for control of vortex breakdown in a closed cylinder. The flow mechanisms employed in actively controlled, fish-like bodies are investigated to optimise their locomotion and maneuvering performance. Concerning biomimetics, the hydrodynamics of beating cilia has been investigated by DNS involving immersed boundary method and the PALM coupler. This approach is useful for the control (passive or active) of the boundary layer flow for the suction of airfoils using a ciliated wall. Flow forcing techniques, as well feedback stabilisation techniques, were also efficiently used for separated bluff bodies. Stochastic feedback flow control has been applied to flexible flapping wing emulating natural flyers, to create thrust and to reduce drag. Optimal control of separated flows has been achieved by adjoint equations, as well as robust closed-loop control methods applied to highlift devices and sub-optimal control approaches applied in separated channel flows. Concerning feedback control strategies, the approach of linear proportional control has been applied in the flow over a sphere. A new strategy, “Multiscale retrograde estimation and forecasting of chaotic non-linear systems”, concerning multiscale complexity and model uncertainty, has been presented. The ensemble of these aspects constitutes major outcomes of the symposium concerning the state-of-the-art for control devices to attenuate/suppress instabilities and unsteady separation. Most challenging research outcomes examined in this symposium are the prediction of turbulent unsteady separated flows around bodies at high Reynolds number, involving also the complex of fluid-structure interaction phenomena. It has been seen that the experimental, DNS and LES approaches of complex unsteady separated flows have proven quite promising, despite the fact that the two latter ones are limited in the relatively low Reynolds number range. This difficulty is overcome by having associated URANS and LES in the context of hybrid turbulence modelling. These last approaches provided a very useful panel of complex flow physics to model unsteady separated 3D flows in the high Reynolds number regime, which is of priority interest for industrial applications. Therefore, a major outcome of this symposium concerning future issues is the fact that there is a need for increasing the knowledge of unsteady flow physics by the synergy of well focused physical experiments in the higher Re-range (e.g. tomographic PIV) and the knowledge coming from the DNS and LES studies. These efforts contribute to improve the above-mentioned modelling methodologies in the higher Reynolds number range, to increase the predictive capabilities of strongly detached flows and especially of the
Preface
ix
fluid-structure interaction phenomena around moving and deformable bodies. These topics are of a significant interest to applications in the domain of flow-induced vibrations (FIV), in unsteady aerodynamics and in aeroelasticity. CNRS-IMFT, France Monash University, Australia
Marianna Braza Kerry Hourigan
International Scientific Committee A. Bottaro A. Kluwick, IUTAM representative B. J. Geurts G. E. Karniadakis C. Norberg F. Smith F. Thiele G. Tzabiras
Universit`a di Genova, Italy University of Vienna, Austria University of Twente, Netherlands Brown University, USA Lund Institute of Technology, Sweden University College, London Technical University, Berlin National Technical University of Athens, Greece
Local Organizing Committee M. Braza (Chairman) P. Chassaing G. Harran A. Sevrain S. Saintlos-Brillac G. Barbut R. Bourguet R. El Akoury G. Martinat M. Sabater D. Bourrel G. Martin Y. Exposito W. Haase Y. Hoarau G. Tzabiras K. Georgiou A. Papageorgiou, M. Koufioti, N. Rapti
CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France CNRS-IMFT, France EADS, Germany University of Strasbourg NTUA, Greece NTUA, Greece Heliotopos Conferences, Greece
x
Host Institutions The symposium was organised by the: Institut de M´ecanique des Fluides de Toulouse (IMFT), affiliated with the: Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) Institut National Polytechnique de Toulouse (INPT) Ecole Nationale Sup´erieure d’Electrotechnique, Electronique, Informatique, Hydraulique et T´el´ecommunications (ENSEEIHT) Universit´e Paul Sabatier (UPS) National Technical University of Athens (NTUA).
Preface
IUTAM “Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control” Symposium, Corfu-Greece, 18–22 June 2007. Best poster award attribution during the gala dinner by Marianna Braza and Kerry Hourigan to the co-authors S.C. Luo, T.T.L. Duong and Y.T. Chew of the National Univ. of Singapore, for their poster “Flow separation of a rotating cylinder”, at the Achilleion Palace, on 20th June 2007.
Participants of the Symposium in the garden of the hotel “Chandris” – Corfu, next to the Conference room, Friday 22nd June 2007.
Detailed Programme
Sunday 17 June 2007: 18:00–20:00
Early registration
Monday 18 June 2007: 09:00–11:00 11:00–11:30
Registration Welcome address
11:30–12:45
Session I.1 Experimental techniques for the unsteady flow separation
11:30–12:15
Effects of unsteady separated flow phenomena in vortex-induced vibrations C.H.K. Williamson, Cornell Univ., USA; Opening lecture* PIV measurements of the flow around oscillating cylinders at low KC numbers D. Sumner, H.B. Hemingson, D.M. Deutscher & J.E. Barth (Univ. of Saskatchewan, Canada) Measurement of instantaneous velocity and surface topography of a cylinder at low Reynolds number A. Fouras, D. Lo Jacono, G. J. Sheard & K. Hourigan* (Monash Univ., Australia)
12:15–12:30
12:30–12:45
12:45–14:00
Lunch
14:00–16:00
Session I.2 Experimental techniques for the unsteady flow separation
14:00–14:45
Unsteady flow around impulsively stopped bluff bodies T. Leweke, M.C. Thompson, G.J. Sheard, L. Schouveiler & K. Hourigan, IRPHE, France - FLAIR, Australia; Invited keynote lecture*
For the presentations marked by () there is no article available
xiii
xiv
14:45–15:00
15:00–15:15
15:15–15:30
15:30–15:45
Detailed Programme
Coherent and turbulent process analysis in the flow past a circular cylinder at high Reynolds number R. Perrin, M. Braza, E. Cid, S. Cazin, P. Chassaing, C. Mockett, T. Reimann & F. Thiele (IMFT, France; TU-Berlin, Germany) Wake behind a sphere: experimental and numerical investigations K. Gumowski, J. Miedzik, S. Goujon-Durand, G. Bouchet, P. Jenffer & J.E. Wesfreid* (ESPCI–PMMH, IMFS, France) Investigation of aerodynamic capabilities of flying fish in gliding flight H. Park & H. Choi (Seoul National Univ., Korea) Effect of unsteady separation on an automotive bluff-body in cross-wind M. Gohlke, J.F. Beaudoin, M. Amielh & F. Anselmet (PSA, IRPHE, France)
16:00–16:45
Coffee break
16:45–18:15
Session II.1 Statistical and hybrid turbulence modeling of unsteady separated flows
16:45–17:30
18:30–19:30
Prediction methodologies for non-stationary turbulent flows T. B. Gatski, Laboratoire d’Etudes A´erodynamiques, Poitiers, France - Center of Coastal Physical Oceanography and Ocean, Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, Old Dominion Univ. Norfolk; Invited keynote lecture* Flow prediction around an oscillating NACA0012 at ReD1000 000 O. Frederich, U. Bunge, C. Mockett & F. Thiele (TU-Berlin, IVM Automotive Wolfsburg GmbH, Germany) Two-velocities hybrid RANS-LES of a trailing edge flow J.C. Uribe, N. Jarrin, R. Prosser & D. Laurence (Univ. of Manchester, UK - EDF, France) Assessment of flow control devices for transonic cavity flows using DES and LES G. Barakos, S. Lawson, R. Steijl & Punit Nayyar (Univ. of Liverpool, UK) Round table discussion
20:00
Cocktail
17:30–17:45
17:45–18:00
18:00–18:15
Detailed Programme
xv
Tuesday, 19 June 2007: 08:30–10:30
Session III.1 Theoretical aspects & analytical approaches of flow separation
08:30–09:15
Near critical phenomena in laminar boundary layers A. Kluwick, S. Braun & E.A. Cox, Technical Univ. of Vienna, Austria - Univ. College Dublin, Irland; Invited keynote lecture State curves and flipping for an orbiting cylinder at low Reynolds numbers L. Baranyi (Univ. of Miskolc, Hungary) Study of a lid-driven cavity in an axisymmetric geometry R. Dasgupta & R. Govindarajan* (JNCASR, India) Global low-frequency oscillations in a separating boundary-layer flow U. Ehrenstein & F. Gallaire (IRPHE, Univ. de Nice-Sophia Antipolis, France) Axisymmetric absolute instability of swirling jets J.J. Healey (Keele Univ., UK) Global instability and control of laminar separation bubbles V. Theofilis (Univ. Polit´ecnica de Madrid, Spain)
09:15–09:30
09:30–09:45
09:45–10:00
10:00–10:15
10:15–10:30
10:30–11:00
Coffee break
11:00–12:45
Session III.2 Theoretical aspects & analytical approaches of flow separation
11:00–11:45
New applications with unsteady flow separation analysis F.T. Smith & N.C. Ovenden, Univ. College London, UK; Invited keynote lecture* Instability of supersonic compression ramp flow R.P. Logue, J.S.B. Gajjar & A.I. Ruban (Univ. of Manchester, UK) Asymptotic theory of turbulent bluff-body separation: A novel shear layer scaling deduced from an investigation of the unsteady motion B. Scheichl & A. Kluwick (Vienna University of Technology, Austria) Cylinders with elliptical cross-section: Wake stability with variation in angle of incidence G.J. Sheard (FLAIR, Australia) Structural stability of the finite-amplitude vortex shedding behind a circular cylinder P. Luchini, F. Giannetti & J. Pralits (Univ. di Salerno, Italy)
11:45–12:00
12:00–12:15
12:15–12:30
12:30–12:45
xvi
Detailed Programme
Posters of session III Influence of 3D perturbations on separated flows F. Alizard & J.C. Robinet* (ENSAM, France) Orbiting cylinder at low Reynolds numbers L. Baranyi (Univ. of Miskolc, Hungary) Global instability computations of separated flow B.V. Bharati Laxmi & J.S.B. Gajjar* (Univ. of Manchester, UK) A two-dimensional disturbed flows over a flat plate: theoretical and numerical approach K. Debbagh & S. Saintlos Brillac (IMFT, France) 12:45–14:00
Lunch
14:00–15:45
Session IV.1 Instability and transition
14:00–14:45
Forced wakes J.E. Wesfreid, ESPCI, France; Invited keynote lecture* Wake transition in the flow around two circular cylinders in staggered arrangements B. Carmo, S. Sherwin, P. Bearman & R. Willden (Imperial College London, UK) Wake dynamics of external flow past a curved circular cylinder with the free-steam aligned with the plane of curvature A. de Vecchi, S.J. Sherwin & J.M.R. Graham (Imperial College London, UK) Successive steps of 2D and 3D transition in the flow past a rotating circular cylinder at moderate Reynolds numbers R. El Akoury, G. Martinat, M. Braza, R. Perrin, Y. Hoarau, G. Harran & D. Ruiz (IMFT, IMFS, ENSEEIHT, France) Direct numerical simulation of vortex shedding behind a linearly tapered circular cylinder V.D. Narasimhamurthy, H.I. Andersson & B. Pettersen (NTNU, Norway)
14:45–15:00
15:00–15:15
15:15–15:30
15:30–15:45
15:45–16:15
Coffee break
16:15–18:30
Session IV.2 Instability and transition
16:15–17:00
Wake transition of oscillating bluff bodies M.C. Thompson, K. Hourigan & J. Leontini, FLAIR, Monash Univ., Clayton, Australia; Invited keynote lecture Dynamics of oblate freely-rising bodies P. Fernandes, P. Ern, F. Risso & J. Magnaudet (IMFT, France)
17:00–17:15
Detailed Programme
17:15–17:30
17:30–17:45
17:45–18:00
18:00–18:15
18:15–18:30
xvii
Parametric study of the two degree-of-freedom vortex-induced vibrations of a cylinder in a two-dimensional flow D. Lucor & M.S. Triantafyllou (Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA) Vortex dynamics associated with the impact of a cylinder with a wall L. Schouveiler, M.C. Thompson, T. Leweke and K. Hourigan (IRPHE, France - FLAIR, Monash Univ., Australia) Modification of the flow structures in a swirling jet K. Atvars, M.C. Thompson & K. Hourigan (FLAIR, Monash Univ., Australia) Thickness effect of NACA symmetric hydrofoils on hydrodynamic behavior and boundary layer states H. Djeridi, C. Sarraf & J.Y. Billard (Ecole Navale, France) Vortex formation in black-step flow A. Mihaiescu, H. Hangan, A. Straatman & J.E. Wesfreid (Univ. of Western Ontario, London - ON, N6G 2B9, Canada, ESPCI, France)
Posters of session IV Transition of boundary layer on a circular cylinder in uniform flow S. Behara & S. Mittal* (Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, India) Numerical simulation of the flow-induced vibration in the flow around two circular cylinders in tandem arrangements B. Carmo, S. Sherwin, P. Bearman & R. Willden* (Imperial College London, UK) Three-dimensionalities of the flow around an oscillating circular cylinder R.S. Gioria & J.R. Meneghini* (Univ. of Sao Paulo, Brazil) Quasi-steady self-excited angular oscillation of equilateral triangular cylinder in 2-D separated flow S. Srigrarom (Nanyang Technological Univ., Singapore) Wednesday, 20 June 2007: 08:30–10:00
Session V.1 Compressibility effects related to unsteady separation
08:30–09:15
Why do shock waves move in separated flows? J.P. Dussauge, IUSTI, France; Invited keynote lecture* Compressibility effects on turbulent separated flow in a streamwise-periodic hill channel - Part1 J. Ziefle & L. Kleiser (Institute of Fluid Dynamics, ETH Zurich, Switzerland)
09:15–09:30
xviii
09:30–09:45
Detailed Programme
09:45–10:00
Global structure of buffeting flow on transonic airfoils J.D. Crouch, A. Garbaruk, D. Magidov & L. Jacquin (St-Petersburg Univ., Russia - ONERA, France) Low-order modeling for unsteady separated compressible flows by POD-Galerkin Approach R. Bourguet, M. Braza & G. Harran (IMFT, France)
10:00–10:30
Coffee break
10:30–12:15
Session V.2 Compressibility effects related to unsteady separation
10:30–11:15
European research on unsteady effects of shock wave induced separation - UFAST Projet P. Doerffer, IMP PAN, Gdansk, Poland; Invited keynote lecture* On the three-dimensionality of shock-wave / laminar boundary layer interaction J.C. Robinet (ENSAM, France) Unsteady flow organization of a shock wave/turbulent boundary layer interaction R.A. Humble, F. Scarano & B.W. Van Oudheusden (Delft Univ. of Technology, The Netherlands) Dependance between shock and separation in a shock wave/boundary layer interaction J.F. Debi`eve & P. Dupont (IUSTI, France) Effect of a serrated skirt on the buffeting phenomenon in transonic afterbody flows P. Meliga, P. Reijasse & J.M. Chomaz* (ONERA - LadHyX, Ecole Polytechnique, France)
11:15–11:30
11:30–11:45
11:45–12:00
12:00–12:15
Posters of session V Large Eddy Simulation of a supersonic turbulent boundary layer at MD2.25 A. Hadjadj & S. Dubos (INSA de Rouen, France) Film cooling mass flow rate influence on a separation shock in an axisymmetric nozzle P. Reijasse & L. Boccaletto (ONERA - CNES, France) 12:15–14:00
Lunch
14:00–15:30
Session II.2 Statistical and hybrid turbulence modeling of unsteady separated flows
Detailed Programme
14:00–14:45
14:45–15:00
15:00–15:15
15:15–15:30
xix
DESider - Detached Eddy Simulation for Industrial Aerodynamics W. Haase, EADS, M¨unich, Germany; Invited keynote lecture Detached Eddy Simulation of a nose landing-gear cavity R.B. Langtry & P.R. Spalart (The Boeing Company, USA) Experimental and numerical study of unsteady wakes behind an oscillating car model E. Guilmineau & F. Chometon (Ecole Centrale de Nantes - CNAM, France) Physical analysis of an anisotropic eddy viscosity concept for strongly detached unsteady flows R. Bourguet, M. Braza, R. Perrin & G. Harran (IMFT, France)
15:30–16:00
Coffee break
16:00–16:45
Session II.3 Statistical and hybrid turbulence modeling of unsteady separated flows
16:00–16:15
Dynamic stall of a pitching and horizontally oscillating airfoil G. Martinat, M. Braza, G. Harran, A. Sevrain, Y. Hoarau & D. Favier (IMFT - IMFS - LABM - France) Unsteady flow around a NACA0021 airfoil beyond stall at 60ı angle of attack R. El Akoury, M. Braza, Y. Hoarau, J. Vos, G. Harran & A. Sevrain (IMFT, IMFS, France - CFS engineering, Switzerland) Analysis of Detached-Eddy Simulation for the flow around a circular cylinder with reference to PIV data C. Mockett, R. Perrin, T. Reimann, M. Braza & F. Thiele (TU-Berlin, Germany)
16:15–16:30
16:30–16:45
16:45–19:30 19:30
Free Venue at Achilleion Palace/Museum - visit and gala dinner
Thursday, 21 June 2007: 08:30–10:00
Session II.4 Statistical and hybrid turbulence modeling of unsteady separated flows
08:30–09:15
On the use of LES for flow control: the compressible cavity flow case P. Sagaut, Univ. Paris VI, France; Invited keynote lecture On the coherent dynamics of turbulent junction flows J. Paik, C. Escauriaza & F. Sotiropoulos (Univ. of Minnesota, USA)
09:15–09:30
xx
09:30–09:45
09:45–10:00
Detailed Programme
Simulation of the unsteady cavity flow of the stratospheric observatory for infrared astronomy S. Schmid, T. Lutz & E. Kr¨amer (IAG Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany) Simulation of bluff-body flows through a hybrid RANS/VMS-LES model M.V. Salvetti, B. Koobus, S. Camarri & A. Dervieux (Univ. di Pisa, Italy)
Poster of session II Numerical simulation of non-steady supersonic double ramp flow by URANS Approach I.A. Fedorchenko, N.N. Fedorova & U. Gaisbauer* (ITAM, Russia - IAG Univ., Germany) 10:00–10:30
Coffee break
10:30–13:00
Session VI DNS and LES of unsteady separated flows
10:30–11:15
Regularization modeling for large-eddy simulation of turbulent separated boundary layer flow B.J. Geurts, Univ. of Twente, The Netherlands; Invited keynote lecture* Direct numerical simulation of the bursting of a laminar separation bubble and evaluation of flow-control strategies O. Marxen & D.S. Henningson* (KTH, Sweden) LES of the flow around two cylinders in tandem G. Palau-Salvador, T. Stoesser, J. Fr¨ohlich & W. Rodi* (Karlsruhe Univ., Germany) Large Eddy Simulation of impinging shock wave / turbulent boundary layer interaction at MD2.3 E. de Martel, E. Garnier & P. Sagaut (ONERA - LMM, Univ. Pierre et Marie Curie, France) Design and validation of a Large Eddy Simulation methodology for compressible shock-free flows on unstructured meshes L. Georges, J.F. Thomas, G. Winckelmans & P. Geuzaine* (CENAERO, Belgium) On coherent structures and low frequency motions of shock wave-turbulent boundary layer interactions via DNS M. Pino Martin & M. Wu (Princeton Univ. USA) Simulation and modelling of a laminar separation bubble on airfoils F. Richez, I. Mary, V. Gleize & C. Basdevant (ONERA, France)
11:15–11:30
11:30–11:45
11:45–12:00
12:00–12:15
12:15–12:30
12:30–12:45
Detailed Programme
12:45–13:00
xxi
Undesirable haemodynamics in aneurysms G.J. Sheard, R.G. Evans, K.M. Denton & K. Hourigan* (Monash Univ., Australia)
Posters of session VI Unsteady separated flow around the Ahmed body J. Hoessler, J.F. Beaudoin & F. Perot* (PSA Peugeot Citro¨en, France) Unsteady RANS Calculation of Flow over Ahmed Car Model J. Yao, O. Mouzoun, Y.F. Yao & P. Mason (Kingston Univ., UK) 13:00–14:15
Lunch
14:15–15:45
Session I.3 Experimental techniques for the unsteady flow separation
14:15–15:00
Vortex shedding dynamics in the laminar wakes of various bluff bodies (cylinders, spheres and cones) M. Provansal & P. Monkewitz, IRPHE, France - LMF EPFL, Switzerland; Invited keynote lecture* Effect of velocity ratio on the streamwise vortex structures in the wake of a stack M.S. Adaramola, D. Sumner & D.J. Bergstrom (Univ. of Saskatchewan, Canada) Unsteady force measurements of an airfoil undergoing dynamic stall at low Reynolds number K.K.Y. Tsang, R.C.K. Leung & R.M.C. So* (The Hong Kong Polytechnic Univ., Hong Kong) Coherent structure eduction from PIV data of an electromagnetically forced separated flow T. Weier, C. Ciepka & G. Gerbeth (Forschungszentrum Rossendorf, Germany)
15:00–15:15
15:15–15:30
15:30–15:45
Posters of session I Detailed wake structure behind unsteady airfoils and characteristics of dynamic thrust M. Fuchiwaki & K. Tanaka* (Kyushu Institute of Technology, Japan) Flow separation of a rotating cylinder Best poster award S.C. Luo, T.T.L. Duong & Y.T. Chew (National Univ. of Singapore, Singapore) Unsteady flow behind a blunt based POD model S.D. Sharma & A.A. Kumar* (Indian Institute of Technology Bombay, India) 15:45–16:15
Coffee break
xxii
Detailed Programme
16:15–18:30
Session VII.1 Theoretical/Industrial aspects of unsteady separated flow control
16:15–17:00
Control systems with large parameter spaces C.M. Ho, S. Ho, P.K. Wong & H. Nassef, Univ. of California, Los Angeles, Office of the Secretary of Defense, Washington, Univ. of Arizona, Fluidiqm Inc, San Francisco, USA; Invited keynote lecture* Control of vortex breakdown in a closed cylinder with a small rotating rod D. Lo Jacono, J.N. Sorensen, M.C. Thompson & K. Hourigan* (FLAIR, Monash Univ., Australia - Technical Univ. of Denmark) The wake dynamics of a cylinder moving along a plane wall with rotation and translation B. Stewart, K. Hourigan, M. Thompson & T. Leweke (Monash Univ. Australia - IRPHE, France) Sub-optimal control of unsteady separation in a channel K.W. Cassel, C. Sardesai, S. Braun & A.I. Ruban* (MMAE, Illinois I. of Tech., USA - I. of FMTH, Vienna Univ. of Tech., Austria - Univ. of Manchester, UK) Accurate POD reduced-order models of separated flows J. Favier, A. Kourta & L. Cordier* (IMFT - LEMTA, France) Simulation study of a robust closed-loop control of a 2D high-lift configuration B. G¨unther, R. Becker, A. Carnarius, F. Thiele & R. King (TU-Berlin, Germany) Linear proportional control of flow over a sphere S. Jeon & H. Choi* (Seoul National Univ., Korea)
17:00–17:15
17:15–17:30
17:30–17:45
17:45–18:00
18:00–18:15
18:15–18:30
Friday, 22 June 2007: 08:30–10:15
Session VII.2 Theoretical/Industrial aspects of unsteady separated flow control
08:30–09:15
Multiscale retrograde estimation and forecasting of chaotic nonlinear systems T. Bewley, Univ. of California San Diego, USA; Invited keynote lecture* Spreading and vectoring of a subsonic axisymmetric air jet by plasma actuator : a preliminary study N. Benard, J. Jolibois, M. Forte, G. Touchard & E. Moreau (LEA, Univ. de Poitiers, France)*
09:15–09:30
Detailed Programme
09:30–09:45
09:45–10:00
10:00–10:15
xxiii
Simulation of the reduction of the unsteadiness in a passively-controlled transonic cavity flow P. Comte, F. Daude & I. Mary (ENSMA - ONERA, France) Passive drag control of a turbulent wake by local disturbances O. Cadot, B. Thiria & J.F. Beaudoin (ENSTA, France) The effect of zero-net-mass-flux jet geometry on active separation control of a NACA0015 airfoil T. Stephens, C. Atkinson & J. Soria* (Monash Univ., Australia)
10:15–10:45
Coffee break
10:45–12:45
Session VII.3 Theoretical/Industrial aspects of unsteady separated flow control
10:45–11:30
Unsteady separated flows and their control M. Triantafyllou, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA; Invited keynote lecture* Active control of a cylinder wake using surface plasma T.N. Jukes & K.S. Choi (Univ. of Nottingham, UK) Active control of flow separation over an airfoil using synthetic jets D. You & P. Moin (Stanford Univ. USA) Flow control for rorocraft applications at flight Mach numbers H. Nagib, J. Keidaisch, D. Greenblatt, I. Wygnanski & A. Hassan* (Illinois I. of Tech., USA - TU-Berlin, Germany - Univ. of Arizona, USA - The Boeing Company, USA) Electromagnetic control of separation at hydrofoils* G. Mutschke, T. Weier, T. Albrecht, G. Gerbeth & R. Grundmann (Forschungszentrum Rossendorf - Dresden Univ. of Technology, Germany) A numerical study of ZNMF jet lift enhancement of a NACA 0015 airfoil V. Kitsios, A. Ooi, J. Soria & D.You* (Univ. Of Melbourne - Monash Univ., Australia)
11:30–11:45
11:45–12:00
12:00–12:15
12:15–12-30
12:30–12:45
12:45–14:00
Lunch
14:00–15:30
Session VII.4 Theoretical/Industrial aspects of unsteady separated flow control
14:00–14:45
Hydrodynamics of beating cilia A. Dauptain, J. Favier & A. Bottaro, Univ. di Genova, Italy; Invited keynote lecture*
xxiv
14:45–15:00
15:00–15:15
15:15–15:30
16:00–16:30
Detailed Programme
Control of the separated flow behind a circular cylinder by low forcing – Experiments and computations E. Konstantinidis, C. Liang, G. Papadakis & S. Balabani* (Univ. of Western Macedonia, Greece - Iowa State Univ., USA King’s College London, UK) Vortex models for feedback stabilization of bluff body wake flows B. Protas* (McMaster Univ., Hamilton, Canada) Computational investigation of flow control over wings P.S. Vavilis & J.A. Ekaterinaris* (Univ. of Patras, Greece) Closing address
Posters of session VII Towards the control of cavitating flows R.E.A. Arndt & M. Wosnik* (Univ. of Minnesota, Minneapolis) Active control of flows with trapped vortices R.M. Kerimbekov & O.R. Tutty (Univ. of Southampton, UK) A three-dimensional numerical study into non-axisymmetric perturbations of the hole-tone feedback cycle M.A. Langthjem & M. Nakano (Yamagata Univ., Japan) Flow control in high-speed train applications A. Orellano & M. Schober (Bombardier, Germany) Flow control of annular jet expansion using cross-flow injection M. Vanierschot & E. Van den Bulck* (Katholieke Univ. Leuven, Belgium)
Acknowledgement
We express appreciation for the support for this symposium from the following sponsors: International Union of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics (IUTAM) Institut de M´ecanique des Fluides de Toulouse, UMR 5502 CNRS-INP/ ENSEEIHT-UPS (CNRS–IMFT) Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) European Research Community on Flow Turbulence and Combustion (ERCOFTAC) European Aeronautic Defence and Space Company (EADS) The symposium chairmen are grateful to the IUTAM Committee for their support and for having attributed the IUTAM label to the symposium’s topic, as well as to the President of INPT (Institut National Polytechnique de Toulouse), Professor G. Casamatta, to the President of UPS (Universit´e Paul Sabatier), Professor J.F. Sautereau, to the Director of ENSEEIHT (Ecole Nationale Sup´erieure d’Electrotechnique, Electronique, Informatique, Hydraulique et T´elecommunications), Professor A. Ayache, to the Director of IMFT (Institut de M´ecanique des Fluides de Toulouse), Dr. J. Magnaudet, for their contribution to the success of this Symposium. The Hellenic Touristic Development Company as well as M.M. Kritikos and Drougas are thanked for having allowed the organisation of the gala dinner in the Achilleion palace and Museum of Corfu, built by the Empress Elisabeth of Austria (1837–1898). This IUTAM symposium was held in the Chandris Hotel of Dassia–Corfu, in the main conference room “Odysseas” of the hotel, located on a very nice coast of the Ionian sea at Corfu. A friendly atmosphere was created among the participants, helped by the organisation of two social events, the cocktail and buffet-dinner on Monday 18th June, at the beach, jointly organised by the IUTAM symposium and
xxv
xxvi
Acknowledgement
the statistical-hybrid one and the gala dinner on 20th June in the superb “Achilleion Palace and Museum”, that was especially open for visiting by all the participants. A general outcome from this symposium was that the scientific communities working on experimental, theoretical and numerical approaches related to the unsteady separation and its control, have learned a lot from one another and the meeting has brought new research ideas to everyone. Toulouse, France Melbourne, Australia
Marianna Braza Kerry Hourigan
Contents
Part I
Experimental Techniques for the Unsteady Flow Separation
PIV Measurements of the Flow Around Oscillating Cylinders at Low KC Numbers : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : D. Sumner, H.B. Hemingson, D.M. Deutscher, and J.E. Barth
3
Coherent and Turbulent Process Analysis in the Flow Past a Circular Cylinder at High Reynolds Number : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 15 R. Perrin, M. Braza, E. Cid, S. Cazin, P. Chassaing, C. Mockett, T. Reimann, and F. Thiele Investigation of Aerodynamic Capabilities of Flying Fish in Gliding Flight : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 27 H. Park and H. Choi Effect of Unsteady Separation on an Automotive Bluff-Body in Cross-Wind : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 35 M. Gohlke, J.F. Beaudoin, M. Amielh, and F. Anselmet Part II Statistical and Hybrid Turbulence Modeling of Unsteady Separated Flows Flow Prediction Around an Oscillating NACA0012 Airfoil at Re = 1,000,000 : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 49 O. Frederich, U. Bunge, C. Mockett, and F. Thiele Two-Velocities Hybrid RANS-LES of a Trailing Edge Flow : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 63 J.C. Uribe, N. Jarrin, R. Prosser, and D. Laurence Assessment of Flow Control Devices for Transonic Cavity Flows Using DES and LES : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 77 G.N. Barakos, S.J. Lawson, R. Steijl, and P. Nayyar
xxvii
xxviii
Part III
Contents
Theoretical Aspects & Analytical Approaches of Flow Separation
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 91 A. Kluwick, S. Braun, and E.A. Cox State Curves and Flipping for an Orbiting Cylinder at Low Reynolds Numbers : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 111 L. Baranyi Global Low-Frequency Oscillations in a Separating Boundary-Layer Flow : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 123 U. Ehrenstein and F. Gallaire Asymptotic Theory of Turbulent Bluff-Body Separation: A Novel Shear Layer Scaling Deduced from an Investigation of the Unsteady Motion : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 135 B. Scheichl and A. Kluwick Structural Sensitivity of the Finite-Amplitude Vortex Shedding Behind a Circular Cylinder : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 151 P. Luchini, F. Giannetti, and J. Pralits Orbiting Cylinder at Low Reynolds Numbers : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 161 L. Baranyi A Two-Dimensional Disturbed Flows Over a Flat Plate: Theoretical and Numerical Approach :: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 167 K. Debbagh and S. Saintlos Brillac Part IV
Instability and Transition
Wake Dynamics of External Flow Past a Curved Circular Cylinder with the Free-Stream Aligned to the Plane of Curvature : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 175 A. de Vecchi, S.J. Sherwin, and J.M.R. Graham Successive Steps of 2D and 3D Transition in the Flow Past a Rotating Cylinder at Moderate Reynolds Numbers : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 187 R. El Akoury, G. Martinat, M. Braza, R. Perrin, Y. Hoarau, G. Harran, and D. Ruiz Direct Numerical Simulation of Vortex Shedding Behind a Linearly Tapered Circular Cylinder : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 201 V.D. Narasimhamurthy, H.I. Andersson, and B. Pettersen Dynamics of Oblate Freely Rising Bodies : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 213 P.C. Fernandes, P. Ern, F. Risso, and J. Magnaudet
Contents
xxix
Parametric Study of Two Degree-of-Freedom Vortex-Induced Vibrations of a Cylinder in a Two-Dimensional Flow : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 223 D. Lucor and M.S. Triantafyllou Vortex Dynamics Associated with the Impact of a Cylinder with a Wall : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 235 L. Schouveiler, M.C. Thompson, T. Leweke, and K. Hourigan Modification of the Flow Structures in a Swirling Jet :: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 243 K. Atvars, M. Thompson, and K. Hourigan Thickness Effect of NACA Symmetric Hydrofoils on Hydrodynamic Behaviour and Boundary Layer States : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 255 H. Djeridi, C. Sarraf, and J.Y. Billard Quasi-Steady Self-Excited Angular Oscillation of Equilateral Triangular Cylinder in 2-D Separated Flow : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 269 S. Srigrarom Part V
Compressibility Effects Related to Unsteady Separation
Compressibility Effects on Turbulent Separated Flow in a Streamwise-Periodic Hill Channel – Part 1 : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 285 J. Ziefle and L. Kleiser Global Structure of Buffeting Flow on Transonic Airfoils : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 297 J.D. Crouch, A. Garbaruk, D. Magidov, and L. Jacquin Low-Order Modeling for Unsteady Separated Compressible Flows by POD-Galerkin Approach :: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 307 R. Bourguet, M. Braza, G. Harran, and A. Dervieux Unsteady Flow Organization of a Shock Wave/Turbulent Boundary Layer Interaction :: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 319 R.A. Humble, F. Scarano, and B.W. van Oudheusden Dependence Between Shock and Separation Bubble in a Shock Wave Boundary Layer Interaction : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 331 J.F. Debi`eve and P. Dupont Large Eddy Simulation of a Supersonic Turbulent Boundary Layer at M D 2:25 : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 343 A. Hadjadj and S. Dubos Film Cooling Mass Flow Rate Influence on a Separation Shock in an Axisymmetric Nozzle : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 349 P. Reijasse and L. Boccaletto
xxx
Contents
Detached Eddy Simulation of a Nose Landing-Gear Cavity : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 357 R. Langtry and P. Spalart Experimental and Numerical Study of Unsteady Wakes Behind an Oscillating Car Model : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 367 E. Guilmineau and F. Chometon Physical Analysis of an Anisotropic Eddy-Viscosity Concept for Strongly Detached Turbulent Unsteady Flows : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 381 R. Bourguet, M. Braza, R. Perrin, and G. Harran Dynamic Stall of a Pitching and Horizontally Oscillating Airfoil : : : : : : : : : : : : 395 G. Martinat, M. Braza, G. Harran, A. Sevrain, G. Tzabiras, Y. Hoarau, and D. Favier Unsteady Flow Around a NACA0021 Airfoil Beyond Stall at 60ı Angle of Attack :: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 405 R. El Akoury, M. Braza, Y. Hoarau, J. Vos, G. Harran, and A. Sevrain Analysis of Detached-Eddy Simulation for the Flow Around a Circular Cylinder with Reference to PIV Data : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 417 C. Mockett, R. Perrin, T. Reimann, M. Braza, and F. Thiele Simulation of Bluff-Body Flows Through a Hybrid RANS/VMS-LES Model : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 429 Maria Vittoria Salvetti, Bruno Koobus, Simone Camarri, and Alain Dervieux Part VI
DNS and LES of Unsteady Separated Flows
Large Eddy Simulation of Impinging Shock Wave/Turbulent Boundary Layer Interaction at M D 2 :3 : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 443 E. de Martel, E. Garnier, and P. Sagaut Simulation and Modelling of a Laminar Separation Bubble on Airfoils : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 457 F. Richez, I. Mary, V. Gleize, and C. Basdevant Unsteady RANS Calculation of Flow Over Ahmed Car Model : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 471 J. Yao, O. Mouzoun, Y. Yao, and P. Mason Effect of Velocity Ratio on the Streamwise Vortex Structures in the Wake of a Stack : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 477 M.S. Adaramola, D. Sumner, and D.J. Bergstrom Flow Separation of a Rotating Cylinder : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 487 S.C. Luo, T.T.L. Duong, and Y.T. Chew
Contents
Part VII
xxxi
Theoretical/Industrial Aspects of Unsteady Separated Flow Control
The Wake Dynamics of a Cylinder Moving Along a Plane Wall with Rotation and Translation :: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 495 B. Stewart, K. Hourigan, M. Thompson, and T. Leweke Simulation Study of the Robust Closed-Loop Control of a 2D High-Lift Configuration:: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 505 B. G¨unther, A. Carnarius, F. Thiele, R. Becker, and R. King Large-Eddy Simulation of Passively-Controlled Transonic Cavity Flow : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 517 P. Comte, F. Daude, and I. Mary Passive Drag Control of a Turbulent Wake by Local Disturbances : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 529 O. Cadot, B. Thiria, and J.-F. Beaudoin Active Control of a Cylinder Wake Using Surface Plasma : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 539 T. Jukes and K.-S. Choi Active Control of Flow Separation Over an Airfoil Using Synthetic Jets : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 551 D. You and P. Moin Electromagnetic Control of Separation at Hydrofoils :: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 563 G. Mutschke, T. Weier, T. Albrecht, G. Gerbeth, and R. Grundmann Active Control of Flows with Trapped Vortices: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 575 R.M. Kerimbekov and O.R. Tutty A Three-Dimensional Numerical Study into Non-Axisymmetric Perturbations of the Hole-Tone Feedback Cycle: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 581 M.A. Langthjem and M. Nakano
Part I
Experimental Techniques for the Unsteady Flow Separation
“This page left intentionally blank.”
