DEDICATION To all women, especially my mother Renate and my daughters Laura, Lisa, and Anna Lea. I love you very much.
...
1695 downloads
5471 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
DEDICATION To all women, especially my mother Renate and my daughters Laura, Lisa, and Anna Lea. I love you very much.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS My gratitude goes to the women who gave me firsthand experiences of how wonderful, challenging, rewarding, and painful relationships can be, and so inspired me to grow in consciousness to become a better man. You know who you are if you happen to get a copy of this manual. Liza Braude-Glidden for her loving friendship, for introducing me to Ken Wilber’s work, and for the early encouragement; Christel Rene and Kim Hansen for spending countless hours on hikes while discussing ideas as the manual took shape; John McCoy, Bill Henderson, and Frederick Ernst for proofreading the first drafts; my friends at the Santa Rosa Integral Salon for their wisdom, support, feedback, and encouragement; the countless men and women who shared their relationship experiences with me in groups and individual sessions; Ken Wilber for the Integral Model that this manual is based on; the many authors whose writings provided the wisdom that allowed me to fill in the blanks (see Appendix I and the Bibliography); Mark Johnson, Bruce Kunkel, Professor Allan Combs, Steve Blackmer, and Gore Yaswen for peer reviews; Rebecca Davenport for proofreading the final manuscript; Annette Berlin for the cover design and inside illustrations, Renate Elhardt for text layout and additional illustrations, and last but not least Harriett Hardman for her guidance and excellent editing.
TABLE OF CONTENTS Title Page Dedication Acknowledgments List of Figures List of Tables Preface Introduction A Few Facts and Figures The Integral Approach The Integral Relationship Model Some Notes About This Manual A Final Suggestion Chapter 1: Understanding the Dimensions of Love The Spiritual Dimension of Love The Evolving Physical and Psychological Dimensions of Love In Summary
PART I – THE BIOLOGICAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL MAKEUP OF MEN AND WOMEN Chapter 2: Understanding the Differences Between the Sexes Sex: Physical/Biological Differences Between Males and Females (Body) Gender: Cultural/Learned Differences Between Men and Women (Mind) Polarities: Masculine/Feminine Potentials for Both Sexes (Soul) In Summary Chapter 3: Lines of Development for Human Intelligences The Many Facets of Humanness Building Relationships through Shared or Compatible Passions and Interests Identifying and Discussing Capacities, Values and Ideals Talking About Needs and Neediness Opening Up to Feelings In Summary Chapter 4: Levels of Growth Consciousness Development (Colors) Spiritual Development Development of Sexuality Anima and Animus Complex Development In Summary Chapter 5: States of Falling in Love Phase 1 – Lust Phase 2 – Romance Phase 3 – Commitment Your Gift That Keeps On Giving Addicted to Love Integrating Chemistry with Reason In Summary Chapter 6: Evaluating Personality Types NLP Types
Five Love Languages The Enneagram Myers-Briggs Type Indicator Astrology Other Types and Beliefs In Summary Conclusion Part I
PART II – MEN AND WOMEN COMING TOGETHER Chapter 7: Primary Fantasy and Personality Attractiveness at Different Levels of Consciousness Personality Matrix In Summary Chapter 8: Our Drive To Connect Holons, Always Partial, Already Whole Characteristics of Individual Holons Social Holons In Summary Chapter 9: Passion/Intimacy/Dependence The Three Sides of the Triangle The Eight Forms of Love Aligning His and Her Triangles In Summary Chapter 10: Differences in Male and Female Consciousness Development The Male-Female Co-Creation of Consciousness From Archaic to Transpersonal Transcend and Include/Exclude Feminine Flow and Masculine Structure Create the River Errors Along the Way Ladder, Climber, View Psychological Healing In Summary Conclusion Part II
PART III – APPLYING THE INTEGRAL RELATIONSHIP MODEL IN THE REAL WORLD Chapter 11: Where Am I Coming From? Where Is She Coming From? What is a Kosmic Address? Identifying Her Perspective and Level of Consciousness Identifying Her Spiritual State-Stage Identifying Her Sexual Stage Identifying Her Animus Complex Identifying Her Type In Summary Chapter 12: Locating Your Partner and Yourself on the Compatibility Matrix Conflict Resolution and Forgiveness To Be or Not To Be—That Is the Question In Summary Chapter 13: Dating Using the Integral Relationship Model The Integral Approach Dating Strategies Internet Dating In Summary
Conclusion Part III Epilogue Appendix I: Relationship Books for All Levels/Colors Books for Red Singles Books for Amber Couples Books for Single Amber Women Books for Orange Couples Books for Orange Single Women Books for Orange Single Women and Men A Book for Orange Single Men Books for Green Singles and Couples Books for Green Singles A Book for Green Men Conclusion to Appendix I Appendix II: Links and References Footnotes Endnotes Bibliography About the Author Copyright & Permissions Backcover
LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: The model with man and woman in spiritual context Figure 2: The model with body and mind Figure 3: The model with feminine and masculine polarities Figure 4: The model with lines and levels of development Figure 5: The model with Primary Fantasy, Personality Matrix, and Triangles of Love Figure 6: The complete model with Kosmic Address and Compatibility Matrix Figure 7: Man and woman in spiritual context Figure 8: The core elements of men and women Figure 9: Body/mind of men and women Figure 10: The four polarities of both sexes Figure 11: The four polarities Figure 12: Understanding ascending, descending, agency, and communion Figure 13: The elevator metaphor for mutual exclusivity Figure 14: The mutual exclusivity of the four polarities Figure 15: Graph showing an individual’s development on various lines Figure 16: A summary of spiritual levels in world religions Figure 17: The Enneagram Figure 18: Integrating the Primary Fantasy and Personality Matrix through Triangles of Love Figure 19: Divergence in male/female Primary Fantasy Figure 20: The Personality Matrix—allowing you to map your and her development Figure 21: Example showing nested holons Figure 22: The four quadrants of individual holons. Figure 23: Characteristics of each quadrant Figure 24: The four quadrants applied to individual holons Figure 25: Every human possesses four quadrants Figure 26: Example of dancing couple and the four polarities Figure 27: The passion/intimacy/dependence triangle Figure 28: Examples of differently shaped triangles of love Figure 29: The eight forms of love Figure 30: Each lover experiences passion, intimacy, and dependence to various degrees. Figure 31: Examples showing two triangles overlaid to evaluate the form and quality of love that is experienced Figure 32: Joke about divergent psychological complexity of men and women Figure 33: Male-female dynamic in consciousness growth Figure 34: Compatibility Matrix for men and women at different levels of consciousness development Figure 35: Global challenges facing humanity
LIST OF TABLES Table 1: List of passions and interests Table 2: List of capacities, values, and ideals Table 3: List of needs Table 4: List of interpretations versus feelings Table 5: Developmental stages, their colors, and proportions of U.S. population Table 6: Fear and desire to be in partnership or alone
PREFACE The proof of the depth and embodiment of your realization will be seen in your love relationship. That’s where the proof is in the pudding. If it all collapses in your relationship, you have some work to do. And people do have a lot of difficulties in their relationships. ~ Adyashanti ~ On July 15, 2006, a woman that I loved and felt truly happy with left me. Until she walked out, I believed that we were in a good place. We seemed to be compatible in almost spooky ways, she loved me (or so she said), we lived together, held good day jobs, and, ironically enough, shared in running singles2couples.org, an Association for Healthy Relationships. A week before her departure we had returned from a romantic trip to Paris and a vacation with our children in Germany, where I introduced her to my family who also fell in love with her. Through books, groups, workshops, therapy, a spiritual path, and previous relationships (among them a 14-year marriage with three children) I had already practiced how to overcome my commitment phobia, as well as how to love unconditionally, communicate compassionately, be emotionally available, engage in tantric lovemaking, resolve conflicts, do my share of the housework, and put down the toilet seat. Still she left. What the §$%& ?!?!?! I felt by turns bewildered, ashamed, angry, frustrated, and sad. Six weeks after the breakup, I sat on my bedroom floor, contemplating what had happened to us. Earlier that year, I had become an avid student of Ken Wilber’s Integral Model of human growth and potentials. All of a sudden I had an epiphany that his insights not only held the answer to my burning question why there are so many singles and unhappy couples in this country (I had grown up in a happy family in Germany and came to the US with my (then) wife and children in 1995), but also why my girlfriend had moved out. I realized that
her leaving me was neither her nor my fault, but an inevitable consequence of our different perspectives and levels of development. I thought, surely others must have applied Wilber’s model to love relationships, but to my surprise there were no books or writings that did. None of my friends, some of them relationship book authors, Integral pioneers, therapists, spiritual teachers, and workshop leaders, had heard of any such application either, but were all very interested and encouraged me to write down my thoughts. In the process of developing this manual I attempted to describe Wilber’s fascinating insights in a more accessible way for newcomers and made several extensions to his model that may be of interest to readers who are already familiar with his work. However when I shared my ideas with women that I dated, I realized that most of them were more interested in chemistry with a successful man than in considering and integrating the multiple dimensions that are vital to a healthy love relationship. I quickly learned that walking my talk by being genuinely curious and meeting women with understanding and compassion as an opposite and equal was more conducive to creating the intimate connection that I was yearning for than sharing my Integral knowledge. As I explored how the Integral Model applied to relationships, my love life improved significantly and many of the women that I dated became my friends instead of breaking my heart. This led me to the decision to write this manual for men. I call it a manual because it is all about how to, rather than me too. After this preface, I won’t bore you with any more “I” statements, details of my life, or stories about others. Instead, this manual will provide you with a practical map that you can use; a comprehensive analysis of male-female relationships in the context of Ken Wilber’s Integral Model. The manual’s purpose is simple and clear: to make you familiar with the Integral Relationship Model and how its application will support you in improving all your relationships, especially romantic relationships with women, no matter whether you are currently single or with a partner.
INTRODUCTION It is not a measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society. ~ Jiddu Krishnamurti ~ Men generally benefit more from being in a committed love relationship/marriage than women do, but are frequently less informed about what makes love work.1 As a consequence, many emotionally and financially independent modern and postmodern women have gotten tired of taking the lion’s share of the responsibility for making their partnerships with men work. Such women no longer want to feel miserable, they blame men for their relationship problems, leave them in frustration, and prefer to remain single rather than live with relationship morons.2 In this process, women often turn to self-help books for advice. Hence, thousands of politically correct and oversimplified3 relationship books that are targeted at women and women’s interests flood the market. These books usually have a narrowly defined focus and discuss men and love relationships from a feminine perspective. If the advice in these books actually worked, then we would see an increasing number of people in healthy partnerships, not a decline. At the same time, women tend to get overwhelmed, uncomfortable, defensive, and sometimes even outright hostile when offered views on relationships that take a masculine perspective and integrate evolutionary differences between the sexes with feminine and masculine polarities along levels of developmental lines. Pushing this unconscious button would only alienate them further from men, which is NOT the intention of this manual. Thus this manual is for men only—providing a sensible solution for men who want to co-create a healthy, sustainable love relationship with a woman.
A FEW FACTS AND FIGURES A multitude of studies have evaluated the status of adult relationships today, generating lots of statistics. Some of the most relevant results are: 84 million Americans (44% of the adult population) live alone.4 Over 30 million adults are trying to find a partner online or through singles organizations.5 The number of singles is constantly increasing, with negative effects for their physical and emotional health, their socioeconomic status, and the size of their ecological footprint.6 Between 40% and 50% of marriages in America will end in divorce, 7 with only 7% of first-time marriages and 15% of all couples experiencing marital satisfaction over an extended period of time.8 Over two-thirds of divorces are initiated by women.9 The emotional and financial suffering of men tends to be larger after a divorce or breakup than that of women.10 The suicide rate of divorced fathers is ten times higher than that of divorced mothers11 and four times higher for men in general.12 The prospects for physical and emotional health, income, job security, promotions at work, sexual satisfaction, and life expectancy generally increase for men who are in a partnership or marriage. The same holds true for women only if they are with a supportive partner, otherwise they decrease. Men find most women to be sexually attractive, while modern and postmodern single women consider less than 5% of available men to be suitable partners.13 Since men naturally compete for attractive women, they get repeatedly ignored, rejected, or dumped,14 while many single women complain that there are no good available men out there. Some women even believe in the urban myth that there are two women for every man in our adult population, while in actuality the overall US population is fairly balanced between the sexes.15 Relationship books top the self-help category and approximately 90% of those books are purchased and read by women.16 Women are also the main consumers of partnership-oriented media content such as newspaper articles, magazine articles, and radio and TV programs. Women also typically outnumber men at churches, support groups, singles events, dating websites, and relationship seminars/workshops (unless the event has “sex” in the title).17 These resources appear to make women even more critical, unsatisfied, and demanding in their relationships with men, while they are often suspicious and feel manipulated if men try to improve their relationship skills by the same means.18 The bottom line is that an ever-increasing number of men who try to find a new partner or to improve their current love relationship find themselves in a confusing, painful, frustrating, and damaging mess in their partnerships with women, and none of the currently available approaches seems to solve their problems.
THE INTEGRAL APPROACH Albert Einstein said, “The significant problems that we face cannot be solved at the same level of thinking we were at when we created them.” This new level of thinking about love needs to come from men who are integrally informed and motivated to take responsibility for their part in the
co-creation of male-female partnerships. Integral means whole, complete, or comprehensive. The term was adopted by the renowned American philosopher, psychologist, and writer Ken Wilber (1949- ), who spent over four decades of his life creating a coherent map of human growth and potentials.19 He considered all recurring patterns of human wisdom and knowledge from the East and West and integrated the largest amount of research from the greatest number of disciplines—including the natural sciences (physics, chemistry, biology, neurology, and ecology), art, ethics, religion, psychology, politics, business, sociology, and spirituality—that had stood the test of time. The result was his Integral Model which has already been used in such fields as politics,20 ecology,21 economics, medicine, law, art,22 management, education, and spirituality. This manual describes an Integral Relationship Model—the first application of Ken Wilber’s Integral Model to dating and the co-creation of healthy love relationships.23
THE INTEGRAL RELATIONSHIP MODEL In this manual we will integrate the multiple dimensions and potentials of our humanness to explain how men and women co-create different forms of love relationships. Below is an outline of how the manual is organized and how the Integral Relationship Model is constructed. In Chapter 1 we will explore how our evolutionary past shapes the spiritual, physical, and psychological dimensions of our love relationships today. Note the larger spiritual context which is indicated by the outer circle in the diagram below.
Figure 1: The model with man and woman in spiritual context Part I of the manual focuses on individuals—what we’re looking for, how we develop, and how we’re different. We will begin by differentiating between the body and mind of males and females, as indicated by the divided squares inside the male and female circles in the diagram below.
Figure 2: The model with body and mind This will be followed by a description of the two opposing feminine and masculine polarities that both sexes can equally embody. These polarities are indicated by four arrows pointing away from the square inside the male and female circles.
Figure 3: The model with feminine and masculine polarities The final chapters in Part I explore multiple intelligences (lines) and growth potentials (levels), indicated by the four arrows inside each of the squares below, as well as states of consciousness and personality types.
Figure 4: The model with lines and levels of development Part II of the manual looks at relationship dynamics between men and women, including various forms of love. These forms of love are indicated in the diagram below by triangles that integrate the Primary Fantasy and personality traits that are outlined in Part I of the manual.
Figure 5: The model with Primary Fantasy, Personality Matrix, and Triangles of Love In Part III of the manual, we will explore how to apply the model in real life by identifying her Kosmic Address through questions and observations. This will allow you to place both of your Kosmic Addresses into a Compatibility-Matrix which will provide you with insights about the quality and sustainability of your love relationship.
Figure 6: The complete model with Kosmic Address and Compatibility Matrix
SOME NOTES ABOUT THIS MANUAL Throughout the manual you will learn that everyone (including you) is right from their own point of view, what these views are, how they evolved over time, and how men and women with various views relate to each other. As you embrace an increasing number of views, and balance and harmonize whatever is present in your own being, you can approach others with ever-increasing integrity, 24 compassion, love, and understanding. This will not only reduce your own suffering, but also that of others, and will drastically improve all your relationships, especially your love relationships with women. You may then open up to further growth potentials and work towards achieving them if you so choose. This book is based on four general premises: (1) We are only self-aware through our relationships (2) We are here to procreate (3) The meaning of life is to grow in consciousness towards awakening to our authentic life purpose and full capacity to love unconditionally25 (4) Love may be unconditional but relationships are not26 If these premises hold true, then male-female partnerships define our past (we would not be here without our ancestors), present (we would not be aware of our male existence and have no purpose without female reflection), and future (males and females can only fully awaken and sustain the human race together).*1 If we are at all concerned with our own health and happiness, the future of our children, the well-being of others, the sustainability of our ecosystem, and the further evolution of humanity, then we need a new, complete, accurate, multidimensional, and comprehensive Integral map of the entire territory of male-female relationships, which this manual provides. However, keep in mind that the map is not the territory, no more than a cookbook is the meal. Maps and words are only pointers to reality. The gap between the map (your vision of a healthy, happy love relationship) and the territory (your reality of being single or in an unfulfilling partnership) is called the reality gap. This is where you come in, to bridge this gap. Only if you apply the Integral Relationship Model to your real-life dating strategy and love relationships can you make the model work for you. Also be aware that there are limitations to the empirical findings that this manual is based on, especially those that result from social and gender studies. The studies may tell us a lot about randomly selected groups of men and women, such as “on average men are taller than women,” or “women are more emotional than men,” but little about individuals. While based on the latest scientific research from the West and enduring wisdom traditions from the East, the content of this manual can only serve as a generalizing orientation that needs your careful verification on an individual level, such as, “am I really taller than she is.” In no way should you use what you learn in the following pages to label, discriminate against, or take advantage of women. To keep the text succinct and flowing, you will find additional thoughts, details, references, and resources for further reading in an abundance of endnotes. You may also skip to the summaries at the end of each chapter if you are already familiar with the chapter’s topic. Throughout the manual we will refer to women whom you romantically relate to as partners and love relationships as partnerships, to distinguish them from the people with whom you have non-romantic relationships.
A FINAL SUGGESTION Don’t share the content of this manual with your date or partner, no matter how excited you might feel. Rather, surprise her with your presence, kindness, understanding, warmth, confidence, curiosity, empathy, and integrity. When it comes to dating and love relationships, women want to know who you are by experiencing your genuine and authentic self, so that they can learn to trust you. If you share your theoretical book knowledge with them, you will always get the same reaction: “You have all these ideas and concepts in your head, but I don’t feel them coming from your heart. I want to get to know the real you who I can trust and connect with.” In other words, “I don’t feel any intimacy, connection, attraction, or chemistry when you talk about stuff from books.” In effect, she is saying, “Don’t explain the map to me, just drive me to the ocean.”
CHAPTER 1 Understanding the Dimensions of Love You have to know the past to understand the present. ~ Carl Sagan ~ Throughout this manual we will discuss two conditional dimensions of love relationships between men and women: First, the physical dimension, which is motivated by our persistent drive to procreate and to raise healthy offspring. Without this drive we would not be here today and would have no future as a species. We may call this dimension selfless love or Agape, which requires compassion and self-sacrifice. Second is the psychological dimension of love, which is driven by our yearning to become complete and to transcend our illusionary sense of separation and aloneness in the universe. This dimension we may call the art of love or Eros, as it requires creativity and skill to co-create a healthy love relationship. Both of these dimensions are set in the larger context of the ever-present unconditional spiritual dimension of Love, which is the ground of all being.
THE SPIRITUAL DIMENSION OF LOVE
Figure 7: Man and woman in the spiritual context Modern physics, philosophy, and mysticism all point us to an infinite and eternal/timeless oneness or connectedness. Everything, including you, is part of this oneness that has been given many names such as God, Spirit, the Absolute, the Infinite/Eternal, Pure Awareness, Ever-Present Origin, Unified Field, or Ground of All Being. This oneness can only experience itself by splitting into the “two-ness” that we perceive as the duality of past and future, emptiness and form, light and dark, male and female, feminine and masculine, etc. By forgetting that these opposites are ultimately the eternal and infinite One, the illusionary play of time, emptiness, and form can begin. The deep yearning of our soul to love and to be loved unconditionally is the call to return to this oneness through ego transcendence. The mind cannot grasp this oneness. Unless you are permanently enlightened (whatever that means), you can only get glimpses of oneness at moments of absolute stillness and presence, during a peak or near-death experience, in certain drug-induced states, or in transcendental tantric sexual union.27 This oneness cannot be thought of or spoken about either, since that would split one into two and make it separate from you. Words and concepts can only point to it, and many sacred texts and poems attempt to do so.28 Why this oneness “went through all the bother to bring the universe into existence”29 remains a mystery to scientists, philosophers, and mystics to this day. True unconditional Love (with a capital L) can be seen as the experience of a return to this oneness.30 So now that we are done speaking about the unspeakable (that was easy, wasn’t it?), we can move on to talk about the physical world and evolution as we understand it today.
THE EVOLVING PHYSICAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL DIMENSIONS OF LOVE Throughout history, human males and females have co-created mutually compatible biological and psychological characteristics that drive us to sustain the human race. What may look like male oppression of females from today’s perspective was actually (with the regrettable exceptions that we see to this day in some parts of the world) a mutually beneficial arrangement for the survival of both sexes, which has resulted in significant increases in human population, longer life expectancy, and more comfort. Today we experience this evolutionary drive to procreate and to complement each other’s psyche through various forms of love. Let’s now take a brief look at history from the point of view of the evolution of the sexes. For a long time after the Big Bang about 13.7 billion years ago, there was only space and dead matter (quantum particles, atoms, clouds of gas, rocks, stars, planets, and galaxies). About 4 billion years ago the first biological life forms appeared on earth as simple sexless organisms.31 About 1 billion years ago, the opposite sex emerged when certain life forms evolved to reproduce by combining their genetic material through sexual reproduction and so passed it on to future generations. Today it is widely believed that mutations in genes generated an increasing variety of species32 of which, through sexual and natural selection, only the fittest and/or most adaptable/cooperative survived to further procreate.33 About 225 million years ago, the first warm blooded mammals came into existence.
