SPATIAL PLANNING FOR A SUSTAINABLE SINGAPORE
Spatial Planning for a Sustainable Singapore Edited by
Tai-Chee Wong National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
Belinda Yuen School of Real Estate, National University of Singapore, Singapore
and Charles Goldblum Institut Français d’Urbanisme, Université de Paris VIII, Paris, France
In association with the Singapore Institute of Planners
Charles Goldblum Institut Français d’Urbanisme Paris, France
Tai-Chee Wong Nanyang Technological University Singapore Belinda Yuen National University of Singapore Singapore
ISBN 978-1-4020-6541-5
e-ISBN 978-1-4020-6542-2
Library of Congress Control Number: 2008920064 All Rights Reserved for Chapter 5. © 2008 Springer Science + Business Media B.V. No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper springer.com
Contents
Preface. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
vii
Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ix
Chapter 1
Sustainability Planning and Its Theory and Practice: An Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tai-Chee Wong and Charles Goldblum
1
Part I Global Development and Planning Chapter 2
Chapter 3
Chapter 4
Chapter 5
Planning the World Metropolis on an Island-City Scale: Urban Innovation as a Constraint and Tool for Global Change . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Charles Goldblum Sustainable City Centre Development: The Singapore City Centre in the Context of Sustainable Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ole Johan Dale Integrated Resort in the Central Business District of Singapore: The Land Use Planning and Sustainability Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tai-Chee Wong Singapore River: Six Strategies for Sustainability . . . . . . . . Chwee Lye Low
17
31
59
79
Part II Transport, Industrial, Housing and Nature Planning Chapter 6
Singapore’s Urban Transport: Sustainability by Design or Necessity? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Paul A. Barter
95
v
vi
Contents
Chapter 7
Chapter 8
Chapter 9
Achieving Sustainable Industrial Development Through a System of Strategic Planning and Implementation: The Singapore Model . . . . . . . . . . . . Kum Chun Seetoh and Amanda Hwee Fang Ong Public Housing in Singapore: A Sustainable Housing Form and Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tony Tan Keng Joo and Tai-Chee Wong
135
Vertical Living and the Garden City: The Sustainability of an Urban Figure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Xavier Guillot
151
Chapter 10
Nature and Sustainability of the Marine Environment . . . Loke Ming Chou
Chapter 11
Singapore’s Natural Environment, Past, Present and Future: A Construct of National Identity and Land Use Imperatives. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Min Geh and Ilsa Sharp
Chapter 12
Index
113
169
183
Conclusion: Beyond Sustainable Development? . . . . . . . . . Belinda Yuen
205
......................................................
211
Preface
In the last four decades, Singapore’s urban development has gradually received an international reputation. From a city of just under two million people in 1960, we replaced squatters and slums with mostly high-rise, high-density public housing as well as industrial estates, commercial centres and parks and gardens. We demonstrated to our earlier well-meaning critics that a high-rise housing programme need not be automatically doomed to failure. Indeed Singapore now serves as an example of shaping successful residential communities to the massive population of Asia. Our city is now at nearly 4.5 million people. It is green and clean, with flowing traffic, functioning infrastructure and proper space allocated for every urban need. It is no longer as clinical as it was in the 1970s, as we can afford to go beyond the basic needs and have added finer and more colourful things to our cityscape. Yet, when people ask me for books to provide an overview of the experience of our urban transformation, there are sadly very few. Singaporeans are more workers than writers. Not enough people have recorded how we did it, or shared the experience with people in other countries, or even with our own younger urban planners and administrators who are less familiar with the historical perspective. This matter is becoming very pressing as most pioneers who went through the start up process of transformation have retired by now. Some are no longer with us and so their valuable visionary yet pragmatic experience is gone for good. As the years go by, I have increasingly realized that there is a wealth of wisdom and know-how amidst us yet to be unearthed. The publication of this broad-based book on our urbanization effort, therefore, is most timely. But we should think of it only as a beginning. If I appear to be speaking rather immodestly about our urbanization, there are good reasons. More and more people, from both developed and developing countries, come to find out about our experiences. Despite the fact Singapore is only a newly developed country, our planners and a whole host of related experts are sought out by the developing world. In fact, it is because we are newly developed, and we have done well, that our experience is most useful. We learned the theories from the west, we managed to adapt them to Asian conditions, and we have had the strong support of our political leaders, who generally stayed clear of professional matters and let us do the right things without undue interference. Singapore in the last 40 years thus functioned as an urban laboratory in its full scientific sense. I can vii
viii
Preface
think of few parallel examples like ours. Our experience is therefore relevant to the majority of cities in the newly developed and developing countries, particularly in populous but land-short Asia. This book offers a peek into these experiences. Thai-Ker LIU Director, RSP Architects, Planners & Engineers (Pte) Ltd, Singapore Former Chief Planner & CEO of Urban Redevelopment Authority, Singapore and former CEO of Housing and Development Board, Singapore
Contributors
Amanda ONG Hwee Fang is a Planner with JURONG International, a whollyowned industrial consultancy arm of JTC Corporation, Singapore. As a strategic planner, she undertakes consultancy work comprising strategic, economic and feasibility studies for overseas industrial parks and specialised economic zones, particularly in the MENA region. She was involved in the consultancy work for establishing the institutional and organizational set-ups for free zone authorities and park operations respectively. Amanda’s research interests focus on sustainable industrial development, sustainable economic development, green energy policy and Renewable Energy Sourced Electricity (RES-E). Amanda holds an Honours Degree in Real Estate and a Masters of Science in Environmental Management from the National University of Singapore. H.-F.A. ONG, Jurong Consultants Pte Ltd, 8 Jurong Town Hall Road, #08-00, The JTC Summit, 609434, Singapore, Republic of Singapore. E-mail:
[email protected] Belinda YUEN is a Chartered Town Planner and Associate Professor at the National University of Singapore. She is currently President, Singapore Institute of Planners, and Vice-President, Commonwealth Association of Planners (Southeast Asia) (2006–2008). Belinda has widely published in the discipline of urban planning, most recently on planning vertical living. She is the editor/co-author of the following books that explicate Singapore’s urban planning: Development Control and Planning Law in Singapore, Planning Singapore: From Plan to Implementation, Urban Quality of Life, Sustainable Cities in the 21st Century, Enhancing Urban Management in East Asia. Belinda serves on various Singapore as well as international committees including on the Editorial Board of Asia Pacific Planning Review; Regional Development Studies; Cities; International Advisory Board, UN State of the World’s Cities Report 2008/09; Working Group 2 of the UN Commission on Legal Empowerment of the Poor. B. YUEN, School of Real Estate, National University of Singapore, 4 Architecture Drive, 117566, Singapore, Republic of Singapore. E-mail:
[email protected]
ix
x
Contributors
Chwee Lye LOW is former Head of Urban Studies Unit, Urban Redevelopment Authority, Singapore. He is currently consultant to a private consulting firm in Singapore. C.-L. LOW, Formely Head of Urban Studies Unit, Urban Redevelopment Authority, Singapore. E-mail:
[email protected] Charles GOLDBLUM is currently professor at the University of Paris – Institut Français d’Urbanisme (former director of this Urban Planning Institute) and senior researcher at the Laboratoire Théorie des Mutations Urbaines, French National Scientific Research Centre (CNRS). He is a specialist in the realm of urban planning, development and urban policy issues on Southeast Asia and has published several books and a large number of academic papers in these areas. He is presently involved in several research and academic cooperation projects (with RDP Lao, Indonesia and Thailand) as well as in expertise activities (recently in Cambodia). He has been Chairman of the Scientific Committee on urban development in developing countries, a broad-based research program launched in 2001 by the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs (Programme de Recherche Urbaine pour le Développement). C. GOLDBLUM, Institut Français d’Urbanisme, Université de Paris VIII, 4 rue Nobel, Cite Descartes, Champs-sur-Marne 77420 Marne-la-Vallée Cedex2, France. E-mail:
[email protected] Kum Chun SEETOH is Vice President (planning) at Jurong Consultants Pte Ltd and is also a Fellow and Immediate Past President of the Singapore Institute of Planners. She has over 30 years of experience in the planning and designing of townships, industrial estates, science parks, business parks; Special Economic Zones and recreational facilities in Singapore, Middle East and the Asia Pacific region. She is one of the key team members of the Singapore Business Parks Study Group involved in designing over 50 planning projects at home and abroad. She has worked on various strategic planning projects which include reviewing the Singapore Concept Plan (1978–1991); the Abu Dhabi Industrial strategic study (2004–2005); the blueprint for the South Africa IDZ project in 2003. Mrs Seetoh has delivered several papers at international conferences, and is author of papers: “Planning and Design of Industrial Estates for Regional Development in Singapore” for the UNCRD (1993); “Singapore Science Park MasterPlan Design” (1984); and “The Business Park Concept” (1997). In May 2006, she was invited by the Bombay Chamber of Commerce and Industry to speak on `City Planning and Development’ at the International Conference at Bombay. K.C. SEETOH, Jurong Consultants Pte Ltd, 8 Jurong Town Hall Road #08-00 The JTC Summit, 609434, Singapore, Republic of Singapore. E-mail:
[email protected] Ilsa SHARP, an Australian freelance writer, is a former Council member of the Nature Societies of Malaysia/Singapore. A Chinese Studies graduate of Leeds University, England, she has worked in Singapore/Southeast Asia since 1968 and is the author of some 20 titles on the region’s natural history and historical heritage.
Contributors
xi
From 1998 to 2000, she worked as Marketing and Public Relations Manager for Greening Australia (Western Australia), a national NGO dedicated to native vegetation conservation. I. SHARP, PO Box 170, Bentley, Western Australia, 6982, Bentley, Australia. E-mail:
[email protected] Loke-Ming CHOU is Professor in the Department of Biological Sciences, National University of Singapore. His research interests include coral reef ecology and restoration, and integrated coastal management. He has studied coral reefs in Okinawa and the ASEAN region and been a member of the Global Coral Reef Monitoring Network (International Coral reef Initiative) since its formation. He has provided consultancy services in the field of marine environment management to UNEP, FAO, World Bank, ICLARM (now WorldFish Center) and many national agencies. He has 70 publications in international journals and over 40 book chapters focusing on the marine environment. L.-M. CHOU, Department of Biological Sciences, National University of Singapore, 14 Science Drive 4, 117543, Singapore, Republic of Singapore. E-mail:
[email protected] Min GEH is a Singaporean eye surgeon and also President of the Nature Society (Singapore); she is a Board member of the Asia Pacific Council of The Nature Conservancy (USA) and a director of the Singapore Environment Council. She sat on the Focus Group on Land Use for the Singapore Government’s Concept Plan/Green Plan 2012 and co-chaired the Focus Group on Air and Climate Change. M. GEH, Mount Elizabeth Hospital, 3 Mount Elizabeth, #17-11, 228510, Singapore, Republic of Singapore. E-mail:
[email protected] Ole Johan DALE holds professional qualifications in both architecture and urban/ regional planning from the United Kingdom. His PhD is from the National University of Singapore. He has worked for a number of years in Singapore where he held senior positions with Urban Redevelopment Authority and private consultancy firms as well as lecturing part-time at National University of Singapore. His research interests focus on urban planning in Asia with special interests in sustainable development. He is the author of Urban Planning in Singapore: The Transformation of a City (Oxford University Press, 1999) as well as several journal articles. He is currently practicing as planning consultant based in Norway. O.J. DALE, Seberg 7, 6863, Leikanger, Norway. E-mail:
[email protected] Paul A. BARTER is an Assistant Professor in the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy at the National University of Singapore where he teaches on infrastructure policy, urban policy and transport policy. His published research has focused on various dimensions of the interactions between urban transport policy and urban policy more widely. Geographically the work has focused on eastern Asia with a
xii
Contributors
particular focus on Malaysia and Singapore (including their cross-border transport). His recent and current research focuses on innovation in transport demand management and the contested fundamental priorities of urban transport policy. P.A. BARTER, Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore, 469C Bukit Timah Road, 259772, Singapore, Republic of Singapore. E-mail:
[email protected] Tai-Chee WONG is Associate Professor at Nanyang Technological University, Singapore. He teaches urban studies and other human geography modules. He is currently Council Member of Singapore Institute of Planners. He received his BA and MA in Urban Planning from University of Paris and a PhD from Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian National University, Canberra. His main research interests are in urban and regional issues on which he has published books and many international journal articles. His three latest books are Four Decades of Transformation: Land Use in Singapore 1960-2000 (Eastern University Press, Singapore); A Roof over Every Head: Singapore’s Housing Policies between State Monopoly and Privatisation (Sampark 2005), and edited volume with Brian J. Shaw & Goh Kim Chuan, Challenging Sustainability: Urban Development and Change in Southeast Asia (Marshall Cavendish 2006). T.-C. WONG, National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, 1 Nanyang Walk, 637616, Singapore, Republic of Singapore. E-mail:
[email protected] Tony TAN Keng Joo graduated in 1967 with a Diploma in Architecture from the Singapore Polytechnic. He joined Housing and Development Board (HDB) in 1968 and became its Chief Architect in 1982 till June 2002. From July 2003 onwards, he was appointed Senior Advisor of Surbana International Consultants Pte Ltd., a subsidiary company of HDB. In 1998, he became a fellow of Singapore Institute of Architects. He contributed a chapter on ‘Physical Planning and Design in Housing a Nation, 25 Years of Public Housing in Singapore’, and delivered many papers in international conferences. The latest was at Asia Pacific Congress IFPRA held during 28 August–3 September 2005. K.J.T. TAN , Surbana Intl Consultants Pte Ltd, 168 Jalan Bukit Merah #01-01 Surbana One, 150168, Singapore, Republic of Singapore. E-mail:
[email protected] Xavier GUILLOT teaches at the National School of Architecture of Saint Etienne (France) and is a research associate at the French Institute of Urban and Regional Planning (University of Paris VIII). He received his DPLG Degree in Architecture from the School of Architecture of Paris La Villette in Paris and his PhD in Urban Planning from the University of Paris VIII. His main research interests are in urbanization, the study of globalization processes and cultural changes in relation to local identities and heritage. He has published academic articles, and has jointly
Contributors
xiii
published a book with Wong Tai Chee, A Roof Over Every Head. Singapore’s Housing Policy between State Monopoly and Privatisation (Sampark, IRASEC Studies on South-East Asia, 2005). X. GUILLOT, Ecole d’architecture de Saint-Etienne, 7, rue Etienne Dolet, BP 94, 42003 Cedex 1, Saint-Etienne, France. E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 1
Sustainability Planning and Its Theory and Practice: An Introduction Tai-Chee Wong1 and Charles Goldblum2
The more specific characteristics that make sustainability planning different from business-as-usual in the profession include a long-term approach to decision-making, a holistic outlook integrating various disciplines, interests, and analytic approaches, a questioning of traditional models of growth and acceptance that limits to these exist, a new appreciation of the importance of place, and proactive involvement in healing societies and ecosystems. (Wheeler 2004: 34)
1.1 Background of Urban Planning in Global Cities To begin with, the 1987 Brundtland Commission Report’s statement that “sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of the future generations to meet their own needs” (WCED 1987) may arouse little passion but it is necessary for resuscitating the origins of associating urban planning with modern values of sustainability. For over three decades, planning for sustainable urban development has been an attempt to monitor runaway and seemingly uncontrollable rates of urban expansion with particular relevance to developing countries. Not only that, but planning for the upper circuit global cities in the developed world has turned out to be equally critical as globalization and city competition intensify. What has characterized city competition is that it requires entrepreneurship and economic growth to support job creation, professional and skills training as well as research and development to enable further reinvestment. Accompanying growth are nevertheless the reward and outcome of tangible material incentives and motivation leading to rising automobile use, consumerism and waste, environmental damage, and greater commuting distances. Cities are increasingly
1 National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, 1 Nanyang Walk, 637616, Singapore, Republic of Singapore, e-mail:
[email protected] 2 Institut Français d’Urbanisme, Université de Paris VIII, 4 rue Nobel, 77420, Champs-sur-Marne, Marne-la-Vallée, France
T.-C. Wong et al. (eds.), Spatial Planning for a Sustainable Singapore, 1–13 © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
2
T.-C. Wong and C. Goldblum
designed primarily for car users, much less for pedestrians or cyclists. Globalization has also resulted in social polarization, exasperating the drive towards equity and wealth redistribution. Social sustainability is being challenged (see Sassen 2001; Hugon 2003; Wong and Yap 2004). Economic restructuring in the globalization era has strengthened links and interaction between major cities situated at the top of the transcontinental urban system organized in a hierarchical manner. The bulk of the surplus would be gained by global cities in proportion to their scaling effects of agglomerations and productivity levels, specified sometimes as “surproductivity”. Because of the multiplier effects of their high-value activities, global cities are also described as the “growth machines” (Logan and Molotch 2002). Financial liberalization and rising connectivity of the information and goods flow has nullified the physically rigid meaning of time and space (Bonnet 2000; Hugon 2003; Newman and Thornley 2002). Apart from highly localized issues, common problems, especially the global environmental ones which are considered counterproductive, are transferable across national boundaries. Indeed, the concern with sustainable urban development arises and takes place in a world of economic globalization and of technological revolution, a world where the financial market’s selective expansion and innovation in the realm of communications systems has benefited strategic urban locations specifically catalytic to economic growth. Cities having built up a silent but revolutionary capacity in mastering flows (goods, people and information), in terms of paths and speed could affect their position and functions, their scale and ability in coping with these issues. If the rise of ecological ideas and consciousness in the early 1970s has been associated with “zero economic growth” (a concept promoted by the Club of Rome during the first oil crisis) and with the ideals of small/local dimensions (Schumacher 1973), the relationship between global dynamics and local development as expressed by the notion of “glocalism” are associated with mega-urban dimensions. The processes leading to this new representation of urban growth, the way to master its effects at urban, territorial and world scales, and to match it with the ideal of “sustainable development” naturally question the significance and the very nature of urban planning. The objective of spatial planning for sustainability is primarily to counter the adverse effects of urban developments by means of systematic and organized land use planning activities. Sustainability planning has a holistic outlook which calls for an integration of the goals of the three Es (Economic, Environmental and Equity concerns) into an organized coherent system for a long-term objective formulation and plan implementation. No country can or should conduct sustainability planning in isolation, as the “stretching and deepening of global-scale processes” has exerted intricate interaction and reaction in one way or another on local scales (see Olds 2001: 19). The extent of local impact depends on the level of integration with the advanced economies, from supply and demand, trends and cycles in the international marketplace, as far as sales of land parcels in the city centres. Such a commodity chain is functionally organized on the premises of the international division of labour, the technological ladder position and the pricing mechanism.
1 Sustainability Planning and Its Theory and Practice: An Introduction
3
The potential for profitability is highly dependent on the timing and specific location of the commodity at stake. Olds (2001: 20–32) has identified five dimensions in which globalization could change urban space: (a) greater inflow of international financial capital and credit into the local/regional marketplace – their significance of growth in volume, complexity and transactions; (b) globalization of property markets; (c) role and intensity of transnational corporations’ activities; d) extent of the stretching of world social networks, social relations (impact of lifestyle by distant sources), and consumption; and (e) mega-projects which create new forms of urbanity. To be effective in sustainability planning, therefore, concerted efforts need to be derived from three levels: (a) both the public and private sectors at the national level; (b) cross-country cooperation at the regional level; and (c) intercontinental cooperation at the world community level. Within cities, movements such as “livable communities”, “landscape ecology” and “participatory planning” have been placed on the planning agenda aimed respectively at enhancing neighbourhood livability, preserving and restoring the natural landscape as well as sharing power between the top municipal officials and ordinary citizens in the planning and decision-making processes (Wheeler 2004: 16). Apparently, they all constitute desirable elements to improve quality of life and to tackle public health problems and deteriorating physical conditions that all citizens are concerned with.
1.2
The New Trends in Asia
As a matter of fact, urban territories are not to be considered as passive receivers of flows generated or accelerated by the transactional revolution (McGee 1998; Castells 1996; Ascher 1995). They react, adapt to this trend or even anticipate it. But haphazard growth and fierce world competition together with social and geopolitical insecurity tend to place mega-urban development and urban planning in a new and, in some instances, contradictory situation with regard to environmental issues. In Asia, the new trends affecting city status and the logics of urban development might be observed as in other parts of the world. Asia’s major urban regions have experienced, for example, urban peripheral expansion in the form of the “extended metropolis” (Ginsburg et al. 1991). Beyond the exclusive case of “global cities” like Tokyo, New York and London (Sassen 1991), we have witnessed the opening of selective places where there is a new generation of urban projects strongly related to new information and communication technologies (namely technopoles and high-tech corridors following more or less the NorthAmerican Silicon Valley pattern) to international functions and events (World Exhibitions, World Cups, Olympic Games). Developing new urban districts to incorporate a new stadium, a new university and research laboratory or other international tertiary functions is definitely not an innovation in itself; but these
4
T.-C. Wong and C. Goldblum
developments are now part of a typology of projects characterized by their large scale and their international dimension (in terms of investment resources, of urban actors, as well as of urban functions). New urban projects are also defined as a new way of making or modernizing cities which appears as a result of mega-projects led by investment opportunities more than as a product of comprehensive, problem-solving planning. Because of their strategic position in the world economy and their situation on the major international trade routes, also under the combined effects of the accelerated urbanization of their populations and of the accelerated transformation of their territories, South and East Asian countries are particularly responsive to these trends, which might be illustrated by some projects often presented as showcases (Antier 2006). Under the category of technological parks, we may mention the Hyderabad Knowledge Park, the Mumbai-Pune Knowledge Corridor, the Electronic City of Bangalore. Projects of this kind are often furnished with international airport and new town projects, such as Cyberjaya and the Multimedia Supercorridor in Kuala Lumpur Metropolitan Area or the Media Valley High-Tech Development Corridor connected with the Incheon International Airport in the Seoul Metropolitan Region. Mega-projects are also strongly associated with international events like the Olympic Games (Seoul 1998; Beijing 2008) or World Exhibitions (Lisbon 1998; Nagoya-Aichi 2005; Shanghai 2010). These projects have a direct or indirect effect on the whole urban structure, the redefining of the central functions, the shape and dimension of the core area (and often its exclusiveness in terms of land prices and eviction of the poor urban dwellers, and the rejection of their ‘informal’ activities and settlements). Furthermore, the extension and structure of the peripheral zone through an expressway and mass transportation have brought about mixed land use to the rural areas by creating new industrial zones with the support of foreign direct investment, often in association with public or private new town development (like Muang Thong Thani in the Bangkok Extended Metropolitan Region or the new town development in the Jakarta Metropolitan Region – Jabotabek). The “territorial revolution” introduced in the rural areas by these large scale developments also signifies a large scale environmental revolution. The mixed land use, if examined from a functional and social point of view, questions the compatibility of agricultural and industrial or even tourist land uses, the economic conditions of access to water, sanitation, transportation, employment, and even the participation of the local inhabitants in the decision-making process that had made these new developments happen. In other words, the holistic concept of “sustainable development” apparently warrants a strong claim to address the complexity of these issues. It should be noticed that these critical dimensions are partly or progressively integrated within the programme of urban projects, at least as a means of access to international loans, or to gain a positive image in the international city competition for foreign investment or tourist attraction. The object could be attributable to an extended awareness of the magnitude of the environmental challenge which the public authorities or developers have opted not to deny. Since the Rio de Janeiro Earth Summit of June 1992, many cities have adopted the principles of Agenda 21
1 Sustainability Planning and Its Theory and Practice: An Introduction
5
and, at least, implement green plans and create new urban forests and parks, like Beijing in the perspective of the 2008 Olympic Games, Bangalore in relation to its high tech corridor mega-project, Shanghai Century Park in relation to the development of Pudong. In this respect Singapore with its “park connector” system as an innovative urban development project is often referred to as a “model city”, a key for exporting its expertise in the realm of urban planning. But when it comes to the goals of sustainable urban development, how far can the remarkable experience of Singapore be separated from the specificities of the city-state? The dimension of Singapore’s territory questions its relevance to approaching the sustainable urban development issues. Also, the specificity of its urban planning system, the new generation of projects like high-tech corridors, regional urban centres, or the Punggol 21 waterfront new town – and most recently the multi-billion integrated resorts approved for Marina Bay and Sentosa Island which have been well integrated within the comprehensive urban planning system and guided by its Concept Plan – seldom exist in other Asian megacities. The case of Singapore appears to be an important prototype for reflection on the question of sustainable urban development and its specific conditions, practices and requirements in the context of Asian world city developments.
