GEOMETRIC MECHANICS
RICHARD TALMAN
Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
GEOMETRIC MECHANICS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
GEOMETRIC MECHANICS
RICHARD TALMAN
Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA
All books published by Wiley-VCH are carefully produd. Nevertheless, authors, editors, and publishex do not WBITBnt the information contained in these books,including this book, to be fieof arors. Readers are advised tokeepinmind that statements,data, illustrations, procedural details or other items may inadvertently be inaccurate.
Library of Congress Card No.: Applied for British Ilbmry Cataloging-ib.PublictionData: A catalogue record for this book is available fkom the British Library
Bibliographic information pubhhed by Me Deutsche BibUothek Die Deursche Bibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Natidbibliogdie; detailed bibliographic data is available in the Internet at
WILEY-VCH Valsg GmbH & CO.KGaA, W d i m
Au rights reserved (incl* those of translation into other languages). No part of this book may be reproducedin any form - nor transmittedor translated into machine language without written permission hm the publishers. Registered names,&ademarb,etc. used in this book, even when not specifically marked as such,are not to be considered unprotected by law. Printed in the Federal Republic of Germany Printed on acid-fie peper
Printing and Bookbinding buch bUcher dd ag, Birkach ISBN-13 9784471-15738-0 ISBN-10: 0-471-15738-4
~~
CONTENTS
Preface
xvii
Introduction
xxix
PART I
SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
1 Review of Solvable Systems
1 3
1.1 Introduction and Rationale / 3
1.2 Worked Examples I 6 1.2.1 Particle in One-Dimensional Potential / 6 1.2.2 Particle in Space / 12 1.2.3 Weakly Coupled Oscillators / 12 1.2.4 Conservation of Momentum and Energy / 24 1.2.5 Effective Potential / 25 1.2.6 Multiparticle Systems / 28 1.2.7 DimensionaVScalingConsiderations / 3 1 Bibliography / 31
PART II THE GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 2 Geometry of Mechanics I: Linear
33 35
2.1 Introduction / 35 2.2 Pairs of Planes as Covariant Vectors / 37 V
Vi
CONTENTS
2.3 DifferentialForms / 42 2.3.1 Geometric Interpretation I 42 2.3.2 Examples Illustrating the Calculus of Differential Forms I 46 2.3.3 Connections between Differential Forms and Vector Calculus I 50 2.4 AlgebraicTensors I 54 2.4.1 Vectors and Their Duals I 54 2.4.2 Transformation of Coordinates I 56 2.4.3 Transformation of Distributions I 60 2.4.4 Multi-Index Tensors and Their Contraction / 61 2.4.5 Overlap of Tensor Algebra and Tensor Calculus I 64 2.5 (Possibly Complex) Cartesian Vectors in Metric Geometry I 66 2.5.1 Euclidean Vectors I 66 2.5.2 Skew Coordinate Frames I 68 2.5.3 Reduction of a Quadratic Form to a Sum or Difference of Squares I 68 2.5.4 Introduction of Covariant Components I 70 2.5.5 The Reciprocal Basis I 71 2.5.6 Wavefronts, Lattice Planes, and Bragg Reflection I 74 2.6 Unitary Geometry / 80 2.6.1 Solution of Singular Sets of Linear Equations I 84 Bibliography I 88 3 Geometry of Mechanics Ii: Curvilinear
3.1 (Real) Curvilinear Coordinates in N-Dimensions I 89 3.1.1 Introduction I 89 3.1.2 TheMetricTensor I 90 3.1.3 Relating Coordinate Systems at Different Points in Space I 92 3.1.4 The Covariant (or Absolute) Differential / 97 3.1.5 Derivation of the Lagrange Equations of Mechanics from the Absolute Differential I 101 3.1.6 Practical Evaluation of the Christoffel Symbols I 106 3.1.7 Evaluation of the Christoffel Symbols Using Maple / 107 3.2 Absolute Derivatives and the Bilinear Covariant I 109 3.3 Lie Derivative-Coordinate Approach I 111 3.3.1 Lie-Dragged Coordinate Systems I 111
89
CONTENTS
Vii
3.3.2 Lie Derivatives of Scalars and Vectors I 115 3.4 Lie Derivative-Lie Algebraic Approach I 120 3.4.1 Exponential Representation of Parameterized Curves I 120 3.4.2 Identification of Vector Fields with Differential Operators I 121 3.4.3 LoopDefect I 122 3.4.4 Coordinate Congruences I 123 3.4.5 Commutators of Quasi-Basis-Vectors I 125 3.4.6 Lie-Dragged Congruences and the Lie Derivative I 126 Bibliography I 130 4 Geometry of Mechanics 111: Multilinear 4.1 Generalized Euclidean Rotations and Reflections I 132 4.1.1 Introduction I 132 4.1.2 Reflections I 133 4.1.3 Expressing a Rotation as a Product of Reflections I 134 4.1.4 The Lie Group of Rotations I 136 4.2 Multivectors I 137 4.2.1 “Volume” Determined by Three and by n Vectors I 137 4.2.2 Bivectors I 139 4.2.3 Multivectors and Generalization to Higher Dimensionality I 140 4.2.4 “Supplementary”Multivectors I 142 4.2.5 Sums of p-Vectors I 143 4.2.6 Bivectors and Infinitesimal Rotations / 143 4.3 Curvilinear Coordinates (Continued) I 146 4.3.1 Local Radius of Curvature of a Particle Orbit / 146 4.3.2 Generalized Divergence and Gauss’s Theorem I 147 4.4 Integration and Exterior Differentiation of Forms I 150 4.4.1 One-Dimensional Integrals I 150 4.4.2 Two-Dimensional Integrals I 151 4.4.3 Metric-Free Definition of the “Divergence” of a Vector I 153 4.5 Spinors in Three-Dimensional Space I 155 4.5.1 Definition of Spinors I 155 4.5.2 Demonstration That a Spinor Is a Euclidean Tensor I 156
132
Viii
CONTENTS
4.5.3 Associating a 2 x 2 Reflection (Rotation) Matrix with a Vector (Bivector) / 156 4.5.4 Associating a Matrix with a Trivector (Triple Product) 1 157 4.5.5 Representations of Reflections / 158 4.5.6 Representations of Rotations I 158 4.5.7 Operations on Spinors / 159 4.5.8 Real Euclidean Space / 160 4.5.9 Real Pseudo-Euclidean Space I 161
Bibliography I 161
PART Ill
LAGRANGIAN MECHANICS
5 Lagrange-Poincare Description of Mechanics
163 165
5.1 Review of the Lagrange Equations I 165 5.2 The Poincark Equation I 166 5.2.1 Some Features of the Poincark Equations / 175 5.2.2 Invariance of the Poincart5 Equation / 176 5.2.3 Translation into the Language of Forms and Vector Fields / 177 5.2.4 Example: Free Motion of a Rigid Body with One Point Fixed I 178 5.3 Vector Field Derivation of the P o i n c d Equation / 181 5.3.1 The Basic Problem of the Calculus of Variations / 181 5.3.2 The Euler-Lagrange Equations I 182 5.3.3 Calculus of Variations Using the Algebra of Vector Fields / 183
Bibliography / 187 6 Simplifying the Poincard Equation With Group Theory
6.1 Continuous Transformation Groups / 188 6.2 Use of Infinitesimal Group Parameters as Quasi-coordinates I 191 6.3 Infinitesimal Group Operators I 193 6.4 Commutation Relations and Structure Constants of the Group / 200
6.5 Qualitative Aspects of Infinitesimal Generators / 202
188
CONTENTS
iX
6.6 The Poincari Equation in Terms of Group Generators I 205 6.7 The Rigid Body Subject to Force and Torque I 207 6.7.1 Group Parameters as Quasi-Coordinates I 207 6.7.2 Description Using Body Axes I 209 6.8 Example: Rolling Sphere I 212 6.8.1 Commutation Relations Appropriate for Rigid Body Motion t 212 6.8.2 Bowling Ball Rolling without Slipping I 214 Bibliography I 220 7 Conservation Laws and Symmetry
221
7.1 Multiparticle Conservation laws I 22 1 7.1.1 Conservation of Linear Momentum I 221 7.1.2 Rate of Change of Angular Momentum: Poincari Approach I 223 7.1.3 Conservation of Angular Momentum: Lagrangian Approach I 224 7.1.4 Conservation of Energy I 225
7.2 Cyclic Coordinates and Routhian Reduction t 226 7.2.1 Integrability; Generalization of Cyclic Variables I 229 7.3 Noether’sTheorem I 230 Bibliography
t 233
PART IV NEWTONIAN MECHANICS
235
8 Gauge-Invariant Mechanics 8.1 Vector Mechanics I 237 8.1.1 Vector Description in Curvilinear Coordinates t 237 8.1.2 The Frenet-Serret Formulas I 240 8.1.3 Vector Description in an Accelerating Coordinate Frame I 244 8.1.4 Exploiting the Fictitious Force Description I 249 8.2 Single-Particle Equations in Gauge-Invariant Form / 255 8.2.1 Newton’s Force Equation in Gauge-Invariant Form I 256 8.2.2 Active and Passive Interpretations of Time Evolution t 259
237
X
CONTENTS
8.2.3 Continued Discussion of the Cartan Matrix I 261 8.2.4 Reconciling Fictitious Force and Gauge-Invariant Descriptions I 262 8.2.5 Newton’s Torque Equation I 265 8.2.6 ThePlumbBob I 266 8.3 Lie Algebraic Description of Rigid Body Motion I 271 8.3.1 Space and Body Frames of Reference / 272 8.3.2 Review of the “Association” of 2 x 2 Matrices to Vectors I 274 8.3.3 “Association” of 3 x 3 Matrices to Vectors I 276 8.3.4 Some Interpretive Comments Concerning Similarity Transformations I 277 8.3.5 Rigid Body Equations in Rotating Frame I 279 8.3.6 The Euler Equations for a Rigid Body / 281 Bibliography I 282 9 Geometric Phases
284
9.1 The Foucault Pendulum I 284 9.1.1 Fictitious Force Solution I 286 9.1.2 Gauge-Invariant Solution I 287 9.2 “Parallel” Displacement of Coordinate Axes / 290 9.3 Tumblers, Divers, Falling Cats, etc. I 295 9.3.1 Miscellaneous Issues / 301 Bibliography I 304
PART V HAMILTONIAN MECHANICS 10 Hamiltonian Treatment of Geometric Optics
10.1 Motivation / 307 10.1.1 The Scalar Wave Equation / 309 10.1.2 The Eikonal Equation / 3 10 10.1.3 Determination of Rays from Wavefronts I 311 10.1.4 The Ray Equation in Geometric Optics I 312 10.1.5 Variation of Light Intensity along a Ray I 3 14 10.2 Variational Principles I 316
305 307
Xi
CONTENTS
10.2.1 The Lagrange Integral Invariant and Snell’s Law / 316 10.2.2 The Principle of Least Time / 3 17 10.3 Paraxial Optics, Gaussian Optics, Matrix Optics / 319 10.4 Huygens’ Principle I 322 Bibliography I 324
11 HamiltonJacobi Theory
325
11.1 The Hamilton-Jacobi Equation / 325 11.1.1 Derivation / 325 11.1.2 The Geometric Picture / 327 11.1.3 Constant S Wavefronts I 328 11.2 Trajectory Determination Using the Hamilton-Jacobi Equation I 329 11.2.1 Complete Integral / 329 11.2.2 Finding a Complete Integral by Separation of Variables / 329 11.2.3 Hamilton-Jacobi Analysis of Projectile Motion / 330 11.2.4 The Jacobi Method for Exploiting a Complete Integral I 332 11.2.5 Completion of Projectile Example / 334 11.2.6 The Time-IndependentHamilton-Jacobi Equation / 335 11.2.7 Hamilton-Jacobi Treatment of 1-D Simple Harmonic Motion I 335 11.2.8 The Kepler Problem / 337 11.3 Analogies Between Optics and Quantum Mechanics / 343 11.3.1 General Discussion / 343 11.3.2 Classical Limit of the Schrodinger Equation / 343 11.3.3 Condition for Validity of Semiclassical Treatment I 345 12 Relativistic Mechanics 12.1 Review of Special Relativity Theory / 348 12.1.1 Form Invariance / 348 12.1.2 World Points / 349 12.1.3 World Intervals / 349 12.1.4 ProperTime / 350 12.1.5 The Lorentz Transformation / 351 12.1.6 Transformation of Velocities / 352 12.1.7 Four-Vectors / 353
348
Xi1
CONTENTS
12.1.8 Antisymmetric 4-Tensors / 355 12.1.9 The 4-Gradient of a 4-Scalar Function / 355 12.1.10The 4-Velocity and 4-Acceleration I 355 12.2 The Relativistic Principle of Least Action / 356 12.3 Energy and Momentum / 357 12.3.1 4-Vector Notation I 358 12.4 Relativistic Hamilton-Jacobi Theory / 359
12.5 ForcedMotion / 360 12.6 Generalizationof the Action to Include ElectromagneticForces / 360 12.7 Derivation of the Lorentz Force Law / 362 12.8 GaugeInvariance / 363 12.9 Trajectory Determination / 364 12.9.1 Motion in a Constant Uniform Electric Field / 364 12.9.2 Motion in a Constant Uniform Magnetic Field I 365 12.10 The Longitudinal Coordinate as Independent Variable / 366 Bibliography / 368
13 Symplectic Mechanics
13.1 Derivation of Hamilton’s Equations I 369 13.1.1 Charged Particle in Electromagnetic Field / 371 13.2 Recapitulation I 372 13.3 The Symplectic Properties of Phase Space / 373 13.3.1 The Canonical Momentum One-Form / 373 13.3.2 The Symplectic Two-Form G / 376 13.3.3 Invariance of the Symplectic Two-Form / 379 13.3.4 Use of G to Associate Vectors and One-Forms / 381 13.3.5 Explicit Evaluation of Some Inner Products I 381 13.3.6 The Vector Field Associated with d7i I 382 13.3.7 Hamilton’s Equations in Matrix Form / 383 13.4 Symplectic Geometry / 385 13.4.1 Symplectic Products and Symplectic Bases / 386 13.4.2 Symplectic Transformations / 387
369
Xiii
CONTENTS
13.4.3 Properties of Symplectic Matrices / 388 13.4.4 Alternate Coordinate Ordering I 395 13.5 Poisson Brackets of Scalar Functions / 396 13.5.1 The Poisson Bracket of Two Scalar Functions / 396 13.5.2 Properties of Poisson Brackets / 397 13.5.3 The Poisson Bracket and Quantum Mechanics I 398 13.6 Integral Invariants / 399 13.6.1 Integral Invariants in Electricity and Magnetism / 399 13.6.2 The PoincarkXartan Integral Invariant / 402 13.7 Invariance of the Poincari-Cartan Integral Invariant 1.1. / 405 13.7.1 The Extended Phase Space Two-Form and Its Special Eigenvector / 405 13.7.2 Proof of Invariance of the Poincark Relative Integral Invariant / 407 13.8 Symplectic System Evolution / 409 13.8.1 Liouville’s Theorem and Generalizations I 410 Bibliography I 412
PART VI APPROXIMATE METHODS
413
14 Analytic Basis for Approximation
415
14.1 Canonical Transformations / 415 14.1.1 The Action as a Generator of Canonical Transformations / 415 14.2 Time-Independent Canonical Transformation I 419 14.3 Action-Angle Variables / 421 14.3.1 The Action Variable of a Simple Harmonic Oscillator I 421 14.3.2 Adiabatic Invariance of the Action I / 422 14.3.3 Action/Angle Conjugate Variables / 426 14.3.4 Parametrically Driven Simple Harmonic Motion / 428 14.4 Examples of Adiabatic Invariance / 431 14.4.I Variable-Length Pendulum / 43 1 14.4.2 Charged Particle in Magnetic Field / 432 14.4.3 Charged Particle in a Magnetic Trap / 434
XiV
CONTENTS
14.5 Accuracy of Conservation of Adiabatic Invariants I 439 14.6 Conditionally Periodic Motion I 442 14.6.1 Stkkel’s Theorem I 443 14.6.2 Anglevariables I444 14.6.3 ActiodAngle Coordinates for Keplerian Satellites I 447
Bibliography I 448 15 Linear Systems
449
15.1 Linear Equations With Constant Coefficients I 449 15.2 Treatment of Velocity Terms I 452 15.3 Linear Hamiltonian Systems I 456 15.3.1 Inhomogeneous Equations I 457 15.3.2 Exponentiation, Diagonalization, and Logarithm Formation of Matrices I 457 15.3.3 Eigensolutions I 460 15.3.4 Eigenvectors of a Linear Hamiltonian System I 461 15.4 A Lagrangian Set of Solutions I 465 15.5 Periodic Linear Systems I 467 15.5.1 Floquet’s Theorem I 468 15.5.2 Lyapunov’s Theorem I 469 15.5.3 Characteristic Multipliers, Characteristic Exponents I 470 15.5.4 The Variational Equations / 471 15.5.5 Periodic Solutions of Inhomogeneous Equation I 473
Bibliography I 478
16 PerturbationTheory 16.1 The Lagrange Planetary Equations I 480 16.1.1 Derivation of the Equations I 480 16.1.2 Relation Between Lagrange and Poisson Brackets I 484 16.1.3 Advance of Perihelion of Mercury I 485 16.2 Iterative Analysis of Anharmonic Oscillations I 489 16.3 The Method of Krylov and Bogoliubov I 495 16.3.1 First Approximation I 495 16.3.2 Examples I 497
479
CONTENTS
XV
16.3.3 Equivalent Linearization I 499 16.3.4 Power Balance, Harmonic Balance I 501 16.3.5 Qualitative Analysis of Autonomous Oscillators I 502 16.3.6 Higher Approximation I 507 16.4 Multidimensional,Near-Symplectic Perturbation Theory I 5 10 16.4.1 PureDamping I 518 16.4.2 Time-DependentPerturbations I 521 16.4.3 Resonance Induced by Time-Dependent Perturbation I 523 16.4.4 Threshold of Instability I 527 16.5 SuperconvergentPerturbation Theory I 528 16.5.1 Canonical Perturbation Theory I 528 16.5.2 Application to Gravity Pendulum I 530 16.5.3 Superconvergence I 532 Bibliography I 533
Index
535
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PREFACE This text is designed to accompany a mechanics course for students who have already encountered Lagrange’s equations. Its purpose is to introduce students to a somewhat more “modern,” but not intentionally more difficult, treatment than Goldstein without requiring the mathematical sophistication assumed by, say, Arnold. It has been used at Cornell in physics courses taken by advanced undergraduates and beginning graduate students. Though the systems analyzed come primarily from the domain customarily called mechanics, the methods employed are intended to be introductory to more advanced topics such as quantum mechanics, elementary particle physics and general relativity. With this emphasis, the geometric chapters of the text have been used as the text for a course “Geometric Concepts of Physics,” taken by advanced undergraduates at Cornell. Communications pointing out errors, making comments, or suggesting improvements will be appreciated. E-mail address; talman @lns62.lns.cornell.edu. Coining the phrase “it takes an institution” to foster scholarship, the institutions contributing (in equal parts) to this text have been the public schools of London, Ontario, and universities, U.W.O., Caltech, and Cornell. I have profited, initially as a student, and later from students, at these institutions, and from my colleagues there and at accelerator laboratories worldwide. I have also been fortunate of family: parents, brother, children and, especially, wife.
RICHARDTALMAN Ithaca, New York June 1999
xvii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
INTRODUCTION GENERALITIES A more descriptive title for this text might have been Geometric Mechanicsfor Pedestrians, where “pedestrian” anticipates that the reader is untrained or, more precisely, since a fairly high degree of training in physics or engineering is assumed, less than optimally trained in mathematics. The most important prerequisite is an understanding of Lagrangian mechanics at the level of texts such as Marion’s or Symon’s. No background in Hamiltonian mechanics is assumed. The word “geometric” in the title is used in a narrow, technical, mathematical sense. For a physicist the phrase “geometric mechanics” is redundant, since mechanics is to geometry what swimming is to water-one occurs in the other. By contrast, a mathematician defines geometry (the kind under discussion anyway) to be the algebraic or analytical representation of spatial objects and relationships. For better or for worse, modern work in mechanics, and much of theoretical physics for that matter, tends to be geometric in this sense. The pedagogy of physics at the level of this text is only beginning to evolve in this direction, however. Since this book‘s approach is supposed to be modem, not classical, and because relativistic mechanics is included, describing the subject matter as modem, nonquantum mechanics would also be accurate. On the other hand, dynamical system theory, often used for material like this, would not be, as it would imply a mathematical emphasis and rigor not strived for, and certainly not attained. If a purely analytic approach to mechanics is calledformal, then the approach to be emphasized here might be called informal mechanics if that did not have misleading connotations-there will be no shortage of formulas-so this statement needs elaboration. Any successful physical theory yields analytic predictions. This fact might seem to force geometry into a subsidiary role and, in fact, most physics can be expressed formally-that is, by formulas. The role of geometry is to provide qualitative structure to this quantitative formalism. From one point of view, this qualitative content may appear to be mere scaffolding,to be discarded once formulas have been obtained, and much of physics and engineering is usually taught in this way. But a broader view shows that qualitative understanding has value in structuring‘results,in avoiding blunders, and in suggesting new directions. Paradoxically, these things bexix
XX
INTRODUCTION
come progressively more true as the evaluation of formulas is more and more taken over by computers. Why, then, the stress on geometry? It may be only an accident of history, but the subject of mechanics is far less pictorial than is electricity and magnetism. In electrostatics, though it would be possible to describe everything in terms of the Coulomb force F12 between pairs of charges 1 and 2, introduction of the (artificial) electric field E yields a more picturesque and ultimately more powerful theory. Density of, and directions of, jseld lines give force magnitudes and directions; surfaces normal to field lines give equipotentials. In mechanics one also introduces artificial functions, such as the Lagrangian, but, commonly, little attention is paid to their geometric properties, such as surfaces on which they are constant. Rather, their main use is formal-differentiating them appropriately yields equations of motion. Here we try to ascribe geometric properties to the functions of mechanics. The most elementary-and already well-understood-example of this kind is the potential energy function V. Surfaces on which V is constant have a well-known significance and work done can be obtained by counting contours of V crossed. There is an even more important reason for “geometricizing” mechanics, but it is hard to appreciate at this point. It has to do with a restriction of Lagrangian mechanics to systems for which “generalized coordinates” can be found. Because of this, an important thread guiding the choice of subject matter for this text is the Poincare‘ equation. This will seem curious to those educated traditionally in classical mechanics, many of whom may not even have heard of this particular equation-this only makes it more challenging to convince the reader that the Poincan5 equation is “better than” the Lagrange equation. (It is easier to show it is “as good,” since in all cases where the Lagrange equation is valid, the two equations are identical.) Anyway, by “better than” I include the recommendation that “it is what undergraduates should be learning.” Whether or not the reader is eventually convinced, the attempt to prove the point is valuable in itself because it provides guidance and motivation. A certain amount of circular reasoning creeps into physics naturally (and not necessarily unproductively) as follows. Suppose that by making a special assumption a certain difficult issue can befinessed. Then, by the simple expedient of defining “physics,” or “fundamental physics,” as being limited to systems satisfying the special assumption, one is relieved by dejnition of worrying further about the difficult issue. In the present context here is how it goes. Once one has found the generalized coordinates of a system, the Lagrangian method proceeds reliably and in a purely mechanical way, with no need to be troubled by annoying mathematical concepts such as tangent spaces. The stratagem then is to define mechanics to be the theory of systems for which generalized coordinates can be found and presto, one has a tidy, self-contained, and powerful tool-Lagrange’s equations-for studying it. (It must be acknowledged that even if this approach is judged cowardly as applied mathematics, it may be “high principle” as physics-the principle being that to be Lagrangian is to be fundamental.) Being unwilling to employ this stratagem, we will face up to the Poincari equation, which is the tool of choice for studying systems that are Lagrangian except for not being describable by generalized coordinates. This, in turn, requires studying
INTRODUCTION
XXf
the geometric structure of mechanics. At that point it becomes almost an advantage that the Poincark equation is novel, since it does not carry with it the baggage of less-than-general truth that already-assimilatedphysics necessarily carries. It is also pedagogically attractive to investigate a brand new subject rather than simply to rehash Lagrangian mechanics. The greatest virtue of the Lagrange method is that it provides a foolproof scheme for obtaining correct equations of motion. With computers available to solve these equations, the mere writing down of a correct Lagrangian can almost be regarded as the solution of the problem. The P o i n c d equation, valid in far less restrictive circumstances (commonly involving constraints or rotational motion) has the same virtue. Its extra terms, compared to the Lagrange equation’s, can also be calculated in a computer using symbolic algebra. The resulting differential equations of motion can then be solved numerically, as in the Lagrangian procedure. This contributes to the validity of the earlier statement that the Poincark equation is better than the Lagrange equation. Purely Newtonian mechanics is also subject to geometrization. In this text, this takes the form primarily of a “gauge-invariant” formulation of mechanics. Both to provide mechanical systems on which to exercise the methods and because of its inherent interest, the subject of geometric phases is emphasized. It is not uncommon for Hamiltonian mechanics to be first encountered in the waning days of a course emphasizing Lagrangian mechanics. This has made it natural for a next course to start with and emphasize Hamiltonian mechanics. Here, though standard Hamiltonian arguments enter, they do so initially via a geometric, Hamilton-Jacobi route. Then the full geometric artillery developed earlier in the text is rolled out under the name of symplectic mechanics, which is just another name for Hamiltonian mechanics with its geometric structure emphasized. Especially important is Liouville’s theorem and its generalizations. Because of their fundamental importance, for example in accelerator physics, and because of their connection with quantum mechanics, adiabatic invariants and Poisson brackets, central to both traditional “canonical” formalism and the more geometric treatment, are also stressed. Though Lagrangian methods have mainly been emphasized in this brief survey, Newtonian and Hamiltonian mechanics get comparable billing in the body of the text. Furthermore, an effort has been made to organize the material in such a way that a path can be followed through any one of the three major approaches independent of the other two. This is not to say that this is recommended, but if there is too much material for any particular curriculum, as there almost surely is, this may help in paring down the material. For some years at Cornell, the curriculum for beginning graduate students in physics has treated the study of mathematical methods of physics per se as best contained in a course on electromagnetism. This has probably reflected the assignment of highest priority to differential equations, special functions, and Fourier methods. But recently algebra and geometry seem to be “making a comeback,” and mechanics is a natural vehicle for exercising those methods. During the half century after the discovery of quantum mechanics, the pedagogy of teaching classical mechanics to physicists and engineers remained static. This
xxii
INTRODUCTION
was perhaps natural while the exciting research developments occurred in quantum physics. Still, because of its obvious technological importance, and because of the (admittedly hard to justify) belief that its understanding is essential to the understanding of quantum physics, classical mechanics has remained an essential part of the cumculum. Recently though, there has been renewed interest in mechanics as a fruitful research area. Unfortunately, with this research field having been left to mathematicians for two generations, the language of modem advanced dynamics bears little resemblance to the subject taught in traditional physics courses. One response to this situation has been the appearance of numerous texts explaining highly specialized topics of abstract mathematics and directed toward their subsequent application in physics. While I understand the concept, and to some extent even agree with it, this text takes a less ambitious approach, staying as close as possible to familiar methods. The reason for this is that a fully satisfactory mathematical preparation for geometrical mechanics would consist of a formidable sequence of subjects: differential equations, calculus of variations, vector and tensor analysis, multilinear algebra, differential forms, smooth manifolds (including a smattering of topology), differential geometry (including Riemannian geometry), Lie groups and Lie algebra, and dynamical systems. Most physicists setting out on that path would never reach its end. They would be stalled by insufficient motivation, be diverted into side issues (valuable or otherwise), or switch to mathematics. Another goal of the text is to demonstrate how natural are the generalizations by which special relativity and quantum mechanics spring from classical mechanics. Also, although the subject of general relativity is not broached here, many of its analytical and conceptual difficulties are faced. Everything contained in this book is explained with more rigor, or more depth, or more detail, or (especially) more sophistication, in at least one of the books listed at the end of this introduction. Were it not for the fact that most of those books are fat, intimidating, abstract, formal, mathematical and (for many) unintelligible, the reader’s time would be better spent reading them (in the right order) than studying this book. But if this text renders those books both accessible and admirable, it will have achieved its main purpose. It has been said that bridge is a simple game; dealt thirteen cards, one has only to play them in the correct order. In the same sense, mechanics is easy to learn; one simply has to study readily available books in a sensible order. I have tried to chart such a path, extracting material from various sources in an order that I have found appropriate. At each stage I indicate (at the end of the chapter) the reference my approach most closely resembles. In some cases what I provide is a kind of Reader’sDigest condensation of a more general treatment, and this may amount to my having systematically specialized and made concrete descriptions that the original author may have systematically labored to generalize and make abstract. The texts to which these statements are most applicable are listed at the end of each chapter, and keyed to the particular section to which they relate. It is not suggested that these texts should be systematically referred to, as they tend to be advanced and contain much unrelated material. But if particular material in this text is obscure, or seems to stop short of some desirable goal, these texts should provide authoritative help.
INTRODUCTION
XXiii
The mathematical level strived for is only high enough to support a persuasive (to a nonmathematician) trip through the physics. Still, “it can be shown that” almost never appears, though the standards of what constitutes “proof” may be low, and the range of generality narrow. I believe that much mathematics is made difficult for the nonmathematically inclined reader by the absence of concrete instances of the abstract objects under discussion. This text tries to provide essentially correct instances of otherwise hard-to-grasp mathematical abstractions. I hope and believe that this will provide a broad base of general understanding from which deeper, more specialized, more mathematical texts can be approached with a respectable general comprehension. This statement is most applicable to the excellent books by Arnold, who tries hard, but not necessarily successfully, to provide physical lines of reasoning. Much of this book was written with the goal of making one or another of his discussions comprehensible. In the early days of our weekly Laboratory of Nuclear Studies Journal Club our former esteemed leader, Robert Wilson, imposed a rule-though honored as much in the breach as in the observance, it was not entirely a joke-that the Dirac y matrices never appear. The (largely unsuccessful) purpose of this rule was to force the lectures to be intelligible to us theory-challenged experimentalists. In this text there is a similar rule. It is that hieroglyphics such as
4 :(X
E
R2 : 1x1 = 1) + R
not appear. The justification for this rule is that a “physicist” is likely to skip such a statement altogether or, once having understood it, regard it as obvious. Like the jest that the French “don’t care what they say as long as they pronounce it properly” one can joke that mathematicians don’t care what their mappings do, as long as the spaces they connect are clear. Physicists, on the other hand, care primarily what their functions represent physically and are not fussy about what spaces they relate. Another “rule” has just been followed; the wordfunction will be used in preference to the (synonymous) word mapping. Other temfying mathematical words such asflow, symplectomorphism, and manifold will also be avoided, except that, to avoid longwinded phrases such as “configuration space described by generalized coordinates,” the word manifold will occasionally be used. Of course, one cannot alter the essence of a subject by denying the existence of mathematics that is manifestly at its core but, in spite of the loss of precision, I hope that sugar-coating the material in this way will make it more easily swallowed by nonmathematicians.
Notation: “Notation isn’t everything, it’s the only thing.” Grammatically speaking, this statement, like the American football slogan it paraphrases, makes no sense. But its clearly intended meaning is only a mild exaggeration. After the need to evaluate some quantity has been expressed, a few straightforward mathematical operations are typically all that is required to obtain the quantity. But specifying quantities is far from simple. The conceptual depth of the subject is substantial and ordinary language is scarcely capable of defining the symbols, much less expressing the relations among them. A way of assessing the seriousness of the problem is to note that the index of symbols in Goldstein’s Classical Mechanics has about 400 entries. This makes
XXiV
INTRODUCTION
the introduction of sophisticated symbols essential. Discussion of notation and the motivation behind its introduction is scattered throughout this text-probably to the point of irritation for some readers. Here we limit discussion to the few most important, most likely to be confusing, and most deviant from other sources: the qual@ed , the vector, the preferred reference system, the active/passive interpreequality tation of transformations, and the terminology of differentialforms. A fairly common occurrence in this subject is that two quantities A and B are equal or equivalent from one point of view but not from another. This circumstance will be indicated by “qualified equality” A % B. This notation is intentionally vague (the “q” stands for qualified, or questionable,or query, as appropriate) and may have different meanings in different contexts; it only warns the reader to be wary of the risk ofjumping to unjustified conclusions. Normally the qualification will be clarified in the subsequent text. Next, vectors. Consider the following three symbols or collections of symbols: +, x, and (x, y , z ) ~ The . first, 4,will be called an arrow (because it is one), and this word will be far more prevalent in this text than any other of which I am aware. This particular arrow happens to be pointing in a horizontal direction (for convenience of typesetting) but in general an arrow can point in any direction, including out of the page. The second, boldface quantity, x, is an intrinsic or true vector; this means that it is a symbol that “stands for” an arrow. The word “intrinsic” means “it doesn’t depend on choice of coordinate system.” The third quantity, (x, y , z ) ~ , is a column matrix (because the T stands for transpose) containing the “components” of x relative to some preestablished coordinate system. From the point of view of elementary physics, these three are equivalent quantities, differing only in the ways they are to be manipulated; “addition” of arrows is by ruler and compass, addition of intrinsic vectors is by vector algebra, and addition of coordinate vectors is component-wise. Because of this multiplicity of meanings, the word “vector” is ambiguous in some contexts. For this reason, we will often use the word “arrow” in situations where independence of choice of coordinates is being emphasized (even in dimensionality higher than 3 if necessary.) According to its definition above, the phrase intrinsic vector could usually replace it, but some would complain of the redundancy and the word arrow more faithfully conveys the intended geometric sense. Comments similar to these could be made concerning higher-order tensors, but they would be largely repetitive. A virtue of arrows is that they can be plotted in figures. This goes a long way toward making their meaning unambiguous, but the conditions defining the figure must still be made clear. In classical mechanics, “inertial frames” have a fundamental significance, and we will almost always suppose that there is a “preferred” reference system, its rectangular axes fixed in an inertial system. Unless otherwise stated, figures in this text are to be regarded as “snapshots” taken in that frame. In particular, a plotted arrow connects two points fixed in the inertial frame at the instant illustrated. As mentioned previously, such an arrow is symbolized by a true vector such as x. It is, of course, essential that these vectors satisfy the algebraic properties defining a vector space. In such spaces, “transformations” are important; a “linear” transformation can be represented by a matrix symbolized, for example, by M,with elements
INTRODUCTION
XXV
M i j . The result of applying this transformation to vector x can be represented symM x of “intrinsic” quantities, or spelled out bolically as the “matrix product” y explicitly in components y’ = MijxJ.Frequently both forms will be given. This leads to a notational difficulty in distinguishing between the “active” and “passive” interpretations of the transformation. The new components y’ can belong to a new arrow in the old frame (active interpretation) or to the old arrow in a new frame (passive interpretation). On the other hand, the intrinsic form y % M x seems to support only an active interpetation according to which M “operates” on vector x to yield a different vector y. To avoid this problem, when we wish to express a passive interpretation we will ordinarily use the form i3 % Mx and will insist that x and Z stand for the same arrow. The significance of the overhead bar, then, is that Z is simply an abbreviation for an array of barred-frame coordinates Xi. When the active interpretation is intended, the notation will usually be expanded to clarify the situation. For example, consider a moving point located initially at r(0) and at r(t) at later time t. These vectors can be related by r(t) = O(t)r(0) where O(t) is a time-dependent operator. This is an active transformation. The beauty and power of vector analysis as it is applied to physics is that a boldface symbol such as V indicates that the quantity is intrinsic and also abbreviates its multiple components V’ into one symbol. Though these are both valuable purposes, they are not the same. The abbreviationworks in vector analysis only because vectors are the only multicomponent objects occurring. That this will no longer be the case in this book will cause considerable notational difficulty because the reader, because of experience with vector analysis, is likely to jump to unjustified conclusions concerning boldface quantities.’ We will not be able to avoid this problem, however, since we wish to retain familiar notation. Sometimes we will be using boldface symbols both to indicate intrinsicality and as abbreviation for multicomponent objects. Sometimes the (redundant) notation ? will be used to emphasize the intrinsic aspect. Though it may not be obvious at this point, this was the source of the above-mentioned need to differentiate verbally between active and passive transformations. In stressing this distinction, the text differs from a text such as Goldstein’s, which, perhaps wisely, deemphasizes the issue. According to Arnold, “it is impossible to understand mechanics without the use of differential forms.” Accepting the validity of this statement only grudgingly (and trying to corroborate it), but knowing from experience that typical physics students are innocent of any such knowledge, a considerable portion of the text is devoted to this subject. Briefly, the symbol dx will stand for an old-fashioned differential esplacement of the sort familiar to every student of physics. But a new quantity dx, to be known as a differential form, will also be used. This symbol is distinguished from dx both by being boldface and having an overhead tilde. Dis lacements dx’ ,dx2, . . . -2 in spaces of higher dimension will have matching forms dx ,dx , . . . . This notation is mentioned at this point only because it is unconventional. In most treatments, one
-1:
‘Any computer programmer knows that, when two logically distinct quantities have initially been given the same symbol because they are expected to remain equal, it is hard to unscramble the code when later on it becomes necessary to distinguish between them.
XXVi
INTRODUCTION
or the other form of differential is used, but not both at the same time. I have found it impossible to cause classical formulations to metamorphose into modern formulations without using this distinction (and others to be faced when the time comes). It is hard to avoid using terms whose meanings are vague. (See the previous paragraph, for example.) I have attempted to acknowledge such vagueness, at least in extreme cases, by placing such terms in quotation marks when they are first used. Since quotation marks are also used when the term is actually being defined, a certain amount of hunting through the surrounding sentences may be necessary to find if a definition is actually present. (If it is not clear whether or not there is a definition, then the term is without any doubt vague.) Italics are used to emphasize key phrases, or pairs of phrases in opposition, that are central to the discussion. Parenthesized sentences or sentence fragments are supposedly clear only if they are included right there, but they should not be allowed to interrupt the logical flow of the surrounding sentences. Footnotes, though sometimes similar in intent, are likely to be real digressions, or technical qualifications or clarifications.
Organization of the Book: The text is divided into major parts (see Figure 1). Part I describes various systems that are subject to exact analytic solution in closed form.With much of modem mechanics dealing with systems that are close to solvable, some of these examples will later serve as the bases from which perturbative treatments can proceed. More important, this material is intended to provide a brief overview of elementary methods that the reader may wish to review. Since the formalism (primarily Lagrangian) is assumed to be familiar, this review consists primarily of examples, many worked out partially or completely. Part II contains geometry that will be used throughout the text. This constitutes a rather heavy initial dose of mathematics for a physics text. This material could instead have been interspersed with the physics throughout the text, for use on a “just in time” basis. Such an organization has sometimes been called “spiral” since all mathematical material is well motivated by the requirements of the immediate physics and the climb toward the final goal is continuous. This approach provides a desirable integration of the mathematics and physics. The spiral approach has not been followed here however, since the resultant fragmentation would impede subsequent study and review. For this reason it is recommended (almost required) that the reader (or course syllabus) restrict coverage of the geometric sections, perhaps covering initial sections in detail and deferring later sections until needed. On the other hand, Chapters 2 through 9 by themselves have served as the text for a one-term course with the title “Geometric Concepts in Physics” for advanced undergraduates at Cornell. The flowchart shown in Fig. 1 is intended to aid this planning by showing where the various geometric methods are primarily employed. Parts III, IV,and V are devoted to the major distinct formalisms of mechanics. Even with the emphasis being geometric, the traditional division of mechanics as Newtonian, Lagrangian, or Hamiltonian continues to be appropriate. In fact, it is primarily the nature of the geometries that motivates this division. The Poincad procedure emphasized previously fits naturally into the Lagrangian approach. Numerous examples intended to illustrate the essence of each of the approaches are included.
INTRODUCTION
I
XXVii
Elementary Lagrangian mechanics / : \
I
FIGURE 1. Major dependencies in the text starting from the assumed prerequisite of elementary Lagrangian mechanics. Proceeding sequentially from chapter to chapter is satisfactory but not particularly recommended. Note that Lagrangian, Newtonian, and Hamiltonian topics are largely restricted to threads on the left, center, and right, respectively, so that mutually independent routes can be taken through each of these major approaches. Broken lines indicate minor dependencies that can perhaps be overlooked and made up heuristically. The most traditional, most elementary, route to practical calculational methods is the Hamiltonian route on the right.
With close-to-integrable systems being so important, it is appropriate to develop approximate methods, and that is the subject of Part VI. Rather than using "the same method" to solve numerous problems, the approach taken is more nearly to use different methods to solve similar problems. Partly this is a reaction to what seems to me to be an overemphasis on the method of canonical transformations in existing textbooks, and partly it is intended to emphasize other geometric aspects.
GENERAL MECHANICSTEXTS V. I. Arnold, Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics, Springer-Verlag. New York, 1978. N. G. Chetaev, Theoretical Mechanics, Springer-Verlag. Berlin, 1989. H. Goldstein, Classical Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1980.
XXViii
INTRODUCTION
L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Mechanics, Pergamrnon, Oxford, 1976. L. A. Pars, Analytical Dynamics, Ox Bow Press, Woodbridge, CT, 1979. F. Scheck, Mechanics, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1990. K. R. Symon, Mechanics, 3rd ed., Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1971. D. Ter Haar, Elements of Hamiltonian Mechanics, 2nd ed., Pergarnon, Oxford, 1971. E. T. Whittaker, A Treatise on the Analytical Dynamics of Particles and Rigid Bodies, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 1989.
SPECIALIZED MATHEMATICAL BOOKS ON MECHANICS R. Abraham and J. E. Marsden, Foundations of Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1985. V. I. Arnold. V. V. Kozlov, and A. I. Neishtadt, Dynamical SystemsIll, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1980. J. E. Marsden, Lectures on Mechanics, Cambridge university Press, Cambridge, UK, 1992. K. R. Meyer and R. Hall, Introduction to Hamiltonian Dynamical Systems and the N-Body Problem, Springer-Verlag. New York, 1992.
RELEVANT MATHEMATICS E. Cartan, Legons sur la ggometrie des espaces de Riemann, Gauthiers-Villars, Paris, 1951. (English translation available.) E. Cartan, The Theory of Spinors, Dover, New York, 1981. B. A. Dubrovin, A. T. Fomenko, and S.P. Novikov, Modem Geometry: Methods and Applications, Part I , Springer-Verlag, New York, 1984. H. Flanders, Differential Forms WithApplications to the Physical Sciences, Dover, New York, 1989. D. H. Sattinger and 0.L. Weaver, Lie Groups and Algebras, Applications to Physics, Geometry, and Mechanics, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1993. B. F. Schutz, Geometrical Methods of Mathematical Physics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 1980. V. A. Yakubovitch and V. M. Starzhinskii, Linear Differential Equations with Periodic Coefficients, Wiley, New York, 1975.
SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
1 REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
1.l.INTRODUCTION AND RATIONALE An introductory textbook on Lagrangian mechanics (which this is not) might be expected to begin by announcing that the reader is assumed to be familiar with Newtonian mechanics-kinematics, force, momentum and energy and their conservation, simple harmonic motion, moments of inertia, and so on. In all likelihood such a text would then proceed to review these very same topics before advancing to its main topic of Lagrangian mechanics. This would not, of course, contradict the original assumption since, apart from the simple pedagogical value of review, it makes no sense to study Lagrangian mechanics without anchoring it firmly in a Newtonian foundation. The student who had not learned this material previously would be well advised to start by studying a less advanced, purely Newtonian mechanics textbook. Because so many of the most important problems of physics can be solved cleanly without the power of Lagrangian mechanics, it would be uneconomical to begin with an abstract formulation of mechanics before developing intuition better acquired from a concrete treatment. One might say that Newtonian methods give better “value” than Lagrangian mechanics because, though ultimately less powerful, Newtonian methods can solve the most important problems and are easier to learn. Of course this would only be true in the sort of foolish system of accounting that might attempt to rate the relative contributionsof Newton and Einstein. One (but not the only) purpose of this textbook is to go beyond Lagrange’s equations. By the same foolish system of accounting just mentioned, these methods would be rated less valuable than La3
4
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
grangian methods because, though more powerful, they are more abstract and harder to learn. It is assumed the reader has had some (not necessarily much) experience with Lagrangian mechanics.’ Naturally this presupposes familiarity with the abovementioned elementary concepts of Newtonian mechanics. Nevertheless, for the reasons described in the previous paragraph, we start by reviewing material that is, in principle, already known. It is assumed the reader can define a Lagrangian, can write it down for a simple mechanical system, can write down (or copy knowledgeably) the Euler-Lagrange equations and from them derive the equations of motion of the system, and finally (and most important of all) trust these equations to the same extent that she or he trusts Newton’s law itself. A certain (even if grudging) acknowledgment of the method’s power to make complicated systems appear simple is also helpful. Any reader unfamiliar with these ideas would be well advised to begin by repairing the defect with the aid of one of the numerous excellent textbooks explaining Lagrangian mechanics. Because a systematic review of Newtonian and Lagrangian mechanics would be too lengthy, this chapter organizes the review in the form of worked examples that illustrate the important concepts. Though these examples are intended for solution “by hand,” many of them can also be worked using a mathematical manipulation computer language such as Maple, Mathematica, or Matlab, and a few such solutions are given in the text. They are given in Maple since, of the languages mentioned, that is the only one the author “speaks,” but there is no reason to suppose this choice is optimal. No attempt is made to explain the Maple programs on a line-by-line basis. Such listings are only given in cases where whole classes of problems can be solved by making minor alterations in the given code. By glancing at these solutions you should be able to assess roughly the effort that would be involved in making such alterations and also to guess the likelihood of success for solving a particular problem of the class. If this problem is extremely close to the solved problem it might be appropriate to port it into your language of choice. Students wishing to use these solutions to confirm their own pencil-and-paper solutions should simply guess the correspondences between variable names and symbols and skip to the results. (In these cases the name puzzle might be more appropriate than problem.) It can be argued (persuasively I believe) that training in the use of mathematical manipulation programs should be part of any scientific curriculum, and (perhaps less persuasively) that classical mechanics is the best training ground. However, appropriate material for a course explaining those methods would go well beyond the scope of this text, which is already uncomfortably broad. This is unfortunate because
‘Though “prerequisites” have been mentioned, this text still attempts to be “not too advanced.” Though the subject matter deviates greatly from the traditional curriculum at this level (as represented, say, by Goldstein, Classical Mechanics) it is my intention that the level of difficulty and the anticipated level of preparation be much the same as is appropriate for Goldstein.
INTRODUCTION AND RATIONALE
5
the results that come effortlessly from the computer (after appreciable initial effort2) lend a concreteness to analytic formulas that can otherwise be achieved only by laborious hand calculation. By permitting one to follow effortlessly in the footsteps of Lagrange, Euler, Gauss, Christoffel, and so on, the computer puts flesh on their methods, makes it thinkable to experiment with variants, and generally enhances one’s admiration for these “parents of the field” who had only pencil and paper to work with. Generally speaking, one should attempt to solve problems in purely analytic form to the extent possible; it is invariably easier to solve problems in purely numerical terms, but such solutions are typically of limited value for gaining insight into the nature of the system under study. In this text much greater emphasis is placed on obtaining correct equations than on solving them. In the present computer age, this might be called “modern” because computers are very good at solving equations. Going further by using the computer to derive the equations might then be called “hypermodern.” Part of our task is to develop methods by which computers can do just that. In spite of these considerations there is simply too much analytical material and the level of abstraction needed to appreciate geometric mechanics is too deep to leave much time for problem solving by computer. Ultimately, though, students with a serious interest in pursuing the methods of this text must plan eventually to become adept in some computer problem-solving environment. Since the process of becoming adept is “fun,” the best approach would probably be for each individual to take the initiative in achieving this goal. If time spent in this pursuit is charged to “hobby” time, it will leave more time for the deeper thought required to assimilate the “theory” of the subject. The following examples and problems are initially stated in such a way as to be appropriate for solution using the traditional tools of a physics course, pencil and paper. Furthermore, their level of difficulty is designed to match the expected level of preparation of the reader. The sufficiently motivated and adequately prepared reader with enough time should be able to work out the answers with pencil and paper, even ignoring the solutions. The given solutions would have to be regarded as extremely generous hints for some of these problems to qualify as homework assignments. But the examples should be appropriate for “self-assignment” by which the reader confirms her or his level of preparation as adequate for the text. To the extent possible, examples in later chapters are based on these examples. The use of examples is especially appropriate for describing the evolution of systems that are close to solvable systems. *In my experience it takes at least three times as long to solve a problem of the sort studied here using Maple as it would to solve the same problem by hand. But this comparison is about as meaningful as comparing the cost of setting up a production line with the cost of building one automobile. Once properly set up. a program can solve not only the problem at hand but also related problems. Furthermore, it can serve as a springboard to the solution of more challenging problems, possibly even qualifying as “research.” Unfortunately, a student in the context of a university course typically has insufficient time for solving related problems, and hence may not be in a position to amortize the expense of writing the program. This practical consideration contributes to my belief that the time-challengedstudent should not be steered too strenuously away from analytical work and into programming.
6
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
1.2. WORKED EXAMPLES 1.2.1. Particle in One-Dimensional Potential The first problem is prototypical of all problems in simple harmonic motion or, in other words, of the linearized description of motion near equilibrium. One locates a point of equilibrium where the force vanishes or, equivalently, the potential function has a minimum, and approximates the potential locally by the best-fit upright parabola. For convenience the origin can be moved to the minimum point. Application of energy conservation yields the “turning points” immediately, in addition to providing a formula relating position and velocity. Probably something close to the computer program listing that serves as a solution can be used to linearize any potential that can be written explicitly as a differentiable function. In higher than one dimension the linearizationprocess is essentially similar but, of course, there are more equations and they are harder to solve.
Problem 1.2.1: A particle of mass m and total energy E is subject to the onedimensional Morse potential U ( X )= ~ ( e - ~-”2e-‘“*).
(a) Assuming the particle bound, find its turning points and its point of stable equilibrium. (b) Find the frequency of small oscillation. (c) Find the frequency of large oscillation. (d) Solve for the general motion by “reduction to quadrature,” i.e., as an integral remaining to be evaluated. (e) On a “phase space” plot with x as abscissa and p = m i as ordinate, sketch typical trajectories.
Maple Program 1.2.1 # Particle i n lDPotentia1 > with(p1ots): with(lina1g): withbtudent):
norm trace
Warning: new definition for Warning: new definition for >
U := A*( exp(-l*alpha*x)
-
P*exp(-alpha*x)
u := A(ef-2’”x) >
>;
-2e(-@”))
F := -diff(U,x);
F := - A ( - ~ u ~ ( - ~ O ” )+ 2 , y e ( - u X ) 1
=.
x-0 := aolve(F,x) ; x-0 := 0
WORKED EXAMPLES
7
> # S u b s t i t u t e f o r x t o avoid s e t t i n g x-0 while obtaining k >
F 1;
F := subs( x'xx,
F := - ~ ( - 2 a e ( - 2 ' ~ *+~2)f f e ( - * ' ) ) > k := -diff(F,xx);
>
F := subs(
F 1:
XX=X,
> xx := x-0:
k := eval(k);
k := 2A a2 > small-amp-period
:= 2*Pi*sqrt (m/k) ;
smallampperiod := IT > #
Must not use "E" a s t o t a l energy; maple i n t e r p r e t s it
# a s 2.718 >
Aff
...
t p t s := solve( U-EE, x> ;
In
(:
)
2A +2A
tpts := -
- l n ( 1 2 A - 2 m A
a
ff
>
d e l t a := 0.0000001: # Fudge f a c t o r t o help i n t e g r a t i o n a t end of range
>
t p t l := t p t s [ l ] + d e l t a : t p t 2 := tpts[2]-delta:
> I n t ( l / s q r t (EE-U)
( 1- (
In 1/2 2A-2-)
,x
=
t p t l . .tpt2
;
A -.110-6
1
,/EE- A(e(--2@X)-2ef-wXf)
In 1 / 2 2A+c=E) A
-
dx
+.110-6
a
> period := s q r t (2*m) *changevar( exp(-alpha*x)=y
,
'I,
y) ;
[ [ "("'7 ,1 104))
Q
period := JZJG
le In(
2 A+2
> A := 1: alpha := 1: period;
4
~
)
1
- A (y2 - 2 y ) y
dY
8
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
(la(l-JiTE)+.110-6)
>
TO := evalf(small-amp-period) ;
TO := 4.442882938 f i >
EE := -0.9:period; .6837723024
1
-
- y 2 -+ 2 y y
J-.9
dY
TI := 4.680867535
p l :=
EE
:=
Jm ( -.9
-0.7:period: T2 := evalf(
- e( - 2 x
)
+ 2 e('-X ) )
'I
1: p2 := sqrt(2*m*(EE-U)):
>
EE := -0.5:period: T3
:= evalf (
'I
):
p3 := sqrt(2*m*(EE-U))
:
>
EE
:= -0.3: period:
T4
:= evalf (
'I
):
p4 := sqrt(2*m*(EE-U))
:
>
EE
:= -0.1:period: T5 := evalf(
I*
1: p5 := sqrt(2*m*(EE-U)):
>
plotsetup(ps,plotoptions='noborder');
plotsetup: warning plotoutput filename set to postscript.out interface(plotoutput='Shape.ps');
plot(U,x=-1. .5, title='Morse Potential, U(x),
1
A=alpha=l');
>
interface(p1otoutputt'Force .pa') ;
>
plot(F,x=-1. -5, title='Force, F(x),
>
m := 1:
>
interface(plotoutput= ' Period .ps ' ;
>
plotpoints := [ [-1,TO] ,I-. 9,T1], [- .7,T2] ,I-. 5,T3] , [- .3,T41,I-. 1,T511;
A=alpha=lO;
plotpoints := [[ -1,4.442882938], [ -.9,4.680867535]. [ -.7,5.308304409], [ -.5,6.281216813], [ -.3,8.109331364], [ -.1, 14.0462873211 >
plot( plotpoints, style=line, title='Period vs. Energy'); interface(plotoutput='PhaseSpace .ps') ;
>
plot (Ipl,p2,p3,p4,p5), x=- 1. .3,title- 'Momentum vs position' ;
WORKED EXAMPLES
;
>
interface(plotoutput='Flou.ps')
>
f ieldplot ( [p/m, F] ,x=-0.5..3,p=O. . 1.3
;
Maple Results 1.2.1
Morse Potential, U(x), A=alpha=l
1
5
FIGURE 1.2.1. Graph of the Morse potential.
Force, F (x), A=alpha=l
FIGURE 1.2.2. The force resultingfrom the Morse potential.
9
10
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
Period vs. Energy 14-
12.-
10-
8-
6-
FIGURE 1.2.3. The period of oscillation about the equilibrium point of the Morse potential, as a function of amplitude.
Momentum vs. position t
t
-1
I
0
I
1
x
2
3
FIGURE 1.2.4. Phase space plot, momentum p versus position x for the Morse potential, for E = -.9, -.7, -5,-.3, -.1. The smooth curves are contours of equal total energy. 'Turning points" are the (extrapolated) intersections of these curves with the x-axis (about which the plot is symmetric.)
WORKED EXAMPLES
11
FIGURE 1.2.5. Arrows represent the flow (plrn, F ) plotted with ( x , p) axes; the Morse potential.
Problem 1.2.2: Two potential energy functions expressible in terms of elementary functions and leading to bounded motion are as follows: (a) U ( x ) = -Uo/ cosh’(ax). (b) U ( x ) = Uo tan’(ax). Sketch these functions, find ranges of energy E for which bounded motion occurs, give a formula determining the turning points, and find the frequency of small oscillations.
Problem 1.2.3: Motion always “back and forth” between two limits, say a and b, in one dimension due to force derivable from a potential energy function V ( x ) is known as “libration.” Conservation of energy then implies
li’ = ( x
- a )(b - x ) @ ( x ) ,
or li = * J ( x
- a)(b - x ) @ ( x ) ,
where @ ( x ) =. 0 through the range a 5 x 5 b but is otherwise an arbitrary function of x . It is necessary to toggle between the two f choices depending on whether the particle is moving to the right or to the left. Consider the change of variable x -+8 defined by x = a - ,9 cos 8,
where a - ,9 = a ,
a
+ ,9 = b.
Show that ( x - a)(b - x ) = /?’sin’ 8 and that energy conservation is expressed by
e = J@(a- j3 cost?), where there is no longer a sign ambiguity because 8 is always positive. The variable 8 is known as an “angle variable.” One-dimensional libration motion can always be
12
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
expressed in terms of an angle variable in this way, and then can be “reduced to quadrature” as
re This type of motion is especially important in the conditionally periodic motion of multidimensional oscillatory systems. This topic is studied in Section 14.6.
1.2.2. Particle in Space Problem 1.2.4: The acceleration of a point particle with velocity v(t) is given by
Show that Ivl is constant. For the case that A is independent of time and position, give the motion of the particle in terms of its initial position ro and velocity vo. 1.2.3. Weakly Coupled Oscillators
Already in two dimensions there is a rich variety of possible system motions. No attempt will be made here to survey this variety, but some of it can be inferred by studying the pictures accompanying the following problem. In particular the final part exhibits the ubiquitous phenomenon of “avoided line-crossing” where “line” refers to the graph of a normal mode frequency plotted as a function of a parameter of the problem. A theory of nonlinear perturbations to systems like this is described in the final chapter.
Problem 1.2.5: The Lagrangian
with la I << w2 and la I << w; describes two oscillators that are weakly coupled. (a) Find normal coordinates and normal mode frequencies Q 1 and 522. (b) For the case w = w;?, describe free motion of the oscillator. (c) Holding a and w;? fixed, make a plot of G? versus w showing a branch for each of and S22. Do it numerically if you wish. Describe the essential qualitative features exhibited.
Maple Program 1.2.5 > #
Two weakly-coupled oscillators
> uith(p1ots):
with(lina1g): plotsetup(ps,plotoptions=‘noborder‘):
WORKED EXAMPLES
13
Warning: new definition for norm Warning: new definition for trace plotsetup: warning plotoutput filename set to postscript.out >
Digits := 5:
>
alias( x=x(t)
>
V
1: alias( y=y(t)
):
:= 1/2*(omega_1^2*~^2 + ornega_2^2*y^2)
-
alpha*x*y;
v := -1 omega-12 x 2 + -1 omega22 y 2 - a x y 2
2 >
T := m/2*(diff (x.t)-2 + diff (y,t)-2);
L := m 2 > # >
L
((i + (i x)’
y12) -
ornega-12x2 - -1 omega22 y2 2
+ax y
Substitute for x and y since they have been aliased := subs( { x=xx, y=yy, diff(x,t)=xp,
diff(y.t)=yp
1, L);
1 L := - rn (xp2 + y p 2 ) - - omega-I2x2 - - omegaJ2yy2 +axryy 2 2 2 1
>
1
dL-dxp := diff(L,xp); d L d r p := m xp
>
dL-dyp := diff (L,yp); d L d y p := m y p
>
dL-dx := diff (L,xx) ; d L d x := --ornega-I2 XT
+ a yy
d L d y := -omega2 2 y y
+a w
dL-dy := diff (L,yy);
>r
a-dxp := subs( Cxx=x, yy=y, xp=diff (x ,t) , yp’dif f(y ,t) 3 , dL-dxp) ; dLAxp := m
>
(i
x)
dl-dyp := subs( {xx=x, yy=y, xp=diff (x, t) , yp=diff (y ,t) 1, dL-dyp) ; d L d y p := m
(i
y)
14
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
d L d r := -omega-12 x
+
a! y
> dL-dy := subs( Cxx=x, yy=y, xp=diff (x,t), yp-diff (y,t)).
d L d y := -ornegaJ2 y > alias( x=x
: alias( y=y
dL-dy);
+ a! x
1; 1
z #
The only remaining alias is I = sqrt(-1)
> eqnx := diff(dL-dxp.t)
eqnx := m >
-
&-dx
($
eqny := diff(dL-dyp,t)
-
x( t ))
= 0 ;
+ omega-] 2 x( t
- a! y ( t ) = 0
dL-dy = 0 ;
> omega-1 := 1: omega-2 := 1: alpha := 0.1: > eqnxl := subs(Cx(t>=xt(t),
y(t)=yt(t)),
m := 1:
eqnx);
> ODE := eqnx1,eqnyl;
> initvals := xt(O)=l.
yt(O)=O,
D(xt) ( O ) = O , D ( y t ) (O)=O:
> funcs := Cxt(t),yt(t));
funcs := { xt( t ), yt( t ) } >
sols := dsolve(
C
ODE, initvals),
funcs, 'laplace');
sols := { x t ( t ) = .5()00coS(.94869t)
+ . ~ ~ O O O C O1.0488t), S(
Yt( t ) = SoOOO COS( .94869 t ) - So000COS( 1.0488 t )) >
assijp(so1s);
=.
interface(plotoutput='xyCpldOsc.ps'):
WORKED EXAMPLES
plot( xt(t>. t=O..100 1:
>
plot1
>
plot2 := plot( yt(t),
>
display({plotl,plot2},
>
omega-1 := 'omega';
:=
15
t=0..100, thickness=l 1: title='x(t)
and y(t) '1;
omega-1 := w >
ODE := eqnx,eqny; +y(t)-.lx(t)=O
X(t)--.ly(t)=O, >
initvals := x(O)=l, y(O)=O,
>
funcs
:=
D(x) ( O ) = O , D(y) (O)=O:
{x(t>,y(t>}; funcs := { x( t ). y (
>
11
sols := dsolve( { ODE, initvals}, funcs, 'laplace');
(
%1 := RootOf l002?
+ (100 + 100w2)
Z 2- 1
>
assign(so1s) ;
>
interface (plotoutput=' CpldOsc-xVsOmega.ps' ) ;
>
plotdd
>
interface(plotoutput='CpldOsc-yVs0mega.p~') ;
>
plot3d
> #
(
(
+ 100w2)
x(t), omega=0.8..1.2,t=O..40, numpoints = 4000, style=hidden, orientation=[-lO,45], axes=BOXED, title = 'x(t>' 1;
y(t), omega=0.8..1.2. t=O..40, numpoints = 4000, style=hidden, orientation=[-10,451, axes=BOXED, title = 'y(t)' ) ;
Unassign alpha and omega-2. i.e. Let them be variables again---they assigned numerical values above.
# were >
alpha
:=
'alpha'; omega-2 := 'omega-2'; (Y
:= (Y
omega2 := omega2 >
M
:= matrix(2,2, [omega-2, alpha, alpha, omega-2^2]
1;
16
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
M:=[ >
w,’
“ 1
omegaz’
eigs := eigenvals(M); eigs := -1 m2
2 1
1
2
2
+ -1 omega22 + -’ J o 4 2
- 2w2 omega22 + omega24 + 4 a 2 ,
2
- 0 2 + - omega22 - 1J 0 4 - 2 0 2 omega22 + omega24 + 4 a2 2
whattype(eig6);
exprseq > omplus := sqrt (eigs C11) ;
omplus := >
1 J2 0 2 + 2 omega22 + 2 J04 2
- 2 a 2 omega22 + omega24 + 4a2
omminus := sqrt (eigs C21) ;
> alpha := 0.1: omega-2 := 1: >
interface(plotoutput=‘ModeFreqs.ps‘);
>
p~ot(Complus,omminus3, omega=o..l.b, title=‘Nonnal Mode Frequencies‘, numpoints=400, axes=BOXED
;
Maple Results 1.2.5
x ( t ) and y ( t )
FIGURE 1.2.6. Sloshing of energy between two weakly coupled oscillators of equal natural frequency, w = y = 1, a = 0.1.
WORKED EXAMPLES
17
t
FIGURE 1.2.7. The displacement x of the originally displaced mass is shown; holding the coupling strength and the other natural frequency constant, (Y = 0.1, y = 1, its natural frequency w is allowed to vary over the range y - 0.2 < 0 c y 0.2.
+
1. 1.
0. 0. 0. 0.
omega FIGURE 1.2.8. Holding the coupling strength and one natural frequency constant at y = 1, a = 0.1, the other natural frequency is allowed to vary over the range 0 < w < 1.5. The eigenfrequencies 521 and Q2 lie on separate branches. For low o the pair (521, 522) x (y. w) but for high 61 (B,, Q2) (w. y). That is, the identificationreverses as one passes from o c w2 to y < w. As a result the two branches never intersect.
18
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
Problem 1.2.6: The approximate Lagrangian for an n-dimensional system with coordinates ( 4 1 ~42. . . . , 4”). valid in the vicinity of an equilibrium point (that can be taken to be (0, 0, . . . ,0)) has the form
(1.2.1) with T positive definite. It is common to use the summation convention for summations like this, but in this text the summation convention is reserved for tensor summations. When subscripts are placed in parentheses (as here) it indicates they refer to different variables or parameters (as here) rather than different components of the same vector or tensor. However, for the rest of the problem the parentheses will be left off, while the summation signs will be left explicit. It is shown in Section 2.5.3 that a linear transformation qi + y, can be found such that T takes the form 1 ” T =-Cmrj;, 2 r=l where, in this case, each “mass” m, is necessarily positive because T is positive definite. By judicious choice of the scale of the yr each “mass” can be adjusted to 1: 1 ” T =5
(1.2.2)
r=l
For these coordinates yr the equation (1.2.3) r=l
defines a surface (to be called a hypersphere). From now on we will consider only points y = (y1, . . . , y,,) lying on this sphere. Also two points u and v will be said to be “orthogonal” if the “quadratic form” Z(u, v) defined by
vanishes. Being linear in both arguments Z(u, v) is described as being “bilinear.” We also define a bilinear form V(u, v) by
WORKED EXAMPLES
19
where coefficients kr, have been redefined from the values given above to correspond to the new coordinates yr so that 1 V(Y) = 2 W Y , Y). The following series of problems (adapted from Courant and Hilbert [ 11) will lead to the conclusion that a further linear transformation yi --f z j can be found that, on t!e one hand, enables the equation for the sphere in Eq. (1.2.3) to retain the same form,
r=l
and, on the other, enables V to be expressible as a sum of squares with positive coefficients:
Pictorially the strategy is, having deformed the scales so that surfaces of constant T are spherical and surfaces of constant V ellipsoidal, to orient the axes to make these ellipsoids erect. In the jargon of mechanics this process is known as “normal mode” analysis. The “minimax” properties of the “eigenvalues” to be found have important physical implications, but we will not go into them here. (1) Argue, for small oscillations to be stable, that V must also be positive definite. (2) Let z1 be the point on “sphere” (1.2.3) for which V ( ‘g ~ K I is) maximum. (If there is more than one such point pick any one arbitrarily.)Then argue that
(3) Among all points that are both on sphere (1.2.3) and orthogonal to z1,let 22 def. 1 be the one for which V( = 9 ~ 2 is ) maximum. Continuing in this way show that a series of points 21, z2,. . . ,z,,,each maximizing V consistent with being orthogonal to its predecessors, is determined, and that the sequence of values, V(zr) = Z1 K ~ , r = 1,2, ... ,n,is monotonically nonincreasing. (4) Consider a point z1 €6 which is assumed to lie on surface (1.2.3) but with 6 otherwise arbitrary. Next assume this point is “close to” z1 in the sense that 6 is arbitrarily small (and not necessarily positive). Since z1 maximizes V it follows that
+
Show therefore that
20
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
This implies that U ( z l , z r )= O
for r > 1,
because, other than being almost orthogonal to 2 1 . 4 is arbitrary. Finally, extend the argument to show that
where the coefficients /cr have been shown to satisfy the monotonic conditions of Eq. (1.2.4) and is the usual Kronecker-6 symbol. Taking these Zr as basis vectors, an arbitrary vector z can be expressed as
In these new coordinates show that Eqs. (1.2.1) become
L ( z , ~=) T - V , T =
--xi:.v
1 " 2 =-CKrzr. 2 r=l
1 " 2 r=l
(1.2.5)
Write and solve the Lagrange equations for coordinates 2,.
Problem 1.2.7: Continuing with the previous formula, using a more formal approach, the Lagrange equations resulting from Q. (1.2.1) are ( 1.2.6)
These equations can be expressed compactly in matrix form as
Mq + Kq = 0,
(1.2.7)
or, assuming the existence of M-' , as
+ M-'Kq
= 0.
(1.2.8)
Seeking a solution of the form qr = ~
~
r= 2 I, 2 ~ , . . . ,n, '
the result of substitution into Eq. (1.2.6) is
( M - ~ K- 0 2 i )=~0.