About 7 million years ago, the predecessors to our human ancestors, the great apes, began to inhabit the African jungles.34 About 5 million years ago, receding forests and declining supplies of plant foods forced our predecessors, the great apes, to descend from their trees. Males learned to hunt small, sick, and injured animals, while females specialized in the gathering of edible fruits, roots, shoots, and leaves. The addition of animal protein to their diet allowed the brains of our ancestors to grow and created a literal meat hunger inside of them.35 Males began to band together to hunt ever larger animals to satisfy their own and the carnivorous appetites of their female mates and offspring. This required males to design and implement clever plans, display good judgment, operate inside hierarchical structures, sit silently for hours, be singlefocused on their prey, kill without remorse, and to develop simple verbal and non-verbal communication skills. The most productive hunters, who were naturally tall, well-built, intelligent, clever, industrious, and competitive, became capable of providing up to three times more meat than their weaker peers. This gave them access to females with the best reproductive qualities—who were naturally young and healthy-looking—while less productive males partnered with physically less attractive and older females. At the same time, females sharpened their sensory awareness to scan the land for edible vegetables and fruit, identify them through their colors and smells, share information about their location with other females, and monitor the ripening cycles of nature. To ensure that their own genetic material would be passed down to future generations, males became protective of the females they had mated with. At the same time, it became advantageous for females to be sexual with only one male to ensure his ongoing commitment as her protector and provider once she became pregnant and bore their children.36 This led to the earliest forms of monogamous partnerships and the establishment of nuclear families37 that bonded together in small bands and clans. Through sexual and natural selection, the offspring of the most successful male hunters and healthiest (by today’s standards sexiest/prettiest) females survived long enough to procreate. The resulting mating behavior became deeply embedded in the physical and psychological makeup of modern humans.38 This can be seen today in the universal male desire for young, vital, and healthy-looking females (most men are turned on by a hot Playboy model or porn star), and the female fantasy of a committed, successful protector/provider who is benevolent towards her and her children, while competing aggressively with other males (most women like chick flicks and romance novels with a striking James Bond-style hero in them).39 About 750,000 years ago, the ability to harness fire for protection from wild animals, for cooking food (which makes it much easier for the body to absorb nutrients), and for seeing in the dark allowed for communal gatherings at night and further advanced the physiological growth and social bonding of these early family clans. About 400,000 years ago, swinging the biggest club and killing the largest animals became no longer good enough to woo the most desirable females, who started to look for additional fitness indicators in their suitors; they wanted to be romanced and entertained. In response, early Stone Age males forayed into the creation of art (cave paintings, body ornaments, drumming, and dances) and developed language.40 About 200,000 years ago, the first modern humans (Homo sapiens) entered the scene. Like their ancestors, they were nomadic hunters and gatherers. About 12,000 years ago, the lifestyle of some families became more settled when horticultural communities found ways to cultivate a variety of crops and to herd small animals around their dwellings. These activities could be largely performed by pregnant and child-rearing women, while men expanded their hunting territories ever further from home to find enough game to feed their growing families, bands, clans, and tribes. By that time, about 1,000,000 humans had spread to all livable areas of the planet. About 8,000 years ago, the invention of the plow (most likely by a man) pulled by domesticated large animals such as oxen, heralded the era of agriculture41 when hunting, gathering, and horticulture alone could no longer feed the human population, which had by then grown to 5,000,000. Plowing was handled exclusively by men, because pregnant and child-rearing women could not perform the strenuous work. Consequently, patriarchal42 social structures developed as men—in addition to being hunters and protectors—took on the major responsibility for providing foodstuffs. As a result, men started to dominate the emerging public sphere of government, education, religion, and politics, while women dominated the private sphere of family, hearth, and home. This division of labor is often referred to as male production and female reproduction, 43 which allowed women to focus on the lighter and less dangerous chores around the house and of tending to their offspring, while males risked their lives through hard labor, dangerous hunts, and defending the territory of their families and clans. Further advancements in farming techniques helped to produce a surplus of food, especially in fertile regions of the world with milder climates, such as the Mediterranean, along the Nile River, and in China. This freed up a certain number of creative men to pursue endeavors like specialized warfare, new inventions such as the wheel and axle, beer, sailboats (around 5000 BCE), competitive sports (in China by 4000 BCE), architecture, and the creation of more elaborate art objects, while women continued to focus on homemaking and raising their children. About 6,000 years ago, small cities and states were founded by men to house some of the 10,000,000 humans that lived on earth by then. With more people on the planet, new conflicts arose between them, and larger wars started to be fought by men to protect their families and farming/hunting territories, gain status, and win the hearts of women. About 4,000 years ago, the first monotheistic religions that worshipped a male God, and generally saw women as inferior, were conceived by men, and recorded history began with the earliest written documents that we know of today. About 3,000 years ago, 50,000,000 people populated the earth and the first large city-states were established in Greece. Athens became the home of such influential philosophers44 as Socrates, Plato and Aristotle. The latter wrote in his book Politics: “the male is by nature superior, and the female inferior; and the one rules, and the other is ruled.” These philosophers laid the foundation for modern civilization and the Western thought systems that remain highly influential to this day.45 About 2,000 years ago, 200,000,000 humans were alive, and the Romans had built their empire, which was later broken up into the European states as we know them today. About 500 years ago, the world’s population had doubled again to 400,000,000 when Columbus and other modern male explorers made their land discoveries, which led to worldwide trading and exploration, while Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler, and Newton made the first modern scientific discoveries. In an ongoing effort to gain the love of women and to improve their quality of life, men made tremendous technical, philosophical, social, and political advancements during the Enlightenment Period in the eighteenth century.46 About 200 years ago, (around the year 1800), the human population hit the billion mark, and the physical strength of males and animals started to be replaced with the power of steam engines and modern weapons during the Industrial Revolution.47 These new technologies allowed women to gradually enter into domains that had been previously developed and occupied exclusively by men, and gave rise to the female liberation
movement,48 which later led to the various forms and waves of feminism.49 Around 1900, men granted women the right to vote,50 to receive an equal education,51 and to work in any profession they were qualified for, gradually earning equal or even higher pay for equal work.52 By that time 1.6 billion humans walked the earth, only to rise to 6 billion by the year 2000, which is, from an evolutionary standpoint, an incredible success story. In 1960, the sexual revolution was spurred by the invention of the Pill (by a man),53 which gave women control over their reproductive capacity. In 1970, no-fault divorce laws started to be established throughout the US,54 which caused divorce rates to double when wives started to initiate divorce twice as often as husbands did to end their marriages.55 In 1990, third-wave feminism empowered modern and postmodern women to forge their independent way into all areas of Western society as we see it today.56 While modern and postmodern women have been liberated from their traditional gender roles and economic dependence on men by gaining unlimited (if they choose) access to traditionally male-dominated domains and full control over their reproductive capacity, men remain largely stuck in their traditional roles as protector and provider57 and continue to depend on females for sex, love, purpose, and emotional support.58 To win the hearts of desirable women, men still have to be success-oriented in their educational and career choices, take higher risks of losing their lives through stressful, hard, and dangerous work,59 or be the disposable sex in wars.60 Modern and postmodern women, on the other hand, can afford to be fulfillment-oriented by generating income from professions that are personally satisfying and financially rewarding, while benefitting from husbands (and ex-husbands),61 benevolent men (who are often naïve/needy), sex partners, and/or boyfriends who support and pay them in exchange for love, company, and sex (think dinner, movies, vacations, diamond ring, car, house, etc.). In other words, males throughout history have had to become ever more successful, sophisticated, creative, inventive, and competitive to amass increasing amounts of power, status, and wealth to win the hearts of desirable females. This dynamic, as we slowly realize, cannot be endlessly sustained without destroying our ecosystem and forcing others into poverty and starvation. On the other hand, it continues to suffice for females to be healthy in body and mind, as well as sexually available, supportive, and understanding towards males to attract them. Gender Mainstreaming is the latest emergence in the evolutionary development between the sexes. It was formulated at the United Nations by women who realized that advocating for the rights, viewpoints, and benefits of one sex only (women) is against both sexes.62 In the October 26, 2009 issue of Time magazine, the article “The State of the American Woman”63 concluded that, “ ... we will soon be having parallel conversations: What needs to be done to free American men to realize their [emphasis added] full potential? You can imagine the whole conversation flipping in a single generation. It’s no longer a man’s world. Nor is it a woman’s nation. It’s a cooperative, with bylaws under constant negotiation and expectations that profits be equally shared.” These latest insights about gender issues, if seen and accepted by both sexes, open up new possibilities for the co-creation of partnerships between integrally informed men and post-feminist/post-postmodern women, who do not only demand equal rights but also assume equal responsibilities, for example to protect our ecosystem and to reward non-violence. These new couples will treat each other as equals while honoring their sexual differences and so point the way into a sustainable and peaceful future for all humanity.64
IN SUMMARY Seen from an absolute spiritual perspective, Love is the everpresent ground of all that is. On the relative physical and psychological plane, love is our means to sustain the human race and to overcome our sense of separation. For thousands of years, males have advanced their fitness to win the hearts of desirable females and to augment the life quality and safety of their families through protecting and providing. In return, women cared for men and rewarded them with their admiration, love, support, company, sex, and children. With the rise of modernity—which gave birth to female liberation and the feminist movement—this long-time equilibrium started to shift. It now provides modern and postmodern women with equal rights and opportunities without equal responsibilities. They have become legally, financially, and emotionally independent, and only consider being in a partnership with a man if he can significantly augment their quality of life. This leaves many average and disadvantaged men struggling to prevent their wives from divorcing them or to find a partner in the first place. The latest development in the evolution of the sexes is called Gender Mainstreaming. It holds the possibility of partnerships between men and women as opposites and equals and promises a peaceful and sustainable future for all humanity by promoting true gender equality (rights and responsibilities) while honoring sexual differences.
PART I – THE BIOLOGICAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL MAKEUP OF MEN AND WOMEN Romantic love is either all I want to talk about, or the last thing I want to talk about, depending on the hour. When I’m in the mood to discuss it, it seems huge and important. When I’m not in the mood, it seems almost neurotic. One thing remains constant, however, regardless of how I view it: romantic love is a mystery. ~ Marianne Williamson ~ In Part I of the manual we will define the core elements of the Integral Relationship Model: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Body (sex-based differences, including the Primary Fantasy), mind (learned gender roles), and soul (feminine/masculine polarities) Lines of human development (intelligences and other potentials) Levels of consciousness, anima/animus complex, sexual, and spiritual development States of falling in love Personality types
Figure 8: The core elements of men and women Elements two to five are based on Wilber’s original Integral Model, so if you’re familiar with his work, the labels match. Note that we’ll discuss Wilber’s first element, the four quadrants, in Part II.
CHAPTER 2 Understanding the Differences Between the Sexes In this country, you gotta make the money first. Then when you get the money, you get the power. Then when you get the power, then you get the women. ~ Al Pacino in “Scarface” ~ While the 20th century brought legal and socioeconomic equality with men for modern and postmodern women, the unique biological and genetic makeup that distinguishes the sexes has remained the same. To gain a deeper understanding of the male-female dynamic, we will now further distinguish between (1) essential sex differences between males and females (body), (2) learned gender roles of men and women (mind), and (3) the feminine and masculine polarities that can be uniquely embodied by both sexes (soul). Throughout this manual we’ll use the following terminology: When referring to biological differences (sex), we’ll speak of male/female. When referring to learned social patterns (gender), we’ll speak of men/women. When referring to polarity (soul), we’ll speak of masculine/feminine.
Figure 9: Body/mind of men and women In this chapter, we will explore each dimension as the first element of our Integral Relationship Model.*2
SEX: PHYSICAL/BIOLOGICAL DIFFERENCES BETWEEN MALES AND FEMALES (BODY) Sex (as a noun) refers to the physiological, biological, and genetic makeup of males and females. It has evolved over billions of years and is unaffected by social change. Typical human males have a penis and XY chromosomes, grow more body hair, turn bald, and produce ten times more testosterone than females, who have a vagina, XX chromosomes, breasts, higher-pitched voices, more estrogen, and think less often about sex. These differences have been hardwired into our bodies by evolution, and require a sex change procedure to be altered. As a consequence, there are distinct mating behaviors for heterosexual men and women that have become equally hardwired: Men are conditioned to be physically attracted to young (or at least, younger), vital, and healthy-looking females with smooth skin, shiny hair, wellaligned complete white teeth, symmetric facial and body features, wide hips, small waists (ideally with an 0.7 hip-to-waist ratio),65 sparkling eyes, and full breasts, which are all indicators for fertility and the ability to bear healthy children.66 Women are intuitively drawn to benevolent, strong, tall,67 successful, intelligent, healthy-looking, and entertaining males with money, future earning potential, power, and social status, who commit to and love them exclusively. These attributes are all indicators for good genes and a male’s capacity to be a strong protector and provider.68 The sexual fantasies of males are objectified in the offerings of the porn industry69 (which are condemned by society), while romance novels70 and “chick flicks” (which are sanctioned by society) represent the equivalents that cater to the sexual fantasies of females.
SEX-BASED DIFFERENCES IN MALE/FEMALE PRIMARY FANTASY Researchers have identified how biological sex differences result in sex-based fantasies that are consistent throughout all cultures. These fantasies run deep in our unconscious, are almost impossible to transcend,71 and their fulfillment is the prerequisite for any romantic interest in a member of the opposite sex. We’re going to refer to them collectively as the Primary Fantasy. All other qualities that lovers typically seek in a partner are secondary to the Primary Fantasy and usually gender-neutral. They include shared values, interests, lifestyle choices, temperaments, plans and dreams for the future, and compatible needs around time spent together, money, and sex.72 Once the Primary Fantasy is fulfilled, a male’s loving feelings for a sexy female and hers for a successful male are experienced as absolutely real and authentic. Their bodies signal the potential to produce and raise healthy offspring to their owners by increasing the production of thrilling hormones that foster lust, desire, and intimacy, while temporarily impairing the rational faculties of the love-struck couple’s brains so that they ignore red flags and have sex with each other.
Lovers with this experience often speak of the chemistry between them and they are right.73 Lust is triggered in males and females by an increased production of testosterone, feelings of intimacy are promoted by dopamine, norepinephrine, and serotonin, and attachment forms through elevated levels of oxytocin in females and vasopressin in males.74 Some of these hormones are as potent as illegal drugs. They can send their recipients on unknown highs, get them addicted, and lead to painful withdrawal symptoms when they drop.75 Males get attracted and fall in love much more quickly than females, since their Primary Fantasy is solely based on her physical appearance and sexual radiance.76 Seeing an attractive woman, looking at sexy pictures, watching an erotic movie, or a stripper in a bar can be enough to elevate the testosterone levels that turn him on. And often, to the utter frustration and puzzlement of females, he can be turned off as quickly once he has conquered the object of his desire and goes on the hunt for another sex object to get his fix. Attractive females in alliance with the cosmetic, beauty, and fashion industry, 77 as well as clever advertisers for goods and services have, of course, been long aware of the effect that images of sexy females have on males. They constantly bombard men with seductive messages that suggest how making and spending large sums of money for status symbols (e.g., diamond ring, car, watch), consuming the right products (e.g., beer, aftershave), or risking their health and lives (fighting in the army, embarking on dangerous adventures, and engaging in violent/competitive sports), will get them the woman of their dreams.78 Females usually experience the same initial spark when they see a physically attractive male, but get turned off quickly if his socioeconomic status and personality do not meet their Primary Fantasy (unless they are looking for a one-night-stand or “boy-toy”).79 Unlike males, females are much more likely to warm up romantically to an older and physically less attractive partner over time if his financial assets, social status, and character traits meet their expectations. While the attention of males is almost exclusively directed towards her body, jumping her bones, and how she will look on his arm, to her, his income, character, intelligence, wit, loyalty, stature, security, use of language, manners, education, job, accomplishments, health, lifestyle, car, home, other material possessions, retirement plan, circle of friends, and integrity are of high significance in addition to (and sometimes instead of) good looks.80 If the sexual attraction is mutual, she will still often need more time to build the confidence that he is able, willing, and available to make an exclusive commitment as her benevolent, generous, trustworthy, and consistent protector and provider. The evolutionary reason for her scrutiny and selectivity before choosing him as a lover and partner lies in the possibility of her getting pregnant. To conceive a child is a much larger emotional and life-changing investment for her than for him.81 Even if couples use methods of contraception or can no longer conceive children, her hormonal system responds in very much the same way as if she could get pregnant, in which case she would have to endure nine months of physical discomfort, could not conceive another man’s child, would risk her life during childbirth, and would be obligated to take care of the child for years to come, while the father could easily abandon her and give his semen, love, and support to another woman.82
THE SEX-BASED FEMALE FEAR—MALE SHAME DYNAMIC The biological differences between the sexes also lead to the primary emotional reactions of fear in females and shame in males. Fear (typically fear of abandonment) arises in her when she experiences an emotional disconnect, usually after the initial chemistry is gone, or if she worries that he falls short as her committed protector and provider. Her fear is triggered when their communication breaks down, if he shows an interest in other women, if he reveals weaknesses, appears incompetent, complains or worries about his job, becomes unemployed, engages in addictive behaviors, or gets defeated. In her efforts to get him to reconnect with her emotionally, to receive reassurance of his support, or to improve his performance, she often starts to withhold sex, and to nag, criticize, challenge, humiliate, compare, or passive-aggressively ignore him, without having a clue how she is undermining their partnership by doing so.83 If he does not respond in a favorable way, she is quick to lose her faith and to accuse him of not listening to or understanding her, and of being insensitive, emotionally unavailable, passive aggressive, or in denial, which may or may not be the case. Her efforts to re-connect and to support him to perform better only push him further away so that he can avoid her ongoing emasculations84 and hide his primary emotion of shame for not being good enough to make her happy. Instead of providing her with the connection, emotional safety, strength, and reassurance that she is longing for, he may get angry at her, start to work longer hours, try to make more money, spend more time with his buddies, engage in his hobbies, embark on a spiritual path, or become whiny and depressed.85 She, on the other hand, does not know how to inspire and reward him by showing empathy and to appreciate him for the things he does (even if they are little) by recognizing/praising and having sex with him, which would often open him up to provide her with more of the support, love, and reassurance that she craves.86 Both partners are then prone to discuss their unhappiness and frustration with members of the opposite sex outside their relationship who show more empathy. Such behavior is called emotional infidelity and is obviously a slippery slope, as sexual infidelity lurks right around the corner. Because of their different evolutionary conditioning, he is usually better equipped to handle her emotional infidelity as long as she does not cheat sexually on him, while she can be forgiving about his sexual infidelity as long as she is assured of his love, financial support, and commitment to her.87 If you experience the fear-shame dynamic in your love relationship, you may be able to turn things around by listening to your partner’s fears and concerns without guilt and without getting defensive or withdrawn, and by reassuring her of your love, loyalty, and support.88
THE SOCIAL TABOO AROUND THE SEXUAL SELECTION PROCESS The Primary Fantasy and the resulting sexual selection process that underlies most of our partnerships is a highly vulnerable and emotionally charged issue for singles and couples alike, and is therefore rarely addressed scientifically or publicly for several reasons:89 (1) Hardly anybody wants to publicly state or admit that the primary criteria for the attractiveness of females are their age, physique, looks, and sexual radiance—in short, their “fuckability factor,” and those of males are their socioeconomic status, competitiveness, and generosity.90 (2) It is hard for singles to face the fact that they may have unresolved psychological issues that prevent them from having a healthy partnership, or that they date way outside their league. Women often have unrealistic expectations of attracting a “prince in shining armor” or “sugar daddy” who they are too old and ugly for, while men may fantasize about younger, sexually attractive Playboy model types whom they can’t afford. (3) Social, radical, and eco-feminists91 are in denial about the role that sexually attractive and partnership-oriented females (oops ... they are women too) play in the creation of social injustice, wars, and the destruction of our ecosystem, by rewarding those males who are most ruthless in competing for power, status, and wealth (at the expense of the environment as well as other women and men) with their love, company, and sex, in
exchange for a safe and carefree lifestyle.92 (4) Couples don’t want to be confronted with the possibility that they have confused the fulfillment of each other’s Primary Fantasy with real love, especially if their partnership is in trouble after the initial chemistry faded away. (5) Singles who lack the necessary physical or material assets to attract a partner don’t want to be reminded of the painful feelings that they have endured after previous rejections from members of the opposite sex whose hearts they could not win. While the Integral Relationship Model doesn’t ignore the important role that the Primary Fantasy and the resulting hormonal reactions play in the co-creation of partnerships, it also does not reduce partner choices or the quality of love relationships to these criteria. In Part II of the manual we will therefore further differentiate how the Primary Fantasy is experienced at different levels of consciousness development, and integrate it with the other elements of the Integral Relationship Model.
UNDERSTANDING SEX-BASED DIFFERENCES REDUCES SUFFERING As many psychologists, anthropologists, and sociologists have confirmed,93 and as you know from your own experiences and observations, “men look for sex objects, and women look for success objects,” “men want the one thing from every woman, while women want everything from one man,” and “for men the physical attraction (and sex) causes the relationship, while for most women, the relationship causes the physical attraction (and sex).” Your investment in this manual may have already paid off if you were unaware of the extent that the often unconscious Primary Fantasy plays in the sexual selection process. This insight can save you a lot of money, grief, and frustration if you can avoid an expensive and devastating breakup/divorce by becoming more understanding of your spouse or by separating amicably if mutual chemistry was the primary motivator for your partnership in the first place and is now gone. If you are single, you can stop going on costly dates with attractive, high-maintenance females whom you can’t afford and can’t make happy in the long run.94
GENDER: CULTURAL/LEARNED DIFFERENCES BETWEEN MEN AND WOMEN (MIND) Gender refers to the roles that society and culture have assigned to each sex. Gender roles are learned during childhood and beyond, as we observe and are told how to think and behave appropriately as men or women in our society. 95 These roles vary among cultures, as they are not hardwired, unlike the sex-based Primary Fantasies that are consistent throughout the world and human history. 96 Nevertheless, gender roles are deeply ingrained into our mind and often unconscious. Social scientists and feminists still debate which characteristics of males and females are created by nature (sex) or nurture (cultural background and social conditioning). The boundaries between them are arguably fluid and certainly blurred.97 For example, we speak of transgender if a man or woman feels themselves to be in the body of the wrong sex and acts accordingly, such as a cross-dresser. Gender is usually expressed through the type of clothes we wear, customary length of hair, the professions we choose, hours we spend at work, what and whom we play with, who proposes and buys the diamond ring, assignment of chores around the house,98 and all other gender-related social roles and cultural norms. It is hard to break out of one’s assigned gender roles, as society puts much pressure on men and women to act according to their sex (for example that men marry younger women, can’t be fulfillment-oriented, or have to be the main breadwinner), but it is certainly possible if we make them conscious and intelligently question the status quo that limits us in our freedom of expression (e.g., the recent trend of older women, so called cougars, dating younger men). Social researchers have found that across 25 nations, the most common and widely accepted gender stereotypes for men are: adventurous, dominant, forceful, independent, strong, aggressive, autocratic, daring, enterprising, robust, stern, active, courageous, progressive, rude, severe, unemotional, and wise. Women are stereotyped as sentimental, submissive, superstitious, affectionate, dreamy, sensitive, attractive, dependent, emotional, fearful, softhearted, weak, sexy, curious, gentle, mild, charming, and talkative.99 It can be quite illuminating and entertaining to learn about sex- and gender-based differences between men and women through pop psychology books and workshops100 that go into more depth about stereotypes, such as: Men are from Mars, single-focused,101 compartmentalize, go the shortest route between points A and B, don’t ask for directions, think before they feel, retreat into their cave or watch TV to deal with problems, think hierarchically, build structures, are rational, have a hunter’s “fuck it or kill it” instinct, pursue women for sex, want to problem-solve, and work harder to become better providers when their partner seems unhappy. Women are from Venus, multi-task, network, like to meander, ask for directions, feel before they think, need to talk to deal with problems, think laterally, go with the flow, are passive and peaceful, have healing energy, give sex, receive, follow, radiate, and are more visual. As we will explore in Part II, gender roles are not as closely tied to the sexes as is suggested by stereotyping, and the dynamics shift and can be transcended as men and women evolve.
POLARITIES: MASCULINE/FEMININE POTENTIALS FOR BOTH SEXES (SOUL)
Figure 10: The four polarities of both sexes While sex-based differences are biological (body) and gender roles are learned (mind), the potentials to embody womanly (or feminine) and manly (or masculine) qualities are equal for both sexes (soul).102 The Integral Relationship Model equates the feminine with descending and communion, which are opposed by the masculine qualities of ascending and agency. The two pairs of polarities can be visualized as a graph (shown below) with ascending and descending on the vertical axis, and communion and agency on the horizontal axis. You may envision these polarities as the positive and negative poles of a battery or magnet that are necessary for sexual energy to flow and to keep the human psyche in a healthy balance.
Figure 11: The four polarities Consider which qualities resonate most with you and which sound familiar from observations in others while you read the descriptions of the four polarities below.
ASCENDING Ascending103 (or self-transcendence) is the upward drive towards heaven, the absolute, union, spirit, or Godhead, away from the fragmented details of the manifest world and its many forms. Einstein’s famous quote aptly describes ascending: “I want to know how God created this world. I am not interested in this or that phenomenon, in the spectrum of this or that element. I want to know His thoughts, the rest are details.” Ascending is also characterized as “the love that reaches up” (Eros) that brings forth new creations by arranging fragments into larger wholes, such as notes into symphonies, ingredients into meals, colors into paintings, words into sentences, knowledge into wisdom, individuals into couples, or communities into societies. Ascenders look at reality from a distance and see fractions as part of the larger whole or a greater totality. They perceive the world from an extended bird’s eye view and try to rise ever higher in consciousness to encompass everything. Ascending energy expresses itself through wisdom, creativity, novelty, visionary concepts, emptiness, and stillness. Healthy ascending is characterized by a desire to improve, to go beyond, to grow, to transcend, to create, and to think big. This is accomplished by gaining wider perspectives of the self and the nature of things. It requires a willingness to change by letting go of old paradigms and not sweating the small stuff. Unhealthy ascending ignores, represses, controls, and dominates the lower, instead of embracing and caring for it. It denies feelings, the body, sexuality, and nature. The fear of ascenders is to get dragged down, engulfed, absorbed, and lost (Phobos).104
DESCENDING Descending105 (or self-immanence) is the downward drive towards earth, into the world of many manifestations and the body. Descenders celebrate life and its many forms, the body, and their sexuality. They go with the flow, are in touch with the richness of the manifest world, and experience things from the fullness of existence by diving in deep. Descending is also characterized as “the love that reaches down” (Agape), embracing everything—including earth and all its inhabitants—with selfless compassion and devotion. Descending energy expresses itself through feelings, empathy, emotions, warmth, movement, surrender, fullness, and flow. A descender perceives the world from the inside. Healthy descending means to be connected with and sensitive to the richness and fullness of the world, to be down-to-earth and in touch with one’s body, feelings, emotions, and sexuality. Unhealthy descending means to be overwhelmed, fused with, and run by the many details of life and its manifestations, feelings, earthly desires, and needs. The fear of descenders is to lose touch, to get lost, or to be dissociated from the fullness of life and its forces (Thanatos).106
Figure 12: Understanding ascending, descending, agency, and communion AGENCY Agency107 (or self-preservation) is the drive towards wholeness, taking action through one’s own will, making independent choices, and exerting power. People with a tendency towards agency have a desire to maintain their own identity, personality, individuality, independence, and autonomy. They focus on rights, rules, laws, and justice that protect and serve the interests of the individual, and are defined by their own decisions, success, and free will, rather than their environment and the opinion of others (it is better to fail at living your own life, than to succeed at living someone else’s). Healthy agency supports the autonomous functioning of the individual. Unhealthy agency leads to alienation and dissociation from others. The fear of agentic people is to lose the freedom to make independent choices, and to become dependent on others for their well-being.
