MURDER G E T T I N G AWAY W I T H
T H E T R U E S T O R Y O F J U L I E R A M A G E ’ S D E AT H
MURDER G E T T I N G AWAY W I T H
T H E T R U E S T O R Y O F J U L I E R A M A G E ’ S D E AT H
PHIL CLEARY
A Sue Hines Book ALLEN & UNWIN
First published in Australia 2005 Copyright text Phil Cleary 2005 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage or retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher.The Australian Copyright Act 1968 (the Act) allows a maximum of one chapter or 10% of this book, whichever is greater, to be photocopied by any educational institution for its educational purposes provided that the educational institution (or body that administers it) has given remuneration to Copyright Agency Limited (CAL) under the Act. A Sue Hines Book Allen & Unwin Pty Ltd 83 Alexander Street Crows Nest NSW 2065 Australia Phone: (61 2) 8425 0100 Fax: (61 2) 9906 2218 Email:
[email protected] Web: www.allenandunwin.com National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-publication entry: Cleary, Phil. Getting away with murder. ISBN 1 74114 691 7. 1. Ramage, James - Trials, litigation, etc. 2. Murder - Australia - Case studies. 3. Provocation (Criminal law) - Australia - Popular works. 4. Murder victims Australia. 5.Trials (Murder) - Australia. I.Title. 364.15230994 Cover and text design by Phil Campbell Typeset by Prowling Tiger Press Edited by Jo Jarrah Printed in Australia by McPhersons Printing Group 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
To all those women who suffered at the hands of the legal lie of provocation and those who brought an end to it.
CONTENTS Into the trap A perfect day Bush burial Bad tidings in Research At the gravesite Daddy’s rich, Mummy’s good looking Early years Mr Dunn arrives The trial begins Jane Ashton is called Her mother’s daughter If Your Honour pleases The jury’s back Little murders everywhere Provocation crumbles
1 8 38 47 64 69 88 102 110 122 141 165 181 199 224
Endnotes Acknowledgements Picture credits
245 247 249
INTO THE TRAP
You have to experience murder to truly understand the anger it generates. I can’t remember when I first saw the photos of my 25year-old sister’s body on the trolley in the Royal Melbourne Hospital. Gruesome, humiliating photos of a rough-sewn cut running from her belly to her chest, where the surgeon had tried to stem the bleeding. Knife wounds to her hands and face. Murder always speaks of unassailable hatred.Witnesses in Cameron Street, Coburg heard her scream, ‘Help, someone help,’ as her former boyfriend brandished his knife. It was just after 8 am onWednesday 26 August 1987.At 10.40 am she was pronounced dead. Sixteen years later in a kitchen on the other side of the class divide, Julie Ramage experienced the same primordial fury of a spurned man. From that moment it was inevitable that I would meet her twin sister.When Jane Ashton told me the story of her sister’s life and death my mind was awash with memories.‘Help, someone help.’Were these the words Julie Ramage found as her husband rose from his chair and lunged at her? 1
Unable to control himself, James Ramage was in a killing mood. More than six feet tall, with a large, broad face, his general bulkiness contrasted starkly with the symmetry of his wife’s face and the elegance of her form.As his right fist crashed into her eye socket he paused only long enough to see the blood squirt from the split on her nose before landing a thumping second blow to the left side of her head. Terrified, she could hardly speak. Unrepentant, he didn’t believe what he was doing was wrong. It was her fault. It was always her fault.All he could think about was how she’d ruined his plans. Everything he’d worked for, lost because of a stupid woman who didn’t know her place. How could he face the parents at the prestigious schools where his children were now enrolled if his wife appeared in public with a battered face and people were whispering he was a wife basher? And after the fall from grace what would he say to his two children? To make matters worse, perhaps he could see Julie’s twin, the ‘mad aunty’ he called her, running around the place saying,‘I told you so, look what he’s done to my sister Julie.’ ‘What will my friends think of me then?’ Is this what he thought as he weighed up his options? Finish her off and outsmart everyone or be humiliated by Julie’s gaggle of mates and Aunty Jane? There was only one way out. Whatever thoughts crossed his mind, Julie had no hope. Stunned by the attack, his wife was already in free fall as she began her descent. No sooner had her head crashed onto the shiny pine floor than he was upon her, his massive hands gripping her neck, his knees pinning her to the floor. So fierce were the blows, blood and fluid were already filling the tissue between the knuckles of his right hand. Ramage was immune to the pain as he landed another blow to the left side of her head where she was now haemorrhaging beneath the skin. Despite the ferocity of the assault she refused to submit. As he compressed his wife’s 2
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
neck and pressed his left thumb into her thyroid cartilage, Julie’s teeth dug into her tongue. As much as she clawed at his fingers with her girlish, dark pink fingernails, she couldn’t release his hand. A few scratches weren’t going to stop this man. Only Ramage was witness to how many blows he landed as she lay beneath him fighting for her life.Although he would later say Julie didn’t resist for long, the trail of marks and grazes told another story.The bruises on her neck and left wrist and another on the third knuckle of her right hand bore testament to a fierce struggle. Fit and strong from horse riding and exercise, and desperately keen to live, Julie fought to dislodge him and protect herself from the blows. With her right arm pinned to the floor and her left wrist immobilised by his grip, the best she could do was claw at his right hand while the thumb of his left hand dug deeper and deeper into her neck. As much as she dragged her girlish, dark pink fingernails across the fingers of his hand she made no impact. A few scratches were not going to stop this man. Then finally, like a criminal dangling from a hangman’s noose, her legs twitched one last time. Unable to speak or alert the world outside, she did what most people facing death do. She grabbed a few treasured moments from her life. Sadly, it was a life that had never been truly fulfilled. Samantha and Matthew, the children she so loved, and her devoted sister Jane would have been there as the last vestige of life was expunged. ‘Jane, Jane, please save me. Will I awake and discover it’s a dream?’ Jane had always been there when it mattered. It had been a violent, prolonged battle. A barren, unfinished room in an Australian dream home in middle class Balwyn had become her coffin. In the middle of a crisp, sunny winter’s day in Melbourne, Ray and Patricia Garrett’s daughter suffered a brutal death. At best, strangulation might take thirty seconds.At worst it could be INTO THE TRAP
3
up to three minutes. Dr Matthew Lynch thought the marks on Julie’s neck were consistent with a struggle considerably longer than thirty seconds. At the trial he couldn’t say how long. In his report he drew attention to a small area of yellow-brown discolouration on the right side of her neck and a line of bruising running six centimetres across the left side that started around her Adam’s apple. It was here that Ramage had planted his left thumb, while simultaneously subduing his wife with blows to the head with his right fist. When asked whether rope might have been responsible for the marks on her neck Lynch replied ‘I can’t exclude it’. A person being strangled first experiences severe pain followed by unconsciousness and then brain death. Professionals who study this form of murder say it’s the embodiment of a man’s power to control and ultimately silence a woman. Unless she did as he said, Julie was in grave danger. If she’d said ‘yes’ to his feigned pleas of love and told him she loved the renovations he’d masterminded for his Georgian castle, he’d have welcomed her back. If she’d said, ‘Pour me a glass of wine and ravage me,’ how different it would have been. All she needed to do was let him rip her trousers off and swoon as he consumed her and she’d have been safe. Conquest, that’s all he ever wanted. Julie Garrett had learnt to be very careful with her words. It was so rare for her to ever say ‘no’ or to question her husband. Not even when he pushed her face into the pillow every morning at 6 am, demanding she tell him how much she loved his favourite kind of sex, did she say ‘no more’. After six weeks away from his bed she could no longer say ‘yes’ to him.There’d be no more faking it and no more lies about the marriage. On Monday she repeated what her husband already knew:‘I’m not coming back.’ No matter what would be said in the coming days and weeks by lawyers and friends, it was this declaration of independence that 4
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
had compelled James Ramage to knock her to the floor. He was not prepared to have her say she wasn’t coming home. ‘If there’s another man or she’s not back one hundred and fifty per cent, it’s the end,’ he’d told friends. Suddenly, it was calm and he could now survey the damage. For a man who never allowed a speck of dust – let alone a drop of blood – to find solace in his home, the death of his wife was a messy affair. ‘I’ll make it look like someone from her riding club did her in.They won’t know it’s me,’ he reassured himself as he looked down upon the woman who only minutes earlier he’d said he loved. Apart from the bruised hand, the blood on his jumper and a broken watch, he’d survived relatively unscathed. Still, he was in trouble. Six weeks earlier his life had looked so different. On Monday 9 June 2003 he’d left for a business trip that would take him to Korea and Japan. With a flourishing company, two handsome children and a glamorous wife, 43-year-old Ramage thought he had the world at his feet.While he enjoyed the luxury of a seat in business class his 42-year-old wife set about photocopying financial documents and preparing to move into a flat in Toorak. At the Target store in Camberwell she laughed when Jane told her to make a splash and spend up big on James’s credit card. Years of badgering from her thrifty husband ensured that Julie would do no such thing. It wasn’t the first time Julie had fled her husband. On a Wednesday in February she’d rung Annette Luckman, a friend at the Hurstbridge Adult Riding Club, to say she was preparing to leave the marriage that day. Later in the afternoon, in a hushed whisper punctuated by breathlessness, she told Annette she’d decided to stay. She sounded scared and traumatised.Threatening to leave, or leaving only to return the next day had been the story of Julie’s life since returning to her husband after the first INTO THE TRAP
5
decisive separation nearly twenty years earlier. In June, though, she was going forever. She’d had enough. As much as an erotic affair had opened Julie’s eyes to life’s sensuous riches, she hadn’t left the marriage to be with her lover. Locked in his own marriage, he offered nothing more than adoration and illicit, secretive sex. She loved the sex and the carnal praise, but it wasn’t for this reason she’d left her husband. She wanted to be free of her husband’s violent attitude, the insults and his stultifying control. Julie’s dreams were reflected in a 700-word farewell letter she’d left for her husband on the lounge room table.The opening paragraphs should have left her husband in no doubt as to her intentions: ‘After a lot of heartache I have decided to leave you because too many things have gone on over the years with you, and I feel we would both be happier on our own…I feel young and gregarious…you are staid and conservative, and people only get worse as they get older’. Terrified of growing old with her husband and being imprisoned in his spartan world of goal setting and sex on demand, she couldn’t stay another day. A lot of water had passed under the bridge since the day 17-yearold Julie Garrett caught the eye of the big, self-assured boy from well-to-do Cuffley. Bursting with money and self-confidence, Balwyn was a long way from the quaint, unpretentious semirural village where they met, forty miles north of London. In beauty and temperament she had been the classic fairy princess. Imposing and athletic he was her bold black knight. Once the pursuit of his princess was accomplished, he scaled the social ladder. While he made money and accumulated influential friends she accepted her lot and learnt not to question the man who had rescued her from obscurity. When Ramage returned home from overseas to find his wife had withdrawn $100 000 from their joint bank account and 6
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
moved to a flat in Toorak with their daughter, he told everyone he was shattered. From flowers to promises in front of marriage counsellors, he tried everything to win her back. Julie was unmoved. On Monday 21 July, she had agreed to make her first visit back to Marock Place. On show were the latest renovations to the couple’s $900 000 house. For his wife’s visit Ramage had placed lunch on the pine table in the semi-renovated family room. Lying on the lounge room sideboard was a catalogue for one of his favourite aphrodisiacs, erotic videos, and in the garage was a roll of blue rope from which he had cut a piece two feet long. Whether the rope had a sinister purpose or was for some sadomasochistic game he’d dreamed up after watching one of the videos in the catalogue, no one would ever really know. Julie wasn’t coming back and he knew it.There was only one reason for the visit.Alone with his wife, he was going to vent his spleen.
INTO THE TRAP
7
A PERFECT DAY
The day had started so differently for Julie. As always, she’d driven her daughter to Lauriston Girls’ School in Armadale. Along the way she passed 30 Mercer Street, the house where local socialite Margaret Wales-King and her husband were living when their murder engrossed Melbourne in April 2002. Julie’s ex-lover was on the phone bright and early. During a fortyminute phone call made from his mobile he learnt every detail of Julie’s trip to Geelong with her husband on Saturday and how she’d told him she had a new man and the marriage was over. In explicit, handwritten letters, invariably signed ‘forever and always, Davey’, her lover fantasised about their moments together. During the summer of 2002 he bombarded her with words. ‘Rubbing you…imagining your fantastic body with a sexy belly ring…I hope you are not training too much in the love making area to be ready for me. You are fantastic so you don’t have to practise. Just the green eyed monster rearing his head.’ Davey’s words and the sex that came with them so enticed her, she would eventually tell her sister ‘sex with James is repulsive’. 8
There was nothing the lovers did in bed that couldn’t find a place in the letters. Julie would collect them from the post office in Lorne and on the way back to the family’s cliff top beach house in nearby Eastern View she’d read them to her friend Gilda Pekin. She never tired of them. Only the joy that came with the birth of her two children and that first year with her husband rivalled those ten months with Davey. Julie knew she was playing with fire. ‘He’ll kill me if he finds out,’ she told Gilda. Possessive and self-absorbed, James Ramage had a nasty streak. After the separation he admitted to five marriage counsellors that he’d been violent to her before. Although Davey shared Ramage’s love of money, he had an eye for the arts and the world of books.‘I’ve been to see the film Frida. The cinematography and the way they incorporated the art of the artist to become part of the scene was something really different and artistic.Would you love to see it…so we could talk about it later?’ Julie’s husband would never have considered a film as a prelude to sex. Sex came with marriage and was something to be taken when and where he wanted it. Davey’s erotic seduction of his wife is not all that would have infuriated Ramage. Julie’s lover was a Jew, and Ramage had crossed swords with Davey’s people in a couple of business ventures. Davey enjoyed discussing world affairs and had an eye for the hypocrisy of the pious. ‘Bush seems obsessed with Iraq, but I think he’s going to have more trouble with North Korea…I guess N Korea doesn’t have oil. That’s what it comes down to, oil and $$,’ he’d written in another letter. Her lover was not a man in Ramage’s political style.The Englishman admired Prime Minster John Howard and President George W Bush and had little time for Julie’s ‘do-gooder’ friends. While the former lovers chatted Jane rang her sister’s phone several times and eventually gave up. If only she’d had that one A PERFECT DAY
9
conversation. Davey says he was just catching up and that they liked to talk. Some of Julie’s friends are less charitable, quick to point out that a previous lover had described him as a pest.The real purpose of the phone calls, they say, was to see whether he still rated as a potential lover. The story of a new man wasn’t what Davey wanted to hear. Unbeknown to Julie, he was extremely jealous.As a teenager in England she’d seen boys fight over her. Secretly, she loved it. Having two lovers fuss over her again so distracted her she seemed to forget the dark forces that sex triggered in her husband.They were far more perilous than anything teenage love could ferment. Compounding the danger, she told her husband she’d left the marriage to escape his control. Yet all he could see were men trying to seduce her. To Ramage it was an act of treachery. ‘I went horse riding with Laurence and we had dinner at the Panton Hill pub. I’m on cloud nine,’ Julie had told workmate Tarsha Warren that morning. As forthcoming as she had been about her sex life, she didn’t describe how she’d twice made love with her new boyfriend, Laurence Webb, before leaving his cottage on Sunday night. So besotted was Webb, he promised her the world and even set about refining his riding skills. At 10.45 am on the day of her alleged murder Julie had left a message on his voice mail. They were planning a trip to Noosa and she wanted him to know how happy she was. He rang back fifteen minutes later to declare his undying love. Although they’d been together a mere ten days and had made love only half a dozen times, Webb was convinced they’d spend the rest of their lives together. Some of Julie’s friends agreed. Others believed it would have petered out within a few months. Julie’s mood that morning was nothing like her husband’s. While she basked in the attention and told everyone about her weekend and her new love, her husband was grumpy and sullen. 10
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
He’d arrived at the Thermo-Glaze factory in Collingwood around 8 am, but his mind wasn’t on work. After facing bankruptcy in a previous business he’d struck gold with Thermo-Glaze. He could hardly believe that recoating bathtubs could be so profitable. Now he was genuinely rich and getting richer by the day.Without his attractive wife by his side, though, it suddenly counted for nothing. He’d become a shell of his normal self. Work colleagues tried to humour him, but Ramage remained distracted and preoccupied. For the first time in nearly twenty years he no longer had control over his wife. On the weekend he’d been told unequivocally that she wasn’t coming back. Worried that she might turn her back on the lunchtime meeting he rang his wife at work to confirm what time she would arrive.At 11 am he drove off for Marock Place. She was expected at 12 noon. After a morning of bubbly phone calls and optimism, Julie appeared at Tarsha’s first floor office door. It was 12.10 pm and she was already running late. In keeping with her general happiness, her words were cheery, almost carefree.‘I’m starving, didn’t have any breakfast, just going to pop out and get some lunch. I won’t be long.’ Tarsha had been working with Julie at the fashion house, Eco-d, in upmarket Glenferrie Road, for three and a half years. From her blonde hair to the tip of her high heeled shoes she was a young woman without a blemish and was blessed with candour and an understanding of her friend’s life that surpassed her twenty-six years. She’d heard all the intimate details of Julie’s disintegrating marriage and after the split had become an even more trusted confidante. Tarsha had only met James Ramage five times. She considered him to be an overbearing man and heard how he dictated A PERFECT DAY
11
the colour of his wife’s nail polish, the way she wore her hair and how Julie even faked orgasms so that the sex he routinely demanded would end sooner. ‘Take care, Julie,’ her friend had told her when Ramage began appearing unannounced at Ecod. Tarsha didn’t see Julie slip into the Mini and disappear along Park Street that day. Nor did she know that lunch involved a meeting with James Ramage at the house in Balwyn to look at the new renovations. Then again, she hadn’t asked where her friend was going when she left on Friday for lunch. Nor did she ask why lunch had lasted three hours. She probably wouldn’t have been surprised to know that Julie had spent lunch in bed with her new boyfriend, Laurence Webb, at her flat in Toorak. Julie was in love.Today she hadn’t turned off her computer, and as it was a cold day she’d also left her heater on. It was only going to be a short chat with her estranged husband. At approximately 12.22 pm, Julie swung her Mini into Marock Place, a circular court of six houses in the upmarket section of Balwyn. It’s almost Canterbury, James would say. Today, his Jaguar was parked next door outside number 6, facing Boston Road. Surprisingly, the builder Graeme McIntosh’s Mitsubishi van was nowhere to be seen. Graeme was a creature of habit. Every day at midday he would hop into his van, unwrap his thickly cut sandwiches and three pieces of fruit, and open the Herald Sun. An hour later he’d be back on the tools. ‘Why isn’t he here, snuggled in his van?’ she must have thought. Only the day before, Ramage had told a friend, Dr Kate Clark, they were to meet the builder at the house. As always, McIntosh had arrived at 7.45 am. Inside the front door he found a note asking him to ring Ramage. When he called he quickly realised how desperate the owner was to be alone with his wife.‘Julie’s coming around so I’d rather there was no work going on. I’ll ring back and tell you when she’s com12
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
ing so you’ll know when to finish,’ said Ramage. Around 9 am he was back on the phone. ‘She’ll be coming at around 12 pm. So I’ll need you gone before that,’ he said. McIntosh’s offer to wait around the corner until Julie had left had been met with a stony ‘I’ll pay you, but I just want you to take the afternoon off.’ McIntosh was genuinely surprised by Ramage’s persistence. He said the offer of a payment without work being done was ‘a first’. A man who loves a chat and a cup of tea in the company of women, the builder had an eye for the businessman’s excesses.‘If you give him a special treat, he might finish the kitchen off sooner,’ Ramage had quipped to his wife, causing the builder to blush. This comment, and Ramage’s offer to ‘shout at the massage parlour’ when the kitchen was done, rang in his head after Julie’s brutal death. On Monday, McIntosh did as he was told and was gone from the house by 11.30 am. When he returned on Tuesday morning the house was an official crime scene. His absence would become a point of conjecture when the facts of the day were pieced together, and he would tell everyone how guilty he felt at not being there when Julie needed him. Julie’s fondness for Graeme McIntosh wasn’t enough to kindle an interest in the renovations. ‘They’re just another ploy to get me back.What will he try next?’ she said jokingly to her sister. She’d once told her neighbour, Debbie Webb (no relation to Laurence), she’d never expected to be living on the flash side of Whitehorse Road. Now all she wanted to do was leave it behind. Mock Georgian, with symmetrical windows and fake weather-beaten shutters that clung to the dark, clinker brick walls, it was a house in her husband’s image. A doll’s house, she called it. ‘Barbie doesn’t live here anymore,’ she’d laughed as she caught a glimpse of her face in the car mirror the day she left. The ‘Ken and Barbie’ lampooning of her marriage from the A PERFECT DAY
13
more bitchy of the Scotch College set had become a distant memory. Six weeks on from fleeing the marriage she was pleased at how she looked and that some of the signs of stress had disappeared from her cheeks and eyes. She felt fit and thought she looked young. As she passed her husband’s Jaguar and prepared to turn into the driveway, she spotted Milka, her cleaning lady, across the court in front of Debbie Webb’s house. ‘How are you, Milka?’ she yelled across the court as she stepped her way along the path. Quietly spoken, with perfectly groomed light brown hair and a classically Slavic face, she always looked a picture.‘I’m sorry I can’t chat longer. I’m in a rush,’ said Julie apologetically. Milka was taken by how happy and attractive Julie looked.The cleaning lady lived in the working class west of Melbourne and was naturally deferential in her relationships with the well-to-do people whose houses she cleaned. It was no impediment to her taking a keen interest in their lives. She’d always found Ramage polite and she genuinely loved Julie, but she knew there was trouble in the marriage. In the coming days she looked for someone who might want to hear what she knew about Julie. Milka so much wanted to tell people how every week Julie would give her extra cash, always hidden somewhere in the house, and make her promise not to tell James. ‘He’ll go mad if he finds out I’m paying you more,’ Julie would say. Shy and heartbroken, at night Milka would cry silently and ask why the rules of evidence were such that she wasn’t allowed to tell the court her special stories. ‘Mr Fastidious isn’t doing such a good job keeping up appearances, now that number one slave has escaped.’ Might this be what Julie thought as she eyed the unkempt garage and the winter leaves in the driveway? She felt sorry for Matthew, who had stayed with his dad after the split and was being bombarded 14
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
with his father’s continual questioning and outbursts of emotion. As she approached the porch she thought about how she’d resurrect her relationship with her son. ‘Being entombed in that house with Jamie will bring him to understand what I’ve endured,’ she’d told her twin sister. All those days spent standing on the banks of theYarra watching her big strong son row. How she wished he’d get over her departure from the marriage. For a change, the heavy, white metal bar gate on the porch was open. Had her departure forced him to relax some of the rules? Usually, visitors had to ring the bell while standing on the path outside in all weather before the front door was opened and the gate unlocked.‘I’m the king of the castle,’ she would sing to herself as he went through the ritual of looking out the window before opening the front door and then the security door. Not that people dropped in much. He didn’t like surprises and hated mess so much even the children had learnt not to have friends over when he was home. In the midst of the separation Julie had sat down one night and listed all the things her husband didn’t like. ‘He doesn’t like much at all, really. I don’t know why he wants me back,’ she concluded. She wasn’t coming back this time. The relationship was over and nothing he said or did could change that. How to free herself without earning her husband’s wrath – that was what occupied her thoughts. Eight days earlier, on the afternoon of Sunday 13 July, her best friend, Gilda Pekin, had let slip a dangerous piece of information. Over a coffee at her house she told Ramage how Julie had met a businessman from Sydney at the Botanical Hotel in South Yarra and been out with him several times. She also told him about Laurence Webb.‘I’m here with you, that doesn’t mean we’re doing anything,’ Gilda told him when he pressed the issue. Although she tried to hide the significance of men showing an A PERFECT DAY
15