(1.2.9)
WORKED EXAMPLES
21
These equations have nontrivial solutions for values of w that cause the determinant of the coefficients to vanish:
I M - ~ K- w2i1= 0.
( 1.2.10)
Correlate these “eigenvalues” with the constants K~ defined in the previous problem.
Problem 1.2.8: Particles of mass 3m, 4m, and 3m are spaced at uniform intervals h along a light string of total length 4k stretched with tension 7 and rigidly fixed at both ends. To legitimize ignoring gravity the system is assumed to lie on a smooth horizontal table so the masses can oscillate only horizontally. Let the horizontal displacements be X I , x2, and x3. Find the normal mode frequencies and the corresponding normal mode oscillation “shapes.” Discuss the “symmetry” of the shapes, their “wavelengths,” and the (monotonic)relation between frequency and number of nodes. See Fig. 1.2.9. Already with just 3 degrees of freedom the eigenmode calculations are sufficiently tedious to make some efforts at simplifying the work worthwhile. In this problem, with the system symmetric about its midpoint it is clear that the modes will be either symmetric or antisymmetric and, since the antisymmetric mode vanishes at the center point, it is characterized by a single amplitude, say y = X I = -x3. Introducing “effective mass” and “effective strength coefficient,” the kinetic energy of the mode, necessarily proportional to j , can be written as T2 = $meff)i2 and the potential energy can be written as V2 = $keffy2. The frequency of this mode is then given by w = d-, which, by dimensional analysis, has to be have been given proportional to Q = J?/(mh). (The quantities T2, V2, and subscript 2 because this mode has the second highest frequency.) Factoring this expression out of Q. (1.2.lo), the dimensionless eigenvalues are the eigenfrequencies in units of q . Complete the analysis to show that the normal mode frequencies are (wi ,w ,w3) = (1, and find the corresponding normal mode “shapes.”
m,m).
Problem 1.2.9: Though the eigenmode/eigenvalue solution method employed in solving the previous problem is the traditional method used in classical mechanics, equations of the same form, when they arise in circuit analysis and other engineering fields, are traditionally solved using Laplace transforms-a more robust method, it seems. Let us continue the solution of the previous problem using this method. Individuals already familiar with this method or not wishing to become so should 3m
3m
h
h
h
h
FIGURE 1.2.9. Three beads on a stretched string. Tha transverse displacements are much exaggerated. Gravity and string mass are negligible.
22
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
skip this section. Here we use the notation
(1.2.11) as the formula giving the Laplace transform X(s), of the function of time x ( t ) . T(s) is a function of the “transform variable” s (which is a complex number with positive real part). With this definition the Laplace transform satisfies many formulas, but for present purposes we use only dx
= sx - x(O), dt
(1.2.12)
which is easily demonstrated. Repeated application of this formula converts time derivatives into functions of s and therefore converts (linear) differential equations into (linear) algebraic equations. This will now be applied to the system described in the previous problem. The Lagrange equations for the beaded string shown in Fig. 1.2.9 are
(1.2.13)
Suppose the string is initially at rest but that a transverse impulse I is administered to the first mass at t = 0; as a consequence it acquires initial velocity u10 = f(0) = 1/(3m). Transforming all three equations and applying the initial conditions (the only nonvanishing initial quantity, u10, enters via Eq. (1.2.12)).
Solving these equations yields XI
=-
+-
1
(1.2.15)
-
x3 = -
+--s 2 +1 q 2
s2+2q2/3
WORKED EXAMPLES
23
It can be seen, except for factors hi, that the poles (as a function of s) of the transforms of the variables are the normal mode frequencies. This is not surprising as the determinant of the coefficients in Eq. (1.2.14) is the same as the determinant entering the normal mode solution, but with w2 replaced with -s2. Recall from Cramer’s rule for the solution of linear equations that this determinant appears in the denominators of the solutions. For “inverting” Eq. (1.2.15) it is sufficient to know just one inverse Laplace transformation, ( 1.2.16)
but it is easier to look in a table of inverse transforms to find that the terms in Eq. (1.2.15) yield sinusoids that oscillate with the normal mode frequencies. Furthermore, the “shapes” asked for in the previous problem can be read off directly from (1.2.15) to be (2 : 3 : 2), (1 : 0 : -l), and (1 : -1 : 1). When the first mass is struck at t = 0 all three modes are excited and they proceed to oscillate at their own natural frequencies, so the motion of each individual particle is a superposition of these frequencies. Since there is no damping, the system will continue to oscillate in this superficially complicated way forever. In practice there is always some damping and, in general, it is different for the different modes; commonly, damping increases with frequency. In this case, after a while, the motion will be primarily in the lowest frequency mode; if the vibrating string emits audible sound, an increasingly pure tone will be heard as time goes on.
Problem 1.2.10: Damped and Driven Simple Harmonic Motion. The equation of motion of mass m, subject to restoring force -wimx, damping force -2Amf, and external drive force f cos y r is 5
f cos y t . + 2 A i + w; = m
(1.2.17)
(a) Show that the general solution of this equation when f = 0 is x ( t ) = ae-At cos(wt
+ $),
(1.2.18)
where a and $ depend on initial conditions and w = d m . This “solution of the homogeneous equation” is also known as “transient” because when it is superimposed on the “driven” or “steady-state” motion caused by f it will eventually become negligible. (b) Correlate the stability or instability of the transient solution with the sign of A. Equivalently, after writing the solution (1.2.18) as the sum of two complex exponential terms, Laplace transform them, and correlate the stability or instability of the transient with the locations in the complex s-plane of the poles of the Laplace transform. (c) Assuming x(0) = f(0) = 0, show that 1,aplace transforming Eiq. (1.2.17) yields
24
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
X(s) =-f
1 2as
S
s2
+ y 2 ~2 + + w;‘
( 1.2.19)
This expression has four poles, each of which leads to a complex exponential term in the time response. To neglect transients we need only drop the terms for which the poles are off the imaginary axis. (By part (b) they must be in the left half-plane for stability.) To “drop” these terms it is necessary first to isolate them by partial fraction decomposition of Fq.(1.2.19). Performing these operations, show that the steady state solution of Eq. (1.2.17) is
where wo 2 - y2
- 2 ~ y?= i J (w2 - y2)2 + 4~ y eis.
(1.2.21)
(d) The response is large only for y close to OXJ. To exploit this, defining the “small” “frequency deviation from the natural frequency” E=Y-wg,
show that y 2 - o2x
~ E O and that
(1.2.22)
the approximate response is (1.2.23)
Find the value of E for which the amplitude of the response is reduced from its maximum value by the factor 1/a.
1.2.4. Conservationof Momentum and Energy It has been shown previously that the application of energy conservation in onedimensional problems permits the system evolution to be expressed in terms of a single integral-this is “reduction to quadrature.” The following problem exhibits the use of momentum conservation to reduce a two-dimensional problem to quadratures, or rather, because of the simplicity of the configuration in this case, to a closed-form solution.
Problem 1.2.11: A point mass m with total energy E, starting in the left half-plane, moves in the ( x , y) plane subject to potential energy function
The “angle of incidence” to the interface at x = 0 is 0, ,and the outgoing angle is 8. Specify the qualitatively different cases that are possible, depending on the relative
WORKED EXAMPLES
25
values of the energies, and in each case find 8 in terms of 8i . Show that all results can be cast in the form of “Snell’s Law” of geometric optics if one introduces a factor ,/-, analogous to index of refraction.
1.2.5. Effective Potential Since one-dimensional motion is subject to such simple and satisfactory analysis, anything that can reduce the dimensionality from two to one has great value. The “effective potential” is one such device.
Problem 1.2.12: The Kepler Problem. No physics problem has received more attention over the centuries than the problem of planetary orbits. In later chapters of this text the analytic solution of this so-called “Kepler problem” will be the foundation on which perturbative solution of more complicated problems will be based. Though this problem is now regarded as “elementary” one is well-advised to stick to traditional manipulations as the problem can otherwise get seriously messy. The problem of two masses m 1 and m2 moving in each other’s gravitational field is easily converted into the problem of a single particle of mass m moving in the gravitational field of a mass mo assumed very large compared to m,that is, F = - K f / r 2 , where K = Gmom and r is the distance to m from mo. Anticipating that the orbit lies in a plane (as it must), let x be the angle of the radius vector from a line through the center of mo; this line will later be taken as the major axis of the elliptical orbit. The potential energy function is given by
K U ( r ) = --,r
(1.2.24)
and the orbit geometry is illustrated in Fig. 1.2.10.
FIGURE 1.210. Geometric constructiondefining the ‘true anomaly“ x and “eccentricanomaly“ u in terms of other orbit parameters.
26
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
W o conserved quantities can be identified immediately: energy E and angular momentum M . Show that they are given by E = -m(r 1 - 2 + r 2 x. 2 ) - -, K 2 r M = m r 2i .
(1.2.25)
One can exploit the constancy of M by eliminating x from the expression for E, 1 E = -mf2 2
+ UeR(r),
M2 K where Ue&) = -- -. 2mr2 r
(1.2.26)
The function Uefi(r).known as the “effective potential,” is plotted in Fig. 1.2.11. Solving both the expression for E and the expression for M for the differential dt
mrL dt = - d x , M (1.2.27) and equating the two expressions yields a differential equation that can be solved by “separation of variables.” This has permitted the problem to be “reduced to quadratures,”
x(r)=
Ir
Mdr’lrf2 J2m ( E
+ $) - M 2 / r f 2 ’
(1.2.28)
Note that this procedure yields only an “orbit equation,” the dependence of x on r (which is equivalent to, if less convenient than, the dependence of r on x .) Though a priori one should have had the more ambitious goal of finding a solution in the
FIGURE 1.2.11. The effective potential U,ft for the Kepler problem.
WORKED EXAMPLES
27
form r ( r ) and x (t), no information whatsoever is given yet about time dependence by Eq.(1.2.28). (a) Show that all computations so far can be carried out for any central force that is radially directed with magnitude dependent only on r. At worst the integral analogous to (1.2.28) can be performed numerically. (b) Returning to the Kepler problem, perform the integral (1.2.28) and show that the orbit equation can be written ECOSX
where E
=
Jm..
M2 1 + 1= mK r’
(1.2.29)
(c) Show that (1.2.29) is the equation of an ellipse if 6 < 1 and that this condition is equivalent to E < 0. (d) It is traditional to write the orbit equation purely in terms of “orbit elements” E, which can be identified as the “eccentricity” and the “semimajor axis” a: (1.2.30) The reason a and E are special is that they are intrinsic properties of the orbit, unlike, for example, the orientations of the semimajor axis and the direction of the perpendicular to the orbit plane, both of which can be altered at will and still leave a “congruent” system. Derive the relations
E = --,K 2a
M 2 = (1 - E2)mKa,
(1.2.3 1)
so the orbit equation is a -= r
~+ECOSX
1-€2
(1.2.32) *
(e) Finally, derive the relation between r and t : (1.2.33) An “intermediate” variable u that leads to worthwhile simplication is defined by r=a(l-ccosu).
(1.2.34)
The geometric interpretation of u is indicated in Fig. 1.2.10. If (x, z) are Cartesian coordinates of the planet along the major and an axis parallel to the minor axis
28
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
through the central mass, they are given in terms of u by x =acosu -a€,
z = a d 1 - € 2 sinu,
(1.2.35)
since the semimajor axis is a,/and the circumscribed circle is related to the ellipse by a z-axis scale factor d n . The coordinate u, known as the “eccentric anomaly,” is a kind of distorted angular coordinate of the planet, and is related fairly simply to t: I
t = J gK( u - c sinu).
(1.2.36)
This is especially useful for nearly circular orbits, since then u is nearly proportional tot. Analysis of this Keplerian system is continued using Hamilton-Jacobi theory in Section 112 . 8 , and then again in Section 14.6.3 to illustrate actiodangle variables, and then again as a system subject to perturbation and analyzed by “variation of constants” in Section 16.1.1. Problem 1.2.13: The effective potential formalism has reduced the dimensionality of the Kepler problem from two to one. In one dimension, the linearization (to simple harmonic motion) procedure, illustrated above, for example in Problem 1.2.1. can then be used to describe motion that remains close to the minimum of the effective potential (see Fig. 1.2.11). The radius ro = M 2 / ( m K )is the radius of the circular orbit with angular momentum M.Consider an initial situation for which M has this same value and f ( 0 ) = 0, but r(0) # ro, though r(0) is in the rsgion of good parabolic fit to U e ~Find . the frequency of small oscillations and express r ( t ) by its appropriate simple harmonic motion. Then find the orbit elements a and E , as defined in Problem 1.2.12, that give the matching two-dimensional orbit.
1.2.6. Multiparticie Systems Solving multiparticle problems in mechanics is notoriously difficult; for more than two particles it is usually impossible to get solutions in closed form. But the equations of motion can be made simpler by the appropriate choice of coordinates, as the next problem illustrates. Such coordinate choices exploit exact relations such as momentum conservation and thereby simplify subsequent approximate solutions. For example, this is a good pre-quantum starting point for molecular spectroscopy.
Problem 1.2.14: The position vectors of three point masses, m l , m2, and m3, are rl ,r2, and r3. Express these vectors in terms of the alternative configuration vectors sc, s;, and 512 shown in the figure. Define “reduced masses” by mn=mi+rn2,
M=mi+rnz+m3,
cLl2
=
m1m2
m12
m3mn
P3 = M
.
Calculate the total kinetic energy in terms of s, sl,,and s12 and interpret the result.
WORKED EXAMPLES
29
FIGURE 1.2.12. Coordinates describing three particles. C is the center of mass and sc its position vector relative to origin 0. C12 is the center of mass of rnl and 4 and s; is the position of m3 relative to C12.
Defining corresponding partial angular momenta 1, I;, and 112, show that the total angular momentum of the system is the sum of three analogous terms. SOLUTION: In Fig. 1.2.12 the origin 0 is at an arbitrary location relative to which the center of mass C is located by radius vector sc. Relative to particle 1, particle 2 is located by vector s12. Relative to the center of mass at C12 mass 3 is located by vectors;. In terms of these quantities the position vectors of the three masses are
Substituting these into the kinetic energy of the system
T = -mIrf 1 2
+ -m& 1 + -m3r3, 1 -2 2
2
the “cross terms” proportional to sc . si, sc . s12, and s; the result
.s12
all cancel out, leaving
where uc = IscI, v; = IsiI, and u12 = JS12).The angular momentum (about 0)is given by
L = rl x
(mli.1)
+ r2 x (m2i.2) + 1-3 x (m3r3).
Upon expansion the same simplificationsoccur, yielding 1 L = - M rc x vc 2
1 1 + -p3 r3‘ x v3’ + -p12 r12 x v12. 2 2
30
REVIEW OF SOLVABLE SYSTEMS
Problem 1.2.15: Determine the moment of inertia tensor about center of mass C for the system described in the previous problem. Choose axes to simplify the problem initially and give a formula for transforming from these axes to arbitrary (orthonormal) axes. For the case m3 = 0, find the principal axes and the principal moments of inertia.
SOLUTION: Setting sc = 0, the particle positions are given by
Since the masses lie in a single plane it is convenient to take the z-axisnormal to that plane. Let us orient the axes such that the unit vectors satisfy
si = 9, s12 = a i + bf,
(and hence a = s;
fs12).
so the particle coordinates are
x3
m 12 = -, M
y3 = 0.
In terms of these, the moment of inertia tensor I is given by
For the special case m3 = 0 these formulas reduce to
The formulas derived in this solution will be used again in Section 9.3. Problem 1.2.16: A uniform solid cube can be supported by a thread from the center of a face, from the center of an edge, or from a comer, In each of the three cases the system acts as a torsional pendulum, with the thread providing all the restoring torque and the cube providing all the inertia. In which configuration is the oscillation period the longest? (If your answer involves complicated integrals you are not utilizing properties of the inertia tensor in the intended way.)
BIBLIOGRAPHY
31
1.2.7. DimensionaVScalingConsiderations Problem 1.2.17: Suppose the potential energy of a central field is a homogeneous function of degree v : V ( a r )= a ” U ( r ) , for any a > 0. (a) Starting with a valid solution of Newton’s law, making the replacements r 3 a r and t + pr, and choosing p = a’-”/2,show that the total energy is modified by factor a” and the equation of motion is still satisfied. (b) For the case u = 2, derive from this the isochronicity of simple harmonic motion. (c) For the case v = - 1, derive Kepler’s third law.
This sort of argument is introduced from a Lagrangian point of view in Landau and Lifshitz [2], where, among other applications, the viriul theorem is proved. Arnold introduces the argument from a Newtonian point of view and gives other interesting applications of similarity.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
References 1. R. Courant and D. Hilbert, Methods of Mathematical Physics, VoI. 1, Interscience, New
York, 1953,P. 37. 2. L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Classical Mechanics, Pergamon, Oxford, 1976. p. 22.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
THE GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS
Since the subject of mechanics deals with the motion of particles in space, the phrase “geometric mechanics” might seem redundant. In this text the phrase is intended mainly to imply that more consideration will be paid to geometric ideas than was once considered appropriate. Close to a century ago the subject of general relativity sprang almost entirely from a deep contemplation of geometry, and yet the appreciation of geometry as physics has accelerated only recently. Until recently an intuitive grasp of high school geometry has been considered adequate as a pedagogical basis for classical mechanics, with the result that high school geometry is pretty firmly fixed in the intuition of most physicists. Generally this is good, or at least satisfactory, but it can impede the learning of physics that employs more abstract geometric methods. As an example of the way restricted intuition can retard assimilation of new physics, one need only recall the mental cortortion that was required before the (counterintuitive)formula for the composition of velocities in special relativity could be accepted. The strategy of this part of the text is to contemplate geometry with mechanics kept in the background, to better understand geometric ideas on their own before they are folded back into the physics. Of course, the geometric ideas important in mechanics will be the ones to be emphasized.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
GEOMETRY 0F MECHANICS I: LINEAR
2.1. INTRODUCTION Even before considering geometry as physics, one can try to distinguish between geometry and algebra, starting, for example, with the concept of “vector.” The question “What is a vector?’ does not receive a unique answer. Rather, two answers are perhaps equally likely: “an arrow” or “a triplet of three numbers ( x , y, z).” The former answer could legitimately be called geometric, the latter algebraic. Yet the distinction between algebra and geometry is rarely unambiguous. For example, experience with the triplet ( x , y , z) was probably gained in a course with a title such as “Analytic Geometry” or “Coordinate Geometry.” For our purposes it will not be necessary to have an ironclad postulational basis for the mathematics to be employed, but it is important to have a general appreciation of the ideas. Again, that is a purpose of this chapter. Since the immediate goal is unlearning almost as much as learning, the reader should not expect to find a completely self-contained, unambiguous development from first principles. To make progress in physics, it is usually sufficient to have only an intuitive grasp of mathematical foundations. For example, the Pythagorean property of right-angle triangles is remembered even if its derivation from Euclidean axioms is not. Still, some mulling over of “well-established” ideas is appropriate, as they usually contain implicit understandings and definitions, possibly different for different individuals. Some of the meanings have to be discarded or modified as an “elementary” treatment metamorphoses into a more “abstract” formulation. Faced with this problem, a mathematician might prefer to “start from scratch,” discard all preconceived notions, define everything unambiguously, and proceed on a 35
36
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
firm postulational basis.‘ The physicist, on the other hand, is likely to find the mathematician’s approach too formal and poorly motivated. Unwilling to discard ideas that have served well, and too impatient or too inexperienced to follow abstract argument, when taking on new baggage, he or she prefers to rearrange the baggage already loaded, in an effort to make it all fit. The purpose of this chapter is to help with this rearrangement. Elaborating on the metaphor, some bags are to be removed from the trunk with the expectation they will fit better later, some fit as is, some have to be reoriented; only at the end does it become clear which fit and which must be left behind. While unloading bags it is not necessary to be fussy, when putting them back one has to be more careful. The analysis of spatial rotations has played a historically important part in the development of mechanics. In classical (both with the meaning nonrelativistic and the meaning “old-fashioned”) mechanics courses this has largely manifested itself in the analysis of rigid body motion. Problems in this area are among the most complicated for which the equations can be “integrated” in closed analytic form in spite of being inherently “nonlinear,”a fact that gives them a historical importance. But since these calculations are rather complicated, and since most people rapidly lose interest in, say, the eccentric motion of an asymmetric top, it has been fairly common, in the teaching of mechanics courses, to skim over this material. A “modern” presentation of mechanics has a much more qualitative and geometric flavor than the “old-fashioned” approach just mentioned. From this point of view, rather than being just a necessary evil encountered in the solution of hard problems, rotations are the easiest-to-understandprototype for the analysis of motion using abstract group theoretical methods. The connection between rotational symmetry and conservation of angular momentum, both because of its importance in quantum mechanics and again as a prototype, provides another motivation for studying rotations. It might be said that classical mechanics has been left mainly in the hands of mathematicians-physicists were otherwise occupied with quantum questions-for so long that the language has become nearly unintelligible to a physicist. Possibly unfamiliar words in the mathematician’s vocabulary include bivectors, multivectors, differential forms, dual spaces, Lie groups, irreducible representations, pseudoEuclidean metrics, and so on. Fortunately all physicists are handy with vector analysis, including the algebra of dot and cross products and the calculus of gradients, divergences, and curls, and in the area of tensor analysis they are familiar with covariant (contravariant)tensors as quantities with lower (upper) indices that (for example) conveniently keep track of the minus sign in the Minkowski metric of special relativity. Tools like these are much to be valued in that they permit a very compact, very satisfactory formulation of classical and relativistic mechanics, of electricity and magnetism, and of quantum mechanics. But they also leave a physicist’s mind unwilling to jettison certain “self-evident” truths that stand in the way of deeper levels of abstraction. Perhaps the simplest example of this is that, having treated ‘Perhaps the first treatment from first principles, and surely the most comprehensive text to base mechanics on the formal mathematical theory of smooth manifolds, was Abraham and Marsden, [l]. Other editions with new authors have followed.
PAIRS OF PLANES AS COVARIANT VECTORS
37
vector cross products as ordinary vectors for many years, one’s mind has difficulty adopting a mathematician’s view of cross products as being quite disimilar to, and certainly incommensurable with, ordinary vectors. Considerable effort will be devoted to motivating and explaining ideas like these in ways that are intended to appeal to a physicist’s intuition. Much of this material will be drawn from the work of Elie Cartan, which, though old, caters to a physicist’s intuition.* To begin with, covariant vectors will be introduced from various points of view and contrasted with the more familiar contravariant vectors.
2.2. PAIRS OF PLANES AS COVARIANT VECTORS The use of coordinates ( x , y , z)-shortly we will switch to ( x ’ , x 2 , x3)-for locating a point in space is illustrated in Fig. 2.2.1. Either orthonormal (Euclidean) or skew (Carte~ian)~ axes can be used. It is rarely required that skew axes be used rather than the simpler rectangular axes but, in the presence of continuous deformations, skew axes may be unavoidable. Next consider Fig. 2.2.2, which shows the intersections of a plane with the same axes as in Fig. 2.2.1. The equation of the plane on the left, in
FIGURE 2.2.1. Attaching coordinates to a point with Euclidean (or orthogonal) axes (on the left) and Cartesian (or possibly skew) axes (on the right). One of several possible interpretationsof the figure is that the figure on the right has been obtained by elastic deformation of the figure on the left. In that case the primes on the right are superfluous since the coordinates of any particular point (such as the point P) the same in both figures, namely (1, 1, 1). *Cartan is usually credited as being the “father” (though I think not the inventor) of differential forms as well as the discoverer of spinors (long before and in greater generality than) Pauli or Dirac. That these early chapters draw so much from Cartan simply reflects the lucidity of his approach. Don’t be intimidated by the appearance of spinors; only elementary aspects of them will be required. 3Many authors use the term “Cartesian”to imply orthogonal axes, but we use “Euclidean” in that case and use “Cartesian” to imply (possibly) skew axes.
38
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
FIGURE 2.2.2. Intersection of a plane with orthogonal axes on the left and a “similar“ figure with skew axes on the right. The equations of the planes are ‘the same:’ though expressed with unprimed and primed coordinates.
terms of generic point (x, y , z) on the plane, is ax
+ by + cz = d ,
(2.2.1)
and, because the coordinates of the intersections with the axes are the same, the equation of the plane on the right in terms of generic point (XI,y’,2 ’ ) is also linear, with the same coefficients (a, b, c , d ) , ax’
+ by‘ + cz‘ = d .
(2.2.2)
The figures are “similar,” not in the conventional sense of Euclidean geometry, but in a newly defined sense of lines corresponding to lines, planes to planes, and intersections to intersections and of the coordinates of the intersections of the plane and the axes being numerically the same. The unit measuring sticks along the Euclidean axes are ex, e y ,e,, and along the skew axes exl, eyt, e,!. The coordinates ( d / a ,d / b , d / c ) of the intersection points are determined by laying out the measuring sticks along the respective axes. Much as (x, y , z) “determines” a point, the values (a, b, c ) , along with d , “determine’’ a plane. Commonly the values ( x , y , z) are regarded as projections onto the axes of an arrow that is allowed to slide around the plane with length and direction held fixed. Similarly, any two planes sharing the same triplet (a, b, c) are parallel. (It would be wrong though to say that such planes have the same normals since, with the notion of orthogonality not yet having been introduced, there is no such thing as a vector normal to the plane. Saying that two planes have the same “direction” can only mean that they are parallel-that is, their intercepts are proportional.) The analogy between plane coordinates (a, b , c) and point coordinates ( x , y, z) is not quite perfect. For example, it takes the specification of a definite value d in
PAIRS OF PLANES AS COVARIANT VECTORS
ax+ b y =d
39
+1
ax
ax
\
+by= 0
FIGURE 2.2.3.
vector x crosses +3 line-pairs number of line-pairs crossed = a x + b y line-pair
Parallel planes. How many plane-pairs are crossed by vector x?
the equation for the plane to pick out a definite plane, while it takes three values, say the (xo, yo, zo) coordinates of the tail, to pick out a particular vector. Just as one regards ( x , y , z) as specifying a sliding vector, it is possible to define a “planerelated” geometric structure specified by ( a , b, c ) with no reference to d. To suppress the dependence on parameter d , observe first that the shift from d to d+ 1 corresponds to the shift from plane ax +by +cz = d to plane ax +by cz = d 1. Each member of this pair of unit-separated planes is parallel to any plane with the same (a, b, c ) values. The pair of planes is said to have an “orientation,’4 with positive orientation corresponding to increasing d. This is illustrated in Fig. 2.2.3.Since it is hard to draw planes, only lines are shown there, but the correspondence with Fig. 2.2.2 should be clear-and the ideas can be extended to higher dimensionality as well. In this way the triplet (a,b, c ) - o r ( a l ,a2, aj), a notation we will switch to shortly-stands for any oriented, unity-spaced pair of planes, both parallel to the plane through the origin ax by cz = 0. Without yet justifying the terminology we will call x a contravariant vector, even though this only makes sense if we regard x as an abbreviation for the three numbers ( x ’ , x 2 , x 3 ) ; it would be more precise to call x a true vector with contravariant components (x, y , z ) E ( X I , x 2 ,x 3 ), so that x E xlel +x2e2 + x 3 e 3 . In some cases, if it appears to be helpful, we will use the symbol 2, instead of just x, to emphasize
+
+
+ +
4The orientation of a pair of planes is said to be “outer.” The meaning of outer orientation is that two points related to each other by this orientation must be in sepamte planes. This can be contrasted to the inner orientation of a vector, by which two points can be related only if they lie in rhe same line parallel to x. An inner orientation for a plane would be a clockwise or counterclockwiseorientation of circulation within the plane. An outer orientation of a vector is a left- or right-handed screw-sense about the vector’s mow.
40
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 1: LINEAR
its contravariant vector nature. Also we symbolize by z, an object with components (a, b, c) = ( a l ,a2, as) that will be called c o v a r i ~ n t . ~ In Fig. 2.2.3 the (outer) orientation of two planes is indicated by an arrow (wavy to indicate that no definite vector is implied by it.) It is meaningful to say that contravariant vector x and covariant vector have the same orientation; it means that the arrow x points from the negative side of the plane toward the positive side. Other than being able to compare their orientations, is there any other meaningful geometric question that can be asked of x and Z? The answer is yes; the question is, “How many plane-pairs %doesx cross?” In Fig. 2.2.3 the answer is “3.” Is there any physics in this question and answer? The answer is yes again. Visualize the right plot of Fig. 2.2.3 as a topographical map, with the parallel lines being contours of equal elevation. (One is looking on a fine enough scale that the ground is essentially plane and the contours are straight and parallel.) The “trip” x entails a change of elevation of three units. This permits us to anticipate/demand that the following expressions (all equivalent)
s
(2.2.3) have an intrinsic, invariant significance, unaltered by deformations and transformations (if and when they are introduced.) This has defined a kind of “invariant x ) ~ of, ~a covariant and a contravariant vector. It has also introduced product”:, the repeated-index summation convention. This product is clearly related to the “dot product” of elementary vector analysis a . x, but that notation would be inappropriate at this point because nothing resembling an angle between vectors, or the cosine thereof, has been introduced. The geometric interpretation of the sum of two vectors as the arrow obtained by attaching the tail of one of the arrows to the tip of the other is well known. The geometric interpetationof the addition of covariant vectors is illustrated in Fig. 2.2.4. As usual, the natural application of a covariant vector is the determination of the number of plane-pairs crossed by a general contravariant vector. Notice that the lines %ew” notation is to be discouraged but, where there appears to be no universally agreed-to notation, our policy will be to choose symbols that cause formulas to look like elementary physics, even if their meanings are more general. The most important convention is that multicomponent objects are denoted by boldface symbols, as for example the vector x. This is more compact, though less expressive, than I?. Following Schutz [2], we use an overhead tilde to distinguish a one-form (or covariant vector, such as Z), from a (contravariant) vector, but we retain also the boldface symbol. The use of tildes to distinguish between covariant and contravariantquantitieswill break down when mixed quantities enter. Many mathematicians use no notational device at all to distinguish these quantities, and we will be forced to that when encountering mixed tensors. When it matters, the array of contravariant components will be regarded as a column vector and the array of covariant components as a row vector, but consistency in this regard is not guaranteed. 6The left-hand side of Eq. (2.2.3).being homogeneous in (x, y , z ) , is known as a “form” and, being first-order in the x i , as a “one-form:’ The notations n i x i , 6, x), and Z(x) are interchangeable. ’In this elementary context, the invariant significanceof Z(x) is utterly trivial, and yet when the same concept is introduced in the abstract context of tangent spaces and cotangent spaces, it can seem obscure (see, for example, Arnold, [ 1, p. 203, Fig. 1661).
41
PAIRS OF PLANES AS COVARIANTVECTORS
,
z
FIGURE 2.2.4. Geometric interpretation of the adgtion of covariant vectors, + E. The solid arrow crosses two of the g plane-pairs, one of the b plane-pairs, and hence three of the + b plane-pairs. Tips of the two dotted arrows necessarily lie on the same g b plane.
z
+ of Z + L are more closely spaced than the lines of either Z or L. The geometry of
this figure encapsulates tJe property that a general vector x crosses a number of planes belonging to Z b e T a l to the number of planes it crosses belonging to Z plus the number belonging to b. The reader should also pause to grasp the geometric interpretations of H - b and b - H. There are various ways of interpreting figures like Fig. 2.2.2. The way intended so far can be illustrated by an example. Suppose you have two maps of Colorado, one having lines of longitude and latitude plotted on a square grid, the other using some other scheme-say a globe. To get from one of these maps to the other, some distortion would be required, but one would not necessarily say there had been a coordinate transformation, as the latitude and longitude coordinates of any particular feature would be the same on both maps; call them ( x , y). One can consider the right figure of Fig. 2.2.2 to be the result of a deformation of the figure on the left-both the physical object (the plane or planes) and the reference axes have been deformedpreserving the coordinates of every particular feature. The map analog of the planes in Fig. 2.2.2 are the equal-elevation contours of the maps. By counting elevation contours one can, say, find the elevation of Pike’s Peak relative to Denver. (It would be necessary to break this particular trip into many small segments in order that the ground could be regarded as a perfect plane in each segment.) With local contours represented by Z(j) and local transverse displacements vectors by x ( i ) , the overall change in elevation is obtained by summing the contributions (X(j), x(i)) from each segment.* Clearly one will obtain the same result from both maps. This is a virtue of the form (X, x) . As stated previously, no coordinate transformation has yet occurred, but when one does, we will wish to preserve this feature-if x + x’ we will insist that Z + Z’ such that the value of the form is preserved. That’s an invariant. Fig. 2.2.2 can also be interpreted in terms of “transformations” either active or passive. The elements of this figure are redrawn in Fig. 2.2.5 but with origins superimposed. In part (a) the plane is “actively” shifted. Of course its intersections with the coordinate axes will now be different. The coefficients (covariant components) in the equation of the shifted plane expressed in terms of the original axes are al-
+
8As always in this text, subscripts (i) are enclosed in parentheses to protect against their being interpreted as vector indices. There is no implied summation over repeated parenthesized indices.
42
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR Z
FIGURE 2.2.5. “Active” (a) and “passive” (b) interpretationsof the relations between elements of Fig. 2.2.2 as transformations. In each case, though they were plotted separately in Fig. 2.2.2, the plots are here superimposed with common origin 0.
tered from their original values. The new coefficients are said to be the result of an active transformation in this case. Part (b) of Fig. 2.2.5 presents an alternative view of Fig. 2.2.2 as a “passive” change of coordinates. The plane is now unshifted but its covariant components are still transformed because of the different axes. Similar comments apply to the transformation properties of contravariant components9 From what has been stated previously, we must require the form (%,x) to be invariant under transformation. This is true whether the transformation is viewed actively or passively.
2.3. DIFFERENTIAL FORMS 2.3.1, Geometric Interpretation
There is a formalism which, though it seems curious at first, is in common use in modern mechanics. These so-called differentialforms will not be used in this chapter, but they are introduced at this point, after only a minimal amount of geometry has been introduced, in order to emphasize that the concepts involved are very general, independent of any geometry yet to be introduced. In particular there is no dependence on lengths, angles, or orthogonality. Since the new ideas can be adequately illustrated by considering functions of two variaJbles, x_and y, we simplify accordingly and define elementary differential forms dx and dy as functions (of a vector) ’While it is always clear that two possible interpretations exist, it is often difficult to understand which view is intended. A certain fuzziness as to whether an active or a passive view is intended is traditionala tradition this text will regrettably continue to respect. In many cases the issue is inessential, and in any case it has nothing to do with the contravariantlcovariant distinction.
DIFFERENTIAL FORMS
43
satisfying
these functions take displacement vector Ax = x - xo as argument and produce c_omponEntsAx = x - xo and Ay = y - yo as values.” A linear superposition of dx and d y with coefficients a and b is defined by” (a&
+ b&)(Ax) = a Ax + b Ay.
(2.3.2)
In practice Ax and Ay will always be infinitessimal quantities and the differentials will be part of a “linearized” or “first term in Taylor series” procedure. Consider a scalar function h ( x , y)-for concreteness let us take h ( x , y ) to be the elevation above sea level at location (x, y). By restricting oneself to a small enough region about some reference location (xo, yo), h ( x , y) can be linearized-i.e., approximated by a linear expansion
In the language of differential forms this same equation is written as
& = a d7U + b &,
(2.3.4)
where, evidently,
(2.3.5)
l h s shows that & is closely connected to the gradient of ordinary vector analysis. It is not the same thing, though, since the ordinary gradient is orthogonal to contours of constant h and the concept of orthogonality has not yet been introduced. Note that & is independent of h(x0, yo). (Neglecting availability of oxygen and dependence of g on geographic location, the difficulty of climbing a hill is independent of the elevation at its base.) Returning to the map of Colorado, imagine a trip made up of numerous path intervals x ( i ) . The change in elevation h(i) during the incremental path interval x ( i ) is given by
+
h(i) = a ( i ) x ( i ) b(i)y(i)= (a(i)&
u
+ b(i)dy)(x(i))= &i)(X(i)).
(2.3.6)
l’Though the value of a differential form acting on a vector is a real number, in general it is not a scalar. A possibly helpful mnemonic feature of the notation is that to produce a regular-face quantity from a boldface quantity r e q u F the Ese of another boldface quantity. “That the symbols dx and dy are no? ordinary di$erentials is indicated by the boldface type and the overhead tildes. They are being newly defined here. Unfortunately, a more common notation is to represent a differential form simply as d x ; with this notation it is necessary to distinguish by context between differential forms and ordinary differentials. A converse ambiguky in our terminology is that it may not be clear whether the term differentialform means adx bdy or dh.
+
44
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 1: LINEAR
Since this equation resembles Eq.(2.2.3),it can also be written as h(i) = (&),
x(i)).
(2.3.7)
The total change of elevation, h, can be obtained by summing over the incremental paths: (2.3.8) 1
As usual, such a summation becomes an integral in the limit of small steps
h=
lE(&
(2.3.9)
dx);
the lower and upper limits of integration correspond to the beginning B and end E of the trip. Though the notation is highly abbreviated, it has an unambiguous, coordinate-free meaning that makes it clear that the result is invariant, in the sense discussed above. The formula has a seeming excess of differentials but, when expanded in components, it takes on a more customary appearance: rE
h=
jB (a(x) d x + b ( x ) d y ) .
(2.3.10)
Example 2.3.1: Three points Pi, i = 1,2, 3, with coordinates ( x ( i ) ,y ( i ) ,q j ) ) , are fixed in ordinary space. (1) Dividing Eq. (2.2.1) by d , find the coefficients in the equation a d
b d
x- + y - +z-
c =1 d
(2.3.1 1)
of the plane passing tkough the points. (2) Defining h ( x , y ) as the elevation z at point (x, y ) , evaluate dh at the point P I . (3) For a general point P whose horizontal displacements relative to PI are given by ( A x = x - ~ ( 1 1 ,A y = y - y(1)),find its elevation Ah = z - z(1) relative to P I . SOLUTION: (a) Ratios of the coefficients ( a ,b, c, d ) are obtained by substituting the known points into Eq. (2.3.11) and inverting:
(":) = (i;:) (:::; c:: ;:)-' =
C'
c/d
X(3)
Y(3)
Z(3)
(i)
.
(2.3.12)
(b) Replacing z by h and defining hl = d/c - ( a / c ) x ( l ) - ( b / c ) y ( l ) ,Eq. (2.3.3) becomes a b h ( x , Y ) = hl - - ( x - X ( 1 ) ) - -(Y - Y ( 1 ) ) . C
C
DIFFERENTIAL FORMS
45
Since the ratios a'/c' and b'/c' are available from Eq.(2.3.12), the required (2.3.4): differential form is given by
a.
-
-
a' b' dh = - - d ~ - -dy. N
C'
a' Ah = - - A X C'
C'
b'
- -Ay. C'
Problem 2.3.1: (a) For points P I , P2, P3 given by (l,O,O), (O,l,O), (O,O,l), check the formula just derived for A h by applying it to each of P I , P2, and P3. (b) The coordinates of three well-known locations in Colorado, Denver, Pike's Peak, and Colorado Springs, are, respectively, W. longitudes 105.1°, 105.1°, and 104.8'; N. latitudes 39.7', 38.8', and 38.8'; and elevations 5280 feet, 14,100 feet, and 5280 feet. Making the (thoroughly unwarranted) assumption that the town of Golden, situated at 105.2'W, 39.7"N, lies on the plane defined by the previous three locations, find its elevation. At this point we can anticipate one implication of these results for mechanics. Recall the connection between elevation h and potential energy U = mgh in the earth's gravitational field. Also recall the connection between work W and potential energy U . To make the equation traditionally expressed as A U = A W = F . Ax meaningful, the vectorial character of force F has to differ from that of the displacement Ax. In particular, since Ax is a contravariant vector, the force F should be a covariant vector (meaning its symbol should be F) for the work to be coordinate independent. In the traditional pedagogy of physics, covariant and contravariant vectors are usually differentiated on the basis of the behavior of their components under coordinate transformations. Note, though, that in our discussion the quantities g and x have been introduced and distinguished, and meaning was assigned to the form 6,x) before any change of coordinates has even been contemplated. This, so far, is the essential relationship between covariant and contravariant vectors. l 2 Since the ideas expressed so far, though not difficult, may seem unfamiliar, recapitulation in slightly different terms may be helpful. It has been found useful to associate contravariant vectors with independent variables, like x and y, and covariant vectors (or one-fonns) with dependent variables, like h . Knowing h ( x , y ) . one can prepare a series of contours of constant h, separated from each other by one unit '*Because the components of vectors vary in such a way as to preserve scalar invariants, a common though somewhat archaic terminology refers to vectors as invarianrs or as invariant vectors, in spite of the facts that (1) their components vary and (2) the expression is redundant anyway. (Note especially that invariant here does not mean constant.) Nowadays the term tensor automatically carries this connotation of invariance. In special relativity the phrase manifestly covariant (or simply covariant) means the same thing, but this is a different (though related) meaning of our word covarianr. Our policy, whenever the invariant aspect is to be specially emphasized, is to use the term true vector, even though it is redundant.
46
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
of “elevation,” and plot them on the (x, y ) plane. For a (defined by a contravariant vector) change (Ax, A y ) in independent variables, by counting the number of contours (defined by a covariant vector) crossed, the change in dependent variable can be determined. We have been led to a somewhat unconventional and cumbersome notation (with d7U being the function that picks out the x-component of an arbitrary vector) so that the symbol dx can retain its traditional physics meaning as an infinitesimal deviation of x. In mathematical literature the symbol dx all by itself typically stands for a differential one-form. Furthermore, we have so far only mentioned one-forms. When a two-form such as dx d y is introduced in mathematical literature, it is taken implicitly (roughly speaking) to pick out the area defined by dx and d y rather than the product of two infinitesimals. We will return to these definitions shortly. There is an important potential source of ambiguity in traditional discussion of mechanics by physicists and it is one of the reasons mathematicians prefer different terminology for differentials: a symbol such as x is used to stand both for where a particle is and where it could conceivably be.13 This is arguably made clearer by mathematician’s notation. Since we wish to maintain physics usage (not to defend it, only to make formulas look familiar) we will use differential forms as much to demystify them as to exploit their power.
2.3.2. Examples Illustratingthe Calculus of Differential Forms Even more than the previous section, since the material in this section will not be required for some time, the reader might be well-advised only to skim over it, planning to address it more carefully later-not because the material is difficult but because its motivation may be unclear. Furthennore the notation here will be far from standard as we attempt to metamorphose from old-fashioned notation to more modem notation. (In any case, since there is no universally accepted notation for this material, it is impossible to use “standard” notation.) For the same reason, there may seem to be inconsistencieseven internal to this section. All this is a consequence mainly of our izsistence on maintaining a distinction between two types of “differential,” dx and dx. Eventually, once the important points have been made, it will be possible to shed some of the notational complexity. A notation we will use temporarily for a differential form such as the one defined in Eq. (2.3.4) is
+
G[dl = f ( x , Y )ZX g(x, Y )&.
(2.3.13)
The only purpose of the “argument” din square brackets here is to correlate i 3 with the particular coordingte diffcentials dx and as contrasted, say, with two independent differentials 6x and 6y:
&,
I3If constraints are present x can also stand for a location where the mass could not conceivably be.
DIFFERENTIAL FORMS
47
The S symbol does not signify some kind of differential operator other than d ; it simply allows notationally for the later assignment of independent values to the differently named differentials. Square brackets are used to protect against interpretation of d or S as an ordinary argument of G. One can develop a calculus of such differential forms. Initially we proceed to do this by treating the differentials as if they were the “old-fashioned” type familiar from physics and freshman calculus. Notationally we indicate this by leaving off the overhead tildes and not using boldface symbols; hence w[dl = f ( x , Y ) dx
+ g ( x , Y )d y .
(2.3.15)
The differential Sw[d] = S(w[d])is defined by
(2.3.16) Since these are ordinary differentials, if f and g were force components, Sw[d] would be the answer to the question, “How much more work is done in displacement ( d x , d y ) from displaced location P SP = (x Sx, y Sy) than is done in displacement ( d x , d y ) from point P = ( x , y)?’ S o [ d ] is not the same as dw[S] but, from the two, the combination
+
+
B.C.[w]
+
Sw[d] - dw[S],
(2.3.17)
can be formed; it is to be known as the “bilinear covariant” of w. After further manipulation it will yield the “exterior derivative” of w .
Example 2.3.2: Consider the example w [ d ] = y dx
+x dy.
(2.3.18)
Substituting into Eq. (2.3.16),we obtain Sw[d] = Sy dx
+ SX d y ,
dw[S] = d y S X
+ dx Sy.
(2.3.19)
Notice, in this case, that the bilinear covariant vanishes, h [ d ] - d o [ & ]= 0.
This is not always true, however; operating with d and operating with S do not “commute”-that is, 6w[d]and d o [ S ] are different. But products such as d x Sy and 6 y dx are the same; they are simply the products of two (a physicist might say tiny) independently assignable coordinate increments.When its bilinear covariant does, in fact, vanish, w is said to be “closed.” In the case of Eq. (2.3.18), w[d] is “derivable from” a function of position h ( x , y ) = xy according to w [ d ] = dh(x, y ) = y dx
+x dy.
(2.3.20)
48
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
In this circumstance (of being derivable from a single-valued function), o is said to be “an exact differential.” Problem2.3.2: Show that the bilinear covariant B.C.[o] of the differential oneform, w [ d ] = d h ( x , y ) . vanishes for arbitrary function h ( x , y ) .
Example 2.3.3: For the differential form w [ d ]= y d x ,
(2.3.21)
one sees that
h [ d ] - dw[S] = Sy dx - d y SX, which does not vanish. But if we differentiate once again (introducing D as yet another symbol to indicate a differential operator) we obtain D(Sy dx - d y SX) = 0,
since the coefficients of the differentials being differentiated are now simply constants.
Problem 2.3.3: For o [ d ]given by Eq. (2.3.15),with f ( x , y ) and g(n,y) being general functions, show that its bilinear covariant does not vanish in general. We have been proceeding as if our differentials were “ordinary,” but to be consistent with our “new” notation Eq.(2.3.16) should have been written
with the result being a two-form-a function of two vectors, say A x ( l ) and Ax(2). Applying Eq. (2.3.1),this equation leads to
Except for the renaming of symbols, Sx + Ax(1),d x + AxQ), Sy -+ Ay(l),and d y + Ay(2),this is the same as Eq. (2.3.16). Hence, though the original symbols had different meanings, Eqs. (2.3.16) and (2.3.22)have equivalent content. For this to be true we have implicitly assumed that the first of the two arguments Ax(1) and Ax(2)is acted on by the 6differential form and the second by the d form. Since these appear in the same order in every term we could as well say that the first form acts on A x ( [ )and the second on Ax(2).Furthermore, since Eq. (2.3.13) made no distinction
DIFFERENTIAL FORMS
49
between S and d forms, we might as well have written Eq. (2.3.22) as
&:(
Cj[dl[d] =
+
(2.3.24)
as long as it were understood that in a product of two differential forms the first acts on the first argument and the second on the second. Note though that in spite of the fact that it is legitimate to reverse the order in a product of actual displacementEli&e Ax(l)Ay(z),it is illegitimate to reverse the order of the terms in a product like dxdy; that is,
&& # Zy&.
(2.3.25)
The failure to commute of our quantities, which will play such an important role in the sequel, has entered here as a simple consequence of our notational convention specifying the meaning of the differential of a differential. How then to express the bilinear covariant, without using the distinction between d and S? Instead of antisymmetrizingwith respect to d and S, we can antisymmetrize with respect to the arguments. A “new notation” version of Eq. (2.3.17), with C j still given by Eq. (2.3.13), can be written
This can be reexpressed by defining the “wedge product” &A&
= && - &&.
(2.3.27)
&,
(2.3.28)
Note from its definition, that
& A & = -gy
A
and zx A gx = 0.
We obtain (2.3.29) which can be substituted into Eq.(2.3.26). Since the arbitrary increments Ax(1) and Ax(2) then appear as common arguments on both sides of Eq. (2.3.26) they can be suppressed as we define a two-form E.D.[Z], which is B.C.[Z](AX(I),Ax(2)) with its arguments unevaluated: (2.3.30)
50
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
When operating on any two vector increments,E.D.[&]generates the bilinear covariant of & evaluated for the two vectors. This newly defined differential two-form is known as the “exterior differential” of the differential one-form G.From here on this will be written ad 4
(2.3.31) Note that this relation is consistent with the rule d(f&) = ZfAZX. The vectors Ax(1) and Axp) can be said to have played only a “catalytic” role in the definition of the exterior derivative since they no longer appear in Eq.(2.3.31). From its appearance, one might guess that the exterior derivative is related to the curl operator of vector analysis. This is to be pursued next.
2.3.3. Connections between Differential Forms and Vector Calculus Like nails and screws, the calculus of vectors and the calculus of differential forms can be regarded as essentially similar or as essentially different depending on one’s point of view. Both can be used to hold physical theories together. A skillful carpenter can hammer together much of a house while the cabinet maker is still drilling the holes in the kitchen cabinets. Similarly the physicist can derive and solve Maxwell’s equations using vector analysis while the mathematician is still tooling up the differential form machinery. The fact is, though, that some structures cannot be held together with nails and some mechanical systems cannot be analyzed without differential forms. There is a spectrum of levels of ability in the use of vectors, starting from no knowledge whatsoever, advancing through vector algebra, to an understanding of gradients, curls, and divergences, to a skillful facility with the methods. The corresponding spectrum is even broader for differential forms, which can be used to solve all the problems that vectors can solve plus others as well. In spite of this, most physicists remain at the “no knowledge whatsoever” end of the spectrum. This is perhaps partly due to some inherent advantage of simplicity that vectors have for solving the most commonly encountered problems of physics, but the accidents of pedagogical fashion probably also play a role. According to Arnold, in Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics (1989), “Hamiltonian mechanics cannot be understood without differential form^."'^ It behooves us therefore to make a start on this subject. But in this text only a fairly superficial treatment will be included (the rationale being that the important and hard thing is to get the general idea, but that following specialized texts is not so difficult once one has the general idea). The whole of advanced calculus can be formulated in terms of differential forms, as can more advanced topics, and there are several texts I4The notation of Eq. (2.3.31) is still considerably bulkier than is standard in the literature of differential forms. There, the quantity (exterior derivative) that we have called E.D.[G] is often expressed simply as d o , andEq. (2.3.31)becomesdo = (-af/ay+ag/ax) d x h d y o r e v e n d o = (-af/ay+ag/ax)dxdy. I5It might be more accurate to say that “without differentialforms one cannot understand Hamiltonian mechanics as well as Arnold,” but this statement would be true with or without differential forms.
DIFFERENTIAL FORMS
51
concentrating narrowly yet accessibly on these subjects. Here we are more interested in giving the general ideas than in either rigorous mathematical proof or practice with the combinatorics that are needed to make the method compete with vector analysis in compactness. The purpose of this section is to show how formulas that are (assumed to be) already known from vector calculus can be expressed using differential forms. Since these results are known, it will not be necessary to prove them in the context of differential forms. This will permit the following discussion to be entirely formal, its only purpose being to show that definitions and relations being introduced are consistent with results already known. We work only with ordinary, three-dimensional, Euclidean geometry, using rectangular coordinates. It is far from true that the validity of differential forms is restricted to this domain, but our purpose is only to motivate the basic definitions. One way that Eq. (2.3.13) can be generalized is to go from two to three dimensions: $1)
= f ( x , y , z) dux
+ g(xt y , z) & + h ( x , y . z) &,
where the superscript (1) indicates that leading to Eq. (2.3.31) yield
(2.3.32)
is a one-form. Calculations like those
Next let us generalize Eq. (2.3.27) by defining
(2.3.34)
& A & A &(Ax(l), AX(^), Ax(3)) = det
4 1 )
Ay(l)
AX(2) 4 3 ) Ay(2) Ay(3)
.
(2.3.35)
where the superscript (2) indicates that Zi(2) is a two-form. At first glance this may seem to be a rather ad hoc and special form, but any two-form that is antisymmetric in its two arguments can be expressed this way.16 We then define the exterior 161n most treatments of differential forms the phrase “antisymmetric two-form” would be considered redundant, since “two-forms” would have already been defined to be antisymmetric.
52
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
differential,
These definitions are only special cases of more general definitions, but they are all we require for now. From Eq. (2.3.37),using Eqs. (2.3.28), we obtain
(2.3.38) Let us recapitulate the formulas that have been derived, but using notation for the coefficients that is more suggestive than the functions f ( x , y, z), g ( x , y , z ) , and h ( x , y, z) used so far.
Then Eqs. (2.3.4),(2.3.33), and (2.3.38) become
-
d
a4-
= -dX
ax
a++ -a$d y + -dZ, aY az
2
+ (--+-
3;)-
-
dZAdx,
(2.3.40) We can now write certain familiar equations as equations satisfied by differential forms. For example,
--
d d2) = 0, is equivalent to
V B = 0.
(2.3.41)
a
The three-form zG(2) is “waiting to be evaluated” on coordinate increments as in Eq. (2.3.32);this includes the “Jacobean factor” in a volume integration of V .B. The = 0 therefore represents the “divergence-free” ngure of the vector B. equation d While V . B is the integrand in the integral form of this law, d includes also the Jacobean factor in the same integral. When, as here, orthonormal coordinates are used as the variables of integration, this extra factor is trivially equal to 1, but in other coordinates the distinction is more substantial. However, since the Jacobean factor cannot vanish, it cannot influence the vanishing of the integrand. This discussion of integrands is expanded upon in Section 4.2. Here are some other examples of familiar equations expressed using differential forms:
z(2)
z(2)
53
DIFFERENTIAL FORMS N
= -d$O) , equivalent to E = -Vd,
&(I)
(2.3.42)
yields the “electric field” as the (negative) gradient of the potential. Also
Z P = 0,
v x E = 0,
equivalent to
(2.3.43)
states that E is “irrotational” (that is, the curl of E vanishes). The examples given so far have been applicable only to time-independent problems such as electrostatics. But let us define $’)
= [J,(x, y, z, t)&
& + J y ( x ,y , z, t)& A & + Jz(X, A &’ A &.
A
- p(X, y, Z, t)&
y, z, t)&
A
&‘]
A
&
(2.3.44)
Then
Zcj‘’)
= o is equivalent to
aP v x J+= 0, at
(2.3.45)
which is known as the “continuity equation.” In physics such relations relate “fluxes” and “densities.” This is developed further in Section 4.4.2. Another familiar equation can be obtained by defining
~ ( l ) = ~ , & + ~ , & + ~ , & - ~ & . (2.3.46) Then the equation
(2.3.47) is equivalent to the pair of equations
B=VxA,
aA E=---Vd. at
(2.3.48)
These examples show that familiar vector equations can be reexpressed as equations satisfied by differential forms. All these equations are developed further in Chapter 12. The full analogy between forms and vectors, in particular including cross products, requires the introduction of “supplementary” multivectors, also known as “the star (*) operation.” This theory is developed in Section 4.2.4. What are the features of these newly introduced differential forms derived by exterior differentiation? We state some of them, without proof for now. 0 The forms derived in this way inevitably find themselves acting as the “differential elements” of multidimensionalintegrals. When one recalls two of the important difficulties in formulating multidimensionalintegrals, evaluating the appropriate Jacobian and keeping track of sign reversals, one will be happy to know that these exterior derivatives “take care of hoth problems.” The true power of the exterior derivatives is that this formalism works for spaces of arbitrary di-
54
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
0
0
0
0
mension, though formidable combinatorial calculations may be necessary. We will return to this subject in Sections 4.3.2 and 4.4. The differential forms “factor out” the arbitrary incremental displacements, such as Ax(1) and Ax(2) in the above discussion, leaving them implicit rather than explicit. This overcomes the inelegant need for introducing different differential symbols such as d and 6. Though this feature is not particularly hard to graspit has been thoroughly expounded upon here-not being part of the traditional curriculum encountered by scientists, it is what causes the equations to have an unfamiliar appearance. The quantities entering the equations of physics such as Maxwell’s equations are, traditionally, physically measurable vectors, such as electric field E, that are naturally visualized as arrows. When writte2 i t terms of forms, invariant combinations of forms and vectors, such as (E, Ax), more naturally occur. Something resembling this observation has no doubt already been encountered in sophomore electricity and magnetism. Traditionally, after first encountering Maxwell’s equations in integral form, one uses vector analysis to transform them into relations among curls and divergences relating space and time derivatives of the electric and magnetic quantities. Though the differential versions of Maxwell’s equations fit more neatly on tee shirts, the integral_ver_sionsare just as fundamental; their integrands are invariant products like (E, Ax). It is only when the differential versions of these equations are expressed in terms of exterior derivatives instead of curls and divergences that they acquire an unfamiliar appearance. By far the most fundamental property of the calculus of differential forms is that they make the equations manifestly invariant, that is, independent of coordinates. Of course this is also the chief merit of the vector operators, gradient, divergence, and curl. Remembering the obscurity surrounding these operators when they were first encountered (some of which perhaps still lingers in the case of curl), one has to anticipate a considerable degree of difficulty in generalizing these concepts-which is what the differential forms do. In this section only a small start has been made toward establishing this invariance; the operations of vector differentiation, known within vector analysis to have invariant character, have been expressed by differential forms. Having said all this, it should also be recognized that the differential forms really amount to being just a sophisticated form of advanced calculus.
2.4. ALGEBRAIC TENSORS 2.4.1. Vectors and Their Duals In traditional physics (unless one includes graphical design) there is little need for geometry without algebra-synthetic geometry-but algebra without geometry is both possible and important. Though vector and tensor analysis were both motivated initially by geometry, it is useful to isolate their purely algebraic aspects. Everything
ALGEBRAIC TENSORS
55
that has been discussed so far can be distilled into pure algebra. That will be done in this section, though in far less generality than in the references listed at the end of the chapter. Van der Waerden 141allows numbers more general than the real numbers we need; Arnold [3] pushes further into differential forms. Most of the algebraic properties of vector spaces are “obvious” to most physicists. Vectors x , y, etc., are quantities for which superposition is valid-for scalars a and b, ax by is also a vector. The dimensionality n of the vector space containing x, y, etc., is the largest number of independent vectors that can be selected. Any vector can be expanded uniquely in terms of n independent basis vectors e l , e2, . . ., en;
+
x = eix’.
(2.4.1)
This provides a one-to-one relationship between vectors x and n-component multiplets ( X I , x 2 , . . . ,xn)-for now at least, we will say they are the same thing.I7 In particular, the basis vectors el, e ~. .,. , e,, correspond to (1 , 0, . .. , 0),(0, 1, . . . ,0 ) ,. . . , (0,0, . . ., 1). Component-wise addition of vectors and multiplication by a scalar is standard. hportant new content is introduced when one defines a real-valued linearfunction f ( x ) of a vector x ; such a function, by definition, satisfies relations
Expanding x in basis vectors ei, this yields
-f ( x ) = fi x’ = (f, x ) , .
-
where
-
fi = f(ei).
(2.4.3)
This exhibits the value of?(x) as a linearform in the components x i with coeifficients fi. Now we have a one-to-one correspondence between linear functions f and ncomponent multiplets (fl, f2, . . . , fn). Using language in the loose fashion often applied to vectors, we can say that a linear function of a vectz and a linear form in the vector’s components are the same thing though, unlike f , the fi depend on the choice of basis vectors. This space of linear functions of vectors in the original space is called dual to the original space. With vectors in the original space called contravariant, vectors in the dual space are called covariant. Corresponding to basis vectors ei in the original space there is a natural choice of basis vectors 3 in the dual space. When acting on ei, 3 yields 1; when acting on any other of the ej it yields 0. Just as the components of el are (1, 0, . . . , 0) the components of Z’ are (1, 0, . . ., 0). and so on. More concisely,18 7‘
e (ej)=
(2.4.4)
l7 As long as possible we will stick to the colloquial elementary physics usage of refusing to distinguish between a vector and its collection of components,even though the latter depends on the choice of basis vectors while the former does not. ‘*There is no immediate significance to the fact that one 01 the indices of 6;. is written as a subscript 1 and one as a superscript. Equal to 6ij, 6’j is also a Kronecker-6.
56
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICSI: LINEAR
By taking all linear combinations of a subset of the basis vectors, say the first m of them, where 0 < m < n, one forms a sub-vector-space S of the original space. Any vector x in the whole space can be decomposed uniquely into a vector y= eixi in this space and a vector z = eixi. A “projection operator” P onto the subspace can then be defined by y = Px. It has the property that Pz = P. Since x = P x (1 - P)x, z = (1 - P)x and 1 - P projects onto the space formed from the last n - m basis vectors. There is a subspace 9 in the dual space, known as the “annihilator” of S; it is the vector space made up of all linear combinations of the n - m forms P+’,P s 2 .,.., p .These are the last n - m of the natural basis forms in the dual space, as listed in Eq. (2.4.4).Any form in So “annihilates” any vector in S, which is to say yields zero when acting on the vector. This relationship is reciprocal in that S annihilatesSo.Certainly there are particular forms not in Sothat annihilate certain vectors in S, but So contains all forms, and only those forms, that annihilate all vectors in S. This concept of annihilation is reminiscent of the concept of the orthogonality of two vectors in ordinary vector geometry. It is a very different concept, however, since annihilation relates a vector in the original space and a form in the dual space; an arrow in S such as el crosses no planes corresponding to a form in SO such as Em+’. Only if there is a rule associating vectors and forms can annihilation be used to define orthogonality of two vectors in the same space. By introducing linear functions of more than one vector variable we will shortly arrive at the definition of tensors. However, since all other tensors are introduced in the same way as was the dual space, there is no point in proceeding to this definition without first having grasped the concept of the dual space. Toward that end we should eliminate an apparent asymmetry between contravariant vectors and covectors. This asymmetry has resulted from the fact that we starred with contravariant vectors, and hence might be inclined to think of them as more basic. But consider the space of linear functions of covariant vectors-that is, the space that is dual to the space that is dual to the original space. (As an exercise) it can be seen that the dual of the dual is the same thing as the original space. Hence, algebraically at least, which is which between contravariant and covariant vectors is entirely artificial, just like the choice of which is to be designated by superscripts and which by subscripts.
xy
Cm+,
+
2.4.2. Transformationof Coordinates When covariant and contravariant vectors are introduced in physics, the distinction between them is usually expressed in terms of the matrices accompanying a change of basis vectors. Suppose a new set of basis vectors e‘j is related to the original set ej by (2.4.5)
(If one insists on interpreting this relation as a matrix multiplication, it is necessary to regard e’j and ej as being the elements of row vectors, even though the row elements are vectors rather than numbers, and to ignore the distinction between upper and
ALGEBRAIC TENSORS
57
lower in dice^.)'^ Multiplying on the right by the inverse matrix, the inverse relation is (2.4.6)
For formal manipulation of formulas, the index conventions of tensor analysis are simple and reliable, but for numerical calculations it is sometimes convenient to use matrix notation in which multicomponent objects are introduced so that the indices can be suppressed. This is especially useful when using a computer language that can work with matrices as supported types that satisfy their own algebra of addition, multiplication, and scalar multiplication. To begin the attempt to represent the formulas of mechanics in matrix form, some recommended usage conventions will now be formulated, and some of the difficulties in maintaining consistency will be explicitly addressed. Already, in defining the symbols used in Eq. (2.4.5), a conventional choice was made. The new basis vectors were called e’j when they could have been called e j ‘ ; that is, the prime was placed on the vector symbol rather than on the index. It is a common, and quite powerful notation, to introduce both of these symbols and to use them to express two distinct meanings. (See for example Schutz.) In this notation, even as one “instantiates” an index, say replacing i by 1, one must replace i’ by l’, thereby distinguishing between el and elf.In this way, at the cost of further abstraction, one can distinguish change of axes with fixed vector from change of vector with fixed axes. At this point this may seem like pedantry, but confusion attending this distinction between active and passive interpretations of transformations will dog us throughout this text and the subject in general. One will always attempt to define quantities and operations unambiguously in English, but everyday language is by no means optimal for avoiding ambiguity. Mathematical language, such as the distinction between el and ell just mentioned, can be much more precise. But, sophisticated as it is, we will nor use this notation, because it seems too compact, roo mathematical, too cryptic. Another limitation of matrix notation is that, though it works well for tensors of one or two indices, it is not easily adapted to tensors with more than two indices. Yet another complication follows from the traditional row and column index-order conventions of matrix formalism. It is hard to maintain these features while preserving other desirable features such as lower and upper indices to distinguish between covariant and contravariant quantities, which, with the repeated-index summation convention, yield very compact formulas.20 Often, though, one can restrict calcula‘’Since our convention is that the up/down location of indices on matrices is irrelevant, Eq. (2.4.5) is the same as e’. = ei A i j . This in turn is the same as ei = ( A * ) i , e j , which may seem like a more natural J ordering. But one sees that whether it is the matrix or its transpose that is said to be the transformation matrix depends on whether it multiplies on the left or on the right and is not otherwise significant. *‘The repeated-indexconvention is itself used fairly loosely. For example, if the summation convention is used as in Eq. (2.4.5) to express a vector as a superposition of basis vectors, the usage amounts to a simple abbreviation without deeper significance. But when used (as it was by Einstein originally) to form a scalar from a contravariant and a covariant vector, the notation includes a deeper implication of invariance. In this text both of these conventions will be used, but for other summations, such as over particles in a system, the summation symbol will be shown explicitly.
58
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
tions to a single frame of reference and, in that case, there is no need to distinguish between lower and upper indices. When the subject of vector fields is introduced, an even more serious notational complication will arise because a new kind of “multiplication” of one vector by another will be noncommutative. As a result, the validity of an equation such as AX)^ = xTAT is called into question. One is already accustomed to matrix multiplication being noncommutative, but the failure of vector fields to commute will seriously compromise the power of matrix notation and the usefulness of distinguishing between row and column vectors. In spite of all these problems, matrix formulas will still often be used, and when they are, the following - conventions will be adhered to: As is traditional, contravariant components X I ,x 2 , . . . , x” are arrayed as a column vector. This leads to the remaining conventions in this list. (Covariant)components fi of form fare to be arrayed in a row. The basis vectors ei, though not components of an intrinsic quantity, will be arrayed as a row for purposes of matrix multiplication. Basis covectors3 will be arrayed in a column. Notations such as will not be used; the indices on components are necessarily 1 , 2 , 3 ,. . . . Symbolic indices with primes, as in x,l are, however, legitimate. The indices on a quantity like h i j are spaced apart to make it unambiguous which is to be taken as the row, in this case i , and which as the column index. The up/down location is to be ignored when matrix multiplicationis being employed. In terms of the new basis vectors introduced by Eq. (2.4.5), using Fq. (2.4.6), a general vector x is reexpressed as
-
e’jxl’
= x = ekxk = e‘j(12-i ) ik x k ,
(2.4.7)
from which it follows that ,Ii
= (A-l)j kx k .
(2.4.8)
Because the matrix giving x i --f xi’ is inverse to the matrix giving ei -+ e’i, this is known conventionally as contravariant transformation. If the column of elements x’j and x k are symbolized by x’ and x and the matrix by A-‘, then Eq. (2.4.8)becomes XI
= A-’x.
(2.4.9)
When boldface symbols are used to represent vectors in vector analysis, the notation implies that the boldface quantities have an invariant geometric character, and in this context an equation like (2.4.9) might by analogy be expected to relate two different “arrows” x and XI.The present boldface quantities have not been shown to have this geometric character and, in fact, they do not. As they have been introduced, since x and x’ stand for the same geometric quantity, it is redundant to give them different symbols. This is an instance of the above-mentioned ambiguity in specifying
ALGEBRAIC TENSORS
59
transformations. Our notation is simply not powerful enough to distinguish between active and passive transformations in the same context. For now we ignore this redundancy and regard Eq. (2.4.9) as simply an abbreviated notation for the algebraic relation between the components. Since this notation is standard in linear algebra, it should be acceptable here once the potential for misinterpretation has been understood. Transformation of_covariant components fi has to be arranged to secure the invariance of the form (f,x ) defined in Eq.(2.4.3). Using Eq.(2.4.8) (2.4.10) and from this fk
= fj(A-‘)jk
Or
f ; = f j A ik .
(2.4.1 1)
This is known as covariant transformation because the matrix is the same as the matrix A with which basis vectors transform. The only remaining case to be considered is the transformation of basis one-forms; clearly they transform with A-’ . Consider next the effect of following one transformation by another. The matrix representing this “composition” of two transformations is known as the “concatenation” of the individual matrices. Calling these matrices A1 and 6 2 , the concatenated matrix A can be obtained by successive applications of Eq. (2.4.9): (2.4.12) This result has used the fact that the2ontravariant components are arrayed as a column vector. On the other hand, with f regarded as a row vector of covariant components, Eq. (2.4.1 1) yields
f7/ =?A1 A2, or A = A l A , .
