Graduate Texts in Contemporary Physics R N. Mohapatra: Unification and Supersymmetry: The Frontiers of Quark-Lepton Physics R E. Prange and S. M. Girvin (eds.): The Quantum Hajj Effect, 2nd ed.
M. Kak:u: Introduction to Superstrings and M-Theory, 2nd ed. J. W. Lynn (ed.): High Temperature Superconductivity H. V. Klapdor (ed.): Neutrinos
J. H. Hinken: Superconductor Electronics: Fundamentals and Microwave Application
Michio Kaku
Introduction to Superstrings and . M-Theory •. Second Edition :: .
:. Wich 45 llIuslrolions •
Springer
Michio Kaku Department of Physics City College of the City University of New York New York, NY 10031, USA
Series Editors Professor Joseph Birman Department of Physics City College of CUNY New York, NY 10031 USA
Professor R. Stephen Berry Department of Chemistry Uni versity of Chicago 5735 South Ellis Avenue USA
Professor Mark Si1vennan Department of Physics Trinity College Hartford, CT 06106 USA
Professor H.E. Stanley Center For Polymer Studies Physics Department Boston University Boston, MA 02215 USA
Professor Jeffrey Lynn Department of Physics University of Maryland College Park, MD 20742 USA Professor Mikhail Vo10shin Theoretical Physics Institute Tate Laboratory of Physics University of Minnesota Minneapolis, MN 55455 USA
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Kaku, Michio. Introduction to superstrings and M-theory I Michio Kaku. -2nded. p. crn.--{Graduate texts in contemporary physics) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-387-98589-1 (alk. paper} I. Superstring theories. I. Title. H. Series. QC794.6.s85K35 1998 539.7'258--<1c21 98-26976 Printed on acid-free paper.
to 1999, 1988 Springer-Verlag New York, Inc. Al! rights reserved. This work may not be translated or copied in whale or in part without the written permission of the publisher (Springer-Verlag New York, Inc., 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010, USA), except for brief excerpts in connection with reviews or scholarly analysis. Use in connection with any form of information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed is forbidden. The use of general descriptive names, trade names, trademarks, etc., in this publication, even if the fonner are not especially identified, is not to be take.p as a sign that such names, as understood by the Trade Marks and Merchandise Marks Act, may accordingly be used freely by anyone. Production managed by A. Orfuntia; manufacturing supervised by Joe Quatela. Photocomposed copy prepared in M-TE'C by The Bartlett Press, Inc., Marietta, GA. Printed and bound by R.R. Donnelly and Sons, Harrisonburg, VA. Printed in the United States of America.
9 8 7 654 3 2 I ISBN 0-387-98589-1 Springer-Verlag New York Berlin Heidelberg
SPIN 10685632
To my parents
Preface
we are all agreed that your theory i.~ crazy. The question which divides IlS
is whether il is crazy enough.
-Niels Bohr
Superstring theory (and its latest fonnulation, M-theory) has emerged as the most promising candidate for a quanrum theory of all known interactions. the past Superstrings apparently solve a problem thai has delled solution
roc
50 years, namely the unification of the two grellt fundamenta l physicallheorics oflhe century, quantum field theory aod general relativlty. Superstring theory introduces an entirely new physical picrure into theoretical physics and a new mathematics that has startled even the mathematicians.
Ironically, although superstring theory is supposed 10 provide a unified field theory of the Universe, the theory itself often seems like a confused j uOlble of folklore, random rules of thumb, and inruilions. This is because the
development of superstring theory has been unlikc thot of any other theory, such as general relativity, which began with a geometry and an action and later evolved into a quannlm theory. Superstring theory, by contrast, has been evolving b..1ckward fOT the past 30 years. 11 has a bizarre history, beginning with the purely accidenUil discovery of the quantum theory in 1968 by G. Veneziano and M. Suzuki. Thumbing through old mathematics books, they stumbled by chance on the Beta fimction, written down in the last century by mathematician Leonhard Euler. To their amanment, they di scovered that the Beta function satisfied
aJmost aU the stringent requirements of the scattering matri.'( describing particle interactions. Never in the history of physics has an important scientific discovery been made in quite this random fashion.
V111
Preface
Because of this accident of history, physicists have ever since been trying to work backward to fathom the physical principles and symmetries that underlie the theory. Unlike Einstein's theory of general relativity, which began with a geometric principle, the equivalence principle, from which the action could be derived, the fundamental physical and geometric principles that lie at the foundation of superstring theory are still unknown. To reduce the amount of hand-waving and confusion this has caused, three themes have been stressed throughout this book.. To provide the student with a solid foundation in superstring theory, we have first stressed the method of Feynman path integrals, which provides by far the most powerful formalism in which to discuss the model. Path integrals have become an indispensable tool for theoretical physicists, especially when quantizing gauge theories. Therefore, we have devoted Chapter I of this book to introducing the student to the methods of path integrals for point particles. The second theme of this book is the method of second quantization. Although traditionally field theory is formulated as a second quantized theory, the bulk of superstring theory is formulated as a first quantized theory, presenting numerous conceptual problems for the beginner. Unlike the method of second quantization, where all the rules can be derived from a single action, the method of first quantization must be supplemented with numerous other rules and conventions. The hope is that the second quantized theory will reveal the underlying geometry on which the entire model is based. . The third theme of this book is duality, which has revolutionized the way we formulate string theory. Duality, which was first discovered in Maxwell's equations, allows us to determine the equivalence of two seemingly different theories. Using duality, we can show that the five different superstring theories in 10 dimensions are actually unified into a single theory in 11 dimensions, a still mysterious theory called M-theory, which reduces to II-dimensional supergravity in the low-energy limit. Since duality allows us to show the equivalence of a weak coupling theory to a strong coupling theory, it has allowed us to probe, for the first time, the nonperturbative region of string theory, where we find a host of new objects, such as membranes, M-branes, and D-branes. Although the complete action of M-theory is still unknown, already it has yielded a flood of new information concerning the strong coupling behavior of string theory. . We now know that strings coexist with membranes of various dimensions; ultimately, the entire theory may be formulated in terms of a master theory in 11 dimensions, perhaps in terms of membranes of some sort. Ironically, although the action for M-theory is not known, physicists believe that the theory exists because of the vast web of consistency checks given by dUality. (However, because M-theory itself is such an obscure theory, we will still refer to the theory by the name superstring theory.) In addition to providing the student with a firm foundation in path integrals and field theory, the other purpose of this book is to introduce students to the latest developments in superstring theory, that is, to acquaint them with the
Preface
ix
...,
fast-paced areas that are currently the most active in theoretical research, such
String field theory; Conformal fi eld theory; J
entitd to understand the miraculous canccUation of d ivergences o f the theory, which separates string theory from al1 other field theories. Because the theory of automorphic functions gets increasingly difficult as one dl.'SC ribcs muit iloop amplitudes. the beginner may skip the disc ussion of higher loops. The serious srudelll, though, will find that multiloop amplitudes form an !l Tea of active research. Part H begins a discussion orthe field theory ofstrings, and Part UI examines phenomenology. The order of these two parts call be interthanged witho ut diffic ulty. Each part v,a<; written to be relatively independent of the other, so
x
Preface
the more phenomenologically inclined student may skip directly to Part ill without suffering any loss. Chapters 6 and 7 in Part II present the evolution of several approaches to string theory. Chapter 6 discusses the original light cone theory and how to quantize multiloop theories based on strings. However, Chapter 7 was written in a relatively self-contained fashion, so the serious student may skip Chapter 6 and delve directly into the covariant theory. In Part III, the beginner may skip Chapter 8. The discussion of anomalies is rather technical and main1y based on point particles, and overlaps the discussions found in other books. Chapter 9 cannot be omitted, as it represents one of the most promising of the various superstring theories. Likewise, Chapter 10 forms an essential part of our understanding of how the superstring theory may eventually make contact with experimental data. In Part IV, we finally have a presentation of duality and M-theory. In Chapter 11, we have a basic presentation ofM-theory, and how the five known superstings can ali be expressed in terms of a single theory. In Chapter 12, we explore the duality relations that exist in D = 8, 6 and 4 dimensions, giving us, for the first time, a look at the nonperturbative region of string theory. In Chapter 13, we explore more advanced topics, such as D-brane physics, matrix models, and applications ofD-branes to black hole physics. The author hopes that this will help both the beginner and the more advanced student to decide how to approach this book. Michio Kaku
Acknowledgments
I would like to thank Dr. L. Alvarez-Gaume for making many extensive and Ydlusble comments throughout the entire book, which have strengthened the presentation and conlen! in several key pll'lccs. Doctors M. Dine, S. Samuel, J. Lykken. O. Lechtenfeld, I. Ichinosc, D.-X. Li, and A. Das also read the manuscript and contributed numerous helpful criticisms that have been incor· paroled into the book. Dr. D. O. Vona carefully read the entire manuscript Ilud made important suggestions thai gready improved the draft. I wou ld especiaJly like to express my sincerest appreciation to Dr. B. Sakila, Dr. J. Birman, and the faculty and students in the Physics Department of the City College oflhe City University of New York for constant encouragement and support thrOUghOllt the writing of this manuscript, without whicb this book would Dot bave been possible. T would also like to acknowledge support from the National Science Foundation and the CUNY- FRAP Program.
Michio Kaku
: Acknowledgments
J First Quantization and Path Integrals
I
I Patb Integrals and Point Particle! 1.1 Why Strings? . .. . . . . . . , . . 1.2 Historical Rcview orOauge Theory . 1.3 Path Integrals and Point Particles 1.4 Relativislic Point Particles . .. 1.5 First and Second Quantization . 1.6 Faddeev- Popov Quantization 1.7 Scwnd Quantization . .. _ . _ 1.8 Harmonic Oscillators _ . . . . 1.9 Currents and Second Quanri7.3tion 1.I 0 Summary . References. . . . . ..
3 3
f'liambu-Goto Slrings 2. \ Bosonic Slri ngs . . . . . . . 2.2 Oupta-Bleuler Quantization . 2.3 Light Cone Quantization . 2.4 BRST Quantization ... . . 2.5 Trees . . . . . . . . . . .. . 2.6 From Path Intcgrals to Operators 2.7 Projecrive lnwriance and Twists
... .. .. ..
. . ..
.
· . . · . ... · ....
. . ..
7
18 25 28 30
..'
34 37
40 44
47 49 49 60 67
.. .. ..
. ..
70 72
78 84
xiv
Contents 87
2.8 2.9
Closed Strings . . . . . . . . . Ghost Elimination . . . . . . .
90
2. 10
Summary..
95
... .
99
References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
Superstrings
101
3.1
101 104
3.2
3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8
3.9 3.10
Supersymmetric Point Particles . . . . . . . . . . . . Two-Dimensional Supersymmetry . . . . . . . . . . Trees . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Local Two-Dimensional Supersymmetry. ... . Quantization.. . . . . . . . . . . GSO Projection . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . . Superstrings . . . . . . . . . .. .. .. . Light Cone Quantization of the GS Action ..... Vertices and Trees . . . . . . . . .' . . . . .
Summary..... . . . . .
References . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4
5
. . . . . . . . . . ..
.....
111 117 119 123 126 128 134 136 139
Conformal Field Tbeory and Kac-Moody Algebras
141
4.1 4.2 4.3
Conformal Field Theory ' . . . . . . . . . . Superconformal Field Theory Spin Fields . . . . . . . . . 4.4 Superconformal Ghosts . . 4.5 Fermion Vertex . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6 Spinors and Trees . . 4.7 Kao-Moody Algebras . . . 4.8 Supersymmetry......... . . Summary.. ... . . . . . . 4.9 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
141
Multiloops and Teichmiiller Spaces
178 178
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5
U nitarity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Single-Loop Amplitude . . . . . . . . Harmonic Oscillators " . . . . . . . Single-Loop Superstring Amplitudes Closed Loops . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.6 Multiloop Amplitudes . . . . . . . . . . . 5.7 Riemann Sufi'aces and Teichmillier Spaces .. . 5.8 Conformal Anomaly . . . . . . . . . . . 5.9 Superstrings.................. 5.10 Determinants and Singularities . . . . . . . . 5.11 Moduli Space and Grassmannians. . . . . . . 5.12 Summary.. . ... References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
150 155 158
165 167
170 174 174 177
181
185 192 195
200 210 217 221 224 226 238
242
Contents S~ond
Quantization and the Search for Geometry
247 250 254 261
267 272
.. .
275 280 '"6 290
.. . ·· .. ·· .. ·. ·. ·.
291 29 1
.
7.3
Gauge Fixing . . . . . .. .
7.4
7.5
interactions . . . . . . . . . Winenfs String Field Theory
7.6
Proof of (quivalence. . . . .
7.7
Closed Strings and Superstrings .
1.8
Summary .
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
245 247
Ught Cone fJ eld Theory : 6.1 Why String Field Theory? . . . _ .. 6.2 Deriving Point Particlc Field Theory Light Cone Field Theory . Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . Neumann Function Method . . . .. Equivalence of the Scauering Amplitudes . four-String Intemction . Superstring Field Theory . . Summary . References. . . . . . BRST Field Theory 7.1 Covariant Siring Field Theory . . . . • .. 7.2 eRST Field Theory
xv
.
..
.
297 300 303 308 311 317
328 33 1
.
Phenomclloloi:)' and Model Building
335
Anomlllies lind the Atiya h-Slngn Theorem 8.1 Beyond GUT Phenomenology . . . . . 8.2 Anomalies and Fcynnum Diagrams . . 8.3 Anomalies in the Functional Fonnlliism . It4 Anomalies and Characteristic Classes . 8.5 Dirac index . . . . .. _ . . . . .. 8.6 G ravitational a nd Gauge Anomalies . 8.7 Anomaly Cancellation in Strings 8.H Summary .
337 337 341 346 348 353 357 366
.. ·. ·
.
368
References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
372
Helerotic Strlni:s and Compactifiutioo
373 373
9.1
9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5
Compactificarion .. . The Hcterotic Smog . . . . . . . .
Spectrum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Covariant and Fennionic Fonnulations Trees . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
·. .
..
378 383 386
388
xvi
Contents 9.6 Single-Loop Amplitude . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.7 E8 and Kac-Moody Algebras . . . . . . . . . . . 9.8 Lorentzian Lattices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.9 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . "
10 CaJabi-Yau Spaces and Orbifolds 10.1 10.2
Calabi-Yau Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Review of de Rahm Cohomology . . . . . . . . . . 10.3 Cohomology and Homology. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 10,4 Kahler Manifolds .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . " 10.5 Embedding the Spin Connection . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.6 Fermion Generations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.7 Wilson Lines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.8 O r b i f o l d s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.9 Four-Dimensional Superstrings . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 10.10 Summary. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . "
IV M-Theory
391 395 398 400 403
404 404 409 413 419 426 428 432 434 438 449 453
455
11 M-Theory and Duality 11.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2 Duality in Physics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3 Why Five String Theories? . . . . . . . . . . . . . I I .4 T -Duality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. .. 11.5 S-Duality............ 11.5.1 Type IIA Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.5 .2 Type IIB Theory. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.5.3 M-Theory and Type lIB Theory. . 11.5,4 E8 ® E8 Heterotic String . . . . . . . . . . . 11.5.5 Type I Strings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.6 Summary.......... . . . . . References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
..
" . .. " "
12 Compactifications and BPS States 12.1 BPS States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 12.2 Supersymmetry and P-Branes . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 12.3 Compactification...................... 12.4 Example: D = 6 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 12.4.1 D = 6, N = (2,2) Theory . . . . . .. . . . " 12.4.2 D=6,N=(1,I)Theories . . . . . . . . . . . 12.4.3 M-Theory in D 7 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . " 12.5 Example: D = 4, N = 2 and D = 6, N = 1 . . . . . ..
=
457 457 458 460 462 465 466 469 471 473 473 476 480 482 482 484 488 490 491 494 496 497
Contents
12.6 Symmetry Enhancement and Tensionless Strings . 12.1 F -Theory .. . . 12.8 F..XliIl1ple: D = 4 . 12.9 Summary . RefcrencC$ . . . . . . . .
Solitons, D-Brane!, and Black Boles 13.1 Solitons . . . . . . . . . 13.2 Supen:Ill:mbranc Actions . 13.3 Five-BnlDe Action 13.4 D-Branes .. .. . . . . . 13.5 D-Bnmc:: Actions . . . . . 13 .6 M(atrix) Models and Membranes 13.1 Black Holes 13.8 Summary .. 13.9 Conclusion . References . . . ..
. . .. ·. ·· .. . . . . .. . ..
. . . ....
:: : Appendh: A. I A Brief Introduction 10 Group Theory . A.2 A Brief lntroduction 10 Genenli Relativity . A.J A Brief fntrodoction 10 the Tbeory of Forms A.4 A Brief lnlrOduction to Supersymmetry . A.S A Brief lntroduction to Supergraviry A.6 Notation Roferences . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
Indu
xvii
499
501 502 504
510 S1J 511 5J3 516
m 52J
525
m
537 542 544 5<5
545
557 561 566
573
.
. ..
577
579 581
Part
I
First Quantization and Path Integrals
1
Integrals and Particles
Why Strings? of the greatest scientific challenges of our time is the struggle to WIile the fundamental theories of modem physics, quantum field theory and gen-
relativity, into one theoretical framework. Remarkably, Ihcsc two theories
~
~!~~::~:!~;~th::e sum total ofall human knowledge concerningthe most forces of Nature. Quantum field theory, fur example, has had in explaining the physics of the microcosm. down to disless than I O - I~ em. General relativity, on the other hand. is unrivaled in
~
:~~~;~~:t;~~~'~~~~;:2;~ fascinating sueand origin orlhe cosmos, Universeproviding itsel f. Theaastonishing togclhcr thcycan explain the behavior of malleT energy over a staggering 40 orders of magnitude, from the subnuclear to
.ecosrn·ic domain. :: : The great mystery of tbe past five decades, however, has been the total ., I of these two theories. It's as if Nature had two minds, each of the otlier in its own particular domain, operoting of other. Why should Nature, at ils deepcst and most level, require two tota lly distinct frameworks, with two sets of of assumptions, and two sets of physical principles? : Ideally. we would want Ii unified theory to unite these two fundamental
Quantum fie ld theory . . Generol re Iatlvlty
1Unified field theory.
the history of attempts over the past decades to unite these two dismal. They have inevitably been riddled with infinities or
4
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
have violated some of the cherished principles of physics, such as causality. The powerful techniques of renorrnalization theory developed in quantum field theory over the past decades have failed to eliminate the infinities of quantum gravity. Apparently, a fundamental piece of the jigsaw puzzle is still missing. Although quantum field theory and general relativity seem totally incompatible, the past two decades of intense theoretical research have made it increasingly clear that the secret to this mystery most likely lies in the power of gauge symmetry. One of the most remarkable features of Nature is that its basic laws have great unity and symmetry when expressed in terms of group theory. Unification through gauge symmetry, apparently, is one of the great lessons of physics. In particular, the use of local symmetries in Yang-Mills theories has had enormous success in banishing the infinities of quantum field theory and in unifying the laws of elementary particle physics into an elegant . and comprehensive framework. Nature, it seems, does not simply incorporate symmetry into physical laws for aesthetic reasons. Nature demands symmetry. The problem has been, however, that even the powerful gauge symmetries of Yang-Mills theory and the general covariance of Einstein's equations are insufficient to yield a finite quantum theory of gravity. At present, the most promising hope for a truly unified and finite description of these two fundamental theories is superstring theory and its latest formulation, M-theory. [1-12]. Superstrings possess by far the largest set of gauge symmetries ever found in physics, perhaps even large enough to eliminate all divergences of quantum gravity. Not only does the superstring's symmetry include that of Einstein's theory of general relativity and the Yang-Mills theory, it also includes supergravity and the Grand Unified Theories (GUTs) [13] as subsets. Roughly speaking the way in which superstring theory solves the riddle of, infinities can be visualized as in Fig. 1.1, where we calculate the scattering of two point particles by summing over an infinite set of Feynman diagrams with loops. These diagrams, in general, have similarities that correspond to "pinching" one of the intemallines until the topology of the graph is altered.
=
()Q
FIGURE 1.1. Single-loop Feynman diagram for four-particle scattering. The ultraviolet divergence of this diagmm corresponds to the pinching of one internal leg, i.e., when one internal line shrinks to a point.
I.! WllY Strings?
5
00 1.2. ")\Yo-loop Fcynman diagram for closed string scattering. The diagram finite because it cannOI be pinched as in the point panicle ease. From wguments alone, wecan see that string theory is less divergent than point @le,'h,,,,',I<,fo,,,"'divergences, however, may still exist.
theory that can simultaueously eliminate the infinities of the S-ma\rix "o
6
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
Unfortunately, the geometry of the superstring and membranes are some of the last features of the model to be developed. In fact, as seen from this . perspe'6:1ve;'uHnn6cld·1Cd"LI~·M-l~~}mltm:lc.vm:d Lhvtlw.S'pl1~;:t1) J")W.x..u, beginning with the accidental discovery of its quantum theory in 1968! By contrast, when Einstein first discovered general relativity, he started with physical principles, such as the equivalence principle, and formulated it in the language of general covariance. Once the geometry was established, he then wrote down the action as the unique solution to the problem. Later, classical solutions to the equations were discovered in terms of curved manifolds, which provided the first successful theoretical models for the large-scale behavior of the Universe. Finally, the last step in the evolution of general relativity is the development of a quantum theory of gravity. The crucial steps in the historical evolution of general relativity can thus be represented as Geometry -+ Action -+ Classical theory -+ Quantum theory. Furthermore, both general relativity and Yang-Mills theory are mature theories: they both can be formulated from first principles, which stresses the geometry and the physical assumptions underlying the theory. Superstring theory and M-theory are just beginning to reach that stage of development. Remarkably, Yang-Mills theory and gravity theory are the unique solution to two simple geometric statements: (1) Global Symmetry The free theory must propagate pure ghost-free spin-l and spin-2 fields transforming as irreducible representations of SU(N) and the Lorentz group. (2) Local Symmetry The theory must be locally SU(N) and generally covariant. What is remarkable is that the coupled Yang-Mills gravity action is the unique solution of these two simple principles l'---;:F11" FloW -2K1 ",-g r-::Rl1"g 11" . L ---4",-g 2
(1 .. 1 1)
(The first principle contains the real physics of the theory. It cannot be included as a subset of the second principle. There is an infinite number of generally covariant and SUe N) symmetric invariants, so we need the first principle to input the physics and select the irreducible representations of the basic fields. By "pure" fields, we mean ghost-free fields that have at most two derivatives, which rule.s out R2 and F4 higher derivatives theories.) The question remains: r¥hat is the counterpart to these two simple principles for superstring theory and M-theory? The plan of this book, of course, must reflect the fact that the theory has been evolving backward. For pedagogical reasons, we will mostly follow the historical development of the theory. Thus, Part I of the book, which introduces the first quantized theory, will at times appear to be a loose collection of
1.2 Historical Review of Gauge Thcory
7
guiding principle. 11131is why we have chosen, in Part "'P""' integral or functional approach to string [beory. Only path integrals do we have a formalism in which we can derive: fonna lisms, such as the hannonic oscillator formalism. AJthough the ji" 'g<'! fonnuJalion ora firs t quantized theory is still woefully inadequate. a genuine second quantized theory, it is the most convenient in which to tie together the loose ends of the first quantized theory. II of the book we will discuss the field theory itself, from which we all the results of the theory from one aClion. However, once again followed hisforicaJ order and pre:"ented llie field theory backward. III we present the "phenomenology" of!;trings. Although it may be 'I'ruo,,,10 do phenomenology starting at 10 19 GeV, it is imponant to the kinds of predictions that the theory makes. in Part IV, we present duality and I I-dimensional M-theory, which w,us" for time, to probe the nonperturbative region of string theory, theory coexists with exotic objects like p-branes and D-branes. ''''''''r. to really appreciate the successes and possible defects of the sutheory, we must first try to understand the historical problems that ,tag"" d physicists for the past five decades. Let us now mcn to a quick of the development of gauge theories in order \0 appreciate the diffi10
".el'm
('f,f~;~~:¥~;:~;:a! fi nite theory of gravity. We will also briefly sketch !he ~i.l
of thc superstring theory.