PIV Measurements of the Flow Around Oscillating Cylinders at Low KC Numbers D. Sumner, H.B. Hemingson, D.M. Deutscher, and J.E. Barth
Abstract The flow around cylinders of circular, square, and diamond cross-section oscillating in quiescent fluid was studied experimentally using particle image velocimetry (PIV). Phase-averaged measurements of the velocity field were obtained at the maximum-amplitude, zero-amplitude, and intermediate positions of the oscillation cycle. The experiments were performed at low Keulegan-Carpenter numbers, from KC D 1 to 3.5, and for moderate Stokes numbers, from ˇ D 250 to 376. Within this range of KC, the flow patterns remained symmetric about either side of the cylinders. For KC D 1, the flow remained close to the surface of the cylinders throughout the cycle. For KC D 1:5 to 3.5, an attached vortex pair formed behind the circular and square cylinders at the maximum-amplitude position. The distinct geometry of the diamond cylinder, with two fixed separation points, led to a unique but still symmetric vortex pattern. Keywords Unsteady flow Bluff body Cylinder Oscillation Particle image velocimetry
1 Introduction The flow around a two-dimensional circular cylinder of diameter, D, oscillating sinusoidally from side to side with amplitude, A, and frequency, f (or period, T D 1=f ), in quiescent fluid of kinematic viscosity, , can be considered a fundamental problem in unsteady fluid mechanics (Fig. 1). The flow is a useful starting point for the study of flow-induced vibrations and has applications in the behaviour of offshore structures in wave motion. The time-dependent cylinder position, x.t/, and velocity, u.t/, are given by
D. Sumner (), H.B. Hemingson, D.M. Deutscher, and J.E. Barth Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Saskatchewan, 57 Campus Drive, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada, S7N 5A9 e-mail:
[email protected] M. Braza and K. Hourigan (eds.), IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control, IUTAM Bookseries 14, c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
3
4
D. Sumner et al.
Fig. 1 Circular cylinder of diameter, D, oscillating with amplitude, A, in a quiescent fluid
x.t/ D A sin .!t / and u.t/ D Umax cos .!t/ ;
(1) (2)
respectively, where t is time, !.D 2πf / is the angular frequency, and Umax is the maximum cylinder velocity, Umax D A! D 2Af D 2A=T:
(3)
Experimental [1,7–10,13,14] and numerical [3,12,15] studies of the oscillating circular cylinder have identified several flow regimes, which are primarily a function of the dimensionless amplitude parameter known as the Keulegan-Carpenter number, KC, where KC D Umax T =D D 2A=D: (4) A second influencing parameter is the Reynolds number, Re, which is defined using the maximum cylinder velocity, Re D Umax D= D 2ADf =:
(5)
The dimensionless Stokes number (or reduced frequency), ˇ, is often used instead of the Reynolds number and behaves in a similar manner, where ˇ D Re=KC D fD 2 =:
(6)
The number of flow regimes, and the limiting values of KC defining these regimes, are functions of Re or ˇ. For sufficiently high values of ˇ, the flow regime is almost solely determined by KC. The flow patterns are distinguished by the “wake re-encounter” phenomenon, where separated flow and vortices formed and shed by the cylinder during one half cycle return to interact with the cylinder during the next half cycle [5]. For KC 1, the flow does not appreciably separate from the cylinder and the extent of the ambient fluid affected by the moving cylinder is small. For 1 < KC < 4, the flow separates from the cylinder and a symmetric pair of attached vortices forms behind the cylinder during each half cycle. For 4 KC < 8, the attached vortex pair becomes asymmetric. For KC 8, vortex shedding occurs during each half cycle [5, 14]. Similar flow regimes and KC boundaries can be identified
PIV Measurements of the Flow Around Oscillating Cylinders at Low KC Numbers
5
for square and diamond-shaped cylinders, as shown in several experimental [1, 8, 9] and numerical [11, 12] studies. For the circular cylinder, the separation points are free to move over large distances during an oscillation cycle [10]. However, for the oscillating square cylinder, the separation points are fixed at the four corners; for the oscillating diamond cylinder, there are only two fixed separation points. There are relatively few experimental studies of oscillating cylinders which report velocity field measurements [2, 4, 6]. In the present study, particle image velocimetry (PIV) was used to measure the velocity field of oscillating circular, square and diamond cylinders at low KC numbers. The PIV measurements were phase locked with the cylinder position, at the zero-amplitude (corresponding to dimensionless time t D t=T D 0, 0.5), maximum-amplitude (t D 0:25, 0.75), and intermediate positions (t D 0:125, 0.375, 0.625, 0.875) in the oscillation cycle.
2 Experimental Approach The oscillating cylinder experiments were conducted in water in an X–Y towing tank (Fig. 2) with internal dimensions of 3.96 m long, 1.03 m wide, and 0.75 m deep. The glass side walls, end walls, and floor of the towing tank give optical access for the PIV system. The primary towing direction (X-direction, 3.5 m of travel) is along the length of the tank, where the main carriage straddles the tank width and moves on two parallel rails. A linear motion stage containing the secondary carriage is mounted on the main carriage for transverse movement across the tank (Y-direction, 260 mm of travel).
Fig. 2 Three-view drawing of the X–Y towing tank showing the circular cylinder suspended in the water beneath the Y-motion stage
6
D. Sumner et al.
The motion control system for the X–Y towing tank includes a personal computer, a National Instruments (NI) PCI-7344 motion controller card, two Intelligent Motion Systems IM1007 micro-step drivers, and a stepping motor on each axis. Encoders provide closed-loop position feedback. The user interface was developed in the LabVIEW programming language. In the present study, only the secondary carriage (Y-direction) was used. A circular or square cylinder of D D 25:4 mm (for the square cylinder, D corresponds to the side length) was suspended in the water vertically beneath the Y-motion stage (Fig. 2). The cylinder aspect ratio ranged from AR D 25:5 to 26.7. The oscillation amplitude ranged from A D 4:04 to 14.15 mm (giving KC D 1 to 3.5). The oscillation frequency ranged from f D 0:38 to 0.60 Hz (giving ˇ D 250 to 376 and Re D 374 to 875); see Table 1. Velocity field measurements (u and v components, in the x and y directions, respectively) were made with a TSI PIV system. Laser light was supplied by a 120-mJ/pulse dual Nd:YAG laser. The light sheet was located 29.2 cm above the lower end of the cylinder. Images were acquired with a TSI PIVCAM 10–30 (1 Megapixel) camera in a fixed location beneath the tank. The timing was controlled by a TSI LaserPulse synchronizer and Insight 5 software and was phase-locked to a reference signal from the motion control system. The water was seeded with 8–12-μm hollow glass spheres. Image pairs were processed with a single-pass Nyquist grid algorithm, a FFT correlation algorithm, and a Gaussian peak detection algorithm. The interrogation window was 32 32 pixels. The field of view was approximately 80 80 mm (60 60 vectors with 50% overlap) giving a spatial resolution greater than [4] but lower than [6]. For each phase (cylinder position), an ensemble average of 250 instantaneous velocity vector fields was obtained. The cylinder completed at least 50 oscillation cycles before PIV measurements were made, to give sufficient time for the flow patterns to be established. The numerical simulations of [12] showed that at least 15 cycles were needed to reach equilibrium flow behaviour.
Table 1 Summary of oscillating cylinder experiments Cylinder Circular Circular Circular Circular Circular Circular Square Square Square
KC 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
ˇ 376 325 250 250 250 250 375 325 250
Re 376 488 499 625 751 875 375 488 500
A/D 0.159 0.239 0.318 0.398 0.477 0.557 0.159 0.239 0.318
Cylinder Square Square Square Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond
KC 2.5 3.0 3.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5
ˇ 250 250 250 374 325 251 250 250 250
Re 625 750 875 374 488 502 625 751 875
A/D 0.398 0.477 0.557 0.159 0.239 0.318 0.398 0.477 0.557
PIV Measurements of the Flow Around Oscillating Cylinders at Low KC Numbers
7
3 Results and Discussion For the range of KC numbers investigated, 1 KC 3:5, the flow fields were symmetric about the axis of motion and on opposite ends of the cylinder for subsequent half-cycles, for all three cylinder geometries. Selected results (only vorticity results are presented here) are shown in Figs. 3–5.
Fig. 3 Phase-averaged vorticity fields for an oscillating circular cylinder at the zero- .t D 0/ and maximum-amplitude .t D 0:25/ positions, cylinder moving to the right: (a) KC D 1:5; ˇ D 325; (b) KC D 2; ˇ D 250; (c) KC D 2:5; ˇ D 250; (d) KC D 3:5; ˇ D 250. Solid isovorticity contour lines represent positive (CCW) vorticity; dashed lines represent negative (CW) vorticity. Minimum vorticity contour of ! D 0:5, contour increment of ! D 0:5
8
D. Sumner et al.
Fig. 4 Phase-averaged vorticity fields for an oscillating square cylinder at intermediate- .t D 0:125/ and maximum-amplitude .t D 0:25/ positions, cylinder moving to the right: (a) KC D 1; ˇ D 375; (b) KC D 2; ˇ D 250; (c) KC D 3; ˇ D 250. Contour lines as in Fig. 3
PIV Measurements of the Flow Around Oscillating Cylinders at Low KC Numbers
9
Fig. 5 Phase-averaged vorticity fields for an oscillating diamond cylinder at the zero- .t D 0/ and maximum-amplitude .t D 0:25/ positions, cylinder moving to the right: (a) KC D 1; ˇ D 374; (b) KC D 2; ˇ D 251; (c) KC D 3; ˇ D 250. Contour lines as in Fig. 3
10
D. Sumner et al.
3.1 Circular Cylinder For the oscillating circular cylinder (Fig. 3), frame-by-frame analysis of the instantaneous velocity fields did not show any asymmetry on either side of the axis of motion up to KC D 3:5, consistent with [14, 15]. The flow at these KC numbers is characterized, for the most part, by the formation and movement of concentrations of vorticity and/or symmetric vortex pairs behind and about the cylinder. At KC D 1, the fluid is swept symmetrically around the circular cylinder from the front to the rear, the process repeating itself with minimal disturbance to the surrounding fluid as the cylinder reverses direction. The region of disturbed, separated flow is small and remains close to the cylinder surface throughout the range of motion, consistent with [5, 15]. The largest concentrations of vorticity are seen on either side of the cylinder at the zero-amplitude .t D 0/ position. As the cylinder moves toward the maximum-amplitude position .t D 0:25/, these concentrations are swept behind the circular cylinder and weaken. At KC D 1:5 (Fig. 2a), the flow field is generally similar to KC D 1, with the separated flow remaining close to the cylinder throughout the cycle. However, a small, weak attached vortex pair is observed behind the circular cylinder at the maximum-amplitude position .t D 0:25/, which is the primary feature of the flow regime for 1 < KC < 4. For KC D 2 (Fig. 2b), the flow behind the cylinder at maximum amplitude .t D 0:25/ contains a prominent attached symmetric vortex pair, similar to what is observed in the near-wake region of an impulsively started circular cylinder, where each vortex is of similar size and strength but of opposite sign. Behind this vortex pair is weaker detached vortex pair, with vortices of opposite sign to those that are attached. As the cylinder reverses direction .t D 0:375/, the attached vortex pair is now ahead of the moving cylinder, and it quickly diminishes in size and vanishes; this is consistent with the simulations of [3]. The flow is similar for KC D 2:5 (Fig. 2c), where a strong attached vortex pair forms at maximum amplitude .t D 0:25/. This is accompanied by the detached vortex pair of opposite sign extending further from the cylinder. As the cylinder reverses direction, the attached vortex pair disappears .t D 0:375/ while the detached vortex pair is split by the approaching cylinder .t D 0:5/. These two concentrations of vorticity are then entrained into the new attached vortex pair that forms behind the cylinder on the opposite side .t D 0:625/. At KC D 3 (Fig. 2d) and 3.5, the attached vortex pair is stronger and more prominent than at KC D 2 and 2.5. The behaviour is characterized by the movement of vortex pairs around the circular cylinder from the front to rear [12, 14]. As the cylinder reverses direction (t D 0:375, 0.5) the attached vortices no longer disappear. Instead, they detach from the cylinder and sweep around into the new wake that is developing behind the cylinder (t D 0:5, 0.625). As this happens, they pair up with the developing vortices that will form the attached vortex pair at the next maximum-amplitude position. The swept vortices eventually meet and pair up downstream of the attached vortex pair.
PIV Measurements of the Flow Around Oscillating Cylinders at Low KC Numbers
11
3.2 Square Cylinder For the oscillating square cylinder (Fig. 4), the four sharp corners lead to welldefined separation points. Vortex formation from the leading corners leads to a wider region of disturbed flow compared to the circular cylinder [9]. For KC D 1 (Fig. 4a), the vortex structures that form during the cycle remain close to the cylinder surface. Movement of vorticity along the upper and lower surfaces of the cylinder results in the formation of a vortex pair at each of the rear corners at the maximum-amplitude position .t D 0:25/. For KC D 1:5 and 2 (Fig. 4b), an attached vortex pair forms behind the square cylinder, similar to what is observed for the circular cylinder, and consistent with [9]. The vortex pair does not meet at the flow centerline; rather, at the maximum-amplitude position .t D 0:25/, there is an arrangement of four vortices of alternating sign on the rear surface of the cylinder, and another pair of vortices of opposite sign at the rear corners (Fig. 4b). The flow pattern has distinct differences at KC D 3 (Fig. 4c) and 3.5 (the flow pattern for KC D 2:5 can be considered transitional). The pairs of vortices at the rear corners are less prominent. Flow separation from the front corners of the square cylinder leads to the formation of small corner vortices. The corner vortices from the previous half cycle enter the wake of the cylinder and form a second, detached vortex pair of opposite sign situated behind the main attached vortex pair (shown for t D 0:125 in Fig. 4c). The detached vortex pair weakens at the maximumamplitude position .t D 0:25/ and is absent when KC D 3:5.
3.3 Diamond Cylinder The flow around the oscillating diamond cylinder (Fig. 5) is distinct from the circular and square cylinders, being characterized by flow separation and vorticity production at the upper and lower sharp corners. In the direction of motion, the angled flat surfaces meet at the front sharp corner that forms the leading edge. Each flat surface pushes the fluid to the side and some of the fluid flows around the upper and lower corners into the wake. In the base region, the angled flat surfaces meet at the rear sharp corner that forms the trailing edge. For KC D 1 (Fig. 5a), appreciable fluid movement is confined mainly to the regions about the upper and lower corners, where large concentrations of vorticity are produced. The sign of the upper and lower corner vorticity concentrations alternates from one half cycle to the next. During the half cycle, these concentrations of vorticity move behind the diamond cylinder to positions on the angled flat surfaces on the trailing edge. At the maximum-amplitude position .t D 0:25/, an attached pair of opposite-sign vortices has formed on both the upper and lower angled flat surfaces on the rear of the diamond cylinder. Narrow rows of vorticity, resembling free shear layers, extend away from the diamond cylinder parallel to the axis of motion on the upper and lower sides of the flow field.
12
D. Sumner et al.
For KC D 1:5, 2 (Fig. 5b), and 2.5, large concentrations of vorticity are produced at the upper and lower sharp corners. These vorticity concentrations are convected into the wake of the diamond cylinder. On the angled flat surfaces at the rear of the cylinder, each pairs up with a vorticity concentration of opposite sign. At the maximum-amplitude position .t D 0:25/, an attached vortex pair has formed on each of the rear angled flat surfaces. For KC D 3 (Fig. 5c) and 3.5, only a single, large attached vortex forms on each of the flat surfaces at the rear of the diamond cylinder. Weaker concentrations of vorticity of opposite sign form further downstream, but are not attached to the flat surfaces (as in the case of KC D 1:5 to 2.5).
4 Conclusions In the present study, PIV was used to study the velocity and vorticity fields for circular, square and diamond cylinders oscillating in quiescent fluid at low KeuleganCarpenter numbers (KC D 1 to 3.5) and moderate Stokes numbers (ˇ D 250 to 376). Phase-averaged velocity and vorticity fields were obtained at the maximumamplitude, zero-amplitude, and intermediate positions of the oscillation cycle. The flow patterns remained symmetric about either side of the oscillation axis. For KC D 1, the flow remained close to the cylinder surfaces throughout the oscillation cycle. For KC D 1:5 to 3.5, attached vortex pairs formed behind the cylinders at the maximum-amplitude position. The flow around the diamond cylinder was generally distinct from the circular and square cylinders, which can be attributed, in part, to its different base geometry. Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the support of the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (NSERC), the Canada Foundation for Innovation (CFI), and the Innovation and Science Fund of Saskatchewan. The assistance of M.G. Crane, O.J.P. Dansereau, J.L. Heseltine, and Engineering Shops is appreciated.
References 1. Bearman, P.W., Graham, J.M.R., Obasaju, E.D., and Drossopoulos, G.M., The influence of corner radius on the forces experienced by cylindrical bluff bodies in oscillatory flow. Appl. Ocean Res. 6 (1984) 83–89. 2. D¨utsch, H., Durst, F., Becker, S., and Lienhart, H., Low-Reynolds-number flow around an oscillating circular cylinder at low Keulegan-Carpenter numbers. J. Fluid Mech. 360 (1998) 249–271. 3. Iliadis, G. and Anagnostopoulos, P., Viscous oscillatory flow around a circular cylinder at low Keulegan-Carpenter numbers and frequency parameters. Int. J. Num. Meth. Fluids 26 (1998) 403–442. 4. Lam, K.M. and Dai, G.Q., Formation of vortex street and vortex pair from a circular cylinder oscillating in water. Exp. Therm. Fluid Sci. 26 (2002) 901–915.
PIV Measurements of the Flow Around Oscillating Cylinders at Low KC Numbers
13
5. Lin, X.W., Bearman, P.W., and Graham, J.M.R., A numerical study of oscillatory flow about a circular cylinder for low values of beta parameter. J. Fluid Struct. 10 (1996) 501–526. 6. Lin, J.C. and Rockwell, D., Quantitative interpretation of vortices from a cylinder oscillating in quiescent fluid. Exp. Fluids 23 (1997) 99–104. 7. Obasaju, E.D., Bearman, P.W., and Graham, J.M.R., A study of forces, circulation and vortex patterns around a circular cylinder in oscillating flow. J. Fluid Mech. 196 (1988) 467–494. 8. Okajima, A., Matsumoto, T., and Kimura, S., Force measurements and flow visualization of bluff bodies in oscillatory flow. J. Wind Eng. Ind. Aerod. 69–71 (1997) 213–228. 9. Okajima, A., Matsumoto, T., and Kimura, S., Force measurements and flow visualization of circular and square cylinders in oscillatory flow. JSME Int. J. B-Fluid T. 41 (1998) 796–805. 10. Sarpkaya, T. and Butterworth, W., Separation points on a cylinder in oscillating flow. J. Offshore Mech. Arct. 114 (1992) 28–35. 11. Scolan, Y.-M. and Faltinsen, O.M., Numerical studies of separated flow from bodies with sharp corners by the vortex in cell method. J. Fluid Struct. 8 (1994) 201–230. 12. Smith, P.A. and Stansby, P.K., Viscous oscillatory flow around cylindrical bodies at low Keulegan-Carpenter numbers using the vortex method. J. Fluid Struct. 5 (1991) 339–361. 13. Tatsuno, M. and Bearman, P.W., A visual study of the flow around an oscillating circular cylinder at low Keulegan-Carpenter numbers and low Stokes numbers. J. Fluid Mech. 211 (1990) 157–182. 14. Williamson, C.H.K., Sinusoidal flow relative to circular cylinders. J. Fluid Mech. 155 (1985) 141–174. 15. Zhang, H.-L. and Zhang, X., Flow structure analysis around an oscillating circular cylinder at low KC number: a numerical study. Comp. Fluids 26 (1997) 83–106.
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Coherent and Turbulent Process Analysis in the Flow Past a Circular Cylinder at High Reynolds Number R. Perrin, M. Braza, E. Cid, S. Cazin, P. Chassaing, C. Mockett, T. Reimann, and F. Thiele
Abstract With the aim of providing a database useful for validation and improvement of turbulence models for strongly detached flows, the flow past a circular cylinder at high Reynolds number has been experimentally studied using PIV, stereoscopic PIV and Time Resolved PIV in the very near wake. As the presence of coherent structures and their non linear interactions with the turbulent motion have to be taken into account in a model, a particular attention was paid to the decomposition of the flow into a coherent and a turbulent part. This was achieved using phase averaging and also using Proper Orthogonal Decomposition. In a precedent study, it was found that the POD coefficients could be used to define a phase angle representative of the vortex shedding, and that defining the phase angle from the POD coefficients may alleviate the overestimation of the turbulent stresses due to phase jitter between the trigger signal and the velocity, compared to a definition of the phase angle from a wall pressure time trace. In this paper two new complementary data sets, which are resolved in time and space, are analysed with the objectives of, first, providing an evaluation of the performed conditional averaging and, second, to achieve a more complete description of the flow. The main results presented here are issued from Time Resolved PIV measurements which were carried out in the near wake. Some results of a Detached Eddy Simulation which have been validated against experiment, are also used. Keywords Cylinder wake Phase averaging POD Time Resolved PIV DES
R. Perrin (), M. Braza, E. Cid, S. Cazin, and P. Chassaing Institut de M´ecanique des Fluides de Toulouse, Unit´e Mixte C.N.R.S.-I.N.P.T. 5502, Av. du Prof. Camille Soula, 31400 Toulouse, France Present address: Laboratoire d’Etude A´erodynamique (LEA), Universit´e de Poitiers, ENSMA,CNRS, France R. Perrin, C. Mockett, T. Reimann, and F. Thiele Institut f¨ur Str¨omungsmechanik un Technische Akustik, TU-Berlin, M¨uller Breslau Str. 8, 10623 Berlin, Germany M. Braza and K. Hourigan (eds.), IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control, IUTAM Bookseries 14, c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
15
16
R. Perrin et al.
1 Introduction Modelling and simulating unsteady turbulent flows past bluff bodies remains a very challenging task, given the strong separations, and the presence of coherent structures in non linear interactions with the turbulent motion, which have to be taken into account in the model used. A experimental data base concerning this class of flow, which can be used for validation or improvement of modelling, is therefore of significant relevance. In this study, the generic case of a circular cylinder was chosen, first because of the strong separations and the presence of coherent structures, and also, because of the symmetries of the flow, which allow adapted processing, and then a better visualisation of the flow. With the aim of allowing direct comparison possible with simulations, and therefore evaluations of the models themselves, the cylinder was placed in a confined environment (a square channel) with a high blockage coefficient and a low aspect ratio, thereby allowing simulations to be made on a domain of moderate size, corresponding to the experimental geometry, with the use of well defined boundary conditions. In precedent studies, the data base was achieved using pressure measurements, PIV, stereoscopic PIV and Time Resolved PIV, carried out near the separation and in the very near wake of the cylinder, [10]. The main limitation concerning the TRPIV measurements was the size of the domain which was smaller than that of the low data rate acquisitions, due to the low energy of the laser used. A particular attention was paid to the decomposition of the flow into a coherent part and a turbulent part. To this purpose, phase averaging, using pressure on the cylinder as a reference signal, and POD have been first applied and compared. Both decompositions have been analysed with the help of TRPIV measurements in the small domain, by comparing the contributions of coherent and turbulent fluctuations to the mean Reynolds stress tensor. It has been found, in agreement with many other studies (e.g. [1]), that phase averaging with pressure leads to an overestimation of the turbulent motion and a smoothing of the K´arm´an vortices, resulting from phase lags occurring at certain instants between the pressure signal and the velocity to be averaged in the wake. On the other hand, POD was found useful to analyse the different parts of the flow, but the main difficulty lies in the choice of the modes to reconstruct the coherent motion. An enhancement of the phase averaging was then achieved, using a definition of the phase angle based on the first two POD coefficients, and thereby alleviating the phase lags effects as the phase is determined directly from the velocity fields to be averaged. This phase averaging was obtained from low data rate PIV. Two new complementary data sets are analysed in this study. First, Time Resolved PIV measurements have been carried out in a domain of similar size as that of the low data rate PIV, using a cylinder of smaller physical size and a laser delivering more energy. Also, a Detached Eddy Simulation has been performed on a domain which corresponds precisely to the experiment. Then, the objectives of this study is both, to use these data resolved in space and time to evaluate the performed conditional averaging, and to achieve a better analysis of the flow.
Coherent and Turbulent Process Analysis
17
Section 2 briefly presents the configuration of the flow and the new measurements which were carried out, together which some comparisons with previous measurements. In Section 3, the instantaneous motion is analysed. Section 4 is devoted to the analysis of POD and phase averaging. Finally an analysis of coherent and incoherent quantities is conducted in Section 5.