1.3
Sustainability Planning in Practice: Singapore in Search of Status as a Global City
Globalization has indeed a deep-rooted influence and implications for land use planning and related professional practice worldwide. While the globalization processes have generated a predominant proportion of revenues for the winners, a substantial part of the revenues are however used to counteract the adverse effects of globalization such as environmental pollution, heritage loss, widening income gaps or polarization, deskilling of certain categories of the workforce. This being necessary as the winners need to share power with the losers in order to sustain their profitable undertakings, and in doing so create new sources of revenue. Waste, for instance, can effectively be treated as a resource for renewed consumption. The practice of sustainability planning in Singapore is most significantly reflected by its economic-centred national planning programme, which at the same time is supported by other relevant measures of sustainability. The economic core is a policy presumption that economic growth is the key to the creation of wealth and resources to support other pursuits in the context of a city-state restricted by land and natural resources that survives in prosperity but is always fragile – a notion that commands a popular acceptability among the population. Growth produces environmental damage. But without remedial resources to prevent further damages and in order to safeguard long-term health and environmental integrity, sustainable environmental development would be hardly tenable. Figure 1.1 shows the Singapore model of sustainability planning. It portrays the interconnectivity and
6
T.-C. Wong and C. Goldblum Multi-ethnic tolerance
Birth incentive, skilled-led immigration law
Cultural Sustainability
Universal public housing & law enforcement
Social Sustainability
Demographic Sustainability Economic Sustainability
Environmental Sustainability
Educational Sustainability Universal education, skill training
Political Sustainability
National Green Plan, land transport policy
One-party dominance & efficiency
Fig. 1.1
The Singapore model of sustainability planning
integration of social, cultural, demographic, educational, political and environmental measures, with the core component being economic sustainability. Each of these measures is again backed by effective and pragmatic plans aimed at achieving sustainable results. For example, the National Green Plan which traces its origins in the “garden city” tree planting campaign of the early 1960s provides a comprehensive undertaking and commitment to the prospect of providing Singapore with a healthy environment, in eight ways: (a) averting a wasteland by optimizing the use of its limited land resources; (b) living in harmony with nature by permanently conserving some of its natural heritage and thus biodiversity; (c) ensuring clean air through rigorous enforcement of the law against polluters; (d) keeping the water flowing to enhance supply reliability, operational efficiency and recycling; (e) improving public health by a rapid response to disease outbreaks; (f) forging a strategic partnership to build up an environmentally aware citizenship; (g) enhancing external collaboration for tackling transboundary environmental problems; and (h) innovating sustainability by adapting world standard practices in sustaining environmentally friendly development (Ministry of the Environment 2002). Supplementary to the National Green Plan is the painstaking land transport policy of mitigating pollution and energy consumption. Tough measures were introduced to control car ownership in 1990, whilst the road network was expanded to cater for changing travel needs. Using the Vehicle Quota System (VQS), the car
1 Sustainability Planning and Its Theory and Practice: An Introduction
7
population was pegged to a maximum of three percent annual growth where potential buyers have to bid for a Certificate of Entitlement (COE) before car registration. Starting in 1998, the Electronic Road Pricing (ERP) System was used to monitor traffic flow and congestion. ERP gantry points that charge vehicle users during operating hours have been installed in many parts of the island for such purposes. In a sustainable way, the notions of integrated land use planning (to reduce the need for travel), promotion of public transport (to make it attractive and comfortable for commuters), and finally, the “users pay” principle is deployed as usage management measures to ensure a more optimal use of road space (LTA 2007). Guided by economic growth as the national planning focus, land use planning practices are primarily led by the Concept Plan.
1.4
The Concept Plan and Sustainability Planning
The Singapore Concept Plan was first drafted in 1970 with the assistance of a United Nations expert team to guide the country’s long-term development. It is a land use planning blueprint designated by a specialized role for meeting the national goal of modernization and to raise Singapore’s economic standing underlain in respect of industrialization, public housing, infrastructure and building a modern central financial district. In responding to the set targets assigned, planning practitioners have to conceive strategic and concrete measures in order to realize them and to bring their actions to a fruitful end wherever possible. These measures are constantly adjusted subject to the impacts and processes of internal and external movements, notably the globalization factor. Ideas and theories have often been adapted to practices that are suited to local requirements. The Singapore Concept Plan has a longstanding reputation for being continuous, and its consistency has been rendered possible by the same government being in charge over the last four decades. Established in 1971 on the basis of an export and multinational-led land use strategy, a full urbanization and infrastructural provision, supported by a “garden city” notion had been conceived to lift Singapore from a small to a large regional centre. Twenty years after, the Concept Plan was revised significantly in 1991 to reflect the newly identified goal of a dynamic global city that, in the early 2000s, promised to build a great city in which to live, work and play (Ministry of Trade and Industry 2003). In terms of planning approach, practicing planners in Singapore could well have been consciously influenced by the prevailing thinking of different periods, such as the comprehensive and rational planning of the 1950s and 1960s, largely of positivist origins. From the 1970s onwards, more attention has been paid to advocacy and community-based planning in order to seek for more public participation; Singapore planners in public authorities have been comparatively much less “critical” and complex than the British planners as Watson claimed the latter were (Watson 2002). Singapore public authority planners have been more effective in response to calls of national ambitions and “instrumental in action and as implementers to particularly
8
T.-C. Wong and C. Goldblum
set ends”. As a whole, notably in the post-1990s, planners have been involved in planning processes which are more an integrated and globally responsive approach in line with the ambition of the city-state in transforming itself into an influential global city. Accordingly, missionary statements had varied over time as they complied with the specific needs of each particular period. In 1991, for example, Singapore’s national planning authority, the Urban Redevelopment Authority’s mission was “to plan, facilitate and regulate the physical development of Singapore into a Tropical City of Excellence”. This changed to building “towards a thriving world-class city in the 21st century” in 2001, and in 2006 “to make Singapore a great city to live, work and play in” (URA 1995, 2001, 2007). In interpreting Flyvbjerg’s work Rationality and Power (1998), it may be understood that the link between the planner’s rationality and state power here is weaker in two-way communications but stronger and effective in implementation and adaptive modification of instructed plans by following up with changes in ideas or local/regional/global circumstances. Guided by American-led pragmatism and communicative rationality, communicative planning practitioners construct free spaces with competence and apply principles of logic, scientific and empirical knowledge to guide their actions (see Fainstein 2003: 175). The present trend among practitioners, in keeping with the purity of their profession, primarily avoids a close examination of the relationship between planning, politics and urban development. A common consensus, which appears popular, has been reached on how to pave the path of growth to build up a world-class global city. The focus of the most recent planning practice is revealed in the Concept Plan 2001 which has mapped out a vision over the next 40–50 years, based on a target population of 5.5 million. Land scarcity has remained the core planning element as it is expected that land demand will continue to rise following economic growth, which requires a larger population to support it. A greater variety of house types will continue to provide greater choice and also green and recreational spaces are made more accessible to the population. Flexibility and responsiveness are highlighted in support of businesses, especially those high-value and knowledge-driven industries able to help build Singapore into an international business hub (URA 2007).
1.5
The Chapters
This book is a collection of essays on a selected number of land use planning issues in Singapore. Of the two parts planned for the volume, Part 1 examines the relationship between the global development trend and the ways in which planning is organized and implemented in the context of a rapidly changing global landscape. In Chapter 2, Charles Goldblum focuses on the extent to which Singapore’s urban planning and approach has been impacted by world metropolitan development trends. Over the last four decades, the responsiveness of Singapore’s ruling government has been well reflected in its sectoral policies and strategic (social, economic, institutional, etc.) changes. The chapter aims to assess Singapore’s performance in
1 Sustainability Planning and Its Theory and Practice: An Introduction
9
its urban planning approach, ranging from the first Ring Concept Plan focusing on new town development in the 1970s to the current planning concepts of regions and specialized corridors. Urban planning has indeed been deployed as a tool for adaptation to the prerequisites of the international economy or for preventing adverse environmental and social effects resulting from this adaptation, and as a means of permanent strategic innovation (from “global city” strategy to the “re-Asianization” process). Changes in planning and orientations such as the heritage conservation approach in urban renewal or town councils in new town management are revisited and analysed. The ways where planned urbanization is being used as a key to sustainably maintain Singapore’s competitive advantages are equally highlighted. In following up Goldblum’s broad framework, Ole J. Dale in Chapter 3 presents a more detailed account of Singapore’s physical and socio-economic change in the city centre, from slums to modernity: what has taken place in the city centre is perceived to be most decisive in influencing its future path. It is a place that attracts tourist flow, a place built up with tall office blocks, retail outlets, convention and exhibition centres as well as being the cosmopolitan hub of the region. It is also a place that island-wide traffic converges on to witness commuting movements of a large number of white collar workers. Its importance has required sustainability planning to keep it up as a clean, green, efficient, pleasant and healthy environment. As a regional city and a global city, the city centre is symbolic of enhanced and global competitiveness, a talent hub and a centre for innovation and enterprise. Also pertinent is the city-state’s waterfront which acts as a magnet to future international design competition as a theme park. Its magnitude and scale capture international attention as a test of new elements of sustainability planning. The challenges are about environmental quality, reconciling environmental and economic needs and dealing with rising expectations. Singapore city centre stands as an exemplary vibrant core where it also manifests itself as a classic case of testing a good sustainable city environment. Tai-Chee Wong, in Chapter 4, follows up with a more substantive investigation of the current core activity in the Centre Area – the integrated resort at the Marina Bay. More specifically, his focus falls upon the newly emerged urban form being created downtown by global market forces to supplement financial and specialized services by high-value leisure businesses, seen as a rising pattern of Singapore’s post-modernist production system in the strategic and prime area. Hence, the chapter examines the changing and expanding functions of the Central Business District (CBD), and the circumstances in which this pattern has evolved and the land use planning implications. Arguably, it is interpreted as a continued effort of the citystate to pursue sustainable economic growth that requires the new input of knowledge-intensive and higher-end leisure industries. The sustainable economic development issue is justifiably weighed against the social issue, the casino. Chapter 5 by Chwee Lye Low deals with another Central Area issue focused on the revitalization process of the Singapore River – the lifeline of early migrants and local-cum-international trade. Lessons of sustainable development in this water margin and seafront figure most characteristically in tandem with its river cleaning
10
T.-C. Wong and C. Goldblum
programme in the 1970s. The successful clean-up has not only sustained fish life but has blended the reconfigured water landscape to support in subsequent decades the renewed lively night life along the river and beyond. It is a case in point that sustainable waterfront development practices carry a significance meaning in transforming as well as influencing the future of unique urban places with waterbodies. Part 2 examines sectoral sustainable planning issues in turn, beginning in Chapter 6 with Paul Barter’s study of Singapore’s urban transport policies which have often been held up by observers as model of “sustainable transport”. The chapter briefly interprets the meaning of sustainable development in relation to the arena of urban transport. It then applies the conclusions to a brief review of the claim that Singapore is an exemplar of sustainable transport. However, of most interest here are the rationales that have justified Singapore’s approach. Several pivotal policy choices were taken in the 1970s, before the idea of sustainable development was prominent. It is observed that locally focused, mainly non-environmental imperatives dominated Singapore’s motivations. The study also considers if there are underlying connections between the idea of sustainable development and the particular imperatives that prompted Singapore’s policies. The answers provide insights that may have wider relevance. Sustainable industrial development and planning is addressed in Chapter 7, where Kum-Chun Seetoh and Amanda Ong discuss the evolution and processes of the industrial policy from the 1960s to the present. They illustrate how Singapore began with the low-cost and labour-intensive industrialization programme which systematically transformed itself to capital-intensive and high-tech and high-value added over four decades. Industrial growth and the expanded market share have enabled JTC Corporation to pay greater attention towards environmentally friendly measures in order to safeguard the living environment whilst intensification of the industrial land has become inevitable. The study also highlights the important role of the industry as a key economic contributor in providing details of a multipronged approach towards achieving sustainable environmental and social development. Chapter 8 by Tony Tan and Tai-Chee Wong looks at the public housing of Singapore in terms of its longstanding and monumental existence as a sustained socio-political product serving the bulk of the population. Its form is characterized by high-rise and high-density buildings ornamented with ‘garden city’ greenery, and is complemented by central place services and infrastructure which have been in existence for over forty years. Yet, given its general popularity justified by the unanimous contention of land scarcity and ample potential in creating vertical living space, it is anticipated that this adapted Corbusian style and form will not merely continue but go higher to accommodate a larger population. Three key dimensions of analysis about sustainability are investigated by the authors: (a) social sustainability is imprinted by general affordability institutionalized by the self-financing central provident fund mechanism. This has been carved out in the political and welfare governance of the state; (b) public housing is integral to the economic sustainability because it is closely associated with Singapore’s growth-driven industrialization and
1 Sustainability Planning and Its Theory and Practice: An Introduction
11
urbanization processes; and (c) environmental sustainability is useful in countering urban sprawl and thus promoting energy saving through a more compact land use. Full state sponsorship and dedication have furnished a whole spectrum of technical expertise required for the planning, design, management and maintenance, laying the foundation for a sustained functioning of the public housing system in Singapore. In “Vertical Living and the Garden City: The Sustainability of an Urban Figure” (Chapter 9), Xavier Guillot’s interest lies with the sustainability of “Ring City” and “Garden City” to stay in people’s minds as a planning concept. In his exploration of this enquiry, he links it with the sustainability of existing urbanization processes and settlement patterns as they have developed in Singapore. By consensus, lowdensity residential living and high dependence on the automobile for commuting or urban sprawl beyond the city fringe driven by market demand does not fit in the sustainability norm. Constructing an urban figure sustainably involves equally sustainable planning of a cultural and political approach that deals meaningfully with the physical evolution of a place. A unique place is established over time on the basis of its identity, character and adaptability that are self-supporting in favour of a sustainable development. In Chapter 10, Loke Ming Chou’s study moves on to the marine environmental protection in Singapore – a small island state highly reliant on the port economy and its further expansion to support sustained economic growth. Four decades of coastal development and land reclamation have transformed the coastline and marine habitat to the extent of no return if we were to trace back to the earlier dynamic levels of ecosystem and rich natural heritage. Heavy losses in marine habitat, especially coral reefs, mangroves are seen to be a necessary evil given the little choice available for territorial and trade expansion. From the mid-1990s, greater care is given to environmental impact assessment, and the approach has also changed from a “close-door” investigation to a more transparent review, sharing public feedback to serve the end of sustainability. Efforts in favour of habitat restoration from nature activists and public authorities have helped to build up stronger biotic communities and to support a more balanced marine biodiversity. Since the marine habitat losses are never economically quantifiable, the future challenge is centred on the public’s appreciation of the natural environment and habitats, hence making them part of the quality of life that they value, and to which the government sees the need to accommodate. Another study on natural environment is presented by Min Geh and Ilsa Sharp in Chapter 11 from the perspectives of national identity and land use. For them, sustainability and preserving natural environment is tantamount to safeguarding Singapore’s identity and its “indigenous tropicality,” a uniqueness that needs to be differentiated from the parkland image of colonial and Western origins. As such, the local non-governmental organizations have a role to contribute. The identity with nature conservation has been established through the proactive involvement of NGOs, such as the Singapore Nature Society, academics and nature lovers and those conscious of or having a belief in conservationist movements as a means to arouse greater government commitment to preserve nature sites such as Chek Jawa
12
T.-C. Wong and C. Goldblum
(a shallow coastal marine habitat) and Sungai Buloh (a swamp). Their sense of achievement has often mingled with disappointment, yet hope has kept them going. Today, public–private collaboration in the dialogue for nature sustainability is increasingly evaluated as a norm; and joint public–private management of visitors to Chek Jawa has already become a reality. Negotiations and compromise between development and preservation go on. Belinda Yuen, in her concluding remarks, briefly reviews recent developments about cities, physical environments and worldwide concerns in preserving and maintaining urban livability in the face of adverse impacts. She goes even beyond the urban aspect of sustainability by warning of climate change and global warming – an earth and holistic issue which encompasses cities as centres of consumerism, an issue that makes an importunate challenge to sustainable development.
References Antier G (2006) Les stratégies des grandes métropoles: Enjeux, pouvoirs et aménagement. Armand Colin, Paris Ascher F (1995) Métapolis ou l’avenir des villes. Odile Jacob, Paris Bonnet J (2000) Mondialisation, Métropolisation: L’effet de la taille sur les activités des grandes villes du monde. In: Dorier-Apprill E (ed). Les très grandes villes dans le monde. Editions du Temps, Paris, pp 49–75 Castells M (1996) The rise of the network society. Blackwell, Oxford Fainstein SS (2003) New directions in planning theory. In: Campbell S, Fainstein SS (eds) (2nd ed) Readings in planning theory. Blackwell, Oxford, pp 173–195 Flyvbjerg B (1998) Rationality and power: Democracy and practice. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL Ginsburg N, Koppel B, McGee TG (1991) The extended metropolis: Settlement transition in Asia. University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu, HI Hugon P (2003) Mondialisation, métropolisation et effet de crise dans les éonomies en développement. In: Osmont A, Goldblum C (eds) Villes et citadins dans la mondialisation. Editions Karthala & Gemdev, Paris, pp 29–49 Land Transport Authority (LTA) (2007) Land transport policy. http://www.mot.gov.sg/landtransport/policy.htm, accessed 20 April 2007 Logan JR, Molotch HL (2002) The city as a growth machine. In: Fainstein SS, Campbell S (eds) (2nd ed) Readings in urban theory. Blackwell, Oxford, pp 199–238 McGee TG (1998) Five decades of urbanization in Southeast Asia: A personal encounter. In: Yeung Y-M (ed) Urban development in Asia: Retrospect and prospect. Hong Kong Institute of Asia-Pacific Studies, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, pp. 55–91 Ministry of the Environment (2002) The Singapore Green Plan 2012: Beyond clean and green towards environmental sustainability. Singapore Ministry of Trade and Industry (2003) New challenges, fresh goals – Towards a dynamic global city. Report of the Economic Review Committee, Singapore Newman P, Thornley A (2002) Globalisation, world cities, and urban planning: Developing a conceptual framework. In: Thornley A, Rydin Y (eds) Planning in a global era. Ashgate, Aldershot, pp 13–26 Olds K (2001) Globalization and urban change: Capital, culture, and Pacific Rim mega-projects. Oxford University Press, Oxford Sassen S (1991) The Global City: New York, London, Tokyo. Princeton University Press, Chichester
1 Sustainability Planning and Its Theory and Practice: An Introduction
13
Sassen S (2001) Spatialities and temporalities of the global: Elements for a theorization. In Appadurai A (ed) Globalization. Duke University Press, Durham, pp 260–278 Schumacher EF (1973) Small is beautiful. Blond & Briggs, London Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) (1995) Annual report, 1994/95. Singapore Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) (2001) Concept Plan 2001. Singapore Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) (2007). URA Website. http://www.ura.gov.sg, accessed 20 April 2007 Watson V (2002) Learning from planning practice? In: Thornley A, Rydin Y (eds) Planning in a global era. Ashgate, Aldershot, pp 143–162 Wheeler SM (2004) Planning for sustainability: Creating livable, equitable, and ecological communities. Routledge, London Wong T-C, Yap, Adriel L-H (2004) Four decades of transformation: Land use in Singapore, 1960–2000. Eastern University Press, Singapore World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED) (1987) Our common future – Brundtland Commission. Oxford University Press, New York
This page intentionally blank
Part I
Global Development and Planning
Chapter 2
Planning the World Metropolis on an Island-City Scale: Urban Innovation as a Constraint and Tool for Global Change Charles Goldblum
Urban planning in Singapore occupies a quite unusual position in the city-state’s development, as an engine for most of the sectoral and strategic changes that occurred during the last four decades. This fact is well admitted by many professional planners and urban research scholars. What might have been less observed or analysed are the links between Singapore’s urban planning strategies and its integration in the world economy. The hypothesis developed in the present chapter is that these two dimensions, the territorial one and the transactional one, may be considered as two faces of a “global city” project. In this respect, Singapore’s current strong position in the global economy is not to be taken as the simple result of a process driven by external economic forces (e.g. transnational capital involved in industrial relocation and foreign direct investment), but rather as a result of a political will, taking advantage of the strategic location of Singapore as a major seaport in the Far-East and using its exceptional planning and anticipation capacities in order to cope with its vulnerability as a small island-state in a period that witnesses the rising of large independent nation-states. Therefore, this chapter aims to approach Singapore’s internationally recognized performance in urban planning not only as a tool in meeting the demands of the international economy or for protecting the national territory against adverse environmental and social impacts, but also as a means for the city-state to keep its competitive advantages through permanent urban and territorial adjustments and innovations.
2.1
Global City as a Project: Urban Basic Tools for a Modern City-State
Initial institutional involvement in urban planning took place during the transitional period from the end of the British colonial rule to Singapore’s independence as a nation-state. Apart from the Singapore Improvement Trust already established in
Institut Franc¸ais d’Urbanisme, Université de Paris VIII, 4 rue Nobel, 77420 Champs-sur-Marne, France, e-mail:
[email protected]
T.-C. Wong et al. (eds.), Spatial Planning for a Sustainable Singapore, 17–29 © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
18
C. Goldblum
the late 1920s, some of the British key urban planning tools were introduced in the 1950s (namely the 1958 statutory master plan, and planning concepts for new or satellite towns and green belt) according to the recommendations of the colonial government-appointed Housing Committee in 1947. Later on, during the 1960s, a decisive period of upheaval for Singapore, new “action programmes” were advanced by a United Nations (UN) experts team as part of comprehensive development which were to be integrated in the State and City Planning project preliminary studies for the 1971 Long Range Concept Plan. This marked the beginning of strategic planning in Singapore (Dale 1999: 71–115). With the Concept Plan the dimension and scope of physical planning completely changed at least in four aspects. Spatially, the planning was meant to cover the whole national territory. Functionally, it was no more limited to sectoral approaches such as housing, or industrial zoning, but integrated in a multidimensional territorial development. In terms of planning concept, the ring concept organizing new town development was an expression of this integrative approach. In terms of objectives, planning was no more dedicated to solving urban problems (in the sense of a corrective urbanism), but as a way to rationalize the city machinery itself, and to make it an efficient engine for nation-building and economic development. In this respect, the key elements of the first Concept Plan of 1971 were a perfect match with the economic strategy, mainly industrial, in response to the 1965 failure of Singapore’s merger into the Federation of Malaysia. The city-state henceforth adopted a prospective strategy open to the world – a unique position in Southeast Asia that Singapore was quite well prepared to assume as a major seaport benefiting from international connections established by entrepôt trade (Rodan 2001: 138–77; Cheng 1991: 182–215). This economic development project is unique in fulfilling Singapore’s anticipated role in the regional economy of Southeast Asia and its vision to link with the world market at a time when other newly independent states were seeking a domestic market for their pioneer industries. Partly inspired by the earlier recommendations of the UN mission led by Albert Winsemius, this strategy of survival encountered harsh competitions and nationalist conflicts with the neighbouring countries. Concomitantly, Singapore’s critical situation of employment was further accentuated by the announcement of withdrawal of the British military bases. This strategy which was successfully promoted under the name of “global city” by the then Minister for Foreign Affairs S. Rajaratnam, though focusing on geopolitics rather than on the territorial dimension, furnished some clues for understanding the meaning of the Concept Plan, which was launched in the same period, as part of the global city strategy. Thus, in his 1972 speech, S. Rajaratnam explained that new technology, such as electronic communications, giant tankers and modern economic and industrial organizations, compensates the city-state of Singapore for its lack of direct hinterland by taking the world as its hinterland for exports as well as for attracting industries and investment. According to S. Rajaratnam, this position gave an alternative
2 Planning the World Metropolis on an Island-City Scale
19
to the traditional image of Singapore like the “Change Alley”, which he elaborated thus (quoted by Leifer 2000: 36–39): If we view Singapore’s future not as a regional city but as a Global City, then the smallness of Singapore, the absence of a hinterland, or raw materials and a large domestic market are not fatal or insurmountable handicaps. It would explain why, since independence, we have been successful economically and, consequently, have ensured political and social stability.
