E-Governance
V.M.Rao
ABD PUBLISHERS Jaipur, India
ISBN: 978-81-8376-114-7
First Puhlisnt>d 2007
ABD PUBLISHERS, B-46, Natraj Nagar, Imliwala Phatak, Jaipur - 302005 (Rajasthan) INDIA Phone:0141-2594705,Fax:0141-2597527 e-mail:
[email protected] website: www.abdpublisher.com
© Rest>rved
Typeset by: Shivangi Computers 267, lO-B-Scheme, Opp. Narayan Niwas, Gopalpura By Pass Road, Jaipur-302018
Printed at: Raidhani Printers, DI;>lhi
All Rights are Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording. scanning or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the copyright owner. Responsibility for the facts stated, opinions expressed, conclusions reached and plagiarism, if any, in this volume is entirely that of the Author, according to whom the matter encompassed in this book ha;o, been origmally created! edited and resemblance with ailY such publicatwll may be incidental. The Publisher bears no responSIbility for them, Wh,1tsoever
Contents
1. E-Governance: An Introduction
1
2. E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
8
3. The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
107
4. E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
145
5. E-Governance in India: Vision and Strategies
174
6. Developments and Implementation
of E-Governance 7. Modified IT Act 2000
Index
199 252 314
"This page is Intentionally Left Blank"
1 E-Governance: An Introduction
Meaning E-Governance or electronic governance may be defined as delivery of government services and information to the public using electronic means. Such means of delivering information is often referred to as information technology or 'IT' in short form. Use of IT in government facilitates an efficient, speedy and transparent process for disseminating information to the public and other agencies, and for performing government administration activities. The term governance may be described as the process by which society steers itself. In this process, the interactions among the State, Private Enterprise and Civil Society are being increasingly conditioned and modified through the influence of information and communication technologies (lCTs), constituting the phenomenon of e-Governance. Examples of these shifts in dynamics are exemplified by: (1) the use of the Internet by Civil Society, NGOs and
professional associations to mobilize opinion and influence decision-making proo'sses that affect them,
2
E-Governance: An Introduction
(2) the increasing electronic delivery of government and commercial services and information, (3) the electronic publication of draft legislation and statements of direction for public feedback, and (4) on the infrastructure side, the increased adoption of e-enabled community centres, the liberalization of telecommunication markets and trends towards webenabled mobile telephony and digital television are facilitating this evolution.
Concept and Scope E-Governance is thus a wider concept than e-Government which is the use of ICTs in the dissemination and services of government. Following the COMNET IT/UNESCO Global Survey on On-line Governance published in 2000 (UNESCO document CII-2000/WS/09), the Commonwealth Netw'ork of Information Technology for Development (COMNET-IT), in association with and with the financial support of UNESCO, has developed national profiles detailing current status alld developments in this area. Whilst impacts of e-Governance in the commercial, NGO and professional areas are covered in these studies, the main focus centres around specific government initiatives, such as: the development of cyberlaws, the liberalization of telecommttnications, plans for e-Government, plans for the development of an Info-Society, the deployment of community e-Centres, instances of public feedback to statements of direction, draft legislation and so on, and (7) web sites of Government agencies, particularly if these offer value beyond a public relations image.
(1)
(2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
In this book, we use the terms Ie-Governance' and Ie-Government' instead of 'online governance' and 'on-line government' because we are effectively convened with all ICTs, not only application of remote access through telecommunications.
E-Governance: An Introduction
3
e-Governance is not only about introducing or using technological tools. It is fundamentally about a change in mindset and work culture in order to integrate government . processes and functions to serve the citizens better. Information and communication technologies can only enhance the transformation of work culture by serving a variety of ends: better delivery of government services to citizens, improved government interactions with business and industry, citizen empowerment through access to information and participation for decision-making, and more efficient government management. In this process, it is crucial that the capacity of government to be open to criticism as well as the application of a new social contract, between all stakeholders, confirming a shared responsibility on the transformation processes. The respect for human rights and freedom of expression is essential to promote and maintain public participation in public consultation spaces. This implies that government personnel have to learn to network and to place people in the centre of the political process. So, the effectiveness of leT in government is closely r,elated with the capacity of governments to induce a culture of change placing networking within its institutions as instrumental to transparency and knowledge exchange and creation. It forces a rethinking of the way hierarchical structures are placed. The transition to a more horizontal government structure, where integration of functions plays a greater role, takes time since the main players need to change attitudes and behaviour as they acquire new skills and knowledge that make them confident in the work culture. According to recent data, there is a close relationship between levels of infrastructure development, education, democrati¥tion, political leadership and commitment to the principles of good governance and the level and quality of e-Governance implanted in the countries. These are strong indicators of e-readiness and the opportunity cost of such endeavour. The resulting benefit can be less corruption, increased transparency, greater convenience, efficiency, revenue growth, and/ or cost reductions, as well as increased legitimacy.
4
E-Covernance: An Introduction
Use for Interaction with Public Traditionally, the interaction between a citizen and a government agency takes place in a government office. With emerging information and communication technologies it is pOSSible to locate service centres closer to the clients. Such centres may consist of an unattended kiosk in the government agency, a service kiosk located close to the client outside the government agency, or the use of a personal computer at home or office. In all the cases the public traditionally looks for information and services addressing his/her needs and in both cases relevance, quality and efficiency are of paramount importance. Therefore, the establishment of e-Governance requires a good knowledge of the needs that exist in the society and that can be offered using ICT. One of the reasons why e-Commerce is well positioned even in countries where e-Governance still lags behind, is that customers know what products and services they want and sellers know what and how they can deliver those. The development of e-Governance includes (1) publishing, (2) interaction, (3) transact. These activities aim at: broadening access to government information such as laws, regulations and data; increasing public participation in decision-making through, for example, the publishing of e-mail addresses of government officials and on-line forums; making government services more readily available to the public through e-Filing of government documents, online permits. To date, most effort, in e-Governance, is centred on publishing and not in the subsf'quent phases of interaction and transaction. Governments, particularly in developing countries face limited resources to move fast in e-Governance, so a strong partnership between the public, government, business and the civil society is instrumental in determining the expected outcomes and the effectiveness of e-Governance. The term e-Governance refers to the process of using information technology for automating both the internal operations of the government and its external interactions with citizens and other businesses. Automation of internal operations reduces their cost and improves their response time while at
E-Governance: An Introduction
5
the same time allowing government processes to be more elaborate in order to increase their effectiveness. Automation of interactions with citizens reduces the overhead for both the government and the citizens, thus creating value for the economy. As an example, consider an online service that can be provided by the transport department for the renewal of driving licences, currently a leading e-Governance application in India. At present, the application works as follows: The applicant visits the regional transport office, completes the renewal form on paper, and submits the form to a clerk, along with a photograph, proof of residence, proof of date of birth, and transaction fee. The clerk processes the application form manually. The applicant typically has to wait in the office for several hours before receiving the renewed driving licence. Besides the inconvenience to the applicant, previous traffic violations are not properly verified, and there is no provision for easy management of expired licence records. With the deployment of the e-Governance framework, we expect the following improvements. In a typical scenario, persons visiting the state government portal can choose to renew their driving licences by completing the renewal forms online. In the future, the information could be digitally signed by the citizen to ensure nonrepudiation using the public key infrastructure of the e-Governance framework, possibly managed by the government. The solution verifies the applicants digital signature, residential address, and traffic violation records in real time using the citizen records maintained in the framework and support for inter-agency collaboration. It then requests the applicant to make online payment for the renewal fees by means of credit card, debit card, etc. On verifying the payment details with a payment server, the application is added to the list of driving licence applications to be approved, and a notification is sent to the approving authority in the government. The approving authority logs on to the state portal, views the pending renewal applications, and approves or rejects them. Approved applications are automatically forwarded to the licence printing application. The driving licence card is then sent to the applicant by courier. The system periodically archives or
6
E-Governance: An Introduction purges the renewal applications and archives the expired driving licence records. The accepted and rejected applications may have to be purged on different schedules.
E-Governance Framework The design and development of such complex solutions poses significant challenges. One such challenge is that in current development environments, the application developers have to work at a low level of abstraction. This means taking care of low-level issues such as interprocess messaging, tools integration, and data modelling while defining the application logic. Similarly, solution reconfiguration and management requires the solution administrator to have a detailed understanding of the application logic, making the task timeconsuming and error-prone. Handling these challenges effectively requires highly skilled and experienced information technology (IT) professionals, increasing development costs for effective e-Governance solutions. Solution administrators typically lack these IT skills, rendering change management impossible. In solutions developed to date, each e-Governance solution has customized existing products to address an individual government agency requirement. However, this might not always be the most economical way to develop a solution. In most industries, around 85 per cent of the processes are same across companies within that industry. A similar fraction of the processes can be expected to be similar across different government solutions. Clearly, it is desirable to develop these processes once and then reuse them for many solutions. This is also likely to be true for data models, user interfaces, etc. For example, the address verification process in the driving licence renewal solution considered above can be reused while developing a passport renewal solution. Similarly, the traffic violation record verification process can be offered as a service to insurance businesses to be reused in a car insurance solution. Lack of information (metadata) on available processes and components and difficulty in customizing these for a specific need currently hinder their reuse for multiple solutions. One can readily conclude from the preceding discussion that there
E-Governance: An Introduction
7
is a need for a framework that can simplify the development, deployment, and management of e-Governance solutions. The e-Governance framework proposed in this chapter addresses the requirements identified in the preceding discussion by: (1) Enabling modelling of a hierarchy of building blocks
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5) (6)
that can be used to abstract government process to a higher semantic level. Enabling specification of workflow for government processes independent of standards; the platform takes care of generating the deployable solution that conforms to the appropriate standards. Enabling reuse of effort across solutions by providing tools to develop generic, parameterized applications or processes that can be stored in a repository with appropriate metadata and effectively reused by various applications with appropriate customization. Extending programming models to specify the customization points in an application or solution during development, and intuitive interfaces to enable modification of solutions easily after deployment without the need for the business user to modify the application source code. Extending programming models to simplify specification of multilingual and multidevice interfaces. Providing tools to author the wrappers for the legacy applications and workflows integrating multiple applications to automate processes spanning several government agencies. The current framework prototype described in this chapter will evolve with customer engagements. The approach is to maximize the reuse of available tools and middleware. In the initial stages, the focus of the effort is on the Indian e-Governance market; however, the platform can be extended to suit the needs of other countries as well.
2 E-Goveman.ce Practices: A Global Perspective
Introduction In order to achieve declared administrative and social goals, pervasive harnessing of ICTs is being brought to give a push to public service reform. Some of the key features driving this reform can be identified as: (1) Public pressures for increased accountability and value
for money in public service operations. (2) International agency and peer pressures for progress in areas such as civil rights and effective financial management. (3) Progressive decentralization and devolution from Central Government to regional offices, local authorities and in some instances, contracted private sector serviceproviders. (4) Increased public awareness and expectations resulting from the pervasiveness of the media, both national and international. There may be some variations in the perceptions, if not the definition, of c-Governancc and its manifestations. Whilst it is
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
9
generally acknowledged that the term implies an electronic interface to the citizen, there may be a danger of attributing an exclusive interpretation to this scenario. Such a narrow interpretation risks turning e-Governance into an expensive 'veneer' or dressing, over inherent inefficiencies and redundant processes. The emerging consensus viewpoint is that the real challenge in administrative systems reform is the inculcation of attitudes that acknowledge data and information to be a corporate resource-and therefore shareable and subject to standardsas well as introducing process and regulatory changes that fly in the face of established hierarchical decision-making structures. Also, since resources, particularly with emerging or less developed economies, are at a premium, sustainable rates of change as well as rate of pay back on investments for e-Governance are an issue. Whilst sections or sectors of the economy may be clamouring for the facilities of e-Governance, large proportions of the population perceive conflicting priorities and are not likely to be in a position to exploit these facilities if they existed (due to affordability, access, language and literacy barriers). In this regard, the potential role of intermediaries assumes greater significance. In many societies, however, the progressive strengthening of these institutions (such as local councils or committees and NGOs) is itself a slow maturing process. Deliberate programmes that recognize the potential contribution of these intermediaries to complement the over stretched and at any rate inadequate structures of central government merit development. For government, the mere transfer of back-office processes to an electronic customer interface, no matter how effective the information-management and the process re-engineering, risks a limited pay back unless contexted within national cross-sectoral processes as well as the 'information' of society through sectoral policies and facilitation measures for the harneSSing of ICTs. Trade facilitation, for instance, could be interpreted restrictively if limited to a streamlining of customs and possibly some other authorizing departments. Handling agents, traders, banks and insurance companies all form part of the national system that
10
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
cuts across both government and private sector. Similarly, for health services and other areas (GIS, etc.). The challenge for coordinated development and improved governance therefore is not limited to the traditional boundaries of government. Arguably, the private sector-and thence civil society-might have an equal stake in the definition and implementation of ICT enabled systems. In the inculcation of an ICT-orientation in the various socio-economic sectors, only the more mature governments see a role in transition-beyond the provision of efficient administrative systems-to a proactive catalytic and facilitation role, engaging society and private sector in partnerships for the innovative application of ICTs to commercial and self-help activity. A good example is Canada's franchising of arrangements extending to its 8,000 public access centres for commercial or social interests. On the infrastructure front, the liberalization of telecommunications progresses at a steady pace, but a number of consolidation issues lag behind. For example, in several instances, the lack of a national Internet exchange subjects an inordinate amount of traffic (and revenues) to international operators. Interestingly, one comes across several instances of countries articulating, as part of their vision, the opportunity of becoming a regional hub for ICT expertise, thereby ignoring or perhaps playing down the fact that the sustainability of quality services to the meet of exponentially growth of national demands is a major issue in itself. Also, in an increasingly networked world, every country is a hub, with multiple external and internal interfaces. Perhaps the reality is that hubbing is an intrinsic prerequisite for economic and social performance in the emerging world order. Islands and Small States seem to constitute a special case, with unique challenges and opportunities. The traditional issues of economic vulnerability and geographical isolation are exacerbated in the digital era by lack of critical mass in terms of service provision and sweeping globalization. And yet these countries are facing the greatest opportunity, in relative terms. Government in these environments is often effectively a single-layer central
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
11
administration, and there is an opportunity to tap into wider virtual markets. Access to information and education through leTs is potentially vast, relative to the national supply, and planned seamless information and technical infrastructure building are within relatively easy reach. All this enables a leap-frogging of social and economic development into the digital age, given the political and managerial leadership and foresight.
(A) Botswana Background Botswana was formerly British protectorate of Bechuanaland and adopted its new name upon independence in 1966. Theeconomy, closely tied to South Africa's, is dominated by cattle raising and mining. It is situated in Southern Africa just north of South Africa. It is completely landlocked and has a semiarid climate, warm in winter and hot in summer. The land is very rich in natural resources and the terrain is predominantly flat to gently rolling tableland with the Kalahari Desert in the southwest. Botswana has a population of about 1.5 million and is a parliamentary republic. The GDP in 1999 was 5.7 billion dollars with a real growth of 6.5 per cent and 47 per cent of the population below the poverty line. The economy is structured with agriculture still providing a livelihood for more than 80 per cent of the population but supplies only about 50 per cent of food needs and accounts for only 3 per cent of GOP. Subsistence farming and cattle raising predominate. The sector is plagued by erratic rainfall and poor soils. Diamond mining and tourism also are important to the economy. Substantial mineral deposits were found in the 1970s and the mining sector grew from 25 per cent of GOP in 1980 to 38 per cent in 1998. Unemployment officially is 21 per cent but unofficial estimates place it closer to 40 per cent. The Orapa 2000 project should have been the main force behind continued economic expansion. The early history of the people and territory of Botswana is still being uncovered, as archaeologists sift evidence from legend. Indications of settled communities go back as far as the
12
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
fourth century. Before that, the territory was sparsely populated by hunter-gatherer communities of the San people. Major settlements took place in the early 16th century. British missionaries arrived in the 19th century. Botswana Paramount Chiefs Bathoen, Sebele and Khama 'the Great', sought British Government protection against the Boer threat in the last quarter of the 19th century. Today Botswana is working hard to strengthen its ICT network yet the statistics show that there is still considerable work which needs to be carried out. 1999 statistics show that Botswana had 77 telephone mainlines per lOOO population and 31 personal computers for every 1000 population. It also had 9 Internet hosts for every 10,000 people.
Use of E-Governance The size and population of the country are two aspects that may present some challenge in the deployment of Information and Communication Technology in Botswana more so since return on investment tends to increase with population density. The other challenges faced by the country are similar to those faced by other developing countries in that it is faced with rural-urban population migration and is largely dependant on expatriates in key professional positions. For the acquisition of ICT facilities the country is also highly dependant on the developed countries. In addition to this, David Magang, Botswana's Works, Transport and Communications minister said that making the Internet available is one of the biggest challenges currently faced by the country. He said that although the Internet market is fully liberalized in Botswana, most of the users are currently corporate institutions and government organizations and that Internet penetration is low both in urban and rural areas, and it should be the stakeholders, including the government, who should promote the use of Internet more in rural areas. The possible reasons for this besides a poor infrastructure is the high cost on Internet connectivity including connection charges and subscription fees and telephone charges for dial-up access. He said a preliminary estimate indicates that to date (May 2001), Botswana has 30,000 Internet users compared to 10,000 in 1999.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
13
And currently there are nine licensed Internet service providers and six licensed data gateway service providers. Recently, the Botswana Telecommunications Corporation (BTC) set up an ISP called Botsnet, mainly with the idea of providing service to Botswana companies that want to get to the Internet. They have set up standard mail and a Botsnet Web server. They offer some special features, like online registration, access to HTML Mail, and a way to search the Botswana telephone directory. Botsnet intends to expand to give users some news channels, a chat board and even a way to set up personal Websites. They will also be offering e-Commerce services. Botswana has an established national development planning process. In 1999 Botswana had no national ICT strategy but the government had its ICT Vision 2003 which basically said that: (1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Botswana will have made significant and positive steps towards becoming a regional leader in the exploitation and utilization of IT within its government administration. In addition, government will have played the leading role in helping the private sector to embrace IT in the interests of national objectives. Quality IT systems will be implemented in key government sectors where competitive advantage can be gained over regional nations or where increased revenues or savings can be realized to help fund the IT Vision. IT will be supported by a workforce whith has been well trained to carry out its duties and r~ponsibilities in IT. In addition, senior officers will be well versed in the critical issues for successful IT management. A Data Communications Infrastructure will be in place to allow ministries and departments to share information and to transfer data electronically amongst themselves in a secure and managed environment. IT systems will be in use in key areas to improve government services to the private sector and the public and to reduce instances of excessive queuing and wasted time.
14
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective (6) Common IT systems will be in place across all ministries for the management of key resources and activities. (7) Each ministry will be developing and generating its own relevant information databases, providing decisionmakers with up-to-date and accurate management information through computer workstations. In addition, ministries will be working closely together 00 IT initiatives of mutual interest. (8) Each ministry will be largely in control of running its own IT systems, with its own dedicated IT support unit working closely with GCB, and will operate within a framework of agreed policies, standards and guidelines. (9) Government will be interchanging information electronically with local authorities, the private sector and other external bodies in a managed and secure environmen t. (10) The volume of paperwork flowing between ministries and physically stored in registries will he reduced and greater emphasis will be placed on the electronic storage of data and its subsequent retrieval on computer networks. (11) A Botswana Centre for Geographic Information will be established to make best use of existing information and to optimize future information sharing and management. (12) Government will be working closely with the private IT services sector to ensure quality and continuity of service in the required areas and will appraise them of future plans to help them develop their business activities.
In order for the successful implementation of the above strategy to happen a number of issues would need to be addressed successfully. These issues include: (1) Getting the top management into adequate level of ICT awareness to ensure meaningful participation in the implementation.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective (2) (3) (4) (5)
15
Setting implementation priorities and time scales. Estimating implementation costs and benefits. Assessing the staffing implications. Ensuring alignment of this strategy to the National and Local government ICT strategy.
Government has no plans at present to interact electronically with the citizens of Botswana. The prevailing view in the public sector is that while Botswana has an enviable telecommunications infrastructure both in terms of reach and diversity of products, there is insufficient access to the technologies (Internet) by the ordinary person on the street to justify the cost of investing in the development of e-portals as a key method of reaching the citizen for the delivery of service. This is borne out by the low (compared to USA and the first world) telephone density and even lower access tool (Personal Computer) density. For now, civil servants believe that using traditional methods of service delivery whether these are counter services, or any other public sector service, are more appropriate to reach the optimum number of citizens. Development of e-Governance has tended to be restricted to back office systems targeted at specific groups, e.g., development of comprehensive business support systems for the members of parliament. There are, however, plans to develop infrastructure (Government Data Network) to support normal back office systems, as well as high bandwidth applications such as distance learning, telemedicine, and appropriate use of videoconferencing in the next two years. The plans are approved for implementation in the current development plan of the country but have not been given much pUblicity as the clients of the infrastructure are intended to be mainly government departments. Plans are also afoot to provide a wide cov~rage of access to the Internet in the public school system as government realizes that for its citizens to compete effectively in the global village, the nation must start to invest on availing technology skills right from the primary school level.
16
E-Governance Practices: A Global Per~pective
(B) Canada Background Canada is part of the North American continent and is considered to be a world leader in the field of innovation in the Public Sector and Government. To paraphrase the Clerk of the Privy Council and Secretary to Cabinet in his speech at the Assistant Deputy Ministers Forum, when it comes to a state that you start receiving e-mail from your mother at work you realize that there is no turning back now. The steps towards e-Governance in Canada struted in the late 1980's through the use of e-mail.in1991-92 government departments and programmes had their first web presence, in 1994 the Information Highway Advisory Committee (lHAC) was set up. IHAC had a mandate to assist gove:t;nment in understanding how information management and information technology is changing economies and societies. The IHAC tabled reports and recommendations in September 1995 and September 1997 and these documents have guided government decision making and have enable Canada to emerge as a world leader in the adoption and use of information management and information technology. In 1995 Green Lane was established on the Information Highway, in 1997 the vision for connectedness was set up, in 1998 the six pillar connectedness agenda was launched on a national level. The Speech from the Throne in October 1999 set a goal for the Government of Canada to become a "model user of information technology and the Internet" and "by 2004 Canada should be known as the Government most connected to its citizens around the world. By this time Canadians should be able to access all government information and services online at the time and place of their choosing".
Use of E-Govemance A lot has been done but where is Canada today and where does it want to go? The Public Service of Canada needs to get better at digitizing information. The websites belonging to federal departments and agencies are not always well organized or
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
17
linked to each other. It needs to begin making inroads to modernize service delivery and to start delivering services in manners that make sense to Canadians and it also needs to start looking at innovative manners to implement and use eGovernance such as for example the use of online auctions as happened for the two bands of the Radio Spectrum or the Leadership Network site (http://www.leadership.gc.ca). The way forward is to try and bring all the parts into one coherent whole and this is being done through two main initiatives. The first called Service Canada aims for a single window access to government services, by telephone, the web and face-to-face with multiple channels always as a back door. The second called Government Online is an SF!' initiative in which by December 2000 all departments had an online presence with information on programmes, services and key forms. A comprehensive list can be found on http://canada.gc.ca/ depts/ major / depind_e.html which gives direct links to the primary websites of Government of Canada departments and agencies, as well as links to websites maintained by organizations for which various departments and agencies are responsible. What are the benefits to Canadians? In its adoption of Information and Communication Technology in the process of government, Canada looked towards its citizens to help in the design of e-Governance. This methodology is characterized as citizen centred government and it is a vision that recognizes the different ways that people interact with their government: Citizens as taxpayers who expect value and results. (2) Citizens as clients who expect accessible, quality services. (3) Citizens as participants in the democratic process.
(1)
It is the challenge of the Canadian Government to enable its citizens to explore all the three aspects of their citizenship. The approach to achieve this goal is outlined in the document Strategic Directions for Information Management and Information Technology. This document outlines, in a comprehensive manner, the direction and opportunities geared toward a more collaborative, integrated model of delivering government services and programmes. It outlines a series of
18
E-Governance PI1cdces: A Global Perspective
priorities that will lever government's significant Information Management-Information Technology investments towards a more integrated, collaborative model of government. Each priority area is supported by detailed workplans with clearly defined milestones. In facing the challenge the Canadian Government analyzed the changing landscape in which it operates. A number of principles emerge. The first is that technology, globalization and the rise of the digital economy are changing our world. The second is that in tandem with the rise of the digital economy is the growing understanding of the citizen as the principal driver of change. The third is the recognition that in the digital economy knowledge is a key resource and how well knowledge is created, managed, shared, transmitted and stored is of growing importance. The fourth is an emphasis on how Information Management and Information Technology as key strategic resources are changing the human resources landscape. This takes us to a second issue which is that of the change in governing in a digital world. It is the vision of the Canadian government to allow citizens to choose how they wish to access information and services. Electronic service delivery should be accessible to all people around the country irrespective of their income, language or disability. To enable this electronic service delivery the federal government has devised a strategy. The key elements of this strategy are: (1) a government-wide information management-information technology infrastructure that provides a secure and trusted environment to connect with citizens and the private sector, (2) a world-class government information management-information technology workforce and (3) successful adoption of integrated g-overnance frameworks to guide information management-information technology investments, manage risks and set standards. In discussing the above one should not get the impression that the Government of Canada is still beginning to provide services through electronic means. It offers an impressive range of services and information online such as those shown below: The Canada Site is a gateway to all federal websites and provides one stop access to electronic directories and many
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
19
commonly requested forms and publications. This site receives as many as 7 million hits each month. The Canadian Health Network brings together the resources of over 460 Canadian health-related organizations to provide members of the public and health intermediaries access to a unified source of valid, Internet-based health information, geared especially towards Canadians. The National Job Bank which is available at kiosks across the country and through the Internet. This job bank lists job openings in communities across Canada. Other such services are The Electronic Labour Exchange, CanLearn Interactive which is a resource to explore education and training opportunities and Youth Resources Network Canada which brings together career information, programmes and services for young people aged 15 to 30. EFILE which allows tax professionals who are approved electronic filers to prepare and deliver income tax returns electronically. There are various other services such as travel and culture with sites for the Consular Services, the National Film Board of Canada Collection ONLINE, Access to Canada's Heritage Collections. In addition there are also environment related resources such as Green Lane and Millennium Eco-Communities Website and resources related to services for business such as Canada Business Service Centres, Incorporating a Business, Patent Applications, Export Information and Export Services. Looking ahead there are a number of other services being developed like a revamp of the Canada Site, a national health information highway, the application for benefits and all related transactions, filing of taxes, online passport renewal, national park reservations, one-stop access to information on the environment and others. The Canadian Government had to reach the following targets: Up-to-date, accurate, bilingual information on key pro~ammes and services available online. (2) Commonly used forms available to download and print.
(1)
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
20
(3) The ability to contact departments through the Canada
Site. (4) The Canada Site will continue to be revamped and organized around citizen needs and topics of interest. A technology and policy framework will be in place that protects the security and privacy of Canadians in their electronic dealings with government. Whereas in the next few years the following are expected: (1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
deliv~rables
Key federal programmes and services-the ones that matter most to Canadians-will be available online. Clients will be able to complete secure and interactive transactions online. Secure and interactive electronic forms will be available. Technical and content support will be provided through various help services. The service will have predictable response times based on published service standards. An easy to use, advanced search capability will be available on the Government of Canada portal and all federal department and agency websites. Clients will be able to find information and services even if the exact name of the programme or service is unknown. Common search principles with similar navigation rules will be implemented across all federal websites, and all sites will have a common look and feel. One-stop access points (or portals) available through the Canada Site, with information and services organized according to types of activity, areas of interest and common citizen needs. Plans are already underway to develop portals for seniors, consumers, aboriginals, the environment, and innovation resources for small- and medium-sized enterprises. Innovative partnerships. The Government On-Line initiative will place increased emphasis on online service delivery partnerships with provinces, territories, municipalities, businesses, volunteer organizations and international partners.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
21
In the beginning of this profile a statement was made about change being driven by the citizens who are eventually the service receivers. In order to have gone a full circle the results from a recent Price Waterhouse Coopers Survey give us the state of play in the current scenario in Canada. Just to report some of the results from a presentation made by PWC on Lessons Learned about e-Governance in Canada it says that: (1)
(2)
(3)
(4) (5)
(6)
(7) (8) (9)
Poorer, older, less educated Canadians will not have access. Canadians have begun using government online with one-third of Canadian Internet users accessing government services but mostly for access to information rather than applying for a service or filing a tax-return. Canadians are using government web sites because it is more convenient in that it takes less time, its easier and simpler, no need to physical travel, etc. Canadians accessing government web sites want all services on line even those not used regularly. Canadians are ready to carry out online transactions with the number of Canadians doing Christmas purchasing online quadrupling. Canadichls want integrated government portals with 86 per cent saying that single website allowing them to access a broad range of government services would be helpful. Provincial governments have a key role to play in the attraction of users. Security remains an issue with users. Implementation should be planned in waves.
