TRACE FOSSILS CONCEPTS, PROBLEMS, PROSPECTS
TRACE FOSSILS CONCEPTS, PROBLEMS, PROSPECTS Edited by WILLIAM MILLER, III Geology Department Humboldt State University Arcata, CA, USA
AMSTERDAM BOSTON HEIDELBERG LONDON NEW YORK SAN DIEGO SAN FRANCISCO SINGAPORE SYDNEY
OXFORD TOKYO
PARIS
Elsevier Radarweg 29, PO Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, UK
First edition 2007 Copyright ß 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (+44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://elsevier.com/locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN-13: 978-0-444-52949-7 ISBN-10: 0-444-52949-7
For information on all Elsevier publications visit our website at books.elsevier.com
Printed and bound in Italy 07 08 09 10 11
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents
The Cincinnati School 23 Conclusions 28 Acknowledgements 29 References 29
Introduction: A User’s Guide— William Miller, III xiii List of Reviewers Contributors
xvii
xix
Memorial to Roland Goldring (1928–2005)— John E. Pollard xxi
3. Edward Hitchcock and Roland Bird: Two Early Titans of Vertebrate Ichnology in North America
I
S. GEORGE PEMBERTON, MURRAY K. GINGRAS,
THE HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF ICHNOLOGY
AND JAMES A. MACEACHERN
Introduction 32 The Ichnology of the Connecticut Valley 33 Roland Bird and the Discovery of Sauropod Tracks 41 Conclusions 49 Acknowledgements 49 References 49
1. The Wadden Sea, Cradle of Invertebrate Ichnology GERHARD C. CADE´E AND ROLAND GOLDRING
Introduction 03 The Early Beginnings of Ichnology 03 The Role of Experiments 04 Research in the Wadden Sea 04 Ichnology Elsewhere in the Wadden Sea The Promotion of Ichnology 08 Conclusions 10 Acknowledgements 10 References 10
08
4. The Ichnofacies Paradigm: A Fifty-Year Retrospective JAMES A. MACEACHERN, S. GEORGE PEMBERTON, MURRAY K. GINGRAS, AND KERRIE L. BANN
2. The Antecedents of Invertebrate Ichnology in North America: The Canadian and Cincinnati Schools
Introduction 52 The Rise of the Ichnofacies Concept Continental Ichnofacies 55 Softground Marine Ichnofacies 58 Substrate-Controlled Ichnofacies 68 Using the Ichnofacies Paradigm 74 Acknowledgements 75 References 75
S. GEORGE PEMBERTON, JAMES A. MACEACHERN, AND MURRAY K. GINGRAS
Introduction 14 The Early Canadian School
15
v
53
vi
CONTENTS
Acknowledgements References 131
II CONCEPTS, METHODS, THEORY, AND CONNECTIONS TO THE EARTH AND BIOLOGIC SCIENCES
MARKUS BERTLING
82
6. Taphonomy of Trace Fossils CHARLES E. SAVRDA
Introduction 92 Trace Fossil Preservation in Soft Mud 93 Preservation in Heterolithic Softground Successions 98 Preservation in Coarse-Grained Substrates 101 Preservation in Firmgrounds 103 Preservation in Hard Substrates 104 Preservation in Woodgrounds 105 Ichnofossil-Lagersta¨tten 106 Conclusions 107 Acknowledgements 107 References 107
7. Uses of Trace Fossils in Genetic Stratigraphy JAMES A. MACEACHERN, S. GEORGE PEMBERTON, MURRAY K. GINGRAS, KERRIE L. BANN, AND LYNN T. DAFOE
Introduction 110 Substrate-Controlled Ichnofacies 113 Substrate-Controlled Ichnofacies and the Role of Autocyclicity 119 Ichnological Applications to Genetic Stratigraphy 120 Conclusions 130
8. The Application of Trace Fossils to Biostratigraphy ROBERT B. MACNAUGHTON
5. What’s in a Name? Nomenclature, Systematics, Ichnotaxonomy Introduction 81 Treating Names of Trace Fossils: Nomenclature Classifying Trace Fossils: Systematics 82 Naming Trace Fossils: Ichnotaxonomy 83 Conclusions 90 Acknowledgements 90 References 91
130
Introduction 135 Limitations and Advantages of Trace Fossils in Biostratigraphy 135 Characteristic Applications of Trace Fossils in Biostratigraphy 136 Other Potentially Useful Ichnotaxa 145 Toward Reliable Trace-Fossil Biostratigraphy 146 Concluding Discussion 146 Acknowledgements 147 References 147
9. Trace Fossils and Marine Benthic Oxygenation CHARLES E. SAVRDA
Introduction 149 Oxygen-Related Ichnocoenoses (ORI) 149 Manifestation of ORI in Vertical Sequences 151 Case Study—Cretaceous Bridge Creek Limestone 153 Potential Limitations and Future Directions 154 Conclusions 156 Acknowledgements 156 References 156
10. Climatic Control of Marine Trace Fossil Distribution ROLAND GOLDRING, GERHARD C. CADE´E, AND JOHN E. POLLARD
Introduction 159 Constraints on Recognition of Climatic Control of Trace Fossils 160 Ichnology of Certain Crustaceans 161 Spatangoid Echinoid Ichnology 164 Discussion on Modern Distributions of Infaunal Echinoids and Ophiomorpha-Forming Crustaceans 164 Ophiomorpha and Spatangoid Trace Fossils 165
vii
CONTENTS
A New Type Ichnospecies for Zoophycos 224 Ichnogenus Zoophycos Massalongo 1855 226 Conclusions 228 Acknowledgements 230 References 230
Other Trace Fossils of Possible Climatic Significance 168 Conclusions 169 Acknowledgements 170 References 170
11. Climatic Controls on Continental Trace Fossils STEPHEN T. HASIOTIS, MARY J. KRAUS, AND TIMOTHY M. DEMKO
Introduction 172 Distribution of Organisms and their Traces—Ichnofossils 173 Soil Formation and Palaeosols 175 Soil-Water Balance: Linking Soil, Biota, and Climate 176 Climate 177 Ichnopedologic Associations as Climate Indicators: Organism Behaviors and Palaeosols 181 Predictions of Ichnopedologic Associations of Palaeoclimate 184 Conclusions 192 Acknowledgements 193 References 193
14. Ichnofacies, Ichnocoenoses, and Ichnofabrics of Quaternary Shallow-Marine to Dunal Tropical Carbonates: A Model and Implications H. ALLEN CURRAN
Introduction 232 Ichnology of Carbonate vs. Siliciclastic Environments 233 The Geologic and Ichnologic Setting: Bahamas and South Florida 234 Ichnocoenoses of the Skolithos Ichnofacies 234 Ichnocoenoses of the Psilonichnus Ichnofacies 241 Conclusions 245 Acknowledgements 246 References 246
15. Deep-Sea Ichnology: Development of Major Concepts 12. The Trace-Fossil Record of Vertebrates STEPHEN T. HASIOTIS, BRIAN F. PLATT, DANIEL I. HEMBREE, AND MICHAEL J. EVERHART
Introduction 196 Vertebrate Ichnology: Concepts and Methods Locomotion Traces: Trails, Tracks, and Trackways 197 Burrows and Nests 205 Feeding Trace Fossils 211 Hominid Trace Fossils 214 Future Directions 215 Acknowledgements 216 References 216
13. Zoophycos and the Role of Type Specimens in Ichnotaxonomy DAVIDE OLIVERO
Introduction 219 An Enigmatic Fossil 219 The Type Specimen 224
197
ALFRED UCHMAN
Introduction 248 Age of Fucoids 248 From Algae to Worms: Towards Consistent Ichnotaxonomy 249 Morphological Classifications 250 What Worms are Doing: Fossil Behaviour 250 Environmental Distribution of Trace Fossils and the Ichnofacies Concept 252 Colonization, Bioturbation and Ichnofabric Concepts 253 Substrate 257 Trophic Level 258 Changes Through Geological Time and Evolutionary Aspects 259 Deep-Sea Fine-Grained Non-Turbiditic Sediments 261 Neoichnology 262 Further Perspectives 262 Acknowledgements 263 References 263
viii
CONTENTS
16. Continental Ichnology: Fundamental Processes and Controls on Trace Fossil Distribution
Conclusions 338 Acknowledgements References 340
340
STEPHEN T. HASIOTIS
Introduction 268 The Continental Realm 269 Terrestrial and Aquatic Biota: Tracemaker Classification and Behavior 276 Synthesis: Continental Ichnocoenoses 279 Conclusion: Two Distinct Parts but One Ichnology 282 Acknowledgements 283 References 283
17. Invertebrate Ichnology of Continental Freshwater Environments ´ NGANO LUIS ALBERTO BUATOIS AND MARI´A GABRIELA MA
Introduction 285 Continental Ichnofacies 285 Ichnology of Fluvial Systems 287 Ichnology of Lacustrine Systems 299 The Ichnofabric Approach to Freshwater Ichnofaunas 307 Applications of Ichnology in Sequence Stratigraphy of Continental Successions 310 Marine vs. Nonmarine 315 Freshwater Ichnofaunas in Marginal Marine Environments 316 Acknowledgements 316 References 316
19. Early History of Symbiosis in Living Substrates: Trace-Fossil Evidence from the Marine Record LEIF TAPANILA AND A.A. EKDALE
Introduction 345 Bioclaustrations as Fossilized Behavior 346 Criteria for Distinguishing Bioclaustrations 347 Bioclaustrations in Context with Other Sessile Associations 349 Early Fossil Record of Bioclaustrations 349 Diversity Trends in the Paleozoic 351 Conclusions 354 Acknowledgements 354 References 354
20. Macroborings and the Evolution of Marine Bioerosion MARK A. WILSON
Introduction 356 Commonly Bored Hard Substrates 357 Most Common Marine Macroboring Taxa 357 History of Macroboring Through the Phanerozoic 363 Conclusions 365 Acknowledgements 365 References 365
18. Traces of Gastropod Predation on Molluscan Prey in Tropical Reef Environments
21. Microborings and Microbial Endoliths: Geological Implications
SALLY E. WALKER
GUDRUN RADTKE, AND KLAUS VOGEL
Introduction 324 Overview of Potential Trace Fossils Attributed to Predatory Reef Gastropods 325 Note on Classification, Ranking Treatment of the Gastropod Groups, and Oichnus 325 Shell-Drilling and Shell-Rasping Families and their Potential Trace Fossil Record 325 Gastropod Predators that Wedge Chip-And-Break, and Abrade Shells 333 Predatory Gastropods that Engulf Prey, Produce Toxins and Acidic Secretions, and Promote Corrosion of the Shell or Shell Blisters 336
Introduction 368 Preparation and Study of Microbial Endoliths and Microborings 368 Diversity and Geological Significance of Microbial Euendoliths 369 Microbial Endoliths and Microborings in the Fossil Record 373 Distribution and Environmental Ranges of Microbial Endoliths 375 Ichnological Treatment of Microborings 376 Vertical Distribution of Phototrophic Microbial Euendoliths 378
INGRID GLAUB, STJEPKO GOLUBIC, MARCOS GEKTIDIS,
ix
CONTENTS
Technical Uses of Trace Fossils in Gravity and Piston Cores 423 Conclusions 425 Acknowledgements 426 References 426
Conclusions 378 Future Research 378 Acknowledgements 379 References 379
22. Stromatolites: A 3.5-Billion-Year Ichnologic Record RUSSELL S. SHAPIRO
25. Theoretical and Experimental Ichnology of Mobile Foraging KAREN KOY AND ROY E. PLOTNICK
Why Stromatolites are Trace Fossils 382 The Complexity of Form 382 Models of Formation 383 How Stromatolites have been Used in the Past as Trace Fossils 385 Utility as Trace Fossils 386 Conclusions 388 Acknowledgements 388 References 388
23. Trace Fossils in Evolutionary Paleoecology
Introduction 428 Ichnofossils: Recording Behavior 429 What is Foraging? 430 Foraging Phases 430 Controls on Foraging 431 Resource Detection 432 Movement Related to Foraging 433 A Model for Mobile Foraging 434 Applications to Ichnology 438 Implications for the Early Evolution of Trace Fossils 438 Acknowledgements 439 References 439
´ NGANO AND LUIS ALBERTO BUATOIS MARI´A GABRIELA MA
Introduction 391 Ediacaran Ecosystems 392 The Cambrian Explosion 394 The Ordovician Radiation 396 Colonization of Brackish Water Environments Continental Ichnofaunas Through the Phanerozoic 400 Conclusions 403 Acknowledgements 403 References 403
26. Material Constraints on Infaunal Lifestyles: May the Persistent and Strong Forces be with You 398
PETER A. JUMARS, KELLY M. DORGAN, LAWRENCE M. MAYER, BERNARD P. BOUDREAU, AND BRUCE D. JOHNSON
Introduction 442 The Materials 445 The Processes 447 Discussion 453 Conclusions 456 References 456
III ADVANCES, FRESH APPROACHES, AND NEW DIRECTIONS 24. Importance and Usefulness of Trace Fossils and Bioturbation in Paleoceanography ¨ WEMARK LUDVIG LO
Introduction 413 Trace Fossils 414 Bioturbation 419
27. Complex Trace Fossils WILLIAM MILLER, III
Introduction: What are Complex Trace Fossils? 458 The Concept of Complexity Applied to Biogenic Structures 459 Classification 461 Interpretation 462 Conclusions 463 Acknowledgements 465 References 465
x
CONTENTS
28. A Constructional Model for Zoophycos DAVIDE OLIVERO AND CHRISTIAN GAILLARD
Introduction 466 Main Characteristics 466 Construction of the Lamina 467 The Construction of Lamellae 469 Construction of Lobes 473 Conclusions 476 Acknowledgements 476 References 476
Material and Methods 510 Bioturbation Activity of Macroscopic Burrowers 510 Meiobenthic Trace Fossils 511 Preservation of Soft-Bodied Meiobenthos Taphonomic History 514 Tidality in the Epicontinental Germanic Basin? 515 Conclusions 515 Acknowledgements 516 References 516
513
29. Arthropod Tracemakers of Nereites? Neoichnological Observations of Juvenile Limulids and their Paleoichnological Applications
RICHARD G. BROMLEY, MAX WISSHAK, INGRID GLAUB, AND
ANTHONY J. MARTIN AND ANDREW K. RINDSBERG
ARNAUD BOTQUELEN
Introduction 478 Nereites and Its Makers: Previous Hypotheses 479 Traces of Juvenile Limulus polyphemus: A Neoichnological Analog for Nereites 480 Nereites and Its Makers Reconsidered 486 Ontogeny and Ichnodiversity 488 Conclusions 488 Acknowledgements 488 References 488
30. Macaronichnus isp. Associated with Piscichnus waitemata in the Miocene of Yonaguni-jima Island, Southwest Japan
32. Ichnotaxonomic Review of Dendriniform Borings Attributed to Foraminiferans: Semidendrina igen. nov.
Introduction 518 History 518 The Dual Nomenclature 519 Details of Morphology 520 Biological Interpretation 520 Recent Distribution and Ecological Aspects 525 Stratigraphic Record 525 Possible Precursors 526 Creation of a New Ichnofamily, Dendrinidae Conclusions 527 Appendix: Systematic Ichnology 528 Acknowledgements 529 References 529
NOBUHIRO KOTAKE
33. Ecological and Evolutionary Controls on the Composition of Marine and Lake Ichnofacies
Introduction 492 Geologic Setting 493 Piscichnus waitemata Filled with Macaronichnus isp. 494 Discussion 498 Conclusions 500 Acknowledgements 500 References 500
MOLLY F. MILLER AND DAVID S. WHITE
31. Meiobenthic Trace Fossils as Keys to the Taphonomic History of Shallow-Marine Epicontinental Carbonates DIRK KNAUST
Introduction 502 Location and Geologic Setting Sedimentology 503
503
Introduction 531 Seilacher’s Model of Control and Distribution of Behavior: Ichnofacies 532 Factors Controlling Marine Ichnofacies 532 Ecologically and Ichnologically Important Aspects of Lakes 534 Benthic Animals in Lakes vs. the Ocean 536 Comparison of Marine vs. Lacustrine Ichnofacies 540 Implications and Significance 541 Conclusions 542 Acknowledgements 542 References 542
527
xi
CONTENTS
34. Trace Fossils in an Archaeological Context: Examples from Bison Skeletons, Texas, USA DIXIE L. WEST AND STEPHEN T. HASIOTIS
Introduction 545 Archaeological Setting and Previous Analyses 546 Approach and Method 547 Ichnology—Architectural and Surficial Morphology, Tracemaker, and Discussion 547 Invertebrate Traces 547 Human Modifications 555 Weathered Bone 558 Discussion and Conclusions 559 Acknowledgements 560 References 560
35. Ichnofacies of an Ancient Erg: A Climatically Influenced Trace Fossil Association in the Jurassic Navajo Sandstone, Southern Utah, USA A.A. EKDALE, RICHARD G. BROMLEY, AND DAVID B. LOOPE
Introduction 562 Geologic Setting 563 Organism Traces in Dunes Trace Fossils 564
Trace Makers 568 Paleoecologic Interpretations 568 Paleoclimatic Implications 569 Entradichnus Ichnofacies 570 Conclusions 572 Acknowledgements 573 References 573
36. Endobenthic Response through Mass-Extinction Episodes: Predictive Models and Observed Patterns JARED R. MORROW AND STEPHEN T. HASIOTIS
Introduction 575 Background 576 Endobenthic Ecosystems and Extinction 577 Predictive Models of Endobenthic Response 579 Observed Endobenthic Responses Across Mass-Extinction Intervals 581 Discussion—Hypothesized and Empirical Endobenthic Ecosystem Responses Compared 592 Directions for Future Research 594 Acknowledgements 594 References 595
564 Index
599
Introduction: A User’s Guide William Miller, III
ICHNOLOGY AT THE BEGINNING OF THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY
following Seilacher’s initial concepts. This kind of activity continues to dominate trace fossil research. Growing gradually and less conspicuously along side the nomenclatural approach has been a more analytic perspective. This involves the fundamental business of trying to determine the trace-producing organisms, comparisons with modern trace producers and modern environments, functional interpretations of structures, computer modeling, and novel approaches to the interpretation of paleoethologic, physiologic and physicochemical properties of biogenic structures of all kinds. The one aspect that has never been adequately developed is theory. I am not sure that the nomenclatural systems developed 50 years ago really qualify as biologic theory; this kind of development may have to wait until connections to behavioral ecology and evolutionary theory have been more completely and plausibly established, and is likely to grow more readily from the analytic side of ichnology. I will be quick to add that the traditional nomenclatural approach has worked very well in getting the modern enterprise of ichnology up and on its feet, has made possible the systematic documentation needed before generalizations could be attempted, and has secured important and reliable applications to sedimentary geology. So, it might be better to say that the biologic side of ichnology is where theory development has lagged—it depends on whether one sees trace fossils primarily as sedimentary structures or as ethologic records. Most modern workers have always considered them to be both, but most have emphasized connections to sedimentology and stratigraphy. Now, skip forward to the beginning of the twentyfirst century, and we see ichnology as one of the most active branches of paleontology (or sedimentary geology, if you prefer), with no signs of slowing down.
We have been describing and attempting to interpret trace fossils, more or less effectively, for over a century. One could point to several times in the history of paleontology or sedimentary geology when ichnology, as a separate discipline, appears to take shape for the first time. This is largely a matter of when the various early practitioners were active. I will leave it to the historians of our discipline to nail down all the exact dates, key figures and origins of ideas. A concise historical sketch can be found in the introduction to Ekdale et al. (1984). It is clear from this brief account, and from the longer essay by Osgood (1975) and especially the excellent historical chapters that follow, that the origins of ichnology are varied but that the discipline takes on its modern methodologic and conceptual aspects in the 1950s and 1960s. In anglophone countries, this development is usually associated with a ‘founder’ (Dolf Seilacher, signaled especially by a series of extremely influential articles: e.g., 1953, 1962, 1964, 1967a,b) and a ‘founding document’ (Ha¨ntzschel, 1962, 1975)—at least for invertebrate ichnology. Vertebrate and plant trace fossil researchers would tell the story a bit differently (see the essays that follow). But most of the central concepts and methods start to circulate and become widely applied or discussed at about this time. During the next five decades, the work of ichnology was largely nomenclatural, not simply limited to the naming and revision of ichnotaxa, but involving the classification and naming of ichnofacies, applying and modifying behavioral classification, and involving the documentation of whole assemblages of different ages and depositional contexts—in many instances
xiii
xiv
INTRODUCTION: A USER’S GUIDE
We have a sense of where we have come from, a good idea of what works and does not work, and a whole host of notions about the potential growing points of ichnology. This book should provide a picture of how things stand at the beginning of the new century, and where ichnology may go next.
PURPOSE OF THE BOOK This collection of historical sketches, reviews of central concepts and previous work, and chapters describing ongoing research is intended primarily as a progress report on the state of ichnology at the beginning of the twenty-first century. It will also serve as a kind of stepping stone or developmental landmark: a collection of chapters in the ‘line of descent’ from the books and edited volumes that I think mark the beginning of the modern, international ichnology that we practice today (most significantly represented in the English language by Ha¨ntzschel, 1962, 1975; Osgood, 1970; Frey, 1975; Basan, 1978; McCall and Tevesz, 1982; Ekdale et al., 1984; Miller et al., 1984; Curran, 1985; Bromley, 1990, 1996; Ekdale and Pollard, 1991; Maples and West, 1992; Donovan, 1994; Lockley and Hunt, 1995)—a discipline that continues to expand in different directions with new volumes appearing every year (e.g., Pemberton et al., 2001; Hasiotis, 2002; Miller, 2003; McIlroy, 2004; Webby et al., 2004; and more in press) and its own special journal (Ichnos). Trace Fossils: Concepts, Problems, Prospects will also be useful to new ichnologists as a starting place: the source of inspiration, ideas and methods that will fuel future research and possibly launch new careers. Established researchers could use this collection of chapters as a way to check the progress of their own particular brand of ichnology or to keep tabs on what other researchers in the discipline are doing. And I hope scientists in other fields will take notice, and see the many potential connections to their parts of geology and biology. Ichnology as a scientific discipline is more vibrant than ever, has consolidated past accomplishments into a strong conceptual and methodologic framework, and continues to push outward with new discoveries, revisions, applications and connections. This volume contains not only the results of our discipline’s accomplishments to date, but also some clear incentives for future growth. The book is divided into three parts. The first part consists of historical sketches of the development of
ichnology, reviewing background information that is rarely brought out and recognizing older researchers who were never adequately acknowledged. The second contains chapters concerning concepts and practice, indicates connections to other disciplines in the earth and biologic sciences, and conveys a sense of the accomplishments and potential of ichnology. The last part is a mix of chapters that explore new territory, describe novel approaches, and serve as examples of ongoing work. There is something here for novice and veteran, outsider and insider, and for the biologists and the geoscientists.
THANKS WHERE THANKS ARE DUE Projects such as this one are impossible without the cooperation of dedicated, well-informed and experienced reviewers willing to spend their valuable time helping to ensure the quality of the contributions. To all the reviewers I extend my sincere thanks; but to those who reviewed several chapters, I owe a great debt. All are listed in the section that follows. A few reviewers, however, deserve special recognition for working on more than one chapter or for giving advice at critical stages in the development of this book: Richard Bromley, Al Curran, Tony Ekdale, Murray Gingras, John Huntley, Molly Miller, Ron Pickerill, Sally Walker and Andreas Wetzel. My friend and mentor, Molly Miller, must be singled out here, because of special help given when it was desperately needed. I thank John Pollard for providing the Memorial to Roland Goldring, to whom this volume is most appropriately dedicated. I believe Roland would have liked very much what we have done here, and would have considered the chapters well crafted, interesting and useful. The editors at Elsevier were immensely helpful and not a little tolerant of my ideas and goals. Femke Wallien invited me to undertake this project in the first place, and gave valuable advice about organization and production. She, and her assistant Tonny Smit, helped me to get the project underway. More recently, Tirza van Daalen and her assistant Pauline Riebeek have guided the book through the final stages of assembly to publication. Their help and advice are much appreciated. Finally, I thank the authors—especially the ones who took the deadlines as seriously as I did—for a remarkable set of chapters. I think we really can get a sense of how things stand in ichnology at the beginning of the twenty-first century from this collection of work. Moreover, we see how trace fossil
REFERENCES
research is carried out, how the central ideas and concepts have been developed and applied, which problems have persisted despite decades of work, and some good indications of where the discipline is heading.
References Basan, P.B. (Ed.) (1978). Trace Fossil Concepts, Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, Short Course 5, 181 pp. Bromley, R.G. (1990). Trace Fossils: Biology and Taphonomy, Unwin Hyman, London, 280 pp. Bromley, R.G. (1996). Trace Fossils: Biology, Taphonomy and Applications, 2nd edition. Chapman and Hall, London, 361 pp. Curran, H.A. (Ed.) (1985). Biogenic Structures: Their Usefulness in Interpreting Depositional Environments, Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, Special Publication 35, 347 pp. Donovan, S.K. (Ed.) (1994). The Palaeobiology of Trace Fossils, Wiley, Chichester, 308 pp. Ekdale, A.A. and Pollard, J.E. (Eds.) (1991). Ichnofabric and Ichnofacies. Palaios, 6, pp. 199–343. Ekdale, A.A., Bromley, R.G. and Pemberton, S.G. (1984). Ichnology: Trace Fossils in Sedimentology and Stratigraphy, Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, Short Course 15, 317 pp. Frey, R.W. (Ed.) (1975). The Study of Trace Fossils: A Synthesis of Principles, Problems, and Procedures in Ichnology, Springer-Verlag, New York, 562 pp. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1962). Trace fossils and problematica. In: Moore, R.C. (Ed.), Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Part W, Geological Society of America and University of Kansas, pp. W177–W245. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1975). Trace fossils and problematica. In: Teichert, C. (Ed.), Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Part W, Supplement 1, Geological Society of America and University of Kansas, pp. W1–W269. Hasiotis, S.T. (2002). Continental Trace Fossils, Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, Short Course Notes 51, SEPM, Tulsa, Oklahoma, 132 pp.
xv
Lockley, M. and Hunt, A.P. (1995). Dinosaur Tracks, and other Fossil Footprints of the Western United States, Columbia University Press, New York, 338 pp. Maples, C.G. and West, R.R. (Eds.) (1992). Trace Fossils, Paleontological Society, Short Course 5, 238 pp. McCall, P.L. and Tevesz, M.J.S. (Eds.) (1982). Animal–Sediment Relations: The Biogenic Alteration of Sediments, Plenum, New York, 336 pp. McIlroy, D. (Ed.) (2004). The Application of Ichnology to Palaeoenvironmental and Stratigraphic Analysis, Geological Society of London, Special Publication 228, 490 pp. Miller III, W. (Ed.) (2003). New Interpretations of Complex Trace Fossils. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology (Special Issue), 192, 343 pp. Miller, M.F., Ekdale, A.A. and Picard, M.D. (Ed.) (1984). Trace Fossils and Paleoenvironments: Marine Carbonate, Marginal Marine Terrigenous and Continental Terrigenous Settings. Journal of Paleontology, 58, 283–597. Osgood Jr., R.G. (1970). Trace fossils of the Cincinnati area. Paleontographica Americana, 6, 281–444. Osgood Jr., R.G. (1975). The history of invertebrate ichnology. In: Frey, R.W. (Ed.), The Study of Trace Fossils, Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 3–12. Pemberton, S.G., Spila, M., Pulham, A.J., Saunders, T., MacEachern, J.A., Robbins, D. and Sinclair, I.K. (2001). Ichnology and Sedimentology of Shallow to Marginal Marine Systems: Ben Nevis and Avalon Reservoirs, Jeanne d’Arc Basin, Geological Association of Canada, Short Course Notes 15, 343 pp. ¨ ber die Seilacher, A. (1953). Studien zur Palichnologie. I, U Methoden der Palichnologie. Neues Jahrbuch fu¨r Geologie und Pala¨ontologie Abhandlungen, 96, 421–452. Seilacher, A. (1962). Paleontological studies on turbidite sedimentation and erosion. Journal of Geology, 70, 227–234. Seilacher, A. (1964). Biogenic sedimentary structures. In: Imbrie, J. and Newell, N.D. (Eds.), Approaches to Paleoecology, Wiley, New York, pp. 296–316. Seilacher, A. (1967a). Bathymetry of trace fossils. Marine Geology, 5, 413–428. Seilacher, A. (1967b). Fossil behavior. Scientific American, 217, 72–80. Webby, B.D., Ma´ngano, M.G. and Buatois, L.A. (Eds.) (2004). Trace Fossils in Evolutionary Palaeoecology: Proceedings of Session 18 (Trace Fossils) of the First International Palaeontological Congress, Sydney, Australia, July 2002. Fossils and Strata, 51, 153 pp.
List of Reviewers
Ken Aalto Kerrie Bann Dave Bottjer Jane Brockman Richard Bromley* Luis Buatois David Burnham Gerhard Cade´e Bill Chaisson Paul Copper Al Curran* Rick Devlin Mary Droser Tony Ekdale* Christian Gaillard Marcos Gektidis Elizabeth Gierlowski-Kordesch Murray Gingras* Susan Goldstein Steve Hasiotis John Huntley* So¨ren Jensen Alan Kohn Michal Kowalewski Heinz Kozur Lisa Levin James MacEachern
Rob MacNaughton Gabriela Ma´ngano Tony Martin Ken McKinney Bob Metz Molly Miller* Liz Nesbitt Davide Olivero Paddy Orr Tim Palmer Lisa Park Bill Phelps Ron Pickerill* Andy Rindsberg Francisco Rodriguez-Tovar Ray Rogers Steve Rowland Chuck Savrda Ju¨rgen Schneider Leif Tapanila John Taylor Alfred Uchman Sally Walker* Andreas Wetzel* Paul Wignall Mark Wilson
*Reviewed more than one chapter.
xvii
Contributors
Kerrie L. Bann (52, 110) Ichnofacies Analysis, Inc., 9 Sienna Hills Court SW, Calgary, Alberta T3H 2W3, Canada Markus Bertling (81) Geological and Palaeontological Institute, University of Mu¨nster, Corrensstra. 24, D-48149 Mu¨nster, Germany Arnaud Botquelen (516) UFR Sciences & Techniques, Pale´ontologie, University of Brest, C.S. 93837, F-29238 Brest, France Bernard P. Boudreau (441) Department of Oceanography, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia B3H 4J1, Canada Richard G. Bromley (516, 560) Geological Institute, University of Copenhagen, Oester Voldgade 10, DK-1350 Copenhagen K, Denmark Luis Alberto Buatois (284, 390) Department of Geological Sciences, University of Saskatchewan, 114 Science Place, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan S7N 5E2, Canada Gerhard C. Cade´e (3, 158) Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research, P.O. Box 59, 1790 AB Den Burg, Texel, The Netherlands H. Allen Curran (231) Department of Geology, Smith College, Northampton, Massachusetts 01063, U.S.A. Lynn T. Dafoe (110) Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2E3, Canada Timothy M. Demko (171) Department of Geological Sciences, University of Minnesota—Duluth, 229 Heller Hall, 1114 Kirby Drive, Duluth, Minnesota 55812, U.S.A. Kelly M. Dorgan (441) School of Maine Sciences, University of Maine, Orono, Maine 04469, U.S.A. A.A. Ekdale (344, 560) Department of Geology and Geophysics, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah 84112-0111, U.S.A.
