In This Issue
November 2005 In This Issue Click article title to open Reviews
People
Ableton Live 5
Leader: Happy 20th Birthday SOS!
Loop-based Sequencer [Windows/Mac OS X]
Paul White As SOS starts its 21st year, Editor In Chief Paul White casts an eye back over the past 20 years and chats about this month's SOS DVD002.
Ableton Live is one of the software success stories of the last few years, with devoted users in fields as diverse as DJing, remixing, theatre sound and music production. Version 5 addresses requests from all these areas, whilst retaining the program's renowned ease of use.
Apple Soundtrack Pro Audio Sequencer & Editor [Mac OS X] Apple's loop-sequencing application has grown up, with the addition of sophisticated recording, editing and mixing facilities, a powerful waveform editor, and many of Logic's most sought-after effects.
Cakewalk Sonar Home Studio MIDI + Audio Sequencer [Windows] With Sonar Home Studio, Cakewalk have made the core features of their flagship sequencing application available at a bargain price.
Manu Katché Session Drumming & Music Technology He is one of the most famous drummers in the world, having played on more than 200 records. His CV reads like a Who's Who of English, American and French popular music, and even if he prefers not to lose himself in computers, he always takes a PowerBook with him, to write songs, at home or on tour. Meet Manu Katché, drummer extraordinaire.
Sounding Off: Stephen Bennett In a desert of noise, the personal MP3 player is an oasis of quiet...
Studio SOS Bella Saer
Crane Song Avocet Stereo Monitor Controller This new monitor controller sets new standards for operational flexibility and sonic fidelity.
Digidesign M Box 2
In another exciting installment of our studio 'makeover' series, the team rotate Bella Saer's entire setup through 90 degrees in search of a more effective working environment.
The Go! Team: Recording Thunder, USB Recording Interface [PC/Mac] Digidesign have given the most affordable interface in their Lightning, Strike Pro Tools range a makeover, with a new case, new preamps Gareth Parton and some additional features. East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs Kompakt Instrument [Mac/PC] Ever fancied arranging 'Oops, I Did It Again' for a full choir? Well now you can, courtesy of Symphonic Choirs, the latest virtual-instrument sample library from East West and Quantum Leap.
Kawai MP8 Digital Stage Piano file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/Contents.htm (1 of 4)10/19/2005 9:40:35 PM
The Go! Team's debut album, a glorious pile-up of mangled samples and lo-fi home recordings, is now attracting widespread acclaim — but its path to Mercury nomination and commercial success has been anything but smooth.
Technique
ReBirth & Reason
In This Issue
Kawai's last few digital pianos have been finely wrought things of beauty: solidly built keyboards with an amazingly realistic playing action and beautifully sampled piano timbres. But their latest claims to surpass all of those. Can it possibly be true?
Reason Notes ReBirth is dead. Long live ReBirth! We discuss the decision to discontinue this pioneering software and discover how Reason users can keep its spirit alive.
Korg OASYS: Part 1
News & Updates We round up a month of small, yet interesting, product releases from Apple, as well as looking at how the company is making it easy for Linux developers to port audio software to Mac OS X.
Workstation Synth
For over 15 years, Korg have produced the world's most successful workstation synths, and the OASYS is their new £5400 flagship, their attempt to take the concept to the next level. In the first instalment of our two-part in-depth test, we assess how they have fared...
Lexicon MX200 Multi-Effects Processor Lexicon's latest hardware reverb is designed to be as easy to control from your computer as a plug-in.
M&K MPS1611P Active Monitors
Apple Notes
CLASSIC TRACKS: Jimi Hendrix Experience All Along The Watchtower Eddie Kramer With his searing version of 'All Along The Watchtower', Jimi Hendrix set a standard for Dylan covers that has rarely been equalled. Eddie Kramer was behind the glass as the sessions moved from London to New York.
Digital Performer Notes News & Tips We've got news of some interesting new plug-ins this month, and the solution to one of those software compatibility problems that can drive you bananas...
Emu's Patchmix DSP Demystified... These new speakers from M&K let you switch between reflex and infinite-baffle designs on a whim.
Technique We demystify the powerful internal routing and mixing engine within Emu's recent popular range of computer audio interfaces.
Plug-in Folder
Logic Notes
Camel Space & DVR2 We test two hot new plug-ins: Camel Audio Camel Space — Formats: PC VST & Mac OS X AU TC Electronic DVR2 — Formats: Mac/PC Powercore
News & Tips More tips and news from the world of Apple Logic.
Rayzoon Jamstix Virtual Drummer PC VST Instrument
Managing iLok Plug-in Licences Technique There can't be many Pro Tools users left who have not had to invest in an iLok key in order to run their favourite plugins. But did you know that you can insure, transfer and even buy and sell iLok plug-in licences electronically? Find out more...
Mastering Reason 3 Mixes Virtual band members are now a regular feature in SOS Technique reviews, but how about a virtual drummer that actually will Reason 3 has several new tools for pumping up final mixes jam with you? Rayzoon claim Jamstix is able to do just that... and creating that 'finished product' sound.
Sample Libraries: On Test
PC Notes
Hot Releases Assessed We check out the latest sample libraries on the block: Reason Drum Kits ***** Beats Working In Cuba ***** The Giovani Edition *****
News & Updates This month we explore the relevance of User accounts and the vital contents of the Windows Documents and Settings folder.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/Contents.htm (2 of 4)10/19/2005 9:40:35 PM
Pointing Devices For The PC Musician
In This Issue
SE Electronics Titan Multi-pattern Condenser Microphone
PC Musician If you've had enough of chasing a mouse around your desk, there are many other ways of controlling the onscreen pointer of your music software. We examine the options.
Pro Tools Notes
The capsule within this microphone has a diaphragm coated News & Tips with titanium, rather than the usual gold. We find out Once again, there's a bumper crop of news from Digi-world whether it makes any sonic difference... to report, including the long-awaited jump to version 7 of Pro Tools. SSL AWS900 Mixer & Control Surface
Sonar Notes
With their latest Superanalogue console, SSL bring the sonics and functionality of their flagship SL9000K to studios with smaller rooms and budgets. In the process, they've incorporated comprehensive control-surface facilities for driving computer DAWs remotely. But can the AWS900 really live up to its pedigree?
Steinberg Halion Player v3.1 Sample Library Player [PC/Mac] If you want the sample playback features of Steinberg's Halion sample player, but you don't need its detailed editing facilities, there's now an affordable answer to your needs and it includes the full Halion sound library, too...
Waves GTR Guitar Tool Rack Guitar Processing System [PC/Mac]
News & Tips When the version number's most significant digit increments, you know something big is going to happen — what's inside Version 5?
The Lost Art Of Sampling Part 4 If you want to artificially extend your instrument samples, or make entire backing tracks from one rhythmic snippet, you'll need to know about looping and time-stretching. And then there's keygrouping... We explain these fundamental sampling processes, and more.
Using Sonar's Dreamstation Soft Synth Technique This modest little soft synth has been bundled with Sonar since version 1.0 and is very kind to your CPU resources, yet many Sonar users are still unaware of just how much you can squeeze out of it. We present some evidence.
Using Hardware Controllers With Logic
Software guitar amp modelling has been around for a while, but GTR is Waves' first foray into the field — and as you'd expect, they have made a huge effort to get it right, even hiring guitar maker Paul Reed Smith to design a bespoke preamp.
Competition
Technique Not everyone can afford to invest in a dedicated high-spec hardware controller such as Logic Control. However, you can use even the most humble of MIDI devices to control your mixer, software synths, and plug-ins instead.
Using V-Racks In Digital Performer 4.6 Technique One of the most exciting and unexpected new features unveiled in Digital Performer 4.6 is V-Racks, and, like many of the best things in life, it's something you probably didn't realise you needed until it came along...
WIN Propellerhead Reason 3, Ableton Live 5, M Audio Key Rig, Drum & Bass Rig, Reason Strings, Drum Kits Refills + Working With Video In Cubase SX/SL ProSession sound libraries. Sound Advice
Q. Can I connect an AES output to an S/ PDIF input? Q. Did Mellotrons use tape loops or not? Q. How can I make the most of a small
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/Contents.htm (3 of 4)10/19/2005 9:40:35 PM
Technique Since its SX reincarnation three years ago, Cubase has once again become one of the most flexible tools for writing music to picture. Let's investigate...
In This Issue
studio space? Q. What is that 'robot voice' effect? Q. What is the best way to mic up a clarinet? Q. What is the difference between mono with one speaker and mono with two? Q. Why is the signal louder when it is panned to the centre?
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/Contents.htm (4 of 4)10/19/2005 9:40:35 PM
Ableton Live 5
In this article:
Ableton Live 5
All Things To All People Loop-based Sequencer Opening DAWs Published in SOS November 2005 Sound Content Plug-In Delay Compensation Print article : Close window Pocket Calculator Reviews : Software Instruments & Other Devices See You Later, Arpeggiator Simpler Updated Organisational Tools
Ableton Live 5 £299 pros Unique, powerful and simple compositional and recording tool providing a huge fun factor with serious results. Completely puts you in control of all the little bits of audio that make up your hard drive: every file is instantly usable. A big selection of sounds and sound-design Devices, with some interesting new sound-manipulation tools. More powerful Arrangement view with MIDI/keycontrollable locators. Reliable.
cons Too few to spoil the experience.
summary
[Windows/Mac OS X]
Ableton Live is one of the software success stories of the last few years, with devoted users in fields as diverse as DJing, remixing, theatre sound and music production. Version 5 addresses requests from all these areas, whilst retaining the program's renowned ease of use. Ingo Vauk
Version 5 of Ableton's Live loopsequencing environment is a serious, feature-packed update, and I can believe the Ableton team when they describe it as their largest development effort since the first version of the program. Ableton have integrated a lot of user requests in this release, and the good relations they maintain with their user base really seem to have paid off for both parties.
If you liked previous versions of Live you'll love this. Ableton have stayed true to their simple design and interface while adding high value to the software, expanding its capabilities in a very creative and usable way. I love it!
In terms of the user interface and graphic display of the software, Live 5 hasn't changed much since the last release, and if you're not familiar with the program I suggest you take a look at Sound On Sound's reviews of Live 4 (September 2004: www.soundonsound.com/sos/sep04/articles/live4.htm) and the original Live (February 2002: www.soundonsound.com/sos/feb02/articles/ableton.asp). There are a few enhancements, like the resizable mixer channels in Clip view, but overall, Live 5 doesn't look much different from its predecessors. To handle information the much greater complexity of the program, Ableton have introduced a couple of £299 including VAT. M Audio UK +44 (0)1923 new buttons to control the display, and a number of contextual menus that can the accessed via right mouse-clicking (Windows) or Ctrl-clicking (Mac). It is worth 204010. familiarising yourself with these menus early on, since they hide a lot of goodies, +44 (0)1923 204039. especially in the file-browser department and with regard to fine-tuning warp Click here to email file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (1 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Ableton Live 5
www.maudio.co.uk
markers.
www.ableton.com
All Things To All People While Ableton's aim with this release is to bring the software to the status of a serious DAW, they haven't forgotten their large contingent of DJ users and remixers, and some of the major improvements target these groups. With the introduction of support for the MP3 file format, Ableton have made the entire contents of everyone's digitised music libraries instantly accessible for what they lyrically call 'guaranteed mash-up gratification'. Not being much of a DJ myself, I had a go and must say that I'm a lot closer to beat-matching than I ever was, while combining Rachel Podger's Bach Sonatas and Partitas for solo violin with select NWA beats made for interesting listening (for a while...). There's also a new automatic track tempo-matching feature, which sets warp markers for imported audio files and is a huge time saver. The function works well, but in most cases it is worth following the manual's suggestions on how to help Live along to the best result. I found that often the general tempo of a recording was tracked quite accurately, but almost invariably the downbeat was missed, resulting in both a late trigger and an offset. Using the optional tools in the Clip Edit window (accessed by right-clicking or Ctrl-clicking on a warp marker) makes fine adjustments to the overall timing easy and painless, and spending about 30 seconds to prepare a track you want to 'mash up' doesn't seem too much to ask. A nice touch is the ability to batchprocess files by Ctrl-clicking a folder containing audio in the Live browser and using the Analyze Audio option (if you select a folder that only contains one audio file, this option doesn't appear, which had me fooled for a while — the logic, I guess, being that you're not really batch processing.) Using the batch processing I set up Live to anaylse my entire iTunes library overnight, and could get right into mash-up mode the next morning.
Right-clicking on a warp marker in the Clip Edit window allows you to fine-tune Live's automated settings.
The new, dedicated 'complex' warp mode should be mentioned here. This is a frequency-domain warp mode that is specifically designed to handle composite, mixed-down signals. It works well, though it is very processor-intensive, exerting about 10 times the CPU load of the other warp modes. The new Freeze Track feature comes in handy in this context, but more about that later.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (2 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Ableton Live 5
Another feature that is targeted at remixers is the new Clip Transport, though this has more far-reaching implications for the use of the Session view in general. In Live 4 it was impossible to audition an audio or MIDI clip from somewhere in the middle, making it necessary to play the clip from the beginning in order to hear a certain section. My way around that used to be a quick transfer over to the arrangement view, but this also had its drawbacks, namely that it was less then instantaneous, and sometimes got in the way of an existing arrangement. In Live 5 you can now click anywhere in the waveform and the software will, true to Ableton's obsession with sync, jump there at the next global quantise value. In conjunction with the 'set' buttons introduced to define beginning and end points of a clip, on-the-fly editing of envelopes and events and positioning of long sections of audio or MIDI has become a lot quicker and more intuitive. Clip loops are now decoupled from the start and end points of the clips, which means that you can set up a section that runs continuously to a certain point and loops thereafter. Using the 'set' buttons you can also set this up on the fly. As with the vast majority of Live features, these functions can be mapped to MIDI controllers.
Opening DAWs As I mentioned earlier, Ableton are looking to become a serious contender in the market for digital audio workstation (DAW) recording software, and have thus introduced a number of features in the Live 5 release that should help them here. While it is undisputed that the simplicity, workflow, ease of operation and nondestructive nature of audio processing all make Live a very attractive tool to work on, there is an aspect to the system that needs specific attention when working in a pro audio, studio environment. Since Live is also a live performance tool, Ableton have built in a great deal of resilience and stability. The application hardly ever crashes, and you will need to push it very hard for the audio to stop completely. However, when you are edging towards that point of system overload both audio quality and timing accuracy begin to deteriorate. Both these artefacts are not acceptable in a professional studio situation, and other applications get around the problem by limiting the voice count and cutting audio that doesn't arrive at the output within spec. In a studio situation, where you have the opportunity to work around such problems, this is good practice in my opinion, since it gives the engineer peace of mind as far as the digital audio quality is concerned. The dynamic nature of Live obviously conflicts with such an approach, and personally I wouldn't want to trade all the great creative possibilities Live 5 offers in favour of deaf trust in the audio. However, it should be pointed out that with Live you have to use your ears to judge the audio: there can be degradation well before you see obvious signs of processor overload such as jittery graphics, and it can be subtle until you know what you're listening for. Ableton's head developer responded to my query on this question as follows: "There is no short answer to this. The behaviour of Live's audio processing under heavy load is a complex thing and heavily file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (3 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Ableton Live 5
dependent on the processor type and system architecture (multiple processors or cores). Of course we took care to give the most critical tasks the highest priority (recording over playback, playback over interaction and display)." It is always good practice to run a system with a degree of processing headroom and this applies even more here, since you are likely to have much more dynamic load variations on the processor than in more conventional applications. Having said that, Ableton have introduced a Clip Freeze function precisely in order to enable you to get more from your machine when running Live. Similar to other Set Live 5 going overnight, and it familiar DAW systems, Freeze generates a will analyse all the audio and 'bounced' audio file to play back processed MP3 files on your hard drive ready for instant use in the sounds off disk rather than running live via the future... CPU. Naturally the frozen processing cannot be manipulated in this state, but it is still possible to trigger clips in the usual way. This is great when you are working on a big arrangement and running out of processing power while you are still experimenting. However, I found that sometimes the frozen clips lacked the accuracy of material that was running live. Loop points sometimes seemed sluggish, and they also tended to shift slightly under moderately heavy load. One drawback of running frozen loops is that audio processors on random cycles, or cycles which are longer than the loop length — such as slow phasers, long delays or the new Beat Repeat device — lose most of their variations. There is a cure to this problem, which is to perform the arrangement in Clip view while the clips are frozen, but then carefully consolidate and bounce the arrangement one part at a time in Arrangement view. Unfortunately this method only applies to a studio situation, but I would have thought that on stage nobody would want to push the system to a point where a lot of frozen audio becomes necessary. Having said that, the way Live recovers files from the undo history after a crash works very reliably, and I haven't really lost anything major due to a crash — yet.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (4 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Ableton Live 5
Sound Content Live 5 boasts a large new sound library, and the way Ableton have delivered it is different from previous versions, where most of the sounds came as sampled loops. Live 5 relies more on the sound-generating and processing power of the software to give the user the tools to write their own material, rather than chopping about pre-recorded sound bites. Simpler and Impulse both come with an extended library of sounds that is designed to give you musical starting points and sound-design inspiration in an open ended way. The new Device management system, which saves entire processing chains in one go, allows the user to port complex Device designs between Live Sets. The large collection of clips goes one step further and provides audio and MIDI clips together with associated Devices, so that you can treat a clip as a musical starting point by using the MIDI provided, or play the instrument that comes with the clip manually to create something new. The modular structure allows you to change effects chains that have loaded with a clip and save the result either in the Device format or as a new clip. To this the user adds his or her own variations and new material, so that almost any piece of audio sitting on your hard drive becomes a potential new sound configuration ready to use and recycle. Live 5 clips are organised into categories such as Bass, Beat, Percussive and Pad — some in MIDI and some in audio form — and there is a lot here to play with. The sound quality is of the high standard we have come to expect from Ableton libraries, and while everyone will still want to use sound sources external to Live, it certainly is possible to create entire tracks using only Live samplers, effects and Operator.
Plug-In Delay Compensation Two further new features in Live 5 help to improve overall timing. Automatic plugin delay compensation is provided for all Live plug-ins at both the track insert and return points, and a per-track time shift-delay can be found under each fader, as is the case on a number of digital mixing consoles and other DAWs. This is there to enable you to deal manually with other constant delay issues, such as delays incurred by sending to a hardware processor. The delay compensation apparently also constantly works to minimise latency for plug-in instruments. With this feature Live is catching up with the competition where delay compensation comes (if not always reliably and not always on group returns!) as standard. Ableton say that the delay compensation works reliably for third-party plug-ins that report the delay time correctly to Live, so it might still be a good idea to check for any unwanted timing errors on more obscure effects. Here the manual delay setting below the track faders will do the job. Incidentally, Sets created with earlier versions of Live will load with automatic delay compensation set to off, whereas anything from Live 5 onwards defaults to having it switched on. Another feature not unique to Live, but nevertheless useful, is the introduction of file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (5 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Ableton Live 5
arrangement locators, which can be set on the fly, named and recalled by mouse clicks, keystrokes or MIDI commands. Navigating though an arrangement this way makes it easy to mock up different structures and also helps when you are editing an arrangement in a more conventional DAW fashion. Also very welcome to a lot of users will be the addition of Mackie Control support. I'm sure that controlling Live from that family of control surfaces must be great fun, but unfortunately I didn't have one at my disposal to try it.
Pocket Calculator A few months back Ableton released Operator, an FM synth following in the Yamaha DX tradition, with four oscillators that can be combined into 10 different algorithms, from all serial to all parallel. Live 5 comes with a demo version, but for full functionality you will have to purchase a licence for 129 Euros. Frequency modulation (FM) synthesis is based on the fact that The signal flows from top to bottom in each you can generate harmonic Operator algorithm, so the envelopes of the sidebands by modulating the lowest oscillator in a serial configuration frequency of one oscillator (carrier) shape the overall amplitude and filter, while with that of another (modulator). those above determine the harmonic content Each time this happens the resulting of the sound. waveform becomes more complex, and thus more rich in harmonic overtones. This way it is possible to generate very complex waveforms from simple sources. The resulting, harmonically rich waves then get filtered in the traditional way in order to shape the sound. Ableton have managed to package this potentially challenging synthesis concept into a very simple and ergonomically friendly design. Every parameter is accessed from the front panel, and once you have understood the basic concept, it is easy to get right in there and create sounds from scratch as well as tweak the patches from the impressive factory library. Each oscillator is accessed on the left-hand side of the control panel where the pitch is set. 'Fixed' pitch can be used to add a 'clicky' percussive attack to sounds such as organs or a harmonically fixed overtone component for breathlike noises. When you click on an oscillator, the central panel switches to show the corresponding envelope. The envelope shape provides three rate parameters — attack, decay and release — and three levels, initial, peak and sustain. You can also set the oscillator's wave shape from a choice of 26, including noise, and a few other parameters such as phase, velocity sensitivity, velocity to envelope rate and key tracking are available. A neat feature, which turns Operator into an instant groove machine not unlike NI's Absynth, is the envelope loop function which repeats the envelope shape in a variety of ways, either beat- or temposync'ed or free-running. file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (6 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Ableton Live 5
Operator has seven envelopes in all, controlling the amlitude of each oscillator, the mod depth of each LFO, and overall pitch and filter frequency. All of these modulation sources make Operator a very A demo version of the Operator synth is flexible synth that spans the sound included with Live 5. spectrum from the traditional FM domain such as electric pianos, bells, brass and synth strings, via electronic percussion and drums, to modern rhythmical sound beds — instant dance tracks in fact. The library is impressive, and the hands-on design of the user interface makes it easily tweakable so that users will very quickly make it their own. The low load Operator puts onto the CPU make it an ideal sound source for Live 5, and combined with all Live's soundmanipulation plug-ins, it becomes a powerful sound design resource. But keep an eye on the voice count...
Instruments & Other Devices A number of improvements and new devices have been introduced to Live 5's armoury of instruments and effects. Since we reviewed Live 4 Albleton have launched Operator, a fully fledged FM synthesizer (see box). This instrument is not part of the Live package and must be purchased separately. However, all other Live plug-ins come free with the software, and in this release Ableton have added the intriguing Beat Repeat. Beat Repeat is, in essence, a delay unit with subsequent pitch transposer and filter, and an input feed that can be triggered in a variety of ways, but basically in sync with the track. If, for argument's sake, you feed a drum loop into it, it will pick individual beats or sections and repeat them — if you wish, with a pitchshifted feedback loop and subsequent filter. The resulting delay output can then be either mixed in together with the original signal in a dry/wet balance, used to replace the original in those sections it triggers, or heard on its own. Depending on the settings, you can achieve a variety of interesting effects, ranging from subtle rearrangements of a drum loop to mad harmonised effects not unlike those achieved with the MXR Pitch Transposer way back in the '80s. This is also very useful in the mash-up department, where whole tracks can be re-funked (try Cameo's 'Word Up'). Other remix applications would include vocal tracks, where you can achieve strange repeat and stutter phenomena if you're sick of the AutoTune yodel and want to try something a little different. Altogether, Beat Repeat is a very versatile and fun plug-in that yields many surprises. Other new plug-ins include a phaser and a flanger. I always find phase-related effects hard to judge in absolute terms, since they so depend on the source material. These two plug-ins apparently have been modelled on '70s guitar pedals (although Ableton are a little non-specific on what pedals these are), do a good job from the subtle to the not-so-subtle, and certainly enhance the sounddesign capabilities of Live. In an environment that is structured in such a modular fashion, phasing effects can always add colour to long processing chains. Nice. file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (7 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Ableton Live 5
Also new is a true stereo panner that provides you with four modulation waveforms (sine, triangle, sawtooth and random) that can be shaped towards a square wave in percentage degrees. The modulation of left and right signal can be in phase, which results in a tremolo to gating effect depending on depth, or phase-shifted by up to 360 degrees, with 180 degrees giving the maximum left/ right depth. There is also a 'spin' mode, which gives the left and right signal different rates of panning, with the maximum 50 percent being approximately a 3/4 ratio between the two. As usual better tried out than explained, this is a versatile plug-in to add interest and movement to your mixes. Designed to add warmth and fuzz, the new Saturator adds warmth and fuzz. Personally I find that kind of thing is best done in the analogue domain, but set the parameters carefully and make use of the Colour section and you can really add character to sounds, in a way that beats adding excessive EQ. Presets like 'Mid-Range Phattener' show the subtle side of this plug-in.