In view of this the work carried out by the Canadian Government can be seen as a good blueprint on which other governments can plan their electronic service delivery.
(C) Estonia Background Estonia has made significa.nt steps towards the information age and several processes initiated earlier,are starting to bear fruit.
22
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
The government has been able to assign about one per cent of its budget to information technology development in the public sector for eight consecutive years now. This has brought PCs to the desks of more than 90 per cent of employees of ministries, authorities, inspectorates and other government institutions who need to work with computers. The Estonian Government has replaced paper documentation prepared for its sessions with digital documents and launched an Intetnet-based system for government sessions. As from of this year all Estonian municipalities are connected to the Internet. A national network of public Internet access points is also taking shape. Recently, the Digital Signature Act was approved by Parliament. This gives the basic legal framework for the development of e-Commerce.
Development of Information .Infrastructure PeaTee, the backbone network for government institutions started in 1998, has now matured to reach its planned volume. The number of government institutions and their subdivisions to be connected to PeaTee has passed the 550 mark (i.e., more than 10,000 computers). About 80 per cent of these entities enjoy the benefits of 2 Mbps or even 10 Mbps transfer speeds. Connection costs have steadily decreased at the same time. The rapid success of PeaTee has driven new developments in information infrastructure. The KulaTee (Village Road) programme of rural data communications, kicked off at the end of 1998 with preliminary studies, yielded the first leased line connections to municipalities last year. Project completion, which meant a minimum of 64 kbps leased line capacity to each of the 245 existing municipalities, was in late 2000. The only obstacle to keeping this schedule may be lack of funding. Although the government has listed KulaTee as one of its priorities, this has not spared the programme from budget cuts. KulaTee also offers the possibility of providing Internet access to several schools and opening new public Internet access points at the municipalities or libraries. As part of networking the public libraries, leased-line public Internet access points have
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
23
been opened at more than 60 libraries all over Estonia. They are equipped with new computers and printers acquired through the public procurement process. It is worth mentioning that KiilaTee has brought together a number of government institutions, commercial entities and organizations. A national cooperation system has been formed, led by a working party in each county and a central programme council. For libraries, the project partners are the Ministry of Culture, the Estonian Informatics Centre and county governments which are jointly organizing the work. The end of the year 2000 saw the end of the special monopoly rights of the Estonian Telephone Company.
More Attention to Support Activities A backdrop for building communications networks is active work in the supporting areas of IT standardization, data security and language technology. During the past three of years, the IT standardization committee has published more than 30 Estonian IT standards. A new edition of the standard Requirements on Information Technology in the Estonian Language and Cultural Environment was completed in early 2000. This should encourage hardware and software vendors to adapt their products to Estonian requirements. The same goal is served by language technology activities, preparing semi-manufactured language resource products for all software vendors. Software vendors are being encouraged to put more effort into Estonian products, even if this will not promise immediate profit. Many software vendors dealing with Estonian language products actually acknowledge that this business may provide a good return on investment. There is a sufficient number of Estonian computer users already-about 40 per cent of the 1.4 million population. In the field of data security, a draft document of security classes has been drawn up, complete with a set of the basic measures to be taken. Manuals have been published for top management and IT personnel, to help them secure emerging information systems and increase their reliability. The Estonian Government has devoted serious attention to
24
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
copyright protection of software, including legalization of programmes in use.
Service Orientation and Efficiency IT solutions will help government institutions to streamline their work, share information faster and concentrate on producing the information and offering the services that are vital for the citizens of Estonia. The system of state registers in Estonia is quite complicatedthere are many registers, the same data is often gathered over and over again for different needs, quality of data is sometimes low, etc. To improve the situation the register of databases was implemented. This registry of data repositories, implemented last year at the Estonian Informatics Centre, has greatly improved cooperation and cross-use of data between repositories. The register of databases is one part of the main development project called 'Registers Service Layer' launched in 2001. Establishment of a joint service layer on the basis of Internet technology has opened the possibility of offering different e-services on the basis of different state databases. The first pilot projects have successfully been completed. At the same time, government institutions are preparing for a transition to electronic business as prescribed in the document management programme initiated by the State Chancellery. The Digital Signature Act, passed in 2000 by the Parliament, provides a foundation for the use of digital documents with exactly the same legal consequences as their paper counterparts. In addition to the present availability of official forms on the Internet, people also have the option of filling them in and submitting them through the same channel (the Estonian tax authority already accepts tax declarations submitted electronically). This popular service is already used thousands of times every business day. We will soon witness successful remote communication between the government and the citizens, without undue delay or cost, now seems to be within reach. Information and services of all government institutions are now provided through a single integrated portal-the State Web Centre (http://www.riik.ee). which is a path to the home pages
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
25
of all government institutions. Through this single window, people should be able to access all institutions and clerks and get solutions to as many problems as possible. The operator of the information server promptly routes user queries to the right clerk. As the next step, the current institution-centric approach should be made even more problem- and service-centric. This calls for effective cooperation between all government institutions and the emergence of common operating principles and rules. The main obstacle may prove to be the legacy management structure that stems from rigid power hierarchies and favours bureaucracy. The challenge is to develop modern management structures, based on cooperation networks and cross-institutional information processing mechanisms. The planned administration reform will hopefully accommodate that. Requirements for information publicity are also taking shape. Freedom of Information Act stipulates both requirements for government institutions to inform the public about their performance, as well as methods of how people should be able to access this vital information. Thus, every institution has to create a digital document registry that can be accessed at any time by any computer user via public data communication networks. This Act and others like it will fill several serious holes in current legislation and thereby certainly help to open up various aspects of decisions made by the government, including perhaps some that, for some reason or another, have been concealed from the public until now.
Information Policy The principles of the Estonian Information Policy were approved by the Parliament of Estonia on May 13, 1998 (http:! / www.eik.ee/english/policy).This policy document gives a proper framework for actions toward the information society.
Action Plan The Information Policy serves as a basis for an Action Plan, which in turn is the basis for all government organizations to plan and
26
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
start different projects and programmes. The Action Plan is discussed once a year in the Government of Estonia and it has been approved first on April 1998 (http://www.eik.ee/english/ policy /plan.htm).
The Coalition Agreement The February 1999 Coalition Agreement (http://www.riik.ee/ government) of the Reform Party, Pro Patria and M66dukad (Moderates) forming the Government Coalition describes some actions based on the Information Policy.
IT Management Organization According to the amendments to the Government of Republic Act recommended by the government and adopted by the Riigikogu (Estonian Parliament) in June 2000, the Ministry of Communications is coordinating the work of the state information systems. In all ministries, county governments and state organizations IT development and maintenance is managed/ coordinated by IT managers.
Some Basic Facts and Indicators (1) Total number of conventional phone lines per 100 inhabitants-35.4 (2) Total number of mobile phone subscribers per 100 inhabitants-31.5 (3) Mobile telephone transmission networks cover 99 per cent of Estonia's populated area. (4) Number of people having used the Internet in the last six months - 400,000 (28% of the population). (5) Number of users of online banking systems-180,000 (13%). (6) RIPE host count by DNS domains (real)-33,280 (July 2000).
(D) Hungary Background The Republic of Hungary has a population of around 10 million people, following the end of the Second World War Hungary
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
27
became part of the Soviet dominated Eastern European block and its government and economy were refashioned on the communist model. During 1956, increasingly nationalist opposition, pushed the Government to announce its withdrawal from the Warsaw Pact, and this led to a massive military intervention by Moscow. During the Gorbachev era Hungary led the movement to dissolve the Warsaw Pact and steadily moved toward multiparty democracy and a market-oriented democracy. After the fall of the USSR in 1991, Hungary developed close political and economic relations with Western Europe and is now being considered as a potential member of the European Union. As regards telecommunications, historically, Hungary has had an underdeveloped communication network. Until 1989 telecommunications used to be a state monopoly and was bundled up with traditional postal services and broadcasting. In 1990, the first transformation came about. The company that had the monopoly for these three services was split into three. The second transformation came around with the Telecommunications Act that became effective in the summer of 1993. This Act essentially established the theoretical framework of the current structure of telecommunications and accelerated the reform in the telecommunications sector. The future for telecommunications in Hungary is as yet not clearly charted, like many other countries, due to the fast rate or change in this sector. Yet as more services become liberalized and the termination of exclusivity of services, which will last until 31 December 2001, comes into effect, an exciting time for the Republic of Hungary is on the horizon.
Use of E-Governance Hungary has realized that a planned investment in information technology and its supporting infrastructure is required for the development of the information society. The effects of such an investment together with the benefits of the information society makes the return on such investment worthwhile. The birth of a global telecommunications network and the convergence of telecommunications, computer engineering and entertainment
28
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
electronics technologies open up new prospects for global trade in information services. In the course of this process, telecommunications itself is becoming part 'of information technology, and its services have an increasingly 'intelligent' content. This infrastructure should be capable of connecting any user network run by businesses, institutions or private individuals, and suitable for intelligent data processing. In addition to this the Hungarian Government has created a Commissioner for ICT within the office of the Prime Minister with two main lines of action related to the establishment of an Information Society National Action Plan. The first line of action is called the Szechenyi Plan which is an ambitious initiative for mid-term national economic development and has a time horizon of six years. The yearly budget for 2001 and 2002 allocated is approximately 1 billion US dollars and government expects a similar contribution from the private sector. This plan has seven priority areas called programmes. In each programme there are several sub-programmes. One of the seven programmes is dedicated specifically to the development of the information society and information economy. In this programme, there are five sub-programmes, covering the areas of e-Governance; improvement of the availability and access of IT resources; creating the foundations for the e-Economy, enhancement of information culture, improvement of accessible contents, improvement of quality of life and rising awareness. A second line of action related to the establishment of an information society plan is to publish a National Strategy for Informatics. This document is intended to serve as the basic guideline for. the development of the Information Society in Hungary. There are several other ongoing activities. The first pilot project on Certificate Authority and Digital Signature system started in October 2000 at the Ministry of Interior. The Ministry of Interior issued new personal identification card and driving licenses harmonized with the EU recommendations and standards of the member states. The system is based on a nationwide IT network, connecting 254 offices in municipalities. The offices are situated at the local governments and supported by the M~nistry of Interior. The offices are one-stop contact points
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
29
between the citizens and government. The local governments and other authorities can use the wide area network for various transactions on the intranets and the Internet as well. The Ministry of Environmental Protection established a website that provides information on the state of the environment. Also, a fully operational network for the collection, processing and monitoring of environmental data in Hungary that will be fully compatible with the European Environment Information and Observation Network (EIONETt There is a national database of substances damaging the ozone layer, too. The digitalization of Hungarian authors' literary works (in the framework of Neumann Digital Library and Multimedia Centre) is in progress. Furthermore, the establishment of the National Audio-visual Archive is in progress, too. The development of high-speed Internet access for National Cultural Institutions (in cooperation with the National IT Infrastructure Development Programme/NIIF) continues. The John von Neumann Computer Society (NJSZT) has joined the European Computer Driving Licence (ECDU Foundation in 1997. There are more than 150 accredited Test Centres, coordinated and controlled by NJSZT. There are more than 30,000 candidates and more than 16,000 completed ECDLs. The Hungarian Quality Assurance System for ECDL Centres is recognized as international best practice. The ECDL Programme is accredited by the Ministry of Education for the Further Education Programme for Teachers. Government has pledged the use of information technology for its operation and its primary aim, in the legislative institutions and the central and local agencies of public administration is to standardize existing systems in five to ten years. It wishes to upgrade the most important registration systems to meet modern standards. (The records involved in this scheme cover data on personal identification, business, social security, tax and customs affairs, real estate, motor vehicles and criminals). This scheme may result in direct savings of billions of forints, while its indirect effects may generate an even greater increase in revenue. Government is also trying to coordinate the use of up-to-date
30
E-Governance Practices: A Global' Perspective
information processing methods in the prelimmary phase of decision-making (handling and flow of documents, availability of data for control by decision-makers, data protection, etc.) in that it may help ease the burden on decision-making bodies, reduce the excessive influence of the specialized institutions and accelerate the decision-making process. Hungary's presence in international fora and organizations will also require that it become connected with the telecommunications and information processing systems of the EU member countries (for instance, the European Nervous System (ENS) and in common with a number of EU states, a long-term modernization objective of Hungary is that both private individuals and enterprises should be able to communicate with government agencies and other authorities by computer, without the need for printed documents (tax affairs, official certificates, access to non-classified government information, etc.). On a legal front Hungary should take legal measures to protect government information processing systems (the legal force of electronic documents and their archiving, rules for the acquisition of information, the accessibility and protection of data bases, consequences of unauthorized access, etc.). On the level of public information processing systems which include education, research and culture, in the next 10 to 15 years all schools, libraries and research institutes should be enabled to establish computer links with one another. Direct access to international networks may help schools and universities retain their more qualified staff. It is also envisaged that the Hungarian citizen would be able to exercise his democratic right directly from the home through the use of his Pc. On a business level these systems should concentrate on the background services that improve the general conditions of economic activities (banking and credit transactions, electronic accounting systems, real estate trading services, capital and commodity market information, data bases, etc.). The government should lay particular emphasis on the protection of personal rights, copyright and business know-how, not only in the traditional fields of civil law , but also in the new branches of administrative law which are increasingly important for the
E-Covernance Practices: A Global Perspective
31
business community (for instance, the monitoring system for public services rendered under concession agreements). With regards to the enabling infrastructure the telephone capacities of the country can be expanded at an annual rate of about 15 per cent and about thirty-one telephone lines are available for every 100 inhabitants. It can safely be predicted that by the 2010, TV and radio transmission and postal services will be close to European standards. In other areas of telecommunications and information processing, market forces should guarantee more rapid development. (E) Jamaica
Background The Government of Jamaica has made the integration of information technology into the Jamaican economy a high priority and a strategic imperative. It aims to promote Jamaica as a Caribbean hub for IT activities and investment. A threepronged approach envisages transformations in human resource development, in infrastructure and in the enactment of an enabling legislative and policy framework. A Cabinet subcommittee for IT is steering the process, together with a newly set up Central IT Office (CITO). The former Ministry of Industry and Commerce now has 'Technology' added to its name and government has publicized its intention to generate 40,000 ITrelated jobs in the coming three-year period. Strategic and other measures being adopted iii. the short term include: (1)
(2)
(3) (4) (5)
The annual allocation of 2 to 4 per cent of the national budget to IT initiatives. Catalyzing ministry tactical plans, with an emphasis on education, for the harnessing of ICTs in the various socio-economic sectors. The introduction of a strong IT component in the Public Sector Modernization Programme. Accelerating the introduction of computer labs in educational institutions. Facilitating private sector initiatives to dramatically increase public access to the Internet.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
32
Create a Chief Information Officer position within each ministry. (7) The establishment of a transparent regulatory framework, adaptable to the emerging e-business environment and covering areas such as privacy, intellectual property and digital signatures. (8) A system of investment incentives to spread IT activities geographically across Jamaica. (9) The development of an appropriate infrastructure to facilitate the delivery of government services. (6)
In addition, a series of high-profile pilot projects are being undertaken to demonstrate the benefits of IT in the short-term. These projects are intended to further the goal of universal access and emphasize public access to information. The post office network is earmarked for the delivery of a wide range of community services, such as online health-care, weather and disaster preparedness bulletins, the marketing of products and agricultural extension services. Expansion of this infrastructure will also facilitate greater public access to government services, communication with government agencies, Parliament and parliamentarians, thereby reinforcing the democratic process. Long-term goals include: The creation of a nation wide public IT network which is competitively priced, utilizes multiple sources and relies on the private sector. (2) The provision of efficient government services to the public through the use of IT. (3) The use of IT to increase international trade. (4) The adoption ofe-Commerce for government functions, as a stimulus to private sector take-up. The latter will also be facilitated through the provision of the infrastructural components for the take-up of e-Commerce and e-Business, particularly by SMEs. 0)
Use of E-Govemance Currently, the quality of service to the public is deeIPed as poor and is characterized by: 0) cumbersome procedures; (2) long delays; (3) unsatisfactory resolution of problems faced by clients;
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
33
(4) high private costs of compliance with laws and regulations; and (5) discourteous behaviour. The Jamaican public sector displays characteristics commonly found in most established bureaucracies. Rigid laws and regulations govern Public Sector entities. Compliance with these laws and regulations takes precedence over achieving organizational objectives. In turn, this reduces responsiveness to emerging situations and discourages innovation. Decision-making is hierarchical and most decisions get pushed up the senior level. Many senior level officials regard themselves as policy makers, controllers or .regulators, rather than facilitators. In addition, both managerial and operational business in the public sector need re-engineering. Most of the current business processes were established decades ago and continue unchanged. In spite of major changes in the external environment and the role of the public sector, business processes have not been restructured. Many business processes that could be completed in one-step or location are fragmented between different organizations or different sections within a given organization. However, the government has begun to make important changes in the operations of public sector institutions to improve efficiencies through a Public Sector Modernization Programme. The Public Sector Modernization Programme is being funded by the Government of Jamaica, the World Bank, and the British Department for International Development and the European Union. The aim is to modernize 17 pilot agencies and 3 pilot Ministries, in order to enhance efficiency and improve performance, as well as the quality of service provided to the public. Ten pilot agencies will be transformed into Executive Agencies, with greater responsibility for service delivery, financial management and human resources management. Executive Agencies will be rewarded for realizing efficiency gains, improving effectiveness or realizing revenue increases. Conversely, sanctions will be applied for poor performance. Other aspects of the public sector programme include: (1) privatizing or contracting out government services in cases
34
E-Governance Prac'.kes: A Global Perspective
where these services are better performed by private providers; (2) reforming the government procurement system to improve transparency and efficiency; (3) the establishment of comput~rized information systems in the public sector to improve financial and personnel management. The next phase of the programme envisages extending the reforms to the entire public sector. Under the National IT Strategy the relevant goals state that: (1) The Government of Jamaica plans to provide its citizens
with efficient government services through the use of IT. (2) Networks will be established to allow access to government services from libraries, post offices, banks, hospitals and other public locations. The government will coordinate the locations access, presentation methods, and sharing of resources. The key focus is to have citizens throughout the country, even in rural areas, be able to find and receive information and services from different government organizations consistently and easily. Actions towards this end include: (1) Delivery of two types of services: (i) providing information to the public, and (ii) allowing transactions
to be performed. Early emphasis is to be placed on the former, i.e., provision of information to the public. The Minister of Commerce and Technology will establish a goal to provide a certain percentage of information services to the public within the next three years. For example, 25 per cent of information services will be provided by the year 2003. (2) Identifying a set of government services su~table for electronic self-service. Enough progress has been made in other countries in the area of electronic government to permit identification and widespread deployment of a core set of commonly requested government services that citizens can initiate and complete in a single electronic session.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
35
(3) Expand locations where public can access information and obtain public services. To ensure that all citizens have equal access to technology, establish a network of kiosk or computer systems that provide government information and services in prominent locations in each region of Jamaica, or broaden access to the rural communities, IT needs to be placed where the public can use it in convenient community locations, such as libraries, post offices, banks, hospitals, and other government offices. For example, rural public libraries can be networked with main libraries to expand the services that are available to the public throughout the country. (4) Use partnerships to obtain support, knowledge, loans, computers, services and training to further the development of the IT industry in Jamaica. Develop partnerships with industry, universities, and multilateral and multi-national organizations. Partnerships are vital to achieving strategic IT goals. These partnerships facilitate major culture changes throughout the government. Public and private sector partners work together to provide more efficient and effective government services.
(F) Malaysia Background Malaysia has embarked on a number of measures to ensure that information and communication technologies (lCTs) playa vital role in that society. The nation was selected as one of the case studies in the prestigious Report of the Digital Opportunity Initiative. The Report notes Malaysia's comprehensive policies that are being developed to encourage ICT use in various sectors of the economy, as well as to accelerate the growth of the ICT sector. Trade and investment policies, such as financial and nonfinancial incentives, a fair trade system, and import and export duties, promote local and foreign investment. With the privatization of the government telecommunications department in 1987, and the formation of the National Telecommunications
36
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
Policy (NTP) in 1994, the market has now been fully liberalized. The Malaysian Government's Master Plan for the telecommunications industry provides guidelines for competition, interconnection charges, tariff rates and network development. At the end of 1995, all operators signed interconnection agreements with Telekom Malaysia to provide seamless communication regardless of carrier, though most carriers have not signed agreements among themselves. The computer and software markets have also been fully deregulated, though restrictions exist on participation in government bids, and there are equity requirements for setting up manufacturing facilities. These barriers do not pose an insurmountable barrier to competition, but encourage the establishment of joint ventures and local distributorships with Malaysian companies.
leT Infrastructure The Malaysian Government has invested heavily in world-class infrastructure. Malaysia's Multimedia Super Corridor (MSC) is designed to create an ideal environment for ICT -related production as well as provide the backbone for an information superhighway. The network contains a high-speed link (10 Gb/s network) that connects the MSC to Japan, ASEAN, the US and Europe, and is capable of supporting extensive public administration, education and business applications. The intent of the superhighway is to provide quality access to global information as quickly and easily as possible. Simultaneously, the Demonstrator Application Grant Scheme (DAGS) is intended to facilitate social and economic progress through the innovative use of ICT. It provides funds for citizens to access the opportunities associated with the MSC and to be involved in multimedia development. The telephone penetration rate--as a measurement of the ICT readiness of the country-rose from 16.6 per cent to 23.2 per cent between 1995 and 1999, while fixed lines in the rural areas rose from 5.2 per cent in 1994 to 11 per cent in 1999. Malaysia is aiming to continue the establishment of basic telecommunications infrastructure, with plans for 250 Internet
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
37
access points, 250 mobile phones and 500 fixed lines for every 1,000 people within the next 5 years. This is in addition to the development of other primary physical infrastructure, such as power supply, transportation, airports, office buildings and extended business areas. As result of fair trade and investment policies, foreign direct investment in Malaysia reached US$6 billion in 1997, but then dropped to US$3.8 billion in 1998 due to the Asian economic crisis. In 1999, flows of foreign direct investment again increased by 31 per cent and GNP rose 5.4 per cent-much faster than initially forecasted. This increase was led by manufacturing, particularly in ICT-related electronics (for export), and this sector is now the key driver of growth in the economy. In 1999, the contribution of the ICT sector to GNP was approximately 36.5 per cent. A number of incentives and projects are underway to foster entrepreneurship and business efficiency. The government provides both financial and non-financial incentives to Malaysian businesses. Financial incentives include zero income tax for a period of 10 years, R&D grants, and a 100 per cent investment tax allowance on new investment in the MSC. Nonfinancial incentives include unrestricted employment of foreign knowledge workers, no restrictions on global capital, and limited restrictions on ownership. The growing economy has created a demand for skilled knowledge workers and professionals. Skilled labour is still in short supply, especially in the ICT sector and manufacturing industries. To address this issue, the Malaysian government is investing in a high-quality, comprehensive education system designed to meet the demands of the evolvinb workplace. At the Multimedia University, for example, new skills such as information and knowledge management, as well as programming applications, will be incorporated into the education and training curriculum. Several additional efforts have been made to increase ICT literacy. The Computer In Education (CIE) Programme has provided computer laboratories to 90 secondary schools and 20 primary schools: Between 1996 and 1998, about 1,230 teachers were trained to conduct the CIE
a
38
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
course. Computer Aided Design and Computer Aided Manufacturing (CAD and CAM) courses were also taught in secondary technical schools. Malaysia has made a concerted effort to provide relevant content to technology users through a number of specific initiatives: for example, Agritani is developing a portal that serves agriculture communities, including farmers, agriculture agencies, consultants, and agriculture service providers; and Cybercare enables orphanage communities in Malaysia to share news, barter goods, train volunteers and increase administrative efficiency. E-Commerce initiatives are helping to provide Malaysian businesses with more efficient access to input and product markets, both locally and globally. For example, MyBiz, an eCommerce platform designed for small and medium enterprises helps facilitate collaborative marketing by linkmg 300 companies including 26,000 employees in a business community network. The same platform can be used to make procurement processes more efficient and effective.
Strategic Compact for ICT Convergence Malaysia's leadership recognized the need for a cooperative partnership to achieve its development objectives and its ambitious vision. To leverage and coordinate public, private and community sectors, the National Information Technology Agenda (NITA) was developed as a major strategy for national development. The National IT Agenda (NITA), launched in December 1996 by the National IT Council (NITC), provides the foundation and framework for the utilization of ICT to transform Malaysia into a developed nation. The NIT A vision is to use ICT to transform Malaysia, across all sectors, into an information society, then a knowledge society, and finally a 'values-based' knowledge society. The necessity for a strong ICT infrastructure has been recognized by Malaysia who has built up its capability in ICTs to improve its capacities in every field of business, industry and life in general. Currently Malaysia is in full gear to meet the challenge of globalization by enhancing the nation's
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
39
competitiveness, through the infusion of knowledge in all production-based industries and steering toward a knowledgebased economy. One key initiative aimed at fast tracking Malaysia into the information age is the Multimedia Super Corridor. Two smart cities have been developed within this corridor, namely, Putrajaya and Cyberjaya. The MSC envisions the harnessing of multimedia to help spearhead economic developm~nt for Malaysia to achieve developed nation status by the year 2020. The address describes the hard and soft infrastructure that has been put into place. This includes, for example, a fibre optic backbone network covering 360 kilometres. The Government has put in place a legal framework, and institutional framework with coordinating mechanisms and a set of ICT policies and guidelines. National and state ICT councils have been established. The National IT Council (NITC) represents the highest ICT forum that acts as a think tank and advises the Government on national ICT strategies. The NITC is chaired by the Prime Minister. No matter how good a domestic infrastructure is in place there is a need for a regional or perhaps even global ICT framework to deepen cooperation and to regulate the now borderless world. Challenges faced by government in the midst of ICT convergence are seen to be:
Political: From the political dimension, the three most significant challenges are managing a borderless virtual· world, the erosion of control and disempowerment of the technologically poor states. (2) Secur~ty: Poor enforcement of rCT security policies and systems with inadequate security features may result in security incidents such as thefts and espionage of government and corporate information and illegal access to personal information. Cyber attacks can also paralyse a country's defence and even cripple key sectors of a country's economy. (3) Socio-cultural: The lCT revolution has resulted in a shortage of skilled know ledge workers and the 'brain drain' to more developed countries. There is also a
(1)
40
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
widening gap between IT 'haves' and 'have-nots' across nations and within nations i.e. between rural and urban areas and between the younger and older generation. Another challenge is the 'hollowing' of culture, which is the erosion of values and ethics through mass global culture pervading the Internet and electronic media. (4) Economic: Globalization has further aggravated the existing unequal distribution of wealth and income, creating imbalance, leading to polarization. Keeping abreast with the ever-changing ICT trends comes with a high cost. Countries which are slow in grasping the opportunities provided by the latest technology such as e-Commerce, will be at a serious disadvantage. In order to respond to the challenges highlighted, government and the public service need to undertake the following initiatives:
Strategic ICT Planning Several countries have undertaken initiatives to come up with their Strategic ICT Plan for example UK has its UK Online, Singapore with its Singapore One and its IT 2000 Masterplan. Malaysia has its NITA (National I Agenda) and the MSC (Multimedia Super Corridor) project and recently has come up with its K-Economy Masterplan.
Reinventing of Govemment There is also a need to transform current government processes in order to improve services. Malaysia has embarked on various initiatives to reinvent Government processes such as eGovernance Flagship Applications, empowerment of the State and Local Governments and the setting up of a special committee to oversee the whole government ICT initiatives, that is the Government IT and Internet Committee (GITIC).