Historical Review of Gauge Theory 196Os, elementary panicle physics seemed hopelessly mired in confuweak, electromagnetic. strong, and gravitational forces were each separately, largely in isolation of the otbers. Moreover, investigations force had reached a fundamental roadblock:
weak interocrions. Theoretical models of the weak interactions had ~ro!",~"d
cmbarrassingly little beyood the }·erm.i theory first proposed deaJdes earlier in the 19305: (1.2.!)
r" represents various combinations of Dirae matrices. The next step, a theory of W bosoos. was plagued with the probJem of in. Furthermore, no one knew the underlying symmetry among the or whether there was any. strong interactions. In contrast to weak interactions. the Yukawa ')n"',"n theory provided a renonnaliz8ble theory of the strong interactions: ( 1.2.2)
8
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
However, the Yukawa theory could not explain the avalanche of "ele- . mentary" particles that were being discovered in particle accelerators. J. Robert Oppenheimer even suggested that the Nobel Prize in Physics should go to the physicist who didn't discover a particle that year. Furtbennore, the quark model, which seemed to fit data much better than it had any right to, was plagued with the fact that quarks were never seen experimentally. (3) The gravitational force. Gravity research was totally uncoupled from research in the other interactions. Classical relativists continued to find more and more classical solutions in isolation from particle research. Attempts to canonically quantize the theory were frustrated by the presence of the tremendous redundancy of the theory. There was also the discouraging realization that even if the theory could be successfully quantized, it WOUld ... still be nonrenormalizable. This bleak landscape changed dramatically in the early 1970s with the com- . ing of the gauge revolution. One of the great achievements of the past 25 years has been the development of a fully renormalizable theory of spin-l gauge par- . ticles in which, for the first time, physicists could actually calculate realistic S-matrix elements. Thus, it took over 100 years to advance beyond the original gauge theory first proposed by Maxwell in the 1860s! (See the Appendix for an elementary introduction to gauge theories and group theory.) . Apparently' me Key lcr eminrtann!5'Lru1 inwI'g~r.:a.'<;6'f,r"1bt.:h~~t~l.'1~~mtll.m~. mechanics is to go to larger and more sophisticated gauge groups. Symmetry, instead of being a purely aesthetic feature of a particular model, now becomes its most important feature. For example, Maxwell's equations, which provided the first unification of the electric force with the magnetic force, has a gauge group given by U( 1). The unification of the weak and electromagnetic forces into the electroweak force requires SU(2) ® U(l). The forces that bind the quarks together into the hadrons, or quantum chromo dynamics (QCD). are based on SU(3). All of elementary particle physics, in fact, is compatible with the minimal theory of SU(3) ® SU(2) ® U(l). Although the verdict is still not in on the GUTs, which are supposed to unite the electroweak force with the strong force, once again the unifying theme is gauge symmetry, with such proposals as SU(5), 0(10), etc., symmetry. Although the gauge revolution is perhaps one of the most important devel- .. opments in decades, it is still not enough. There is a growing realization that the Yang-Mills theory by itself cannot push our understanding of the physical universe beyond the present level. Not only do the GUTs fail to explain important physical phenomena, but also there is the crucially important problem of formulating a quantum theory of gravity. Grand Unified Theories, first of all, cannot be the final word on the unification of all forces. There are several features of GUTs that are still unresolved:
1.2 Historical Review of Gauge Theory
9
.' . GUTs cannot rcso! ..'C the problem of why there are three ncarly cxact . ~ .. ~~ : copies or families of elementary particles. We still c~mnot answer Rabi's :. ::. :: "Who ordered the muo n?" still have 20 or so arbitrary parameters. They cannot, for example, ; '",.le" I,," the masses of the quarks, or lhe various Yukawa couplings. A truly unilled theory should have at most one arbitrary parameter. GUTs have diffieuJLy solving the hierarchy problem. Unless we llppeal to supersymmctry, it is hard to keep thc physics of incredib ly massive particlcs from mixing with everyday energies and destroying the hierarchy. The unification of panicle forces occurs around 10-21 em which is very 01,)" to the Planck length of 10-)) cm, where we expect gravitational to become dominan!. Yet GUTs say nothing whatsoever about ",vltation. far, prolon decay has not been conclusively observed, which ai; :;~~~ru~l~e,:',~out minimal SU(5). There is, thcreforc, still no compelling :~. reaso n for introducing the theory. difficult to bel ieve that no new interactions will be found between ~~:;';:':~ energies and the unification scale. The "desert" may very well 1 new jnt craction~ yet unknown. most perplexing and the most challenging of these problems, from
,~;~~~::~~~;~~o~f;:"';·:e'o.V, has been to find a way of quanti ring Einstein's ,~
Although Yang-Mills theoricshllve had spectacular unifying the known laws of particle physics, the laws of gravity ~:~:~:~ different at a fundanlentallevcl. Clearly, Yang- Mills theory and ~ gauge theory arc incapable of dealing with this problem. Thus, arc faced with fonnidab le experimental and theoretical problems when to their limits. (;~::'I relativity is also plagued with simi lar d ifficulties when pushed to it has been established thnt Einstein's equations necessarily .: .:: ,: exhibit poinllike singularities, where we eJ(pect the laws of general rela. ~: :. tivity 10 collapse. Quantum corrections mUSI dominate over [he classical .' in this domain. action is not boundt.'i.i from below, because it is linear in the curvature . lbus, it may nOI be stable quantum mechanically. relativiry is not rcnormali7.able. Computer calculations. for examhave now condusively shown that there is a nonzero countcnerm in nst,I,,', theory at the two-loop level. attempts to quantize Einstein's theory of gravitation have met with failwe. One of tbe firs t to point out that gcncral relativity be incompatible with quantum mechanic:.'l was Heisenberg, who noted
~~:lr::~~"~;~O::f.~'~dimcnSional
coupling constant would ruin the usual
10
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles Ifwe set -
h
2n
= 1,
c = 1,
(1.2.3)
there still remains a dimensional constant even in the Newtonian theory of gravity, the gravitational constant G:
which has dimensions of centimeters squared. When we power expand the metric tensor g(J." around a flat square with the metric 1]1-'" = ( - + + + ), we introduce the coupling constant K, which has dimensions of centimeters: (1.2.5) .• Therefore (1.2.6) In this system of units, where the only unit is the centimeter, this coupling ·· constant K becomes the Planck length, 10-33 em or 10 19 GeV, which is far beyond the reach of experimentation! ..• Renormalization theory, however, is founded on the fundamental premise • • that we can eliminate all divergences with an infinite redefinition of certain constants. Having a negative dimensional coupling constant means that this complicated reshuffling and resuming of graphs is impossible. Negative coupling constants mean that we can always insert the interaction term into .a " Feynman diagram and increase its power of divergence. This means that any , graph can be made arbitrarily divergent by multiple insertions. This means that general relativity cannot be a renonnalizable theory. The amplitude for graviton-graviton scattering, for example, is now a power expansion in a dimensional parameter (see Fig. 1.3):
(1.2.7) where we are no longer able to shuffie graphs in the usual manner to cancel the infinities, which is the heart of renormalization theory. Thus, renormalization theory breaks down. Because general relativity is hopelessly outside the domain of conventional renormalization theory, we must reconsider Dirac's fundamental objection. It was Dirac who said that the success of quantum mechanics was based on ap- . proximation schemes where each correction term was increasingly small. But· renormalization theory is flawed because it maximally violates this principle and manipulates infinite quantities and discards them at the end. One solution might be to construct a theory of gravity that is finite to every order in the coupling constant, with no need for renormalization at all. For a while, one bright hope was supergravity [14, 15], based on the local gauge·
1.2 Historical Review ofey.mge Theory
M..,>-< ..' X +
~)=(
1',I(~ >-0-<
+
,I(' ):c(
+
IJ
+ ...
~)-2-0-<
+ •••
lURE 1.3. Scattering amplirude for graviton-graviton scattering. Because the constant has negative dimensio n any graph can be made arbitrarily divcr,~tll~n'by requiring an infini te number of counlerterms. ThI.L~ theo ries cOnlain ing grdvi ty must be either divergent aT completely finite ordcr-by-order. Pure gravity has been shown on computer to diverge al the two-loop level. Counhave also been found for quantum gravi ty coupled to lower-spin particles. ",_'",>en""'g!h,m,, is the only candidate for a finite theory.
:: ; Osp(N / 4) (see Appendix). which was the first nontrivial extension of .; equations in 60 years. The hope was that this gauge group would of Ward--Takahashi identities 10 cancel a large class The larger the gauge group, the more likely troubl esome cancel (sec Fig. 1.4): Theory Electromagnetism
Electroweak
Strong GUT(?) Gravity(?) S upergravi IY(,!)
Gauge gro up U[I) SU(2) ® U(I) SU(l) SU(5), O( I0) GL(4). 0(3, I)
Osp(N / 4)
• t",iic strategy being pursued was Gaugc symmetry -+ Ward-Takahashi idemitics -+ Cancellation ofgrapbs -+ Renormalizablc theory.
exAInple, even Einstein's theory o f gravity can be shown to be trivthe first loop level. There e"ists a remarkable identity, called the identity, which immedi:1tely shows that all o ne-loop gntphs in relativity (which wou ld take a computer to write down) sum to zero. tbe super-Gauss-Bonnet identities eliminate many of the divergences . but probahly not enough to make the theory tinite. and most promising of the s upcrgravi tics, the 0(8) supergrnvity, divergent. Unfortu nately, it is possible to write down locally supercounterterms at the seventh loop leve l. It is highly unlikely that the of this and probably an infinite number of other counte rterms can ,,..._ without appclliing to an even higher synunetry. This is d iscourag-
12
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
Electricity V(1) Magnetism Weak Force Strong Force
SV(2)
®
V(1) SV(51, 0(10) ?
Superstrings?
Gravitation
FIGURE 1.4. Chart showing how gauge theories based on Lie groups have united the fundamental forces of Nature. Maxwell's theoI)', based on U(l), unites electricity .•. and magnetism. The Weinberg-Salam model, based on SU(2) 0 U(1), unites the. weak force with the electromagnetic force. GUTs (based on SU(5), 0(10), or larger .... groups) are the best candidate to unite the strong force with the electroweak force. Superstring theory is the only candidate for a gauge theoI)' that can unite gravity . with the rest of the particle forces. ing, because it means that the gauge group of the largest supergravity theory, Osp(8j4), is still too small to eliminate the divergences of general relativity, Furthermore, the 0(8) gauge group is too small to accommodate the minimal SU(3) ® SU(2) ® U(I) of particle physics. Ifwe go to higher groups beyond 0(8), we find that we must incorporate higher and higher spins into the theory. However, an interacting spin-3 theory is probably not consistent, making one·. suspect that 0(8) is the limit to supergravity theories. . In conclusion, supergravity must be ruled out for two fundamental reasons.: (1) It is probably not a finite theory because the gauge group is not large enough to eliminate all possible supersymmetric counterterms. There is a possible counterterm at the seventh loop level. (2) Its gauge group 0(8) is not large enough to accommodate the minimal symmetry of particle physics, namely, SU(3) 0 SU(2) ® U(l); nor can the theory accommodate chiral fermions. Physicists, faced with these and other stumbling blocks over the years, have concluded that perhaps one or more of our cherished assumptions about our Universe must be abandoned. Because general relativity and quantum mechanics can be derived from a small set of postulates, one or more of these .. postulates must be wrong. The key must be to drop one of our commonsense assumptions about Nature on which we have constructed general relativity and quantum mechanics. Over the years, several proposals have been made to drop some of our commonsense notions about the Universe: (1) Continuity This approach assumes that space-time must be granular. The size of these : grains would provide a natural cutoff for the Feynman integrals, allowing .•
1.2 Historical Review of Gauge Theory
13
us 10 have a finite S-matrix. Integra ls like ( 1.2.8)
wou1d ihen diverge as 6- n, but we would never take the limit as f; goes to zero. LAttice gravity theories are of this type. In Regge calculus [161. for example. we latticize Riemannian space with discrete four-simplexes and replace the curvature tensor by the angular deficit calculated when moving in a circle around a simplex:
-~, A 2<
R -T angular deficit.
Hat space, th.ere is no angular deficit when walking around 8 closed :" :: path. and the action collapses.) UsulI.lly, in lattice theories, we take the limit as the lanice length goes 10 zero. Here, however. we keep it filted 81a nwnbcr L17). At present, however, there is no experimental evidence support the ide;! that space-time is granular. Although we can never
out this approach, it seems to run counter to the natural progression particle physics, which has ~e n to postulate larger aDd more elegant
__ upproach allows small violations in causality. Theories that ineor· :" parate the Lee-Wick mechanism (18) are actually renormali7.able, but : :' ::. permit small dcviations from causality. These theories make the Fcynman .' .' . by adding II fic titious Paull-Villars field of mass M that ultraviolet behavior of the propagator. Usually, the Fcynman converges as p-l in the uitnlViolet limit. Howt."Vcr. by adding particle, we can make the propagator converge even [aster, like 1
"p"+'-;-M'" ~
,. p
(1.2.9)
is a ghost becausc of the - 1 that appears . (This means that the theory wiU be riddled with negative I Usually, we lei the mass of the Pauli-Villars field tend to How~e r, here we keep it finite, letting thc pole go out onto the sheet. Investigations of the structure of the resulting Feynman show, however, that causality is violated; tbnt is, you can meet parents befOre you are born.
~~i~~t~rePlaec Einstein's theory, which is based on the cwvarurc tensor, II
conformal theory based on the Weyl tensor:
( 1.2. 10)
14
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
where the Weyl tensor is defined as ell-up" = RJLup"
+ gll-[" RpJv + gv[pR"JIl- + tRgll-[pg"ju,
0.2.11)
where the brackets represent antisymmetrization. The conformal tensor possesses a larger symmetry group than the curvature tensor, that is, invariance under local confonnal transformations:
0.2.12) The Weyl theory converges because the propagators go as p-4; that is, it is a higher derivative theory. However, there is a "unitary ghost" that also appears with a -1 in the propagator, for the same reasons cited above. The· . most optimistic scenario would be to have these unitary ghosts "confined" ... by a mechanism similar to quark confinement [19,20]. (4) Locality Over the years, there have also been proposals to abandon some of the ... important postulates of quantum mechanics, such as locality. After all, • • there is no guarantee that the laws of quantum mechanics should hold •• down to distances of 10-33 cm. However, there have always been problems whenever physicists tried to deviate from the laws of quantum mechanics, such as causality. At present, there is no successful alternative to quantum mechanics. (5) Point Particles Finally, there is the approach of superstrings, which abandons the concept. of idealized point particles, first introduced 2000 years ago by the Greeks. •. '-'
The superstring theory, because it abandons only the assumption that the fun- •. damental constituents of matter must be point particles, does the least amount of damage to cherished physical principles and continues the tradition of increasing the complexity and sophistication of the gauge group. Superstring theory does not violate any of the laws of quantum mechanics, yet manages to eliminate most, if not aU, of the divergences of the Feynman diagrams .• The symmetry group of the superstring model, the largest ever encountered • in the history of physics, is probably large enough to make the theory finite • to all orders. Once again, it is symmetry, and not the breakdown of quantum· mechanics, that is the fundamental key to rendering a theory finite. . In Fig. 1.5 we see diagrammatically the evolution of various theories 9( gravity. First, there was Newton's theory of action at a distance, where gravi-. tational interactions travel faster than the speed of light. Einstein replaced this •. with the classical interpretation of curved manifolds. Quantum gravity, in tum," makes quantum corrections to Einstein's theory by adding in loops. Finally,. the superstring theory makes further corrections to the point particle . theory by summing over all possible topological configurations ofinU~ra(;tiIllg} strings.
1.2 Historical Review of Gauge Theory Einrtein
15
Ouenlum Grev iry
.. . ..
o Superstrings
1.5. Steps in the evolution of the theory of gntvilation. Each step in this .' builds On Ihe SUCC~!!$ of the previous step. Ne\OI10n Ihought gravity wa>; a . '.. that acted instanlly over a distance. EiMtein proposed Ihat gravitation was . .. . by the CUf\I'dturc of space-time. The naive merger of general relativity and mechanics produces a divergent theory, quantum gravity. which assumes is cuuscd by the exchange of particle-like gravitons. Superstring proposes that gravitation is caused by the exchange of closed !>tring~.
other
~~~::~:~r~!~:~~h~ow~~Cvtr, is qui te unlike its predcccssors in its historical Unlike physical theories, superstring theory has perhaps
!
in science, with more twislS and turns than a roller
young physicists Veueziauo and Suzuki [21,221. independently ;ov,,,d its qunntum theory when they were thumbing through a mathbook and accidentally noted that the Euler Bela function satisfied postulatcs of the S-matrix for hadronic intcldctions (except un.itarity). Schwarz, and Ramond [23-25] quickly generalized the theory to inspinning particles. To solve the problem ofunitarity, Kikkawa, Saki Is, {26] proposed that the Euler Beta function be treated as the Born to a perturbation scrit.'S. Finally. Kaleu, YlI, Lovelace, and Alessandrini the quantum theory by calculating boson ic multiloop dia· hOlVevcr. was still formulated entirel y in renns of on-shell twO
'v.i.,oco
and Ooto []4, 35] realized that lurki ng behind these scanering was a classical relativistic string. In one sweep, they revolutionthe entire theory by revenling the unifying, classical piCf\lre behind the The relationship between the clossical theory and the quanrum theory y ;~:~;;:G~O~ldstone, Goddard, Rebbi, and Thorn 136] and further b: [3 7]. The Ihcory, however, ""'as still fonnulated as a
16
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
first quantized theory, so that the measure, the vertices, the counting of graphs, etc., all had to be postulated ad hoc and not deduced from first principles. The action (in particular gauge) was finally written down by Kaku and Kikkawa [38]. At last, the model could be derived from one action strictly in terms of physical variables, although the action did not have any symmetries left. However, when it was discovered that the theory was defined only in 10 and 26 dimensions, the model quickly died. Furthermore, the rapid development of QCD as a theory of hadronic interactions seemingly put the last nail in the coffin of the superstring. For 10 years, the model languished because no one could believe that a 10- or 26-dimensional theory had any relevance to four-dimensional physics. When Scherk and Schwarz [39] made the outrageous (for its time) suggestion that the dual model was acruaUy a theory of all known interactions, no one . took the idea very seriously. The idea fell like a lead balloon. The discovery in 1984 by Green and Schwarz [40] that the superstring theory is anomaly-free and probably finite to all orders in perturbation theory has·· revived the theory. The £8 ® £8 "heterotic string" of Gross, Harvey, Martinec,.· and Rohm [41] was considered to be the best candidate for unifying gravity·· with physically reasonable models of particle interactions. . One of the active areas of research now is to complete the evolution of the < theory, to discover why all the "miracles" occur in the model. There has been . a flurry of activity in the direction of writing down the covariant action using methods discovered in the intervening 10 years, such as BRST. Finally, intensive work on duality in the early 1990s, and especially the work of Witten and Townsend in1995, established M-theory as the latest, most ad~ . vanced formulation of string theory. The five superstring theories could now be unified into a single theory in 11 dimensions, perhaps in terms of membranes. Furthermore, the vast web of dual relationships in lower dimensions has given. us a "road map" by which to probe nonperrurbative solutions to string theory. What is still missing, however, is the geometry on which the theory ultimately lies. Understanding this geometry may allow us to formulate the entire theory into a simple, coherent equation. This could complete the evolution of the •. theory, which has been evolving backward for the past 30 years. .
Quantum theory -+ Classical theory -+ Action -+ Geometry. Let us summarize some of the promising positive features of the superstring • model: (1) The gauge group includes E 8 ® E 8 which is much larger than the minimal group SU(3) ® SU(2) 0 U(l). There is plenty of room for phenomenology in this theory. (2) The theory has no anomalies. These small but important defects in a quantum field theory place enormous restrictions on what kinds of theories are
1.2 Historical Review of Gauge Theory
17
The symmetries of the superstring llieory. by a series of cancel all of its potential anomalies. from the theory ofRiemano surfaces indicate that the is to all orders in perturbation theory (although a rigorous still lacking). is very linle freedom to play with. Superstring models arc nodifficult to tinker wilh without destroyi ng their miraculous Thus, we do not have the problem of 19 arbitrary coupling thcory includes GUTs, super-Yang-Mills, supergravity, and Kaluza-::: Klein thcories as subsets. Thus, many ofthe features of the phenomenology :::: for these theo ries carry over info tbe string theory. ,pe;~.ing
thoary, crudely speaking, unites the various forces and particles same way thai 8 violin string provides a unifying description of the tones. By themselves. the noteS A, B. C, ele., are not fundamcntal. the violin string is fundamental; one physical object can explain ;";i,tios of musical notes and eveD the harmonics we can construct from much the same way, the superstring provides a unifying description of ;""twyparticles and forces. In fact, the "music" created by the superstring forces and particles of Nature.
~~'~~~~~:::~~~:~!
theory, because of its fabu lously large set of symme-
' cancellations of anomalies and divergences, we must
C!
present a balanced picture and point out its shortcomings. To be fair we "~::: list the potential problems of the theory that have been pointed out Cl
of the model:
is impossible experimentally to reach the tremendous cnergies found the Planck sCllle. Therefore. the theory is in !>nme sense unlestable. A th"o,y "hat is untcslable is not an acceptoble physical theory. one shred of experimental evidence has been found fO confirm. the ofsuIP,,,,ym,,,,,'ry, let lone superstrings. . presumptuous to assume that there will be no surprises in the "desert" ::: betwecn 100 and 10 19 GeV. New, totally uncxpected phenomena have alup when we have pushed the energy scalc ofouraccelerators. theory, however, wakes predictions over the next 17 orders of which is unhcan.l of in the history of science. does not ~ Iain why the cosmological constant is zero. Any thaI claims to bc II ''theory of everything" must surely explain puzzle of a vanishing cosmological conSlant, but it is not clear how
""""no<
/;:;;'~;::;'~S:O:II~VC this problem.
)
a
embarrassment of riches. There are apparently millions ways to break down the theolY to low energies. Which is thc correct the superstring theory can produce lhc minimal theory other interucljons that have
18
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
(6) No one really knows how to break a lO-dimensional theory down to four dimensions. Of these six objections to the model, the most fundamental is the last, the inability to calculate dimensional breaking. The reason for this is simple: to every order in perturbation theory, the dimension of space-time is stable. Thus, in order to have the theory spontaneously curl up into four- and six-dimensional universes, we must appeal to nonperturbative, dynamical effects, which are notoriously difficult to calculate. This is why the search for the geometry under- . lying the theory is so important. The geometric formulation of the model may give us the key insight into the model that will allow us to make nonperturbative calculations and make definite predictions with the theory. Thus, the criticism that the model cannot be tested at the Planck length is actually slightly deceptive. The superstring theory, ifi! could be successfully ...
broken dynamically, should be able to make predictions down to the level of . everyday energies. For example, it should be able to predict the masses of the .... quarks. Therefore, we do not have to wait for several centuries until we have accelerators that can reach the Planck length. Thus, the fundamental problem facing superstrings is not necessarily an ... experimental one. It is mainly theoretical. The outstanding problem of the theory is to calculate dynamical symmetry breaking, so that its predictions
can be compared with experimental data at ordinary energies. A fundamental theory at Planck energies is also a fundamental theory at ordinary energies. Thus, the main stumbling block to the development of the theory is an understanding of its nonperturbative behavior. . In Part I of this book, however, we will follow historical precedent ahd present the first quantized formulation of the model. As we will stress through~ out this book, the first quantized theory seems to be a loose collection of random facts. As a consequence, we have emphasized the path integral formulation (first written down for the Veneziano model by Hsue, Sakita, and Virasoro [42, 43]) as the most powerful method of formulating the first quantized theory. Although the path integral approach cannot reveal the underlying geometric formulation of the model, it provides the most comprehensive formulation of the first quantized theory. We will not tum to the functional formulation [44] of point particle theory,. which can be incorporated almost directly into the string theory.
1.3
Path Integrals and Point Particles
Let us begin our discussion by analyzing the simplest of all possible systems, the classical nonrelativistic point particle. Surprisingly, much of the analysis of • this simple dynamical system carries over directly to the superstring theory. The language we will use is the formalism of path integrals, which is so versatile that
1.3 Path Integrals and Point Particles
19
jt,~~~;~,;,:~~~.~ both first quantized point particJ~s and second qua ntized
&1
equal elise. in classical mechanics. the starting point is the Lagrangian for a point
1m.i:f -
L =
(1.3.1 )
V{x),
p",,;,lo is moving in an external potentia1 . The real physics is con· :d ;n tllO statcmcnt thai the action S must be minimized. The equations of can be derived by minimizing the action:
S= / L(Xi,x;' t)dt.
8S
~
O.
(1.3.2)
i':~:::~I~: equations of motion, let US make a small variation in the path If!. given by
ox,.
(1.3 .3)
r"th;, smaU variation, the action varies as follows:
J/
-ox' oX,
8L 8L dr -Ix· t ' + • • ",Xi
I
I
= 0•
( 1.3.4)
'!lI''''''8 by parts, we arrivc al lbe Euler- Lagrange equmions:
8L d!L - - -~ Oxl tir lix,
~O.
( 1.3.5)
point panicle, the equations of motion become d2Xi
m-
dt 2
~
-
aV(x)
ax,
( 1.3.6)
correspond to the usual classical Newtonian equations of ma ti on. add ition to the Lagrangian formulation of classical mechanics, there is
PI
8L
= 8x, """":"'" '
(1.3.7)
dcfinition of the conjugate variable, we have
H = PiX, - L.
p'
H (PI,Xi) = 2~
+ Vex) .
(1.3.8)
the Poisson brackets between the momenta and the coordinates are (1.3.9)
20
1. Path Integrals and Point Panicles
A celebrated theorem in classical mechanics states that the equations of motion ofNewton and the action principle method can be shown to be identical. Beginning with the action principle, we can derive Newton's laws of motion, and vice versa Equations of motion ++ Action principle.
This equivalence, however, breaks down at the quantum level. Quantum .. mechanically, there is a fundamental difference between the two, with the equations of motion being only an approximation to the actual quantum behavior of matter. Thus, the action principle is the only acceptable framework ... for quantum mechanics. Let us now reformulate the principles of quantum mechanics in terms of ·. Feynmanpath integrals [44]: (1) The probability pea, b) ofa particle moving from point a to point b is the square of the absolute value of a complex number, the transition function K(a, b): Pea, b) = IK(a, b)12.
(1.3.10) ...
(2) The transition function is given by the sum of a certain phase factor, which · . is a ftmction of the action S, taken over all possible paths from a to b: K(a, b) =
I)eiZ1tS/h,
(1.3.11)
patlls
where the constant k can be fixed by K(a, c) =
L K(a, b)K(b, c),
I.-
(1.3.12)
paths
and the intermediate sum is taken over paths that go through all possible intermediate points b. The second principle says that a particle "sniffs out" all possible paths from point a to point b, no matter how complicated the paths may be. We calculate this phase factor for each oftbis infinite number of paths. Then the transition factor for the path between a and b is calculated by summing over all possible · phase factors (see Fig. 1.6). Remarkably, the essence of quantum mechanics is captured in these two principles. All the profoundly important implications of quantum mechanics, which represent a startling departure from classical mechanics, can be derived from these two innocent-sounding principles! In particular, these two princi- . pIes summarize the essence of the quantum interpretation of the double-slit • experiment. which, in turn, summarizes the essence of quantum mechanics · itself. . •• It is apparent at this point that the results of classical mechanics can be reproduced from our two assumptions in a certain approximation. Notice that,
1.3 Path 100cgJals and Point Particles
... ",, I , ,/ ...
Clil$Sical Mechanics
"!
to.., I,
I
I
"
/
(
I
,,-"","
\,
J
",'"
''" I " "\\
"
,
J
.,/
---
I
;' -_ --'I ,
.........
'" '"
I"
21
.-
",""
1.6, The essential difference between classical mechanics and quantum 'iian;e, . Classical mechanics assumes lhat II panicle executes jusl one path be· points based either on the equations of motion or on the minimization of By contrast, quantum mechani~ ~um.<; the conuibUl;ons of probability on 3n action) for all possible paths between two points. Although path is Ibeone most favored, in principle all possible paths contribute to integral. Thus, the action principle is morc fundamental than lhc equations al the quantum level. of S that are large compared to Planck's constant. the pbase facLOr
rapidly. canceling out these contributions: h
oS» -,
(1.3.13)
2n
the only contributions to the path integral that survive are those for which ev;ati,o", in the action from the c lassical path are on the order of Planck's
(1.3.14) that the Euler-Lagrange equations of motion are reproduced only in a classicallimil, that is, when Planck's constant goes to zero. Therefore of Planck's constant ultimately dctennineli the probability lhat 8 parexecute lraje<:tories that are forbidden classically. We see the origin ,is"nl""g'sunccrtainty principle embodied in these two principles. tel us try to reformulate this more precisely in terms of path integrals. "ee~,dpri " '; pl' now reads
K (a, b) =
K(a , c) = /
11> D;ui2d / ",
(1.3.15)
K(a, b)K{b. c)Dx/t
(1.3.16)
22
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
and
L ~ /DX =
lim /rIIldxi,n,
N ..... oo
paths
(1.3.17)
;=1 n=1
where the index Il labels N intermediate points that divide the interval between the initial and the final coordinate. We will take the limit when N approaches ··. infinity. . •.. It is absolutely essential to understand that the integration Dx is not the ... ordinary integration over x. In fact, it is the product of aU possible integrations • over all intermediate points Xi,nbetween points a and h. This crucial difference . between ordinary integration and functional integration goes to the heart of the path integral formalism. This infinite series of integrations, in turn, is equivalent to summing over all . possible paths between a and h. Thus, we will have to be careful to include normalization factors when performing an integration over an infinite number .• of intermediate points. Ifwe take the simple case where L = all functional integrations can actually be performed exactly. The integral in question is a Gaussian, which is fortunately one of the small number of functional integrals that can actually be · performed. One of the great embarrassments of the method of path integrals • . is that one of the few integrals that can actually be performed is
!mx;,
"f xx d
2n
_, 2.<2 _
e
-
-00
r(n
+ ~)
r 2n+ I
•
(1.3.18) ".
l
We will be using this formula throughout the entire book. Let us now break up the path into an infinite number of intermediate points, xi,n' (Notice that the functional expression integrates over all possible values of the intermediate point Xi ,n. so we cannot expect that Xi,n and XI.n+l are close to each other even for small time separations.) Let us write .
dt
~ E
(1.3.19) . In order to perform the functional integral over an infinite number of ·. intermediate points, we will repeatedly use the following Gaussian integration:
i:
dX2 exp[ -a(xl =
r;;
- x2i - a(x2 - X3)2]
exp [-
~a(x1 -
X3)2] "
(1.3.20) .
One of the crucial points to observe here is that the integration over a Gaussian in one of the intermediate points yields another Gaussian with that interme: diate point removed. This is the fundamental reason why we can perform the functional integration over an infinite number of intermediate points.
1.3 Path Integrals and Point Particles
23
the path integral that we wish to perform is given by K(a , b)
=
!~JJ
... f
dXI
dX2·· ·dXN_I
I
XC~£) -limN exp ~: l/Xtt -X"_1)2 j
(1.3.21)
we have suppressed the vector index i). Using the previous relation the final result is equal to K(a, h)
=
m 21(11> -I.)
'n exp ( 4im(XII -
rb - ta
xoi)
.