In Terry McGee’s portrait of “Five decades of urbanization in Southeast Asia”, the 1970s were characterized by “new forms of integration into the global system” (McGee 1998: 55–91). One of the main features was the development of free trade zones arising from Japan’s industrial strategy designed to export labour intensive firms and low value-added activities (like electronics in Malaysia) while orientating its national industries towards the high-tech sector. Another feature related to this global integration process has been the development of central business districts (CBDs) with office and hotel buildings, shopping complexes, etc. These trends might have enhanced to an extent the market competition Singapore had to face in this period. But it also shed light on some elements which differentiate the city-state not in terms of geo-economy, but in terms of strategy. While the neighbouring countries were trying to respond to the internationalization process, Singapore developed an attractive strategy for foreign companies which was not based on incentives such as profit repatriation, but on the quality and efficiency of the infrastructure that the city-state was able to offer in catering for the multinational corporations (MNCs/TNCs), on the top of which the security provided through state intervention or involvement must also be accounted for. The general orientations adopted for urban planning since the beginning of the 1970s fit in totally the guidelines underlying Singapore’s economic development strategy. Tay Kheng Soon, one of Singapore’s leading architects and architectural thinkers, had well perceived the relation between these new economic directions of the “global city era” (1970–1980) and the new urban features brought about by the “international corporate style of architecture” associated with the new financial centre under construction along Shenton Way and the nearby streets – a CBD zone known as the Golden Shoe because of its shape and high land values within the Central Area. As a matter of fact, a significant number of the superblocks built in this area were precisely occupied (or to be occupied) by statutory boards and government-linked companies (GLCs) set up to follow closely the reorientation of the city-state development according to the standards of the international economy – notably in the realm of finance (Development Bank of Singapore – DBS), infrastructure (Public Utilities Board headquarters), communications (Telephone Exchange). Among these the Central Provident Fund (CPF) Building deserves a special mention for CPF’s key role in juggling between public housing policy and the expansion of the wages system, in line with the set objectives of industrial development and modernization of the tertiary sector (Trocki 2006: 172). These observations certainly breathe in a useful idea of the intertwining between economic and spatial renovation, and have demonstrated the key modernization role the Singapore’s
20
C. Goldblum
People’s Action Party (PAP) government has been playing and still plays in the form of state institutions and governmental administrative and economic organizations. However the specific urban and architectural properties cited above need to be replaced within the framework of the comprehensive physical planning strategy introduced in the 1970s. In confronting the global city vision, this strategy had given them their precise meaning beyond their functional or symbolic significance in terms of location and high-rise built form. Basically, the principles of spatial distribution guiding the Concept Plan and organizing the infrastructure and building projects on national and local scales are relatively simple to identify. The main elements comprise a ring of new towns developed around the water catchment reservoirs connected to the city centre (the node of tertiary activities), an expressway network complemented by a mass rapid transit system, and two major infrastructural entities also connected to the city centre: the Jurong Industrial Park to the southwest already under construction since the end of the 1960s and the new Changi International Airport to the east. But this spatial arrangement has first to be understood as a holistic and innovative machine; the main innovation being development itself as a system in which each single element finds its very meaning: in the comprehensive dimension of physical planning in terms of space and function, in the global city strategy in terms of function and dynamics, and in future outlook in terms of horizon and legitimacy. Therefore, innovation could be considered here in relation to functional change and spatial exclusion by means of modernization. It can also be understood as an “uprooting” process directed somehow against the compact Sino-colonial urban fabric; a development pattern characterized by mixed land use whose capacity had been brought to an end after over half a century of development in the 20th century. The process of course also means that all the innovative elements like public housing or industrial zoning were not decided in an isolated or sectoral manner when the 1971 Concept Plan was launched. The integration and coordination of these elements reinforced the strategic dimension of planning that the city-state was empowered to perform in consideration of the economic flows and objectives planned for. In this respect, the new approach that has been given to public housing in the new town development framework is a key element and a good example of relating the Concept Plan with the global city strategy. As soon as the PAP acceded to power in 1959, it launched a successful housing policy through five-year public housing programmes on a rental basis. Soon after in 1964, it began with the home ownership scheme, applying the ideals of property housing democracy, the success of which has relied since the late 1960s on the integration of the Central Provident Fund (CPF) compulsory savings system to finance public housing and amenities, as well as to facilitate access of wage earners to the housing delivery system. Since then, the home ownership scheme has acquired a new dimension associated with new employment opportunities, population redistribution, new facilities for commuting and mobility through infrastructure linkages between new towns and the rest of the island. This also meant availability of adjoining industrial estates with job opportunities for young women and easy access to employment centres in the Central Area.
2 Planning the World Metropolis on an Island-City Scale
21
In that sense, and even if the public housing success story is often presented as the social part of the PAP government’s action, public housing has never been intended as a welfare action, but rather as a vector for economic modernization and integration. Thus, public housing is a special kind of instrument facilitating the development of the formal activities, reducing pressure on wages by keeping the housing delivery system outside the free market. However, the development of an efficient workforce for the manufacturing or services industry was not the only objective. The public housing policy was part of social engineering for nationbuilding in an immigrant society, and at the same time an integral component of planning the future of the city-state through education, schools (a basic reference for neighbourhood planning in the new towns) and universities (with the principles of knowledge economy associated with the practice of English language). This also meant in a way cutting the traditional roots which linked the community based (formal and informal) economy with the ethnically distinctive social space. Consequently, the massive transfer of population from old urban districts and pseudo-rural kampongs to new town public housing has eventually been a means to destroy the central slums which used to house a third of Singapore’s population and make room for a new CBD in place of the old Chinatown. If the new town policy together with industrial zoning and public transportation facilities have been the main agents for expanding the global city to the whole national territory, which was a real challenge in a period of contested survival, and to construct a sense of belonging among the majority of Singapore citizens, they have created in accordance with the Concept Plan the conditions for transforming the Central Area into a real matrix of a global city. Urban renewal has in that sense been playing a coordinated part with new town development. Correspondingly, the first sales of sites programmes, managed on a tender system for leasehold, had met the objectives of modernization and internationalization of the tertiary sector within the “global city” strategy. The outcome has seen office buildings symbolic of a major financial centre in Asia – the Zurich of the East; international class hotels and shopping complexes for mass tourism attraction – namely on or off Orchard Road, then followed by mixed programmes integrating the residential dimension – with condominium developments on the reclaimed land of Marina Centre to accommodate the expatriates working for international firms.
2.2
New Challenges and Institutional Innovation: Planning for the Future
Considering the magnitude of planned changes that occurred from Singapore’s access to internal autonomy in 1959 up to the 1980s, in comparison with the slower evolution of neighbouring states within the ASEAN,1 this process of change seems 1 Association of Southeast Asian Nations, a cooperative organization of the countries belonging to the liberal market economy established in August 1967.
22
C. Goldblum
to belong to the realm of innovation rather than adaptation. Innovation covers a broad series of changes, affecting urban or project management and developments, their forms and products. All these are reflected in the implementation of Southeast Asia’s first large free-trade export processing zone in Jurong, with car restricted access to the central business area (Area Licensing Scheme), urban renewal by super-block development proposals in the Central Area under sale of sites, and the introduction of the condominium concept with limited access for wealthy foreigners, seen as an extension of real estate property accumulation. By micro-zoning rules, such implementations represent a system popular in large cities like Bangkok, though less sophisticated urban planning regulations are used. These few examples are often earmarked as Singapore’s performance in urban management and planning, strongly related to the global city dimension. Rodolphe De Koninck’s expression of “territorial revolution” gives a clear idea of the spatial impact of this process, the Concept Plan being the conductor of the sectoral changes and their translation in spatial terms (De Koninck 2006: 71–91). In these specific sectoral realms where public actions have taken place, the creation of new state institutions as statutory boards in charge of specific objectives have been a key factor of change and a form of change in itself (Quah 1987: 120– 45). As far as urban planning is concerned, the first institutional creation was the Housing and Development Board in charge of the public housing policy which replaced the Singapore Improvement Trust, and some functions of the former City Council. Within the 1971 Concept Plan framework, HDB’s responsibility expanded as it became the developer and manager of new towns, while one of its departments in charge of urban renewal, the Urban Renewal Department (URD), became in 1974 a powerful autonomous statutory board under the name of the Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA), responsible for the CBD development. A third institution created in the late 1960s, the Jurong Town Corporation, initially in charge of the development of Jurong, was to play a major role within the Concept Plan framework, in managing new industrial zones including the Sembawang Shipyard, and industrial estates adjoining the new towns. The mix of adaptability and pragmatism the Singapore PAP government has proved to have in managing structural changes does not operate in dealing with external factors alone. It also concerns or affects the internal development dynamics, even in terms of institutional specialization. Economic integration in a mutable and often unpredictable world requires strong structural continuity affected by permanent changes. Indeed, political continuity is a major element for securing the logics, if not the nature, of long-term mega projects of national interest. This might partly explain the extent of commitment to intended transformations influencing spatial effects of economic change by emphasizing physical or social continuity. Thus, the task assigned to urban planning and specifically to the Concept Plan such as land reclamation for Marina East and South could be taken as a symbolic representation of this process. Another aspect of structural continuity is concerned with the control of production factors in terms of cost – land being the main factor and a key issue for mastering territorial development (Wong and Yap 2004). Partly a result of the
2 Planning the World Metropolis on an Island-City Scale
23
specific nature of British colonization and colonial rule in Singapore, partly because of the importance of military bases in the Settlement, the British legacy in dealing with extended public lands and their legal control has been instrumental for largescale transformations through land reclamation, eviction or compulsory acquisition and land-use conversion. But the legal framework needed an in-depth revision to cope with the magnitude of the spatial transformations which were undertaken. Three key texts produced before the Concept Plan’s inception were of major interest with regards to the comprehensive implementation and sectoral developments. First, the 1966 amended land acquisition act broadened the legal basis for compulsory public acquisition, a decisive apparatus for new town and industrial zone development. Then, the other two texts of major importance for organizing the changes in the Central Area: the 1967 property tax order and the 1968 controlled premises (special provisions) bill as incentives for urban renewal. Even amended or modified, these texts remained the reference for establishing the new centre-periphery system by virtue of the Long Range Concept Plan in its task of rationally preparing space for territorial fixation in international flows mobilized through the actions and incentives provided by the Economic Development Board (EDB).
2.3
Planning the Future of the World Metropolis: Innovation in the Concept Plan as a Response to Global–Regional Change
By the time Singapore had to review its 20-year Concept Plan in order to prepare its 1991 version, the international and regional context had deeply changed, giving a new perspective to its global city strategy. At global level, the “transactional revolution” varying from speed, space, and communication to virtual interaction and exchange has created new economic hierarchies in the world economy. In a fast urbanizing world, it gives privileges and edge to powerful and well-equipped metropolises to develop their financial centres to be qualified as global or world cities. It also shapes new spatial patterns such as urban corridor and growth triangles within the so-called “archipelago economy”, which is in an apparent position to renew and reinvent the dynamics of the city-state (Veltz 1996). Meanwhile, on the regional scale, the Asia–Pacific region is experiencing a fundamental change which would have a profound impact on Singapore’s position in the regional economy. This would have an effect on the revised Concept Plan too (Lo and Yeung (eds.) 1996–1999). First, after the end of the second Indochina war, the opening of the socialist countries, namely China and Vietnam and their reforms in the 1980s, was followed by the other former French Indochina countries. Under Vietnam’s influence, Laos and Cambodia took part in the regional integration, hence enlarging the economic cooperation structure of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations to include socialist countries. The enlargement has intensified the move towards an accelerated urbanization in the Pacific Asia sub-continent, as an adjustment effect in a region previously known as one of the less urbanized parts of the world.
24
C. Goldblum
Then, with the end of the regional conflicts in Indochina, and the rise of Southeast Asian economies, a new role was given to urban development as “a catalyst for growth”, as international organizations used to say – a role that has enhanced Singapore’s position. Even if there was a long-standing tradition of urban centres, related to sultanates and empires, in Southeast Asia, the city-state used to be looked upon as a foreign or external territorial entity by its regional neighbours; this is not only because of the Chinese origins of the majority of its population in a muslim-Malay world, but also because of its specific situation as an urban territory in a world that has remained largely founded on rural societies of rice-growing and fishing. These characteristics have been considered as the traditional norms of cultural authenticity. With these new trends the city-state has suddenly become at least a reference or even a model for the region’s future development. Such a reference point is shown by new mega-urban projects in the neighbouring metropolitan areas – Muang Thong Thani private new town near Bangkok, public and private new town development in the Jabotabek-Jakarta metropolitan region (Goldblum and Wong 2000: 29–37) and the Multimedia Super Corridor, a high-tech mega-project in the Kuala Lumpur metropolitan area (Bunnell 2004). In retrospect, Singapore’s present envied position as an urban planning model for new town and condominium developments in Asia draws us back to its beginning as a British trading post in the Malacca Straits in the early 19th century. It was the first example of a planned commercial emporium in Southeast Asia, not only in terms of spatial allocation but also in terms of codification of the shophouse complex. The combination of shophouses and the street network has produced the model of planned Chinatown, a reference for Bangkok and Phnom Penh urban development at the turn of the 20th century. This new context brought to Singapore new opportunities for exporting its Asian skills, knowledge and know-how, even in the field of urban planning and real estate, especially when Western industrialized countries were haunted by economic recession at the end of the 1980s. But opportunities also brought new challenges for Singapore to cope with: if there were some prospects in absorbing part of the foreign investments to Hong Kong after retrocession of the British Colony to China (this apparently did not happen), some new competitors were also appearing. If Singapore was prepared to take advantage of its advancement to become a kind of laboratory for emerging Asian economies, notably in urban planning and exporting it, there was a real need for the city-state to make such an advance as an experienced technical expert. In that sense, if there was some continuity in Singapore’s global city strategy by strengthening its regional integration (Leifer 2000: 36–7), it was clear that innovative policies were again needed to keep its attraction as a kind of new frontier in competition and cooperation with China and a sub-continental state, India. The importance of the integration issue and challenge appears clearly in the project management and implementation of the 1991 Concept Plan. Of course there were some forerunning actions at the end of the 1980s predicting these new trends in several directions, such as progressively opening the public housing programme and the new town services delivery to the private sector, establishing town councils as pilot projects (according to the 1988 Town Councils Act) in order to facilitate public participation in the management of new towns and to limit the extended
2 Planning the World Metropolis on an Island-City Scale
25
powers and responsibilities of the HDB. Also, changing the official position concerning sensitive issues such as population and birth control, the past ethnic dimension affecting social space and language use, was systematically translated into new policies. Measures encouraging higher population growth to 4.4, then 5.5 million inhabitants (including permanent residents) were put in place, in order to tackle the generational gap problems of dynamism affecting solidarity in an aging society. Active urban conservation policy measures were introduced and bilingualism with Chinese language as the second language or mother tongue for ethnic Chinese was reinforced in schools. In consolidating regional cooperation, industrial activities were initiated in the Indonesian Riau Islands and in Johor within the SIJORI2 growth triangle. Again, these elements were to gain their very meaning within the framework of the new concept plan. And even if, as mentioned, there are some continuity effects imbedded in URA’s slogan of the “Tropical City of Excellence”, the importance of change appears clearly when observing the institutional change in the elaboration of the Concept Plan. This task which was previously given to a department of the Ministry of National Development (MND), the Planning Department under the responsibility of the Chief Planner, was from now on given to the renewed Urban Redevelopment Authority (new URA), the head of which carries the portfolio of Chief Planner. One has an idea of the importance thus given to this statutory board, which earlier was only in charge of the Central Area. But the change of role of the URA has also raised new expectations vis-à-vis the revised 1991 Concept Plan, observing that these extended functions were attributed to the maître d’oeuvre of the new town planning policy, the former powerful chief executive officer of the Housing and Development Board: architect-planner Liu ThaiKer, a key personality of Singapore’s urban planning success story in the second half of the 20th century. Apart from the already mentioned forerunning elements which were integrated in the new concept plan, the main components and the major innovative elements have appeared clearly and quite simply in the scheme. However, they need explanatory notes to account for the new orientations and scope of urban planning, and the new perspective of Singapore in search of a global metropolis, which must be differentiated from the initial global city strategy.
2.4
Controversial Issues and New Challenges: Which Strategy for Singapore as a World Metropolis?
Though still organized on the principles of the ring concept, the Singapore 1991 Concept Plan and its 2001 revision deliver an urban and territorial image differing from the previous one. The general image is no more the “Fordist” expression of a
2 A growth triangle concept initiated by Singapore in 1989 which included Singapore, Southern Johor and the Riau Islands of Indonesia.
26
C. Goldblum
marked difference of concept and of management between the Singapore world of international finance, tourism and luxury consumption and the busy, somewhat Spartan world of local Singaporean wage earners, commuters and new town dwellers. It tends to evoke the world of an affluent society, a new urban hierarchy ranked by levels of population and intensity of commercial services. Considering the centre-periphery system, much attention is paid to facilitate mobility, accessibility and connectivity: the mass rapid transit (MRT) network is extended and supplemented by a light rail transit (LRT) system. Indeed, the MRT/LRT integration shows a less marked differentiation between the regional centres and the city centre, making it possible to transfer some high level tertiary activities in these new regional nodes (Tampines, Woodlands, Jurong East – initially including Seletar) designed for servicing a population of about 800,000 inhabitants as part of the Constellation Plan concept. New towns are recognized as the living environment for a large majority of the Singapore population, most of whom were benefiting from at least a 3-room apartment. With 55 development guide plans (DGPs) completed with detailed local plans covering the whole city-state, more attention is now paid on public space and its amenities, and new concepts are introduced in new town planning in relation to leisure activities. The integration of the leisure facet in waterfront cities, like the Punggol 21 new town project, notably through land reclamation, has met to an extent some expectations of the Singaporean population. Taking the expatriate or tourist living as an idealized reference, this residential development concept is seemingly reducing the separation line between the private condominium and walk-up apartments development concepts and some of the new public housing projects. In parallel, in response to greater demand for quality living-environment and transportation, waterfront living fits in well with the new economic orientation for high-tech research centres, universities and specialized engineering schools organized along high-tech corridors and international business parks. This development trend is also in line with the SIJORI growth triangle launched by Deputy Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong in the late 1980s. The regional geopolitical context has made it possible for Singapore to extend its industrial and some tourism activities outside its national territory to the Riau Islands of Batam and Bintan in Indonesia and to southern Johor at the south of Peninsular Malaysia. Furthermore, a second link was built in Tuas joining south-western Johor to ensure a better connection. Another aspect that needs to be addressed is the re-Asianization policy. As far as urban development is concerned, what takes place in the Central Area such as land reclamation for marina projects offers Singapore the possibility of reducing the pressure on prime land in the CBD. Re-Asianization also gives the possibility of extending the conservation or rehabilitation projects in the colonial civic centre as well as in the so-called ethnic districts, which supposedly represent the three major Asian cultural communities of Singapore (Chinese, Malay and Indian). For this purpose, parts of the old Chinatown, Kampong Glam and Little India, have been conserved. Though conservation is partly meant to promote tourism, it is also a way to foster the once contested image of “Instant Asia” at a time when ethnic origins and languages of ancestry may also serve to facilitate economic exchange
2 Planning the World Metropolis on an Island-City Scale
27
and diplomatic relations with Asian countries like China and India. It may be noticed that being able to deliver an acceptable discourse on Asian modernization without being a competitor with the large States in the regional power game, Singapore has been in the position of becoming the champion of (modern) “Asian values”. As far as urban planning is concerned, Singapore is already exporting its expertise as well as turnkey projects to neighbouring countries due to internationally recognized capacities in this realm (Wong and Goldblum 2000: 112–22). In making a new laboratory for urban planning project and concept export, it gives the city-state another dimension to redefine its Concept Plan. In that sense, regional centres in Singapore also figure some kind of regional (peripheral) development in miniature. There is a prospect that gives specific interest to urban conservation when Singapore deals with countries of long cultural history which often raise the question of heritage as an asset and development criteria of a new modern metropolis. Having said that, it is necessary to approach the question of urban environmental planning and urban sustainable development since it has provided a new set of criteria for assessing world metropolises of the 21st century. Since its inception in 1959, the PAP Government has shown a real concern about the question of environmental quality, fighting against pollution in all fronts with “clean and green” or “garden city” as slogans, tree planting campaigns (initiated by the National Parks Board of the Ministry of National Development in 1967), etc. Urban poverty, crowded dwelling slums and makeshift kampongs of the past partly explain this attitude which has proved to be very successful in the treatment of public space, development of parks and gardens, etc. Singapore is also an example for its early choice for public transportation (first in modernizing the bus service, then by developing MRT/LRT into very efficient systems), even though it seems difficult to refrain a more affluent population from its desire for cars. Environmental issues are from the start a major component of Singapore’s urban planning strategy. Based on a legal and institutional framework, national regulations and regional and international agreements such as waste management, a waste minimization department was set up in 1992 and a resolution was signed on waste management for the coastal areas of the ASEAN region, following an international conference held on this topic in Singapore in June 1991 (Ooi (ed.) 1995). The formalisation of a “green plan” only occurred in 1992 as an extension of the 1991 concept plan. Published in May 1992 as The Singapore Green Plan – Towards a Model Green City, the plan focused on public health (clean air, land, water and quality of living environment) and has gained international recognition when presented at the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro in June 1992, as Singapore’s national plan supporting Agenda 21. Specifically, the “green plan” as well as the “blue plan”, which was designed to protect and safeguard the Central Water Catchment area, have been integrated into the 1991 Concept Plan and the revised 2001 Concept Plan vision. In both the revised plans, an island-wide park connector system has been designed and integrated with leisure (recreational areas for jogging or cycling) and tourism (historical or natural theme parks). It is also integrated in Singapore’s exportable
28
C. Goldblum
model city concept in the form of a “Model Green city”, giving a new scope to the long-standing version of the garden city concept (Wong and Yap 2004: 120–40). Other planning choices nonetheless are more controversial, such as the high-rise energy consuming buildings or the development of a consumerist society. This also leads to the question of the relevant scale on which to approach such issues as how to deal with external environmental effects like forest fires in Sumatra, for instance, on how to understand externalization of pollution producing activities such as pig farming or heavy industries. What makes the environmental issue even more questionable in Singapore is that the new approach towards globalisation or its international concept conflicts with its original dynamics, with concepts or discourse like Agenda 21. Added to this dilemma would be especially questioning the social or political dimension of the public participation or involvement in the decision-making concerning urban development. Broadly speaking, one may wonder if sustainable development as expressed in a large set of criteria in the 21 local agenda is compatible with the functions and requirements of a world metropolis: tourist shopping, housing, mass transportation, seaports, international airports, etc. The paradoxical aspect of metropolitan development in this direction which has led to social disparities between regions and territories, is quite well documented as far as European countries are concerned (Laigle 2006). If sustainable development criteria are applied to the specific situation of Singapore, the issue affects the fundamental functions of the city-state. Can the survival question on the island scale be turned into the question of sustainable development? According to Liu Thai-Ker, the constellation plan principle in a form of a hierarchized satellite town network adopted in Singapore’s 1991 Concept Plan may figure as a possible answer, at least as a means to alleviate the burden of excessive concentration in the mega-cities. Accordingly, as Liu (1998: 3–26) explained: Given its small size, the sustainability of Singapore is the most important issue on the national agenda. A good deal of attention and effort has been put in to make the physical environment sustainable … The good physical environment contributes towards Singapore’s reputation in the region and internationally.
These reflections for the future lead to another related question for Singapore. Even if the nature of the city-state as belonging or not to a specific category of global city might be a matter of theoretical discussion (Olds and Yeung 2004: 489–521), a question still remains concerning its effective position as a model city (Ooi (ed.) 1999). That is, how does Singapore hold its status as a tropical city of excellence by keeping its advancement and innovative capacities and by largely exporting its skills and even its planning concepts, while new competitors (from Shanghai to Dubai) are emerging to deliver their own image of new world metropolises of the 21st century? And, how would Singapore argue its causes while new international criteria of sustainability may introduce some controversial aspects in the evaluation of the Singapore urban planning experience (Sassen 2001: 69–76). Let us accept that this is a new challenge, a new frontier for Singapore, in which the concept of sustainable urban development is also questioned. Till now, Singapore has proven its exceptional capability to respond to new challenges in such a way that they seem to be, or at least to serve, its raison d’être.