interest in Julie, the damage was done. Gilda well knew that Julie had made love with Webb on Friday and Saturday and had revelled in it. As much as his wife had told him she wanted to end the marriage, Ramage had never seriously believed Julie could live without him.The conversation with Gilda rattled him. For the first time since their six-month separation in 1984 it seemed his wife was genuinely free of him. What Gilda didn’t realise was that the thought of another man frolicking carnally with his wife made Ramage sick in the stomach.That’s why Julie was furious when she found out what Gilda had divulged. Jealous and possessive, James Ramage was not a man to be played with. His wife knew that much.That’s why she told people he’d kill her. Believing things might be moving fast, Ramage was on his best behaviour as he prised information from Julie’s circle of friends, speaking of his love for her and asking how he might win her back. Bit by bit the facts of an irrevocably broken marriage were sinking into his head.The once haughty, nit-picking and domineering Ramage was now begging his wife to forgive him. There was only one card left in the pack. Seventeen-yearold Matthew, his adoring son, was his only hope. Matthew had made it clear to his mother he wanted her back in the family home. Desperate to please her son, Julie had agreed to attend a session with psychologist Rosemary De Young in Hawthorn on Tuesday 15 July. De Young had been recommended by a close friend of the Ramages, Dr Rob Moodie. Ramage sat impassively as his wife told DeYoung the marriage was over.The psychologist gave him no comfort. ‘You have conflicting agendas. Julie wants separation.You want reconciliation,’ she said. De Young noted that there ‘was no goodwill on Julie’s part to revive the marriage and counselling was inappropriate’. Desperate to find a psychologist who’d pressure his wife to return to the marriage or at least say she should refrain from 16
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
meeting other men, Ramage was frantic. No sooner had he left the session with De Young than he was on the phone to sixtyyear-old psychologist Tom Paterson.When he received a call in the early evening from Paterson informing him of a vacancy at 5.45 pm he immediately rang his wife. Julie told him it was no use, but she agreed to attend. At 5.38 pm Ramage was back on the phone to the psychologist.They spoke for fifty seconds, during which time a meeting was set at his Hawthorn office. As brief as the phone call was there was enough time for Ramage to make a remarkable admission.‘Julie’s ninety-nine per cent sure she’s not coming back,’ he told the counsellor. By the time he’d driven from Collingwood to Hawthorn he’d made three further calls, at two minute intervals, to Julie’s mobile. She was a woman under siege. Rosemary De Young recorded that there’d been previous violence, but didn’t document any specifics. Paterson, however, heard about Ramage head-butting Julie and breaking her nose in 1991 and that he broke glasses, had an explosive temper and she feared he might hurt her horse or punish her. Neither psychologist told Julie she might be in danger. When Paterson suggested it was ‘not a good idea in the short term’ for either of them to go out with anyone else, Ramage felt vindicated. As equivocal as it was, Paterson’s comment was pounced upon by Ramage and used against his wife. This fictitious promise, supposedly made by Julie, would become a cursed thing and would be used to tarnish her character in the trial. Paterson would tell me he only offered this advice because men sometimes responded violently to the news that their wife was having sex with another man. ‘I’ve shot myself in the foot, the counselling didn’t work,’ a dejected Ramage told Jane Ashton over lunch at her home in Research two days later. It was now Thursday 17 July and Julie’s A PERFECT DAY
17
life was rapidly drawing to a close. ‘It’s quite innocent with Laurence. She’s only spreading her wings,’ said Jane when the conversation turned to the boyfriend. She didn’t tell him she knew the marriage was over and that Julie was telling everyone she genuinely fancied the new boyfriend. The girls had made a pact. Ramage was to be let down gently and no one was to say anything that might rile him. Committed to seeing her sister leave an unhappy marriage, Jane stuck to the script and told him he should continue to see counsellors and try to change his behaviour. It didn’t matter to Ramage that his sister-in-law had little time for him. As humiliating as it was, he had no alternative but to throw himself at the feet of Julie’s girlfriends.What else could he do? A few weeks earlier Ramage had met his sister-in-law in the restaurant at the Yan Yean Driving Range in nearby Arthurs Creek. He was wearing his blue Ralph Lauren jumper and sat with his back to the panorama of mountains that bordered Yan Yean. Although the mountains had caught his eye when he arrived, he made not one comment about their beauty. In a few days they’d assume a new significance. Jane had no idea she was a pawn in Ramage’s game and that he was gleaning information from all her sister’s friends. If they fell for his promises she might be persuaded to return to the marriage. That was the strategy. In the restaurant that day Ramage was forced to listen. It wasn’t something that came easily to him. He didn’t believe anything Jane said. It was Julie’s problem, she just didn’t understand his work and had trouble communicating her real feelings, he said. When Jane explained that Julie’s dismissive ‘whatever’ in the face of his hectoring was an act of surrender, he nodded. He just didn’t understand. He never had. Nineteen years earlier Jane, who was still living in England then, although the twins’ parents had migrated by this time, had received a prophetic letter from her sister in Australia: 18
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
We both felt we needed a break and time to ourselves to decide what we really want from life. Hopefully we’ll grow together again, but it would be a completely different relationship. I just feel as though I’ve stepped off a Merry Go Round and can’t believe how uncomplicated life can be on your own. If I want to buy something I buy it, if I want to go out I just go. I’m seeing Jamie on Sunday and we are going horse riding at Diamond Creek…Mum and Dad have been really great over the whole thing and haven’t interfered at all. They are quite happy whatever I decide and Jamie has appreciated that and there are no ill feelings…Connie and I went to the pictures today – Sunday.We ended up seeing ‘Friday the Thirteenth’ which was really scary so I didn’t see much through my fingers! Anyway I got home by six and managed to tidy-up and do the ironing before Mum and Dad got home from the ‘Pokies’ looking rather tired. I have bought a nice little car which goes really well, it’s a Mazda 808 Delux Coupe 1300cc, white in colour. So I’m really mobile now and drove 100 km this weekend. Bye Bye for now
‘Horse riding in Diamond Creek’.Whenever his wife threatened to leave him, the offer to go horse riding with her was Ramage’s gift to Julie. Little did she or anyone else know how important Diamond Creek would be in the story of her death. After lunch at Jane’s house in Research on Thursday 17 July, Ramage rang his son’s mobile on five consecutive occasions. It was part of a campaign to harass Julie into travelling with him to Geelong on Saturday to watch Matt play football with the Scotch College senior team. That goal achieved he insisted on picking her up from the flat. Under further pressure she said A PERFECT DAY
19
she’d visit the house on Monday to look at the renovations.‘Matt will be so happy,’ he’d said when she finally conceded. By Sunday, Ramage’s two children, Gilda Pekin and their mutual friends the Moodies and Farleys knew about the lunchtime rendezvous at the house. The Geelong trip on Saturday was particularly taxing for Julie. Beyond the prying eyes of other Scotch parents Ramage had bombarded her with a series of questions and promised to do whatever it would take to bring her back. She was unmoved. Dr Kate Clark, an anaesthetist by profession and Scotch College parent, happened upon the couple during the course of the afternoon. She described them as looking distressed and solemn. Day and night over the previous weeks Ramage had rung her seeking advice about how to get Julie back. She would later say he oppressed and controlled his wife and that he ‘didn’t really talk about missing her’.All he was interested in, she said, was the effect of her departure on ‘the state of the family’. The picture painted of the pair at Geelong by Dr Clark, a gentle and unobtrusive woman, presaged the violent act that lay ahead.And while Ramage had taken up his traditional role at his wife’s shoulder, no longer did he have the look of the confident lord protector. He’d lost his fairy princess. Unfortunately, as events would show, he was not a man to take any kind of slight lying down. Despite Julie knowing this about him, the next day she would tell her twin sister he seemed to take the revelation of a new boyfriend very well. ‘I’m glad I gave James the benefit of the doubt and didn’t take out a restraining order,’ she said. Although he pressed her about the relationship she was optimistic that the visit on Monday would pass without too much angst. When Julie spoke with Laurence Webb on Saturday night, she said it had been a difficult day and that she was too tired to go out. In fact she attended a friend’s fiftieth birthday party, 20
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
while Ramage went out on a blind date. His version of events was that he eventually told the woman he didn’t have his heart in it and went home alone. That night he was so distraught his fifteen-year-old daughter Samantha hopped into bed to comfort him. He said the thought of a new man on the scene had cut him deeply. Little did his daughter know that simmering anger lay beneath the tears. ‘When I hopped into bed he told me he loved Mum and wanted her back, then he goes and does this,’ she would wail on Monday night. ‘Don’t worry, Mum. I’m not silly. I won’t see him on my own’. As she reached the front door did Julie remember the promise she’d made to her parents? Did she remember the words and reassure herself that he wouldn’t do her any harm? Only a week earlier she’d told Tarsha her husband would kill her if he found out about Webb. So why did she let her guard down? Later, her appearance at the house would be used as evidence that she had nothing to fear from her husband. ‘No, he won’t hurt me.’ I remember my own sister reassuring me with those bouncy, unequivocal words.Three months later she was dead. In time we’d all discover she knew her ex-boyfriend was capable of such violence. It’s impossible to believe Julie Ramage would have gone to Marock Place if she’d known she was going to be alone with her husband. After the separation she told her daughter she was scared of him and would only meet him in crowded places or with other people. The trip to Geelong was the first time she’d been alone with him since she moved out of the family home. She must have expected Graeme McIntosh to be at the house. Ramage would subsequently tell his police interrogators the lunchtime rendezvous had not been confirmed until Monday morning and that, up until he rang her that morning, the meeting was scheduled to take place at nine in the evening, when of A PERFECT DAY
21
course Matthew would be home. If it was a cunning lie it was designed to convince the doubters that the meeting was spontaneous and that he’d not acted with premeditation.The note for the builder confirmed that Julie had agreed to meet him for lunch. All that was in doubt was the exact time. A decisive piece of information had unwittingly come Ramage’s way on the weekend. While waiting for her in the Toorak flat on Saturday the disconsolate Ramage had looked for anything that might give him a clue about the future. In the kitchen he saw a calendar with the words ‘holiday with Laurence’ circled around a date in the school holidays. It was the last straw. For the first time since they were married he knew she was impervious to his tricks and fake promises. During the course of the day she confirmed what he’d seen and said that Laurence was now her boyfriend. She had told her friends she was no longer going to hide her life from him. For many years she’d tolerated her husband’s sins because, deep down, she admired him. The regret she felt at having to leave the marriage was reflected in the final letter: I could hate you so much for some of the things you have done and said to me over the years but I also understand that you are a very good person and that you work hard and most importantly that you love our kids very much…
The kindness of these lines didn’t weaken her resolve to leave him behind. Nor did it stop her laughing with her twin sister as they tried to second guess what he would do next. Week after week huge, expensive bunches of flowers had arrived at the front desk of Eco-d. James Ramage wanted everyone to know how much he loved his beautiful wife. If only you’d told me privately and meant it, she thought, as she searched for a place to hide the 22
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
flowers. ‘If only he’d said how much he loved me years ago and that I was a great mother,’ she told friends. Respect and genuine love would have been enough. In an earlier time a hand-picked flower with the single word ‘sorry’ might have done the trick. The homemade CDs of ‘their’ favourite songs that arrived on her desk were a pitiful recompense for all he’d done over the years. Nor did it cut any ice with her twin sister.‘Asking his son Matthew to burn the CDs only gave Jamie another opportunity to show him how hard he was trying to win his mother back. It was straight manipulation,’ said one of her friends. On Sunday 20 July, Ramage spent more than an hour grilling close friend Nick Farley at Marock Place. Farley and his wife Jen had been to dinner at Julie’s flat on the Friday night. She told them it was over with Ramage. Although Farley knew that Julie had been sleeping with her new boyfriend, when Ramage asked if it might be the case he said, ‘I wouldn’t have a clue.’ This wasn’t all he knew. In November 1997 the Farleys had been at lunch at Marock Place when Julie divulged to Jen that she was having an affair with a mutual friend, banking executive Sean Mays. For some reason he thought this was something the police should know and had included it in his statement. Like Julie’s other close friends, the Farleys had heard first hand that Julie believed her husband would kill her if he found out about the affair with Mays.They knew it wasn’t a throwaway line. That’s surely why Nick Farley vividly remembered Jamie Ramage’s ominous, ‘I’m angry with Julie’. Farley’s comment to the police that there was nothing about Ramage’s demeanour that ‘alarmed’ him reads like the words of a man who, with the value of hindsight grasped what Ramage had really been saying.As history would show, there had been good reason to be alarmed. At 9.15 pm on Sunday 20 July, after more than an hour discussing the prospects of Julie returning, Farley bade his mate farewell. A PERFECT DAY
23
‘You just have to accept what happens, James. Make sure you look after your kids. Look, Matt’s still with you,’ he said, in an attempt to reassure his friend one last time. Ramage shrugged his shoulders. Farley remembered that shrug and those ambiguous words when Tuesday’s edition of the Channel Ten News reported what Ramage had done. He also vividly remembered how his friend had said it would be his decision as to whether he’d have his wife back. Ramage’s words bore all the hallmarks of an angry, brooding man. A primary school principal, Farley wished his understanding of the dynamics of relationships and Ramage’s ‘male chauvinism’ had set the alarm bells ringing. When James Ramage said he was ‘angry’ it was a far cry from what Farley understood it to mean. It would have been enough to worry Julie, though. If Farley had divulged what he knew to Jane Ashton she’d have tried to stop her sister walking into the trap her husband had set. To those who’d never thought about why a man kills his wife, Ramage was no threat to his wife. He didn’t have any convictions for violence and apart from losing his licence for drink driving had never been in trouble with the law. Some friends knew he had a temper and was aggressive when drinking, but he wasn’t a pub brawler or pugilist. And his business partner Tony Brady had never divulged the secret that might have got them thinking. What they didn’t know was that he was a wife basher. It wasn’t chronic, but he’d done enough to his wife to be capable of inflicting unimaginable violence. Three weeks had passed since Ramage told his confidant Dr Rob Moodie, he’d once hit his wife. When he lied and said it was only minor, Moodie didn’t press the issue. It was the same on Sunday 20 July when Moodie called in at Marock Place for lunch. During the conversation Ramage said he intended to ask Julie whether the new boyfriend had been on the scene before the separation. They 24
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
were ominous words. Upon hearing that Ramage had killed his wife, Moodie offered one very perplexing observation. He said he’d been so concerned about his friend’s state of mind he considered ringing him on the Monday. He thought he might be suicidal. It never occurred to him that Julie might be in danger. The man who waited for the unsuspecting Julie Garrett carried all the deep anxieties of the worst of men. Psychologists and experts in family violence say offenders learn their violence from their father. Had James ever seen violence in his own family? Whatever the truth of the speculation about his father, James Ramage could not be trusted to control himself. And what his male friends didn’t know was that he had no aversion to using his head as a weapon. Anyone who’s felt the force of another man’s fists or seen the violence in a bully’s eyes knows that men who head-butt can never be trusted. If Moodie or Farley had been knockabout blokes they’d have known that Ramage was on a dangerous path. Julie’s friends still wonder what Ramage was thinking when he walked upstairs and slid into his brass bed that night. If his dreams were fired by wild thoughts of revenge, his bed gave nothing away.As always, he stretched his long body neatly down the left hand side, where he always slept. Ramage wasn’t one to roll about or throw the bedclothes around. There was no sign that he grabbed the pillow where his wife had once put her head and cuddled it. When he awoke, he stepped from the bed and ever so neatly folded back the doona a few inches.Was it an invitation to his wife? Whatever the reason it was in keeping with the James Ramage people had come to know. Methodical and clinical, he wasn’t one to be consumed by flights of fancy. Tense and belligerent, he would have been standing at the window when his brazenly happy wife exchanged pleasantries A PERFECT DAY
25
with Milka. Although he hated her being late, at the front door he greeted her calmly, laid a kiss on her cheek and looked for a sign that she might be his. It was now approaching 12.23 pm and Felicity Holding, owner of Eco-d, had organised a meeting for 1 pm. ‘You’ll have to get used to me not running on your timetable.’ When he looked at his watch and admonished her after she’d been out horse riding on Wednesdays she’d so much wanted to utter that line. She told her friends having to live by his timetable drove her mad. Today, he said nothing to prompt such a response. After escorting his wife on a tour through the renovations, Ramage offered her a place at the pine table. He would later claim she dismissed the renovations as unimportant. It was almost 12.30 pm by the time they took up their places at the table. Ramage sat at the head of the table with his back to the glass windows, while she sat with her back to the large cabinet that stretched along the wall. To reach the front door she would have had to pass him. The king of the castle didn’t like to waste money on heating, so as always it was chilly in the house. To ward off the cold he was wearing his fashionable navy blue Ralph Lauren jumper. Julie took off her black leather jacket and placed it on the chair. Today she was wearing navy jodhpurs, a pale blue polo-necked jumper and the leather jacket. On her feet was a pair of RM Williams boots. As always, gold jewellery adorned her neck and hands. She was not wearing a wedding ring. Tarsha Warren said she looked gorgeous when she arrived for work in the morning.Yet there was nothing about the way she’d dressed that might have led him to believe today was anything but business. She was also menstruating. As if nothing had changed, she did as her husband wanted. Under his watchful gaze she lifted his peace offering to her mouth. There was no bottle of Moet or plate of caviar to induce his wife to think well 26
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
of him. All that was on offer today was a salad roll from the deli next door to his factory. There was also nothing she could say today that she hadn’t said on Saturday or in front of the marriage counsellors.The day before, her husband had told Rob Moodie the marriage was virtually over. So what did happen in those 10 to12 minutes before he began his murderous attack? She didn’t want to go to war with him or fight about the children or property. Desperate to avoid trouble, she tried to steer the conversation away from her private life.The more she tried to change the topic the worse it became. Alone at Marock Place wasn’t the time for Julie to tell him anything about her private thoughts. Although the sun was directly overhead, it was bright in the family room and the expanse of glass at the western end framed every blink of an eye as they sat at the table. If only the builder Graeme McIntosh or the wise Debbie Webb had walked through the back gate.As she grasped the uncontrollable anger in those bristling, angry eyes, did she think of making a run for the back door? ‘He’s an absolute pig,’ she’d told a neighbour the night in 1987 when she fled their house at 33 Percy Street, Balwyn. Pregnant and terrified, she thought he was going to kill her. How she must have longed for a reassuring hand on her shoulder.Today, the men who admired her generosity and beauty were nowhere to be seen. She was alone and he was in an unforgiving mood. Aware that the renovations were not going to bring her back, Ramage moved to the matter of the children. His daughter’s attitude to spending time at Marock Place and finally the so-called promise to be faithful – that’s where he wanted to take the discussion. Ultimately, Ramage had his sights set on one major question. He wanted to know about the new bloke and offer her one last chance. If she said ‘no’ she was going A PERFECT DAY
27
to pay. Ramage’s actions showed he was incapabe of constraint. The intransigence of his demands was in total contrast to the conciliatory nature of her farewell letter: I know that you would really try to do anything to keep us together but that is not the point because it’s what’s in your heart that truly matters and I know you can’t help yourself and the real you bubbles to the surface and I don’t like that person. If you care for me please let me go without a horrible fight for the kids’ sake. Let’s prove to them that we are better than all the other separated couples that we know…
In Ramage’s world, sex was power. As Julie unzipped her jacket and placed it on the chair he must surely have imagined what Laurence Webb was doing with her. The idea that some interloper was consuming her would have fired his anger.To be sure his wife truly enjoyed being overpowered by him in the marital bed the king of the castle insisted the light be left on. He wanted to see the pleasure in her face when he devoured her. It was no secret that he was increasingly interested in sadomasochistic sex and what Julie described as ‘acrobatics’.‘The sex is getting scary,’ she confided to a riding club friend, Robyn Watson, during a brief exchange in the toilet at a restaurant prior to the separation. After a burst of tears they each fixed their make-up and returned to their husbands at the table. Every morning he would roll over, tap her on the shoulder and demand sex. She told Tarsha it felt like rape. Was he thinking about sex today? An accomplished horse rider, Julie loved competing at the Hurstbridge Adult Riding Club. In the foothills of the Great Dividing Range she was free. He despised the horse riding scene and the friends she made.‘Bush pigs,’ he called them.As much as 28
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
he hated her mixing with the ‘bush pigs’, he wasn’t unhappy about what the exercise did for her body.Yet such was Ramage’s arrogance he’d been oblivious to his wife’s secret life. As he sat pounding her with questions and sullenly weighing up his options there was so much he didn’t know about the woman who sat opposite him. Sean Mays and Davey had told her she was irresistible. He had his suspicions, but he’d always found it hard to believe she could have sex with another man. Her newly found independence and her refusal to return to the family home had shattered the illusion. He’d seen his power evaporate in the blink of an eye. No longer could he bludgeon her with his arrogance and tell her how lucky she was to have him. ‘Don’t tell me you’ve been listening to your mad sister,’ he used to chide his wife, in front of the children. Now, the days of savaging Julie’s friends and her sister were over. No matter what he told the counsellors about wanting to change, history would bear testament to his capacity for violence. Every time she defended her sister and said she needed space, did he want to smash his head into her face? Is that why his wife said he’d kill her if he found out about the other men? Whatever the answer, she was going to pay.This was what he was thinking as the conversation, and ultimately the relationship, reached its finale. By 12.35 pm, less than fifteen minutes after arriving at the house, Julie had had enough of the discussion.‘I must go, I have a meeting,’ she said, grabbing her jacket and beginning to move past him. The force of his hands gripping her from behind was everything she feared. ‘Come on, you’ll enjoy it,’ he liked to say in the marital bed. ‘I’m not having sex with you anymore. Don’t you get it? We should have separated ten years ago,’ she’d already told him in front of a marriage counsellor. Did she repeat that declaration in the kitchen? A PERFECT DAY
29
‘My relationship with Laurence is none of your fucking business and, anyway, Laurence is much nicer, and sex with you would repulse me.’ Did she really deliver this brutal coup de grâce and send her husband into a state of loss of control? Friends say Julie rarely swore, and psychologist Tom Paterson said she never said or did anything provocative during the marriage counselling session six days earlier.‘She was being very constructive and very open, and was prudent and civilised,’ he said. Paterson’s picture of Julie Ramage is a far cry from the woman who, Ramage says, belittled him throughout the lunch. ‘What hope does Sam have when she’s got a slut of a mother?’ Ramage had roared during an argument about their daughter’s attitude to boys. Did the word ‘slut’ pierce the air as he drew his hand from her jodhpurs and began his attack? If only he’d smashed his forehead into her face as he had done twelve years earlier and said, ‘Fuck off out of my house.’ But there would be no reprieve today. One after another the punches crashed into her head. The day he left for the overseas business trip she swore she would never again feel the weight of his naked body on her. ‘I can’t stand his little dick and his hairless pink body,’ she told a friend. If it had only been rape she’d have gritted her teeth and let him have his way. For once he wasn’t interested in sex.The chilling sound of Ramage’s right fist crashing into Julie’s face confirmed that. Only violence would have his wife ‘shut the fuck up’. Her kicking and clawing and her gasps and cries for help didn’t tug at his heartstrings. There was no way he was going to stop. Bleeding and bruised, Julie hit the floor only a couple of feet from the glass doors, in full view of the back yard. A neighbour chopping an overhanging branch or a child chasing an errant football would have seen every frame. It was like a scene from the Hollywood classic Rear Window. 30