See You Later, Arpeggiator By public demand Ableton have also added an arpeggiator, and as you would expect by now, it can do more than your standard up and down patterns. The Live 5 arpeggiator comes with a list of 18 play orders (Styles), from the usual up/ down to chord triggers, converging and diverging arpeggios and more. Rate and gate settings are self-evident, but the Retrigger section is a little more interesting. Here you can limit the number of repeats the arpeggio runs New effect Devices in Live 5: from left, Beat for each trigger (from 1 to 16 and Repeat, Saturator, Flanger and Phaser. infinite) and set it up to retrigger either on a regular rhythmical sub-division, per note or not at all. You can achieve interesting pseudo-polyrhythmic effects by setting an odd number of steps like 7 or 9 and retriggering the result on a halfnote or whole-bar base. This way the arpeggio gets 'pulled back' into the overall rhythm while running on an unusual cycle. An unusual and interesting addition is the Transpose section, which depending on your setting adds notes of a predetermined interval into the arpeggio. These notes can be forced into a scale for obvious harmonic reasons, or set to run free at the fixed interval. The Steps fader in this section controls how many of these intervals get added to the original trigger. It sounds more complicated than it is, and you don't need to know exactly what's going on to create a nice-sounding sequence. Last but not least there is the Velocity section, where you can set a target velocity you want the arpeggio to reach over time. The arpeggiator will 'fade' from your trigger velocity up or down to the target velocity over the length of the file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (8 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Ableton Live 5
'decay' time (0.01ms to 60s). When the Retrigger mode is enabled in this section the velocity behaviour will follow the trigger setting selected in the Retrigger section of the Style settings. Using, for example, a synth sound with velocitysensitive filter settings, you can create dramatic slow build-ups with a low trigger velocity and a high destination setting over a long decay time. Alternatively, you can generate looped effects with the retrigger mode set to Beat. I could go into more detail, but suffice it to say that there are hours of fun to be had with this little beast. Ableton have managed to design this MIDI effect with relatively few parameters that all have a dramatic effect on the result, so when you tweak a control here you do hear the difference immediately.
Simpler Updated With the inclusion of independent envelopes for filter, pitch and amplitude, the Simpler sampler is still simple (just) but a little more powerful. Glide control and an improved LFO (the rate can be related to key position — build you own Theremin from a sine wave!) are welcome additions. This instrument needs to be seen in context with the other processing power of the software, since in combination with all the other plug-ins it becomes a surprisingly powerful sounddesign building block.
Organisational Tools Apart from all the previously described improvements and additions, the biggest news in my opinion is the rethink the Ableton developers have had on the filing structure for Live. I love the way everything is integrated now via the new Live Clip format. As mentioned above, saving a clip now means that all the relevant settings for the sound generator, any MIDI processing and audio plug-ins get carried with the clip file, regardless whether it happens to be an audio file, sampler or synth. Also, whole Live Sets now appear in the browser as folders containing all the clips they are made up of. So if you remember a track you have worked on and want to reproduce a certain sound or setting from that in a totally unrelated project, it is as easy as browsing to the old track and dragging the relevant clip into the new Live 5 Set. The beauty is that this works for previous versions of Live, so anything you have done up until now is available to you without any re-saving or other complication. I also like the fact that this is the same for audio or MIDI clips, which means that you don't have to set up different housekeeping systems and can just think of your sounds as sounds. Since this means that you are all of a sudden dealing with a lot more sounds (keep in mind the potentially large MP3 library you might have included) Live 5 also comes with an improved browser. All saving and loading of clips and Devices from within a Live Set can be done by drag and drop or simple save buttons, with Live creating the necessary tracks automatically on load. It is also file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (9 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Ableton Live 5
possible to drag entire Live Sets into an already open Set, which merges the two. One suggestion I would like implemented is to include the drag-and-drop facility for the Replace/Locate button in the clip display, since it can be a little tedious to have to browse from the root directory all the way to a sample location that might be open in the browser already. What this way of archiving sounds and ideas has that really sets it apart from any other file-management system I've come across is the way it so totally integrates with the operating system. Suddenly all your hard disks become library material — everything you work on can be combined with The new Arpeggiator MIDI anything else seamlessly, regardless of whether it is Device. in the audio, MIDI/sound-generating or mixprocessing domains. The integration of MP3 files with all my samples and sound processors even awoke my curiosity in the process of DJ mixing. Altogether the new browsing and filing system is a huge step forward, making Live 5 even more immediate and incredibly quick for accessing all your sounds. I should also mention Device Groups at this point; in essence, Live allows you to combine a number of plug-ins into a group, which can then be loaded and saved as one object. For example, suppose you have a chain consisting of an arpeggiator and a MIDI scale device plugged into Operator, through a ping-pong delay and compressor, to give you a patch that can be used as an instant trance generator. By shift-selecting all these plug-ins together and choosing the Group command from the Edit menu you can create a Device Group. Saving this just takes a mouse-click on the Save button of the Device Group, and once the Device then shows in the browser window you can rename it. What takes a little getting used to is that Ableton have opted for this format to save the settings as well as the instrument architecture, meaning that you cannot have multiple presets for a single Device Group — the Device Group itself is the preset. Once I got my head around that concept, though, I began to appreciate the simplicity: you never have worry about remembering how you created a sound again, just what it sounds like and where you archived it. Naming and archiving therefore becomes a key to a good library, and it is worth spending a little time on setting up a folder structure that will make it easy for you to manage your sounds. The fact that the browser is now searchable from within Live 5 helps a lot, and you can also create folders without having to leave the software. It just remains to say that in all of this I didn't experience any unpleasant crashes, and although it is quite obvious that a powerful audio program like Live 5 will suck up any processing power you allow it to, I was surprised by its moderate CPU consumption and reliability on my trusted G4 workhorse. Nevertheless, Live 5 is so much fun that it still made me crave a more powerful machine — and finally convinced me to get one! My main problem in writing this review was
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (10 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Ableton Live 5
simply to get to the point where I stopped playing with Live 5 and started writing the review. Several nights in a row I sat down to finally put pen to paper, only to end up playing and exploring until the early hours yet again, and it took serious strength of will to close it down and open my word processor! Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/abletonlive5.htm (11 of 11)10/19/2005 9:40:53 PM
Apple Soundtrack Pro
In this article:
Apple Soundtrack Pro
The Interface Say Hello, Waveform Editor Audio Sequencer & Editor Published in SOS November 2005 Mixing And Matching Minor Gripes Print article : Close window
Apple Soundtrack Pro £199
[Mac OS X]
Reviews : Software
pros Adds significant audio capability when working with Final Cut. Largely intuitive to use. Has access to some great Logic effects as well as introducing some new processes of its own. Very affordable. Includes a very powerful waveform editor and some great workflow tools, such as the Actions list.
Apple's loop-sequencing application has grown up, with the addition of sophisticated recording, editing and mixing facilities, a powerful waveform editor, and many of Logic's most sought-after effects. Paul White
The marketing copy for Apple's original Soundtrack claimed that it enabled anyone working in picture to build cons Being restricted to recording professional-quality audio soundtracks by combining the thousands of readyonly one track at a time precludes some music made, royalty-free Apple Loops that are applications for which the included with the program. Apple program might otherwise be describe the program as 'A royalty-free very well suited. orchestra at your command', but what it summary really offers is a royalty-free orchestra If you were to judge plus a royalty-free composer, both of whom will work for no wages, and I'm sure Soundtrack Pro as an audio sequencer, it could be seen to I'm not alone in feeling a little uncomfortable with this 'even the family pet can play it!' approach. To be fair, you can also record and import 'real' audio in the be lacking in certain key areas, but you have to form of AIFF or WAV files as well as bringing in Acid loops, but what it seems to remember that it is really a be saying to the musician busy working on TV projects is that we can cut out the picture soundtrack assembly middle man — and the middle man is you! tool and the fact that it gets so close to offering what the audio side of so many major sequencing programs offer is a testimony to its sophistication. Moreover, Apple don't force this sophistication on you — you can work at your own level of complexity without unwanted features getting in the way.
information
The new Soundtrack Pro, however, is an entirely different thermal inducing device full of aquatic lifeforms of the subphylum Vertebrata. Indeed, it is so much more sophisticated than the original Soundtrack that it has little in common other than the name. Yes, you can still do intuitive loop-based music compilation, but now you can also edit stereo and multitrack audio to single-sample accuracy, mix, use third-party plug-in AU effects and restore audio corrupted with clicks, hiss or hum. You can bring in movies and sync them to your music, while the time-bending tools built into the program let you change the tempo of the music to fit the video or sync to Final Cut 5's Scoring Markers.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/soundtrackpro.htm (1 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:01 PM
Apple Soundtrack Pro
£199; Final Cut Studio Suite £899. Prices include VAT. www.apple.com
As you'd expect, Soundtrack Pro is specifically designed to work alongside Final Cut Pro and other Apple software to facilitate the transferring of video and audio files between applications, and the multitrack capabilities of the program are ideally suited to layering up and mixing music, dialogue and effects for use in Final Cut Pro. If you think of the program as combining elements of programs like Logic, BIAS Peak LE and Garage Band in a way that is familiar to Final Cut users, you won't be far off the mark, though it also includes some very advanced workflow tools that you won't find in many other audio programs. You can even use Soundtrack Pro's waveform editor section as a stand-alone waveform editor for use with applications like Logic, Live or Reason. However, there's no MIDI or software instrument part to the program; Soundtrack Pro is more about editing audio and sync'ing it to picture. Soundtrack Pro is available as a stand-alone application but also comes as part of the Final Cut Studio Suite along with Final Cut Pro 5, DVD Studio Pro and Motion 2.
The Interface Essentially, Soundtrack Pro works in two distinct modes, one for handling multitrack projects and one for waveform editing (see box). In multitrack projects, you can record new audio and add or arrange audio clips (including Apple Loops) on a timeline, much as you can in Logic or Garage Band. The user interface is more Final Cut than Logic, with the same menus appearing in all windows and a toolbar at the top of the main window. However, the program does make extensive use of tabbed windows to jump between different project views and controls so you can access a lot of information without cluttering up your screen. Clicking a tab makes it active and brings it to the front, and the workspace can be customised to suit the project you are working: windows can be moved and resized, and the tabs can be reordered by dragging them. Similarly, you can decide which tools should be visible in the toolbar at the top of the screen. There's also a counterpart to Logic's screen sets feature. Soundtrack Pro can save and recall preset window layouts, which are named and then saved in the Layouts submenu from where they can be recalled at any time. Project controls are used to define the project's time signature, tempo, musical key, sample rate and time format. The musical key data controls the transposition of Apple Loops; non-looping (one-shot) files retain their length and pitch. To help prevent visual congestion, you can choose whether or not the video track, audio tracks, busses, outputs and master envelopes are visible. There's also a miniature global timeline view that provides an overview of the whole project and allows you to jump to different parts of the project. Fairly conventional transport controls start and stop playback or recording and set the position of the play cursor, and you can also set up a loop cycle when required. Soundtrack Pro also supports audio scrubbing, both in multitrack projects and in the waveform editor.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/soundtrackpro.htm (2 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:01 PM
Apple Soundtrack Pro
The Timeline itself is arranged into three horizontal sections for tracks, busses and outputs, where each track, buss and output has controls in its header at the left of the screen. Several different cursor tools are available, much as they are in Logic and other sequencer programs, for selecting and splitting audio clips and so on. Recordings are initiated on the Soundtrack Pro supports third-party effects selected channel after setting up the in Audio Units format, and allows you to audio source in the Recording dialogue combine them and apply them off-line as well window, but it seems you can arm only as in real time. one track at a time for recording. The whole track header background turns red in record-ready mode, so it's always very clear when a track is armed. A looprecording feature allows you to do multiple takes, then Ctrl-click between them to select the best parts of each. Soundtrack Pro allows you to add audio files in AIFF, WAV, MP3 and AAC (except protected AAC) format and you can also bring in Quicktime audio files. Audio files with any combination of 8kHz to 192kHz sample rate and 8- to 32-bit resolution can be imported. Though you can use the internal audio capabilities of your Mac for monitoring, the best quality and greatest flexibility is afforded by using an external interface box compatible with Mac OS 10.3 or above. If you want to record into Soundtrack Pro, an interface with a low-latency driver is recommended for obvious reasons. Soundtrack Pro supports a maximum sample rate of 96kHz at 24-bit for working, though it can import and convert all the formats listed earlier. Though Soundtrack Pro isn't designed to work with MIDI instruments, it does support MIDI sync via MIDI Clock or MTC at its MIDI input. Dropping a Quicktime movie onto the Quicktime video window or into the Video timeline places the audio component onto the first audio track, in stereo where the source is stereo. The header frame of the video is also shown in the Video track, but you can't string multiple video clips together here — even though the interface looks a little like Final Cut, it's for editing audio not video! A slider controls the video playback position directly, or you can type a time value into the value slider. When moving or resizing audio clips alongside video, you probably want them to synchronise with the video elements of the project, while when editing audio, you tend to do so by beats and bars. Here, you can set each track to be time-based or tempo-based as required, and Soundtrack Pro includes a Snap feature so that edits, markers and moves lock to the nearest Snap To position. Even envelopes and crossfades lock to Snap.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/soundtrackpro.htm (3 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:01 PM
Apple Soundtrack Pro
Say Hello, Waveform Editor Soundtrack Pro's Waveform Edit window can be opened by double-clicking in an audio region, or you can open audio files directly in the waveform editor without going through the multitrack view. Audio can be viewed and edited down to the individual sample level, either destructively or non-destructively. There are tools that allow audio files to be analysed for common problems — especially prevalent in video production — such as clicks, pops, hum and noise, and all the other common functions such as normalisation, fades and gain changes are also supported. At sample level, you can also redraw the audio data to get rid of digital spikes and other short-duration artifacts. Zoom tools allow you to home in on sections of interest, and interestingly, you can also toggle between a waveform view and an audio spectrum view. The waveform display also animates to enable you to visualise the results of your processing. Actions and Analysis buttons show either the Actions list or the Analysis Type with relevant parameters and analysis result listings. The Analysis functions include the ability to check for clipped audio, provided the file has not subsequently been reduced in level — the audio has to hit the end stops to be recognised as clipping. Some analysis types have parameters, such as threshold, that need to be adjusted prior to analysing the file. When Actions is active, you can add real-time effects via the Effects tab. One feature that will make Logic users jealous is that you can also 'flatten' the results to make them permanent, without having to bounce and re-import a new file. Any actions performed on the audio, such as normalising, are listed in the Actions window with a tick box alongside each action. Unchecking the box reverses that action up until the point where you decide to flatten the file and make your edits permanent. This is a particularly elegant feature and goes far beyond being a simple undo-redo history. For example, you can reorder actions by clicking and dragging, and you can undo an single action you did several steps ago without having to redo lots of later ones. Additionally, Actions can be temporarily bypassed rather than undone, so this feature really does make for a flexible workflow. What's more, you can save Action sequences as Apple Script droplets to facilitate drag-and-drop batch processing. Action droplet settings may be edited directly in the Apple Script editor so it's not difficult to make small changes to a multi-stage batch process that you've set up. Soundtrack Pro also ships with a number of 'Automator Actions' that take advantage of the new Automator features in the Tiger operating system. In effect, these make it possible to automate certain audio processing tasks (sample-rate conversion, audio trimming, denoising, normalising and so on) without having to write your own Apple Scripts. While the waveform editor might not have quite so much functionality as the most advanced dedicated audio editing packages, it comes pretty close and handles all the essentials such as sample-rate and stereo-to-mono conversion, fades in and out, normalising and gain change, reversing and time-stretching. It also has a fingerprint noise-reduction system that works reasonably well providing you don't give it anything hopelessly noisy to deal with. This isn't a conventional real-time plug-in: instead, you load in a section of noise, then loop the audio while adjusting the threshold control until you get the best result. When you've tweaked to your satisfaction, you can then apply the process to the whole file or to the selected region. While not quite state-of-the-art, it's infinitely better than the denoiser in Logic.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/soundtrackpro.htm (4 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:01 PM
Apple Soundtrack Pro
Mixing And Matching Track level and pan can be adjusted in the main page using controls in the track header section where you can also mute and solo tracks, add insert effects as plug-ins and send to a reverb buss. Automation is available via a pop-up menu and the now familiar folder content 'swivel arrowheads' allow the automation relevant to any given track to be displayed directly below it, again not unlike the way it is handled within Logic. Three automation modes are supported — Latch, Touch and Read — and automation data may be input directly from a mouse or hardware controller, or edited graphically using envelopes and breakpoints. Hardware control surfaces that impement the Mackie Control protocol are supported. When you come to mix a project, there's a dedicated Mixer page where each track, buss and output has a channel strip with level meter, level control, mute and solo buttons, slots for adding effects, pan controls and so on. Each track may be given an icon selected from a list, again rather as you can in Logic, though there is a great choice of colourful icons here that would make most Logic users jealous! A pop-up menu lets you select an output for the track or buss as well as letting you pick multiple physical output channels for the output audio channels. Conceptually, this isn't dissimilar to the Logic Track Mixer, though it looks a little simpler. Finished projects may be exported as audio files or as a Quicktime movie. There's also a Media and Effects Manager, which comprises five tabbed areas and is designed to allow you to find and preview audio, video and effects. A Browser window lets you trawl through your hard drives and folders in the usual way, and favourite items can be stored under the Favourites tab. The Search tab lets you locate audio files filtered by criteria and you can also search for specific text or Apple Loop tagging descriptors. Candidates may then be auditioned from within the Search Results list. The Bin tab contains media files added to the project and you can drag files directly from the Bin onto the timeline. Files not currently added to the project are dimmed, whereas off-line files appear with red text. Using an Effects tab, you can add plug-in effects and configure effects sends for the project and also call up information on effects already instantiated on tracks, busses, outputs or audio files. Soundtrack Pro now includes over 50 plug-in effects from the Apple range, including high-end reverb, delay, EQ and chorus plus more dramatic soundmangling processors like Sub Bass, Bitcrusher and Auto Filter. Many of the effects are ported directly from Logic and they still have their distinctive blue graphical interfaces. Even Logic's high-end Space Designer reverb is available here. As with Logic, third-party effects are supported in Audio Units format only — there's no VST or RTAS support.
Minor Gripes file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/soundtrackpro.htm (5 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:01 PM
Apple Soundtrack Pro
I did encounter a couple of minor problems with Soundtrack Pro. For one thing, it seemed like whenever I did anything at all on screen, even adding track icons, the G5 processor fans revved up to take the strain. There were no performance issues associated with this, just a lot of huffing and puffing from the fans as though I was asking the CPU to do something arduous. Even dragging windows around the screen started it off, and it was most disconcerting. The program also seemed a little halfhearted about accepting my Logic Control as a hardware controller and 'unexpectedly quit' twice while I was setting this up. It seemed to recognise that a controller was connected but I had to tell it that it was a Logic Control, not a Mackie Control, and also tell it to which MIDI ports it was connected, even though it should have been able The Waveform Editor's Analysis functions to work that out for itself. After that it include a clipping detector. worked fine with no further crashes, though some functions don't seem to be supported from Logic Control, such as horizontal display zooming. In fact most of the Logic Control lights go out, leaving you with level and pan control, Select, Solo and Mute on the channels plus overall transport control with cursor jogging but no scrubbing. Track names are correctly displayed, so if you already have a Logic Control or a Mackie Control, it's well worth using it to drive Soundtrack Pro, but I wouldn't recommend buying one specifically for the job as many of the more sophisticated functions are unavailable. Logic users should also note that Soundtrack Pro's interface doesn't always work in the way you're familiar with, and I suspect this comes from making the program fit in with Final Cut working methodology. It may take a while longer before the best of both approaches becomes the new Apple standard. For example, in Logic you can double-click the stop button to return to the start of the file, but here there's a separate 'go to start' button; and to add points to an automation envelope, you have to double-click to create a new envelope point, and so on. Overall, though, this new Pro version is way more flexible and sophisticated than the original Soundtrack, and as such it offers far more than just a simple way to put media composers out of business! It comes loaded with a great set of movie sound effects as well as musical loops and can now handle serious multitrack mixing with the benefit of all Logic's best effects, including the excellent Space Designer. As a music recording program, Soundtrack Pro is very powerful providing you don't need to record MIDI parts, and gives the user access to effects that once cost more than the entire asking price for the program. It is pretty easy to learn, it offers practical waveform editing in a familiar way and it has full mix automation file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/soundtrackpro.htm (6 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:01 PM
Apple Soundtrack Pro
capability. I like the way you can configure the Workspace to suit your own style of working and the ability to create the equivalent of Logic's screen sets makes the program easy to navigate, even if you have only a single monitor. Realistically, you can do just about anything you might reasonably wish to do in a multitrack audio recording and mixing environment except recording multiple tracks at once, so if Logic seems heavy going and Garage Band is too simplistic, Soundtrack Pro might also be a good choice for musicians working on their own who don't work with MIDI instruments. Its real strength, though, is in bringing advanced audio mixing and editing into the sound for picture world. Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/soundtrackpro.htm (7 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:01 PM
Cakewalk Sonar Home Studio
In this article:
Piece Of Cake System Requirements The Pursuit Of XLence More Effective Better & Better
Cakewalk Sonar Home Studio MIDI + Audio Sequencer [Windows] Published in SOS November 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
Cakewalk Sonar Home Studio £79 pros Inexpensive for a fully specified DAW. Easy to learn, easy to use. Stable. The XL version provides even more bang for the buck.
cons
With Sonar Home Studio, Cakewalk have made the core features of their flagship sequencing application available at a bargain price. Alan Tubbs
No Freeze function. Help could use a little help.
For the last couple of years, users of Cakewalk's entry-level Home Studio summary package have felt like second-class Sonar Home Studio 4 citizens, sitting at the back of the sonic provides outstanding value for bus with a Sonar 2 sound engine and a an entry-level professional screen stuck in the 1990s. It wasn't DAW. It doesn't skimp on the bad, but it was beginning to show its basics, and most of the missing features from the age. I used it mostly for MIDI work, higher-priced versions are recording external synths and functions most of us won't use rendering soft synths before mixing the often, if at all. audio in Vegas, which I was more information comfortable with. The new Sonar Home Studio now shares the cool grey look $ £79; XL version £109; Home Studio (SHS) remedies both of Sonar. The Track Inspector on the left upgrade from previous gives an in-depth look at the focused track, those complaints, using the Sonar 4 versions £39. while the Docking view (bottom right) sound engine and a clean blue/grey Edirol Europe +44 (0)20 expands over the entire right-hand side of user interface. There are other 8747 5949. the screen for audio and MIDI editing on a improvements and goodies, of course, +44 (0)20 8747 5948. large scale. Floating on top is an abbreviated but for musicians looking for a first look at the XL version's RXP REX player, www.edirol.co.uk loaded with a pre-sliced guitar file. DAW and those thinking of upgrading www.cakewalk.com or switching from a competitor's product, SHS streamlines Cakewalk's extensive (and sometimes confusing) Test Spec product line and offers a entry-level pro sequencer and audio recording package PC with 1700GHz AMD with support for sample rates up to 192kHz and the ability to use multiple Athlon CPU and 1GB RAM, processors, dual cores and Hyperthreading. The only major things missing are running Windows XP, with the high-end effects and synths, which can be added at one's leisure, and the Presonus Firepod and Mability to use more than 64 audio tracks. Audio Transit soundcards. Tested with Cakewalk
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cakewalkhomestudio.htm (1 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:04 PM
Cakewalk Sonar Home Studio
Project 5 v2 plus various plugins.