2 Planning the World Metropolis on an Island-City Scale
29
References Bunnell T (2004) Malaysia, modernity and the multimedia super corridor: A critical geography of intelligent landscapes. Routledge, London Cheng SH (1991) Economic change and industrialization. In: Chew Ernest CT, Lee E (eds.) A history of Singapore. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 182–215 Dale OJ (1999) Urban planning in Singapore: The transformation of a city. Oxford University Press, Oxford De Koninck R (2006) Singapour: La cité-Etat ambitieuse. Belin (Asie plurielle), Paris Goldblum C, Wong T-C (2000) Growth, crisis and spatial change: A study of haphazard urbanisation in Jakarta, Indonesia. Land Use Policy 17 (1): 29–37 Laigle L (2006) Métropolisation et développement durable, Pouvoirs locaux 70 (III): 33–36 Leifer M (2000) Singapore’s foreign policy: Coping with vulnerability. Routledge, London Liu T-K (1998) From megacity to constellation city: Towards sustainable Asian cities. In: To TS (ed.) Megacities, labour, communications. Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore, pp 3–26 Lo F-c, Yeung Y-m (eds.) (1996–1999) Emerging world cities in Pacific Asia. United Nations University Press (in association with The Chinese University of Hong Kong), Tokyo McGee TG (1998) Five decades of urbanization in Southeast Asia: A personal encounter. In: Yeung Y-m (ed.) Urban development in Asia: Retrospect and prospect. The Chinese University of Hong Kong – Hong Kong Institute of Asia-Pacific Studies, Hong Kong, pp 55–91 Ooi GL (1995) (ed.) Environment and the city: Sharing Singapore’s experience and future challenges. Times Academic Press/The Institute of Policy Studies, Singapore Ooi GL (1999) (ed.) Model cities: Urban best practices, Vol. 1, Urban Redevelopment Authority/ The Institute of Policy Studies, Singapore Olds K, Yeung HWC (2004) Pathways to global city formation: A view from the developmental city-state of Singapore. Review of International Political Economy 11 (3): 489–521 Quah JST (1987) Statutory boards. In: Quah JST, Chan HC, Seah CM (eds.) Government and politics of Singapore. Oxford University Press, Singapore, pp 120–145 Rodan G (2001) Singapore: Globalisation and the politics of economic restructuring. In: Rodan G, Hewison K, Robinson R (eds.) Political economy of Southeast Asia: Conflicts, crises, and change. Oxford University Press, Melbourne, pp 138–177 Sassen S (2001) Politics of the global city: Claiming rights to urban spaces. In: United Nations Centre for Human Settlements (Habitat), Cities in a globalizing world. Global Report on Human Settlements 2001, Nairobi, pp 69–76 Trocki CA (2006) Singapore: Wealth, power and the culture of control. Routledge, London Veltz P (1996) Mondialisation, villes et territoires. L’économie d’archipel. Presses Universitaires de France, Paris Wong T-C, Goldblum C (2000) The China-Singapore Suzhou Industrial Park: A turnkey product of Singapore? Geographical Review 90 (1): 112–122 Wong T-C, Yap L-HA (2004) Four decades of transformation: Land use in Singapore 1960–2000. Eastern Universities Press by Marshall Cavendish, Singapore
Chapter 3
Sustainable City Centre Development: The Singapore City Centre in the Context of Sustainable Development Ole Johan Dale
3.1
Introduction
Sustainable development has two parts to it. The first is development; the core dimension is here economic growth, the generation of wealth against poverty. Then there is the second part, “sustainable”. How do we keep growing with what we have; the environmental challenge to economic development. What is a sustainable city? It is organized so as to enable all its citizens to meet their own needs and to enhance their well-being without damaging the natural world or endangering the living conditions of other people, now or in the future (Girardet 2001). This definition emphasizes the importance of people and their needs. These include good quality air, water, good housing, a good working environment, good and healthy food etc. They also include job opportunities; healthcare, quality education, culture, safety as well as equal opportunities and the needs of the elderly and the disabled must be adequately provided for. The key question to be asked in a sustainable city is: are all users able to satisfy their needs without damaging the host environment? This chapter looks at one small area, the Singapore City Centre – the very heartland and nerve centre of the nation’s sustainable economic planning and development. It conforms approximately to the “Central Area” used in the overall island planning, the Singapore Concept Plan. Its area has expanded since 1958 and it now covers an area of about 1,700 hectares (Fig. 3.1). It is perhaps small from a global perspective, yet it shows in a looking glass what can be achieved once there is a determined effort to reach certain goals. Singapore is through its location and economic structure an integrated component in economic globalization, involving not only the corporate economy and the transnational corporate culture but also the immigrant economies and work cultures evident in global cities (Sassen 2006). However, Singapore like Hong Kong is unique because the state/nation or territory is contained within a fully urbanized and territorially constrained unit.
Seberg 7, 6863, Leikanger, Norway, e-mail:
[email protected]
T.-C. Wong et al. (eds.), Spatial Planning for a Sustainable Singapore, 31–57 © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
This page intentionally blank
32
O.J. Dale
Fig. 3.1 Evolution of Singapore’s central area, 1958–2000
The city centre situated around the mouth of the Singapore River is, in terms of urban planning, an integrated part of the national planning framework. Historically, it is the core of Singapore’s development. Thomas Stamford Raffles planted the British flag on the banks of Singapore River in 1819 and the story of modern Singapore began there. The early settlement grew and became a major colonial town. All important administrative and economic activities were located there. It was the main population centre. The city centre represented once colonial Singapore. Like colonialism itself, it provided the setting for the encounter of races and civilizations – yet one that took place in a situation of structured inequality. It provided a market place for trade and exchange. Today it is still a place for trade and exchange but also a centre for international trade, finance, production as well as cultural services and entertainment. It is the context of the city centre’s specific development dimensions, which represents the image and aspirations of the present
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
33
Singapore, that this study examines. In connection with sustainable development, the focus is on the overall city aspects as well as selected sectors which illustrate the prevailing programmes.
3.2 3.2.1
City Centre Developments City Centre
To residents and visitors alike, Singapore city centre is the epitome of cleanliness and of a well managed city. It is difficult to understand that 40–50 years ago it was a very different city. The 1947 census revealed that 73 percent of the island population was concentrated in the Municipal Area, most of it in the city centre. The most densely populated area, part of what today is known as Chinatown conservation area had a density of more than 1,800 persons per hectare (Department of Social Welfare 1948). By 1957 more than 1.1 million people or 79 percent of the population were living in the Municipal Area. The population densities in some areas had risen to more than 2,500 persons per hectare (Ministry of National Development 1965). About 400,000 or almost one-third of the island population were squatters, of these 246,000 were living in the city. Social surveys gave a dismal picture of overcrowding, poverty and slum-like housing conditions throughout the centre of the city (Goh 1958). Two- or threestorey shophouses, originally, intended to house one or two families were subdivided into a maze of interior cubicles, the majority were without windows and in permanent semi-darkness. In such cubicles, on average less than 10 square metres – dark, confined, insanitary and without comfort –a family of seven to ten people could live. The 1958 Master Plan described the city as one of the worst slum areas in Asia. The transformation Singapore has gone through has not happened through coincidence. It is important to stress the extraordinary role played by government both as planner and entrepreneur (Dale 1999). From the earliest days of self-government it was recognized that the main resource Singapore had was its people. The development of this resource became paramount. With a very limited land area, land became another resource which had to be judiciously planned and managed so as to accommodate the range of activities. Combined with a self-reliance thinking that in the case of an emergency Singapore could not rely on its neighbours to supply water and other essential commodities, this had a major impact on retention and management of natural resources such as water. The physical environment was to be rebuilt, not only to eradicate old slum areas but also to give Singapore a modern face reflecting its aspirations. The early election platform focused on housing for the masses as one of its main targets. The renewal programme and the public housing programme therefore became key pillars in the implementation of government policies. There was tremendous pressure on the bureaucracy and the new statutory boards to achieve the targets. These
34
O.J. Dale
included almost all aspects of city life, from housing, clean water supply, transportation and commercial infrastructure, drainage schemes, improvement to the sewerage system, to public hygiene and control of street food hawkers. By today the economy has been completely restructured and vastly expanded. From one dependent on port-related trade and administration before 1960, the city economy is now largely based on employment in office work related to the growth and management of regional and local industries, an international orientated supply of banking, finance and general commercial services as well as supply of services catering to the local market. There has been some decentralization of office functions to other parts of the island. These are mostly local service industry jobs. The city has become more specialized, as a greater part of the jobs are in sectors serving an international and regional market. Retail shopping was an important city function before 1960. Its organization, technology, types of buildings and volume has, however, undergone a transformation. A very important customer in many shopping centres is the international tourist shopper, in particular in the Orchard Road/Marina Centre corridor. From a humble beginning tourism has become a major industry (90,000 visitors in 1960 to 9.7 million in 2006). Its impact on the city is foremost in accommodation, food and beverages, and shopping. About 90 percent of all hotel rooms are in the city centre. The multiplier effect of tourism is reflected in services such as travel agencies, airline offices, financing and convention activities as well as in the arts and culture which is becoming an important job generator. From the 1960s, new housing in the centre has largely been provided through public housing estates developed as part of an island comprehensive programme of new towns. Following slum clearance, the bulk of the residential population has largely moved out of the city centre, either because of resettlement or in tandem with the wider choice of housing elsewhere. The centre, together with the adjoining areas, now accommodates about 3 percent of the island population in a mix of public housing and private housing in the higher price brackets. In many cities, a traditional function has been recreation, culture and entertainment. In pre-1960 Singapore, culture and entertainment tended to be ethnic-based and closely integrated with economic service functions. By and large the various ethnic groups were compartmentalized and seldom interacted with each other except in the market place. The cultural interface was kept to a minimum. Behind the present Singapore consciousness and national identity are many diverse political and socio-economic forces. Foremost are government policies such as urban renewal and public housing, bilingualism and multiracialism, integrated schools, national service, community development, economic growth and meritocracy. Spatially the former ethnic and dialect concentrations have more or less disappeared. The economic restructuring and growth has largely removed the former ethnic and dialect occupational specialization and has also resulted in greater social mobility. Socially and culturally, the population is far more homogeneous than before.
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
35
From the mid-1980s, a new dimension to cultural activities was created through more support for the arts and the provision of more and better facilities for orchestral music, theatres and the arts in general. The museum precinct started to become a reality. The massive centre for the performing arts at the Marina Centre moved in the mid-1990s from the planning stage to implementation. There was therefore a gradual transition within the city centre, from an ethnic-based culture towards a non-communal centre serving the nation as a whole. The aim for the new Marina Centre performing arts centre, named Esplanade-the Theatres on the Bay, was more ambitious, and planned as a contribution to establishing Singapore as an international hub for international services, culture and the arts. A new urban fabric has been established for the built environment. From an early emphasis on infrastructure, housing as well as commercial activities, the emphasis has shifted and is directed towards office buildings, upper-income residences and specialized consumption activities. The consumption activities are focused on shopping, specialized goods and cultural activities aimed in particular at the interests of the middle and upper classes and the international visitors. The growth of tourism as a leading urban industry combines production and consumption in a novel way. Besides investment in buildings the producers, the tourist industry and government have invested on a large scale in the production of aesthetically appealing districts. Rehabilitation of conservation areas is in fact also rehabilitation for service production or consumption. From the early start onwards the renewal or redevelopment of the city followed overall planning guidelines that controlled the development. While the updated 1958 Master Plan was used as a guide in the early years, the Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA), set up in 1974 specially to take charge of the Central Area, followed up the 1971 Islandwide Concept Plan priorities with detailed concept plans for the Central Area. These plans formed the basis of development from the mind-1970s. These were far more than ordinary land use and design guidelines. The concept plans were accompanied by action programmes for large areas. These incorporated land amalgamation including compulsory acquisition, resettlement, land clearance and management. People and businesses affected by clearance had the right to resettlement facilities. Construction of suitable housing, shops, industrial premises as well as education and health facilities therefore had to be completed and be ready well ahead of clearance initiation. The land use and design component of the concept plans included detailed schemes for land parcels which would be sold for private development. Due to lack of suitable private land the URA sale of sites to the private sector became the main vehicle to ensure sufficient space for offices, shops, hotels etc. The sites were sold through well publicized public tenders and with planning guidelines giving type of development permitted and the plot ratio. The design guidelines gave aspects such as height control and streetscape. The sites were sold vacant and free from any encumbrances; potential purchasers were furthermore informed about any technical conditions such as sewerage and drainage requirements. Since it would take about five years from the planning stage until a project on a site sold would be completed, research into future demand was necessary so as to provide
36
O.J. Dale
space based on anticipated marked demand. This required rolling development programmes, both long-term and year by year.
3.2.2
Garden City Concept to National Green Plan
Of great importance was the emphasis given to tree planting and well maintained green spaces aimed at softening the harshness of the urban fabric and a subtle way of convincing investors in the early years that Singapore was an efficient and effective place and therefore a good place for business. A good example of the latter is the construction of the expressway from the city to Changi International Airport which was planned and built in the second half of the 1970s. Planners were instructed to ensure that the expressway including tree planting was completed ahead of the airport. When the first visitors arrived in 1981 they could drive to the city on a scenic expressway lined with mature trees. Their first impression was to be: Singapore as the well organized garden city. The vision was a Singapore where the streets would be lined with trees. For all new streets and roads, tree planting became part of the standard design and construction; there was the carriageway, the pedestrian pavement or walkway and the tree planting strip. Much of the old streetscapes in the city centre were devoid of greenery. The first task of the Parks and Recreation Department formed in 1976 under the Ministry of National Development (MND) was to focus on the greening of Singapore. A detailed planting plan for the old existing streets was prepared by the Public Works Department which coordinated and upgraded all streets in the city area. This included new drainage channels dimensioned to absorb heavy monsoon rainfall, new pavements and tree planting. The garden city concept strategies were further developed and greatly expanded as part of the Singapore Green Plan under the Ministry of the Environment (1992). The target was to transform Singapore into a model environment city and the regional centre for environmental technology by the year 2000. The latest plan, The Singapore Green Plan 2012 was launched in 2002 and updated in 2006 (Ministry of Environment 2006). It is a ten-year blueprint towards national environmental sustainability. Six focus areas are covered: air and climate change, water, waste management, nature, public health and international environment.
3.2.3
Impacts of the Concept Plan on the City Centre
Singapore’s limited land resources (660 sq km) have necessitated a thorough and yet sufficiently flexible overall island planning. The first island comprehensive development plan or Concept Plan had been completed in 1971 largely by UN sponsored consultants. Until 1989, responsibility for land use planning and design for the city centre had been under the purview of URA. In 1989, URA became the national planning authority. The 1991 Singapore Concept Plan which built on the
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
37
1971 plan introduced a new and much more open dialogue with the general public. The 1991 plan amalgamated the various plans, including the URA Concept Plans for the city area into one, in so doing the government also opened for the first time for fairly extensive consultations with the public, in particular professional organizations such as the Singapore Institute of Architects. The Concept Plan is a longterm structure plan or a big picture plan. It is therefore supplemented by area plans, now termed “Master Plans” which give more detailed land use and urban design guidelines. A key feature of the 1991 plan was to sustain economic growth and the land use and development strategy had this as a main aim. An important aspect was to cater for the higher aspirations of the population through what was termed “providing a good quality of life”. The Concept Plan is revised at regular intervals and the last revision was in 2001 (URA 2001). Much planning and design has been conceived to transform the central business district, including the reclaimed land, the Marina South, Marina East into a new financial district in line with the city-state’s goal to attain global city status, and as a global financial hub (see URA 2001). The latest revision of the Concept Plan (2001) for the city centre has provided a frame to make it more dynamic and lively in the night time by introducing varied uses, such as residential. In the city centre, development to very high residential densities has been a necessity. It is anticipated that many office workers will be working in the near future in proximity to their downtown homes. The city centre is envisioned in the long-term to have about 7 percent of the total population as against 3 percent in 2001. In 2006 the total population was 4.4 million of which 3.6 million were registered as Singapore citizens and permanent residents (Department of Statistics 2007a). The long-term population parameters were recently revised to 6.5 million. It is not a target figure, but a scenario which takes into account current demographic trends and population policy (Mah 2007).
3.2.4
Singapore River
To sustain life – sustainable development – requires effort, it requires a vision and planning to achieve it and it requires the will and ability to implement it. A major feature in the urban landscape is Singapore River – the original trading centre and anchorage for Singapore town. Today it is an important and attractive part of the city and it has the potential to become even more so. Thirty years ago it was more like a garbage dump. By the 1960s the life cycle of the river as a port and port-related commercial centre was over. Some tongkangs still used the quaysides along the river for unloading goods but the volume was negligible. Operators used the river for mooring of their boats and rubbish was dumped into the river. The warehouses were no longer used for distribution of goods. The buildings which once bustled with life were half empty and poorly maintained. The river banks were dilapidated. The river itself was increasingly becoming more like a polluted drain or a sewer. It was blackish, foul smelling and devoid of aquatic life.
38
O.J. Dale
A new life cycle commenced in the late 1970s. URA had by then started preparing a Concept Plan with the aim of bringing the river and adjoining areas back to become an important and attractive part of the economic and social fabric of the city. The actual cleaning up and revitalization of Singapore River started with the prime minister Lee Kuan Yew in February 1977 throwing a challenge to the implementation agencies. “It should be a way of life to keep the water clean, to keep every stream, culvert and rivulet free from pollution. In ten years let us have fishing in the Singapore River and Kallang River. It can be done” (Lee 1977). By October 1977 the Ministry of the Environment had prepared a detailed action plan for the cleaning up of both Singapore and Kallang River. The plan which was approved by the government the same year meant a massive planning, construction and management operation. The catchment area of the two rivers covered about one fifth of the total land area of Singapore. Some statistics indicate the scale of the problem. Area surveys showed that there were 27,000 families, approximately 100,000 persons living as squatters in temporary structures without basic facilities such as proper water supply, drainage and sewer access. All these had to be given appropriate affordable new housing. More than 21,000 premises, almost all in the city area were without connection to sewer. Discharge from these premises went into the street or roadside drains where it was mixed with rain and surface water, and from there into the rivers. The surveys also show that there were 3,600 cottage type backyard industries, 610 pig farms, 480 duck farms, 4,900 street hawkers (most of these operating in the city area), 390 fruit and vegetable wholesalers (almost all operating their business from makeshift markets without basic hygienic conditions). More than 60 small boatyards for ship repairs were located along the upper parts of the two rivers: the location meant that they were no longer viable businesses but they added considerably to the pollution. About 770 lighters or tongkangs used the rivers for mooring. The project was coordinated by the Drainage Department under the Ministry of the Environment which set up a special working group where all the key agencies such as HDB, URA, PWD, PPD (Primary Production Department) and PSA (Port of Singapore Authority) had important functions. Besides government agencies, the project also included grass-root and civic organizations and the business community. Public housing accommodation, resettlement shops, markets and food or hawker centres had to be provided first. New locations had to be found for pig and duck farms. At the same time the farmers had to be trained in new methods of highly intensive, non-pollutive farming. A new centralized wholesale market for fruits and vegetables was built at Pasir Panjang. The street hawkers were relocated into food centres where they could operate their purpose-designed stalls in premises with water, public sewer and waste disposal facilities. The close to 800 or so lighters provided a picturesque view for visitors but at the same time were a major source of pollution. New mooring facilities were now constructed at Pasir Panjang and all lighters were relocated in 1983. Once the sources of pollution were removed, work started on the physical appearance of the rivers. This included dredging, demolitions, removal of deposits
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
39
and rubbish, repairs of the steps along the quays and the walkways along Singapore River were tiled and planted. The cost of the entire project amounted to about S$200 million and it was completed in 1987. The Singapore River and Kallang Basin project took ten years to complete (1977–1987). The foremost result is a cleaner environment, cleaner water and the return of aquatic life. The key factor in making it possible is no doubt the political will of the government. It is also a project which can be used as a model for many rapidly developing cities exemplifying of the many complex issues – social, economic and environmental – which have to be solved. Management and control of pollution is an ongoing task. Because of the high level of urbanization, problems such as littering and sullage water discharge still remain. To keep the rivers clean, engineering measures are used to minimize the pollution. Enforcement of the legislation is thorough. Regular inspections are conducted to ensure that wastewater is discharged into the sewerage system and that treatment facilities installed by industries are properly operated and maintained. There are frequent programmes which educate the public against littering and the discharge of waste into the rivers. Ten years after the project started, by the end of the 1980s, there were once again fish swimming in Singapore River, and they could be eaten. However, more work was needed to make the river fully functional and attractive. The next step was to reconstruct the century old river walls into strong embankment structures on deepseated foundations. The work started in 1992 and was completed in 1998 at a cost of S$140 million. Simultaneously the river walks were completed inclusive of paving, planting, lighting and street furniture. The land use, design and development guide plans for the river were prepared parallel with the engineering and cleaning up works. The first step was the land use aspect: substantial areas along the upper parts of Singapore River had been zoned for warehousing and industrial use. These uses were no longer permitted and new land use plans with development guides were released to the public. Buildings with architectural value had to be retained and the guidelines stipulated control aspects such as a four-storey height along the river and a maximum of ten storeys further behind. The shophouses along Boat Quay and adjoining areas had been designated for conservation and retention. Specific guidelines for usage and architectural upgrading were now issued. To further encourage private owners to upgrade and repair the buildings, the old rent control was liberalized and finally lifted, not only for the Boat Quay area but also for other areas designated for conservation. At the same time the individual building owners were encouraged to bring in new activities such as retail shops and restaurants. The public areas such as the river banks were rebuilt by public funds as part of the general upgrading. These became pedestrian spaces for walking, outdoor dining and recreation. To facilitate river traffic, boarding spaces for boats were provided at selected points along the river. Tour operators and associations were now encouraged to use the river for cruises and festivals such as dragon boat races. About 30 years or so after the first life cycle ended the river was again alive.
40
O.J. Dale
The river and its adjoining areas as we see today is therefore the result of a long and planned implementation process. The first step was a vision of what it could become; then specific target plans and implementation of these through public action; then conservation and development guide plans which private property owners as well as public agencies had to adhere to; then gradual renewal based on these plans and in tandem with the property market demand for uses such as housing, hotels and retail space.
3.2.5
City Traffic
In June 1975 the Area Licensing Scheme (ALS) was introduced as the first step to control access of private vehicles into the city centre. The ALS required that private cars possess and display a license to gain access (between 7.30 and 10.15 am) into a defined Restricted Zone which covered 620 hectares of the most built-up parts of the city. The scheme was later extended to include an evening period. To encourage car pooling, vehicles carrying four or more persons were at first exempted from paying the fee. Total car traffic into the city during morning peak hours was halved immediately. Despite the large increase in city jobs during the subsequent ten years, the 1985 total city-bound traffic was still 20 percent less than the pre-ALS figure. The ALS became part of a two-pronged approach to enforce traffic restraint – restraint on car ownership and on the use of the car. A deliberate policy of private car ownership restraint was implemented through fiscal measures, in the form of import duties, the VQS (Vehicle Quota System), registration fees and annual road taxes. Perhaps the most efficient measure is the quota system. To own a car, a person needs a Certificate of Entitlement (COE) which is valid for ten years. Anyone who intends to purchase a vehicle must first obtain a COE through an open bidding system. The quota of the number of COE to be issued every month is set by the transport authority which allows the government to have full control of the growth of the vehicle population. Since its introduction in 1990 the government through the quota system has set the cap for the annual vehicle growth rate to about 3 percent. An important side effect is cars with better fuel economy and reduced pollution. The VQS has resulted in a very young car population. Most cars are taken off the road after ten years. If it is deregistered the owner gets part of the COE payment back, if an extended COE is purchased this refund is forfeited. Since new cars have better fuel economy and are cleaner with less emissions the pollution level is reduced in tandem with the renewal of the car population. A reward system is now in place to encourage the use of cars with low emission levels. Green vehicle rebates are offered for electric, hybrid and compressed natural gas vehicles. The ALS was replaced by the Electronic Road Pricing (ERP) from 1998 onwards. The main principle behind this is that motorists should pay for the specific road use, related to the congestion caused. Restraint on city bound traffic is still the main function and motorists here pay according to the time of the day they travel. As the system is being developed, more and more sectors of the road network are included.
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
41
It is envisaged that gradually there will be a shift from the upfront cost of buying a car to a usage cost: usage of the car during peak hours on the most congested roads in the most congested sectors will give the highest road use bills. Pricing and the quota system have controlled the growth of the number of vehicles and measures such as ALS and its replacement, the ERP, have kept the number of vehicles entering the city area to a level that does not cause congestion. One component of the policies pertaining to private cars is the compulsory provision of car parks in all new developments. Office buildings, shopping centres and other developments in the city area are therefore well provided with car-parks. The rationale behind this seeming inconsistency of imposing car-park requirement as a planning condition whilst restricting traffic is that it should be made expensive for a motorist to drive into an area where he can cause congestion: but once the car is there it should be taken off the street quickly. Furthermore, car parks are viewed as an economic necessity but congestion and pollution must be minimized. The backbone of the transportation system is, however, public transport, consisting of MRT (mass rapid transit), LRT (light rapid transit), buses and also taxis. About 52 percent of Singapore residents go to work using public transport (Singapore Census of Population 2000). Forty-two percent use private transport such as cars (23 percent), motorcycles (5 percent); and the remaining use group travel such as chartered van and lorry. About 6 percent do not require any form of transport (Department of Statistics 2000). The public transport facilities have been rapidly expanded during the past few decades and the government policies have focussed on developing a high class public transport system whilst restricting ownership and usage of private cars, yet at the same time facilitating easy car movement by construction of a good quality road network. Despite the general trend whereby increased incomes frequently favour use of private transport it is envisaged that by further improvements to the public transport system its share of total commuting can increase. The expressed overall aim is therefore to increase the number of people who commute via public transport to 75 percent of all trips (LTA 1996; 2006). Since completion of the first Concept Plan in 1971 and the subsequent updating, land had been safeguarded for possible MRT stations and the line routes. New buildings constructed in the vicinity of the stations had furthermore been approved with conditions that in case of MRT the owners would provide access to the underground station concourse. When a decision was taken in 1984 to build the system, this therefore did not lead to any major planning problems. The project was scheduled to be completed in 1992 and would cost S$5 billion. The official opening was in March 1988 and the last stages were completed in 1990, two years ahead of schedule. Land acquisition as governed by the Land Acquisition Act has been instrumental in transforming the physical landscape (Khublall 1984). It has facilitated extensive accumulation of land by the state where the main beneficiaries have been the buyers of public housing flats. Within the city area the traditional land ownership pattern was one of a very large number of individual small lots making new developments very difficult. To achieve renewal objectives substantial areas were acquired.