(1.3.22)
""";,,ie''0 probability function K has some vel)' interesting properties. For it solves the wave equation: -I a2 a ---2 K(a, b) = i - K(a, b)
2m axo
ata
( 1.3.23)
t.. is greater than I". we will generalize these expressions for the case offrccly propagating ,and we wil l find that these expressions for the Green's functions carry only smail, but important, changes. show the relationship between tbe Hamiltonian :md Lab'nmginn fo rin the path inlegrdl approach, it is helpful to insert a compJete set .~;::~~::: states when we divide up the path from a to b. Let us treat the is as an opt.'TtIlor acti ng on a set of eigenstates:
x
X Ix) = x Ix).
(1.3.24)
: Ix) represents an eigenstate of the position operator, treating i as an whose eigenvalue is I:qua1 to the number .r. Then completeness over ,ils""s Co" ,,";,d;"I" and for momenta can be represented as 1=
1= nonn" li,~
f f
j:c)d.r(xl,
Ip) dp (pI.
(1.3.25)
= 8(x - y), e'Px (pix) = =
(1.3.26)
our states as follows: (xly)
,,2 ~
of the infinite number of normalization constants that constantly the path iotcgral fonnalism, we will often delete them for the sake of in this book. We do not lose any generality, because we can, of course, them into the path integral if we desire.)
24
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
With these eigenstates, we can now rewrite the expression for the Green's function for going from point Xl to XN.
(1.3.27) In order to derive the previous expression (1.3.22) for transition amplitude, let us insert a complete set of intermediate states at every intennediate point between Xl and XN: (Xl, tllXN tN) = (Xl, tllX2, t2) I
f
" ·IXN-h tN-I)
dX2 (X2, t21
f
f
dX2
dXN-1 (XN-lo tN-t!XN. tN)' (1.3.28)
Now let us examine each infinitesimal propagator in tenns of the Hamiltonian, which we write as a function of the coordinates and derivatives:
H = H(x, ax).
(1.3.29)
Then the transition for an infinitesimal interval is given by (Xl. tllX2. 12) = (XII e-iH(x.az)li1 I X2) = e- iH (x.ai)51 (xllx2)
=
e-iH(x,a.;)~1 (xdp)
= e-iH(x.p)~t
= e-iH (x.pl51
f f
f
dp (plx2)
dp e ip(X2 -x I ) 2:rr dp e ipi8t • 2:rr
(1.3.30) .
It is very important to notice that path integrals have made it possible to . • make the transition from classical to quantum commutators. The Hamilt6nian can be expressed either as a function of derivatives with respect to the position or as a function of the canonical momenta because of the identity:
(1.3.3l) This allows us to make the important identification: H(x. p) ++ H(x. ax), . 0 { p ++ - 1 - .
(1.3.32)
ox
In the functional formalism, the important correspondence between momenta ... and partial derivatives arises because of this identity. . Putting everything together, we can now write the complete transition amplitude as (Xl, tdXN, tN)
= jX'; DpDx exp {i [III [pi' XI
II
- H(p, X)] dt} ,
(1.3.33)
1.4 Rciati,,;slic Point Particles
p' 2m
H = -.!....
+ Vex).
25
(1.3.34)
":,:::;, we have dropped 1111 Ihe intermediate Donnalizations. which are f! of 21r .) Notice that the fu nctional imegrol, which. wall once only of the coordinates, is now B function of both the momenta and the
~~:;;~ retrieve the original Lagrangian, we can perform the p integration because il is 3 simple Gaussian integral, and we arrive at
;:: ., ... I I Ix .... '
IN) =
1.'"
Dx exp
{il IN Until - V (x)] dt } .
(1.3.35)
la~~~,:: made tbe transition between the Lagr,mgian and we Hamiltonian
t8
u<;ing functional m.ethods. We can usc either:
L = ~m..i} - Vex)
+-!o
pi + V(x) . m
H = 2-
(l.J.36)
• the only difference between these two expressions is whether
over the coordinates or a combination of the coordinates and the The transition probability can be represented as
1: 1
K(a, b) =
=
Dxcxp
1" .r,
{i1.-' dt[~mx; -
! f"
DxDpexp i
I.,
V(X )] }
[
II
dl pi; - 2~' p' - V(m)
.(1.3 .37)
Relativistic Point Particles OUI discussion has been limited to nonrelativistic partid cs, where aU of freedom arc physical. However, nontrivial complications occur we generalize our previous discussion to the case of relativistic par. In panicular, lbc (- 1) appearing in the Lorentz metric will, in general, ~:~::fc~;~'~; !>tates to propagate in lbe tbeQry. These nonphysical "ghost" e: have negalive probability, must be eliminated carefully to ensure causal theory free of negative norm statcs. 0'"'" rel"iv,,,k case, lei us 31'.SUme that lbe location of a puint particle is by a four-vector. (1.4.1)
i'~~~::;:~'~~:,,:~ r docs not necessarily refer 10 the time. The action is ~
simple, being proponionalLO the four-dimensional path lenglh : S = - m / ds = -m (length).
( J.4.2)
26
I. Path Integrals and Point Particles
The path length ds can be written in terms of the coordinates:
ds =
J-x Jl2 dr:'
(1.4.3)
where the dot refers to differentiation with respect to the parameter r:. This action, unlike the previous nonrelativistic action, is invariant under reparametrizations of the fictitious parameter r. Let us make a change of coordinates from T to f: (1.4.4) .
T
-* i(r).
d
dr r = di d r:,
Then we find
dx dx df -=--, dr di dr:
1(a::)'j'" ~ 1(a:;)'r dr
(l.4.5)
di
Thus, the action is invariant under an arbitrary reparametrization ofthe variable · . r:.
This can be written infinitesimally as r: -+ r { 8x)i =
+ or:, x)i8r:.
As before, we can now introduce canonical conjugates: 8L
PJl =
oxJl
(l.4.6) l
mXJl
J x;'
=
(1.4.7)
The crucial difference, however, from our previous discussion of the nonrelativistic point particle is that not all the canonical momenta are independent. . In fact, we find a constraint among them: ( l.4.8) Thus, the mass shell condition arises as an exact constraint among the momenta. If we calculate the Hamiltonian associated with this system, we find that
H =
pJlx/J. -
L
= O.
(1.4.9) .•
The Hamiltonian vanishes identically. These unusual features, the vanishing of the Hamiltonian and the constraints .. among the momenta, are typical of systems with redundant gauge degrees of freedom. The invariance under reparametrization, for example, tells us that the path integral that we wrote earlier actually diverges:
/ Dxe
iS
=
00.
(1.4.10)
1.4 Relativistic Point Particles
27
"o.us.e there is a St:par-dle contribution from each particular param. But since /Jx is parametrization invariant, Ihis means that we are ~!~~:,. an infinite number of copies of the same thing. Thus, the integral however, explained how to quantize systems with redundant gauge of freedom. For example, let us introduce canonical momenta P and constraint condition via a Lagrange multiplier as follows:
+ m2 ).
L = Py.x/I. - ~e(p!
(lA.II)
.co,.stmint equation (l.4.8) is imposed here as a classical equation of varying e, we recover the constraint 00 the momenta. Quantum however, this constraint is imposed by functionally integrating the path integral, we have
f
Decxp
[-i f
drte(p2 +m2)] '" o(p2 +ml),
( 1.4.1 2)
we have used the fact that the integral over eik;t (or the Fourier transfonn ,. number I) is equal to o(x). Notice that the new Lagrangian ( 104.11) still the gauge degree of freedom. It is invariant under
exj.l ,
OX~
=
cPr.
= sP/l.' d(se)
oe= dr'
(1.4.13)
that this netion has over the previous one is that all variublcs We do not have to worry about complications caused by the " Ilolld e that we have introduced will become the metrie tensor we generalize this action to the string.)
tet"' now functionally integrate over the p variable. Becausethe integration a Gaussian, we have no problem in performing the p integration:
f
Dpoxp \'
J
d, [pi -le(p' +
'" exp
{jf
rn')ll
dr ~(e- lx2 - em 2) } .
(1.4. 14)
we have now obtained a third version of the point particle action. The lD"'go of this action is that it is linear in the coordinates rnd is invariant
:Xp_ d::;;
[ De _
d,
.
(1.4.15)
i,";::::1~'we have fOWld tluce equivalent ways to express the relativistic [)t The "second~order" Lagrangian (104.14) is expressed in lenns of
28
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
second-order derivatives in the variable x lL ( 1:) and the field e. The "nonlinear" Lagrangian (1.4.3) is expressed only in terms of xlLC'r). It can be derived from .. the second-order form by functionalIy integrating over the e field. And finally, . the "Hamiltonian" fonn contains both x IL ( r) and the canonical conjugate p( r) (it is first-order in derivatives): first-order (Hamiltonian) fonn: L
= PILi'" -
!e(p~
+ m2),
second-order fonn: L = ~(e-I i~ - em 2), nonlinear fonn: L =
(1.4.16)
-mJ i~.
All three are invariant under reparametrization. Each of them has its own distinct advantages and disadvantages. This exercise in writing the action of ...• the free relativistic particle in three different ways is an important one because it will carry over directly into the string fonnalism. Expressed in terms of path . integrals, the point particle theory and the string theory are remarkably similar. .
1.5
First and Second Quantization
In this section, we will quantize the classical point particle and then show • the relationship to the more conventional second quantized formalism offield .. theory. The first quantization program, as we shall see, is rather clumsy com-, pared to the second quantized formalism that most physicists are familiar with, but historically the string theory evolved as a first quantized theory. The great . advantage of the second quantized fonnalism is that the entire theory can be derived from a single action, whereas the first quantized theory requires many , additional assumptions. The transition from the classical to the quantum system is intimately linked .. with the question of eliminating redundant infinities. As we said before, the . path integral is formal1y ill-defined because we are summing over an infinite . number of copies of the same thing. The trick is to single out just one copy. There are at least three basic ways in which the first quantized point particle may be quantized: the Coulomb gauge, the Gupta--Bleuler formalism, and the BRST formalism.
Coulomb Quantization Here, we choose the gauge Xo = t = r.
(1.5.1)
In other words, we set the time component of the x variable equal to the real time t, which now parametrizes the evolution of the string. In this gauge, the
1.5 First and Se.:ond Quantization
29
.i",du,,,, to
L=-mf JI
I.Il
dr.
(1.5.2)
: limit of velocities smal l compared 10 the velocity of light, we have (1.53)
so that the functional integral is modified to
f
Dx"S(xo -
()e's =
f
DXI
cxp
(i ! lm# dl) .
(1.5.4)
case of the string, this simple c.x.ample will lay the basis for the light
.~:;:~~;;:::~~Th~:.:eadvantage of the Coulomb gauge i~ thai all ghosts have ~
from the theory, so we arc dealing only with physical
ntit;". The other ad .....dI1lagc is that the zeroth component of the position now explicitly defined to be the time variable. The parametrization point panicle is now given in terms of the physical time. disadvantage of the Coulomb fonnaJism. however, is that manifest symmetry is broken and we have to check explicitly that the quan-
~:::;,~~!;~:cJosc correctly. Although this is trivial for the point features will emerge for the quan tum string. fixing the
;
to be 26.
LeuLer QuanlizQlion tries to maintain Lorentz invariance. This means, of course, thai must be taken to prevent the ncg31ive norm states from spoiling properties oftbe S-matrix. The Gupta-Bleuler method keeps the tOluJly relativistic, but imposes the constraint (1.4.8) on state vectors: (1.5.5) . that the above etjuation is a ghost-killing constraint. because we can -. -: it to eliminate Po.) This fonnu lism allows us to keep the commutators fully (1.5.6)
wc choose r]1'-~ = (- + + + ... ). Notice that this gauge constraint "",liy generalizes to the Klein-Gordo n cqualion: (0 - m')~(r) ~ O.
(1.5.7)
Gupta-Bleuler fonnalism is an imponant one because most of the ,o].d,,", in string theory have been carried out in this formalism.
30
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
ERST Quantization The advantage of the BRST formalism [45,46] is that it is manifestly Lorentzinvariant. But instead of regaining unitarity by applying the gauge constraints .. on the Hilbert space, which may be quite difficult in practice, the BRST formulation uses the Faddeev-Popov ghosts to cancel the negative metric particles. Thus, although the Green's functions are not unitary because of the propagation of negative metric states and ghosts, the final S-matrix is unitary because all the unwanted particles cancel among each other. Thus, the BRST formalism· manages to incorporate the best features of both formalisms, i.e., the mani-· fest Lorentz invariance of the Gupta-Bleuler formalism and the unitarity of .. the Coulomb or light cone formalism. In order to study the BRST formalism, .• however, we must first understand Faddeev-Popov quantization.
1.6 Faddeev-Popov Quantization Before we discuss the BRST method, it is essential to make a digression and ••• review the formalism developed by Faddeev and Popov [47]. As we said earlier, . the path integral measure DxiJ. is ill-defined because it possesses a gauge degree· . of freedom, so we are integrating over an infinite number of copies of the same thing. Naively, we might insert the gauge constraint directly into the path integral. If the constraint is given by some function F of the fields being set to zero: l
F(xiJ.) = 0,
(1.6.1)
then we insert this delta functional directly into the path integral: Z =
f n Dx
8 [F(xlL)]e
iS
•
(1.6.2)
x
However, this naive approach is actually incorrect because the delta functional contributes a nontrivial measure to the functional integral. The key to the Faddeev-Popov method is to insert the number 1 into the functional, which obviously has the correct measure. For our purposes, the most convenient formulation of the number 1 is given by
1=
AFP
f
De8[F(x;)],
(1.6.3)
where e is the parametrization of the gauge symmetry of the coordinate, in (1.4.6), x~ is the variation of the field with respect to this symmetry, and the Faddeev-Popov determinant AFP is defined by the previous equation. Notice that the integral appearing in the previous equation is an integration over an possible parametrizations of the field. Since we are integrating out over all possible parametrizations, then, by construction, the Faddeev-Popov
1.6 Fllddccv-Popov Quantization
Jt
!l"inanl is gauge independent of any particular parametrization: o'FP(X)
= AFP(X').
(\.6.4)
";o.::li~ins~,ert the nwnbcr I inlO Ihe functional integral and make a gauge isl to reabsorb the E dependence in x:
Z=
=
f f
Dx6.}l'(x)
f De~[P(x£)]els
Dxll. }l'{x) /
DetJ( F (x )]eiS ,
(1.6.5)
here the x' was gauge rota led back into the original variable x. Since parts of the fu nctional integral were al ready gauge independent. we
(1.6.6) aow extract o ut the integral over the gauge parameter, which measures inJini,'",ohllln' of the group space: ,;olume =
f
(1.6.7)
De
t~~~~;~, n"w expression for the functional which no longer has this infinite
z=
f
(1.6.8)
DXfifPo[ F(x)]e's.
that a naive quantilBlion of me path inlcgral wou ld simply insert the
[;i~~~W~O~U!I~d~om~it thecome Faddeev-Popov determinant, which is 3. new Lhc measure out correctly.
~
the Faddeev-Popov dctcrminant, which carries all the ho,;ls ,ofthe,lheory. Tbe trick is to change variables because both f1 and F havc the same number of of freedom. Thus, the Jacobian can be calculated:
dec 'can
[~: ] D e =
(1.6.9)
DF.
"'''''(0'' write Il"
~ !f D'Wf = !f DFdet [:~]
a,] ]-' [ I
= del -
of
F= O
['F]
=det -
D£
.
W f (1.6. 10)
F",O
the Faddeev-Popov factor can be expressed as a simple determinant of vari";on of the gauge constraint. It is more convenient to introduce this
32
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
factor directly into the action by exponentiating it. We use the fonowing LlFP
=
!
D()D8e iSt)1,
(1.6.11)
where the new ghost contribution to the action is given by Sgh
=
!
dr8
[~:t=o
(),
(1.6.12)
where the e variables are anticommuting c-numbers called Grassmann num- . bers. Normally, when performing functional integrations, we expect to find the • detenninant of the inverse of a matrix. With functional integration over Grass- . mann numbers, the determinant occurs in the numerator, not the derlonlimltOlr.. Grassmann numbers have the strange property that
(1.6.13) . In particular, this means (1.6.14) .. '
. ..
Normally, this would mean that e vanishes. However, this is not the case for a •• Grassmann number. Thus, we also have the strange identity ( 1.6.15) This identity makes the integration over exponentials of Grassmann-va1u~ . fields in the functional integral rather easy, because they are simply pol)'I)o- . rnials. More identities on Grassmann numbers are presented in the Appendix, . where we show that
!n
d(); d8/ exp
,= 1
[.f
8iAij()j] = det(Aij).
(1.6.16) • •
I.}=I
This identity verifies that integration over Grassmann variables yields deter- •.• minant factors in the numerator, not the denominator, so that we can express . the Faddeev-Popov determinant in (1.6.11) as a Grassmann integral. Now that we have developed the apparatus of Faddeev-Popov quantization, let us return to the BRST approach, where we wish to impose the gauge condition
e= 1
(1.6. 17) .
(we omit some subtleties with respect to this gauge). In this gauge, we should be able to recover the usual covariant Feynmann propagator. To show this, . . notice that our action (1.4.14) becomes (1.6.18)
1.6 Faddeev-Popov Quantization
33
this Lagrangian, our Green's function for the propagation of a point from one point to another is now given hy .6.F(XI ,Xl)
= (Xtl 0 1m 1-'2) = (x II 2
=
101) dre- «rJ-",I) 1-'2)
l<X>d'l~lDxexp(-~l rd r(i;, - m2)).
(1.6.19)
that this is the usual covariant Fcyrunan propagator rewritten in first ~ti,<ed
integral language. before gauge fixing. our action was invariant under
',= dd(',')·
(1.6.20)
o
Faddecy-Popov detenninafll associated with the gauge choice e = 1 determinant of the derivative. We now use II Gaussian integral over ~"'"""' states to represent the detenninant, using (1.6.10):
.6.~'p =dct loTI = -
f
D9D8CXP(
f dr:iiaTo).
(1.6.21 )
we had used ordinary real fields instead of Grassmann-valued fields. the would bave corne out with the wrong power.} we find that our final action can be represented
(1.6.22)
r:;;;,~~;::fCth" B.RSr
Q.pp,,,",h .~ to notice Ihat Ihis gOllge-fu:ed action has
~X/l
= i£9xIJ.' Jp,. = if;f:J PI<' MJ = j£90,
08 =
i£(}O
(1.6.23)
+ !s(p; + m 2) .
we may wonder why yet anot her symmetry appears after we have the gauge degree of freedom. However, this extra symmetry is and hence does not allow us to impnl'le any eonstmints on the theory. symmetry, therefore. is different from the ones found earlier and cannot used to eliminate gauge fields from the action. summarize the BRST approach by extracting an operator Q that will the symmetry fOWld earlier:
'¢ = L8Q,¢I, Q = 9(0 - m 1 ).
Q2 = O.
( 1.6.24)
34
I. Path Integrals and Point Particles
The physical states satisfY
Q lei» =
o.
Notice that enforcing this constraint recovers the Klein-Gordon equation on-shell particles:
1.7
Second Quantization
So far, we have been analyzing only the first quantized approach to quantum particles. We have quantized only the position and momentum vectors: .
[Pi, X j] = -i 8u.
first quantization:
The limitations of the first quantized approach, however, will soon beC:OIIlle apparent when we introduce interactions. Let us say that we wish to del:;crlibe point particles that can bump into each other and split apart, rather than duce an external potential. We must now modify the generating functional include summing over Feynman graphs:
L
Z=
topologies
f
1ength
Dxe-
•
(Notice that we have Wick rotated the r integration so that the exponential converges. It will be clear from the context when the Wick-rotated theory being used in this book because the exponential becomes real. We will discuss the delicate question of the convergence of path integrals.) In other words, we must, by hand, sum over the various particle tOpIOJ()g1I~S·. where point particles can split and reform. Each topology represents the hi~,t"r'\J ofthe trajectories ofthe various point particles as they interact. The amplllnIO,e,: for N-particle scattering, with momenta given by k], k2, ... , k N , can now represented as A(k 1 , k2 ••••• kN) = .
L
topologies
X
gn
f f
exp (-
DXll.FP
dt L(t)
+i
t
k"xj ) .
Notice that we are taking the Fourier transform of the Green's function, so the amplitude is a function of the external momenta. This formula can be mClrp." conveniently represented as
\ .1 Second Quantization
we associate a fdCtor
e,'h
transfonn terO'i. This path ,00","" because it will configurations and ~_""'tri·x i.s not al all obviolL<;.
35
for each external particle coming from the
fonnu la for the scattering amplitude i fomlalism. is. We must fix the set ofall topologically weights by hand. Furthermore, unitarity of
a second quantized description, however, we introduce a field V(x) t:.:~s~";('" relations between the fields themselves, not between the (1.7.5)
' :"I",.o"'g" of· the second quantized approach is that the inlcracting Hamilcan be written explicitl y, without having to inltoducc sums over 'OS"": Showing that the Hamiltonian is Hennitian is sufficient to fix the of all diagrams and to demonstrate !he unitarity of tbe S-matrL"( . . "unID'''I. the pros and cons of first and second quantizations are as
must be added in by hand. order by order in the coupling of Ihe final S-mlllrix is not obvious. This must be explicitly
order by order. formalism is necessarily a pc:rturbative one, ~ince the expansion in l~;:;:::~s is intimately tied to the expansion in terms of lhc coupling difficult 10 describe the theory otT-sheil. Quanti7.ation interactions arc cxplicit in lhe action itself. ~";"'.rilyiS guaranteed if the J-Iamiltonian is Hcnrulian. theory can be formally written nonperturbatively as well as perturba-
.""'y.thcory is necessarily off-shell. .. . transition from the ~tto the second quanti:tcd.lhcory can also be per... most easily in the path integral forma lism in the Coulomb gauge. we showed that thc Grcen's function tor a propagating free point can be explicitly evaluated:
f,,}
l
[.m(x.-x.)']
' ~ exp /
2{rb
1,,)
.
(1.7.6)
""""·s function can also be written in a second quantized fashion. Let with the Hamihonian:
H
1
,
=-- v . 2m
(1.7.7)
36
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
The Green's function satisfies
= 8(3)(x -
(iar - H)K(x, t;x' , t')
X')O(t - t').
Solving for this Green's function, we find K(a, b) = [i8r - H]x-1r 'x I ' 6. 11, b, b
where we are treating the inverse Green's function as if it were a discrete trulttrt~i in (x, t) space, and we have dropped trivial normalization factors. This us to write the integral in second quantized language. To demonstrate this, will use the following identities throughout this book:
f0
dx; exp
(i~ -x;Aijxj + n(l/2)N
il: I Jix;
(I"4 i~ Ji(A N
= det [Aijl exp
-1)ijJj
I .
(This integral can easily be derived using our earlier formula for the integral (1.3.18). We simply diagonalize the A matrix by making a change variables in x. Thus, the quadratic term in the integral becomes a function of eigenvalues of the A matrix. Because all the modes have now decoupled, Gaussian integral can be performed exactly by completing the square. we make another similarity transformation to convert the eigenvalues of back into the A matrix itself.) From this, we can also derive the following:
f D il: XnXm
dXi exp (
-xjAijxj +
il: I JiXi
~ [~~ .. J'}] det Ik'I-1 ojn ojm exp {~l'(A-I) 4 J Y 1=0 1
IJ
~ (A -I )nm(det IAu I)-I.
These are some of the most important integrals in this book. Using these equations, we can now write the Green's function totally in terms of . quantized fields: K(a, b) =
f
1/!*(xa, ta)1/!(Xb, tb)D1/!* D1/! exp
[i f
dXdtL(1/!)] ,
where L(1/!) = 1/!*(iar
-
H)1/!,
where we are again treating K(a, b) as if it were a matrix in discretized (x, space.
1.8 Hannunic Oscillators
37
;,ummary. we now have two complementary dcscriplions of che point We can write the theory either in lenns of the particle's coordinates in terms of its fields W(x). free level, both de.<;criplions (ll'e totally equivalent, both in ease of ri~:: and also in mathematics. However. at the interacting level, distinct !'C appear. For example, it is easy 10 write
L, _tj)l,
"'¢.,
(1.7.14)
are guaranteed to get a unitary description of an interacting field. '''''. in the firs t quantized approach, the sum over topologies:
L
( 1.7.IS)
oopolol_
way in which to describe a unitary theory. We must check uniby order in increasingly complicated diagrams. Furthermore, we to adopt a tOIAlly pcrlurbative description for the first quanti7.ed . The sum over topologies in the first quanti7.ed path integraJ is a Feynman diagrams, so the formulation is necessarily from the very beginning. Thai is the fundamental reason why we this book into first quantization and second quantization.
Harmonic Oscillators ~rumpl"h'I will illustrate the relationship between first and scoond quan-
the harmonic oscillator problem. This example. will prove helpful )(\,U~~~h~the harmonic oscillator representation, which we will use ex.h string model. Let us begin with a point particle governed by lowmg Hamiltonian: (1.8.1 ) is the spring constant. Because the momenta and coordinates are we can use the same arguments presented earlier in our discussion ,Ib," "g,.I, 10 SCI [p, xj = -i.
(1.8.2)
now redefi ne our coordinates and momenta in Icnns of hannonic p
= (f mw)I i2(a +at ),
x = j(2mw)-I!2(a _ at),
( 1.8.3)
( 1.8.4)
38
I. Path Integrals and Point Particles
In order to satisfy the canonical commutation relation (1.8.2), we must have . : [a, at ] = l.
If we insert this expression back into the Hamiltonian, we find
H = tw(aa t
+ ata).
By extracting a c-number term, we can write this in normal ordered fashion:
H = w(ata
+ ho),
where ho is the zero point energy. We can now introduce the Hilbert space harmonic oscillators. Let us define the vacuum as
a 10) = O. Then an element of the Pock space of the harmonic oscillator Hamiltonian " given by In) = (att 10)
Jnf such that the states form an orthonormal basis: (nlm) =
onm.
The energy of the system is quantized and given by
En = (n
+ i)w.
So far, the systems has been presented only in a first quantized formal .. We are quantizing only a single point particle at any time. We would now to make the transition to the second quantized wave function by introducing 00
I<%» =
L ¢n In) , n=O
where we power expand in the basis states of the harmonic oscillator. instead of describing a single excited state of a point particle, we are introducing the wave function, which will be a superposition of an
(xlct» = <%>(x). This can be calculated explicitly. Notice that we now have two iI'Idepel1de:nt:::;?4 basis states, the harmonic oscillator basis In) and the position eigenvectors Ix) . We must now calculate how to go back and forth between these two bases. . Let us first analyze the simplest matrix element: Uo(x)
= (xIO).
1.8 HarmonK: Oscillatonl
39
element satisfies the equation
0 = (xl (I 10)
= (xl p~x 10) 2m",
(-
ia - imwx ) (..rIO) ax
= -i(2mW)- I(l
(a~ + mcux) oa(x).
=
(2mllJ)-11l
( 1.8.15)
equation can be solved e.xacuy:
ao(.,r) = (mwljf)I J~e-(If2}f l,
( 1.8.16)
(1.8. 17) 8
straightforward titep to calcu late aUsuch matrix elements. Let
o~(x)
= (xJn )
= (xI (n!)I/lat~ 10)
r
= (n!)- lfl (2mw}-
=
(n!)-ln(2mw)~I/l)n
(-i a~ +
(~IuDion is therefore
a~{x) = iM(2~n!)- If2 (mw/lT)II'
(t - aa~
im(o)x
uo(x).
r
~-(If2)tI.
(l.8. IS)
( 1.8.19)
"::~~thcse are nothing but Hermite polynomials H". In terms of these we Can CJtpress the eigenstaTe Ix ) and III) in lenns of each other:
1)(
~
Ix )
~
= L: In) (nix ) = L: In ) a. (x). ,
In ) = Ix)
!
..
dx (x1n)
=/
dxo~(x) Ix).
( 1.8.20)
>s. '~';', g ,(I. . 12) and (1 .8.20). we have the power expansion of the wave in tcnns of a complete set o f orthogonal polynomials, the Hcnni te
I .