2 Configuration and Experimental Set-Up The experiments were conducted in the wind tunnels S1 and S4 of IMFT. As mentioned in the preceding section, a high blockage coefficient and a low aspect ratio were employed to allow comparison with simulations carried out on a domain corresponding precisely to the experimental geometry without the use of ’infinite boundary conditions’. For the previous measurements, the cylinder had a diameter of 14 cm and was placed in a square channel of cross section 6767 cm, leading to a blockage coefficient of D=H D 0:21 and an aspect ratio of L=D D 4:8. Due to the low energy of the laser used, and to the access of the wind tunnel, the previous TRPIV measurements were limited to a small domain. To carry out TRPIV on a larger domain in the wake, the new measurements have been done in the wind tunnel S4 of IMFT, which has a cross section of 61 71 cm. To keep the same blockage coefficient as in the previous measurement, the diameter of the cylinder was chosen 12.5 cm, which results in a blockage coefficient of 0.21 and an aspect ratio of 5.7. Although this aspect ratio is different from the previous one and therefore the flow was not expected to be rigourously the same, it will be shown that a good agreement with the old measurements is achieved for the mean flow and the velocity spectra. A detailed description of the former measurements by low data rate PIV can be found in [11], as well as the procedure used for the reconstruction of the three components in stereoscopic measurements. The new measurements were done using a laser Darwin 220 mJ from Excel Technology, a camera CMOS APX (PHOTRON) with a resolution of 1024 1024 pixels, and DEHS as seeding particles (typical size 1 μm). The system allowed acquisition of image pairs at a rate of 1 kHz. The image pairs were analysed using an in-house code ‘PIVIS’ developed by the ‘Services Signaux Images’ of IMFT, which uses an algorithm based on a 2D FFT cross correlation function implemented in an iterative scheme with a sub-pixel image deformation ([5]). The flow was analysed by cross-correlating 50% overlapping windows of 32 32pixels, yielding fields of 61 57 vectors with a spatial resolution of 3 mm (0.0238D). Approximately 2% of the calculated vectors were detected as outliers using a sort based on the norm, the signal-to-noise ratio, and a median test filter, and these vectors were replaced using a second order least square interpolation scheme. Six temporal series of 3,072 images pairs have been acquired and analysed, each series containing approximately 85 vortex shedding periods. Before presenting results in the following sections, some comparisons between these new TRPIV measurements and the former measurements are necessary, given the small differences in the experimental set-up. First, some comparisons
18
R. Perrin et al.
y/D = 0.5
0.8 W21
0.4
5 4.5 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 −0.5 −1 −1.5 −2 −2.5 −3 −3.5 −4 −4.5 −5
-3 -2.5 -2 -1.5 -1
y/D
0.2
-0.5 0 0.5
-0.2 1.5
-0.4 -0.6
3 2.5
1
2
1
1.5
x/D
2
y/D = 0.4
y/D = 0.3
Sv
0.6
y/D = 0.2
y/D = 0.1
10
−2
10
−1
St
10
0
(a) iso contours of 21 (top: low data rate PIV, bot- (b) spectra of v at x=D D 1, and differtom: TRPIV) ent y=D Fig. 1 Comparison of new measurements with the old measurements
between the TRPIV measurements and the former measurements are made. Figure 1a shows a comparison of the mean 21 component of the rotation rate tensor. Although not shown here, the recirculation length is found 1.25 and agrees well with the value of 1.28 found with low data rate PIV. Figure 1b shows a comparison of velocity spectra at the same points issue from the new TRPIV measurements, and TRPIV performed in the S1 wind tunnel. A very good agreement is also achieved. Therefore, the influence of the aspect ratio which had to be modified comparing to the previous studies is found to not have a important effect in the middle span plane. Some results of a Detached Eddy Simulation, which has been performed on a domain that corresponds precisely to the experimental geometry, are also presented in this paper. This simulation, which have been validated against experiment using time averaging, phase averaging and POD in [12], will be presented in details in a companion paper [8] and the numerical details are not presented here. The data set analysed here consists in 14,000 instantaneous snapshots, corresponding to approximately 90 vortex shedding periods, the dimensionless time step being 0.0321.
3 Instantaneous Motion Figure 2 shows a sequence of instantaneous vorticity and velocity, corresponding approximately to half a period (one picture every three is represented and one velocity vector every two is represented). The vortex shedding is clearly shown, together with smaller vortices in the separated shear layer which are wrapped around the K´arm´an vortices. This behavior is in good agreement with the measurements of [7] at a lower Reynolds number, although the flow is more irregular, as could be expected at this high Reynolds number.
Coherent and Turbulent Process Analysis 0.6 W21 10 8 6 4 2 1 -1 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10
0
-0.2 -0.4
10 8 6 4 2 1 -1 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10
0.2 0
-0.2 -0.4
1
1.5
x /D
-0.4
1.5
x /D
2
1
(b) t=9.5424
0.6
0.2 0
-0.2 -0.4 -0.6
10 8 6 4 2 1 -1 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10
0.2 0
-0.2 -0.4
2
W21
0.4
10 8 6 4 2 1 -1 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10
0.2 0
-0.2 -0.4 -0.6
-0.6
1.5
1.5
0.6 W21
0.4
y/D
10 8 6 4 2 1 -1 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10
x/D
(c) t=9.9456
0.6 W21
0.4
x /D
0 -0.2
-0.6
1
2
(a) t=9.1392
1
10 8 6 4 2 1 -1 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10
0.2
-0.6
-0.6
W21
0.4
y/D
y/D
0.2
0.6 W21
0.4
y/D
0.4
y/D
0.6
y/D
19
2
1
(d) t=10.3488
1.5
x/D
1
2
x/D
1.5
2
(f) t=11.1552
(e) t=10.752
Fig. 2 Sequence of instantaneous fields (TRPIV)
1 0
100
−1
10−1
10
Su
−1
10
−2
10
−3
10
−2
10
−1
10
0
10
fD/U
10
1 0
10
Su
0
10
Su
101
10
1
10
−2
−2
10
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 y/D
10
−3
10
−4
10
−2
10
−1
10
10
0
fD/U
1
0
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 y/D
−3
10
−4
10
−2
10
10
10
0
10
fD/U
(b) U at x/D=1.3
(a) U at x/D=0.5
−1
10
1
0
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 y/D
(c) U at x/D=2
2
10
1
10
1
10
0
10
10 0
−1
10
−2
10
−3
10
−2
10
−1
10
0
10
fD/U
1
10
0
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 y/D
(d) V at x/D=0.5
10
Sv
Sv
Sv
10
−1
10
10
−2
10
−3
10
−2
10
−1
10
0
10 fD/U
10
1
0
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 y/D
(e) V at x/D=1.3
10 10
1 0
−1 −2 −3
10
−2
10
−1
10
0
fD/U
1
0
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 y/D
10
(f) V at x/D=2
Fig. 3 Velocity spectra in the near wake (TRPIV)
Regarding the velocity spectra, shown in Fig. 3 at different locations, they classically exhibit a peak and harmonics which are linked with the vortex shedding, and a continuous part which corresponds to the turbulent motion. As expected, due to the absolute character of the von K´arm´an instability, the peak which corresponds to the vortex shedding is found at the same dimensionless frequency at every point (Strouhal number St D 0.21). On the rear axis, the first harmonic is predominant in the u spectrum due to the symmetry of the flow. It is also seen that the level of the second harmonic increases as x=D increases, especially for v.
20
R. Perrin et al. 1
V
1
0.5 0 0
v,p
v,p
−0.5 −1
−1
−1.5 −2
−2
−2.5
P
−3 0
100
200
300
400
150
t*
200
250
300
t*
Fig. 4 Time signal of V velocity at x=D D 1, y=D D 0:5 and of the pressure signal at D 70ı from the simulation (left) and the experiment (right)
The same temporal behavior has been found in the DES simulation. Looking at the time signals of velocity and pressure obtained from the experiments and the simulation, it also appears that some irregularities are present at certain instants (Fig. 4 at t ' 350 and t ' 400 for the DES and t ' 240 for the experiment). During these instants, which do not appear with a regular frequency, the periodic component of the pressure and of the velocity in the very near wake seems to disappear and the ‘mean value’ of v tends to zero. By looking at the field on a larger domain, it appears that the formation of the vortices occurs further downstream in the wake, the velocity signal at a position further downstream still exhibiting a periodic component (Fig. 5).
4 POD and Phase Averaging The quasi periodicity of the vortex shedding allows the use of phase averaging, according to [13], using the triple decomposition: Ui D Ui C UQi C u0i
(1)
where Ui is the time-independent mean flow, UQi is the quasi periodic fluctuating component, u0i is the random fluctuating component, and hUi i D Ui C UQi is the phase averaged velocity. In [11], this was done using the pressure signal on the cylinder at D 70ı as a trigger signal. In [10], it was shown that due to phase lags occurring at certain instants between the pressure signal and the velocity in the wake, a residual periodic component remained in the ‘random fluctuation’, the spectra of which exhibited a small peak in addition to the continuous part. As a result, the contribution of the coherent motion to the time independent Reynolds stresses was underestimated
Coherent and Turbulent Process Analysis
21
1
1
+
+
+
0
-0.5
1
x/D
2
+
2
3
0
-1
3
v
1 0.5 0 −0.5 −1
0
1
x/D
1 0.5 0 −0.5 −1
350 355 360 365 370 375 380 385 390 395 400 405 410 415
t* 1
320
330
340
320
330
340
t*
350
360
370
380
350
360
370
380
1
0
v
v
+
-0.5
-1 0
v
+
0.5
y/D
y/D
0.5
−1
0 −1
350 355 360 365 370 375 380 385 390 395 400 405 410 415
t*
t*
Fig. 5 Near wake behavior at instants where the shedding is regular (left) and irregular (right). top: DES, bottom: TRPIV
and that of the random motion was overestimated. To alleviate this problem, the phase angle was then defined using the coefficients associated with the two first POD modes, following [2, 14]. It was shown that the vortices was less smoothed by the averaging, and that the level of the contribution of the ‘random motion’ to the time independent Reynolds stresses was diminished. The data used here, which are resolved in space and time, allow to look more precisely at the time evolution of the POD coefficients, as well as the achieved decomposition from a spectral point of view. Figure 6a–c show the first POD modes, obtained from the TRPIV measurements. In agreement with many other studies in wakes ([3, 9]), the two first mode are linked with the von K´arm´an vortices. Spectra of the coefficients associated with these modes are represented in Fig. 6d. As expected, the spectra of the first two coefficients mainly exhibit a peak at the Strouhal frequency. The spectrum of the third coefficient is more important in the low frequency range. The temporal evolution of
22
R. Perrin et al.
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.2
0
y /D
0.6
0.4
y /D
0.6
0.4
y/ D
0.6
0
0
−0.2
−0.2
−0.2
−0.4
−0.4
−0.4
−0.6
−0.6 0.8
2
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
−0.6 0.8
2
2
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2
x/D
x/D
(b) mode 2
(a) mode 1
0.8
2
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2
x/D
(c) mode 3
2
10
a1 a2 a3
1
10
0
10
−1
10
−5/3
−2
10
−3
10
−4
10
−5
10
−6
10
−2
10
−1
10
0
fD / U
10
1
10
(d) spectra of POD coefficients (e) time evolution of coeffi- (f) spectrum of v, VQ and v0 at cients a1 , a2 and 'POD x=D D 1:5, y=D D 0:5 Fig. 6 POD and phase averaging (TRPIV)
the first two coefficients, represented in figure 6e, confirms the possibility to define a phase angle representative of the vortex shedding using: p 22 a1 'POD D arctan. p / 21 a2
(2)
where 1 and 2 are the corresponding eigenvalues. The time evolution of this phase angle is represented on Fig. 6e. As this phase angle is defined directly from the velocity to be averaged, the effects of the phase lags occurring between the reference signal and the velocity are expected to be alleviated. For the phase averaging, the instants where the shedding is irregular discussed in the preceding section have been detected and removed. As a low amplitude of the first two POD coefficients q is observed during these instants, this was achieved by
applying a threshold to a12 C a22 . Approximately 20% of the signal was rejected. Although not shown here, this phase averaging have also been applied to the numerical data, and as simulation give access to the whole domain, the influence of the region on which is performed POD have been studied. It appears that the peak in the spectra are well represented by the two first POD modes when using a region which is extended up to approximately 5D. Taking a larger region leads to obtain more modes linked with the von K´arm´an vortices, and then it is difficult to define a phase angle. However, the definition of a phase angle when POD is performed in the near wake allows the phase averaging on all the domain, and the results appears similar to those achieved for the experiment.
Coherent and Turbulent Process Analysis
23
The resulting phase averaged motion and fluctuation away from this phase average can be view from a spectral point of view. Figure 6f shows spectra of vQ and v0 at x=D D 1:5 and y=D D 0:5. A significant reduction of the residual peak in the v0 spectrum is achieved using POD coefficients, confirming that the effects of phase jitter are alleviated. The same conclusions have been obtained for the simulation.
5 Analysis of Phase Averaged and Turbulent Motion The phase averaged fields and phase averaged turbulent stresses obtained are presented in this section. Figure 7 shows the phase averaged velocity, the h21 i component of the rotation rate tensor, the turbulent stresses obtained from 2C-PIV and 3C-PIV, as well as the turbulent kinetic energy and the production term at the phase angle ' D 45ı . h21 i clearly exhibits the vortex shedding. The maximum value at the centre of the vortices is of order 3 at x=D ' 1 during their formation and decreases to 2 at
-3
1.2
0.4 0.6
-0.5
1.4
1.2
1
0.8
0
1
-0.5
1
1.5
2
1
1.5
x/D
0.2
0.1
y/D
y/D
0.2
0.2
-1
4
3
1
1.5
2
x/D
(c) h21 i
0.25
0.15
0
0.15
vv
0.2
0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0
0.1 0.05
0.2
0.1
0.6 0.25
0.15
0.2
0.4
w2 0.3 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0.02 0
0.15
0.2 0.2
0
0.1
0.1 0.15 0.05
-0.2 -0.5
1.5
-0.4
2
1
1.5
x/D
(d) hu i -0.12
0.5
1
1.5
-0.08
0.02
0.04
0 0.02 0.04
1.5
0.3
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.15 0.2
0
0.25
0.2
0.7
1.5
x/D
0.3 0.1
(h) hki
Fig. 7 Phase averaged quantities at ' D 45ı
P 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1
0
-0.2 -0.4
2
0.5
0.2
-0.6
1
0.7
0.4
0.1
-0.2 -0.4
2
0.6
0.1 k 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0
0.2
x/D
(g) huvi
0.2 0.25
0.05
0.02
0.12
0.25
0.5
0.04
0.2 0.16 0.12 0.08 0.04 0.02 -0.02 -0.04 -0.08 -0.12 -0.16 -0.2
y/D
0.02
0.08
(f) hw i 2
0.5
0.6 uv
2
x/D
(e) hv i
-0.04
1
2
2
-0.02
0.04
0.02
x/D
2
y/D
-0.5
2
5 4 3 2 1 0.5 -0.5 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5
0.15
1
-0.5
3
2
0.2
uu
0.05
0.5
0.2
0.1
0.5 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0
0
-0.5
0.05
0.1
0.1
0.15
0
(b) hV i
0.15 0.1
04
1
x/D
(a) hU i 0.25
-2
-0.5
1.6
0.5
1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -0.2 -0.4 -0.6 -0.8 -1
0.8
-0.6
W21
v
0.6
0.8
-1
-1 -0.5
0.4
0.6 -0.4
-3 -2
0.5
0
0.2
y/D
y/D
0
1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -0.2 -0.4
0.2
0
0 -0.2
u
-0.4 -0.2
0.5
1
0.8
y/D
0.6
y/D
0.4
y/D
0.5
0.5
0.4
0.1
0.1 0.2
0.2
1
01
1.5
x/D
(i) hP i
2
24
R. Perrin et al.
x=D ' 2 at the beginning of their convection. hu2 i and huvi presents their highest values in the shear regions near the separation. When the vortices are formed, the two lobes of high values of hu2 i are transported towards the rear axis, and the centre of the vortices. At the beginning of the convection, the highest values of huvi are located in the shear regions near the saddles points between the vortices, where the deformation rate is important. Concerning the normal stresses in the near wake, they all exhibit their highest values near the centre of the vortices when they begin to be convected. High values of hv2 i and hw2 i are also present between the vortices, and can be supposed to be linked with the presence of longitudinal vortices connecting the primary one. Finally, regions of low values of stresses are identified in front of the vortices, corresponding to external fluid entering in the wake. It is also noticeable that a strong anisotropy is observed. The general topology of the stresses is found in good agreement with precedent studies in wakes ([1, 4, 6]). With the use of stereoscopic PIV, the turbulent kinetic energy can be evaluated without assumption on hw2 i, and its topology is compared here to the production term that appears in its equation. It appears, in agreement with the aforementioned studies, that while the production is mainly located near the saddles points in the shear regions, where the deformation rate and huvi are important, the turbulent kinetic energy is mainly located near the centre of the vortices, suggesting a transport of the turbulent energy.
6 Conclusion and Outlooks The very near wake of a circular cylinder at high Reynolds number was experimentally studied using PIV, stereoscopic PIV and TRPIV. Due to the organised and random character of the flow, a particular attention was paid to achieve a decomposition of the motion into a coherent and a turbulent part. While it was shown in precedent studies that phase averaging using the pressure signal on the cylinder could lead to an overestimation of the random motion, due to phase lags occurring between the reference signal and the velocity in the wake, it has been shown that the first POD coefficients could be used to define a phase angle directly from the velocity fields, then alleviating the overestimation of the turbulent motion. Two complementary data sets which are revolved in space and time, obtained by TRPIV and by a DES simulation, have been used to analysed the instantaneous motion, as well as to analyse the POD and phase averaging that were performed. Then, a cartography of the phase averaged mean motion and turbulent stresses in the near wake have been provided. A future study will be devoted to the analysis of the tridimensionality, and particularly the longitudinal vortices which connect the primary ones, using both the presented numerical results and also Time Resolved Stereoscopic measurements in planes along the spanwise direction. Acknowledgements The company ”Excel Technology France” is greatly acknowledged for loaning Darwin PIV laser system.
Coherent and Turbulent Process Analysis
25
The authors also acknowledge the partial funding of the work presented here by the European Community during the DESider project (in the 6th Framework Program, under Contract No. AST3-CT-2003-502842) and by the German Research Foundation (DFG) within the scope of the Collaborative Research Center SFB 557.
References 1. B. Cantwell and D. Coles. An experimental study of entrainment and transport in the turbulent near wake of a circular cylinder. J. Fluid Mech., 136:321–374, 1983. 2. M. Ben Chiekh, M. Michard, N. Grosjean, and J. C. Bera. Reconstruction temporelle d’un champ a´eodynamique instationnaire partir de mesures PIV non r´esolues dans le temps. In 9e Congr`es Francophone de V´elocim´etrie Laser, 2004. 3. A. E. Deane, I. G. Kevrekidis, G. E. Karniadakis, and S. A. Orzag. Low-dimensional models for complex geometry flows: Application to grooved channels and circular cylinders. Phys. Fluids A, 3:2337–2354, 1991. 4. A. K. M. F. Hussain and M. Hakayawa. Eduction of large-scale organized structures in a turbulent plane wake. J. Fluid Mech., 180:193–229, 1987. 5. B. Lecordier and M. Trinite. Advanced PIV algorithms with image distortion - Validation and comparison from synthetic images of turbulent flows. In PIV03 Symposium, Busan, Korea, 2003. 6. A. Leder. Dynamics of fluid mixing in separated flows. Phys. Fluids A, 3(7):1741–1748, 1991. 7. A. Leder and M. Brede. Comparisons between 3D-LDA measurements and TR-PIV data in the separated flow of a circular cylinder. In 12th International Symposium on Applications of Laser Techniques to Fluid Mechanics, Lisbon, Portugal, 2004. 8. C. Mockett, R. Perrin, T. Reimann, M. Braza, and F. Thiele. Analysis of detached-eddy simulation for the flow around a circular cylinder with reference to piv data. In IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control, June 18–22, Corfu, Greece, 2007. 9. B. Noack, K. Afanasiev, M. Morzynski, G. Tadmor, and F. Thiele. A hierarchy of lowdimensional models for the transient and post-transient cylinder wake. J. Fluid Mech., 497:335–363, 2003. 10. R. Perrin, M. Braza, E. Cid, S. Cazin, A. Barthet, A. Sevrain, C. Mockett, and F. Thiele. Phase averaged turbulence properties in the near wake of a circular cylinder at high Reynolds number using POD. In 13th International Symposium on Applications of Laser Techniques to Fluid Mechanics, Lisbon, Portugal, 2006. 11. R. Perrin, E. Cid, S. Cazin, A. Sevrain, M. Braza, F. Moradei, and G. Harran. Phase averaged measurements of the turbulence properties in the near wake of a circular cylinder at high Reynolds number by 2C-PIV and 3-C PIV. Exp. Fluids, 42(1), 2007. 12. R. Perrin, C. Mockett, M. Braza, E. Cid, S. Cazin, A. Sevrain, P. Chassaing, and F. Thiele. Joint numerical and experimental investigation of the flow around a circular cylinder at high reynolds number. Topics in Applied Physics, PIVNET 2. To be published, 2007. 13. W. C. Reynolds and A. K. M. F. Hussain. The mechanics of an organized wave in turbulent shear flow. Part 3. Theoretical models and comparisons with experiments. J. Fluid Mech., 54:263–288, 1972. 14. B. W. van Oudheusden, F. Scarano, N. P. van Hinsberg, and D. W. Watt. Phase-resolved characterization of vortex shedding in the near wake of a square-section cylinder at incidence. Exp. Fluids, 39:86–98, 2005.
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Investigation of Aerodynamic Capabilities of Flying Fish in Gliding Flight H. Park and H. Choi
Abstract In the present study, we experimentally investigate the aerodynamic capabilities of flying fish. We consider four different flying fish models, which are darkedged-wing flying fishes stuffed in actual gliding posture. Some morphological parameters of flying fish such as lateral dihedral angle of pectoral fins, incidence angles of pectoral and pelvic fins are considered to examine their effect on the aerodynamic performance. We directly measure the aerodynamic properties (lift, drag, and pitching moment) for different morphological parameters of flying fish models. For the present flying fish models, the maximum lift coefficient and lift-to-drag ratio are similar to those of medium-sized birds such as the vulture, nighthawk and petrel. The pectoral fins are found to enhance the lift-to-drag ratio and the longitudinal static stability of gliding flight. On the other hand, the lift coefficient and lift-to-drag ratio decrease with increasing lateral dihedral angle of pectoral fins. Keywords Flying fish Aerodynamic performance Gliding Static stability Wing morphology
1 Introduction Other than numerous birds and flying insects, several vertebrates have been observed to possess an ability to fly in air [1, 2]. Among them, marine flying fish has been noted for its excellent flight performance and a few early studies investigated the basic aerodynamics of flying-fish flight based on the field observations [3–5]. Morphologically the flying fish has hypertrophied pectoral and pelvic fins which it uses as wings for gliding flight. The flight of flying fish is quite remarkable, e.g., it can glide the distance over 400 m in successive flights which are enabled by the unique method for take-off, named ‘taxiing’. Recently several biologists like
H. Park () and H. Choi School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea e-mail:
[email protected] M. Braza and K. Hourigan (eds.), IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control, IUTAM Bookseries 14, c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
27
28
H. Park and H. Choi
Davenport [6–8] and Fish [9] conducted allometric studies in relation to the aerodynamic performance of flying fish. They measured the variations of morphometric parameters for various flying-fish species in live or preserved states and analyzed their influences on the flight characteristics. Although several aspects of flying-fish flight has been understood or conjectured in previous studies, any quantitative analysis about the flying-fish flight has not been conducted so far. Furthermore, it might be interesting to compare the aerodynamic properties of flying-fish flight with those of other fliers in nature. Therefore, in the present study, we directly measure the aerodynamic forces and moment on flyingfish models in a wind tunnel. To meet the real flight condition of flying fish, flyingfish models are made of the real darkedged-wing flying fishes (Cypselurus hiraii) that are stuffed in gliding posture. The force measurements are conducted at the freestream velocity of 12 m/s. The maximum flight speed of real flying fish is known to be 10–20 m/s [7, 9]. We also investigate the aerodynamic function of flying fish’s wing morphology.
2 Experimental Setup 2.1 Flying-Fish Models For our study, we collected about 40 darkedged-wing flying fish (Cypselurus hiraii) and stuffed four of them in appropriate gliding postures (Fig. 1). As shown in Fig. 1, Cypselurus hiraii has both enlarged pectoral and pelvic fins and we consider the wing configuration of each flying-fish model as follows: (a) both pectoral and pelvic fins enlarged (models 1–3), and (b) only pectoral fins enlarged with pelvic fins folded against the body (model 4). For four models, we measured several parameters representing the aerial morphology of flying fish as tabulated in Table 1. Definitions of these parameters are illustrated in Fig. 2. For models 1–3, the lateral dihedral angles .ˇ1 / of pectoral
Fig. 1 Pictures of the flying fish (Cypselurus hiraii) models considered in the present study
Investigation of Aerodynamic Capabilities of Flying Fish in Gliding Flight
29
Table 1 Morphometric parameters of the flying fish models Models Standard length (SL, mm) Aspect ratio (AR) Pectoral fin area .A1 ; mm2 / Pelvic fin area .A2 ; mm2 / Wing span (S, mm) Averaged chord length of pectoral fins (c, mm) Lateral dihedral angle of pectoral fins .ˇ1 ; ı / Incidence angle of pectoral fins .ˇ2 ; ı / Incidence angle of pelvic fins .ˇ3 ; ı /
1 205 8.5 7,468 1,858 252 29.6 22 12 2
2 209 9.1 7,392 2,020 260 28.4 12 15 2
3 203 9.8 6,946 2,131 261 26.6 7 12 5
4 199 9.6 5,639 – 233 24.2 5 8 –
Fig. 2 Definitions and orientations of morphometric parameters
fins are artificially changed such that models 1 and 3 have largest and smallest ˇ1 , respectively. On the other hand, other parameters are the original values of the specimen. The aspect ratio (AR) of the present flying fish is around 8.5–9.8 which is comparable to those of birds in general [2, 9]. Each flying-fish model is connected to the force/torque sensor to measure aerodynamic forces and moment.
2.2 Force Measurements Force measurements are performed in an open-circuit blowing-type low-speed wind tunnel as shown in Fig. 3. Here, x, y, z denote the streamwise, vertical and spanwise directions, respectively. The test section has the size of 3 0:3 0:6 m in the streamwise, vertical and spanwise directions, respectively and the maximum speed is 25 m=s. At the free-stream velocity of 10 m=s, the background turbulence intensity and the uniformity of the mean velocity is within 0.5%.
30
H. Park and H. Choi
Fig. 3 Schematic diagram of the force measurement in a wind tunnel
To measure the forces and moment, we use a six-axis force/torque sensor (NANO17, ATI) that measures three-components of forces and moments simultaneously. The resolutions of the sensor are 1=1,280 N and 1=256 N mm in measuring force and moment, respectively. Varying the attack angle (˛, see Fig. 3) in the range of 15ı < ˛ < 45ı , we measure the lift and drag forces, and pitching moment for models 1–4. To minimize the interference by the strut, we use very slender strut whose cross section is an ellipse with maximum thickness is 2.68 mm. The repeatability error of the measurement is within ˙1:5%. The raw signals from the sensor are digitized by the A/D converter (PXI-6259, NI) for 300 s at the sampling rate of 10 kHz. As the maximum flight speed of real flying fish has been reported to be 10–20 m=s [7, 9], force measurement is conducted at the free-stream velocity .u1 / of 12 m=s and the corresponding Reynolds numbers are Re D u1 c= D 20;000– 24;000, where u1 is the free-stream velocity, c is the averaged chord length of the pectoral fins and is the kinematic viscosity.
3 Results and Discussion From the measured lift .L/, drag .D/ and pitching moment .M /, we obtain lift .CL /, drag .CD / and pitching moment .CM / coefficients as a function of angle of attack as follows: CL D L=.0:5u1 2 A/:
(1)
CD D D=.0:5u1 A/:
(2)
CM D M=.0:5u1 2 A1 c/:
(3)
2
Investigation of Aerodynamic Capabilities of Flying Fish in Gliding Flight
31
Fig. 4 Variations of the lift .CL / and drag .CD / coefficients with the attack angle: (a) CL ; (b) CD
where is the density of air, and A is the total wing area, A1 C A2 (see Fig. 2 and Table 1). Figure 4 shows the variations of the lift and drag coefficients with respect to the attack angle, ˛ C ˇ2 , for models 1–4. Here, ˇ2 is the incidence angle of the pectoral fins which is different for each model (Table 1). As shown in Fig. 4, the maximum lift coefficients are about 1.0–1.1 and the minimum drag coefficients are about 0.07–0.12, which are similar to those of the vulture and nighthawk [10]. The lift coefficients for models 1–3 (with both enlarged pectoral and pelvic fins) are smaller than that of model 4 (with only pectoral fins enlarged). Since the area of the pelvic fins is about 20% of the total wing area (Table 1), pelvic fins do not enhance the wing loading. On the other hand, the lift coefficient decreases with increasing lateral dihedral angle of pectoral fins .ˇ1 /. The variations of lift-to-drag ratio with the attack angle, ˛ C ˇ2 are given in Fig. 5. The maximum lift-to-drag ratio is about 4.4 (model 3) which is greater than that of hawk (3.8) and petrel (4.0) [10]. The lift-to-drag ratios for models 1–3 are larger than that of model 4, indicating that the pelvic fins enhance the gliding performance of flying fish by having smaller drag coefficient. Like the lift coefficient, the lift-to-drag ratio also decreases with increasing lateral dihedral angle of pectoral fins .ˇ1 /. For a gliding animal, flight stability is also one of the important issues. It is known that the nose-down pitching moment should increase with increasing attack angle (i.e., the slope of the pitching moment coefficient curve should be negative) for a glider to have a longitudinal static stability [11]. Also, the more negative the slope of pitching moment curve, the more stable the glider is. The variations of the pitching moment coefficient at the center of gravity are shown in Fig. 6. It is found that the gliding flight of flying fish is statically stable in longitudinal direction, and with pelvic fins (models 1–3) the longitudinal static stability is enhanced, which is similar to the function of tail plane in modern aircraft. On the other hand, the longitudinal static stability is more enhanced with decreasing lateral dihedral angle of pectoral fins .ˇ1 /.
32
H. Park and H. Choi
Fig. 5 Variations of the lift-to-drag ratio (L=D) with the attack angle
Fig. 6 Variations of the pitching moment coefficient .CM / with the attack angle
Investigation of Aerodynamic Capabilities of Flying Fish in Gliding Flight
33
4 Conclusions In the present study, we investigated the aerodynamic properties of flying-fish flight by directly measuring the lift and drag forces, and pitching moment on real flyingfish models. The flying fish has a wing performance comparable to those of birds like the vulture, nighthawk and petrel in terms of the lift coefficient and lift-to-drag ratio. We also examined the effects of wing morphologies on the gliding performance of flying fish. Enlarged pelvic fins enhanced the lift-to-drag ratio and longitudinal static stability of the flying fish, but, the lift coefficient decreased due to enlarged pelvic fins. On the other hand, the lift coefficient and lift-to-drag ratio decreased with increasing lateral dihedral angle of pectoral fins. Acknowledgements This work has been supported by the National Research Laboratory Program of the Korean Ministry of Science and Technology.