Michael J. Everhart (195) Sternberg Museum of Natural History, Fort Hays State University, Hays, Kansas 67601, U.S.A. Christian Gaillard (465) UMR 5125 CNRSPale´oenvironnements et Pale´obiosphe`re, UFR Sciences de la Terre, Universite´ Claude Bernard Lyon 1, 69622 Villeurbanne cedex, France Marcos Gektidis (367) GeologischPala¨ontologisches Institut, Johann Wolfgang GoetheUniversita¨t Frankfurt, Senckenberganlage 32-34, 60325 Frankfurt, Germany Murray K. Gingras (14, 32, 52, 110) Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2E3, Canada Ingrid Glaub (367, 516) GeologischPala¨ontologisches Institut, Johann Wolfgang GoetheUniversita¨t Frankfurt, Senckenberganlage 32-34, 60325 Frankfurt, Germany Roland Goldring (3, 158) Deceased Stjepko Golubic (367) Biological Science Center, Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts 02215, U.S.A. Stephen T. Hasiotis (171, 195, 267, 543, 573) Department of Geology, University of Kansas, 1475 Jayhawk Blvd., Lawrence, Kansas 66045-7613, U.S.A. Daniel I. Hembree (195) Department of Geological Sciences, 316 Clippinger Laboratories, Ohio University, Athens, Ohio 45701, U.S.A. Bruce D. Johnson (441) Department of Oceanography, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia B3H 4J1, Canada Peter A. Jumars (441) School of Marine Sciences & Darling Marine Center, University of Maine, 193 Clark’s Cove Road, Walpole, Maine 04573, U.S.A. Dirk Knaust (501) Statoil ASA, N-4035 Stavanger, Norway
xix
xx
CONTRIBUTORS
Nobuhiro Kotake (491) Department of Earth Sciences, Faculty of Science, Chiba University, Yayoi-cho, Inage-ku, Chiba 263-8522, Japan Karen A. Koy (427) Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Illinois—Chicago, 845 West Taylor Street, Chicago, Illinois 60607, U.S.A. Mary J. Kraus (171) Department of Geological Sciences, University of Colorado, Campus Box 399, 2200 Colorado Ave., Boulder, Colorado 80309, U.S.A. David B. Loope (560) Department of Geosciences, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, Nebraska 68588-0340, U.S.A. Ludvig Lo¨wemark (412) Department of Geosciences, National Taiwan University, P.O. Box 13-318, Taipei 106, Taiwan James A. MacEachern (14, 32, 52, 110) Department of Earth Sciences, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, British Columbia V5A 1S6, Canada Robert B. MacNaughton (134) Geological Survey of Canada, Natural Resources Canada, 3303 33rd Street NW, Calgary, Alberta T2L 2A7, Canada Marı´a Gabriela Ma´ngano (284, 390) Department of Geological Sciences, University of Saskatchewan, 114 Science Place, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan S7N 5E2, Canada Anthony J. Martin (477) Department of Environmental Studies, Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia 30322, U.S.A. Lawrence M. Mayer (441) School of Marine Sciences, Darling Marine Center, University of Maine, Walpole, ME 04573, U.S.A. Molly F. Miller (529) Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, 2301 Vanderbilt Place, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee 37235, U.S.A. William Miller, III (xiii, 457) Department of Geology, Humboldt State University, 1 Harpst Street, Arcata, California 95521, U.S.A. Jared R. Morrow (573) Department of Geological Sciences, 5500 Campanile Dr., 237 GMCS, San Diego State University, San Diego, CA 92182-1020, U.S.A. Davide Olivero (218, 465) UMR 5125 CNRSPale´oenvironnements et Pale´obiosphe`re, UFR Sciences de la Terre, Universite´ Claude Bernard Lyon 1, 69622 Villeurbanne cedex, France
S. George Pemberton (14, 32, 52, 110) Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2E3, Canada Brian F. Platt (195) Department of Geology, University of Kansas, 1475 Jayhawk Blvd., Lawrence, Kansas 66045-7613, U.S.A. Roy E. Plotnick (427) Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Illinois—Chicago, 845 West Taylor Street, Chicago, Illinois 60607, U.S.A. John E. Pollard (xxi, 158) School of Earth, Atmospheric and Environmental Sciences, University of Manchester, Manchester M13 9PL, United Kingdom Gudrun Radtke (367) Hessisches Landesamt fu¨r Umwelt und Geologie, Rheingaustr. 186, 65203 Wiesbaden, Germany Andrew K. Rindsberg (477) Geological Survey of Alabama, P.O. Box 869999, Tuscaloosa, Alabama 35486-6999, U.S.A. Charles E. Savrda (92, 148) Department of Geology and Geography, Auburn University, Auburn, Alabama 36849-5305, U.S.A. Russell S. Shapiro (381) Department of Geological and Environmental Sciences, California State University, Chico, California 95929, U.S.A. Leif Tapanila (344) Department of Geosciences, Idaho State University, Pocatello, Idaho 83209-8072, U.S.A. Alfred Uchman (247) Institute of Geological Sciences, Jagiellonian University, Oleandry 2a, 30-063 Krako´w, Poland Klaus Vogel (367) Geologisch-Pala¨ontologisches Institut, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universita¨t Frankfurt, Senckenberganlage 32-34, 60325 Frankfurt, Germany Sally E. Walker (323) Department of Geology, University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia 30602, U.S.A. Dixie L. West (543) Natural History Museum and Biodiversity Research Center, University of Kansas, Dyche Hall, Lawrence, Kansas 66045, U.S.A. David S. White (529) Hancock Biological Station, Murray State University, 561 Emma Dr., Murray, Kentucky 42071, U.S.A. Mark A. Wilson (355) Department of Geology, The College of Wooster, Wooster, Ohio 44691-2363, U.S.A. Max Wisshak (516) Institute of Palaeontology, University of Erlangen, Loewenichstr. 28, D-91054 Erlangen, Germany
Memorial to Roland Goldring (1928–2005) John E. Pollard School of Earth, Atmospheric and Environmental Sciences, University of Manchester, Manchester M13 9PL, UK
early issues of Palaeontology (Goldring, 1958; Amos et al., 1960). In 1956, Roland moved to become an assistant lecturer at St Andrew’s University, Scotland; then in 1959 he was appointed to a lectureship at Reading University. From here Roland published his first article on ichnology, ‘Trace Fossils of the Baggy Beds of North Devon’ (Goldring, 1962) which became a classic study as it combined the use of trace fossils with sedimentology of shallow marine sandstones– fields he continued to research for the next four decades. In 1962, the new sedimentology laboratories were opened at Reading as Postgraduate Research Institute for Sedimentology (P.R.I.S) and Roland invited Dolf Seilacher to present his scheme of ichnofacies as an inaugural address. This address and Seilacher’s subsequent lecture to the Palaeontological Association at the Geological Society on behaviour of trilobites deduced from trace fossils opened the eyes of several younger palaeontologists and sedimentologists to the potential of trace fossils. During the 1960s Roland continued to research and publish on trace fossils and shallow marine sandstones, visiting Australia to examine the Ediacara Series (Goldring and Curnow, 1967) and preparing his Geological Society Memoir on sedimentology of the Baggy Beds (Goldring, 1971). Ichnology articles varied from reviews on deltaic and shallow marine deposits (Goldring, 1964), to limulid undertracks (Goldring and Seilacher, 1971) and burrowing of Micraster in the Chalk (Goldring and Stevenson, 1970) in the landmark volume Trace Fossils (Crimes and Harper, 1970). In 1969, Roland visited the U.S.S.R. for six weeks on behalf of the Royal Society to meet Professor R.F. Hecker and report on the state of palaeontology and sedimentology in the U.S.S.R. He was one of the
Roland Goldring (Figs. 1 and 2), the senior British ichnologist, died on August 30, 2005 from a heart attack while cycling to the University of Reading. In appreciation of his many contributions to ichnology, sedimentology and palaeontology, particularly fossil–sediment relationships over five decades, this book is dedicated to his memory. The selected publications cited and listed below reflect the breadth and development of Roland’s interests in his long academic career. Although born in London on June 28, 1928, Roland grew up in the coastal town of Westward Ho! in North Devon before returning to London for secondary education at Royal Commercial Travellers’ Schools at Pinner, Middlesex. After school and National Service in the army (1946–1948), Roland proceeded to Bristol University, graduating with an Honours B.Sc. in Geology in 1952. He then studied for a Ph.D. in Bristol (1952–1955) on palaeontology and stratigraphy of Devonian and Carboniferous rocks of the North Devon coast under the supervision of Professor Scott Simpson, who had studied the type section of the Devonian of the Eifel region before the Second World War under Professor Rudolf Richter. In 1955–1956, Roland held a post-doctoral research associateship jointly between universities of Bristol and Frankfurt am Main. As a rare British researcher in Germany at that time he met many of the leaders of the research schools at Frankfurt and Wilhelmshaven, such as Rudolf Richter, Walter Ha¨ntzschel, Wilhelm Scha¨fer, and younger researchers Dolf Seilacher and Hans-Eric Reineck, becoming familiar with the new concepts of sedimentology, aktuogeology and aktuopalaeontology. Much of Roland’s early palaeontological work on Upper Devonian and Lower Carboniferous trilobites and brachiopods was published in German journals (Goldring, 1955, 1957a,b) and later in the
xxi
xxii
MEMORIAL TO ROLAND GOLDRING (1928-2005)
FIGURE 1 Roland preparing for fieldwork in Saudi Arabia in 2003.
first British geologists to visit Russia in that part of the cold war period. Roland Goldring’s research fields broadened in the 1970s as although he continued some work on Devonian rocks and trace fossils including those in Poland (Goldring and Kazmierczak, 1974) and Germany (Goldring and Langenstrassen, 1979), he moved into the study of Tertiary estuarine sedimentation and ichnofaunas in southern England with his students at P.R.I.S. (Goldring et al., 1978;
Goldring and Alghamadi, 1999). During this decade he received the Lyell Fund of the Geological Society (1970), served as editor of Palaeontology (1966–1975) and Vice-President of the Palaeontological Association (1973–1975). His breadth of interest and experience continued in the 1980s including ichnology of the flysch (Crimes et al., 1981) and event beds (Goldring and Aigner, 1982; Frey and Goldring, 1992), but later focused on preparation of his text book Fossils in the Field (1991). This book presented
SELECTED PUBLICATIONS CITED ABOVE
FIGURE 2
xxiii
Roland (right) on winter fieldwork in the UK in 1999.
his unique perspectives on palaeontology and fossil–sediment relationships, particularly in field analysis and was successful enough to need a second edition less than a decade later (1999a). By the late 1980s, Roland’s reputation as an ichnologist and sedimentologist led to him becoming involved in the analysis of trace fossils and bioturbation in the wealth of hydrocarbon cores obtained from North Sea oilfields and preparation of an atlas of ichnofabrics of the Fulmar Formation for a major oil company (Goldring and Pollard, 1988). This fed his enthusiasm for ichnofabric analysis and development of such new techniques as the ‘ichnofabric constituent diagram’ (I.C.D.) (Taylor and Goldring, 1993) and a series of articles and presentations at symposia (Goldring et al., 1991; Pollard et al., 1993). Roland organised several trace fossil symposia (Palaeontological Association, Reading, 1980; International Palaeoecological Congress, Lyons, 1983; Lyell Meeting, London, 1992) and he attended most of the International Ichnofabric Workshops between 1991 and 2003. Despite his retirement from his academic post as Reader in Geology at University of Reading in 1993, Roland remained extremely enthusiastic and active in ichnology research, both in Mesozoic and Tertiary rocks in England (Goldring and Pollard, 1995;
Goldring, 1996, 1999b; Goldring et al., 1998, 2005a) and abroad with visits to Mongolia (Goldring and Jensen, 1996), China (Bin et al., 1998) and Malta (Goldring et al., 2003). He also developed and applied his teaching skills and the uses of ichnofabric analysis (Goldring, 1995; Taylor et al., 2003), particularly assisting in short courses taught to the oil industry in the UK, France, Norway and even Saudi Arabia (Goldring et al., 2005b). Roland’s unabated enthusiasm, wide interests and meticulous research are shown not only by his coauthorship of two chapters in this volume, but also that at the point of his untimely death he had eight articles in press or in revision in which he was either lead author or co-author. We remember, therefore, with some sadness but much gratitude, our friend and quiet colleague who has left us a lasting legacy of a life’s work of over eighty papers in fields of ichnology, sedimentology, taphonomy and fossil–sediment relationships.
SELECTED PUBLICATIONS CITED ABOVE Amos, A.J., Camphell, J.S.W. and Goldring, R. (1960). Australosutura gen. nov. (Trilobita) from the Carboniferous of Australia and Argentina. Palaeontology, 3, 227–236.
xxiv
MEMORIAL TO ROLAND GOLDRING (1928-2005)
Bin, Hu, Wang, G. and Goldring, R. (1998). Nereites (or Neonereites) from Lower Jurassic lacustrine turbidites of Henan, central China. Ichnos, 6, 203–209. Crimes, T.P. and Haper, J.C. (Eds.) (1970). Trace Fossils, Seel House Press, Liverpool, 547 pp. Crimes, T.P., Goldring, R., Homewood, P., van Stuijvenberg, J. and Winkler, W. (1981). Trace fossil assemblages of deep-sea fan deposits, Gurnigel and Schlieren flysch (Cretaceous–Eocene), Switzerland. Eclogae Geologica Helvetica, 74, 953–995. Frey, R.W. and Goldring, R. (1992). Marine event beds and recolonization surfaces as revealed by trace fossil analysis. Geological Magazine, 129, 325–335. Goldring, R. (1955). The Upper Devonian and Lower Carboniferous Trilobites of the Pilton Beds in North Devon, with an appendix on Goniatites of the Pilton Beds. Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 36, 27–48. Goldring, R. (1957a). The last toothed Productellinae in Europe. Pala¨ontologisches Zeitschrift, 31, 207–228. Goldring, R. (1957b). Pseudophillipsia (Tril.) from the Permian (or Uralian) of Oman, Arabia. Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 38, 195–210. Goldring, R. (1958). Lower Tournaisian trilobites in the Carboniferous Limestone facies of the south-west province of Great Britain and of Belgium. Palaeontology, 1, 231–244. Goldring, R. (1962). The trace fossils of the Baggy Beds (Upper Devonian) of North Devon, England. Pala¨ontologisches Zeitschrift, 36, 232–251. Goldring, R. (1964). Trace-fossils and the sedimentary surface in shallow-water marine sediments. In: van Straaten, L.M.J.U. (Ed.), Deltaic and Shallow Marine Deposits: Developments in Sedimentology 1, Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 136–143. Goldring, R. (1971). Shallow-water sedimentation as illustrated in the Upper Devonian Baggy Beds. Memoir of the Geological Society of London, 5, 1–88, 12 plates. Goldring, R. (1991). Fossils in the Field: Information Potential and Analysis, Longman, Harlow, 218 pp. Goldring, R. (1995). Organisms and the substrate: response and effect. In: Bosence, D.W.J. and Allison, P.A. (Eds.), Marine Palaeoenvironmental Analysis from Fossils, Geological Society, Special Publication, 83, pp. 151–180. Goldring, R. (1996). The sedimentological significance of concentrically laminated burrows from Lower Cretaceous Ca-bentonites, Oxfordshire. Journal of the Geological Society, London, 153, 255–263. Goldring, R. (1999a). Field Palaeontology, 2nd edition. Longman, Harlow and John wiley, New York, 191 pp. Goldring, R. (1999b). Sedimentological aspects and preservation of Lower Cretaceous (Aptian) bentonites (fuller’s earth) in southern England. Neues Jahrbuch fu¨r Geologie und Pala¨ontologie Abhandlungen, 214, 3–24. Goldring, R. and Aigner, T. (1982). Scour and fill: the significance of event separation. In: Einsele, G. and Seilacher, A. (Eds.), Cyclic and Event Stratification, Springer, pp. 354–382. Goldring, R. and Alghamadi, J.A. (1999). The stratigraphy and sedimentology of the Reading Formation (Palaeocene to Eocene) at Knowl Hill, near Reading (southern England). Tertiary Research, 19, 107–116.
Goldring, R. and Curnow, C.N. (1967). The stratigraphy and facies of the late Precambrian at Ediacara, South Australia. Journal of the Geological Society of Australia, 14, 195–214. Goldring, R. and Jensen, S. (1996). Trace fossils and biofabrics at the Precambrian–Cambrian boundary interval in Western Mongolia. Geological Magazine, 133, 403–415. Goldring, R. and Kazmierczak, J. (1974). Ecological succession in intraformational hardground formation. Palaeontology, 17, 949–962. Goldring, R. and Langenstrassen, F. (1979). Open shelf and nearshore clastic facies in the Devonian. Special Papers in Palaeontology, 23, 81–97. Goldring, R. and Pollard, J.E. (1988). Atlas of Trace Fossils and Ichnofabric Analysis of the Fulmar Formation in the Central North Sea, 2 volumes, 54 plates. (For Shell UK Exploration and Production, London). Goldring, R. and Pollard, J.E. (1995). A re-evaluation of Ophiomorpha burrows in the Wealden Group (Lower Cretaceous) of southern England. Cretaceous Research, 16, 665–680. Goldring, R. and Seilacher, A. (1971). Limulid undertracks and their sedimentological implications. Neues Jahrbuch fu¨r Geologie und Pala¨ontologie, Abhandlungen, 37, 422–442. Goldring, R. and Stevenson, D.G. (1970). Did Micraster burrow? In: Crimes, T.P. and Harper, J.C. (Eds.), Trace Fossils, Seel House Press, Liverpool, pp. 179–184. Goldring, R., Bosence, D.W.J. and Blake, T. (1978). Estuarine sedimentation in the Eocene of southern England. Sedimentology, 25, 861–876. Goldring, R., Pollard, J.E. and Taylor, A.M. (1991). Anconichnus horizontalis: a pervasive ichnofabric-forming trace fossil in postPaleozoic offshore siliciclastic facies. Palaios, 6, 250–263. Goldring, R., Astin, T.R., Marshall, J.A.E., Gabbott, S. and Jenkins, C.D. (1998). Towards an integrated study of the depositional environment in the Bencliff Grit (U. Jurassic) of Dorset. In: Underhill, J.R. (Ed.), Development and Evolution of the Wessex Basin, Geological Society, Special Publication, 133, pp. 355–372. Goldring, R., Gruszczynski, M. and Gatt, P.A. (2003). A bow-form burrow and its sedimentological and paleoecological significance. Palaios, 17, 622–630. Goldring, R., Pollard, J.E. and Radley, J.D. (2005a). Trace fossils and pseudofossils from the Wealden strata (nonmarine Lower Cretaceous) of southern England. Cretaceous Research, 26, 665–685. Goldring, R., Taylor, A.M. and Hughes, G.W. (2005b). The application of ichnofabrics towards bridging the dichotomy between siliciclastic and carbonate shelf facies: examples from the Upper Jurassic Fulmar Formation (U.K.) and Jubaila Formation (Saudi Arabia). Proceedings Geologists’ Associationd, 116, 235–249. Pollard, J.E., Goldring, R. and Buck, S.G. (1993). Ichnofabrics containing Ophiomorpha: significance in shallow-water facies interpretation. Journal of the Geological Society, London, 150, 149–164. Taylor, A.M. and Goldring, R. (1993). Description and analysis of bioturbation and ichnofabric. Journal of the Geological Society, London, 150, 141–148. Taylor, A.M., Goldring, R. and Gowland, S.G. (2003). Analysis and application of ichnofabrics. Earth-Science Reviews, 60, 227–259.
S E C T I O N I
THE HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF ICHNOLOGY
1
2
C
H
A
P
T
E
R
1 The Wadden Sea, Cradle of Invertebrate Ichnology Gerhard C. Cade´e and Roland Goldring
(in 1928) of the first marine institute devoted entirely to the study of recent sedimentary environments: Senckenberg am Meer in Wilhelmshaven, Germany.
SUMMARY : Invertebrate ichnology developed separately from vertebrate ichnology; many invertebrate traces were first interpreted as fossil algae. Recent traces have helped to discover their real nature. The study of recent traces of invertebrates in the Wadden Sea played an important role in the development of ichnology. In 1928, Rudolf Richter (1881–1957) founded the first marine institute devoted entirely to Aktuogeologie and Aktuopala¨ontologie in Wilhelmshaven, and the school of researchers inspired by him was crucial. Their work became widely known and influential when research articles and reviews of their work in the Wadden Sea began to be published in the English language. Ha¨ntzschel’s contribution on ‘Trace Fossils and Problematica’ to the Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology and Seilacher’s important contributions to the classification of trace fossils and the use of trace fossil assemblages to estimate the depth of deposition crown the work started by Richter in the Wadden Sea.
THE EARLY BEGINNINGS OF ICHNOLOGY The study of invertebrate ichnology developed separately from that of vertebrate ichnology. Vertebrate (paleo)ichnology is the older of the two: bird-like dinosaur tracks were discovered in 1802 in the Connecticut Valley (USA) and the first published record of fossil tracks of quadrupedal reptiles discovered in Dumfriesshire, Scotland in 1814 dates from 1828 (e.g., Buckland, 1828). The earliest history of ichnology characteristically deals practically only with vertebrate traces (Winkler, 1886). In his excellent history, Osgood (1975) gives the reasons for the slow development of invertebrate ichnology: most trace fossils were originally interpreted as fossil brown algae, fucoids, during what he named the ‘Age of Fucoids’ (1828–1881) and therefore omitted by Winkler (1886). When it became clear that most fossil ‘fucoids’ were caused either by sedimentary processes or by burrowing and crawling organisms, the popularity of their study considerably decreased. The ‘Age of Fucoids’ culminated in voluminous monographs such as of Heer (1877) in which numerous Flysch Lebensspuren were described in great detail as plants. It ended in the 1880s when the paleobotanist Nathorst (1881, 1886) proved
INTRODUCTION Ichnology, the study of fossil and recent traces made by organisms, has a history of about 200 years. In understanding the nature and producers of traces, the study of recent organisms has been very important. Shallow, easily accessible intertidal areas have proved to be the best area to start such studies. In this chapter we will underline the important role, research in the Wadden Sea has played in the past and in particular the role of Rudolf Richter the founder
Copyright ß 2007, Elsevier B.V. Trace Fossils: Concepts, Problems, Prospects
3
All rights reserved.
4
1. THE WADDEN SEA, CRADLE OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY
experimentally that many fucoids of earlier authors were in fact traces of invertebrate organisms. Nathorst (1881), Winkler (1886), Osgood (1975) and Ha¨ntzschel (1962, 2nd edition 1975) cite a few paleontologists who rightly described traces as invertebrate trails. Hitchcock (1858) used the first real ichnogenus name ending in -ichnus (e.g., Cochlichnus) for an invertebrate meander trail; Dawson (1862) studied trails by modern Limulus (the horseshoe crab) comparing it with fossil traces Protichnites, and Dawson (1864) interpreted Rusophycus as resting traces of trilobites (see for Dawson also Pemberton et al., this volume). Nicholson (1873: pp. 288–289) regarded Skolithos as dwelling burrows. Indeed, those working on Paleozoic rocks in North America and Great Britain mostly attributed traces to animal activity. In Great Britain, Salter’s work was influential for the British Geological Survey (a.o. Salter, 1857). However, invertebrate ichnology as a science was in our opinion born in 1880 in Kristineberg (Sweden), where Nathorst (1881) experimented with live invertebrates to understand fossil traces. A few years earlier he had already published how worms were able to form branching traces suggesting a ‘fucoid’ nature (Nathorst, 1873).
THE ROLE OF EXPERIMENTS Buckland was the first experimenter in ichnology (1837: footnote p. 261). He compared the Scottish fossil tracks of Dumfriesshire (Buckland, 1828) ‘with the tracks which I caused to be made on soft mud, and clay, and upon unbaked pie-crust, by a living Emys and Testudo Graeca’ (respectively a marsh and a land tortoise). From his experiments, he concluded that the fossil track was made by a land tortoise. Nathorst (1881) was probably unaware of Buckland’s work, so this indicates that the still existing divide between vertebrate and invertebrate ichnology was already present. Nathorst’s (1881) first idea was to let animals crawl over wet plaster in order to get preservable traces. This worked with some (terrestrial) worms and raindrop impressions. However, a mixture of plaster with salt water did not harden and few of the marine animals he wanted to work with liked to perform in a mixture of plaster of Paris and freshwater. He used Kristineberg’s Zoological Station (founded only a few years earlier in 1877) for his experiments. Here, he collected marine mud from several depths and was surprised to observe that a number of traces were produced within a few hours. Finally he succeeded in
casting the traces in plaster, including those made by crustaceans (Carcinus maenas, Crangon vulgaris, Idotea baltica, Corophium, Gammarus), polychaetes (Glycera, Terebella), and an amphiurid with its symbiotic bivalve Mysella bidentata. His well-illustrated study in Swedish (with an extended summary in French) clearly indicates why fossil traces had hitherto been identified as ‘fucoids’. He shows, for example, traces produced by crustaceans Idotea baltica (Nathorst, 1881, plate III), where two animal traces meet each other, where-after both animals used the same path: such traces resemble a bifurcating fucoid. Nathorst also recognised that one organism may produce more than one type of trace. Osgood (1975) identifies the years between 1881 and 1920 as the ‘Period of Controversy’ and describes the heated debate pro and contra Nathorst’s ideas. Only in 1886 did Nathorst take part in the discussion. ‘Fucoids’ were disproved, but there was no surge in interest. It was in continental Europe, especially through Mesozoic and Cenozoic workers, that the fucoid controversy raged (a.o. Saporta, 1884). In any case there was a steady publication of ichnological literature (generally with discussion as to the producers) in the early part of the twentieth century, mainly in the English-speaking world and a few in French (a.o. Fraipont, 1912). Seilacher (1975) gives two reasons for the decline in interest in Europe: first, ‘fucoids’ could no longer be used as reliable fossil guides or as indicators of shallow-water sediments deposited in the photic zone. Second, ‘fucoids’ fell into a taxonomic no-man’s land. They were either omitted from textbooks, or listed under ‘incertae sedis’ or ‘problematica’. And, the chief biostratigraphically useful groups are not actually trace fossil producers! Nathorst’s studies in Sweden did not result in a new research school for trace fossils that might have started at Kristineberg. Nathorst returned to the study of fossil plants. Only later did Rudolf Richter start the first organised study of ichnology in the Wadden Sea. Removing the cradle of ichnology from Kristineberg to the Wadden Sea proved successful.
RESEARCH IN THE WADDEN SEA Rudolf Richter (1881–1957) changed his law studies for geology in 1904 after a field excursion with the famous geologist Emanuel Kayser to the Devonian strata in the Eifel, Germany (Ziegler, 1981). In 1908, he started working at the Senckenberg Museum in Frankfurt and was soon a world authority on
RESEARCH IN THE WADDEN SEA
FIGURE 1.1
5
Map of the Wadden Sea; shaded areas are tidal flats.
trilobites, not only on their taxonomy and the role of trilobites in Devonian biostratigraphy, but also on the paleobiology of trilobites. This work was influenced by Dollo (1910), and by the traces trilobites produced, leading to his still very readable articles on ‘Bau und Leben der Trilobiten’ (Richter, 1919–1920). In Germany, Walther (1893–1894) and later Abel (1927, 1935) had promoted the study of modern environments to gain a better understanding of the mode of formation of fossil sediments. It was Richter who selected the Wadden Sea for this purpose (Fig. 1.1). The mesotidal Wadden Sea extends from the North Sea coast of The Netherlands across northern Germany into Denmark. It is bounded on the seaward side by a line of barrier islands (Frisian Islands), interrupted by the estuaries of the Ems, Weser and Elbe. Richter (1926c) recalled his first visits to the Wadden Sea in The Netherlands in 1911. In 1919, he stayed several weeks on a Wohnbake (a small fixed
observation-post on piles on the tidal flat) in the Wadden Sea near Mellum, with his wife Emma who was also a geologist and collaborator. Here, he said he learned much more than during his visits to the (non-tidal) marine institute of Naples or to the rocky shores near the Helgoland Marine Institute (Richter, 1926c; Scha¨fer, 1962b). Walking over a tidal flat surface is an ideal experience for a geologist who wants to see geology at work. In 1920, he gave a lecture at the Senckenberg Museum in Frankfurt on the importance of the study of the Wadden Sea for geology and paleontology. This was never published, but from his series of publications on ‘Flachseebeobachtungen’ (Observations in a shallow sea, Richter, 1920–1926) it is clear what kind of studies he had in mind: a better understanding of sedimentation processes and (trace) fossils by comparison of old and modern deposits (Fig. 1.2). In 1928, he succeeded in founding the first marine institute devoted entirely to actuogeology
6
1. THE WADDEN SEA, CRADLE OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY
FIGURE 1.2 (A–E) Figures from Richter (1920) to illustrate his objectives in studying Wadden Sea traces, by comparing the modern (tube worm) Sabellaria ‘reefs’ with the fossil trace Skolithos (pipe rock). (A) ‘Sand coral’ ‘reef’ at low tide, Wadden Sea. (B,C) Fragments viewed from the side and above. (D,E) Skolithos (pipe rock), Lower Devonian, Rhineland, bar = 1 cm. (F) Cluster of tubes with annelids; left, external view of two tubes; right, worms seen in three positions. (After Scha¨fer, 1962, Fig. 130.) (All with permission from Senckenbergische Naturforschende Gesellschaft, Frankfurt/Main, Germany.)
and actuopaleontology ‘Senckenberg am Meer’ in Wilhelmshaven, Germany. In 1929, Richter published the manifesto of this institute and from the beginning ichnology was to be one of its major research fields. In the 1920s with Richter, the period of the ‘Modern approach of Ichnology’ started (Osgood, 1975). The foundation of Senckenberg am Meer was also a milestone in the study of actuogeology, the science that ‘makes stones alive’ (Reineck, 1981). Richter’s Wadden Sea studies did not remain unnoticed: already in 1928 a long English review of his publications in German on Scolithus was prepared by Bucher (1928) and this has certainly influenced early ichnologists such as the Fentons in the USA, as it was published in the American Midland Naturalist of which naturalist/paleontologist Caroll Lane Fenton was associate editor from 1923 to 1960 and where the Fentons published a number of their articles on fossil and recent traces starting with Fenton and Fenton (1931). Pemberton and MacEachern (1994) give a complete list of their later ichnological articles.
When Richter became director of Senckenberg Museum in Frankfurt in 1934, he appointed Walter Ha¨ntzschel as his successor as Director at Wilhelmshaven. While in Frankfurt, Richter played an important role to keep Nazi influence in Senckenberg at bay (Ziegler, 1992). He also retained his interest in traces (e.g., Richter, 1942) and remained an influence on the development of ‘his’ Senckenberg am Meer. Ha¨ntzschel (1904–1972) started his geological research on Cretaceous sediments in Germany, and became increasingly interested in fossil traces (see Ha¨ntzschel, 1924, 1931, 1934). From 1934 to 1938, Ha¨ntzschel spent probably the happiest time of his life exploring the Wadden Sea tidal flats. This resulted in a new series of articles now on modern traces, among which star-like traces drew his interest (Ha¨ntzschel, 1935, 1939a, 1940). His work in the Wadden Sea, although published in German, was nevertheless not unknown in North America. It was again Bucher (1938) who after his visit to Wilhelmshaven and the tidal flats of the Wadden Sea in 1937, reviewed in English the many articles
RESEARCH IN THE WADDEN SEA
published in German by scientists from the institute. Rindsberg (pers. comm., 2005) mentioned the influence Bucher’s review had on a.o. the Fentons. Trask invited Ha¨ntzschel to contribute to his benchmark book Recent Marine Sediments published in 1939. His contribution was translated from the German by Marie Siegrist and Trask himself (Ha¨ntzschel, 1939b). This study mainly deals with the tidal sediments themselves rather than with the traces, although the presence of fecal pellets and the role of filter feeders in depositing mud are mentioned (Ha¨ntzschel, 1939b, reprinted in 1955 and 1968). In 1938, Ha¨ntzschel was appointed as curator at the Dresden Museum, providing the opportunity to resume his study of Cretaceous outcrops. The Second World War destroyed his hopes for a better life for himself and his family. He was drafted in 1942 and returned later after three years in a Russian prison camp to find Dresden and its museum destroyed. Not until 1949 was he able to secure a new position at the Geological Institute of Hamburg University as a librarian, where he remained until his retirement in 1969. In Hamburg, he returned to his beloved trace fossils and in an important article from this period he was able to relate the fossil lebensspur Ophiomorpha to callianassid crustaceans (Ha¨ntzschel, 1952). In Hamburg, he also became the foremost expert on trace fossil literature. This led to his greatest contribution to ichnology, the trace fossil part of the Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology (1962, 2nd edition 1975). The invitation to take part in the First International Salt Marsh Conference in March 1958 at Sapelo Island, and his visit later to several of the leading marine institutes in the USA marked his growing international fame. It also marked the growing interest in the work done in the Wadden Sea. Among the few European scientists invited were three who worked in this area: in addition to Walter Ha¨ntzschel, Wilhelm Scha¨fer and the Dutch sedimentologist L.M.J.U van Straaten (Ragotzkie et al., 1959). Hertweck (1972), Lehmann (1972) and Seilacher (1975) provide a more detailed picture of this great successor of Richter. In 1938, Wilhelm Scha¨fer (1912–1981) followed Ha¨ntzschel as Director at the age of only 26. This proved to be another excellent choice by Richter. By training, Scha¨fer was a marine biologist but he soon became interested in actuopaleontology as can be judged from his publications in the first years at Senckenberg am Meer (see Flemming and Gutmann, 1992), and his review book (Scha¨fer, 1962a, translated in English in 1972). During the war Scha¨fer was in military service, Senckenberg am Meer was severely damaged and finally closed, the
7
library was destroyed by the occupation after the war. Scha¨fer returned to Wilhelmshaven in 1947 and started with the help of K. Lu¨ders to rebuild and re-open the marine institute and research regained impetus. In his article on the influence of some 30 benthic organisms on layered sediments (Scha¨fer, 1956), we can see the influence of Hans-Erich Reineck (inventor of the box-core to take undisturbed sediment samples), who started working as an actuogeologist at Wilhelmshaven in 1954. The illustrations in this article demonstrate the great capacities of Scha¨fer as an artist. In 1961, Scha¨fer moved to Frankfurt and H.-E Reineck took over as Director. At Frankfurt Scha¨fer completed his magnum opus. This monumental encyclopedia ‘Aktuopala¨ontologie nach Studien in der Nordsee’ published in 1962 gives an excellent overview of the work done not only in Wilhelmshaven but also by others such as Linke and Wohlenberg in the Wadden Sea and the nearby North Sea. Linke’s (1939) work in part of the Wadden Sea (the Jade Busen) is rarely mentioned in the ichnological literature, but Linke gives inter alia an excellent overview of burrows and traces of the Wadden Sea fauna. The English translation of Scha¨fer’s book is now well known: ‘Ecology and Palaeoecology of Marine Environments’ (1972). H.-E Reineck (1918–1999) joined the institute as a geologist in 1954, and was its Director from 1961 until 1984 (Flemming, 1999). Mainly because of his studies of the Wadden Sea tidal sediments Reineck became a sedimentologist and wrote a textbook (in English, with Singh, 1973, later editions in 1980 and 1986) on modern sediments. He often stressed: ‘Nowhere is the seabottom so easy to study as on a tidal flat’ (e.g., Reineck, 1957). He became well known, due to his inventions of new methods to take undisturbed sediment samples with the box-corer (in German, ‘Kastengreifer’), and artificially hardened soft sediment samples in order to study them in cross sections and thin slides, just like ancient sedimentary rocks (Reineck, 1957, 1963b,c, 1967a, 1970b), thus building on earlier inventions by Senckenberg am Meer scientists such as Schwarz (1929) and Ha¨ntzschel (1936). He was one of the few European scientists invited to take part in the Conference on Estuaries held in 1964 at Jekyll Island, Georgia, USA. The publication of the proceedings of this conference (Lauff, 1967; Reineck, 1967b) became a landmark in estuarine research, which has since made many of its contributors well cited. Also, Reineck published many articles on recent traces (e.g., Reineck, 1958, 1968; Reineck et al., 1967, 1968). With his Kastengreifer he was not
8
1. THE WADDEN SEA, CRADLE OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY
restricted to the Wadden Sea but could also use it in deeper waters, which gave rise to well-illustrated articles such as Reineck (1963a) and Reineck et al. (1967, 1968). The art of making ‘Reliefgu¨sse’ (relief casts) was further perfected to real artwork by Hertweck, who joined the institute in 1964 (e.g., Hertweck and Reineck, 1966), and ‘Kunstharz’ (polyester resin) was used to fill open burrows. Reineck retired in 1984 (Flemming, 1999) to be followed by Burghard Flemming, but remained active in research, and continued publishing on tracks and traces (e.g., Reineck and Flemming, 1997). Research by the Wilhelmshaven team resulted in numerous articles, at first mainly in German. But once the scientists started publishing in English, and went abroad to conferences such as the salt marsh conference in 1958 at Sapelo Island and the Estuaries Conference in 1964 at Jekyll Island, their work became known outside Germany. Wadden Sea work at Senckenberg am Meer concentrated more on ichnofacies zonation (Hertweck, 1970a,b, 1994; Do¨rjes and Hertweck, 1975). The export of their knowledge was also promoted by co-operative research with, for example, James ‘Jim’ Howard and Robert ‘Bob’ Frey in the Sapelo Island region (Howard et al., 1972); in Italy (e.g., Hertweck, 1973), and Taiwan (Reineck and Cheng, 1978; Do¨rjes, 1978). Such co-operation, particularly that with the group of Howard and Frey, who had developed their own research methods such as the use of X-rays in studying the production of traces (Howard, 1968; Howard and Elders, 1970), was fruitful for both groups. Ichnology left its cradle in the Wadden Sea and moved globally. The aims and history of Senckenberg am Meer are well documented, mostly in German (e.g., Richter, 1929; Ha¨ntzschel, 1956; Scha¨fer, 1967; Reineck, 1981; Flemming, 2004).
ICHNOLOGY ELSEWHERE IN THE WADDEN SEA Not all Wadden Sea ichnology studies were based at Wilhelmshaven. Wohlenberg (1937) worked from Sylt, and contributed a detailed study of traces and burrows made by the supratidal beetles. These beetles formed the main subject of an article by Larsen (1936) who worked in the Danish Wadden Sea from the Skalling Laboratory, where Thamdrup (1935) had worked on the tidal flat fauna, including pioneer studies on the burrows of these animals. Van Straaten (1920–2004), a well-known Dutch sedimentologist, worked from Groningen University
in the Dutch sector of the Wadden Sea (Veenstra, 2004). One of his interests was in tidal flat sediments and their recognition in the geological past (van Straaten, 1950, 1952, 1954a,b, 1956). He also discovered a shell-rich layer present at about 25-cm depth below many Wadden Sea tidal flats that proved to be due to the bioturbating activities of the lugworm Arenicola. This worm continuously ingests sand particles and defecates them at the surface. Shells and shell fragments are too large to be swallowed and so become concentrated at the feeding depth of lugworms. Quantitative research on annual rates and seasonal variation of bioturbation by polychaetes and birds in the Wadden Sea was mainly carried out from the Netherlands Institute for Sea Research at the western part of the Wadden Sea on the island of Texel by Cade´e (1976, 1979, 1990, 2001), though earlier estimates of the sediment reworking rates by lugworms in the Wadden Sea had been made by Linke (1939). Wattenmeer station Sylt at the northern end of the Wadden Sea became an important institute for Wadden Sea research before the second World War (Wohlenberg, 1937), and particularly after Karsten Reise became its director. Reise (1985) is already a ‘classic’ concerning tidal flat ecology.
THE PROMOTION OF ICHNOLOGY In the 1960s, ichnology research started blooming all over the world and became accepted as an important area which was attracting international symposia (e.g., Crimes and Harper, 1970). Probably no one has done more to promote ichnology than Dolf Seilacher. Though never part of the Wilhelmshaven team, being a student of Otto Schindewolf at the University in Tu¨bingen, his first research on traces was carried out on the Island of Mellum (in the Jade-Weser estuary in the Wadden Sea) in 1949 (Seilacher, 1951). There he studied the formation of tubes by the worm Lanice conchilega (Fig. 1.3). He mentions his fruitful contacts with the Wilhelmshaven group particularly with Scha¨fer. Seilacher’s early studies in the Wadden Sea (Seilacher, 1951, 1953a, 1957) formed the base for his later influential ethological classification system of traces, building on earlier classifications by Richter (1927) and Krejci-Graf (1932), but much easier to use and thus more appealing. Two articles (Seilacher, 1953b,c) are landmarks in the behavioural classification approach in ichnology. Seilacher’s publications are also legendary for
THE PROMOTION OF ICHNOLOGY
9
FIGURE 1.3 The formation of tubes by the polychaete Lanice conchilega (sand mason). (A,B) The tube is first free at the sediment surface. With the help of respiratory currents (arrows) the worm digs into the sediment. (C) In older worms the respiratory current is reversed, thereby enabling the worm to dig deeper. As the tube cannot be widened, the growing worm has to add a new tube which becomes W-shaped. The fringed, feeding crown is finally added (from Seilacher, 1951, Figs. 2 and 4). (D) Lengthening and branching of the tubes into laminated sands and muds (after Scha¨fer, 1962, Fig. 190). (All with permission from Senckenbergische Naturforschende Gesellschaft, Frankfurt/Main, Germany.)
their excellent illustrations. In this he followed his ‘teacher’ Scha¨fer! Seilacher (1957) observed that not all fossil traces had counterparts in the sediments of the Wadden Sea, and that many of the then known Wadden Sea traces had no fossil counterpart. He realised that this discrepancy was due to the fact that so many of the Wadden Sea traces studied were surface traces, often with little fossilisation potential, whereas many ancient traces could be shown to have been formed by organisms burrowing below the sediment surface. These had to be studied in a different way. He promoted the study of modern traces in vertical sections such as that which could be readily examined along eroding creeks in the Wadden Sea. Such studies were aided by the new methods of collecting
undisturbed sediment samples by methods and apparatus invented by Reineck (1957), and used by Scha¨fer (1956). Although Seilacher’s early articles were in German, they were noticed a.o. by Goldring in the UK (Goldring, 1962) and Lessertisseur in France. Lessertisseur had frequent contacts with Seilacher, and Lessertisseur’s 1955 publication, based on his 1953 thesis, gives an ecological classification of traces reviewing the German work in French also and commenting favourably on the trace assemblages approach by Seilacher (1954). His article is illustrated with a nice set of plates of invertebrate traces on tidal flats along the French Atlantic coast. Goldring visited Seilacher in Tu¨bingen in 1956 and helped to make his work better known in
10
1. THE WADDEN SEA, CRADLE OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY
the UK (Goldring et al., 2000). In the early 1960s, Seilacher started publishing in English as well. He was invited as a guest speaker at the opening of the new sedimentology laboratories in Reading, UK in 1962 in which he presented his scheme of ichnofacies (Goldring et al., 2000). In 1963, Seilacher was invited to give a speech at a meeting of the Geological Society of America in Cincinnati, followed by an invitation for consultation at Humble Petroleum. Thus, with Seilacher’s post-war UK and North American journeys, enthusiasm and his ten principles (Seilacher, 1994), this led to a major response in activity and the establishment of ichnology in the 1960s. More especially, it was his realisation that ichnology could be a major tool in the interpretation of ancient sediments, and thus highly significant to the petroleum industry. Beginning (Seilacher, 1954) with his distinction between flysch (deep water and turbiditic) and molasse (shallow marine and terrestrial) traces in Alpine sediments (Seilacher, 1955 — figure reproduced in the ‘Treatise’ 2nd edition, 1975) and at the 5th International Sedimentology Congress at Geneva, this led to the principles of ichnology and enunciation of ichnofacies (Seilacher, 1964).