COMMUNION Communion (or self-adaptation) is the drive to connect (commune) with others, to be part of and act in the interest of the unit or group, and to cooperate. Communion is expressed through qualities of care, responsibility, relationship, lateral bonding, connection, communication, empathy, intimacy, joining, and participation. Communal people feel that their well-being depends on their ability to contribute, trust, depend on others, fit into their environment, and maintain a mutual support system of give and take. Healthy communion is expressed through the peaceful, responsible (response-able), considerate, and caring connection between people. Unhealthy communion leads to fusion, dependency, neediness, and clinging—with the loss of one’s own will, individuality, and autonomy—which eventually leads to resentment. The fear of communion-oriented (communal) people is to be abandoned, unsupported, and alone.
MUTUAL EXCLUSIVITY A person can either be agentic or communal, or ascending or descending, but not communal and agentic or ascending and descending at the same time—just as it is impossible to simultaneously breathe in (descend) and out (ascend), or to be together (communion) and apart (agentic). It can be challenging to clearly differentiate between the four polarities of ascending/agency and descending/communion, because they may initially sound and feel the same. One way to do so is to realize that you can ascend or descend in either an agentic or communal way (think of going up or down in an elevator alone or in a group).
Figure 13: The elevator metaphor for mutual exclusivity You may—for example—want to experience Godhead (ascend) and go off alone into the desert (agency) to meditate, empty your mind, and chastise your body, or chant mantras in a group with others (communal). Or you may want to comfort and nurture your body (descend), either by taking a hot herbal bath and eating chocolate-covered strawberries in solitude (agency), or by joining a group of friends for a healthy meal and intimate sharing of feelings, followed by ecstatic group dancing (communal). In other words, ascending or descending either appears in a communal or an agentic way. The resulting intersection between the two lines provides you with the feminine or masculine address.
Figure 14: The mutual exclusivity of the four polarities Our natural impulse is to equate the two feminine polarities (descending and communion) with females and the masculine polarities (ascending and agency) with males, which is the original meaning of the terms.108 This congruency may have been the norm (or at least expected behavior) in the past, but it often shifts in modern and postmodern individuals, as we will explore in more detail later. It is therefore important not to automatically link the two, as both sexes have the potential to embody any of the four polarities in a healthy or unhealthy way. Some people are pathologically stuck in either one of the positive or negative directions, while others have learned to move more freely between the healthy expressions of all of them as their needs or the situation at hand require.
BALANCING POLARITIES FOR BETTER RELATIONSHIPS The goal is to balance and harmonize the healthy qualities of the feminine and masculine polarities at all levels of our being (body, mind, heart, and soul), which can be only effectively achieved in an intimate love relationship. It takes two people with opposite polarities to create the femininemasculine dynamic that is then experienced as the sexual attraction and synergy of the couple. In this respect, opposites certainly attract and similarities repel, just as the positive and negative poles of two magnets do. The level of appreciation for the different qualities of each polarity defines the couple’s ability to complement each other, and to co-create a whole that is larger than the sum of its parts. If partners are energetically too close, little or no sexual magnetism and synergy will be experienced; if they are further apart than they can tolerate, especially in an unhealthy way, they will experience a disconnect, aversion, and ongoing conflict.109 By becoming aware of the four polarities, you can gain a sense of where you and your partner’s energies are at any given moment in time, and complement and balance each other by developing a wide range of fluidity in its healthy form in each direction. Tantra,110 which means “to weave and expand continuously,” or the union of wisdom (ascending) and compassion (descending), is an accumulation of Eastern spiritual practices that attempts to harmonize the four polarities, especially ascending and descending, heaven and earth, or Shiva and Shakti—expressing the assumption that God manifests through both. In the West, Tantra has become largely associated with the art of using ritual and techniques to reach transcendental states of consciousness (or to experience God) through sexual union. No wonder lovers often exclaim “Oh my God” during ecstatic lovemaking and orgasm. In the Eastern traditions, tantric sex was reserved for highly realized spiritual practitioners after they had passed through many years of rigorous nonsexual tantric training.111
A METAPHOR FOR THE POLARITIES: THE RIVER A wonderful metaphor to envision the feminine and masculine polarities is to see them as a river. The depth and span of the water represent the feminine qualities of descending and communion. The height and distance of the banks indicate the masculine capacities for ascending and agency. Together they co-create the river, with the feminine fullness/flow and the masculine emptiness/structure. It is a true co-creation, as neither the banks nor the flow can be said to have come first, nor can they exist without each other. Without the structure and direction of the banks, the feminine is without orientation and uncontained; without the fullness and flow of the water, the masculine is without purpose and fulfillment. Even though males and females may equally embody the feminine fullness/flow or the masculine structure/direction, they can’t do so at the same time, just as you can’t simultaneously inhale and exhale, be still and moving, alone and in company, empty and full, on top and at the bottom, etc. Yes, you can try to alternate back and forth—and many singles do so—but something will always be lacking and so contributes to the stress and depression in modern and postmodern people. Only through the feminine-masculine co-creation between opposites and equals can there be a return to oneness (awakening) on all levels of our being and a balanced life.
IN SUMMARY Males and females are characterized by their sex, gender, and feminine/masculine polarities. Sex refers to the hardwired biological makeup which leads to the different Primary Fantasies, gender refers to learned social and cultural roles as men and women, and the feminine/masculine polarities represent universal “mannish” and “womanish” qualities that may be embodied equally by both sexes. Denying, confusing, or leaving out any of these three dimensions will lead to a partial or distorted view of male-female partnerships.
CHAPTER 3 Lines of Development for Human Intelligences Everything that irritates us about others can lead us to an understanding of ourselves. ~ Carl Gustav Jung ~ In the Integral Model, Lines of Development*3 (or simply lines) refer to the various kinds of skills, traits, or intelligences112 that humans possess, such as maths, sports, music, or connecting with the feelings of others. To which degree these lines develop and the sequential levels through which they develop will be covered in the next chapter “Levels of Growth.” Without getting into the nature versus nurture debate,113 we can safely say that the potential for the development of each line is either hardwired from birth or formed in early childhood. You are either musical or have mathematical talents etc., or you don’t. Out of these lines arise a multitude of passions, needs, interests, hobbies, and lifestyle choices that are important factors in your compatibility with your partner. Below is a list of the lines (the ten most significant in bold) that Wilber mentions in various places in his writings:114 aesthetics (what is beautiful) kinesthetic affect/emotion (feelings about things) mathematical altruism meditative stages care morals/ethics (what to do) cognition (awareness of what is) modes of space and time communicative competence musical concern needs (immediate needs for well-being) creativity psychosexual (expression of Eros) death seizure role-taking defense mechanisms self-esteem empathy self-identity (who are you) gender identity socio-emotional capacity idea of the good spiritual (what is of ultimate concern) interpersonal capacity (interacting with others) values/worldviews (what is important)
One person may have developed their musical, mathematical, and cognitive lines, but have little emotional intelligence and low morals. Another person might be highly kinesthetic, empathetic, and show deep concern for others, while having a limited sense of space and time, and weak defense mechanisms.
THE MANY FACETS OF HUMANNESS While the Primary Fantasy and opposing feminine and masculine polarities create sexual attraction and synergy, couples with similar values, interests, passions, personalities, lifestyle choices, relationship skills, needs, and cultural/ethnic backgrounds—which we may call gender-neutral secondary fantasies—have a higher chance of staying together.115 Both sexual attraction and compatible secondary fantasies are essential for a healthy partnership: the opposite attractors that present the opportunity for psychological healing and spiritual growth through heavenly feelings of passion, intimacy, and unconditional love, 116 AND the similarities that unite by providing the practical earthly structure and conditional foundation for a sustainable love relationship.117 Below you will find lists of characteristics. As you read through them, you may find it useful to mark the words that express the qualities that you: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Bring to a partnership Must have, would like, can tolerate, and can’t stand in a partner Would like to develop further with or without a partner Would like to be mutual Would like to have a conversation about with your partner
BUILDING RELATIONSHIPS THROUGH SHARED OR COMPATIBLE PASSIONS AND INTERESTS118 The Latin root for the word passion is passio, which means suffering. We suffer if we can’t follow our passions, and sometimes we exercise them to a degree of suffering. A passion is intrinsic to our being and emerges passively without conscious doing,119 while an interest or hobby is more of an active choice, externally motivated, passing, or inspired by the egoic mind. Identifying your own and your partner’s passions is essential
for any healthy relationship, as you either have to be able to share them, support each other in expressing them, or at the very least be able to tolerate them.
If she is passionate about dancing, gardening, and horseback riding, and insists on sharing these activities with you, while you loathe them, your relationship will obviously become strained. The words below provide good topics for questions and conversations about your own and your partner’s passions and interests.120
Table 1: List of passions and interests Identifying and Discussing Capacities, Values, and Ideals In addition to passions and interests, we have our uniquely developed capacities, values, and ideals. These also deserve consideration and make good topics for conversations.
Table 2: List of capacities, values, and ideals
TALKING ABOUT NEEDS AND NEEDINESS The words that are listed below describe needs.121 All human needs are legitimate and deserve consideration on an individual level. Some needs have been identified to be universal.122 There is, however, a very important difference between needs and neediness that is often
confused: Needs are things that we must have for our well-being. Neediness is the projection of emotional needs onto others, and expecting, nagging, manipulating, or forcing people to meet our needs, while punishing them through accusations, rejection, threats, or violence if they don’t. We all know how babies and small children react if they don’t get what they need. Of course, a baby dies if its parents or caregivers do not meet its needs for survival (food, warmth, safety, physical contact), and a child that wants something has little to no concern for the reality of others. In the healthy process of maturing/awakening, humans learn how to satisfy their own needs rather than depending on others, by transforming (1) needs into wants, (2) wants into desires, (3) desires into preferences, and (4) preferences into “no preference.”123 If you and your partner follow this continuum, then destructive emotional, sexual, and material neediness can be transformed into a voluntary and loving exchange of give and take that leads to the gratitude and mutual appreciation that is one of the characteristics of a healthy partnership.124 As you read through the list below, mark the words that express the needs, wants, desires, and preferences that you and your partner have and expect to meet for each other—both in kind and degree. When you listen to your partner, note the words need and want in her language and which of those you are willing and able to meet for her. If she makes many demands, such as “you need to make me ...” or “you need to be...” or “I have a need for...,” then you should make sure that you can accommodate her by asking upfront what she exactly means and expects of you.125 Otherwise, the two of you won’t have much fun together.
Partnerships that are largely based on satisfying each other’s needs become quickly problematic as needs tend to change in kind and degree over time, and the willingness or ability of partners to meet them diminishes. The words below may help you to have a conversation with your partner about your and her needs, wants, desires, preferences, and no preferences. acceptance affection aliveness appreciation
contribution cooperation creativity discovery
integrity intimacy joy learning
authenticity ease leisure awareness efficacy moderation beauty effectiveness mutuality belonging empathy nurturing celebration of life equality order challenge freedom participation choice fun peace clarity growth play closeness harmony presence communion honesty protection community humor purpose companionship inclusion quality time consciousness independence consideration inspiration
Table 3: List of needs
OPENING UP TO FEELINGS Emotional intelligence126 is the capacity to be in touch with our own feelings and the feelings of others, and to use this information to guide our thinking and actions.127 The variety and intensity of feelings and emotions that humans experience, witness, and tolerate in themselves and others are directly correlated with their level of consciousness and psychological health. The English language names over 3,000 feelings,128 but we usually only distinguish ten to twenty common ones. Feelings range from shame, guilt, apathy, grief, fear, desire, anger, sadness, disgust, pride, envy, and surprise on the negative side, to courage, neutrality, willingness, acceptance, reason, love, joy, peace, and enlightenment on the positive side. 129 Scientists recently confirmed that the brains of females are better equipped to be in touch with their own and the feelings of others, and to communicate them in more subtle ways than males.130
Not surprisingly, almost every modern and postmodern woman says that she wants a man who is “emotionally available.”131 What she means by that is his ability to stay mentally present (or at least physically in the room) when she shares her feelings or gets emotional, that he intuitively interprets her emotional state and feelings correctly at all times (yes, even if she is ambiguous or does not verbalize them at all), and that he responds to her with kindness, empathy, compassion, and love in a reassuring way, without being condescending or trying to fix, change, or belittle her.132 What she doesn’t mean is for him to share his own vulnerable feelings, especially if they are negative. Even worse for most women are angry emotional outbursts that mask his underlying (often unconscious) fear, hurt, shame, guilt, jealousy, neediness, or insecurity in an aggressive or passive-aggressive way (see “submerged unconscious” in Chapter 9 for more). Such feelings and emotions lie outside the comfort zone of almost every woman and bring up primal fears of abandonment (that he will no longer be a provider) and insecurity (that he will no longer be a protector) from her unconscious female shadow, that will prompt an unpleasant fight or flight reaction from her. It is of course desirable for men to be in touch with, and to be guided by their own feelings. But even if she invites you to share your thoughts and feelings openly, you should be cautious with expressing critical ones in reference to her, such as disapproval, frustration, sadness, loneliness, ambivalence, coldness, or distance.133 She will lose her attraction to your masculinity and feel that she is with a woman in a male body if you emote134 too much or show vulnerabilities.135 She may still (or may not) appreciate you as a sensitive friend, but certainly not as a man that she can trust, whom she is sexually attracted to, and whom she wants to be in a partnership with.136 Communicating positive feelings of your love and commitment that provide her with the sense of intimacy, connection, and safety that she longs for is of course welcome, and you will get brownie points and sex for that. The best way to deal with your negative emotions is to heal the underlying wounds with a therapist and to start a meditation practice that allows you to stay present with your and her emotional pain when it emerges.137 To be compatible with your partner in your emotional development is obviously an important factor for a healthy love relationship. The list of feelings and emotions below may help you to expand your vocabulary and bring you in touch with your own and the feelings of your partner. The first word (in capital letters) provides a primary emotion or feeling, while the following words give you a more subtle differentiation.
FEELINGS WHEN NEEDS ARE SATISFIED138 AFFECTIONATE: Compassionate, friendly, loving, open-hearted, sympathetic, tender, warm CONFIDENT: Empowered, open, proud, safe, secure. ENGAGED: Absorbed, alert, curious, engrossed, enchanted, entranced, fascinated, interested, intrigued, involved, spellbound, stimulated INSPIRED: Amazed, awed, wonder EXCITED: Animated, ardent, aroused, astonished, dazzled, eager, energetic, enthusiastic, giddy, invigorated, lively, passionate, surprised, vibrant EXHILARATED: Blissful, ecstatic, elated, enthralled, exuberant, radiant, rapturous, thrilled GRATEFUL: Appreciative, moved, thankful, touched HOPEFUL: Expectant, encouraged, optimistic
JOYFUL: Amused, delighted, glad, happy, jubilant, pleased, tickled PEACEFUL: Calm, clear-headed, comfortable, centered, content, equanimous, fulfilled, mellow, quiet, relaxed, relieved, satisfied, serene, still, tranquil, trusting REFRESHED: Enlivened, rejuvenated, renewed, rested, restored, revived FEELINGS WHEN NEEDS ARE NOT SATISFIED: AFRAID: Apprehensive, dread, foreboding, frightened, mistrustful, panicked, petrified, scared, suspicious, terrified, wary, worried ANNOYED: Aggravated, dismayed, disgruntled, displeased, exasperated, frustrated, impatient, irritated, jerked ANGRY: Enraged, furious, incensed, indignant, irate, livid, outraged, resentful AVERSION: Animosity, appalled, contempt, disgusted, dislike, hate, horrified, hostile, repulsed CONFUSED: Ambivalent, baffled, bewildered, dazed, hesitant, lost, mystified, perplexed, puzzled, torn DISCONNECTED: Alienated, aloof, apathetic, bored, cold, detached, distant, distracted, indifferent, numb, removed, uninterested, withdrawn DISQUIET: Agitated, alarmed, discombobulated, disconcerted, disturbed, perturbed, rattled, tasteless, shocked, startled, surprised, troubled, turbulent, turmoil, uncomfortable, uneasy, unnerved, unsettled, upset EMBARRASSED: Ashamed, chagrined, flustered, guilty, mortified, self-conscious FATIGUE: Beat, burnt out, depleted, exhausted, lethargic, listless, sleepy, tired, weary, worn-out PAIN: Agony, anguished, bereaved, devastated, grief, heartbroken, hurt, lonely, miserable, regretful, remorseful SAD: Depressed, dejected, despair, despondent, disappointed, discouraged, disheartened, forlorn, gloomy, heavy hearted, hopeless, melancholy, unhappy, wretched TENSE: Anxious, cranky, distressed, distraught, edgy, fidgety, frazzled, irritable, jittery, nervous, overwhelmed, restless, stressed out VULNERABLE: Fragile, guarded, helpless, insecure, leery, reserved, sensitive, shaky YEARNING: Envious, jealous, longing, nostalgic, pining, wistful INTERPRETATIONS VERSUS FEELINGS Words like ignored express how we interpret the behavior or reality of others, rather than how we feel. Below is a sampling of words that are not feelings but interpretations: abandoned threatened provoked co-opted betrayed unsupported misunderstood distrusted cheated taken for granted patronized let-down abused unheard put-down cornered boxed-in unwanted neglected interrupted coerced unappreciated pressured manipulated attacked unseen rejected diminished bullied used overworked intimidated
Table 4: List of interpretations versus feelings COMMUNICATING FEELINGS AND NEEDS MORE EFFECTIVELY A good strategy to express feelings and needs in a considerate way (but not beyond her comfort level) is to put them into a sentence that expresses (1) an objective observation, (2) the feeling that is created, (3) an underlying need that is not met, and (4) that makes a doable request which is specific in time and place (in short, an OFNR ... Observation, Feeling, Need, Request). It goes like this: (1) State an observation that is factual (when you ... e.g., showed up late, did not keep your promise, etc.); (2) Describe the feeling that was created for you—which is called owning your feelings or making an “I statement”—such as (I felt ... e.g., irritated); (3) Explain the need that was not met (because I have a need for ... e.g., respect for my time); and (4) Make a doable request (would you be willing to ... e.g., call me when you are late next time?). If the answer is no, you can either make another request (would you be willing to ... e.g., accept that I won’t wait for you and meet you later at ...) or state in the same structure how you feel about her saying no.
Some examples of OFNR’s: When you showed up late, I felt annoyed because I have a need for the effective use of my time. If that happens again, would you be willing to call me in advance? When you didn’t reply to my email, I felt anxious because I have a need for clear communication. Would you be willing to send me a brief reply so that I know that you received my email and that you are just too busy to reply in more detail at that time? When you stopped talking to me after I hugged my former girlfriend, I felt puzzled because I have a need for understanding. Would you be willing to write me a note about what is going on for you if you can’t talk to me? A good strategy to connect with her feelings is to guess them without interpretation or judgment in the following form: (1) Guess her feeling (are you feeling ... e.g., frustrated?) (2) State or guess a fact why she may feel that way (because I did/did not .... e.g., “listen to you”) (3) Guess a need (and you have a need for/to ... e.g., be heard and understood?) and (4) Make a doable/realistic offer that is specific in time and place (would you like me to ... e.g., listen to you tonight at home in the living room from seven to eight?) Some examples of this kind of communication, which is sometimes called an “empathy guess”: Does it frighten you when I tell you about my problems at work because you have a need for safety? Would you rather have me share my fears of being fired in my men’s group and reassure you that I am strong enough to handle the situation without getting you involved? Do you feel furious because I left my dirty clothes on the bathroom floor and you have a need for tidiness? Would you like me to put my dirty clothes into the laundry basket right after I take them off? Do you feel frustrated because I forgot to buy you flowers for Valentine’s Day and you have a need to be recognized on a day like this? Since I hate to buy flowers, would you feel honored if I take you out to a nice dinner tonight at 7:00? This way of communication is called Non-Violent Communication139 (NVC) or Compassionate Communication. The goals of NVC are (1) to make everybody feel better after a conversation, (2) to get emotional needs, typically for understanding and connection, met, and (3) to not be attached to certain outcomes or solutions. NVC does not judge or evaluate feelings, does not demand that people make each other feel/not feel a certain way, does not criticize others for the way they feel, and does not make people responsible for the feelings of others.140 This is a very feminine way of communicating that
often feels inefficient and inauthentic to males, because it does not get to the point, does not focus on the dialectic of good/bad, right/wrong, or win/lose, and often does not get things accomplished in an expedient manner.141 But the long-term benefits for partnerships are undeniable, because “winning the argument” or “being right” often means losing the relationship. NVC has not only proven to be more effective in one-on-one intimate relationships but also in areas of modern management and politics.142 Please refer to the list of books in Appendix I if you want to gain a deeper understanding of this vital relationship topic.
IN SUMMARY While we may love another human being unconditionally, being in a healthy partnership/marriage is always based on practical conditions. It requires certain compatibilities in intelligences, passions, interests, lifestyle choices, and life-purpose/dreams. Many people say that they want to love and be loved unconditionally, which is possible and desirable, but romanticize this notion at the expense of practical considerations, only to realize later that their partner is too different. On the other hand, some people are so overly focused on having all the needs from their endless laundry lists exactly met, that they completely miss the opportunity to learn and grow in a partnership by staying open to new possibilities and expanding their horizon. The Integral Relationship Model considers both the spiritual and practical dimensions of love relationships equally: the desire for intimacy and to love and to be loved (unconditionally), and the compatibility requirements to co-create a (conditional) life together.
CHAPTER 4 Levels of Growth He who desires to see the living God face-to-face should not seek him in the empty firmament of his mind, but in human love. ~ Fyodor Dostoevsky ~ Humans have different potentials to develop their capacities in each of the lines of development discussed in the previous chapter. This development occurs in levels or stages (Wilber also uses the terms waves or spirals) from lowest towards highest, and may do so over a lifetime.
Understanding what level of development you and your partner have reached in each of these lines and what your future growth potentials are will help you to evaluate your long-term compatibility. In which particular line and for how long people develop depends on many complex factors, including their predisposition, socio-economic environment, cultural background, available nutrition, and personal circumstances.143 The number of levels given for each of the lines can vary. The granularity of simple models may be three levels, such as low, medium, and high, or pre-conventional, conventional, and post-conventional, while more complex models may specify twenty levels or more.144 The grades in our public school system provide an analogy. We could talk about three levels (elementary, middle, and high-school) or we could talk about twelve levels (dividing the same span into first through twelfth grade). Some lines depend on each other for their development, while others develop independently. For example, highly intelligent people (cognitive line) may be low in their moral development, such as the Unabomber, while people with highly developed moral values like Mahatma Gandhi, Nelson Mandela, or Martin Luther King, Jr., are always intelligent. You obtain a simple psychograph if you rate an individual’s level of growth for some or all of the developmental lines listed in Chapter 3 as low, medium, or high.145
Figure 15: Graph showing an individual’s development on various lines The Integral Model does not suggest that every human being needs to be at the highest level known to man in every line in order to be fully realized—which would be impossible anyway, as intelligences and capacities are all open-ended and continually evolve. It rather suggests that it is desirable to (1) be integrally informed about the existence of these lines, (2) understand their individual significance, (3) accept that lines are differently developed in people, (4) recognize the potential for future growth in yourself and others, (5) have a desire to foster the development of each line in yourself and others to the highest individual potential (called self-actualization), and (6) balance and harmonize your development in relationship with an equal and opposite partner. An Integral Life Practice (ILP) that includes multiple modules for the health of body, mind, spirit/soul, shadow, ethics, sexuality, work, emotions, and relationships is a proven method to support growth in the major developmental lines.146 Being in an integrally informed partnership is not only beneficial but mandatory to effectively engage in these practices. In this chapter we will focus on the levels of consciousness, spiritual, sexual, and anima/animus complex development, which are pivotal for love relationships.