(2.4.13)
It may seem curious that the order of matrix multiplications can be opposite for “the same” sequence of transformations, but the result simply reflects the distinction between covariant and contravariant quantities. Since general matrices A and B satisfy (AB)-’ = B-IA-’, the simultaneous validity of Eq. (2.4.12) and Eq. (2.4.13) can be regarded as mere self-consistency of the requirement that @, x ) be invariant. The transformationsjust considered have been passive, in that basis vectors were changed but the physical quantities were not. Commonly in mechanics, and even more so in optics, one encounters active linear transformations that instead describe honest-to-goodness evolution of a physical system. If the configuration at time tl is described by x ( t l ) and at a later time ?2 by x(t2). linear evolution is described by
and the equations of this section have to be reinterpreted appropriately.
60
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
2.4.3. Transformationof Distributions
Often one wishes to evolve not just one particle in the way just mentioned, but rather an entire ensemble or distribution of particles. Suppose that the distribution, call it p ( x ) . has the property that all particles lie in the same plane at time t i . Such a distribution could be expressed as $ ( x ) 3 ( a x + by cz - d), where 6 is the Dirac &-“function”with argument which, when set to zero, gives the equation of the plane. (For simplicity set d = 0.) Let us ignore the distribution within the plane (described by b(x)) and pay attention only to the most noteworthy feature of this ensemble of points, namely the plane itself and how it evolves. If x(1) is the displacement vector of a generic particle at an initial time t(l), then initially the plane is described by an equation
+
f(l)ix’ = 0.
(2.4.15)
For each of the particles, setting x i = xll) in Eq. (2.4.15)results in an equality. Let us call the coefficients f(1)i“distribution parameters” at time f1 since they characterize the region containing the particles at that time. Suppose that the system evolves in such a way that the individual particle coordinates are transformed (linearly) to xi2). and then to x i 3 ) , according to
(2.4.16) With each particle having been subjected to this transformation,the question is, what is the final distribution of particles? Since the particles began on the same plane initially and the transformations have been linear, it is clear they will lie on the same plane finally. We wish to find that plane, which is to say to find the coefficients f(3)k in the equation f(3)k X k = 0.
(2.4.17)
This equation must be satisfied by xt3, as given by Eq. (2.4.16),and this yields k if(3)k (BA)i x - 0.
(2.4.18)
It follows that f(3)k
1
= f(l)i((BA)-l)ik = f(l)i(A-B
-1
i
k.
(2.4.19)
This shows that the coefficients fi describing a distribution of particles transform covariantly when individual particle coordinatesx i transform contravariantly. We have seen that the composition of successive linear transformations represented by matrices A and B can be either BA or A-lB-’ depending on the nature of the quantity being transformed, and it is necessary to determine from the context which one is appropriate. If contravariantcomponents compose with matrix BA,then covariant components compose with matrix A-’B-’.
ALGEBRAIC TENSORS
61
Though these concatenation relations have been derived for linear transformations, there is a sense in which they are the only possibilities for (sufficientlysmooth) nonlinear transformations as well. If the origin maps to the origin, as we have assumed implicitly, then there is a “linearized transformation” that is approximately valid for “small-amplitude” (close to the origin) particles, and the above concatenation properties must apply to that transformation. The same distinction between the transformation properties of particle coordinates and distribution coefficients must therefore apply also to nonlinear transformations, though the equations can be expected to become much more complicated at large amplitudes. It is only linear transformations that can be concatenated in closed form using matrix multiplication, but the opposite concatenation order of covariant and contravariant quantities also applies in the nonlinear regime. There is an interesting discussion in Schutz, [2, Sec. 2.181, expanding on the interpretation of the Dirac deltafunction as a distribution in the sense in which the word is being used here. If the argument of the delta function is said to be transformed contravariantly, then the “value” of the delta function transforms covariantly.
*2.4.4. Multi-index T e n s o r s and Their Contraction2’ We turn now to tensors with more than one index. Tbo-index covariant tensors are defined by conssering real-valued bilinear functions of two vectors, say x and y. Such a function f(x, y) is called bilinear because it is linear in each of its two arguments separately. When the arguments x and y are expanded in terms of the basis introduced in Q.(2.4.3), one has22 u
f(x, y) = fi, x i y J , where
fi,
-
= f(q, ej).
(2.4.20)
As usual, we will say that the functionTand the array of coefficients fi, are the same thing and that?(x, y) is the same thing as the bilinear form fij x iy J . The coefficients fi, are called covariant components of f. Pedantically it is only T(x, y), with arguments inserted, that deserves to be called aform, but common usage seems to_be to call T a form all by ?self. An expressive notation that will often be used is f(.,.), which indicates that f is “waiting for” two (as yet nameless, or “anonymous”) vector arguments. Especially important are the anti-symmetric bilinear functions f(x, y) that change sign when x and y are interchanged:
-
-
-f(x, y) = -T(Y, x),
or
fij
= -f... I‘
(2.4.21)
21Thissection is rather abstract. The reader willing to accept that the confrnczionof the upper and lower index of a tensor is invariant can skip it. Footnote 23 hints at how this result can be obtained more quickly. 22Eq. (2.4.20) is actually unnecessarily restrictive, since x and y could be permitted to come from different spaces.
62
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
These alternating or antisymmetric tensors are the only multi-index quantities that represent important geometric objects. The theory of determinants can be based on them as well. (See Van der Waerden, Section 4.7.) To produce a contravariant two-index tensor requires the definition of a bilinear function of two covariant vectors G and V. One way of constructing such a bilinear function is to start with two fixed contravariant vectors x and y and to define f@, 7) = (Z, x)
6,Y).
(2.4.22)
This tensor is called the tensor product x 8 y of vectors x and y. Its arguments are u and v. (The somewhat old-fashioned physics terminology is to call f the dyadic product of x and y.) In more expressive notation,
The vectors x and y can in general belong to different spaces with different dimensionalities,but for simplicity in the following few paragraphs we assume they belong to the same space having dimension n. The components of x @ y are .
.
f " = (x@y)(Z'i, Z j ) = ( ? , x ) ( Z J , y ) = x ' Y'.
(2.4.24)
Though the linear superposition of any two such tensors is certainly a tensor, call it t = ( r i j ) , it does not follow in general that two vectors x and y can be found for which t is their tensor product. However, all such superpositions can be expanded in terms of the tensor products ei 8 e j of the basis vectors introduced previously. These products form a natural basis for such tensors t. In the next paragraph the n2-dimensionalvector space of two-contravariant-index tensors t will be called 7. At the cost of greater abstraction, we next prove a result needed to go from one index to two indices. The motivation is less than obvious, but the result will prove to be useful straightaway-what a mathematician might call a lemma;23
THEOREM 2.4.1: For any function B ( x , y) linear in each of its two arguments x and y, there exists an intrinsic linear function of the single argument x 8 y, call it S(x C?J y), such that
The vectors x and y can come from different vector spaces. Proofi In terms of contravariant components x i and y j , the given bilinear function has the form B(X, y) = sjj x i y j .
(2.4.26)
23The reader impatient with abstract argumentation may consider it adequate to base the invariance of the trace of a mixed tensor on the inverse transformation properties of covariant and contravariant indices.
ALGEBRAIC TENSORS
63
This makes it natural, for arbitrary tensor t drawn from space I,to define a corresponding function S(t) that is linear in the components r i j oft: ..
S(t) = sij r’J.
(2.4.27)
When this function is applied to x @ y, the result is S(x @ y) = sij x i y j = B(x, y),
(2.4.28)
which is the required result. Since components were used only in an intermediate stage the theorem assures the relation to be intrinsic (coordinate-free). (As an aside, note that the values of the functions S and B could have been allowed to have other (matching) vector or tensor indices themselves without affecting the proof. This increased generality is required to validate contraction of tensors with more than two rn indices.) Other tensor products can be made from contravariant and covariant vectors. Holding i? and V fixed while x and y vary, an equation like (2.4.22) can also be regarded as defining a covector product i? @V. A mixed vector product f = u @ y can be similarly defined by holding i? and y constant:24
-
f(x,V) = G,x ) F , Y).
(2.4.29)
The components of this tensor are
fi’
= c;;@ y)(ei, ~
j =)
(i?,e i ) g j , y) = ui yj.
(2.4.30)
Later on we will also require antisymmetrizedtensor products, or “wedge products” defined by
V) - (x, 3 ( Y , 3 , y) = (& X) 6, y) - (z, Y) 6, X).
x A Yc;;,7) = (x, 3 ( Y ,
5 A ?(X,
(2.4.31)
-
The generation of a new tensor by “index contraction” can now be considered. Consider the tensor product t = u @ x where iT and x belong to dual vector spaces. The theorem proved above can be applied to the function
BC;;, bilinear in
X)
= (i?,X) = uj x i l
(2.4.32)
and x, to prove the existence of intrinsic linear function S such that
~(ii 8 X) = uj x i = tr(ii 8 XI,
(2.4.33)
where tr(t) is the sum of the diagonal elements of tensor i? €3 x in the particular coordinate system shown (or any other, since 5,x is invariant). Since any mixed two24A deficiency of our notation appears at this point since it is ambiguous whether or not the symbol f in f = 8 y should carry a tilde.
64
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 1: LINEAR
component tensor can be written as a superposition of such covectorkontravector products, and since the trace operation is distributive over such superposition, and i ix) is an intrinsic function, it follows that tr(t) = tii is an invariant since ~ (8 function for any mixed tensor. tr(t) is called the contraction oft. 2.4.5. Overlap of Tensor Algebra and Tensor Calculus Before leaving the topic of tensor algebra, we review the differential form & obtained from a function of position x called h ( x ) . We saw a close connection between this quantity and the familiar gradient of vector calculus, V h. There is little to add now except to call attention to a potentially confusing issue of terminology. A physicist thinking of vector calculus thinks of gradients, divergences, and curls (the operators needed for electromagnetism) as being on the same footing in some sense-they are all “vector derivatives.” On the other hand, in mathematics books discussing tensors, gradients are normally considered to be “tensor algebra” and only the divergence and curl are the subject matter of “tensor calculus.” It is probably adequate for a physicist to file this away as yet another curiosity not to be distracted by, but contemplation of the source of the terminology may be instructive. One obvious distinction among the operators in question is that gradients act on scalars whereas divergences and curls operate on vectors, but this is too formal to account satisfactorily for the difference of terminology. Recall from the earlier discussion of differential forms, in particulE Eqs. (2.3.3) and (2.3.4) that, for a linear function h = ax +by, the coefficients of dh are a and b. In this case selecting the coefficient a or b, an algebraic operation, and differentiating h with respect to x or y, a calculus operation, amount to the same thing. Even for nonlinear functions, the gradient operator can be regarded as extracting the coefficients of the linear terms in a Taylor expansion about the point under study. In this linear “tangent space” the coefficients in question are the components of a covariant vector, as has been discussed. What is calculus in the original space is algebra in the tangent space. Such conundrums are not unknown in “unambiguously physics” contexts. For example, both in Hamilton-Jacobi theory and in quantum mechanics there is a close connection between the x-component of a momentum vector and a partial-with-respect-to-xderivative. Yet one more notational variant will be mentioned before leaving this topic. There is a notational convention popular with mathematicians but not commonly used by physicists (though it shouId be since it is both clear and powerful.) We introduce it now, only in a highly specialized sense, intending to expand the discussion later. Consider a standard plot having x as abscissa and y as ordinate, with axes rectangular and having the same scales-in other words ordinary analytic geometry. A function h ( x , y ) can be expressed by equal h-value contours on such a plot. For describing arrows on this plot it is customary to introduce “unit vectors,” usually denoted by (i, j) or (f,9).Let us now introduce the recommended new notation:
(2.4.34)
ALGEBRAIC TENSORS
65
Being equal to i and j, these quantities are represented by boldface symbols? i is that arrow that points along the axis on which x varies and y does not, and if the tail ofi is at x = xo, its tip is at x = xo 1. The same italicized sentence serves just as well to define alax-the symbol in the denominator signifies the coordinate being varied (with the other coordinates held fixed). This same definition will also hold if the axes are skew, or if their scales are different, and even if the coordinate grid is curvilinear. (Discontinuous scales should not be allowed, however.) Note that, though the notation does not exhibit it, the basis vector @/ax also depends on the coordinates other than x because it points in the direction in which the other coordinates are constant. One still wonders why this notation for unit vectors deserves a partial derivative symbol. What is to be differentiated? The answer is h ( x , y) (or any other function of x and y). The result, a h l a x , yields the answer to the question of how much h changes when x varies by one unit with y held fixed. Though stretching or twisting the axes would change the appearance of equal-h contours, it would not affect these questions and answers, since they specify only dependence of the function h ( x , y) on its arguments and do not depend on how it is plotted. One might say that the notation has removed the geometry from the description. One consequence of this is that the application of vector operations such as divergence and curl will have to be rethought, since they make implicit assumptions about the geometry of the space in which arguments x and y are coordinates. But the gradient requires no further analysis. x). What is the From a one-form % and a v e c t z x one can form the scalar 6, quantity formed when one-form dh, defined in Eq. (2.3.4), operates on the vector a/ax just defined? By Eq. (2.3.1) and the defined meaning of a/& we have = 1. Combining this with Eqs. (2.3.4) and (2.3.5) yields
+
&(a/&)
(2.4.35) where the final term is the traditional notation for the x-component of the gradient of h. In this case the new notation can be thought of simply as a roundabout way of expressing the gradient. zome modem authors, Schutz for example, (confusingly in my opinion) s i p l y call dh “the gradient of h.” This raises another question: Should the symbol be dh, which we have been using, or should it be &? Already the symbol d has been used toindicaLe “exterior differentiation,” and a priori the independently defined quantities d h are dh are distinct. But we will show that they are in fact equal, so it is immaterial which notation is used. From these considerations one infers that for contravariant basis vectors ex = and ey = 8 / 8 y the corresponding covariant basis vectors are Z* = d7u and
u
a/&
25Whetheror not they are true vectors depends on whether or not i and j are defined to be true vectors. The answer to this question can be regarded as a matter of convention; if the axes are regarded as fixed once and for all then i and J are true vectors; if the axes are transformed, they are not.
66
Z2
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
&I. Why is this so? For example, because & ( 8 / 8 x ) a ax’
el = -,
a
e2 = - , . . . , e n 8x2
= 1. To recapitulate: 8
=-
(2.4.36)
OX“
are the natural contravariant basis vectors, and the corresponding covariant basis vectors are -1
Z1 = d x ,
-Jz
-2
e =dx
,..., uen = d-xn .
(2.4.37)
The association of a/&’,B / B x 2 , .. . , B/Bx”, with vectors will be shown to be of far more than formal significance in Section 3.4.3. where vectors are associated with directional derivatives.
2.5. (POSSIBLY COMPLEX) CARTESIANVECTORS IN METRIC GEOMETRY 2.5.1. Euclidean Vectors
Now, for the first time, we hypothesize the presence of a “metric” (whose existence can, from a physicist’s point of view, be taken to be a “physical law,” for example the Pythagorean “law” or the Einstein-Minkowski “law”). We will use this metric to “associate” covariant and contravariant vectors. Such associations are being made constantly and without a second thought by physicists. Here we spell the process out explicitly. The current task can also be expressed as one of assigning covariant components to a true vector that is defined initially by its contravariant components. A point in three-dimensional Euclidean space can be located by a vector x = elx 1
+ e2x 2 + e3x3
E eixi,
(2.5.1)
where el, e2, and e3 form an orthonormal (defined below) triplet of basis vectors. Such a basis will be called “Euclidean.” The final form again employs the repeatedindex summation convention, even though the two factors have different tensor character in this case. In this expansion, the components have upper indices and are called “contravariant” though, as it happens, because the basis is Euclidean, the covariant components xi to be introduced shortly will have the same values. For skew bases (axes not necessarily othogonal and to be called “Cartesian”), the contravariant and covariant components will be distinct. Unless stated otherwise, xl, x 2 , and x3 are allowed to be complex numbers-we defer concerning ourselves with the geometric implications of this. We are restricting the discussion to n = 3 here only to avoid inessential abstraction; in The Theory of Spinors by Cartan, most of the results are derived for general n, using arguments like the ones to be used here. The reader may be beginning to sense a certain repetition of discussion of concepts already understood, such as covariant and contravariant vectors. This can best be defended by observing that, even though these concepts are essentially the same
(POSSIBLY COMPLEX) CARTESIAN VECTORS IN METRIC GEOMETRY
67
in different contexts, they can also differ in subtle ways, depending upon the implicit assumptions that accompany them. All vectors start at the origin in this discussion. According to the Pythagorean relation, the distance from the origin to the tip of the arrow can be expressed by a “fundamental form” or “scalar square” @(x)=x.x=
(x + (q2 + (x3)2.
(2.5.2)
Three distinct cases will be of special importance: The components xl, x2, and x3 are required to be real. In this case @(x), conventionally denoted also by 1xI2,is necessarily positive, and it is natural to divide any vector by 1x1 to convert it into a “unit vector.” This metric describes ordinary geometry in three dimensions, and constitutes the Pythagorean law referred to above. 0 The components x’, x2, and x3 are complex with fundamental form given by Eq. (2.5.2). Note that @(x) is not defined to be X’x 1 X 2 x 2 X3 x 3 and that it has the possibilities of being complex or of vanishing even though x does not. If it vanishes, the vector is said to be “isotropic.” If it does not, it can be normalized, converting it into a “unit vector.” 0 In the “pseudo-Euclidean” case the components xl, x2, and x3 are required to be real, but the fundamental form is given not by E!q. (2.5.2) but by 0
+
@(x) =
+ (x2)2
- (x3)2.
+
(2.5.3)
Since this has the possibility of vanishing, a vector can be “isotropic,” or “on the light cone” in this case also. For @ > 0, the vector is “space-like”; for @ < 0 it is “time-like.’’In these cases a “unit vector” can be defined as having fundamental form of magnitude 1. In this pseudo-Euclidean case, “ordinary” space-time requires n = 1 3. This metric could legitimately be called “Einstein’s metric,” but it is usually called “Minkowski’s.” In any case, its existence can be regarded as a physical law, not just a mathematical construct. To the extent possible these cases will be treated “in parallel,” in a unified fashion, with most theorems and proofs applicable in all cases. Special properties of one or the other of the cases will be interjected as required. The “scalar” or “invariant product” of vectors x and y is defined in terms of their Euclidean components by
+
x . y d y 1 + x 2 y 2 + x 3 y 3.
(2.5.4)
Though similar-looking expressions have appeared previously, this is the first one deserving of the name “dot product.” If x . y vanishes, x and y are said to be orthogonal. An “isotropic” vector is orthogonal to itself. The vectors orthogonal to a given vector span a plane. (In n-dimensional space this is called a “hyperplane” of n - 1
68
GEOMETRYOF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
dimensions.) In the pseudo-Euclidean case there is one minus sign in the definition of scalar product as in Eq. (2.5.3). The very existence of a metric permits the introduction of a “natural” association of a vector form ito a vector x such that, for arbitary vector y, i(y) = x y.
Problem 2.5.1: Show that definition (2.5.4) follows from definition (2.5.3) if one assumes “natural” algebraic properties for “lengths” in the evaluation of (x + hy) . (x h y ) , where x and y are two different vectors and h is an arbitrary scalar.
+
2.5.2. Skew Coordinate Frames The basis vectors ql,q2,and q3,in a skew, or “Cartesian,” frame are not orthonorma1 in general. They must however be “independent”; geometrically this requires that they not lie in a single plane; algebraically it requires that no vanishing linear combination can be formed from them. As a result, a general vector x can be expanded in terms of vl,q2,and q3.
(2.5.5)
x = q j x i,
and its scalar square is then given by . .
@(x) = qi . q
j x l x ~
(2.5.6)
gijxixj.
Here “metric coefficients,” and the matrix G they form, have been defined by
gij
= g/”l --~
i * 7 1 j ,
G=
771 ‘ 7 7 1
rll .772
772.111
~ 2 , 7 7 2 772.113
773 .77l
r13 ’772
(
771.773
773 - 7 3
)
.
(2.5.7)
As in Section 2.4, the coefficients x i are known as “contravariant components” of x. When expressed in terms of them, the formula for length is more complicated than the Pythagorean formula because the basis vectors are skew. Nevertheless it has been straightforward, starting from a Euclidean basis, to find the components of the metric tensor. It is less straightforward, and not even necessarily possible in general, given a metric tensor, to find a basis in which the length formula is Pythagorean. *2.5.3. Reduction of a Quadratic Form to a Sum or Difference of Squares26 For describing scalar products, defined in the first place in terms of orthonormal axes, but now using skew coordinates, a quadratic form has been introduced. Con26Tbe material in this and the next section is reasonably standard in courses in algebra. It is nevertheless spelled out here in some detail since, like some of the other material in this chapter. analogous procedures will be used when “symplectic geometry” is discussed.
69
(POSSIBLY COMPLEX) CARTESIAN VECTORS IN METRIC GEOMETRY
versely, given an arbitrary quadratic form @ = giju'u', can we find a coordinate transformation xi = q j u j to variables for which @ takes the form of Eq. (2.5~1)?~ In general, the components can be complex. If the components are required to be real then the coefficients ai, will also be required to be real; otherwise they also can be complex. The reader has no doubt been subjected to such an analysis before, though perhaps not with complex variables allowed.
THEOREM 2.5.1: Every quadratic form can be reduced to a sum of (positive or negative) squares by a linear transformation of the variables. Proof: Suppose one of the diagonal elements, say g l 1 , is non-zero. With a view toward eliminating all terms linear in ul, define (2.5.8) which no longer contains u ' . Hence, defining YI
(2.5.9)
gliu',
the fundamental form can be written as @
1 = -yy: g11
+ aq;
(2.5.10)
the second term has one fewer variable than previously. If all diagonal elements vanish, one of the off-diagonal elements, say does not. In this case define 2
@2
gijuiui - -(g21u1
g23u3)(gl2u2
g12
g12,
+ g13u3),
(2.5.11)
4-g13u3,
(2.5.12)
which contains neither u 1 nor u 2 . Defining Y1
+ Y 2 = g21u1 4- g23u3,
YI - Y 2 =
we obtain @
= g12 ( Y : - Y:)
+ @2,
(2.5.13)
again reducing the dimensionality. 27F0rpurposes of this proof, which is entirely algebraic, we ignore the traditional connection between upperflower index location, and contravariantkovariantnature. Hence the components xi given by x; = a i j d are nor to be regarded as covariant, or contravarianteither, for that matter.
70
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICSI: LINEAR
The form can be reduced to a sum of squares step-by-step in this way. In the real domain, no complex coefficients are introduced, but some of the coefficients may be negative. In all cases, normalizations can be chosen to make all coefficients be 1 or -1.
Problem 2.5.2: Sylvester’s Law of Inertia. The preceding substitutions are not unique but, in the domain of reals, the relative number of negative and positive coefficients in the final form is unique. Prove this, for example by showing a contradiction resulting from assuming a relation @ = y 2 - z l2- z ; = u l +2u 2 - w 2 ,
2
(2.5.14)
between variables y, 21, and 22 with two negative signs on the one hand, and u, u2, and wl with only one negative sign on the other. In “nondegenerate” (that is, det lgj, I # 0) ordinary geometry of real numbers, the number of positive square terms is necessarily 3. 2.5.4. Introductionof Covariant Components The contravariant components x 1 are seen in Eq. (2.5.5) to be the coefficients in the expansion of x in terms of the qi. In ordinary vector analysis one is accustomed to identifying each of these coefficients as the “component of x” along a particular coordinate axis and being able to evaluate it as 1x1 multiplied by the cosine of the corresponding angle. Here we define lowered-index components x i , to be called “covariant,” (terminology to be justified later) as the “invariant products” of x with the ‘li: xi = x . qi = g i k X k ,
or as a matrix equation x = ( G XT) N
where ? stands for the array Eq. (2.5.4) can be written
(XI,
. . . ,x n ) .
x T GT ,
(2.5.15)
Now the scalar product defined in
~ . y = ~ i =y y’ j ~ ’ .
(2.5.16)
By inverting Eq. (2.5.15) contravariant components can be obtained from covariant ones
x T =%(GT)-’, or as components, x i = g i k X k
where g i k = (G-’)jk. (2.5.17) For orthonormal bases, G = 1 and, as mentioned previously, covariant and contravariant components are identical. Introduction of covariant components can be regarded as a simple algebraic convenience with no geometric significance. However, if the angle 0 between vectors x and y is defined by cost? =
X.Y
vwm5’
(2.5.18)
(POSSIBLY COMPLEX) CARTESIANVECTORS IN METRIC GEOMETRY
71
x:(x’= 2, x*= 1)
92
+
FIGURE 2.5.1. The true vector 2111 7)2 expressed in terms of contravariant and, using Eq. (2.5.19), its covariant components related to direction cosines. For Euclidean geometry is normally symbolized by 1x1.
then a general vector x is related to the basis vectors q l , q2,and q3 by direction cosines cos 01, cos 02, cos 03, and its covariant components are xi = X . qi =
Jm
COSO~.
(2.5.19)
This definition is illustrated in Fig. 2.5.1, The angles (or rather their cosines) introduced in these definitions would be just redundant symbols except for the fact that all of trigometry is imported into the formalism in this way.
2.5.5. The Reciprocal Basis Even in Euclidean geometry there are situations in which skew axes yield simplified descriptions, which makes the introduction of covariant components especially useful. The most important example is in the description of a crystal for which displacements by integer multiples of a right-handed triad of “unit cell” vectors ql, q2, and q3leave the lattice invariant. Let these unit cell vectors form the basis of a skew frame as in Section 2.5.2. For any vector x in the original space we can associate a particular form E in the dual space by the following rule, giving its value %(y)when acting on general vector y: 6,y) = x . y. In particular, “reciprocal basis vectors” and basis forms ?f are defined to satisfy @ q .J ) =qi . qJ . =A‘.,J
(2.5.20)
and $, ;i”,and G3 are the basis dual to ql, q2,and q3 as in Eq. (2.4.4). The vectors qi in this equation need to be determined to satisfy the final equality. This can be accomplished mentally;
(2.5.21) where the orientation of the basis vectors is assumed to be such that f i is real and nonzero. (From vector analysis one recognizes to be the volume of the unit
72
GEOMETRYOF MECHANICSI: LINEAR
cell.) One can confirm that Eqs. (2.5.20) are then satisfied. The vectors ql, 772, and q3 are said to form the “reciprocal basis.” The “reciprocal lattice” consists of all superpositionsof these vectors with integer coefficients.
Problem 2.5.3: In terms of skew basis vectors q l , q2,and q3 in three-dimensional Euclidean space, a vector x = q i x i has covariant components xi = gijx’. Show that x=x1q
1
+ x 2 q 2 + x 3 q3.
where the q‘ are given by Eq.(2.5.21). By inspection one sees that reciprocal base vector q’ is normal to the plane containing q3and q2.This is illustrated in Fig. 2.5.2, which shows the unit cell vectors superimposed on a crystal lattice. (q3points normally out of the paper.) Similarly, 772 is normal to the plane containing q3and ql. Consider the plane passing through the origin and containing both q3 and the vector q1 N q 2 , where N is an integer. Since there is an atom situated at the tip of this vector, this plane contains this atom as well as the atom at the origin and the atom at 2(ql N q 2 ) , and so on. For the case N = 1, these atoms are joined by a line in the figure and several other lines, all parallel and passing through other atoms
+
+
-=I a = 0.69
b = 0.57 sin4 = 0.87 = 1.67
= 2.02
FIGURE 2.5.2. The crystal lattice shown has unit cell vectors 91 and 92 as shown, as well as 9 3 pointing normally out of the paper. Reciprocal basis vectors qi and $ are shown. The particular lattice planes indicated by parallel lines correspond to the reciprocal lattice vector 4 - q’ . It is coincidental that $ appears to lie in a crystal plane.@ , = absin4.
(POSSIBLY COMPLEX) CARTESIAN VECTORS IN METRIC GEOMETRY
73
that are shown as well. The vector
is perpendicular to this set of planes. (Again for N = 1) the figure confirms that q' - $ is normal to the crystal planes shown.
Problem 2.5.4: Show that for any two atoms in the crystal, the plane containing them and the origin is normal to a vector expressible as a superposition of reciprocal basis vectors with integer coefficients, and that any superposition of reciprocal basis vectors with integer coefficients is normal to a set of planes containing atoms. [Hint:For practice at the sort of calculation that is useful, evaluate (ql q2). (ql q2).I
+
+
It was only because the dot product is meaningful that Eq. (2.5.20) results in the But once that identification is association of an ordinary vector q' with the form made, all computations can be made using straightforwardvector analysis. A general vector x can be expanded either in terms of the original or the reciprocal basis
q.
x = qix' = x i qi ,
(2.5.22)
(The components xi can be thought of either as covariant components of x or as components of 2 such that %(y) = xiy'.) In conjunction with Eqs. (2.5.17) and (2.5.20) this yields
(gik)=G-l= q3
.q1
773
.$
q3
.$
(2.5.23)
Problem 2.5.5: Confirm the Lugrunge identity of vector analysis
(A x B) . (C x D) = det
:: ; 1 ;:,"I.
(2.5.24)
This is most simply done by expressing the cross products with the three, index anti-symmetric symbol E i j k . With the vectors A, B, C, and D drawn from ql,q2,and q3,each of these determinants can be identified as a cofactor in Q. (2.5.7). From this show that g = det IGI.
Problem 2.5.6: Show that original basis vectors qi are themselves reciprocal to the reciprocal basis vectors qi.
74
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
2.5.6. Wavefronts, Lattice Planes, and Bragg Reflection In this section, to illustrate the physical distinction between contravariant and covariant vectors, we digress into the subjects of wave propagation, wave-particle duality, coherent interaction, energy and momentum conservatibn, and, ultimately, the condition for Bragg scattering of X-rays from crystals. The main purpose of this section is to provide examples of covariant vectors. Though these calculations may appear, superficially, to have little to do with mechanics, in the end a surprising connection with mechanics, especially quantum mechanics, will emerge. A two-dimensional slice through a crystal lattice is shown in Fig. 2.5.2. The unit cell vectors q1 and q2 lie in the plane shown. Their lengths are a and b. The remaining basis vector q3 is normal to both of them and has length c. Applying Eqs. (2.5.21), f i = abc sin 4, q1has length l/(a sin#) and is normal to q2,and # has length l/(b sin 4) and is normal to ql. In preparation for describing the interaction of X-rays with a lattice we review some properties of waves. We use standard Euclidean geometry. The wave vector k of a monofrequency plane wave points in the direction of propagation of the wave and has magnitude 2n/A where k is the wavelength. A “wavefront” is, on the one hand, a plane orthogonal to k and, on the other hand, a plane on which the “phase” # is constant. Analytically, # appears in the description of the wave by a wave function *(x, t ) q,(x, t )
-
ei@(x)e-iwr
, where
4(x) = k . x = k ; x ’ .
(2.5.25)
Note that the final expression, trivially valid for Euclidean axes, is also valid for skew axes; in this case it is seen to be economical to describe the wave vector by its covariant components, k; . To emphasize this point we can associate with k a form such that N
4(x) = k W .
(2.5.26)
This is entirely equivalent to the second part of (2.5.25). We wish now to point out the natural connection between pairs of adjacent wavefronts and the pairs of planes of a covariant vector. Though previously the spacing between pairs of planes representing a covariant vector have been taken to be “unity,” it is more natural, in a physics context, for the spacing to have the dimensions of length, and the natural choice is the wavelength I or perhaps A/(2n). Even though waves are being described, it is customary from geometric optics to define “rays” as being normal to wavefronts. One can keep track of the value of 4 by “stepping off’ wavelengths along a ray and multiplying the number of wavelengths by 2n. But it is more in the intended spirit of the present discussion to observe that the advance of 4 (in radians) along any path is obtained simply by counting the number of wavefronts crossed. This eliminates the need for introducing rays at all, since it works for any path. Fig. 2.5.3illustrates Bragg scattering from a particular set of parallel lattice planes in a two-dimensional lattice with unit cell vectors 77, and q2.Though shown as single
(POSSIBLY COMPLEX) CARTESIANVECTORS IN METRIC GEOMETRY
75
FIGURE 2.5.3. Bragg scattering from a crystal. The candidate scattering planes are indicated by straight lines with spacing d . It is only coincidentalthat the incident beam is directed more or less . construction hinted at by the dashed wavefronts normal to the lattice plane containing ~ 1The of incident an scattered wave demonstrates that coherence from all scattering sites in the same plane requires the (candidate) angle of reflection to be equal to the angle of incidence 0.
arrows, the incident X-rays actually form a wave-packet or beam, extended both longitudinally and transversely. We must assume that each wave packet is coherent (i.e., plane-wave-like) over a volume containing many atoms. Then the essence of the present calculation is to seek a situation in which there is constructive interference of the scattering amplitudes from numerous, say N, scattering sites so that the scattering amplitude, proportional to @, dominates all other scattering processes by a relative factor of order N . Offhand, one might imagine that N could be of the order of Avogadro’s number, which would yield a truly astronomical enhancement factor. Even apart from the fact that such a large scattering probability might imply more scattered intensity than incident intensity, there are many effects that reduce the effective coherence volume, thereby restricting the value of N to smaller numbers. (Some such effects are microstructure or “mosaic spread” due to imperfect crystals, thermal effects, and limited beam coherence.) For our purposes we will only assume that a situation yielding coherence from numerous sites dominates the scattering process. The result in this case is called “Bragg scattering.” The construction of Fig. 2.5.3 demonstrates that coherence from all scattering sites in a single plane requires the (candidate) angle of Bragg reflection to be equal to the angle of incidence 8.In this case the incident beam phase lag for the scattering on the right relative to the scattering on the left is exactly compensated for by its phase advance after scattering. This argument relies on the assumed equality of scattered and incident wavelengths. With the rest energy of a single scattering site being large compared to the energy of a single photon, this would tend to be approximately true even for scattering from a single atom, but in Bragg scattering the crystal recoils as a whole (or as nf sites anyway), validating the assumption by a further large factor N.
76
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
For simplicity the following discussion is restricted to the particular configuration of planes shown in Fig. 2.5.3; the origin and ql q2 lie in the same plane, and the normal to the scattering planes (emphasized by parallel lines) is given by 17’ - $. (At the cost of introducing a few more integer coefficients, the final results could be proved in the far greater generality for which they are valid.) Denoting the incident and scattered wave vectors as p and q. the corresponding forms are and Define also ? = 5 - i. Motivated by earlier discussion, these quantities are defined as forms (with overhead tildes). (This comment is primarily pedantic in any case since the presence of a tilde, say on 5. distinguishes it from a corresponding vector p only by the feature that a dot product such as p . x can be expressed as F(x).) The condition ensuring coherence of the atom at the origin and the next atom on the same plane (and hence all atoms in the plane) is
+
G.
This condition fixes the direction, but not the length of r. For general scattering planes, this condition would beF(rnlql + r n 2 q 2 ) = 0 where rnl and rn2 are integersthe natural argument of ^i: is a vector from the origin to any lattice site. The enhancement factor h/z coming from the many coherent sites in any one plane may’be appreciable, but it will still.lead to negligible scattering unless there is also coherence from different planes. One way of expressing this extra coherence condition is that the phase lag caused by the extra path in scattering from the next plane must be equal to 2 n (for simplicity we skip the further possibility of this being an integral multiple of 2n),or h = 2dsin
(5 -
0) ,
(2.5.28)
which is traditionally known as “Bragg’s law.” This is illustrated in Fig. 2.5.4. This condition can also be expressed by an equation more nearly resembling Eq. (2.5.27). Starting from the origin, the vector q1 leads to an atom on the preceding scattering plane, and the vector q2leads to the one on the next plane. Recalling Eq.(2.5.26),and applying the condition for constructive interference from these
extrapath
-
dcos0
incident
:,
. e e ,
I
1 reflected
FIGURE 2.5.4. Geometric construction leading to Bragg’s law.
(POSSIBLY COMPLEX) CARTESIAN VECTORS IN METRIC GEOMETRY
77
atoms as well, leads to the equations u
r(ql) = -2n,
and F(v2)= 27r.
(2.5.29)
These are (a rather specialized version of) the so-called “Laue equations.’’ We now use these equations in order to write r as a superposition of reciprocal basis vectors of the form r = q 1 + & 2.
(2.5.30)
From Eq. (2.5.20) one has rJ . q j = Jij, which, combined with Eqs. (2.5.29) yields = -,9 = -2n, and hence
(Y
r
-=
2n
q2 - q1.
(2.5.31)
Referring to Fig. 2.5.2, this shows that the Bragg condition can be expressed by the statement that (except for factor 2n) the difference of incident and scattered wave vectors is equal to the reciprocal lattice vector describing the planes from which the scattering occurs. This form of the condition for coherence from successive planes is illustrated graphically in Fig. 2.5.5. The incident beam is represented by wavefronts that correspond to the incident covariant wave vector E, and the scattered beam by (shown as -6 in the figure). As drawn, equality of angles of incidence and reflection is satisfied, but the spacing of planes is not quite right for coherence. For conve-
FIGURE 2.5.5. Bragg scattering from a crystal. Dashed lines are wavefronts of incident wave covariant vector and (negative) reflected wave covariant vector -i. Dotted lines represent covariant vector - q. As drawn the Bragg condition is almost, but not quite, satisfied.
7 7
78
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
nience in correlating with Eq. (2.5.31), let us suppose the contour lines of p and q in Fig. 2.5.5 are spaced by 2n rather than by unity. Then, to make the dotted lines match the solid lines exactly, it would be necessary to decrease the incident and scattered line spacings slightly; this would require a slight increase in the light frequency or a slight decrease in the angle of incidence (relative to the normal). Elegant as it is, Eq.(2.5.31) becomes yet more marvelous when conservation of momentum is invoked along with the deBroglie relation between momentum and wavelength. By introducing Planck’s constant we can state that if the momentum of an incident photon is given by bnc= hfi and of a reflected photon by fiEf = h i , then conservation of momentum yields for the recoil momentum of the lattice as a whole, AClat = hF. (Apologies for the dimensionally inconsistent notation.) Then Eq. (2.5.31) becomes (2.5.32) (Naturally, for scattering from another set of planes, the right hand side of this equation contains the appropriately different reciprocal lattice vector.) One of the justifications for calling this equation “marvelous” is that both sides of the equation refer to the lattice, leaving no reference to the incident and scattered photon beams. This suggests, and the suggestion is confirmed experimentally, that other elementary processes, such as bremstrahlung and electron-positron pair production, will acquire coherent enhancement when the crystal’s recoil momentum matches one of its reciprocal lattice vectors as in Eq.(2.5.32). Some of these considerations may well have been behind deBroglie’s original conjecture relating momentum and inverse wavelength. For our purposes it is perhaps more appropriate to regard these results as telling us that the natural interpretation of momentum is as a covariant vector. This statement is especially evident when the condition is written out in covariant components. Then Eq. (2.5.32) becomes
(This is dimensionally consistent because the reciprocal basis vectors have the dimensions of inverse length.) The generalization of this equation to arbitrary crystal planes is that the lattice recoil momentum (divided by h ) has to be a superposition of reciprocal basis vectors with integer coefficients. The following comments, though not germane to classical mechanics, may be of interest nonetheless. We have here stressed a connection of Planck‘s constant h with momentum that can be investigated experimentally using Bragg scattering from a crystal. There is an independent line of investigation, for example using the photoelectric effect, in which h is related to the energy of a photon. Comparison of the values of h obtained from these entirely independent types of experiment provides a serious test of the overall consistency of the quantum theory. By this point the reader should be convinced that the natural geometric representation of a covariant vector is as contour lines (in spite of any previously held prejudice to the contrary based on thinking of a gradient vector as an arrow pointing in the direction of maximum rate of ascent). It may take longer to become convinced
79
(POSSIBLY COMPLEX) CARTESIAN VECTORS IN METRIC GEOMETRY
that in the context of smooth manifolds (such as the set of configurations of a system described by generalized coordinates in Lagrangian mechanics) this is the onfy possible interpretation of a covariant vector. It is because, in that case, there is no such thing as a direction of maximum rate of ascent. Numerous important topics concerning the use of skew frames (i.e., frames linearly related to Euclidean frames) remain to be covered. They are characterized by the property that components of the metric tensor are constant, independent of position. We will be returning to these topics starting in Section 4.1.1. The reader might prefer to proceed there directly, skipping the discussion of curvilinear (nonlinear) reference frames in the next chapter. As mentioned before, even in nonlinear situations, a limited region can always be defined in which linear analysis is approximately valid.
Problem 2.5.7: With patterns photocopied onto transparency material from Fig. 2.5.6, two sets of parallel lines, representing incident and reflected wavefronts, are
0
0
0 0 0
0 0
0 0 0
0
0 0
0
0 0
0
0
0 0 0
0
0 0
0 0
0
0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0
0 0
0
0
0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
0 0
0
0 0 0
FIGURE 2.5.6. Patterns for investigating covariant vectors and the Bragg reflection condition. This page is to be copied (twice) onto transparency material in order to perform Problem 2.5.7. The purpose of the two patterns on the left is to give a preview of the sort of pattern being looked for. The virtue of a pattern of circles is that all possible orientations of parallel (if only tangent) lines are represented. The problem uses only the patterns on the right.
80
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
to be laid over the “lattice” of tiny circles in a configuration for which the Bragg condition is satisfied. Cell atoms are located at (O,O), (3,0), (1,3), (4,3), etc. and, in the same units, the spacing between lines is 21/22. There is not a unique solution. If managing three arrays proves to be too frustrating, a fairly good solution can be obtained using the planes in the lower left comer of the figure.
Problem 2.5.8: For Bragg scattering from the plane, mentioned below Eq. (2.5.27), containing the origin and the point m 1ql + m2q2, find the recoil momentum r corresponding to Bragg scattering with the longest wavelength possible and obtain a formula for that wavelength. *2.6. UNITARY GEOMETRY2*
Yet another kind of geometry, namely unitary geometry, can be introduced. This is the “geometry” of quantum mechanics. In physics one prefers to avoid using complex numbers because physical quantities are always real. But complex numbers inevitably result when the equations of the theory are solved. In quantum mechanics one accepts this inevitability and allows complex numbers from the start. However, since the eigenvalues of physical operators are interpreted as the values of physical measurements, it is necessary to limit the operators to those that have real eigenvalues, namely Hermitean operators. This can be regarded as one of the main principles of quantum mechanics. This is fortunate because the resulting simplification is great. In classical mechanics complex quantities also necessarily intrude, and so also do eigenvalue problems, and with them complex eigenvalues. But these eigenvalues do not have to be real, and there is no justification for restricting operators to those that are Hermitean. This is unfortunate, because the resultant formalism is “heavy.” As a result, this mathematics has not been much used in classical mechanics and cannot be said to be essential to the subject. Nevertheless the unitary formalism is consistent with the ideas that have been encountered in this chapter. It may also be interesting to see quantum methods applied to classical problems. However, since our operators will in general not be Hermitean, results cannot be carried from one field to the other as easily as we might wish. The main application of the theory in this section will be to analyze the solution of singular linear equations. This is more nearly algebra than geometry, but the results can be interpreted geometrically. They will be used while discussing linearized Hamiltonians and will be essential for the development of perturbation theory in the last chapter of the text. Other than this, the material will not be used. Because complex eigenvalues and eigenvectors are unavoidable in analyzing linearized Hamiltonian equations, it provides major simplification to introduce “ad**This section and the rest of the chapter can be skipped until needed. The results are used only in discussing Hamiltonian eigenvectors starting in Section 15.3.4 and in developing near-symplectic perturbation theory in Chapter 16. On the other hand, its connection with quantum mechanical formalism may be of interest; it also serves as a fairly elementary generalization of ordinary Euclidean geometry and illustrates the association of a form with a vector.
UNITARY GEOMETRY
81
joint” equations and solutions. It is for similar reasons that Dirac’s “bras” and “kets” are used in quantum mechanics. For any two (possibly complex) vectors w and z, a “Hermitean scalar product” is defined by the sum
(w, z) = wi*zi;
(2.6.1)
for the rest of this section two vectors placed in parentheses like this will have this meaning. One can say therefore that the elements w’* are components of a covariant vector or form in a space dual to the space containing z. In this way an association is established between the original space and the dual space-the association is implemented by complex conjugation. This definition has the feature that . .
(z, z) = zi*z‘
= 1212
(2.6.2)
is necessarily real and positive (unless z = 0). This is the “metric” of unitary geometry. The vanishing of this product can be expressed “w is orthogonal to z.” More explicitly this means that the form associated with w vanishes when evaluated on vector z. The adjoint matrix At is obtained from A by the combined operation of transposition and complex conjugation (in either order);
At = A*T.
(2.6.3)
(In the case that A is real, which will normally be true in our applications, the adjoint is simply the transpose.) The motivation for this definition is provided by the following equation:
(w. Az) = (A’w, z).
(2.6.4)
Definition (2.6.3) is applicable to vectors as well; that is, zt is the row vector whose elements are the complex conjugates of the elements of column vector z. Hence Eq. (2.6.1) can also be written as
(w, z) = wtz.
(2.6.5)
Much of mechanics can be reduced to the solution of the equation
dz - = AZ dt
(2.6.6)
where z is a column vector of unknowns and A a matrix whose elements characterize the (linearized) dependence of “velocities” dz/dt on position z. In principle all these quantities (except t) could be complex, but it will not hurt to think of them all as real. The equation that is said to be adjoint to (2.6.6) is (2.6.7)
82
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICSI: LINEAR
This is not the same as “taking the adjoint” of Eq.(2.6.6), which yields
dzt - = ztAt dt
(2.6.8)
An important feature making the adjoint solution useful can be seen in the following.
Let x(t) be a solution of Eq. (2.6.7) and y(t) a solution of Eq. (2.6.6). We evaluate
d -(x, y) = (-Atx, y) dt
+ (x, Ay) = 0.
(2.6.9)
That is, the scalar product of any solution of the direct equation with any solution of the adjoint equation is a constant. Perhaps the solutions of Eq. (2.6.6) that are easiest to visualize are those whose initial values are zl(0) = (1,0,0, .. . ,O ) T , z2(0) = (0, 1,0, . . ., O ) T , and so on. One can form the “transfer matrix” M(t) of Eq. (2.6.6) by assembling these solutions as the columns
M(t) = (zl(t)
~ 2 ( t ) .. . ) .
(2.6.10)
Note that M(0) = 1, the identity matrix. A transfer matrix Mad’(?)of the adjoint equation can be defined similarly. The equations
d -Madj = -AtMadj dt
and
d -M=AM dt
(2.6.1 1)
can be used to show that the transfer matrices are related by
Mad’([) = (Mt)-’(t).
(2.6.12)
This relation is true at t = 0 since both sides are equal to 1 and it continues to be true for all t since, using Eqs. (2.6.1l), (2.6.13) In discussing perturbation theory we will frequently need the transfer matrix of the adjoint equation; we will always express Mad’ as it appears as on the right-hand side of Eq. (2.6.12) to reduce by one the number of confusingly related functions. The solutions of Eqs. (2.6.6) and (2.6.7) (2.6.14) are not particularly simply related. The best one can do is Eq. (2.6.9) and Eq. (2.6.12), along with the following converse statement. If a function $(x, t) = (z(t), x(t)) (obtained from test function z(t) and arbitrary solution x(t) of the first equation) is a constant of the motion of the first of these equations, then z(t)) satisfies the
UNITARY GEOMETRY
second equation. To confirm this, evaluate the rate of change of by hypothesis); +(z,Ax)= dt
83
+ (which vanishes
(Z
-+A’z,x
. )(2.6.15)
Assuming an arbitrary function can be formed by superposition of solutions x ( t ) , the desired result follows. In solving Eq.(2.6.6), the eigenvectorsof A play an important role. We can exploit Dirac-like notation to provide a “box” to contain the eigenvalue of a vector w = (w’,w 2 , . . . , w2n)Tthat is known to be an eigenvector of a matrix (operator) A with eigenvalue A. This provides a convenient labeling mechanism. For simplicity we assume h is nondegenerate. Symbolizing the eigenvector by w = /A), it therefore satisfies
Alh) = All-).
(2.6.16)
w2*,. . . , w ~ ~ *If )A. has p as an eigenvalue, then At Its adjoint is Ih)t = (wl*, has p* as eigenvalue. Define (pit to be the eigenvector of At with eigenvalue p*; it therefore satisfies At(Plt = CL*(Pl+.
(2.6.17)
The adjoint of this relation is (PIA = CL(II.1.
(2.6.18)
(11.1 can therefore also be said to be the “left eigenvector” of A with eigenvalue p. The scalar product of row vector (ul = ( u l , u2, . . . , ~ 2 n with ) Ih) = w is defined by
(2.6.19) which is the same as straight matrix multiplication. In general (A( and Ih), being left and right eigenvalues of the same matrix with the same eigenvalue, are not simply related, and neither are (A*l and /A). (Confirm this for yourself on a simple matrix like
(k i).)
But in the special case that A is
“self-adjoint” or “Hermitean,”
At = A ,
(2.6.20)
the situation is simpler. In quantum mechanics it is taken as a matter of principle that operators representing observable quantities satisfy (2.6.20), since this condition ensures that the eigenvalues are real. (You should reconstruct the proof that this is true.) We will not be able to make this assumption universally, but if A is Hermitean, Eq. (2.6.18) becomes
A ( A t = P(Plt, or (PIt = IF.).
(2.6.21)
84
GEOMETRY OF MECHANlCS [: LINEAR
Under the same circumstance (At = A), we have
(A I A) =
c
wi*wi = (w,w) E Iwl2 .
(2.6.22)
2.6.1. Solution of Singular Sets of Linear Equations Adjoint matrices can be usefully applied to the problem of solving linear algebraic equations of the form AX = b,
(2.6.23)
where A is a square, 2n x 2n matrix and b is a 2n-element column vector. (The number of equations being even has no significance, other than that this is always the case in Hamiltonian mechanics.) All elements are (possibly complex) constants. In the trivial case that det IAl # 0, the solution is
x = A-’b,
(2.6.24)
but the situation is more complicated if det IAI = 0, since Eq. (2.6.23) may or may not be solvable. In ordinary geometry Eq.(2.6.23) could be the formulation of a problem “find vector x whose dot products with a set of vectors a(1),a(2),.,.. are equal to the set of values b .= ( b l ,bZ, . ..).7729 The matrix A would have a{1) as its upper row of elements, a:2, as its second row, and so on. The determinant of A vanishes if any combination of the a’s are mutually dependent, say for simplicity a(1)= a(2). In this case, EQ. (2.6.23) would be solvable, if at all, only if 61 = b2. In general, dependency among the rows of A has to be reflected in corresponding dependency among the elements of b. If det IAl = 0, there is a nonvanishing vector z satisfying the equation ATz = 0. (For the simple example mentioned in the previous paragraph this would be z = (1, - 1, 0, 0, . . .).) A necessary condition that has to be satisfied by b for the equations to be solvable can be obtained from the matrix product zTb = Z’AX = ( A = z ) ~ x= 0. One would therefore conclude that Eq. (2.6.23) could be solvable only if b is orthogonal to z. For the simple example this implies bl = b2, as already stated. The initial statement of the problem just discussed made it appear that the set of equations under discussion was specific to metric geometry, but this is misleading. With no metric defined, no product of vector a(i)with vector x can be defined. But the rows of the original matrix A can always be regarded as the components a(i)jof one-forms &. Then the individual equations are a(i)jx’ = bi. It is then no longer appropriate to regard b as a vector. These reinterpretations of the meaning of quantities entering Eq. (2.6.23) have no effect on the necessary condition for its solvability, 29AU entries in A and b would be real in ordinary geometry,and solutions for which entries in x are complex would be declared unacceptable. Such solutions would however be judged acceptable from the point of view of this section.
UNITARY GEOMETRY
85
since it was derived algebraically. The solvability condition is (6,z) = 0, which involves only the invariant product defined for any linear vector space. In the remainder of this section, conditions like this one for the solvability of Eq.(2.6.23) will be based on the Hermitean product (2.6.1). In this case it is a priori natural to think of b and the rows of A as forms. Though the overhead tildes will not be used, the temptation to think of b and x as belonging to the same space should be resisted. Since things become seriously messy if 0 is a multiple root of A, we will initially assume this to not be the case. Let y and z then be the solutions (unique up to multiplicativefactors) of the “homogeneous” and “adjoint homogeneous” equations:
Ay=O
and Atz=O.
(2.6.25)
Conjecturing that x satisfies Eq. (2.6.23), we form the scalar (2,
b) = (2, AX) = (Atz, X) = 0.
(2.6.26)
Certainly then, Eq. (2.6.23) can be solved only if b is “orthogonal” to z in the sense that (2, b) = 0. Conversely, suppose (2,
b) = 0.
(2.6.27)
The vector z can be chosen as a basis vector in the dual space, say the first, and 2n - 1 more basis vectors can be chosen, arbitrary except for being independent. We assemble these column vectors into a 2n x 2n matrix Z. In a similar way we form a square matrix Y whose first column is y (defined above) and whose other columns are arbitrary but independent. Next form the matrix
ZtAY=(. 0 A0o ) ,
(2.6.28)
which has been partitioned into a 1 x 1 element in the upper left, a (2n - I ) x (2n - 1) matrix A0 in the lower right, and so on. The elements shown to vanish do so because of the conditions previously placed on z and y. Also, because of the assumed absence of multiple roots, the matrix A0 has to be nonsingular. We return to the original Eq.(2.6.23), changing variables according to
x’ = Y-’x,
and defining b’ = Ztb.
(2.6.29)
The equations become
(o0
Ao)x’ 0 = b’ G ((:b)).
(2.6.30)
The uppermost element of b’ is (z, b). If this vanishes, then Eq. (2.6.30) is solvable; otherwise it is not. Supposing that (z, b) = 0, we can find a “particular solution” of
86
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
Eq. (2.6.23), (0, x:)~, whose uppermost element is 0 and whose remaining elements satisfy Am = b or x g = A g l b N .
(2.6.31)
The matrix inversion is necessarily possible. From here on, the vector xo will be augmented by another uppermost component with value 0. We have found therefore that the condition (z, b) = 0, with z satisfying the first of Eqs. (2.6.25), is necessary and sufficient for the solvability of the original equation in the event that det IAJ= 0. Assured of the existence of a solution xo, we ask whether it is unique. Obviously not, since xo can be augmented by any multiple of y and still remain a solution. Since one prefers to have unique solutions, it is worth establishing a disciplined procedure for placing a minimal further requirement or requirements that pick out, from the set of solutions, the particular one that satisfies the extra requirements. In this spirit we insist that x also satisfy
(y, x) = 0,
which is to say ytx = 0.
(2.6.32)
Consider then the equation (A - ZY+)X = b,
(2.6.33)
which is the same as the original equation except for the second term. (Note that the second term (in parentheses) is a column vector multiplying a row vector, which yields a square matrix of the same size as A.) But our condition (2.6.32) makes the second term vanish. The unique solution to our augmented problem is therefore given by x = (A - zyt)-'b,
(2.6.34)
provided this matrix is not itself singular. Since the properties of z have not been used, the factor z could be replaced by (almost) any other, and it is unthinkable that the matrix would always be singular. But for the particular choice of z (the solution to the homogeneous adjoint equation), the matrix in Eq. (2.6.33) can be shown to be nonsingular. For the proof, it is enough to show that the only solution of the equation (A - zyt)yo is yo = 0. This is left as a not particularly easy exercise. Commonly the zero root of A is multiple, say double, in which case the homogeneous equation has two independent solutions, say y1 and y2. Since any linear combination of these is also a solution, these are not uniquely determined but, other than being independent, they can be chosen arbitrarily. Similarly the adjoint homogeneous equation has two independent solutions z1 and 2 2 . All of the above arguments can be generalized to cover this situation. Eq.(2.6.27) is generalized by accumulating the adjoint homogeneous solutionsjust mentioned as the columns of a matrix
V=(z1
22).
(2.6.35)
UNITARY GEOMETRY
87
The necessary and sufficient condition for the solvability of Eq. (2.6.1) is then
Vtb = 0.
(2.6.36)
In words, b must be orthogonal to all solutions of the adjoint homogeneous equation. The main increase in complexity comes in generalizing condition (2.6.32). We accumulate also the solutions of the direct homogeneous equation as the columns of a matrix.
u=(Yl
Y2)>
(2.6.37)
and place the extra condition on solution x that
u t x = 0.
(2.6.38)
(A - W t ) x = b,
(2.6.39)
Replacing Eq. (2.6.33) by
the unique solution of the original equation, augmented by condition (2.6.38) is given by
x = (A - W t ) - ' b .
(2.6.40)
Roots of even higher multiplicity can be handled in the same way. Later in the text, operators like the one appearing on the right-hand side of this equation, which generate a unique solution consistent with subsidiary conditions, will be symbolized by S,as in
x = Sb,
where S = (A - VUt)-'.
Problem 2.6.1: For the matrix A = this section.
(2.6.41)
( i)check all the formulas appearing in
When equations like Eq. (2.6.23) arise in a purely algebraic context they are often expected to be nonsingular, for example because they solve a well-posed problem. But it is more common for Eq.(2.6.23) to be singular in a geometric context. For example, in ordinary geometry, if A represents a projection onto the ( x , y ) plane followed by a rotation around the z axis, then Eq. (2.6.23) can be solved only if b lies in the ( x , y) plane, and the solution is unique only up to the possible addition of any vector parallel to the z-axis. The equations of this section have similar geometric interpretations for unitary geometry. In technology (and later in this text) the sort of analysis that has been applied to Eq. (2.6.23) is often somewhat generalized. Let the n-component vector x = ( x ' , . . . ,x") be replaced by x(t), a vector functim depending on a continuous parameter ?.Apart from possible new requirements, such as continuity,this amounts to
88
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS I: LINEAR
little more than letting n +. 00. Suppose also that b is replaced by “drive” f(t) and A by linear “response operator” md2/dt2 k:
+
(m$
+ k) x ( t ) = f(t).
(2.6.42)
This equation can have “transient” solutions with f = 0 and “driven” solutions with f # 0. Important practical issues are whether a driven solution exists and, if it does, how the transient content of the solution is made unique by insisting that other conditions be satisfied. Examples of the use of the notation, manipulations,and results of this section can be found starting in Section 15.3.4.
BIBLIOGRAPHY References 1. R. Abraham and J. E. Marsden, Foundations of Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1985. 2. B. F.Schutz, Geometrical Methods of Mathematical Physics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 1995. 3. V. I. Arnold, Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics, 2nd ed., Springer-Verlag, New York, 1989. 4. B. L. Van der Waerden, Algebra. Vol. 1, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1991.
References for Further Study Section 2.2 E. Cartan, Lqons sur la gkometrie des espaces de Riemann, Gauthiers-Villas, Paris, 195 1. (English translation available.) J. A. Schouten, TensorAnalysisfor Physicists, 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1954.
Section 2.5 E. Cartan, The Theory of Spinors, Dover, 198 1
I
Section 2.6 H.Weyl, The Theory of Groups and Quantum Mechanics, Dover, New York, p 1-27. V. Yakubovitch and V. M. Starzhinskii, Linear Direrential Equations with Periodic Coeficients, Wiley, New York, 1975.
3 GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR 3.1. (REAL) CURVILINEAR COORDINATES IN N-DIMENSIONS 3.1.1. Introduction In this section the description of orbits in real n-dimensional Euclidean space is considered, but using nonrectangular coordinates. The case n = 3 will be called “ordinary geometry.” Generalizing to cases with n > 3 is unnecessary for describing trajectories in ordinary space, but it begins to approach the generality of mechanics, where realistic problems require the introduction of arbitrary numbers of generalized coordinates. Unfortunately the Euclidean requirement (i.e., the Pythagorean theorem) is typically not satisfied in generalized coordinates. However, analysis of curvilinear coordinates in ordinary geometry already requires the introduction of mathematical methods like those needed in more general situations. It seems sensible to digest this mathematics in this intuitively more familiar setting rather than in the more abstract mathematical setting of differentiable manifolds. In the n = 3 case, much of the analysis to be performed may already be familiar, for example from courses in electricity and magnetism. For calculating fields from symmetric charge distributions, for example one that is radially symmetric, it is obviously convenient to use spherical rather than rectangular coordinates. This is even more true for solving boundary value problems with curved boundaries. For solving such problems, curvilinear coordinate systems that conform with the boundary must be used. It is therefore necessary to be able to express the vector operations of gradient, divergence, and curl in terms of these “curvilinear” coordinates. Vector theorems such as Gauss’s and Stokes’s need to be similarly generalized. In electricity and magnetism one tends to restrict oneself to geometricaliy simple coordinate systems such as polar or cylindrical systems, and in those cases some of the following formulas can be derived by more elementary methods. Here we con89
90
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
sider general curvilinear coordinates where local axes are not only not parallel at different points in space (as is true already for polar and cylindrical coordinates) but may be skew, not orthonormal. Even the description of force-free particle motion in terms of such curvilinear coordinates is not trivial-confirm this by describing forcefree motion using cylindrical coordinates. More generally, one is interested in particle motion in the presence of forces that are most easily described using particular curvilinear coordinates. Consider, for example, a beam of particles traveling inside an elliptical vacuum tube which also serves as a wave guide for an electromagnetic wave. Since solution of the wave problem requires the use of elliptical coordinates, one is forced to analyze the particle motion using the same coordinates. To face this problem seriously would probably entail mainly numerical procedures, but the use of coordinates conforming to the boundaries would be essential. The very setting up of the problem for numerical solution requires a formulation such as the present one. The problem just mentioned is too specialized for detailed analysis in a text such as this; these comments have been intended to show that the geometry to be studied has more than academic interest. But, as stated before, our primary purpose is to assimilate the necessary geometry as another step on the way to the geometric formulation of mechanics. Even such a conceptually simple task as describing straight-line motion using curvilinear coordinates will be instructive. 3.1.2. The Metric Tensor An n-dimensional “Euclidean” space is defined to consist of vectors x whose components along rectangular axes are xl, x2, . . . ,x ” , now assumed to be real. The “length” of this vector is x . x = X I 2 +x2
2
+ . . . +x”!
(3.1.1)
The “scalar product” of vectors x and y is x . y = x I y 1 + x 2y2 + . * . + x ” y ” .
(3.1.2)
The angle 0 between x and y is defined by (3.1.3) repeating the earlier result Eq. (2.5.18). That this angle is certain to be real follows from the well-known Schwarz inequality. A fundamental “orthonormal” set of “basis vectors” can be defined as the vectors having rectangular components el = (1,0,.,.,O),ez= (0, 1,...,0), etc. More general “Cartesian” or “skew” components are related to the Euclidean components by linear transformations xli
= Aijxj,
xi = (A-l)ijx’J.
(3.1.4)
Such a homogeneous linear transformation between Cartesian frames is known as a “centered-affine” transformation. If the equations are augmented by (possibly
(REAL) CURVILINEAR COORDINATES IN N-DIMENSIONS
91
vanishing) additive constants, the transformation is given the more general name ‘‘fine.” In terms of the new components the scalar product in (3.1.2) is given by (3.1.5) where the coefficients g’,k are the primed-system components of the metric tensor. Clearly they are symmetric under the interchange of indices, and the quadratic form with x = y has to be positive definite. In the original rectangular coordinates gjk = 6jk, where 6,k is the Kronecker symbol with value 1 for equal indices and 0 for unequal indices. In the new frame, the basis vectors ell = (1, 0, . . . ,0), e’2 = (0, 1, . . . , 0), etc., are not orthonormal in general, in spite of the fact that their given contravariant components superficially suggest it; rather (3.1.6)
e fI . . eJ’ .--k ’ i j . f
As defined so far, the coefficients gjk are constant, independent of position in space. Here, by “position in space” we mean “in the original Euclidean space.” For many purposes, the original rectangular coordinates x ’ , x 2 , .. . ,X” would be adequate to locate objects in this space and, though they will be kept in the background throughout most of the following discussion, they will remain available for periodically “getting our feet back on the ground.” These coordinates will also be said to define the “base frame” or, when mechanics intrudes, as an “inertial” frame.’ As mentioned previously, “curvilinear” systems, such as radial, cylindrical, or elliptical systems, are sometimes required. Letting u l , u 2 , . . . , u” be such coordinates, space is filled with corresponding coordinate curves; on each of the %’curves,” u1 varies while u 2 , . . . , U” are fixed, and so on. Sufficiently close to any particular point P, the coordinate curves are approximately linear. In this neighborhood the curvilinear infinitesimal deviations Au’ , Au2, . . . , Au“ can be used to define the scalar product of deviations Ax and Ay:
This equation differs from Eq. (3.1.5) only in that the coefficients g j k ( P ) are now permitted to be functions of position P? The quantity 4 is designated as IAxl or as As and is known as “arc length.” ’There is no geometric significance whatsoever to a coordinate frame’s being inertial, but the base frame will occasionally be called inertial as a mnemonic aid to physicists, who are accustomed to the presence of a preferred frame such as this. The curvilinear frame under study may or may not be rotating or accelerating. 21n this way, a known coordinate transformationhas determined a corresponding metric tensor g , k ( P ) . Conversely, one can contemplate a space described by components u’ , u 2 , . . . u” and metric tensor g , k ( P ) , with given dependence on P, and inquire whether a transformation to components for which the scalar product is Euclidean can be found. The answer, in general, is no. A condition that must be satisfied to ensure that the answer to this question be yes is given in Cartan [I].
.
92
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
FIGURE 3.1.1. Relating the “natural” local coordinate axes at two different points in ordinary space described by curvilinear coordinates. Because this is a Euclidean plane, the unit vectors el and e2 at M can be “parallel slid to point M +dM without changing their lengths or directions; they are shown there as dashed arrows. The curve labeled u h + 1 is the curve on which u1 has increased by 1, and so on.
3.1.3. Relating Coordinate Systems at Different Points in Space One effect of the coordinates’ being curvilinear is to complicate the comparison of objects at disjoint locations. The quantities that will now enter to discipline such comparisons are called “Christoffel coefficients.” Deriving them is the purpose of this section. Consider the coordinate system illustrated in Fig. 3.1.1, with M dM(ul d u l . u2 d u 2 , . . . , u” d u n ) being a point close to the point M(ul, u2, . . . , u“). (The figure is planar but the discussion will be n-dimensional.) For example, the curvilinear coordinates ( u ’ , u2, . . . , u”) might be polar coordinates (I;8,Cp). The vectors M and M dM can be regarded as vectors locating the points relative to an origin not shown; their base frame coordinates (x’ ,x2, . . . ,x”) refer to a rectangular basis in the base frame centered there; one assumes the base frame coordinates are known in terms of the curvilinear coordinates and vice versa. At every point, “natural” basis vectors3 (el, e2, . , .en) can be defined having the following properties:
+
+
+
+
+
ei is tangent to the coordinate curve on which u i varies while the other coordinates are held constant. Without loss of generality i can be taken to be 1 in subsequent discussion. 0
With the tail of el at M, its tip is at the point where the first component has increased from u’ to u’ 1.
+
3The basis vectors being introduced at this point are none other than the basis vectors called 8 / 6 u 1,
B/Bu2,etc.. in Section 2.4.5,but we ref’rain from using that notation here.
(REAL) CURVILINEAR COORDINATES IN N-DIMENSIONS
93
However, the previous definition has to be qualified because the unit increment of a coordinate may be great enough to cause the coordinate curve to veer noticeably away from the straight basis vector-think, for example, of a change in polar angle @ -+ @ 1 radian. Clearly the rigorous definition of the “length” of a particular basis vector, say el, requires a careful limiting process. Instead, forsaking any pretense of rigor, let us assume the scale along the u 1 coordinate curve has been expanded sufficiently by “choosing the units” of u1 to make the unit vector coincide with the coordinate curve to whatever accuracy is considered adequate.
+
0
0
We will be unable to refrain from using the term “unit vector” to describe a basis vector ei, even though doing so is potentially misleading because, at least in physics, the term “unit vector” usually connotes a vector of unit length; the traditional notation for a vector parallel to ei, having unit length, is 6.Here we have ei 11 $ but $ = ei/leil.