42
O.J. Dale
The decision to commence the MRT project necessitated acquisition of land for the stations within the city area. However, the government went one step further in the acquisition objectives. It was envisaged that the MRT would lead to a very high enhancement of land values around the stations. It was therefore decided that this enhancement should benefit Singapore society through the state since it was a result of public infrastructure investment. It could therefore be used to pay for the construction of the MRT. Acquisition furthermore facilitated amalgamation of the small individual lots and made it possible to re-parcel the land to maximize its development potential for subsequent integrated station developments. Land within a given distance from the stations was therefore compulsorily acquired, except for land with recently completed buildings and land with valid planning approval. The acquired land was amalgamated and held in a land bank by the state, administered by the Land Office. It is subsequently offered for sale through URA’s public tender system and according to new detailed area plans. The public transport system now consists of several well integrated components which again are integrated with land use and town planning: the MRT which has been extended and new lines added serve the heavy transit corridors. The city centre in particular is entirely dependent on the MRT as the main means of commuting. The LRT lines serve as feeders to MRT as well as suburban travel. Buses continue to serve the less heavy network corridors to complement MRT-LRT networks. There are also premier bus facilities which provide higher grade of bus service. In addition, taxis provide a car-like services. Pedestrian movement within sheltered conditions is often forgotten in traffic planning. One aspect learnt from the early shophouse architecture was to use covered walkways along the building frontage, a very important aspect especially in a hot tropical climate with frequent heavy rainfall. This concept was extended to new developments. The provision of a public accessible covered walkway became a planning condition and together with a roadside pavement this provides a safe pedestrian environment. Access for the disabled is another aspect. Twenty-five to 30 years ago a person in a wheelchair could hardly move within the city. A wheelchair user could not even cross the streets because the wheelchair could not climb from carriage level to the higher pavement level. Gradually access to all public spaces as well as to buildings has been secured. There are now spayed edges or ramped access for wheelchair users at all pedestrian crossings; the pavements must be barrier free. From 1989 the building control regulations stipulate that all buildings must have barrier free access: the owners must provide the necessary ramps, elevators and toilets. In most cities the demand for transport has been translated into an extensive use of motorized vehicles with an adverse effect on the environment. The dependence on fossil fuels makes these a main culprit in releasing emissions into the atmosphere. In Singapore the original primary objective for the restrictions on usage of private vehicles was congestion reduction, in particular within and into the city. The positive side effects were pollution control. Singapore has by now developed one of the best managed transportation systems in the world. It is, however, important to stress that the type of restrictions imposed
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
43
on private vehicles would not have been possible in a society with such high income levels without a corresponding high level of public transport service. Several cities have utilized the Singapore experience: none, however, have implemented the entire package. Why did it work in Singapore? Integrated planning between land use, town and transport planning the key. All the measures have become part of a comprehensive strategy and are coordinated very closely. Most important is the political will to think forward, make pragmatic decisions and implement these. There are, however, signs that the transport system may face increasing problems in the future. Despite the cap of 3 percent on the annual growth of private vehicles this growth will be pushing the vehicle population to about 1.2 million by 2020 as against 800,000 in 2006 (Lim 2007a). A more serious problem is the increased travel demand resulting from a population and employment growth which is substantially higher than the transport network planned for (LTA 1996). The current network is planned according to the parameters of the 1990s when Singapore had a very restrictive immigration policy. With low birth rates a very moderate population increase was expected. Already now the population envisaged in the long-term future has almost been reached. Today the population is close to 4.5 million. The long-term population planning parameters is now revised to 6.5 million. To solve the transportation part of this increase without undermining the quality of the environment will require bold solutions. A comprehensive review is now being carried out by LTA/Ministry of Transport. One expressed aim is to increase the proportion of trips taken on public transport during morning peak hours from 63 percent to at least 70 percent over the next 10–15 years (Mah 2007). To achieve this, very large investments will go into the public transport infrastructure. The new Circle Line will open from 2010 and will link all existing MRT lines running into the city and thus greatly enhance connectivity between suburban lines. The LTA is completing feasibility studies for a new 33-station City line which will link both the eastern and north-western parts of the island to the City Marina Bay area. It is expected that the current rail network will be more than doubled (Lim 2007b). The most critical part of the network will be the movement of people to and from the city centre. It is today the main employment location and will retain this position in the future but with substantial increase in employment and it will thus test the capabilities of the planners and political decision makers.
3.2.6
Conservation and Cultural Sustainability
Today the traditional Singapore shophouse street is recognized as an important part of the cultural and historical heritage of the nation but it was not like that some years back. The shophouse, 2–3 storeys in height, a continuous covered walkway along the front, a narrow frontage of about 6 metres, about 25 metres deep lots – the architectural styles reflect different time periods and are a mix of the European and Chinese influences which again reflect the dynamism of early Singapore’s economic growth.
44
O.J. Dale
Singapore’s first conservation efforts focussed on the monumental buildings. These included civic buildings, churches, temples, mosques etc. A selected number of buildings were protected under the Preservation of Monuments Act and the preservation order supervised by the Preservation of Monuments Board. Until the mid-1980s very little was done to retain the valuable shophouse environments. Substantial city districts such as the present Chinatown and Little India were safeguarded against demolition as they were defined as conservation areas. However, the houses were falling into disrepair and year by year the building condition deteriorated. The main reason for this was the rent control (Control of Rent Act 1970) together with uncertainty about the future of these areas. The rent act was designed to protect tenants from unscrupulous landlords by freezing all rents of properties completed before September 1947. Under the act the landlord of rent controlled properties could not legally evict tenants or sub-tenants, but could pay them compensation to vacate the premises, if they agreed to leave on their own accord. The general view of the value of retaining districts with traditional shophouses was one of ambivalence. Conservation of these was looked upon by most people, including many leading politicians as something Singapore could hardly afford. In their view the land could be redeveloped into new, modern commercial high yielding capital investments – besides removing what was considered leftover slums. Those advocating conservation of the historical areas argued and stressed their historical and cultural value, as well as the architectural and urban design contribution of these to the city (SIP, Forum on Conservation 1983). In the mid-1980s the tourist industry was facing extensive problems. The rapid growth had stopped and there were signs that it could go into decline. Several studies by international consultants followed. All strongly recommended conservation of historical and cultural features, focus should be on attractions which would bring to life the historical and cultural heritage of Singapore (Pannell, Kerr, Foster 1986). Conservation of the historic areas now got a new economic value, the future of tourism depended upon these. In October 1986, the then first Deputy Prime Minister, Goh Chok Tong, announced that Singapore, in order to attract more tourists would spend about S$1 billion over the next five years on tourist infrastructure. Of this S$187 million1 would be spent on building, preservation and restoration projects; S$260 million would be spent on upgrading historical areas and landmarks (Ministry of Trade and Industry 1986). The breakthrough in perception was the value of conservation areas and buildings for the tourist industry. Without this at a very critical point in time it would have been difficult to get political decisions to integrate such fairly large conservation areas in the city into the overall planning process. Once the process started, more and more people realized the value of the traditional buildings and their
1
As at August 2007, one United States dollar was equivalent to 1.52 Singapore dollars (S$).
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
45
importance to the heritage of the nation. Today the question is no longer “Why keep these buildings?” but rather, Why did we not save more? Rent control was relaxed and finally lifted in 1988 so as to facilitate upgrading of private-owned premises. A Master Plan for conservation was made public in 1989. It included not only areas within the city but also areas and districts as well as individual buildings on a national basis. Detailed guidelines were issued. Owners of private properties were encouraged to upgrade and to improve the maintenance. Management of state-owned properties became better and URA initiated the sale through public tender of land parcels with shophouses for conservation. The purchasers had to complete conservation work according to guidelines and within a given time frame. The success of the sales and the changing perceptions of the traditional buildings made these also into financial successes. The shophouse streets were no longer “slums” but valuable property investments. By the 1990s a total of about 5,600 buildings were under conservation protection. Conservation of the urban fabric has increasingly been included as an important part of strategic planning. A new focus on place identity was highlighted in the 2001 review of the Concept Plan. The local stakeholders and communities became involved in a more interactive dialogue with government agencies so as to share ideas and possibilities. Conservation of the built environment has come a long way. The traditional shophouses and shophouse street environment together with individual buildings and the selected major buildings protected under the Preservation of Monuments Board are cherished as important parts of the heritage of the nation. Their uniqueness also gives a special identity to a place as well as being important elements in the overall urban design of that area. The importance given to identity is an international trend. The globalization of cultures and ideas have reinforced the appreciation and strengthening of national cultural identity. The built environment is the most noticeable part of this. It has further strengthened the conservation efforts, seen as an important part of the identity of being Singaporean. The URA states that in order to ensure conservation itself is sustainable it takes a balanced approach. Owners are allowed to adapt conservation buildings to serve contemporary functions as well as to meet modern needs. Experience shows that with economically viable use the buildings are properly maintained and their useful lifespan extended. By 2004, these were approprietely 6,400 buildings in 67 areas all over Singapore with conservation status (URA 2004). The conservation effort is now integrated with overall planning in a unique comprehensive package which includes a legal framework for conserving buildings, inviting private development, encouraging good restoration practices, private and public sector consultations and promoting conservation of the built environment through education. The interdependence of culture, identity and commercial tourism is international. This aspect was already strongly stressed in the 1980s. The tourism product today is probably even more dependent on this than ever before. For Singapore, the ethnic-related historic areas such as Chinatown and Little India, together with a
46
O.J. Dale
range of individual buildings and a mix of shophouse retention integrated with new modern developments, are vital components in the tourism package. The museum precinct with museums and Fort Canning Park and Singapore River are other important components in this package. Within the city area most of the building occupiers are recent tenants. The management have therefore largely become orientated towards the consumers they serve, in particular the different groups of visitors. The Singapore Tourism Board (STB) has also played a very active role both as adviser, organizer and promoter. The cultural heritage, in particular within the city is therefore expressed foremost in the buildings and the overall street ambience. The activities and the inside of the buildings represent the business needs of today. It is the market mechanism at work. Yet, it creates environments which are unique and are popular among visitors and locals alike. Combined, all give a place uniqueness and special attraction; a sense of being in a history book, yet working, dining, shopping and experiencing a culture trip in a pleasant business environment (STB 2006).
3.3 3.3.1
Singapore City Centre and the World External Impacts on Singapore
The economy of Singapore at the time of independence revolved around its entrepôt trade with related services and the British military complex. Raw materials of the region were shipped to Singapore, reprocessed, packaged and then exported. Manufactured goods were imported and redistributed from Singapore to the countries in the region. The trade was dominated by British companies together with Chinese middlemen who conducted the regional part of this trade. The financial services of banking and insurance, shipping, and warehousing were supplied by both British and local Chinese banks and enterprises. The bulk of commercial activities took place within the city centre shophouses. The relatively well-developed entrepôt and service sector coexisted with small-scale manufacturing of consumer goods for the domestic markets of Singapore and Malaysia. With a large, growing population and unemployment, the creation of employment opportunities became the overriding objective of the newly elected government once Singapore attained self-government in 1959. From the onset, the viability of Singapore as a nation was questioned. It seemed to be too small, it had no natural resources, it had no room to expand. The separation from Malaysia in 1965 did not dispel the feeling of gloom. To solve the mounting problems the government adopted a policy of rapid industrialization based, in large measure, on the attraction of foreign investments into an export-orientated labour intensive industry. Singapore was fortunate in that multinational corporations at this time were shifting production out of their homebase. Singapore gave these corporations a good base for their money by providing a
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
47
competitive environment. The growth of manufacturing acted as a catalyst for the growth of services, which as time passed became a growth sector in it own right. Singapore also became an increasingly popular tourist destination. By the late 1960s Singapore had proven that despite its size it both could and would prosper on its own. During the years since the multiplier effects of several growth sectors such as manufacturing, entrepôt trade, banking, financial and general commercial services and tourism have created a dynamic and fast growing economy. The overall national economic changes and growth are reflected in the gross domestic product (GDP). In 1960 the GDP at market prices was S$2,149.6 million, in 2006 it was S$209,990.9 million. This gives a per capita figure of S$1,306 in 1960 and S$46,832 or US$29,474 in 2006 (Department of Statistics 2007b). The key to Singapore’s success is probably the pragmatic use of the wide range of social and economic policies and their implementation. Singling out individual factors such as leadership or favourable geography is not sufficient. Even if one goes into the inner cultural workings of society, it is not enough to single out political stability, or teamwork or choice of a particular economic strategy. It is probably the successful combination of all these that has made Singapore’s economic growth so rapid (Schein 1996). A most important component is the sustained expansion in skills and knowledge. An example is the educational system. From humble beginnings, the National University of Singapore and Nanyang Technological University, despite being public universities are today ranked among the top hundred in the world (The Times 2006). They represent the thinking that all levels in the educational system must be top rated, from manual skills and vocational training to university – that the Singapore population must be able to provide better skills and services than neighbouring countries and perceived competition from further away. I may add that academic services have been targeted as a growth sector in its own right with several top American and European universities offering courses jointly with local colleges or with mini-campuses in Singapore. Singapore’s progress has never been entirely smooth. There have been crises, both economic and political, but each time there has been a pragmatic and visionary evaluation of problems and a determination to find solutions, and to anticipate problems before they become big problems. For example, around 2000 problemsignals were emerging. The impact of the Asian financial crisis in 1997 and the emergence of China and India as Asia’s new economic powerhouses had relegated Southeast Asia to a second choice destination for many foreign investors. Only about 10 percent of foreign investment in Asia (2000) went here as against 60 percent in the early 1990s. The lessons from both Singapore’s regionalization programme and internal developments indicated a central weakness of the Singapore economy, a lack of “entrepreneurial talent”. An Economic Review Committee was given the task in 2001 of drawing up a blueprint. Simultaneously a “Remaking Singapore” Committee was formed to explore the social and political changes deemed necessary. The vision proposed was that Singapore must become a leading global city, a hub of talent, enterprise and innovation. Singapore will become the most open and cosmopolitan city in Asia and one of the best places to live and work. In another decade and a half,
48
O.J. Dale
Singapore will connect China, India and Southeast Asia and beyond. We will become an Asian centre of choice for global talent, attracting skilled technicians, managers, entrepreneurs and creative people from all over the world. We will be a creative and innovative society, always eager to try out new ideas and change for the better, with a culture that respects achievements in the sciences and arts. (Ministry of Trade and Industry 2003) Over the years Singapore society has been orientated towards a global market; at the same time the regional ties have been strengthened and developed. However, it is a competitive environment where Singapore cannot take economic progress and sustainability for granted. The rapid economic transformation has provided the capital for real estate investments, consumers with increasingly more money to spend; the demand for space (offices, shops, hotels, recreation facilities, etc.). It is a cumulative circular process where each component effects the growth of the others. Since the 1980s, major transformations in the composition of the world economy, including the sharp increase in specialized services for firms and finance, have renewed the importance of major cities for producing strategic global inputs (Brenner and Keil 2006). This combination of the global dispersal of factories, offices and service outlets, and global information integration has contributed to a strategic role for certain major cities or global cities (Sassen 2001; 2006). These new geographies of centrality bind together the major international financial and business centres such as New York, London, Tokyo, and Amsterdam. It now also includes cities such as Singapore. The intensity of transactions among these cities, particularly through financial markets has increased sharply and so have the orders of magnitude. One can argue that today’s global cities are command points in the organization of the world economy, key locations for the leading industries – finance and specialized services and major sites for production. Modern Singapore has greatly benefited from the globalization of manufacturing, trade and services. It started its economic growth path as a production platform for international corporations as they relocated to low-cost manufacturing areas. Over the years it has changed from a low-cost production centre to a high-technology society. Already in the 1980s corporations were actively encouraged to locate their regional and international headquarters to Singapore. Another arm of a national development policy started in the 1990s through the government’s regionalization strategy. Rising labour and land costs started to make Singapore less attractive for labourintensive manufacturing activities. Instead of doing nothing and seeing foreign corporations move far away without any further linkage, the new strategy encouraged them to locate production in Singapore’s developed industrial parks and in selected cities across the Asia Pacific region (Pereira 2005). Of particular importance were production bases in neighbouring countries. These could still provide Singapore with a good source of income when they made use of Singapore as a service hub to meet their needs for transportation, finance and other headquarter services and facilities (Toh 2006). The governments of Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia agreed to establish a sub-regional cooperative framework known as the Indonesia–Malaysia–Singapore
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
49
Growth Triangle, and which included the Riau Islands in Indonesia and Johor state in Malaysia. It involved political decisions to reduce barriers to trade and investment as well as tax and financial incentives. In terms of an internal hierarchy Singapore has focussed on becoming the regional finance, business and high-technology centre, while unskilled and semi-skilled, labour-intensive industries move to Johor and the Riau islands of Batam and Bintan. While regional cooperation including trade agreements through ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) as well as bilateral agreements has ensured that the Southeast Asian countries have a stable and cordial good relationship to each other there has always been some competitive tension, in particular between Malaysia and Singapore. Malaysia’s “multimedia super corridor” is an example of a deliberate global city formation project. Massive public resources have been poured into developing and promoting show-case projects. The aim is both to establish Kuala Lumpur as part of the global city network and to challenge Singapore’s leading regional position. As mentioned, the Singapore government has actively promoted Singapore as a major player in the global economic and social network. Its limited and confined land area was turned to its advantage. The city and the nation was one and could be planned and managed accordingly. The city centre is the main stage for international and local business, finance, tourism, culture, arts and recreation. It is supported by and integrated with a well planned system of residential areas, new towns, areas for business, manufacturing, recreation etc. An important element in the development is that government has refrained from direct investment in prestige projects. Its policy has been to be a planner/manager and provider of infrastructure as well as active promoter of selective objectives. Even infrastructure investments must comply with cost/benefit targets. The exceptions are social infrastructure and public housing. Investment and construction of commercial buildings and private housing is up to the private sector, which must ensure that its investments are financially sound. A comparison of Singapore city centre with central areas in other major Asian cities shows many similarities in terms of the dynamics of development. Multinational and transnational corporations of all sizes play a significant role both through their own cross-national activities and through their relations with local firms in host cities. There are similarities in city centre role as the primary cultural, entertainment and recreational locations. Yet, there are major differences. Singapore has no large population reservoir: new entrants from elsewhere to the Singapore labour market must go through immigration controls. Only those with the desired qualifications are given permanent residence, an employment pass or work permit. Urban scale is another major difference. Singapore is relatively small. In a comparison the population in the major Asian cities is not only larger, but also growing at a faster rate. For example; Shanghai (14.5 million), Beijing (10.7 million), Guangzhou (8.4 million), Mumbai (18.2 million), Delhi (15.0 million), Seoul (9.6 million), Tokyo (35.2 million), Osaka (11.2 million); Bangkok (6.5 million), Hong Kong (7.0 million) (United Nations 2005). There is a major difference in land use structure in that through deliberate planning policies combined with landownership and control policies, and purpose
50
O.J. Dale
planned new towns, Singapore has a far more defined city centre compared to other cities where it tends to be fused with the surrounding sprawling city areas. The process of economic restructuring in global cities as diverse as London, New York and Shanghai generating a large growth in demand for low-wage workers and jobs that offer few advancement possibilities is present but there is not a big floating population ready to take jobs. The confined land area and a government committed to a fair distribution of development benefits have meant that planning and management of land resources has been a national priority task. Herein lies the main difference between Singapore and most other large Asian cities: planning of the city based on long-term vision, and determined plan implementation and management together with the advantage a nation/city boundary gives.
3.3.2
Energy, Pollution and Regional Cooperation
Regional cooperation is largely structured through ASEAN. While the organization is an excellent vehicle for trade agreements, mutual understanding and general political decisions, the member countries deliberately avoid what may be called interference or strong criticism of other members. One example is the environmental disaster caused by illegal logging of the Indonesian tropical jungle. Each year during the dry season large parts of Malaysia and Singapore, inclusive the city centre are for periods covered in haze produced by forest fires in Indonesia. The fires are largely a result of illegal logging and forest clearing. For more than a decade ASEAN environment ministers have had regular meetings to discuss ways to tackle the trans-boundary haze pollution in the region. Yet very little has happened. There have been a lot of committees. The haze is an example of a regional environmental problem but the solution lies with specific countries. If these lack the political will, and do not have the full administrative abilities, there is little recipient countries can do by direct involvement besides contributing to a haze fund. On paper it should be straightforward: less meetings, focus on the logging and the haze, develop the work plan and start implementing things on the ground. The Singapore industrial parks on Batam and Bintan were envisaged as selfcontained projects with minimal dependency on the surrounding environments, and with their communication and business linkages through Singapore rather than through Indonesia (Yeoh et al. 2003). These were initiated as a well-planned and efficient Singapore-styled business environment in emerging economies for local companies and Singapore-based MNCs. However, Batam, in particular; soon achieved a “boomtown” reputation which overwhelmed it. Almost half the population, which had more than tripled from 1990 to 2000 consisted of new migrants living in illegal squatter houses. Other industrial parks have been rapidly developing, many are backed by prominent Indonesian politicians, and serious environmental considerations are frequently lacking. Economically Batam seems to be a success. In 1989, prior to the creation of the Batam Industrial Park the total employment was about 11,000, mainly in local
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
51
services, tourism and oil-related firms using the island as a base (Yeoh et al. 2003). In 2004 the economic activities provided employment for more than 260,000 workers. It reportedly generated about 14 percent of Indonesia’s export income other than oil (Toh 2006). However, the need for environmental sustainability was clearly underestimated from the beginning. It highlights the problems of initiating projects with specific objectives, and then facing rapid development in an area with only very basic infrastructure, a “soft” administration, a huge increase in immigrant population over a short time, and location of large numbers of manufacturing firms with a wide range of requirements and outputs. Singapore and Hong Kong or highly urbanized countries need to import resources to meet their needs. Measured in ecological footprint they use far more resources than is consonant with their area capacity (Wackernagel 2001). In general, cities and industrial regions are dependent on a vast and increasingly global hinterland of ecologically productive areas. The industrialized countries appropriate the ecological output and life support functions of distant regions all over the world through commercial trade and the natural biogeochemical cycles of energy and material (Rees 1996). Even more dependent on imported ecological capacity from a global marketplace is a city-state such as Singapore. Singapore therefore has to rely on imported ecological capacity. Like Hong Kong it will have a more dispersed footprint which will have a substantial transportation overhead. However, it may be increasingly difficult to maintain competitiveness as the global deficit increases and resources become scarcer. Neighbouring countries such as Indonesia with a rapid growing population are already exceeding their capacity. Reduced ecological deficit to decrease risk exposure and secure future well-being is becoming increasingly important. A critical part of the sustainability relates to the production and use of energy. The production of energy is the Achilles heel in the Singapore energy sustainability programme. Another major problem is energy consumption and emissions such as carbon dioxide. Singapore is currently entirely dependent on imports for primary energy consumption. Crude oil constitutes about 80 percent and natural gas piped from Malaysia and Indonesia about 20 percent. To meet future demand and ease its dependence on natural gas there are plans to diversify the gas supplies by importing and processing liquefied natural gas. Future sources may include solar energy, biomass energy and wind-powered electricity but there are no immediate plans for such. Singapore has a very high energy consumption related to its population size. The reason for this seeming inconsistency when we know that the country has some of the most stringent energy use and conservation requirements is because of the industrial users. Singapore is one of the top three oil trading and refining hubs in the world. Visitors may not notice the size of these facilities as they are mainly localized on Jurong Island and Jurong industrial estates. The energy intensive petrochemical industries and Singapore’s role as the major oil products exporter result in energy consumption figures which in overall international statistics give Singapore very high comparative energy consumption rates per population and to GDP. Oil and gas are used as fuel for most industrial activities. Reduction in the carbon dioxide or CO2 emissions from the energy sector is therefore critical. A series of measures adopted as part of the Singapore Green Plan 2012 are tailored to reduce
52
O.J. Dale
CO2 emissions per GDP dollar by 25 percent from the 1990 level by 2012. A further step was taken in 2006 as Singapore committed itself to the Kyoto Protocol and would reduce emissions of CO2 and other heat trapping gases to about 5 percent below the 1990 level (Ibrahim 2006). Natural gas use is now rising rapidly as the government promotes policies aimed at reducing carbon dioxide and sulphur emissions. In 2002 it set a target of 60 percent of the country’s electricity to be generated from natural gas by 2012. The Energy Market Authority (EMA) reported that already in 2005 about 80 percent of the electricity supply came from natural gas. The newest power stations consist solely of natural gas-fired combined cycle gas turbines (EMA 2006). The import of natural gas requires extensive regional cooperation. Pipelines are costly to build; they need to be constructed over substantial distances; and require constant maintenance. The supply lines must be reliable since the recipient cannot easily switch supplier. So far pipelines have been constructed from Johor in Malaysia to Singapore as well as from separate fields in Indonesia. Despite the range of energy saving measures the demand for energy is projected to grow. APEC forecasts indicate an annual growth rate of 3.7 percent based on current trends. It is thus projected that by 2030 total energy demand will be 33 Mtoe as against 12 Mtoe in 2002. The industry sector will maintain the largest share with 55 percent, followed by transport (30 percent), commercial (10 percent) and residential (5 percent) (APEC Energy Review 2006). The implications are that the large consumers – in particular industry and transport – must completely revamp their operations and energy consumption patterns. If the current trends continue then the transport and commercial sectors are both expected to grow at about 4 percent annually. The primary reason for the high growth in transport is the projected demand for fuel in the air transport business centred on Changi Internationl Airport. Despite the constraints on ownership and use of passenger vehicles the demand for road transport fuel is expected to grow at 2 percent annually, the main reason being the increasing number of commercial vehicles. Besides the transport usage the main demand for energy within the city area is from the commercial sector as well as residential and institutional buildings. The main source of energy in residential buildings is electricity (90 percent) and gas. Electricity is the only energy source utilized in the commercial sector. The production of electricity is oil and gas dependent. By 2030 it is envisaged that at least 90 percent of the fuel will be natural or liquefied gas and more efficient power generation technology will be in use. Due to the tropical heat close to 60 percent of electricity used in commercial buildings such as offices and shopping centres is for air-conditioning of the buildings. Whether these are high-rise or low makes little difference in air-conditioning usage. Air-conditioning has become a necessity and has probably been a prerequisite for Singapore’s development success. Despite average outdoor temperatures of above 30 degrees Celsius and high humidity the controlled indoor environment has made living in a hot and humid tropical country pleasant. Efforts to improve energy efficiency started long ago. Energy conservation standards were introduced and included in the building code in 1979 prescribing the
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
53
maximum overall thermal transfer value (OTTV). The standards which over time have been updated gave permissible efficiency standards and guidelines both pertaining to the building envelope as well as internal conservation measures (Building and Construction Authority 2004; Singapore (SS) 530, 2007). In 2004 a more stringent and comprehensive set of regulations were introduced. Buildings had to comply with a stipulated thermal transfer value (ETTV). A green building rating system was also in place from the same year. The purpose was to reward and enhance the construction of buildings which incorporate environment-friendly design and construction practices. One feature was the inclusion of green landscaping and roof-top gardens together with site conservation and restoration criteria. In January 2007 the revised Singapore Standard 530 on Energy Efficiency for Building Services and Equipment was launched (SS 530, 2007). The new standard is operational from July 2007. SS530 provides the minimum energy efficiency standard of building equipment such as air-conditioning, heat rejection, water heaters, electric motors and lightings (SS 530, 2007). On average it is expected that implementation of the new standard will lead to energy savings of about 30 percent. It is also important to highlight other factors which contribute to sustainability levels. Besides building design and planning standards, all buildings must comply with stringent requirements pertaining to fire safety, drainage and sewerage, ventilation and general building codes. The majority of existing office buildings, shopping centres etc. were built in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s and constructed using old building codes and technology. By today’s standards they consume too much energy and are ripe for retrofitting. So far this process is moving at a slow pace. Perhaps one positive effect of the increasingly high energy costs is that it becomes more profitable to retrofit older buildings and thus achieve a dual objective:owners collect higher retals after retrofitting from tenants who would save energy expenses, and a subtantial overall energy saving and pollution reduction is attained. The question is, is this enough? Should the performance standards be higher? Should there be high penalties for building owners who retain low-performing equipment? Environmental awareness among the real estate and construction sector is still in its early stage. There is a conflict between what is desirable and business competitiveness. It is a difficult balance. If Singapore stipulates substantially higher requirements than those in competing business cities, then it adds onto other cost and regulatory factors which may make the cost of doing business too high. Yet, lower consumption and cleaner energy is a necessity.