CONCLUSIONS Since the early beginnings of ichnology, paleontologists (Nathorst, Abel, Richter, Ha¨ntzschel and Seilacher) have played a dominant role in the study of modern invertebrate traces, because they wanted to understand the fossil traces they found. Without the vision of Richter in the early 1920s and his founding of the Senckenberg am Meer research institute in Wilhelmshaven, the Wadden Sea would never have played the role it did in ichnology. Ichnologists have exported their knowledge gained in the Wadden Sea, certainly since they started publishing in English. Actuoichnology of invertebrates has come of age and left its cradle in the Wadden Sea long ago and is now studied at all academic levels and from (tropical) tidal areas to the deep sea. It has proved its value for the interpretation and classification of fossil traces and their (paleo)environmental significance.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We very much appreciate the interest and help of our colleagues Sally Walker (University of
Georgia, Athens), Gu¨nther Hertweck and Burghard Flemming (Wilhelmshaven) and Geert-Jan Brummer (NIOZ, Texel), we thank John Pollard particularly for his help in the finishing stage. The libraries of Naturalis (Leiden) and NIOZ (Texel) proved excellent for supplying literature. We thank referees Sally Walker and Andres K. Rindsberg for their very useful comments. Coauthor Roland Goldring has been very co-operative in writing this chapter, he has commented on the last draft before it was sent by the editor to referees. Sadly he died the 30th August 2005.
References Abel, O. (1927). Lebensbilder aus der Tierwelt der Vorzeit, 2nd edition. Gustav Fischer, Jena, 714 pp. Abel, O. (1935). Vorzeitliche Lebensspuren, Gustav Fischer, Jena, 644 pp. Buckland, W. (1828). Note sur des traces the tortues observe´es dans le gre`s rouge. Annales des Sciences Naturelles, 13, 85–86. Buckland, W. (1837). Geology and Mineralogy Considered with Reference to Natural Theology, 2nd edition. Pickering, London, 618 + 129 pp. Bucher, W.H. (1928). Observations on organisms and sedimentation on shallow sea-bottoms (review of Rud. Richter’s work). American Midland Naturalist, 11, 236–242. Bucher, W.H. (1939). Key to articles published by an institute for the study of modern sediments in shallow seas. Journal of Geology, 46, 726–755. Cade´e, G.C. (1976). Sediment reworking by Arenicola marina on tidal flats in the Dutch Wadden Sea. Netherlands Journal of Sea Research, 10, 440–460. Cade´e, G.C. (1979). Sediment reworking by the polychaete Heteromastus filiformis on a tidal flat in the Dutch Wadden Sea. Netherlands Journal of Sea Research, 13, 441–456. Cade´e, G.C. (1990). Feeding traces and bioturbation by birds on a tidal flat in the Dutch Wadden Sea. Ichnos, 1, 23–30. Cade´e, G.C. (2001). Sediment dynamics by bioturbating organisms. In: Reise, K. (Ed.), Ecological Comparisons of Sedimentary Shores, Ecological Studies 151. Springer, Berlin, pp. 127–148. Crimes, T.P. and Harper J.C. (1970). Trace Fossils. Geological Journal, Special Issue, 3, 1–597. Dawson, J.W. (1862). On the footprints of Limulus as compared with Protichnites of the Potsdam sandstone. Canadian Naturalist and Geologist, 7, 271–277. Dawson, J.W. (1864). On the fossils of the genus Rusophycus. Canadian Naturalist (New Series), 1, 363–367. Dollo, L. (1910). La pale´ontologie e´thologique. Bulletin de la Socie´te´ de Ge´ologie, Pale´ontologie et d’Hydrologie, Me´moires, 23, 378–421. Do¨rjes, J. (1978). Sedimentologische und faunistische Untersuchungen an Watten in Taiwan. II Faunistische un aktuopala¨ontologische Studien. Senckenbergiana Maritima, 10, 117–143. Do¨rjes, J. and Hertweck, G. (1975). Recent biocoenoses and ichnocoenoses in shallow-water marine environments. In: Frey, R.W. (Ed.), The Study of Trace Fossils, Springer-Verlag, New York, 459–491 pp.
REFERENCES
Fenton, C.L. and Fenton, M.A. (1931). Apparent gastropod trails in the Lower Cambrian. American Midland Naturalist, 12, 401–405. Flemming, B.W. (1999). Personalia. Hans-Erich Reineck. Natur und Museum, 129, 355–356. Flemming, B.W. (2004). 75 Jahre Senckenberg am Meer, Aktualismus als Forschungsprinzip. Natur und Museum, 134, 1–20. Flemming, B.W. and Gutmann, F.W. (1992). Armin Friedrich Wilhelm Scha¨fer 1912–1981. In: Klausewitz, W. (Ed.), 175 Jahre, Senckenbergische Naturforschende Gesellschaft, Jubila¨umsband 1, Kramer, Frankfurt am Main, pp. 376–383. Fraipont, C. (1912). Empreinte ne´reitiforme du marbre noir de Dene´e. Annales de la Socie´te´ ge´ologique de Belgique, 38, 31–36. Goldring, R. (1962). The trace fossils of the Baggy Beds (Upper Devonian) of North Devon, England. Pala¨ontoligische Zeitschrift, 36, 232–251. Goldring, R., Pollard, J. and Rindsberg, A.K. (2000). Development of invertebrate ichnology in UK: Roland Goldring and John Pollard in interview. Ichnology Newsletter, 22, 40–45. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1924). Die Einbettungslage von Exogyra columba in sa¨chsischen Cenoman-Quader. Senckenbergiana, 6, 223–225. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1931). Sternspuren von Krebsen und Ko¨cherbauten von Wu¨rmen in der sa¨chsischen Kreide. Sitzungsberichte und Abhandlungen Naturwissenschaftlichen Gesellschaft Isis Dresden, 1930, 18. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1934). Schraubenfo¨rmige und spiralige Grabga¨nge in turonen Sandsteinen des Zittauer Gebirges. Senckenbergiana, 16, 313–324. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1935). Ein Fisch (Gobius microps) als Erzeuger von Sternspuren. Natur und Volk, 65, 461–465. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1936). Die Schichtungsformen rezenter Flachmeer-Ablagerungen im Jade-Gebiet. Senckenbergiana, 18, 316–356. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1939a). Die Lebensspuren von Corophium volutator (Pallas) und ihre pala¨ontologische Bedeutung. Senckenbergiana, 21, 215–227. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1939b). Tidal flat deposits (Wattenschlick). In: Trask, P.D. (Ed.), Recent Marine Sediments, American Association for Petroleum Geologists, Tulsa, (reprint 1955, and 1968 Dover publ. pp. 195–206). Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1940). Wattenmeer-Beobachtungen am Ringelwurm Nereis. Natur und Volk, 70, 144–148. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1952). Die Lebensspur Ophiomorpha Lundgren im Mioza¨n bei Hamburg, ihre weltweite Verbreitung und Synonymie. Mitteilungen aus dem GeologischesPala¨ontologisches Insitut der Universita¨t Hamburg, 21, 142–153. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1956). Ru¨ckschau auf die pala¨ontologischen und neontologischen Ergebnisse der Forschungsanstalt ‘Senckenberg am Meer’. Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 37, 319–330. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1962). Trace fossils and problematica. In: Moore, R.C. (Ed.), Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, 2nd edition. Geological Society of America and University of Kansas Press, Pt W. Miscellanea, New York & Lawrence, Kansas, pp. W177–W245, 1975. Heer, O. (1877). Flora Fossilis Helvetiae. Die vorweltliche Flora der Schweiz, Wu¨ster, Zu¨rich, 182 pp. Hertweck, G. (1970a). Die Bewohner des Wattenmeeres in ihren Auswirkungen auf das Sediment. In: Reineck, H.-E. (Ed.), Das Watt, Ablagerungs- und Lebensraum, Kramer, Frankfurt am Main, pp. 106–130. Hertweck, G. (1970b). The animal community of a muddy environment and the development of biofacies as effected by the life cycle of the characteristic species. In: Crimes, T.P. and
11
Harper, J.C. (Eds.), Trace Fossils, Geological Journal Special Issue 3, 235–242. Hertweck, G. (1972). Walter Ha¨ntzschel 16.11.1904-10.5.1972. Pala¨ontologische Zeitschrift, 46, 105–112. Hertweck, G. (1973). Der Golf von Gaeta (Tyrrhenisches Meer). VI. Lebensspuren einiger Bodenbewohner und Ichnofaziesbereiche. Senckenbergiana Maritima, 5, 179–197. Hertweck, G. (1994). Zonation of Benthos and Lebensspuren in the tidal flats of the Jade Bay, southern North Sea. Senckenbergiana Maritima, 24, 157–170. Hertweck, G. and Reineck, H.-E. (1966). Untersuchungen von Gangbauten und anderen Wu¨hlgefu¨gen mariner Bodentiere. Natur und Museum, 96, 429–438. Hitchcock, E. (1858). Ichnology of New England, A report of the sandstone of the Connecticut Valley especially its footprints, White, Boston, 220 pp. Howard, J.D. (1968). X-ray radiography for examination of burrowing in sediments by marine invertebrate organisms. Sedimentology, 11, 249–258. Howard, J.D. and Elders, C.A. (1970). Burrowing patterns of haustoriid amphipods from Sapelo Island, Georgia. In: Crimes, T.P. and Harper, J.C. (Eds.), Trace Fossils, Geological Journal Special Issue 3, 244–262. Howard, J.D., Frey, R.W. and Reineck, H.-E. (1972). Georgia coastal region, Sapelo Island U.S.A.: Sedimentology and Biology. I. Introduction. Senckenbergiana Maritima, 4, 3–14. Krejci-Graf, K. (1932). Definition der Begriffe Marken, Spuren, Fa¨hrten, Bauten, Hieroglyphen und Fucoiden. Senckenbergiana, 14, 19–39. Larsen, E.B. (1936). Biologische Studien u¨ber die tunnelgrabenden Ka¨fer auf Skallingen. Videnskabelige Meddelelser fra Dansk Naturhistorisk Forening I Københaven, 100, 1–231. Lauff, G.H. (Ed.) (1967). Estuaries. American Association for the Advancement of Science Publication, 83, 1–757. Lehmann, U. (1972). Ein Nachruf. Mitteilungen aus dem Geologisches-Pala¨ontologisches Insitut der Universita¨t Hamburg, 41, 7–14, (Walter Ha¨ntzschel, 1904–1972). Lessertisseur, J. (1955). Traces fossiles d’activite´ animale et leur significance pale´obiologique. Me´moires de la Socie´te´ Ge´ologique de France N.S, 74, 1–150. Linke, O. (1939). Die Biota des Jadebusenwattes. Helgola¨nder Wissenschaftliche Meeresuntersuchungen, 1, 201–348. MacGinitie, G.E. (1934). The natural history of Callianassa californiensis Dana. American Midland Naturalist, 15, 166–177. Nathorst, A.G. (1873). Om na˚gra fo¨rmodade va¨xtfossiler. Kongliga Svenska Vetenskaps-Akademiens Handlingar, 9, 25–52, (1874). Nathorst, A.G. (1881). Om spa˚r af evertebrerade djur m. m. och deras paleontologiska betydelse (with abridged french translation: Me´moire sur quelques traces d’animaux sans verte`bres etc. et de leur porte´e pale´ontologique p. 61–104). Kongliga Svenska Vetenskaps-Akademiens Handlingar, 18, 1–104. Nathorst, A.G. (1886). Nouvelles observations sur les traces d’animaux et autres phe´nome`nes d’origine purement me´canique de´crits comme ‘Algues fossiles’. Kongliga Svenska VetenskapsAkademiens Handlingar, 21, 1–58. Nicholson, H.A. (1873). Contributions to the study of the errant annelids of the older Paleozoic rocks. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, 21, 288–290. Osgood, R.G. (1975). The history of invertebrate ichnology. In: Frey, R.W. (Ed.), The Study of Trace Fossils, Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 3–12. Pemberton, S.G. and MacEachern, J.A. (1994). Carroll Lane Fenton and Mildred Adams Fenton: Pioneers of North American Neoichnology. Ichnos, 3, 145–153.
12
1. THE WADDEN SEA, CRADLE OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY
Pemberton, S.G., Gingras, M.K. and MacEachern, J.A. (2007). The antecedents of invertebrate ichnology in North America: the Canadian and Cincinnati schools. In: Miller, W. (Ed.), Trace Fossils: Concepts, Problems, Prospects. Ragotzkie, R.A., Pomeroy, L.R., Teal, J.M. and Scott, D.C. (Eds.) (1959). Proceedings Salt Marsh Conference, Sapelo Island, Georgia, 1958, Athens, Georgia, 133 pp. Reineck, H.-E. (1957). Stechkasten und Deckweiß, Hilfsmittel des Meeresgeologen. Natur und Volk, 87, 132–134. Reineck, H.-E. (1958). Wu¨hlbau-Gefu¨ge in Abha¨ngigkeit von Sediment-Umlagerung. Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 39, 1–23. Reineck, H.-E. (1963a). Sedimentgefu¨ge im Bereich der su¨dlichen Nordsee. Abhandlungen Senckenbergische Naturforschende Gesellschaft, 505, 1–138. Reineck, H.-E. (1963b). Naßha¨rtung von ungesto¨rten Bodenproben im Format 5 x 5 cm fu¨r projizierbare Dickschliffe. Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 44, 357–362. Reineck, H.-E., (1963c). Der Kastengreifer. Natur und Museum, 83, 102–108. Reineck, H.-E. (1967a). Ein Kolbenlot mit Plastik-Rohren. Senckenbergergiana Lethaea, 48, 285–289. Reineck, H.-E. (1967b). Layered sediments of tidal flats, beaches, and shelf bottoms of the North Sea. In: Lauff, G.H. (Ed.), Estuaries, American Association for the Advancement of Science Publication, pp. 191–206. Reineck, H.-E. (1968). Lebensspuren von Herzigeln. Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 49, 311–319. Reineck, H.-E. (1970a). Das Watt. Ablagerungs- und Lebensraum, Kramer, Frankfurt am Main, 142 pp. Reineck, H.-E. (1970b). Reliefguß und projizierbarer Dickschliff. Senckenbergiana Maritima, 2, 61–66. Reineck, H.-E. (1981). Die Wissenschaft die Steine lebendig macht. Natur und Museum, 111, 343–346, (Rudolf Richter Heft). Reineck, H.-E., Gutmann, W.F. and Hertweck, G. (1967). Das Schlickgebiet su¨dlich Helgoland als Beispiel rezenter Schelfablagerungen. Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 48, 219–275. Reineck, H.-E., Do¨rjes, J., Gadow, S. and Hertweck, G. (1968). Sedimentologie, Faunenzonierung und Faziesabfolge vor der Ostkuste der inneren Deutschen Bucht. Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 49, 261–309. Reineck, H.-E. and Singh, I.B. (1973). Depositional Sedimentary Environments, Springer, Berlin, 439 pp. Reineck, H.-E. and Ying Min, Cheng. (1978). Sedimentologische und faunistische Untersuchungen an Watten in Taiwan. I. Aktuogeologische Untersuchungen. Senckenbergiana Maritima, 10, 85–115. Reineck, H.-E. and Flemming, B.W. (1997). Unusual tracks, traces, and other oddities. Courier Forschungsinstitut Senckenberg, 201, 349–360. Reise, K. (1985). Tidal Flat Ecology, Springer, Berlin, 191 pp. Richter, R. (1919–1920). Vom Bau und leben der Trilobiten. I. Das Schwimmen. II. Die Aufenthalt auf den Boden. Der Schutz. Die Erna¨hrung. Senckenbergiana, 1, 213–238; 2, 22–43. Richter, R. (1920). Flachseebeobachtungen I. Ein devonischer ‘Pfeifenquarzit’ verglichen mit der heutigen ‘Sandkoralle’ (Sabellaria, Ann.). Senckenbergiana, 2, 215–235. Richter, R. (1921). Flachseebeobachtungen II. Scolithus, Sabellarifex und Geflechtquarzite. Senckenbergiana, 3, 49–52. Richter, R. (1924a). Flachseebeobachtungen VII. Arenicola von heute und Arenicoloides, eine Rhizocorallide des Buntsandsteins, als Vertreter verschiedener Lebensweise. Senckenbergiana, 6, 119–140.
Richter, R. (1924b). Flachseebeobachtungen IX. Zur Deutung rezenten und fossiler Ma¨ander-Figuren. Senckenbergiana, 6, 141–157. Richter, R. (1926a). Flachseebeobachtungen XII. Bau, Begriff und pala¨ogeographische Bedeutung von Corophioides luniformis (Blanckenhorn, 1917). Senckenbergiana, 8, 200–219. Richter, R. (1926b). Flachseebeobachtungen XIV. Abdru¨cke lebendiger Tiere (Fische und Wu¨rmer). Senckenbergiana, 8, 221–224. Richter, R. (1926c). Eine geologische Exkursion in das Wattenmeer. Natur und Museum, 56, 289–301. Richter, R. (1927). Die fossilen Fa¨hrten und Bauten der ¨ berblick u¨ber ihre biologischen Grundformen Wu¨rmer, ein U und deren geologische Bedeutung. Pala¨ontologische Zeitschrift, 9, 193–240. Richter, R. (1929). Gru¨ndung und Aufgaben der Forschungsstelle fu¨r Meeresgeologie Senckenberg in Wilhelmshaven. Natur und Museum, 59, 11–30. Richter, R. (1942). Marken und Spuren im Hunsru¨ckschiefer. 3. Fa¨hrten als Zeugnisse des Lebens auf dem Meeresgrunde. Senckenbergiana, 23, 218–260. Salter, J.W. (1857). On annelide-burrows and surface markings from the Cambrian rocks of the Longmynd. Quaterly Journal of the Geological Society of London, 13, 199–206. Saporta, G. (1884). Les organismes proble´matiques des anciennes mers, Masson, Paris, 100 pp. Scha¨fer, W. (1956). Wirkungen der Benthos-Organismen auf den jungen Schichtverband. Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 37, 183–263. Scha¨fer ,W. (1962a). Aktuo-Pala¨ontologie nach, Studien in der Nordsee. Waldemar Kramer, Frankfurt am Main, 666 pp., (translated in 1972 as Ecology and Paleoecology of marine environments. University of Chicago Press, Chicago). Scha¨fer, W. (1962b). 60 Jahre Mellum. Natur und Museum, 92, 173–176. Scha¨fer, W. (1967). Forschungsanstalt fu¨r Meeresgeologie und Meeresbiologie Senckenberg in Wilhelmshaven. Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 48, 191–217. Schwarz, A. (1929). Ein Verfahren zum Ha¨rten nichtverfestigter Sedimente. Natur und Museum, 549, 204–208. Seilacher, A. (1951). Der Ro¨hrenbau von Lanice conchilega (Polychaeta). Ein Beitrag zur Deutung fossiler Lebensspuren. Senckenbergiana, 32, 267–280. Seilacher, A. (1953a). Der Brandungssand als Lebensraum in Gegenwart und Vorzeit. Natur und Volk, 83, 263–272. ¨ ber die Seilacher, A. (1953b). Studien zur Palichnologie. I. U Methoden der Palichnologie. Neues Jahrbuch fu¨r Geologie und Pala¨ontologie, Abhandlungen, 96, 421–452. Seilacher, A. (1953c). Studien zur Palichnologie. II. Die fossilen Ruhespuren (Cubichnia). Neues Jahrbuch fu¨r Geologie und Pala¨ontologie, Abhandlungen, 98, 87–124. Seilacher, A. (1954). Die geologische Bedeutung fossiler Lebensspuren. Zeitschrift der Deutschen Geologischen Gesellschaft, 105, 214–227. Seilacher, A. (1957). An-aktualistisches Wattenmeer? Pala¨ontologische Zeitschrift, 31, 198–206. Seilacher, A. (1964). Biogenic sedimentary structures. In: Imbrie, J. and Newell, N.D. (Eds.), Approaches to Paleoecology, John Wiley, New York, pp. 296–316. Seilacher, A. (1975). Walter Ha¨ntzschel (1904-1972) and the foundation of modern invertebrate ichnology.
REFERENCES
In: Frey, R.W. (Ed.), The Study of Trace Fossils, Springer, New York, pp. v–viii. Seilacher, A. (1994). Response by Adolf Seilacher. Journal of Paleontology, 68, 917–918. ¨ kologie Thamdrup, H.M. (1935). Beitra¨ge zur O der Wattenfauna auf experimenteller Grundlage. Meddelelser fra Kommissionen for Danmarks Fiskeri- og Havundersøgelser Serie Fiskeri X, 2, 1–125. Trask, P.D. (Ed.) (1939). Recent Marine Sediments, American Association Petroleum Geologists, Tulsa, Oklahoma, 736 pp., (later and enlarged editions in 1955 and 1968). van Straaten, L.M.J.U. (1950). Environment of formation and facies of the Wadden Sea sediments. Tijdschrift Koninklijk Nederlands Aardrijkskundig Genootschap, 67, 94–108. van Straaten, L.M.J.U. (1952). Biogenic textures and formation of shell beds in the Dutch Wadden Sea. I and II. Proceedings Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen (B)55(5), 500–516. van Straaten, L.M.J.U. (1954a). Composition and structure of recent marine sediments in the Netherlands. Leidse Geologische Mededelingen, 19, 1–108.
13
van Straaten, L.M.J.U. (1954b). Sedimentology of recent tidal flat deposits and the Psammites du Condroz (Devonian). Geologie en Mijnbouw, 16, 25–47. van Straaten, L.M.J.U. (1956). Composition of shell beds formed in tidal flat environment in the Netherlands and the Bay of Arcachon. Geologie en Mijnbouw, 18, 209–226. Veenstra, H.J. (2004). In memoriam Lambertus Marius Joannes Ursinus van Straaten 1920–2004. Annual Report 2004 of the Geological Society (London), 1, 44–45. Walther, J. (1893–4). Einleitung in die Geologie als historische Wissenschaft, Fischer, Jena, 1055 pp. Winkler, T.C. (1886). Histoire de l’Ichnologie. E˙tude ichnologique sur les empreintes de pas d’animaux fossiles. Archives du Muse´e Teyler (Se´rie 2), 2, 241–440. Wohlenberg, E. (1937). Die Wattenmeer-Lebensgemeinschaften im Ko¨nigshafen von Sylt. Helgola¨nder Wissenschaftlige Meeresuntersuchungen, 1, 1–92. Ziegler, W. (1981). In Memoriam Rudolf Richter. Natur und Museum, 111, 341–343. Ziegler, W. (1992). Rudolf Richter 1881–1957. In: Klausewitz, W. (Ed.), 175 Jahre Senckenbergische Naturforschende Gesellschaft, Jubila¨umsband, 1, Kramer, Frankfurt am Main, pp. 335–350.
C
H
A
P
T
E
R
2 The Antecedents of Invertebrate Ichnology in North America: The Canadian and Cincinnati Schools S. George Pemberton, James A. MacEachern, and Murray K. Gingras
has been in use for approximately 175 years, but it is only within the last 20 or 30 years that the importance of ichnology has been recognized. In the past and to a certain degree even recently, trace fossils were classified as ‘Problematica,’ and Caster (1957) defined these as ‘the residuum of paleontologic materials, or of materials supposedly of organic origin, still awaiting definitive systematic assignment’ (Caster, 1957, p. 1025). For most of the nineteenth century, ichnofossils were interpreted to represent fucoids—i.e., fossilized remnants belonging to an order of algae (Fucales), which includes marginal-marine and marine seaweeds, and rockweeds such as modern Sargassum and Fucus. It is easy to see how this early misinterpretation evolved. Many beddingplane-oriented trace fossils display graceful, curving morphologies and possess repeating components that are superficially similar to modern plants. The singular beauty of such examples has been celebrated in Dolf Seilacher’s (1995) book Fossile Kunst (translated title Fossil Art). Trace fossils have been recognized as burrows and trails since the 1880s. This resulted from insightful interpretations published by Nathorst (1873, 1881) that were aimed at dispelling the notion that ichnofossils represented the remains of fossilized algae. By the early 1900s, most researchers accepted trace fossils to be the inorganic expression of an animal’s interaction with a substrate. Osgood (1970, 1975) divided the development of ichnology into 3 broad sections: (1) the Age of Fucoids from 1823 to 1881, which envelopes the period when
SUMMARY : The development of ichnology in North America radiated from two independent centers: the Canadian School, consisting of professional geologists generally associated with the Geological Survey of Canada, and the Cincinnati School, consisting predominantly of amateur paleontologists. Both schools had considerable impact but worked somewhat in isolation from the active European ichnological centers in Germany, France, and England. North American researchers were quick to realize that many of the markings described as fucoids were not seaweeds, but were, in fact, produced by animals.
INTRODUCTION Trace fossils (or ichnofossils) are biologically produced sedimentary structures that include tracks, trails, burrows, borings, fecal pellets, and other traces made by organisms. Markings that do not reflect a behavioral function are excluded. Owing to their nature, trace fossils can be considered as both paleontological and sedimentological entities, thereby bridging the gap between two of the main subdivisions in sedimentary geology. In the multi-disciplinary field of sedimentary geology, ichnology is playing an important role in the interpretation of sedimentary facies, depositional environments, and sequence stratigraphic discontinuities. The term ‘ichnology’
Copyright ß 2007, Elsevier B.V. Trace Fossils: Concepts, Problems, Prospects
14
All rights reserved.
THE EARLY CANADIAN SCHOOL
biogenic structures were considered to be fossil marine algae, initiated with the article by Brongniart (1823) and ending with the landmark Nathorst (1881) article; (2) the Period of Reaction extending from 1881 to 1925, describing the period when the vegetable origin of fucoids was seriously questioned; and (3) the Development of the Modern Approach from 1925 to 1953, spanning the establishment of the Senckenberg Laboratory by Rudolf Richter in 1925 and ending with the seminal works of Dolf Seilacher. We can now add another division: The Modern Era, which started with the pioneering work of Seilacher in 1953 and extends to the present day. The roots of ichnology go back to the early pioneer European work of Sternberg, Brongniart, Buckland, Salter, and Nathorst (see Osgood, 1970, 1975; Ha¨ntzschel, 1975; for details). However, in North America, two centers of excellence emerged: the Canadian School inhabited by William Logan, John Dawson, Elkanah Billings, and William Matthew; and the Cincinnati School, dominated by Uriah James, his son Joseph James, and Samuel Miller. These two groups made important ichnological discoveries and, despite being isolated from the mainstream researchers, were instrumental in the development of the modern conceptual framework of ichnology.
present day. The Geological Survey of Canada, established in 1842, provided the impetus for extensive geological examination of strata. The early researchers took an active interest in trace fossils and very early on interpreted them correctly as structures produced by the activities of organisms. William Logan, J. William Dawson, Elkanah Billings, and George Matthew were all, in some regard, linked to the Geological Survey of Canada, and were responsible for fundamental advances in how traces fossils were studied.
William Edmond Logan (1798–1875) Biography Sir William Edmond Logan is, perhaps, Canada’s most famous geologist. In fact, during a survey in 1998 the prominent Canadian magazine Maclean’s (July 1, 1998 issue) determined that Sir William Edmond Logan was the most important scientist in Canadian history. He was a stratigrapher, structural, and economic geologist, and was the first director of the Geological Survey of Canada. Details on Logan’s life have been summarized from Harrington (1883) and Winder (1972, 2004). William Logan (Fig. 2.1A) was born on April 29, 1798 in Montreal, where he received his early education at Skakel’s Private School. He was then sent to Scotland and continued his education, first at the Edinburgh High School (1814–1816), and then Edinburgh University (1816–1817), where he studied
THE EARLY CANADIAN SCHOOL Canada played an important role in the development of ichnology and this tradition continues to the
A
15
B
FIGURE 2.1 (A) Sir William Edmond Logan 1798–1875 (courtesy of the Public Archives of Canada). (B) Type Specimen (GSC Holotype 6299) of Climactichnites wilsoni. This slab was on the wall in Logan’s office (photograph courtesy of the Geological Survey of Canada).
16
2. THE ANTECEDENTS OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
chemistry, mathematics, and logic. His early work was in the copper mining industry near Swansea in southern Wales. While in Wales, he produced highly accurate topographic and cross-sectional maps of nearby coal seams, which were later adopted by the Geological Survey of Great Britain. In 1840, Logan proposed his theory on the in situ formation of coal, which enabled geologists to determine the location of workable deposits of coalified strata. He subsequently studied the coalfields of Pennsylvania and Nova Scotia in 1841. Logan was appointed the first director of the Geological Survey of Canada in 1842, a position he held until 1869. In order to get this position, Logan compiled an impressive list of testimonials including letters from four of the most influential British geologists of the time: Henry de la Beche, Roderick Murchison, Adam Sedgwick, and William Buckland. His early work at the Geologic Survey included further studies of the coalfields of Nova Scotia and New Brunswick. He also analyzed the copper-bearing rocks on the north shore of Lake Superior, and undertook geologic work on the Gaspe Peninsula. Logan, with the help of one assistant, Alexander Murray, identified and mapped the major geological structures of the Province of Canada, in particular the Laurentian and Huronian series of the Precambrian Shield (Logan, 1858). In 1863, Logan published the monumental work ‘The Geology of Canada,’ followed in 1865 by an atlas, and in 1869 by a larger geological map. During most of his time at the Survey, Logan maintained a twelve-hour day in the field, usually alone carrying all of his own supplies. In the evenings he wrote up his notes and completed his maps. In 1869, at the age of 71, he recognized that a younger man should take over his post and he resigned as the Director. Upon ‘retirement,’ he divided his time between an estate he purchased in Wales and conducting further exploration in Canada. While preparing to do field work in the eastern townships of Quebec, Logan became ill and following a short illness, died on July 22, 1875. Sir William Logan was then buried in the churchyard at Cilgerran, Wales. Based on the high caliber of his work, Sir William Edmond Logan received many honors during his lifetime. In 1851, based on the excellence of his display of Canadian minerals at the London exposition, Logan became the first Canadian-born citizen to be inducted into the Royal Society of London. Similarly, Logan was awarded the Cross of the Legion of Honor at the Paris Exhibition in 1855. The following year, Queen Victoria knighted Logan and he also received the Wollaston Medal from the Royal Society in 1867. Although never associated with a university, he did donate $19, 000
to McGill University in Montreal to establish the Logan Chair in Geology. The first holder of the chair was his good friend William Dawson. Both McGill University in Montreal (1856) and the University of Bishop’s College in Lennoxville, Quebec (1855) conferred honorary degrees on him. During his career, he was a Fellow of the Geological Society of London (1837), a Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh (1861), and a member of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia (1846), the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, Boston (1859), and the American Philosophical Society (1860). Contributions to Ichnology Although ichnology was not a main thrust of Logan’s research, he was cognizant of the importance of the subject and recognized that traces were, indeed, constructed by organisms. His work on paleoichnology in Nova Scotia provided the first demonstration of the existence of land animals in the Upper Paleozoic, when he described the first ever traces observed of land animals from the Carboniferous System. The trace consisted of a series of small, but well-marked footprints, found in the lower coal measures of Horton Bluff, Nova Scotia (Logan, 1842). Later, in 1851, Logan documented the occurrence of tracks and footprints from the Potsdam Sandstone of Lower Canada (Logan, 1851, 1852). The tracks were found in a quarry at the village of Beauharnois, on the south side of the St. Lawrence River, about twenty miles above the city of Montreal. They occur on the bedding planes between sandstone units and argillaceous interbeds. The Potsdam Sandstone was determined to be Lower Silurian in age, through the correlation of the presence of Lingula or Scolithus (= Skolithos) and ‘Fucoid’ horizons, in conjunction with graptolite zones. Plaster casts of the tracks were made by Logan and shown to Prof. Owen, who proposed a classification for them under the ichnogenera Protichnites (P. septem-notatus, P. octo-notatus, P. latus, P. multinotatus, P. lineatus, and P. altnans); the ichnospecies were defined on the basis of variations of the median furrow and appendage impressions (Owen, 1852). In all the occurrences of the tracks, there is no clear evidence of unequivocal marks of toes or nails, and most display a median track or impression. Protichnites is now generally considered to be the locomotion structure of trilobites or other arthropods (Ha¨ntzschel, 1975). In 1860, Logan described another occurrence of fossil tracks or trails from the Potsdam Sandstone in the vicinity of Perth, Ontario (Fig. 2.1B). These tracks consisted of a number of parallel ridges and furrows similar to ripple marks, which were arranged between
THE EARLY CANADIAN SCHOOL
two narrow, contiguous parallel ridges. The track is gently sinuous, somewhat resembling a ladder of rope. The transverse ridges are either straight or curved, and there is locally a median ridge, which can be sinuous or straight, running between the two parallel side ridges. Logan proposed the name Climactichnites wilsoni (Logan, 1860)
Sir John William Dawson (1820–1899) Biography Sir John William Dawson stands as one of Canada’s most outstanding scientists. During his long and illustrious career, he distinguished himself as a geologist, a paleontologist, an educator, an administrator, and a churchman. Details on Dawson’s life and the significance of his work may be found in publications by Adams (1899), Ami (1900), O’Brien (1971), Clark (1972), and Hofmann (1982). Dawson (Fig. 2.2A) was born on October 19, 1820 at Pictou, Nova Scotia, where his father John was a prominent businessman. At an early age, he developed a love for the natural sciences and made large collections of fossil plants from the Nova Scotia Coal Measures. Dawson was educated at the Pictou Academy. On two separate occasions he spent time at Edinburgh University, where Robert Jamieson and Edward Forbes influenced him. In 1841, he graduated with a Master of Arts degree from Edinburgh University and returned to Nova Scotia to pursue his geological research. During this period, Dawson
A
B
17
met two individuals who would play prominent roles in his subsequent geological career—Sir Charles Lyell, who was touring North America, and Sir William Logan, who would be the first director of the Geological Survey of Canada. In 1850, at the age of 30, Dawson was appointed Superintendent of Education for Nova Scotia. This position afforded him the opportunity to tour the countryside, and he accumulated an immense body of information dealing with the geology, paleontology, and mineral resources of Nova Scotia. This material was assimilated and his first and, arguably, most important book, ‘Acadian Geology,’ was published in 1855 and appeared in three editions (Dawson, 1868). In 1854, Edward Forbes, a professor of geology and zoology at the University of Edinburgh, died, and Lyell, who was greatly impressed with Dawson’s work, urged him to apply for the vacant chair. Soon after, however, he received word that the position has been filled by a zoologist who had been supported strongly by the medical school. By strange coincidence, he received, almost on the same day, a letter offering him the principalship of McGill University in Quebec. He accepted this position with the proviso that he also assumed the chair of natural history. Under his guidance, McGill progressed from an obscure college with three faculties and 16 professors in 1855, to a world-class educational institution with more than 120 professors by 1900. In addition to his teaching duties, Dawson administered the university, initiated and acted as first librarian for the university, and was a prominent
C
FIGURE 2.2 (A) Sir John Dawson Logan (1820–1899) (courtesy of the Redpath Museum, McGill University). (B) Original drawing of Dawson’s Rusichnites acadicus(after Dawson, 1864). (C) Photograph of the specimen depicted in B, Rusophycus acadicus, Redpath Museum No. 3177.