Human Resource Development The lack of trained IT and knowledge workers to support application diffusion in both the public and private sector is a
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
41
major challenge in efforts to expand the use of IT in the country. As such the Malaysian Government has adopted various strategies to enhance ICT literacy and skills. Some of the initiatives undertaken include: (1) Establishment of COtI1puJ~( labs in schools. (2) Establishment of new private higher education insti tu tions. (3) Allocation of special funds for ICT training by the Human Resource Development Council.
In addition, the Smart School initiative under the MSC project, also responds to the need for Malaysia to make the critical transition from an industrial to a knowledge-based economy. The Malaysian government has also undertaken a special study on IT Manpower requirements to support the application and diffusion of IT. The study focuses on several important components including human resource reguirements and occupational classification of public sector I'h. personnel, the effectiveness of IT training programmes and the relevant online IT services to industry users.
Enhancing Security Issues ~urrounding security of ICT systems have also become a major concern. Hence to ensure a conducive and safe electronic environment, the necessary steps in enhancing ICT security has to be undertaken. In tandem with what other countries are doing, the Malaysian Government has undertaken the following measures: Establishment of an ICT Security Division in MAMPU. (2) Appointment of ICT Security Officers in agencies. (3) Establishment of the Government Computer Emergency Response Team (GCERT). (4) Publication of the Malaysian Management of ICT Security (MyMIS) Handbook:
(1)
At the national level, a number of initiatives have also been undertaken such as the establishment of the National ICT
42
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
Security and Emergency Response Centre (NISER) which provides for skill development and consultancy services relating to ICT security and establishment of Malaysian CERT (MyCERT), established to tackle security issues for the private sector.
BridgiI!g the Digital Divide The issue of digital divide is one that is common across most countries. The Malaysian Government has also undertaken numerous programmes to reduce this phenomenon such as: (1)
(2)
(3)
(4) (5)
The 'Medan Infodesa' programme which provides training ana hardware to rural communities by the Ministry of Rural Development. The 'Internet Desa' programme by the Ministry of Energy, Communication and Multimedia which involves supplying of computers to provide free Internet access to rural communities. The K3P (Kumpulan 3 P-Pendengaar, Penonton, Pembaca) programme initiated by the Ministry of Information, which has set up centres called 'Pondok Harmoni', equipped with PCs and Internet access. Setting up of eServices kiosks at both community and public areas. Provision of government services via Interactive Voice Response (IVR) which can be accessible through telephones.
Reviewing the Legal Framework The development of IT and multimedia without the parallel development of laws can result in abuses and in turn discourage the use of such technologies. The use of The Internet has raised a few concerns and issues, namely: Integrity and security of information. (2) Legal status of online transactions. (3) Privacy and confidentiality of information. (4) Intellectual property rights.
(1)
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
43
Taking cognizance of these issues, the Malaysian Government has already approved and passed its own set of cyberlaws: (1) Digital Signature Act 1997. (2) Computer Crimes Act 1997. (3) Telemedicine Act 1997. (4) Communications and Multimedia Act 1998.
The Personal Data Protection Bill is also currently being drafted and the existing Copyright Act is being aligned to the electronic environment.
Promotion of E-Commerce Governments should take cognizance of the fact that the Internet has changed business rules and the way business is being conducted. E-Commerce activities are expected to give rise to new economic development opportunities and in the process produce different impact to businesses and organizations. Amongst Malaysia's efforts to promote e-Commerce include: (1) Conducting an e-Commerce readiness assessment to
identify the gaps and map appropriate strategies. (2) Supporting e-Commerce through effective legislation. (3) Encouraging local manufacturers to pursue e-Commerce. Three major policies and strategic directions are to be undertaken by the government in order to move towards a Kbased society and economy, namely: (1) New policy and regulatory framework to promote the
development of the communications and multimedia sector and industry. (2) Strategies for widening access an.d content development. (3) Policies for building trust and confidence in e-transactions.
Building National Communications Infrastructure This can be achieved through the implementation of efficient communication media (wired/wireless) and transmission modes
E-Govemance Practices: A Global Perspective
44
(narrowband / broadband) as well as improvement in education facilities such as online education and smart schools. Acknowledging the fact that digital divide exists and has to be addressed, steps are undertaken to bridge the gap through the implementation of Universal Service Provision and e-Community projects.
Providing Global Communication Links Global communication links have been improved through access to global satellite facilities such as cable and satellite systems as well as the Internet gateways (IDe, ARIX) and international exchanges (PSTN). Other services provided include COINS global and mobile international roaming.
Facilitating Knowledge Development In the area of knowledge development, efforts have been undertaken to improve and increase training facilities such as the establishment of the Multimedia University, training centres and colleges. Research and development and the aspect of Intellectual Property Rights have also been given emphasis. Participation and sponsorship from industry has itself become a national agenda of which the issue has been discussed in various industry forums. Further actions that need to be addressed in order to support the National Communications and Multimedia Agenda, amongst which are: (1)
(2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
Raising awareness for ICT adoption. Enhancing network infrastructure. Improving policy and regulations. Enhancing operational efficiency. Capacity building. Adapting appropriate e-Commerce technology, harnessing technical and operational standards and striving for sustainable technology transfer.
Use of E-Govemance Malaysia'S e-Govemance programme aims at reinventing how the government works as well as improving the quality o(
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
45
interactions with citizens and businesses through i~proved connectivity, better access to information and services, high quality services and better processes and systems. Of the six eGovernance pilot projects being implemented, four of them have gone 'live' at their respective pilot agencies. These include the Project Monitoring System (PMS), e-Procurement, Generic Office Environment (GOE) and the services projects. The Human Resource Management Information System (HRMIS) and the Electronic Labour Exchange System or ELX are currently under development and will be rolled out in the near future. The implementation of e-Governance has taken a holistic approach encompassing elements such as applications, networks, security, process re-engineering, operations and support, change management, and skills and knowledge. In moving forward into the future, four guiding principles have been identified, namely: collaboration between the public and private sectors, sharing of data and information, customer satisfaction and information and data security. There are currently 6 pilot applications, multiple websites and on multiple platforms. In the future, more and more services will be included in the government e-Services portal and there will be greater sharing of data and information through the adoption of concepts such as single point of data entry, data integration and single sign on. An issue faced is whether the government should standardize on the use of a single platform or product for the whole of government or whether to allow the current use and adoption of heterogeneous platforms/ products as long as they can inter-operate with each other. Another issue concerns the implementation of the second wave of eGovernance applications which should have started two years ago but have been delayed due to delays in the implementation of the first wave of applications. While the e-Governance programme is being implemented, government computerization continues in other agencies. A service provider has been appointed to provide wide area connectivity to all agencies implementing e-Governance via an intranet called the E-Governance*Net. The issue facing the government is that many agencies have already implemented
46
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
their own networks using. the services of other providers. Migration of agencies to the new Federal Government Administrative Centre in Putrajaya has compounded the complexity of the communications issue as these agencies require connectivity to other agencies within Putrajaya and to the outside world. There will therefore be gradual migration of agencies to the E-Governance*Net, a more cost effective implementation approach to developing application systems which are more 'bandwidth' friendly, and the use bf new communication and network technologies. Regarding the issue of security, Government has established an IT Security Policy as well as adoption of smartc;ards and the public key infrastructure. In the future, more awareness, enforcement and standardization activities will be carried out. In the re-engineering of processes, current e-Governance applications have implemented automation and streamlining of current processes which may result in new roles and responsibilities for certain personnel. In the future, applications will be built with more customer focus, departing from functionbased type of processes. This will entail the elimination of boundaries, restructuring of organizations, establishment and adoption of common procedures with continuous improvement embedded. As ministries and agencies move to Putrajaya and as more and more agencies implement e-Governance applications, there is invariably an increasing need to share resources. The government is in the process of establishing a Shared Services Outfit or SSO which provides centralized facilities such as Help Desk, Command and Data Centre, Networks and Enterprise Systems Management. The major challenge lies in getting buyin from agencies willing to share resources as well as in utilizing the services that will be offered by the SSO. The future points to greater IT coordination and support with upgrade policies, service contracts or service level agreements (SLAs) with service providers, and maintenance procedures. One of the biggest perceived challenges faced in implementing e-Governance is the 'people' probl€ .~ -·that is, in getting their buy-in, support and commitment. As such,
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
47
implementation of each of the e-Governance application is inevitably linked to a cohesive change management programme involving its three main tenets namely transition management, communication management and benefits realization. The future success of e-Governance lies in the ability to sustain change where success is measured and a change in mindsetl culture has occurred. Finally, in the area of skills and knowledge, government has established dedicated project teams to implement the various applications with the consortia appointed. However, it has been found that transfer of technology from the consortia to the government team members has not happened as desired. This situation is at times attributed to the non-availability of the technology recipients, and the fact that the consortia may be too focused on getting their applications finished on time.
(G) Malta Background Malta is a small island state with a population of 400,000 people. In 1987 the government embarked on a large-scale modernization programme which among other things foeused on putting the Island on the world-map of information technology. The change programme within the public sector was spearheaded by a new agency acting as a change agent and an IT enabler and the first Information Systems Strategic Plan was published. Much has been done and still more is planned to be done. All ministries and government departments are connected to the Malta Government Network, known as MAGNET for short, and a large proportion of public officers have their own e-mail address and Internet access. Government also has its own official website and plans are in hand to transform this website into a portal with the capacity to support e-Governance initiatives.
Use of E-Govemance In its white paper on the Vision and Strategy for the Attainment of e-Governance published in October 2000, the Office of the Prime Minister outlined its vision and strategy to attain
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
48
e-Governance in Malta. It is made very clear from the outset that such a vision can only be implemented if both the private and the public sector contribute to it. Government should act as an enabler, creating the right environment through a proper legislative framework and institutional set-ups. Government will also implement e-Commerce solutions in its businessoriented. activity. The Private sector on the other hand should be able to support, supply and implement the solutions that would be in demand throughout all sectors of the economy. Government's vision for the creation of a Maltese Information Society and Information Economy is underpinned by a number of principles which are: (1)
(2)
(3)
(4) (5) (6)
All Maltese will have the opportunity and the means to participate in the Information Society and the Information Economy irrespective of their financial, social or educational circumstances. Government will actively promote the creation of the Information Society and the Information Economy via the provision of transactional online e-Governance Services. Government will provide the necessary policy, institutional and regulatory framework that is required for the successfut.proliferation of electronic commerce. Businesses will be encouraged to adopt electronic commerce. The achievement of computer literacy by all sectors of the population will be actively pursued. The necessary measures will be taken to build up a critical mass of Information Technology specialists that will be required to sustain the growth of the Information Society and the Information Economy.
The creation of the Information Society and Information Economy in Malta would transform Maltese society in a manner which would result in service improvement, universal access to education, a thriving economy, affordable communications of th.e highest standards and a country which is among the frontrunners in the Global Information Society.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
49
As already argued above, the achievement of the Information Society and Information Economy in Malta requires the building of the national capacity to sustain this development. This is envisaged to happen through partnerships between the Public and the Private Sector. Government will build the legal and regulatory framework through a number of Bills: The Electronic Commerce Bill which provides a secure legal basis for electronic communications, contracts, signatures and transactions, and establishes the framework for Certification Authorities and their regulation. (2) The Data Protection Bill wh'ch will ensure the protection of data, in Qrder to protect the rights of individuals visa-vis personal information. (3) The Computer Misuse Bill which criminalizes offences relating to the misuse of computers and related equipment. (1)
In building the national capacity government is faced with a number of other challenges such ~s the promotion of a widespread uptake of the Internet by businesses and households which is one of the major challenges government has to face in the creation of the Information Society and Information Economy in Malta. Together with this government has to:
convince the Private Sector to invest in the adoption of e-Commerce solutions; (2) accelerate and upgrade those initiatives aimed at producing IT specialists in order to fill the shortage of labour supply that the country faces. This is planned to be achieved again through a partnership with the Private sector and by the implementation of strategies for a mixture of IT literacy in schools, life-Iong'learning, vocational training and tertiary education; (3) explore initiatives set at promoting universal use"of the Internet. This could be achieved through three potential initiatives which are the dissemination of e-mail on a
(1)
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
50
national scale, the creation of a Malta Internet Exchange and a National Free Maltese Internet; and (4) develop a high quality and affordable telecommunications infrastructure which could be achieved through the maximization of the current infrastructure and the liberalization of the telecommunications industry, a process that has already started and is at an advanced stage in Malta. The achievement of the Information Society and Information Economy in Malta requires a champion to drive the initiative in a focused and concentrated manner. A number of bodies in Malta have been created in the past with this in mind and the White Paper mentioned above identifies the Information Society and Economy Commission as this driver. This commission has been set up with the following terms of reference: (1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Identify quantifiable benchmarks for the development of an Information Society and Information Economy in Malta and monitor the achievement of these benchmarks on an annual basis. Promote the creation and development of an Information Society via the appropriate training initiatives both within and outside the ambit of formal educational structures. Recommend initiatives and programmes relative to training and human resources in specialized IT-related professions in order to support the Information Society and Information Economy in Malta as well as build an IT industry in Malta. Propose the necessary legal framework that is required for the regulation of all forms of electronic communication. Develop and implement awareness programmes on its own and in conjunction with government entities and the private sector, that are targeted at all sectors of the community and that will focus on the benefits and opportunities of the Information Society and Information Economy in Malta.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
51
(6)
Recommend measures to increase access to information and communication technologies at homes, schools, businesses and public offices, including measures aimed at those in the disadvantaged groups, (7) Recommend measures to government and"lworking with its institutions for and towards the attainment of the Information Economy. (8) Establish working groups and task forces to highlight specific sectoral issues with respect to the Information Society and Information Economy and develop and propose recommendations for action. (9) Work with government entities and the private sector to encourage Information Society and Information Economy initiatives in the delivery of the public services and information. (10) Monitor trends in IT legislation overseas and recommend legislation that will establish a framework for the attainment of an Information Society and Information Economy in Malta. (11) Align national objectives in the attainment of the Information Society and Information Economy with those of the European Union, to which Malta aspires to accede in the short-term. It is envisaged that all e-Governance Services will pass through one on-line portal. The portal is seen as the interface that brings together the services offered by government with its users and will be made up of a-three tier architecture. Access to the portal should be through multiple chan~els and service provision through the portal would be characterized, among others, by having access from a wide range of locations, a 24 hours 7 days a week service, seamless one stop-shopping for a range of Government Services from a number of Government Departments and increased efficiency. Key to the success of the Information Society and Information Economy in Malta is the security by which online transactions can be made. The portal would address a number of key features related to security and these are:
52
E-Governance Practic.es: A Glebal Perspective (1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5) (6) (7)
Secure authentication and d3.ta encryption processes and prevention from unauthorized use. A multi-step authorization process using private data stored in a Public Key Infrastructure (PKI)-protected vault on the e-Governance portal to achieve equivalent levels of information entropy to that provided by the private key used for e-signing. The super-registration of data by clients, on a voluntary basis, into a personal PKl- protected vault on the e-public service portal for data items such as digital photographs, income details, family details, phone contact details, roles in organization, etc. Access by government systems to the data in this vault would be totally under client side control. The super registration process would also be used for PKl registratiop. Data-protection compliance and multi-step authorization processing, which will be carried out at the e-Governance Portal by using the episode knowledge base and data held in the personal vaults. Electronic signing of HTML forms of XML or XSL files which are transferred to the e-Governance Portal. Electronic signature requirements for all interactions between the e-Governance Portal and back-end systems. Message digests for all client-side interactions that should be archived to deal with any contract or service delivery issues that might arise later on.
The Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) already mentioned above is the technology currently being adopted worldwide for the provision of online security and personal authentication. Whereas in other larger countries several certification authorities exist and a need for cross-certification is required, the Maltese scenario is such that a simple scaled down version of government PKI is used. The provision of e-Services can be conveyed through several routes with direct access from PC over the Internet being the most obvious channel. Yet other factors of social inclusion and public convenience would point to the utilization of alternative
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
53
channels. The exploration of these other alternative channels is required because of a relatively low level of Internet penetration (penetration rate in Malta is around 10%) together with unsatisfactory and expensive Internet serv~ce provision. The alternative channels mentioned above are mobile telephony, value added services through normal telephony, interactive TV, kiosks, over the counter service and call centres. The services provided are also varied and consist of the provision of information, transactional e-services, electronic commerce and e-Democracy. Currently a number of services are already available or pilot projects have been launched. Services that are already available are the listing of government tenders, government agencies and officials, national events, employment possibilities, public service information, budget expenditure, laws and regulations and government expenditure. These services are normally provided through the World Wide Web or e-mail but the level of utilization is either moderate or low. A number of other initiatives are being launched or planned. These are the provision of national statistics, national archives, tax information, payment ofbilIs, application forms, opinion polling and the provision of feedback by the citizen. The establishment of the Information Society and Information Economy requires a focused effort and requires that the concept is accepted and adopted by the people who will be using it. The White Paper mentions the development of a communications strategy to achieve this goal. Financing of the Information Society and Information Economy is mainly dependent on government yet other external sources such as the European Union and large international players in the field of IT should be explored.
(H) Mauritius Background Mauritius is situated in the south-west of the Indian Ocean, 2000 km. from the east coast of Africa. It is of volcanic origin and has been formed millions of years ago following two series of volcanic eruptions, separated by a long period of erosion. Volcanic activity has, however, completely ceased in Mauritius.
54
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
The island has an area of 1,864 sq.km. and is almost entirely surrounded by coral reefs. Mauritius has a maritime climate, tropical during summer and sub-tropical during winter. The island had for a long time remained unknown and uninhabited. It was probably visited by Arab sailors during the Middle Ages, and on maps of about 1500, it is shown by an Arabic name 'Dina Arobi'. In 1598, a Dutch squadron, under the orders of Admiral Wybrand Van Warwyck, landed at Grand Port and named the island Mauritius, in honour of Prince Maurice Van Nassau, 'Stathouder' of Holland. The first Dutch settlement lasted only twenty years. Several attempts were subsequently made, but the settlements never developed enough to produce dividends and the Dutch finally left Mauritius in 1710. They are remembered for the introduction of sugarcane, domestic animals and deer. Abandoned by the Dutch, the island became a French possession when, in September 1715, Guillaume Dufresne D' Arsel landed and took possession of this precious port of call on the route to India. He named the island Isle de France, but it was only in 1721 that the French started their occupation. The French stayed on the Island till 1810 until a strong British expedition was sent to capture the island due to raids by the corsairs on British trade ships. A preliminary attack was foiled at Grand Port in August 1810, but the main attack launched in December of the same year from Rodrigues, which had been captured a year earlier, was successful. The British landed in large numbers in the north of the island and rapidly overpowered the French. The British administration, which began with Robert Farquhar as governor, was followed by rapid social and economic changes. One of the most important events was the abolition of slavery in 1835. The planters received a compensation of two million pounds sterling for the loss of their slaves which had been imported from Africa and Madagascar during the French occupation. The abolition of slavery had important repercussions on the socio-economic and demographic fields. The planters turned to India, from where they brought a large number of indentured labourers to work in the sugarcane fields. Cultivation of sugarcane was given a boost and the island flourished, especially with the export of
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
55
sugar to hngland. Economic progress necessitated the extension and improvement of means of communication and gradually an adequate infrastructure was created. Use of E-Govemance The Presidential address at the opening of the First Session of the National Assembly lays down the agenda of the new government and i." his speech of the 3 October 2000 to the Third National Assembly the President stated that the development of information technology and telecommunications has been given top priority. Quoting the President Government is fully conscious of the importance of the 'new economy' of information and communication technology and the opportunities which it affords to countries like ours. Government will develop the Information Technology and Communications industry to increase national wealth, create new opportunities and jobs. Extensive deployment of information and communications technology will promote and democratise access to information. An intelligent village will be set up as a digital free zone to accelerate the development of the IT industry. The necessary incentive schemes and improved facilities will be provided to attract foreign investment. The use of IT in education is central to supporting the development of an efficient workforce for sustaining economic growth. Computer-aided learning facilities will be put in place right from the pre-primary level. Partnerships and alliances will be devised with local and international technology leaders to ,attract high calibre IT professionals to support and drive the net economy. The existing legal framework will be reviewed and consolidated to provide for the emergence of a knowledge society, and to create the right environment to boost the growth of-the IT industry. In addition, an IT Promotion Agency will be set up in order to market and promote Mauritius as a centre of excellence for information technology and telecommunications.
56
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
Government will lead the way by bringing its services closer to businesses and the people by implementing the concept of one-stop non-stop delivery channel. It will further leverage on existing infrastructure by setting up information kiosks in public areas including a modernized postal service to offer customized and value-added e-services. The way to e-Governance was initiated in 1996 with the government on the Internet project which had as its main objectives to put all ministries on the web. The websites of these ministries consist of information on the aims, objectives and services provided by the ministry to the public. Most of the ministries provide regular updates concerning new acts, publications and events. Despite the lack of interactivity on these sites, the access rate to these sites has been increasing with time. The government is paving the way to an e-Governance through numerous projects already undertaken. Such projects are Government on the Internet which is a portal to all ministries/ department websites initiated in 1996 and to date each ministry has a regularly updated website. The Contributions Network Project implemented under the Ministry of Finance, comprises the setting up of an electronic one-stop shop for all payments and contributions of the private sector to government. The electronic submission of Income Tax and VAT returns is operational since May 2000. The Tradenet project has been operational since 1994 under the Ministry of Finance. This system deals with the electronic authorization by customs for delivery of goods, the electronic submission of sea manifest by shipping agents, electronic declaration and processing of bills of entry and the transfer of containers. The Government Data Centre (GDC) aims at creating a 'Connected Government' through which public sector will communicate and work together more effectively and where services will be delivered to the public and private sector electronically in a timely manner. The GDC will have the responsibility of implementing electronic delivery of government services. In the long term, a full fledged GDC will offer the following services to public sector institutions from a central location wherever possible: Internet Access, Email, e-Governance Services, Government Call Centre, Helpdesk
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
57
for technical support, Intranet Services, Server Co-location facilities, Consultancy Services, Web Design and Development Services. Other projects are the Electronic Transfer of Deeds, while e-mail for the civil service, electronic procurement and electronic processing of permits are examples of future projects. On April 20, 2001, Cabinet has taken note of the proposed amendment to the Industrial and Vocational Training (Imposition of Levy) Regulations 1989 to make provision for employees to submit their returns electronically to the Ministry of Social Security, National Solidarity and Senior Citizen Welfare and Reform Institutions. In addition to this, government has furthermore laid stress on the e-Governance issue by its commitment to lead the way by bringing its services closer to businesses and the people by implementing the concept of one-stop non-stop delivery channel. It will further leverage on existing infrastructure by setting up information kiosks in public areas including a modernized postal service to offer customized and value-added e-Services. On 5th February 2001, a high-powered ministerial committee on ICT, chaired by the Prime Minister, was set up. Three taskforces set up under the aegis of this committee are 'Cybercities & Business Parks' headed by the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance, 'E-Education' headed by the Minister of Education & Scientific Research and 'e-Governance' headed by the Minister of Information Technology & Telecommunications. In the implementation of e-Governance projects the stakeholders are varied and include ministries, departments and other external agents depending on the project. The private sector, professional assqciations or NGOs are involved and examples of this partnership can be seen in the projects such as the Servihoo Portal which has as its objective to be the portal for the Republic of Mauritius, is a Telecom Plus initiative and provides personal email hosting, interactive chat, electronic gr,"eting cards, e-Commerce sales, forums, polls and guest book, another initiative is the Virtual Mauritius which is an e-Commerce platform to sell services including online shipping, real estate, insurance and entertainment and another initiative
58
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
is the Virtual Appeal Clip managed by an NGO called SPES and it depicts skills training using ICT to create a new generation creative and productive workforce from the marginalized illiterate kids at risk to themselves and to society. The implementation of this online activity has also brought about a number of lessons. It is clear that in the implementation of projects the commitment of top level people and that of users, standardization for better interconnectivity and practical security guidelines and policies to ensure a seamless but secure e-Governance system together with collaboration among the players for information sharing are critical enablers of e-Governance. On the other side of the coin are the issues that needed to be dealt with and for Mauritius these were managing the change especially with the users, ensuring that the commitment from top level people remained constant at all stages of the project, dealing with the legal changes to enable computerization and enhance standards for future integration and upgrades. (I) Mexico
Background Mexico has an area of 2 million square kilometres with a 9,000 km. coastline and a climate that varies from tropical to desert. By the early 1300 AD, the Aztecs established roots on an Island in lake Texcoco, site of present day Mexico City. In 1521 the Spanish explorer Hernan Cortez captured and razed the Aztec city, building a Spanish city in its place. In 1821, Mexican revolutionaries captured Mexico City and broke all ties with the Spanish crown. The city was occupied by the United States in 1847 during the Mexican War and by France for four years starting in 1862. Heavy fighting ensued from 1910 to 1915, the years of the Mexican Revolution. The end of the Revolutionary movement marked the beginning of a period of dramatic social changes which led to the creation of the Mexican Constitution of 1917. Widespread land reform and nationalization of the country's basic industries were achiev~d during the 1930's. The last 60 years have been characterized by industrial
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
59
.expansion, rapid population growth and political domination. In the first six years of the 1980's development slowed down as a result of a recessionary world economy. Vast austerity and strict debt restructuring measures were a direct result of that· decade for the Mexican economy. In the past few years, the Mexican Government has carefully tried to steer a new and prosperous Mexico in the direction of becoming a first-world economy. However, and despite the efforts in allying itself as partner in trade with Canada and the United States unexpected political and economical events in the early 1990's have conspired to delay achievement of this goal. Today Mexico has a GOP of 484 billion with 4 per cent growth in 1999. It has 23 Internet hosts for every 10,000 population, 112 telephone mainlines per 1000 population and 44 PCs per 1000 population. The population stands at around 100 million and it has a growth rate of 1 per cent. In the year 2000 Internet hosts numbered 41 per 10,000 population.
Use of E-Govemance The public sector in Mexico faces issues similar to those faced by other public sectors around the world and these are issues of transparency, lean governme.nt, deregulation, private-public partnerships, efficiency, e-Governance, etc. In addressing these issues e-Governance is seen as a tool for the development of a better public sector for Mexico. The Government of Mexico has initiated a number of initiatives that have placed it on the map of e-Governance. Some notable projects relate to access to government information. The pilot project Mexico On Line is developed by the President's Office. Its goal is to diminish the distance between the citizen and the government by involving the former in the public decision-making with a 24 hours a day 7 days a week digital broadcasting channel, working interactively with Internet users, crossing the country's geographic boundaries and allowing every connected Mexican in the world to be in touch with his/ her government. This channel is only the first step in a longterm Citizen's Participation Plan, which eventually will intensify online consultations.