References 1. Alexander, D.E., Nature’s Flyers, The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD (2002). 2. Vogel, S., Lift in Moving Fluids, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ (1994). 3. Breder, C.M., Jr., On the structural specialization of flying fishes from the standpoint of aerodynamics. Copeia 4 (1930) 114–121. 4. Mills, C.A., Source of propulsive power used by flying fish. Science 83 (1936) 80. 5. Hertel, H., Take-off and flight of the flying fish. In: Structure – Form – Movement, eds. M.S. Katz, Reinhold, New York (1966) 218–224. 6. Davenport, J., Wing-loading, stability and morphometric relationships in flying fish (Exocoetidae) from the north-eastern atlantic. J. Mar. Biol. Ass. U.K. 72 (1992) 25–39. 7. Davenport, J., How and why do flying fish fly? Rev. Fish Biol. Fish. 40 (1994) 184–214. 8. Davenport, J., Allomeric constraints on stability and maximum size in flying fishes: implications for their evolution. J. Fish Biol. 62 (2003) 455–463. 9. Fish, F.E., Wing design and scaling of flying fish with regard to flight performance. J. Zool. Lond. 221 (1990) 391–403. 10. Withers, P.C., An aerodynamic analysis of bird wings as fixed aerofoils. J. Exp. Biol. 90 (1981) 143–162. 11. Thomas, A.L.R. and Taylor, G.K., Animal flight dynamics. I. stability in gliding flight. J. Theor. Biol. 212 (2001) 399–424.
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Effect of Unsteady Separation on an Automotive Bluff-Body in Cross-Wind M. Gohlke, J.F. Beaudoin, M. Amielh, and F. Anselmet
Abstract This paper is treating the dynamic effects of cross-wind on a 3D bluffbody. It is shown that contrary to the mean flow, it is not the upper vortex that predominates the forces, but the flow generated and piloted by the front lee-strut wake. It is made responsible for the appearance of a frequency peak in the bluff-body force spectra. Furthermore it is shown that the intensity as well as the frequency of this peak depend on the yawing angle. Experimental and numerical results are used to analyse the flow dynamics. Keywords Cross-wind Aerodynamics Bluff-body Vortices Wake
1 Introduction During many years automobile aerodynamic research was concentrated on drag-reduction and some major advances have been achieved. However, a new topic has emerged recently. As consumers demand bigger interior, cars become higher and larger. This leads to more side wind sensibility. Hence, it is necessary to understand the link between side-force, yawing-moment and rolling-moment, so that the driving-stability and -comfort can be enhanced. Howell [4] and Gillhaus and Hoffmann [3] have shown that in automobile applications it is essentially the side force and its repartition, causing the yawing moment, that are responsible for driving stability. The aim of the present study is to get some insight into the flow-structures that have an influence on these forces, which is a fundamental question that concerns many fields beyond the automotive aerodynamics community. To reduce the
M. Gohlke () and J.F. Beaudoin PSA Peugeot-Citro¨en, Department of Research and Innovation, V´elizy-Villacoublay, France e-mail:
[email protected] M. Gohlke, M. Amielh, and F. Anselmet IRPHE, UMR CNRS 6594, Technopˆole de Chˆateau-Gombert, Marseille, France M. Braza and K. Hourigan (eds.), IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control, IUTAM Bookseries 14, c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
35
36
M. Gohlke et al.
Fig. 1 Coordinate system and forces as applied to the bluff-body used for investigation, over all length used as reference length: Lref
complexity of the flow around a vehicle in cross-wind a simplified bluff-body in ground-proximity, introduced by Chometon et al. [1], has been chosen for a more generic analysis. Figure 1 shows the model, “Willy”, used for the present study, with the forces and moments in their reference system. In a cross wind situation the flow around this bluff body is basically characterised by its asymmetry, which is at the origin of additional forces and moments, namely side force and yawing moment. This paper mainly aims at giving some insight to the dynamics of the forces and their link to the flow structures. First of all a summary of the principal results, obtained from the steady flow analysis, are presented. In the main part, devoted to the unsteady character of the flow, first a brief description of the numerical simulation and the experimental setup is given. Some results obtained from these investigations are then analysed and finally the influence of the flow structures is discussed.
2 Recapitulation of Mean Flow Features In this section the main features of the steady flow field are presented. A more exhaustive overview of these results can be found in Gohlke et al. [2]. As mentioned in the introduction, the main interest is turned toward the side force distribution and the resulting yawing moment. To simulate cross wind, a simple but often applied method is used. The wind tunnel model is therefore turned in respect to the free stream by an angle ˇ, called the yaw angle. As this angle rises, the component of the oncoming flow becomes more important, simulating a stronger cross wind. In this study, the maximum yaw angle is 30ı and the upstream velocity is 40 m=s. Figure 2 shows the strong dependency of forces and moments on the yawing angle. While the global side force (Fig. 2a) has a rather linear rise, the slope of the yawing moment CN (Fig. 2b) shows an inclination at around 16ı , which, as discussed in the introduction, is favourable for cross-wind stability. To clarify the origin of this decrease, the lateral force is divided into front and rear side forces (Fig. 2c), which leads to the following two observations. The front contribution CYF
Effect of Unsteady Separation on an Automotive Bluff-Body in Cross-Wind
−0.14
−0.5
−0.21
−0.1
−0.67
−0.5
−0.27
−1
−0.2
−0.83
−0.34
−30
−20
−10
0
10
20
Yaw angle β [°]
(a) global side force CY
30
CYF(β) [1]
0
−0.07
−0.33
0.1
CN(β) [1]
CY(β) [1]
−0.17
0.2
0.5
0
CYF CYR
0
−0.3 −30
−1 −20
−10
0
10
20
30
Yaw angle β [°]
(b) Yawing moment CN
CYR(β) [1]
0
0.3 1
37
−0.41 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Yaw angle β [°]
(c) Front and rear side-force CYF , CYR
Fig. 2 Steady force coefficient as a function of yaw angle ˇ (stars: numerical simulation)
Fig. 3 Lee side flow for ˇ < 20ı (left) and ˇ > 20ı (right)
is three times higher but it is the rear side force CYR that shows two slope changes, at 4ı and 16ı . The second one, occurring at yaw angles above 16ı , leads to a steeper slope which is thought to partially explain the decrease in yawing moment. In Gohlke et al. [2] these two slope changes are linked to the presence of two vortices (a) and (b) as shown by the sketch in Fig. 3. The vortex (b) is close to the body at small yaw angles and induces low pressure at the rear end of the model. As ˇ grows, this flow structure gains in size but is also orientated away from the body, hence it has less influence on the rear side force. The front strut wake plays herein an important role by imposing a direction to this vortex. At yaw angles around 15ı a second vortex (a) is created, due to detachment of the flow over the top. This vortex grows in size, as visible on the LDV-measurements shown in Figs. 4a and 4b, and induces a low pressure zone on the rear lee side, giving rise in CYR , and finally leading to a counter-rotating rear yawing moment. This local effect is shown in Fig. 4c, which is obtained from local static pressure measurements and has permitted the calculation of force contributions per region. It f can be observed that the strongest gain in local yawing moment C N is measured on the rear upper leeward side (). Figure 5a and b give an overview of the mean flow field of the lee side at 15ı and 30ı as obtained from numerical simulations. They illustrate the presence of the longitudinal vortices and their location in respect to the model.
38
M. Gohlke et al. 0.04
0.02
CN (? )
0
−0.02
−0.04 Upper luv side Lower luv side Lower lee side Upper lee side Over all sum
−0.06
−0.08 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
?
ı
(a) ˇ D 15
ı
(b) ˇ D 30
f (c) C N pseudo-yawing moment on the rear part of the model
Fig. 4 LDV measurements and local yawing moment contributions on the rear half of the model
(a) Bluff-body flow at ˇ D 15ı
(b) Bluff-body flow at ˇ D 30ı
Fig. 5 Lee-ward side view of the mean flow field for 15ı and 30ı yaw, obtained from numerical simulation
3 Unsteady Flow Analysis 3.1 Setup In this section the setup used to analyse the unsteady character of the flow is presented. First the numerical method employed and its setup is discussed and then the experimental method is outlined. The upstream flow velocity in both cases is 40 m=s. To simulate a cross flow, the model is turned around its z-axis at the strut centre in respect to the oncoming flow up to a yaw angle of ˙30ı . Numerical Investigation The numerical code used in this investigation is based on a lattice Boltzmann method. Two yaw angles have been studied, one at 15ı and one at 30ı . Different zones of spatial resolution are used, the finest grid being close to the model and around the cylindrical struts of the order of magnitude of 0:875 106 Lref . In the 30ı case a special refinement of 1:75 106 Lref is done in the zone
Effect of Unsteady Separation on an Automotive Bluff-Body in Cross-Wind
39
of the lateral vortices on the lee side. This zone is defined by the iso-surface of the vorticity norm, obtained from an earlier coarser numerical investigation. The total number of voxels used to define the flow field is of the order of 107 . 1:4 105 timesteps are simulated for both yaw angles, which correspond to a physical time of 0.56 s. To find a converged behaviour drag-, side-force- and lift coefficients are monitored and it is found that 2 104 timesteps are necessary to consider the simulation as converged. This leaves 0.48 s of physical time for dynamic flow analysis. The turbulence level and the boundary layer are adapted to fit the conditions in the wind tunnel experiments. The numerical simulation is confronted with experimental results and globally show a satisfactory correspondence. Exemplarily some of these confrontations are given here. The force measurements in Fig. 2 show that the steady forces are well reproduced (the numerical results are displayed by the stars). At the high yaw angle, the side force is slightly over estimated by the simulation with a difference of CY D 8:8%, but the front/rear distribution is well respected, which is confirmed by a good CN estimation differing by CN D 1:4%. A further confirmation of good coherence comes from the LDV measurements in a plane close to the blunt end. The vorticity level as well as the roll-up of the streamlines is quite similar for the 30ı case, shown in Fig. 6a and b. It is therefore stated, that the numerical simulation gives accurate results and can be amended with the experimental investigation, which is completer in angular resolution.
(a) LDV measurements 30ı
(b) Numerical simulation 30ı
Fig. 6 Vorticity in a plane obtained from LDV measurements and from numerical simulation at 30ı yaw
40
(a) Wind tunnel model equipped with pressure transducers
M. Gohlke et al.
(b) Three different measurement series : , and ı
Fig. 7 Model equipped with pressure transducers and their position during the different setups
Experimental Investigation One half of the hollow experimental model is equipped with 249 pressure holes with a diameter of 0.8 mm. They can be equipped with microphones to analyse local pressure fluctuation. The microphones are fixed on the inside of the model with the help of tight joints, that are glued to the shell. The measuring equipment used is capable to analyse 60 microphones at a time. Three different setups are hence used: one covering the upper part, one covering the lower part and a combination of both of them (see Fig. 7). This investigation has been undertaken for a yaw angle range between 30ı and C30ı with a step of 5ı at a measurement frequency of 8 kHz.
3.2 Results and Discussion It has been shown that the steady flow is mainly characterised by two longitudinal vortices on the lee side of the model and that they play an important role in the local side force and local yawing moment distributions (see Section 2). In this section, further results are presented, that aim at understanding the dynamics of the side force CY and the yawing moment CN . These results are based on two different approaches, on the one hand, a numerical simulation gives access to the unsteady forces and a very good spatial resolution. But, on the other hand, good yaw angle resolution can only be achieved with an experimental approach, where pressure fluctuations are measured on the model surface. These two setups are described in Section 3.1 Numerical Investigation To analyse the dynamics of the forces, numerical simulations were undertaken for two different yaw angles, 15ı and 30ı . As shown in Section 3.1 the comparison between the wind tunnel measurements and the numerical simulation is satisfactory. It can be seen that the steady forces and moments of the numerical simulation correspond fairly well. This is demonstrated by the stars in the forces versus yaw angle graphs in Fig. 2. On the bases of this good correlation
Effect of Unsteady Separation on an Automotive Bluff-Body in Cross-Wind dBref(1)
−50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110 −120 −130 −140 −150 101
dBref(1)
102
103 f [Hz]
104
105
−50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110 −120 −130 −140 −150 101
(a) CY .f / dBref(1)
−50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110 −120 −130 −140 −150 1 10
2
3
10 f [Hz]
(e) CY .f /
102
103 f [Hz]
104
5
10
−50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110 −120 −130 −140 −150 1 1 10
(b) CYF .f / dBref(1)
10
dBref(1)
10
4
5
10
−50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110 −120 −130 −140 −150 1 10
2
3
10 f [Hz]
10
2
3
10 f [Hz]
4
10
105
−50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110 −120 −130 −140 −150 1 1 10
(c) CYR .f / dBref(1)
10
dBref(1)
41
10
4
10
5
−50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110 −120 −130 −140 −150 1 101
(f) CYF .f /
103 f [Hz]
(g) CYR .f /
2
3
10 f [Hz]
10
4
105
(d) CN .f / dBref(1)
102
10
104
105
−50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110 −120 −130 −140 −150 1 10
2
10
3
10 f [Hz]
10
4
10
5
(h) CN .f /
Fig. 8 Force spectra for 15ı (a–d) and 30ı case (e–h)
between the numerical simulation and the wind tunnel measurements for the steady flow, it is assumed that the unsteady analysis using the numerical data will also produce reliable results. Force autospectra obtained from the numerical simulation of the 15ı case and 30ı case, as shown in Fig. 8 for the side force and the yawing moment, display overall simplicity. A first observation is the resemblance of these spectra between the two yaw angles. The spectra globally have the same energy level. At high frequencies they follow a power law, typical for generic turbulent flows, but the slope value of 4, could not be explained so far. Furthermore, all spectra display a frequency peak emergence, which is easiest to distinguish for the small yaw angle. These peaks have an amplitude that is about 10 dB higher for the 15ı case than for the 30ı case. Furthermore, these frequencies vary with yaw, most visible on the front side force, where f15CıYF D 317 Hz and f30CıYF D 363 Hz. To analyse the origin of this coherent part of the spectra, indications can be obtained from local force analysis undertaken on the cylindrical struts. They are shown in Fig. 9. Again, at high frequencies, the spectra show a decrease following a power law. Generally, peaks with identical frequencies, as observed for the whole body, emerge clearly at both yaw angles. The amplitude of the frequency peak is higher and the peaks are slimmer for the 15ı case. The global and the front side force again show a variation of the frequency which depends on the yaw angle: f15ı D 317 Hz and f30ı D 363 Hz. Only the frequency on the rear struts is independent of the yaw angle change: f15ı D f30ı D 317 Hz. Due to the fact that there is a strong coherent phenomenon in the spectra, with the same frequency as observed on the body force spectra, it is believed that the struts are at the origin of these frequencies. This can be explained by vortices shed in their wake, similar to the “von Karman vortex street”. This shedding is thought to induce its proper frequency on the body, by an alternation of local low and high pressure zones close to the body surface.
42
M. Gohlke et al.
dBref(1)
−50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110 −120 −130 −140 −150 1 10
dB
Struts 15° Struts 30°
2
10
10
3
4
10
−50
5
10
−50 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110
−120 −130 −140 −150 1 10
−120 −130 −140 −150 1 10
10
2
3
10
10
4
10
5
dBref(1)
Struts 15° Struts 30°
ref(1) −60
−70 −80 −90 −100 −110
10
2
10
3
10
4
10
5
−50 −60 −70 −80 −90 −100 −110 −120 −130 −140 −150 1 10
Body 15° Body 30°
10
(b) CYF .f / on struts
2
10
3
10
4
10
5
f [Hz]
f [Hz]
f [Hz]
f [Hz]
(a) CY .f / on struts
dB
Struts 15° Struts 30°
ref(1) −60
(c) CYR .f / on struts
(d) CYF .f / on body
ı
Fig. 9 Force spectra of the cylindrical struts and of the body for 15 and 30ı case
Fig. 10 Oncoming flow UX at different heights z for 15ı (filled) and 30ı (empty) – ground clearance g = 0.037 m
50 45
0.033m 0.028m 0.019m
UX [m /s]
40 35 30 25 20 −0.25 −0.2 −0.15 −0.1 −0.05 Distance to strut [m]
The spectrum of CYF is presented in Fig. 9d, it has been obtained only from the force on the body (without the contribution from the struts). Again the frequency peak can be observed, which underlines the influence of the strut wake on the body forces. A first attempt is to verify whether the order of magnitude corresponds to the vortex shedding frequency of a cylinder. This is done by a simple comparison through the Strouhal number. The corresponding shedding frequency is calculated with the dimensions of the cylindrical struts and a Strouhal number of St D 0:21 (for a Re D U1 D= D 103 to 3 106 ). The local Reynolds number being Re.U1 ; d / D 8:2 104 this corresponds to f D 274:5 Hz. A detailed look at the oncoming flow velocity is shown in Fig. 10. It can be seen that the flow velocity upstream of the lee strut is at first slowed down, due to a blockage effect of the model, before it is strongly accelerated due to the curvature on the model nose, generating a convergent effect. So the velocity to be taken into account to estimate the vortex shedding frequency is about 10 m=s higher than the actual free stream velocity, so that the obtained frequency is about 343 Hz, corresponding to the 30ı yaw angle. This is to be compared with f30CıYF D 363 Hz and shows a good agreement.
Effect of Unsteady Separation on an Automotive Bluff-Body in Cross-Wind
43
This comforts the idea that the vortex shedding from the leeward strut is responsible for the peaks found on the force spectra. Figure 10 also shows that the oncoming flow velocity changes with the yaw angle, leading to a change in the shedding frequency. The authors believe that this explains in part the variation of the frequency of the coherent phenomena observed in the spectra; but other factors such as the model geometry behind the strut might favour an acceleration of the strut wake, which then also influences the resulting frequency. Experimental Investigation The numerical investigation suggests that there is a yaw angle dependency of the coherent part of force spectra, showing frequency changes and amplitude variations. With the help of surface pressure measurements, as described in Section 3.1, an analysis can be undertaken over the whole yaw angle range from 30ı to C30ı , with a step of 5ı . The spectral analysis of the results from these local pressure measurements is shown in Fig. 11. Exemplarily, four different transducers 30, 31, 32 and 37 are analysed for the yaw angles between 0ı to 30ı (lee side). First of all, it has to be pointed out that these transducers are not only sensitive to turbulent fluctuations, but also to acoustic noise. The wind tunnel, being equipped with four turbines downstream of the model, generates a noise with a frequency of 86 Hz for a wind velocity of 40 m=s. Black lines in the illustrated graphs indicate this frequency and its harmonics, so that they can be clearly distinguished. It can be stated that their amplitude stays below 100 dB. Flow analysis will nevertheless be restricted to frequencies that do not correspond to these acoustic frequencies. A further observation on these measurements is a broad band bump in the spectra at frequencies around 2 kHz. This is explained by the way the transducers are installed and corresponds to resonance frequencies of the cavity between the outer shell of the model and the transducer. This frequency can vary slightly with the location and the fixation of the transducer. Figure 11a–c reproduces the results from three different pressure transducer at different heights on the lee ward side, No. 30 being the lowest, placed on the horizontal underbody, as indicated in Fig. 12a. This transducer No. 30 shows a yaw angle independent energy level. The further the transducer is located upward the lateral side of the model, the more this level depends on the yaw angle. Figure 11b shows a dependency up to a yaw angle of 10ı , beyond the energy levels remain constant. A strong dependency of this level on the yaw angle is demonstrated by transducer No. 32. It can also be pointed out that at 30ı yaw the global energy level is the same for all the positions. This means that the lateral side is more and more subject to the flow fluctuation and the lateral turbulence level rises constantly with the yaw angle, as a large lateral wake is building up. Furthermore, these spectra show a slope at high frequency of 7/3, this spectral decrease has often been observed on pressure measurements in homogeneous and isotropic turbulence. Most of the spectra show clear peaks at frequencies between 270 and 300 Hz with an amplitude mostly above 100 dB. Although this is not exactly the same value as observed in the numerical simulation, these frequencies are rather close. As already
44
M. Gohlke et al. 120
120 f −7/3
100 90
80
70
30° 25° 20° 15° 10° 5° 0° 1
10
2
2
3
10
10
f [Hz]
f [Hz]
(a) No. 30
(b) No. 31 120 f −7/3
30° 25° 20° 15° 10° 5° 0°
101
f −7/3
110 dBref(2 10−5)
dBref(2 10−5)
1
10
10
100
70
30° 25° 20° 15° 10° 5° 0°
90
70
3
10
110
80
100
80
120
90
f −7/3
110 dBref(2 10−5)
dBref(2 10−5)
110
100 30° 25° 20° 15° 10° 5° 0°
90
80
102
70
103
1
2
10
3
10
10
f [Hz]
f [Hz]
(c) No. 32
(d) No. 37
Fig. 11 Spectral analysis of different pressure transducers as a function of ˇ 310 305
No 31 No 37
125 No 31 No 37
300
dBref(2 10−5)
120
f [Hz]
295 290 285 280
115 110
275
105
270 265
0
5
10
15
20
Yaw angle β
25
30
100
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Yaw angle β
(a) Position of transducers No (b) Peak frequency vs yaw (c) Peak amplitude vs yaw angle 30-32 and 37 angle Fig. 12 Frequency peak and amplitude analysis as a function of the yaw angle (error bar indicate width of peak maximum)
observed on the force spectra, the amplitudes and the corresponding frequencies, obtained from the pressure transducers, vary with the yaw angle. Figure 12b and c show this behaviour exemplarily for the transducers No. 31 and 37, the later one being just behind the front lee side strut (see Fig. 12a) and therefore measuring in its wake.
Effect of Unsteady Separation on an Automotive Bluff-Body in Cross-Wind
45
It can be observed that at low ˇ the frequency and the amplitude rise with the yaw angle. The amplitude reaches its maximum for 10ı to 15ı , where the frequency attains a value of around 290 Hz. While the amplitude decreases with a further rise in yaw angle, the frequency seems established around 295 Hz. In addition to this, there is a further frequency bump arising around a frequency of 160 Hz at yaw angles of 25ı and 30ı , mainly visible on the autospectra of the transducer No. 31, which still has to be analysed in more detail. The amplitude change observed on the pressure transducer No. 37 is most likely due to its position in respect to the front lee cylinder wake. As the yaw angle grows the wake is more and more turned away from the measurement point, so that it is less sensible to the vortex shedding. The variation in amplitude of tap No. 31 on the other hand is believed to be linked to the observations made for the mean flow. At 0ı yaw the cylinder wake stays under the model and hence has little or no influence on the lateral side. As the angle rises, the cylinder wake interacts with the lateral flow and the peak appears. With a further rise, a lateral vortex (b) is generated due to an interaction of the underbody flow with the free flow and is piloted by the cylinder wake. As the angle becomes larger than approximately 15ı , this longitudinal structure detaches from the body and hence the coherent part of the fluctuations is orientated further away from the body, so that they have less effect on the body forces. This results in a decrease in the induced pressure fluctuations and hence the organised force fluctuation. This shows that it is mainly the front lee strut that pilots the flow on the lee side and induces coherence into the flow and hence onto the body forces.
4 Conclusion Summarising, the mean flow is characterised by two lee ward vortical structures (a) and (b), shown in Fig. 3. The upper vortex (a) plays an important role on the mean forces and is at the origin of a counter rotating yawing moment, created on the upper rear lee side. This moment has a positive effect on the global yawing moment, which it reduces. The work on the analysis of the force dynamics, as developed in this paper, has shown that a coherent frequency is induced to the model dynamic forces. It is shown that this is linked to the vortex shedding of the cylindrical struts, especially to the wake of the front lee strut. Furthermore, the frequency and the amplitude of this shedding phenomenon, are shown to depend on the yawing angle. The amplitude reaches its maximum around 15ı at a frequency around 290 Hz for the pressure measurements and 317 Hz for the numerical simulation. The wind tunnel measurements indicate that the frequency rises with the yaw angle. Beyond 20ı the frequency stays fairly constant around 295 Hz, but the amplitude decreases further. This phenomena is explained by the analysis from the steady flow, more precisely it is linked to the flow structure (b). This longitudinal vortex detaches from the model at yaw angles larger than 15ı , hence causing less coherence in the dynamic forces.
46
M. Gohlke et al.
So in the dynamic analysis it is not the upper vortex, that plays a predominant role at high yaw angles, as it is the case for the mean force, but it is especially the lower vortex that is strongly interacting with the front lee strut and has the most effect in the mid yaw angle range.
References 1. CHOMETON , F. ET AL.: Experimental Analysis of Unsteady Wakes on a New Simplified Car Model. Bluff Body Aerodynamics and Applications Congress, Ottawa (2004) 2. GOHLKE, M. ET AL.: Experimental Analysis of Flow Structures and Forces on a 3D-Bluff-Body in Constant Cross-Wind. Experiments in Fluids, 43(4), 579–594, Springer (2007) 3. GILHAUS, A.M. & RENN , V.E.: Drag and Driving-Stability-Related Aerodynamic Forces and Their Interdependence Results of Measurements on 3/8-Scale Basic Car Shapes. In: SAE, Society of Automotive Engineers, Warrendale, PA (1986) 4. HOWELL Shape Features which Influence Crosswind sensitivity. In: Vehicle Ride and Handling Conf., I. Mech. E. Paper C466/036/93
Part II
Statistical and Hybrid Turbulence Modeling of Unsteady Separated Flows
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Flow Prediction Around an Oscillating NACA0012 Airfoil at Re D 1,000,000 O. Frederich, U. Bunge, C. Mockett, and F. Thiele
Abstract The maximum obtainable lift of a rotationally-oscillating airfoil is significantly higher than in the static or quasi-static case. The correct prediction of dynamic stall as the basis of the dynamically increased lift is essential to quantify the time-dependent load on the airfoil structure. This study applies unsteady RANS (URANS) and detached-eddy simulation (DES) with various turbulence models and parameter variations in order to capture the physics around an oscillating NACA0012 airfoil at a relatively high Reynolds number and to identify possible advantages and potential drawbacks of the given methods. The quality of the flow prediction is assessed primarily on the basis of integral force coefficients compared to experimental results, revealing the influence of resolution on maximum lift and the corresponding angle of incidence. Keywords NACA0012 Oscillating airfoil Dynamic stall URANS DES
1 Introduction Flows around rotationally-oscillating airfoils are characterised by two important physical phenomena. On the one hand a hysteresis develops in the curves of lift and drag versus angle of attack and on the other hand the maximum lift is much higher than in the static or quasi-static case. Both effects are associated with unsteady flow separation, which is also referred to as “dynamic stall”. A dynamically affected process occurs when the oscillatory frequency is significantly higher than the frequency of potential vortex shedding in the presence of high angles of attack.
O. Frederich (), C. Mockett, and F. Thiele Berlin University of Technology, Institute of Fluid Mechanics and Engineering Acoustics, M¨uller-Breslau-Str. 8, 10623 Berlin e-mail:
[email protected] U. Bunge IVM Automotive Wolfsburg GmbH, Wolfsburger Landstr. 22, 38442 Wolfsburg M. Braza and K. Hourigan (eds.), IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control, IUTAM Bookseries 14, c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
49
50
O. Frederich et al.
Such patterns appear in diverse engineering applications e.g. helicopter rotor blades, turbo-machinery and wind turbines. The configuration investigated here is a NACA0012 airfoil that oscillates sinusoidally around the quarter chord line and mean incidence of 15ı with an amplitude of 10ı at Reynolds number Rec D106 . With the reduced frequency of the oscillatory movement kosc D fosc c=u1 D 0:1 and the estimated Strouhal number for the vortex shedding (vsh) of a NACA0021 St D fvsh c=u1 D 0:2 [8], the ratio fosc =fvsh 18 confirms the existence of a dynamically affected stall. This also reveals that the large-scale dynamics in the stalled flow are dominated by the prescribed motion of the airfoil in contrast to the vortex shedding behind a steady airfoil at high angle of attack or behind a bluff body. The present case comprises an oscillation around the maximum lift, and thus the challenge to rise to is the massively-separated flow after stall and the accompanying highly unsteady flow physics. The time-accurate prediction of this is essential to enable a correct prediction of any fluid-structure interaction. This has already been outlined in [3], where turbulence-resolving and more advanced simulation methods such as detached-eddy simulation (DES) are recommended. With integral values in the focal point of interest though, unsteady RANS (URANS) is in some cases seen to be sufficient in this study due to the aforementioned motion-induced unsteadiness of the flow. This will be demonstrated by comparison with experimental results averaged over 200 cycles that have been published by Mcalister et al. [6].
2 Numerical Method and Parameters The flow field around the NACA0012 airfoil is discretised using block-structured grids with varying topology and spatial resolution. Concerning the spatial discretisation, a c-type grid arranged for URANS boundary layer predictions with 35;000 cells in each 2D slice is tested against an o-type grid specially prepared for DES of massive separation with 46;000 cells in 2D (Fig. 1). The spanwise domain size of one chord length is resolved for the c-type grid by 3, 11 and 21 nodes (variants C3, C11, C21), whereas the number of nodes for the o-type grids is 60. Two different o-type grids are considered (variants 01 and 02), which differ only in the wall-normal refinement of the boundary layer region. The 02 variant exhibits a fine resolution of y C < 1 throughout the oscillation cycle. A no-slip condition is applied to the physical wall with a universal hybrid treatment implemented to the turbulence equations allowing arbitrary values of y C . A periodic condition is applied to the lateral boundaries and a convective outflow condition to the downstream boundary. The whole grid is rotated sinusoidally using rigid body motion, thus a constant inflow profile with the bulk velocity u1 is sufficient. With focus on the integral force coefficients of relevance for engineers, URANS simulations were performed on the c-type grid and DES on all grid types. Turbulence models with varying degrees of complexity are used, such as the SALSA one-equation [9], the two-equation LLR k–! [10] and an explicit algebraic stress
Flow Prediction Around an Oscillating NACA0012 Airfoil at Re D 1,000,000
51
Fig. 1 2D planes of the c-type and o-type grids.
model, the CEASM [5]. For details the reader is referred to [1], where a detailed description of the implementation of these models and their DES variants is given. The investigations were performed using the solver ELAN developed at the Berlin University of Technology. This numerical procedure uses a conservative finite-volume discretisation based on general curvilinear coordinates of the Navier–Stokes equations for incompressible and compressible flows. The spatial discretisation of the diffusive and convective terms is realised using central differencing, and a backward difference quotient of first or second order accuracy is used for the temporal derivative [12]. The code has been enhanced towards DES as well as an arbitrary Lagrange–Eulerian formulation (ALE) to capture moving and deforming grids [2], and is therefore able to handle all common simulation approaches such as URANS, DES, LES as well as direct numerical simulation for a wide range of engineering applications. The correct treatment of moving grids is realised with the space conservation law which is important for the presented case. In order to prevent unwanted encroachment of the LES mode of the DES inside attached turbulent boundary layers, the delayed DES (DDES) shield function of Spalart et al. [7] has been implemented to the CEASM-based DES.
3 Flow Physics For the configuration investigated, the airfoil exhibits a sinusoidal oscillation between 5ı and 25ı . Such harmonics around the maximum static lift are characterised by a forced rotatory movement of the wing or an equivalent unsteady inflow condition with viscous effects dominating the flow. The flow phenomena during the oscillation period and the pressure distribution on the central airfoil section predicted by a numerical simulation are visualised in Figs. 2 and 3.