18
2. THE ANTECEDENTS OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
figure in almost all phases of the educational system in Quebec. During all this, he still managed to find time to carry out original research in numerous areas. As pointed out by Hofmann (1982), Dawson’s scientific productivity was enormous and included articles not only in geology and paleontology, but also in agriculture, anthropology, and theology. Ami (1900) listed 364 contributions in the most comprehensive bibliography ever assembled on Dawson’s work. Of these, Clark (1972) indicated that 198 dealt with some aspect of paleontology. Throughout his career, Dawson received many honors and held numerous important positions. He received an honorary LLD from McGill University (1857) and Edinburgh University (1884); he was elected an honorary or corresponding member of many learned societies. He was a fellow of the Royal Society of London (1862), was awarded the Lyell Gold Medal by the Geological Society of London (1881), was the first president of the Royal Society of Canada (1882), was elected president of the American Association for the Advancement of Science (1882), was created a Knight Bachelor by Queen Victoria (1884), was elected president of the British Association for the Advancement of Science (1886), and was elected president of the Geological Society of American (1893). In 1893, Dawson was seized with a severe attack of pneumonia, and his health became so seriously impaired that he was forced to retire. He passed away on November 19, 1899 at the age of 79. Contributions to Ichnology The synthesis of natural science and religion was influential in Dawson’s works. In effect, his career shows the durability of the two theologies’ tradition (O’Brien, 1971). It was this deep involvement in the two theologies’ tradition which thrusted Dawson into numerous controversies. The reassuring synthesis of science and religion that was so convincing in his youth, seemed to crumble on all sides as he grew older (O’Brien, 1971). During the span of Dawson’s career, geology was in a state of continual controversy, where both new and old ideas were questioned and debated. John William Dawson was well known to be a man always involved with a controversial issue. At the forefront of such controversies stood the question of the origin of Eozoon canadense, ‘the dawn animal of Canada.’ The discovery was made in 1858 in the rocks of Precambrian age, located in the Ottawa valley (Logan, 1858). The coral-like surface of the specimen immediately suggested to Sir William Logan that it might be a fossil; potentially a very important discovery. In 1865, Dawson named the specimen
Eozoon canadense. His involvement was inevitable, since in the 1860’s he was the only accomplished microscopist in Canada and specimens of Eozoon were, as a matter of course, brought to him for investigation (O’Brien, 1971). After examination of the specimen, Dawson declared that it was a foraminifer. Dawson’s advocacy of Eozoon as a foraminifer received much opposition. In 1866, he also proposed that curious holes in rocks containing Eozoon were worm burrows similar to Scolithus (= Skolithos) (Dawson, 1866). However, Dawson knew that, if his opinion were correct, evolutionists would have had to contend not only with an immense gap in time and in the paleontological record, but also with the presence of a very advanced and complex form preceding in time much simpler Foraminifera (O’Brien, 1971; Hofmann, 1971). Once aware of the consequences Eozoon was offered to the theory of evolution, Dawson was determined to exploit them to the fullest. It is important to understand Dawson’s deep involvement in synthesizing science and religion. Such motivation was responsible for most of Dawson’s involvements in other controversies. While the origin of Eozoon has been established as undoubtedly inorganic, the significance or relevance of the controversy on science is important to remember. ‘. . . It provides an example of the manner in which every aspect of 19th Century paleontology was scrutinized for its bearing on evolution. It is also a classic case of the confrontation of younger specialists with each other and with the older generation of broadly trained naturalists’ (O’Brien, 1971, p. 28). Despite Dawson’s keen opposition to evolution and its proponents (particularly Charles Darwin); he remained a forerunner in the most controversial issues apparent in geology during the nineteenth century. Even if all his beliefs and interpretations were to be proven wrong at some point in time, it is his contribution to the progress of geological thought during this time that is important. It was Dawson’s keen eye for observation and his determination, which resulted in numerous other contributions both to geology, and more specifically, ichnology. He went on to propose seven new ichnogenera to the taxonomic classification of ichnofossils, of which two are still considered trace fossils (Diplichnites Dawson, 1873; and Sabellarites Dawson, 1890), three are pseudofossils (Archaeospherina Dawson, 1875; Eozoon Dawson, 1865; and Rhabdichnites Dawson, 1873), and two are invalid (Rusichnites Dawson, 1864, Fig. 2.2B; and Astropolithon Dawson, 1878). Demonstrating that Cruziana and Rusophycus represent the works of animals rather than the remains of algae marks one
THE EARLY CANADIAN SCHOOL
of the most significant turning points in the history of invertebrate ichnology. The distinction for achieving this breakthrough is generally attributed to Nathorst (1873, 1881) who, in a series of well-documented articles, was able to defend and disseminate this viewpoint. However, nearly a decade before Nathorst’s work appeared in press, Dawson, had already demonstrated that Rusophycus could not be a plant but, instead, must have been produced by the burrowing activities of trilobites (Fig. 2.2C). He also understood the toponomic relationship of the trace, and its ethologic significance (Pemberton and Frey, 1991). Likewise, Dawson (1890) indicated that Asterophycus Lesquereux was not fossilized seaweed, but represented the burrow of an annelid. Dawson summarized his criteria for distinguishing between algae and the traces of animals as follows: ‘The author of this work has given much attention to these remains, and has not been disposed to claim for the vegetable kingdom so many of them as some of his contemporaries. The considerations, which seem most important in making such distinctions are the following: 1. The presence or absence of carbonaceous matter. True Algae not infrequently present at least a thin film of carbon representing their organic matter, and this is more likely to occur in their case, as organic matters buried in marine deposits and not exposed to atmospheric oxidation are very likely to be preserved. 2. In the absence of organic matter, the staining of the containing rock, the disappearance or deoxidation of its ferruginous coloring matter, or the presence of iron pyrite may indicate the removal of organic matter by decay. 3. When organic matter and indications of it are altogether absent, and form along remains, we have to distinguish from Algae, trails and burrows similar to those of aquatic animals, casts of shrinkage cracks, water marks, and rill marks widely diffused over the surfaces of beds. 4. Markings depressed on the upper surfaces of beds, and filled with the material of the succeeding layer, are usually mere impressions. The cases of possible exceptions to this are very rare. On the contrary, there are not infrequently forms in relief on the surfaces of rocks which are not Algae, but may be shallow burrows arched upwards on top, or castings of worms thrown up upon the surface. Sometimes, however, they may have been left by denudation of the surrounding material, just as footprints on dry snow remain in relief after the surrounding loose material has been drifted away by the wind; the portion consolidated by pressure being better able to resist the denuding agency.’ (Dawson, 1888, pp. 26–27). Dawson also made observations in modern settings of Limulus (Dawson, 1862a,b, 1878) and
19
compared its activities to the ichnogenus Protichnites. He experimented with the animals under different substrate consistencies and noted that different markings were produced depending on the nature of the substrate. This represents one of the first experimental neoichnological studies, and predates the landmark work of Nathorst (1873, 1881) and Darwin (1881). Unfortunately, geologists, largely overlooked Dawson’s work on Rusophycus, much like the original article by Nathorst in 1873, because it appeared in an obscure regional journal. Perhaps more importantly, all these works show that the ‘age of fucoids’ was not merely the ‘dark age’ of ichnology, as commonly subsequent authors have depicted it. Nor did North America lag behind Europe in the early development of the discipline, as has commonly been assumed.
Elkanah Billings (1820–1876) Biography Elkanah Billings is generally regarded as Canada’s first paleontologist. Details of Billings’s life are summarized from Whiteaves (1877), Ami (1901), and Clark (1971). Elkanah Billings (Fig. 2.3A) was born on May 5, 1820 by the Rideau River, on a farm located three miles from the town of Bytown (now Ottawa) in the Township of Gloucester, Upper Canada (now Ontario). He received extensive formal education from an early age, initiated by a governess and extended through a family tutor. Later he attended several local private schools up to the age of seventeen. From 1837 to 1839, he spent two years at St. Lawrence Academy at Potsdam, New York, in preparation for a law career. In 1939, Elkanah entered the Law Society of Upper Canada and was articled to several lawyers from both Bytown and Toronto, and at the end of his studies was called to the bar in 1845. While articled to the legal firm Baldwin and Wilson of Toronto, he met and later in, married Eleanor, a sister of the junior partner Adam Wilson (later Chief Justice of Ontario). For eight years he practiced law in Bytown and surrounding area. Following his return to Bytown in 1852, he opened a law office but almost immediately became editor of the Bytown Citizen and retained the position until shortly before joining the Geological Survey of Canada in 1856 (Whiteaves, 1877). As editor of the Bytown Citizen, he began to define his interests in the natural sciences through the writing of popular articles on geological topics and natural history subjects. His love for natural history may have been fostered by his eldest brother,
20
2. THE ANTECEDENTS OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
A
B
FIGURE 2.3 (A) Elkanah Billings 1820–1876 (courtesy of the Geological Survey of Canada). (B) Original figure of Licrophycus ottawaensis from Billings (1862). Specimen is now considered to be Phycodes (courtesy of the Geological Survey of Canada).
Bradish who became an accomplished botanist and entomologist (Clark, 1971). Between 1852 and 1856, he began to learn the principles of geology and zoology. Beginning in 1852, he began to accumulate a large collection of fossils from local Ordovician outcrops and quarries. His collection of asteroids, crinoids, and cystids was particularly good. In 1854, his first two scientific articles concerned with the latter group were published in the Journal of the Canadian Institute of Toronto. These articles stamped him as a capable paleontologist and show that, by this time, he had achieved a mastery of zoological taxonomy and the rules of nomenclature. Billings initiated the publication of ‘Canadian Naturalist and Geologists’ in 1856 for two reasons. Through the articles he could qualify himself as a field geologist and at the same time, they provided the youth of Canada with a convenient means of learning the natural history of their country. Following the publication of the journal, William E. Logan appointed Billings, Paleontologist to the Geological Survey of Canada. While at the Geological Survey of Canada from 1856 until his death in 1876, Billings’ time was devoted to the description and naming of Silurian, Ordovician, and Devonian fossils of Upper Canada (Ontario), Lower Canada (Quebec) and Newfoundland. His recognition of fossil assemblages was instrumental in the determination of the precise limits and distribution
of geologic formations. As a result of Billing’s determination of the age of the rocks of the ‘Quebec Group’ as Germantown and Chazy, Logan was able to demonstrate his ‘great overlap,’ now referred to as Logan’s Line. Among his most important scientific publications are two articles entitled ‘On some new genera and species of Cystoidea from the Trenton Limestone’ which appeared in 1854. It was these two articles that established his ability as a scientist. In his first report to the Survey in 1857, he described one hundred and six new species belonging to thirty-five genera (of which thirteen were new). He continued the work on the ‘Canadian Organic Remains’ series, of which Decades Ill and IV were published in 1858 and 1859, concerned largely with fossil echinoderms. He initiated a second series entitled ‘Palaeozoic Fossils,’ the first volume appearing in 1865, and the first part of the second in 1874. During his time at the Survey, he erected sixty-one new genera and one thousand and sixty-five new species. In a bibliography of more than two hundred titles (Walker, 1901), ninety were concerned directly or indirectly with paleontological subjects (Clark, 1971). This work received recognition in 1867 when the Natural History Society voted him a silver medal ‘for his life-long efforts in the promotion of science in Canada’ and the jurors of the International Exhibition of London in 1862 and
THE EARLY CANADIAN SCHOOL
the Paris Exhibition in 1867 also awarded him a bronze medal. Billings continued to work even in the final three years of his life, but was slowed by Brights disease to which he succumbed on June 14, 1876. Billings was buried in the Wilson family plot in Toronto, Ontario. Contributions to Ichnology Although echinoderms were his specialty, he studied and wrote on all invertebrate groups. Over the course of his professional life, he erected sixty-one new genera and 1065 new species. His bibliography comprises over 200 titles, a remarkable feat for essentially a self-taught paleontologist. Billings was an early contributor to the field of ichnology in North America. He erected three ichnogenera, Saerichnites Billings, 1866; (Arthraria Billings, 1872; and Licrophycus Billings, 1862, and at least seventeen ichnospecies including species of Skolithos (S. canadensis Billings, 1862), Cruziana (C. similis Billings, 1874), Palaeophycus (P. incipiens Billings, 1861a; P. congregatus Billings, 1861a; P. beverleyensis Billings, 1862; P. funiculus Billings, 1862; P. obscurus Billings, 1862; and P. beauharnoisensis Billings, 1862), Rusophycus (R. grenvillensis Billings, 1862), and Eophyton (E. jukesi Billings, 1874)). Of these, Saerichnites and Artharia are still considered valid, while Licrophycus (Fig. 2.3B) is now grouped with Phycodes. Many of the species can be incorporated into existing taxa or, as in the case of Eophyton, may represent inorganic structures. Billings’ fossil descriptions indicate that he considered that the fossil remains were those of plants, and not the traces left behind by the activities of an organism. He followed the convention of the day that many of these markings were, in fact, seaweeds.
George Frederic Matthew (1837–1923) Biography The contributions of amateurs have long been a part of the historical development of paleontology and continue to this day. George Frederic Matthew was such an amateur, and growing up in New Brunswick was of significant importance to Matthew’s career because a large percentage of his work as a geologist was focused within a few hundred miles of his hometown. Matthew did not restrict his work to the Maritime Provinces, however, and in working with several individuals was able to study and report on areas such as Sweden and Wales. His unique situation as an amateur geologist created many opportunities for Matthew in some aspects of
21
his career while restricting him in others. Details on the life of George Matthew are summarized from Bailey (1923), Matthew (1924), and Miller (1988). George Frederic Matthew (Fig. 2.4A) was born on August 12, 1837 in St. John, New Brunswick to United Empire Loyalist parents. Matthew attended St. John Grammar School, a one storey Anglican school in South St. John near his home for several years, finishing his formal grammar school education at the age of sixteen. He then entered the work force as a staff member of the St. John Customs Service and after several years of excellent service was appointed chief clerk and surveyor of the St. John port. He remained at this post for the remainder of his working life. Matthew’s early life in St. John had cultivated an interest in geology and botany, which by the age of twenty had intensified sufficiently to encourage him to form the Steinhammer Club (Miller and Buhay, 1988). This small club, which studied the geological formations in and near St. John, lead to the formation of The Natural History Society of New Brunswick in 1862. Matthew immediately became a charter member and the society’s first curator. After the Canadian Confederation in 1867, Matthew’s work in New Brunswick received a huge boost as the Geological Survey of Canada undertook the mapping of the provinces. With the sudden availability of money for geological work, Matthew became a temporary, parttime employee of the Survey, while maintaining his position as chief customs clerk. Several field seasons of work in southern New Brunswick followed, during that time Matthew published a number of regional geology maps and amassed a large collection of paleontological data and specimens. From the early 1880s to the turn of the nineteenth century, Matthew’s work became recognized for its excellence, which led to the bestowment of several awards, memberships, and honorary degrees. These included honorary doctorates from Lava1 University and the University of New Brunswick, as well as, charter memberships in the Royal Society of Canada, the Academy of Sciences, and the Paleontological Society. Awards received included the Murchison Medal from the Royal Geographic Society and the Wollaston Medal from the Geological Society of London. Societies such as The Natural History Society of New Brunswick and the Royal Society of Canada had G.F. Matthew as a chartered member and president for several years in the late 1880s and 1890s. Matthew was quick to utilize his positions as president of these societies and began publishing with regularity in both journals. Several years of publishing in these journals allowed Matthew to amass a total of over 200 articles, as well as
22
2. THE ANTECEDENTS OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
A
B
FIGURE 2.4 (A) George Frederic Matthew 1837–1923 (courtesy Randall Miller, New Brunswick Museum). (B) Specimen of Acripes minor (New Brunswick Museum No. 3030).
to cultivate contacts around the globe (Landing and Miller, 1988). Later in his career, while studying Cambro-Ordivician rocks and their contained insects and trackways, Matthew’s focus became ichnological. The resulting collections formed the basis for several later studies and ultimately the classification of several ichnogenera and ichnospecies by Matthew himself, as well as other scientists using his collected data (Miller, 1996). Despite being a fulltime customs officer and parttime geologist, Matthew was also able to have a full family life. His marriage to Katherine M. Diller in 1868 was the beginning of a family that eventually included six sons and two daughters. The eldest of his sons, William Diller Matthew followed his father’s path in becoming a paleontologist, eventually rising to the post of curator of vertebrate paleontology at the American Museum of Natural History. On April 17, 1923, while preparing a paper to defend one of his proposals, George Frederick Matthew died in Hastings-Hudson, New York at the age of 86. Contributions to Ichnology Ichnology became the focus of Matthew’s interests as a result of the study of insects and trackways in Cambro-Ordivician rocks near St. John, New Brunswick. These studies led to the publication of several articles, which discussed new genera and
species of ichnofossils. George Frederic Matthew’s contributions to the emerging field of ichnology had more impact in vertebrate ichnology, where he erected 9 ichnogenera and 18 ichnospecies including some that are still valid today. This work was more successful than his contributions to invertebrate ichnology, which were often marked by equivocal descriptions and poor illustrations. Much of the original material he described has been reclassified or is now viewed as inorganic. Archaeoscolex Matthew, 1899; Eurypterella Matthew, 1889; Halichondrites Matthew, 1890; Phycoidella Matthew, 1890; and Medusichnites Matthew, 1891 are unrecognizable genera and Bipezia Matthew, 1910 is now considered a junior synonym of Cruziana. Two of the forms that he described are listed in Ha¨ntzschel (1975) as valid ichnogenera: Myriapodites Matthew, 1903 and Acripes Matthew, 1910 (Fig. 2.4B). Debate over the synonymy of Acripes Matthew, 1910 and Diplichnites Dawson, 1873 is ongoing. Detailed review using the principles of significant and accessory features indicates that Acripes Matthew is indeed a junior synonym of Diplichnites Dawson (Miller, 1988, 1996). In describing trace fossils, Matthew meticulously discussed their morphology and attempted to remove animal behavior as a premise for his descriptions. Very early work done by ichnologists was focused on
THE CINCINNATI SCHOOL
the organisms making the trace rather than on the trace itself. Matthew, therefore, was one of the first to use a purely descriptive approach to ichnological taxonomy. This trend is presently employed by ichnologists. He also used the traces in stratigraphic correlation, especially in the Cambrian strata in and around the Maritimes (see Matthew, 1888, 1890, 1891, 1899, 1901). George Frederick Matthew established himself as a quality geologist at a time when science was in fierce competition with the church. Despite working as an amateur throughout his career, he was recognized by professional scientists as a valued contributor to the fields of paleontology and stratigraphy. His significance as an ichnologist can be measured in terms of concrete contributions to the science as well as his recognition of the significance of this emerging field of study.
THE CINCINNATI SCHOOL Cincinnati has long been known to be one of the centers of paleontological excellence in the early nineteenth century (Caster, 1982; Davis, 2001). Many of the early paleontologists became interested in the
A
23
fossils of the area as young people, and a booming amateur fossil collecting community fostered their interests. Many of these young people, such as Charles Schuchert, Ray Bassler, Edward Ulrich, and John Nickles went on to become accomplished professionals and some of the most influential paleontologists in the United States. Still others remained essentially amateurs and did their palaeontological work as a hobby. This group included: David T.D. Dyche, Charles B. Dyer, C. Faber, G.W. Harper, J.F. James, U.P. James, J. Mickleborough, S.A. Miller, and A.G. Wetherby. Of these, Uriah James, Joseph James, and Samuel Miller were pioneers in the fledging science of ichnology and their contributions can be considered as the roots of the science in the United States.
Uriah Pierson James (1811–1889) Biography Uriah Pierson James (Fig. 2.5A) was born on December 30, 1811 in the town of Goshen, Orange County, New York. He died 78 years later, at his home near Loveland, Ohio on February 25, 1889. Details on the life and times of Uriah James are taken from the biography by his son Joseph (James, 1889).
B
FIGURE 2.5 (A) Uriah Pierson James (1811–1889) (after James, 1889). (B) Joseph Francis James 1857–1897 (after Gilbert, 1898).
24
2. THE ANTECEDENTS OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
Uriah was one of the 6 children (3 boys, 3 girls) born to Thomas and Rhoda James. His father, a carpenter, died accidentally in 1824. His mother, Rhoda Pierson, was the daughter of Thomas Pierson and niece of Reverend Abraham Pierson, the first president of Yale College. At the age of 20, Uriah and his brother Joseph left Goshen and traveled west to Cincinnati, Ohio, arriving there in August of 1831. Soon after their arrival Uriah, a printer and stereotyper by trade, set up the U.P. James firm, and began publishing books. In 1847, Uriah and his brother Joseph entered into partnership as publishers, printers, stereotypers, and typefounders. The new firm, J.A. and U.P. James, flourished over the next years. Also in 1847, he married the daughter of an English lady, Olivia Harriet Wood. Together they parented 6 children (3 boys and 3 girls). Unfortunately, one son died in infancy, but Uriah’s other sons survived and continued on their father’s interests. The elder son took over his father’s publishing firm and Joseph, his younger son, continued on with his father’s geological work. Uriah James devoted his leisure time to scientific work. It was not long after his arrival in Cincinnati that he was drawn to the profusion of fossils in the hills surrounding the city. Later in life, Uriah took his son Joseph on these fossil-collecting adventures, and he instilled an early love for geology in his young son. Uriah’s interest in geology never left him and he was collecting fossils up until a few months before his death. After 30 years of fossil collection, James published the first catalog of fossils from the Cincinnati area. Over those years of collection, Uriah amassed an unrivaled collection of fossils from the neighborhood of Cincinnati. During a visit to Cincinnati in 1845 by Charles Lyell, Uriah James was among the distinguished few that guided Lyell through the familiar hills surrounding Cincinnati. Uriah James published 23 articles between 1871 and 1888, and although his writings were merely descriptive, they were complete and accurate. Being the owner of a publishing firm had its advantages. Uriah was able to publish many catalogs of his work, some of which were compiled by committees from the Western Academy of Natural Sciences. He was also able to create a small periodical in 1878 that he called ‘The Paleontologist.’ This periodical contained 7 issues and was distributed to libraries, societies, and correspondents, or could be bought for a hefty 25¢ each. Uriah James was a life member, long-time treasurer, and one-time president, of the Western Academy of Natural Sciences, predecessor to the Cincinnati Society of Natural History. James was also a member
of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, in the early days of the association. Contributions to Ichnology Probably the greatest contribution Uriah James made to the study of ichnology was being the father of and early influence on his son Joseph James. Joseph carried on his father’s geological work with his primary contributions to ichnology involving the re-identification of many fossils to their correct origin and thereby, was able to help clean up the taxonomic nomenclature. Uriah himself described about 130 species of fossils during his 17 years of publications. Many of these species were shells or corals, while others belonged to the genus Fucoides. It was described as being a genus to unite all of the fossils that appeared to have belonged to the family of non-articulate Algae. As a consequence, the ‘genus’ was used as a dumping ground for more than 200 species and sub-genera of obscure or indeterminable origin. Authors were delighted that a new genus had been formed in which they could place innumerable specimens they felt were not of animal but, perhaps vegetable origin. Uriah James was one of these many early paleontologists who misinterpreted the origins of certain Fucoides. Although Uriah James mis-identified a few trace fossils as plants, their original recognition is rightly attributed to him. Thus, Uriah James was able to contribute to ichnology through the recognition of at least 2 ichnogenera: Lockeia James, 1879 and possibly Saccophycus James, 1879, and 3 ichnospecies (Buthotrephis filoiformis James, 1878; Palaeophycus flexuous James, 1879; and Scolithus delicatulus James, 1881). In these publications, Uriah James followed the convention of the day and described these traces as fucoids or plant fossils. Later, James (1883) described tracks that he interpreted to be constructed by crustaceans. His greatest contribution to ichnology would not, however, be in the identification of fossils. Rather it would be his son, Joseph Francis James, who helped to re-identify the origins of many Fucoides, some of which were ichnofossils. Uriah’s love for geology influenced Joseph at a young age and guided him to a life’s work in botany, paleontology, geology, and ichnology.
Joseph Francis James (1857–1897) Biography Joseph Francis James (Fig. 2.5B), the youngest son of Uriah James, was born in Cincinnati, Ohio on
THE CINCINNATI SCHOOL
February 9, 1857. Details on his life are based on the biographical accounts of Gilbert (1898) and Stanton (1898). Joseph’s interest in the natural sciences stemmed from his father, and from an early age he collected living plant specimens and fossils from the region. By the time he was 16, Joseph had already assembled a manual of the flora in and around his hometown of Cincinnati. In 1879, at the age of 22, Joseph moved to Los Angeles, California to establish a business and settle down. The business venture failed, however, due to a tragic fire. He then went to work with a railroad construction crew, traveling through southern California, Arizona, and New Mexico. Two years after having moved to California, he returned to Cincinnati. There, he was appointed custodian of the Cincinnati Society of Natural History while serving concurrently as Professor of Medical Botany at the Cincinnati College of Pharmacy. His works during this period were predominantly botanical, but soon his scientific endeavors began to sway toward paleontology. By the time he was 27, he began publishing on the paleontology and geology of the Ordovician- and Silurian-aged rocks of the Cincinnati Group in Ohio. During this period, he married Miss Sarah C. Stubbs, a high school physiology and botany teacher with whom he raised 2 sons. In 1886, Joseph became the chairman of Botany and Geology at Miami University in Oxford, Ohio. After only 2 years, his position was terminated due to his religious inclinations conflicting with other faculty members’ beliefs. He was unfairly accused by his colleagues of being an agnostic, and in his defense, claimed to be a Unitarian. After this, he received a professorship and taught Natural Science at the Agriculture College of Maryland. He moved from there to work as an assistant paleontologist at the United States Geological Survey division for Paleozoic paleontology. Both of these jobs were disappointments to him because of the routine nature of the work, and the opportunities for publication that he had anticipated did not materialize. In 1889, James received an appointment as an assistant vegetable pathologist for the United States Department of Agriculture. He received little gratification from this job as well, and while working there, he devoted his leisure time to the study of medicine. In 1895, he graduated from the Medical School of Columbia University, subsequently accepting work in hospitals in New York and London in the field of bacteriology. In 1896, he opened a practice in Hingham, Massachusetts. Only a few months after having moved there, he died from a severe case of
25
pneumonia, contracted during the course of his work on March 29, 1897. Contributions to Ichnology Joseph James’ earliest studies were in the field of botany, and he first assembled a catalog of the flora of the Cincinnati area when he was 16. This was subsequently published in the Journal of the Cincinnati Society of Natural History in 1879. In 1882, James wrote a memorandum to Charles Darwin a few weeks after his death. Darwin’s Origin of Species was published on November 24, 1859, 2 years after Joseph was born. Darwin was an idol of James,’ which can be attested to in his own words: ‘In the hands of Mr. Darwin, order is brought out of chaos, and what would under other circumstances be a mere jumble, is through the medium of his pen a work of lasting value’ (James, 1882, p. 74). James wrote on a diversity of topics in botany, geology, paleontology, ichnology, and stratigraphy. In paleontology, he dealt with mainly fucoids and other problematic organisms, but also sponges, algae, protozoa, cephalopods, corals, Polyzoa (Bryozoa), and fish. In his lifetime, he published over 200 scientific and popular scientific articles (Gilbert, 1898; Stanton, 1898). James was one of the first scientists to make an attempt to bring some order to the undeveloped field of ichnology. In his research, he was patient and competent and dealt mainly with details of description and classification. He tended to re-evaluate and bring some order to problematic species that were poorly understood at the time. His main contribution to the field of ichnology was on the interpretation of fucoids, and he was one of the primary opponents to their plant origins. James concluded that the three main sources for fucoids were: inorganic structures and residues; trails and burrows of organisms; and hydozoa (James, 1885a). Much of his work involved discarding many problematic species names, especially those of Fucoides. He chose to discard many of the old species and lump them together under pre-existing taxa. In many cases, his critical work did not bring favor to his reputation, as he attacked many of the top scientists of the time in the literature. He was skeptical of the organic nature of many problematical specimens attributed to Fucoides (Fig. 2.6B). As a result of his botanical background and critical nature, he was able to assign many of these species to processes other than plants (James, 1884, 1885a,b,c,d, 1890, 1891, 1892a,b, 1893a,b, 1894, 1895a,b).
26
2. THE ANTECEDENTS OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
A
B
FIGURE 2.6 (A) Title page of the James (1892a) paper that revised the systematics of Scolithus (= Skolithos). (B) Title page of the James (1893a) paper that revised the systematics of Fucoides.
James contributed to the sorting out of the ichnogenus Skolithos (which he referred to as Scolithus). Although first recognized as having an annelid burrow character by Logan (1852), most authors considered it a fossil plant. James reviewed all of the known species of Skolithos, and attributed their formation to worm burrows (Fig. 2.6A). For a breakdown of his work, refer to the section on his contributions to ichnological taxonomy below. He noted that it was next to impossible to separate many species of differing ages of Skolithos from one another. Even still, he proposed, ‘that the geological position shall decide the name to be used’ (James, 1892a, p. 43). J.F. James’ contributions to ichnology were mainly in his meticulous and thorough classification, description, and organization of problematic genera and species. He could be considered the first ichnological taxonomist. He was not the most creative of scientists, and did not contribute much to the naming of ichnotaxa, but rather chose to discard taxa and classify them properly. James viewpoint is typified by what he wrote in 1885, where he stated: ‘It is indeed time that this habit of referring to some sort of life for every mark found in the
rocks of the earth, and calling all uncertain marks marine plants, should be protested against. If it is not done the nomenclature of the science will be so encumbered with useless names that chaos will result. The multiplication of species has gone entirely too far already; and when every mark made by a dash of water, every turn made by a worm or shell, and every print left by the claw of a crustacean is described as a new addition to science, it is time to call a halt and eliminate some of the old before making any more new species’ (James, 1885b, p. 167).
Samuel Almond Miller (1837–1897) Biography Samuel Almond Miller (Fig. 2.7A) was born on August 28, 1837, in the community of Coolville, Ohio. Unfortunately, the only biographies of this notable amateur palaeontologist are two very brief obituaries written at his death in 1897 (Bather, 1898; Billings, 1898), and little is known about his youth or how he acquired his deep interest in geology and paleontology. We do know, however, that he
THE CINCINNATI SCHOOL
A
27
B
FIGURE 2.7 (A) Samuel Almond Miller (1837–1897) (Front piece from Volume 1 of the Cincinnati Quarterly Journal of Science). (B) Plate 1 from Miller and Dyer (1878a), trace fossils include Blastophycus diadematus (Figs. 1 and 2); Trichophycus lanosus (Figs. 3 and 4); and Rusophycus asper (Figs. 5 and 5a).
went to the Ohio University where he graduated with a degree in Arts, Law and Philosophy, and that this institution later conferred an honorary Ph.D. on Miller, in 1893. Samuel A. Miller was not only the owner of a respected and busy law firm, but was also actively involved in local politics and, for a time, edited a weekly newspaper. However, Miller became interested in the field of paleontology and ultimately in ichnology, and it is remarkable that despite all his other interests, he published more work than many professional palaeontologists of the time (Billings, 1898). In addition to his own voluminous work, Miller also managed to find the time to edit the Journal of the Cincinnati Society of Natural History (of which he was a founding member) and to edit and publish the brieflived (1874–1875) Cincinnati Quarterly Journal of Science. Much of his work was published in these two periodicals. Perhaps Miller’s greatest overall contributions are his two books, American Paleozoic Fossils (Miller, 1877) and the more comprehensive North American Geology and Paleontology (Miller, 1889). Both of these were regarded as indispensable volumes with regard to the study of Paleozoic strata in North America. According to Billings (1898), the latter work
(including the two appendices) constituted 793 pages, with 1457 illustrations, totaling about 3000 figures. Caster (1982) indicated that this volume ‘was probably the most used volume on American paleontology ever compiled, and it certainly was the most ambitious private publication in the discipline.’ (Caster, 1982, p. 25). That such a monumental work was accomplished while maintaining a business and a political career, and while doing other geological work on behalf of five states (Ohio, Illinois, Missouri, Indiana, and Wisconsin) is a credit to Miller’s energy and dedication. It is interesting to speculate upon what more he may have accomplished in his life had cancer of the liver not taken him on December 18, 1897. Contributions to Ichnology Most of Miller’s ichnological contributions are concentrated in three articles, one entirely on trace fossils (Miller, 1880) and two others describing ‘fucoids,’ as well as body fossils, in collaboration with a local collector and fellow amateur, C.B. Dyer (Miller and Dyer, 1878a,b). Miller and Dyer (1878a,b) described 8 new genera and 13 new species of ‘fucoids’; they considered the majority of these to be plant fossils in the classical
28
2. THE ANTECEDENTS OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
fucoid manner (Fig. 2.7B). They did, however, describe Scolithus [sic] tuberosus and interpreted it as a burrow by analogy with burrows of crayfish seen in local streams, and not a plant. Miller (1880) perhaps stands out as his most significant contribution to the science of ichnology, as it was the first truly ichnological article published by what became the influential ‘Cincinnati School’ of ichnologists. He erected 6 ichnogenera and 8 ichnospecies, which included speculations on possible tracemakers. All six ichnogenera are still considered valid (Petalichnus, Ormathichnus, Teratichnus, Asaphoidichnus, Trachomatichnus, and Plangtichnus). They are all, however, probable arthropod trackways and likely subjects for reassessment, as part of the major overhaul of trackway nomenclature called for by many researchers. It is important to emphasize, however, that Miller was not truly breaking away from the fucoid tradition with this article; all the traces described are trackways (or inorganic structures misidentified as trackways (Osgood, 1970)), and were obviously nothing like ‘fucoids.’ Indeed, Miller (1889) listed all his and other Cincinnati workers’ ‘fucoids’ as such, despite the work of James (1884, 1885a), which exposed almost all Cincinnatian ‘fucoids’ as trace fossils or inorganic structures. However, Miller (1889) did mention that there was controversy regarding the nature of ‘fucoids.’ The quality of Miller’s work is also worthy of mention. Although an amateur, Miller’s articles were very well written, with excellent descriptions and detailed illustrations. Osgood (1970) remarked on this characteristic of Miller’s work, indicating that despite Miller’s ‘fucoid’ interpretations, his morphological descriptions were very accurate and made restudy of Miller’s contributions much easier. As one of the earlier researchers identified with the Cincinnati School, it seems fair to assume that the high quality of Miller’s work, to some extent, inspired the high quality of the work accomplished by later adherents of that notable body.
CONCLUSIONS The development of ichnology in North America radiated from two independent centers: the Canadian School of professional geologists, generally associated with the Geological Survey of Canada, and the Cincinnati School consisting generally of amateur paleontologists. Both schools had considerable impact and worked somewhat in isolation from active European centers in Germany,
France, and England. This isolation could be viewed in a negative light, but it also freed the investigators from the preconceived ideas that were prevalent in Europe. It left them free to explain these obscure structures they saw fit. Although the fucoid interpretation was prevalent in the works of Elkanah Billings, Samuel Miller, and Uriah James, others like William Logan, J. William Dawson, and Joseph James were quick to dismiss that interpretation and considered alternative options. This resulted in some very insightful interpretations, such as Dawson (1864) correctly exposing Rusophycus, one of Europe’s most sacred of all fucoids, as a product of the burrowing activities of trilobites. This interpretation predates the European view by almost 15 years. Convinced of the animal origin of Rusophycus, Dawson ventured on to reinterpret other forms. In an 1873 article on trace fossils in Carboniferous strata of Nova Scotia, he concluded: ‘I have long been of opinion that many of the cylindrical markings which have been described as plants under the names Palaeochorda, Buthotrephis, Palaeophycus, Arthrophycus, etc., are burrows of this kind, but the main difficulty seemed to be to account for their branching in a radiate or palmate manner. I have recently met with specimens from the Primordial and Carboniferous which seem to explain this. They show a central hole or burrow from which the animal seems to have stretched and withdrawn its body in different directions, so as to give an appearance of branching and radiation, possibly due merely to the excursions of the same worm from the mouth of its burrow’ (Dawson, 1873, p. 19). Dawson (1862b) also conducted neoichnological studies on modern Limulus and compared its activities to the ichnogenus Protichnites, a trace discovered by Logan (1852) and named by Owen (1852). Likewise, Logan (1860) correctly interpreted Climactichnites as the locomotion trail of an invertebrate and not a fucoid. Additional work on interpreted arthropod trackways by Dawson (1873), Miller (1880), and Matthew (1903, 1910) all recognized that the trackways were the product of animals, and they speculated on possible track makers as well. Osgood (1970) pointed out that James (1884, 1885a), working independently and in ignorance of Nathorst, arrived at and utilized many of the same criteria that Nathorst used to criticize the fucoid origins of many trace fossils. With his restudy of the systematics of Fucoides, Skolithos, and Arthrophycus, Joseph James (1892a, 1893a,b) brought to light many of the taxonomical nightmares that faced the fledging science (and some are still facing it today) and can rightfully be considered the first ichnotaxonomist.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We would like to thank Dr. Randall Miller of the New Brunswick Museum for supplying photographs of Matthew. We are also indebted to the Geological Survey of Canada and the Public Archives of Canada for supplying copies of photographs in their collection. The senior author would like to thank the Canada Research Chair Program for support of his research. The Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada provided funding for this research. Finally, we would like to thank Dr. Gerhard Cade´e and Dr. Tony Martin for their excellent and through reviews of this manuscript.