3.4
Conclusion
A theme which has been running through all debates on future directions from the 1960s until the present is “we cannot stand still”. There is a continuous strive towards a higher level of activity which has been sustaining the development of Singapore, the nation, and so clearly reflected in the city centre environments.
54
O.J. Dale
Investments in the tourist industry are a good example of the drive for Singapore to reinvent itself (STB 2006). Singapore had been losing ground relative to other destinations. New initiatives for the tourist industry were made public in 2005. The government would spend S$2 billion in an effort to double the number of overseas visitors from 8.9 million in 2005 to 17 million by 2015 and create 100,000 new tourism-related jobs. The focus would be on three key areas: enhancing Singapore’s position as one of Asia’s most popular convention and exhibition centres; developing its attractiveness as a holiday destination; and promoting the country as a hub for services such as healthcare and education (Lim 2005). Central here is the decision to award a 12.2 hectare site at Marina Bay to Las Vegas Sands for an integrated resort. The key component in the project, named Marina Bay Sands is a casino. The idea of building a casino in Singapore has been mooted several times before and rejected. Social, political and religious organizations voiced opposition, even within government there were substantial doubts. Besides fears over the possible social fallouts another aspect is that Singapore may be moving too fast and it would be difficult to sustain such growth. The counterargument is that without the type of project the integrated resort represented Singapore would stagnate and not reach its ambitious goals. It is therefore necessary in order to sustain the long-term well-being of the hospitality sector. The project cost to the developer is more than S$5 billion and the project has a total floor area of 570,000 square metres of which the casino amounts to less than 5 percent. It is scheduled to be completed by 2010. Together with existing facilities and another integrated resort on Sentosa it will make Singapore a hub for tourism, business and conventions. The Marina Bay Sands will employ more than 10,000 people. The spin-off throughout the economy is expected to include 30,000 new jobs in the hospitality sector and an initial S$2.7 billion contribution to GDP. The government has put the stakes high. The project is part of its plan to push Singapore to a higher level in seeking to become a “global city, attracting talent from around the world, lively, vibrant, and fun to live in – a cosmopolitan hub of the region” (Lee 2005). There is now a radical shift in perceptions. In the debate in Parliament about the integrated resort Lee Kuan Yew stressed that the new Singapore cannot remain the same as old Singapore, a neat and tidy place with no chewing gum, no this, no that – not a fun place. The old model was to create a first world city in a third world region – clean, green, efficient, a pleasant healthy and wholesome society, safe and secure for everyone. These virtues are no longer considered sufficient. Now it must be an economically vibrant and exciting city to visit, with top class symphony orchestras, concerts, drama, plays, artists and singers and popular entertainment. These are the lifestyles international professionals and executives seek (Lee 2005). Therefore Singapore has to reposition itself. The underlying concept which has been generally accepted by the political leadership is that economic globalization is leading to a hierarchy of cities, dominated by the notion of enhanced competitiveness. The globalization is seen as creating a new role for cities. This again means that the global economic forces require cities to respond competitively with strategies adapted so as to attract new economic investments.
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
55
Singapore has from the early beginning had to position itself within the framework of international politics, capital and technology. However, as it seeks to embrace the economy as a global city, a talent hub and a centre for innovation and enterprise it will increasingly have to play even closer by the rules of a global marketplace. The Marina Bay development is at the centre as Singapore also tries to reinvent the urban landscape image. It is part of the repositioning of the Singapore brand or uniqueness. About 25 years ago most of the reclamation of the 340 hectare land called Marina South had been completed. The final part of the reclamation and the embankments along the bay was completed in the 1990s. Marina Bay is the name now given to the current city expansion. Together with the earlier completed Marina Centre the reclaimed land has given Singapore city a unique land reserve for future long-term expansion. Hardly any major city has such land bank opportunities available adjacent to the traditional city centre and existing CBD. The development concept reflects Singapore’s ambition to be a global city. The vision as outlined by the Minister for National Development is that “it is to be a place for thriving business, gracious living and endless entertainment, as well as a place of creativity, arts and culture, architectural excellence, world class recreation, global commerce and modern city life rolled into one” (Mah 2005). Marina Bay is envisaged to become the new heart of the city. It comprises the existing CBD at Raffles Place and Shenton Way, the hotel and convention concentration at Marina Centre, and the new developments around the bay. In 2007 the Marina Barrage will be completed and the water body within Marina Bay will together with Singapore River and Kallang Basin form a controlled water basin. The fit ones can then take a 12-kilometres walk around the entire bay area. The aim is to create a waterfront city in a garden. The overall planning concepts include a series of distinctive districts, clustered around major public open spaces and signature streets. A common services tunnel provides uninterrupted space for the network of underground electricity cables, pipes for water supply, cooling systems etc. A district cooling system is planned to alleviate individual building air-conditioning. The plans emphasize environmentally friendly design solutions. Within this framework an international design competition was recently completed (2006) for the 54hectare central park. The winning design by a UK-based team highlights the application of sustainable energy systems and environmental education. What will the future be like? Can Singapore sustain the growth levels people have got used to? For the next 20–30 years the main economic forces are generally considered favourable. The economy is closely linked to the three big economic centres, USA, EU and Japan. In addition China and India together with Australia are pulling at the economies of not only Singapore but also some of the adjoining countries. It is generally accepted that Singapore will have a significant role. However, some analysts would add that Singapore is a small, open economy. It is therefore highly vulnerable to international events outside its own control. It is pertinent to relate the sustainability of Singapore to the overall environmental problems in Asia, due in particular to the magnitude and scale of the development projects in China and India. Does this generate a fear for the future? Generally
56
O.J. Dale
speaking there is a growing understanding of the need to readjust policies. The view that international environmental problems are mostly created by the industrialized countries, in particular, the USA, is becoming obsolete, and instead there is a realization that Asian countries must urgently take action to avoid huge problems and thus expenditure in the near future. For example, China has now the world’s most ambitious national renewable energy targets (WWF 2005). Much can be learned from existing initiatives. Japan’s economy is already almost three times as energy efficient as that of the USA. There is also an optimistic attitude that problems can be solved. The rapid economic development and the transformation of the social structure have induced a positive view that there are always solutions. Singapore’s environmental challenges are about environmental quality, reconciling environmental and economic needs and dealing with rising expectations. Within the regional political framework it has to take a more pro-active role in stimulating and assisting in the implementation of more sustainable development directions. The overriding problems of energy supply, consumption and emissions are danger factors, not so much for the city centre but for Singapore’s overall energy sustainability levels. This means an urgency to accelerate the introduction of clean technologies, resource-efficient buildings and the deployment of new energy saving and greenhouse reducing technologies. Singapore city has come a long way; it is an example of what can be achieved when there is political will to set goals and to achieve these. Increasingly higher social and economic targets have been met. The city centre is exemplary and is clean, green and vibrant. With judicious adaptation of environment-friendly solutions it has the potential to present itself as a textbook example of a good sustainable city environment.
References Asia Pacific Energy Research Centre (2006) APEC energy review, energy demand and supply outlook (Singapore). Tokyo/Singapore Brenner Neil, Keil Roger (2006) The global cities reader. Routledge, London Building and Construction Authority (2004) Guidelines on envelope thermal transfer value. Singapore Dale Ole Johan (1999) Urban planning in Singapore: The transformation of a city. Oxford University Press, Shah Alam, Malaysia Department of Social Welfare (1948) Report of the social survey of Singapore, 1947. Singapore Department of Statistics (2006) Singapore census of population 2000, Yearbook of Statistics. Singapore. Department of Statistics (2007a) Singapore population estimates, Singapore. http://www.singstat. gov.sg Department of Statistics (2007b) Annual GDP at Current Market Prices, Singapore. http://www. singstat.gov.sg Energy Market Authority (EMA) (2006) Annual report 2005/2006. Singapore Foster, Pannell, Kerr et al. (1986) Tourism Product Development Plan for Singapore. Singapore Tourist Promotion Board Girardet Herbert (2001) Creating sustainable cities: the green books for the Schumacher Society, Devon Goh Keng Swee (1958) Urban incomes and housing – a report on the social survey of Singapore, 1953–54, Singapore
3 Sustainable City Centre Development
57
Khublall N (1984) Law of compulsory purchase and compensation-Singapore and Malaysia. Butterworths, Singapore Land Transport Authority (1996) A world class land transport system – White Paper, Singapore Land Transport Authority (LTA) (2006) http://www.lta.gov.sg accessed January 2007 Lee Hsien Loong (2005) Prime Minister’s speech in Parliament on the casino decision. Channel News Asia, 18 April 2005 Lee Kuan Yew (1977) Prime Minister’s speech at opening of Upper Pierce Reservoir, 27 February 1977 Lee Kuan Yew (2005) Minister mentor’s speech in Parliament, 19 April 2005, Singapore, Government Press release Lim Hng Kiang (2005) Unveiling tourism plan 2015. Asian Economic News, Minister for Trade and Industry, 18 January 2005 Lim Raymond (2007a) Transport Minister, Channel News Asia, 9 March 2007 Lim Raymond (2007b) Transport Minister, Business Times, 10 March 2007 Mah Bow Tan (2005) Speech at ULI international waterfront conference. Minister for National Development, Singapore, 3 October 2005 Mah Bow Tan (2007) URA corporate seminar, 9 February 2007. Minister for National Development, Singapore Ministry of National Development (1965) Master Plan – First review. Singapore, Planning Department Ministry of the Environment (1992) Green Plan – Towards a Model Green City – A Tropical City of Excellence, Singapore Ministry of the Environment (2006) Singapore Green Plan 2012. Singapore Ministry of Trade and Industry (1986) The Tourism Product Development Plan, Singapore Ministry of Trade and Industry (2003) Report of the Economic Review Committee, Singapore Pereira Alexius (2005) Singapore’s regionalization strategy. Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy, Vol. 10, August 2005 Planews (1983) SIP Forum on Conservation 1. Singapore Institute of Planners, Singapore Rees William (1996) Revisiting carrying capacity: Area-based indicators of sustainability, population and environment. A Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies, Vol. 17, January 1996 Sassen Saskia (2001) The global city: New York, London, Tokyo. Princeton University Press, New York Sassen Saskia (2006) Cities in a world economy. Pine Forge Press, Thousand Oaks, CA Schein Edgar (1996) Strategic pragmatism: The culture of Singapore’s Economic Development Board. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. Singapore (SS) 530 (2007) Energy efficiency standard for building services and equipment, SPRING Singapore Singapore Tourism Board (2006) Beyond words: The next phase of uniquely Singapore brand campaign, Singapore Times (The) (2006) World university rankings, The Times higher education supplement, 6 October 2006 Toh Mun Heng (2006) Development in the Indonesia–Malaysia–Singapore Growth Triangle. SCAPE Working Paper no. 2006/06, National University of Singapore, Singapore United Nations (2005) The 2005 Revision Population Database. http://esa.un.org accessed December 2006 Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) (2001) Concept Plan 2001. Singapore Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) (2004) Skyline, March/April 2004, Singapore Wackernagel Mathis (2001) Advancing sustainable resource management, using ecological footprint for problem formulation. Policy Development and Communication, DG Environment, European Commission, 27 February 2001 World Wildlife Fund (WWF) (2005) The ecological footprint and natural wealth. Asia- Pacific, 2005 Yaacob Ibrahim (2006) MEWR news release, Minister for the Environment and Water Resources, 7 March 2006 Yeoh Caroline, Cai Charmaine, Wee Julian (2003) Transborder industrialization and Singapore’s industrial parks in Indonesia and China. Singapore Management University, Singapore
Chapter 4
Integrated Resort in the Central Business District of Singapore: The Land Use Planning and Sustainability Issues Tai-Chee Wong
4.1
Introduction
Placing land use planning in the same basket with sustainable development is a relatively new issue in the domain of modern urban development. Sustainability planning, if it is to be perceived as a new agenda of planning, has yet to overcome hurdles put forward by politicians, economists and the general public (see Wheeler 2004: 32). By the very nature of planning, whether in terms of land use, economic, social or environmental, its purpose is to achieve in a systematic and organized approach the set medium- or long-term objectives and goals. Land use planning therefore is an instrument per se or an organized profession for those practicing it that would have to adapt to changing circumstances associated with the set goals. For example, when sustainable urban development is a set goal that aims to achieve an environmentally pleasant city, the planning criteria deployed would then be based on a “visionary garden city”. Logically, in the real world, as decision-makers’ priorities change from one stage to another, land use planners are often in no position to undertake a holistic approach to planning of the urban environment. In practice, they habitually have to ignore the realities of political and economic power that have effected land use change, and have to facilitate its change orientated towards those set by decision-makers for one reason or another. Digital technology, rising global city competition and changing functions of the central business districts (CBD) have resulted in dynamic and rapid evolution of the city core functions today. Classical and conventional categorization of the 1950s is largely invalid for defining the contemporary functions of key world cities. Even in the large American cities during the 1950s, CBD structure and outlines were changing and difficult to define. Pictures of the CBD would reflect its continual response to prevailing economic conditions that would lead to a forecast of the future (see Murphy et al. 1955: 41–42; Gottmann 1961). Over the last 50 years, in North America
National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, 1 Nanyang Walk, 637616, Singapore, Republic of Singapore, e-mail:
[email protected]
T.-C. Wong et al. (eds.), Spatial Planning for a Sustainable Singapore, 59–78 © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
This page intentionally blank
60
T.-C. Wong
massive suburbanization has created new sub-core centres in extended metropolitan regions, diluting the values of the originally dominating CBD core to a series of sub-cores of challengeable functions in some cases (Kaplan et al. 2004). More significantly, and specifically during the last two decades, urban services growth and expansion of global tourism have injected new life into the conventional functions characterized by advanced and financial services. Furthermore, cultural and entertainment businesses have played an increasing role in the central city restructuring to regenerate dynamism with an aim to make the downtown core lively after office hours. Thus, an “innovative” planning response has begun. The CBD feature has changed from conventional emphasis on land values and land use intensity, to values of production of high-order services, whatever their nature. Under the impact of intensifying globalization and global city competition, the emphasis has equally shifted towards international digital flows of information and human traffic – the latter being notably business and higher-end tourists. In Singapore, a new urban form is being created downtown by global market forces as the city-state advances into a post-industrialist and post-modernist production system characteristic of an increasingly flexible specialization of urban services. Against this backdrop of development, ideas of sustainable urban development are a crucial element to counter the adverse effects of intensifying global business competition as a means of safeguarding rapid urban transformation. The encounter of CBD transformation with policy measures in favour of sustainable development has brought forth an intriguing issue to be discussed in this chapter. This chapter aims to examine the changing and expanding functions of the CBD, how financial and leisure services might merge to become a new integrated function. To understand how such a merger is taking place, the first part of the study investigates the rationale of Singapore’s integrated resort (IR) in association with its aim to expand tourism and knowledge-intensive industry – both are high-end revenue generators (Wong et al. 2006; Fagence 1995). The second part of the study analyses the land use planning and the characteristics of the Las Vegas Sands Proposal, highlighting how it takes Singapore’s aspirations forward to a global city. Finally, the sustainable development issue is addressed as to how sustainable economic development is justified against the controversial sustainable social development issue, the casino issue.
4.2
Changing Functions of the Central Business District
The definition of the Central Business District has changed in context over time. But the centrality, high index of accessibility and economic dynamism of such a district have remained crucial conditions to qualify for such a classification. Take the case of New York CBD. It had evolved from a port CBD in the 18th century as a port break-ofbulk site where European freight was unloaded and immigrants landed to a specialfunction CBD requiring financial and banking services. Its service area was restricted to a localized agricultural hinterland in the 19th century but went on to achieve national and global influence in the 20th century (see Kaplan et al. 2004).
4 Integrated Resort in the Central Business District of Singapore
61
Population density profiles in a spontaneously developed CBD in a vast country such as the USA might have followed the successive stages of city development outlined by Newling (1969) that demonstrated a staged pattern of density change from young, early maturity, late maturity and finally to old age. From a small CBD, its rapid growth bolstered high population density in the centre, to gradually shift from the centre to further away at the late maturity and old age stages. Such an evolution might be symbolic of some identified American cities but it could differ dramatically from Western Europe, Japan, Latin America and Southeast Asia (Scargill 1979: 43–46). Decline of the CBDs in the US began in the 1960s, as central city retail and financial services shifted to the suburban zones in the decentralization process. By the early 2000s, only an average of three percent of retail sales took place in the metropolitan area, with the bulk of business transferred to suburban centres and edge cities (Kaplan et al 2004). The experience of a colonial port city such as Singapore, Hong Kong, Jakarta or Manila had been very different from that of New York due to their functions preset by their colonial authorities, as well as their post-independence development path and economic strategies. Evolution of the Singapore CBD has been dramatic since its independence in 1965.
4.2.1
Evolution of the Singapore CBD and Inclusion of Integrated Resort in Marina Bay
The city-state of Singapore has a well-defined coastal boundary without a hinterland and its land development has been predetermined by a centralized land use planning system and a highly economic-biased policy. Having gone successfully through the modernist process of urban renewal and rational comprehensive planning of the Central Area during the 1960s–1970s (see Dale 1999; Wong and Yap 2004), the persistent pursuit for sustained economic growth by the People’s Action Party (PAP) government has tended to reorient Singapore’s CBD development towards the “entrepreneurial CBD package”. If downtown revitalization schemes in the US have been put in place in an attempt to bring back dynamism and prosperity to the once-powerful CBD, Singapore has initiated identical “growth machine” efforts but in different forms based on the business potential of the various schemes. As a symbol of the most advanced capitalist society, post-modern development of the American contemporary metropolitan centres is manifested in the massive suburban malls in a dispersed pattern, revitalized downtowns and festival market places (Knox and Pinch 2000; Gottdiener 1997). Concomitantly, new spaces of post-modern consumerist culture are being constructed in Singapore through the theming of Chinatown, the Singapore River and the creation of new entertainment commodities (Huang and Chang 2003). Against the backdrop of the old paradigms of economic growth, more and more researchers are broadening their scope of study from “land, labour, capital and management” to the new frontier of the “new economy” in the contemporary globalization era.
62
T.-C. Wong
Recreational planning in Singapore, with no exception, has also changed from the straight-jacket open and green spaces provision, recreational provision such as a bowling alley, squash courts and other outdoor facilities (see Koh and Tan 1976; Weiskopf 1982) to more intensive and sophisticated entertainment businesses. Increasingly, culture, amenities (notably tourism) and entertainment are seen as a consumption-based good, an important development tool to drive economic growth (Clark 2004; Ergazakis et al 2006). Whether leading and being led in the globally competitive world, the most significant and common goal of both the US and Singapore is to attract tourists to their new developments. If the American cities focus on winning the suburbanites back to downtown, the Singapore model’s purpose is to capture an international clientele. Over the last 15 years, many strategies have been used to render the downtown area more attractive, with the objective to sustain economic growth, and cultural and social viability. Like the United States, a number of downtown development strategies have been deployed in Singapore such as historic conservation and architectural preservation (inclusive of Chinatown, Little India, Kampong Glam), downtown and waterfront housing (gentrification for revitalization, see Wong 2006), cultural attractions (Esplanade’s Arts Centre), new office constructions, a convention centre (Suntec City), creation of underground pedestrian spaces. The latest and most current are the two integrated resorts in Marina Bay and Sentosa Island. This study focuses on the integrated resort at Marina Bay which is a planned merger of conventional CBD with the tourist-oriented business district, also known as tourism business district, a characteristic of the merger of functions.
4.2.2
A Merger of Financial and Leisure Services in Downtown Singapore
4.2.2.1
The Case of an Integrated Resort at Marina Bay
Integrated resorts create a themed environment that today forms a strong basis of modern tourism operations. A themed environment satisfies the search for leisure and happiness by means of production of desire made effective through marketing, advertising and the provision of related services and infrastructure. It is therefore a commercial venue that has potential for realizing substantial profit that justifies the use of a prime and centralized site, characterized supposedly by intensive commercial usage. An urban tourism business district, by definition, does not always rely on natural resources but has an all-year orientation in services, using a concentrated form, cultural images and purpose-built structures to woo visitors. In an increasingly mobile business world, the tourism business district is also interpreted as an inevitable supplement in after-hour vitality and recreational nightlife for major CBDs currently suffering from deserted streets after dark (see Getz 1993, Zhang and Shang 2006). The integrated resort as a tourism business district in the making at the
4 Integrated Resort in the Central Business District of Singapore
63
Marina Bay is adjacent to the existing CBD; both engage high intensity of land use, high-value activities and are highly accessible. They are mutually dependent, given that the former depends on the intensity of business travel in relation to the CBD financial and professional/specialized services of foreign multinationals and local international firms. Differentiated by separate functions, they share the Marina Bay as the common waterfront; the CBD’s morphological feature is characterized by skyscrapers as a built skyline landscape complemented by the integrated resort’s recreational significance of sea, beach, water sports and other leisure services. Matching up with the need to capture entertainment as a key source of growth, the Singapore downtown reserve – Marina South has modified its land use functions. Marina Bay, which is situated at the north of Marina South, was planned for local shopping (low- to medium-density commercial use) in the 1991 revised Concept Plan. With rapid global change since then, and as Singapore intensifies its tertialization process towards a knowledge-intensive economy, themed and commodified cultural activities have overshadowed conventional land use considerations. A new and growing concern of optimizing the prime central city lands takes priority from the early period of the decade 2000s. This time, it is a distinct segment of tourist market for higher-end leisure consumers found to be desirable next to Singapore’s existing CBD – the making of an integrated resort.