60
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
The creators of Mexico On Line aim to break the old paradigms about the citizen-government relationship. By using the new technologies they seek to foster a democratic participative clJ.lture, where citizens can express their opinion, ask questions and solve their problems relating to governance/ government. To date, there has been a provision of informatIon, interactive facilities and routing of citizen concerns to the appropriate authorities. In the future, the service seeks to enhance its credibility, introduce opinion polling and provide consultation for public policy formulafion. The broadcasting channel can be found in the President's Webpage which also downloads free software for its use. At present the channel provides following main features: 0) Live broadcasting of the programme 'Mexico en Linea' (a 'phone-in' discussion programme). (2) Broadcasting of the President's Programme. (3) The radio programme transmitted by the President every Saturday is broadcast on this channel at the same time. (4) 24-hour Channel. (5) The remaining transmission time is dedicated to Mexican music and public campaigns supporting the federal government's programmes. Another initiative is direct access to laws, regulations, official documents and government programmes, electronic systems for the procurement of government, a social security system and the use of information technology in the educational sector. The Mexican Government also intends developing further the use of IT systems in order to improve the quality of service provided to citizens, carrying out studies to establish norms and standards for the application of IT in the provision of services to the citizen. The new tax administration system, is one such programme available on the Internet whose objective is to modernize and strengthen tax administration, ensuring that tax collection is carried out in an opportune and effective way. Another project is that of the federal register of transactions
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
61
which is a project developed by SEDOCAM and which incorporates the various transactions that are carried out by departments and various entities within the Public Sector. SEP has also developed a system, Tele-SEP, which consists of a system of transactions and services, public directories and general educational material contained in one database and also accessed by one telephone number or through the Internet. The Ministries of the Federal Public Administration all have an Internet site that describes the services offered to the citizens, the organizational structure, directory of the principal civil servants and the most important activities carried out. A large majority of local governments have a website which is used to consult information related to the different economic activities of the different governments, their industry, tourist attractions as well as state information. The Government of Nuevo Leon State is directly incorporating the concept of e-Governance. It is now offering the electronic payment of motor taxes and it is announcing that in this year the payment of house taxes, commercial taxes, water services, driving licence renewals and general citizens enquiries will be available through the Internet. The Mexican City Government better known as the Federal District provides not only information but also uses the benefits of commercial electronic banking to pay motor taxes and performs opinion polls about governance issues. In terms of consultation processes, a good example is Mexico's Citizen's Consultation and Participation System for Science and Technology. Soon after the presidentia"l elections of July, 2000, 'transition teams' were set up for different public issues. Their main goal was to define and plan the direction that the new government was to take on each topic. The Science and Technology Transition Team considered the use of the Internet for public consultation. The goal was to create an effective way of communication between the Transition Team
62
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
decision-making require a permanent consultation with all the actors involved. The Participation System on the Internet allowed the reception, classification, discussion and publication of the proposals made by the members of the science and technology community. It offered flexible catalogues for the classification of proposals, forums for discussion and a virtual library with statistics related to user's profile. The user could get information about previous proposals for his/her better participation, choose a topic, send a proposal and take part in a discussion forum. Besides, it gave him/her the option of making public his/her participation. Even though at the beginning it was only designed for the scientific community. It was later extended to the whole citizenry. Unfortunately, despite the positive experience, the system was not retained beyond its initial consultation phase. Another significant project was that for Citizen's Consultation for the 2001-2006 National Development Plan. The 2001-2006 National Development Plan (PND) represents the main Federation's planning instrument which contains not only the government's principles but also its objectives and strategies. It is the central document for the whole federal public administration and is legally approved by Congress. In December 2000, at the beginning of the new presidential period, a planning system was organized to promote citizen participation in a nation-wide programme whose purpose was to involve citizens in the drafting of the 2001-2006 National Development Plan. Public servants in government saw in this process a formal mechanism to note citizen's opinions, proposals and expectations about some relevant development issues at different levels: federal, local, municipal, family and even the individual level. Citizen participation was possible via mailed surveys and the Internet. Additionally, the ministries organized citizen meetings in which outstanding academics and opinion leaders participated. Proposals were collected on about 110 national issues classified under the three most important gc . .:rnment areas:
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
63
Human and Social Development. (2) Growth with Quality. (3) Law and Order.
(1)
A total of 117,040 questionnaires were received by the Internet and mailed surveys, and 196,854 proposals were withdrawn from them. The Internet page built for the PND extended the possibilities of participation, speeded the registration of opinions, and permitted the participation of Mexicans living abroad, who submitted over 43,000 proposals. The citizen's participation process represented a significant commitment by society and government. Suggestions were gathered and analyzed and many of them were included within the PND's objectives and strategies. All the proposals were sent to the different public agencies for their analysis and possible inclusion in the PND. Furthermore, all actions taken by society and government to work out the PND will provide important elements for institutional regional or local plans, thus furthering the PND's goals. There has been some concern that the compilation and integration of the proposals received were not clear to the public, because citizens were not able to verify if their proposals were being used, and if so, how. The offices responsible for the reception and management of the proposals within each ministry are not publicly known either. There are also some relevant cases of online consultation at the local level. A pilot project of online consultation is being conducted in Estado de Mexico (State of Mexico, http:! / gem.edomexico.gob. mx/portalgem/sectores.htm). The state government designed a Participation Programme for the Modernization of Fiscal Law for the year 2002, with the purpose of receiving by the Internet comments, suggestions and proposals for a legal reform at state and country levels. Another consultation process is the Consultation Forum for the Creation of a State Attorney for the Protection of the Environment. Inputs will be received by the Internet and through other media. All citizens are invited to participate, as
64
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
well as environmental organizations, universities and society in general. On the private and NGO sector side there are a number of websites that focus attention on Mexican Political, Social, Economic and Government Issues the most common of which are those related to the media. The website of the biggest Mexican Telephone Company, Telmex, shows the main political and government news and presents a daily opinion poll about what they consider the relevant issue of the day. The second largest biggest TV Mexican company, Television Azteca, also has a similar website to the former one.
E-Mexico Project The Mexican Government has adopted an ambitious plan to reduce the digital divide that exists in the country through the development of a national system called e-Mexico, that will allow the greatest possible part of the population to have access to ICTs (http://www.e-mexico.gob.mx). The purpose of this initiative is to enable citizens to communicate among themselves, with their government and with the rest of the world. The e-Mexico national system has as its main target to offer access to a series of contents and applications in the matter of education, health, commerce, tourism, government services and other community services, in order to contribute to quality of life as well as offering more opportunities to companies and promoting faster and more equitable development for all regions and communities, especially the most needy areas. The e-Mexico national system will provide sufficient telecommunications bandwidth to small communities to allow simultaneous Internet access for a minimum number of computer terminals in each community, as well as additional telephone lines so as to provide higher quality telecommunication services at lower prices. In the first phase of this project, 2,400 communities will be covered, to which in a second phase 10,000 points of presence will be added. Although the Federal Government is providing leadership and substantial economic support for the project, e-Mexico is a grid of distribution and information in which ministries, schools,
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
65
libraries, researchers and individuals as well as private operators are participating. It is intended as an integrating project of technological and operator convergence, linking existing public and private networks to generate synergy and advantages to benefit society.
(J) Morocco Background Telecommunications, postal services and information technology are a key sector of the Moroccan economy and are considered of vital importance for the achievement of the government's main growth, job creation and disparity-reduction targets. Major institutional reforms have been carried out in this area. . The Secretariat of State for Postal Services and Information and Communication Technology is the government agency that has been assigned the mission of bringing Morocco into the information age, promoting the development of a competitive and dynamic telecom industry in order to ready Morocco for the challenges of the 21st century, and making postal services more competitive by improving their management methods and bringing them up to the highest international standards. For this purpose, the Secretariat plans to: 0) Ensure access to telecom, postal and IT services for Moroccan businesses in order to improve their competitiveness. The Secretariat considers it critically important that optimal conditions of timing, quality and price be met in satisfying business demand for such services. The range of available services must also be wide enough to meet the expressed demand. (2) Ensure access to modern means of communication and information for the disadvantaged and inhabitants of remote areas. For this purpose, the Secretariat is working with other appropriate government agencies to define objectives with respect to land-use planning and universal telecom and postal service, with a view to guaranteeing sufficient coverage of needs at a reasonable cost to the general public and to operators. It is working
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
66
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
to put in place the necessary mechanisms to ensure that providers of postal and telecom services can carry out their public service mission effectively and in a manner that is responsive to public needs. Promote modernization and efficiency in the government administration and particularly in public institutions that provide social services in the fields of education and health care, by expanding their access to information technology and developing their capacity to use IT effectively. Improve the overall performance of postal services and increase their financial self-sufficiency by developing all segments of the postal market (new, higher-quality services, long-term improvement of the quality of all services) and enhancing productivity. Gradually liberalize the postal market, streamline regulations and offer the private sector opportunities for greater participation. Grant postal operator BAM sufficient financial and commercial independence to make it a modern, dynamic business operating in an increasingly competitive environment. Promote the development of postal financial services in order to give a larger segment of the population access to financial services (savings, credit and insurance products), particularly in the country's most remote rural areas; to mobilize savings and use them to stimulate private investment and the development of financial markets; and to diversify the postal operator's sources of revenue at a time of growing liberalization of postal services, redefinition of the State monopoly in the area, and transformation of BAM's legal status. Support the emergence of new economic activities in Morocco based on IT development and use.
Use of E-Govemance Institutional Achievements The legislative and institutional framework for postal services,
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
67
telecommunications and information technology has been overhauled. The changes include: (1) Morocco's signing of to the World Trade Organization
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(WTO) Agreement on Basic Telecommunications, of which it was one of the main architects. The enactment of Act 24/96 in August 1997, allowing competition in all segments of the telecommunications market and the privatization of the historic carrier. The Act provided for the separation of postal and telecom operations through the creation of a public postal institution (BAM) and an independent telecommunications company (lAM). It also e5tablished a telecommunications regulatory agency (ANRT) reporting to the Prime Minister. The enactment of 15 decrees and executory orders under Act 24/96. With respect to interconnection, an executory decree established general principles for interconnection, a dispute settlement mechanism, required elements of interconnection contracts, and general technical and pricing principles for interconnection services. Other executory decrees regulate leased lines and ini:roduce a list of value-added services that may be provided following a simple declaration to the regulator. The adoption of an 'information technology development plan', which wU.s finalized and made public. The' online government' initiative, aimed at linking all departments and their staff, was announced by the Government Council on October 28 and should be fully operational by the end of 200l. The 'e-commerce initiative' was launched with the drafting of regulatory texts on electronic data exchange and electronic signatures, and approval for three Moroccan companies to provide e-Commerce services on national platforms. A bill on intellectual property, with a specific section on information technology, was introduced in Parliament.
68
E-Governance Prac~1ccs: A Global Perspective
At the same time, significant progress has already been made toward full liberalization of telecommunications and opening up the industry to the private sector, including: (1) The granting of a second licence for mobile telephone
(2)
(3) (4)
(5) (6)
services using GSM technology tp a consortium led by Telefonica of Spain and Portugal Telecom, in August 1999. The granting of two licences to operate GMPCS networks for the provision of digital paging and localization services, as well as telephony, fax and data transmission, in the first half of 2000. The granting of three licences for VSA T telecommunications networks, in March 2000. The approval of more than 1,800 Internet service providers (ISPs) and Internet cafes, many of which are subsidiaries of EU-based operators. The decision by the Moroccan Government in January 2000 to fully liberalize the telecom industry. With respect to postal services, authorization for four private firms to offer attractive products that meet market demand for fast, reliable international delivery of documents and parcels.
Infrastructure Achievements Considerable effort has already been made toward achieving the objectives listed above. With respect to telecommunications, the number of telephone lines increased from 260,000 at the end of 1987 to 1.5 million in 1999. The average waiting time for installation of a line has been cut from 80 months to 1.4 months (including rural areas). The transmission network's capacity has increased from almost 4,000 to 466,000 circuits, using primarily fibre-optic technology. The use of SDH fibre-optic technology and the near-total digitization of transmission and switching systl!ms have substantially improved network reliability and now support an expanded range of services including videotex, ISDN, Internet and high-speed links. The number of automated rural communes has increased from 65 to 1,058, or 82 per cent of the 1,297 rural communes. The number of payphones
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
69
increased from 484 at the end of 1987 to 36,000 at the end of 1999,83 per cent of which are managed by private operators. As of January 2001, there were over 2.7 million subscribers to NMT-450 and GSM-900 cellular systems, which cover the main roads and the administrative centres of all the prefectures and provinces of the Kingdom. The near-total digitization of transmission and switching systems, and the development of new networks, have noticeably improved service quality and reliability. The Internet, introduced in November 1995, is spreading slowly but surely. There are now 'over 1,800 ISPs and Internet cafes, with over 200,000 subscribers to Internet service and steady growth in the Internet cafe market. There has been explosive growth in computers since 1991 as a result of lower prices and lower import duties, which were cut from 42.5 per cent to 17.5 per cent on January I, 1996. Moroccans own an estimated 200,000 personal computers, for a penetration rate of 0.7 per cent. Annual sales vary between 40,000 and 50,000 units. The number of computer firms is estimated at over 800; they employ an estimated total of 4,000 people and have annual sales of about 3 billion dirhams (DH). Initiatives to improve the management of postal services are also in progress. The creation of Barid Al-Maghrib (BAM) in 1998 established a platform for sustainable improvement in order to enhance the effectiveness of postal services. BAM has produced a corporate strategy and investment plan for the 19992003 period. A study is being conducted to recommend appropriate business structures and systems to support efficient implementation of the strategic options. New products have appeared and new partnerships have been established to offer more and higher-quality financial services. The expanded network of points of sale, consisting of 2,400 retail locations, offers partners (banks and insurance companies) an attractive opportunity to reach new regions and new customers who are not being served at present. Management of postal cheques and of the national savings bank has been computerized, delivering steady improvements
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
70
in service: New IT -based fund transfer services have been introduced, including electronic money orders and access to the Eurogiro network for foreign transfers. New domestic express mail services have been launched (Poste rapide nation ale, Rapid'j and Rapid'H). Pilot cyber-mail sites have been installed at post offices and universities. For the second year in a row, BAM reported healthy earnings (approximately 92.7 million DH in 1999, compared with 55 million DH in 1998).
Development of Telecom Infrastructure Since telecommunications is a key sector and an engine of economic growth in Morocco, the objective is to increase competitiveness and promote the development of a competitive, dynamic telecom industry that can bring Morocco into the information age. Therefore, the Secretariat of State intends, among other things, to: (1) Promote the development of the telecommunications
c:n (3) (4) (5)
(6) (7)
infrastructure required for new multimedia applications. Extend access to telecom services to all segments of the population and to all parts of the country. Expand the telecom market. Promote competition in all segments of the telecom market. Revise the regulatory framework for telecommunications services to allow the use of alternative infrastructures and strengthen the competitive environment, so as to spur development of the telecommunications market. Ensure availability of and access to business services that can increase business competitiveness. Strengthen Morocco's role as a regional telecommunications platform.
To this end, the following actions will be taken.
Extension of Fixed Public Telecommunications Network Despite the broad geographic reach of the fixed public telecommunications network and coverage of all the rural
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
71
commune seats and many other centres, sustained effort is still required in order to increase teledensity, particularly in rural areas and the urban periphery. (1) The government's target in this area is a telephone
density of at least 10 per cent by 2005 and 15 per cent by 2012. (2) Public telephones are to increase from 1.14 per 1,000 people at present to 2 by 2005 and 4 by 2012. (3) The service quality target, as measured by the malfunction reporting rate per subscriber per year, is 20 per cent by 2005 and 10 per cent by 2012.
Extension of Cellular Network Mobile telephony is the segment of the telecommunications market that is posting the strongest growth rates and generating the most value-added. To meet the growing demand for cellular services, efforts will be made to increase network density, diversify services and improve service quality. The network density target calls for coverage of all the main rqads linking the provinces and the prefectures. . The service quality effort will focus on improving coverage in the urban periphery and inside buildings in urban centres. The diversification objective is to expand the line of services to include data transmission, Internet access and messaging. Because of the spectacular growth of mobile telecommunications and demand for broadband multimedia services,....the establishment of third-generation (lMT-2000) cellular systems must be accelerated. The government's objective in this area is to make frequencies available for such systems and to put in place a system for granting licences and defining licence content.
Development of National High-speed Telecommunications Infrastructure In order to create a telecommunications infrastructure capable of carrying the flow of traffic for services that require high transmission speeds, such as high-speed Internet,
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective videoconferencing, radio and television broadcasting, and applications such as medical imaging, the government has set the following medium- and long-term objectives: (1) Continue rolling out high-speed transmission and
switching networks. (2) Step up the migration of public fixed telecommunications networks to IP-based systems. (3) Link all PBXs to a backbone. (4) Extend high-speed access 'to the doorstep' of all administrative and business customers in the medium term an4 of all residences in the longer term. (5) Establi¥t alternative infrastructures. (6) Condu~t a feasibility study for a national multiservice satellite system.
Intemet Since the Internet is increasingly becoming the standard for the exchange of all types of economic, commercial and cultural information, the government plans to promote wider Internet use. In addition to extending the telecommunications infrastructure, certain measures need to be taken specifically to support Internet development: (1) Improve terms of access to and interconnection with
public telecommunications systems for ISPs. (2) Extend the MARWAN academic network, a high-speed information system designed to promote research and training. (3) Develop national content on the Internet. (4) Computerize the schools and introduce IT into education at all levels. (5) Increase the number of graduates in the field and retrain unemployed graduates in IT. (6) Implement the 'online government' programme. (7) Set up public telecentres with Internet access. (8) Use IT as a land-use planning tool by launching digital city projects and developing local portals and a unifying national portal.
E-Governance Practices: A Global PerspectIve
73
(9) Develop national e-Commerce platforms.
Expansion of Rural Service Developing telecommunications infrastructures in rural areas will help stabilize the population, provide access to basic services, improve agricultural production and promote the emergence of non-agricultural activities. The objective here is to achieve teledensity of at least 3.5 per cent by 2005 and 7 per cent by 2012, and to install at least one payphone in every community with a population of more than 250 by 2005 and in every community with a population of more than 100 by 2012.
Linkage to Global Systems Linking Morocco to global cable and satellite systems will provide the country with a complementary, secure and diversified infrastructure for services (voice, data and image) and global connectivity, and will strengthen its role as a leading regional platform for telecommunications. To do this, the government intends to implement a policy to facilitate linkage to global systems for Moroccan operators.
Universal Service and Wide Access to Basic Telecommunications To promote the welfare of vulnerable populations and reduce regional disparities, the government plans to carry out the following initiatives in the medium and long term: Set price caps for universal service. (2) Introduce measures that address the following objectives:
(1)
(i)
Hi)
Expand local calling areas in order to gradually reduce disparities in access to the fixed public network between residents of large urban centres and subscribers to small- and medium-capacity systems; Reduce the rate gap between local calls and domestic long-distance calls;
74
E-Govemance Practices: A Global Perspective (iii) Introduce special rates for people with disabilities, the elderly and low-income people to provide the following benefits: (a) lower subscription rates; (b) connection charge payable in instalments; (c) adapted communications interfaces for people with disabilities (e.g., voice dialling, TTY). (3) Expand and adapt universal service to keep pace with technological change and user requirements.
Strengthening the Role of the Private Sector Having taken the first major steps of opening up telecommunications services to the private sector and to competition, the priority now is to allow private investment in Itissalat al Maghrib (lAM), the main public telecommunications operator. The government believes this is necessary to enable lAM to position itself effectively in the fast-changing domestic and international telecom markets. An international call for tenders was published in October 2000 in order to select a strategic partner; as a result, Vivendi has acquired a 35 per cent interest in lAM. The transaction will be followed by a public offering of a portion of lAM's stock on international and domestic equity markets. The public offering should help integrate lAM into the world telecommunications market, develop the domestic capital market and strengthen our presence on foreign markets. To support this process, the government took several measures prior to the call for tenders to choose a strategic investor: (1) Publication of the revised interconnection agreement,
which lAM offers to all new entrants and competitors to ensure consistency with international best practices and with pricing systems in other competitive markets. (2) Definition of the principles of the universal service and land-use planning system, particularly how it will apply to lAM in the long term and during the transition period
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
75
which will follow the current situation, in which lAM is the only :)rovider of these services.
Accelerating the Liberalization Process The government is of the view that increased competition will yield faster growth in the telecommunications industry as a whole and improved performance. It has therefore decided to speed up the process of liberalization in telecommunications services so that the industry will be completely open in 2002, under rules that are transparent and fair to both new and existing operators. The following specific measures are planned in order to further liberalize the telecommunications sector: (1)
(2) (3) (4)
(5) (6)
(7)
Expand the range of services that can be offered by simple declaration. Process all additional GMPCS licence applications. Grant telecommunications licences for trunked radio systems. Issue a telecommunications licence for the marketing of non-voice systems nationwide and another for non-voice long-distance services; voice services will follow. Issue two licences for international telecommunications covering all the services. As stipulated by its licence, the second GSM operator will be authorized to build its own domestic infrastructure immediately and to provide international service using its own facilities. More generally, the government intends to grant other licences in order to guarantee users a choice between differelilt operators in all market segments, with a view to total liberalization of the tclecom market.
Improving the Regulatory Framework for Liberalization While the quality and credibility of the regulatory framework for telecommunications were clearly demonstrated by the successful issuance of the second GSM licence, the Secretariat of State believes the following improvements are necessary:
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspecti,.ve
76
Amend Act 24/96 in order to (i) allow the national telecommunications regulatory agency (ANRT) to set graduated penalties for violations of the Act, regulations and licences; (ii) replace the ANRT's a priori controls with a posteriori controls; (iii) finalize the separation of the National Postal and Telecommunications Institute (INPT) from the ANRT. (2) Ensure consistency between the Competition Act and Act 24/96, and take the necessary steps to permit a smooth transition from specific telecommunications regulations to general competition regulations as the telecom market becomes truly competitive. (3) Ensure that the ANRTconducts public consultations and publishes its decisions, including rationale, so as to increase regulatory transparency.
(1)
Postal Services For postal services, the Secretariat of State's objective is to offer citizens in all parts of Morocco high-quality service at the lowest price. It is planning major reforms in the sector in order to increase BAM's competitiveness and efficiency, gradually liberalize the sector, and enable postal financial services to more effectively mobilize small savings.
Information Technology Information technology is vital in modern society and must therefore be considered a strategic sector thelL makes a significant contribution to economic and social development. The Secretariat of State's priority is to promote IT applications in 0) education and training; (2) government administration, through implementation of the "online government" initiative; (3) the upgrading of businesses; (4) culture; (5) closing the digital divide; (6) supporting decentralization and land-use planning.
Adoption of Legal ~nd Regulatory Framework Building an information society, the main goal of any telecom development policy, requires an appropriate legal and regulatory environment which creates confidence and provides
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
77
a framework for the use of information technology, and which is capable of adapting to fast-paced technolog;cal change. The Secretariat of State's action programme in this area consists in improving and adapting legal and regulatory texts related to: '(1) The protection of privacy, by instituting disclosure and
(2) (3) (4) (5)
authorization procedures for the creation and use of personal files, and an entitlement for citizens to access their files and make corrections. The confidentiality and security of electronic communications and transactions. The evidentiary weight of electronically transmitted data and electronic signatures. Consumer protection. Adaptation of the tax system and customs code to eCommerce.
Data Standardization The development of advanced information exchange systems and the networking of databases and information systems necessitates the standardization of data and protocols, in accordance with international standards. The availability of technical standards and standardized data would enable businesses and administrations to improve their organization, their information systems and their databases, and facilitate the introduction of electronic data exchange mechanisms. Before embarking on the standardization process, the government is conducting a study in order to establish a standardization body, which will conduct the standardization process (establish standards), coordinate the standardization of information by administrations and professional organizations, develop standardized databases containing public or sectoral information, and define the encoding and the formats for the exchange of electronic data.
Online Govemment The government will use IT as an instrument to modernize Morocco's administration. The objective is to promote
78
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
information access and exchange between the administration, citizens and businesses through online processes. Efforts in this area will be directed toward: (1)
(2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
Integrating common services and applications. Realizing economies of scale. Introducing standard data exchange procedures. Ensuring data security. Bringing the administration closer to citizens. Outsourcing some operations.
Upgrading Businesses and E-Commerce The spread of information technology in business, particularly SMEs, is an important issue for Morocco's economy. The development of networks, mobile communications and multimedia, and the use of these technologies by business, is not just a matter of productivity enhancement but also an opportunity for businesses to conquer new markets otto make themselves stand out from the competition by developing new services related to their products, which will help generate growth and jobs. Since e-Commerce helps spur the introduction of IT by businesses, the Secretariat of State is working to facilitate access to and use of e-Commerce by means of appropriate incentives, including tax incentives. At the same time, the agency is preparing a legal and regulatory framework designed to build confidence and create conditions conducive to the promotion of e-Commerce. The agency is particularly interested in promoting, in partnership with the chambers of commerce and crafts, the development of virtual trade shows that offer services and products in areas such as tourism, handicrafts and agriculture.
Decentralization and Land-use Planning IT is unquestionably a useful instrument for integrating and developing land-use policy, deconcentration and decentralization. (2) The main objective in this area is to ensure better distribution of communication and information
(1)
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
79
infrastructures and equitable access to those infrastructures in terms of technical conditions and pricing. For this purpose, the Secretariat of State will implement a strategy organized around the following priorities: (1) Creation of community telecentres providing all
segments of the population with access to communication and information services, including the Internet, on the most economical terms, and reducing the isolation of rural areas. The government's objective is to open a community telecentre in each commune. (2) Creation of a conducive environment for the development of distance services such as distance education, telemedicine and remote information services. The Secretariat of State plans to promote their use, in partnership with local communities, by creating 'city portals' in order to: (1) publicize local economic, cultural and tourism potential; (2) facilitate information access and exchange at the local and inter-regional levels; (3) promote the development of distance services; and (4) develop virtual commercial showcases for local products.
Presentation of the Cultural Heritage The movement toward an information society provides an opportunity to strengthen Morocco's cultural identity through digitization of the cultural heritage and its dissemination, whkh can be increased exponentially through the use of IT. The heritage digitization policy will pursue the following objectives: (1) create electronic archiving systems at the administrations; (2) promote public access through (3) digitization of heritage collections and the general library and archives; and (4) creation of multimedia cultural spaces.
Education and Training The far-reaching impact of IT in the fields of education and training calls for a strategy and action programme in order to:
80
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective (1) popularize IT tools in educational institutions; (2) introduce basic computer training in primary and secondary schools; (3) generalize computer training and Internet use in all institutions of higher learning; and (4) increase the number of connections supported by the MARWAN network in order eventually to link up the entire education and training system.
This programme must be accompanied by measures to increase the student capacity of training institutions in disciplines related to information and communication technology. In addition, another programme aimed at retraining unemployed graduates in IT trades and educating government officials and employees in multimedia tools and the Internet has been launched.
(K) New Zealand Background The Government of New Zealand published its vision for eGovernance in May, 2000. This recognizes that the key forces of change-including globalization, the rise of knowledge economies and new technology-are transforming the relationship between government, business and society. Public attitudes and expectations of government in more mature societies are changing quickly and the government acknowledges that it must change the way it relates to the public it serves. Indeed, the creation of e-Governance is perceived as a key to New Zealand's future social well-being through its focus on better understanding and meeting individual New Zealander's needs and creating opportunities for greater public participation in government and democratic processes. In addition, at a third of that country's Gross Domestic Product, government activity constitutes a large part of the economy. In this context, value for money looms as a very significant objective. A number of examples of e-Governance are already in evidence in New Zealand. They range from the New Zealand Government Online website (http://www.govt.nz). to being able to register a new
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
81
company on the Internet (http://www.companies.govt.nz.) or to getting comprehensive statistical information about New Zealand from Statistics New Zealand's website. The task for the government is to build on these individual initiatives and develop them into a comprehensive plan for achieving the benefits of e-Governance more widely on behalf· of all New Zealanders. The planned development of eGovernance aims to .improve the ability of all people to participate in the democratic process. But, left to develop by itself, e-Governance has the potential to create new divisions in society between those who have the skills and tools to use the new technologies and those who do not. E-Governance is expected to improve government in four important ways: (1) It
will be easier for people to have their say in government. For example, the introduction of new administrative measures will be subjected to public feedback through electronic means. (2) People will get better services from government organizations. For example, public transactions can be done round the clock and from geographically remote locations. This will be of particular benefit to those thousands of New Zealanders who do not live in the main centres of population. This will improve flexibility, speed and access to government services, and will lower the cost of government. (3) People will receive more integrated services because different government organizations will be able to communicate more effectively with each other. For example, reporting an incident or change in domestic circumstances would be shared between different institutions, and a person need only go through that process once instead of several times. (4) People will be better informed because they can get upto-date and comprehensive information about government laws, regulations, policies and services, and would go about their leisure or business in a more informed and compliant manner.