~
lI>(x )
~
= (xl
(1.8.21)
il is not difficult to calculate the Green 's function for the propagahpoi.t particle in II hllrmonic oscillator potential. The Green's function
40
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
would be the same as if we had started with the second quantized with the action: L = ct>(x)* (iar
+ 2~ V2 -
LV1UH1U"lJ,l:,::;
(1.8.2~~i::m
ikX2) ct>(x).
From this second quantized action, we can therefore derive the equations . motion: .
[-1
V2 + 2m = H¢(x, t).
ia,ct>(x, t) =
!kX 2] ct>(x, t)
From this, we can define the canonical momenta conjugate to ¢(x, t) such the canonical quantization relations are satisfied:
[n(x, t), ct>(x', t)] = -i S(x - Xl).
1.9
Currents and Second Quantization
Let us begin with a discussion ofthe relativistic second quantized theory, WhlCttS;:::: as we have seen, is equivalent perturbatively to the first quantized theory. quantizing the point particle in the Gupta-Bleuler formalism, we were the equations of motion: ( [0 - m2 ]q'> = 0
which can be derived from the second quantized action:
L = Hallq'>i}llq'>
+ m 2q'>2].
One of the most powerful techniques we used to explore the first theory was symmetry. We would now like to study the question ofsyrnrnletri~W within the second quantized formalism. First, let us calculate the equations of motion by making a small in the field and requiring that the action be invariant under this variation:
8S
f
= 0=
dDx (8L 8q'> +
8q'>
~8aflq'» 8i}fl¢
.
Let us now integrate by parts, using 8I1(1.q'> = afl8¢:
8S =
!
dDx
G~
-
a(1.
o~~¢) o¢ +
f
dDxi}1l
(8:~¢ o¢) .
lfwe temporarily ignore the surface term, the action is stationary if we hli;;i@E:l the following equation of motion:
8L oL aJ.L -oaJ.Lq' > oq'>
= 0
(l ....
"'0'1
L . ...
1.9 Current:; lind Second Quantization
41
im"rt the Lagrangian into Ibis equation. we obtain the equations of which reproduce the constraint found earlier in the first quantized noW make n small change in the fields, pammetriz.ed by a small, as ,,,Ui,J, Ilwnber 0":
8¢ = 8¢ as".
'c·
( 1.9.6)
this into the previous equation for the variation of the action, keep term intact, Illld assume that the equations of motion are satisfied,
have the following:
!s~fdDxa" (~'¢)"-' JJ ¢ at"
(1.9.7)
Il
~efin,
the tensor in the parentheses as the current: !ii, 8¢
" J" =
aa ll ¢, oE!"
(1.9.8)
, .",ve the important equation
oS = / dDx0I'J:Ssa.
(1.9.9)
action S is stationary under this variation. we have a conserved (1.9.10)
I
w"' ,hi" ",""ri,," over and over again in the discussion ofslrings when
extrnct the currcnt for supersymmetry and conformal invariancc. note that the integrated eharge Q" associmed with the current is
in time:
f
d D xal' JI"J =
f
d D - 1x8rJJo..
+ surface term,
( 1.9.11 )
(1.9. 12) we wish to construct yet another conserved current associated with Let us make a small variation in the spacHime variable: (1.9.13) charge, the volume clement of the integral changes as
odDx
=dDxallax".
(1.9. 14)
42
I. Path Integra1s and Point Partic1es
Therefore, the variation of the action under this change is
f
dDx[LafLDX fL
+ 8L].
DS
=
DL
= DXfLollL + -8¢' + --8all ¢,.
8L
8L
8¢'
8all¢'
Now, if we assume that the equations of motion are satisfied, we have
SS =
!
D d x all { (
+L8~ - 8!~¢' au¢,) ox
u } •
If we now define the energy-momentum tensor as 8L TJ.l.u = sail¢' au¢,
then we have the equation
SS =
!
- 1)J.l.u L ,
dDxoll(T!'-vS xv ).
So if the action is invariant under this change, then the tensor is conserved: aJ.l.p v = O.
emlrg:y-{nOlnellltu~a~
(1.9.1 (
For example, for the scalar particle action, the energy-momentum becomes TJ.l.v = a/1¢,a,,¢, -
1]/1V
L
which is conserved if the equation of motion holds. Lastly, it is instructive to investigate how the various quantization dures treat the Yang-Mills field (see Appendix). Let us begin with the' invariant action:
where
F;v
= a/1A~ -
avA~ - roc AtA~.
The action is invariant under SA"/1!i = a N l - f abe AbJ.I. A C ' where A a is a gauge parameter. The path integral method begins with functional
Z=
tenlsdj~m
fn
dA/1(x)i fh -(I/4)F; ••
J.I. .x
Now we consider the three methods of quantization.
prclcei~~
Currenl~
1.9
and Second Quantization
43
invariancc permits us to take thc gauge
"ViAr = O.
,"gro,t, 0"" 'h' Ao component because it has no time derivatives, so formulation is explicity ghost-free. (The price we pay for this, of loss of manifest Lorentz invariance, which must be checked by :- :. this gauge, the action becomes
~(F;jl
L = +HaoAn2 -
+ " ',
(1.9.25)
,field, are D'ansverse. This is the canonical form for the Lagrangian.
of the Gupta-BJculcr fonnulation is that we cao keep manifest 'Y'"m,,"y without viol
(1.9.26)
, the propagator for massless vector particles becomes
,. '.'
(1.9.27)
p
"~~;~~'~i'~~,a~:" explicitly eontains a ghost. The timclike excitation i 1 in the propagator. which represents a ghost. However, to !.{uantize in this covariant approach becausc we will impose the "'~""'''01 on the Hilbert space:
:f
(
a" AI''' Iljr) =
(1.9.28)
O.
,on,;", allo,",'5 us to solve for and hence eliminate the ghost modes. the .
will allow ghosts to
the Hilbcrt ghost-free.
approach begins by calculating the Faddeev-Popov determinant , Let us calculate the de terminant of the ma!rix:
M ab (
) _
~(a~A""(.x-)
,sAbey)
x. Y -
= 8 Dj.l SAO(x) "
,sAbey)
= OJ.lDj.l(8\l -
yW b ).
( 1.9.29)
44
1. Path Integrals and Point Particles
As before, we can write the determinant of Mal, by exponentiating it into action using (1.6.10):
L = _1 F a2 4
IlV
+ _l_(a AJ.lQ)2 + ca MObcb 2a Il ,
where the anti commuting Faddeev--Popov ghost fields are represented by and c. This action is invariant under the following BRST transformation:
.sA: = (V BRST:
DCa -
-
-a
IlC)Q
e,
_!.fobdcbCd e
2
'
1 a
DC = -(aJ.l"A"·c<)e.
Once again, it is important to notice that the BRST transformation is nillPoteIit~:W The BRST symmetry is not connected to the conservation of any oO!;enraOl~::::: quantity. From the previous invariance, we can extract out the generator transformation S such that Q2 = O.
The physical states of the theory then satisfy Q Iphy) = O. (
1.10
Summary
The great irony of string theory, which is supposed to provide a framework for all known interactions, is that the theory itself is so sorgatliz(~g.~!:m ! String theory is often frustrating to the beginner because it is full of . conventions, md arbitrary rules of thumb. The fundamental reason for this: that string theory has historically evolved backward as a first quantized th_'nri,,:~1% rather than as a second quantized theory, where the entire theory is <1ellllC~CI:~~ in tenus of a fundamental action. The disadvantages of the first qu:antize:q;~~ approach are that: (1) The interactions of the theory must be introduced by hand. They canlnC!!~m be derived from a single action. (2) Unitary is not obvious in this approach. The counting of graphs must checked tediously. (3) The formulatiop. is perturbative, so that crucial nonperturbative tions, such as dimension breaking, are beyond its scope. (4) The formulation is basically on-shell, rather than off-shell.
By contrast, the advantage of the second quantized approach is that everything can be derived from a single off-shell action, where is manifest and nonperturbative calculations can, in principle, be pelfolrn1!}d;;;
LtO Summary
45
string theory evolved historically a... a first quantized theory. theory has been evolving backward, with the second quantized gestill in its infancy. For pedagogical reasons, we have introduced from a semihistorical point of view, beginning with the first quanand later developing the second quantized theory and M-theory. that future accounts of string theory will reverse this sequence. level of arbitrariness in the first quantized theory as much as in this chapter we have lried to lay the groundwork for slring theory I integrals. This functional fonnalism has Ule great adlbat we can express the first and sccond quantized gauge theories with We fmd. in fuet. that large portions of the path integral formulation particles can be incorporated wholesale into string lheory. integral method postulates two fundamental principles that express c-'--- of quantum mechanics:
i
e p,rn"bllll"y P(a, b) of a parlide going from point a to point b is given absolute value squared ofa transition function K (a, b).
P(a.b) = IK(G.b)I', ~' l"n,lll' on function is g iven by the sum of a phase factor
a to h,
the action. taken over all possible paths from
K(a, b):::
tis. where S
.
L kels. ~
the limit of continuous paths, we have K(a , b) =
Dx:= Io'_oc lim
lb
Dxi s ,
, " TITIdXin. i_ I
~ ", I
'
action S of thc firSI quantized point particle: is given by the length path that the particle swccpS out in space-time. We can represent the ~gl,n for the point particle in three ways:
,urst-{),uer ~ (H a mil tOm3n . )"Jonn: sccond-order fonn: non linear form:
I~ := p",x." - 'if ( PI''+ m, ')
x! - em 2 ),
L = i(t' - r
L=
(LlO.I)
-mJ-x~.
because all three forms of the action are parnmetrizationthe path integral diverges. Thus, the quantization procedure must
~:~~~;~:~i':')'DllTI;' etry and yield the correct measures in the functionaJ. ~
be quantized in three ways, each with its own advantages
46
J. Path Integrals and Point Particles
(1) Coulomb Quantization By explicitly fixing the value of some of the fields, such as
xo=t=r we can eliminate the troublesome negative metric states and the becomes! The Coulomb quantization method is therefore man , Itestl~f.m ghost-free. However, the disadvantage of this method is that it is very ward because manifest Lorentz symmetry is broken and must be chl;:ckfrill at every level. (2) Gupta-Bleuler Quantization The advantage of the Gupta-Bleuler quantization method is that we ha'ie::;:; a manifestly covariant quantization program. Of course, negative mettilllt:;:: ghosts are now allowed to circulate in the theory, but they are eVl~ntual~Y:}':§) eliminated by imposing the gauge constraints directly onto the ,n~J'U!:ij~,!,: space:
mvi.
[p~
+ m2 ] 1<{1) =
O.
Thus, the S-matrix is ultimately ghost-free. The disadvantage of thiS:ru approach, however, is that the imposition of these gauge cOllStrmD:W$.~ especially at the interacting level, is frequently quite difficult (3) BRST Quantization This method of quantization keeps the good features of both apllro;acl:leil;~ The theory is manifestly covariant, but the S-matrix is still uru·ltaI"Yt,ecalli;~J.$ the addition of ghost fields in the theory cancels precisely against , negative metric states. The BRST method imposes the gauge e = I' the first-order form and then inserts the Faddeev-Popov term 6 FP into functional to get the correct measure. We can exponentiate this deternliruili.~1 into the action by using Grassmann variables: AFP
= det lOr I =
f
de dee; f dfoa,9.
The resulting gauge-fixed action has a residual symmetry, called the u~,.~' ;l;.,:,m . symmetry, which is generated by Q, the BRST charge. When we generalize these methods to the interacting case, the path mt~~~ formulation begins with the fundamental formula for the transition functi(ju for N -particle scattering: A(kt. k 2 ,
••• ,
kN)
=
L topologies
X
=
gn
!f
exp i
L topologies
f
Dx 6FP
dtL(t)
+ i tk/kXt }
gn (e l L~~I kpxt').
References
47
quantized descriptiOn for the N -particle scattering amplitude is
Y,~~':'~This ;~~':>:~,~;~I; '~·;It1~~~~:. overcenain topologies, which must be rnenns thlll tulilatily is not obvious in the first quantized
"1:
Later, we wiU sec that this problem in the first quantized point . theory carries over directly into the first quanlized string theory. In the
r~~:~~;:~:ri:l:' :~;hl:~::: all topologies can be derived explicitly action.
~,n
from a first [0 a second quantized description is straightin the path integral formulation. For example, the propagator can be
;,";lh"6"1. o,sec<)Ddqu.nll2.t1I~guag"
an" = =
" 1 ! ~
Dxelt:JII.(f)
Dl/t Dl/r"Vt{xa)ifr'(x,,)t! f
D~LC"'),
(1.10.3)
(xl"'l = ,,(.,). L(t) = ~mi:, L(",) = ",'oa,
(1.10.4)
-
H)",.
equation is the Lagrangian for the SchrOdingcr wave equation., which -derived with the postulates o(path integrals and L:::= ~mu? j also possible (0 extract the second quantized vertices first quantized theory in exactly the same fllshioD. We simply writ!: functional integra] over a world sheet where tbe point partiele splits hcr 00'.'" particles, and then write chis Green's function as a functional over second qualltized fields. . shortly see the advantage o f carefully working out the details of part,;', Ie palh integrals. We will find that almost all of this fonnalism over directly into the string formalism!
reviews of string theory, see J. H. Schwarz, cd., SuperslringlI, Vols. 1
47, :~:~~:~~;f:~z;':~::%~~i,~!~11"";"" New York, 1974. i Rep. ge, 199 ( I
~
Mod. PJrys. PJrys.
1213
Jacob, ed., Dual Theory. North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1974.
48
I. Path Integrals and Point Particles
[10] J. H. Schwarz, Phys. Rep. 8C, 269 (1973). [11] M. B. Green and D. Gross, eds., Unified String Theories, World tic](mt11ic: Singapore, 1986. [12] M. B. Green, J. H. Schwarz, and E. Witten, Superstring Theory, Vols. I and .. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1986. [13] H. Georgi and S. L. Glashow, Phys. Rev. Lett. 32,438 (1974). [14] D. Z. Freedman, P. Van Nieuwenhuizen, and S. Ferrara, Phys. Rev. D13, (1976). [IS] S. Deser and B. Zumino, Phys. Lett. 62B, 335 (1976). [16] T. Regge, Nuovo Cimento 19 558 (1961). [17] N. H. Christ, R. Friedberg, and T. D. Lee, Nucl. Phys. B202, 89 (1982). [18] G. C. Wick and T. D. Lee, Nue!. Phys. B9, 209 (1969). [19] M. Kaku, Nucl. Phys. B203, 285 (1982). [20] M. Kaku, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 1895 (1983); Phys. Rev. 27, 2809, 2819 (\ [21] G. Veneziano, Nuovo Cimento 57A, 190 (1968). [22] M. Suzuki, unpublished. [23] P. Ramond, Phys. Rev. 03,2415 (1971). [24] A. Neveu and J. H. Schwarz, Nucl. Phys. B31, 819 (\ 971). [25] A. Neveu and 1. H. Schwarz, Phys. Rev. D4, 1109 (l97\). [26] K. Kikkawa, B. Sakita, and M. A. Virasoro, Phys. Rev. 184, 1701 (1969). [27] M. Kaku and L. P. Yu, Phys. Lett. 33B, 166 (1970). '1.2.'01' M: ~crK.allM L? rY'! u'i'h'Ys?Iti::1'3...~2.9-1~;0R,7, ,;/}?IllWZ.1,\,. [29] M. Kaku and 1. Sehert, Phys. Rev. D3, 430 (1971). [30) M. Kaku and 1. Schert, Phys. Rev. D3, 2000 (1971). ( [31] V. Alessandrini, Nuovo Cimento 2A, 321 (1971). [32] C. Lovelace, Phys. Lett. 32B, 703 (1970). [33] C. Lovelace, Phys. Lett. 34B, 500 (1971). [34] Y. Nambu, Lectures at the Copenhagen Summer Symposium (1970) . . [35] T. Goto, Progr. Theoret. Phys. 46, 1560 (1971). [36] P. Goddard, J. Goldstone, C. Rebbi, and C. B. Thorn, Nuci. Phys. B56, 1 (1973). [37] S. Mandelstam, Nucl. Phys. 864,205 (1973); B69, 77 (1974). [38) M. Kaku and K. Kikkawa, Phys. Rev. DID, 1110, 1823 (1974). [39) 1. Scherk and J. H. Schwarz, Nucl. Phys. 881, 118 (1974). See also 1 . YOlle~i:::~ Progr. Theoret. Phys. 51, 1907 (1974). [40] M. B. Green and J. H. Schwarz, Phys. Rev. 149B, 117 (1984); 151B, 21 (l __ ,.., .:.~ [41] D. J. Gross, J. A. Harvey, E. Martinec, and R. Rohm, Nucl. Phys. B256, (1986); B267, 75 (1986). [42] C. S. Hsue, B. Sakita, and M. A. VirasOTo, Phys. Rev. D2, 2857 (1970). [43] 1. L. Gervais and B. Sakita, Nucl. Phys. B34, 632 (1971); Phys. Rev. D4, 229 • (1971); Phys Rev. Lett. 30, 716 (1973); see also D. B. Fairlie and H. B. . Nucl. Phys. 820,637 (1970). [44] R. P. Feynman apd A. R. Hibbs, Quantum Mechanics and Path /nt<'O'rll'/.t McGraw-Hili, New York, 1965. [45] C. Becchi, A. Rouet, and R. Stora, Ann. Phys. 98,287 (1976). [46] I. V. Tyupin, Lebedev preprint FIAN No. 39 (1975), unpublished. [47] L. D. Faddeev and V. N. Popov, Phys. Lett. 258,29 (1967).
2
Strings
Bosonic Strings theory. at first glance, seems divorced from the standard techniques 'J~:;! over the past 50 years for second quantized field theories. This !c:' . string theory was first historically d iscovered as a IlI'St qUQlllized This is the reason why string theory al limes ap~ars to be a random
Cri~~~::;;~!~:~,~,;o~nv,;;~en~":·~ons. Although a second quantized field theory
Ie
single action. 3 first quantized theory requires assumptions. In particular, the vertices, the cho ice of interactions, of these perturbation diagrams must be postulated by hand to be uni tary laler. integral formal ism for the first quantized point particle generalized for the string by J. L. Gervaisand R Sakita, which enables write dowo the dynamics of interacting strings with remarkable ease. previous chapter, we laid the crucial mathematical groundwork for a nssk i on of the first quantized point particle theory. Surprisingly, almost all main features of the Nambu-Goto string have some fonn of analogue " f;", quantized point particle theory. Of course, entirely new features are in Ole ~tritlg theory, such as the existence of powerful symmetries on the sheet, but the basic methods of quantization can be carried over directly . '. the point particle case studied in the previous chapter. saw that the usual formulation of second qua nrized field theory can t~,~,~( in first quantized form. Thus, the traditional covariant Feynman ?2 ( 1.6. 19) can be written vin (1 J.28). (1.3.30), ( 1.3.37) as
50
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
where we integrate over all possible trajectories of a particle located at x).t which start at Xl and end at point X2. The interactions, we saw, were introdlucle( by hand into the theory by postulating a particular set of topologies over this particle can roam. The scattering amplitude, for example, is A(k l , k2, ... , kn ) =
L
! n
topologies
;=1
L topologies
Dx 1l.Fpe- f
N
(
LdHi
L:~=! k,·x,
ik,.x' ) ,
where we integrate over topologies that form the familiar Feynman fu¢30r~~~
.• It is important to notice that the resulting Feynman diagram is a graph, not .... :"'n",' manifold. At the interaction point, the local topology is not R1J, so it cannot be manifold. There is no correlation between the intemallines and the I'rlteractlOIl; points. This means that we can introduce arbitrarily high spins atthe int1emcti()t(:W, point of the first quantized relativistic point particle. Thus, the first qU!1p.tizel~:}~ point particle theory has an infinite degree of arbitrariness, corresponding to lU<;!.:.:* different spins and masses we can place at the interaction point. t'1Uthl~mlore; the ultraviolet singularities of each Feynman diagram correspond to the nu:mb,eir::::ili of ways we can "pinch" the diagram by shrinking an intemalline to zero, LlLU",.,.:,:'-": defoIDling the local topology. This picture, however, totally changes with the string. Although the integral fonnalism looks almost identical, there are profoundly important uu-.·.·_-""'" ferences. In particular, the sum over histories becomes a sum over all pO:5silJI~::::::a~
FIGURE 2_1. Vertex functions for point particles and strings. A large number . point particle theories are possible, based on different spins and isospins, be(:ause::;:~ the Feynman diagrams are graphs. Only a few string theories are known, n"'>J",r"lV because the interactions are restricted to be manifolds, not graphs. Conformal syrn';:::::::::::l metry, modular invariance, and supersymmetry place enormous restrictions on th~r:::;:~ manifolds we may use to construct superstring theories that have no counterpart itt:::::IJ point particle theory.
2. 1 Bosonic Strings
51
sheets thai we can uraw bet'ween two different strings (see 'This world sheet, in tum, is a genuine manifold, a Riemann sursci ofintcmctionsconsistem with the propagator is severely limited.
Furthermore. the super~: ~~:~1?:~~~;;:a~3' ~ :~~:~:'~~~1:::::~::'~~~: contrast to the docs not suITer from ultraviolet divergences caused by :r;hrinking lheories we can write.
in
liDes 10 zero. You cannot "pinch" the string world sheet to Thus, string theory is free of ultraviole I diver;: . from strictly arguments. (We must be careful to paim Olll . diagram, can be reinterpreted as an infrared diverof massless. spin-O particles into the vacu um. eliminates these infrared divergences.)
path integral formalism can treat both the first the first quantized string theory with relative ease, profoundly important physical differences between the two !boories from strictly topological arguments. ,~" gi'n our discussion of strings by first introducing the coordinate of vibrating in physical spac(}-{im~. Let the poims along the string be etr~,d by !be variable (J. and then lei thc Siring propagate in lime. Let
(2.1.3)
the spacHUne coordinates Oflhis string (see Fig.2.2) P.'ll"8ffictrizcd variables. When the string moves, it sweeps out a two-dimensional which we call the ··world sheet " We will paramctrize this world sheet variables. u and r . The vC(:tors thai are tangent to the surface arc by the d~rivatives oflhe coordinate; tangent vectors
ax" aXJ< 8a
(2. 1.4)
::::~.
,r
~
~
t~~~T~h~,~t~W~O:~.dimen$iOnal sheet swept out by 8 striTlg. When a string, in space-time, it sweeps out a two-dimensional . by a moves world I
bya and T . The string variable X,,(O,l) is just a vcctortllat to a poin! on tllis two-dimcnsionJI\ manifolcL
52
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
The contraction of two of these tangent vectors yields a metric:
where we have now replaced the two variables (r, a) with the set (a, b), a, b can equal either 0 or 1. The infinitesimal area on this surface can be wriLtt~ij;::::~ simply as
d Area '" Jdet Igabl da dr. In analogy to the point particle case, where the action is the length swept
by the point, we now define our action to be the surface area of this sheet. Our Lagrangian is therefore [1--4]: L = -12rc ex'
wo.rr4:~~
J'X2 X'1L2 - (X. X'IL)2 IL
IL'
where the prime represents a differentiation and the dot represents r dittefl~nt(~::::~ ation. (When we discuss M-theory, we will introduce the theory oflmemt,rali¢~:~m in arbitrary dimensions in the same fashion. But instead of two cO()fdiliaWs::n! on a world sheet, we now have (p + 1)-coordinates on a world volume. Th~@~ action for the p-brane is still the same: the square root of the determinant .• . the metric tensor. The action is just the volume ofthe membrane.) The actIon: is just the Lagrangian integrated over the world sheet, which is the total of the two-dimensional surface:
s=
J
da dr L(a, r).
The Green's function for the propagation of a string from configuration Xa a·!~:*~ "time" ra to configuration Xb at "time" rh, as well as the path integral OV{·:r::;::;~ a surface that expresses the topology of several interacting strings, can b~jm represented as
Z=
L topologies
J
d/lDXe- area ,
where D X = rIll.a. r d X IL (a, r), d ILfepresents the measure of integration ovt~t::§~ the location of the extemallegs, and where we have made a Wick rotation the t variable (r ---* -it) so the integral converges. . The correspondence between the point particle path integral formalism thu~];§l we carefully developed in the previous chapter and the string formalism. quite remarkable. We find that almost the entire point particle formalism c@~m
2.1 Bosonic Strings
53
into the string fom13lism:
xli(r) length
XI'(a, r)
''''
n ,.'
IT dXI'(a, r)
dXI'(r)
1'-.0". t
the path integral for the point particle and the string theory have similarities. The N -point function for the N -string scattering amalso be written as R Fourier transform, similar to point particle path
" 1 .r;
X,
i,.
Dxe-f,;l.I.r"ldt
•
D X e- f.
0
d" f., L{X)d<
(,.,fr ;. ")
:;;:;: ::~~:~in;th~;'~I,~,"=gu:,,~:gc~:Of t
there are remarkable similarities between point particle and
~tring
path i TItegrals.over the cmdal difference the topologles which the objects For the the topologies are graphs. as in Feynman whereas the topologies for string theories arc manifolds: I
Graphs --+ Manifolds. crucial reasons why there are so many point partide actions (and so actions) is the differcncc bctweengraphs and manifolds. Thcnontrivstniotio", pl""d on manifolds severely restrict the number of consistent ... theories. the case oflhe point particle. the choice of parametrization was totally Thus. our actions must· be reparametrization invariant. To see this, ,mak,,,,,,,bitracy oh'"'I!' of variables: (; = (;(0 • • ).
r=
i(a, .).
(2.1.10)
r ti,i,rep"a""'tn,,,,';ion,, the string variable changes as
8X# = X'!'S(Y
+ XlLor.
(2.1.11)
the area of a surface is independent of the parametrization. the action :s'ly ,rep"",m",i,.tioD invariant, which is easily checked. us now write down the canonical conjugates of the theory:
p = OL = I'-
sku.
~ X XI' - (X"X"")X~ 211"'" Jdet la X"3b X.1 f2
Q
54
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
As in the point particle case, these momenta are not all independent. In fac1~/]~ we find two identities that are satisfied by the canonical momenta: . .
I
P~ +
Constraints:
1 (2Jt a /)2
Pp,X'p,
= O.
X~ = 0,
Thus, the canonical momenta are constrained by these two conditions. If ","'.••.,,-"calculate the Hamiltonian of the system, we find that it vanishes identically,'",.,.:-:« in (1.4.9): ..
The vanishing of the Hamiltonian and the presence of constraints among th!'l'" ::;m: various momenta are indications that the system is a gauge system with ar!::;:;m: infinite redundancy. The reparametrization invariance of the system is the on,..:·:,:,:,:, gin of this redundancy. We can therefore write down the close . between the constraints of the point particle theory and the string theory: {p2
+ m2 =
O}
I
1 Xa (2Jt~22 11 =
Pfl.2 +
--+
PI1 X
0,
I
(
= 0.
Before we begin a detailed discussion of the quantization ofthe string, it '.' instructive to investigate the purely classical motions of this string. Let us firs'it8~ classically set the parameter r equal to time, so that
X/1 =
(1, v;),
X~ = (0,
X;>.
Then let us factor out X a from the action (2.1.7): L = __ 1_IX~211/2(l_
2Jta'
where
v~)1/2,
r
r
vis the velocity component perpendicular to the string: _ Vi
=
VkX~
Vi -
I
-a-X;. Xj
The boundary conditions that we derive from this gauge-fixed action UJ\JJUULV.
v~ = 1. This means that the e.nds of the classical string travel at the speed of light. We can also calculate the energy of the classical string. Let us assume the string is in a configuration that maximizes its angular momentum, Le., it , a rigid rod that rotates with angular velocity w around an axis labeled by unit vector r. The string can be parametrized as
X = err,
2.1 Bosonic SlTi llg~
r :::: w x
55
r,
r · w :::: 0,
(2.1.19)
o~1.