References Adams, F.D. (1899). Memoir of Sir J. William Dawson. Bulletin Geological Society of America, 11, 550–580. Ami, H.M. (1900). Sir John William Dawson. American Geologist, 26, 1–46. Ami, H.M. (1901). A brief biographical sketch of Elkanah Billings. American Geologist, 27, 265–281. Bailey, L.W. (1923). George Frederick Matthew. Proceedings and Transactions Royal Society of Canada, Third Series, 17, 7–10. Bather, F.A. (1898). Obituary: Samuel A. Miller. Geological Magazine, 35, 192. Billings, E. (1861a). On some new or little-known species of Lower Silurian fossils from the Potsdam Group (Primordial Group). Paleozoic Fossils, Volume 1, Canadian Geological Survey, pp. 1–24. Billings, E. (1861b). On some new or little-known species of Lower Silurian fossils from the Potsdam Group. Hitchcock, E. (Ed.), Report on the Geology of Vermont, Volume 2, pp. 942–960. Billings, E. (1862). New species of fossils from different parts of the Lower, Middle, and Upper Silurian rocks of Canada. Paleozoic Fossils, Volume 1, Canadian Geological Survey, pp. 96–168. Billings, E. (1866). Catalog of the Silurian fossils of the Island of Anticosti with descriptions of some new genera and species: Canada. Canadian Geological Survey Publication, 427, pp. 1–93. Billings, E. (1872). On some fossils from the primordial rocks of Newfoundland. Canadian Naturalist, new series, 6, 465–479. Billings, E. (1874). Paleozoic Fossils, Volume 2, Canada, Geological Survey, 144. Billings, W.R. (1898). Death of a distinguished American amateur geologist and palaeontologist – S.A. Miller. Ottawa Naturalist, 11, 208. Brongniart, A.T. (1823). Observations sur les Fucoides. Socie´te´ d’Historie naturelle de Paris, Me´moire, 1, 301–320. Caster, K.E. (1957). Problematica annotated bibliography. In: Ladd, H.S. (Ed.), Paleoecology, Geological Society of America, Memoir, 67, pp. 1025–1032.
29
Caster, K.E. (1982). The Cincinnati School of Paleontology. Earth Science History, 1, 23–28. Clark, T.H. (1971). Elkanah Billings (1820–1876) – Canada’s first paleontologist. Proceeding of the Geological Association of Canada, 23, 11–14. Clark, T.H. (1972). Sir John William Dawson (1829–1899) – Palaeontologist. Proceedings of the Geological Association of Canada, 24, 1–4. Darwin, C. (1881). The Formation of Vegetable Mould, Through the Action of Worms, John Murray, London. Davis, R.A. (2001). Science In The Hinterland: ‘The Cincinnati School of Paleontology.’ Geological Society of American Abstracts With Program, 33, 59. Dawson, J.W. (1862a). Notice on the discovery of additional remains of land animals in the coal-measures of the SouthJoggins, Nova Scotia. Geological Society of London, Quarterly Journal, 18, 5–7. Dawson, J.W. (1862b). On the footprints of Limulus as compared with the Protichnites of the Potsdam sandstone. Canadian Naturalist and Geologist, 7, 271–277. Dawson, J.W. (1864). On the fossils of the genus Rusophycus: Canadian Naturalist and Geologist, New series, 1, 363–367. Dawson, J.W. (1865). On the structure of certain organic remains in the Laurentian limestones of Canada. Geological Society of London, Quarterly Journal, 21, 51–59. Dawson, J.W. (1866). Note on supposed burrows of worms in the Laurentian rocks of Canada. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London, 22, 608–609. Dawson, J.W. (1868). Acadian Geology, 2nd edition. Macmillan & Co., London. Dawson, J.W. (1873). Impressions and footprints of aquatic animals and imitative marking of Carboniferous rocks. American Journal of Science, Third series, 5, 16–24. Dawson, J.W. (1875). The Dawn of Life, Dawson Brothers. Publishers, Montreal. Dawson, J.W. (1878). Supplement to the 2nd Edition of Acadian Geology. In: Acadian Geology, 3rd edition. Macmillan & Co., London. Dawson, J.W. (1888). The Geological History of Plants, D. Appleton & Co. New York. Dawson, J.W. (1890). On burrows and tracks of invertebrate animals in Paleozoic rocks, and other markings. Geological Society of London, Quarterly Journal, 46, 595–617. Gilbert, G.K. (1898). Joseph Francis James 1857–1897. American Geologist, 21, 1–11. Ha¨ntzschel, W. (1975). Trace fossils and problematica, In :Teichert, C. (Ed.), Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, 2nd edition. Pt. W, Miscellanea, Supplement 1, Geological Society of America and University of Kansas, Lawrence. Harrington, B.J. (1883).The Life of Sir William E. Logan, Dawson Brothers Publishers, Montreal. Hofmann, H.J. (1971). Precambrian fossils, pseudofossils, and problematica in canada. Geological Survey of Canada Bulletin, 189, 18–22. Hofmann, H.J. (1982). J.W. Dawson and nineteenth century Precambrian paleontology. Proceedings of the Third North American Palaeontological Convention, 1, 243–249. James, J.F. (1882). Charles Robert Darwin. Journal of the Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 5, 71–77. James, J.F. (1884). The Fucoids of the Cincinnati Group, Part 1. Journal Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 7, 124–132.
30
2. THE ANTECEDENTS OF INVERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
James, J.F. (1885a). The Fucoids of the Cincinnati Group, Part 2. Journal Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 7, 151–166. James, J.F. (1885b). Are there any fossil algae? American Naturalist, 19, 165–167. James, J.F. (1885c). On the tracks of insects resembling the impressions of plants. [Translated from the French of M.R. Zeiller.] Journal Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 8, 49–52. James, J.F. (1885d). Remarks on some markings on the rocks of the Cincinnati Group described under the names of Ormathichnus and Walcottia. Journal Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 8, 160–163. James, J.F. (1889). Uriah Pierson James. American Geologist, 1889, 1–7. James, J.F. (1890). Fucoids and other problematic organisms. American Naturalist, 24, 1222. James, J.F. (1891). The manual of paleontology of the Cincinnatin Group. Part 1. Journal Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 14, 45–72, 149–163; 15, 1892–1893, pp. 88–100, 144–159; 16, 1894, pp. 178–208; 18, 1895–1896, pp. 67–88, 115–140; 19, 1897, pp. 99–118. James, J.F. (1892a). Studies in problematic organisms. The genus Skolithus. Bulletin Geological Society of America, 3, 32–44. James, J.F. (1892b). The preservation of plants as fossils. Journal Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 15, 75–78. James, J.F. (1893a). Studies in problematic organisms. Number 2. The genus Fucoides. Journal Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 16, 62–81. James, J.F. (1893b). Remarks on the genus Arthrophycus Hall. Journal Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 16, 82–86. James, J.F. (1894). On the value of supposed algae as geological guides. American Geologist, 13, 95–101. James, J.F. (1895a). Daimonelix, and allied fossil (Abstract of paper read before Biological Society of Washington). Science, New series, 1, 420. James, J.F. (1895b). Remarks on Daimonelix, or ‘Devil’s Corkscrew’ and allied fossils. American Geologist, 15, 337–342. James, U.P. (1878). Descriptions of newly discovered species of fossils and remarks on others, from the Lower and Upper Silurian rocks of Ohio. The Paleontologist, 2, 9–16. James, U.P. (1879). Description of new species of fossils and remarks on some others, from the Lower and Upper Silurian rocks of Ohio. The Paleontologist, 3, 17–24. James, U.P. (1881). Contributions to paleontology: fossils of the Lower Silurian Formation: Ohio, Indiana and Kentucky. The Paleontologist, 5, 33–44. James, U.P. (1883). Descriptions of new species of fossils from the Cincinnati Group, Ohio and Kentucky. The Paleontologist, 7, 57–60. Landing, E. and Miller, R.F. (1988). Bibliography of George Frederick Matthew. In: Landing, E., Narbonne, G.M. and Myrow, P. (Eds.), Trace Fossils, Small Shelly Fossils and the Precambrian–Cambrian Boundary Proceedings, New York State Museum Bulletin, 463, pp. 4–7. Logan, W.E. (1842). Canadian Carboniferous footprints. Proceedings of the Geological Society of London, 3, 707. Logan, W.E. (1851). On the occurrence of a track and foot-prints of an animal in the Potsdam Sandstone of Lower Canada. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 7, 247–252. Logan, W.E. (1852). On the foot-prints occurring in the Potsdam Sandstone of Canada. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 8, 199–213.
Logan, W.E. (1858). On the Laurentian limestones. Canadian Naturalist and Geologist, 4, 300–301. Logan, W.E. (1860). On the track of an animal lately found in the Potsdam formation. American Journal of Science, Second series, 31, 17–23. Matthew, G.F. (1888). On Psammichnites and the early trilobites of the Cambrian rocks in eastern Canada. American Geologist, 2, 1–9. Matthew, G.F. (1889). On some remarkable organisms of the Silurian and Devonian rocks of New Brunswick. Royal Society of Canada, Proceedings and Transactions, 6, 49–62. Matthew, G.F. (1890). On Cambrian organisms in Acadia. Royal Society of Canada, Proceedings and Transactions, 7, 135–162. Matthew, G.F. (1891). Illustrations of the fauna of the St. John Group, no. V. Royal Society of Canada, Proceedings and Transactions, 8, 123–166. Matthew, G.F. (1899). Studies on Cambrian faunas, no. 4. Fragments of the Cambrian faunas of Newfoundland. Royal Society of Canada, Proceedings and Transactions, 5, 97–119. Matthew, G.F. (1901). Monocraterion and Oldhamia. The Irish Naturalist, 10, 135–136. Matthew, G.F. (1903). On batrachian footprints and other footprints from the coal measures of Joggins, Nova Scotia. Bulletin Natural History Society of New Brunswick, 5, 103–108. Matthew, G.F. (1910). Remarkable forms of the Little River Group. Royal Society of Canada, Proceedings and Transactions, Third series, 3, 115–125. Matthew, W.D. (1924). Memorial to George F. Matthew. Bulletin of the Geological Society of America, 35, 181–182. Miller, R.F. (1988). George Frederick Matthew (1837–1923). In: Landing, E., Narbonne, G.M. and Myrow, P. (Eds.), Trace Fossils, Small Shelly Fossils and the Precambrian–Cambrian Boundary Proceedings, New York State Museum Bulletin, 463, pp. 4–7. Miller, R.F. (1996). Location of trace fossils and problematica of George Frederick Matthew from Part W, treatise on invertebrate paleontology. Journal of Paleontology, 70, 169–171. Miller, R.F. and Buhay, D.N. (1988). The Steinhammer Club: geology and a foundation for a natural history society in New Brunswick. Geoscience Canada, 15, 221–226. Miller, S.A. (1877).The American Paleozoic Fossils, A Catalog of the Genera and Species, Published by the author, Cincinnati, 253 pp. Miller, S.A. (1880). Silurian ichnolites, with definitions of new genera and species. Journal of the Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 2, 217–229. Miller, S.A. (1889). North American Geology and Paleontology for the Use of Amateurs, Students and Scientists, Western Methodist Book Concern, Cincinnati, Ohio. Miller, S.A. and Dyer, C.B. (1878a). Contributions to Paleontology, no. 1. Journal of the Cincinnati Society of Natural History, 1, 24–39. Miller, S.A. and Dyer, C.B. (1878b). no. 2. Contributions to Paleontology, Published by the authors, Cincinnati, pp. 1–11. ¨ versigt af Nathorst, A.G. (1873). Om na˚gra fo¨rmodade va¨xtfossilier. O Vetenskapsakademien–Akademie Fo¨rhandlingar, Stockholm, 1873, 25–32. Nathorst, A.G. (1881). Om spa˚r af nagra evertebrerade djur m. och deras palaeontologiska betydelse. K. Svenska Vetenskapsakademien Handlingar, 18, 1–104. O’Brien, C.F. (1971). Sir William Dawson-A life in Science and Religion, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia, Memoir, 84. Osgood, R.G. (1970). Trace fossils of the Cincinnati area. Paleontographica Americana, 6, 281–444.
REFERENCES
Osgood, R.G. (1975). The history of invertebrate ichnology. In: Frey, R.W. (Ed.), The Study of Trace Fossils, Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 3–12. Owen, R. (1852). Description of the impressions and foot-prints of the Protichnites from the Potsdam Sandstone of Canada. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 8, 214–225. Pemberton, S.G. and Frey, R.W. (1991). J.W. Dawson and the interpretation of Rusophycus. Ichnos, 1, 237–242. Seilacher, A. (1995). Fossile Kunst: Albumbatter der Erdgeschichte, Goldschneck-Verlag, Korb, Germany. Stanton, T.W. (1898). Memoir of Joseph Francis James. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 9, 408–412.
31
Walker, B.E. (1901). List of the published writings of Elkanah Billings, F.R.S., Paleontologist to the Geological Survey of Canada, 1856–1876. Canadian Record of Science, 8, 366–388. Whiteaves, J.F. (1877). Obituary notice of Elkanah Billings, F.G.S. Canadian Naturalist, 8, 251–261. Winder, C.G. (1972). Sir William Edmond Logan (1798–1875) – founder of Canadian geology. Proceedings of the Geological Association of Canada, 24, 39–41. Winder, C.G. (2004). William Edmond Logan (1798–1875) Knighted Canadian Geologist, Trafford Publishing, Victoria, British Columbia.
C
H
A
P
T
E
R
3 Edward Hitchcock and Roland Bird: Two Early Titans of Vertebrate Ichnology in North America S. George Pemberton, Murray K. Gingras, and James A. MacEachern
INTRODUCTION
SUMMARY : Vertebrate ichnology in North America has a long and distinguished history, starting with the remarkable discoveries by Edward Hitchcock of dinosaur footprints and trackways from the Connecticut River Valley. Hitchcock assembled a unique collection that is currently housed in the Pratt Museum, Amherst College, and his work essentially constituted the beginnings of ichnology as a viable sub-discipline of paleontology. Although his original interpretation that these Late Triassic repichnia were bird tracks was incorrect, he indirectly linked birds and dinosaurs. In the southwest, the gifted American Museum of Natural History collector Roland T. Bird discovered the first sauropod tracks from Cretaceous strata near Glen Rose, Texas. These tracks gave paleontologists a means of assessing the behavior of sauropods, compared to the inaccuracies of preconceived popular conception, and fledgling skeletal reconstructions. The observations of trackways, recording the activity of the organisms while they were alive, ultimately led to the recognition that sauropods actually walked on land and could support their weight rather than requiring water to buoy them, possessed an upright posture with limbs directly beneath them, held their tails above the ground rather than dragging them, and that some forms had adopted herd behavior.
Vertebrate ichnology has a long and distinguished history, going back to the 1828 discovery of footprints in the Permian of Scotland by Henry Duncan (see Pemberton et al., 1996; Pemberton and Gingras, 2003). In North America, vertebrate ichnology was embraced as a viable sub-discipline of paleontology, because of a number of spectacular finds. Included in this group are: (a) the abundant track sites associated with the Upper Triassic Newark Group in the Connecticut Valley, first described by Hitchcock (1836a); (b) the first traces ever observed of land animals in the Carboniferous of Nova Scotia, first described by Logan (1842); (c) the large spiral burrow Daimonhelix (Devil’s Corkscrew) from the Miocene of Nebraska, first described by Barbour (1892); (d) the abundant dinosaur trackway sites associated with the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation in the Western United States, first described by Marsh (1899); (e) the tracks, including probable ankylosaur trackways in the Peace River Valley of Alberta
Copyright ß 2007, Elsevier B.V. Trace Fossils: Concepts, Problems, Prospects
32
All rights reserved.
THE ICHNOLOGY OF THE CONNECTICUT VALLEY
and British Columbia, first reported by Sternberg (1932); (f) the impressive sauropod tracks and trackways in Cretaceous strata near Glen Rose, Texas first described in detail by Bird (1939b); and (g) the well-preserved Chirotherium from the Lower to Middle Triassic Moenkopi Formation of northeastern Arizona first described by Peabody (1948). Of these, the work associated with the Connecticut Valley and the Glen Rose Texas site are particularly noteworthy, and illustrate the central role that North American investigators have played in the development of vertebrate ichnology. This tradition of excellence continues today, as illustrated by the landmark research of investigators in both the United States (Martin Lockley, James Farlow, and Paul Olsen; to name just a few), and Canada (the late Bill Sarjeant, Phil Currie, and Richard McCrea). For a more formal history of vertebrate ichnology see Sarjeant (1975).
THE ICHNOLOGY OF THE CONNECTICUT VALLEY The Newark Supergroup consists of a series of 13 large basins that extends from Nova Scotia to South Carolina. Two of these basins comprise the present day Connecticut Valley: the Deerfield basin in the northern Valley, and the Hartford basin constituting the remainder (Olsen et al., 1996). In the Early Mesozoic, these basins were filled with sediments and formed temporary playa lakes. These lakes, in turn, provided a rich environment for the recording of tracks and traces along their shores. In fact, the richest assemblage of trace fossils in the world can be found at sites in the Connecticut Valley of Massachusetts. Hundreds of fish fossils have been recovered from the gray shales in Sunderland and Turner’s Falls, Massachusetts (Olsen and Rainforth, 2002). Ironically, only a few body fossils of the land-dwelling trackmakers have been found to date (e.g., several prosauropods in Connecticut and southern Massachusetts). The tracks were the subject of considerable study, primarily by Edward Hitchcock, Professor at Amherst College. Collecting, studying, and interpreting the fossil tracks became his primary scientific passion for the last 30 years of his life. The early history of research on the Connecticut Valley footprints has been covered in an excellent article by Steinbock (1989). The dedicated
33
amateurs James Deane and John Warren conducted additional work on the tracks. Deane, in particular, was involved in one of the more interesting aspects of this period of study. Vertebrate paleontology in North America has generated some of the most intense rivalries in science, including the Cope–Marsh ‘Bone War’ and the Brown–Sternberg rivalry. Vertebrate ichnology is no exception, and Edward Hitchcock and James Deane ultimately engaged in a bitter dispute over who was the first discoverer of the Connecticut Valley tracks.
Dramatis Personae Edward Hitchcock (1793–1864): Edward Hitchcock (Fig. 3.1A) was a man for all seasons: clergyman (pastor in Conway), teacher (Deerfield Academy and Amherst College), scientist (who executed the first comprehensive state survey in the United States; that of Massachusetts from 1830 to 1833), and administrator (principal of Deerfield Academy, president of Amherst College). He was a prolific author, publishing 26 books, 94 scientific papers, 35 pamphlets, and 80 newspaper articles, comprising a total of 8453 pages, with 256 plates and 1134 woodcuts and included in his published works are a tragedy (Merrill, 1906, p. 152) and a poem (Marche´, 1991). His textbook on geology (Hitchcock, 1840) was widely read and passed through some 30 editions. Details on the life of Edward Hitchcock have been gathered from Lesley (1877), Hitchcock (1895), Foose and Lancaster (1981), and Belt (1989). Hitchcock was born in Deerfield, Massachusetts on May 24, 1793, the youngest of five children born to Justin and Mercy Hitchcock. His father, a hatter by trade, was of modest means and Edward worked his way through Deerfield Academy. In 1811, his observations on a comet marked the beginning of his fascination with science, but his poor eyesight ended any hopes that he had for being an astronomer (Marche´, 1993). Hitchcock then became a teacher at Deerfield Academy from 1815 till 1819. During this time, he met Amos Eaton, the New York geologist, and Benjamin Silliman from Yale, both of them were instrumental in turning his attention towards natural history. Yale offered him an honorary Master of Arts degree in 1818, and he studied theology there in 1820. Following graduation, he served as a pastor in Conway, Massachusetts from June 1821 to October 1825. His interest in science, however, did not wane and he found himself in a position to accept a position at Amherst College. From 1825 until 1845 he was Professor
34
3. EDWARD HITCHCOCK AND ROLAND BIRD: TWO EARLY TITANS OF VERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
A
B FIGURE 3.1 (A) Edward Hitchcock (1793–1864), geologist, clergyman, poet, teacher, administrator, poet, and ichnologist (courtesy of Amherst College Archives). (B) Hind foot prints of Anomoepus major, Specimen 1/7, Amherst Collection (courtesy of Amherst College).
of Chemistry and Natural History. In 1844, Hitchcock was made president of Amherst College and was ultimately considered one of Amherst’s greatest presidents. During his tenure from 1844 to 1854, he raised intellectual standards, doubled the number of students, and saved the college from impending bankruptcy. He also taught natural theology and geology from 1845 until his death in 1864. Hitchcock was one of the foremost proponents of Natural Theology and, like William Dawson in Canada; he saw no conflict between Christianity and a long Earth history. He held an endowed chair (endowed by a local merchant, also named Hitchcock) that he named the Professorship in Natural Theology and Geology, to instruct in both geology and theology in their connected form. Unfortunately, a successor could not be found and within a decade, the chair reverted only to geology (Foose and Lancaster, 1981). Although he was a catastrophist and believed in the Noachian Flood, he admired the more scientific uniformitarian approach expounded by Lyell (Foose and Lancaster, 1981). At the beginning of his career, Hitchcock felt that all scientific truth was revealed in the Bible. By the close of his career, however, he conceded that the Bible was a popular account, not a scientific one, and no correlation existed between the
Scripture and science (Guralnick, 1972; Foose and Lancaster, 1981). Hitchcock was also anti-Darwinian and remained so for the rest of his life (Lawrence, 1972). On June 13, 1821, Edward Hitchcock married Orra White, the daughter of a prosperous Amherst farmer. They had eight children, six of whom lived past infancy. Two sons, Edward Jr. and Charles, became geologists, with Charles rising to the positions of state geologist for Vermont, Maine, and New Hampshire. Orra White was an accomplished artist and illustrated some of Edward Hitchcock’s earliest geological papers and reports. She also created oversize paintings for use in her husband’s classes (Aldrich and Leviton, 2001). At a time when women generally did not study science, the Hitchcocks encouraged the inclusion of science in the curriculum of the all-female school founded by Mary Lyon, which eventually became Mount Holyoke College. Hitchcock was instrumental in trying to organize geologists and other scientists and bring them together to confer and compare results. In 1840, he co-founded the American Association of Geologists, which met for the first time in Philadelphia with Hitchcock serving as its first president. This organization eventually evolved into the American Association
THE ICHNOLOGY OF THE CONNECTICUT VALLEY
for the Advancement of Science, in 1848. In 1863, Hitchcock became a charter member of the National Academy of Sciences. In 1836, Hitchcock undertook a study of the curious tracks found in the vicinity of Deerfield Massachusetts (Fig. 3.1B). He was convinced that these markings resulted from the activity of birds, and the study of these tracks dominated his latter years. During his career, Hitchcock published 26 articles (Hitchcock, 1836a,b,c,d, 1837, 1841, 1843, 1844a,b, 1845a,b,c, 1847, 1848, 1854, 1855, 1856a,b,c,d, 1857, 1861, 1862, 1863a,b, 1866) and two books (Hitchcock, 1858, 1865) on these tracks and trackways. Edward Hitchcock passed away on February 27, 1864 and was buried in the Amherst Cemetery. James Deane (1801–1858): The person who brought the Connecticut Valley tracks to the attention of Edward Hitchcock was James Deane of Greenfield. Details on the life of James Deane are provided by Bowditch (1858) and Bouve (1859). James Deane was born in Coleraine, Franklin County, Massachusetts, the eighth child of Christopher and Prudence Deane, on February 24, 1801. The Deanes were a farming family and the father wanted his sons to workin the farm. James Deane was educated in the local school but did spend one term at the Deerfield Academy, where he was taught Latin and developed an interest in medicine. He worked the family farm until he was 19, and then went to Boston to find a trade. Unable to find work, Deane returned to Deerfield where he worked copying legal documents in the law office of Elijah Alvard. He remained in Deerfield for 4 years, and saved his money with the intent of going to medical school. Deane entered Medical School at the University of the State of New York in 1829 and graduated with his MD in 1831, just prior to his 30th birthday. Deane moved back to Deerfield and established his medical practice, remaining there for the rest of his life. He was a passionate doctor and was especially adept at operative surgery. During his medical career, he was a frequent contributor to the Boston Medical and Surgery Journal; publishing 20 articles over the period 1837–1855. He also served as Vice President of the Massachusetts Medical Society in 1854, and took an active role in that society. Early on in his life, he developed a love of nature and was a naturalist at heart. He was a member of the Boston Society of Natural History and published a number of his footprint articles in their journal. James Deane was a tall, powerful man who had a commanding presence. He was an able and selftaught artist and a highly talented musician. He constructed his own musical instruments and even
35
crafted an organ. Deane was a devoted family man and in 1836 he married Mary Clapp Russell of Deerfield with whom he had 3 daughters. He was a gifted mimic and would often entertain his friends with his many different voices. He contracted typhoid fever in the spring of 1858, and passed away on June 8 of that year. He was buried in Deerfield. In 1835, Deane was made aware of curious marks in strata at Turner’s Falls near Greenfield and thought that they represented bird tracks. Although a number of prominent citizens had seen the markings, Deane was the only one who actually studied them. On March 7, 1835, he wrote letters to the prominent geologists Edward Hitchcock in Amherst, Massachusetts, and Benjamin Silliman in New Haven, Connecticut. On March 15, 1835, Hitchcock replied but was not very encouraging about the possibilities that the markings could be bird tracks. Deane persisted, and in April 1835 sent another letter to Hitchcock and Silliman, along with plaster casts of the markings. This elicited a visit from Hitchcock who now was determined to study these markings. In Deane’s letter to Silliman, he sent a paper that he wished to be published, but Silliman decided to wait until Hitchcock had completed his study. Deane was also in contact with geologists in Great Britain, and in September, 1842, he wrote to Dr. Gideon Mantell, who transmitted the communication and the casts to the membership of the Geological Society of London. As a result Professor Richard Owen and Sir Roderick Murchison were convinced by the bird track interpretation that Deane suggested. Despite the studies of Hitchcock, Deane persisted in working on the markings and produced a number of scientific papers on them (Deane, 1843, 1844a, 1845a,b,c, 1847a,b, 1848, 1849, 1850, 1856). A posthumously published volume (Deane, 1861) with photographs and etchings completed his work on the tracks (Fig. 3.2). Deane always maintained that he was the first person to fully appreciate the significance of the markings, and was the true scientific discoverer of them. As will be discussed later he, and Hitchcock engaged in a war of words over the traces. Deane felt that Hitchcock had misrepresented what had happened, and had attempted to claim all the scientific credit for the tracks (Deane, 1844b,c; Hitchcock, 1844b). John Collins Warren (1778–1856): Dr. John Collins Warren (Fig. 3.3A) was one of the most renowned American surgeons of the nineteenth century. Details of his life have been gathered from Warren (1860) and Steinbock (1989). Warren was born on August 1, 1778 in Boston, the son of Dr. John Warren, the founder of the Harvard Medical College. Warren started his education at the age of five at Master Vinals reading
36
3. EDWARD HITCHCOCK AND ROLAND BIRD: TWO EARLY TITANS OF VERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
B
A
FIGURE 3.2 (A) Cover page of James Deane’s (1861) ichnological volume. (B) Lithograph from the Deane volume.
and writing school in Boston, and later attended the Public Latin School. In 1793, he enrolled at Harvard College and graduated in 1797. In 1798, he began the study of medicine under the tutelage of his father. In 1799, he went abroad, continuing his medical studies in London and Paris. As an intern, Warren attended and studied at Guy’s Hospital in London with Sir Astley Cooper and later he studied, in Paris under the direction of the naturalist and anatomist Georges Cuvier. He received an honorary medical degree from Harvard in 1819. On his return to America in 1802, Warren entered into partnership with his father, and also began to assist him with anatomical lectures, dissections, and demonstrations at Harvard Medical School. He was named Adjunct Professor of Anatomy and Surgery in 1809. Upon his father’s death, he assumed the Hersey Professorship of Anatomy and Surgery, and he held that post until he retired in 1847. Dr. Warren was also the first dean of the Medical School and promoted its removal from Cambridge to Boston, in order to obtain better access to clinical facilities. He was also closely associated with the foundation of Massachusetts
General Hospital and was that facility’s first surgeon. Warren held an appointment on the hospital staff until 1853, and then served on its Board of Consultation until his death. On October 16, 1846, at Massachusetts General Hospital, Warren performed the first operation on a patient, Gilbert Abbott, under ether anesthesia administered by dentist William T.G. Morton. Over the course of his long career, he assembled an extraordinary teaching collection of 1116 anatomical and pathological specimens. He presented it to the Harvard Medical School in 1847 along with a $5000 endowment consisting of railroad stock. This was the beginning of the Warren Anatomical Museum, which now contains approximately 13 000 items, including anatomical and pathological specimens, various anatomical models, photographs, paintings, drawings, medical instruments and machines, and other medical memorabilia. Warren passed away on May 4, 1856. Aside from his medical pursuits, Warren was also an accomplished naturalist and contributed a number of interesting publications. In 1846, he obtained
THE ICHNOLOGY OF THE CONNECTICUT VALLEY
A
37
B
FIGURE 3.3 (A) John Collins Warren, 1778–1856 (after Warren, 1860, Volume 1). (B) Counterpart slab (of specimen used in the first photographic image in a scientific publication in North America, specimen is in the Collections of the American Museum of Natural History), specimen 26/10 in the Amherst College collection and was figured in Hitchcock, 1858 as Plate 40, Number 1 (reproduced here).
perhaps the best-preserved Mastodon skeleton ever recovered from the Hudson Valley, and produced a lavishly illustrated monograph about it (Warren, 1852). He also produced a modest tome on the Connecticut Valley footprints (Warren, 1854a) as well as a number of articles on the subject, published in the Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History (Rogers et al., 1855; Warren, 1854b, 1855, 1856). Warren obtained his original track specimen from James Deane in 1845. In 1852, the Boston Society of Natural History purchased slabs from the collection of one Mr. Marsh, a mechanic from Greenfield who had died of consumption, and who had collected for James Deane. Additional specimens were obtained from Edward Hitchcock. Like Hitchcock and Deane, Warren ascribed the tracks to ostrich-like birds. Warren’s publication is not particularly noteworthy except for the fact that it contains the first use of a photographic image in an American scientific publication (Steinbock, 1989). The specimen figured in that photograph is now at the American Museum of Natural History. The counterpart slab is specimen 26/10 in the Amherst College collection and was figured in Hitchcock (1858) as his Plate 40, Number 1 (Fig. 3.3B).
The Tracks In 1836, Hitchcock’s first description of Connecticut Valley fossil tracks was published in the American Journal of Science, describing 7 species of what he termed giant bird tracks (Fig. 3.4). The largest of these earliest footprint finds was a natural cast of a threetoed track that he named Orinithichnites giganteus. The specimen was collected from what is now the northern side of Holyoke, Massachusetts, on the east bank of the Connecticut River (Specimen number 15/3 in the Amherst Collection). Later, this track was renamed Eubrontes giganteus; it was the first dinosaur track to be described formally. It was a sensational discovery and a lithograph of the track was at once incorporated into Buckland’s famous ‘Bridgewater Treatise’ (2nd edition , 1837). That same year, Hitchcock published a poem ‘The Sandstone Bird’ in The Knickerbocker magazine under the pseudonym Poetaster (meaning a mediocre writer of verse) just after his original article on the tracks appeared (Hitchcock , 1836a). The poem is about a sorceress bringing the great sandstone bird back to life (Marche´ , 1991) and probably represents the first ichnological poem. Details on the genesis of the poem have been well documented by Marche´ (1991). The Connecticut River Valley tracks also
38
3. EDWARD HITCHCOCK AND ROLAND BIRD: TWO EARLY TITANS OF VERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
A
B FIGURE 3.4 Figures and plate from the initial Hitchcock, 1836 publication on the Connecticut tracks. (A) Figures 1–20, 23, and 24. (B) Plate 1.
inspired the poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow in the poems ‘Footprints on the Sands of Time’ and ‘To the Driving Cloud’ (Dean, 1969). By 1889, the Amherst College collection included the biogenic structures of 17 pachydactylous birds, 17 leptodactylous birds, 21 ornithoid reptiles, 25 assorted reptiles and amphibians, 17 frogs or salamanders, 6 turtles, 2 fish, 1 marsupial, and 45 insects,
crustaceans, or larvae. All of these 151 species were collected from about 38 localities (Hitchcock, 1889). His ichnological collection was placed on exhibition in the specially designed Appelton Cabinet (Fig. 3.5A) erected in 1855. Samuel Appelton of Boston bequeathed $10 000 to erect the building in order to house the collection (Hitchcock, 1858). Hitchcock insisted upon natural southern light to
THE ICHNOLOGY OF THE CONNECTICUT VALLEY
A
39
B FIGURE 3.5 (A) The Appelton Cabinet, built in 1855 (after Hitchcock, 1858, Plate 4, bottom). (B) Sketch of the interior of the Ichnological Cabinet (after Hitchcock, 1858, Plate 4, top).
best illuminate the slabs with the tracks. By his own count, over 8000 tracks were on display (Fig. 3.5B). The Appelton Cabinet has since been converted to a dormitory and Hitchcock’s collection currently resides across the Amherst College yard in the basement of the Pratt Museum. Simpson (1942, p. 167) stated that Amherst was perhaps ‘the first college to possess any considerable collection of vertebrate fossils under the study and care of a qualified faculty member.’ Amherst College is currently building a $10 million museum to showcase the footprint collection and to pay homage to Hitchcock’s remarkable discoveries. Hitchcock’s specimens will be displayed on the lower level of the three-story museum. In addition to the dinosaur-track slabs, the collection contains some 11 000 tracks and traces left by other Early Triassic and Jurassic life-forms, including lizards, crocodilians, worms, insects, and other invertebrates.
The Hitchcock–Deane Controversy In his first paper on the tracks, Hitchcock (1836a) credited James Deane as being the first to bring the tracks to his attention. Subsequently, the two men engaged in a public dispute about who really found the first tracks and realized their significance. Hitchcock (1844a) tried to defuse the situation by recounting a story about the young Pliny Moody, whom he suggested was the ‘first’ discoverer of the tracks. The implication of the story is that one can ‘find’ something that is important without comprehending its relevance and therefore, the question is asked, is the ‘discoverer’ the one who collects the specimen, or the one who understands and scientifically expounds their significance? Moody was a farmer in South Hadley, Massachusetts around the
turn of the eighteenth century who, in 1802, plowed up some slabs of dinosaur tracks in one of his fields (Fig. 3.6A). One particular slab stood for many years as a doorstop in the Moody home (Fig. 3.6B). Dr. Elihu Dwight of South Hadley subsequently purchased this slab when Moody left for school and referred to the specimen as ‘Noah’s Raven.’ The tracks are now recognized as Anomoepus scambus, the footprints of a small ornithischian dinosaur. Dwight was in possession of the specimen for nearly 30 years; upon his death, in 1839 Edward Hitchcock purchased the specimen for Amherst College (cataloged as specimen 16/2). Specimens from South Hadley near the site of the original Pliny Moody find are still being excavated (Fig. 3.6C) at the Nash Footprint Quarry. Hitchcock (1844a) then went on to outline that, in 1834, a number of gentlemen in Greenfield made arrangements with one Mr. William Wilson to obtain flagging stones to repair a street. Mr. Wilson brought the stones from a quarry near Montague in the spring of 1835 and noticed marks that he referred to as ‘turkey tracks.’ He pointed out these marks to the Greenfield gentlemen and one of them, James Deane, took considerable interest in them and called them to the attention of Edward Hitchcock. These specimens were subsequently purchased by Edward Hitchcock on behalf of Amherst College from James Deane, and are cataloged as Specimens 18/1 and 18/2. Deane objected to Hitchcock’s (1844a) article and published his own version of events (Deane, 1844a). Deane felt that Hitchcock had belittled his contribution and was upset on several grounds: (1) Deane felt that he, unlike the other early observers mentioned by Hitchcock (e.g., Moody, Wilson, Dwight), had looked at the tracks scientifically and conducted serious study of them.
40
3. EDWARD HITCHCOCK AND ROLAND BIRD: TWO EARLY TITANS OF VERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
A
B
C
FIGURE 3.6 (A) Sketch of the Pliny Moody Quarry where the first specimen was found (after Hitchcock, 1858, Plate 1). (B) Original specimen found by Pliny Moody and dubbed as ‘Noah’s Raven’ by Dr. Elihu Dwight of South Hadley. It was subsequently purchased by Edward Hitchcock for Amherst College in 1839 and cataloged as specimen 16/2 (courtesy of Amherst College). (C) Specimen from the Nash Footprint Quarry, South Hadley, Massachusetts.