If one insists on ascribing physical dimensions to the ei, one must allow the dimensions to be different for different i. For example, if (el, e2, e3) correspond to (r, 8, @), then the first basis vector has units of length while the other two are dimensionless. Though this may seem unattractive, it is not unprecedented in physics-one is accustomed to a relativistic 4-vector having time as2nz coordinate and distances as the others. On the other hand, the vectors @, 8,4) all have units of meters-but this is not much of an advantage since, as mentioned previously, the lengths of these vectors are somewhat artificial in any case.
Hence, deviating from traditional usage in elementary physics, we will use the basis vectors ei exclusively, even calling them unit vectors in spite of their not having unit length. Dimensional consistency wiIi be enforced separately. Dropping quadratic (and higher) terms, the displacement vector dM can be expanded in terms of basis vectors at point M:4
d~ = d u ’ e l + du2e2 + .dunen = du‘ei.
(3.I .8)
Note that this equation imples aM/aul = e l , aM/au2 = e2, etc. At each point other than M, the coordinate curves define a similar “natural” nplet of unit vectors. The reason that “natural” is placed in quotation marks here and above is that what is natural in one context may be unnatural in another. Once the particular coordinate curves (u’,u2, .. . ,u ” ) have been selected, the corresponding n-plet (el, e2, . . .,en) is natural, but that does not imply that the coordinates ( u l , u2,. . . , u”) themselves were in any way fundamental. Our present task is to express the frame (e’l ,e’2, . . . , e’n)at M dM in terms of the frame ( e l ,e2, . . . ,en) at M. Working with just two components for simplicity,
+
4A physicist might interpret Eq. (3.1.8) as an approximate equation in which quadratic terms have been neglected; a mathematician might regard it as an exact expansion in the “tangent space” at M.
94
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICSIt: CURVILINEAR
the first basis vector can be approximated as
e’l = el
+ del = el + q l e l + wfe2
(3.1.9a)
The (yet to be determined) coefficients oij can be said to be “affine-connecting” as they connect quantities in affinely related frames; the coefficients r j k are known as Christoffel symbols or as an “affine connection.” Both forms of Eq. (3.1.9) will occur frequently in the sequel, with the (b) form being required when the detailed dependence on coordinates ui has to be exhibited, and the simpler (a) form being adequate when all that is needed is an expansion of new basis vectors in terms of old. Here, as in the previous chapter, we employ a standard but bothersome notational practice; the incremental expansion coefficients have been written as q’rather than as doi’-a notation that would be harmless for the time being but would clash later on when the notation do is conscripted for another purpose. To a physicist it seems wrong for a differential quantity del to be a superpositionof quantities like ullel that appear, notationally, to be nondifferential. But, having already accepted the artificial nature of the units of the basis vectors, we can adopt this notation, promising to sort out the units and differentials later. The terminology “affine connection” anticipates more general situations in which such connections do not necessarily exist. This will be the case for general “manifolds’’ (spaces describable, for example, by “generalized coordinates” and hence essentially more general than the present Euclidean space). For general manifolds there is no “intrinsic” way to relate coordinate frames at different points in the space. Here “intrinsic” means “independent of a particular choice of coordinates.” This can be expressed by the following prohibition against illegitimate vector superposition: A vector at one point cannot be expanded in basis vectors belonging to a different point?
After this digression we return to the Euclidean context and Eq. (3.1.9).Thisequation appears to be doing the very thing that is not allowed, namely expanding e’l in terms of the ei . The reason it is legitimate in this case is that there is an intrinsic way of relating frames at M and M + dM-it is the traditional parallelism of ordinary geometry, as shown in Fig. 3.1.1. One is really expanding e’l in terms of the vectors ei slid parallel from M to M dM.All too soon, the concept of “parallelism” will have to be scrutinized more carefully, but for now, since we are considering ordinary space, the parallelism of a vector at M and a vector at M dM has its usual, intuitively natural meaning-for example, basis vectors el and e’l in the figure are almost parallel, while e2 and e’2 are not. With this interpretation,Q.(3.1.9) is a relation entirely among vectors at M+dM. The coefficients oiJand rijkbeing well defined, we proceed to determine them,
+
+
’This may seem counterintuitive; if you prefer, for now replace “cannot” by “must not” and regard it as a matter of dictatorial edict.
(REAL) CURVILINEAR COORDINATES IN N-DIMENSIONS
95
starting by rewriting Eq. (3.1.9) in compressed notation:
e', = ei
+ dei = ei + wij ej = ei
(3.1.10a)
+ riJkduke j .
(3.1.lob)
The quantities 0.'
= rijkdUk
(3.1.1 1)
are one-forms, linear in the differentials duk.6The new basis vectors must satisfy Q. (3.1.6):
e/ i .eI r = gjr
+ dgjr = (ei + mi'
e j ) . (e,
+ a,"e s ).
(3.1.12)
Dropping quadratic terms, this can be written succinctly as
+
dgj, = wiJg,, w,Sgi, '2 W i r
+
Ori.
(3.1.13)
(Because the quantities w i j are not the components of a true tensor, the final step is not a manifestly covariant, index-lowering tensor operation, but it can nonetheless serve to define the quantities wij, having two lower indices.) Because also
dgi, - ( a g i , / a u J )d u J ,one obtains
(3.1.14)
For reasons to be made clear shortly, we have written the identical equation three times, but with indices permuted, substitutions like gri = gir having been made in some terms, and the first equation having been multiplied through by - 1.
+
Problem 3.1.1: Show that Eqs. (3.1.14) yield n2(n 1)/2 equations that can be applied toward determining the n3 coefficients rijk.Relate this to the number of parameters needed to fix the scales and relative angles of a skew basis set. For the n = 3, ordinary geometry case, how many more parameters are needed to fix the absolute orientation of a skew frame? How many more conditions on the ri'k does this imply? Both for n = 3 and in general, how many more conditions will have to be found to make it possible to determine all of the Christoffel coefficients? old references they were known as pfaffian forms.
%
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
3.1.3.1. Digression Concerning “Flawed Coordinate Systems.” Two city dwellers part company intending to meet after taking different routes. The first goes east for N E street numbers, then north for NN street numbers. The second goes north for N N street numbers, then east for N E street numbers. Clearly they will not meet up in most cases because the street numbers have not been established carefully enough. Will their paths necessarily cross if they keep going long enough? Because cities are predominantly two-dimensional, they usually will. But it is not hard to visualize the presence of a tunnel on one of the two routes that leads one of the routes below the other without crossing it. In dimensions higher than two that is the generic situation. Though it was not stated before, we now require our curvilinear coordinate system to be free of the two flaws just mentioned. At least locally, this can be ensured by requiring (3.1.15) When expressed in vector terms using Eq. (3.1.8), the quantities being differentiated here can be expressed
aM
(3.1. I 6 )
aui = ei* Hence, using Eq. (3.1.10)b, we require
(3.1.17) This requirement that ryi be symmetric in its lower indices yields n2(n - 1)/2 further conditions which, along with the n2(n 1)/2 conditions of Eq. (3.1.14), should permit us to determine all n3 of the Christoffel coefficients. It can now be seen why Eq. (3.1.14) was written three times. Adding the three equations and taking advantage of Eq. (3.1.17) yields
+
(3.1.18) For any particular values of “free indices” i and j (and suppressing them to make the equation appear less formidable) this can be regarded as a matrix equation of the form gkrrr
= Rk
or GI’ = R.
(3.1.19)
Here G is the matrix (gkr) introduced previously, r = (r,)is the set of Christoffel symbols for the particular values of i and j , and R = (&) is the corresponding righthand side of Eq. (3.1.18). The distinction between upper and lower indices has been
(REAL)CURVILINEAR COORDINATES IN N-DIMENSIONS
97
ignored? Being a matrix equation, this can be solved without difficulty to complete the detemzination of the Christoffel symbols:
r =G-~R,
(3.1.20)
and the same can be done for each i , j pair. Though these manipulations may appear overly formal at this point, an example given below will show that they are quite manageable. 3.1.4. The Covariant (or Absolute) Differential There is considerable difference between mathematical and and physical intuition in the area of differentiation. Compounding this, there is a plethora of distinct types of derivative, going by names such as total, invariant, absolute, covariant, variational, gradient, divergence,curl, Lie, exterior, Frechkt, Lagrange, etc. Each of these-some are just different names for the same thing4ombines the common concepts of differential calculus with other concepts. In this chapter some of these terms are explained, and eventually nearly all will be. The differential in the denominator of a derivative is normally a scalar, or at least a one-component object, often d t , while the numerator is often a multicomponent object. The replacement oft by a monotonically related variable, say s = f(r), makes a relatively insignificant change in the multicomponent derivatives-all components of the derivative are multiplied by the same factor d t l d s . This makes it adequate to work with differentials rather than derivatives in most cases, and that is what we will do. We will disregard as inessential the distinction between the physicist’s view of a differential as an approximation to a small but finite change and the mathematician’s view of a differential as a finite yet exact displacement along a tangent vector. We start with a type of derivative that may be familiar to physicists in one guise, yet mysterious in another; the familiar form is that of coriolis or centrifugal acceleration. Physicists know that Newton’s first law-free objects do not accelerateapplies only in inertial frames of reference. If one insists on using an accelerating frame of reference-say one fixed to the earth, incorporating latitude, longitude, and altitude-the correct description of projectile motion requires augmenting the true forces, gravity and air resistance, by “fictitious” coriolis and centrifugal forces. These extra forces compensate for the fact that the reference frame is not inertial. Many physicists, perhaps finding the introduction of fictitious forces artificial and hence distasteful, or perhaps having been too well-taught in introductory physics that “there is no such thing as centrifugal force,” resist this approach and prefer a strict inertial frame description. Here we insist instead on a noninertial description using the curvilinear coordinates introduced in the previous section. ’Failing to distinguish between upper and lower indices ruins the invariance of equations as far as transformation between different frames is concerned, but it is valid in any particular frame. In any case, since the quantities on the two sides of Eq. (3.1.19) are not tensors, distinction between upper and lower indices would be unjustified.
98
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
A particle trajectory can be described by curvilinear coordinates u ' ( t ) , u 2 ( t ) , . . . , u"(f) giving its location as a function of time r. For example, uniform motion on a circle of radius R is described by r = R, Q = o f . The velocity v has curvilinear velocity components that are dejned by .
du' dt
V ' E - E U ,
.i
(3.1.21)
In the circular motion example, i. = 0. Should one then define curvilinear acceleration components by (3.1.22) No! One could define acceleration this way, but it would lead, for example, to the result that the radial acceleration in uniform circular motion is zero-certainly not consistent with conventional terminology. Here is what has gone wrong: while v is a perfectly good arrow, and hence a true vector, its components vi are projections onto axes parallel to the local coordinate axes. Though these local axes are not themselves rotating, a frame moving so that its origin coincides with the particle and having its axes always parallel to local axes has to be rotating relative to the inertial frame. One is violating the rules of Newtonian mechanics. Here is what can be done about it: Calculate acceleration components relative to the base frame. Before doing this we establish a somewhat more general framework by introducing the concept of vectorjeld. A vecforjeld V ( P ) is a vector function of position that assigns an arrow V to each point P in space. An example with V = r, the radius vector from a fixed origin, is illustrated in Fig. 3.1.2. (Check the two boldface arrows with a ruler to confirm V = r.) In the figure the same curvilinear coordinate system as appeared in Fig. 3.1.1 is assumed to be in use. At each point the curvilinear components V' of the vector V are defined to be the coefficients in the expansion of V in terms of local basis vectors:
v = Vie'.
(3.1.23)
The absolute differential DV of a vector function V( P ) . like any differential, is the change in V that accompanies a change in its argument, in the small change limit. For this to be meaningful it is, of course, necessary to specify what is meant by the changes. In Fig. 3.1.2, in the (finite) change of position from point M to point M',the change in V is indicated by the arrow labeled V' - V; being an arrow, it is manifestly a true vector. Jh terms of local coordinates, the vectors at M and M' are given, respectively, by
V
= V ( M ) = V'el
+ V2e2,
V' = V(M') = V'le'I
+ VI2e'2.
(3.1.24)
In the limit of small changes, using Eq. (3.1.10a), one has
DV
= d(V')ej + V j d ( e , ) = d(V')ei + V j u j i e i = ( d ( V ' ) + V j m j i ) e j . (3.1.25)
(REAL) CURVILlNEAR COORDINATES IN N-DIMENSIONS
99
FIGURE 3.1.2. The vector field V ( P ) = r(P). where r(P) is a radius vector from point 0 to point P, expresssed in terms of the local curvilinear coordinates shown in Fig. 3.1.1. The change V’ - V in going from point M to point M’ is shown.
This differential (a true vector by construction) can be seen to have contravariant components given by
DV’=(DV)‘= d V ‘ + V J w j i ~ d V ’ + V j , J ! . ~ d u ~ ,
(3.1.26)
where the duk are the curvilinear components of M’relative to M. (Just this time) a certain amount of care has been taken with the placement of parentheses in these Note that, since equations. The main thing to notice is the definition DV E (DV)’. the components uk and V’ are known functions of position, their differentials duk and d V’ are unambiguous; there is no need to introduce symbols D(uk) and D( V‘) since, if one did, their meanings would just be duk and d V’ . On the other hand the quantity DV is a newly defined true vector whose components are being first evaluated in Eq.(3.1.26). (It might be pedagogically more helpful if these components rather than by DV but since that is never done, were always symbolized by (DV)’ it is necessary to remember the meaning some other way. (For the moment the superscript i has been moved slightly away to suggest that it “binds somewhat less tightly” to V than does the D.)Note then that the DV are the components of a true vector, while d V ’ , differential changes expressed in local coordinates, are not. DV is commonly called the covariunt differential; this causes DV to be the “contravariant components of the covariant differential.” Since this is unwieldy, we will use the term absolute differential rather than covarianfdifferential. If the vector
’
’;
’
100
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
being differentiated is a constant vector A , it follows that D A = 0,
.
.
and hence, d A i = -AJ#,’.
(3.1.27)
How to obtain the covariant components of the absolute differential of a variable vector V is the subject of the following problem.
Problem 3.1.2: Consider the scalar product, V . A , of a variable vector V and an arbitrary constant vector A. Its differential, as calculated in the base frame, could be designated D (V . A), while its differential in the local frame could be designated d (V . A). Since the change of a scalar should be independent of frame, these two differentials must be equal. Use this, and Eq. (3.1.27) and the fact that A is arbitrary, to show that the covariant components of the absolute differentials of vector V are given by D v i = d V j - vkaik .
(3.1.28)
If ?; is the form naturally associated with V then the DVi are the components of a form E V .
Problem 3.1.3: The line of reasoning of the previous problem can be generalized to derive the absolute differential of more complicated tensors. Consider, for example, a mixed tensor aiJ having one upper and one lower index. Show that the absolute differential of this tensor is given by Da
iJ
= d a i J - akJ‘ wi k
+ aik #k j .
(3.1.29)
Problem 3.1.4: Ricci’s Theorem. Derived as in the previous two problems, Dai, = dai, - ak, mik - aik w j k .
(3.1.30)
Using this formula and Eq. (3.1.13), evaluate Dgij, the absolute differential of the metric tensor gi,, and show that it vanishes. This means that the metric tensor elements act like constants for absolute differentiation. Use this result to show that the absolute differential D ( A .B ) of the scalar product of two constant vectors A and B vanishes (as it must). Because the concept of absolute differentiation is both extremely important and quite confusing, some recapitulation may be in order. Since the difference of two arrows is an arrow, the rate of change of an arrow is an arrow. Stated more conventionally, the rate of change of a true vector is a true vector. Confusion enters only when a vector is represented by its components. It is therefore worth emphasizing that The components of the rate of change of vector V are not, in general, the rates of change of the components of V.
(REAL) CURVILINEAR COORDINATES IN N-DIMENSIONS
101
This applies to all true tensors. Unfortunately, since practical calculation almost always requires the introduction of components, it is necessary to develop careful formulas, expressed in component form, for differentiating vectors (and all other tensors). The derivation of a few of these formulas is the subject of the set of problems just above. 3.1.5. Derivation of the Lagrange Equations of Mechanics from the Absolute Differential In mechanics one frequently has the need for coordinate systems that depend on position (curvilinear) or time (rotating or accelerating). Here we analyze the former case while continuing to exclude the latter. That is, the coefficients of the metric tensor can depend on position but are assumed to be independent of t . On the other hand, the positions of the particle or particles being described certainly vary with time. In this section we symbolize coordinates by q’ rather than the ui used to this point. There is no significance whatsoever to this change other than the fact that generalized coordinates in mechanics are usually assigned the symbol q . The first vector to be subjected to invariant differentiation will be the position vector of a point following a given trajectory.
Example 3.Z.Z: Motion that is simple when described in one set of coordinates may be quite complicated in another. For example, consider a particle moving parallel to the x axis at y = 6 with constant speed u. That is (x = u t , y = 6). In spherical coordinates, with 6 = 71/2, the particle displacement is given by 6 r=sin 4 ’
4 =tan-
1 -.6
ut
The time derivatives are U
vrri=ucos4,
v@E$=---sin24; 6
following our standard terminology for velocities, we have defined v‘ = i and v@ = 6. (This terminology is by no means universal, however. It has the disagreeable feature that the components are not the projections of the same arrow onto mutually orthonormal axes, as Fig. 3.1.3 shows. Also they have different units. They are, however, the contravariant components of a true vector along well-defined local axes.) Taking another time derivative yields u2 F = -sin 6
3
..
4, 4 =
2u2 -CCOS~
b2
sin34.
Defining by the term “absolute acceleration”the acceleration in an inertial coordinate frame, the absolute acceleration obviously should vanish in this motion. And yet
102
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
X
Ut
FIGURE 3.1.3. A particle moves parallel to the x-axis at constant speed u.
the quantities i: and Example 3.1.4.
6 are nonvanishing. We will continue this example below in
Example 3.1.2: In cylindrical ( r , 4, z) coordinates the nonvanishing Christoffel elements are 1 r22 = -r,
(as will be shown shortly). The polar components of r = (r, 0) components of the covariant derivative with respect to r are
= (4' , q 2 ) and the
That is, (i-, t$) are the polar components of D r l d t . This is a misleadingly simple result, however. It follows from the result that, if r = rer is the radius vector of a particle, and r is taken as its first, and its only nonvanishing, coordinate, then Dq'ldr = 4' rr'i,:. For this particular choice of coordinates, the second term vanishes. In general, though the elements dq' transform like the components of a vector, the coordinates q' themselves do not, because they are macroscopic quantities that cannot be expected to have properties derived from linearization. Hence the quantities Dq' have nondescript geometric character and should perhaps not even have been written down. Nevertheless, (q l , q 2 , . . . ,q") is a true vector.
+
Exumpfe3.1.3: This same result can be obtained simply using traditional vector analysis on the vectors shown in Fig. 3.1.4:
The factor r in the final term reflects the difference between our basis vector eg and the unit length vector (i) of ordinary vector analysis.
(REAL) CURVILINEAR COORDINATES IN N-DIMENSIONS
103
P FIGURE 3.1.4. Time rate of change of a unit vector.
If the changes to vector V discussed in the previous section occur during time d t , perhaps because a particle that is at M at time t moves in such a way as to be at M' at time t d t , the differentials DV' of vector V can be converted to time derivatives:8
+
The quantity V being differentiated in Eq. (3.1.31) is any vector field. One such possible vector field, defined at every point on the trajectory of a moving particle, is its instantaneous velocity v = d x / d t . Being an m o w (tangent to the trajectory) v is a true vector; its local components are ui = dq'/dt = q ' . The absolute acceleration a is defined by
Dv a=-
dt '
. Dv' or a' = -. dt
(3.1.32)
Substituting V' = ui in Eq. (3.1.31) yields (3.1.33)
As the simplest possible problem of mechanics let us now suppose that the particle being described is subject to no force and, as a result, to no acceleration. Setting a' = 0 yields
# = -ri k 4.' q k. j
(3.1.34)
This is the equation of motion of afree particle. In rectangular coordinates, since rik = 0,this degenerates to the simple result that v is constant; the motion in question is along a straight line with constant speed. This implies that the solution of Eq. (3.1.34) is the equation of a straight line in our curvilinear coordinates. Since a line is a purely geometric object, it seems preferable to express its equation in 'In this and previous expressions the common shorthand indication of ford time derivative by an overhead dot has been used. One can inquire why V' has been defined to mean dV ' / d r , rather than DV ' / d t . It is just a convention (due originally to Newton), but the convention is well established, and it must be respected if nonsense is to be avoided. The vector field V. though dependent on position, has been assumed to be constant in time; if V has an explicit time dependence, the term V r would have to include also a contribution av'lar.
104
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
terms of arc length s along the line rather than time t. As observed previously, such a transformation is easy-especially so in this case since the speed is constant. The equation of a straight line is then d2q’ -=-r! ds2
. dqjdqk
--.
J
ds ds
(3.1.35)
Suppose next that the particle is not free, but rather is subject to a force F. Substituting a = F/m, where m is the particle mass, into Eq. (3.1.33) can be expected to yield Newton’s law expressed in these coordinates, but a certain amount of care is required before components are assigned to F. Before pursuing this line of development, we look at free motion from another point of view. There are two connections with mechanics that deserve consideration-variational principles and Lagrange’s equations. The first can be addressed by the following problems: the first of these is reasonably straightforward; the second is less so and could perhaps be deferred or looked up9
Problem 3.1.5: Consider the integral S =
J7
L ( q ’ , q ’ , r)dr, evaluated along a candidate particle path between starting position at initial time rl and final position at time 22, where L = ygijq’q’. Using the calculus of variations, show that Eq. (3.1.34) is the equation of the path for which S is extreme. In other words, show that Eq. (3.1.34) is the same as the Euler-Lagrange equation for this Lagrangian L .
Problem 3.1.6: It is “obvious” also, since free particles travel in straight lines and straight lines have minimal lengths, that the Euler-Lagrange equation for the trajectory yielding extreme value to integral I = 1d s where ds2 = g;,dq’dq’ should lead also to Eq. (3.1.35). Demonstrate this. These two problems suggest a close connection between Eq. (3.1.33) and the Lagrange equations that will now be considered. The key dynamic variable that needs to be defined is the kinetic energy T. In the present context, using Eq. (3.1.7),
T =m --gjkqiqk. 2
(3.1.36)
(Though not exhibited explicitly, the metric coefficients depend on the coordinates 4’ .) When one thinks of “force” one thinks either of what its source is, for example an electric charge distribution, or what it must be to account for an observed acceleration. Here we take the latter tack and (on speculation) introduce a quantity Q; (to be
9B0th problems are solved in Dubrovin et al. [2].
(REAL) CURVILINEAR COORDINATES IN N-DIMENSIONS
105
interpreted later as the “generalized force” corresponding to q’ ) by Ql=
d aT d t aq
aT
7 --
aql‘
(3.1.37)
We proceed to evaluate Ql by substituting for T from Eq. (3.1.36), and using Eq. (3.1.18):
(3.1.38)
This formula resembles Eq. (3.1.33); a comparison with Eq. (2.5.17) shows that their right-hand sides are covariant and contravariant components of the same vector. Expressed as an intrinsic equation, this yields
(3.1.39) This confirms that the Lagrange equations are equivalent to Newton’s equations since the right-hand side is the acceleration a’. For this equation to predict the motion, it is of course necessary for the force Q’ to be given.
Recapitulation: From a given particle trajectory it is a kinematical job to infer the acceleration, and the covariant derivative is what is needed for this task. The result is written on the right-hand side of Eq. (3.1.39), in the form of contravariant components of a vector. It was shown in Eq. (3.1.38) that this same quantity could be obtained by calculating the “Lagrange derivatives” d / d t ( a T / a q ) - a T / a q where T = (m/2)g,k q J q k (The . occurrence of mass m in the definition of T suggests that it is a dynamical quantity, but inclusion of the multiplier m is rather artificial; T and the metric tensor are essentially equivalent quantities.) It is only a minor complication that the Lagrange derivative of T , yields covariant components which need to “have their indices raised” before yielding the contravariant components of acceleration. Dynamics only enters when the acceleration is ascribed to a force according to Newton’s law, a = F / m . When a in this equation is evaluated by the invariant derivative as in Eq. (3.1.39), the result is called “Newton’s equation.” When a is evaluated by the Lagrange derivative of T , the result is called “Lagrange’sequation.” Commonly force is introduced into the Lagrange equation by introducing L = T - V , where V is “potential energy.” This is an artificial abbreviation, however, since it mixes a kinematic quantity T and a dynamic quantity V. From the present point of view, since it is not difficult to introduce forces directly, this procedure is, logically speaking, clearer than introducing them indirectly in the form of potential energy.
106
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
The prominent role played in mechanics by the kinetic energy T is due, on the one hand, to its close connection with ds2 and, on the other hand, to the fact that virtual force components Ql can be derived from T using Fq.(3.1.37). 3.1.6. Practical Evaluation of the Christoffel Symbols The “direct” method of obtaining Christoffel symbols for a given coordinate system is to substitute the metric coefficients into Eq. (3.1.18) and solve Eqs. (3.1.19). But this involves much differentiation and is rather complicated. A practical alternative is to use the equations just derived. Suppose, for example, that spherical coordinates are in use: ( q l , q2,q 3 )= (r, 6,4). In terms of these coordinates and the formula for distance ds, one obtains metric coefficients from Eqs. (3.1.5) and (2.5.17): ds2 = d r 2
+ r2 do2 + r2 sin26 d#’,
822 = r
gll = 1,
2
,
g33
= r2 sin26,
(3.1.40)
and all off-diagonal coefficients vanish. ( g ” , g22,g33are defined by the usual index raising.) Acceleration components aican then be obtained using Eq.(3.1.39),though it is necessary first to raise the index of Ql using the metric tensor. From Eq. (3.1.39) one notes that the Christoffel symbols are the coefficients of terms quadratic in velocity components, i., 8, and in Eq. (3.1.38), and this result can be used to obtain them. Carrying out these calculations (for spherical coordinates with m = l), the kinetic energy and the contravariant components of virtual force are given by
4
2T = i 2 + r 2 b 2 + r 2 sin28#2,
_ - _ _~ ~ ) = k . + ; i2* - s i n 6 c o s e ) 2 ,
( d aT
Q2=-
r2 dt
a@
case . .
Q 3 = - - (1d ~ - - 5 ) = 4 + - i ) + 2..- 6 )2 . r2sin26 dt a+ r
(3.1.41)
sin 6
Matching coefficients, noting that the coefficientswith factors of 2 are the terms that are duplicated in the (symmetric) off-diagonal terms of (3.1.38), the nonvanishing Christoffel symbols are
r2I
= -r,
r,2
= F,
3
r313= -r
sin26 ,
1
2 r33 = -sin6
1
r 2 3 =sin6 .
r 1 3= -, r
3
cose
cos6,
(3.1.42)
(REAL) CURVILINEAR COORDINATES IN N-DIMENSIONS
107
Example 3.1.4: We test these formulas for at least one example by revisiting Example 3.1.1. Using Eq.(3.1.41), we find that the force components acting on the particle in that example are u2 sin3 4 - r$2 = 0, Q' = 7 2u2
Q3
= p cos4 sin3 4
2 + -i-i = 0. r
This shows that the particle moving in a straight line at constant speed is subject to no force. This confirms statements made previously.
Problem 3.1.7: For cylindrical ( p , 4, z) coordinates, calculate the Christoffel symbols both directly from their defining Eqs. (3.1.18) and indirectly using the Lagrange equation.
3.1.7. Evaluation of the Christoffel Symbols Using Maple It is even easier to obtain the Christoffel symbols using a computer program. The following listing shows the use of Maple to obtain the Christoffel symbols for spherical and cylindrical coordinates. This would be most useful for less symmetric coordinates, defined by more complicated formulas. Calculate Christoffel coefficients readlib(tensor1: Ndim:=3: #
# #
Spherical coordinates xl:=r; x2:=theta; x3:=phi; gll:=l; g22:=r-2; g33:=rA2*sin(theta)^2; tensor0 ; for i from 1 by 1 to 3 do for j from 1 by 1 to 3 do for k from 1 by 1 to 3 do if i<=j then if C.i.j.k <> 0 then printf( '%d,%d,%d',i,k.j); print (C. i.j.k) ; fi; fi; od ; od ; od ; #
1,2,2
108
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
2
- r sin(theta1
# Cylindrical coordinates restart; readlib(tensor): Ndim :=3: xl:=r; x2:=phi; x3:=z; gll:=l; g22:=r^2; g33:=1; tensor0 ; for i from 1 by 1 to 3 do for j from 1 by 1 to 3 do for k from 1 by 1 to 3 do if i<=j then if C.i.j.k <> 0 then printf ( '%d,%d,%d' ,i,k,j); print(C.i.j.k); fi; fi; od ; od ; od ;
l/r 2.1.2
ABSOLUTE DERIVATIVESAND THE BILINEAR COVARIANT
109
3.2. ABSOLUTE DERIVATIVES AND THE BILINEAR COVARIANT Absolute differentials have been defined for contravariant vectors in Eq. (3.1.26), for covariant vectors in Problem 3.1.2, and for two-index tensors in Problem 3.1.3. The generalization to tensors of arbitrary order is obvious, and the following discussion also transposes easily for tensors of arbitrary order. For simplicity, consider the case of Eq. (3.1.30): (3.2.1) Since duk and Dair are true tensors, the coefficients (3.2.2) also constitute a ?ruetensor. As another example, if X i are the covariant components of a vector field, then (3.2.3) is also a true tensor. The tensors of Eq. (3.2.2) and Eq. (3.2.3) are called covariant (or invariant) derivatives of ail and X i , respectively. We now perform an important, though for now somewhat poorly motivated, manipulation. What makes this apology necessary is that our entire discussion up to this point has been more specialized than will eventually be required. A (subliminal) warning of this was issued as the Christoffel symbols were introduced and described as a “connection.” Their unique definition relied on the fact that the curvilinear coordinates being analyzed were embedded in a Euclidean space, with distances and angles having their standard meanings inherited from that space. In more general situations, an affine connection exists but is not calculable by Eq. (3.1.18). Once one accepts that the rikjcoefficients are special, one must also accept that covariant derivatives like (Dair)k or ( D X i ) j ,rather than being universal, are specific to the particular connection that enters their definition. But, relying on the fact that the Christoffel symbols are symmetric in their lower indices, it is clear (in Eq. (3.2.3) for example) that a more universal (independent of connection) derivative can be formed by antisymmetrizing these tensors to eliminate the Christoffel symbols. Subtracting Eq. (3.2.3) and the same equation with indices interchanged yields (3.2.4) Being a sum of tensors this is a tensor and it has intrinsic significance for any system described by smoothly defined coordinates. It generalizes the “curl” of vector field
110
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
X,familiar from vector analysis. For tensors having more indices, similar antisymmetrized, intrinsic derivatives can also be defined. That this combination is a true tensor can be used to prove the invariance of the so-called “bilinear covariant”” formed from a differential form w ( d ) . Here w[d] is an abbreviation
The same differential, but expressed with a different argument 6, is w[S] = XlSU’
+ X2SU2 + . + X“SU”.
(3.2.6)
(More symmetric notation, such as d(l) and d(2) instead of d and 8, could have been used but would have caused a clutter of indices.) Interchangingd and 6, then forming another level of differential in Eqs. (3.2.5) and (3.2.6), and then subtracting, yields dw[S] - 6w[d] =
2
(3 - 3) (6uk duj auJ au
- SuJ
duk) .
(3.2.7)
(The factor 1/2 takes advantage of the fact that when this is expanded the terms are equal in pairs.) The right-hand side is the tensor contraction of the product of the first factor (shown to be a true tensor in Eq. (3.2.4)) and the bivector (also an invariant”) formed from du and 6u. The upshot of this paragraph is that this combination dw[S] - 6 4 4 ,called the “bilinear covariant” of the form w, has been shown to be independent of choice of coordinates. The combination ( D X i ) , - (DXj)i has also been shown to be intrinsic or a true tensor. This is true for fields defined on any smooth manifold. Strictly speaking, this result has only been proved here for manifolds with connection rikjdefined, but the only requirement on the connection is contained in Q. (3.1.10b), which links basis frames at nearby locations, including the requirement of symmetry in the lower indices. For manifolds encountered in mechanics, this weak requirement is typically satisfied.
“For the time being we continue to use the somewhat archaic “bilinear covariant” as it was introduced in Section 2.3.2 rather than rely on the “exterior derivative” formalism because the only result that will be used is explicitly derived in this section. The exterior derivative formalism streamlines the algebra and obviates the need for introducing the distinguished symbols d and 6, but our terminology is (arguably) better motivated in the present context. ”Bivectors will be discussed at length in Chapter 4. For now, their tensor character can be inferred from their transformation properties under the transformations defined by Eq. (2.4.5).
LIE DERIVATIVE-COORDINATE APPROACH
111
*3.3. LIE DERIVATIVE-COORDINATEAPPROACH’* 3.3.1. Lie-Dragged Coordinate Systems Prototypical coordinate systems discussed so far have been spherical, cylindrical, elliptical, etc., the fixed nonrectangular coordinate systems familiar from electricity and magnetism and other fields of physics. We now consider coordinate systems that are more abstractly defined in terms of a general vector field V defined at every point in some manifold of points M.The situation will be considerably more general than that of the previous section in that the coordinates of point M are allowed to be any generalized coordinates and no metric is assumed to be present. From studying special relativity, one has become accustomed to (seemingly) paradoxical phenomena such as “moving clocks run slow.” Closer to one’s actual experence, at one time or another everyone has been sitting in a train watching the adjacent train pull out slowly, shortly to be surprised that the watched train is stationary and it is actually one’s own train that is moving. The “Lie derivative” is a mathematical device for analyzing phenomena like this. To appreciate the name “the fisherman’s derivative” that Arnold gives the Lie derivative, one has to visualize the fisherman sitting on the bank and watching the river flow by or (better, because there are more concrete objects to view) sitting in a boat that is coasting with the flow and watching the shore. I prefer the term “passing-parade derivative.” Visualize yourself standing by the side of the road as a parade passes by. The evolution you observe is a marching band turning into a float that turns into prancing horses that turn into another marching band, and so on. An alternative is to visualize yourself in the parade watching the buildings along the route metamorphose into one another. Since these parade images violate the requirement of smooth evolution, let us try another one. Visualize yourself by the side of the route of a marathon race, 10 miles from the starting point, 1 hour after the start, well after the leaders have passed. As the runners straggle by you say “the runners are aging rapidly” when, in fact, it is just that the older runners have taken longer getting there. If the 30-year-olds run at 11 miles per hour and the 40-year-olds run at 10 miles an hour, 1 hour into the race the 30-year-olds will be ahead by 1 mile, relative to your viewing station, and the 40-year-olds will be where you are. The aging rate you observe is (4030)/( 10/10 - 10/11) x 100 yearshour. The same result could have been obtained via the spatial rate of change of age at fixed time which is -10/1 = -10 yeardmile. To get (the negative of) the observed aging rate from this you have to multiply by the 10 mileshour velocity. The 100yearshour aging rate you observe can be said to be the negative of the “Lie derivative” of runner’s age. 12Sections marked by an asterisk are noticeably more difficult and should perhaps be skipped or skimmed over on first reading. The material in this section will only be required when the properties of vector fields are used to derive the Poincad equations. It is placed here because it is based on concepts like those required to analyze curvilinear coordinates. It would be possible to avoid the Lie derivative altogether in analyzing the algebra of noncommuting vector fields, in which case the concept would never need to enter mechanics. But vector fields and Lie derivatives are so similar, and so thoroughly woven together in the literature, that one is eventually forced to understand this material. There will also be striking similaritiesbetween the Lie derivative and the covariant derivative derived earlier in this chapter.
112
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
From the point of view of physics, age and rate of aging are fundamentally, dimensionally different, but from the point of view of geometry, apart from the limiting process, they differ only by a scalar multiple dt and hence have the same geometric character. A similar relationship is that position vectors and instantaneous velocity vectors have the same geometric character. In the same way, the Lie derivative of any quantity has the same geometric (i.e., tensor) character as the quantity being differentiated. When one recalls the mental strain that accompanied first understanding the time dilation phenomenon of special relativity mentioned above, one will anticipate serious conceptual abstraction and difficult ambiguity avoidance in defining the Lie derivative. Here it will be defined in two steps. First, starting from one (henceforth to be called preferred) coordinate system, one defines another “Lie-dragged‘’ coordinate system (actually a family of other Lie-dragged coordinate systems). Then, mimicking procedures from Sections 3.1.3 and 3.1.4, components in the dragged frame will be “corrected” to account for frame rotation or distortion, relative to the preferred frame, to form the Lie differential. To elaborate further, consider a row of birds flying across the sky. Assume the velocities v of the birds depend13 on their position but not on their time of arrival at that location. In other words we assume that v(x) depends only on x. As time goes on, the birds remain in a (possibly curved) transverse line. A multiple-exposurephotograph showing a single line of birds at uniformly spaced time intervals (interval = At) is shown in Fig. 3.3.1. The velocity in the lower left comer has been chosen to be about l/Af so that the curved grid conforms with the rectangular grid in that
7
4At
6 5 4
3
2 1 y= 0 X =
FIGURE 3.3.1. Locations of a single “line” of birds at successive times, t = -At, 0 , At, 2At.. . . . The picture is a multiple-exposure photograph. Because the curves in this plot refer to different times, they are not the coordinate curves sought at this time-that system is illustrated in the next-but-one figure. 13This and all similar dependencies are assumed to be smooth.
LIE DERIVATIVE-COORDINATE APPROACH
113
region. If the birds were numbered sequentially, the numbers could serve as a kind of one-dimensional transverse coordinate system. Successive lines of birds would permit the definition of a longitudinal coordinate system based on the exposure number. The reader should not become too attached to this system, however, since the Lie-dragged coordinate system to be introduced shortly, though also based on bird locations, is different because, unlike this system, it relies only on bird locations at a fixed time. A picture that is closer to what we seek (but still is not it) is shown as Fig. 3.3.2. In this figure, successive flights of airplanes.. . , FO, F1, F2, . . . take off at regular intervals, with large ones taking off first and later flights being made up of progressively smaller ones. (Airplane size has been introduced only to clarify the picture; it has no effect on the analysis.) The flight paths are the same as in the previous figure. A viewer at a fixed location may regard the overhead airplanes as being “dragged past”; however, the smooth curves in Fig. 3.3.2 still do not constitute a Lie-dragged coordinate system. Finally, after two false starts, consider Fig. 3.3.3, which could be derived from either one of the previous two figures. Let us suppose that at ? = 0 there is a bird or airplane at each square of the initial rectangular ( x , y ) grid, and that a single snapshot is taken at a later time t = At. (Though the time interval At is arbitrary in principle, it will be useful to think of it as “small” because, for the most important considerations to follow, At will approach this limit.) To construct this figure it is necessary to plot displacement-in-time-At vectors in Fig. 3.3.1 and interpolate from them to Fig. 3.3.3. The rows and lines of birds at t = A? provide the sought-for “Lie-dragged” new coordinate system (X,Y).
F-1 FO 7
6 5
F1
F2
F3 F4 F5 ,F6
4
3
F7
2 1 y= 0 X=
FIGURE 3.3.2. Successive flights of airplanes fly overhead, larger ones in the front; a single snapshot records all of the flights at a fixed time. To a viewer at fixed location, the airplanes appear to (and do) become gradually smaller with time. Though the planes may appear to be being “dragged past,”the smooth contours still do not define a Lie-draggedcoordinate system.
114
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
x=
0
2
3
4
Y=4 Y=3
a b c
d A
Y=
B
X =
C
D
x
y
X
Y
3 4 4 3
3 3 4 4
1.9 2.9 2.7 1.8
2.9 2.9 3.8 3.8
4.2 5.6 6.0 4.3
3.2 3.3 4.8 4.3
3 4 4 3
3 3 4 4
FIGURE 3.3.3. Corresponding to Fig. 3.3.1 or Fig. 3.3.2, the (new) ( X , Y ) coordinate system derived by ”Lie-dragging”the (old) ( x , y ) coordinate system for time A t with velocity vector field v. The boldface arrows are (almost) parallel to the trajectories of the previous figure but are displaced a bit transversely. To restrict clutter, only enough interpolated arrows are shown to illustrate where curves of constant X (shown dashed) and Y (shown dotted) come from.
Since any point in the plane can be located by “old” coordinates (x, y) or “new” coordinates (X, Y), there necessarily are well defined functional relations x = x ( X , Y), y = y(X,Y )as well as inverse relations X = X ( x , y ) , Y = Y ( x , y). Of course this presupposes that all relevant functions are sufficiently smooth and invertible, and that interpolation between “bird locations” is arbitrarily accurate. The new (X, Y) system is said to be “Lie-dragged’ from the old system. Four points a, 6, c, and d, defining a unit rectangle in the old coordinates and the corresponding, at-time-At, unit “rectangle” with corners A , B, C, and D, are emphasized in Fig. 3.3.3 and broken out on the right, where their coordinates are also shown. Note that none of these points lies on the bird paths in Fig. 3.3.1, but their velocities are parallel (after interpolation) to the bird velocities shown in that figure. In the table, the coordinates of all these points are given in both the old and the new coordinate systems. Because of the way they have been defined, the new coordinates (XA, Y A ) of point A are the same as the old coordinates (xa, ya) of point a, and the same is true for every similarly corresponding pair of points. We now seek explicit transformation relations between old and new coordinates, though only as Taylor series in powers of At. Regarding point (I as typical, one has
+ ux(a)At + . YA = yo + U y ( U ) A t + . . . ,
XA
= xa
(3.3.1)
LIE DERIVATIVE-COORDINATEAPPROACH
115
where ux and UY are known functions of position; they are the “old” components of v, an arbitrary vector field. (It is not necessary to make the arguments of ux and uY more explicit since, to the relevant order in Ar, it is not necessary to distinguish among %, XA, Xa, and XA.) Eq. (3.3.1) can be regarded as the description in the old system of reference of an active transformation of point a + A. However, since one has defined the numerical equalities X A = Xa and YA = ya, Eq. (3.3.1) can be rewritten as XA
=x~+u~Ar+.-.
YA
= YA + VYAt + . . . .
(3.3.2)
These equations can be regarded as apassive (X,Y) --+ (x, y) coordinate transformation. They can be checked mentally using the entries in the table in Fig. 3.3.3, making allowance for the nonlinearity (exaggerated for pictorial clarity) of that figure. Since the subscripts A in this equation now refer to the same point, they have become superi3uous and can be dropped
+ vXAr+ . .. y = Y + uYAr+ . . . .
x =X
(3.3.3)
The inverse relations are
X =x
- vXAr+...
Y = y - uYAr
+ . ...
(3.3.4)
Since these equations describe transformation between curvilinear systems, they can be treated by methods described earlier in the chapter. But, as mentioned before, we are not now assuming the existence of any metric. Hence, though the old coordinate system in Fig. 3.3.3 is drawn as rectangular, it would not be meaningful to say, for example, that the line bc is parallel to the line ad, even though that appears to be the case in the figure. (The pair ( x , y) might be polar coordinates ( p , 4) for example.) 3.3.2. Lie Derivatives of Scalars and Vectors Having Lie-dragged the coordinate system, we next define the Lie-dragging of a general scalar function f ( x ) , or of a vector function w(x), or for that matter of tensors of higher rank. For vectors (and tensors of higher rank), this calculation is complicated by the fact that the Jacobean matrix relating coordinate systems depends on position. We defer addressing that problem by starting with scalar functions, which, having only one component, transform without reference to the Jacobean matrix. We define a “Lie-dragged function” f* (whose domain of definition is more or less the same as that of f ) by asserting the relation
f*(a) = f ( A )
(3.3.5)
116
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
to typical point a and its Lie-dragged image point A . This function describes a new physical quantity whose value at a is the same as that of the old quantity f at A. (If A is thought of as having been “dragged forward” from a, then f * might better be called a “dragged-back” function. This ambiguity is one likely source of sign error.) It could happen that f * and f have the same value at a point such as a but, because of f’s dependence on position, this will not ordinarily be the case. Though it is not shown explicitly in Eq. (3.33, the definition o f f * depends on At; this dependence has been incorporated by introducing a new function f * rather than by giving f another argument. For small At, f (A) can be approximated by the leading terms of a Taylor series: f (A) = f ( a )
af af + --*At + -uYAt + - .. . ax aY
(3.3.6)
The “Lie derivative” of function f , relative to vectorfield v, evaluated at a, is defined, and then evaluated, by (3.3.7)
Problem 3.3.1: In the text at the beginning of this section, an observation of runners passing a stationary spectator was described. For the example numerical values given there, assign numerical values to all quantities appearing in Eq. (3.3.7) and confirm the equality approximately. Also derive a function a ( x , t ) that gives the age of runners at position x at time t . From it evaluate La!at the observation point. V
Before evaluating the Lie derivative of a vector field w(x), we must assign meaning to the Lie-dragging of a vector. To do this, first consider Fig. 3.3.4, which is a blown-up version of the circular insert in Fig. 3.3.3. Consider in particular the arrow a‘c, and suppose it to be w(a), the value of vector field w evaluated at a. (It happens to connect two intersections of the original gri$ but that is just to simp$fy the picture.) Further suppose that w(A) is the arrow AC‘. The vectors a‘c and AC’, because they are defined at different points in the_manifold M, cannot be directly compared (or, more to the point, subtracted). But AC’ is the result of Lie-dragging some vector ac* along the vector v for the time At being considered. In the small At limit, the arrow A is the Lie differential of w with respect to v and the Lie derivative of w with respect to v at the point a is defined by
-
L w = lim v
At40
a;* - ic A = lim -. At At-0 At
(3.3.8)
The construction exhibited in Fig. 3.3.4 is similar to that in Fig. 3.1.2. In that figure, the vector V was slid from the point M to M’ without changing its direction. This was possible because “parallelism”was meaningful in the metric geometry valid for that figure. The purpose in sliding V was to evaluate V’ - V and from that the derivative of V.The corresponding construction in Fig. 3.3.4 is to obtain vector a;*
LIE DERIVATIVE-COORDINATEAPPROACH
*
117
Y
a
0.0 0.0
c
1.0 1.0
c* 0.8 1.2 A -0.2 0.2
FIGURE 3.3.4. The circular inset of Fig. 3.3.3 is blown up to illustrate the Lie-dragging and Lie derivative ot a true vector field w(x) whose value at a is the arrow a’c and whose value at A is the arrow AC’.
from vector A:’ in order to evaluate A F cz* and from that a derivative. The yector a;* is said to be “pseudo-parallel’’to AC’. Byjhe samq token “unit vectors” ab and A-B can be said to be pseudo-parallel, as can ad and AD. Here the “pseudo” means that, their components being proportional, they would be truly parallel except for the fact that the basis vectors do not define parallelism. Because w is a true vector, this constructionensures that Cw is also a true vectorV the fact that we are able to draw the Lie differential A as an unambiguous arrow shows this. This implies that to transform to coordinates other than ( x , y), the transformation matrices for Cw and w must be the same. This requirement will now be V
applied to obtain a formula in component form for Lw.It will be much like the V formulas for absolute differential in Section 3.1.4. Before obtaining the formula, it will be useful to introduce a more expressive notation than (X,Y) for the new, Lie-dragged, coordinates-namely, (,rLt,y&). In addition to making explicit the previously implicit dependence on A?, this makes 0. The indicates “new.” manifest the smoothness requirement for the limit Af (Often the notation * is used to indicate “new,” but * is already in use.) After this replacement, Eq. (3.3.4) becomes
+
(3.3.9)
’118
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
For deviations from x i t , yLt these equations yield
Exumple 3.3.1: For the situation illustrated in Fig. 3.3.3, the numerical values are, roughly, aux
aux
(Eax $) = (0.10.4
0.1 0.2)
(3.3.1 1)
Contravariant components of a vector must transform with the same matrix as in Eq. (3.3.10). Applying this to the contravariant components of the vectors shown in Fig. 3.3.4 yields
the notation on the left indicates that the components are being reckoned in the “new” system. (In hopes of improved clarity, some redundancy has entered here. The super- 1 - 2 scripts 1,2 are interchangeablewith x , y, and the elements AC’ , AC’ are identical to w’(A), w2(A).) But the prescription for Lie dragging is that the elements on the left-hand side are numerically equal to the components of a;* in the old system, which are (a;*’, (This is illustrated in Fig. 3.3.4, where the location of point c* is proportionally the same within the square above dc as the point C’within the parallelogram above DC.) Remembering that the arrows came originally from the vector w whose Lie derivative is being evaluated, in a step analogous to Eq. (3.3.6), the vector appearing on the right-hand side of Q. (3.3.12) can be obtained as
After substituting this in Eq. (3.3.12) and completing the multiplication, Gtl and - 2 ac’ can, to adequate accuracy, be replaced by w1 and w2 in the terms proportional to A f .Combining formulas we obtain
As required, Lw is a tensor of the same order as w,and its contravariant components V are displayed in this equation. For the sake of concreteness, this result has been de-
LIE DERIVATIVE-COORDINATEAPPROACH
119
rived in the 2-D case, but extending the result to higher dimensions is straightforward (as will be sketched shortly). One observes that the terms with positive sign come from changes of the individual components (treated as scalar functions of position) and the terms with negative sign come from frame distortion and (using the word loosely) rotation. It is also possible to define the Lie derivative of covariant vectors and of tensors of higher dimensionality. Toward this end, in order to take advantage of formulas derived previously, we recast result (3.3.14) in terms reminiscent of the “absolute derivative” derived in Section 3.1.4. Linear transformation equations like Eiq. (3.3.10) were introduced and analyzed in Section 2.4.2. To make Eq. (3.3.10) conform with the notation of Eq. (2.4.8), we define the transformation matrix A (truncating higher order terms for simplicity): l - z aAV=t -%At), (,+%At !$At (A-l)ij = A‘. = %At l+%At At 1 - aY At
.,
7’
(3.3.15) By Eq. (2.4.5), these same matrix elements relate unit vectors along the axes according to
(3.3.16) These equations can be related in turn to Eqs. (3.1.9), in which the connecting quantities mii were introduced:
e+Ar,l = el
+ w1I el ,+% q e+Ar.2 = e 2 + o2el + w22 e 2 . 1
(3.3.17)
Here, unlike in Section 3.1.3 and as has been stated repeatedly, no metric is being assumed. Still, even though coordinate systems at different points have been connected using the vector field v rather than a metric, we may as well use the same symbols wi’ for the connecting coefficients now:
(3.3.18) According to Eq. (3.1.26), the components of the absolute differential D w ’ of a vector field w subject to “connection” w j i are given by
Dw‘ = dw‘ + w i w j i ,
(3.3.19)
where the second term “adds” the contributionfrom ham? rotation to the “observed” change dw’.In our present context, wishing to evaluate A C ’ - A k , (because dragging
120
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
i c forward is as good as dragging A?? back), we have to “subtract” the contribution
from frame rotation. Hence we obtain
in agreement with Eq. (3.3.14). As mentioned before, this same line of reasoning makes it possible to evaluate the Lie derivative of arbitrary tensors, contravariant, covariant, or mixed, by simple alteration of the formulas for absolute derivatives derived in Section 3.1.3.
Problem 3.3.2: Evaluate Cv, the Lie derivative of a vector with respect to itself, V in two ways-once using the formula derived in the text, the second time, in a more intuitive process, using the construction of a vector diagram like the one in Fig. 3.3.4. *3.4. LIE DERIVATIVE-LIE
ALGEBRAIC APPROACH14
3.4.1. Exponential Representation of Parameterized Curves A family of noninteracting, space-filling curves such as those encountered in the
previous section is known as a congruence. At each point on every curve of the congruence there is a unique tangent vector, call it v. The curves are then known as “flowlines” of v. Two of them are illustrated in Fig. 3.4.1. The lower curve passes through point A with parameter value Av,o, and other points on this curve are given by coordinates x i ( A , Av.o, Av). If another vector field, say u, is to be discussed, it is necessary to introduce another parameter, such as Au or p, but for now, since only one vector field is under discussion we can suppress the v subscript from Av. The coordi-
FIGURE 3.4.1. Two out of a congruence of curves belonging to vector field v, both parameterized by Av.
I4Sections marked by an asterisk are noticeably more difficult and should perhaps be skipped or skimmed over on first reading. The material in this section repeats the derivation of the Lie derivative of the preceding section. but using intrinsic, coordinate-free methods.
LIE DERIVATIVE-LIE ALGEBRAIC APPROACH
121
nates of the point with parameter value A, on the particular curve of the congruence that passes through point A (parameter value l o ) , can be expressed compactly using a Taylor series expansion in E = A - A0 and the exponential function:
-+... d
)
IAo
1,d2
(3.4.1) “]A0
The “exponential operator” appearing in the last line can be regarded simply as an abbreviation for the expansion in the previous line. In the sequel, standard formulas satisfied by the exponential function will be appfied to it. Such manipulations will be regarded as formal, subject to later verification, but they could be verified on the spot.
3.4.2. Identification of Vector Fields with Differential Operators
At this point we take what might be said to be the most important step on the route from classical formalism to modem formalism. It is to assert the curious identity
d dAv
- = v,
(3.4.2)
where v is one of the vector fields discussed in the previous section and Av is the parameter of the v-congruence of curves. Like v, the arrow corresponding to d/dAv depends on where it is located. By its definition (3.4.2), both it and v are tangent to the curve passing through that location, and it is assumed that Av is adjusted so their are, by definition, two symbols for ratio is equal to 1 everywhere. In short, v and the same quantity. For any usefulness to accrue to this definition, it is necessary to ascribe more properties to d/dAv. First of all, in a linearized approximation, an increase by 1 unit of the parameter Av corresponds to the same advance along the curve as does v. This is like the relation of ordinary vector analysis in which, if arc length s along a curve is taken as the curve’s parameter Av and x is a radius vector to a point on the curve, then dx/dAv is a unit-length tangent vector. If time t is taken as the curve’s parameter Av, then dx/dAv is instantaneous velocity. (It is just a coincidence that, in this case, the symbol v is appropriate for “velocity.”) These formulas can be interpreted as the result of “operating” on the coordinates of x (which are functions of position and hence of A) with the operator d/dAv. More generally, if f is any smooth function of
&
122
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 11: CURVILINEAR
position, then’5
d dAV
- f is the (linearized) change in f for Av +. Av
+ 1.
(3.4.3)
With the new notation, to recover velocity components from a trajectory parameterized as x i ( t ) , one applies the operator d/dr to x i (t). Further justification for the derivative notation will be supplied in the next section.
3.4.3. Loop Defect Consider next the possibility that two vector fields, the previous one v and another one u, are defined on the space under study, Since the quantity g = (d/dAv)f just introduced is a smooth function of position, it is necessarily possible to evaluate =
(&)(3
(3.4.4)
f.
Then, for consistency with Eq. (3.4.2), the quantity (d/dAu)(d/dAv),the “composition” of two operators, has to be regarded as being associated with a vector that is some new kind of “product” of two vectors u and v. With multiplication being the primary operation that is traditionally referred to as “algebraic,” one can say then that there is a new algebra of vector fields based on this product. It is not yet the Lie algebra of vector fields, however-the product in that algebra is the “commutator.” An attempt to understand the new “product” of two vectors is illustrated in Fig. 3.4.2, which brings us to the first complication. Though, according to Eq.(3.4.4), the “multiplication” of two vectors is necessarily defined, according to the figure the result of the multiplication can depend on the order of the factors. To quantify this we will use Eq. (3.4.2) to calculate (approximately, for small t) the difference of the coordinates of the two points B(,,”) and B(vu) shown in Fig. 3.4.2:
(3.4.5) To abbreviate formulas like this we introduce square brackets to define the “commutator” of two vectors d/dp and d/dA by (3.4.6) With this notation, dropping terms cubic and higher in t , Eq.(3.4.5) becomes
‘%he result (3.4.3) is also what would result from the replacement v -+ v . V in ordinary vector analysis.
LIE DERIVATIVE-LIE ALGEBRAIC APPROACH
123
0 FIGURE 3.4.2. Two routes to (potentially) the same destination. One route starts out from 0 along the v-congruence curve through that point; advancing the parameter by E yields point A("). The route continues from there to point B("") along the u-congruence curve as its parameter advances by the same amount C. For the other route, the congruences are traversed in reversed order. The deviations between tangent vectors and smooth curves are vastly exaggerated, especially since proceeding to the small E limit is anticipated.
d
Xf,,)
- Xf,,, = [e%,
d
eCG]xi
d I+€-+-€ dl,
I
0
12d2 -, I+€-+-€ 2 dl: dl,
12d21
2
- xi dl;l
(3.4.7) 0
This shows that the commutator, a new vector field, when applied to the position coordinates x i , provides (to leading, quadratic, order) the coordinate deviation between the two destinations. This justifies representing the closing vector by c2[d/dlv, d/dl,], as shown in the figure. This has provided us with a geometric interpretation for the commutator of two vector fields.
3.4.4. Coordinate Congruences The congruences corresponding to general vector fields u and v just analyzed have much in common with the coordinate curves of ordinary coordinate systems such as the curves on which x 1 varies while x 2 (and, in higher dimensions, all other coordinates) remain constant. We anticipated this connection in Section 2.4.5, Eq.(2.4.34), where notation
(3.4.8)
124
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 11: CURVIUNEAR
for unit vectors along coordinate axes was introduced formally. The main difference between the present notation and that of Eq.(3.4.2) is that partial derivative symbols are used here and total derivative symbols there. This distinction is intentional, for reasons we now investigate. One thing important to recognize is that the quantity x’ plays different roles, usually distinguishable by context: The set (x I , x2, . . . , x”) serves as coordinates of a manifold M. Any one coordinate, such as X I ,is a one-component function of position in M. This is the role played by x’ in Eq. (3.4.2). But x can equally well be regarded as the parameter establishing location on the curve resulting from variation of the first coordinate as the remaining coordinates ( x 2 , . . . , x”) are held fixed; this is one of the curves of one of the coordinate congruences. This is the sense of x 1 as it appears in Eiq. (3.4.8). In this context, x’ could just as well be symbolized by Ael where el is the vector field yielding this congruence. The vector d/dAv can presumably be expanded in terms of the basis unit vectors
(3.4.9) where the ui are the ordinary components of v. They are, themselves, also functions of position. When this expansion is used to evaluate the commutator defined in Eq. (3.4.6),the result is
(3.4.10) where the fact that the order of partial differentiation makes no difference has been used. In this form, it can be seen that the failure to commute of u and v is due to the possibility that their components are nonconstant functions of position-otherwise the partial derivatives on the right-hand side of Eq.(3.4.10)would vanish. When this observation is applied to the coordinate basis vectors themselves it can be seen that
(3.4.11) since the expansion coefficients of basis vectors are all constant, either zero or one. In other words, coordinate basis vectors belonging to the same basis commute. Up to this point one might have been harboring the impression that a “grid” made up of curves belonging to the u and v-congruences was essentially equivalent to a coordinate grid made of, say, curves of constant x ’ and x2. It is now clear that this is not the case since the latter set “commutes” while the former may not. (Actually it is a special property of two dimensions that the curves of two congruences necessarily
125
LIE DERIVATIVE-LIE ALGEBRAIC APPROACH
form a grid at all. In higher dimensionality the points B(,,”)and B(YU)in Fig. 3.4.2can be displaced out of the plane of the paper and the curves can pass without intersecting.) We have shown, then, that for u and v to serve as basis vectors it is necessary that they commute. It will be shown below that this condition is also sufficient.
Example 3.4.1: Expressing a Vector in Other Coordinates. Consider the vector v = - y a / a x x S / a y , with x and y being rectangular coordinates. How can this vector be expressed in terms of the unit vectors O/Br and 6/64 where polar coordinates r and 4 are defined by r(x, y) = d m ’ and @ ( x , y) = tan-’ f ? Evaluating vr and vqj we find
+
vr = 0,
and v4 = 1 ,
and from this we find
a + ( ~ 4 a) - = -. a
v = (vr)ar
84
This example makes the act of changing coordinates simpler than is the case in general. The simplifying feature here is that both vr and v4 are independent of x and y . In general, to express the coefficients of v in terms of the new coordinates requires substitution for the old variables in the new coefficients. It is still a useful and straightforward exercise to generalize this procedure to arbitrary coordinate transformations, leaving this substitution implicit.
3.4.5. Commutators of Quasi-Basis-Vectors A circumstance common in mechanics is that one wishes to use an independent set
of vector fields q I ,q2.. . ., qr as “iocal” basis even though they do not commute. In this case they are called “quasi-basis-vectors.” Let their expansions in terms of a true basis set be
r = 1 , 2 , ..., r.
(3.4.12)
where the coefficients are functions of position and, as is customary in mechanics, the coordinates of x are denoted 9 ’ . Sometimes the number r of these vectors is less than the dimensionality n of the space, but for now we assume r = n and that Eqs. (3.4.12)can be inverted; the inverse relations are (3.4.13)
Using Eq. (3.4.10),the commutator of two such quasi-basis-vectorsis given by
126
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 11: CURVILINEAR
(3.4.14)
This can be abbreviated as
This formula will result in a remarkable simplification in Section 5.3.3.
3.4.6. Lie-Dragged Congruences and the Lie Derivative A gratifying inference can be drawn by combining Eqs. (3.3.20), (3.4.9), and (3.4.10):
which can be written succinctly as
L = [v, ’ I,
(3.4.17)
where the appearing as the second argument is a placeholder for an arbitrary vector field, such as w(x). In words, Lie differentiation with respect to v and commutation with respect to v are identical operations. Arnold also calls [u, v] the “Poisson bracket” of the vectors u and v, but in this text the term Poisson bracket is applied only to scalar functions. This is such an important result that it is worth rederiving it in the modem language of vector fields, not because the derivation of Eq.(3.4.17) has been deficient in any way, but to exercise the methods of reasoning. We return, then, to Lie-dragged coordinate systems, first encountered in Section 3.3.1, now discussed using the new vector field notation. Consider Fig. 3.4.3; it shows the same two curves of the v-congruence as are shown in Fig. 3.4.1. (These curves happen to lie in the (x1,x2)-plane, but there is the possibility, not shown, of other, out-of-plane coordinates.) Temporarily supposing that some other vector field u is also defined, suppose that one curve of the u-congruence passes through points A and B. From A and B, advancing the v-parameter by c results in motions to points P and Q’,and advancing other points on the curve through A and B results in the dashed curve PQ’. Heavy curve PQ is
LIE DERIVATIVE-LIE ALGEBRAIC APPROACH
127
U
FIGURE 3.4.3. The (heavy) curve through points A and B is Lie-dragged by amount aAV= along the v-congruence,preservingits parametervalues, to yield the dashed curve. If both heavy curves belong to the u-congruence, and if the curves PQ and PQ’ coincide and their parameters match, the u congruence is said to be “Lie-draggedalong v.”
the member of the u-congruence passing through P. As drawn, the point Q lies on the curve BQ’, but in more than two dimensions the curves PQ and BQ’ might m i s s completely. In any case the points Q and Q’ do not necessarily coincide. On the other hand, if points Q and Q’ coincide and the I, parameter values at P and Q match those at A and B, the u-congruence is said to be “Lie-dragged along v.” As an alternative, let us drop the assumption that a vector field u has been predefined, and proceed to define u, retaining only the curve AB to get started. (In higher dimensions it would be a hypersurface.) We assume that &(A) = Iv(B)-this can be achieved easily by “sliding” parameter values by the addition of a constant-and we assume the same is done for all points on the curve AB. Performing the dragging operation shown in Fig. 3.4.3 for a continuous range of parameter values E yields a “Lie-dragged” u-congruence. In this dragging, points Q and Q’ coincide by definition, and the parameter values along curve AB are dragged (unchanged) to the curve PQ. By construction then, the parameters Iv and I , can serve as coordinates over the region shown. (In higher dimensionality, if AB is a hypersurface with coordinates I,, , I u 2 ,. . ., then a similar dragging operation yields hypersurface PQ, and I V ,IU1, A,, .. . form a satisfactory set of coordinates.) The basis vectors of this newly defined coordinate system are d/dIv and d/dA, because these vectors point along the coordinate curves and (in linearized approximation) match unit advance of their parameter values. Furthermore, because Iu is constant on a curve of the v-congruence, the replacement d/dIv + a/& is valid. Similarly, since I Vis constant on a curve of the u-congruence, the replacement d/dIu -+ O/OI, is also valid. Applying Eq. (3.4.1 I), we conclude that the u-congruence generated by Lie-dragging along v satisfies
[u, v] = 0.
(3.4.18)
128
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 11: CURVILINEAR
X2
>.
0
X’
FIGURE 3.4.4. Construction illustratingthe vector field derivation of the Lie derivative.
Finally, we revisit the Lie derivative concept, defining and then evaluating Cw, the Lie derivative of w relative to v. For vector w,we repeat both lines of reaso4ng applied to the vector u earlier in this section. On the one hand, w will not, in general, satisfy the requirements of having been Lie-dragged by v. On the other hand, starting with a single curve of the w-congruence such as the curve AB in Fig. 3.4.4, setting A, = Av,o at every point on it by appropriate sliding, we can generate a v-dragged congruence-call it w* = d/dAw*.To simplify the notation slightly, since all calculations take place in the vicinity of the particular curve AB, which was chosen arbitrarily, we make the replacement A,,o + Av. For w* constructed in this way, d d d& dAc,*
d d dAw* dA,
w*(&) = ~ ( h , ) and -- - --.
(3.4.19)
The notation here is not quite consistent with that used in Fig. 3.3.4 because here the function w* is dragged forward whereas there it was dragged buck. This difference will be accounted for by a sign reversal below. For the following discussion, to avoid having to display vector functions, we introduce an arbitrary scalar function of position f ; it could be called “catalytic” since it will appear in intermediate formulas but not in the final result. Using Taylor series expansion to propagate w*forward we obtain d
d
d
d
d
d
(3.4.20)
where both of the relations (3.4.19)have been used. We can evaluate the second term similarly, by propagating w backward:
LIE DERIVATIVE-LIE ALGEBRAIC APPROACH
129
with adequate accuracy, the second coefficient has been evaluated at A,. Because the two quantities just evaluated are both being evaluated at the same place, they can be directly subtracted to define the Lie derivative by
(3.4.22) Combining formulas, ignoring the distinction between w and w*in the double derivatives, and suppressing the subsidiary function f , we obtain
cw = [v,w],
(3.4.23)
in agreement with Eq. (3.4.16). It is possible now (if one is so inclined) to abstract all “geometry” out of the concept of the commutator of two vector fields (or equivalently the Lie derivative.) One can think of a curve not as something drawn with pencil and paper (or by a skywriter in 3-D) but as a one-dimensional (smoothly connected, etc.,) set of points parameterized by hV in a space with coordinates (x’ ,x2, . . .), and think of d/dAv as a directional derivative operator (where “directional” means along the set). Then determining the discrepancy resulting from changing the order of two directional differentiations is a problem of pure calculus. This observation will be put to good use when the Poincark equation is derived in Chapter 5 . Numerous properties of the Lie algebra of vector fields are investigated in the following series of problems (mainly copied from Schutz). The most important Lie algebraic applications apply to a set of vector fields that is “closed under commutation” (meaning that the commutator of two vectors in the set is also in the set) in spite of the fact that it is a “proper” (not the whole set) subset.
Problem 3.4.1: Show that
and from this, removing the catalytic function u, show that, when operating on a vector
LC
c] = [v,w]‘ c
v’ w
(3.4.24)
Problem 3.4.2: Confirm Eq. (3.4.24)when the terms operate on a scalar function of position.
130
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS II: CURVILINEAR
Problem 3.4.3: Using
6u = [v, u], show that, when acting on a vector u, (3.4.25)
which is known as the “Jacobi identity.”
Problem 3.4.4: For scalar function f and vector function w,show that
L
)
(3.4.26)
L(fw) = L f w + f Lvw , which is known as the “Leibniz rule.”
Problem3.4.5: If v = a/&’, which is to say v is one of the coordinate basis vectors, use Eq. (3.3.20) and the properties of a coordinate basis set to show that
&J‘
i
=B” XI
(Lw)
(3.4.27)
Problem 3.4.6: Consider any two vector “superpositions” of the form x = au
+ bv,
y = cu
+ dv,
where [u, vl = 0,
(3.4.28)
and where a, b, c, and d are functions of position with arguments not shown. Show that [x, y] can be written as a similar superposition of u and v.