4.3 4.3.1
Rationale of Singapore’s Integrated Resorts Tourism: Global Trend
Since the 1980s, increasing tertialization of the global economy has been remarkably reflected in the tourism industry – the world’s largest service industry. It is anticipated that by 2010 the industry will contribute to 11.6 percent of global GDP, and 9 percent of global employment. International tourists across the globe would increase from 673 million in 2000 to 1,602 million in 2020, involving more than US$2 trillion spending in different categories of hospitality services. Comparable rates of growth are also projected for East Asia and the Pacific which will surpass the Americas to become the second most important recipient region after Europe. Real income growth, demographic and social changes, new tourism products as well as technological and trading developments are, interalia, factors that have bolstered tourism in the Asia Pacific as the fastest expanding region in international tourism arrivals. Major cities as gateways are expected to benefit from the MICE sector (meetings, incentives, conventions and exhibitions) more than adjacent regions or natural resort areas. Multiplier effects and job creation impacts are greater in gateways than non-gateways (Mistilis and Dwyer 1999; Singapore Tourism Board 2002). Whether Singapore will be one of the focal points would very much depend on its ways and means in attracting such huge tourist flows.
64
T.-C. Wong
The rise in global tourism has simultaneously undergone dramatic change and internal restructuring over the last two decades as globalization further intensifies. No longer are middle class travelers satisfied with homogeneous packages, known as mass tourism, which are “perceived to be characterless, unfashionable and low in quality”. Customer expectations for product differentiation and quality have turned to be priorities where money is increasingly spent (Morgan 1998: 317). Morgan (1998) has identified a number of factors that had contributed to the decline of conventional tourism. First, it is the “variety-seeking behaviour” of tourists as consumers. This mindset makes new destination offers more appealing. Second, with the general rise of purchasing power for those who could afford to travel, a new recreational lifestyle offering relaxation, and an opportunity to forget about the competitive routine working life, often an office-bound repetitive working cycle, capture greater interest. New market and new product needs are transforming the tourism landscape.
4.3.2
Local Singapore Tourism
A number of restrictions have limited growth of Singapore’s conventional tourism industry. Weaknesses include the lack of historic sites, lack of richness in features of cultural identity for a city-state emerging from a newly independent status. Though known to some extent as a food paradise, there is limited success given its being an isolated tourism spot in a small island of only 720 square kilometres, separated from neighbouring places for connecting pleasure seekers. Tourism and infrastructural links with Batam, Karimun, Southern Johor are relatively poor. Falling tourist numbers and income over the last decade has spoken for itself. During 1993–2002, tourism in Singapore had lagged behind other sectors in the national economy. Its contribution dropped from 6.1 percent in 1993 to 3 percent in 2002. The slow or rather stagnant growth in numbers of tourists to the city-state has added to the worry of top decision-makers that Singapore, as a young nation, is handicapped by a lack in “spectacular wildlife, historical relics or world heritage sites, [and] seasonal variations” vital in attracting tourists (Lim 2005). As Table 4.1 shows, business and business cum holiday tourists who have a higher spending power have not increased to any significant extent from the mid-1990s. The business cum holiday category has indeed started to decline from then onwards. More importantly, Singapore’s market share in the fast expanding tourism industry in the Asia-Pacific region has declined over the last few years (Department of Statistics 2005). The globalization of capitalism has posed a threat to Singapore’s pursuit of sustained economic growth, and has spread a sense of insecurity. In contemplating remedial measures, an integrated resort was seen as worthy to be integrated in the central area given its high accessibility from the Changi Airport. A new product, for countries where there is none, is the gaming industry. A casino or gaming is a kind of market segmentation that leads to the segregation of users – those who are encouraged to use it and those who are not encouraged or forbidden
2000
TOTAL 7,049.8 7,350.0 6,755.5 6,207.4 5,493.6 6,033.3 6,292.6 Americas 357.0 308.2 344.3 357.7 389.4 355.5 404.1 Asia 5,584.2 5,914.2 5,365.6 4,770.7 3,929.6 4,599.2 4,768.7 Southeast Asia 2,521.3 2,829.2 2,419.3 2,144.7 1,485.0 1,756.4 2,158.4 Europe 714.0 713.3 677.0 693.9 753.7 636.9 698.0 Oceania 293.1 323.8 295.3 323.1 349.1 375.9 357.7 Africa 101.4 90.5 73.2 62.1 71.7 65.8 64.1 Source: (Compiled from Singapore Tourism Board 2006: Total Expenditure of Visitors, Ministry of Trade and stb.com.sg/asp/tou/tou0201.asp, accessed 25 September 2006.)
Table 4.1 Total expenditure of visitors in Singapore by region, 1994–2003 (S$ million) Year 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999
2002
2003
5,699.3 5,425.8 4,315.6 361.4 347.6 256.3 4,103.8 3,905.1 3,161.7 1,980.1 1,854.7 1,671.7 746.5 714.6 571.5 407.6 405.5 286.3 80.1 53.1 39.7 Industry, Singapore. Available at: http://app.
2001
4 Integrated Resort in the Central Business District of Singapore 65
66
T.-C. Wong
to use it. In the Singapore context, there are two layers of segregation. First, the religious taboo of Islam that forbids Muslims to gamble. The second is the need to segregate the local ethnic Chinese who have little fortune to lose in the gambling business; and this restriction is thought to be necessary to mitigate social problems of gambling addiction and potential family conflict. As such, the objective of the marketing orientation is to increase the market publicity to keep up the proportion of overseas tourists in the gaming business. Proliferation of the themed environment and the inclusion of a gaming component in the integrated resort serve therefore the purpose of realization of capital to a greater potential and meeting the goal of production of desire (see Gottdiener 1997; Braun 2005).
4.3.3
Towards Knowledge-Intensive Economy
After four decades of close integration with the OECD developed economies, there are some similarities between Singapore and their development trends. First, there is a contraction of production capacity and workforce in basic industries, those characterized by Fordist mass-production manufacturing. The processes in lowerordered industrial decline have been followed up by more new industries of flexible specialization and technology-intensive in character. For both OECD and Singapore in general, service sector growth has been a key feature of economic restructuring towards a post-Fordist production system and deregulation of financial and other service industries. Like other cities of quite identical ranking in the Asia-Pacific Rim such as Shanghai, Fukuoka, Hong Kong, and Vancouver, Singapore constitutes one of the emerging service poles competing for global service investment, global trade markets and global city networks (see Daniels 1998; Hutton 2003). According to Hutton’s (2003: 30–31) classification and ranking by hierarchy, Singapore, together with Hong Kong, Seoul, Osaka, San Francisco and Sydney are second-order global cities in the Asia-Pacific region. They are ranked after the first-order global cities Tokyo and Los Angeles which are dominant corporate control centres with downtown complexes and headquarters of international banking and finance. More significantly, Tokyo and Los Angeles, on top of being core to major universities of international standing, are also “global centres of cultural production and dissemination, media concentration, and applied design and creative industries”. Despite the identical trend in the search for market orientation and production linkages, urban service centres in the Asia-Pacific and the OECD regions are unlikely to be heading for similar urban morphology, identity or image representative of them. Even the CBD form is likely to show some basic features of functional differentiation, each in response to its own needs, competitive advantages and strengths, or sometimes probably in compliance with the level of political acceptability of certain policy measures. City rank-order has little direct correlation with level of service specialization. Flexibility of core activities in the CBD in assisting
4 Integrated Resort in the Central Business District of Singapore
67
major cities to achieve success in global business competition leads us to examine the latest development in Singapore’s downtown core where integration of different sectors in finance, services, retailing, leisure and entertainment is being used to create a new dynamic CBD. The CBD comprises specialized and high-value financial services which are critical in maintaining Singapore’s international competitiveness. As part of the globally advanced economy, Singapore’s strategy, as highlighted in 2000 by the Singapore Productivity and Standard Board (2000), is to develop itself into: An advanced and globally competitive knowledge economy within the next decade [before 2010]. At the same time, Singapore should strive to become a premier services hub in Asia with a global orientation by growing [its] existing hub services and developing new high growth services.
In 2003, this strategic statement was translated by the Economic Review Committee into a land use planning and design in the city centre area. Bigger pieces of land for integrated phased development, including an integrated Business Financial Centre (BFC), were to be allowed for the first time in Singapore planning history after its independence in 1965. Following this planning intention, the Report of the Economic Review Committee, in an attempt to promote and strengthen Singapore’s position as a financial hub, recommends thus (MTI 2003: 110): A master developer of such a centre should be given the flexibility to plan, design and phase the development of the project to match rapidly changing global needs. In addition, the Government can facilitate the development of the BFC by making the payment scheme as flexible as possible. Commitment from several suitable anchor tenants should also be sought before it is developed.
This preemptive notion set the prerequisite for a merger of financial and leisure services in Singapore’s new CBD.
4.4
Planning of the Integrated Resort at Marina Bay
When Marina South was reclaimed from the sea in the late 1970s, it was aimed at providing additional prime land adjacent to the central business district, with Raffles Square and Shenton Way as its core. The planning intention at that time focused on strengthening Singapore’s international financial position and status, using specialized financial and other services to bolster growth. No notion and norm of sustainable economic development as understood in the present day was ever associated with it, except that for a green and clean garden city. During the revision of the Singapore Concept Plan in the late 1980s, planning options were built fundamentally in pursuit of sustained economic growth, landscaped greenery aesthetics and quality housing. A mix of office and commercial buildings, parks, medium- to highdensity housing and open spaces along the waterfront edges was put into the design. Medium- to high-density housing was incorporated as part of the downtown revitalization and gentrification effort to revive the Central Area (Wong 2006).
68
T.-C. Wong
The Revised Concept Plan was approved by the Singapore Cabinet in 1991, but implementation was slow and response from the private sector in the 1990s was cool, in particular in the wake of the financial crisis in 1997. On 13 March 2004, a state-led initiative changed the prospects for the inactive Marina Bay waterfront when an integrated resort was publicly announced – a S$300 million initial outlay would be spent in key infrastructure and facilities in the Marina Bay to prepare for massive public and private investments (Low 2004). This included building a 3.35 km waterfront promenade around Marina Bay overlooking the Fullerton Hotel across the bay. In December 2004, public bids were invited following a nine-month debate whether Singapore should overturn its long-standing ban on casinos. On 19 April 2005, Minister Mentor Mr Lee Kuan Yew spoke in the Singapore Parliament, urging Singaporeans to rethink in the interest of the nation’s future whether it should reject an integrated resort on the grounds that it would have a casino. Aspiring to reposition Singapore and making it more cosmopolitan on a par with leading global cities such as London, Paris, New York, San Francisco, Sydney, he asserted that Singapore had a special role in the economic renaissance of Asia and as a business centre for leisure and entertainment. He also reassured that Singapore would have the determination and capability to manage social problems which might arise from casino gambling (Lee 2005). In February 2006, amidst unsettled controversies and worries about the adverse consequences of gambling, the Singapore Parliament passed the Casino Control Act to set up a Casino Regulatory Authority to monitor and regulate gaming business. Three months later in May, the successful bidder was announced from out of four world-class entertainment firms or consortiums: Las Vegas Sands, MGM-CapitaLand, Harrah’s Entertainment and Genting International. And the winner went to the US-based Las Vegas Sands.
4.4.1
Planning of Marina Bay’s Integrated Resort: Land Use Plan
4.4.1.1
Characteristics of the Las Vegas Sands Proposal
In response to the ambitions of the Singapore Tourism Board1 (STB), Las Vegas Sands, the world’s largest casino company by market value, has proposed a grand and comprehensive resort plan to meet Singapore’s economic and tourism objectives. The plan has highlighted five elements that pleased the selection panel consisting of five cabinet ministers. These five elements were the MICE (meetings, incentive travel, conventions and exhibitions), entertainment (branded symbol of a global-scale entertainment business with tourist appealing varieties), attractions (financial, professional
1 The Singapore Tourism Board hoped to increase the number of tourists from less than 9 million in 2005 to 17 million by 2015, to generate 100,000 jobs and to triple the tourism revenues to S$30 billion during this period (Straits Times, 27 May 2006: H4).
4 Integrated Resort in the Central Business District of Singapore
69
and specialized services), retail and dining experience (globally appealing shopping offers, floating pavilion restaurants with top chefs), and the gaming business offer (Straits Times 27 May 2006: H4). Accordingly, the panel, which was supported by several design specialists, remarked that the land use design had tied in well as an extended new downtown of the Central Area where 110,000 square-metre convention space was planned. Another decisive factor could be the prominent feature in the design of a one-hectare sky park situated on the top of three 50-storey hotel towers overlooking the waterfront in all directions (see Fig. 4.1). Capturing international attention in the resort industry, the Marina Bay integrated resort, as proposed by Las Vegas Sands, has incorporated key features well described by Goh Kim-Chai (2006: 9), who wrote for URA’s periodical Skyline thus: Sands’ design also responds well to the existing and future developments in Marina Bay and the overall planning intention to create a layered, three-dimensional skyline. Three soaring, 50-storey hotel blocks are located between Bayfront Avenue and Sheares Avenue, with three lower-rise components housing the MICE facilities, casino and theatres fronting the Bay. This makes the development relate well to the waterfront promenade … The facades of the hotel towers facing Garden at Marina South have fully landscaped balconies, extending the greenery vertically up the building and across the roof terraces reinforcing Singapore’s image as ‘City-in-a-Garden’.
On the top of S$1.2 billion of land cost, Las Vegas Sands has a plan to invest S$3.85 billion in the resort, totalling more than S$5 billion. Targeted to be fully completed by 2009, the resort covers 20.6 ha and is offered a lease of 60 years. Paralleling the launch of the integrated resort, STB has also drawn from its S$2 billion development fund to put forward a strategy over the next 5 years to:
Fig. 4.1 Proposed Marina Bay Sands Integrated Resort Source: Urban Redevelopment Authority (2006) Skyline. July-August Issue, p.9
70
T.-C. Wong
(a) Woo international organizations to establish regional offices in Singapore with financial assistance provided by STB; and (b) Assist event organizers including international firms with no local registered office to draw in mega-events. Apart from STB, other government agencies and the private sector would also have incentives to promote Singapore as a global business hub (Straits Times 4 August 2006: 1).
4.4.2
Planning Singapore’s Aspirations for Ascent Towards a Global City?
The Marina Bay integrated resort is integral of Singapore’s aspirations to build itself into a tourism and financial services hub in Asia as its economy moves in a knowledge-intensive globalization era. From introduction of the garden city concept as the fundamental land use logic in the 1960s, planning in Singapore has since evolved slowly but steadily along its economic-biased development path and space management processes. Adopting a pragmatic and forward looking approach, the city centre went through an effective urban renewal and slum clearance, at the end of which a modern central business district came into being in the late 1970s. This modernist procedure set the footing for an economic premise of sustained growth. With the “garden city” concept initiated earlier, land use planning set a bipolar ruling of sustainable economic cum environmental development, giving relatively little attention to the social equity issue. Key actors in Singapore’s land use planning process have been: (a) the state, through its planning agencies such as the Urban Redevelopment authority, the Housing and Development Board, the Jurong Town Corporation, the Land Transport Authority, the Singapore Land Authority; (b) the professionals in both public and private sectors (planners, architects and developers/contractors); (c) the interest groups (private land owners, to an extent environmentalists, clan association/community representatives; and (d) general stakeholders (the business groups and citizenry). The overwhelming dominance of the state manifests itself on behalf of public interest, towards which professional planners also have a committed role. On behalf of the government, planners regulate land use allocations, sales of public land for property development, and are responsible for protecting the environment Determination to make the integrated resort a success has been alimented with water sports. Situated between the designated integrated resort and the existing CBD is Marina Bay (Fig. 4.2). In supplementing the new development of the CBD at the Marina area, the Bay has been planned for a motorized and non-motorized water sports zone. Here, water sports such as canoeing, dragon boating and kayaking will be set in motion, with water taxis cruising around the bay area. Merging with the waters of the Marina Channel, the Singapore River and Kallang Basin, Marina Bay is scheduled to become a Greater Marina Bay to “provide an enlarged stage for activities and events …[including] international events” to highlight Singapore’s downtown skyline (URA 2006: 12–13). Also, the area around the Marina Bay between Collyer Quay and the integrated resort will
Fig. 4.2 The Existing Central Business District Source: URA (1995) Downtown core (part) planning area. Planning report. Singapore
Fig. 4.3 Proposed Marina Bay Financial Centre Source: URA (2007) Skyline Jan/Feb 2007 issue, Singapore
72
T.-C. Wong
be designated a Marina Bay Financial Centre (MBFC) (see Fig. 4.3). By 2010, this centre is expected to provide 244,000 square metres of gross floor area (61 percent office space and 39 percent of luxurious apartments), doubling consequently the existing office space of Singapore. Recovery of the property market and national economy in 2006 has furnished positive signals in head-starting the launch towards the end of the year2 (Straits Times 06 Oct 2006: 1).
4.5
Sustainable Economic Development versus Sustainable Social Development
To most people, sustainable economic development carries a much pragmatic meaning of continued business success or, at the national or local government level, a sustained achievement of high economic growth rates. At a more in-depth level, nevertheless, economic development will not be sustainable if its operations are not executed on par with sustainable social and ecological development pursuits (Macnaghten and Pinfield 1999). Broadly speaking, an economic system, whatever its scale, cannot be claimed to be sustainable without effective linkage to the triangular relationship of economic with social/cultural and ecological/environmental requirements. For instance, economic growth jacked up by tourism pays the price of high consumption of fossil fuel which is ecologically unsustainable. Furthermore, where economic growth thus produced could lead to polarizing incomes, such an outcome is socially unsustainable. Consequently, “free trade” if conducted at the expense of and unmatched by social and ecological goals, has a tendency to support corporate dominance and competition, and cannot be perceived a fair “free trade”. Economic outcome cannot be an end in itself but should be employed as a means to serve social interests and communal harmony. Ideally, corporate interests should share their social and ecological responsibility with non-profit organizations dedicated to a common sustainable future of the community. It is therefore the concept termed as “humanizing economic relations” that is of utmost importance when businesses, public or private, should be held accountable in their own way for social and ecological responsibility (see Green Party 2004). Many neo-classical and Keynesian economists have difficulty in recognizing sustainability associated with ecology and social equity as a professional issue because this concept is incompatible with conventional theory of economics. More often than not, such an extra-economic association beyond conventional economic logic could be cited as a source of “market failures” (Ikerd 1997). This is argued on
2
A first phase launch of luxurious apartments at the Marina Bay Financial Centre in early December 2006 witnessed a success, recording a high-price of S$2,700 per square foot. All 422 units of the 99-year lease property were booked soon after launch (Straits Times 14 December 2006:H26). Among the buyers, 40 percent were estimated to be from, inter-alia, Indonesia, Hong Kong, India, the Middle-East and China.
4 Integrated Resort in the Central Business District of Singapore
73
the basis that short-term maximization of profits and satisfaction of consumption desire will eventually deplete natural and social resources on which the survival of the human species relies. Accordingly, some principles should be used to guide economists towards a sufficiently broad sustainable economic development that could build up a basis for long-run human progress. The conventional economic approach, which has a rooted belief in profit maximization and that growth has no limits, is in no position to lead us towards sustaining long-run human progress.
4.5.1
Tourism and Sustainable Development
In his speech at Parliament House on 18 April 2005, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong admitted that the primary aim of the integrated resorts proposal was to boost the tourism industry. The casino component of the integrated resorts was debated for a while in 2004 in the local Singapore media and Parliament before it was adopted. Adoption was made on the basis that the casino would attract large crowds from neighbouring countries, and is a positive factor for competition (see Lee 2005). The basis of the argument is linked with the assumption that social or environmental problems could be managed without objecting to the current broad advanced capitalist system that has guided global development of high-value production systems. The argument rests on the belief that sustained economic growth should be driven by market forces which could be the key towards improving welfare for the citizens in the long-term (see Knox and Pinch 2000). In an attempt to diversify its service-based economy which is also fast expanding, an integrated resort in the CBD is interpreted as a newly reinvented development scheme that global cities such as New York, London and Paris are currently doing. For the Singapore government, the challenge is to have the city-state catch up with world leading cities and not to let it fall into the backwater of global city competition. After all, as was explained by Premier Lee in Parliament, the casino is only a small component (3–5 percent of total allowable floor area) of the whole integrated resort programme which would include development of grand hotels, shopping malls, convention and exhibition buildings, museums and theatres. In a broader context, the integrated resort is to complement other major projects that aim to breathe new air into the new downtown area: the Esplanade, the new Sports Hub in Kallang and the Marina Barrage. Besides the 35,000 jobs that the two IRs (Marina Bayfront and Sentosa Island) would generate, the whole multiplier effect was estimated to be substantial. After portraying the adverse effects of the gambling element, the Prime Minister’s decision was to proceed with the IRs on the basis of Singapore’s long term national interest and its vision to be a “vibrant and dynamic city in Asia” (see Lee 2005). As the aim of the integrated resort is to attract large numbers of international tourists, the problem therefore is how to minimize adverse impacts on the quality of the air, water and other natural elements in order to sustain the ecosystem’s overall integrity. Environmental management is a means through which sustainable
74
T.-C. Wong
economic development and environmental protection must be made mutually supporting and not mutually exclusive (see Murphy 1998: 176; Wong 2006). Given that economic resources or financial revenues are crucial for protecting and preserving the physical environment, business objectives can be made compatible with inducements to the tourism industry. The issue, however, is the carrying capacity. What is the upper limit of tourist volume that is acceptable to justify for a sustainable tourism development? It is an issue that is obviously difficult to define and even more difficult to measure in terms of the extent of environmental or social stress. Furthermore, this notion presets an “existence of fixed and determinable limits to development” or “limits to acceptable change” which, by right, is a dilemma per se. More specifically, the business concern is normally based more on the conditions that the selected area could generate revenues rather than on the level of tolerance an area can bear (Murphy 1998: 180–181). As raised in the early part of this study, the integrated resort has been deployed to help sustain economic growth in Singapore, as a result of falling incomes from tourism, and by creating new “knowledge-intensive” spaces in the extended CBD – the Marina Bay. The environmental impact of the integrated resort is mirrored in land use intensification, and the making of a world-class site for entertainment, finance and other high-end services. A greater intensification implies higher consumption of fuel and use of water resources. Both fuel and water are imported commodities that require revenues generated from the integrated resort to acquire them. Nevertheless, the environmental impact is expected to be manageable and is unlikely to be noticeable to the surrounding environment. Within the notion of economic sustainability, whilst the environmental impact is seen as manageable and the cultural impact is speculative at this stage, the social effect is perceived to be at the highest stake of the IR.
4.5.2
Social Impact: Casino as a Planned Entertainment Machine
Before examining the social impact, it is useful to look briefly at the current development in Singapore – the widening gap between its social strata. While its minimal welfare oriented policy has been ideologically supported by neo-liberalism that has swept through heavy-burdened welfare-states in Europe since the 1980s, Singapore’s push for a sustained growth in the globalization era is believed to have had polarization effects with low-income earners as losers. A new “dual economy” has become more noticeable (see Tay 2007). Questions have arisen as to the validity of Singapore’s responsiveness to the market-driven entertainment business as a source of sustaining economic growth. In response to the divergent income patterns, public measures such as increasing goods and services taxes to seven percent to generate more revenues for lower income groups, provision of workfare bonuses and skills retraining are being undertaken. Gambling has historically been perceived by the ethnic Chinese community as a cultural tradition in Singapore. It is generally seen as something amoral but tolerated
4 Integrated Resort in the Central Business District of Singapore
75
if it is not excessive such that it results in family problems and financial ruin. More often than not, gambling is operated “underground” or disguised in different forms. Having inherited the British colonial policy, the Singapore government has laid down regulations to tax gambling such as horse racing, “Toto” and the four-digit draws. All other unregistered gaming exercises are deemed illegal. Besides taxation that generates state revenues, legitimization of casino in Singapore may be argued for on the basis that “underground” and disguised gambling practices could be mitigated, regulated and managed in a more secured manner. Gambling taxation, derived presumably from voluntary participants, may be used or redirected for other social, educational and welfare needs, as is the case of a casino set up in an Indian community reserve in Canada. However, though casino gambling could serve as a means of state accumulation, the potential costs that were observed in the Indian reserve such as gambling addiction, alcoholism and rising domestic violence were a trade-off that could not be overlooked (see Skea 1997). In the United States and Australia, adverse effects cited include the rise in pathological gamblers and social problems in the proximity of casinos (see Low 2005), which is seen as a countering factor to social sustainability. What then is social sustainability in an urban context? Yiftachel and Hedgcock (1993: 140) define urban social sustainability as having: the continuing ability of a city to function as a long-term viable setting for human interaction, communication and cultural development. It is not necessarily related to the environmental and economic sustainability of a city, although the links often exist between the three areas … Such a city is characterized by a lack of overt or violent intergroup conflict, conspicuous spatial segregation, or chronic political instability. In short, urban social sustainability is about the long term survival of a viable urban social unit.