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Thinking she was dead, Ramage stood up and checked his clothing for blood.The clock had clawed its way to 12.37.As the adrenalin rush that accompanied his violent attack waned, he began to grasp the gravity of his situation.‘Where will I put the body?’ he must have wondered, as he pondered his next move. Like thermoglazing a bathtub in the family business, time was the essence of the matter. How quickly could he mastermind a cover-up? With son Matthew due home around 6.15 pm there was no time to waste. First he had to ring the plumber, Patrick Leonard, and tell him not to come to the house. A straightforward kind of bloke, Leonard had seen the aggressive side of the man of the house. The plumber was no dandy, but he told the builder he was genuinely stunned to hear Ramage call his daughter a ‘fucking slut and a moll’ after an incident during the renovation: Samantha had flushed the toilet causing an unsavoury blockage and her father had gone feral. There was nothing feral about him as he calmly walked through the kitchen and into his office to find the plumber’s number. On the circular table was his briefcase and on the walls a collection of photos and drawings that appeared to confirm the normality of life in this suburban home.Two of the photographs were of his daughter’s rowing team and another featured a shop front bearing the brand name Jazzies, the business venture that had set him on the path to riches. Even without his wife, Ramage had plenty to live for. ‘It’s James Ramage here. Look, Patrick, I’m just ringing to let you know I don’t need you at the house today,’ he said.The conversation was over in thirteen seconds. It was now 12.38 pm. In his rush to grab his Filofax the killer was oblivious to the bloodstains he’d left on two company documents in his briefcase. With much to do, Ramage put his clinical mind to work on how to solve the little problem he’d created. Just what he did A PERFECT DAY
31
next isn’t entirely clear. Debbie Webb would later tell police that she drove into the court around 1 pm. It was probably a few minutes before 1 pm when she parked her car in the garage across from Ramage’s house. She said she noticed her neighbour’s Jaguar outside number 6 and was surprised to see Julie’s Mini in the driveway at number 5. If these times are correct, it’s likely that Ramage was still cleaning up the blood and his wife was lying alongside the rear door to the garage, under the valance he’d pulled from a cupboard. In his police interview, Ramage wasn’t asked to chronicle with any exactness the sequence of events. Everything he said was designed to enhance his defence. He would tell Detective Darren Wiseman he dragged Julie out of the house and put her in the boot of the Jaguar. If his car was still outside number 6 at 1 pm, twenty minutes after he’d killed her, this is impossible.The story about dragging Julie out of the house and throwing her body in the boot reads like the actions of a man out of control. The methodical shifting of cars as part of an elaborate cover-up reeks of cool-headedness. It was not the story Ramage wanted to tell. There was no blood in the cabin of the Jaguar, but there was some on the armrest of the Mini Cooper.This indicates the Mini was the first car he touched after the savage killing. One thing’s for sure: he had to move Julie’s car before he could dump her in the boot of his Jaguar. It’s possible he backed the Mini out of the driveway and drove the Jaguar into the garage, dumped Julie’s body in the boot and returned the cars to their original positions, then went inside and cleaned up. If this is the sequence of events then Julie’s body was in the boot of the Jaguar when Debbie Webb drove past and saw both cars at 1 pm. It seems unlikely he’d move two cars in this manner and risk drawing attention to activities at the house. 32
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Debbie had gone shopping with her son at 11 am and wasn’t home when Julie parked in the driveway. If she had been home the sequence of events might have been much clearer. It’s unfortunate the police didn’t press Ramage on the moving of the cars. If only someone had said ‘Debbie Webb saw your car outside number 6. How did you get your wife’s body into the boot when her Mini Cooper was in the driveway?’ Such a question would have exposed the clean-up and the shifting of cars for what it was: a cold-hearted attempt to get away with murder. Julie was dead by 12.38 pm, yet at 7.50 pm that night Ramage would tell her boss, Felicity Holding, she’d been at the house until 2 pm. His version of events was that Julie had driven away and he knew nothing of her whereabouts.Whatever lies he told regarding the killing, it was important to lie about the amount of time Julie spent in the house. If Julie was attacked after only ten or so minutes inside, at worst it would seem like premeditated murder and at best like the actions of an intolerant and domineering thug. A long lunch suggested he had seriously tried to win his wife’s heart, only to be hurt by her callous contempt for him and the renovations. There was no long lunch. Were Ramage’s actions those of a man who’d been bristling with thoughts of revenge? Whatever the truth, he was certainly smart after the event. The real story isn’t that hard to uncover. Once he was sure there’d be no unexpected visit from the plumber he could deal with the body without fear of interruption.With her ankles resting against his hips, Ramage dragged his wife across the floor, through the side door and across the gravel that led to the garage.The gravel cut into her skin so much that she looked like the victim of a flogging. By the time he dumped her alongside the garage door her jumper had been pulled almost from her back. Had he tried to smother her with the jumper or cover her face while he strangled her? Behind was a trail of blood from the A PERFECT DAY
33
injuries to her nose. It was now approximately 12.42 pm. How different she looked from the woman who’d radiated such warmth in a brief exchange with a cleaning lady outside her house fifteen minutes earlier. When Senior Constable Stephen Lake cast an eye over Marock Place at 3.25 pm the next day, the crime scene was framed by a shaft of light that sent long shadows from a defoliating silver birch tree into the court. A large rubbish bin and a smaller crate sat benignly alongside the driveway and the front garage door was up. It looked like any other suburban home. Among the photographs Lake requested from police photographer Senior Constable Lisa Cook was one of a roll of blue rope next to a set of cricket stumps on a shelf in the front eastern corner of the garage, and another of a droplet of blood at the back of the garage.The photographs added a touch of mystery to an otherwise ordinary ‘domestic’ murder. The blood in the garage proved one thing. Julie had spent some time on the floor of the garage. If she’d been carried out of the house and dumped straight in the boot it’s unlikely there’d have been blood on the garage floor. Exactly what happened next is telling. As he prepared to return to the house and wipe up the blood, did he wonder whether she was dead? Did she heave or move in such a way as to leave him thinking she wasn’t dead and that she might be gone when he returned? And did he then grab the rope, cut a piece, burn it at both ends and wrap it around the neck of Julie’s jumper and tighten it until he was certain she was dead? No, says Julie’s twin. She thinks the rope was already cut (and burnt, to stop it fraying) in preparation for the murder. Whether he cut it before or after the murder matters little. Did he use it to finish his wife off? That’s the question. In February 2005 Maria Korp was found unconscious in the boot of her car near the Melbourne Shrine of Remembrance. 34
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Her husband Joe and his girlfriend Tania Herman were subsequently charged with her attempted murder. Maria had been strangled in her garage. Unfortunately for whoever was responsible, Maria wasn’t dead when she was dumped in the boot.This macabre attempted murder proved one thing: it takes an experienced killer to know whether their victim is dead when strangulation has been the method of execution. With his wife now certainly dead, Ramage moved to his next challenge. Cool as a cucumber he walked inside, grabbed a couple of tea towels and a little red bucket and began wiping away his wife’s blood. It was now 12.45 pm. All that Stephen Lake could find the next day were three tiny droplets of blood near the window in the family room and another in the garage. His wife’s blood gone, Ramage packed a change of clothes, eyed the street and waited. It was characteristically quiet in Marock Place as Debbie parked her Volvo in the garage. She wondered momentarily whether she should walk across the court and say hello, just as she’d done when the Ramages moved in eight years earlier. As jaundiced as her view of Ramage was, it would have been hard for her to imagine the mayhem inside her neighbour’s house at that moment. Six weeks earlier she’d seen the top of the removalist’s van above the line of her front fence as Julie shifted her possessions from the house. She knew James Ramage ruled the roost and that he wouldn’t react calmly to his wife leaving him. She recalled the time Julie went to a school function with red hair only to revert to her mousy blonde the next day. Ramage had hit the roof.‘I’m a businessman. I can’t be seen with a wife looking like a tart,’ he told Julie. Although she thought him overbearing, it had never crossed Debbie’s mind that he’d hurt his wife like this. Once Debbie had parked her car in the garage and disappeared into her neat, modern house across the court, Ramage A PERFECT DAY
35
walked to his wife’s Mini, opened the door and pushed back the seat. As he shut the door a tiny droplet of blood was deposited on the armrest. It takes only a couple of minutes to drive from Marock Place to Colombo’s pizza restaurant in Whitehorse Road, Balwyn. It was here, in a parking bay alongside the back door of the restaurant, that he would leave Julie’s car.When the coast was clear he calmly stepped from the car and hurried home across Balwyn Park. At around 1.05 pm he hopped into his Jaguar and reversed into the garage where his wife’s body lay. Debbie Webb didn’t see him walk into the court or drive his Jaguar into the garage. Neither did the eagle-eyed Harry Testro at number 1 nor Max and Betty Muir at number 3. No one saw or heard a thing.Testro has lived at the entrance to the street for thirty-two years.A considered man who doesn’t appear opinionated or likely to thrive on gossip, Harry has seen plenty in Marock Place. ‘Julie was lovely, but he was an angry man, and arrogant as well.’ An angry man, I thought? So too did I ponder what Harry meant when he said it was ‘all very clever and premeditated’. So, was Ramage all bad? On one occasion he’d sent Matthew across to clean the leaves from Harry’s roof gutters. ‘Don’t pay them.They need to learn to help people without getting paid,’ Ramage had told his neighbour. Harry was impressed. ‘What’s he doing moving his car into the garage in the middle of the day?’ Harry might have thought if he’d walked into the street. Hidden from his gaze, Ramage looked down on his wife and opened the boot of his 1998 Jaguar. By now, Julie’s left eye socket was blue and there was blood over her face. It was just as she looked on 18 February 1991, the day he slammed his head into her face. So traumatised was his wife, Ramage was forced to ring Dr Jillian Webster and have her visit the house. She would record that Julie was ‘quite shaken by the episode’ and was suffering a broken nose and a laceration that needed plastic surgery. 36
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
The doctor recommended they visit a psychotherapist.After one visit Ramage convinced his wife it would never happen again, and that was the end of the matter.Twelve years later and only a few blocks away, he finished what he’d started that night. We’ve all seen pictures of a distressed husband in a war-torn country wrapping his arms around a loved one in a sea of wailing. And haven’t we all prayed that it would never be our lot? James Ramage could have been any distraught husband as he reached down and lifted Julie Ramage’s body from the ground. If his son had walked in to the garage, Ramage might have been a loving father who’d returned home to find his wife murdered by some evil stranger. ‘Quick, call the police. Mum’s in trouble,’ he might have said, wiping a tear from his eye. Today, Ramage wasn’t a sad or grieving husband.The absence of a tear in those barren green eyes proved that. He’d killed someone he hated, not the woman he loved. If he’d been able to order a servant to dispose of the body he would have done so. Instead, her head sat on his shoulders, so close he could have kissed her lips and run his hands across that engaging face and through her thick blonde hair. Now she was a dead weight and a burden. In death, just as in life, she was yet again an inconvenience. God only knows what was he thinking as he squeezed his large frame between the rear garage door and the boot of his Jaguar, dropped his wife’s body in the boot, prodded her one last time and covered her with the valance. His wife safely secured in the boot, he walked inside and collected his change of clothes.When the family went on holidays Ramage would spend several hours meticulously packing and designating tasks for his wife. Disposing of his wife was as simple as packing for a holiday. At around 1.10 pm he drove his car out of the garage and headed towards Heidelberg.
A PERFECT DAY
37
BUSH BURIAL
It’s a fifty-minute drive from Balwyn to the bushland off Running Creek Road in Arthurs Creek where James Ramage had decided to bury his wife. He took a direct route via Rosanna and Greensborough Roads and then drove due north along Yan Yean Road. It was while out riding here in 1984, during their first major separation, that he made a stunning promise to his wife:‘I’ll never bully you again. Please come back to me. I promise I’ll change,’ he said. It was one of only a handful of trips to the area. As coincidence would have it, he’d met Jane Ashton to discuss the marriage breakdown nearby, in Yan Yean Road, a couple of weeks before the homicide. She would forever wonder whether he surveyed the territory on his way home in preparation for the final solution. If he were to get away with his murderous attack, it would help if his wife were found in the vicinity of the grounds where she rode. In his wildest dreams, Ramage imagined Laurence Webb as the prime suspect – his wife dead and Webb 38
charged with murder. That would have been the perfect Hollywood ending to the problems they’d created. Once his escape from Balwyn was completed, Ramage made a series of phone calls. At 1.19 pm the East Ivanhoe tower recorded him ringing a mobile number, 0438 559 141.The call took twenty seconds.There was no way the owner of the phone could take the call. Julie Ramage was well and truly dead, and her phone was buried in her Oroton handbag in the boot of the car. James Ramage didn’t know what he might have said if she’d answered the phone and asked where he was taking her.Would he have apologised and asked her forgiveness? Or might he have said, ‘Serves you right for forcing me to lose self-control, you slut’? Exactly one minute after ringing Julie’s mobile he rang her direct line at Eco-d. The call lasted two seconds, with Ramage hanging up before the call went to voice mail. It was the last call he would make until after he buried his wife. Around 2 pm he brought his luxury car to a halt at the gate to an isolated track off Running Creek Road. The locals call it Stolen Car Gully. After opening the gate, he drove 134 metres along the rough bush track past a small dank pond alive with insects. Here the track turns to the left, leaving a clearing to the right, out of sight from the road. With his Jaguar hidden from view he stepped seven metres in an easterly direction and pressed his spade into the soft earth. For a bloke whose only physical exercise was a gentle game of touch rugby and cycling, it was hard work.‘I’d call it an accountant’s grave,’ said one cop. By the time he’d excavated a hole that was one and a half metres in diameter by half a metre deep, his businessman’s body was spent. This would be his wife’s grave. Digging a grave ‘was stupid’, he would later tell his police interrogators. Is that what he really thought as he lifted his wife from the boot of the car, carried her across the bracken and threw her into BUSH BURIAL
39
the pit? Did ‘stupid’ explain why he’d crudely dragged her by the feet from the house rather than carrying her or lifting her by the arms? ‘I hated myself,’ he said to the police. Did this brutality speak of a man who was sorry? To squeeze her into the hole it was necessary for him to turn his wife on her side and bend her legs. As a memento of their time together, Ramage left the bloodied blue jumper he’d worn to the Yan Yean meeting with Jane alongside his wife’s battered head. Near her right wrist was the leather jacket she’d removed when she arrived at the house. His wife dispensed with, Ramage then hurriedly dug a small hole in which he buried the bloodied tea towels, valance, the striped shirt and chino trousers he’d worn at lunch, and his black shoes and watch. And there too was the piece of blue rope. For a brief moment he stood semi-naked, like Adam in the Garden of Eden after the fall.There was, however, a major difference. In keeping with the Scottish Protestantism of his ancestors, he believed the killing of his wife was not his fault. It was really God’s work. It was preordained. Later he would explain exactly what he meant. Even as he dumped her expensive Oroton handbag in the hole, changed his clothes and pulled on his Blundstones, he didn’t believe he’d done anything wrong. It was stupid and he hated himself, he would say, but he never said he was sorry.The word ‘sorry’ had no place in his life. The police didn’t ask him why he dug two holes or whether they might have been dug the day before. Nor did they ask him why the shovel was the only item he brought home. Might the holes have been dug the day before? Only the killer knows the answer to those questions. With a change of clothes he was ready for the next leg of the journey.At 2.35 pm he rang the receptionist at Acropolis Marble and Granite, Despina Panagakis, to say he was in Balwyn and would be in Reservoir to look at a granite benchtop around 40
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
3 pm. At 9.30 am he’d rung Despina to say he wouldn’t be able to make it to the factory.Was the nine-thirty call proof that the killing of his wife had never entered his head until the alleged argument in the kitchen? Maybe he fancied his chances of enticing Julie into his brass bed for an afternoon of wild sex. Or was it all about deception? Was his call to Despina a way of hiding some premeditation of the Arthurs Creek solution? Was he pondering the possibility of killing Julie and dumping her in a bush grave, and that’s why he created this illusion? At around 3 pm he pulled into the Diamond Creek petrol station. Here he spent $56 on petrol using his NationalVisa Gold credit card. It left him with a balance of $28 000. Then, as if he was washing away his sins, he sat in the driver’s seat as his green Jaguar was submerged in a swirl of car wash soap. Was there method in Ramage’s madness? Purchasing petrol in the vicinity of his wife’s makeshift grave was either madness or a stroke of genius. Might it have proved that he was looking for her? Maybe! Jane Ashton still wonders whether a man with no experience in manual work could begin digging two holes at Arthurs Creek at 2 pm and be over in Reservoir by three-thirty in the afternoon. Were the holes already partially dug? Had he imagined killing another person, maybe Laurence Webb, and dumping him in the second hole? Or are these the fanciful thoughts of a grieving and vindictive sister? Whatever the truth, Ramage must have set a frenetic pace. He was in Bundoora when he rang his business partner Tony Brady at 3.17 pm to say he’d be away for the rest of the day. At 3.28 pm he again rang Acropolis Marble, this time to tell Despina he was stuck in traffic on the Broadway, a well-known thoroughfare only a few minutes away. ‘It was weird,’ she said, that he would ring again when he was only a few minutes away and there’d been no exact time for him to be at the factory. BUSH BURIAL
41
Eventually she’d realise that it was all about alibi and that Ramage was methodically trying to build a story that might save him from being accused of murdering his wife. At reception she noticed he was ‘fidgety with his hands’. Was he thinking about what to say to the manager, Lena Tzimas-Koroi, should she offer an outstretched hand and ask how he’d bruised his right hand? Although she didn’t notice his hand she did recall that he’d removed his Blundstones to dislodge a thistle and was wearing blue work socks. He’d been in a hurry at Stolen Car Gully. For all his haste at the gravesite he was unfazed as he confirmed the multicoloured green granite for his kitchen. He was, said Lena ‘well mannered, polite and calm’. Just as Ramage was never asked to explain exactly how he found Stolen Car Gully, so he never clarified the route he took back to Balwyn. The easiest way home was to follow Malua Street into Newlands Road and head south. This route would have taken him past the Coburg Drive-In and within 100 metres of the house where I’d grown up. In the distance he would have seen the northern wall of the old Pentridge Prison. Until it closed in 1999, Pentridge had been home to some famous murderers, some of them wife killers like Peter Keogh, who murdered my sister Vicki. For men who couldn’t fight or wield a weapon, it was a hellhole. What thoughts must have crossed Ramage’s mind as he turned left at Murray Road and, under the shadow of those grim bluestone walls, drove towards Fitzroy and the entrance to the Eastern Freeway? It was close to 4.30 pm when James Ramage’s Jaguar cruised into the driveway at Marock Place.With Matt not due home till after 6 pm he had time to do a little spot-cleaning, throwing his clothes in the washer and running the bath before addressing a matter that had concerned him for some time. Some months earlier Julie’s phone had rung while she was in the shower. He 42
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
rummaged in her handbag to find the phone but missed the call, so he pressed the redial button. It was her lover, Davey. Ramage was suspicious. When he grilled his wife she said it must have been the boyfriend of her colleague Jo McLean from Eco-d. It was one of several near misses. On another occasion she’d accidentally dialled her husband’s mobile number during an outing with her lover and was petrified that her husband might have heard their conversation. As good friends do, Gilda Pekin and Jo McLean agreed to cover for her. Worried about what might eventually happen, Gilda told her she should leave the marriage. Thirty-four-year-old Jo McLean is yet another of the goodlooking blondes who formed Julie’s network of friends and acquaintances. She knew her way around the nightspots. A few weeks after the separation she’d taken a very nervous Mrs Ramage to the Botanical Hotel in SouthYarra.While Jo spent the evening with a high-profile AFL footballer, Julie was left chatting with a businessman from Sydney. Ramage’s defence counsel Philip Dunn would pounce upon the meeting when the time arose. Whatever his failings, Ramage was not a fool. He wasn’t fond of Julie mixing with women who frequented bars and liked men. He knew they were hiding things from him. As the days passed his resentment of them would only increase. In the aftermath of the killing he thought of them as he prepared his defence. In Philip Dunn’s monologue, Julie’s girlfriends would become the weak link. Desperate to build a case against the charge of murdering his wife and to satisfy his doubts, Ramage had rifled his wife’s phone, before burying it in the hole at Arthurs Creek. At 5.40 pm, as he waited for his son, he rang the mobile number he’d found under the name Davey. For whatever reason, he didn’t wait long enough for Julie’s former lover to answer the phone. ‘Unfaithful slut,’ he thought as he ended the call. A few minutes BUSH BURIAL
43
later Samantha Ramage appeared outside Lauriston Girls’ School. The weather had turned nasty and it was cold and windy in Huntingtower Road,Armadale. Her mother was due to pick her up at 5.45 pm and she was never late.When Samantha rang her mother’s mobile it went to message bank. After a short wait she rang her boyfriend then caught the tram to the flat in Toorak. While his daughter fretted about her mother, the killer had other things on his mind. At 6.15 pm his son Matthew arrived home from football training. Ramage, who had good reason to be watching events in the court, greeted him at the front door. There was nothing out of the ordinary in his father’s manner or disposition.‘I’ll take you to dinner at Colombo’s,’ he told his son. ‘I’ll have a bath first,’ he replied. Like his father, Matthew Ramage was fond of a bath. It was a remnant of the Englishness that James secretly believed made him superior to the colonials. At six thirty-five Ramage was back in the Jaguar, this time without his wife’s battered body in the boot. It felt almost normal and he was proud to have his tall, intelligent son alongside him. Bill Kurban emigrated from Lebanon in 1971 and has been the owner of Colombo’s for twenty years. Laconic with a dry sense of humour, Kurban oversees his restaurant like a good publican runs a hotel. Those patrons who remember the US TV detective Colombo are quick to point out the striking resemblance. He has an amusing grasp of the character of his clientele and, like most Lebanese, loves football. ‘Why didn’t you play for Carlton?’ he quipped when I visited his restaurant looking for clues. Ramage had been a customer at the restaurant since he moved to Marock Place, and Bill knew him well. Ramage usually parked in the rear car park and came in via the back entrance. On the night of Julie’s death he remembered Ramage 44
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
walking through the front door at 6.35 pm with his son and taking up a spot at table 40. Although Ramage was his usual serious self as he ate his veal parmigiana and sipped a glass of red, Bill noticed the somewhat intense nature of the conversation. He didn’t hear Ramage step his son through his immediate challenges and prioritise their respective aims and objectives. Nor did he hear Ramage tell the young Matthew he was everything he could have wanted in a son and that his most pressing personal goal was to get over the break-up with his mother. It was close to 7.30 pm when they finished and Ramage walked to the counter to sign for the $35 meal. ‘Where’s your wife?’ asked Bill. ‘She’s away for a few days,’ replied Ramage. Bill’s not sure whether Matthew heard that final comment. If he did he never made mention of it in his police statement. What tale might Ramage have spun if Bill had seen his wife’s car parked outside the back door? ‘How could you eat a meal after murdering your wife?’ Bill said to me with a shake of his head.Whether this was Ramage’s version of the Last Supper and an opportunity to say goodbye to his son, or an act of callous insensitivity, depends on which camp you’re in. To Jane Ashton it confirmed what she’d always thought. He was a man without a heart.To the men who would stick with him it was the action of a sad and lonely man savouring his last moments of freedom. Several times during the evening he would tell his son,‘I love you lots.’ As they drove back in the Jaguar, James Ramage appeared not to have a care in the world. In the passing of a suburban afternoon he’d killed the boy’s mother, dumped her in a pit like a piece of garden refuse and, while sipping a glass of red over dinner, compared how he and his son had scored on their aims and BUSH BURIAL
45
objectives for the week. The restoration of his pride was surely worth a few points on any evaluation sheet. Having reinstated his authority over 5 Marock Place, Ramage continued with his red wine and contemplated his next move. Elsewhere, people who knew Julie were beginning to panic. ‘Have you seen your mum?’ asked Laurence Webb when Samantha answered the phone around 7.30 pm. Once he explained that he’d been ringing her all day she knew there was trouble afoot. Only ten minutes earlier she’d rung her father who’d said, ‘She’s probably off with her boyfriend, Laurence. If she doesn’t come home in an hour, give me a call.’ It was a callous lie to a daughter who would soon be hysterical about her mother’s disappearance.To convince everyone of the righteousness of his actions Ramage had chosen to emphasise her alleged wrongdoings.