This is corroborated by the fact that he published a number of articles (Deane, 1843, 1844a, 1845a,b,c, 1847a,b, 1848, 1849, 1850, 1856) on them and a posthumously published volume (Deane, 1861). It should be pointed out, though, that he waited some 8 years to publish his first article. (2) In 1835, Deane had sent casts and a communication to Benjamin Silliman at the same time he sent them to Hitchcock. The communication was a description, and in it Deane attributed them to the activities of birds. Silliman contacted Hitchcock on July 22, 1835 for his opinion and Hitchcock asked him to withhold publication of
Deane’s manuscript until his study was completed (Hitchcock, 1844b). (3) Deane felt that Hitchcock had intimated that had Hitchcock not published on the tracks, no serious scientific work would have been done on them. The Deane (1844a) article led to one of the first discussion-and-reply scenarios in geology. Hitchcock (1844b) published a rejoinder or discussion of the Deane article, and re-iterated many of the points he made in his earlier article (Hitchcock, 1844a). To his credit, he did append a postscript that related the events of the Silliman intervention on the publication of the Deane description. He stressed the fact that he
ROLAND BIRD AND THE DISCOVERY OF SAUROPOD TRACKS
A
41
B FIGURE 3.7 Plates from Hitchcock, 1858. (A) Plate 57 depicting a variety of tracks. (B) Plate 6 depicting the concept of undertracks (Figs. 1 and 2) and comparative tracks of modern organisms (Figs. 3–13).
had assembled an impressive array of specimens and reiterated that he was the true scientific discoverer of the tracks. He did state, ‘I admit him to have been in a popular sense, the original discoverer of the footmarks; and had it not been for his scientific discernment, probably they would still have remained undiscovered’ (Hitchcock, 1844b, p. 398). Deane (1844b) then followed with his reply to the discussion of Hitchcock (Hitchcock, 1844b) and reiterated his position. Subsequently both men worked on the tracks and the matter was not broached again until Deane’s death, when both Bowditch (1858) and Bouve (1859) brought it up in their memorials to Deane. Hitchcock then felt obliged once again to present his case in his Ichnology of New England volume (Hitchcock, 1858, pp. 191–198). His arguments had not changed at all. Summary Although footprints and other markings made by animals were known to exist before Hitchcock’s work (cf. Pemberton et al., 1996; Pemberton and Gingras, 2003), he was the person most responsible for developing the emerging field of ichnology. His 1858
volume is by far the largest compilation and most comprehensive treatise on vertebrate ichnology published to date. The volume is lavishly illustrated (Fig. 3.7A) and Hitchcock was aware of the concept of undertracks and the need to compare the fossil tracks with modern counterparts (Fig. 3.7B). The volume stands with the William Jardine (1853) book ‘The Ichnology of Annandale’ as an early landmark in the development of ichnological research.
ROLAND BIRD AND THE DISCOVERY OF SAUROPOD TRACKS Perhaps no other moment in the history of vertebrate ichnology in North America compares to the discovery and eventual excavation of the sauropod tracks and trackways from the banks of the Paluxy River near Glen Rose, Texas. It is still regarded as the single largest excavation of a track site, and it is a testament to the work of a tracker extraordinaire, Roland Thaxter Bird.
42
3. EDWARD HITCHCOCK AND ROLAND BIRD: TWO EARLY TITANS OF VERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
Roland Thaxter Bird (1899–1978) The American Museum of Natural History has had its share of intrepid adventurers, including Roy Chapman Andrews, Barnum Brown, Walter Granger, and Bashford Dean; but probably none was as unique as Roland Thaxter Bird. Bird was a self-made man and one of the last of the specialized fossil collectors. Details on the life of Roland Bird were gathered from Colbert (1978), Bird (1985), Farlow (1985), and Farlow and Lockley (1989). Roland Thaxter Bird (Fig. 3.8A) was born on December 29, 1899, the first of four children to Henry and Harriet Bird of Rye, New York. His father, a successful businessman, was also an amateur entomologist who conducted important studies on noctuid moths. He instilled in Roland a love of nature and a respect for learning. As a young boy, Roland was frequently ill and suffered from rheumatic fever, which plagued him for the rest of his life. Due to his illness, it was determined that he should spend time away from the coastal town. He was sent to live with his uncle on a farm near Grahamsville, New York, in the Catskill Mountains. It was here that Bird developed a love for farming, cattle breeding, and the outdoor life. At age 15, Bird’s mother died of tuberculosis and shortly thereafter, he dropped out of Junior High School. At his father’s insistence Bird apprenticed as a plumber but, at the age of 19, Bird went to farm and raised cattle in Florida, where he also invested in land. During the Depression he lost everything so he decided to see the country and constructed a motorcycle with a homemade camper (Fig. 3.8B). He traveled around doing odd jobs until
A
November, 1932, when he discovered a fossilized skull (Stanocephalosaurus birdi) south of Holbrook, Arizona. The skull brought him to the attention of Barnum T. Brown, the curator at the American Museum of Natural History. Brown enlisted Bird to be one of his fossil hunters. Bird joined the staff of the American Museum of Natural History in 1934 and remained Barnum Brown’s right-hand man in the field and the laboratory for many years. Bird had the utmost respect for Brown and even titled his memoirs ‘Bones for Barnum Brown.’ Bird worked tirelessly for Brown and was responsible for many of the finds Brown reported in his latter years. Bird was the perfect assistant for Brown. He was a quiet, modest man and his quest for finding fossils was of great importance to him. He spent his summers happily in the field doing what he loved; he would work with Brown either by himself or with assistants. This passion for fieldwork dominates his memoir (Bird, 1985), and makes it one of the best paleontological reads ever. In it Bird shows his humility, his dedication, and his sense of honor in finding himself associated with such major scientific discoveries. In one of the most touching passages, Farlow (1985) discusses an event when Bird was sick in bed and his wife and sister were reading to him from a book on dinosaurs by Adrian Desmond. Upon hearing a passage that mentioned his work, Bird remarked ‘I am listed among the titans!’ (Farlow, 1985, p. 219). During the summer of 1934, Bird was one of the key figures in collecting the massive sauropods from the Late Jurassic boneyard of the Morrison Formation in
B FIGURE 3.8 (A) Roland Thaxter Bird (1899–1978). (B) Roland Bird on the road with the Harley homemade camper (after Bird, 1985).
ROLAND BIRD AND THE DISCOVERY OF SAUROPOD TRACKS
43
FIGURE 3.9 The map that Bird created of the bones in the Howe Quarry site (after Bird, 1985).
the famous Howe Quarry near Shell, Wyoming. In his obituary for Bird, Colbert (1978) stated that his quarry map (Fig. 3.9) is perhaps the most complex ever produced. Bird suffered from ill health for most of his life and was something of a hypochondriac. This may have been exacerbated by his eccentric diet, which often consisted of a single food item (such as potatoes, chicken, or fish patties) that he would eat meal after meal for weeks at a time (Farlow, 1985). Despite his somewhat frail appearance and health issues, Bird was an energetic field worker. His good friend, V. Theodore Schreiber, described him as ‘one of the toughest little guys I ever met . . . he used to embarrass me no end, the way he could gallop up a mountain goat trail without breathing hard at the top’ (Schreiber, quoted in Farlow and Lockley, 1989, p. 35). Bird’s career as a fossil hunter was relatively short. When Brown retired from the American Museum of Natural History in 1942, Bird continued to do field work for him but eventually the events of World War II brought changes. The Federal Government, in concert with several mining companies, was in the hunt for uranium and vanadium and was in need of
experienced field geologists. Bird resigned from the Museum and accepted a healthy pay raise to search for uranium in the same beds he once scoured for fossils. After the war, due to health issues, Bird was no longer able to do field work and he returned to New York where in 1946 he married Hazel Russell. Shortly afterward the family (Hazel had 2 daughters from a previous marriage) moved to Homestead, Florida, where Bird once again went into the cattle business. In 1952, the American Museum of Natural History was remodeling the Brontosaur Hall, and Edwin H. Colbert, Barnum Brown’s successor, contacted Bird to supervise the reassembly and installation of the Paluxy River trackway slab beneath Brown’s Apatosaurus mount. The slabs that Bird had collected long before were deteriorating in the Museum’s courtyard, and Colbert had the inspiration to place the specimens into context. Despite being weak, Bird took to the task with renewed vigor (Fig. 3.10A) and the resulting display (Fig. 3.10B) was a tribute to both Bird and Barnum Brown. Roland Thaxter Bird died at his home in Homestead, Florida, on January 24, 1978, and was buried in Grahamsville, New York, with a gastrolith in
44
3. EDWARD HITCHCOCK AND ROLAND BIRD: TWO EARLY TITANS OF VERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
A
B FIGURE 3.10 (A) Workers busy assembling the Glen Rose trackway (photograph courtesy of the American Museum of Natural History. (B) The finished product of the reassembly of the Glen Rose tracks behind the dinosaur at the American Museum of Natural History (after Bird, 1954).
Barnum Brown (1873–1963)
FIGURE 3.11 The headstone of Roland T. Bird in the Grahamsville, New York Cemetery.
his pocket. His gravesite overlooks the Catskill Mountains that he had loved in his youth. At the top of his headstone (Fig. 3.11) a picture of a brontosaur is carved and his epitaph reads ‘Discoverer of Sauropod Dinosaur Footprints.’
Barnum Brown (Fig. 3.12A) was an intriguing figure in his own right, and it would be impossible to discuss Roland Bird without commenting on Barnum Brown. Biographical details concerning Barnum Brown are taken from Barton (1941), Lewis (1964), and Preston (1988). Brown was born on February 12, 1873, the youngest child of William and Clara Brown. The Brown’s had left Virginia and moved west by wagon train, settling in what is now Carbondale, Kansas. They named their youngest son after P.T. Barnum, in order to jazz up a somewhat common last name. Brown was the last and most successful of the great fossil hunters, and led expeditions not only throughout the United States, but also Canada, South America, India, and Ethiopia (Fig. 3.12B). He was associated with the American Museum of Natural History for 66 years from 1897 until his death in 1963. To fund expensive digs,
ROLAND BIRD AND THE DISCOVERY OF SAUROPOD TRACKS
A
45
B FIGURE 3.12 (A) Barnum Brown, Curator of Vertebrate Paleontology at the American Museum of Natural History (after Bird, 1989). (B) Barnum Brown (far right), Roland Bird (left), and Erich Schlaikjer (middle) with the reconstructed skull of Deinosuchus (photography courtesy of the American Museum of Natural History).
he eventually made a deal with the Sinclair Oil Company. He wrote dinosaur booklets for the company and it paid for his expeditions. In the 1930s and 1940s Sinclair gas stations, with their Diplodocus logo, attracted customers, by giving away the booklets. Brown’s collaboration with the Sinclair Oil also resulted in impressive dinosaur exhibits at the Chicago World’s Fair in the 1930s and the New York World’s Fair in the 1960s (Preston, 1988). To dinosaur enthusiasts, Brown’s greatest achievement was likely to be his discovery of Tyrannosaurus rex in Hell Creek, Montana. He discovered the first skeleton in 1902 and a better-preserved skeleton in 1908. Both skeletons were put on display in the American Museum; the 1902 skeleton was subsequently shipped to the Carnegie Museum in Pittsburgh. After he retired from the American Museum of Natural History in 1942, he continued to work as a consulting field geologist for oil companies in both Alberta and Guatemala. Brown also continued his work in Montana, collecting fossils for the Museum, including a skeleton of Plesiosaurus that he excavated at the age of 82. Brown passed away on February 5, 1963, a week shy of his 90th birthday.
Bird’s Ichnological Contributions Bird’s ichnological work is admirably covered in a tribute article by Farlow and Lockley (1989) and an article by Farlow et al. (1989) dealing with specimens of Brontopodus birdi. Highlights of his career in ichnology included a number of fundamental observations that helped interpret dinosaur behavior. His first foray into vertebrate ichnology occurred in the fall of 1935, when he decided to look at and possibly collect some of the abundant footprints in the Triassic of New England. During this trip, he visited the ichnological collections at Amherst College where he described a unique specimen (Bird, 1985, pp. 79–80, see also Fig. 3.1A), which he interpreted as the trace of a squatting dinosaur waiting out a rain shower. The tracks show raindrop impressions up to the point where the dinosaur squatted to wait out the storm, but the body impression and tracks leading away from it show no raindrop marks. In 1937, in a coalmine near Cedaredge, Colorado, Bird excavated (Fig. 3.13A) a large slab weighing 18 000 pounds that contained a set of large hadrosaur tracks (Brown, 1938). Although he did not formally publish on this material, he was instrumental in the excavation of the specimens. Barnum Brown used these specimens (Fig. 3.13B) to determine a step length
46
3. EDWARD HITCHCOCK AND ROLAND BIRD: TWO EARLY TITANS OF VERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
B
A
FIGURE 3.13 (A) Roland T. Bird extracting a track from a mine near Cedaredge, Colorado. (B) The extracted tracks from the mine that Barnum Brown calculated a step length of 15 feet (after Brown, 1938).
of 15 feet and postulated that the tracks represented the activities of a giant mystery dinosaur. Using the formula for calculating dinosaur speed, Russell and Be´land (1976) calculated a speed of 27 km/h (some 17 mph). However, Thulborn (1981) showed that the 15-foot step recorded by Brown was really a stride (two steps), and recalculated the speed to be a more realistic 8.5 km/h (or 5 mph). Near Pueblo, Colorado, Bird examined large tracks in the valley of the Pugatoire River in the hope that they might represent sauropod tracks. This site was reported (MacClary, 1938; Bird, 1939a) but the tracks were not considered to be of sauropod origin. The site was abandoned as being too remote and because Museum quality tracks were not exposed. However,
this site is now considered to be one of the most prolific mega-tracksites in the world, with undisputable sauropod tracks (Lockley et al., 1986; Lockley and Hunt, 1995). By far, Bird’s most spectacular find was the footprints at the tracksite on the Paluxy River near Glen Rose, Texas, at the close of the 1938 field season. Although the site had been known before (Shuler, 1917) it was here that Bird discovered both carnosaur tracks and the elusive sauropod tracks that he had been hunting for (Bird, 1939b, 1941, 1944, 1953, 1954). The specimens were suitable for display at the Museum, and Bird returned to the site in the spring of 1940, supported by funds from the Sinclair Oil Company, the State of Texas, and
ROLAND BIRD AND THE DISCOVERY OF SAUROPOD TRACKS
the federal government. The site excavated by Bird and his crew revealed trails of a dozen sauropods and four carnivores (Lockley, 1991); they quarried a section of rock 29 feet long by 8 feet wide for the American Museum of Natural History, and several adjacent sections for other institutions that were willing to pay the freight costs. In total, the excavated slabs weighed more than 80 000 pounds and constitute the largest track excavation ever undertaken. The slabs for the American Museum of Natural History were shipped more than 2000 miles, and in his memoir Bird stated that he was worried that the tracks might be the target of German submarines that were operating in the vicinity of the Gulf Stream (Bird, 1985). In 1938, at the Paluxy River near Glen Rose in central Texas, Bird uncovered a unique slab that contained two sets of trackways. He believed one set of tracks belonged to a four-legged herbivore (a sauropod), and the other to a two-legged carnivore (a theropod). According to Bird’s track charts (Fig. 3.14), the meat-eater’s tracks run parallel to the tracks of the plant eater. But the tracks also show that
47
at one point, the meat-eater’s tracks take a strange skipping stride or hop, leaving two consecutive right footprints in the mud. Bird believed these two sets of prints with a peculiar hop in the middle represented the moment the smaller carnivore attacked the herbivore. The sequence has since been identified as the ‘attack scenario’ in the excavated slabs. Lockley (1991) has suggested that the footprint evidence does not support such a scenario. There is no change in speed indicated by the tracks, there is no disruption caused by the landing of the supposed ‘hop’ and the missing track may simply be an artifact of preservation. Lockley (1991) thinks that a more likely scenario involves a herd of 12 sauropods followed by 3 theropods. Preliminary work was also done on the Mayan Ranch and Davenport Ranch tracksites. These sites exposed the same bed that was present at Glen Rose and both that contained sauropod tracks, but they were deemed to be inferior to the Glen Rose site and were abandoned. The Mayan Ranch site contains the famous swimming sauropod track (Fig. 3.15A) that was used to reaffirm the popular belief of the time that
A
B
FIGURE 3.14 The attack scenario trackway, Paluxy River bank near Glen Rose, Texas (after Bird, 1939).
FIGURE 3.15 (A) Trackway at the Mayan Ranch that Bird interpreted as resulting from a swimming sauropod. (B) Bird’s sketched interpretation of swimming sauropods (after Bird, 1944).
48
3. EDWARD HITCHCOCK AND ROLAND BIRD: TWO EARLY TITANS OF VERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
A
B FIGURE 3.16 (A) Roland T. Bird at the Davenport Ranch site examining one of the trackways. (B) He described twenty-three sauropod trackways heading in the same direction and correctly concluded that such evidence pointed to gregarious behavior (after Bird, 1944).
sauropods did not live on land but instead used water to help buoy them (Fig. 3.15B). In 1944, Bird described a trackway consisting almost entirely of sauropod front-foot impressions and he inferred that this might represent a swimming dinosaur (Bird, 1944). This contention is still debated today. Other possible swimming sauropod trackways have been described (e.g., Ishigaki, 1989), though other researchers (e.g., Lockley, 1991) favor the interpretation that these shallow tracks are simply undertracks. At the Davenport Ranch site, Bird uncovered twenty-three sauropod trackways heading in the same direction (Fig. 3.16), and correctly concluded that such evidence supported gregarious behavior (Bird, 1944). Such a concept was revolutionary in the 1930s and Bird is correctly recognized as one of the originators of the herding hypothesis (Farlow and Lockley, 1989). One event associated with the Paluxy River site clearly upset Bird, and that was his role in the ‘ManTrack Controversy.’ Although Bird never reported any real human tracks in the Paluxy Riverbed, his writings
FIGURE 3.17 The supposed Man Tracks that Bird saw in a store in New Mexico that brought the Gen Rose site to his attention (after Bird, 1939b).
49
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
would inadvertently lead to the spread of the ‘man track’ claims. Bird (1939b) mentioned and figured (Fig. 3.17) the carved ‘man tracks’ that he saw in the window of a shop in New Mexico that led him to Glen Rose, as well as rumors from locals that ‘giant man tracks’ could be found in the Paluxy riverbed itself. A local farmer directed Bird to one such track, and Bird referred to as a ‘mystery track’ and described it as, ‘something about 15 inches long, with a curious elongated heel’ (Bird, 1939b, p. 257). Noting that the print was too indistinct to diagnose precisely, Bird suggested that it was made by some ‘hitherto unknown dinosaur or reptile’ (Bird, 1939b, p. 257). In his 1985 memoir, Bird relates his frustration at being used as a pawn in trying to suggest that man and dinosaurs coexisted. The curious mystery fossils that Bird described have subsequently been reinterpreted, in a superb article by Kuban (1989), as dinosaur tracks that are indistinct due to mud collapse and erosion.
CONCLUSIONS The discovery and analysis of the Connecticut River Valley tracks and the Glen Rose sauropod tracks are significant episodes in the development of vertebrate ichnology. They quickly established North America as the center of vertebrate ichnological research, and demonstrated the intrinsic value of tracks and trackways in the interpretation of dinosaur behavior. Interestingly, the principal workers on these trackways were essentially amateur scientists. In a very real sense, the work of Edward Hitchcock constituted the first systematic study of ichnology. His collection of tracks was by far the most comprehensive ever assembled, and established Amherst College as the center of ichnological research. Although at first his work was viewed with skepticism, it was soon accepted and his views quickly ignited both the scientific and artistic world. Dean (1969) indicated that Hitchcock’s research had a profound effect on the work of writers like Emily Dickenson (who he knew personally), Henry Wadsworth Longfellow (Nathan Appelton, the benefactor of the building that housed the ichnological collection was Longfellow’s father-in-law), Herman Melville, Oliver Wendell Holmes, and Henry David Thoreau. In his recent homage to Edward Hitchcock, Robert T. Bakker concluded that Hitchcock deserved to be recognized as the first paleontologist to suggest the relationship of dinosaurs to birds and concluded that, ‘In fact, Hitchcock didn’t need help from bones.
He reconstructed the fore and hind paws of Jurassic dinosaurs directly from the footprints with extraordinary sagacity. I find Hitchcock’s inaugural 1836 monograph awe-inspiring. His observations are detailed, his reasoning tight. This one publication made paleoichnology a robust discipline, a window into the grand succession of dominant life forms in the terrestrial sphere’ (Bakker, 2004, p. 3). In their tribute to Roland T. Bird, Farlow and Lockley (1989) summed up his place in history very well when they stated ‘He was the most conscientious American vertebrate ichnologist since Edward Hitchcock, and with the exception of Charles Sternberg and Richard Swan Lull, the only one to produce enduring work in the first half of the twentieth century’ (Farlow and Lockley, 1989, p. 35).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We would like to thank Dr. Whitey Hagadorn and Dr. Edward Belt for supplying photographs from the Amherst College Collection and the archivist at the Amherst College Archives for access to the Hitchcock papers. We are also indebted to the American Museum of Natural History for supplying copies of photographs in their collection. The senior author would like to thank the Canada Research Chair Program for support of his research and funding was provided by the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada. Finally, we would like to thank Dr. Robert MacNaughton and Dr. Steve Hasiotis for their excellent and through reviews of this manuscript.
References Aldrich, M.L. and Leviton, A.E. (2001). Orra White Hitchcock (1796–1863) geological illustrator; another belle of Amherst. Geological Society of America, Abstracts with Programs, 33, 246. Bakker, R.T. (2004). Introduction: dinosaurs acting like birds and vice versa an homage to the Reverend Edward Hitchcock, first director of the Massachusetts geological Survey. In: Currie, P.J., Koppelhus, E.B., Shugar, M.A. and Wright, J.L. (Eds.), Feathered Dragons, Indiana University Press, Bloomington, Indiana, pp. 1–11. Barbour, I.H. (1892). Notice of new gigantic fossils. Science, 19, 99–100. Barton, D.R. (1941). Father of the dinosaurs [biographical sketch of Barnum Brown]. Natural History, 48, 308–312. Belt, E.S. (1989). A brief sketch of Edward Hitchcock (1793–1864). In: Jordan, W. M. (Ed.), Boston to Buffalo, in the Footsteps of Amos Eaton and Edward Hitchcock, Field Trip Guidebook T169, 28th International Geological Congress, Washington, DC, pp. 14–20. Bird, R.T. (1939a). Letter. Natural History, 43, 425.
50
3. EDWARD HITCHCOCK AND ROLAND BIRD: TWO EARLY TITANS OF VERTEBRATE ICHNOLOGY IN NORTH AMERICA
Bird, R.T. (1939b). Thunder in his footsteps. Natural History, 43, 254–261, 302. Bird, R.T. (1941). A Dinosaur walks into the museum. Natural History, 47, 74–81. Bird, R.T. (1944). Did Brontosaurus ever walk on land? Natural History, 53, 60–67. Bird, R.T. (1953). To capture a dinosaur isn’t easy. Natural History, 62, 104–110. Bird, R.T. (1954). We Captured a Live Brontosaur. National Geographic, 105, 707–722. Bird, R.T. (1985). Bones for Barnum Brown: Adventures of a Dinosaur Hunter, Texas Christian University Press, Fort Worth, 225 pp. Bouve, T.T. (1859). Sketch of the life and labors of James Deane. Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History, 6, 391–394. Bowditch, H.I. (1858). An Address on the Life and Character of James Deane, M.D, H.D. Mirick and Co., Greenfield, 45 pp. Brown, B. (1938). The mystery dinosaur. Natural History, 41, 190–202, 235. Buckland, W. (1837). Geology and Mineralogy Considered with Reference to Natural Theology, Volume 2, William Pickering, London. Colbert, E.H. (1978). Roland T. Bird (1899–1978). News Bulletin, Society of Vertebrate Paleontology, 114, 43–44. Dean, D.R. (1969). Hitchcock’s dinosaur tracks. American Quarterly, 21, 639–644. Deane, J. (1843). Ornithichnites of the Connecticut River sandstones. American Journal of Science, 45, 177–183. Deane, J. (1844a). On the fossil footmarks of Turner’s Falls, Massachusetts. American Journal of Science, 47, 73–77. Deane, J. (1844b). On the discovery of fossil footmarks. American Journal of Science, 47, 381–390. Deane, J. (1844c). Answer to the rejoinder of Professor Hitchcock. American Journal of Science, 47, 399–401. Deane, J. (1845a). Illustrations of fossil footmarks. Boston Journal of Natural History, 5, 277–284. Deane, J. (1845b). Description of fossil footprints in the New Red sandstone of the Connecticut Valley. American Journal of Science, 48, 158–167. Deane, J. (1845c). Fossil footmarks and raindrops. American Journal of Science, 49, 213–215. Deane, J. (1847a). Notice of new fossil footprints. American Journal of Science, 3, 74–79. Deane, J. (1847b). Fossil footprints. American Journal of Science, 4, 448–449. Deane, J. (1848). Fossil footprints of a new species of quadruped. American Journal of Science, 5, 40–41. Deane, J. (1849). Illustrations of fossil footprints of the valley of the Connecticut. Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, 1849, 209–220. Deane, J. (1850). Fossil footprints of Connecticut River. Journal of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, 2, 71–74. Deane, J. (1856). On the sandstone fossils of Connecticut River. Journal of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, 3, 173–178. Deane, J. (1861). Ichnographs from the Sandstone of Connecticut River, Little, Brown and Co., Boston, Massachusetts, 61 pp. Farlow, J.O. (1985). Introduction and volume notes. In: Schreiber, V.T. (Ed.), Bones for Barnum Brown, Texas Christian University Press, Fort Worth, Texas, pp. 1–15, 208–219. Farlow, J.O. and Lockley, M.G. (1989). Roland T. Bird, dinosaur tracker: an appreciation. In: Gillette, D.D. and Lockley, M.G. (Eds.), Dinosaur Tracks and Traces, Cambridge University Press, New York, pp. 33–36.
Farlow, J.O., Pittman, J.G. and Hawthorne, J.M. (1989). Brontopodus birdi, Lower Cretaceous Sauropod Footprints from the U.S. Gulf Coastal Plain. In: Gillette, D.D. and Lockley, M.G. (Eds.), Dinosaur Tracks and Traces, Cambridge University Press, New York, pp. 371–394. Foose, R.M. and Lancaster, J. (1981). Edward Hitchcock; New England geologist, minister and educator. Northeastern Geology, 3, 13–17. Guralnick, S.M. (1972). Geology and religion before Darwin: the case of Edward Hitchcock, theologian and geologist (1793–1864). Isis, 63, 529–543. Hitchcock, C.H. (1889). Recent progress in ichnology. Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History, 24, 117–127. Hitchcock, C.H. (1895). Edward Hitchcock. American Geologist, 133–149. Hitchcock, E. (1836a). Ornithichnology: description of the footmarks of birds (Ornithoidichnites) on New Red Sandstone in Massachusetts. American Journal of Science, 29, 307–340. Hitchcock, E. (1836b). Ornithichnites in Connecticut. American Journal of Science, 31, 174–175. Hitchcock, E. (1836c). Ornithichnology defended. Knickerbocker, 8, 289–295. Hitchcock, E. (1836d). Poetical remarks on reptile tracks from the Connecticut Valley. Knickerbocker, 8, 750–752. Hitchcock, E. (1837). Fossil footsteps in sandstone and graywacke. American Journal of Science, 32, 174–176. Hitchcock, E. (1840). Elementary Geology, J.S. and C. Adams, Amherst, Massachusetts. Hitchcock, E. (1841). Final Report on the Geology of Massachusetts, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Boston, 831 pp. Hitchcock, E. (1843). Description of five new species of fossil footmarks, from the red sandstone of the valley of Connecticut River. Association of American Geologists Report, 1, 254–264. Hitchcock, E. (1844a). Report on ichnolithology or fossil footmarks, with description of several new species and the coprolites of birds, and of a supposed footmark from the valley of Hudson River. American Journal of Science, 47, 292–322. Hitchcock, E. (1844b). Rejoinder to the preceding article of Dr. Deane. American Journal of Science, 47, 390–399. Hitchcock, E. (1845a). Extract of a letter from Prof. E. Hitchcock, embracing miscellaneous remarks upon fossil footmarks, the Lincolnite, etc, and a letter from Professor Richard Owen, on the great birds’ nests of New Holland. American Journal of Science, 48, 61–65. Hitchcock, E. (1845b). An attempt to name, classify, and describe the animals that made the fossil footmarks of New England. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 6, 23–25. Hitchcock, E. (1845c). Remarks on fossil footprints. American Journal of Science, 48, 159. Hitchcock, E. (1847). Description of two new species of fossil footmarks found in Massachusetts and Connecticut. American Journal of Science, Series 2, 4, 46–57. Hitchcock, E. (1848). An attempt to discriminate and describe the animals that made the fossil footmarks of the United States and especially of New England. Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, 1848, pp. 129–256. Hitchcock, E. (1854). On fossil footmarks of the Connecticut Valley. Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History, 1854, pp. 378–379. Hitchcock, E. (1855). Shark remains from the Coal Formation of Illinois, and bones and tracks from the Connecticut River Sandstone. American Journal of Science, Series 2, 20, 416–417.
REFERENCES
Hitchcock, E. (1856a). On a new fossil fish and new fossil footmarks. American Journal of Science, Series 2, 21, 96–100. Hitchcock, E. (1856b). Additional facts respecting the tracks of the Otozoum moodii on the Liassic sandstone of the Connecticut Valley. American Association for the Advancement of Science, Proceedings, 9, 228. Hitchcock, E. (1856c) On a new fossil fish, and new fossil footmarks. American Journal of Science, Series 2, 21, 96–100. Hitchcock, E. (1856d) Description of a new and remarkable species of fossil footmark, from the sandstone of Turners Falls, in the Connecticut Valley. American Journal of Science, Series 2, 21, 97–100. Hitchcock, E. (1857). On impressions in the sandstone from Turner’s Falls on Connecticut River, Massachusetts. Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History, 6, 111. Hitchcock, E. (1858). Ichnology of New England: A Report on the Sandstone of the Connecticut Valley, Especially its Fossil Footmarks, W. White, Boston, 220 pp. Hitchcock, E. (1861). Remarks upon certain points in ichnology. American Association for the Advancement of Science, Proceedings, 144–156. Hitchcock, E. (1862). Supplement to the ichnology of New England. Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, 6, 85–92. Hitchcock, E. (1863a). New facts and conclusions respecting the fossil footmarks of the Connecticut Valley. American Journal of Science, 36, 46–57. Hitchcock, E. (1863b). Reminiscences of Amherst College, Bridgman & Childs, Northampton, Massachusetts, 412 pp. Hitchcock, E. (1865). Supplement to the Ichnology of New England, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Boston, 96 pp. Hitchcock, E. (1866). Supplement to the ichnology of New England. Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, 85–92. Ishigaki, S. (1989). Footprints of swimming sauropods from Morocco. In: Gillette, D.D. and Lockley, M.G. (Eds.), Dinosaur Tracks and Traces, Cambridge University Press, New York, pp. 83–86. Jardine, W. (1853). The Ichnology of Annandale, W.H. Lizars, Edinburgh, 17 pp. Kuban, G. (1989). Elongate dinosaur tracks. In: Gillette, D.D. and Lockley, M.G. (Eds.), Dinosaur Tracks and Traces, Cambridge University Press, New York, pp. 57–72. Lawrence, P.J. (1972). Edward Hitchcock; the Christian geologist. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 116, 21–34. Lesley, J.P. (1877). Memoir of Edward Hitchcock, (1793–1864). National Academy of Sciences Biographical Memoirs, 113–134. Lewis, G.E. (1964). Memorial to Barnum Brown (1873–1963) Geological Society of America Bulletin , 75, pp. 19–20. Lockley, M.G. (1991). Tracking Dinosaurs, Cambridge University Press, New York, 238 pp. Lockley, M. and Hunt, A. (1995). Dinosaur Footprints and other Fossil Tracks of the Western United States, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 285 pp. Lockley, M.G., Houck, K. and Prince, N.K. (1986). North America’s largest dinosaur tracksite: implications for Morrison formation paleoecology. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 97, 1163–1176. Logan, W.E. (1842). Canadian Carboniferous footprints. Proceedings of the Geological Society of London, 3, 707. MacClary, J.S. (1938). Dinosaur trails of Purgatory. Scientific American, 158, 72. Marche´, J.D. (1991). Edward Hitchcock’s poem, The Sandstone Bird (1836). Earth Sciences History, 10, 5–8. Marche´, J.D. (1993). Edward Hitchcock’s promising astronomical career. Earth Sciences History, 12, 180–186.
51
Marsh, O.C., (1899). Footprints of Jurassic dinosaurs. American Journal of Science, Series 4, 7, pp. 227–232. Merrill, G.P. (1906). Contributions to the history of American geology. United States National Museum Report 1904, pp. 189–734. Olsen, P.E. and Rainforth, E.C. (2002). The ‘Age of Dinosaurs’ in the Newark Basin. American Paleontologist, 10, 2–5. Olsen, P.E., Kent, D.V., Cornet, B., Witte, W.K. and Schlische, R.W. (1996). High-resolution stratigraphy of the Newark rift basin (early Mesozoic, eastern North America), Geological Society of America, Bulletin, 106, pp. 40–77. Peabody, F.E. (1948). Reptile and amphibian trackways from the Lower Triassic Moenkopi formation of Arizona and Utah. Bulletin Geological Sciences, University of California, 27, 295–468. Pemberton, S.G. and Gingras, M.K. (2003). The Reverend Henry Duncan (1774–1846) and the discovery of the first fossil footprints. Ichnos, 10, 69–75. Pemberton, S.G., Sarjeant, W.A.S. and Torrens, H.S. (1996). Footsteps before the flood: the first scientific report of vertebrate footprints. Ichnos, 4, 321–323. Preston, D.J. (1988). Dinosaurs in the Attic, Ballantine Press, New York, 308 pp. Rogers, H.D., Rogers, W.B., Jackson, C.T. and Warren, J.C. (1855). Footprints and other impressions on Carboniferous red shale of Pennsylvania. Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History, 5, 182–186. Russell, D.A. and Be´land, P. (1976). Running dinosaurs. Nature, 264, 486. Sarjeant, W.A.S. (1975). Fossil tracks and impressions of vertebrates. In: Frey, R.W. (Ed.), The Study of Trace Fossils, Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 283–324. Shuler, E.W. (1917). Dinosaur tracks in the Glen Rose Limestone near Glen Rose, Texas. American Journal of Science, 44, 33–37. Simpson, G.G. (1942). The beginnings of vertebrate paleontology in North America. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 86, 130–188. Steinbock, R.T. (1989). Ichnology of the Connecticut Valley: a vignette of American science in the early 19th century. In: Gillette, D.D. and Lockley, M.G. (Eds.), Dinosaur Tracks and Traces, Cambridge University Press, New York, pp. 27–32. Sternberg, C.M. (1932). Dinosaur tracks from Peace River, British Columbia. Annual Report National Museum of Canada, pp. 59–85. Thulborn, R.A. (1981). Estimated speed of a giant bipedal dinosaur. Nature, 292, 273–274. Warren, E. (1860). The Life of John Collins Warren, M.D. Ticknor and Fields, Boston, Volume 2, pp. 382–420. Warren, J.C. (1852). The Mastodon giganteus of North America, John Wilson, Publisher, Boston, 219 pp. Warren, J.C. (1854a). Remarks on Some Fossil Impressions in the Sandstone Rocks of Connecticut River, Ticknor and Fields, Boston, 54 pp. Warren, J.C. (1854b). Remarks on fossil footprints form the Connecticut Valley. Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History, 5, 19–21. Warren, J.C. (1855). On raindrop impressions and footprints from the Connecticut River Sandstone. Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History, 5, 258. Warren, J.C. (1856). On new remarkable gigantic fossils and footmarks. Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History, 5, 298–300.