Piece Of Cake SHS ships with a serial number, just like all other Cakewalk software, but unlike HS, it has to be registered on-line, too. However, this only took a minute to do and will hopefully forestall some of the hackers out there — it still beats the devil out of a dongle. Cakewalk's migration tool transfers settings from previous editions over to the new software, and all the songs I was working on in HS2 opened fine in SHS. The new program found both my audio interfaces, along with their attendant ins and outs, without difficulty. The new Sonar look of Home Studio is not only aesthetically pleasing, it is also easier to navigate, and if you find the the default colour scheme too muted, it can be altered. HS was very busy-looking, with several rows of Windows-style toolbars running along the top, and another above the track controls. The whole toolbar menu format is gone in SHS, to be replaced by a Master Control bar containing the play/record buttons, clock and most-used buttons from HS's toolbars. There are still track toolbars at the top of the tracks, but Cakewalk have also added a navigator button which opens up an overview at the top of the track headers and allows the mouse to drag the track view through your entire project. Another ergonomic addition is the Track Inspector. This gives more room for channel settings than previous versions of HS, where all the information System Requirements was squeezed into the track headers themselves. Windows 2000 or XP. There are other changes too: for multiple track 1 GHz or better processor. settings, the Console View is now only a mouseclick away in the Master Control bar, where it is 100MB hard disk space. easier to find than in HS's taskbar. The virtual 256MB RAM. mixer in the Console View gives all channels a Track Inspector-sized scribble strip, making it easy to tell at a glance what channel effects are inserted in the FX slots, as well as which tracks are sent to any auxiliary send. Unlike HS, SHS lets you add busses and assign them as needed: they show up in the centre Master section of the Console View. Once audio is routed to any buss, the buss can be used as an FX sub by inserting a track effect into it and routing back to the master, or into a sub out (hardware dependent, of course) for external processing, or into yet another buss. Every audio track (including busses) has a send section, and only the busses you assign a track to show up there, which helps keep things uncluttered if you have a lot of busing going on. Scribble strips allow you to name everything, which also helps to keep track of which is doing what to whom in a complex mix. The Master Control bar is not resizable, but it can be undocked and moved over the main screen or to a second monitor, if you like. And, of course, it always remains on top of the screen.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cakewalkhomestudio.htm (2 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:04 PM
Cakewalk Sonar Home Studio
These big controls are an improvement over the smaller taskbar buttons, and Cakewalk have made great strides in making SHS more of a single-screen environment. HS made use of deployable, resizable pages for editing audio and Acidised 'groove clips', MIDI info by piano roll, staff or event, and for adding synths or even lyrics to a project. These pages are now part of a docked and tabbed view which occupies the bottom right of the main screen, opposite the buss pane, in an otherwise empty area. The tabs for the Docking View don't appear until you have right-clicked on some audio or MIDI for editing, or have inserted a Staff, Event, synth or Lyric via the Windows View command. The tabbed views are too small for any real editing, as they occupy only the quadrant of the screen beside the busses, but a minimise/maximise button expands the edit view to the entire right side of the screen, replacing the track audio/MIDI content. This is usually enough room to edit without resizing the track headers themselves. I find this to be a more ergonomic layout than finding various pages scattered over two screens: if you need to edit some MIDI, right-click on them, Piano Roll jump to the top of the tabs, hit maximise, and you're ready to edit. Used in conjunction with the Navigator, it is easy as eating pie to edit song-length swathes of MIDI. Some of the changes from HS to SHS may force you to alter the way you work, though if you prefer the old ways, it is possible to right-click on individual Tab Views and disable each separately, returning the tab to a floating page. But the new look and feel are so easy to use I haven't gone back to the HS way of working.
The Pursuit Of XLence As well as the Reverb XL plug-in described in the main text, the XL version of Sonar Home Studio adds three extra synths to the mix. Dyad is a second Soundfont synth, but has considerably more control over the sound than the basic SFZ. You can load in two sounds and edit their pitch, filter and amplitude envelopes, filter cutoff, resonance and slope, and assign two LFOs. There is also RGC Audio's Square 1 virtual analogue synth, which is not as flexible as some of the other VA synths out there, but sounds excellent, with three oscillators and a good filter. Finally, there is the RXP1 REX file player, which can play back REX files as whole loops or slices. RXP will also load in WAV and other formats, but REX files are where the fun is. I had the lyrics for a blues song, but no music ideas to complete it, so I loaded up RXP with a blues guitar file that was included on the XL content disc. It was a very nasty guitar riff that I played from the keyboard, which turned my plinking into a John Lee Hooker lead. You can also use the button layout to play slices or the whole loop at different pitches. If you need any of the above items, each is worth the extra price by itself; together with Reverb XL, they represent a great deal.
More Effective Sonar Home Studio ships with the usual complement of effects: gates, limiters, compressors, parametric and graphic EQ and reverb are all there. These are workhorse effects — nothing too fancy, but they do what they should. SHS comes with Cakewalk's VST wrapper, so VST and VSTi plug-ins are available in file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cakewalkhomestudio.htm (3 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:04 PM
Cakewalk Sonar Home Studio
addition to those in Cakewalk's native DX format. All my VST effects and instruments showed up and worked. If you have a large investment in some highend software, you might want to make sure it works with Sonar before buying, but there have been few complaints in the forums. Cakewalk do include one unusual effect with SHS: Powerstrip. Like the free FX Pad and their Spectral FX, this is a preset unit with different effects (or controls) assigned to sides of a X-Y control pad. You can grab and move the cursor or assign it to move in a circular pattern in time with your song. In the past, I had tended to use FX Pad rather than Spectral FX, since the effects were wilder, but Powerstrip, to my ears, sounds better than either of The Console View gives an overview for the others and has moved to the top of mixing and setting effects. The virtual mixing board is fairly straightforward. Reverb XL, my list. The SHS XL package adds included in the XL package, sounds better Reverb XL, a very tasty reverb. This than most stock reverbs, while Powerstrip doesn't have a natural sound like a can add motion to an effect. convolution reverb, but is more like a good modelling rackmount unit. It is a step above the stock reverbs included with most DAWs, offering a thick sound with a smooth tail. Besides effects, SHS comes with DXi synths. As well as Dreamstation, a basic polyphonic virtual analogue synth, there is a Soundfont (SF) playback synth by RGC Audio. Many people turn up their noses at Soundfonts, thinking of gaming boards, but SFZ provides an easy and cheap way to add sample playback to your project. Most SFs are pretty basic, but I used a bank I had found on the Internet to drive the middle section on one song. The bank had a bunch of effects and mechanical sounds, and I beat out an industrial rhythm from the keys, which I named 'the washerdrum'. Not bad for a free download. The other included soft synth is the Edirol Virtual Sound Canvas 1. This is the software version of Roland's once-ubiquitous Sound Canvas, a souped-up GM synth. The sounds are, for the most part, nothing to write home about, but it is good for temp tracks, or more if you find yourself in a pinch. There are the other improvements over Home Studio: Group edit now allows clips to be selected and have slip edits, fades and splits applied to each clip at the same time, nudging allows clips to be, well, nudged forward or backward by a pre-selected amount using keyboard commands, and the metronome finally allows audio clips to be used instead of MIDI notes. Other things have been left out, such as track Freeze. Sonar Home Studio allows you to put all the audio clips for a project into one folder, but Bounce to Track still doesn't allow you to name the new track, instead automatically assigning something like 'song 1, Master, Mix (2).wav'. If I'm going to have to name a file anyway, let me do it beforehand, not afterwards! And since there are only 64 audio tracks, you'll have
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cakewalkhomestudio.htm (4 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:04 PM
Cakewalk Sonar Home Studio
to budget for the full version if you need to close-mic a full orchestra. Finally, the help doesn't include enough screenshots, and most of the included synth help files are pretty skimpy. There are on-line video tutorials, but when you need an answer while actually working, screenshots with the text search save time.
Better & Better On the SHS forum, some users back Cakewalk's claim that the Sonar 4 engine is more efficient; others claim they can't see any real improvement. I haven't noticed a great leap forward in CPU use, but I haven't had any crashes, either. With Home Studio 2 and previous HS incarnations I would sometimes get a program freeze, and I also ran into a bug whereby the MIDI icon stayed up in the taskbar after I used Alt+Del to close HS and wouldn't open correctly until I opened and immediately closed the program. It didn't happen often enough for me to track down and fix the problem, but it was still unwelcome. With Sonar Home Studio, I haven't had any crashes, freezes or any other surprises, and stability matters to me much more than any improvement in efficiency. Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cakewalkhomestudio.htm (5 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:04 PM
Crane Song Avocet
In this article:
Digital Interfacing The Remote Controller Signal Selection & Conditioning Input Gain Trim Options Using The Avocet
Crane Song Avocet Stereo Monitor Controller Published in SOS November 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Accessory
Crane Song Avocet £1821
This new monitor controller sets new standards for fidelity.
pros
Exemplary sound thanks to operational flexibility and sonic discrete Class-A electronics and passive attenuators. Stunningly good internal DHugh Robjohns A converter. Extremely flexible facilities for console integration and This new high-end monitor controller external control. has been designed by Crane Song's Superb input-level offset mastermind, Dave Hill — someone mode. with a reputation for fastidious attention Independent volume for to detail and for demanding the highest main and headphone outputs, technical and sonic standards. While it dim, and talkback dim. Nice ergonomics throughout. is a widely held belief that passive monitoring controllers must be best, in Beautifully constructed.
cons You can't control the mono monitoring mode remotely. There are no individual speaker mutes. The truncated 16-bit mode is pointless.
summary An expensive but highly accomplished stereo monitoring controller with comprehensive facilities for stand-alone operation or full integration with a console. Exemplary analogue circuitry is complemented with a superb D-A stage, and controlled via an extremely ergonomic remote panel.
information
practice the inputs and outputs need buffering to remain reliable and consistent in the real world of unknown Photos: Mark Ewing impedances. Furthermore, it is extremely hard to derive mono from a stereo source passively without affecting the sound, so some electronics are inevitable in a versatile high-quality monitoring controller. However, these electronics clearly define the ultimate performance of the monitoring chain, so the Avocet's audio path employs just three all-discrete Class-A buffer amplifiers in each channel. Level control is another difficult area to address. Ganged potentiometers often track poorly and can produce image shifts, while active circuitry such as voltagecontrolled amplifiers, although affording very flexible control options, often introduce unacceptable levels of distortion. The ideal solution is usually passively switched attenuators, often arranged around an expensive rotary switch. However, the Avocet manages all of its level-control functions (and I/O selections) with sealed, high-quality relays and resistor chains. Clever logic control of these relays also allows some quite sophisticated additional features — regaining much of the flexibility of a VCA design without sacrificing audio purity.
£1821.25 including VAT. KMR Audio +44 (0)20 file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cranesongavocet.htm (1 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:07 PM
Crane Song Avocet
8445 2446. +44 (0)20 8369 5529. Click here to email www.kmraudio.com www.cranesong.com
The bulk of the Avocet's electronics are housed in a 2U rackmounting case, which is controlled remotely from a desktop unit connected with a 25-foot cable. The front panel of the rack unit features only a stereo headphone socket and a large green vintage-style power lamp, while the rear panel is crammed full of XLRs. Inside the mainframe is a large circuit board covering the whole of the available floor area, with a long row of relays for the stepped volume attenuator across the front. Mounted above this all-analogue board is a smaller digital board, the role of which is described the 'Digital Interfacing' box. The Avocet is equipped with three stereo analogue inputs referred to as Analog 1, Analog 2, and Aux — all nominal +4dBu balanced XLRs with multi-turn trimmers to fine-tune the levels over a ±8dB range — and there are also three digital inputs feeding a high-grade D-A stage. Apparently, an internal link in the current Revision 4 version of the unit (the review model had older Revision 2 circuit boards) optionally provides the Analog 2 input with 14dB of additional gain to accommodate a nominal -10dBV semi-pro input, which is a useful facility. The rear panel also carries three sets of +4dBu balanced stereo analogue outputs on XLRs, a second stereo quarter-inch headphone socket, an IEC mains inlet (with integral fuse holder), and two D-Sub connectors. One of these (Remote) is used to hook up the remote control panel, while the other (Accessory) provides various auxiliary functions such as external switching of talkback, solo, dim, and mute, as well as generating buffered outputs for the talkback mic, headphone output, and unbalanced mono and stereo outputs (the last being intended for an external metering system). There is also provision here for an additional remote-control signal which will be used in future for linking Avocet units when monitoring in surround. Although missing from the review model, the Avocet is normally supplied with adjustable in-line XLR attenuators for use between the Avocet's outputs and the inputs to power amplifiers or active loudspeakers. They are intended to address the perennial problem that most amplifiers are far too sensitive for direct connection to nominal +4dBu line-level outputs. Rather than compromise the signal-noise performance of the Avocet's electronics, Crane Song supply adjustable attenuators which can be placed at the inputs of active speakers or power amps to reduce the signal level by up to 30dB.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cranesongavocet.htm (2 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:07 PM
Crane Song Avocet
Digital Interfacing The Avocet is equipped with three 24-bit digital inputs. Two are straightforward AES inputs able to accommodate a full range of sample rates from 32kHz to 192kHz, and labelled Digi 2 and Digi 3. The third is referred to as the DAW input, and this has three input modes selected by a switch on the back panel. One accepts a normal 'single-wire' AES input via an XLR, while another accommodates a conventional coaxial S/PDIF input via a phono socket. The third mode invokes a second XLR socket to partner the first so that dual-wire highsample-rate AES signals can be connected. The digital inputs do not need to be synchronous — the internal DAC simply locks to the selected source — and changing digital sources is fast, without any nasty bangs or crashes. Interestingly, the Avocet's D-A design employs a similar strategy to that used in the Benchmark DAC1 (which I reviewed back in SOS July 2005), oversampling the selected input to 192kHz and passing it through a sample-rate converter to help remove jitter before D-A conversion clocked by a local crystal. Internal links allow the oversampling to be disabled or limited to 96kHz, if required, although the designer claims the 192kHz option sounds best. The selected digital input is received through a pair of Cirrus Logic CS8416 chips, before being routed to a Burr Brown SRC4492 sample rate converter, and then on to a Cirrus Logic CS4398 — the company's latest 192kHz flagship device. A local crystal is used to clock the output of the SRC and the D-A chip independently of the incoming digital signal's embedded clock. Among the impressive specifications and features of the D-A chip is the choice of two oversampling interpolation filter designs. This function has been made available through another link on the digital board, with the default being a 'slow roll-off' setting. A 'fast rolloff ' mode is also available, and may be more appropriate if source oversampling is not employed. One rather odd function of the D-A board is operated by a button on the Avocet remote control labelled 16-bit. This truncates the selected digital input to 16 bits and is apparently 'for checking what 16 bits sounds like'. I can't imagine any situation where one might want to do this — at least not without applying proper dithering as part of the process. Not a button that will see much use, I suspect!
The Remote Controller The remote controller is a chunky metal 'brick', roughly 45 x 200 x 190mm (hwd), the rear panel of which carries just a D-Sub connector, to link with the mainframe, and a female XLR connector. The latter is for a talkback mic (there being no phantom power available), and the mic preamp's gain is adjusted via a multi-turn trimmer adjacent to the XLR. The control buttons are laid out simply and logically in two long columns, with colour coding to help navigation. In the centre of the panel is a large green rotary encoder with a detented action and 24 green LEDs around the periphery to indicate the current level setting. The knob feels great to use — just the right size and weight to allow accurate click-by-click adjustments or a quick spin up or down with a flick of the wrist, causing the relays to chatter away in the main file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cranesongavocet.htm (3 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:07 PM
Crane Song Avocet
frame. The level setting is very clear, and although marked in 2dB steps the LEDs resolve to 1dB level changes simply by lighting adjacent LEDs to show the midway positions. At the top of the panel is a highresolution stereo bar-graph meter, spanning a 46dB range and calibrated with 0dB at the top — although it A small trimmer on the rear panel of the seems a little odd to have a digitalremote control allows the talkback mic's gain style meter in an analogue controller. setting to be adjusted. An internal link configures the meter to show either the level of the selected input (default), or the output level from the Avocet. The right-hand column of buttons selects the input source, talkback function, and an odd 16-bit monitoring mode. Only one input can be selected at a time, and there is no summing or mixing ability. When the headphone control mode (of which more in a moment) is active, the bottom three buttons in this column serve to configure the headphone monitoring source. There are three options: a feed of the Aux analogue input (intended to pass through a cue mix from a console, for example); a fixed-level feed of whatever input is selected to feed the main monitors; or the same main-monitor feed but taken after the mono, phase, and level controls. The talkback signal is mixed in with the headphone outputs, regardless of what source mode is selected. If the solo mode is activated via the Accessory connector, then the currently selected input is overridden by either the Analog 1 or DAW inputs, according to the position of another internal jumper link. The idea of this feature is to allow complete integration between the Avocet and a mixing console, allowing soloed channels to appear on the monitoring automatically.
Signal Selection & Conditioning The left-hand column of buttons determines the output destination (only one of the three can be active at any time) and the input signal conditioning (phase, mono, dim, and mute), and activate the headphone control mode. With the headphone mode selected the rotary encoder sets the headphone volume, which is totally independent of the main monitoring volume. The mono monitoring mode can be configured with another internal link to send the derived mono signal just to the left speaker, or to both (the default is both). The Mute and Dim buttons are conveniently located at the bottom of the column where they are easy to reach, and the dim level can be adjusted by turning the volume control while in dim mode. The setting is then remembered, even after powering the unit down. The monitoring level when the talkback button is file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cranesongavocet.htm (4 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:07 PM
Crane Song Avocet
pressed can also be set independently of the normal dim level, which is a superbly useful feature. Every button has an associated LED to indicate the current status, and the buttons all have a very positive mechanical click action. There are no obvious pops or splats on the monitored signal when operating any buttons — in fact the unit even turns on and off gracefully, without any nasty thumps. When powering up, all the settings are remembered, but the Mute button is sensibly always enabled.
Input Gain Trim Options To me, one of the nicest functions is that input levels can be temporarily trimmed from the remote controller, but without messing up the precision gain structure dialled in using the rear-panel trimmers. This is essentially done by manipulating the logic data that controls the attenuator relays, so that the audio quality is not affected. The only downside is that you can't adjust the monitoring level beyond the physical attenuator range. For example, if you dial in a +10dB offset, and then crank the level up full, you are effectively asking the attenuator to provide 10dB above the maximum level, which isn't possible. In practice, though, this is very unlikely to become a concern. The gain trim mode is activated simply by pressing the selected input's button a second time, whereupon the gain can be trimmed by up to 10dB in either direction using the large green knob (the latest models provide 0.5dB increments, earlier units 1dB steps). Tap the source button a third time and the operation returns to normal, but with the new gain offset remembered — even if the power is turned off. This gain trim mode is excellent for allowing different sources to be compared accurately at the same perceived level — for example the original and compressed versions of a track.
Using The Avocet Connecting the Avocet is very intuitive and simple, as is the basic operation. Selecting sources and destinations, adjusting the monitoring level, and checking mono and phase compatibility are all very straightforward. The ability to set, and more importantly reset, the monitoring level within 1dB is excellent, and essential in a mastering environment. Likewise, the ability to set the headphone and dim levels independently, using the same control and in such an intuitive way, makes life very easy. The facilities to enable complete integration with a console are well thought out too, but don't compromise the stand-alone operation, or indeed the sound quality, in any way. There are only a couple of niggles. The inability to select mono to one or both speakers from the remote panel is disappointing. Clearly, David Hill recognises file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cranesongavocet.htm (5 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:07 PM
Crane Song Avocet
the important distinction between these two monitoring modes, because the option is available via an internal link. Also disappointing is the lack of individual speaker muting. Often a problem can only be identified by listening to each channel separately. Bearing in mind the absence of separate speaker mutes, it is interesting to read in the Operator's Manual that there are plans afoot to The circuit boards feature more than a dozen enable the linking of multiple Avocets jumper connections which allow the user to to form a surround monitoring tweak the operation of the Avocet to their own personal tastes. controller. Being able to solo and mute individual channels is of paramount importance when working in surround, so it will be fascinating to see how this key functionality is provided. The most important thing about a monitoring controller, though, is how it sounds, and in this there is no doubt whatever. The Avocet sounds totally transparent and I could not detect any quality changes whatsoever when inserting the unit into my monitoring chain. The analogue signal path is exemplary in every way, demonstrated by the fact that the tonality and stereo imaging don't change at all, regardless of the volume setting. Auditioning digital sources was equally impressive, and it quickly became clear that the internal D-A stage easily matched the quality of my favourite new reference, the Benchmark DAC1. The performance of the Benchmark is truly stunning (once it has warmed up), so for the Avocet to match its resolution is praise indeed, and particularly noteworthy given that both D-As employ a very similar technological approach. The Avocet's headphone drivers use high-quality op amps and powerful LM3886 integrated power-amp chips rather than discrete Class-A circuitry, but even so I can't fault the performance at all. There is more than enough volume available, even for the most demanding of artists, and the design provides absolute clarity and neutrality, conveying accurate transients and powerful deep bass. The Avocet is as near to the perfect monitor controller as I have yet found. Yes, it lacks individual speaker muting, the mono check mode is not as versatile as I would like, and the truncated 16-bit mode is, to be blunt, utterly pointless. But the plus points far outweigh these irritations. Excellent ergonomics, stunning audio quality, precision level adjustments, console integration flexibility, and the potential of an upgrade path for surround work all make a very convincing case indeed for the Avocet. Published in SOS November 2005
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cranesongavocet.htm (6 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:07 PM
Crane Song Avocet
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/cranesongavocet.htm (7 of 7)10/19/2005 9:41:07 PM
Digidesign M Box 2
In this article:
On The Outside Up And Running Summing Up
Digidesign M Box 2 £335
Digidesign M Box 2 USB Recording Interface [PC/Mac] Published in SOS November 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Recording Channel
pros Good sound quality, with decent preamps and a powerful headphone amp. Buss-powered, yet offers phantom power to mics. Now offers MIDI I/O, an output level control and the ability to record analogue and digital inputs simultaneously.
cons
Digidesign have given the most affordable interface in their Pro Tools range a makeover, with a new case, new preamps and some additional features. Sam Inglis
Still no option to disable input monitoring in software. Zero-latency monitoring still doesn't apply to digital inputs. Not entirely happy at low latencies in the review system. Lacks the M Box's insert points. Uninstalling Pro Tools on Windows can be a minefield.
summary If you're intending to buy a Firewire or USB 2 interface, Digidesign's revamp of the M Box is unlikely to change your mind. However, if you're content with USB 1.1, it's still one of the best options, and the improvements do make the M Box 2 superior to the original.
information £334.88 including VAT. Digidesign UK +44 (0) 1753 655999. +44 (0)1753 658501. Click here to email
In the three and a half years since the original M Box was introduced, it has become one of Digidesign's most successful products. A simple stereo-in, stereo-out USB audio interface, the M Box allowed anyone with a Mac or PC to call themselves a Pro Tools user without breaking the bank; and its clever circuitry meant that the Focusritedesigned mic preamps could derive phantom power parasitically from the host machine's USB port, making it a truly go-anywhere system. Recently, the M Box has faced increasingly stiff competition. There are plenty of affordable interfaces around which use the higher-bandwidth Firewire protocol, including those made by Digidesign's partner company M Audio, which are now compatible with Pro Tools. M Audio and other companies such as Edirol and Terratec also make USB devices that are much cheaper than the M Box. A change of plan from Digidesign seemed inevitable, and many people expected them to turn to USB 2 or Firewire to achieve a higher channel count, or perhaps just to drop the M Box altogether and extend their support for M Audio hardware to include USB interfaces such as the Fast Track Pro and Mobile Pre USB. (Or how about a PCMCIA card along the lines of Echo's Indigo IO? Please?) Instead, they've replaced the M Box with another USB 1.1 device which offers an almost identical feature set: the M Box 2.
www.digidesign.com
Test Spec
On The Outside file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/mbox2.htm (1 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:10 PM
Digidesign M Box 2
Pro Tools LE v6.8.1. Centrino laptop with 2.0GHz Pentium-M CPU and 2GB RAM, running Windows XP Service Pack 2. Tested with Steinberg Cubase SX v3.02.