E-Governance Pr,1c~lces: A Global Perspective
82
The State Services Commission (SSC) has been taskeq with the coordination and delivery of e-Governance. Within the next five or so years, New Zealanders should be able to do the following: 0) Electronically register information with the government-for example, births, deaths and marriages-at a time and place that suits them. (2) Conduct their financial dealings with government organizations electronically. (3) Complete and send all government forms from one place on the Government's Internet site. (4) Have their say on a wide range of government proposals and policies through the Internet. (5) Benefit from high quality health care from a public health service that provides integrated and personalized services from GP to specialist to hospital to pharmacist based on individual patient record management made possible through comprehensive and highly secure information sharing and analysis. (6) Have confidence that effective controls backed up by good legislation will safeguard privacy. (7) Benefit- from the reduced costs and time involved in property transactions because land survey and title information is available electronically and transactions can be registered the same way. (8) Notify changes of address, so that one entry on 'the Internet can ensure multiple Government agencies are notified automatically. The e-Governance vision is seen as supporting two important goals. T!'tey are: 0) Restoring trust in government and providing strong social services. (2) The e-Governance vision will play an important role in achieving this goal. It will (i)
increase collaboration between government organizations;
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
83
(in strengthen the relationship between people and the state through greater opportunities for participation; and (iii) provide the state sector with an opportunity to improve' the effectiveness and efficiency of their services to the public while, at the same time, reducing the cost of delivery. Those three factors will help restore trust in government and provide strong social services. (3) Helping grow an inclusive, innovative economy for the benefit of all. New Zealand's ,e-Governance vision emphasis inclusionthe ability of all people to take part in the economy. It is also seen to complement well similar developments in business and commerce. Together, e-Governance, e-Business and e-Commerce will play an import';lnt role in the development of an economy based on the combined impact of the knowledge and skills of all New Zealanders.
E-Govemance Programme The e-Governarlce programme and the e-Governance Unit within the State Services Commission were formally established for four years on the 1st July, 2000. The role of the e-Governance Unit, as agreed ?y Cabinet, embraces: (1)
(2) (3)
(4) (5)
Strategy:, Develop and manage the delivery pf an overar'hing e-Governance strategy, as well as supporting policies, standards and guidelines. Leadership: Facilitate uptake by government agencies of the.e"Governance vision, Coordination/Collaboration: Identify opportunities for collaboration across government agencies; leverage existing il"lformation management and technology investment, and provide coordination. Policy: Provide e-Governance policy advice to the Minister of State Services. Monitoring: Monitor progress toward achievip.g the e-Governance vision.
84
E-Governance Practices: A Glol5al Pwspective
The E-Governance Unit has a central role in defining and achieving the government's objectives for c-Govcrnance. The delivery of e-Governancc is the responsibility of all government agencies in partnership with the Unit. Public Service departments and some other government organizations have nominated e-Governance agency leaders who meet monthly. The role of the agency leader is to drive the implementation of e-Govcrnance in their organization. Responsibilities include acting as a conduit for two way communication between their organization and the EGovernance Unit, ensuring mandatory requirements from the programme are included into their organization's work plan and working within their organization to ensure that the approach to online service delivery is consistent with the policies and standards developed in the e-Governance programme. Two CIO (Chief Information Officer) networks support the managers who are accountable for the design and delivery of the technical and information management dimensions of e-Governance. The CIO networks (one for policy departments and one for operational departments) typically focus on the implementation of the interoperability framework, technical standards and guidelines, and leveraging of go\ternment IT infrastructure. An e-procurement network concentrates on' establishing a common approach for government to procurement, including syndicated procurement and e-procurement. The E-Governance programme consists of a number of projects. These range from policy development and implementation, development of standards and guidelines to delivery of solutions and applications. These are outlined below:
Authentication The authentication project is looking at ways of ensuring that government services delivered over the Internet are going to the right person. This will be achieved by electronically verifying that people are who they say they are, and that privacy is protected at all times.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
85
Awareness of e-Govemance Activity This project is aimed at keeping central and local government people up to date with what is happening on electronic government projects. It one of several activities to ensure government agencies are ready for e-Governance.
Electronic Billing and Payments A strategy for a whole of government approach to electronic billing and payment systems is under development. This would enable government agencies to carry out financial transactions securely over the Internet, either between each other or with people and business. Geo.~patial Information
Addresses, road and place names make up what is called geospatial information. This information can be shared over the Internet. Geospatial information is vital for a wide range of government functions. For example, it is necessary for running an election-registering people against the correct electoral district and Territorial Authority, or helping to achieve emergency services' responses, the management of civil defence emergencies, or underpinning land use decisions. The government is now looking to make sure that address, road and place name information used nationally is fit for these purposes, consistent, up to date, and readily accessible. When the New Zealand government portal website is launched in July 2002, geospatial information will be present behind the scenes allOWing you to search for informatiori relating to a specific geographical area, for example school zones or police stations.
Govemment Information Discovery (GUIDE) The government portal will be useful only if the information and services made accessible are described consistently. The GUIDE project is taking care of the way in which government information and services-online and offline-are described now and how those descriptions should be managed over time. These descriptions are called meiadata. The reason government is not just describing online government information and
86
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
services, is that it is useful for people to know where they need to go or who they need to call to carry out other government related tasks.
Government Portal This portal is a single website giving structured access to other web sites, in this case, the websites of New Zealand government agencies. It is a convenient way of finding out about government information and services from one place, without having to understand how government is structured and therefor~ which sites you need to use. Portals are usually grouped by industry or sector type, for example, health, education, building industry. They are sometimes organized by types of services, for example registration and licensing, or purchasing. The New Zealand government portal will be a website providing search capability for, and links into the online and offline information and services of most government agencies.
Government Services Online The vision for e-Governance in New Zealand is that citizens will be able to find public information and services within government departments quickly and easiIy over the Internet. - Between August and November 2001 the Government Services Online project will identify the most useful services. These services were made available through the portal website from June 2002.
Government Web Guidelines The primary goal of this e-Governance project is to ensure government websites are accessible to the people using them. People cannot be excluded from government services and information provided over the Internet because of disability or . lack of reliable access to high-speed technology. The guidelines will detail how government websites should be built so that everyone can use them.
Internet SkilIs of Public Servants This project will encourage the adoption by government of
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
87
training schemes to ensure public servants use the Internet in an efficient and productive way. It is one several activities to ensure that government agencies are ready for e-Governance.
InteroperabiJity Framework The business systems and processes supported by information technology (IT) that exist within each government agency will need to agree some common practices of making information available. Each government agency runs its own business and technology systems. The Interoperability Framework project will introduce an agreed, standardized system of decision-making processes about investment, development and management of IT resources. These standard processes will be used where age,ncies work together to provide information and services to the public.
Leveraging Infrastructure 'Leveraging infrastructure', means using more effectively the government's existing technical capabilities throughout its central, regional and local agencies. Infrastructure includes staff, business processes, computer hardware and software. The project has now analyzed the current infrastructure and has proposed a first draft of a technical architecture. The work will be taken forward by the Interoperability Framework project.
National Infonnation Infrastructure Protection (NIIP) NIIP seeks to improve the protection of New Zealand's critical infrastructure from cyber attacks. New Zealand people and business depend on the continuing supply of various services such as power, telecommunications and health care. Critical infrastructure includes the wires, machines, and software needed to make this happen, such as power lines and telephone exchanges. NIIP seeks to bolster the protection of this critical infrastructure from cyber-threats such as computer misuse and hacking.
Procurement The government is looking at ways to smarten up how it buys
88
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
goods and some services. It is doing this various ways, including syndicated procurement is where government agencies can collectively purchase goods and services such as electricity, fuel, motor vehicles and travel. This will result in savings from lower prices, improved terms and conditions and reduced costs of tendering. Syndicated procurement builds on the strategic sourcing approach being taken by leading government agencies. Strategic sourcing enables an agency to define and consolidate their requirements for all goods and services, understand the supply market, and negotiate with suppliers.
Secure Electronic Environment The Secure Electronic Environment Project is developing solutions so public servants can securely work together over the Internet.
Shared Policy Workspace Often more than one government agency contributes to the development of a single policy. By implementing a shared policy workspace people from different government agencies in different locations will be able to use the Internet to work on policy documents to develop policy that cuts across several areas. (1) Republic of Korea
Background The Korean Government has a long history of IT -based administration. It set up the 1st Office Automation Project which computerized several statistics (1978-1982), and the 2nd Office Automation Project which computerized civil service personnel, payments, pensions, etc. (1983-1986). Subsequently, the 1st Public Business Networking Project developed six networks such as the People's Identification Data Network, the Land Registry Data Network, the Vehicle Registry Data Network, the Employment Network, the CustomsClearance Management Network (1987-1991). This was followed by the 2nd Public Business Networking Project which developed many networks (1992-1996)-the Post Office Network, the Welfare Network, the Fishing Boat Management Network, the
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
89
Customs Clearance Electronic Document Exchange Network, the Industry Property Right Management Network, the Meteorological Information Network, the Office Supplies Catalogue Management Network, the Economy and Trade Network, the Agriculture Technique Management Network, the Environmental Protection Network, the Inland Revenue Network. Networks were established separately without regarding interoperability.
E-Governance Vision and Strategy In 1998, the Ministry of Government Administration and Home Affairs published its Vision and Strategy for e-Governance: Toward 21st century electronic government. The report aimed to promote a knowledge-based government which delivers high quality service and does best work through IT-based innovation. The strategy aims to: (1) Deliver one-stop service to every citizen any time,
anywhere. (2) At least match the private sector performance. (3) Be transparent and customer-friendly. For these purposes, the government set up six initiatives: (1) To deliver information and service electronically. (2) To re-engineer business process and exchange electronic documents. (3) To share information resources and protect privacy. (4) To establish information technology standards and connect all PCs to the network. (5) To promote civil servants' IT literacy. (6) To modify laws and rules for .electronic business.
The Vision and Strategy for e-Governance consists of three development stages. The first stage (1998-1999) was a preparatory period for an electronic governance: (1) Connecting government departments and administra-
tions with the administrative intranet.
90
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective (2) Undertaking pilot projects. (3) Sharing key public data.
The second stage (2000-2001) is the construction period for integrated information: (1) Connecting central and local governments with a
network. (2) Exchanging electronic documents among the central and local governments. (3) Giving public servants e-mail addresses and Internet access. The third stage (2002) is the operationalization period for electronic govern men t: (1) Exchanging electronic documents between the public
sector and the private sector. (2) Constructing open and transparent government. (3) Supporting policy, etc. In 1999, the Action Plan for e-Governance, incorporating the following actions, was published: For one-stop and non-stop service the government will develop: (1) a Comprehensive Information System that connects 21
data networks, (2) the Electronic Ombudsman System, (3) the Family Record Online System, and (4) a Web-based Service Delivery Systems. For diversifying electronic service delivery routes: (1) an Integrated Call Centre, and
(2) an Integrated Kiosk System. For open government: (1) the Government Information Locator Service,
(2) the Open Government Service, (3) the Local Administration Information Bank, and (4) Web Bulletin Board Service of Local Governments.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
91
For promoting government productivity: (1)
(2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7)
business process reengine~ring, electronic document exchange between public entities, electronic document management, government knowledge management, personal resource information management, electronic organization management, and personnel and payment integration.
For interoperability: data storing and sharing, (2) defence against hackers and viruses, and (3) backup systems.
(1)
For infrastructure the government will develop: (1)
(2) (3) (4) (5)
the government intranet, data code standardization, information technology and resource standardization, public key infrastructure, and key management infrastructure.
For civil servants' information literacy: electronic mail addresses for all office workers, (2) training opportunities for all officials, (3) testing opportunities, and (4) the Cyber Training Centre.
(1)
For institutional solutions the government aims to: to amend laws and rules, (2) enhance the Chief Information Officer functions, and (3) enhance cross-departmental information resource management. (1)
Implementation of E-Governance
Networking Public Entities The Government Superhighway Network (GSN) connects three government complexes within a 160 km. radius and almost all
92
E-Governance Practi~es: A Global Perspective
departments and administrations are fully connected with the GSN. All of the 16 provincial government networks are also connected and all of the 232 municipal government networks have been recently connected. However, some small and remote governmental branches require a satellite solution.
Empowering Public Servants Korean public servants number approximately 800,000 (including provincial and municipal personnel but excluding military personnel). Office workers comprise 73,000. Personal computers are used by about 86 per cent of the office workers. All of the PCs are connected with LAN. E-mail addresses are used by about 91 per cent of the office workers. However, Korean public documents are not exchanged via email, but via groupware called electronic document systems. The electronic document systems are distributed to all departments and administrations, all provinces and most of the 232 municipalities. Government is also planning to train all public servants to deal with IT.
Electronic Document Exchange Korean departments and administrations have exchanged electronic documents for several years. However, exchanges are limited within a department or an administration because electronic document systems are different from one another. There are 20 different electronic document systems in Korea's administration. Therefore standards for electronic document systems were announced last year and a number of suppliers upgraded their systems. Cross-departmental document exchange had been undertaken among seven ministries. Now electronic documents are exchanged among the General Service Divisions of departments and administrations. Within a short span all divisions of the government will participate in the pangovernmental document exchange.
Data Sharing for Street-level Service The Korean Government made a start on integrated street-level
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
93
services. There are 21 types of data such as personal ID, vehicle registration, water and sewage, disaster management,. regional development, fishing management, forest management, road planning, etc. The databases are managed both by central government and by local governments, and ten of the 21 databases are linked to the Comprehensive Information System (Cn in four municipalities. (The municipalities usually deliver street-level services.) The CI system is established in all of the 232 local governments in Korea. The remaining databases will be linked to the CI system. One of the beneficial results of data linking is exemplified by the Productive Welfare Data Sharing, which will support means-testing welfare subsidies. When the CI system is fully established, it will reduce the documents for applying for a welfare service from 60 to 13, and the workdays for dealing with it from 21 to 3.
Information Service Central departments and administrations have their Internet home pages. So do all the provincial governments and practically all the 232 municipal governments. Prominent cases are the Open Procedure Service, the Home Minwon Service, the Local Administration Information Bank Service (LAIB), the open Plaza Service and so on. The Open Procedure Service was started in the Seoul Metropolitan Government, which shows the detailed process of office: who files the application, when the application arrives, when the application is Signed, where the application stops, why the application is rejected, etc. The service makes the office process so transparent that people are able to forget their doubts and just see publi<; servants at work. The system has been distributed to about 200 provincial and municipal governments so far, as well as to all government entities and local authorities by this year. The Home Minwon Service delivers 3,300 application forms and provides information on 4,400 kinds of application through a single website. LATB is an information bank of provincial and municipal goverJilments. The governments present their
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
94
information in the given formats. The information consists of about 400 items such as the organization, the boundary, the information resources, etc. and the number of items will be enlarged by this year. The Open Plaza Service is providing very high input to the democratic process. All citizens can post their opinions on the Open Plaza and all citizens can read them. People criticize the government and public servants through the Open Plaza, which is accessible by the President, governors and supervisors. These activities influence government policymaking. Some candidates for the Members of the National Assembly lost their membership of the Assembly after the April 2000 gen
(1)
Moreover, information such as cultural treasures, museums and art galleries via the Internet is being established, and an integrated tourist information system will operate by connecting local authorities and travel agencies.
Electronic Service Delivery Electronic service is delivered through PC communications, the Internet, telephones and kiosks. The kiosks are located in about 100 municipalities and serve people with a number of rertificates. PC communication service is used for 20 certifications, but these services will not be fully developed because of the Internet
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
95
service. The number of Internet users in Korea stands at over 14 million increasing at the rate of 900,000 per month, mainly among young people in their teens and twenties. 72 per cent of regular Internet users go online two or three times a week. About 70 per cent of the total Internet population are using e- mail. Of those who did conduct online commerce, 50.8 per cent used credit cards, 45.6 per cent bank online payment and only 2.3 per cent made use of some form of cyber money. Public-key cryptography is fast becoming the foundation for e-Commerce and other applications that require security and authentication in an open network such as the Internet and intranet. The new method makes it possible to use PKI technology for a faster broader, flexible range of network-based businesses as well as processing both encryption and decryption. Notable public services already delivered online include: The National Tax Administration has developed an electronic filing system for tax returns. The NTA is establishing the E-filing Centre, and receiving applications for e-filing from tax agents. On the other hand, many municipal governments have developed and use an electronic local tax system through which residents pay their local taxes. (2) An EDI system for processing applications for medical insurance and their appraisal is being expanded all over the country. Hospitals and public health care centres will be connected so that they can share medical information concerning blood, organ transplants and contagious diseases. An integrated service centre for the four major social insurance services has been established to streamline the process of billing and charging and to enhance the quality of service. (3) The Korean Industrial Property Office (KIPO) has developed and started an Immediate Notification System as of July 3,2000. With the help of the system, applicants can be notified of any phYSical errors or obvious reasons for refusal of their patent application as soon as they file their electronic application or registration documents with KIPO. (1)
96
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
The private sector also participates in the public service. A job information site called Humanpia (www.humanpia.com) is a leading local job information system which has merged with local recruitment information. These electronic service deliveries are fragmented and imperfect. Therefore the Korean government has set up a new project-'IT-based Reform for Government Systems'. The system aims to deliver to people electronic services through a single window and people will be able to make all the requests online concerning their life events.
Bridging the DigitaJ Divide The South Korean Government has launched an initiative to bridge the digital divide. Computer education is now mandatory at all primary schools and the government will expand IT training opportunities to all levels of society, including young children and soldiers. The Ministry of Education (MOE) presented a programme aimed at boosting English language proficiency by reinforcing English as the medium of instruction at primary and middle schools. English proficiency is seen as a basic requirement towards achieving IT literacy. The education of soldiers was also addressed. The Ministry of Defence (MOD) requires, all of the approximately 270,000 soldiers to sit for web search specialist certification exams annually before being discharged from the service. The major goal of the Ministry of Information and Communication is to expand opportunities to those who are apt to be left out of the information age. The high speed Internet network has been expanded to about 200 towns this year. Free public access to personal computers (PCs) will be more readily available. Public libraries and social welfare centres should be equipped with PCs connected to the net in addition to those available at most post offices. A programme that gives free PCs and five years of free Internet access service to about 50,000 children in the lower income group is also being studied. About 10 million workers need to be formally trained in IT.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
97
Overhauling the Relevant Laws and Regulations The information society brings with it a fundamental change to the framework and the way of living that have been accepted in an industrial society. Thus, -the current rules and regulations need to be revised to meet the needs of the new society. An annual survey has been conducted since 1995 to assess which rules and regulations should be revised to create a better environment for the information society. The enactment and revision of 63 legal statutes was completed on the basis of the annual reports from 1995 to 1997. The Electronic Commerce Act (1999) and the Digital Signature Act (1999) were enacted in order to facilitate the widespread use of IT by the private sector and we will present measures to enhance the protection of privacy. Overhauling the relevant legal statutes will be continued on electronic procurement, the management of information resources, telemedicine and geographical information systems, amongst others.
(M) South Africa Background The Government of South Africa has embarked on a number of ri;easures to ensure that information and communication technologies (leTs) playa vital role in society. On the 9th February 2001, President Thabo Mbeki outlined, in his address to Parliament, the principal programme areas for the year 2001. The President reflected on a wide range of socio-economic and political issues that need to be addressed in order to accelerate and consolidate national growth, development and democracy. The President indicated that the government has started the process of introducing managed liberalization of the telecommunications industry. The policy process will ensure greater regulatory certainty in the telecommunications industry by creating an enabling environment for local and foreign direct investments. It is envisaged that this process will improve the competitiveness and efficiency of the sector, thereby enabling it to contribute to national growth, employment and redistribution of national wealth.
98
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
E-Govemance Vision and Strategy The President announced the establishment of the Presidential International Task Force on Information Society and Development to assist government in narrowing the digital divide with the rest of the world. This is to be followed by the appointment of members of the Presidential National Commission on Information Society and Development, which will deal with skills development issues in the ICT sector. The role of broadcasting has also been accorded a high priority with the appointment of the CEO and other senior managers at the South Africa Broadcasting Corporation. Consistent with government's commitment to promoting access to information as enshrined in the Constitution, the roll-out of community radio stations is to continue with a specific focus on under-served areas. The development and funding of community programming is to be carried out in collaboration with civil society and international development organizations. Other steps were announced as part of government's integrated rural development strategy including the restructuring of the Postbank to enhance its developmental role and an accelerated roll-out of Public Information Terminals (PIT) to provide easy and cost effective access to government information. Priority has also been given to e-Commerce policy with discussions taking place between government and stake holders as well as amongst stakeholders. Government has fast-tracked the legislative process aimed at providing the required certainty in the industry with regard to, amongst others, security, intellectual pr'\lperty nights, domain names and privacy of e-Commerce transactions. Four government departments are intimately involved with IT and Communications Technologies: the Department of Communications (DoC) deals with the provision of infrastructure, access and connectivity. The Department of Public Service (DPSA), deals with provision of services efficiently, equitably and accessibly. The Department of Arts, Culture, Science and Technology (DACST) is concerned with language issues, making the Internet truly universal through access in the language of the populations concerned, and issues of research
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
99
and development in the ICT sector. The Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) deals with matters of commerce, international trade and the IT industry. The DoC has launched a series of initiatives under the collective label of the 'Info. Com 2025' programme, which seeks to achieve broad-based growth and equitable development through communications and information technologies. Some of the key elements of the Info.Com programme include: (1)
(2) (3)
(4)
(5)
A Commission for Information Communications Technology (CICT). The Universal Service Agency (USA) telecentre projects. Public Information Terminals (PITs), Internet-2000, and Web Internet Lab. Projects designed for rapid expansion of access to the Internet and for experimentation with Internet applications. TradeNet: Liaison with the Department of Trade and Industry to promote international trade opportunities via e-Commerce. Houwteq: A national training institute for study, research, and development in Technology and software.
These and other initiatives reflect the way in which government is responding to the challenge of using enabling technologies and new business paradigms to improve its service delivery and Plans for e-Commerce legislation are well advanced, as shown in the following timetable of events: (1) Discussion paper launched in July 1999. (2) Stakeholder working group submissions collated November 1999. (3) Green Paper: Issued on November 2000. (4) E-Law Conference: Stakeholders invited to discuss proposed framework/outline of the Bill and make recommendC\tions. (5) E-Bill (2nd quarter 2001) dealing with legislative issues. (6) E-Legislation. (7) Policy Directions (Beyond e-legislation) including policy positions, regulations and guidelines and self-regulatory
E-Governance Prac>ices: A Global Perspective
100
measures-contracts, industry norms and practices, codes. An important development was the creation of The State Information Technology Agency, SITA, in April, 1999. Its mandate is to serve as the information systems facility of the State, chiefly responsible for the management and execution of IT-related work for, and on behalf of the Government of South Africa. The guiding philosophy of the prOVision of government services is to bring IT Value through cost effectiveness, increased productivity and citizen convenience. The technical pillars of this philosophy rest on minimum information security, interoperability, economies of scale and no duplication. The transition to a Citizen Focused Service Delivery model is expected to offer:
A common service provider model for procurement of IT goods and services. (2) The removal of duplication through inventory of government systems (central database). (3) Integrity of providers with an objective for black economic empowerment. (4) Partnerships around skills transfer, training and local employment.
(1)
The first phase in the transition is to strengthen the internal workings of government through the roll-out of a public service technical network, the provision of applications, systems and inff)rmation and the engagement of local manufacturers and skills. The second phase of the transition is to create universal access involving the expansion of network access devices. To this end, a number of e-Govemance initiatives are already underway, including: E-justice (2) Integrated justice system (3) Automated Fingerprint Identification system (4) Smart card
(1)
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective (5) (6) (7) (8)
101
Government wide call centre G2G-government wide intranet G2C-single electronic window to government services Electronic document management systems.
Creating the Enabling Policy Environment An e-Commerce policy and legislative framework needs to consider a complex set of issues touching all major aspects of economic life including technology, micro and macro economics, social and political angles and global and national concerns. A national policy is perceived as important because the growth of e-Commerce, as a vehicle into the new Information society / economy, requires transparent, predictable and flexible regulation and legislation in certain areas. The measures must address fundamental legal barriers, security and privacy concerns, lack of understanding and preparedness by those who stand to benefit, the need to ensure harmony and compatibility with the international trading regime, and universal access and service. Both government and the private sector have a role in addressing challenges, threats, risks and legal barriers presented by e-Commerce. The government sees its role as a facilitator fundamentally responsible for laying out a legal and regulatory foundation for e-Commerce: a policy instrument to address uncertainties such as validity, legal effect and enforceability of transactions conducted through electronic means. The private sector remains a critical driving force in implementing e-Commerce applications, providing technological solutions and using some self-regulatory mechanisms to address challenges.
(N) United Republic of Tanzania Background Tanzania is situated in East Africa and has a total population of around 33 million. Tanzania is bordered on the south by Mozambique, Malawi, and Zambia; on the west by Zaire, Burundi, and Rwanda; on the north by Uganda and Kenya; and on the east by the Indian Ocean. T<1?Zania is the largest of the
102
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
East African nations, and it possesses a geography as mythic as it is spectacular. The country has a surface area of 945 thousand square kilometres and a climate which varies quite a bit, considering that its environment includes both the highest and the lowest points on the continent. While the narrow lowland coastal region is consistently hot and humid, the central regions of Tanzania are sufficiently elevated so as to offer much cooler temperatures. The rainy seasons extend from November to early January and from March to May. The history of human habitation in Tanzania goes back almost two million years, and the fossils found at Olduvai Gorge by Louis and Mary Leakey now stand among the most important artefacts of the origins of our species. Artefacts of later Paleolithic cultures have also been found in Tanzania. There is evidence that communities along the Tanzanian coast were engaging in overseas trade by the beginning of the first millennium AD. By 900 AD those communities had attracted immigrants from India as well as from southwest Asia, and direct trade extended as far as China. When the Portuguese arrived at the end of the 15th century, they found a major trade centre at Kilwa Kisiwani, which they promptly subjugated and then sacked. The Portuguese were expelled from the region in 1698, after Kilwa enlisted the help of Omani Arabs. The Omani dynasty of the Bu Said replaced the region's Yarubi leaders in 1741, and they - proceeded to-further develop trade. It was during this time that Zanzibar gained its legendary status as a centre for the ivory and slave trade, becoming in 1841 the capital city of the sultan of Oman. In Tanzania's interior, at about the same time, the cattlegrazing Maasai migrated south from Kenya into central Tanzania. Soon afterward the great age of European exploration of the African continent began, and with it came colonial domination. Tanzania fell under German control in 1886, but was handed over to Britain after WWI. Present day Tanzania is the result of a merger between the mainland (previously Tanganyika) and Zanzibar in 1964, after both had gained independence. Tanzania has like many African nations experienced considerable strife since independence, and its
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
103
economy is extremely weak. However, political stability does appear to have been established in recent years. Today Tanzania has a GOP of around 8.5 billion US dollars with an annual growth of 5 per cent. Figures show very low Internet and computer penetration with 2 personal computers for every 1000 people and 5 telephone mainlines for every 1,000 population. Internet hosts in 1999 stood at 0 for every 10,000 population.
Use of E-Govemance It is an accepted fact that information poverty has been a
characteristic of most countries in the African continent and this is not because the planning mechanisms of these countries lack data on which to base various meaningful socio-economic planning exercises but rather the problem has been the in('ll:>ility of African countries to develop and maintain appropriate information infrastructures. In his speech to the opening of the workshop on elaboration of information and communication policy for the United Republic of Tanzania, in 1997, the Principal Secretary and Secretary to the Planning Commission said that Tanzania had achieved a measure of information generation and processing capacity. Quoting from his speech "Presently there are information systems which have been developed at micro level in various institutions to meet their information requirements. However, these systems are being developed in an uncoordinated approach and utilized in isolation irrespective of their potentiality for meeting cross-sectoral information needs." The Principal Secretary noted that Tanzania is committed to the strengthening of the Information and Communications sector and welcomed any support from international communities in the strengthening of this sector. He stated that the information challenges facing Tanzania were immense and Tanzania needed to pursue its efforts to participate in the Global Economy, and the strengthening of the information and communications infrastructure was a prerequisite.