46
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
BAD TIDINGS IN RESEARCH
In the peaceful village of Research, just south of Kinglake National Park and the Hurstbridge Adult Riding Club, friends were arriving at Jane Ashton’s house for a committee meeting. It should have been a bright and bubbly night, and would have been, but for the phone call. ‘Hello, Jane Ashton speaking,’ said Julie’s twin. ‘Laurence here, Jane,’ he said, his well-modulated English accent disguising his anxiety. ‘Laurence, how are you?’ ‘Sorry to bother you, Jane. I’ve been speaking with Samantha at Julie’s flat. Julie was supposed to pick her from up from school before six and no one’s seen her. Felicity Holding says Julie didn’t return to Eco-d for a meeting after going out for lunch. I’ve rung Julie on the hour since twelve-thirty and she’s not answering,’ said Webb. Smitten by his new love,Webb was hoping Jane might soothe his fears. She had a different view. ‘Julie’s missing. My sister is dead. He’s killed her,’ she 47
screeched as she dialled Felicity’s mobile number. ‘Is there any news on Julie?’ asked Jane. ‘I’m at Julie’s flat with Samantha and I’ve got Jamie on the other line,’ she replied. ‘Jamie!’ ‘Yes, he thinks Julie might have had a car accident. She left the house at 2 pm. I’m taking Sam back to my place and he says he’ll pick her up there.’ ‘Felicity, don’t let him near her. Don’t let him near her. Say she’s sick. Say anything, but don’t let him take her. I’ll have to go, but please don’t let her go anywhere.’ ‘Liar, bloody liar, he’s killed my sister,’ thought Jane as she put the phone down. It was now 7.50 pm and no one had seen Julie since she left Eco-d for lunch. As much as she agreed to follow Felicity’s advice and ring Missing Persons, Jane Ashton knew it was pointless and ridiculous. Julie wasn’t missing. Her husband had hurt her. ‘Find Jamie and we’ll find Julie,’ she said. Against her better judgment and the weight of evidence she tried to convince herself her twin might still be alive. Hurt and maybe battered, but still alive. The animosity and the fear that fired Samantha’s ‘no, no, no’ when her father had initially said he’d pick her up from her mother’s flat convinced Ramage the game was up. In his police interview he would say, ‘I had a quick meal and then Sam rang up worried about where Julie was and that’s when I thought, I’ll go and see Dyson.’ It was a lie. Ramage had only one goal, to save his skin: ‘Dyson’ was barrister Dyson Hore-Lacy.The killer wasn’t worried about his daughter. She was a mere fifteen years of age, yet he’d left her waiting at school for her mother and knew she’d be panic-stricken. Not once did he try to contact her. And when she rang all he talked about was rowing and trivia. Samantha Ramage knew about her father’s violence. Not 48
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
only had her mother told her about it, she’d experienced it herself.The day he backhanded her leaving her with a black eye was enough for her to know he was dangerous. She knew he’d done something to her mother. Lorna Cleary was only fifty-four years of age when she picked up the phone at eight-fifteen on the morning of 26 August 1987 and heard the words ‘Peter Keogh’s stabbed Vicki, you’d better come quickly.’ In her dreams the night before, my mum had seen a vision of a coffin. As much as she searched, Mum couldn’t identify the face or the body. Once she heard those words, it all made sense.The news that a man has killed the woman in his life is never really a surprise to those who’ve watched the relationship collapse. Lorna Cleary, Samantha Ramage and Jane Ashton had seen it coming but were incapable of stopping it. Jane Ashton wouldn’t have been surprised to hear that Ramage had chillingly told Felicity Holding, ‘You don’t know what’s been happening over the past month.’ ‘I don’t care about that. I’ve got a hysterical girl here and you need to do something about it,’ the uncompromising Felicity had told him. While his frantic daughter pleaded with Felicity to reassure her that ‘Daddy wouldn’t hurt Mummy’, the killer plotted a course and filled his head with hatred for his wife.As he did, Jane dialled the 000 police emergency line and explained that her sister was missing. It was the first of a stream of phone calls in a night of despair. Highly organised like Julie and rarely known to cry in public, Jane had work to do. She and her friends, who’d soon be joined by Webb, began ringing hospitals for word that Julie might be lying injured in an emergency ward. At the same time others set off for Ramage’s factory in Collingwood and the beach house near Lorne. Jane knew her sister would not be found alive. BAD TIDINGS IN RESEARCH
49
Around 8 pm the man Jane had already fingered for killing her sister put the phone back on its receiver, lifted the crystal glass to his lips, took a sip and placed it on the table. ‘I’m leaving now. I love you lots. I’ll see you soon,’ he said to his son, squeezing the cork into the half-empty bottle of wine and grabbing his keys. Despite his apparent calm, the killer knew things were afoot and that he needed help. His daughter had seen enough to suspect he’d killed her mum.And if she suspected this then it was only a matter of time. Out of earshot, he quickly dialled the mobile phone of Dyson Hore-Lacy. Ramage was a social climber who liked to brag about wellknown people in his circle. So often did he speak about the barrister, many people concluded that they were best of mates. Hore-Lacy says they were only acquaintances. Whatever the depth of their friendship, it was a frenetic conversation. His version is that Ramage said he needed professional help and that when he asked whether it might wait until the morning Ramage gave an emphatic ‘no’. ‘Can you come round?’ said Hore-Lacy. ‘I’d rather meet somewhere,’ replied Ramage. It was agreed they’d meet at the Harp Hotel, which was just up the road from where the barrister was having dinner with his female companion. ‘See you shortly, in the gaming room,’ said Ramage.The eminent silk will tell you a criminal barrister is never really shocked by the trouble that can engulf people. He says Ramage didn’t elaborate on what had happened until they met. Given the phone call lasted one minute and twenty-one seconds, I think the killer must have done more than say, ‘Can we meet to discuss a problem?’ As Ramage backed his car out of the drive he half expected to see a police car, sirens wailing, roar into the court. ‘Must get 50
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
away, she’s on to me,’ he thought as he drove down Boston Road and turned into Mont Albert Road. Around 8.45 pm Felicity Holding rang Jane to say Ramage hadn’t turned up at her house to collect Sam and that he’d been gone from Marock Place since 8 pm.‘He’s probably trying to leave the country,’ thought Jane as she banged out her sister’s phone number at Marock Place. ‘Hello, Matt, it’s Jane here.Your dad hasn’t picked Sam up. Can you check the filing cabinet and see if his passport is still in the house,’ she said. Confused by the rapidly unfolding events, the boy did as he was told. ‘It’s still there,’ he said upon his return. What a disaster, she thought. When constables Leanne Booth and Mick McGill arrived at Jane’s home at 8 pm her version of events was straightforward. ‘He’s strangled her and put her in the boot. I know it. He’s been violent before. Just go and find him,’ she pleaded with the two young officers, when they placed a Missing Persons form on the table. ‘We have to search the house and have you complete this form,’ they said. If she’d had her way there’d have been a police car blocking Ramage’s retreat. Instead, Ramage had made his escape. ‘Search the house? We’ve got ten acres. Have you got a torch?’ she replied, her frustration growing.When they asked her what clothes Julie had been wearing her anger was almost uncontrollable. ‘I don’t know. I’ll ring and find out.’ While the police rummaged around in Jane’s house the phones ran hot. By 8.16 pm they’d completed their report and established that Julie Ramage, bookkeeper and mother, was now officially a missing person.A few kilometres away a stony silence, interrupted only by the steady fall of rain, had enveloped the track where Julie lay. Like a cat with a dead rat, Ramage had left his wife’s body on her sister’s doorstep.An act of revenge against the woman he believed had been complicit in his humiliation, it BAD TIDINGS IN RESEARCH
51
was the final insult and an affirmation of his ultimate power. If his wife loved the area so much she could be buried there. Horse riding in Hurstbridge had offered Julie the freedom she craved. What better way of crushing that freedom than burying her in the place where she had frolicked with her boyfriend? Sometime after 8 pm, Dyson Hore-Lacy walked into the Harp Hotel in Kew. A man with a distinctive presence and an alluring voice, he is known as a fearless defender of human rights. In 1994 he’d represented serial woman killer Paul Denyer in the appeal court. At the Victorian coronial hearing into the 1989 police shooting of Gary Abdullah in inner suburban Carlton, he delivered a withering attack on the police. No theatre, just hard nosed indignation and logic. ‘Would Gary Abdullah really point a toy pistol at his police captors?’ Dyson had asked rhetorically.‘No, he was shot like a dog on a leash,’ he said. Abdullah had been accused of driving the getaway car after the murder of two young policemen in South Yarra in 1988. Dyson’s accusations made him no friends in a police force bent on revenge. He knew a victim when he saw one. At the Harp Hotel he was in no position to take the high moral ground.The man he’d met as a Deepdene Primary School parent was now a killer. Hore-Lacy says that after he told Ramage his friendship with Julie precluded him from acting as his counsel, he rang barrister Steven Pica and some time later moved to another table to avoid any conflict of interest. If Ramage chose not to take the witness stand and be cross-examined at trial the only version of the alledged murder available to the crown prosecutor was his police interview. The next three hours were spent ensuring that his interview would not be incriminating. By the end of the night Ramage knew exactly what to say once the cameras were activated at the Homicide offices. 52
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
A busy looking man with a wave of brushed back, black hair, Pica looks like he’s stepped from the set of West Side Story or Grease. He is no stranger to the sins of the rich and famous. Only two months earlier Pica had sat opposite Michael Tovey QC in Court 2 of the Melbourne Supreme Court delivering snippets of information for the defence.Their client was Matthew Wales, the killer in what would become known as the Wales-King ‘society murders’. Representing Matthew’s wife, Maritza, in court was Philip Dunn QC. Maritza Wales, who found out about the murders on the night they were committed, had been charged with perverting the course of justice. Soon Pica and Dunn would be reacquainted, this time as part of the defence of James Ramage. While the killer built then rehearsed his case at the pub, it was business as usual across the road in the Boroondara police station. Constables Pickett and Lowe were driving the streets of Kew while Constable Peios manned the front counter. It wasn’t until close to midnight that Lowe and Pickett, unaware that Ramage was on his way to Boroondara police station, received instructions to go to Marock Place. What a difference it might have made if they’d happened upon Ramage before Pica got to him.Would he have dispensed with the lies and simply told the truth? And what was the truth? That after some discussion, his wife repeated what he already knew, that she wasn’t coming back, and at 12.34 pm she said,‘I must go, James, I have a meeting at work’? At 11.40 pm, Ramage and Pica left the Harp Hotel and walked across the road to the Boroondara Police Station at 34 Harp Road in Kew. As they did, Ramage pointed to his Jaguar, parked about 100 metres down the road. Unbeknown to the killer, a further 100 metres beyond his car was a little weatherboard house with a similar tale of murder. Here on the night of BAD TIDINGS IN RESEARCH
53
19 November 1987, Kevin Crowe shot dead his estranged wife Christine Boyce, in front of her two young children. She was only twenty-eight years old. At trial Crowe would be granted a defence of provocation and be found guilty of manslaughter. A little further up Harp Road is the Life Development Centre. The centre specialises in the treatment of all manner of psychological ailments, including those that allegedly cause men to kill. On the Friday before the killing, on the advice of Rob Moodie, Ramage visited the centre looking for help. It was his fifth visit to a marriage counsellor since his wife had left him. After rating his anxiety level at ten out of ten he went on to tell director Pauline McKinnon he would never again hit his wife. As with so much Ramage had said over the previous month, it would turn out to be a lie. He was due back on Tuesday for a meditation session. After three hours with Pica at the Harp Hotel, Ramage was prepared for the ordeal that lay ahead. He now knew that the only way out of the predicament was to plead provocation.That meant painting a picture of victimhood and, when the time arose, convincing a jury that the dead woman had insulted his sexual prowess and his dignity. Ramage was ready to tell that story. ‘My name is Stephen Pica. I’m a solicitor. I’m here with my client who wants to hand himself in for a homicide,’ Pica told Constable Jimmy Peios.The official story of the murder of Julie Ramage had begun. Constable Peios asked Ramage and Pica to take a seat while he sought assistance in the form of a superior officer.At the same time, Sergeant Paul O’Connell was making his way to Marock Place. Stationed at Doncaster, O’Connell had received a call at 10.45 pm from Acting Sergeant Carl Stella at Eltham police station in relation to a missing person. He soon knew that the 54
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
woman was Julie Ramage and would record that there was a history of ‘violence between the missing person and her husband’. It was a curious way of describing Ramage’s violence towards his wife. It was also recorded that the woman’s ‘estranged husband, James Ramage, drove a Silver/green Jaguar registration RJG 414’. More than three hours had passed since Jane Ashton had notified police her sister was missing and told them she was sure Ramage had ‘strangled her and put her in the boot of his car’. In the hours that followed, his car sat like a beacon in sight of the Boroondara police station, until at midnight it was wrapped in crime scene tape. After a rendezvous with Constables Lowe and Pickett at the corner of Boston and Mont Albert Roads, Sergeant O’Connell pulled up at 5 Marock Place. In the driveway was Gilda Pekin’s silver Honda. It had been a bad night for Julie’s best friend. She’d tried unsuccessfully to contact Julie during the day and at 8 pm had taken a call from a clearly distressed Samantha. It set the alarm bells ringing.All she could think about was what he might have done and whether her revelation a week earlier about Laurence Webb had backfired.When Jane rang at 9 pm and said ‘Jamie’s gone missing, can you go round to Marock Place to look after Matthew?’ she feared the worst. Gilda was so frightened she took her son with her. Gilda and Julie had first met in 1985 at the health centre in Cherry Road, Balwyn. Julie was impressed that her friend had studied law as a mature age student and would often talk with her about engaging in further studies. A sometimes pessimistic woman with a quietly understated strength of character, she was genuinely scared of the physically imposing and hot-headed Ramage. She’d heard all about his violence and intimate details of Julie’s sex life. She told Julie that what her husband demanded in bed amounted to rape and she should leave. Her friend BAD TIDINGS IN RESEARCH
55
agreed, but shrugged her shoulders as if it was her lot in life. While Ramage rehearsed his defence a few blocks away at the Harp, Gilda Pekin sat in the lounge room and remembered the dinner parties with James at the head of the table, and the same men dominating the conversation; she saw it so vividly. And as the time passed her imagination only became more florid. On the family room floor she’d seen stains she thought looked very much like blood. No amount of corporate legal training would have fortified her had the confident and imposing Ramage arrived at the door. She was nervous and worried. It was 11.40 pm when the phone rang. ‘Hello,’ she said. ‘Can I speak with Matt?’ was the dismissive reply. There was nothing unusual about James Ramage’s perfunctory demand, and Gilda was not so brazen as to ask any questions. Women quickly learnt their place in Ramage’s world. And it was to the apple of his eye, son Matthew, not some feminist interloper, that he’d confirm what had happened. In what Matthew described as a stuttering tone, his father said he was ‘on the way to the police station and probably won’t be home tonight’, to which his son replied, ‘Where’s Mum?’ ‘That’s why I’m going to the police station now. Make sure you tell your sister I am going to the police station and that I love her lots. I’ve got to go, but I love you lots,’ were his father’s last words. It was a puzzling conversation. It seems strange that he didn’t press his father to elaborate on why he wouldn’t be home and where his mum might be. No sooner had Gilda rung Jane with the news about Ramage than Sergeant O’Connell was at the door of 5 Marock Place. Within a few minutes of his arrival at the house the sergeant received a phone call from Boroondara police station informing him that James Ramage had ‘surrendered himself ’ and admitted 56
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
to killing his wife. Julie had been dead nearly twelve hours. In the same conversation O’Connell learned, through Pica, that Julie had been killed in the family room and was ‘buried in the Kinglake area’, a vast tract of bushland northeast of Melbourne. ‘He can show you where but he doesn’t know how to tell you how to get there,’ said Pica, when asked the exact location of the burial. When Sergeant O’Connell delivered the news of his mother’s death to Matthew, he stared into the abyss then plunged his face into his hands. In response to O’Connell’s request for a statement he simply replied, ‘OK, OK.’ It wasn’t until 4.45 am on Tuesday morning that Matthew Ramage gave his account of the previous day’s activities to the police. Notwithstanding his tiredness and the trauma he’d undergone, his police statement raised so many questions. Not once did he make a specific or even passing reference to his mother’s visit to the house. If it was so important for Julie to like the renovations and for her son to know she did, why didn’t James talk about it with his son? It’s hard to believe that when Matthew arrived home he didn’t ask his dad about the lunchtime rendezvous – after all, he knew she was coming to the house. If Julie had belittled Ramage at lunch then surely he’d have told his son during the dinner at Colombo’s. It might even have been the time to say he’d killed Julie.Was it because it was a fabrication that Ramage didn’t tell his son Julie had ridiculed him and the renovations? At the time of the dinner Ramage could hardly have known that such a story might form the basis of a provocation defence. Surely he only learnt about the mysterious laws of provocation when he met Hore-Lacy and Pica? Although the defence team had sought sympathy for their client by claiming he’d wanted to plead guilty, no such sympathy was warranted. Julie had done nothing to hurt him except say she wasn’t coming back. Instinct and common sense told him BAD TIDINGS IN RESEARCH
57
that the only way he could escape a murder charge was by burying her body and covering up the killing. Ramage’s so-called interest in pleading guilty didn’t place him in a good light. It was an admission that he’d killed his wife in cold blood. Prior to Matthew Ramage making his statement Gilda Pekin offered him some well-meaning but strange advice.‘Nothing will bring your mother back, but you don’t need to put your dad in a bad light,’ she told him. Coming from a woman who’d lost her best friend to a man for whom she had little regard and knew to have been violent to Julie, it was very strange. Nevertheless it might explain why Matthew appears to have excised his mother from his statement. Even at 7.20 pm when he became aware that his sister was looking for their mother, he appears not to have asked his father whether she had told him where she was going. Not even the phone call in which his aunt asked him to look for his dad’s passport was recorded in his statement. Whenever the police investigate spouse murder they make every effort to record prior violence by the killer.When it came to retelling the story of his father head-butting his mother in 1991, Matthew’s response was apologetic. ‘Dad punched Mum, which resulted in her having a broken nose. I was aware that this had been sorted out and both parties regretted the situation. Dad also said that Mum said the nastiest things to him and questioned his ability.’There was no place for the word ‘sorry’ in Matthew’s account of his father’s wrongdoings. Sadly, Julie’s son had become a victim of his father’s selfish manipulation. It was something that would trouble Julie’s friends and family. No matter what Ramage said to his son that night, there was one irrefutable fact. Julie Ramage was officially dead and Marock Place was now a crime scene. No one in the street had ever expected to see blue and white police tape across a neighbour’s front yard. But there it was, running from above the little white 58
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
letterbox, around the garbage bin to the western fence.At 1.40 am, the man responsible for putting Marock Place on the map was escorted to the toilet then taken to an interview room in the homicide offices in St Kilda Road.‘Where are my children?’ asked an otherwise emotionless Ramage. After some preliminary interviews and a further wait while the police went about their business, Ramage agreed to show them where he’d buried his wife. At 2.50 am, Detective Senior Constable Darren Wiseman handed Ramage a Melways street directory. In the top right hand corner was Arthurs Creek Road and an arrow with directions to Running Creek Road, on the edge of the Kinglake National Park. On the same page was the location of the restaurant in Yan Yean Driving Range where he’d met Jane Ashton a few weeks earlier, and where Julie used to have coffee with Davey. It took Wiseman, Detective Senior Sergeant Jeff Maher and Detective Senior Constable Mark McCann forty-two minutes to reach the 200-acre bushland property, Majella. They arrived there at 3.42 am. Ramage didn’t tell his captors the property next door belonged to Julie’s good friend Louise Barry. Louise had enticed her to begin jumping at the Hurstbridge Adult Riding Club. I met Louise at the gravesite during the trial and heard all about Julie’s courage and determination on a horse and how she’d once become almost hysterical when her car broke down and she feared she’d be late home. Louise Barry suffers from MS and has battled it for years.These days there’s a special trophy on her mantelpiece. Louise was the first recipient of the Julie Ramage Memorial Award for best club member. Once inside the entrance to the bushland property the police were led to the clearing where Ramage had parked his Jaguar. The property is so large and isolated, Julie’s body might have lain there for years. From the clearing, Ramage pointed to a green sapling in a sea of bracken. ‘That’s where I buried her,’ he said. BAD TIDINGS IN RESEARCH
59
At no point did he mention anything about a second hole. Nor did he break down and cry. It was now close to 4 am on the morning of Tuesday 22 July. Robert Ellks is the sergeant in charge of the Kinglake police station and was rostered on duty from midnight on Monday night. At 3.30 am he answered his mobile and was requested to attend Running Creek Road. Here he met Detective Senior Sergeant Maher, who explained that a woman was in a rough grave up the track.At 4.28 am Ellks took up a post alongside the gate and began the process of filling in his crime scene log. At 4.30 am, after nearly an hour at the burial site, Ramage was bundled into the police car and driven back to Boroondara police station, where he was placed in a cell. From 5 am until he was roused at just after 10 am, he acquired his first real taste of prison life. He would later say he didn’t get much sleep. From here he was taken to the Homicide offices in St Kilda Road and led to an interview room. At 11.33 am on Tuesday 22 July the video camera was activated and Ramage gave his first account of what had happened almost twenty-four hours earlier. ‘I was totally devastated when she moved out. I didn’t understand it. The relationship was fine,’ he told Senior Constable Darren Wiseman and his partner Detective Mark McCann. From his wife snubbing him on the renovations and gesticulating a ‘wank, wank’ motion with her hands, to the final belittling words ‘sex with you would repulse me’, Ramage’s onehour confession followed the script. It was the kind of rambling story, studded with feigned remorse and memory lapses, that a defence lawyer loves. ‘I just can’t believe…and I can’t remember getting off,’ he replied, when asked if his wife fought back as he strangled her. ‘I think she held her arm up. I…I can remember hitting her and holding her neck. I can’t remember anything else.’ 60
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
‘I got – yeah, I got up off the…and I couldn’t believe what I’d done, and I wandered around and then I dunno, it was plain stupid…just stupid,’ he said, when asked whether he let her go during the struggle. And why didn’t he contact anyone? ‘I just realised – stupid. I should have done something.’ And parking her car at Colombo’s restaurant? ‘I know the whole thing was just stupid…cos I knew I would be…It was just stupid.’ What about the choice of burial site? ‘I know that area a bit and just drove until I came to that spot. I knew I was gonna do something stupid…Julie rides up there and just would be, no, no reason.’ And when he got there? ‘Dug the hole and put Julie in it and then hated myself.’ When you run a careful eye over Ramage’s offerings, there’s a stench of deceit that no smartarse lawyer can hide.There’s no way that Julie Ramage would use a ‘wank, wank’ gesture with her hand on an imaginary cock. Such pranks are the work of men, not women. Equally, a woman who told everyone she feared her husband would kill her was hardly likely to say ‘sex with you would repulse me’. In any case, thirteen days earlier Ramage had told psychologist Sharon Marcus that his wife could no longer imagine having sex with him. There was no sudden revelation.The so-called sexual taunt was nothing more than a dressed-up version of what she’d already told him. She was over him and wasn’t coming back. Between 11.33 am and 12.54 pm on Tuesday 22 July Ramage was asked 403 questions. Many of the questions amount to little more than an ‘Mmm?’ with answers like ‘Yeah’, or others that run for a couple of lines. Unlike the crime shows that dominate our TV sets it’s far from an interrogation and there’s little if any BAD TIDINGS IN RESEARCH
61
pressure from the police questioners.The killer rambles and the police gently seek out the information they think they need. Even when Ramage deliberately fumbled with his recollection of the killing there was little attempt by Wiseman to nail him on facts. The police had their man and he’d admitted to strangling his wife.What more did they need? Julie’s friends thought this was an open and shut case of murder. But was Detective Wiseman thinking provocation as he led the killer through his questions? I don’t think so. The prosecution would need a lot more evidence to weather the accusation that ‘promiscuous’ Julie Ramage had taunted and provoked him. Ramage was now fighting for his life and well understood what he should say to build a provocation defence. His response to Question 283 offers a snapshot of the preparation that had gone into his defence. ‘What did you do once you got there?’ asked Detective Wiseman. ‘Dug the hole and put Julie in it and then hated myself. And then drove back and all the way I was thinking I should just go and see someone…gonna go and see Dyson, who’s a family friend…and then I thought, well I’ll go back and see Matt and we went and had a quick meal and then Sam rang up worried about Julie and that’s when I thought I’ll go and see Dyson.’ Strip away the feigned confusion and the answer bristles with deceit. Dyson wasn’t a family friend. He was an eminent defence barrister. And the only reason Ramage decided to see him was because he knew that after his daughter Samantha’s emotional phone call at 7.50 pm, the game was up. A more significant act of deceit was his attempt to hide the existence of the second hole. In the police interview Ramage told Detective Wiseman ‘I dug a hole’. In fact, he dug two holes.The longer the police were in the dark about the second hole the better it was for the killer. Eventually they would have found it, but if they’d known about 62
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
the second hole when they drove him to Running Creek Road, they’d have known much earlier about the rope. It wasn’t until just before midday, almost twenty-four hours after Ramage strangled his wife, that Detective Wiseman came upon the existence of the second hole.Although Ramage had earlier said he’d changed his clothes and left his bloodstained jumper ‘out there’ he’d steadfastly avoided mentioning that he’d buried the clothes in a second hole. Not until question 289 was the impasse broken.‘You said the jumper, what about your chinos and shirt, where did you take [them]?’ asked Wiseman.At this stage the detective was unaware of the import of the question. ‘That in – in another hole,’ replied Ramage. After a series of short questions regarding the location of the second hole, Wiseman then said,‘Alright, what did you put in that then? What about the towels, where did they go?’Thinking there was nothing of interest in the second hole, the detective had lost the opportunity to entice Ramage to either lie about the contents of the hole or tell the truth and mention the rope.The revelation of a second hole seemed to pass without any alarm bells going off. There is no reference in any of the police statements to someone at Homicide ringing Sergeant Ellks at Running Creek Road and asking him to search for the second hole. At 12.14 pm, approximately fifteen minutes after the detectives learnt about this second hole, the interview was suspended. It would be resumed twenty-four minutes later at 12.38 pm and conclude at 12.54 pm on Tuesday afternoon, without a single question about the rope. Presumably, by the time the interview resumed the detectives at Homicide were made aware of what was in the second hole. If they weren’t, you’d think they’d surely have held on to Ramage until the contents were known. It seems the rope wasn’t considered that important.