>~~~.~;. ::.:the energy and the angular mornenrum of the system. we must ~
the Lorentz generators associated with the ~tring: M il":::: /
da(P~ X/I
- P"' X ") .
(2. 1.20)
that this generates the algcbrd. of the Lorentz group if we impose the brackets: [XII(q), P..(q')l "" 11... ~ 8«(J - a ' ).
(2.1.21)
now calculate the energy and the angulor momeorum from th(: )O,ots of the UlrenlZ generator [5 J:
J = -1- / ' d. ;.,----'...','~-;,c;),cor> [r x (w 2Ha '
_I
(I
w-.....
,•
X
T)]
... w(4a'w·1)-1
""' wE 2a'.
(2.1.22)
tbe angular momentum of me rolating string is proportionai lo tlte square of the system: (2. 1.23) p lot the energy squared on the x-axis and the angular momentum on we obtain a curve called the Regge trajectury. The slope of the is: given by a' and the curve is linear. Thus, we have obtained Regge trajectory for the classical motion of a rigid rotator. We this book. lake the oonnalization a' :::: This is an arbitrary However, we will see laler that the intercept Qo of the leading must be equal to one, which is fixed by confonnal invariaoce once the theory. Thus, we set
i.
,
,
a :::: 2' ao = 1.
(2. 1.24)
we quantize the system, we will find that there is an infin ite number cb IP",IlI,,I Regge trajectories, but with increasingly negative },-interceplS. we bave stressed, there is a crucial difference between the point particle and the string, which is tbat the string system has a larger set of conthat generate the gauge group of teparametrizations. For example, if
56
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
we introduce the canonical Poisson brackets, then we can explicitly show tll~~{~1 the constraints generate an algebra. To calculate this algebra, we decompose the X and P in terms of nOlrni!~~]1 modes for the open string:
+2 L 00
X"(o-) = xl"
pl"(o-) =
n=1
!I
pI"
1 -X~ cos no-,
..jii
+ [; In p~L cos no-
I·
Notice that the X decomposition is given strictly in terms of cosines. This because, when we calculate the equations of motion of the string, we mti$~:j:m integrate by parts and hence obtain unwanted surface terms at 0- = n: aIi~~:~~ 0- = O. In order to eliminate these surface terms, we must impose
X'I" = 0 at the boundary. This boundary condition eliminates all sine modes of tll~::@ string. (These are called Neumann boundary conditions. It was once th~mllnt::W that Dirichlet boundary conditions, where the derivative of the string V
= XI"(-o-),
X~(o-)
=
-X~( -0-).
The same applies for the modes of the canonical conjugate Pw This, in allows us to combine both constraints into one, using the properties of string under reflection from 0- into -0-. If we let the string pruranletJriz:~ti()*:::m length be n: we can define
1 L f = 4n:
l
Jr
-Jr
do-f( 0-)
(
X' .j2a' n: PI" + .j{a l
)2
'
where f(o-) is an arbitrary function defined from -n: to n:. Notice that botl~:@ilil constraints are now combined into one equation because of this ."." .......... vJ....: symmetry. Using (2.1.21), we can show that these generators form a "a.. ,~ . . ... algebra:
2.1 lJosonic Strings
/X8=/8 ' -8/' ·
57
(2.1.30)
to show that this algebra satisfies the Jacobi identities:
[LU' [L &, LhJ l = 0,
(2.1.3 1)
,ot"••:ke,,,ep,·<s,,~t.111 po,;ible cyclic symmetrizations. This algebra Jlirasoro algebra which will turn out to be one of the most tools we have in constructing the string theory. . . I l}. we can elevatc the constraints into the action with Lagrange ""'ta, r) and pCa, r):
X~
L=P j(/'-+JrU'A[p2+ I'
(2lTa')2
/J.
J+PP XiI'. I'
(2.1.32)
integrating out over these Lagrange multipliers, we arrive at set {Jf constraints. Not surprisingly, this new action has its own group parametrized by 'I and €: SXI' = 2Jra'eP,<
,X'
oP,.,. = [ 21f;' (lA
=
lip =
-i;
+ '1X~,
+ TJP/'-
1
+ ).'1/ -1/';" + pie -
-i7 +>..'£ -
(2.1.33)
"
pe',
AS' + P"I- 'l'p.
~
~~7n:~~~O~f~this~'!~fo~nn~,~fO~r'i~theofthe action is thataction. it is firsl-{)rder and docs nol original As in the point particle
there exists yet one more form for the action, expressed of an auxiliary field. To find this third formulation of the action, lei ;od"", a new independent field
(2.1.34)
""P"'.""'"
metric on a two~dimensional surface. UnJike our previous this metric is now totally independent of the string 'lIIinble. Let us i' d,,~ the Polyakov fonn of the action [7] (g = I detgQ"I):
(2.1.35) generalization of the second-order point particle action (1.4.14). No~ Ihe Polyakov aetion resembles an action with scalar fields inleracting external tvJo~dimensionalgravitational field. This action, too, possesses reparametrization invariance:
8XI' = e"8 XP Q
&gQb = eCac8Qb
~
,.;g ~ .,(e',/8).
gQc11"eb _ g',e8"Eu,
(2.1.36)
58
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
The action is also trivially invariant under Weyl rescaling: 8g ub = Agub. The Polyakov action is entirely equivalent at the classical level to the p
Tab
= -4na,1 ..;g 8g8Lab '
~3.'~w.
(2.1..)
Working this out explicitly, we find (2.1.3·~·m~
The moments ofthe energy--momentum tensor will correspond to the generators. Thus, we have another way ofderiving the Virasoro generators tr",,;,;,:.;, this new but equivalent formalism. Notice that the metric field gab is not a propagating field. The metric tenS!..~~; does not have any derivatives acting on it. Thus, we can eliminate it via its owij:~~ equations of motion. This leads us to (
8L = 0 8gab
--+
2BaX/18bXIL gab = gCdBc X v 8d Xv'
Substituting this value of the metric tensor back into the action, we re(lefJlv.~@ the original Nambu-Goto action. Thus, at the classical level, the two actioi1l~~~ are identical. In summary, as in the point particle case, we now have three different ""'''''·irw.:l~ which to write down the action, all of which are equivalent classically. Each hi·:'I$.:a~ its own particular advantages and disadvantages when we make the transiti(jii~ to the quantum system. These string equations are direct generalizations .: .....U h the three point particle Lagrangians found in (1.4.16). As before, we have thii:l:::::! second-order formalism, which is expressed in terms of the string variable .. as well as the metric tensor gab; the nonlinear formalism, which is eXIJressll@~ entirely in terms of X/1; and the Hamiltonian formalism where we have and its canonical conjugate P/1 (or the pair BuXIL and PUlL): first-order (Hamiltonian) form:
second-order form: nonlinear form:
L = P.. X/1 + na' )., [P/12 ~
L
+ (2na X~ )2]· .:.• • '
+ PP/1X'/1 "-' ..;g P: gabPblL + PU/18aX IL ..;g/na,' = ~..;ggUbBuXIL8bX/1, (2.1.
L = _1_(X2 XI2 - (X X'/1i)I/2. 2na' IL v /1
2.\ Bosonic Strings
59
we suspect that thcse actions are totally equivalent, so that we can drop the others. This is apparently not so. fortwo subtle reasons:
>n""'.
dealing with a firSI quamized theory, we have to take the interacting topologies that are swept out by the string. For the string, the precise mlhlJ"e of these topologies is ambiguous be specified hy hand. However. for the Polyakov form of the which contains an independent metric tensor, we can eliminate of this ambiguity by specifying that we sum over all conJonnally .",dula, inequivolent configurallons. (Thesc tcrms wi ll be defined This wiIJ become a powerful constraint once we start to derive nod will determine thc function measure uniquely. The measure and
~
::rl~.~in the Nambu-Goto action, however, are nol well defined.
out, hQwever, that this rule of integrating over inequivalent not automatically satisfY unitarity. This sti ll must be checked
fix ing ofWeyl invariance fo r the Polynkov action, although triva~':;:'1; poses when mak.e the transition to quan twn 18 An anomaly appears when we carefully begin the quaotizaprocess. In fact, this conformal anomaly will disappear only in 26
probk-ms
we
now discuss the quanti2ation of the string aclion. The strategy we will
~~:~i;;j~~'~ h e~fr~~ee~~ili~eo~ry~'~O~obf~ " ~m~l'b~ e ~ph~Y~S~ 1 C ~ '~ I ~H;n~b~ert~~~CeWi l Jbe [
thealgcbra symmetry. (For the string, the symmetry will invariance and the algebra will be the Virasoro algebra..) must apply the constraints onto the Hilbert s pace, which eliminates and creates a unitary theory. It is important to keep thi ~ strategy in begin the quantization of the string.
-. Symmetry -+ CurrCllt -+ Algebra -+ Constraints -+ Unitarity. ~" I)oln< 1",,'lcllcc••:.,~ " ~ begin the quantization program in several arc three fonnalisms in which 10 fix the gauge o f the theory: ~" -B ll eul,"
(eonfonnal gauge). (2) light cone gauge, and (3) BRST The advantages and disadvantages of eacb area as follow~ :
Gupta-Bleuler is perhaps the simplest of the three fonnalisms. We ghosts to appea r in the action, which permits us 10 maintain manifest The price we must pay, however, is that we m ust impose constrai nts on the Hilbert space. Projection operators must in al l propagators. For trees. this is trivial. For higher loops, , this is exceedingly difficult. lIdvulitage of the light cone gauge formalism is that it is expl icitly 'o"-r.",, in the action as well a... the Hilbert space. There are no eo01-
60
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
plications when going to loops. However, the formalism is very awkw~~{l:§I and Lorentz invariance must be checked at each step of the way. (3) The BRST fonnalism combines the best features of the previous two malisms. It is manifestly covariant, like the Gupta-Bleuler formalism, . it is unitary, like the light cone formalism, because the negative mel[nt;= ghosts cancel against the Faddeev-Popov ghosts. Let us now discuss each quantization scheme separately.
2.2
Gupta-Bleuler Quantization
The Gupta-Bleuler formalism will maintain Lorentz invariance by lilljpmim.~r:ill~: the Virasoro constraints on the state vectors of the theory:
{¢I Lf 11fr} = 0, where (¢ 1and 11fr) represent states of the theory. This constraint will ell[l1ln:a~¢} ghosts in the state vectors, allowing us to keep nonphysical negative m~:tiii~~ ghosts intact in the action. ( Classically, the metric tensor has three degrees of freedom that we c~~m~: gauge away, two arising from reparametrization invariance and one from.-v.1Z~lJl:ii invariance. Since the metric tensor has three degrees of freedom, we cang. all of its components away: 8ab
=
Dab
= ( -~
~)
which we call the conformal gauge. (There are complications, as we have in taking the confonnal gauge for the quantum theory and for higher lOOps~rn~ Our action reduces to
r
S = _1_ da !dT(X 2 4Jtct' 10 fl.
_
X,2). fl.
This is exceptionally simple because the action now corresponds to uncoupled free string. This action yields the free equations of motion:
@;~:$
(a~2 - aa;2) Xp.(a, T) = 0 with the boundary condition: X~(O, r) = X~(Jt, T) = 0
which we need to enforce when we integrate by parts and eliminate the surta¢.~::::~ term. The solutions of the equations of motion are arbitrary functions of a and a - r:
XIJ.(a, T)
= Xj(a + T) + Xj(a -
T).
2.2 Gupta-BleulerQuantization
~,,;"'I
61
coo,",u"";O,O relations are now (2.2.7)
, I( + ..f-, 1
6(0 - (f) =:rr
2 ~cosnucosna
') .
(2.2.8)
' However, as
in the case, we can always choose the ;~Of~C~OU:'~S~c"i'~O~~;O~:fi~~ r~u't::,~O;:umb:~":::~;::,:~~~;~~~~, of the path
:~~ Unlike the point particle case, 18~:;~~'~: b we ~;: now ~::'~ have anbecomes infinite osc;II",o<',. one set for each normal mode:
of'
x:: = ii ../2a'(a~ -
a~It),
1 (an, +a,_It, ) PIt" = ..j2a'
(2.2.9)
can satisfy thc canonical commutation relations if we set
(2.2.10) conventional to introduce an equivalent sct of oscillators: m > m
XfJ.(a, t) = x"
0,
> 0,
+ 2a' p"r + j ../20"
."
L ~e-I'"
cos nO" .
(2.2. 11 )
",.0 II
in this basis, tbe Hamiltonian takes on an especially simple f('lnn (see
~
..,
= '"' + O"p'/'-' L natIt/'- aJl. n
(2.2.12)
have made an infinite shift in "the zcro point energy. At this point. of the lowcst-ordcr particle is not well defined because we made ;0;1. 'mill, but we will later show thai this lowest particle is actually n We will show that the intercept of tbe model is fixed at L
'~:~:~:,:~:~,:~~I~;::;~:~l~ is basically uncoupled from the other oscil-
n'
. In fact, the Hamiltonian is diagonal in the Fock space ofbatmonic
excitations. Taking this specific representation oflhe string function
62
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
s_
10> kl1 a?10>lkl1 a;1110>
FIGURE 2.3. Regge trajectories for the open string. The x-axis corresponds to t~~~~11 energy squared and the y-axis to the spin. The particle farthest to the left is t'~~:~~ tachyon, which corresponds to the vacuum of the Fock space. The massless ~ni .. ~,,·~·»!w. particle is the Maxwell or Yang-Mills field, which corresponds to a single creaQ(~~~m operator acting on the vacuum. There is an infinite number of Regge trajectlori(~~J~m.: corresponding to the infinite excitations of a relativistic string or the infinite nUlnbl~~W. of states in the Fock space. from the infinite number of possibilities is a great advantage because lowed eigenstates of our Hamiltonian are now simply the products of the Fo(~~::::=i spaces of all possible harmonic oscillators: ( eigenstates:
rr
[a!.IL} 10} ,
n.1L
where the vacuum is defined as
n > O. The spectrum of the lower lying states can be categorized as (see Fig. tachyon -+ 10) , massless vector -+ a[1L 10) , massless scalar -+ klLai lL 10} ,
(2.2.15:)iW
massive spin-2 -+ ai lL ai 10) , massive vector -+ lL 10} . v
ai
(The fact that the string theory is so simple to quantize can be traced t~~m the fundamental fact that the Hamiltonian is quadratic in the string this means that it decomposes into an infinite series of free particles. A va:i~~:~m collection of vacuum solutions to string theory can be constructed because, i:t.@;§!§ essence, it is a free theory. However, this simplicity breaks down c~:~;~~7ij1~~ when we analyze membranes in M-theory. We will find that the I~ is now quartic, making the quantization intractable. In contrast to the sinllp].ic~:m~ ity of string theory, there is still no satisfactory method for quantizing fte,~@m membranes.) As expected, we recover the leading Regge trajectory that we obtained earli~~:m*l from classical arguments, and also an infinite number of daughter tra,jectori~~:mi
2.2 Gupta-meuler Quantization
63
increasingly negative y-intcrccpl. In this gauge, the propagator or function takes on a simple form: K(a, b):;:: (Xul e- m • IX b )
=
r" Dxex p -jdad,!-I-(X! - X )1 , (2.2.16) lx. 41!'a' '2 /I
DX=
TITI dX'(u) = TI dX:. ,
0
(2.2. 17)
,."
careful to note that the functional integral over DX is an infinite over each point along the string,. or each Fourier mode of ;;'",I.y" this integration can be carried out cxplicitly. Let the particle , :;:: 0 to r = 00. Because the Hamiltonian is diagonal on the harmonic oscillators, we can perfonn the integration over 't: exactly.
(2.2.18) is the zeroth Fourier component of the Virasoro generators (2.1.28). ,"'or,ds, I,ro.pal,ator for the fn."C theory is
0'"
(2.2.1 9)
id"d brlwoo. stales of the string. However, becausc wc have the identity IX)
j
DX (XI = I
(2.2.20)
~:"'m.v<'"" l"lh integrals explicitly at every intermediate point between state. In fact. because of the simplicity of the N -point be able to remove all functional integrations over string states the hamlOnic oscillators. It is important to stress again oscillator fonnalism is nothing but a specific representation int(':l7"L liS simplicity is a consequence of the Hamiltonian being in the Fock space ofharmoni<': oscillator states. the same way, the closed SlI'ing can also be .....'fitten in terms of . oscillators. For the closed string, there is no X' = 0 boundary conwe can use both sine and cosine functions to decompose its normal Thu.<;, we expect twice the nllmb{~r (If (I!':cill~lOr!': for the closed string.
64
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
The oscillator decomposition is given by X/i(a)
I ( = xI' +"2et' )
1/2
~ 1 . rnrr ~ r,z(ane-
.
t .
t
.::
+ ane wa + ana rnrr + an e- l1Ia )/i
n=] V"
(2.2·4.~ J::W
P (a) = PI' I' 2IT
+
1
fJn(-iane-ina-ianeinrf+iateina+iiite'
2IT.J2(;i n= I n n n
The Hamiltonian for the closed string is
H= IT 12rr da (ex P; + 4:fex I
00
l )
-t- ) 2 + nana n + ex P w
( t = " ~ nanan
I
n=1
Again, the Fock space consists of all elements created out of harmonic oscii@ lators, but this "time there is an extra constraint that is not found for the nrii>m string:
(Lo - Lo) I¢} = O. (The interpretation of this constraint is that the closed string must be mdlep1ew. dent of the origin of the 0' -coordinate. For example, the operator f dO't>ia:(:Lo...;;tiiXED can be interpreted in two ways. First, it generates rotations in O'-space, so w.~ED average over a rotation of 2IT in a -space. Second, if we perform the i'Iltel¥~!~WI we have B(Lo - Lo), which is constraint (2.2.23) when applied to the H'.1lbj~m:~ space. We will return to this constraint later.) The Fock space consists of (see Fig. 2.4): tachyon
~
massless spin-2 ~
10>
IO} ,
aitlai" IO} ,
v, ,
k /I k a+/I i+PIO>
FIGURE 2.4. Regge trajectories for the closed string. The Fork space is of two commuting sets of hannonic oscillators. The massless spin-2 particle graviton, which corresponds to the product of both types of operators acting ontMM vacuum.
2.2 Gupta--BJeuler Quantization
6S
massless scalar ....... k"kllar"ar~ 10).
a massless spin-2 particle occurs in the speclruOl of che closod "n th:' "'fig model was first being interpreted as a model ofhadroos. of this gravilonlikc spin·2 particle was
II.
great embarr.lssment.
were made to associate this particle with the Pomeron trajectory . S-matrix theory. It can be shov.'t1 that, when we generalize to trees this OllIssless spin-2 particle has n gauge invariance equivalent to of Einstein's theory. By dropping the earlier interpretation of the th."y as a model ofhadrons, we find a natural place for £his gravilonlikc
graviton itself. ~:~~~~,t~h~:e, Gupla--Blculer formalism in the confonnal gauge appears ir mainJy because we arc allowing ghosts to appear throughtheory reduces to the simplest possible string theory, a free string. we must pay for this simplicity, however, is the imposition of the the Fock space. We ean writo the Virasoro generators as [til:
(2.2.25) 00
1.0 = .
..L,a_~/J.a~ + !a~
.
states of the theory must therefore satisfy Ln 14I} = 0. (L. - I) I ~ ) = O.
II >
0, (2.2.26)
generated by these operators is
[Ln. L .. J = (11
~
D , m)L,,-t .. + 12(n - n)1in._m ,
(2.2.27)
is the dimension of space-time. The fact that there is a c-number appearing in this equation at first sounds surprising, but this can ,1"IOd explicitly by taking the vacuwn expectation product of a simple
(OI(L,.
D
Ld 10) = '2'
(2.2.28)
of this e<:ntral tenn is that we normal ordered the generator 1.0 to matrix elements. This normal ordering was even found in the point in (1.8.7), exeept now the energy shift is infinite. The price we pay . elemenl.t i~· that locality in u is /0.1"/. The normal ordering spoils the generators I. f were originally local functions in 0'. The process
66
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
of quantization necessarily destroys the locality of Viras oro generators variable a, and hence the c-number central term occurs. Thus, the qwmt:Lzal\~QjjI$ scheme and regularization scheme used to extract finite information .. v.LU>'<1IU~ model are actually inconsistent with conformal symmetry. Fo:rtuJnat.el)';t1f1@i inconsistency can be eliminated if we fix the dimension of space-time t(j:ttiim 26. That there are ghosts in the theory is due to the fact that the zeroth cOlnp0Itl~U~1 ofthe harmonic oscillator has negative metric: ghost = {a,;,o} 10) . Thus, the coefficient of the Green's function occurs with a negative V~""~.'c.H,* addition, there are zero norm states and negative nonn states that must be taJ<~ into account. To analyze the spectrum, let us define a spurious state IS) to be oile th~rt"R orthogonal to all physical real states IR). Spurious states can be written
IS) = L_n Ix) ,
n > 0,
{RIS} = 0, for some integer n and some state Ix}. (If we take the matrix elemeqt onfifi~ state with a physical state, the scalar product always vanishes bel::aULse< destroys a physical state.) Now let us construct the spurious state:
It} = [L-2 + aL~tll
SPf:ctrUJjjI~
This fixes the following:
3 - 2a = 0,
!D - 4 - 6a = 0,
which, in tum, fixes D = 26,
3
a= 2'
Thus, this spurious state satisfies (2.2.26) and hence is part of the nh'vsilm: Fock space. At first, this seems disastrous. We want our physical Hilbert to be ghost-free. But notice that in 26 dimensions this state has zero norm: negative norm). Since 11) was arbitrary, we have constructed an infinite .. states It} that are simultaneously spurious and physical. If we take the no:rril;;!$l this higher-order state, we find that it also vanishes in 26 dimensions, ma~~iJa~ it a null spurious state. This state is still acceptable because the norm~:~~I~ state is nonnegative. Thus, in 26 dimensions we have an acceptable sJ for this set of states. Similar analyses of the state vectors of the theory show that a physical Ie) can be constructed which actually has negative norm if D is greater
2.3 Light Cone Quantization
18) = (aO"~J
67
+ bk . 0" _1 + c{k . Il'_J /) 10) .
L,18) = L 2 10) = 0, we find that b = a(D - 1)/5 and c 10. We find that the nOnn of the state is (Big) = i~a2(D - 1)(26 - D) . . dimension of space-time cannot exceed 26 or else negative norm as part ofthc physical states. In general, we find thallhe spectrum if the dimension ofspacc-{ime is Jess than or equal to 26: ghost-free:
I
a ~ I, a:::; 1.
D=26' j
D
~
25.
(2.2.34)
!",.,,;,;o was donc only for a picce of the Fock space.
But call ghosts 10 all orders in Lhc string model? We will return to the difficult ;~::~:o!~e, in Gupr.a-Bleliler formalism at the end oflhis ::, we actually construct the physical Hilbert space and show that negative norm states in 26 dimensions.
m;m,,;ou the
Cone Quantization the light cone gauge, where all unphysical degrees of fn.-cdom are removed from the very beginning, is possible because we have twO and hence two gauge-fixing conditions can be in. One of these gauge-fixing constraints can be the modes from the Hilbert space, as in the Coulom b of ghost states, which is quite involved for the see at the end of this chapter), becomes
light cone gauge. choose the notation
x+=
x-
~[XO+XD- ' J
= _1_ [Xo _ XLH }
-Ii
.
(2.3. 1)
(2.32) 0 11
which version of the action in (2.1.4I) we use, we will have constraints. lfwe Slart with the original Nambu-Got.o action. gauge conditions in tile path integra l arc
DX M t:.FP
n •
S(X+(u) - p+r)S(X!
+ x~ -
2XuX'I')e-s, (2.3.3)
68
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
where M is a measure term that must be added to have a unitary th~~orY";;aff&~ the two delta-functions represent the gauge-fixing constraints. The relltWl~ able feature of the second constraint is that the Nambu-Goto action, WhlCh::~ expressed as a highly nonlinear square root, completely linearizes [12)
/ X! X~ -
(XItX'It)2 "-'
~(X~
X~).
-
(Because the light cone action is no longer a square root, we have a . behaved action that can be canonically quantized.) .. The constraint X+ = p+. means that the a dependence within .. completely disappeared and that the "time" • now beats in synchronism w •. itiW, X+. We can use the second constraint, in turn, to eliminate the X.:. hence all longitudinal modes have completely disappeared. The action can. be expressed totally in terms of transverse ones. :: Next, we will solve the constraints in the first action in (2.1.41). "':"!'~,:_!,,)1 integrate over the Lagrangian multipliers p and ).. in the Hamiltonian tor~~ml the action, and then impose the gauge-fixing constraints:
Z=
f
DXDP
x8
IJ
o(X+(o') - p+.)8 (p+(o') -
(p; + ;;)
:+) (
8(Pp.x'JJ-)e- s.
Because the covariant Hamiltonian (2.1.13) is equal to zero, the only the Lagrangian is PItXp. (the X- term drops out): L =
1](
da PJJ-Xp. =
1](
da(P;Xi - p+ P-(a)).
There are several remarkable features to this formalism First, we can four, not two, constraints onto our Hilbert space, two from gauge fixin~~.~mrn two by integrating over).. and p. Second, because the covariant ~Utll11UUJ.lJ
H = p+ 111" da P-(o'). On the other hand, we can solve the constraint for P-: _
P (a)
=
11:
2p+
(2Pi + Xl) 1<2
•
Plugging the value for P- into the definition of the light cone (2.3.7), we now have
H =
r (p/ + 1<~X2)
"21< Jo
dO'
HamiLt6i~m
2.3 Light COOO Quantization
69
just the Hamiltonian (2.2. 12) defi ned over physical cransvcrse
we can also eliminate the X- modes by solving another constraint: PI'X'1l = 0
(23.1 0)
be solved for X-. yielding X-(u)
~
1" •
du'-"-l P,X;J. p'
(2.3.11)
"" rytJhing together, our functional now becomes Z =
f
D X j DPj ;/dr!d<1CI',X,-H).
(2.).12)
the light cone Hamiltonian density. The great advantage of the light
is that the Vinssoroconsrraints have beeD explicitly solved. so there to impose them on Slates. All + modes have been gauged away from the - modes have been el iminated in Icnns of transverse stales Virnsoro conditions have been solved exactly through (2.3.8) and "",,,d of imposing the Virasoro constraints on the Hilbert space, we
them exactly and eliminate the - modc1:i. the great disadvantage of the fonnaJism is that we must tediously Lo" nl2 inY'Miance at each step of the calculation. Normally, the of the Lorentz group arc given by
MPv =
1"
dO'[X" P'" -
xv P" ) (2.3.13)
[0 eheck from (2.2.7) Ihat this satisfies tbe correct commutation for the Lorentz group:
[M"", M"'''J = ;11"" M'"
+ ....
(2.3.14)
Lorent2. invariancc has to he checked once again in light of the fnc t "~::~:~;,tl; all ghOSt modes. Most ofthe commutators are trivial to el
Ihcyare linear. The troublesome term comes from X -. which and is written as
x- =.c '
~
+ p -. + i L 11
,,0
I
_tr;e- JIIr cos na,
(2.3.15)
/I
(2.3.16)
70
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
and a is the intercept. All commutators are easily calculated, except one involving X-. The calculation, which is lengthy and must be pelrfOl~iU carefully, yields the final answer: [M- i , M-j] = p
}2 f)Q'~nQ'~ - Q'~nQ'~]lln, n=l
where
II = n
~(26 12
D) + ~n [D -1226 + 2 - 2a] .
For this commutator to vanish, we must have D =26,
a=1.
This fixes both the dimension of space-time D and the intercept a model. .
2.4
BRST Quantization
(
As in the point particle case, the BRST quantization method starts Faddeev-Popov quantization prescription and then extracts out a new IJ.Jll.Jl,I~ symmetry operator. The action is invariant Wlder a reparametrization (2.1;$!~1 ogah = gacobovc + o"OV c gel> = 'ilaOVb + 'ilbOva
-
gabOc OVc
(the second line has been written covariantly and contains twl)-djmem>IQi~ Christoffel symbols). This allows us to impose the gauge constraint: gab = Oab. This, in turn, generates a Faddeev-Popov determinant: ..0..FP
= det(Va) =
det('il;J det(Vz}.