Problem 3.4.7: Consider any two vector “superpositions” of the form x = au
+ bv,
y = cu
+ dv,
where [u, v] = eu
+ fv,
(3.4.29)
and where a, b, c , d, e, and f are functions of position with arguments not shown. Show that [x, y] can be written as a superposition of u and v. Before proceeding to further curvilinear properties, we will concentrate once again on linear spaces in order to further develop some linear-algebraic/geometric properties. In particular, multivectors are introduced in the next section. Curvilinear analysis resumes in Section 4.3.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
References 1. E. Cartan, LeFons sur la gbometrie des espaces de Riemann, Gauthiers-Villas, Paris, 195 1 (English translation available).
BIBLIOGRAPHY
131
2. B. A. Dubrovin, A. T. Fomenko, and S. P. Novikov, Modem Geometry: Methods and Applications, Part 1, Springer-Verlag,New York, 1984, p. 317.
Reference for Further Study Section 3.4 B. E Schutz, Geometrical Methods of Mathematical Physics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 1995.
4 GEOMETRY 0F MECHANICS Ill: MULTILINEAR
4.1. GENERALIZED EUCLIDEAN ROTATIONS AND REFLECTIONS 4.1 .l.Introduction “Generalized Euclidean” rotations will be considered next. As pointed out in Section 2.5, Euclidean geometry is characterized by the existence of metric form @(x) that assigns a length to vector x. The discussion here will mainly be restricted to three dimensions, even though, referring to Cartan’s book, one finds that most results can be easily generalized to n-dimensions. Certainly relativity requires at least four dimensions, and we will need more than three dimensions later on. Though arguments are usually given in 3-D, only methods that generalize easily to higher dimensionality are used. This may make some arguments seem clumsy, but the hope is that maintaining contact with ordinary geometry will better ground the discussion, by addressing issues for which the motivation is familiar. On deeper study at a later date, the reader should have no difficulty constructing more general relations. The word “generalized” is intended to convey two ways in which something more general than Euclidean geometry is being studied. One of these, already rather familiar from special relativity, is the “pseudo-Euclidean” case in which one of the signs in the Pythagorean formula is negative. One knows of course that, including time, nature makes use of four coordinates. To save words without essential loss of generality, we will restrict the discussion to three, say x, y, and t. The more important “generalization”is that the “components” x’, x2, and x3 will be allowed to be complex numbers. In spite of the extra level of abstraction, the theorems and proofs are quite straightforward,and physical meanings can be attached to the results. In ordinary geometry, spatial rotations are described by “orthogonal” matrices. They are sometimes called “proper” to distinguish them from “improper” rotations 132
GENERALIZED EUCLtDEAN ROTATIONS AND REFLECTIONS
133
- combine a reflection and a rotation. But to avoid confusion later on, because the term “proper” will be used differently in connection with the pseudo-Euclidean metric of special relativity, we will use the terms “rotations or reversals” for transformations that preserve the scalar product of any two vectors. Such a transformation has the form x” = a i k x k , or as a matrix equation x’ = Ax.
(4.1.1)
If both frames of reference related by this transformation are “orthonormal,” then the orthogonality requirement is (4.1.2) where the usual “Kronecker-8” symbol satisfies 8jk = 1 for j = k and zero otherwise. These conditions simply express the assumed orthonormality of the new basis vectors. These terms determine the elements of the matrix product AAT, they also imply that det lAATI = 1 and hence
det IAI =
1.
(4.1.3)
The same transformation, when expressed in terms of skew axes that are related to the orthonormal basis by matrix 7, will be described by a matrix equation y’ = 7 A 7 - l ~= By. As a result, because of the multiplicative property of determinants, det IBI = f l for any basis vectors, orthonormal or not. Operations for which det IAl = 1 are to be called “rotations,” and those for which det IAJ = -1 are “reversals” or “reflection plus rotations.” 4.1.2. Reflections Referring to Fig. 4.1.1, the equation of a plane (or, in general, a hyperplane) ?r containing the origin is a . x = aix’ = 0 .
X’
FIGURE 4.1.1. Reflection of vector x in plane ff associated with vector a.
(4.1.4)
134
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
This implies that R is associated with a vector a having covariant component ai and that any vector x lying in K is orthogonal to a.l Whenever the statement “a hyperplane is associated with (or corresponds to) a vector” appears, this will be its meaning. A vector x’ resulting from “reflection” of vector x in plane K is defined by two conditions: (1) The vector x’ - x is orthogonal to hyperplane R; (2) The point i<x’ x) lies in 7r.
+
The first condition implies that x’ - x is parallel to a:
+ Lai.
(4.1.5)
aixi ai(2xi+ ha’) = 0, or A = -2. aia’
(4.1.6)
x”
- x i = Aai, or x” = x i
The second condition then implies that
Since this formula fails if aia’ = 0, we insist that a be nonisotropic, and in that case we may as well assume that a is a unit vector. Then the reflection vector x’ is given bY ’i
-
.
n - x‘ - 2akxka’,
or x’ = x - 2(a. x)a.
(4- 1.7)
(For real vectors, using standard vector analysis, this formula is obvious.) This transformation can also be expressed in matrix form: x’ =
(
I - 2a’al -2a2al -2a3al
I
-2a’a2 -2a’as - 2a2a2 -2a2a3 -2a3a2 1 - 2a3a3
) ($) =
Ax.
(4.1.8)
Just as the reflection plane K can be said to be “associated” with the vector a,the 3 x 3 matrix A can also be said to be “associated” with a. Since a can be any nonisotropic vector, it follows that any such vector can be associated with a reflection plane and a reflection matrix. Transformation Eq. (4.1.8), when associated with plane R,or equivalently with unit vector a, is called a “reflection.” Reflection preserves the scalar square, as can be checked. In the real, pseudo-Euclidean case, reflections for which a is space(time)like are called “space(time)-like.” 4.1.3. Expressing a Rotation as a Product of Reflections In this section, some properties of rotations are obtained by representing a rotation as the product of two reflections. Though it may seem distasteful and unpromising ’If a has a nonvanishing scalar square, as will be required shortly, then a can be taken to be a unit vector without loss of generality.
GENERALIZED EUCLIDEAN ROTATIONS AND REFLECTIONS
135
to represent a continuous object as the product of two discontinuous objects, the arguments are both brief and elementary, and encompass real and complex vectors, as the following theorem shows. The theorem is expressed for general n because the proof proceeds by induction on n; to simplify it, mentally replace n by 3. It applies to all transformations that leave @ (the form introduced in Q. (2.5.2)) invariant, but differentiates between the two possibilities, rotations and reversals. For rotations of ordinary geometry the theorem is illustrated by Fig. 4.1.2.
THEOREM 4.1.1: Any rotation (reversal) in n-dimensional space is a product of an even (odd) number 5 n of reflections. Proof: For n = 1, the theorem is trivially satisfied because rotation (reversal) amounts to multiplication by 1(- 1). Assume it holds for n - 1. As a special case, suppose that the transformation leaves invariant a nonisotropic vector ql.(In ordinary 2-D geometry (in a plane), this could be true for a reflection, but not for a typical rotation.) Taking ql as one basis vector, and augmenting it with n - 1 independent vectors all orthogonal to ql to form a complete set of basis vectors, the fundamental form becomes
aJ= 811(U1)*
*
+ @,
(4.1.9)
where in = giju’uj, the summation running 2,3, . . .,n . Since the transformation leaves u’ invariant, by applying the theorem to the n - 1-dimensional hyperplane orthogonal to vi the domain of applicability of the theorem is increased from n - 1 to n, and hence to all n in this special case. Advancing from the special case just discussed to the general case, suppose the transformation is such as to transform some nonisotropic vector a into a’. Consider
Y
I’
FIGURE 4.1.2. Composition of a pure rotation from two reflections.
136
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
then the reflection associated with the vector a - a’. For this reflection to make sense, the vector a - a’ must itself be nonisotropic; we assume that to be the case and defer discussion of the exception for the moment. Applying conditions ( 1 ) and (2) above, it can be seen that the vector a transforms to a‘ under this reflection. The original transformation can then be thought of as being composed of this reflection plus another n - 1 dimensional rotation or reversal that leaves a invariant. Having manipulated the problem into the form of the special case of the previous paragraph, the theorem is proved in this case also. There still remains the possibility that the vector a - a’ is isotropic for all a. The theorem is true even in this case, but the proof is more difficult [l]. We will cross this particular bridge if and when we come to it. Factorization of a rotation in twodimensional space into a product of two reflections is illustrated in Fig. 4.1.2.
4.1.4. The Lie Group of Rotations That rotations form a group follows from the fact that the concatenation of two reflections conserves the fundamental form and that each reflection has an inverse (which follows because the determinant of the transformation is nonvanishing). To say that the group is continuous is to say that any rotation can be parameterized by a parameter that can be varied continuously to include the identity transformation. Continuous groups are also called Lie groups. One scarcely expects a proof depending on closeness to the identity to be based on transformations that are clearly not close to the identity, such as reflections. But that is what will be done; clearly the product of two reflections can be close to the identity if the successive planes of reflection are almost coincident. Referring again to Fig. 4.1.2, let a and b be the vectors associated with those reflections.
THEOREM 4.1.2: In complex Euclidean space, and in real Euclidean space with positive definite fundamental form, the set of rotations (real in the latter case), forms a continuous group. Proof: For any two unit vectors a and b, and for n 2 3, there is at least one unit vector c orthogonal to both a and b. From these vectors one can construct two continuous families of reflections depending on a parameter I; they are the reflections defined by unit vectors
a’ = acos t +csin t ,
b’ = bcos t +csin t
0 5 t 5 n/2.
(4.1.10)
The planes of reflection are associated, as defined above, with these unit vectors. The product of these reflections is a rotation. Let us suppose that a particular rotation under study results from reflection corresponding to a followed by reflection corresponding to b. That case is included in Eq. (4.1.10) as the t = 0 limit. In the t = n/2 limit, the transformation is the identity rotation-it is the product of two reflections in the same plane, the one corresponding to c. This exhibits the claimed continuity for rotations constructable from two reflections. For dimensions higher
MULTIVECTORS
137
than 3, a rotation may need (an even number of) reflections greater than two. Proof that the continuity requirements hold in this case can be be based on pairs of these rn reflections. Every rotation in real 3-D space is represented by a 3 x 3 orthogonal matrix with determinant equal to 1. The group formed from these matrices and their products is called S0(3), where “S” stands for “special” and implies determinant equal to 1, “0’ stands for “orthogonal,” and “3” is the dimensionality.
+
+
4.2. MULTIVECTORS “Multivectors” in n-dimensional space are multi-component objects, with components that are functions of p 5 n vectors, x, y, z, . . .. Because of this they are also known as “p-vectors.” They can be regarded as the generalization of the well known vector cross product to more than two vectors andor to dimensionality higher than 3. The number p must have one of the values 1,2, . . . , n. Of these, p = 1 corresponds to ordinary vectors, and the case p = n is somewhat degenerate in that, except for sign, all components are equal. (In the n = 3 case, they all equal the “triple product” x . (y x z). See Fig. 4.2.1.) For the case n = 3 then, the only nontrivial case is p = 2. That is the case that is “equivalent to” the vector cross product of standard physics analysis. Here this geometric object will be represented by a 2-vector, also known as a “bivector.” This will permit generalization to spaces of higher dimension. Multivectors are also essentially equivalent to “antisymmetric tensors.”
4.2.1. “Volume” Determined by Three and by n Vectors The (oriented) volume of the parallelopiped defined by vectors x, y, and z is V = x (y x z). The sign of this product depends on the order of the three vectors-that is the essential content of the “oriented” qualifier. The interpretation as “volume” can be inferred from the well-known geometric properties of cross products. By this
-
Y
FIGURE 4.2.1. For n = 3-dimensional space, the p = 3-multivector formed from vectors x, y, and z is essentially equivalent to the triple product x . (y x 2 ) . Its magnitude is the volume of the parallelopiped defined by the three vectors and its sign depends on their orientation; this makes it an “oriented volume.”
138
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
interpretation, it is clear that the volume is invariant, except possibly in sign, if all vectors are subject to the same rotation or reversal. The same result can be derived algebraically from the known properties of determinants. For this the volume A is related to the determinant of the array of components x1
x2
i;: $
A = detl
::1
x3
(4.2.1) *
Assume temporarily that these components are Euclidean, i.e., the basis is orthonormal. If the three vectors are all transformed by the same rotation or reversal (defined previously), the determinant formed the same way from the new Components is unchanged, except for being multiplied by the determinant of the transformation. This is known as “the multiplication property of determinants.” (This result is regularly used as the “Jacobian” factor in the evaluation of integrals.) For rotations or reversals, the determinant of the transformation is f 1, and A is at most changed in sign. Now retract the assumption that the basis in Eq. (4.2.1) is Euclidean. A determinant can also be formed from the covariant components:
I
x1 x2 A ’ = det y1 y2
x3
z2
z3
z1
y3
I
.
(4.2.2)
Its value can be determined from the definition of covariant components (Eq. (2.5.15)) and the multiplication property of determinants, A’ = g A ,
(4.2.3)
where g is the determinant of the matrix of metric coefficients g i j . Taking advantage of the fact that transposing a matrix does not change its determinant, the product
AA‘=det
y’
y2 y3 det
z1 z2 z3
1 1: 1 I x2
Y1 y2
21
y3
23
z2
x.x x.y x.z = det y.x y-y y.z z.x
z.y
z.Z
1
= V2, (4.2.4)
where the product has been called V2; its value is independent of the choice of axes because the final determinant form is expressed entirely in terms of scalars. (They can be evaluated in the Euclidean frame.) From Eqs. (4.2.3) and (4.2.4), it follows that
(4.2.5) Here the signs of V and A have been taken to be the same. All the determinants in this section generalize naturally to higher dimension n. It is natural to define the volume V of the hypervolume defined by n vectors in ndimensions by Eq. (4.2.5), with A being the n x n determinant of the contravariant components of the n vectors.
139
MULTIVECTORS
4.2.2. Bivectors
In 3-D, consider the matrix of components of two independent vectors x and y:
(”: Y
From this array,
(
z)
Y
;i).
(4.2.6)
= 3 independent 2 x 2 determinants can be formed:
(4.2.7) as well as the three others that differ only in sign. (One might think it more natural to define x l3with the opposite sign, but this is just a matter of convention, and the present definition preserves the order of the columns of the subblocks and orders the indices correspondingly with no sign change.) The pair of vectors x and y can be said to constitute a “bivector” with components given by Eq. (4.2.7). Note that the components are the “areas” of projections onto the coordinate planes (except for a constant factor, which is 1 if the axes are rectangular). This is illustrated in Fig. 4.2.2. A common (intrinsic) notation for this bivector is x A y, which is also known as the
..... - ........... r..
<....*..
FIGURE 4.2.2. The components xg of the bivector x A y, as defined in Eqs. (4.2.7), are areas of projections onto the coordinate planes. Their magnitudes (with orientation) are also given by cross products of projections of x and y onto the corresponding planes.
140
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
“wedge product” or “exterior product” of x and y. The components are also said to belong to an antisymmetric tensor.2 The bivector x A y “spans” a two-dimensional space, the space consisting of all linear superpositions of x and y. The condition for a vector t to belong to this space is x2 y2
x3
det y ’ t’
t2
t3
I
XI
I
y3 = t 1 x 2 3+ t2x31
+ t3x12 = 0
(4.2.8)
(the volume defined by x, y, and t is zero). This means that the necessary and sufficient condition for two bivectors xi’ and y’j to span the same space is that their components be proportional. One can also define covariant components of a p-vector. They are the same determinants, but with contrayiant components replaced by covariant components. From two one-fonns Z and b one can similarly form a two-form that will be the oneforms’ wedge product ; A 6. Mixed two-forms for which one factor is a vector and the other a form can also be defined. The geometric object on which the symplecric geometry of Hamiltonian systems is based is such a two-form. (See Chapter 13.)
4.2.3. Multivectors and Generalization to Higher Dimensionality
In three dimensions one can define a 3-vector from the vectors x, y, and z. It consists of the
(:>
= 1 independent determinants that can be formed by picking three
columns from the 3 x 3 matrix whose rows are xT, yT, and zT.From Eq. (4.2.4) it is clear that the value of this component is the oriented volume defined by the three vectors. In an n-dimensional space, a p-vector can be defined similarly, for p 5 n. Its elements are the
(l)
determinants that can be formed by picking p columns from
the matrix with p rows xy, x;, . , - ,xp’. An invariant “measure” or “area” or “volume” (as the case may be) V of a pvector can be defined by a p x p determinant:
y.x
V 2 = det ...
... y*z . . . ... . . . = det
y.y
Y’xi
.,.
y’yj
...
” ’
...
ykZk
...
2Normally the “antisymmetrization”of tensor x’j is defined to yield .[‘’I I(1/2!)(xij - 1 ’’). This means there is a factorial factor (1/2!) by which the wedge product differs from the antisymmetrized product.
MULTIVECTORS
=xiyj
. . . Zk det . . . . . . . . . . . .
141
(4.2.9)
The validity of removing a factor common to a column of a determinant has been employed repeatedly in going from the first line to the second, and so has the vanishing of all terms for which two indices are equal. That V 2 is invariant is made manifest by its definition by the first expression. In the final summation the only nonvanishing terms have combinations of indices that are all different, and for any such combination there are p! equal terms-this accounds for the l/p! factor For example, consider a bivector whose covariant components Pij are given by
The square of the measure of this bivector is
+
This has the dimensions of area squared. For n = 3, it is equal to P1*P12 P23P23 f P31 P31. If axes 1 and 2 are rectangular, PI2 and P12 are each equal to the projected area on the 1,2 plane. Since the product P l2 P12 is invariant for other, not necessarily skew, axes 1’ and 2’, provided they define the same plane, its value is the squared area of the projection onto that plane. As a result, the square of the measure of the bivector is the sum of the squared areas of the projections onto all coordinate planes. In particular, if x and y both lie in one of the basis planes-a thing that can always be arranged-the measure is the area of the parallelogram they define. These relationships can be thought of as a “Pythagorean relation for areas.” They are basic to invariant integration over surfaces. Clearly the bivector Pi, and the conventional “cross product” x x y are essentially equivalent, and the measure of the bivector is equal to Ix x yI, except possibly for sign. The virtues (and burdens) relative to x x y of Pij are that it is expressible in possibly skew, possibly complex coordinates and is applicable to arbitrary dimensions. The invariant measure of the trivector formed from three vectors x, y. and z, in the n = 3 case, is x’
x2
x3 (4.2.12)
An important instance where this combination arises is when x and y together represent a bivector (geometrically, an incremental area on the plane defined by x and y) and z = F is a general vector field. In this case V measures the flux of F through the area. In the next section, V will be equivalently regarded as the invariant formed from vector F and the vector “supplementary” to the bivector formed from x and y.
142
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
As mentioned elsewhere, V as defined by Eq. (4.2.12) and regarded as a function of vectors x, y, and z is known, for example by Arnold, as a three-form because it is a linear, antisymmetric function of its three vector arguments. The measure defined by Eq. (4.2.9) will be important in generalizing Liouville’s theorem in Section 13.8.1. 4.2.4. “Supplementary” Multivectors
There is a way of associating an (n - p)-vector Q to a nonisotropic p-vector P. Cartan calls Q the “supplement” of P, but it is more common to call it the “the Hodge-star of P,” or * P. It is the mathematician’s more-sophisticated-than-crossproduct but in-simple-cases-equivalent way of obtaining a vector from two other vectors when a fundamental form exists. The conditions to be met by Q are as follows:
(1) The (n - p)-dimensional manifold spanned by Q consists of vectors orthogonal to the p-dimensional manifold spanned by P; (2) The “volume” or “measure” of Q is equal to the “volume” of P; and (3) The signs of the volumes are the same. For the case n = 3, p = 2, the identification proceeds as follows. Let xij = (x A y)‘’ be the 2-vector P and t be the sought-for 1-vector Q. The conditions for t to be orthogonal to both x and y are tin’
+ t2x2 + t3x3 = 0,
tly’
+ t2y2 + t3y3 = 0.
(4.2.13)
Eliminating alternately t2 and rl yields t1xl2
+ 23x32 = 0 ,
t2x21
+ t3x3’
= 0.
(4.2.14)
On the other hand, as in Eq. (4.2.8), if the Qi are the covariant components of Q . the condition for t to belong to the space spanned by Q is that all 2 x 2 determinants in the matrix
(:,
:2
i3)
must vanish:
t l Q3
- t 3 Q l = 0,
f2 Q 3
- r3 Q 2 = 0.
(4.2.15)
Comparing Eqs. (4.2.14) and (4.2.15), it then follows that the Qi and the x ’ j are proportional when the indices ( i , j , k) are an even permutation of (1, 2,3): (Ql, Q2, Q3)
= const. ( x * ~ , x ~ ~ , x ~ * ) .
(4.2.16)
Using condition (2) to determine the constant of proportionality, further manipulation yields
MULTIVECTORS
143
(4.2.17)
As an example, suppose that x ’ j derives from x = (Ax, 0,O)and y = (0, Ay, 0). so that its nonvanishing components are x I 2 = -x2’ = Ax Ay. Then the supplementary covector is ( Q l , Q2, Q3) = ,&(O,O, Ax Ay). This combination will be used later on in Section (4.3.2),in deriving a generalized version of Gauss’s theorem. This derivation could also have been carried out within traditional vector analysis. All that is required is that the three-component “vector” with components x2y3 x3y2,x3y2 - x 1 y 3 ,x1y2 - x2y3 be orthogonal to both x and y. The point of the present derivation is that it works for complex components and for skew axes and, furthermore, that it can be generalized to arbitrary n and p (though it involves relatively difficult combinatorics). The most general multivector P has contravariant components with p superscripts. These components are related to the covariant components of the supplemen.. . tary multivector Q, which has n - p subscripts, by P t I 1 2 - ’ p = ( l / & l Q i p + l i p + p i , , . Altogether the indices are to be taken in cyclic order. Interchanging covanants and contravariants, the formula is Pjli2,,.jp= J r i Q i p + l i p + z . . . i f l . Applying this result in three dimensions, the vector supplementary to the bivector formed from (contravariant) vectors x and y is given by Q i = & € i j k X i y k , where C j j k is the Levi-Civita, antisymmetric symbol. This is the same formula used to calculate the components (x x y)’ of the cross product in rectangular coordinates. One sees now that it is more appropriate to regard the results as being covariant components. 4.2.5. Sums of pVectors An algebra of p-vectors can be defined according to which two p-vectors can be “added” component-wise. All components of a p-vector can also be multiplied by a common factor. Dual (n - p)-vectors are obtained using the same formulas as above. After addition of two p-vectors, each derived from p 1-vectors as above, one can inquire whether p 1-vectors can be found that would yield the same p-vector. The answer in general is no. Hence one introduces new terminology. A “simple” p-vector is one obtainable from p 1-vectors as above, and the term p-vector is redefined to include sums of simple p-vectors. However, for n = 3 all bivectors are simple.
4.2.6. Bivectors and Infinitesimal Rotations We finally make contact with mechanics by identifying an infinitesimal rotation, such as a physical system might be subject to, with a bivector. It is appropriate to mention that the potential ambiguity between the active and passive interpretations of transformations is nowhere more troublesome than in this area. This difficulty shows up mainly in a difficulty in maintaining notational consistency between boldface index-free symbols that stand for geometric objects and regular-face symbols with
144
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
indices that stand for their components. However, the difficulty will mainly come up in later chapters, when the results of this section are applied in mechanics. Consider a rigid object, such as the one illustrated in Fig. 4.2.3, with a single point, perhaps its center of mass, fixed in space. Taking this point as the origin, let x ( t ) be a vector from the origin to a point P fixed in the body-this vector depends on time 1 because the object is rotating. The components x i ( t ) of x(t) are taken with respect to Cartesian axes (el, e2, e3), not necessarily orthonormal, but fixed in space. The most general possible relation between x(t) and an initial state x(0) is a rotation
(With skew axes, the matrix 0 is not necessarily orthogonal, but it will facilitate use of this formula in a later chapter if it is given a symbol that suggests it may be orthogonal. 0 can be time-dependent.)The velocity of point P is given by (4.2.19) This shows that velocity components u i ( t ) are linear combinations of the ~ ~ ( 0 ) which, by the second of Eqs. (4.2.18), are in turn linear combinations of the instantaneous particle coordinates x ' ( t ) . This implies that the ui( t ) are linear functions ofthe x l ( t ) , (4.2.20) which serves to define the matrix 0: (4.2.21) Since the body is rigid, the velocity is necessarily orthogonal to the position vector:
Since this is true for d l x i , it follows that Qlk = -&[. his means that the components Q'k are the mixed components (one index up, one down) of a bivector. During an "infinitesimalrotation" occuring in the time interval from t to f +dt, the displacement of point P is given by dx = v d t . To work in linearized approximation, while nevertheless suppressing dr from the formulas, we simply set dt = 1, in effect assuming that the unit of time is so small as to legitimize linear approximation. This is the only way that one can "legitimize"the addition of the "tangent plane quantity" dx to x. Then from Eq.(4.2.20), the coordinates of point P at time dt are given by x" = x i
+ dx',
where dx' = n i k X k
(4.2.23)
MULTIVECTORS
145
0 FIGURE 4.2.3. A rigid object with point 0 fixed rotates by angle d@about an axis along vector w during time dt. The velocity of point P is given by v = w x x.
and where the Q’k are the mixed components of a bivector. (In an attempt to maintain dimensional consistency, since C2 has inverse time units, a physicist might call dx’ the incremental displacement of P per unit of time.) Referring to Fig. 4.2.3, one can compare this result with rotational formulas from vector analysis, w=-
dx=d4xx,
d4 dt ’
v=wxx,
(4.2.24)
where d+ is an infinitesimal vector, directed along “the instantaneous rotation axis,” with magnitude equal to the rotation angle. Our bivector Rik clearly corresponds to the “angular velocity” vector w; in fact, transcribing the last of Eqs. (4.2.24) into matrix notation,
(The “qualified equality” symbols are intended to acknowledge the nonintrinsic, i.e., coordinate-dependent,nature of the relationship.) Infinitesimalrotations around individual Euclidean base axes can be expressed in terms of the antisymmetric matrices
,I=(,
0 0 0 0 -I), 0 1 0
0 .=(O
0
1
0 0). -1 0
0
0 -1 0 h=(l 0 0). 0 0 0
(4.2.26)
146
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
For example, an infinitesimal rotation through angle d& around el is described by
(The sign of the second term depends on whether the transformation is regarded as active-x rotates-or passive-the coordinate system rotates. As written, the frame is assumed fixed and the vector x is actively rotated-a positive value for dbl corresponds to a vector aligned with the positive x2 axis being rotated toward the positive x3 axis.) The transformation yielding rotation through angle d$ around unit vector a is x' = ( 1
+ (a151 + a252 + a353)d#)x = (1 + a .J d4)x,
(4.2.28)
where the triplet (51, J 2 , J 3 ) is symbolized by J, as if it were a vector. Eq. (4.2.28) strains our notation. The appearance of a matrix like 51 as one element of the triplet (31, J2, 53) suggests it should have a lightface symbol, while the fact that it, itself, has multiple elements suggests that a boldface symbol would be appropriate. However, the latter is somewhat unpersuasive since the elements of J1 are not different in different coordinate systems.
4.3. CURVILINEAR COORDINATES (CONTINUED) At this point, several of the threads encountered so far can be woven together: bivectors along with their measures, curvilinear coordinates, invariant differentiation, differential forms. and mechanics.
4.3.1. Local Radius of Curvature of a Particle Orbit Recall the analysis of a particle trajectory in Section 3.1.5. As in Eq. (3.1.36),with local coordinates being u' ,the particle speed u is given in terms of its velocity components 6' by u2
= gjkLiJuk3
(4.3.1)
where gjk is the metric tensor evaluated at the instantaneous particle location. Since the particle acceleration ai = iii I')kuJ6kwas shown to be a true vector in Section 3.1.5, it can be used along with the velocity to form a true bivector
+
(4.3.2) The square of the measure of this bivector (as defined by Eq. (4.2.11) it is equal to a sum of squared-projected-areason the separate coordinate planes) is known to be
CURVILINEAR COORDINATES (CONTINUED)
147
coordinate-independent.In particular, if the particle orbit lies instantaneously in one such plane-a thing that can always be arranged-the measure of the bivector is the area defined by the instantaneous velocity and acceleration vectors, that is, by u 3 / p , where p is the local radius of curvature of the particle trajectory.
Problem 4.3.1: .Write . a manifestly invariant expression for local radius of curvature p in terms of 2 ,a', and g j k . Check it for uniform circular motion on a circle of radius R in the x , y plane. *4.3.2. Generalized Divergence and Gauss's Theorem3 As derived in vector analysis, Gauss's theorem relates the volume integral of the divergence of a vector to the flux of the vector through the volume's surface. Here, in several steps, this result is generalized to be independent of choice of coordinates. This is only a partial generalization in that we are still describing Euclidean geometry, though using arbitrary curvilinear coordinates. The first step is to define the divergence of a vector. The other steps are: (a) express the volume element in terms of Christoffel symbols, (b) express the volume integral as a sum of one-dimensional integrals, (c) utilize the fundamental formula of integral calculus, ( d X / d x )dx = X I : , and (d) express the resulting terms as a surface integral of an intrinsically defined flux. Absolute differentials have been defined for contravariant vectors in Eq. (3.1.26). for covariant vectors in Problem 3.1.2, and for two-index tensors in Problem 3.1.3. The generalization to tensors of arbitrary order is obvious, and the following discussion also transposes easily for tensors of arbitrary order. For simplicity, consider the case of Eq, (3.1.30):
Since duk and Dail are true tensors, the coefficients4 (Dail)k G ail;k =
aair auk
- - ajr riJk- aij
riJk
(4.3.4)
also constitute a true tensor. As another example, if Xi are the covariant components of a vector field, then
(DXi)j z X i ; j = Xi,j - X k
k Ti j
(4.3.5)
3Sections marked by an asterisk are noticeably more difficult and should perhaps be skipped or skimmed over on first reading. The next section contains similar material, based instead on differential forms, which does not depend on material in this section, and is more central to the later developments in mechanics. 41n this section, following Schutz, a covariant derivative with respect to u k is indicated by the semicolon subscript ;k . This notation must be distinguished from the even more common notation in which the subscript , k is used to indicate the ordinary partial derivative, as in X i . j = a X i / a u J , which appears in Elq.(4.3.5).
148
GEOMETRY OF MECHANlCS 111: MULTILINEAR
is also a true tensor. The tensors of Eq. (4.3.4) and Eq. (4.3.5) are called covariant (or invariant) derivatives of ail and Xi, respectively. In preparation for the formulation of volume integration, one must understand the curvilinear description of volume itself. It was shown in Section 4.2.1 that the volume of the parallelopiped defined by n independent-of-position vectors x, y, . . . , z in a Euclidean space of n dimensions is given by V = A &,where A is the determinant of the n x n matrix of the vectors' contravariant coordinates and g = I det lgij II. The vectors x, y, . . . , z also define an n-vector, which is an n-index antisymmetric tensor all of whose components are equal, except for sign, to u12"'n. (See Section 4.2.3.) Forn = 3, x1 x2 x3
= A.
(4.3.6)
The covariant differential of this tensor is 0-~
~ 1 2 - +-1 da12"'n
- da12...n
+ ai2...n
+ali...n
+ a12.,.n
wi2
+ . . . + a'2-i
+ wzZ + . * . +
onn),
wi
(4.3.7)
which vanishes because the vectors of the multivector are assumed to be constant. Expressing this in terms of the volume V yields
-
(4.3.8)
fi
Being defined by constant vectors, V itself is constant, which implies
(4.3.9) a relation fundamental to volume integration.
Problem 4.3.2: Confirm Eq. (4.3.9)by direct differentiation of g. This is unacceptably tedious unless one takes advantage of the fact that the metric can be made diagonal (variable elements) by appropriate choice of coordinates. Consider next the covariant derivative of a contravariant vector X i; it is given by Eq. (3.1.26).It was shown in Section 2.4.4that contraction on the indices of a mixed tensor such as this yields a true scalar invariant. In this case it yields what is to be known as the divergence of X,
where Eq. (4.3.9) has been used. This quantity does not depend on the Christoffel symbols.
149
CURVILINEAR COORDINATES (CONTINUED)
As in ordinary vector analysis, the primary application of the divergence operation is in Gauss’s theorem. Cross multiplying the &factor in Eq.(4.3.10) and integrating over volume V (again specializing to n = 3 for convenience) yields
& ,
divXdu’ du2 du3 =
au
du’ du2 du3.
(4.3.11)
At this point one should recall the derivation of Gauss’s theorem for ordinary rectangular coordinates-the volume is broken up into little parallelopipeds with faces on which one of the coordinates is fixed and the others vary. Applying Taylor’s theorem to approximate the integrands variation, and recognizing that contributions from intenor surfaces cancel in pairs, one can replace the right-hand side of Eq. (4.3.1 I ) with a surface integral over the closed surface S bounding the volume V .The result is
Jfs,
divX &du‘
du2du3 =
Js,
&(XI du2 du3 + X 2 du3 du’
+ X 3 du’ du2). (4.3.12)
//l
d i v X A d e t dq’ dr’
dq2 dq3 = dr2 dr3
&det
dw‘
x’
dw2 dw3 , x2
x3
’Though expressed in coordinates, the coordinate-independenceof individual factors has been demonstrated previously.
150
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
called the value of a two-form d2) evaluated on the two vectors, so that k(2) (x, y) is the “measure” (in this case area) the vectors define. We have come most of the way toward deriving the generalized invariant integration theorem without introducing the formalism of exterior differential forms. This is no worse than following in the footsteps of P o i n c d , who obtained these results in the first place. It also serves as preparation for the application of the exterior differential, which comes next. *4.4. INTEGRATION AND EXTERIOR DIFFERENTIATION OF FORMS6 4.4.1. One-Dimensional Integrals
The integration of a one-form has already been considered in Eqs. (2.3.8) and (2.3.10), which are combined here in slightly modified form: (4.4.1) In this case, the one-form being integrated is 6 and the “line integral” runs along a curve from beginning point B to end E, in steps Ax(i) that become infinitesimally small as n becomes large, and the result is the difference in elevation h between B and E. For a general position-dependent 1-form Z(X),a corresponding integral is
(4.4.2) An important special case has the line integral being evaluated over a closed curve y , and in this case the result will be called the “circulation” of E over y and will be represented by an abbreviated notation:
f Z = f(Z,
ax).
(4.4.3)
Line integrals like these are very important in physics, not only to represent work, as in mechanics (e.g. EQ.(4.4.1)), but even more so in electricity and magnetism to represent things like the line integral of a magnetic field around a closed path. This is where the curls come from in Maxwell’s equations. There is a minor difference now, however, since our integrands contain differential forms, whereas the line integrals involved in the derivation of Maxwell’s equation involve quantities like H . dx instead. Our task therefore is to find the analog of the curl for differential forms and in the process find the analog of Stokes’s theorem, which one may recall as the mathematical tool needed to convert the integral forms of Maxwell’s equations into their more compact differential forms. ‘Sections marked by an asterisk are noticeably more difficult and should perhaps be skipped or skimmed over on first reading. The material in this section will be required mainly near the end of Chapter 13, but there it will be central to the entire development.
INTEGRATIONAND EXTERIOR DIFFERENTIATIONOF FORMS
151
The analog of the curl of a vector is the “exterior derivative” of a one-form. This particular derivative is just one example of the more general form of differentiation of forms of any order known as exterior differentiation. However, since we will use only the derivative that is analogous to the curl, we will not attempt to proceed with such great generality. This being the case, no mathematics described here will be more difficult than the reader saw on first encountering the curl of a vector. For this reason, the treatment here will be very limited, intended to provide just enough discussion for the reader to be persuaded that nothing too mysterious is involved.
4.4.2. Two-Dimensional Integrals In this spirit let us restrict the discussion to two dimensions and integrate the differential form Z = f ( x , y ) & g ( x , y) $y over the curve y shown in Fig.4.4.la. A regular grid based on repetition of basis vectors u and v has been superimposed on the figure. As drawn, since the curve lies in a single plane, a vector normal to the surface is everywhere directed along the z-axis, and a surface r with y as boundary can be taken to be the ( x , y ) plane. (For a general, nonplanar curve, establishing the grid and the surface would be somewhat more complicated, but the following argument would be largely unchanged.) Though the curve y is macroscopic, the required circulation can be obtained by summing the circulations around individual microscopic “parallelograms” as shown. Instead of traversing y , one is instead traversing every parallelogram once and summing the results. The interior contributions cancel in pairs and the stair-step path around the periphery can be made arbitrarily close to y by reducing the grid size. (Though the number of steps is inversely proportional to the grid size, the error made in each step compared to the correct path along y is proportional to the square of the step size.)
+
D surface
(b)
X
FIGURE 4.4.1. (a) Approximation of the circulation of a one-form around a contour y by summing the circulations around the elements of a superimposed grid. For simplicity, the surface r bounded by y is here assumed to be a plane. (b) EJaluation of the circulation around one (differential) element of the grid.
152
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS Ill: MULTILINEAR
In this way the problem has been reduced to one of calculating the circulation around a microscopic parallelogram as shown in Fig. 4.4.lb. The vectors u and v forming the sides of the parallelogram will be treated as “differentially small” so that their higher powers can be neglected relative to their lower powers. We now wish to introduce for one-forms the analog of the curl of a vector so that the integral can be expressed as an integral over the surface r rather than along the curve y . We have not as yet assigned any meaning to the surface integral of a form, but we can do so by applying our previously defined line integration. The line integrals2long the counterclockwise vectors in Fig. 4.4. l b corning from the first term f ( x , y) dx of the form 2 being integrated are given approximately by
f (u+;)(&,v)=
:;
(f ( O ) + - ;: ( Y ) + - ( ux+-
uy+- :))uxv
where all partial derivatives are evaluated at the lower left comer. Approximating the clockwise contributions similarly and summing the four contributions yields
Performing the same calculations on g(x, y)& and summing all contributions yields
in& (-”ay + 3 ) ax
M
(UXUY
- uYvX).
(4.4.4)
Here the notation ll has been introduced for the parallelogram under discussion described as an area and an for the the same parallelogram described as the curve circumscribing it in a counterclockwise szse. The exterior derivative of form G = fdx+gzy was defined in Eq. (2.3.31),which is repeated here, (4.4.5) with the notation & being used for the exterior derivative. Also, when Eq. (2.3.29) is applied to the vectors u and v, the result is -
N
dx A dy(u, V ) = u x v y - uYux.
(4.4.6)
All these results can be combined and abbreviated into the equation (4.4.7)
INTEGRATION AND EXTERIOR DIFFERENTIATION OF FORMS
153
This equation relates infinitesimal quantities, but completing the argument implied by Fig. 4.4.1 we have (4.4.8) where r is the complete surface and y = ar is the curve circumscribing it in a counterclockwise sense. This is known as Stokes’s theorem for forms. Strictly speaking, we have still not defined such a thing as an area integral, as only line integrals have appeared. It is implied, however, that we intend Sr d G to be regarded as an integral Sr G(2)of an antisymmetric two-form G(’) over the surface r. Any surface r can be spanned by a grid of infinitesimal parallelograms for which a typical one has sides u and v. The integral can then be regarded as the sum of infinitesimal contributions Z(*)(u,v). In ordinary vector analysis, an integral over a two-dimensional surface can legitimately be called an “area integral” because areas are defined by the usual Pythagorean metric and, if the integrand is 1, the integral over surface r yields the total area. Another sort of integral over a two-dimensional surface in ordinary physics is to calculate the “flux” of a vector, say E,through the surface. Not only does the definition of the meaning of such an integral rely on a metric within the surface, it implies the introduction of the concept of “normal to the surface” and the scalar product of E with that vector. In contrast, the integral (4.4.9) does not require the existence of a metric on the surface and does not require anything involving “going out of the surface.” Probably the main reason for having introduced two-forms (and forms of other order) is illustrated by Eq. (4.4.9), where the two-form serves as the integrand of an integral over a two-dimensional surface. 4.4.3. Metric-Free Definition of the “Divergence” of a Vector The theorem expressed by Eq.(4.4.8) applies to the integration of an exterior differential form & of arbitrary order n - 1 over the “surface” bounding a closed ndimensional “volume.” This generalization will also subsume Gauss’s theorem (see Section 4.3.2) once the divergence has been expressed in the form of an exterior differentiation. While a metric was assumed to exist, the definition of divX amounted to requiring that Eq. (4.3.13) be valid in the limit of vanishingly small ranges of integration, but this definition is no longer applicable. Since we have dropped the requirement that a metric exist, it is now necessary to define differently the divergence of the given vector X(x). We assume that an nform G(’) is also given. The number G(“)(dp,dq, . . . , dr) obtained by supplying arguments to this form is the measure of the hyperparallelogram delineated by incremental vectors (dp, dq, . . . , dr). Performing an n-volume integration amounts to
154
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
filling the interior of the n-volume by such parallelograms and adding the measures. It is possible to choose coordinates such that n dots
z(n)(-)
n dots
=
r\
G2r\ ...a7y"( e ., ., ., . ).
(4.4.10)
Expanded in terms of basis vectors, X is given by (4.4.1 1)
From
and X one can define an (n - 1)-form (4.4.12)
Substituting from Eq.(4.4.11) into Eq. (4.4.10)yields a-1 dots
*
- 2
&")(X;,.,.,.)=X'dx
- 3
r\dx
r \ . . .s
- 3
- 4
+ X 2 d x Adx
h.
. .s
* \ l + .
(4.4.
Forming the exterior differential of this expression yields n dots
n-1 dots
(4.4. This has validated the following definition of divergence:
r
n-1 dots
1 (4.4.15)
This definition of divergence depends on G('), a fact that is indicated by the subscript can be written on div,. Finally, Eq. (4.4.8) Zj(")div,X =
I,
-
n - 1 dots
Z(')(X, -,., ., .).
(4.4.16)
Here the form Cj(') is playing the role of relating "areas" on the bounding surface to "volumes" in the interior. This role was played by the metric in the previous form of Gauss's law. More precisely, the factor a d e t I I in Eq. (4.3.13) constituted the definition of the "volume measure" Zj(3)(dp,dq, dr). Finally, let us contemplate the extent to which the operations of vector calculus have been carried over to an intrinsic calculus of geometric objects defined on a general manifold. A true (contravariant) vector field is, in isolation, subject to no curl-like operation, but a one-form (or covariant vector) is subject to exterior differentiation, which can be thought of as a generalized curl operation. Furthermore there
SPINORS IN THREE-DIMENSIONAL SPACE
155
is no divergence-like operation by which a true scalar can be extracted from a true (contravariant) vector field X,in the absence of other structure. But we have seen that an n-form-dependent divergence div,X can be formed.
*4.5. SPINORS IN THREE-DIMENSIONAL SPACE’ The treatment here resembles somewhat the discussion of “Cayley-Klein” parameters in Goldstein. Basically the close connection between groups SO(3) and SU(2) is what is to be explored. The treatment follows naturally what has gone before and has the virtue of introducing Pauli matrices in a purely geometric context, independent of quantum mechanics. Our primary purpose is to exploit the representation of a rotation as the product of two reflections (see Fig. 4.1.2) in order to find the transformation matrix for a finite rotation around an arbitrary axis. The three components of certain vectors will, on the one hand, be associated with an object having two complex components (a spinor). On the other hand, and of greater interest to us because it applies to real vectors, a 3-D vector will be associated with one 2 x 2 complex matrix describing rotation about the vector and another describing reflections in the plane orthogonal to the vector. 4.5.1. Definition of Spinors The Euclidean, complex components ( ~ 1 x 2x3) , of an “isotropic” vector x satisfy x12 + x 22
+ x 32
=o.
(4.5.1)
To the vector x can be associated an object called a “spinor” with two complex components (60,tl),defined so that xi
=ti--;, x 2 = i ( t i + t 3 ,
~3=-2totl.
(4.5.2)
Inverting these equations yields
(4.5.3) It is not possible to choose the sign consistently for all vectors x. To see this, start, say, with some particular isotropic vector x and the positive sign for 60. Rotating by angle 01 around the e3 axis causes X I - i x z to be multiplied by e-jrr,and t o by e-ia/2. Taking 01 = 2n causes x to return to its starting value, but causes the sign of 60 to be reversed. Rotation through 2rr around any axis reverses the signs of (to, 61). (This will be easier to see after the next few sections.) Another full rotation restores the signs to their original values. 7S0me parts of this section should perhaps only be skimmed initially. Apart from its obvious importance in atomic physics, this formalism is necessary for analyzing the propagation of spin directions in accelerators and is helpful for analyzing rigid body motion.
156
GEOMETRY O F MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
4.5.2. Demonstration That a Splnor Is a Euclidean Tensor For (60,61) to be the components of a tensor, they must undergo a linear transfonnation when x is subjected to an orthogonal transformation:
(4.5.4)
To see that the right-hand side is a perfect square, write the discriminant (a13
+ i a 1 2 + a22)(-al1 + i a 2 1 + i a 1 2 + 022) (4.5.6) = (all - i ~ 2 1+ ) ~(012 - i ~ 2 2 + ) ~(a13 - ia23)’ = 0, ’
2
- la231 - ( a i l
- ia21
where the vanishing results because the rows of an orthogonal matrix are orthonormal. As mentioned before, 66, with square-only determined by Eq. (4.53,can be given either sign. The second spinor component 4; is given by a similar perfect and (4.5.2); square, but its sign 4; follows from the third of Eqs. (4.5.4)
4.5.3. Associating a 2 x 2 Reflection (Rotation) Matrix with a Vector (Bivector) It has been seen above in Q. (4.1.8) that there is a natural association between a vector a, a plane of reflection 7r orthogonal to a, and a 3 x 3 transformation matrix describing the reflection of a vector x in that plane. There is a corresponding 2 x 2 matrix describing reflection of a spinor (60,Jl) in the plane. It is given by
where (known as Pauli spin matrices in quantum mechanics)
0 -i
1
0
(4.5.9)
SPINORS IN THREE-DIMENSIONAL SPACE
157
Some useful results follow easily from this definition: det 1x1 = -x . x,
x x = (x XY
*
x)l,
+ Y X = 2(x. y)l.
(4.5.10)
The latter two equations are especially noteworthy in that they yield matrices proportional to the identity matrix 1. In particular, if x is a unit vector, X2 = 1. Also, if (XI, x2. x3) are real, X is Hermitean:
x* = XT.
(4.5.1 1)
All these relations can be be checked for q , a2. and a3. For example, ‘ I
for i # j.
= -ojq
Next consider the bivector x x y = ( ~ 2 ~ x3 3 ~ 2 Eq.(4.5.8) is used, the bivectorhatrix association is
2i(x x y) + XY
-YX
(4.5.12)
, ~ 3-~~ 11 ~ 3 , ~ 1 yx2y1). 2
= [X,Y],
If
(4.5.13)
where the matrix “commutator” [X,Y ]E XY - Y X has made its first appearance. If x . y = 0,then XY = - YX and
i(x x y) -+ XY.
(4.5.14)
Problem 4.5.1: Suppose spinor ( t o , 61) is derived from vector x. Show that matrices 61,a 2 , and ~ 3 when , acting on a (40, .$I), have the effect of reflecting in the y, z, the n, z, and the x , y planes, respectively-that is, of generating the spinor derived from the corresponding reflection of x. 4.5.4. Associating a Matrix with a Trivector (Triple Product) Consider a trivector corresponding to three orthogonal vectors x, y, and z.It has six components, one for each permutation of the indices (1,2,3), all equal, except for sign (which depends on the evenness or oddness of the permutation), to the same determinant, which is (x x y) . z = u . z where u = x x y, a vector necessarily parallel to z. The matrices associated to these vectors by Eq. (4.5.8) are to be called X,Y,Z,and U.ByEq.(4.5.10),thematrixiu~zlisequaltoiUZ.ByEq.(4.5.14), the matrix i U associated with iu is XY. Hence
X Y Z = i U Z l = i(x
x y) .zl = iul,
where u is the volume of the trivector. In particular, ala203 = il.
(4.5.15)
158
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS HI: MULTILINEAR
The following associations have been established: x
+ x , y + Y,
1 2
x * yl = -(XY
+YX),
2i(x x y)
-9
[X,Y ] ,
iu
4.
XYZ.
(4.5.16) 4.5.5. Representationsof Reflections Reflections in a plane orthogonal to unit vector a have been described previously, in
Eq.(4.1.7): x’ = x - 2(a.x)a.
(4.5.17)
Rearranging this into a matrix equation using Eq.(4.5.10)and A2 = 1 yields X’ = X - A ( X A + A X ) = - A X A .
(4.5.18)
By Eq. (4.5.14),the matrix associated with the bivector corresponding to orthogonal vectors x and y is proportional to X Y , and reflecting this in the plane defined by A yields X’Y’ = ( - A X A ) ( - A Y A ) = A X Y A .
(4.5.19)
In terms of the matrix U , defined in the previous section as associated with the bivector, U’ = A U A .
(4.5.20)
Comparing Eqs. (4.5.18)and (4.5.20)one can say that, except for sign, vectors and bivectors transform identically under reflection.
4.5.6. Representationsof Rotations It was demonstrated in Section 4.1.3that any rotation can be expressed as the product of two reflections. Let the matrices for these reflections be A and B . When subjected to these, the vector-matrix X and the bivector-matrix U of the previous section transform according to
x’ = B A X A B = ( B A ) x ( B A ) - ’ , u’ = B A U A B ,
(4.5.21)
which is to say identically. Note that A B = ( B A ) - ’ , since it reverses the two reflections. Defining the matrix S 3 B A to represent the rotation, the rotations can be written
x’ = sxs-1, u’ = sus-‘.
(4.5.22)
From these one can say that vectors and bivectors transform identically under rotation.
SPINORS IN THREE-DIMENSIONALSPACE
159
These formulas can be expressed more concretely: Let I be a unit vector along the desired axis of rotation-it is unfortunate that the symbol I, for axis vector, and 1,for unit matrix, are so easily confused-L. its associated matrix, and 8 the desired angle of rotation. By Eq. (4.5.10) and Eq. (4.5.13), since the angle between unit vectors a and b is 8/2, suppressing the identity matrix for brevity, AB
e
+ B A = 2 a . b = 2 cos -,e2
A B - B A = 2iL sin -. 2
(4.5.23)
Subtracting and adding these yields
e
S = B A = cos - - iL sin 2 2
e
(4.5.24)
which with Eqs. (4.5.21) and (4.5.8) yields
X’=
(4.5.25)
This is a very old formula, derived initially by Hamilton. Stated more compactly, (4.5.26) A general, real, orthogonal 3 x 3 rotation matrix has nine parameters, of which all but three are redundant. This representation of the same rotation has only one redundancy-the components of 1 must make it a unit vector. The four elements of S are known as Cayley-Klein parameters. Eqs. (4.5.26) are somewhat coupled but, by Eq. (4.5.8), the third component x i is not, and it is not difficult to separate x i and x i . When that is done, if x is a reference location of a point, then the new location x’ is expressed in terms of the Cayley-Klein parameters. Also, formula Eq. (4.5.26) lends itself naturally to the “concatenation” of successive rotations. Note that the rotated vector x’ can also be obtained from initial vector x and the axis of rotation vector 1 using normal vector analysis (see Fig. 4.5.1): x’ = (1. x)l+ cose((1 x x) x 1)
+ sine(1 x x).
(4.5.27)
4.5.7. Operations on Spinors
The defining use of matrix A associated with vector a is to transform spinor 6 into t’,its “reflection” in the plane defined by a:
6‘
=At.
(4.5.28)
160
GEOMETRY OF MECHANICS 111: MULTILINEAR
I
9
FIGURE 4.5.1. Vector diagram illustrating Eq. (4.5.27) and giving the result of rotating vector x by angle 0 around axis 1. Except for the factor ]Ix XI, which is the magnitude of the component of x orthogonal to I, the vectors I x x and (I x x) x I serve as orthonormal basis vectors in the plane orthogonal to 1.
It is necessary to show that this definition is consistent with our understanding of the geometry, including the association with the reflected isotropic vector associated with 6. For special cases, this was demonstrated in Problem 4.5.1. Also the spinor rotation is given by (4.5.29)
4.5.8. Real Euclidean Space
All of the results obtained so far apply to real or complex vectors, either as the components of points in space or as the vectors associated with reflections or rotations. Now we restrict ourselves to real rotations and reflections in Euclidean (ordinary) geometry. It has been seen previously that a real vector x is associated with a Hermitean reflection matrix X :X* = X T . The matrix U associated with a real bivector satisfies U* = --LIT. Since a rotation is the product of two reflections, S = B A , it follows that
this is the condition for S to be unitary. Hence a 2 x 2 spinor-rotation matrix is unitary. This is the basis of the designation SU(2) for the 2 x 2 representation of spatial rotations. Since a spinor is necessarily associated with an isotropic vector, and there is no such thing as a real isotropic vector, it is not possible to associate a spinor with a real vector. It is, however, possible to associate “tensor products” of spinors with real vectors. The mathematics required is equivalent to the “addition of angular momenta” mathematics of quantum mechanics.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
161
4.5.9. Real Pseudo-Euclidean Space In special relativity, taking axis 2 as the time axis to simplify the use of preceding formulas, the position of a (necessarily massless) particle traveling at the speed of light can satisfy 2
X I +X3
- c2 t 2 ,
2-
x2
= ct,
x;
- x;
+x32
= 0.
(4.5.31)
Replacing ix2 by x2 in the preceding formalism, and now requiring ( x i , x2. x3) to be real, the associated matrix x3
XI - x 2
X I +x2
-x3
(4.5.32)
is real, and there is a spinor (40,tl), also real, associated with x:
BIBLIOGRAPHY References 1. E. Cartan, The Theory of Spinors, Dover, New York, 1981, p. 10.
2. V. I. Arnold, Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics, 2nd ed., Springer-Verlag, New York, 1989, Ch. 7.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
LAGRANGIAN MECHANICS
The major formulations of mechanics are known as the Newtonian, Lagrangian, and Hamiltonian. From the point of view of the physicist this division is rather artificial, since most predictions of one approach have identical predictions in each of the others. The segregation is based entirely on the mathematical methods used. In both the Lagrangian and the Hamiltonian descriptions, artificial functions (Lagrangian and Hamiltonian) are introduced and variational principles are prominent. Central to Lagrangian mechanics is the need to describe the system by n “generalized coordinates.” Variational methods in the “configuration space” of these coordinates are used to derive the n second-order, ordinary equations of motion, determining the system evolution. Motion-describing kinetic quantities (velocities) appear only as time derivatives of the generalized coordinates. Though most powerful when idealizations are made that are frictionless, lossless, etc., the Lagrangian method also permits the introduction of phenomenological forces. The P o i n c d equation further generalizes the Lagrange procedure when it is impossible to define generalized coordinates. The division into Newtonian, Lagrangian, and Hamiltonian descriptions has always been regarded as natural in mechanics, and we follow that tradition. In fact, the division is even more natural in a treatment (like this one) that emphasizes the geometric formulation of the subject. The space of generalized coordinates, though describing the same configurations as the Euclidean space with which we are familiar, requires a more complicated geometrical treatment. Furthermore, the geometry of configuraton space and of phase space are different. The most basic aspect of this difference is that the momentum variables basic to phase space require different geometric representation than do the position vectors.
164
LAGRANGIAN MECHANICS
We start with Lagrangian descriptions. If only elementary methods were being described, the Newtonian description would come fist, but that is not the case here because a more sophisticated “gauge-invariant” treatment employs different geometric methods than are needed for the Lagrange-Poincd description. To see the dependencies amongst the chapters in this text, refer to the flowchart near the end of the introduction.
LAGRANGE-PO INCARE DESCRIPTION OF MECHANICS 5.1. REVIEW OF THE LAGRANGE EQUATIONS One of our stated aims is to show that the Poincark equations are “better than” the Lagrange equations (while preserving the ways the Lagrange equations are “better than” the Newton’s equations). We start by recalling the Lagrange equations and review the benefits that justify the level of abstraction needed to use them. The actual use of the equations can be mechanized, making it tolerable, even natural, to forget whatever complexity attended their derivation. This will also largely be true for the Poincark equations. In particular, in cases where the Lagrange equations are valid, the Poincark equations trivially reduce to the Lagrange equations. It is when the Lagrange equations are not applicable, and/or when the system exhibits symmetry, that the power of the Poincark method emerges. Consider an N particle mechanical system. It is convenient to use Cartesian coordinates ( x ( i ) , y ( i ) , z ( i ) ) to locate each of the N point particles of the system. In the presence of constraints, however, it is often both necessary and possible to introduce “generalized coordinates” q = (4’. q 2 , . . . , q”),n 5 3N, that automatically respect the constraints. They are related to the Cartesian coordinates by functions fi : X(j)
= f(i)(q), i = 1,. . , N .
(5.1.1)
In this case, the constraints are said to be “holonomic” or “integrable.” It does not complicate the formalism greatly if the functions f(i) are allowed to depend also on time r, but for simplicity we exclude this possibility for now. (One of the merits of the Poincark formalism is its ability to handle nonintegrable constraints, but to simplify the present discussion we exclude this case also and restrict discussion to the case where the mechanical system is unambiguously described by generalized coordinates.) 165
166
LAGRANGE-POINCARE DESCRIPTION OF MECHANICS
The kinetic energy of the system is defined as a sum over all particles in the system: (5.1.2)
Substituting Eqs. (5.1.1) into Eq. (5.1.2), the kinetic energy of the system can be expressed in the form 1
T(q, 4) = p ( q ) 4 k d .
(5.1.3)
In general, the coefficients Ukl are functions of q as indicated, but not of the velocities q. If the system is subject to generalized forces, they are often describable by a potential energy function V(q, t ) (this assumption is not essential, however). The Lagrange equations are
d _ aT _
dt aqi
-
av a T - -aqi
aqi’
i = 1, ..., n.
(5.1.4)
It is customary to simplify these equations by defining a “Lagrangian function” L(q, q) = T - V, but the resulting simplification is mainly cosmetic. Because it is common for T and V to have different symmetry, and because symmetry will often be essential, we will often leave force terms explicit but refer to the equations as Lagrange equations nevertheless.
5.2. THE POINCARE EQUATION
We are now ready to apply our geometric ideas to mechanics proper. The plan is to introduce the “Poincar6 equation” as an “improvement” over the Lagrange equation. This equation will be derived two different ways, first using traditional elementary calculus and then using modern geometric methods. This is not really an extravagance since it is important to correlate old and new methods. Furthermore, this discussion can serve as a review of Lagrangian mechanics, since more than half of the derivation amounts to studying the properties of the Lagrange equations. There are two rather different ways of introducing the Lagrange equations themselves. Both methods start by assuming that the configurations of the mechanical system under study are describable uniquely by “generalized coordinates” 4‘.From there it is quickest to postulate Hamilton’s principle of least action and then apply the calculus of variations. Though this procedure seems like “black magic” when first encountered, it has become so well established that it is now considered reasonably straightforward and elementary. This variational method has the further advantage of immediately exhibiting a remarkable “invariance” to changes of coordinates. The other method amounts to applying “brute force” to the equations given by Newton’s second law to transform them into Lagrange equations using nothing but calculus.
THE POINCARE EQUATION
167
This method is also not very well motivated since it is not clear a priori what one is looking for. Furthermore, once one has derived the Lagrange equations, one has to derive their remarkable invariance property. We will take the second approach, taking advantage of the fact that the Lagrange equations were already derived this way in Chapter 3, and proceed to study their properties. Before proceeding, we preview the ways in which it is necessary to be more ambitious in order to obtain the Poincark equations by the same methods that yield the Lagrange equations. Two considerations are important: 0
0
Fundamental to the Lagrangian formalism are its generalized coordinates q’ and their corresponding velocities q ’ . l However, there are convenient velocities, of which angular velocities are the most familiar example, that cannot consistently be expressed as the time derivatives of generalized coordinates. Something about the noncommutativity of rotations causes this (as we shall see). In describing constrained motion, it is always difficult, and usually impossible, to express the constraints analytically without the use of velocity coordinates-such constraints normally are not “integrable.” The coordinates are said to be nonholonomic, and the Lagrange procedure is not applicable.
One tends to be not much concerned about the latter restriction, but that is more because physics courses skip over the problem than because nonholonomic systems are rare in nature. Trains, which are holonomic (at least if they are on cog railways) are far less prevalent than automobiles, which are not. Because it permits “quasicoordinates,” the Poincark equation can descibe nonholonomic systems. Later we will see how the whole line of reasoning can be greatly streamlined by a “geometric” treatment. It is assumed the reader has already mastered the Lagrange equations, especially concerning the definition of generalized coordinates and generalized forces and the application of d’Alembert’s principle to introduce force terms into the equations. We assign ourselves the task of changing variables in the Lagrange equations. This will illustrate some of the essential complications that Lagrange finessed when he invented his equations. To follow these calculations it is necessary to “understand” the tangent space of possible instantaneous velocity vectors of the system or (more likely) to accept without protest some steps in the calculus that may seem a bit shady. A remarkable feature of the Lagrange equations that has already been pointed out is that they maintain the same form when the generalized coordinates q’ are transformed. Since the Lagrangian depends also on velocity components q’, one is tempted to consider changes of the velocity variables as well, especially in cases where the kinetic energy can be expressed more simply in terms of “new” velocities, call them si , rather than in terms of the 4’. In simple cases, the velocity transformation can be “integrated” and is equivalent to a pure coordinate transformation-for ‘In this text, the quantity q’ = dq’ /dr is always called “the velocity corresponding to q’” even though in some cases this causes the physical dimensions of different velocity components to be different.
168
LAGRANGE-POINCARE DESCRIPTIONOF MECHANICS
example, consider the change of rectangular coordinates describing transformation to a uniformly translating frame of reference-but in general this is impossible. The most familiar example of the sort of complication being discussed is rotational motion of an extended object: Let d, s2,and s3 be three instantaneous angular velocities2 around respective axes of a rectangular frame. If two of the angular velocities vanish, then the motion can be “integrated to yield the macroscopic value of the remaining angle and hence specify the orientation. One can attempt to define three global angles, one at a time, in this way. But if rotation occurs around more than one axis, since the order of application of rotations affects the final orientation, these angles would not satisfy the requirement that there be a on-to-one correspondence between generalized coordinates and system configurations? Our purpose in the rest of this section therefore, is to learn how to change the velocity variables in the Lagrange equations to new variables in which these complications can be handled. Consider then a mechanical system described by generalized coordinates q l , q 2 , , . , q”.To describe the system, introduce new “quasi-velocities’’ sl, s2,. . . , s“,some or all of which differ from q ’ , q 2 , , . . , 4”. By definition they are invertible superpositions of the generalized velocities related to the original velocities by linear relations of the form4
.
(5.2.1)
Typically the coefficients in Eq. (5.2.1) are functions of the coordinates, but they must not depend on velocities. If the number of quasi-velocities is small, it may be convenient to give them individual symbols such as (sl, s2, . . .) = (s,g , 1 , . . .). In this case the transformation looks like (5.2.2)
? h e r e are too few letters in the English alphabet. It is conventional to give the coordinates of a mechanical system symbols that are Roman characters such as r , x, y, etc., and, similarly, to use such characters as u for velocities. To emphasize their ephemeral character, we use Greek symbols u,y , b, . . . , to stand for the “quasi-coordinates”that are about to be introduced. Comesponding to these will be “quasivelocities” and, to emphasize their real existence while preserving their ancestry, they will be symbolized by matching Roman letters s. g, I, . . . . A further (temporary and self-imposed) “requirement” on these characters is that there be uppercase Greek characters Z, r, A, . .. , available that “match” them (to serve as a mnemonic aid later on.) The quantities 3’. s2, s3 being introduced here are “quasi-velocities:’ not momenta. Probably because the most common quasi-velocities are angular velocities, the symbol w is commonly used in this context, but that symbol is already overworked, for example also as a general f o m . In any case, once the general arguments have been made, a less restrictive notational scheme will have to be acceptable. 3By carefully specifying their order of application, the so-called “Euler angles” circumvent this problem to some extent. 4The slight displacement to the right of the lower index is to facilitate mental matrix multiplication but otherwise has no significance, and the upldown location of indices will also have no significance for the time beiig. Also, the order of the factors A‘( and q’ could be reversed without changing anything, except that it would no longer be a conventional representation of an equation using matrix multiplication.
THE POINCARE EQUATION
169
This form has the advantage of mnemonically emphasizing the close connection between any particular quasi-velocity, say g , with its corresponding row
(rl,r2,r3,r4).
As an example, for a single particle with coordinates x , y and z, one could try the definition s = x x x, which can be written SX
(zz)
nogood
-
noinverse
0
(2y
-2
i
Y
ix)
(i).
(5.2.3)
This choice, though linear in the velocities as required by (5.2.1), is illegal because the determinant vanishes identically, meaning the relation cannot be inverted. Note that the vanishing does not occur at a single point in configuration space (which would be tolerable), but rather is identically true for all ( x , y, z ) (see Problem 5.2.2 and Problem 5.2.3).This failure is unfortunate since the transformation (5.2.3) seems to be otherwise promising. Its purpose would have been to write the equations of motion in terms of the angular momentum variables (sx , sY , sL) rather than the linear velocities (i,j , 2). The characteristics of this transformation can be discussed at greater length to illustrate the concept of foliation. To have a similarly motivated sample to visualize, we can try instead (5.2.4) which is invertible. For s‘ defined as in Eq. (5.2.1) it can happen that coordinates or are findable such that5
do‘ q -=sr, dt
r = l , Z ,..., n ,
(5.2.5)
but this is the exception rather than the rule. (The or would have to be found by “integrating” Eqs. (5.2.I), which may not be possible, even in principle.) Nevertheless, for the time being, we will pretend that “quasi-coordinates” exist, promising to later undo any damage that this incurs. In any case, Eq. (5.2.1) can be written in differential form
da‘ = A‘i(q)dq’ r = 1 , 2 , .. . , n.
(5.2.6)
That this is a differential of the “old-fashioned” calculus variety is indicated by the absence of overhead tildes. The concept of “tangent space”-a linear vector space containing sums of and scalar multiples of tangent vectors-is central to the present derivation. The tangent space is a mathematical device for making it legitimate to regard a quantity like dx/dt as not just a formal symbol but as a ratio of two quantities dx and dt that 5Recall that the symbol
means “qualified” equality.
170
IAGRANGE-POINCAR6 DESCRIPTION OF MECHANICS
are not even necessarily “small.” A physicist is satisfied with the concept of “instantaneous velocity” and does not insist on distinguishing it from an approximation to it that is obtained by taking d t small enough that the ratio d x / d t is a good approximation. In this text, the tangent space will be said to constitute a “linearized” approximation for evaluating the effects of small deviations from any particular configuration. The following partial derivatives can be derived from Eq. (5.2.6):
(5.2.7) these are the “Jacobian matrices” for the coordinate transformations of Eq. (5.2.6). The invertibility requirement can be stated as a nonvanishing requirement on the determinant of the matrix of coefficients. We assume then that Eq. (5.2.6) can be inverted:
s- k --( ~ - l ) k . ~ i I
’
(5.2.8)
It must be remembered that the matrices A and A-’ depend on q. In mechanics, the most important differential is dW = Fdx, the work done by force F acting through displacement d x . For a system described by generalized coordinates 4’.this generalizes to
dW = Q i d q ‘ ,
(5.2.9)
where the Qi are said to be “generalized forces.” The discussion of contravariant and covariant vectors in earlier chapters suggests strongly that the Qi may be expected to be covariant, and the notation of (5.2.9) anticipates that this will turn out to be the case6 When expressed in terms of the quasi-coordinates,d W is therefore given by
dW = Sidu’,
where Si = Qk(A-’)ki,
(5.2.10)
where the generalized forces Si have been obtained from the Qi in the same ways that generalized forces are always obtained in mechanics. Geometrically it amounts to counting contours (represented by covariant vector Qi or Sj) that are crossed by the m o w represented by the dqi or the d u ’ . At this point, the “shady” steps mentioned above have to be faced. Regarding the velocities s‘(q, q) as depending on q and independently and linearly on q, one has
(5.2.11) the assumed linearity in the q’ has made this step simple. (Recall that the meaning of partial differentiation is only unambiguous if the precise functional dependence summation in Eq.(5.2.9)may be more complicated than it appears. It may include sums over particles or independent systems. Such sums should not be implicitly included in the summation convention but, for brevity, we let it pass.
