THE EDUCATION OF BLACKS IN THE SOUTH, 1860-1935
This page intentionally left blank
JAMES D. ANDERSON
THE E D U C A...
607 downloads
3120 Views
20MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
THE EDUCATION OF BLACKS IN THE SOUTH, 1860-1935
This page intentionally left blank
JAMES D. ANDERSON
THE E D U C A T I O N OF
BLACKS IN THE SOUTH,
1860-1935
THE UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA PRESS
CHAPEL HILL AND LONDON
© 1988 The University of North Carolina Press All rights reserved Manufactured in the United States of America The paper in this book meets the guidelines for permanence and durability of the Committee on Production Guidelines for Book Longevity of the Council on Library Resources. 04
03
ii
10
9
8
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Anderson, James D., 1944— The education of Blacks in the South, 1860—1935 I by James D. Anderson. p. cm. Bibliography: p. Includes index. ISBN 0-8078-1793-7 (alk. paper). ISBN 0-8078^x1-4 (pbk.: alk. paper) i. Afro-Americans—Education—Southern States—History—19th century, z. Afro-Americans—Education—Southern States— History—zoth century. I. Title. LC2.8OZ.S9A53 1988 87-35196 370'.0889073075—dci9 CIP
To my mother, Annie Byrd Anderson; and in memory of my grandmother, Mary Eliza Matthews; my brother, Leon Anderson; and my father, Fred Anderson
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
Acknowledgments Introduction 1. Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education in the South, 1860—1880
xiii i 4
2. The Hampton Model of Normal School Industrial Education, 1868-1915
33
3. Education and the Race Problem in the New South: The Struggle for Ideological Hegemony
79
4. Normal Schools and County Training Schools: Educating the South's Black Teaching Force, 1900-1935
no
5. Common Schools for Black Children: The Second Crusade, 1900—1935
148
6. The Black Public High School and the Reproduction of Caste in the Urban South, 1880-1935
186
7. Training the Apostles of Liberal Culture: Black Higher Education, 1900—1935
238
Epilogue: Black Education in Southern History
279
Notes
287
Bibliography
313
Index
353
This page intentionally left blank
TABLES AND FIGURES
TABLES
2.1. Number and Percent of Blacks in Total Population of Southern States, 1870—1930
41
2.2.. Black Workers as a Percentage of All Workers in Agricultural Occupations by Southern States, 1890—1930
45
4.1. Black Students and Graduates in Public and Private Normal Schools, High Schools, and Colleges in Southern States, 1900
112
4.2. Total College Enrollment and Enrollment of Graduates in Institutions of Higher Learning for Blacks in the South, 1929—1930
146
5.1. Elementary School Attendance by Race and Age in Southern States, 1900
151
5.2.. Summary of Completed Buildings and of Amounts and Percentages of Cash Contributions by Blacks, Whites, Public Taxation, and Rosenwald Fund, 10 June 1914— i July 1932
155
5.3. Summary of Completed Buildings and of Amounts and Percentages of Cash Contributions by Blacks, Whites, Public Taxation, and Rosenwald Fund, 10 June 1914— i July 1927
160
5.4. Summary of Rosenwald School Day Program by States for the Academic Year 1930—1931
174
5.5. Black Teachers and Student Enrollment in Southern States and Percentage of Rural Teachers and Students in Rosenwald Schools for the Academic Year 1925—1926
180
x
Tables and Figures
5.6. Elementary School Attendance by Race and Age in Southern States, 1940
182
6.1. High School Enrollment by Age, Race, and Southern States, 1890
189
6.2. High School Enrollment by Age, Race, and Southern States, 1910
190
6.3. Southern Cities of 20,000 or More Inhabitants without Public High Schools for Blacks, 1915
194
6.4. Southern Cities of 20,000 or More Inhabitants with Public High Schools for Blacks, 1915
2,00
6.5. High School Enrollment by Age, Race, and Southern States, 1933-1934
236
6.6. Secondary School Enrollment and Graduates in Black Public Schools in Southern States, 1940
237
7.1. Black College and Professional Students and Graduates in Southern States and the District of Columbia, by Sex, 1900
246
7.2. Black College and Professional Students in Private and Public Colleges in Southern States and the District of Columbia, by Sex, 1935
275
FIGURE 6.1. Architectural Sketch of an Industrial High School
218
ILLUSTRATIONS
Zion School in Charleston, South Carolina
8
Ex-slave school, St. Helena Island, South Carolina
14
Southern white reaction to the ex-slave crusade for universal schooling
Z4
Hampton Institute students hoeing
48
Hampton Institute students plowing
48
Hampton Institute students sewing
56
Hampton Institute students cooking
56
Correlating the academic and the industrial in a Tuskegee Institute classroom
76
Normal school teachers and kindergarten class doing field work at Tuskegee Institute
76
Tuskegee's twenty-fifth anniversary
93
Tuskegee students serve a gathering of the school's white donors and supporters
93
Tangipahoa Parish Training School of Louisiana
139
Wharton Negro Training School of Wharton, Texas
139
"Domestic science" class at Marion County, South Carolina, Training School
143
Ben Hill County Training School of Georgia
143
The old Hunter Hill School of Autauga County, Alabama
163
The new Hunter Hill School of Autauga County, Alabama
163
The old Duncan School of Cass County, Texas
164
The new Duncan School of Cass County, Texas
164
xii
Illustrations
School construction fund-raising rally in rural Alabama
167
Greene County Training School of Boligee, Alabama
167
Hardeman County, Tennessee, Training School
169
Biedenhard School of Warren County, Mississippi
169
Rosenwald School Day at Bethlehem School of Monroe County, Arkansas
175
Dublin School of Coahoma County, Mississippi
175
Paul Laurence Dunbar High School of Little Rock, Arkansas
212
William Spencer Industrial High School in Columbus, Georgia
2.2.5
Fisk University, Nashville, Tennessee
264
Eutaw School of Eutaw, Alabama
284
Blacks in Gee's Bend, Alabama, conduct school in their church
284
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I wish to express my gratitude to the many persons who assisted and encouraged me in the preparation of this book. I gratefully acknowledge the advice and suggestions of those who read all or portions of the manuscript. Darlene Clark Hine, V. P. Franklin, Robert L. Harris, David B. Tyack, O. Vernon Burton, Hoda Zaki, and Frederic C. Jaher gave generously of their time and knowledge to my work and suggested new directions for research. My colleagues and friends at the University of Illinois have put in so much time, effort, and hard criticism that I could not begin to thank them. Anyway, to Clarence J. Karier, Paul C. Violas, William Trent, Steven Tozer, Ralph Page, Joe R. Burnett, and Terry Denny, your advice and encouragement were extremely helpful. I also wish to thank my good friend and former colleague at Indiana University, B. Edward McClellan, for his advice and support. A number of graduate students read portions of this study as mimeographed classroom reading assignments. I owe them a debt for their honest feedback. Their questions gave me a great deal to think about. Particularly, I wish to thank my doctoral students, Brenda Jackson, Linda Perkins, Dale Tatalovich, Larry Parker, Warren Chapman, Stafford Hood, Guy Senese, Alexis Freeman, Carolyne White, Casey Machula, and Bernard Ray. They offered good suggestions and continued encouragement over the years. That helps as much as anything. I would like to acknowledge also the long-standing support of my friends Hakim Muhummad and Mikal Kariem. An important debt to my early teachers is the most difficult to acknowledge in written words. They were my exemplars, and without them my academic development would not have been possible. Honor and respect to my teachers Herman Hughes, Eunice O. Outland, J. C. McCampbel, E.W. Underwood, and J. T. Parker who kept the faith and brought me through the dark path. I am also grateful to Haywood L. Strickland and Joffre T. Whisenton for picking up where they left off. They contributed much to this final product. I would like to offer special thanks to Marsha May, who typed all drafts of the manuscript. She put in much hard work on this book, and
xiv
Acknowledgments
her dedication and professionalism will always be cherished. Jean Bettridge, my research assistant, gave significant aid in the development of the bibliography, and I gratefully acknowledge her assistance. She did excellent work. A special thanks and debt of gratitude are due my research assistant, Carrie Geyer Franke, who read and critiqued the entire manuscript. Her suggestions, corrections, and additions contributed significantly to the quality of this book. She worked hard under very difficult conditions and demonstrated an impressive quality of scholarship and professional character. I am also grateful to Mary Prignano for helping to correct the galleys. I particularly want to thank several librarians for their very able assistance. Vera Mitchell and Rosemary Stevenson of the University of Illinois and Beth Howse, Ann Shockley, and Jessie Carney Smith of Fisk University helped to make this work possible. And I wish to thank William Hess of the Rockefeller Archive Center. For Teresa Fisher, words cannot convey the depths of appreciation for your support, understanding, and encouragement.
THE EDUCATION OF BLACKS IN THE SOUTH, 1860-1935
This page intentionally left blank
INTRODUCTION
THE H I S T O R Y of American education abounds with themes that represent the inextricable ties between citizenship in a democratic society and popular education. It is crucial for an understanding of American educational history, however, to recognize that within American democracy there have been classes of oppressed people and that there have been essential relationships between popular education and the politics of oppression. Both schooling for democratic citizenship and schooling for second-class citizenship have been basic traditions in American education. These opposing traditions were not, as some would explain, the difference between the mainstream of American education and some aberrations or isolated alternatives. Rather, both were fundamental American conceptions of society and progress, occupied the same time and space, were fostered by the same governments, and usually were embraced by the same leaders. Appropriately, it was Thomas Jefferson who first articulated the inseparable relationships between popular education and a free society. If a nation expected to be ignorant and free, he argued, it expected the impossible. To the legislature of Virginia in 1787 Jefferson proposed a popular educational system that would offer three years of public schooling to every white child of the commonwealth and then send the brightest male youngsters on to grammar school and college at public expense. But what of the enslaved children who constituted about 40 percent of the total number of Virginia's children and who along with enslaved adults formed the basis of wealth for Jefferson, as well as for the state of Virginia? It was believed that Virginia's peace, prosperity, and "civilization" depended as much, if not more, on the containment and repression of literate culture among its enslaved population as it did on the diffusion of literate culture among its free population. These two contradictory traditions of American education emerged during the first half of the nineteenth century and clashed with each other until well into the twentieth century. Both legacies flow into our own present. They reflect fundamentally, though not exclusively, the long struggle between two social systems—slavery and peasantry on one
2.
The Education of Blacks in the South
hand, and capitalism and free labor on the other. The successful campaign to contain and repress literacy among enslaved Americans triumphed just as the crusade for popular education for free people began to flourish. Between 1800 and 1835, most of the southern states enacted legislation making it a crime to teach enslaved children to read or write. In contrast, a massive campaign to achieve popular schooling for free Americans developed between 1830 and 1860, and out of this campaign emanated designs for state systems of public education. By the end of the antebellum period a majority of the states had established public school systems, and nearly half of the nation's free children were already getting some formal education. Still, it was not until the latter part of the nineteenth century that the organization, scope, and role of schooling were transformed into a carefully articulated structure of free tax-supported public institutions. In 1863, the enslaved Americans were emancipated whereby they temporarily joined the ranks of the nation's free citizens at the very moment that public educational systems were being developed into their modern form. For a brief period during the late i86os and 18705, as free laborers, citizens, and voters, the ex-slaves entered into a new social system of capitalism, Republican government, and wage labor. Their campaign for first-class citizenship, however, was successfully undermined by federal and state governments and by extralegal organizations and tactics. Soon after the late 18705, blacks were ruthlessly disfranchised; their civil and political subordination was fixed in southern law, and they were trapped by statutes and social customs in an agricultural economy that rested heavily on coercive control and allocation of labor. From the end of Reconstruction until the late 19605, black southerners existed in a social system that virtually denied them citizenship, the right to vote, and the voluntary control of their labor power. They remained an oppressed people. Black education developed within this context of political and economic oppression. Hence, although black southerners were formally free during the time when American popular education was transformed into a highly formal and critical social institution, their schooling took a different path. This book tells the story of the unique system of public and private education that was developed by and for black southerners between 1860 and 1935. It examines the structure, ideology, and content of black education as part and parcel of the larger political subordination of blacks, for it was the social system in which blacks lived that made their educational institutions so fundamentally different from those of other Americans. Education within this social context was not necessarily deleterious, nor was all of black education repressive in reality. Indeed, a central theme in the history of the education of black Americans is the
Introduction
3
persistent struggle to fashion a system of formal education that prefigured their liberation from peasantry. The book begins with the movement by ex-slaves to develop an educational system singularly appropriate to defend and extend their emancipation. Within this movement the basic form, philosophy, and subject matter of black education reflected the ex-slaves' intent to restructure and control their lives. Yet their struggle to defend and advance themselves was undertaken as oppressed people. Apart from this conception we cannot appreciate fully the choices they made, the greatness of their triumphs, and their ultimate failure to dominate the course of their educational development. As black southerners lost political and economic power, they lost substantial control of their educational institutions, especially in the public sector, and the shape and character of their education took a different turn. As detailed in Chapter 2, this system of second-class education for blacks did not just happen. It was the logical outgrowth of a social ideology designed to adjust black southerners to racially qualified forms of political and economic subordination. The ex-slaves, however, persisted in their crusade to develop systems of education compatible with their resistance to racial and class subordination. This effort set the stage for the bitter national debate about the social purposes of black education that unfolded at the turn of the century; it is detailed in Chapter 3. A description of how these educational movements and ideologies were translated into institutional behavior is presented in Chapters 4 through 7. This section of the book begins with a study of black teacher training institutions, followed by a detailed examination of the structure and content of black common schools and high schools, ending with a study of black higher education. This approach reflects two primary goals. First, this volume seeks to give meaning to educational movements and ideologies as they influenced the basic organization and substance of educational institutions. Second, it seeks to provide a detailed documentation of the actual structure and content of each level of black education. So often the histories of black education attend excessively to the growth of intellectual currents and ideological debate, leaving the readers without a clear, concise, and comprehensive understanding of what actually existed in the way of elementary schools, normal schools, secondary schools, and colleges. This approach makes it difficult, if not impossible, for readers to understand how politics, power, and ideology shaped the framework and opportunity structure of black educational institutions and how these institutions differed from the educational institutions of other Americans. This volume examines both the ideological and institutional nature of schooling in the black South and the interplay of both in the education of an oppressed class of American citizens.
I EX-SLAVES AND THE RISE OF UNIVERSAL EDUCATION IN THE SOUTH, 1860-1880
F O R M E R S L A V E S were the first among native southerners to depart from the planters' ideology of education and society and to campaign for universal, state-supported public education. In their movement for universal schooling the ex-slaves welcomed and actively pursued the aid of Republican politicians, the Freedmen's Bureau, northern missionary societies, and the Union army. This uprising among former slaves was the central threat to planter rule and planters' conceptions of the proper roles of state, church, and family in matters of education. The South's landed upper class tolerated the idea of pauper education as a charity to some poor white children, but state-enforced public education was another matter. The planters believed that state government had no right to intervene in the education of children and, by extension, the larger social arrangement. Active intervention in the social hierarchy through public education violated the natural evolution of society, threatened familial authority over children, upset the reciprocal relations and duties of owners to laborers, and usurped the functions of the church. During the period 1860 to 1880, other classes of native white southerners, including small farmers, industrialists, and laborers, showed little inclination to challenge the planters on these questions. Indeed, specific economic, political, social, and psychological relationships bound southern whites in general to the ideological position of the planter regime. The result was a postwar South that was extremely hostile to the idea of universal public education. The ex-slaves broke sharply with this position. With the aid of Republican politicians, they seized significant influence in state governments and laid the first foundation for universal public education in the South. This chapter tells the story of the ex-slaves' struggle for universal schooling, why they pursued it, how they organized to defend their common interests, how they coped with the resistance of opposing social
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
5
classes, and finally, how they gained the cooperation of sympathetic social groups. Blacks emerged from slavery with a strong belief in the desirability of learning to read and write. This belief was expressed in the pride with which they talked of other ex-slaves who learned to read or write in slavery and in the esteem in which they held literate blacks. It was expressed in the intensity and the frequency of their anger at slavery for keeping them illiterate. "There is one sin that slavery committed against me," professed one ex-slave, "which I will never forgive. It robbed me of my education." The former slaves' fundamental belief in the value of literate culture was expressed most clearly in their efforts to secure schooling for themselves and their children. Virtually every account by historians or contemporary observers stresses the ex-slaves' demand for universal .schooling. In 1879 Harriet Beecher Stowe said of the freedmen's campaign for education: "They rushed not to the grog-shop but to the schoolroom—they cried for the spelling-book as bread, and pleaded for teachers as a necessity of life." Journalist Charles Nordhoff reported that New Orleans's ex-slaves were "almost universally . . . anxious to send their children to school." Booker T. Washington, a part of this movement himself, described most vividly his people's struggle for education: "Few people who were not right in the midst of the scenes can form any exact idea of the intense desire which the people of my race showed for education. It was a whole race trying to go to school. Few were too young, and none too old, to make the attempt to learn." When supervising the first contrabands at Fortress Monroe in 1861, Edward L. Pierce "observed among them a widespread desire to learn to read."1 The foundation of the freedmen's educational movement was their self-reliance and deep-seated desire to control and sustain schools for themselves and their children. William Channing Gannett, a white American Missionary Association teacher from New England, reported that "they have a natural praiseworthy pride in keeping their educational institutions in their own hands. There is jealousy of the superintendence of the white man in this matter. What they desire is assistance without control." The values of self-help and self-determination underlay the exslaves' educational movement. To be sure, they accepted support from northern missionary societies, the Freedmen's Bureau, and some southern whites, but their own action—class self-activity informed by an ethic of mutuality—was the primary force that brought schools to the children of freed men and women. This underlying force represented the culmination of a process of social class formation and development that started decades before the Civil War. "Emancipation," as Herbert Gutman showed, "transformed an established and developed subordinate class, allowing ex-slave men and women to act on a variety of class
6
The Education of Blacks in the South
beliefs that had developed but been constrained during several generations of enslavement." Hence the South's postbellum movement for universal education is best understood as an expression of the ex-slaves' beliefs and behavior. External assistance notwithstanding, the postwar campaign for free schooling was rooted firmly in the beliefs and behavior of former slaves. W. E. B. DuBois was on the mark when he said: "Public education for all at public expense was, in the South, a Negro idea." Such a view of postbellum southern education acknowledges the important contributions of northerners but recognizes the ex-slaves as the principal challenge to the region's long-standing resistance to free schooling.2Most northern missionaries went south with the preconceived idea that the slave regime was so brutal and dehumanizing that blacks were little more than uncivilized victims who needed to be taught the values and rules of civil society. They were bent on treating the freedmen almost wholly as objects. Many missionaries were astonished, and later chagrined, however, to discover that many ex-slaves had established their own educational collectives and associations, staffed schools entirely with black teachers, and were unwilling to allow their educational movement to be controlled by the "civilized" Yankees. In vital respects, missionary propaganda continued in spite of the social reality that contradicted it, but some of the more insightful Yankees began to appreciate ex-slaves as creative participants in the postbellum social process. John W. Alvord, the national superintendent of schools for the Freedmen's Bureau, was one of those perceptive Yankees. His growing awareness of a distinctly black perspective on educational and social matters was probably a result of his work, which compelled him to travel across the South and thereby afforded him a view of the depth and breadth of exslaves' values and behavior. In September 1865, Alvord was appointed inspector of schools for the bureau. The title was later changed to general superintendent of schools. In July 1865 Alvord appointed a superintendent of schools for each southern state to help compile records on the bureau's educational activities. Alvord had traveled through nearly all the Confederate states by December 1865 and filed his first general report on the Freedmen's Bureau schools in January 1866. In this document he gave special attention to the practice of "self-teaching" and "native schools" among the freed men and women. "Throughout the entire South," Alvord reported, "an effort is being made by the colored people to educate themselves." "In the absence of other teaching they are determined to be self-taught; and everywhere some elementary text-book, or the fragment of one, may be seen in the hands of negroes." Not only were individuals found teaching themselves to read and write, but Alvord also discovered a system of what he chose to call "native schools," one of which he found at Golds-
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
7
boro, North Carolina: "Two colored young men, who but a little time before commenced to learn themselves, had gathered 150 pupils, all quite orderly and hard at study." Further, Alvord discovered that "no white man, before me, had ever come near them." Hence native schools were common schools founded and maintained exclusively by ex-slaves. Two of Alvord's findings must be heavily emphasized. First, he found "native schools," in his own words, "throughout the entire South." Second, he discovered many of them in places that had not been visited by the Freedmen's Bureau or northern benevolent societies. Alvord, realizing that his findings did not square with existing perceptions of "the character of the Negro," took "special pains" to ascertain the facts on native schools. Such schools were found in "all the large places I visited," and they were "making their appearance through the interior of the entire South." After receiving much testimony from his field agents, "both oral and written," Alvord estimated in 1866 that there were "at least 500 schools of this description . . . already in operation throughout the South." This estimate, he warned his readers, was not an "overstatement." Alvord had little doubt about the significance of his findings: "This educational movement among the freedmen has in it a self-sustaining element." This "self-sustaining" activity was rooted firmly in the slave experience and began to surface before the war's end.3 Before northern benevolent societies entered the South in 1862., before President Abraham Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation in 1863, and before Congress created the Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen and Abandoned Lands (Freedmen's Bureau) in 1865, slaves and free persons of color had already begun to make plans for the systematic instruction of their illiterates. Early black schools were established and supported largely through the Afro-Americans' own efforts. The first of these schools, according to current historiography, opened at Fortress Monroe, Virginia, in September 1861, under the leadership of Mary Peake, a black teacher. Primary historical sources, however, demonstrate that slaves and free persons of color started schools even before the Fortress Monroe venture. In July 1864, for instance, the black New Orleans Union commemorated the founding of the Pioneer School of Freedom, established in New Orleans in 1860, "in the midst of danger and darkness." Some schools predated the Civil War period and simply increased their activities after the war started. A black school in Savannah, Georgia, had existed unknown to the slave regime from 1833 to 1865. Its teacher, a black woman by the name of Deveaux, quickly expanded her literacy campaign during and following the war. It was this type of "self-sustaining" behavior that produced the native schools Alvord observed throughout the South in i866.4 Herbert Gutman's pioneering work on this subject demonstrates fur-
8
The Education of Blacks in the South
xf
Zion School in Charleston, South Carolina, established in December 1865, had an entirely black administration and teaching staff. By December 1866 it had 13 teachers, an enrollment of 850 students, and an average daily attendance of 720 pupils. Wood engraving in Harper's Weekly, 15 December 1866. ther that the native schools of Fortress Monroe, Savannah, and New Orleans were not isolated occurrences. Such schools were also begun among refugees in Alexandria, Virginia. A white teacher did not work with Afro-Americans in Alexandria until October 1862., by which time they had already established several schools. "In April 1863," wrote Gutman, "about four hundred children attended such schools." Likewise, he documented schools for rural ex-slaves in northeastern South Carolina. In 1867 Camden blacks, largely through their own individual and collective efforts, established twenty-two schools in which more than four thousand children were instructed. Schooling also made significant progress among blacks in Sumter, Marion, Darlington, Simmonsville, Florence, Kingstree, Chetau, Bennettsville, and Timonville, South Carolina. Ex-slaves contributed their money and labor to help make these schools possible, and they organized responsible committees to supervise the schools.5 What happened in Alexandria, Virginia, before 1865 and in northeastern South Carolina in 1866 and 1867 occurred elsewhere in the South. Afro-Americans over the entire region contributed significantly to the origin and development of universal schooling. Even where the Union
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
9
army and Freedmen's Bureau were heavily involved in the education of refugees and ex-slaves, the long-term success of schooling depended mainly on Afro-Americans. The activities of Louisiana refugees and exslaves illustrate the importance of such involvement. Blacks began establishing small private schools between 1860 and 1862.. Though these first schools were inadequately financed and haphazardly run, attempts were made to organize them on a systematic basis. After Union forces occupied New Orleans in 1863, however, the federal Commission of Enrollment presided over blacks' educational activities. According to historian John W. Blassingame, Major General Nathaniel P. Banks "instituted the most thorough of all systems for educating the freedmen in his Department of Gulf (Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, and Texas)." In October 1863, Banks authorized the Commission of Enrollment to take a census of Afro-Americans in the Gulf states and to establish schools for blacks in New Orleans. On 22 March 1864, he established a Board of Education to organize and govern the spread of black schools. In September 1864, the black New Orleans Tribune reported that Banks's effort had already resulted in 60 schools with "eight thousand scholars and more than one hundred teachers." By December 1864, the Board of Education was operating 95 schools with 9,571 children and 2,000 adults, instructed by i6z teachers. This system of schooling extended beyond the New Orleans area. The Tribune reported, in July 1864, that teachers were "sent to instruct black pupils in rural areas." In 1865 the Freedmen's Bureau took control of this school system, which then included 126 schools, 19,000 pupils, and 100 teachers.6 Such historical evidence has been wrongly used to attribute the freedmen's school movement to Yankee benevolence or federal largesse. The events that followed the Freedmen's Bureau takeover, however, underscore Gutman's observation that the ex-slaves' educational movement was rooted deeply within their own communal values. The Board of Education and later the Freedmen's Bureau maintained these schools through federal contributions and by levying a property tax. Jn 1866, allegedly to reduce the financial costs to the bureau, its officials temporarily closed all black schools under their authorization, and the general tax for freedmen's education was suspended by military order. The effect of this change was catastrophic. Alvord recorded the actions of Louisiana's ex-slaves: "The consternation of the colored population was intense. . . . They could not consent to have their children sent away from study, and at once expressed willingness to be assessed for the whole expense." Black leaders petitioned Yankee military officers to levy an added tax upon their community to replenish the bureau's school fund. Petitions demanding the continuation of universal schooling poured in from all over Louisiana. As Alvord recounted: "I saw one [petition],
io
The Education of Blacks in the South
from plantations across the river, at least 30 feet in length, representing 10,000 negroes. It was affecting to examine it and note the names and marks (x) of such a long list of parents, ignorant themselves, but begging that their children might be educated, promising that from beneath their present burdens, and out of their extreme poverty, they would pay for it." Such actions reveal the collective effort and shared values of the exslaves who built and sustained schools across the postwar South.7 Much more than federal largesse made free schooling a reality among Louisiana's ex-slaves. After the bureau withdrew its support, the freedmen took control of the educational system and transformed federal schools into local free schools. The New Orleans Tribune reported that as soon as the bureau's failures were recognized, educational associations "were organized in various parts of the state, at least in its principal cities, to promote the cause of education, and with the particular view of helping the children of parents in reduced circumstances to attend schools." One such association, the Louisiana Educational Relief Association, was organized in June 1866. Its primary aim was to "disseminate the principle of education, by assisting poor children whose friends are unable to do so." The board of trustees could "lease or buy such school property as may be deemed judicious, and examine and employ teachers." Louisiana's freedmen believed themselves primarily responsible for providing education for their children. "Each race of men, each class in society, have [sic] to shape their own destinies themselves," wrote J. Willis Menard, secretary of the Louisiana Educational Relief Association. Although acknowledging the support of the Freedmen's Bureau and northern benevolent societies, Menard maintained that the ex-slaves' survival and development rested largely on their own shoulders: "The colored people are called today to mark out on the map of life with their own hands their future course or locality in the great national body politic. Other hands cannot mark for them; other tongues cannot speak for them; other eyes cannot see for them; they must see and speak for themselves, and make their own characters on the map, however crooked or illegible." That Menard's feelings were not unusual is revealed through the behavior of Louisiana's freedmen from 1866 to 1868. During this period they developed a parallel system of free schools. Even when the bureau reopened its schools, private schools for black pupils continued to spring up outside its control. Enrollment in such schools grew rapidly and actually exceeded the number registered in the bureau's system. In January 1867 there were sixty-five private schools in New Orleans enrolling 2,967 pupils; the bureau maintained fifty-six schools with 2,52.7 pupils enrolled. Free schooling was sustained in Louisiana largely as a result of the ex-slaves' collective efforts.8 The relationship between black self-activity and educational changes
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
11
in the postwar South is further illustrated by the behavior of Georgia's ex-slaves. In December 1864 a committee of Afro-American leaders in Savannah met with Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton and General William T. Sherman to request support for the education of Georgia's liberated blacks. Out of this conference evolved a plan for establishing an organized system of free schools. In 1865 Afro-American leaders formed the Georgia Educational Association to supervise schools in districts throughout the state, to establish school policies, and to raise funds to help finance the cost of education. Freedmen's Bureau officials described the aims and structure of this association: To associate the efforts of the people, the prominent educators in the State, the agents of northern societies, and such officers of the government as are authorized to aid the work, and to unite in such a manner as shall exclude any subject at all likely to divide their efforts or direct them from their one great and desirable object. To secure this end, subordinate associations are established as far as practicable. By this means a thorough union is formed and a prompt and constant communication with the parent society is had. Connected with the State association is a State board of education, which . . . is a general executive committee. Through this association Georgia's Afro-Americans sustained in full or part the operation of more than two-thirds of their schools. In the fall of 1866, they financed entirely or in part 96 of the 123 day and evening schools. They also owned 57 of the school buildings. Such accomplishments fulfilled the primary purpose of the Georgia Educational Association, "that the freedmen shall establish schools in their own counties and neighborhoods, to be supported entirely by the colored people." In Savannah, for instance, there were 2.8 schools in 1866, and 16 of them, reported the black Loyal Georgian, were "under the control of an Educational Board of Colored Men, taught by colored teachers, and sustained by the freed people." These beliefs and behavior were consistent with the activities of ex-slaves in Virginia, South Carolina, and Louisiana.9 Significantly, Georgia's black educational leaders were critical of popular misconceptions, which attributed the schooling of ex-slaves to Yankee benevolence. The Loyal Georgian, official newspaper of the Georgia Educational Association, rejected explicitly the argument that Yankee teachers brought schooling to the freedmen. In February 1866, though defending Yankee teachers against southern white criticism, the Loyal Georgian also expressed its hope that missionary teachers were not in the South "in any vain reliance on their superior gifts, either of intelligence or benevolence; or in any foolish self-confidence that they have a
12.
The Education of Blacks in the South
special call to this office, or special endowments to meet its demands." Historian Jacqueline Jones has demonstrated that northern teachers in Georgia were "taken aback to discover that some blacks preferred to teach in and operate their own schools without the benefit of northern largesse." Similarly, Ronald E. Butchart has shown that ex-slaves, in general, initiated and supported education for themselves and their children and also resisted external control of their educational institutions. In 1867, for instance, the Freedmen's Record complained about the tendency of ex-slaves to prefer sending their children to black-controlled private schools rather than supporting the less expensive northern whitedominated "free" schools. A white observer noted that "in all respects apart from his or her competency to teach—they will keep their children out of school, and go to work, organize and [sic] independent school and send their children to it." It is no wonder, then, that some missionaries complained of the ex-slaves' lack of gratitude "for the charity which northern friends are so graciously bestowing." The ex-slaves' educational movement became a test of their capacity to restructure their lives, to establish their freedom. Although they appreciated northern support, they resisted infringements that threatened to undermine their own initiative and self-reliance.10 In other important ways ex-slaves initiated and sustained schools whether or not northern aid was available. The "Sabbath" school system, about which little is known, provides a particularly clear study of educational activities operated largely on the strength of the ex-slave community. Frequently, Sabbath schools were established before "free" or "public" schools. These church-sponsored schools, operated mainly in evenings and on weekends, provided basic literacy instruction. "They reached thousands not able to attend weekday schools," writes historian Samuel L. Horst. In January 1866, in his first report to the Freedmen's Bureau, Alvord commented: Sabbath schools among freedmen have opened throughout the entire South; all of them giving elementary instruction, and reaching thousands who cannot attend the week-day teaching. These are not usually included in the regular returns, but are often spoken of with special interest by the superintendents. Indeed, one of the most thrilling spectacles which he who visits the southern country now witnesses in cities, and often upon the plantations, is the large schools gathered upon the Sabbath day, sometimes of many hundreds, dressed in clean Sunday garments, with eyes sparkling, intent upon elementary and Christian instruction. The management of some of these is admirable, after the fashion of the best Sunday
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
13
schools of white children, with faithful teachers, the majority of whom it will be noticed are colored. Some of Alvord's findings are especially worthy of emphasis. Sabbath schools were common in ex-slave communities across the South immediately following the war's end. In 1868 Alvord described the scope of Sabbath schools in North Carolina: "In all the cities of the State, in most of the smaller towns, and in many of the rural districts, Sabbath schools are established and well conducted." Although white religious societies sponsored some Sabbath schools for ex-slaves, the system was largely black-dominated, relied on local black communities for support, and generally had all-black teaching staffs. The importance of the Sabbath schools varied across states and localities. In some areas they constituted the only viable system of free instruction. T. K. Noble, Freedmen's Bureau superintendent of education in Kentucky, said in 1867: "The places of worship owned by the colored people are almost the only available school houses in the State."J r It is important, therefore, to emphasize another of Alvord's observations, that the Sabbath schools, often spoken of with special interest by the state superintendents, were not usually included in the regular bureau reports. C. E. Compton, the bureau's superintendent of education in Tennessee, reported in 1870 that "many children attend Sabbath schools at colored churches of which no report is received." The Freedmen's Bureau kept statistics from 1866 to 1870. These records include almost exclusively schools under the auspices of northern societies. Hence, exslaves laid a significantly larger foundation for universal education than is accounted for in official reports and in the histories of southern education. James M. McPherson writes, "At no time were more than 10 percent of the freedmen of school age attending the [missionary] societies' schools." Meyer Weinberg concludes that, in 1870, "nine out of ten black children still remained outside any school." These estimates, however accurate for schools reporting to the bureau, do not include data on the black church-operated schools. In 1869 Alvord asked his field agents to estimate numbers of teachers and enrollments in Sabbath schools. These reports, admittedly conservative in their estimates, enumerated i,5iz Sabbath schools with 6,146 teachers and 107,109 pupils. Sabbath schools continued to grow in the black community long after Reconstruction. In 1868 the African Methodist Episcopal church (AME), for example, enrolled 40,000 pupils in its Sabbath schools. By 1885, the AME church reported having "2.00,000 children in Sunday schools" for "intellectual and moral" instruction. These Sunday schools were not devoted entirely to Bible study. As Booker T. Washington recalled from
14
The Education of Blacks in the South
This school on St. Helena Island in South Carolina was typical of the Sabbath and free schools attended by ex-slaves in the period immediately following the Civil War. Courtesy of the National Archives.