BAD TIDINGS IN RESEARCH
63
AT THE GRAVESITE
On the morning of Tuesday 22 July, Stolen Car Gully was a hive of activity. Forensic expert Stephen Lake had arrived at the site of the burial at 8.30 am. Sandy haired and with a degree in applied chemistry, it was Senior Constable Lake’s role to gather anything, visible or otherwise to the naked eye, that related to this apparent murder. The sun was up and there was a shaft of light through the eucalypts that marked the spot where Ramage had covered his wife. Lake described it as ‘a pile of scrub, logs and bracken 134 metres north along the track and 7 metres in an easterly direction’. He went on to say that a ‘small portion of the deceased’s blue pants and arm were exposed from the soil covering the rest of the body’. Before the excavation began, Lake was photographed standing knee high in bracken with his left hand pointing towards the base of the tree in front of which Ramage had put his spade to work. The excavation of her body, as documented by Senior Constable Lisa Cook’s camera, is a sad and humiliating story. At 64
first we see her lying, almost peacefully, on her left side in the pit under the shadow of the sapling. She could have been a clay statuette. It’s when Cook steps forward and photographs her from the front that the true horror of what Ramage did is inescapable. With her jumper wrapped around her left wrist, her upper body naked except for a blue bra and her head tilted back, she looks almost grotesque. Her husband always knew she took her appearance seriously. The picture is a grievous insult to her dignity. Not even the gold chains around her wrist and neck and the ring in her ear could camouflage the humiliation. Julie Ramage was a pitiful sight. How could the young bride have imagined that one day she’d be found smattered with blood and clay in a hole dug by the man who pressed a ring on her finger in the Northaw Church and promised to love and honour her? Once Lake rolled her onto her right side there was no mistaking the ferocity of the attack. Although Dunn would cajole Dr Lynch into saying Ramage had used only moderate force to kill Julie, the photos spoke of savagery. It may not have been a mass grave such as those in the Balkans or Nazi Germany, but it reeked of the same hatred. So much of her blood did Ramage spill, it was matted in her hair, congealed on her back and spread over the patch of dirt where her head had been. While Lisa Cook’s camera documented the unearthing of Julie Ramage the killer waited for the question that might destroy him.‘What about the rope, James? What was the purpose of the rope you buried in the second hole?’ It was the one question for which he had no answer.When Detective Wiseman said, ‘I’ll conclude the interview. Do you agree that the time is now approximately 6 minutes to 1 pm in the afternoon by my watch?’ Ramage simply said,‘Yes.’ He might not have shown any emotion, but he must have been very relieved. AT THE GRAVESITE
65
Ramage knew that if a jury genuinely suspected he’d wrapped a piece of rope around his wife’s neck and finished her off, he was in trouble.Without the rope in the picture he had a much better chance of convincing a court he was just an ordinary man out of control when he strangled her. Five minutes after the interview with Ramage ended at the Homicide offices, Stephen Lake handed Julie’s handbag to Detective Senior Constable Andrew Payne at Stolen Car Gully. It was just after 1 pm on Tuesday afternoon.The rope was then placed on a piece of brown paper with the two tea towels for Senior Constable Cook to photograph.Twenty minutes later in St Kilda Road Dr Marginean examined the killer and concluded that he was ‘alert, oriented and generally composed and that his right hand was swollen and there were a few small red abrasions over the knuckles’. Ramage said he’d acquired them rowing on Sunday. Just after 2.30 pm Detectives Wiseman and McCann drove him to the Magistrate’s Court, where he was remanded in custody to reappear in the court for a committal mention, on 25 November 2003.At the committal mention Ramage’s counsel would learn the names of the witnesses being called by the crown and be provided with their statements. Under Victorian law an accused person cannot be reinterviewed over the same offence once he has been formally charged. Ramage had made his last public utterance on the question of what he’d done to his wife.The usual legal procedural issues, including Ramage’s right to sufficient time to prepare his case, meant that his next appearance in the Magistrate’s Court would occur on Wednesday 5 May 2004. Although it was a mere formality that Ramage would be committed to stand trial for murder, it would be a long and arduous wait for the Garrett family. While Ramage was being processed at the Melbourne Remand Centre alongside Spencer Street Station, Detectives Maher and Wiseman were in discussion with forensic man Stephen Lake at 66
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Marock Place.There’s no record of what they said as they walked across the garage floor and pointed to the roll of blue rope. It wasn’t the first time Maher had investigated a ‘domestic murder’. He’d been part of the Homicide crew that arrested Robert Parsons in 1997 after the murder of his wife. Not even the bluster of Philip Dunn could convince Justice Cummins to give Parsons a provocation defence. Although Maher thought it was possible the rope had a role in the homicide, he didn’t put great store on it. In his mind Ramage had planned the murder of his wife and strangled her with his bare hands. It was an open and shut case. He couldn’t countenance the idea that the killer would be granted a provocation defence. With her mum and dad in Queensland and her husband Howard and daughter Charlotte in England, it could not have been a more catastrophic and lonely time for Jane Ashton. After ringing Gilda on Monday evening she steeled herself to talk to her parents, who were in their caravan getting ready for bed. How nice of Jane to ring for a chat, her mum thought when she heard her voice. It was around 9.30 pm and they’d spent a wonderful day at the beach. The futile question, ‘Have you heard from Julie?’ was all that was needed to break her mother’s state of calm.When Ray Garrett saw the colour drain from his wife’s face he knew it was bad tidings. Julie was missing. They knew she would never be found alive.While they sat in a caravan waiting for further updates from their daughter, the man who’d ruined their lives trawled back and forth through the story that might save him from murder. It was just after midnight when Jane rang to tell her parents the awful truth.‘I’m sorry, Dad. She’s dead.They haven’t got the body. But James has admitted killing her. Julie’s dead.’ ‘Oh no, Jane,’ said her father, age suddenly seeming to have caught up with him. AT THE GRAVESITE
67
At 6 am on Tuesday 22 July, Sergeant Paul O’Connell knocked on Jane’s door in Research. She and Laurence Webb listened as O’Connell explained all that had happened.The body had been found and Jane now officially knew that a shallow grave alongside a bush track a few kilometres away had been her sister’s last resting place. Her mirror image was dead. She couldn’t believe it.As much as she’d never trusted James Ramage, Jane still found it hard to believe he could kill the mother of his children and dump her under a cover of dirt and bracken. ‘You liar.You cowardly liar. My father was right.’As the events of the last twenty-three years tumbled through her mind she remembered her dad’s words: ‘He’s no good. Only harm will come of it’. She thought of the day Julie had stepped between Ray Garrett and his son-in-law at a social gathering to stop blood being spilled, and the telephone conversations and lunchtime meetings with Ramage in the weeks before the kiling. She couldn’t get them out of her head. He was always going to kill her. It broke her heart to have to tell her husband. Howard Ashton took the news with a mixture of disbelief and fatalism. He’d never liked Jane’s brother-in-law. The son of an identical twin sister, he understood the unique bond between the women. A week after leaving Australia, Howard Ashton was back in Research with the woman he loved. Do men who kill the woman they claim to love ever think about how many lives they hurt? And why do they do it? Jane Ashton didn’t need to ask that question. She had always known what made James Ramage tick.
68
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
DADDY’S RICH, MUMMY’S GOOD LOOKING
On Sunday 20 July 2003, the sun was shining, the temperature was around seventeen degrees and there was hardly a breath of wind in Melbourne. There was no AFL football that weekend, so the city wasn’t reverberating with the roar of wild fans at Optus Oval, the MCG and Telstra Dome. The Richmond Football Club had organised a game between the Tiger legends of yesteryear and the Allies, a collection of former footballers, me included, at the famous old Punt Road Oval. One of the Tiger legends, and a star of the 1967 and 1969 premierships, Bill Barrot, had collapsed under a barrage of chest pains. ‘I hope they’ve booked a bed at the Epworth Hospital for me,’ Billy had remarked with a laugh as we took up our positions after quarter-time. Half an hour later a heart attack went close to killing him. It was touch and go for Barrot for the next few days. Julie Ramage didn’t care too much for football. It was the last thing on her mind as she frolicked with her lover Laurence Webb in the Kinglake foothills and made erotic, uncomplicated 69
love on Sunday. Death seemed a million miles away. ‘The next forty years are going to be different and they’ll be on my terms,’ she told her friends.The next day, as Barrot fought to stay alive, Julie was driving towards Balwyn and her own demise. While the football world celebrated Barrot’s escape from potential death, a small piece appeared in Wednesday’s Herald Sun newspaper about a Balwyn businessman who’d strangled his wife and buried her body on a dirt track north-east of the city. Exactly twenty-four hours after Barrot collapsed Ramage was parking his car at the Acropolis marble factory, off Newland’s Road, Reservoir, two kilometres north of the working class neighbourhood that had been so much a part of my childhood. If Jane had chosen to ring me the day before Ramage set his trap, rather than after her sister’s death, things might have been different. From the moment Justice George Hampel granted Peter Keogh a defence of provocation, then sentenced him to three years and eleven months in gaol for the manslaughter of my sister, my attitude to these matters was changed forever. Treat every man harassing an ex-partner as a potential killer.That’s what I told Julie McAllister, four years before Julie Ramage was killed. McAllister had begun living with Keogh soon after he was released from gaol in 1991.When she kicked him out of her home in Lake Tyers in 2000 he became threatening.Ten months later he torched her home. Fearing he’d be charged with arson and face a long gaol sentence, Keogh gassed himself in his car. At least McAllister wasn’t dead. Sending killers to gaol isn’t the solution to wife murder. Stopping them before they inflict their act of humiliation is the challenge. ‘Get an intervention order and don’t let him near your sister. Don’t let him near her on any account,’ would have been my advice to Jane. In a letter written to me after the trial Jane lamented not telling her sister to take such an escape route: 70
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Don’t let him down gently. Don’t worry about the children. Don’t worry about protecting family and friends. Don’t leave a note you’ve agonized over, in a clean house, with a freezer stocked with food. Don’t go to counselling so you can get away safely. Just leave a note saying,‘Fuck off you dickhead I’ve had enough’, and then run away, as far as you can go, and never ever come back.
Although the details were sketchy, I knew Ramage would plead provocation. Outside Canterbury and Balwyn and the school communities of Scotch and Lauriston, no one was talking about Julie Ramage. A photo of the couple and a few lines in the newspaper had been enough to satisfy everyone. A man killing his wife, even on the turf of lawyers, judges and the captains of industry, was not an affront to bourgeois sensibilities.And the private school boys who made the laws weren’t running around King Street’s legal precinct expressing outrage about wife murder.A man’s home was his castle and Ramage had rights. For now it looked like yet another run-of-the-mill wife murder. Because of the need for an autopsy, Julie’s funeral couldn’t be held until ten days after her death. Jane Ashton described the wait as a nightmare. From his prison cell the killer was still pulling the strings. Although his name was never invoked James Ramage was adamant it would be a society funeral. Having assumed that it was the responsibility of the Garretts to bury Julie, the family chose Montsalvat, an Eltham reception centre that had begun its life as an artist colony. The beautiful Gothic buildings were near where she rode and it was a place her family loved. It was also synonymous with her freedom. Ramage eventually had his way and it was agreed that St John’s Church in Toorak would host the funeral and Montsalvat the wake. In his gaol cell, one week after walking into the local DADDY’S RICH, MUMMY’S GOOD LOOKING
71
police station and admitting to killing his wife, James Ramage, businessman and associate of the well-heeled Canterbury set, would run a self-serving eye over his son’s funeral speech.‘Make sure you mention our happy family life and don’t forget to put a red rose on Mum’s coffin for me,’ he would tell his son. The final dinner at Colombo’s had been part of the plan to save what was left of his family. His son’s acquiescence gave every indication it had worked. There were no camera bulbs flashing and no television cameras tracing the steps of Ramage’s children and the dead woman’s friends at the church on Thursday 31 July. A crowd in excess of one thousand, mostly drawn for the same social class as the Wales-Kings of Mercer Street, descended on the church. Built in 1862, St John’s is no stranger to praise. As one Internet site puts it: St John’s is one of Australia’s most famous churches. Prominently sited in Australia’s most exclusive residential area, the imposing bluestone church building houses many unique features, which include a wealth of splendid wood and stone carvings, impressive memorial stained glass windows, and the acclaimed pipe organ.The organ was built by the distinguished English organ building firm of William Hill & Son in 1913…The organ was given to St John’s by the Connibere family in memory of their father George Connibere, who had died in 1911.
The beauty and status of St John’s was little consolation for Jane Ashton. Not even the architectural and spiritual splendour of the church could camouflage the gulf emerging between the Garretts and Ramage’s defenders. Nor was it lost on Julie’s friends that a number of people at the service had been visiting 72
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
gathering of guests that all refugees should be towed out to sea and their boats sunk. If he hadn’t left England in 1978 he’d have voted Tory and rated British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher one of his heroes. The only human rights that mattered to him were business rights and his ability to hire and fire employees. It was reflected in a comment to a friend that if any of his employees became pregnant at an inconvenient time he’d tell them to have an abortion. ‘I’d even give them the phone number of the clinic,’ he growled. If only he’d known that his own wife had had an abortion in the months before the fortieth party. My discussions with Dyson at the time of the trial were a game of cat and mouse. He was clearly unhappy discussing his conversations with the killer during their time at the Harp. When I asked why he didn’t give evidence he said that if the police thought he had anything to offer they’d have spoken to him. Maybe! The truth is somewhat less clear, for Ramage carefully avoided identifying Dyson Hore-Lacy as the ‘friend by the name of Dyson’ he was ‘going to see’. At no point in his police interview does he say exactly who ‘Dyson’ was or that he was a barrister. The moral conundrum aside, one important question still rattled in my head. ‘What would you have done if you’d bumped into Jane Ashton or one of Julie’s friends had rung looking for James on the night of the murder?’ I asked. ‘Sorry, Phil, I can’t help you,’ he told me. The question was one of a number I emailed Dyson in relation to what had happened at the Harp. None of them involved him offering me privileged information. The best he could say was,‘I am not sure why the info is necessary unless you are thinking of doing a chapter on legal ethics.’ A book about legal ethics might question how Dyson HoreLacy could use emotive, passionate language such as ‘shot like a dog on a leash’ when talking about the police shooting of Gary 74
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Abdullah but seek refuge behind legal protocol when the victim is an estranged wife. It might also question why defence barristers are more affronted by the treatment of refugees and the suffering of women and children in detention centres than the violence behind the clinker brick of a suburban home. Julie had never committed an act of violence and her death was slower than Abdullah’s.And one telling fact remained.While Dyson and then Pica talked with Ramage, Jane Ashton was going out of her mind.Was she asking too much to think Julie’s friend might have said, ‘Sorry, James, you’re on your own, mate’? Our final conversation took place in March 2005. I was trying to clarify what Margaret had meant when she told me that on the afternoon of the murder Dyson had said, ‘I have some shocking news, but I can’t tell you anything.’ Unless it was after the meeting at the Harp or the next day, it just didn’t make sense. When I pressed the question, he said, ‘You’re pushing a friendship, Philip, I’m going to hang up.’That was the end of the matter. Margaret obviously got the days confused. As good a man as Dyson Hore-Lacy is, he’d not have been welcome at the funeral if Julie had been my sister. Also at the funeral was Rob Moodie, a friend of the family and CEO of the Victorian Health Foundation. Educated at Scotch College, the alma mater of former Victorian Liberal Premier Jeff Kennett, he told Julie’s friends he’d visited Ramage in gaol to find out why he’d done it. Jane was astounded when she heard about the visits. She said it made her ‘feel sick’. Nor did it help when she read in the Age newspaper that Moodie thought Ramage was a victim of ‘the fundamental problem of the poor mental health of men who are not comfortable in their identity’. She desperately needed him to say Ramage took a woman’s life because he was a bully and a chauvinist. The last thing Jane wanted was for her sister’s children to think their DADDY’S RICH, MUMMY’S GOOD LOOKING
75
father’s actions could be explained away. If Rob had picked up the phone and rung the Garretts he’d have heard first hand of the physical and psychological impact of Julie’s murder. Maybe then he’d have understood. It was to be the start of a painful journey for Moodie. The damning words Jane would save for Ramage in her victim impact statement were not those that readily sprang to mind for Rob Moodie in the immediate aftermath of the murder. In a conversation with me almost two years later he said the verdict was wrong and that he sympathised with the Garretts over their ‘terrible loss’. He went on to say that it was ‘a terrible act’ and that he didn’t want them to think that the evidence he gave in court, what he’d said in the press or his gaol visits meant he ‘condoned what Ramage did’. No one had ever suggested Rob Moodie might have condoned what Ramage did. Even Ramage’s mother wouldn’t be that silly. The real problem was that Moodie’s visits to Ramage in gaol were a grave insult to the family and helped Ramage legitimise his crime to his children. Archdeacon Newman, his grey hair parted neatly on the left and his glasses and bright robes radiating authority, began proceedings. No one told him what to say or asked which version of Christianity would be on display. They soon realised it was not going to be an Old Testament sermon.Today there would be no talk of an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth.‘It seems unreal. How do we approach it, in the face of such tragedy…what are we doing here…why did it happen …could we have done anything…we want to find answers.’ The Archdeacon didn’t divulge that he’d visited Ramage in gaol and had agreed to act as a character witness. Such was the nature of the words that had a stranger wandered into the church they’d have had no idea what fate had befallen the woman in the 76
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
coffin. No mention of murder or a violent death, or that the name of the killer was James Stuart Ramage. No sense that Archdeacon Newman’s god might have something to say in another court or that anyone should think about the vexed question of justice or how the community might protect women in future. ‘It doesn’t matter.’ This was the Archdeacon’s solution to the perplexing issue of ‘finding answers’.We must have faith, for faith is the basis to understanding suffering, he added. The Archdeacon’s words would have fallen on deaf ears if Ramage had been let out of prison for his wife’s funeral. He paid homage to only one god: Mammon. The funeral service might not have been the time to publicly condemn James Ramage, but was it the time to treat the murder as a mystery or imply that Ramage’s violent act was inscrutable or beyond condemnation? ‘Place aside any thought and speculation about the manner of her death,’ said the civil celebrant as she introduced the eulogies. For those who’ve experienced familial murder this is something you never imagine saying. To deny what Ramage did was to offer comfort to all wife killers, past and present. Such was the depth of the killer’s denial he’d told his son to place a red rose on the coffin. ‘I wished that my sister’s hand had emerged from the coffin and pushed it away,’ said Jane. Seated in the front row, Jane looked at the coffin and remembered how slim her sister had been and how despite being strong and well nourished she’d have been no match for his violent attack. How could she not think about the way her twin sister had died when she knew the gruesome details? She pondered so many things. How he never accepted no for an answer. How he’d cunningly gathered information from her friends about his wife’s activities and then, on the fatal Monday, had sent the builder away. She could well imagine the despair Julie must have DADDY’S RICH, MUMMY’S GOOD LOOKING
77
felt when she saw the look in his eyes that day. ‘The minute she said she wasn’t coming back Julie would have known she was going to die. Even before he laid a hand on her she would have known. I’ve seen that look in his eyes and so had she,’ Jane would tell me. I believed her. Jane couldn’t bring herself to view her twin sister in the funeral parlour. She wanted to remember her as she’d last seen her. Three days after the killing, she’d come home to seventytwo telephone messages. Night after night she dreamt about her sister. In one dream Julie was in bed dressed in purple pyjamas with white spots. Lying alongside her was the sleeping Ramage. When Jane tries to rescue her twin sister Julie is transformed into a grotesque zombie. At other times her sister is alive, laughing and smiling, and Jane is desperate not to wake up. How could she paint these pictures for her niece and nephew as they stood alongside her? How could she make them understand that their father’s actions were not those of a man in love but a man consumed by hate? Today, no one was about to mention the word murder or killing. Julie’s confidante, Gilda Pekin, spoke of the beautiful woman who took her children to the park so she could rest while looking after her sick father. She called it ‘Julie’s caring recipe’.As much as she disliked James Ramage and hated him for what he’d done to her best friend, she too didn’t step on the Ramage name. Remember VicKick and the basketball at Kew High School? Julie was there with the same style and smile, proud of her kids. Julie was inclusive and generous. Julie came for dinner Thursday, a week or so ago. Gorgeous, black high-heel boots, that black ruffled skirt and the black and silver jumper. I looked at her boots. She looked at our new timber floor and 78
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
began to take the boots off saying, ‘Oh, oh, the glam’s gone now.’ And the thick woolly black socks were revealed, complete with holes. No one cared. Our beautiful friend, Julie, just happened to be beautiful on the outside as well.
As Matthew and Sam stepped into the aisle, Julie’s closest friends braced themselves. Privately, many were of the view that Matthew was under his father’s control.There is nothing in any book to guide children, even those of the rich, when their father is accused of murdering their mother. Matthew was visiting his father in gaol and driving the Mini Cooper James Ramage had planted behind Colombo’s as part of a pathetic attempt at an alibi. On the door’s armrest the police had found a droplet of blood. No man had stepped forward to explain to the boy how his father was manipulating the situation or that it was his responsibility to uphold the memory of his mother.There were no Garrett uncles to honour her name or make threats to his dad. Friends such as Christine Howgate believed that Ramage had forgone his rights to a relationship with the children. His refusal to say sorry only hardened their animosity towards him. It mattered little to him. He didn’t like or respect strong women. Julie’s friends never tried to stand between Ramage and his children.When a male friend of Julie’s gave me the DVD of the funeral, I was left wondering whether they wished they had.Tall like his dad, and impeccably dressed in a dark blue suit, Matthew spoke calmly and deliberately, the occasional gulp and a tilt of his head punctuating the lines. His fifteen-year-old sister stood silently at her brother’s left shoulder.Women’s words were never given pride of place in Ramage’s household. In spirit she was clearly her mother’s girl and had been her ally before and after the separation. It was a shame that Julie’s loving daughter didn’t have the opportunity to repeat the intimate, girlish lines she writDADDY’S RICH, MUMMY’S GOOD LOOKING
79
ten in a letter in November 2002 from boarding school. In the letter she’d lamented how her father had made her mum look ‘unreasonable’ and after changing his attitude for a couple of weeks would go back to his ‘old ways’. Life was not just about cleaning and cooking – it was about being happy, she’d told her mum. If only the congregation had heard these words. It was a far cry from the ones they were about to hear from her brother. Beginning with the awkward ‘Our mum was a beautiful and amazing lady’ Matthew tried to sing his mother’s praises in a way that avoided confronting the manner of her death. In Matthew’s eyes she was a woman with a passion for horse riding and swimming. She was a woman who loved a glass of wine with friends and enjoyed cooking for a dinner party. A mother whom he remembered kissing him and his sister goodnight.A mother who did everything with all her heart. She was a perfect mother. Honest and firm, she gave her children boundaries that were defined by love and patience, he said. So, why was she dead, thought Christine Howgate? Delivering a eulogy for your dead mother when your father has killed her makes George Bush declaring war on Iraq seem almost trivial. For all the difficulties such a task posed for the seventeen-year-old Matthew Ramage, it was a eulogy that raised more questions than it delivered answers. Matthew didn’t use his sister’s name. She was always ‘my sister’ rather than ‘Samantha’. It was the same anonymity James Ramage had foisted on Sam in his telephone conversation with Matthew on the night of the killing. Matthew’s closing words fell from his lips like hand grenades. She was a great mother and a great wife to the greatest family, from which we draw our fondest memories. A family, which we can say with all our hearts, is one that we are 80
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
proud to be a part of and one that we would not swap for the world.
What did he mean when he said he ‘wouldn’t swap his family for the world’? His father had bashed and strangled his mother and dumped her in a bush grave. Is that the kind of family we all want? Soon one of Ramage’s friends would let the secret out of the bag. The speech had been written by James. Like the headline ‘Love pulls the trigger’ that accompanied a newspaper account of the murder of Christine Boyce in 1987, James Ramage had found a set of words that absolved him of any guilt. And the swine had left his son to deliver them.Worse still, while Matthew sang the praises of a ‘great mother and great wife’ his father was building a mountain of stones to throw at her. To those close to Julie it was a declaration of war by the killer. Even on the day they were under no illusion as to who had written the eulogy.To conclude, Matthew asked that the gathering listen as he recited the final stanzas from the song ‘Summertime’.The words, he said, encapsulated ‘the vivid image we hold of our mum’. Donna Carrodus couldn’t hide her disbelief. A social worker by profession and dubbed a ‘bohemian’ by Ramage, she knew why the killer loved it. It was an affirmation of his power. Once a favourite lullaby in the Garrett household in England, James Ramage had turned ‘Summertime’ into a ghoulish defence of the murder of their daughter. ‘Your daddy’s rich and your mummy’s good looking.’ Angie Hayes, widow and Scotch parent, also cringed as the words echoed through the church. She’d met Ramage for lunch on the Friday before he killed Julie. She was so concerned with his attitude she later rang another Scotch parent, Dr Kate Clark, and asked whether she thought Ramage might hurt Julie. The next DADDY’S RICH, MUMMY’S GOOD LOOKING
81
day Clark was a witness to the ominous Geelong rendezvous. As Matthew uttered the final words – ‘with your mummy and daddy standing by’ – he lifted his head, his nervousness palpable. ‘Make sure you redeem the family name,’ his father had told him.Young and confused, Matthew simply wasn’t able to escape his father’s control. In the Gershwin musical Porgy and Bess, for which ‘Summertime’ is famous, the cripple Porgy falls so in love with Bess he kills the man who tries to take her from him. For all the wrong reasons it was the right song. When all the anger of Julie’s friends is swept aside, it’s just plain tragic that a son’s love of his father should have been exploited in this way. In time their relationship might have evolved into something quite special. It wasn’t Matthew’s responsibility to protect his mother from a bullying father, but it was truly sad he couldn’t speak freely for his mum at her funeral and so confront the scourge of family violence. Had it been a working class funeral there’s little doubt some awful curses would have been uttered. Here at St John’s in Toorak, no one dared lift the cone of silence that had been placed over Julie’s coffin. From the Scotch College boys in their imperious red coats to the authoritative archdeacon, not a soul fired a salvo at James Ramage. Only Susie Walker, a friend from the riding club, went close to smashing the lie of Julie’s death orchestrated from gaol by the killer. For a few moments it appeared the distraught Susie would be unable to compose herself sufficiently to speak. Eventually she uttered the words so many people wanted to hear: ‘She learnt to hide well her anguish and fear.’ Not long before she left the marriage Julie had appeared at the riding club with the remnants of a black eye.‘I walked into a door,’ she told her friend. No mention of that at the funeral. The day after the killing, Neil Cracknell, head of Year 12 at Scotch College, told an assembly of boys Julie 82
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Ramage had ‘died in tragic circumstances’. If any boys needed counselling the school would provide it, he said. No public forums on the scourge of family violence were scheduled and no special classes run. Is it true, as one teacher claims, that ‘the switchboard lit up like a Christmas tree’ with Scotch mothers seeking counselling for boys who’d seen violence at home? No one will say. Jane Ashton was the last speaker. The burden she carried was written across her taught, strained face. There was so much she wanted to say. How could she talk about the pain when her sister’s children were foremost in her mind? Already she knew Ramage had been delivering instructions from gaol and that Matt had visited Julie’s flat in the company of several Scotch parents and removed everything except Julie’s clothes and underwear. In her victim impact statement she described it this way: There was no time to reflect…and respectfully sort out her belongings. Men who didn’t even know her had gone in and ransacked the place. Even the cleaning materials had all gone. So we had to make do with what we had brought, to hoover the carpets, clean the bathroom and toilet and polish the cooker.We always knew our side of the family was good for something. And here we were again reduced to the lowest in the pecking order.