52
O. Frederich et al.
15.0◦
23.1◦
18.1◦
21.7◦
20.9◦
20.0◦
21.7◦
18.1◦
22.4◦
15.0◦
23.1◦
10.9◦
23.7◦
7.6◦
24.1◦
5.5◦
24.5◦
5.0◦
25.0◦
5.5◦
24.5◦
7.6◦
23.7◦
10.9◦
Fig. 2 Instantaneous iso-lines of the z-vorticity (SALSA DES, O1, t D T=300)
By rapidly increasing the incidence of the airfoil beyond the static separation angle the boundary layer on the upper side of the profile becomes fully turbulent. When further increasing the incidence a vortex starts to develop at the separation of
Flow Prediction Around an Oscillating NACA0012 Airfoil at Re D 1,000,000
53
curve sampling
CL
2
10.9o
1
7.6o
0 5
15 α 20
10
25
o
5.5 o
5.0 5.5o 7.6o 10.9o 15.0o 18.1o 20.0o o
21.7 23.1o 23.7o 24.5
o
25.0o 24.5o 24.1o 23.7o 23.1o 22.4o 21.7
o
20.9o
Cp
–5
18.1
o
15.0o
0 0
x
0.5
Fig. 3 Instantaneous pressure coefficient Cp (SALSA DES, O1, t D T=300)
the turbulent boundary layer near the profile’s leading edge. The vortex grows very fast and is convected downstream, while remaining close to the surface, increasing drastically the suction on the upper side. The maximum dynamic lift is created as
54
O. Frederich et al.
the vortex is transported just beyond the streamwise midpoint of the profile, but before the maximum incidence is reached. The vortex suction is reduced further downstream until passing the trailing edge, thereby initiating full dynamic stall. The brief, wake-induced reattachment of the stalled region above the profile leads to an intermediate increase of the suction and the lift. Thereafter vortex shedding at the stalled airfoil occurs until the incidence has decreased such that the flow can reattach from the front to the rear.
4 Results In the following, the results of the numerical simulations are summarised and evaluated with respect to the variation of individual parameters. The force coefficients obtained using the o-grids are phase-averaged with respect to the sinusoidal oscillation of the airfoil (Section 4.5). The analysis of the differences between two solutions is mainly focused on the numerical and modelling reasons for the deviation.
4.1 Spatial Resolution The variation of the spatial resolution comprises two main parts. On the one hand there are two general grid topologies, and on the other hand the number of spanwise nodes is varied among the c-type grids as well as between c-type and o-type grids. The curves in Figs. 4 and 5 depict the lift coefficient predicted by URANS and DES with varying grids for different background models. Figure 4 clearly shows that for URANS the lift curve changes very slightly with increasing spanwise resolution (Fig. 4), whereas using DES the changes are significant, especially in the region of total stall. The flow predicted by URANS apparently tends to remain twodimensional without considering the resolution of the span. The DES modification of the same equations results in a much reduced eddy viscosity through a length scale based on the maximum grid dimension, i.e. the spanwise dimension in these McAlister 1982 SALSA C03 SALSA C11 SALSA C21
2,5
2
lift coefficient
lift coefficient
2 1,5 1 0,5 0
McAlister 1982 LLR C03 LLR C11 LLR C21
2,5
1,5 1 0,5
5
10
15
angle of attack [°]
20
25
0
5
10
15
angle of attack [°]
Fig. 4 URANS: Lift coefficient with varying spatial resolution and t D T=300
20
25
Flow Prediction Around an Oscillating NACA0012 Airfoil at Re D 1,000,000 McAlister 1982 SALSA DES C03 SALSA DES C11 SALSA DES C21 SALSA DES O1 SALSA DES O2
lift coefficient
2
2
1,5 1 0,5 0
McAlister 1982 LLR DES C03 LLR DES C11 LLR DES C21 LLR DES O1 LLR DES O2
2,5
lift coefficient
2,5
55
1,5 1 0,5
5
10
20
15
0
25
5
10
angle of attack [°]
20
25
McAlister 1982 CEASM DDES C03 CEASM DDES C21 CEASM DDES O1 CEASM DDES O2
2,5 2
lift coefficient
15
angle of attack [°]
1,5 1 0,5 0
5
10
15
20
25
angle of attack [°]
Fig. 5 DES: Lift coefficient with varying spatial resolution and t D T=300
highly under-resolved cases. Thus, the turbulent structures can more easily become three-dimensional, leading to a reduction of the secondary vortex shedding with increased spanwise resolution. This can be recognised in the lift curves of DES (Fig. 5) by the smoothing of the lift curve and the decreasing discrepancy compared to the experimental results. The difference of the curves between c-type and o-type grids in Fig. 5 results from the fact that originally the c-type grid was adapted for boundary layer flows to be predicted by URANS, whereas the the o-type grid is as uniform as possible to account for the grid resolution necessary in the LES region. This fact, together with the improved agreement achieved by the c-type grid suggests that for this case capturing the dominant wall effects is essential for the integral force coefficients. The convergence of the results with respect to the spanwise resolution is evident for URANS. In the case of DES clear convergence of the solution is not seen, but might be possible with further refined resolution of the span on the same grid topology.
4.2 Temporal Resolution The temporal discretisation is based on a varying number of 300, 600 and 1,000 timesteps t to resolve a single period of oscillation Tosc D c=.kosc u1 /. The
56
O. Frederich et al. McAlister 1982 SALSA Δt=T/300 SALSA Δt=T/600 SALSA Δt=T/1000 SALSA Δt=T/1500
lift coefficient
2
McAlister 1982 LLR Δt=T/300 LLR Δt=T/600 LLR Δt=T/1000 LLR Δt=T/1500
2,5 2
lift coefficient
2,5
1,5 1 0,5
1,5 1 0,5
0
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
0
25
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
25
Fig. 6 URANS: Lift coefficient with varying temporal resolution on C03-grid
McAlister 1982 SALSA DES Δt=T/300 SALSA DES Δt=T/600 SALSA DES Δt=T/1000
2,5
2
lift coefficient
lift coefficient
2 1,5 1 0,5 0
McAlister 1982 LLR DES Δt=T/300 LLR DES Δt=T/600 LLR DES Δt=T/1000
2,5
1,5 1 0,5
5
10
20
15
0
25
5
10
angle of attack [°]
15
20
25
angle of attack [°]
McAlister 1982 CEASM DDES Δt=T/300 CEASM DDES Δt=T/600
2,5
lift coefficient
2 1,5 1 0,5 0
5
10
15
20
25
angle of attack [°]
Fig. 7 DES: Lift coefficient with varying temporal resolution on C03-grid
influence of the timestep size is investigated using the c-type grid with the coarsest spanwise resolution C03. This has been used to keep the required simulation expense within affordable limits. The Figs. 6 and 7 show the lift curves for URANS and DES for fixed grid and background model. The results of the URANS simulations with the SALSA model clearly demonstrate convergence of the lift curve with refined temporal resolution. The same level of convergence can be recognised also for the SALSA DES as the timestep size is reduced. By contrast, the LLR k–! is far from demonstrating convergence with increasing temporal resolution, neither for URANS nor DES. It is
Flow Prediction Around an Oscillating NACA0012 Airfoil at Re D 1,000,000
57
evident that the simulation resolves more unsteadiness with reduced timestep size, but in case of the LLR k–! model the numerical results increasingly deviate from the experimental results in the detached flow region predicting an excessive secondary vortex shedding that appears to be unphysical. The temporal dependency for the CEASM cannot yet be concluded from the results available. The hypothesis that remains to be proven is that the LLR model constants have been derived based on the presence of excessive numerical dissipation (either from coarse grids or overly-dissipative numerical schemes), giving rise to a model that itself is insufficiently dissipative. A RANS model should show independence of the time step beyond a certain extent, as the Reynolds-averaged paradigm upon which it is derived dictates that fine turbulent structures remain modelled using eddy viscosity irrespective of spatial and temporal resolution. It is supposed however that the LLR model does not produce sufficient eddy viscosity to damp small scale structures when the time filtering effect of a large numerical timestep is reduced, resulting in the unphysical “resolution” of fine-grained structures corresponding neither to a RANS or an LES. Independent of the modelling approach used, the lift curves in Figs. 6 and 7 clearly show that the maximum lift and the corresponding angle of attack are reduced with increasing temporal resolution, which corresponds to better corroboration with the experimental results. The curves in Figs. 6 and 7 reveal that the dynamics of the flow is already captured correctly for the extensively used timestep size of t D T=300. Although the Courant–Friedrichs–Lewy criterion CFL D u t= x 1 is not met overall for this temporal resolution, the influence on the flow prediction is relatively small and has been neglected in order to achieve a wider range of parameter variations with available computational resources.
4.3 URANS Versus DES In the Figs. 8 and 9 the lift and drag curves are shown such that the model influence can be judged on a fixed grid. In the case of URANS, Fig. 8, the results demonstrate McAlister 1982 SALSA C03 LLR C03 SALSA C11 LLR C11 SALSA C21 LLR C21
lift coefficient
2 1,5
McAlister 1982 SALSA C03 LLR C03 SALSA C11 LLR C11 SALSA C21 LLR C21
1
drag coefficient
2,5
1
0,5
0,5 0
5
10
15
angle of attack [°]
20
25
0
5
10
15
angle of attack [°]
Fig. 8 Lift and drag coefficient for URANS on fixed grid and t D T=300
20
25
58
O. Frederich et al. McAlister 1982 SALSA DES C11 LLR DES C11 SALSA DES C21 LLR DES C21 SALSA DES O1 LLR DES O1
lift coefficient
2 1,5
McAlister 1982 SALSA DES C11 LLR DES C11 SALSA DES C21 LLR DES C21 SALSA DES O1 LLR DES O1
1
drag coefficient
2,5
1
0,5
0,5 0
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
25
0
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
25
Fig. 9 Lift and drag coefficient for DES on fixed grid and t D T=300
that the solution does not depend on the spatial resolution but on the turbulence model used. In addition, comparison to the experimental results reveals that the LLR k–! model agrees slightly better with these. In contrast to URANS, the results obtained using DES show on the one hand a significant dependency upon the spanwise resolution, and on the other a reduced dependency on the turbulence model used. This behaviour arises from the hybrid synthesis of RANS and LES, where the LES activity and RANS=LES blending location causes the differences in the results for varying spatial resolution and the RANS region is mainly responsible for the model influence, visible in Fig. 9.
4.4 Model Influence For the present configuration the maximum lift is experienced before the maximum incidence is reached. This behaviour is predicted by all models and for all grids (see Figs. 10, 11). However, the angle of attack where the dynamic stall occurs is predicted best by the one-equation SALSA model compared to the two-equation models, even though the angle on the c-type grid and the maximum lift on the o-type grid are predicted too highly. The latter aspects can also be observed for the LLR k–! model but with slightly degraded performance concerning the prediction of the maximum lift and the associated incidence. Nevertheless the agreement of the results for this model with the experimental results is somewhat better close to the maximum incidence, where secondary vortex shedding occurs. The k"-based CEASM has only been applied in the DDES variant and URANS has not yet been performed with this model. The force coefficients obtained for this model on the C21-grid, shown in Fig. 11, reveal the changing quality of the pre and post-stall prediction. On the one hand the predicted lift matches the experimental results during the upstroke until the dynamic stall vortex develops, whereas on the other hand the discrepancy with the experiments is much higher than for the other models, especially noticeable in the drag curve. The results obtained on the O2-grid show the opposite behaviour for the lift and drag; the drag agrees well with the
Flow Prediction Around an Oscillating NACA0012 Airfoil at Re D 1,000,000 McAlister 1982 SALSA DES C21 LLR DES C21 CEASM DDES C21
lift coefficient
2
McAlister 1982 SALSA DES C21 LLR DES C21 CEASM DDES C21
1
drag coefficient
2,5
1,5 1
59
0,5
0,5 0
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
0
25
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
25
Fig. 10 Lift and drag coefficient with varying DES background model (C21, t D T=300) McAlister 1982 SALSA DES O2 LLR DES O2 CEASM DDES O2
lift coefficient
2
McAlister 1982 SALSA DES O2 LLR DES O2 CEASM DDES O2
1
drag coefficient
2,5
1,5 1
0,5
0,5 0
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
25
0
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
25
Fig. 11 Lift and drag coefficient with varying DES background model (O2, t D T=300)
experimental results in the pre-stall period, whereas the lift curve and the post-stall part of the drag are poorly predicted. Taking into account that the c-type grid resolution is focused close to the profile and for the o-type grid a uniform resolution in the wake was preferred, the conclusion is that capturing the physics near the profile is essential for the size of the maximum lift and the sufficient wake resolution is the basis for the correct dynamic stall angle. This thesis is supported by the results of the SALSA and LLR models, and partly those of the CEASM model.
4.5 Numerical Aspects The DES approach is a hybrid of RANS and LES. To obtain stable but also physical solutions for a given problem, it has been ensured that for both modes the favourable convection scheme will be used – in case of RANS upwind-based and for LES central schemes. Thus, the DES modification of the turbulence equations is connected with the usage of a hybrid convection scheme [11]. The blending of upwind-based and central schemes depends mainly on the local flow solution and is therefore not limited to DES.
60
O. Frederich et al.
The importance of the hybrid convection scheme is demonstrated by the lift curves in Fig. 12. Depicted are URANS solutions obtained with an upwind-based TVD scheme, with the hybrid scheme and the respective DES solution. In case of the SALSA model, it is evident that the main improvement of DES relative to URANS is based on the convection scheme (at least for this relatively coarse grid). For the LLR k! a small improvement can also be recognised in the downstroke region. This comparison reveals that URANS flow predictions can be improved by adapted numerical schemes, especially in the presence of flow separation. Starting a testcase from scratch, the temporal behaviour of the flow solution passes several periodic cycles (2–4) until initial perturbations are decayed. As can be recognised in Fig. 13, the solution reaches a stable periodic state represented by
McAlister 1982 SALSA TVD SALSA HYB SALSA DES
2,5
2
lift coefficient
lift coefficient
2 1,5 1 0,5 0
McAlister 1982 LLR TVD LLR HYB LLR DES
2,5
1,5 1 0,5
5
10
20
15
0
25
5
10
angle of attack [°]
15
20
25
angle of attack [°]
Fig. 12 Lift coefficient with varying convection scheme or DES (C03, t D T=300) McAlister 1982 SALSA DES C03
2,5
2
lift coefficient
lift coefficient
2 1,5 1 0,5 0
McAlister 1982 SALSA DES C11
2,5
1,5 1 0,5
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
25
0
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
McAlister 1982 SALSA DES O1
2,5
lift coefficient
2 1,5 1 0,5 0
5
10
20 15 angle of attack [°]
25
Fig. 13 Lift coefficient in three successive cycles on varying grid (SALSA, t D T=300)
25
Flow Prediction Around an Oscillating NACA0012 Airfoil at Re D 1,000,000
61
the nearly perfect reproduction of the lift curve in successive cycles for the coarse C03-grid. With increasing spatial resolution of the span, the convergence of the hysteresis is reduced to the upstroke phase of the airfoil. Due to the variations in this phase for fine spanwise resolution, the integral quantities obtained for the o-grids are phase-averaged with respect to the oscillation of the airfoil. However, the consistent reproduction of the lift curve with minor variations for an arbitrary number of cycles is caused by the entire reattachment of the flow without vortex shedding at the minimum incidence, and assisted by the timestep size chosen as an exact partition ratio of the periodic time. Thus, the hysteresis converges also for such – relative to the averaged experimental data – seemingly unphysical results predicted by the LLR k–! at fine temporal resolution.
5 Conclusion and Outlook Numerical simulations using URANS and DES were performed for the flow around an oscillating NACA0012 airfoil in order to identify important parameters influencing the prediction of the dynamic load on the structure. Both approaches can be used to capture the dynamics of the dynamic stall phenomenon correctly with acceptable discrepancies to few experimental results, but with some restrictions according mainly to the spatio-temporal resolution. Moreover, the necessity of sufficient spatial resolution in the spanwise direction as well as a very good circumferential resolution and in the wake has been clearly demonstrated. In addition, the prediction of the stall angle and the maximum lift is improved with increased temporal resolution. The results reveal that the one-equation SALSA model seems to be more robust and captures most of the physics for this case than the two-equation models applied. The technology feedback from DES to URANS, namely the application of a hybrid convection scheme for URANS, can improve the flow prediction without additional resolution. The ongoing work and further research will concentrate especially on the refinement in time and space. Therefore, the circumferential node distribution in the O-type grid will be improved and c-type grids with increased spanwise resolution, e.g. C41 and C61, will be used. In this context, the impact of an increased spanwidth, refined temporal resolution (such that CFL 1 is achieved) as well as the hybrid convection scheme applied to URANS on a fine grid will be investigated. To side-step the problems experienced with the two-equation models, more established standard models such as the Wilcox k–!, will be considered. The hypothesis concerning the possible recalibration of the LLR k–! model should be further investigated, which would certainly require more comprehensive experimental results and additional testcases. Acknowledgements The support of the EU within the DESider project (Detached Eddy Simulation for Industrial Aerodynamics – http://cfd.me.umist.ac.uk/desider), contract-no. AST3-CT-200-502842 and the IBM pSeries 690 of the North German cooperation for High-Performance Computing (HLRN) facility is gratefully acknowledged.
62
O. Frederich et al.
References 1. B UNGE , U., M OCKETT, C., T HIELE , F. (2007) Guidelines for implementing detached-eddy simulation using different models. Aerospace Science and Technology 11(5), 376–385. 2. B UNGE , U. (2004) Numerische Simulation turbulenter Str¨omungen im Kontext der Wechselwirkung zwischen Fluid und Struktur. Ph.D. thesis, ISTA, TU Berlin. 3. B UNGE , U., G URR , A., T HIELE , F. (2003) Numerical aspects of simulating the flow-induced oscillations of a rectangular bluff body. Journal of Fluids and Structures 18(3–4), 405–424. 4. F REDERICH , O. (2003) Numerical simulation of oscillating airfoils in turbulent flow with URANS and DES in comparison. Diploma thesis, ISTA, TU Berlin. ¨ 5. L UBCKE , H. (2001) Entwicklung expliziter Darstellungen zweiter statistischer Momente zur numerischen Simulation turbulenter Str¨omungen. Ph.D. thesis, ISTA, TU Berlin. 6. M C A LISTER , K.W., P UCCI , S.L., C ARR , L.W. AND M C C ROSKEY, W.J. (1982) An experimental study of dynamic stall on advanced airfoil sections. NASA TM-84245. 7. S PALART, P., D ECK , S., S HUR , M., S QUIRES , K., S TRELETS , M., AND T RAVIN , A. (2006) A new version of detached-eddy simulation, resistant to ambiguous grid densities. Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics, 20:181–195. 8. S WALWELL , K.E., S HERIDAN , J. AND M ELBOURNE , W.H. (2003) Frequency analysis of surface pressure on an airfoil after stall. 21. AIAA Applied Aerodynamics Conference, Orlando, Florida, June 23–26. 9. RUNG , T., B UNGE , U., S CHATZ , M. AND T HIELE , F. (2003) Restatement of the SpalartAllmaras Eddy-Viscosity Model in Strain-Adaptive Formulation. AIAA Journal 41(7), 1396– 1399. 10. RUNG , T. AND T HIELE , F. (1996) Computational Modelling of Complex Boundary-Layer Flows. Proc. 9th Int. Symp. on Transport Phenomena in Thermal-Fluid Eng., Singapore, 321–326. 11. T RAVIN , A., S HUR , M., S TRELETS , M. AND S PALART, P. (2000) Physical and Numerical Upgrades in the Detached-Eddy Simulation of Complex Turbulent Flows. Proc. of the 412th Euromech Colloquium on LES and Complex Transitional and Turbulent Flows, Munich. 12. X UE , L. (1998) Development of an efficient parallel solution algorithm for the threedimensional simulation of complex turbulent flows. Ph.D. thesis, ISTA, TU Berlin.
Two-Velocities Hybrid RANS-LES of a Trailing Edge Flow J.C. Uribe, N. Jarrin, R. Prosser, and D. Laurence
Abstract The flow around a trailing edge is computed with a new hybrid method designed to split the influences of the averaged and instantaneous velocity fields. The model is first tested on channel flows at different Reynolds numbers and coarse meshes giving good predictions of mean velocities and stresses. On the trailing edge flow the predictions of the hybrid model are compared with those using DES-SST on the same coarse mesh. The results of the hybrid model are close to the reference fine LES in terms of mean velocity and turbulent content. Keywords RANS LES Trailing edge Hybrid methods
1 Introduction Large Eddy Simulation has been successfully applied to different kinds of flows, but its use in industry has remained scarce mainly due to the large constraint present in the mesh requirements of wall bounded flows, specially at high Reynolds numbers. For such flows, the size of the energy containing structures scales with Re and hence the number of grid points required to resolve accurately the near wall eddies scales approximately with Re 1:76 [6]. To circumvent this severe near wall requirement, LES can be restricted to the simulation of the outer flow eddies whereas a RANS like eddy viscosity model is used to model the dynamics of the near wall eddies. In recent years, such hybrid methods combining RANS and LES have received increased attention from groups around the world. J.C. Uribe (), N. Jarrin, and R. Prosser School of Mechanical, Aerospace and Civil Engineering, The University of Manchester, Manchester M60 1QD, UK e-mail:
[email protected] D. Laurence School of Mechanical, Aerospace and Civil Engineering, The University of Manchester, Manchester M60 1QD, UK EDF R&D, 6 quai Watier, 78420 Chatou, France M. Braza and K. Hourigan (eds.), IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control, IUTAM Bookseries 14, c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
63
64
J.C Uribe et al.
In an attempt to ease the computational requirements in wall bounded flows, many approaches have been suggested. One method is to use so-called “wall functions” to bridge the viscous sublayer and provide a suitable boundary condition for the wall cells [20]. This can range from a log-law approximation [22] to a solution of a system of simplified equations in the near wall region [4]. Another approach is the use of RANS equations near the wall to provide the outer layer with correct information. The main problem of this type of approach is how to connect a statistically averaged flow (RANS) with the instantaneous filtered field (LES). A way to couple the two types of flows is the Detached Eddy Simulation (DES) ([24,30]) in which the turbulent lengthscale in the RANS equation is switched to a lengthscale based on the mesh filter width in order to reduce the viscosity in the separated region. The main idea of the DES approach is to solve the attached boundary layers with a RANS models and the separation region with a LES-like technique. One of the main issues of the DES approach is the fact that in regions near the wall where the grid is refined, the turbulent length scale dictated by the RANS model can become larger than the grid length scale therefore making the model reduce the turbulent viscosity and leading to a “grid induced separation”. A way to reduce the sensitivity to the grid induced separation was formulated by Menter et al. [15] using the blending function of the SST model to “shield” the boundary layer. As its name implies, DES should only be applied for separated flows and when the resolution of near wall fluctuations is required, another approach should be used. Other approaches are ‘zonal’, in which a part of the domain is set to be computed using RANS equations and the rest is computed with LES. Davidson and Peng [8] used the k! model in a region near the wall (y C 60) and a one equation model for the sub-grid stresses in the outer region. The location of the interface was fixed and Neumann boundary conditions were applied for the RANS variables. Another zonal approach has been developed by Temmerman et al. [28] where continuity of the turbulent viscosity is imposed at the interface. Different RANS models and different locations for the interface were tested. Using this constraint, the coefficient C is extracted from the interface and then adapted via exponential functions to increase the RANS contribution as the wall is approached. Hamba [12] tried coupling a near-wall RANS region with an outer LES by using a lengthscale computed from DNS. The approach resulted in an acceleration of the velocity profile at the interface, which was compared to another approaches where there is a similar effect ([8, 19]). In the zonal approach, the treatment of the interface has always been of importance for the success of the method since the RANS information does not provide correct turbulent fluctuations. Some ways to deal with this issue are the introduction of backscatter [21], damping the modelled stresses [27], the addition of fluctuations at the LES side of the interface [7] or the use numerical smoothing [31].
Two-Velocities Hybrid RANS-LES of a Trailing Edge Flow
65
2 The Hybrid Approach In many hybrid approaches the main problem is how to couple the two different velocity fields used in RANS (statistically averaged) and LES (filtered). This is often done by applying a matching criteria, i.e. same turbulent viscosity at the interface, same kinetic energy or dissipation etc. This poses a problem since these values represent totally different properties of different velocity fields. Instead of using one velocity field to couple RANS and LES, the model presented here attempts to adjust the resolved velocity field with information taken from the averaged velocity field. Many sub-grid models assume that the flow contains an inertial subrange and hence the sub-grid motions can be assumed to be isotropic. This is true only if the grid is small enough so that the anisotropy introduced by the mean shear can be neglected. At high Reynolds numbers, the refinement of the grid becomes too costly, therefore restricting the LES method to low Reynolds numbers flows. As the solid boundary is approached, the mean shear becomes high enough to introduce anisotropy across a diminishing range of scales. It is then necessary for the model to represent at the same time subgrid-scale contributions to the mean shear stress and isotropic dissipation effects. The approach presented herein differs form the previous ones by an attempt to separate these two issues in a way that allows the LES fluctuations to develop deeply in RANS layer without any perturbation on or from the mean flow characteristics. This allows to use coarser near wall meshes in all directions (i.e. very high aspect ratio cells as in classical near-wall RANS grids) while maintaining the turbulent characteristics of a resolved field on the whole domain.
2.1 Modelling The instantaneous velocity can be decomposed as U D hU i C u0
(1)
where hU i is the averaged velocity and u0 is the fluctuating one. Schumann [22] proposed to split the residual stress tensor into two, one “locally isotropic” part and one “inhomogeneous” part. The isotropic part is proportional to the fluctuating strain and does not affect the mean flow equations but determines the rate of energy dissipation. The inhomogeneous part is proportional to the mean strain and controls the shear stress and mean velocity profile: 2
ijr kk ıij D 2r .S ij hS ij i/ 3 ƒ‚ … „ locally isotropic
2a hS ij i „ ƒ‚ …
(2)
inhomogeneous
where h:i denotes ensemble averaging of the filtered equations. The viscosities r and a are based on fluctuating and mean strains. The isotropic part of the residual
66
J.C Uribe et al.
stress tensor has a zero time mean value. By refining the grid the residual stresses must tend to zero, therefore the inhomogeneous part must have a grid dependence parameter in the turbulent viscosity a . Schumann [22] used a mixing length model for a with the length scale computed as L D min. y; C10 /, where C10 is a constant that is difficult to prescribe for all types of flows. Schumann [22] and Grotzbach and Schumann [10] tried to derive a theoretical value for the constant but they were forced to introduced corrective constants to agree with a range of experiments. Moin and Kim [17] used the same principle of splitting the residual stress but in the mixing length model, they use the spanwise size of the cell as the length scale. They argue that for the near wall region in a channel flow, the important structures are streaks that are finely spaced on the spanwise direction. Therefore a coarse resolution in the spanwise direction would lead to larger eddies and a thicker viscous sublayer. Sullivan et al. [26] developed a similar approach for planetary boundary layer flows but chose a to match the Monin-Obukhov similarity theory [5]. Baggett [3] used a similar approach to compare two hybrid models, one “Schumann-like” and one “DES-like” but found excessive streamwise fluctuations leading to streaks that were much too large. In the context of hybrid LES–RANS, a blending function, fb , can be used to introduce a smooth transition between the resolved and the ensemble averaged turbulence parts. In the present study the total residual stress is written as: 2
ijr kk ıij D 2r fb .S ij hS ij i/ 2.1 fb /a hS ij i 3
(3)
In this way the averaged stress would be: 2 r
ij kk ıij D 2.1 fb /a hS ij i 3
(4)
which is just the RANS stress. This way the total shear stress would be 2.1 fb / a hS ij i C hu0 v0 i. It is therefore necessary that the blending function fb tends to one in the region where hu0 v0 i is resolved correctly and to zero in the region near the wall where the shear stress is under resolved due to the coarse grid. The total rate of transfer ˝of energy ˛from the ˝ filtered ˛ motions to the residual scales is given by (assuming that r S ij S ij r S ij S ij [18]) ˛ ˝ ij S ij D
˝ ˛ ˛ ˝ ˛ ˝ ˝ ˛ 2 r fb .S ij S ij /S ij C 2.1 fb / a S ij S ij
˛ ˝ ˛˝ ˛ ˝ ˛˝ ˛ ˝ D 2fb r . S ij S ij S ij S ij / C 2.1 fb /a S ij S ij
(5) (6)
which shows how the RANS viscosity contributes to dissipation in association with the mean velocity only, i.e. the resolved turbulent stresses are free to develop independently from the RANS viscosity.
Two-Velocities Hybrid RANS-LES of a Trailing Edge Flow
67
For the isotropic viscosity r , Schumann [22] used a model based on the sub-grid energy. Moin and Kim [17] used the standard Smagorinsky [23] model based on the fluctuating strain. Here the later approach is used: q r D .Cs /2 2sij0 sij0
(7)
sij0 D S ij hS ij i
(8)
In the frame of unstructured codes, the filter width is taken as twice the cell volume ( D 2Vol). In this study the elliptic relaxation model ' f of Laurence et al. [13] is used to calculate the RANS viscosity. This model solves for the ratio ' D v2 =k to compute the turbulent viscosity as: a D C 'kT (9) k p where T D max " ; CT " . Although for the channel flow calculations presented here, there is not much difference in the choice of the RANS models, the aim is to have a formulation that can be used in complex 3D flows, therefore the elliptic relaxation method seems a suitable choice to account for the wall effects. The blending function has been parameterised by the ratio of the turbulent length scale to the filter width: Lt n fb D tanh Cl (10) Here Cl D 1 and n D 1:5 are empirical constants. These values were chosen to match the shear stress profile based on channel flow results at Re D 395 with DNS data. When using the ' f model (Equation 9), the wall distance is not desirable and the blending function can be formulated using Lt D 'k 3=2 =". The blending function has been devised to connect the two length scales smoothly so its value is close to zero near the wall and one far from it. Similar functions have been used in other hybrid approaches (see Abe [1], Hamba [11] or Speziale [25]). Although the function in Equation (10) is totally empirical, it has been tested for a range of Reynolds numbers and grids and gave satisfactory results (not presented here). The function allows a higher contribution from the LES part as the grid is refined. Different coefficients have been used in the optimisation of the blending function, but the results are not greatly affected and anyway are always better than standard LES on the same mesh. In Equation (3) the averaged velocity has been calculated as a running average with an averaging window of about ten times the eddy turnover time. Although it is possible also to use plane averaged in the case of the channel flow, this was not done in order to keep the formulation applicable for 3D flows where no plane averaging is possible. In all computations shown here, a finite volume code Code Saturne [2] has been used with a second order time advancing scheme.
68
J.C Uribe et al.