CONSCIOUSNESS DEVELOPMENT (COLORS) A key factor in creating a good relationship is to have a partner with a matching level of consciousness development. In this section we will discuss what consciousness is and how it develops in humans through stages. Each stage will be identified with a different color. To be conscious means “to know, be aware of, sense, feel, or experience things.” 147 For humans these things include physical objects that can be looked at or measured (such as the physical body, the manifest world, or invisible forces such as electromagnetic waves), AND non-physical objects in consciousness (such as thoughts, beliefs, feelings, intentions, dreams, concepts, theories, etc.). In other words, what’s out there (objectivity), and what’s in here (subjectivity). To the level that we are conscious, we know of and/or experience these things; if we are unconscious, we don’t.148 So, simply put, we can say:
“The world consists of things plus consciousness that experiences things.”149 This implies that consciousness is neither a thing (object) in itself, nor necessarily local; it just IS.150 Feel inside yourself for a moment and ask “who is conscious of things?” You may say “me, I, myself, the witness, my ego (a.k.a. self-organizing principal or separate/false sense of self),151 my conscious self,” or something like that. How we can experience an “I” or a “self ” that is conscious of
“itself ” in a physical body is quite a miracle if you think about it for a moment, and still a mystery to philosophers and scientists alike. They call it “the hard problem,” because it is hard (and perhaps impossible) to explain.152 This conscious self that experiences—and in a sense creates153—its own story about the world in a unique way as it selectively receives, evaluates, sorts, names, compares, prioritizes, stores, and remembers information also develops. People sometimes call this development growing up, self-development, personal development, or personal growth. We will call it consciousness development. Women often intuitively say, “I want to be with a man who knows who he is,” or “I want a man who has done some growth work,” or “I want a man who is aware, loving, intuitive, creative, spiritual, compassionate, wise, mature, emotionally available, understanding...” Note that all these terms point to consciousness and not to things. She is basically saying “I want a man who sees me, himself, the world, and God/Spirit from the same level of consciousness as I do,” usually without knowing that there are multiple levels of consciousness or what they entail. Today, hardly any social scientist questions that humans became increasingly conscious throughout evolution and that children develop cognitively from gestation to the end of adolescence.154 However, it is not widely known, and sometimes vehemently rejected—especially by women and postmodernists—that adults are at different levels of their consciousness development, with an open-ended potential for future growth. The critics tend to ignore the fact that there is a lot of carefully conducted research that supports the idea of growth hierarchies in adult development.155 The refusal to rank people on a hierarchical scale as more or less evolved, conscious, or developed results from the well-founded concern that individuals and groups who are presumed to be at lower levels (such as indigenous people, the poor, the less educated, people of color, women, children, etc.) may be dominated, abused, marginalized, exploited, or oppressed by those who are or who put themselves at higher levels. The fallacy of people who are critical of developmental hierarchies is to confuse natural growth hierarchies156 of increasing integration and complexity (which allow for more perspectives, cooperation, care, love, responsibility, creativity, and compassion) with dominator hierarchies in which power and superiority are abused. It is therefore important to understand the difference between the two forms of hierarchies when we discuss the stages of growth and development in any of the developmental lines so that we don’t offend those who are sensitive to this issue (e.g., women) or abuse our knowledge.157 Adult growth in consciousness appears in three different ways: (1) almost unnoticed over long periods of time; (2) through a structured meditation or contemplative prayer practice (typically two levels in four years); or (3) when particular beliefs, capacities, and views of a certain stage no longer provide adequate answers to life’s questions, challenges, and demands. The latter is often the case for men who want to win the heart of a woman, are in a troubled partnership, or have gone through a painful breakup/divorce. Each consecutive level provides better solutions to life’s challenges, deeper insights, wider perspectives, and more capacity for love and compassion than the previous one.
THE EIGHT STAGES OF CONSCIOUSNESS DEVELOPMENT AND THEIR COLORS We will use eight levels of consciousness development for our Integral Relationship Model. The initial six stages are grouped together in first-tier consciousness, while the two highest stages are grouped in second-tier consciousness. A different color of the rainbow is assigned to each level to deflect from ranking or labeling individuals, and to avoid confusion between the various numbers and names of the multitude of developmental systems.158 It is important to understand that the various levels of consciousness do not describe different types of people (such as primitive or intelligent, good or bad, right or wrong, sensitive or insensitive, functional or dysfunctional, etc.), but look at the underlying motives and worldviews within people that guide their thinking and behavior. The question to ask is therefore NOT “how are people behaving,” but “what are the underlying values and worldviews that motivate and drive their behavior.” Keep in mind that (1) each level carries its own assets and liabilities, (2) everybody (including you) started at square one, (3) higher levels are always achievable, (4) altered states of consciousness can cause temporary shifts to lower or higher levels at any time, and (5) people who express personal judgments always do so from their own limited level of consciousness. The table below summarizes the different stages and colors and the proportion of the American population that falls into those levels.
Table 5: Developmental stages, their colors, and proportions of U.S. population You may visualize the sequential stages as a vertical string of light bulbs with different colors that become illuminated as higher stages of consciousness emerge, musical notes on a piano that get arranged in ever more complex ascending chords, or the seven chakras. As you read through the descriptions below, you can get a sense for the levels of consciousness that are alive in you.
THE SIX LEVELS OF FIRST-TIER CONSCIOUSNESS Pre-conventional stages The first three stages are called pre-conventional, as only a first person “I, me, mine” perspective can be taken. The ability to conform to the conventions of other individuals, a society, a single supreme power (God), or scientific evidence, which requires the ability to take a second- and
third-person perspective, has not emerged yet.
1. Infrared—archaic—dead or alive The infrared level is called archaic and covers all the levels of human consciousness that had emerged up to about 50,000 years ago. It concerns our basic needs for survival: food, water, shelter, warmth, and sex. These needs are closely related to our animal nature and are embedded in our reptilian brain stem. At this level, behavior is guided by instincts and impulses for physical comfort. There is little awareness of the past or future, and the world is perceived through the senses, which can be highly developed in functional adults at this stage e.g., in indigenous tribes. Some spiritual seekers confuse this stage of total fusion with the environment (called a-duality) with higher stages of non-duality.159 Only few adults in the developed world are exclusively at the infrared level, such as the mentally ill, delusional street people, individuals in deep shock, or Alzheimer’s patients. They represent less than 1% of the U.S. adult population.
2. Magenta—magic—safe or unsafe The magenta level is called magic or superstitious and started to emerge about 50,000 years ago, when humans became self-conscious, realized the threats and dangers of their immediate environment to their survival, and sought solutions for their safety. As a result, all kinds of superstitious explanations and beliefs were created to explain natural phenomena such as lightning, thunder, natural cycles, birth, illness, and death. This lead to the formation of close bonds—often based on kinship—with others for protection. For today’s people at this level, being part of a family, tribe, clan, or cult supersedes individuality and rationality. “One for all, and all for one” is their motto. False beliefs in the power of magic, group rituals, sacred places and objects, voodoo-like curses, spells, ghosts, good-luck charms, astrology, or magical healing powers are indicators of magenta. To this day, primal “fight or flight” reactions are triggered from this level when individuals feel threatened by situations and experiences that they can’t rationally explain or control. On the positive side, sharpened sense perceptions, sensitivity to nature, and supernatural capacities such as remote viewing or telepathy, as seen in members of indigenous tribes and shamans, are qualities of magenta that often get diminished or completely lost in later, higher stages of development. Green (see below) often confuses the pre-rational superstitious fantasies and behavior of magenta with verifiable trans-rational phenomena and capacities that can only be differentiated at higher levels of consciousness.160 Magenta awareness is seen in members of clan-like families, street gangs, athletic teams, corporate “tribes,” cults, and pagan/earth-oriented Goddess-worshipping religions. It represents about 10% of the U.S. adult population.
3. Red—egocentric—good or bad The red stage is called egocentric and emerged about 10,000 years ago, when young males started to break free from the dictates of their elders and confinements of their family clans to claim their own autonomy. Self-serving choices, power, independence, high risk-taking, stubbornness, and unrestrained creativity are used by red to control their environment and destiny, instead of being controlled by it. 161 In an attempt to feel good, red energy is focused on behaviors that provide instant gratification, often through sex, food, gambling, alcohol, illegal drugs, shopping, or mindless entertainment, without concern for others or negative consequences for its own future. “I want it all and I want it now” is the motto. To red, the world appears like a jungle in which only the fittest survive. The resulting value system is polarized between good and bad. People in this stage tend to identify with powerful gods or idols (rock stars, movie or video-game heroes, etc.) who are on their side, demand respect from others, and fight everyone who tries to control, dominate, or shame them. In its healthy form, red energy can be refreshingly spontaneous, creative, innovative, original, uninhibited, emotional, carefree, and alive. Red consciousness is seen in leaders of street gangs, narcissistic New Age communities (with claims that egoic thoughts manifest objects, physical well-being, and material abundance, or that being “In The Now” is sufficient for the development of a functional self), pimp and prostitute relations, wild rock stars, pre-conventional artists, Rambo- and Terminator-type fighters, ruthless dictators, characters in violent video games, and James Bond villains. Red represents about 20% of the U.S. adult population.
Conventional Stages The amber and orange stages are called conventional, as amber can take a second -person (you, thou) and orange a third-person (he, she, it, its, them) perspective. This allows individuals in these stages to conform to the conventions (norms) of others, a religion, society, or scientific evidence.
4. Amber—mythic—right or wrong The amber stage is called mythic and emerged about 5,000 years ago through males who sought to transcend their red egocentric short-term thinking. They realized their eventual mortality, searched for deeper meanings of life (which they found in mythic religious beliefs), and developed ethical codes of conduct (laws) for the growing number of peoples in their communities. This stage satisfies the human need for stability, order, purpose, rules, hope, recognition, and future rewards for right behavior. Amber values are derived from literal interpretations of mythic scriptures, such as Jesus was born to a virgin, Lao Tzu was eighty years old when he was born, Moses parted the Red Sea, or that obeying the Ten Commandments and confessing one’s sins will open the gates to heaven after death. Hence, amber thoughts allow for only one right way of belief and doing things. The resulting value system labels things as either right or wrong. The right way is based in conformist political, religious, or social belief systems (e.g., Marxism, Islam, patriarchy) and governed by a single authority such as a father, the church, the government, the ruler of a nation, a superior commander, or a teacher/guru. Amber is therefore found in members of fundamentalist religious and spiritual communities (my God/Guru is right, no matter what), patriarchal families (the father is right, no matter what), law and order societies (my people are right, no matter what), extreme patriotism (my country is right, no matter what), organizations (our mission is right, no matter what), the military (superior orders are right, no matter what), and hierarchical corporations (the boss and making profits is right, no matter what).
Right conduct and following the proper rules, laws, orders, religion, or a spiritual path promise future rewards, such as ongoing support from a family, being promoted, receiving a medal of honor, going to heaven after death, or enlightenment. Wrongdoing will cause chaos and leads to punishment, such as losing family support, being dishonorably discharged, being fired or asked to leave, ending up in prison, burning in hell after death, or being subject to an endless cycle of suffering and rebirth. In its healthy form, amber provides stability, security, and order for families, groups, organizations, and societies to flourish. In its unhealthy form, amber is dogmatic, intolerant, repressive, and irrational. Amber values are seen in patriarchal family structures, government and military organizations, hierarchical corporate structures, fundamentalist churches, spiritual communities, and the Republican Party. It represents about 40% of the U.S. adult population.
5. Orange—rational—win or lose The orange stage is called rational and emerged about 300 years ago during the Enlightenment Period—which brought the rise of modernity— when a number of men questioned the feudalistic systems and supreme power of monarchies, and challenged the church dogma. Today, orange represents the human desire for the good life of material abundance and personal liberty through objective reasoning, use of scientific methods, democratic capitalism, individual choice, excellence, and acceleration through taking controlled risks. The resulting value system is “win or lose.” Winners are those who effectively use their higher education, superior talents, and the best information available to succeed financially, politically, or academically. Orange individuals think and act globally, show confidence, believe in their own abilities, have a “can-do” attitude (Yes We Can), play hard, and take risks to try to win big. From this level, the world looks like an ever-changing and evolving place, with limitless possibilities and opportunities for those who are flexible, clever, and fast. Intelligent and witty people with knowledge, financial assets, or social/political status (think Albert Einstein, Bill Gates, Ted Turner, Donald Trump, or Barack Obama) are the icons of orange who replace the mythic superiors of amber as authority figures and role models. Efficiency, effectiveness, positive thinking, visioning, strategic planning, goal setting, innovation, and the evaluation of progress (where are we, where do we want to go, how do we get there) are the highest priorities. Orange wants the facts and nothing but the facts, and conflicts are resolved in a rational way (getting to yes without giving in),162 through expensive lawyers, or acceptance of collateral damage. Even though orange energy can be ruthless in the pursuit of its goals and lack conscience when harm that is done to others is justified as “necessary and eventually good for them,”163 it also considers the long-term effects of its actions (otherwise it is red egocentric). Repeat customers are valued, bridges don’t get burned easily, the past is forgiven if it is beneficial for the future, and networking with others is seen as an important tool for success. Orange may also appear like Teflon when it doesn’t allow emotions that could alienate others or reveal weaknesses to get in the way or distract it from being efficient. Problems that would devastate others slide right off. When things fail, depression does not last very long. “Pick yourself up, dust yourself off, and start all over again” is the motto.164 Instead of asking others for support or advice, which would imply weakness and is therefore to be avoided, orange asks for input, data, and information to be evaluated by itself for arriving at its own conclusions and decisions. The U.S. constitution and many of the laws that are written to protect individual freedoms and rights originate from the rational level. Through advancements in many areas, such as medicine, transportation, information-technology, architecture, agriculture, and the industrial production of goods, orange has also contributed (and continues to contribute) to the abolition of poverty in most parts of the Western—and now increasingly in the developing—world, our modern comfortable lifestyle, and the increasing longevity that many people enjoy today. It is also responsible for much of the environmental damage and global social injustice that has emerged from this stage. Orange consciousness is seen on Wall Street, in the cosmetic and fashion industry, scientific community, upper management, emerging middleclass, success churches, self-improvement and wealth seminars, and among left-wing Republicans, Democrats, and the liberal feminist movement. Orange represents about 25% of the U.S. adult population.
Post-conventional stage The green postmodern pluralistic stage is also called post-conventional, as it can take a 4th person “all of us” perspective that transcends the conventional norms of the previous stages.
6. Green—pluralistic—sensitive or indifferent The green stage is called pluralistic. It emerged about 100 years ago and came into full bloom in the 1960s, when postmodern male artists and intellectuals challenged the theories, assumptions, and ideologies of modernity. Green is characterized by multiple interpretations of history, language, science, religion, spirituality, politics, culture, and social systems—with the belief that absolute truth doesn’t exist in any objective sense, but is created individually rather than discovered. The ability to take a fourth-person (cultural) perspective allows for greater compassion, idealism, and involvement. A sense that all human beings—regardless of race, gender, or class—are born equal and should be equally heard and respected becomes prevalent. Green feels strongly that the human spirit must be freed from masculine orange greed and amber dogma. It is against hierarchy/patriarchy and establishes lateral social structures with an emphasis on friendships, empathy, non-violent or compassionate communication, and consensus, often with the downside of endless processing and inability to reach decisions. Green has the capacity for subjective, nonlinear thinking, and shows a great degree of affective warmth and sensitivity towards others. The concept that all souls are connected in a big web of life with a deep caring for mother earth and all its inhabitants emerges. Along comes the desire to find peace and happiness within, which triggers an exploration of the inner feelings and experiences of the self and others, with an increasing attention to the unconscious. This often brings green men in touch with their anima (deconstructing their ego, which makes them more feminine), and women with their animus (strengthening their ego, which makes them more masculine). While it seems that green would love and embrace everything and everyone, it opposes orange rationality and patriarchal amber conformity, with the idea that men should let go of their egos, and women should stand up for themselves. Green also denies the existence of higher stages of consciousness development and considers such notions as arrogant, judgmental, and ranking. “What stages?” says green, “we are all equal! Everything is relative!” By denying any kind of hierarchy and calling it ranking, oppressive, and outdated, green quickly gets caught up in “performative contradictions,”165 such as “lateral systems are better than hierarchy,” (and therefore unwittingly creating its own hierarchy which says no hierarchy is better than hierarchy) “people should not be judgmental,” “I hate people who are unloving,” or “let’s fight for peace,” and prohibits itself from further growth.
At the same time, green often identifies red (egocentric) as a victim of orange’s rational greed and amber’s conformist repression, and romanticizes magenta’s superstitious tribal living and their assumed sensitivity towards mother earth and its inhabitants. This sometimes makes the pre-conventional red and post-conventional green stage look alike, since they are both un-conventional. The energies of these two stages often resonate with each other in a very confused and destructive way, e.g., when instant gratification is mistaken for being present in the now, red violence erupts during a Greenpeace or anti-globalization demonstration, or when green people consider it to be healthy to let red emotions erupt in an uncontrolled way. Green consciousness is seen in the civil and animal rights, environmental protection, ecology, human liberation, radical and eco-feminist, and humanistic sciences movements, which gave birth to organizations such as Greenpeace, Amnesty International, Doctors Without Borders, the Sierra Club, and the National Organization of Women (NOW).166 Green represents about 10% of the total U.S. adult population, with higher concentrations in pockets such as Boston, Northern California, Boulder Colorado, New Mexico, and Oregon.
THE TWO STAGES OF SECOND-TIER CONSCIOUSNESS Post-post conventional With less than 3% of the U.S. adult population at teal (below), and less than 1% at the highest, turquoise level, second-tier consciousness is still extremely rare, and represents the leading-edge of human consciousness evolution.167
7. Teal—Integral—integrated or partial The teal stage is called Integral. It first emerged in the early 20th century in India and Europe,168 and was widely recognized by pioneering U.S. psychologists and social researchers in the 1970s.169 Teal is not just another stage, but marks the shift into what is called second-tier consciousness. Previous levels insist that their particular views are the only way to see the world. Whenever threatened or challenged, individuals in first-tier consciousness react negatively and lash out, using their own tools (magenta voodoo-like spells, red anger and crude violence, amber moral wars and shaming, orange cold logic and collateral damage, and green emoting, victimizing, demonstrations, activism, and endless processing). Teal and above intuitively recognizes the importance of all preceding levels—including the process of development itself—and integrates them with the healthy qualities of masculine agency and feminine communion. It is the first stage that doesn’t force its own values onto others by “should”ing them to be more like me/us. In teal, knowledge and competency supersede rank, power, gender, or status. Flexibility, spontaneity, and functionality become the highest priority. Unlike green, which does away with developmental hierarchies and maintains that all humans are equal, teal sees the liabilities, contributions, benefits, values, and limitations of each previous stage. It supports the cultivation of healthy feminine and masculine qualities (a.k.a. self-actualization170 and horizontal translation)171 at each level, communicates with others in their voice, facilitates their healthy growth through the stages, and acknowledges that higher levels of development are always possible. Teal can see beyond a fourth-person perspective and recognizes the prevailing world-order as a result of the existence of developmental stages, as well as the movement of individuals and groups through them. Seen from the perspective of first-tier consciousness, people in the teal stage may seem cold, calculating, opportunistic, manipulative, analytical, distant, cynical, or arrogant—and sometimes they are. Teal can feel quickly discouraged, bored, and frustrated, as it thinks it has seen and had it all. And while it can easily connect with others in earlier stages of development when making the effort, teal often feels isolated and alone, as it gets tired of the limited worldviews, self-created drama, narrow-minded labeling, and naive stereotyping of people in first-tier consciousness.
8. Turquoise—transpersonal—wisdom and compassion The turquoise stage is called transpersonal (or post-Integral)172 and represents all the stages above Integral.173 While teal tends to observe, analyze, and evaluate the inner and outer world in an analytical, left-brained, righteous, distant, and ascending way, people in these higher stages display an actual embodiment, full embrace, or interweaving of all the healthy qualities of the previous stages and the four feminine/masculine polarities. They have reached the top of the developmental pole and gone one step further, plunging into the fullness of their own being and the world, but without getting lost in it. They have a sense of “being in the world but not of it”174 and transcend good/bad, right/wrong, win/lose, sensitive/indifferent, and integrated/partial thinking, representing the leading edge of human consciousness development—with higher stages possible in the future.175 Desires, attachments, and fears, with the resulting striving for ever more exterior comfort, luxury, safety, power, order, status, wealth, peace, and knowledge, are replaced with inner qualities of increasing wisdom, compassion, presence, and surrender. This transformation is caused by a conscious, stepwise deconstruction of unconscious habits of the mind and the healing of negative emotions. An awareness of the intersubjective and interobjective co-creation of experiences and a sense of a universal unified order that is the result of all manifestation comes into focus. For turquoise and above, a grand unification is possible in theory and in actuality, and ever more perspectives can be taken. This often involves the emergence of a new spirituality as a meshwork of all existence. Turquoise consciousness may be seen as aloof and indifferent about the condition of others (e.g., a partner), as well as the earth and all its inhabitants, but nothing could be further from the truth. People in turquoise are simply no longer attached to certain outcomes that are governed by their ego, and have no preference to have things one way or another. Turquoise and above has the wisdom to accept what is, proactively respond where action is needed, and to leave a situation at its own devices if opposing it would do more harm than good.
THE PRE/POST OR PRE/TRANS FALLACY Both, the pre-conventional infrared to red stages, which are also referred to as pre-modern or pre-rational, and the post-conventional green and higher stages, which are also called postmodern or trans-rational, are non-conventional/non-rational and are therefore often confused with each other by people who are not integrally informed. They are prone to mistake the pre-rational infantile stage of a-duality with trans-rational stages of non-dual awareness, or pre-conventional unrestrained but ultimately narcissistic/egocentric behavior in children or adults with responsible authentic expressions of post-conventional personal freedom.176 Thus, the pre/post or pre/trans fallacy leads to many misunderstandings in spiritual circles, confusion in postmodern groups and organizations, and irresolvable conflicts in love relationships between pre- and post-conventional partners.
SPIRITUAL DEVELOPMENT The word spiritual generally means “that which is not bound to time, the physical world, or mental concepts,”177 which is all the domain of the mind and our senses. Spiritual may also refer to obtaining a sense of self, happiness, joy, and peace from an inner or higher source, instead of external objects and pleasures. To be spiritual implies different things for different people. It is therefore crucial to verify what concept, teaching, experience, insight, wisdom, belief-system, or practice a woman refers to when she mentions the word. Her answer will most likely fall into one of four general categories: (1) random spiritual and paranormal phenomena, (2) a particular attitude or quality, (3) superhuman achievements in one or several of the developmental lines, or (4) a permanent level or stage of spiritual realization that is attained through a practice such as yoga, meditation, Tantra, or contemplative prayer. The first definition describes random, blissful, transitory, altered states that arise spontaneously during a peak experience, use of illegal drugs, transcendental sex, after a dark night of the soul, birth of a child, death of a loved one, energetic healing session, or a psychic episode. The second refers to a particular attitude of openness, loving kindness, humility, devotion, compassion, joy, or wisdom. Your grandparents may have lived by the Golden Rule all their life and never heard about spirituality, and yet appeared to be totally spiritual by this definition. The third form is experienced through exposure to superhuman achievements in any of the developmental lines, such as sports (Michael Jordan), music (Mozart), poetry (Rumi), visual art (Michelangelo), knowledge (Einstein), or wisdom (Gandhi). It creates a sense of divine awe, as their gift seems to originate from a realm beyond human possibility, from a “spiritual place.” The fourth description points to a formal spiritual practice, often conducted under the guidance of a teacher (or guru), lineage, or religion, that aims to transform temporary spiritual states into permanent stages which then become accessible by choice rather than by chance. States that become accessible through formal study/practice are often called state-stages and their unfolding will be the focus throughout the
following paragraphs. STATE-STAGES Spiritual state-stages tend to unfold in a certain order that are likened to the three broad states of waking (in which we are aware of physical objects), dreaming (in which we are identified with nonphysical objects in our mind), and dreamless sleep (in which we fall into a state of timeless emptiness) that every human being, regardless of age, education, or cultural background, experiences during the course of a normal day. Two advanced state-stages that are called the witness (in which a conscious awareness of timeless emptiness arises) and non-duality (in which awareness and that which we are aware of unite) become available through grace or advanced practices. Another helpful way to look at spiritual state-stage development (or any growth for that matter) is to make a clear distinction between (1) the self and (2) the things that the self can observe, such as physical objects in our surroundings, our own physical body, or the thoughts that create objects in consciousness. This “I” or “subject” that is doing the seeing, witnessing, or observing is by nature unaware of itself. Once it can be seen, it becomes an object, so who/what is doing the looking? This may sound quite strange, and it is. Think about it this way: You can look at the words on this page, observe your surroundings, and think about things (symbols, objects, concepts, ideas, etc.), but you can’t see the actual observer. The objects that you observe are those aspects of your experience that are apparent to you, and can so be thought of, related to, reflected upon, engaged with, manipulated, or connected to something else. You can be “objective” about them because you don’t experience them as the self or witness. The objects can so be differentiated from the aspects of your experience that you are identified with, embedded in, or fused with.178 In a nutshell, we can say that spiritual growth appears when the subject that we identify with becomes the object of the subject of the next stage. As mentioned above, this growth unfolds in five general state-stages:179
1. GROSS/WAKING The initial level of spiritual awakening is called the gross/waking (or psychic) state-stage, and marks the major transition from a complete identification with the material world and the physical body into the spiritual realm. It emerges with the realization that you are defined by neither your body with its needs, impulses, and emotions,180 nor your material possessions or social status. Instead of having knee-jerk reactions to inner habits and other people’s behavior, you increasingly learn how to stay present, and how to respond in mindful ways. 181 You become the witness of your environment and the master of your body, instead of its slave. This may sound easier than it is, and may require the support of practices such as yoga, conscious breathing,182 relaxation techniques, physical exercise, contemplation (such as reading this manual), or—in severe cases of pathological attachments—psychotherapy. Just think how often you may consume unconsciously, have a negative emotional reaction to somebody else’s reality, avoid physical exercise, fail to properly nourish your body, identify with the car you drive and other material possessions, derive your self-worth from the amount of money you have (or don’t have), or the physical appearance of the woman on your arm. The awareness of “I have a body—but I am not my body,” with the ability to observe and use it, instead of being used by it (often through addictive behavior),183 is very liberating. People who enter this state-stage of spiritual realization may start to have psychic,184 synchronistic,185 or mystical experiences in nature,186 and have a clear sense of awakening to a different reality. They realize that the physical and emotional pains of the body may be inevitable, but that suffering is optional. As the body becomes the object of the subject, more compassion for the self and others emerges. The feminine in this state-stage tends to move consciously into the body (descend) and the manifest world. This downward movement gave rise to earth-bound and Goddess-worshipping religions such as paganism. The masculine tends to move away from the body (ascend) and deny its pleasures, as seen in male God-worshipping religions such as Christianity, Buddhism, Hinduism, and Islam in their fundamentalist forms.