104
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
In an earlier survey of Online Governance by COMNET-IT in association with UNESCO, to which the Tanzania Commission for Science & Technology responded under initiatives for the use of informatics and telematics in government and public service, two examples were given: the Parliament World Wide Web and the Bank of Tanzania World Wide Web. In addition to the above, there are other initiatives which should be mentioned and which are described by Richard Heeks in a background paper on e-Governance in Africa. Quoting from this paper the Government of Tanzania has implemented management control mechanisms through the use of information technology. It has recently launched its integrated human resources and payroll systems covering 280,000 public servants. While the capital invested was significant at around 6.5 million US dollars, the savings already accrued in improved management, reduced ghost workers, improved control and accuracy, mean that the project has already paid for itself. The Government of Tanzania has also implemented an Integrated Financial Management System (IFMS) at all ministries in Dar es Salaam and Dodoma via a wide area network. IFMS has improved control over expenditure management, resulting in more timely and detailed reporting. Internet-enabled versions of both systems will soon be rolled out nationwide. Another example of the use of information technology for the good of the citizen or community in this case is the case of the Kibidula Farm Institute which provides research and local expertise in health, agriculture and construction techniques in rural central Tanzania. But there is no running water, no electricity and no efficient means of communication with the outside world. However, the Kibidula Farm Institute was then supplied with a solar-powered satellite ground station with e-mail and Internet connectivity. This has provided to address serious local health and medical issues. Subsequently, the Farm used the link to manufacture a single-engine airplane from parts right in the bush and to keep it running through Internet e-mail consultations with the American company that produced the kit. By the late 1990s there were two planes used to get supplies and medical relief to even more remote villages.
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
105
Citizens therefOre receive the benefits of the ICT revolution but indirectly via an intermediary. What accounts for the long-term success of this ICT-based project? First it is a good example of an NGO clearly understanding the need~ of its target population. The Farm as an intermediary NGO was able to translate the action dimension of its clientele's needs into corresponding informational components and then to establish a mechanism permitting reliable acquisition of that information on a timely basis. This example shows how NGOs can act as intermediaries between Citizens and ICTs. Once again this example is adopted from Heeks. Another ICT initiative is Tanzania Online which is a gateway to information on development issues in Tanzania. It is a UNDP fUN, Government of Tanzania and Economic and Social Research Foundation (ESRF) initiative to address problems faced by government officials, policy makers, private sector, civil society, donor community, researchers and academicians accessing information on development issues in Tanzania. The objective is to provide an interactive facility for easy access to a comprehensive set of documents about development in Tanzania, analytic work about priorities in development and progress towards poverty reduction and other development targets. The expected output of the initiative is an up-to-date online Internet-based database consisting of a comprehensive set of documents in full text on development issues in Tanzania. Tanzania Online expects to improve access and exchange of information among and between key government institutions, the public, donor community, private sector, civil society, researchers and academicians. Tanzania Online database includes analytic documents concerning development in Tanzania, work about priorities in development, progress towards poverty reduction and other sector reform developments. The subjects covered are: Education, Agriculture, Mining, Tourism, Trade, Industries, Health, Poverty Reducti<m, Water Environment, Women Development, Private Sector Development, Science and Technology, and others on development issues. The website
106
E-Governance Practices: A Global Perspective
disseminates its information content in various ways in order to reach various targeted stakeholders. Anyone from anywhere in the world with an Internet connection can access and download information. A Current Awareness list is e-mailed to users with no Internet access. The output is in text or Portable Document Format (PDF). Initial funding has been provided by the UN System (through a Swedish Grant) and the Tanzanian Government. Tanzania Onliw is implemented by ESRF.
3 The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Govemance
Introduction Does the evolution of e-Democracy practices, such as online consultations, enhance the current system whereby the polity governs society, and continues to have limited and controlled input from the citizen, or shall we see the evolution of a new form of democracy? These are pressing issues for modern governments as the new technologies are contributing to the creation of faster communications, the sharing of information and knowledge, and the emergence of new forms of our respective cultures. E-Democracy is explored as a subset to the greater, and more important, philosophical topic of democracy itself. This sets the framework for an assessment of whether or not e-Democracy shall be a natural extension of representative and liberal democracy, as practiced today in most western countries. These reports to date represent guidelines for policy implementations for e-Governance that can be used by governments, whether they are developed or developing. countries. This chapter addresses some of the changes we are witnessing as the e-Democracy movement grows. Networked communities are quickly evolving through the Internet, and
108
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
citizens are increasingly using the new technologies to organize themselves so their voices can be heard, and to develop tools to attempt to influence government policy and programmes at the political and public administration level. Writers and researchers, analyzing and assessing the emergence of e-Democracy, often leave out the broader philosophical nature of democracy itself. For purposes of this chapter it is important to put the whole question of how leTs will be used to further engage the citizenry into a wider context of democracy as we practice it. There are different schools of thought as to whether leTs will change the nature of democracy, or if leTs will simply result in an extension of democracy we now practice and understand. There has been much talk in recent years of public cynicism toward politicians and public officials. Much of this is based, amongst other rEasons, on a lack of knowledge and understanding of the inner workings of government, including the public service and legislative arm. This combined with the lack of government programmes, in many instances, to inform people of what the government is dOing, or to engage people in the development of public policy are only some of the many symptoms of why there is such growing cynicism in the public in the last two decades. The reasons for the cynicism are wide and diverse, and it is not the role of this chapter to come to conclusions about this prevailing public attitude, but to suggest that the new leTs could contribute to creating renewed faith in government bodies through the creation of an interactive government engaged in wide dialogue with an interactive citizenry. The important issue to hand is that there be a vigorous debate and discussion about the nature of democracy and how all our new technologies can be used to produce a more engaged and interactive citizenry. Such an achievement is going to take commitment and hard work by many sectors of society, not solely governments or legislative bodies
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
109
traditionally, most democratic governments have relied on interest groups, experts, and academics to assist them with the input of new legislation, legislation to be amended, regulations, or public policy. To make significant changes that would draw the citizenry more widely into the process requires commitment and attitudinal change. Cost factors also come to bear on this as well as the question of how to engage people for their input and opinion. Referendums, offline and online, could be one first step towards bringing the wider public into the whole process of government. However, this raises an even more fundamental question: Does the public want to be more engaged in government or do they simply want the opportunity to make their views known every once in awhile? If governments do engage the public more frequently into public debate over issues of the day, how often do they do this? What mechanisms will be available to facilitate this process? How often should referendums be used and what subject matters should be considered priorities for referendums? What institutions within government need to be set up to make the wider transition to e-Democracy beyond online voting and online consultations? These are just a few questions that need to be addressed and scoped out if we are to move to a new form of democratic participation and beyond online voting (very limited at the moment) and online consultations (at a very nascent stage). Groups and individuals outside government are developing their online tools and methode logy to create different methodologies of e-Democracy in order to influence governments and the issues of the day. Online activists and interested citizens alike also use e-Democracy tools to enhance democracy within their own groups and amongst themselves. Thus, weSee a culture of a different approach to traditional democracy developing outside the sphere of government circles (with some input into government, and some politicians making effective use of ICTs to further their political goals) while governments make tentative steps to move into the arena. Governments are traditionally conservative and slow to
110
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
move due to the nature of their organizations and the duty to take all interests of society into consideration when undertaking change. For the moment there is a difference in cultures occurring and a wide gap between what individuals and groups are doing online and what governments are currently capable of doing online, especially in their relationships with the public. The challenge of governments in the next few years will be to set out mechanisms on how to embrace more of the public into the decision-making process. 'More importantly governments, especially the elected bodies, need to take a leadership role in engaging the public in wide debate on how, or if, ICTs can and should change our current dynamics of democracy. for while many might argue that being online is crucial for politicians to continue to get elected, the evidence does not point to this being a deciding factor at this time. The debate is a fluid one. We all need to become partners in a debate on the nature of democracy in our very changed world, which will then lead to ways and means whereby ICTs can be strategic tools for the democratic process. Governments are concerned about the decline in public approval of their institutions. There are tools available that can help reverse this attitude - it is now a question of how extensively these tools can be used to effect this change. As this Report shows, it is becoming increasingly important to engage the citizen. Tools for consultation are still run from the top down but, if done properly, the goals of an interactive government and an interactive citizenry can be reached. Democracy as practiced now by many countries is an evolving concept. The principles and practice of democratic ideals vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, but underpinning all democracies are the underlying tenets of liberal democracy as evolved in the past two to three hundred years. There is representative democracy (and many electoral and legislative forms of this type of democracy), participatory democracy (practiced in some jurisdictions, such as the town hall meetings tradition in the United States), and direct democracy (the closest example of this today is the practice of decisions of national importance by a referendum amongst the electorate.)
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
111
These are but a few examples. There is a hint that the evolution of e-Democracy could take us into a new form of democracy, which would reflect a wider voice of the public. But there is no clear vision of what such a democracy would entail, and how it would differ from current practices or reflect the overall society. In our current system of representative democracy, elected officials, and the institutions adopted from this system, have been the traditional means in recent times of governing in the interests of society. So the question is: will leTs and the tools that continue to be developed enable people to have access to more information (often a negative if there is too much information or a lack of organization or critical skills to assess the importance of the information that can then be turned into knowledge) and to have the ability to better communicate with govern~ent? Both these abilities could be a result of the rapid transformation of our collective societies because of the emergence of these information and communication technologies. However, as we have learned, technology is only a medium and a driver of new and important trends in society to the extent that they are driven by new ideas, conceptual constructs that contain innovation and creativity. Technology is not the creator of change, but is simply a tool. Usage of technologies, no matter their form, result in cultural evolutions because of the way that people adapt them. Implementation of new technologies may change the way societies organize and administer themselves, but they are never the driver of ideas, only the facilitator. Original ideas come from the mind of one person or from collective debate that then drives philosophical, cultural, societal, organizational, and administrative change. Thus, the usage of ICTs for the purposes of e-Democracy principles, as articulated to date, is only the beginning, and simply one tool, on the road to possible new forms of democracy. It is how we use this tool and the way in which we frame the debate that will result in these new forms and an extension of our current structures of democracy. Whatever the outcome of the debate, it is becoming apparent that the emergence of e-Democracy is starting to have some
112
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
impact on both governments and society. It is the continued practice of e-Democracy, the development of new tools and ideas, and a debate on the overall subject of democracy, which will bring us to a possible new plateau of a system of democracy that will reflect our increasingly changing culture and societies. This is not a suggestion to change what we"have, but to build on the strength of the forms of democracy that have been developed over the past centuries.
E-Democracy: An Emerging Concept Some e-Democracy advocates, such as Steven Clift and author Howard Rheingold, believe that if parliaments and other elected bodies do not institute reforms to develop e-Democracy mechanisms there will be severe political consequences, such as political candidates seeking office who do not use online technologies to deal with the voters will not be elected. These views are based on the belief that the online generation expect their leaders to communicate to them in this new generation's medium of use. These arguments assume that there are a host of c!tizens arming themselves with the tools to have a direct influence on legislative and policy development, and who also have the will and desire to engage in the emerging e-Democracy process. However, the current literature does not reflect any empirical evidence that there is a significant shift towards citizen engagement in the political process due to ICTs. In fact, democracy is as threatened in developed countries by a laissezfaire attitude that leads to inequalities, and power becomes concentrated in the hands of specialized groups. Recognizing this to some degree, Steven Clift in his work has also focused on building online communitie~ to mobilize like-minded individuals around the world, to increase their communication with each other in regard to issues of the day so that their voices may be heard. Officials in the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom are seeking ways to combat voter apathy, especially because of the declining engagement amongst yOlo ...3 people. For example, in the UK, only 59.7 per cent of voters voted in the
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
113
last general election, and less than 30 per cent of young people under 30. Some argue that this is rather a political problem, and there will not be significant shifts to new forms of democracy or participation by the citizenry because of leTs. They suggest instead that the new leTs will serve only to strengthen existing democratic institutions, but not dramatically change the legislative bodies of public sector institutions. On the other extreme end of the spectrum, some contend that while the Internet provides new sources of information for those who are interested in political affairs, they remain skeptical about its potential to transform the participation of the citizenry. These authors posit that it will be business as usual and that the new leTs will not create the great revival of democracy as argued by proponents above. Others argue that social and economic biases will continue on the Internet, further marginalizing those who have little interest in or knowledge of public affairs. Michael Margolis and David Resnick, authors of Politics as Usual: The Cyberspace Revolution insist that initial expectations for such a democratic revival were short-lived and simply produced 'politics as usual'. The electronic form of governance, of which e-Democracy is an extension, emerges in the midst of various theories about governance, one of which is the concept evolved by French philosopher Michel Foucault, of 'governmentality', wherein he articulated a kind of rationality integral to the art of government. Foucault was concerned with the 'how' of governing, and for him governmentality was a 'way or system of thinking about the nature of the practice of government.' He used 'rationality of government' interchangeably with 'art of government', to include who can govern, what governing is, what or who is governed. For him the most significant development in modern government, and by extension modern democracy, is the introduction of economy as the main objective of political practice, and population as representing the end or goal of government, with the apparatuses of security as its essential mechanism. But what of the concept of democracy itself and how does this align with the new online movement for increased ' participation by the citizen?
114
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
Theoretical Frameworh. of Democracy Theories of democracy are as numerous as those thinkers who have written about it through the ages. So too the concept of the citizen and exactly who is to be included within the term has changed dramatically since articulated in ancient Athens. There are many conflicting interpretations of what constitutes a democracy, the meaning of political participation, representation, and scope of citizens' capacity to choose freely. Historically, the city-state of Athens was the first democratic state that engaged in direct democracy from the citizenry. In the close to 200 years that democracy did thrive in Athens there were different evolutions of how it engaged in democratic practices. At the height of their practices of democracy, 6,000 to 8,000 citizens of Athens would gather almost weekly to form a consensus on legislative issues. On first blush it appears this system was an ideal democracy. However, this was not a true democracy as we understand it today as vast numbers of citizens of Athens were excluded. Those not participating were the slaves and members of families who were not recent citizens of the City but considered immigrants (an immigrant family could be one that arrived in Athens even as much as four generations or more earlier). Women were also excluded, thus eliminating over half the population from the process. However, the democratic practice in ancient Athens is an early, though flawed, example of the practice of direct democracy and the reaching of consensus amongst the participants. Throughout the centuries, democracy has undergone major changes, as the size of the citizenry has evolved from a narrow, exclusively defined body that participated in a collective will within a small city-state, to a genuinely universal suffrage in many countries, and a metamorphosis of ancient democracy into what is today called a representative, liberal democracy. Academic author Robert Dahl argues that this latter form of democracy leads to both accountable and feasible government, with the potential of stability over large territories and periods of time. The writer and theorist, Carol Gould, on the other hand,
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
115
maintains that a theory of democracy is necessary that both elaborates freedom and equality, and effectuates them in practice, arguing that the form of decision-making should be participatory to the extent feasible, and representative otherwise. The author and philosopher Alain Touraine, distrusting participatory democracy as lacking in wisdom, and dissatisfied with deliberative democracy, advocates the need for a liberating (representative) democracy - where there is a "democratic will to enable those who are subordinate and dependent to act freely and to discuss rights and guarantees on equal terms with those who possess economic, political, and cultural resources." He proposes this as a limitation on what would otherwise lead to the omnipotence of those who control the financial and information resources. In such a regime, the concept of citizenship is based on a guarantee that all citizens of a country have the same legal and political rights, regardless of their social, religious, or ethnic background. This concept also carries the notion of an actively responsible individual, though he further cautions that in modernized societies, it is in danger of being reduced to the "freedom to consume in the political marketplace". The theoretical framework, to be used in this Report, is the definition of democracy by Joseph Schumpeter who defines representative or liberal democracy in terms of its structural characteristics, as follows: . Pluralistic competition among parties and individuals for all positions of government power. (2) Participation among equal citizens in the selection of parties and representatives through free, fair and periodic elections. (3) Civil and political liberties to speak, publish, assemble, and organize, as necessary conditions to ensure effective competition and participation.
(1)
Point one allows citizens to choose from alternative candidates. Point two allows for periodic elections that translate votes into seats in government, promoting transparency, so that representatives can be held accountable for their actions. Point
116
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
three allows for multiple sources of information so that citizens can make informed choices. This model of democracy is useful to a discussion of electronic governance and electronic democracy in that it gives equal weight to the value of mass participation as to the other two core democratic functions of politics. Within this framework, and reflecting the classical liberal view of the role of parliament in representative democracy, government websites (though not specifically envisioned by Schumpeter), as a means of creating an informed citizenry, should therefore ideally serve two primary functions: "the 'top down' provision of information from the legislature to the public, and a 'bottom up' channel of communication from the public to the elected members". This also includes interactive communication between government agencies and departments and the public. There have been arguments for many ways in which government web sites and other features of the new ICTs have the potential to increase the democratic participation of the citizen. The debate is heated but it remains difficult to find systematic comparative evidence. James Fishkin outlines four conditions that must exist for a greater engagement by the citizen: political equality, (2) deliberation, (3) participation, and (4) non-tyranny (that includes the tyranny of the majority).
(1)
A system that achieved all four conditions simultaneously he calls a "democracy of civic engagement". The OECD Public Administration (PUMA) Group that has been conducting extensive studies on e-Governance and e-Democracy has articulated three main components of governments in their programme evolutions, policy and legislative implementations, required for online interactions between government and the citizen: information, (2) active participation, and (3) consultation.
(1)
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
117
Many governments have pledged to move in this direction but movement towards results is slow. This may be partly explained due to the hierarchical nature of organizations and the current role of representative government in these democracies. External groups and individuals on an international scale are working to change this dynamic (as will be illustrated below.) Governments are moving at a slower and different pace than those groups and citizens who are using the Internet to try to influence the evolution of policy and legislation. It is not the purpose of this paper to discuss the relative merits of the various forms of democracy, including the different forms of representative democracy as practiced in different countries, nor whether or not it would benefit the society for the citizen to have a greater role in the decisionmaking processes of government, but rather to explore whether there is a potential for increasing that role through the use of the new leTs and e-Democracy. Do they have the prospect of increasing the completeness of the debate on the issues and the public's engagement with it? And if so, are those who participate statistically representative of the entire citizenry? The question as to whether or not the movement of governments online and a growing influence of the citizen online working to influence government policy and legislative development, will result in new forms of democracy will not be answered for a long time. Only historical evolutions and changes in society in the coming decades will decide the question. What can be stated at this juncture is that ICTs are beginning to shape the form of democracy citizens now practice, albeit in a small, but significant, way.
Meaning of E-Democracy There are as many interpretations of what constitutes e-Democracy as there are interpretations of democracy. And because e-Democracy is in its beginning stages, there is much confusion about what it encompasses and how to clearly define it. Steven Clift, of DO Wire, is an acknowledged expert and· leader in the worldwide e-Democracy movement. He describes
118
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
e-Democracy as referring to "how the Internet can be used to enhance our democratic processes and provide increased opportunities for individuals and communities to interact with government and for the government to seek input from the community" (democracy online http://www.dowire.org). Characteristics of the Internet which he feels support eDemocracy are that it provides opportunity to participate in debates as they happen, participation is less limited by geography, disability or networks, and it facilitates the access to information and provision of input by individuals and groups who previously had not been included in these debates. Another organization that specializes in e-Democracy is the International Teledemocracy Centre in Scotland. Their stated goal is to strengthen democracy through the use of innovative ICT to deliver improved democratic decision-making processes, thereby increasing citizen participation-specifically through the use of electronic consultation and electronic petitions. This is undertaken within a backdrop of the devolution of control to the Scottish Parliament for its own domestic legislation. The Centre takes its cue from the OECD study on e-Governance and e-Democracy, concentrating on the last two of the three types of interaction outlined in the OECD's study: a two-way relationship where citizens are given the opportunity to give feedback on issues; and a relationship based on partnership where citizens are actively engaged in the policy-making process. The UK-based Dialogue by Design, summarily defines eDemocracy as "the use of computers to enhance the democratic process." As a proponent of its own data management software to be used in the e-Consultation process, it is clearly unapologetic in its view that ICTs have the potential to transform the political world as dramatically as the invention of the printing press did over five hundred years ago. Ake Gronlund, from the Umea University in Sweden, however, is concerned that definitions of e-Democracy often focus on ICT use and projects, rather than on democratic processes and institutional innovation. In order that the term Ie-Democracy' does not become merely a convenient shorthand for ICT use in democratic processes, he argues that it should be
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
119
assessed in terms of its defining processes, not to what extent ICTs are used. He notes that as e-Governance is still in its early days, e-Democracy is a marginal occurrence, but he does not discount its potential for the future, though which initiatives will be successful and which directions e-Democracy will take will depend on the actions by many different actors.
E-Govemance and E-Democracy: Inter-relationshi p Some proponents of e-Governance in Canada and internationally have dispensed with the term 'e-Governance'. For many eGovernance is used to encompass all electronic activities and programmes, with e-Democracy included as a 'growing' part of e-Governance. Terms such as 'digital government' and 'digital voice' have more and more corne into use instead. E-Democracy is treated more as a result than as an equally important part of the equation. The emphasis on the use of ICTs by government and elected officials in the business of government often overshadows the real difficulties involved in online citizen engagement, which is presented almost as an extension of the more traditional consultation methods. In fact, the subject of online consultation is actually a work in progress and we are witnessing the early stages of its growth. A pilot on online consultation was recently completed by the Centre for Collaborative Government, in conjunction with the Department of Canadian Heritage, to develop and test the concept of a 'Digital Commons': "a place where Canadians can openly discuss, debate and share issues and experiences electronically in an open forum." The discussion agenda, determined by the government, was highly controlled and run by them, with the "focus on the role of government and of elected officials as participants in such a space." While the final report from the consultation contains recommendations for an e-Democracy framework by doing more pilots, the emphasis of the pilot undertaken was on "government comfort and familiarity with online citizen engagement" rather than from the viewpoint of the citizen's participation in governance. Theirs appears to be a method of enabling government to
120
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
adapt gradually to the idea of citizen engagement, and it may well be argued that this approach is needed in order to move government and politicians into an acceptance of this new reality. The downside, however, is that although their report constantly speaks of increasing citizen engagement, it proceeds from the top-down perspective rather than incorporating the citizen's viewpoint. Gilles Paquet, of the University of Ottawa Centre on Governance, views governance in relation to organizations, moving from centralized to distributed governance. In his view, "e-Governanc.e presents a real transformation in democratic governance, including design, decision-making and service delivery capabilities. E-Governance refers to new processes of coordination made possible or even necessary by the advent of technology-and the spreading of online activities in particular. As a result, e-Governance refers to an IT-led reconfiguration of public sector governance-and how knowledge, power and purpose are redistributed in light of new technological realities." The Internet has certainly brought about a decentralization of power in one respect. In the wired world, individuals can now make their own choices as to which authorities and information sources they will accept. It may be argued that this is leading to a greater democratization of knowledge, empowerment of the individual, and the potential for more informed interactions between the citizenry and organizations, including government. Moreover, since individuals now have ready access to a variety of information resources, governments have to adopt new proactive measures to compile and disseminate information in a competitive information environment. Effective ability to access government information, and to use information as a tool in all aspects of one's life, has become more and more vital in today's society. Recent research into e-Governance practices, applications, and successes and failures of government websites illustrates the following: (1)
E-Democracy is a growing trend amongst outside groups, but most governments are still very much struggling with the concept.
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
121
(2) E-Governance is changing the ways in which government does business with the public and, in the process, is creating demand for some form of participation from the citizen. This gives some credence to the ongoing thinking that e-Governance will eventually result in some form of e-Democracy. (3) E-Democracy movements are founded on information precepts and engage in the sharing and developing of knowledge. (4) For the citizen to influence government policy, programmes or policy evolution, the creation and sharing of knowledge by governments with the public will become mandatory.
Citizen Participation in E-Democracy Discussions of e-Governance and e-Governance inevitably lead to the question of citizen participation. This can take many forms and different subject headings, such as participatory democracy, e-participation, teledemocracy, and e-Democracy. The latter has come to be the umbrella term for citizen participation in the political, bureaucratic and legislative process. While there are many sites on the Internet where citizens may organize their own petitions, some governments such as Scotland and Queensland, Australia are exploring ways to adapt the legal right to petition the government to the online medium. One regional government in Jutland, Denmark is building a system whereby local citizens will be notified bye-mail when the government plans to take action on an issue in which they have indicated an interest. Two e-Democracy advocates, Stephen Coleman, of the Institute for Internet Research, Oxford and John G0tze, in the Swedish Government, argue that the main thrusts of e-Democracy for legislators and public administrators will be online voting and online consultations. Online consultation is mostly restricted to the bureaucratic side of government in many countries, but in jurisdictions like the US, the UK, and Sweden, it refers to consultations between the citizenry and the political side of government as well.
122
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
The e-Democracy movement is driven by the emergence of ICTs that allow swift exchange of communications, the ability to share information and build communities of networks of people and groups who, amongst other things, share common interests and ideologies. What once took months or years to turn into an issue can now occur in less than a day. The Internet is becoming more and more an important organizational tool for all manner of groups and citizens who, in the past, had a difficult time either being heard by the government or influencing policy. The size and timeliness of the international protests over the globalization policies of the OECD and the WTO were due to groups being able to organize themselves over the Internet, mobilize support for the issues, and exchange information and communicate messages in real time. In Seattle, Washington D.C., and Prague, the initial G8 protests were organized both off line and online, but it was the Internet that gave this movement the international momentum to make it the effective demonstration, and the somewhat collective voice of outsiders, that it became. It has become the symbol not only for the voices able to speak from the Internet, but of the fact that the citizenry has found a tool by which they can bypass all the normal channels of government. Many people talk about the 'individual' being in control, or having great power because of the ability to tap into the world through the keyboard. It has also been identified as the power of the consumer to buy the product he wan~s, or read the online newspaper of choice. But more central to this development is the degree to which people can communicate, form opinions, make judgments from available data, and then act upon them. The Internet is a medium that allows ideas to flow among thousands of channels, a form of 'capillary action', that the French philosopher Michel Foucault viewed in the multiple and decentralized way that power is exercised. People are empowered not because one can get onto the Internet and buy a product, read a newspaper or research out some knowledge, but by the ability to talk back (true interactivity), dialogue, and go to whatever source an individual wants to choose.