This determinant can be calculated by exponentiating it into the ""T,nn do this, we must introduce anticommuting ghost fields b and c (see (l As before, these ghost fields make it possible to place the det.ernninanl:9~iji derivative in the exponential. Let us define z = -r + iu; then:
L =:rr1 (IIazx/J.azx/J.
- ). + baze + bazc
Notice that this action is invariant Wlder
oX/J. = s[cazx/J. DC = s[eazc], DC = S[COiC],
+ COiX/l]'
2.4 BRST Quantization
71
!Jb = t:[ca,b + 2fJocb - -l8, X p oz X lL j, -
-
-
I
ob = elcui: b + 2a:cb o
:'
•
•
2ai X",a~ X"1.
variation end ( 1.9.8), we can extract out the niJpotcnI BRST opHowever, it is also important to nOle that in gcnernl, given any with commutation relations p."" ). . . ! = f! . . )...p. it is possible 10 a nilp'''"' operator Q [10] oul of anti commuting operators e" and 00
Q~
L ,-. lA. -l/!.,-.b,j.
(2.4.6)
ft"'~OO
Ie" , b",l = 0. . .-""
(2.4.7)
.ST· O~"""o,can be wrineo in this form:
I
00
- a)
+ L[c_~L . . + L_"c.. J - '2 ",.1
L ....... 00
:c_ .. C_ ... b"T",:(m - n).
=-«1
(2.4.8)
equals the X -dependent VlI1lsoro genemlOr, and L~' is the ghost
~::;~~i~~::f:t:;~~~~1~:;,~:!~th~c;re~~are two unspecified parameters
and the dimension of spac~ should be zero:
Vll)ue the square o f Q,
(2.4.9) vanish, we [Dust fix the dimension of spaco-timc to be 26 and me to be equal to I. point particle case, we find thai the physical states of the theory
by
Q Iphy) = O.
(2.4. 10)
'CO"P'''''tc ()"' the modes, we find that the lowest !.1 ate satisfies
o. L. I.) ~ o.
( L , - 1)10)
~
(2.4. " )
72
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
2.5
Trees
So far we have quantized only free strings. The interaction of strings can;:~ determined either through functional methods or through harmonic V"'''H''~.'PJ:~ methods. Of the two, functional methods are by far the more powerfuL we can view the hannonic oscillator method as just one specific ref're!;entatJi~ of the functional method. For trees and even the first loop, oscillator me:tnmi: provide a fast and convenient method of calculating the amplitudes, higher loops the oscillator method rapidly becomes impractical. The tuncPO!Ul method, because of its vast versatility, can always be used either to deiive:1 oscillator method for trees and the first loop, or to derive all loops. Historically, the dual model was first discovered accidentally as a "l"""'+~. amplitude for the scattering oftachyons. These amplitudes possessed a rm;n!iii able property called duality, meaning that they could be factorized in tep'!:® s-channel poles or t-channel poles. (This duality between sand t Chfll1Il;¢l$;=Jfi entirely different from the duality that we will find in M-theory.) V.-,'HlH the theory of point particles, the Feynman diagrams sum the s- and t-c.ti@~ poles separately (see Fig. 2.5), but the dual amplitudes already posisessedp'4~ in both channels for the s- and t -channel poles separately. For more QOlnpll~~tij diagrams, we see that the same N -point amplitude could be factorized number of ways. Because the counting of these diagrams was not the . counting of Feynman diagrams, for years it was erroneously believed . true field theory interpretation of the dual model was not possible. Following the analogy with the point particle case, let us begin by detmu the N -point scattering amplitude for tachyon scattering [11-13]:
X 6.FP
exp
[i f L drY dr (D .;g exp(ik'.1l X
- IOP~e.! f dfL(D.;gexP{iki.IlXlli)). Dgab
This expression will be the fundamental path integral from which derive the theory of interacting strings. It will be the single most imlJott:a formula in the firSt quantized formulation. In the expression, momentum k i from the i th tachyon flows into the b01ltiq~ of the surface at a point Zi. The string variable X III is defined at that Zi on the boundary where momentum k i flows into the diagram. The mea&'Pl of integration d fL is an integral over the various Zi, which we will det,e~~ shortly.
,
,
3
H ,
z~
4
=1
.
I
2.5 Tree!;
73
3
4
-, '. '
•
Z1 •
00
- ' - -a Duality of the Veneziano model. The four-point amplitude carl be in tcmlS of either s-chnnncl or t-channel poles. This is in contrast 10 particle field theory, which sums over both .f- and t-channcl poles, i the N-point function. I'or this reason, il was once a field theory of strings was impossible. A field theory of strings would by overcounting, especially at higher orders. ;Xp",,,;ion:silnplifi1;:.'j wl1:siderably
i fw~
lakt: Iht: I.:uuformal gaug::. In
f f 4:':' !(a,xlI.a~X!l)d21. + t X" I L J (fI ,,,,.x) , dp.
DX exp (
dlJ.
1(I!)010fI1..
i
k,I'
(2.5.2)
I~ 1
we show how to simplify the string intemction diagram. By letting interaction length to go to zero for the external tacbyons, wc see that interaction surface can be reduced to an infinite horizontal strip in plane, extending from a _ 0 to a = :rT and 't _ ..too. that the action, althougb it is no longer reparametrization invariwe have fixed gab = 8"b, is still conformal ly invariant. Thus, to of conformRlly equivalent surfaces, we will take t.he set of we rnustsum to be lhe SCI ofall cOlljomwlly inequivalent I complex surfaces.
74
2. Nambu--Goto Strings
tu F
G
I
H
J
u=lI'
1'_
c
D
B
z = e T + io
l
FIGURE 2.6. Conformal surfaces for open string propagation. In the P-~:~:'~;l~1 surface over which a string propagates is a horizontal strip of width rr. Tl)e lines at the bottom corresponds to "zero width" strings or external tachyons. z-plane, the surface becomes the upper half complex plane. The mapping from;l~~m surface to the other is given by the exponential. Let the world sheet of the N -point tree be a horizontal strip of width extends horizontally in the complex plane. The x-axis corresponds to r an4H~[OOr, y-axis corresponds to a. Let us now change coordinates to complex
z=
eT+;cr.
This mapping takes this infinite strip, which describes the world sheet interacting string (with zero width tachyons), into the upper half of the cOlnp!t~ plane. Fortunately, the functional integral is a Gaussian that can be evallua.ted;~i.~m the identities presented in the previous chapter. Let us define Xc\.ssical solution to the classical equations of motion: 2
V X!"cl
= -2i:rra'JI1 •
where N
JI1 (z) =
L k;JLll(z -
z;).
;=1
where Z; are points on the real axis of the complex plane that COlTe!;polnd external zero width tachyons interacting with the string. After a Wick ro~~t@m
2.5 Trees
7S
' variable, this is just Poisson's equ8lion for electrostatics. To solve this, the Green'5 function:
(2.5.6) calculate the Green's func tion, with NeumarUl boundary conditions, ! f!::;~C~,Th~':le~;a~S;iest way to calcuillte this is to bOiTOW n trick '~:~ 0 namely the method of images. Let us place ~t at the point z' in the upper half-plane. CotlSidcr another point the point that is symmetricaUy reflected through thc x-axis; half-plane. If we are silting on a point charge l ill lhe upper then the pol(.:n tial at thnt point is proportional to
z'
zt
0(%. z,) = In II'.: -ll ce~~:;:i !fwe (5
+ In It - tl.
(2.5.7)
arc sitting on the x-axis so that z is real, then the derivative
function nonnal to the x-axis is zero. Thus, these boundary 8re precisely what we want, so (by the uniqueness theorem) this is function for the upper half-plane. now insen this Green 's function back inlo the integral. The classical that solves (2.5.4) is
Xd = -hi ! G(r, z') J(z' )dz:
(2.5.8)
make a shift in the integration variable:
X,. -+ X,. .d + X,..
(2.5.9)
,",.,,,,fo,',, that the functional imegra[s can be performed using (1 .7. 10):
/ DXCXP { - 4;a, j iI:X,.iltX"d2 Z+i ! J"X 1' d1Z }
{~
= cxp
=
IT
!
J,.(z )O(z. l )JI'(r'} dz dl' }
exp (a'k! . k j in IZi
- i:jl j
i'l-J
=
n
Iq - lj]2«'!, ... / ,
(2.5.10)
'
]I'(z) =
L)(z -
zj)k/'.
/ '~"";ng tog,clh "
in (2.5.11). we fi nd (2.5. 11 )
.
76
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
(Notice that we have explicitly removed the "self-energy" term for i which would be divergent. We can truncate the integral and still maintamtll' conformal properties of the theory. We will find that this truncation have to be performed in the harmonic oscillator method.) . Now we must complete the last step, which is to fix the measure d fJ.. • . :: Our first guess is that, when the amplihIde is expressed in terms of <..;;. •: ·n .... measure is simply equal to one. This is the correct choice that is cOlnp:at with conformal invariance. To prove it, recall that earlier we said sum over all conformally inequivalent surfaces. Consider the set OfCOllf(jwR transformations that map the upper half-plane into itself, such that the <""<.""11 is mapped into itself. In general, the points on the real axis that are into each other transform under a subset of the conformal projective or Mobius transformations: I
y =
ay +b
ey+d
for real a, b, c and d such that ad - be = 1. This set offour parameters a real matrix with unit determinant:
In general, the group defined by the set of all real 2 x 2 matrices unit determinant is SL(2, R). Notice that this group of transformations c~~.; generated by making successive transfonnations:
y ---+ y + b, y ---+ ay, 1
Y---+ -.
Y Thus, we wish the amplitude, including the contribution of the me:asure il~~~~ projectively invariant. Let us make a projective transformation on the integrand to see transforms:
I1(ZI - Zj)2a'k,.k j = [1(z; - zjfa'krk j i <}
i <j
fl(a - CZD2. k
We want our measure to cancel out the noninvariant term in the above sion. Let us take our measure to be the number 1 and the integration regtQij: be fixed by Zi > Zi+t. Then there is one last complication. We must " ... t~:.:~~ the gauge" for projective transformation or else we will have oVlercoUJ[ltiI1g;:~~ must integrate once and only once over each projectively distinct COlrIDIM·?M of the Zi variables. If the external momentum flows into the upper hal.f·pl~@gl points given by Zi, then we are allowed to fix three of these points at ra~r~~fi This corresponds to "gauge fixing" the projective invariance, which self:q~:~
2.5 Trees
77
loj,,,,;.voly inequivaiem paramctrizations. Our final resull is d
- 8(41 - 4i+ 1)
IJ.-
dV
~b<'
n" d 4/.
(2.5.16)
i_I
have explicitly removed the contribution ITom the three fixed points (2.5. 17) are Ihrccpoints that can be randomly chosen on the real axis. Notice ~ve fixed three variables so that we only integrate over projectively "" "m configurations. (If we integrated over these three variables. we overcounting of the integration region. We could be integmting ,:~;~~nwnbcr of copies oflhc same thing.) :.5 choices for the three fixed points are Zl
= 1.
1.N ==
(1.5.18)
O.
(o"fig"",rio, . our final result for the N-poinl ampl itude becomes [14-
(2.5.19) region of int~gration is 00
==
XI ::: 41
==
I ::: Z)· • '1.H_1 ~ IN
== O.
(2.5.20)
final result fo r the N -point amplitude, which we derived using .cti,,,oll techniques. summarize what we have done:
~
~:t.i~~~:~~,~;;;~I:,~,~gt:h~S~,~o~:b:~e was zeroaforhorizontal the external so the striptachyons, in the complex has width 1T. Momentum ITom the external tachyons flowed into at designated points along the real axis 1./ (see Fig. 2.6). a conformal transformation from the strip to the upper half explicitly solved for the Neumann function, which we using a trick from electrost(ltics, thc method of images. invariance fixed the measure of integration to be the number I. the external points z, > ZI+I' the gauge" lefl over from projective transformations; i.e .. we three of the N points of the integrand.
1e,;O,,, e'p,,,,,;;,)n for the N -point amplitude (2.5. 19) considered only : with external tachyons entering the world sheet al selected points on
78
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
the boundary. In principle, we can have particles with arbitrary spin boundary. For higher spins, we have the same factor e1k-X, which Ten·Tf'"i>i;i!; part of the Fourier transfonn, multiplied by the polarization tensor of the spins. Thus, the vertex function for the tachyon is not actually elk-X, is universal for all spins because it is part of the Fourier transform. The ... vertex for the tachyon is actually just the number 1. Spin-2 vertices can be represented as
V = ..;gg"bauX"abXve"viki"X~, where e"v is the polarization tensor. For the general case:
V
2.6
1u' __ -gU2."-l U2.,,j)a = '\Ir;:;gg([a 0
121
XI'I
.•• t
a X" 2m e J.iL ..... 1J.2I1J elk~X~.
'122111
From Path Integrals to Operators
We used functional methods to calculate the N -point scattering ampli1tud,e; only nontrivial part of the calculation was the integration over COI[lfq,rml3.nY:~ii equivalent two-dimensional complex surfaces, which determined of integration of the amplitude. The same calculation can also be performed using the harmonic V''''U~J~M formalism, which, as we have stressed, is nothing but a particular rep,re\ilm.i:1 tation of the path integral for which the Hamiltonian is diagonal. For and the first loop, the harmonic oscillator method is quite simple be(~aus~::1~ Hamiltonian is diagonal on the Fock space of the harmonic oscillators .... : ever, for higher loops this is no longer true: the harmonic oscillator mc;~OOn becomes increasingly difficult and impractical. The path integral methc)d:tl:iUll~ provides the only systematic way in which to analyze the higher-loop tudes with relative ease. (The calculation of anomalies, however, is eas,i~~jm the harmonic oscillator formalism, where the integer index n serves as off for the theory. In the path integral formalism, we must use [email protected] techniques and other regulators, as we shall see in Chapter 5.) In the functional fonnalism, we know that the propagator for free stri!j~t. given by
(X" I {'XJ dU- TH IX b} = (Xu I I 1 IX!>} . Loo
J
Similarly, we also know that, by inserting a complete set of intl;:ml~~!* states within the path integral, the vertex function for the i th tachyon
(Xu I elki~xl' IXb} , where
X~
= X,,(a = 0, < =
2.6 From Patb Integrals to Operators
IXI
J
DX(XI
=
79
I
;r~:~~:~:~a:~,;,;~f;:: from the N -point function and make the tTan-
the
~
oscillatOr
formal ism to harmonic formalism. ":~~li~ l e~'l~us with the path integral expression for the N-point ~ and make the substitution to harmonic oscillators:
= =
=
J f !
= /
DX dl.Le- s
" e"t,X(~) n ,-.
dJLe - s { ... i
k / xlf;)
IXi )
f
D Xi (X
j! c itH,X(r, . d ... }
dJ1, {... eltiXlOl jx ,) / DX J (X J! e-(" ~ '- 'IIHe'k,., XIO)._ }
n, dr,
(O, k,f elklX(Ole-i', HelkJ X(O)"' !O,kN)
= (0, kd V(kl}DV(k ))··· V (kN _1 )!O, kN)' points in this derivation must be clarified. First, in the path integral we found that we had [0 omit the i = j contribution to tbe inte(2.5.10). Similarly, we also have to truncate the harmonic oscillator . The expression for the vertex function (2.6.2) is fortllaUy infinite convert to harmonic oscillators. For example, if we naively take the ~_ex!pc"~ '; O~ value of the exponential, we arrive at a divergent sum. ordered. expression is the one we desire. which has finite matrix . Let us exponemiate (2.2. 11): ; exp ik /"X"/ (0" = O.
T/)
:= exp
X
(k.f (X;~ e ,
exp
..
1n
"
1it ~(1.)
(-k .f: :. ,-;'" "-.
I.
(2.6.4)
ordering consists of moving all creation (desttuction) operators to the - so that the resulting operator has fini le matrix elements.} in the transition from path integrals 10 operators we used the fact . '" Hamiltonian is the generator oft" !;hifts. The expression Lo - I acts as . Hamiltonian for horizontal displacements in the complex plane. lind the following formul a useful: yLo f (•• )y -Lo
fu ••";on
f.
Thus, we
= f( •• y - ·)
(2 .6.5)
can define
y 4 Vo(k;)y - LI = V(k y, = ~-"). "
(2.6.6)
80
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
We used this expression in the transition from path integrals to narmofmc<9:~~ dilators when we converted the vertex function at 1:i to the vertex the origin. Third, in our derivation ofthe hannonic oscillator formalism we intJ'Odll¢m the vacuum state 10, k). Notice that the functional formalism started w;:~~I~ world sheet of the interacting strings being an infinite horizontal strip ][ in the complex plane. The external lines were placed along the real ~~~I Therefore the effect of a string coming in from negative (positive) ir"rliTIlity .@;~~ responds to the functional integral over a semi-infinite strip. Thus, the va(:u~ijit.~ state 10) is the functional integral of the string theory over a semi-infinite sfi'iPm~ We can represent the tachyon vacuum with momentum k as:
of
10; k) =
kx -
i
10; 0) ,
where
n > O.
cr:n 10; 0) = 0,
Putting everything together, we can now convert the path integral to naImCIJ;tlj! oscillator form:
An =
f dIL J
DXe-s
D N-I
dZ i exp[ikiXfLi(a = 0;
= (0; kll VO(k 2)D VO(k 3)D ... DVo(k N -
1)
.in
10; kN)
•
It is important to realize that the harmonic oscillator expression is a consequence of the functional formalism. Fortunately, this amplitude is easy to calculate. As an exercise, let us calculate the four-point function explicitly: A4
= (O;kll V(k 2 )DV(k3 ) IO;k4 } =
=
r' dxx
10
10
k3 4 1 • -
{Ol exp (-k2 .
f
cr:n
n=1
n
I
x R exp (k3 .
1
dxx-{l/2)s-2(1 _
X)-O/2)1-2
r( -cr:(s))r( -cr:(t)) r( -cr:(s) - cr:(t)) = B( -cr:(s) , -aCt)),
where a(s) = 1 + ~s,
s = -(kl
+kd,
t = -(k2 u = -(kl
+ k3i, + k3)2,
f
n=1
cr:-
n
n
)10).:: .:
2.6 From Path Integrals to Operators
81
iil:~~~:~l_ ~::'I":::~~~~~~":IlIflplitude R is the number operator: R = L:: Ina!an. ~ :' four-point hn.s an elegant form. In fact, it can ;",.,",,00 as tbe Eu ler fWlction. This Beta fWlclion bas fnscinating properties tha t first excited the imagination of high-energy theorists -' -late 1960s. It was discovered by G. Vcne7.iano and M. Suzuki quite by as they were looking for a way in which to satisfy fmite energy sum the badronic S-matrix.. At lhat time. theorists wanted to construct a ~_:~~::~",~e for hadrons thai had the following ofG. Chew's criteria
· IIUSI";~
theorists sometimes added;
A(s. t) ....., s«(')
(2.6.12)
large s and fixed I, and also ~wllity,
i.e., (2.6.13)
of "axioms"
the hadronic S-matrix "''as so large that physicists
the
ever be satisfied. Then,through when a math Eulerbook, Beta discovered wbile thumbing ;:~:;~;:e~'hl~'~'~\~LCOUld
gSI"ling',
were surprised thRt this analytic function satisfied axioms! For example, Regsc behavior can be s hown by approximation on the r function; r(x):::.:
x'
..fii .,;;e-x.
(2.6.14)
can also be shown by evaluating the poles of the integrand near the of integration x = 0 and x = 1:
) +' ;...:02),-'_"",('"('",)..:+-,,,-n) A(.f,t} ..... -1 -'('_"('",)..:+...:1,,,)(,,'(,,-'" n! a(s) - n
(2.6. 15)
mil" ,ex"","i,>" exists for the r-<:hannel poles. In fact, aU the postulates first, unitarily. can be satisfied. (Unitarily is violated for the simple On":~tthe ana[ytie SlrUcture of the ampJirude is a series of poles in s· f A true Wlitary amplitude. however, should also havc imaginary ,instead ofpoJesand cuts along the real axis, as wcshall sec in Chapter 5). . operator methods, we can now solve for the N -point function.
the
82
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
z,=oo
ZN=O
FIGURE 2.7. The N-point function. Projective invariance allows us to fix thr~ee~1t.: the N variables. The most convenient parametrization is to take the first vaIiabl~;~~ be 00, the second to be 1, the last to be 0, and all the others to be ordered betweJ.~.~H
and O. The N -point amplitude can be written as (see Fig. 2.7):
AN = (O;kll V(k2 )D ... V(kN_1}IO;k N) IN-1dX.
=
joo 0-.' (O;kd V(k ;=3
2,
1)V(k3,Y3)V(f4'Y4) .. ·V(kN-l'e'N-dlV~:~!Nti2
Xl
(2. v..',.•" " _
where
fi 1=3
dXj
=
dyj ,
1=3 YI
XI Yj
n
=
X3 X4"
·Xj.
(Notice that we commuted the factors ofX R to the right, until they amllhl.lat~~i;I:~itm the vacuum.) This expression can most easily be simplified using the COlile,~¢~ state formalism. Let an arbitrary state of the Fock space be represented
L 00
II.) =
n=O
}..n - I (atr
10) = e~aj 10) .
n.
Then we have {J.LI}..} xuta
= ell· ...
I}..} = Ix}..) ,
elLut II.) = I}.. + J.L} • By using these identities in succession, we find
2.6 From Path lnlcgrals 10 Operators
83
find the same expression for the N-point function (2.5. 19) that we using functional methods:
(2.6.21)
. ::
y's are ordered along the real axis as befort. Notice that we have fixed the values nfthree pornES along the real axis to be 0, t, and 00,
. ~,a.
oscillator methods, we can show that the N-point fimction is cydi-
'.r~~~~~i)'W~lhiCh is not obvious when we write the amplilUde as the ~ D V D V. We use the following identity, which expresses
"ppe'" when two vertices arc pushed past each other: Yl) V(kl. )'2)
= V(k2.)'2) V(k" yJ) exp[2ct'1r ik j • k J6(YI - n)l. (2.6.22)
= I if x > 0 IUlde(x) = -I if x < O. have to rewrite the vacuum 10; kN) in a fann where it resembles vertices, so we can calculate the properties ofthc amplitude under a '..,,,,,ng.,menl of the vertices. We wili usc the following identities:
tim VI' . y) 10;0) ~ 10;k).
,..., y Hm (O;OlyV(k . y)~ (k;OI.
(2.6.23)
J~""
in this fashion, the tachyon states at the extreme right and left arc no ...ted unsymmetrically from the others. The vertex 011 the right is now a! O. and the vertex on the left is defined at 00, and all other vertices ,:w,i lhi' n that interval. when we push the Nth vertex completely around the amplitude, we (V(k"
yJl ... V(k N• YN» = ( V(kN, YN)V(k l. y,) . . . V(k .... _h YN-d) x exp [2Cli1fkN.
I:kiE ,., ].
(2.6.24)
. :: : !hal the last factor vanishesNif we have t:onsen-arioa of momentum:
L: k; ~ O. ,-, uscdtheon-shell co ndiliona'k~
(2.6.25)
= I . We sec that only on-
an amplitude that is cyclically symmetric. (Historically, this reason why pbysicists believed that a field theory of strings was not possible. A field theory, by definition, is an off-shell fonnulation, marvelous features of the Veneziano model worked only on-shell .)
84
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
2.7
Proj ective Invariance and Twists
In addition to cyclic symmetry, we saw that the integrand of the N-n.m . 'fd: function was also Mobius invariant; i.e., the function remains the same '. make the following change of variables:
y' =
ay+b , ey+d
where
ad - be = 1. We showed Mobius invariance in the functional formalism. Now let us {l:'~!I a Mobius transformation directly on the hrumoruc oscillator matrix ele'lIie)~~
(O; 01 V(k t , Yt) ... V(kN. YN) 10;0) Yt YN
= (O;OI V(kt;
YD ... V(k Y~) 10;0) N
,'
YN
Yt
Il(a _
ey;}2.
1=1
(
As we saw earlier, this factor, in turn, can be canceled by the trallsti)m18,~~~
in the measure
It turns out that we can actually calculate the generator of these infilnhesQUiji transformations on the vertex function. Not surprisingly, the generator Mobius transformations will be the Vrrasoro generators. Let us define ... :< ::::::m~: T = 1-
6
Lan L n, n
z=
Z'
+6 L
anZ n+ 1.
n
Then TV(k" Zj)T- 1
= (1 - sa'k; ~ nanZR) V(k j , z;},
(Ln. V(kj,z,)] =zn [z:z +nalkl] V(kj,z,). We say that the vertex V has conformal weight equal to a ' k~. (The COl1lIOrm weight will play an important part in the proof that the string model is g' !l~~m free. In Chapter 4, we will explain the origin of the conformal weight, wl:llitfi~ labels irreducible representations of the conformal group generated .. Virasoro Ln. For a vertex function to be properly defined, it must have lon-shell, which is true for the tachyon.)
2.' Projective lnvllriancc and Twists
. the
85
L~
generate conformal transformations when I:Icting on the ver. In tact, we can show tha t a specific representation of the Virasoro
conforma l fields is given by
Ln = ~i'+ 1 0,. "'",nt.ti()O satisfies the definition afthe conformal algebra in (2.2.27) central term) and generates conformal transformations in functions variable :c:. in the subgroup ofthe conformal transformations that maps inlo itself and the real axis into itself. i.e., the projective ': ", This subgroup is generated by only 1..,1> L _h Lo, which generates
(2.7.7)
easily calculate the transformation of a vertex function induced by ea L,
V(y)e-
= V[y(l - ayr- l ].
ebLOV(y)e-t>1.o = V[e"'y ). d
e
. 'V(y)e- cL ,
=
V(y
(2.7.8)
+ c).
element ofSL(2. R), then we also have .
U 10;0) ~ 10;0).
... .
(2.7.9)
" . this might seem surprising, because we know that real states are ",' by L" for positive, nOI negative, integers n . However, 10; 0) is not It is annihilated by L_I because LI IO;O) ...... O:o· Q"_ I IO;O} =0
(2.7.10)
Q"o 10; 0) = O. Thus. 10; 0) corresponds to the true vacuum of the
Igroul', which is not a real Slate of the theory. When we multiply 10; 0) it becomes a real stale (because x has commutation relations with is annihilated by Lit for positive,,). everything together. we have {o; 01 V-I U Vek l . yd ... V(kN. YN) V-I YI YN
~
u 10; 0)
(0;01 VI',';': ) ... VI'",' J'N) 10;0) )"1
"P
YN
fIca - cy:J'
(2.7.11)
1", [
(2 . 7.3). the ViI"asoro gauge group, one other feature ofsiring theory is totally in the point particle case, and that is the "tw:ist" operator. Remember
86
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
that a string sweeps out a two-dimensional world sheet, not just a srnlgl~:lil~Q:il1 Thus, if we were to twist the world sheet, a topologically inequivalent Wl1iilfiit sheet would be swept out. At the first loop level, for example, this is the cniiiif~ topological difference between a disk with a hole and a Mobius strip. A simple expression for the twist operator [20] can be derived observation that a vertex function located on the real axis should cOllVertiJliii: a vertex function located on the top of the strip:
n
Q,V(CT
= n")n- I = V(a = 0).