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
15
his own experience, "the principal book studied in the Sunday school was the spelling book." The Sabbath schools represent yet another remarkable example of ex-slaves seeking, establishing, and supporting their own schools.12' It was such local activities by ex-slaves that spurred the establishment of widespread elementary and literacy education and provided the grassroots foundation for the educational activities of northern missionary societies and the Freedmen's Bureau. To be sure, ex-slaves benefited greatly from the support of northern whites; but they were determined to achieve educational self-sufficiency in the long run with or without the aid of northerners. Their self-determination has escaped the attention of all but a few historians. The larger significance of their behavior, however, did not go unnoticed by Freedmen's Bureau superintendent John Alvord, one of the most perceptive Yankee observers of postwar southern educational changes. As early as January 1866, Alvord noted the "self-sustaining element" in the ex-slaves' educational movement. He quickly recognized the organization and discipline that underlay the school campaign. In July 1866 he reported "that the surprising efforts of our colored population to obtain and [sic] education are not spasmodic." "They are growing to a habit," he continued, "crystalizing into a system, and each succeeding school-term shows their organization more and more complete and permanent." Initially, Alvord did not know what to make of these "surprising efforts." Foreshadowing the interpretations of some later historians, in January 1866 he attributed the ex-slaves' campaign for schooling to "the natural thirst for knowledge common to all men," a desire to imitate educated whites, an attraction to the mystery of literate culture, the practical needs of business life, and the stimulating effects of freedom. By July, however, Alvord pointed to a more fundamental motive for the freedmen's behavior: "They have within themselves . . . a vitality and hope, coupled with patience and willingness to struggle, which foreshadows with certainty their higher education as a people in the coming time." Universal education was certain to become a reality in black society, not because ex-slaves were motivated by childlike, irrational, and primitive drives, but because they were a responsible and politically self-conscious social class. Alvord, therefore, was confident that the ex-slaves' educational movement would not soon fall into decline: "Obstacles are yet to be encountered. Perhaps the most trying period in the freedmen's full emancipation has not yet come. But we can distinctly see that the incipient education universally diffused as it is, has given these whole four millions an impulse onward never to be lost. They are becoming conscious of what they can do, of what they ultimately can be. . . . Self-reliance is becoming their pride as it is their responsibility." The great efforts blacks made to establish schools for their own children
16
The Education of Blacks in the South
soon after the war and to establish state-supported systems of public education for all children reflected both their self-reliance and distinct educational and social philosophy. These ideals had been cultivated in large part during their long ordeal of slavery/3 Ultimately, the formation and development of the ex-slaves' beliefs and behavior regarding universal education in the postwar South will have to be understood as part of a process that started decades before the Civil War. For, as Herbert Gutman has demonstrated, the choices so many freed men and women made immediately upon their emancipation, before they had substantial rights by law, had their origins in the ways their ancestors had adapted to enslavement. Hence, before the reason why Afro-Americans emerged from slavery with a particular desire for literacy can be understood, slavery and especially slave literacy await refined and detailed study. That is beyond the primary scope of this chapter, but a few examples might illuminate the social context of slave literacy and, therefore, black consciousness of literate culture. The way slaves and other southern social classes thought about literacy and education developed along with the modes in which they actually learned or experienced it. That experience for slaves was vastly different in most important respects from the experiences of planters, white small farmers, industrialists, and poor whites. During the three decades before the Civil War slaves lived in a society in which for them literacy was forbidden by law and symbolized as a skill that contradicted the status of slaves. As former slave William Henry Heard recalled: "We did not learn to read nor write, as it was against the law for any person to teach any slave to read; and any slave caught writing suffered the penalty of having his forefinger cut from his right hand; yet there were some who could read and write." Despite the dangers and difficulties, thousands of slaves learned to read and write. By 1860 about 5 percent of the slaves had learned to read. Many paid a high price for their literacy. Thomas H. Jones, a slave in mid-nineteenth-century North Carolina, learned how to read while hiding in the back of his master's store. "It seemed to me that if I could learn to read and write," said Jones, "this learning might, nay, I really thought it would point out to me the way to freedom, influence and real secure happiness." As he became more engrossed in his pursuit of literate culture and careless about concealing it, Jones was surprised one morning by the sudden appearance of his master. Having only a second to react, Jones threw his book behind some barrels in the store, but not before his master had seen him throw something away. The slaveowner assumed that Jones had been stealing items from the stockroom and ordered him to retrieve whatever he had thrown away. "I knew if my book was discovered that all was lost, and I felt prepared for any hazard or suffering rather than give up my book and my hopes of
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
17
improvement," recalled Jones. He endured three brutal whippings to conceal his pursuit of literacy. In another instance a slave by the name of Scipio was put to death for teaching a slave child how to read and spell, and the child was severely beaten to make him "forget what he had learned." The former slave Ferebe Rogers was married by a slave, Enoch Golden, who persisted throughout his life in spreading literacy among his fellow slaves. "On his dyin' bed he said he been de death o' many a nigger 'cause he taught so many to read and write," said Rogers. Elizabeth Sparks was part of a group of rebel slaves who held secret literacy sessions in the slave quarters. The gatherings, known among slaves as "stealin' the meetin','' were attended by free blacks who attempted to teach slaves to read and write. Although slaves became literate in a variety of ways, including at the hands of slaveowners, probably the typical experience was characterized by former slave Louisa Cause: "No child, white people never teach colored people nothin, but to be good to dey massa en mittie, what learnin dey would get in dem days dey been get it at night; taught demselves." No other class of native southerners had experienced literacy in this context. Hence emancipation extruded an ex-slave class with a fundamentally different consciousness of literacy, a class that viewed reading and writing as a contradiction of oppression.14 In the history of black education the political significance of slave literacy reaches beyond the antebellum period. Many of the educators and leaders of the postbellum years were men and women who first became literate under slavery. Moreover, many prominent post—Civil War black educators who were not literate as slaves received their initial understanding of the meaning of literacy under slavery. Such black leaders as Frederick Douglass, Bishop Henry M. Turner, Bishop Isaac Lane, Bishop Lucius H. Holsey, and P. B. S. Pinchback and educators Isaac M. Bergman, Bishop John Wesley Gaines, W. S. Scarborough, and Lucy C. Laney are some of the prominent nineteenth-century figures who became literate in the antebellum South. Their ideas about the meaning and purpose of education were shaped partly by the social system of slavery under which they first encountered literacy. After slavery many of the leading black educators emerged from among the rebel literates, those slaves who had sustained their own learning process in defiance of the slaveowners' authority. They viewed literacy and formal education as means to liberation and freedom. Postslavery experiences continued to reinforce and shape a distinctive Afro-American consciousness of literate culture. "Every little negro in the county is now going to school and the public pays for it," wrote one disgruntled planter. "This is a hell of [a] fix but we can't help it, and the best policy is to conform as far as possible to circumstances." Such re-
18
The Education of Blacks in the South
sponses emphasized the planters' persistent beliefs that literate culture contradicted the status of black southerners. Many postslavery developments provided ex-slaves with compelling reasons to become literate. The uses and abuses of written labor contracts made it worthwhile to be able to read, write, and cipher. Frequently, planters designed labor contracts in ways that would confuse and entrap the ex-slaves. As the Freedmen's Bureau superintendent observed, "I saw one [labor contract] in which it was stipulated that one-third of seven-twelfths of all corn, potatoes, fodder, etc., shall go to the laborers." Hence when a middle-aged black woman was asked why she was so determined to learn to read and write, she replied, "so that the Rebs can't cheat me." The enfranchisement of black males also gave ex-slaves an impulse to become literate. "At the place of voting they look at the ballot-box and then at the printed ticket in their hands, wishing they could read it," reported Alvord in 1867. Education for the freedmen could serve as a safeguard against fraud and manipulation.15 More fundamentally, the ex-slaves' struggle for education was an expression of freedom. It was, as Ronald Butchart maintains, an effort of an oppressed people "to put as great a distance between themselves and bondage as possible." The New Orleans Black Republican proclaimed in April 1865: "Freedom and school books and newspapers, go hand in hand. Let us secure the freedom we have received by the intelligence that can maintain it." This proclamation was signed by prominent black leaders of New Orleans, including Thomas S. Isabelle, C. C. Antoine, S. W. Rogers, Professor P. M. Williams, and A. E. Barber. Similarly, in 1867, the black Equal Rights Association of Macon, Georgia, resolved: "That a Free school system is a great need of our state, and that we will do all in our power by voice and by vote to secure adoption of a system." That same year black leaders Henry M. Turner, T. G. Campbell, John T. Costin, and Thomas P. Beard formed the Black Republican party of Georgia. The organization declared that "Free Schools and churches are the guardians of civil and religious liberty." Northern observers quickly noted that education stood as "the token and pledge" of blacks' emancipation. Even adult ex-slaves were, as the Freedmen's Bureau superintendent recorded, "earnestly seeking that instruction which will fit them for their new responsibilities." For the freedmen, universal schooling was a matter of personal liberation and a necessary function of a free society.16 Thus ex-slaves did much more than establish a tradition of educational self-help that supported most of their schools. They also were the first among native southerners to wage a campaign for universal public education. From its small beginnings in 1860 and with the help of the Freedmen's Bureau and northern benevolent societies, the school system was virtually complete in its institutional form by 1870. According to
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
19
historian Henry Allen Bullock, fourteen southern states had established 575 schools by 1865, and these schools were employing 1,171 teachers for the 71,779 Negro and white children in regular attendance. School attendance was not uniform across cities and towns, but it was visible in enough places to signal a fundamental shift in southern tradition. In 1866 Alvord reported his findings on the level of ex-slaves' school attendance: "The average attendance is nearly equal to that usually found at the North. For instance, in the District of Columbia, the daily attendance at the public school is but forty-one (41) percent; while at the colored schools of the District it is seventy-five (75) percent. In the State of New York, the daily attendance at the public school averages forty-three (43) percent. At the colored schools in the city of Memphis it is seventy-two (72.) percent; and in Virginia eighty-two (82) percent." In Louisiana over 60 percent of all black children from five to twelve years of age were enrolled in school by 1865. The ex-slaves' school enrollment suffered a setback in 1868, rose again in 1869, and leveled off in 1870. In the entire South in 1870, about one-fourth of the school-age ex-slaves attended "public" schools. Reliable data are not available to determine Sabbath school attendance rates, but it seems probable from scattered evidence that Sabbath schools increased their enrollment throughout the 18705 and i88os. The freedmen's initiative in starting schools and their remarkable attendance rates made it evident that "free" schooling was fast becoming a customary right in the postwar South/ 7 The ex-slaves' most fundamental challenge to the planters' ideology and structure of schooling, however, went beyond the practice of universal schooling as a customary right. They played a central role in etching the idea of universal public education into southern state constitutional law. As DuBois demonstrated, "The first great mass movement for public education at the expense of the state, in the South, came from Negroes." Black politicians played a critical role in establishing universal education as a basic right in southern constitutional conventions during congressional Reconstruction. Under the Military Reconstruction Acts passed in 1867, Congress empowered the generals of the armies of occupation to call for new constitutional conventions in which blacks were to participate along with whites. Black politicians and leaders joined with Republicans in southern constitutional conventions to legalize public education in the constitutions of the former Confederate states. By 1870, every southern state had specific provisions in its constitution to assure a public school system financed by a state fund. And even when white southerners regained control of state governments, they kept the central features of educational governance and finance created by the ex-slave—Republican coalition. Ex-slaves used their resources first in a grass-roots movement to build, fund, and staff schools as a practical
20
The Education of Blacks in the South
right; then they joined with Republicans to incorporate the idea into southern state constitutional law. With these actions they revolutionized the South's position regarding the role of universal public education in society.18 The freedmen's educational revolution bred a counterrevolution. Postwar southern economic and social development, including educational reform, was heavily influenced by the persistent domination of the planter class. Traditional historiography has contended that the Civil War and emancipation brought about the downfall of the prewar planter class. The most recent historical scholarship, however, demonstrates convincingly the extent to which wealth and power in the postwar South continued to rest in the planters' hands. What actually occurred was not the downfall or destruction of the old planter class but rather its persistence and metamorphosis. Plantation land tended to remain in the hands of its prewar owners.19 The persistence and tenacity of the planter class throughout the war and Reconstruction, contends Jonathan Wiener, laid the basis for its continued domination of the southern political economy in the iSyos and i88os. As a consequence, the South took the "Prussian road to industrial capitalism—a delayed industrialization under the auspices of a backward agrarian elite, the power of which was based on a repressive system of agricultural labor." In 1880, 75.4 percent of the South's labor force was in agriculture. Black agricultural laborers constituted more than 40 percent of the South's total agricultural labor force and formed a clear majority in several southern states. Agriculture accounted for only 23.3 percent of the work force in the Northeast and 54.5 percent in the North Central region. The planters' approach to labor control posed a formidable threat to the ex-slaves' educational movement. Elsewhere in the nation, particularly the industrial Northeast, dominant classes had already committed themselves to tax-supported public education, partly as a means to train and discipline an industrial work force. Freedmen's Bureau Superintendent Alvord, echoing the northern idea of universal schooling for the laboring classes, proclaimed to the South in 1866: "Popular education cannot well be opposed; free labor is found to be more contented with its privileges." But southern planters did not share northern ideas on free labor or popular education. Postwar planters complained that their "free" laborers were unreliable, failed to comply with the terms of their labor contracts, and would not obey orders. Most important, schooling most emphatically was not the answer to southern labor problems. "The South could not supply by schools," said one southern writer in 1868, "the restraining, correcting, elevating influences" cultivated and maintained by slavery. When Carl Schurz toured the South in late 1865, he found the planters believing that "learning will
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
2.1
spoil the nigger for work." Faced with the possibilities of moving toward a northern-style system of free labor and mass literacy or remaining with their coercive mode of labor allocation and control, the planters chose the labor-repressive system, which rested at least partially on the absence of formal schooling among agricultural and domestic laborers.10 Hence at war's end the planters attempted to reestablish the plantation system with only minor modifications. With the overseer renamed "manager" or "agent," the planters tried to force ex-slaves to work the postwar plantation in antebellumlike work gangs. The planters needed above all a resumption of work on the part of black laborers in numbers and involving costs similar to those prevailing in the pre-war era. This desire was thwarted when ex-slaves withdrew a substantial portion of their labor power. By greatly reducing the number of days worked and the number of hours worked each day, they created a serious labor shortage. According to economic historians Roger L. Ransom and Richard Sutch, upon emancipation the supply of black labor fell to two-thirds its prewar level. This reduced labor supply had a profound impact on the ability of the South to produce cotton. It represented a severe financial blow to the planter class. Therefore, ex-slaves gained some power in the labor market to insist upon educational and economic changes in the South's social hierarchy. Planters, however, generally favored a policy of strict labor control and discouraged the education of freedmen.il In the immediate postwar years, ex-slaves, sometimes assisted by northern troops, were able to use their labor power to give weight to their educational demands. In January 1866 Alvord noted: If they are to be retained as laborers in the rural districts, [educational] opportunities must be furnished on the plantations. More than one instance could be already given where a school in the interior has been started from this motive. . . . The head of one of the largest of the timber and turpentine enterprises in South Carolina told me that he formerly had hired only men, but he had now learned that he must have their families too, and that this could only be done by allowing them patches of land, treating them properly, paying them well, and giving them schools. In 1866 and 1867, Freedmen's Bureau officials observed the widespread emergence of the "educational clause" in labor contracts between planters and ex-slaves. In July 1867 Frank R. Chase, the bureau's superintendent of education for Louisiana, reported: "Many of the freedmen made it a special clause of their contract this year, that they should have the benefit of schools. But the planter was only willing to have colored teachers employed, thinking that such schools would amount to little or nothing. In this they are mistaken, as many of the most prosperous
22
The Education of Blacks in the South
schools in the State are taught by competent colored teachers." Such reports from bureau officials throughout the South convinced Alvord that "the educational clause in the contracts . . . is rapidly becoming universal." Hence, he continued, "Schools are everywhere springing up from the soil itself at the demand of those who till it—a state of things which localizes the benefits of education in a fixed, permanent society." Because ex-slaves understood that their labor power was essential for the restoration of southern agriculture to its prewar level of prosperity, they demanded not only fair wages for their work but educational opportunities as well. This practice, at least for a brief period in the postwar years, enabled some plantation ex-slaves to experience the benefits of schooling. Some planters, desiring to secure and stabilize a needed supply of laborers, even shielded freedmen's schools from harassment by white terrorists. Schools on the plantations were usually financed by the exslaves, but a few were paid for by planters.Zi In general, the ex-slaves were unable to reconcile the planters to the idea of black education. It has been argued that the most intelligent and successful planters usually supported Negro education and that the most bitter opposition came from the white lower classes. To be sure, militant opposition did come from lower-class whites, but it came also from planters. A few planters did accept or tolerate the idea of universal education among the ex-slaves, and so did a few poor whites. As a class, however, the planters reacted decisively to the freedmen's educational movement; they were opposed to black education in particular and showed substantial resistance to the very idea of public schooling for the laboring classes. The planters' opposition to black education surfaced early. In 1864 the New Orleans Tribune reported that Louisiana planters were strongly opposed to the ex-slaves' educational movement. In the country parishes, white teachers were "condemned and scorned" and landlords "refused to rent buildings for school purposes, and to board the teachers." In 1867 Louisiana's superintendent of education complained that "a large majority of the planters are opposed to the education of the freedmen." An example from 1871 illustrates the point with much greater force. General John Eaton, commissioner of the new Federal Bureau of Education, sent out three thousand questionnaires to laborers and employers regarding the benefits of universal education in the South. Concerning the replies, he wrote: "A large number have been received, and the writers were unanimous in their testimony as to the value of education to every class of laborers, with one striking exception, namely, the southern planters; the majority of whom did not believe in giving the Negro any education." Planters resisted in various ways the ex-slaves' pursuit of universal schooling. Henry Allen Bullock found that Virginia planters in 1865 "were seeking to prevent Negro parents from
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
2.3
sending their children to school by threatening to put them out of their houses." Alabama whites who employed ex-slaves as domestics would terminate the employment of servants whose children attended school. Similarly, in 1869 the Freedmen's Bureau school superintendent for northwestern Louisiana and northern Texas discovered that "many of the planters will not allow colored children on their places to go to school at all, even when we have started those which are convenient." The planters, with few exceptions, viewed black education as a distinct threat to the racially qualified form of labor exploitation upon which their agrarian order depended.Z3 The planters' heavy use of child labor contributed significantly to their opposition to black education. During good crop years black school terms were so short and irregular that children hardly had time to learn to read and write. "Owing to unusual employment of children this season in gathering crops, especially cotton, which was very abundant, many schools did not open until December," reported John Alvord in 1870. Many parents fought this infringement upon their children's educational opportunities, but others conceded to the planters' interests.M Despite the ex-slaves' early success in laying the foundation for universal education in the South, planters presented severe obstacles to those who endeavored to establish an elaborate bureaucratic system of free public schooling. Between 1869 and 1877, the planter-dominated white South regained control of the state governments. The moment of broad retrenchment came with the disputed presidential election of 1876 and the settlement that resulted in the Compromise of 1877. Southerners agreed to the election of Rutherford B. Hayes, and Republicans agreed to remove federal troops from the South. With both state authority and extralegal means of control firmly in their hands, the planters, though unable to eradicate earlier gains, kept universal schooling underdeveloped. They stressed low taxation, opposed compulsory school attendance laws, blocked the passage of new laws that would strengthen the constitutional basis of public education, and generally discouraged the expansion of public school opportunities. The planters' resistance virtually froze the ex-slaves' educational campaign in its mid-18705 position. "At the beginning of the twentieth century," wrote Horace Mann Bond, "the condition of the schools for Negro children in the South was but slightly improved over their condition in 1875." Indeed, between 1880 and 1900, the number of black children of school age increased 2.5 percent, but the proportion attending public school fell.*5 The planters gained further control over black education as they increased their supervision and control over the ex-slave laboring class. The semiautonomous position and newly acquired economic power of freedmen in the labor market had buttressed their educational move-
24
The Education of Blacks in the South
This Thomas Nast cartoon that appeared in Harper's Weekly, 24 October 1874, depicts the southern white reaction to the ex-slave crusade for universal schooling. Note the fallen school book and the schoolhouse burning in the background while an ex-slave is being lynched. Courtesy of the Library of Congress. ment, but as landlords regained control over black labor, the force and autonomy of the campaign for universal schooling were severely weakened. The planters established a system of coercive labor designed to reduce wages, to restrict labor mobility, to protect individual planters from competition with other employers, and to force blacks to sign repressive labor contracts. Historians William Cohen, Pete Daniel, and Jonathan Wiener discovered a variety of state laws and local customs aimed at helping planters acquire, hold, and exploit black labor virtually
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
2.5
at will. Enticement laws passed by ten southern states from 1865 to 1867 were the most common measures aimed at controlling the black labor force. "Enticement statutes," writes Cohen, "established the proprietary claims of employers to 'their' Negroes by making it a crime to hire away a laborer under contract to another man." Many other laws facilitated the recruitment and retention of black labor. Vagrancy laws, passed by all the former Confederate states except Tennessee and Arkansas in 1865 and 1866, gave local authorities a "virtual mandate to arrest any poor man who did not have a labor contract." Such statutes enabled police to round up "idle" blacks in times of labor scarcity, and, except in North Carolina, they provided for the hiring out of convicted offenders. Those jailed on charges of vagrancy could sign a "voluntary" labor contract with their former employer or some other white man who agreed to post bond. Workers who had no surety often wound up on chain gangs and were forced to labor through the convict-lease system.16 The planters favored a labor-repressive system of agricultural production. They had little incentive to use education and technology to increase efficiency and productivity or to use schooling as a means to train and discipline a more efficient work force. The postwar planters held to the beliefs and behavior of over two centuries of slavery; they did not trust the system of "free labor." Force, rather than rational free choice, was the basis of the South's political economy. Hence the region's slow development in education was in substantial part the result of the planters' stubborn adherence to a set of values inconsistent with democracy, modernization, rapid industrialization, and free schooling. To be sure, other factors militated against rapid educational change. Fundamentally, however, the South's slow rate of educational development and the planters' particular opposition to black education sprang from their clear economic and ideological interests in preserving the racially qualified system of coercive agricultural labor. Both race and class conflict existed between white planters and their black agricultural laborers. Even though the long-term gains in public education for ex-slaves proved to be small and slow, their organized efforts and ideological imperatives laid the foundation for universal education in the South. Between 1860 and 1880 no organized challenge to the planters' interests came from the region's white middle or lower classes. Both groups were not only economically dependent on the planters, as were the ex-slaves, but also subservient to the planters' interests. Freedmen's Bureau officials were particularly alarmed by lower-class whites' general apathy toward public education. Bureau officials recognized that some planters were hostile to the idea of public education for poor whites. Louisiana's superintendent in 1869 observed planters' opposition to "the education of freedmen and poor whites." "In the parish of Franklin," he reported,
26
The Education of Blacks in the South
"public sentiment, as to the education of freedmen and poor whites, is very decidedly against it." Unlike the ex-slaves, however, "the whites take little or no interest in educational matters, even for their own race." Throughout the bureau's history, its officials contrasted ex-slave and lower-class white attitudes toward public education. In 1866 Alvord noted: "We make no invidious comparisons of the ignorant freedman, and the ignorant Anglo-Saxon of the South. We only say the former has most creditably won his present position; and he has done it by good conduct, and rapid improvement under that instruction we are now reporting." In 1869 a bureau state school superintendent observed: "As a class they [ex-slaves] are eager to learn, while the poor whites are indifferent." Poor whites were not so much indifferent as they were bound to the planters' regime. Before the war poor children were unable to afford private schooling and only rarely had the opportunity to attend charity institutions. In the immediate postwar years the region's poor whites, in general, were still too closely tied to the planters' interests and ideology to pursue a different conception of education and society. White laborers and small farmers when organized in the Farmers' Alliance and Populist party challenged the planters' opposition to universal schooling only in the late i88os. Ex-slaves, or black native southerners, had struggled for universal schooling over two decades before the Populist campaigns of the late i88os and 18905. The ex-slaves' campaign also predated the organized movement for free schooling by southern middle-class progressives. The South's white middle classes, unorganized and subservient to planter interests throughout the nineteenth century, did not begin their campaign for universal education until the dawn of the twentieth century. Hence, surrounded by planters who were hostile to public education, middle-class professionals who allied themselves with planter interests, and lower-class whites who were largely alienated from mass education, ex-slaves were the only native group to forge ahead to commit the South to a system of universal schooling in the immediate postwar years.i? Clearly, the freedmen's educational movement had an impact that reached far beyond their own communities. Their initiative forced whites of all classes to confront the question of universal schooling. From the Freedmen's Bureau superintendent came testimony that "the white population of the South feels the power of the [freedmen's] schools." "The poor whites are provoked by hearing Negroes read, while they are ignorant; and it is my belief that they will now receive schools, if furnished them, as never before," wrote Alvord in 1866. Further, "The educated class are not slow to perceive that their schools must be reopened, or fall behind humiliated, and that new schools must now be organized on a more popular plan than heretofore." Mass education was necessary for
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
2.7
white children, insisted Robert Mills Lusher, white school superintendent of Louisiana, so that they would be "properly prepared to maintain the supremacy of the white race." The ex-slaves' initiative in establishing and supporting a system of secular and Sabbath schools and in demanding universal public education for all children presented a new challenge to the dominant-class whites—the possibility of an emerging literate black working class in the midst of a largely illiterate poor white class. This constituted a frontal assault on the racist myth of black inferiority, which was critical to the maintenance of the South's racial caste system. The planters, unable to wipe out the educational gains made by ex-slaves between 1860 and 1870, had to take a more liberal posture regarding universal education among whites of all classes. Moreover, poor whites became less indifferent toward the idea of public education. Thus the Populist demands for free schooling in the late i88os and 18905, as well as the middle-class educational reforms of the early twentieth century, were indebted to the ex-slaves' educational movement of the i86os and i87os.z8 In the late 18705 and early i88os, one could already detect a slight shift in southern white attitudes regarding universal schooling in general and particularly for black children. Southern whites began realizing the improbability of reversing the gains made by freedmen during the Civil War and Reconstruction years. Hence a growing, although small, minority of prominent southern whites began speaking in favor of universal schooling for the region's laboring classes, including Afro-Americans. Foremost among these whites were those promoting limited or rapid southern industrialization. Although traditional planters continued to favor a repressive system of agricultural labor and to discourage working-class literacy, proponents of southern industrialization increasingly viewed mass schooling as a means to produce efficient and contented labor and as a socialization process to instill in black and white children an acceptance of the southern racial hierarchy. In 1877 Thomas Muldrop Logan, former Confederate general and industrialist in Richmond, Virginia, spoke before the American Social Science Association on the question of education in the southern states. Logan, who became one of the South's most prominent railroad magnates, articulated a rationale for supporting working-class and Afro- American schooling that came to characterize the thinking of many dominant-class whites in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. "Wherever public schools have been established," argued Logan, "the industrial classes, becoming more intelligent, have proved more skillful and efficient; and all competing countries must likewise establish public schools, or be supplanted in the markets of the world." Logan was well aware of the planters' argument against black schooling, "that when the freedman regards himself quali-
2.8
The Education of Blacks in the South
fied to earn a support by mental work, he is unwilling to accept manual labor." Logan believed, however, that maintenance of caste distinctions and division of labor were possible if blacks were offered industrial education such as was practiced at the Hampton Normal and Agricultural Institute of Virginia. By training blacks "to perform, efficiently, their part in the social economy, this caste allotment of social duties might prove advantageous to southern society, as a whole, on the principle of a division of labor applied to races." These views were echoed by famous and little-known southern industrialists as they testified before a subcommittee of the United States Senate Committee on Education and Labor in 1883.Z9 But the prevailing philosophies of black education and the subjects taught in black schools were not geared to reproduce the caste distinctions or the racially segmented labor force desired by Logan and many other postbellum white industrialists. The black teachers, school officials, and secular and religious leaders who formed the vanguard of the postwar common school movement insisted that the ex-slaves must educate themselves, gather experience, and acquire a responsible awareness of the duties incumbent upon them as citizens and as male voters in the new social order. Their thinking on these questions indicated virtually no illusions about the power of schooling to ameliorate fundamental economic inequalities. Rather, it reflected their belief that education could help raise the freed people to an appreciation of their historic responsibility to develop a better society and that any significant reorganization of the southern political economy was indissolubly linked to their education in the principles, duties, and obligations appropriate to a democratic social order. Ex-slave communities pursued their educational objectives by developing various strata, but the one they stressed the most was leadership training. They believed that the masses could not achieve political and economic independence or self-determination without first becoming organized, and organization was impossible without welltrained intellectuals—teachers, ministers, politicians, managers, administrators, and businessmen. Toward this end the black leaders and educators adopted the New England classical liberal curriculum, so the subjects taught in post—Civil War black elementary, normal, and collegiate schools did not differ appreciably from those taught in northern white schools. Students in elementary schools received instruction in reading, spelling, writing, grammar, diction, history, geography, arithmetic, and music. Normal school students took this standard English curriculum with additional courses in orthography, map drawing, physiology, algebra, and geometry, as well as the theory and practice of teaching. The college curriculum varied
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
29
slightly among institutions, but the classical course leading to the B.A. usually required Latin, Greek, mathematics, science, philosophy, and, in a few cases, one modern language. Black leaders did not view their adoption of the classical liberal curriculum or its philosophical foundations as mere imitation of white schooling. Indeed, they knew many whites who had no education at all. Rather, they saw this curriculum as providing access to the best intellectual traditions of their era and the best means to understanding their own historical development and sociological uniqueness. To be sure, a study of the classical liberal curriculum was not a study of the historical and cultural forces that enabled Afro-Americans to survive the most dehumanized aspects of enslavement. Yet that curriculum did not necessarily convince black students that they were inferior to white people.30 For example, Richard Wright, one of the brightest and most influential educators of the post-Reconstruction era, found in his study of the classics solid evidence to counter claims of black inferiority. Wright was a student in an American Missionary Association school in Atlanta in 1868 when a group of visitors from the North, including General Oliver O. Howard, asked the black pupils what they should tell their friends in New England about the Georgia freedmen. Replied the young Wright, "Tell them we are rising." Wright graduated from Atlanta University in 1876 and in 1880, at age twenty-seven, he was principal of the Augusta, Georgia, "Colored High School" (later named E. A. Ware High School), the only public high school for blacks in the state. In 1883 principal Wright was sworn and examined by the U.S. Senate Committee on Education and Labor regarding conditions for education and work among blacks in Georgia. Senator Henry W. Blair of New Hampshire, the committee's chairman, queried Wright about the comparative inferiority and superiority of races. Drawing upon his understanding of the classics, Wright replied: It is generally admitted that religion has been a great means of human development and progress, and I think that about all the great religions which have blest this world have come from the colored races—all. . . . I believe too, that our methods of alphabetic writing all came from the colored race, and I think the majority of the sciences in their origin have come from the colored races. . . . Now I take the testimony of those people who know, and who, I feel are capable of instructing me on this point, and I find them saying that the Egyptians were actually woolly-haired negroes. In Humboldt's Cosmos (Vol. 2, p. 531) you will find that testimony, and Humboldt, I presume, is pretty good authority. The same thing is
3O
The Education of Blacks in the South stated in Herodotus, and in a number of other authors with whom you gentlemen are doubtless familiar. Now, if that is true, the idea that this negro race is inherently inferior, seems to me to be at least a little limping.
Wright's study of the classical liberal tradition led him to conclude that "these differences of race, so called, are a mere matter of color and not of brain." For such educators as Wright, the classical course was not so much the imposition of an alien white culture that would make blacks feel inferior as it was a means to understanding the development of the Western world and blacks' inherent rights to equality within that world. Thus, with few exceptions, both the schools founded and sustained by black churches and secular organizations as well as those founded by northern missionary societies taught a basic English education supplemented with the classical courses at the normal school and collegiate levels.31 During the immediate postwar years the more conservative missionary societies made some attempts to superimpose upon the common school curriculum a set of readers designed specifically and exclusively for exslave children. The American Tract Society of the American Missionary Association published the largest collection of these materials. Such readers as The Freedmen's Primer, The Freedmen's Spelling Book, The Lincoln Primer, and the First, Second and Third Freedmen's Readers contained social values designed to inculcate in the ex-slaves an acceptance of economic and racial subordination. These books portrayed blacks in subservient roles and frequently assumed that blacks were morally and mentally inferior. Their use of such books to propagate ideas of racial subordination betray the conservative missionaries' perception that the appropriate regressive social values were not already contained in the New England common school course. Whether these special books had any widespread and long-range impact is extremely doubtful. First, even in the most conservative missionary schools the basic pattern of freedmen's education followed that of northern public schools. Second, the missionary-sponsored common school structure was much too weak and fragmented to affect the instruction of large numbers of ex-slaves. In 1870 the American Missionary Association, for instance, sustained 157 common schools. That number had declined to 70 in 1871 and to 13 in 1874. By the mid-iSyos, the northern societies had already reduced their involvement in black southern education, particularly in the area of common schools. After this period, they concentrated their efforts and financial aid primarily on normal and higher education. Their normal schools and colleges offered the traditional classical liberal curriculum. This em-
Ex-Slaves and the Rise of Universal Education
31
phasis was important in determining curricular trends in black common schools because missionary colleges trained the bulk of black teachers until well into the twentieth century.31 The short-range purpose of black schooling was to provide the masses of ex-slaves with basic literacy skills plus the rudiments of citizenship training for participation in a democratic society. The long-range purpose was the intellectual and moral development of a responsible leadership class that would organize the masses and lead them to freedom and equality. Being educated and literate had an important cultural significance to Afro-Americans, and they pursued these goals in opposition to the economic and ideological interest of the planter-dominated South. Despite what seemed like overwhelming opposition to their educational campaigns, the masses of Afro-Americans persisted in becoming literate. Their 95 percent illiteracy rate in 1860 had dropped to 70 percent in 1880 and would drop to 30 percent by 1910. The former slaves were becoming literate; the process could be slowed but it could not be stopped or reversed.33 By 1880, many white southerners saw that any attempt to reverse the thrust of the ex-slaves' school campaigns would invite greater black resistance and possibly northern intervention. They began to make an uneasy peace with the Reconstruction-era educational reforms. Most did not agree with the idea of universal education for both races any more than they agreed with the Fifteenth Amendment and universal franchise for all men. They could agree, however, that it was politically unwise to attempt to repeal the legal basis of either. A particular class of southern whites began thinking more about controlling and restricting the expansion of public schooling in the black South and the possibility of adapting it to the region's traditional social structure and racial mores. Their interest in the schooling of Afro-American children differed in social origin and purpose from the ex-slaves' educational movement and even from the interests of the most conservative missionary societies. They called for the special instruction of the former slaves in a manner that could not be adapted from the curriculum and teaching materials of the classical liberal tradition. A full curriculum of special instruction for black students was being developed at that time by Samuel Armstrong at the Hampton Normal and Agricultural Institute in Hampton, Virginia. This new curriculum offered the possibility of adapting black education to the particular needs and interests of the South's dominant-class whites. Hence those southern and northern whites who thought it wiser to redirect the social purpose of freedmen's education rather than attempt to destroy it rallied to this new model of special instruction. This aspect of the exslaves' struggle for universal education—the development of a special
3 2.