Jane also knew that Matthew had found his mother’s love letters and had read a few lines.When he told his father what was in the letters Ramage couldn’t believe his luck. Jane Ashton was different from her sister in so many ways. She hadn’t rushed into motherhood. Charlotte, the first of her two children, was born in 1992, seven years after Julie’s first child. She had no desire to be a teenage bride and had revelled in university. Tertiary educated and respectful of his wife’s independence, her DADDY’S RICH, MUMMY’S GOOD LOOKING
83
husband was nothing like James Ramage. None of this protected her from the grief of losing her twin sister. In the ten days that preceded the funeral and the months that followed, she was unable to sleep and was back and forth to the doctor for check-ups, counselling, sleeping pills and treatment for depression. By the time it came to bury her sister, she was a physical and emotional wreck. Tense and hurt, she refused to cry as she dragged a little speech from her handbag: My dear Julie, my twin, my friend, my playmate.We learnt to crawl together, walk together, run together, climb together and play together. We took the bus or walked to school together, we went to the movies together, we had many other friends, but never suffered doubts about being alone, you were my shadow, and I was yours. We played netball together, and pushed each other on. We were together, freezing, muddy and wet on those famous English hockey fields. We sailed and capsized, but always went down laughing.We swam for hours and hours in pools, rivers and the sea until our skin began to wrinkle. We made a pact together to avoid cross-country at all costs. We fell off ponies each week, if not exactly together, then usually shortly after each other. We explored our early world together, school camps together and Europe together. Always confident that Julie’s ability of speaking very slowly in English would make up for any actual knowledge of the language. Together we shared our highs and lows, never judging each other, but always pushing forward.A problem shared is a problem halved; two heads are better than one. We laughed so much we would cry and never took life too 84
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
seriously. My dear Julie is your friend, your playmate, your companion, your ally, your support. Julie met many of my friends and became a part of their lives. Being able to share her with them was a joy to me at the time and a terrific support to me now. Today we tend to pigeonhole our friends, our family and all the many different parts of our lives.Think about your brothers, sisters, children, parents and friends and simply be there for them. Do not be afraid to open up those boxes and let people get close to you and each other. God has given us all a tremendous capacity for love and understanding. Julie had those qualities and I know that her strength has gone into me, and all of you. I shall move on, always with her in my heart, and never ever alone, and I hope and pray that you will all be able to do the same.
Christine Howgate watched the proceedings with a mixture of sorrow and anger. She’d walked with Julie and heard every detail of her friend’s disintegrating marriage, including the sexual abuse. Although she and her husband were property developers with an office in Hawthorn, she voted Green and was staunchly pro-refugee. A good-looking mother of three with a quiet, almost girlish voice that belies her intellectual combativeness, she’d begun to tire of the hypocrisy. ‘I couldn’t understand why the school children clapped after the eulogies,’ she would later say. Why doesn’t someone tell the truth about James Ramage? Why doesn’t someone speak of the broken nose, the sexual abuse and the put-downs, she asked? More than five hundred people gathered at the former artists’ haven of Montsalvat for the wake. Julie’s friends from the Hurstbridge Adult Riding Club had prepared Julie’s and Sam’s DADDY’S RICH, MUMMY’S GOOD LOOKING
85
horses and were waiting in full uniform when people arrived.At the wake her friends decried James Ramage’s bullying and wondered what would become of him. They wondered why they hadn’t been able to save their friend. Another close friend of the twins would relate a bizarre story. In 1978, when Julie Garrett and James Ramage were racing towards marriage, Kay was striking up a friendship at Newlands High School with my murdered sister,Vicki. Most people aren’t touched by murder, let alone the murder of a friend by her partner or former partner. Kay had now experienced it twice. She says it has made her paranoid about the safety of women who separate and that she can’t understand why the most beautiful and generous women end up murdered. Lindy Weir, another friend of Julie’s from the riding club, was so shocked when she learned about the killing she dropped the phone and couldn’t speak. She’d been on the Hurstbridge Riding Club committee with Julie. Lindy never forgot seeing Ramage hover over his wife as she prepared a salad at the Christmas 2001 riding club barbecue.‘He watched every move and I could see her hands twitching,’ she said.And what was her opinion of him? ‘He was a pompous bastard.’ Still, she wondered why her friend had once said,‘Jane has no money, but they’re happy.’ Julie’s twin lives on a beautiful ten-acre property in Research that by anyone’s standards is far from modest. It must surely have been Ramage speak. And there too was ‘Ruby’, who in the aftermath of the killing would announce that the first fifteen years of her marriage had been ‘marred by domestic violence’.A parent at Scotch and married to a successful businessman who was also a member of the Masonic Order, Ruby had spent the evening discussing the marriage breakdown with Ramage at Marock Place on Thursday 3 July. During the conversation he admitted that he’d regularly hit his son in the past and if Julie was having an affair it would ‘be 86
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
the end’. Not even her own experiences with violence were enough for her to conclude that Julie was in danger. On Tuesday 22 July, after a neighbour told her Julie had been murdered, she drove to Marock Place to see for herself. When she found the house cordoned off by the police, she was flabbergasted. As the Garretts stumbled towards their first Christmas without Julie, Ray Garrett became seriously ill and was placed in intensive care at the Austin Hospital.While Ray was in hospital Jane had her appendix removed. She’d been unwell since August, but ultrasounds had not picked up anything. Her doctor said it was due to her not eating properly for the six weeks following her sister’s death. Then Pat Garrett broke down. The grief was killing her. I didn’t meet Julie’s mother until the day Justice Osborn delivered his sentence. It was 9 December 2004, a day after my birthday. So often, the strength of a handshake or the warmth of a hug says everything about a person. Pat Garrett hugged me like I was her son, and her husband spoke to me with such a level of trust, it was impossible not to love them. It seemed inconceivable that this lovely woman could have been overwhelmed by such trauma. She didn’t look like the kind of person to be found wandering aimlessly through the corridors of a mental hospital. An abundance of intelligence and a career as a statistician and accountant counts for nothing when your daughter is murdered. While Ramage and his defence counsel prepared their attack on Julie’s character, her parents prepared to move into a retirement village. It should have been, says Jane, a happy occasion and a benchmark of the next step in their lives. Instead it was a solemn occasion in which there were no ritualistic sad goodbyes. ‘The memories of Julie being there and those of her children staying over when they were little were too painful for them,’ says Jane.
DADDY’S RICH, MUMMY’S GOOD LOOKING
87
EARLY YEARS
Like Lorna and Ron Cleary, the Boyce family and all the others that preceded them, the Garretts never thought it would be their lot to receive the paralysing news of the murder of their daughter. It was a far cry from the early days of North London, where they and their little twins were part of a bustling working class community. Pat Kellett and Raymond Garrett were young children when the Second World War exploded all over Europe. They were evacuees, pushed onto a train with a label around their necks, never knowing if they would see their parents again. Then they were repatriated to London and yet another home, the previous one a pile of burnt-out rubble. Cockney singsongs deep below London in the relative safety of the Underground railway stations while they waited for the bombs to stop became their lullabies. Ray had very little formal education during these turbulent years, and only had a few carefree years as an apprentice before he took up his military service with the Royal Scots Greys in 88
North Africa. Pat, an only child, received a scholarship to the local grammar school and was ready to go to university at sixteen years of age. Outstanding at maths, she was dux of the school. Unfortunately it was a time when girls couldn’t go to university until they were eighteen years old and with the family dependent on her income she put university on hold and went out to work. As was the case in postwar Australia, most women in England drifted back into the home once the demand for labour subsided. Not so Pat, who took up a position at London Transport and then at the Department of Defence, doing statistical modelling. Pat worked with Douglas and Valerie Lovelock, who later became Sir Lord and Lady Lovelock.Valerie was to be the twins’ godmother and Douglas ended up Treasurer of the Church of England.The British Establishment would also be shaken by the outcome of R v Ramage. Pat and Ray were only teenagers when they met. Ray’s love letters, sent from Africa, cemented their growing affection and soon they were thinking about marriage. By the late 1950s they were part of a new generation that had thrown off the shackles of their working class forebears.Through a small grocery shop they’d opened in Edmonton, North London, they’d freed themselves from the hand to mouth existence of their parents. The twins arrived on 11 September 1960.A male obstetrician of the old school watched on as Pat struggled to give birth to twins, both breech, with no intervention. ‘Stop crying, woman,’ were his only words of encouragement as the girls finally arrived – Julie five minutes before Jane, so that for the rest of her life she would be referred to as the eldest. Ray felt so bad about the state he found his wife in when he arrived at Barnet Hospital, he promised they would have no more children. The twins spent many hours in a big old-fashioned twin pram outside the front of EARLY YEARS
89
the shop. Women passing by or coming in to buy something would chat away to them and say,‘’allo darlings.’ Like a couple of parrots on the perch they were so taken by the greeting,‘’allo’ was the first word they uttered. On Saturday mornings Nanny Kellett, or ‘Little Nanna Kellett’ as she was known, and her husband Grandad Kellett would collect the twins and take them to Miss Maureen’s Dancing School in Tottenham. A dilapidated old hall behind a huge rundown Victorian home would instil in them a lifelong love of dancing. Ray had been the eldest of four brothers, all five years apart. There was little love and affection from his mother and he yearned for it. In his life with Pat this dream was realised. She was from Welsh and Yorkshire heritage and belonged to a large clan of vivacious, fun loving men and women. Parties above their small shop in Raymond Street, Edmonton would go on until dawn.They had friends from all over London and jazz and blues would be played and they would dance, play cards and talk politics till the shop needed to open the next day. Long before the film Bend It Like Beckham, Jane joined a girl’s soccer team. Already her mischievous sense of humour was her trademark: ‘It’s not strange. I still wear my lippy and mascara on the field, unless of course it’s raining.Then it’s just the lippy.’ Jane was never one to let feminist ideology curtail her instinct or her femaleness. In the aftermath of the trial it would be one of her great strengths as she fronted a ravenous media. The Kellett and Garrett clans followed Tottenham Hotspur in the English football league. Both sets of grandparents lived within a short walking distance of White Hart Lane. On Saturday afternoons the twins would play in Little Nanny Kellett’s garden, bordering the railway line, waiting to hear the crowd roar. Men from both families would meet at the football and then walk back to Newlyn Road, cold and wet, ready for 90
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
tea. Once the footy ‘Pools’ had been ticked off the girls would be bundled into the back of their father’s black Austin and taken home. It was an idyllic setting in which the English football hooligans had yet to make their mark. At Miss Maureen’s they’d stumbled across the floor in their pink leotards, and played Tweedledum and Tweedledee and the legendary American Andrews Sisters. After dancing on Saturday, Nanny and Grandad would take the girls shopping to the same Jewish bakery in High Street.Years later, making love to a Jewish man who loved food and wine would give Julie the added confidence to leave her stuffy English husband. It was 1977 and the North London bus was bursting with noisy, awkward teenagers acting out the courting ritual when James Ramage made his first play for the pretty Julie Garrett. The other boys said she was a real catch. Imposing, strong and full of confidence, he believed he was the man to take her out of parochial Goffs Oak. Ray Garrett didn’t think his children needed to be taken anywhere. His corner shop in working class Edmonton, near Tottenham, had been such a success he’d been able to move up the social ladder, first to Cheshunt, where he made a nice nest egg from two supermarkets, and then to Moorhurst Avenue in Goffs Oak in tranquil Hertfordshire. Here, Ray thought his family would be safe from the violence he envisaged would one day beset Tottenham and its surrounds. James Ramage wasn’t Julie’s first boyfriend, and she wasn’t a virgin when they met. She’d had a number of boyfriends before a local bloke, Maurice Saggars, asked her out. Maurice, or ‘Mole’ as he was called, due to a large mole on his neck, was the leader of the pack. His dad was a bookmaker with lots of East End connections. Saggars was huge and was weight-lifting at sixteen to increase his bulk even more.Very intelligent at school, but a troublemaker, he was a ‘lover and a fighter’. An Arsenal supporter, his EARLY YEARS
91
idea of fun on a Saturday was being a football hooligan or bovver boy. Right wing in the ‘Alf Garnet’ mould, he supported the National Front and wore Doc Martens boots, laced up to just under his knee with re-enforced toecaps. Julie soon realised that women were little more than ‘chattels’ in the world of Mole Saggars.When she dumped him her family was not displeased. Already she seemed to have a habit of falling into the arms of boys who wanted to control or own a woman. Roy Collins and Nicky Smith, who followed Mole, were better looking than the National Front thug and less violent, but they didn’t mind a bit of fisticuffs after the disco on a Saturday night.Young cockney men with cars and money, and older than Julie, they did nothing to please Ray and Pat Garrett. One night at Cuffley Youth Club all of Julie’s ex-boyfriends met up and there was a huge fight in which bottles were broken and the police had to be called.Although she was frightened and shaken at the time, she felt powerful. Strange as it seems, it made some women swoon and feel secure. A victim of a culture that calculated a woman’s value according to how many men were fighting for her, Julie Garrett had fallen for the lie. She just loved being desired. James Ramage was neither cockney nor as boisterous as Julie’s cousins. The Garrett boys were big, loud and abrasive. They were also very protective of their women. Ramage lived ‘up the hill’ in Cuffley, the second most expensive suburb in the district. He wasn’t from old money, but it’s where he wanted to be. His father’s success in business had given him a start, and with an attractive woman by his side he fancied he could go anywhere. Julie’s mother knew early on that her daughter was besotted with her flashy boyfriend. She also knew they were having sex. Pat Garrett had walked down the aisle in Tottenham with her husband Ray in 1956, when she was only twenty-one 92
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
years of age and her husband was twenty-three, so she knew about young love. It’s just that she didn’t think Ramage was right for her daughter. As much as James seemed more agreeable than the wild boys Julie had known, the Garretts soon began to have their doubts about the boy from Cuffley. In his police statement twenty-five years later, Ray remembered how one night Ramage ‘charged upstairs like a madman and started shouting at Jane’. He was, said Julie’s dad,‘a hothead’.Was it this challenge to a father’s authority that eventually drove Ray to tell his daughter, ‘If you’re old enough for sex, you’re old enough to work’? Ray had quickly realised that the Ramages were different. He remembered how their house was mostly full of people who discussed business. He also noticed that Ramage’s mother talked constantly about Jamie’s brother Clive, ‘who was a very good tennis player’. James regularly boasted about his sporting talents and how he’d tried out for county rugby. And the Garretts heard how his father had set up the Norwich Union insurance company in Australia and had taken his family around the world and had even lived in Africa. Long before Ramage laid a hand on Julie there were signs that the Ramages and the Garretts were two very different tribes. Pat Garrett had genuinely hoped the relationship with Ramage would run its course. On 11 September 1978 she received the news she never wanted to hear. It was the twins’ eighteenth birthday and their parents had hired the local community centre to celebrate the event. When Julie grabbed hold of her mum, presented her an outstretched hand and said,‘James gave me it.We’re engaged,’ her mother could only offer a stony-faced nod. In her police statement she said the sight of the diamond solitaire ‘broke my heart’. Ramage hadn’t asked Ray for his daughter’s hand in marriage. It was a bad start and in time the uneasiness would give way to a bitter feud between father and lover. The EARLY YEARS
93
twins may have been identical, but they’d reached a fork in the road. From here on their lives would be remarkably different. Within a few months of the engagement, Ramage left for Australia, where he hoped to make his mark. His father had organised for him to live with a business acquaintance, Bill Martin, and learn about commerce and making money. Bill had set up Arnos Australia Pty Ltd during the Second World War and had made a mint selling map pins to the US army. Eventually the company expanded until it had offices in Canada and France and sold products to forty-four countries worldwide. The young James Ramage lived with Bill Martin’s family in Black Rock. Here he began to taste privilege Australian style, and learnt that the median price for a house in Black Rock at that time was double the median price for the rest of metropolitan Melbourne, and that the suburb had a well-appointed yacht club frequented by Melbourne’s rich. Ramage soon understood how the class system worked and the way the nouveau riche networked through golf, yachting, the Masonic Order, the right private schools and institutions such as the Melbourne Cricket Club. He wanted to live like this, and his immediate goal was to start the climb up the ladder of success.With a pretty blonde wife by his side he reckoned it was possible.The girl who wanted to be his wife was so desperately in love she saved every cent made from working in the ANZ Bank so she could join her hero in Australia. In mid March 1979, after a few months apart, the couple was reunited in sunny Australia, where Jamie had organised a flat for his fiancée. She told her sister in a letter written from her flat at 9 Stayner Street, Beaumaris: Please excuse my writing as I am sunbathing in my little garden. I spent all weekend cleaning up the flat. It now 94
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
looks quite good.There is a new fridge and a small electric cooker.The weather is beautiful and I don’t mind being on my own all day as I can sunbath. Bill [Martin] has been very helpful and is only charging me $22 a week, about 12 pounds, which is good for this area. On Monday Bill took us to lunch to one of the best restaurants in Melbourne, after lunch he rang a friend of his who is one of the directors of the ANZ, I spoke to him on the phone and he said I could go for an interview in 5 minutes. We rushed there on a tram and I saw him. He told me I would have to wait a month probably, but it doesn’t matter because I am working in the printing department of Bill’s factory.
Sometime later she was living with her mother’s cousins, the Kelletts, in Preston. Friends say it was after a fight with her husband-to-be. Alf and Mavis Kellett lived at 15 Dunstan Street in a brick house built by Alf. The block was twice the size of his neighbours’ Housing Commission properties, so Alf had reason to think he was doing quite well. It might not have been wealthy Beaumaris, but it was no poky little shack. At the East Coburg end of the street was the Kodak factory, where thousands of immigrants from Europe and the UK found work after the war. The Preston of 1979 was a working class suburb dotted with factories, warehouses and Housing Commission estates that produced their share of Melbourne’s criminals. It wasn’t the Wild West, but rape and violence were no strangers to the area. As much as Alf Kellett wasn’t a criminal or a rough and tumble man, and his house was comfortable, he was very much cut from working class rock. James Ramage took a clinical view: a man who worked in the revenue section of theVictorian Tramways at the Preston depot was not going to introduce him to men of influence.The relationship with the Kelletts had to be severed. EARLY YEARS
95
Eventually, Julie and James resumed their relationship and began planning the wedding. Already they were savouring the delights of middle class Melbourne. Soon it would become a pilgrimage. In the middle of 1979 Julie rang her parents to organise a date for the wedding. With 5 January 1980 set as the big day, the couple duly arrived in England on Boxing Day 1979. It proved to be an emotionally charged eleven days, during which ominous signs appeared and some began to think the relationship between the Garretts and Ramage might be tumultuous. The Garretts had organised a relatively quiet and quaint wedding that suited their budget and what they thought were the interests of the couple. Ramage wanted something bigger and more ostentatious.When it came to finding the extra money for the additional guests, the about-to-be son-in-law displayed another trait that would become synonymous with his style. Pat Garrett still remembers him walking in and throwing an envelope filled with the money on the table then strolling out of their kitchen. On a pleasant winter’s day nineteen-year-old Julie Garrett married her sweetheart.The bride wore a white lace gown and the groom a three piece grey suit with a red carnation on the lapel. As would be her wont throughout her short life, Julie offered only a half-smile for the camera. His right hand on her tiny waist and his left hand on the knife as it sliced into the wedding cake, the princess was his.Who’d have thought those hands would unleash such terror twenty-three years later? St Thomas of Canterbury’s church in Northaw was a picture. A beautiful fairytale church with an elegant spire, it dates back to 1881, the year fire damaged the original building.When Thomas à Beckett was canonised by the Pope, 1173 churches were built in dedication to him throughout the Catholic world. The acclaimed English satirist Geoffrey Chaucer would call him the ‘blissful martyr’. In time Julie’s friends would see the irony. 96
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Julie’s cousins in England did not share Ray and Pat Garrett’s dislike of their new son-in-law. Peter Garrett, a tall, strongly built man with a robust tongue, had put Ramage up in his house when he visited a year before the killing. ‘I liked him. I didn’t know what he’d done to Julie,’ he told me in March 2005, during a short trip to Australia. While in Melbourne he met Matt and Samantha Ramage. ‘Looking at their teeth and Sam’s $200 sunglasses, I’d say they don’t want for much,’ he said. He didn’t discuss the murder or tell the children what he might have done to their dad if he’d had a chance. While Julie flashed her wedding ring and thought about love, her sister was poring over Shakespeare, Chaucer, and Bronte’s Wuthering Heights. And when she wasn’t reading she was partying and smoking cigarettes. From organising student protests in Trafalgar Square to working in a women’s refuge in Swansea, Jane Garrett threw herself into an array of social causes. Two months after her sister’s wedding she was in the back of a truck in an eye-catching Farah Fawcett bodysuit spruiking for donations for charity. At every pub she’d jump off the truck and run in rattling her tin. She’d been crowned the Rag Queen of Swansea University.Although she’d not spent a lot of time thinking about her brother-in-law, she considered him rather conservative. He fancied that her belief in human rights and equality between men and women might be his Achilles heel. It was a friction that never really subsided. Within three years of the marriage, Ray and Pat Garrett had migrated to Australia. In 1986 Jane and her husband Howard Ashton joined them. It had been a roller coaster ride for Jamie and Julie since their wedding in 1980. Already there’d been a separation during which they found other potential partners. Although there is no documented account of violence, Gilda Pekin believes it was physical assault that led to the first separation. From this EARLY YEARS
97
break-up until Julie’s death, there would always be a sniff of violence in the marriage. A letter in August 1984 to Jane leaves little doubt that this was an unlikely marriage: I don’t know whether Mum told you, but I have been seeing a really nice guy called Chris Wilks, he is very genuine and has really spoilt me and we’ve had lots of fun in the last few weeks. I’ve met most of his family and they all know I’m separated, but they’ve all been lovely to me. Chris lives at home with his parents, but they’re away a lot of the time with business so he tells everyone his parents have left home…I’m still seeing my girlfriends too but plan to take it a bit easier for a while as it’s very tiring being a single swinger especially as I’m getting on a bit. Jamie and I still keep in touch but the longer we’re apart the less chance we have got of getting back together because our personalities (especially mine) are changing all the time. So far Jamie’s organized half the money for the Datsun for me, but he still hasn’t decided whether he will sell the house or pay me out for my half. I haven’t taken anything from the house yet because he might as well have the use of it until I get my own place and need things too. I can’t wait for the summer weather the new fashions look great don’t bring or buy too many summer clothes because you’ll be able to go shopping with Mum and I when you get here. I have decided to really concentrate on finding a new job as I’m rather bored and a complete change would do me good, new people etc. so I am going to sit down and write out a good resume this afternoon and go from there.
Julie had told her mum she genuinely liked Wilks and would have given Ramage up for him. Unfortunately her flashy new 98
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
boyfriend wasn’t quite ready to settle down.With regret and disappointment she returned to her husband. She really was a girl who couldn’t stand being on her own. Without a man in her life she didn’t think she was a real woman. Chastened by her departure, Ramage knew he had to act. Five months after telling her mother she didn’t love her husband she was pregnant with his child. It was a master stroke by Ramage. Now she wasn’t going anywhere.Yet strangely enough, he clung to an affair with a local Catholic girl while luring his wife back to the marriage. It continued until Julie rang her and politely explained the situation. The woman didn’t even know he was married.Although Julie would tell her twin sister she felt hopeless and trapped, she decided to try and make the marriage work. For now there would be no other men in her life. When the Garretts arrived in Australia in 1983 they lived with James and Julie in Percy Street, Balwyn, a few blocks away from Marock Place. It was here that Julie’s parents experienced the hot-headedness they’d seen in their home in England. It came one night while they were in bed.They never asked their daughter exactly why he’d been shouting and screaming during the night.When Julie sheepishly said he’d punched a hole in the wall, her parents didn’t know what to say. ‘Going off to war’ was one of Ramage’s favourite expressions when he shut the door behind him every morning. Only Julie knew the extent and depth of the war. When she went into labour with Matthew on 27 October 1985, his response was consistent with every step of his march through life:‘You’ll have to drive yourself,’ he told her. He’d lost his licence after a drink driving offence. Many people say James Ramage was aggressive when he’d had too much to drink. A political discussion with Ray Garrett over dinner would spiral into a war of words and create a torrent of bad blood. It scared Julie’s mother. In a rage he’d smash glasses EARLY YEARS
99
and anything else he could get his hands on. He was probably drunk and angry when he destroyed a depiction of Northaw Church painted by Julie’s uncle. Julie was petrified to bring home ornaments of any value.The exquisite Limoges china she’d received as a nine-year-old during a visit to France was left with her mum. The thought that the artless James Ramage might smash it was simply too much for his wife to contemplate. From neighbour Harry Testro to the marriage counsellors who listened to him before he killed Julie, it was agreed that Ramage’s temper was a problem.The head-butt in 1991 was not an isolated incident. It might have been the only time he broke Julie’s nose, but it wasn’t the only time he went on a rampage or knocked her to the ground. Although the Garretts didn’t know about the violence, Ramage was scarred by it. He knew it was his weakness and it made him a coward. And the thought that Julie’s father or other men might know cut him deeply. For all his failings, Ramage never damned his wife when he sought the help of psychologists after the separation in 2003. If it’s true that she just ‘lay there’ when they made love, it’s hardly surprising he was annoyed. If he’d known about the affairs, god only knows what he would have said or done. Julie was cheating on him. And, as Philip Dunn was about to show, her girlfriends were a party to the deception. His response to the tension within the marriage was to drive Julie’s family away and isolate her. She didn’t attend the christening of Jane’s first-born child, Charlotte, in 1992 or her parents’ sixtieth birthday parties or William’s christening in 1994. The funeral of Alf Kellett, who’d shown her so much love in Preston after her arrival in Australia, was another special event she was barred from attending. It was heartbreaking for Julie’s family. After years of conflict, the Christmas before Julie was killed offered some hope. It was their first Christmas lunch with the 100
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
extended family for ten years. The erotic affair with Davey and the excitement of her growing status at Eco-d had given her the confidence to demand that they share Christmas with her family. There were thirty-two people at Jane’s house, lots of laughs and plenty of alcohol. ‘He seemed to have a good time and I enjoyed his company and his humour. It was like the good old days,’ said Jane. It wasn’t exactly how Ramage saw it. As they drove home down the dirt road he proceeded to lampoon her dad. It broke Julie’s heart. Six months later she was dead.