THE POINCARE EQUATION
171
is specified. In this case, the implication of asr/aqk is that all the q’ and all the q’ except qk are being held constant.) Many people have difficulty seeing why it makes sense for q‘ to vary and q’ to not vary. However, Lagrange thought it made sense, and everyone since then has either come to their own terms with it or taken their teacher’s word for it. As mentioned before, the accepted mathematical procedure for legitimizing this procedure is to introduce “tangent planes” at every location. Displacement in any tangent plane is independent of both displacements in the original space and displacements in any other tangent space. Once this concept has been accepted, it also follows that (5.2.12) This maneuver will be said to be “pure tangent plane algebra.” Because S‘ stands for d a r / d f and q i stands for dq’/dt, and because do‘ and dq’ reside in the tangent space, it is legitimate (in spite of one’s possible recollections from freshman calculus) simply to divide out the dt. With the first of Eqs. (5.2.7), this yields Eq. (5.2.12). In deriving the Lagrange equations from Newton’s equations, the only tricky part is more or less equivalent to deriving Eq. (5.2.12). Because the Lagrange equations have already been derived (from purely geometric considerations) in Section 3.1.5, we skip this derivation and directly express the Lagrange equations as the equality of two ways of evaluating the work during arbitrary displacement Sqk; (5.2.13) (The only significanceto the fact that Sqk is used instead of, say, d q k ,is that later the Sqk will be specialized for our own convenience.) We now wish to transform these equations into the new quasi-coordinates. Because the Lagrange equations are based on the expression for the kinetic energy of the system, the first thing to do is reexpress T. The function expressing kinetic energy in terms of the new coordinates will be called 7: T(q, 4, t ) = T(q, S, t ) .
(5.2.14)
If this were a true coordinate transformation, then it would be possible for the first argument of T to be u.But since the very existence of coordinates u is in question, a hybrid functional dependence on new velocities and old coordinates is all we can count on. What will make this ultimately tolerable is that only derivatives of T will survive to the final formula. The terms in Eq. (5.2.13) can be worked on one at a time, using Eqs. (5.2.7) and (5.2.1 I), to obtain aT
aTaz
as.@
aqk -
-
aT
- -Ark, asr
172
LAGRANGE-POINCARE DESCRIPTIONOF MECHANICS
(5.2.15)
The strategy so far, in addition to trying to eliminate the q and q variables, has been to replace 5' by si wherever possible. The q i factors remaining can be eliminated using Eq. (5.2.8). Collecting terms, the left-hand side of Eq. (5.2.13) contains the following three terms:
(5.2.16)
To abbreviate the writing of the second term, the following coefficients, destined to play a large role as "structure constants" in the sequel, have been introduced: (5.2.17)
Because the differentials 60' are arbitrary, they can be replaced by Kronecker 6's. As a result, the Lagrange equations have been transformed into (5.2.18)
These are known as the Poincad equations. Unlike the n Lagrange equations, which are second-order-in-time derivatives, these n equations are first-order-in-timederivatives, and the independent variables are now velocities. The defining equations (5.2.1) provide n more equations, making 2n in all. In this regard, the Poincar6 procedure resembles the transition from Lagrange equations to Hamilton's equations but, in spite of this, I believe it is more appropriate to regard the Poincad equations as only a modest generalization of the Lagrange equations. No momentum variables have been defined and no phase space has been introduced. Apart from the fact that these are complicated equations, an essential complication is that 'i; and the coefficients c'li are a priori known explicitly only as functions of the original q-variables. If the equations were being solved numerically, then, at each time step, once the the s-variables had been updated, the corresponding q's would have to be calculated, and from them the c'lj coefficients calculated. To avoid this complication, it would be desirable to have the c'li coefficients expressed in terms of the cr variables. But this may be impossible, which brings us back to the issue that has been put off so far-what to do if the cr-variables do not exist.
THE POINCARE EQUATION
173
Though the quasi-coordinates cri do not necessarily exist, the quasi-velocitiescertainly do-they are given by Eq. (5.2.1). Our task then is to evaluate terms in the Poincark equation that appear to depend on the 0‘ in terms of only the s’ . Actually, we have already done this once without mentioning it in Eq. (5.2.10) when we calculated the quasi-forces Si . Because this calculation was “local,” it depended only on differentials da’,which, as we have said before, are strictly proportional to the s’ in linearized approximation. That was enough to relate the Si ’s to the Qi ’s. Essentially equivalent reasoning allows us to calculate the derivatives a?;/acr‘ that appear in the Poincark equation: (5.2.19) Earlier, we minimized the importance of obtaining the generalized forces from a potential energy function U . But if this is done, and Lagrangian L = T - U is introduced to take advantage of the simplification,then, to complete the transformation to quasi-coordinates, we have to introduce a new Lagrangian appropriate to the new coordinates; the formula is -
L(q, s, t ) = n q , s, t ) - U(q),
(5.2.20)
whereT(q, s, t ) is given by Eq. (5.2.14). The “force” terms of the Poincark equations then follow as in Eq. (5.2.19). Cartan’s witticism that “tensor formulas exhibit a dkbauche d’indices” is supported by formula (5.2.17) for c‘li. We can make this formula appear less formidable in preparation for its practical evaluation using matrices. First, having introduced the notation
(which declines to distinguish between lower and upper indices), by performing Problem 5.2.1 you can show that c‘li is antisymmetric in its lower indices. Furthermore, note that the upper index r is “free” on both sides of the equation. To illustrate this last point, suppose that, as in Eqs. (5.2.2), quasi-velocities are symbolized by s 1 = s, s2 = g, . . . . Then definitions A’i 3 C; and A2i E r; correlate the “rows” of “matrix” A with the “output variables” s and g in a mnemonically useful way (because the uppercase Greek (C and r) and lowercase Roman (s and g ) symbols form natural pairs); an index has been suppressed in the bargain. With this notation, the defining equations (5.2.17) become
The definitions have been manipulated in this way to allow them to be treated by matrix multiplication; the order of factors has been changed and one matrix has been transposed in order to switch the order of indices. Also, the superscripts (s) and (g)
174
LAGRANGE-POINCARE DESCRIPTIONOF MECHANICS
are no longer running indices-they ously known as s’ and s2.
’
identify the particular quasi-velocities previ-
Example 5.2.1: A simple pendulum, bob mass rn = 1, hanging from the origin at the end of a light rod of length t = 1 swings in the x , z plane, in the presence of gravity g = 1. Let q 1 = 8 define the pendulum angle relative to the z-axis (which is vertical, positive up). Define quasi-velocity s = cos 0 8. Write the Poincare equation for s. Is there a coordinate 0 for which s = d a / d t in this case? Will this result always be true in the n = 1 case? The equation da/dr = cose d@/dtby which a is to be found, transforms immediately into d@/d8 = cos9 which, neglecting a constant of integration, yields u = sin 9. Since u exists, all the coefficients (5.2.17) vanish. (In the n = 1 case this will clearly always be true.) The potential energy function can be chosen as U ( 0 ) = cos 8; here a possible constant contribution to I/ has been dropped since it would not contribute to the Poincark equation anyway. The kinetic energy is T (0) = b2/2, and transformation to quasi-velocities yields
The derivatives needed are d
aZ
1
These are already complicated enough to make it clear that the transformation was ill-advised but, since this is just an example, we persevere. The Poincak equation (along with the quasi-velocity-defining equation) is
. s2sin6 s = -COS2
+ sin8cos8,
S
8 = __ cos 8 *
It is not hard to show that these are equivalent to the well-known equation 8 = -sin 8.
Example 5.2.2: Suppose the pendulum in the previous example is a “spherical pendulum,” free to swing out of the plane assumed so far. Letting Cp be an azimuthal angle around the z-axis, define quasi-velocitiesby
(i)(i) ( =
=
- sin4 0 cos$e
).
7Though they have lower indices, the elements Ci or Ti are not automatically the covariant components of a tensor-recall that they are only the row elements of an arbitrary, position-dependent matrix. However, in their role of relating two tangent plane coordinate systems, they will be subject to important invariance considerations later on.
THE POINCARE EQUATION
175
As mentioned before, only two of these (any two) are independent. Let us choose sx
and sz.The matrix A and its inverse are then
To correlate with the numbering system used above, let 8 -+ 1, 4 the Poincari coefficients are obtained from the upper row of A:
4 2.
For r = 1,
5.2.1. Some Features of the Poincare Equations In general, the factors c‘lj(q) are functions of position q and Poincark Eqs. (5.2.18) represent no improvement over the original Lagrange equations. However, there is immediate simplification in important special cases that will be considered now. Suppose that generalized coordinates a’(q) do in fact exist globally such that si = dai/dr, as in Eq. (5.2.5). Because the order of taking partial derivatives does not matter, differentiating Eq. (5.2.7) yields
(5.2.23) From Eq. (5.2.16), it then follows that the array of factors C‘li all vanish. In this case, the Poincari equations become simply the Lagrange equations in the new generalized coordinates d . This means that the analysis up to this point amounts to having been an explicit exhibition of the form invariance of the Lagrange equations under a coordinate transformation. Another important simplification occurs when the partial derivatives vanish. This possibility is closely connected with symmetry. If the coordinate ol can be regarded as fixing the orientation or location of the system and the kinetic energy = 0. If the external is independent of orientation or location respectively, then forces are similarly independent of cri, the generalized force factors Si also vanish. The best-known case in which both of these simple features occur is in the force-free rotation of a rigid body; if s is an angular velocity, then the kinetic energy depends on s but not on the corresponding angle (I (which would specify spatial orientation of the system), and there is no torque about the axis, so the corresponding generalized force S also vanishes. This example will be pursued shortly. In the traditiond Lagrangian vocabulary, the coordinate d is then said to be “ignorable.” In general, the factors c;‘(q), defined in Eq. (5.2.17), depend on position q, but it is the case where these factors are constant, independent of q. that Poincari had particularly in mind when he first wrote these equations. In this case, as will be shown in the next chapter, the transformations resulting from changing the quasicoordinates form a “Lie group” for which the c‘li are “structure constants” that fix
5
176
LAGRANGE-POINCARE DESCRIPTION OF MECHANICS
the commutation of infinitesimal group transformations. Examples illustrating this case are the subject of a series of problems to appear shortly.
*5.2.2. lnvariance of the Poincare Equation* The newly introduced coefficients c'li have a certain "intrinsic" coordinate independence. To show this they will be expressed in terms of the bilinear covariant introduced in Chapter 2. To accomplish this, start by recalling that the quasi-velocities s,g, . , defined by Eq.(5.2.1) can be written in the form
.
a [ d ] = C; dq',
y [ d ] = ri dq',
etc.,
(5.2.24)
where, as in Section 2.3.2, the "argument" d indicates that the coordinate deviation is dq' (rather than, say, Sq'). The (position-dependent) coefficients are, on the one hand, elements in the row corresponding to s of matrix Ar(q) and, on the other hand, coefficients of the form a[d]. If we introduce a second coordinate deviation Sq', by Eq. (3.2.7)the bilinear covariant is da[S] - h [ d ] =
(s - 3) aqj
aqk
8qk d q j
(Sqkdqj - S q j dqk)r.
(5.2.25)
In Section 3.2, this quantity was shown to have an invariant significance, and in Chapter 2 the coefficients of an invariant form linear in the contravariantcomponents of a vector were identified as covariant components. For the same reasons, the coefficients can be regarded as the covariant components of an antisymmetric tensor in the q' coordinates or as the coefficients of an antisymmetric differential two-form in the basis. One also recognizes the coefficients (!?% - $ as ap84' pearing in Eqs. (5.2.22). Though the elements & were chosen arbitrarily in the first place, the matrix elements Bki appearing in Eq. (5.2.22) are none other than the Jacobian coefficients that relate tensors in the original and quasicoordinates, and this imposes conditions on the partial derivatives of the E:k.According to Eqs. (5.2.1) and (5.2.21), the displacements are related by Sqk = Bk;Saiand dqJ = BJIdal,and as a result
(3 2)
1
&'
da[S] - Sa[d] = c$)a"S]a"d].
(5.2.26)
This shows that Eqs. (5.2.22) amount to being equations transforming the components of an antisymmetric tensor between two coordinate systems and that the coefficients c:;) are components of the forms (5.2.25) in the quasi-basis. 'This section can be skipped on first reading. The same result will be obtained more geometrically later on.
177
THE POINCARE EQUATION
We have seen therefore that the extra terms in the Poincare equation (over and above those in the Lagrange equation) exhibit an invariance to coordinate transformation that is much like the invariance to coordinate transformation of the Lagrange equation itself. The invariance is more difficult to express, but that should perhaps have been expected since the class of applicable coordinate transformations has been extended.
5.2.3. Translation into the Language of Forms and Vector Fields Using notation introduced first in Section (2.2), the defining equations (5.2.1) or (5.2.2) can be expressed as
etc. A differential duqi on the right-hand side is a form that, when o p e r sn g on a displacement vector, projects out the change in coordinate 4'.Similarly, do projects out the change in quasi-coordinate c.Note that at this stage the equations relate local coordinate systems and have no content whatsoever that depends on or describes actual motion of the system. Proceeding, as in Section 2.4.5, by labeling dual-basis vectors . -j as Z' = dq in the original system, andZ(') = da,3 8 ) = d y , etc., in the new system, Eq. (5.2.28)is equivalently written as
-
-
As defined in Section 2.4, the 2 are natural basis forms in the space dual to the space with basis vectors el along the coordinate directions 4'. The @), Z(g), etc., are similar basis forms for the quasi-coordinates. It was shown in that section that the basis vectors themselves are then related by
(e,
eg
.
.)
=(a/&
B/ay
.
.)
= (a/aql a/aq2 . .)a,
(5.2.29)
where the matrix has been expressed as A. All matrix elements are, of course, implicitly dependent on q. The velocity vector is expressed in the two bases by
v = q = se, +ge,
+ . . . = (i1el +(i2e2+. . . .
(5.2.30)
178
LAGRANGE-POINCARt DESCRIPTION OF MECHANICS
Repeating Eqs. (5.2.2) with the notation of Eq. (5.2.28), the velocity coordinates in the two frames are related by $1 =
C j i q i , and qi = A ’ j s j .
(5.2.3 1)
The transformation formulas for the components of forms have been given in Eq. (2.4.10). As in that section, the matrices that have been introduced here are related by X = A-’ .
5.2.4. Example: Free Motion of a Rigid Body with One Point Fixed The orientation of a rigid body with one point fixed can be described by Euler angles (#,@,@) (see Fig. 5.2.1). The problem of noncommuting rotations mentioned above is overcome in this definition by specifying the order, first by angle Q, about the zaxis, next by B about the new x-axis, then by @ about the new z-axis. The unprimed axes in Fig. 5.2.1 can be regarded as fixed in space; the triply primed axes are fixed in the rigid body, with origin also at the fixed point. That the origin remains fixed in space can result either from its being held there by a bearing or from the facts that the body is free, the origin is its center of mass, and the origin of space coordinates is taken at that point. At any instant, the rigid body is rotating around some axis, and the angular velocity vector points along that axis, with length equal to the speed of angular rotation around that axis. This vector can be described by coordinates referred to the fixed-inspace (“laboratory”) (x, y, z) axes or to the fixed-in-body (x”’, y”’, z’”) axes. For the
FIGURE 5.2.1. Definitionof Euler angles (&,O, $). Initial coordinate axes are (x, y , z ) ,final axes are (x”’, y”’,z”’), and the order of intermediate frames is given by the number of primes. The initial axes are usually regarded as fixed in space, the final ones as fixed in the rigid body with one point fixed at the origin.
THE POINCARE EQUATION
179
FIGURE 5.2.2. An iIlusJation2 Eulezngles that is less cluttered than that in Fig. 5.2.1, showing the rotation axes d@/dt,dO/dt, dJl/dt for angular rotations with one Euler angle varying and the other two held fixed.
former choice, evaluating the kinetic energy is complicated because the spatial mass distribution varies with time and with it the moment-of-inertia tensor. Hence we will w2,03)To . take the body angular velocities as quasi-velocities, calling them (d, calculate them, one can treat the Euler angular velocities d, 6, and $ one by one. Taking advantage of the fact that they are vectors directed along known axes, one can determine their components along the body axes. Finally the components can be superimposed. Fig. 5.2.2 shows the axes that correspond to varying Euler angles one at a time. The transformation to quasi-velocities is illustrated in the following series of problems.
Problem 5.2.1: Show that the factors c r l i ( q ) , defined in Eq. (5.2.17), are antisymmetric in their lower indices. For n = 3, how many independent components c'ri are there?
Problem 5.2.2: Define three vector fields (or operators)
a a R - - - z- - x y -
a#y
a
- ax
a
R,=--=x--ya@ a y
a az'
a ax'
where @', and 9' are azimuthal angles around the respective coordinate axes. In spherical coordinates, qjz is traditionally called simply 4. Show that these operators
180
LAGRANGE-POINCARC DESCRIPTION OF MECHANICS
satisfy the commutation relations
[Rx,RyI= -RZ, [Ry, &I = -Rx,
[R,, RxJ = -Rye
Using (r, 8 , # ) spherical coordinates and Example 3.4.1, derive the relations
a
R, =-sin#R,
86
= -cos#-
-ccos@cot&---,
a 84
a +sin#
[email protected] ae a@
Problem 5.2.3: For a single particle, with the three components of quasi-velocity s defined as linear functions of Cartesian velocities ( i ,j , i) in Eq.(5.2.3), evaluate the elements Af according to Eq.(5.2.1). State why this is unsatisfactory and interpret the failure geometrically. Show how the result of the previous problem implies the same thing.
Problem 5.2.4: The pendulum defined in Example 5.2.1 is now allowed to swing freely out of the x , z plane, making it a “spherical pendulum.” Natural coordinates describing the bob location are the polar angle 6’ relative to the vertical z-axis and the azimuthal angle around the z-axis 4, measured from the the x, z plane. Instantaneous angular velocities around the x, y and z-axes are given by
0”= s x = -sin$& e y = s y = cos@0, (42
SZ
= 6.
Choose s x and sz as quasi-velocities and write the Poincark equations for these variables along with 0 and #, (This is just an exercise in organizing the work; there is no real merit to the choice of variables.)
Problem 5.2.5: With Euler angles ($I,@,$) as defined in Fig, 5.2.1 playing the role of generalized coordinates 4’.define quasi-velocities (ul, u2, u3) = ( w ’ , w2, w 3 ) as angular velocities of rotation of a rigid body around body-axes x”’,y”’, z”’. Evaluate ( w ’ , w 2 ,w 3 ) in terms of “Euler angular velocities” Express the transformations in the form w‘ = A r , ( q ) q i as in Eq. (5.2.1). [Since the angular velocity is a true vector (insofar as rotations and not reflections are at issue), it is valid to start with an angular velocity with only one Euler angle changing, say corresponding to 6 # 0, and work out its body components, do the same for the other two, and apply superposition.]
(4,(4,$).
Problem 5.2.6: For the velocity transformation of the previous problem, evaluate the coefficients c‘li (9) and show that they are independent of (4, 8, $). (Note that q stands for ( # , 8 , $) in this case.) If highly satisfactory cancellations do not occur in the calculations of c‘li, you have made some mistake.
VECTOR FIELD DERIVATION OF THE POINCARE EQUATION
181
Problem 5.2.7: The kinetic energy of a rigid body, when expressed relative to “body-axes” (necessarily orthogonal), is a sum of squares: 1 12 1 T(w)=-Z1w +-z2w 2 2
-
22
1 +-z3w 2
32
.
Using this expression for the kinetic energy, write the Poincari5 differential equations, Eq. (5.2.18), for the angular velocities (o’, w2,w3).
Problem 5.2.8: Specialize the solution of the previous problem to the case of the spherical pendulum.
5.3. VECTOR FIELD DERIVATION OF THE POINCARE EQUATION Since it has become standard for intermediate-level mechanics to be based on Hamilton’s principle, it is assumed that the reader is familiar with the calculus of variations. Nevertheless, application of the principles of “least time” and of “least action” will now be reviewed. This is introductory, on the one hand, to a variational derivation of the Poincari5 equation (later in this chapter) and, on the other hand, to the introduction into mechanics (in a later chapter) of ideas drawn from physical optics-the main new quantity being the “eikonal” or “optical path length.”
5.3.1. The Basic Problem of the Calculus of Variations A “Lagrangian” function L ( q , 4, t) depends on the generalized coordinates q, the generalized velocities q, and time t. Any configuration space curve specified in the form q = q ( t ) ,with instantaneous velocity given by q E is a candidate, though not necessarily a physically realized, trajectory of the system. Deferring any discussion of its physical meaning, the “action” S corresponding to such a curve is defined by
9,
where the path begins at point P1 : (?I, ql) and ends at point P2 : ( t 2 , qz). Only the dependence on endpoints is indicated explicitly by the notation S( P I , P . ) ,but S depends on the entire curve joining these points as well. For this reason, S is known as a “functional.” n o such curves are illustrated in Fig. 5.3.1. The basic problem is to find that “extremal” curve from P1 to P2 that makes S(P1, 9 )take on an extreme (minimum or maximum) value. The action S in mechanics will turn out to be the analog of the optical path length of physical optics. The basic integral like (5.3.1) in optics that can be analyzed using
182
LAGRANGE-POINCARE DESCRIPTION OF MECHANICS
t x
x* (t) +6x(t)
tl
t2
FIGURE 5.3.1. Graph showing the extremal trajectory x * ( t ) and a nearby nontrajectory x * ( t ) + 6X(t).
the calculus of variations has the form C
C
(5.3.2) Here x, y, and z are Cartesian coordinates with x and y “transverse” and z more or less parallel to the “beam” of light. The abbreviation O.P.L.stands for “optical path length,” which is the “path length weighted by index of refraction n.” This quantity, O.P.L./c, is the “time” in “principle of least time.” Although it is not entirely valid in physical optics to say that the “speed of light” in a medium is c / n , one may act as if it were and use the formula to obtain the time of flight of a particle following the given trajectory with this velocity. 5.3.2. The Euler-Lagrange Equations Once a curve q*(t) making Eq. (5.3.1) extreme has been found for arbitrary endpoints, its dependence S( PI,&), on its upper endpoint in particular, has become well-defined. The so-called Hamilton-Jacobi theory is based on this dependence, but for now we consider the endpoints fixed. For notational simplicity (generalization is easy), we will take q as having just two components and call them x and y. Fig. 5.3.1 shows the dependence of one of these, the x coordinate, on time t . A similar figure for y ( t ) need not be drawn, as we will vary only x ( t ) at this time. Plotted are the extremal trajectory x * ( t ) and both a deviant trajectory x * ( t ) Ax(t) and the deviation Ax(?) itself, which vanishes at both ends. The varied action is given by
+
S
+ (AS), =
il 12
+
L(x* SX, y , X*
+ &, t ) d t .
(5.3.3)
By Taylor expansion of the integrand, the variation is given by
(5.3.4)
VECTOR
FIELD DERIVATION OF THE POINCARE EQUATION
183
The function a x ( ? ) is arbitrary in shape, but smooth. It is also vanishingly small in order to justify having kept only first-order terms in the Taylor expansion. In order to make the integrand proportional to a x ( ? ) , the second term is integrated by parts, yielding the extremum condition
The last term vanishes because (for now) Sx(t1) = Ax(t2) = 0. The parenthesized integrand factor must then vanish because Sx is arbitrary. The result is the EulerLagrange ordinary differential equation d aL - aL -dt
ai
ax‘
(5.3.6)
Spelled out more explicitly, with partial derivatives indicated by subscripts, (5.3.7) Identical manipulations in n dimensions yield the equations satisfied by generalized coordinates q‘ :
(5.3.8) In mechanics, these equations reduce to Newton’s equation, F = ma, in optics to the equation for the path taken by a “ray” of light, Eq. (10.1.17).
Problem 5.3.1: Starting from Eq. (5.3.8) and the O.P.L. given by Eq.(5.3.2), derive the differential equation satisfied by optical rays (it will reappear as Eq. (10.1.17))
d ds ( n z ) = Vn, where n ( r ) is index of refraction and r is a radius vector from an arbitrary origin to a point on a ray at a position given by arc length s along the ray.
5.3.3. Calculus of Variations Using the Algebra of Vector Fields In this section {and only this section) we use the notation a/at instead of d / d t for the “total time derivative.” The reason for this is that a new subsidiary variable u will be introduced and the main arguments have to do with functions f (u, t ) and derivatives holding one or the other of u and t constant. Consider again Fig. 5.3.1. The particular (dashed) curve Sx(t) can be called the “shape” of a variation from the looked-for “true trajectory” x*(t) shown as a solid curve. We now restrict the freedom of variatior by replacing 6 x ( t ) with uSx(t), where u is an artificially introduced variable whose range runs from negative to pos-
184
IAGRANGE-POINCARE DESCRIPTIONOF MECHANICS
itive and hence certainly includes u = 0; the range will not matter, but it may as well be thought of as - 1 < u c 1. With 6 x ( t ) being called the shape of the variation, u can be called its “amplitude.” Differentiation with respect to amplitude at fixed time and with fixed shape will be expressed as a / a u . Differentiation with respect to time along a varied trajectory whose shape and amplitude are both fixed will be expressed as a / a t . The function u b x ( t ) is still an arbitrary function of time, but at intermediate points in the analysis, we will insist that only u vary so that the shape 6 x ( t ) can be held fixed and the action variable S treated as a function only of u. The varied curve joining P1 and 9is given, then, in parametric form, as
(5.3.9)
...
+
q“(u, t ) = q*”(t) ui$q“(r).
Though being “restricted” in this one sense, variations will be “generalized” in another sense. In the formalism developed so far, the variation 6 x ( t ) has been described only by deviations Sq’ of the generalized coordinates describing the system at time t. But the variation at time t can be regarded as belonging to the tangent space at the point x ( t ) on the candidate true trajectory at that time. As a result, the shape of a variation can be described by a general vector field w(t). This vector will be treated as “differentially small” so that it makes sense to add it to the position vector of a point in the space. Also it is assumed to vanish at the endpoints. Then Eq. (5.3.9) is generalized to become x(u, t ) = x*(t)
+ uw(t).
(5.3.10)
With this notation, as in Eq. (5.3.3), the action corresponding to Lagrangian L(x, i, t ) is given by (5.3.11) This is the first instance of our unconventional use of the symbol a / a t mentioned above in italics; its meaning here is that integrand L is being evaluated along a varied curve in which u and the shape of the variation are both held constant. Again S ( u ) depends on all aspects of the curve along which it is evaluated, but only the dependence on u is exhibited explicitly. The extremum condition is
+--
d t = i , r 2 ( aL .w+ ax
%g)
dt.
aql
au
(5.3.12) From this integral condition we wish to take advantage of the arbitrariness of the function w to obtain the differential equation of motion. As in Eq. (5.3.5) we must manipulate the integrand in such a way as to leave w (or one of its components) as
VECTOR FIELD DERIVATION OF THE POINCARE EQUATION
185
a common multiplier. This has already been done with the first term, which has furthermore been written as manifestly an invariant-which means it can be evaluated in any convenient coordinate system. If we proceeded from this point using the original coordinates we would reconstruct the earlier derivation of the Lagrange equations (see Problem 5.3.2). Instead we proceed to obtain the equations of motion satisfied by quasi-velocities. Basis vectors directed along the original coordinate curves in the tangent space at any particular point are a/&l , a/aq2,. . . , a/aqn.Symbolize the components of the velocity vector in this basis by vi = 4'. At every point in configuration space arbitrarily different, other basis vectors ql , q2,.. .q,, can be introduced and a vector in the tangent space such as the instantaneous velocity vector v can be expanded in terms of them. Such coordinates of the velocity are known as "quasi-velocities" si. (Recall that a typical example of an s' is an angular velocity around a coordinate axis.) The velocity can then be expressed in either of the forms
As in Q. (5.2.1), the quasi-velocities can also be expressed as linear combinations of the vi components: S"
= ArjvJ.
(5.3.14)
With the time argument suppressed for simplicity, after substitution of Eq. (5.3.14) the Lagrangian is expressible as a new function
-
L ( x , s) = L ( x , X).
(5.3.15)
Proceeding as in Eq. (5.3.12), we obtain
(5.3.16) As noted before, the first term is automatically expressible in invariant form, but we are still left with the problem of expressing the second term in a form that is proportional to the (arbitrary) vector w. We are forced at this point to take what may seem like a digression, referring back to Section 3.4.2, where vectors were interpreted as operators. Let f ( x ) be an arbitrary function of position in configuration space. If x is expressed as a function o f t and u to describe evolution of the system along a given trajectory, then f ( x ) will be similarly expressible as a function o f t and M . Its time rate of change with u fixed can be expressed two ways:
(5.3.17)
186
LAGRANGE-POINCARE DESCRIPTIONOF MECHANICS
Using Eq.(5.3.10), the derivative off with respect to u with t fixed can be expressed in terms of the quasi-basis:
(5.3.18) Recall that w is an arbitrary variation function. Note also that (though it is inconsistent with our normal conventions) the w i are its components relative to the quasibasis-not relative to the original coordinate basis. Eqs. (5.3.17) and (5.3.18) are therefore equivalent to a / a t = s i q i and a / a u = w ' q , . When Eqs. (5.3.17) and (5.3.18) are differentiated with respect to u and t respectively the results are therefore
(5.3.19) Subtracting these equations, the left-hand sides cancel because the order of partial differentiation does not matter, and the right-hand sides can be simplified using [qj,qkl
(5.3.20)
= cikoi?
where a formula for the coefficients cSk was derived in Eq. (3.4.15).The result is asi
awi
au
at
.
- = -+ c;ksjwk.
(5.3.21)
This formula is quite remarkable in that the si and w i are utterly independent quantities-the last term entirely compensates for the differences between their derivatives. This digression puts us in a position to substitute Eq. (5.3.21) into Eq. (5.3.16):
The first and third terms are proportional to w but, remembering that w k is the component in the quasi-basis, we should express the first term as e,t ( Z ) w k in order to obtain w k as a common factor. Also, the second term can be manipulated using integration by parts. Since the function w vanishes at both endpoints, the result is
With the factor w k being arbitrary, the integrand must vanish, or
d dt
aZ
.
ask
J k as1
aZ .
_ _ - cl. -sJ
-
= qk(L).
(5.3.24)
BIBLIOGRAPHY
187
Since the subsidiary variable u can now be discarded, the traditional d / d t notation for total time derivative has been restored. Lo and behold, the Poincare equation has reemerged. As before, the n first-order differential equations in Eq. (5.3.24) have to be augmented by the n defining Eqs. (5.3.14) in order to solve for the 2n unknowns q' and s'. In addition to being much briefer than the previous derivation of the P o i n c d equation, this derivation makes the interpretationof each term clearer. This derivation illustrates the power of the modem vector field formalism. (The derivation was made artificially long here by our verbosity and because of our need to digress to derive Eiq. (5.3.21).)
Problem . . 5.3.2: Starting from Eq. (5.3.12) and assuming a Lagrangian of the form L ( q ' , q ' , t ) where the q' are unconstrained generalized coordinates, derive the Lagrange equations (5.3.8). This yields a derivation that is equivalent to that of Section 5.3.2 but that is made neater by the introduction of the artificial variable u. BIBLIOGRAPHY References for Further Study Section 5.2 N. G. Chetaev, Theoretical Mechanics, Springer-Verlag. Berlin, 1989. H. Poincark, C. R. Hebd. Seances Acad. Sci., 132,369 (1901).
Section 5.3 M. Born and E. Wolf, Principles of Optics, 4th ed., Pergamon, Oxford, 1970. R. Courant and D. Hilbert, Methods of Mathematical Physics, Vol. 1. Interscience, New York, 1953. L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Mechanics, Pergamon, Oxford, 1976. H. Rund, The Hamilton-Jacobi Theory in the Calculus of Variations, Van Nostrand, London, 1966. B. F. Schutz, Geometrical Methods of Mathematical Physics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 1995.
Section 5.3.3 V. I. Arnold, V. V. Kozlov, and A. I. Neishtadt, Mathematical Aspects of Classical and Celestial Mechanics, 2nd ed., Springer-Verlag. Berlin, 1997, p. 13.
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARE EQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
6.1. CONTINUOUS TRANSFORMATION GROUPS
It is obvious that the symmetries of mechanical systems have a significant impact on the possible motions of the system. To describe this the mathematical treatment can be functional or geometric. The former approach is probably familiar from the concept of “cyclic” or “ignorable” coordinates in Lagrangian mechanics: If the Lagrangian is independent of a coordinate, then its conjugate momentum is conserved. The more purely geometric treatment in Newtonian mechanics should be familiar, for example in the treatment of the angular velocity as a vector subject to the normal rules of vector analysis. In Chapter 8, the use of purely geometric, “Lie algebraic” methods in Newtonian mechanics will be studied, and here we apply group theory to the Lagrange-Poincarb approach. The power of the Lagrange procedure is that it becomes entirely mechanical once the coordinates and Lagrangian have been established, but it can be regarded as a weakness that symmetries of the system have an analytical but not a geometric interpretation. We wish to rectify this lack by incorporating group theoretic methods into Lagrangian mechanics, or rather into the P o i n c d equation, since, as has been mentioned repeatedly, the Lagrange procedure is insufficiently general to handle many systems. Of course we also wish to maintain the “turn the crank‘’ applicability of the Lagrangian method. Though a supposedly “advanced” subject+ontinuous groups-is to be used, only its simpler properties will be needed and those that are will be proved explicitly. Furthermore, only calculus and linear algebra are required. This is consistent with the general policy of this text of expecting as preparation only material with which most physicists are comfortable, and developing theory on a ‘3ust in time” basis. It is not appropriate to claim that a deep understanding of the subject can be 188
CONTINUOUSTRANSFORMATION GROUPS
189
obtained this way, but starting from “the particular”-manipulating a Lagrange-like equation-provides a good introduction to “the general.” As mathematics, therefore, the treatment in this chapter would have to be regarded as “old-fashioned” (being due to Lie it is certainly old) and perhaps even clumsy. A change of variables’ (such as x’ = (1 a ’ ) x a’) that depends on continuously variable parameters (such as a’ and a’) and with the property that a small change in parameters causes a small change in the transformed variable is called an r-parameter continuous transformation (r = 2). Such a transformation acts on a space of n-component variables x (n = 1). If there is a parameter choice (such as u1 = 0, u2 = 0) for which the transformation is the identity, and the inverse a’))x’ (-a2/(1 a ’ ) ) ) , and patransformation is included (x = (1 - u’/(l rameters can necessarily be found that give the same transformation as the product (also known as concatenation or composition) of any two transformations (x” = ( 1 +a1 +b’ b’al)x+ (a2 b2 +b ’a 2 )),the transformation is called a continuous transformation group or a Lie group. Let R(a) = R ( a ’ , a’, . . . ,a‘) symbolize the element of the transformation group corresponding to parameters a. (The main transformations of this sort that have been studied up to this point in the course are orthogonal transformations, with the orthogonal matrix 0 parameterized by three independent parameters, for example Euler angles. In this case R ( a ’ , a’, a 3 ) = O(+, 8,v).) For notational convenience, zero values for the parameters are assumed to correspond to the identity transformation-that is, R(0) = Z.(If this is not true, the parameters should be redefined to make it true as it simplifies the algebra.) In general, R need not be a matrix but it is the simplest case as concatenation is then represented by matrix multiplication. In any case, the concatenation of R(a) followed by R(b)is indicated by R(b)R(a). The existence of a transformation inverse to R(a) requires the existence of parameters 3 such that
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
R(ii)R(a) = R(0)
(6.1.1)
( -a1 - - a ’ / ( l + a ’ ) , a 2 = -a2/(l+a1)).Fortransformation R(a)followedby R(b) the group multiplication property is expressed as the requirement that parameters c exist such that
R(c) = R(b)R(a)
(6.1.2)
(c’ = a1 +b’ +b’a’, c2 = a’+b’ +b’a2).It is primarily this concatenation feature that causes these transformations to have useful properties. Expressed functionally, the required existence of parameters c requires the existence’ of functions 9“(a; b) ‘In the following paragraphs, as new quantities are introduced they are illustrated, in parentheses, by an ongoing example, starting as here with x’ = ( 1 a ’ ) x a2. ’Though the existence of functions gY(a;b) is analytically assured, their definition is implicit and they are not necessarily available in closed form. Examples for which they are explicitly available will be given shortly.
+
+
190
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCAREEQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
such that cK = @ K ( a l..., , a'; b ' ,
. . . ,b'),
K
= 1 , 2 , . . . , r,
or c = &a; b) (6.1.3)
(@'(a;b) = ~ ' + b ' + b ' a ' , @ ~ b) ( a= ; a2+b2+b1a2).Forourpurposes,Eq. (6.1.3) will be employed primarily in situations where B is infinitesimal, meaning that it corresponds to a transformation close to the identity; to signify this, we change symbols b + 6a and identify c as a da. Then Eq. (6.1.3) yields
+
a
+ da = 4(a; ba).
(6.1.4)
(Throughout this chapter, the symbol S will always be associated with near-identity group transformations.) Differentiating EQ.(6.1.4) yields a linear relation between the increments (Sa', . , . ,Sa') and the increments (da', . . ., da'), daA = B i ( a ) S a f i , where B i ( a ) =
...,d; b l , . . . ,b r ) abfi
.
(6.1.5)
The matrix B is r x r. It provides the (linearized) variations of (arbitrary) Lie parameters due to a subsequent close-to-identity transformation.Introducing its inverse, A = B - ' , and inverting Eq. (6.1.5) yields
(6.1.6)
SaA = A\(a)dafi.
(In our example
Note that A and B, matrices belonging to the group, are independent of x. Continuous transformations, when acting on a configuration space with generalized coordinates q' (in the simplest case the original coordinates q' are Cartesian coordinates ( x , y, z)), are expressed by functions f (nonlinear, in general, and independent in ways to be clarified later) such that
'
q" = f ' ( q 1 , . . . ,q";a 1, . .. , a'),
i = 1 , 2 , . . . , n or q' = f(q; a)
(6.1.7)
(f'(q; a) = (1 + a ' ) x + a 2 ) .Derivatives of these transformations will be symbolized by (6.1.8)
USE OF INFINITESIMAL GROUP PARAMETERS AS QUASI-COORDINATES
191
= x , u12 = 1). Because the derivatives are evaluated at a = 0, the functions an instantaneous system reconfiguration can be represented by an infinitesimal group transformation, there is a corresponding velocity of evolution of the system coordinates (ull
u’, (q) are independent of the near-identity parameters a. If
dq‘- - uIK(q)--: . SaK -
(6.1.9)
dq’ = uiK(q)SaK,
(6.1.10)
dr
dt
or in general
where the SaKare the parameters of the transformation. A requirement to be used below is that the functions uIk be independent-none of them is allowed to be identically expandable in terms of the others. One says that all of the parameters are to be essential-identities like a2 = 2a’, a3 = a’ a2,or a’ = any-function(a2, a3, .. .) are to be excluded. The concatenation requirement of Eq. (6.1.3) for these transformation functions is
In our example r > n, but commonly the number of parameters r is less than the number of independent variables n. The arguments in the next section are followed most easily in the case r = n.
6.2. USE OF INFINITESIMAL GROUP PARAMETERS AS QUASI-COORDINATES Sometimes the time evolution of a mechanical system can be described using a continuous group (for example the rotation group when rigid body motion is being described) with the coordinates q(t) expressible in terms of the transformation functions f;
q(r) = f(q(0);W)).
(6.2.1)
Here it is assumed that the configuration can necessarily3 be described as the result of operating on an initial configuration q(0) with R(a(r)). At a slightly later time the same equation reads
q
+ dq = q(t + d t ) = f(q(0); a(t + d t ) ) .
(6.2.2)
3A continuous group is said to be “transitive” if it necessarily contains a transformation carrying any configuration into any other. This requires r ? n.
192
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARE EQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
FIGURE 6.2.1. Pictorial representation of alternate sequential transformation leading from an initial configuration to the same altered configuration.
The occurrence of time variable t suggests that Eq. (6.2.2) describes the actual motion of a particular system, but we wish also to describe "virtual" configurations that are close together, but not necessarily realized in an actual motion. For such configurations
q
+ dq = f(q(0);a + da).
(6.2.3)
Eqs. (6.2.1) show that the quantities a, called parameters so far, can be satisfactory generalized coordinates and can serve as independent variables in Lagrange equations for the system! Before writing those equations we pursue some consequences of Eq. (6.1.1 l), applying it to a case where a is macroscopic and b = da is differential;
q
+ dq = f(f(q(0);a);6a) = f(q(0); @(a;6a)) = f(q(0);a + da) = f(q; da). (6.2.4)
As illustrated in Fig. 6.2.1, parameters a
a+d?
+ da describe the direct system reconfig-
uration q(0) q 4-dq. But the final configuration can also be produced by the da sequence q(0) 8, q 3 q dq. In the latter case the final transformation is infinitesimal, close to the identity, and its parameters are 6a = (Sa' , . . . ,Sa'). We encountered equations like Eq. (6.1.10) (or rather its inverse) in Eq. (5.2.1), while discussing quasi-coordinates a' with their corresponding quasi-velocities si . As in that case, though small changes SaK can be meaningfully discussed, it is not valid to assume that the quasi-coordinatesaK can be found globally for which these are the resulting differentials. On the other hand, Eqs. (6.2.1) define the parameters a" globally. We will shortly employ the SaA's as differentials of quasi-coordinates. We now have three sets of independent differentials-local displacements can be expressed in terms of dq' (not independent if r < n), dux, or Sa". From the outermost members of Eq. (6.2.4), substituting from Eq. (6.1.8), variations dq' can be related to variations d a A indirectly via variations SaK,
+
dq' = uiK(q)6aK = uiK(q)AK,(a)daA,
(6.2.5)
4There are situations with r 5 n in which reconfigurations are usefully described by variations of a, but they can form a complete set of generalized coordinates only if r = n. The parameters a will in fact be interpreted as generalized coordinates below.
INFINITESIMAL GROUP OPERATORS
193
where 6aKhas been replaced using Eq. (6.1.6).This leads to
(6.2.6) The first factor depends on the configurational coordinates q (and implicitly on the definition of, but not the values of, the parameters a); the second factor is a property of the transformation group only. The elements of (6.2.6)can be regarded as the elements of the Jacobian matrix of the transformation q -+ a only if r = n, but they are well-defined even if r < n ; in that case, the variations generated by variation of the group parameters span less than the full tangent space. Expressions (6.2.6) are fundamental to the proof of Lie’s theorem, which governs the commutation relations of infinitesimal transformations of the Lie group. Before turning to that, it will be useful to first associate directional derivative operators with tangent space displacements. 6.3. INFINITESIMAL GROUP OPERATORS It has been remarked that different variables can be used to specify displacements in the tangent space at q. Here we concentrate on Lie transformations close to the identity, as parameterized by S a p . Consider any general (presumably real) scalar function F(q) defined on the configuration space. Using the left portion of (6.2.5), its change d F corresponding to parameter variation 6aP is
aF . aF d F = -dq’ = -u’ P (Q)6aP. (6.3.1) 34’ 89‘ The purpose of this expansion is to express dF as a superposition of changes in which one parameter aA varies while the rest remain constant. To emphasize this, Eq. (6.3.1) can be rearranged and reexpressed in terms of operators X, defined by5 ‘
.
dF = (Sap X,)F,
a
where X, = u*,(q)-.
aqi
(6.3.2)
The operators X, (which operate on functions F(q)) are called “infinitesimal operators of the group.” There are r of these operators, as many as there are independent parameters in the group. Each one extracts from function F the rate of change of F per unit change in the corresponding parameter with the other parameters fixed. Though the motivation for introducing these operators Xp comes entirely from our analysis of continuous groups, the operators are no different from the vector fields discussed in Section 3.4. To conform with notation introduced there, they have been assigned boldface symbols, and the O / 8 q i are given similar treatment. 51n Eq.(6.3.2) (and all subsequent equations) the order of the factors 2 and u’,(q) has beenreversed . Bq’ to avoid the nuisance of having to state that does not act on u I p . As a result, the indices no longer appear in their conventional, matrix-multiplication order. But since u I p has one upper and one lower index, their order doesn’t really matter; if one insisted one could restore the conventional order by defining u$ = upi and regarding the elements 8, as being arrayed as a row instead of a column.
w
B4’
194
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARE EQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
Instead of the differentials Sap, one can introduce "quasi-velocities''
(6.3.3) Then the system evolution described by Eq. (6.1.9) results in evolution of the function F ( q ) according to
dF -= sPXpF. dt
(6.3.4)
Results obtained previously can be reexpressed in terms of the X,. For example, choosing F to be the variable qi yields a result equivalent to Eq. (6.1.9):
+
+
Example 6.3.1: For the infinitesimal transformation x' = (1 a')x a2, it was shown above that u l1 = x , u \ = 1 , and the infinitesimal operators are therefore
Example 6.3.2: For 2-D rotations given by x' = R(a')x,
($) - (cossin aa'1
-sin a ' ) cos a 1
(d)
4' = a ' +b'
(6.3.6)
Note that this result followed from the fact that rotation angles about the same axis are simply additive. Explicitly, the transformation formulas and infinitesimal operators are
f' = cos a 1 x 1 -sin a' x2, u"
2
= -x ,
f 2 = sin a' x ' +cos a' x 2 ,
u 21 = X I ,
XI = - x 2 ( a / a x ' )
+ n'(B/8x2).
Anticipating later formulas, the same result could have been obtained using the matrix J3 defined in Eq. (4.2.26) (satisfying J: = -1 after suppressing the third row and the third column). x' = e4J3x,where a more conventional symbol for the parameter results from setting a' = 4. Differentiating with respect to r#~ yields
195
INFINITESIMAL GROUP OPERATORS
0 - o)x=(;:2). 1
Example 6.3.3: In 3-D, consider the transformation
o x' = ea.Jx, where a -J =
a2 -a'),
-a3
0
a3 -a2
(6.3.7)
o
a'
and the triplet of vectors J was defined in Eq. (4.2.26).This expresses the matrix for angular rotation around i by macroscopic angle a in terms of the matrix describing = 1 a . J/1! microscopic rotation around the same axis. Expanding it as (a . J)2/2! . . ., differentiating with respect to a', then setting a = 0 yields
+
+
+
Combining this with corresponding results for a2 and a3 yields -x3
0
x2
-x'
(6.3.8) 0
A common notation is to change the name of these particular differential operators to Ri:
R1 = x2(8/Lk3) - x3(8/ax2), R2 = x3(a/8x') - x'(8/ax3), R3 = x ' ( S / O X ~ -)x2(S/&').
(6.3.9)
These can be written compactly as Ri = e i j k x j a / a x k . In the next section it will be where #Ji is a rotation angle about axis i. shown that Ri = a/a#Ji,
Example 6.3.4: The 3-D Rotation Group. To calculate the matrix B i j , defined in Eq. (6.1.6), for the 3-D rotation group (in a special case) it is sufficient to consider a finite rotation R(a) like that of Example 6.3.2 followed by an infinitesimal rotation R ( b ) like that in Example 6.3.3: R(c) = R ( b ) . R(a) =
b2 -6') 1
0 ( Io cosa' o sina'
1 b3 -b2
-b3 1 b'
1 b3 -b2
-cosa'b3+sina'b2 cosal - sinal b' sina' + c o s a l b l
-sina' cosa'
sina'b3+cosa'b2 - sina' - cosa' b' cosa' - sinal b'
(6.3.10)
196
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARE EQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
Ideally, this result would be expressible in the form R ( c ) = since that would mean the coefficients c were known. Not knowing how to do this we have to proceed less directly. The computations can usefully be performed using Maple; the listing is given below. The eigenvalues of a 3-D orthogonal matrix are, in general, given by 1, e*@, where 4 is the rotation angle. The trace of a matrix is the sum of its eigenvalues, and it can be seen from the matrix R(a), which represents pure rotation around the x-axis by angle u ' , that the sum of eigenvalues for an orthogonal matrix is 1 cia' +e-iu' - 1 2cosa'. Letting #c be the rotation due to matrix R ( b ) . R ( a ) , it
+
+
+
follows that 1 2 c o s 4 ~= 1 + 2 COSU' - 2 sina' b'. and hence, to lowest order in b', 4~ w u1 + b'. For the matrix R ( c ) , let u(') be the eigenvalue corresponding to eigenvalue 1 . That is, Rv(') zz and hence also R T d ' ) = ~ ( ' 1 ,since RT = R - ' . It follows that
( R - RT)u(')= 0, and from this follows the proportionality
($::) U p
(R23 R31 - R13 R32) . R12 - R21
+
This can be converted to a unit vector and then multiplied by u' b' to produce a vector with both the correct direction and correct magnitude. These calculations are carried out in detail in the accompanying Maple run. For the argument value a = ( a ' , 0, 0), the functions defined in Eq. (6.1.3) are given by
(6.3.11) Then we have
To deemphasize the special significance of the first axis let us replace U ' by a variable #, a rotation angle around arbitrary axis. The determinant J ( 4 ) = IBI, the Jacobean of transformation (6.1S ) , may depend on the rotation angle, but not on the rotation axis; by Eq. (6.3.12) it is given by
(6.3.13)
INFINITESIMALGROUP OPERATORS
197
which satisfies J ( 0 ) = 1. This Jacobean relates increments of parameter volume according to
d3a = J(4)s3a
(6.3.14)
where da and 6a are the parameter increments illustrated in Fig. 6.2.1. 6.3.0.1. Inwarimt fntegration: For a function f defined for every element I;:, = 1,2, . . . , N, of a finite group, it is possible to define the “sum” F = This amounts to assigning equal (unit) weight to each element of the group, and the sum is “invariant” in the sense that, for any particular group element T, we have f(TI;:)= f(Tj),since the two summation differ only by the ordering of their terms. We wish to define a similar “sum” over elements of our continuous group. If the parameter u l ,u 2 ,u3 are plotted along rectangular axes, since “radius” /ul’ a2’ a3* = 4, the rotation angle, all possible rotations can be represented by points in the interior of a sphere of radius A, with diametrically opposite points being identified as representing the same transformation. A‘summation” of function f over all transformations of the group takes the form of a sum over “grains” ai or as an integral
EL,f(c).
i
EL,
EL,
+ +
(6.3.15)
where R(a) is the group element, and pd(4)d3a is the “number of grains” in parameter volume d3a. For this sum to be invariant, the “density” pd(4) must depend only on 4, as shown, and for the same reason, the function f must depend only on 4 as well. Complicating the task of defining this sum to be invariant is the fact that, for any particular transformation R,the parameters of product transformation RR(ai) will not in general match any of the initially chosen grains. But it is possible to choose the density pd to provide the integral form of the summation with the desired property. Reintroducing the infinitesimal parameters 6a1,Sa2, 6u3, the number of grains in parameter volume &i3acan be expressed as ps(Sa) 63a = S3u, where we have arbitrarily set the density in the vicinity of the identity transformation equal to 1. Invariance can be assured by requiring pss3a = pdd3a, and for this, Eq. (6.3.14), we require pd(4) = J - ’ ( + ) , where J ( 4 ) is given by Eq. (6.3.13). Using polar coordinates to evaluate integral (6.3.14), we obtain (6.3.16) as the invariant integral over parameter space.
198
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARe EQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
Maple Program > >
# Investigate
3D Rotations
uith(lina1g): readlib(trigsub6) : Ra := matrix( 3, 3, [ 1 , 0 , 0 0 , cos(a1) , -sin(al) o , sin(ai) , cos(a1)
, 1 1;
c1 0 [ Ra := [ 0 cos(a1) [ [ 0 sin(a1)
Rb := matrix( 3, 3, [ 1 , -b3 b3 , 1 -b2 , bl
, , ,
0
-
1
sin(a1) cos(a1)
1 1 1 1
b2 , -bl , 1 1 1; [
1
-b3
c Rb := [ b3
1
c [-b2
b 2 1
- bl
bl
1 1 1
1 1
RbRa := evalm(Rb &* Ra) ; [
1
c
RbRa := [ b3
c
[
-
b2
- b3
cos(a1)
cos(a1)
-
+
b2 sin(a1)
b3 sin(a1) + b2 cos(a1)
bl sin(a1)
bl cos(a1) + sin(a1)
CosphiC := 1/2*( RbRa[l,l] + RbRa[2,2] + RbRac3.31
phiC := a1 + bl; phiC := a1 + bl cllp :- RbRa[2,3] c12p := RbRa[3.1] c13p := RbRa[1,2]
-
-
-
RbRa[3,2] ; RbRa[1,3]; RbRa[2,11;
-
sin(a1) cos(a1)
-
1 1;
- bl
cos(a1)
- bl sin(a1)
1 1 1 1 1
INFINITESIMALGROUP OPERATORS
199
cllp := - 2 sin(a1) - 2 bl cos(a1) c12p := - b2 - b3 sin(a1) - b2 cos(a1) c13p := - b3 cos(a1) + b2 sin(a1) - b3 expand(cl1p-2 + c12p-2 + c13p-2): csq := subs( {bl^2=0,b2~2=0,b3'2~0,b1~3=O,b2~3=0,b3^3~0~, I' ; 2
csq := 4 sin(a1)
+ 8 sin(a1) bl cos(a1)
taylor( phiC*cllp/sqrt(csq), bl=0, 2): simplify( 'I , sqrt): # csgn stands for "complex sign" which can be taken as -1 subs( csgn(sin(al))=-l , 1: c-1 :=
1'
.
2 cll := a1 + bl + O(b1 ) taylor( cl2p/sqrt(csq), b2=0, 2) : # This result is already linear in small quantities (b's) taylor( phiC*(") , bl=O, 1): simplify( 'I , sqrt): subs( csgn(sin(al))=-l , 'I 1: c12 := ; # Dropped terms are actually quadratic in b's
taylor ( cl3p/sqrt (csq) , b2=0, 2) : taylor( phiC*(") , bl=O. 1): simplify( 'I , sqrt): , 1: subs( csgn(sin(al))=-l c13 := 11 .
Problem 6.3.1: Consider a matrix of the form ex where X = a . J as given in Eq. (6.3.7);that is, X is a skew-symmetric 3 x 3 matrix. Show that sin+ eX=l+-X+
4
1 -cos+ ~2
X , where
+2
1 2
= -- tr(X2).
(6.3.17)
DO this first for a' = 4, a2 = a3 = 0, which was the special case appearing in Example 6.3.4.
200
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCAREEQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
6.4. COMMUTATION RELATIONS AND STRUCTURE CONSTANTS OF THE GROUP
The operators X, operate on functions to describe the effect of infinitesimal group transformations; the functions u i p are expansion coefficients (see Eq. (6.3.2)).The property of the infinitesimal operators making them specific to some continuous group is that their commutators can be expressed in terms of so-called group "structure constants." Lie proved that for a continuous group these structure constants are, in fact, constant. This will now be demonstrated. Substituting from Eq.(6.3.2), the required commutators can be expressed in terms of the operators 8;; 89
(6.4.1) Though quadratic in the functions X, (and hence in the functions do)these will be shown to be expressible as a linear superposition (with constant coefficients) of the operators Xu themselves. The expression for [X,,X,] in Eq. (6.4.1) can be simplified using results from the previous section. The quantities 6aK,being differentials of quasi-coordinates, are not necessarily the differentials of globally defined coordinates. But they occur only as intermediate variables, and the variables q and a are globally related by Eqs. (6.2.1).By equalifyofmixed partials it follows that
(6.4.2) In these equations it is not required that r = n. In the summations, Roman indices range from 1 to n, and Greek indices run from 1 to r . Substituting from Eq. (6.2.6) yields
(6.4.3) Differentiating ui,(q(a)) with respect to a* and using Eq. (6.2.6) yields
(6.4.4) Substitution into Eq. (6.4.3)yields a relation satisfied by the coefficient of a/&' on the right-hand side of Eq. (6.4.1):
COMMUTATION RELATIONS AND STRUCTURE CONSTANTS OF THE GROUP
Multiplying by B y
E
(A-’)?
where the coefficients c:~ PoincarC equation:
and by B i
= (A-’):
201
yields
have the same form as encountered previously in the
(6.4.7) This definition should be compared with Eq. (5.2.17), encountered while discussing the Poincari equation. (See also Section 3.4.5.) The only difference has to do with the choice of independent variable. Instead of using the qK variables in the earlier derivation of the PoincarC equation, we could have used the variables a K .In that case, the formula (6.1.6) would have resembled the formula (5.2.1) in which quasicoordinates were first introduced. It seems therefore as though our notation has been ill-advised, since the matrices A; appearing here and there have different meanings. However, it was shown in Section 5.2.2that the coefficients c“& depend on the quasicoordinates only, not on the particular variables used in defining them. It follows that the coefficients c:, calculated here are the coefficients appearing in the Poincari equation. Previously the matrix Aij was arbitrary; now it is specific to the Lie group. To continue the proof of Lie’s theorem, one can take advantage of the antisymmetry in its lower indices of cKTa by subtracting from Eq. (6.4.6) the same equation with r and CT reversed. Next differentiate with respect to a”, using the expansion a / a d = (aqk/aaP)(a/aqk) while evaluating the left-hand side-this permits the parameters a to be treated as constant-to show that it vanishes. Finally, because of the factorized form of the right-hand side, a/aaP can be applied directly to it. The final result is
(6.4.8) Such an identity would imply a functional dependency among the uiK,which have, however, been hypothesized to be independent. It follows that the coefficients vanish and hence that the c“& are constants. We have seen before that the constancy of these coefficients simplifies the Poincark equation markedly. Lie also proved the remarkable converse result according to which the constancy of the cKTuimplies the existence of a corresponding continuous transformation group. We will not need that result. Recapitulating, Eqs. (6.4.I), (6.4.6), and (6.3.2) yield
x
[X,,X,] =c;,,u’K-‘ 8 =
8s
‘TO
K’
(6.4.9)
J
The name “structure constants” given to the coefficients c:,, is based on this relation.
202
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARE EQUATIONWITH GROUP THEORY
6.5. QUALITATIVE ASPECTS OF INFINITESIMALGENERATORS
The infinitesimaloperators Xi are examples of the vecrorjelds introduced in earlier chapters and are related therefore to directional derivatives. Recall, for example, Eq. (2.4.34): B
8 BY
-=j=ey.
(6.5.1)
When introduced, Eq. (2.4.34) was justified only for Euclidean axes. These definitions provided a natural association of basis vectors such as ey and the corresponding operator When applied to function F ( x ) , this operator extracts the (linearized) variation of F ( x ) as y varies by 1 unit while x and z are held fixed. This is also known as the directional derivative in the y direction of the function F. Before developing this further, we make two qualitative comments. First, an abstraction that most physicists first grasp in high school is that of insfuanraneousvelocity, as well as its distinction from average velocity. Whereas average velocity relates to actual displacements occuring over finite times, instantaneous velocity yields an imaginary displacement that would occur in unit time if conditions remained unchanged. Another abstract concept is that of “virtual displacement,” say Sq’, when the generalized coordinates are 4’.This is a possible displacement, consistent with constraints if there are any; it is a conceivable but not necessarily an actual displacement of the system. The actual motion picks one out of the infinity of possible virtual displacements. Second, for some purposes the detailed trajectory taken by an object is important, but the particular parameterization of the trajectory, and in particular the time, is not. Here is a far-fetched example: Suppose you are writing a field guide to birds, intended to provide information as to which birds can be seen near which cities. To research it you drive from New York to Florida, taking down at intervals the time, birds observed, and the towns where they were observed. Suppose you make a mistake and read the odometer instead of the clock, or fail to hold your speed constant. Neither of these errors would affect the data, since the time data is used at most for interpolating between towns. Of course, it is important for the correct route to be taken and for town names to be recorded correctly whenever a bird is observed. The effect of recording distance instead of time is only to change the parameterization of the route, but not the route itself. We now return to our discussion of continuous transformations. The operator X, is a “directional derivative operator” acting in the direction for which only parameter up varies. Hence rotation operator R1 operating on F(q) extracts a quantity proportional to the differential d F in an infinitesimal rotation around the x-axis. If F depended, say, only on r , then d F would vanish. Consider the “infinitesimal rotation” of Example 6.3.4:
6.
1 b3 -b2
-b3 1
b’
b2 -bl). 1
203
QUALITATIVE ASPECTS OF INFINITESIMAL GENERATORS
This equation requires b to be dimensionless. Substituting b = $a$, where $ is a unit vector along the rotation axis, is at least dimensionally consistent: 1
843 -842
-843 1 84’
842 -84’).
(6.5.2)
1
Explicitly, pure rotation around the x-axis through an angle 84’ is described by XI
= x,
yl = y - S&Z,
ZI
=z
+64’y.
(6.5.3)
Though valid for small rotation angles, these equations clearly break down well before the angle becomes comparable with one radian. They have to be regarded as a “linearized” extrapolation of the instantaneous angular motion as follows. Consider the vector P T = (Ax, Ay, Az) = (0, - z , y) shown in Fig. 6.5.1. Being tangential, it can be said to be directed “in the direction of instantaneously increasing &.” Also, its length being equal to the radius R, it is the tangential motion correspondingto unit increase in coordinate # I . An angular change of one radian can scarcely be called an infinitesimal rotation, but one may proceed indirectly, starting with the vector (0,- z / q , y/q) where the numerical factor q is large enough that arc and vector are indistinguishable. Scaling this back up by the factor q produces the segment PT, which is declared to be the geometric representation of instantaneous rotation of 1 radian. Such a “tangent vector” PT can also be associated with a “directional derivative” symbolized by a/&’, with operational meaning the same as those of previously introduced tangent vectors.
FIGURE 6.5.1. Pictorial illustration of the ”vector” a . The point T is reached from point P by Gf motion along the tangent vector corresponding to unit increment of
204
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARE EOUATlONWITH GROUP THEORY
Referring again to Fig. 6.5.1, the linearized change of arbitrary function F ( x , y, z) when (x, y , z ) changes as in Eq.(6.5.3) is
+
d F = F ( x , y - W’Z, z 64’~) - F(x, y , Z) (6.5.4)
To be consistent with previous terminology, this change d F should be given by 6#’X4r F , where X+P’ is the infinitesimal operator corresponding to angle 4’. Guided by this, we de@e the infinitesimal operator X41 and the symbol 8/84’ by (6.5.5)
This is dimensionally consistent, since 4’ is an angle. Again, even though 1 is not a ‘‘small’’ change in I$’, XIF yields the change in F that results from simply “scaling up” the first-order Taylor series approximation in the ratio 1/6r$I. This yields the linearized change in F for unit change of the parameter 4’ in the direction in which only 4’ changes. Also, even if the existence of variable as a globally defined variable is problematic, the meaning of the partial derivative 8/84’ is not. The issue of angular units is confusing. If we choose to measure 4’ in degrees instead of radians, Eq. (6.5.3)acquires extra factors of n/180multiplying the 64”s (because they are now in degrees). In order for d F = &‘X,I F to remain true, Eq. (6.5.5) is replaced by
X+I = (n/180)(-zS/ay
+ y B / 8 z ) , = 8/84’,
4’ in degrees.
In this case, the “unit” coordinate tangent vector is (n/180)(0, -z, y). For pure rotation at angular velocity m1 around the x-axis, the positional changes occurring in time 6 r are given by xI=x,
yf = y - - w 1St
z, z‘=z+-w 1 6t y.
(6.5.6)
Except for the factor 6r (needed if nothing else to mollify physicists concerned with dimensional consistency), this is the transformation R(w) of Example 6.3.4 above.6 Since W ‘ is a velocity, one is perhaps interested in d F / d t , which is given by
18F = w 1X,p F
= w I R1
F . (6.5.7)
% h e factor 81, strongly suggestive of true particle motion, is misleading in Eq.(6.5.6) if virtual displacements are intended. We will be willing to simply suppress the factor 6t (that is. set it to 1) while continuing to call w the angular velocity. Then the changes in Eiq. (6.5.6)can be regarded as changes per unit time. The need to retain 6r in these equations for dimensional consistency can serve as a reminder that the angular velocity u1is not the quantity to be regarded as the Lie parameter to,& identified as a quasicoordinate. Rather, the Lie transformation to be used is that of Eq. (6.5.2). and &’ is the quasi-coordinate.
THE POINCARc EQUATION IN TERMS OF GROUP GENERATORS
205
These comments have been made in preparation for applying the terminology of continuous groups to the Poincard equation. A quantity such as da’ , the differential of a continuous group parameter, will be identified with d a , the differential of quasi-coordinate D , which is related to quasi-velocity s by s = d a / d t . Suppose, for example, that the role of s is to be played by m l , the angular velocity about the x-axis. For continuous group transformation relevant to this variable, we use Eq. (6.5.3), so that 4’ is the quasi-coordinate corresponding to a and = m’. The coefficients =y defined in Eq. (6.1.8) become uil = S f ’ / a # ’ , or u ’ ~= 0, u22 = -z, and and the infinitesimal operator corresponding to 4‘ is X @ I= y a / a z - z a , f a y . It is unfortunate that so much circumlocution has been required. With angular velocities being manifestly well-defined quantities, why not simply define matching angular coordinates? Once again, it is because such angular coordinates do not exist! (As an aid to memory on this point one can visualize taking a three-legged round trip, keeping track of one’s “westerly displacement” by integrating one’s westerly velocity. For the first leg, proceed in a more or less westerly direction. Proceed next in a pure northerly direction, all the way to the North Pole, as the second leg of the trip. For the final leg, take a pure southerly direction along the longitude passing through the starting point. One returns to the starting point but one’s “westerly displacement” does not.) Finally, we can express the remaining terms in the Poincark equation (or for that matter the Lagrange equation) using the infinitesimal operators X,. Derivatives, with respect to position, of functions such as T or V can be expressed in terms of derivatives with respect to quasi-coordinates such as p (which may be a true coordinate) using the relations
6’
aT
- =X,T, aP
and
BV -=XpV aP
(6.5.8)
6.6. THE POINCARE EQUATION IN TERMS OF GROUP GENERATORS In the last chapter, the Poincard equation was written in what we now appreciate was only a preliminary form. At this point we have developed machinery that permits it to be written in terms of group generators: d aT dt asp
aT c ; p ( w j p - X,,T = -XaV,
p = 1,..., n.
(6.6.1)
The left side contains “inertial terms,” the right side “force terms.” Many points of explanation have to be made about these equations, especially because some of the symbols have not been fully defined: The quantities sp are quasi-velocities, as defined previously. They are related to quasi-coordinates u p by s p = 3‘.As we know, it is in general not possible to “integrate” these to define D P globally, but neither will it be necessary. It
206
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARC EQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
is assumed that the kinetic energy has been reexpressed in terms of the quasivelocities T = T(q, s), but we are no longer indicating this with an overhead bar. 0
The coefficients ci,(q) have also been defined previously, in Eq.(5.2.17): (6.6.2) where the s p were given in Eq.(5.2.1): s p = AP(q)qi,
r = 1 , 2 , . , ., n .
(6.6.3)
Their dependence on position is indicated explicitly to emphasize the point that, in general, they are not constants. (In many cases of interest they are constant, however.) By inverting Eq. (6.6.3), one obtains expressions for q' which, when substituted in Eq. (5.1.3), provide the kinetic energy in the functional form T(q. s). 0
The quantities X, are directional derivatives taken in the direction of changing D P , which is to say, in the direction of s p :
a x, = BOP
(6.6.4)
*
(In discussing rotational motion below, these operators will be symbolized by R,, R,, R,, or just Ri.) In the most important cases, these directional derivatives are infinitesimal operators corresponding to parameters of a continuous transformation group. In general, they need only correspond to whatever quasivelocities have been chosen. Notice that the generalized force is calculated by differentiating potential energy function V in the direction of varying ur,which is just what the expression X, V(q, r ) provides. The term X,T has been derived previously in Eq. (5.2.18) in the same way. 0
The coefficients c' (q) can also be expressed in terms of commutators of the fie operators X, according to
[X,, x, I = CYpa (q)&
9
(6.6.5)
If the X, are infinitesimal operators of a continuous group, the coefficients cK 40 are constants, independent of q, as has been shown previously. In this case it is not necessary to obtain the coefficients from Eq. (6.6.2) since they can be obtained from Eq. (6.6.5). For example, for rotations they are given by Eq.(6.3.9). 0
As with the Lagrange equations, by defining L = T - V, and using the fact that V is independent of velocities, these equations can be simplified somewhat.
THE RIGID BODY SUBJECT TO FORCE AND TORQUE
207
Unlike in Lagrangian analysis, where finding appropriate generalized coordinates is the main focus, it is the choice of velocity variables that is central to the use of the Poincarb equations. Because rotational symmetry is so common, the quasiangles # x , 4 Y , and # z , corresponding to rotation angles around rectangular axes, are the prototypical quasi-coordinates. As we know, these angles do not constitute valid generalized coordinates because of the noncommutativity of rotations, but they are satisfactory as quasi-coordinates. Though attention has been focused on the quasi-velocities, once they have been found it remains to “integrate” them to find actual displacements.