The Education of Blacks in the South
form of industrial education for Afro-Americans—provoked more controversy than any other issue in black education during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. As the period 1860 to 1880 was characterized by efforts to establish the legal, institutional, and moral foundation of universal schooling for ex-slaves, the quarter century following was characterized by movements to transform the content and purpose of instruction in black education.34
2, THE HAMPTON MODEL OF NORMAL SCHOOL INDUSTRIAL E D U C A T I O N , 1868-1915
IT is ONE of the great ironies of Afro-American history that the ideological and programmatic challenge to the ex-slaves' conception of universal schooling and social progress was conceived and nurtured by a Yankee, Samuel Chapman Armstrong, and a former slave, Booker T. Washington. But even as the leaders of the ex-slave class struggled to build an educational system to help reinforce their conceptions of freedom and social order, there was born in Hampton, Virginia, in 1868, a conjuncture of educational pedagogy and social ideology of different origins and character. Armstrong represented a social class, ideology, and world outlook that was fundamentally different from and opposed to the interests of the freedmen. Thus in his establishment of the Hampton Normal and Agricultural Institute, he was neither unconscious nor contrarious, but honest. The institute's curriculum, values, and ethos represented his social class and ideology as properly as the moral foundation of the Sabbath schools, free schools, public schools, and colleges represented the social and cultural values of the ex-slaves. The ex-slaves struggled to develop a social and educational ideology singularly appropriate to their defense of emancipation and one that challenged the social power of the planter regime. Armstrong developed a pedagogy and ideology designed to avoid such confrontations and to maintain within the South a social consensus that did not challenge traditional inequalities of wealth and power. In time these two ideologies and programs of black education collided, and Armstrong's prized pupil, Booker T. Washington, was at the center of the confrontation. Washington founded Tuskegee Normal and Industrial Institute in 1881, and by the turn of the century, the "Hampton-Tuskegee Idea" represented the ideological antithesis of the educational and social movement begun by ex-slaves. The strife between these two ideologies and systems of education did not subside until the late 19205, when Hampton and Tuskegee radically reformed
34
The Education of Blacks in the South
their curricula and moved closer to the ideological mainstream of black education.1 The traditional emphasis on Hampton as a trade or technical school has obscured the fact that it was founded and maintained as a normal school and that its mission was the training of common school teachers for the South's black educational system. The Hampton-Tuskegee curriculum was not centered on trade or agricultural training; it was centered on the training of teachers. A condition for admission to Hampton was the "intention to remain through the whole course and become a teacher." This goal was achieved because approximately 84 percent of the 723 graduates from Hampton's first twenty classes became teachers. Moreover, Hampton did not offer any trade certificates until 1895, twenty-seven years after the school's founding. This was long after it had been embraced by northern and southern white educational reformers as the most appropriate form of education to assist in bringing racial peace, political stability, and material prosperity to the American South. Still, in 1900, only 45 of Hampton's 656 students were enrolled in its trade school division, and only 4 students were listed as majoring in agriculture. These programs were secondary and relatively insignificant. From its inception until well into the twentieth century, Hampton was almost wholly devoted to teacher training. A normal school became confused with trade training and economic development because Armstrong, and later Washington, employed a unique manual labor routine and an ideology of "self-help" as the practical and moral foundation of their teacher training process. Both established farms and small shops to give their prospective teachers the required manual labor experience. In these routinized work situations, however, the development of persons skilled in trades or farming was a secondary aim, seldom acquired by the students. The primary aim was to work the prospective teachers long and hard so that they would embody, accept, and preach an ethic of hard toil or the "dignity of labor." Then, and only then, believed Armstrong, could his normal school graduates develop the appropriate values and character to teach the children of the South's distinctive black laboring class.1 As a normal school Hampton was markedly different in structure and content from black teachers' colleges and liberal arts colleges. Like other normal schools of the nineteenth century, Hampton offered a curriculum of two or three years in length and did not grant a bachelor's degree. Moreover, the completion of a four-year secondary school curriculum was not required for admission to Hampton and other normal schools. Most of Hampton's beginning students arrived with a less than adequate elementary school education and successfully completed the normal school program with an education equivalent in quality to that of a
The Hampton Model
35
fair tenth grade program. A good high school offered a superior academic program. In contrast to the normal school's precollegiate academic program, a teachers' college or department was a state, municipal, or incorporated private institution or an independent unit of a recognized college or university having at least one four-year unified curriculum. It was devoted also to the preparation of teachers but required for admission to its curriculum a standard four-year secondary program and granted a standard bachelor's degree. Hampton was neither a college nor a trade school but a normal school composed of elementary school graduates who were seeking two additional years of schooling and teacher preparation courses so that they might qualify for a common school teaching certificate. Normal school students tended to be much less educated, older, and more economically disadvantaged than college students. Further, unlike students pursuing trade and technical training, normal school students sought professional education courses to achieve their major goal of becoming elementary school teachers. Thus Hampton should be analyzed more in the context of post-Civil War black normal school training than as part of the era's general trend toward technical, trade, and manual education. Unlike Hampton's concern with teacher training, the late nineteenth-century industrial education movement did not include the training of teachers but instead stressed three basic types of vocational training. First, and of the highest status, were the schools of applied science and technology, whose purpose was to train engineers, architects, chemists, and the like for professional work in the emerging technology-based economy. A second and widely different class of industrial schools encompassed the trade schools, organized to train workers in industry and to educate them for their prospective individual occupations in life. In contrast to technical schools, which trained the overseers and superintendents of labor, the trade schools sought to educate individual operatives. The third class of schools consisted of those in which manual instruction was introduced, mainly as a supplement to the traditional academic curriculum, to promote habits of industry, thrift, and morality. Several years before Hampton was established, institutions such as Mt. Holyoke Seminary for Women, Wellesley College, and Oberlin College had required students to do some manual labor to acquire fixed habits of industry and to provide financial support for the colleges. At such schools simple manual training was not a basic part of the instructional program; at Hampton, manual labor formed the core of the teacher training program and intruded into every aspect of both curricular and extracurricular activities.3 Hampton's manual labor routine was designed partly to teach students steady work habits, practical knowledge, and Christian morals. Most
36
The Education of Blacks in the South
important, however, Armstrong viewed industrial education primarily as an ideological force that would provide instruction suitable for adjusting blacks to a subordinate social role in the emergent New South. Significantly, he identified Hampton with the conservative wing of southern reconstructionists who supported new forms of external control over blacks, including disfranchisement, segregation, and civil inequality. Armstrong's philosophy of "Black Reconstruction," widely publicized as the "Hampton Idea," essentially called for the effective removal of black voters and politicians from southern political life, the relegation of black workers to the lowest forms of labor in the southern economy, and the establishment of a general southern racial hierarchy. He expected that the work of adjusting blacks to this social arrangement would be carried out by indigenous black educators, particularly teachers and principals, aided by Hampton-styled industrial normal schools, state departments of education, local school boards, and northern white philanthropists. Hence Hampton developed an extensive manual labor routine because the school's faculty believed that a particular combination of hard work, political socialization, and social discipline would mold appropriately conservative black teachers. In 1888 Atticus G. Haygood, the general agent of the John F. Slater Fund, touched upon Hampton's central mission when he stated that the school's faculty viewed industrial training as the best intellectual and moral discipline for "those who are to be teachers and guides of their people." Haygood went to the heart of the matter. Hampton's teacher training program and its attendant political values focused mainly on the relationship of black "teachers and guides" to the larger issues of southern political and economic reconstruction.4 Hampton's ideological and pedagogical framework was derived mainly from the racial, political, and economic views of Armstrong, the principal from 1868 until his death in 1893, and from Hollis Burke Frissell, the vice-principal and chaplain from 1880 to 1893, who succeeded Armstrong and served as principal until 1917. Armstrong, with the help of the American Missionary Association, founded Hampton Institute in April 1868. Four years after the institute was established he initiated and edited the Southern Workman, an illustrated monthly, to present his views on the freedmen's place in the developing New South. The paper was created ostensibly as Hampton's official news organ; but from the outset, Armstrong aimed to create a forum much more far-reaching than a typical school newspaper. As he wrote to his friend and Hampton trustee Robert C. Ogden, "We mean to push it by mail, up and forwards—think of this—the paper may become, and I mean it will be a power." The Southern Workman became a "power," especially among northern philanthropists and southern white moderates, who favored elementary school and normal school education for blacks and who were
The Hampton Model
37
basically opposed to black higher education, equal job opportunities, civil equality, and equal political rights. Although Armstrong attempted to promote the Southern Workman as a nonpolitical "instructive monthly," the paper, which expressed vividly his ideas of black reconstruction, sided with conservative political groups who wanted to disfranchise the freedmen and create a legal and customary racial hierarchy. Two years after the founding of the Southern Workman, a black newspaper concluded that Armstrong's monthly had "become so conservative that it leans the other way," meaning that it had become reactionary.5 To Armstrong, the removal of black people from any effective role in southern politics was the first step toward "proper" reconstruction. He wrote almost exclusively of the immorality and irresponsibility of black voters; he excoriated black politicians and labeled the freedmen's enfranchisement as dangerous to the South and the nation. In his view, the "Colored people" could "afford to let politics severely alone." He maintained, for instance, that black participation in politics in South Carolina resulted in a "shameless legislature" that had "ruined the credit of a great state." Armstrong instructed black leaders to stay out of politics because they were "not capable of self-government," and he blamed the black voters for creating situations which "no white race on this earth ought to endure or will endure." "The votes of Negroes have enabled some of the worst men who ever figured in American politics to hold high places of honor and trust," argued Armstrong. "Such votes marshalled by cunning knavery are dangerous to the country in proportion to their numbers." Thus he advised black men to refrain from voting and urged "every colored leader" to refuse public office for generations to come.6 Armstrong waged a campaign against black political rights that should have embarrassed a self-proclaimed "friend of the Negro race," and occasionally it apparently did. He stated in 1876 that he did not intend to "denounce as such every colored man who takes part in politics." In i88z he even admitted that a few "colored politicians" could be "trusted." But these isolated statements tended to appear when Armstrong perceived that black political power was disintegrating. He was convinced that the withdrawal of Union soldiers from the South in 1877 meant the end of black influence in southern politics. In 1879, however, William Mahone, with the aid of black voters, led Virginia's Readjusters to victory in the state legislative elections. After assuming full control of Virginia's government in 1881, the Readjusters pumped money into public education and enacted several measures to please their black supporters, including abolishing the whipping post and the poll tax and creating Virginia Normal and Collegiate Institute in Petersburg. Armstrong was greatly disturbed by the continuing black participation in Virginia poli-
38
The Education of Blacks in the South
tics. In 1879 he stated angrily that "the colored vote was reappearing as a political force." When this vote influenced the 1879 elections in Virginia, few "rebels" were more reactionary than Samuel Armstrong: "The Colored vote has suddenly the balance of power and gives victory to the readjusters. There is a split in Conservative ranks. Ex-Confederate leaders are arrayed against each other. The heroes of the war are replacing one-legged soldiers who fought under them with colored men who might have fought against them." In Armstrong's view, this "calamity" threatened "Virginia's honor or standing in the markets of the world." The black race, he warned, "will act up to its light, but its best light is dim and therefore unsafe." The masses were "weak and blind," and "their so-called leaders" were, according to Armstrong, "ignorant, immoral preachers or selfish politicians."7 Armstrong insisted that the freedmen should refrain from participating in southern political life because they were culturally and morally deficient and therefore unfit to vote and hold office in "civilized" society. He fell heir to a particular theory of racial subordination while growing up as the son of a missionary in the Hawaiian Islands. His father, Richard Armstrong, entered Hawaii as a missionary in 1831 and by 1840 was minister of public instruction; he eventually became president of the Board of Education. Samuel Armstrong was told that his father's missionary career was "noble work for the savage race." This missionary inheritance was reinforced and consolidated in the milieu of the postwar South. The southern "darkies," like the Polynesian "savages," were "so possessed with strange notions" that they had to be "most carefully watched over." The "darkies" were "emotional in their nature," improvident by habit, and "not capable of self-government." The Hampton principal easily shifted his missionary views from the Polynesians to the black southerners. Indeed, he observed that "there was worked out in the Hawaiian Islands the problem of emancipation, and civilization of the dark-skinned Polynesian people in many respects like the Negro race." In both instances, Armstrong maintained that it was the duty of the superior white race to rule over the weaker dark-skinned races until they were appropriately civilized. This civilization process, in Armstrong's estimate, would require several generations of moral and religious development.8 In his political and educational thought, Armstrong attributed the "barbarism" of dark-skinned people largely to historical and environmental conditions. He occasionally invoked genetic arguments in his attempt to rationalize the dominance of whites over blacks. But the heredity concept set unchangeable patterns that did not readily support the moral and social goals of educational reform movements- Mental or academic achievement was more measurable and came much sooner
The Hampton Model
39
than moral development, thus supporting more rapid social change than Armstrong was willing to concede. To justify his position that all blacks, educated and noneducated, be excluded indefinitely from active participation in southern politics, Armstrong proclaimed moral development instead of mental development as the chief criterion for political enfranchisement. He believed exclusive white rule was justified because whites had developed exceptionally "in moral strength, in guiding instincts, in power to 'sense things' in the genius for this or that." The Negro, on the other hand, could not "see the point of life clearly, he lacks foresight, judgment and hard sense." The critical problem with the black race, according to Armstrong, was "not one of brains, but of right instincts, of morals and hard work." The freedmen's chief misfortunes were "low ideas of honor, and morality, want of foresight and energy, and vanity." In short, Armstrong contended that the white race was mentally and morally strong, and the black race was mentally capable but morally feeble. He attributed the moral capacity of the different races to historically determined conditions: "The [American] white race has had three centuries of experience in organizing the forces about him, political, social and physical. The Negro has had three centuries of experience in general demoralization and behind that, paganism." This historical legacy, Armstrong argued, robbed the black race of the moral wisdom and foresight necessary for responsible political activity.9 Armstrong used concepts such as "guiding instincts" and "moral strength" with slight regard for definition or accurate meaning. But despite the theoretical poverty of his social philosophy, it was a convenient doctrine to support his Reconstruction policy of white rule and black disfranchisement. In 1877, when three black men were elected from the Hampton district to serve in the Virginia state legislature, Armstrong commented: "This district will be represented in both houses by men of intelligence, but of no moral standing." In his view, "political ambition had proved unhealthy for the brightest minds of the [black] race." Until a moral foundation was broadly laid, he counseled, "no sensible colored man could wish to see his race take a leading part in government." In the long run, however, the black race could "develop those guiding instincts and institutions that the Anglo-Saxon has reached through ages of hard experience." Mora! intuition was largely automatic, instinctive, and culturally determined. Groups lacking it could acquire it over time but "only by a series of experimental tests, which must of necessity include successive generations." Because the Anglo-Saxon race was morally strong, precisely because of its unique historical experiences, it seemed logical to Armstrong that whites would preside over the exslaves' gradual evolution into "civilized" life.10 In posing morality, rather than intelligence, as the criterion for admis-
4O
The Education of Blacks in the South
sion to the body politic, Armstrong rejected the idea of literate culture as either a civilizing force or appropriate preparation for morally responsible citizenship. In his cultural theory of racial subordination, mental aptness was not an important measure of moral development; on the contrary, it was a characteristic of primitive existence. As Armstrong put it, "Most savage races are not mentally sluggish. The African Zulu tests the wit and resources of an educated missionary. The Polynesian cannibal is a natural orator and takes to law and theology with readiness. The Aborigines of Australia are quickwitted." Similarly, Armstrong observed that black children were mentally "capable of acquiring knowledge to any degree, and to a certain age, at least, with about the same facility as white children." "Most savage people," Armstrong explained, "are not like 'dumb driven cattle;' yet their life is little better than that of brutes because the moral nature is dormant." Thus, as long as the Negro's moral nature remained underdeveloped, Armstrong believed that it was the whites' duty to prevent blacks from voting and running for political office. In establishing moral development as the decisive cultural basis of political and civil equality, Armstrong, wittingly or unwittingly, ideologically precluded even property-owning and educated blacks from participation in the body politic. Property and education, he argued, could be acquired in a generation, but moral development, and by extension readiness for parliamentary government, took centuries.11 To apprehend fully Armstrong's preoccupation with black political development it is imperative to recall that those southerners defined in law and custom as "Negroes" constituted over one-third of the region's population. In 1870, as illustrated in Table z.i, black persons formed a majority of the total population in Louisiana, Mississippi, and South Carolina. In Alabama, Florida, Georgia, and Virginia the black populations ranged from 42, to 49 percent of the totals. North Carolina and Tennessee reported 3 7 and 2.6 percent of their populations as black persons, and Texas reported 31 percent. These citizens and voters deserved a considerable share of the region's political power and the lion's share in some states and districts. That blacks might achieve their fair share of political power was Armstrong's nightmare and a problem he wished to solve in the realm of education and culture, rather than through political struggle. Armstrong had much in common with the white planters of the South, who, in general, believed that blacks should be politically disfranchised and fitted for the physical drudgery of unskilled farm and domestic labor. But he differed from them on the question of universal schooling. The planters believed that schooling would raise blacks' political and economic aspirations and ruin them as agricultural and domestic laborers. Armstrong held a deep faith in the powerful capacity of moral and
TABLE Z . I
Number and Percent of Blacks in Total Population of Southern States, 1870—1930 1880
1870 State
Number
Alabama Arkansas Delaware Florida Georgia Kentucky Louisiana Maryland Mississippi Missouri North Carolina South Carolina Tennessee Texas Virginia West Virginia
475,5*0 12.1,169 2-1,794 91,689 545,!42. 222,210 364,110 I75>391
444,101 118,071 391,650 415,814 322,331 2-53,475 512,841 17,980
1890
Number
Percent
Number
47-7 600,103 25.2 210,666 26,441 18.1 48.8 126,690 46.0 72.5,133 16.8 2-7i,45i 50.1 483,655 11.5 210,230 53-7 650,291 6.9 M5,350 36.6 53!,i77 58.9 604,332 25.6 403,151 31.0 393,384 41.9 631,616 25,886 4.1
47-5 26.3 18.0 47.0 47.0 16.5 5i-5 22.5 57-5 6.7 38.0 60.7 26.1 2-4-7 41.8 4.2
678,489 309,117 28,386 166,180 858,815 268,071 559,193 2-15,657 742-,559 150,184 561,018 688,934 430,678 488,171 635,438 32,690
Percent
1910
1900 Percent 44-8 2-7-4 16.8 42.5 46.7 14.4 50.0 20.7 57.6 5.6 34-7 59-8 2-4-4 21.8
38.4 4-3
Number 827,307 366,856 30,697 230,730 1,034,813 284,706 650,804 235,064 907,630 161,234 624,469 782,321 480,243 620,722 660,722 43,499
Percent 45-228.0 16.6 43-7 46.7 13.3 47.1 19.8 58.5 5-2-
33.0 58.4 23.8 20.4 35-6 4-5
Number 908,282 442,891 31,181 308,669 1,176,987 261,656 713,784 232,250 1,009,487 !57,452697,843 835,843 473,088 690,049 671,096 64,173
1920 Percent 42.5 28.1 15.4 41.0 45.1 11.4 43-i 17.9 56.2 4.8 31.6 55-22-1-7
17-7
32.6 5-3
1930
Number
Percent
Number
900,652 472,220 30,335 32-9,487 1,206,365 2-2-5,938 700,257 2-44,479 935,i84 178,241 763,407 864,719 451,758 741,694 690,017 86,345
38.4 27.0 13.6 34-o 41.7 9-8 38.9 16.9 52.2 5-2 29.8 5 J -4 19.3 J 5-9 29.9 5-9
944,834 478,463 32,602 431,828 1,071,125 226,040 776,326 276,379 1,009,718 223,840 918,647 793,681 477,646 854,964 650,165 114,893
Percent 35-7 25.8 J 3-7 29.4 36.8 8.6 36-9 16.9 50.2 6.2
29.0 45.6 18.3 14-7 26.8 6.6
Source: U.S. Bureau of the Census, Negroes in the United States, 1920-32 (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1935), pp. 9-10, 15-
42.
The Education of Blacks in the South
industrial education to socialize blacks to understand and accept their disfranchisement and to make them more productive laborers. As the right moral education would ultimately prepare blacks for self-government, he believed, the right industrial training would make them an economic asset instead of a burden to the South. Hence the other fundamental dimension of Armstrong's educational and social philosophy focused on the methods and content to develop black teachers and leaders who would prepare the black masses for efficient service in racially prescribed occupational niches. When Armstrong maintained, as he frequently did, that the black race was "low but not degraded," he usually meant that it was the habit of labor, acquired under slavery, that saved the race from complete "moral ruin." "The Negro has one source of strength," he argued, "the habit of industry acquired in the time of slavery." This source of strength was important to Armstrong's platform of southern economic reconstruction. "Southerners must make the best of Negro labor," he said, "they cannot afford to do otherwise, with them it is that or none." In Armstrong's view, northern capital and cheap black labor were critical to southern economic reconstruction and reunion with the Northeast. "The Eastern states have the capital and experience," he announced in 1875, "while the South has the cheap labor; to bring the two together is to cement a real peace between the sections." This union, he believed, was hindered mainly by the political and racial turmoil in the South, which discouraged capital investments from the Northeast. To Armstrong, the debate over black political participation "kindled the passions of war" and blocked the "swift return of southern prosperity through immigration and capital from the North." The return of order and prosperity in the South was largely dependent upon "the rapidity with which the power of the politician is undermined by the gradual growth of the moneyed classes, whose pecuniary interests depend upon peace, and upon the respect and goodwill of the rest of the world, outside the South." Realizing that the racial upheaval in the postwar South resulted in "scarcity of capital" and "demoralized labor," Armstrong consistently called for racial peace and political stability, but nearly always at the expense of southern blacks. Because northern capitalists would not eagerly invest in a region characterized by labor disorders and race riots, "liberalism must be organized into outward forms to induce northern men and capital to cross the border lines of the southern states." He urgently demanded a quick resolution of political and racial conflict so that economic leaders could set in motion the wheel of material prosperity.12' Armstrong attempted to organize Hampton Institute as a model for the emerging southern economy. Early on, he appealed for small busi-
The Hampton Model
43
nessmen to experiment with student and community labor. In December 1877 he explored the idea of engaging the Hampton students in the manufacturing of cotton clothing for northern markets. Armstrong instructed Charles Whiting, a white member of the Hampton staff, "to work up Negro labor, compete with New York labor in manufacturing for northern markets." The students regularly performed hard labor for cheap rates in the school's workshops. According to the 1880 annual report, the school's Knitting Department produced "fifteen thousand dozen pairs of mittens for S. B. Pratt and Company of Boston, who sell them chiefly in the Northwest." The young men in the trade school department were also required to make products for the market economy. Advertising the manufacture of doors, sashes, and blinds for the general market, Armstrong reported that the workshop did a prosperous business of "six thousand dollars a month, cutting over two million feet of lumber every year." On several occasions he invited entrepreneurs to take advantage of the "cheap labor in and out of the institution; students are paid from six to ten cents per hour."13 These work experiments extended beyond the typical industrial educational activities of the era. The Hampton model resembled the industrial training that first appeared during the iSzos in the reform schools established in New York City, Boston, and Philadelphia. Like the reformatories, Hampton sometimes contracted student labor to outside entrepreneurs who assigned the students routine and repetitive tasks similar to those done by unskilled factory or agricultural laborers. Tileston T. Bryce, Hampton's financial agent, opened a meat-packing and canning factory on the institute's grounds in 1879. After two years he reported employing "hundreds of poor people" in "the large canning business," both student and community laborers. In a similar experiment, C. D. Cake, a white Virginia businessman, employed "ten colored and five Indian students," who "cut daily from six to eight thousand feet of yellow pine lumber." The Hampton staff observed the adaptation of black workers in these industries and developed theories that supported the extension of white dominance over black labor. After observing black workers in his canning factory, Bryce reported: "I have found that the colored people, if the same chance be given them, work as diligently as the whites but not so intelligently. With intelligent direction they are admirable laborers, obeying orders and willingly; but when they attempt the direction of their own labor, it is apt to amount to but little."14 In an attempt to convince black leaders and workers to remain in the South as cheap and contented laborers, Armstrong and his associates spread propaganda that white opposition to black participation in southern politics was not a barrier to black opportunity in the educational and economic arenas. He insisted that "there was no power and
44
The Education of Blacks in the South
little disposition on the part of leading white conservatives to prevent the colored people from acquiring wealth and education." Indeed, he argued that "competition in the North" held back skilled Afro-American workers "more than prejudice at the South." Southern black mechanics, according to Armstrong, had "a fair field." Armstrong's propaganda well illustrates the economic consciousness that he expected Hamptontrained teachers and leaders to model for the black community. Booker T. Washington, his devoted student, often told black southerners that "when one comes to business pure and simple, stripped of all ideas of sentiment, the Negro is given almost as good an opportunity to rise as is given to the white man." Like Armstrong, the Tuskegee principal forthrightly claimed that "the black man has a better chance in the South than in the North" for economic progress. Thus, "In spite of all talk of exodus," said Washington in 1885, "the Negro's home is permanently in the South." Washington epitomized the type of black educator Armstrong desired to train and in whom Armstrong wanted the black working class to place its trust. It is safe to say that the educational theory and method at Hampton were formulated to train an army of Booker T. Washingtons.15 The Hampton-Tuskegee philosophy, which requested black southerners to eschew politics and concentrate on economic development, was not, as it has been hailed, a great compromise. It was the logical extension of an ideology that rejected black political power while recognizing that the South's agricultural economy rested on the backs of black agricultural workers. The United States Bureau of the Census did not classify agricultural laborers by race in the 1870 and 1880 censuses. But the data from the 1890 census, as shown in Table z.z, documented the substantial presence of black workers in southern agriculture. In the Deep South (Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, and South Carolina) black agricultural workers ranged from 48 to 68 percent of the totals, and they were from 2.3 to 40 percent of the totals in Delaware, Arkansas, Maryland, North Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia. Because the South's economy was essentially agricultural, its prosperity depended heavily on black workers. The philosophy that embraced blacks as agricultural laborers and rejected them as voters and politicians was a one-way street, not a compromise. From Armstrong's standpoint, it addressed the region's most fundamental social realities—political power and economic development. In both instances he sought to preserve the region's traditional inequalities of wealth and power. His major task was to carry this message to black southerners and seek to obtain their conscious or half-conscious complicity in their own victimization. The great educational question absorbing Armstrong's attention and intruding itself into every aspect of Hampton Institute was the nature and role of teachers in shaping the social, economic, and political con-
45
The Hampton Model T A B L E 2.. 2.
Black Workers as a Percentage of All Workers in Agricultural Occupations by Southern States, 1890-1930 State Alabama Arkansas Delaware Florida Georgia Kentucky Louisiana Maryland Mississippi Missouri North Carolina South Carolina Tennessee Texas Virginia West Virginia
1890
1900
1910
192.0
!93o
57 34 23 48 54
54 34
53 38 23 5i 56 8 61
47 36
45 34
12
67 33 68 4 39 68
21
49 53 9 64 28 69 3 35 68
2.6
22.
2-5
23
40 4
34 i
21
21
43 53 8 56
42
2-9
2-7
7°
65 3 36 66 20
2
37 69 23 23 34 2
22 32 I
46
I
54 26 65 4 36 62 19 20 30 i
Source: U.S. Bureau of the Census, Twelfth Census of the United States, 1900, cxxxvcxxxvi; Henry Gannett, Occupations of the Negroes (Baltimore, 1895); U.S. Bureau of Education, Negro Education: A Study of the Private and Higher Schools for Colored People in the United States (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1917), i :?8; U.S. Bureau of the Census, Fifteenth Census of the United States (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1933), vol. 4, Table n, p. 874.
sciousness of the black masses. Armstrong expected the sociopolitical views embodied in the Hampton Idea to be propagated among the black masses primarily by black teachers. He conjectured that schools and churches were the best institutions to socialize or "civilize" the black population. They were viewed as agencies of amelioration and control, and they were the agencies under which most of the freedmen were organized. Therefore, said Armstrong, "Let us make the teachers and we will make the people." Surely the teachers and the people could be easily molded because they were "in the early stages of civilization." "Our students," stated Armstrong, "are docile, impressible, imitative and earnest, and come to us as a tabula rasa so far as real culture is concerned." Hampton was designed to form an ideological foundation in these "blank minds" and return them to the outside world not as "polished scholars" but as "guides and civilizers, whose power shall be that
46
The Education of Blacks in the South
of character and example, not of sounding words." Armstrong believed that Hampton Institute had taken "a new departure" in the education of freedmen; it was a "civilizing power" that would encourage through its exemplars the "right ideas of life and duty."16 Armstrong's 1880 call, "Politicians to the background and schoolmasters to the front," echoed at once his disdain for black politicians and his vision of black teachers propagating the Hampton Idea of economic efficiency throughout the Afro-American South. His was not merely another naive view of the ameliorative and modifying powers of common schooling. Armstrong's emphasis on the training of teachers or "guides" had even deeper roots in his awareness that black teachers could mold the ideologies of the black masses. As he reasoned, black teachers were "usually the best educated of their society, are leaders of its thought, and give it tone by their superior wisdom and culture." Moreover, "The colored teacher is looked up to for his wisdom, is often chosen magistrate or other local dignitary, and is sometimes the only source of information from the outside world." Armstrong's concern with the potential role of black teachers in the black community led him to consider the forces that enhanced and threatened his aims. He feared the influence of black teachers and ministers who rejected the ideological discipline he propagandized. "The real trouble of the colored teachers," he complained, "is with a class of preachers, politicians, and editors of their own race who resent the introduction of intelligent ideas into religion and into the relations of life. They could easily be conciliated by substituting Latin for labor." Armstrong opposed the existing system of college and normal school training for blacks and campaigned relentlessly for the Hampton model.17 Armstrong sought to regulate the flow and quality of black teachers through careful admissions processes and independent boarding schools. In 1881 he asked Virginia and other southern public school officials to notify Hampton Institute of "worthy colored youth" who would make the best teachers. Through this process conservative whites could "do much to select wise leaders for the colored race." The teachers would be bound to the white establishment, and "any conflict of the races will be impossible." These recruits would be properly trained in independent boarding schools like Hampton. The "average Negro student," according to Armstrong, needed a boarding school so that his teachers could "control the entire twenty-four hours of each day—only thus can old ideas and ways be pushed out and new ones take their place." "When his whole routine of life is controlled," Armstrong believed, "the Negro pupil is like clay in the potter's hands." From this "clay" he intended to "create a class or guild who will be a nucleus of civilization" and would
The Hampton Model
47
transmit the Hampton doctrines of politics and economics to the black race.18 Armstrong viewed his own brand of industrial education as the appropriate pedagogy to mold the economic and political consciousness of prospective black leaders and educators. Hampton's curriculum, therefore, was not intended primarily to create "small individualistic entrepreneurs" or to offer "Negroes the technical training necessary for effective competition in an industrial age." It was designed mainly to train black ideologues, who were expected to exemplify and propagate Armstrong's philosophy of southern Reconstruction to the Afro-American working class. "The Negroes, who are to form the working classes of the South," he maintained, "must be taught not only to do their work well, but to know what their work means." But first it was necessary to condition the personalities and attitudes of the teachers. Armstrong believed that "a teacher does more by virtue of what he is than of what he says; the most powerful constructive influence is indirect." He envisioned Hampton students as the embodiment of "habits of living and labor . . . in order that graduates may be qualified to teach others these important lessons of life." To him, hard labor was the first principle of civilized life, and he drilled his students in manual labor routines so that they could effectively teach the value of routinized labor to the black masses. "If you are the right sort of man you will engage in any sort of labor, and dignify it," declared Armstrong. Indeed, "A man had better work for nothing and find himself than to spend his time in idling and loafing." Therefore, he instructed blacks to "plow, hoe, ditch, grub; do anything rather than nothing." To be sure, Armstrong was not opposed to teaching trades to a few individuals, but he primarily sought to cultivate through his graduates a nonskilled or semiskilled black work force that would support the southern economy. If the South were to achieve industrial and agricultural greatness, black workers needed to be taught to "love" labor and to understand the meaning of work more than they needed trade or technical skills. Consequently, Armstrong was almost exclusively concerned with the ideological and psychological value of industrial teacher training.19 Routine and repetitive manual labor activities were developed to screen and condition students to serve as missionaries of the Hampton Idea. Armstrong held a lifelong suspicion of highly educated blacks, believing that their aspirations were vain and dysfunctional to his views of southern Reconstruction. His idealized student was a hard worker with elementary education and industrial training. He did not believe that highly educated blacks would remain as "civilizers" among the rural masses. "There is such a thing as over-education," he warned. "A highly
48
The Education of Blacks in the South
**»"
The prospective female teachers of Hampton Institute (top) were compelled to do field work in order to internalize the value of hard work that they were expected to transmit to their students. The normal school students (bottom) found that plowing was an important part of Hampton's teacher preparation program. Courtesy F. B. Johnston Collection, Library of Congress.
The Hampton Model
49
educated Negro is as little likely as a highly educated white man to do a work against which his tastes and sensibilities would every day rebel." The highly educated could not serve as models for the masses, who, according to Armstrong, were destined to plow, hoe, ditch, and grub. Therefore, manual labor rather than scholarship became Hampton's chief criterion for educational excellence. "One who shirks labor may be a fine mathematician," noted Armstrong, but "the blockhead at the black board may be a shining example in the cornfield." The idealized "blockhead" or "plodders," as they were called, became the standard by which all students were evaluated. In 1882. Armstrong reported: "A good labor record has often saved one from being dropped as incompetent while one brilliant in studies is sometimes sent away for inefficiency in the shop or farm." The students with good labor records were thought the best potential exponents of the Hampton Idea. Vice-Principal H. B. Frissell, after visiting Hampton graduates in the field, reported in 1885 "that very frequently the dull plodder at Hampton is the real leader of his people toward better things, while the bright scholar who was our pride and delight at school, because of his mental acuteness, either yields to temptation or leaves school work for the more tempting offers of clerkships or political appointments." Similarly, Armstrong argued that "the plodding ones make good teachers."10 Hampton's industrial teacher training system consisted of three main areas: the elementary academic program, the manual labor system, and a strict social discipline routine. The entire operation was systematically ordered to provide moral and intellectual discipline to a conservative black teachers corps; however, each division emphasized certain specifics. The academic program, aside from preparing students to teach grade school and to pass varied state teachers' certification examinations, was planned mainly for the ideological training of potential Hampton missionaries. The manual labor system, organized to shape attitudes and build character through steady, hard labor, was designed to connect the theoretical and practical lessons. The daily discipline routine served to rid the school of students at variance with the Hampton Idea. The Hampton academic program consisted of an English course of study embracing reading and elocution, elementary mathematics, history, literature, moral science, and political economy. Armstrong excluded classical studies because he believed that such training stimulated "vanity" in black students, which propelled them toward high-flown notions of politics and professional life. Hampton sought to impress upon its students their "true" place in the southern social order largely through courses in political economy, civil government, and practical morality. Whereas the other academic courses were taught by white women teachers, these courses were taught by Armstrong and Hollis
5O
The Education of Blacks in the South
Frissell with assistance from Tileston T. Bryce. Armstrong began the courses in the 18705 with triweekly talks on the important economic and political questions of the era. In i88x he reported that the political economy course included the "discussion of labor, wages, money value, and the tariff." The course was developed to promote proper relations between capitalists and laborers, and the courses in practical morals and civil government were aimed at correcting the students' "wrong notions" regarding the "rights of persons and property, the origins of these rights, and how they may be violated."ZI The Southern Workman, the main text in the political economy course, was used in all reading classes. Armstrong recommended the paper to other "colored normal schools and colleges." He was particularly satisfied with Tileston T. Bryce's series of articles on political economy that were eventually gathered into the Hampton textbook Economic Crumbs, or Plain Talks for the People about Labor, Capital, Money, Tariff, etc. In 1878 Bryce initiated a series of essays that were structured around questions which appeared repeatedly on the students' senior examination in political economy. The Hampton students, examined annually by a committee appointed by the Board of Trustees, were required to answer the following questions: "What is labor? Who are the laboring classes? Show how all men are mutually dependent. What are wages? Who determines the price of wages? What is capital? Show the relationship of capital to labor. How are all men capitalists?" Bryce's essays on these questions were consistent with the basic premises of the Hampton Idea." Bryce saw no inherent or legitimate conflict between capital and labor. It was erroneous "to speak of the 'laboring classes' as distinct divisions of society" because "every man who puts forth any exertion, in order to obtain something in return, is a laborer." If the expression "laboring classes" had any distinctive meaning, it signified "free men as opposed to slaves." Bryce concluded that there were "no class feelings to irritate, no color line to fight over": The most pernicious quack, who peddles political nostrums, is he who attempts to excite the multitude by declaring that "all the ills that flesh is to heir" come from the employers of labor. People of this sort hold it as an axiom that there is an unending feud between capital and labor; and that the former ever seeks to extinguish the latter. Some of these mischief-makers, assuming this statement to be true, are logical enough to declare that labor should try to extinguish capital. This is the doctrine of communism. Now if there be two things in this world between which the utmost amity should exist, and between which the most intimate reciprocal relations do exist, they are Capital and Labor.
The Hampton Model
51
Thus, contended Bryce, labor unions were conspiracies to defy the laws of economics and to get something for nothing. Those who interfered with the workplace by violence or threats were labeled "either slavecatchers or thieves."2'3 "The bottom idea of capital," Bryce argued, "is that somebody has saved something." A man with only an "extra shirt" was "to that extent a capitalist." It was natural, however, for some men to have more capital than others, and it was "no more unjust, than that one man should be stronger, taller, or more healthy than another." "The majority of people accept such as the natural state of things," he continued, "and the minority, who decline to accept it, are found among the vicious, who have squandered all they had, the improvident, who never labor for more than mere existence." These views were supported by other Hampton textbooks/4 Thomas Jesse Jones, an instructor of social studies at Hampton Institute and later director of the Phelps-Stokes Fund, described the purpose and function of social studies in the Hampton curriculum. Jones explained that Armstrong and his co-workers gave "a very important place" to such subjects as "political economy, civil government, moral science and general history." These subjects were aimed primarily at teaching Hampton's students the "right" ideas of citizenship, the duties of laborers, and the history of race development. History, for instance, was designed as a study of the "evolution of races" and was aimed at giving the pupils "a new notion of race development." Jones contended that black students arrived at Hampton with common-sense notions of the problems of racial subordination. "Their acquaintance with the race problem has made them precocious in their knowledge of social forces controlling and limiting the development of races. The white youth grows to manhood without feeling any of the limitations which the colored youth feels all his life." But, Jones continued, "while the colored youth is more conscious of social forces than the white, his views are not natural." From Jones's vantage point, black students' views of "race development" were unnatural because blacks tended to interpret the social limitations imposed on them as arbitrary and unjust. The Hampton faculty taught black students that the position of their race in the South was not the result of oppression but of the natural process of cultural evolution. In other words, blacks had evolved to a cultural stage that was two thousand years behind that of whites and, therefore, they were naturally the subordinate race. In this respect, Washington learned his lessons well while attending Hampton. As he said in 1900 before the General Conference of the African Methodist Episcopal church, "My friends, the white man is three thousand years ahead of us, and this fact we might as well face now as well as later, and that at one stage of his development, either
52,
The Education of Blacks in the South
in Europe or America, he has gone through every stage of development that I now advocate for our race." Thus although Washington was opposed to depriving blacks of the legal right of franchise, he advised, like Armstrong, "that in their present condition it is a mistake for them to enter actively into general political agitation and activity." This conception of "race development" was a key component of the HamptonTuskegee retrogressive social philosophy.z5 According to Jones, each social study at Hampton contributed "to this picture of the evolution of races." When the Hampton program of social studies worked successfully, a black student, "instead of regarding the difficulties of his race as the oppression of a weaker by the stronger, he interprets them as the natural difficulties which almost every race has been compelled to overcome in its upward movement." Booker T. Washington could not have said it any better. The ideology of both the Hampton and Tuskegee programs of social studies served to conceal the arbitrary, unjust, and oppressive nature of black subordination in the South. What worried Armstrong and his co-workers, as Jones implied, was the probability that prospective black teachers and leaders might translate the social outlook implicit in their traditions and day-to-day experiences into a conception of politics that defined the South's racially qualified form of working-class subordination as arbitrary, unnatural, and unjust.16 Armstrong was always pleased with the results of the senior class examination because "the students got a higher percentage of correct answers in Political Economy than in any other of the several branches." Black students came to Hampton, according to Armstrong, thinking "much of the rights of the laborers and little of those of the capitalist"; they viewed the two classes "as being opposed to one another." Clearly, such thinking diverged from the Hampton Idea, and the school's staff labored to "correct" it. There is no way of determining how many students were converted to Armstrong's doctrines of political economy. But the educational thought of the two most well-known Hampton graduates, Booker T. Washington and Robert R. Moton, parroted the Hampton doctrines. Doubtless other educators at the time, black and white, propagandized similar views. The point, however, is that Hampton was deliberately teaching prospective black leaders and educators economic values that were detrimental to the objective economic interests of black workers. Black domestics, sharecroppers, and factory laborers were not capitalists, and their objective economic interests, as many of them realized, were fundamentally different from and opposed to those of the southern bosses and landlords who ruled over them. Thus, when Hampton trained leaders such as Booker T. Washington to counsel blacks to remain in the South as cheap and contented agricultural laborers and to
The Hampton Model
53
refrain from political activity, it contributed to the development of a conservative Afro-American leadership, which did not foster the political and economic improvement of black workers and voters. The Hampton social and educational ideology was inherently opposed to the political and economic advancement of black southerners and therefore oppressive, in the objective sense that it was ranged against the development of social ideas that might have encouraged blacks to pursue basic political and social justice.17 The relationship of black religious and moral development to the southern social order was another major concern of the Hampton faculty. To Frissell and Armstrong, the "old-time" Negro religion hindered the development of a "new" political economy. It was too removed from questions of practical social responsibility. Armstrong commented: "There is plenty of religion, such as it is, among both parents and scholars, but it is too often a religion that regards more the emotional part of the nature than the moral, and so aids little in the work of checking the evil tendencies of these growing lives." In Armstrong's view, the separation of black religion from moral responsibility was nicely illustrated in the tale of the devout old "Auntie" who attended church regularly without allowing one poor old goose (that she had stolen) to "come between her and her blessed Lord." In discussing black religion and moral strength in 1877, Armstrong told the American Missionary Association that "pastors and deacons all sell whiskey and lead loose lives without scandal; an ex-jail bird returns to his former social position; in politics and in society, character goes for little or nothing."18 Behind Armstrong's moral rationale lay more mundane considerations for political and economic reconstruction. He viewed black ministers as eschewing hard labor in favor of political and professional life. He believed that "at least two-thirds" of the ministers were represented by one who explained in a cotton field on a warm day, "O Lord, de work is so bad, de cotton is so grassy, and de sun am so hot, I b'leave dis darkey am called to preach." Such "exemplars" could not be expected to convey the Hampton doctrines of industry and hard labor to the black community. The Hampton staff, therefore, sought to train a corps of teachers who would counteract "the bad leadership of demagogues, whose chief temptation is to get a living by something else than hard work." Frissell attributed black conceptions of social responsibility to the slave experience: "Having been so grossly wronged, their thoughts have been fixed upon their dues from others more than on what is due others from themselves." To "correct their wrong notions," Frissell gave regular instruction on the importance of holding to a contract, on the origin and rights of property and person, and on the duties of citizenship. The Hampton staff labeled this course Practical Morals.219
54
The Education of Blacks in the South
As the academic courses were arranged to influence the students' political and economic ideology, the manual labor system was developed to reinforce consciousness through the formation of habits and character. The manual labor system was a central factor in admission and retention policy and in the students' day-to-day existence. Hampton advertised for "country youth who don't mind hard work." To acquire more "strong, able bodied young men" for the heavier farm and mill work, in 1888 Armstrong created a "special class" who "could not pass the entrance examination, but who were desirable from the work standpoint." Because the entrance examination was mainly a literacy test, it is reasonable to assume that many of these students were semiliterate. They were admitted mainly to work, and after two years in the "Preparatory class" they entered the regular normal school curriculum. Meanwhile, brilliant students considered "indifferent and careless workmen" were "discharged from the farm and usually from the school in consequence." In the nineteenth century, Hampton graduated only one-fifth of its students, and many of those expelled were disqualified because of bad work habits and "weakness of character." The first three months of the school term were considered the "weeding out" session when approximately 2.0 percent of the new students were dismissed. During the entire three-year course, according to Armstrong, there was "frequent leaving of students for disciplinary, pecuniary, domestic, and other reasons."30 All Hampton students were required to work because nonworkers were viewed as "an aristocracy ruinous to manual-labor schools." The amount of work, however, varied according to the student's curriculum. Those who were admitted directly into the normal school to qualify as teachers for graded schools were required to work two ten-hour days per week during their three years of study. They were paid from seven to ten cents per hour or one dollar to one dollar and fifty cents per week. These earnings were credited to the students' accounts for the cost of board, washing, room rent, and tuition, which amounted to approximately ten dollars per month. Thus the students were invariably deficient, and to earn additional credit they agreed to work any time "for any number of days not exceeding twelve [consecutive]." The trade students, generally about sixty males in simple mechanical training, worked six ten-hour days every week for three years and then entered the normal school for two additional years. Such students were also given a normal school certificate until 1895, when Hampton began awarding trade certificates.31 The heart of Hampton's manual labor program was established in 1879, when Armstrong created the night school with Booker T. Washington as principal. It opened with 36 students who were required to labor ten hours per day, six days per week, eleven months per year for
The Hampton Model
55
two years. Two years of night school work were equivalent to one year of the normal school course. In their last two years of normal school the students had to study four days and work two days during each week. More than any other division, the night school implemented Armstrong's social philosophy. By 1893, it enrolled 305 of Hampton's 541 black students. The admissions to the regular or day school declined significantly during the i88os, and consequently, "the Night School became the main-feeder of the Day School." It functioned as a sifter for the normal school by giving the Hampton staff ample opportunity to assess the students' character, industrial habits, and political attitudes before admitting them to the regular normal school. To work from seven o'clock in the morning until six o'clock at night, and then study from seven o'clock until nine, was, as Booker T. Washington said, "an undertaking that few young men would be willing to stick to, through all the seasons of the year."3Z Night school students were chiefly farm laborers, domestic servants, and mill hands. "Much of the labor that goes into our industries," reported Armstrong, "is neither skilled labor nor apprentice labor, but is made up of the great body of unskilled laborers who come here to work a year or two at whatever work the school may be able to give them." Male students worked in the sawmill, on the farm, in the kitchens as dishwashers and pantry boys, in the dining rooms as waiters, and in the cottages and smaller buildings as house boys. Female students received less regular training and were encouraged to do little except "plain sewing, plain washing and ironing, scrubbing, mending, etc." In the words of the Hampton faculty, the students learned "how to work steadily and regularly, to attend promptly at certain hours to certain duties," and they "gained new ideas of the value of manual labor." As Armstrong put it in his last report, "We do not mean to say that much is not learned by every faithful student in these departments; he or she will be a better cook, laundress, or farmer, and surely much needed lessons in promptness, and thoroughness are inculcated, but still the object in view is not to teach a trade but to get the work done." Such jobs were no more instructive in ideas and skills of "self-help" and "self-sufficiency" than the hoeing, picking, mining, washing, and ironing that black southerners had done as slaves for centuries. Armstrong required his prospective teachers to perform the same routinized drudgery as the working class that they were destined to instruct so that the teachers would stand as exemplars of the "dignity of labor." His great fear was that black pupils, under teachers trained in the literary or academic tradition, might come to view formal schooling as an avenue to escape hard toil. Hampton's emphasis on the moral value of hard labor in contrast to technical and skill training evidenced Armstrong's concern with the economic adjustment rather
56
The Education of Blacks in the South
Female students in Hampton Institute's teacher preparation program (top) learned to sew as part of their training in the ethic of routinized hard labor and in occupations prescribed for black women in the South. The cooking class (bottom) was designed to teach similar lessons. Courtesy of the Library of Congress.