2. SUBTLE/DREAMING The subtle dream stage is entered by grace or through a regular spiritual practice such as meditation or contemplative prayer. It emerges with the realization that you are not your thoughts and beliefs. Similar to awakening from a dream after sleeping, you realize that random and unobserved thoughts (assumptions, projections, etc.), which are frequently fed by pain from the past and fears of the future, are just as unreal as your dreams at night. These thoughts can play in your head like a radio station that repeats the good old “coulda, shoulda, woulda” blues over and
over. If this is the case, you are essentially just one step away from an insane person who talks out loud while walking down the street. This self-talk may then trigger negative emotions, which in turn feed more paranoid thoughts that can become a cause for depression187 and other pathologies. People who enter the subtle state-stage awaken from this nightmare (or cognitive prison), and learn to recognize their random thoughts as unreal objects in consciousness. They can then either turn down the volume (quiet the mind), push the Off button, change the radio station from KFUCK to KLOVE (positive thinking), or simply observe their thoughts and allow them to move freely like the wind through the branches of a tree, without being affected by them. Advanced forms of insight meditation, such as Vipassana, that focus on the breath or the reciting of mantras, are practices that can support individuals in their ability to observe, quiet, and focus the mind. They can then use their mind as a tool for visualizations, introspection, contemplation, creativity, and critical thinking, instead of being used by it. With the realization that “I have thoughts, but I am not my thoughts,” 188 individuals may start to dream lucidly,189 have experiences of subtle illuminations, or experience unconditional love for all creation. In an effort to enter this state-stage through observing and quieting the mind, the masculine tends towards repressing and dissociating from emotions and the ego, while the feminine tends to strengthen the self and connects more deeply with feelings and the heart.
3. CAUSAL/DEEP SLEEP The causal formless state is likened to deep dreamless sleep. It is experienced as a timeless openness or emptiness with the realization that you are not your feelings (happy, sad, afraid, content, etc.), intuitions, or intentions. It becomes a state-stage with the arising of a permanent sense of “I AM-ness” that observes—and therefore transcends—time 190 and separation. In this state-stage, any identification with the physical world and objects in consciousness disappears. You intuitively sense that there is a Ground of all Being that transcends the physical world and the egoic mind, which both create the illusion of a separate self. This state-stage is often likened to emptiness, except that it is not a mere blank, but an utter fullness of Being or Godhead that enters the space as light. It feels so full that no other manifestation can contain it. Lucid dreaming becomes more regular and there is a clear sense of “I have experiences but I am not my experiences.” The masculine tends to experience this state as radical stillness and emptiness; the feminine experiences it as radical fullness and flow.
4. WITNESSING The witnessing state is entered when the observer that experiences the timeless emptiness of state-stage three drops away. In Zen this experience is called “Satori,” “Radical Emptiness,” “the Cloud of Unknowing,” “Beginner’s Mind,” or “the Vertical Drop.” In this state there is no more separate you or witness that would experience time, form, emptiness, or even enlightenment (who would be there to be enlightened?).191 It is a state-stage to which many mystics and sages point. But instead of looking at their pointing finger, you become the finger AND that which it points to. Lao Tzu, the first Taoist philosopher, wrote in the opening verse of the Tao Te Ching (or Dao De Jing), “the Tao that can be spoken of is not the true Tao” (and then goes on to write eighty more verses that point TO the truth that can’t be spoken of). If you fall into this radical egoless state you may lose any sense of the manifest world and need to have caretakers in place, otherwise you may starve or freeze to death. A sense of “I witness Being but I am not Being” emerges. The witnessing state becomes a state-stage when you can access complete non-attachment or non-desire by choice, similar to accessing language, and retain a subtle awareness during dreamless sleep.192 In this state-stage, the feminine-masculine duality is fully transcended.
5. NON-DUAL Non-dual awareness is not as much a state-stage as it is a merging of the ever-present infinite ground of all the previous levels. In the preceding witnessing state-stage, one can become completely absorbed in blissful emptiness and oblivious to all form. In non-duality, both are integrated: Emptiness manifests as form, and form as emptiness. Both are simultaneously real and unreal. Non-dual awareness cannot be really experienced, since all experiences (including the witnessing state) come and go and require a witness who has the experience. It also cannot be contained in words. As soon as you talk or think about “it,” it would become separate from “you” and therefore dual. Non-duality has been described as reaching the top of a pole and then climbing one step further. What follows is a complete emptying of the subject (climber) into the object (world), so that there is, in a sense, no more subject (observer/witness)/object duality at all. It is devoid of any looking out on the world from any vantage point that is apart from it. You are then the world’s perspective or one with Godhead (sorry, you are still not God—or a Goddess if you happen to be a woman reading this—this notion would be a psychotic193 delusion that many New Age narcissists have fallen into). In this latest state-stage of development that we are aware of, the self has become entirely identified (but not fused in an a-dual psychosis) with the world. There is recognition of the oneness of the uni-verse, a realization that wisdom literature from the East and West has pointed to repeatedly. Only few humans (if any) have attained this state-stage as a permanent realization, which could be called full enlightenment, Buddha or Christ nature. It may well be that duality can only be temporarily overcome during transcendental sexual union between lovers who have both reached witness consciousness (which can be a permanently accessible stage or a temporary drug-induced state or peak experience), since it entails male-female union on all levels from the physical/gross to the witness level. Individual humans are obviously never complete on the physical level (one is either male or female),194 and can’t be feminine or masculine at the same time (you can’t breathe in and out simultaneously), but they can find wholeness through sexual union in an enlightened relationship.
SPIRITUAL BUT NOT RELIGIOUS Many modern and postmodern women identify themselves as “spiritual but not religious.” They may say this without any deeper understanding, or have a certain spiritual teacher, practice, belief system, or realization, but are not members of an organized church, sangha, temple, mosque, or cult with a common creed. However, women who are religious may still be spiritual, as all religions, and even some New Age movements, have developed branches that represent the initial four state-stages of consciousness, which lead to different religious denominations and branches; from atheist to polytheist, monotheist, and mystical.195
Figure 16: A summary of spiritual levels in world religions Design by Brad Reynolds, used by permission. To assume that some religions are more spiritually advanced than others is a fallacy, as all enduring religious or spiritual practices lead through the same state-stages of realization, insight, and illumination that we outlined above. To be in a partnership with a woman who is at the same or next higher state-stage of spiritual development is obviously conducive for the spiritual alignment and growth of both partners, and mandatory for an Integral Life Practice that includes spirituality. Compatible partners can support each other in transforming temporary spiritual states into more permanent state-stages. This often requires the woman to challenge her partner’s ego,196 while the man may support her in building her selfesteem. It can, however, be difficult for a partner who has not experienced certain states, is arrested in a lower state-stage of spiritual development, or only pursues a feminine or masculine form of spirituality to stay in a partnership with a more evolved practitioner.
DEVELOPMENT OF SEXUALITY There are five general levels of sexual exchange between partners that are a direct reflection of their physical, psychological, and spiritual health.197 Similar to the unfolding of the spiritual realizations outlined above, these levels can be experienced as a temporary state or become permanently accessible state-stages through practice with a partner.
1. REPRESSED SEXUALITY In this lowest stage, the body and sex are viewed with suspicion as something negative and dirty. Usually driven by shame, guilt, and fear that originate from childhood trauma and abuse, adults at this level either avoid sexual activities altogether, perform out of duty in a dissociated way (with closed eyes, under the sheets, in the dark), or develop forms of obsessive-compulsive disorders around their sexuality that can lead to sexual addiction and other abusive behaviors. Oral sex or similarly playful sensual activities are usually out of the question for people at this stage, where modesty is confused with shame.
2. FUCKING In the fucking stage, sexuality is instinctual, self-serving, and limited to the physical, hedonistic pleasures of the body. Sex partners tend to objectify each other without seeking a deeper personal connection. They want to have fun, “get off,” and don’t care much about their partner’s emotional needs, feelings, or sexual desires. There is no shame or guilt, and “everything goes,” which can be confused with the higher, unrestrained forms of transcendent sexuality (see below), which is another form of the pre/trans fallacy (see above). In this stage, males often dominate and manipulate females into having intercourse and to engage in hurtful practices such as anal sex or deep-throating/gagging. In the fucking stage, everything is seen as OK, as long as the partner cooperates or at least does not call the police. Rarely is there a prior conversation about consent, sexual preferences, sexual history, sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), no-no’s, expectations for a monogamous commitment, or possible consequences such as emotional/sexual dependence or pregnancy. Women at this stage often have an unspoken expectation of their partner to make an exclusive commitment after intercourse and feel used and abused if he moves on. They may also become intentionally pregnant without their partner’s consent to “hook him” and/or to collect child support and social security payments. Once the excitement of the newness vanishes, couples in this stage often lose interest in sex with each other and stop having sex or seek a new fuck buddy.198
3. HAVING SEX In this stage, mindfulness comes into play. Sex becomes a conscious choice between a couple that has a mutual understanding and agreement about the implications and consequences of being sexual. Having sex is seen as a beautiful and important activity which brings two people together and provides many physical and emotional health benefits.199 There is usually an agreement for monogamy or openness about multiple lovers, and partners try to find the time and energy to be sexual with each other. Sex partners in this stage go beyond the pure physical aspects
(fucking), and see each other as conscious subjects. They focus on pleasing the other within the context of individual boundaries, rather than trying to openly express and meet their own sexual needs, desires, and fantasies. This leads to sexuality at the lowest common denominator that often leaves both partners unfulfilled over time. Relationship difficulties such as power struggles or emotional withdrawal tend to be carried into the bedroom, but don’t get resolved there. Instead of working on deeper issues to improve their sexual relationship, couples in this stage sometimes try new positions or locations, engage in role playing, apply sex-toys, watch porn movies, or join swinger clubs to keep their sex life interesting. Unless they evolve to the next higher stage of sexual development, merely having sex will eventually turn stale, die completely, or become so difficult that their partnership ends when one of them falls in love/lust with a new sex partner.200
4. LOVEMAKING In the lovemaking stage, a couple’s sexuality becomes the expression of their genuine love, mutual acceptance, deep emotional intimacy, and the joy of being together. Body, mind, and heart are integrated in their lovemaking which is no longer just “a thing that couples do,” but an expression of who they are as sexual human beings. No special effort to find the time or energy to be sexual needs to be made by them. Their love making is a life-giving and rejuvenating affirmation of their bond and the depth of their connection. They are open to talking about their desires and exploring all forms of healthy sexual play that bring pleasure and deepen their union. They naturally stay in verbal and non-verbal communication (eye contact) with each other during their love making. Sex at this level is not used to cover up conflicts, to keep score, or to manipulate each other. Instead, sexual and emotional blocks that may arise are worked out between them, and therapeutic help is sought if they can’t resolve the problems that they face.201
5. TRANSCENDENT SEX This stage represents all advanced sacred or tantric practices that lead to spiritual state experiences through sexual union (such as Kundalini),202 that transcend the lovers’ sense of separation from each other and the universe. This kind of sexuality emerges as a stage between partners that share a deep soul connection, enjoy a high level of physical, emotional, and relationship health, and have reached an advanced stage of spiritual development (see above) with the ability for intense presence and full surrender. Spiritual practices such as meditation, partner-yoga, and ecstatic dance are often interwoven in this form of lovemaking. Partners who consciously engage in transcendent sexuality allocate ample quality time for their lovemaking (instead of waiting until they are in the mood); create sacred space in their home or away (think of a tastefully decorated warm room, soft sheets, various sized/shaped pillows, dimmed lights, scented candles, burning incense, veils around the bed, oils and lotions, and soft sacred music); and co-create a wide range of experiences through rituals such as sharing sensual food (think strawberries, chocolate, ice-cream, etc.), eye gazing, erotic dance, synchronized conscious breathing into the seven chakras, reciting of mantras, reading poems,203 alternate giving and receiving of arousing touch and massage, playfulness with objects (think feathers, boas, silk, flower petals, ice cubes), gentle intercourse, or unrestrained ravaging (that may be falsely interpreted as a form of rape).204 A common position for deep tantric connection is for the man to sit cross-legged (or on a chair) and the woman on top of him, allowing them to meet each other faceto-face as opposites and equals.205 The goal of transcendental sexuality is not solely to pleasure and to reach orgasms, but to move (Kundalini) energy up the spine or through the seven chakras, and to deepen the soul connection between the lovers that leads them to consciously experience the divine, instead of unconsciously exclaiming “oh my God” during a short orgasmic release.206 This requires the ability for men to delay or avoid orgasm, and/or to have orgasms without ejaculating by squeezing their PC muscle.207 Often, deeply rooted emotional blocks that are embedded in the body and inhibit a further spiritual awakening get revealed and can be released through transcendental sex.
ANIMA AND ANIMUS COMPLEX DEVELOPMENT In Jungian psychology, the anima and animus are seen as the bridge to the soul. One way to experience the soul is to get in touch with the unique sense of self that remains after we strip away all learned conceptions and false beliefs (ego) about who we are.208 What remains is the deepest possible authentic expression or essence of our unique being that is still personal, the subject that cannot be made into an object, or the soul. This unique core of our existence knows nothing about the duality of the opposite sex, gender, or the feminine-masculine polarities.209 As our self-identification as boys or girls develops during childhood, we invariably cover up, split-off, disown, repress, or dismiss qualities of the opposite sex to various degrees.210 Since we are all born to a mother, this intricate process is different for males and females. Little boys soon learn that they are not like mother, painfully dissociate from her, and identify with father figures, while little girls learn that they are like her, but not like father, who becomes somewhat of a mystery to them. 211 Carl Jung212 discovered this split-off and called the disowned feminine in males the anima, and the disowned masculine in females the animus.213 The parts of these disowned (and therefore unconscious) realities that are not recognized and reclaimed in later life appear as inward shadows that cover parts of the soul and consequently become outward projections onto the opposite sex, which is called a complex.214 You experience the projection of your anima when you feel a strong emotional (versus sexual or otherwise) attraction to, or threat from, a woman’s aura. If the attraction is mutual and you decide to become a couple, it will feel as if you have found and come home to your long lost other, your soul mate, or “twin-flame.” The blissful feelings of completeness when you are harmoniously together, the longings that you feel when you are apart, and the fears of loss and abandonment that you experience when she withdraws or challenges you are expressed in the lyrics of many love songs, such as “when I found you, there was no more emptiness inside,” or “if you leave me now, you take away the biggest part of me,” and movie dialogs such as “I love you, you complete me,” and her “you had me at hello.”215 Lovers with these experiences have fallen in love with a partner who has a compatible anima/animus complex. After a while, the pain of separation and missed love/care during childhood which created the complex in the first place will resurface. This especially happens once the honeymoon is over and the lovers fail to live up to their unrealistic expectations of meeting each other’s every need for comfort, acceptance, assurance, understanding, closeness, kindness, appreciation, approval, empathy, support, autonomy, etc. (see list in Chapter 3 under “Needs” and the difference between needs and neediness). In other words, they will start to push each other’s emotional buttons which they did not install in the
first place.216 If you cling and never want to let her go, miss her badly when she is away, get easily jealous if she turns her attention to somebody or something else,217 withdraw in shame if you can’t make her happy, 218 run if she seems to threaten, manipulate, control, or suffocate you, or if you feel that you can’t live without her—but need to change her so that you can live with her—then you know where the edge of your complex lies and where the healing work of your wounded anima begins.219 Your soul calls you to transcend your complex (shine light into your shadow) by realizing the wholeness of your essence and your oneness with all creation (Love), while your ego tries to protect you from being hurt again by defending its separate sense of self or clinging to what seems to be its salvation.220 If she shares your emotional attraction and you decide to stay together as a couple despite the inevitable conflicts that will arise, then you can serve each other as catalysts to uncover your soul’s essential nature by starting your healing, growth, and awakening process together. You then become soul mates in the true sense; two people who lovingly but relentlessly challenge each other to transcend their egos. This will bring forth your soul’s full potential to love unconditionally, not only for your own sake, but also for that of your partner and all sentient beings. 221 This dynamic answers the question of how a soul mate is different from family members or friends whom we may love dearly, but not in the unique way that we experience with a romantic partner.222 The five stages of anima/animus complex development that are outlined below provide you with a generalizing orientation to how a woman’s animus and a man’s anima may evolve. The actual stage and severity of the complex that an adult displays depends largely on his or her childhood and past relationship experiences. As you read through the descriptions below, one or more stages of the anima may resonate with your own level of development, just as you will recognize the animus of women that you are—or have been—in a relationship with. Note how stage five is almost identical for both sexes.
STAGES OF ANIMA DEVELOPMENT IN MEN 1. Women as mother He needs a mommy to take care of him. In this first stage, a man’s anima is completely tied up with the mother. She is not necessarily his personal mother but the image of a woman that is a faithful provider of nourishment, security, and love. She represents all that is natural, instinctual, and biological. 223 A man with an anima complex of this type cannot function well without a vital connection to a woman, and is easy prey of being controlled and exploited by her. He frequently suffers from impotence or has no sexual desire at all, and is therefore called a mama’s boy. This type of anima possession also manifests through fear of accidents or disease, or in a sort of dullness of personality. The Greek Sirens and the German Lorelei personify these dangerous aspects of the anima, which may even lead a man to his death over a lost love relationship through suicide.
2. Women as sex object He wants her to make him feel good. In the second stage, the anima is a collective sexual image. She is a Marilyn Monroe, Madonna, or Playboy model. Men in stage two are often Don Juans who see all women as sex objects, and engage in repeated sexual adventures, sometimes developing into sexual addictions. These relationships are invariably short-lived, because he is not faithful, is always looking for his next conquest, and no woman can ever live up to his unrealistic image of the ideal female partner.
3. Women as wife He wants her loyalty and support. In the third stage of his anima complex development, a man becomes ready to care for a wife and be devoted to his family. He is the loving protector and provider that women in the equivalent stage three of their animus development seek. Men with this anima accept their partner as she is, as long as she fulfills her role as supportive, undemanding, caring, and faithful wife, available sex partner, and loving mother to his children. His sexuality is usually integrated into their relationship and not an autonomous function that drives him. He can differentiate between love and lust, which allows him to create a lasting partnership (if she stays), because he can tell the difference between the objects of his sexual desire and the benefits of being a faithful partner/husband.
4. Women as guide to creativity and awakening He struggles with her need for independence. In the fourth stage, a man’s anima functions as a guide to his inner life. As women in this stage become emotionally and financially independent from men, they often turn away and abandon their partners against their will. This challenges him to seek other sources of fulfillment, happiness, aliveness, passion, joy, purpose, peace, and love. Through his quest arises a desire to answer life’s deeper questions of “who am I,” “where do I come from,” “why am I here,” “what is the meaning of my life,” “what should I do,” “what is my purpose,” and “where do I go”? Contemplating these questions, reading books like the one that you are holding right now, meditating, or seeking a bond with others on a similar path in men’s groups, New Age churches, and personal growth workshops allow him to bring deeper levels of his unconscious anima into his awareness. This leads to a liberating process of awakening to his authentic nature, true purpose, genuine passions, and capacity to love unconditionally that are independent from a partnership with a woman.224 On the flipside, he may show behaviors that are usually described as a midlife crisis,225 become commitment phobic, avoid deeper intimacy with
women altogether, or engage in serial monogamy or polyamory, 226 since he does not want to sacrifice his newfound freedom or to be limited by one partnership. This partial awakening (the idea of living alone is not Integral, fully realized, or the ultimate realization of human development) is transcended when a man enters stage five of his anima development.