3 Channel Flows Channel flow computations have been carried out at different Reynolds numbers on the same domain, a box of dimensions [0,6.4], [0,2], [0,3.2]. Here only few of the simulations are shown. For the channel flow at Re D 395 the coarsest mesh used has 40 40 30 cells (denoted C1). In Figs. 1 and 2 the resulting velocity and shear stress profiles for a standard Smagorinsky model and the hybrid model can be seen. The mesh is too coarse for a standard LES to capture all the small scales and therefore the shear stress is underpredicted, which in turn, produces an overestimation of the velocity magnitude. The hybrid model successfully blends the average shear stress and with the resolved one to produce the correct magnitude and therefore a better prediction of the velocity profile. The normal stresses can be seen in Fig. 3. The usual behaviour of overestimating the streamwise normal stress on coarse
30 DNS LES Hybrid
25 20 15 10 5
Fig. 1 Velocity profile at Re D 395
0
1
10
100
1000
Resolved Modelled Total DNS
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
Fig. 2 Shear stress at Re D 395
0
0
100
200 y+
300
400
Two-Velocities Hybrid RANS-LES of a Trailing Edge Flow Fig. 3 Normal stresses at Re D 395
69 DNS Hybrid LES
, , <w’w’>
10 8 6 4 2
0
100
Fig. 4 Velocity profiles at different Reynolds numbers
log-law Reτ = 395 Reτ = 590 Reτ = 1100 Reτ = 2000 Reτ = 4000
Cells 40x30x30 40x40x30 50x50x40 50x50x40 64x80x64
200 y+
+
Δx 59 88 140 256 400
300
400
1000
10000
+
Δz Case 39 C1 59 C4 88 C6 160 C8 200 C10
40
U+
30 20 10 0
1
10
100 y+
meshes by LES is corrected by the hybrid model. For higher Reynolds numbers the results have a similar trend. In Fig. 4 the velocity profiles are shown for different Reynolds number with coarse meshes. All the velocity profiles follow the log-law.
4 Trailing Edge Computations In the present study, we performed various hybrid simulations of the flow past an axisymmetric bevelled trailing edge. The geometry is described in detail in [33]. The Reynolds number based on the free stream velocity U1 and the hydrofoil chord, is 2:15 106 . The trailing edge tip angle is 25ı . Simulations were performed over the rear-most 38% of the hydrofoil chord with inlet conditions discussed below.
70
J.C Uribe et al.
The inlet Reynolds numbers based on the local momentum thickness and boundary layer edge velocity are 2;760 on the lower side and 3;380 on the upper side. These values were obtained from an auxiliary RANS calculation although some questions remain about their fidelity as mentioned in [32] and [33]. The computational domain is 0:5 h 41 h 16:5 h where h denotes the hydrofoil thickness. The grid was coarsened from 1;536 96 48 cells (claimed to be sufficient for a well resolved LES by Wang and Moin [33]) to 512 64 24 cells. The mesh has 192 cells in the streamwise direction on the wing both on the lower and on the upper side and 64 cells in the wake. The maximum grid spacing in wall unit is zC D 110 in the spanwise direction and x C D 230 in the streamwise direction. The mesh spacing in the streamwise direction is kept constant along the trailing edge when it is refined in the fine LES of Wang and Moing [33] ( zC D 55 and x C D 60). The minimum grid spacing in the wall normal direction is about y C D 2. The boundary conditions at the inlet are taken from Wang and Moin [33] using the following procedure. First, an auxiliary RANS calculation is conducted in a domain enclosing the entire strut. The resulting mean velocities, accounting for the flow acceleration and circulation associated with a lifting surface, are used as the inflow profiles outside the boundary layers on both side of the strut. Originally two RANS simulations were performed using the v2 f turbulence model of Durbin [9] and the Menter [16] SST model. In the present study the SST profiles have been used. The two turbulence model produce a noticeable difference in the velocity overshoot (undershoot) outside the upper (lower) boundary layer. SST results are associated with a smaller mean circulation, which is thought to promote trailing edge separation. Within the turbulent boundary layers the time series of inflow velocities are generated from two separate LES calculations of flat-plate boundary layers with zero pressure gradient, using the method described by Lund et al. [14]. The inflow generation LES matches the local boundary layer properties, including the momentum thickness and Reynolds number, with those from the RANS simulation. The boundary conditions for the RANS simulations are obtained from time averaging of the available samples. A no-slip condition is applied on the surface of the strut. The top and bottom boundaries are placed far away from the strut to minimise the impact of the imposed symmetry boundary condition. At the downstream boundary a standard exit boundary condition is applied. This case has been treated with dynamic wall models by Wang and Moin [34] and with similar methods in Tessicini et al. [29]. Two simulations using the same mesh are presented here. One with DES using the SST model as the RANS background model. The blending function F1 is used to avoid grid induced separation (see [15] for details). The second simulation is done with the hybrid method presented above. Velocity profiles and rms streamwise velocity fluctuations profiles are available from the fine LES [33] at locations of x=h D 0:625, 1:125, 1:625, 2:125, 3:125 on the aerofoil and at x D 0, 0:5, 1, 2 and 4 in the wakep(x=h D 0 is located at the trailing edge). Figure 5 shows the absolute velocity ( U 2 C V 2 ) profiles at the five stations on the aerofoil. The hybrid model presents a better agreement with the reference LES. It can be seen how the DES separates earlier and by the station at x=h D 1:125 there is a strong
Two-Velocities Hybrid RANS-LES of a Trailing Edge Flow Fig. 5 Velocity profiles over the aerofoil
71
x/h=−3.125 x/h=−2.125 x/h=−1.625 x/h=−1.125 x/h=−0.625
(y – yw) / h
DES + F1 shield function LES Wang & Moin (2000) Hybrid
0.4
0.2
0
Fig. 6 urms profiles over the aerofoil
0
1
2
3 |U| / Ue
4
5
x/h=−3.125 x/h=−2.125 x/h=−1.625 x/h=−1.125 x/h=−0.625
0.6
(y – yw) / h
0.5
DES + F1 shield function LES Wang & Moin (2000) Hybrid
0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0.2
0.4 urms / Ue
0.6
0.8
recirculation which is not present in the reference LES. The hybrid model predicts a slightly earlier separation but closer to the reference value. The turbulent content is also better predicted by the hybrid model as it can be seen from Fig. 6. The DES simulation does not sustain the fluctuations from the inlet and by the time the flow reaches the station at x D 3:125, the resolved fluctuations are very small. This is the normal behaviour of DES in an attached boundary layer, since it is designed to be used in massively separated flows. In general the structures predicted by DES are larger than what the hybrid model predicts. The structures are better resolved than with the DES approach because in the hybrid model the resolved stresses can develop independently from the RANS viscosity, i.e. the model associates the RANS viscosity with the mean flow only and links the resolved scale dissipation to the LES viscosity only (as shown in
72
J.C Uribe et al.
Equation (6)). This can be seen in Figs. 7 and 8 where the isosurfaces of fluctuating streamwise velocity are shown (C0.05 in red, 0.05 in blue). This is mainly due to the way in which each approach treats the boundary layer. DES uses RANS in a zone much larger near the wall, solving much of the boundary layer. On the other hand, the hybrid only uses full RANS in a zone very close to the wall and then it has a transition zone where both approaches contribute via different velocity fields. The blending function contours can be seen in Fig. 9. In Fig. 10 the zones where the two different length scales are used on the DES simulation can be seen.
Fig. 7 Iso-contours of u0 , hybrid model
Fig. 8 Iso-contours of u0 , DES model
Fig. 9 Blending function contours for the hybrid model
Two-Velocities Hybrid RANS-LES of a Trailing Edge Flow
73
Fig. 10 LES and RANS zones on DES simulation
Fig. 11 Velocity profiles at the wake
x/h=0.0 x/h=0.5 x/h=1.0 x/h=2.0 x/h=4.0
1
DES + F1 shield LES Wang & Moin (2000) Hybrid
y/h
0.5
0
−0.5
−1
0
1
2
3 U/U∞
4
5
The red region represents where the DES acts in LES mode, i.e. where the turbulent scale (k 3=2 =") is larger that the filter length scale (Cs ). In DES, the zone close to the wall is solved in RANS mode, therefore damping the fluctuations, whereas the hybrid model resolves the structures dictated by the size of the mesh, and introduces the effect of the wall via the averaged velocity. Although DES is acting in LES mode in the separated region, as it is designed to do, it is possible that the coarse resolution of the grid does not allow for a good resolved LES. Therefore a finer grid would probably lead to better results but this issue needs to be investigated further. In Fig. 11 the streamwise velocity profiles at the wake can be seen. Due to the better representation of the separated region by the hybrid model, the velocity profiles are in a better agreement than the DES. The rsm fluctuations can be seen in Fig. 12 where it can be seen that the levels are similar, although the spectral content is most certainly very different (as seen from Figs. 7 and 8) and this is important in aero-acoustic applications.
74
J.C Uribe et al.
Fig. 12 urms profiles at the wake
x/h=0.0 2
x/h=0.5
x/h=1.0
x/h=2.0
x/h=4.0
DES + F1 shield function LES Wang & Moin (2000) Hybrid
y/h
1
0
−1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3 0.4 urms / U∞
0.5
0.6
0.7
5 Conclusions A new hybrid method has been presented based on splitting the contributions from the averaged and fluctuating velocity fields. The method performs well in channel flows where the boundary layer is attached and on the separated flow over a trailing edge. The method has been compared with the DES method which is not designed to reproduce the behaviour of attached boundary layers. In the case of the separated flow around a trailing edge, the DES method behaves in LES mode in the separated region but is found to be not turbulent enough predicting a early separation from the curved surface. On the other hand, the hybrid method is capable of sustaining fluctuating behaviour only limited by the size of the cells. Although the mesh is too coarse to be able to reproduce the small structures, the model successfully includes the near wall effect on mean strain via the mean velocity field, allowing a separation of dissipative effects. This makes the model predict better separation and mean quantities compared to the DES simulation. There are many issues to investigate such as the sensitivity of the model to different meshes and different blending functions but the results obtained here are encouraging. Acknowledgements This work was financed by the DESider project (Detached Eddy Simulation for Industrial Aerodynamics) which is a collaboration between Alenia, ANSYS-AEA, Chalmers University, cnrs-Lille, Dassault, DLR, EADS Military Aircraft, EUROCOPTER Germany, EDF, FOI-FFA, IMFT, Imperial College London, NLR, NTS, NUMECA, ONERA, TU Berlin, and UMIST. The project is funded by the European Community represented by the CEC, Research Directorate-General, in the 6th Framework Programme, under Contract No. AST3-CT-2003502842.
Two-Velocities Hybrid RANS-LES of a Trailing Edge Flow
75
References 1. K Abe. A hybrid LES RANS approach using an anisotropy-resolving algebraic turbulence model. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 26:204–222, 2005. 2. F. Archambeau, N. Mechitoua, and M. Sakiz. A finite volume method for the computation of turbulent incompressible flows – industrial applications. International Journal on Finite Volumes, 1(1):1–62, 2004. 3. J.S. Baggett. On the feasibility of merging LES with RANS for the near-wall regions of attached turbulent flows. In Annual Research Briefs, pp. 267–276. Center for turbulence research, Stanford, CA, 1998. 4. E. Balaras, C. Benocci, and U. Piomelli. Two-layer approximate boundary conditions for large eddy simulations. AIAA Journal, 34:1111–1119, 1996. 5. J.A. Businger, J.C. Wyngaard, Y. Izumi, and E.E. Bradley. Flux-profile relationships in the atmospheric surface layer. Journal of Atmospheric Science, 28:181–189, 1971. 6. D. Chapman. Computational aerodynamics development and outlook. AIAA Journal, 17:1293– 1313, 1979. 7. L. Davidson and S. Dahlstr¨om. Hybrid LES-RANS: An approach to make LES applicable at high Reynolds number. International Journal of Computational Fluid Dynamics, 19:415–427, 2005. 8. L. Davidson and S.-H. Peng. Hybrid RANS-LES: A one equation sgs model combined with a k! model for predicting recirculating flows. International Journal of Numerical Methods in Fluids, 43:1003–1018, 2003. 9. P.A. Durbin. A reynolds stress model for near-wall turbulence. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 249:465–498, 1993. 10. G. Grotzbach and U. Schumann. Direct numerical simulation of turbulence velocity-pressure, and temperature fields in channel flows. In Symposium on Turbulent Shear Flow, pp. 18–20, 1977. 11. F. Hamba. An attempt to combine large eddy simulation with the k" model in a channel flow calculation. Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics, 14:323–336, 2001. 12. F. Hamba. A hybrid RANS LES simulation of turbulent flows. Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics, 16:387–403, 2003. 13. D. Laurence, J.C. Uribe, and S. Utyuzhnikov. A robust formulation of the v2-f model. Flow, Turbulence and Combustion, 73:169–185, 2004. 14. T. Lund, X. Wu, and D. Squires. Generation of turbulent inflow data for spatially-developing boundary layer simulations. Journal of Computational Physics, 140:233–258, 1998. 15. F. Menter, M. Kuntz, and R. Langtry. Ten years of industrial experience with the SST model. In K. Hanjali´c, Y. Nagano, and M. Tummers, eds., Turbulence, Heat and Mass Transfer 4, 4:625–632, 2003. 16. F.R. Menter. Two-equation eddy-viscosity turbulence models for engineering applications. AIAA Journal, 32(8):1598–1605, 1994. 17. P. Moin and J. Kim. Numerical investigation of turbulent channel flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 118:341–377, 1982. 18. F. Nicoud, J.S. Baggett, P. Moin, and W. Cabot. Large eddy simulation wall-modeling based on suboptimal control theory and linear stochastic estimation. Physics of Fluids, 13:2968–2984, 2001. 19. N.V. Nikkitin, F. Nicoud, B. Wasistho, K.D. Squires, and P. Spalart. An approach to wall modelling in large eddy simulations. Physics of Fluids, 10:1629–1632, 2000. 20. U. Piomelli and E. Balaras. Wall-layer models of large eddy simulation. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 34:349–374, 2002. 21. U. Piomelli, E. Balaras, E. Pasinato, K.D. Squire, and P. Spalart. The inner-outer later interface in large eddy simulation with wall layer models. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 23:538–550, 2003. 22. U. Schumann. Subgrid scale model for finite difference simulations of turbulent flows in plane channels and annuli. Journal of Computational Physics, 18:376–404, 1975.
76
J.C Uribe et al.
23. J. Smagorinsky. General circulation experiments with the primitive equations: I the basic equations. Monthly Weather Review, 91:99–164, 1963. 24. P. Spalart, W. Jou, M. Strelets, and S. Allmaras. Comments of feasibility of les for wings, and on a hybrid RANS/LES approach. In International Conference on DNS/LES, Aug. 4–8, 1997, Ruston, LA, 1997. 25. C.G. Speziale. Turbulence modeling for time-dependant RANS and VLES: A review. AIAA Journal, 26:179–184, 1998. 26. P. Sullivan, J. McWilliams, and C. Moeng. A subgrid-scale model for large eddy simulation of planetary boundary layer. Boundary Layer Methodology, 71:247–276, 1994. 27. L. Temmerman and M. Leschziner. A priori studies of near wall RANS model whithin a hybrid LES/RANS scheme. In Rodi W. and Fueyo N., editors, Engineering Turbulence Modelling and Experiments, 5:317–327, 2002. 28. L. Temmerman, M. Hadˆziabdi´c, M. Leschziner, and K. Hanjali´c. A hybrid two-layer URANSLES approach for large eddy simulation at high Reynolds numbers. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 26:173–190, 2005. 29. F. Tessicini, L. Temmerman, and M. A. Leschziner. Approximate near-wall treatments based on zonal and hybrid RANS-LES methods for LES at high Reynolds numbers. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 27:789–799, 2006. 30. A. Travin, M. Shur, M. Strelets, and P. Spalart. Detached-eddy simulation past a circular cylinder. Flow Turbulence and Combustion, 63:393–313, 1999. 31. P. Tucker and L. Davidson. Zonal kl based large eddy simulations. Computational Fluid Dynamics, 33:267–287, 2004. 32. M. Wang. Progress in les of trailing-edge turbulence and aeroacoustics. In Annual Research Briefs. Center for turbulence research, Stanford, CA, 1997. 33. M. Wang and P. Moin. Computation of trailing-edge flow and noise using large-eddy simulation. AIAA Journal, 38:2201–2209, 2000. 34. M. Wang and P. Moin. Dynamic wall modeling for large-eddy simulation of complex turbulent flows. Physics of Fluids, 14:2043–2051, 2002.
Assessment of Flow Control Devices for Transonic Cavity Flows Using DES and LES G.N. Barakos, S.J. Lawson, R. Steijl, and P. Nayyar
Abstract Since the implementation of internal carriage of stores on military aircraft, transonic flows in cavities were put forward as a model problem for validation of CFD methods before design studies of weapon bays can be undertaken. Depending on the free-stream Mach number and the cavity dimensions, the flow inside the cavity can become very unsteady. Below a critical length-to-depth ratio (L=D), the flow has enough energy to span across the cavity opening and a shear layer develops. When the shear layer impacts the downstream cavity corner, acoustical disturbances are generated and propagated upstream, which in turn causes further instabilities at the cavity front and a feedback loop is maintained. The acoustic environment in the cavity is so harsh in these circumstances that the noise level at the cavity rear has been found to approach 170 dB and frequencies near 1 kHz are created. The effect of this unsteady environment on the structural integrity of the contents of the cavity (e.g. stores, avionics, etc.) can be serious. Above the critical L=D ratio, the shear layer no longer has enough energy to span across the cavity and dips into it. Although this does not produce as high noise levels and frequencies as shorter cavities, the differential pressure along the cavity produces large pitching moments making store release difficult. Computational fluid dynamics analysis of cavity flows, based on the Reynolds-Averaged Navier–Stokes equations was only able to capture some of the flow physics present. On the other hand, results obtained with Large-Eddy Simulation or Detached-Eddy Simulation methods fared much better and for the cases computed, quantitative and qualitative agreement with experimental data has been obtained. Keywords Transonic cavity flow LES DES Flow control
G.N. Barakos, S.J. Lawson (), and R. Steijl CFD Laboratory, Department of Engineering, University of Liverpool, Brownlow Hill, Liverpool L69 3GH, UK P. Nayyar Aircraft Research Association, Manton Lane, Bedford MK41 7PF, UK M. Braza and K. Hourigan (eds.), IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control, IUTAM Bookseries 14, c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
77
78
G.N. Barakos et al.
1 Introduction Numerous experimental investigations have been performed on cavity flows in an attempt to better understand the problem. Most cavity experiments were originally based on unsteady pressure measurements in wind tunnels. Ross et al. from QinetiQ [1,2] and Tracy et al. from NASA Langley [3] are two examples of researchers who have conducted a significant number of wind tunnel experiments on cavities of several configurations over a broad range of Mach and Reynolds numbers. Ross and Peto [4] also provided experimental data on cavity acoustical suppression methods including leading-edge spoilers and vortex-shedding rods amongst others. Recent experimental endeavours have exploited non-intrusive, optical techniques such as Schlieren Photography [5] and Optical Reflectometry [6] to study cavity flows. More advanced non-intrusive methods such as Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) [7] and Laser Doppler Velocimetry (LDV) [8] are also beginning to appear in cavity flow studies as a means of obtaining high-fidelity, high-resolution data for the instantaneous flow-field and the velocity variations inside the cavity. Such methods are, however, expensive and are either restricted to low Reynolds number flows. Recent studies of cavity flows have therefore attempted to use Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) as an analysis tool, with most emphasis on the use of Reynolds-Averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) equations in conjunction with various turbulence closures. Most applications of Unsteady RANS (URANS) to cavity flows have employed algebraic turbulence models, especially different versions of the Baldwin-Lomax models, due to their simplicity [9–11]. However, such simple eddy viscosity models were realised to be generally incapable of accurately predicting the turbulent cavity flow-field [12], and investigations with more advanced turbulence models such as the two-equation k" and k! models were made. Most references to cavity flow modelling with two-equation models were related to supersonic flow conditions [13, 14] while applications of two-equation models to transonic cavity flows are rare. A detailed survey of published works on cavity flow can be found in [15]. One of the major drawbacks of URANS is the difficulty in predicting the full spectrum of turbulent scales. In high Reynolds flows, for instance, a broad range of turbulent length and time scales persist. For the cavity, this intense turbulent environment is further coupled with strong acoustic radiation, the source of which is located at the downstream corner of the cavity. The acoustical signature in the cavity is composed of broadband noise (lower-frequency, lower-energy noise contributed by the free-stream and=or the shear layer) with the narrow-band noise (a combination of higher-frequency and lower-frequency noise of different magnitude contributed by vortex-vortex, vortex-wall, vortex-shear layer, shock-shear layer and shear layer-wall interactions) superimposed on it. The narrow-band spectrum comprises of discrete acoustic tones called Rossiter modes after J.E. Rossiter who developed a semi-empirical formula to calculate them [16]. Statistical turbulence models tend to predict well the larger scales associated with the lower-frequency discrete acoustic tones but fail to provide the same accuracy in capturing the smaller, higher-frequency and more intermittent time scales. The broadband noise is not
Assessment of Flow Control Devices for Transonic Cavity Flows Using DES and LES
79
captured by these models either. The presence of these multiple acoustic tones and of a large number of turbulent scales may mean that achieving a good level of accuracy and consistency with turbulence models is difficult for cavity flows. Previous computations with a cavity L=D ratio of 5, for example, showed that the results were sensitive to the grid used. In an attempt to reduce the grid sensitivity and obtain a grid-converged solution, grids finer than those employed in previous studies [15] were used. In addition, cavities of different dimensions were investigated to determine the range of applicability of the URANS method. This was accomplished by performing parametric studies in time and space on 2D cavities of different sizes, e.g. L=D D 2, L=D D 10 and L=D D 16. Ever since the problems associated with cavity flows were realised (such as high acoustics and buffetting) many experiments and computations were conducted with the aim of improving the cavity environment. Some control methods involved manipulating the cavity geometry by either modifying the angle at which the cavity walls are slanted, for instance, or by adding an external device to deliberately alter the flow inside the cavity (see Fig. 1). Such control techniques are referred to here as open-loop control because no feedback loop is implemented in the control method. Consequently these open-loop control methods are most effective at one particular stage in the aircraft’s flight profile. Rossiter [16] and more recently Ross [2], for example, have performed extensive wind tunnel experiments on the effectiveness of spoilers as open-loop flow control devices. The non-versatility of such openloop control devices over a larger proportion of the flight regime diverted attention
3D Cavity with Sloping Walls 3D Cavity Model
Rod spoiler
Flat spoiler
Fig. 1 Flow control devices used in combination with the clean cavity
Saw-tooth spoiler
80
G.N. Barakos et al.
to closed-loop control methods, which continually adapt to the flight conditions making them more suitable for time-varying and off-design situations. Although open-loop control studies have dominated most control efforts in cavity flows, examples of closed-loop cavity control studies are also beginning to appear in literature. For more information on the cavity flow control, the reader is directed toward an excellent review by Cattafesta et al. in Ref. [17], which provides an elaborate account of different open-loop and closed-loop control strategies adopted by different researchers.
2 Outline of the Experiments by Ross et al. Experimental pressure measurements were obtained using the Aircraft Research Association Ltd (ARA) wind tunnel at Bedford, UK (see Ref. [2]). The ARA wind tunnel is a 9 by 8 foot continuous flow, transonic wind tunnel (TWT) with ventilated roof, floor and side walls. 3D clean cavities were first studied with or without doors (see Fig. 1). The doors prevented any leakage at the cavity edges in the span-wise direction forcing the flow to channel into the cavity. In this configuration, the flow behaves as if it were two-dimensional and is assumed to be well represented by modelling the cavity as 2D. Several flow control devices were subsequently added to the cavity as shown in Fig. 1. The L=D D 5 cavity model (with width-to-depth ratio [W/D] of 1) measured 20 in. in length and 4 in. in width and depth. The generic cavity rig model was positioned at zero incidence and sideslip and the wind tunnel was operated at a Mach number of 0.85 and atmospheric pressure and temperature. Unsteady pressure measurements were registered inside and outside the cavity via Kulite pressure transducers: ten pressure transducers were located inside the cavity aligned along the cavity rig center, two on the flat plate ahead of the cavity (see Fig. 1), one on the flat plate aft of the cavity, two on the front and rear walls and four on the port side walls [2, 18]. The data was sampled at 6 kHz using a high-speed digital data acquisition system. The measured data was presented in terms of Sound Pressure Level (SPL) and Power Spectral Density (PSD) plots. The SPL is an indication of the intensity of noise generated inside the cavity and can be obtained from the measurements using the following equation: SPL .dB/ D 20 log10 prms =2 105
(1)
where prms is the RMS pressure normalised by the International Standard for the minimum audible sound of 2 105 Pa with the RMS pressure denoted by: prms D
r X
p pmean
2 =N
(2)
Assessment of Flow Control Devices for Transonic Cavity Flows Using DES and LES
81
Fig. 2 SPL computed using the experimental data by Ross [4] for the cavity configurations shown in Fig. 1
Spectral analysis was performed using Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) to obtain the power spectral density, which presents the RMS pressure versus frequency and provides a measure of the frequency content inside the cavity. Indicative results of the SPL along the floor of the L=D D 5 cavity are shown in Fig. 2 where the relative effectiveness of the flow control devices is compared.
3 Results and Discussion Several sets of results have been obtained for this work. Starting from URANS calculations, CFD grids of approximately 4 million cells were used. Figure 3 presents an overview of such a grid. Care has been taken to maintain uniform cells near the cavity region and grid dependency has been checked [19]. The LES results required finer grids with further requirements for orthogonality and aspect ratio, so grids with more than 6 million cells were employed. For the cases where flow control devices were present, the region near the front of the cavity had to be refined so that spoilers can be embedded in the grid. The details of the employed CFD solver as well as the employed turbulence models are given in [20]. For all cases computed the Mach number at the free-stream ahead of the cavity was kept at 0.85. The Reynolds number based on the length of the cavity was 1 million, and the LES solutions were forced with noise at the free-stream which corresponded to 1% of turbulence intensity. The k! and Spalart–Almaras turbulence models were employed along with their Detached-Eddy Simulation (DES) versions. For LES the
82
G.N. Barakos et al.
Fig. 3 3D view of the employed CFD grid for LES calculations. Almost uniform grid was applied within the cavity and around the walls, however, cell skewness had to be tolerated further away from the cavity
Table 1 Summary of the obtained URANS results and comparison with the experimental findings Location
Control device
Numerical data
X=L D 0:05
No device Spoiler Rear sloping wall
˙6;000 ˙500 ˙2;000
Experimental data (doors on) ˙4;000 ˙2;000 ˙1;000
Reasonable prediction? Yes No Yes
X=L D 0:55
No device Spoiler Rear sloping wall
˙10;000 ˙500 ˙4;000
˙6;000 ˙2;000 ˙1;500
Yes No No
X=L D 0:95
No device Spoiler Rear sloping wall
˙15;000 ˙500 ˙5;000
˙10;000 ˙4;000 ˙2;000
No No No
classic Smagorinsky sub-grid scale model was employed. Table 1 summarises the obtained URANS results and gives an overall assessment of these in comparison to the experimental data. As can be seen, the employed URANS method (based on the Spalart–Almaras and the k! models) did not capture the changes induced by the flow control devices in the overall flow topology and the reduction in noise. Inspection of the experimental data suggests that although the overall level of pressure fluctuations is lower for the cases where flow control devices are deployed, the distribution of acoustic energy in the various frequency-bands around each Rossiter mode is not significantly affected. For this reason further LES and DES results were obtained for cavities with the control devices deployed. Indicative results of these URANS computations are shown in Fig. 4 where the obtained RMS pressure at a station close to the downstream corner of the cavity is compared with the experimental data. It is evident that URANS based on the k! model was not able to capture even the magnitude of the pressure fluctuations measured in the wind tunnel.
Assessment of Flow Control Devices for Transonic Cavity Flows Using DES and LES
83
Fig. 4 URANS results using the k! turbulence model for the case where slanted walls have been deployed at the front and back of the cavity
3.1 LES for Cavities Without Flow Control Devices The first set of results were obtained for clean cavities with and without doors and these are compared against experimental data and Rossiter’s theory in Figs. 5 and 6. Given the complexity of the flow and the demanding conditions, fair agreement has been obtained with experiments, at least for the magnitude of the mean pressure and the pressure fluctuations for the lowest Rossiter frequencies. The results shown here suggest that the current LES is perhaps a good compromise for the analysis of these complex flows since it maintains good predictions for a range of cases (doors=no-doors) and compares well (at least in magnitude) with experimental data. For the cases shown in this paper, DES results were also obtained based on the Spalart-Almaras model but these are not shown here due to space. In contrast to the URANS results, the LES=DES results show substantial unsteadiness in the flow around the cavity and the instantaneous results have enough frequency content. This encouraging result suggests that for the flow controlled cases LES and DES could also be used. Further computations on finer and coarser grids revealed much less dependency of the obtained results on grid size which was not the case with the employed URANS models.
3.2 Cavities with Flow Control Devices Out of all controlled cases computed, results are shown here for the cavity with a slanted downstream wall. For this test case, Table 1 indicates that stations close to
84
G.N. Barakos et al.
Fig. 5 LES results for the clean cavity case (no doors): RMS pressure at four different stations (g, h, i and j) along the cavity floor
Fig. 6 LES results for the clean cavity case (with doors): RMS pressure at four different stations (g, h, i and j) along the cavity floor
Assessment of Flow Control Devices for Transonic Cavity Flows Using DES and LES
85
the leading edge of the cavity were well-predicted by URANS. This, however, was not the case for downstream stations. Figure 4 compares the URANS predictions with experiments and as can be seen, substantial discrepancies are encountered. The overall characteristics of the URANS solution indicate that the shear layer formed just after the leading edge of the cavity remains coherent until it reached the downstream wall. This flow topology is in contrast to experimental observations and resulted in a less noisy cavity in comparison to measurements. The striking difference between LES (or DES) results and URANS for this case was the instantaneous flow-field predicted by LES and DES was not coherent downstream the middle of the cavity, and this resulted in a much more energetic flow-field with higher levels of noise. Figure 7 shows exactly this effect by comparing the RMS pressure and the pressure spectra with experiments. Although discrepancies still exist, the level of RMS pressure is much better predicted and most of the tones measured during experiments were also present in the CFD solutions (at least for the lower Rossiter frequencies). An instantaneous flow-field from our LES computations for the clean cavity case is shown in Fig. 8a while Fig. 8b presents results for the case where a downstream slanted wall was employed. Similar results have been obtained for the control devices shown in Fig. 1, however, these are not presented here.
RMS Pressure
Pressure Spectra
Fig. 7 RMS pressure at two different stations (e and f) along the cavity floor for the case where a slanted downstream wall was used as a flow control device
86
G.N. Barakos et al.
(a) Clean cavity (no doors)
(b) Slanted downstream wall (no doors)
Fig. 8 Comparison between instantaneous Mach number fields for (a) the clean cavity and (b) the controlled cavity (slanted downstream wall)
4 Conclusions In this paper, results have been presented from URANS, LES and DES computations for transonic cavity flows. For clean (without control) cavity flow cases, LES and, to some extend, DES computations were in good agreement with experiments providing a reliable (though expensive in terms of computing time) method for the analysis of such complex turbulent flows. Having established confidence on the obtained results for clean cavities, several cases have been investigated where changes in the cavity geometry were introduced in an attempt to control the flow and reduce the level of noise radiated from the cavity. As was the case for clean cavities, URANS results (obtained using the Spalart–Almaras and the k! models) were in poor agreement with experiments and failed to predict essential pars of the cavity flow physics. LES based on wall-functions and the Smagorinsky sub-grid scale model, as well as DES results (using the Spalart–Almaras model) captured much better the energetic and unsteady flow field of the cavity and compared better with experimental data. The current set of computations generated significant amounts of data, which after further analysis could be used to better identify possible modifications to the employed URANS and DES approaches that could lead to better computing efficiencies. Further work is currently underway to obtain results using finer grids and different sub-grid models for LES so that confidence can be established in the adopted method. Acknowledgements The financial support of the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council through grant EP=C533380=1 is gratefully acknowledged. The authors would like to extend their gratitude to John Ross and Graham Foster of QinetiQ (Bedford) and Trevor Birch of DSTL for providing the experimental data.