The Hampton Model
57
than advancement of black southerners. Hampton's theme, "Education for Life," meant the training of blacks to adjust to the life that had been carved out for them within an oppressive social order.33 Armstrong had a lifelong distrust of highly educated black persons, and at Hampton he used his power to deemphasize the "black scholar" and to place on a pedestal the "dull plodders." The night school was developed particularly to reproduce "dull plodders." The Hampton faculty described the students as "mostly grown men and women .. . willing to spend their days in hard work on the farm or at the mill," for a chance to enter the normal school curriculum. One night school director, Anna G. Baldwin, reported that the students, most in their early twenties, were "often the best workers" but "the dullest scholars." The demanding work day undoubtedly retarded the students' academic progress. Armstrong, however, maintained that "nothing essential in study is lost, and much that is essential to success in life is gained." Yet the teachers in the academic department constantly complained about low academic achievement, some regarding it a "puzzling mathematical problem" how the night school students could learn anything significant. Baldwin recalled that an ambitious boy could "be overheard conjugating a verb while hoeing in the garden, or perched on a fence watching the cows, [and] meanwhile furtively study his reader." Similarly, night school principal Booker T. Washington reported that "one was noticed to carry a broken piece of slate about with him on which he could work examples while the wheelbarrow of dirt he had loaded, was being emptied." Washington, to illustrate the effectiveness of the night school work routine, quite innocent of satire, stated "their books were in their hands at every spare moment." Indeed, Armstrong had stood the educational process on its head; spare time was used for study and regular time devoted to hard labor.34 The "dull plodders" received praise and special treatment from the Hampton faculty. In the summer of 1885, approximately two hundred applicants were refused by Hampton's admission office. Many initial rejects were reconsidered, but only those physically able to take vacant positions in the sawmill and to do the heavier farm work were taken. The Hampton staff certainly had good reason to announce, "There is a certain amount of grit and pluck needed for doing successful work in the night classes." The survivors were held up as model students. As H. B. Frissell explained in 1885, Hampton gave special recognition to successful night school students: There must always be here the double standard of judging students, by which their moral worth is taken into account even more than their intellectual advancement. What will this student do for the
58
The Education of Blacks in the South
upbuilding of his race? is the question we are obliged to ask everyone placed under our care. During the past year, students have been asked to leave the school, whose scholarship was of the best, because it was felt that they lacked in moral earnestness. . . . At the last anniversary exercises, a young man spoke as the valedictorian of his class who by no means led his fellows in scholarship, but had notably taken the lead in Christian Manhood. Character or "moral earnestness," however, was judged by the students' willingness to perform "ten hours' drudgery" in unskilled or semiskilled occupations. The study of mathematics or classical lore for hours on end was not considered an index of hard labor or moral strength.35 Finally, for those students lacking in "moral earnestness," a rigid system of social discipline was instituted to remove the unfit. Armstrong established a "Daily Order of Exercises," which occupied nearly every minute of the students' time. They reported for morning inspection at 5:45, had breakfast and prayer from 6:00 to 6:30, worked or studied during the day with scarcely a half hour to themselves, went to supper and evening prayers from 6:00 to 6:45 P.M., and, if in night school, retired to their dormitories thoroughly fatigued after evening study from 7:00 to 9:00. Male students were required to participate in military drill and to march to and from classes. Beret-Captain Henry Romeyn, who commanded the Hampton Cadets in 1878, stated that the military drill was "not intended to make soldiers out of our students, nor to create a warlike spirit," but to "create ideas of neatness, order, system, obedience, and produce a better manhood." In Romeyn's view, the drill cultivated a "respect for order and properly constituted authority, that, in general, would do much to keep down the dangerously increasing communistic elements in the midst of the population of our country." All students submitted to a system of demerits for infractions of the social code. This routine enabled the teachers to observe the students' adaptation to the Hampton program. Many pupils were expelled for small infractions of the social code. One student was dismissed permanently after receiving reprimands for "using profane language," "not having room in order," "absence from church without permission," and "having light on after hours without authority." Another student, accused of "not rising during singing at morning prayers and causing disturbance by laughing," was suspended for the year 1879. Many other students met a similar fate as Hampton sought to instill a respect for order and "properly" constituted authority.36 The Hampton model of industrial education was viewed with suspicion and resentment by significant segments of the black community. The black students who experienced the Hampton routine delivered an
The Hampton Model
59
important critique. Historians have failed to analyze the industrial education programs from this perspective. Yet for Hampton, and probably for many other institutions, the most intimate assessment of industrial education, in practice, came from this group. Moreover, when it is considered that nearly all of Hampton's "rebel" students were probably dismissed during the "weeding-out" season, the protest of those who remained is particularly insightful and illuminating. A significant number of the Hampton students attacked the school's industrial program at its most vulnerable points. Many came to Hampton with the understanding that they would learn skilled trades for future livelihood. But because Hampton was designed primarily to train conservative teachers and leaders, some students were disappointed with the absence of technical training and the low level of trade training. William W. Adams, having heard that "scholars could learn trades" at Hampton, entered the school in 1878 to learn the printing trade. Adams was appalled at the elementary character of the academic program and commented bitterly that he was "not learning anything," merely "going over what I had learned in a primary school." He was more disheartened, however, in discovering that no one would teach him the printing trade. He left in dismay and charged that the school was "greatly overrated." Ten years later, another student complained about the inadequate training in the printing division. As Thomas Mann wrote to Armstrong, "Bookbinding is a part of the printer's trade of which we get none. . . . As I wish to become a successful printer, I would like to learn all about the trade." Hampton was capable of offering better training in the printing trade because the school printed the Southern Workman and the African Repository and operated the Normal School Press. But in 1878 there were no students in the printing trade, and by 1890 there were only eight black students working in the printing office. But the Hampton mission was to train teachers, not printers or shoemakers.37 From the vantage point of the student, the trade instruction at Hampton was elementary and limited. A student in the blacksmith department complained in 1888 that there were "six blacksmiths and only two forges," which greatly restricted their practice in heating and hammering metals. John H. Boothe, in his last year of training to become a shoemaker, wrote that he had not received "any instructions on cutting out and fitting shoes." J. F. Satterwhite stated that the students were not trained to make boots, a product that brought significant profits to shoemakers. C. L. Marshall further criticized the shoemaking program for not teaching "sewed work" in the shop. Marshall, like Satterwhite, was displeased with his training in shoemaking. As he informed Armstrong, "The people do not want peg or nail work, but they want sewed work. Should I go home and attempt to set up a shoe shop without any knowl-
60
The Education of Blacks in the South
edge of sewed work, I don't think I could earn my daily bread." Indeed, a shoemaker who could not make boots or cut, fit, or sew shoes was hardly worthy of the name.38 The "carpenters," like the shoemakers, were trained to be handymen rather than craftsmen or artisans. William M. Keffie was annoyed because he and fellow apprentices did not receive "enough practice in the way of building and framing houses." J. A. Colbert, another aspiring carpenter, worked "all day for six days each week" and was dissatisfied with the lack of training in "the use of timber." Apparently, Hampton's program in carpentry involved little more than instruction in making window sashes and frames. The students urged Armstrong to upgrade the work from essentially manual labor to skilled trade training. Perry Shields, writing to Armstrong in 1888, revealed much about the quality of the carpentry course. We the boys in the HIW [Huntington Industrial Workshop] need to learn how to build houses, the practice for which, we do not get in the mill. We work in the mill three years, after which we leave, giving others to think that we are carpenters. All of us can't find mills to get employment, hence we will soon find out that building is the chief and only work of our branch by which we can earn a living. So you see that the only thing we learn in that direction is the use of tools and three years are too much time to spend learning merely to use tools. We draw buildings every week and if we had some of the work to do after drawing it we would become selfsupporting mechanics. As it is, we begin with making window and door frames and have but few other jobs, but making frames. Hampton's trade students were acutely aware of the institute's shortcomings. O. H. Hawkins requested "more practical training or instruction pertaining to framing houses and how to get the different levels, angles, etc." Whether it was Jackson M. Mundy requesting mechanical drawing or George Johnson asking for improvements in the sawmill, trade students at Hampton were largely disappointed with their training.39 The students' resentment was eventually expressed in a petition of protest issued to the Hampton faculty in the summer of 1887. According to two students, Perry Shields and W. H. Scott, "every apprentice of the school signed his name" to the protest document. The faculty, however, ignored the petition, and Shields informed Armstrong: "We feel that we form a very insignificant part of the working class, from the fact that last summer a letter was written the faculty to which every apprentice of the school signed his name, and from that letter we have heard nothing, for nor against; from such points we lose interest." Likewise, Scott complained to Armstrong: "The petition put through by the trade-boys dur-
The Hampton Model
61
ing the fall was seemingly ignored much to our disappointment." In the letters that followed the petition, the students protested against the menial level of training, hard labor, low wages, and poor working conditions. Realizing that very little educational benefit accrued from the industrial program, the students responded as a discontented working class. Dissatisfaction with overwork was a consistent and pervasive theme in their letters. John H. Boothe, who described the working conditions in terms suitable to characterizing convict labor, said that the students were "confined" in the shops "for a term of three years to work every day except legal holidays and Sundays." Hawkins viewed the students' training not as an educational program but as a process of "toiling at their trade through three years." Scott spoke for many of his fellow students in candid remarks about the work schedule: "It is to be remembered that four years at a trade like ours, working from 7 A.M. to 5:50 P.M., is enough to break down the constitution of a man, much less boys in the bloom of youth."40 Hampton's students understood that they were performing hard labor and some, like J. F. Satterwhite, stated simply, "I think we ought to get paid more." Similarly, Roberta Whiting, the mother of a Hampton student, questioned the school's manual labor program, which operated at the expense of both trade and academic training: "I received a letter from my son and he tells me that he has not attended day school since entering your institution. He also mentioned that his work was hard having to milk, and attend to a number of cows every day and that he has to get up at four A.M. to do this and the only time spent in school was at night. I have spoken to my physician and he thinks that amount of work detrimental to the health of a boy his age." James C. Rollins also consulted his physician about the Hampton labor routine. Arriving at the school in "tolerably good health," he informed Armstrong that "my doctor has seriously cautioned me about overworking myself." George Johnson resented the harshness of his boss; Clayton Elks demanded better food; G. G. Spraggins complained of the rain leaking into his shop; and W. Z. Ruth pleaded for improved working conditions.41 Publicly, Armstrong propagandized that at Hampton "there was no begging except for more work." The students, however, actually asked for reduced work loads. J. H. Tucker, who may have understood Armstrong's passion for hard labor, could not comprehend why he had to continue painting in the dark merely to complete a ten-hour work routine. Male students particularly requested Armstrong to suspend work hours on Saturdays at four o'clock. According to Hawkins, they wanted the time "to engage themselves in such games, or local pleasures as they think best." Armstrong, however, believing that blacks had no "respect" for labor, insisted upon "the ten hours' drudgery" to put the students "in
62.
The Education of Blacks in the South
shape for the struggle of life." But, in the words of Perry Shields, "after working for a long time upon the same old thing in which there is no future," many students lost interest in their training. In sharp protest against the constrictions on the students' intellect and creativity, Shields asserted, "The shop is cold and our minds are straying and our hands freezing—and we cannot retain any interests."4Z Hampton's students also resented the school's active support of Jim Crow racial practices. In 1878, Hampton's newly formed Alumni Association petitioned the school's faculty regarding its policies and practices of racial subordination. The Alumni Association, which met at Hampton during the May commencement exercises, urged the faculty to "examine carefully" whether black visitors were accorded proper respect. More specifically, the petition charged: "That the graduates of this Institution have been insulted and have had our feelings mortified by public rumors and newspaper articles to the effect that the officers and teachers of this Institution have not, and do not accord to colored visitors the courtesies and hospitalities due them as a race." The Hampton alumni used their own experiences to charge the faculty with racial proscription. As the petition stated, "We the graduates of this Institution, after returning in compliance with the call of our Alma Mater, have had our feelings wounded most grievously by being barred from some of the privileges that ordinary white visitors enjoyed." Much of this protest remained within the confines of the institute; nevertheless, it reveals important student perceptions of the Hampton program. Clearly, many of them realized that Armstrong and his colleagues were trying to convince black people to accept a subordinate social position in the institution and in the society at large.43 Hampton's students and alumni were not alone in questioning the relevance of Armstrong's social philosophy to the interests and aspirations of the Afro-American South. Both Frissell and Armstrong acknowledged persistent black opposition to the Hampton Idea. In 1878 Armstrong declared that black criticism of the institute was "no novelty," and in 1879 he admitted that objections to the Hampton program were "common in the colored papers." In 1888 Armstrong further stated: "During the first ten years of our school life our work was looked upon with disfavor by the Negro leaders as providing only a low grade of instruction." H. B. Frissell recalled that "Negro conventions referred to Hampton as a 'slave pen and literary penitentiary.' " The black Virginia Star recommended that the government make Hampton "a National Reform School" for its wards. "It is admirably adapted for such, and it would prevent many unwary parents from sending their children there to equip them with a classical education." The Christian Recorder of the African Methodist Episcopal church, after criticizing the conservative
The Hampton Model
63
view of a Hampton student in 1875, asked, "Have Virginia conservatives captured Hampton?" 44 Black criticisms of Hampton Institute received national attention in the Afro-American press during the late 18705. In 1876 two black writers for the People's Advocate, which was edited in Alexandria, Virginia, by the prominent black journalist John Wesley Cromwell, characterized the Hampton program as an educational experience that sought to affirm the legitimacy of black subordination. After attending the 1876 commencement, one writer, struck by Hampton's pattern of race relations, reported: On Commencement Day May i8th visitors were present, white and colored, but not one of the latter was to be seen on the splendid platform of Virginia Hall. The rudest and most ignorant white men and women were politely conducted to the platform; respectable and intelligent colored ladies and gentlemen were shown lower seats where they could neither see nor hear the exercises of the day with any pleasure. To speak in general the colored people and students are made to feel that they must forever remain inferior to their white brethren no matter what their attainments may be. The reporter concluded that it was "better, far better, yes infinitely better that we have no high schools and colleges, if our youth are to be brought up under such baneful influences." Several days later another reporter for the People's Advocate, who had also visited Hampton Institute, commented boldly: "I had rather my boy, should grow up ignorant of letters, than attend an Institution to be taught that Negroes, notwithstanding their acquirements, are and must forever remain inferior to the whites."45 This line of criticism continued in 1878, when the prominent black leader Henry M. Turner visited Hampton and reported his impressions of the school in the Christian Recorder. In his weekly column "Wayside Dots and Jots," Turner chastised Hampton for its Confederate orientation. He was struck immediately by the pictures of Andrew Johnson and General Robert E. Lee hanging on the walls of the school's chapel and commented acidly: "What [they] had ever done for the colored people I could not tell." Turner attended an advanced class for seniors purportedly in astronomy, and he concluded that "the teacher knew comparatively nothing about it, and the class knew, if possible, less than nothing." He was convinced that Hampton deprived black students of intellectual development, particularly in "algebra, geometry, higher mathematics, Greek, Latin, and Science." He was most upset, however, with Hampton's policy of racial subordination. During his stay, "not a teacher asked me to sit down, made a solitary explanation, gave me a
64
The Education of Blacks in the South
welcome look, nor showed me the civility of a visitor, while I was in the building." In contrast to the treatment he received, Turner observed that "when white visitors come in, chairs were offered them, etc." Turner's treatment at Hampton differed sharply from the cordial receptions he had received at other black schools. Thus he assessed the Hampton teachers and students as follows: "They are either in the whole ex-slaveholders themselves, or are pandering to the spirit of slavery. The graduates they send out cannot be called educated by any means, for they have not near the learning given by a respectable grammar school. . . . Besides, I think colored children are taught to remember, 'You are Negroes,' and as such, 'your place is behind.' "46 R. A. Green, editor of the Virginia Star, reprinted Turner's editorial and informed his readers that he had received similar treatment while visiting Hampton Institute. A year later the Louisianian reported that "General Armstrong, the principal of Hampton Institute, does not seem to stand in high favor with the colored people of the east." The Louisianian declared that Armstrong was charged with "curbing the aspirations of his students" and with crushing the manhood of the male students by refusing to hire black professors. "To know and feel that he is indeed a man," argued the Louisianian, "the Negro should have the black professor side by side with his white brother. This manhood education can never come from white teachers alone, however competent." The Louisianian charged that Armstrong "by his educational policy, seems to think that we should only know enough to make good servants."47 Even the more moderate wing of black educators and writers criticized industrial education during the i88os and 18905. Such black spokesmen as Harry Smith, Alexander Crummell, and Calvin Chase questioned the motives of those who promoted industrial training as the educational model most suitable for Afro-Americans. Initially, it appeared that Crummell, the venerable and learned rector of Washington, D.C.'s St. Luke's Methodist Church, would support the Hampton-styled industrial education movement. In 1887 he published Common Sense in Common Schooling, which praised vocational education and stated that higher education was "ruinous [to] well-nigh half of the colored youth who graduate from high schools and colleges." The African Methodist Episcopal church's Church Review criticized CrummelPs position on the grounds that many whites would "refer to him as endorsing the position they hold, to wit, that the Negro only needs and should therefore only receive an industrial education." The editor of the Church Review, however, understood that Crummell meant only to emphasize the value of skilled trades and technical training and did not intend to encourage the Hampton program of Negro industrial education. Crummell confirmed this view when he later wrote, "All the talk about 'industrialism' is with
The Hampton Model
65
regard to the Negro and Negro education, and there is a lot of white men in the land who pity the Negro but who have never learned to love him, who take up this miserable 'fad,' and are striving by one pretext or another to put this limitation upon our brains and culture."48 In the 18905 Harry Smith, editor of the Cleveland Gazette, and Calvin Chase, editor of the Washington Bee, continued to warn the black community about the dangers of the Hampton-Tuskegee style of industrial education. The Gazette, arguing that attainments in the industrial arts would not fit young blacks for the "higher duties of life," reported in 1890 that Hampton graduates were being employed as waiters and porters. Although admitting to the necessity of trade training, the Gazette advocated higher and professional training for "the fullest development of the [Negro] mind." Likewise, the Washington Bee urged blacks to relegate industrial education to a secondary role and to place top priority on the training of lawyers, doctors, scientists, and other professional persons. Much of the Bee's attack on industrial training focused on Booker T. Washington as he became in the 18905 the leading black spokesman for industrial education. In a typical editorial against Washington and the Hampton-Tuskegee Idea, the Bee remarked in 1896: "It is a notorious fact, that the utterances of Mr. Washington are nothing more than to make himself rich by assuring the white people of this country that the negroes [sic] place is in the machine shop, at the plow, in the washtub and not in the schools of legal and medical professions; that he [the Negro] has no business to aspire to those places as they are reserved for the proud Caucasian." Significantly, such criticisms, which started in the middle 18705, long predated the Washington-DuBois debates of the early twentieth century and represented a persistent strain of black protest against the Hampton-Tuskegee Idea for the training of black educators and leaders.49 Black protest against the Hampton Idea was directed at that particular form of industrial education; it was not a blanket rejection of vocational and technical training. Black leaders in conjunction with white antislavery leaders were interested in establishing black trade and industrial schools as early as the eighteenth century. This interest increased significantly with the emergence of militant abolitionism and the Negro convention movement of the 18305. In 1831 black male activists from the major northern urban centers assembled in Philadelphia for the First Annual Convention of the Free People of Color at which they proposed the establishment of a black "Manual Labor College" in New Haven, Connecticut, that would embrace all the mechanic arts and provide a thorough classical education. Early on, it seemed that the proposed trade and technical college would receive general support from the New Haven white community and prove itself a success within a short time.
66
The Education of Blacks in the South
New Haven whites, however, foreshadowing future opposition to serious black trade and technical training, "were as one in their protest" against the plan and forced the initial project to be abandoned. In 1833, still attempting to realize the goal of a black trade and technical school, black leaders and white abolitionists sought to transfer their resources to an academy in Canaan, Connecticut. But the white townspeople demolished the building that was erected to start a black manual labor college; again, the plan was squelched almost before it began. The project was pursued through the 18405 and 18505, but no black polytechnic institute was established in the antebellum era. Still, the persistent campaign for such a school underscored black interest in education that could combine a classical liberal course with training in technology and trades. This idea differed sharply from the Hampton program that precluded technical education and did very little with respect to trades. Ironically, when "industrial education" programs developed in black schools during the postbellum period, they never met the long-standing aspirations of Afro-Americans.50 The most significant expansion of industrial education in black normal schools and colleges occurred during the i88os. Its sudden rise was the result primarily of the establishment of the John F. Slater Fund in 1881, which offered financial aid exclusively for the development of black industrial education. Perhaps more than any other factor, the Slater Fund caused several black schools to initiate vocational programs during the i88os. Many of the schools' reports indicate that the industrial work would not have been possible without the Slater Fund. As badly as most black schools needed money just to scrape by, they could hardly afford to ignore the availability of this new philanthropy, even if it was targeted for low-level industrial training. Indeed, the increased interest in industrial education by black schools indicates, above all else, a pragmatic search for funds, not a commitment to the social and educational philosophy embodied in the Hampton program. Thus, although many schools offered or at least advertised new courses in industrial education, they never allowed it to displace classical liberal academic education.51 The sudden rise of industrial education in black schools during the i88os has often led to the erroneous conclusion that it became the ascendant form of education in black normal schools and colleges and temporarily eclipsed liberal and higher education. Yet a careful analysis of the curriculum reveals that most black colleges relegated industrial education to a subordinate role. Among the black colleges under mission societies, the traditional liberal or classical curriculum remained dominant throughout the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Most black col-
The Hampton Model
67
leges were under the direction of four major mission societies: the American Missionary Association, the Freedmen's Aid Society of the Methodist Episcopal church, the American Baptist Home Mission Society, and the Board of Missions for the Freedmen of the Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A. A significant number of black secondary schools and colleges, however, were organized and controlled by black religious organizations. The African Methodist Episcopal church, the Colored Methodist Episcopal church, and the African Methodist Episcopal Zion church established nearly all of the major colleges controlled by black organizations, and their combined voice largely articulated the educational policy of the black community. These institutions never adopted the HamptonTuskegee pattern of black industrial education, and they gave low priority to all forms of industrial training. Robert G. Sherer, in a useful study of black secondary and normal schools and colleges in nineteenthcentury Alabama, demonstrated that Booker T. Washington was virtually alone in urging that prime emphasis be put on industrial rather than classical liberal education. Sherer concludes correctly that Washington and the Hampton-Tuskegee Idea were "outside the mainstream of black educational thought." Consequently, at the close of the nineteenth century, the proponents of the Hampton Idea found little support for their model of industrial training. In fact, they faced powerful resistance, especially from important leaders in the mission societies.5i The northern mission societies generally accepted manual training courses such as printing, carpentry, and blacksmithing for student work programs, the teaching of skilled trades, and character development, but they tended to view such courses as relatively insignificant for intellectual and leadership training. The proponents of the Hampton model never accepted the missionary interpretation of industrial training. Samuel Armstrong was one of the first to recognize that the industrial education concept left "a wide opportunity for difference of opinion as to the application of the principle, and these differences go deeper than the surface." There were clear distinctions between the Hampton and the missionary models of industrial education. Whereas Hampton established a system of menial labor to build character and mold the ideology of prospective teachers, missionary schools focused on job training. Teacher training in the missionary schools focused on the classical liberal tradition. At Hampton, industrial training was the core curriculum for all students, whereas the mission societies maintained industrial education as a relatively insignificant adjunct to the classical liberal curriculum. The Hampton model was organized around a conservative sociopolitical ideology that advocated the political disfranchisement and economic subordination of the black race. The mission societies emphasized
68
The Education of Blacks in the South
literary and professional training to develop a black intelligentsia that would fight for political and civil equality. Thus there was far more discord than harmony between the two camps.53 The missionary vanguard was headed by Thomas J. Morgan, Henry L. Morehouse, and Malcolm MacVicar of the American Baptist Home Mission Society and Joseph E. Roy and William Hayes Ward of the American Missionary Association. Morgan, a colonel of the Fourteenth United States Colored Infantry during the Civil War and former commissioner of Indian affairs, served as executive secretary of the Baptist Home Mission Society and as editor of the society's influential Home Mission Monthly from 1893 to 1902.. Morehouse was the executive secretary of the American Baptist Education Society. MacVicar, superintendent of the Home Mission Society's Educational Department from 1890 to 1900, headed the society's Virginia Union University from 1900 to 1904. Ward, one of the most vigorous defenders of black higher education, was for many years chairman of the American Missionary Association's executive committee and was associate editor, 1868—70, superintending editor, 1870—96, and editor, 1896—1913, of the New York Independent. His colleague, Roy, was field superintendent of the American Missionary Association. The status of these men in missionary activities and in the larger society enabled them to form a powerful vanguard that stood clearly and unswervingly for black higher education and for the development of advanced technical schools to prepare blacks for executive and administrative posts.54 This vocal missionary leadership objected to the Hampton model on the grounds that it undermined the democratic rights of blacks by assuming that black students were destined for a subordinate industrial role in the southern economy. Following a conference on black education in 1895 at the American Social Science Association, Morgan and Ward attacked the "reviving Negrophobia," which opposed the higher education of blacks and laid "special stress upon the necessity of Industrial training." Morgan, through the Home Mission Monthly, and Ward, in the Independent, "protested] vehemently against any philosophy of education which will restrict the Negro schools to industrial training, or to rudimentary education." Moreover, they suspected "that the prime motive of the white men in the South who urge most strongly the industrial education of the Negroes, is the conviction in their minds that all the Negro needs to know is how to work. This proceeds upon the assumption that the race is doomed to servitude." The Negro industrial education concept, as Morgan and Ward understood it, was "based upon the denial of the humanity of a whole race" and was calculated to make the Negro "absolutely content with his lot as a servant." In contrast to the Hampton model of industrial training, Morgan urged the mission soci-
The Hampton Model
69
eties to establish for blacks technical departments and schools "to develop among them architects, artists, engineers, master mechanics, superintendents of mines, overseers of mills," and the like. On another occasion, after politely stating his sympathy for Booker T. Washington, Morgan rejected the manual training concept in favor of "the higher grade of industrial training proper, such as is now furnished in Pratt Institute and other similar institutions in the North."55 Generally, the missionary leaders were diplomatic in their handling of the industrial education movement, and they attempted to check its growth by vigorously defending the need for black higher education. "Neglect, if you will, the common school education in your missionary labor; neglect, if you must, the industrial education," advised Ward, "but never forget that it is your work to educate leaders." To the mission societies, leadership training meant, above all, higher literary education. According to Morehouse, the Home Mission Society believed in "the thorough humanity of the black man, with divine endowment of all the facilities of the white man; capable of culture, capable of high attainments under proper conditions and with sufficient time; a being not predestined to be simply a hewer of wood and drawer of water for the white race." Morehouse believed that the black race would progress largely through the wise leadership of a gifted intelligentsia, and he therefore placed top priority on the higher education of a black "talented tenth." Morgan also thought that black progress depended on the leadership of "noble and powerful minds raised up from their own ranks." Similarly, MacVicar argued for the highest form of liberal education because the mental development of the black man followed "precisely the same laws as in the case of the white man."56 Significantly, the views of the missionary vanguard were shared by white presidents of the mission societies' black colleges and secondary schools. Henry S. DeForest, president of the American Missionary Association's Talladega College, contended "that while all should have the lower education, a great many should receive the higher." As he put it, "Every man may need silver, but the best commerce of the world requires that some should have gold, and a good deal of it." DeForest stated that Talladega had "not forgotten the industrial education"; the college's primary goal, however, was to offer the black students "choice scholarship." George Sale, president of Atlanta Baptist College (Morehouse), informed the white Georgia State Teacher's Association that he objected to "the idea that the education of the Negro should be exclusively or distinctly industrial." If classical studies were valuable for whites, Sale asked, "Why should they not have the same value for Negroes?" E. C. Mitchell, president of Leland University in New Orleans, reasoned that it was purposeless to include industrial training in black colleges because
jo
The Education of Blacks in the South
"every village has its Negro mechanics who are patronized both by white and colored employers, and any who wish to learn the trade can do so." He viewed industrial training as a form of "class education" for blacks and argued that it did "not educate, even in trades." Likewise, Presidents Charles F. Meserve of Shaw University, George F. Genung of Richmond Theological Seminary, and MacVicar of Virginia Union University regarded industrial training as relatively insignificant to the higher education of black students.57 To be sure, many other college presidents were less adamant in their opposition to industrial training. In fact, most probably considered it a positive adjunct to the black students' general academic program. Even so, they relegated industrial training to a subordinate role in the curriculum. A. C. Osborn, president of Benedict College, saw some usefulness in industrial training, but as he clearly stated, "Benedict is not a trade or industrial school, in that it does not give the industrial work the foremost place." President L. G. Barrett of Jackson College also praised the positive aspects of limited industrial training while emphasizing that his college directed black students "on to higher study." Ward spoke well for the missionary leadership when he said, "Industrial education is good, very valuable, and we give it as an adjunct, but it is not an important thing." 58 The conflicting ideologies of black education led to some significant confrontations between the missionary and Hampton camps in the late nineteenth century, and the outcome shaped the Hampton's advocates' course of action at the turn of the century. In 1890, following a suggestion of former President Rutherford B. Hayes, Quaker philanthropist Albert K. Smiley organized a conference at his Lake Mohonk resort hotel in the Catskills to discuss the "Negro question." Of this conference Armstrong wrote, "In order to be sure and get the southern white men to come, he [Smiley] decided not to invite any colored people." Modeled on the annual Indian conferences at Mohonk, the conferences of 1890 and 1891 concentrated essentially on Negro education. Samuel C. Armstrong, Hollis B. Frissell, Rutherford B. Hayes, chairman of the Slater Fund, and others argued strongly for the Hampton model as the best form of black education. The words of Armstrong were typical: "The great mass of Negroes must be farmers and they need to be taught to farm intelligently." But regardless of whether blacks were forced to be farmers, the missionary educators objected to imposing second-class industrial training on the black race. Reverend Roy, secretary of the American Missionary Association, after making a brilliant defense of blacks' right to higher education, informed the Hampton supporters that it was "too late in the history of civilization to impose any repression upon any
The Hampton Model
71
class of people." Similarly, Lyman Abbott, Congregational minister and editor of the Christian Union (renamed the Outlook in 1893), admonished the conference that it was "not in the province nor in the power of one class to determine the metes and bounds of another class." "I claim, therefore," said Abbott, "the Negroes' right to an education from a, b, up to Syriac, from the multiplication table up to conic sections. Or, if there is anything higher than that, that higher thing, whatever it may be." Ward and MacVicar also supported higher education and equal rights for black people. Even though blacks were barred from the Mohonk conference, the Hampton boosters failed to achieve a consensus in support of industrial normal schools for training black leaders.59 Another debate regarding the "instruction of the colored citizens" was held at the 1896 annual conference of the American Social Science Association. The major address was given by Hampton booster H. L. Wayland, editor of the New York Examiner, who retired as president of the association in 1894. Wayland took great care to summon distinguished black supporters of the Hampton model, particularly Booker T. Washington and Hugh M. Browne, principal of a black high school in Washington, D.C. He wrote Robert C. Ogden, president of the Hampton Board of Trustees: "On Tuesday evening, September i, I shall read a paper at the Social Science, at Saratoga, on the higher education of the southern colored, which will be followed by a debate. We hope to have Prof. Washington, who is heartily with us, and I shall ask Mr. Durham and one or two others. . . . Now what I want to say is this, will you not make it a point to be present." Ogden did not attend the conference, but Wayland, Washington, and Browne gave an adequate defense of the Hampton Idea. To these men, as Wayland aptly phrased it, the whole question of black education could be summarized in two words: "These two words are 'Hampton' and 'Tuskegee.' " But Morgan, Atlanta University Professor Silas X. Floyd, and Malcolm MacVicar were not persuaded by the arguments of the Hampton supporters. "I submit," replied Morgan, "that no form of industrial training yet devised can take the place of a college curriculum in giving breadth of knowledge, catholicity of sympathy, power of thought, constructive ability and fitness for leadership." Floyd and MacVicar joined Morgan in rejecting industrial training as an appropriate model of education for the black leadership. Wayland, in describing the results of the debate to Ogden, revealed his frustration over the resistance to the Hampton Idea: Gen. Morgan and Dr. MacVicar held on to the old theory. I am surprised that they do not take counsel with common sense. Probably they would say, "The Colored people demand Greek and Latin,
72.
The Education of Blacks in the South
and if we do not give it to them, they will go elsewhere." But to that I would reply, "Both Hampton and Tuskegee have annually more applications than they can receive." And also it is our duty to give them what we conscientiously think best, and it is our right to do so since we pay for it ourselves. It became increasingly clear to the advocates of the Hampton model that a powerful cadre of missionary educators and important black leaders would not accept industrial training as the dominant form of black education. In 1895 and 1896 Wayland was sharply assailed for making caustic criticisms of black higher education. Even President William McKinley was chastised by Ward when, in 1898, the president praised Tuskegee for giving black students instruction in "practical industry" and for not "attempting the unattainable" by offering higher education. Ward replied acidly: "What there is 'unattainable' to the Negro, or what school offers the unattainable, we do not know." The missionary vanguard met well the challenge of the Hampton ideologues and effectively blocked the spread of the Hampton doctrine in the mission schools; thus in the late nineteenth century, the Hampton spokesmen found themselves cut off from the mainstream of black higher education.60 The Hampton Idea was not isolated from the mainstream of American society, however. In sharp contrast to its rejection by black teachers and the leaders of black schools and colleges, leading American politicians, businessmen, and philanthropists came to view Hampton and Tuskegee as pointing the way toward a national and even worldwide solution of the "Negro problem." The Hampton Idea was supported actively by Ulysses S. Grant, Rutherford B. Hayes, James A. Garfield, Theodore Roosevelt, William Howard Taft, Woodrow Wilson, Andrew Carnegie, John D. Rockefeller, Jr., Julius Rosenwald, George Eastman, Charles W. Eliot, Jabez L. M. Curry, and Clark Howell, to name only a few. Through correspondence and visits to Hampton and Tuskegee, such men had come to know Hampton's work intimately. They understood correctly that Armstrong, Frissell, and Washington propounded not merely an educational theory but a social philosophy. President Garfield said that Armstrong was working out the race problem "in the only way that will give us a country without section and a people without a stain." "If there is any work which every American must believe in," said Theodore Roosevelt, "it is the work you are doing at Hampton and Tuskegee." Harvard University President Charles W. Eliot said: "Hampton and Tuskegee have done great good. I know of no educational or philanthropic object which should more commend itself to American patriots." These two small normal schools, with academic programs comparable to the
The Hampton Model
73
quality of instruction in an adequate common school, received national acclaim because of their profoundly conservative approach to the problems of race, labor, and politics in the New South.61 Booker T. Washington's rise to national prominence in 1895 breathed new life into the Hampton Idea and accounted in large part for its fame and achievements during the early twentieth century. Indeed, from 1895, when he addressed the opening of the Cotton States and International Exposition at Atlanta, Georgia, to his death in 1915, the Hampton Idea was recognized nationally as the Hampton-Tuskegee Idea. On 18 September 1895, Washington delivered his widely publicized "Atlanta Compromise." He said virtually nothing about education but much about economics, politics, and racial equality. True to the Hampton philosophy, which he learned under Armstrong from 1872. to 1875, Washington stressed the political and economic value of his educational philosophy. Had he lived to hear it, Armstrong would have been proud of the way his favorite student addressed the South's dominant-class whites. He spoke carefully to their greatest fears: that black southerners would persist in their struggle to attain the political power formally granted to them by the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments and that they might choose not to till the region's cotton, tobacco, and sugar fields, or at least withdraw a substantial portion of their labor power. "No race can prosper," said Washington, "till it learns that there is as much dignity in tilling a field as in writing a poem." Washington urged the development of a black laboring class that would "buy your surplus land, make blossom the waste places in your fields, and run your factories." These black workers, he promised, would be "the most patient, faithful, law-abiding, and unresentful people that the world has seen." Washington was silent on the questions of black voting and officeholding, and his silence was evidence enough of his willingness to accommodate the practical disfranchisement of black voters. Washington, an ex-slave, embodied the objective conjuncture of race and class that threatened to tear apart the southern social order, and, therefore, his espousal of the Hampton Idea gave it more legitimacy than Armstrong ever did or could have. Somehow, the retrogressive and repressive tenets of the Hampton Idea rang differently when spoken by an ex-slave.61 Still, Washington and Tuskegee were Armstrong and Hampton in blackface. "The mission of Tuskegee Institute," said Roscoe Conkling Bruce, the director of the school's Academic Department, "is largely to supply measurably well equipped teachers for the schools." Tuskegee, like Hampton, was primarily a normal school, and Washington, as Armstrong, saw his students as prospective missionaries of the traditional Hampton educational and social philosophy. The student body at both
74
The Education of Blacks in the South
institutes was divided into day students and night students. At Tuskegee, said Bruce, "The night students work in the industries, largely at common labor, all day every day and go to school at night, thus paying their current board bills and accumulating such credits at the Treasurer's office as will later defray their expenses in the day school." The student pay rate remained two and a half cents per hour or one dollar for a fortyhour week, so much hard toil was required of the night students. The day students were divided into two sections that alternated working every other day for three days a week and attending academic classes for three days. Not surprisingly, Louis Harlan discovered that at Hampton and Tuskegee "there was perhaps one graduate for every ten ex-students."63 Because the night students worked all day for six days a week and attended school at night, while the day students spent one-half of their time at common labor, Tuskegee's curriculum was also weighted heavily toward the manual labor routine. As at Hampton, academic education was of low quality. Bruce, putting the best possible face on his department, told a Boston audience in 1904 that Tuskegee's lowest day school class was "about the equivalent to a fourth grade in the North" and the senior day school class was comparable to "the first or the second year (barring the foreign languages) in a northern high school." Washington thought that even this standard placed too much emphasis on academic learning, and the following year he and Bruce enforced a directive: "Every academic teacher is appreciably to diminish the amount of time required of his students for the preparation of his subjects." Washington's decision raises a fundamental question. Why did he, as principal of a normal school, whose avowed mission was to train teachers, deliver such a crippling blow to an already weak academic program? Here it is important to recall that Washington was called back to Hampton in 1879 to preside over Armstrong's night school. What he did in 1905 was no different than what Armstrong did in 1879—base the training of teachers primarily on manual labor rather than on academic studies. Washington kept Tuskegee in line with the educational form and content he had received at Hampton.64 Both Armstrong and Washington believed strongly in correlating academic and industrial training. In reality this meant academic instruction no higher than the three Rs and what was presupposed by the manual labor routines. As Bruce stated, But, the teaching of agriculture, even in its elementary stages, presupposes a considerable amount of academic preparation. To be sure, a flourishing garden may be made and managed by bright-eyed tots just out of the kindergarten, but how can commercial fertilizers
The Hampton Model
75
be carefully analyzed by a boy who has made no study of general chemistry?—and how can a balanced ration be adjusted by an illiterate? Similarly, the girl in the laundry does not make soap by rote but by principle; and the girl in the dressmaking shop does not cut out her pattern by luck or guess or instinct or rule of thumb, but by geometry. Bruce saw in such training the "technical utility of Tuskegee's Academic Department." It is hardly necessary to add again that Tuskegee was not training farmers, laundry women, or dressmakers, but teachers. The teachers were trained in academic skills presupposed by common labor occupations. It is no wonder, then, that Louis Harlan found that "a generation of Tuskegee graduates, not to mention the larger number who left before graduation, murdered the King's English in their letters back to the school." This performance reflected the Hampton glorification of "dull plodders."65 When Hampton and Tuskegee are taken on their own terms, as normal schools, there is no logical reason why they should have given priority to technical and trade training. Yet, with all the talk about industrial training, both contemporary observers and later historians mistakenly assumed that trade, technical, and commercial training formed the essence of Washington's educational philosophy. In fact, Tuskegee placed even less emphasis on trade and commercial training than did Hampton. In 1903 Daniel C. Smith, Tuskegee's auditor, made a study of the school's industrial training program. According to Smith, of 1,550 students, "there were only a dozen students in the school capable of doing a fair job as joiners. There were only fifteen boys who could lay brick." "Meanwhile," Smith continued, "the number of students who are doing unskilled drudgery work is increasing, and the number who receive no training through the use of tools is getting to be very large." This finding was not inconsistent with Tuskegee's aims. Nor was Tuskegee's failure to teach commercial or business subjects, despite Washington's preachings about economic development as the only salvation of black Americans. In 1906, in assessing Tuskegee's endeavors in the teaching of business and commercial subjects, Robert E. Park discovered that "there is a large amount of business conducted by the school, but there is no school of business here." There were "a large number of stenographers employed on the ground but stenography and typewriting are not taught here." Three papers and a number of pamphlets were published at Tuskegee, but printing was not taught there. There was not even a formal course in bookkeeping.66 From their founding to the late 19205, Hampton and Tuskegee were
76
The Education of Blacks in the South
Normal school students at Hampton and Tuskegee were trained in academic skills presupposed by common labor occupations. The captions on a Tuskegee blackboard—Shoemaking, Blacksmithing, Machine, Carpentry—indicate the topics for reading and composition. This practice of correlating the academic and the industrial was known as "dovetailing." Courtesy of the Library of Congress.