5. Women as equal partner He meets her as an opposite and equal partner. Similar to a woman in this stage (see below), a man in stage five of his anima complex development has accepted the fact that conflicts and ambivalence are intrinsic to human relationships, and sees how their resolution contributes to his ongoing healing, personal growth, and spiritual realization. He feels confident, secure, and comfortable to authentically express his sexual essence (which tends to be masculine in heterosexual men), while he embraces his feminine (anima).227 This allows him to invite differing views, experiences, and feelings of his female partner without feeling threatened, offended, or puzzled by them. Her authentic stage-five feminine qualities naturally complement his masculinity and vice versa. Since he has found his own purposeful identity that does not depend on her inspiration, support, or approval, he appreciates his partner’s independent authority,228 and doesn’t feel responsibility, shame, or insecurity if she is unhappy—even though he shows empathy, care, and devotion—and enjoys when she is happy. He neither clings, nor pushes her away, but fully opens to embrace her at all levels of his being when they are together, and stays content and fulfilled when they are apart. This allows him to enter into a mature monogamous relationship of opposites and equals from which radically new life experiences, emotional healing processes, and deeper spiritual realizations that often become the foundation for altruistic acts of kindness and service towards others emerge.229
STAGES OF ANIMUS DEVELOPMENT IN WOMEN 1. Men as alien outsiders She fears, hates, and loves him. Because of abuse or abandonment from men that she indentified with during childhood, such as a father, father figure, older brother, uncle, or family friend, a woman in this stage completely denies and suppresses her animus as alien inside and outside of herself. She trusts her mother and other females, while she distrusts, hates, or fears men. This is often countered by a strange curiosity about men, which she cannot differentiate. This ambivalence can make her extremely seductive, needy, and clingy, and cause severe symptoms of the “seduce and withhold” 230 syndrome. As soon as a man gets close to her she withdraws, only to come back to ask for more after he becomes distant. She can break the heart of a weak man who tries to prove that he is different, attempts to rescue her from her fears, and so becomes codependent231 as she lures him into her pathological cat and mouse game. Within the limits of her domain in household, family, and female-oriented work environment (e.g., school teacher, nurse, artist, gardener, therapist, healer, working with animals, etc.), such a woman may seem grounded and self-confident. Outside those limits, she leaves the work and responsibility to men and more mature women.232
2. Men as father, God, or king She wants his approval. The self-esteem of a woman in this stage is directly connected to the response and approval that she receives from men. She is often driven by a need to be seen as the most attractive female, and constantly monitors her value by her internalized masculine judgment and through externalized male reflection. This may lead to a split in her personality when she imitates male behavior to be liked by them, and at other times presents herself as a sexually seductive femme fatale (such as in the movie Basic Instinct) to be desired. She either hides behind a feminine mask of beautiful appearance, graceful charming manner, and entertaining wit, or develops a tomboyish attitude through teasing, competing, and challenging, or some other facade that suggests success. Women in this stage gravitate towards men that they perceive to be more attractive, intelligent, and exciting than they could ever be themselves. They often try to live up to men by dietary restrictions, vigorous physical exercising, adapting to their intellectual interests, developing new talents, and being sexually available to become the perfect mate. If a woman remains in this stage, she is at great risk of entering a profound depression when her beauty and sexual attractiveness wane, and the number of heads that she is turning, and men who admire her diminishes. She may then isolate herself from all intimate relationships, because her perfectionism overrides her ability to be compassionate and to forgive her own and others’ mistakes. This may lead her to withdraw into a cold and bitter self-denial in which her anxieties create all kinds of psychosomatic illnesses, such as panic attacks, vomiting, heart problems, fatigue, and body aches. A strong, conscious, and patient man (or a good psychotherapist) can support a woman in this stage to find her own worth, passions, and identity, independent of male approval, which then allows her to enter into stage three.233
3. Men as hero She wants him to take care of her. Women in stage three seek a man as protector and provider with strength, courage, and ability, who can meet her needs, cherish her, and whom she wants to marry. He represents her ideal (and often unrealistic) image of the knight in shining armor who fulfills her expectations for good looks,
intelligence, solid reputation, stable finances, generosity, loyalty, humor, kindness, care, integrity, and faithfulness. To be in a good bargaining position, this woman will focus on her appearance, health/fitness, and adapting to the world of men by seeking a higher education, pursuing a career, fighting for social justice, or saving a failing business. She will appear as self-affirming and expects something in return. She functions well in the competitive world of men, sees herself as equal, is willing to share responsibilities, and will contribute and perform as long as her partner is able to provide more in return, since women want to marry up. As long as he meets her expectations for financial security, social status, and devotion, she will support him to achieve his full potential while often denying such achievements to herself. This can lead to feelings of resentment and anger when she sees that she has been “denied” the right to experience her own competence, and when her partner/husband fails to live up to her ever-growing expectations. Some women in this stage will enter an inward journey once they become aware of the transitory nature of their physical attractiveness, ability to succeed with men, and limitations of finding acceptance in the male world. This may lead them to the restoration of their female authority234 as they take responsibility for their own identity once they have moved into stage four of their animus complex development.235
4. Men as independent beings She wants her independence. A woman in stage four makes an active choice in favor of her self-interest and self-fulfillment—independent of a partner or husband. This transition takes place with the realization that she has constructed her own experiences throughout her lifetime in relationship to men, and now wants to find her own identity. She will stop trying to be perfect in all things in order to please her partner (who was a heroic father figure in the previous stage), as she becomes emotionally free from his approval and support. Having discovered her own source of worthiness and foundation, she is working to restore her female authority. Financial independence through her own labor or through other sources of money that are often only available to women, such as “divorcing well,” alimony and child-support payments, generous lovers, support from parents, or Social Security benefits, are the prerequisite for this transition. You will notice if your partner enters into stage four of her animus development when she starts to challenge you, cares less about your needs, seeks her financial independence, and refuses to take responsibility for holding your relationship together. If you are in partnership with a woman in this stage, it is important to know that it is not your fault that her pain of staying will eventually be greater than her fear of leaving, and that there is nothing you can do but to take care of yourself emotionally236 and sexually, protect the financial assets that are legitimately yours (if you have to, with the help of a CPA or lawyer), and, if you can, support her with love and compassion in her transition. Once separated and/or divorced, she will feel free from the evaluation and needs of men for the first time in her life. These newly single women are then much occupied with challenging work, their animals and children, social activities, educational advancements, maintaining their household, hobbies, world-travel, and their friendships.237 At the same time, they look down at women who show more feminine or balanced qualities and who desire to be (or are) in a committed partnership with a man. To women in stage four, partnered women still seem to be in the pitiful stage two or three of dependence on a male partner (which they have just escaped). However, married women may have actually advanced into stage five, which women in stage four cannot fathom yet. They discredit partnered women as unevolved and often compete with them in merciless ways. Women in stage four frequently break with the conventional role of caring mother, show tough love, and feel fulfilled outside a partnership with a man. Still, there remains an underlying fear of abandonment, especially in older women, when concerns about the disappearance of their skills and autonomy in the midst of a crisis arise. This often leads to feelings of ambivalence. On one side there is a secret longing for the stability and support that a partnership with a man could provide during times of stress, fatigue, loneliness, or desire for sex. On the other side there is the fear of becoming emotionally dependent, used, and dominated again. Frequent complaints about the lack of good men who are physically fit and attractive, highly intelligent, successful, accomplished, mature, kind, loving, generous, evolved, supportive, spiritual, and available when they need/want them, but who remain flexible, undemanding, and unattached otherwise, are a hallmark of women in stage four. 238 Becoming men-hating diehard singles, settling for “friends with benefits” whom they string along, or serial monogamy are often the only solutions that seem to solve their dilemma. It is not your fault if you get mixed messages, are rejected, or are ignored altogether by women in stage four that you try to date or get a commitment from, as these women are highly independent, endlessly demanding, impossible to please, and commitmentphobic.239 This is, of course, no problem for men who have entered stage four of their own anima development, which many single males and females falsely see as the highest stage of their personal and spiritual development (as in, I am so whole and complete, I don’t need a partner to complete me). If you have matured into stage five and meet a woman who is at the end of her animus stage four development, then you may be able to patiently support her to transition into stage five and find a wonderful partner in her.
5. Men as equal partners She wants him as an equal and opposite partner. Just as a man, a woman in stage five of her animus development has accepted that conflict and ambivalence are intrinsic to human relationships, and realized the significance of a partnership to balance her further psychological growth and spiritual awakening.240 Having fully claimed her own authority after transcending her animus complex, she no longer sees men as alien, superior, inferior, or independent. The realization that the idea of living and going it alone was a distorted conception of human existence emerges in her, because we never live alone. She sees that in being human we have a variety of economic, physical, sexual, psychological, and spiritual needs that cannot be met by living alone. At last she has the insight that a balanced personality always develops in a self-other conception, and never through the discovery of an independent self.241 This woman then desires the material, intellectual, emotional, sexual, and spiritual synergy that is co-created with a man who meets her as an opposite and equal (which means opposite feminine and masculine polarities with equal levels of consciousness, rights, and responsibilities). Since she may have never experienced a stage five partnership, she needs guidance from a man (like you?) at the same stage of his anima development, who is able to meet her in an integrally informed way. These couples can then form interdependent 242 partnerships in
which they heal, learn, grow, and enjoy family and social activities together, while contributing to the well-being of others.243
GROWTH The stage of anima/animus development in which individuals find themselves at the end of adolescence depends largely on the relationship that they have had with their parents during childhood, especially their opposite-sex parent.244 People may then remain stuck at that post-adolescent level for the rest of their lives, or they may advance to higher stages once the possibilities of one stage have been exhausted and pain stimulates a move to the next. This move rarely appears without struggle or crisis, such as fights with a partner, addictions, job loss, relocation, breakup, or divorce. If a man’s anima in any of the first four stages feels lonely and desperate for attention, he will experience an emotional attraction to a woman at a similar stage of her animus development, and vice versa. For example, a man in a mother-bound stage one will choose a woman who clings and takes care of him in exchange for getting her codependent needs met by him. A man in stage two who is not living up to his true potentials will be attracted to a woman who spurs him on and makes more of him than he would otherwise be, in exchange for getting his approval. A man in stage three may project his complex onto a woman who wants to get married, cared for, and provided for, and is thus led away from his responsibility to himself. He has the opportunity to enter stage four when his wife/partner leaves him, when he no longer wants to put up with her constant unhappiness and ignorance, or when he embarks on a spiritual journey to discover his own identity and passion—independent of a committed partnership (the latter is usually triggered by a midlife crisis). This may eventually lead him into stage five, in which his complex becomes increasingly conscious and transcended, which feels like a big awakening. He then no longer depends on women to complete him AND he can open up fully to a committed partnership without emotional neediness or fear of abandonment. This allows him to attract a woman in stage five of her animus development who wants to co-create a partnership with a man who is an opposite and equal. In other words, the feminine and masculine qualities that men and women have denied within themselves will confront them in their relationships with the opposite sex.245 What is often painfully experienced as a difficult or failed marriage can actually support men and women in moving forward in their anima and animus complex development and spiritual awakening. This move forward is always worthwhile, for it leads us ever closer towards the discovery of our true essence (soul). Individuals who ignore or repress the calling of their anima or animus and avoid growth through intimate relationships (although there are, of course, times in life where it is prudent to be alone) risk becoming depressed, cynical pseudointellectuals. They may then lose all joy, capacity to love, meaning, purpose, and spontaneity in their lives. Active avoidance of a partnership out of fear of becoming engulfed or abandoned, or out of arrogance (the feeling that no one is good enough for me) is therefore an indication that more growth-work is needed, and by no means a sign of maturity, transcendence, wholeness, or enlightenment.246 As men and women transcend their anima/animus projections in the course of their partnerships and increasingly develop internally what they seek or avoid externally, they will be rewarded with becoming deeper, more vibrantly alive and creative human beings as well as more balanced partners in their love relationship.247
IN SUMMARY Not only children, but also adults have the potential to advance in all the developmental lines. This growth appears in progressive levels from lowest to highest, one step at a time. Each higher level provides better answers to life’s questions and challenges than the preceding one. In this chapter we defined the levels of four developmental lines that are particularly relevant to partnerships: (1) eight levels of consciousness development (from archaic to magic, egocentric, conformist, rational, pluralistic, integral, and transpersonal); (2) five state-stages of spiritual development (from gross to subtle, causal, witness, and non-dual); (3) five levels of sexual expression and experience (from repressed sexuality, to fucking, having sex, lovemaking, and transcendental/tantric sexuality); and (4) five levels of the feminine and masculine shadow that cover up the soul/essence of males and females, called the anima and animus complex. In Chapter 7 we will introduce a Personality Matrix that ties these four lines together with personality types (see below) and the feminine/masculine polarities.
CHAPTER 5 States of Falling in Love Sometimes with the Heart Seldom with the Soul Scarce once with the Might Few—love at all ~ Emily Dickinson ~ All temporary experiences that come and go in a fluid way and are recognized as such by the subject (e.g., I was angry, happy, sleeping, awake, stoned, drunk, in love, etc.) are called states of consciousness (not to be confused with the vertical/hierarchical structure stages of consciousness from which states are observed and interpreted). In the context of this manual, this chapter will focus on the states of falling in love.248 Feelings such as sexual lust, infatuation, bliss of romance, emotional bonding, or pain/depression after a breakup or divorce are all temporary states (versus permanent stages) that are caused by elevated or lowered levels (imbalances) of specific chemicals in our body, called hormones and neurotransmitters.249 These hormonal responses originally evolved through our ancestors, who chose the fittest and most compatible sex partners, excluded others once they found a mate for procreation, moved on if pregnancy wasn’t the result of their efforts in due time,250 stayed together while raising their young, and, if they were to become depressed during times of hardship, abandonment, or loss, solicited compassionate responses from others.251 These powerful chemicals still play an important role in our mating behavior to this day, as they can send us on incredible highs when we fall in love, and cause deep pain when we get cut off from the object of our desire. The intensity of the chemistry that lovers experience is directly related to the degree that they meet each other’s Primary Fantasy. Other factors include, compatible genes,252 the matching of their mutually compatible unconscious anima/animus complex and other shadow elements, and the level of their preceding loneliness.253 Even though many people fantasize about, and even anticipate falling in love at first sight, only 11% of married couples report having had this experience when they first met.254 For the remaining 89%, the love hormones kicked in over time once they had a neutral or positive first impression of each other, but experienced no particular initial sexual or romantic attraction. Proximity, their general state of vulnerability and unsettlement,255 as well as frequency, duration, and intensity of the ensuing contacts were crucial factors for romantic feelings to emerge, especially in women.256 Once infatuated, lovers see the object of their desire through rose-colored glasses, and often falsely interpret their chemistry as a sign of true love and compatibility that will last forever—the “happily ever after” fantasy that is the theme of many romantic movies, love songs, romance novels, and fairy tales. Fortunately, all hormone-driven states of falling in and out of love are temporary states and not permanent stages. The three major states/phases of attraction that are outlined below provide you with a very general overview of the intricate and mysterious role that chemicals play in the human experiences of lust, romance, commitment, and painful breakups.257
PHASE 1 – LUST Sexual urges and lust are driven by the sex hormone testosterone. It is not only present in males—even though levels in their bodies are usually ten times higher than in women’s bodies, which leads men to think about and crave sex more often258—but also plays a role in the sexual desires and emotional well-being of women. However, estrogen is the dominant cuddle hormone in females and stimulates seductiveness, openness, and receptiveness, as well as longing for physical closeness, skin-to-skin contact, and sex.259 Estrogen is also important for vaginal health (thick viscosity of lubrication, firm muscle tone, elasticity, and thickness of the vaginal walls) and often diminishes during and after menopause, when frequency of intercourse diminishes.260 Sometimes a role reversal in sexual appetites appears around midlife when testosterone levels and the resulting libido naturally decrease in men, while the libido of women increases as the testosterone-masking effects of estrogen decline.261 At any rate, increased levels of testosterone create sexual desire and get men and women out there looking for somebody, and healthy levels of estrogen make women seductive and receptive.262
PHASE 2 – ROMANCE This is the truly love-struck phase. After people get infatuated and enter the romance state, they can hardly think of anything else, lose their appetite, need less sleep, spend hours at a time daydreaming about their new love, engage in endless phone conversations, email exchanges, and text messaging, and try to spend as much time together as possible. In the infatuated romance state, a group of neurotransmitters called monoamines play an important role. These are: Dopamine—also activated by cocaine, nicotine, heroin, and other addictive substances. It creates the drive to seek the rewarding stimulus and is therefore associated with any kind of major addiction, in our case to a member of the opposite sex.263 Norepinephrine—similar to its better known cousin adrenaline, increases energy, memory function for new stimuli (men really listen and remember after they have fallen in love), perspiration, heart rate, and blood pressure, with the downside of lowered appetite, sleeplessness, and exhilaration. It also stimulates more “fight or flight” responses, which often leads new lovers to be over-reactive or edgy.264
Serotonin—suspected to be one of love’s most important chemicals. Lowered levels of serotonin allow for an increase of the love hormones testosterone, dopamine, and norepinephrine.265 Similar to patients with obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), the serotonin-starved brains of lovers obsessively think about the object of their desire, which renders them temporarily insane, especially if their love is unrequited. Serotoninenhancing antidepressants (a.k.a. selective serotonin seuptake inhibitors or SSRI’s) such as Prozac, Celexa, Lexapro, Luvox, Paxil, or Zoloft can help in such situations, but are also known to lower a person’s sex drive and romantic feelings towards others. So it is advisable to stay away from these medications if you can.266 The drug-induced romance phase lasts between 3 and 24 months, which, again, has evolutionary reasons. This was the period of time that it took for our ancestors to try to get pregnant. Otherwise they would move on to find a new partner. Even modern couples who don’t want children couldn’t stay infatuated forever, otherwise they wouldn’t get any work done, which does not mean that you should no longer be romantic after the romance phase—quite the contrary. If lovers manage to resolve the inevitable conflicts that arise at the end of the romance phase in a constructive way and stay together,267 they may reap the long-term benefits of increased social status, financial stability, physical health, and sexual satisfaction, as well as personal and spiritual growth in the commitment state that follows.
PHASE 3 – COMMITMENT Two attachment hormones support couples in sustaining their commitment to each other beyond the romance phase, especially if pregnancy occurs. These chemicals evolved through the descendants of devoted parents who were more successful in raising their young to maturity by staying together and supporting each other, than those who separated. Oxytocin—released during childbirth and causes the female breasts to produce milk. It helps cement the strong bond between mother and child. Oxytocin is also released in both sexes during orgasm and is thought to promote the bonding between adults who become sexually intimate. It also reduces stress, especially in women, and is believed to have many other health benefits for both sexes.268 Vasopressin—the monogamy hormone that plays an important role in the long-term commitment between partners. Levels increase before and during orgasm. The bonding effect of vasopressin was discovered when scientists injected different amounts into the bodies of prairie voles.269 Long-term partnerships can stay satisfying and exciting beyond the romance phase if the couple is compatible along crucial developmental lines, is dedicated to ongoing personal and spiritual growth in the context of their union, and shares rewarding activities such as travel, hobbies, joint projects, realization of common dreams, participating in growth workshops, and a vibrant tantric sex life with each other.270
YOUR GIFT THAT KEEPS ON GIVING The seminal fluid (ejaculate/cum) that surrounds sperms contains dopamine, norepinephrine, testosterone, various estrogens, oxytocin, and vasopressin, which all contribute to the physical and emotional health of women.271 The theory goes that the more sex a couple has, the deeper their bond becomes—so go for it if you want her to stick around, and be responsible if you are not serious and don’t want to hurt her feelings.272
ADDICTED TO LOVE Some people, especially those who are highly desirable to the opposite sex and have no problem attracting partners, can get addicted to the hormonal thrill during the infatuation and romance state, and often move from one lover to the next, which can become destructive to their own and other people’s lives (think movie stars and rock stars). There is even a 12-step group for sex and love addicts, called Sex and Love Addicts Anonymous, or for short SLAA.273 Such behavior is called “digging many shallow holes,” as it never leads to the rewards that staying and doing the work in a committed, healthy, long-term partnership provides. Some people try to prolong the romance phase by engaging in the excitement and drama of codependent, polyamorous, or open relationships,274 which are rarely sustainable. Yet others are afraid of the distracting, challenging, and sometimes emotionally devastating effects that the rise and fall of the love hormones can have on their life, and avoid partnerships altogether. Therapists have suggested to their female clients to run in the opposite direction when they feel a strong attraction to a man. From their experience with pathologically feminine clients who only follow their chemically-induced feelings without verifying them with their rational mind (ignoring red flags), such relationships usually end in a disaster. This leaves many females confused between their chemistry-driven instincts and their reasoning mind, instead of learning how to integrate them both in a functional way and to see a partnership as an opportunity for their healing and growth.275
INTEGRATING CHEMISTRY WITH REASON On one hand, chemistry is the prerequisite for any romantic interest to emerge and for good reasons—it is the ancient wisdom of our body and unconscious mind that signals to us that we have found a physically/socially (see Primary Fantasy), genetically, emotionally, and spiritually compatible mate to procreate, heal, grow, and awaken with. On the other hand, chemistry effectively impairs our rational faculties, which leads us to conveniently ignore incompatible values, worldviews, intellects, relationship skills, passions, interests, lifestyle choices, and dreams for the future. The ability of a man to differentiate between chemistry and rationality, and to integrate them both is therefore essential for the co-creation of a sustainable, healthy love relationship—if that is what you and your partner desire. If you don’t take this responsibility, your mate is likely to deny any fault and say that she overlooked red flags, lost faith in you, grew apart, no longer loves you, or that you seduced and manipulated her for sex, when she dumps you after the romance phase is over. In Parts II and III of the manual we will dive deeper into the factors that allow you to determine if a temporary love-struck phase (or a marriage that went sour) can be transformed into a healthy partnership or not. This will put you in command of your emotional, time, and financial investment in a woman. It will also allow you to make responsible choices with integrity about engaging her further and working inside the partnership to resolve
problems (if she happens to be willing to do so), or to let her go gracefully with love and compassion when it is time for her to move on.
IN SUMMARY The various feelings of lust, infatuation, romance, and commitment are temporary hormone-driven states and not permanent stages. Even though chemistry plays a vital role in the sexual selection process, the love hormones can blind lovers to the red flags, indicating that a long-term healthy partnership may fail to flourish. By differentiating and integrating both aspects of love—the hormone-driven thrills of chemistry AND practical compatibility factors—integrally informed men can make responsible mate choices and minimize the risk of bad emotional, financial, and time investments in infatuated women who will eventually move on and break their hearts. It also allows men to show compassion and patience if their partner suffers because of hormonal imbalances.
CHAPTER 6 Evaluating Personality Types He who knows others is learned. He who knows himself is wise. ~ Lao Tzu ~ All humans possess certain personality characteristics that stay consistent throughout their lifetime. The Integral Model refers to these fixed character traits as personality types or simply types. Most commonly known are introverts and extroverts, Type-A (impatient, hostile) and Type-B (calm, laid-back) personalities, the nine types of the Enneagram, and the infamous astrological signs of the Zodiac. Less recognized but equally relevant are the three NLP types, the Five Love Languages, and the Myers-Briggs type indicator. Knowledge about viable personality types and their integration with the other elements of the Integral Model provide you with crucial information that can make or break a relationship. Unfortunately, women often reduce questions of compatibility to types (he is just not my type, I don’t get along with Capricorns, I don’t like introverts, etc.), so knowing about the validity of typologies can be useful. Exploring and analyzing types is relatively simple, can be fun, usually resonates with women, and can provide a lot of insights, so here we go.
NLP TYPES Neuro-Linguistic Programming, or NLP, is a method that originated in the 1970s to improve therapeutic and personal successes by replicating effective patterns of behavior and communication. The model soon became popular in sales, education, and change management to create better rapport with customers, students, and employees276 and can also be applied to improve success with a woman.277 NLP identifies three basic learning and communication modalities in people—auditory, visual, and kinesthetic. Auditory types connect through verbal exchange and might say “I hear what you say,” or “let me tell you something.” They learn and communicate through words. Visual types like to see/show things and might say “I see what you mean” or “let me show you how I see things.” They learn and communicate through images. Kinesthetic types like to feel and touch and might say “this really touches me” or “don’t you feel what is going on.” They learn and communicate through shared feeling and hands-on experiences.
NLP TECHNIQUES To effectively communicate and build rapport with women (or others in general), it is helpful to understand their NLP type and to communicate in the language that resonates most with them. The Eye Accessing Cue technique (described in more detail in the endnotes) helps to identify if people are thinking in images (visual), in sounds and self-talk (auditory), or through their feelings (kinesthetic), and if they are focused on the past or constructing ideas for the future.278 Reading these cues correctly can support you in understanding and responding to your partner with more empathy. Another NLP technique called mirroring can be used to build instant rapport. During mirroring/pacing you synchronize your body language, facial expressions, tone of voice, and breathing pattern with your partner. This will give her a sense of comfort, ease, and safety through familiarity.279
FIVE LOVE LANGUAGES Based on the three NLP types that we discussed above there are five different ways through which people give and receive love.280 These are: 1) Words of affirmation (NLP auditory) such as “I love you,” “you are wonderful,” “I miss you,” and by calling frequently or, sending emails, text messages, cards, and handwritten love letters. 2) Quality time spent together while doing enjoyable things such as going to the movies, playing board/card games, sharing time with friends and family, shopping sprees, sports, cooking, or travel. 3) Gifts (NLP visual) such as chocolate, flowers, candles, books, CDs, clothes, jewelry, a car, boat, house, island, or country. 4) Acts of service such as cooking dinner, cleaning the house, bringing breakfast to bed, driving the car, fixing things, or running errands. 5 ) Physical touch (NLP kinesthetic) such as holding hands, cuddling, kissing, giving and receiving massages, taking baths together, or sensuality/sex. All people have a primary and secondary Love Language that resonates most with them. Often, partners are not aware of their different love languages and therefore miscommunicate their affection and appreciation for each other; for example, if he washes her car and buys her gifts, while she would rather receive a love letter and cuddle. You can identify your partner’s love language through skillful questions and answers (ask for a list of 10 or more things that make her feel loved, and do a few every day), observations, by asking her to take an online test,281 or by having her answer the questionnaire in the back of the book, The 5 Love Languages by Gary Chapman.
THE ENNEAGRAM
The Enneagram is a synthesis of several ancient wisdom traditions that has become one of the most popular typologies in recent years. Today it is widely applied in business (team building/change management), psychotherapy, personal growth, and spirituality. 282 The Enneagram symbol is composed of three interlaced “triangles” that form a geometric figure with nine points around a circle, with each of them representing a specific personality type. It is common to find a little of yourself in all of the types, although one of them will stand out prominently as being closest to yourself. Each of the nine types has unhealthy, average, and healthy expressions (or assets and liabilities). The number above or below a person’s main type represents the secondary quality or “wing,” while the two inner lines point to the corresponding types that individuals gravitate towards under stress/disintegration and during healthy integration/growth.283
Figure 17: The Enneagram THE NINE ENNEAGRAM TYPES284 1. The reformer, judge, perfectionist Is focused on personal integrity and seeks truth. Can be a teacher, crusader, or advocate for change. Is often ignorant of his/her own flaws and overly critical of others. Fears being corrupt, evil, or defective—wants to be good, balanced, perfect, and have integrity.