Assessment of Flow Control Devices for Transonic Cavity Flows Using DES and LES
87
References 1. J.A. Ross and J.W. Peto. Internal Stores Carriage Research at RAE. Technical Report 2233, Royal Aircraft Establishment, January 1992. 2. J.A. Ross. Cavity Acoustic Measurements at High Speeds. Technical Report DERA/MSS/ MSFC2/TR000173, QinetiQ, March 2000. 3. M.B. Tracy, E.B. Plentovich and J. Chu. Measurements of Fluctuating Pressure in a Rectangular Cavity in Transonic Flow at High Reynolds Numbers. Technical Report 4363, NASA, June 1992. 4. J.A. Ross and J.W. Peto. The Effect of Cavity Shaping, Front Spoilers and Ceiling Bleed on Loads Acting on Stores, and on the Unsteady Environment Within Weapon Bays. Technical report, QinetiQ, March 1997. 5. H. Heller and J. Delfs. Cavity Pressure Oscillations: The Generating Mechanism Visualized. AIAA, 33(8):1404–1411, August 1995. 6. M.A. Kegerise, E.F. Spina and L.N. Cattafesta. An Experimental Investigation of Flow-Induced Cavity Oscillations. In 30th AIAA Fluid Dynamics Conference. AIAA, June/July 1999. AIAA Paper 99-3705. 7. S.A. Ritchie, N.J. Lawson and K. Knowles. An Experimental and Numerical Investigation of an Open Transonic Cavity. In 21st Applied Aerodynamics Conference, Orlando, Florida, June 23–26 2003. AIAA Paper 2003-4221. 8. M.J. Esteve, P. Reulet and P. Millan. Flow Field Characterisation within a Rectangular Cavity. In 10th International Symposium Applications of Laser Techniques to Fluid Mechanics, July 2000. 9. O. Baysal and S. Srinivasan. Navier–Stokes Calculations of Transonic Flows Past Cavities. Technical report, NASA, 1989. Contractor Report 4210. 10. P.D. Orkwis and P.J. Disimile. Transient Shear Layer Dynamics of Two- and ThreeDimensional Open Cavities. Technical Report ADA 298030, Air Force Office of Scientific Research, 1995. 11. C.-J. Tam, P.D. Orkwis and P.J. Disimile. Algebraic Turbulence Model Simulations of Supersonic Open-Cavity Flow Physics. AIAA, 34(11):2255–2260, November 1996. 12. D.P. Rizzetta. Numerical Simulation of Supersonic Flow Over a Three-Dimensional Cavity. AIAA, 26(7):799–807, July 1988. 13. S.H. Shih, A. Hamed and J.J. Yeuan. Unsteady Supersonic Cavity Flow Simulations Using Coupled k" and Navier–Stokes Equations. AIAA, 32(10):2015–2021, October 1994. 14. X. Zhang. Compressible Cavity Flow Oscillation due to Shear Layer Instabilities and Pressure Feedback. AIAA, 33(8):1404–1411, August 1995. 15. D. Lawrie. Investigation of Cavity Flows at Low and High Reynolds Numbers Using Computational Fluid Dynamics. Ph.D. thesis, University of Glasgow, 2004. 16. J.E. Rossiter. Wind Tunnel Experiments on the Flow over Rectangular Cavities at Subsonic and Transonic Speeds. Technical Report 64037, Royal Aircraft Establishment, October 1964. 17. L.N. Cattafesta, D. Williams, C. Rowley and F. Alvi. Review of Active Control of FlowInduced Cavity Resonance. In 33rd AIAA Fluid Dynamics Conference. AIAA, June 2003. AIAA Paper 2003-3567. 18. M.J. de C. Henshaw. M219 Cavity Case. Technical Report RTO-TR-26, Research and Technology Organization, October 2000. 19. P. Nayyar and G. Barakos. A Summary of Turbulence Modelling Approaches in CFD. Technical report, University of Glasgow, 2002. Aerospace Engineering Report 0206. 20. P. Nayyar, G. Barakos and K. Badcock. Numerical Simulation of Transonic Cavity Flows using LES and DES. The Aeronautical Journal, 111(1117):153–164, March 2007.
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Part III
Theoretical Aspects & Analytical Approaches of Flow Separation
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers A. Kluwick, S. Braun, and E.A. Cox
Abstract Recent developments in the construction of airfoils and rotorblades are characterized by an increasing interest in the application of so-called smart structures for active flow control. These are characterized by an interplay of sensors, actuators, real-time controlling data processing systems and the use of new materials e.g. shape alloys with the aim to increase manoeuvrability, reduce drag and radiated sound. The optimal use of such devices obviously requires a detailed insight into the flow phenomena to be controlled and in particular their sensitivity to external disturbances. In this connection locally separated boundary layer flows are of special interest. Asymptotic analysis of boundary layer separation in the limit of large Reynolds number Re ! 1 has shown that in a number of cases which are of importance from a practical point of view solutions of the resulting interaction equations describing two-dimensional steady flows exist up to a limiting value c of the relevant controlling parameter only while two branches of solutions exist in a regime < c . The present study aims at a better understanding of near critical flows j c j ! 0 and in particular the changes of the flow behaviour associated with the passage of through c . Keywords Boundary layer theory Separation bubble Laminar-turbulent transition Fisher’s equation
1 Introduction Asymptotic analysis of high Reynolds number flows Re ! 1 has shown that there exist at least two different routes leading to the formation of a separated flow region inside an otherwise attached laminar boundary layer. Firstly, the presence A. Kluwick () and S. Braun Institute of Fluid Mechanics and Heat Transfer, Vienna University of Technology, Resselgasse 3/E322, A-1040 Vienna, Austria e-mail: falfred.kluwick, [email protected] E.A. Cox School of Mathematical Sciences, University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4, Ireland e-mail: [email protected] M. Braza and K. Hourigan (eds.), IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control, IUTAM Bookseries 14, c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
91
92
A. Kluwick et al.
of an imposed adverse pressure gradient acting over a distance of order one on the typical boundary-layer length scale may cause the wall shear to decrease and finally become negative over a bounded distance before it recovers again. Examples of this so-called marginal separation are provided by the leading edge separation on slender airfoils at incidence, flow separation associated with the deflection of wall jets and flow separation in channels enforced by suction. Secondly, a firmly attached laminar boundary layer may be forced to separate due to the presence of a large adverse pressure gradient acting over a short distance caused, for example, by a surface mounted obstacle or the Kutta condition near the trailing edge of a slender airfoil. Although these scenarios ultimately resulting in the formation of separated flow differ vastly in detail they, nevertheless, share a number of common features. Most important, it is found that a uniformly valid description of the flowbehaviour close to separation requires the investigation of three layers or decks having substantially different properties. Viscosity plays a significant role inside a thin sublayer of the oncoming boundary layer (the lower deck) only while the dynamics of the flow further away from the wall is predominantly inviscid. The main portion of the boundary layer (main deck) primarily acts to transfer the displacement effects of the low speed flow inside the lower deck to the region outside the boundary layer (upper deck) and to transfer the resulting pressure response unchanged to the near wall region. While the leading order upper and main deck problems can be solved analytically, the study of the flow behaviour inside the viscous wall layer requires a numerical treatment in general. Specifically, for the 1st route it is found that the essential features of the lower deck region associated with marginally separated flows are captured by the integro-differential equation 3 2 Zx Z 2 @P .; z; t/ 1 @ P .; z; t/ 4 A2 x 2 C D C p d 5 d @ @z2 x 1 1 (1) Zx Zx 1 @.A h/ vw d d .x /1=4 @t .x /1=4 1
1
where A.x; z; t/ and P .x; z; t/ denote the (negative) perturbation displacement thickness and the pressure while the parameter represents a measure of the angle of incidence, the turning angle and the suction rate, respectively. Furthermore, x, z and t denote Cartesian coordinates in the streamwise and spanwise directions and the time while , , are positive constants. All quantities are suitably nondimensionalized and scaled. Finally, h.x; z; t/ and vw .x; z; t/ account for the effects of controlling devices such as surface mounted obstacles and suction stripes. In contrast, if boundary layer separation is approached along route 2 then the boundary layer equations in incompressible form @u @v @w C C D 0; @x @y @z
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers
93
@u @u @u @P @2 u @u Cu Cv Cw D C 2; @t @x @y @z @x @y @w @w @w @P @2 w @w Cu Cv Cw D C 2 @t @x @y @z @z @y
(2)
together with the matching and boundary conditions u!y
for x ! 1 ; B.x; z; t/ ; w! y
u ! y C A h;
u D w D 0 ; v D vw
Zx B D 1
at y D 0
@P d @z
for y ! 1
(3)
have to be solved. Here u, v, w are the velocity components in x, y, z directions where y measures the distance from the solid wall. To close the problems (1) and (2), (3) a relationship P D F .A/ between A and the induced pressure P is required which is problem specific. Here we focus on incompressible flows where 1 P D 2
Z1 Z1 1 1
@.A h/.; ; t/=@ p dd : .x /2 C .z /2
(4)
Despite the fact that the form of the interaction law P D F .A/ depends on the specific problem under consideration, marginally separated flows exhibit a number of properties which appear to be universal. Most important, in all known cases of marginal separation it is found that two-dimensional steady state solutions exist up to a critical value c of only and that inside a range of values < c the problem is non-unique and admits two branches of solutions. As a specific example, Fig. 1 displays A.0/ versus for uncontrolled incompressible flow h D vw D 0
1.5
upper branch
1
0.5
A(0) 0 −0.5
¡c
lower −1 −1
−0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
¡ Fig. 1 Fundamental curve of marginal separation; dashed line: local solution of classical boundary layer theory (asymptote for ! 1), dotted line: parabola approximation near the bifurcation point, see Section 2.1
94
A. Kluwick et al.
past the leading edge of a slender airfoil at incidence first studied by Ruban [17] and independently by Stewartson et al. [20] where c 2:66. Interestingly, similar phenomena are known to occur also in situations where a fully attached boundary layer separates due to rapid changes of the boundary conditions, e.g. subsonic trailing edge flow, Korolev [14], supersonic flow past flared cylinders, Gittler and Kluwick [10]. The nonexistence of steady two-dimensional solutions to equations (1) or (2), (3) supplemented with the interaction relationship P D F .A/ if the relevant controlling parameter exceeds a critical value raises a number of questions concerning the changes of the flow behaviour associated with its transition from sub-critical to super-critical values, e.g. Braun and Kluwick [4]. Their answer requires the investigation of unsteady, three-dimensional effects which poses an extremely difficult numerical task. To the authors knowledge it has been attacked so far for marginally separating flows only where Smith [19], Ryzhov and Smith [18], Elliott and Smith [7] noted that the evolution of unsteady two-dimensional disturbances above c inevitably leads to the formation of finite time singularities. Probably the most detailed calculations based on the Navier–Stokes equations have been carried out by Alam and Sandham [1] for the specific case of a channel flow designed such that boundary layer separation on the lower wall is enforced by the pressure increase resulting from suction at the upper wall. The results indicate that the flow inside the separation bubble becomes increasingly sensitive to disturbances as the suction rate increases ultimately leading to bubble bursting and, if the suction rate is sufficiently high, to repeated bubble bursts in the form of self-sustained oscillations. Also, it is found that a transition from laminar to turbulent flow then occurs near and downstream of reattachment which is characterized, among others, by the formation of -type vortices, Fig. 2, which is supported also by experimental evidence. Obviously, one then is confronted with the question if and how the singularities predicted by the asymptotic theories for Re ! 1 are related to flow structures for large but finite Reynolds number and how much of the dynamics emerging from Navier–Stokes calculations can be captured by considering truly unsteady, threedimensional effects described by (1) or (2), (3).
2 Bifurcation Analysis of Near Critical Flows 2.1 Route 1 Towards Separation As noted by Braun and Kluwick [2–4] the treatment of marginally separated flows simplifies considerably if differs only slightly from c or, more precisely, by focussing on the limit " D j c j1=4 ! 0. Appropriate expansions of A; h; and vw then are
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers
95
x
y
m rea ean tt. z
m sep ean . Fig. 2 Instantaneous contours of the span-wise vorticity component !z D @v=@x @u=@y, [1]. -vortex structures within the time mean separated region are associated with the generation of moving singularities (white lines) immediately after blow-up events
A D A1c .x/ C "2 a1 .x; zN; tN/ C "4 a2 .x; zN; tN/ C : : : ; h D h1 .x/ C "4 h1 .x; zN; tN/ C : : : ;
(5)
vw D vw1 C " vw1 .x; zN; tN/ C : : : 4
Here zN D "z, tN D "2 t and the subscript ‘1c’ refers to steady two-dimensional critical flow conditions. Introducing the abbreviations Z1 I D x
@2 p d ; x @ 2 1
Z1 J D x
d p ; x
Zx K D 1
d ; .x /1=4
(6) substitution of expansions (5) into (1) and (4) yields .2A1c I /a1 D 0. Consequently, a1 D b.x/ c.Nz; tN/ where b.x/ denotes the right eigenfunction of the singular operator .2A1c I /: .2A1c I /b D 0 : (7) Solutions of the equation for a2 .2A1c I /a2 D sgn. c / b 2 c 2 C
J b @2 c @c Kb I h1 Kvw1 (8) 2 @Nz2 @tN
exist only if Fredholm’s alternative is met, i.e. if the yet unknown ‘shape’ function c.Nz; tN/ satisfies the evolution equation
96
A. Kluwick et al.
@2 c @c 2 C c 2 sgn. c /ı D gN : @tN @Nz
(9)
The constants , , ı and the function gN which accounts for the effects of controlling devices are uniquely defined in terms of b.x/ and the left eigenfunction n.x/: .2A1c I / n D 0. Here R 1 .2A1c I / denotes the adjoint of .2A1c I /. Using the notation h n; q i D 1 nq dx one obtains: D
h n; J b i ; 2h n; Kb i
gN D
D
h n; b 2 i ; h n; Kb i
ıD
h n; 1 i ; h n; Kb i
h n; I h1 i C h n; Kvw1 i : h n; Kb i
(10)
Numerical results for A1c .x/, b.x/ and n.x/ with h1 D vw1 D 0 are displayed in Fig. 3 and yield: p 3:0, 2:07, ı 1:60. If < c stationary points of (9) satisfy c D ˙cs , cs D ı= and correspond to upper and lower branch solutions for below critical flow conditions, p Fig. 1. Finally, by applying the transformation c.Nz; tN/ C cs D 2cs u.z; t/, zN D =.2cs / z, tN D t=.2cs /, g D g=.4ı/ N equation (9) assumes the parameter free form ut uzz D u u2 ‚. c /=2 C g.z; t/
(11)
known as the forced Fisher-Kolmogoroff, Petrovsky, Piscounoff (FKPP)-equation, e.g. Fisher [8]. Here ‚.s/ denotes the Heavyside function ‚ D 0 for s < 0 and ‚ D 1 for s > 0. 4
3
A∞c
b
2
1
n
0 −1 −4
−2
0
4
2
x
Fig. 3 Near critical marginally separated flows (h1 D vw1 D 0): (negative) perturbation displacement thickness A1c .x/, right and left eigenfunctions b.x/ and n.x/
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers
97
2.2 Route 2 Towards Separation The main ideas associated with the bifurcation analysis of marginally separated flows carry over unchanged although the details are considerably more complicated. To be specific, we consider the case of incompressible flow pastp an expansion ramp with ramp angle ˛ and slightly rounded corner h1 .x/ D ˛.x C x 2 C r 2 /, r 1. Generalizing equations (5) we now expand as Œu; v D Œuc ; vc .x; y/ C "2 Œu1 ; v1 .x; y; zN; tN/ C "4 Œu2 ; v2 .x; y; zN; tN/ C : : : ŒP; A D ŒPc ; Ac .x/ C "2 ŒP1 ; A1 .x; zN; tN/ C "4 ŒP2 ; A2 .x; zN; tN/ C : : : w D "3 w1 .x; y; zN; tN/ C : : :
(12)
B D " B1 .x; zN; tN/ C : : : 3
Œh; vw D Œh1 ; vw1 .x/ C "4 Œh2 ; vw2 .x; zN; tN/ C : : : where " D j˛ ˛c j1=4 and as before zN D "z, tN D "2 t. Steady two-dimensional flow fields have been computed first by Korolev [15] for r D 0 who found that numerical solutions cannot be obtained for ˛ > ˛c while two branches of solutions exist for 0 ˛ ˛c , Fig. 4. Similar to marginally separated flows deviations from the critical two-dimensional steady state but now characterized by the perturbations of the two velocity components u, v and the perturbation displacement !T
function A and expressed in terms of the vector r 1 D .u1 ; v1 ; A1 / can be writ! ! ! ten as r 1 .x; y; zN; tN/ D c.Nz; tN/ r .x; y/. Here r T .x; y/ D .ur ; vr ; Ar / represents the right eigenvector of a singular operator matrix M which depends on the unperturbed flow quantities only: 20
lb 15
10
5
0
®c
−6
−5.8
−5.6
−5.4
−5.2
−5
−4.8
® Fig. 4 Non-uniqueness of the planar ramp flow: bubble length lb versus ramp angle ˛ for r D 0:1 and vw1 D 0: ˛c 5:926, source: Zametaev (2003, private communication)
98
A. Kluwick et al.
0
1 Z1 2 0 1 1 d =d 2 B uc @x C ucx C vc @y @yy ucy C d C ur B CB C ! x ! C @ vr A D 0 : Mr DB 1 B C @x @y 0 @ A Ar 0 0 @y (13) As before the ‘shape’ function c.Nz; tN/ remains arbitrary at this level of approximation and is determined by the requirement that solutions for the higher order approxima!T
tions u2 , v2 , A2 exist. Introducing the left eigenvector l the resulting solvability condition assumes the form @c @tN
Z
Z mur dD C c 2
D
m.ur urx C vr ury / dD C D
Z sgn.˛ ˛c / D
@2 c @Nz2
.x; y/ D .m; n; q/ of M
Z nwr dD D
Z1 Z1 h2 m C d dD D n0 vw2 dx : x 1
(14)
1
which is again recognized as an equation of Fisher type. The quantity wr accounts for cross flow effects via the relationship w1 D wr .x; y/@c=@Nz and is obtained as the solution of uc
@2 wr @wr @wr C vc D Pr C ; @x @y @y 2
Z1 0 1 Ar C d : Pr d with Pr D y D 0 W wr D 0 ; x 1 1 (15) Numerical work in progress (Szeywerth, 2007) indicates that the problems for the right and left eigenvectors have a unique solution and that the integrals entering (14) exist which, therefore, can transformed into its canonical form (11) which will be taken as the basis for the following discussion. 1 y ! 1 W wr y
Zx
3 FKPP Equation Equations of Fisher’s type (heat equations with nonlinear source terms) are known from nonlinear wave propagation phenomena in gene populations, reactiondiffusion and heat conduction processes. Its appearance in the context of near critical flow phenomena forms one of the key observations of the present study. In contrast to previous applications where u.z; t/ is limited to positive values within the range Œ0; 1 or Œ0; 1/ no restrictions on the magnitude and sign of u exist in cases which are of interest here. As a consequence, the associated dynamics becomes considerably more complicated and only first steps towards a full understanding have been taken.
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers
99
3.1 2-D Unsteady Flows 2-D unsteady flows where further analytical progress is possible provide a natural starting point for a discussion of flow phenomena described by (11). In the case of unforced flow gN D 0 it reduces to Bernoulli’s equation which can be solved in closed form for both sub- and super-critical flows
< c W
u.t/ D
u0 C u0 tanhŒ.t t0 /=2 ; 1 C .2u0 1/ tanhŒ.t t0 /=2
(16)
> c W
u.t/ D
u0 C .u0 1/ tanŒ.t t0 /=2 : 1 C .2u0 1/ tanŒ.t t0 /=2
(17)
Here u0 D u.t0 / denotes the value of u imposed at time t D t0 . According to (16) the steady upper branch solution us D 1 is approached for initial conditions u0 > 0, Fig. 5. In contrast, for u0 < 0 i.e. for u0 below the steady lower branch solution us D 0, finite time blow-up occurs at the blow-up time t D t0 C 2 artanh Œ1=.1 2u0 / :
(18)
Still, however, the steady upper branch solution us D 1 is approached in the limit t ! 1. No such steady state exists for super-critical flow where Equation (17) predicts periodic blow-up, i.e. self-sustained oscillations of the separation bubble. The above interpretation of solutions to Equation (11) is watertight if u remains bounded for all times t t0 but hinges on tacit assumptions if finite time blow-up occurs, namely (i) that u.t/ can be extended beyond t and (ii) that the singular behaviour of u for t t ! 0 causes a singular response of u for t t ! 0C . Although no rigorous proof of (i) and (ii) exists at present, their validity appears to be supported by available numerical data and physical considerations. For example, as mentioned before, DNS calculations for marginally separated channel flows
4
u(t) 2
0 −2
t∗
−4 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
t Fig. 5 Solutions of (11) for unforced planar flow; sub-critical conditions < c , (16); dashed lines: steady states corresponding to upper and lower branch solutions; blow-up time t
100
A. Kluwick et al.
carried out by Alam and Sandham [1] predict that self-sustained bubble oscillations occur if the suction rate ˛ D VPs =VP1 where VP1 and VPs , respectively, denote the volume fluxes at the channel entry and the suction strip is sufficiently large. Specifically, such oscillations were observed in the range ˛ D 0:2 0:25 which is larger than but of the same order of magnitude as the critical suction rate ˛c 0:09 predicted by the asymptotic approach which is encouraging. Also, if a singular behaviour of u.t/ for t t ! 0 is accepted, conservation of mass immediately implies a related singular behaviour for t t ! 0C which in turn ‘selects’ unique solutions (16), (17) for arbitrary values u0 . Therefore, assumptions (i), (ii) will be adopted in the following considerations dealing with more general situations as for example unsteady 2-D forced flow where g.t/ is taken to be purely harmonic g.t/ D a‚.t/ sin !t. Introduction of the transformation u ! R:
1 R0 .tN/ ! u.t/ D 1C! ; tN D t (19) 2 R.tN/ 2 4 then leads to the canonical form of Mathieu’s equation R00 C Œp 2q cos.2tN/ R D 0
(20)
with p D 1=! 2 and q D 2a=! 2 . Taking into account (19), blow-up solutions of (11) are associated with zeros of solutions to (20) and multiple blow-up will be associated with periodic solutions of (20). For p D a0 .q0 / this equation has an even 2 periodic solution with no zeros R D c e0 .tNI q0 / where c is a normalization constant. Using the transformation R D c e0 .tNI q0 / .tN/ application of the theorem of Leighton [16] to the resulting equation for shows that repetitive blow-up occurs for < c if the forcing amplitude a > ac D q0 ! 2 =2 and is inevitable if > c . Evaluation of the relationship ac D ac .!/ as displayed in Fig. 6 together with its p limiting form ac != 2 as ! ! 1 shows that the danger of bubble bursting in sub-critical flows decreases with increasing values of ! in agreement with experimental observations (Ruban, 2005). Numerical solutions of (11) for < c , ! D 2 and two different values of a are depicted in Fig. 7 and seen to be in complete agreement with the prediction following from the analytical result q0 0:7268, ac 1:45216.
3.2 Further Analytical Solutions of the FKPP Equation Closed form solutions of (11) without forcing can be obtained also in the case of steady three-dimensional flow where it reduces to the integrated form of the Korteweg-de Vries equation if < c . Consequently, bounded solutions varying periodically with z are given in terms of the Jacobian elliptic functions cn .sjm/ and the integration constant ' 2 Œ0; =3:
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers
101
1.6 1.4 1.2 1
ac(!)
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
! Fig. 6 Critical forcing amplitude for planar flow and p g.t / D a‚.t / sin.2t /: a > ac leads to repetitive blow-up; ac .0/ D 1=4, ac .! ! 1/ != 2 C (dashed line)
2
a = 1:44
1
u(t)
0 −1
g(t)=a 1:5
−2 0
5
10
15
t∗ 20
25
30
t Fig. 7 Planar forced flow: numerical solutions of (11) with g.t / D a‚.t / sin.2t /. Repeated blowup occurs for a > ac 1:45216
s !# " ˇ p ˇ 2 tan ' sin ' z 1 ˇp C 3 sin ' cn2 u.z/ D sin2 cos ' C p 2 2 3 2 ˇ 3 C tan ' (21) known from the theory of shallow water waves, Fig. 8(a). The limit ' D =3 yields the homoclinic orbit (solitary wave) '
u.z/ D 1
z 3 cosh2 ; 2 2
(22)
102
A. Kluwick et al.
a 1.2
¼=3
1
u(z)
1:02
0.8
0:9
0.6
¼=4
0.4
¼=6
0.2 0 −0.2
' = 0:2
−0.4 −0.6
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
z
b
2 1.5
u(z)
−1=216
0 1 0.5 0 −0.5
−0:01
−1 −1.5
−0:005
g3 = −0:05 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
z Fig. 8 Steady sub-critical solutions of (11) without forcing; dashed lines: us D 0; 1; (a) bounded, Equations (21), (22), (b) singular, Equation (24)
while in the limit ' ! 0, which corresponds to a linearization about the unperturbed planar steady state u D 0, one obtains (Stokes waves) p 3 ' cos z C O.' 2 / : u.z/ 2
(23)
An additional family of solutions which vary periodically with z is obtained if, as in the case of two-dimensional unsteady flow, the presence of singularities is accepted. It exists for sub-critical and, interestingly, also for super-critical flow conditions and can be expressed in terms of the Weierstrass elliptic function }.zI g2 ; g3 / with g2 D sgn. c /=12 while g3 remains arbitrary: u.z/ D 6}.zI sgn. c /=12; g3 / C 1=2 :
(24)
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers
103
5
u(z) 4 3 2 1
1 0
2!2 -1
0
5
g3 = −1 10
15
20
z Fig. 9 Singular steady super-critical solutions; solid line: limiting case with maximum period 2!2max 10:2909 (g3 0:00423616)
For < c , Fig. 8b, the distance between consecutive singularities (streak spacing) varies between 0 and 1 and a non-periodic solution is found in the limit g3 D 1=216. In contrast solutions for > c , Fig. 9, are always periodic as they cannot decay to a two-dimensional steady state and there exists an upper bound z 10:2909 for the spacing of streaks. The soliton solution (22) exhibits the exponential decay for z ! 1 observed in numerical solutions for steady two-dimensional upper branch flows disturbed by an isolated three-dimensional surface mounted obstacle while the existence of periodic solutions (21) support the finding that the perturbation displacement thickness A exhibits an oscillatory behaviour for z ! 1 if one considers disturbances of steady planar states corresponding to the lower branch, Braun and Kluwick [2]. The physical meaning of singular solutions (24) and in particular the possible existence of super-critical steady states associated with a maximum streak spacing remains unclear at present. As a last class of exact solutions to the unforced version of (11) we consider travelling wave solutions u.z; t/ D v./ ;
D z U t 0 ;
(25)
where U and 0 denote the wave speed and an arbitrary constant. For < c one then obtains v00 C U v0 C v v2 D 0 : (26) Because of the invariance property u.z; tI U / D u.z; tI U / it is sufficient to consider right running waves U > 0 only. Except for U D 0 bounded solutions connect the steady states us D 1; 0, Fig. 10a. In contrast, singular travelling wave solutions are seen to deviate and return to the stable upper branch level u D us D 1, Fig. 10b.
104
A. Kluwick et al.
a
1
v(») U=3
2
0
0:5 0 0
10
20
30
40
»
b
10
v(») 5
0 0
0:2 2 −5 U=3 −10 −10
−5
0
5
10
» Fig. 10 (a) Bounded and (b) singular travelling (right running) wave solutions of Fisher’s equation (26) depending on the wave speed U
3.3 Blow-up in Unsteady Three-Dimensional Flow For two-dimensional unsteady flow the singular behaviour of u near blow-up is readily obtained from the exact solution (16), (17): u 1=.t t / as jt t j ! 0. In the case of three-dimensional flow, however, the analysis of the flow structure is considerably more complex and a fully self-consistent description has not been obtained yet. Work carried out by Hocking et al. [11] in a different context suggests the ansatz, Braun and Kluwick [4] u.z; t/
1 f .; / C ; t
z D p ; jtj
D ln jtj
(27)
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers
105
as t ! 0 (where the blow-up point is assumed at t D 0 and z D 0 without loss of generality) and results in f C
sgn.t/ . c / f f 2 D f f f sgn.t/ e f C e2
g : 2 2
2
(28) Expansion of f .; / for ! 1 requires the introduction of logarithmic terms ! f1 ./ ln
ln2
: (29) C CO f .; / f0 ./ C g1 ./
2 Near blow-up exponentially small terms in (28) can be neglected to the order considered here which in turn allows for an analytical treatment and, furthermore, reveals the important symmetry property f .; / ! f .i; / if t ! t indicating that, similar to two-dimensional flows, also z-dependent solutions of (11) can be extended beyond blow-up and that the singular behaviour for t ! 0 forces a singular behaviour for t ! 0C : 16 c1 2 82 ln j8 ˙ 2 j : .8 ˙ 2 /2 (30) Here c1 is an arbitrary constant depending on initial conditions and the upper/lower sign corresponds to t ! 0 . According to (30) the focussing of u as the blow-up time is approached leads to the generation of a pair of vortices after blow-up moving along the paths p zs .t/ s . / D p D ˙ 8 C ; (31) t
f0 D
8 ; 8 ˙ 2
g1 D
10 2 ; .8 ˙ 2 /2
f1 D
Fig. 11, which is thought to provide a mechanism for the appearance of coherent structures (-vortices, see Fig. 2) in transitional separation bubbles, Braun and Kluwick [4]. Unfortunately, expansion (29) ceases to be valid in a vicinity of the moving singularities where all terms become of equal magnitude. This p deficiency can be partly corrected through the introduction of inner regions .˙ 8/ D O.1/ where the leading order terms represent singular travelling waves discussed in Section 3.2 in the limit of infinite wave speed. Higher order terms, however, cannot be matched with the outer solution (29) and, as a result, the flow description remains incomplete. Nevertheless, this analysis generalized by the p method of strained coordinates indicates that s . / may deviate from the values ˙ 8 by corrections of O.ln = / which appears to be supported by numerical evidence, Braun and Kluwick [4].