6.7. THE RIGID BODY SUBJECT TO FORCE AND TORQUE 6.7.1. Group Parameters as Quasi-Coordinates By interpreting group parameters as quasi-coordinatesthe infinitesimal operators can also be derived directly, without using the continuous group formalism, though their signs depend on the interpretation of the transformations. Consider the group of translations and rotations in three dimensions x i = b‘ + O\zk.
(6.7.1)
The coordinates x k belong to a particular particle, say of mass m. A possible further index distinguishing among particles is not indicated explicitly. If there are N particles, this will have introduced 3N coordinates. But if the system is a rigid body, there must be enough constraints to reduce these to six independent generalized coordinates. The parameters of a transformation group can serve this purpose as quasicoordinates. Clearly the vector b is to be the quasi-coordinatecorresponding to translation. Its corresponding quasi-velocity is v = b. The matrix elements 0;will parameterize rotational motion. The group is transitive-there is a choice of parameters giving every configuration, and vice versa. As written, this transformation still has too many parameters, however. There are three parameters b‘ and nine parameters of the orthogonal matrix 0:. (Geometrically, the elements 0: are direction cosines of the axes in one frame relative to the axes in the other frame; this can be seen by assuming ( x j - b’)C, = xi& and using Eq. (6.7.1) to evaluate 8i . g j .) These matrix elements satisfy the orthogonality conditions, O‘kOJk = & j ,
oio k kj
=&j,
(6.7.2)
where summation on k is implied even though both are upper or lower indices. The reduction to a minimal set of independent parameters can proceed as follows. Since the transformation to quasi-coordinates is actually a velocity transformation we differentiate Eq. (6.7.1) with respect to time, yielding
xi = b‘
+ Oi$ + 0;x‘ A.
(6.7.3)
208
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARE EQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
As in Section 4.2.6, we introduce the matrix fl = OTO = -OT0 Qij
= okid5,
(6.7.4)
that was shown there to be antisymmetric.The components of 0 = On are
(6.7.5) which can be written as d n i = -6.. Ilk on.&. J
(6.7.6)
This exhibits each of the redundant 0 velocities (Lea,matrix elements) as a linear superposition of the three independent quasi-velocitieswk. We now interpret Eq. (6.7.1) in the spirit of Eqs. (6.2.1) and (6.57). with Tk E ~~(0 Consider ). an arbitrary function of position F ( x ( t ) ) and evaluate its derivative d F / d t , which is its rate of change as observed at a point with moving frame coordinates xk;
Because the variation of F can be expressed in terms of the nonredundant variables wk along with the ui,together they comprise a complete set of velocities. The infinitesimal translation operators are
(6.73) The infinitesimal rotation operators are
(6.7.9) In a problem below, this definition will be shown to be equivalent to our earlier definition of Ri . The infinitesimal translations commute with each other. The structure constants of rotation generators are given by 1
~ 3= 2 -~\3=
I,
(6.7.10)
with cyclic permutation, as the following problems show. These constants will also be obtained in a more direct way later on.
Problem 6.7.1: From these equations, derive the commutation relations (6.7.11)
209
THE RIGID BODY SUBJECT TO FORCE AND TORQUE
Perform a similar operation for cyclic permutations. This result could have been obtained differently; for example, it could have been obtained following solution of the next problem.
Problem 6.7.2: Show that the infinitesimal rotation generators can be written (6.7.12) where r$’, qP’, and tpz. are quasi-angles corresponding to w x ,my, and w z . (Evaluate a F / a @ k in terms of variations in O j k , and use the fact that aO/at$ and ad/@ mean the same thing.)
Problem 6.7.3: Evaluate all commutators of the form [Xi,R,].In the next section, to calculate the kinetic energy, uk will be specialized as being the centroid velocity. 6.7.2. Description Using Body Axes Calculation of the kinetic energy proceeds exactly as in Lagrangian mechanics. Consider a moving body with total mass M ,with centroid at x c moving with speed u, and rotating with angular velocity w about that point. With a general point in the body located at SZ relative to C, one has
C m i = 0,
(6.7.13)
by virtue of C’s actually being the centroid. Then the kinetic energy is given by
1 = -Mu2
2
1 + -1 x m ( W x Q2 = -1M u 2 + -Ss’i,,W”,
2
2
2
(6.7.14)
where
A notational clumsiness has appeared in (6.7.14) that will recur frequently in the text; it has to do with the symbols SZ and ZS. Since Z is a true vector it is not meaningful to associate it with a particular frame, and yet the notation seems to imply that it is so associated. The components X‘ themselves are not subject to this criticism; the overhead bar indicates that the components are taken relative to the moving frame (which is why they are constant). The only meaning the overhead bar on SZ can have is to suggest that these constant components will be the ones to be employed in subsequent calculations that use components. Once 5 and Z appear in the form (W x SZ)2, which, standing for (Z x SZ). (5x 9,is a scalar quantity, it is clear
210
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARGEQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
this quantity could equally as well be written (w x x ) ~Even . a hybrid expression like w x E could enter without error provided components of x and w and their cross product are all taken in the same frame.7 As usual, to simplify the T , one can choose body-fixed axes and orient them along the principal axes. J i that case the kinetic energy is given by
(I
1 1 2 T = -M u 2 + T2Z22 -i3G32) . (6.7.16) 2 2 For substitution into the Poincark equation we calculate partial derivatives of Eq. (6.7.16), assuming the elements lpare constant because (in this case) the axes are fixed in the body:
+
+
(6.7.17) where parentheses indicate absence of summation. Before including external forces, we consider the force-free case. Substitution into Eq. (6.6.I), with s -+ i& and using structure constants c”& from Eq. (6.7.10)yields
(6.7.18) and cyclic permutations. Clearly the first equation(s) describe translational motion, the second rotational. It is pleasing that the Euler rotational equations and the centroid translation equations emerge side-by-side without having been subjected to individualizedtreatment. Furthermore, though developing the machinery has been painful, once developed, the equations of rotational motion have been written down almost by inspection. Forced motion is described by including the right-hand sides of Eqs. (6.6.l),
M ~ J= ’ -Xi V,
I1ih’ + Z2Z3(73 - 72) = -R1 V
(6.7.19)
and cyclic permutations. The right-hand sides are externally applied force and torque, X2,X3)V are the components of a manifestly respectively. The three quantities (XI, true vector X V , and (R1,R2, R3)V is a true (pseudo)vector R V . * This result will soon be exploited to simplify the equations by permitting freedom in the choice of coordinate frames. The first of Eqs. (6.7.19)applies to translational motion, the second to rotational motion. Whatever influence external forces have on these motions is contained in the dependencies of potential energy V, which, it should be remembered, is a sum over the mass distribution:
(6.7.20) 71t is especially important not to make the mistake of assuming W = --w even though, given that w desribes the motion of the moving frame relative to the fixed frame, this might seem to be the natural meaning of Q. ‘There is a clash between the use of boldface to indicate that XI,Xz,and X3. in addition to being vector fields, are also the components of a three-component object X. In the examples in the next section, the boldface notation will be dropped.
THE RIGID BODY SUBJECT TO FORCE AND TORQUE
211
Hereporential energy V has been written as an explicit sum over the particles making up the rigid body, with “charges” e(i) (which would be defined as masses m(i) = e(j) in the gravitational case) to permit the porenrial V’(x) (potential energy per unit charge) to be regarded as an externally imposed field. In the final form of Eq. (6.7.20), the subscripts ( i ) have been suppressed, as they will be in most of the subsequent equations; they will have to be restored as appropriate. In this way gravitational forces are cast into terms like those used in electromagnetism.We assume V’ is timeindependent in the (inertial) space frame. Corresponding to V’ we define a “force intensity” field at the position of particle (i)
(6.7.21) For simplicity, assume F’ is approximately constant over the body. The first Poincari equation becomes Newton’s law for the motion of a point mass,
(6.7.22) Rotational motion is controlled by applied torque.For unconstrained motion in a uniform force field there is no torque about the centroid. In practical cases of unconstrained motion in a nonuniform force field, the resulting translational motion has the effect of making the force at the position of the body change with time. Since this would make it impossible to decouple the rotational and the translational motion in general, we exclude that possibility and consider rotational motion with one point, not necessarily the centroid, fixed. When using body-frame coordinates, tumbling of the body causes the force com-1 to have nontrivial ponents F;(i)aE e(i)F(i)(Yacting on particle (i) at location variation with time. To get around this complexity, let us work out the right-hand side of the Poincari equation in the space frame, and later use the recently demonstrated fact that force is a vector to obtain its body-frame coordinates. Though it has been necessary to introduce body-frame components Fii)u,it is not necessary to intoduce a symbol p’ as the force intensity F’ is a true vector. Assume F’ is constant in space and time, with its value being Fb, a vector pointing along a fixed-in-space direction 6, whose (space-frame) components are q‘. (For example, in a uniform gravitational force field, F’ = g+, FA = g, and ij would usually be taken to be -k, pointing vertically downward along the z-axis.) Hence we have
a v-1 - -FA+ ax
or V ’ ( X )= - F A X ’ ~ZE ~ -FA(~.
6).
(6.7.23)
According to Eq. (6.3.9),the rotation generators are Rj = €inmXn(B/BXm),and the right-hand side of the rotational equation (6.7.19)becomes
212
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARE EQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
This can be recognized to be the external torque, which is a true vector (actually a pseudovector). Taking advantage of its invariant property, as anticipated above, its body-frame components can be substituted directly into Eq. (6.7.19),
Ilk’ + Sj2553(T3 - 72) =
Z(Ex F),,
(6.7.25)
and cyclic permutations.
Problem 6.7.4: To an observer stationed on the rigid body, the gravitational field, though spatially uniform, has a varying direction $ ( t ) . (a) Show that its time derivative is
q=qxz.
(6.7.26)
Justify the sign, and (since the bars on the symbols for the vectors are either ambiguous or redundant) break out the same equation into equations for the separate body-frame coordinates. (b) The potential energy V of the body (not to be confused with potential V’) acquires time dependence because it depends on the body’s orientation relative to the gravitational axis or, if you prefer, on the orientation of the gravitdonal axis in the body frame. This can be expressed functionally as V = V ( q ( t ) ) . The (time-varying)“gradient” of this function is VqV. Show that the Poincark equation can be written
-
I,&’
+ &3(T3
- 72) = (7j x VFV)L,
(6.7.27)
with cyclic permutations. Paired with Eq. (6.7.26), this is known as the EulerPoisson equation. Its virtue is that the vector ;ri is independent of position in the body, facilitating the calculation of V (7). 6.8. EXAMPLE: ROLLING SPHERE A spherical body has the simplifying feature that the elements of its moment of inertia tensor are constant even in the space frame. This permits us to use space-frame velocities as the quasi-velocities in the Poincark equation. Also, it seems rather pedantic to continue to employ boldface symbols for the generators and partial derivatives that enter only for the purpose of emphasizing their interpretation as vector fields. We therefore review and simplify somewhat.
6.8.1. Commutation Relations Appropriate for Rigid Body Motion The continuous transformation equations (Eq. (6.7.1))
x i = b‘ + O $ z k
(6.8.1)
EXAMPLE: ROLLING SPHERE
213
FIGURE 6.8.1. Vector diagram illustrating the &, the generator of infinitesimal rotation about the z-axis.
form the “Euclidean Lie group in three dimensions” because they preserve lengths and angles. The infinitesimal displacement generators are
(6.8.2) and (as shown in Fig. 6.8.1), the infinitesimal rotation operators areRi = cijkxJa/axk,
a
a
R, = y- - z--, az ay
Ry = z-
a
ax
a
- x--,
az
R,= x -
a
ay
- y-,
a
ax
(6.8.3)
and the latter are equivalent to (6.8.4) These operators satisfy commutation relations
[Xi, Xjl = 0, (6.8.5)
[xi, R j ] = -6ijkXkt [Ri,Rjl = -cijkRk,
which constitute the “Lie algebra” of the Euclidean group. The Poincark equations, with potential energy U , are
d aT dt a w p
aT a d -X
ctp(q)wp-
T = -X,U.
(6.8.6)
214
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARC EQUATIONWITH GROUP THEORY
This is the equation for quasi-coordinatenp,whose corresponding quasi-velocity I 7 i P and whose infinitesimal generator is X p = a / a n P . We interpret ( x , y. z) as the laboratory coordinates of the center of mass of a moving rigid body, ( u x , u y , u z ) as the corresponding velocities, and (ox,oy,oz)as the instantaneous angular velocity of the body, as measured in the laboratory. The structure coefficients c i P were defined in Eq. (6.6.5):
is
o P
[Xp
1
x, I = cKpo x, .
(6.8.7)
They can be obtained simply by identifying coefficients in Eq. (6.8.5).
6.8.2. Bowling Ball Rolling without Slipping
The sphere of unit mass and unit radius shown in Fig. 6.8.2 rolls without slipping on a horizontal plane, The moment of inertia of such a sphere about a diameter is I = 0.4. For specifying rotational motion, one uses axes parallel to the fixed-frame axes, but with origin at the center of the sphere. Since the Poincad equation is to be used, there is no need for concern that these would not be legitimate as Lagrangian generalized coordinates. There are two conditions for rolling without sliding,
FIGURE 6.8.2. Bowling ball rolling without slipping on a horizontal alley. In addition to constraint force components Rx and Ry and external forces Fx and Fy, which are shown, there are also possible external torques about the center of the sphere Kx, Kv, and Kz. All vertical force components cancel.
EXAMPLE: ROLLING SPHERE
215
and these imply
To record the structure constants in an orderly way let us assign indices according to (w”,wy, wL,x, y) + (1,2,3,4,5). There are five nontrivial Poincark equations, even though at any instant there are only three degrees of freedom. The excess is accounted for by the two conditions for rolling. The Lagrangian expressed in quasivelocities is 2 1 L =2 (Iwl
+ I J 2+ Iw32 + w42 + w ” )
(6.8.10)
The nonvanishing derivatives of L are
(6.8.11) The nonvanishing commutators are
(6.8.12)
Because the ball stays in the same plane, it is not necessary to retain x 6 = a/az. The nonvanishing operators appear on the right side of EQ.(6.8.12), and the corresponding structure constants are their coefficients: Ci3
= -1,
c32 1 = 1,
c213 = 1,
c$ = -1,
- -1, c453 - -1,
cl;
c;3 = I ,
c;4 = -1.
c312
= 1,
(6.8.13)
c& = 1,
Let the transverse components of the force of ccnstraint be R4 and Rs, and allow for the possibility of external transverse force components F4 and F5 (for example
216
SIMPLIFYINGTHE POINCARCEQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
because the plane is tilted) as well as external torques ( K I ,K2, K3) about the center of the sphere. The constraint force itself provides torque ( R 5 , - R 4 , 0 ) . The vertical components of F and R need not be introduced, as they will always cancel. The Poincark equations are
+ K1, lh2 = -R4 + K2,
lhl = R5
I & 3 = K3,
+
(6.8.14)
h4 w3w5 = R4
+ F4,
h5- 0 3 w 4 = R5
+ Fs.
Reexpressed in more intuitive symbols these become
+ K,, = -R, + K y ,
Ihx = R,
I&'
I&' = K,,
(6.8.15)
fix +ozuY = R,
+ F,,
fi" - o z v x = R ,
+ F,.
As a special case, temporarily suppose that wz = 0; for this to be compatible with the
third equation implies K , = 0. Subsituting from Eq. (6.8.9) the equations become
(6.8.16)
These equations permit the constraint forces to be calculated from the external forces: I 1 R, = F,, 1 IKy - 1+1
+
1 I R , = -l+IFY. 1 + I Kx - -
(6.8.17)
(These equations imply that the absence of external forces and torques implies the absence of constraint forces, so that ignoring all forces gives the correct equations of motion. But this simplification will be seen below to be fortuitous; in general, the forces of constraint should be allowed for, and then eliminated using the rolling conditions.) Substituting Eq. (6.8.17) into Eq. (6.8.16) yields fix
1 =l+IK,+-
1 1+1
F,,
fiy
1 K , -k 1+IFY. 1+1
= --
1
(6.8.18)
EXAMPLE: ROLLING SPHERE
217
These equations show that, in the absence of external torque, the ball responds to external forces like a point mass, but with its apparent mass being increased by the factor 1 I . This result is derived, for example, in Landau and Lifshitz [l], as well as (painfully) in Whittaker [2]. From our derivation above we can see that the result is somewhat oversimplified, in that it makes no allowance for the possibility that the sphere is initially spinning around a vertical axis. To illustrate this possibility (in a special case), return to Eqs. (6.8.16), suppose that external forces and torques vanish, and impose initial condition wz = ~0 # 0. The equations of motion are
+
I 3 = R,,
16, = - R z;z
fix
X1
= 0,
(6.8.19)
+ wZvy = R x ,
$’ - wzux = R,.
The third equation implies that wz remains constant. Using conditions (6.8.8), the equations reduce to (1
+ Z)tY
= uclvy,
(1
+ Z)iY
= -fBovx.
(6.8.20)
These equations imply that the sphere does not travel in a straight line, even when subjected to no external force. In fact, the ball follows a circular path. (This presumably accounts for a bowler’s ability to make a bowling ball curve or a pool player’s ability to escape a seemingly impossible “snooker.”) The vertical component of angular momentum, due initially to the spin imparted to the ball on release, causes the total angular momentum to be not quite horizontal. This requires the constraint to exert a transverse force that causes the ball to curve.
Problem 6.8.1: A (riderless) “skateboard” is a pointlike object supported by a plane surface which has a line defined such that the skateboard slides or rolls without friction along that line, but not at all in the transverse direction. It can also rotate about the axis normal to the surface and passing through the single point of contact. Let the plane be inclined by a fixed angle 0 relative to the horizontal and let (x, y). with y-axis horizontal, be the coordinates of the skateboard in that plane. Let +(I) be the instantaneous angle between the skateboard axis and the x-axis. The skateboard has mass m and rotational inertia such that its rotational kinetic energy is Z42/2. Its potential energy is -mg sin 0 x. (a) Write the Lagrangian L ( x ; i ,j , $), and express the sliding constraint as a linear relation among the velocities. (b) For quasi-coordinates x 1 = x, x2 = y, and x3 = 4, evaluate all coefficients cKpa.
218
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARE EQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
(c) Write the Poincar6 equation for + ( t ) . Solve it for the initial conditions4(0)= 0, &O) = 00. (d) Write the Poincari equations for x and y. Solve them assuming the skate is at rest at the origin at t = 0. [Answer: x = sin2uot/(20& y = (Ogt sin 2oot)/2w$.l (e) As time is allowed to increase without limit, give the maximum displacements down the hill and horizontally along the hill.
Problem 6.8.2: A spherical marble of unit mass rolls without sliding on the inside of a circular cylinder whose axis is perfectly vertical. If the marble is released from rest it will obviously roll straight down with ever-increasing speed. Assuming it is released with finite initial transverse speed, solve for its subsequent motion. Be sure to allow for the possibility of initial angular velocity about an axis through the point of contact and normal to the surface. You should obtain the (surprising) result that the ball does not “fall out the bottom,” but rather oscillates up and down the tube. Problem 6.8.3: Hospital beds and some carts roll on wheels attached by casters that swivel at one end and are fixed at the other, as shown in Fig. 6.8.3. To control the position ( x , y) and angle 0 of the cart, forces F j or F, are applied at the midpoints between the wheels. (a) Write the equations of motion and constraint equations governing the motion. (b) Discuss the relative efficacy of pushing the cart from the fixed and swivel ends and explain the way you expect the solutions of the equations of motion to analytically confirm this behavior. (c) Complete the solution discussed in the previous part.
Problem 6.8.4: This problem exhibits the true power of the Poincari, Lie algebraic approach, but don’t expect to complete it in less than a day. It explains the motion of a “tippie-top,’’ the curious toy which, when set spinning “right way up” ends up
FIGURE 6.8.3. The wheels at one end of a rolling cart or hospital bed are “fixed,”while those at the other end are free to swivel. The cart can be propelled by forces Ffat the fixed end or Fs at the swivel end.
EXAMPLE ROLLING SPHERE
219
spinning “upside down” until it eventually falls over. The tippie-top will not be mentioned again however, since the system to be analyzed is slightly idealized. A solid plastic spherical bowling ball, radius R, mass M ,has one (instead of the usual three) shallow holes drilled on its periphery. This hole is filled with some material of density different from that of the plastic, so that the outer surface is again a perfectly smooth sphere. The drilled out hole is small enough to be treated as a point mass m at point P. (To cover the possibility that the filling material has lower density than plastic, m may be negative.) The ball rolls or spins without sliding on a hard surface. Friction (coefficient p ‘2’ 0.1) prevents the ball from sliding. For many purposes dissipation (due to the friction) is negligible, but to avoid unphysical residual motion as t --f 00 one can assume the ball is flattened in a tiny circle where it contacts the floor. (a) Define variables describing the motion of the ball, including the position of point P. Specify relations among redundant variables clearly. Define all relevant forces and torques and give formulas for them. Write formulas describing the constraints and make the no-slip restriction explicit. (b) Write equations of motion for the system that are free of approximation (other than those already mentioned.) It is not realistic to solve these problems in complete generality (except numerically) but there are special cases where the motion can be described approximately for some appreciable period of time by analytic formulas, and they can be used to infer how the motion will evolve qualitatively over long periods of time. The approximation that is most productive is to treat the extra mass perturbatively, assuming m << M .You are expected to use discretion as to what approximations are both useful and valid. In this spirit, discuss the motion in the following cases, giving information about the (quantitative) early motion and the (qualititative) eventual motion. Dependence of qualitative features on initial angular velocity should be featured. (c) The ball is initially approximately “sleeping”-spinning with angular velocity ~0 about a vertical axis, with the point P almost on the rotation axis and the centroid is at rest. Consider all four possibilities: P near top or bottom, m > Oorm 4 0. (d) Same setup as in (c) but the point P is initially at angle 80 relative to the vertical axis. Again consider all four possibilities. Attempt to find a “pure precession” in which the height of point P stays constant. (e) The ball is launched with no vertical spin but rolling straight down the bowling lane. The loaded point P starts out exactly at right angles to the motion so its initial velocity is equal to the centroid velocity. (The predicted motion can be persuasively confirmed by rolling a tippie-top on its side. It can also be used to understand how a bicycle can be steered by leaning.)
220
SIMPLIFYING THE POINCARE EQUATION WITH GROUP THEORY
BIBLIOGRAPHY References 1. L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Mechanics, Pergamon, Oxford, 1976, p. 124.
2. E. T. Whittaker, A Treatise on the Analytical Dynamics of Particles and Rigid Bodies, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 1989.
References for Further Study Section 6.1 M. Hamermesh, Group Theory and Its Application to Physical Problems, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1962.
Section 6.7.2 N. G. Chetaev, Theoretical Mechanics, Springer-Verlag. Berlin, 1989.
Section 6.8.2 V. I. Arnold, V. V. Kozlov, and A. I. Neishtadt, Dynarnical Systems 111. Springer-Verlag,Berlin,
1990.
7 CONSERVATION LAWS AND SYMMETRY The material in this chapter does not belong exclusively to Newtonian, Lagrangian, or Hamiltonian mechanics, as conservation laws can be derived using any of the formalisms. It is placed here largely to provide examples that exercise the Poincark approach and to show that certain ideas familiar from Lagrangian mechanics carry over trivially to “Poincark mechanics.” The main area that can be said to be strikingly simplified by the Poincark procedure is that of “integrability,” which is briefly discussed. Discussion of Noether’s theorem, which provides the most fundamental description of conservation laws, will also be discussed briefly here, even though it might be be more appropriately deferred until after discussion of the tangent space and the development of symplectic mechanics in Hamiltonian context. To make the present discussion self-contained, the “tangent bundle” is introduced here, even though the main discussion of it will be reserved for a later chapter, where it will be reintroduced. Because continuous transformation groups provided the original motivation for the Poincark equation, and because the mathematical description of symmetry is based on groups, it is natural to use the Poincark equation to investigate the effect of symmetry on mechanical systems. 7.1. MULTIPARTICLE CONSERVATION LAWS 7.1.l.Conservation of Linear Momentum The kinetic energy of a system of N particles is
221
222
CONSERVATIONLAWS AND SYMMETRY
xzl
x
Here, and in the future, replacements like x(i) + x will be made to reduce clutter. The presence of the summation sign is the only reminder that there is one term for each of the N particles. An essential simplifying feature of these rectangular coordinates, one that is not valid in general, is that the coefficients of the quadratic velocity terms are independent of position. B B The particle-(i)-specific infinitesimal displacement generators are r , K ,and The Poincark equation for D;) = i ( i ) is
&.
“(If
Z(i)
not different from the Lagrange equation, or for that matter from Newton’s equation. This has used the fact that = 0, which is a manifestation of the invariance of kinetic energy under pure translation. Defining total mass, centroid displacement, and velocity by
2
M
=Em,
MX = x m x ,
MV = x r n v
(7.1.3)
and summing Eqs. (6.8.13) yields (7.1.4)
where the operator
(7.1.5) is the infinitesimal (vector) generator that translates all particles equdly. The somewhat ad hoc inclusion of an overhead arrow is to indicate that mere is one operator for each component. Operating on -U,the vector of operators yields the components of the total force FtOt. Suppose translation of the mechanical system parallel to the ( x , y) plane generates a “congruent” system. This would be true for a displacement parallel to the earth’s surface (when treating the earth as flat) with vertical gravitational acceleration g . In this case
&
a -u Bx
a
= ---u = 0,
By
(7.1.6)
with the result that M V X and MVY are “constants of the motion.” But M V Z is not constant in this case. The case of linear momentum conservation just treated has been anomolously simple because of the simple relation between velocity and momentum. A more gen-
223
MULTIPARTICLE CONSERVATION LAWS
era1 formulation would have involved defining the linear momentum vector p(i) by (7.1.7) which would have led to the same result. 7.1.2. Rate of Change of Angular Momentum: PoincareApproach
For a rigid body rotating with one point fixed, the kinetic energy summation of Eq. (7.1.1) can be reexpressed in terms of particle-specific angular velocities about the fixed point (w&, w&, wti)),(see Eq. 6.7.15), T , , ~=
1
Cm ( ( y 2 + z2)wx2+ ( x 2 + .z2)wy2
+ ( x 2 + y2)wz2- 2yzwywz - 2xzwxwz - 2xyw wy > ,
(7.1.8)
(even though (w&, w ; ) , w f i ) ) are invalid Lagrangian velocities). Define particlespecific operators
We have seen previously that these are equivalent to
where 4 = ( # x , # Y , qiZ) is a “vector” of quasi-angles. Since appearance of these angles would not be valid in Lagrangian mechanics, the following development would not be valid there (though the same results can be obtained from Newton’s equations). It does represent a considerable emancipation to be able to work, guiltfree, with angular velocity components. We also define
(7.1.11) The first term needed for substitution in the equation for quasi-velocity wx is
224
CONSERVATION LAWS AND SYMMETRY
Also, using structure constants from Eq. (6.8.13),
a Trot
1
-(-aZ)= -(x2 m awy
1 aTrot -(d)m
ad
= ( x2
+ z 2 ) w W + y z d 2 + xyw”wZ,
+ y2 )w ywz - yzoy* - x z o x o y .
(7.1.13)
On substitution into the Poincark equation, these terms all cancel. Defining
a Trot
L, = a d’
a Trot
L , = -, awy
L , = - a Trot aoz
(7.1 14) I
’
the Poincark equation for L , is
d -L, = -R,U
dt
=
BU
(7.1.15)
with similar equations for L, and L,. These are the three components of angular momentum vector L and
s
L = --u
a4
= K,
(7.1.16)
where K is called the applied torque. If the externally applied force applies no torque around some axis, say the zaxis, then BU/B#, = 0, and it follows that the component of L along that axis is conserved. If U is independent of direction (“isotropic”), then all components of the angular momentum vector L are conserved. Problem 7.1.1: In the derivation of angular momentum conservation just completed, no account was taken of “internal” forces of one mass within the rotating object acting on another. Show that including such forces does not alter the result.
7.1.3. Conservation of Angular Momentum: Lagrangian Approach Proof of the conservation of angular momentum in the absence of external forces also is easy using ordinary Lagrangian methods. Under an infinitesimal rotation A#, each particle radius vector is shifted r --+ r A# x r, and its velocity is shifted similarly v --+ v A# x v. With no external forces, the Lagrangian and the kinetic energy are equal; under the same rotation, its change is given by
+
+
MULTIPARTICLE CONSERVATION LAWS
225
In the last step, both the defining relation for p and the Lagrange equation for p have been used. Defining angular momentum
L=Crxp,
(7.1.18)
dL - = 0. dt
(7.1.19)
it follows from Eq. (7.1.17) that
Problem 7.1.2: For the field sources listed, indicate what components of P and L are conserved. For definiteness suppose that the sources are static electric charge distributionsand that the mechanical system under analysis is subject only to electric forces due to those sources. The particles making up the mechanical system have arbitrary masses and charges, but the fields due to their charges are to be ignored. In each case, indicate which choice of axes best takes advantage of the symmetry and assume that choice has been made. (a) A plane is uniformly charged. (b) An infinite circular cylinder is uniformly charged. (c) The surface of a noncircular infinite cylinder is uniformly charged. (d) Two parallel infinite lines have equal, uniform charge densities. (e) Two points have equal charges. (f) An infinite cone is uniformly charged. (g) A torus, circular in both cross sections, is uniformly charged. (h) An infinite solenoid of uniform pitch is uniformly charged. The pitch is such that the distance along the solenoid’s axis at which the helix has made one revolution is A. In this case, the only conserved momentum is a combination of two of the elementary momenta.
7.1.4. Conservation of Energy Suppose that both T and U are independent of time. Multiplying P o i n c d equation (6.8.6) by up,summing over p , and utilizing the antisymmetry of cApp to justify setting o P c A p p o=~0 yields
= u P X p ( T- U).
(7.1.20)
The last two terms can be merged using
d aT - ( T - U )= -hp dt aOp
+ u P X P ( T- U).
(7.1.21)
226
CONSERVATIONLAWS AND SYMMETRY
(This equation would acquire an extra term ( a / a t ) ( T - U ) if we were not assuming this quantity vanishes. This extra term would otherwise have to be included in the following equations.) We obtain (7.1.22) Defining a new function
aT h(w,q)=mp--T+U
(7.1.23)
a0p
and integrating Eq. (7.1.22) yields (7.1.24)
h ( w , q) = constant = Eo.
This formula says that the function h remains equal to its initial value Eo. In our present approach the function h, obviously related to the “Hamiltonian,” makes its appearance here for the first time. It is a dynamical variable whose numerical value remains constant, equal to initial energy Eo. Technically the function h, though equal in value to the energy, cannot legitimately be called the Hamiltonian, however, since its functional dependency is incorrect.
Problem 7.1.3: Starting from the Euler equations of a freely moving rigid body with one point fixed, I,;’
3 1 i2&j2 = (z3 - il)@ ,
= (i2- 13)0203,
3 I3h
= (iI - i2)@
1 2
,
(7.1.25) exhibit explicitly the constancy of both energy h and the total angular momentum squared, L2 = Lx2 LY2 Lz2.
+
+
7.2. CYCLIC COORDINATES AND ROUTHIAN REDUCTION One of the important problems in “Dynamical System Theory” is that of reduction, which means exploiting some conserved quantity of the system to reduce the dimensionality of the problem. Normally the term “reduction” also includes the requirement that the equations retain the same form, be it Lagrangian, Poincark, or Hamiltonian, in the reduced number of unknowns. Even when a constant of the motion is known, it is not necessarily easy to express the problem explicitly in terms of a reduced set of variables. This section considers the simplest example of reduction. This is not essentially different from a procedure due to Routh for reducing the Lagrange equations to take advantage of an ignorable coordinate. Within the P o i n c k formalism the procedure is quite analogous. The procedure can also be regarded as a variant of the procedure for deriving Hamilton’s equations.
CYCLIC COORDINATES AND ROUTHIAN REDUCTION
227
Suppose that one quasi-coordinate, say q l , and its corresponding quasi-velocity u l , have the property that ( d / d t ) ( a T / a u ’ ) is the only nonvanishing term in their
Poincark equation. This equation can therefore be integrated immediately: aT
(7.2.1)
=B1,
where is an integration constant. Two conditions sufficient for this simplification to occur are that all relevant commutators vanish, [ X I ,X,] = 0, and that X l ( T U ) = 0. In this case the variable q is said to be “cyclic.” Elimination of q1 and u1 begins by solving Eq.(7.2.1) for u1: u 1 = u 1(q2 , ..., q “ ;B1, u2 , ..., u”).
(7.2.2)
For the method to work, this has to yield an explicit formula for u1. The “Routhian” is defined by R ( q2 , . . . , q n ;B1, v 2 , . . . , u”) = T - U - u 1-.aT
ad
(7.2.3)
The absence of q’ is due to the fact that q’ is cyclic, and the absence of u1 is due to the fact it will have been replaced using Eq.(7.2.2). The Poincak-based Routhian reduction continues by writing the Poincar6 equations for the remaining variables:
(Terms with coefficients c A l pnecessarily vanish.) The quantity B1 can be treated as a constant parameter as these equations are solved. After they have been solved, u1 can be found by substituting into Eq.(7.2.3) and then differentiating with respect to B1:
(7.2.5) which follows from substituting Eq. (7.2.1) into Eq. (7.2.3).
Example 7.2.1: Symmetric Top. Consider the axially symmetric top shown in Fig. 7.2.1, rotating with its tip fixed at the origin. Let its equal moments of inertia be 11 and its moment of inertia about the ?-axis be 13. Its body axis angular velocities sx‘, sy‘, and sz’are related to the Euler angular velocities $ , 6 , and li/ by the relations sin 8 sin
+
cos @ (7.2.6)
cos 9
0
1
228
CONSERVATION LAWS AND SYMMETRY
FIGURE 7.2.1. An axial symmetric top rotating with its tip fixed. its orientation is determined by Euler angles 4, 0, and @. The vertical force of gravity mg acts at its centroid C, at distance e from the tip. “Space axes” are x , y , z. “Body axes” are x’, y’, z‘.
The kinetic energy is given by 1 1 T = -11 (d2 s Y ’ ~ )+ - Z ~ S ” ~ 2 2 1 1 = -Zl(sin28d2 d2) -Z3(cos2 &j2 2cosBd$ 2 2
+
+
+
+
+ $’),
(7.2.7)
and the potential energy by
u = mgecose,
(7.2.8)
’,
neither of which depend on $, which is therefore chosen as the variable q and = u’ in the Routhian reduction. (This step was made possible by a cancellation depending on the equality of 11 and 12 and by the absence of “commutator terms” in the Poincark equation which, in this case, is simply the Lagrange equation because legitimate generalized coordinates are being used.) The relations corresponding to Eq.(7.2.1) and (7.2.2) are
6
aT
- = 13(cos8&+ 4)= / ? I ,
all-
B1 and u 1 = -.
(7.2.9)
13
The Routhian is
. a~
R = T - V - @ Y
all-
1
= - I1 (sin2ed2 2
+ 8’) + pl, cos8d - mgl cos 8
-
812
-,
213
(7.2.10)
CYCLIC COORDINATES AND ROUTHIANREDUCTION
229
Since the final term is constant, it drops out of the “Lagrange” equations obtained from R.
Problem 7.2.1: After the Routhian reduction just performed for the symmetric top, the Routhian R is independent of the coordinate 9. Perform another step of Routhian reduction to obtain a one-dimensional equation in Lagrangian form. Any such equation can be “reduced to quadratures.” 7.2.1. Integrability; Generalization of Cyclic Variables The Routhian reduction just studied was made possible partially by the absence of “commutator terms” in the Poincare equation. But reduction may be possible even if some of these terms are nonvanishing. It is possible for all terms in the Poincari equation except ( d / d t ) ( a T / a v ’ )to cancel even when some of the cAP1 coefficients are nonvanishing. With T given by (7.2.11) and assuming X I( T - U )= 0, the unwanted terms are (7.2.12) which vanishes if
Example 7.2.2: Consider the same axially symmetric top, subject to gravity, spin2 2 ning with its lower point fixed. With body axes, T = (1/2)(11w1’ Z2w2 13w3 ). If 11 = 12, then the Poincari equation for @3 = $r, which is a quasi-angle of rotation around the instantaneous axis of the top. is
+
13h3= -X3U = 0.
+
(7.2.14)
Since rotation around the top axis does not change the potential energy, X3U = 0, and as a result w3 is a constant of motion. Note that this cancellation is not “generic” in that ZI = 12 cannot be exactly true in practice. On the other hand, in the absence of this cancellation the equation of motion is nonlinear, which almost always leads to bizarre behavior at large amplitudes. Hence one can say that bizarre behavior is generic. There are a small number of other known choices of the parameters in rigid body motion with one point fixed that lead to completely integrable systems. (See Arnold et al. [l].)
230
CONSERVATIONLAWS AND SYMMETRY
7.3. NOETHER’S THEOREM I n this section (and only this section) we use notation slat instead of d l d t f o r the “total time derivative.” The reason for this is that a new subsidiary variable s will be introduced and the main arguments have to do withfunctions f ( t , s ) and derivatives holding one or the other o f f and s constant. For much of Lagrangian mechanics the Lagrangian can be regarded as a purely formal construct whose only role is to be differentiated to yield the Lagrange equations. For this purpose it is not necessary to have more than an operational understanding of the meaning of the dependence of the Lagrangian on q. But here we insist on treating L ( q , q) as a regular scalar function on the configuration space M of coordinates q augmented by the tangent spaces of velocities. We must therefore define carefully the meaning of the dependence on q. Based on curves q ( t ) in configuration space, parameterized by time t , one constructs the so-called tangent spaces TM, at every point q in the configuration space. TM, is the space of possible instantaneous system velocities at q. This space has the same dimensionalityn as does the configuration space M itself. The union of the tangent spaces at every point is known as the “tangent bundle” TM. It has dimensionality 2n with a possible choice of coordinates being q ’ , q 2 , . . . ,q” and the remaining n coordinates being the corresponding “natural” velocity components introduced in Eq.(3.1.8). The Lagrangian L ( q , q) is a scalar function on TM. We have seen many examples in which symmetriesof the Lagrangian are reflected in conserved dynamical variables. The simplest of these involve “ignorable coordinates.” For example, the absence of z in the Lagrangian for particles in Euclidean space subject to potential U ,depending on the xi and yi components but not on the z , components, (7.3.1) implies the conservation of total momentum p z ; this follows trivially within the customary Lagrangian formalism. The ad hoc nature of such conclusions should seem mildly troubling and one wishes there were a more general theoretical construct from which all such conserved quantities, or at least broad classes of them, could be derived. Such a construct would exhibit simple invariance properties (symmetries) of the Lagrangian and associate a definite conserved dynamical variable with each such symmetry. This is what Noether’s theorem accomplishes. Since the Lagrangian is a scalar function, constancy under particular transformation of its arguments is the only sort of symmetry to which it can be subject. For example, the Lagrangian of Eq. (7.3.1) is invariant under the transformation x+x,
y+y,
z--,z+s,
(7.3.2)
where s is an arbitrary parameter, provided this configuration space transformation is accompanied by the following tangent space transformation: (7.3.3)
NOETHER’S THEOREM
231
From a physical point of view, the fact that these configuration space and tangent space transformations have to go together in this way is an obvious requirement for descriptions of the same physics in two frames that differ only by constant displacement s along the z-axis. From a mathematical point of view, a smooth transformation f : M -+ M mapping q to f(q) implies a transformation f*, : TM, + TMf(q)from the tangent space at q to the tangent space at f(q). For any particular curve through q, this maps its instantaneous velocity q inferred at q into f*q(q).which is equal to the instantaneous velocity inferred at f(q). “Infer” here means “go through the usual limiting procedure by which instantaneous velocity is extracted from a system trajectory.” f*s is an n-dimensional transformation. Geometrically, the output of this transformation is a vector, which is the reason a boldface symbol has been used for f. Combining the transformations f*q at all points q we obtain an n-dimensional transformation f* at every point in an n-dimensional domain; it maps the entire tangent bundle. The coordinate map can depend on a parameters and therefore be symbolized by F,and the corresponding map of velocities is symbolizedf”, . Consider a valid system trajectory q(t). At every time t the point q(t) can be mapped by F to yield a point q(s, t). This yields a family of curves that are individually parameterized by t with different curves distinguished by parameter s (as illustrated in Fig. 7.3.1). The s = 0 curve satisfies the equations of motion, but the curves for other values of s will not be valid system trajectories, except under conditions to be considered next. The Lagrangian system is said to be invariant under a mapping f if
THEOREM 7.3.1: Ifa Lagrangian system is invariant for the transformations F along with the induced transformutions fs for all values of the parameter s, then the
(I(0. n’ -
/
FIGURE 7.3.1. A family of curves, each parameterized by time t, with the different curves differentiated by s.The curve with s = 0 is a valid system trajectory, but the curve with s # 0 is typically not.
232
CONSERVATION LAWS AND SYMMETRY
quantity
is a constant of the motion.
The middle term in Eq.(7.3.5) uses the notation first introduced in Eq.(2.2.3). Since is covariant and W( ) is contravariant, the quantity Z(q, q) is invariantly
Is=o
defined, independentof the choice of coordinates, but its practical evaluation requires the use of coordinates as spelled out in the rightmost term of Eq. (7.3.5).The former notation will be used in the proof that follows.
Pro08 The analytic statement of the invariance of L under P is
When this equation is expressed in terms of the function r,it becomes (7.3.7)
With the assumed invariance, the same variational calculation showing that q ( t ) satisfies the equations of motion shows that q(t, s) satisfies the equations of motion also, for all s. As a result, the Lagrange equations are satisfied as identities in s: (7.3.8)
Proceeding to calculate a I / a r (while recalling that the notation a / a t is a total time derivative with s held constant) and using Eq. (7.3.8), we obtain
(7.3.9)
In the final step, the order of s and t derivatives has been reversed and Eq. (7.3.7) has been used. This completes the proof.
Exumple 7.3.1: For the transformation given by Eqs. (7.3.2) and (7.3.3), we have (7.3.10)
where e, is a unit vector along the z-axis. With the Lagrangian of (7.3.1) we obtain
BIBLIOGRAPHY
233
The assumed Euclidean geometry and the orthonormal property of the coordinates has been used here (for the first time) in evaluating the invariant product as an ordinary dot product of two vectors.
Example 7.3.2: Consider next rotation about a particular axis, say the &-axis, through angle s. According to Eq. (4.2.24), keeping only the term linear in s, we have xi + x j + s & x x j + . . . ,
(7.3.12)
and therefore that (7.3.13) If the Lagrangian is invariant under transformation (7.3.12) (as (7.3.1) would be if U were invariant to rotation around &), then the Noether invariant is given by
This shows that the component of angular momentum about the &-axis is conserved.
Problem 7.3.1: Formulate each of the invariance examples of Problem 7.1.2 as examples of Noether’s theorem and express the implied conserved quantities in the form of EQ. (7.3.5). BIBLIOGRAPHY
Reference 1. V. I. Arnold, V. V. Kozlov, and A. I. Neishtadt, Mathematical Aspects of Classical and
Celestial Mechanics, 2nd ed.,Springer-Verlag. Berlin, 1997, p. 120.
Reference for Further Study
Section 7.3 V. I. Arnold, Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics, Springer-Verlag. 1978, p. 88.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
IV NEWTONIAN MECHANICS
Roughly speaking, Newtonian methods work directly with position vectors (and their geometric generalizations) without introducing variational principles or artificial functions such as Lagrangians. The prototypical Newtonian equation, F = m a , expands to being a system of second-order, ordinary differential equations containing the measurable kinematic, inertial, and dynamic quantities. The Newtonian formulation is usually regarded as elementary, and the reader is assumed to be conversant with it. It is the introduction of the concept of gauge invariance, because it depends heavily on geometry, that justifies having delayed returning to the Newtonian approach until now. By relating descriptions in coordinate frames accelerating relative to each other, gauge invariance generalizes the concept of Galilean invariance, which applies only to inertial systems having constant velocities relative to each other. There will be a certain amount of repetition of material already encountered, for example concerning the Cartan matrix 51, whose role here will be more “physical,” with the emphasis being on reconciling descriptions made by observers in different frames of reference.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
Geometry as the basis of mechanics is a theme of this textbook. Though it may not have been recognized at the time, the importance of geometry was already made clear in freshman mechanics by the central role played by vectors. The purpose of this chapter is to develop a similar, but more powerful, algebraic/geometric basis for mechanics. However, unlike the chapters just completed, the approach will be Newtonian, with no artificial Lagrangian or Hamiltonian-like functions being introduced and no variational principles. The description of motion in noninertial frames of reference will be of central importance. To indicate the intended style, we begin by reviewing vector mechanics.
8.1. VECTOR MECHANICS
8.1 .l.Vector Description in Curvilinear Coordinates In its simplest form, Newton’s law for the motion of a point particle with mass m (an inertial quantity) subject to force F (a dynamical quantity) yields the acceleration (a kinematical quantity): a=
F m
-.
(8.1.1)
This is hypothesized to be valid only in an inertial frame of reference. In such a frame, the acceleration vector is given by (8.1.2)
237
238
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
where r(t) is the radius vector from the origin. The traditional notation has been used of replacing d / d t , the “total derivative” taken along the actual particle trajectory, by an overhead dot. For actual c_om_putation,it is often appropriate to introduce unit vectors such as @,?,3 or @, 8, q5), with the choice depending, for example, on the symmetry of the problem. With Euclidean geometry being assumed implicitly, these are “unit vector”’ triads, mutually orthogonal and each having unit length. The “components” of r are then given (in rectangular and spherical coordinates) as the coefficients in
r = x%+ y y + z2= rF.
(8.1.3)
The component-wise differentiation of this vector is simple in the rectangular form, because the unit vectors are constant, but it is more complicated for other coordinate systems. In the case of spherical coordinates (see Fig. 8.1.l), as the particle moves, a local unit vector,?for example, varies. As a result, the velocity v = dr/dt is given by v
= u%+
A
+ u @ 4= tT+r k h
(8.1.4)
Already at this stage there are minor complications. One is notational: in this text, when (r, 8,d) = ( q ’ , q 2 ,q 2 ) are taken as “generalized coordinates,” we refer to ( q ’ , q 2 , q 2 ) as their “generalized velocities,” and these are not the same as u‘, u’, and
[email protected], symbolizing the time derivative of r by v, we have to accept the fact that the components of the time derivative are not equal to the time derivatives of the components (except in rectangular components). Finally, formula (8.1.4), which is intended to give the velocity components, still depends on the rate of change of a basis vector.
FIGURE 8.1.1. For a particle moving instantaneously in the plane of the paper, the direction of the radial unit vector ?(f) at its instantaneous location varies with time, but its length remains constant. Instantaneously,7 is rotating with angular velocity o about the axis w normal to the paper. ’In this chapter, and only in this chapter. “unit vectors” are defined to have unit length. In other chapters, a unit vector is usually a vector pointing along the curve on which its correspondingcoordinate varies while the other coordinates are held fixed, and “unit” implies (in a linearized sense) that the coordinate increases by one unit along the curve. To reduce the likelihood of confusion, the overhead “hat” symbol will be used only for vectors having unit length.
239
VECTOR MECHANICS
In general, a vector can vary both in magnitude and direction, but a unit vector can vary only in direction-with its tail fixed, the most that can be happening to it is that it is rotating about some axis 8 with angular speed o;together w = w 8 . Consider the radial unit vector 7 illustrated in Fig. 8.1.1. Since its change in time At is given (in the limit) by wAt x F,we have
d?
-=wxr dt
A
(8.1.5)
3
This same formula holds for 5 and and hence for any vector u or unit vector F fixed relative to the coordinate triad (you should convince yourself):
dti
-= w x u . h
(8.1.6)
dt
The change in orientation of the unit triad is due to the motion of the particle; from the geometry of Fig. 8.1.1 one infers h
w=
rxv
(8.1.7)
+
r
Combining this with Eq. (8.1.6) yields h
V r d t i 1 -=-(Fxv)xF=(F~G)--(v*6)-. r r dt r
(8.1.8)
When this formula is applied to each of the three spherical coordinate unit vectors, the results are
+= 65+sinti@&
I
8 = -&,
A
4 = -sine@
(8.1.9)
Substitution into Eq. (8.1.4) yields v=?F+rG+rsint&ii.
(8.1.10)
sin e
i
FIGURE 8.1.2. Components of the velocity vector in a spherical coordinate system.
240
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
This has been a circuitous route to obtain a result that seems self-evident (see Fig. 8.1.2) but, if one insists on starting by differentiating Eq. (8.1.4), it is hard to see how to derive it more directly. The reason Eqs. (8.1 .lo) seem self-evident is that it is taken for granted that velocity is a true vector whose spherical and Cartesian components are related as if they belonged to a displacement vector.
Problem 8.1.1: The acceleration can be calculated similarly, starting by differentiating Eq. (8.1.10). In this way confirm the calculations of Section 3.1.6. We have seen then that calculating kinematic quantities in curvilinear coordinates using vector analysis and the properties of vectors is straightforward though somewhat awkward. 8.1.2. The Frenet-Serret Formulas Describing the evolution of a triad of unit basis vectors that are naturally related to a curve in space is one of the classic problems of the subject of differential geometry. It is done compactly using the formulas of Frenet and Serret. If the curve in question represents the trajectory of a particle, these formulas describe only variation in space and contain nothing concerning the time rate of progress along the curve. Also, the case of free motion (in a straight line) is degenerate and needs to be treated specially. For these reasons (and a more important reason to be mentioned later), traditional treatments of mechanics usually rederive the essential content of these elegant formulas explicitly rather than using them as a starting point. A vector x ( r ) pointing from some origin to a point on its trajectory locates a particle’s position P at time t . But because time t is to be suppressed from this treatment we take arc length s along the curve as an independent variable and represent the curve as x(s). To represent differention with respect to s, a prime (as in x‘) will be used in the way that a dot is used to represent differention with respect to t , Any three disjoint points on a smoothly curving space curve define a plane. In the limit of vanishing separation of these points, the plane they determine is known as the “osculating plane.” This metaphorical terminology can be used when two smooth surfaces or curves “kiss,” which is to say, touch without crossing. If the smooth curve happens to be a straight line, no unique osculating plane is determined this way. This fact represents something of a nuisance in applying this formalism. Clearly, the velocity vector v defined in the previous section lies in the osculating plane. However, depending as it does on speed u, it is not a unit vector, so it is replaced by the parallel vector
v dx =; = - EX’. ds
(8.1.1 1)
is known as the “unit tangent vector.” The unique vector t2that also lies in the osculating plane but is perpendicular to and points “outward” is known as the “principal normal” to the curve. From the study of circular motion in elementary mechanics, one knows that the trajectory is
VECTOR MECHANICS
241
FIGURE 8.1.3. Vector construction illustratingthe derivation of the Frenet-Serret formulas. El is the unit tangent vector; ,$2 is the unit principal normal vector.
instantaneously circular, with the center C of the circle being “inward” and lying in the osculating plane as well. Letting p stand for the radius of curvature of this circle, we know that the acceleration vector is - ( u 2 / p ) t 2 , but we must again eliminate references to time. See Fig. 8.1.3. If xb is the tangent vector at the point P in question, then the tangent vector at a distance ds further along the curve is given by Taylor expansion to be xb +Gds +. .. Denoting the angle between these tangents by O(s), the radius of curvature is defined by (8.1.12)
e2is parallel to xg and that lxgl = l/p. Since c2
From the figure it can be seen that is to be a unit vector, it follows that
€2 = p x l l .
(8.1.13)
To make a complete orthonormal triad of basis vectors at the point C we also define the “unit binormal” by
e3
€3
=t 1 x
e2.
(8.1.14)
Proceeding by analogy with the introduction of the radius of curvature, the angle between t3Ip and t 3 ( s d s ) is denoted by #(s), and a new quantity, the “torsion” 1/T,is defined by
+
(8.1.15) This relation does not fix the sign of t . It will be fixed below. The Frenet-Serret formulas are first-order (in s) differential equations governing the evolution of the or-
242
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANfCS
(el,
thonormal triad 52, E3) (to be called “Frenet vectors”) as the point P moves along the curve. The first of these equations, obtained from Eqs. (8.1.1 1) and (8.1.13), is 52
=
(8.1.16)
P’
c3
Because the vector is a unit vector, its derivative 6; is normal to €3 and hence expandable in and &. But <$ is in fact also orthogonal to €1. To see this, differentiate the equation that expresses the orthogonality of t1and 5 3 ,
d 0 = -6. €3) = ds
<;
*
+ €1 . r;,
€3
(8.1.1 7)
where, using Eq. (8.1.16) and the orthogonality of <2 and t3,the first term must vanish. We have therefore that ($ is parallel to and the constant of proportionality is obtained from Eq. (8.1.15):
e2
t2.
(8.1 . I 8)
= -7’
the sign of T has been chosen to yield the sign shown. From Eq. (8.1.14), we obtain = t3x which can be differentiatedto obtain cb. Collecting formulas, we have obtained the Frenet-Serret formulas
<*
52 s; = -7.
(8.1.19)
Problem 8.1.2: Show that
_1 -- x’ . (X” XI‘
T
x
. XI‘
X”’)
Problem 8.1.3: If progress of a particle along its trajectory is parameterized by time t , show that the curvature p and torsion l / r are given by
_1 P2
*
-
-= t
. (X x X) (X . X)3 ’
(X x X)
X.(XXX)
(X x X)
. (X
x
X)
.
As they have been defined, both p and T are inverse parameters in the sense that trajectories they quantify become more nearly straight as the parameters become
VECTOR MECHANICS
243
large. For this reason, their inverses l/p, known as “curvature,” and l / t , known as “torsion,” are more physically appropriate parameters for the trajectory. Loosely speaking, curvature is proportional to f and torsion is proportional to 2.It might seem to be almost accurate to say that in mechanics the curvature is more important than the torsion “by definition.” This is because, the curvature being proportional to the transverse component of the applied force, the instantaneously felt force has no component along the binormal direction. This is also why the leading contribution to the torsion is proportional to X. The only circumstance in which the torsion can be appreciable is when the instantaneous force is strongly dependent on position. Unfortunately, in this case, the direction of the principal normal can change rapidly, even when the force is weak. If the motion is essentially free except for a weak transverse force, the principal normal tracks the force even if it is arbitrarily small, no matter how its direction is varying. In this case, the Frenet frame is simply inappropriate for describing the motion, as its orientation is only erratically related to the essential features of the trajectory. Furthermore, the torsion is also, in a sense, redundant because the specification of instantaneous position and velocity at any instant, along with a force law giving the acceleration, completely specifies the entire subsequent motion of a particle (including the instantaneous torsion). It is perhaps these considerations that account for the previously mentioned lack of emphasis on the Frenet-Serret formulas in most accounts of mechanics. &>remains orthonormal, it is related to the triad of inertial Since the triad frame basis vectors (i,?, 2) by a pure rotation and, instantaneously, by a pure angular velocity vector w such as was introduced just before Eq. (8.1.5). This being the case, the Frenet vectors should satisfy Eq. (8.1.6). Applying this result to the Frenet equations yields
(c1 c2,
v€2 w x €1 = -,
P
(8.1.20)
w x €3 = --.v€2 r
Furthermore, w should itself be expandable in terms of the Frenet vectors, and this expansion must be
w = -51 v r
+ Pv 4
3
9
(8.1.21)
as can be quickly checked. Normalized curvature v / p measures the rate of rotation of the Frenet frame about the principal normal, and normalized torsion v/t measures its rate of rotation around the tangent vector. Previously in this text, relations specifying the relative orientations of coordinate frames at different positions have been known as “connections”; curvature and torsion can be said to parameterize the connection between the fixed and moving frames of reference.
244
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
8.1.3. Vector Description in an Accelerating Coordinate Frame Another important problem in Newtonian dynamics is that of describing motion using coordinates that are measured in a noninertial frame. W o important applications of this are the description of trajectories using coordinates fixed relative to the (rotating) earth and description of the angular motion of a rigid body about its centroid. These examples are emphasized in this and the following sections. Though frames in linear acceleration relative to each other are also important, the concepts in that case are fairly straightforward,so we will concentrate on the acceleration of rotation. The treatment in this section is not appreciably different and probably not clearer than the excellent and clear corresponding treatment in Symon [ 11. Though we will not describe rigid body motion until a later section we borrow terminology appropriate to that subject, namely spuce-frame K and body-frame F. Also, it will seem natural in some contexts to refer to frame P as “the laboratory frame” to suggest that the observer is at rest in this frame. The frame K, which will also be known as “the inertial frame,” has coordinates r = (r l , r2, r 3 ) ,which are related to coordinates F = (F’, F2, F3) by rotation matrix O ( t ) :
r = o(~)F, or r j = o j k ( t ) F k k .
(8.1.22)
The “inertial” designation has been interjected at this point in preparation for writing Newton’s equations in an inertial frame. Much more will be said about the matrix O(t),but for now we only note that it connects two different frames of reference. Unfortunately there is nothing in its notation that specifies what frames O ( t ) connects and it is even ambiguous whether or not it deserves to have an overhead bar? It would be possible to devise a notation codifying this information, but our policy is to leave the symbol 0 unembellished, planning to explain it in words as the need arises. In this section, the point of view of an observer fixed in the frame will be emphasized (though all vector diagrams to be exhibited will be plotted in the inertial system unless otherwise indicated). A x-frame observer locates a particular particle by a vector Fp, where the overhead bar connotes that its elements .“p refer to frame K.If this frame is accelerating or rotating, the motion will be described by Newton’s law expressed in terms of Z>, and the effects of frame rotation are to be accounted for by including fictitious forces, to be called “centrifugal force” and “Coriolis force.” The absolute coordinates of P in inertial frame K are then given by the second of Eqs. (8.1.22).3 Eq. (8.1.22) could have been interpreted actively, with F being, for example, the initial position of a particular point mass and r its position at time t. This would be a convenient interpretation for describing rigid body motion, for which F remains 21t has been mentioned before, and it will again become clear in this chapter, that when one attempts to maintain a parallelism between “intrinsic appearing” formulas l i e the first of Eq.(8.1.22)and coordinate formulas like the second, there is an inevitable notational ambiguity that can only be removed by accompanyingverbal description. 31t might seem artificial to describe motion from the point of view of a rotating frame were it not for the fact that. living on a rotating earth, we do it all the time.
VECTOR MECHANICS
245
constant in the K frame, because it signifies the arrow joining two points that are fixed in that frame. We do not permit this interpretation of Eq. (8.1.22), however. Our policy is explained in the following digression. When one vector, has an overhead bar and the other, V,does not, the equation V = O v will always be regarded passively. That is, the symbols V and 5 stand for the same arrow, and the equation is an abbreviation for the equation VJ = O j , v k , which relates the components of the arrow in two different coordinate frames: It is unattractive to have an intrinsic boldface symbol modifed to key it to a particular frame, but this is a price that has to be paid to maintain a compact matrix-like notation. It is important to remember this feature of the notation. So is that true vector (or arrow) whose K-frame components are Vi, and V is the same arrow whose K-frame components are x i.5 Note that it is only the equation relating apparently intrinsic (because they are in boldface type) quantities for which the notation has to be strained in this way-the relation among components V j = O j , v k is unambiguous. Whenever the “matrix” 0 appears in a formula like V = O v that links a barred and an unbarred quantity, the quantity 8 will not be used because it would become ambiguous later on. Also, with w being the angular velocity of frame relative to frame K ,we must resist the temptation to use 5 to signify the angular velocity of frame K relative to frame as that would clash with our later definition of W. For the time being (until Section 8.2), this discussion will have been academic since equations of the form V = O v will not appear and, for that matter, neither will vectors symbolized as Description of the motion of a single particle by observers in frames K and F is illustrated in Fig. 8.1.4. (One can apologize for the complexity of this figure without knowing how to make it simpler.) Heavy lines in this figure are the images of arrows in a double-exposure snapshot (at t and r A t ) taken in the inertial frame. Like all arrows, the arrows in this figure illustrate intrinsic vectors. Body-frame K rotates with angular velocity w about the common origin. Like 0,w is called a connecting quantity because it connects two different frames. Mainly for convenience in drawing the figure, the (n,y ) and (E, L> axes are taken orthogonal to w, which is therefore a common z and t axis, and the axes coincide at t = 0. (The axes will not actually be used in the following discussion.) At any time t , the position of the moving particle is represented by an arrow r(t). which is necessarily the same arrow whether viewed from K or F. But at time t A t , an observer in frame “remembers” the position of the particle at time t as having been at a point other than where it actually was-
v,
x,
v.
+
+
40ne must fear ambiguity whenever a frame-specific notation, such as an overhead bar, is attached to a (boldface) vector symbol. This ambiguity is intrinsic to the intrinsic nature of a true vector, since such a vector has an existence that transcends any particular frame of reference. There is no such ambiguity when a notation such as an overhead bar is attached to the components of a vector. We have to accept the unsettling feature of this notation that, though we say and V are the same arrow, it would not be good form to say = V since that would make the equation V = O v seem silly. If we slip into writing such an equation it should be written as V, or as an intermediate step in an algebraic simplification where the situation is to be repaired in a subsequent step.
v
246
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
* 0
determination, K's plot
(a)
(b)
a determination, K's plot
FIGURE 8.1.4. Body-frame Ti rotates with angular velocity w about its common origin with inertial-frame K. All arrows shown are plotted In frame K. (a) Two pointsr(t) and r(t A t ) on the trajectory of a moving particle are shown. For an observer in frame K at time t At, the radius vector r(t -F At) is the same arrow as the K-frame arrow at that time; but r(f) \ K , ~ +the ~~, K-frame observer's recollection at t A t of where the particle was at time t , is different from its actual location at time t, which was r(r). (b) A similar construction permits determination of acceleration a IF.
+
+
+
in the figure this is indicated by the dashed arrow labeled r ( f ) l ~ , f + aAs f . a result, the actual displacement A r occuring during time interval At and the apparent-to-K displacement (shown dashed) & are different. Our immediate task is to relate the velocities observed in the two frames. Since the vectors Ar and & stand for unambiguous arrows, plotted in the same frame K, it is meaningful to add or subtract them. From the figure, in the limit of small At, r(t) = r(t)lE,t+Ar- wAt x r(t)
or A r =
ar + wAr x r(r).
(8.1.23)
From this we obtain -
dr d -=-r+uxr dt dt
or v = v \ ~ + w x r ,
(8.1.24)
where, transcribing the geometric quantities into algebraic quantities, we have defined -
d v [KE - r = dt
Ar lim A t 4 0 At' -
(8.1.25)
and thereby assigned meaning to the operator d / d t . The components of d/dt r are ( d T ' / d t , d Y 2 / d t , . . .). Since Eq. (8.1.24) is a vector equation, it is valid in any coordinate frame, but if it is to be expressed in components, it is essential that components on the two sides be taken in the same frame. Since we are trying to describe motion from the point of view of a x observer, we will eventually use components in that frame. First, though, to apply Newton's law, we must calculate acceleration.
VECTOR MECHANICS
247
Though the derivation so far was based on the displacement vector r, any other true vectur V , being an equivalent geometric object, must satisfy an equivalent relation, namely
-
dV d _ - -v dr dt
+w x v
(8.1.26)
In particular this can be applied to velocity v, with the result
-
-
dv d _ - -v dt dt
+
d2 w x v = -r dt2
-
d + dt -(w
x r)
+ w x v l z + w x (w x r),
(8.1.27)
where the extra step of using Eq. (8.1.24) to replace v has been taken. Though the formal manipulations have been simple, we must be sure of the meaning of every term in Eq. (8.1.27). The term on the left is the well-known inertialframe acceleration; for it we will use the traditional notation a = d v / d t . In the terms w x V I K and w x (w x r), only standard vector multiplication operations are performed on mows illustrated in Fig. 8.1.4. All except v l are ~ shown in the (a) part of the figure, and that is shown in the (b) part. V I K is the apparent velocity where “apparent” means “from the point of view of an observer stationary in the frame who is (or pretends to be) ignorant of being in a noninertial frame.” The K-frame components of v l are ~ ( d Z ’ / d t ,dF2/dt, . ..). It is shown as “approximately parallel” to r because average and instantaneous velocities over short intervals are approximately parallel-in the limit of small At this becomes exact. For simplicity, let us assume - that w is time-independent (this restriction will be removed later), in which ~ only remaining term in Eq. (8.1.27) deserves closer case $(w x r) = w x v l The scrutiny. Defining (8.1.28)
x
it can be said to be the apparent acceleration from the point of view of F. Its components are (d2Y’/dt2,d 2 F 2 / d t 2 ,. .). The (b) part of Fig. 8.1.4 continues the construction from the (a) part to determine a. Combining these results, we obtain a = al,+2w
x
VIK+
w x (w x r).
(8.1.29)
At the risk of becoming repetitious, let it again be stressed that, even though all terms on the right-hand side of this equation are expressed in terms of quantities that will be evaluated in the frame, the arrows they stand for are all plotted in the K frame in Fig. 8.1.4 and are hence commensurable with a-otherwise Eq. (8.1.29) couldn’t make sense. On the other hand, since Eq. (8.1.29) is a vector equation, it can be expressed in component form in any frame-in particular in the K frame. The resulting K components are related to the K components in the well-known
x
248
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
-
(a) 7 determination,g’s plot
(b)
a determination, K s plot
FIGURE 8.1.5. Vectors entering into the determination of v IT and a IT plotted in a plot that is stationary in the R frame. a IT is given by xv lK / A t in the limit of small At. This figure violates our convention that a// figures be drawn in an inertial frame.
way vectors transform, namely the component form of Eq. (8.1.22).6 The point of introducingfictitiousforces has been to validate an analysis that describes kinematics purely in terms of the vectors shown as heavy arrows in Fig. 8.1.5. Since the second and third terms of Eq. (8.1.29),though artifacts of the description, appear to augment (negatively) the inertial acceleration, they are known as “fictitious” accelerations. With the inertial accelerationrelated to the “true force” F(true) by Eq. (8.I . I), the “fictitious” forces are F(centrifuga1) = -mw x (w x r ) = mo2r - m(w . r)w, F(Corio1is) = -2mw x
VIK,
(8.1.30)
and the equation of motion becomes 1
alF = &(F(true)
+ F(centrifuga1) + F(Corio1is)).
(8.1.3 1)
For practical calculation in component form, each of the terms is decomposed into K-frame components. In the case of F(true), this exploits the fact that F(true) is in fact a true vector. After some examples illustrating the use of these formulas, this analysis will be reexpressed in different terms, not because anything is wrong with the derivation just completed, but in preparation for proceeding to more complicated situations.
Problem 8.1.4: Express in your own words the meaning of the symbols Ar and A ( v 1 ~ )in Fig. 8.1.5. If that figure seems obscure to you, feel free to redraw it in a way that makes it seem clearer. 6A vector construction analogous to that of Fig. 8.1.4 can be performed in the K frame, as shown by 8.1.5. These vectors are only shown to make this point, though; the noninertial frame description describes the motion using only the heavy arrows. the dashed vectors in Fig.
VECTOR MECHANICS
249
Problem 8.1.5: The radial force on a mass m , at radius r relative to the center of the earth (mass M E ) is F = - m M E G / r 2 . If one ignores the motion of the earth about the sun, but not the rotation of the earth, one can describe the motion of a satellite of the earth in inertial coordinates with the earth at the origin or in terms of (r,8,4), which are the traditional radial distance, co-latitude, and longitude that are used for specifying geographical objects on earth. (a) It is possible for the satellite to be in a “geosynchronous” orbit such that all of its coordinates (r,8, #) are independent of time. Give the conditions determining this orbit and find its radius rs and latitude 0s. (b) Consider a satellite in an orbit just like That of part (a) except that it passes over the North and South poles instead of staying over the equator. Give (timedependent) expressions for the coordinates (r, @,#),as well as for the Coriolis and centrifugal forces, and show that Newton’s law is satisfied by the motion. 8.1.4. Exploitingthe Fictitious Force Description The mental exertion of the previous section is only justified if it simplifies some physical calculation. The reader has probably encountered discussions of the infiuence of Coriolis force on weather systems in the earth’s atmosphere [2]. Here we will provide only enough examples to make clear the practicalities of using Eq. (8.1.31). Working Problem 8.1.5 goes a long way in this direction. The most historically significant example, the Foucault pendulum, is analyzed in the next chapter. Though Eq. (8.1.31) was derived by working entirely with vectors drawn in the K frame, since it is a vector equation, it can be used working entirely with vector calculations in the frame. In this frame, the Coriolis and centrifugal forces are every bit as effective in producing acceleration as is the force which to this point has been considered fundamental. For terrestrial effects, the angular velocity is WE
=
2n = 0.727 x lOW4s-’. 24 x 3600
(8.1.32)
On the earth’s equator, since the centrifugal force points radially outward parallel to the equatorial plane, the acceleration it produces can be compared directly to the “acceleration of gravity” g = 9.8 m/s. The relative magnitude is
-W ~
2 R 3.44 ~
10-3.