The much-imitated look of the M Box has changed completely, although the new design is equally distinctive. The smart moulded plastic case can be stood on its end or arranged horizontally; in this case, the carrying handle attached to the front panel tilts the front of the M Box 2 up slightly, making it easier to see the settings. The handle can be swapped out with an alternative, solid piece of blue plastic if you prefer. According to the manual, this saves space and allows the unit to sit flat on a table top, but the one supplied with the review model was barely smaller than the handle, and still tilted the front panel upwards. If you really wanted to save space and lay the M Box 2 flat, you could just leave the handle off altogether, so the alternative faceplate seems pretty redundant. In terms of features, the M Box 2 has a great deal in common with its predecessor. Once again there are two analogue inputs, although since Digidesign's partnership with Focusrite is no more, the associated mic preamps are of a different design from the originals. Neutrik Combi connectors are no longer used, and the M Box's analogue insert points are also missing in action. Instead, each analogue input features separate XLR mic, quarter-inch balanced line and quarter-inch instrument DI sockets on the rear of the unit, with the controls on the front panel. These consist of a rotary gain control, a switch to engage a 20dB pad, and a button to switch the channel's source from Mic to DI. As on the original, 48V phantom power is available at both mic inputs (or neither — it is globally switched), and is derived from the host machine via the USB connection. Unlike its
On the 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it' principle, the M Box 2 also predecessor, features the same direct monitoring arrangement as its the M Box 2 allows you to predecessor. As well as being routed to the computer for recording via the A-D converters, the analogue input signals are record analogue and also sent directly to the outputs, and when you're overdubbing, digital inputs at a dial labelled Mix allows you to balance the levels of this the same time. monitor path against the previously recorded material coming back from the computer. By pressing the Mono button you can choose whether to hear the two directly monitored input signals panned hard left and right, or both panned centrally. The former is appropriate when you're recording in stereo, whilst the latter would be more natural when tracking two different mono sources. There is only one headphone socket this time around, on a front-panel quarter-inch jack. There are, however, three welcome improvements compared to the old M Box. The first is the addition of MIDI In and Out sockets on standard five-pin DIN connectors; the original was widely criticised for its lack of MIDI I/O, and although many of those with portable setups are now moving over to USB controller keyboards, its inclusion makes the M Box 2 a more complete recording product. The second addresses one of my major gripes against the original unit. The M Box had a headphone level control but no hardware control over the main output file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/mbox2.htm (2 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:10 PM
Digidesign M Box 2
level, which meant that you couldn't monitor on headphones and mute the main outputs. The M Box 2 has separate level controls for the phones and the main outputs, which is a real boon for those who might want to connect a pair of powered monitors, yet record in the same room. The third improvement is that the M Box 2 is actually a four-in, two-out device, because you can record the two channels of S/PDIF digital input simultaneously with the two analogue input channels. As with the original, however, there's no zero-latency monitoring on the S/PDIF input, which is a shame, and the digital output always mirrors the main analogue output.
Up And Running The M Box 2 ships with version 6.8.1 of Pro Tools LE. The unit itself acts as a dongle for Pro Tools, which won't run without it attached, but an iLok key is also included and used to authorise some of the bundled plug-ins. It's slightly annoying that you need to take up another USB port for the iLok; couldn't the M Box 2 itself have acted as a USB hub? I had a lot of trouble installing Pro Tools, mainly because I already had a different version of the program installed on my machine. LE spotted this and demanded that I use Control Panel's Add/Remove Programs tool to rid my computer of the other version. Once I'd done this, the LE installer got most of the way through its routine before crashing. It seemed that Add/ Buffer sizes between 128 and 2048 samples Remove Programs had not quite are supported. succeeded in eradicating the old version, and it took several hours of head-scratching, calls to Digidesign tech support, blue screens of death and Registry editing to get everything sorted. I say 'sorted', but even after I finally succeeded in installing LE, Windows didn't seem quite itself, sometimes doing strange things to keyboard input and the like. Once I'd got the software installed, however, I was able to get started straight away, and the plug-ins I'd installed in the old version of Pro Tools still seemed to work. Unlike many Firewire audio devices, the M Box 2 appears to be truly hotpluggable, although Windows sometimes took a while to notice that I'd attached it. The new MIDI ports worked as they should do, and with buffer sizes down to 128 samples available, software instruments felt nicely responsive from the keyboard. As on the original, the headphone amp offers plenty of power and a crisp, well-defined sound, whilst the main outputs (on balanced quarter-inch jacks) were also impressively clean.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/mbox2.htm (3 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:10 PM
Digidesign M Box 2
Digidesign say that their new preamp design is the best available in any current buss-powered device, and having tried them out, I won't argue with that claim. The recordings I made with them were uniformly noise-free, detailed and solid. The M Box 2 had no problem phantom-powering two condenser mics simultaneously, and provided a decent amount of gain — I've found in the past that some budget Pro Tools LE is now a mature and wellspecified DAW, although the lack of any gear has trouble with the very low level facility to disable input monitoring can be output by my Rhodes piano, but here annoying when working with the M Box 2. there was power in reserve. I also had no problem recording the full complement of four inputs whilst playing back a stereo output. The limited bandwidth of the USB 1.1 protocol means that sample rates higher than 48kHz are not supported, but you can record and play back at 24-bit. As on the old M Box, the zero-latency monitoring works well enough, but Pro Tools LE still doesn't include an option to disable input monitoring in software. If you're overdubbing to previously recorded tracks while monitoring the input directly, you'll need to mute the track you're recording to, unless you want to hear the directly monitored input signal doubled with the delayed signal returning from Pro Tools. One consequence of this is that there's no way to drop in on existing tracks whilst monitoring with zero latency. Another is that you're constantly having to manually mute and unmute tracks in order to hear what you've recorded, which is a nuisance. Other software packages have handled this perfectly well for years, so it's disappointing that Digidesign still haven't implemented a better system in Pro Tools. If your system allows, of course, you could ignore the direct monitoring option and use a buffer size small enough to deliver an effective latency that's low enough not to be a problem; the minimum 128-sample buffer size equates to a combined record and playback latency of around 6ms at 44.1kHz. On my machine, however, I ran into problems with small buffer sizes whereby Pro Tools would sometimes stop recording or playback and warn me that 'The operating system held off interrupts for too long.' This never caused a crash, but it did cut me off halfway through a good take on occasion. At the default 512-sample buffer size, it happened infrequently; at smaller settings, it happened more often, and when I raised the buffer size to 1024 samples, it disappeared completely. I find it slightly odd that this should be occuring on a relatively new and high-spec Windows laptop, when Pro Tools M-Powered has never complained about running at 128 samples with an M Audio Firewire 1814. While I'm in 'minor gripe' mode, I'll mention that the I/O Setup window behaved a little oddly. I encountered similar problems when I reviewed PT M-Powered; with fewer inputs and outputs here, there is less to go wrong, but I found that it sometimes failed to create both stereo and mono paths for the S/PDIF inputs,
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/mbox2.htm (4 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:10 PM
Digidesign M Box 2
and that pressing the Default button didn't always rectify this. It's easy enough to create them manually, so it's hardly a fatal flaw, but it can lead to some confusion when you try to select an input, only to find that it doesn't show up in the list of available inputs. The M Box 2's alternate faceplates.
As well as the DAE engine used by Pro Tools, Digidesign also supply an ASIO driver for use with other applications. I tried this briefly in Cubase SX, and it appeared to work as expected, offering the same choice of buffer settings as in Pro Tools. If you didn't want to use the Pro Tools software at all, then the M Box 2 probably wouldn't be something you'd consider, as there are much cheaper USB interfaces available, but it's certainly useful to be able to run other applications in conjunction with PT.
Summing Up It's not hard to see why the general reaction to the M Box 2 has been one of surprise. It is so similar to its predecessor that some will doubtless accuse Digidesign of standing still. In their defence, they might say 'It wasn't broken, so we didn't fix it'. If you want Firewire connection and more inputs and outputs, Digi and M Audio already offer a range of alternatives, but the concept of the M Box still meets a demand, and the changes in this version do represent an improvement over the original. These advances are not momentous, and I can't imagine that existing M Box owners will see much point in upgrading to the new model, while those on the tightest budgets can find cheaper products with more features. In the final analysis, though, the M Box 2 still represents an affordable, practical and portable way to buy into the Pro Tools brand, and I expect that plenty of people will continue to do just that. Published in SOS November 2005
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/mbox2.htm (5 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:10 PM
East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs
In this article:
Building A Choir Installation Ooh, Aah Words Under Construction Lessons In Latin In Use Conclusions
East West Symphonic Choirs £500 pros Fabulous audio quality. Different mic positions allow control of the hall ambience, and offer support for surround output. Word Builder is capable of amazing results — with a little effort.
East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs Kompakt Instrument [Mac/PC] Published in SOS November 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Sound/Song Library
Ever fancied arranging 'Oops, I Did It Again' for a full choir? Well now you can, courtesy of Symphonic Choirs, the latest virtual-instrument sample library from East West and Quantum Leap. John Walden
While the sample world seems to be overflowing with quality orchestral Support for Word Builder as libraries, the same is not true for the a plug-in is limited to Cubase, obvious complement to the orchestra — Nuendo and Sonar at present. the choir. Admittedly, choral music is a Requires a well-specified somewhat more specialised genre but, computer (or multiple for film and media composers in computers) for most effective use. particular, the use of choral parts is a common requirement. Way back in summary 1997, Spectrasonics' five-disc Akai/ Symphonic Choirs raises the Emu Symphony of Voices library set bar for the sampled choir. While the Word Builder utility the standard for sampled choral is not perfect, with a little user sounds. It fully deserves its 'classic' effort, the results can be very status and can still be regularly heard in film and TV music. cons
realistic.
information £499.99 including VAT. Arbiter Music Technology +44 (0)208 207 7880. +44 (0)20 8953 4716. Click here to email www.arbitermt.co.uk
Of course, sample technology has moved on considerably since that time, and competing products have subsequently appeared. One of these is Quantum Leap's Voices Of The Apocalypse, a four-disc Gigasampler library that got a fivestar Sample Shop review from Mark Wherry back in October 2002. Again, VOTA has proved a popular library, and it also included one unique feature — the ability to 'build' words from the comprehensive sample set that consists of every consonant and vowel sound for both the male and female choirs.
www.soundsonline.com
Test Spec
Despite being capable of some excellent results, one of the criticisms levelled at VOTA was that the word-building process was rather clunky in operation. QL's new release, produced in collaboration with East West, is Symphonic Choirs,
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/ewsymphonic.htm (1 of 9)10/19/2005 9:41:14 PM
East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs
PC REVIEW SYSTEM 3.2GHz Pentium 4 PC with 2GB of RAM running XP Pro (and SP2), with Echo Mia 24, Egosys Wami Rack 24 and Yamaha SW1000XG soundcards. Steinberg Cubase SX v3.1.0.
and, as well as being the largest choral library currently available (nine DVDROM disks containing over 38 Gigabytes of sample data), it comes with a dedicated application for turning text into sung phrases, the appropriately named Word Builder. This application has been written by Nuno Fonseca, who also developed the word-building utility for VOTA. As with other major releases from East West/Quantum Leap in recent months, Symphonic Choirs is available for both Mac and PC using Native Instrument's Kompakt as the playback front-end. So, providing you are not a member of a professional choir, is Symphonic Choirs a good thing?
Building A Choir The Symphonic Choirs package consists of three elements: NI's Kompakt, the extensive sample library and the Word Builder application. There is little to say about the first of these that hasn't already been covered in SOS. Just as it was when supplied with Colossus and RA, which I looked at in recent issues of SOS, Kompakt is a cut-down version of NI's flagship Kontakt software sampler, and the Symphonic Choirs samples set can only be used with the dedicated version supplied here, or the full version of one of NI's software samplers. It's worth mentioning that you need a DVD drive for the installation, plus of course that slimand-trim 38GB of hard disk space to put the library in. In terms of host computer specification, East West recommend that you own a minimum 3GHz Pentium III or Athlon-based PC running Windows XP, or a 1.8GHz Mac G5 running OS 10.2.6 or later, with a minimum of 2GB of RAM on either platform. The sample library itself can also be divided into three components; a series of Kontakt Multis for each of the five choir sections (Soprano, Alto, Tenor, Bass and Boys), individual Kompakt Instruments for the same five sections and Kompakt Instruments for three soloists (Soprano, Alto and Boy Soprano). In principle, the two sets of individual Instrument Programs are similar to more typical choir-based sample libraries in that they offer various performance combinations including vowel sounds, consonant sounds, vibrato, staccato and a selection of special effects such as whispers, falls and shouts. Many of the Programs include velocity and mod wheel control of the sound for extra expressive options, while the three soloists all have key-switched performance articulations available within their Programs, as you can see from the screenshot at the head of this article, which shows a soloist Program loaded. The blue keys contain the samples, while the brown keys select the key-switched performance articulations. The section Multis really come into play with third element of the overall package,
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/ewsymphonic.htm (2 of 9)10/19/2005 9:41:14 PM
East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs
Word Builder. This sits between the normal MIDI data input (the melody of the line to be sung) and the Kompakt Multi. Each of the special Multis is arranged across five MIDI channels and contains a combination of the vowel and consonant samples. Given the user-specified phrase, Word Builder then splits the MIDI input across the five channels of the Kompakt Multi to sequence the various vowel and consonant sounds together to create the required phrase. As made very clear in both the advertising and documentation for Symphonic Choirs, it is worth noting that Word Builder can only be used with these specially designed Multis. The individual Instrument Programs — both of the choir sections and the soloists — cannot be used with Word Builder. As with the previous Symphonic Orchestra library, Professor Keith O Johnson supervised the recording process for Symphonic Choirs, using the same concert hall and recording arrangements employed for the orchestral library. All the recordings were made at 24-bit resolution using three mic positions. The 'C' (close) mic position reproduces the sound heard when standing directly in front of the singers, while the 'F' (full) position The stand-alone version of Word Builder, represents the sound from the very while similar to the plug-in version, does have the advantage of being resizable (the front of the stage and consequently stand-alone version cannot be resized). contains more of the concert hall's Resizing is particularly useful when you're natural reverberation. Finally, the working with the Time Editor. 'S' (surround) mic position represents the sound at the back of the hall (the manual suggests the front row of the balcony) and therefore contains the full acoustics of the hall. Each Multi and Instrument is therefore provided in three versions. This approach to the recordings provides three obvious advantages to the user. First, the output from the different mic positions can be used control the degree of ambience, either by using a particular mic position or by blending them as required. Second, output from the different mic positions might be used to create a surround sound mix — and this clearly has applications in a film music context. Third, with both having been recorded by the same team, in the same concert hall and using the same microphone configuration, blending the sounds of Symphonic Choirs with Symphonic Orchestra ought to produce a very coherent mix.
Installation After I'd made some sandwiches and poured myself a stiff drink or two, installation of Symphonic Choirs proceeded without any problems on my test
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/ewsymphonic.htm (3 of 9)10/19/2005 9:41:14 PM
East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs
system — although given its size, it did proceed for quite some time! Registration of the Kompakt front-end involves a quick visit to the NI web site, but is painless enough. As with other Kompakt-based instruments reviewed recently in SOS, Symphonic Choirs is provided in all the common plug-in formats for both Mac and PC and as a stand-alone application. Word Builder is installed separately and is also available as a plug-in and a standalone application. However, the plug-in formats for Word Builder are VST-MA (Module Architecture, supported by Cubase and Nuendo from v2 upwards on PC and Mac) and MFX, for use with Sonar 4 under Windows XP. The implication is that users of other sequencers will, at present, need to use the stand-alone version of Word Builder (above).
Ooh, Aah While the potential star of the Symphonic Choirs show is the combination of Word Builder and the section Multis, the various Instrument Programs are also worthy of comment. In short, if you do need just some pad-like 'aahs', 'oohs' or 'mmms', then Symphonic Choirs is more than up to the task. For each of the four adult choir sections, individual Instruments are available for eight vowel-based sounds and 15 consonant based-sounds. These Instruments feature dynamic crossfading (changing the character of the sound) and four key-switched articulation options (normal, legato, staccato and slurred/sliding). The Instruments for the Boys section differ slightly, in that the vowel sounds only include two key-switched attacks; normal and legato — but in other respects they are the same as the adult sections. A small number of 'effects' Programs are also included for each section with performances such as unpitched whispered words, evolving vowels, slides, shouts and falls. Slightly fewer options are provided for the Boys section. In addition, four 'Full Chorus Church' Instruments — Three instances of Word Builder with provided in just the 'S' mic position — are the same phrase in English, Phonetics also provided. These are all based on and Votox formats — translation is done vowel sounds and include mod wheel automatically. control over vibrato depth. While they do not offer the detailed control of working with the individual sections, these single Instruments are excellent for a quick mock-ups or situations where you need a simple background choral 'wash'. Individual Kompakt Instruments are also provided for three soloists. Individual Instruments are provided for each of the Soprano, Alto and Boy soloists and each features a number of key-switches to control the syllable being sung and the style of the singing. These mainly feature vowel sounds sung with nonvibrato, vibrato, slur and other expressive options. The Boy soloist also features file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/ewsymphonic.htm (4 of 9)10/19/2005 9:41:14 PM
East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs
random Latin syllables and these could easily be strung together to construct a mock (or genuine!) Latin phrase. For convenience, the final element for each of the soloists is a pre-configured '5.1' Multi consisting of the 'C', 'F' and 'S' mic positions and ready for use in a surround configuration. While experimenting with these various component Programs I was, without exception, impressed by the quality of the sound. The sections are very full sounding and, when combining them to form a full Soprano, Alto, Tenor and Bass ('SATB') chorus, the results were The Learn function allows Word Builder to extremely good. The contrast between match the sung phrase to the timing of a the three mic positions is both obvious MIDI phrase. and useful. The 'C' position is very much 'in your face' and would be ideal if you wished to apply your own reverb. The 'F' positions have noticeably more ambience but are still very clear. As a result, I found myself starting with these versions before blending in either a little of the 'C' or 'S' sound as required. In contrast, the 'S' versions sound very lush and warm, and are extremely effective for constructing choral pads. Interestingly, no Tenor or Bass soloists are provided. The manual suggests that this is because these solo voices rarely appear in film scores. I don't think this is a major omission by any means, but it does reveal who East West have in mind as the potential purchasers of Symphonic Choirs. My only other comment would be that, compared to Spectrasonics' Symphony Of Voices, the palette of Symphonic Choirs is somewhat less diverse — there are no Gregorian chants, for example. Without doubt, though, the advances in sampling technology mean that Symphonic Choirs is putting the most impressive sampled choir sounds currently available into the hands of composers — even before we consider the potential of Word Builder...
Words Under Construction The most intriguing elements of Symphonic Choirs are Word Builder and the special Multis designed to work with it. The application interface uses the same styling as Kompakt. The Voice section has slight differences between the standalone and plug-in versions; in the former, the MIDI In/Out options can be set in this section, while both versions include useful MIDI connector icons that blink to indicate MIDI activity. In the plug-in version, though, because Word Builder is placed as an Insert within a MIDI track, the MIDI in/out routings are set within the host sequencer. The Type setting specifies the type of choral section to which this instance of Word Builder is connected, and this needs to match the type of Multi loaded in Kompakt. The phrase to be sung is entered in the Text Editor. This can be entered in file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/ewsymphonic.htm (5 of 9)10/19/2005 9:41:14 PM
East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs
standard English, Phonetics or Votox, a phonetic alphabet created specifically to work with Word Builder. East West recommend that regular users get to grips with it as, once mastered, it allegedly provides more precise control over pronunciation of words. Usefully, Word Builder includes a 100,000-word dictionary and can convert between the various formats. Using one of the phonetic alphabets, Latin phrases also seem to work fine — although if your Latin is a little rusty, see the 'Lessons in Latin' box on the right for some inspiration. The section that requires the most head scratching (initially, at least) is the Time Editor The options in the Letter dialogue (the lower right section in the screen below). box offer you detailed access to When a phrase is first entered, each syllable is each syllable within a word to allocated a certain default time length and these improve pronunciation. are displayed within the Time Editor for the selected word. Syllable lengths are not allocated in an arbitrary fashion; consonants are generally short, while vowels have longer sustains as would be the case for a real singer. By default, each word within the phrase is triggered by a single MIDI note (or chord) although, as described below, this behaviour can be changed. However, it is also worth noting that some syllables (which are triggered by the MIDI note off event) are only sung after the 'off' position on the time line. Therefore, to avoid the Program starting a new word before finishing the previous one, it is useful to leave a gap between the MIDI notes that trigger consecutive words. The default syllable lengths assigned in the Time Editor can be adjusted by dragging the coloured bars. Syllables can be overlapped; this creates a fade and is useful for smoothing out the pronunciation of certain words. However, in most cases, users will want the tempo of the sung phrase to be controlled by a sequence of MIDI notes. It is here that the Learn button (shown on the previous page) comes into play. This function allows Word Builder to learn the timing and length of each MIDI note within a phrase (either played via a MIDI keyboard or from a sequencer track) and to then adjust the lengths of the syllables within each word to match. On the whole, this works well enough but, for all but the most simple of phrases, I still found some minor manual editing was required to make the pronunciation clearer. Further phrase tweaking is possible in the Letter dialogue box (above), which allows the attack type and relative velocity of each syllable to be adjusted. Again, this can be useful for adding clarity to the pronunciation or to add emphasis to particular syllables within a sung phrase — although volume swells are probably more easily added via MIDI continuous controller #11 (Expression).
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/ewsymphonic.htm (6 of 9)10/19/2005 9:41:14 PM
East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs
Lessons In Latin While it is difficult to resist getting Word Builder to conjure a selection of common expletives from the Symphonic Choirs Boys section, once this novelty has worn off, Latin phrases can still be good fun for scaring elderly relatives or small children. If, like me, your Latin is not so hot, you might want to check out this link, which was posted by a user on the East West forums: www.yuni.com/library/latin. html. This includes a huge list of short Latin phrases with English translations and, as well as the religious examples such as 'Agnus Dei' (Lamb of God) or 'Sanctum Sanctorum' (the holy of holies) there are also some classic one-liners. I can't vouch for the accuracy of the translations provided, but particular favourites of mine are 'Sane ego te vocavi. Forsitan capedictum tuum desit' ('I did call. Maybe your answering machine is broken') and 'Suntne vacci laeti?' ('Are your cows happy?') but there are countless others.