106
A. Kluwick et al.
u(z; t)
t
blow-up
z
Fig. 11 Local blow-up behaviour of solutions to Fisher’s equation (11) (schematic); for t > 0 the solution is shown in the right half plane only
3.4 Numerical Prediction of Blow-up: Influence of Forcing The forced FKPP equation (11) is one of many partial differential equations which have solutions that blow-up in a finite time. The blow-up typically involves the solution becoming infinite at an isolated point at a finite time. Near the blow-up point the solution develops a singular spike with both decreasing width and increasing height. To compute the solutions of blow-up accurately it is essential to employ an adaptive method which can then move points into the blow-up region. The adaptive meshing algorithm implemented here is based on the moving mesh methods of Huang, Ren and Russell [12, 13]. Defining a monitor function M.z; t; u.z; t// > 0 and a computational coordinate an equation for the evolving mesh is given by @ @z @2 @z M D 2 ; @ @ @ @t
(32)
where the parameter 1 is a relaxation time determining the time scale over which the mesh converges to a steady state. This is an approximation to the equation M z D 1 modified to include temporal smoothing. The approach is to discretise (32) on a uniform mesh and discretise the Fisher equation using Hermite cubic collocation on the nonuniform mesh generated from (32). The choice of function M is critical and motivation comes from requiring that the underlying self-similar scaling transformation exhibited by solutions of Fisher’s equation near blow-up should be a property also of the numerical algorithm. In the neighbourhood of the blow-up point the linear and forcing terms in (11) are insignificant in describing the leading blow-up structure. With these terms neglected the resulting equation is invariant under the rescaling t ! t C ˇ.t t /, u ! u=ˇ, z ! z C ˇ 1=2 .z z / where the
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers
107
blow-up point is at .z ; t /. The choice of M D u then ensures that (32) is also invariant under these scalings near blow-up. While solutions of (11) near blow-up are not self-similar under these scalings they are approximately self similar, see Equations (27), (29), and (30). It can be shown then, Budd, Chen, Huang and Russell [6], that for the coupled problems (11), (32) the computed mesh points near blow-up have also the desirable property of lying on trajectories for which given by (27) is constant. This reveals the usefulness of the moving mesh method in inheriting the natural spatial structure of the original differential equation. An example of blow-up in finite time is shown in Fig. 12 where we see the 2 evolution to blow-up for the applied forcing g.z; t/ D 30 sin.2t/e100z with initial condition u.z; 0/ D 1. The scaling analysis above suggests that the evolution presented in Fig. 12 provides a typical structure that is independent of the precise forcing imposed in the neighbourhood of blow-up. The question is then: how are variations in the applied forcing reflected in blow-up formation? The formal asymptotics of Galaktionov, Herrero and Vel´azquez [9] indicate the possibility of an alternative ‘flatter’ asymptotic structure near blow-up described by the Herp mite polynomials Hm .y/, y D z= t t with m 4 and m even. We are able to generate results suggestive of this flatter blow-up structure through coalescing spike structures generated by a two-peak forcing of the form g.z; t/ D 2 2 30 sin.2t/.e100.zR/ C e100.zCR/ /. For R large there is blow-up at two points and R small at one point. However for R D R 1:92969 the blow-up at z D 0 is associated with the coalescing of two maxima. This blow-up pattern is seen in Fig. 13. More complicated and flatter blow-up patterns can also be generated by inclusion of additional peaks in the forcing and appropriate tuning of the peak separation distance.
1 0.8
(t−t∗)u
f0−
0.6
0.4 t = 3:75
0.2 0
1
2
3
4
5
´ Fig. 12 Evolution to blow-up for the applied forcing g.z; t / D 30 sin.2t /e100z with initial condition u.z; 0/ D 1. Consecutive time steps: t D 3:75; 3:752; 3:75349998; 3:7541998; estimated blow-up time t 3:75438944, blow-up profile f0 , (30) 2
108
A. Kluwick et al. 0 t = 4:180145 −1e+06
u(z; t) −2e+06
−3e+06 0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
z Fig. 13 Flat blow-up structure for forcing g.z; t / D 30 sin.2t /.e100.zR/ C e100.zCR/ /, R D 1:92969 with initial conditions u.z; 0/ D 1. Consecutive time steps: t D 4:180145 C i t , i D 0; 2; 4; 6; 8; 10; 15; t D 107 2
2
4 Conclusions In the present study it has been shown that near critical flow phenomena are governed by the same evolution equation of Fisher’s type for both routes leading to the separation of high Reynolds number laminar flows analyzed in the past. Although this equation has been investigated over 70 years, the existing literature contains relatively little material which is of relevance in the present context. This is due to the fact that in most investigations carried out to date u.z; t/ is taken to be in the interval Œ0; 1 or Œ0; 1/, which is sufficient if one stays within its classical field of applications, e.g. population dynamics, but is too restrictive if it is used to study near critical separated flows. Here u may vary in the whole range .1; 1/ which significantly increases the richness of solutions. First steps towards the understanding of the associated new phenomena have been taken by Braun and Kluwick [4, 5]. Here a number of new solutions have been presented which are of interest both in the context of structure formation and flow control. For example, it has been shown that unsteady two-dimensional perturbations of a two-dimensional critical steady state caused by harmonic oscillations of a surface mounted hump starting at t D 0 can be expressed in terms of Mathieu functions leading in turn to a complete picture of the flow behaviour. Among others it is found that, in incompressible sub-critical flows, the critical value ac of the amplitude a causing bubble bursting increases with increasing forcing frequency as observed experimentally. In addition to analytical considerations a new numerical scheme allowing the study of general unsteady, z-dependent flows and specially designed to capture the phenomenon of bubble bursting in detail has been presented. Results obtained so far support existing analytical evidence that the flow properties for jt t j ! 0 where t denotes the bursting time are universal, i.e. independent of the specific form of
Near Critical Phenomena in Laminar Boundary Layers
109
the adopted forcing term but work in progress also shows that the actual value of t is very sensitive to small changes of the forcing and thus can be controlled very effectively.
Acknowledgement Part of this work was supported by the Austrian Science Fund FWF (project number WK W008) which is gratefully acknowledged.
References 1. Alam, M. & Sandham, N.D. 2000 Direct numerical simulation of ‘short’ laminar separation bubbles with turbulent reattachment. J. Fluid Mech. 410, 1–28. 2. Braun, S. & Kluwick, A. 2002 The effect of three-dimensional obstacles on marginally separated laminar boundary layer flows. J. Fluid Mech. 460, 57–82. 3. Braun, S. & Kluwick, A. 2003 Analysis of a bifurcation problem in marginally separated laminar wall jets and boundary layers. Acta Mech. 161, 195–211. 4. Braun, S. & Kluwick, A. 2004 Unsteady three-dimensional marginal separation caused by surface-mounted obstacles and/or local suction. J. Fluid Mech. 514, 121–152. 5. Braun, S. & Kluwick, A. 2005 Blow-up and control of marginally separated boundary layer flows. In New Developments and Applications in Rapid Fluid Flows (Eds. J.S.B. Gajjar & F.T. Smith). Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A 363, 1057–1067. 6. Budd, C.J., Chen, J., Huang, W. & Russell, R.D. 1996 Moving mesh methods with applications to blow-up problems for PDEs. In Numerical Analysis 1995: Proceedings of 1995 Biennial Conference on Numerical Analysis (Eds. D.F. Griffiths & G.A. Watson). Pitman Research Notes in Mathematics, Longman Scientific and Technical, pp. 1–17. 7. Elliott, J.W. & Smith, F.T. 1987 Dynamic stall due to unsteady marginal separation. J. Fluid Mech. 179, 489–512. 8. Fisher, R.A. 1937 The wave of advance of advantageous genes. Ann. Eugenics 7, 355–369. 9. Galaktionov, V.A., Herrero M.A. & Vel´azquez, J.J.L. 1991 The space structure near a blow-up point for semilinear heat equations: a formal approach. USSR Comput. Math. Math. Physics, 31 (3), 399–411. 10. Gittler, Ph. & Kluwick, A. 1987 Triple-deck solutions for supersonic flows past flared cylinders. J. Fluid Mech. 179, 469–487. 11. Hocking, L.M., Stewartson, K., Stuart, J.T. & Brown, S.N. 1972 A nonlinear instability burst in plane parallel flow. J. Fluid Mech. 51, 705–735. 12. Huang, W., Ren, Y. & Russell, R.D. 1994 Moving mesh methods based on moving mesh partial differential equations. J. Comput. Phys. 113, 279–290. 13. Huang, W., Ren, Y. & Russell, R.D. 1994 Moving mesh partial differential equations (MMPDEs) based upon the equidistribution principle. SIAM J. Numer. Anal. 31, 709–730. 14. Korolev, G.L. 1990 Contribution to the theory of thin-profile trailing edge separation. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR: Mekh. Zhidk. Gaza 4, 55–59 (Engl. transl. Fluid Dyn. 24 (4), 534–537). 15. Korolev, G.L. 1992 Non-uniqueness of separated flow past nearly flat corners. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR: Mekh. Zhidk. Gaza 3, 178–180 (Engl. transl. Fluid Dyn. 27 (3), 442–444). 16. Leighton, W. 1949 Bounds for the solutions of a second-order linear differential equation. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 35, 190–191. 17. Ruban, A.I. 1981 Asymptotic theory of short separation regions on the leading edge of a slender airfoil. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR: Mekh. Zhidk. Gaza 1, 42–51 (Engl. transl. Fluid Dyn. 17 (1), 33–41).
110
A. Kluwick et al.
18. Ryzhov, O.S. & Smith, F.T. 1984 Short-length instabilities, breakdown and initial value problems in dynamic stall. Mathematika 31, 163–177. 19. Smith, F.T. 1982 Concerning dynamic stall. Aeron. Quart. 33, 331–352. 20. Stewartson, K., Smith, F.T. & Kaups, K. 1982 Marginal separation. Stud. in Appl. Math. 67, 45–61.
State Curves and Flipping for an Orbiting Cylinder at Low Reynolds Numbers L. Baranyi
Abstract Sudden changes found in the time-mean and rms values of force coefficients of a circular cylinder in forced orbital motion placed in a uniform stream when plotted against ellipticity of the orbital path suggest that two solutions (states) exist. This 2D numerical simulation was performed in order to gain further evidence of this hypothesis through flipping of the solution. Time histories and limit cycle curves of force coefficients for stationary, in-line, and orbital paths around the time of the flip were investigated, as well as time-mean and rms values of lift, drag, and base pressure coefficients versus ellipticity for the flipped solution. Results provide evidence of the existence of two solutions. Keywords Orbiting cylinder Numerical simulation Flipping 2D flow Low Reynolds number
1 Introduction Although there are countless studies for flow around a circular cylinder, either stationary or oscillating in one direction, investigations concentrating upon orbital motions are still rather uncommon (see e.g. [10, 11]). Among these, studies of a cylinder in forced orbital motion in a uniform stream are relatively rare. Didier and Borges [7] were able to identify lock-in for in-line and transverse cylinder oscillation and for a cylinder orbiting in a circular path. Lu and Dalton [8], working with forced transverse cylinder oscillation and investigating the effect of oscillation frequency, found switches in flow patterns and sudden 180ı phase angle change between lift and cylinder displacement. Blackburn and Henderson [6] confirmed these findings, as well as identifying sudden changes in energy transfer between cylinder and fluid. L. Baranyi Department of Fluid and Heat Engineering, University of Miskolc, H-3515 Miskolc-Egyetemv´aros, Hungary e-mail: [email protected] M. Braza and K. Hourigan (eds.), IUTAM Symposium on Unsteady Separated Flows and their Control, IUTAM Bookseries 14, c Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009
111
112
L. Baranyi
In earlier studies, the author identified sudden jumps in the time-mean and rms values of force coefficients when plotted against ellipticity of orbit. Since these sudden jumps occur between two envelope curves [2], the author’s hypothesis is that there are two solutions (states) that characterise the wake flow, and these represent changes in the structure of flow patterns. These jumps were investigated for several cases at different Reynolds numbers, and at different amplitudes of the in-line component of orbit [3]. A pre- and post-jump study also incorporated energy transfer, limit cycle curves, phase angle differences, and flow patterns [4]. All showed sudden switches, in agreement with the forced transverse results of [6] and [8]. This study attempts to gather further evidence of wake behaviour through flipping the solutions, as this has been recommended as one method of confirming the presence of two solutions [5].
2 Governing Equations and Numerical Method The dimensionless governing equations for an incompressible constant property Newtonian fluid flow around an orbiting circular cylinder are the two components of the Navier—Stokes equations, the continuity equation and pressure Poisson equation written in a non-inertial system fixed to the cylinder: @u @u @u @p 1 2 Cu Cv D C r u a0x ; @t @x @y @x Re
(1)
@v @v @p 1 2 @v Cu Cv D C r v a0y ; @t @x @y @y Re
(2)
@u @v C D 0; @x @y
@u @v @D @u @v r 2p D 2 @x @y @y @x @t DD
(3) (4)
In these equations r 2 is the 2D Laplacian operator, x; y are Cartesian co-ordinates, u; v are the x; y components of velocity in the system fixed to the cylinder, a0x ; a0y are the components of cylinder acceleration, p is the pressure, D is dilation. Here Re is the Reynolds number, Re D Ud= where d is the cylinder diameter, U is the free stream velocity and is the kinematic viscosity. Although in Equation (4) the dilation D D 0 by continuity (3), I retain its partial derivative with respect to time to reduce numerical errors. Equations (1), (2) and (4) will be solved while the continuity equation (3) is satisfied at every time step. No-slip boundary condition is used on the cylinder surface for the velocity and a Neumann-type condition is used for pressure p. A potential flow distribution is assumed far from the cylinder.
State Curves and Flipping for an Orbiting Cylinder at Low Reynolds Numbers
113
Boundary fitted coordinates are used to impose the boundary conditions accurately. Using unique, single-valued functions, the physical domain bounded by two concentric circles can be mapped into a rectangular computational domain where the spacing is equidistant in both directions. In the physical domain logarithmically spaced radial cells are used, providing a fine grid scale near the cylinder wall and a coarse grid in the far field. Using the mapping functions, not specified here, the governing equations and boundary conditions are transformed into the computational plane. The transformed equations are solved by using the finite difference method. For further details see [1]. The 2D code developed by the author has been extensively tested against experimental and computational results for a stationary cylinder and good agreement has been found [1]. The code was extended first for an oscillating and then for an orbiting cylinder. For this study the dimensionless time step was 0.0005 and the number of grid points 301 177. For all Re investigated in this study .Re D 120–180/ the solution was grid independent. The ratio of the radius of the outer computational domain and cylinder radius was 40. Figure 1 shows the flow arrangement. The motion of the centre of the cylinder with unit diameter is specified as follows: x0 .t/ D Ax cos .2f t/ ; y0 .t/ D Ay sin .2f t /
(5)
where f is the dimensionless oscillation frequency, Ax ; Ay are the dimensionless amplitudes of oscillations in x and y directions, respectively. In Fig. 1 U is the free stream velocity. Here the frequencies in the two directions are identical, which for nonzero Ax ; Ay amplitudes gives an ellipse, shown in the dotted line in the figure. If one of the amplitudes is zero, in-line or transverse oscillation is obtained. Ax alone yields pure in-line oscillation, and then as Ay is increased, the ellipticity e D Ay =Ax increases to yield a full circle at e D 1. The negative sign in y0 in Equation (5) makes the cylinder orbit clockwise (clw); by changing this sign of y0 an anticlockwise (aclw) orbit is obtained.
y
U
O
P1 1
d=
Ay
Fig. 1 Cylinder in orbital motion
Ax
x
P2
114
L. Baranyi
3 Computational Results During each set of computations Re and Ax are fixed and f is kept constant at some percentage of Strouhal number St0 (the frequency of vortex shedding from a stationary cylinder at that Re). In this study this percentage was between 70–105 to ensure lock-in at moderate oscillation amplitudes. An interesting phenomenon was observed when looking at the time-mean value (TMV) and root-mean-square (rms) values of lift, drag and base pressure coefficients for an orbiting cylinder in a uniform flow. Abrupt jumps were found when these values were plotted against ellipticity e with Re and Ax kept constant, [3]. A typical example for the TMV of lift coefficient for both clockwise and anticlockwise direction of orbit is shown in Fig. 2a for Re D 160; Ax D 0:4; f D 0:85St0 . The filled triangles show results for a cylinder orbiting anticlockwise (aclw in the figure). Note that there are two envelope curves, which are roughly parallel with each other and of negative slope. On the other hand, the empty squares in Fig. 2a show results for a clockwise (clw) orbit, with the other parameters unchanged. The two envelope curves can be seen, again roughly parallel, but the slope is positive, and they are a mirror image of the envelope curves of the cylinder orbiting anticlockwise. Although it cannot be seen well at small e values in the figure, there are eight jumps or switches in state. For both directions of orbit the jumps occur at the same ellipticity values and computational points for the two cases lie on different state curves except for the values near e D 0. In all calculations made so far, CLmean has shown this pattern. Time histories of CLmean before and after the jumps are substantially different, [2]. The TMV and rms of drag and base pressure, further the rms of lift, behaved differently from CLmean , characterised by two state curves which are not parallel but intersect each other at e D 0. A typical example is shown in Fig. 2b. The main parameters (Re, Ax and f ) are the same as in Fig. 2a. From the sets of computations, it is clear that the two pairs of envelope or state curves are independent of the direction of orbit. Here the computational points belonging to the same e values coincide with each other and thus naturally lie on the same envelope curve. This is reassuring in two ways: (1) The code produces the same time-mean and rms results for two a
b
Re=160; Ax=0.4; 0.85St0
Re=160; Ax=0.4; 0.85St0
0.7 1.2
0.5 1
0.1 –0.1 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
–0.3
CLrms
CLmean
0.3
0.8 0.6 0.4
–0.5
0.2 0
–0.7
e=Ay/Ax
clw
aclw
0.2
0.4
0.6
e=Ay/Ax
0.8
1 clw
1.2 aclw
Fig. 2 Time-mean and rms values of lift versus ellipticity for clockwise (clw) and anticlockwise (aclw) direction of orbit .Re D 160I Ax D 0:4; f D 0:85St0 D 0:15997/
State Curves and Flipping for an Orbiting Cylinder at Low Reynolds Numbers
115
different situations represented by the two directions of orbit, and this confirms that the code is consistent, and (2) the existence of envelope curves is proved by results obtained for two different cases. This finding also supports the idea that there are two states or solutions and the solution jumps from one state to the other and back. To sum up the findings, there appear to be two states between which the solution switches which indicates a strong possibility of bifurcation. The two solutions can be obtained (a) by using different initial conditions or (b) by flipping the solution. It was shown in [4] that changing the initial condition for the orbiting cylinder yields two different solutions. With flipping, if both states are obtained, this is additional evidence for a two-state solution. For this purpose the solution for a circular cylinder (stationary, moving in-line, or in orbital motion) placed in an otherwise uniform flow is flipped. This is done by replacing every quantity (velocity and pressure fields) by its mirror image values, at one instant . ! 2 / without changing the cylinder motion, where is the polar angle. Time-histories and limit cycles were plotted in order to compare pre-flip and post-flip solutions. Two types of limit cycles were produced: one for two components of flow velocity at a point, and the other for drag and lift coefficients. To check that the code for flipping was effective, the least complicated cases were attempted first.
3.1 Flipping for a Stationary Cylinder Computations were carried out for a stationary cylinder at Re D 180 for the dimensionless time interval of [0, 500] and the solution was flipped at t1 D 250 when the flow was already periodic (limit cycle). Time histories of lift and drag coefficients and those of u and v velocity components were stored at points P1 (2,1) and P2 .2; 1/, as these points have been shown to be reliable for experimental measurement of velocity signals (see [9]). Points P1 and P2 , shown in Fig. 1, are mirror images of each other and are located in the wake of the cylinder on the physical plane, where the origin of the coordinate system is fixed to the centre of the cylinder and coordinates are made dimensionless by the cylinder diameter d . Time history and limit cycle curves for velocity components at these points, i.e. .u1 ; v1 /; .u2 ; v2 / and limit cycle curves for force coefficients .CD ; CL / were plotted before and after the flip. It was found that: – All three limit cycle curves mentioned remain unchanged after flipping. – There was an approximately 180ı phase shift in CL .t/ at flipping and practically no phase shift in CD .t/. – For a stationary cylinder the shape of lift and drag coefficient signals are regular and this feature of the solution is preserved after the flipping as well. – Due to symmetry in the position of points P1 and P2 , limit cycle curves for the velocity components are mirror images of each other, i.e. .u1 ; v1 / D .u2 ; v2 / and .u2 ; v2 / D .u1 ; v1 /. All these expected results serve to show that the code works well. Due to lack of space no figures are included for the stationary cylinder.
116
L. Baranyi
3.2 Flipping for In-Line Oscillation Computations were carried out for a cylinder oscillating in-line at Re D 180 with Ax D 0:3 amplitude and f D 0:9 St0 D 0:1737 frequency. Flipping was carried out when the oscillating cylinder reached its furthest downstream position .x0 D Ax /. In this case, velocity signals were measured at points P1 and P2 , which are fixed to the oscillating cylinder. In this way, the velocity components at the two points are relative velocities measured in the coordinate system fixed to the cylinder. – Figure 3 shows the CL .t/ signal around the flip .t1 D 247:5535/. The shape of the signal, after a short transitional period, is reversed, i.e. the more rounded peaks switch from bottom to top. This is evidence for the existence of two solutions. – Here, all limit cycle curves change with the flip. Still, some symmetries can be found between quantities before .t < t1 / and after .t > t1 / the flip, e.g. .u1 ; v1 j t < t1 / D .u2 ; v2 j t > t1 / (see Fig. 4a, b) .u2 ; v2 j t < t1 / D .u1 ; v1 j t > t1 / (see Fig. 4c, d) .CD ; CL j t < t1 / D .CD ; CL j t > t1 / (see Fig. 5) Figure 5 shows the relationship between CL and CD through the flip. The thin and thick closed curves show the .CD ; CL / limit cycle curves before and after the flip, respectively. Arrows show the orientation of the curves. The thin straight line represents the flip, when the solution jumps between the two states.
1.5
1
CL
0.5
0
−0.5 −1 −1.5 230
235
240
245
250
255
t
Fig. 3 Time history of lift coefficient in the vicinity of the flip
260
265
State Curves and Flipping for an Orbiting Cylinder at Low Reynolds Numbers
b
1
1
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
− v2
v1
a
0.2
0.2
0
0
−0.2
−0.2
−0.4
−0.4
−0.6 0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
−0.6 0.6
1.6
0.8
1
u1
1.2
1.4
1.6
u2
(u1, v1| t < t1)
(u2, -v2| t > t1)
c
d 0.35
0.35 0.3
0.3
0.25
0.25
0.2
0.2
0.15
0.15
−v1
v2
117
0.1
0.1 0.05
0.05 0
0
−0.05
−0.05
−0.1 0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
−0.1 0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
u2
u1
(u2, v2| t < t1)
(u1, -v1| t > t1)
1.4
1.6
Fig. 4 Limit cycles for in-line cylinder oscillation .Re D 180; Ax D 0:3I f D 0:1737I t1 D 247:5535/
Fig. 5 Relationship between CD and CL near flip (parameters as in Fig. 4)
118
L. Baranyi
3.3 Flipping for Orbiting Cylinder To break the symmetry of in-line motion an orbiting cylinder was investigated, although due to lack of space we cannot go into detail here. A disturbance to in-line motion, the amplitude of transverse oscillation Ay , is chosen to be much smaller than Ax . In this way we expect that the symmetry features obtained for the cylinder oscillating in-line are not much distorted. The main parameters of the investigated case are: Re D 160I Ax D 0:3; Ay D 0:012 and f D 0:9 St0 D 0:16938; t1 D 247:5535. – The CL .t/ signal around the flip is reversed, similarly to the one shown in Fig. 5 after a short transitional period; i.e. the more rounded peaks switch from bottom to top. – Limit cycle curves show similar features, with the difference that relations mentioned for limit cycle curves in Section 3.2 are just approximately true. – Limit cycle .CL ; y0 / alters to a near-mirror image with the flip, while .CD ; x0 / hardly alters at all.
3.4 Effect of Flipping on Time-Mean and rms of Force Coefficients
CLmean
For all investigated cases the cylinder was orbiting in clockwise direction. Sets of computations were performed to investigate the effect of flipping on the TMV and rms values of different force coefficients. Out of the four sets investigated, two patterns have been identified. Representatives are shown in Figs. 6 and 7, where the CLmean curves are plotted against ellipticity e. The main feature of the first pattern (see Fig. 6) is that solutions flipped when the cylinder position is characterised by x0 x0max (‘3 o’clock’ position) roughly correspond to the solutions belonging to the anticlockwise direction of orbit (see also Fig. 2a), while keeping the other
0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0 −0.05 0 −0.1 −0.15 −0.2 −0.25 −0.3
0.1
0.2
0.3
e
0.4
0.5
aclw
0.6
t1=247.5535 x0≈x0max (3 o’clock)
flip
Fig. 6 Flipped and unflipped TMV of lift versus e .Re D 160; Ax D 0:3; f D 0:9 St0 D 0:16938/
CLmean
State Curves and Flipping for an Orbiting Cylinder at Low Reynolds Numbers 0.65 0.55 0.45 0.35 0.25 0.15 0.05 −0.05 0 −0.15 −0.25 −0.35
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
e
clw
1.2
119
t1=248.484 y0=y0max (12 o’clock)
flip
Fig. 7 Flipped and unflipped TMV of lift versus e .Re D 160; Ax D 0:4; f D 0:85 St0 D 0:15997/
0.65
CLmean
0.45 0.25
t1=248.484 y0=y0max (12 o’clock)
0.05 –0.15
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
1
0.8
1.2
–0.35
e
clw
flip back
Fig. 8 Original and doubly flipped TMV of lift versus e (as in Fig. 7)
parameters (Re; Ax and f ) unchanged. This means that CLmean has negative slope, and that the flipped results are basically complementary to the values belonging to the case before flipping. The discrepancy tends to become larger with increasing e, but at times returns to near zero. If the solution is flipped once more (flipped back), however, we obtained an almost perfect reproduction of the original curve after two flippings! Although only CLmean versus e is shown here, similar results were obtained for the other TMV and rms values. Figure 7 shows the other characteristic pattern found belonging to flipping time when the cylinder position is characterised by y0 D y0max (‘12 o’clock’ position) Interestingly in this case the flipped solutions approximate the results belonging to the clockwise direction of orbit. The location of the jumps is unchanged and the flipped results are complementary to the unflipped solutions (i.e. can be found on the other state curve). In this respect the effect of flipping is very similar to that of changing the initial conditions for the cylinder motion [4]. The other surprising thing is that the flipped solution reproduces the state curves very accurately over the whole investigated e domain. The flipped solution was flipped back; Figure 8 shows an almost perfect reproduction of the original curve after two flippings. At this stage it is unclear what kind of mechanism leads to either pattern 1 or pattern
120
L. Baranyi
2. Hence further investigations are needed. It seems, though, that the position of the cylinder at the time when the flipping takes place has a crucial effect. Results for both patterns, however, give some extra evidence for the existence of a double solution, which seems as if it might be a case of bifurcation.
4 Conclusions The effect of flipping on flow features for a stationary, oscillating or orbiting cylinder in a uniform stream was studied. Limit cycle and time history curves were investigated, and results for a cylinder either stationary or in in-line motion gave evidence for the existence of two solutions (states). Simulations of an orbiting cylinder with small cross-wise amplitude further supported this conclusion. The time-mean and rms values of force coefficients were investigated versus ellipticity e for a cylinder orbiting clockwise, and two patterns were identified: (1) the flipped solution approximates the solution belonging to the anticlockwise orbit, discrepancy increasing with e, or (2) the flipped solution gave a very accurate complementary solution to the clockwise orbit, even when double-flipped. Further research is needed to explain why two patterns appear, and to further clarify the phenomenon causing sudden changes in time-mean and rms values of force coefficients. POD analysis is planned to identify the type of bifurcation. Acknowledgements The support provided by the Hungarian Research Foundation (OTKA, Project No. T 042961) is gratefully acknowledged. The author also thanks Prof. D. Barkley of Warwick University for his valuable advice, and Mr. S. Ujv´arosi for his help in figure preparation.
References 1. Baranyi, L., Computation of unsteady momentum and heat transfer from a fixed circular cylinder in laminar flow. Journal of Computational and Applied Mechanics 4(1) (2003) 13–25. 2. Baranyi, L., Numerical simulation of flow past a cylinder in orbital motion. Journal of Computational and Applied Mechanics 5(2) (2004) 209–222. 3. Baranyi, L., Sudden jumps in time-mean values of lift coefficient for a circular cylinder in orbital motion in a uniform flow. In: 8th International Conference on Flow-Induced Vibration, Eds. E. de Langre and F. Axisa, Paris, II (2004) 93–98. 4. Baranyi, L., Energy transfer between an orbiting cylinder and moving fluid. In: Proceedings of the ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference 9 (2007) 829–838. 5. Barkley, D., Private Communication, University of Warwick, December, 2005. 6. Blackburn, H.M., Henderson. R.D., A study of two-dimensional flow past an oscillating cylinder. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 385 (1999) 255–286. 7. Didier, E. Borges, A.R.J., Numerical predictions of low Reynolds number flow over an oscillating circular cylinder. In: Conference on Modelling Fluid Flow, Eds. T. Lajos and J. Vad, Budapest (2006) 165–172. 8. Lu, X.Y., Dalton, C., Calculation of the timing of vortex formation from an oscillating cylinder. Journal of Fluids and Structures 10 (1996) 527–541.
State Curves and Flipping for an Orbiting Cylinder at Low Reynolds Numbers
121
9. Koide, M., Kubo, Y., Takahashi, T., Baranyi, L., Shirakashi, M., The vibration response of a cantilevered rectangular cylinder in cross-flow oscillation. Journal of Fluids Engineering 126, Trans. ASME (2004) 884–887. 10. Stansby, P.K., Rainey, R.C.T., On the orbital response of a rotating cylinder in a current. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 439 (2001) 87–108. 11. Williamson, C.H.K., Hess, P., Peter, M., Govardhan, R., Fluid loading and vortex dynamics for a body in elliptic orbits. In: Conference on Bluff Body Wakes and Vortex-Induced Vibration, Eds. P.W. Bearman and C.H.K. Williamson, Washington, DC (1998) 1–8.
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Global Low-Frequency Oscillations in a Separating Boundary-Layer Flow U. Ehrenstein and F. Gallaire
Abstract A separated boundary layer flow at the rear of a bump is considered and two-dimensional flow states at increasing Reynolds numbers are computed using a nonlinear continuation procedure for the stationary Navier–Stokes system. The global instability analysis of the steady states is performed by computing two-dimensional temporal modes. The analysis reveals non-normal modes which are able to describe localized initial perturbations associated with large transient energy growth. At larger time a global low-frequency oscillation is found accompanied with periodic regeneration of the flow perturbation inside the bubble, as the consequence of non-normal cancellation of modes. The initial condition provided by the optimal perturbation analysis is applied to Navier–Stokes time integration and is shown to trigger nonlinear ‘flapping’ typical for separation bubbles. Keywords Boundary-layer separation Global instability Non-normality
1 Introduction There is general evidence that laminar detached boundary layers are likely to undergo two-dimensional low-frequency global oscillations [6] which have been observed both in experiments, whether the separation bubble is triggered by leadingedge geometries [4] or by adverse pressure gradients [8, 11]. The physical mechanisms at the origin of this type of instability which occurs above a critical Reynolds number are only partially understood. For instance, the frequencies associated with possible transition from convective to absolute instability of local velocity profiles U. Ehrenstein () ´ Aix-Marseille Universit´e, 4