C
H
A
P
T
E
R
4 The Ichnofacies Paradigm: A Fifty-Year Retrospective James A. MacEachern, S. George Pemberton, Murray K. Gingras, and Kerrie L. Bann
SUMMARY : The ichnofacies paradigm endures as the elegant, unifying framework within which accurate ichnological observations and reliable environmental interpretations can be derived from the rock record. These temporally and geographically recurring, strongly facies-controlled groupings of trace fossils reflect specific combinations of organism behavior (ethology), and constitute the benchmark animal-sediment responses to optimum environmental conditions. Seilacherian ichnofacies are distinctive, archetypal associations of traces. Ichnofacies are part of the total aspect of the rock, and consist of primary biogenic structures imparted by organisms responding in predictable ways to variations in energy conditions, deposition rates, food resource types, substrate consistency, water salinity, oxygenation, subaerial exposure, substrate moisture, and temperature, among others. Like lithofacies, ichnofacies are subject to Walther’s Law, have lateral continuity, display predictable vertical successions, and lead to mappable constructs. Like all facies analyses, interpretations of ichnofaunas are improved substantially when evaluated in the context of the host rocks and their sedimentologic and stratigraphic implications.
wave energy, tidal flux, storm influence, fluvial-sediment input, subaqueous vs. subaerial exposure, salinity, temperature, substrate consistency, water turbidity, oxygenation, and other physicochemical factors. These factors can be very difficult to discern and apply to paleoenvironmental interpretations of the rock record. Ichnology constitutes a valuable tool in diagnosing many of these physico-chemical parameters in ancient systems, particularly when integrated with sedimentological and stratigraphic analysis. Trace fossils are unique, in that they are not merely paleontologic entities but also biogenic sedimentary structures, and must be evaluated in this sense. They are strongly facies controlled, and generally temporally long ranging, making them ideal for facies analysis. Ichnofossils are also readily observable at both outcrop and subsurface core scales, making their identification and interpretation as routine as that of physical sedimentary structures. The integration of both sedimentological and ichnological data, therefore, constitutes a powerful tool in the interpretation of ancient depositional systems. Ichnofacies consist of distinctive, recurring (both in space and time) ethological groupings of trace fossils, reflecting specific combinations of organism responses to environmental conditions. Interpretations of ichnofacies are enhanced when placed into the context of the original ichnocoenoses (temporally and genetically related trace fossils). It must be stressed that ichnofacies are not trace fossil
INTRODUCTION Modern depositional systems are characterized by a complex interaction of numerous physical, biological, and chemical processes, including
Copyright ß 2007, Elsevier B.V. Trace Fossils: Concepts, Problems, Prospects
52
All rights reserved.
THE RISE OF THE ICHNOFACIES CONCEPT
suites; rather, they are conceptual constructs based on numerous empirical observations, to which particular ichnocoenoses are attributable. The ichnofacies paradigm offers critical information about the conditions operating during deposition (e.g., softground ichnofacies) or during colonization of stratigraphic discontinuities (e.g., substrate-controlled ichnofacies and palimpsest softground ichnofacies). One of the strengths of the ichnofacies concept lies in its ease of integration with classical physical sedimentologic facies analysis, and its adherence to Walther’s Law (the basic tenet of sedimentary geology). The close ties of ichnofacies with lithofacies are further highlighted by the advent of genetic stratigraphic frameworks. Marine and marginal marine discontinuities are commonly demarcated by substrate-controlled trace fossil suites, and there is hardly an article published since 1995 dealing with such stratigraphic discontinuities that has not acknowledged the presence of omission suites attributable to the Glossifungites, Teredolites, and/or Trypanites ichnofacies. Past misuse or misconception of ‘ichnofacies’ has led to considerable scrutiny and discussion of the concept (e.g., Ekdale, 1988; Frey et al., 1990; Bromley and Asgaard, 1991; Pickerill, 1992; Goldring, 1993; Savrda, 1995; Bromley, 1996). Some researchers have argued that if employed independently of lithofacies, the utility of ichnofacies may lead to limited resolution, and may yield grossly over-generalized results (Goldring, 1993; Savrda, 1995). Certainly, any interpretation that ignores the complete dataset is prone to inaccuracy or imprecision. Properly done, however, ichnofacies analysis is fully integrated with the sedimentology, paleontology, and stratigraphy of the succession, and emerges as a powerful tool for highresolution reconstructions of depositional environments (e.g., Kern and Warme, 1974; Crimes et al., 1981; Wightman et al., 1987; Frey et al., 1990; MacEachern and Pemberton, 1992, 1994; MacEachern et al., 1992, 1999; Pemberton and MacEachern, 1995, 1997; Bromley, 1996; Gingras et al., 1998; Pemberton et al., 2001; Bann and Fielding, 2004; Bann et al., 2004; Fielding et al., 2006; MacEachern and Gingras, in press). Without the coherent underpinning of the ichnofacies concept, trace fossil identifications, ichnologic assemblages, and ichnofabric designations have no conceptual basis for interpretation. The ability to understand and therefore utilize ichnology in sedimentology and stratigraphy is contingent upon the unifying paradigm of ichnofacies.
53
THE RISE OF THE ICHNOFACIES CONCEPT From the perspective of paleoenvironmental reconstruction of facies, nothing compares to the quantum leap in our comprehension of biogenically modified strata than that imparted by the development of the ichnofacies concept. This contribution cannot be overstated: the ichnofacies model elevated ichnology from the obscure concern with animal and plant ‘scribbles’ on rocks and disruptions in modern sediments, to a valuable facies analysis tool, superbly suited to outcrop and subsurface studies. As a conceptual framework, it forms the template within which ichnological data can be interpreted environmentally. The concept of ichnofacies was developed by Adolf Seilacher in the 1950s and 1960s (Seilacher, 1953a,b, 1967), originally based on the empirical observation that many of the parameters controlling the distribution of tracemakers tended to change progressively with increasing water depth (Fig. 4.1). In response to the potential geological value of this bathymetric relationship, the ‘Seilacherian’ ichnofacies framework soon came to be regarded almost exclusively (albeit erroneously) as a relative paleobathymeter (e.g., Weimer and Hoyt, 1964; Farrow, 1966). Though ichnofacies remain essential to environmental reconstructions, paleobathymetry is only one aspect of the modern concept. The principal controls on ichnofacies distributions tend to change progressively with bathymetry, and so ichnofacies are properly regarded to display a passive relationship to water depth (e.g., Ekdale et al., 1984; Ekdale, 1988; Frey et al., 1990). Organism behaviors, and their resulting biogenic structures are principally controlled by factors such as substrate consistency, energy near the bed, food resource types, water turbidity, water salinity, depositional rates, oxygenation, and temperature, among others (Fig. 4.1). Seilacher (1967) defined six original ichnofacies, named for a characteristic ichnotaxon. These fall into four softground marine types (Skolithos, Cruziana, Zoophycos, and Nereites), one substrate-controlled type (Glossifungites), and a single softground continental type (Scoyenia). Frey and Seilacher (1980) added the Trypanites Ichnofacies to characterize borings associated with hardground substrates. Bromley et al. (1984) introduced the Teredolites Ichnofacies to encompass borings into xylic (woody) substrates. Frey and Pemberton (1987) proposed the Psilonichnus Ichnofacies for permanent vertical to inclined
54
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
Seilacher's Concept of Recurring Ichnofacies TRACE FOSSILS
BEHAVIOR
ENVIRONMENT
Trace fossils are a manifestation of behavior which can be modified by the environment.
Agrichnia
Cubichnia
Feeding
Fodinichnia
Resting
Fugichnia
Dwelling
Locomotion
Pascichnia Domichina
A
B ECOLOGICAL CONTROLS
C
Distributions and behaviors of benthic organisms are limited by interrelated ecological controls, including:
D
Soupground
Softground
Looseground
Stiffground
Nereites Zoophycos
1. Sedimentation Rate
5. Turbidity
2. Substrate Coherence
6. Light
3. Salinity
7. Temperature
4. Oxygen Level
8. Depositional Energy
Firmground
Hardground
Woodground
Zoophycos
Cruziana Mermia Skolithos Psilonichnus Scoyenia Glossifungites Trypanites Coprinisphaera Entobia Gnathichnus Teredolites
FIGURE 4.1 Seilacher’s concept of recurring ichnofacies. (A) Ethological classification of trace fossils and their relationships with body fossils (Modified from Pemberton et al., 2001). (B) Behavioral classification of biogenic structures. With environmental fluctuations, virtually all traces are intergradational with the fugichnia (Modified from Pemberton et al., 2001). (C) Ecological controls that affect the distribution of trace-making organisms, many of which change predictably with relative water depth. (D) Relationship of substrate type and the distribution of the named ichnofacies.
CONTINENTAL ICHNOFACIES
dwellings in sand-prone substrates typical of high intertidal and supratidal coastal settings. These constitute the nine ichnofacies that have demonstrated recurrence both spatially and temporally. More recently, the hardground setting has been proposed to include two additional ichnofacies (Gnathichnus and Entobia) (Bromley and Asgaard, 1993). The continental setting has likewise seen some expansion, with the initial proposal of the Termitichnus Ichnofacies to address assemblages associated with paleosols (Smith et al., 1993) and Mermia Ichnofacies to reflect suites occupying lacustrine settings (Buatois and Ma´ngano, 1995). Since then, the Termitichnus Ichnofacies has been discarded, in favor of the Coprinisphaera Ichnofacies (Genise et al., 2000).
CONTINENTAL ICHNOFACIES There are currently three continental ichnofacies: Scoyenia, Mermia, and Coprinisphaera (Table 4.1). The systematic ichnological analysis of the continental realm has been a relatively recent development, with an ever increasing number of case studies being added to the developing models. Researchers have demonstrated that the continental regime is far more diverse and complex ichnologically than previously considered. Buatois and Ma´ngano (2004) have recently summarized the Mermia and Scoyenia ichnofacies, typical of permanently to intermittently aquatic continental environments. Genise et al. (2000, 2004) have summarized many of the principal elements of the Coprinisphaera Ichnofacies, characteristic of more or less permanently terrestrial conditions, ranging from dry and cold to humid and warm climates. Donovan (1994) and Hasiotis (2002) have approached the study of continental ichnology from slightly different perspectives, yielding innovative insights into these regimes as well.
Scoyenia Ichnofacies Frey et al. (1984) summarized and refined the original designation of Seilacher’s (1967) Scoyenia Ichnofacies, and concluded that it remained a valid recurring grouping. Buatois and Ma´ngano (1995) further refined the Scoyenia Ichnofacies, and placed it within a broader continental spectrum. The Scoyenia Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.2A, Table 4.1) is characteristic of low-energy continental settings characterized by periodically subaerial conditions. Most settings are inundated intermittently with freshwater. Common depositional environments include lake margins,
55
fluvial channel margins and overbanks, progressively desiccated crevasse splays, and wet interdune areas (e.g., Seilacher, 1967; Ekdale et al., 1984; Frey et al., 1984; Frey and Pemberton, 1987; Bromley and Asgaard, 1991; Buatois and Ma´ngano, 1995, 2004). The Scoyenia Ichnofacies encompasses trace fossil suites that consist of: (1) horizontal, meniscate (backfilled) structures made by mobile deposit-feeding organisms (e.g., Scoyenia (Fig. 4.2D), Beaconites, Taenidium, and adhesive meniscate burrows; Fig. 4.2E); (2) horizontal, mobile deposit-feeding structures (e.g., Planolites); locomotion traces, including tracks and trails (e.g., Umfolozia, Hexapodichnus, Acripes, and Cochlichnus); (3) fish fin markings (e.g., Undichna; Fig. 4.2F); (4) vertical dwelling structures (e.g., Camborygma, Macanopsis, Skolithos, and Cylindricum); (5) horizontal dwelling structures (e.g., Palaeophycus); (6) a mixture of invertebrate (predominantly arthropod) and vertebrate structures (dwelling structures and footprints); and (7) plant root traces. Suites tend to display low to moderate diversities, with localized high abundances. Ornamented structures and scratch marks (e.g., Scoyenia) are more typical of endobenthic activity during subaerial exposure and substrate desiccation. The Scoyenia Ichnofacies may comprise two distinct expressions: one characterized by meniscate, backfilled structures without ornamentation developed in a soft substrate, and the second characterized by striated traces developed in a firm substrate, which commonly cross-cut the former (Buatois and Ma´ngano, 2004).
Mermia Ichnofacies The Mermia Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.2B, Table 4.1) was proposed by Buatois and Ma´ngano (1995) for freshwater assemblages associated with low energy, permanently subaqueous conditions, largely characterized by high degrees of environmental stability. Such suites probably record the highest preservation potential of all continental regimes (Buatois and Ma´ngano, 2004). In recent years, a number of case studies identifying the Mermia Ichnofacies have been recorded. Buatois and Ma´ngano (1995) included a table summarizing occurrences of the Mermia Ichnofacies from the Carboniferous to the Pleistocene. Suites attributable to the Mermia Ichnofacies are characterized by a dominance of horizontal to subhorizontal grazing (e.g., Mermia, Gordia; Fig. 4.2G, Cochlichnus, and Helminthoidichnites) and feeding traces produced by mobile detritus and deposit feeders (e.g., Planolites, Treptichnus, and Circulichnus),
56
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
TABLE 4.1 Summary of Basic Features and Environmental Implications of Continental Ichnofacies. (Modified from Buatois and Ma´ngano, 1995 and Pemberton et al., 2001) Characteristic Trace Fossils
Typical Benthic Environment Scoyenia Ichnofacies
Small, horizontal, lined, back-filled feeding burrows; curved to
Moist to wet, pliable, argillaceous to sandy sediment at low energy
tortuous, unlined feeding burrows; crawling traces, vertical cylindrical to irregular shafts; tracks and trails. Invertebrates
sites; either very slightly submerged lacustrine or fluviatile deposits periodically becoming emergent, or water side subaerial deposits
mostly deposit feeders and predators; vertebrates are grovellers,
periodically or becoming submergent; semi-aquatic vegetation may
predators or herbivores. Invertebrate diversity typically low, yet
be present. Intermediate between fully aquatic and non-aquatic,
some traces may be abundant. Vertebrate tracks may be diverse and
continental settings. Physical sedimentary structures may include
abundant around water bodies; dung or coprolites occur locally.
desiccation cracks and allied features. Typical sedimentary envir-
Trackways moderately diverse and dominant in Paleozoic exam-
onments: transitional alluvial lake zones, floodplains, ephemeral
ples. Arthropods comprise the most important invertebrate trace-
lakes, ponds, and wet interdunes.
maker. Typical components include Scoyenia, Beaconites, Planolites, Skolithos, Cruziana, Rusophycus, Camborygma, Palaeophycus, Umfolozia, Acripes, and vertebrate tracks. Mermia Ichnofacies Small, horizontal to subhorizontal, simple, non-specialized grazing
Non-cohesive, fine-grained sediment in well-oxygenated, low
trails dominant; common feeding traces; rare locomotion traces.
energy, permanently subaqueous zones; sedimentation rates are
Tracemakers mostly mobile deposit feeders. Diversity moderate to
normally low, but punctuated episodic deposition (e.g., turbidity
high. Colonization suites are typically of low diversity. Producers
currents, density underflows) may occur. Physical sedimentary
may include annelids, arthropods, nematodes, nematomorphs, oligochaetes, bivalves, gastropods, and fishes. Trails are dominant
structures may include parallel lamination, ripple cross-lamination, normal grading, tool and flute marks, as well as soft-sediment
in Paleozoic examples, whereas an increase in burrows is recorded in
deformation structures. Typical sedimentary environments include
post-Paleozoic occurrences. Typical components include Mermia,
deep and shallow lakes, and fjord lakes.
Gordia, Helminthoidichnites, Cochlichnus, Treptichnus, Undichna, Lockeia, Tuberculichnus, Maculichna, and Planolites. Coprinisphaera Ichnofacies Large and small traces, mostly dwelling burrows (including
Soft to incipient cohesive muddy, silty, sandy and marly sediment,
breeding structures), less common feeding burrows, rhizoliths, tracks, coprolites, and bite traces in leaves. Termite, bee, and beetle
in low-energy terrestrial areas; associated plant growth is highly variable, from humid forest to open country. Associated inorganic
nests are typical. Ichnodiversity is moderate to high. Tracemakers
sedimentary structures include parallel lamination, erosive sur-
comprise a mixture of vertebrates (mainly mammals), invertebrates
faces, and a wide variety of paleosol and diagenetic features (e.g.,
(particularly various types of arthropods, as well as oligochaetes and
concretions). Sedimentary environments include various types of
annelids), and plants. Typical components include Coprinisphaera,
mature and, more rarely, immature paleosols developed within
Termitichnus, Edaphichnium, Scaphichnium, Celliforma, Macanopsis,
alluvial plains, desiccated floodplains, abandoned fluvial bars,
Ichnogyrus, Attaichnus, Pallichnus, Daimonelix, and Uruguay.
zones marginal to dune fields, and coastal plains.
as well as subordinate occurrences of locomotion traces (e.g., Undichna and Maculichna). Assemblages generally lack striated or scratch-marked structures, and vertebrate trackways. Fish, amphibian, reptile, and possibly even mammal feeding structures may, however, be present. Suites display relatively high to moderate diversities and abundances, particularly for lacustrine settings that are hydrologically open. Restriction of the water body commonly leads to heightened salinities and oxygen reduction, and ichnogenera diversities decline markedly. Consequently, ephemeral lakes may be largely devoid of bioturbation.
Coprinisphaera Ichnofacies The Coprinisphaera Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.2C, Table 4.1) was erected by Genise et al. (2000) to accommodate suites associated with more or less permanently subarially exposed continental settings. Their analysis showed the recurrence of 28 suites derived from 58 paleosol intervals, reflecting a variety of geographic locations. Recurrence in time is less clearly extensive, with assemblages spanning the Paleocene to Holocene. Ethologically, the principal grouping is nesting/breeding (calichnia), but suites also include dwellings employed as refugia, aestivation, and ambush
57
CONTINENTAL ICHNOFACIES
amb
amb
amb
Sc
Sc
A D
amb
E
F
U
B
Go
F
G
amb
Tm
C
H
FIGURE 4.2 Schematic block diagrams of continental ichnofacies. (A) Diagram of the Scoyenia Ichnofacies. Traces include Ancorichnus (An), adhesive meniscate burrows (amb), Camborygma (Ca), Cochlichnus (Cl), tetrapod footprints (F), Macanopsis (M), Palaeophycus tubularis (Pt), Planolites (P), rhizoliths (R), Scoyenia (Sc), and Skolithos (S). (B) Diagram of the Mermia Ichnofacies. Traces include bivalve dwellings, Cochlichnus (Cl), Gordia (Go), Helminthoidichnites (He), Mermia (Me), Planolites (P), Treptichnus (Tr), Palaeophycus tubularis (Pt), and Undichna (U). (C) Diagram of the Coprinisphaera Ichnofacies. Traces include Celliforma (Ce), Coprinisphaera (Co), Eatonichnus (Ea), footprints (F), roots (Rt), Skolithos (S), adhesive meniscate burrows (amb), Teisseirei (Ti), and Termitichnus (Tm). (D) Scratch-marked expression of Scoyenia (Sc), with meniscate visible in the right-hand example, Triassic Tarkastad Subgroup, Karoo Basin, South Africa. (E) Adhesive meniscate burrows (amb), Lower Cretaceous Mannville, Group, Alberta, Canada. (F) Modern Undichna (U), formed by the pectoral fins of fish, and tetrapod footprints (F) in mud, Australia. (G) Gordia (Go), Upper Permian Balfour Formation, Karoo Basin, South Africa. (H) Termitichnus (Tm), Pleistocene of the Karoo Basin, South Africa. Photo (D) courtesy of Dr. Fiona J. Evans.
58
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
predation. Some mobile deposit-feeding structures, larger (vertebrate) domiciles, and rhizoliths may also be included in some suites. Predominant tracemakers include bees, ants, wasps, beetles, termites, and other unassigned insects. The ichnofacies namesake is for one of the most common structures; the nest structure of dung beetles. Trace fossil suites are prone to complex tiering patterns, particularly in mature soils, reflecting the variable depths of emplacement of hymenopterous, termite, and dung beetle nests. Suites show moderate to relatively high diversity, and generally high abundance of traces, particularly in mature paleosols. The suites attributable to the Coprinisphaera Ichnofacies typically contain dung beetle nests (Coprinisphaera), bee traces (e.g., Celliforma, Uruguay, Ellipsoideichnus, Palmiraichnus, and Rosellichnus), wasp nests (e.g., Chubutolithes), ant traces (e.g., Attaichus and Parowanichnus), other beetle traces (e.g., Monesichnus, Fontanai, Pallichnus, Eatonichnus, and Teisseirei), and termite nests (e.g., Termitichnus; Fig. 4.2H, Syntermesichnus, and Tacuruichnus). Various larger mammal ‘caves’ may also be present, and the ichnofacies probably includes dwelling networks of rodents and other burrowing organisms. Settings characteristic of the Coprinisphaera Ichnofacies correspond to paleosols developed in paleoecosystems of herbaceous communities. This may effectively limit the ichnofacies to units ranging from Late Cretaceous to the Holocene as there were no herbaceous communities earlier in Earth history. Climatically, settings range from arid and cold steppes (dominated by hymenopterous nests) to humid and hot subtropical savannas (dominated by termite nests). Paleosol settings occupy alluvial plains, desiccated floodplains, crevassse splays, levees, abandoned point bars, and vegetated eolian environments (Genise et al., 2000). These settings are strongly controlled by microclimates (e.g., temperature, radiation, humidity, and wind speed near the ground) associated with vegetation, topography, and overall climatic conditions (cf. Hasiotis, Chapter 16).
SOFTGROUND MARINE ICHNOFACIES Softground ichnofacies tend to be differentiated from one another by variables that are typically depth related. The Zoophycos and Nereites ichnofacies are more characteristic of deeper-water environments, whereas the Psilonichnus, Skolithos, and Cruziana ichnofacies are represented in nearshore marine or coastal environments (Table 4.2). Summaries of the
ichnology of marine shoreface environments can be found in publications such as MacEachern and Pemberton (1992), Bromley (1996), MacEachern et al. (1999), Pemberton et al. (2001), and Bann et al. (2004). The Zoophycos Ichnofacies and especially the Nereites Ichnofacies tend to characterize outer shelf, slope, and bathyal to abyssal settings. For details on the ichnology of deep-marine deposits, see Uchman (2004).
Psilonichnus Ichnofacies The Psilonichnus Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.3A, Table 4.2) represents a mixture of marine, quasi-marine, and non-marine conditions. Typical environments include the beach backshore, coastal dunes, washover fans, and supratidal flats. Frey and Pemberton (1987) indicated that such environments are subject to extreme variations in energy levels, sediment types, and physical and biogenic sedimentary structures. Marine processes generally dominate during spring tides and storm surges, whereas maritime eolian processes predominate during neap tides and nonstorm periods. Such conditions can result in alternations of wind and water deposition, producing complex, truncated laminae dipping shallowly in diverse directions. Owing to their topographic position, few such substrates are available to benthic marine animals. The only persistent, notable exceptions are amphibious crabs of the Family Ocypodidae (Figs. 4.3B,D), which include both scavengers and surficial deposit feeders; these animals typically excavate J-, Y-, or U-shaped dwelling burrows referable to the trace fossil Psilonichnus (Fig. 4.3C,E and F). The mud shrimp Upogebia can also construct Psilonichnus in subaqueous estuarine mouth deposits, where it constitutes part of the Skolithos Ichnofacies (Nesbitt and Campbell, 2002). Other biogenic structures are generated by essentially terrestrial organisms and include: (1) the vertical shafts of insects and spiders; (2) the horizontal tunnels of other insects and tetrapods; and (3) the ephemeral tracks, trails, and fecal pellets of insects, reptiles, birds, and mammals. The other major type of biogenic structure relates to plant-root penetrations. The types of plants able to exploit these substrates range from intertidal halophytes on the distal margins of some washover fans, to maritime or terrestrial grasses, weeds, vines, shrubs, bushes, and trees on backshore dunes. To the extent that ocypodid crab burrows may occur in the uppermost foreshore or the upper part of
59
SOFTGROUND MARINE ICHNOFACIES
TABLE 4.2 Recurring Archetypal Marine Softground Trace Fossil Associations and their Common (but not exclusive) Environmental Implications (Adapted from Pemberton et al., 2001) Characteristic Trace Fossils
Typical Benthic Environment Psilonichnus Ichnofacies (shifting substrates I)
Predominantly vertical small shafts, some with bulbous basal cells, to
Supralittoral to upper littoral, moderate to low-energy marine and/or
larger, irregularly J-, Y-, or U-shaped dwelling burrows; local invertebrate and vertebrate crawling and foraging traces or surficial
eolian conditions subject to modification by torrential rains or storm surges. Associated with well-sorted, variably laminated to cross-
tunnels; algal mats, vertebrate tracks and coprolites may be present.
stratified sands, to root- and burrow-mottled, poorly sorted sands or
Invertebrates mostly predators or scavengers of low diversity.
muddy sands. A common coastal setting, typically represented by the
Vertebrates mostly predators or herbivores; diversity may be
beach backshore and dunes, but also by washover fans and supratidal
appreciable locally. In pre-Cretaceous occurrences, crab-like dwelling
flats. Intergradational with the maritime terrestrial zone.
structures may be absent. Skolithos Ichnofacies (shifting substrates II) Vertical, cylindrical or U-shaped dwelling burrows; protrusive and retrusive spreiten in some U-burrows, developed mainly in response
Lower littoral to infralittoral, moderate to relatively high-energy conditions most typical. Associated with slightly muddy to clean,
to substrate aggradation or degradation (escape or equilibrium
well-sorted, shifting sediments subject to abrupt erosion or deposi-
structures); forms of Ophiomorpha consisting predominantly of vertical
tion. Higher energy increases physical reworking and obliterates
or steeply inclined shafts. Animals are chiefly suspension feeders or
biogenic sedimentary structures, leaving a preserved record of
passive (tubicolous) carnivores. Diversity is low, though given kinds of
physical stratification. Generally corresponds to the beach foreshore
burrows may be abundant. Vertebrate biogenic structures may occur
and shoreface; but numerous other settings of comparable energy
locally, especially in low-energy intertidal settings.
levels also may be represented, such as some estuarine point bars,
tidal deltas, and deep-sea fans. Cruziana Ichnofacies (shifting to stable substrates) Abundant crawling traces, both epi- and intrastratal; inclined
In shallow marine settings, typically includes infralittoral to shallow
U-shaped burrows with mostly protrusive spreiten (feeding swaths;
circalittoral substrates below minimum but not maximum wave base,
soft-sediment
Rhizocorallium);
forms
of
Ophiomorpha
and
to somewhat quieter conditions offshore; moderate to relatively low
Thalassinoides consisting of irregularly inclined to horizontal compo-
energy; well-sorted silts and sands, to interbedded muddy and clean
nents; scattered vertical cylindrical burrows (suspension feeders or
sands, moderately to intensely bioturbated; negligible to appreciable
passive carnivores). Animals may include mobile carnivores as well
(though not necessarily rapid) sedimentation. A very common type of
as various mixtures of suspension and deposit feeders. Diversity and abundance generally high, although crawling traces of limited
depositional environment, including not only shelves and epeiric embayments but also littoral to sub-littoral parts of certain estuaries,
diversity may predominate in certain Paleozoic nearshore settings.
bays, lagoons, and tidal flats.
Zoophycos Ichnofacies (oxygen-poor settings) Relatively simple to moderately complex, efficiently executed grazing
Circalittoral to bathyal, quiet-water conditions, or protected intra-
traces and shallow feeding structures; spreiten typically planar to
coastal to epeiric sites (silled basins, restricted lagoons) with muds or
gently inclined, distributed in delicate sheets, ribbons, lobes, or
muddy sands rich in organic matter but more or less deficient in
spirals (flattened forms of Zoophycos or, in pelitic sediments,
oxygen. Epeiric or coastal sites reflect somewhat stagnant waters.
Phycosiphon). Virtually all animals are deposit feeders. Diversity is very low, though given structures are typically abundant. The
Offshore sites range from just below maximum wave base to fairly deep water, in areas free of turbidity flows or significant bottom
ichnogenus Zoophycos may also be abundant in the Cruziana and
currents. Where relict or palimpsest substrates are present, particu-
Nereites ichnofacies, under normal oxygen levels; occurrences of the
larly if swept by shelf-edge or deeper water contour currents, this
ichnogenus thus do not necessarily constitute the ichnofacies.
ichnofacies may be omitted in the transition from infralittoral to abyssal environments.
Nereites Ichnofacies (turbidite-type settings) Complex grazing traces and patterned feeding/dwelling structures,
Bathyal to abyssal, mostly quiet but oxygenated waters, in places
reflecting highly organized, efficient behavior; spreiten structures typically nearly planar, although Zoophycos forms are spiraled,
interrupted by down-slope or down-canyon bottom currents or turbidity flows (flysch settings). Resident pelagic muds are typically
multilobed, or otherwise very complex. Numerous crawling/grazing
bounded above and below by turbidites, some exhibiting complete
traces and sinuous fecal castings (Helminthoida, Cosmorhaphe), mostly
Bouma cycles. In more distal regions, the sedimentary record is
intrastratal. Animals, chiefly deposit feeders or scavengers, although
mainly one of continuous deposition and bioturbation; few physical
some may trap or farm microbes within essentially permanent, open
or biogenic structures are preserved, unlike the Nereites Ichnofacies
domiciles (Paleodictyon, Megagrapton). Diversity and abundance are
sensu stricto.
generally significant.
60
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
Ps
Ps
tb
tb
FIGURE 4.3 The Psilonichnus Ichnofacies. (A) Diagram of the Psilonichnus Ichnofacies developed in a back-barrier coastal dune setting. Traces include Aulichnites (Au), Lockeia (Lo), Macanopsis (M), Planolites (P), Protovirgularia (Pr), Psilonichnus (Ps), and rhizoliths (R). (B) Opening of modern Ocypoda quadrata in the backshore (arrow). (C) Y-shaped Psilonichnus (Ps) of the modern ghost crab in the backshore of Sapelo Island, Georgia, USA. (D) Ocypoda quadrata and the burrows that it makes (arrows) in the backshore, St. Catherines Island, Georgia, USA. (E) Outcrop photo of an inferred Psilonichnus (Ps), Pleistocene outcrop, Willapa Bay, Washington, USA. It is infilled with rhythmic (passive) laminations. (F) Resin cast of the burrows (unlabeled arrows) of Hemigrapsus oregonensis (shore crab) from the middle intertidal zone, Willapa Bay, Washington. Notable are the chelae impressions and (locally) commensal threadworm burrows (tb), likely of the capitellid polychaete Heteromastus.
SOFTGROUND MARINE ICHNOFACIES
estuarine point bars, the Psilonichnus Ichnofacies may slightly overlap the Skolithos Ichnofacies; however, the boundary between these two ichnofacies is normally distinct. In contrast, because of its potentially large numbers of terrestrial traces, the Psilonichnus Ichnofacies may be broadly intergradational with the continental Scoyenia and Coprinisphaera ichnofacies.
Skolithos Ichnofacies The Skolithos Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.4A, Table 4.2) is indicative of relatively high levels of wave or current energy, and is typically developed in clean, well-sorted, loose or shifting particulate substrates. Abrupt changes in rates of deposition, erosion, and physical reworking of sediments are characteristic. Such conditions commonly occur on the shoreface and sheltered foreshores, but similar conditions may occur in a wide range of depositional environments (e.g., proximal wave-dominated delta fronts, sandy bars and spits, tidal channels and inlets, flood- and ebb -tidal deltas, sandy bay margins, low intertidal sand flats, estuary mouth complexes, and submarine fans). Associated stratification features typically consist of fine-scale, parallel to subparallel, gently seaward-dipping laminae (swash zone cross-strata) to large- and small-scale, multidirectional trough cross-stratification with current ripple cross-laminae. In strongly storm-dominated settings, low-angle, undulatory parallel lamination may be erosionally amalgamated into thick bedsets of swaley cross-stratification (SCS). In turbidites, beds may display massive, horizontal planar parallel, and current ripple cross-lamination (Bouma A, B, and C divisions). Settings characterized by tidal processes may show trough cross-beds and current ripples with cyclic development of mud drapes on foresets (i.e., tidal bundles), bidirectional orientations, and/or thin lenses of mud in the ripple troughs (i.e., flaser bedding). As dictated by fundamental interrelationships of water agitation, sediment transport, and animal distribution, most tracemakers are suspension feeders. Substrates serve mainly as an anchoring medium. Infaunal organisms typically construct deeply penetrating, more or less permanent domiciles (Figs. 4.4B–I). Depth of burrowing in the intertidal zone is controlled, in part, by tidal range and height of the low-tide interstitial water column in the substrate. During low-tide, moist sediments at depth help to buffer organisms against desiccation and salinity or temperature shock, and also help to provide respiratory water. In both intertidal and high-energy
61
subtidal settings, deep burrowing is one means of escaping the instability of the ever-shifting substrate surface (Fig. 4.4). The Skolithos Ichnofacies is characterized by: (1) predominantly vertical, cylindrical, or U-shaped burrows; (2) protrusive and retrusive spreiten in some U-burrows, which develop in response to substrate aggradation or degradation, respectively; (3) few horizontal structures; (4) few structures produced by mobile organisms; (5) low diversity suites, although individual forms may be abundant; (6) predominance of dwelling burrows constructed by suspension feeders or passive carnivores; and (7) vertebrate traces in some low-energy intertidal settings. Typical ichnogenera include Skolithos (Fig. 4.4I), Diplocraterion (Fig. 4.4H), Ophiomorpha (Fig. 4.4C,G and I), Conichnus (Fig. 4.4E,F,) Bergaueria, Lingulichnus, Piscichnus, Schaubcylindrichnus, Palaeophycus, Arenicolites (Fig. 4.4B), and Gyrolithes saxonicus. Possible depositfeeding structures that can be associated with the Skolithos Ichnofacies include Taenidium, Siphonichnus, Macaronichnus, Cylindrichnus, and Rosselia (Fig. 4.4D). The Skolithos Ichnofacies ordinarily grades landward into supratidal or terrestrial zones and seaward into the Cruziana Ichnofacies. The landward boundary tends to be more abrupt than the latter. Finally, the Skolithos Ichnofacies may appear in slightly to substantially deeper-water deposits, wherever energy levels, food supplies, and/or hydrographic and substrate characteristics are suitable (Crimes et al., 1981). Potential examples include submarine canyons, deep-sea fans, and bathyal slopes swept by strong contour currents. Therefore, as emphasized previously, paleobathymetric interpretations cannot be based solely on checklists of trace fossil names: evaluation of associated physical sedimentary structures, stratigraphic position, and other facies evidence is essential, even in normal beach-to-offshore successions.
Cruziana Ichnofacies The Cruziana Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.5A, Table 4.2) is most characteristic of permanently subtidal, poorly sorted, and unconsolidated cohesive (muddy) substrates in shallow marine settings typified by uniform salinity. Conditions typically range from moderate energy levels lying below fair-weather (minimum) wave base but above storm wave base, to lower energy levels in deeper, quieter waters. The most common settings correspond to the offshore extending to the very distal fringes of the lower shoreface. Variably impoverished
62
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
B
A
C
D
E
F
O
Sk
O
O
Sk O
Sk
G
H
I
FIGURE 4.4 The Skolithos Ichnofacies. (A) Schematic block diagrams of the Skolithos Ichnofacies (artwork by Tom Saunders). (B) Sandstone with Arenicolites (arrow), Upper Cretaceous Horseshoe Canyon Formation, Alberta. (C) Siderite-cemented Ophiomorpha borneensis (arrow) from the Upper Cretaceous Appaloosa Sandstone, Drumheller, Alberta. (D) Vertically stacked (re-equilibrated), siderite-cemented Rosselia socialis (arrow), Upper Cretaceous Appaloosa Sandstone, Drumheller, Alberta. Rosselia is a common ichnogenus associated with the Skolithos Ichnofacies in storm-dominated successions, though it is a facies-crossing element of the Cruziana Ichnofacies. (E) Conichnus conicus (upper arrow) with associated escape/collapse structure (lower arrow) in upper shoreface deposits of the Upper Cretaceous Blackhawk Formation, Book Cliffs, Utah. (F) Conichnus conicus (arrow) from upper shoreface deposits of the Upper Cretaceous Appaloosa Sandstone, Drumheller, Alberta. (G) Ophiomorpha nodosa (arrow) with siderite-cemented pelleted margins, from the proximal lower shoreface deposits of the Upper Cretaceous Sego Sandstone, Utah. (H) Abundant Diplocraterion habichi (arrows), Middle Jurassic Fensfjord Formation, Northern North Sea, Norway. (I) Thick tempestite of the middle shoreface, with Ophiomorpha nodosa (O) and unlined Skolithos linearis (Sk), Upper Cretaceous Appaloosa Sandstone, Drumheller, Alberta.
63
SOFTGROUND MARINE ICHNOFACIES
Helminthopsis Proximal Expression Rosselia Chondrites Distal Expression
Ophiomorpha
Schaubcylindrichnus
B Archetypal Rhizocorallium Asterosoma
A
D
C
E H
Ch P Te
Z
Te As
Ph
Ch Ph
Z
Ch
Pa
Ch Rh
F
G
H
I
As
FIGURE 4.5 The Cruziana Ichnofacies. (A) Diagram of the Cruziana Ichnofacies showing the archetypal as well as distal and proximal expressions (artwork by Tom Saunders). (B) Sideritecemented Rosselia socialis (arrow), Lower Cretaceous Viking Formation, Alberta. (C) Complete Asterosoma (arrow) exposed on bedding plane of outcrop, Upper Cretaceous Cardium Formation, Alberta. (D) Asterosoma lobes (arrows) in outcrop, Upper Cretaceous Blackhawk Formation, Book Cliffs, Utah. (E) Silicified Thalassinoides (arrow) showing Y-shaped branch, Mississippian Mount Head Formation, Mount Greenock, Jasper, Alberta. (F) Storm-bedded upper offshore deposits, with Teichichnus (Te) and Chondrites (Ch), Upper Cretaceous Cardium Formation, Alberta. (G) Heterolithic distal delta front deposits, with dense Chondrites (Ch), small Teichichnus (Te), Planolites (P), and Rhizocorallium (Rh), Lower Cretaceous Bow Island Formation, Alberta. (H) Upper offshore deposits with Asterosoma (As) (reburrowed with Chondrites), Phycosiphon (Ph), and robust Chondrites (Ch), Upper Cretaceous Cardium Formation, Alberta. (I) Upper offshore deposits with Helminthopsis (H), Zoophycos (Z), Phycosiphon (Ph), Palaeophycus (Pa), and Asterosoma (As), Upper Cretaceous Cardium Formation, Alberta.