Notice that the only change in the vertex function under this tra1l1st~orniilitia is that every oscillator at the nth level is multiplied by (-l)u. Thus, the.: . operator must b e < . Q,
= (_l)N+I,
where 00
N=
L a-nlLa~ .
l
n=l
Notice that this satisfies
as it should. This establishes the twist operator up to an overall sign. HOlwe~yjm since N even states are charge conjugation even and N odd states are odd Il·ri.'.;if!iil C, this fixes the value of Q, that we have chosen in the expression. There is an equivalent method of obtaining the form of the twist Opf~rii!~~@ Notice that the action of the twist operator on a tree is to reverse the ori.en1i~tt~~ of the extemallines (see Fig. 2.8) Q, Vo(k J )DVo(k2) ... Vo(k N -,) ]0; kN)
=
VO(kN)D Vo(kN-d ... VO(k2) ]
Notice that the cyclic ordering of the tree has been reversed by the erator. To extract the operator that will perform this reversal, let us first ... 1
2
N-l
N
N
1
2
N-l
NN-l
2
1
FIGURE 2.8. Action ofthe twist operator. The twist operator twists the factorize!l!:r@i~ which is equivalent to flipping the entire diagram upside-down. By duality, ho\~ei7.m:l we can always rewrite the diagram in the original configuration (with ext.ernlaffii§? renumbered).
2.8 Closed Strings
&7
"",,;00 in tenns of y variables: Q
f TI
dYI Vo(k J, Yl)'" Vo(k".. y,..) 10;0),
(2.7.17)
take the limit as Yl --) I and y". -~ O. written in this fashion, we now see that we can reverse the cyclic end interchange YI and YN by a change of variables: y:=I-y/.
wish to write down an opemlor tbat will pcrfonn this change of Previously, we wrote dOWIl the generators of SL(2. R} that will a projective transformation on a vertex function. By examining this - -' of variables, we easily find that the Mist operator mlL"! he given by Q
= (_I}Re- L.,.
(2.7.18)
'O~:l~~'~~,~two forms of the twist operator seem totally different, they arc y on-shell. Since the Veneziano amplirudc is strictly on-shell, the freedom of choosing either form of the twist operator.
.osed Strings our discussion has been specific to open strings. where the external attacb themselves to the endpoints of the conformal SlTip swept out string. Poles cOlerge in the Veneziano model when two points lj and the edge of the strip come close together. Let us now analyze tbe model, which is based on closed rather than open strings I . III a path inlegmllaken on the lull!:: (or sphere) swept out by a The pole structure of this model is much larger than the original because external sl ate..~ can attach themselves anywhere of the tube as it moves in spacIHime [21 J: ::
t u) _
:::: '
'.
- r[ - ~(a(l)
r( - !a(s»)r(-!a(t) f( - !a(u)) 1
2
2
+ a(u»)]r[ -f(n-(u) + a{s»)Jr[ -~(a(s) + aCt))]"
9··1)
,"erio". unlike the earlier Veneziano function, bns poles simuhaneall three channels, rather than j ust two channels. This was quickly aI,,,,d to the N -point fWlction: (2.82)
(2.8.3 )
88
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
As in the case of the Veneziano function, the poles in this amplitude emLe~m;1 when two variables Zi and Zj come close together, except now the poles¢.:~~I occur anywhere in the complex plane, not just on the real axis. Our starting point for the quantization of the closed string is (2.2.21), wn.em we decompose the string X/l(a) and its conjugate into normal modes. canonical commutation relations remain the same as (2.2.7), which leads . Hamiltonian given in (2.2.22). As in the open string case, we can fac;torizc;:».i:~em amplitude into vertices and propagators in the harmonic oscillator tbrma.lis1w.~ but now several important differences emerge: (1) We now have two sets of mutually commuting harmonic oscillators a" . ~ii4~W 0:" to sum over, rather than just one set as in the open string case. (2) The Vrrasoro conditions now consist of two sets of conformal' geller.at~fK:S~ Ln and Ln acting on the physical states:
L" 1¢} =
L" I¢} =
0, (Lo - 1) I¢} = (La - 1) I¢) =
o.
(3) We must integrate over all shifts in a, because the closed s~~~,~:~.~~~~ should be independent of where we chose the origin of the a Cl (4) The amplitude is not just the sequential product of vertices and pn)pagat:drsOO Because external lines can occur anywhere in the complex plane, we sum over all different orderings of the external lines. . (5) Fixing the vertex function to have weight 1 and using the anomaly caniC;~~~ lation argument show that the intercept for the closed string model be 2 and a'k2 = 2, meaning that the theory necessarily contains the nul;~~ less graviton. In fact, the linearized genern1 covariance gauge syrnmleft~ of genern1 relativity simply emerges as the lowest-order Vrrasoro gatlg¢ symmetry (we will expand on this in Chapter 7). Let us begin by discussing the propagator:
D = _1_ ( zLo-2zLo-2d2z 2Jr J1d :5.1 sin Jr(Lo - La)
Jr(Lo -
Lo)
1
Lo
- + La
2
This actually has a simple physical interpretation. Notice that the tactor the inverse L's simply is the usual propagator of a closed string. The HUIIJLlI.I;'""WA involving the sines, however, is equal to zero unless
Lo =
La.
This, in tum, can be represented as
f
dO' exp[i2JrO'(Lo -La)].
2.8 Closed Strings
8.
t,
,
C D
F
,
C
8
A
D
0-
8
2lf
,-
A
C A
2.9. Confonnal surfuee~ for closed stri ng propagation. In the p-plane, the D~,.~~:,r::~~,<;,~(]'n a horizontal s!rip of width 2", such that the upper and lower h i ' identified with each other. whieh is topologically equivalent to . In eontrast to the open string case, the cxlcmallincs attaeh themselves 10 ~:';:;;;;,,;D,;f:the surface, nol the boundllf)'. In the "plane, this $urface IMPS 10 the ~I plane by the exponential map.
are two ways 10 interpret this operator. If we explicitly perform thc oS'' ', we have the operator &(Lo - La), which is a projection operator on the ful l Hilbert space lhat eliminates states I¢) which do not satisfY - La) 14') = O. Second, we notice that this operator is the generator of roo";o" by one fun cycle, so that the propagator simply expresses the fa ct closed string moves, we must integrate over one fu ll cycle. The c losed . is therefore independent ofwhcrc we chose the origin of the . (This constraint w ill !\ave important consequences when discuss the compactification of the closed string and the heterotic s tring in chapters.) Fig. 2.9, we see that the world sheet originally consists of a horizontal in the complex plane that is 211" in width, soch that the top and bottom are identified with each other (creating a long horizontal rube ). External 'h;,;~;,~t;;,n~es entcr this tube intcrna1ly. We see that by exponentiating these !O we can transform this horizontal tube into the entire complex . Extcmallines then couple [0 all pointS within the plane.
can
90
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
As before, the vertex function is once again given by :e ikX :, where the Str~o;~ X is defined at the point in the complex plane where the external m()ml;:nt].li;jjt:~ is entering. Because the two sets ofbarmonic oscillators commute, the veliWii=m function factorizes into the product of two open string vertex functions. final expression for the N -point scattering amplitude of tachyons is given •.: [22,23]; . . AN =
L (0; kJI V(k )D··· V(kN-d 10; kN) . 2
peml
The summation over all possible permutations of the ordering of the exteni.fd:;:: lines guarantees that the variables can roam freely in the complex I./l<1U<'".
'I
2.9
Ghost Elimination
We have developed the harmonic oscillator formalism using quantization. In the conformal gauge, the theory maintains manifest LoreI).~~ij invariance and, in fact, becomes a theory based on free fields. This ac(;ou~~:m for the fact that the theory at the tree level is very easy to write liown. The price we have to pay for this simplicity, however, is that we must II'np()s:t::~ the Virasoro constraints directly onto the Hilbert space to eliminate 51l1J""" •• In general, the proof that ghost states do not couple in tree diagrams is qWlte::;~ simp Ie. (The proofbreaks down in loops, where extreme care must be [email protected]:~ to properly eliminate ghost states.) Let us define a real physical state as otl;~~:ill that satisfies the Gupta-Bleuler constraints:
Ln IR) = 0, [Lo - 1] IR) = O.
n > 0,
Let us define a spurious state as one that does not couple to real states:
(SIR)
= O.
We can conveniently represent such a state as IS) = L_n Ix)
for some state X. We now wish to show that spurious states do not couple ... trees, i.e., (S] Tree) = O.
To show this, we need two more identities:
[Ln - Lo - n + lJVo = Vo[Ln - Lo + 11, 1 1 [L n -Lo+11 1= [Ln- L o-n+l]. L0 Lo +n - 1 (This can easily be proved from (2.7.6), which in tum crucially depends on vertex function having conformal weight 1 with external tachyons ,,"'t-id='lifli~W&
2.9 Ghost E.limination
91
1. Thus, thc restriction on the ronfonnal weight of the vertex is crucial ;mination of all ghosts in the theory.) these two identities, we can now easily show
[t" - Lo - n + I )VoDVQD··· Vo 10) =
o.
(2.9.6)
· is the direct result; it shows tlllll the L 's can be pushed to lhe right until · finally annihilate on the vacuum. • """,mary, we have shown (hat Spurious slates do nOI rouplc to trees:
L" ITree) = 0
~
-+
(SI Tree) = O.
(2.9.7)
:~~'~::i we do 1I0t have to make any speciaJ change in the functional for because of the presence of ghosts. The ghosts stales propagat-
the tree amplitude automatically cancel by themselves. However. we . that the loop functions do indeed have problems with gh~ts propagating · I . This is because
(SI Tree IS)
f
O.
(2.9.8)
we naively trace over the trees to obtain loops, we thus inadvertently ud,,,h,, presence of ghosts, which must be facLOred out explicitly:
th",p =
L (n I Tree In) .
(2.9.9)
•
explicitly contoins ghost slales.
;~;~~~:~~.E~:l~ ~d~":':IU;;:plehappens from trees andooly contribute loop diagrams in the Yang--Mills case. to Faddecv-Popov
~
to the Yang-Mills theory do not contribute to the IrCCS of theory, but they do contribute to the loops. The Faddcev-Popov ghost . . is (see (1 .9.30): (2.9. 10)
that this produces the foUowing interaction of the gauge field A with ghost field c:
L, '" cAe.
(2.9.11)
,i, """piing means that a single ghost cannot couple to a tree diagram congauge fields. They can only contribute to loops, where the e fields circulate internally. Thus, particular attention was required to guarantee lhc Faddeev--Popov ghosts canceled against lhe negative metrie Slates in loops. m(
'~:.' :;,'~:: il:;,~h~~o';w::e:;v:~e'r, an extremely complicated task. In principle, the ability gauge is normally sufficienl to prove that the theory is
i!
. However. we can never be sure that the quantum theory doesn't anomalies thai destroy this fact. Therefore, it becomes important explicitl y that the Fock space is ghost-free in the Gupta-Bleuler
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
92
formalism. There are two independent proofs of this theorem, neither ot1iVhit~li~ is very simple, due to Brower, Thorn, and Goddard [24, 25]. The reader tilliv.ill skip the following discussion. Because of the numerous details involved, let us first sketch our .,tr.,tf'OV the elimination of ghosts. We would like to construct a set of physical opl~ra~t9ijim V~ and V;;; such that: (1) they commute with the Virasoro generators:
[Ln' V~] = 0, [Ln, V;;;] = 0; (2) the V~ and V; generate the physical Hilbert space: [phy}
=
V.:'~, V.:'~2 ... V::::" V:::m ,
'"
V::: mp [0; Po}
such that the states have either positive or zero norm, but never neI5atii¥~~ norm. The original Fock space of D-dimensionaI harmonic oscillators "llU·UH.I. equivalent to the set of states generated by these (D- 2)-dimensionaI operators, the - component of these oscillators, and the original operators:
{V~n'
V::: n, L,,} .
The L-n generate ghost states, so that by only taking the states V~n and v.':,=~u;.;. we will generate the correct ghost-free states. This is the desired gn'OSl"KllllU; result that we now want to prove. Let us begin by first defining
.
A~
1
= 2](
1
21 (
.
V'{nko, r)dr,
0
where
where ko is a null vector: k~ = 0,
{
ko = -1,
k6'
= k~ =
O.
We can view this vertex operator as the vertex for the insertion of a massll~~ vector particle. This particular vertex function was chosen for the .v.""u reason. Notice that, because kQ is a null vector, the Virasoro generators hA}l~ the following commutation relations with this vertex operator:
d . [Lm' VCr)] = -i-(e'mf V(r)). dr
2.9 Ghost Elimination
93
~~;;~~~.~thi~·:S,,~iSS 8 total derivative. When integrated over a circle, this means [L •. A~l =
o.
(2.9.19)
we chose the form of the vertex function such iliat we fulfill the first the A's commute with tbe Virasoro generaum . So far, however, we '. flO constraims on ko other than that it is a null vector. We will need to more constraints so that we fulfill the second condition. us start with a ground state veclOr of momentum Po. such thai Po and k{) Ct "Po::::
1, ko'Po=l.
(2.9.20)
us apply the vertex operator A: on the state vector 10; Po}. The resulting momentum Po + IIkO' We wanl this resulting state to satisfy the mass co"d;irio"118 well. As 3 consequence, we demand (X'M2
= -!(Pll + nkoi = -I -
II .
(2.9.21)
we demand that the momentum vector ko be constrained 10 be a null that the vertex: operator commutes with the Virasoro generators, and I. nmn,d that 4 . Po = 1 in order to generate additional transverse mass states whcn acting on the ground state. we must fuUy implement the last condition, namely that these opin fact, generate the entire physical space of states. There are some
" :,~~~~:~~;:,A::t.:r;,,~'t~,,;wc might suspect that the - modes can be created by ~
. vlllue ofk o. NormaUy, since the conformal spin ofa of operutors their sum, we expect this to be truc. However. the ordering destroys this. In ftlc t, we find thai the - components do not ,.-__ . with the Virasoro generators:
:x-I"x': ] = I"" ( -;
:r + m) :X- e'~X+: + inm1e,,,,,+id' . (2.9.22)
.d,no remedy this difficulty, we must add an cxlra item to tbe definition.
,.",m"',I, definition is now V$«k. T} =
:x$<:I' x + _,' ik,",~(logk. d,
X}e'H.
(2.9.23)
, .es'bo..... thal the above combination bas cooforma1 spin I and reduces, we take the transverse components, 10 the previous expression when we integral. let us take the commutator between these fields:
(2.9.24)
(2.9.25)
94
2. Nambu--Goto Strings
This allows us to write
v,: = om.Q. [V~, V!] = mOijom._n.
[V;. V~] = -nV~+n' [V;, Vn-] = (m - n)V;+n
+ 2m 3 0m ._n.
Notice that the + components are trivial and that the commutation rellltii;lilW1I of the transverse operators are exactly the same as for the usual narmCt~:::m oscillators. Now let us redefine the - modes once again:
Putting everything together, the final commutation relations are
[V~. V!] = moUom._n.
l
V~] = 0. -_ -_ -_ 26 - D 3 [V m • Vn]=(m-n)V m +n + 12 m Om.-n,
[V;;;.
[Ln.
V;;-]
= [Ln. V~] = O.
This is the final set of commutation relations. Notice that new V;;; n",~TR'iilf.i: commute with the original V~ operators and that they both commute wilth;l~ill1 Vrrasoro generators. Thus, we have now created a new Hilbert space independent operators that we can use to replace the original Fock "'1.1<'"' J1
.-
{a_nl""""* {V.: n • V:::: n • Ln}.
The physical Hilbert space is thus generated by the operators {V~n' V,""'j~Jmw which are equivalent to the DDF operators [26] which generate the nm""""" space in the light cone gauge. Furthermore, we know that the following has zero norm:
V::::n1 V:::: n2 ••• V::::nN 10) • This can be checked explicitly by taking the norm of the state and uS~:~':I~ commutation relations of the V;;-. Thus, we have the final statement, set of states generated by
have either positive norm or zero norm, but never negative norm. This cQJi.OOi:S pletes the proof that the Vrrasoro conditions completely remove the gh(f$~~ from the Hilbert space.
2. 10 Summary
95
Summary
~
:E~;%~r:\~~:;E~f~; is remarkably similar to the theory of point [ for the addition of gauge symmetries representing i
invariance of lhe \.\'Orld sheet. A3 in point particle theory .4.1 6), we have three cquivalem aCliOflS for the string:
~t~,.-d"
(Hamiltonian) form:
L = P"X" + "a' ,," [p2+ "
Xil ,]
(21ra ')
+ pP"X'I' ..... .;gPI~g"l>p b" + p aP 8" X/,../i/](cx.' secolld-order form :
- I L = _../ig"bJ"X",abX". 4:rra'
L = ~(Xl X fl
nonlinear form:
21f0"
".
_
(2.10. 1)
(X X'I')2 )1/2 I'
•
us summarize the similarities fOund in the point particle case and the
:th,co,y v,hen expressed in pi:lth integral language: xI'(r)
Dx =
n
--t-
X,, (u, r ),
length -+ area,
d.tp( t )
--t-
DX =
P.T
n
dXI'(a, r),
I',r.a
(fI ""') - (fI ""X') ' I_I
I_I
graph _ manifold,
"
P +m =0-+
(P,,+-X; )' =0. 2Jra'
'~:::;:, for quantizing the Siring action is
\0 write down the symmetry ~I extract the currents from this symmetry. calculate the a lgebra currents, and apply these currents onto the Hilbert space in o ,Itim;,"" ghosts. The Slmtegy we follow throughout the book is _ Symmetry -) Current _ Algebra ~n'~"t; ot"
--t
Constraints
--t
Unitarity.
possess repar~trization symmetry, which generates the
(2. 10.2)
96
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
The algebra generated by these operators is
[L", Lml
= (n -
m)Ln+m
D 3 + 12 (n -
(2.1·~·:_
n)8n,_m'
As in the point particle case, there are three ways in which to qUirntiz¢.~W theory.
Gupta-Bleuler Quantization In the Gupta-Bleuler fonnalism, we fix the gauge: gab
= 8ab
and the resulting action breaks reparametrization invariance but mElml:alrlsJl subgroup of conformal transformations:
L = _1 (X 2 _ X'2). 2][ I' I' (,
This Lagrangian, of course, propagates negative metric ghosts associated . the timelike mode of X. To eliminate them, the Gupta-Bleuler qUirnt'izalti~~ method states that the state vectors of the theory must satisfy
L" I¢} = 0, (Lo - 1) I¢} = o.
n > 0,
This means that the constraints are constructed to vanish on the Hilbert Sp~(~~ Although the action in this formalism is quite elegant, the price we "
Light Cone Quantization In the light cone quantization program, we set X+ = 2a' p+r.
(2. 1"'.'!'r.'m
The advantage of this approach is that we can eliminate all the redun(1@~ ghost modes of the theory from the very start in terms of only the tra'lTerse components. The disadvantage is that the fonnalism is awkward and we ,...;,"~v~ reestablish Lorentz·· symmetry at every step. The surprising feature is the Lorentz generators of the broken theory close only in 26 dj'im~msiIOn!~i;: Specifically, the problem occurs with the commutator:
2.10 Summary
1
n I[D - 26 6."=12(26 - D)+; 12 +2-2a.
97
(2. 10.9)
commutator to vanish, we must MVC D
~
26.
a = J.
(2.10.10)
' RRST method combines the best featuIes of both approaches. We still Lorent7. covariance of the action, but the negative metric states worry us bl..'Causc they cancel against the ghosts circulating in the because of the FaddccY-Popov dctcnnioant. When we exponentiate .d,lce....I'''l'~vd'''nnir''nt,we must introduec two anticommuting ghost . : band c. The resulting gauge-fixed action scUJ has a residual symmetry
:
by the HRST charge: I
00
00
L
'2
co(/o - a) + 2:)cn L .. + L"c..1,,=1
:L",c-"bn+", :(m - n).
11."'.-00
(2.10.11) (2. 10.12)
inlcrccpt 10 be ooe and the dimensioll of space-time to be 26. The states of the theory are defined by Q Iphy) ~ O.
(2.10.13)
in point particle theory, interactiolls are introduced by summing over
topological configurations in the path integral. The fundamenta l func· ~~,:~q~;ii' (>D for the interacting theory. upon whlch this entire chapter rests,
k" .... kN)
J J J '.........
~ E.
X LlFP
~ E IOpOIogics
d"'N
exp
[i /
D.o'
DX
L dO' dr
ID
./i exp ik',Il X ""
I]
JDg"" Jd",(fI .JEexP(ik•.,X"»)' ' .. I
(2. 10.14)
98
2. Nambu-Goto Strings
The amplitude can be computed exactly in the conformal gauge by uSlngtn~ identity
f
DX exp {= exp
=
IT
{~'
f
4~a' aZxfLa~xfL d2z + i
f
f
JfLXI< d
2Z}
JI«z)G(z, z')JI«z') dz dz' }
IZi - Zj 12a 'ki ·k,.
i<j
In the conformal gauge, the sum over topologies is given by the sum oviiW';: aU confonnally inequivalent configurations. If we consider conformal tra'!~(~~ formations that map the upper half-plane into itself and the real axis i~'(W,i itself, then the points along the real axis transform according to a projec'tiWill transformation SL(2, R): ,
y =
ay +b , cy+d
(
where the coefficients are real and satisfy ad - be = 1. This fixes the m~:as':¢~ili§ d fJ." so the formula for the N -point function becomes
where the z's are ordered along the real axis. The transition to the harmonic oscillator formalism is straightforward ..,'",::;"-/h cause, in the conformal gauge, the Hamiltonian is diagonal on the Fock sp~'r¢i'~ of oscillator modes. The propagator from the configuration Xa to Xb is (Xul
(''''0 e-THdr IXb) =
10
(Xul
1
Lo - 1
IXb ).
The vertex is equal to (Xci
eiki"X.i(O.r;)
IXd ).
We can remove aU the string eigenstates because IX}
f
DX{XI = 1.
Thus, the N -point function is equal to AN
= (0; ktl VO(k2 )D VO(k3)' .. VO(kN-d 10; kN) .
In the operator formalism, projective invariance can be reestablished using the fact that the operators L±l and Lo generate the projective gro,liit.=§jl SL(2, R). In fact, under an arbitrary conformal transformation, the V"""""'.~~/...
References
TV(k; , 1./) T - 1 =
(1- 6a.'t: 'tnotn1. .., n )
V(k/.
zj).
99
(2.10.22)
(2.10.23) thai the vertex V h3S conformal weight equal 10 a'kl = I.
ean explicitly conSUUct the operators that will generate only physjcaJ with zero or positive nonn The previous identity shows thai operators ,(",rm=~. ~piD equal to I automatically commute with the Virasoro genThis allows us to create operators, based on the vertex for a massless
, that will generate the physical space. We can coosuuct three commuting operators which together generate Ihe eillirt Fock
(V.'..
ii:•. L
.IIO).
(2. 10.24)
on ly tbuse states buil! out of V~II nnd V:" and dropping the L_ n • obtai, a new Fock. space thai has only Siaies which have posiljve and zero Thus, lhe set of spaces thai satisfy: L.I~) ~
O.
(Lo-I)I~) ~O.
(2. 10.25)
.., ,o f " eg;"i" norm states in 26 dimensions. we nole that string theory is easy to quantize because its Hamiltonian ua~~~; in the string variables. Simple harmonic oscillators ean be used III the theory. However, in M-theory, this simplicity breaks down. the membrane is quartic in the Hl'lmiltonian. At present, there i ~ no '''''Y in which to quantize thc free mambmne.
,r""",y
Y. Nambu, Lectures at the Copenhagen Summer Symposium ( 1970). T. 0 010, Progr. Theoret Phys. 46, 1560 ( 1911 ).
For eartier fonnuJations, sec: also H. 8 . Nielsen, 15th International Co'iferenc~ ofHigh Energy Physics (Kiev), 1970. L Susskind, NuollO Cimento 69A, 451 ( 1970). SeeC. B. Thorn. in Unified String I1leory (ediTed by M. B. Oreen and D. Oross), . World Scientific, Singapore. 1985. M. A. Virasoro, Phys. Rev. 01. 2933 (J910). A. M. Polyakov, " hys. Lell. 1038, 207,2 11 (1981). S. Fubini, D. Gordo n. and O. Veneziano, Phys. Letl. 29B, 679 (1969).
100
2. Narnbu-Goto Strings
[9] P. Goddard, J. Goldstone, C. Rebbi, and C. B. Thorn, Nuc!. Phys. (1973). [10] M. Kato and K. Ogawa, Nuc!. Phys. B212,443 (1983). [11] C. S. Hsue, B. Sakita, and M. A. Virasoro, Phys. Rev. D2, 2857(1970). [12] J. L. Gervais and B. Sakita, Nucl. Phys. B34, 632 (1971); Phys. Rev. D4, (1971); Phys. Rev. Leu. 30, 716 (1973). [13] D. B. Fairlie and H. B. Nielsen, Nucl. Phys. B20, 637 (1970). [14] K. Bardakc;i and H. Ruegg, Phys. Rev. 181, 1884 (1969). [15] M. A. Virasoro, Phys. Rev. Lett. 22, 37 (1969). [16] C. J. Goebel and B. Sakita, Phys. Rev. Lett. 22, 257 (1969). [17] H. M. Chan, Phys. Lett. 28B, 425 (1969). [18] H. M. Chan and S. T. Tsou, Phys. Lett. 28B, 485 (1969). [19] Z. J. Koba and H. B. Nielsen, Nuc!. Phys. B12, 517 (1969); B10, 633 (19~~~ [20] L Caneschi, A. Schwimmer, and G. Veneziano, Phys. Lett. 30B, 351 (I [21] M. A. Virasoro, Phys. Rev. 177,2309 (1969). [22] J. Shapiro, Phys. Lett. 33B, 361 (1970). [23] M. Yoshimura, Phys. Lett. 34B, 79 (1971). [24] P. Goddard and C. B. Thorn, Phys. Let!. 40B, 235 (1972). [25] R. C. Brower and K. A. Friedman, Phys. Rev. D7, 535 (1973). [26] E. Del Giudice, P. Di Vecchia, and S. Fubini, Ann. Physics 70, 378 (1
3
ngs
Supcrsynunetric Point Particles '~~;::'~,,;;'~.,'one of the most elegant of all symmetries. uniting bosons Cl single multiplet: Fermions
No
Bosons.
fields of differing statistics. supersynunetry and supergroups have up an entireiy new area of mathematics. . there is nota single shred of experimental evidence For example. physicists have tried to fit the electron or neutrino into "ym,nOltrio multiplets. but the scalar partners of these leptons have never . In fact, nonc of the presently known particles has a supersyoum:tric Some critics have called supersymmelIy a "solution looking for a
" 1~::',~~~': arc absolut.ely no empirical data to support the notioDof su-
!'l
il is undewable that supcrsymmetry provides a wealth of highly theoretical mechanisms ilial hold tremendous promise. Supersymis more elegant way in which to unite elementary panicles 1 multiplets; it also has definite practical appl ications field theory;
'.~;:':';:~:','Z generales super-Ward-Takahashi identities thai cancel normally divergent Feynma1 grapbs. For example, Feynman loop a"~ttlli· with bosons and fermions circulating internally in the loop differ a facto r of -1. Because of supersymmetry, the boson loop can cancel .'g'",,,,, the fermion loop, leaving us with a much milder divergence, We therefore. thai Ynng- Mills theories with supcrsymmetry have be-tter
\
102
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
3. Superstrings renonnalization properties than ordinary gauge theories. In fact, ce.~,tl1.t~ "nonrenormalization theorems" can be proved to all orders in pel1UlrbaQQj~ theory. Supersynunetry may solve the "hierarchy problem" that plaglJes ordi1)~mi Grand Unified-type theories. In GUTs, there are two widely se"flanlte~i;~~ ergy scales, the energy scale of ordinary particle physics in the v~'fit.~i electron volt range and also the GUT energy scale at I 0 I 5 or so t.V~Wl}1m electron volts. In between these two energy scales is a vast :'desert" no new phenomena are found. However, when renonnalization efii~c~!~:lCf.i calculated, the two energy scales inevitably begin to mix. Loop c~~6.'IJ~ ings, for example, to the quark masses can push them up near the' .• scale, which is unacceptable. "Fine-tuning" one's coupling . masses by hand can, in principle, solve the hierarchy problem, ~U".·"" is very contrived and artificial. Fortunately, the Ward-Takahashi la~:.tm ties of supersymmetry are strong enough to enforce theorems" to all orders in perturbation theory. Thus, SUI),er:syrnrnLeti;v,]m! necessary to stabilize these two mass scales in perturbation thp,"ni' prevent mixing. ( ::::::::::W::! Supersymmetry may help shed light on the "cosmological constant" 'P'i(9im lem. Empirically, the cosmological constant term )...,j=g, correction to the Einstein-Hilbert action, is exceedingly small on a#;~i tronomical scale. The problem is to explain the near vanishing OI:)~ cosmological constant without "fine-tuning." Supersymmetry is pn)b~!1.i:JjOO strong enough to force the cosmological constant to be zero to all otiieRm:i in perturbation theory (because this term breaks supersymmetry). 'H""""'" doesn't completely solve the cosmological constant problem., hO'weve~~:~AA cause we must inevitably break supersymmetry to reach ordinary enlel'g~§J (The problem, therefore, is to explain the vanishing of the constant after sypersymmetry breaking has occurred.) Supersymmetry eliminates many undesirable particles. The t~"hv,")n·::·flml appears in the bosonic string model, for example. is elimrijln~~a~:te~:d~~~I~ it violates supersymmetry. By eliminating these particles, SI also reduces the divergence ofthe higher loop graphs. In Chapter 5 show that the potential divergences of the superstring theory are a~~~I~ with the infrared emission of tachyons and dilatons. Thus, by I ing these particles, we simultaneously eliminate the source" of pO"t¢llUi divergences. .:: Lastly, when supersymrnetry is elevated into a local gauge theory, if' rally reduces the divergences of quantum gravity. This is becaus~e::'~1.'~ supersymmetry can be defined only in the presence of gravit()fis Appendix). Local supersymmetry is thus intimately tied up with relativity. In fact, local supersymmetry successfully eliminates the . loop divergences of supergravity. However, the largest of the supergraV~\1 theories, 0(8) supergravity, probably has a divergence at the se\rerrth):95.l§ level, which most likely rules out supergravity as an acceptable qw~~~~~
II
3.1 Supersymmetric Point Particles
103
th,,",y.Only when we combine local supersymmcrry with the coninvariancl'l of the string theory do we have a large enough gauge to eliminate perhaps all the divergences of quantum gravity.