EARLY YEARS
101
MR DUNN ARRIVES
Like the rest of Melbourne, the Canterbury set had pored over the Wales-King murders, a year before Julie was killed. Many read Hilary Bonney’s book The Society Murders. Not one of them seriously thought that James Ramage could ever have acted like the brutish, stupid Matthew Wales. Ramage was clever and independently wealthy. He wasn’t a killer. Ian Dicker, president of the Hawthorn Football Club, had been so taken with the Ramage myth he bought a ten per cent share in Thermo-Glaze in 1999. Keen to see him kick on, he encouraged him to join the Young Presidents Association, a worldwide society of aspiring movers and shakers. On 23 March 2004 I met Dicker at the Hyatt Hotel to discuss a business project. On the same day the Age newspaper published an article I’d written on the rape allegations that had rocked rugby and Aussie Rules football. Dicker had read the article. He said the allegations were of great concern to football clubs and society at large. Out of the blue he told me that a business 102
friend had killed his wife. He didn’t say he’d visited the killer in gaol, nor did Dicker recount how he’d cried during the encounter with his friend. Although I was aware of the case I’d not yet spoken to Jane Ashton, and as the committal hearing was still just over a month away, I didn’t make the connection with the Ramage case. The reluctance of male friends to tell Ramage there was no excuse for what he’d done left Jane Ashton sad and confused. Unlike Dicker and Moodie, Jane and her friends decided there’d be no sympathy for the killer. As the committal approached, the women had met to organise rosters for the hearing. ‘We should dress in black,’ Christine Howgate had said. At the lunches that followed the committal a list of names of women angry about the killing and how Julie was being blamed was compiled. When Jane Ashton received word that everything was in order for the committal she organised a meeting with Anne O’Brien from the witness assistance program. A feisty woman with an eye for the horrors of the justice system, O’Brien stepped her through the rules of evidence and the purpose of the committal hearing. A committal is considerably different from a trial. Its essential purpose is to determine whether an accused person has a case to answer.The rules of evidence are such that evidence potentially prejudicial to the defendant is allowed to be aired in order that the magistrate can best determine whether the accused should be committed to stand trial and on what charge. Unfortunately, so strict are the laws governing admissibility of evidence at trial, crucial evidence often doesn’t make its way to the Supreme Court on the grounds that it is prejudicial to the accused. Nothing O’Brien said prepared Jane or Julie’s girlfriends for the barrage that Philip Dunn QC would deliver. Dunn had cut his teeth in the legendary Frank Galbally’s office and was admitted to the bar in 1968. He’s a member of a MR DUNN ARRIVES
103
high-powered team of barristers known as Foley’s List.The presence of ‘so many women from the pony club’ had caused Dunn to raise the spectre of a conspiracy and ask Magistrate Greg McNamara to request that the women leave the court while Ramage’s children were giving evidence. Out of respect to the children, Jane did leave. So too did the majority of the women. Jane knew the real reason Ramage didn’t want the women in court was because he hated the idea of Julie’s friends hearing what he’d done to his wife. In his blinkered eyes the killing of his wife was a private family affair in which other women had no place. ‘Did you speak to anybody else before making your statement? So Julie had Wednesdays off so she could go horse riding and do whatever else?’ The implications of Dunn’s questions to the female witnesses throughout the committal were always the same. The women were part of a plot to discredit Ramage and defend a selfish, adulterous wife. And what did he mean by the rhetorical question about her activities on Wednesdays? She was off fucking the lover.That much was true. Unfortunately no one would hear that she’d become a nervous wreck of a woman who could only survive by popping Valium tranquillisers. Desperate to protect their friend’s name from Dunn’s character assassination, Jane Ashton, Gilda Pekin, Joanne McLean, Tarsha Warren, Rhonda McMurtrie and Felicity Holding fought the defence counsel every step of the way. It didn’t matter. The affairs were Julie’s Archilles heel and Dunn was obsessed with airing them. Julie’s girlfriends had never considered these affairs would form the foundation of Ramage’s defence or that the lovers Laurence Webb and ‘Davey’ would be Dunn’s ace of spades. Soon they realised that very little evidence unfavourable to Ramage would make its way to the Supreme Court.The narrative in which Julie was transformed into at best a promiscuous 104
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
wife and at worst a slut who’d abandoned a devoted father had begun. Jane offered some telling observations: I was shell-shocked at having to relive the death of my sister, with absolutely no compassion or regard for our loss. The witnesses were all articulate, intelligent and honest people who were there on oath to answer questions. We were not there because we were on trial, but because we had unfortunately lost a loved one and had been asked to help the police with their investigations.
What upset Jane immeasurably was that Mr Daryl Brown, who prosecuted the police case at the committal hearing, seemed unable to protect witnesses from Dunn’s attack. All Brown did was ask each witness if their statement was true, then resume his seat and allow Dunn to unleash his bullying. On Friday 7 May 2004, after three days of evidence, Magistrate Greg McNamara advised the defendant he was not obliged to plead guilty or not guilty and that he could reserve his plea until the trial. In response Ramage declared that he was ‘not guilty of murder, but guilty of manslaughter’. Although the charge of murder stood, Ramage had flagged his intention to argue that he’d been provoked to kill by his wife’s taunts and that he should only be found guilty of manslaughter. Provocation was on the agenda again. The mothers at the riding club and in the Scotch and Lauriston milieu knew nothing about the law of provocation.As unpalatable as it might be to some, the law has survived only because its victims have been the powerless. Working class women disconnected from the epicentre of power don’t change laws. As long as it was those women whose rights were trammelled, the law could be hidden from the public gaze. MR DUNN ARRIVES
105
If Christine and the girls had read my book Just Another Little Murder, they’d have been prepared for Dunn’s tirade. Published in late 2002, less than a year before Julie was killed, the book followed years of campaigning against the law of provocation and documented some of the worst acts of criminal law bastardry. If the girls had sat through R v Crowe or cast an eye over what defence barrister Bob Kent said about the murdered Christine Boyce in that trial, they’d have known the courts take a dim view of any woman who enjoys sex outside the marriage. In this disgraceful and barbaric trial the Boyce family suffered humiliation almost unparalleled in Victorian criminal justice history. It reached its lowest point when Kent argued that naked photos of Christine should be admitted as evidence: We would submit it is a proper and valid argument to say it is relevant to know that the person who is deceased in this case was an attractive woman both in face and body and was in fact the wife of the deceased man. And that in those circumstances a juror might say, ‘an ordinary man in this man’s situation may well have acted, lost control and acted in that way [the photos show] she is somebody whom we could understand him having a great passion for.
The photographs had been taken as a birthday present for Crowe at his request.They were in keeping with the way many couples now use digital cameras. US celebrity Paris Hilton and Melbourne singer Debbie Byrne would be stunned to learn that their sexually explicit home videos could be used as defence evidence should an estranged partner kill them. A couple of years before he shot her dead Crowe had broken Christine’s jaw.Wife killers are never cleanskins. Born into a middle class family and educated at a private 106
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Catholic school, Christine never became a cause célèbre of the Canterbury set. Prior to her murder, she had begun working as a prostitute. Her sister says she was so financially poor as a result of the relationship with Kevin Crowe that it was the only way she could survive. Kent’s reason for wanting the photos admitted had nothing to do with understanding how her beauty might have impacted on the killer.The purpose of the salacious photos was to assassinate her character. She was a harlot or, as James Ramage had said of his wife, ‘a slut’. And the murder of sluts, adulterers and prostitutes can never be as serious or morally repulsive as the killing of a chaste or ‘good woman’.That’s why the jury found Crowe guilty only of manslaughter and he was out of gaol in less than four years. History told Philip Dunn that trawling through a dead woman’s affairs only enhanced a killer’s chances. The story about Julie’s Eco-d colleague Jo McLean meeting an AFL footballer at the Botanical Hotel was typical.The events of the night had no bearing on the alleged murder, yet Dunn salivated at the prospect of alluding to the man’s identity. Although prosecutor Daryl Brown objected when Dunn said ‘you’d had a relationship with the prominent footballer’, the point had been made. Despite neither the events of the night nor the footballer’s name throwing any light on the killing, Dunn twice cited the man’s Christian name. Everyone knew he was married. That Julie, who’d hidden so much from her husband, would tell him about Jo’s flirtation mystified her friends. It shouldn’t have. He browbeat her so much about the man she met it was her only escape route. She could never have imagined Jo’s alleged fling would be used against her. Julie should have known better. At the committal hearing Dunn used it to intimidate the female witnesses and, by association, to besmirch Julie’s character. It was testimony to Jo’s confidence and courage that MR DUNN ARRIVES
107
she didn’t cower. So powerful was her defence of Julie, Dunn was left in her wake. A modern woman, she was not about to be silenced by his puritanical cross-examination. Descriptions of Julie as ‘fearing’ Ramage convinced Dunn that Jo McLean might do his client untold harm if he tried to intimidate her at the trial. This probably explains why he didn’t ask her about the night at the Botanical, when she took the stand in the supreme court on 18 October 2004. The joust between Dunn and McLean at the trial was a tame affair. Sounding old and out of date, like the law of provocation itself, Dunn was no match for this young woman. A man of traditional values, Ray Garrett was devastated by the portrayal of his daughter at the committal. For a protective father who’d never wanted his daughter to marry Ramage and had been implacably opposed to her having sex with him as a seventeen-year-old, the trial evidence was confounding and humiliating. In the face of Ramage’s aggression and violence his daughter’s loyalty made her look like a helpless victim, a woman so weak that she couldn’t leave the marriage.Then when she did seek romantic comfort outside a loveless marriage the whole saga looked so undignified and sordid. After he gave evidence on 5 May 2004, the first day of the three-day committal hearing, Ray’s health went into a spiral. On the Saturday he had to be taken to the Austin Hospital by ambulance suffering severe stomach pains and a dangerously high temperature. A proud father helpless to protect his daughter and denied the right to advise anyone on how to represent her. Abandoned and forgotten, like all the dead women before her, it seemed Julie Ramage had become just another victim. Shocked and rattled by Philip Dunn’s bullying of witnesses, Christine Howgate was the first of Julie’s friends to ring me. It was late May 2004. ‘Would you mind speaking with Jane?’ she 108
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
asked.When Jane rang a few days later it was all so familiar. He’ll get manslaughter – I didn’t say it, but I knew it. Already Christine had fired off a letter to Dunn: Matthew and Sam don’t need a father who killed their mother, but they do need to hear what a wonderful person their mother was. They need to know that she was proud of them and that she endured the condescending taunts and abuses of James because she knew that if she were to leave he would try to poison her children against her and would make their lives difficult in order to punish her. He had a track record of doing just that whenever she did anything for herself that he didn’t approve of. Matt and Sam testified that their parents had a ‘normal’ marriage.You would have to agree that ‘normal’ is very difficult to define and of course those kids knew nothing else. But we all know what isn’t normal.
Julie’s friends didn’t realise what a difference they were about to make and how this murder would capture the public’s imagination. Everywhere Julie Garrett went, people took to her. From Eco-d to the pony club, she made people feel good.That’s why her friends were in court in defiance of the bullyboy Philip Dunn.This was a murder case with a twist. It was a middle class murder in a society where class is as powerful a force as it has ever been. Just as the murder of the wealthy matriarch Margaret Wales-King and her husband Paul King in 2002 had everyone talking, so the story of Julie Ramage would soon dominate the headlines.
MR DUNN ARRIVES
109
THE TRIAL BEGINS
I didn’t meet Jane Ashton in person until just before 10.30 am on Tuesday 12 October 2004, the first day evidence was heard in the trial. She was seated on one of the church-like pews in the foyer outside Court 12, in Melbourne’s Supreme Court building on the corner of Lonsdale and William Street. The court was on the opposite side of the Supreme Court complex from where Vicki’s killer had been tried.The memory of a gruelling committal hearing flooding her head, she looked almost comatose as a witness assistance officer hovered over her. Jane had emailed me the day before to say she would be giving evidence. Now fully aware that her brother-in-law would be pleading guilty to manslaughter on the grounds that his wife’s provocative behaviour had caused him to lose control, she was genuinely fearful of what lay ahead. We spoke only a few words before I stuck my head in the empty, silent courtroom. No matter which court or foyer you’re in, they all look the same. It’s like being lost in Venice, where 110
every canal looks identical to the next. It could have been yesterday that I was in the supreme court listening to Keogh’s defence unfold. George Hampel’s fine-boned face – ferret-like, said Mum – embellished by the white wig and the splash of red around his shoulders.The pictures were all so vivid. Keogh at the back, fixated on every word. He couldn’t sit still in school and as a kid was legendary for terrorising teachers, yet in court he didn’t miss a beat. It seemed like yesterday. The reminiscing was brought to an end when a gruff female security guard burst in and said, ‘Move away, please.’ She was doing a security reconnoitre for the arrival of the killer. I stepped out into the foyer. If those walls could talk they’d relate some gut-wrenching stories about the killing of women.Terrible stories, hidden away in the vaults of the Office of the Public Prosecutor. It was the first time I’d been inside one of those courts since 1989. For the first two weeks of February my family made the almost religious pilgrimage to the court for the ponderous and sublimely fictitious reconstruction of the murder of my sister Vicki. On the last day, Detective Barry McIntosh burst into tears near the window that looks out on Lonsdale Street and the new County Court building. He took the manslaughter verdict as hard as my family did. ‘I thought I might see you here,’ Crown Prosecutor Julian Leckie said as I took his outstretched hand.A quietly spoken and methodical man, educated at Ivanhoe Grammar, Leckie had been assigned the task of countering the theatrical windbag, Philip Dunn. Dunn had built a name as an animated, combative defence lawyer. His critics said it was all show. ‘So, what are you going to do about the provocation? You’ll oppose it going to the jury, won’t you?’ I said as Leckie prepared to squeeze his slender body through the narrow swing doors leading to the court. THE TRIAL BEGINS
111
‘Don’t want a retrial,’ he replied with a sort of nervous grimace. ‘What’s that mean?’ asked a friend of Julie’s who’d overheard the conversation. How do you explain the absurdity of the law of provocation, I thought as I set about unravelling the real meaning of the words? ‘If Leckie convinces the judge that provocation shouldn’t be left to the jury and Ramage is found guilty of murder, he’ll appeal and ask for a retrial. So Leckie will agree to Ramage running provocation, but he’ll tell the jury they should reject it and find him guilty of murder,’ I replied. The bloke looked bewildered. So he should have. It was the wrong decision by the crown prosecutor and would come back to haunt him. There was nothing flamboyant about Julian Leckie and he wasn’t a risk-taker. The ruddy-faced man with a penchant for interrupting any woman, who didn’t give him the answer he wanted, would be the risk-taker in this case. While Dunn was bombarding Julie’s friends at the committal hearing, Crown Prosecutor Julian Leckie had been up to his neck in R vYasso. Mazin Yasso, an Iraqi living in Meadow Heights, had stabbed his estranged wife, Eman Hermiz, to death on 8 May 2001. So terrified was Eman that she’d taken out a restraining order against Yasso. Her niece, Susan Kalandos, says that the day before she was murdered, Eman rang 000 and asked for help.The police ethical standards department say they have no record of the call. Susan swears that the call was made. A piece of paper made no difference to Yasso. Outside the language centre where he corralled Eman he showed her who was boss. Later he would claim she spat at him and that this caused him to lose control. His counsel said he was entitled to the defence of provocation. Leckie wouldn’t hear of it. Justice Coldrey agreed and the jury found the killer guilty of murder, whereupon Coldrey sentenced 112
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
him to fifteen years’ gaol. On 5 August 2004, two months before the Ramage case was set to open, an appeal court overturned the verdict. In a two to one ruling, with Justice Frank Vincent dissenting, judges Stephen Charles and John Batt ruled that Justice Coldrey was wrong to deny Yasso a provocation defence and he should therefore be retried. It was another example of backward thinking on the bench. The appeal court’s Justice Stephen Charles captured the spirit of the judiciary when he observed ‘in the present case there was much evidence that the alleged affair between the deceased and Nasir Haba had brought shame and humiliation to the applicant and caused him much distress. All of this would have provided a basis for suspecting that the applicant in speaking to the police may have down-played or lied about the deceased’s relationship with Nasir Haba.’ Charles was so far off the mark it was embarrassing. There was no affair. Nor did Yasso think his wife was having an affair. All Eman was doing was confiding in a man she’d met at language school. In any case, it didn’t seem to register with Justice Charles that ‘an affair’ is not an excuse to murder or a reason for allowing a provocation defence. That John Howard, George Bush and the so-called coalition of the willing had taken us to war in Afghanistan and against so-called ‘fundamentalist Muslims’ elsewhere to free women from oppression seemed to carry no weight when a Taliban-like warrior murdered an Australian woman on home soil. In his summary Justice Charles justified his decision as follows: Mr Tehan, who appeared for the applicant, submitted that the following matters of Chaldean culture had been established in evidence and were relevant. Chaldeans live under a code of strict traditions and customs that have continued THE TRIAL BEGINS
113
for many hundreds of years. In Chaldean tradition marital fidelity is of paramount importance. Divorce is not allowed, nor remarriage upon the death of one of the spouses. And no distinction is drawn between married parties who live together and those who live apart. In Chaldean tradition the wife’s marital infidelity is a source of strong, social disapproval not only for the wife but for the husband with the potential to result in a lifelong smear upon the husband who is considered responsible for the acts of his wife.There was evidence also that the act of a wife spitting at or upon her husband is an act of almost unthinkable insult of such gravity that there would be an expectation that the wife would be beaten or killed if not by her husband then by her family.
Not one of the defenders of the war in Afghanistan or Iraq put pen to paper in condemnation of the appeal court’s decision to take a sympathetic view of ‘cultural murder’. Nor did they ask any of Eman’s family whether it was true that Chaldeans were religious or fundamentalist. Jamal Kalandos, Eman’s brother-inlaw, told me it was ‘bullshit’ that Chaldeans live by strict rules. ‘They’re Christians not strict Muslims and they divorce in Iraq and in Australia,’ he said. Eman Hermiz didn’t wear a veil. She went out to work as a hairdresser, wearing jeans and clothing no different from any other working class girl from the northern suburbs. This wasn’t an ethnic killing.To describe it that way, as Justice Charles did, was to ignore the fact that Australian men kill their wives for exactly the same reasons. The murder in Meadow Heights was an honour killing. It was honour killing founded in western patriarchy, not ethnicity. When the appeal court couldn’t find any ameliorating factors in Yasso’s slaughter of his 114
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
estranged wife they imagined some. Patriarchy, dressed up in the strictures of Chaldean culture, had triumphed again. If an affair doesn’t condemn a woman, then separation will. If that fails, there’s always something to save a man.The excuse for the redhaired, freckly Balwyn businessman was ‘a rigidity of thinking’. According to the textbook, provocation murders turn on whether a man has lost control, as any ordinary man might do after being subjected to insulting words and actions. For Ramage it was the provocative words of his wife.When the cant is stripped away, the law of provocation is all about a woman’s defiance and has nothing to do with provocative words or gestures. Eman Hermiz stood 152 centimetres tall and weighed 47 kilos. If she was so frightened of Yasso that she’d taken out an intervention order and was regularly ringing 000 in desperation, was she likely to spit at him? Like Julie Ramage, she didn’t stand a chance. It was left to the appeal court’s Justice Vincent, an established critic of the provocation defence, to provide the truth as to the extent of provocation in R v Yasso: In my view it was clearly open to his Honour, who clearly had regard to all of the relevant legal principles and evidence addressed in the trial including that concerning the cultural background of the applicant, to conclude in effect that, as Brooking, J.A. found in Parsons:‘no reasonable jury could have failed to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the applicant’s reaction to the victim’s conduct fell below – indeed, fell a long, long way below – the minimum limits of the range of powers of self-control that must be attributed to the ordinary person.’