(8.1.33)
g
Though appreciable, this is comparable to the variation of g over the earth’s surface and can be included by “renormalizing” the force of gravity slightly in magnitude and direction. The centrifugal force does not have appreciable meteorological consequences. The relative magnitude of the Coriolis and centrifugal forces tends to be dominated by the (small) extra factor of o in F(centrifugal) relative to F(Corio1is). The centrifugal force would be expected to make itself visible most effectively through the force difference occurring over an altitude difference compa-
250
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
rable with the height of the earth‘s atmosphere; let a typical value be Ar = 10 km. The Coriolis force can be estimated as being due to the velocity of a particle having “fallen” through such a change of altitude. For a particle accelerating through distance Ar under the influence of earth’s gravity, the velocity v is &Z, and a typical value for the ratio v / A r is % 0.04s-’. This is for a “large” fall; for a smaller fall the ratio would be greater. Since it is already much greater than W E , the Coriolis force tends to be more significant than the centrifugal force in influencing terrestrial phenomena. The Coriolis force has the property of depending on the velocity of the moving particle. Some precedents for velocity-dependence in elementary mechanics are friction and viscous drag. These forces are dissipative, however, while the Coriolis force clearly is not, since it results from a change of reference. In the regard of depending on velocity but being lossless, the Coriolis force resembles the force on a moving charged particle in a magnetic field, with the magnetic field and w playing roughly analogous roles. The characteristic qualitative feature of motion of a charged particle in a magnetic field is that it tends to move in a roughly circular helix wrapping around the magnetic field lines. This suggests, at least in some ranges of the parameters, that the Coriolis force will cause qualitatively similar wind motion circulating around w. Of course the presence of the earth’s surface acting as a boundary that is not normal to w tends to invalidate this analogy, but it should be expected that the Coriolis force can lead to atmospheric motion in “vortices.”
Example 8.1.1: A Particle Falling Freely Close to the Earth’s Surface. Newton’s law for free fall with the earth’s curvature neglected is t = -g$ where g is the acceleration of gravity and f points in the local “vertical” direction. Starting with velocity vo, after time r the particle’s velocity is vo - gtf. Including the Coriolis force, the equation of “free fall” is
t + g i = 2OEv x G,
(8.1.34)
where & is directed along the earth’s axis of rotation. As a matter of convention to be followed regularly in this text, the terms describing an idealized, solvable system have been written on the left-hand side of this equation, and the “perturbing” force that makes the system deviate from the ideal system has been written on the right-hand side. If the perturbing term is “small,” then it can be estimated by approximating the factor v by its “unperturbed” value, which is obtained by solving the equation with the right-hand side neglected. This procedure can be iterated to yield high accuracy if desired. In the present case, the equation in first iteration is
4
where 8 is the “co-latitude” angle (away from North) and is a unit vector pointing from east to west along a line of latitude. Since all the force terms are now functions only of r, (8.1.35) can be integrated easily. Starting from rest (in the Northern hemisphere), the falling object veers eastward because of the Coriolis force. This is contrary to the intuition of those people visualizing the Earth rotating “out from under” the mass.
VECTOR MECHANICS
251
Problem 8.1.6: Integrate Eq. (8.1.35) (twice) to find r(t) for a freely falling mass subject to gravity and the Coriolis force. For the case vo = 0, find the approximate spatial trajectory by using the relation between time and altitude appropriate for unperturbed motion. Problem 8.1.7: Using the velocity obtained from Eq. (8.1.35), perform a second iteration and from it write an equation of motion more accurate than Eq. (8.1.35). Example 8.1.2: The Reduced Three-Body Problem. Though the problem of three bodies subject to each other’s gravitational attraction is notoriously nonintegrable in general, there are simplifying assumptions that can be made that simplify the problem while still leaving it applicable to realistic celestial systems. In the socalled “reduced three-body” problem, the three masses are taken to be l - p, p, and 0 (where mass being zero would better be stated as “mass is negligible,” implying that the position of the third mass has no effect on the motions of the first two). In this case, the motion of the first two is integrable and they move inexorably, independent of the third. This inexorable motion causes the gravitational potential sensed by the third particle to be time-varying. Since the problem is still complicated, one assumes also that all three orbits lie in the same plane; call it the (x, y) plane. For further simplification one assumes also that the orbits of the first two masses around each other are circular. All the approximations mentioned so far are applicable to the system consisting of sun, earth, and moon, so let us say that this is the system we are studying. Symbols defining the geometry are shown in Fig. 8.1.6. Formulated in this way, the problem still has interest apart from its mundane, everyday observability. One can, for example, inquire as to what stable orbits the earth’s moon might have had, or what the possible orbits are of satellites around other binary systems. For that reason, although
ms
FIGURE 8.1.6. The sun, earth, moon system, with all orbits assumed to lie in the same plane. The bisector of the sun-earth line is shown, and the point 4 makes an equilateral triangle with sun and moon.
252
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
it would be valid to assume m , << me << m , , we will only assume m , << me and m , << m,. Also, we will not assume re << r,, even though it is true for the earth’s moon. As mentioned above, the gravitational potential at the moon depends on time. But if the system is viewed from a rotating coordinate system, this feature can be removed. Defining the “reduced mass” m of the sun-earth system by m 5 m,me/(m,+ me), R as their separation distance, M as their angular momentum, one knows that this system is rotating about the centroid with C O ~ S ~ angular Q I ~ ~ velocity !2 given by
a=---M
(8.1.36)
mR2‘ It was the requirement that C? and R be constant that made it appropriate to require the sun and earth orbits to be circular. The other constant distances satisfy R, = R m / m , , Re = R m / m e , and R, Re = R . Viewed from a system rotating with angular velocity R about the centroid, both sun and earth appear to be at rest, so the gravitationalpotential has been rendered time-independent. The potentials due to the sun and the earth are
+
v,
ms G
=-
J(x
+ RS12+ y2
and
Ve = -
meG J(x- Re)’
+ y2
(8.1.37) *
The centrifugal force can be included by including a contribution to the potential energy given by (8.1.38)
Combining all potentials we define
Including the Coriolis force, the equations of motion are
(8.1.40)
+
Problem 8.1.8: The quantity h = Veff + u 2 / 2 , where u2 = i 2 j 2 , would be the total energy of the moon, which would be conserved (because the total energy of the sun-earth system is constant) except (possibly) for the effect of being in a rotating coordinate system. Show, by manipulating Eqs. (8.1.40) to eliminate the Coriolis terms, that h is, in fact, a constant of the motion. It is known as the “Jacobi integral.” Problem 8.1.9: Find a Lagrangian for which Eqs. (8.1.40) are the Lagrange equations. (It is not necessary for a Lagrangian to have the form L = T - V , and if it
VECTOR MECHANICS
-2
-1
0’
1
253
2
X
FlGURE8.1.7. Contour plot of V,wfor R = 1, G = 1,52 = 1 , p =0.1, ms = 1 - p , me = p. The contours shown are for constant values of Vew given by -10, -5, -4, -3, -2.5, -2.4, -2.3, -2.2, -2.1, -2, -1.9, -1.8, -1.7, -1.6, -1.54, -1.52, -1.5, -1.48, -1.46, -1.44, -1.42, -1.4, -1.38, -1.36, -1.3, -1.2, -1.1, -1, -.5, -.2, -.1. The order of these contours can be inferred by spot calculation and the observation that there is a maximum running roughly along a circle of radius 1. Only the positive y region is shown; Vew is an even function of y .
is written in this form it is legitimate for V ( r ,r) to depend on both velocities and positions.) On the basis of the constancy of the Jacobi integral, some things can be inferred about possible motions of the moon from a contour plot of VeR. For a particular choice of the parameters, such a contour plot is shown in Fig. 8.1.7. Some of these contours are approximatetrajectories, in particular the “circles” close to and centered on the sun, but otherwise the relations between these contours and valid orbits is less clear. For each of these contours, if it were a valid trajectory, since both h and V,R are constant, so also would be u. For an orbit that is temporarily tangent to one of these contours, the tangential components of both the Coriolis force and the force due to Veg vanish, so u is temporarily stationary. Presumably the “generic” situation is for u to be either a maximum or a minimum as the orbit osculates the contour. For orbits that are approximate elliptical Kepler orbits around the sun, these two cases correspond approximately to the maximum and minimum values of u as the moon (in this case it would be more appropriate to say “other planet”) moves more of less periodically between a smallest value (along a semiminor axis) and a largest value (along a semimajor axis). In this case, then, the orbit stays in a band between a lowest and and a highest contour, presumably following a rosette-shaped orbit that, though, resembling a Kepler ellipse, does not quite close. If the moon’s velocity matches the speed u required by the osculating contour, then this band is
254
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
slender.’ In greater generality, at any point in the space, by judicious choice of initial conditions, it should similarly be possible to launch a satellite with the correct speed and direction so that it will follow the particular contour passing through the launch point for an appreciable interval. It will not stay on the contour indefinitely, though because the transverse acceleration deviates eventually from that required to remain on the contour. The points labeled L1, L2, and L3 are known as “Lagrange unstable fixed points,” and LA, with its symmetric partner L5, are known as “Lagrange stable fixed points.” These are the points for which aVe,/i3x = aVeR/i3y = 0. If a “moon” is placed at rest at one of these points, since the Coriolis force terms and the Veff force terms vanish, the moon would remain at rest. The most interesting points are L4 and L5. Since there are closed curves surrounding these points, there appears to be the possibility of satellite orbits “centered” there. In modem jargon, one would say that Lagrange “predicted” the presence of satellites there. Some 100 years later it was discovered that the asteroid Achilles resides near LA in the sun-Jupiter system, and numerous other asteroids have been discovered subsequently near L4 and L5.It has been proposed that a “Next Generation Space Telescope,” to replace the Hubble Space Telescope, be located at L2. Its orbit would therefore resemble the Earth’s elliptical orbit about the sun.
Problem 8.1.10: On a photocopy of Fig. 8.1.7, sketch the contours that pass through the Lagrange fixed points, completing the lower half of the figure by symmetry and taking account of the following considerations. At “generic” points (x, y), the directional derivative of a function V ( x , y) vanishes in one direction (along a contour) but not in directions transverse to this direction. (On the side of a hill there is only one “horizontal” direction.) In this case, adjacent contours are more or less parallel and hence cannot cross each other. At particular points, though (fixed points), both derivatives vanish and contours can cross (saddle points) or not (true maxima or minima). It is easy to see that Ll is a saddle point, and from the figure it appears that L4 and L5 are either maxima or minima. For the parameter values given, test which is the case and see if this agrees with Eq. (8.1.44) below. For L2 and L3, determine if they are stable or unstable, and, if the latter, whether they are saddle points or m a ima. Sketch contours that either cross or not, as the case may be, at these points. It should be possible to follow each such contour back to its starting point, wherever that is. Also, in general, one would not expect two fixed points to lie on the same contour. The linearized equations of motion, valid near one of the fixed points, say L4,are i = 2aj - vxxx - V,,y, j; = -2Qf - vrxx - V,,y,
(8.1.41)
where partial derivatives are indicated by subscripts and the origin has been placed at the fixed point. Conjecturing a solution of the form x = A&‘, y = BeA‘,these ’There are remarkable “ergodic theorems” (due originally to Poincd) that permit heuristically plausible statements such as these to be turned into rigorous results.
255
SINGLE-PARTICLEEQUATIONS IN GAUGE-INVARIANT FORM
equations become
(2!a
+ v,,
+
VX,
-2m h2
+ vxy) (;)
+ v,,
= 0.
(8.1.42)
The condition for such linear homogeneous equations to have nontrivial solutions is that the determinant of coefficients vanish: h4
+ (4Q2+ v,, + Vy,)h2 + (VXXVYY- vx’y)= 0.
(8.1.43)
This is a quadratic equation in h2. The condition for stable motion is that both possible values of h be purely imaginary. This requires A* to be real and negative.
Problem 8.1.11: Evaluate the terms of Eq. (8.1.43) for the Lagrange fixed point LA, and show that the condition for motion in the vicinity of L4 to be stable is 2 7 ~ ( 1- P )
-= 1,
(8.1.44)
which satisfies the where p = m,/m,. For the sun-Jupiter system, p x condition for stability consistent with the previously mentioned stable asteroids near LA and L5.
Problem 8.1.12: Larmor’s Theorem (a) The force F, on a particle with charge q and velocity v in a constant and uniform magnetic field B is given by F, = q v x B. Write the equation of motion of the particle in a frame of reference that is rotating with angular velocity w relative to an inertial frame. Assume that w is parallel to B. Show that if the magnetic field is sufficiently weak, the magnetic and fictitious forces can be made to cancel by selecting the magnitude of the angular velocity. Give a formula expressing the “weakness” condition that must be satisfied for this procedure to provide a good approximation. (b) Consider a classical mechanics model of an overall neutral atom consisting of light negatively charged electrons circulating around a massive point nucleus. Causing what is known as the “Zeeman effect,” placing an atom in a magnetic field B shifts the energy levels of the electrons. In the classical model, each electron is then subject to electric forces from the nucleus and from each of the other electrons as well as the magnetic force. Assuming the weakness condition derived above is satisfied, show that the electron orbits could be predicted from calculations in a field-free rotating frame of reference.
8.2. SINGLE-PARTICLE EQUATIONS IN GAUGE-INVARIANT FORM
The term “gauge-invariant,” though long prevalent in electromagnetic theory, has recently acquired greater currency in other fields of theoretical physics [3]. In colloquial English, a “gauge” is a device for measuring a physical quantity-a ther-
256
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
mometer is a temperature gauge, a ruler is a length gauge. In electromagnetic theory, “gauge-invariant”describes a kind of freedom of choice of scalar or vector potentials, but it is hard to see why the word “gauge” is thought to call such freedom to mind in that case. In the context of geometric mechanics, the term “gauge-invariant” more nearly approximates its colloquial meaning. When one describes a physical configuration by coordinates that refer to inertial, fixed, orthonormal, Euclidean axes, one is committed to choosing a single measuring stick, or gauge, and locating every particle by laying off distances along the axes using the same stick. A theory of the evolution of such a system expressed in those coordinates would not be manifestly gauge-invariant, because it would be expressed explicitly in terms of a particular gauge, but this does not imply that the same theory cannot be expressed in gauge-invariant form. An example of this sort of mathematical possibility (Gauss’s theorem) was discussed in Section 4.3.2; though Gauss’s theorem is commonly expressed in Euclidean coordinates, it is expressed in coordinate-independentform in that section. In this chapter the term “gauge-invariant” will have the similar meaning of “coordinate-frame-invariant.”The gauge could, in principle, depend on position, but since that will not be the case here, we have to deal only with a much simplified form of gauge-invariance. Much of the subsequent analysis can be described as the effort to derive equations in which all quantities have overhead bars (or all do not). Such an equation will then be said to be form-invariant.If the frame in which the equation was derived is itself general, then the equation will have the powerful attribute of being applicable in any coordinate system. An example of equations having this property are Maxwell’s equations; they have the same form in all frames traveling at constant speed relative to a base frame. 8.2.1. Newton’s Force Equation in Gauge-Invariant Form A particle of mass m,8 situated at a point P with coordinates x i ,is subject to Newton’s equation, d2xi
m-
dt2
.
= f’(r, v, t ) ,
(8.2.1)
where f’ is the force’ (possibly dependent on r, r, and I ) . Since the f’ are components of a vector, they are subject to the same transformation Eqs. (8.1.22) as r: f = O(t)i, f’ = 0’,(t).Tk.
(8.2.2)
Recall that, by our conventions, this is to be regarded as a passive transformation, relating the components o f f and j , which stand for the same arrow. Our mission is to write Newton’s equation in “gauge-invariant’’form where, in this case, choice of 8We talk of a point mass m even though it will often be the mass dm contained in an infinitesimal volume d V , perhaps fixed in a rigid body, that is being discussed. 9Since we will use only Euclidean coordinates for now, it is unnecessary to distinguish between covariant and contravariant components of the force.
SINGLE-PARTICLE EQUATIONS IN GAUGE-INVARIANT FORM
257
“gauge” means choice of coordinate system, with rotating coordinate systems being allowed. (The ordinary Newton equations are gauge-invariant in this sense when the choice is restricted to inertial frames; this is known as “Galilean invariance.”) Formally, the task is to reexpress Newton’s equation entirely in terms of quantities having overhead bars. The introduction of Coriolis and centrifugal forces has gotten us a long way toward realizing our goal-they are fictitious forces which, when added to true forces, make it legitimate to preserve the fiction that a rotating frame is inertial. This “fictitious force” formulation has amounted to evaluating inertial frame quantities entirely in terms of moving frame quantities. Once the gauge-invariant formulation has been established, there will be no further need for more than one frame, and it will be unnecessary to distinguish, say, between d / d t and d / d t . For want of better terminology we will use the terms “fictitious force formalism” and “gauge-invariant formalism” to distinguish between these two styles of description even though the terminology is a bit misleading. It is misleading because not only are the formulations equivalent in content, they are similarly motivated. The present treatment strives to express Newton’s equations in such a way that they preserve the same form in any reference frame. It is somewhat more general than the simple introduction of fictitious centrifugal and Coriolis forces because the axis and velocity of rotation of the rotating frame will not necessarily be constant. At some point a sense of dkja vu may develop, as the present discussion is very similar to that contained in Section 3.1.5, which dealt with the application of the absolute differential in mechanics, though the present situation is somewhat more general because time-dependent frames are being allowed. In that earlier section, an operator D was introduced with the property that position r and its time derivative were related by i = Dr, but that the curvilinear effect was shown to cause the absolute acceleration vector a = D2r to differ from r. In the present case, an analogous differential operator D, will be defined; in terms of this operator, the absolute velocity is Drr. Again it will be true that r # D:r, but the time-dependent relation between frames will cause r to differ from Dtr as well. Differentiating Eq. (8.1.22), the inertial-frame velocity v = r is given by
v = oi + O F = 06 + ( 0 T O ) F ) = 06 + a@,
(8.2.3)
wherelo
and the orthogonality of 0 has been used: 0-’ = O r . It is easy to be too glib in manipulations such as those just performed in Eq. -(8.2.3). Having said that r and I; are in some sense the same -but d / d r and d / d t are different, what is the meaning o f f ? We mean it as f = d/dtF, the m a y of lome quantity 0’0 is known in differential geometry as “the Cartan matrix.” It was introduced by Cartan in his “mdrhode du rephe mobile” or “moving frame method.”
258
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
elements ( d x ’ l d t , dT*/dt, . . .), and we mean Of as an abbreviated notation for the array of elements OJ,dYk/dt. We introduce a vector 5, related to v in the same way F is related to r: v = O(r)V.
(8.2.5)
From Fq.(8.2.3), T is given by
+
v = + 51F.
(8.2.6)
(This shows that V is not equal to the quantity k, which might have seemed to deserve being called the F-frame velocity of the moving point; this reminds us that transformation between frames deserves considerable care.) We introduce a “time derivative” operator
-
-
d dt
D, = - +51,
(8.2.7)
dependent on “gauge” 61, that relates F and V as in (8.2.6):”
-
-
v = DtF.
(8.2.8)
This equation has the desirable feature that all quantities have overhead bars, making the equation “gauge-invariant.”12It can be reiterated that absence of a symbol 6 distinct from 0 is inessential,but it may be reassuring that 61, because it is the product of a “forward” and a “backward” matrix, can naturally link quantities evaluated in the same frame of reference. A way of calculating i equivalent to that of Eq. (8.2.8) is to first calculate the space-frame dispacement OF, find its time derivative (d/dr)(OF),and then transform back:
v = OT
($) OF = OTO-dF + OT0F =:(- + 51) F = BtF. dt
(8.2.9)
This shows that Bt can also be written as
-
D1 = OT
‘
($) 0.
(8.2.10)
‘V can be regarded as a relative velociry vector, composed from an apparent velocity in one frame and the relative velocity of the two frames. Its components are then subject to the same transformationrelation as all other true vectors. It is unclear how helpful to the intuition this is, however, since the individual terms are not m e vectors. ‘*When a tensor equation expresses a relationship between components in the same frame of reference using only invariant operations such as contraction on indices. it is said to be manifestly covarianr. The concept of gauge invariancecurrently under discussion is therefore a similar concept.
SINGLE-PARTICLE EQUATIONS IN GAUGE-INVARIANT FORM
259
a
Remembering that OT = O-I, this formula shows that and d l d t , though they operate in different spaces, can be regarded as being related by a “similarity transformation.” In this case, the two spaces are related by 0, and the K-frame evolution operator 5 is “similar” to the K-frame evolution operator d / d f . We now write Newton’s equation using the operator
z:
-2-
-
mDt r = f ( F , Q .
(8.2.11)
This has the sought-for property of being expressed entirely in terms of quantities with overhead bars. As in Eq. (8.2.2), the vectorial property of force f has been assumed. (The force can also depend on time, but that dependence is not shown because it does not affect the present discussion.) To check that this equation is correct, we need to see that it agrees with Eq. (8.2. l), which is Newton’s equation in an inertial frame:
m a 2 i =m
(OT (OT $0)
$0) F
= mOTr = OTf(r,v) = OTf(OT,OV) = f(F, V).
(8.2.12)
These manipulations have been formally motivated by the goal of eliminating quantities without overhead bars. The only remaining evidence of the fact that the body frame is rotating is that the evaluation o f f from F(t) depends on the gauge 51. When expanded more fully, the “acceleration” term of Newton’s equation becomes -2-
-*
D, r=o,(F+51?)=~+nT+262f+n2F.
(8.2.13)
The term -2mfli is the Coriolis force, -mf12T is the centrifugal force, and -mhT accounts for the nonconstancy of the relative angular velocities of the frames.’3
*8.2.2. Active and Passive Interpretationsof Time Evol~tion’~ In discussing rotational motion, the sign of the angular velocity vector w seems to be particularly confusing, and so also does the distinction between active and passive interpretations of transformations. Consider a point P fixed at location Tp in a rotating rigid body. At least temporarily, at a time we take as t = 0, the body, as viewed in inertial-frame K, is rotating with angular velocity w, and we assume that moving and inertial-frames are aligned at this time, so we have rp(0) = Tp(0). At later time t, the point P has K-frame 131t has been explained repeatedly why one need not be concerned by the absence of an overhead bar on n as it appears in Eq. (8.2.13). 14This and the next section are confusing without being extremely important. It commonly is needed only to determine the sign of a rotation velocity, a factor that can typically also be determined by other means. Once one has appreciated the difficulty of avoiding ambiguity, it may be sensible to defer worrying about signs and whether a matrix or its inverse is required until a concrete case is being studied.
260
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
location r p ( t ) , related to its earlier location by (8.2.14) where 0’is an othogonal matrix that will later be related to 0. Other than some seemingly irrelevant differences in subscripts and arguments, the equality of the outer quantities here looks like the first of Fqs. (8.1.22). But we should compare these equations more closely; to allow for its possible difference from 0, the matrix 0’has been given given a prime in Eq. (8.2.14). We have stated that the vectors r and F in Eq. (8.1.22) are “the same arrow,” whose coordinates differ because they refer to different frames. On the other hand, a picture illustrating Eq. (8.2.14) would seem to have Fp(0) independent of time and hence fixed and rp(t) moving. This does not square with their being “the same arrow”-a paradox. The presence of the qualified equality symbol acknowledges this, and the same qualification should have been placed on the earlier equation r p (0) i p (0). Since the quantity r in Eq. (8.1.22) stood for the location of any particle, it can stand for our particular particle P, so the subscript P has no bearing on the paradox. Furthermore, the presence or absence of arguments ( t ) cannot matter, since each Fp(O), which just happens of the vectors could be given such an argument-ven to be time-independent (though only when viewed in the frame). This parenthetic comment is the tip-off; the resolution of the paradox is that Fp (0) is not in fact a fixed arrow in the K frame but is rotating along with r p ( t ) . This means that Eq.(8.1.22) and the outer equality of Eq. (8.2.14) are not necessarily inconsistent after all. In component form, Eq. (8.2.14) reads r’(t)
= O’ik(t)FqO),
(8.2.15)
Not only is this consistent with the second of Eqs. (8.1.22), it has no “seemingly paradoxical” character. The constant quantities Fk (0) are related to the time-varying quantities r j ( t ) by a time-varying matrix o”k(t) in a way that simply reflects the instantaneous relative orientation of the reference frames. These considerations are important in understanding the Cartan matrix s1 that figured prominently in the previous section. The Cartan matrix was also introduced in Section 4.2.6, where it was used to relate bivectors and infinitesimal rotations. As bivectors and infinitesimal rotations are discussed there, a fixed vector is related to a moving vector. The first equality in Eq. (8.2.14) (suppressing the P), r(t) = O’(t)r(O),
(8.2.16)
is just such an equality. Its natural interpretation is active with O’(t)acting on constant vector r(0) to yield rotating vector r(t). This is illustrated in the upper part of Fig. 8.2.1. Let us contrast this with Eq. (8.1.22), which we repeat now for emphasis:
r = O(t)F.
(8.2.17)
SINGLE-PARTICLE EQUATIONS IN GAUGE-INVARIANT FORM
y ( r ) = sin 8, x(0)
M
261
+ cos e, y(0)
y (positive) X
pAsslvE
x - sin ep-Y
x = cos ep
y = sin B,X
+ cos epy
r z r FIGURE 8.2.1. Pictorial representations of Eqs. (8.2.16) and (8.2.17) exhibiting the active and passive effects of the same matrix. The figures have been arranged so that the coefficients of the inset equations are element-by-element equal (in the case Be = Bp).
We have insisted on apassive interpretationof this equation, with r and F standing for the same arrow; the equation is simply an abbreviation for the matrix multiplication that relates components in different coordinate systems. The lower part of Fig. 8.2.1 illustrates this interpretation. Any relation between O’(t)and O ( t )would depend on the relation between active angle 6, and passive angle 8,. In general, there is no such relation since the relative orientation of frames of reference and the time evolution of systems being described are independent. Commonly though, the passive view is adopted in order to “freeze” motion that is rotating in the active view. To achieve this, we combine Eqs. (8.2.16) and (8.2.17), -
r(r) = (O-’(t)O’(r))T(O),
(8.2.18)
where we have assumed r(0) = F(0). In order for F(r) to be constant, we must have O’(t)= O(r). Though it is logically almost equivalent, essentially the same argument applied to linear motion seems much easier to comprehend-to freeze the motion x = a ut wedefinex = X + b ut so thatX = a ut - b - ut = a - b.
+
+
+
*8.2.3. Continued Discussion of the Cartan Matrix We now continue with the Cartan analysis, ceasing to distinguish between 0’and 0. Differentiating Eq. (8.2.16), which is the same as the first of Eqs. (8.2.14), the velocity of point P is v(t) = o(t)r(O).
(8.2.19)
262
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
Using the inverse of Eq. (8.2.16),v(t) can therefore be expressed in terms of r(t),
v(r) = OOTr(t),
(8.2.20)
where OT = O-l, because 0 is an orthogonal matrix. It was shown in Section 4.2.6 (from the requirement r . v = 0) that the quantity OOT is an antisymmetric tensor. It then follows from d / d t ( O O T )= 0 that O*O, for which we introduce the symbol n,is also anti~ymmetric:’~
(8.2.21 ) This meets the requirement of antisymmetry, but for the time being the quantities e l , e2,and e3are simply undetermined parameters; the signs have been chosen for later convenience. We next introduce a quantity i that is related to v by
v = ov,
(8.2.22)
which is to say the same way vectors introduced previously have been related in the two frames of reference; that is, v and V stand for the same arrow but with components to be taken in different frames.16 Combining these formulas, we arrive at
-
v = O*V = O T 6 0 T r ( t = ) Q(r)r.
(8.2.23)
The essential feature of n is that it relates the instantaneous position vector and the instantaneous velocity vector “as arrows in the same frame.” This is the basis for the phrase “Cartan’s moving frame.” If we now allow the point P to move with velocity r in the moving frame, this becomes 5 =t f
n(t)r;.
(8.2.24)
We have rederived Eq. (8.2.6)though the components of n are as yet undetermined.
8.2.4. Reconciling Fictitious Force and Gaugeinvariant Descriptions Clearly the “fictitious force” and “gauge-invariant” descriptions contain the same physics, but their conceptual bases are somewhat different and their interrelationships are subtle. Eq.(8.2.13) is equivalent to Eq. (8.1.29) (or rather it generalizes that equation by allowing nonuniform rotation), but minor manipulation is required to demonstrate the fact, especially because Eiq. (8.2.13) is expressed by matrix multiplication and Eq. (8.1.29) is expressed by vector cross products. The needed formula was derived in Eq.(4.2.25),but to avoid the need for correlating symbols we rederive it now. I5Tbe calculation OOT has generated an element of the Lie algebra of antisymmetric matrices from the Lie gmup of orthogonal matrices. This generalizes to arbitrary continuous symmetries. 16Commentsmade in the footnote following Eq.(8.1.22) concerning the risk of ambiguity in the interpretation of quantities like B are just as applicable here.
SINGLE-PARTICLE EQUATIONS IN GAUGE-INVARIANT FORM
263
To do this, and to motivate manipulations to be performed shortly in analyzing rigid body motion, the two representations of the same physics can now be juxtaposed, starting with velocities from Eqs. (8.1.24) and (8.2.6): v = vlz + w x r, -
v = $ + JZF,
fictitious force description,
gauge-invariant description.
(8.2.25) (8.2.26)
The latter equation, in component form, reads
-
0
4
3
z 2
(8.2.27) where the components of 51 have been chosen to make the two equations match termby-term. The mental pictures behind Eqs. (8.2.25) and (8.2.26) are different. For the former equation one has mo coordinate frames explicitly in mind, and the equation yields the inertial-frame quantity v from quantities evaluated in a moving frame. In the gauge-invariant description, one “knows” only one franie, the frame one inhabits, and that frame has a gauge 51 externally imposed upon it. In Eq.(8.2.26), JZ acts as, and is indistinguishablefrom, an externally imposed field. That the quantity V is more deserving than, say f, of having its own symbol is just part of the formalism. (There is a similar occurence in the Hamiltonian description of a particle in an electromagnetic field; in that case the mechanical momentum is augmented by a term proportional to the vector potential. Furthermore, recalling Problem 8.1.12, one knows that JZ has somewhat the character of a magnetic field.) In Eq. (8.2.26), or more explicitly in Eq. (8.2.27), all coordinates have bars on them in the only frame that is in use. Except that it would introduce confusion into the comparison of the two views, we could simply remove the bars in Eqs. (8.2.26) and (8.2.27). For these two views to correspond to the same physics, there must -be an intimate connection between the quantities w and fl. Identifying VIE = (;Tix, d - 7x y-, 7xZ) T (this is necessarily a “qualified” equality, since the quantity on one side is intrinsic and on the other side is in component form) and equating corresponding coefficients, it is clear that the quantities ol, w2,and w3 entering the definition of 51 in Eq. (8.2.21) are in fact the components of w. The two formalisms can then be related by replacing vector cross product multiplication by w with matrix multiplication by s1: w x + 51.
(8.2.28)
Spelled out in component form, this is the well-known cross-product expansion of ordinary vector analysis: 0 (w3
-02
+Ji) ,2
-,3
0 Lo’
0
Iwxr.
(8.2.29)
264
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
Like numerous previous formulas, this has to be regarded as a “qualified” equality since it equates an intrinsic and a nonintrinsic quantity. It is valid in any frame as long as the appropriate components are used in each frame. Accelerations, as given in the two approaches by Eqs. (8.1.29) and (8.2.13), can also be juxtaposed: a =a
IF +2w
-
($)=(Z2+2(
x
VIK
+ w x (w x r),
0
-533
-732 233
gj’ 0
7552
+0+ (
fictitious force description,
-
0 -Tjz Ts3
-733
732
0’ 0
0
gauge-invariant description.
(8.2.30)
(8.2.31) y-2-72-d’ alx = (a; x , ;ii y, dr q
nT.
One identifies acceleration components according to The quantities on the left sides of Eqs. (8.2.31) are “dynamical” in the sense that they are to be inferred from the applied force and Newton’s law; the quantities on the right side can be said to be “kinematical,” as they are to be inferred from the particle’s evolving position. Clearly the matrix and vector equations are equivalent representationsof the same physics. It would be a helpful mnemonic if the correction terms in the fictitious force formalism were expressed using cross-product notation and the correction terms in the gauge-invariant formalism were expressed in matrix form. But this would be too great a sacrifice in the latter case, since the cross-product formulas are so handy to to distinguish which interpreuse. There will still, however, be a notational device tation is intended. In the fictitious force formalism, d / d t will have an overhead bar, but vectors like w and v will not. In the gauge-invariant formalism, all quantities applicable to the frame, including will have overhead bars. At this point, one can further mull over the difficulty of maintaining logical, selfconsistent notation, especially concerning the quantities w and ZZ that, on the one hand, relate different frames and, on the other hand, have been said to represent “the same arrow.” Here the meaning of “same” includes all their intrinsic propertiesthey represent the same geometric object, the same axis of rotation, and the same angular speed and orientation around that axis. This geometric object, represented by a vector,17 is subject to the addition and transformation properties this implies. Of course the components of this geometric object differ in different frames. This is consistent with the components w iand Tsi being different. But, as stressed previously, w and Zi differ only by the frames in which their coordinates are expected to be expressed. When a cross-product expression such as w x i; is encountered, how is it to be interpreted intrinsically? How are its components to be calculated? Since it is the cross product of two unambiguous arrows, the rules of vector analysis assure that w x f is also an unambiguous arrow (it is an arrow perpendicular to both w and 3,but the latter question is poorly posed-it requires further specification of what frame is intended. If, as is likely, one wishes the components given as an answer to
m,
I7w is actually a pseudo-vectorbut the distinction is inessential here; the connection between bivectors and infinitesimal rotations is discussed in Section 4.2.6.
265
SINGLE-PARTICLEEQUATIONS IN GAUGE-INVARIANT FORM
refer to frame K,then components Ti and Ziare to be used in working out the cross product. Again our notational difficulties result from the fact that intrinsic quantities, by their nature, are not naturally related to any particular frame of reference.
’*
8.2.5. Newton’s Torque Equation
For analyzing rotational motion of one or more particles, it is useful to introduce “torques” and to write Newton’s equation in terms of the angular momentum L (relative to 0) of a particle with radius vector r (relative to 0 )and velocity v, which is defined by Lrrxmv.
(8.2.32)
By the rules of vector analysis, this is a true vector (actually a pseudo-vector) since both r and v are true vectors. The torque about 0 due to force F acting at position r is defined by
-r=rxF.
(8.2.33)
As it applies to L, Newton’s “torque law,” valid in inertial frames, is
dL _ --d r
dt
dt
dv = r x F = 7. dt
x mv+ r x m-
(8.2.34)
Consider next a point B, also at rest in the inertial frame, with radius vector rg relative to 0, and let r - r B = x so x is the displacement of mass m relative to point B. The angular momentum LB and torque T B relative to B are defined by
Lg=xxmv,
TBEXXF.
(8.2.35)
We have, therefore,
*
dv = ( i ( r - r I g ) ) x m v + x x m- = 7 8 - v g x mv, dt dt
(8.2.36)
where the final term vanishes because point B has so far been said to be at rest. We have not eliminated this correction term explicitly to prepare for the later possibility that point B is in fact moving. This formula is especially useful when a single particle is constrained by an element incapable of applying torque or when two or more particles are rigidly connected so that the torques due to their internal forces cancel in pairs; then, if there are external torques but no net external force, the point of application of the forces does not matter. But for the time being, all forces are to be applied directly to a single particle. I8It is because of the way that overhead bars are interpreted that we must not make the mistake of interpreting 5 as the angular velocity of frame K relative to frame since, by our conventions, that would yield the wrong sign.
266
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
Next let us consider similar quantities reckoned in the rotating frame K.From the rules of vector analysis and from our algebraic conventions, certain relations have to be true:
-
LB
= il x mv,
FB
= I x 7,
d -LB dt
-
ddt
= -LB
-
+W x E B .
(8.2.37)
What is not clear is the relation between $LB and 7 ~One . complication is that even if the point B is at rest in the K frame, it will be moving in the frame and vice versa. Setting m = 1, we commence the evaluation: -
-
dd --Lg = - ( @ - F B ) dt dt
x
V) = (V- ve) x
V+X
x
(z-) -V
,
(8.2.38)
The tactic of this manipulation has been to work on removing bars. (The formula is now in some kind of hybrid state that would probably not pass mathematical muster because some quantities have bars and some do not, but the situation will be rectified in subsequent steps.) For a vector such as I,appearing at a place in the formula where it will not subsequently be differentiated, one has simply removed the bar. Continuing the evaluation, evaluating barred derivatives algebraically, and simply removing bars from quantities that will not be differentiated later, we find -
d-Lg dt
= (V - V B - w x
X)
x V+X x
d = -v,q x v - (w x x) x v + x x -v - x x dt d = x x - v - @ x (x x v) - v B x v. dt
(W
x v)
(8.2.39)
Taking advantage of the validity of putting bars back on quantities that will not be differentiated, this equation could have been written as
(z )-+SX
Lg =X
dv x m- - v B x mv=?B dt
- i B
x mv.
(8.2.40)
In the final line, the bars have been put back on the vectors so that both sides of the equation are expressed in variables of the same frame. (If we had trusted the formalism, we could have written this directly from Eq. (8.2.36) and the last of Eqs. (8.2.37).)
8.2.6. The Plumb Bob What could be simpler than a plumb bob, a point mass hanging at the end of a light string or rigid rod? It hangs straight down “in the laboratory.” But what is “down”?
SINGLE-PARTICLE EQUATIONSIN GAUGE-INVARIANT FORM
267
The fact that the earth rotates makes this system not quite so simple. But its apparent simplicity makes it a good system to exercise the methods under discussion. It will be approached several ways. Because the bob appears to be at rest there is no Coriolis force, even when working in the laboratory system.
(a) Inertial Frame Force Method: The earth-plumb bob system is illustrated in Fig. 8.2.2. The mass m hanging, apparently at rest, at the end of the light string of length 1 is subject to gravitational force FE directed toward the center of the earth and tension force FT along the smng. The resultant of these forces causes the mass to accelerate toward the axis of rotation of the earth. Of course this is just the acceleration needed to stay on a circular path of radius RE sine and keep up with the earth’s rotation at angular velocity o.Its radial acceleration is a = - R E sin802, where 8 is the co-latitude of the bearing point B on the earth from which the bob is suspended. The angle by which the plumb bob deviates from the line to the earth’s center is a.Since the mass is at rest axially, we have FT COS(8 - a) = FG COS
(8.2.41)
where an extremely conservativeapproximation has already been made in the second argument, and the term a ( ) c / R ~of) ,order RE relative to a,will immediately be dropped in any case. Taking FG = mg,we have therefore (8.2.42)
B
FIGURE 8.2.2. Mass m, hanging at rest at the end of light string of length A, constitutes a plumb bob. Its length is much exaggerated relative to the earth’s radius RE.
268
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
Equating radial components yields (8.2.43) which simplifies to
(8.2.44) Finally this reduces to REU~ ff=-
2g
sin28
‘21.6 x
10-3radians,
(8.2.45)
where the Greenwich co-latitude of 8 = 38.5 degrees has been used. It is customary to incorporatethis tiny angle by redefining what constitutes “down” so that the plumb bob points in this direction and not toward the earth’s center. (Actually,the bob would not point toward the center of the earth in any case since the earth is not a perfect sphere. Its major deviation from being spherical is itself due to the centrifugal force which, acting on the somewhat fluid earth, has caused it to acquire an ellipsoidal shape.) Once this has been done the centrifugal force can (to good approximation) be ignored completely. For the rest of this section, it will be assumed that the direction of gravitational acceleration vector go = -gi, that is, it will be assumed that it points toward the center of the earth, but from then on we will assume an “effective” gravitational acceleration vector g(B) given by
which will permit the centrifugal force to be otherwise neglected. This constitutes an approximation, but since the deviation is so small it is a good one. If the earth were spinning sufficiently fast, the plumb bob would end up pointing sideways, and treating the centrifugal force would be more difficult, though not as difficult as the other problems life on Earth would present.
(b) lnertial Frame Torque/Angu/ar-MomentumMethod: To evaluate the torque acting on rn about point 0, we define local unit vectors i radial, C eastward, and C southward, as shown in Fig. 8.2.3. Still working in the inertial frame, the angular momentum of the mass rn relative to point 0 is
SINGLE-PARTICLEEQUATIONSIN GAUGE-INVARIANT FORM
269
FIGURE 8.2.3. The same plumb bob as in the previous figure is shown along with local basis vectors ? radial, e eastward, and & southward.
and its time rate of change is given by
dL _- -m R i a 2 sin 86 cos 8. dt
(8.2.48)
As shown in the figure, the only force applying torque about 0 is the string tension, which is given approximately by FT = mg. Its torque is r = RE? x FT = --REmg sin&.
(8.2.49)
Equating the last two expressions, we obtain
Rp2 sincr = -sin 28, 2g
(8.2.50)
in approximate agreement with Eq.(8.2.45) since a is an exceedingly small angle.
(c) Fictitious Force Method: If we act as if the earth is at rest and continue to use the center of the earth as origin, the situation is as illustrated in Fig. 8.2.4. There is an outward-directed fictitious force Fcentwith magnitude m RE^^ sin 8 which has to balance the gravitational force FG in order for the bob to remain at rest. Since both of these forces are applied directly to m , we can equate their components normal to the bob, which amounts also to equating their torques about point B. The condition for this balance is mgcr
mREw2 sin 8 cos 6,
(8.2.51)
270
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
FIGURE 8.2.4. When viewed “in the laboratory,”the earth, the bearing point B and the mass m all appear to be at rest, but there is a fictitious centrifugal force Fcent.
which agrees with the previous calculations. In this case it has been valid to work with torques about B, but this would be risky in general because B is not fixed in an inertial frame.
(d) Transformation of Angular Momentum; Origin at 0: Alternatively we can use transformation formulas to infer inertial frame quantities. Since m is at rest (to excellent approximation) relative to B we can use RE? both as its approximate position vector and for calculating its velocity using Eq. (8.1.24). The inertial frame angular momentum of m about 0 is given by L = mRE? x (;RE?
+ w x RE?
= -mR&sinBi.
(8.2.52)
-
Note that the d / d t term has vanished because the mass appears to be at rest. The time rate of change of angular momentum is given by -
d_L d - -L dt dt
+w x L = -mRiu2
cos0 sin&,
(8.2.53)
__
where the d / d t term has again vanished because the angular momentum appears to be constant. The torque is again given by Eq. (8.2.49),and the result (8.2.45) is again obtained.
(e) Gauge-Invariant Method: Referring to Fig. 8.2.4 and substituting into Eq. (8.2.40), we have
LIE ALGEBRAIC DESCRIPTIONOF RIGID BODY MOTION
(z- )
@ x V) = w x
-+WX
(X
x V) = x x
FG.
271
(8.2.54)
(In evaluating expressions such as this, a frequent mistake is setting 7 to zero; this is a mistake because the bob is not moving-it is d/dtE that vanishes, not 9.The term V B x v in Eq.(8.2.40) vanishes because, though the support point B is moving in the inertial system, the velocities of the bob and the support point are parallel. The needed vectors are
x = -A?, w = o ( c o s 8 i - sin&), TB
= x x FG x hmgari,
(8.2.55)
and Eq. (8.2.40)becomes R
~
ee = hmgcri,
Osine I ~ cos~
(8.2.56)
which agrees with the previous determinations. Incidentally, no great significance should be placed on which of the above plumb bob equations have been indicated as equalities and which as approximations. Most of the equations are approximate in one way or another. The first method, though the most elementary, has the disadvantage compared to all the other methods that, because of the need to equate components parallel to the plumb line, more careful approximation is required.
8.3. LIE ALGEBRAIC DESCRIPTIONOF RIGID BODY MOTION Much of the material in this section repeats material in earlier chapters in which the Lagrange-Poincark approach is taken. This is partly to permit this chapter to be accessible whether or not that material has been mastered and partly to compare and contrast the two approaches. The main example will be the description of angular motion of a rigid body by the “Euler equations” describing rigid body motion. These are equations governing the time evolution of the body’s angular velocity components, as reckoned in the body frame (id, W 2 ,W3).The equations will be be derived using Lie algebraic methods. One purpose of this discussion is to practice with the commutator manipulations that are basic to application of Lie algebraic methods. It will turn out that the method to be developed is applicable to any system with symmetry describable as invariance under a Lie group of transformations. Every physicist has intuitively assimilated Newton’s equations as giving a valid description of mechanics (at least in the nonrelativistic, nonquantal domain). Every physicist who has advanced beyond freshman-level mechanics has acquired a similar
272
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
(perhaps less deeply held) confidence in the Lagrange equations as containing the same physics and leading economically to correct equations of motion. And many physicists have followed a derivation of the Euler equations and their application to describe rigid body motion. Probably far fewer physicists can answer the question “Why is it that the Euler equations can be derived from Newton’s law, but not from the Lagrange equations?” For our theory to be regarded as satisfactorily powerful, it should be possible to derive the Euler equations by straightforward manipulations. Well, the Poincark equation derived in Section 5.2 provided exactly that capability, making it possible to derive the Euler equationsjust by “turning the crank.” The situation was still somewhat unsatisfactory, in the way that Lagrangian mechanics often seems, because the formulas tend not to have visualizable content. This may make it hard to make sensible approximations or to see how symmetries or simple features of the physical system can be exploited to simplify the equations, or how the method can be applied to other problems. This justifies working on the same problem with different methods, for example Newtonian methods. It will turn out that commutation relations again play an important role, but now the noncommuting elements will be 2 x 2 or 3 x 3 matrices rather than the vector fields prominent in Lagrange-Poincark mechanics. In addition to the material just covered concerning rotating reference systems and Coriolis and centrifugal forces, the description of rotational motion of rigid bodies and the mathematics of infinitesimal rotations deserve review at this point. It is entirely intentional that Hamilton’s equations and “canonical methods” have not been, and will not be, used in this discussion. Hamiltonian formulation is of no particular value for clarifying the issues under discussion, though of course the present discussion will have to be reviewed in that context later on,
8.3.1. Space and Body Frames of Reference We wish to describe rigid body motion in much the way single-particle motion was described in the preceding sections. At this point, familiarity with the inertia tensor and its use in expressing the kinetic energy of a rotating body is assumed. Position and orientation of a rigid body can be specified in an inertial “space-frame” K ,or a “body-frame” whose origin is fixed at the centroid of the body and whose axes are fixed in the body. Another inertial frame might be introduced with origin at the centroid and axes aligned with those of K , but for simplicity from now on we ignore centroid motion and assume the centroid remains at rest. The inertial-frame rotational, kinetic energy Trotcan be written in terms of K-space variables as
L
(8.3.1)
where the angular velocity vector w(r) is time-dependent (if the body is tumbling) and the inertia tensor I(t) is time-dependent because the mass distribution varies relative to an inertial frame (if the body is tumbling). In Eq. (8,3.1), the matrix multi-
LIE ALGEBRAIC DESCRIPTION OF RIGID BODY MOTION
273
plications are indicated by the . symbol. This is purely artificial since the spelled-out form
(8.3.2) is the same as is implied by ordinary matrix multiplication. The dot or “dyadic” notation is intended to discourage the interpretation of Zij as having any geometric significance whatsoever-it is preferably regarded as the array of coefficients of a quadratic form since there are quite enough transformation matrices without introducing another one.” The kinetic energy Tmtcan be written alternatively in terms of body variables?* However, 1 is time-independent (because the body is rigid, its particles are not moving relative to one another in the frame): Tmt = %(t) 2
. I .Z(t).
(8.3.3)
The inertia tensor also relates w to angular momentum 1:
I=I-w.
(8.3.4)
Here, as in Eqs. (8.3.1) and (8.3.3), we use dyadic notation in which expressions like these treat I as a matrix that multiplies a vector by the normal rules of matrix multiplication. Eq. (8.3.4) is simplest in the body frame where f is time-independent. Since I is symmetric, it can be diagonalized by the appropriate choice of axes, in which case
(8.3.5) Like other vectors, the angular momentum components in different coordinate frames are related by a rotation matrix 0, as in Eq. (8.1.22). The matrix 0, being orthogonal, can itself be expressed in terms of basis matrices defined in Eq. (4.2.26): J1=
(
0 0 0 0 0 -1 0 1 0
),
52 =
(
0 0 -1
0 1 0 O), 0 0
0 -1 0 0 0
53 = ( 1
0 0) . (8.3.6) 0
These satisfy commutation relations:
190f course, there is a useful “moment of inertia ellipsoid,” which is a kind of geometric significance that I i j has, but this has little to do with the geometry of transformation between coordinate frames. 201t is still true that vectors w and G signify the same amw and are best regarded as simple algebraic abbreviations for the arrays of elements wl, m2,.. . and Zl,E2, . . ..
274
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
+
For rotation through angle about axis
3, defining
C#J
= 43, the formula for 0 is2’
0 = @J.
(8.3.8)
Example 8.3.Z: Let us check this for 53 (which satisfies the equation 5: = -1 after the third row and the third column have been suppressed): e@’3
(+J3)2 (#J3I3 = 1 + 953 -+ +-+... I! 2! 3!
=
cos+
-sin+
After restoring the suppressed rows and columns, when acting on a radius vector, this clearly produces rotation by angle about the z-axis.
+
Problem 8.3.1: Derive Eq. (8.3.8) by “exponentiating”Eq. (4.2.28). As explained above, since the angular velocity is a true vector (actually a pseudovector), the same rotation matrix relates angular velocity vectors w and G: w =o(f)G,
WJ
= ojk(f)Tjk;
(8.3.9)
similarly, the angular momentum vectors 1 and i are related by 1 = o(t)i,
ij
= ojk(t)ik.
(8.3.10)
In terms of 0, known to be an orthogonal matrix, the inertia tensors of E,q. (8.3.1) and (8.3.3) are related by
L o T. L O .
(8.3.11)
To confirm this, substitute it into Eq. (8.3.3) and use Eq. (8.3.9): 2
(8.3.12)
which agrees with Eq. (8.3.1). This manipulation has used the fact, mentioned previously, that the dot operation is performed by standard matrix multiplication. From here on, the dot will be suppressed.
8.3.2. Review of the “Association” of 2 x 2 Matrices to Vectors This section consists mainly of a series of problems that review material developed in Chapter 4,but they should be intelligible even to one who has not studied that material. Furthermore, it is only a digression, as the association between vectors and 2 x 2 matrices that is derived here will not actually be used for the analysis of rigid body motion. The purpose is to refresh your memory of the essential ideas. In the 21Because rotations do not commute, it is not legitimate to factorize this as a product of three exponentials, e-41 ’ ~ & ’ 2 e + 3 ’3, though, of course, angles can be found to make such a factorizationcorrect.
LIE ALGEBRAIC DESCRIPTIONOF RIGID BODY MOTION
275
section following this one, a corresponding association to 3 x 3 matrices will be developed, and that will be the basis for analyzing rigid body motion. A concept to be used again is that of “similarity transformation.” Consider two arrows a and b, and suppose that the pure rotation of a into b is symbolized by b = Ta. Imagine further an azimuthal rotation by some angle (such as one radian) around a; let it be symbolized by 9,.The result of this rotation about a of a vector x is a vector x’ = 9,x. Are we in a position to derive the operator !@b that rotates x by the same angle azimuthally around the vector b? The answer is yes, because we can first rotate b into a using T-I, then rotate around a using @ a , and then rotate back using T. The result is
This is known as a similarity transformation. The rationale for the terminology is that transformations ‘Pa and @b are “similar” transformations around different axes-the word “similar” is used here as it is in the “high school” or “synthetic” Euclidean geometry of rulers and compasses. The same argument would be valid if 9, and @ b designated reflections in planes orthogonal to a and b respectively. Consider the following associations (introduced in Section (4.5.3), where uppercase letters stand for matrices and lowercase letters stand for vectors: x3
x 1 -ix2
X = (xl+ix2
. I = (0~ 1o).
01
-x3 ~
x + X, y + Y,
2
=0 (
-o i~
),
+ x 2~2 ~
2i(x x y) -+ [X,Y]
3
+X
3
=1 (
~3
G
0~
= XY - YX
x . a, (8.3.14)
(8.3.15) (8.3.16)
Though these associations were derived previously, they can be rederived by solving the following series of problems, thereby obviating the need to review that material. In transforming between frames, as for example from inertial frame to body frame, vectors transform by matrix multiplication as in Eqs. (8.1.22),(8.2.2), (8.3.9), and (8.3.10). Because the matrices associated with these vectors themselves represent transformations, their transformations between frames are similarity transformations. This will now be spelled out explicitly. The matrices 01, cr2, ~3 are the Puuli spin matrices; they satisfy the algebraic relations
Problem 8.3.2: Show that (a * a ) ( b . a)= a b l
+ i(a x b) .a.
(8.3.18)
276
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
Problem 8.3.3: Show that (8.3.19)
Shortly, this matrix will be symbolizedby S-l; it appeared previously in Eq.(4.5.24). Problem 8.3.4: According to EQ. (8.3.14), the matrices 0 1 , 02, and a3 are "associated with" the unit vectors el, ez, andZ3, respectively. Derive the following similarity transformations: 0 . -
e
-
+ siny 0 2 , = - sin y q + cosy 0 2 , = cosy 0 1
'+3cqei+3
e-ifu3Dazei+3
,-if03a3ei?iu3
= q.
(8.3.20)
A coordinate frame related to the original frame by a rotation by angle y around the n 3 axis has unit vectors given by cos yZ1 sin yZ2, - sin yZ1 cos ~ $ 2 , and$$ The
+
+
right-hand sides of Eq.(8.3.20) are the matrices "associated" with these unit vectors. This demonstrates, in a special case, that when vectors transform by an ordinary rotation, their associated matrices transform by a similarity transformation based on the corresponding matrix. Problem 8.3.5: Making the association x -+ X zz x .CT, show that
det
1x1 = -x
. x.
Problem 8.3.6: Show that the inverse association X + x can be written in component form as ' 1 xi = -tr(X~j).
2
Problem 8.3.7: Compute X' = e - i ( e / 2 ) " u X e i ( e / 2 ) and ~ . ~ show that x' = 6. x)G
+ cose[(ii x x) x 3 + sin$@ x XI.
Note that this is the same as Eq.(4.5.27). Problem 8.3.8: Show that x-yl=
XY +YX 2
i
and x x y + --[XY]. 2
8.3.3. "Association" of 3 x 3 Matrices to Vectors
We now set up a similar association between vectors x and 3 x 3 matrices X. The use of the same uppercase symbol for both 2 x 2 and 3 x 3 matrices should not be too confusing as only 3 x 3 matrices will occur for the remainder of this chapter.
277
LIE ALGEBRAIC DESCRIPTION OF RIGID BODY MOTION
Using the triplet of matrices J defined in Eq. (8.3.6), the association is
x-+XZX*J.
(8.3.21)
Observe that the matrix infinitesimal rotation operator dt and the angular velocity vector o introduced previously are associated in this sense, and their symbols were chosen appropriately to indicate this.
Problem 8.3.9: Show that with this association
x x y -+ [X,Yl, i.e., vector cross products map to matrix commutators.
Problem 8.3.10: By analogy with Eq. (8.3.20), one anticipates the following equations:
(8.3.22) Prove this result.
Problem 8.3.11: Compute X’ = e-@
[email protected] show that x‘ = ox,
(8.3.23)
where 0 is given by Eq.(8.3.8). A coordinate frame related to the original frame by a rotation by angle 4 around sinq!i$2, -sin&* cos4$2, and the x 3 axis has unit vectors given by cos& g3. The right-hand sides of Eq. (8.3.22) are the matrices “associated” with these unit vectors. This demonstrates, in a special case, that when vectors transform by an ordinary rotation, their associated matrices transform by a similarity transformation based on the corresponding matrix.
+
+
8.3.4. Some Interpretive Comments Concerning Similarity Transformations What is the fallacy in the following line of “reasoning”? If x + X = x . J, and = X . J, and x = OZ, then X = Ox. The correct relation is X = OxO-’, as we now see. Referring to Fig. 8.3.1, consider a vector y(r) evolving in time according to
X+
YO) = A(t)Y(O).
(8.3.24)
Let us regard this as an active transformation, the vectors y(0) and y(t) being geometrically different arrows-the symbol A is mnemonic for “active.” Consider also
278
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
X
FIGURE 8.3.1. Figure illustratingdescriptionof system evolution in two coordinate frames. Most of the discussion does not require the transformationsto be rotations.
another, “barred” coordinate system, related to the previous frame so that
Y=W,
(8.3.25)
or in components,
Our convention is to regard this as a passive transformation, with y and j7 standing for the same geometric arrow-the symbol P is mnemonic for “passive.” Both A and P stand for orthogonal transformations. When described in the “barred” coordinate system, the same time evolution as described in Eq. (8.3.24) is described by
-
YO)=
mm*
(8.3.27)
which serves to define X ( t ) . Combining these equations yields the result
A(t) = PA(r)P-’.
(8.3.28)
One says that operator A has been subjected to a “similarity transformation.” Let us spell out the active transformation in more detail, assuming it is the rotation “associated with” some time-varying vector x ( t ) , according to Eqs. (8.3.8) and (8.3.21): A(t) = ex(‘) = ex(‘)’J, so that y ( t ) = eX(’)’Jy(0).
(8.3.29)
The geometry of this equation is such that the configuration at time r is obtained from the configuration at time 0 by rotating by angle Ix(t)l around axis Z(r). ( x ( t ) is nor, for example, directed along the instantaneous axis of rotation.) Substitution into Eq. (8.3.28) yields
This formula relates finite rotations. The corresponding result for infinitesimal rotations,
LIE ALGEBRAIC DESCRIPTION OF RIGID BODY MOTION
x(r) = P
~ P - ’ ,
279
(8.3.31)
is obtained by making the replacement X + XS and allowing S to be very small. Various questions come to mind: 0 The operators A and P were stated to be active and passive, respectively. This was intended to permit a verbal description of one easily visualized situation to which these formulas apply. Were the active/passiveassignments essential? The answer has to be no. The reader should be able to visualize other pictures where the two transformations have reversed interpretation, or are both interpreted as passive, or both as active. 0 Given its definition in terms of x, namely X = x . J, can we assume = X. J? (Here the absence of an overhead bar on J is appropriate because, by convention, the matrix elements of (51, 52, 53) are the same in all frames.) For the answer to be yes, Eq. (8.3.27),
x
y(t)
= ,%r).JY (0) I
(8.3.32)
would have to be true. Since this is the same result as is obtained by applying Eq. (8.3.29) in the barred frame, the result = X .J is confirmed. 0 In traditional tensor analysis, inrrinsic geometric equalities are represented by demanding consistent indices on frame-dependent components-this is manifest covariance. In traditional vector analysis, intrinsic geometric equalities are represented by boldface equations such as c = a x b. Our policy of maintaining both of these conventions is greatly strained at this point; it has forced us, for example, to swallow the proposition that the quantities y and symbolize the same arrow. This is not entirely academic since, when one gets down to actually calculation using components, it is essential to be clear what frame is to be used. The use of group theoretic methods, in which vectors are associated with other objects, compounds the notational difficulties just discussed. As long as only one coordinate frame is in use, there is no problem. Introduction of other frames brings in complication. When symmetry considerations suggest system invariance under certain passive coordinate transformations, and this is exploited by coordinate transformation, the result is further abstraction.
x
8.3.5. Rigid Body Equations in Rotating Frame We now apply the associations defined in the previous section to the generalized Newton’s equation derived before that. For reasons that will only become clear gradually, rather than studying the evolution of displacement vector x, we will study the evolution of its associated “displacement matrix” X. - The fixed-frame and rotating-frame “displacement matrices” are X = x J and X = X . J, respectively; they are related by
x = oRoT.
(8.3.33)
280
GAUGE-INVARIANT MECHANICS
As we have seen, X and % have geometric interpretations as transformation matrices for infinitesimal rotation around the vectors x and iz. This conforms with the
remark made previously that the operators X and are related by “similarity transformation.” By analogy with our earlier treatment, the “time derivative operator” % should be defined so that “velocity” matrices are related by
-
v = OVOT = O(D1X)OT, (8.3.34) where the parentheses indicate that 5 does not operate on the final factor OT .Dif) 0 yields ferentiating Eq. (8.3.33) with respect to t and using ( d / d r ) ( O T O=
d v = x = -(OXOT) dt = O(k
+ okoT + oXOT
= OXoT
+ [n,%])Of,
(8.3.35)
This conforms with Eq. (8.3.34) if
- -
V = DrX = x + [a,x]
d or 5 = - + [a,.].
(8.3.36)
dt
x
The . in [a,-1 is to be replaced by the quantity being operated upon?2 Yet another dispensation is required in that the symbol & has acquired a new meaning that can be inferred only from the context.23 We can also define a matrix L(’) associated with angular momentum I(’) = x ( ~ x) m%(’) defined in Eq. (8.3.4). Here, in anticipation of analyzing multiparticle systems, the notation has been generalized by introducing superscript (i), which is a particle index. The space and moving frame angular momenta “matrices” for the i th particle are given by
L(i) = m ( i ) [ X ( i ) VW], ,
f;(i)
= OTL(i)O= m ( i ) [ X ( i ) --(i) v I
I.
(8.3.37)
Newton’s torque equation (8.2.36). expressed in arbitrary frame as in Eq. (8.2.40), relative to a point on the axis of rotation, becomes -(j)
DtL
-A(i) - L + [a,P]= T?
(8.3.38)
Expressed here in “associated” matrices, this is the gauge-invariant equation of rotation of a rigid body that consists of a single point mass m(i) subject to applied torque. Since the centroid of a one-particle system is coincident with the mass itself, this equation so far gives a useful and complete description only for a spherical pen”With n regarded as a member of a Lie algebra, the operator [bl, .] is known as its &joint operator adbl = [bl, .I. We refrain from using this notation because formal results from the theory of Lie Algebra will not be. used. 23A computer scientist would say 4 is “overloaded”;a mathematician might call it “abuse of notation“ (but use it nevertheless).
281
LIE ALGEBRAIC DESCRIPTIONOF RIGID BODY MOTION
dulum, with the mass attached to the origin by a light rod (or for an unconstrained cheerleader’s baton, which amounts to the same thing). One wishes to employ Eq. (8.3.38) to obtain ?)
and eventually the evolution
of the angular momentum. This is simplest to do in the body frame, where ?) vanishes. Working in that frame, where it is also true that Ti(’) = [Sa, and using Eq. (8.3.37), one obtains a formula for the “angular momentum” in terms of the “position” (and mass) of the particle:
!8i)],
-L (i)
-(i) = -m (.”[X
1
- ( i ) , Sall. [X
(8.3.39)
As required, this has dimensions [ML2/T]. Substituting it into Eq.(8.3.38), Newton’s torque equation becomes
(8.3.40) This equation will be exploited in the next section. There has been a large investment in establishing formalism. Eq. (8.3.40) represents the first return on this “overhead.” With a remarkable thrice-nested matrix commutation, the torque is augmented by a fictitious torque that accounts for the rotation of the moving frame relative to the inertial frame. 8.3.6. The Euler Equations for a Rigid Body
Consider a rigid body made up of masses m ( i ) .Any one of these masses m(i) can be considered as contributingL(’) (given by Eq. (8.3.39)) to the total angular momentum of the body, and hence an amount I(’) to the moment of inertia tensor: (8.3.41) Here the (per particle) “moment of inertia” tensor has been generalized to be a function that generates the “angular momentum” I linearly from the “angular velocity” 0.Then the total moment of inertia tensors and the total angular momentum are
Since the moment of inertia is a symmetric tensor, we know it can be diagonalized, yielding three orthogonal principal axes and corresponding principal moments of inertia, call them Ti. In the body frame, these are independent of time. The same algebra ensures the existence of principal axes determined by our new, generalized, moment-of-inertia tensor (see Problem 1.2.15). The argument of I, namely n, can itself be expanded in terms of the “basis” matrices Ji defined in Eq. (8.3.6), and each of these, being in turn associated with an angular rotation vector aligned with its respective axis, is the transformation matrix for an infinitesimal rotation around that axis. Superposition is applicable because 1 is a linear operator. Supposing that these
282
GAUGE-INVARIANTMECHANICS
axes were judiciously chosen to start with, to be these principal axes we must have
Clearly it is advantageous to express 61 in terms of components along these axes:
(8.3.44)
61 = T ZiJi. Y i=l
Of course, the coefficients are the body-frame, principal-axis components of the intstantaneous angular velocity of the rigid body. The total angular momentum is then given by
Substitution into Newton's Eq. (8.3.38) (with vanishing torque for simplicity) yields
j-1
j=1
J
i. i
since the J j satisfy the commutation relations of Eq. (8.3.7).The equations of motion become
(8.3.47) and cyclic permutations. Once again, these are the Euler equations. Once the machinery was in place their derivation was remarkably brief.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
References 1. K. R. Symon. Mechanics, 3rd ed., Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1971. 2. D. Kleppner and R. J. Kleppner, An Introduction to Mechanics, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1973, p. 364. 3. D. H. Sattinger and 0. L. Weaver, Lie Groups and Algebras with Applications to Physics, Geometry, and Mechanics. Springer-Verlag, New York, 1993.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
283
References for Further Study Section 8.1.3 D. Kleppner and R. J. Kleppner, An Introduction to Mechanics, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1973, p. 355. K. R. Symon, Mechanics, 3rd ed., Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1971, p. 271.
Section 8.1.4 V. I. Arnold, V.V. Kozlov, and A. I. Neishtadt, Mathematical Aspects of Classical and Celestial Mechanics, 2nd ed., Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1997, p. 69. G. Pascoli, Elements de Mkcanique Ckleste,Masson, Paris, 1997, p. 150.
Section 8.3 D. H. Sattinger and 0. L. Weaver, Lie Groups and Algebras with Applications to Physics, Geomety, and Mechanics,Springer-Verlag.New York, 1993.
GEOMETRIC PHASES
9.1. THE FOUCAULT PENDULUM
Seen by every one who visits a science museum, the Foucault pendulum is one of the best experiments of all time. It rarely gets the credit it deserves. It is cheap to construct (though it behaves improperly if it is implemented too cheaply) and requires no more sophisticated data acquisition apparatus, even for quantitatively accurate measurements, than a patient “nurse” willing to look at it every few hours for a few days.’ Yet these observations have profound implications. Trusting mechanics, the (not so) profound implications concern the earth’s state of rotation. Trusting that the earth rotates, the (very) profound implications concern the most fundamental aspects of mechanics. If one starts the pendulum swinging at, say, noon, say parallel to a nearby wall, then leaves and comes back a few hours later, the pendulum is no longer swinging parallel to the wall. “It’s the earth’s rotation,” you say. “I’ll check it when the earth has made a complete revolution, so everything will be back where it started.” Coming back at noon the next day, you find that everything is back except the pendulum. The v2
‘If the base has a readable scale permitting one to note the pendulum’s advance over a couple of hours, one can check the performance of the setup to perhaps 10-percent accuracy. If one is prepared to spend all day at the science museum, one can do better yet. 2The most professional setup I have seen is at the Science Museum in London, England, where the co-latitude is 38.5’ and the plane of oscillation rotates 11.8°/h0ur.
204
THE FOUCAULT PENDULUM
285
FIGURE 9.1 .l.Illustration of parallel transport of an ideally mounted pendulum around a line of latitude. Note that the fixed frameis specificto the particular latitude along which the pendulum is carried. The support point is B.
wall is presumably back (the earth’s orbit around the sun introduces only an angular advance of 2n/365) but the pendulum is not.3 Since the Foucault pendulum at rest is nothing other than the plumb bob that was analyzed ad nauseam in the previous chapter, we know that it hangs down along the direction of eflective gravity and not precisely aimed toward the earth’s center. As was anticipated there, we take the resting orientation of the pendulum as defining the effective direction of the acceleration of gravity &c and continue to use the traditional symbol g for its magnitude. Once this is done, we can from the