Normal school teachers bring the ethics of hard toil and field work directly to the black kindergarten children of Tuskegee's elementary school, the institute's lab school, which was used primarily for practice teaching. Courtesy of the Library of Congress.
The Hampton Model
77
not trade schools, nor academic schools worthy of the name, but schools that attempted to train a corps of teachers with a particular social philosophy relevant to the political and economic reconstruction of the South. Their mission and source of strength was to train teachers and leaders who would, as Washington urged, "carry a drop of [Armstrong's] life blood into the darkest corner of the darkest South." Their espousal of this mission gained Hampton and Tuskegee the support of America's leading politicians, businessmen, and philanthropists. But the HamptonTuskegee Idea had not won the hearts and minds of the teachers and administrators who controlled black educational institutions.67 By the close of the nineteenth century, Hampton supporters recognized that their model of industrial training was relatively insignificant in the overall scheme of black higher education. Yet they were determined to advance the Hampton program as the dominant educational model for the training of black leaders. In 1899 Frissell planned a tour of several southern cities to convert important black leaders to the Hampton Idea. Frissell wrote: "Our trustees have felt strongly that it is important to stir up the colored people to an interest in industrial education." He had no illusions about the black community's view of industrial education. "As you know," he wrote to a friend, "there is a perhaps natural feeling among them against this form of instruction." But to the Hampton ideologues, their form of industrial training represented the best solution to the southern race problem, and they launched a campaign to impose it as a regional system of black education. As Ogden, the president of the Hampton Board of Trustees, declared: "The main hope is in Hampton and Hampton ideas. Our first problem is to support the School; our second to make the School ideas national." Or, as Hampton Trustee Collis Potter Huntington put it, "The only question is, Where shall we get another Booker T. Washington for these other schools?" William H. Baldwin, Jr., the president of Tuskegee Institute Board of Trustees, said to Washington: "I tell you again that your course is the only one, and the work must be organized in other states, and you must do it, and we must get the money."68 This dogmatic determination to spread the Hampton model throughout the Afro-American South set the stage for the early twentieth-century struggle over the proper education of black people. Though many historians would come to view this struggle mainly as the Washington-DuBois debate, it is well to remember that the Hampton model was launched in 1868, the year DuBois was born. The Washington-DuBois controversy merely represented one of the last great battles in the long war to determine whether black people would be educated to challenge or accommodate the oppressive southern political economy. DuBois and his colleagues, however, would face a far more powerful and well-organized
78
The Education of Blacks in the South
Hampton movement than had the missionary and black educators of the late nineteenth century. Beginning in 1898, the Hampton model constantly gained support among northern businessmen-philanthropists and southern whites. The Hampton advocates also picked up additional support in the black community. But the main reason the Hampton movement gained momentum was because its supporters waged a well-organized campaign to spread the Hampton-Tuskegee doctrines.
3 E D U C A T I O N AND THE R A C E P R O B L E M IN THE NEW SOUTH THE STRUGGLE
FOR IDEOLOGICAL HEGEMONY
O F A L L the topics covered in southern black educational history, the reforms and debates that began in the late 18905 and ended around 1915 have been examined most thoroughly. Still, fundamental misunderstandings persist. Indeed, particular distortions and half-truths, which have been developed and repeated in a series of fine monographs, have evolved into the standard interpretation of southern educational reform at the turn of the century. A synopsis of this interpretation would run as follows: philanthropic northerners, perturbed by the social and economic hindrances placed on black southerners by white southerners, sought "to cushion the Negro against the shock of racism and to keep public education open as an avenue of Negro advancement." These philanthropists, less concerned about constitutional rights and social equality than were the radical Republicans of the Reconstruction era, hoped to form an alliance with the South's conservative upper class to protect black southerners from rampant racism. But, according to this school of thought, the northern philanthropists fatally miscalculated the depth and force of the white supremacy movement and soon found themselves overpowered by it. Consequently, they were deflected from their original aim to challenge racism by "good will, tact, and hard work," and they compromised with the region's white supremacists to "save for the former slaves what could be salvaged."1 What could be salvaged, the story continues, was a system of universal common schooling for black children which would serve as the last avenue of black advancement in an otherwise oppressive society. This is, of course, a peculiar interpretation because it is difficult to comprehend how a subordinate institution such as state-controlled public education might advance a class of people against the racist oppression of government and other dominant social institutions. Yet the philanthropists'
8o
The Education of Blacks in the South
support of universal public education for black children is cited as decisive evidence of their alleged original aim to cushion black southerners against the shock of extreme racism. This brings us to the last phase of the standard interpretation, which sees the emergence of the HamptonTuskegee model of black industrial education as the basis of a great compromise. Northern philanthropists, enveloped by the white supremacy movement and largely deflected from their original directions, readjusted their aim and moved to save black public education from total eradication by stressing the value of the Hampton-Tuskegee style of industrial education. In this context the philanthropists' persistently extreme emphasis on the Hampton-Tuskegee philosophy of black education emerges as a politically expedient device to reconcile hostile southern whites to the idea of universal common schooling for black children, and not so much as a unique form of second-class education to reinforce the social oppression of black southerners. The story ends with a partial redemption. Southern white industrialists, middle-class professionals, and school reformers, with little but a nominal connection with the traditional planter regime and poor whites, accepted the idea of minimal schooling for black children so long as the curriculum embodied the basic theory and practices of the Hampton-Tuskegee program.1 Historians of the South, on balance, have failed to grasp the fundamental ideological conflicts contained in the late nineteenth- and early twentieth-century southern educational movement. It was not in any significant sense a conflict between extreme racists and moderate racists. There were racists, extreme and moderate, who both supported and opposed the idea of universal public schooling for blacks and whites. There were also extreme and moderate white supremacists who favored a racially restrictive form of universal public education. What separated white southerners from each other, and from the philanthropic northerners as well, were conflicting conceptions of the relationship between political economy and universal education. In other words, they were separated by their particular educational ideologies. A coalition of northern philanthropists and southern whites viewed universal schooling for the laboring classes as complementary to a changing and modern political economy. Believing that the right schooling could train laborers to be better citizens and more efficient workers, they viewed universal education as a sound investment in social stability and economic prosperity. From this standpoint, universal education was not conceived of as transforming the social position of any laboring class, not to mention black southerners, but a means to make society run more efficiently. Consequently, philanthropic and southern white crusaders for universal public education wished to substitute education for older and cruder methods of socialization and control. In pursuit of this goal they collided with the
Education and the Race Problem
81
South's landed upper-class whites and their allies, who depended for their wealth and power on large classes of illiterate, exploited agricultural laborers. The white planters were, at best, ambiguous about the value of universal education as a means to social stability and economic growth. They lived in a society in which agricultural laborers worked for them under direct legal and extralegal compulsion. The planters' views on socializing and controlling labor developed in the context of premodern modes of social control that rested on coercion. They therefore resisted the idea of universal education on the grounds that it would inflate the economic and political aspirations of their workers and thereby spoil good field hands.3 Thus because there were white racists of all degrees on all sides of the question, the common denominator of racism is insufficient to place the social and educational ideology of philanthropic northerners and southern white school reformers at one with that of the planter class and its allies. Although white southerners in general shared a belief in white supremacy, they did not share a belief in universal public education for the laboring classes. The philanthropic northerners and southern white school reformers understood this split but did not accept it as fixed and unchangeable. The school reformers sought to convert the South to northeastern standards of social welfare and economic efficiency, including universal education as a better and more subtle means of preparing laborers for work and citizenship. To accomplish this goal they were compelled to challenge the educational and social ideology of the planter regime. Such aims underlay the southern education movement, which proceeded in an organized fashion from 1898 to 1915. Another basic ideological conflict in the southern education movement was that which separated the northern philanthropists and southern white school reformers from the educational ideas of the region's laboring classes. What historians of the South have termed the southern education movement was in fact the region's third distinctive campaign for universal education. Obviously, the first such campaign began during the Reconstruction era. The ex-slaves were the first native southerners to wrestle with the problem of universal public education. Next came the white small farmers of the late i88os and 18905. Rising up during the long depression, members of the Farmers' Alliance and Populist party seized control of state and local governments and made the first substantial gains in public education since the ex-slaves' campaigns during Reconstruction. Both of these educational movements were components of larger social movements that challenged the social power of the South's dominant planter class. In some respects, the turn-of-the-century educational movement also challenged the planters on ideological terrain, but its implications for political and economic changes were far less threat-
82.
The Education of Blacks in the South
ening than those contained in the educational campaigns of the ex-slaves and white small farmers. The new school reformers' central task was to convince the planters that particular forms of education would produce a more productive and contented agricultural work force and to allay suspicion among industrialists that universal schooling would increase competition between whites and blacks for the better urban workingclass jobs. The reformers who believed that rudimentary schooling could help upgrade black labor productivity while preparing blacks for racially prescribed social roles threw their influence behind the HamptonTuskegee Idea. In particular, they sought to build a universal public education system because they believed that such a system would improve the deportment, the health, the morals, and the efficiency of the region's workers and would socialize the young to the disciplines and values needed to maintain proper race and class relations. In 1899, at the Capon Springs, West Virginia, conference that launched the southern education movement, northern philanthropist William H. Baldwin expressed succinctly this ideology of industrial training for a racially qualified form of class subordination: The potential economic value of the Negro population properly educated is infinite and incalculable. In the Negro is the opportunity of the South. Time has proven that he is best fitted to perform the heavy labor in the Southern States. "The Negro and the mule is the only combination, so far, to grow cotton." The South needs him; but the South needs him educated to be a suitable citizen. Properly directed he is the best possible laborer to meet the climatic conditions of the South. He will willingly fill the more menial positions, and do the heavy work, at less wages, than the American white man or any foreign race which has yet come to our shores. This will permit the southern white laborer to perform the more expert labor, and to leave the fields, the mines, and the simpler trades for the Negro. Baldwin assured his southern audience that the Hampton program would achieve the proper racial hierarchy by teaching black youth to "work with their hands," to have "few wants," and to stay in their "natural environment." The Hampton-Tuskegee curriculum of industrial education was central to the philanthropists' educational ideology, not as a means to reconcile white supremacists to the idea of black public education, but as a program to reinforce the existing structure of the South's political economy and make it run more efficiently.4 Therefore, the twin slogans of the southern education movement were universal schooling for all, black and white, and the Hampton-Tuskegee style of industrial education for blacks. Each of these slogans, for different reasons, evoked strong resistance within and without the South. Uni-
Education and the Race Problem
83
versal education held one meaning for the northern philanthropists and southern white school reformers and another for the planters. Industrial education held one meaning for the northern philanthropists and their southern white allies and quite another for the black educators and white missionaries who presided over the vast majority of the South's black normal schools, secondary schools, and colleges. These were almost diametrically opposed educational ideologies which arose from different conceptions of political economy and the function of universal schooling in modern society. It was, of course, each group's goal to achieve ideological and political victory over the rest of the field. Any such victory, however, required the development of an educational and social ideology that would appeal to a wide range of social groups within the South and the nation, including the planter class, white small farmers, industrialists, middle-class professionals, black leaders, northern philanthropists, and missionaries. The philanthropists accepted the challenge and officially began their struggle for ideological hegemony in 1898. The meeting place of northern philanthropists and southern white educational reformers was the Conferences for Education in the South, which convened at Capon Springs, West Virginia, from 1898 to 1900 and met annually at various locations in the South from 1901 to 1914. The first stage of the campaign, 1898 to 1900, focused on fortifying the appropriate educational and social ideology within the coalition of northern philanthropic and southern middle-class school reformers. The second stage, 1901 to 1914, sought to spread the ideology beyond the borders of the coalition to obtain the allegiance of other major social groups. Modeled after the Lake Mohonk conferences on the Negro question, the first three annual meetings were private and informal, and no black persons were invited or permitted to attend. Noticeably absent also were members of northern missionary societies. The Capon Springs coalition, as Louis Harlan has demonstrated, was an intersectional partnership of white northern industrial philanthropists and white southern businessmen and middle-class professional educators. At the center of the philanthropic northerners were Robert C. Ogden, George Foster Peabody, and William H. Baldwin, Jr. Prominent members included Wallace Buttrick and two southerners transplanted to the North, J. L. M. Curry and Walter Hines Page. The southern contingent was headed by a group of North Carolina educational reformers. The key members were Charles Dabney, a University of North Carolina chemistry professor, later president of the University of Cincinnati; Charles D. Mclver, president of North Carolina Women's College and president of the Southern Educational Association; and Edwin A. Alderman, president of the University of North Carolina. Other southern members of this coalition
84
The Education of Blacks in the South
were Philander P. Claxton, later federal commissioner of education; Edgar Gardner Murphy, organizer of the Montgomery, Alabama, Conference on the Race Question; and Hollis B. Frissell, principal of Hampton Institute, a northerner transplanted to the South.5 The Capon Springs conferences provided an opportunity for philanthropic northerners and southern white educational reformers to rehearse their propaganda in friendly confines. Appropriately, Principal Frissell of Hampton Institute gave the opening address at the First Capon Springs Conference for Southern Education. He maintained that slavery had been a "civilizing" influence on the "barbarous Negroes" and recommended Hampton's model of industrial education as a system that would complete the "education" begun under slavery. J. L. M. Curry, recognized as the Horace Mann of southern educational reform, laid the groundwork for a racially qualified form of dominance and subordination in the South: "The white people are to be the leaders, to take the initiative, to have the directive control in all matters pertaining to civilization, and the highest interests of our beloved land." Still, when Curry spoke of universal education he had in mind common schooling for both blacks and whites, demonstrating that there was no inherent conflict between white supremacy and the advocacy of universal education. At the Second Capon Springs Conference, in 1899, William H. Baldwin, Jr., advised black southerners to accept racial subordination: "Avoid social questions; leave politics alone; continue to be patient; live moral lives; live simply; learn to work . . . know that it is a crime for any teacher, white or black, to educate the negro for positions which are not open to him." Baldwin also saw the Hampton-Tuskegee curriculum of industrial training as the only answer to the race problem. After three annual meetings the northern and southern participants in the Capon Springs conferences recognized that they shared beliefs in universal education, white supremacy, and black industrial training. They also held similar ideas regarding the promotion of public welfare, the training of laboring classes, industrialization, and the efficient organization of society. Having fortified their social and educational ideology from within, they were ready to take on the whole South.6 The regionwide southern education movement began in 1901 with a journey by Pullman train of influential and philanthropic northerners to North Carolina. This trip included a public meeting with Governor Charles B. Aycock, a white supremacist who supported the disfranchisement of black voters and universal education for all children. This meeting, the Fourth Conference for Education in the South, was the first of a series of annual organized forums. The enthusiastic group met at Winston-Salem, and the meetings, lasting through three days, were well attended. At this meeting the northern philanthropists gave the floor to
Education and the Race Problem
85
white southerners. Charles W. Dabney, then president of the University of Tennessee, declared that "the only solution of the southern problem is free public schools for all the people, blacks and whites alike, and compulsory-attendance laws." He spoke strongly for universal education for black children. "The negro is in the South to stay—he is a necessity for southern industries—and the southern people must educate and so elevate him or he will drag them down." But, cautioned Dabney, "We must use common sense in the education of the negro." Most important, "We must recognize in all its relations that momentous fact that the negro is a child race, at least two thousand years behind the Anglo-Saxon in its development." Blacks, said Dabney, must work out their salvation by practicing the industrial arts. Hence, "Nothing is more ridiculous than the programme of the good religious people from the North who insist upon teaching Latin, Greek, and philosophy to the negro boys who come to their schools." For Dabney, there was only one right way to educate black boys and girls: "General Armstrong, of Hampton, and Principal Washington, of Tuskegee, have worked out a sensible plan for the education of the negro. Our state schools for this race should be modeled after their plan." Similarly, George T. Winston, president of North Carolina's College of Agriculture and Mechanic Arts, advocated universal education and black industrial training. Winston argued that "the Old South was overthrown not by Webster and Greeley and Lincoln, but by the industrial inefficiency of Negro slavery." Therefore, the free black laboring class "must be taught to work, to submit to authority, to respect their superiors . . . the saw and plane and the anvil must take the place of geography." Winston believed that "the entire system of public education for the negro race, from top to bottom, should be industrial." He recommended that the Hampton-Tuskegee program be "duplicated in every southern state—if possible in each Congressional district." Such views were reinforced by Charles D. Mclver and G. R. Glenn, Georgia's state superintendent of education.7 White delegates from all over the region attended the Fourth Conference for Education in the South. The philanthropic northerners and southern white educators were generally satisfied with the manner in which their social and educational ideology was received by the southern delegates. Thus at the Winston-Salem meeting they decided to subsidize a regionwide public school campaign through the creation of two organizations, the Southern Education Board and the General Education Board. In his 1900-1901 annual report, the U.S. commissioner of education described the Southern Education Board as "an investigating and 'preaching' board for carrying on a propaganda of education" and the General Education Board as a foundation composed of businessmen, "to provide funds and to follow up and give effect to the work of the propa-
86
The Education of Blacks in the South
gandists." This was an accurate description of the distinct functions of the two boards. Louis Harlan has shown that "the Southern Education Board was a propaganda agency both in the South and the North." It was composed mostly of southern white educators, young men in their thirties and early forties, who "magnified the virtues of the dominant Northeast." This board had among its original members Robert C. Ogden, J. L. M. Curry, Edwin A. Alderman, Charles Dabney, Charles Mclver, Hollis B. Frissell, George Foster Peabody, William H. Baldwin, Jr., and Wallace Buttrick. The General Education Board also grew out of the Winston-Salem meeting. Ogden invited John D. Rockefeller, Jr., as a guest on the chartered Pullman train to the Fourth Conference for Education in the South. After visits to Hampton and Tuskegee Institutes and many discussions with educational reformers and philanthropists, the young Rockefeller became sufficiently impressed with the southern education movement to approach his father regarding financial contributions to the school campaigns. The senior Rockefeller responded by creating the General Education Board in i^oz. He gave an initial endowment of $i million, supplemented it by others amounting to $53 million in 1909, and by i9Zi had personally donated over $12.9 million to the General Education Board. Ogden, Peabody, Baldwin, Curry, and Buttrick, all original members of the Southern Education Board, were among the original trustees of the General Education Board. Besides this interlocking directorate, the Peabody Fund and Slater Fund acted largely through the General Education Board. Moreover, agents and supporters of the board directed other foundations established to aid southern educational reform, such as the Anna T. Jeanes Foundation and the PhelpsStokes Fund, created in 1907 and 1910 respectively. As Louis Harlan aptly stated, the General Education Board acquired "virtual monopolistic control of educational philanthropy for the South and the Negro."8 Significantly, the northern reformers who effectively shaped the policy and programs of the Southern Education Board and the General Education Board were originally involved in southern school reform through their nineteenth-century connections with Hampton and Tuskegee Institutes. Robert C. Ogden, the man chiefly responsible for bringing northern philanthropists and southern white educational reformers together, had helped to establish Hampton Institute in 1868. He was Hampton's most active trustee from 1874 to 1894, and from then until his death in 1913, he served as president of the board. Ogden's commitment to the Hampton program reflected his belief that industrial training was the appropriate form of schooling to assist in bringing racial order, political stability, and material prosperity to the American South. He considered Hampton's principal, Samuel C. Armstrong, "the clearest thinker upon Negro education and the race question generally" and viewed Hampton
Education and the Race Problem
87
as "one of the greatest successful educational experiments in the country." Hence Ogden labored from the early 18705 to obtain financial support for Hampton's industrial education program and to publicize the school's cause in northern philanthropic circles. His career as a wealthy merchant capitalist in New York City afforded him the opportunity to know important northern philanthropists, and his connections meant the addition of many new donors for Hampton and, later, Tuskegee Institute.9 By 1901, when the southern education movement was publicly launched, Ogden was generally recognized by northern philanthropists as the leading reformer interested in the development of southern education, and he soon gained the respect and confidence of southern white educational reformers. From 1901 to 1913 he championed the southern education movement through such powerful positions as president of the Conference for Education in the South, president of both the Southern Education Board and the General Education Board, and president of the Hampton and Tuskegee Institute boards of trustees. In 1906 Ogden was at once president of all five organizations and was ably situated to project the Hampton-Tuskegee program of industrial training into national prominence and favor.10 Second only to Ogden in influencing northern philanthropists and southern educational reformers was George Foster Peabody, a wealthy Wall Street banker. He was a full partner in the banking firm of Spencer Trask and Company. As an investment banker with special expertise in railroads and public utilities securities, Peabody worked closely with many of America's wealthy men. He was also very active in politics. In 1904 he was treasurer of the National Democratic Party Committee, and in 1912. he campaigned for Woodrow Wilson's presidential nomination. Wilson offered him the position of secretary of the treasury in 1913, but Peabody declined, maintaining that he could perform greater public service outside of political office. In 1914, however, he accepted appointment as deputy chairman of the New York Federal Reserve Bank.11 Peabody, like Ogden, became actively involved in southern education through Hampton Institute. His interest in black industrial education surfaced as early as 1876, when he became impressed with the Hampton program through contact with Samuel Armstrong. Ogden influenced Peabody to join the Hampton Board of Trustees in 1884. Peabody also viewed the Hampton program as the solution to the southern race problem and contributed his investment banking skills toward placing Hampton and Tuskegee on a solid economic foundation. He served briefly as Hampton's treasurer and a longer tenure as financial manager on Hampton's and Tuskegee's investment and endowment committees. Like Ogden, he succeeded in arousing a great deal of enthusiasm among
88
The Education of Blacks in the South
northern millionaires for the Hampton-Tuskegee pattern of industrial education. In the 192,05 he helped spearhead a successful campaign to raise $8 million for Hampton and Tuskegee Institutes. The money he secured to expand the Hampton-Tuskegee model of industrial education came largely from northern millionaires such as William E. Dodge, Collis P. Huntington, John D. Rockefeller, and George Eastman, who had come to trust Peabody's judgment on southern educational matters. Peabody, a key founder of the Southern Education Board and the General Education Board, served as treasurer of the former from 1901 to 1914 and of the latter from i9oz to 1909. In vital respects, he was the investment banker of the southern education movement." William H. Baldwin, Jr., a railroad entrepreneur who employed thousands of black laborers, was the third leading reformer who significantly shaped the direction of the southern education movement. Born in Boston on 5 February 1863, he was educated in the city's public schools and the Roxbury Latin School and graduated from Harvard in 1885. After one year in Harvard's law school Baldwin entered the railroad business under the tutelage of Charles Francis Adams. He rose rapidly in the railroad industry and was appointed vice-president and general manager of J. P. Morgan's Southern Railway Company in 1894. Baldwin became a trustee of Tuskegee Institute the same year and, until his premature death in 1905, worked closely with Booker T. Washington in advancing the growth of that institution. Baldwin went south as an agent of northern capital to take charge of the region's railroads. The centrality of black labor in the railroad industry compelled him to consider the Negro's place in the southern social economy. Like Ogden and Peabody, he became convinced that the Hampton program represented the solution to the "Negro problem," and he used his connections among northern capitalists and southern whites to spread the influence of Hampton and Tuskegee. Baldwin's advocacy of the Hampton Idea meant literally thousands of dollars for black industrial education. As an original trustee of the Southern Education Board and first president of the General Education Board he played a major role in committing northern philanthropy to black industrial education.13 The philanthropists were particularly interested in the role of black workers in the southern agricultural economy and the relationship of that economy to the emergent urban-industrial nation. Their interest in black industrial education was not merely or primarily a rationalization for personal economic gains, but the reformers' own investment in Negro cotton tenancy revealed that for them economic and educational concerns fused as part of their broader vision of southern development. The philanthropists were similar to other twentieth-century northern ur-
Education and the Race Problem
89
banites who "demanded an organized and efficient agricultural sector to supplement the emergent industrial nation." Their concern for southern agricultural prosperity was inextricably bound to a consideration of black farm workers, especially in a period of declining rural population and rapid urban growth. "Our great problem," said Ogden, "is to attach the Negro to the soil and prevent his exodus from the country to the city." In Ogden's view, "The prosperity of the South depend[ed] upon the productive power of the black man." He embraced the Hampton model of black industrial education as a vehicle to hold blacks to southern rural society, stating specifically that Tuskegee's "first and large work" was in the area of "industrial leadership, especially in Agriculture." "The purpose of the Hampton school," said Ogden, "is to furnish district school teachers, well equipped with all the necessary knowledge of domestic science for practical missionary work among the colored people." He believed that the Hampton-Tuskegee program would help fit blacks into the southern agricultural economy as wage laborers, sharecroppers, and domestic workers. Indeed, this was the function of the black school maintained by the Southern Improvement Company, the corporation that owned the philanthropists' cotton plantation of which Ogden was a major stockholder.14 Like Ogden, northern philanthropist George Peabody endeavored to convince his southern countrymen that the Hampton-Tuskegee program could help build a strong southern economy on the backs of submissive, nonpolitical, cheap black laborers. Convinced that industrial training would "help the Negro fit his environment," Peabody used his influence to impress upon white southern businessmen the idea of an inseparable relation between black education and the region's material prosperity. "I believe that the South needs their [blacks'] labor and would be practically bankrupt without it," he argued. Thus he informed a prominent Georgia planter and politician that industrially trained black laborers would primarily benefit white investors: Have you the least doubt but that if the one million Negroes, constituting nearly one-half of the men, women and children of Georgia were rightly educated to the development of their bodily health and strength and facilities and of the application of the same, which means their minds trained, to have their arms and legs work promptly and accurately in coordination, their moral apprehension rightly trained to know and do the right and avoid the wrong, and their affectional nature encouraged to love and not hate their white neighbors, and to respect and honor their own sexual purity, that they would be worth in dollars and cents to the state of Georgia
90
The Education of Blacks in the South
more than three times their present value. If this be true, as I am positively sure that it is, and as the property of the State of Georgia is so largely owned by the white race, would not the gain to the white race, under present methods of distribution, be most incalculable in dollars and cents.15 Peabody used his connections to sell the Hampton Idea to the nation's leaders. In 1918 he wrote to invite his friend President Woodrow Wilson to make the keynote address at Hampton's fiftieth anniversary celebration. Based on his "long and wide experience" in southern education, Peabody explained to Wilson the importance of the Hampton program to the South's cotton production. "One-ninth of our population is of Negro blood, and the prosperity of the South and the world's supply of cotton are intimately bound up with the development of the Hampton Idea of 'Education for Life,'" he wrote Wilson. Peabody believed that black people's role in the South was primarily in agricultural labor, and he advocated the Hampton model of industrial education to train them for that function.16 Baldwin, more than the other reformers, elaborated the philanthropic vision of black workers' role in regional and national economic development. In 1899, at the Second Conference for Education in the South, he spoke about the "great black stratum of human beings, with human intelligence, who can be directed to produce infinite wealth for the South." Baldwin, who entered the South to organize the Southern Railroad, remained acutely aware of the region's cotton mills and their relationship to increased industrialization. Likewise, he recognized the centrality of black farm workers to the cotton industry, and this concern also underlaid his interest in the Hampton-Tuskegee program. As he wrote to southern historian John Spencer Bassett, "I agree with you, also, that the high price of cotton is going to have a great effect upon the southern white people. I feel sure with you that the reaction has begun, and that the economic value of the Negro is going to prove his salvation. It is for this reason that I have always been so much interested in industrial education." To spread black industrial education, Baldwin urged northern and southern whites "to build up a secondary school system under the general control and supervision of Hampton and Tuskegee."17 Baldwin also viewed black laborers as a potential force to protect the South's economy against the onslaught of unionized labor. He believed that the industrial nations would ultimately engage in economic warfare and the prospects of an American victory depended significantly on the nation's ability to assemble quickly a nonunionized, cheap, efficient laboring class. To Baldwin, the South was fortunate because black workers
Education and the Race Problem
91
could be used to break the power of white labor unions. As he wrote to the southern white industrialist N. F. Thompson: The union of white labor, well organized, will raise the wages beyond a reasonable point, and then the battle will be fought, and the Negro will be put in at a less wage, and the labor union will either have to come down in wages, or Negro labor will be employed. The last analysis is the employment of Negro labor in the various arts and trades of the South, but this will not be a clearly defined issue until your competition in the markets of the world will force you to compete with cheap labor in other countries. . . . I believe, as a last analysis, the strength of the South in its competition with other producing nations will lie in the labor of the now despised Negro, and that he is destined to continue to wait for that time. For this and similar reasons, he struggled to keep black workers in the South by offering them an education that would adapt them to their "natural environment" of unskilled and semiskilled labor and preclude them from pursuing skilled and professional occupations. He praised Tuskegee because there black students were "educated for their environment and not out of it."18 Other philanthropists also made it abundantly clear that white industrialists and landowners were to be the main beneficiaries of black industrial training. In 1904 the Armstrong Association of New York City held a conference to discuss the work of Hampton Institute and "the bearing of industrial education on race problems at the South." Andrew Carnegie, who had given Tuskegee its first major endowment in 1903, spoke on the economic necessity of training southern black workers: We cannot produce cotton enough for the wants of the world. We should be in the position in which South Africa is today but for the faithful, placable, peaceful, industrious, lovable colored man; for industrious and peaceful he is compared with any other body of colored men on the earth—not up to the standard of the colder North in continuous effort, but far in advance of any corresponding class anywhere. South Africa has just had to admit contracted Chinese labor, although there are between five and six million of colored people there who will not work. We should be in the same condition but for our colored people, who constitute one of the most valuable assets of the Republic, viewed from an economic standpoint. It is certain we must grow more cotton to meet the demands of the world, or endanger our practical monopoly of that indispensable article. Either the efforts of Europe will be successful
92
The Education of Blacks in the South
to grow in other parts, even at greater cost for a time, or the world will learn to substitute something else for it. We cannot afford to lose the Negro. We have urgent need of all and of more. Let us therefore turn our efforts to making the best of him. James Hardy Dillard, the Tulane University president who became general agent of the Slater Fund, was similarly impressed with the economic potential of an industrially trained black citizenry. "We of the South," he informed the Southern Educational Association in 1908, "cannot afford to have in our midst any mass of ignorance, and it is to our interest in every way to train the Negroes to thrift and intelligent industry. It will pay us in material advancement." Walter Hines Page, editor of the Atlantic Monthly and trustee of the Southern Education Board, said: "I have no sentimental stuff in me about the Negro, but I have a lot of economic stuff in me about the necessity of training him." Similarly, the Tuskegee Institute trustee from New York City declared that black industrial education was not only "good business especially for the South, but good business for the entire country."19 Thus historians have revealed only a half-truth in arguing that it was the white South that insisted on a second-class education to prepare blacks for subordinate roles in the southern economy. The northern philanthropists insisted on the same. White supremacists themselves, northern reformers were not perturbed by the southern racism per se. They also viewed black Americans as an inferior and childlike people. Peabody maintained that black people were "children in mental capacity." Likewise, Southern Education Board and General Education Board trustee Wallace Buttrick said: "I recognize the fact that the Negro is an inferior race and that the Anglo-Saxon is the superior race." Ogden also spoke of the black man's "childish characteristics" and argued that blacks were thriftless, careless, shiftless, and idle by disposition. Hence he believed that the Hampton program was good for blacks all over the nation. "I have many times thought that a school of domestic training for colored people in New York City would be of immense advantage, and in certain ways I have had the opportunity to promote the idea in a practical fashion in this city," wrote Ogden in 1903. "The English, Irish, French and Swiss," he continued, "are holding places in domestic service in this city that would naturally belong to the colored people, but the latter are distanced in the competition because of ignorance and easy-going ways." These philanthropists also shared the white southern belief in Negro disfranchisement, even though they opposed movements to repeal the Fifteenth Amendment. As Baldwin, for example, put it, "It seems to me perfectly ridiculous to discuss the question of repealing the XV Amendment. I have always said that it was from many points of view an abso-
Education and the Race Problem
93
Tuskegee's twenty-fifth anniversary was celebrated in part by inscribing the names of key northern industrial philanthropists and political supporters on the institute's lawn. Courtesy of the Library of Congress.
Tuskegee students serve a gathering of the school's white donors and supporters in 1906. This segregated dining on Tuskegee's campus was in keeping with Washington's declaration, "In all things that are purely social we can be as separate as the fingers, yet one as the hand in all things essential to mutual progress." Courtesy of the Library of Congress.
94
The Education of Blacks in the South
lute mistake in the beginning; but for political and other reasons it is ridiculous to talk about repealing it." Clearly, Baldwin put greater stress on his view that any argument to repeal the amendment was impolitic than he did on its injustice. This was consistent with his advice to blacks to "leave politics alone." Both in their public utterances and private correspondence, the philanthropists consented willingly to southern efforts to disfranchise black voters, as long as such efforts stopped short of attempts to repeal the Fifteenth Amendment. Some white southern leaders, particularly the "progressive" industrialists of the urban South, found virtually no conflict between their own political and economic views and those of the philanthropists. Thus the philanthropists were not a group of antiracist, democratic northerners challenging southern racism by goodwill, tact, and hard work. Rather, white superiority seems to have been one of the few things upon which virtually all of the northern philanthropists and white southerners agreed. The common belief of whites that black human beings were inherently less capable and less worthy, however, did not assure agreement on other important social questions, particularly the role of universal schooling in southern society.i0 Though the philanthropists obtained support from some of the South's prominent and influential white leaders, the southern white majority and many of its spokesmen were opposed to the southern education movement. Southern opposition to Yankee reform, taxes for education, compulsory school attendance bills, and Negro schooling was voiced by backcountry demagogues, state school superintendents, politicians, industrial capitalists, periodical and newspaper editors, and men in high academic positions. When efforts were made to institute practical educational reforms at the state level, southern resistance was sharp, and what the philanthropists defined as educational and social improvement seldom corresponded to most southerners' definitions of those terms. Among other things, many white southerners resented the northern philanthropic movement as an encroachment upon regional initiative, pride, and independence. Led by the Charleston News and Courier, the Charlotte Observer, and the powerful Manufacturer's Record, the unregenerate southern press excoriated the philanthropic movement as an "insidious attack upon the high spirit of the southern white man." The Memphis Commercial Appeal greeted the northern reformers with the comment: "All that the South asks is that the North will mind its own business and keep its missions to itself." Georgia's Governor Allen D. Candler, who attempted in 1898 to cut his state's meager school fund in half, informed the philanthropists in 1901 that "we can attend to the education of the darky in the South without the aid of these yankees." Richard H. Edmonds, a southern businessman of supreme importance
Education and the Race Problem
95
and editor of the influential Manufacturer's Record, waged the most systematic and sustained attack against philanthropic "meddling" in southern educational affairs. Edmonds and other writers in the Manufacturer's Record inveighed against the "southern education scheme" charging that it eroded southern initiative and self-reliance. "The South needs no outside help in the development of its educational system," said the Manufacturer's Record, "and the acceptance of such help means the loss of manliness and strength of character." The weekly also argued that state pride would suffer "as no man can feel a pride and claim an interest in educational institutions and schemes fostered and dominated by foreign factors." The Manufacturer's Record urged the South to "develop and maintain its schools from funds derived from state taxation and contributions from southern philanthropists." During the early stages of the southern education movement the paper frequently warned the South of the North's "patronizing educational scheme."11 Many southern leaders misread the northern-based school reform movement as a subversive scheme to achieve "social equality" for the region's black citizens. Newspaper headlines read: "Millions to Teach Negroes," "Uplifting Dark Races," "Two Races Occupied the Same Gallery," and the like. Philanthropists Robert C. Ogden and Walter H. Page were attacked for promoting social and educational equality. Ogden, receiving the brunt of southern resentment for his close association with Booker T. Washington, was labeled a "Negrophile" for escorting Washington through New York City's Wanamaker clothing store. Thomas Dixon, author of The Clansman, a bitter indictment of the black race, was the prime mover behind the stories on Ogden. Dixon wrote that Ogden, a "Negro worshipper, pure and simple . . . conducts the only first-class restaurant in the metropolis where a big, buck Negro is allowed to seat himself with a white man's wife and daughter." The Manufacturer's Record, clearly misrepresenting the aims of the southern education movement, contended that the philanthropists ultimately wanted blacks and whites to be "taught in the same schools" and warned that no "tendency to a mingling of the races in the common schools shall be permitted in the South."" The white southern leaders were especially fearful that northern philanthropists would make the blacks discontent with the political and economic roles accorded them in southern society. The New Orleans Picayune, with good logic, charged that "just as soon as all the Negroes in the State shall be able to read and write they will become qualified to vote, and it is not to be doubted that they will demand their rights in the primaries with the i4th Amendment to back them up." Similarly, the Charleston News and Courier viewed the philanthropic movement as an attempt to educate the Negro "so that in time he shall become a political
96
The Education of Blacks in the South
factor in the administration of the affairs of the South." From the vantage point of the southern white majority, any system of universal education for blacks, even industrial education, would potentially lead to universal suffrage. South Carolina's senator Ben Tillman argued that education would qualify blacks to vote and potential black voters would "bring strife by trying to regain political power." Many white landowners opposed black schooling on economic grounds because they believed that reading, writing, and arithmetic would make black workers discontented with unskilled and semiskilled farm labor. In 1905, the North Carolina state labor commissioner conducted an opinion poll among the state's white farmers on the question of compulsory school attendance. The commissioner reported that nine-tenths of the farmers preferred "a compulsory system if it applied only to the white race, but they do not desire it to apply to Negroes as they contend that educated Negroes, in nearly all cases, become valueless as farm laborers." A Virginia landowner put the question frankly: "If we educate the Negro out of being a laborer, who is going to take his place?" Many southern white employers clamored for an illiterate, tractable black work force, one with low socioeconomic aspirations, and one that avoided political activity and labor unions. A North Carolina mill owner asserted that it was necessary to maintain a "large number of illiterate people to perform the labors of the country." Compulsory education, said A. F. Johnson, chairman of the Board of Education of Sampson County, North Carolina, "may be fatal to the cotton crop," which depended "upon the labor of children for pickers." The millionaire Georgia landowner Colonel James Smith maintained that his own success with illiterate black workers proved that they needed no education to be satisfactory farm laborers. Governor Robert Glenn of North Carolina stated in 1905 that the education of black children had been "a flat failure."13 By 1900, in Virginia, belief in the practical destruction of black schools and the view that black education had caused a serious breakdown in race relations had won the approbation of many leading white men. Professor Richard H. Dabney of the University of Virginia declared it foolish for the state to tax itself for the education of the black citizens it sought to disfranchise. Paul B. Barringer, chairman of the faculty of the University of Virginia, addressing the tenth annual meeting of the Southern Educational Association in 1900, charged that black southerners had used their education "as a weapon of political offense" against white southerners. "Any education will be used by the Negro politically; for politics, once successful, is now an instinctive form of warfare," he explained. Barringer argued that "whites should cease to support free schools for the blacks" because "the schools tended to make some negroes idle and vicious" and "others able to compete with the whites."
