The New Americans Recent Immigration and American Society
Edited by Steven J. Gold and Rubén G. Rumbaut
A Series from...
36 downloads
1132 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The New Americans Recent Immigration and American Society
Edited by Steven J. Gold and Rubén G. Rumbaut
A Series from LFB Scholarly
This page intentionally left blank
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth in an American High School
Craig Centrie Preface by Maxine Seller
LFB Scholarly Publishing LLC New York 2004
Copyright © 2004 by LFB Scholarly Publishing LLC All rights reserved. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Centrie, Craig, 1953Identity formation of Vietnamese immigrant youth in an American high school / Craig Centrie. p. cm. -- (The New Americans) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1-931202-67-2 (alk. paper) 1. Vietnamese American youth--Education (Secondary)--Social aspects--New York (State)--New York--Case studies. 2. Children of immigrants--Education (Secondary)--Social aspects--New York (State)—New York--Case studies. 3. Group identity--New York (State)--New York—Case studies. 4. West Side High School (New York, N.Y.)--Students—Social conditions--Case studies. I. Title. II. Series: New Americans (LFB Scholarly Publishing LLC) LC3501.V53C45 2003 373.18295'92073--dc22 2003023711
ISBN 1-931202-67-2 Printed on acid-free 250-year-life paper. Manufactured in the United States of America.
This work is dedicated to my entire extended family.
This page intentionally left blank
Table of Contents
1
Chapter 1:
Introduction
Chapter 2:
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
27
Chapter 3:
Vietnamese in Perspective
47
Chapter 4:
Inside West Side High School
69
Chapter 5:
West Side High Vietnamese Males
121
Chapter 6:
West Side High Vietnamese Females
159
Chapter 7:
Family Matters: The Contribution of Parents, Friends and Community
193
Chapter 8:
Conclusions
233 253 257 269
Notes References Index
vii
This page intentionally left blank
Acknowledgments
I would especially like to thank the Spencer and Carnegie Foundations for their generous support through most of the data collection and all of the analysis and writing of this work. These funds were granted to Lois Weis and Michelle Fine for The Unknown City. Without this assistance, this research would have been a much more difficult task. There are also many other individuals who guided me throughout this work. I would first like to thank Lois Weis whose guidance was present throughout every phase of this work and whose consistent encouragement and praise pushed me to finish. I would also like to thank Lois for inviting me to work with her on so many of her research projects, providing me with a very thorough knowledge and understanding of qualitative research. I would also like to thank many others, particularly Maxine Seller, who has graciously offered to write a preface to this work and whose life work on immigration has been of unparalleled inspiration. Maxine asked all the right questions at just the right time. I would also like to thank Ruth Meyerowitz, who sat me down for the last chapter and teased out the final details after I explained that I was brain dead, and John Stalely, whose assistance in the final phase of this work was invaluable and raised the level of scholarship. Without John, this work would have been much more difficult to read. Thank you for going through every page, checking for language errors and simplifying the prose. A special thanks to Julia Hall for much encouragement and many suggestions. I would like to thank my dear friend Harold McNeal who also pushed and encouraged me to get this work done. I would especially like to thank him for the critical work he did in re-typing and editing of the manuscript after several of my disks went corrupt. There are also endless lists of friends who encouraged me through their genuine interest in this work, for their patience, listening to my frustrations, and asking “Is it done yet?” I would like to thank the late Gail Kelly, who encouraged me to work with the Vietnamese, and who generously gave me her personal collection of Vietnamese papers and scholarship. ix
x
Acknowlegments
Thank you Amy Ferry for accepting the difficult task of correcting this manuscript after many problems arose in the final draft. Finally, I would like to thank Leo Balk, the publisher of Scholarly Press, who has been very patient and saw some value when I myself was not sure.
Preface by Maxine Seller
From its beginnings, the United States has been a favored destination for immigrants and refugees from all over the world, and, in early years of the twenty-first century it continues to be so. As wave after wave of newcomers have entered the country, Americans have argued about whether they should be welcomed as economic and cultural assets or feared as aliens diluting the national culture. Whatever their perspective on immigration, Americans have agreed on the importance of the public school as the central institution in the education and acculturation of “foreign” populations. While some immigrants have established their own schools in the hope of preserving native languages, religions, and cultures, most have entrusted their children to the quintessential American institution, the American public school. Craig Centrie’s study Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth examines the experience of one recently arrived community that has done so, the Vietnamese of “Nickel City,” a mid-sized industrial city in the Northeast. In the nineteenth century, the creators of American public schools envisioned the institution not only as both a builder of a national culture, but also as an agent of equality. Public schools, they believed, would prevent poverty by extending the benefits of education equally to all and would provide diligent students from humble backgrounds Ptake them. In the early twentieth century, the public schools were expanded and compulsory attendance extended largely as a response to the arrival of unprecedented numbers of immigrants, mostly from Southern and Eastern Europe. As the second and third generations made their way into American society, educators and the general public praised the public school as the “portal to America,” the open door through which not only immigrants but also the native born “minority populations could pass from poverty into the middle class. If some immigrant groups and other racial and ethnic communities didn’t “make it” in America, it was because they didn’t try or, more sympathetically, because they came from culturally and economically deprived homes. xi
xii
Preface
In the 1960s and 1970s, scholars responding to the Civil Rights Movement with new scholarship on the history of education pointed out that the public schools had failed to provide social mobility to African Americans and other native-born minorities and, indeed, had helped maintain and reproduce social inequalities. As the education, or miseducation, of native-born minority children was being reexamined, a new generation of educational scholars—historians, sociologists, philosophers, and others—also reexamined the education of immigrants. The new scholars, known as the “revisionists,” argued that the traditional view of immigrant education, “the great school legend” as historian Colin Greer called it in a book of the same name, was simply not true. Immigrants from impoverished backgrounds who succeeded in moving into the middle class were likely to have done so in spite of the schools rather than because of them. Revisionist scholars pointed out that schools did Americanize immigrant children, but at the cost of suppressing native languages and cultures. Instead of promoting social mobility, schools reproduced an oppressive hierarchical social order by tracking minority students into academically inferior vocational courses. In the closing decades of the twentieth century, a new generation of educational scholars—I will call them post-revisionists—moved beyond the now well-worn debate between traditionalist and revisionist interpretations of the education of immigrants. While taking on the critical perspective introduced by the revisionists, the new scholars did not accept the revisionist tendency to treat students (and their families and communities) as passive victims of an all-powerful educational system. They argued that even where the power of the parties involved in making educational decisions was not equal, there was room for negotiation. They stressed the importance of agency, the self initiated activity of immigrant students and their families in their own behalf, in the public schools, in ethnic and parochial schools, and in their own communities. They noted the great diversity not only among but also within immigrant communities, and investigated the impact of culture and gender as well as race and class on education and Americanization. They moved beyond theory to examine interactions within actual classrooms, homes, and communities. The result was a scholarship on the education of immigrants that was sophisticated and nuanced as well
Preface
xiii
as critical. Craig Centrie’s ethnographic study of Vietnamese high school students in “Nickel City” is part of this new scholarship. Centrie focuses on Vietnamese who, like some other Asian groups, have been relatively successful in American public schools. Despite lack of prior knowledge of English and in most cases, parents who could offer little in the way of academic help or economic resources, the young people Centrie studies (with some exceptions) make As and Bs, do their homework, and behave respectfully in the classroom. Centrie moves beyond the “model minority” stereotype, however, to explore these students’ difficulties, to document their educational strategies and to analyze the reasons for their successes. Building on the work of John Ogbu, Centrie notes that the Vietnamese behave like “voluntary “ immigrants. Unlike many born minority students, they are unburdened by the weight of past discrimination. Although their school in Nickel City is a troubled one, they compare their educational opportunities in the United States with the lack of opportunities in Vietnam, rather than with the superior opportunities available to the American middle class. Building on the work of scholars like Paul Willis and Lois Weis, Centrie investigates the student culture created by the Vietnamese students, in this case a culture that is favorable rather than “oppositional” to the requirements and goals of the school. He shows how this culture is supported by the availability of a “free space,” a homeroom where Vietnamese students feel safe and where a Vietnamese teacher with links to both the local community and the school administration provides counseling, academic help, books, and computers. While some scholars have noted that high achievement in some European and Latino communities separated the achiever from his friends and family, Centrie demonstrates that it is the underachieving Vietnamese student who will be in conflict with family and community. His findings highlight the role of family, siblings as well as parents, and community in reinforcing students’ positive attitude toward academic achievement. He notes, too, that Vietnamese expectations of what is, at best, a mediocre urban school are limited and realistic. The students do not expect academic excellence. They want the schools to introduce them to American life and teach them English so that they can go on to higher education, and they believe that, on the whole, the school does this.
xiv
Preface
Centrie is an informed and sensitive ethnographer. He brings the reader into the lives of Vietnamese students, documenting in their own words their ambitions, and their problems. He captures the dynamics of classroom, family, and community and analyzes the complex interaction among them. His work is grounded in history, both in the history of Vietnamese immigration to the United States and in the smaller story of the Vietnamese experience in “Nickel City.” His study places him in the center of the new scholarship on the education of immigrants in American schools.
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
“…(A)nd you know, when the North Vietnamese, the Viet Cong, were almost at our door steps, we did not believe it; we could not believe it. It was not until we saw the Americans panic and begin to leave that we begin to understand. It was, I think, the saddest day of my life.” Grandpa Tiu The fall of American occupied Saigon, South Vietnam to the Viet Cong in April 1975 initiated the departure of 130,000 shocked and confused Vietnamese to the United States. No one, particularly Saigoners, believed that their beloved country, protected and supported by the powerful United States, would succumb to the communist guerrillas from the North. Just days before Saigon was under siege, it was business as usual in the capital. The South Vietnamese believed that the Viet Cong of the North would be defeated. Few made preparations. Within hours of the attack on the capital, crowds of Vietnamese, mostly those with connections to the United States government, stormed the American embassy in Saigon, seeking asylum and evacuation from the besieged city. While hundreds left on helicopters and were taken to American tankers waiting in the South China sea, many more were left behind while the saddened and panicked American ambassador left on the last flight to safety. The hundreds of Vietnamese that evacuated in April 1975 began a journey that would be continued by more than one and a half million countrymen over the next quarter century. Shortly after Saigon fell, other Southeast Asian refugees, mostly from Laos and Cambodia, fled their homes to seek safety in the United States or Thailand as political instability in both countries increased. The massive departure of fleeing Southeast Asians to the United States occurred in three waves, the first immediately following the initial departure of refugees from Vietnam from 1975 until 1979, the second 1
2
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
from 1979 until 1983, and the third continuing until 1997, when the United States reestablished diplomatic relations with Vietnam, eliminating refugee status. By 1997, 70,000 Vietnamese refugees were being admitted into the United States annually. Since 1997, most Vietnamese have entered the United States on an individual basis. Historically, Southeast Asian immigration is identified by the class background of the refugees. The Vietnamese who departed in the early seventies are mostly highly educated and skilled individuals and their families have strong connections to the American administration in South Vietnam. The second wave consists predominantly of urban, middle class Vietnamese with strong business backgrounds who are financially independent. The third and final wave consists primarily of less educated and often rural Vietnamese and fishermen. Over the past 25 years, thousands of Vietnamese children have been educated in American schools. Most were new arrivals when they began their American educational odyssey. Although there are now many Vietnamese American children born in the United States (the children of the first arrivals), it is the new arrivals, those youth that have been in the United States five years or less, and their identity formation, that are the focus of this research. The Vietnamese, like all the immigrant groups before them, are becoming an integrated and dynamic part of the immense patchwork of cultures and traditions that compose American society. Like other immigrants, the Vietnamese are struggling to find their place. Nickel City, a rust belt urban environment with few economic opportunities, rarely saw its population grow from external migration. Over the last twenty years, this pattern is slowly changing, bringing new ethnic groups from Latin America, the Caribbean, Africa and Asia. Today, the Vietnamese are one of the most visible newcomers, establishing a presence and leaving their imprint on the urban “street scape.” Although the newest arrivals have a much easier time adjusting and establishing themselves than their predecessors, there are still many hurdles to overcome. This research has convinced me that it is the youth that negotiate the most difficult obstacles. Vietnamese refugees generally have a difficult time adapting and adjusting during the first two to three years after their arrival because of language and cultural difference, although this process has been greatly mediated since the establishment of communities. The first refugees,
Introduction
3
however, had an especially difficult time because they arrived during a period of deep economic recession, creating concerns among American citizens that Southeast Asians would take job opportunities, and reminding Americans of an immensely unpopular war. Adjustment was further complicated because many of the first arrivals did not understand that they would never return to Vietnam. They are in many ways the reluctant immigrant. They believed that they would be leaving or evacuating for only a temporary period and to would return to a stabilized political structure, perhaps a major victory. For several days after the end of the war, many Vietnamese did not realize that South Vietnam lost, and that the United States was pulling out permanently. As a result of this misunderstanding, many first arrivals were very reluctant to cut ties with their homeland (Kelly, 1977). Since the greater economic growth of the 1990s, Vietnamese communities have emerged in many cities across the nation, allowing for easier adjustment for those that followed. In 1999, the first Buddhist temple and community center of the region has opened on the East Side. Twenty-five Vietnamese families have recently purchased homes and are creating businesses within walking distance of the temple, creating what may be the beginning of Nickel City’s first little Saigon. Since the arrival of the first wave of Vietnamese refugees—and despite many difficulties—a generation of Vietnamese students have become educated in the American school system. The literature on the Vietnamese experience has grown considerably, increasing as the Vietnamese population has grown. Literature from the 1980s was primarily concerned with policy issues. Today, the literature is more varied and addresses the many facets of the Vietnamese experience, including the experiences of Vietnamese American children growing up American and who have never seen Vietnam.
Research Description This research is a micro examination that analyzes the identity formation of Vietnamese teenagers and young adults in one high school. Specifically, I have explored the construction of Vietnamese collective social identity within one secondary school in a large
4
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
northeastern city in the United States referred to throughout this research as Nickel City. I examine those factors, both within and outside of school, which relate to this identity formation process. My research strategies involve an exploration of how Vietnamese student school behavior and attitudes toward school, both male and female, impact their identity; how teacher/administrator perceptions and practice, as well as institutional practices, contribute to Vietnamese identity formation; in what ways Vietnamese students’ educational and occupational aspirations and expectations impact their identity; and how family and community expectations and attitudes affect their education. I also explore what Vietnamese students’ lives are like and what this may mean in terms of cultural change, and the extent to which these young adults are supported by their parents, family, teachers, administrators and friends. I further investigate what Vietnamese students’ social lives are like in school, what sorts of friends they have acquired in school and out, what leisure or extracurricular activities they are involved in, and whether American socialization is creating tension and conflict within themselves and between themselves and their families. In summary, this research probes the collective social identity of Vietnamese students in school and the Vietnamese community as a whole, and the ways Vietnamese students construct culture as a response to both schooling and broader social experiences. It is not my intention to collect data on other groups in the school system and compare the experience of these groups to that of the Vietnamese, although some discussion of inter-group relations is unavoidable. I wish to note that Vietnamese youth identity in the research at this particular site at least partly arises in relation to the two dominant groups in West Side High: Latinos and African Americans.1 Any comparisons here, however, are speculative. In the end, I find that identity formation is fluid and ongoing, emerging, not in a vacuum, but rather as part of a complex dynamic of institutional, inter-group, and personal relationships. To acquire the data, I interviewed and observed approximately 20 Vietnamese students, 20 parents, and 20 school administrators, teachers, and counselors to uncover the internal and external factors contributing to the construction of student culture and Vietnamese student identity. I have also interviewed 25 Vietnamese community
Introduction
5
leaders, observed and recorded family life and attended numerous community celebrations. Preliminary or background information on Vietnamese in the Nickel City area was acquired through Catholic Charities, a voluntary agency which has settled Vietnamese families in the Nickel City area since 1975. Currently, there are approximately 3,000 Vietnamese in the area. Significant numbers of Vietnamese high school students are located in three public city schools. The field site for this study is a neighborhood school referred to as West Side High, after the neighborhood in which it is located. As an inner city school, it serves a racially and ethnically mixed, largely working class population. Therefore, the present study probes the micro issues outlined above within one educational institution and within one Vietnamese neighborhood. The community celebrations and interviews with community leaders situate the students of West Side High and the 18th Street community in a larger citywide context. In this research, Vietnamese youth identity formation is understood to emerge in relation to their families, neighborhood and broader relationships with American youth, teachers and school administrators. As such, the school becomes a microcosm of American society. Throughout, I have employed John Ogbu’s voluntary and involuntary minority theoretical framework to analyze Vietnamese youths’ attitudes and perceptions toward schooling and achievement, as well as their future expectations and social relations both inside and outside of school. Stacey Lee’s (1996) work on model minorities helped to further refine this analysis as it pertains to Asians. In addition, I have employed the “free space” work of Michelle Fine and Lois Weis (1998) to explore how the Vietnamese use space in West Side High and the public and private domain of family and community life. Throughout, I argue that the Vietnamese dual reference framework on education positions them to appreciate education, and moves them toward a collective identity of achievement, most continuing on to higher education. Further, their collective experiences as refugees and immigrants, and specifically as Vietnamese, help to consolidate them as a group, moving them toward success. The Vietnamese youths’ emerging identity is, as explored in this research, forged from a supportive and nurturing home, community,
6
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
and institutional environment. In this research I argue that the majority of these Vietnamese have been excluded, either directly or indirectly, from participating in the benefits of education “back home” by a communist regime that viewed them suspiciously, creating a dual reference framework that appreciates American public education, encourages higher education, and directs students toward future economic success. Throughout this work I find that the institutional dynamics of West Side High create an environment where the Vietnamese can consolidate as a group by using their homeroom as “free space,” moving them toward a goal of educational attainment. Teachers and administrators, discouraged by the rigors and difficulties of working in an inner city school, are encouraged by the positive attitudes and hard work of the Vietnamese. I speculate that the Vietnamese designation as ESL (English as a Second Language) students, often viewed as a detriment in other school contexts, also helps to consolidate the Vietnamese as a group in West Side High. ESL positions non-native English speakers, and the Vietnamese in particular, within the context of an inner city school, as hard workers and students that appreciate the value of education. Most literature on the Southeast Asian experience does not take into account the different experiences of males and females. To provide for a richer account, I explore the different attitudes and experiences between Vietnamese males and females. While both males and females share positive attitudes toward school and work collectively toward academic achievement, I argue that Vietnamese females negotiate the dual expectation of having to maintain traditional female Vietnamese roles (thereby maintaining male dominant roles), and having to appease American attitudes of greater gender equality. I argue that females are not unaware of the dual expectations, but often do not challenge these traditional relationships because of the fragile state of the immigrant Vietnamese family and community. Every male I interviewed stated his interest in pursuing a professional college degree; females, by contrast, were less likely to do so. In addition, I examine Vietnamese relationships with other students at West Side High. I argue that American students, African American and Latino in particular, perceive the Vietnamese as being privileged, creating an atmosphere of resentment which sometimes
Introduction
7
leads to the harassment of the Vietnamese. In turn, this dynamic provides for the creation of stereotypes and the foundation for racist attitudes on the part of the Vietnamese toward African Americans and Latinos and vice versa. Finally, I examine the role of the Vietnamese community and family in the development of Vietnamese high school students’ identities. In this chapter I argue that the collective experiences of the Vietnamese as immigrants and refugees position the Vietnamese family and community to act as a complex network of support for Vietnamese youth, providing a nurturing environment that encourages academic achievement. The home becomes a miniature education system where everyone, family and community, participate in the education of Vietnamese youth. At the same time, I find the line between the public and private sphere becoming blurred, creating a community where Vietnamese youth are carefully monitored by both adults and each other in both public and private spaces. While for most, this atmosphere creates an environment of love and support, it also creates an arena of tension, where Vietnamese teens must balance traditional culture and expectations with American teenage values and the broader American experience. Overall, I find that Vietnamese youths’ identity formation is forged, not from a static insular experience, but rather, from a complex dynamic incorporating community, family, and school, none of which singularly block or facilitate its development. Rather, it is a discursive dialogue between institutions that enables a forging of collective and public identity modified and interpreted by the individual. It is here that I turn to a review of literature to frame the data and analysis of this study.
The Vietnamese Immigrant Experience in Perspective Scholars such as Kelly (1977) in From Vietnam to America, Weis (1985) in Between Two Worlds, Cusick (1973) in Inside High School, and others have demonstrated and suggested that large quantified studies cannot probe the more embedded issues of social process. The aforementioned scholars have turned to qualitative data collection to
8
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
begin to understand how, in a detailed way, people make sense of their world. In a similar manner, this study employs qualitative data collection in order to investigate the process of collective identity formation, and the more embedded issues of family educational expectations and aspirations, and administrator, teacher, and counselor expectations. The large quantitative statistical technique, while arguably more scientific and objective, cannot uncover the micro issues of social process in schools as outlined in this study. A further feature of this study is that it probes the many facets of their experience and textualizes the Vietnamese experience within an historical framework. This research also broadens the current discourse on identity formation to include Asians and to push beyond debates which primarily explore only the voices of Blacks and whites (Seller and Weis, 1997). To this end, it is often the case that the basic concerns of adjustment and identity remain the same but the process differs. The results of this study, therefore, can shed light on the overall process of group integration and collective social identity formation beyond Black and white, and situates the process and the experience within a cultural and historical context.
Background on Vietnamese in the United States The first wave of Vietnamese and other Southeast Asian immigrants and refugees came to the United States in 1975. The abrupt ending of the war provided for an equally abrupt arrival. The American government was unprepared to cope with the large volume of incoming refugees. Processing and settling the refugees was a huge task for which Congress slowly developed policies. For the first wave, policy development translated into many months in a detention camp. Vietnamese immigration in the United States is marked by three waves, the first occurring in the mid-1970s and the other two in the late 1970s and early 1980s. Settling has not been easy; the Vietnamese were greeted with hostility, and the traumatic conditions of their departure made adaptation difficult (Kelly, 1977). Unlike other immigrants, the early Vietnamese had no predecessors to assist them in adjusting (Nhu, 1976).
Introduction
9
The early settlement policies scattered the refugees around the nation. The Vietnamese, however, have since relocated themselves in urban communities. They previously had been isolated with no established community to attach themselves to. In addition, their culture and language are drastically different from the Western cultural and language base, making adaptation and adjustment more difficult. There is a tendency in the United States to group people who have geography, culture, or language together, disregarding differences in history. This is especially evident with Latino peoples, making them all Hispanics for demographics and census data, and more importantly, for the political distribution of federal dollars. The significance here is that the Vietnamese are surely Asian, but have very different cultural and historical experiences than the Chinese or Koreans; for example, though both Chinese and Koreans have also fled communist governments. It was not possible for the Vietnamese to attach themselves to an existing Asian community. Furthermore, it would be a disservice to them and inaccurate to compare the Vietnamese experiences with other Asian groups already established in the United States. While some comparison is unavoidable, this review focuses on literature which addresses the Vietnamese experience. The current literature available on Vietnamese immigrants and refugees focuses on four major areas: 1) Departure/settlement; 2) adjustment and adaptation; 3) employment/self-reliance—social services/dependency; and 4) education. Several Vietnamese settlement, adjustment, and employment experiences emerge in this study. It has been posited that many of the Vietnamese refugees in Vietnam were white-collar professionals, some working directly for the American government (Kelly, 1977, 1984; Caplan, 1989, 1991). Since their arrival in the United States, they have experienced considerable downward social mobility. They have either been routed into welfare or entry-level blue-collar positions. Downward social mobility is most profound in the refugees of the first wave, since this group is marked by a high number of professionals. As an ethnic group, the Vietnamese have higher levels of education than other Southeast Asian refugees and have been found to use state aid less. They have also had better success finding employment, though for professionals, employment is often underemployment (Kelly, 1977).