Many researchers have furnished evidence that gaming affects productivity, and that gaming is seen as a second-class leisure activity linked to irrational motivation, but casino gaming is doubtlessly a good source of public revenues (Smeral 1998; Choi 1997). Smeral’s study of Austria shows that casinos are a major recreational attraction for local and regional tourists; and their services are an important component of the regions’ qualitative competitiveness. It is hard to imagine that the casino in Singapore could lead in future to urban violence or political instability, other than the “moral degeneracy” debate in 2004. No public infringements in Macau, except perhaps money laundering, could be hitherto effectively associated with its many casinos. As to the maintenance of crime control and law enforcement, in the study on the impact of casino gambling to the local Canadian community, in Windsor, Ontario, Albanese (1997) used a prediction model to address three crime-related concerns. These concerns were: a) the integrity of the games themselves; b) organized crime infiltration; and c) the impact on street crime in and around the casino. Control of the gaming integrity of the casino governance rests with the police. In the case of Singapore, responsibility is likely that of the Commercial Crime Department which will have to ensure fair play and honesty in the games. Casinos, at least in theory, are a potential hotbed of organized crime because of huge cash turnovers of winners and losers. Consequently, street-level crimes are likely to rise, putting increased pressure on police resources.
76
4.6
T.-C. Wong
Conclusions
For a small island-state which has transformed itself from a largely rural area to a highly urbanized city-state over a span of 40 years, Singapore’s CBD was created out of a dualistic town centre of the early 1960s to that of a western-modeled financial district in the 1990s. Faced with new challenges in the global city competition, the modernist CBD moves a step further towards a post-modern dimension, diversifying and broadening its functions to include, among others, entertainment culture as one of the core elements of high-value service activities. Economic priority considerations have been the determining factor in adopting an integrated resort or tourism business district including a casino in the Marina Bay, the extended zone of the current CBD. The casino will be subject to rules and regulations as to who would use it and who could afford it. Global cities operate as a producer and as a consumer; both factors contribute towards the gross domestic product (Glaeser et al 2004). In cities acting as gateways for international business travellers, the leisure industry, if successful, can be made into a growth machine given their higher-value activities and multiplier effects. This industry in the post-modern Singapore has become a core national planning project in search of sustained economic growth. In land use planning terms, the integrated resort has turned itself into part of the commodified and contested space in the midst of globally competitive businesses in which Singapore has opted to be an active player. The IR industry is creating a new Singapore identity in a venue of strategic importance designated for a deepened and new accumulation of wealth of in particular international origin. This new place identity supported by leisure and recreational services, beaches, waterbodies, greenery is in the making and is targeted to be a centre of globalised high-end consumerism. The resort is also a symbolically new organization of urban space and imaging on the waterfront. The conventional paradigm that profits and growth are conditions of victory and success in the game of global city competition has borne evidence of an endangered future if we believe a sustainable urban development is our future. The sustainability paradigm, albeit vague hitherto, needs to be established and consolidated on the basis of a “dynamic balance among inseparable ecological, social and economics dimensions of quality of life” (see Ikerd 1997). If the decision-making process of the integrated resort is purely economical, a reflection worthy of further contemplation in planning is that economic outcome cannot be an end in itself but should be employed as a means to serve social interests and communal harmony. Ideally, corporate interests should share their social and ecological responsibility with non-profit organizations that are dedicated to the common sustainable future of their communities. The concept termed as “humanizing economic relations” is of utmost importance and businesses, public or private, should be accountable for the way they meet their social and ecological responsibilities.
4 Integrated Resort in the Central Business District of Singapore
77
References Albanese JS (1997) Predicting the impact of casino gambling on crime and law enforcement in Windsor, Ontario. In: Eadington WR, Cornelius JA (eds) Public policies and the social sciences. Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gaming, University of Nevada, Reno, USA, pp 351–366 Braun B (2005) Environmental issues: writing a more-than-human urban geography. Progress in Human Geography 29(5):635–650 Choi Hak (1997) Gambling in Hong Kong. Journal of Travel Research Fall issue: 23–28 Clark TN (2004) Introduction: Taking entertainment seriously. In Clark T. Nichols (ed). The city as an entertainment machine. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 1–18 Dale JD (1999) Urban planning in Singapore: the transformation of a city. Oxford University Press, Shah Alam (Malaysia) Daniels PW (1998) Economic development and producer services growth: the APEC experience. Asia Pacific Viewpoint 39(2):145–160 Ergazakis K, Metaxiotis K, Psarras J (2006) An emerging pattern of successful knowledge cities’ main features. In: Carrillo FJ (ed) Knowledge cities: approaches, experiences, and perspectives. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 3–15 Fagence M (1995) City waterfront redevelopment for leisure, recreation, and tourism: some common themes. In: Craig-Smith SJ, Fagence M (eds) Recreation and tourism as a catalyst for urban waterfront redevelopment: an international survey. Praeger, Westport (USA), pp 135–156 Getz D (1993) Planning for tourism business districts. Annals of Tourism Research 20: 583–600 Glaeser EL, Kolka J, Saiz A (2004) Consumers and cities. In Clark T. Nichols (ed). The city as an entertainment machine. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 177–183 Goh Kim-Chai (2006) Sand fits the bay. Skyline July/August issue, 8–9 Gottdiener M (1997) The theming of America: dreams, visions and commercial spaces. Westview Press, Boulder, CO Gottmann IJ (1961) Megalopolis: the urbanized Northeastern Seaboard of the United States. Twentieth Century, New York Green Party (2004) Economic sustainability. Http://www.gp.org/platform/2004/economics.html, accessed 21 September 2006 Huang S, Chang TC (2003) Selective disclosure: romanicing the Singapore River. In: Goh RBH, Yeoh BSA (eds) Theorizing the Southeast Asian city as text. World Scientific, Hackensack, New Jersey, pp 77–108 Hutton AH (2003) Service industries, globalization, and urban restructuring within the AsiaPacific: new development trajectories and planning responses. Progress in Planning 61(1):1–74 Ikerd J (1997) Toward an economics of sustainability. http://www.ssu.missouri.edu/faculty/jikert/ papers/econ-sus.htm retrieved on 21 September 2006 Kaplan DH, Wheeler JO, Holloway SR (2004) Urban geography. Hoboken (NJ) Knox P, Pinch S (2000) 4th ed. Urban social geography: an introduction. Pearson Education, Harlow, UK Koh Gee Kum, Tan Tsu Huang (1976) Planning and recreation – the Singapore context. Singapore Institute of Planners Journal 5(1):11–20 Lee Hsien Loong (2005) Proposal to develop integrated resorts. Singapore Government Press Release, http://app.sprinter.gov.sg/data/pr/2005041803.htm, retrieved on 27 September 2006 Lim Hng Kiang (2005) Casino decision. Statement by Minister for Trade and Industry on Integrated Resort. http://www.channelnewsasia.com/casino/text_limhk.htm, accessed 06 Nov 2006 Low Bernadette (2004) $300 million to kick off downtown at Marina Bay. Skyline Mar/Apr issue Low Thia Khiang (2005) Casinos in integrated resorts. The Workers’ Party of Singapore website, retrieved on 19 August 2005
78
T.-C. Wong
Macnaghten P, Pinfield G (1999) Planning and sustainable development: prospects for social change. In: Allmendinger P, Chapman M (eds) Planning beyond 2000. John Wiley, Chichester, UK, pp 17–32 Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI) (2003) New challenges, fresh goals – towards a dynamic global city. Report of the Economic Review Committee, Singapore Mistilis N, Dwyer l (1999) Tourism gateways and regional economies: the distributional impacts of MICE. International Journal of Tourism Research 1:441–457 Morgan M (1998) Homogenous products: the future of established resorts. In Theobald William F. (ed) 2nd ed. Global Tourism. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, pp 317–336 Murphy PE (1998) Tourism and sustainable development. In: Theobald William F. (ed) 2nd ed. Global Tourism. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, pp 173–190 Murphy RE, Vance JE, Epstein BJ (1955) Internal structure of the CBD. Economic Geography 31:21–46 Newling BE (1969) The spatial variation of urban population densities. Geographical Review 59:242–252 Scargill DI (1979) The form of cities. Bell & Hyman, London Singapore Productivity and Standard Board (2000) Competitiveness of the economy. Http://203.116.36.232/statistics_faq/statistics/competitiveness.html, accessed 17 January 2000 Singapore Tourism Board (2002) Travel & tourism’s economic impact. Http://www.stb.com.sg/ t21, accessed 04 October 2002 Skea WH (1997) The rationale of state gambling policy: the case of on-reserve casinos in Canada. In: Eadington WR, Cornelius JA (eds) Public policies and the social sciences. Institute for the Study of Gambling and Commercial Gaming, University of Nevada, Reno, USA, pp 255–265 Smeral E (1998) Economic aspects of casino gaming in Austria. Journal of Travel Research 36 Spring:33–39 Straits Times (The) Singapore local newspaper, various issues Tay Erica (2007) Economists discuss downside of fast growth. The Straits Times, 12 January 2007:4 Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) (2006) Skyline July/August issue. Singapore Weiskopf DC (1982 2nd Ed) Recreation and leisure: improving the quality of life. Allyn and Bacon, Boston Wheeler SM (2004) Planning for sustainability: creating livable, equitable and ecological communities. Routledge, London Wong CYL, Choi Chong-Ju, Millar CCJM. (2006) The case of Singapore as a knowledge-based city. In: Carrillo FJ (ed) Knowledge cities: approaches, experiences, and perspectives. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 87–96 Wong Tai-Chee, Yap ALH (2004) Four decades of transformation: land use in Singapore 1960– 2000. Eastern University Press, Singapore Wong Tai-Chee (2006) Revitalising Singapore’s central city through gentrification: the role of waterfront housing. Urban Policy and Research 24(2):181–199 Yiftachel O, Hedgcock D (1993) Urban social sustainability: the planning of an Australian city. Cities, 10(2):139–157 Zhang Juan, Shang Zhu-nan (2006) The distinction between CBD and RBD and the expansion of their functions. Tourism Tribune 21(12): 77–80 (in Chinese)
Chapter 5
Singapore River: Six Strategies for Sustainability Chwee Lye Low
5.1 5.1.1
Introduction The Water Margin
The water’s edge has always exerted a pull for mankind to sink roots there (Hoyle and Pinder 1992; Breen and Rigby 1994). Countless villages, towns and cities have arisen from such places of elemental intersection – be they on sea coasts, river confluences or around oases, where the easy availability of life-giving water was a prime consideration for setting up home. Soon, these settlements became focal points of not just the trade in goods and services, but also of ideas and information. Waterfront settlements have thus evolved to become the centres of social and intellectual life in their respective countries and cultures. But these nurturing factors that help create such waterfront settlements are no guarantee for urban immortality, as is exemplified by numerous waterfront districts that have seen better days (Hoyle et al. 1988; Dovey 2005). Still, as has happened in waterfront cities such as Boston, Seattle and San Francisco in the United States 40 years ago, waves of renewal are possible, sparking intense redevelopment of run-down areas near the water margin. As a result, derelict waterfront areas have been transformed into vibrant commercial and recreational areas. Likewise, English and European cities have also witnessed similar revitalisation of their waterfront areas (Malone 1996; Marshall 2001). The British examples would include London’s South Bank and Bristol’s Harbourside. With its seaport history, the fortunes of Singapore’s waterfront areas have mirrored this global trend. Tanjong Rhu, for instance, once a shipyard and graveyard of derelict schooners and junks, has been spruced up and redeveloped into a prime housing and recreation enclave smack between the city centre and the future Sports Hub, and with the entire East Coast Park as its recreational “hinterland”. In examining the topic of sustainable urban waterfront development, this chapter will focus, however, on the revitalisation of the Singapore River. Former Head, Urban Studies Unit, Urban Redevelopment Authority, Singapore, e-mail:
[email protected] T.-C. Wong et al. (eds.), Spatial Planning for a Sustainable Singapore, 79–92 © All Rights Reserved
80
5.1.2
C.L. Low
River Reborn
River estuaries, in particular, have always been attractive as places for human habitation. They afford not just geographical fixity in a pre-Global Positioning Systems era, but also shelter from the open ocean and ease of access to the unseen ports of opportunity beyond the horizon. At the same time, the rivers are a lifeline to the hinterland, whose condition often has an inverse relationship with its success as a lifeline. The more development its banks enjoy, the worse the rivers’ environmental status, degenerating into mere conduits of congested riverine traffic with all the life choked out of it due to man’s polluting ways. This history of pollution and ecological destruction of rivers that serve conurbations is by no means a preserve of the great rivers or megacities of the world. Singapore is a prime example of how even a tiny island city-state, founded on the banks of a river running a mere 3 km, is not immune to this inverse relationship between urban development and deteriorating river environs. In the following sections we will examine how the Singapore River fell into a sorry state, how it was revived after a 10-year clean-up process, and the sustainable strategies that were employed to ensure that the River remains an urban asset and not a liability.
5.2
A Victim of Her Own Success
Even before Sir Thomas Stamford Raffles landed on the banks of the Singapore River in 1819, there was reportedly, already an Orang Laut (sea people) settlement at the mouth of the river. The economic mainstay of the day included unsavoury activities such as piracy; and accounts describe the scene at the mouth of the Singapore River around the time about the occasional skull sightings at low tide. But Raffles’ brilliant vision in banking on Singapore as a strategic trading post sitting astride the shipping threshold between east and west was to forcibly change this unsavoury occupation for another – trade. Singapore’s meteoric success on the back of free trade, however, brought its own unsavoury results, no thanks to the unchecked and unsustainable predatory practices of trade and business. As a measure of its success, by the 1870s, three quarters of the shipping business was done at the Boat Quay at the river mouth. Thus, within the span of a century, the Singapore River was transformed from a pirate’s lair to a seaport of repute and a natural magnet for human habitation. After all, the opening of the Suez Canal in 1869 had already helped to strengthen Singapore’s claim to be one of the world’s great ports. However, the rapid influx of people to this emerging regional port powerhouse was too much for the rudimentary waste disposal system and the Singapore River was turned into a veritable cesspool for the exponentially-expanding urban population.
5 Singapore River: Six Strategies for Sustainability
81
By the 1970s, the Singapore River had become a manifestly unsightly and smelly urban problem. While the Singapore River supported vessels bearing the very fibre of Singapore’s economic muscle, the water itself was completely bereft of all life. On 27 February 1977, Mr Lee Kuan Yew, then Singapore’s Prime Minister, recognising the central place that the Singapore River occupied, not only in Singapore’s history, but also its physical setting, challenged the nation to transform it from the liability it had become, to an asset, within 10 years (Sunday Times 1977). Singaporeans rose to the challenge and by September 1987, the Singapore River was once again flowing clean and clear of debris and flotsam. A million fishes – sea bass and red tilapia – and prawns were released in the River. Ten years on, the river was indeed, unrecognisable from the urban cesspool that it had been. Its rebirth has become an enduring legacy of the collaborative effort of numerous private, public and people sector stakeholders, working together to realise the central vision that Singapore’s first Prime Minister had painted. Singapore had learned, the hard way, that sustainable development was the way to ensure that this key and central piece of real estate in the city will be an urban asset that would help propel it to the league of the world’s great cities. The following sections detail the various aspects of sustainability that contributed to this urban waterfront’s success story.
5.3
Six Pistons
The lessons on sustainable development with regard to the Singapore River can be summarised as six “pistons”, working in tandem to produce the desired end-result. These six pistons are: a b c d e f
Visionary leadership and far-sighted planning Leveraging on the private–public–people sector synergies Restoring and maintaining water quality Restoration of the historic fabric as a character-giving asset Encouraging mixed use Providing for easy public access
5.3.1
Visionary Leadership and Far-Sighted Planning
Vision and opportunity make for an incendiary mix. However, visionary ideas may be no more real than a mirage without the necessary confluence of circumstances to make its conception a reality. One such historic moment of the confluence of vision and opportunity took place in 1977 when, the then-Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew threw the gauntlet to his compatriots to transform the Singapore River from the gutter that it was then to the crown jewel of its historic civic and business district.
82
C.L. Low
The vision was crystal clear. And this went a long way in aligning and galvanizing the efforts of the multitude of stakeholder agencies from both the private and public sectors involved in this mammoth and complicated 10-year undertaking to achieve its desired goal of a clean and thriving Singapore River. Nevertheless, no matter how visionary, a goal cannot achieve manifest reality if not for the supporting circumstances to nurture its conception. In the Singapore River’s case, a key favourable circumstance was the contemporaneous advent of container shipping. This development eventually led to the relocation of Singapore’s sea trading activities from the Singapore River to Keppel Harbour on Singapore’s southern coastline and provided the opportunity to redevelop the river. This paved the way for the redevelopment of the Singapore River itself and the opening of a new chapter of its long association as the nexus of development of Singapore, from a 19th century trading outpost to an international port of call. Thus, Mr Lee’s clarion call to clean up the Singapore River in 1977 could not have come at a more opportune moment. The call had made it patently clear to these stakeholders that, no matter the hardships of physical displacement of the riverrelated trades in shipping, warehousing and ancillary livelihoods, the clock was ticking towards the time when the River would turn from an urban liability into Singapore’s peerless, signature asset for the greater, long term good of the country. Having painted the vision for the Singapore River, it was then up to the government agencies to hatch far-sighted planning to realize the vision in collaboration with the private sector stakeholders. The planning and development machinery was thus kick started, beginning with a government taskforce spearheaded by the Ministry of the Environment which was in charge of the mammoth “Great river clean-up”. Planning for the sustainable development of the Singapore River’s environs began in tandem. Two years before the clean-up was completed, the Urban Redevelopment Authority published its vision for the Singapore River in its Singapore River Concept Plan of May 1985 (URA 1985). This Singapore River Concept Plan benefited from the lessons of successful river revitalization studies that URA had conducted – on the Seine in Paris and Paseo del Rio in San Antonio, Texas. Even as the river clean-up was being completed, URA undertook the comprehensive improvement work on the derelict infrastructure along the River’s banks. These included a new river wall and a 6 km long promenade that line both banks of the Singapore River. In URA’s plan, three development zones were identified for the Singapore River – Boat Quay, Clarke Quay and Robertson Quay. These zones, straddling both banks of the River, were to be linked continuously by an up to 15 m-wide promenade along the riverbanks. The tripartite division of the Singapore River offered different focal themes for the development of these zones as distinct areas for living, working and playing, using as a lever the selective conservation of historic fabric found in each of the zones. Appropriate urban design guidelines were laid down to further enhance these attributes while guidelines aimed at achieving land use optimization and establishment of appropriate riverine activities were put in place.
5 Singapore River: Six Strategies for Sustainability
83
The URA’s 1991 Concept Plan for Singapore as a whole also recognized the importance of the Singapore River as a commercial corridor that is linked to the established Orchard Road corridor. This intent influenced the development guidelines for Clarke Quay and Robertson Quay, where local commercial use was planned complete with a local residential population that would offer the base support. These macro plans were further complemented by a detailed Development Guide Plan (DGP), published in 1994 (URA 1994), that provided for integrated conservation and adaptive reuse of historic fabric to contemporary uses like retail, entertainment, and food and beverage provisions. In these ways, the distinct architectural and urban design attributes of each zone was capitalized upon to guide the development of the distinctive waterfront precincts. These coordinated efforts, orchestrated by the initial vision of a clean Singapore River coursing through the downtown of a great tropical metropolis, was deemed worthy of a place among the top-100 of the UN-Habitat’s Dubai International Awards for Best Practices in Improving the Living Environment in 2000. But this vision is not cast in concrete. Nor is it the end of the sustainable planning story of the Singapore River. In the next stage of its transformation, the Singapore River will be turned into a freshwater reservoir.
5.3.2
Leveraging on Private–Public–People Sector Synergies
A key principle of sustainable development is to leverage on the respective strengths of the private, public and people sectors in achieving its desired aims. The government agencies’ role is to ensure that a high standard of design and supply infrastructure is implemented through transparent public policies, strategies and development mechanisms. Private sector stakeholders are involved early on in this process so as to ensure active interest and successful collaboration in speedily realizing the development aims for the area. Through mechanisms such as upfront exhibitions and forums, public consultation can also be effected in the interest of the proposed development. In these ways, the public, private and people sectors can all partake in the process of implementing sustainable developments. These strategies are relevant not just at the onset of the development, but throughout its entire lifespan, as cyclical and constant renewal and place-making figure as a standard practice of sustainable development in order to ensure the development’s long-term economic and social success. One of the things that constantly amaze planners who visit Singapore is how plans that are made are actually implemented on the ground. This is unusual because in many countries what is actually implemented may vary tremendously from the original planning intent, if they are implemented at all. Singapore’s miniscule size, compared to most countries, certainly helps to make this a fact rather than fantasy. Public consultation has some history in Singapore’s planning history. In August 1992, a public exhibition was held at the Raffles City atrium where the government’s
84
C.L. Low
plans for three development precincts in the Central Area – the new Downtown Core, Portview and the Singapore River – were featured. Public feedback was canvassed on the preliminary ideas that were put forth in the exhibition that attracted some 60,000 people. A follow-up public dialogue was later organized to involve the public and professional sectors to expand and further develop some of the ideas and feedback received at the exhibition. The Development Guide Plans for these areas that were eventually published in 1994 were, thus, the fruit of the public engagement exercise conducted two years before. Such public consultation continues throughout the life of the districts – thus helping to ensure that the government’s development proposals remain in tune with the needs of the times. In the Singapore River precinct, such consultation has, for instance, resulted in the extension of al fresco dining areas along Circular Road, taking over the space formerly occupied by surface parking lots (URA 1998). The project cost S$500,000 and managed to extend 300 m of sidewalk al fresco areas along Circular Road to complement similar and highly popular outdoor dining areas along Boat Quay. With the loss of surface car park lots along Circular Road, drivers now park their cars at the new and larger surface carparks in Carpenter Street, or those at UOB Plaza and One, George Street. This initiative was welcomed by the local shopowners and their customers alike, with more than 30 pubs and restaurants extending their business outdoors, thus lending a bustling atmosphere along what was a quiet street before. A key planning mechanism that allowed the structural redevelopment of inner city precincts and unlocked the development potential of the prime real estate it represented, is the Government Land Sales programme (URA 1995). The year 1993 saw the first Government Land Sale (GLS) of a site in the Singapore River area. This was quickly followed by the redevelopment of both private and public sector-owned sites in the area over the next seven years. In such ways, entire precincts in places along the Singapore River such as in Clarke Quay and Robertson Quay experienced either conservation of historic fabric, redevelopment, or a combination of the two. Aside from playing the role of the government’s agent for the administration of the GLS, the URA also guided and facilitated the public–private partnership in the implementation of river infrastructural and enhancement works. This role entailed detailed coordination with numerous public and private sector stakeholders and covered the entire spectrum of development – from the macro to the micromanagement of details, such as deciding what kind and number of trees to plant on the promenade. Working with National Parks Board, URA guides developers to ensure the harmonious planting of trees on both banks. Such guidelines for tree-planting to developers include the type and spacing of trees to be planted along the water edge, as well as on the landward edge of the promenade. Likewise, URA collaborates with the Singapore Tourism Board (STB) to coordinate the provision of night lighting along the Singapore River’s banks. These guidelines help enhance the overall harmony of the lighting schemes for the
5 Singapore River: Six Strategies for Sustainability
85
promenades and bridges of the Singapore River by indicating the lamp post designs, colour and brightness of the lamp lights. Another collaboration with STB and the National Heritage Board was to encourage the installation of art in outdoor public areas. Such public-access sculptures continue to delight pedestrians using the Singapore River’s 6 km continuous river promenade and lend a sense of identity to different nodes there. Over the years, such popular sculpture installations as those of the kucinta cats and the boys jumping into the river never fail to evoke a smile on the faces of passers-by. Thus, through such involvements with the private and people sectors, the public sector can effectively lead in creating vibrant precincts in the city – as exemplified today by the Singapore River – that are sustainable from the economic, as well as the social and even ecological fronts.
5.3.3
Restoring and Maintaining Water Quality
Waterfront developments that are designed to capitalize on their sitting next to a body of water can really be very special places. But no masterpiece of urban and architectural design would stand a chance of realizing its full potential, or even its most perfunctory purposes, if it were sited on the bank of a fetid, open sewer. A fundamental prerequisite of successful and sustainable waterfront developments is a good quality of water. Multiply this lost potential to the scale of an entire river and immediately, the need to improve and maintain water quality becomes abundantly clear – be it on China’s longest river, the Yangtze, which runs through 186 cities including Shanghai on its way to the sea, or the 3 km long Singapore River, running past Singapore’s CBD. Around the world, the task of implementing sustainable programmes of water quality management has become or will soon become staple preoccupations for municipal authorities. The example of one of the world’s greatest river systems – that of the Yangtze – is instructional for its water quality problems (Reuters 2006). The city of Shanghai, China’s largest city and one of the world’s most flamboyant metropolises of our time, is literally choking on its water – for which it relies on the great Yangtze to supply. On May 30, 2006, China’s official Xinhua News Agency reported an expert from East China Normal University, Lu Jianjian, as saying: “As the river is the only source of drinking water in Shanghai, it has been a great challenge for Shanghai to get clean water.” “(Yet) [m]any officials think the pollution is nothing for the Yangtze. The pollution is actually very serious,” a professor from the China University of Geosciences Yuan Aiguo was quoted as saying. The same is true for the other cities lying on the banks of the world’s third longest river after the N