In Use Currently, the Word Builder plug-in only functions with Cubase, Nuendo or Sonar. Users of other sequencers will need to work with the stand-alone version. This has the same functionality, but is perhaps a touch more fiddly to set up, as it involves using a MIDI loopback connection of some sort. Fortunately, this configuration is described quite clearly within the documentation and on the East West web site. I did most of my own testing using the VST-MA plug-in via Cubase SX v3.1, and both Kompakt and Word Builder behaved 'as advertised'. I did, however, experiment with the stand-alone version too, and had no problems getting Word Builder to talk to Kompakt via a MIDI loopback utility. In use, one or two aspects of Word Builder are a little quirky. For example, in Cubase, key commands have to be disabled in order to type text into the Word Builder Text Editor — regular key command users will find this a bit irritating. A second oddity was the 'Hold Syllable On' function. This allows a MIDI controller to be assigned to enable a sung word to be held over several MIDI notes, effectively The use of multiple vowel sounds — as in stretching the word over a melodic the 'EE' sound used here — was a decent phrase. I could not make this function work-around when I couldn't get the 'Hold work under SX and, having searched Syllable On' function (shown at the top of the the East West on-line forums, it seems next page) to work under Cubase SX! that one or two other SX users have reported the same behaviour. However, the same forums produced a usable work-around. As it is usually a vowel sound that would be sung in this fashion, the vowel can simply be file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/ewsymphonic.htm (7 of 9)10/19/2005 9:41:14 PM
East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs
repeated as a separate word within the Text Editor for each note in the melody. Presumably East West and Quantum Leap will be working on these sorts of issues for an update to Word Builder. Two other practical aspects are worth mentioning. First, each instance of Word Builder can hold only a single phrase. A separate MIDI track, each with an instance of Word Builder is therefore required for each phrase. These can, of course, all be routed to the same instance of Kompakt so, for example, the phrases to be sung by the Tenor section only require a single instance of Kompakt to be available. Second, and perhaps more significantly, in order to use Word Builder with a full 'SATB' choir, four instances of Kompakt would need to be run, each with a suitable Multi loaded. By choosing the 'lightest' of the Multis (based on the 'C' mic position and with fewer velocity or key-switched layers), I was able to work quite happily on my test system, but attempting the same with some of the more expressive Multis soon The 'Hold Syllable On' option allows a generated 'memory low' messages. syllable to be held over several MIDI notes, While the 'track freeze' options within but I couldn't get this to function under Cubase SX. However, I found a work-around SX provide a suitable work-around, (see below left). professional composers using Word Builder and Symphonic Choirs on a regular basis would probably wish to follow the advice given in the printed manual — use a very well-specified machine or spread the workload across multiple computers. All this said, the combination of Word Builder and Symphonic Choirs is capable of some truly remarkable results. Is Word Builder perfect? No, it is not — it does take some time to learn how to use it and, even with experience, some manual tweaking of pronunciations and phrasing is required to add a sense of 'life' to a part. However, a useful comparison here is with Yamaha's Vocaloid (reviewed back in the March and December 2004 issues of SOS). While Vocaloid is also capable of amazing results, crafting an entire solo lead vocal is a major undertaking. With Symphonic Choirs, the task is less daunting, as the very nature of a choral performance makes the absolute clarity of the diction less critical. As a result, obtaining convincing results from Word Builder and Symphonic Choirs requires much less effort on behalf of the user, and I could imagine experienced users soon learning to make fairly light work of individual phrases.
Conclusions
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/ewsymphonic.htm (8 of 9)10/19/2005 9:41:14 PM
East West Quantum Leap Symphonic Choirs
Symphonic Choirs takes the 'virtual' choir to a new level. The sound quality of the sample library is simply magnificent; these sounds would add class to any musical production. Word Builder is both remarkable in its conception and fun to experiment with — but it can also be frustrating to the new user, so go in with your eyes open and, expect to invest some time, at least initially. I hope East West have the energy and resources to keep developing the potential of Word Builder, and I'm sure suggestions from users will provide useful input to this process. I can see this library appealing to hobbyist, educational and professional markets, although the two former groups ought to heed East West's recommendations about the need for a high-end system in order to keep the work-flow efficient. However, as film and TV music budgets are nearly always tight, Symphonic Choirs is undoubtedly going to be a solution that many a media composer will turn to. In that context, it is most certainly worth the asking price, and the computer resources required to get the most out of it are unlikely to be a major concern. As with East West's recent world and ethnic instrument library, Ra, I think you can expect to hear Symphonic Choirs coming to a film score near you soon. Highly recommended! Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/ewsymphonic.htm (9 of 9)10/19/2005 9:41:14 PM
Kawai MP8
In this article:
Beauty & The Beast Features & Sounds Sound Comparisons Multitimbre Modes The AWA Grand Pro Keyboard Sound & Setup Modes XLR Outputs Conclusion Brief Model Comparison Chart
Kawai MP8 £1999 pros Arguably the best-sounding digital stage piano on the market. A wide range of additional sounds. 192-note polyphony. High-quality weighted keyboard action.
cons Weight of keyboard action takes some acclimatisation. Needs two people to lift it — worth remembering if you do plan to use it live... Master Volume slider bypassed when using XLR outputs. Significant timing latency when played via MIDI — although on a keyboard designed for live playing, this may not bother potential users much.
summary The Kawai MP range goes from strength to strength, with more of everything. The great piano sounds the company has become known for are enhanced by 192-note polyphony, 256 userprogrammable Setups, a wide range of supplementary
Kawai MP8 Digital Stage Piano Published in SOS November 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Keyboard
Kawai's last few digital pianos have been finely wrought things of beauty: solidly built keyboards with an amazingly realistic playing action and beautifully sampled piano timbres. But their latest claims to surpass all of those. Can it possibly be true? Nick Magnus
The MP8 is the latest flagship addition to Kawai's acclaimed MP range of digital stage pianos, following on from the excellent MP9000 (reviewed in SOS January 2000 — read the review at www.soundonsound.com/sos/jan00/ articles/kawai.htm) and the MP9500 (SOS January 2003 — or see www. soundonsound.com/sos/feb03/articles/ kawaimp9500.asp).
Photos:Mike Cameron
Fans of the MP9000 proclaimed it to be 'near-perfect' — not least because of its superior AWA Grand weighted keyboard action. It also sounded rather splendid. The MP9500 received yet more accolades for its improved AWA Grand Pro action, and introduced a more flexible Setup mode, allowing up to four internal/ external sounds to be layered together, as opposed to the MP9000's two internal and two external layers. The MP8 brings yet more to the table — in short, the design philosophy is 'more of everything'.
Beauty & The Beast The MP8's new black livery and dark wooden end cheeks are striking and
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/kawaimp8.htm (1 of 8)10/19/2005 9:41:18 PM
Kawai MP8
sounds and Kawai's top-ofthe-range AWA Grand Pro 88note keyboard action. Try it, and then try to resist it!
information £1999 including VAT. Kawai UK +44 (0)1480 474751. +44 (0)1480 474752. Click here to email www.kawaiuk.com
sensual, lending the instrument a sense of gravitas befitting a quality grand piano. The basic layout and appearance of the panel remains largely unchanged from previous models apart from some additional buttons at the right-hand end, and four red and four green LEDs accompanying the four sliders on the left — more on which later. The remaining front-panel controls, EQ and Effects sections have been carried through from the MP9000 and MP95000 — a detailed description of these can be found in that January 2000 MP9000 review. Rear-panel connections (see the final page of this review) are also much as before, with two differences. Firstly, the headphone socket is gone, having been relocated to the front (left) of the instrument. This is sure to please everybody who has ever complained about rear-mounted headphone sockets — myself included! Secondly, keeping in vogue with the current trend, a USB connector is provided. No specific editing software is bundled with the MP8, so in this case USB is provided simply as an alternative to using conventional MIDI connections. Windows XP and Mac OS X both include generic USB device drivers — Windows 2000/98SE users will need a suitable driver, which can be downloaded from www.kawai.co.jp/english/Download1.html. USB is not supported for Mac 9. xx, so a standard MIDI interface will be needed.
Features & Sounds Kawai have not just doubled, but tripled the polyphony previously offered on the MP9000 and MP9500. The MP8 can play a whopping 192 notes, allowing for the most pedal-heavy, cadenza-laden performances to be reproduced without missing a note. This is clearly of benefit when playing layered sounds — even with all four layers addressing internal sounds, a respectable 48 notes of polyphony is always available. The MP8 provides a sizeable set of 256 sounds, laid out in eight sound categories — Piano, Electric piano, Drawbar, Organ, Strings/Vocal, Brass/ Wind, Pad/Synth and Bass/Guitar. Each category has eight principal variations, and each of those variations has a further four sub-variations, accessed via the four new A,B,C & D buttons below the two rows of eight preset buttons.
The main volume slider, zone level faders, keyboard zoning controls, and four rotary controls at the left end of the MP8. The latter controls can be used to adjust effects, EQ, sound envelope parameters, or to send MIDI controller data, as on the original MP9000.
The acoustic piano sounds are as good — if not even better — than those on the previous MP models. Kawai's Harmonic Imaging system works extremely well, providing almost seamless dynamic variation and a consistent (although in places not perfect) tonal balance across the keyboard. file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/kawaimp8.htm (2 of 8)10/19/2005 9:41:18 PM
Kawai MP8
The slightly plummy 'Concert Grand 2' and the Elton John-flavoured 'Studio Grand 2' get my vote as personal favourites, but all the variations are eminently useable, and are designed to suit a wide range of musical styles. The samples all sound as if they have been recorded using close-miking techniques — the tone is highly detailed, more so than if the microphones had been placed at a greater distance. This may not be to everyone's taste, and as such the MP8 arguably lends itself (in a DI'd recording situation) more to modern music styles. Of course, if you were giving a classical recital using the MP8 in a hall, the audience would provide its own distance! To further improve realism, there are two new additions to the pianos' edit parameters — String Resonance and Damper Effect. These give independent control over the reverberant 'thump' heard when notes are played with the sustain pedal down (Damper Effect) and the amount of sympathetic overtones created by other strings in a specific note's harmonic series (String Resonance). Both can be turned off if they prove distracting, which can be the case in headphones, but it seems less of a problem on speakers. These parameters replace the MP9000 and MP9500's Sympathetic Resonance, which on those instruments was provided as an EFX effect. There are also plenty of new and varied patches to be found, such as Steel Drums, Nylon Guitar, Scat Vocals, Bassoon, Pan Flute, Banjo and Pedal Steel to name just a few, and there are even four basic Drum kits lurking at the end of the Bass/Guitar category. Sonic highlights include the Rhodes soundalikes, which are fun to play and would certainly pass muster on stage or in the studio. The '60s E-Piano' is a tad too bright and 'clipped' to be a convincing Wurlitzer, but could easily pass as a Hohner Pianet N (think The Zombies 'She's Not There'). The FM-style electric pianos are pleasingly nostalgic, creating a suitably convincing 'LA' feel when layered with the acoustic pianos. Other sounds are less authentic (the woodwinds instantly bring to mind Roland's SH2000 synth, and the Clavinets come across as disappointingly 'fake' and synthetic) but this is offset by a number of very useable Drawbar Organs (featuring the Rotary EFX) and some rather comely String textures.
Sound Comparisons As mentioned elsewhere in this review, the MP8's piano sounds compare favourably with some of the high-octane software pianos on the market. Out of interest, I did a direct comparison with two pianos that I hold in high regard — the Roland SRX11 Complete Piano expansion board installed in my XV5080 (a version of which apparently graces Roland's new RD700SX), and Vintaudio's Yamaha C7 (close-miked version) running under NI Kontakt 2. The Vintaudio C7, incidentally, uses 4GB of samples, comprising six velocity layers with pedal up, down and release layers. The SRX11 has no pedal down or release layer, but all 88 notes have been sampled across four velocity layers. The MP8 appears to have been sampled at every fourth semitone, and has a release layer but no pedal down layer (although it does have the Damper Effect and String Resonance to compensate). The number of velocity layers on the MP8 is harder to determine — clearly Kawai's Harmonic Imaging method is very effective! I chose three existing projects to run in Sonar, each of which was piano-driven but with the emphasis varying between rock and orchestral. The results were very file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/kawaimp8.htm (3 of 8)10/19/2005 9:41:18 PM
Kawai MP8
illuminating — all three pianos acquitted themselves admirably. However, what did become clear is that there is no such thing as the universally 'perfect' piano sound. Where one piano suited a certain piece, it sat less comfortably in another. The MP8 is arguably the most versatile of the three, having more tonal variations to choose from — however, within classical/orchestral passages the SRX11 was the most effective, possibly due to the fact that its samples are not as close miked as the MP8 or C7, hence it sounded more natural in a classical context. Both the MP8 and SRX11 responded in a very consistent and musical manner to the prerecorded performances' key velocities, whilst the C7 tended to over-react slightly at lower velocities. On a slightly less glowing note, I noticed the MP8 was prone to some MIDI timing discrepancies, which were especially noticeable when playing back a quantised piano sequence alongside other quantised (zero-latency) software instruments. The discrepancies varied from negligible to delays of anything up to 20ms, which may not sound like much but is distinctly audible, particularly within a simple arrangement. As these 'latencies' are not consistent, they cannot be compensated for by simply shifting the part (or recorded audio) forward in time — that just makes certain notes occur early rather than late. Something is clearly awry here, but admittedly, it's less of a problem on this keyboard, which is clearly designed to be played rather than triggered, than on, say, a multitimbral synth module. In these days of excellent software-based piano instruments and affordable (and much more compact) rack units, I can't believe there will be many people, or indeed anyone, who would buy the MP8 solely as a sound source for triggering over MIDI, so the problem, whilst certainly extant, is arguably limited by the MP8's very nature. Nevertheless, if they can, it would be good if Kawai could do something about this!
Multitimbre Modes Like the MP9000 and MP9500 before it, the MP8 can also function as a 16-part multitimbral instrument. The manual is extremely reticent about this, stating that you can do it but omitting to explain the procedure — which is bound to cause great frustration to MIDI technology novices! The procedure is actually straightforward, and of course requires the participation of a MIDI sequencer. Firstly, the MP8 must be set to Multitimbre mode in the System menu. Two such modes are offered, the difference being how the MP8 interprets MIDI program change commands. Mode 1 The display's a bit of an '80s throwback responds to bank and program changes by in terms of its size, but then there isn't number according to the list set out in the too much that needs to be accessed or viewed with it, so it's not too much of a MP8's manual. Mode 2 responds to problem. program and bank changes by name according to the GM standard — so if your sequencer is configured so that you can specify 'acoustic bass' as the sound you want, the relevant MP8 channel will select the nearest equivalent sound. Since
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/kawaimp8.htm (4 of 8)10/19/2005 9:41:18 PM
Kawai MP8
the sounds for individual channels cannot be directly assigned from the MP8 panel, sending program change messages is the only means to select the parts' sounds. There are compromises to using Multitimbre mode — for example, the only effects available to each part are Reverb and Chorus. Unless I'm missing some glaringly 'obvious' hidden parameters, the other EFX effects appear not to function at all — and again, the manual makes no reference to this. As a result, the Drawbar presets (which normally use the EFX Rotary effect by default) don't sound as they should in this mode. This is curious, as the older MP9000 allowed EFX to be used on parts 1&2. Multitimbre mode also caused some strange things to happen when using the USB connection. My sequencer (Sonar 4) took a worryingly long time to start up, Sound/Setup selection was erratic (with buttons refusing to respond), and I lost USB input several times while in this mode, although the MP8 happily played back recorded data. None of these problems occurred using standard MIDI connections.
The AWA Grand Pro Keyboard First seen on the MP9500, the AWA Grand Pro keyboard constitutes Kawai's attempt to replicate the touch and feel of the company's own Concert Grand EX acoustic piano. The result is a fairly heavy action which will certainly delight some players, whilst conversely being initially quite hard work for those used to a lighter action. My initial impression was that it is distinctly heavier than many acoustic pianos I've played, but after a few hours of playing, you soon get used to the extra muscle power it demands. You also begin to appreciate the enhanced sense of dynamic control this keyboard brings — especially at the lower end of the velocity range. To help players adapt to the feel of the keyboard, the MP8 provides five preset velocity curves — the normal default 'linear' response plus 'light', 'light+', 'heavy' and 'heavy+' choices. Most people will probably be happy with the normal setting — however, if none of these curves feel comfortable, the MP8 very obligingly offers two user-definable curves. To define a User curve, simply play the keyboard in a manner that feels natural to you (the manual suggests turning the volume off so you won't be distracted by what you hear). When you've finished playing, the MP8 analyses your touch and scales the velocity response to match the gentlest and hardest notes you played. This seems to work quite well — the resulting curve feels quite comfortable to play, although you may subsequently find yourself tempted to redefine the curve according to each piece of music you're playing! One small criticism concerning the manufacturing finish is that the top corners of the keys (on the review model, at least) are rather sharp — so if you're planning on doing sweeping Hammond glissandi, make sure you have a first-aid kit to hand!
Sound & Setup Modes file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/kawaimp8.htm (5 of 8)10/19/2005 9:41:18 PM
Kawai MP8
On the MP9000 they were called Sound and Setup mode. In MP9500 parlance they were referred to as Single and Multi mode. Now the MP8 has reverted to calling them Sound and Setup... so how do these modes operate on the MP8? Basically, Sound mode provides access to 256 preset tones, arranged by category as described previously. Setup mode provides 256 user memories in which to store all your edited sounds and master-keyboard configurations. When first powered up, the MP8 presents itself in Sound mode; any of the 256 Presets selected in this initial state will call up a single sound. However, although the primary function of this mode is to select single sounds, its secondary function is to serve as your editing palette. From here, you can activate any or all of the four zones, select sounds for each zone, edit those sounds, apply effects, set zone key ranges, and so on. So rather than merely being an operational state Patch-selection and management controls from which you select single preset are to the right of the MP8's top panel, sounds, Sound mode is also a creative including the buttons for switching between starting point — a single preset 'Setup' Sound and Setup mode. in itself wherein all the MP8's parameters are freely editable. For example, you could make zones 1 to 4 active, layering four different internal sounds together, while zones 2 and 3 simultaneously transmit data to external MIDI devices on different channels, and the MP8 will remain in this state until you either change something or power off the MP8. Once you have created the sound and master keyboard configuration you want, you simply save it to any of the 256 Setup memory locations for later recall. If you wish to quickly return Sound mode to its original 'single sound' state, simply press the first two 'number 1' preset buttons simultaneously (marked 'Piano Only) and you're back to scratch. To make it easier to identify which zones are addressing internal sounds, external devices or both of these, each zone fader is now accompanied by a pair of status LEDs. If the red LED is lit, that zone is assigned to an internal sound. If the green LED is on, the zone is transmitting data from the MIDI output. If both LEDs are on, then that zone is assigned to an internal sound and the MIDI output. The large zone on/off LEDs below the faders normally glow red when a zone is active — however, if a zone has been set to less than the full 1-127 key range, it will glow green to indicate that zone operates over a restricted key range.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/kawaimp8.htm (6 of 8)10/19/2005 9:41:18 PM
Kawai MP8
XLR Outputs One further (but not visible) rearpanel change is to the XLR outputs; on previous models, these outputs rather perversely bypassed the Master Volume and internal EQ. On the MP8, the EQ settings do affect the XLR outputs, although the There are a couple of changes from the Master Volume slider remains MP9500's rear panel — firstly, the bypassed as before. This latter point headphone socket has sensibly been moved to the front, and MIDI interfacing is is less of a problem when playing now possible via the new USB port on the single sounds (you can simply raise right. Otherwise, the connectors — stereo or lower that sound's Zone fader), out on jacks and XLRs, five-pin MIDI trio, but becomes rather inconvenient expression pedal and footswitch jacks, when playing layered Setups, where and socket to attach the damper and soft the balance between the layers is pedal — are unchanged. critical — there is no single fader to control the level of the total sound. Admittedly, you can go into Edit mode and change the Setup's Master Volume setting there, but this wouldn't be an ideal solution if you needed to change level on stage in a hurry. Alternatively you could connect an expression pedal and use that to alter the volume, but I suspect most people would rather opt for the standard jack outputs so they can use the front-panel fader!
Conclusion The MP8 is a fine instrument, comparable with the better Giga-sized software pianos out there. In fact I'd wager that if you sat the MP8 next to a computer and told people they were playing some top-flight software piano from the Kawai's keyboard, most would accept it without question. Which leads me to wonder whether Kawai's next step might be to develop a truly comprehensive, gigabytesized piano sample set that would rival or improve upon the best of the software pianos. High-capacity 1GB and 2GB flash RAM cards are commonly available now that don't cost the earth — so why not take advantage of today's inexpensive memory technology and use it inside a stage piano? As a master keyboard, the MP8 may not offer the same level of control as the current crop of dedicated, purpose-built units — but it certainly provides more than you'd expect from your average digital piano. There's no arguing the quality of the MP8's keyboard, which lends a great deal of pleasure to playing those great piano sounds. Whether you feel the keyboard action is appropriate for all your playing tasks is very much an individual choice — I personally found the MP8's action slightly heavy for general non-piano applications. Rather like trying to trim your fingernails with garden shears, it's not necessarily the right tool for every job, leading me to prefer my trusty semi-weighted synth-action keyboard for tackling most non-piano parts.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/kawaimp8.htm (7 of 8)10/19/2005 9:41:18 PM
Kawai MP8
If the MP8 contained only the piano sounds, it would be a fantastic instrument. As it is, the wide range of additional sounds should prove a welcome bonus for players who major in piano but need a little extra firepower, especially in a live context. Anyone who has previously considered investing in one of Kawai's MP pianos should now be especially attracted by the huge polyphony of the MP8, and for those looking to incorporate it into a The F20 sustain and soft pedal unit supplied with the MP8. live MIDI rig, those 256 programmable Setup configurations make it an even more attractive proposition. Find one, play it, and try not to want it.
Brief Model Comparison Chart MP9000
MP9500
MP8
PRESET SOUNDS
16
64
256
SETUPS
64
64
256
POLYPHONY
32
64
192
KEYBOARD ACTION
Enhanced AWA Grand action
AWA Grand Pro action
AWA Grand Pro action
VOLUME/EQ TO XLR OUTS
No
No
EQ only
WEIGHT
34kg
32kg
32kg
HEADPHONE SOCKET
Rear-mounted
Rear-mounted
Front-mounted
Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/kawaimp8.htm (8 of 8)10/19/2005 9:41:18 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
In this article:
OASYS I & II Bringing OASYS To The Market OASYS III OASYS — Or POCKY? The Open Synthesizer? Big Screens, Little Screens HD1 EXs2 — Piano Lessens And The Sound? Next Month...
information OASYS88, £5399; OASYS76, £5149. Prices include VAT. Korg UK Brochure Line +44 (0)1908 857150. +44 (0)1908 857199. Click here to email www.korg.co.uk
Korg OASYS: Part 1 Workstation Synth Published in SOS November 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Keyboard workstation
For over 15 years, Korg have produced the world's most successful workstation synths, and the OASYS is their new £5400 flagship, their attempt to take the concept to the next level. In the first instalment of this two-part review, we assess how they've fared... Gordon Reid
Tens of thousands...nay, hundreds of thousands of words have already been written about the OASYS, over 2000 of them in this magazine (see the preview in March's SOS at www.soundonsound.com/sos/ mar05/articles/ korgoasys.htm). Quite apart from Korg's humongous brochure, the Web offers numerous discussions, videos, and a host of support services that tell you everything you need to know about it. Except that they don't. You know that OASYS is expensive, has three modes of synthesis, is a powerful sampler, incorporates wave Photos: Richard Ecclestone sequencing and KARMA, has a big sequencer, built-in effects, and offers audio recording to make it as close to an all-in-one production system as is currently possible. But even if you know all that, do you know what it feels like to use one? Let me answer that: if you haven't used one, you don't. So, over the next two months, I'm going to try to tell you what it's like to program and make music on the OASYS88. What I'm not going to do, however, is tell you everything about it. Why? Because the manuals are well over two inches thick, that's why. If four issues of Sound On Sound are piled on each other, they're still not as thick as the OASYS's parameter guide! And do you know what...? These
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (1 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
huge tomes still don't tell you what it's like to use an OASYS! But now I'm getting ahead of myself. Let's take a step back and begin, as all good stories should, at the beginning...