10
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
The settlement literature (Kelly, 1977, 1984; Baker, 1977; Baldwin, 1984; Kivisto, 1990) has also indicated that the policy implications differ considerably for refugees and immigrants. Refugees leave because of persecution, but immigrants leave of their own desire to improve their life circumstances. In terms of adjustment and adaptation, refugees, especially those of middle or higher socioeconomic backgrounds, tend to strive hard to recover what has been lost (Stein, 1979). Further, the more education the Vietnamese have, the better economically adjusted they are. They are, however, less satisfied than those with lesser education. Higher education has been linked to dissatisfaction due to unemployment or underemployment (Khe-Minj, 1979; Basche, 1979; Baldwin, 1984). In light of the research question posed earlier in this chapter, a number of sub questions were considered. For example, I examined the question: do family socio-economic background characteristics of the Vietnamese families affect their children’s identity formation in school, or, do Vietnamese children have an identity concurrent with their families’ lived experiences here in the United States? As previously stated, Kelly (1977) has posited that the Vietnamese are not a homogenous group. The second and third waves have had more Vietnamese of blue-collar or agrarian backgrounds with less education. I explore, therefore, what dominant identities school administrators and teachers associate with the Vietnamese students as a group. Ogbu (1989) has argued that racial groups in the United States (i.e., African Americans) constitute a socio-economic caste. Have the Vietnamese, because of American perceptions of Asians, been accepted as “honorary” whites, along with all the associated privileges, or, are they being racially categorized differently, like African Americans? The literature on Vietnamese adjustment has also posited that Vietnamese exile and settlement in the United States has affected their adaptation (Lanphier, 1978). In addition to general geographic isolation, Vietnamese families were found to adjust better culturally if they had a sustained relationship with an American host family. Stein further argues that the type of settlement experience by the Vietnamese “establishes both a priority in the orientation of the refugees, as well as the path of outcome which itself significantly determines other life chances” (Stein, 1979, p. 48). The overall changes experienced by the refugees have created a considerable amount of anxiety. When the
Introduction
11
gender variable is introduced, it has been found that young men, required to find jobs to support their families, have experienced greater anxiety than women and older men who remain at home. This is also the case for young single women with families. Considering these findings, I investigate how specific circumstances of Vietnamese family settlement have an effect on the identity formation and aspirations of young Vietnamese students in high school. This literature has also posited that adjustments and social integration for the Vietnamese have been better when they have been introduced into a heterogeneous community, which, by virtue of class and ethnic mix, is more flexible about facilitating integration and adjustment (Starr and Roberts, 1980). The above adjustment and adaptation issues relate to the individual and group identity formation in school. Some of the high school students themselves have experienced some or all of these adjustment issues. Parents who experienced their effects may influence their children’s perceptions of school. As it relates to this research, the collective experience of the Vietnamese as refugees and as members of the same ethnic group has affected student, parental and community acceptance of academic culture and its values. Some scholars have argued that the experiences of Vietnamese refugees will encourage their children to take full advantage of the opportunities afforded to them in the United States (Nhu, 1976). Addressing this point, Andrada (1984) argues that Vietnamese students are adjusting rapidly to the American system of education. This is creating, however, tension and conflict in the family in the area of norms and values. Rapid adjustment of Vietnamese students has also been noted to alienate them from the group. New appearances and the acquisition of American peers are creating conflict as well. While Vietnamese students may be adjusting culturally, it is not clear what specific group identity they are forming in school. They may either resist or accept school norms and values. While there is no specific study available on Vietnamese achievement in school, it is further argued that Southeast Asian students are perceived by teachers to maintain good school habits because of their learning style, and teachers have passed students on good behavior even when they have failed academically (Goldstein, 1987b). Their most significant
12
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
problems are cited to be having no official records, having to rely heavily upon classroom lectures rather than texts, and shyness and inappropriate smiling. The literature on the Vietnamese suggests that their previous socio-economic background in Vietnam and their refugee related experiences will affect their desire to achieve success and their social mobility here in the United States. In the present study, Vietnamese West Side High students fit the profile as outlined by the above studies. In terms of Vietnamese children’s collective social identity formation in school, their parent’s background experiences or the firsthand experiences of the children may affect their identities. To examine these possibilities, the family settlement experiences and the experiences of Vietnamese children are probed in parent and student interviews to determine possible relationships between group settlement experiences and identity formation in school. Vietnamese collective social identity issues are also related to various debates in the field. I now turn to a presentation of these debates in order to situate this study within a larger theoretical framework, and to identify the points which bear directly on Vietnamese collective social identity formation in school.
Schools and the Reproduction of Structure The Vietnamese have not been in the United States long enough to have established a firm position in the nation’s socio-economic structure. Because they have no similar predecessor, it is difficult to predict social outcomes by linking them to the experiences of other groups. Their relationship to the economy, the state, and its institutions are still evolving. Because Vietnamese families relocated themselves in urban areas and were initially routed into entry-level blue-collar employment and welfare, it would be easy to conclude that they are becoming the newest members of a growing and struggling urban underclass. However, that analysis would be simple and incomplete. The findings of present research suggest the opposite. Ethnographic studies of poor urban comminutes such as Valentine’s (1978) African Americans in Blackston or Bourgois’ (1995) poor urban Latino community in a large northeastern city argue that group dependence on irregular work, such as domestic service,
Introduction
13
seasonal agrarian employment, or state aid in the form of welfare and food stamps, entrap individuals in a cycle. Insufficient incomes from sporadic and unpredictable blue-collar jobs or the elimination of one household income forces individuals to derive additional income from illicit or “extra” legal activities (e.g., numbers running or the selling of marijuana). This dependence on a secondary job market, welfare, and/or illicit income-producing activities is essentially a survival existence that is a difficult cycle to break. This permanently entraps groups in an urban underclass. Because the Vietnamese have fallen into similar situations, it would be easy to assume a beginning entrapment. However, there are some differences. Both African Americans and Puerto Ricans have had a different historical relationship in the United States. African Americans began in the United States as slaves and were relegated to low socio-economic positions through various forms of institutionalized racism. Puerto Ricans have had a quasi-colonial relationship, which tends to relegate them to a similar position as Blacks vis-à-vis the economic system (Fine and Weis, 1998). It is, perhaps, this lack of a long historical relationship that makes the Vietnamese position potentially different from these two groups and may offer the strongest argument to explain why the Vietnamese are achieving academic and financial success. The literature on the Vietnamese suggests that their prior backgrounds and refugee experiences encourage them to recover what they have lost, or that their experiences will encourage them to take advantage of the opportunities afforded them here in the United States. The data from this study clearly posit that West Side High Vietnamese students, their families, and community are working hard to become self-sufficient and contributing members of American society. American schools are subject to a number of expectations. They are, on the one hand, to be institutions which reward students on a fair meritocratic basis, and on the other hand, it is argued, schools must respond to the needs and demands of a larger economic infrastructure (Bowles & Gintis, 1976). In accordance with these dual expectations, schools must distribute knowledge, but they distribute specific knowledge to certain groups so as to meet the requirements of the economy.
14
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
As Bowles and Gintis contend with their theory of correspondence, while responding to economic requirements, schools produce student outcomes which reproduce the class structure. The entire organization of schools (e.g., grades, tracks, hierarchy and competition) is geared toward the needs of capitalism. Refining this position further, Apple and Weis (1983) argue that the requirements of the state (the legitimation function of which is expected to ensure meritocracy) and the economy (capitalist accumulation) result in schools producing educational outcomes favorable to the job market. During their years in school, students are socialized into appropriate work behavior and have acquired certain job skills for various forms of employment. Group socialization, however, is not random. Groups are placed into a hierarchically organized labor force as a result of the cross demands of the economy. Correspondence theory (Bowles & Gintis, 1976) assumes that the ideological characteristics of schooling and the categorization of students by the system are accepted by them. Other scholars (Willis, 1977; Valli, 1986; Weis, 1990) have since argued that while Bowles and Gintis are not entirely wrong, this model does not explain everything. Critical cultural theorists have challenged the perception that identities are immutable forms manufactured in a passive manner. Rather, by introducing culture as a critical element, critical cultural theorists recognize the autonomous nature of individual and group subjectivity and its relationship with others (Roman, Christian-Smith, and Ellsworth, 1988). Here, identities are formed in a more dynamic way, taking into consideration symbolic meanings and lived experiences, as well as those social structures which support historic domination and subordination patterns between groups (Omi and Winant, 1994). In this model, race, class, and gender become culturally synthesized “texts,” both real and symbolic, which are applied in everyday experiences, and which affect everyone within a particular culture. Therefore the collective cultural experiences are created between “texts” through changing social struggles and economic contests in everyday locations of social and economic interaction, (Roman, Christian-Smith, and Ellsworth, 1988). What goes on at the institutional level is, under this formulation, of great significance.
Introduction
15
Studies produced by Willis (1977), Valli (1986) and Weis (1985) have posited that schools are sites where culture and ideologies are produced through interactions, rather than being places where ideologies are imposed and remain static. Interactions and processes of identity construction are characterized by tension and conflict. It is the two major points of this discussion which are specifically important to the study of Vietnamese collective social identity formation in school: 1) schools are required to perform two contradictory functions; and 2) the contradictions are worked out at the cultural level of the group as groups define their identity (i.e., class, race, gender).
Ethnographic Studies of Student Identity Formation In the 1970s and the 1980s, the cross pressures of legitimation and capital accumulation on schools increased. Since the 1960s, minorities, recognizing their inferior socio-economic status, pressured for increased state involvement to narrow the gap between themselves and their more affluent counterparts through political contest. To solve this contest, which is fundamentally an issue of the economy, the state has “required” schools to mediate these problems by emphasizing the meritocratic ideology and increasing access. Increased access itself was contradictory to the needs of capital accumulation. It became more contradictory because the state was reliant on the economy for support and was more involved in the capital accumulation process than ever before. However, more recently, since the explosion of technology, it appears that the corporate world needs people with enough education to be useful in the new workforce and to prevent shortages in the work force that raises wages. It is arguable today that better access to education, and better education itself, is in the interest of corporate America, not contradictory to those issues. Routing the Vietnamese into welfare and low level blue-collar jobs suggested that the economy in the 1970s and 1980s was unable to absorb large numbers of people at the white-collar or professional level, nor had there been a policy which allowed for a ratio of qualified Vietnamese to attain professional status, as is arguably the case for other groups. Their refugee/immigrant status does not adequately
16
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
explain these points either. During the 1950s, large numbers of Hungarian refugees were assisted by the state to recover the professional status they had left behind. Vietnamese minority status is not successfully linked to the Black or Puerto Rican position as previously stated because of a lack of historical relationship to the United States and the lack of an established cadre of unsuccessful or successful predecessors from which to formulate an identity. Ogbu (1989) begins to demystify the possible relationship between immigrant status and identity formation. He argues that voluntary minorities (individuals that have opted to come to the United States), regardless of race or cultural background, such as various Asian groups, do better (in school) than involuntary minority students, such as African Americans. Because voluntary minorities have come on their own, they tend to focus on the potential for success rather than failure. Involuntary minorities, because of their history and historically oppressed positions in the United States, view education and its rewards to be for white Americans. While this theory does not completely address the experiences of the Vietnamese, there are some points which offer insight. The distinction between “refugee” and “immigrant” is mostly significant in policy issues due to its determination of political status. While the refugee is not voluntary in the same sense as an immigrant, refugees are, like immigrants, leaving a less desirable situation for a better one. Therefore, the overall realities of socio-economic adjustment and adaptation for both groups are likely to be the same. While some Vietnamese left a middle or upper class position and may suffer psychologically from the loss of status, a desire to recover lost status has been posited in the psychological literature on Vietnamese (KheMinj, 1979; Montero, 1979; Cohon, 1981; Nguyen, 1984). Ogbu’s (1989) framework suggests that the Vietnamese may have a more positive outlook on education than other minorities or possibly even working class whites. Whether or not this potentially optimistic view of education will continue after they attempt to articulate their education and job plans with the economic sector is significant to the identity formation of West Side High Vietnamese, but falls outside of the realm of this research. To understand more clearly how group frameworks function and how they are related to tension, conflict, and resistance or
Introduction
17
accommodation in school, the following three ethnographic studies which examine resistance as it is lived and formulated along lines of class, race and gender make the points very clearly. Paul Willis’ (1977) Learning to Labor examines an all male school in a central industrial city in England. It is an ethnographic account which identifies two distinct student groups: the “lads” and the “ear ‘oles” so identified by the “lads.” The “lads” identified along white working class lines and resisted the middle class norms and values of the school. They view their schooling as a way to “have a laff.” The “ear ‘oles” accepted or accommodated the norms and values of school and were looked down upon by the other group. The “lads” were resistant to authority and the accountability of time, but especially to the total mental processes involved in, and required by schools. The “lads’” identification with the working class ethos of manual labor viewed blue-collar work as positive and successful. By extension, the position that manual labor is good became linked to a larger masculinity ethos, as well. The “ear ‘oles” and their compliant identity in school and intellectual process were characterized as effete and, therefore, unsuccessful. The total working class cultural forms of the “lads” acted to counter school culture. The “lads’” class identity further divided the working class, both materially and ideologically. This issue was particularly salient in the “lads’” positioning of working class minorities in England. While both groups (the “lads” and the minorities) may have common economic interests, racism separated both groups, disallowing a working class unity which might apply pressure on the state and the economy. Most significant in Willis’ study is that the “lads’” acceptance of manual labor and resistance to school confirmed the most basic distinction of a capitalist system. In essence, the “lads’” resistance continues to retain them at their current socio-economic stratification level and embraces a class-based economic structure which, as Willis argues, works against them. Between Two Worlds (Weis, 1985) provides insights on race, the economy, and education. Here, Weis examines Black community college students in a large northeastern city in the United States. She argues that race and its relationship to historical economic experiences created a group identity formation process within the college.
18
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
Essentially, the lived culture of poor Black students acted to return many of the students back to the ghetto. Weis argues that student cultural forms are thus lived and only partially produced in school. These specific cultural elements embody oppositional tendencies which contribute to the maintenance of an unequal social structure. Different from Willis’ (1977) working class “lads,” Black community college students view education and knowledge as critical to success. Though Black collective identity held institutional racism partially responsible for group failure, individuals also blamed themselves for their own personal failure. Since the formal barriers to access have been eliminated, and because of the group acknowledgment of education and knowledge as “key” to success, it was clear that students internalized some dominant ideological points. But inability to “penetrate” the complete ideology caused students to turn their personal failures inward. Similar to the “lads’” culture, Black community college student culture served to limit their own group’s political potential, and to encourage the maintenance of their socioeconomic position. Though the basis and causes of resistance among Willis’ “lads” and Weis’ Black community college students are different, the outcomes are similar. In Linda Valli’s Becoming Clerical Workers (1986), working class high school women’s roles were examined and the process of understanding gender-based differences began. Typical female roles were reinforced by subordinate curricula, tracking, and messages of teachers and the school. Women were selected out of certain training (male dominant tracks) and routed into clerical work, home economics and other traditionally female jobs. Unlike men, women’s identities tended to be less intrinsically linked to wage labor. Further, women’s beliefs about themselves as inferior were reinforced by ideological messages. The women themselves maintained a group cultural resistance of primping and talking about clothes and dates at inappropriate times. As a dynamic culture, it reinforced the concept of men’s superiority and women’s inferiority as workers and wage earners. Because of women’s major family roles (i.e., mother, homemaker), they resisted the double workload of full time jobs. Though not stated but inferred in this piece, it was clear that women were expected to get married and have a family as a routine part of their existence rather than become major income-producing agents.
Introduction
19
Thus, by subordinating themselves to men, they made themselves dependent on them. In comparing the identities of Valli’s (1986) women and Weis’ (1985) Black college students, we again find that the dynamic resistant culture produced in schools serves to encourage the maintenance of an inferior socio-economic position and confirm basic distinctions within the working classes. Also, these studies demonstrate the ways in which the group and the individual may become cross identified by class, race, and/or gender and construct resistant or accommodating cultures in school. Studying the Vietnamese collective social identity formation will add to the existing body of knowledge on cultural production and reproduction by examining the way in which ethnicity or immigrant status relates to the formation of culture. While this present study also uses the school as the site to examine the development of culture, it also looks at the development of culture in relationship to internal school factors (teachers and administrators) and external factors (parents’ expectations and background). Before moving to methodology, I turn to two studies (Payne, 1986; Ogbu, 1991) which examine these factors separately. Payne (1986) identified a totally chaotic institutional culture in one inner city high school. The school predominantly served inner city Black youths who were resistant to the fundamental norms and values of school. However, faculty and administrator culture also participated in the general chaos in terms of leaving early, arriving late, having inadequate lesson plans, etc. While it was clear that student, administrator and teacher cultures emerged in response to one another, it was also clear that faculty and administrators had a personal stake in maintaining the status quo. To do so allowed them less accountability while blaming the students for their failure. By examining the total social dynamics of the institution, Payne was able to acquire insight as to how lived cultures emerge in response to one another and reproduce the structure. Though students, teachers and administrators maintain different positions in the school hierarchy, their collective cultures, born of tension and conflict, create a symbiotic relationship which recreate the social order in school. Payne thus provides an example of the ways in which teenagers contribute to the collective student identity
20
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
formation process. Following Payne, my study investigates the role of teachers, administrators and school culture as well. As previously stated, Ogbu’s (1991) notions of voluntary and involuntary minority status and dual reference framework are threaded throughout this work. In addition, I have found the theoretical construct of “free space” helpful where I explore the Vietnamese use of space in West Side High and the ways in which the Vietnamese community and family interact to create a safe haven in which to nurture Vietnamese youth.
The Second Generation Since the mid-1990s, a new literature has been written which explores the lives of the second generation children whose immigrant/refugee parents have settled in the Unites States since the 1970s. Although these scholarly works do not directly pertain to the youth I have examined in this research, as the voices uplifted here for analysis are all refugees themselves, Second Generation Literature does address a number of questions I have posed throughout this present work. In the final chapter of this research I have suggested that although the Vietnamese in Nickel City have created a culture which supports Vietnamese youth’s academic success, it is not clear what the future will hold. The following work begins to unravel this question. Perhaps the most significant of these new works which statistically presents a broad expanse of second generation lives is Legacies: The Story of the Immigrant Second Generation (Portes and Rumbaut, 2001). Here Portes and Rumbaut elegantly lay out the societal and economic conditions in the United States over the past 30 years, which differ greatly from those prevailing at the beginning of the 20th century. The turn of the preceding century saw an unprecedented economic expansion in the United States which easily accommodated the millions of new European immigrants and provided them with small incremental economic steps by which to achieve upward social mobility. This economic expansion, along with the relative similarity in culture and physical appearance to the existing population, made possible easy socio-economic assimilation of the new European immigrants. However, the gradual de-industrialization of the American economy beginning in the late 1960s, and the overall global economic
Introduction
21
restructuring of the U.S. economy has created an environment much more difficult for new immigrants to achieve upward social mobility in. The present hour glass configuration of the economy along with several economic downturns has created drastically different conditions for new immigrants that the previous generations had not faced (Portes and Rumbaut, 2001; Waters, 1999; Zhou and Bankston, 1998). In addition, the new immigrants and refugees are primarily arriving from Latin America, Asia, and Africa, differing drastically culturally, linguistically and socially from previous immigrant groups and making successful upward social and economic mobility harder to achieve. As Portes and Rumbaut explain, “A racial gradient continues to exist in U.S. culture so the darker a person’s skin is, the greater the social distance from dominant groups and the more difficult it is to make his or her personal qualifications count.” Furthermore, the U.S. government has only selectively assisted groups over the last 30 years, of which the Vietnamese have been one, and leave many groups on their own to negotiate America’s more complex society and economy. Overall, the general reception of all these groups along with their personal, family and community structure greatly affect potential success. Portes and Rumbaut have identified that the extent to which second generation adaptation occurs is strongly linked to family composition and the extent to which it includes both biological parents. This affects outcomes even after taking into account parental human capital or education and occupational skills. Vietnamese students in the present study are from varying backgrounds. Some come from two parent households, others have had fathers join after many years of separation, and others still live in one parent households headed by the mother or some other older adult such as a grown brother or sister. A limitation of the present work is that I have not examined differences between these family configurations. Also of consideration in second generation immigrant student success is what type of neighborhood these students grow up in. Portes and Rumbaut suggest that “(i)n this situation, the central question is not whether it will assimilate into U.S. society but to what segment of that society it will assimilate.” In this historical context, they suggest there are three major challenges to educational attainment and further career success: the persistence of racial discrimination, the bifurcation of the
22
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
U. S. labor market, and the growing inequality and consolidation of a marginalized population in the inner city. Depending on the group or the experiences of the individual, they may identify with countercultures in school and neighborhoods that promote dropping out, joining youth gangs, or participation in drug culture, an alternative path labeled as downward assimilation (Portes and Rumbaut, 2001; Waters, 1999; Zhou and Bankston, 1998). This was particularly the case with some Vietnamese youth in Versailles Village, students studied by Zhou and Bankston in Growing Up American (1998). These were children who arrived in the U.S. before age 13 or were born in the U.S. and regarded by the overall Vietnamese community as “bad children,” or those who were alienated from their communities and overexposed to American society. In a sense then, these are youth who I would describe as between traditional Vietnamese community and American society, but not completely accepted by either. They are to some extent trapped by a desire to assimilate to American society but are discriminated against in one way or another. My experiences with these children who are “lost” to the Vietnamese community are rather limited. I saw evidence of this segment of Vietnamese youth in terms of tough kids on the bus or walking down the street, but they were an isolated few. This is partly due to the relative small size of the Vietnamese community here in Nickel City and the overall ability of the Nickel City community to maintain control. Similarly, in Black Identities: West Indian Immigrant Dreams and American Realities (1999), Mary Waters (1999) suggests that American racial discrimination negatively impacts West Indians’ upward social mobility. Attempting to improve their lives, middle class West Indians in Brooklyn, N.Y. move to better neighborhoods with better services, better schools, and no drug and gang activity, only to have whites flee. Quickly to follow behind white flight is the very element that middle class West Indian families tried to escape, creating a never-ending cycle of marginalization. Like their Mexican counterparts identified in Legacies (Portes and Rumbaut, 2001), West Indians as a group find that a significant part of their youth identify with counter-cultures leading to downward assimilation. These marginalized inner city neighborhoods have been described by Waters as toxic. I couldn’t agree more. Although the Vietnamese in the present research are exclusively living in inner city environments and only partially live in two parent
Introduction
23
households, they tend to exhibit high degrees of upward social mobility and have displayed high degrees of academic achievement very similar to most of the youth in Versailles Village community. One possible explanation, in addition to Vietnamese refugee culture and a dual reference framework, is that racial discrimination experienced by Nickel City’s Vietnamese at the hands of Latino and African American students works in Vietnamese youth’s overall favor. By this I am suggesting that attending a school which is primarily minority, and where the Vietnamese experience discrimination, may in fact block Vietnamese counter-culture identification. Discrimination of Vietnamese by American minorities is not unique to the Nickel City community. This has also been documented in works such as From Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia: A Refugee Experience in the United States (Hein, 1995). While American ethnic discrimination is usually perpetrated by whites on groups such as African Americans, Hein finds that in Philadelphia, for example, where Blacks have a high representation, Vietnamese have suffered racial discrimination at the hands of American minorities. The argument I have just presented is in direct contrast with the theories presented in many second generation analyses, including the exhaustive work on the Vietnamese by Zhou and Bankston (1998). They, too, paint an equally bleak picture of the prospects of the second generation stating that: Children growing up in households headed by poor, lowskilled immigrants face uncertain prospects for moving ahead through school success. The parents, of course have few of the economic resources that can help children do well in school. The environment does not help; when neighborhoods are poor, beset by violence and drugs, and local schools do not function well. To add to this difficulty, immigrant children receive conflicting signals, hearing at home that they should achieve at school while learning a different lesson—that rebellion against authority and rejection of the goals of achievement—on the street. At the same time, both real life and the television screen expose children to the wage and consumption standards of U.S. society, and children come to expect more than their parents.
24
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
However, keep in mind that the Vietnamese examined here are first generation immigrants/refugees. For many second generation immigrant/refugee children, socio-economic marginalization in poor neighborhoods and what I am boldly referring to as bad schools, can lead to ghettoization “…provid(ing) for a political atmosphere and mentality that preserves class distinction along racial lines, leading to greater alienation of minority children from American institutions and further diminishing their chances for upward mobility” (Fainstein, 1995). Ultimately, what may initially work for immigrant and refugee children, along with their distinct ethnic and cultural qualities, may not work for the next generation. On this point, the data presented in Black Identities (Waters, 1999) is in agreement. Nickel City Vietnamese youth have benefited from the stereotypes given by West Side High administrators and teachers, but have been alienated from their Latino and African American peers. Overall, the Vietnamese original culture has promoted upward assimilation, at least academically, in the inner city. If West Side High’s Vietnamese would have been placed in a predominantly white suburban school, the second generation literature strongly suggests they would not have nearly been so successful. The analysis here also suggests the same. Like the Vietnamese of Versailles Village, Nickel City Vietnamese have established themselves in racially mixed inner city neighborhoods where the rent is cheap. In both communities (Nickel City and Versailles Village), the Vietnamese youth attend marginal schools where the general student population views teachers and administrators with oppressive authority. Although the majority of Nickel City’s Vietnamese are academically successful, they are confronted with oppositional youth culture in light of a parental and community push for success. Further, although a few of Nickel City’s Vietnamese youth have been “lost,” the majority appear to be successful academically and may provide a positive alternative to the overall bleak picture presented in the second generation literature.
Creating a “Free Space” Nickel City is an urban environment that has been plagued by a withering private sector and an increased reliance on public dollars. Over the last twenty years, there has been a dramatic increase in
Introduction
25
poverty, crime, and domestic violence (Fine and Weis, 1998). For many individuals and families, there is an increased sense of isolation and loss of community along with a concomitant search for, and creation of, safe and alternative spaces. To explore these existing and emerging spaces, Weis and Fine (2000) further refine the theoretical constructs of “free space” as posited by Boyte and Evans (1992). Here, “free space” is understood to be the terrain between private lives and institutional structures where individuals learn to critique their experiences, assigned stereotypes, and often engage in community affirmation through democratic consensus. A critical component of participation is that it is totally voluntary. In these locations, individuals learn new skills and create a new identity while incorporating diverse perspectives. These new skills and identities translate into institutional practice, social lives, and politics. As it relates to the Vietnamese of West Side High, “free space” assists in the analysis of how the Vietnamese faculty and students delegate space in their homeroom, as well as how this space is used to consolidate them as a group, moving them forward, shaping goals, creating a safe environment free of outside stereotypes (and sometimes abuse), and forging a collective identity as Vietnamese, regardless of prior status based on common experiences and ethnicity. I also employ the construct of “free space” to explore how the Vietnamese family and community come together to create a nurturing environment for Vietnamese youth, positively enforcing the value of education and self-sufficiency. At the same time, these spaces can enable the creation of a hegemonic group identity that can be oppressive for Vietnamese youth as well. By exploring the role of the institution, as well as the roles of teachers, administrators, students (both males and females), families, and the Vietnamese community, this research examines a comprehensive environment in which Vietnamese student identity is forged. In addition to investigating the immigrant experience as a factor in identity formation, and adding to the existing body of literature on culture and the reproduction of structure, the present study also employs ethnographic data collection techniques to explore culture inside and outside of school. By doing so, I am suggesting that external influences greatly influence Vietnamese identity in school. Due to the
26
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
lack of information on refugee student construction of academic culture, the present work explores a new area of research. The following chapter descriptions help to explain this research design. This first chapter presented brief historical remarks in which to frame the Vietnamese immigration to the United States, and was followed by the major theoretical questions explored in this work. Included in this chapter was a review of the literature which couches my questions and analysis. Chapter 2 examines the methods used to gain access to the sites, as well as the collection, management, and analysis of the data. Chapter 3 presents background on Vietnamese immigration to the United States. This chapter also presents a profile of the national Vietnamese population and compares it to the local Vietnamese population, which constitutes the major focus of this research. Chapter 4 explores the ways in which the Vietnamese of West Side High manage space, particularly in the homeroom. This chapter also looks at the ways in which institutional culture contributes to the identity formation of the Vietnamese, with additional data collection on West Side High’s teachers and administrators. Chapter 5 examines the narrations of Vietnamese high school males, their aspirations for the future, perceptions and attitudes toward school, and the struggles with stereotypes both for themselves and others. Chapter 6 examines the narrations of Vietnamese high school females, their aspirations for the future, and their perceptions and attitudes toward school, and compares female narrations to Vietnamese male narrations. Chapter 7 explores the role of the Vietnamese community and family in the identity formation of Vietnamese youth. Chapter 8 presents the findings and the conclusions of this research and suggests other avenues for further research.