Education and the Race Problem
97
The Richmond Dispatch editorialized that black education had been "a failure and a blunder," a waste of tax dollars, a needless expense that made "hotbeds of arrogance and aggression" out of black schools. Besides, the paper noted bluntly, "Many families distinctly prefer nurses and cooks who cannot read and write." Such themes were repeated endlessly at the turn of the century. "When they learn to spell dog and cat they throw away the hoe," complained Virginia's Farmville Herald. Virginia's state superintendent of education, Joseph W. Southall, was reported to have said that "negro education is a failure." All such views were effectively summed up by a white citizen of Richmond, John S. Curtis, who declared that he was in favor of "giving the white child all the education possible, and the black child as little as possible." With opposition to universal education for black children emanating from such prominent white southerners, the philanthropists and school reformers realized that they had encountered a different and contradictory conception of the proper relationship between formal schooling and social development.*4 The philanthropists were disillusioned by the South's "failure" to comprehend the social and economic "advantages" of industrially trained laboring classes. Concentrating largely on the political and social implications of an educated black laboring class, many white southern politicians and school superintendents often made no significant distinctions between black industrial and academic schooling. In fact, nearly all of the black common schools and the few public high schools supported by public taxation in the South were academic institutions, and none of them were modeled after the Hampton program. The philanthropists recognized and were baffled by the South's lack of enthusiasm for black industrial training. As Peabody complained to a prominent Georgia attorney: "Probably not 5 percent of this southern expenditure for Negro education goes to industrial education to help the Negro fit his environment. The remaining 95 percent is wasted in so-called academic education." The philanthropists were particularly perturbed by the white South's occasional hostility to the Hampton-Tuskegee program. In 1904 Edgar Gardner Murphy, vice-president of the Conference for Education in the South, informed Ogden that "the demagogue is abroad." "I have never seen so much sentiment against the Negro; Tuskegee and Mr. Washington were never so intensely unpopular." The northern reformers could not understand most white southerners' educational ideology. The northerners were convinced that majority opinion in the South was shaped by emotionalism and political demagoguery rather than by enlightened self-interest. Ogden believed that southern whites were "insane upon the Negro question" and that such insanity prevented them from organizing their social and economic institutions to their own benefit.
98
The Education of Blacks in the South
No southern politician, said Baldwin, would dare have his platform read "Free education for the white man and the Negro," because "the politician, who has always represented the southern leadership, has always played the demagogue and depended almost entirely upon arguments against the Negro in order to gain the popular, good will." Although some southern politicians, such as North Carolina's Governor Charles Aycock, did stand for universal education for both races, the philanthropists could comprehend the deep southern resistance to public schooling for blacks only as a form of political demagoguery.2'5 The southern white opponents of universal schooling were not as emotional or irrational as the philanthropic reformers charged. In fact, they grasped firmly the peculiar nature of their oppressive social order and understood better than the philanthropic northerners what was required to hold it intact. Two characteristics of their opposition evidenced their good insights into the complications of southern society. First, the major concerns reflected constantly in the opposition to universal education were fears of political instability and increased competition between black and white laborers. Second, the opposition to universal education for all children came largely from the states of Virginia, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Florida, Mississippi, and Louisiana. In this context, education was viewed as a two-edged sword. The same instructional process that taught the children of illiterate farm workers to read and write about industrial arts also enabled them to read and sign their names to voting ballots. In these states the majority of the agricultural workers were black, ranging from a low of 40 percent in Virginia to a high of 69 percent in Mississippi. In the same states the black populations ranged from 4Z percent of the total in Virginia to 60 percent in South Carolina. Was it possible, in the name of greater industrial efficiency, to make these black populations literate and simultaneously exclude them from voting? And would not their disfranchisement if they were literate require an even greater use of force? White southerners, particularly in these states, feared that increased literacy among black citizens would only add to the latter's demand for equal political rights. In contrast, the educational reformers argued that white dominance could best be maintained by educating blacks to accept or internalize the idea that white southerners had some legitimate right to rule over them. From the reformers' standpoint, the right universal schooling could influence black children to accept the values embodied in the Hampton Idea, so that in time black southerners would acknowledge the legitimacy of the South's racial caste system and submit willingly to its order. White southerners who encountered black southerners daily had good reasons to doubt that blacks were that pliable. The northern philanthropists failed to grasp the fundamental differ-
Education and the Race Problem
99
ence between their society based on class stratification and southern society based on a racially qualified form of the more general subordination of the laboring class. Racism was rampant in both societies, but the organized structures of domination and subordination differed in form and content. The principle of one-man-one-vote held no significant racial implications in New York, where the philanthropists lived, but in South Carolina, where Ben Tillman lived, it meant, theoretically, black control of the state. Hence in South Carolina, as elsewhere in the South, whites stressed coercion as the only safe means of keeping blacks in "their place." They knew that blacks as a class had never submitted willingly to racist oppression or acknowledged the legitimacy of whites to rule over them. Most white southerners, therefore, were naturally suspicious of the philanthropists' claim that blacks could be formally schooled to accept subordinate social and economic roles. Consequently, black education became the ideological medium of conflict between southern whites' wishes for the preservation of traditional, coercive methods of subordination and the educational reformers' demands for modern, subtle forms of social control. The southern white opposition to universal education for both races was tied to entrenched social values, and it especially frustrated the philanthropic northerners.16 The northern reformers, however, were inspired by what Baldwin perceived as the "new leaders of southern thought," who were "gradually shaping a new and enlightened public opinion." These new leaders, prominent middle-class professionals who committed themselves to universal education and pledged their support to expanding the HamptonTuskegee pattern of black education, included Alderman, Dabney, Aycock, Claxton, Mclver, Murphy, and Walter B. Hill. They articulated the interests of many commercial-minded southerners who aligned themselves with the urban-industrial North and who were determined to proselytize their unregenerate countrymen to northern standards of economic efficiency and social organization. These men understood the educational reform movement largely from the vantage point of the philanthropists. Hill made his first visit to Hampton in 1905 with Peabody as his "guide, philosopher and friend." "I was greatly impressed with the excellence of the Hampton work," wrote Hill to Ogden, "certainly I know of no other place where education is so immediately related to life." Convinced of the social and economic necessity of schooling the entire southern population, these men campaigned, as Murphy put it, "to know and to work with one another, in order that the better [white] sentiment may gain organization and expression." Through such southern leaders the philanthropists organized state campaigns for compulsory school attendance laws, to legalize taxation for public education, and to arouse public opinion in favor of the Hampton Idea.17
ioo
The Education of Blacks in the South
Although southern white resistance to philanthropic intervention was powerful, northern reformers found significant white support for their school campaign. Against the early attacks by papers such as the Charleston News and Courier and the Manufacturer's Record, the philanthropists found powerful advocates in the Atlanta Constitution, Nashville Banner, Birmingham News, Richmond Times, Raleigh News and Observer, and the State of Columbia, South Carolina. The reformers were also able to establish alliances with some of the region's businessmen and politicians. Upon hearing criticism of the philanthropic movement, Congressman John H. Small of Alabama assured Ogden that "the best sentiment and the best people, those who stand for the best ideals, are with you in this good work." Similarly, T. G. Bush, president of the Mobile and Birmingham Railroad Company, welcomed the philanthropists to Birmingham, Alabama, for their 1904 conference. Another southern white businessman, Belton Gilreath, president of the American Coal Corporation and of the Gilreath Coal and Iron Company, shared the reformers' view of black education. Gilreath, a Tuskegee Institute trustee who employed many black laborers in his coal mines, believed that an industrially trained black working class meant "so much to the future wealth and improved social and industrial conditions of every part of our country where the colored man is to dwell." As he expressed in a letter to Principal Frissell of Hampton Institute, Gilreath worked to obtain southern businessmen's support for the Hampton model of black education: I was especially anxious for the businessmen of Birmingham to meet you, and also the large corporate interests, because I feel that the industrial work which you are doing at Hampton, and through the government at Washington, and Tuskegee, which is the outcome of Hampton, is not as fully known at present by the businessmen as it ought to be. Its bearing on our commercial interests and the reflex benefit which we derive in other ways is manifest to my mind, and I think is going to be more fully appreciated in the near future than ever before by our people generally. Gilreath's belief in universal schooling for blacks was shared by Birmingham's school superintendent, John Herbert Phillips. Reflecting the educational views of the South's growing number of urban white industrialists, Phillips believed that the "enlightened selfishness" of white southerners, as well as their sense of duty, should lead them to provide public schooling for black children. The philanthropists and school reformers found solid support among the region's few progressive urban school administrators. But the South was largely rural, and out in the countryside local
Education and the Race Problem
101
governments were dominated by planters who resisted investment in black education.i8 During the southern education movement, 1901—15, the region resisted educational reforms in the Negro's behalf. Virginia's state political machine, because of its peculiar dependence on railroads and other outside corporations for campaign funds, stressed low taxation and fought against public school appropriations for whites and especially for blacks. The white majority in South Carolina stood solidly against expanding public education for blacks, and the Charleston News and Courier, which articulated the interests of the city's capitalists, opposed the compulsory attendance bill of 1900. Even the supporters of compulsory school attendance carefully assured the state that local white officials could exclude blacks from the compulsory school law. North Carolina whites opposed taxation for black schools, and white Georgians generally viewed the "educational awakening" as either Yankee meddling in southern affairs, a cause of high taxation, or a scheme to promote racial equality. Georgia did not pass its compulsory school attendance bill until 1916, and it still allowed local school boards to exempt black children from the law. Southern opposition was further reflected in the meager financial support that the region gave to black education. And it made no difference whether the advocates of black schooling presented themselves as industrial or classical liberal educators. Baldwin, to no avail, informed Edmonds of the Manufacturer's Record that northern reformers approached southern education "without sentiment" and were interested in it "only as a great economic sociological question." To the Raleigh Morning Post, Baldwin insisted that "the Negro should be taught to work, to work at the trades and in the fields, and a common school education along with their work is not only unharmful but a great benefit to them [and] to their employers." The dominant white South could agree that blacks should be trained to work efficiently in the fields, but it did not see the necessity of sending them to school for that, especially inasmuch as they had performed such tasks for centuries without any schooling. Decades later the South would appreciate more fully the socializing power of public education, but in the early twentieth century the region presented the reformers with a strong rival ideology that virtually assured the retardation of the philanthropists' black industrial education program. Louis Harlan concluded that the Southern Education Board "had almost no effect on the Negro schools."19 "With southern prejudice on the one hand and Negro suspicion on the other, we have a delicate course to steer," wrote Ogden to Baldwin in 1903. To expand the Hampton program the industrial philanthropists had to fight on two major fronts. In an effort to obtain more economic
IO2.
The Education of Blacks in the South
and political support for universal schooling in the South, they were compelled to struggle with the region's white leadership. The southern white leadership, on balance, insisted that any large-scale expansion of black education, even industrial education, would set in motion a revolution in race relations that would undermine the South's existing political and economic arrangements. The philanthropists, however, won considerable support among the commercial-minded editors and educators who pushed for a southern alliance with the industrial Northeast. On the other front, the reformers fought to obtain the allegiance of the leading Afro-American intellectuals in an effort to persuade the black community to acknowledge the legitimacy of the Hampton-Tuskegee program. In this endeavor, as with the white South, the philanthropists faced a formidable intelligentsia that, for radically different reasons, opposed the Hampton-Tuskegee philosophy. Many black intellectuals and leaders recognized that the Hampton-Tuskegee program was essentially an educational blueprint for black subordination. In 1904 Ogden correctly noted that "the so-called 'educated' Negroes are more violent than the southern people" in their criticisms of the southern education movement.30 To the northern philanthropists, Booker T. Washington loomed as the indispensable agent in their struggle to obtain the support of black intellectuals and leaders. Washington entered Hampton in 1872 aspiring to become a lawyer before Armstrong persuaded him to spend his life spreading the Hampton doctrine. In Armstrong's words, Washington was "the best man we ever had here." Thus in 1881 when Armstrong received a letter from Alabama state commissioners requesting a principal for the newly authorized black normal school at Tuskegee, he enthusiastically recommended Washington. From this post Washington worked closely with northern philanthropists, and following Armstrong's death in 1893, he became the chief spokesman for the HamptonTuskegee Idea. Washington fully embraced Armstrong's philosophy of racial progress, which urged Afro-Americans to remain in the South and seek their fortune, primarily in common agricultural and domestic labor. He asserted frequently that blacks had "a better chance in the South than in the North" for economic progress. He also argued that in the southern economy "the Negro is given almost as good an opportunity to rise as is given to the white man." Believing that black workers could control southern agricultural and domestic labor, Washington advocated a paternalistic relationship between them and white employers in which "the material and business interests in the southern communities would become so linked together, so interlaced, that instead of strife there would become peace and union." To prevent racial strife, Washington, like Armstrong, discouraged blacks from voting, running for political office,
Education and the Race Problem
103
and pursuing civil equality. In short, Washington's endorsement of the southern racial hierarchy and black industrial training was consistent with the basic premises of the Hampton Idea.31 A key factor in Washington's rise to fame was the support of industrial philanthropists, who virtually developed Tuskegee Institute and played the central role in projecting Washington onto the national scene as the new leader of the black race. Through their influence Booker T. Washington and the Hampton-Tuskegee Idea were heavily advertised in national periodicals and magazines during the late nineteenth century. Washington knew full well that Tuskegee would quickly fall were it not for the philanthropists' political and economic support. In 1899 Baldwin was the leading figure in obtaining for Tuskegee twenty-five thousand acres of land through special acts of the United States Congress and the Alabama state legislature. Baldwin then established the Tuskegee Committee on Investment of Endowment Fund with himself as chairman, along with Ogden, Peabody, and J. G. Phelps-Stokes as members. He was also the key person in securing Tuskegee's first significant endowment of $600,000, a gift from Andrew Carnegie in 1903. And when he became chairman of the General Education Board in 1902., Baldwin used his position to provide funds for Tuskegee's annual operating expenses.31 Washington's address at the Atlanta Exposition on 18 September 1895 set in motion the ideological struggle between the industrial philanthropists and the black intelligentsia to determine the social purpose of training Afro-American leaders and teachers. As Washington apprehensively faced the southern white audience inside the Exposition Hall, Baldwin paraded nervously around the building anticipating the outcome. In Washington's words: "When I delivered my address at the opening of the Atlanta Exposition in 1895, Mr. Baldwin was in Atlanta, and on the Exposition grounds, but he was not in the building when I spoke. He was so much concerned as to the impression that my address would make upon the audience that, during the entire opening exercises, he walked nervously around the building, waiting impatiently for the close of the exercises, to hear the verdict of those who had listened to my remarks." Washington, Baldwin, and other philanthropists were pleased with the northern and southern white response to the "Atlanta Compromise," but they were not satisfied with the divided black response. In December 1895, the Christian Recorder printed an article by C. H. Taylor challenging Washington's philosophy. Taylor, who had recently read the Philadelphia Standard-Echo's editorial, "Is Booker T. Washington Correct?," replied that it was shameful for a Negro to stand up and "make a willing surrender" to southern racism. "What the Negro desires today," said Taylor, "is a Moses who will not lead him to the plow, for he knows the way there, but who will lead him to the point in this country where he
104
The Education of Blacks in the South
can get all his manhood rights under the Constitution." Five months after the young black educator John Hope heard Washington speak at the Atlanta Exposition, he told a Nashville audience that it was "cowardly and dishonest for any of our colored men to tell white people or colored people that we are not struggling for equality." Such black resistance to Washington's program constantly gained support, waxing stronger with each passing year. The Philadelphia Tribune, which was sympathetic to Washington, reported in 1899 that some black leaders were denouncing Washington as a "traitor" to his race. According to the Tribune, "Booker T. Washington, the famous Negro educator, was roundly criticized at the Afro-American Convention recently assembled at Chicago." By 1899, Washington and the philanthropists realized that they could not easily sell the Hampton Idea to black educators and leaders. Hence they entered the twentieth century prepared to struggle for ideological control of the black intelligentsia.33 Washington's training and essential character did not prepare him well for the struggle to gain the allegiance of black intellectuals and leaders. He was not an intellectual and was much more a man of action than an ideologue. Yet his advocacy of a special form of industrial education for Afro-Americans and the political and moral underpinnings of his educational program compelled him to engage forthrightly in a national debate about the appropriate schooling for black children. Washington's educational program, as much as that of his opponents, depended primarily on his ability to persuade the emergent black intellectual or leadership class to propagate and implement a particular social and educational gospel. Hence, despite Washington's concerns about industrial education for the masses, in actuality both he and DuBois were seeking to educate, organize, and direct the same segment of Afro-America, the "talented tenth" or the black intelligentsia. Had DuBois advocated higher education for the few and Washington merely proposed industrial education for the masses, a compromise might have been feasible. Indeed, at the 1904 "Washington-DuBois" conference, DuBois stood on a platform of "higher education of selected youths" and "industrial education for the masses." Both Washington and DuBois, however, looked primarily to the "selected youth" (prospective teachers, editors, ministers, and businessmen) to guide the race's social development. DuBois, of course, stated boldly his interest in the "talented tenth" whereas Washington often kept in the background his central concern with training prospective race leaders. Yet, as Washington explained in 1895, leadership training was the one thing that schools like Tuskegee promised to do well: "It is not a practical thing for the North to educate directly all the Negroes in the South, but it is a perfectly practical and possible thing for the North to help the South to educate the leaders, who in turn will go
Education and the Race Problem
105
and reach the masses and show them how to lift themselves up." The philanthropists also viewed Tuskegee as a training center for the black leadership class. As Ogden put it, "The education is too costly to be expended upon the production of domestic servants, and the purpose of the Institution is to supply strong characters well equipped for practical work . . . to go out as leaders among their people." Whatever the secondary concerns of DuBois, the philanthropists, and Washington, they were all concerned primarily with the training of black teachers and leaders and the ideological persuasion of that class. For the exceptional persons to guide the race, DuBois looked to colleges like Atlanta to produce egalitarian social critics and Washington looked to industrial normal schools like Tuskegee to produce leaders who would endorse and advance the Hampton Idea.34 The conflict thus became increasingly bitter as the two camps struggled for the allegiance of the very small sphere of black youth who attended normal schools, secondary schools, and colleges. Led by William Monroe Trotter, the fiery editor of the Boston Guardian, a significant and influential segment of the black intelligentsia opened the twentieth century with a heated attack on the Hampton-Tuskegee Idea. Trotter bitterly opposed the Hampton-Tuskegee program because "the idea lying back of it is the relegating of a race to serfdom." He insisted that whites generally supported the program because of their belief in the innate mental inferiority of Negroes. Trotter was particularly critical of Washington. "It is bad enough to be enslaved by white men," he said, "without being put under thraldom to a Negro." In i9oz, when Washington's daughter Portia had flunked out of Wellesley College, Trotter contended that her misfortune was consistent with her father's "antipathy to anything higher than the three Rs for his 'people.' " Black leaders such as Charles Chesnutt, John S. Durham, John Hope, Bishop Alexander Walters, Bishop Henry M. Turner, Ida Wells-Barnett, Calvin Chase, and W. E. B. DuBois did not agree with Trotter's freewheeling attacks on Washington, but they endorsed Trotter's stand for racial equality, political enfranchisement, equal civil rights, and higher education for black teachers and leaders. They were backed at times by such black periodicals as the Boston Guardian, Ida Wells-Barnett's Conservator, Voice of the Negro, Washington Bee, Chicago Broad Ax, West Virginia Pioneer Press, and Cleveland Gazette. In 1905 these black leaders organized themselves into the Niagara Movement, which aggressively and unconditionally demanded for blacks the same civil rights and privileges which other Americans enjoyed.35 Similarly, Washington, the philanthropists, and a supporting cadre of black leaders entered the new century determined to discredit their opposition and to unify the race behind the Hampton-Tuskegee program. The
106
The Education of Blacks in the South
"Tuskegee Machine," as DuBois called the Washington forces, was formidable because it consisted of wealthy white philanthropists, large amounts of capital, large sections of the black press, a cadre of black educators in small industrial schools, and powerful white politicians. The philanthropists, with Washington's assistance, organized an impressive vanguard of black educators to propagate the Hampton-Tuskegee Idea. Included in this leadership were Robert R. Moton and W. T. B. Williams of Hampton Institute; Isaac Fisher, principal of the Colored Branch Normal College in Pine Bluff, Arkansas; W. J. Edwards, principal of Snow Hill Institute in Alabama; Henry A. Hunt, principal of the Fort Valley, Georgia, High and Industrial School; William H. Holtzclaw, principal of the Utica, Mississippi, Industrial and Normal School; and Hugh M. Browne, principal of the Institute for Colored Youth in Cheyney, Pennsylvania. Washington also controlled the black press and used it shrewdly to project a positive image of his campaign to commit blacks to the Hampton-Tuskegee educational and social ideology. Using philanthropic funds, he heavily subsidized the Boston Colored Citizen and later Alexander's Magazine to counter the influence of Trotter's Guardian. In Chicago, where Ida Wells-Barnett's Conservator and the Broad Ax were attacking him, Washington toyed with the idea of subsidizing a rival newspaper. When such efforts proved unsuccessful, Washington suggested to Baldwin: "One of the most important things to do is first to establish a strong national negro paper which will unify the race and keep it at work along sensible and constructive directions. We could either buy a paper now established and re-organize it, or start a new paper." As Washington admitted to Francis Garrison, he was determined "to keep the race in harmony" with the Hampton-Tuskegee philosophy. Washington and the philanthropists did not establish a new journal, but they secured control over the majority of the New York Age's stock in 1907. To the Age and most of the other black journals Washington submitted material for editorials, advised on changes in staff, and persuaded editors to attack or ignore opposing campaigns such as the Niagara Movement and the National Suffrage League. Both were organizations of anti-Washington forces.36 The philanthropists and Washington also used a variety of methods to obligate key black intellectuals and leaders to the Hampton-Tuskegee program. The Boston attorney William H. Lewis and the Age's editor T. Thomas Fortune came upon hard times in their personal finances and career goals and came under Washington's influence when he helped them out of difficult situations. In 1902 Baldwin, Ogden, Peabody, and other philanthropists urged DuBois to join Tuskegee's faculty. They were particularly anxious to obtain his considerable talents, for DuBois was the first Afro-American scholar whose work was widely published by
Education and the Race Problem
107
influential national periodicals. DuBois, however, became suspicious and refused the offer. Still, Washington proposed early in 1903 that he and DuBois convene a private conference of prominent men for the purpose of uniting black leaders behind certain "fundamental principles" of racial progress. A definite date and place for the meeting—6—8 January 1904, Carnegie Hall in New York City—were set in October 1903. Washington anticipated that the conference was "going to be the most important, serious, and far-reaching in the history of our people." Significantly, DuBois's The Souls of Black Folk, with a critical essay on Washington, was published in April 1903. After its publication DuBois was recognized as Washington's chief opponent. In October 1903 Washington wrote to Ogden: "I have evidence which is indisputable that Dr. DuBois is very largely behind the mean and underhanded attacks that have been made upon me during the last six months." DuBois's attacks on the Hampton-Tuskegee Idea, however, were open and above board. As he wrote to Peabody in December 1903, "every energy is being used to put black men back into slavery, and Mr. Washington is leading the way backward." Peabody acknowledged to his fellow philanthropist Ogden that DuBois's letter could not be "called encouraging," but they persisted in organizing the conference to confront Washington's opposition. DuBois instructed his associates that "the main issue of this meeting is Washington; refuse to be side-tracked." The Carnegie Hall meeting became a forum for each side to affirm its ideology. Philanthropists Carnegie, Ogden, Peabody, and others witnessed DuBois and his supporters affirm their unequivocal commitment to black suffrage, equal rights, and higher education. Although Washington and the philanthropists had hoped to achieve a consensus around the Hampton-Tuskegee philosophy, the 1904 conference, financed by Carnegie, failed to harmonize the black intelligentsia. Among his northern supporters Washington characterized the meeting, which appointed the Committee of Twelve to unify the race, as a clear victory for the Tuskegee machine. "I am quite sure," wrote Washington to Baldwin, "that several of the members, perhaps the majority of those who have been in opposition, are either silenced or won over to see the error of their way." DuBois, however, resigned from the Committee of Twelve in protest, refusing to have his demands for black progress "countersigned by Booker Washington or laid out by Robert Ogden." As Trotter aptly put it, "Washington can't settle this controversy behind closed doors, even if [Lyman] Abbott, Carnegie, and Baldwin are there." Indeed, black opposition to Washington and the philanthropists increased sharply after r9O4- 37 Some students of the Washington-DuBois controversy have concluded that the Trotter-DuBois forces were "outgeneraled by that Machiavellian prince of Negroes, Booker T. Washington." Clearly, Washington contin-
io8
The Education of Blacks in the South
ued to serve as the Negro power broker for northern philanthropists, but this was mainly because he shared with them the Hampton philosophy of black education. Washington and the philanthropists, however, did not outmaneuver the Trotter-DuBois forces on the ideological front. From 1902 to 1904, the philanthropists attempted to prevent a total break between the Washington and DuBois camps. They failed, and out of their failure grew the radical Niagara Movement in 1905. By forthrightly demanding voting rights, equal educational opportunities, and "the abolition of all caste distinctions," the black Niagarites helped drive a wedge between the philanthropic movement and northern white neoabolitionists. Northern white liberals such as Francis Garrison, William Hayes Ward, Mary White Ovington, and Oswald Garrison Villard became disillusioned with the triumvirate of industrial philanthropists, southern white educational reformers, and Negro accommodationists. They began to attack the conservative coalition and responded affirmatively by establishing the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) in 1910, which, like the Niagara Movement, stood for universal political and civil equality. In 1903, betraying a respect for the important ideological victories won by Washington's opponents, Baldwin informed his fellow philanthropists that "a great deal of harm is being done by Dr. DuBois, and some other people, notably some other Negroes in Boston who have never seen the South." By 1911, Peabody admitted that "the large majority" of blacks followed DuBois. And by 1915, even the pro-Washington New York Age, Chicago Defender, and Indianapolis Freeman were becoming increasingly critical of the philanthropists' approach to black education. The Trotter-DuBois forces had won the ideological war and prevented the Hampton Idea from becoming the dominant Afro-American educational ideology.38 More important than the open opposition to Washington and the Hampton Idea was the undercurrent of sentiment against industrial education emerging throughout the Afro-American South. This opposition never was voiced in newspapers and journals, but it was often reported to Washington and the philanthropists. For example, one of Washington's former students and his trusted associate Isaac Fisher kept him abreast of such developments in Arkansas. Fisher, who had attended Tuskegee from 1893 to 1898, became, in 1902, principal of the Colored Branch Normal College in Pine Bluff, Arkansas, a state-supported normal and land-grant school for black students. In April 1904, Fisher hosted the meeting of the "Presidents of Land Grant Colleges and other Schools." During the conference anti-Washington feeling ran high. As Fisher wrote to Washington:
Education and the Race Problem
109
I believe that I ought to write you of some phases of the meeting: In the first place while I have known of the opposition of many Negroes towards you, I have not appreciated until now how bitter and unfair and widespread is that opposition. I think I do not err at all when I say that every Negro but one attending the meetings is an anti-Washington Negro. In the opening session covert flings at Booker Washington was the order of the day. I remained quiet until I discovered that I was the only Washington man present. This afternoon agricultural education was under discussion. A young woman from Miss Laney's school at Augusta was discussing the need of such training. She made a good impression. When she sat down one of the principals of one of the colored schools here rose and attacked all kinds of industrial education as well as the young woman. Later that year Fisher informed Washington that Pine Bluff was "bitterly anti-Washington." When Fisher sent three of his female graduates to study industrial training at Tuskegee, "prominent colored citizens" of Pine Bluff "almost begged the parents of these girls not to send them to Tuskegee." Black organizations and communities in general discouraged the development of more Hamptons and Tuskegees. Although black religious and secular organizations created and controlled many private secondary and normal schools and colleges, they were not modeled on the Hampton program, except for a cluster of small industrial normal schools founded by Hampton and Tuskegee graduates. The philanthropic northerners won an important battle in conquering the Tuskegee machine, but they lost the war as black leaders everywhere moved farther away from the Hampton-Tuskegee educational and social ideology.39 In the meantime, the industrial philanthropists continued their campaign to expand the Hampton model of black industrial education throughout the Afro-American South. The black opposition was limited primarily to ideological weapons, but the philanthropic movement consisted of wealthy foundations and powerful whites with access to federal and state power. Thus the philanthropists could mount a flexible response to political and ideological setbacks. Step by step, they used their private foundations and government connections to establish educational institutions modeled on the Hampton program. Failing to conquer the existing black secondary and collegiate system, the philanthropists began erecting an alternative industrial normal school and county training school system to train black teachers and leaders for the rural districts. In this movement, the philanthropists drew upon their great wealth and political connections to build the institutions that corresponded to their economic, political, and social interests.
4
NORMAL SCHOOLS AND COUNTY TRAINING SCHOOLS EDUCATING THE SOUTH'S TEACHING FORCE,
BLACK
1900-1935
AT THE D A W N of the twentieth century, the various proponents of universal elementary education for black southerners, irrespective of their unique social and educational ideology, recognized a common problem: the infrastructure necessary for a viable black public school system did not exist. Nearly two-thirds of the black children of elementary school age were not enrolled in school, primarily because there were not enough school buildings or seating capacity to accommodate the overwhelming majority of these children. Another serious problem was the great shortage of black teachers. No adequate common schools could be developed until there were black teachers to teach in them because most southern white educators would not teach black children. Northern white missionary teachers, who had contributed significantly to the spread of common schools among ex-slaves during the postwar period, could not be acquired in sufficient numbers, and their presence in the South was statistically insignificant by 1900. If black children were to learn, be it academic or industrial and manual training, they would be taught by black teachers. Hence the proper training of an adequate supply of black teachers was a necessary first step toward the successful expansion of common schooling for black children. In 1900 the supply of black teachers depended almost entirely upon the private normal schools, secondary schools, and colleges. As illustrated in Table 4.1, over 70 percent of the black normal school students were enrolled in private institutions and 80 percent of those who graduated were from private schools. Seventy-five percent of the black students enrolled in secondary schools, and 5 5 percent of the high school graduates were in private institutions. Nearly 90 percent of the black college students and 81 percent of the college graduates were in private schools. Altogether the private normal schools, high schools, and col-
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
111
leges claimed 17,541 or 75 percent of the 2.3,362. black students enrolled in normal, secondary, and collegiate courses, and 1,379 or 66 percent of z,o87 students graduating in 1900 with a normal school certificate, high school diploma, or college degree. These graduates, whether they had received teacher training or not, were filling public school positions. Still there was a great teacher shortage and the annual demand for approximately 7,000 new black teachers was increasing at a much faster rate than the yearly output of about 2,500. In 1900 in the sixteen former slave states there were 2.6,770 black teachers for the 2.5485,737 black children ages five through eighteen, or one black teacher for every 93 black children of school age. The black teaching force in the southern states would have to double if it were to supply one teacher for every 46 black children of school age, a ratio well above the then accepted standard of one teacher for every 30 pupils. The southern black ratio of 93 school-age children per teacher was also well above the southern white ratio of 57 school-age children per teacher. To enroll 75 percent of the black school-age population in 1900, an additional 35,373 teachers were required to provide one teacher for every 30 pupils. Although the magnitude of this teacher shortage declined with each passing year, the basic pattern remained through the first third of the twentieth century.1 Significantly, the great shortage of black teachers existed at a moment in history when the philanthropists, white school reformers, and black leaders were locked in a struggle to shape the ideological content of schooling for the black masses. If the system of common schooling for black children had been fairly well developed by 1900, many of the ideological debates among industrial philanthropists, northern missionaries, black leaders, and southern whites might have ended as rhetorical wars. But those interested in shaping the beliefs and behavior of southern black children through formal schooling viewed the great teacher shortage as an opportunity to influence significantly the form and content of black teacher training and thereby contribute directly to the socialization of black children. All groups understood that no system of beliefs could be transmitted to the millions of black schoolchildren except through the ideas and behavior of black teachers. Consequently, during the early twentieth century black teacher training departments became primary battlefields for campaigns to translate particular ideologies of black education into institutional and bureaucratic forces. The problem of supply and demand of black teachers presented both opportunity and despair. At the beginning of the twentieth century, teachers for the common school system could be produced at little cost. Although southern states, counties, and cities varied in their standards for certifying and hiring teachers, many elementary school teachers had not gone beyond high school. Some normal schools continued the nine-
TABLE 4.1
Black Students and Graduates in Public and Private Normal Schools, High Schools, and Colleges in Southern States, 1900 High Schools
Normal Schools Students State Alabama Arkansas Delaware Florida Georgia Kentucky Louisiana Maryland Mississippi Missouri North Carolina South Carolina Tennessee Texas Virginia West Virginia Totals
Public
659 62 3 5
o
73 2-5 0
o o 2-53 o
Graduates
Private
Public
Private
767 77 o 66 384 50 20 49 105
4i
26 J 3 o 15 87 18 15 J 3 48
22 538
*54 88
z66 660 97 i6z 98
i>3"
3,36i
0
o
o 3 5
o 5 2 0 O
o 49 o
o
22 123
JI
5 82
Public
Private
7°
2,007
o 60 79 7M 0 221
394 682 77 169 42.5
308 3i 306 i,5M
270 529 199
1,318
228 i,544 1,262 i, 060
Public
10 39
o
8 13 93 0
28 3° 72. 17 2-5
67
553
650
547 56
1,201
II
3 4i 6
186
44 67 J 4
156
627
4,320
12,623
52.7
0
40
Students
Graduates
Students
2-73
Colleges
Source: U.S. Commissioner of Education, Report, 1899—1900, 2:2504—7, 2514—21.