,>","""tc" as an invnriancc of an action, was first discovered in the Gervais and Sakita [1] showed that an extension of the usuaJ possessed a symmetry that converted bosons into fermion:>. it languished for many years because the supcrsymmetry of model was a two-dimensional supcrsymmetry on the world until relatively recently that it was fml:l.!Iy proved that the ~~!:;;~"'''''d borh two-dimensional and IO-dimensional spaoo-tlmc our di.scussion by t:oWiitlcring the siwph::st possible spinning ,e spi~'~i"g point particle. In addition to the \f'.uiable x)J.' which locates of the pOin! particle, let us introduce Dirac spinors 0", where A is In general, a Dimc spinar the Dirac matrix in D dimensions ;n"ioo;b", 2''''''"compiex components. We can writc p. 3J
r" .
'f -'( '
S=i
e
..t)J. -
'£j"r)J. B")'d r.
lv
(HI)
particle action is invariant under
80 A = t: A ,
B8 A = Ox)J.
e,
=ieA r"8 A ,
(3.1.2)
Be = O.
(3.1.3) ~:~~:I, all by itself under this transformation. Thus, any expression
combination will be invariant under this symmetry. The strange action, however. is that half of the components of the fennioruc from the action by itself. "Ying,th'"'' .f.)J.. and e fields. we can derive several equations of motion: IB
n 2 = 0, Ii" =: 0,
r·no =o.
(3. 1.4)
(3.1.5)
aJ!~:~~i,.~~::'J'l~;: :~!"~~:~~~~;~ vanish. Butsincc8 always appears p'e". half they. ncomponents of the Dirac spinor are
:
104
3. Superstrings
actually missing from the action. Thus (J is not an independent splnolf::.t)j satisfies a constraint that reduces its components by half. The reason for this decoupling is that the action is invariant under yet an(lftijijjij local symmetry [2]: '
{
8(JA
= i r • OKA.
8 X IL
= i~ArILS(JA.
Se = 4ee A KA.
Furthelmore, there is also another bosonic invariance of the action: S(JA
= ),J)A.
8X IL = {
ieArIL(j(JA,
lie = O.
When we try to commute two supersymmetry operations given in (3 .1'~I':'"' find that the algebra does not close unless we use the equations of mCIt1o~::::;:: [8 1• 82]eA = (2ir IL Kte Br.
orILK~ +4ir· oKteBK~)-(l ~ 2).
(This is actually typical of supersymmetric actions. Notice that the nU1J1lj:~ of components of x lL and (J A do not necessarily match off-shell. which 1l1~~~ that auxiliary fields are in general necessary to close the algebra.) Lastly, if we calculate the canonical conjugate to the coordinates, we A _
1T:(J -
8L _.
-.- -
(j(JA
I
r IL nile A .
This poses vast complications for the covariant quantization. Because the~t-e:: an explicit dependence on x within the canonical conjugate, the qUJmtiiz.a1.ft relations become nonlinear and hence exceedingly difficult to solve. Wij~1 it turns out that the term r il OIL becomes a projection operator in the th~~~ meaning that we cannot invert the transformation and solve for (JA. In q:~g words, a naive covariant quantization of the spinning point particle dotlS;:~ijffi seem to exist at all! This is a warning that the supersymmetric string is:)~m§ going to be as simple as super-Yang-Mills or supergravity theory. As sequence, we will discuss the simpler two-dimensional world sUI)en;yn:Up:i¢~~ of the N eveu-Schwarz-Ramond (NS--R) model first, and then the more .Cj9~~ plicated lO-dimensional space-time supersymmetry of the Grleenr-SlcMv:im~ model.
3.2
Two-Dimensional Supersymmetry
Given the problems associated with superparticles (such as lack of a cO'vM'iJPll quantization and lack of an algebra that closes off-shell), let us tenlpoltW;!m:: abandon space-time supersymmetry and discuss the two-dimensional
3.2 Two-Dimensional Supersynunl:try
lOS
ym",e~
of the simplest possihle action involving free strings and free . This action will already be gauge fixed in tile conformal gauge, but all the essential features oftwo-dimcnsional supert.ymmctry. In dixod fonnulation, we will impose the gauge COllstrnims on the Fock hand. Lalcr, we will present the complete action, where we will be lhese cOllstraints starring from a locally symmetric action.
gauge, we have [J] 1 L = --2 (a~ X",a~ X" - iy,JJ p "a.. Yt14 ), n
(3.2.1)
I, 2 and labe ls two-dimensional vectors, and J.L is a space-lime is a bizarre object, an anticommuting Majorana spinor in two
,im" ,md a vector in real space-time. Let us define
!/1M =
(~~ ) ,
pO =
(~ ~j ),
, (0 i)
p...
Ip", p'} =
j
0
~jJ ~ iftupo,
'
(3 .2.2)
-2,"".
this out explicitly in components, v.'C have (3.2.3) action is gauge fIXed, it is still inv:lriant under the global
jrmatio",
SX" = e",". Sl/f" = - ;p"a. xl't.
(3.2.4)
abandoning OUf attempt to produce a theory of strings spucHme sp inors, we have achieved a two-dimensional theory that is quite s.imple, involving free bosonic and fie lds. the NS- R theory [4-6J was the first successful attempt at spin inlo the dual model. It was also the first example of a lin. action and was soon followed by fOUI·dimensional actions [7. 8}. wri tten down our two-dimensional supcrsymmetric acn'tn,,, the "lOP"'" '"ed in the previous chapter to solve the system. !.1ep is to extrnct the currents associated with these symmetries, then the algebra that these currents generate, and fmally apply these conon the Hilbert space. TIle sequence we will follow in this section is
"U'
106
3. Superstrings
a straightforward generalization of the steps we developed in the chapter: Action -* Symmetries -)- Current -)- Algebra -* Constraints -)-
nrp',';"
UUHi1I(i~(
Following this strategy, let us now calculate the supersymmetric curretll:m~ sociated with this symmetry. As we saw in the last chapter, the eXllste:n¢I~:; conformal symmetry is sufficient to generate a conserved current. h1 ( we saw that this conserved current could be written as
r=~ 8¢. 8 ap,¢ 8s a
p,
By inserting (3.2.4) into (3.2.6), we find Ja =
! pb p" 1fJ/'/' abx
Jl"
To check that this is conserved, we must first write down·the motion for the system, which is especially easy since it is a~ee action:
[ar + Orr ]1fJt; = 0, [or - arr ]1fJi = o. It is now easy to show
Oa 1"=0. Written out in components, this equals (h
= !(Jo ± J 1»)
L = 11fJt;(o, - orr)X/./" J+ =
!1fJi(ar + aCT)X IL .
U sing the equations of motion, we can show that
(a r
+ arr)L =
(ar
-
arr)J+
0,
= O.
In addition to the supersymmetric current, we also have the momentum tensor, which as we saw earlier in (1.9.17) can be as
8L P' = - 0 A. v SOIL¢ V'Y
-
wr.l~M
LSI'
v'
This can easily be adapted for our purposes. Inserting (3.2.1) into (3.2.1"fj:;::~~ find
Tab = OaX/'/'ObX IL
i -
i -
+ 41fJ IL Pa Ob1fJp, + 41fJ/'/'PbO,,1fJ1L o"T"b = 0,
(Trace),
3.2 Two-Dimensional Supersynunctry
\07
is traceless because we have explicitly subtractcd out the explicitly, this is
1'2
== l(X
+ X ,:z ) -
t rac~.
i" i .. '41Jro (a, - iJ,,)1Jrou - '41Jr1 (a r -+ B")1JrI I,,
== Till
(32.14)
. Ii.. iu = X· X + 40/0 (Of - 8,,)Vto.. - 41P1 {a f
+ (1,,)"11"
i strategy (3.2.5) is to use these currents to restrict the Fock space so ghosts are eliminated:
(T,,/>l =
o.
~
o.
(J.)
(3.2.15)
strcs..~
again, however, that we are simply imposing Ihis constraint the Pock space. Because me action is not locally supcrsymmetric, ,Ier;;vethis constraint from first principles. Later, when we present symmetric action, we will see that these constraints emerge because
""<"
String, we actually have a choice of two distiuct boundthat we can place on the % and 1Jr1 fie lds, either periodic or rio,iio . At C1 = 0, we can always choose "'0 =: 1/1"1' However, at C1 = I(, the choice of two distinct boundary conditions. If the field is periodic p,,,;o,jio), we have the Romond (Neveu-Schwar.£) boundary conditions Ramond: Neveu-Schwarz:
Vro{1r, r) == "'I(re, .), ( 1Jro(n, 1:) = -1JrI(rc, r).
(3.2.16)
two different types of boundary conditions for our SpinOT, we nanually different ways in which to pO'.'l"er expand these two fields in Fourier ipo"",<~ with integer (half-integer) modes [8, 9]:
L 00
1Jr6'("',, ) = rl/2
d~e-i~(r--Gl,
(3.2. 17)
00
1Jri(cr, r) = TI/2 1Jr~(a, T) = riP
L L L
d:e- III!I-'-D 1,
b!'e-'r(r-o),
rEZ+I/2
VrUa,
r)
==
2- 1/2
b~e -ir(t+a).
(3.2.1 S)
rEZ+I/l
",:~~x;~t:~:~~.~:~::;te~~.;(3;;.;2:.5) is to isolate the algebra thai these currents r:;:
we saw that the symmetries yielded the
108
3. Superstrings
energy-momentum tensor, which in tum generated the Virasoro or co'n~81ffl;jil algebra. For the NS-R action, we will find that the superconfonnal alg;l';bi6tJ1 generated. With this decomposition of the fields, the moments Ln of the curren~:~ can now be written as
1'" 2rr
L" = - 1
0
da{e rll " (Too + To l )
,
+ e-,na(Too -
TOI )}.' '
Notice that the definition of the conformal generators now >w..,...,.,,~ contributions from the anti commuting sector. We can repeat this Fourier expansion for the supersymmetric current as,if"eJI: For the R sector, we have '
v21'"
Fn = -
IT
+ e-
da{e rll'" h
,
1ntf
0
L}. •
For the NS sector, we have
v21' " rr
G, = -
,
l
da{e"" J+ + e->r" L}.
0
To extract the algebra from these moments ofthe currents, we need to "U~'~!:!J:Im the canonical conjugates of the fields. Ifwe define .,.,Jl _
_
"A -
-::-
8L _
81/1 A.Jl
,
then we find that the fermionic field is self-conjugate. Thus, we l11l1Dos:ei (1/I~(a, T), l{I;(a', T)}
= rr8 AB 8(a -
a'}r,lLv.
Therefore the oscillators in (3.2.17) and (3.2.18) obey R: NS :
{{d:,d~}=r,JlV8"._m' {b~, b;} = r,JlV 8r.-s .
It is important to notice that the zero component of the R sec:t9tOO proportional to the Dirac gamma matrices:
{db, do} = r,Jlv. Hence, we will see that the R sector corresponds to the fennionic sector, at*~!g~ the NS sector, even though it contains anticommuting operators, still renfAlI2 a bosonic sector. The fact that boundary conditions like (3.2.16) an important role in the development of the fennionic and bosonic of the theory is quite novel and apparently unique to the string ~"""1"\' apparently obscure fact will play an important role when we discuss mUiltr~. amplitudes defined over surfaces with holes. Then these boundary ..v ..,"'~!:!: will determine what are called the "spin structures" of the manifold.)
3.2 Two-Dimensional Supersymmctry
109
,b.,d,w" C"~ construct the algebra generate. As before, the moments of these currents will . :: . closed algebra. The algebra for the NS sector is
D ,
= (m - n)L",+/I + g(m - m)8... _".
(L,.. L II )
[L "" 0.] = (im - r)G", ~"
10,. G,I = 2L r 'i"
(3.2.26)
+ 1D{r2 -
~)o,._,.
we have, in terms of oscillators in the NS sec lor.
I
=
~
2" ~
~
L :CL"a",+,,: + ~ L (r + 4m ) :b_rb",+, :, .. -oo ,-.-00 (3.2.27)
same steps for the R sector, we have
[L"" L,,] = (m - n)L .. +<
D ,
+ Sm
Ol/l._~'
[L"" F,, ) = (im - n)F"'H ' {F.. ,
F4 1=
2L",+"
(3.228)
+ ~Dm2o... _".
explicitly. we have
I
L,. =
00
00
L
2"
:«_,,0'.. +00:
+ 1 L (n + !m) :d.."dm+,, :.
~"-OC>
" .. -DO
(3.2.29) ~ ...d ,,!f1~, H,'mil"mi,,,, ,
H
=
-
rb~,b,,. + er:' p~.
(3.2.30)
L ..,na~"a"" + L_.,md~",d",,. +a' p~.
(3.2.31)
.. "'[
00
H=
-
L na~"a",. + L
,.". 1/2
_
"_. that this Hamiltonian i~ diagonal on the Fock space of bllIOlonic :" . This is cxtremely important, because ihis means thai we can easily . transition from path integrals to the harmonic oscillator formalisDl. ". for the theory becomes a simple integral over the exponential. performed .
110
3. Superstrings
u",IO>
FIGURE 3.1. Regge trajectories for the NS-R model for open strings. The h",","-!« states corespond to the Fock space generated by an possible prQducts of a+ an(I:~~ harmonic oscillators acting on the vacuum. The fermion states correspond ..",,:.U.Mo Fock space generated by all possible products of a+ and d+ oscillators actirigl:;l}1~ the vacuum, which is a space-time spinor, not a scalar. On the left, the mas~l!1i§ spin-l particle corresponds to the Maxwell or Yang-Mills field (all tachyon sWiim including the vacuum, can be eliminated when we impose the G;SO the right, the massless spin-1 fermion is the supersynunetric partner ofthe vector field. ( The states of the theory, as in the bosonic sector, are simply given Fock space of the product of these oscillators: NS eigenstates:
h,,:.1t6,;;s
nn nn
{a!.IlHb;n.o} 10) ,
nip. m.v
R eigenstates:
{a!,1l }{d~,v 10) ua ,
n,ll m,o
where u'" corresponds to an arbitrary spinor, which as yet has no res.tri(~tii'~~ placed on it. Some ofthe lowest lying states in the NS sector are as Fig. 3.1):
NS states:
R states:
2
= 2,
10) ,
k
tachyon
kJ1b~1/2 10) ,
e=l,
massless vector
a~l 10) ,
spin-! fermion
[0)
vacuum
{ {
Ua ,
spin-~ fermion
d~l 10) U a ,
spin-~ fermion
a~l 10} U a •
In summary, we find a remarkable similarity between the NS-R mctdel'!i:ilm the original bosonic string, In each case, we begin with an action, detin¢!::~~:::l symmetries, generate its currents from the symmetries, construct the .' bra from the currents, and then apply the constraints onto the Hilbert spa~~~ The main difference is the addition of the supercurrent, which gel1erates,::tj1ti superconformal algebra (3.2.26) and (3,2.28).
3.3 Trees
111
step in our strategy is then to apply this supcrconfonnal algebra Hilben space of the NS-R model. The ghost-killing conditions IlfC
Fn or Or 14') = 0 nand r . To establish the mass-shell conditiow, however, wc will investigate the tree amplitudes fo r the NS-R model.
. ,our sTarting point for the intemcting string meol}' is the functional Unfortunately, we have no guiding principle fo r the conslJ;Uctioo of ~e,."i' theory except for intuition. As a guess, let us multiply the usual term with a facto r of k/J. Vr~ at the poim at whieh a spio-O particle diab'T3ffi. Then a reasonable asslUuptioD is that the N -point scattering for this scalar particle is a generalization of(2.5.2) and is given by
A(t,2,3 ... ,N)=
L topolOf:;""
- L
lopolDg.ics
D", ~
Jd1).DXDVrfIki",vr~il:,.·X'~ f d,,(fr k"""""".X") , ;",1
IT IT N,(a, ,), II
(3.3.1)
(= I
(3.3.2)
".'
we arc now functionally integrating over an infinite sequence of ,,,,,,",variables. the bosonic functional integral, we can remove the functional integrals intermediate point along the string sheet because the Hamiltonian is on this space. Thu.~, by using
I = IX) ,"'1
f
DX D",
l.pl IXI
(3,),3)
intennediate pornt, we ciln remove all the functional integrals, leaving h,h"mo"i, oscillators. Thus, once again the functional integral permits of the barmonic oscillator formalism, which we vicw as only one representation of the functional integral. '~~i: language, the vertex for the emission of a scalar particle with :tl bc:comes
(33.4)
~;:~;~~~;'I,,:::~:;;';iO,~
::(
for choice
this is the rute thaI vertex functions must weight I, in order to preserve the ghost-killing conditions
•
112
3. Superstrings
(2.9.5). From (3.2.27) and (3.2.28), we can calculate the commutator with 1/11" and we find that it has confonnal weight ~. Since Vo has cOIltOI~~~ weight a' k 2 and 1/1 has weight the weight of V is the sum of the two:
!,
a'k 2 + -21 = 1
f(1 = _1_. 20"
-?
!.
where a' is equal to This vertex function, which corresponds to the ' or absorption of a tachyon, is guaranteed to satisfy the correct ghlost-killiiii§~ conditions. The propagator is easy to calculate. Notice that the Hamiltonian is di;jl~~ onal in the space of harmonic oscillators. Therefore, we will use an eXJ)l~!W representation of the functional based on the normal modes of the harm:Ii'~~W oscillator. Then we have
1
00
D=
e-r(Lo-l} dr
o
=
I . Lo - I
Let us constmct an N -point function of tachyons:
(
{O; kd kl . b l/2 V(k 2 )D ... V (kN-I)k N • b- 1/ 2 10; kN) • where we have placed the tachyon states to the left and right of all the vertJ~m and propagators. In this fonnalism, we can prove cyclic symmetry in the sa1iiliil way it was shown for the bosonic string. We first note: . V(k. y) hm 10; 0) = k . b_ 1/2 10; k) •
y~O
Y
lim (O; 01 y V(k, y) = (0; -kl k . b 1/2 •
y ~oo
This permits us to treat all external tachyons alike. By commuting the ,.I~~~ vertex to the left, we can show, in exact parallel to the bosonic case studle(t~m (2.6.24), that the amplitude is cyclic symmetric. At this point, however, we have a problem. The tachyon state that we Mi(~~ just constmcted corresponds to k/Lb~l!2 10; k), which satisfies
[Lo - l]kl'b~1/210;k} = 0
-?
a'k 2 =
!.
However, this means that the vacuum state 10; k) has even lower mass it satisfies the following conditions:
[Lo -1] IO;k)
=0
-?
a'k2 = 1.
We are faced, therefore, with the unusual problem that the we vacuum theory (3.3.10) does not correspond to the tachyon that we have' t cOlflstrilc:~m (3.3.9), In other words, the Hilbert space seems to be too large; the we is an unnecessary state. We seem to have two lowest lying states. The resolution to this puzzle comes from the fact that the vacuum indeed, is a redundant state that can be removed from the theory. This is accomplished by redefining the Hilbert space of the theory.
3.3 Trees
11 3
that we bave been working with is called the PI formalism clumsy one. The vacuum of the theory is not equal to the tsChYOIl, so
space is acrually larger than necessary. Although cyclic symmetry is :: : to prove in this formalism, we would like to introduce a more streamfonnalism, called F2 [10], which works with the reduced Fock sp.:1ce by
the vacuum state at k2 = ila'. accomplish this, let us rewrite the t!tchyon state as kJlb~ln IO;k) = G_1/ZIO;k},
(3.3. 11)
(0 ;/( 1kp bf/2 = (O;kl G 1f2 .
(3.3. 12)
N-point tachyon scattering ampJirudc (3.3.7) using
(3.3. 13 ) comes the crucial step. We will push the 0)/2 to the right successively
various vertices and propagators. We need the fannulas IC" V) = [L 2r • Vol = [Lo + r - J]Vo - Vo(Lo - 1), I
G I/l
I
Lo
-
1..0
. "son.li. 1 to notice that when we shove of the propagator .,--:-~
i GIn· G!1l
to the right, we change the
1 _ cc-=--,
Lo - l
(3.3. 14)
(3.3. 15)
Lo-!
the othcr tenns involving the L 's vanish as in the bosonic case. Finally. ,,"', p""h"d G 1/2 all the way to the right, where it vanishes on the tachyon (3.3. 16)
",,>Ulling all tenns together, we flnally have AN ::: (o; kl l
=
*1 . blp V(I0)
(0;kdY(k 2 )
1 !
La - '2
I L.
1
... V(kN_dk .... . h- 11 2 10; kN) .
.· ·Y(k N_dIO; k.v} .
(3.3. 17)
we have now completely rewritten the original amplitude sucb. has been shifted. In particular. the old va<.ouum state FI formal is.m at 0'k 2 = , hal'; vanisherl from the Hilbert l';pltce. 11 has ,"p.1,dl coml,letcly in the new fonna iism, whieh we call F2 (I OJ. Instead, we with the tachyon statc being represented by 10; k), which now satisfies >ow cOlodilion [Lo 10;..1:) = 0 with a'k2 = is quite remarkable. The state fO; k}, which used to represent the old "m "," at (1' k 2 = I , has now suddenly transfotmed into the tachyon state
V
t.
114
3. Superstrings
= !.
Thus, in the F2 formalism, the tachyon state and the new va(~u~~m at a' k 2 are the same particle. (y./e should be careful in noting that the same synl11jQru§§ 10; k) can represent either the old vacuum in the FJ formalism or the tachy(j~:§§ in the new F2 formalism.) This shifting of the Hilbert space is a novel feature not found in point l?;~i tide field theories. In fact, when we discuss the conformal field theory l1 next chapter, we will find that this strange "picture changing" phlenc)lru:~9im~ arises whenever we construct irreducible representations of the sU]:lerc:onJtO'J mal group. Hence, it is not a trick, but an essential feature of the group thp;,,,, (We should also mention that when we make the model space-time SU~ler~rvtJj~ metric, we will eliminate the tachyon state as well. Thus, the tachyon de(~Ou~t~~~ from the true superstring Hilbert space, leaving a unitary theory.) . Let us summarize the differences between these two formalisms: vertex = V, propagator = (Lo - 1)-1, tachyon:
kfJ.· b~I/2 10; k) (afe =
vacuum:
IO;k) (a f k2 = 1),
k),
(
vertex = V,
F2 :
I
propagator = (Lo tachyon = Vacuum:
krl, IO;k) (afe = ~).
The advantages and disadvantages of the two formalisms are as follows: (I) In the FI formalism, manifest cyclic symmetry is much easier to However, we must carry along the excess baggage of the vacuum which decouples completely. (2) In the F2 formalism, cyclic symmetry is obscure, but ghost and gauge transformations are easy to perform. The advantage is are now working in a smaller Fock space. Using the F2 formalism, it is not hard to evaluate the four-point furLci%9mm exactly: (0, -kd V(k2)
I I V(k3 ) 10; 1.4) Lo - '2
=
r(1 - a(s))r(l - a(t)) , r(l - a(s) - aCt)) .
(3.3:~91§1
wherea{s) = 1 +ais. There is also a straightforward generalization to the N -point function. ~W N -point function is represented as 1:
3.3 Trees ~.~I,
115
this expression contains many factors that are tedious to work out
method of obtaining the entire resuh is to usc the relation
-V(y) ~
.;;
f
dO exp{ik· X
+ 9k· "".;;).
(3.3.22)
that i f we power expand the exp onential. only the linear teno survives 'j"",,&",u,on, and we wind up with the previous cllpression for tbe vertex. at this point, done nothing. Now, leI us use two identities:
(01 "'"(,,) ,,"(y,) 10) ~
../Yi...!Yi I
V(y,) V(n)
../Yi ../Yi
10) =
f
."" y, - 12
dO, dfh. exp[k 1 . k1ln(y.
-)'2 -
91th)] (3.3.23)
bard to generalize the above relation to lhc N -point tachyon amplitude:
;~:;:~.~ '~:'~~:'~:'~~;~: is that We can now read off the various terms
[:1
the
by successively power expanding and integrating
Grassmann variables. to tachyon-tachyon scattering amplitudes, we can also calculate of massless vector particle!; (which correspond 10 Maxwell and
. The choice of the vertcx function for the massless vector by thl: mclthat it must hnve conformal weight 1 and thc spin. A natural choice for this vertex is
vcclorofthe vector particle amI kl = {·k = O. The of the vertex is equal 10 the sum of the conformal weights of factors. Since '" has conformal weight! and flU has conformal (J'k 2 , this means that the conformal weight of this vcrtex is given by
~+~+O= I , is the desired weight. This vcrtcx is guaranteed to satisfy the G and L conditions. It is not difficult to calculate the N -point scattering trus massless gauge particle us ing thc same fonnalism developed tachyon. For example, the scattcring amplitude for four massless gauge is givcn by
116
3. Superstrings
where the kinematic factor K is given by K =
+ SU/;23;14 + tU/;12;34) . + I s(k I4 k 32l;z4 + k23 k41 /;13 + k 13k 4Z /;Z3 + k24 k 31/;14)
-i(stl;I3;Z4 1
+ !t(k2I k 43 l;31 + k 34k 12 /;24 + k 24k 13 /;34 + k 3I k 42 l;lZ) + ~U(k12k43l;32 + k 34k 21 l;14 + k 14 k23 /;34 + k32 k 41 /;li), where
(The scattering involving fermions can also be calculated; they will also Mj!~ the basic form, except that the kinematic factor K will depend on the ext:eJ·m.«m spinors.) We should add that another advantage of working with the Pi t~~~~(~~~11 that we can explicitly show the invariance of the amplitude under the (
8Yi = eje, 8ej = e. This generates the group Osp(!, 2) (see Appendix), which