CHAPTER 2
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
“Do you know these people; I mean, are you related to them in some kind of way?” Triage nurse in Nickel City General Hospital Feminist research methodology and post-modernism has brought to the forefront a number of important research considerations that have exploded the myth of total objectivity. Throughout my research I have been concerned with what I bring to this ethnography, and what effect my background has on the analysis. Who I am in relationship to my work, my background, what effect I have on the methodology, and in what ways my past experiences, feelings, and assumptions affect the analysis of the data are questions raised by others in the field (Peshkin, 1986; Ladson-Billings, 1994). These are valid questions and ones which suggest that the researcher, no matter how good, is not neutral or completely passive in the process of collecting and analyzing data. Because of my concerns and occasional difficulties during the course of collecting and analyzing the present data, I am including in this chapter some brief remarks on my background, along with my feelings and experiences while investigating my topic. In addition, I include information on the preliminary steps I took before entering into the formal data collection process, how the site was acquired, a profile of the Nickel City school district, and a description of the site. This chapter also contains an explanation of how I collected the data, managed the data and, finally, how the data were analyzed.
27
28
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
Starting Up I was raised by my maternal grandparents in an old established middle class East Side neighborhood composed of various white ethnics and various “others” like myself. During the mid-1960s, the neighborhood became transitional, at first attracting middle class African Americans, and shortly after, working class and poor African Americans as well. Like everyone else in this community, I awoke in the morning, not to people rushing to get to work, but rather, to people strung out on heroin, prostitutes returning after a night out, and drug pushers and pimps making a deal. Most people survived through a complex network of relationships. Many people I know from this community continue to be on welfare, or are in jail, and in too many instances, are dead. I continued to live in this neighborhood for the next fifteen years, interacting as a member of the community and affiliating with several community-based organizations which predominantly served African Americans. After leaving Nickel City for several years, I returned to live on the West Side in a fully integrated neighborhood which included many Latinos. I have worked for a number of Latino agencies and continue to do so. Currently, as a director of the only Latino arts organization in the city, I am in regular contact with both Latino and African American organizations. Perhaps because of all of the above, this research, more simply put, asks, “why do some people make it, and others don’t?” Partly because of my own complicated background, I have become increasingly interested in issues of identity formation, and chose to examine how one ethnic group in a secondary school setting makes its life meaningful. I believe, after conducting this study and participating in many others, that the specifics of identity formation are particular to each group and person, and yet, the feelings of frustration and insecurity are general to all. In retrospect, I found the identity formation of the Vietnamese of West Side High to be a product of many things, but especially the relationship between people and institutions. My concern for my preconceived feelings and assumptions, along with the positive and negative aspects of knowing many people in both the African American and Latino communities, directed me to study a group with which I had few contacts. Nickel City has historically not attracted many Asians. Only since the late 1970s (a direct result of the
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
29
end of the Vietnam War) has there been any Asian community not associated with the various colleges and universities. Today, these inner city communities are largely Laotian, Cambodian, and Vietnamese. They continue to be very small but are creating a somewhat cosmopolitan atmosphere, and to some extent, are beginning to revitalize core urban areas. Throughout the course of data collection, I have questioned my decision to work with an ethnic group that I was so unfamiliar with and which seriously complicated the process. Initially, I knew little of the history of Vietnam or its cultures and customs, and nothing about the language. In order to center myself, I felt it necessary to first read several books and monographs on Vietnam’s history and culture before reading extensively on the U.S./Vietnam War and Vietnamese exodus and settlement in the United States. I then gathered U.S. government information on immigration and Congressional refugee acts. For local information, Catholic Charities, the regional VOLAG (Voluntary Resettlement Agency), was very helpful and insightful. They were able to give me many regional facts and introduced me to local Vietnamese community leaders, which was key to accessing the community. Because of these introductions, I was able to meet with the leaders of the Vietnamese community and discuss the community before entering West Side High. I attended numerous community meetings and celebrations such as Tet (Vietnamese New Year) as well. All of these things made me recognizable to members of the Vietnamese community, and facilitated the more in-depth aspects of my research. Meetings with local Vietnamese community leaders were critical to my comfort level while working with the Vietnamese. Dropping a familiar name before doing an interview put parents at ease. Also, Mr. Nguyen, a local Vietnamese businessman, made many helpful suggestions regarding proper conduct, for which I continue to be grateful. Unlike the more emotive, informal, and occasionally effusive community gatherings of the African American and Latino communities, the Vietnamese community, for me, was more formal and less demonstrative in public. It was difficult to “read” people’s feelings and gauge my interpersonal successes. When interviewing parents, it was immediately clear that inter-gender (male to female) interactions were governed by unfamiliar rules. For example, formal Vietnamese
30
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
culture dictates that unrelated males do not touch females; therefore introductory handshakes were regarded as inappropriate. Conversations with women were handled more formally than male-to-male conversations. Younger people were expected to stand until older persons or persons of high position were seated. When offered something to eat or drink, it was more polite to wait until the host or hostess made the first gesture to begin. Although a mistake in these areas did not kill an interview with parents (Americans were not expected to know Asian culture), following convention facilitated them. It was regarded as polite and respectful. When interacting with the Vietnamese, both young and old, I learned never to touch the top of peoples heads, sit in any way deemed disrespectful, or call someone with hand motions that were regarded as aggressive or insulting. I had to learn to take particular care with my feet, never allowing the bottoms of my shoes to be visible or pointing them towards anyone. More complicated still, is the fact that the broader Vietnamese community is not centered in one location. It is a community, or an immigrant “space,” that crosses many sites and geographic locations, although there are clusters of Vietnamese families like the one I refer to in this research as the 18th Street community. Overall, the geographic vastness of the Vietnamese community in Nickel City made becoming familiar with the larger Vietnamese community more challenging. Data collection also presented a number of learning situations. When interviewing parents at home, it was always the case that the mother deferred all responses to her husband or oldest male, when available. Interviews with Vietnamese high school students were generally no different than interviewing American high school students in terms of etiquette. Cultural rules were more essential with the Vietnamese who were the most recent arrivals. Those who had been here over a year were more informal. Overall, I found myself to be much more conscious of my behavior in the Vietnamese community than any other community in which I have conducted ethnographic work, largely because the community was so unfamiliar.
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
31
Situating the Site: A Description of the Nickel City School District All qualitative research was conducted in Nickel City, a mid-size, postindustrial city in the northeast. The vestiges of a blue-collar mentality remain in the city, though much of its heavy industry left in the late 1970s and early 1980s. Since then, Nickel City has been attempting a slow economic and cultural renaissance with a shift toward a service sector economy. Nickel City was designed in the earlier part of the 20th century to accommodate a population of 1 million. It peaked in the 1930s and 1940s to nearly 600,000, but fell short of ever realizing its intended population. Since the 1950s, it has regularly lost population to the suburbs. Census 2000 has documented the population to be less then 300,000, with white flight to the suburbs continuing at alarming speed. Today, the population is nearly half minority. It is a predominantly Black and white town with only 4.5 percent of the population foreign born. With the continuing loss of jobs, the city has lost over 35,000 people since 1980 (Fine and Weis, 1998). City government was correct to anticipate that the city would continue to lose white capital to suburban sprawl while the city itself became poorer. Fine and Weis in The Unknown City (1998) further comment that “(Nickel City’s) poor and working class are still relatively supportive of schools and other public institutions” (p. 10). However, the destabilization of the economy, lack of jobs, and the increasing poverty of the city has “(…) seen corresponding/coincident increases in violent crimes, growth of the street-selling drug industry, particularly of crack, the rapid expansion of the prison system, and the intensification of police arrests and reports of police harassment (Fine and Weis, 1998, p. 11). Choosing a site in Nickel City was very easy for this study. Only one high school, West Side High, had a large enough Vietnamese study body to conduct the research; only West Side High offers a secondary level ESL program. Two other schools also had Vietnamese high school students, but the students were too few in number to situate this research. Both are neighborhood schools like West Side High, and are governed by the same attendance rule: you must live in the designated
32
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
area to attend. There are no other requirements. The Vietnamese in these schools, however, speak English well enough not to require additional language assistance, generally because they were born here in the United States. The Nickel City school system, since the mid-1970s, has been driven by federal regulations on desegregation.2 It has been under court order and supervision since then, but more recently, a state supreme judge has relaxed this decision, allowing the city to pursue its own methods. In response to desegregation orders, Nickel City maintains a magnet system that has been phased in over a long period of time. Previous to desegregation, the district operated on a neighborhood basis. In the neighborhood school system, each school is designated an area bounded by various streets. The only attendance requirement is to live in the district. Children from outside the area had no choice, unless they opted for vocational training. However, West Side High is a special case, accepting students citywide because it has the city’s only high school level English as a Second Language Program. Because of social segregation, Blacks and whites in Nickel City tended to live in separate neighborhoods. Consequently, there were nearly all Black or all white schools, and unequal opportunities under this system. In response to civil rights lawsuits, the federal government found the Nickel City school district guilty of de-facto segregation and set up a court plan to segregate the city schools. Schools nationally became an easy target to manipulate. Nationally, the government commissioned the Coleman Report to scientifically document assumptions on inequality and to place federal dollars for equalization. What was not anticipated was the conclusion by Coleman and Associates that, no matter what the government did, it would not affect overall outcomes. For this reason, the release of the findings occurred during the summer when Congress was in recess. The report did not initially receive extensive publicity. What the allocation of federal dollars would do is relieve social pressure by giving the appearance that government intervention would address social and economic inequality. As a result of federal desegregation orders, school districts around the country experienced varying degrees of social unrest. The horrifying media pictures of the National Guard protecting Black high school children in Little Rock, Arkansas in the early 1960s set a precedent for segregated school districts around the country to find a better way to
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
33
achieve racial balance. Nickel City’s response much later in 1976 was to create the magnet school system. As the name suggests, the magnet system’s intent is to draw students from around the district to achieve racial balance between whites and Blacks; a 50/50 ratio, or as close to it as possible, was regarded as ideal. Rather than forced integration, the magnet system operates as a voluntary transfer initiative. Innovative curricula were a primary feature of the magnets. There are currently three full magnet high schools, along with many neighborhood high schools that maintain magnet programs within the school. In addition, the district has magnet elementary schools which include early childhood pre-K through 2, academies grade 3 through 8, and some 3 or 4 through 12. There continue to be traditional vocational schools and strictly neighborhood schools as well. Neighborhood schools with magnet programs are viewed in the system as magnet schools, although technically they are not. For example, Upper East Side High has an international studies program, a law program and a computer program. If a student wishes to attend one of these programs, he or she would apply to the magnet program and be placed at Upper East Side High. Children attending Upper East Side High on a neighborhood residency basis cannot attend the magnet programs unless they have applied and been selected. The magnet system results in bussing school children around the district. To avoid forced bussing and the problems it created around the nation, it was necessary for the district to become creative to achieve its ends. Various programs and curricula were put into place whose focus and methodology varied. Therefore, parents would select a program in which to place their child. Parents apply to the magnet office and have a choice of three programs. Children are selected on a binary basis (minority vs. majority). Some programs have additional requirements such as entrance exams. If one program is balanced, the child will be considered for one of the other two. On the secondary level, a child may also opt for a vocational track, of which there are several schools that are not officially regarded as magnet schools. As previously mentioned, vocational schools were already in place prior to desegregation and achieved racial balance by chance.
34
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
The vocational schools specialize in various vocations such as horticulture, cooking, drafting, etc., with a de-emphasis on college preparation. They act as a magnet school because their population is drawn district-wide. Neighborhood schools are similar to those that existed throughout the district prior to desegregation. There are various reasons why someone would want to go to one. Children may have been rejected from a specific magnet school because they did not meet the academic requirements, or simply because they did not wish to attend school outside of their neighborhood. In addition, there might be any vagrant reason, such as a desire to play on a specific sports team, or perhaps their girlfriend or boyfriend is in attendance. Because magnet schools have more expensive programs and higher paid teachers, “the magnet system relies upon the existence of less costly neighborhood schools to balance the budget.”3 Most often, students from middle class backgrounds with educated parents apply to, and are accepted into, the magnet schools. The poorest students, therefore, typically attend the severely under-funded neighborhood schools, thereby serving to segregate the system by social class. Since magnet schools have been in place, there has been an aggressive public relations campaign centered on the high quality of education offered by the magnet system, which has enticed parents and students to participate. It has been so successful that parents, and to some extent administrators and teachers, believe that non-magnet education, or the education offered by the neighborhood schools, is inferior. The district is now encouraging parents to be more informed and conscientious about their choices. The Board of Education reports that the publicity campaign was so successful that they must de-emphasize the magnet system. The new position states that while the methodologies may differ, the quality of education is the same, regardless of whether a child attends a magnet school or a neighborhood school. One high-ranking administrator commented, for instance, that “every child is not suited for Montessori School, or any other program for that matter, and parents must act judiciously.” The ultimate purpose of desegregation is to equalize opportunities for all. However, according to the assistant superintendent, an African American female, there has never been an evaluation of Black and white achievement locally. Therefore, it is not
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
35
known if Black students learn better if taught by white teachers or if they sit next to white students. Currently, the Nickel City district has a 61 percent minority enrollment, making racial balance in all schools impossible. White children are needed to make the system work. In 2002 there continues to be middle class white flight to the suburbs, making the city poorer. Therefore, any white city child is almost assured to be able to attend any program of his or her choice with a few exceptions, such as the most competitive schools like Honor’s High. Due to the departure of many companies and businesses, many whites have left the area entirely, or have moved to suburbs to avoid the growing violence and poverty of the city. Middle class flight is also increasing among minorities as well. One Black administrator remarked, “I had to think long and hard about remaining in the city and placing my children in the city school system. So we have moved to the suburbs, they attend schools there. It has become too dangerous in many of the schools. People are worried.”
Profiling the Site West Side High is located on the city’s lower West Side, a traditionally poor and immigrant neighborhood. It is a large and imposing turn of the century red brick Georgian revival building originally constructed as the area’s Teacher’s College. West Side High was originally located in what is currently the administration building of State College, several miles further north. In 1920, the ever-expanding population of the lower West Side, paralleling national increases in immigration from Europe, dictated that a high school in the neighborhood be provided. This was accomplished by relocating Teacher’s College to the smaller building further north and converting Teacher’s College into what is now West Side High School. Today, because of its architectural significance, West Side High has been awarded local historic status. Its age, however, presents various problems and challenges for the students and staff. Nearly everyone would prefer a more modern building. Teachers, in particular, complain that the building is drafty and cold. Its Edwardian style auditorium is large but has few amenities. In the last twenty years, a
36
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
new gymnasium has been added with a pool, but it is still not as wellequipped or as large as those in the more recent structures. Nevertheless, its wooden oak interior gleams with polish and many faculty refer to West Side High with some pride, speaking of the many years of service it has provided the community, and its fascinating history. In 1969,4 West Side High was designated as the city’s only English as a Second Language High School. It currently has one principal, three vice principals, and three assistants for discipline. The attendance office has two aides. In addition, there are two and one half time guidance counselors. Guidance also has one administrative assistant and two teacher’s aides. There is also one Native American counselor provided by the Native American Community Center. Currently, West Side High has ninety full time teachers and twenty teacher’s aides along with one librarian. West Side High has a multitude of community volunteers from the neighborhood. West Side High’s student population is the most varied in the city. As of the writing of this research, West Side High has a total school population of 636 students. The school student profile, provided by West Side High’s officer of statistics, breaks down as follows: 354 Latinos, 147 African Americans, 85 whites (including Arabs), 126 Asians, and 24 Native Americans. Of the total school population of 636, 47 percent are listed in the school records as below or at the federal poverty level. A full 72 percent are eligible for free or reduced lunches. Thirty-seven percent of the total school population is enrolled in the ESL program.
Collecting the Data Because this study acknowledges the importance of studying the deeply embedded issues of social process within and outside the institution, the qualitative techniques of observation, participant observation and in-depth interviewing predominates in my research methodology. Using multiple qualitative techniques allows for themes to be generated that are multi-dimensional (Bogdan and Biklen, 1982). Primary resource statistical data and analysis are used to establish immigration trends for the Vietnamese background chapter. For the period 1980-2002, Vietnamese refugee data was acquired from the INS (Immigration and Naturalization Service) Statistical
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
37
Yearbook. Secondary sources have provided recent data (Zhou and Bankston, 1998; Portes and Rumbaut, 2001). This research covers the following areas: age distribution, sex distribution, income/occupational data, family units, religious affiliation, origin—rural or urban, educational characteristics, and language skills. The historical background of Vietnamese immigration is summarized through secondary sources. The literature on the early trends of Vietnamese immigration is quite rich, spanning the problems of initial settlement to the long-term adjustment issues faced by immigrants and refugees. While most of my research is conducted in a public high school, a substantial portion is conducted in the Vietnamese community, which is spread over many neighborhoods. In order to preserve the anonymity of the individuals interviewed or observed, the name of the city, school and all participants will be referred to by names I have created and assigned to my narrators in the actual research presentation. Some of the Vietnamese narrators have traditional Vietnamese names and others Western names. I have changed all names in accordance with the originals. My initial contact with the Vietnamese community was made through two sources: 1) Catholic Charities Refugee Resettlement Program, the voluntary agency (or VOLAG) responsible for the majority of Vietnamese settlements in the area, and 2) the Nickel City Public School System. Although I have met several Vietnamese in my neighborhood and local corner store, the Vietnamese community was an enigma for me and appeared to have no central location. I was initially perplexed at how to make contact, but was advised by the local grocery man, a Vietnamese, that I should pay a visit to the local Catholic Charities who “settled nearly everyone.” The director of the Catholic Charities Resettlement Program was extremely helpful, introducing me to local community leaders, giving me dates of Vietnamese community events, and making it clear that West Side High was the most likely place to do my high school research. For his assistance and advice I will always be grateful. Before I began collecting the main body of data at West Side High School, I visited and spoke with many of the Vietnamese leaders. I also attended several public gatherings, the most important being the Tet
38
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
celebration held annually in a downtown hotel and attended by nearly everyone in the Vietnamese community. Before entering the public school system, I was required to get written permission from the superintendent of the district. In retrospect, this was one of the most anxiety-producing aspects of the entire study. I was denied an appointment with the superintendent’s office several times. After the third try, I was permitted to meet with the superintendent who was especially critical of research being done in his schools. I was reprimanded for being insistent. Further, I was informed that students were in school to study and not be the subject of research. He informed me that the city’s public school system was subject to too many research projects, and many had placed the district “in a bad light.” I was required to write a lengthy proposal outlining my research and its ultimate purpose. After submission of my outline, I waited three months (and several phone calls later) before receiving a letter giving me permission to enter the school. Within days, I presented the letter to the principal of West Side High, who also required a copy of the outline I presented to the superintendent, forcing me to wait an additional month before allowing me to make formal entry. After receiving permission to enter, I began by introducing myself to the Vietnamese teacher, who also had to give me permission to attend his classes and homeroom. He did so without hesitation. The first several days, I walked around the school a great deal, familiarizing myself with the building and facilities, often interacting with office personnel and meeting teachers and administrators at lunch or in the lounge, while using the Vietnamese homeroom as a home base. The teachers and staff were especially open and helpful throughout this study. The entire length of the research in the school was one full academic year, September through June, though I attempted to enter the previous year. In total, 20 students were interviewed, 10 males and 10 females, although all 36 Vietnamese students (including the 20 interviewed students) were observed in homeroom or classroom rounds. Twenty teachers and staff, such as guidance counselors and librarians, were interviewed as well as an additional 7 administrators, including the principal, vice principals, and support staff.
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
39
Homeroom and classroom observations took the form of journal entries. A journal was kept for the entire academic year, and was handwritten, with each entry identified by location, such as homeroom or classroom, and dated. Other entries may include observations in offices or other locations in the school, such as the faculty lunchroom, student cafeteria, guidance office, hallways, auditorium, etc. Each evening, after a site visit, the observations were typed as formal data and initially maintained in chronological order. During the course of an observation, I wrote my feelings or comments with a collection of anecdotal information along the margins to assist in the later analysis of the work. Entries include Vietnamese students interacting with administrators, teachers, counselors, supportive staff, and peers. I also observed classroom settings, free time situations such as study hall, lunch, and after school informal settings like walking home. While many of the observations were focused on Vietnamese students, I also noted the interactions of non-Vietnamese to make comparisons. In both the classroom and study hall, I noted major occurrences such as lecture content and peer and teacher dynamics, but also minutiae such as students napping and peering out of the windows bored with classroom lectures. I often find that qualitative researchers prefer the very large and dramatic issues to explore, most likely because they provide immediate and powerful evidence of trends. However, in this research I also explore the minutiae of the students’ day-to-day experiences which, I believe, present powerful portraits (Fine and Weis, 1998). After the first two weeks in the homeroom, I began my student rounds in the classrooms. I accompanied 10 males and 10 females, 20 students in total, on their daily classroom routines for one week each, including joining them for lunch and leaving with them at the end of the school day. Often, I walked home with the students on my way back to my neighborhood, creating familiarity and trust with the Vietnamese community. In the classroom I noted the conduct of all of the students, their seating, the frequency of teacher/student questions and responses, their overall attentiveness, cooperativeness, and adherence to general classroom regulations, as well as course content, lecturing, and teaching style. After all classroom rounds were completed, I arranged with Mr. Lee to interview Vietnamese students individually in a quiet room in
40
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
the library with permission from the librarian. Each interview lasted approximately 45 minutes, or the length of a school period. Interviews were semi-structured, with an interview schedule that was administered to each student. All interviews were taped with permission from the students and their parents. Students were given the option to have the recorder turned off if they wished to say something off the record. Although this never happened with the students, it happened very often with the teachers, administrators, and staff. The interview schedule was open ended, meaning that students could speak at length on issues that I raised. Questions were carefully constructed so as not to imply a preferred response. Often, questions began with the phrase “how do you feel about…” (this or that subject). One student interview required the assistance of an additional Vietnamese student who spoke English fluently and who assisted me by translating my questions into Vietnamese. Student interviews also allowed for students to speak broadly about themselves, including their home life, community, and educational experiences. After completing student interviews, I began the process of making appointments with teachers and administrators for interviews. Although I would have preferred to interview teachers as a set, and administrators as a set, scattered appointment times made interviewing individuals easier as they became available. As previously mentioned, administrators were the most difficult to interview because of their busy schedules and general reluctance. Like students, teachers and administrators were interviewed generally in one hour sessions, though they were allowed to continue longer if they had a great deal to say. Teacher/administrator questionnaires were prepared in advance and consisted of 15 open-ended questions. These questions acted primarily to structure the interview and ensure that all areas of interest were covered. However, they essentially acted as conversation starters or probe questions, which allowed for the narrator to express themselves freely. Narrators were aware they were being taped and, like the students, had the option to turn off the recorder at any time. Both administrators and teachers used this option rather frequently. When this occurred, I continued to take handwritten notes with their permission. Later, in the transcription process, I would fill in these blank areas with my written notes. Handwritten notes were italicized to distinguish them from the actual taped material. After completing all
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
41
in-school interviews, I then turned my attention to the Vietnamese community. The most difficult aspect of this study was entering the broader Vietnamese community. It was here that my ability to conduct qualitative research was really tested. In the community, I did not have an institution to rely upon to provide structure. Although I began my study by meeting and interviewing community leaders and attending various Vietnamese public functions, this did not provide me with immediate entry into the Vietnamese neighborhood around the school. Living in the immediate neighborhood helped to some extent, partly because I was visible, but mostly because it allowed for me to be very flexible in terms of having time to “hang out.” Ten families were observed and 20 parents in total were interviewed, 10 males and 10 females. Access to Vietnamese families came from my acquaintance with five students at West Side High. I often walked with students on my way home. I occasionally was asked to sit on the porch or just stopped briefly to chat. Eventually, I became known well-enough to speak with a father or a mother, be offered something to eat, or just come inside and watch T.V. After a few such occasions, I asked if they would mind being observed in a more formal way. Sometimes the answer was no. However, with time, and a better understanding of what I was doing, I found 5 families that permitted my observations. Through the initial 5 families, I met other families. From these, I selected an additional 5. Selection was based primarily on my ability to visit with them easily in terms of proximity to my home. In the beginning of my research, penetrating the broader Vietnamese community was the one aspect of the study I was most concerned about, fearing that it would be impossible to do. With time, however, it was possible, and in retrospect, offered the most personally rewarding phase of this research. Observing families’ lived experiences occurred simultaneously with field research conducted in the school. Handwritten journals were labeled by family and date. I maintained a separate journal for each family. It was my personal choice not to record conversations on tape. I tried this twice, and found that it was unnecessarily invasive, often creating an artificial atmosphere and making people uncomfortable. Instead, I chose to observe by taking handwritten notes similar to
42
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
classroom observations. I continued the practice of collecting anecdotal information and writing my feelings and thoughts along the margins, which helped enormously in the later data analysis. The amount of time I spent with each family varied from just two hours to an entire evening, depending on the circumstances. In two cases, I became a friend of the family, and as such, was often called upon for advice or help in various ways. I am fully aware of the anthropological/ sociological concerns regarding cultural transference. Although there were times when I felt very sympathetic to these families and their issues, I was careful not to allow my personal sentiments to influence unduly my analysis of the material. I find that to be completely objective in observations is nearly impossible, especially in such intimate surroundings. Rather, heightened moments of involvement provided me with rare glimpses into the real life experiences of a people that I would otherwise not have had. In the end, I believe that all people have the same limited number of human experiences and feelings. It is how they are managed and handled that makes the difference. On a final note, I once was asked to go to a hospital emergency room with one of the Vietnamese families, their neighbors, and a few friends, most likely for moral and cultural support. It was certainly not because of any language ability I had acquired. Like everyone else in the family, I was herded en mass from room to room with a seriously ill child. At the end of the evening, when the doctors and nurses completed their observations, the hospital decided it was in the best interest of the child to remain overnight; everyone else was told to go home and rest. The family was particularly reluctant to leave the child alone with strangers. There was real concern on the part of the Vietnamese family that, because they did not personally know the doctors and the nurses, there was no real accountability. Further, it was noted by an elderly grandparent that hospitals are places where people die. In fact, she was probably right. It is likely that among the agricultural class of Vietnam, people go to hospitals as a last resort. Individuals are so sick, they are not likely to leave. It was then that I was called upon, in this instance by a doctor, to try to convince the family that leaving the child was the right thing to do, and to assure them that the child would be fine. I suddenly became the liaison between American culture and a foreign culture, and, by hospital
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
43
implications, a primitive culture at that. I did so reluctantly. I, too, was not completely convinced that the child would be fine. By all accounts, it appeared as if the child had acute appendicitis and would certainly become dangerously ill if not attended to properly. A long and loud discussion broke out within the group. As is typical among Southeast Asians, people speak over one another, not waiting for one speaker to finish before the other begins. The atmosphere appeared riotous, and hospital staff and other patients began staring and talking between themselves. At one point a guard took particular notice of us, and I was afraid that we would all be escorted out, or worse, arrested. I immediately became aware that I was neither Vietnamese nor white, and not in concert with the dominant cultural perceptions around me. It was one of those odd and rare cultural experiences. I clearly understood that this was an impassioned discussion with the good of the child at heart, but it was not one that was typical of white middle class America. It was the type of communal process that characterized the Vietnamese community. While the rest of the group was oblivious to the situation, I became self-conscious and hoped that the matter would soon be resolved. By extension, I suddenly understood how African Americans must feel when isolated in a totally white environment, fearing both misunderstanding and simultaneously not caring, realizing the worst white stereotypes as Franz Fanon describes in Black Skin, White Masks (1952), ranging from “yes sah boss” to “sho’ nuf’ good eaten’.” A laborious twenty minutes later, it was collectively agreed that Bin, the ill child, would stay in the hospital overnight and everyone would return early the following morning. On the way out, one of the nurses asked me if I was Vietnamese, and who I was in relation to the sick child. I was stunned and perplexed at this question, since I feel I do not look or act Asian in any way. After explaining that I was just a friend, the nurse made some awkward attempt at an explanation, commenting in a somewhat humorous way that I almost had slanted eyes. I smiled politely and later thought a great deal about this comment and the entire night’s experience and the racism it involved. It seems to me that context is very important, even critical to a proper analysis of ethnographic data. Do we as researchers really see what we think we see? Often, data are collected in very specific and isolated circumstances like a school or other such
44
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
institution, but not often enough through the real lived experiences of people. By including a chapter on community and family, I just begin to explore the enormous impact these influences have on the identity formation of Vietnamese high school students and the correspondence between broader lived culture and the institution.