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
123
This is not to say there are thousands upon thousands of people out there engaged in political activism. But there are legions of people who are engaging in conversation (or whatever activity they choose). Many of these people are not restrained by the dictates of mass media. In today's wired world, ~ith the increased demand for more and faster information, man~ would say that the interactive citizen has evolved from what Manuel Castells, author of "The Internet Galaxy" termed "virtual communitarians" (people who use ICTs for social organization), and that the Internet has put new power and knowledge into the hands of the citizen. In practice, one of the primary functions of government has been the creation and dissemination of information. Governments have always been considered to be the largest library in any jurisdiction because of the enormity of their information holdings. Perhaps the Internet is now the largest library in the world given the billions of web pages, joined-up chat rooms, newsgroups, listservs, etc. As a result, a citizenry that is able to seek and obtain information and knowledge from any place in the world through the Internet will, in all Iikelihood, also expect more from government. Current research indicates that at this stage of development few governments have effectively been able to involve their citizenry electronically in the democratic process in any great numbers. Many governments have reached a stage where they are able to dispense information more effectively, which often passes as a means of enhancing the democratic process. But there are also some government initiatives seeking to help citizens to get online, seek feedback on government reports online, and develop listservs and discussion groups to'elicit the views of the citizens. There are many groups actively participating in online activities in the hope of influencing government policies. One of these is Open Democracy which describes its goal as a "true arena for democratic change, for dosing the distance between people and power, influencing global policy and ... share knowledge across borders and differences." According to Steven Clift, Democracy Online consultant in Minnesota, those engaged in online activities involving social
124
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
or political changes see the Internet as a medium to foster, enhance, and change the way people have traditionally engaged in the democratic process. The Internet is a medium that could result in hundreds of thousands of people around the world participating in the political process as citizen politicians. However, the reality and the promise of what could occur are far apart. There is the question as to whether citizens would in fact use the Internet tool to become more involved with the decisionmakinr; process of government, if they were given the opportunity. This question may likewise be reflected in an emerging trend, which surfaced in a sample survey, showing that people are increasingly spending more time in isolation sitting in front of their terminals. A survey in 2000, of 4,113 adults, conducted by Stanford University's Institute for the Quantitative Study of Society, found that "55 per cent of Americans have access to the Internet at work or at horne, and approximately 20 per cent of regular Internet users spend more than 5 hours a week online. Of those 20 per cent, 13 per cent spend less time with family and friends, 8 per cent attend fewer social events, and 25 per cent spend more time working at hom~ in addition to spending a full day at the office." Another finding of that study also corroborates the UCLA's Center for Communication Policy's latest study of Internet usage, that the more than 70 per cent of Americans who use the Internet now consider online technology to be their most important source of information, ranking :t higher as an information source than all other media, incluJing newspapers and television. Indeed, a majority of US Internet users (surveyed by the Markle Foundation as part of their Internet Accountability study) viewed the web as a 'library' and not an online shopping mall. But whether this will translate into a greater involvement in political or government affairs remains to be seen, and there are conflicting studies. A survey conducted in 2002 by the Forrester Consultancy Group found that, despite the numerous programs to implement e-Governance in Great Britain, only 10 per cent of the population are going online for government services, while
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Govern~nce
125
at the same time online retail sales have skyrocketed to one billion pounds sterling a year. Clearly, the British would rather go shopping. Without doubt, the Internet has been a tool of enrichment for large numbers of the population. It has allowed diversity, the rise of the entrepreneur, the mushrooming of home businesses, the bringing together of family and friends through instant communications. It has also been a voice for many who previously did not have the means to express themselves because prior media of the expression of communication have been controlled by the few. But the question remains as to whether the Internet too will eventually become another medium of expression also controlled by the few or a free-for-all of opinion and bias not grounded in factual or thoughtful discussion. While the Internet has become more and more an intrinsic part of our cultures, nevertheless there are sehous issues to be dealt with, especially that of the digital divide. Modern societies and governments have traditionally operated on a hierarchical model of information flow and interaction. So, for the most part, have traditional information technologies. Because new technologies have in the past influenced the evolution of society and, as a consequence, the nature of government, it is anticipated by many that leTs will contribute to an increased interactivity with the public. The potential for wide change in the e-Governance area now exists beyond simply e-Governance service delivery, but also in the promise of wider interaction with the citizen. What this will entail and the speed with which it may be accomplished is still very uncertain. Indeed, evidence of the lack of programmes and initiatives in many jurisdictions for actively engaging the citizenry through electronic means speaks to its much lower priority for government than the electronic delivery of services, and fuels the assertion by many others that it will simply be 'business as usual' for governments. However, the problem is not necessarily lack of government action in making widespread commitments to conducting online consultations (though at the political level in many countries there is still much reluctance to change the status quo). One of
126
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
the major problems in government departments and agencies in achieving this goal is simply the lack of financial and human resources to create a 'back office' that would take care of all the activity that would occur once online consultations are undertaken on a regular basis. On the other hanel, the January 24, 2003 issue of the Economist, which surveyed a number of developments brought about by the new ICTs, emphasizes the promise and potentiality of these technologies to bring about a shift in power to the ordinary citizen: " ... every big change in communication technology, from the printing press to television, has eventually produced big, and often unexpected, changes in politics. As the internet becomes mobile and ubiquitous, it will bring about changes of its own. Precisely what these will be is not yet clear, but the earliest claims of cyber-dreamers-that the internet will produce a shift of power away from political elites to ordinary citizens-may well become reality." A key issue that must be addressed as part of any discussion on e-Democracy is that of the digital divide, as there can be vast disparities between those who will benefit from access to the new technologies and those who are either technologically illiterate or do not have the financial means to go online. Not only have the new ICTs changed the economy, whereby technological literacy and access have become more and more vital, but such a divide, perpetuated by economic barriers, will preclude many from engaging in the e-Democratic process. A report published by Citizens Online, a registered charity in the UK established to explore the social and cultural impact of the internet on society, revealed that three times as many welloff families in the UK are going online for the first time as those with low incomes. Interestingly, this group, which is committed to universal access and tackling the issues of the digital divide, is funded by the private sector and not by government. Similar results concerning income-related home access were reported in a recent study done in Canada by the survey company Ekos:
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
127
0) while home access increased across all groups, growth rates were more significant in upper income households; (2) a majority of upper income households (81 % with $8099K and 83% with $100K and over) and upper middle income households (60% with $40-59K and 72% with $60-79K) have home access; (3) less than half (46%) of lower middle income households ($20-39K) and a little over one in three (35%) of lower income households (less than $20K) have home access; (4) the division of home access based on income has continued to widen between upper and lower income households from a 39 point gap in 1997 to a 48 point gap in 2001. Canada, the United States, Britain, Denmark and Sweden, among others, have implemented community access programmes to attempt to bridge this divide in some measure. Though by no means do they fully resolve the issue of the digital divide, these programs seek to provide free internet access for every citizen by establishing hook-ups in public libraries, schools, community centres and kiosks. There are almost weekly press releases by Industry Canada announcing the establishment of more public access points in both rural communities and urban areas across Canada. Britain's goal is to have a public access point no farther than 1 kilometre from every individual in the country, so that government information and service delivery is accessible to all. A Report released by the US Census Bureau in February, 2002, entitled a Nation OnLine shows that the vast majority of Americans now have access to computers and the Internet in great numbers and on a daily basis. While it paints an optimistic picture of Internet usage, it does not deal with the digital divide .
•
0) "The rate of growth of Internet use in the United States is currently two million new Internet users per month. More than half of the nation is now online. (2) Children and teenagers use computers and the Internet more than any other age group.
128
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance (3) 90 per cent of children between the ages of 5 and 17 (or 48 million) now use computers. (4) 75 per cent of 14-17 year olds and 65 per cent of 10-13 year olds use the Internet. (5) Households with children under the age of 18 are more likely to access the Internet (62 per cent) than households with no children (53 per cent). (6) Computers in schools substantially narrow the gap in computer usage rates for children from high and low income families. (7) Approximately 24 million of the 65 million employed adults who use a computer at their job also work on a computer at home."
A study by the Washington, Pew Internet & American Life Project, released in April, 2002, illustrates the extent of eGovernance usage in the country: "While many government site users focus on their personal needs in dealing with government agencies, there is abundant evidence that a new 'e-citizenship' is taking hold: 0) 42 million Americans have used government web sites
to research public policy issues. (2) 23 million Americans have used the Internet to send comments to public officials about policy choices. (3) 14 million have used government web sites to gather information to help them decide how to cast their votes. (4) 13 million have participated in online lobbying campaigns. " A similar study of e-Governance usage in 27 countries around the world, was conducted by the European firm, Taylor Nelson Sofres, with the following findings: 0) 26 per cent of people globally have used the Internet to
either access government information, prOVide personal information to the government, or transact with e-Governance services. (2) E-Governance usage varies globally-Norway and Denmark have the highest e-Governance usage at 53 and
The Evolution of E-Democracy. Role of E-Governance
129
47 per cent respectively, Finland 46 per cent, US 34 per cent, France 18 per cent, Germany and Korea 17 per cent, and Great Britain 11 per cent. Overall, one might argue that the penetration rate of the Internet in a number of countries around the world does create a cultural climate for e-democracy to grow based on the numbers of people online. Email and mailing lists have led to the emergence of virtual communities. Yet, in stark contrast, the Internet's reach in most of the developing countries ranges only from less than 1-5 per cent of the total population. For example, in the Philippines it is currently put in the range of 2-3 per cent and in Nigeria 0.1 per cent. While some developing nations such as Malaysia, Brazil and Taiwan have made substantial progress, approximately 87 per cent of people online live in post-industrial societies. There are twice as many users in Sweden than across the entirety of Sub-Saharan Africa. The potential is also there for the Internet to become dominated by a few large, corporate interests, or subsumed by government regulation that could inhibit the freedoms offered by this new technology. There are efforts by many governments, worried about the potential freedoms a medium such as the Internet brings, to curtail both access and content on the Internet. Canada, the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Australia, and many other countries have implemented laws making it possible to engage in wide surveillance of citizens. In the US the government is planning to converge databases of public and private sector organizations, in order to track citizens both in the US and abroad. In his annual report, the Privacy Commissioner of Canada warned that privacy rights have been under assault as a result of these new laws. All these inhibiting legislative and regulatory changes could potentially create a climate where we see citizens anxious about their online activity. In MalaYSia, the government closed down an Internet publication, Malaysiakini, that advocated e-Democracy and robust online public discourse. The Malaysian Government has stated their commitment to e-Governance and freedom on the Internet through their e-Governance strategy. Yet, according to
130
The Evolution of E-Democr,'cj: Role of E-Governance
the publisher of Malaysiakini, it appears the government was nervous about an outlet that did not express views they endorsed. In other words, the clear message from the government was that it was they alone who would set the agenda. From her perspective through the lens of the digital and democratic divides, Pippa Norris, author of Digital Divide: Civic Engagement, Information Poverty and the Internet Worldwide, argues that optimistic claims that the new leTs will facilitate a new era of direct democracy, "like a virtual Agora, while attractive ... are implausible in practice as soon as we understand who becomes involved in digital politics." She maintains that it will simply reinforce the activism of the activists, and it is unlikely it will reach the "disengaged, the apathetic, and the uninterested," further increasing the divisions between the actives and the apathetics.. While the leTs may have set the stage for the potential of e-Democracy to take hold in society, there are many uncertainties and questions that still remain. Is there significant progress towards an e-Democracy culture, and will it truly provide representation for all citizens, when there is both unequal access to the technology and unequal technical capabilities of citizens? The figures above show that there is a definite culture of Internet usage emerging that creates the environment for e-Democracy, but how realistic is it that it will come into being? Will e-Democracy simply be another version of voting, and be used as a limited means for governments to consult with people on different political and public sector issues? Will there be a new form of democracy emerging, as this Report suggests, or will it be an augmentation of representative democracy with an Ie' added on? Will people engage themselves in political and government issues, and will their voices actually be heard and taken into account, or will the Internet be simply another tool for politicians and governments to enforce top-down decisions? These are questions that are central to: the current e-Democracy debate; (2) the future of e-Democrc.cy itself;
(1)
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
131 '
(3) and how the form of democracy as we currently know it may evolve into a new form of participatory or direct democracy or (4) take a shape we have yet to articulate. No treatment of e-Governance and e-Democracy could help but raise these questions. However, they represent much broader issues than can be effectively covered in this Report, which instead, is limited to the role of the citizen in the evolving e-Governance structure. The issues above present some of the limitations, but one must also consider those means that are currently being used to engage the citizen in the decision-making process.
The Role of Public in Government Consultation Representative form of parliamentary democracy in Canada, the United Kingdom, Australia, New Zealand and other western democratic governments around the world has resulted in the development of specific practices on how to consult with the public on issues of the day and the development of legislation. Parliament and provincial or state legislatures create legislation through the Committee process of their respective assemblies. These Committees invite members of the public to submit briefs and comments on the bill being considered. In some instances, Parliamentary committees will travel across the country, holding public hearings to get input from professional groups and associations, non-governmental organizations, academics, and citizens groups and individuals with expertise in the specific subject of the proposed legislation. This process is also followed when the government releases White papers (the government's intent on a given issue, of what they propose to do in the way of legislation) or Green papers (a discussion paper of the various alternatives the government is considering on a certain issue). In Canada and other countries they are generally announced in different ways, especially in official government publications and details given on how to provide input. Ministers' staff and public administration officers also ensure that the White paper or Green or other Discussion
132
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
papers are circulated to people who should know about it and whose input the government is seeking. This is a very controlled mechanism run from the top. On important pieces of legislation, concerted efforts are made by the government in power to seek input from specific groups or allies of the legislation. In Canada, since Confederation and the formation of Canada, in 1867, a system has evolved of public sector officials seeking ·out representatives of vested and specific interest groups from the different regions of the country, who would be invited to Ottawa to take part in discussions. The system tends towards elitism, as the practice has been for favourites to be selected for their input. Except for public meetings, sometimes required by law, and committee meetings across the country on major political issues of the day (such as with the ongoing debates on the Canadian Health Care System or the Constitutional discussions in the late eighties), the average citizen has not been a major factor in public input into legislative and public sector debates. Online consultations being run at the provincial and federal levels in Canada are an attempt to change this process and are tentative steps towards engaging the citizen in the development of the policy making process or input on major issues of the day. Similar activities, in varying degrees, are taking place in many other jurisdictions in the world. While governments continue to work from a top down position there are pressures from outside groups and citizens, using online tools, to change the current system of engagement between the government and the public. In the last twenty years, the use of opinion polls and focus groups by public sector organizations has become common, but this represents only very limited input from the citizen. Television presents a public forum where political issues of the day may be discussed, and phone-in shows for people to express their opinions. But media programs, including the radio talk shows, are more a medium for listeners to sound their opinions than they are a venue for government to have an educated debate for input on their agendas. The United States has similar mechanisms but, in addition, have a tradition of town hall meetings as a mechanism for publiC
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
133
input into the democratic process. These town hall meetings, originating in the New England states over two centuries ago, have spread across the countl"y. Politicians from the local and state levels are very involved in the process. Town hall meetings are convened on any issue that is relevant to the local town or county. It has been a tradition that robustly involves people in the democratic process. In fact, there has been some suggestion that the wide interest in e-Democracy in the United States, where there is growing involvement, stems from this tradition of the town hall meeting.
Involving the Citizen Online An online organization in the US, called Teledemocracy Action News and Network, describes their purpose as follows: "We are primarily dedicated to the creative use of modern technologies (lCTs) and face-to-face deliberative techniques in all forms that directly empower citizens to have authentic input into political systems at all levels of governance around the world." Other groups, such as the Centre for Democracy and Technology (QDT) in Washington, have a similar goal of getting people more involved in the democratic process through the use of technological tools. The potential to achieve such a goal may be possible, as can be seen by examples below of people who are working to get governments to go online and engage the citizen in the process of government. But for the moment, most of those groups working in an e-Democracy environment are reliant on government and reacting to what government is doing to create input. There are many others who play active roles but two of the more well known approaches in developing online communities of e-Democracy participants are those by e-Democracy experts, Steven Clift and Ann Macintosh. The Clift approach is to build a community of networks in which people can engage themselves in political discourse, develop ways to input into government policy and decisionmaking, send people to appropriate sites, and recommend ways to use technology to be able to influence the process of government. Much of what he does is from his own perspective,
134
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
using the means through his newsgroup wire list, Democracy Online newswire ('do-wire') tracking developments in e-Democracy and sharing them with colleagues around the world. Clift works with governments to encourage them to get online, use tools to engage citizens, and use the Internet as a tool for online voting. The Macintosh approach has been a traditional one of working with governments from an academic institution to develop tools to help legislators and administrators obtain public input on issues of the day. Through her International Teledemocracy Centre she has been engaged in online consultations on a number of policy issues for the Scottish parliament, developed tools to obtain public input, including programs directed specifically at youth, and has also worked with the London Council on recent transport issues. Macintosh also does work with the European Union on their e-Democracy projects. Although her work is set by the government agenda, hers differs from Clift in that much of her e-Democracy research is done from the perspective of an academic researcher. She provides in-depth analysis, based on extensive research, on the different projects in which she is engaged. Clift writes papers and proffers tips and advice from his own perspective, as an effective advocate who has been responsible for building an international community of networks dealing with some form of e-Democracy. His 2650-member do-wire list serves to keep the interested subscribers up to date, posts notices of important events, and points people to web sites, articles, and other newsgroups and listservs of interest. Clift is proactively devcIoping a culture of e-Democracy whilst Macintosh contributes through the input of researched papers and online consultations developed through government funding. Her role is not so much an advocate as a facilitator, creating an information base of knowledge on the subject matter, which is made available through the lTC's website. Some argue that the current focus of governments on providing easily accessible online services drives the push to e-Participation, in that it presents a challenge to those governments between a consumer's view of the world and a
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
135
citizen's view-the former focussed on services, the latter on policies, which promotes e-participation and democracy. Governments putting online their legislation, legislative proposals and background documents on issues may be a start towards bringing more citizens into the process. But it is still very much a top-down approach by government, as an analysis shows that the groups and individuals engaged in e-Democracy mainly rely on the agenda set by government and react to what government is doing to create input. This is a natural extension of our current system of representative democracy. In Canada there have been tentative steps towards citizen engagement at the federal level by Human Resources and Development Canada, who conducted a series of workshops in 2001/2002 on the possibility of developing online consultations, but these were solely from the perspective of members of parliament and of the public service. Other departments and agencies such as the Law Reform Commission, Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, Health Canada, Statistics Canada, Department of Indian and Northern Affairs, and the Library of Parliament have all conducted some form of online consultation over the past 2 years. The number of responses were not large nor necessarily a wide representative sampling of the population. However, these online consultations do represent a tentative step forward. The Ontario government's website proclaims its strategy on citizen engagement, claiming they are 'committed to' greater citizen involvement, and outline 'possibilities' of what could be done, with no indication of when or how they intend to develop these, let alone implement them. Most recently, an online consultation was utilized in Ontario to gain citizen input for the Premier's throne speech, and again the numbers responding demonstrated that this method of engaging the citizen is still in its infancy.
Reforms through E-Democracy Online Consultations Online consultation is a methodology that includes the use of ICTs as part of the process for obtaining input from .he citizel)
136
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
into government policies and initiatives. It coni:inues to use other traditional offline methods of submitting that input, by complementing rather than replacing existing structures. There is a multitude of activity in the United States, especially at the state and local levels. France has many online consultative activities, as do the Scandinavian countries (see Swedish example below). The State of Queensland in Australia is developing extensive e-Participation tools through use of web sites, kiosks and other mechanisms to extend e-Participation. The British Government is actively pursuing ways and means to change the current methods cf representative democracy and to bring people into the system through the use of the new ICTs. In July 2002, the UK Government released their e-Democracy Consultation Report, In the Service of Democracy: A Consultation Paper on a Policy for E-Democracy, outlining their strategy on how they intend to modernize electoral procedures, and encourage greater citizen participation in policy-making and the processes of democracy: "The Government's e-participation strategy seeks to find ways in which new technologies can be utilised in the democratic process to connect politicians and the public between elections. The proposals seek to provide greater opportunities for consultation and dialogue between government and citizens." Thl! report emphasized that the goal remained the improvement of democracy not the promoting of technology. They see technology as an enabler, a tool to achieve policy goals, as opposed to the solution to a problem. The paper is a consultative document and funds were allocated for both the consultation process and the follow-up reports and implementation. It encourages citizens to send their comments on the proposals to the government, and offers the options of online or offline input - in writing by mail, fax, or e-mail to the Office of the e-Envoy, or by going to the website: http://www.edemocracy.gov.uk The consultation paper is an ambitious first step towards some form of democratic change from a national government.
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
137
The two main thrusts of their democratic reform agenda are e-Participation and e-Voting, and the paper makes a clear distinction between them as follows: (1) e-Voting: The use of ICT to facilitate participation in
elections or other ballots under statutory control. This comprises e-Voting in: elections to the UK, Scottish and European Parliaments, the devolved assemblies and local councils; (ii) referendums; (iii) private ballots under statutory control. (i)
This track also includes online registration of voters and online application to be an absentee voter. (2) e-Participation: The use of ICT to open new channels for participation in the democratic process between elections. This comprises e-Participation of citizens in: government's policy process; the processes of policy-making, law-making and scrutiny by elected representatives; (iii) the processes of policy formulation in political parties; and other civil society organisations." (i) (ii)
With the aim of intensifying the engagement of its citizens, the city council of Kalix in Sweden conducted an experiment in online deliberation. It enabled the citizens to have online discussions with local politicians and each other and to give their opinions on the renovation of the town centre. Over a two-week period citizens could participate through the Internet, as well as through traditional means of communication such as the telephone, post and fax. Most (86%) of those participating chose to use the Internet. The citizens were also able to vote on the issue online. To ensure that only those entitled to do so could vote and that they voted only once, the council set up a password-protected website and issued a password to registered voters. For citizens without a computer the council arranged for PCs to be made available at schools and libraries.
138
The Evolution of E-Dcmocracy: Role of E-Governimce
Approximately 1,200 of the 15,000 inhabitants participated, 72 per cent of whom reported the experience as a valuable democratic initiative. In November 2001, the government of Queensland, Australia approved a comprehensive community engagement policy and e-Democracy policy framework. The Queensland Government is committed to exploring the many new opportunities the Internet brings and to discovering ways in which this medium can strengthen participative democracy within Queensland. Their commitment, through a three-year e-Democracy trial, to extend opportunities for community participation in the democratic process via the Internet, included measures to: (1) post a number of issues on the website on which the
government desires wide consultation and feedback; (2) provide online access to government consultation documents relevant to those issues, such as discussion and policy papers, and draft bills; (3) broadcast parliamentary debates over the Internet; and (4) develop a system to accc:pt petitions to the Queensland Parliament online. An examination of their website shows an e-Democracy Unit established in the Office of the Premier. "They have broadcasts of parliament online and an online petition system operational (launched August, 2002). An online community consultation trial was launched in November 2002 to develop a standard mode'l, and these are expected to be running by mid-2003." Stephen Coleman reported that ten online consultation experiments undertaken in the UK, which produced some positive results, also found that the public: (1) is interested in political issues that directly affect them;
(2) wants to be heard but not necessarily take over the political process; (3) feels the political elite is difficult to reach; and (4) considers themselves' outside the equation'. He argued that just because a government has implemented online service delivery does not mean this will automatically
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
139
lead to greater democracy. There is definitely a potential for the new ICTs to invigorate democracy but only if harnessed to achieve a 'two-way accountability'. In the second part of its consultation paper the UK Government lays out seven criteria of online consultations, which form part of the Code of Practice on e-Democracy developed by the Office of e-Envoy UK: (1)
(2) (3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
Timing of consultation should be built into the planning process for a policy (including legislation) or service from the start, so that it has the best prospect of improving the proposals concerned, and so that sufficient time is left for it at each stage. It should be clear who is being consulted, about what questions, in what timescale and for what purpose. A consultation document should be as simple and concise as possible. It should make it as easy as possible for readers to respond, make contact or complain. Documents should be made widely available, with the fullest use of electronic means (though not to the exclusion of others), and should be effectively drawn to the attention of all interested groups and individuals. Sufficient time should be allowed for considered responses from all groups with an interest. Twelve weeks should be the standard minimum period for a consultation. Responses should be carefully and open-mindedly analyzed .. and the results made widely available, with an account of the views expressed, and reasons for decisions finally taken.
Departments should monitor and evaluate consultations, designating a consultation coordinator who will ensure the lessons are disseminated. The 2002 study undertaken by the British organizations, SOCITM (Society of Information Technology Management) and Idea (The Improvement and Development Agency), discovered that e-Democracy initiatives carried out in smaller, local jurisdictions were much more successful than in larger states.
140
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
An excellent example is taking place in the town of Jesi in Italy, where the development of a civic network has created a democratic space for discussion and interaction between citizens and ,government, and where the high number of visits to the web site and of citizen participation to the open debate testifies to its success. A second example, in the town of Grefsen-Kjelsas in Norway, demonstrated that although there is a high level of Internet usage and literacy, combined with an affluent, active and involved population, this does "not necessarily ensure swift take-up of e-Democracy" nor result in a wave of democratic renewal. Their e-consultations exposed the limitations of this method, showing that the Internet will play only a partial role in the consultation process.
Online Voting The British Government has maintained, since the last General Election in June 2001, that one of their main goals is to bring youth into the democratic process. The paper sees e-Voting and e-Participation through the use of ICTs as means to engage this age group. In the UK general election of 2001, 60 per cent of the total registered population voted, whereas only 40 per cent of those between the ages of 18-24. Given the nature of the Internet and the age groupings of those who use it (80% of the age group 16-24,70 per cent of the age group 25-44) the government hoped that ICTs could be an application to bring the younger voters into the democratic process in order to improve representative democracy. But participation overall was poorer than expected when online voting was tried in a number of electoral wards, in the May 2002 local elections across the UK: For example in Swindon, which mirrored most areas, only 10.8 per cent of the voters chose to cast their votes via the Internet from home, local libraries and council-run information kiosks. The 2002 Report nevertheless remains optimistic about the potential of online voting, although it recognizes there are other factors to be addressed as well. A recent study commissioned by Elections Canada, and
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
141
done by Jon Pammett and Lawrence Leduc, of those who did not vote in the 2000 Canadian federal election, produced even more surprising results. Qualifying the 960 non-voters into those who: (1) had access to a computer;
(2) were 'very or fairly likely' to vote via the Internet if this were possible; and (3) were 'very or fairly interested' in the 2000 election, the survey found there would be only a potential rise of 2.82 per cent in the voting rate if Internet voting were implemented. The United States federal government and many states, especially California and Arizona, are working towards developing methodologies to achieve online voting. However, as the system of registration of voters is much different in the United States than in parliamentary democracies (the political parties register the voters not electoral commissions), online voting is seen as being further away from reality. In the US presidential election 2000, the Federal Voter Assistance Programme conducted a pilot of remote Internet voting among US military officers overseas. It used the Department of Defense's public key infrastructure to provide authentication. The pilot raised many issues, not least how to increase the size of the system for a larger population and how to ensure the usability of the chosen security system. Brazil, the world's third largest democracy, has been using computer-based tabulation to monitor the integrity of their elections for a number of years. In the 1990 general election in the state of Santa Catarina, the Brazilian Government first introduced the concept of electronic voting by having citizens cast their paper ballots and election workers entering the results into a computer system for tabulation. By 1996, after presenting identification at polling stations to verify eligibility, citizens used electronic voting kiosks to choose their candidates nationwide. By 1998, almost two-thirds of the voting population had cast electronic ballots in federal, state and local elections (Holmes, 2001). While this is not strictly online voting, it does
142
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
enable the results to be published more quickly and accurately, and serves to educate the public in the skills needed for future online voting. Despite the fact that some governments are experimenting with online voting in the hope that more citizens will vote, it is inconclusive whether online voting will help to facilitate a greater civic participation in the electoral process, and indeed the Pammett/Leduc study suggests it will be minimal. There is no evidence as yet that the use of ICTs will rekindle involvement in representative democracy. What seems to be very much needed is a renewal of debate on the nature of democracy itself that will lead to a re-engagement of citizens in the political process. The use of ICTs would be but one small tool in this overall effort. Responding to government-initiated consultations is the most common means of trying to influence policy. However, ICTs offer the possibility of much wider and varied forms of participation. For the purposes of the proposed e-Participation policy the UK consultation paper sets out four main types of political activity and interaction: (1) Citizens and government.
(2) Citizens and representatives. (3) Political parties. (4) Civic activity. The UK paper recognizes that it is important to ensure that all sectors of society are brought into this new vision. It also addresses the issues of trust, privacy and security, three issues about which people have expressed anxiety when asked about their online activities. To this end it articulates very specific principles that need to be incorporated, and recognizes the importance of the inclusion of all, the building of trust, and the necessary policy issues to ensure that citizens will become engaged and that the goals of e-Democracy will be achieved. Seeking to find an interactive role for the citizen in an effective and meaningful way is one of the major challenges now facing governments. There is a clear understanding th"t the new ICTs provide the opportunity and the means to engage the
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
143
citizen. The major obstacle governments will have to solve in order to meet this new challenge will be to develop administrative means and a sufficient back office, consisting of resources, funding, and personnel, to achieve this. Another task will be the finding of ways and means to tabulate and assess the responses received from citizens. New ideas require creativity and innovation. The movement towards online consultations within government, with concomitant pressures from an increasingly interactive citizenry, will test the capacity of governments to change. Providing the short answer to the question of what is the citizen's role in the e-Governance and e-Democracy equation, Stephen Coleman, in his opening address to a recent conference, warned that citizens felt they were 'outside the equation'. Ironically, it was Coleman who said in an online debate on new methods for democratic decision-making called, Boosting the Net Economy 2000: "All of this must be conducted by trusted bodies. Neither government nor commercial firms are sufficiently free of interests to enable them to build such trusted structures. " As shown above, there are continuing gaps between different layers of society, depending on income and place in the society, of those who are online at home and at work and those who are not. The digital divide of cyberspace in developed countries is a serious issue that governments are grappling with. Together with the extent of the digital divide, voter malaise, disinterest, and the public's cynicism about and distrust of their politicians and governments, it is uncertain whether the new ICTs, though they may have the potential to strengthen
144
The Evolution of E-Democracy: Role of E-Governance
problem-definitions, backgrounds, professions, interests, values or traditions must find common ground, must build a shared framework within which they can work together." His is a vision inclusive of a broad public contribution, and his work is liberally referred to in a recent Privy Council Office (Canada) report. Yet in actual practice, based on the re-characterization of e-Governance as an elusive concept, and the exclusion of that broad public voice of different viewpoints, beliefs and backgrounds, from a seminal conference on the future of e-Democracy, that dialogue is in danger of taking place among the clites. Again, this is a fundamental issue, which has to be addressed by politicians and public administrators alike if e-Democracy is to evolve and encompass the majority of our citizens. If citizens are to be engaged online, the tools n('cd to be provided, the issues broadcast widely, the facts made clear and stated in a palatable, understandable form, access to the means for input given to those who will be directly affected by the issues, a safe public space provided for an informed debate, and rational incentives for the ordinary citizen to enter into them. There is some evidence in several countries around the world, as shown in the examples above, that if the leaders and politicians make the effort, people will respond. E-Democracy is in its nascent state and while we cannot accurately predict what shape it will take in generations to come, we do know that there will be changes. The key to the success of e-Democracy will be the participation and partnership of all the stakeholders in government and the citizenry alike.