2. The helper, giver, caretaker Is compassionate, attentive, generous, and caring. Can be clingy, needy, flattering, people-pleasing, and manipulative. Often well-meaning and driven to be close to others, but can slip into doing things for others in order to be needed. Fears being unwanted and unlovable—wants to be loved and needed.
3. The achiever, performer, status seeker Is adaptable and changeable. Walks the world with confidence and acts in ways that will bring approval and accomplishments, sometimes at the expense of his/her true self. Fears failure and being worthless—wants to feel valuable and worthwhile.
4. The individualist, romantic, aesthete Is driven by the desire to understand and to find his/her place in the world. Embraces individualism, is creative, intuitive, and humane. Fears having no identity or personal significance—wants to be significant.
5. The investigator, expert, thinker Is driven to understand the world and derives self-worth through contribution, can be withdrawn, observant, and quiet, until he/she can impress with a witty remark. Fears incompetency or uselessness—wants to be capable and knowledgeable above all else.
6. The loyalist, hero, rebel, defender Longs for secure stability and exhibits unwavering loyalty and responsibility. Is slow to trust again if betrayed and prone to fearful thinking. Displays emotional anxiety as well as reactionary and paranoid behavior. Fears being without support and guidance—wants to have security and support.
7. The enthusiast, adventurer, sensationalist Is adventurous and constantly busy, embraces life with all its various joys and wonders, and moves frantically from one new experience to another. Fears being unable to provide for him/herself, and is afraid of missing out on life with all of its richness—wants to be satisfied, content, and to have his/her needs fulfilled.
8. The challenger, boss, maverick Is strong, with a desire to be a powerful and controlling leader. Can be friendly and charitable, or dictatorial, manipulative, ruthless, and willing to destroy anything that stands in the way. Fears being harmed or controlled by others—seeks self-protection and wants to be in control of life and destiny.
9. The peacemaker, mediator, preservationist
Is empathetic, receptive, gentle, calm, and at peace with the world. Avoids conflict, withdraws, shuts down, and goes along with other people’s wishes. Is prone to dissociation and passive-aggressive behavior. Fears loss and separation—wants to have inner stability and peace of mind.
THE ENNEAGRAM COMPATIBILITY COMBINATIONS No pairing of types is particularly blessed or doomed. You can have a healthy relationship between any two types. Free or affordable assessment tests on the Internet allow you to determine your and your partner’s type and the assets and liabilities between the two of you.285
MYERS-BRIGGS TYPE INDICATOR According to the Myers-Briggs type indicator, all people can be classified using four opposing criteria: Extroversion - Introversion Sensing - Intuitive Thinking - Feeling Judging - Perceiving
INTROVERT AND EXTROVERT286 These are the attitudes that show how a person orients and receives their energy. The extrovert’s energy flow is outward, and the preferred focus is on other people and things. The introvert’s energy flow is inward and the preferred focus is on his or her own thoughts, ideas, and impressions.
SENSING AND INTUITION These are the perceiving and non-rational functions. People don’t have much control over their perceptions, only how to process them once they have them. Sensing people tend to focus on the present and on concrete information gained from their five senses. Intuitive people tend to focus on the future, with a view towards patterns and possibilities, and prefer to receive guidance from their unconscious or the spiritual realm.
THINKING AND FEELING These are the judging functions. Both types strive to make rational judgments and decisions based on the information from their perceiving functions, above. Thinkers tend to base their decisions on logic such as “true-false, if-then” connections and on objective analysis of cause and effect. Feeling people tend to base their decisions primarily on values and subjective evaluations based on concerns for other people. They use “more-less, better-worse” evaluations. It could be said that thinkers decide with their heads, while feelers decide with their hearts. When thinking or feeling is extroverted, decisions tend to rely on external sources and the generally accepted rules and procedures. When introverted, thinking and feeling judgments tend to be subjective, relying on internally generated ideas for logical organization and evaluation.
JUDGING AND PERCEIVING287 People who favor judging like a planned and organized approach to life and prefer to have things settled. People who prefer perceiving tend to like a flexible and spontaneous approach to life and prefer to keep their options open.
COMBINATIONS Different combinations of the four either/or criteria determine a type. For example: ISTJ - Introvert Sensing Thinking Judging The sixteen possible combinations are ISTJ, ISFJ, INFJ, INTJ, ISTP, ISFP, INFP, INTP, ESTP, ESFP, ENFP, ENTP, ESTJ, ESFJ, ENFJ, and ENTJ. You can identify your own and your partner’s types with their associated strengths and weaknesses by taking an online Myers-Briggs typology test.288
ASTROLOGY According to a Harris poll, 31% of Americans believe in astrology (25% of men, 36% of women). 289 Astrological charts and computer programs claim to provide solid information about personality types, compatibilities, and one’s destiny. At the very least, they make for interesting and revealing conversations; so no matter if you are one of the 25% of male believers or not, you may want to stay open-minded. Some women will not even consider you as a partner if you are not a good astrological fit, while others may determine that you are their soul mate after doing your chart without ever having met you.290
OTHER TYPES AND BELIEFS You may come across some other typing (and stereotyping), such as numerology, human design, 291 birth order, 292 genetic types,293 the inner animal, cultural background (e.g., European versus Asian), or race. Unfortunately, most of these ways of typecasting people are not very scientific, but rather stem from magical thinking or judgmental projections. Showing an open and discerning interest in unscientific approaches to typologies and acceptance of superstitious, magical, or mythic beliefs (see pre/trans fallacy in Chapter 4), such as tarot card readings, divination cards, psychic readings, horoscopes, past-life experiences, shamanic voyages, Reiki healing, out-of-body experiences, etc. that your partner might subscribe to can provide new insights for you and her that create more
intimacy and expand your horizons.
IN SUMMARY Personality types describe character traits that stay consistent throughout human growth and stage development. Most classifications, such as how people give and receive love, or their Enneagram type, are based on viable psychological tests or self-assessments and describe habitual responses to reality that lie under the surface of our normal awareness. Other typologies originate from superstitious beliefs or cultural stereotyping and can, at best, provide interesting topics for authentic self-revealing conversations. To explore and discuss your own and your partner’s types in different areas can be a lot of fun and reward you with new personal insights that will improve your self-understanding and partnership.
Conclusion Part I We started out with a brief evolutionary history of the sexes that culminated in our modern-world reality, in which liberated modern and postmodern women have gained equal rights and access to virtually every male domain (often without assuming equal responsibilities), while males have remained largely stuck in their traditional gender roles as disposable protectors and providers. We discussed the UN strategy of Gender Mainstreaming as a concept for the co-creation of a desirable future for humanity, between post-feminist/post-postmodern women and integrally informed men. This led us to the five core elements of the Integral Relationship Model: (1) sex/gender/polarities, (2) lines of development, (3) levels of development, (4) states of falling in love, and (5) personality types—which have been identified in the East and West as the essential facets of our human experience and growth potentials.
Part II – Men and Women Coming Together In every age men have tried to assemble all the knowledge and experience of their day into a single whole which would explain their relation to the universe and their possibilities in it. In the ordinary way they could never succeed. For the unity of things is not realisable by the ordinary mind, in an ordinary state of consciousness. The ordinary mind, refracted by the countless and contradictory promptings of different sides of human nature, must reflect the world as manifold and confused as is man himself. A unity, a pattern, an all-embracing meaning—if it exists—could only be discerned or experienced by a different kind of mind, in a different state of consciousness. It would only be realisable by a mind which had itself become unified. ~ Rodney Collin ~ It is one thing to take a holistic approach and to consider all the essential elements of our human nature, but a totally different task to integrate those factors into a coherent model. This is what Ken Wilber elegantly accomplished with his Integral AQAL model of human growth and potentials. In this part of the manual we will take Wilber’s original ideas one step further to explore interpersonal dynamics between men and women on a physical, psychological, cultural, and social level (or body, mind, heart, and soul). We will: (1) Look at the Primary Fantasy at different levels of consciousness (2) Construct a Personality Matrix that integrates the developmental lines (consciousness, spiritual, sexual and anima/animus) personality types and the feminine/masculine polarities that we outlined in Part I (3) Introduce the concept of holons, which clarifies how humans can be simultaneously whole in themselves and part of a relationship (4) Add the missing “Q” element (the four quadrants) of Ken Wilber’s original AQAL model that we omitted in Part I (5) Construct several Triangles of Love (6) Investigate differences in male and female growth in consciousness
Figure 18: Integrating the Primary Fantasy and Personality Matrix through Triangles of Love
CHAPTER 7 Primary Fantasy and Personality Women marry men, hoping that they will change. Men marry women, hoping they will not. So each is inevitably disappointed. ~ Albert Einstein ~ Men and women tend to fall in love with members of the opposite sex who meet their Primary Fantasy and have a charming personality. In this chapter we will explore how the attractiveness of men and women changes at different levels of consciousness development and what makes partners compatible in their psychological makeup.
ATTRACTIVENESS AT DIFFERENT LEVELS OF CONSCIOUSNESS From your personal experiences in partnerships and observations of other couples, you have most likely seen that the most successful males have access to the sexually most attractive females and vice versa. Less desirable singles either settle for a partner with comparable social assets (looks/age, status/money), try to augment their socioeconomic status (males) or sexiness (females),294 keep holding out for the off-chance to attract a partner who is “out of their league” (these relationships usually don’t last very long), settle for uncommitted “friends with benefits” or “fuckbuddies” (where meeting each other’s Primary Fantasy is not so important), or give up on finding a partner for a love relationship altogether. The parameters that define male success in the eyes of females significantly increase in complexity with each level of her consciousness development, while the definition of sexiness that makes females attractive to males (a healthy body, sexual availability/radiance, and support of his vision) is consistent throughout human evolution, across cultures, and within vertical stage development of men.295 In the archaic infrared stage of consciousness development (1% of U.S. adult population), male success is defined by day-to-day survival skills. In females, a healthy sexy body that indicates fertility and sexual availability are seen as attractive. In the superstitious magenta stage (10%), male success is defined by the ability to adapt to their immediate natural environment, cleverly exploit its resources, appease threatening ghosts or spirits through perceived magical powers, and loyalty to their family clan, band, or gang. In females, a healthy sexy body that indicates fertility, sexual availability, and healthy instincts are seen as attractive. In the egocentric red stage (20%), male success is measured by their level of independence, confidence, aggressiveness, potency, creativity, and ability to cleverly exploit others for their own immediate gain. In females, a flashy sexy body, a high “fuckability” factor, and respect for his needs/attitude are seen as attractive. In the conformist amber stage (40%), male success is measured by their level of reliability, job security, and devotion to family, religion, and country (the conservative, consistent, law-abiding husband). In females, a healthy sexy body, sexual willingness, elegance, and devotion to him are seen as attractive. In the rational orange stage (25%), male success is defined by their levels of income,296 future earning potentials,297 overall net worth, displays of status symbols (e.g., Rolex watch, luxury car, designer clothes, penthouse apartment, or mansion—and lately some pseudo-environmental consciousness, for example driving a hybrid or electric car, or installing solar panels), social status, advanced degrees and titles, professional achievements, international travel experience, ambition, cleverness, wit, generosity, and physical fitness (the winner). In females, a healthy sexy body, being “sex-positive,” physical fitness, classiness, and support of his mission are seen as attractive. In the pluralistic green stage (10%), male success is evaluated by the amount of available time, level of passive income, accumulated wealth, altruism,298 emotional availability, environmental awareness, natural health consciousness, worldliness, and sensitivity (the affluent, kind, semiretired activist, philanthropist, healer, teacher, artist, etc.). In females, a naturally beautiful, healthy, sexually radiant body, and support for his vision are seen as attractive. In the Integral teal and transpersonal turquoise stages (4%), male success is defined by increasing wisdom, ability to integrate all the healthy qualities from the previous stages (survival skills, natural instincts, power/creativity, devotion, financial success/status, and sensitivity), and embodiment of higher state-stages of spiritual realizations and ego transcendence. In females, a healthy sexy body, sexual shine, skills as a tantric lover, and ability to meet him as an opposite and equal at the level of all seven chakras in kind and degree are seen as attractive.
WOMEN MARRY UP As we have seen above, the demands of females to have their Primary Fantasy fulfilled increases in complexity and financial cost with each higher stage of their consciousness development (from survival to protection, heroism, stability, material abundance, independent wealth, and integration of all the former qualities), while the desire of males for a healthy-looking, sexy, and sexually available female who supports him in his particular mission and purpose stays consistent as he evolves, and is rather narrowly defined (see Chapter 2). As a consequence, we find most adults in the pre-conventional red and conventional amber stage in a partnership, while many modern orange and postmodern green women stay single, because it is harder for them to find suitable partners who meet their high standards. Red women tend to depend on the approval, protection, and support of men, and only leave their partner if they find a more successful protector. Women in amber usually stay with their husbands “for richer or poorer, in sickness and in health, for better or worse, till death does them part” ... until they enter into the rational orange and/or animus complex stage four of their development and often leave. Because the different gender roles and feminine/masculine polarities in the pre-conventional and conventional stages are clearly assigned and divided between the sexes (males are masculine producers/protectors, females are feminine reproducers/caretakers), it is easy for women to fall in love and to choose a partner that they can “marry up to.” This changes dramatically for women who have entered the rational and pluralistic stages with an animus complex at level four. By definition, they
have climbed the social ladder and become emotionally and financially independent from a partner through their own education and professional careers, “divorcing well” (70% of divorces are filed by women), and/or trust funds (the modern trust-fund baby). Having reached full gender equality with men in terms of rights (without the same responsibilities), and often exceeding their socioeconomic status, it becomes ever harder for these women to find the elusive Mr. Right (“where are all the good men?????”) to “marry up to.” 299 This is especially true for those who are older, overweight, out of shape, or otherwise physically unattractive.300 It is of course understandable and legitimate that healthy, intelligent, successful, and highly independent women don’t want to become “a nurse and a purse” for older “loser men” who are typically interested in them. It simply leaves many former trophy wives and self-fulfilled career women without a steady partner after they successfully divorced their husbands, or were abandoned by them for a younger woman. Those who like to have sex (called “sex-positive”) and who are still physically attractive may become “cougars”301 who engage significantly younger men (who often can’t attract/afford women at their own age or younger) as uncommitted lovers, fuck-buddies, and boy-toys. This dynamic leads to an ever-increasing number of attractive single women who get “piled up” at the top of the social ladder, and less attractive “loser men” (such as divorced and child-support-paying fathers, failed business men, men in their midlife crisis, starving artists, lower- and middleclass workers/managers, socially/environmentally conscious dropouts, as well as the unemployed, disabled, ill, addicted, insecure, depressed, etc.) at the bottom.302 On the other hand, the assets of financially successful males (less than 5% of the population) tend to appreciate as they get older, while the primary assets of women (age/looks) inevitably depreciate.303 Consequently, these highly desirable and sought-after men have no real incentive to become a “one-woman man” or to get married, especially if they have been burned financially and emotionally in previous relationships or have not dealt with unresolved psychological issues.304 These changes in the socioeconomic fabric have led to a sad reality for many modern and postmodern men and women who have a “flatland”305 perspective, and objectify the opposite sex for their looks, wealth, and social status. The following diagram illustrates this dynamic: On the horizontal X axis you find the increasing attractiveness of men based on their income/wealth and that of women based on their sexual desirability. On the vertical Y axis you find the number of males and females. While the U.S. median income in 2006 for people age 25 and older was $32,140 (with only 5.2% making more than $75K),306 most attractive women (of which there is a high number) desire men who make $75K-150K or more. This leads to the dynamic that many man with average incomes (see the bump in the center of the graphic) look at sexually attractive women (see the bump in the right side of the graphic) whom they can’t afford, while these women look for men with high incomes, who are few and far between. As a consequence we see an increasing number of frustrated single men and women.
Figure 19: Divergence in male/female Primary Fantasy There is one more (widely unacknowledged) twist to this new social dynamic: the professional medical community and public health organizations urge people to maintain a healthy body mass index (BMI)307 and to stay physically fit through regular exercise (at least thirty minutes daily).308 Women who follow these guidelines become—as a side effect—sexually more attractive to men. On the other hand, we slowly come to realize that, as Rabbi Michael Lerner has observed, “the unrestrained pursuit of money and power lead to huge ethical distortions for human life, and the destruction for our ecosystem and society.” 309 Ergo, the Primary Fantasy of males (unless taken to rare extremes, such as men longing for significantly underweight women with enlarged breasts) has positive effects for the health and well-being of females, while the Primary Fantasy of most women (if taken to the unsustainable levels that have become the norm in modern societies of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, especially in the U.S.) has become a liability for all humanity and our ecosystem.310 This is quite a dilemma, as men have little choice but to be attracted to healthy sexy women, who are naturally highly demanding, and women have little choice but to desire financially successful, competitive, and powerful males whose actions are often socially and environmentally irresponsible. One possible solution to this dilemma would be that more men start to live responsible single lives than to compete with other males for the admiration, love, sex, and company of physically and mentally healthy women. The less likely alternative would be that women start to reward men who pursue an environmentally sustainable and non-violent existence through downsizing their lifestyle and through cooperation instead of competition. “What a wonderful world this would be”...at least for us men and our environment.
PERSONALITY MATRIX The relationship dynamic that develops between partners beyond the fulfillment of the individuals’ Primary Fantasy is determined by their personalities. Of special relevance are the eight levels of consciousness (from archaic to transpersonal), the feminine/masculine polarities, the five state-stages of spiritual, sexual,*4 and anima/animus complex development, as well as the various personality types, all of which we covered in Part
I of the manual. To better grasp how these multiple dimensions interconnect and affect the quality and sustainability of a partnership beyond the love-struck phase, we will weave them together in a Personality Matrix311. We’ll place the eight stages of consciousness development on a vertical axis. Next to it are two vertical lines, showing the most common tendencies of the feminine and masculine polarities for men and women as they grow in consciousness. Then we’ll map the spiritual, sexual,†5 and anima/animus complex lines onto a horizontal axis, since these aspects can develop independently from each other at each level of consciousness. This gives you 1,000 different correlates (8 x 5 x 5 x 5) for the fluid feminine/masculine polarities and personality types of every person (deep breath now). Using this matrix allows you to identify compatibilities and differences between you and your partner, and provides you with directions towards future growth potentials. You may, for example, be a pluralistic (green), feminine, kinesthetic, Enneagram type seven man at stage three of your spiritual, stage two of your sexual, and stage four of your anima complex development, who is in a partnership with a rational (orange), masculine, visual, Enneagram type three woman at stage four of her sexual, stage one of her spiritual, and stage five of her animus complex development. In the future, you may both remain at your vertical level of consciousness or grow further, become more masculine or feminine, or evolve along some or all of the three horizontal lines (or not).
Figure 20: The Personality Matrix—allowing you to map your and her development Couples with similar lifestyle choices, interests, intelligences, and passions, who are at the same level of their consciousness, spiritual, sexual, and anima/animus complex development, with opposite feminine/masculine polarities and complementary personality types experience the most fulfilling long-term partnerships. These compatibilities allow them to enjoy their sexual attraction and synergy, and to resolve conflicts by the same means (see Chapter 12 under Conflict Resolution and Forgiveness) until they grow apart in their developmental lines or lose their opposite sexual polarities. Partners with minor differences in their horizontal stage development may be able to get along and support each other in their growth, while couples with larger discrepancies will experience conflicts that are irresolvable312 once the initial hormonal rush that impaired their rational perception and made them look at each other through rose-colored glasses wears off, and the day-to-day reality of life sinks in.
THE POLARITIES (FEMININE/MASCULINE DYNAMIC) ALONG THE WAY As males and females grow in consciousness, their feminine/masculine polarity attributes tend to shift.313 The two curved lines in the Personality Matrix that are next to the eight vertical stages of consciousness development show this dynamic. Both males and females start out relatively undifferentiated in their polarity in the two earliest stages of development. In the egocentric red and conformist amber stages, males display predominantly masculine, and females predominantly feminine qualities, hence the origin of the terms. The opposite polarities are neutralized in the rational orange stage when females swing towards the masculine side and become androgynous314—often being communal and ascending, or agentic and descending—while most males further strengthen their masculine capacities. As a result, the energetic flow that created sexual attraction and synergy between males and females in earlier stages vanishes 315 and many relationships start to struggle and fall apart in the orange stage where the clearly divided gender roles that are found in red and amber get blurred and females become economically (through their own career and/or “divorcing well” from a financially successful husband) and emotionally (through personal growth work, therapy, a spiritual practice, or a shift in their hormonal balance) independent from men.316 In the green pluralistic stage, males and females start to connect more deeply with the interior qualities that they had denied in themselves in earlier stages of development. For males this often means fully embracing their anima—with a swing over to their feminine side—while females tend to transcend their animus complex and fully embrace their masculinity. 317 Green men are perceived to be in their midlife crisis or Sensitive New Age Guys (SNAGs) when they get in touch with their feelings, pursue a spiritual or altruistic path, 318 and lose their drive to be aggressive
providers and protectors (often accompanied or caused by lowered levels of testosterone).319 At the same time, financially and emotionally independent green women strengthen their masculine qualities and embrace radical (or eco-) feminist ideals,320 which claim female superiority over men, and blame hierarchical patriarchal structures for all the problems in the world, such as wars, pollution, poverty, oppression of minorities, abuse of women and children, etc. Other women in this stage muse how they can establish an authentic female spirituality and shape a better future for humanity and the world by asserting their feminine power (a contradiction in terms if seen from an Integral perspective) independent of men.321 This forces many abandoned and confused green males to lick their wounds in men’s groups of the male liberation movement or in New Age and Eastern-oriented spiritual communities. This role reversal is very confusing and makes healthy and nurturing love relationships between the sexes in green almost impossible as the socially accepted gender roles are reversed, while the underlying biological makeup and Primary Fantasy that create the sexual polarity/attraction remain intact. Green men are still sexually attracted to healthy feminine women, while green women can’t help but be drawn to successful males with a strong masculine streak (which often leads both of them back to “bad boy/girl” red partners ... see Chapter 4 under pre/post fallacy). In the second-tier Integral teal stage, both sexes become aware of the benefits that healthy ascending, descending, agency, and communion play in their lives and balance and harmonize them along the first-tier stages that they have transcended. They can now consciously embody their feminine or masculine polarities as the life-situations at hand require, and are able to co-create synergy with an equal and opposite partner. The transpersonal turquoise stage heralds the return to the authentic embodiment of one’s sexual essence, but this time with a conscious recognition, honoring, valuing, appreciation, and enjoyment of opposite polarities in other human beings. At last, men and women can comfortably relax into and embrace all the healthy facets of their authentic masculine and feminine expression from moment to moment. This allows them to effortlessly engage with each other without elevating their own way of being over that of their mate, forcing their way onto the other, or being offended by their differences.
INTEGRATING THE SPIRITUAL, SEXUAL, AND ANIMA/ANIMUS COMPLEX Located to the right of the two vertical lines of the feminine and masculine polarities on the Personality Matrix are three rows with the five stages of spiritual, sexual, and anima/animus complex development that we explored in Part I of the manual. They are arranged separately on a horizontal axis for each of the vertical stages for three reasons: (1) they can develop independently at each level of consciousness and are then interpreted from that altitude,322 (2) they can be experienced as temporary states that may or may not be developed into a state-stage, and (3) their development can be interrelated.323 This indicates that (1) every human being has the potential to reach higher levels of their spiritual, sexual, or anima/animus complex development at every vertical stage of consciousness, (2) the experiences at each level can be a temporary state or— through tantra, meditation, and/or psychotherapy—be transformed into permanently accessible state-stages, and (3) the three lines are interrelated, since a peak experience or stage development in any one of them can positively affect the others.324 For example: A modern magenta male shaman may be fully present in his body (spiritual stage 1), while being in sexual tantric union with a woman (sexual state-stage 5), and fully accept her as an equal and opposite human being (anima complex stage 5). He may then interpret his experience as a magical spirit flowing through him to the woman and being reflected back from her. An amber male priest who conforms to the mythic laws of the Bible may have had a mystical experience (spiritual state-stage 4) of Christ consciousness, see women as sex objects (anima stage 2), and, while on a vacation in Thailand, fuck several prostitutes (sexual state-stage 2). He may see his spiritual experience as grace from God, treat women as inferior to men whom they should obey, and curse his sexual addiction, which he can’t control, as a Satanic affliction. An orange female biology teacher who has never had any spiritual experiences (spiritual stage 0) may enjoy various “boy-toys” as sex partners (sexual state-stage 3), and see men as being as equally independent as she is (anima complex stage 4). She may reject any spiritual notion as irrational, enjoy sex as a pleasurable and healthy physical activity, and value men as competent colleagues but not as romantic life partners.