Data Management All data for this research were managed similarly to the methodology outlined in Bogdan and Biklen (1982). Initially, journals were handwritten, dated, and titled according to location and maintained in chronological order. Each evening, journal entries were typed as data. Parenthetical information, such as my feelings or insights, was typed separately at the end of each entry and labeled as such. The typed journal entries were copied twice. The originals were filed away. The entire set of journal entries were read and reread for trends which were recorded. Later, the entries were divided into categories such as homeroom, classroom, lunchroom, etc. for referencing in specific ways. Taped interviews were labeled with the name of each interviewee, the date of the interview, the status of the individual, such as student, teacher, administrator, parent, or community leader, and the gender of the narrator. I learned to include gender because I was at first unfamiliar with Vietnamese names and couldn’t distinguish between male and female. Tapes were maintained in separate boxes according to the type of interview (i.e., student, teacher, etc.). After all the interviews were collected—a total of 70—I began the process of transcription. This was, in fact, the most laborious phase of the work. After completing this task, I copied each interview twice, maintained the originals intact, and filed them away. Each set of interviews were read and reread for trends which I hand wrote on a separate sheet of paper. These initial trends, along with areas of interest implied by the list of questions, were the basis for the codes which I would later use for coding the material. Next, all observations and interviews were coded. Although I know how to code by computer program, I prefer to manage the data by hand. Each journal entry or transcribed interview was coded according to the pre-established code sheet, one for each category. Most entries or interviews were coded once, but occasionally they were double or triple
The Politics of Site, Self and Access
45
coded. Those areas of the interviews or entries that were double or triple coded were copied again, with the additional pages inserted behind the originals. Coded entries and interviews were then cut into data chunks and filed according to code in folders identifying its contents. Each data chunk had handwritten identifications on the back, such as the name of the interview and page, so that I could view the data in context if something was not clear. Each collection of codes were then read and reread for major themes which were typed and placed inside the envelope. By managing the data in this fashion, it made analysis easier.
Analysis Occasionally, similar data categories and trends were collapsed in order to provide a richer analysis. By doing so, emergent trends in the data provided the broad categories and subcategories for discussion. Each category of analysis was related to relevant literature. Major theoretical points were compared and contrasted to relevant scholarly works. Categories of discussion are illustrated with data chunks—interview or observation excerpts—providing the material for discussion after the theoretical arguments have been made.
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 3
Vietnamese In Perspective
You have to understand how determined we are as a people, to get our lives back. Mr. Sung, restaurant owner The purpose of this chapter is to examine the background characteristics of Vietnamese refugees in the United States from the period 1975 to 2002. The issues I review in this section are not all directly related to the questions I posed in chapter 1, but are critical— from my perspective—for a full understanding of how the Vietnamese are beginning to formulate their collective identity vis-à-vis American society. This broad picture includes the often brutal conditions of their departure and the lengthy, and sometimes uncertain, resettlement processes of the national group, as well as the profile of a small community of Vietnamese refugees in the Northeast. My goal is to capture how, under difficult conditions, and without an established community with which to attach themselves, a diversified group of Vietnamese refugees situate themselves in their new homeland. I emphasize their personal adjustment and assimilation problems, as well as how they intersect with the labor market and participate in the economy. Through secondary resources, I review their children’s academic achievement. Lastly, I compare the local picture of Vietnamese students with the national profile. The data reviewed in this chapter questions the reproduction of structure literature and its theories, and further provides a basis to suggest that identity formation processes are dynamic rather than static, as posited by some scholars. Without the advantage of American middle class privileges, and in spite of language and cultural differences, as will be seen, Vietnamese refugee children are performing very well in schools. 47
48
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
The Departure from Vietnam The fall of Saigon in April 1975 initiated the departure of 130,000 Vietnamese and other Southeast Asian refugees. This began a new chapter in U.S. immigration history. Over the years, two additional waves of Vietnamese followed; the last, or third wave continues to the present. Scholars disagree when the second and third waves began. Caplan (1991) cites 1978 as the beginning of the second wave, and 1981 as the beginning of the third wave. Since 1981, approximately 70,000 Vietnamese, in addition to other Southeast Asian refugees, have arrived annually in the United States. Most have come in search of freedom and a better life for themselves and their children. Their introduction to American society has been, not surprisingly, a difficult one. First wave Vietnamese arrived to an unwelcoming America. The United States was experiencing a deep recession at the time, creating concerns for Americans that Southeast Asians would take away scarce job opportunities. Unfortunately, the Vietnamese reminded America of an immensely unpopular war. With distance of time and the continuing improvement in relations between the United States and Vietnam, these issues became less important in the experiences of the Vietnamese. The experiences of the first wave immigrants were especially difficult due to their lack of understanding of what was actually happening in the final days of the war. The Vietnamese expected only to be evacuated from a threatened territory and later to return. They never intended to leave Vietnam permanently. Subsequently, many of the first Vietnamese refugees put much energy into maintaining ties with their homeland, with the notion that they would soon come back (Kelly, 1977). In the initial evacuation, transportation helicopters, troopships, fishing boats, and sampans headed toward the American fleet in the South China Sea. It was only after several days that most first wave Vietnamese realized they were expatriating themselves. The Vietnamese intended to escape, but had no intended goal. A 500-acre Japanese World War II airstrip in Guam unexpectedly became the first refugee processing center. The United States Congress, like the Vietnamese, was also taken by surprise. The American government was unprepared to cope with
Vietnamese in Perspective
49
the large volume of incoming refugees, though top ranking officials were aware of the impending success of the North Vietnamese. Processing and settling the refugees was a huge task for which Congress slowly developed policies. For the first wave, policy development translated into many months in detention camps. Overall, the Vietnamese were greeted with hostility. Along with the traumatic conditions of their departure, adaptation was especially difficult (Kelly, 1977). Furthermore, unlike other immigrants, the Vietnamese had no predecessor to assist them in adjusting (Nhu, 1976). The early settlement policies scattered the refugees around the nation. The Vietnamese, however, have since relocated themselves in urban communities, creating clusters of Vietnamese enclaves. Before secondary migration, they were isolated with no established community to which they could attach themselves. Their culture and language were drastically different from Western cultures and languages, which made adaptation and adjustment extremely difficult. Kelly (1977, 1982) has posited that many of the first wave Vietnamese were white-collar professionals in Vietnam. Some worked directly for the United States government or American corporations. This group was also marked by an abundance of doctors, lawyers, professors, journalists, and other highly trained professionals. They often spoke English, were well-educated, and were part of the middle and upper classes of South Vietnam. This, in fact, necessitated their departure; they and their families would have experienced intimidation, and most likely torture, if they did not leave. The first wave was prepared to leave, but only for a short time, and only with very short notice. Since their arrival in the United States, they have experienced severe downward social mobility. Like most Vietnamese, they have either been referred to or channeled into welfare or entry-level, bluecollar positions. Downward social mobility is most profound among these first wave refugees, since this group is marked by a high number of professionals without comparable job opportunities in the United States. The second wave of Vietnamese refugees, which closely followed the first, was vastly different. They were composed of fishermen and soldiers. Many were Catholic and ethnic Chinese, once fleeing communists in the North and now again in the South (Kelly, 1984).
50
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
They were blue-collar or lower middle class with much less education. The Vietnamese, as documented by Kelly (1984) and again by Caplan (1991), are not a homogeneous group. Native Vietnamese regarded ethnic Chinese as wealthy and bourgeois. For generations they maintained most of the small businesses in North and South Vietnam. This made them the focus of much negative attention, especially in North Vietnam. In anticipation of brutal treatment by the communists, they fled en mass to the South. The first two waves of refugees to the United States were comprised of a disproportionate number of Catholics, who were also concerned about reprisals. Like the ethnic Chinese, Vietnamese Catholics generally did better than Vietnamese Buddhists, who were not culturally influenced by other philosophies (Kelly, 1984). Furthermore, Catholic doctrine was incompatible with communism. Many of the Catholic clergy were opposed to communism, using their pulpits and congregations as anti-communist forums. In fiscal year (FY) 1980-1981, the flow of Southeast Asian refugees peaked (166,727 in FY 1980, and 132,447 in FY 1981); the vast majority (90%) were Vietnamese (Organization of Refugee Resettlement (ORR), 1989). Since then, there has been a relatively consistent flow of Vietnamese every year. Social workers complain that their jobs have become harder as each new group is less prepared for life in the United States. Fiscal year 1987-1988 marked a new phenomenon in Southeast Asian refugee migration, as Vietnam released Amerasians. They are the children of Vietnamese women and American soldiers. Many were orphaned; all of them were disliked because they were illegitimate and bi-racial. Zhou and Bankston document the refugees in the following way: Exiles who fled at the end of the war made up most of the first group. Then came the “boat people,” who entered the United States in two waves, one peaking in 1978 and the other in 1982. The influx of Vietnamese refugees then declined for several years, only to surge again between 1988 and 1992. Over six hundred thousand Vietnam-born people were resettled in the United States between 1975 and 1995, most of them as refugees. By the mid-1990s, the Vietnamese refugee crisis had eventually subsided. Subsequent arrivals are mainly
Vietnamese in Perspective
51
immigrants rejoining their families already resettled in the United States” (Zhou and Bankston, 1998).
The Process of Resettling As mentioned in the previous chapter, the literature on settlement posits that policy implications differ considerably for refugees and immigrants. Refugees leave because of persecution, but immigrants leave of their own desire to improve their life circumstances. In real terms, individuals who expatriate themselves from communist or unfriendly nations are regarded as refugees. Others who expatriate themselves from nations that are regarded by the American government as friendly, such as Haiti, are regarded as economic asylees, and therefore, not admissible under the U.S. Refugee Act. As refugees, the Vietnamese were required to be processed in resettlement camps. Resettlement camps were created by U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service officials to prepare the first wave Vietnamese and other Southeast Asian refugees. Camp Pendleton, California; Fort Chaffee, Arkansas; Elgin Air Force Base, Florida; and smaller ones such as Indian Town Gap, Pennsylvania, were set up ad hoc in the United States (Kelly, 1977). In addition to the bureaucratic aspects of processing, such as background checks, interviews, health exams, identification number issuance, and awaiting sponsors through voluntary agencies and church groups, refugees were becoming educated on becoming American. It is argued that “(I)n the camps, Vietnamese were…introduced into American society and culture and found a place to live and work in the U.S. Vietnamese went into the camps as refugees, they came out as immigrants” (Kelly, 1977). This point has also been documented by Zhou and Bankston (1998). In the camps, children went to school; culture classes taught them the skills needed to become functional in the United States, for example, grocery shopping, apartment hunting, and general social interaction. Everyone went to English classes. Refugees saw movies, attended orientation sessions, and took an assortment of vocational training courses. In short, the camps were at all times highly structured environments designated to Americanize the Vietnamese and other Southeast Asians and to facilitate the process of assimilation (Kelly,
52
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
1977). The final step was registration with a resettlement agency or voluntary agency, which are social service agencies often run by church organizations and given the task of finding host families, and/or assisting the refugees in finding a place to live. Refugees were free to select the agency of their choice. This choice was often random; sometimes the choice was connected to refugee networking. Choosing an agency was, for the Vietnamese people, a first step toward independence. Agencies in 39 states continued the assimilation process by offering English classes, job screening and placement, as well as assisting in the acquisition of public assistance. For resettlement services, the U.S. government allotted large sums of money (ORR, 1989). In some instances, refugees were abused. There are reports of refugees being put to work at hard labor in unsafe and unsanitary conditions. In almost all cases, refugees were given minimum wage positions. Under the circumstances, not all refugees were willing to resettle (Doyle, 1985). Some repatriated themselves. The U.S. government assumed that the flow of refugees was a onetime only phenomenon. Thus, the resettlement programs were regarded as proceeding on schedule. By the end of 1975, the resettlement camps closed and the interagency task force that managed refugee resettlement was disbanded. Thereafter, refugees came under the supervision of the U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. Between April and December of 1975, only an additional 377 refugees appeared for asylum from other Southeast Asian countries. The new Refugee Act established by Congress required that all incoming refugees be admitted into a first nation of asylum before being considered for immigration to the United States. Many refugees, therefore, were detained in other countries such as Thailand and Malaysia before gaining admittance to the United States. Most Vietnamese were in these camps a year or less. Foreign asylum camps offered fewer services than the ones in the United States. In 1976, the Vietnamese refugee total rose to 5,619, and in 1977 the total number jumped to 21,276. Due to the influx of refugees, two new permanent agencies were created: the Interagency Task Force for Indochinese Refugees and the Office of Refugee Resettlement. “The role of IATF and ORR has been to allocate funds, keep track of the refugees, and organize resettlement strategies” (Caplan, 1991, p. 52).
Vietnamese in Perspective
53
The basic task of resettlement comes from local affiliates (voluntary agencies) such as not-for-profit private organizations like Catholic Charities. Each agency is provided $500.00 for each refugee resettled. All refugees must have a sponsoring individual before resettlement. This could be a family member or unrelated sponsor or agency such as a church or voluntary agency. After the second wave of refugees, sponsorship has shifted primarily to voluntary agencies. In the city in which this study was conducted, the director of the local Catholic Charities Resettlement Program remarks as follows: Refugees leaving Vietnam after 1975 were very different from their predecessors. They were no longer the cream of South Vietnam, but rather the common man. They also left Vietnam under very different circumstances; most departed in overcrowded boats which were attacked by pirates. Many of these refugees never arrived at any port but perished at sea. Those that arrived suffered enormous hardships. These are the people we refer to as boat people. Many of these were, as previously stated, ethnic Chinese or the Hoa. The Hoa were historically disliked because they represented 1,000 years of Chinese rule. Their businesses were completely disrupted when the communists abolished all free trade in 1978. The communist Vietnamese of the North, who were often in dispute with China, questioned their loyalty and often sent ethnic Chinese to different economic zones. In 1978, the relations between China and Vietnam worsened. In February of 1979, China invaded Vietnam in a 17-day war. Concerned for national security, the Vietnamese ordered the Hoa an option to leave. Virtually all Chinese left North Vietnam. For fees, the Vietnamese allowed the Chinese to leave, creating a 3 billion dollar enterprise. Many ethnic Vietnamese posed as Chinese, speaking in limited Cantonese to take advantage of this option. The North Vietnamese act of ethnic cleansing was intended to minimize internal threats and to attempt to homogenize the populace and culture. To be fair, the ethnic Vietnamese perception of the Hoa was at best a stereotype. While it is true that some Chinese-Vietnamese are wealthy
54
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
business people, the majority are not. Survey data indicates that the Hoa are less educated than ethnic Vietnamese, and as a group are poorer, even if their community includes some successful business owners (Gold, 1994). Like the Vietnamese, other governments and political factions throughout world history have imposed similar acts in order to target specific peoples as scapegoats for their country’s ills.
The Vietnamese: A Demographic Profile5 Well over one million Southeast Asian refugees have resettled in the United States over the past 24 years. Of this group, the vast majority are ethnic Vietnamese.6 According to the 1990 U.S. Census, Asian Americans are currently the fastest growing minority group in the United States, and will grow to 20 million, or more than 6 percent of the total U.S. population, by 2020. Currently, Asians comprise 7.3 million, or 3 percent of the total population. Their overall growth rate was 95 percent during the 1980-1990 decade. This compares to 6 percent for whites, 13 percent for Blacks, and 53 percent for Latinos during the same period. Of the total Asian population in the United States, Vietnamese constitute 8 percent. The Vietnamese median age is 21 years, or 3 years younger than the median age of the population of the United States as a whole. Because of the youthfulness of the Vietnamese population, 32 percent are of school age, while 8 percent are of preschool age. (School age is defined in the United States as that cohort of the population that is eligible to attend elementary through high school.) Less than 2 percent of the Vietnamese population is 65 years or older. Of the total Vietnamese population, 55 percent is male, with a clustering of persons in their late teens. From the period 1975 to 1997, Southeast Asians, and specifically the Vietnamese, have remained the largest category of refugee arrivals to the United States. Approximately 4 percent of the total Vietnamese population has been in the United States one year or less. Fourteen percent of the total Vietnamese population has been in the United States three years or less. Approximately 34 percent of Vietnamese arrived in the United States in the peak fiscal year 1980-1981. Over time, the ethnic composition of the Southeast Asians has become more diversified, while the Vietnamese population has become
Vietnamese in Perspective
55
more ethnically and religiously homogenous (the majority of Christian Vietnamese and Hoa departed Vietnam between 1978 and 1980). Between 1975 and 1979, 90 percent of all Southeast Asian refugees were from Vietnam. Cambodian and Laotian refugees have arrived in much larger numbers since 1980 (in 1981, 72.3 percent of all Southeast Asian refugees were Vietnamese; 21.3 percent Laotian; and 6.4 percent from Cambodia). Since then, the statistics have remained relatively stable. During this 24-year period, Americans have been concerned over the large number of Southeast Asians immigrating to the United States. However, in the last ten years, with economic prosperity, this concern has declined. A comparison of arrivals indicates that the total Southeast Asian population is similar to that of the total Cuban immigrant population.
Demographic Settlement The United States resettlement policy for Southeast Asian refugees has been to spread them across the continental United States. Ostensibly, this is to prevent any one or several states from having to absorb too many immigrants into their economy and tax base. Over the years, a secondary migration process has occurred, especially to areas where an established ethnic community exists. In 1989, the states with the largest Vietnamese and other Southeast Asian communities were Texas, 66,200; Washington, 41,400; California, 40,400; New York, 32,100; Minnesota, 31,700; Pennsylvania, 28,600; Illinois, 28,400; Virginia, 23,100; and Oregon, 20,000. Recently, several states have changed their relative rank position due to secondary migration and recent arrivals. Currently, 39.5 percent of the entire Vietnamese community resides in California. Over a seven-year period from 1983 to 1990, however, the data show a declining trend in secondary migration to California. Conversely, Minnesota and Wisconsin increased their Vietnamese population by small fractions through secondary migration and new arrivals. Secondary migration trends are characterized by increased employment opportunities, the pull of an established ethnic community, more generous welfare benefits, better training opportunities, or a congenial climate. The federal government has identified the
56
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
geographic mobility of refugees by their Social Security numbers, which all refugees must acquire immediately after their arrival. Though little federal data are available, trends reported by resettlement agencies suggest that in the period from 1990 to 1999, Southeast Asian secondary migration was more evenly distributed over the continental United States as refugees became more psychologically comfortable in their adopted homeland. Vietnamese refugees, as well as other Southeast Asian refugees, initially became established in the cities and states of their sponsors or their sponsoring agencies. Early Vietnamese professionals who were able to re-establish their professional status, such as dentists or doctors, have, through secondary migration, moved to larger Vietnamese communities to acquire Vietnamese clients. For other professionals, it has not been so easy. In many instances, there are no equivalent positions, especially if the refugee was a career politician or member of the military. For these and many other early arrivals, there continues to be downward social mobility trends. However, recent reports to Congress state that many of the first and second wave refugees are establishing small businesses such as restaurants, boutiques, etc. In addition to employment concerns, religion or ethnicity may also be a consideration in secondary migration trends, especially for Catholic Vietnamese or the Hoa. Catholic Vietnamese almost always select Catholic family sponsors or Catholic voluntary agencies. The initial or secondary pull to various communities is partially due to the Vietnamese perception that certain communities have a higher tolerance of non-traditional American religions. In the case of the Hoa, there is a pull toward a Chinese community.
Vietnamese Participation in the Economy and Labor Force The vast majority of Southeast Asian refugees begin life in the United States on welfare or some other form of public assistance. It varies from state to state and often comes in the form of Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC).7 In spite of the cash assistance available, they consistently take employment as it becomes available, regardless of quality (Caplan, 1991). It is important to note that most family income was a combination of grants and wages from low level or part
Vietnamese in Perspective
57
time employment. Over a three-year period of time, refugees rely less on grants and more on wages until the outright grants are eliminated. For Vietnamese refugees, the period from 1983 to 1999 has been marked by a labor force participation of 37 percent to 40 percent for those 16 years or older, as compared to 66 percent for the United States population as a whole. These data are compiled from an annual random sampling of refugees arriving in the United States since 1984 by the Office of Refugee Resettlement. Each year, refugees are reinterviewed. Refugees who arrived since the previous year’s survey are sampled and added to the total survey population each year. The survey continuously tracks the progress of a randomly sampled group of refugees over their initial five years in the United States. Of those Vietnamese refugees in the labor force, approximately 92 percent were employed as compared to 95 percent for the U.S. population as a whole. For those who entered after 1982, labor force participation was considerably lower than the overall U.S. population, but after five years of residency, Vietnamese employment rate increased, but only slightly higher than the general population. These statistics include refugees who have only recently been admitted into the country and are still involved in various adjustment and settlement processes. It is important to note that the statistics of recent Vietnamese arrivals lowers the overall outcomes of the sampled group participating in the labor force. Surveys prior to March 1983 indicate that refugees are far more likely to be residing in self-sufficient households. When employment status was considered separately by year of entry, the results indicate the progress of earlier arrivals and the relative difficulty faced by more recent arrivals. For example, refugees arriving in 1988 had a labor force participation rate of 20 percent and an unemployment rate of 21 percent. Those refugees arriving earlier in the sample showed increased labor force participation. A major determinate in labor force participation and earnings was proficiency in the English language. However, in 1986, a survey of the median incomes of Vietnamese who arrived in the United States in 1975 indicated that Vietnamese incomes exceeded the medium income of the U.S. general population anywhere between several hundred to several thousand dollars, demonstrating their determination to regain their former socio-economic status.