OASYS I & II Back in June 1995, Korg asked me whether I would be willing to exhibit some vintage keyboards at an event they were planning to hold in the Science Museum in Kensington, London. They wanted to demonstrate the progress they had made since their earliest days, so I took a Minikorg 700, a Trident, a Polysix, and a PS3200, and sat back to enjoy whatever it was that the company had lined up for the evening. Soon, I wasn't leaning back, but leaning forward, intent on gleaning everything that I could from the presentation. The event was, of course, the dual launch of the Trinity and Prophecy, and it was riveting. But dramatic though the launches were, the presenter, Korg's Steve McNally, kept referring to two mythical products that appeared simultaneously to predate and supersede the Trinity and the Prophecy. Both had been developed at Korg R&D in California. The first, called Synth Kit, was a software environment within which the physical models in the Prophecy had been developed. Based on a Mac computer with additional DSP hardware, it was perhaps the first system capable of crunching the numbers needed to perform physical modelling in real-time. The other was a keyboard designed using Synth Kit, intended for thee and me, and which was mooted to cost £10,000. This huge sum of money was justified by the instrument's ability to run several synthesis engines simultaneously. There was even an example of it on show. It was big, it was blue, it was called OASYS, (the Open Architecture SYnthesis System) and it looked the business. But we couldn't touch it, we couldn't play it, and we most certainly couldn't hear it. The OASYS concept was an appealing one and, in 1995, quite radical. To quote Mr McNally, whom I subsequently interviewed, "OASYS is basically a computer, rather than a hardwired keyboard synthesizer. If you want to change how it works you can load a completely different synthesis system from a hard drive. It's multitimbral as well as polyphonic, and can also be multitimbral in the sense that different types of synthesis can be positioned under different areas of the keyboard. For example, you can have a single patch which, when you play softly at the top of the keyboard, gives you an FM sound layered with an analogue sound, but gives you a physical model of a file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (2 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
saxophone when you play a little bit harder, and a PCM sample of a pipe organ when you bring in the ribbon controller... It's all completely controllable." Umm... no, it wasn't. The 'Blue Bomber' (as it was later called within Korg) never appeared. The reason was that it didn't work. Apart from a few limited demos, it had never worked, and it was never going to work. The technology available in 1995 simply wasn't up to the task. Four years later, the second incarnation of the OASYS appeared. The OASYS PCI card incorporated many of the ideas that had formed the bedrock of the OASYS ideal. It boasted a 12-channel mixer at the centre of the system, and this provided access to some superb physically modelled synth engines, more than 100 excellent effects, a PCM-based synthesis engine with multisample loading and manipulation, audio streaming from hard disk, 32 MIDI channels of control, plus 24-bit audio I/O. The difference was that, whereas the original OASYS had been planned as a synthesizer with a computer inside, the OASYS PCI was a synth on a card designed to go inside a computer. In some ways, OASYS PCI was a triumph. Its synthesis was superb and, when Korg released it, they announced that Synth Kit itself would soon be made available, thus allowing users to design their own models. Unfortunately, it had a fatal flaw. When used to the full, the polyphony dropped to as few as four or even three notes. So, while OASYS PCI was very close to McNally's description of the mythical OASYS keyboard, you couldn't do anything useful with it. Furthermore, while Synth Kit eventually appeared, the anticipated slew of third-party synth models and effects algorithms did not. OASYS PCI was not a success, and it passed through the world causing barely a ripple on the consciousness of music makers anywhere. But the promise of 1995 seems finally came to have come to fruition with the appearance of the third product to bear the OASYS name, the Open Architecture Synthesis Studio. The first production OASYS (serial number 000001) is in my studio as I type this, and it's the unit you can see in these pictures. As you can see, it's beautiful.
Bringing OASYS To The Market Korg faced a dilemma when developing the OASYS. Unlike previous workstations, whose capabilities and limitations are decided when their various VLSI chips are fabricated, Korg have stated that the OASYS specification is a work-in-progress, limited only by programming and marketing decisions. You want some more of this? Sure. Some more of that? No problem. This has led to an enormous wish list that encompasses the sound engines, effects, sequencing and recording capabilities. Korg couldn't incorporate every idea in the first release version of the OASYS's operating system, so they had to decide what was a priority, and what could be the subject of later upgrades. In the end, they decided that sound generation, sound quality, and the KARMA engine were the most important aspects of OASYS, so they concentrated on finishing the three synth engines that it boasts today. file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (3 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
However, that's not to say that other aspects of the OASYS, such as the sequencer and recorder, are unfinished. I've had access to them for two months, and can attest that they are fully functional, and seem robust in operation. However, I think it's safe to say that we will see a great deal of development in these areas over the coming months.
OASYS III Every once in a while a keyboard appears that captures your imagination even before you start to play it — the ARP Quadra, the Roland Jupiter 8, and the Yamaha GX1 all spring to mind — and the OASYS is one of these. But unlike the colourful Quadra and Jupe, and the physically imposing Yamaha, the OASYS is slightly understated. When you sit in front of it, it says, "Yes, I'm bloody impressive, but in an unassuming sort of way. If you're a serious musician, I'm exactly what you need." Touching the OASYS confirms what your eyes are telling you. Take the keyboard as an example. Korg has pursued a policy for nearly two decades of building two families of synthesizers based on any given technology: a flagship line that incorporates expensive keyboards, and a more affordable line with low-cost keyboards. It's clear which one they've used in the OASYS; the keyboard is a pleasure to play. More imposing yet is the screen. Everybody must know by now that the OASYS is essentially a PC at heart, and that it is edited primarily via a 10.4-inch colour, touch-sensitive screen, yet this wasn't always the plan. Apparently, OASYS started life with a screen the same size as a Triton's. But, at one of the early development meetings, Tsutomu Katoh, the founder and President of Korg, entered the room, saw the drawings and said simply, "Too small... screen too small... make screen bigger". Soon afterward, an email was circulated to announce that the synth was to have the screen that it now boasts. So, what's it like to use a 10.4-inch colour, touch-sensitive screen on a synthesizer? The answer, in my best American accent, is "awesome, dude". As regular readers of Sound On Sound will know, I still use my Trinity Pro as both a major sound source and as my controller keyboard, and one of the most significant reasons for this is because the touchscreen works so well. Although small by modern standards, it is responsive, has no faulty pixels or lines across it, and it's angled by just the right amount to make it useable in almost all situations. On OASYS, it's simply excellent to have a large, bright, touch-sensitive The OASYS's colour touchscreen,
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (4 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
through which players access all the screen that you can place at the angle of parameters relating to the operation of your choosing. What's more, by avoiding the synth. Microsoft's Windows and Apple's Mac OS X, Korg have been able to write application software that is perfectly tailored for the screen, and I am convinced that it would not have been possible to equal its clarity within the standard operating systems. I do, however, have a reservation. Having owned a laptop whose hinge mechanism sheared on more than one occasion, I'm concerned about whether the clutch mechanisms supporting the OASYS screen are strong enough. The screen is supported only by its clutches, and that's a lot of weight to be bearing backward week in, week out. What's more, unlike the screen on a laptop, which suffers no poking or prodding, you're going to be stabbing at the OASYS screen from the day that you start to use it. I have discovered that the hinges are only guaranteed for 2000 movements, which may be fine in the studio, but which may well prove inadequate for long-term, regular live use. I'm surprised there's no support or brace, like the one that supports a Minimoog's control panel. I wonder whether Korg might consider this.
As for the rest of the controls, it's extremely rare for everything on a synthesizer or workstation to fall to hand so correctly. How many times have you felt that it would be nice if this switch were over there, or that fader were over here? I find few keyboards to be ergonomically satisfying, and the last with which I was really comfortable was the Trinity. Well... it's taken 10 years, but there's now another, and it's the OASYS. If you haven't yet used an OASYS, and are just looking at these pictures, it's important to realise that (with the exception of the value slider and up/down buttons) you edit it using the touchscreen and the switches to the right of the screen, and you control it using the performance controls and the knobs and switches to its left. This means that, for example, if you want to create a huge filter sweep in the middle of a song, you should first assign the cutoff frequency to a knob or fader, not try to control it directly from the screen. You can do the latter, of course, but why would you? It's the wrong way to go about it. Once you've got to grips with this basic philosophy, everything falls to hand: not just to the extent that editing sounds becomes a doddle, but putting together whole songs using synthesized sounds, samples, sequences and audio recorded to disk is remarkably straightforward. I would venture that, notwithstanding some criticisms (of which more later, and next month), there has never been a keyboard that is closer to being a complete and useable music production system.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (5 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
OASYS — Or POCKY? I work in Japan for about 10 days each year, and I am a sucker for the snacks available from the all-night convenience stores spotted every hundred metres or so along every major street in Tokyo. There are cute little sandwiches, surprisingly good sushi and bento boxes — and irresistible chocolate biscuit sticks which go by the name of 'Pocky'. Well, it seems that Korg employee Steve McNally shares my taste for Pocky sticks, because (so the story goes) some years ago, he was nibbling away at a packet in a development meeting when Korg's president, Tsutomu Katoh, walked in and grabbed one of them. Apparently, Steve slapped his hand away and said something (probably through a mouthful of chocolate) that boiled down to, "Oi, get your own". Katoh growled, everybody laughed, and Katoh then left the room, only to reappear half an hour later with about 150 packs of the things, which he dumped on the table, before leaving again. Now fast-forward several years, to the rebirth of OASYS. As you may know (or not), Korg products are developed by individual country groups that work in specific areas of the music industry. For example, Korg Italy is responsible for domestically oriented instruments such as the PA1X, while Japan has traditionally developed workstations such as the Triton. Anyway, in 2001, Korg R&D (the Californian group responsible for Synth Kit, the original OASYS, and OASYS PCI) presented a proposal to Korg Japan. This suggested that the concept of an updateable, multi-synthesis, open-architecture keyboard was now feasible, and could be developed provided that they and Korg Japan worked in parallel to design and build it. It was a radical proposal, because no other major instrument had crossed geographic boundaries in that way, so the senior management asked for a Proof Of Concept for Korg (Japan) to be presented by the end of the Year. In short, a POCKY. I have picked up hints that — for a while, at least — this may have been an informal way of referring to the new project amongst chocoholic Korg employees. However, by the time the world heard of it, the product was once again named OASYS. In my view, that was a very good decision!
The Open Synthesizer? Although Korg like to think of the concept of open architecture synthesis as their own, the 10-year delay between the dream of OASYS and the reality has meant that the company has been beaten to the market not once, but several times, by very different systems that offer the same promise. One of these was the Roland VariOS, which Roland call an 'Open System Module'. This is a configurable module that — in principle — will allow you to load new synthesis engines, effects, and production tools as and when they become available. Unfortunately, VariOS was launched in 2003 with three modules (V-Producer, VariOS 303 and VariOS 8) and, two years later, these are still the only modules available. The blame for this lies entirely with Roland, who never released a third-party developers' kit. Not surprisingly, few people have chosen to investigate the potential of VariOS. file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (6 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
More significantly, the past few years have seen the appearance of the keyboard/computer; most notably the Open Labs Neko, which was reviewed in Sound On Sound in December 2004 (see www.soundonsound.com/sos/jan05/ articles/openlabsneko.htm). Unashamedly a marriage between a hardware control surface in a keyboardshaped case and a PC running Windows (albeit with a shell operating system to hide the Windows core from the user), you might think that this offers everything that the OASYS does. An array of assignable sliders and rotary controls fall easily to hand to the left of the touchscreen.
Some have taken this line of thinking further. Surely, they say, you could emulate the OASYS's sound generators with a PCM-based software synth, a virtual analogue software synth, and a Hammond software synth? Add a software sampler, a competent MIDI sequencer with audio recording capabilities, and a bunch of VST effects, and you have the lot, at a fraction of the cost. But as you can probably tell, I don't think this argument stands up, and here's why. The heart of the OASYS is indeed a 2.8GHz Pentium 4 PC with 1GB of RAM. However, instead of running Windows, the boot system is a cut-down Linux core (Linux was derived from the Unix operating system, and is often used for critical applications where stability and reliability are of paramount importance). In the OASYS, there is just enough Linux present to make the computer boot and load Korg's proprietary application software. This confers a huge benefit. You have to understand that neither Windows nor Mac OS X was designed to be a real-time operating system. If, for example, Windows decides that it wants to check whether there is a modem present, or to update some of its internal parameters, it will interrupt whatever applications are running and do so. This is of no consequence if you're performing a spot of word processing or browsing the web, but if you're sending eight channels of 24-bit, 96kHz audio out of the PC in question, it can be disastrous. The only way around this is to disable as much of Windows as you can (which is one of the major elements of optimising PCs for audio applications) and to use software that has large enough buffers to bridge the gap when the processor goes off to gaze at Bill Gates' navel. So, what's the big deal about OASYS? It should now be obvious. If you ask a PC to play more voices, or use more effects, or output more audio tracks, there will come a point where the CPU can no longer cope with the demands being placed upon it by numerous disparate applications. Anyone who uses such a system knows what happens next. At that moment, it takes just the tiniest push to shove the whole thing over the edge, and you get a glitch, a freeze, or the 'blue screen of death'. Sometimes you can defer the point of no return by increasing the file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (7 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
latency of the system, but that's often not acceptable in a musical environment. On the OASYS, you can continue to ask for voices, effects, samples, and streamed audio, and when you decide to add another channel of VA synthesis, or another Hammond (or whatever), the synth simply says, 'I can't do it all, mate...' and steals a voice from somewhere. Because the whole system is integrated, it can cope with excessive demands in a way that a Mac or PC cannot.
Controls on the right of the screen include numeric keypad and data-entry dial, Mode and Bank selection buttons, and the switches for starting and stopping the built-in sequencer and sampler (more on these next month).
Integration confers other benefits, the most significant of which is speed. Let's say that you're the arranger and keyboard player for a West End production, you do 'spots' on a TV show, and you play in a rock band for fun (if so, congratulations!). Each of these has different requirements, and the modern way to cope with them is to couple a portable PC offering sequencing and software-synthesis capabilities to a controller keyboard and a small selection of rackmount modules. It's not the most reliable of setups, and most players live in fear of glitches and crashes. On the OASYS, you hit a button or two, and everything is done; the appropriate synths and sounds are loaded, the sequencer is primed and ready to roll, and all the pre-recorded audio is sitting behind the internal mixer ready to be triggered. To be fair, this is not new — a handful of workstations offer similar facilities — but none promise to cope with everything so elegantly. Returning to the issues at hand, can we really say, therefore, that the OASYS is an open system? There is as yet no third-party developers' kit, and it cannot handle software that conforms to VST, MAS, DXi, or any of the other common 'open' application formats. Korg's stated view is that the OASYS is as open as (for example) Digital Performer or Pro Tools, which require developers to write to the MAS or Audiosuite standards respectively, but I fear that this is a tad disingenuous. There are thousands of DP systems and hundreds of thousands of Pro Tools systems in use worldwide, which makes it viable for small companies to develop for them. It's daft to imagine that Korg will sell many thousands of OASYSs, so it's much less likely that third parties will develop for it, whether it's 'open', or not. This places a heavy burden upon Korg to provide new synthesis engines and other upgrades, or they may find that the lessons of the Roland VariOS come back to haunt them.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (8 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
Big Screens, Little Screens Some people on Korg-oriented web forums have already started to speculate about using a large screen with the OASYS, and in principle, this is possible. If you look at the back panel, you'll find a blanking plate that covers a standard video output: remove this, and there's nothing stopping you from connecting an external monitor. Of course, disconnecting The multiple USB connectors on the back the touch-screen would make it panel are accompanied by this mysterious impossible to edit the OASYS blanking panel, behind which lurks a although, alongside the video standard video output connector. output, there are several USB2 ports, so it should also be possible to connect a mouse or trackpad (or both). For the moment, however, all this is moot, because the OASYS's operating system does not support it. However, when I asked Korg whether they intended to provide support for external screens and control devices, the answer I obtained was encouraging. They said, "If enough people want this, we'll look into it". Time will tell.
HD1 As things stand, there are three sound engines in the OASYS. The first is a PCMbased engine called HD1 which, contrary to some of the uninformed comments you may have read on the Web, is far more than just an expanded Triton. The other two engines are expansion instruments, or 'EXis': the AL1 analogue modelling synth, and the CX3 organ. Despite the fact that they come pre-installed from day one, Korg's use of the term EXi for the AL1 and CX3 demonstrates that they see HD1 as the heart of the OASYS. This makes sense; workstations are invariably based on S&S, no matter what other facilities they host. Currently, HD1 lives inside 1GB of RAM and, although there's a slot on the motherboard for a further Gigabyte, the OS is as yet unable to access it. Apparently, this upgrade is high on the list of Korg's priorities, and that's just as well, because the current arrangement imposes some unhealthy constraints on how you can use the system. When you switch on OASYS, it loads approximately 303MB of PCM samples into its memory. Korg refers to this as the 'ROM' but, of course, it's not. The samples are held on the internal 40GB hard disk, so it's possible for the company to update or replace them at any time it chooses. Next, the OASYS can load one of two choices of EXs (EXtended sample) memory. EXs1 is another selection of multisamples occupying 314MB, while EXs2 is a grand piano (see the box over file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (9 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
the page) that takes up a whopping 504MB. Ah, you're ahead of me... If you try to load all three sets of samples, you need approximately 1.1GB of RAM, and the OASYS has only 1GB. This means that your options are (i) the 'ROM' alone, (ii) the ROM plus EXs1, or (iii) the ROM plus EXs2. Any unallocated RAM (up to a maximum of 500MB) is then made available to the sampler, which we'll discuss next month.
The main screen for viewing an HD1 patch, with the oscillator, LFO, filter and envelope configurations all on display.
While this system doesn't sound too bad, there's a problem. Firstly, if you want to switch between EXs1 and EXs2, you have to make your selection in the Global menu, switch the OASYS off and then back on again! Now, let's say that you've create a set of Programs that use the samples in EXs1. And let's say that you've placed them all in program Bank E so that you can find them quickly and easily. And let's say that you now want to load EXs2 to play the grand piano. Inevitably, every patch in Bank E is 'broken'. Likewise, you could program your piano sounds using the samples in EXs2, but these will go horribly silent if you invoke EXs1. Let's face it... that's clunky. At some point, someone within Korg must have decided it was unacceptable to have the piano sounds mutually exclusive from much of the rest of the OASYS, so the designers took EXs2, shortened the loops and used fewer samples to create a lesser piano that occupies about 133MB of the 314MB in EXs1. This, Korg claim, is a very respectable piano in its own right. In the version I am reviewing, 1.0.0, it loses one of the velocity splits (only the ff, f and mf samples have survived), and occupies just a single layer with no sympathetic resonance, so you would expect it to be less realistic than EXs2. Nevertheless, the difference is small. What's more, if you inspect the list of multisamples in EXs1 you'll find that the mp samples and the so-called 'Damper' sample are still available, so you can reconstruct something that sounds remarkably similar to EXs2, gain access to the other 200MB of EXs1 multisamples, and release 200MB for your own samples. This brings us to the issue of editing Programs in HD1. As I stated at the start of the review, I'm not going to describe the details of this, nor am I going to trot out the specification. But perhaps I can give you an idea of what it's like to create sounds on the OASYS. Put simply, it's great. You edit OASYS using the touchscreen to select things, and any combination of the Value slider, Up and Down buttons, or the data-entry wheel to adjust them. I found myself using the soft plastic end of a ballpoint pen to select items on screen, because this was more precise than my fingertips. Then, depending upon whether I was holding the pen as a 'righty' or a 'lefty', I could manipulate the slider and buttons to the left of the screen or the data-entry file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (10 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
wheel to the right with the other hand. Very neat, and very comfortable. Sound design will be second nature to anyone who has programmed any previous Korg workstation. In short (but in a long sentence), two oscillators feed two filter sections that feed two amplifier sections that feed an insert effects section that feed the master The flexible AMS mixers from the OASYS's effects, the end result of which is sent HD1 synth engine, seen here in 'AxB' (left) to the outside world for your pleasure. and 'A+B' configurations. If that sounds remarkably like an M1, that's not surprising. It is, although the power of each section — oscillators, filters, envelopes, LFOs and so on — is hugely greater. So, while there may be a lot of synthesizer here, it's not mindnumbingly complex. You select pages (in effect, synthesis modules) using the two rows of tabs running along the bottom of the screen, and select parameters by touching... well, the parameters themselves. As you can see from the Program screen on the opposite page, the voice structure is surprisingly clear, and it's equally clear that a lot of thought went into the interface. For example, if you want to adjust the nature of Filter B in Filter1 of a dual-oscillator patch, you press the Filter tab, then the Filter1 tab that is thus revealed, and then the Filter B 'Type' control, selecting from the drop-down menu that appears. This may sound complex, but the beauty of the system is that, on a 10.4-inch touchscreen... it's a beautiful system! If I had to single out one aspect of HD1 that's worthy of special mention, it would be the AMS Mixers (shown in the screengrab above). The AMS (Alternate Modulation Source) concept first appeared on the Trinity, and in essence replaced the patch leads and CV inputs of a modular analogue synth, allowing you to specify which source modulated which destination, and by how much. On the OASYS, Korg have taken the concept a step further by adding two AMS Mixers in each voice (or, to put it another way, up to four AMS Mixers in each Program). These offer six modes: A+B, AxB, Offset, Smoothing, Shape, and Quantise. I particularly like 'AxB' mode, because this allows you to control the amplitude of one modulator using another, just as you would using a VCA on a modular analogue synth. Given that the outputs from the two AMS Mixers are themselves available as AMS sources throughout the voice structure, this suggests no end of programming possibilities. I would also like to compliment the OASYS on its patch-selection mechanism. Click on the Category area at the top of the Play screen and, rather than see an almost endless list of patches, you'll find a list of 17 categories (strings, brass, organs, lead synth, and so on) each with up to eight sub-categories. Click on one, then the other, and the thousands of Programs in the OASYS are narrowed down to exactly the type of sound you want, making selection painless. Bravo!
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (11 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
EXs2 — Piano Lessens What constitutes a 'good' piano sound is a very personal matter, but few people would suggest that Korg have ever done other than lag behind the major players in the digital piano market. First, there was Kurzweil, and then there was Roland, and now... well, there's still Roland. In comparison with these, Korg's pianos have always sounded a little two-dimensional, and they have never achieved the same commercial success as other manufacturers' offerings. So, when Korg Japan were discussing what sounds to place in the OASYS, they decided that a superb piano was a top priority, and that it could occupy as much space as needed to get it right. The developers found that the required samples occupied more than 500MB, and thus was EXs2 born. So, how does it sound? Oh heck... I really don't want to say this, but my initial impressions were not great. At first, I couldn't easily determine what was bothering me, because the samples that comprise EXs2 are undoubtedly 'piano-y'. The recreations of the undamped strings at the top of the keyboard are good, the long decays when the damper pedal is pressed are superb, the stereo imaging is nice, and the sympathetic resonance adds a welcome layer of realism. Nonetheless, there are other areas in which the EXs2 pianos just don't sound realistic to me: for example, the lack of body in the middle octaves and the unnatural haste at which upper mid notes disappear to silence when the damper pedal is not pressed. Consequently, the EXs2 piano Programs didn't convince me, and I got a similar feeling from them as I get when playing one of Roland's early SAS (Structured Adaptive Synthesis) pianos, or even a Yamaha CP80... great instruments that you can use in the same way as a piano, but without them ever sounding like a perfect imitation of a piano. Faced with this, I removed all the effects from the Programs, inverted Korg's 'smiley face' EQ, and tweaked the curves and lengths of the envelopes a little. The sound improved considerably. Of course, the use of a conventional monitoring system ensured that I was not fooled into thinking that I was sitting at a nine-foot Bösendorfer (nor even my mum's Broadwood) but the modified Programs — although not up to the standard of the very best of the competition — now worked well. I am sure that all but the most demanding listeners would be happy to hear them in a mix and, with sympathetic playing and recording, many — myself included — could be fooled into thinking that they were listening to a 'real' piano. Of course, you may like Korg's Programs without having to go through these kinds of tweaks. As I said, piano sounds are very personal.