The crown prosecutor’s decision to roll over on provocation and not oppose it being left to the jury, spelt trouble for the THE TRIAL BEGINS
115
Garretts. All the ingredients existed for another swine to be excused of murder. He wasn’t an unemployed, tattooed Peter Keogh or a struggling Iraqi whose swarthy skin was a symbol of inferiority.This was a ‘society murder’ and a soap opera in which money, glamour and the deadly sin of adultery would fire every frame. Ramage had struck the first blow with provocation being left to the jury. Whatever they might have thought deep down, the twelve men and women of the jury now had to ask themselves one very perplexing question. Might an ordinary man with the characteristics of James Ramage kill his wife if, as he alleged, she taunted him about his sexual prowess? If they believed the prosecution had not proved beyond reasonable doubt that an ordinary man could not do this, then Ramage would walk with manslaughter and reduce his sentence by up to ten years. Philip Dunn QC understood the real meaning of Justice Charles’ ruling onYasso. It’s always infidelity or alleged infidelity, not words or gestures, that form the basis of provocation. And what better way to explore the issue of infidelity than with an inquisition of Julie’s identical twin, Jane Ashton. Jane faced her day in court and the prospect of another round of bullying from Philip Dunn with great trepidation. Prior to the commencement of proceedings she’d sat with Matt and Sam Ramage and her dad in the little witness room. It was tense and uncomfortable as they waited for the crown prosecutor to explain their roles.When Leckie arrived he advised the children of their right to avoid giving evidence if they felt it might jeopardise their relationship with their father. They nodded then said they wished to take the stand. Some of Julie’s friends were surprised that Leckie had decided to take this course of action. Jane had pleaded with the prosecution team not to put the children in the witness box. From his gaol cell Ramage had been 116
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
placing his children under increasing pressure. They’d lost their mother. What was to be gained from losing their father for twenty years, said Phil Dunn? As the months rolled on the children had come to the realisation that they should make the best of a bad lot. As much as Jane longed for them to defend her twin, she wasn’t hopeful.‘If I get a long sentence I’ll commit suicide,’ Ramage had told his son. She prayed that it would backfire and his son would disown him. While the discussion with Leckie was taking place I grabbed a seat in the court almost identical to the one I’d had in court 3 in 1989. From the end of a long pew just inside the doors I had a panoramic view of the court and a direct view of the jury. Between the killer and me was the female security guard I’d seen earlier. Ramage was so close I could have spoken to him without raising my voice.When he was led through the foyer past the little pole that gives directions to the various courts he was anything but imposing. Gaunt and drained of colour he looked poorly. He was a big man; around 6 feet 2 inches (188 centimetres), but he looked more like a businessman down on his luck than a hardy plumber or a construction worker.‘Coward,’ I thought. What made him tick and what really happened when Julie sat opposite him in the kitchen that day? Why did a man with assets worth $2.5 million and a bathtub thermoglazing business making money hand over fist need to kill his wife? So many questions, so few answers. None of the men whose acquaintance he’d made in pursuit of his wealth were in the court.Although Ian Dicker and Rob Moodie had visited him in gaol, they hadn’t found time to hear the evidence or mix with the grieving family in court. Despite scores of manipulative letters to friends and parents at Scotch College, Ramage had hardly a friend in the world. Ramage had chosen to send his son to the prestigious Scotch College for all the wrong reasons.The all-boys ‘army on the hill’, THE TRIAL BEGINS
117
as Scotch was known locally, was the place where men of influence networked and deals were done, sometimes by way of the secret Masonic handshake. In these circles Ramage had fanatically sought out those who might help him make money. And there he was, a truly pathetic and lonely man, caged in a little platform at the back of a courtroom. If only we could ‘wind back the clock’ and start again, Ramage had said in his police interview on the night of the alleged murder. Unfortunately he didn’t mean it. ‘I’ve been too controlling. I wish I could wind back the clock,’ he’d told psychologist Tom Paterson in front of his wife six days before the murder. The prospect of Ramage being convicted of murder and going to gaol for fifteen years was of little comfort to Julie’s family. A simple ‘sorry’ would have been more comforting. Why wasn’t he stopped? Where were the men when Julie needed them? Suburban thug or Balwyn businessman, it made no difference.The challenge was to stop them. Before he could cross-examine Jane Ashton, Philip Dunn had faced one major hurdle. He had to expunge from the trial as much evidence as possible prejudicial to his client. The test wasn’t only whether the evidence was verifiable fact or hearsay. Might it unfairly prejudice a fair trial and was it relevant? They were the questions Dunn would ask Justice Robert Osborn. For the duration of the week before the jury was empanelled, Leckie and Dunn had put their cases before the judge. Dunn knew his best chance of a manslaughter verdict lay in dragging Julie’s affairs with Sean Mays and Davey and her relationship with Webb backwards and forwards past the jury. He also knew that Ramage’s documented head-butting of his wife in 1991 was damaging. It was too long ago to be of relevance, said Dunn. After five torturous days of what in legal circles is pompously known as voir dire, Justice Osborn ruled that the jury would not 118
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
hear how Julie had told her friends her husband would ‘kill her’ if he found out about her affairs. It was considered prejudicial to the accused. Julie’s friends were dumbfounded. Although the affair with Davey had no connection with the killing, Dunn wanted it in. He argued that even if Ramage didn’t know about his wife’s sexual dalliances, their existence added veracity to the claim that his wife had insulted his sexual prowess in the kitchen before he killed her. In other words, if she’d had affairs before and in the weeks after the marriage break-up, Julie was more likely to be in a position to belittle his sexual prowess. It didn’t matter that Ramage had never once in his police interview suggested his wife had used her affairs to insult or belittle him. Nor did it matter that she’d been terrified that he’d find out about David and that the only man mentioned by Ramage was Laurence Webb, who he already knew about. To ensure that the defence was not denied ‘evidence considered most favourable to the accused’, as the law deems it, Osborn said the jury should hear about the affairs. The admissibility of the steamy affair with Davey was a massive strike for Ramage: ‘Well, one way of avoiding upsetting her husband would have been to have not had an affair,’ Dunn would quip before the trial was over. And while Julie’s affairs were admissible, the same did not apply to Ramage’s violence. Despite a doctor’s report that he’d head-butted his wife and broken her nose in 1991, and evidence at the committal that he’d given his daughter a black eye, the prior violence could not be led. It was too long ago according to the rules of relationship evidence. If relationship evidence was desgined to help a jury better understand the origins of an act of violence, it was a disgraceful failure in R v Ramage. With Julie’s frantic ‘he’ll kill me if he finds out’ ruled inadmissible, the best Leckie would be allowed to induce people to THE TRIAL BEGINS
119
say was that she was scared he might kill her horse and maybe hurt her. It was odd, but not entirely surprising that Justice Osborn allowed the jury to hear about Julie’s affairs. This is the stuff of ‘wife murder’ trials. It isn’t just about a jury hearing ‘all evidence favourable’ to the accused. It’s about the sanctity of marriage and the power of sex and adultery. For Jane Ashton and Christine Howgate and the women who made up Julie’s social set, the decision was baffling. For those who’ve seen a provocation defence unfold in a so-called civilised western court, it was unremarkable. Whereas Ramage had hired Dunn before the committal, Julian Leckie had only picked up the case five days before the trial. A veteran of the circuit, with a considered and highly critical view of the operation of the law of provocation, he genuinely thought Ramage would go down for murder. There was a body and little mystery if any, and the killer had not only strangled his estranged wife, he’d buried her. Although Leckie had to familiarise himself with the facts of the case in a hurry, his instructing solicitor, twenty-eight-year-old Jordana Millman, had been with it since the committal. Educated at Wesley College, Jordana had been involved in only six murder cases, none of them involving provocation. She’s a young woman with a phlegmatic view of the law and its nuances. ‘I can’t afford to be overly passionate if I’m to think straight about the facts,’ she told me. Millman’s not one to make rash or colourful statements or throw the word ‘misogyny’ into a public conversation.‘Prosecutors must be objective at all times.’ To the family of a murdered woman, detachment of this kind can be akin to insensitivity. When I noticed Dunn and Leckie laughing, if only briefly, in the doorway to the courtyard during a break in proceedings my heart sank. Murder does that to you. 120
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
There was nothing phlegmatic or dispassionate about Philip Dunn.When interviewed on Channel Seven’s Today Tonight program after the trial he described as ‘bullshit’ the claim that his client had three hours to construct his case.The young reporter didn’t bother to ask him to elaborate. It was typical of Dunn’s bravado. Which part of the assertion didn’t he agree with? Was Pica only there for two hours? Did they not discuss the murder or the defence of provocation? A woman had been murdered and the best Dunn could do was offer a smartarse riposte. I lost a sister to murder and saw her killer found guilty of manslaughter due to provocation. I wouldn’t laugh with Dunn in the foyer or anywhere else.
THE TRIAL BEGINS
121
JANE ASHTON IS CALLED
Following a ten-minute break during which Leckie explained his instructions to Ramage’s children, His Honour Justice Bob Osborn asked that the jury be called back into the court.There was nothing out of the ordinary about this jury of seven men and five women. No young women, university students or men with dreadlocks. It was a very suburban collection; pious and censorious. Anyone looking vaguely feminist had been expunged. After describing herself as a retired journalist, Kate Baillieu was given short shrift by Dunn. Sister of Liberal politician Ted Baillieu and a child of one of Melbourne’s wealthiest and most prominent society families, Kate Baillieu’s history preceded her. The last thing Ramage needed was a woman with a deep vein of suffragette blood judging a wife killer. Nervous but determined, Jane Ashton looked straight ahead, her blonde hair resting in neat symmetry on her shoulders. Despite the tired eyes she looked fit and healthy in black trousers and a white blouse. It was the same outfit she’d worn to the 122
funeral.As much as she wanted to tell the real story of the killing of her twin sister, the best she’d been able to say to prosecutor Julian Leckie during her time in the witness box was that her sister ‘didn’t want to trigger any incidents of violence, and that she just hoped that he would accept her decision’. The cocky Philip Dunn,‘Dunny Boy’ to his mates, was itching to get at her.The moment he stood up to cross-examine Jane his intentions were transparent. ‘Mrs Ashton, on Sunday 20 July last year you had a conversation with your sister Julie, did you not?’ Before she’d finished the answer she knew what would follow. Laurence Webb was the reason for this tragedy. The man Dunn had labelled a ‘bounder’ and a ‘cad’ at the committal would play a crucial role in the case for the defence. Dunn didn’t waste any time. ‘During that conversation, she told you, did she not, that she had met the love of her life?’ ‘She said that she and Laurence were in love.’ Desperate to have Jane repeat the words ‘love of her life’ Dunn reminded her of an earlier statement and then asserted that she was now changing her statement. Even before she could properly answer, he was into her. Edgy and looking straight ahead rather than at Dunn, Jane tried to hold her nerve. Frustrated by Jane’s refusal to buckle, Dunn tried to portray her as a prejudicial witness.‘You don’t like James Ramage, do you?’ It’s a rhetorical question asked by every defence lawyer when a witness has something unpalatable to say about a killer. Ramage had killed Jane’s sister and she was being asked to confirm her evenhandedness to him. ‘Just because he slaughtered my sister doesn’t mean I don’t like him.’ Is this what Dunn expected Jane to say? Unperturbed, Jane told the truth. She disliked him. Had she disliked him for many years, asked Dunn? Again the answer was a powerful ‘yes’.The truth was that from the time they first met at the Garrett home in Goffs Oak, Hertfordshire in 1978, she’d been JANE ASHTON IS CALLED
123
his nemesis. Bright, irreverent and independent, she was no man’s doormat and there was no love lost between them. A mirror image of the dead woman, it was as if Julie was speaking from the grave. With her good looks and her English accent, whilst not upper class, adding an air of authority, Jane’s cross-examination was as eerie as it was tense. Her vulnerability as a witness, however, was that she’d told Ramage the relationship with Webb was innocent and that it would be good for him to go to counselling. She was cast as a duplicitous matchmaker who hated Ramage so much she’d say anything to hurt his name. Hadn’t she offered the fragile James Ramage hope while secretly facilitating Julie’s abandonment of him for another man? From the first moment of the first day of evidence, Ramage was presented as a man in love, encircled by a gaggle of heartless feminists intent on wrecking his family. Bored, or feeling he’d exhausted that line of argument, Dunn turned the spotlight on Jane’s father. ‘Your father was a strict disciplinarian?’ he said. ‘Yes.’ ‘Conservative?’ ‘No.’ ‘Old-fashioned in some ways?’ ‘No.’ ‘When your sister was having an intimate relationship–’ It was enough for Leckie. ‘I object to this,’ he said. ‘Why?’ ‘How is it relevant? ‘Your Honour, I understood the psychological state of mind of Mrs Ramage was very relevant, and what I wanted to establish was that she’d been asked to leave school by her father.’ ‘It’s hearsay…ancient history…and it’s to get sympathy,’ said Leckie, rolling up his sleeves for a rare battle with his opposite 124
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
number. Dunn had one parting shot.‘It had nothing to do with trying to get sympathy,’ he said. It was a bullshit answer. There could only be one reason for this question. He was trying to cast doubt on the state of mind of the dead woman. In 1991 a psychotherapist, Dr John Buchanan, had documented Julie as saying that ‘like her father James was too involved in business’. Dunn would have loved to refer to it as an example of Julie’s ungratefulness. The trouble was Buchanan’s report only came about because of Ramage’s violent head-butt of Julie, and Dunn didn’t want the jury to know about that. As Dunn attacked Julie’s state of mind I recalled Australian author Helen Garner’s book Joe Cinque’s Consolation, and how I cringed when she describes Anu Singh, the woman convicted of the drug-induced killing of her boyfriend in Canberra in 1997, as the epitome of what women fear in themselves:‘the damaged infant, the vain, frantic, destructive, out of control’. It was this poisoned chalice that Philip Dunn had handed to Julie’s twin sister at the committal. Now it was in her hand again and it was brimming with lust, love, vanity and betrayal. Dunn had to do more than convince the jury that his client was out of control when he strangled his wife. If Ramage was to avoid a verdict of murder, Dunn had to convince a jury that Jane’s sister was ‘vain, destructive and out of control’. Erotic letters from a lover would help prove Julie’s vanity and betrayal of her husband. Her declaration of love for Webb, after being intimate only five times, proved she was ‘frantic’. Julie was menstruating.Would that help prove that she was out of control? If he could paint her as an example of the ‘damaged child’ about which Helen Garner wrote, the jury might be sympathetic to the killer. After a series of inferences about affairs and deceit being the reason for the killing, Dunn attempted to bully Jane into saying there had been no violence in the marriage.To do this he had to JANE ASHTON IS CALLED
125
concentrate on the past few years. If Dunn offered an open question, the only answer Jane could give was that Ramage had bashed her sister in 1991.This being the case, he asked whether she knew of any violence in the years 2000, 2001, 2002 and 2003. When she replied, ‘Sorry, could you repeat the dates?’ he restated the question again, without the dates. This merely prompted a further question from Jane. Whether she had planned her answer or it had come spontaneously, it was a brilliant strategy.‘The dates please?’ she said once more, whereupon Dunn decided to answer it himself. His ‘I know you say he does’ was met by the same question, ‘The dates please?’ It was an unambiguous confirmation by Jane that there was violence. It was just a matter of when. It wasn’t the answer Dunn wanted. Believing she needed rescuing, Leckie had interjected, ‘Let her finish, please, she was…’ Jane didn’t need help. ‘I want the dates, the years you were suggesting,’ she said. Dunn had nowhere to go except to repeat the years. Aware that there was no documented evidence of violence over the past three years, Dunn wanted Ramage’s enemy to utter the words ‘there was no violence’. Eventually he took the witness back to the statement she made at the committal hearing:‘the only incident I’ve heard about was when he pushed her around, pushed her off the bed’. Even if the rules of evidence prevented her from saying Ramage had bashed her sister, broken her nose and bullied her, it had been a brave try. Julie would have been proud. I understood Dunn’s position, but I just didn’t respect it.We all deserve to be judged by what we say and do. Dunn can hide behind the ‘only doing my job’ line as much as he likes. It cuts no ice with me.The endless salacious drivel about the men Julie had met and how James was having counselling threw not one shred of light on the homicide. Nor did the pigeonholing of witnesses’ answers allow the real truth to surface. As theatre, 126
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Dunn’s antics were worth a look. As pursuit of truth or fact, the whole trial was a disaster. Derisively portrayed by Dunn as having ‘fallen in love with a new beau’ Julie was being transformed into a femme fatale.Worse still, she was being made to look silly and capricious.Three brief affairs in twenty years had turned an otherwise ordinary suburban mother into a sex siren. Julie had met a man at the Botanical Hotel and agreed to meet him for dinner and she’d been out a handful of times with Laurence.And there was Dunn, his big square head crowned by a wig that made him look like a Cromwellian foot soldier and gave his words the ring of an antiquated old fart, floundering in a world he simply didn’t understand. Back in his office were all the signs that he was a man of the world and a defender of the downtrodden. The Aboriginal art and the leather trappings confirmed he was both a great advocate of the disadvantaged and a person of taste. Sadly, defending wife killers came with the territory. Watching Dunn parading before the court filled me with a mixture of anger and contempt. It was the same contempt that consumed me when I came across Bob Vernon’s words in Peter Keogh’s musty files at the Office of Public Prosecutions.Vernon had died prematurely in 2000, only three years after losing a scandalous case before the Crimes Compensation Tribunal in which he’d been accused of rapaciously seducing his fourteenyear-old babysitter, Barbara Biggs, in the early seventies.A couple of years after the sexual assault of Biggs he was defending Keogh against the charge of raping a nine-year-old girl. Vernon’s theatrical courtroom capers were legendary in the bars around Melbourne’s legal precinct. None was better than his performance in getting Keogh off the attempted murder of a police officer in 1964.‘Whatever he [Keogh] may be, he is not the sort of person who would normally take a dagger and attack people with it,’Vernon had implored Justice Monahan. JANE ASHTON IS CALLED
127
In 2001 a letter from a young woman,Terri McNulty, showed just how wrong Vernon had been.‘We looked under the beds, in wardrobes…then we opened Mum’s wardrobe and all her clothes had been cut and her shoes cut…then Mum yelled to get out of the house…Mum came running out the front door with him [Keogh] chasing…he grabbed her with one arm around her neck and another with the knife at her throat.Then a truck came along and he let her go.’The incident occurred in Northcote, less than six years before Keogh used his knife on my sister. Terri’s mother had separated from Keogh. Defence barristers don’t tell the truth about wife murderers. Protected by a discriminatory law they create a lie. That’s why I’d always regretted not telling defence barrister John Champion that his version of my sister’s murder was almost as bad as the murder itself. This time there’d be no regrets. ‘Excuse me, Mr Dunn, I was wondering whether I could interview you,’ I said as he made his way towards the courtyard during the lunch break on Tuesday 12 October 2004. He looked a little perplexed until I identified myself. ‘Oh, Phil Cleary, you’re a legend,’ he said. ‘I’d like to ask you whether you see any similarity between your questions and the way women are treated by the Taliban in Afghanistan.’ It wasn’t anywhere near the most difficult question he’d been asked, but it struck a nerve. ‘Only doing my job,’ he said, scurrying off. It was a far cry from the bullying man who paraded before the jury. Christine Howgate was so stunned by Dunn’s cross-examination of Jane and his demeaning of Julie that she went to Jane’s home that night and cried until 2 am. Another friend was so distressed she began talking suicide. The women couldn’t believe that the true story of Julie’s life was being hidden from the world. Matthew Ramage, approaching nineteen years of age and almost at the end of his first year at Melbourne University, was 128
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
the first of Ramage’s children to take the stand. Over the previous year James Ramage had bludgeoned his son into believing his mother’s death was the consequence of an unfortunate sequence of events. An accident brought about by his mother’s wayward behaviour. As much as Matt’s physical size created the appearance of confidence, he was snared in an intricate web. James Ramage’s share of Thermo-Glaze was calculated at around $1.1 million. Even if Dunn and his team wiped out $200 000 it was a nest egg few teenage children could ever contemplate. Ramage had told his son he’d be the recipient of the money. This and the pressure he faced to not damn his father, was a massive burden for someone so young. On top of the money from the business, their mother’s last will and testament bequeathed them a $900 000 house in Balwyn and other policies and investments worth close to $500 000.This was no family fighting over table scraps. When police photographer Lisa Cook turned her camera on the house she gave us a glimpse into the character of the inhabitants. From the Donna Hay poster above his bed to the Scotch College school photo on the wall, there was not a single thing out of place in Matthew’s room. No one could quite explain why a cookbook queen had pride of place on his wall. If nothing else, like his father he was a disciple of orderliness. No fraying posters with ripped corners for this eighteenyear-old boy. No clothes on the floor.The large photo of those proud Scotch boys, every single one and another of Scotch’s Cadet Unit bore testament to the path he was walking.Although his dad liked Prime Minister John Howard and Matt probably voted the same way at the 2004 election, his taste in music wasn’t conservative. The Australian band Powderfinger, who’d been known to take a swipe at Pauline Hanson and John Howard style politics, and the alternative bands the Black Eyed JANE ASHTON IS CALLED
129
Peas and the John Butler Trio, all featured on the symmetrically decorated walls.Yet for all the flirtations with dissent it was said he was not a boy in revolt.As one family friend put it,‘Matt was malleable like his mum, whereas Sam was the rebellious partygirl.’ I waited to see if he was right. From the opening account of the events of the early evening to the dinner at Colombo’s it was obvious Matthew was not about to set his dad adrift. They’d driven to Colombo’s rather than walked because he had a physics exam the next day and was in a hurry. He couldn’t remember much discussion about his mother apart from their collective desire to move on after the separation. His parents had arguments ‘like any other couple’. His father had told him on the night of the Geelong trip that Julie was seeing another man. However his dad ‘didn’t know the full extent of the relationship at that time’, said Matthew. Did he mean before or after the Geelong trip? It wasn’t clear. Leckie would return to this vital question. By now it was obvious to Julie’s friends in court that everything Matthew Ramage said about his father would be considered and careful. They didn’t expect him to crucify his dad, but they did think he might stick up for his dead mother. They didn’t know he’d spent four hours with Dunn in his chambers before the committal hearing.When it came to the question of the phone call made by his dad as he walked to the police station, suspense gripped the courtroom. ‘He sounded, I suppose a bit jittery and worried and yes, a bit of a wreck,’ said the boy. Hearts sank in despair. ‘How could he be a wreck when he’s taken Matt out for dinner and spent three hours with a barrister?’ said Christine Howgate. When asked whether he knew about the serious argument that might have precipitated Julie’s decision to leave, Matthew offered the benign ‘they had arguments, like all people’. He told 130
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Leckie he knew about his father pushing his mother out of bed but couldn’t remember who told him. By now some of Julie’s friends were furious. There was hardly an answer he gave that pleased them. It was all about emphasis. In the face of concerted resistance the crown prosecutor went about the task with skill and quiet diligence. Despite the emotional tension he was experiencing, Matt had a sharp eye for the implications of every question. This was no more evident than when Leckie returned to the question of the relationship with Webb and what Matt’s father knew about it.‘Do you remember having a conversation with your mother around Friday 18 July just a few days before she died?’ asked Leckie. The prosecution desperately needed to quash the idea that Ramage only grasped the seriousness of the relationship when Julie arrived at Marock Place on the Monday of her death. And one person who knew the truth was her son. ‘Yes, I think I have to distinguish – I spoke to Mum on Sunday night as well,’ he said, as Leckie searched for an answer that put time between the killing and when Julie told her husband the relationship was over. ‘Did he say anything about it being obvious that the relationship was totally over?’ asked Leckie. ‘No, he didn’t.’ ‘Are you certain about that?’ ‘I can’t remember.’ ‘You can’t remember? Did you make a statement?’ ‘Yes, I made a statement.’ ‘I’d ask that you have a look at this document…you understand the line I’m referring to?’ ‘Yes.’ ‘I’d ask you again now …’ ‘Yes, I suppose that over the Saturday and the Sunday when JANE ASHTON IS CALLED
131
we found out [about Laurence and the marriage being over] we talked a lot about it and I suppose we might...yes…he could have said those things. On Friday 18 July Mum told me that there wasn’t much chance of them getting back together. I feel that Dad felt very disappointed that Mum was already with someone so soon after the split up. I was extremely disappointed in Mum because she promised me that she wouldn’t be with anyone else. Dad and I spoke at length about Mum seeing another man and he made the comments such as “it keeps getting worse…it’s obviously totally over now”.’ ‘Thank you. I have no further questions of the witness,’ said a contented Julian Leckie. Julie’s friends had a mountain of questions. ‘How could Matthew possibly forget that he’d told the police this critical fact within hours of learning his dad had killed his mum?’ they muttered in the gallery. How could he be so certain his father knew about Julie’s new lover on Saturday or Sunday, then tell the court Ramage ‘could have said he knew’? Did pressure from a manipulative father leave this devoted son open to the accusation that he was hiding the truth? It was a tragedy that a boy’s love for his father should have come at the expense of the woman who’d brought him into the world. On 13 November 1985 his mum wrote to her sister about her love for her baby: ‘It’s hard to put in a letter just how much we both love him. He’s just so beautiful. He laughs and has a real personality already.’ Would reading those words have made any difference to what Matthew might have said? Who knows? The prosecutor didn’t want to be seen to be too harsh on a boy who’d lost a mother, but as much as he didn’t show it or make any public comments, in the foyer he was heard to say ‘it was like pulling teeth’.The generous would forgive Matthew and his aunty still loved him. Others, especially those who listened as Julian 132
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
Leckie read the last line from Matthew’s statement, weren’t as generous. In front of two counsellors on Tuesday afternoon and on Saturday in Geelong, Julie had told her estranged husband it was over. She even told him there was another man.What more could she have done? Only one thing: return to ‘the boys’ and their fortress in Balwyn.The truth lay in the fine print. No one noticed Matthew’s use of the collective noun ‘we’ in his answer.‘Yes, I suppose that over the Saturday and the Sunday when we found out, we talked a lot about it and I suppose we might...yes…he could have said those things,’ said Matthew. These were the words of a boy under immense pressure from a desperate father. As much as Julie had tried to let her husband down gently, everything she did would come back to haunt her. If she stayed until her husband came home from the overseas trip he’d never have let her out of the house. If she’d hired a lawyer she’d have looked like a gold-digger. If she’d left with nothing, she’d have been a saint, but a poor one. And even that wouldn’t have saved her. ‘I have asked Sam to come with me as it would be hard to be on my own at a time like this, she is very upset and isn’t choosing me over you. Matthew is old enough to make up his own mind…I haven’t said anything to make them take sides and never will...I have tried to leave the house clean and tidy and prepared a meal for this evening,’ she’d said in her final letter. Although Julie genuinely thought her farewell letter conciliatory and her sister and her friends considered it kind and generous, there was more to it than met the eye. As Dallas Price, husband of her friend Christine Howgate, observed:‘It’s all about perception. He comes home from a work trip, which he sees as part of the next step in their elevation, and she’s left a letter saying she’s taken $100 000 and gone to a nice little house inToorak. JANE ASHTON IS CALLED
133
And then there’s a boyfriend. He’s not going to like it.’ Dallas was right. It was all about perception. She’d taken his money and abandoned him.That was the story Dunn wanted to tell. ‘I think doing the renovations brought everything to a head. I just couldn’t get enthusiastic about something that should have been fantastic to do…I’m not saying you are a bad person or the way you want to live is wrong, it just isn’t right for me.’ Words such as these were hardly what Ramage wanted to hear.As the events that followed would show, it clearly played on his insecurities. The idea that she could be happy without him was dynamite. ‘You are a good person and you work hard and most importantly you love our kids.’This may have played to his ego, but the more saccharine and sanguine the farewell letter became, the deeper it cut into his pride. And what did she mean when she said ‘I know you will be mad when you realise I have left for good’? Was he entitled to be mad? Was the letter naïve and insensitive? As early as 1991 Ramage had told psychotherapist Dr John Buchanan that sex with his wife wasn’t all he expected. Were the affairs evidence that she stayed with him for the money alone? Although little was made of it, Ramage was fuming that Julie had taken money from an overdraft account. ‘Do you think you can have all this on a $40 000 bookkeeping job in a clothes store?’ he used to sneer.To him it was tantamount to robbery. And with what he perceived as robbery came a letter that read like the thoughts of woman who was ungrateful for what he’d given her.‘I feel I need to be my own person and that I let you run my life too much and that I’m stifled. If you said I could do anything I wanted, I couldn’t because I have become conditioned over the years to always worry about what your reaction will be to the things I do and say and therefore am never fully relaxed.’ In the eyes of the censorious, Julie’s desire for freedom 134
GETTING AWAY WITH MURDER
was a euphemism for plundering her husband’s wealth while fucking a lover.To others these were the words of a brave woman who’d suddenly discovered there was more to life than being an obedient housewife. Despite the revelations, Julie’s letter maintained the myth that her man was indestructible. Jane Ashton says she and her sister liked strong men and that their father was such a man. If the teenage Julie Garrett was looking for a man with her father’s strength of character, it appeared she’d found him. Unfortunately, this was where the similarities ended.Twenty years of control had cemented in her head the belief that he didn’t need her, let alone love her.‘You have often said you would be happ