58
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
The Refugee Act of 1980 and the Refugee Assistance Amendments of 1982 and 1986 stress employment and economic selfsufficiency as soon as possible after the refugees arrive in the United States. Achievement and economic self-sufficiency, as defined by the Refugee Resettlement Act, is “the employment potential of the refugees, including their skills, education, English language competence, health and desire for work; the needs that they as individuals and members of families have for financial resources, whether for food, housing, or child rearing, and the economic environment in which they settle, including the availability of housing and other local resources” (ORR, 1989). The total Southeast Asian refugee population labor force participation has remained relatively steady, with a slight declining trend during the period 1983-1990. The labor force participation rate was 55 percent in 1983 and 1984. The rate dropped to 44 percent in 1985, 42 percent in 1986, 39 percent in 1987, and to 37 percent in 1988, and finally 36 percent in 1989. Again, it is important to note that these statistics include the most recent arrivals. Social service agencies have reported that the most recent arrivals are less prepared for life in the United States, in terms of employment skills, education, and language ability, as compared to Southeast Asian refugees prior to 1984. However, reports of refugees who do participate in the labor force indicate a good record for finding and retaining jobs. The drop in labor force participation can be viewed more favorably in light of Vietnamese unemployment rates, which peaked in 1982 at 24 percent. By October 1984, this figure dropped to 15 percent, and during the next two years, remained steady at 16 percent. In 1987, the unemployment rate dropped to 12 percent and in 1988, to 8 percent. The unemployment rate trend is higher in the first year of entry and decreases rapidly over the next 3 to 4 years. For example, for 1985 arrivals, it decreased from 50 percent to 20 percent in 1986 and to 5 percent in 1988. In 1988, the arrival cohort showed an unemployment rate reduction from 32 percent in their initial year, to 11 percent in 1988. The 21 percent unemployment rate in their first year in the United States for the 1988 cohort is the best since the statistics have been calculated in 1981. Often, the types of jobs held by Vietnamese refugees are vastly different from the ones they held in Vietnam. Far more hold blue-collar
Vietnamese in Perspective
59
jobs or service sector jobs in the United States than in Vietnam. Survey data indicate a tripling of those in service occupations and a near doubling of those in skilled blue-collar occupations as compared to the proportion in similar jobs in Southeast Asia. Examples of skilled bluecollar jobs are maintenance work and factory work. There are many reasons cited by Southeast Asian refugees for nonparticipation in the labor force. Much depends on age and gender. For those under 25, the pursuit of an education is the overriding concern. For Southeast Asian refugees between 25 and 44 years old, family needs rank highest—college must be put aside for participation in the workforce. Health was the highest ranked concern for those over 44. Limited English ability was declared as well for those Southeast Asian refugees over 34. Health, a reason for not seeking work, increased in all categories except in the 16-24 age cohort. Among all Southeast Asian refugees for the period 1975-1989, the poverty rate ranges from 80 percent for those in the U.S. three months or less, to 30 percent for those in the United States three to four years. It is comparable to the poverty rate of other minorities in the United States. The statistics indicate that there is a continuing decrease in poverty with an increase in length of time in the United States (U.S. Census, 1990; U.S. Census 2002).
Vietnamese Adjustment The type of exile and settlement experienced by the Vietnamese in the United States is considered by some scholars to affect their ability to adapt (Lanphier, 1978). In addition to adjusting better psychologically in cities with large populations of Asians and especially other Vietnamese, Vietnamese families were found to adjust better culturally if they had a sustained relationship with an American host family (Stein, 1979). The type and amount of trauma experienced by refugees also has had an effect on their psychological ability to adapt. It is further argued that the type of resettlement experienced by the Vietnamese “establishes both a priority in the orientation of the refugees as well as the path of outcome which itself significantly determines other life chances” (Stein, 1979). The overall amount of changes experienced by
60
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
the refugees creates a considerable amount of anxiety. When gender is considered, it has been found that young men—required within the culture to find jobs to support their families—have experienced greater anxiety than women and older men remaining at home. This is also the case for young single women with families who enter the job market, and who do not have financial support from other family members. Adjustment and social integration of the Vietnamese has been noted to be better when they have been introduced into a heterogeneous community, which, by virtue of class and ethnic mix, is more flexible in facilitating adjustment and integration (Starr and Roberts, 1980). Some scholars have argued that the experiences of Vietnamese refugees have encouraged their children to take full advantage of the opportunities afforded them in the United States. Addressing this point, Andrada (1984) argues that Vietnamese students are adjusting rapidly to the American system of education. This is creating, however, tension and conflict within the family in the area of norms and values. Rapid adjustment of Vietnamese students has also been noted to alienate them from the larger Vietnamese community. In particular, changes in personal appearance and the acquisition of American peers is creating conflict as well. While Vietnamese students are adjusting culturally, it is not clear what specific group identity they are forming in schools. As stated earlier, it is further argued that Southeast Asian students are perceived by teachers to maintain good school habits because of their learning style. Teachers have passed students on good behavior even when they have failed academically (Goldstein, 1987b). Their most significant problems—only indirectly academic—are cited to be having no official records, heavily relying upon classroom lectures rather than texts, and shyness and inappropriate smiling. The literature on the Vietnamese suggests that their previous socio-economic background in Vietnam and their refugee related experiences have positively affected their desire to achieve success and social mobility here in the United States.
Vietnamese Academic Achievement8 Caplan, Choy, and Whitmore (1992) have examined, through quantitative analysis, the achievement of Vietnamese children currently living in California. They found that a 52.1 percent majority of
Vietnamese in Perspective
61
Southeast Asians fell within the B range (2.6 - 3.5 GPA) and 21 percent of the cohort fell within the A range (3.6 - 4.0 GPA). These percentages, however, only compare Vietnamese students to others in the same situation. Of all subjects tested among Southeast Asians, math scores are the highest, with 47 percent in the A range; in the general population the mean is B, or 3.18. If the Southeast Asian statistics were removed from the total California GPA (Grade-Point Average), the overall mean would drop to 2.63. Similarly, Vietnamese and other Southeast Asian students did well in other subjects such as physics and biology, or science subjects that required less English proficiency. Vietnamese and other Southeast Asians did least well in subjects that require more language proficiency such as history, social sciences, and English (Caplan, 1991). Out of the 3 Southeast Asian ethnic groups— Vietnamese, Laotian, and Cambodian—the Vietnamese maintained the highest academic performance. Similarly, across the United States, where large Vietnamese communities exist, administrators report excellence in Southeast Asian high school achievement with over-representation as valedictorians. Also, administrators report no suspensions, drug use, or serious misconduct (Caplan, 1991). The national data of standardized achievement tests, such as the Texas Achievement or the Iowa Achievement tests, demonstrate that Southeast Asians excel not only on the local level, but do as well or better than the national average. The vast majority, or 69.7 percent of Southeast Asians, fall within the second and third quartile (39.7 percent in the 3rd and approximately one-fifth, or 21.0 percent, fall in the fourth, or highest quartile) with only 9.3 percent in the first, or lowest quartile.9 Like the GPAs, the data demonstrate that Southeast Asians do exceptionally well in subjects which require less language proficiency. For example, the mean for Southeast Asians in national math scores is 72, indicating they do better than more than 71 percent of the total national cohort. The lowest ratings for Southeast Asians in the same subject are close to the national average. Further, they do least well in areas that require English proficiency, such as language and reading. However, these scores are also close to the national average. The average length of residency (time in the United States) for this cohort is three and a half years.
62
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
When ethnicity is taken into account, the mean GPA for Vietnamese is 3.7; the mean for the total Southeast Asian cohort (Vietnamese included) is 3.5 (Science, 3.08, math, 3.35); the mean for Southeast Asians (Vietnamese not included) is 3.18. The data suggest that the Vietnamese do better by .12 percent than the total Southeast Asian average.10 While it is unclear what gives Vietnamese students an additional advantage over other Southeast Asians, I am speculating that it is due to their previous relationship with schools in Vietnam. Cambodians and Laotians (primarily Hmong) have had a less-sustained relationship with formal education. In the case of the Hmong, the majority of students have had no experience with formal educational institutions at all. Traditionally, the ethnic Vietnamese have advanced through education, the Hoa have relied more so on commerce, and the Laotians—though having the lowest test scores of Southeast Asians, but still higher than the national average—have had the least continued contact with schools. They have spent the longest amount of time in the camps and have engaged only in pre-industrial agricultural economic activities in Laos. When religion is taken into account as an independent variable affecting achievement, it has been found that students with Confucian backgrounds have the highest GPA mean followed by those with Mahayanna Buddhist backgrounds. Catholics had the average mean among Southeast Asians, and Protestants and Theravada Buddhists had the lowest. No reliable difference exists in the GPA or CAT data when adjusted for gender. Similarly, no reliable difference exits in GPA or CAT scores when adjusted for socio-economic status. The vast majority in the sample come from lower or poor backgrounds, both in the United States and in their Southeast Asian homeland.11 Therefore, while reading and writing English proficiency was very low, it did not affect student ability significantly in GPA or CAT performance (Caplan, 1989, 1991). Researchers have also found that age and maturity of Southeast Asian refugee children was identical to that of the national population. They also found that younger children (grades 1-8) who experienced less trauma from departure and resettlement did not significantly alter the Southeast Asian achievement mean by maintaining higher GPA or CAT scores. This younger cohort, however, did do better than the total Southeast Asian cohort in language proficiency (Caplan, 1991).
Vietnamese in Perspective
63
Within the family, it is found that there is a positive relationship between the number of children in the household and academic performance. This is opposite of what is found among the American population in general. That is, “…the effects of family size and birth order on school achievement have shown a strong negative relationship: the greater the number of children, the lower the level of academic achievement, with the later born doing less well than the older siblings” (Caplan, 1991, p. 22). Academic aptitude tests demonstrate a 15% drop with the addition of each child in the family. Some scholars have argued that the social network of the family, within which parents and children form relationships, accounts for this result. Others posit that family size acts as a proxy for socio-economic standing, which includes limited home resources, overcrowded conditions, etc. Even among Vietnamese families with five or six children, all do as well or better. Furthermore, these findings among Vietnamese and other Southeast Asian families were not related to prior socio-economic status (SES) backgrounds in Southeast Asia. Children from formally low class backgrounds do as well in the United States as do those of the elite.
Local Vietnamese Population Profile As mentioned in chapter 1, the present study was conducted in a large Northeastern city which I call Nickel City, with an approximate population of 320,000. Vietnamese refugee families may be sponsored by an American host family, Catholic parish, or social agency. In Nickel City, the local sponsoring agency is Catholic Charities. Refugees, however, are preferably sponsored by family members or an American host family. The director of the local Catholic Charities commented that the local Catholic Diocese was one of the first in the country to respond to the needs of the Vietnamese refugees. However, there has been a decreasing number of willing American host families locally as well as nationally. There are few statistics kept by the local INS agency, as is the case on the national level. The only source of information is general and for the purpose of tracking individual whereabouts. More substantive information is available at the offices of Catholic Charities, but it is
64
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
mostly informal. The more official statistics are in the form of recording the number and ethnicity of clients served and are only for the purposes of keeping records for the federal government to maintain funding. The director took special care to point out that record keeping such as I was seeking was not required. Therefore, there are no records of age, gender, religion, or SES background available on the local population. The director of Catholic Charities did remark that the local population appeared to reflect the general trends recorded in national statistics. The only perceived difference is the high number of Catholics in the local group. This observation by the director of Catholic Charities is inconsistent with the interviews I have conducted with students at West Side High and with local Vietnamese community leaders who cite traditional Vietnamese ancestor worship or Buddhism as the principal religions of the local Vietnamese population. I can only infer that the purpose of the Vietnamese telling Catholic Charities that they are Catholic is because they anticipated preferential treatment. Currently, there are approximately 3,000 Vietnamese individuals in Nickel City. All of them have been placed by Catholic Charities. Vietnamese refugees have been arriving since the first wave and, like the national profile, continue to arrive. The Catholic Charities director reports that the local population increases by approximately 75 to 100 individuals per year. Eighty-five percent are family reunion cases, with about fifteen percent being single individuals with no family sponsor. Since 1989, there has been a marked increase in Amerasian refugees—the children of American servicemen and Vietnamese women. Over the past 10 years, there has been an attempt by the Vietnamese government to export Amerasians. In Vietnam, Amerasians were treated poorly because Vietnam was not a pluralistic12 society and because these mixed children were reminders of the war with the United States. However, a recent visit to Vietnam strongly suggests that the whole of Southeast Asia, Vietnam as well, is putting the past behind them and is looking forward to a new era of cooperation with the United States. Because of the special social difficulties experienced by these children (the children report cruel social treatment and overall marginalization from their communities) and their lack of a complete family in Vietnam (having a father is regarded as very important), I have chosen not to include them in the interviews presented in later chapters of this research. I am prepared to briefly state that the
Vietnamese in Perspective
65
Amerasian children I conversed with stated unequivocally that they were happier here in the United States than in Vietnam. During the period from 1998 to 2002, I have informally witnessed, through the complex process of immigration, a more inclusive Vietnamese bonding with Vietnamese Amerasian children as “real” Vietnamese, which appears to not occur in Vietnam itself. Most Vietnamese Amerasian children I met at West Side High lived with Vietnamese families here. A few lived with American parents. At Catholic Charities, Vietnamese refugees were counseled and assisted by social workers. All refugees initially received public support and were placed in housing. In addition, refugees were required to attend daily language and cultural classes where they learned English and day-to-day operational skills. Today, any newly arriving Vietnamese is likely to be part of an established family that can ease the transition. There is also a Buddhist temple with many services available to the community. The majority of Vietnamese have elected to relocate themselves on the city’s West Side in inexpensive housing. The city’s West Side is the most diverse area of the city in terms of race, ethnicity, and socioeconomic status. Here, the Vietnamese have blended with the rest of the population and have not experienced any adverse reactions from the locals. During the period 1985 to 1995, I rarely observed informal gatherings of Vietnamese refugees and Americans. The Vietnamese appeared to prefer to remain among themselves, interacting only when necessary. The issue of social interaction between Vietnamese and Americans will be discussed later. However, a casual stroll down some West Side Streets strongly suggests that some Vietnamese in Nickel City are slowly creating relationships with all types of Americans. A second clustering of Vietnamese refugees has appeared on the East Side, near little Polonia, where the population is also diverse and includes Polish families and African Americans. Near the university, several small Vietnamese businesses have opened and are catering to a predominantly university clientele. There is one very small additional clustering of Vietnamese much farther Northwest in Rockland. I have had no contact with this group. The city’s first Buddhist temple opened in little Polonia in the summer of 1999. Near the temple, 24 homes have been sold to Vietnamese so the families can be near the services
66
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
offered at the temple and adjacent community center. This section of the city has the most affordable housing. When I questioned the generally poor quality of housing I observed, the director of Catholic Charities and Vietnamese residents informed me that the Vietnamese would rather save money for future purposes than spend on short-term conveniences. Because the Vietnamese community is so small, and because there is no prior existence of an Asian community to which they could attach themselves in Nickel City, the Vietnamese in Nickel City have assimilated faster than Vietnamese in other cities where larger Asian communities exist, according to Catholic Charities. The director’s remarks on assimilation are in some disagreement with scholars mentioned earlier, which suggests that existing communities of immigrants greatly help the assimilation process. It should be noted that there is no section of the city for the Vietnamese that is comparable to Chinatown in New York City or San Francisco. The areas of Nickel City I have discussed are large geographic areas. The Vietnamese are spread across them. Occasionally an apartment building may have two or more Vietnamese families, but there is not one complete city block or section of town where they have clustered. The newly formed East Side community is the exception, but was not in existence when this research was begun. Although the population continues to increase in Nickel City, there is a secondary migration pattern to larger cities with larger Asian or Vietnamese communities. Approximately 20 to 35 young individuals leave Nickel City each year. The most frequently cited complaint by the Vietnamese refugees is the cold climate. However, local Vietnamese community leaders have commented that there now is a slow but increasing trend for young Vietnamese to return to Nickel City because of the difficulties of living in larger American cities, as well as the general perception by the Vietnamese that Nickel City is friendly and manageable. Over the past 20 years, the local Vietnamese community has created several social groups. They are predominantly for the purpose of celebrating Vietnamese customs and holidays, and to create a general feeling of community. The celebration of Tet is the most important event for the Vietnamese community. Because of the lack of a “Little Vietnam,” these social clubs are important to their sense of
Vietnamese in Perspective
67
well-being. In addition to celebrating, these gatherings are used for networking, electing leaders, and providing entertainment. In terms of education, the Vietnamese high school students are clustered predominantly in three neighborhood high schools—two on the city’s West Side and one in the Rockland area. West Side High maintains the city’s English as a Second Language curriculum, which is why the majority of Vietnamese students are there. School 36 on the city’s East side is where the majority of grammar school-age children attend school. Because of the ESL requirement, as well as a cross-town bussing pattern which came as a result of desegregation court cases, Vietnamese parents have little say in where their children go to school. If they were wealthy and well-informed, they could, of course, send them to a private school.
Summary In this chapter, I have discussed the diversity of the Vietnamese refugees who came to the United States during the period 1975 to 1990 in terms of socio-economic status and ethnicity. Many of these refugees, especially from the first wave, have experienced downward social mobility through underemployment. Regardless of previous training, many from this group were routed into blue-collar employment. Others from the later second and third waves were far less prepared to enter into a technologically advanced society and had few, if any, English language skills. Their economic adjustment was further complicated by the timing of their entry. The end of the 1970s marked the downturn of the second longest period of sustained economic growth in U.S. history, the first being the present one in the 1990s. For the American proletariat, the de-industrializing Reagan-Bush economy was lean and unable to accommodate and sustain large numbers of incoming aliens. What is now clear is that the Vietnamese often took jobs no American wanted. Despite rigorous social and economic impediments, Vietnamese refugees demonstrated their resolve to eliminate public assistance from family income and to enter in the labor market and participate in the economy. The mean national Vietnamese income is slightly higher than the national mean, with 30 percent (mostly new arrivals) living in
68
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
poverty. This figure is on par with African American and Latino poverty statistics. Scholarship by Caplan (1991) and Goldstein (1987b) document the vast majority of Vietnamese children are doing exceptionally well in terms of academic achievement. This is particularly so in subjects which require few language skills, such as science and math. Vietnamese children of low socio-economic backgrounds, both here and in Vietnam, are performing as well as those of the elites. Predictors of low achievement, such as large families or low rank order in families, are not positively correlated with poor performance, as is the case in the general American population. It is certain that Vietnamese families and their children are struggling to control their futures and relationships to society and the economy. Their continuing collective identity formation, thus far, has resisted economic marginalization. Like other Asians before them, they are well on their way to “model minority” status. However, the ways in which their identity is being formed is unclear. Unlike African Americans and Puerto Ricans, they do not have a long historical relationship of colonialism or internal colonialism with the United States to contend with and, by extension, a sustained familial relationship to American social movements. Vietnamese refugees, unlike Ogbu’s (1991) voluntary immigrants, are not clearly voluntary either. Ogbu posits that minority children from families that have voluntarily immigrated to the United States do better in schools than non-voluntary minorities such as African Americans and Puerto Ricans. The Vietnamese high school students in Nickel City’s West Side High mirror the national profile in their academic achievement and socio-cultural adjustment issues. It would be easy to assume that previous SES background characteristics or a sense of having “lost everything” bears a positive causal relationship to their academic success and presumed pro-school identity here in the United States, especially for children of the first wave. However, the basis of this assumption is unfounded in light of the same academic success of poor Vietnamese. For these reasons, I turn to the revelations and observations of Vietnamese youth to uncover the ways in which the school acts as a site for the production of identities.
CHAPTER 4
Inside West Side High School
Now, what can I tell you about my brilliant and beautiful students? Mr. Lee, Vietnamese teacher In the previous three chapters, I have examined the national and local profile of Vietnamese immigrants/refugees in the United States and in Nickel City. In the present chapter, I will explore how the school, as an institution, contributes to the identity construction of West Side High Vietnamese students through management of space and effective use of curriculum. The school, as a contributing institution to Vietnamese identity, will also be explored through teacher and administrator narratives. I will argue that the delegation of space by the school, and effective utilization and appropriation of this space, particularly the Vietnamese homeroom/study hall, contribute in very powerful ways to the consolidation of the Vietnamese as a group, and move them towards an orientation of achievement. In addition, the Vietnamese students and their teacher utilize West Side High as an agency of culture and skill acquisition. I also argue that the particular circumstances of West Side High School within the larger magnet system helps to position Vietnamese students in an especially favorable way with administrators and teachers. Throughout this chapter, I have found “free space” theory to be particularly helpful in understanding how the Vietnamese of West Side High manage space and “use” West Side High overall. “Free Space,” as explored by Boyte and Evans (1992), is a space or location created by individuals and groups, such as church groups, community programs, schools, block clubs, etc., where people enable a sense of control over one’s circumstances. They are most often places where a great deal of political work is done. In the case of the Vietnamese of West Side High 69
70
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
School, their creation of “free space” more closely resembles spaces explored by Fine and Weis in The Unknown City (1998) and Oldenburg in The Great Good Place (1989). Here, spaces are created to recuperate from harmful stereotypes and are locations where individuals may reenvision themselves and engage in a process of self-affirmation. West Side High is a neighborhood school which teaches general high school academics. However, Nickel City operates under the magnet system. That is, many schools in the city have a specialization such as performing arts, technical studies, or vocational studies including horticulture or cooking. To be accepted into magnet schools, students are selected primarily by lottery to balance gender and race. Other schools, like Honor’s High, also have an entrance exam requirement. As two guidance counselors and several teachers at West Side High state, a disproportionate amount of the city’s educational budget goes to magnet schools, with neighborhood schools like West Side High being underfunded. To be fair, in conversations with the members of the Board of Education, most disagree with parent and teacher perceptions that this is the case. Neighborhood schools, unlike magnet schools, have an open enrollment policy and are attended primarily by students living in the community who have not attempted to enter a magnet school, or have not been accepted into one. The neighborhood surrounding West Side High is primarily poor, with many immigrant families, creating a transient student body with special needs. As such, as one high-ranking Board of Education member remarked in a private communication, the magnet system, while balancing race and gender, essentially siphons off students who are stable, and thus better prepared, segregating students by social class. In the words of one disillusioned history teacher “…(T)he magnet system takes all the best students, leaving just the academic trash for us.” Although this was not the expressed opinion of most teachers and administrators, the perception that West Side High students were not the best and the brightest was widespread. For some teachers, this led to apathy towards the teaching profession and teaching at West Side High in particular. However, teacher and administrator attitudes toward the Vietnamese students were decidedly positive. Scholarship, such as Making and Molding Identities: Negotiating Family, Peers, and School by Ann Locke Davidson, et al. (1996),
Inside Wes Side High School
71
posits that ESL students are often marginalized and isolated. ESL students at West Side High, however, were often viewed as the exception to teacher perceptions that many students were lazy and inept. ESL students are viewed as hard workers and studious when compared to American students. Vietnamese students, in particular, are perceived as hard working, good students and, as the librarian stated, “the bright spot in a school where most students are dull.” This statement becomes more compelling when considering the Valedictorians and Salutatorians of the last 5 years: 1999, Hispanic and Russian; 1998, Vietnamese and Indian; 1997, Indian and Vietnamese; 1996, Vietnamese and Vietnamese; 1995, Hispanic and Vietnamese. Due to the high concentration of students with a foreign language as their first language, West Side High is designated as the city’s principal ESL (English as a Second Language) high school. Any high school student in the city with ESL needs would likely attend West Side High, though the majority of immigrant families already live in the neighborhoods nearby. Due to their ESL needs, most Vietnamese students, regardless of where they live, attend West Side High. As a singular, ethnic language minority, the Vietnamese constitute the second largest culturally different, non-native English-speaking population after Puerto Ricans. When I began this study, the Vietnamese student body was 20. By the time I concluded my fieldwork, the Vietnamese student population increased to 52. At the time the fieldwork was conducted, other ethnic language groups, such as Eastern Europeans, collectively constituted 10 students; Japanese, 2; Cambodians, 3; and Laotians, 9; The West Side High student enrollment, however, poses some problems for the school administration. Because so many of the students are poor and transient, West Side High has the city’s worst retention and graduation record in the city and one of the worst in the state. The previous statement was corroborated by one Board of Education member, one vice principal, and one assistant vice principal. Often, students come to West Side High without appropriate transfer records or no records at all, as is often the case with foreign refugee students, leaving student placement at the discretion of the administrators. In 1999, there were 61 students that had never been in school before. All of these were students from underdeveloped
72
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
countries. Because so many of the students come with English language deficiencies, many students do very poorly on the Regents English Language Arts Exam, a six hour test that examines reading, writing, and speaking abilities. This exam is especially difficult for the foreign students. The principal was consistently in the position of trying to keep the state from placing the school under official state scrutiny, or SURR (School Under Regents Review). Near the end of my study, the principal briefly lost the battle with the state auditors and turned over the school to state review, creating very negative local headlines. For many years, however, the principal was successful in keeping West Side High out of the papers and out of the hands of the state. In a number of ways, the Vietnamese students helped considerably by maintaining high academic standards and keeping the school’s success record higher than it would have been without them. Because of this, the administration appeared to be especially receptive to Vietnamese needs and was especially accommodating to Vietnamese admissions.
Creating Intellectual “Free Space” Within the Institution West Side High has a very tough citywide reputation. I expected to find metal detectors at the door and to be frisked upon entering the building. I also expected to see hall fights and massive amounts of graffiti on the walls. Instead, I walked right in and found a clean, rather orderly school. West Side high had the typical bells ringing to signal the beginning and end of classes, the usual hall monitors who cajolingly urged the straggler to hurry, and teachers and administrators who knew the first names of many students. There was a relaxed and familiar quality to the building. I was surprised to find that many neighborhood adults I personally knew were teacher’s aides, personnel, or just volunteers. Several people waved to me and greeted me by my first name. At least two neighbors, however, were deeply chagrined that I was not focusing my work on Latinos. One neighbor, Ana Maria, was especially vocal and disappointed with me. She commented, “Craig, Craig, the Vietnamese again. You should be here working and studying with us. We need your help a lot more than the Vietnamese do.” This was one of a number of remarks on my first day that suggested that the Vietnamese at West Side High were perceived as a privileged group.