And The Sound? As you are probably aware, the OASYS offers extremely advanced effects, wave sequencing and KARMA to further spice up its sounds, and we'll discuss all of
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (12 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
these next month. But I'm sure that you're dying to know how the HD1 Programs sound without all this fairy-dust being sprinkled across them because, unethical though the practice may be, the deficiencies of many a dull synthesizer have in the past been masked by built-in effects. In short, HD1 can sound superb. Traditionally, I have used four brands of synths for specific characters of sounds. Kurzweils have provided orchestral sounds and the warm, low-end timbres for which they're famous, Yamahas have provided precise, percussive sounds, Rolands have provided the pianos, ethnic instruments and pads that sit unobtrusively in a mix, and my Korgs have always been used for the wonderful washes and textures that they do better than anything else. The OASYS breaks the mould. Its orchestral sounds are a revelation: more authentic and with more character than any previous Korg. Its percussive sounds are brighter and more precise than any previous Korg. It is capable of ethnic sounds and pads that work better than similar sounds on any previous Korg. As for the spacey textures and effects... well, you know what I'm going to say. In part, this is because many of its PCMs are stereo, uncompressed and longer than those of other workstations. In part, the high internal processing speed means that the PCMs can be manipulated with high bandwidth and high precision, so they are clearer at high frequencies than ever before. In part, it's because its huge polyphony consigns note-stealing to history when using Programs. Furthermore, Korg's claims that the OASYS generates very little aliasing appear to be well-founded. Take something with a rich, highfrequency spectrum, and play it at the top end of the keyboard. Now apply an LFO to the pitch, and an octave of upward pitch-bend. On most synths, you would now be hearing all manner of unwanted frequencies polluting the sound. On OASYS, you hear little or none of this, and that's impressive. However... much less impressive are the obvious multisample points on many of the sounds. To demonstrate this to yourself, select patch INTA024: 'Pipe Organ Mixture' or INTA032: 'Clav1/Mure Sw1', and play middle 'C'. Now play the 'B' a semitone below it. As you will hear on both Programs, the timbres change considerably. If you want to shock yourself, isolate multisample 0072: 'Pipe Organ Mixture2' in the former Program. Alternatively, play A4 and A#4 using 0116: 'Tin Whistle' — the two notes sound as if they come from two different types of instrument. To be fair, generating large libraries of multisamples is difficult, and there are many examples of other manufacturers' instruments that suffer from the same
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (13 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Korg OASYS: Part 1
problems. The silver lining here is that, because they are disk-based, the OASYS's sample sets can be replaced by improved versions. I hope that Korg will consider doing so. Another criticism concerns Korg's misleading claims that the oscillators (and I quote from the brochure) "support four-way layering, switching and crossfading". This is not true. While you can load up to four samples in a single oscillator, you can't layer them four deep; only two can sound at any given moment. On a more positive note, the mechanism for inserting samples and crossfading or layering them and the way that these operations are represented on the touchscreen are object lessons for other designers.
Next Month... While Korg can't claim to have invented wave sequencing (it's an extension of the wavetable synthesis made popular by PPG) or vector synthesis (this first came to prominence on the Prophet VS), it's fair to say that both these technologies reached maturity in the Korg Wavestation and its descendents. Happily, both these technologies are present in the OASYS, and in much improved forms. Similarly, the Korg M1 may not have been the first synth with splits and layers, but it cemented the concept of the Combi (in other words, a selection of sounds distributed across the keyboard as required) whereupon other manufacturers adopted it as the ideal way to create complex layered sounds. Again, this technology is present in the OASYS, and again, it's more advanced than before. However, I'm not going to say any more about these just yet because they are not used only by the HD1 engine, but also by the AL1 and CX3 engines. So this is where we'll pick up the story next month. Until then... Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/korgoasys.htm (14 of 14)10/19/2005 9:41:30 PM
Lexicon MX200
In this article:
Lexicon MX200
Simple Operation Multi-Effects Processor Effect Algorithms Published in SOS November 2005 Reverb Options MX-Edit Software Print article : Close window The MX200 In Practice Reviews : Effects MX200 Audio Specifications Sounding Out
Lexicon MX200 £200 pros Good effect quality for the price range. Very easy to use. Can generate two effects at once with four routing options. Included software allows patches to be edited and automated within a Mac or PC sequencer and patch data is also remembered within the project file. Costs less than many reverb plug-ins.
cons Some limitations in the implementation of automation in Logic.
summary The way Lexicon have gone about making the MX200 appear as a DAW plug-in for control purposes is both simple and practical. You need to ensure you have enough spare I/O to handle the audio, but other than that it is very easy to use. DAW users who lack the CPU power for serious software reverb will find the MX200 particularly attractive.
information £199.99 including VAT. Harman Pro UK +44 (0) 1707 668222. +44 (0)1707 668010. Click here to email
Lexicon's latest hardware reverb is designed to be as easy to control from your computer as a plug-in. Paul White
For years now we've become used to software plug-ins that look like hardware, but the Lexicon MX200 turns this idea on its head by being a hardware effects box that tries to look like a plug-in. What this means in practice is that the front-panel controls Photos: Mike Cameron of the machine can be accessed via a plug-in window, and settings can be The MX200 hardware (below) can be controlled from your sequencer via its control saved as part of your DAW song as plug-in (above), here seen running under with any other plug-in. This happens Apple Logic Pro. courtesy of a direct USB connection that functions as a MIDI port, though the audio still has to be connected to your audio interface in the usual way — it would have been neat if the audio could also have gone via USB, but no luck there. The MX200 features the classic Lexicon reverb sound as well as providing additional effects (32 effect types in all), where two effects can run at the same time under one of four routing options. These may be accessed through very simple front-panel controls or using the MX-Edit editor/librarian software that works within VST or Audio Unit hosts. This way the MX200 is seen by the host software as a plug-in, even though it is really externally connected hardware. However, you can only open one instance of the plug-in at a time, of course, because there's only one MX200. In addition to being able to control the effect parameters in the same way you would with a plug-in, you can also automate the control settings and save or load patches. MX-Edit is included with the MX200 and runs on both Apple Mac or Windows XP systems.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/lexiconmx200.htm (1 of 6)10/19/2005 9:41:33 PM
Lexicon MX200
www.harmanprouk.com www.lexicon.com
Test Spec Apple Mac G5 dual 2.5GHz with 4GB RAM, running Mac OS 10.3.9.
The 1U rack processor is powered from an included AC power adaptor. It has stereo balanced inputs and outputs on TRS jacks and can also handle S/PDIF I/ O. Alongside the USB link are conventional MIDI In and Out/Thru ports. When an external digital input is connected to the unit, the MX200 expects the external device to be the clock master.
Simple Operation To keep things simple, a front-panel LED matrix uses four columns of lights to show which two of the 32 available effects are active. There are separate control areas for the two effect processors with buttons for Effect Select, Tempo (for tapping in tempos directly), and Bypass. Three parameter control knobs adjust the three most important parameters for the currently selected effect, and further global controls adjust Input Level and Mix 1 and Mix 2 wet/dry adjustment, as well as allowing the storing or auditioning of patches. To help audition patches, there are five audio samples that can be fired off as source material. The large dial on the left selects effects programs, and it is pushed to load them. Lexicon have created 99 presets to get users off to a flying start, but there's room on board to save a further 99 user patches. As this is a budget unit, the display offers two-digit numbers only, with no opportunity to name patches, but this isn't unreasonable on a processor at this UK price point. The two effects engines can be used in four different routing configurations categorised as Dual Mono (two independent mono-in, mono-out processors), Cascade (stereo series), Dual Stereo (stereo parallel), or Mono Split (dual monoin, stereo-out processors with mixed outputs). Two banks of factory patches have been set up, one Series and one Parallel, where the Parallel bank is designed to be used with mixer sends and returns, providing a 100-percent wet signal at the MX200's output. Conversely, the Series-bank effects are set up to be best suited for use in insert points, where the wet/dry balance is set as required using the Mix 1 and Mix 2 controls. The default bank is the Series bank, so to switch to the Parallel bank you need to go through a short routine initiated by pressing the Store and Audition buttons together, as described in the manual.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/lexiconmx200.htm (2 of 6)10/19/2005 9:41:33 PM
Lexicon MX200
Effect Algorithms Small Hall.
Reverse.
Arena.
Mod Delay.
Phaser.
Large Hall.
Vocal Hall.
Spring.
Reverse Delay.
Tremolo/Pan.
Small Plate.
Vocal Plate.
Compressor.
Rotary.
Large Plate
Drum Hall.
De-esser.
Vibrato.
Chorus.
Pitch-shift.
Flanger.
Detune.
Room.
Drum Plate.
Chamber.
Ambience.
Gated.
Studio.
Studio Delay. Digital Delay. Tape Delay. Pong Delay.
Reverb Options Clearly the Lexicon reverbs are stars of this particular show, with 16 variants on offer including some nice short plates, chambers, and room ambiences. Of the remaining 16 effects, there's a dynamics section designed by Dbx as well as all the common modulation/delay treatments and rotary speaker emulation. Pitchshifting is also catered for, along with reverse delay and de-essing, making this a real processing toolbox rather than a simple one-trick pony. Given the low cost, you may be wondering what the catch is, but other than a maximum working sample rate of 48kHz and the simplistic display, I can't see it yet if there is one! Further global settings enable the user to set the MIDI channel on which control data will be sent, or to disable MIDI completely. You can also set whether programs load as soon as they are selected or whether changes wait until the knob is pressed. Digital or analogue input selection is another global setting, though both analogue and digital outputs are always active. Another neat trick is that you can set the unit to send the dry signal out over coaxial S/PDIF while the processed signal comes via the analogue outs — a clever option for providing monitor reverb without actually recording it. And of course there's a factory reset that restores all of the original 'out of the box' settings. It is also possible to configure the MX200's outputs to run in mono or stereo.
MX-Edit Software Once installed, the MX-Edit software lets you access the factory and user patches. Communication can be via USB or MIDI, though USB is usually more convenient, and user patches from the MX200 can be retrieved by the software. New effects programs can be set up using the software via its graphical panel interface, and you can also create archives of all your user patches.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/lexiconmx200.htm (3 of 6)10/19/2005 9:41:33 PM
Lexicon MX200
Separate VST and Audio Unit software allows the MX200 to function within a plug-in environment and this installs from CD along with MX-Edit. The audio routing through the MX200 needs to be set up via the DAW you happen to be using: Logic users can use the I/O plug-in, whereas Cakewalk users can add send and return effects to a buss. Steinberg's Cubase also has the option of connecting external effects. The Lexicon plug-in window is available within your plug-in list so you can open this in the channel that is set up to pass audio through the MX200. The session-recall and patch-saving routines then work as they would for any other plug-in, so you can guarantee repeatability provided that you make a note of the input gain setting on the MX200, as this isn't automated. The controls within the plug-in window operate in much the same way as in the MX-Edit software.
The MX200 In Practice Lexicon's software installed in one simple operation, and MX-Edit opened like any other application, its plug-in counterpart appearing in the host DAW's plug-in list. For my main Logic test, I inserted the MX200 plug-in into a vocal track and then used Logic's I/O plug-in to send audio to and from the MX200 hardware via another insert in the same track. I had no problem getting Logic to automate the MX200's parameters in more or less the same way as with any other plug-in, although it didn't matter whether I chose Latch or Touch modes for the automation, it always behaved as though it was in Latch mode. Other plug-ins inserted here behaved normally. Quite a lot of zipper noise was in evidence when changing some of the parameters (specifically pre-delay or anything else related to delay times) during playback, so clearly you need to do a few tests to see what you can easily automate and how quickly you can make changes before artefacts become audible. Reverb mix and decay time behave fine in this respect. That aside, the effects are all rather good, even though this is one of Lexicon's lower-cost processors. The reverbs may not have quite the same PCM91 or even MPX500 sparkle, but they still manage to sit well in a mix without clouding the sound, and they integrate well with the dry sound rather than sitting on top like a layer of fog. I particularly like the shorter plate and ambience treatments, though the algorithms on offer cover the full range of useful reverb types, from barely audible small-room acoustics to cathedrals. Even the spring emulation sounds really sweet on vocals.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/lexiconmx200.htm (4 of 6)10/19/2005 9:41:33 PM
Lexicon MX200
The remaining effects don't disappoint either, with the reverse delay being one of my personal favourites. For the more conventionally minded, the delays, phasers, and chorus/flanger effects are right on the money. From my own viewpoint, I wouldn't use the dynamics processors for serious track processing, not because there's anything wrong with them but because an analogue unit (or a plug-in emulation of one) with good metering is so much easier to use. Having made that point, it can be extremely useful to place a compressor before a reverb (fed from a send) to pump up the reverb energy, and a de-esser can be very effective placed before a bright reverb to stop it over-emphasising sibilance in the original vocal sound. Operation is a real no-brainer, especially if you're using the software, as you can choose the effect algorithms for each effects engine by name from a pull-down menu, rather than having to step through the front-panel matrix. The legends beneath the three controls also change to reflect their function, which is clearly not the case on the hardware. In most cases, the controls stick to a predictable convention, such as reverb pre-delay, decay time, and timbre, but it's still easier when you can see what the controls do. The four routing options make this processor very flexible, and the mixed pair of mono-in, stereo-out processors is a very practical arrangement if you want to set up two send effects using only one stereo aux return. The parallel stereo mode is also good for creating spectacular spatial effects combining different reverbs on each engine, or using a reverse reverb or delay on one channel and a conventional treatment on the other.
MX200 Audio Specifications Audio inputs: quarter-inch TRS balanced (impedance 20k(omega)) or unbalanced (impedance 10k(omega)). Input level: +4dBu nominal, +20dBu maximum. Frequency response: 20Hz-20kHz ±1dB (reference 1kHz). Total harmonic distortion plus noise: less than 0.007% within the 20Hz-20kHz range. Audio outputs: quarter-inch TRS balanced or unbalanced. Output level: +20dBu maximum. Dynamic range: more than 107dBA. A-D conversion: 24-bit resolution, 48kHz sample rate. Audio processing: 24-bit resolution.
Sounding Out Aside from the small operational quirks I discovered when using the plug-in control panel within Logic, the system performed flawlessly. Being able to save tweaked effects settings within the sequencer made it almost as immediate as a file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/lexiconmx200.htm (5 of 6)10/19/2005 9:41:33 PM
Lexicon MX200
software plug-in, but without the DSP load that good reverb invariably entails. You do have to be careful which parameters you automate and also how fast you change them, as delay-time adjustments sound very glitchy during the change, but most of the things you'd realistically like to do are possible with care. The main operational difference between the MX200 and a 'real' plug-in is that you can only use one instance of the MX200 at a time, but you can still set up two different reverbs in a parallel configuration and feed them from two sends in your virtual mixer. The sound quality of the unit is comparable with Lexicon's other entry-level boxes of recent years, which is to say exceptionally good, but still short of what a highend Lexicon box can deliver. You still get the characteristic density and shimmer when you need it, albeit without the same degree of finesse at the high-frequency end, and the additional effects cover most mixing eventualities. I've made no secret of my opinion that hardware needs to be able to function smoothly within a plug-in environment if it is to appeal to computer studio owners who take for granted that all effects settings will be saved with their sequencer projects. Lexicon have gone a long way towards getting the 'hardware as plug-in' paradigm right, and only the ability to stream audio via the USB connector would have made it better. The future of studio audio hardware is almost certainly that it will all connect to the central system via a high-bandwidth data hub of some kind — Yamaha have been working towards this scenario for many years with mLan — but for the present day Lexicon seem to have got it about right given that they need to maintain compatibility with just about any type of recording or live-sound system. Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/lexiconmx200.htm (6 of 6)10/19/2005 9:41:33 PM
M&K MPS1611P
In this article:
Hardware Overview To Bung Or Not To Bung? In Use
M&K MPS1611P £1549
M&K MPS1611P Active Monitors Published in SOS November 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Monitors
pros Tonally neutral but detailed presentation. Spacious stereo imaging. Flexible input options. Configurable bass response. Sealed or reflex cabinet modes.
cons
These new speakers from M&K let you switch between reflex and infinite-baffle designs on a whim. Hugh Robjohns
None.
summary A compact two-way nearfield active monitor with the unusual facility to operate either as a sealed cabinet or as a ported design, the latter offering greater SPL at the expense of some bass extension and smoothness. The MPS1611P maintains M&K's characteristic tonal and dynamic accuracy, and is an impressive addition to the product range.
information £1548.65 per pair including VAT. Stirling Trading +44 (0) 20 8963 4790. +44 (0)20 8963 4799. Click here to email
The American professional loudspeaker company Miller & Kreisel have built up a very solid reputation for their studio monitors. The unusuallooking multi-driver M&K MPS2510 flagships (reviewed in SOS July 2001) have become firm favourites in many small film and TV dubbing theatres, as well as in surround-sound remixing applications. The latest addition to the MPS range is a compact two-way nearfield monitor called the MPS1611P, and this one does things a Photos: Mike Cameron little differently from the norm too. The speaker is intended primarily for use in a 'satellite plus subwoofer' arrangement, although it can also be used as a standalone full-range speaker, albeit with a lower maximum SPL capability. The review was based on the MPS1611P monitors on their own, without a subwoofer.
www.stirlingtrading.com www.mkprofessional.com
Hardware Overview The speaker cabinet measures a neatly proportioned 320 x 213 x 308mm (hwd) and weighs a fraction over 9kg. The cabinet is ported to the rear, but is supplied with a removable plug (of which more in moment). The driver complement comprises a one-inch soft-dome ferrofluid-cooled tweeter and a 6.5-inch polypropylene woofer, with the system designed to provide 91dBSPL at one metre for a nominal-level input signal. The maximum SPL is not given in the
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/mkmps1611.htm (1 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:36 PM
M&K MPS1611P
specs, but like all M&K products, the 1611P is a very capable design and it's easily able to provide substantial levels when used in its intended nearfield role. The tweeter design incorporates an aluminium faceplate and bezel designed to help increase power handling and reduce dynamic compression effects at high volumes, while the rear of the tweeter is loaded with a proprietary 'transmission line' to prevent the sound projected from the rear of the tweeter being reflected back — something that would otherwise cause comb-filtering problems. The woofer has a generous magnetic motor design with full shielding. The rear panel of the speaker forms a chassis for the electronics — a 100W amplifier to drive the woofer and a 50W unit for the tweeter. Both are described as using 'mixed bipolar DMOS technology' and quoted with 0.02 percent total harmonic distortion (THD). The input signal can be accepted either via a balanced combi jack/XLR socket or an unbalanced RCA phono socket. There is no input selector — both appear to be active at all times — but there is an input sensitivity switch. This three-position toggle offers options of 200mV (-12dBu or -14dBV), 1.23V (+4dBu), or a variable level set by an adjacent knob. The last covers a range of ±6dB relative to the +4dBu reference level. These figures all relate to the balanced input; levels at the unbalanced input are halved (in other words, the options equate to 100mV (-20dBV), 615mV (-4dBV) and the variable ±6dB swing around -4dBV. In practice, these options make it easy to find a sensitivity setting that suits pretty much anything likely to feed the speakers.
Under the speaker's rear control panel is the single port — the plug can be removed to increase the overall output level of the speaker.
The remaining rear-panel controls are another pair of toggle switches that determine the low-frequency response of the speaker. The first switch is labelled Bass Response with Normal and Full Range options. In the first position the speaker has a claimed response of 45Hz-22kHz (±3dB), and in the second it extends down to 35Hz — although this low-frequency extension figure is based on the speaker being close to a rear wall. The last switch introduces an 80Hz high-pass filter, but this is only available when the Bass Response switch is set to Normal, and is intended for use when the MPS1611P is operating with an appropriate subwoofer. Below the large heat sink area on the rear panel is the IEC mains input connector, a fuse holder, and the main power switch. An LED next to the phono input socket provides an indication that the speaker is powered and working — there is also a recessed green LED on the front baffle above the tweeter to aid in aligning the speaker's listening axis.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/mkmps1611.htm (2 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:36 PM
M&K MPS1611P
To Bung Or Not To Bung? The MPS1611P can be used either as a sealed-cabinet (sometimes called 'infinite baffle') design, or as a reflex-cabinet design which boasts a higher maximum SPL capability. As shipped, the speaker's rear port is closed off with a tight-fitting foam bung mounted between metal end plates, the front having a knob with which to insert and remove the bung. With the bung in place, the rear switch selector set to Full Range, and the speakers mounted in free space, the low-frequency response extends to 50Hz (6dB point) with a very gentle roll-off below that and minimal phase shift. In Normal mode the response rises to 80Hz at -3dB, and this is the standard alignment for use with an M&K subwoofer (such as the LFE4 or LFE5). If the subwoofer doesn't have bass-management facilities, then switching in the 80Hz filter introduces a steeper roll-off (-6dB at 80Hz). With the port bung removed the bass extension figures change minimally, but the character of the speaker changes dramatically, and it is capable of higher SPLs, as you might expect.