Private
95 15 o 19 194
Public
o o 20 O 22
o
36
34 4
0
0
36
8 82 62 9 17 73
33 o 39
o 0 0
27
0
o
646
179
Graduates
Private
33 7°
o i 290 36 35 ii 5213 429 76 297
188 26
Public
Private
o o i o
o o
o o
o
o o 8 0
7
o o o 9
4 4
9 9
0
7 o 36 12 15
0
o
3 7 o
!,557
2.5
106
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
113
teenth-century practice of admitting students who had not gone to high school but who passed an examination in common school subjects. States still recognized high schools and junior colleges as adequate teacher preparatory institutions. Consequently, schools that, in many instances, were only slightly above the common school level were graduating students who received jobs as common school teachers. This pattern was especially compatible with the Hampton-Tuskegee industrial normal school model of teacher training, which offered elementary academic education while stressing manual labor practices. Yet many of these traditional low-level teacher certification requirements were being upgraded, and the new trends played into the hands of those who controlled the black four-year colleges. During the early twentieth century states began to require a high school diploma for admission to the normal schools. This step automatically put the normal schools on the college level and led to higher academic and professional standards for training teachers. Meanwhile, nearly all of the colleges and universities developed teacher training programs, and soon larger numbers of their graduates were going into teaching than any other postgraduate occupation. To be sure, the development of teacher training programs for black students in the South evolved at a slower pace, in large part because southern white school authorities were unwilling to enforce equally high standards for black schools. Still, efforts to direct and control the training of black teachers were shaped significantly by the early twentiethcentury transformation of teacher preparatory programs. The existing black educational institutions with possibilities of developing sound departments of teacher education fell into four groups: (i) the sixteen land-grant and seven state normal schools; (2.) approximately fifty public high schools and five city normal schools; (3) approximately sixty private colleges; and (4) the more than two hundred private institutions offering secondary and normal courses. The land-grant state agricultural and mechanical schools had unique possibilities for teacher training. Their public ownership and regulation gave them an official status in the school system. But they did not attain adequate provisions for teacher training until after 192.0. The state normal schools were scarce and inadequately equipped to train significant numbers of black teachers. Before World War I, only Virginia, Alabama, Maryland, and North Carolina maintained state normal schools, and four of the seven were in the latter state. City normal schools were located in Louisville, Baltimore, Richmond, St. Louis, and Little Rock. The output annually from these schools was insufficient to meet local demands. Practically, then, the supply of black teachers depended almost entirely upon the black private secondary and normal schools and colleges. Having resisted the development of universal common schooling for black chil-
ii4
The Education of Blacks in the South
dren, the South provided very little public support for black teacher training. Moreover, although many of the public facilities for teacher training could be developed, it was obvious that the black private institutions would be needed for some years to come. Because of the strategic place they occupied in the overall structure of black teacher training, these private institutions became prime targets of reform movements to shape and control the form and content of southern black public education during the first third of the twentieth century. The major struggles for control of black teacher training institutions occurred between the black educators who presided over the private normal and secondary schools and the supporters of the HamptonTuskegee model of industrial normal education. The advocates of industrial teacher training were proud of the success of Hampton and Tuskegee, but they were very disappointed with the reality that the Hampton-Tuskegee model of normal school training had not become widely accepted among black private secondary and normal institutions. Because these institutions were training the vast majority of the South's black teaching force, the Hampton-Tuskegee supporters correctly viewed themselves as losing the struggle to implant industrial and manual training as the primary curriculum in black public schools. The black private colleges, whether owned and controlled by black or white organizations, resisted successfully the Hampton-Tuskegee model of teacher training. The black public high schools, which trained many of the teachers for the South's black elementary schools, also resisted by holding to the classical liberal curriculum. The Hampton-Tuskegee advocates considered even the teacher training courses in southern state-supported normal schools too academically oriented. Therefore, in view of the existing structure of black teacher training and the difficulties of redirecting the black colleges in favor of the Hampton-Tuskegee model, northern industrial philanthropists and their allies chose to use their wealth and power to influence small black private secondary and normal schools to eliminate classical liberal curricula and adopt the Hampton-Tuskegee model of industrial normal education. The philanthropists saw the small private black normal schools and high schools as the most strategic means to supplement the HamptonTuskegee supply of industrial teachers. First, they knew that some of the small private schools had been founded by Hampton-Tuskegee graduates and were known as Hampton-Tuskegee offshoots. Second, such institutions depended for their support mainly on voluntary contributions recruited by their financial agents in the North. The federal government offered limited support to industrial education in the poorly equipped black land-grant schools, but neither Tuskegee nor any of the HamptonTuskegee offshoots received any federal aid. The white South did little to
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
115
alleviate the financial burden. In short, the smaller schools faced constant financial crisis year after year. The philanthropic reformers believed that they could exercise much greater control over the structure and content of the small private schools because these schools were not under the control of either missionary societies, black religious organizations, or federal and state authorities. The efforts made by northern philanthropists to increase the supply of black industrial teachers through the development of small private black normal and high schools has been one of the most neglected aspects of black educational history during the early twentieth century. These efforts provide a concrete picture of the particular translation of their social and educational ideology into institutionalized teacher training programs. Moreover, they help us to see the extent to which the intellectual debates about the purpose of black education reflected a real struggle to control and shape the form and content of black schools. Further, such efforts at the level of particular institutions reveal the individuals and organizations involved, the specific results they sought, the methods and techniques they employed, and the overall impact these developments had on black students, faculty, and administrators. The following case history of the Fort Valley High and Industrial School (the name was changed in 1932. to the Fort Valley Normal and Industrial School and then to Fort Valley State College in 1939) provides a closer view of this aspect of black educational history. The struggle to control and shape black teacher training institutions rested on the assumption that those who shaped the beliefs and behavior of the teachers would also influence heavily the minds and hearts of black schoolchildren. Located in Fort Valley, Georgia, the center of the state's Black Belt, the Fort Valley High and Industrial School was started in 1890 by Atlanta University graduate John W. Davison. Founded as a private school, the institution was chartered as a public normal and industrial school in 1895. During its first five years, Fort Valley High and Industrial School consisted of one small shanty on four acres of land valued at $800, against which there was a mortgage of $1,000. The school, situated within a one-hundred-mile radius of five hundred thousand black Georgians, had just two teachers and enrolled only one hundred pupils for a mere four-month term. Principal Davison, unable to secure funds from public or private agencies, was forced to invest his own money to maintain the school from year to year. He relied mainly on Fort Valley's black community for additional support. This method of fund-raising, however, proved inadequate, and in 1896 Davison hired James H. Torbert, also a graduate of Atlanta University, as assistant principal and financial agent. Torbert managed to solicit enough funds from local donors to pay off the school's mortgage and to cover his own salary. Still, Davison had
n6
The Education of Blacks in the South
to mortgage his home to pay off the school's full indebtedness, and on another occasion he mortgaged his farm to obtain funds for annual expenditures. Fort Valley High and Industrial School entered the twentieth century under severe financial handicaps.z The desperate need for economic assistance pointed the Fort Valley educators north in search of capital from wealthy whites. In this period virtually every black educational institution flooded the North with letter-writing campaigns, school publications, and appeals for financial contributions, and Fort Valley was no exception. Fort Valley, like other small private black schools, relied mainly on its financial agent, who made annual and, in many cases, monthly trips north to solicit donations personally. Torbert, accompanied by a student quartet singing "plantation melodies," conducted door-to-door-appeals, visited fashionable resort hotels and churches, and held fund-raising meetings in northern cities to uncover new sources of financial aid for the struggling Fort Valley school. To Fort Valley's credit, Torbert was one of the most persistent and successful fund-raisers of his day. By 1900, he collected from $3,000 to $5,000 annually. His efforts might well have prevented Fort Valley from closing its doors.3 Torbert's fund-raising efforts, though moderately effective in procuring money to cover annual expenditures, did not solve the school's financial woes. The donations were too small substantially to alleviate a desperate fiscal situation. Fort Valley received no aid from Georgia or the federal government, and the local black community could contribute only small gifts. The funds from northern white benefactors, which could be used to cover immediate expenses, were not sufficient to start an endowment or to cover the cost of consistent growth and expansion. There was no money to erect new buildings, to increase salaries, or to hire more staff. In addition, Torbert's fund-raising job was filled with hardships and difficulties that made the process of obtaining northern donations very unstable. As he described it, "Many times I have tramped from door to door, all day with no success and with hardly enough money in my pocket belonging to the school to pay for my night's lodging or get a wholesome meal." Obviously, more reliable and substantial sources of funding were needed to maintain and build a sound educational institution.4 With Davison's approval, Torbert sought to solve Fort Valley's financial difficulties by cultivating relationships with whites who could give large, continuous donations to the school. From 1900 to 1904, Torbert campaigned successfully to stack Fort Valley's Board of Trustees with northern industrial philanthropists who were becoming increasingly interested in contributing their capital to southern educational reform. He convinced Philadelphians Theodore J. Lewis and Dr. Joseph H. Schenck
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
117
to become trustees. Both men were listed in the Philadelphia Blue Book among the city's "prominent" householders. J. H. Hale, a wealthy white from Connecticut with "large orchard interests at Fort Valley, Georgia," also agreed to join the school's Board of Trustees. George Foster Peabody was undoubtedly the most influential philanthropist to join the Fort Valley trustees. Peabody had been interested in the development of southern black education since he was appointed to the Hampton Institute Board of Trustees in 1884. From the outset, Peabody showed strong interest in the development of Fort Valley. He donated $1,000 of the $5,000 needed to erect the main school building and contributed $500 of the $2,500 needed to construct the Children's Training School. Most significantly, however, he brought the school to the attention of the General Education Board, a source that could promise long-term funding.5 The shift from small and scattered donations to organized industrial philanthropy eventually had great impact on Fort Valley High and Industrial School. The institution was chartered specifically to promote the "higher and mental and manual training" of black students, but principal Davison was concentrating mainly on the development of a good liberal arts secondary and normal school for the training of black teachers. Both he and Torbert were graduates of Atlanta University, and apparently they intended to model Fort Valley on the Atlanta system. The support received from individuals and northern white churches did not threaten these plans because the money was usually given with no strings attached. But although philanthropic foundations declared it their policy to put no pressure, direct or indirect, upon any institution to conform to a certain course of action, it was well known that northern organizations such as the General Education Board were donating funds almost exclusively to promote the Hampton-Tuskegee model of black industrial education. Hence struggling black private institutions, especially those not committed to the Hampton-Tuskegee model, found it easier to secure funds from northern industrial philanthropists by trumpeting industrial training than by stressing academic education. Such was the case with Fort Valley. The financial appeal made to Peabody and the General Education Board advertised the school as the prospective Tuskegee of Georgia's Black Belt. As the interest of philanthropists increased, Torbert recommended the addition of "a first-class industrial department to the school." "It has been our desire from the beginning," wrote Davison to Peabody in 1902., "to make this an industrial school after the order of Hampton and Tuskegee." Yet, as Torbert wrote to Peabody in 1906, "Davison did not care much for the industrial department." It largely was a department in name only, a means of attracting funds that could be diverted to building Davison's idea of a liberal arts institution.6 Organized industrial philanthropists were not easily fooled or mis-
n8
The Education of Blacks in the South
used, however. In 1899 Hollis B. Frissell, Hampton principal who later became a trustee of the General Education Board and the Southern Education Board, warned that too many "sham" schools in the South called themselves "industrial" only because industrial education was popular in the North. The following year Frissell publicly demanded a closer scrutiny of black fund-raisers and warned that philanthropists were disturbed by the prevalence of deception. Similarly, in 1899 railroad industrialist and Tuskegee trustee William H. Baldwin, Jr., called for a reorganization of northern philanthropy to support schools engaged in appropriate industrial training. Baldwin, who became the first president of the General Education Board, urged that such an organization "be recognized by the whole country as a proper channel through which the Negro Industrial Education can be reached successfully." As a consequence of such concerns, northern philanthropic foundations established "school inspectors" and committees to investigate the industrial features of black institutions. Some of these paid inspectors, such as W. T. B. Williams of Hampton Institute, were black. Also, Booker T. Washington and his staff were constantly called upon to evaluate the industrial education curriculum of schools applying for philanthropic aid. This close scrutiny made it particularly difficult for institutions to persuade philanthropists to support fake industrial schools—or even legitimate industrial schools—that gave too much attention to academic training.7 From the outset, northern philanthropists had doubts about Fort Valley's commitment to industrial education. Usually when such "unscrupulous imposters" were discovered, philanthropists simply stopped donating funds and severed all ties with the "guilty" institution. But Fort Valley was extremely significant in the philanthropists' campaign to spread industrial education throughout the Afro-American South. They were particularly disturbed that Georgia, with the largest black population in the South, entered the twentieth century with no black teacher training institutions based on the Hampton-Tuskegee model. When the philanthropists discovered Fort Valley, therefore, they set out immediately to make it a model institution for industrial education in Georgia. Peabody visited the school twice "to look it over," and he sent Hollis B. Frissell to assess Fort Valley's potential as an industrial normal school. Peabody thought Fort Valley was in "a good location for a school of central influence in Georgia." He asked Wallace Buttrick, executive officer of the General Education Board, to inspect the school in November i9oz. "I am greatly pleased with the institution and am confident that it will improve from year to year," wrote Buttrick. "It is located where there are many Negroes, and this school is a most promising civilizing agency." Because Fort Valley appealed to the philanthropists, they decided not to allow Davison to pursue his own course. As Buttrick wrote
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
119
to Peabody, "I quite agree with you that we ought to take hold of the Fort Valley work promptly."8 The philanthropists moved quickly to direct Fort Valley along the Hampton-Tuskegee model of industrial education. Principal Davison was the first target. They concluded that he needed extensive in-service training in the Hampton program to transform Fort Valley. As a test of his commitment to industrial education, and for him to continue to receive financial support, the philanthropists required Davison to attend Hampton Institute during the summer of 1902. for an orientation to the proper industrial education curriculum. Meanwhile, the philanthropists and other white trustees of Fort Valley were growing increasingly doubtful of Davison's willingness to lead the school in the "right" direction. Fort Valley trustee C. G. Gray, president of the Fort Valley Exchange Bank, informed Peabody that Davison, at the suggestion of Professor Cloyd, will leave for Hampton where he will take an industrial course during the summer, and we hope that he will make such progress on these lines as will qualify him for the position he now holds. There is every disposition on the part of the committee to assist Davison rather than to dispose of him, but each of us feel the responsibility of our position and will strive to make this school a success with Davison if possible, but without Davison if absolutely necessary.9 By early fall of 1902, the philanthropists were eager to see what lessons Davison had learned from his summer experience at Hampton. Wallace Buttrick informed E. C. Branson, a white trustee who was chairman of Fort Valley's Teachers' Committee, that "Principal Davison is on trial this year." Thus Davison started the year with little support among the philanthropists and white trustees. After a meeting with Davison in September 1902., Buttrick expressed his contempt for the black principal: "I don't like him. He has a furtive glance that is far from assuring." In November 1902., treasurer and trustee C. G. Gray reported that Fort Valley was running smoothly except for "quite a number of foolish suggestions that are frequently made by the Principal." Two months later Gray wrote to Peabody: "I fear that he will never learn that amount of common sense that is so necessary to lead an enterprise like the one we have in mind." Such criticism of Davison's leadership continued during the 1902.—3 school term and reached a peak in April 1903. David E. Cloyd, a school inspector for the General Education Board who had investigated Fort Valley, advised the philanthropists to "dismiss Davison instantly."10 On 15 May 1903, philanthropist and trustee George Foster Peabody informed Wallace Buttrick that "Mr. Davison is in disfavor and the
12.0
The Education of Blacks in the South
Trustees are to have a meeting at Philadelphia." The Philadelphia meeting, attended by Peabody, Buttrick, Schenck, Lewis, Gray, Torbert, and Davison, was called specifically to decide Davison's future at Fort Valley. Although there were several black members on the Fort Valley Board of Trustees, not one of them was invited to the Philadelphia meeting. During the meeting, according to Gray, the white trustees chastised Davison for poor leadership, whereupon he returned to Fort Valley "very quiet." The reprimand, however, was merely the tip of the iceberg. While in Philadelphia, the white trustees had met privately and agreed to seek Davison's resignation. Buttrick advised Schenck and Lewis to "proceed cautiously" with plans to remove Davison and revealed that he and Peabody were already considering a successor for the black principal. Soon after, Buttrick wrote to Schenck: "When you reach the point where you think it best to make an attempt to reorganize the school, Mr. Peabody and I have in mind a very competent man and his wife who, it seems to us, would be eminently qualified to take up that work. We should want to inquire a little further about him but we have already made some investigation and all reports are exceedingly favorable." Schenck replied that he and Lewis would cooperate with Buttrick and Peabody in efforts to secure Davison's resignation. "As I told you over the phone when you were last in our city," said Schenck to Buttrick, "it will be for the interest of the school for Davison to resign." Schenck further stated, "I cannot see how we are going to make a success of the school with that man as principal." The philanthropists agreed to push for Davison's resignation during the summer following the 1902.—3 school year. Buttrick quickly made plans to arrive at Fort Valley before the school's annual trustee meeting in June so that he and the white trustees could urge Davison to resign the principalship.11 Meanwhile, Davison, having learned of plans to remove him, began to maneuver for his own survival by vigorously trumpeting the utility and efficacy of industrial education for the black masses. In a report to the General Education Board, he proposed to buy four cows so that Fort Valley boys and girls could learn dairying, "a most useful occupation." He also recommended the appointment of an "expert laundress" because laundering was a key occupation at which many black females would work "all their lives." He proclaimed laundering as a "very useful occupation" that was "much needed in civilized life." Davison promised to "follow the leading industrial schools: Tuskegee and Hampton," and invited the General Education Board to help reorganize Fort Valley on the Hampton-Tuskegee model. The Fort Valley principal even apologized to Peabody for having the school's motto printed in Latin and explained that it was only "put in Latin for brevity's sake," not to symbolize a commitment to classical training. Thus Davison attempted to convince
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
12.1
the philanthropists that he was "no hypocrite" on the question of industrial education.11 But praising the virtues of industrial education was one thing; persuading northern philanthropists that he was no hypocrite was quite another. They were not convinced by Davison's instant conversion to the gospel of industrial education and still awaited the opportunity to dismiss him. By Z3 June 1903, trustee Gray informed Peabody that he had sufficient support to oust Davison and advised the philanthropists to search for a replacement, "some colored man from the South who has industrial training and is 'chuck full' of common sense." From the philanthropists' standpoint, the June meeting was a success. Two days later, Gray apprised Buttrick of Davison's response: "He came to my office this morning and notified me that he would not be an applicant for the office of principal this year but had made up his mind to leave the place entirely." On the same day, Davison informed Buttrick that he would resign because he understood that the General Education Board and "northern trustees" would withdraw their financial support from the school if he continued as principal. Yet, in a final plea for his job, Davison reminded the philanthropists of his sacrifice and devotion to Fort Valley during its formative stages. They believed, however, that his resignation was a small and necessary price to pay for the development of a solid industrial normal school in Georgia's Black Belt. Buttrick replied to Davison: "I appreciate your earnest labors of many years, and sympathize with you and your disappointment, but I am convinced that your manly offer to resign the principalship will contribute most to the progress of the school."13 Thus the philanthropists saw to it that Davison was dismissed because of his failure to model Fort Valley on the Hampton-Tuskegee curriculum, and their actions enable us to assess the depth of their commitment to black industrial education. The philanthropists, according to current historiography, placed heavy emphasis on industrial education so as to reconcile hostile southern whites to tolerate even limited Negro education. Hence it is alleged that grants were made to Hampton-Tuskegee—styled agricultural and domestic training to accommodate southern whites' idea of the Negro's "place" and as a means to save black education from total eradication. Presumably, this policy of respecting the feelings of southern whites, as Merle Curti and Roderick Nash contend, "was not the deliberate aim of the philanthropists and their agents, who instead sought to improve the Negroes' lot." Historians of southern education, on balance, contend that the philanthropists originally went south to support more liberal educational opportunities for Negroes but curbed their aspirations for fear of alienating southern whites, which in turn would thwart the expansion of common schools for black children.
12,2.
The Education of Blacks in the South
These assumptions, however, are seldom tested against specific relationships among philanthropists, black educational institutions, and southern whites.14 Interestingly, Davison, who was unanimously opposed by northern white philanthropists, received significant support from some important southern whites. C. M. Carethy, a local white medical doctor and supporter of Fort Valley, insisted that the philanthropists retain Davison even if the black principal was devoted to classical liberal education. Carethy argued that academic education was necessary for a good trade program and he believed that Davison was "as well-fitted as anyone" to teach academic subjects. Further, Carethy maintained that a reorganization of Fort Valley without Davison was equivalent to "slapping in the face all the efforts Mr. Davison has put forth for the school." Similarly, W. J. Scroggs, the white superintendent of the Fort Valley public schools, wrote in Davison's defense: "He appears to be well-adapted for his work and as far as I am able to learn he has influence among his people and is well thought of by the whites." Davison even received support from George B. Culpepper, a local businessman who worked for the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance Company of Philadelphia. Culpepper, "sired by a secession father, nursed by a rebel mother, and not yet reconstructed," as he described himself, supported Davison. "I believe in J. W. Davison," he wrote, "and would like to see him succeed in bringing to his race in this section whatever of good there is in education." These statements do not support the argument that philanthropists made grants to Negro industrial education solely to mollify hostile southern whites/ 5 To be sure, many southern whites favored simple agricultural and manual training as a form of second-class education for blacks. But it is misleading to assume that northern white philanthropists supported black industrial training primarily to respect southern white opinion. Northern philanthropists had their own reasons for supporting the Hampton-Tuskegee model of industrial education.16 Thus, even when southern whites cooperated with black academic institutions, philanthropists withheld their donations because schools failed to conform to the Hampton-Tuskegee model. The relationship between northern philanthropists and the Georgia State Industrial College (Savannah State) illustrates this point. Richard R. Wright, Sr., a well-known black educator, was president of Savannah State, a school whose curriculum emphasized academic education and training in selected skilled trades. Wright, a member of the first graduating class of Atlanta University, was a strong advocate for the higher literary training of black students and even offered Latin and Greek in the Savannah State curriculum. He managed to make his brand of academic and industrial education acceptable to Georgia's all-white Board of Commissioners for Savannah State. North-
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
123
ern philanthropists, however, thought the school was much too academic to merit financial assistance. William H. Baldwin, Jr., visited Savannah in 1900 and concluded that the school's "industrial feature" was not sufficiently emphasized. In 1903 Baldwin's cousin George J. Baldwin (president of the Savannah Electric Company) attempted to get the General Education Board to support Savannah State, "provided the industrial feature was made more prominent." William H. Baldwin, then president of the General Education Board, replied emphatically: "You say we might be willing to be of assistance to the college, providing the industrial feature was made more prominent. You have hit the nail on the head. It isn't to make the industrial feature prominent only, however, that we are interested in doing, but to make it effective. There are lots of schools in the South that talk a good deal of industrial features, and really do not mean it, and I am told that is the trouble with the Savannah institution." For him, Savannah State was too much under the "false atmosphere" of Atlanta University, which stressed "that a higher education only is of importance to the Negro race." Hence Savannah State was not among those black institutions favored by northern philanthropy. Clearly, such policies were not adopted to mollify "hostile" white Georgians who were supporting the institution with state funds. Similarly, the philanthropists' campaign to transform Fort Valley into a Hampton-Tuskegee—like industrial school was not done to appease southern whites.17 With Davison's resignation in hand, northern philanthropists plunged vigorously into hiring a new principal for Fort Valley. Although they stated publicly that institutions would be left to "work out their own salvation," the strong desire to establish Fort Valley as an industrial training school for teachers worked against any impulse to respect institutional self-determination. By July 1903, Peabody and Buttrick had identified two candidates for the Fort Valley vacancy. Peabody recommended Henry Alexander Hunt, who was business manager and director of trades at Biddle (currently Johnson C. Smith) University, a Presbyterian college for black men in Charlotte, North Carolina. Buttrick, however, was convinced that his nominee, a Mr. Diamond (a Hampton Institute graduate), who was employed at Walden University in Nashville, Tennessee, was the best man for the job. "He has had the industrial training which makes him specially capable of directing an Industrial School, such as Fort Valley aims to be," wrote Buttrick. Diamond was "a competent man and thoroughly imbued with the Hampton methods and spirit." The philanthropists submitted their candidates to Booker T. Washington for his scrutiny. Washington knew very little about Diamond or Hunt and recommended Tuskegee graduate Isaac Fisher for the Fort Valley principalship. The philanthropists then considered Fisher and
124
The Education of Blacks in the South
Diamond their top candidates, and both men were offered the Fort Valley position, but they decided to remain at their respective institutions. Thus the philanthropists were left with their third choice, Henry A. Hunt.18 Initially, Peabody and Buttrick were skeptical of Hunt's allegiance to the Hampton-Tuskegee model of industrial education. "I do not know whether Hunt is committed to the idea of Industrial Education," wrote Buttrick, "he may be but, I simply do not know." Like Davison, Torbert, and Wright, Hunt was a graduate of Atlanta University. The philanthropists disliked Wright's brand of industrial education, had coerced Davison to resign because of his halfhearted commitment to industrial training, and, as Buttrick said, did "not expect much from men like Torbert." Moreover, Booker T. Washington had advised them that industrial schools were "not likely to do effective work" unless directed by Hampton or Tuskegee graduates. The philanthropists, made wary by Davison's deception, took a long look at Henry A. Hunt. Fort Valley opened in the fall of 1903 without a principal, and Mr. Miller, head of the school's mechanical shop, served as acting head until February 1904. During this time, however, Hunt convinced Buttrick and Peabody that he was seriously committed to developing an industrial education program at Fort Valley. Hunt emphasized his "mechanical" study at Atlanta University and his experience as head of Biddle University's Industrial and Boarding departments. In addition, wrote Hunt, "I do not know about mechanical work in a theoretical way only, but I'm a practical workman as well, having 'carried the dinner pail' and earned $2.50 per day as a carpenter during vacation seasons while a student." Buttrick was "favorably" impressed. On 5 November 1903, he informed Peabody, "I have a growing conviction that it might be well to secure the services of Mr. Hunt as principal and retain the services of Torbert as vice-principal and soliciting agent." Hunt was hired in November 1903 and began his long career (1904-38) as principal of Fort Valley on 9 February 1904.19 From the outset, the philanthropists watched closely Hunt's development of Fort Valley's industrial education program. Peabody directed his friend Walter B. Hill, chancellor of the University of Georgia, to investigate Hunt's educational activities. Hill would arrive at Fort Valley unannounced and question Hunt rigorously about every aspect of the school's industrial program. In his first report, Hill was very critical of Hunt's initial efforts toward the development of industrial training. "I had gone through the buildings and had talked with Mr. Hunt and Mr. McNiel," wrote Hill to Peabody, "and had heard nothing said, and had seen nothing, as to industrial work." Still worse, Hunt had closed down the old industrial shop and made it into a boys' dormitory. Conse-
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
12.5
quently, Hill was "compelled to have some skepticism as to his earnestness in regard to the industrial feature."10 Peabody, distressed by Hill's report, requested from Hunt a full explanation of the changes at Fort Valley and warned the principal that philanthropic funding would be forthcoming only if he developed a Hampton-Tuskegee model of industrial education. Peabody stated: Write me rather freely respecting your own thought as to the industrial work and your reasons for suspending it in order to make dormitory rooms. I should be glad to take up promptly through Doctor Buttrick as representative of the General Education Board the question of making you a proposition to put the amount necessary for completing the building which is now under way. I think I should be inclined in view of what I now learn to make some condition respecting a proper development of the industrial work which should, I think, grow to be as at Hampton, an essential element in the entire work of the school being correlated to all branches of study. Obviously, Peabody was using philanthropic capital to pressure Hunt to conform to the Hampton model of industrial education. In this endeavor Peabody sought successfully the cooperation of Buttrick and the General Education Board. "I shall hope that it may seem feasible to you and that you may think it wise," said Peabody to Buttrick, "that definite pressure be brought for the inauguration of immediate industrial work as far as is practicable." Hunt replied that Fort Valley's industrial education system developed slowly because of inadequate resources; he was not opposed to industrial training in principle. "I agree heartily with your idea in the matter of having the industrial feature grow to be an essential element in the work of the school; in fact, I would not have undertaken the work had I not expected this to be the case." As evidence of his commitment to industrial training, Hunt reported his activities in organizing classes in sewing, cooking, carpentry, and gardening. He had also planted two hundred peach trees to provide training in "the care and cultivation of fruit trees." Such activities were especially satisfying to Fort Valley trustee J. H. Hale, the Connecticut owner of Hale's Fruit Company, who possessed large peach orchards in Fort Valley, Georgia/1 The philanthropists became pleased with Hunt's attitude toward industrial training. As Buttrick wrote to Hunt in January 1905: "Your letter of January 10 to Mr. Peabody was duly received. I have just had a long conference with him regarding it. The letter is exceedingly satisfactory to us both. You have outlined the situation with great clearness. I am glad to say that I can authorize you to complete and furnish the
12.6
The Education of Blacks in the South
needed recitation rooms in the new buildings, funds for which will be furnished through the General Education Board." Confident that they had found the right man to implant industrial training in Georgia's Black Belt, the philanthropists cemented a relationship with Hunt in 1905 that lasted into the 19305. The General Education Board made yearly contributions to help cover Fort Valley's annual expenses and contributed larger sums for buildings, equipment, and other permanent improvements. By 1910, the board was contributing $z,ooo annually to cover the school's current expenses; this annual donation increased to $3,500 in 1917, $5,000 in 192.0, and peaked at $7,500 in ijz^. In addition, the board made substantial contributions to the improvement of Fort Valley's physical plant. In 1928, for example, $100,000 was donated to the school for buildings and equipment. During this entire period Fort Valley was literally starved for financial aid, and the philanthropists, with their immense and desperately needed funds, had within their power the resources to assure Fort Valley's continuation. Hence they held a whip over Fort Valley's administrators and teachers.Zi Philanthropic domination required and conditioned new types of black trustees, teachers, and students. Because Principal Davison had originally emphasized liberal arts training, the black trustees, teachers, and students attracted to the schools during his era did not fit easily with Hunt's program of simple agricultural and domestic training. Thus when W. T. B. Williams, a black school inspector for the General Education Board, investigated staff relations at Fort Valley in 1906, he discovered some "very positive opposition to Mr. Hunt" among "the colored trustees and a set of the young men teachers of the school." From the philanthropists' standpoint, all such resistance stood in the way of any effective and rapid development of industrial education. Consequently, with Hunt and Torbert's cooperation, the philanthropists mounted a successful campaign to remove from Fort Valley virtually all black trustees and teachers who opposed the new order.13 In the spring of 1907, Peabody conveyed to Torbert his growing discontent with Fort Valley's black trustees. Torbert replied: "Mr. Meyers has written me how you feel towards Fort Valley in view of the presence on the Board of Trustees of a number of incompetent members, a matter which you very kindly discussed with me at Lake George last summer. I want to assure you that I see clearly the need of dropping most, if not all of the local colored Trustees, for the reason that they are not the proper kind of material for the school to depend upon and Mr. Hunt thinks likewise." Torbert agreed to use his influence to rearrange Fort Valley's Board of Trustees to "inspire a larger confidence in the school among our northern constituency." Principal Hunt also promised his assistance. The great "purge" of black trustees came in June 1907, when Torbert
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
i zy
and white trustees Matthews and Gray used questionable tactics to remove the black trustees. Torbert described their arbitrary actions to Peabody: The Board was called to meet Friday, but we did not get a quorum. By the keenest strategy in parliamentry usages, we took up the matter of revising the Board and began the transaction of business without a quorum. It was embarrassing to take up the matter of revising the Board, as those aimed at for elimination were in evidence and were contending for what they termed their "rights." But we mastered the situation by voting that we all tender our resignation and appoint a committee of three men to confer and recommend to the Board for trustees such men as in their judgment are best suited to serve. Col. Matthews, Mr. Hunt and myself compose this committee, Col. Matthews naming me chairman of the committee. The new committee, having secured the resignations of all the trustees present, refused to recommend the black trustees for appointment.2-4 The search for new trustees reveals that the philanthropists desired blacks who held to Booker T. Washington's ideology and believed in the Hampton-Tuskegee model of industrial education. Peabody nominated W. H. Spencer, a leading black educator in Columbus, Georgia, who was sympathetic to the industrial education program. Torbert recommended E. R. Carter, pastor of the Atlanta Friendship Baptist Church and one of the most influential black clergymen in Georgia. Black educators W. T. B. Williams and Robert R. Moton of Hampton, and Warren Logan of Tuskegee, Hunt's brother-in-law, were also suggested. The ideological character of these nominations became even clearer when someone, mistakenly perhaps, nominated W. B. Matthews, a black school principal in Atlanta, Georgia, who was critical of the Washington philosophy. Torbert acted quickly to remove Matthews from the list of nominees and stated his reasons explicitly: "He has a record of being opposed to Booker T. Washington and his methods of education. I don't think he is the man we should desire for a trustee of Fort Valley." The Fort Valley Board of Trustees was reorganized with Warren Logan, W. H. Spencer, and E. R. Carter as the new black members. The philanthropists, pleased with this arrangement, demanded one more major change: they wanted to remove Lee O'Neal, the black president of the board, and replace him with a white. Philadelphia trustee James H. Schenck wrote to George Foster Peabody: "I am convinced that the Fort Valley High and Industrial School can be made a grand success if we only had a good white man as President." So Peabody telegrammed Torbert and requested that the trustees elect Theodore J. Lewis as the new white president. Following the annual meeting in June 1907, Lee O'Neal wrote to Peabody that
12,8
The Education of Blacks in the South
"Mr. Theo. J. Lewis was elected Chairman, according to your directions and also in accord with a telegram received by Mr. Torbert from you." O'Neal was made vice-president.Z5 Parallel to the movement to reorganize Fort Valley's Board of Trustees, Principal Hunt waged his own successful campaign to weed out opposing black teachers. When W. T. B. Williams inspected Fort Valley for the philanthropists in 1906, he recorded that three men teachers stood "aloof" and were not "in sympathy with the working of the school." Williams described these teachers as "young fellows and fully conscious of their own importance" who could not "lose themselves in their work and forget about their rights, restrictions, and the like." Between 1905 and 1908, Hunt dismissed all of these teachers and more. In March 1906, he abruptly terminated the appointment of the music teacher, S. Madora Watts. According to Watts, "Mr. Hunt demanded then and there my resignation, without a moment's notice or alleging any reasons therefor." Later, Hunt replied that she was terminated "for a lack of interest in the conduct and affairs of the school." In February 1907, Levi Nelson, Jr., resigned his teaching position to avoid a violent confrontation with Hunt. "I have tolerated long enough with his thrusts, insinuations, etc., until I can bear no more and feel that for my own sake I had better leave here, for fear if he makes one more funny move, someone will get hurt." Nelson reported that working conditions at the school were very unpleasant because Hunt interfered with the work and rights of several teachers. Similarly, R. T. Bowles complained about Hunt's harassment of the Fort Valley teaching staff. S. A. Grant, a teacher in the academic department, resigned in July 1907. Grant maintained that at least five teachers suffered continuously from Hunt's actions, for no other reason than "an honest difference of opinion as to our social freedom and personal rights." He further charged that "individual action and thought," unless in conformity with Hunt's policies, was exercised at "very great hazard" to one's position in the school. In short, the philanthropists and Hunt dismissed virtually all of the black trustees and teachers who came to Fort Valley under Davison's principalship, especially those not firmly committed to the Hampton-Tuskegee model of industrial education.16 As would be expected, educational and leadership changes had a significant impact on Fort Valley students. Since 1890, students from Georgia's Black Belt had enrolled at Fort Valley primarily to obtain a liberal arts education. As Davison told the philanthropists in 1903, black students "came with the notion that school was not the place for anything but the books." Davison reported that only through "persistent effort" could he interest a few students in manual labor, practical farming, and gardening. Hunt soon discovered that Davison was right: "It is a sad
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
12.9
thing that so few students choose agriculture." As Fort Valley changed from a liberal arts to an industrial school, however, students were coerced to select industrial programs. Many rebelled against the new emphasis on industrial training. As soon as Davison resigned and Miller, the Fort Valley carpenter, became acting principal, a significant number of students left the school. C. H. Nixon, the black secretary of Fort Valley's Board of Trustees, reported the changes in student enrollment to Peabody: The moment he was placed there the people began to complain, notwithstanding the fact that he was placed there until a better man could be secured. The school opened with less than a dozen students while in previous years it has opened with not less than seventy-five or a hundred; up to the present time there are less than forty while every other year at this time the number has reached 2.00; most of the students of the <jth and zoth grades have entered other schools, feeling that Miller could not instruct them. Such problems continued over the next three years as Hunt pressured the students to conform to the industrial program. By the spring of 1907, Hunt's campaign threatened to tear the school asunder. Assistant Principal Torbert was especially disturbed by the disappearance of the male students. "Most of the boys," Torbert observed, "had for various reasons left the school and gone either to their homes or to work elsewhere." In the fall of 1907, black teacher Levi Nelson noted that Hunt had "been so rough on the student body as a whole that quite a number have threatened to leave." Undoubtedly, many of the students caught in the transition from liberal arts to industrial training resisted the changes, but in the long run, Hunt admitted students who were more amenable to industrial education.2-7 By 1910, Fort Valley had new black trustees, teachers, and students, and virtually no traces of Davison's regime remained. The school offered industrial training to approximately five hundred black students annually. W. T. B. Williams made a second survey of the school for the General Education Board in 1914 and found Hunt conducting "the most thorough-going industrial school in Georgia." Great pressure was placed on black students to take practical farming and gardening. Hunt contended that it was "absolutely necessary" to give "special inducements" to students interested in industrial training. In 1915 he asked the General Education Board to help Fort Valley purchase fifty-five acres of additional farm land for agricultural training. Particularly, Hunt aimed to convince the local community, "especially the whites," that Fort Valley was "earnest about the matter of teaching students to work." Fort Valley students, like those at Hampton and Tuskegee, were required to spend a
130
The Education of Blacks in the South
considerable amount of their time doing common labor. Every student had to major in some form of menial labor such as laundering, cooking, or the care and cultivation of fruit trees. Special stress was laid on training in agriculture at a time when only 12..8 percent of Georgia's 86,789 black farm operators were owners. Fort Valley's student-teachers were being prepared to socialize their prospective pupils for the role of common laborer for white landowners. This trend pleased northern philanthropists, and Hunt received annual donations from the General Education Board, the Phelps-Stokes Fund, and the John F. Slater Fund. Peabody was convinced that Hunt had implanted industrial education in the "strategic center" of the South. The philanthropists gave Hunt their highest praises for his loyalty to industrial training. "I am proud of the good work you have done and I am bound to say that you have more than fulfilled all the expectations which Mr. Peabody and I had when you were chosen for the position at Fort Valley," wrote Buttrick to Hunt in i9zz. z8 Economic dependency on industrial philanthropy required and conditioned a different kind of black leadership. In choosing Davison's successor, the philanthropists searched for a principal who was willing to accommodate to white authority, agreeable to placing control of Fort Valley in the hands of white authority, and committed to the HamptonTuskegee model of industrial normal education. The philanthropists disliked Davison for being "uppity" or too assertive in the presence of whites. Buttrick made private references to the black educator as the "esteemed Davison," and trustee Gray joined with his own sarcastic characterization of the principal as the "illustrious Davison." A school inspector for the General Education Board, David E. Cloyd, accused Davison of "insolence" and reported on one occasion that Gray was compelled "to throw Davison, bodily, out of his office at the Bank." Indeed, Davison was very assertive. Moreover, he insisted that black people should control their own educational institutions because "one learns to govern only by governing." "I have always thought," wrote Davison to Peabody, "that the colored man, when it comes to schools for his own people, should not only have considerable voice, but should be required to largely govern them, for the object of all education is to develop the power of self-government." Thus Davison appointed many blacks to Fort Valley's Board of Trustees and put them in charge of important committees. This disturbed the white trustees. As E. C. Branson complained to Peabody, "I shall discharge my duties as trustee to the very best of my ability, but with two Negroes with me on the committee to select teachers, they hold the reins, and at some critical juncture may run away with a most important department of our work."*9 In contrast to their perceptions of Davison, the white philanthropists
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
131
and trustees viewed Hunt as more accommodating to white authority. White trustees E. C. Branson and Gray were particularly pleased with Hunt. "Mr. Gray says that Hunt is a gentleman," Branson informed Buttrick, "and when Mr. Gray says a thing like that about a darky, he must be a wonderful darky." Branson saw Hunt as a "man of capability, common sense, and devotion, a useful man." Beyond the opinions, however, Hunt was clearly more accommodating to white intervention. "I believe we shall for sometime need not only the financial help, but the sympathetic cooperation and wise counsel of men, who like yourself, are interested in such work and who by reason of broader training are better able to give wholesome advice," said Hunt to Peabody. Under Hunt's principalship, the philanthropists had a firm voice in deciding Fort Valley's programs and policies.30 Increased philanthropic control significantly affected the role of black trustees and teachers in shaping Fort Valley's development. Against the onslaught of philanthropic intervention, Davison based his leadership on the support of the black staff and delegated much authority to them. According to W. T. B. Williams, under Davison the black trustees shared very largely in the immediate control of the school. "Their opinion was asked apparently, even if not followed, about every little thing." Hunt, however, generally did not consult the black trustees about the affairs of the school. Similarly, he hired and dismissed teachers without the advice of Fort Valley's Teachers' Committee. Even Torbert, Hunt's main supporter, complained that the principal was "getting rid of some of the best material available in the race without giving good reasons for the making of such changes." Yet as long as the philanthropists and white trustees did not complain, Hunt saw no need to consult the black staff. "I may be wrong," he said to Peabody, "but as I have seen and known colored schools it seems a necessity that one person should be in control, especially in the management of the teaching force." Hunt maintained that committees led invariably to "disaffection and discontent," which he proposed to remedy through one-man rule. This relationship to philanthropic power resulted in self-contradictory leadership that frequently characterized the black leaders of such institutions as Fort Valley. On one hand, they accommodated the interests of white philanthropists and trustees, and, on the other, they ruled their black staff, faculty, and students with an iron hand. This schizophrenic behavior made sense within the larger framework of black oppression. The white philanthropists and trustees searched for a principal who could efficiently put into practice their ideology of black education. The execution of their orders, however, required autocratic rule because black teachers in general were not inclined to impose upon black schoolchildren a model of industrial education designed to turn them into unskilled and semiskilled laborers.31
132.