Inside Wes Side High School
73
After reporting to the main office, one of the clerks accompanied me to see Mr. Lee in the Vietnamese homeroom and study hall (as room 210 was known), despite other ethnic groups in the room. I was introduced to Mr. Lee, a very well-educated teacher from South Vietnam, and also a leader of the local Vietnamese community. I was instructed by Mr. Lee to sit on the left side of the room. After observing the Southeast Asian homeroom, I suspected that I was asked to sit there with the non-Vietnamese Southeast Asians so as not to disturb the Vietnamese students in any way. The following observation/ description of the Vietnamese homeroom explores and helps situate the Vietnamese experience in the school. For the first two weeks, I spent my time solely in this room before following each student around on his or her daily classroom rounds. It is important to note, this room was also used by the Vietnamese as a study hall. If any of the Vietnamese students had a free period, they went to Mr. Lee’s room where they would study and get special assistance. Observation, Vietnamese Homeroom/Study Hall13 The Vietnamese homeroom is a very large room that easily can accommodate over 100 students. It is so large that there are two entrances. I am surprised to find that this is not just the Vietnamese homeroom but the Southeast Asian homeroom. In addition to 20 Vietnamese students, there are also 12 other Southeast Asian students: 9 Hmong from Laos and 3 from Cambodia. The homeroom/classroom is essentially divided into two rooms. The Vietnamese sit on the right side of the room and the other Southeast Asians sit on the left side of the room where I am sitting. There is a very large aisle down the center giving the distinct impression that there are two separate spaces. The desks on the Vietnamese side are very ordered and are facing the front toward Mr. Lee’s desk. The desks on the left are a bit half-hazardly placed (they appear to be moved around a lot), but also face the front of the room toward the desk. I was not introduced to the Southeast Asian teacher’s aide. The room is surrounded with blackboards. There are many lessons written on the board in English and in
74
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth Vietnamese on the right side of the room. The boards are blank on the left. There are many tall windows, all located on the right side of the room, but there are only two on the left side, making the right side of the room bright and cheerful, while the left side of the room (the Laotian and Cambodian side) is primarily illuminated by two fluorescent light bulbs from the ceiling. One of the bulbs is burning out and is giving an annoying flickering. Overall the left side where I and the other Southeast Asian students are sitting, is somewhat gloomy. The Vietnamese side is decorated with colorful pictures of beautiful scenic views of Southeast Asia and pictures of beautiful Vietnamese girls dressed in native costume with fans and looking coquettish. Also on the right side are various big plants which give the Vietnamese side of the room a homey and inviting quality. The left side of the room is totally undecorated. As a matter of fact, there are many folding tables pushed against the walls. The tables are filled with a disorderly assortment of packages and empty boxes. There are several piles of boxes and papers leaning menacingly to one side and about to topple over. There is an assortment of stuff pushed under the tables as well. All of this disarray gives the left side of the room the appearance of a storage facility. Observation, Southeast Asian Homeroom/Study Hall …(I)t has just occurred to me that there are a great many reference books, such as dictionaries, thesauri, encyclopedias, in the room. There are several bookcases filled with a large assortment of academic books. There are also five computers in the room. All of these learning aids are on the Vietnamese side of the room. There are no such learning materials on the left side of the room where the other Southeast Asian students are sitting. (…) It is now after class and I am looking at all the books and dictionaries in the room. There are 10 English/Vietnamese translation dictionaries in the room, but no English/Hmong or English/Cambodian dictionaries.
Inside Wes Side High School
75
Observation, Southeast Asian Homeroom …(I) have been here now for two weeks. The Southeast Asian homeroom is not used in the traditional way that I remember homerooms being used as study time by individuals or relaxation time before ending class. There are twelve Vietnamese students in the room during this period. Ten of them have grouped together in two groups of five. One group is a tutor/study group for math, and the other group is a tutor/study group for English. Different individuals in the group take the lead, depending on the problem. Mr. Lee moves between groups to monitor progress, and answer questions and give directives. He also goes to the remaining individuals who are working on separate assignments and asks questions and gives responses. This is all done very quietly in Vietnamese. On the other side of the room are the other Southeast Asians. There are six of them in the room now. They are sitting individually at their desk. Four of the six are just talking to each other while the remaining two appear bored and unoccupied. (A)bout half an hour into the period, one conversation between two Hmong becomes a little loud. Mr. Lee first scolds them in English, telling them they are talking too loud and reminding them that some students want to study and learn. He then walks over to the Cambodian teacher’s aide and says something to her in an inaudible tone of voice. She looks disgruntled but is not confrontational. (…) In consideration of space and convenience, the administration of West Side High placed all Southeast Asian students in the same room. It simply made sense. When I first began this study there were 32 Southeast Asian students in all. Everyone easily fit into this one homeroom. However, what the administration did not take into consideration is that the Vietnamese, Cambodians, and Laotians have a long history of mutual antagonism in Southeast Asia. There are also considerable cultural differences. Historically, Vietnam has always been wealthier and more powerful, with a long list of military aggressions against their neighbors. While the mutual experiences of
76
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
immigration would appear to give all three groups a common purpose, placed in the same room, it created an atmosphere of exclusion of Laotians and Cambodians by the Vietnamese. In fact, the entire Southeast Asian homeroom was set up to the total benefit of the Vietnamese, and to the exclusion of the other Southeast Asians. This arrangement was not missed by the other Southeast Asian students or their teacher’s aide. The following excerpt from an interview with Ms. Wacharamontri, the teacher’s aide from Laos, confirms this point. C.C.: Is there anything that you would change here at West Side High? Ms. Wacharamontri: Yes there is. I would have my students out of this room. C.C.: Why is that? Ms. Wacharamontri: You have been here over a week. I know that you can see what is going on. The Vietnamese students have everything and my poor students, they have nothing. C.C.: I shouldn’t be saying this, but why don’t you do something about it. I mean, why don’t you have a talk with Mr. Lee and if that doesn’t solve the problem, why don’t you talk to some people in the administration, and if that doesn’t work why not speak to someone at the Board of Education? Ms. Wacharamontri: It’s not that easy. Mr. Lee is a tenured teacher here, and he knows many people and he is very powerful. He was a well-respected teacher and leader even in Vietnam. The Vietnamese are the only foreign group of students that have their own teacher. All the rest of us are teacher’s aides and we don’t have any say in what is going on. And as far as Mr. Jackson (the principal) is concerned, he needs the Vietnamese. C.C.: What do you mean?
Inside Wes Side High School
77
Ms. Wacharamontri: They’re (West Side High) always in trouble. They always have problems with the Board of Education and the state. Students don’t do well on the state exams and there is a low graduation rate here. The school always has problems. The Vietnamese, they are doing very well, and it helps to keep the school out of trouble. C.C.: Why do you think that the Vietnamese do so well? Ms. Wacharamontri: Because they are aggressive. They are very aggressive. They are the most aggressive people in Southeast Asia. (…) Also, they have an extensive education system in Vietnam, and they know how to use the system. They know how to use the American education system better than the Americans do. Ms. Wacharamontri’s conversation with me was filled with a great deal of emotion. Her reference to “them” (Vietnamese) rather than “us” (Cambodians and Laotians) is telling. She viewed herself and her students as outside of mainstream school decisions and activities. It was clear that she was deeply disturbed that non-Vietnamese Southeast Asians were not being treated as well as the Vietnamese. Every conversation I had with her during the year was filled with great disappointment and frustration that she could not do anything about it. The Laotian and Cambodian students themselves, by comparison to the Vietnamese, appear very timid generally, but seemed even more so when having any interactions with Vietnamese students or the Vietnamese teacher. The following observation helps clarify this point: Observation, Vietnamese Homeroom/Study Hall This is the fourth period and Kim, a student, and I have returned to Mr. Lee’s room for a study hall. It’s very quiet as usual. There are three groups of Vietnamese students studying collectively, Mr. Lee is walking around the room offering support and answering questions. There are four Vietnamese students alone at their own desks with books open and writing. There is a new teacher’s aide here, also from Vietnam. He is
78
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth working with one of the Vietnamese students. (…) From time to time, one or more of the Vietnamese students gets up and walks to the reference books or support materials, and takes what he or she needs and returns to the group or to their desk. On the left side of the room there are four other Southeast Asian students, three Hmong and one Cambodian. One of the Hmong students appears asleep, another is leaning forward on folded arms and is staring at the Vietnamese side, and another Hmong student is rapidly leafing through one of her textbooks. The Cambodian student appears to be just staring out of the window and looking very bored. The teacher’s aide from Laos is at her desk and is doing some paperwork. (…About fifteen minutes into the period), one of the Hmong males raises his hand but is not noticed by the teacher’s aide, who is engrossed in paperwork. Exhausted, he is holding up his arm with his other hand. A minute or so later, he lowers his hand and begins scribbling in his notebook. I noticed that Mr. Lee sees the Cambodian student trying to get the teacher’s aide’s attention, but he continues to work and talk with the group of Vietnamese students. Observation, Vietnamese Homeroom (…) Today the Cambodian teacher’s aide is out, but there are three Vietnamese adults in the room: Mr. Lee, Mr. Bow, and a Vietnamese college intern from State College. The Vietnamese side of the room is very busy studying and using the computers and reference materials to do their work. The Cambodians and Laotians are at their desks working individually, and two are napping at their desks. (About one half hour into the period)… (O)ne of the Cambodian males raises his hand to be recognized, but is not. After about five minutes he gets up and walks over to the Vietnamese side, and begins to use one of the unused computers. Two Vietnamese males working on the nearest computer emphatically state that the computer is going to be used, the place is already taken. A few more things are said that I cannot hear. The Cambodian student defers to the two Vietnamese, and quietly walks away, resuming his place at his desk.
Inside Wes Side High School
79
Over the course of an academic year, I have never seen a Cambodian or Laotian student either using the computer or using any of the instructional support material on the Vietnamese side of the room. It appeared to be the exclusive domain of the Vietnamese. Also, the Vietnamese students in the homeroom/study hall, though always polite to the teacher and the aides, regularly acted more independently and assertively by walking around the room, creating study groups, or using the support materials. By comparison, the other Southeast Asian students always appeared to be more timid and shy, even when interacting with Vietnamese students. Although all of the Southeast Asian students were in the same homeroom, it functioned as two separate ones: a Vietnamese room and a Cambodian/Laotian one. The Vietnamese teacher and aides also did not see it as their responsibility to encourage the other Southeast Asians in the room to work hard, or to assist them with their work. When I questioned Mr. Lee on this point, I was told that the Cambodians and the Laotians were the responsibility of the Laotian teacher’s aide. The responsibility to arrange and decorate the left side of the room and acquire teaching support materials was also the responsibility of the Laotian aide. The privileges of the Vietnamese students were also understood by the Laotian and Cambodian students. On the first day I began my fieldwork, I sat behind a Hmong student on the left side of the room. He looked delighted to see me, and shortly after I was settled, he turned to me and asked what I was doing there. I responded by saying that I was there to study the Vietnamese. His entire facial expression changed and he said: “Everyone is interested in the Vietnamese, no one is ever interested in us.” I felt very bad about this remark and felt that I could have answered that I was there to study Southeast Asians. Over the course of an academic year, I have accumulated nearly 100 Southeast Asian homeroom observations of varying lengths, which have essentially the same content. The Vietnamese within the larger Southeast Asian homeroom were both numerically dominant, and appeared privileged by comparison to the others by maintaining a very orderly and attractive space, while the Laotians and Cambodians could not. This was accomplished my Mr. Lee’s successful marshaling of all instructional and support materials to the right side of the room, and the
80
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
seemingly intentional use of the left side of the room as storage by Mr. Lee and his students. Because of the above, the Vietnamese experience homeroom very differently from other Southeast Asians or any other group in the school. The Vietnamese used their space as an instructional time and tutorial session. African Americans and Latinos, for example, were dispersed throughout the school and grouped according to grade level. Other ESL students were kept together and were assigned a teacher’s aide, but did not have large enough numbers to have an entire homeroom to themselves. For example, all Eastern Europeans shared the same homeroom along with Yemenite students and some others. In the case of American minorities such as African Americans or Latinos, the school could not group them together because their numbers were too large, and to do so would violate the rules of integration. Since most of the teachers in the school were white, most homerooms had a white teacher, along with various teacher’s aides. The point is, no other student group, as far as I could see, was given their own space or had a teacher who was looking out solely for their benefit, as was the case with the Vietnamese. During an interview with Mr. Lee, I asked him about this. He responded by saying that it simply made sense that the Vietnamese were grouped together in this fashion; instead of grouping the Vietnamese and others together according to class rank (such as freshman, sophomore, etc.), he presented this as a viable option to the administration. Regardless of how this arrangement came about, it worked well for the Vietnamese. By doing so, the Vietnamese students and their teacher effectively created a “free space” within the larger institution.
Accommodating Special Needs West Side High was not necessarily viewed by the Vietnamese staff or students as a rigorous site for learning; rather, it was viewed primarily as a site for skills and culture acquisition, and specifically, as a site for learning the English language. I had many conversations with Mr. Lee, the aides, and the students, which suggested that West Side High did not compare favorably with the academic rigors of schools in Vietnam. However, it was viewed by staff and students as an important place to learn American culture, acquire English language skills, and prepare
Inside Wes Side High School
81
the students for “moving up.” The following excerpt from an interview with Mr. Lee, the Vietnamese teacher, makes this clear. C.C.: Tell me, Mr. Lee, what your impressions are of West Side High? Mr. Lee: My impressions are from the point of view and the interest I have with my students. They are pleased to be in an American school. It is a big deal for them, you know, to come up and get help here. Especially the language. They need the ESL program in this school in order for them to go up in the world. Here they learn what they need, especially in English and culture. They need this before they enter the work market. And this school is a very special setting, especially for immigrant(s). Also, my students are not singled out (as unusual) or isolated, because there are many different foreign students in this school from many countries. So what I know is that this is very important and very useful. This is a very important setting for them to start their new life here and study new language. C.C.: If there was something that you could change here, what would that be? Mr. Lee: Just one thing? I would change many things. Not just one thing. I would want to change the curriculum and the building. C.C.: The curriculum and the building? Mr. Lee: First of all, the curriculum is not so difficult here like in Vietnam. I think that it is better in Vietnam. It needs more science here, better curriculum. My students, they have this already. Although West Side High was not necessarily viewed as a rigorous site for learning, it played a very important role for Vietnamese teens. Here, students learn how to function in the United States and how to
82
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
speak English. Here, they prepared themselves for their futures in higher education and for employment. As Mr. Lee points out, it is a perfect place for the Vietnamese to learn these skills. At West Side High, the majority of the city’s Vietnamese teens are grouped together to learn essential skills in a controlled environment. It is also a place where they are not completely conspicuous, as there are many other ethnic/language groups there as well and difference is better tolerated. Most of all, it is an environment where Vietnamese values are present and articulated through Mr. Lee and the other Vietnamese teacher’s aides. During a very critical point in their lives, Vietnamese teens have the guiding and nurturing presence of people from the community that are genuinely interested in them and look out for their interests. While the presence of Mr. Lee is recognized throughout the school, nowhere is he more effective than in the homeroom. Other ways in which the Vietnamese homeroom was used effectively to accommodate Vietnamese student needs was the extra English taught by Mr. Lee during study hall. Technically, study hall is a free period where students individually use time to catch up on other classes or do homework. As discussed above, the Vietnamese homeroom often was used for this purpose through collective or group studying. Mr. Lee, however, also used this period to teach important language and cultural skills. In the beginning of the school year, these language and culture lessons were more prevalent, but did occur periodically throughout the entire academic year. The following are some examples: Observation, Vietnamese Study Hall The Vietnamese side of the room has a stand with a large writing pad. This is placed at the head of the space next to Mr. Lee’s desk. On it were written the following words or phrases: Hello Good evening How are you? Please
Good morning Good night I am fine May I have
Good afternoon Good bye Thank you Excuse me
The lecture/tutorial consisted of the entire group saying and pronouncing the words together as Mr. Lee pointed to
Inside Wes Side High School each work or phrase. The aides and advanced students moved around the room to listen to the student’s pronunciation and would make individual corrections. This was done several times. Students were required to write these words or phrases in their notebooks along with a personal guide to pronunciation. After the pronunciation tutorial, Mr. Lee again translated the words into Vietnamese and began explaining the appropriate time to use them according to American customs. For example, Mr. Lee remarked that it is always polite to say thank you whenever anyone does something for you or gives something to you. He also explained that before 12:00 noon, one always greeted someone with good morning and after noon greeted them with good afternoon. Good evening was used for greeting someone after five and good night for ending an evening. Each work or phrase was explained in the same fashion. After this was done and students took notes, the group practiced the lesson on each other several times. Observation, Vietnamese Homeroom Today Mr. Lee is preparing the students for common interactions with Americans. He pulls out his pointer and stand and begins to write common phrases and words down. How much is this? Do you have something less expensive? How do I get to… How much is the fare to… I am lost. Can you help me? Where can I find… May I ask…? I am looking for… Where is the men’s/ladies’ room? Students were asked to write the phrases in their notes along with a translation and pronunciation guide. Together, the class was asked to say and pronounce the phrases out loud while the aides walked around the room and listened to the individual students. If a student badly mispronounced a word or phrase, the aide stopped and worked with the student until it was done correctly. After, students were asked to break down into groups and try the phrases out on one another with appropriate phrase endings, such as “How do I get to school?” This
83
84
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth continued for about 30 minutes and then Mr. Lee put new words and phrases on the board. The students were asked to study them for tomorrow.
All Vietnamese homeroom lessons were not always language oriented. Mr. Lee also did such practical things as teach the students about money. Observation, Vietnamese Homeroom Today during third period study hall, Mr. Lee asks all new students to come to the front of the class and stand around his desk. Other students are to use study hall for studying. He then places on his desk several types of American currency including a one dollar bill, a five dollar bill, ten dollar bill, and a twenty dollar bill, as well as an assortment of change. Each student is asked to come up around the desk and examine each piece of currency. Mr. Lee then explains in Vietnamese what each piece of currency is and what it is worth and what the students are to look for on the bill to determine what it is. After about ten minutes, he picks up a five dollar bill and asks, “If you buy something for $2.50, how much money should you get back? What are some of the ways you will get your change?” Several students raise their hand. He picks one student. Andy responds, “I should get two one dollar bills and two quarters.” Mr. Lee approves and asks again. Another student raises her hand and gives other possible ways to get the right change. This lesson continues for the duration of the period. In addition to the language/culture classes that Mr. Lee conducted, the Vietnamese homeroom was also used as a miniature guidance center. The bookshelves were filled with brochures and applications to local colleges and the university, in addition to ones around the state and elsewhere. This was the only room in which I noticed college application material. Other students acquired guidance material, including college applications and information, in the guidance office. Beginning around the end of November, the aides were instructed to pass out brochures and applications. By May, all juniors and seniors
Inside Wes Side High School
85
were regularly filling out applications in the room, often asking Mr. Lee and the aides for assistance with questions. The following observation is one of many during the school year where students are engaged in applying for college during study hall. Observation, Vietnamese Study Hall, Fourth Period During the past week, Mr. Lee has asked all juniors and seniors in study hall to sit near the front of the class near his desk. He begins by giving them all a lecture on how important it is for them to attend college or the university. These are the ways they will get ahead in life. Furthermore, the community and their family expect all of them to work hard and be successes. He passes out applications to two local institutions of higher education and tells them that certain fields, like nursing, are specialties that are available only at certain schools. If they know what they want to major in, he recommends that they speak to him after school and then follow this meeting with an appointment with the guidance counselor. Each student is expected to fill out at least three applications. There are more applications on the tables surrounding the room if they make a mistake or want applications to other places. If they have any problems with any question, they are expected to raise their hand and he, or one of the aides, will come around and assist them. Part of some applications is a personal biography or some other essay. Seniors are to begin these essays, and be finished with them by Monday of the following week. Students are told to submit them and he will check them for mistakes or suggestions. The above observations explore how the Vietnamese have used their study hall, and West Side High, as a location for learning basic necessities to function in American society, such as specific simple language skills and money exchanges. It is also used as a preparation time for application to higher education for advanced students. It is interesting that both of these skills are available at other times in the school. Basic language skills are taught in bilingual education, and
86
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
college applications and general guidance are available in the student guidance office. Mr. Lee, however, does not wish to leave learning these important skills to chance for his students. When I asked him about this, he responded by saying that “It is my job to make sure my students get ahead. I don’t want to leave my work up to other people.” The following guidance office observation helps to support his position. Observation, Guidance Office There is a great deal of activity here. People are coming and going at all times, students and staff. There are a great deal of books and information on the shelves on college applications and financial aid. There is more stuff available on careers in the Navy, Army, and the Marines as well as the Coast Guard and the National Guard. The Army band is playing in the auditorium right now. Many of the posters are of local schools but predominantly of business schools, all two-year institutions. There is nothing on the university or state college. I have been sitting here for over an hour, and there is no guidance counselor. I have several observations similar to this where I have sat for at least an hour or more observing in the waiting room of the guidance office. During these times, office hours were posted and a counselor was scheduled to be there but, in fact, no one was there. The availability of printed material and kinds of material tells a great deal. It was clear that guidance was encouraging many students to pick a career in the military as an alternative to higher education. The higher education material that is available is mostly for two-year institutions that teach business or skills such as secretarial work and general office work. Given the ambitions of the Vietnamese community, these options would not be considered the optimum choices. Mr. Lee justified his additional work in guidance by explaining that the Vietnamese needed extra assistance because of culture and language. Throughout my fieldwork, it was suggested by Mr. Lee many times that because the Vietnamese are recent arrivals, they require an intensive amount of work to bring them up to speed. His language in this statement is very telling. The Vietnamese were clearly Mr. Lee’s domain. Unlike many of the other teachers, Mr. Lee was a member and
Inside Wes Side High School
87
leader of the Vietnamese community, and expressed deep personal obligation to his students. It is easy to understand that, in addition to his personal interest, he is easily held personally accountable by this relatively small community of people. Both his credibility and position within the community are at stake. It also suggests his own personal lack of trust (and perhaps that of the entire Vietnamese community) in the ability of the school to get the job done right. This is a powerful statement about the community and personal accountability, and the particular attitudes of their students towards school. The Vietnamese homeroom poses some interesting questions on how a group can, within an institution, carve out “free space.” The grouping of all Vietnamese into one homeroom was orchestrated, to some extent, by Mr. Lee. All of the Vietnamese students were very supportive and enthusiastic about having this arrangement, and were generally aware that other groups did not have a similar one. Free Spaces, as explored by Boyte and Evans (1992), speaks of geographic locations or communities, places in public institutions, or imagined spaces where individuals gather for personal and collective work. Fine and Weis (1998, 2000) and Fine, Weis, Centrie, and Roberts (2000) further refine and explore this theoretical construct, identifying through their fieldwork locations within the community setting where individuals, faced with shifting and often disappearing opportunities for traditional communities, carve out locations of “recuperation, resistance and home.” Examining these communities and constructions, Fine, Weis, Centrie, and Roberts (2000) state: They are not just a set of geographical/spatial arrangements, but theoretical, analytical and spatial displacements—a crack, a fissure, a place to come together and restore sanity, and to imagine possibilities. Individual dreams collective work, and critical thoughts are smuggled in and then re-thought. Not rigidly bounded by walls/fences, the spaces often are corralled by a series of imaginary borders where community intrusion and state surveillance are not permitted. These are spaces where offensive social stereotypes can be contested; where troubling questions of parenting, schooling, and faith can be posed without recrimination. (p. 10)
88
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
The Vietnamese were the largest Asian group at West Side High and were the first Asian group to come in large numbers to the city, but overall, they constituted a small minority. Their newness and relatively small numbers often made the Vietnamese targets for harassment, or perceived harassment, by other students. The three major racial/ethnic groups at West Side High—African Americans, Latinos, and whites— viewed the Vietnamese as outsiders. Acquaintanceships with nonVietnamese students were rare for the Vietnamese. Further, the ESL program in which all of them were enrolled also contributed to their alienation from the rest of the student population; grouping them in certain classes reinforced their image as culturally and linguistically different. Similarly, Ann Locke Davidson, et al., in Making and Molding Identities (1996) remarks on the silencing, marginalization, and social segregation of ESL students. Historically, ESL “…conveys the message that the knowledge and skill from students’ ESL work is less highly valued and somehow different than that of the world of their European American classmates” and “…that adults so often underestimate, so often down scale their cognitive expectations, rather than provide a scaffolding appropriate to high-level cognitive engagement” (Davidson, et al., 1996, pp. 85-86). Although this type of marginalization was the same for all nonEnglish-speaking/ESL students at West Side High, the Vietnamese were able to counter these liabilities, to some extent, by effectively using the homeroom as a location of resistance and recuperation, or a “free space.” Here, the dominant group was the Vietnamese, creating a safe haven. It was a place where unflattering Vietnamese stereotypes could be soothed and challenged. It was the one place in the school where the Vietnamese had a majority experience. Further, Mr. Lee provided very effective leadership, advancing the interests of the group with the school administration and with the Board of Education. He also was a very effective presence in the larger community, thus reinforcing Vietnamese cultural values and ensuring that the ideals of hard work and academic achievement were followed. Similarly, the Vietnamese appropriated West Side High curriculum, using it to their advantage. Along with the their use of the homeroom, the Vietnamese created and maintained an effective “free space.”