4 E-Govemance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
Introduction Information and communication technologies can only enhance the transformation of work culture by serving a variety of ends: better delivery of government services to citizens, improved government interactions with business and industry, citizen empowerment through access to information and participation for decision-making, and more efficient government management. E-Governance is not only about introducing or using technological tools. It is fundamentally about a change in mindset and work culture in order to integrate government processes and functions to serve the citizens better. In this process, it is crucial the capacity of government to be open to criticism as well as the application of a new social contract, between all stakeholders, confirming a shared responsibility on the transformation processes. The respect for human rights and freedom of expression is essential to promote and maintain public participation in public consultation spaces. This implies that government personnel have to learn to network and to place people in the centre of the pulitical process.
146
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
So, the effectiveness of leT in government is closely related with the capacity of governments to induce a culture of change placing networking within its institutions as instrumental to transparency and knowledge exchange and creation. It forces a rethinking of the way hierarchical structures are placed. The transition to a more horizontal government structure, where integration of functions plays a greater role, takes time since the main players need to change attitudes and behaviour as they acquire new skills and knowledge that make them confident in the work culture. According to recent data, there is a close relationship between levels of infrastructure development, education, democratization, political leadership and commitment to the principles of good governance and the level and quality of e-Governanc.e implanted in the countries. These are strong indicators of e-Readiness and the opportunity cost of such endeavour. The resulting benefit can be less corruption, increased transparency, greater convenience, efficiency, revenue growth, and/ or cost reductions, as well as increased legitimacy. Traditionally, the interaction between a citizen and a government agency takes place in a government office. With emerging infmmation and communication technologies it is possible to locate service centres closer to the clients. Such centres may consist of an unattended kiosk in the government agency, a service kiosk located close to the client outside the government agency, or the use of a personal computer at home or office. In all the cases the public traditionally looks for information and services addressing his/her needs and in both cases relevance, quality and efficiency are of paramount importance. Therefore, the establishment of e-Governance requires a good knowledge of the needs that exist in the society and that can be offered using ICT. One of the reasons why e-Commerce is well positioned even in countries where e-Governance still lags behind, is that customers know what products and services they want and sellers know what and how· they can deliver those. The development of e-Governance includes (1) publishing, (2) interaction, (3) transact. These activities aim at: broadening
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
147
access to government information such as laws, regulations and data; increasing public participation in decision making through, for example, the publishing of e-mail addresses of government officials and online forums; making government services more readily available to the public through e-filing of government documents, online permits. To date, most effort, in e-Governance, is centred on publishing and not in the subsequent phases of interaction and transaction. Governments, particularly il'! developing countries face limited resources to move fast in e-Governance, so a strong partnership between the public, government, business and the civil society is instrumental in determining the expected outcomes and the effectiveness of e-Governance.
Mozambique's leT Policy The Government of Mozambique, after lengthy consultations with a variety of stakeholders defined in its leT policy six priority areas, which are all related to its main objectives as defined by the Poverty Alleviation Programme (PARPA). These six priority areas are: (1)
(2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
education; human resource development; health; universal access; infrastructure; and e-Governance.
E-Governance is one of the priority areas but in fact can only be effective if is accompanied by interventions in the other areas as well: provision of information and services through the internet makes sense only if a substantial part of the citizens has access to the net, which, in turn, requires the development of infrastructures and human resources. Thus, the priority areas are interrelated and interdependent. E-Governance, according to the policy, will improve the quality of services at the different levels, increase speed, and efficiency as well as reduce costs. A process of reform in the pUblic sector is taking place. This reform aims to analyze and
148
E-Governance Implementation'
r~essons
from Expt;!rience
redesign the functions performed by each unit of work and ministry, exploring ways in which integration is key and takes into consideration the organizational structures and processes, information systems and the human role with the goal to enhance value, quality and efficiency to the Public Administration. ICT is placed high as a tool to improve service delivery within government and to the public, however, the change process requires a management system ready to address the transformations on the organizational culture. For instances, the lack of improvement in the management of government information would lead to reduced effectiveness and efficiency in delivering government programmes and services; reduced opportunity to improve services; decreased information quality; loss of public trust and credibility; inability to demonstrate accountability even if ICT are used. In order to advance with e-Governance programme, surveys are being carried out in the different government institutions to assess the e-Readiness and to establish the capacity building programmes necessary for the future. The implementation strategy is also addressing areas such as project management; coordination and integration of ICT related activities; the conceptualization of the legal framework for telecommunication and ICT usage; and a strategy for integrating all e-Governance initiatives. Different projects have been formulated C'Tld are being implemented:
GovNet-the government's electronic network that will link through a intranet the central, provincial and local government bodies. (2) SIP 2000-a standardized registration system for all civil servants. (3) e-SISTAFE-standardized and computerized system for the administration of public finances, including electronic payments of salaries. (4) Computerized land register-the creation of a cadastre (land register) at the national, provincial and district
(1)
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
(5)
(6) (7) (8) (9)
149
level, which will be easily updated and accessible and verifiable. Civil identification system-a system that will facilitate the emission of identification cards and include a register for all citizens. Mozambique Development Gateway. Health information system. Electoral Management System. One Stop Shop for Government transaction.
E-Governance in Mozambique and the Implementation Challenges
Mozambican Government in the Internet One element of e-Governance is the visibility of government on the Internet. This visibility, similar to e-Commerce, increases possible demand on government services. This visibility can be very general, such as a web page where information about the country is made available to possible clients, ranging from tourists to enterprises, or more specific, i.e., making public the activities of a particular government agency. Five years ago, the use of the Internet by government agencies was extremely low. Some ministries did already use e-mail. However, e-mail is, by nature, a more personalized form of communication, and is not intended to serve the communication needs of the broader public. Since then, and as part of the ICT Policy, a concerted effort by the government, the Eduardo Mondlane University (UEM) and private agencies has lead to an increased presence of the government on the Internet. There is one central web page (www.govmoz.gov.mz) from where all government agencies can be reached. Moreover, there is another page (www.mozambique.mz) where general information on Mozambique can be found including government information. This page is designed to serve a broader, foreign audience willing to invest in or make a visit to Mozambique. Both pages are maintained by the Centre for ICT (CIUEM) of UEM. At the same time, individual ministries are creating their web pages and developing a service platform.t.o the public with their own resources.
150
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
E-services Whereas six years ago, e-Governance was non-existent in Mozambique, in the mean time, many government agencies have entered into the digital era. In Table 1 we list 25 central government agencies and provide information as to their accessibility bye-mail address published in the web. Seven out of 25 ministries have published their e-mail addresses on the central web page of the Mozambican government or on their own web page, although all of them have email addresses that are used not only inside the government but also with personal interaction with the public. Nine ministries do not have a web page. Some of the existing web pages, however, do not cover the entire ministry but only one or two directorates (e.g., MOPH, MPF, MIREME) and four websites arc still under construction. Only three ministries offer a website that covers the entire institution (MINED, MESCT, Youth and Sports). Most pages arc in Portuguese, although some (MIREME, MOPH) use English as well. The information offered cover essentially: (1)
(2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
information about the organization; contacts; agenda of the Minister; events; laws and regulations; policy statements.
Some ministries offered other services in addition to those indicated above and are starting to move into e-transacting. For example, MESCT allows for the download of forms and other documents of public interest, consultation of the final results of science competitions, competitive funds and fellowships. In addition, its web page is also used to promote debates on public policies related to the work of the ministry. The public, in general, can send comments about a proposed policy and their comments not only are used to revise the documents on discussion but can also be accessed by other participants in the debate. This method was very successful during the design of
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
151
Table-l The State of E-Govemance in Mozambique
Agency
E-mail WebAddress site in the Web Page
Presidency Prime Minister Ministry of State Administration (MAE) Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MADER) Ministry of Former Combatants Ministry of Environment (MICOA) Ministry of Culture Ministry of Defence Ministry of Education (MINED) Ministry of Higher Education, 5&T (MESCT) Ministry of Industry and Trade (MIC) Ministry of the Interior (MINT) Ministry of Justice Ministry of Youth and Sports Ministry of Women and Social Action (MIMUCAS) Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MINEC) Ministry of Public Works (MOPH) Ministry of Fisheries Ministry of Planning and Finance (MPF) Ministry of Mineral Resources and Energy (MIREME) Ministry of Health (MISAU) Ministry of Labour Ministry of Transport and Communications Ministry of Tourism (MITUR) Ministry for the Presidency and Diplomatic Affairs
N N N
N N N
N N Y N N
Y N N N N Y Y N N N Y
y*
Y N N N Y Y
y**
Y N N N N
y**
N N Y N N
N N
Y y**
Y Y
y**
Y N
* Not mentioned in www.govmoz.gov.mz ** Under construction
•
152
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
our science and technology policy. The added value brought by this me~hod of knowledge exchange and creation through networks, was a successful experience that can be used for a strategic planning and implementation of more shared public spaces. In order to address some of the needs of MESCT's clients it is possible for the public to use the computer room at the ministry to access relevant information related to our services and to higher education, science and technology in general. Unfortunately this service is only offered in Maputo. Maintenance of the pages seems to constitute a problem with few exceptions. Although e-Governance is advancing only four, out of the 25 ministries, use at least up to a certain level all facilities that the Internet offers: information, communication, services. Few transactions or deliveries are done through the Internet, and for most services it is still necessary to visit the physical structures and deal directly with civil servants at the ministry's offices. Moreover, key service providers such as the Ministries of Agriculture; Fisheries and Mining (exploitation rights, land titles, etc.) do not yet use the Internet for the provision of these services. Several public agencies such as the Central Bank, Customs and the Centre for the Promotion of Investments (CPI) also operate on the Internet. Another key agency is the National Institute of Statistics (INE). Through its web page one can access up-to-date information and statistics on demography, poverty, health, macro-economic indicators. INE is currently working on the construction of an interactive system where data will be stored in a data warehouse and accessed through multidimensional tables. This system will offer almost complete access to relevant statistical information to the public. Mozambique's government has embarked on a road to a more intensive use of ICT in administration and in improving the contacts between the government and citizens and has built the initial basis for the full implementation of the e-Governance programme.
Connectivi ty Although over the last decade a rapid increase has occurred
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
153
in the access to telecom services, connectivity remains a serious problem. Currently, teledensity is about 7.6 fixed phone lines per 1000 inhabitants. The cellular network, now operated under two competing licenses, serves approximately 560,000 people and covers according to one of these providers almost 25 per cent of the national territory. However, it should be stated that coverage is often deficient and that geographical coverage and capacity is limited, mainly, to the capital, Maputo, along the two principal international corridors (MaputoSouth Africa and Beira-Zimbabwe) and in some tourism development areas such as Xai Xai, Bilene, Vilanculos and Mozambique Island. Internet access is even more restricted. In Maputo City, a Television Cable operator has expanded into offering fast, broadband, Internet services. However, its action radius is restricted to the heart of the City and does not reach the outskirts. This provider is working on expanding its operations into Maputo's satellite city Matola, but these operations are still very small-scale. An optical fiber connects Maputo, the capital, to Beira, the country's second most populated city. VSAT connections are being established in most provincial capitals as part of an effort to expand e-Governance into the provinces. Moreover, one of the major Internet operators has opened local facilities in all provincial capitals reducing significantly the costs of those who depend on dial-up connections. However, the capacity of these lines remains small. Indeed, for the government it is easier to do the investment in hardware, than to sustain the recurrent costs of maintenance and phone bills. The connections currently on offer with a quality that enables a government agency to act on and through the Internet surpass national carrying capacity. The Quality/ Cost ratio is normally more favourable in Maputo, implying that it is more difficult to use ICT to strengthen the vertical connections in ministerial organizations that link district and province and province and capital. As a considerable part of the citizens lives outside Maputo, it is of key interest that cheaper solutions are found. Currently, several alternative options are being studied to
154
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
improve coverage. These options range from the use of the power network through wireless connection through the use of mobile stations, e.g., similar to the Citizen Assistance Service Centres in Bahia, Brazil.
Relations between Public and Private Sectors The expansion of ICT in government structures requires the establishment of new infrastructures, the purchase of new machines, and expanding education and training in ICT to provide the required knowledge and skills. Privately owned corporations offer these goods and services. Software can be bought from corporations/companies such as Microsoft and Oracle, who also provide the required training of the engineers who will manage the systems. Hardware can be acquired from Dell, IBM and many others. National companies such as Mcel, TDM, Teledata and Virconn build the necessary infrastructures, whereas foreign companies control access to gateway to the Internet outside Mozambique. Thus, the expansion of e-Governance implies automatically the establishment of strong and long-terru relationships between the public and the private sector. This requires the establishment of a regulatory framework that promotes these partnerships. One may ask what shape that relation should take. One option is for the Mozambican government to wait for the emergence of a significant private demand and ride on the infrastructures put in place in response to that demand. However, in a country such as Mozambique, with low income, high illiteracy rate and low level of private demand, might be insufficient to justify a rapid expansion of quality Internet connections into provincial and district capitals. Indeed, today an operator that offers a broadband connection-TVCaboonly operates in the centre of Maputo City, where 88 per cent of the access to the Internet in the country is concentrated. With the private demand lagging behind, it appears that the relation has to be reversed and that the government will have to drive the creation of the infrastructures that will enable the expansion of ICT in°to the provinces and districts. However, a cash-starved government such as that of Mozambique is
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
155
unable to sustain the full load of such investments. It will have to try to create partnerships, with the private sector, and attract private long-term investment through the creation of enabling conditions and incentives for such participation. This makes the e-Governance project very dependent on the assessment these companies make of future gains. At this stage, e-Governance in Mozambique is highly dependent on donors' support. Some countries and multilateral agencies have, through their development agencies, pledged funds for project that support the expansion of e-Governance in Mozambique. Sustainability is an issue placed high in the government agenda for it is the government role to support the demand growth that will lead to reduced costs and build the necessary human capacity to run, efficiently, the system. The Mozambican government has established partnerships with different enterprises such as Microsoft, Oracle and others to provide the hardware and software infrastructure necessary and build the required expertise for the implementation of components of its policy towards various sectors and also as to e-Governance.
The Demand for Intemet Services It is extremely difficult to estimate the need for e-Govemance services. One of the possible indicators of that need for e-services is the level of use of government's websites. Unfortunately, no systematic inventory of this use has been made. The only available data is from MESCT. These data show: (1) A considerable monthly variation in the number of
visits, ranging from only 431 in December 2003 to almost 6000 in April 2004. (2) There is a considerable daily variation, with a low number of visits during weekends and public holidays; this suggests that most visits are either made from an office or for professional aims. However, almost 40 per cent of all hits in the month of May were outside office hours, between 17.00 and 08.00, suggesting a considerable private capacity among MESCT's current audience to access the Internet.
116
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience (3) The most visited pages are those that provide information about grants, academic degrees and the Internet competition on math equations. (4) Downloaded documents correspond typically to services provided by MESCT (Quality and Innovation Fund, study grants, etc.). (5) In May 2004, MESCT's website was visited by 2,386 different computers (URL's). (6) Thirty URL's were respons\ble for 27.6 per cent of the hits; out of these, 6 URL's were internal (MESCT).
These data, obviously help us little to understand to what extend MESCT is reaching and serving its clients through the Internet and the mechanisms that determine whether people will use it. It does show, however, that in one Month (May 2004) its page was accessed by at least 2,310 computers from outside the ministry. Taking into consideration that MESCT caters for a rather small universe (17,000 university students, 1,800 university staff and 500 researchers at research stations), it seems that in this case its web page is, indeed, serving a considerable demand.
Standardization and Norms E-Governance concerns basically the integration of procedures and information. Such integration can only be successful if a common vision is created about the key concepts and if procedures are standardized. Currently, MESCT is engaged in building an integrated system for the higher education sector for data management and storage. This system would bring together higher education institutions in one network, which would be more cost-effective than having the rather small institutions developing individual solutions. However, to do so, the institutions will have to standardize concepts and proced ures. In this particular case the usefulness of standardization is not restricted to the computerization of management. MESCT needs to monitor the development of the sector to be able to assess the effect.iveness of current policies and to design new strategies. Thus, the need of the government to standardize
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
157
concepts and procedures is completely compatible with the digitalization of the sector. The same is happening to E-SISTAFE and to SIP, projects under the Ministries of Planning and Finance and State Administration.
Rapid Development of ICT We are often led to believe that digital storage of information is safer than the conventional way, on paper. However, this claim is highly debatable. Although paper may decay, eaten by insects and fungi or be burned, digital information carriers are no guarantee for safe conservation over a long period of time. Actually, the preservation of electronic information poses a significant additional challenge: (1) Digital data are subject to different forms of decay.
Similar to conventional paper records, they are subject to material decay caused by the degeneration of its material support. A disk may suddenly turn Ifaulty' and the information it carries is lost. (2) Whereas the life expectancy of some of the digital information carriers is surprisingly short, traditional forms have survived centuries. Today we are still capable of reading the writings left behind in the pyramids of Old Egypt, although its scripture is no longer in use. Digital data, however, suffer from a very fast technical decay. This technical decay is due to the gradual upgrading of the software and machines that are used to read it. We all have the experience of having databases written in programmes languages that died out, and the incompatibility between programmes from different providers or even between different versions of the same programme. Thus, a document we saved ten years ago in WordPerfect may no longer be accessible because our current version of word no longer recognizes the text.
Economies of Scale E-Governance is not a cheap solution. The investment in
158
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
equipment and the recurrent costs related to maintenance and connectivity makes it an expensive endeavour. The unit costs of this investment can be brought down if economies of scale exist. MESCT's endeavour to create an integrated system for the higher education institutions is a good example: bringing together the public and private institutions will reduce costs and improve efficiency. As the project encompasses campuses and institutions in different parts of the country, it will imply costs of connectivity, but as these connections will be used for other aims as well, such as offering Internet access to staff and students in parts of the country where such access is very restricted or non-existent, the added value may justify the investment. The eLonomies of scale may surpass the restricted dimensions of government institutions, or even, as in the case of MESCT's project, that of the main stakeholders. Bringing VSAT or other wireless options to a university will offer third parties, e.g., private enterprises, an opportunity to engage in using leT. In that case, the government will act as a catalyst, triggering the expansion of access to leT. into the country. Even with economies of scale e-Governance could be seen as a wasteful tool if it is not able to respond the people's interests in consultation and participation. If e-Governance is well targeted, it will not only enhance the capacity of the government to respond to these interests, but it :will also create new demands and stimulate a more active participation. In certain cases, scale may be an additional instrument to improve the balance between costs and benefits.
Need for Know-how E-Governance requires two types of know-how. One concerns the normalization and standardization of concepts and procedures. The other concerns the hardware and software related to the use of leT. Both needs are sine qua non and have to be addressed if e-Governance is going to have any success. In the particular case of Mozambique, one should emphasize that know-how is extremely restricted. Mozambiql1e has approximately 60 university graduates in computer sciences.
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
159
There is a considerable demand for these graduates. Government agencies find it difficult to compete with the NGO and private sectors be,cause of budgetary restrictions and lengthy bureaucratic recruitment procedures. Moreover, investing in their upgrading may be rather risky, as this will raise their market value and therefore increase the risk of their departure to a better-paid position outside government. Table-2 Number of ICT Related Professional in Government Institutions Professional Training
Women
Information Technology Technician Programmers and System Operators System Engineers B.Sc. in other areas System Analysts
Male Total
12 2
35
47
o
4 5
5
19
6 5 24 1
o
1
Reference: National Commission for ICT. The government is aware that leT is crucial to the country's developmental goals, and through the ICT implementation unit is organizing training and awareness courses to the civil servants, planners and policy-makers. Recommendations Based on the Mozambican case we can say that, the use of ICT to improve government efficiency and transparency dependents how well we tackle important areas such as:
Improvement of Information Management Too often the introduct4m of ICT and the construction of web pages is seen as an objective on its own. However, the success of these endeavors depends largely on the capacity of government bodies to manage the information under their control. This requires standardization of concepts and procedures, as well as the creation of secure storage systems, back-ups and redundancy. Digital data may prove hlghly
160
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
volatile and entrusting archives to hard disks might be the securest way to their loss if preventive measures are not taken.
Improvement of Services to the Public E-Governance is citizen centered. Obviously, putting a computer on somebody's desk is not enough to shift the focus of government to the citizen. To achieve this, one has to change the existing organizational culture. Civil servants should realize that their work is indeed a service to the public. Improvement of attitude requires a cultural change that can only happen if the leadership fully understands and supports the need for attitudinal and behaviour change.
Improvement of Education Level To guarantee that the people can exercise their citizenship one needs an educated citizen. The -technology used in the processing, storage and publication of data and in the transactions with the citizens is a secondary issue, it is the capacity to interact between the citizen and government, that will guarantee the .quality of services. Every person has the skills and knowledge that are relevant to his or her survival. To equate an uneducated society with a society without knowledge is therefore totally ludicrous. However, survival in a period where the world has shrunken to a village and ICT are increasingly permeating the different aspects of life, makes it necessary that people acquire the knowledge and skills to fully benefit from these technologies. For that reason, it is necessary to invest in raising the level of education of the population. The use of ICT is heavily dependent on literacy and related skills of reading information in computer screens.
Adequate Technological Solutions Currently, different options exist as to the various aspects related to ICT and it is likely that in the near future new options will eIl1:erge. It is up to the government to find the different combinations that respond adequately to the geographical, cultural and educational diversity existing in Mozambique.
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
161
The efficiency of ICT usage depends on increased teledensity and mobile penetration and the scale-up of initiatives such as the development of mUlti-purpose community centres and e-schools.
Possible Causes of Failure: An Evaluation (1) Planning to Fail or Fail to Plan: The first step in any
project is to plan the project. The success of the project will depend on the skill and expertise with which it is planned and conceptualized. It is often felt that Government Department shy away from spending a few lakhs in preparation of project plans for eGovernance projects worth hundreds of crores. And at times unskilled individual decides the plan and they plan fail. The plans are made without clear objectives, unclear roles and responsibilities. There are no parameters for financial controls. Areas like risk assessment, feasibility assessment, prioritization and strategy are not even thought lest be addressed completely. So, whereas there exists no plan in some projects, in others the planning is done for failure. (2) Mission hrpossible: Another cause of project failure is to visualize the impossible. The project consultants as hired by various Government Departments generally promise the moon to the departments. They expect that whatever they suggest will be implemented in government without realizing the fact that the government has its on limitations. At times there are procedural and departmental constraints, other times legal constraints and at times even constitutional constraints. Consultants without even realizing the ground reality propose solutions which are redundant, non practical and non-achievable. As a result their reports lie in the shelves of Government Officers catching dusts. There always exists a vision and reality gap between what is proposed and what can be implemented. The initial over expectations created by consultants leads to difficulties in managing customer
162
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience expectations later. The reality and vision gap is the second step towards e-Governance failure (3) Misunderstanding Governance: The consultants taken by the government at time totally misunderstand the governance process and the institution of government. They do not realize that the government will be governed by constitution and the laws therein. A simple example from India is that the consultants most often suggest centralized e-Governance solutions without realizing that India is a federal state and there is clear distinction of subjects between state and centre in the constitution. To implement a solution as suggested by them will require constitutional amendments which are not easy to implement. Consultants feel that government will change according to the solution suggested by them. They have an impression that government has to fit into their solution and not vice versa. In reality they have to actually ensure that their solutions fit into government needs. Further the consultants do not realize that government is a complex structure which has existed over years and any big changes are very difficult to implement. There are other political, social, economic, security constraints for the government leading to certain changes totally unacceptable. Therefore whatever solutions are suggested have to be after proper understanding the government and its complexities. Misundersting government and governance is third step leading to eGovernance projects to fail. (4) Bottleneck is at the Top of Bottle, Always: It is often sited that the project has failed because the staff at the lower level is not ready to adapt to the computerized environment. However in Indian scenario the success of computerization in Indian Posts, Indian Railways and Public Sector Banks has proved otherwise. Therein the staff at the bottom is also using computers and the changes are very fast. Then why the changes in various Government Departments are not taking place. It is
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
163
more because of the top leadership. The departments in Government of India are mostly headed by individuals who are near to their retirement. Majority of the Secretaries, as they are termed have just few months in service and therefore they are not keen on any new initiative or a reform process. This has been happening since many years. The top officials are lovers of status quo and develop resistance to change. With no support from the top leadership the e-Governance projects do not get encouragement and therefore meet death. Further, even if one secretary is reformist there will be new secretary to take his place within two months who will bring back the British legacy of working. Further, at times there are individuals and vested interests who try to de-rail the projects. At time the leadership appointed for project coordination is inadequate and unskilled. The resistance created by top leadership is the fourth step towards e-Governance failure. (5) Vendor Driven e-Govemance: It was a shock to the whole nation when one of the leading names in consultancy published a report and stated that e-Governance in India is Vendor Driven. It was then realized that in multiple e-Governance projects the vendors for hardware, databases, operating systems, software applications, etc., were driving e-Governance. The Government Officials in most cases were mislead to believe that the vendor's solutions were the e-Governance solutions. Not to say what made Government Officials to believe those vendors. Vendors in a quest to sell their solutions, sold anything and every thing to the government. The author recalls that in an instance multiple copies of Voice to Text software were bought by a Department as e-Governance application. Needless to say, they were n~ver used and Personal Secretaries continued to take dictations. Vendor driven e-Governance therefore is the fifth cause that leads to failure in e-Governance projects.
164
E-Governance Implementatio'l: '~essons from Experience (6) Focus on Ie' than Governance: Every seminar, every author, every Government Officer stresses that e-Governance is more about Governance than 'e'. However, the implementers in government have not realized the importance of same. Majority of the nations across the world have their e-Governance initiatives spearhead from the Ministries of Information Technology, as if e-Governance is about IT and not Governance. It is not realized that for successful implementation of the e-Governance programme the programme managing unit must be placed under the Prime Minister or the President to lead to successful implementation. The team for this programme management unit must comprise of individuals with experience in diverse government background. In many countries it had been observed that the teams are drawn from electronics and IT background which may lead to skewed implementation challenges. Further, it must be realized that e-Governance is beyond Internet Governance. In a nation there are very few people who have access to internet and very few who are internet users amongst them and further few who use internet for e-Governance. Therefore e-Governance solutions must be planned with multiple access facilities. Focus on IT and electronics is the sixth and most important causes of failure of e-Governance. (7) Employees as Stakeholder Universe: Majority of the projects take government employees as the only stakeholders. The consultation process happens with the senior government employees and rest stakeholders are neglected. The Government Departments feel that they know all the requirements of the stakeholders and therefore it is useless spending time on such project. Despite the lectures on outside in approach, the projects are actually conceptualized on inside out approach only. It is only the senior employees who take the decision. Further at times the Departments are even scared that if they get into stakeholder consultations
E-Governance Implementation: Lessons from Experience
165
there will be lot of resistance from other stakeholders and the project will end before it takes off. The Departments in this case do not realize that they will face higher resistance from these stakeholders at the time of implementation and they will also not be able to capture their needs properly. The Department/ Client remains satisfied with the consultant for it is giving answers to all the problems of one stakeholder that is the project leader or in better case his Department, neglecting other stakeholders. The con'lultant is happy because it is saving its time and resources on stakeholder consultation. Therefore, the stakeholder universe limited to employees is another cause of failure. (8) Lets Build Rome in a Day: Most e-Governance projects arc given unachievable timelines. Most of the time Ministers or leaders make announcements and the deadlines than the quality become key challenge in project implementation. For a project to be successful and error free minimum time is required. Taj Mahalthe Best Project in the world-took 17 years and 20,000 workers to be completed. Even though we may not require 17 years now but two to three years is minimum time for an e-Governance project to actually be ready to be launched from its planning. It may take another two to three years for training and adoption of the project by all stakeholders. A change is not