The Education of Blacks in the South
Fort Valley typified the widespread efforts by philanthropists and their allies to induce black high schools, normal schools, and colleges to establish industrial teacher training courses to produce teachers for the black common schools. The philanthropists found it impossible to cooperate with existing institutions because of fundamentally different conceptions of the purpose of black education in general and different philosophies of the nature and goals of industrial education in particular. Other organizations significantly involved in the development of black secondary and normal schools and colleges—Congregationalists, Baptists, Methodist Episcopalians, Presbyterians, African Methodist Episcopal, Colored Methodists, and African Methodist Zion—gave some attention to industrial education. Within the schools controlled by these organizations, however, industrial education remained in a secondary role, was used mainly to prepare select individuals for skilled occupations, and certainly was not advocated as a core curriculum for the training of teachers. Whereas most organizations and individuals involved in black education viewed the preparation of teachers as primarily academic training, the philanthropists saw industrial training as the very foundation of teacher education. From the philanthropists' standpoint, there was but one appropriate model of teacher education for blacks, that of Hampton and Tuskegee. Their extreme devotion to the Hampton-Tuskegee model of industrial normal education placed them at odds with the general flow of black teacher training and compelled them to attempt a major transformation of it as in the Fort Valley case.31 Conflict over the content and goals of black teacher training institutions emerged early in the twentieth century. Soon after the General Education Board was established in 1902, its agents undertook a careful inspection of the black private secondary schools, normal schools, and colleges. The board's inspectors started in 1903 with the schools operated by the American Baptist Home Mission Society. Then the society supported twelve colleges and fourteen secondary schools for black youth. In December 1903, Wallace Buttrick filed a preliminary report on eight of the society's black colleges and noted that their major problem was too much emphasis on classical and higher literary training. Jackson College in Mississippi taught Latin and Greek; Alabama Baptist University, aiming "to develop a classical school for negroes," offered Latin and Greek in the second year of "the so-called Normal Department"; and Shaw University in North Carolina emphasized "classical training." In 1904 Buttrick, with the help of school inspectors W. T. B. Williams and David Cloyd, continued his assessment of black private institutions. Buttrick himself visited scores of black private institutions, completing a journey of forty-five hundred miles between 5 and 2.2, October 1904. He found that Leland University in New Orleans, formerly under the Baptist
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
133
Home Mission Society, had an endowment of over $100,000 and "fine property of some 18 acres with two large buildings." Moreover, Leland exerted "a wide influence among the 75,000 colored Baptists of Louisiana." "It is my judgment, however," said Buttrick, "that it holds too strictly to classical ideals and that under the present president the school is not likely to take any active interest in training the negro for productive efficiency." Any black institution emphasizing classical liberal education was regarded by Buttrick as impractical and not geared to prepare black youth for useful citizenship and productive efficiency.33 Even those institutions offering a considerable amount of industrial education were viewed as misguided so long as the industrial training was not used primarily for the preparation of teachers. Bishop College in Marshall, Texas, for instance, had a fine and well-equipped building for men's industrial work, including blacksmithing, carpentry, machine work in wood and iron, and facilities for mechanical drawing. Buttrick described the teacher of men's industries as a man of "undoubted high character, general intelligence, and mechanical skill." Yet the fundamental flaw in this program, according to Buttrick, was that the instructor was not a trained teacher and did not know how to transform industrial training into a program of teacher education. Thus, said Buttrick, "He can supervise the erection of buildings, can train the young men in carpentry, iron work, etc., but he is not prepared to direct a manual training department or to train the students as teachers." Buttrick emphasized a point often misunderstood by his contemporaries and later historians. Many then and now believed that industrial education was advocated in the secondary schools, normal schools, and colleges to train individuals for industrial occupations. Industrial philanthropists, however, believed industrial education courses were central in the training of teachers. Buttrick was not the least bit concerned about the failure of such courses to produce skilled industrial workers. "The chief sign of weakness," said he, "is a failure to make the industrial courses educational and a lack of correlation between the industrial and literary work." In short, the industrial work at Bishop was not designed, as it was at Hampton and Tuskegee, to train industrial teachers for the black common schools.34 In October 1904, as Buttrick completed his inspection of black private schools and analyzed related observations recorded by the General Education Board's school inspectors, he reached very definite conclusions regarding the potential role of philanthropic foundations in shaping black teacher training institutions. At Houston and Hearne, Texas, he visited two schools established, controlled, and taught by black teachers. Both schools emphasized "the classical and so-called higher education." After this experience Buttrick had seen enough of black classical liberal schools under the leadership of black educators and trustees. "I am led
134
The Education of Blacks in the South
to believe," he wrote, "that the negroes are not yet prepared to direct their own schools." He maintained that the really good schools for black youth had the counsel and advice of white people. More important, Buttrick had formed his own impression of what constituted a really good school for black youth. He recommended that all industrial philanthropy adjust its course to direct private and denominational schools toward "the true education of the negroes." In Buttrick's words: Denominational schools still have a mission and for many years will continue to have. But they should have well trained—modern trained—educators as principals, they should be "Hamptonized" as far as is practicable, they should largely eliminate Latin, Greek, etc., to say nothing of piano music and the like, they should teach agriculture and related industries with constant and growing appreciation of the educational values in such courses; in a word, they should "choose and object" and direct all efforts to the accomplishment of that clearly defined and clearly seen object, viz.—such training of the negro for the life that now is as shall make of him a producer—a servant—of his day and generation in the highest sense. Black private institutions in general, as Fort Valley in particular, had to be transformed because the principals were not modern in that they held to the classical liberal curriculum. The schools were not "Hamptonized" as they taught Latin, Greek, piano music, and other academic subjects aside from the "three R's." The industrial courses, when offered, were designed to produce skilled workers and not to train industrial teachers who would socialize black children to be common laborers and servants in the South's caste economy. How could the black private institutions be changed? "Do not give them a dollar," advised Buttrick, "unless they accept supervision, do genuine work, and hold to a course of study in which there is orderly progress from the elementary to the secondary." His report and recommendations were read by John D. Rockefeller, Jr., and Frederick T. Gates and, according to Gates, "We have no doubt of the justice of your observations." Gates concluded that the philanthropists should use all their influence toward the ends set forth by Buttrick.35 In pursuing this course the philanthropists found moderate success and a great deal of opposition. Those institutions supported by the various religious denominations continued to regard academic or literary education as the most important facet of their work and strongly objected to the notion that academic subjects should be subordinated or correlated to industrial training. In 1900 the American Missionary Association supported five major black colleges—Fisk, Talladega, Tougaloo, Straight, and Tillotson—along with forty-three normal schools for black
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
135
youth. The Methodist Episcopal church operated one theological seminary, ten colleges, and twelve secondary schools for blacks in the South. The Presbyterian church, U.S.A., maintained two colleges for men, five normal and graded schools for women, and eighteen coeducational graded and normal schools. The American Baptist Home Mission Society controlled twelve colleges and fourteen secondary schools. The African Methodist Episcopal church supported Wilberforce University in Ohio, Turner Normal School in Tennessee, Campbell College in Mississippi, Kittrell College in North Carolina, Allen University in South Carolina, and Central Park Normal and Industrial School, Payne College, and Morris Brown University in Georgia. The Colored Methodist Episcopal church established and sustained Miles College in Alabama, Lane College in Tennessee, Holsey Normal and Industrial Institute in Georgia, and the Mississippi Industrial College. These and other secondary and normal schools and colleges maintained by various religious denominations relegated industrial education to a separate and distinctly secondary role. As Thomas J. Morgan, corresponding secretary of the American Baptist Home Mission Society, wrote to Buttrick: "I feel very keenly the sense of responsibility for using what little influence I may have in developing our schools to a high grade, so that they may offer to the ambitious and competent young Negroes the best possible opportunities for self-culture, development, training and preparation, for life's duties." Although most of the denominations were in favor of annexing industrial training courses, they would not transform their institutions into either trade schools or industrial normal schools. The power and prestige of the great philanthropic foundations could not influence the denominations to abandon their primary commitment to classical liberal education, even though this commitment meant losing badly needed money such as the funds contributed by philanthropists to Hampton, Tuskegee, and Fort Valley.36 The philanthropists' campaigns to transform existing black secondary and normal schools into Hampton-Tuskegee-style industrial teacher training centers met with moderate success among the growing number of small, independent black private institutions. The leading nondenominational schools were Snow Hill Normal and Industrial Institute and Calhoun Colored School in Alabama, Robert Hungerford Normal and Industrial School in Florida, Utica Normal and Industrial Institute in Mississippi, Manassas Industrial School in Virginia, Penn Normal Industrial and Agricultural School and Voorhees Industrial School in South Carolina, the High Point Normal and Industrial School in North Carolina, and the Fort Valley High and Industrial School in Georgia. Such institutions depended for their support mainly on voluntary contributions recruited by their financial agents in the North from philanthro-
136
The Education of Blacks in the South
pists. As the small, nondenominational, black private graded and normal schools multiplied early in the twentieth century, their principals and financial agents were forced to travel north for extended periods to raise funds just to meet annual expenditures. For most of them, successful northern fund-raising campaigns often meant the difference between financial life or death. The leaders of these institutions, whether committed to industrial education per se or to a pragmatic search for funds, were unique in their adherence to the Hampton-Tuskegee model of industrial normal education.37 For the advocates of the Hampton-Tuskegee model, obtaining the cooperation of a cadre of black industrial graded and normal schools was only a small conquest. These institutions in general did not have the physical facilities or teaching forces to accommodate a significant number of students at the high school or normal school grades. In 1917 Thomas Jesse Jones, in his popular survey of black private and higher education, demonstrated that the Hampton-Tuskegee offshoots and similar schools enrolled few or no students in their normal and secondary courses. For instance, Robert Hungerford, Snow Hill, and Penn Normal enrolled no students beyond the elementary grades, and Calhoun, Utica, Manassas, Voorhees, and High Point Normal were described as elementary schools "with a few pupils in secondary subjects." The secondary enrollments ranged from zero to thirty-four, and only a minority of those enrolled were expected to finish the tenth grade. Clearly, this population was not bound to make much impact on the black teacher shortage and would not go very far in spreading industrial education throughout the black common schools in the rural South.38 Meanwhile, the southern states were making little effort to provide public support for the training of black teachers. The annual output of graduates of both high school and normal courses from state normal schools and land-grant colleges was significantly less than the annual increase in new classrooms that the black public schools were providing, to say nothing of the replacement of teachers who left the profession. Moreover, not all of the graduates would teach. In a study made by Jackson Davis of the General Education Board in 192.4, it was found that southern state normal schools and land-grant colleges between 1921 and 192.8 produced 387 graduates from the normal departments, 33 graduates from the colleges, and 505 graduates from the high school departments. It was estimated that at least eight thousand new black teachers were needed that year just to fill the vacancies in the public schools. Hence, if the entire number of black high school, normal school, and college graduates from southern state-supported institutions had entered teaching in 1922, they would have constituted but 11.5 percent of the new black teachers required for the public schools for that year. The
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
137
state schools could not supply enough black teachers to fill the jobs in the major cities and towns, and these were the most attractive teaching positions in the southern states. The common schools in the rural South, where the majority of black children lived, had little chance of securing normal school or high school graduates and virtually no chance of securing black college graduates. Black private schools continued to produce the vast majority of secondary, normal, and college graduates, but they could supply only a fraction of the yearly demands for new black teachers. Throughout the first third of the century there remained a large vacuum in the South's black teaching force, especially in the rural common schools.39 ' Northern philanthropists were acutely conscious of this vacuum and sought to fill it with a unique educational institution, the county training school. Beginning in 1911, the General Education Board, John F. Slater Fund, and Anna T. Jeanes Fund decided to pursue their interest in the development of industrial and manual training in black rural schools through state departments of education in general and particularly through the preparation of teachers in county training schools. The county training school system was made possible in large part because the General Education Board devised a plan to place its paid agents as official staff of southern state departments of education. The board offered in 1911 to assist the state department of education in each of the southern states to employ as a regular member of the department staff a state agent for black rural schools. Virginia had already done so in 1910. Kentucky, Alabama, and Arkansas responded at once and were closely followed by North Carolina, Georgia, Tennessee, and Louisiana. By 1918 there were state supervisors of Negro rural schools in Mississippi, South Carolina, Maryland, and Texas as well. They were all white men of considerable experience as county superintendents or in other positions of school management. The position was modeled on the work of Jackson Davis, the superintendent of schools in Henrico County, Virginia. H. B. Frissell, principal of Hampton Institute and trustee of the General Education Board, brought Davis's work to the attention of the General Education Board in 1909. Davis, having been converted to the Hampton Idea, kept close supervision over the black schools in his county to make certain that they offered the right kind of industrial training. Desiring to expand Davis's work statewide, the board approached the state of Virginia and proposed to attach to the state superintendent's office a school supervisor, an educational administrator who would be an official of the State Department of Education and who would have permanent tenure and authority to work out a program of education for black schools.40 In 1910 Davis was appointed state supervisor of Negro rural schools
138
The Education of Blacks in the South
for Virginia. His appointment was confirmed by the Virginia State Department of Education, but he was selected "on the nomination of the State Superintendent of Education and the Secretary of the General Education Board." The board paid his salary, $1,500 a year, and travel expenses, which amounted to $500 or as much as was required to cover expenses each year. He was required to file monthly and annual reports of his travel and administration of black rural schools with the board and the Virginia State Department of Education. The same agreement was made with other appointees as state supervisors. Although the state supervisors of Negro rural schools were officially responsible to the state superintendents of education, they took their assignments from the General Education Board. Upon accepting the position of state supervisor in North Carolina, N. C. Newbold wrote to Wallace Buttrick in New York to confirm the duties of his new position. Newbold understood his duties to be as follows: The position which I am to fill is to be known as, "State Supervisor of Rural Elementary Schools." In broad terms its duties are: To give special attention and encouragement to the upbuilding of the negro rural schools by helping to introduce into them all kinds of useful and profitable industrial education and vocational subjects; to promote better farming, better community conditions, better morals and cleaner home life; to endeavor in every possible way to make better workers, and better citizens of the negroes of North Carolina. In short, Newbold's job was to spread the Hampton-Tuskegee program of industrial education throughout the black common schools of North Carolina. Advancing the Hampton-Tuskegee program was the primary responsibility of all the state supervisors.41 Under the authority and supervision of the state agents the philanthropic foundations developed and expanded the county training schools. The basic idea was to establish an industrial boarding school, centrally located in the counties of southern states, with facilities and teachers to operate seven elementary grades and three years of secondary and normal school courses to train industrial teachers for the little country schools. The county training school movement began in 1911 with the construction of the Tangipahoa Parish Training School for Colored Children of Louisiana. In the same year the General Education Board and John F. Slater Fund supported three additional county training schools. By March 1913, James H. Dillard, general agent of the Slater Fund, was convinced of the value of the "county industrial schools." He therefore wrote to the southern state superintendents describing this new institution for rural blacks and offering philanthropic funding to any county interested in creating one. The state superintendents of Alabama, Flor-
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
139
Image Not Available
Tangipahoa Parish Training School of Louisiana was the first of its kind. Courtesy of Fisk University Library.
Image Not Available
Wharton Negro Training School ofWharton, Texas. Courtesy of Fisk University Library.
140
The Education of Blacks in the South
ida, North Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia expressed interest and promised cooperation. By 1917, all the former slave states, except Missouri and West Virginia, had one or more county training schools. During the twenty-year period from 1911 to 1931, the number of county training schools supported in a given year grew from 4 to 390. This rapid increase indicated that the philanthropists saw great opportunities to spread industrial education through these schools. In its 1917—18 annual report, the board stated: "There is perhaps no more promising movement in Negro Education than the development of the County Training Schools, which offer seven years of elementary work, with suitable industrial courses, and in addition three years of high school work emphasizing the arts of home making and farm life; the last year includes a simple course in teacher training." Having failed or achieved only modest success in its attempts to "Hamptonize" existing black educational institutions, the philanthropists established their own unique structure of black education.4* For local authorities to receive county training schools, the board and the Slater Fund demanded that they meet certain minimum requirements. The school property must belong to the state, county, or district, and the county training school must be recognized as part of the local public school system. Further, the local school boards were required to make an annual appropriation for teachers' salaries of not less than $750. The board and the Slater Fund demanded a school term of at least eight months and required that the course work extend at least through the eighth grade. The philanthropists expected local school officials to add two years of high school and normal school courses for the training of industrial teachers. It was the policy of the board and Slater Fund to appropriate to each county training school $500 per year for teachers' salaries. This appropriation was made on a diminishing scale, in the hope that all costs would be absorbed eventually by local school authorities. The philanthropists also contributed funds to erect industrial shops, teachers' homes, and dormitories. Altogether, from 1911 to 1937, when the county training schools were finally integrated into the public school system of the South, the board contributed $1,488,678 to the schools, and the Slater Fund, by 1931, had contributed $1,2.08,475.43 The state superintendent of Negro rural schools was responsible for defining the county training schools at the local level and for selecting suitable locations for the schools, planning the course of study, and hiring industrial teachers and principals to staff them. The state supervisor for Alabama, James L. Sibley, defined the purpose of the county training school as threefold: "to give definite instruction in home economics to girls; in agriculture to boys; and in teacher training to both." The Georgia state supervisor, George D. Godard, viewed the county training
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
141
school movement as an opportunity to spread industrial education in black common schools and "to make the Negro a more economical, industrious, and profitable citizen." Supervisor J. A. Presson of Arkansas emphasized the county training school as a vehicle to "prepare the girls and boys for more efficient work and happier lives in the home and on the farm." The state supervisor in Tennessee, S. L. Smith, equipped the Dyersburg County Training School with a kitchen, "as nearly like a wellordered kitchen of the city as possible." "This will," Smith contended, "better prepare the girls to do cooking for the white people of the town." Before he could do this, however, he had to convert the president of the county Board of Education to the cause of industrial education. This man, a native white southerner, advocated, according to Smith, "that Negro children learn Latin, Greek, and Higher Mathematics." Leo M. Favrot, then state supervisor in Louisiana, saw the southern states' role in promoting the new industrial schools as analogous to the duties of the antebellum slaveholders: "Under the industrial system that prevailed in slavery times the Negroes were not left in ignorance, but were carefully trained along industrial lines. In those days the industrial slaveholder assumed a responsibility which in our day and time the state can illafford to shun. In those days it was to the interest of the slaveholder to train the slave Negro to become efficient. It is no less to the interest of the South today to train the Negro in industrial efficiency." Favrot eventually came to be regional director of the county training school movement, and he made a detailed study of the schools in 192.3. He reported that all the county school officials in the South were "making the training schools distinctly industrial and agricultural all the way through the course offered."44 Although the philanthropists found it relatively easy to sell the idea of the county training school to the state supervisors, it was quite another task to sell it to the black people of the rural South. Publicly, the philanthropists and their agents claimed that the county training schools were a response to a general demand for industrial education arising from the southern black rural community. Moreover, the philanthropists stated publicly that the money contributed to support these schools was given with no strings attached and that each county was left to define and construct the curriculum. "No attempt has been made to dictate what shall be taught," said Jackson Davis in 1918, who was then head of the board's southern black education division. Similarly, Leo M. Favrot wrote: "There has never been a serious effort to make uniform the training school course of study." These public pronouncements stood in marked contrast to the philanthropists' private actions.45 In spite of this and other pronouncements, the state supervisors encountered opposition from rural black principals and teachers from the
142
The Education of Blacks in the South
outset. In 1913 Favrot stated privately that rural black teachers' opposition to industrial training made it extremely difficult to introduce industrial education into the black rural schools of Arkansas. Four years later, John A. Presson, who succeeded Favrot as state supervisor of Arkansas, gained some insight into the underlying causes of the black teachers' resistance to industrial education. He visited the state's black colleges where a good portion of them had been educated. Presson discovered that the three black colleges—Philander Smith, Arkansas Baptist, and Shorter—were "not equipped at all, for teaching industrial subjects." Moreover, "They seem to pride themselves on their academic work, and take great credit to themselves for work offered in traditional courses, such as are given by leading colleges of the country." Because these colleges had in attendance "a considerable number of students who are planning to teach in the schools of the state," Presson was anxious to convert them to a more favorable view of industrial education. He was not very successful in this effort. Similarly, S. L. Smith visited the Haywood County, Tennessee, Training School in 1914 and discovered black teachers "attempting to teach four years of Latin, and neglecting a great deal of the [industrial] school work." Such matters reached the breaking point the following year, when James H. Dillard discovered a county training school in Georgia that had installed a classical liberal curriculum. The Ben Hill County Training School had changed its name to the Queensland Normal and Industrial Institute, and the principal had divided the institute into four departments embracing Greek, German, psychology, ethics, moral philosophy, economics, and evidences of Christianity. Dillard asked George Godard, state supervisor, to cut out the "objectionable part of this course."46 The philanthropic agents were particularly disturbed by what happened at Ben Hill. They recognized that many of the first teachers and principals in the county training schools were educated in liberal arts institutions. Hence the philanthropists paid for such principals and teachers to attend summer school at Hampton or Tuskegee so they would learn how to do industrial education the right way. In this instance, the attempted baptism failed. As Jackson Davis said of the Ben Hill principal, "I had hoped that this principal had received some inoculation of sound doctrine at Hampton this summer, but evidently it did not take." Davis understood, however, that the problem was much larger than one principal: "Many of the principals are not able to resist the popular demand of colored people for pretentious and high sounding courses." Both Davis and Dillard realized that such popular demands could be suppressed only by compulsion. "It is quite evident that we shall have to use more pressure in having the proper kind of work done in these schools," said Davis. Dillard thought that it was "high time" for
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
143
Image Not Available
"Domestic science" class at Marion County, South Carolina, Training School. The young women were being prepared to work as cooks in the homes of whites in the county. Courtesy ofFisk University Library.
Image Not Available
Ben Hill County Training School of Georgia. Here, black educators, by initially installing a classical liberal program, subverted the industrial education curriculum. Courtesy of Fisk University Library.
144
The Education of Blacks in the South
the philanthropic agents and state supervisors to get together, "where we could be perfectly quiet and could discuss and work out a good, sensible course of study for County Training Schools." In October 1915, Abraham Flexner, on behalf of the board, informed all the state supervisors that a meeting had been scheduled "in order to agree upon a program for the development of the county training schools and in order to discuss further the situation with which you all are dealing." In March 1916 Dillard convinced the southern state supervisors at a meeting in New York City to construct a uniform course of study for the county training schools.47 The New York City conference resulted in the appointment of Leo Favrot and Jackson Davis to write a course guide for the county training schools. This guide was published in 1917 under the deceptive title of Suggested Course for County Training Schools. It was much more than suggestive; it was a course of study to which all county training schools were expected to conform, and the state supervisors were charged with enforcing it. The course booklet outlined the typical Hampton-Tuskegee industrial education program, a knowledge of the three R's and a substantial amount of simple industrial and agricultural labor. It was recommended that the county training schools devote about one-half of their time to teaching the three R's and the other half to the theory and practice of gardening, cooking, woodwork, laundering, and routine manual labor. In addition to the industrial courses, it was recommended that each boy organize a "pig club" and each girl cultivate a home garden. The secondary courses were to emphasize observation and practice teaching, elementary principles of teaching, and school management. The teacher training course also included ample time for agriculture, gardening, cooking, sewing, housekeeping, canning, and similar tasks. The academic subjects in the teacher training course did not go beyond what was required for a first grade county teachers' license, which was very little beyond the subjects of the common school course. Studies of educational practices in the county training schools demonstrated that in general they conformed to the course of study developed by Dillard and Davis.48 At the time the county training school movement had its inception, relatively few of the black teachers in rural elementary schools had been trained in industrial education. As Favrot discovered in 1913, "Probably less than three percent of the public school teachers in Negro schools have normal training of any kind, and practically none of these are trained for industrial activities." The philanthropists and other supporters of the county training schools had hoped that the institutions would provide for black students a simple preparation for teaching industrial education in the rural schools of the county wherein the training school
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
145
was located. But the teacher training function performed by county training schools was never of major importance. The proponents of the county training schools were unconscious of or underestimated the changes in education and certification that were occurring in the teaching profession. As teacher training programs at the normal school and college level developed, the opportunity for even four-year secondary schools, not to mention county training schools, to discharge this function rapidly diminished. With higher standards for certification paralleling the development of professional standards, the job opportunities in teaching for county training school graduates diminished proportionately. By 1932., except for Louisiana, all southern states had abolished teacher training work in the public black secondary schools. The enrollment in the teacher training courses in county training schools was never significant. A report completed in 1928 demonstrated that of the 35,000 students enrolled in these schools only 324 students were enrolled in teacher training departments. The low enrollment occurred in large part because blacks who aspired to be teachers searched for a higher quality of academic education than was offered in the county training schools.49 In the long run, the philanthropists and southern school reformers were unable to direct the course of black teacher preparatory programs along the lines of the Hampton-Tuskegee model. As southern states and localities required higher levels of education for entry-level teachers, the roles of small private normal schools and county training schools diminished. As illustrated in Table 4_z, in the academic year 1929-30 very few black students were enrolled in the small private teacher preparation institutions; the majority were enrolled in four-year private colleges and universities. At this time, although 75 percent of the black high school teachers in the South had at least a bachelor's degree, only about 9 percent of the black elementary school teachers had at least a bachelor's degree. The vast majority of southern black students were enrolled in the elementary grades, and thus the teachers of the masses were still more likely to receive training in private normal schools and county training schools. Yet state teacher certification requirements and student aspirations converged to shape long-run trends away from the industrial normal and county training school models.50 Nevertheless, black southerners were left to contend with a significant structure that had been built to reproduce them as contented common laborers in the South's caste economy. Because they filled a void in black education that normally would have been filled by public high schools, the county training schools became a far-reaching and dominant institution in southern black secondary education. In 2.93 of 912. counties in fifteen southern and border states, the county training school was, for blacks between the ages of fifteen and nineteen, the sole source of public
T A B L E 4 . 2.
Total College Enrollment and Enrollment of Graduates in Institutions of Higher Learning for Blacks in the South, 1929-1930 Total enrollment
Type of institutions
Number of institutions
State teachers colleges State normal schools Private teacher-preparation institutions Public universities City teachers colleges Private colleges and universities
8 ii 2
Total
Regular session
Enrollment of graduates
Summer session, extension or correspondence courses
Number of institutions
4-year
3 -year
2-year
i -year
4 9 — — — —
32-° 546 — — — —
i 43 — — — —
13
866
44
M5 1 2-,433 — 583 — 8,219
8 ii
4 59
6,577 2,540 577 697 864 14,025
3 39
3ii — 388 73 J 74 ^563
86
25,280
12,787
65
2,509
2
Source: Caliver, Education of Negro Teachers, p. 93.
2 2
Graduate degree
— — — — 15 15
Normal Schools and County Training Schools
147
secondary education in 1933. Further evidence of the centrality of the county training school in black education is that 44.2. percent of all southern black pupils of high school age were located in counties where county training schools were either the only secondary schools or the ones with the most number of grades. In states with large black populations, the county training school provided the only or most advanced secondary education for 64.9 percent of black youth in Mississippi, 59.2. percent in Virginia, 54 percent in Louisiana, 5Z.5 percent in Alabama, 48.4 percent in Florida, 47.9 percent in South Carolina, and 40.2, percent in Georgia. These percentages increase when rural schools are considered separately. In 1933, 66 percent of all rural southern black high school pupils were enrolled in county training schools. The legacy of the county training schools was not so much in what they prepared black students to become as in the ways they shut off alternative development. Most important, the students who were forced to attend these schools because they had no other access to educational opportunities were denied good academic training. A considerable amount of valuable classroom time was spent doing simple manual labor exercises, and the socalled academic component was watered down to the lowest level. The graduates of the county training schools were not prepared to undertake college-level work, they did not attain occupational skills that were salable in the job market, and in the long run they were denied the opportunity to teach in the little country schools. After 1935 these schools were rapidly phased out or in a few instances transformed into public high schools. The development of these county industrial schools rested on the assumption that good academic education was dysfunctional for the world in which black children were compelled to live. This conception of black education was reflected in the structure and content of the county training schools and pushed them heavily toward an emphasis on work and social adjustment. The intended purpose of these schools was to make black children think and feel that traditional, high-quality academic education was incongruent with their station in life. Their purpose was to adjust black southerners to a life of subordination, and they were oppressive in form and content, except when their intended purposes were subverted by local school officials.51
5
COMMON SCHOOLS FOR BLACK CHILDREN THE SECOND
CRUSADE,
1900-1935
P U B L I C E L E M E N T A R Y S C H O O L S became available to the majority of southern black children during the first third of the twentieth century, long after common schools had become universal for other American schoolchildren. For the nation outside of the South, the common school crusade occurred between 1830 and 1860. Ex-slaves, as explained in Chapter i, waged the first crusade for state systems of common schools in the American South following the Civil War. Although they succeeded in instituting a public school system in a region where universal public education had been unknown, it was only partially developed when the planters returned to power in 1876 and promptly contained the expansion of common schools in general and particularly for black children. The planters' great conquest required the political support of white small farmers, and a virulent racism formed the cornerstone of this interclass bargain. By the late nineteenth century white small farmers were demanding a public school system which they expected to educate their children. This demand brought them to a point at which their own educational interests were at variance with the planters' traditional preferences for private academies which called for very limited state support for public education. But the political interests of the planters shaped their behavior in this instance more than did their traditional opposition to state-regulated, tax-supported, universal public education. They accommodated the white small farmers' demand for public education, but there were two important consequences of this bargain. Public school funds for black children were diverted to white children, and there was increased opposition to black education by both planters and white small farmers. Hence the planters' return to power in alliance with white small farmers suppressed the ex-slaves' campaign for universal public schooling. Consequently, black rural southerners, unlike working classes elsewhere in America, could expect little support for common schools from state and local governments. Thus following the
Common Schools for Black Children
149
planters' return to power in the late 18705, black southerners began to turn inward and attempted to construct and maintain the semblance of a common school system from their own meager resources. Much was accomplished, but it was impossible for such an economically poor social class to finance a system of universal education. Black southerners therefore had to wage a second crusade to establish common schools for their children.1 The economic and social forces that were aligned against universal education for black children in the Reconstruction era still existed at the dawn of the twentieth century. For the profitable growing of cash crops, chiefly cotton and tobacco, planters considered a cheap labor supply as essential and regarded black agricultural laborers as the mainstay of their exploited work force. Many planters, believing that schooling actually spoiled a good field hand, preferred their laborers illiterate or at best semiliterate. Moreover, the labor needs for growing cash crops and the rhythms of economic life were inherently opposed to formal schooling. Nowhere was this clash between cotton production and formal schooling expressed more eloquently than in Richard Wright's Twelve Million Black Voices. Born and bred in Mississippi's cotton economy and speaking on behalf of the South's black agricultural laborers, Wright said: Sometimes there is a weather-worn, pine-built schoolhouse for our children, but even if the school were open for the full term our children would not have time to go. We cannot let them leave the fields when cotton is waiting to be picked. When time comes to break the sod, the sod must be broken; when the time comes to plant the seeds, the seeds must be planted, and when the time comes to loosen the red clay from about the bright green stalks of the cotton plants, that, too, must be done even if it is September and school is open. Hunger is the punishment if we violate the laws of Queen Cotton. The seasons of the year form the mold that shapes our lives, and who can change the seasons.z In 1900 significant numbers of black children and their mothers were breaking sod, planting seeds, and harvesting crops. Of black children between the ages of ten and fifteen, inclusive, 49.3 percent of boys and 30.6 percent of girls were engaged in gainful occupations, and the overwhelming majority of them, 404^55 out of 516^76, were employed as unskilled agricultural laborers. The proportions of white boys and girls of the same ages engaged in gainful occupations were zz-5 and 7 percent respectively. Almost one-half, 46.6 percent, of black children aged ten to fifteen were gainfully employed in 1910. Black women also were a significant part of the South's agricultural labor force. Of the 665,791 females reported by the census of 1900 as engaged in agricultural labor,
150
The Education of Blacks in the South
509,687 or 76 percent were black. The number of black women working as farm laborers increased from 509,687 in 1900 to 970,060 in 1910; this increase of 460,337 was more than three times the corresponding increase for males. More than 40 percent of all black women in America over ten years of age were at work in 1900, as against 16 percent of all white women. Further, 26 percent of all the black married women were in the labor force, but only 3 percent of the white married women of the country were at work. The majority of black males gainfully employed were also engaged in agricultural labor. These estimates do not include unpaid family labor, which was high for blacks in the South.3 Despite the structure and work rhythms of the southern agricultural economy, black children did not voluntarily sacrifice formal schooling for gainful employment. Rather, there were no public or private schools available to the great majority of black children, and in the absence of school facilities employment seemed the next best opportunity. Both the heavy use of black children in the agricultural labor force and the limited availability of black public schools reflected the planters' domination of the rural South. Where public schools were available black parents in general accepted the loss of child labor and additional household income so that their children would attend school. The southern planters understood black attitudes toward formal schooling and thus regarded the establishment of black public schools as a powerful distraction for their school-age laborers. The planters, therefore, used what power and influence they had in local and state governments to restrict the availability of public schools to black children. The structure of the black public school system at the turn of the century, particularly in the rural South, seemed quite congruent with the planters' economic and political interest. As illustrated in Table 5.1, there were in the South in 1900 2,136,016 black children five to fourteen years of age. Yet only 36 percent of these children attended school. Of the 1,120,683 black children five to nine years of age, only 22 percent attended, and of the 1,015,333 black children ten to fourteen years of age, slightly over one-half attended school. Furthermore, a full 86 percent of all those children fortunate enough to go to school received less than six months of instruction per year. Even when schools were available, most of the children lived beyond a reasonable walking distance of one and a half miles from the schools in their area, and the region's rough topography made walking difficult. Unlike for white children, southern state and local governments refused to provide transportation for black children. This structure of schooling for black children had been solidified since 1875 and at the beginning of the twentieth century seemed fixed for a long time to come. Meanwhile, processes of migration and urbanization converged with school reform cam-
TABLE 5.1
Elementary School Attendance by Race and Age in Southern States, 1900 Number of children 5 to 9 years old, inclusive
Number attending school
State
Black
White
Black
Alabama Arkansas Delaware Florida Georgia Kentucky Louisiana Maryland Mississippi Missouri North Carolina South Carolina Tennessee Texas Virginia West Virginia
118,403 51,793 3,548 30,401 151,516 3i,97i 93,447 27,586 134,2-9^ 16,837 89,833 119,669 63,012. 91,491 91,469 4,4°3
138,2.91 135,628 15,891 40,048 161,648 2.41,2.87 98,42.8 105,159 87,836 353,92.7 I 73.53 I 74,594 101,783 339,863 149,159 116,566
16,174 n,7i5 I I , 53 8,854 33,070 9,785 11,791 8,810 36,770 7,008 11,405 11,188 15,395 17,339 11,900 1,645
36,001 47,3n 7,775 !5,36i 58,855 94,543 18,315 51,077 37,835 179,566 58,116 11,644 7i,i35 80,501 57,639 49,159
1,110,683
1,433,639
146,173
896,853
Totals
White
Percent attending school Black
White
M
16 35 49 38 36 39 19 49 43 51 33 30 36
Number of children 10 to 14 years old, inclusive Black
White
Black
White
n 1,759 "9,767 J 5,345 34,604 143,32.5 118,498 86,582 99,678 79,505 32.9,937 154,019 67,435 184,430 300,480 135,218 106,658
43,8io 15,419 1,111 i6,439 61,190 2.1,594 18,751 16,857 62,279 11,697 44,783 47,853 33,5H 55,867 48,938 1,758
1,198,440
515,978
37
39 42-
105,916 46,7M 3,4°! 26,361 134,540 33, J 55 82,803 2.6,539 118,560 17,318 81,296 106,981 59,343 81,697 85,609 4,079
11
37
i,oi5,333
2-5
3i 19 11 3i 14 31 2-7
41 2-4
18 2-4 19 2-4
2-4
Number attending school
Percent attending school Black
White
80,917 84,881 11,646 16,943 100,198 170,711 56,705 79,8i7 59,44i 176,777 103,891 4i,959 133,177 141,086 102,251 88,199
4i 54 62 61 46 68 35 64 53 73 45 56 66 57 68
66 7i 81 78 70 78 65 80 75 84 67 64 7i 80 76 83
1,660,708
5i
76
55
Source: U.S. Bureau of the Census, Twelfth Census of the United States: 1900, Population, pt. i, pp. 6, n, 20, 24, 26, 42, 44, 48, 56, 58, 74, 88, 94, 100, 104, 353, 359.
152.
The Education of Blacks in the South
paigns by black southerners and northern philanthropists to point to a new day for common schools for black children.4 One of the most significant factors contributing to the second crusade for black common schools was the rapid rate at which black children were withdrawn from the agricultural labor force after 1910. Although nearly one-half of all black children aged ten to fifteen were gainfully employed, primarily in agricultural pursuits, in 1910, by 1920 this percentage had dropped sharply to 2.1.8 and it decreased to 16.1 in 1930. The migration of black laborers from the rural farm areas to the city was central to this emancipation of black children from daily labor. The migration, which started in full force in 1914, was also a key factor in forcing the southern white agrarian classes to reconsider the idea of universal schooling for black children. When the United States Department of Labor made an investigation of the black migration in 1917, its researchers cited increased support for a viable system of black schools as a means to "keep the Negroes in the South and make them satisfied with their lot." As a means of checking the exodus of blacks to the city, an insightful editor in the Jackson, Mississippi, Daily News made the following observation: A Negro father, if he is honest, hard working, and industrious, has the same ambition for his children that a white man possesses. He wants to see his offspring receive an education in order that they may be properly equipped for the battle of life. But they are not getting this. Every person who is familiar with educational affairs in Mississippi knows this to be the case. And it forms one of the chief reasons why thrifty, industrious Negroes, who want to get ahead in the world, who have a desire to live decently, are following the lure of higher wages and better living conditions and moving to the northern states. To be sure, not every white southerner shared this perspective. But the Daily News's conclusion, that black agricultural laborers should "continue to desert our farms, leaving thousands of fertile acres untilled," unless they received a "square deal" in the matter of education, appealed to the most stubborn planters.5 The migration opened the way for a second crusade for black common schools in the rural South. This crusade, known by contemporary observers and later historians as the Rosenwald school building program, was launched officially in 1914, the same year the migration started in full force. By the mid-19305, black elementary schools, though still far from excellent, had been transformed into a viable system of universal education. This transformation was effected by ordinary black men and women, local white s