Inside Wes Side High School
89
Knowledge or Skills? Vietnamese students, especially in their homeroom/study hall, were engaged and challenged by the teacher and the aides. This was markedly different from what I observed with other students and teachers. The Vietnamese certainly used West Side High to accommodate their needs to acclimate to American culture within a controlled environment. While following the Vietnamese students on their daily routines, I had the opportunity to observe many courses at West Side High. Most courses took the form of information reviews, rather than engaging students in the production of knowledge. In other words, teachers gave contradictory messages. While school knowledge was highly prized by teachers and administrators alike, teachers adhered more to the form of knowledge rather than the content. Although it was impossible for me to observe all classes at West Side High, I am confident that this was the norm rather than the exception. In Working Class Without Work (Weis, 1990), Weis posits that Freeway School, as a working class school, maintains a contradictory attitude toward knowledge. That is, teachers, administrators, and students all agree that education is important to get a job, but in fact, knowledge is “pre-packaged” and delivered for form rather than for its substance or for the importance of its content. The entire purpose of school becomes an exercise to get through exams and to get a diploma. As analyzed by Weis, “teachers tend to adhere to the form rather than the substance of education, and knowledge tends to be flat and prepackaged. This is reminiscent of curriculum described by Linda McNeil in her high school study, and Jean Anyon in her study of knowledge as distributed through the working class elementary school” (Weis, 1990, p. 81). In fact, knowledge at West Side High is generally not managed any differently. Like Freeway, knowledge at West Side High appears as “pre-packaged” and low level. Lectures, especially in areas such as history or social studies, are similar to a string of note cards, where teachers deliver a series of unconnected dates and events to cover a topic without any analysis, little background, and no critique. Students generally do not ask questions, and no questions are posed by teachers. Like Freeway, the ultimate purpose of the class is to get students to respond correctly to answers on finals, thereby passing
90
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
students and ultimately moving them on to the next level or graduation. The teachers’ focus on exam-taking was so prevalent that it became a major theme in my observations. Because it was so much a part of the curriculum, I asked one of the vice principals about it. At first, Ms. Gomez began by explaining that demonstrating to students how to take an exam was part of effective teaching. After the interview was over and the tape recorder shut off, she remarked, as did many others, that “West Side High for many years has had a bad state record in graduating students. If we don’t do this, the school’s graduation record would undoubtedly be worse. Students here have to be told exactly what to do or they won’t do it. It’s just the way it is.” Interestingly, her comment reveals more concern for the school than for the students. I followed each Vietnamese student around on his or her daily class rounds and found each of their classes to be largely similar in pedagogical technique. The following observation explores my earlier point that knowledge at West Side High is “pre-packaged.” Observation, American History, Period 3 The lesson today is a continuation of a series of lectures on the Civil War. Students are told what to put in their notes. “Write in your notes that the Civil War began in 1861. It was a dispute between the northern states and the southern states. Then put in that in 1862, the situation worsened and the fighting continued. The following year, Lincoln freed the slaves. That was in 1863. The war continued until 1865 when Lincoln was shot and killed. Those are the most important dates and events connected to them. Be sure to put these in your notes. These dates are going to really be important on the Regents exams. Be sure you get them right.” (…) The lecture continued with a series of events and dates that were essentially unconnected and provided no analysis. During the entire session, Mr. Jacobs, the history teacher, never asks a question and not one student raised his or her hand to ask a question either. Observation, English, 5th Period I’m following Joy around today and am sitting in on her English class. Mrs. Mabry apparently has recently finished a
Inside Wes Side High School section exploring Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet. Today’s lesson is focusing on how to take the English Regents exam. Mrs. Mabry asks students to open up their notebooks and take careful notes. She points out that part of the Regents exam is comprehension, and that students will be given a written passage and asked to answer questions about what they have read. She instructs them to have a piece of scrap paper ready at the exam and to write down the critical information about the passage. She then informs them that they can’t take too much time on any of the sections and must be able to work as fast and efficiently as they can. Then she gives an example. She reads a passage from Shakespeare. She explains that during the test, students will have the passage in front of them. After she is finished, she passes out a set of ten questions which examines if students have understood the passage. The students respond to the questions. She gives the class about ten minutes to respond. (…) After, she gives the students the correct responses; students were to check their own papers. After they accomplished this, Mrs. Mabry asks how everyone did, but does not wait for responses. She then explains that there are certain things that students should be watching out for and goes through a list, instructing them to put it all in their notes, such as: first do this; two, then do this; three, do this etc. (…) During the forty five minute class, no one asks questions, not Mrs. Mabry and not the students. Observation, Social Studies The lesson today is on the American Civil Rights movement. Mr. Charles begins by talking about social relations between the races in the United States after World War II. He explains that throughout much of the country, segregation is the rule. After the war, many African Americans returned and were displeased with being treated as second class citizens even though they had fought and died just like everyone else. Students were asked to open up their notebooks and their textbooks and turn to page 224. He then gives a list of dates and events; i.e., Rosa Parks is considered to be the mother of
91
92
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth the Civil Rights movement because she refused to give up her seat on a bus to a white person. “I can see that no one is writing this in their notebooks. You have to write these dates in your notebooks because they are very important. They are sure to come up on the exams.” The list continues with dates on the march on Washington, and eventually ends with the death of Martin Luther King. After each event, Mr. Charles reiterates that these dates are important and students must write them in their notes. Mr. Charles comments rather sarcastically that he is sure that everyone read this chapter in the book. He then points to page 224 of the textbook, which he has instructed everyone to open to. “There is a chapter summary that is very important that contains the most important information on the chapter, which you’ll need for the exam.” (…) During the class, several students are looking out of the window, and at least 6 are slumped over their desks resting their heads on their folded arms. There are 3 Vietnamese in the class sitting close to one another. Each one is meticulously taking notes on the instructions.
In fact, most of the social sciences or humanities classes that I observed, regardless of level, were conducted in a similar way. Like Weis’ Freeway, teachers and administrators presented a contradictory attitude toward education, focusing primarily on form rather then content, and not insisting that students think or become challenged. After I had become acquainted with various teachers, I was permitted to walk around the room during class and observe what students were doing. The first few times I did this, I expected that students would become more fastidious with their note taking. Instead, students would have me look at the work in their notebooks, expecting that I would make a correction as to where to place a comma or some similar matter of punctuation. Both students and teachers appeared frustrated. Most students wrote in their notebooks only what they were told to put in them. Yet, the teaching technique encouraged students to write only when insisted upon by teachers. During one lecture in an American history class, the teacher stopped and said, “All of you look very bored. What are you going to do when you get a job? You can’t sit around and look bored,
Inside Wes Side High School
93
you’ll have to do something or you will get fired.” Again, the appearance of being engaged was more important than actually being engaged. Graduating was the ultimate purpose of going to school, and graduating was regularly linked by teachers and administrators to getting a job and being contributing, self-sustaining members of society. The task at hand was almost always to get students to take exams properly and pass them so that they could move up in rank or graduate. Like the above data suggest, most students wrote only what they were told to write in their notes. Many of the Vietnamese, however, wrote nearly everything that the teacher said, appeared attentive, and were physically responsive (like smiling, although often inappropriately) while teachers lectured. Later, in the homeroom or in the students’ homes, Vietnamese students would get together to compare notes and make corrections. I am not suggesting here that the Vietnamese students were any more intellectually challenged, or that they intellectualized content better then other students. They were, however, more enthusiastic and thorough, giving the appearance of being better students by being polite and constantly engaged. It is not at all clear that overall the Vietnamese were necessarily any more intrinsically interested in the actual content of the course work than the other students. Another topic that was raised in many courses was “how to take an exam.” While this subject occurred intermittently throughout the academic year, it became almost a regular part of lectures, in almost all courses, as the school year approached state exam time. In addition to being told exactly what to put in their notes, students were told how to approach the exam. In one history class the teacher explained, “If you get stuck on a particular question, don’t spend too much time on it. Go on to the next one and go back to it later if you have the time.” Exam-taking instruction was important in the Vietnamese homeroom as well. As exam time approached, Mr. Lee began to instruct the students on how to take various types of exams. Although most of the discussion was conducted in Vietnamese, with the help of a Vietnamese aide, it wasn’t difficult for me to understand what was occurring.
94
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth Observation, Vietnamese Study Hall Everyone present in the homeroom was given sample exams and response sheets. Mr. Lee held up both sheets and discussed how the exam was to be taken. The sample was multiple choice. Responses required that one find the corresponding number and then fill in the appropriate bubble with a no. 2 pencil. Mr. Lee then took a ruler and instructed the students to place the ruler under the question and extend the ruler to the response page so as not to make the mistake of filling in the wrong bubble. All students were expected to follow his example. He further explained that at some point it would be clear that a mistake was made, but that it would take a lot of work to find the original mistake and it would cause people to lose a lot of time and possibly fail the exam or get a much lower grade. He then instructed them to begin, and made his rounds around the room to see how everyone was doing. Occasionally someone was not performing the task in the way he instructed them. He then insisted on it being performed exactly as he demonstrated.14
Studying, in general, was a major theme in the Vietnamese homeroom. Students often assisted one another in exam-taking. The following observation demonstrates how students also became engaged in teaching one another how to take exams. Observation, Vietnamese Study Hall Mr. Lee and the teacher’s aides began to pass out sample exams. These exams involved being able to complete the tasks within a particular time limit before moving on to the next section. It was clear that students could not return to the previous section if it was not completed. Students were broken down into dyads. One student watched the clock while the other took the exam. Anyone who did not complete the task within the time limit was asked to explain what the problem was. If it was reading comprehension, Mr. Lee instructed the student to do more work on reading comprehension and to link up with a Vietnamese student whose English was better and work with them after school.
Inside Wes Side High School
95
Weis, in Working Class Without Work (1990), has demonstrated that teachers focusing on form rather than on content is typical in working class high schools. As with Weis’ Freeway, West Side High is no exception. The message that all teachers and administrators give at West Side High is that education is very important to a student’s future. Without an education, one’s future is bleak. It is, as I often heard, a necessity for employment, and hence, for being an independent, selfsufficient, and contributing member of society. Students were rarely asked questions by their teachers, nor did students ask any. Instead, students were encouraged to take specific notes, to memorize them as given, and repeat them as necessary on exams. Rather than educating, teachers became involved in training. This was especially evident in the amount of time devoted to test and exam-taking. Here again, students were trained in the method of taking state exams to ensure advancement to the next level or graduation. Exams were not viewed as a tool for learning, but rather, as an end unto themselves. In one case, a veteran social studies teacher (a middle aged, white male) frustrated at my questions, quipped, “All you academic types are the same. You think that everyone should be a philosopher or great inventor or something, spending time always thinking about stuff and reading or listening to classical music. Well, I have some real serious news. Most of these kids are lucky if they’ll be able to find a minimum wage job after they get out of here. It will be a real job for many of them to stay off of welfare.” While most teachers did not express this extreme position, the belief that most West Side High students were going to have a tough time after graduation, if they did graduate, was prevalent. It was this prevailing belief that justified the emphasis on memorization of unanalyzed facts and dates, and the extensive amount of time devoted to training on how to take an exam. Secondly, as one teacher confided, the administration officially encouraged teachers to take this approach in order to ensure the best possible graduation numbers, thus improving the school’s statewide status. The approach taken by the Vietnamese— the students, teacher, and aides alike—was somewhat different. Rote memorization of information is typical of traditional Vietnamese teaching and study habits. The Vietnamese teacher and aides encouraged this study technique, adopting it to the American
96
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
circumstances by eliminating group singing or chanting of the information, which was typically used in Vietnam as an aid to memorization. Instead, they engaged small groups to form study units with the most knowledgeable student taking the lead. In this way, the Vietnamese actually capitalized on a method that the school employed to “get students through.” The American emphasis on individual achievement or development discourages group activities of this sort. To do so suggests cheating or dependence. When I mentioned to one of the American teachers that I found the Vietnamese study technique helpful, she responded by saying, “They are adjusting to the American system and have some language problems; it helps them to learn when they are together.” Administrators and teachers were very supportive of the Vietnamese at West Side High, sometimes accommodating them in special ways or being more flexible, as will be explored in the following section.
Helping to Forge Identity: Administrator and Teacher Contributions The intent of this section is to explore the ways administrators and teachers contribute to the identity formation of West Side High’s Vietnamese students. Here I will argue that the school’s bad reputation, relatively poor funding as a neighborhood school, and constant threat of coming under state review creates an atmosphere which demoralizes many teachers and administrators. However, the bad reputation of the school and its overall poor and transient population works to the benefit of the Vietnamese. The presence of the Vietnamese, in contrast, provides an opportunity for the administration to raise the school’s academic standard by providing teachers with a relatively stable student population that ostensibly appreciates the opportunity to learn and, in comparison to American students, is respectful and cooperative. Together, these internal school factors help to create a Vietnamese student identity that positions them as academic achievers. In many ways, the administrators of West Side High were the least cooperative of any group I interviewed and offered the least substantive information. The majority of administrators, and there were many of them, claimed to be too busy to participate in the interviews, regularly
Inside Wes Side High School
97
breaking appointments or suggesting I speak to someone else. However, several of them reluctantly did participate. It was school protocol that I spoke with the principal, Mr. Jackson, first. The principal and the other high-ranking administrators presented to me what is essentially the official school “party line.” That is, “West Side is a truly wonderful and personable school with good students and good teachers; neighborhood schools always get a bad rap that is not warranted.” Over the past decade, neighborhood schools were receiving, according to Mr. Jackson, a high volume of bad press. West Side High, in particular, received a disproportionate amount of bad publicity, partly because of its location in a poor and unstable community, but also because of its problems with student retention, an inability to graduate substantial numbers of seniors, and bad Regents scores. The proportion of students taking Regents exams from 1995 to 1999 is as follows: Africans and African Americans, 20 to 25 percent; Hispanics, 30 to 35 percent; others (which includes whites and Native Americans at West Side High), 30 to 32 percent; Asians, 90 percent. When Vietnamese are disarticulated from Asians, Vietnamese percentages are 90 to 95 percent. Vietnamese and East Indians rank highest. Mr. Jackson was intent on demonstrating to me that West Side High was a truly wonderful school that provided the benefits of a full and traditionally rounded education; side benefits included being personal and neighborly, as well as providing a cosmopolitan experience for everyone because of the diversity of its foreign student population. Together, according to Mr. Jackson, these attributes made for a great educational experience for students and staff. C.C.: Mr. Jackson, you spoke briefly earlier in our conversation about problems that West Side High was experiencing. Can you expand more on that topic for me? Mr. Jackson: (laughs) Well, I know you must read the papers. West Side High is a great school. It’s friendly, we have a great staff…the students here are the most culturally and linguistically diversified of any school in the district. We offer a traditional education here and an extensive bilingual
98
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth education program. This makes West Side High one of the most interesting and enjoyable places to go to school and to teach for me. (…) But in many ways, this is part of the problem. C.C.: Can you explain that? Mr. Jackson: (…) Many of our students come from poor and unstable families. People move around a lot. There are many students that don’t even complete one full academic year. So, we don’t graduate them. We don’t even get the chance to educate them and advance them to the next level. And…we are unfairly criticized for not doing so. (…) If students don’t return, what can we do? Similarly, we are under constant scrutiny from the Board of Ed. and State Regents for low test scores. C.C.: Do you mean that the school as a whole has Regents test scores that are below average? Mr. Jackson: Yes. C.C.: (…) And you are saying that is the case because the student body is poor and transient? Mr. Jackson: That, and the fact that we have a very high concentration of non-native speaking English students in bilingual ed. C.C.: I see. Can you explain that a little more because it’s not completely clear to me. Mr. Jackson: Many of the students here do not speak English well. Students come here without much English at all. This severely impedes their ability to be successful on State Regents exams.
Inside Wes Side High School C.C.: So, let me restate this. Are you saying that bilingual ed. students are required to take the same Regents exams, and that because of their poor English, they are not able to do well on them? Mr. Jackson: Yes. (…) And then these scores are factored into the overall school performance. C.C.: I understand. And you believe that this is contributing to West Side High’s poor reputation? Mr. Jackson: This is contributing in a major way. C.C.: And what, if anything, do you think can be done about this? Mr. Jackson: Well, we are trying to work on that now (laughs). If you have any suggestions, please let me know. C.C.: (…) Mr. Jackson, as you know, I’m here to study the Vietnamese students of West Side High. Is there anything in particular you think I should know. Mr. Jackson: Well, they are a wonderful group of people and I will do anything that I can do to help. C.C.: Wonderful in what way? Mr. Jackson: They have been through a lot and they need as much help as they can get. They work very hard and they are very cooperative. C.C.: Do you find them to work harder and to be more cooperative than Americans, shall we say? Mr. Jackson: I think that they really appreciate the opportunity to go to school, something that American students have come to expect.
99
100
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth C.C.: Can you expand on that? Mr. Jackson: I really should get back to work. You should also speak to other teachers and maybe Ms. Martinez (one of the vice principals and the school’s unofficial publicity agent). Let’s carry on this conversation at another time.
I was unable to obtain another appointment with Mr. Jackson. We spoke briefly and informally throughout the academic year, often by chance when meeting in the hall, but he never further developed his thoughts on the Vietnamese. At the time I interviewed the teachers and administrators, there was considerable tension in the school because it was under a great deal of criticism and bad press for doing a poor job of educating its students. This, I’m sure, contributed considerably to the reluctance of administrators to be interviewed. However, although Mr. Jackson again managed to keep the state out of West Side High, there was an atmosphere of tension in the school and many teachers and administrators appeared demoralized. This was especially evident in their faces and in informal conversations I observed in the teacher’s cafeteria. People looked tired and spoke of how unfair they felt the state was in regards to its assessment of West Side High. The administration, teachers, and support staff were overwhelmed without enough support and time to accomplish their goals. The following excerpts from an interview with Ms. Martinez, one of the vice principals, and Ms. Sanchez, the guidance counselor, examines this. C.C.: Now tell me specifically about West Side High. From your perspective, is there anything special about school here in a way that is different from other public schools? Ms. Martinez: There is no other public school like West Side High in the State, well, lets say out(side) of Metro City. And since I am not familiar with the schools in Metro City, I don’t even know if there’s any high school like this in Metro City. Not only does West Side High differ from other high schools because we are the designated English as a Second Language School, which would receive those students who are not native speakers of English, but we’re just unique because we have
Inside Wes Side High School The (Nickel City) Training and Vocational Center. We have students who belong to that who come and go. We’re tremendously diverse in many areas and for many, many reasons. And then you take into account the very large limited English proficiency population. There is no other school like this in the whole city, or the whole state. C.C.: If you were going to tell me one or two of the very best things about West Side High, what would that be? Ms. Martinez: All of the kids, the ESL kids especially, they’re wonderful. They really, really are wonderful. People have the impression that poor kids are difficult, but that is not so. It’s an inner city school and we have inner city students. But you have some of the sweetest kids. The easiest children to deal with. Not that they’re free of problems and situations. Those, unfortunately, have been dished out to them by society and by parents, or lack of parents, but the children themselves are wonderful. There is no question about that at all. And the diversity. (…) C.C.: Is there anything that you would change here if you could? Ms. Martinez: Do you have ten hours, Craig? The only problem is that I don’t have 10 hours to give you if you do (laughs). Well, I think the major problem is how West Side High is criticized. We are always under severe scrutiny from the Board of Education and the state. I am working on some things right now as a matter of fact. We are always accused of not doing a good job educating, promoting, and graduating our students. But there are so many things that contribute to this problem. For many reasons, all of which I’m sure you understand, our student population is very mobile. Sometimes we don’t even get a chance to have a student an entire year before they leave the school. The parents move around a lot and the students move out of the neighborhood. These
101
102
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth students have choppy and often incomplete educations. Sometimes students come to us with incomplete records or no records at all. That is especially the case with students from Puerto Rico or other parts of Latin America. (…) C.C.: How does this affect the staff and faculty, if at all? Ms. Martinez: Everyone always feels under a lot of pressure. We do more justifying than we should. There is never enough time to do everything that has to be done. *** C.C.: Ms. Sanchez, tell me a little about West Side High; describe to me what kind of school it is. Ms. Sanchez: Well, I guess I am bias(ed). Why? Because we have suffered with such a bad reputation through all the years; but I have been working here for sixteen years. And I know that we have a good faculty, and they are caring, you know, we have people (teachers) who have been here for more than twenty-five years now…so we have pretty much the same faculty here, and uh, we have good kids here also. The reputation that we have, like, we have fights, things like that, but we don’t have any more than any other regular public school. C.C.: Why do you think West Side High has such a bad reputation? Ms. Sanchez: Well, I have asked these same things. The problem goes further back to the sixties. That is what I have been told. That’s when all the riots in the city (happened). It used to be that way. And then we seem to be carrying these bad reputations around, you know, all through the years. And what do we do? Like myself, what I do when people talk to me about West Side High? I always ask them, how do they know so much about this place and have they ever been here.
Inside Wes Side High School
103
So then I invite them. Tell me Craig, you have been here many, many times, I think you are studying something or writing a little paper, is that right? C.C.: That’s right. Ms. Sanchez: Well, you tell me, what do you think? C.C.: Well, I’ve done a lot of studying here, and it’s my favorite school in the city because everyone is so warm and friendly. I haven’t found that anywhere else. Ms. Sanchez: And that is the environment that everybody, you know, claims that we have here. Another thing is, you know, when people like you say that, you know, they really get the new spirit of the school. And I have heard that for the last four years. (…) And the word spreads like that. We have such a wonderful diversity of students here, a rich diversity of people. I feel like I’m coming to work at the UN or something. It’s maybe the best thing about the school. The above was typical of the interviews I had with high-ranking administrators and some teachers. They felt besieged by the Board of Education, the state, and the press for reasons that they believed they had little control over. West Side High is a neighborhood school, they point out, that cannot refuse entry to anyone. West Side High’s designation as the city’s major ESL high school made student retention, promotion, and graduation difficult, along with the problems of maintaining acceptable student scores on Regents exams. The result of this intense scrutiny was a demoralized faculty and administration, with teachers and administrators working and reworking figures to show that the school was doing the best job possible under the circumstances. Without exception, however, the diversity of West Side High’s foreign student population was always stated as the best feature, or asset, of the school by administrators and teachers alike. However, every administrator and teacher did not agree that the school was doing the best job possible. The following interview excerpts examine this point.
104
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth C.C.: (…) Tell me, what are the best things about West Side High School?15 Mrs. Bradberry: Without a doubt it’s the foreign students, the Vietnamese in particular. And, I would say there are some teachers and a few administrators that are a joy to work with but they are far, few, and in between…I’m sorry. Could you ask that question again? C.C.: I had asked you what you would change here if you could change anything. Mrs. Bradberry: Yeah, ok, well, as you probably know, we are in a lot of trouble…with the Board of Ed. and the state. This is no joke, there are lots of problems here. This is putting everyone under a great deal of pressure. And the fact is, the problem is with the administration; to put it mildly, the administration, it really stinks. It is really, really disorganized and inefficient (the administration) and there are plenty of people who are not really doing their job. The students aren’t learning and there is a lot of confusion. Everyone is dissatisfied. C.C.: So, in your opinion, the bad reputation that West Side High has is warranted? Mrs. Bradberry: It certainly is. Beyond just the administration being inept, there are lots of fights here, problems with gangs, and a lot of the teachers don’t really give a damn. The students know it too. That’s why there are so many absentees every day. Have you seen the absentee records? Go take a look at them if they’ll let you. You will be astounded. Does that sum it up? C. C.: Why do you think there are so many absentees here? Mrs. Bradberry: The whole environment is oppressive. Students understand that. Most of the students, they know they
Inside Wes Side High School
105
are the ones that the system has discarded. Most of the students here are at serious risk. They need to be motivated. You have to offer them some real incentives to be here…so they can feel better about themselves and get a better selfimage. We don’t do that here. I feel that this is a real disadvantage of the magnet system. You take disadvantaged kids and put them with other disadvantaged kids. Here, you come from a disadvantaged background, you are sent to a disadvantaged school with other disadvantaged students. Tell me, where does the motivation come from? If you don’t have a better model to aspire to, how can you become anything else? You don’t know what “above” really means. *** C.C.: (…) Tell me Mrs. McNeil, what are the best things about West Side High? Mrs. McNeil (assistant vice principal): I would have to say the students, they are the best part of this job and I have been here for 28 years. When I started, it was a predominantly Italian area. Now its very mixed racially and ethnically. The students now, they need quite a bit. C.C.: Can you explain that? Mrs. McNeil: This is a neighborhood school and the students come predominantly from the local catchment area. And this is a poor, poor neighborhood with lots of problems. I mean, it isn’t even working class here, its poor. Almost all the students and their families are on welfare. Very few people here own their own home, making for a very transitional population. People, you know, they have a tendency to move. Also, many of the parents, they’re not fluent in English and that means that we (West Side High) are on the lower end of the scale in terms of receiving money. C.C.: How does that position the school for less money?
106
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
Mrs. McNeil: Neighborhood schools get less money in general than the magnets; but it’s worse here because the parents cannot speak English well enough and are not educated enough to assert their rights and receive the resources needed to make the school better. C.C.: Understanding that, can’t the administration make a case for additional funds, given the circumstances? Mrs. McNeil: Look, monies are given to schools with principals who are well liked and who knows what other reasons. (Mrs. McNeil turns off the tape recorder. She states that Mr. Jackson, the principal, is not well liked, and that there was a push several years ago to remove him.) Understand? The parents are not able to assert themselves with the powers that be. A full 75 percent or more are on public assistance. They don’t know how to do this kind of lobbying. If they did, their own personal business would be in order. Most administrators and teachers expressed that the school’s position in the larger magnet system created a difficult situation for West Side High in regards to its overall academic student outcomes. Others, perhaps speaking more frankly, placed the blame on the inefficiencies of the administration. The parents themselves, foreign and American alike, were not in a position to demand better funding for their children’s education at West Side High. In any case, West Side High was in a unique position in Nickel City’s public school system because it was the city’s ESL high school. What is interesting about the above interviews is that teachers and administrators viewed the students as the best part of the school. In particular, it was the diversity of the school that made West Side High an interesting place to work. When pressed, teachers and administrators specifically appreciated the nonnative English-speaking students. Not one teacher or administrator made positive comments about the American students at West Side High. Specifically, the Vietnamese were singled out as ideal students, as the following teacher interview excerpts suggest.