INTEGRATING STATES AND TYPES The final two elements of the Integral Relationship Model, temporary states such as falling in love, and the consistent personality types, are located at the very right side of the Personality Matrix. States represent the fleeting experiences that are observed by the subject and interpreted from his or her level of consciousness. In the context of this manual we focused especially on the states of falling in and out of love, while other common examples include the waking, dreaming, and dreamless states, drug-induced euphoria, meditative states, and peak experiences. Personality types such as the Five Love Languages and Enneagram remain consistent throughout stage development and vary only in the way they are expressed and how an individual identifies with them.
IN SUMMARY In this chapter we established that increasing levels of social status for men provide them access to sexier (younger/healthier) women (and vice versa), and that most women (especially in first-tier consciousness) want to marry up. The quality of a partnership between two individuals who fulfill each other’s Primary Fantasy and fall in love is determined by their individual stage of vertical consciousness, and the five levels of their horizontal spiritual, sexual, and anima/animus complex development. By integrating these elements (8 x 5 x 5 x 5) we arrived at a Personality Matrix with 1000 possible combinations for the feminine and masculine polarities, and the various states and types for each partner.
CHAPTER 8 Our Drive to Connect A hundred times every day I remind myself that my inner and outer life are based on the labors of other men, living and dead. ~ Albert Einstein ~ At one point or another, lovers may ask themselves how they can be simultaneously part of a partnership and maintain individual wholeness. Lovers may also wonder how they can balance and harmonize physical and emotional/spiritual attraction to a partner in a healthy way. The answer can be found in the concept of holons and the four quadrants that are part of Ken Wilber’s original AQAL model.325
HOLONS, ALWAYS PARTIAL, ALREADY WHOLE In Ken Wilber’s Integral Model, a holon326 is a whole that is simultaneously a part of a larger whole, while being made up of parts that are whole in themselves. An example is right in front of you: take a closer look; whole words that contain whole l e t t e r s make up whole sentences, which are parts of whole paragraphs, etc. Or whole atoms are parts of whole molecules, which are parts of whole cells, which are parts of whole organs, which are parts of whole humans, which are parts of whole couples, which are parts of whole families, communities, societies, nations. Letters > words > sentences > paragraphs >; ... atoms > molecules > cells > organs > humans > couples > families > communities ... all are holons. These groups of related holons, or holonic structures, lead to natural growth hierarchies327 (often called holarchies) in which the higher levels are always more inclusive and therefore have more depth. At the same time, the higher level requires the presence of the lower; otherwise it will cease to exist. Therefore, the lower level is always larger in numbers and has “more span.” For example, there are more letters than words in this manual, and more individual humans than couples in the world. The higher level depends on two factors for its existence: to maintain its wholeness (such as a marriage) AND the presence of the lower (such as the individual spouses). Otherwise it will eventually disintegrate into its parts and disappear. A cell can exist without organisms, but not without molecules; sentences can exist without a paragraph but not without words; partnerships can exist without communities but not without individuals.
Each circle represents a holon Figure 21: Example showing nested holons By definition, holons always have their unique characteristics and can’t be reduced to the sum of their parts.328 For example, an organism is more than just the sum of its cells, it has its own unique structure and function; a word is more than the sum of its letters, it has its own meaning; a partnership is more than the sum of two individuals, it creates its own dynamics, values, and experiences (think of your two hands working together, or two people having sex.) Ken Wilber’s Integral Model specifies four different types of holons: (1) Individual holons (everything that is conscious and has its own volition (choice/will) or experience, such as cells, dogs, or humans). (2) Social holons (groups of individual holons, such as flocks of geese, male-female partnerships, families, or communities). (3) Artifacts (objects created by individual holons, such as paintings, books, cars, or houses). (4) Heaps (structures created by nature, such as sand dunes or a pile of leaves).329 For our Integral Relationship Model we will now focus on individual and social holons.
CHARACTERISTICS OF INDIVIDUAL HOLONS In the following paragraphs we will discuss three unique characteristics that are exclusive to individual holons and of relevance for the formation of social holons as love relationships: 1. Individual holons have a single governing force (dominant monad).
2. Individual holons have an interior/exterior and individual/collective dimension (which we will diagram as four quadrants). 3. Individual holons have four drives (related to the masculine/feminine polarities that we discussed in Chapter 2).
WHO’S IN CHARGE? The first unique quality of individual holons is their independent will or consciousness that acts as a single governing force which all its constituent parts (holons) have to follow. In Wilber’s language, this single governing force is called a dominant monad. If you, as the dominant monad of an individual holon that is a single organism, decide to walk across the room to talk to a woman, all of your constituent parts, such as organs, tissues, cells, molecules, and atoms, have to follow—no exceptions. The three other forms of holons (social, artifacts, and heaps) do not have a dominant monad (see below under “social holon”).
THE FOUR QUADRANTS Individual holons have four distinct dimensions that are intrinsic to the holon’s existence:330 (1) An individual interior subjective/experiential “I” or mind. (2) An individual exterior objective/material “it” or form/body. (3) A collective interior intersubjective “we” or shared values/culture. (4) A collective exterior inter-objective “its” social environment.331 For easy reference, the AQAL model diagrams these four dimensions as four quadrants that are labeled: (1) Upper Left (UL) “I” (2) Upper Right (UR) “It” (3) Lower Left (LL) “We” (4) Lower Right (LR) “Its”
Figure 22: The four quadrants of individual holons In other words, the four quadrants represent your individual consciousness in the upper left, and physical body in the upper right-hand quadrant, and how these two dimensions are extended and connected to the world around you in the lower quadrants. You—being an individual holon—can experience these four dimensions right now:332 (1) The Upper Left (UL) quadrant represents your subjective individual interior “I” dimension. You experience this dimension when you focus your attention inward and ask yourself, “what is alive in me right now?” It includes the full spectrum of your awareness, from sensations, to feelings, thoughts, dreams, intentions, intuitions, perceptions, and sense of beauty. The levels of consciousness development, spiritual state-stages, and personality types that we explored in Part I are located in this quadrant. Introspection, psychotherapy, cognitive development, and meditation are UL practices. (2) The Upper Right (UR) quadrant represents your objective individual exterior, physical “it” dimension that can be observed by you or anyone else. It includes your sex, skin, muscles, cells, hormones, enzymes, brain structures, smell, voice, height, size, etc. Differences in male and female bodies, such as their gender characteristics (breasts, penis, vagina, body hair, etc.), hormonal levels (testosterone, estrogen, etc.), and genetic makeup (X and Y chromosomes, etc.), are located in the Upper Right. Behaviors such as physical exercise, body language, and emotional outbursts fall into the UR quadrant. (3) The Lower Left (LL) quadrant represents your collective interior (cultural) “we“ dimension. You experience this dimension when you focus your attention outward and ask yourself, “how do I relate to others and how do they affect my awareness?” This includes everything that you have learned through your culture, such as language, religious beliefs, worldviews, moral values, commitments, humility, empathy, compassion, devotion, and faith. Your way of creating mutual understanding with others, intimacy (which we can rewrite as “into-me-you-see,” emphasizing the interpersonal nature of intimacy),333 and vulnerability, as well as the lines of moral, communicative, worldview, value, and anima/animus complex development, are located in this quadrant. Communication and management training, couples therapy, conflict resolution, mediation, petitionary prayer, and religious beliefs fall into the LL quadrant.334 (4) The Lower Right (LR) quadrant represents your collective exterior (social) “its“ dimension. You experience this dimension when you focus your attention on the physical world around you and ask yourself, “what is the social, economic, and ecological environment that sustains my body?” This includes the air that you breathe, the food that you eat, shelter, possessions, occupation, financial assets/liabilities, social status, physical relationships, family, friends, and community. How a woman evaluates you as a protector/provider, and how you are seen by others with her on your arm are located in this quadrant. Family relations, social activities, educational systems, community building, team sports, money management, relationship laws (such as legal marriage and divorce), and acceptable conduct between men and women (such as sexual harassment, who buys the diamond ring, who pursues and takes the risk of rejection, etc.) fall into the LR.
Figure 23: Characteristics of each quadrant You may already see how these four dimensions are essential for partnerships in which two individual (UL) “I’s,” with two (UR) “it” bodies, experience a (LL) “we” mutual understanding/resonance (or misunderstanding/dissonance), that is embedded in their (LR) “its” social structure.
Figure 24: The four quadrants applied to individual holons If you ignore or marginalize any of these four dimensions, you get a distorted perspective of your inner and outer world, your relationships, and your social environment.
Development Inside the Quadrants Each of the developmental lines that we outlined in Chapter 3 can be placed into one of the four quadrants—for humans, the stages of consciousness development in the UL, increasing complexity of their physical body and brain in the UR, emergence of cultures and worldviews in the LL, and advancements of social structures in the LR. These lines co-emerge (which Wilber calls tetra arise) in all four quadrants simultaneously. For example, consciousness at the rational level (UL) requires a neocortex (UR) to produce a scientific worldview (LL), which leads to an industrial society (LR).335
Figure 25: Every human possess four quadrants
THE FOUR DRIVES OF INDIVIDUAL HOLONS The third unique characteristic of an individual holon that is paramount for partnerships is the four drives that moderate its ability to be simultaneously a whole and a part.336 In humans, these four drives are closely related to the feminine and masculine polarities that we outlined in Part I, Chapter 2. We named them ascending and descending (displayed on a vertical axis), and agency and communion (displayed on a horizontal axis). We will simply stick with this terminology. Again, you as an individual holon can feel these four drives right now. Ascending (self-transcendence) is your drive towards the higher, the creation of larger holons, bigger and more complex ideas/concepts, the greater good, and to reach beyond the limited self.337 This drive is the creative love that reaches up (Eros). Examples include the forming of a partnership/marriage, creation of a family, and founding of organizations, teams, groups, businesses, communities, nations, etc. This drive represents the capacity for creativity, integration, presence, vision, and to see the larger picture. If you resist this drive, your life will be without purpose. In its unhealthy form, the ascending drive will neglect the needs of the individual holons that make up the larger whole. Descending (self-immanence) is your drive towards the lower, to embrace and to care for the parts/members that make up the larger whole. This drive is the selfless, altruistic, and caring love that reaches down (Agape). Examples include concerns for the health and well-being of your body, spouse, and individual members of your family, team, group, or community. This drive represents the capacity to show compassion, to feel, accept, allow, and to surrender. Resisting this drive will lead to burnout, illness, depletion, emptiness, and loss of support from the base. In its unhealthy form, the descending drive will lead to the dissolution, decomposition, or deconstruction of the larger whole by losing sight of the greater good. Agency (self-preservation) is your drive to stay whole, complete, independent, and separate—the autonomous functioning of the holon. Examples are maintaining and protecting the integrity and functionality of yourself and your family, group, team, or organization. This drive represents the capacity for autonomy, self-reliance, and free will, and to act and exert power. If you resist this drive, you will become invaded, taken over, fused, attached, or dependent. In its unhealthy form, agency leads to conflict, isolation, alienation, and loneliness. Communion (self-adaptation) is your drive to act in partnership with others—to connect, join, communicate, participate, fit in, consider, take responsibility, compromise, and cooperate. This drive represents the capacity for understanding, empathy, linking, and openness. If you resist this drive, you will become alienated, isolated, and cut off from others. In its unhealthy form, communion will lead to dependence, fusion, and loss of independent functioning, and free will.
Differentiating the Four Drives It can be challenging to clearly differentiate ascending/agency and descending/communion, as they may sound and feel similar. One way to do so is to realize that every individual or social holon, once created through ascending, needs to balance healthy agency and communion, and embrace its members through descending in order to exist and survive over time. We need to take care of our cells and organs to maintain our body (descending), otherwise we will get ill and may even die/decompose into molecules, atoms, quarks, strings...all the way down. We also need the emotional and material support of others (communion) to survive, while maintaining our autonomy as individual beings (agency), and creating partnerships and communities (ascending) to sustain the human race. An extreme example of unhealthy development of the four drives is Hitler’s Nazi Germany which initially succeeded at ascending (creating a large, unified “us”) and agency (isolating itself and fighting the rest of the world), but failed miserably at descending (caring for its individual members – including six million German Jews and other fringe groups who were brutally murdered in concentration camps), and communion (cooperating with its neighbors). This endeavor, as history has shown, not only caused unimaginable harm to millions, but collapsed as a whole within a short period of time.338 But we don’t need to go back that far to see dysfunction in social holons. A look at most relationships, the high divorce rates, the increasing number of singles who are unable to form healthy partnerships and families, the pollution of our environment, and many other social, economic, ecological, and humanitarian problems that our species is facing, provides enough evidence for the imbalance of the four drives. Clearly, we need to learn to balance and harmonize all four capacities in their healthy expression from the lowest (our bodies and ecosystem), to the highest (the whole of humanity and all creation)—and everything in between (our partnerships, families, communities, nations, etc.)—to lead our planet and all its inhabitants into a better future.
Interior/Exterior Conflicts Sometimes, conflicts between the four drives in our interior and exterior world arise. For example, you may be physically attracted to a woman and would like to have sex with her (exterior communion), but you sense an inner fear of rejection or are afraid to lose your autonomy and instead withdraw into your shell and meditate (interior agency). Integrity is when you align your intentions (values/beliefs) with your behavior in the face of opposition. To address potential conflicts between your interior and exterior, and to make sense of love relationships, we will consider the four drives separately in the left-hand “I/we” and right-hand “it/its” quadrants.*6 This gives us eight combinations that you can experience right now:
Interior Your interior is ascending if it is directed towards creative thinking/mindfulness, seeing the bigger picture, experiencing God above, stillness, emptiness, and presence. Your interior is descending if it is directed towards feelings, wandering thoughts, sensing, self-love, embracing the lower, compassion, fullness, and surrender. Your interior is agentic if it is directed towards keeping your thoughts and feelings to yourself, and to deal with problems alone (introverted). As many relationship books indicate, most men prefer to go into their cave when they experience stress (watching TV, working alone on a project, meditating, going on a solo hike, etc.).
Your interior is communal if it is directed towards sharing your thoughts and feelings with others (extroverted) and showing empathy. As we know from experience, most women prefer to deal with their problems by sharing them with others, without expecting any constructive feedback or needing to be fixed.
Exterior Your exterior is ascending when it is directed away from the body with its lower impulses, fears, needs, and desires through repression/dissociation or self-discipline and control. Your exterior is descending if it is directed towards embracing your body, to surrender to its impulses (indulge/allow), to have compassion (suffer with), to be passive and to adapt. Your exterior is agentic if it is directed towards being alone, physically distancing yourself from others, not touching or wanting to be touched. Your exterior is communal if it is directed towards being in the company of others, physical closeness, touching others, and being touched.339
Examples You may, for example, want to have sex with your partner (exterior-communion), do her (exterior-ascending), or be done by her (exteriordescending), feel an inner space and emptiness (interior-ascending), or emotional charge (interior-descending), and want to be silent/have no eye contact (interior-agency) while fucking her from behind (exterior-agency), or want to talk/make eye contact while facing her during your lovemaking (interior-communion). Alternatively, you may want to be alone (exterior-agency), fast (exterior-ascending), or eat a delicious five-course meal (exterior-descending), daydream about a lost love (interior-descending), or think about a creative dating profile (interior-ascending), write your thoughts into a personal journal (interior-agency), or post them on a public Internet blog (interior-communion).
SOCIAL HOLONS Individual holons (such as humans) that group together are called social holons. Typical examples include couples, families, communities, groups, work-teams, organizations, and nations.340 Unlike the constituent parts of individual holons that are governed by a single
dominant monad, social holons have members who share a mutual resonance at the level of their body, mind, heart, and soul, on a conscious and unconscious level. They are usually free to join or leave the group at will, getting married or divorced, taking a job or quitting, becoming a member of or resigning from a team or association, or moving from one community/country to another. 341 Since social holons have no singular mind/consciousness or physical body, they also–by definition–don’t have four quadrants.342 However, most social holons have hierarchies with a dominant power structure (or “pecking order”) that direct and hold them together. We find these structures in corporations, politics, military, sports, churches, families, and partnerships. They are formed through a dominant mode of resonance (versus a dominant monad) and shared mode of discourse that is usually necessary and beneficial to create a functional unit, such as a partnership, family, group, business, organization, or society. These hierarchies serve very real needs for expedience/effectiveness/efficiency (corporate world), survival/protection (military), awakening/realization (religious/spiritual community), learning/maturing (school/family), maintenance of social order/justice (politics/law enforcement), or recreational/fitness activities (groups/games/sports). Individuals who are not willing or able to fit into such hierarchical group structures may be marginalized, denied access, or be asked to leave. Hierarchical structures become problematic if individuals at higher or more powerful levels wield unjustified control over people at the lower levels, instead of caring for them. Unfortunately we see this all around us, including in love relationships. An integrally informed man is aware of the difference between abusive dominator and natural growth hierarchies, and sensitive to where his (or her, for that matter) vision, direction, leadership, and power are desired and necessary to maintain the wholeness of a social holon (partnership, organization, nation, etc.), and when his or her actions start to oppress, manipulate, coerce, dominate, or take unjustified advantage of others. Simply put, we need to make our relationships the highest priority in order to maintain their wholeness while caring for and maintaining the health of the individuals (parts) that comprise them–and this is best practiced in an intimate committed love relationship with a woman.343
BALANCE AND HARMONIZE To maintain their individual wholeness and partialness in a co-created healthy love relationship, both partners need to balance and harmonize the healthy forms of the four drives in their interior and exterior quadrants in an opposite and equal fashion. This creates attraction and synergy through an energy flow (think of a magnet, battery, or sex), and harmonizes the couple’s giving and receiving through a shared resonance and mode of discourse between them. Otherwise the couple will experience an inner and outer stagnation or conflict. Partner dancing with a leader (ascending) and follower (descending) that allows a couple to move in (communion) and out (agency) of embrace in a fluid way may serve as a simple example for the dynamic in the exterior.
Figure 26: Example of dancing couple and the four polarities Dance partners may share (interior) thoughts and feelings in a conversation (communion) with one of them speaking (ascending) and the other listening (descending), or remain both silent (agency). If neither partner leads nor follows, they will be static or stumble over each other. If they don’t flow in and out of embrace, they will either suffocate each other or drift apart. If neither of them talks, they might as well be mechanical puppets or zombies. If they both incessantly talk all the time with no one listening, they are like two radios playing without a listener or an Off button. An integrally informed man will work towards harmonizing his interior and exterior vision (ascending) for his partnership/marriage by considering his own needs and the needs of his spouse (descending).344 He will also balance his interior and exterior needs for autonomy (agency) with his and her desire for deep harmonious intimacy, closeness, and connection (communion). Without this balance, two extremely agentic people will have a hard time coming together; extremely communal partners will become fused and codependent; two ascenders will rarely connect on a deeper emotional/sexual level and their separate visions may constantly collide (unless they have a shared vision, which is desirable); and two descenders may get lost in the morass of their emotions and details of their life.
OPPOSITES VERSUS EQUALS In pre-conventional magenta or red, and conventional amber relationships, we often see couples that are opposites but not equals.345 They share opposite polarities/drives which attract and make them compatible, but are not equals, as the ascending/agentic partner (often, but not always the male) holds the economic, physical, intellectual, and emotional power (often through anger or repression of feelings), while the descending/communal partner tends to be financially and emotionally dependent and cares for the members of the family (partner/children/aging parents). These relationships begin to fall apart in the modern orange stage of development when women start to gravitate towards the masculine polarities (ascending/agency), claim their authority, and pursue their financial and emotional independence from men. Since men retain their masculinity in orange, the sexes become equals but are no longer opposites that synergize and attract.346 Things get even more confusing in the postmodern green stage of development, when men embark on an inner journey of self-discovery and get in touch with their feminine side (anima), while women fully embrace their masculinity (animus). The sexes are then equals and opposites but with a complete role reversal in which emancipated women neither want to care emotionally or financially for “sensitive New Age loser men,” nor engage with insensitive orange workaholics, or conservative amber patriarchs, while green men find women at this level to be insensitive to their needs (neediness) and emasculating. In post-postmodern integrally informed relationships, both partners become fully aware of, and integrate the feminine-masculine dynamic. They become opposites AND equals by relaxing into their sexual essence while embracing the opposite feminine and masculine polarities in a conscious, balanced, and harmonized way, as the situation or mood warrants. This way, they co-create synergy between them, keep their sexual passion/attraction alive, and allow each other to express their male or femaleness in a natural and healthy way, without feeling limited, manipulated, oppressed, victimized, or used by the opposite sex.
READY OR NOT? You may find some deeper answers about your ability to balance and harmonize the four quadrants and drives in a healthy partnership by answering the four questions below:347
Table 6: Fear and desire to be in partnership or alone If little or no specific needs and fears come up for you in any of these four areas, and if your answers seem to express reasonable concerns and healthy desires, then you possess the best prerequisites to co-create a healthy partnership. If your answers indicate imbalances, neediness, or fears, then you may want to address those issues first before seeking and engaging with a partner.348
IN SUMMARY Congratulations! You made it through the most abstract and technical (but hopefully not boring!) chapter of the manual in which we established that humans are individual holons who are simultaneously whole and partial in their relationships. They possess individual and collective interior and exterior dimensions which we placed into four quadrants for ease of reference. We looked at the four drives that mediate the individual holon’s capacity to be whole in itself and part of a social holon, and explored opposite versus equal relationship dynamics in pre-conventional, conventional, post-conventional, and integrally informed partnerships.
CHAPTER 9 Passion/Intimacy/Dependence In the arithmetic of love, one plus one equals everything, and two minus one equals nothing. ~ Mignon McLaughlin ~ Even though love is experienced by the individual in the upper left “I” and upper right “it” quadrants, the actual love relationship is created through the lower “we” and “its” quadrants, plus an unconscious dimension.
In this chapter, we will look at the resulting three core elements of love relationships: LL intimacy, LR passion and unconscious dependence. By drawing the levels for each of these core elements as lines, we can combine them into differently shaped metaphorical triangles. These triangles are indicative of eight forms of love that we will discuss in detail below. Understanding the shape and congruency of the triangles will allow you to understand the type and quality of love that you and your partner experience.
THE THREE SIDES OF THE TRIANGLE The length of the triangle’s left side represents the level of intimacy that individuals experience with another person through their lower left-hand
“we” quadrant (language, values, worldviews, interests, etc.). They may say “we understand each other,” “we click,” “we resonate with each other,” “we share the same values,” “we see the world in the same way,” or “we are best friends.” The length of the triangle’s right side represents the level of passion that individuals experience through their lower right-hand “its” quadrant towards members of the opposite sex who meet their primary sexual fantasy (looks, status, etc.). If the attraction is mutual between two lovers, they may say “we have a lot of chemistry,” “we are physically attracted to each other,” “we can’t keep our hands off each other,” “we have great sex,” “we have fun together,” “we like to do things together,” or “we are a great team.”
Figure 27: The passion/intimacy/dependence Triangle The length of the triangle’s bottom represents the various levels of dependence that individuals may experience in a partnership through their unconscious (in second-tier couples, which are extremely rare, dependence increasingly becomes an act of choice and will, instead of an unconscious attachment). They may say “we complete/complement each other,” “we can’t live without each other,” “we push each other’s buttons,” “we fight a lot,” or “we are soul mates/twin flames/worthy opponents.” The unconscious dimension of love relationships is always experienced as mysterious, miraculous, or magical, as the “love-struck” couple has no rational explanation for their magnetic push/pull.
Figure 28: Examples of differently shaped triangles of love To better understand the mysterious dimensions of love that affect all three sides of the triangle, and especially the lower part of dependence, we will first take a look at the unconscious and the role that it plays in our attraction to certain members of the opposite sex. After this journey into the underworld of our psyche, we will combine the three core elements of love into eight forms of love.
THE UNCONSCIOUS We all carry a psychological blueprint that holds the details and lingering imprints of our heritage and life experiences. The unacknowledged/unconscious parts of that blueprint contain the information that drives our irrational fears, anxieties, coping mechanisms, and defenses, as well as our creativity, dreams, and passions. And just as the conscious aspects of our interior and exterior dimensions have opposing feminine and masculine polarities that complement and attract each other, so do the unconscious parts. There are five major components of the unconscious349 that are of relevance for the mysterious magnetism or aversion that lovers experience on the level of their bodies, minds, and hearts: (1) The ground unconscious represents our unrealized embedded potentials. All humans carry the potential to grow in awareness (from body to mind, soul, and spirit) after birth. The unrealized stages of these future growth potentials are not actively suppressed or involuntarily repressed; they just have not entered into conscious awareness yet. Examples are certain aspects of a child’s sexual impulses and preferences that have not emerged due to their young age, or an acorn that will grow into an oak tree, and not into a tomato plant. The child or the acorn is not suppress