64
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
expressions of the ichnofacies may also correspond to prodelta to distal delta-front settings, fully marine lagoons, and open bays. Variants of the ichnofacies occur in subtidal to intertidal mud-prone environments that may experience some salinity reductions, such as marginal marine central bays of estuaries, brackish lagoons, mixed sand and mud tidal flats, and inclined heterolithic stratification (IHS) in lateral accretion beds of tidally modified channels (MacEachern and Pemberton, 1994; MacEachern and Gingras, in press). Sediment textures and bedding styles exhibit considerable diversity, including thinly bedded, well-sorted silts and sands, discrete mud and shell layers, interbedded muddy and clean silts and sands, and extremely poorly sorted beds derived from any of the above, through intense bioturbation. Physical sedimentary structures, where not modified or destroyed by bioturbation, most commonly include low-angle, undulatory, parallel and subparallel lamination (interpreted as hummocky cross-stratification (HCS) and oscillation ripple laminated sand, alternating with silty or sandy mudstones. In restricted bays, estuarine central basins and lagoons, HCS is less common and/or more thinly bedded, but oscillation and combined flow ripples are typically abundant. Mixed sand and mud flats may display classical wavy, lenticular and pinstripe heterolithic bedding with current rippled sand beds, but in less markedly stressed examples such units may be pervasively bioturbated. Small-scale trough cross-bedded and current-rippled sands may also occur in some tidally generated lateral accretion bedding. Sediment deposition rates may be highly variable, and range from negligible to appreciable, though they are not normally rapid. As a result of reduced but not negligible energy levels, food supplies consist of both suspended and deposited components; either fraction may predominate locally, or the two may be intermixed. Characteristic organisms, therefore, include suspension and deposit feeders, as well as mobile carnivores and scavengers. In response to lowered energy and cohesive substrates and an abundance of deposited food, tracemakers tend to construct their burrows horizontally rather than vertically, although scattered vertical or steeply inclined burrows occur locally. Profusions of burrows may be present at stable, low-energy sites. Trails of epibenthic and endobenthic foragers may also be common and reflect the abundance, diversity, and accessibility of food (Fig. 4.5). Surface grazing is also commonly associated but does not dominate the suites.
The Cruziana Ichnofacies is characterized by: (1) a mixed association of horizontal, inclined, and vertical structures, many of them corresponding to permanent to semi-permanent dwellings; (2) structures constructed by mobile organisms; (3) generally high diversity and abundance; (4) predominance of deposit-feeding structures with subordinate grazing structures; and (5) common overprinting of deep-tier over shallow-tier structures during continued burial, locally leading to the preservation of composite structures and complex structures. The dominant Cruziana Ichnofacies elements comprise both deposit-feeding structures and permanent dwellings of inferred deposit feeders (see Table 4.2). These encompass a highly diverse group, and include Taenidium, Siphonichnus, Cylindrichnus, Rosselia (Fig. 4.5B), Teichichnus (Fig. 4.5F), Planolites, Rhizocorallium (Fig. 4.5G), Thalassinoides, Phoebichnus, Phycodes, Asterosoma (Figs. 4.5C,D,I), Chondrites (Fig. 4.5F–H), and Zoophycos (Fig. 4.5I), though this list is by no means exhaustive. Resting structures and surface trails associated with deposit feeding are also common and include such structures as Rusophycus, Cruziana, Lockeia, Gyrochorte, and numerous others. Significant numbers of grazing structures such as Helminthopsis and Phycosiphon (Fig. 4.5H,I) are common and pervasive, with less common Cosmorhaphe present locally. Passive carnivore structures such as Palaeophycus (Fig. 4.5I) and Schaubcylindrichnus may also be present. Permanent dwelling structures of inferred suspension-feeding and omnivorous tracemakers are generally uncommon, though in some successions they comprise significant elements to the suites. The main ichnogenera include Ophiomorpha, Diplocraterion, Arenicolites, and Skolithos. In shallow waters, periodic scour by storm waves and renewed deposition following their cessation may lead to tempestites incorporated within a succession of otherwise low-energy deposits (Pemberton and MacEachern, 1997). Development of hummocky crossstratification may involve the introduction of new sediment as well as the reworking of previously deposited sediment. Any of these conditions may yield burrow truncations and escape structures. Increased energy and allied parameters thus represent a temporary excursion of Skolithos-type conditions into an otherwise Cruziana-type setting. However, this overall bedding style differs from that of the main Skolithos Ichnofacies, in which stratification features, substrate scour, burrow truncations, and escape structures are contained entirely within discrete high-energy event beds, rather than persisting throughout the facies. Eventually, the storm beds are
SOFTGROUND MARINE ICHNOFACIES
overprinted with suites attributable to the Cruziana Ichnofacies.
Zoophycos Ichnofacies Of all recurring marine ichnofacies, the Zoophycos Ichnofacies is most debated and least understood. The ichnogenus Zoophycos has an extremely broad paleobathymetric range; hence its designation as name-bearer for a supposedly depth-related ichnofacies has long been controversial (see Kotake, 1991; and Uchman and Demı´rcan, 1999). In popular bathymetric schemes, the Zoophycos Ichnofacies is typically portrayed as an intermediary between the Cruziana and Nereites ichnofacies, at a position corresponding more or less to the continental slope. More specifically, the original designation placed it in flysch-molasse areas below wave base and free of turbidites, within a broad depositional gradient (Seilacher, 1967). As reevaluated (Seilacher, 1978; Frey and Seilacher, 1980), one of the major environmental controls represented by the ichnofacies is lowered oxygen levels, associated with organic debris accumulation in quiet-water settings. To some extent, these conditions do occur across the shelf-slope break, and thus the popularized bathymetric placement of the ichnofacies is commonly suitable. However, such reducing conditions replete with a dominance of Zoophycos are perhaps even better known in shallower water, epeiric deposits. The Zoophycos Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.6A, Table 4.2) is characterized by suites that display: (1) low diversity, although individual traces may be abundant; (2) predominance of grazing structures and feeding structures produced by deposit feeders; (3) both shallow- and deep-tier structures; and (4) horizontal to gently inclined, spreiten-bearing structures. Suites appear impoverished by comparison with distal expressions of the Cruziana Ichnofacies, and are dominated by Zoophycos (Figs. 4.6B–D), Helminthopsis (Fig. 4.6C), Phycosiphon (Figs. 4.6E–G), Cosmorhaphe (Fig. 4.6C), and Planolites (Figs. 4.6B,G), with lesser Chondrites, Thalassinoides (Figs. 4.6F,G), Scolicia (Figs. 4.6F, G), and Spirophyton (Figs. 4.6F). Considering the above characteristics of the ichnofacies, together with the widespread distribution of individual specimens of Zoophycos in both shallowand deep-water deposits (Frey et al., 1990; Olivero and Gaillard, 1996; Uchman and Demı´rcan, 1999), we speculate that Zoophycos-producing animals were simply broadly adapted in most ecologic respects. Some animals tolerated not only a considerable
65
range of water depths but also numerous substrate types, variable food resources, and different energy and oxygen levels. Their traces, therefore, appear in the Cruziana through Nereites ichnofacies (Crimes et al., 1981). Indeed, in final analysis, their tolerance may be their most distinguishing environmental characteristic. The animals were able to complete successfully with diverse tracemakers under Cruziana- and Nereites-type conditions, but few other animals were able to compete with them under the restricted conditions outlined above. Due to its singular prominence in many restricted settings, the association seems to warrant its own ichnofacies designation. Conversely, the less restrictive the environment at a given site, the less distinctive the ichnofacies is as a separate entity. In numerous places, the ichnofacies is hardly discernible in the broad transition from the Skolithos or Cruziana to the Nereites ichnofacies, especially on unstable ancient slopes originally subject to turbidity flows, or swept by shelf-edge or contour currents. Whatever the major environmental implications of the Zoophycos Ichnofacies and its variants, the final word is not yet in. The most important factors in the distribution of the animal, in addition to its own opportunism, evidently include water depth, depth of burrowing, sediment cohesiveness, and interstitial or bottom-water oxygen levels (Kotake, 1991; Olivero and Gaillard, 1996; Uchman and Demı´rcan, 1999; and Olivero, 2003). Stressed quiet-water environments, particularly those exhibiting anoxia, seem to be the primary common denominator, even though the animal itself was cosmopolitan.
Nereites Ichnofacies In most respects, bathymetric implications of the Nereites Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.7A, Table 4.2) are less equivocal than those of any other recurrent ichnofacies. Although numerous trace fossils otherwise typical of shallow-water deposits may range into deep-sea deposits, the reverse is not ordinarily true. In addition to water depth, turbidite deposition strongly influenced original environmental interpretations of the Nereites Ichnofacies. Despite this, depth- and energyrelated variables appear to be of greater importance than turbidite deposition per se (Crimes et al., 1981; Leszczyn´ski and Seilacher, 1991; Miller, 1993). For example, the ichncoenose persists today on distant abyssal plains essentially beyond the reach
66
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
A
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z P
Z
Z
Z
Z
H Z
B
C
D
Cr
Sc
Sc P
Sc Ch
As
Ph
Th
Sp Sc
Ph Th
E
F
G
FIGURE 4.6 The Zoophycos Ichnofacies. (A) Diagram of the Zoophycos Ichnofacies. Traces include Chondrites (Ch), Cosmorhaphe (Cr), Phycosiphon (Ph), Planolites (P), Scolicia (Sc), Spirophyton (Sp), Thalassinoides (Th), and Zoophycos (Z). (B) Abundant Zoophycos (Z) and Planolites (P), Upper Cretaceous Doe Creek Formation, Alberta. (C) Zoophycos (Z), Helminthopsis (H), and Cosmorhaphe (Cr) in shelf deposits, Upper Cretaceous, Northern North Sea, Norway. (D) Zoophycos (Z) structure from slope deposits of the Upper Cretaceous Cedar District Formation, British Columbia. (E) Abundant Phycosiphon (arrows) in a shelf diatomite, Miocene Monterey Formation, San Joaquin Basin, California. (F) Scolicia (Sc), Spirophyton (Sp), Chondrites (Ch), Phycosiphon (Ph), Thalassinoides (Th), and diminutive Asterosoma (As) in shelf deposits of the Upper Cretaceous Northern North Sea, Norway. (G) Scolicia (Sc), Planolites (P), Phycosiphon (Ph), and Thalassinoides (Th) from shelf deposits of the Upper Cretaceous San Miguel Formation, Texas.
67
SOFTGROUND MARINE ICHNOFACIES
B
Z
H
H Cr
Z C
A
D
E
F
G
Cr
FIGURE 4.7 The Nereites Ichnofacies. (A) Diagram of the Nereites Ichnofacies. Traces include Chondrites (Ch), Cosmorhaphe (Cr), Fustiglyphus (Fg), Helminthorhaphe (He), Lorenzinia (Lr), Nereites (Ne), Paleodictyon (Pd), Planolites, Scolicia (Sc), Spirodesmos (Sd), Spirophycus (Sh), Spirophyton (Sp), Spirorhaphe (Sr), Thalassinoides (Th), Urohelminthoida (Ur), and Zoophycos (Z). (B) Bedding plane of Scolicia (arrows), Upper Cretaceous Nanaimo Group, British Columbia. (C) Thin, muddy Zoophycos (Z), with Helminthopsis (H), and Cosmorhaphe (Cr), Upper Cretaceous, North Slope of Alaska. (D) Bedding plane entirely covered with Nereites, Eocene Zumaya Flysch, Spain. (E) Bedding plane with abundant Nereites, Eocene, Austria. (F) Paleodictyon cast on the sole of a thin turbidite bed, Eocene Zumaya Flysch, Spain. (G) Spirorhaphe cast on the sole of a thin turbidite bed, Eocene, Austria.
68
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
of turbidity currents, but is absent among welldeveloped, shallow-water turbidite successions. Nevertheless, most trace fossil suites attributable to the Nereites Ichnofacies studied to date occur in turbidite-rich successions, probably because the stratigraphic record of deep-water deposits examined in this context mainly represent subsiding basins or subduction zones, rather than the broad abyssal plain. Thus, associated sediments may consist of virtually any lithology, except that the ratio of sediment-gravity derived sand to hemipelagic or pelagic mud tends to diminish toward distal extremities of the deposit, and carbonates become increasingly scarce as the calcite compensation depth is approached. Bouma cycles or modified successions are common locally, and physical sedimentary structures may include flute, groove, and load casts as well as prod marks, flame structures, and linguoid or other current ripples. The Nereites Ichnofacies is characterized by: (1) high diversity but low abundance; (2) complex horizontal grazing traces and patterned feeding/dwelling structures; (3) numerous crawling/grazing traces and sinuous fecal castings; and (4) structures produced by deposit feeders, scavengers, or possibly harvesters (i.e., agrichnia). Animals exploiting lower bathyal to abyssal environments have two principal concerns: (1) scarcity of food, relative to more abundant supplies in shallower settings, and (2) periodic disruption by strong, down-canyon bottom currents or actual turbidity currents. In response to the latter factor, and over long spans of geologic time, the overall community ultimately developed two component parts: pre-turbidite and post-turbidite associations, as documented by their respective traces (Leszczyn´ski and Seilacher, 1991; Miller, 1993). The pre-turbidite resident association is characteristic of quiet, normal conditions and is dominant wherever the substrate is free of the influence of turbidity currents. It tends to be overwhelmed or eliminated by severe erosion or turbulence, however, and is replaced by the postturbidite association after cessation of the turbidity current. As conditions then revert to the normal, prevailing low-energy setting, the pre-turbidite association gradually reestablishes itself. Pre-turbidite animals thus comprise a stable, persistent community, well adapted to quiet conditions, derived mainly from original early-Paleozoic colonizers of the deep-sea floor. In contrast, post-turbidite animals represent a more opportunistic, less stable community better adapted to turbidite colonization, derived mainly from subsequent evolutionary immigrants from shallower waters (Frey and Seilacher, 1980).
In addition to pre- and post-turbidite associations, numerous turbidites display ichnologic gradients along depositional dips, particularly where they are related to submarine fan development (Crimes et al., 1981). Where strong bottom currents issue from submarine canyons or flow along submarine fan channels, components of the Skolithos Ichnofacies may be present (e.g., Ophiomorpha and Diplocraterion). Otherwise, proximal parts of turbidites may be characterized by rosetted or radiating traces (e.g., Lorenzinia, Spirorhaphe (Fig. 4.7G), Spirophycus, and Zoophycos (Fig. 4.7C)), as well as gently meandering forms of Scolicia (Fig. 4.7B). Medial areas of deep-sea fans may be indicated by spiraled or tightly meandering traces (e.g., Helminthorhaphe, Urohelminthoida, and Cosmorhaphe (Fig. 4.7C)), while patterned networks typify distal regions (e.g., Nereites (Figs. 4.7D,E), Paleodictyon (Fig. 4.7F), Paleomeandron, and Fustiglyphus) although other traces are generally present as well. Zoophycos is common locally in various settings, but it tends to be multi-lobed, and in places is more complex than in the Zoophycos Ichnofacies (cf. Savary et al., 2004). Finally, the Nereites Ichnofacies is recognized in Deep Sea Drilling Cores, within unconsolidated, finegrained sediments, including distal turbidites and pelagic rhythmites of modern ocean basins. However, the association per se, if present, tends not to be preserved on great expanses of abyssal plain, where sedimentation and bioturbation are more or less constant, rather than episodic (Scholle et al., 1983).
SUBSTRATE-CONTROLLED ICHNOFACIES The ichnofacies paradigm recognizes three substrate-controlled ichnofacies: Glossifungites, Teredolites and Trypanites (Table 4.3). Each ichnofacies reflects different substrate consistencies at the time of colonization, and so, intuitively reflect palimpsest suites that typically cross-cut the original suites. In many examples, these ichnofacies are associated with erosionally exhumed discontinuities in the rock record, though scenarios favoring autocyclic development are also locally common (see MacEachern et al., Chapter 7). In the case of the Glossifungites Ichnofacies, firmground suites may be intergradational with palimpsest softground suites, particularly where substrates pass from muddy to sandy; burial compaction may lead to firm or stiff mud, but allow sands to retain their non-cohesive character. Likewise, trace suites attributable to the Glossifungites Ichnofacies may
SUBSTRATE-CONTROLLED ICHNOFACIES
69
TABLE 4.3 Recurring Archetypal Substrate-Controlled Trace Fossil Associations and their Common (but not exclusive) Environmental Implications (Adapted from Pemberton et al., 2001) Characteristic Trace Fossils
Typical Benthic Environment Glossifungites Ichnofacies (firm substrates)
Vertical cylindrical, U-, or tear-shaped borings, or sparsely to
Firm but unlithified marine littoral and sublittoral omission
densely ramified dwelling burrows, or various mixtures of burrows and borings. Protrusive spreiten in some U-shaped burrows,
surfaces, especially semiconsolidated carbonate firmgrounds or stable, cohesive, partially dewatered muddy substrates either in
developed mostly through growth of animals (fan-shaped
protected, moderate-energy settings or in areas of somewhat higher
Rhizocorallium and Diplocraterion, formerly Glossifungites). Many
energy where semiconsolidated micritic or siliciclastic substrates
intertidal species (e.g., crabs) leave the burrows to feed; others are
offer resistance to erosion. The final sedimentary record typically
mainly suspension feeders. Diversity is typically low, yet given
consists of a mixture of relict and palimpsest features, including
kinds of structures may be abundant. Unlike ichnogenera of the
cross-cutting ichnofaunas.
Trypanites Ichnofacies, those of Glossifungites tend to avoid obstructions within the substrate. Teredolites Ichnofacies (xylic substrates) Sparse to profuse clavate (shipworm) borings. Dense excavations
Resistant substrates consisting of driftwood pavements, peat
may be deformed but ordinarily do not interpene trate. Boring walls
deposits, or related xylic substances, many of which appear as
may be ornamented with the texture of the host substrate (e.g., tree-
lignite or coal in the rock record. May represent omission surfaces
ring xenoglyphs). Stumpy to elongate, subcylindrical, subparallel
developed on matted wood clasts, log jams, or other xylic materials
excavations predominate in marine or marginal marine settings.
(but not single clasts or trunks), or slow deposition in marshy or
Shallower, sparse to profuse nonclavate etchings (isopod borings)
swampy areas of peat accumulation. Most common in estuarine,
typify freshwater ichnofaunas.
deltaic, or various backbarrier environments. Trypanites Ichnofacies (hard substrates)
Cylindrical to vase-, tear-, or U-shaped to irregular domiciles of
Consolidated marine littoral and sublittoral omission surfaces
endolithos, oriented normal to the respective substrate surface, or
(rocky coasts, beachrock, hardgrounds), reefs, or particulate strata
shallow anastomosing systems of borings (sponges, bryozoans);
formed of organic constituents (bone beds, shell beds, coquinites,
excavated mainly by suspension feeders or passive carnivores.
but not individual bones, shells, or clasts). Bioerosion is as
Raspings and gnawings of algal grazers and equivalent organisms
important as (and serves to accelerate), physical erosion of the
(chitons, limpets, echinoids mainly). Diversity moderately low,
substrate. Intergradational with the Glossifungites Ichnofacies; in
although borings or scrapings of given kinds may be abundant. In particulate lithic substrates, margins of borings cut through grains
sequential hardground development, suites of the Trypanites Ichnofacies may crosscut earlier suites of the Glossifungites or
or shells instead of skirting them.
Cruziana ichnofacies.
be intergradational with hardground suites of the Trypanites Ichnofacies, where differential compaction and/or cementation occur (e.g., Bromley, 1975, 1996). The Teredolites Ichnofacies is somewhat more problematic in this grouping, as the consistency of the substrate may or may not fundamentally change prior to colonization. Some woodground suites correspond to the colonization of the xylic substrate prior to coalification, and this is particularly apparent in modern ichnocoenoses of Willapa Bay (Gingras et al., 2004). Some, however, are associated with erosional discontinuities that have ‘bottomed-out’ on a coal seam (presumably xylic material coalified prior to exhumation) (e.g., Bromley et al., 1984). The anomalous nature of a xylic medium for endobenthic colonization probably justifies its inclusion with these other ‘substrate-controlled’ ichnofacies, though it is somewhat distinct from the progressive change in
original substrate consistency exhibited from softground through firmground and into hardground scenarios.
Glossifungites Ichnofacies The Glossifungites Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.8A, Table 4.3) is characteristic of firm but unlithified substrates, such as dewatered muds, though less commonly incipiently cemented sands may also host the firmground ichnogenera. In most siliciclastic settings, trace suites attributable to the Glossifungites Ichnofacies constitute the most widespread and pervasive expression of the substrate-specific suites. These demarcate a number of discontinuities of both sequence stratigraphic importance (e.g., sequence boundaries, transgressive surfaces of erosion, and amalgamated sequence
70
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
A
B
C
D
F
E
Sk
Rh Th
Th Th
G
Th
H
FIGURE 4.8 The Glossifungites Ichnofacies. (A) Diagram of the Glossifungites Ichnofacies. Firmground ichnogenera include Skolithos (S), Gastrochaenolites (G), Arenicolites (A), Diplocraterion (D), Psilonichnus (Ps), Conichnus (C), Bergaueria (B), Palaeophycus (P), Taenidium (Ta), Rhizocorallium (Rh), Thalassinoides (Th), Chondrites (Ch), and Zoophycos (Z). (B) Firmground Skolithos crosscutting offshore mudstone and subtending from an amalgamated sequence boundary and flooding surface, Lower Cretaceous Viking Formation, Alberta. (C) Firmground Arenicolites filled with coarse-grained sandstone, associated with a transgressive surface of erosion, Lower Cretaceous Viking Formation, Alberta. (D) Firmground Thalassinoides subtending from an incised valley complex, Upper Cretaceous Dunvegan Formation, Alberta. (E) Firmground Rhizocorallium subtending from the base of an estuarine incised valley complex, Lower Cretaceous Viking Formation, Alberta. (F) Firmground Diplocraterion associated with a transgressive surface of erosion, Jurassic Gravelburg Formation, Saskatchewan. (G) Submarine canyon margin with a firmground suite of Thalassinoides (Th), and Skolithos (Sk), lower Miocene Nihotupu and Tirikohua formations, Northland, New Zealand. (H) Firmground Rhizocorallium (Rh) and Thalassinoides (Th) demarcating the same discontinuity as shown in (G).
SUBSTRATE-CONTROLLED ICHNOFACIES
boundaries and flooding surfaces) and autocyclic derivation (e.g., cut-bank margins of tidal channels, periodically exposed intertidal flats, etc.). The sequence stratigraphic significance of the Glossifungites Ichnofacies has been addressed by Savrda (1991a), MacEachern et al. (1992), Pemberton and MacEachern (1995, 2005), Pemberton et al. (2004) and MacEachern et al. (this volume). Firmground ichnogenera are dominated by vertical to subvertical dwelling structures of suspension-feeding organisms (Figs. 4.8B–F). The most common structures correspond to the ichnogenera Diplocraterion (Fig. 4.8F), Skolithos (Figs. 4.8B,G), Psilonichnus, Arenicolites (Fig. 4.8C) Conichnus, Bergaueria, and firmground expressions of Gastrochaenolites. Dwelling structures of inferred deposit-feeding organisms are also constituents of the ichnofacies, and include firmground Thalassinoides (Figs. 4.8D,G,H), Spongeliomorpha, Taenidium, Palaeophycus, Chondrites, and Rhizocorallium (Figs. 4.8E,H). More recently, Zoophycos has been recognized to occur within firmground suites (MacEachern and Burton, 2000). The presence of vertical shafts within shaly intervals is anomalous, as these structures are not capable of being maintained in soft muddy substrates. Glossifungites elements are typically robust, commonly penetrating 20–100 cm below the bed junction. Many shafts tend to be of large diameter (e.g., 0.5–1.5 cm), particularly Diplocraterion habichi and Arenicolites. This scale of burrowing contrasts markedly with the predominantly horizontal and diminutive trace fossils typical of shaly intervals. Firmground traces are also generally sharp-walled and unlined, locally with scratch-marked margins, reflecting the stiff, cohesive nature of the substrate at the time of colonization and burrow excavation. Further evidence of substrate stability, atypical of soft muddy beds, is the passive nature of burrow fill. This demonstrates that the structure remained open after the trace-maker vacated the domicile, thus allowing material from subsequent depositional events to be piped into the open burrow. The post-depositional origin of trace fossil suites attributable to the Glossifungites Ichnofacies is clearly demonstrated by the ubiquitous cross-cutting relationships with the previous softground assemblages. The final characteristic of the firmground suites is their tendency to demonstrate colonization in large numbers. In numerous examples, seven to fifteen firmground traces, most commonly Diplocraterion habichi, have been observed on the bedding plane of
71
a 9 cm (3.5 inch) diameter core, corresponding to a density between 1100 and 2300 shafts per m2.
Teredolites Ichnofacies The Teredolites Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.9A, Table 4.3) encompasses suites of borings excavated into xylic (woody or coaly) substrates (Bromley et al., 1984; Savrda, 1991b). It is critical to identify whether the woodground borings were excavated into an in situ xylic horizon (i.e., reflecting a substrate) or allochthonous (e.g., transported logs in coastal or marine environments). Savrda et al. (1993) applied the term ‘log-grounds’ to high concentrations of allochthonous wood strewn across a depositional surface. Only traces excavated into an in situ substrate, or bored into an allochthonous log-ground after log deposition constitute the Teredolites Ichnofacies (cf., Pemberton et al., 2001; MacEachern et al., Chapter 7). Isolated logs containing wood borings do not constitute the Teredolites Ichnofacies. Log-grounds consisting of logs bored prior to emplacement may form useful mappable horizons but do not constitute the ichnofacies, because the borings do not record colonization of a continuous substrate. Determining the timing of wood boring in such log-grounds may prove challenging. The Teredolites Ichnofacies, as described from the rock record, is probably confined to marine and marginal marine settings. The principal namesake, Teredolites, reflects the borings of wood-boring bivalves (Fig. 4.9C), which in the present day only occur in fully marine to slightly salinity-reduced environments. The presence of the ichnogenera Teredolites (Figs. 4.9B–E,G), Thalassinoides (Fig. 4.9F), and Diplocraterion excavated into xylic material is taken, therefore, to indicate largely marine conditions. Non-marine wood borings do occur, but these are predominantly insect generated and lack marine ichnogenera. Hasiotis (2002) provides a good summary of the characteristics of terrestrial wood borings. Most rock-record occurrences of woodgrounds display a low diversity of trace fossils (e.g., Bromley et al., 1984; Savrda, 1991b; Savrda et al., 1993). These low-diversity suites are dominated by penetrative borings attributable to Teredolites longissimus and Teredolites clavatus. Woodground trace suites are commonly monospecific, however, sizeclass variations have been observed in some of the boring assemblages (e.g., Bromley et al., 1984; Savrda et al., 1993). Modern wood-boring occurrences in the marine realm show higher diversities
72
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
Teredolites
C D
A E
B
Th Th
F
G
FIGURE 4.9 The Teredolites Ichnofacies. (A) Diagram of the Teredolites Ichnofacies (artwork by Tom Saunders). (B) Teredolites clavatus (white arrow) in peat horizon, truncated by mud-filled channel (black arrow), Upper Cretaceous Horseshoe Canyon Formation, Drumheller. (C) The wood-boring bivalve Martesia sp. at the base of the Teredolites clavatus depicted in (B) and (D). (D) Teredolites clovatus from the horizon depicted in (B) and (C). (E) Siderite-cemented Teredolites clavatus, Upper Cretaceous Horseshoe Canyon Formation, Drumheller. (F) Woodground Thalassinoides (Th), at the base of a tidal channel excavated into coal, Upper Cretaceous Ferron Sandstone, Utah. (G) Teredolites (arrows) excavated into lignitic coal, Lower Cretaceous Grand Rapids Formation, Alberta.
SUBSTRATE-CONTROLLED ICHNOFACIES
73
Entobia
B
Trypanites Gastrochaenolites
A C
D
E FIGURE 4.10 The Trypanites Ichnofacies. (A) Diagram of the Trypanites Ichnofacies (artwork by Tom Saunders). (B) Entobia in carbonate, Oligocene–Miocene Bluff Formation, Grand Cayman Island. (C) Gastrochaneolites with in situ bivalves (Zirfaea pilsbyri), excavated into Triassic sandstones along the margin of the Bay of Fundy, Economy, Nova Scotia. (D),(E) Trypanites excavated into carbonate hardground, marking the Silurian–Devonian disconformity, southern Ontario.
than generally recorded from the rock record (Gingras et al., 2004).
The Trypanites Ichnofacies The Trypanites Ichnofacies (Fig. 4.10A, Table 4.3) is characteristic of fully lithified marine substrates such as reefs, hardgrounds, rocky coasts, beach rock, unconformities, and other omission surfaces. As in the case of the Teredolites Ichnofacies, the concept does not apply to borings in individual shells, bones, and
clasts. Bromley and Asgaard (1993) erected the ‘Entobia Ichnofacies’ and the ‘Gnathichnus Ichnofacies’ to either serve as subsets of the Trypanites Ichnofacies, or as its replacement. In reality, these new additions are closely associated with tiers. The ‘Entobia Ichnofacies’ is broadly similar to the Trypanites Ichnofacies, in that it corresponds to long-term bioerosion of a lithified surface (typically carbonate), with little or no contemporaneous sedimentation, allowing deep-tier dwelling structures to be excavated and maintained, and superficial borings to be obliterated. The ‘Gnathichnus Ichnofacies’
74
4. THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM: A FIFTY-YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
encompasses ichnocoenoses associated with predominantly surficial bioerosion structures, but predominantly on isolated clasts, or skeletons. Such structures do not form continuous mappable surfaces, and do not correspond to the classical meaning of the word ‘facies.’ We suggest that Trypanites better serves as the ichnofacies while Entobia and Gnathichnus serve as expressions of the ichnocoenoses that characterize the ichnofacies as a whole. Suites attributable to the Trypanites Ichnofacies consist of sharp-walled, unlined, cylindrical, vase- and tear-shaped domiciles (e.g., Trypanites, (Figs. 4.10D,E), Gastrochaenolites (Fig. 4.10C), and Ubiglobites), irregular dwellings (e.g., Entobia, Fig. 4.10B), irregular pits or borings formed by barnacles (e.g., Rogerella), shallow anastomose systems excavated by sponges, bryozoans, suspension feeders, or passive carnivores, and/or raspings and gnawings of algal grazers such as echinoids, chitons, or limpets. Golubic et al. (1984) described a number of microbial endolithic borings that may also be associated. Borings are distinctive, in that they cut through shells or grains, and are commonly oriented normal to the substrate. Suites attributable to the Trypanites Ichnofacies are commonly intergradational with those of the Glossifungites Ichnofacies, and may crosscut former softground and firmground suites (Bromley, 1975, 1996). Suites commonly show moderately low diversities, though trace abundances may be high.
USING THE ICHNOFACIES PARADIGM We have asserted that ichnofacies serve as theoretical constructs, based on numerous case studies that demonstrate global and temporal recurrence. We have maintained that these formally defined ichnofacies record particular environmental conditions. As in formal, physically based facies models (e.g., Walker and James, 1992; Reading, 1996), the ichnofacies serve as models for evaluating discrete trace suites (MacEachern and Pemberton, 1992; Pemberton et al., 1992), a point echoed by Genise et al. (2000) in their analysis of the ichnofacies paradigm for the continental regime. In practice, the trace fossil suites are identified from the rock record and integrated with all aspects of the physical sedimentology, and with as many other lines of evidence as considered reasonable for the scope and limitations of the study. The trace suites are then evaluated in the context of various environmental factors and attributed to the relevant ichnofacies.
The generalized character of the ichnofacies, in contrast to the detailed information of the suite, has led many to erroneously conclude that the ichnofacies are too broad to yield precise paleoenvironmental interpretations. McIlroy (2004) has suggested that ichnofacies may serve as a starting point, but that otherwise, ichnology has outgrown the concept. In contrast, to turn a phrase of Walker (1992), it is the generality embodied by the ichnofacies, as opposed to the summary of one particular case study, that enables the ichnofacies concept to serve its most valuable functions. Like facies models, the ichnofacies paradigm serves three main functions for ichnological analysis: (1) It acts as a norm for the purposes of comparison. The ichnofacies comprises the features shared by all suites attributable to the ichnofacies. Any individual suite need not contain all the ichnogenera characteristic of the ichnofacies, nor even the namesake element. Rather, it must contain traces that are consistent with the ethological grouping that defines the ichnofacies–it is what all suites, regardless of age and locality, have in common. Archetypal ichnofacies, by acting as a norm for comparison, allows new trace suites to be compared–does the new suite meet the criteria for inclusion within a particular ichnofacies? It also allows one to recognize departures from the archetypal expressions of the ichnofacies, permitting the identification of depositional stresses in the setting. Such stresses may indicate deltaic sedimentation (e.g., Gingras et al., 1998; MacEachern et al., 2005), or brackish-water accumulation (e.g., Beynon and Pemberton, 1992; MacEachern and Pemberton, 1994; Gingras et al., 1999; Bann et al., 2004; MacEachern and Gingras, in press). Without this norm for comparison, one cannot determine whether a new ichnocoenose contains any unusual or anomalous characteristics. (2) The ichnofacies concept acts as a framework or guide for future observations. Sand-prone marine successions tend to carry the Skolithos Ichnofacies. When the ichnologist is working in such units, mental search criteria are erected. The ichnologist working in sandy successions therefore knows that most elements of the suite tend to be vertical dwellings, branching dwellings, escape or equilibrium-adjustment structures, and lined horizontal dwellings, many of them exceedingly subtle in well-sorted sandstones. (3) The ichnofacies concept serves as a predictor in new situations. The paradigm erected by
75
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Seilacher demonstrates that the various ichnofacies correspond to different but predictable combinations of environmental parameters. In a simple shoreline to basinal shoreline profile, these parameters tend to change progressively, according to a predictable distribution of ichnofacies. The Skolithos Ichnofacies, for example, corresponds to high-energy, shifting particulate substrates, generally in marine water. The Cruziana Ichnofacies records lower energy, generally more cohesive substrates, with mainly suspended sediment accumulation. We may then, reasonably, consider that if we have a locality with suites attributable to the Skolithos Ichnofacies, and the other facies indicators are consistent with an open marine, upper shoreface environment, then by moving in a more distal direction, we would expect to encounter mudprone, open marine facies carrying suites attributable to the Cruziana Ichnofacies. Having done so, we can, with even greater confidence predict the presence of the Zoophycos Ichnofacies and of shelf-like conditions further basinward. Alternatively, should we move in what we believed to be the seaward direction, but encounter sand-prone environments with trace suites corresponding to the Psilonichnus Ichnofacies, then we can predict that we have erred in our reconstruction of the paleogeography. In reality, the role of ichnofacies as a predictor is far more complex than this simple example suggests. A physical facies model displays a fourth use: it may act as an integrated basis for interpretation of the system that it represents. Such a use is achieved once the model is fully mature, and is based on the combined features of many case studies. The turbidite model, for example, has reached this level: it has a hydrodynamic basis for interpretation of the event beds, based on many thousands of occurences. The ichnofacies concept is starting to approach this use, owing to the continued clarification of the environmental parameters that constrain the faunal behaviors and the types and diversities of the resulting ichnogenera. Such process-based ichnofacies analyses are not far off (e.g., MacEachern et al., 2005). The Skolithos and Cruziana ichnofacies, for example, are particularly well poised to move into this arena, because of the great abundance of shallow marine successions that have been studied. Once a suite is identified to be attributable to a particular ichnofacies, a particular grouping of paleoenvironmental characteristics are indicated. A suite attributable to the
Skolithos Ichnofacies reflects persistent, high-energy deposition, shifting substrates, and clean (nonturbid) marine water. No matter what particular depositional environment is ultimately determined for the facies, it must embrace these physico-chemical parameters. The ichnofacies paradigm comprises the unifying framework within which ichnological observations can be accurately interpreted in a depositional context. Rather than outgrowing the ichnofacies paradigm, it continues to