Inside Wes Side High School C.C.: Mr. Jacobs, tell me what it is like teaching here. Mr. Jacobs (history teacher): It is challenging, I’ll tell you that (laughs). C.C.: How so? Mr. Jacobs: Most of our students come from poor and often difficult family backgrounds. I would say that over three quarters of our student body come from families that are on welfare. And a lot of these families have major problems such as drug and alcohol abuse. Sometimes students come in and they are tired and sleepy or what have you. School might be the place where they can get away from the problems at home, but it is not always a place to learn. At other times, the same student might be absent for days and days. Some of these kids have kids of their own. I have two juniors in the history class that you were just in that have children. One of them has two. These are children having children. So, many times I’m not really teaching, I’m just trying to get them through the system. (…) (A)nd in the end, I’m not sure the magnet system is all that great. The more stable and academically able students go to the magnet schools. That leaves behind the ones that are less able and…what can I say. There are no incentives for those students. The system puts all the less qualified students together and what do they have to inspire them? C.C.: What would you say is the best part of West Side High? Mr. Jacobs: Oh, I would say our best work is in ESL. C.C.: Tell me why. Mr. Jacobs: There you know that you’re having a real impact. The kids are learning English and you know that’s a skill that they really need and one that they will have all their lives. And the ESL students, in my opinion, are better students. They appreciate the opportunity to go to school and learn, and I
107
108
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth think that the American kids have come to just expect it and not really work for it. In the last ten years many of our top seniors are Vietnamese. C.C.: Do you feel that the Vietnamese really appreciate the education that they are getting here? Mr. Jacobs: Without a doubt. Many, maybe all of them, lost their opportunities in Vietnam because of the takeover of the communists. (…) Education is valued there and is understood to be reward for a job well done and not to be taken for granted. They work very hard. They are polite and cooperative. Not everyone is brilliant, but they work hard, and that makes teaching them worthwhile. C.C.: What did you think teaching would be like when you began twelve years ago? Mr. Jacobs: Oh, I thought that I wanted to really make a contribution. I wanted to really change things. I thought that the best way I could do that was to go into teaching. You know, really help form young minds. I expected that it was going to be intellectually stimulating and exciting. C.C.: Is it all of these things? Mr. Jacobs: No, not at all. C.C.: Can you explain that? Mr. Jacobs: Everything is mostly drudgery. The administration is partly the fault for that and the Board of Ed. for the way they set up the system. The students here are stupid. The magnet system siphons off all the smart kids and leaves all the academic trash for us in the neighborhood schools. C.C.: (…) I noticed that you never ask questions in your class, and students never raise their hand to ask questions. Why is that?
Inside Wes Side High School
109
Mr. Jacobs: I told you, the students are stupid. I don’t ask questions because they don’t want to be embarrassed. They don’t ask questions because they’re not interested. *** C.C.: Tell me Ms. Hetenger, what is the best part of teaching at West Side High? Ms. Hetenger (math teacher): Oh, I would have to say it’s the students. C.C.: All of the students. That is the best part of being here at West Side? Ms. Hetenger: No, not all of the students (laughs). The ESL and other foreign students, that is the best part of being here. C.C.: Why is that so? Ms. Hetenger: Because they are interested in learning. Let’s take the Vietnamese for example, they have lost everything (in Vietnam) and they appreciate coming to school and really work hard and learn. I wish the American kids were more like them. C.C.: What do you think makes the difference? Ms. Hetenger: Hum, I don’t think it’s just one thing. It’s many things. Their background teaches respect for education and teachers. I think that they have a really good support system. Mr. Lee really stays on them. I think their families and their friends all contribute to their learning and making sure that they do their work and help them keep their motivation up. To compare them, Americans and the Vietnamese, lets say, I would have to say that the American kids, they don’t really give a damn. Just two days ago I actually got into an argument
110
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth with one of my American students and she threatened to slap me. Now, who wants to put up with this kind of bullshit, given everything else you have to put up with around here? *** C.C.: Tell me, what is the best thing about working at West Side High? Mr. Fox (science teacher): Oh, without a doubt it’s the students, the foreign students especially. C. C.: Tell me, why is that? Mr. Fox: Because they are more serious about leaning and studying. Its not like with the American students. Sometimes I feel like I’m a dentist and not a biology teacher, you know, its like pulling teeth to get the students to learn and do their work. C.C.: And why do you think it is different with the foreign students? I suspect you meant that it was like pulling teeth with the American students? Mr. Fox: They (foreign students) really want to learn; they really appreciate the opportunity to learn. It’s not like it’s a given in many of their countries to get an education. For some, they would never get an education, and if they did, there would be nowhere to use it, you know what I mean? And the Asian students, they are really serious about going to school and learning. I think every last one goes on to college. Now wouldn’t that be great if we could say that about all the kids? C.C.: All the Asian students are really good students, Mr. Fox? Mr. Fox: No, not all, but I would say most. The Vietnamese are probably my best students. The Laotians and the Cambodians don’t do so well. I’ve been told that they didn’t
Inside Wes Side High School
111
really have an education system in place in these two countries. So maybe they don’t appreciate education as much. But the Vietnamese surely do. They work hard and their teacher, Mr. Lee, he makes sure that they work hard. Isn’t that the group that you are studying? Although every teacher did not find every Vietnamese student to be brilliant, every teacher I spoke with, 20 in total, found the Vietnamese to be polite, hard working, and most of all, appreciative of the opportunity to go to school. American students, by contrast, were viewed as unappreciative of education and generally disinterested, if not impolite and sometimes confrontational, as discussed by Ms. Hetenger. In one case, American students at West Side High were regarded as stupid. By comparison Ann Locke Davidson, et al.’s ESL students in Making and Molding Identities (1996) were viewed as being marginalized and trivialized by virtue of their ESL status in an otherwise middle class school. At West Side High, the native speaking, or American population was poor and transient, and exhibited the full range of problems typical of an inner city student population, creating low expectations on the part of the teachers and administrators. As Mrs. McNeil remarked in her interview, “You have to give students some initiative, a reason for doing better, to raise above their circumstances. The American students, the African Americans, in particular, are not getting that here.” Mrs. Bradberry, in her interview, pointed out, “The whole atmosphere here is oppressive.” Students intuitively understand that they are the discards of the magnet system. On the other hand, many ESL students—the Vietnamese in particular—arrived from an oppressive situation where education and its articulation into a well paying job was unlikely; therefore, they were very appreciative of the education they received at West Side High. Furthermore, they had nothing else to compare it to here in the United States, although the Vietnamese clearly understood that education here was not as rigorous as what they were accustomed to in Vietnam. Here again, Ogbu’s (1991) dual consciousness of a voluntary minority population comes into play. While education in Vietnam may have been better, it was generally unavailable to most of West Side High’s Vietnamese students, and even if it were available, it would not have
112
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
articulated into any opportunities in Vietnam. The opportunity to go to school at West Side High would at least prepare them for jobs or higher education. During the course of my fieldwork at West Side High, I was aware that some of the Vietnamese students were older than the average American student in the same grade. My initial inquiries as to why was answered with the response that many of the Vietnamese had dropped out due to economic necessity, or arrived in the United States with incomplete school records or no records at all. Some students, therefore, picked up their schooling right where they left off, or were placed in a grade level based on their ability. For the most part, this is accurate. However, after one of my interviews with a Vietnamese teacher’s aide, I was informed in a personal communication that some of the older students had completed the Vietnamese equivalent of high school, or the baccalaureate degree, which includes an additional year of study equivalent to the freshman year of college in the United States. The point here is that the Vietnamese were frequently cited as West Side High’s academic success story. Many of the most recent valedictorians of West Side High were Vietnamese. If it is true that some of the Vietnamese had already completed high school or a grade higher than they were placed, how fair was this? Although I was unable to verify this with hard evidence—that is, the opportunity to see records that clearly indicated that some of the Vietnamese were already high school graduates—at least one administrator and two teachers verified this point in personal communication. No one wanted to go on record with this information. In my opinion, this placed the Vietnamese at an unfair advantage over other students at West Side High, and further positioned them as achievers. The following data from an interview with an assistant to one of the vice principals explores the above points. C.C.: I’ve heard in one of my interviews that some of the Vietnamese have already finished their baccalaureate degree in Vietnam? Mr. Dipiro: Craig, I really don’t want to go on record with this information. (…) (B)ut I can tell you this, it is true that some of the Vietnamese, I’m not sure how many, have already
Inside Wes Side High School
113
completed their degrees in their homeland. That is why some of them (the Vietnamese) are so much older than the other students. (…) And maybe, better students. C.C.: Normally, if a student was older, and had not completed their high school studies, wouldn’t they be placed in an equivalency program or in an adult education program; or if a student needed language skills they would be placed in a language program, let’s say at the International Institute, or somewhere with other adults? Mr. Dipiro: Normally that would be the case, yes. C.C.: Why, then, did that not happen here with the Vietnamese? Mr. Dipiro: I believe that did not happen here because Mr. Jackson (the principal) needed something to raise the school’s stats and keep the state out of the school. The fact that at least some of the Vietnamese were already accomplished graduates raises some interesting points. After a brief discussion on this matter, Mr. Lee conceded that as many as 13 of 52 Vietnamese had acquired their baccalaureate degree in Vietnam, but had no American cultural skills or English language skills. As I stated in the above interview, normally, older students would be sent to a high school equivalency program or to an adult learning center to acquire language skills or earn a high school equivalency diploma. In the case of the Vietnamese, most lacked adequate English language skills and none had a working knowledge of American culture. At least some language skills could be learned at the local International Institute and some of the culture could be learned in local Catholic Charities programs, but not in a real, controlled environment like a high school. Clearly, West Side High was the district’s ESL high school, and by far, better equipped to handle large numbers of students. By placing the Vietnamese in West Side High, the Vietnamese had the advantage of one of the best ESL staffs in the city, and the school, by extension, had the benefits of an academically advanced student body that it
114
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
desperately needed to balance its poor record. Normally, adding large numbers of students to an already stressed high school would not be advantageous, but the Vietnamese were seen to be an exception. The Vietnamese were partially isolated from the rest of the general student body with a homeroom of their own, a Vietnamese teacher and Vietnamese teacher’s aides, and ESL classes. They also had the additional advantage of having some advanced students that could act as mentors and as very powerful examples for the less accomplished students, helping to consolidate them and maintain an identity focused around achievement. Although I am speculating here, I believe that Mr. Lee was very aware of the advantages that the Vietnamese brought to West Side High, and was able to marshal this into some additional advantages for the Vietnamese students. His insistence that many Vietnamese students attend the more advanced courses, regardless of their ability, is one possibility. These privileges were not missed by other students (see chapters 5 and 6) or, as we see below, the administrators and teachers. The following interview excerpts explore this point: C.C.: Mrs. Santiago, you mentioned earlier that there were many Vietnamese that were earning top grades, why do you think that is the case? Mrs. Santiago: (…) Well, you know that we (Puerto Ricans) can go back and forth to the island, so we always feel a connection there. And, since the economy of Puerto Rico isn’t as bad as Vietnam, we don’t have to leave the island, I believe. We are not really persecuted, you know. So, you know, I see their circumstances as very different; they, they have to leave. To get the thing that they want to achieve. So, they, they tend to really, to view this as a way to staying here and getting what they want. So, they work extra hard for that. C.C.: So, academically speaking, when you look at the records of Vietnamese students, are they doing better than American students in terms of grades?
Inside Wes Side High School Mrs. Santiago: Okay, well ah, if you take a look at the first twenty students, the Vietnamese are there. But you should know that there are some Puerto Ricans there and a few Russians there too. The difference is many times the Vietnamese, some of the Vietnamese kids tend to take, like physics, you know, or other related courses, and those are harder. But, so I guess that is what I’m saying. C.C.: So, the Vietnamese students, as far as you can tell, they are taking more advanced and difficult classes than most of the other students? Mrs. Santiago: Uh, maybe, maybe. Like I said, you know, probably because they see it as a way to learn more, be more competitive. Their teachers, their Vietnamese teachers, the ones that work with them, they are very direct with them, and it seems to be, like, that these kids listen more to their adult teacher than the other kids. So, Mr. Chee or Hee or Lee, or what is his name, he is their teacher, and he is very direct with the kids and they listen to him. C.C.: How would this be different from, let’s say, the Puerto Rican Students? Mrs. Santiago: We, see, okay, I don’t really know. Like, myself, I have taken upon myself—and the other bilingual teacher, like Ana Fuentez—to be as directive as we can with the Hispanic kids. You know, push and push and push and push as much as we can. The other teachers in the school, the non-Hispanic teachers in the school, they perceive things differently. You know, its like, “Well, you are on you own, you know, you should know your responsibilities.” And if they take the advice, okay; but if not, then they (the Hispanic students) don’t. It’s like that.
115
116
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
Mrs. Brown, one of the few African American staff, states: C.C.: Mrs. Brown, tell me about the teachers here at West Side High. Mrs. Brown: Well, I really don’t like most of them. As a matter of fact, I really hate them. The teachers here don’t care about all the students. They are here, as far as I can see, to just get a paycheck. The vast majority of them are white and are not concerned about the area or the kids. We have a 30 percent African American population here but only two teachers are African American. There are no distinctions between the minorities—Black, Hispanic, they’re all the same as far as the white teachers are concerned. I think the African American kids would do better if they had Black teachers just like the Vietnamese do. The teachers are different with the American kids than the Asians, particularly the Vietnamese. They take more time with the Asian kids. Basically, the school and the teachers are racist. How do you convince someone to work if their parents and their neighbors don’t work? Some of these kids, you wonder, how do they get to school at all? I say to myself, if I had to go through what some of these kids go through, I wouldn’t be sitting in this chair. People who live and work in bleak neighborhoods never escape. Let’s take you, for example, where do you live? C.C.: Around the corner. Mrs. Brown: Ah huh, and were you born and raised here? C.C.: No, but I have lived around the corner for 17 years. Mrs. Brown: Well, you have moved there by choice. You see something that they (the white teachers) can’t see, the cosmopolitaness of it all. But most people can’t see that. They don’t ever get a chance to see the fancy shops on Elmwood. I would, for instance, tell the students they would have two hundred dollars at the end of the year if they get a B, or three
Inside Wes Side High School hundred if they get an A. I have boys here that have three kids already and they aren’t seniors yet. They’re grandparents at 30 and, of course, these kids are not taking responsibility for these kids. They are staying with the grandparents. C.C.: You mentioned earlier in the interview that you saw distinctions in how student groups were treated. So, you see a distinction between Asians as well? Mrs. Brown: The Vietnamese seem to be the top dog and the Laotians the bottom dog. They clashed for a very long time. They are now just learning to tolerate one another. I don’t know what the circumstances are in their homeland that contributed to all this. C.C.: What about academics? Mrs. Brown: The Vietnamese always demand the most academically advanced classes, even if they are not prepared to take them. For instance, they will demand, and I do mean demand, algebra rather than beginning math. The Russians are the same way. The American kids are not like this at all. The Vietnamese all have the same aspirations. Regardless of their abilities, they all want to be professionals. Sometimes I feel they would be willing to do you bodily harm if you don’t put them in the classes they want. C. C.: Why do you think this is so? Mrs. Brown: Because I think they, or the ones that we get, are the ones that were the most clever or the most aggressive. They are the ones that go away. As far as I can see, any ethnic group has the usual spread of people with abilities: those that do well and those that do not. But these are the ones that are aggressive and the ones that managed to get out, and they know how to get what they need.
117
118
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
Teachers and administrators were clearly demoralized by the circumstances surrounding West Side High, which included the threat of intervention by the state, poor funding as a neighborhood school in a magnet system (despite much need), and the rigors of teaching an inner city student population. Teachers, in particular, were searching for the moral rewards that come with a job well done, but found such rewards difficult to attain under the conditions they were operating. The rewards of a cooperative and hard working student population were met, to some extent, by the ESL students, and the Vietnamese in particular. I am speculating here that in a magnet school with a more diversified student body in terms of class make-up, the Vietnamese would not necessarily have been as highly regarded by the faculty and staff and would have had a more difficult time being the school’s success story. The academic achievement and perceived privileges of the Vietnamese were resented by the Latino and African American staff and faculty. The vast majority of teachers and administrators were white, despite the fact that most students were American minorities. Minority staff and faculty believed that the white, dominant faculty did not care about the minority students. This easily could have created severe destabilization within the institution if the staff and faculty were more balanced in terms of race and ethnicity. But because the minority administration and faculty were so poorly represented, they believed there was little they could do to change things. They, too, felt the same pressures as the whites, but felt the additional burden of safeguarding the interests of a large minority student body with far fewer people to do so.
Summary In this chapter, I have examined the factors in West Side High which contribute to the identity formation of West Side High’s Vietnamese students. I have argued that various conditions particular to West Side High set the stage to consolidate the Vietnamese towards an orientation of achievement and a relative position of privilege. Further, the Vietnamese use West Side High School partially as a site for rigorous learning, but primarily as a site for language and culture learning and skills acquisition.
Inside Wes Side High School
119
West Side High is a neighborhood school in a magnet system. As such, according to teacher and administrator conversations, it receives less funding. It is also has the city’s only English as a Second Language (ESL) program at the high school level. Because of its location on the lower West Side, home to a dense population of the city’s poor and non-English-speaking population, West Side High’s student population reflects all of the problems of an inner city school. The combination of poor and transient students, and a high concentration of ESL students creates a situation where West Side High routinely scores low on Regents standard exams, is always under the threat of state review, and has relentless bad press. West Side High administrators and faculty find themselves constantly justifying their work, creating an atmosphere of tension and overall demoralization. Similar to Weis’ Freeway, West Side High teachers maintain a contradictory attitude toward school knowledge; that is, they adhere to the form of knowledge rather than the content. The influx of large numbers of Vietnamese into West Side High created both challenges and opportunities for the Vietnamese and the school. A Southeast Asian homeroom was created with a Vietnamese teacher and several aides, which consolidated the Vietnamese as a group and allowed for the reinforcement of the Vietnamese values of collective learning, hard work, and appreciation of education, essentially moving the Vietnamese towards an orientation of achievement and the other Southeast Asians toward an orientation of exclusion. The lower academic standards of the school and inclusion of older and more academically accomplished Vietnamese students allowed the Vietnamese to use West Side High primarily not as a site for high level academic learning, but rather, as a site to learn English and American culture in a relatively safe and controlled environment before moving on to higher education or the job market. By extension, the routinely hard working Vietnamese provided West Side High with a student population that helped raise the academic outcomes of the school, thereby assisting the administration in keeping the school out of state review and providing the faculty with a student population that is polite, respectful, and appreciative of education. By contrast, many administrators and faculty viewed American students as less appreciative and cooperative, positioning the Vietnamese as West Side
120
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
High School’s academic success story. While there is much room for divisiveness in West Side High, the minority faculty and administrators found the predominantly white faculty to be unresponsive to other minority needs and were angry about the attention given to the Vietnamese. The particular circumstances surrounding West Side High did much to provide opportunities for the Vietnamese that otherwise may not have been available in a magnet school with a more varied student body in terms of class background and academic ability. I recognize that the picture I present of classroom teaching at West Side High is, in fact, rather grim; yet the Vietnamese students are very enthusiastic. Beyond providing entre into the American tertiary education system and providing much needed and appreciated acculturation, West Side High, I believe, stands for something much more in Vietnamese youth’s lives. West Side High administrators and teachers, for the most part, appreciate the Vietnamese, something that was clearly not the case in Vietnam. Secondly, West Side High symbolizes the beginning of their new lives and their new freedoms. This is the start of reclaiming lost opportunities and the time to lay plans for the future.
CHAPTER 5
West Side High Vietnamese Males
Khon ngoan, doi dap nguoi ngoai! Ga cung mot me cho hoai da nhau… If you are clever, go and argue with outsiders! Chicks of the same hen don’t turn on one another…16 In this chapter I will present both interview and observation data which examine the identity formation of Vietnamese males at West Side High School. Various aspects of their identity formation are similar to previous ethnographies of high school males, but depart from those profiles in a number of important ways. The profiles available in Sociology of Education literature have focused primarily on white, working class youth whose identities were formed in relation to the dynamic between capital and labor, as well as the various social movements that have arisen from rapidly changing British or American economies (Willis, 1977; Weis, 1990). By contrast, the Vietnamese are immigrants who have left their home country to seek a better life through resettlement in the United States. They, of course, do not have a long historical relationship with the United States, and are regarded in the literature by Caplan (1989) as model minorities. The literature available on Asians is, historically, often aggregate performance studies which do not examine the varying degrees of success between groups, or the identity formation of any particular group. Though very little else is to be found, performance literature, especially that which has taken a comparative approach (Weis, 1985; Ogbu, 1978, 1991; Gibson, 1988, 1991), is helpful in analyzing the larger context of the emerging identity of Vietnamese males as voluntary minorities. I will argue that the identity profile of Vietnamese males in West Side High emerges from a set of circumstances based on their particular 121
122
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
refugee experiences and the development of their that emerges in relation to African American and Latino students at West Side High. It should be noted again that this identity emerges in an environment that is characterized by a low enrollment of white students and a high enrollment of African American and Latino students.
Reading, Writing, and Arithmetic: Vietnamese Males Creating a Pro-school Identity Ethnographies examining the identity formation of males within the institution of school, such as Willis’ (1977) lads, Everhart’s (1983) students in a junior high school, or Weis’ (1990) Freeway males, have centered on the white working class, and have had long established historical relationships to social economic institutions. In all three cases, the males were antagonistic towards authority and disengaged from the form and content of schooling, either directly or indirectly. The identity studies that have focused on white, working class students have assisted my understanding of the process and structure of identity formation, and therefore, cannot be overlooked when examining the identity formation of the Vietnamese males of West Side High. I have also found helpful those works which examine the immigrant/refugee experience. The Vietnamese, however, are neither white, nor historically working class in the same way as white youth, and do not have a long-term relationship with the United States. This literature, therefore, is not able to account for the identity of Vietnamese youth. To understand their identity, I find Ogbu’s (1989) theory of voluntary versus involuntary performance framework to be very helpful. As Ogbu contends: …(I)mmigrant minorities do better in school than nonimmigrants, even though the former do not share the language and culture of the dominant group and even though, like nonimmigrants, they face barriers in adult opportunity structure, which is reinforced by two cross-cultural observations. One is that in some instances the minority groups who are doing well in school are the ones more different from the dominant group in culture and language. …The second reinforcing observation
West Side High Vietnamese Males
123
is that a minority group which does poorly in school in its country of origin, or where it has an involuntary status, appears to do much better when its members emigrate to another country, where its culture and language are even more different from the language and culture of the dominant group of the host society (as cited in Weis, 1985, pp. 181-2). The profile that Ogbu (1989) has outlined quite accurately describes the Vietnamese of West Side High. For example, because the Vietnamese are minorities but have elected to come to the United States, they lack a long-term relationship, which marginalizes them from societal benefits. In effect, the Vietnamese and their parents have no perception or internalization of institutionalized racism to inhibit them from performing well. Because they have left oppressive conditions in Vietnam, they are better positioned to take advantage of American education than, as is the case at West Side High, African Americans or Puerto Ricans. The latter groups have long historical relationships to the United States that are founded in slavery and colonialism. Because of this history and institutionalized racism, African Americans have been placed at the very bottom of a caste system, further contributing to their unsuccessful participation in the process of schooling. Puerto Ricans have a long colonial relationship with the United States, as well as a difference in language and culture. The issue of Vietnamese voluntary status, however, can be contested. The nature of their departure from Vietnam and their status as refugees, some scholars argue, has qualified them for involuntary status (Gibson, 1988; Ogbu, 1989, 1991). For example, Gibson (1988) states that: The situation of guest workers, undocumented workers, and refugees, differs significantly from those of voluntary immigrants, and the degree to which their adaptation patterns are similar merits further comparative analysis. (Gibson, 1988, p. 33) As is the case for voluntary minorities, such as Cuban and Central American refugees, Gibson (1988) does agree that a comparison of the
124
Identity Formation of Vietnamese Immigrant Youth
performance data indicates that the Vietnamese have a high degree of success. For the purposes of this study, I argue that the Vietnamese of West Side High are voluntary minorities. This is based on their personal assessments as recounted in their narratives and presented later in this section. The Vietnamese males interviewed for this study were either juniors or seniors, and stated a median age of 20, which was two to three years older than is the norm for the grades they attended. This was clearly due to the amount of time they had lost in the expatriation process. The average length of residency in the United States was three years. All of the males, except one, reported having originated from South Vietnam. Half explained that they had come from rural backgrounds, while the other half described themselves as having come from urban backgrounds. Vietnamese males also reported being Buddhist, Roman Catholic, or Taoist. Like many of the oral histories of Vietnamese refugees, over half of the West Side High males recounted horrendous stories of departures from Vietnam on overcrowded boats and being subjected to Thai pirates, sea sickness, food and water deprivation, as well as varied stays in processing camps in the Philippines, Malaysia, and/or Hong Kong. These were the stories of the males who had left Vietnam prior to the improved diplomatic relations between Vietnam and the United States in the late 1990s. The remainder of the males reported much easier departures from Vietnam in airplanes and through normal diplomatic/counselor procedures. The Vietnamese males’ narratives suggest that this is a group that spanned much of the Vietnamese class structure. Some reported having an agricultural or a semi-skilled background, while others claimed family ties to the Vietnamese government. After arriving with their families in the United States, Vietnamese males reported living alone, or with nuclear and extended families. Some Vietnamese males reported living alone on government assistance, or with their families on government assistance. Some students also reported having fathers who were semi-skilled and working in areas such as clothing manufacturing, or who had skilled employment in areas such as electronics. Two males reported living in female-headed households, one with a mother who worked as an unskilled laborer, and one who lived on government assistance. One Vietnamese male, the exception to
West Side High Vietnamese Males
125
the group, narrated that both his mother and father worked as dietician in a local hospital. One male reported that his father had just acquired a corner store in a very economically depressed community. None of their family backgrounds in any way reflected their previous socioeconomic status in Vietnam. After reviewing Caplan’s (1989) performance data on the Vietnamese, I initially suspected that Vietnamese academic success might be linked to class background. As noted in chapter 3, from 1975 until 1981, those Vietnamese arriving in the United States were the most able to leave because of a high-ranking relationship with either the South Vietnamese government or the United States government. The others, who immediately followed, could do so because of their ability to pay. The lower middle class, semi-skilled and unskilled laborers, and those engaged in the agricultural sector, came after. Most data on Southeast Asian student academic success were collected in the mid to late 1980s, and reflected many of the Vietnamese students who had arrived in the first and second wave emigrations to the United States. Vietnamese students at West Side High were the later arrivals, from the period of the early to mid-1990s. I further suspected that as my study and other studies were conducted, the data would reflect a drop in Vietnamese academic success, and a corresponding identity that was less likely to accommodate school culture than among the previous groups of Vietnamese. In other words, I suspected that Vietnamese high school identity would bear a relationship to the lower class backgrounds reflected in Vietnamese immigrant trends. Many (Gibson, 1988; Hirschman & Wong, 1981) have raised similar concerns regarding the reproduct