In Use The MPS1611P is a sweet-sounding speaker with a precise and neutral character, and it is claimed to be timbre-matched to other M&K monitors, although I was not able to verify that. Transients are replayed with crisp detail and natural dynamics, and with the port bung in place the speaker delivers a smooth and well-balanced bass response that manages to provide a surprising amount of information on low-frequency signals. With the bung removed the character of the bass presentation changes noticeably, but it remains a wellbehaved design overall. If the speaker was supplied only as a ported design then it would receive very favourable reviews, but as a sealed-cabinet design it gains a subtlety and smoothness in the bass region that really impresses. Personally, despite the lower maximum SPL, I much preferred the sound with the bung in place. Set up about 20cm from a rear wall, the speakers delivered a surprisingly powerful bass response, benefiting from the additional bass loading effect of the rear boundary. As long as the speakers are placed well away from the side walls they can deliver wide, stable stereo images with reasonable depth and spaciousness. I found accurate aiming of the listening axis towards the 'hot seat' was important, though, but that is made very easy thanks to the recessed LED on the front panel. With the aid of an assistant to move the speaker, the increasing apparent brightness of the LED makes it very obvious when the optimum angle and height have been found. Used farther from the rear wall, the bass response naturally becomes less powerful, but the smooth extension
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/mkmps1611.htm (3 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:36 PM
M&K MPS1611P
remains and still allows the detail, tuning, and relative balance of bass instruments to be heard clearly. Overall, these little speakers impressed me very much, delivering an accurate, tonally neutral sound with natural dynamics and transient details — even when delivering relatively high nearfield sound pressure levels. Although I was unable to try the MPS1611P with a suitable subwoofer during the review, experience would suggest that they will integrate very well, such is the controlled evenness of the bass response, in which case the combination would make a very competent and compact full-range nearfield monitoring system. Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/mkmps1611.htm (4 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:36 PM
Plug-in Folder
In this article:
Camel Audio Camel Space TC Electronic DVR2
Plug-in Folder Camel Space & DVR2 Published in SOS November 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
Camel Audio Camel Space Formats: PC VST & Mac OS X AU Camel Audio are a name that should be familiar to plug-in fans, having started out with the popular Camel Phat VST effect before unveiling the groundbreaking and critically lauded Cameleon 5000 additive synth. Lately, as well as updating Camel Phat to its third incarnation, they've given it a stablemate in the form of Camel Space, an interesting amalgam of a few studio staples along with some twists not found in your average effect plug-in. Like its brethren, one of Camel Space's biggest assets is its filter, which can provide 10 different modes of operation, comprising high-, low-, and band-pass algorithms in standard and 'fat' versions, along with the less common comb, notch, peaking and ring-mod types. As you might expect, 'fat' seems to denote more than just a steeper cutoff slope, instead affording the kind of grit and wallop that can make for much more pleasing filtering, not to mention the odd speaker-endangering resonant honk. It sounds great and provides a lot of versatility for broad and subtle applications, and there's a dedicated LFO to go with it. Camel Space also boasts auto-pan, enhancer, stereo delay, flanger and reverb modules that are all very straightforward and conventional in operation. The reverb is particularly simple, with just Mix and Size controls, yet sounds pretty smooth and non-metallic — particularly taking into account its very efficient performance in terms of CPU use. The enhancer is another highlight, capable of providing both top-end lift and soft saturation that can vary between a nice gentle warmth and some quite raucous distortion.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/pluginfolder.htm (1 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:40 PM
Plug-in Folder
Whilst the various modules add up to a nice set of effects, the real heart of the beast is a step sequencer with which you can modulate the pan and filter cutoff, along with a simple one-button output attenuator named the 'trance gate'. With up to 128 steps in eight banks, the sequencer provides quite some scope for sculpting evolving rhythmic sounds, and there's control over the attack, sustain and decay characteristics as well as the ability to chain individual steps together. With different modulation destinations selectable on each of the eight banks it's an exceedingly capable tool and one that's not too fiddly in operation to put a damper on experimental fun. A run through the presets demonstrates well how powerful the sequenced filtering, panning and gating are in combination with the other modules. There are some great sounds on offer here, regardless of whether you want to make actual trance music, get seriously experimental, or just do 'How Soon Is Now' covers on the guitar. In fact, although only one of Camel Space's numerous categorised presets has the 'GTR' prefix, I found it excelled as a guitar effect. There's also a lot to help you get the most out of the plug-in's potential for real-time performance, including an X-Y pad for linking and manipulating any two rotary controls, and MIDI learn functionality for hardware control if your host application supports it. Plus, there's an invaluable randomise button that works intelligently to help create fresh — and always usable — patches when inspiration runs low. Overall, it's safe to say that Camel Audio have scored another hit, with a great plug-in that's as happy lending a little warmth and ambience as it is dealing allout swirling wackiness. Thanks to an attractive, well thought-out interface and some very convenient design features, Camel Space is a pleasure to use and would make a good addition to anyone's plug-in folder. What's more, its very nicely priced at 45 quid, so I'd definitely recommend grabbing the demo and giving it a try. Mike Bryant £45. www.camelaudio.com
TC Electronic DVR2 Formats: Mac & PC Powercore It seems that this year TC have launched a different Powercore reverb every few weeks, but to fair, they are all different and they are also of extremely high quality. The latest is DVR2, based on algorithms ported from the System 6000 processor and designed to generate what TC call 'generic reverb with true vintage flavour'. While room simulation reverbs are designed to create a specific sense of space, a generic reverb is more about adding reverb as an effect without suggesting any particular type of acoustic environment. DVR2 has clearly been designed to model as closely as possible the tonal attributes of the famed EMT 250 digital reverb processor. While EMT are best known for their plates, the all-digital EMT 250 was extremely well respected by file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/pluginfolder.htm (2 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:40 PM
Plug-in Folder
engineers and in some respects it was a convenient and modern replacement for their earlier plate units. It could thus be said that TC have attempted to emulate an emulation of a plate! DVR2 sounds plate-like without recreating the undesirable rumbling and ringing that is often evident in plate reverbs; it also includes internal chorus-like modulation drawn from the EMT 250, though what it definitely does have in common with plates is that there are no pronounced early reflections and the reverb density builds up quite quickly. This type of reverb works well for adding to material that has already been mixed or partially mixed or that contains a degree of acoustic ambience already. Typically it gives a flattering, larger-than-life sound with a nice gloss but without getting in the way, and it also works well on moving (or panned) sound sources. Of course what may be considered attributes in some situations are drawbacks in others, and a generic reverb such as this diminishes the stereo imaging of sources. Where the modulation is used, it can also cause problems with instruments that don't include any natural modulation, piano being the prime example. That's why there are different types of reverbs available for different jobs. To my ears, DVR2 sounds very much like a cross between an early Lexicon reverb and a vice-free plate, and gives a nice steamy sizzle to the sound being treated. TC's designers do seem to have worked hard to capture the authentic sound of the EMT 250 here, including electrical effects such as amplifier saturation and the original artifacts of the converters used at the that time. They've also worked to get the parameters to interact as they do in the real thing. DVR2 comes with a small but useful set of presets that can be easily tweaked by the user, and DVR2 presets can also be imported from the System 6000 platform. Compared with most software reverbs, the controls are very simple, affecting mainly the predelay, decay time, high cut and high/low damping of the reverb tail. A single slider controls the modulation and the high cut control also has a Q parameter for emphasising frequencies at and around the cutoff point. Two further buttons bring in emulations of the input transformer and low-end cut of an original EMT 250, while the Vintage Reset button claims to produce a sound that comes very close to that of a well maintained EMT 250. In high-resolution (non-vintage) mode, there's lower noise, wider bandwidth, and user control over the degree of modulation. My tests with this reverb largely supported TC's claims, insomuch as I wasn't immediately transported to a club, a concert hall or a cathedral, but the reverb provided sympathetic musical support to the material, particularly to vocals. It has the airy, larger-than-life quality that made the original EMT 250 so popular, and because the EMT 250 didn't set out to capture the less welcome aspects of real
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/pluginfolder.htm (3 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:40 PM
Plug-in Folder
plates, TC have not needed to model all the side-effects that engineers used to try desperately to EQ out of their plate reverb returns. As an addition to the existing TC Powercore reverbs, DVR2 works extremely well and provides a good alternative for material that would traditionally benefit from a plate reverb. Paul White £313 including VAT. TC Electronic UK +44 (0)800 917 8926. +44 (0)800 917 6510. Click here to email www.tcelectronic.com Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/pluginfolder.htm (4 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:40 PM
Rayzoon Jamstix
In this article:
Recommended System Requirements Flavours Of Jam Jam Today Conclusions
Rayzoon Jamstix Virtual Drummer PC VST Instrument Published in SOS November 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : VST Instruments
Rayzoon Jamstix $99 pros Real-time response to MIDI or audio input has considerable creative potential. Once mastered, can produce some very convincing results.
Virtual band members are now a regular feature in SOS reviews, but how about a virtual drummer that actually will jam with you? Rayzoon claim Jamstix is able to do just that.....
cons Does take some time to learn. Current sounds and styles less diverse than some of the obvious competition.
John Walden
Pretty soon, SOS readers are going to have to carry out extensive auditions if they want to assemble a virtual band. summary The most recent candidate for the Uniquely, Jamstix allows you electronic drumstool is Jamstix from to put the phrases 'virtual band member' and 'interesting Rayzoon, which approaches the virtual and occasionally surprising drummer idea from an interesting playing' into the same angle, the unique feature being its sentence. Rock, blues and ability to jam 'live' with either a MIDI or funk fans should check out audio input, responding to what you the Jamstix demo for a costplay in the same way that a human effective route to some new drumming inspiration. drummer might. Rayzoon have (thankfully) failed to replicate some of information the other behaviours normally associated with real drummers — but just how $99 (approximately £57). good is a Jamstix jam session? Click here to email www.rayzoon.com
Test Spec Jamstix v1.2. PC with 3.2GHz Pentium 4 CPU, 2GB RAM, Echo Mia 24, Egosys Wami Rack 24 and Yamaha SW1000XG soundcards, running Windows XP Pro SP2. Tested with Steinberg
Jamstix is available for on-line purchase directly from the Rayzoon web site and although it has been tested with a wide variety of hosts including Cubase SX, Sonar, Ableton Live and Tracktion, Rayzoon advise potential purchasers to download the demo version prior to purchase. This has a number of limitations compared to the full version, such as random audio dropouts, but does allow for compatibility testing within a user's own system. You will need a broadband connection, as Jamstix is a large download. Installation proved straightforward on my test system, and Rayzoon supply a licence key via email once a purchase has been completed. Within a couple of minutes, I was up and running with Jamstix within Cubase SX.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/jamstix.htm (1 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:45 PM
Rayzoon Jamstix
Cubase SX 3.0.1 and Groove Agent 2.0.
Jamstix includes a high-quality set of drum samples, featuring up to nine velocity layers and both close (mono) and ambient (stereo) mics that can be blended to taste. The range of drum kit styles is not extensive, perhaps suiting pop, rock and funk genres best. However, Jamstix provides a variety of ways to route its playing to alternative drum modules such as Steinberg's Groove Agent, Toontrack's DFH or FXpansion's BFD to trigger a different set of sounds. Jamstix also includes a large collection of drum patterns, intro, fills and endings to suit a range of styles. These do perhaps not cover such a wide musical territory as those found in Groove Agent but, as we'll see, a key feature of Jamstix is its ability to introduce a range of variations to those patterns much like a real drummer would do. Aside from the ability to jam, other features include a 'limb priority control' algorithm that means Jamstix will only attempt to play a combination of drums that is physically possible for a real drummer and an Arrangement screen that allows patterns to be sequenced on a bar-by-bar basis in much the same way as audio or MIDI loops might be within a sequencer application.
Recommended System Requirements Pentium III or Athlon 500MHz CPU (2GHz+ recommended). Windows XP or 2000 (Windows Me and 98SE are not supported but should work). 512MB RAM. 500MB free hard drive space. VSTi 2.0-compliant host.
Flavours Of Jam As shown in the various screenshots, the Jam, Rhythm, Arrangement, Mapping and Output tabs hide the large number of features hidden under the Jamstix hood. Three 'jam' modes are provided: Manual, Free and Keyword. In Manual mode, the Play Input button allows Jamstix to be played via a MIDI keyboard like any other drum module. Alternatively, any of the preset rhythm patterns can be loaded via the Rhythm tab and sequenced via the Arrangement tab; a maximum of 16 patterns can be loaded at any one time, although for reasons described below this is not as restrictive as it might sound. Intros, fills and endings can also be set within the Arrangement screen, so complete drum sequences can be built from scratch. Things get further off the beaten track in Free Jam mode. With Free Jam selected, Jamstix will, in essence, make up its own drum patterns on the fly and will adjust its playing to match aspects of your own playing, either in response to MIDI or audio input. Both can be live or from a pre-recorded track and a second AudioM8 plug-in is supplied. This is placed as an insert on the required audio
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/jamstix.htm (2 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:45 PM
Rayzoon Jamstix
track and routes the signal to Jamstix. With an audio input, Jamstix responds to the changes in volume (velocity) of the signal, playing more busily and louder at higher input volumes. With a MIDI input, the velocity response is similar but the rhythmic and harmonic content are also used to introduce some variations to the drumming. At the same time, the Style and Control settings can be adjusted to introduce all sorts of random variations much as a real drummer would. For example, Individual patterns can be customised within the degree of Funkiness, Complexity the Rhythm screen. and Accentuation can be adjusted within the Control section. The freshly created patterns are automatically placed within the Arrangement screen, so if you create either individual patterns or sequences that hit the spot, these can subsequently be fine-tuned and re-sequenced by switching to Manual mode. Key Word Jam allows the user to pre-select a number of the built-in rhythm patterns on the basis of key-word descriptions. These patterns are loaded into the Arrangement screen and can then be arranged in Manual mode; alternatively, Jamstix can arrange them automatically in response to a 'jam' against the audio or MIDI input as in Free mode. Again, the Control options allow the degree of variation around these patterns to be set. My initial 'jamming' felt a little clumsy: Jamstix varied its volume too much and its playing became both too busy and too loud at high input volumes. It took some time experimenting with the various controls to gradually achieve what I was after. There are aspects of the user interface and the manner in which Jamstix functions that are a little quirky, but it is certainly worth persevering: for rock, blues and funk styles, some of the results were truly excellent. The sensation of having a virtual drummer respond to the dynamics of your playing is quite remarkable, and Jamstix throws in some genuine surprises that are very unmachine-like.
Jam Today Jamstix also boasts plenty of other control options, some of which are worthy of particular mention. For example, the Arrangement screen is very straightforward to use, and right-clicking on a particular bar allows an intro, fill or ending to be inserted at a particular bar. Fills sit on top of the basic pattern, with the limb priority control ensuring things are kept within the bounds of possibility. The Toggle Locks button allows the arrangement to be locked once you have created your sequence. Within Cubase SX, arrangements can also be saved for later recall using the Save Bank option.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/jamstix.htm (3 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:45 PM
Rayzoon Jamstix
One possible criticism of Jamstix is the rather narrow range of acoustic drum samples included; while their quality and velocity response is excellent, for dance, hip-hop and electronica styles, a wider palette (such as that included with Groove Agent) is really required. However, the Mapping screen includes a Sounds panel, from where an external drum module can be selected. In essence, that drum module is loaded into Jamstix and the Jamstix performance is then routed to the drum module before being returned to Jamstix for output. As shown in the screenshot above, I tried this with Groove Agent and it worked flawlessly. This offers instant access to any other drum sounds you already have available, which is very neat. The Output screen does pretty much what you would expect. Four outputs are provided, each with its own compression controls. If you are using Jamstix's own internal drum sounds, these can be routed to any of the four outputs within the Mapping screen, and the amount of ambience added from the stereo room mics can also be controlled from the Output screen. This is very effective in moving from a dry sound through to a more 'live' Bonhamlike sound.
The Arrangement screen does exactly what it says on the tin.
The Mapping screen allows the velocity response of Jamstix relative to the input velocity (either MIDI or audio) to be adjusted for each drum or globally.
Finally, it is worth mentioning that once you have your drum sequence completed, Jamstix can output it as a MIDI file. This is useful if you want absolute control on the level of individual hits, or you need to move to a different working environment. Jamstix's four outputs all feature compression and the amount of stereo mic room ambience can be adjusted to taste.
Conclusions Jamstix adopts a very different approach to virtual drumming from that offered by Groove Agent. The key feature of live response is unique as far as I'm aware, file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/jamstix.htm (4 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:45 PM
Rayzoon Jamstix
and is both good fun and very creative, although it takes some experimentation to get the best from it. Jamstix doesn't perhaps offer as diverse a range of drumming styles or sounds as GA2 and is most certainly more complex to learn, but it will occasionally surprise you by adding some distinctly human-like touches to its playing. Given the low price, for those with an interest in rock, blues and funk, Jamstix is well worth considering: download the demo and give it a through test run. Rayzoon have a virtual bass player, Jambace, in development and, on the basis of what they have achieved with Jamstix, I'll be very keen to see what that has to offer when it is released. Published in SOS November 2005
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/jamstix.htm (5 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:45 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
In this article:
Sample Libraries: On Test
Reason Drum Kits ***** Beats Working In Cuba ***** Hot Releases Assessed Published in SOS November 2005 The Giovani Edition *****
Star Fifth Beatles ***** George Martin
Print article : Close window
Reviews : Sound/Song Library
**** Brian Epstein *** Stuart Sutcliffe ** Phil Spector
Reason Drum Kits *****
* Yoko Ono
REFILL On the evidence of this huge and detailed Refill, it seems clear that Propellerhead see their prime product, Reason, as much more than a loop-based dance tool. As you might guess, the focus is on the drum kit, as in kick, snare, toms, hi-hats, and cymbals. (Oh, and hand claps and finger snaps.) Names to drop here include Yamaha, Ludwig, Pearl, Zildjian, Meinl, and Paiste; if you need to know exact drums and head sizes, the printed manual reveals all. The kits were set up at Stockholm's Atlantis Studio. Classic mics recorded the drums to analogue tape, after which the lot was transferred to a Pro Tools HD system at 176.4kHz/24-bit resolution. The Refilling process has resulted in a well-recorded, well-edited, well-organised collection of NNXT sampler patches, both of full kits and of individual drums from which you can assemble custom kits. The set also features some simpler offerings for the Redrum drum machine, plus a smattering of RV7000 reverb and Scream 4 distortion patches. (There are no Combinator patches, as this library was released before Reason 3.) After the drums, the room, and the recording, the big issue here is multisampling, or Hypersampling as Propellerhead put it. NNXT's velocity-fired layering abilities are pushed into overdrive, and you soon learn not be surprised at seeing 14 samples assigned to a key. In addition, multi-mic setups have been faithfully reproduced, so you'll be able to mix close-miked main drums with overhead cymbal mics (complete with spill from the kit) and ambient mics that add the sound of the main room. Thus, the 14-layer sample just mentioned would turn up three times — once up close, once from the overheads, and once from the ambient mics — yet be triggered from one key. It's up to you to mix the result, via the NNXT's individual audio outs, which is a doddle courtesy of standardised routing and keymapping throughout (a handy little chart serves as an aide memoire).
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/sampleshop.htm (1 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:50 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
If all this sounds like it could become a little sample heavy, you'd be right — there are over 10000 samples on the installation DVD. And Propellerhead are ahead of you: stereo variants of kits and individual drums are joined by close-miked and 'no ambience' varieties, so you're not committed to maxing out your RAM and CPU load. The Redrum patches seem a bit token when compared to the NNXT offerings, but are welcome nonetheless. In addition, the whole lot is supplied as independent 16-bit and 24-bit Refills — the latter nearly 2GB in size — the contents of which are otherwise identical. It's impossible to pick out favourite kits or sounds — it's all good, if a little samey after an hour or two of auditioning. Even Propellerhead's grouping into pop, rock, and vintage soul/funk kits seems arbitrary. Familiarise yourself with what's on offer and choose the kits or drum sounds that suit your session. Then fix it in the mix! Derek Johnson Reason Refill DVD-ROM, £79 including VAT. M Audio UK +44 (0)1923 204010. +44 (0)1923 204039. www.maudio.co.uk www.propellerheads.se
Beats Working In Cuba ***** INTAKT INSTRUMENT This is another of Zero G's sample libraries based around an Intakt instrument front end — for information on this software's functionality, have a look back at the East West/Zero G instruments review back in SOS February 2005. As suggested by the title, this particular collection is a percussion and drum library, and the 'in Cuba' tag is a genuine one — all the recording was done in Estudios Abdala, a modern recording studio located near Havana, Cuba, and performed by established Cuban musicians. Indeed, full details of the recording process are provided in a DVD video that is included within the package. This is a really nice bonus and demonstrates the authenticity of the sounds and playing included within the collection. This is complemented further by a detailed HTML-based document which, given the size of the library, is very helpful for the new user trying to find their way around the contents. The sample content is provided on two DVD-ROMs and occupies approximately 8GB of hard drive space. The samples are dominated by multitracked loops but there are also a large number of individual drum hits supplied for those users who want to build their own loops or augment those provided. The library covers what are considered the dominant rhythm types found in Cuban music: Cha Cha Cha, Danzon, Son Montuno, Bolero, Pilon, Son Traditional, Guajira Son, Guaracha, Mambo, Songo, Timba, Conga Habanera (Carnival), and Conga Moderna. Some of the styles contain additional variations, so they can be played in a 'modern' (often with a drum kit) or 'traditional' (without a drum kit) format. The file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/sampleshop.htm (2 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:50 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
single hits aside, most of the loops were recorded as an ensemble — to allow all the performing musicians to get into the groove — but with multiple microphones set up. As a result, in addition to pre-mixed stereo versions, the collection includes the outputs from each close mic and a number of 'room' mics that could be used to add ambience or to create a surround-sound configuration. A minimal amount of EQ or compression was used in the recording stage, so users can add their own to taste. When first starting to explore this library, the sheer number of Intakt patches is quite daunting. However, the contents are organised in a consistent and logical fashion. At the top level, all the material is categorised by rhythm style (Cha Cha Cha, Bolero, and so on), and within each of these categories are between 20 and 50 further subfolders. Each of these contains all the samples and loops for an individual groove arranged as a number of different Intakt patches. The first of these is always based upon a stereo mix, the full stereo loop being generally mapped to C1 using Intakt's Time Machine mode, so that it will sync to the tempo of the host sequencer. Other samples are mapped onto keys above this, and these generally include some combination of the main individual elements of the loop (for example the congas or timbales), the 'room' microphones, or, for those styles where it is appropriate, the 'modern' and 'traditional' alternatives. This arrangement works well, because, as well as giving access to the full loop, it is also possible to break it down and construct variations on it using these key elements. The bulk of the remaining Instruments within these subfolders contain each individual percussion element from the particular groove presented in Intakt's Beat Machine mode, with slices mapped to a series of keys. In use, the considerable lengths to which Zero G have gone in the recording process really do pay off. While the audio quality is very good, most importantly so are the grooves. I particularly liked those in the Bolero section, which had a lovely slow, lazy (even sexy) feel. In contrast, the more up-tempo Mambo loops had plenty of flair and a much 'hotter' vibe. I also enjoyed the Son Montuno and Congo Habanera grooves, although in truth there was little not to like — these types of rhythms are just made to dance to, and if this collection doesn't make you want to dance around your studio then, frankly, you should take up stampcollecting or train-spotting! On the downside, I would have really liked an additional single Intakt patch for each of the major musical styles, containing all of the stereo loops for that particular style mapped across the keyboard in Time Machine mode. This would be ideal for quick auditioning (much quicker than having to load each loop, in turn, into Intakt) or for occasions when mixing and matching stereo loops is all that is required for the project in hand. In addition, for the Time Machine-based loops I think the majority of users would prefer to see Intakt's Loop and Legato modes engaged by default (it is in just a few cases, but far from all). When this is done loops keeps playing as long as a key continues to be pressed, and any
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/sampleshop.htm (3 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:50 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
loops triggered play back in sync with each other. The user can change these settings, but it is a bit frustrating to have to do it on every occasion. Both of these issues could easily be addressed by an update to the Intakt patch files, so maybe Zero-G should consider offering this as an update. These minor niggles aside, there is no doubting either the quality or authenticity of the material itself. Beats Working In Cuba was obviously quite a significant undertaking for its producers and that, and the quantity of sample material, explain the fairly hefty price tag. As a result, and given that the size of the collection owes much to the multitrack format, this is probably less likely to appeal to those producers just looking for a few Hispanic loops to spice up their tracks. However, those specialising in Cuban music styles and who want their samples to be as close to the genuine article as possible will probably find this an essential purchase. John Walden Intakt Instrument (including VST, DXi, Audio Units, RTAS, and stand-alone versions), £249.99 including VAT. Time + Space +44 (0)1837 55200. +44 (0)1837 55400. Click here to email www.timespace.com www.zero-g.co.uk
The Giovani Edition ***** MULTI-FORMAT Bela D Media built their reputation on the excellent Diva solo soprano library, and this new library once again aims for the unique, offering a library purely of children's voices. Girls' and boys' choirs are recorded in 24-bit on separate DVDROMs, each having Ensemble sections of sixteen voices and Chamber sections of four voices. Both sections boast sustain, staccato, pads, and so on, and they're packed with controllable articulations such as glottals, using release triggers and crossfades. There are also phrases — from theological 'Agnus Dei' to surreal 'Mary, Mary quite contrary'! Finally you get a series of patches designed to take advantage of the bundled Vocal Control software. Hooked up to a sequencer, this utility allows for precise manipulation of phrases. A table allows you to construct up to four chained phrases, adjusting the time spent on each syllable and the point at which one phrase switches to the next. Whilst not as comprehensive in terms of phonemes as East West/Quantum Leap's Symphonic Choirs, it's a far more accessible and user-friendly approach that is surprisingly effective. A built-in Legato tool strings notes together and slurs up and down as required in a phrase. So how does it sound? In a word, natural. It's not clinical, it's not hyper-accurate, but it is, above all, moving. Considered use of the close and ambient patches can have shivers running down your spine with a single note. Never have I heard as file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/sampleshop.htm (4 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:50 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
much emotion from a choir that I wasn't conducting live myself! Whether soaring above an orchestra or blending into the background, the voices exude pathos. The playable range is restricted, as befits the vocal capabilities of the girls and boys in question, and there's no oversampling or pitch-shifting at all — the intention was to construct a pure library, not in terms of perfect pitch or harmony, but rather in terms of the naturalness of the sound. Some users might frown upon hearing one or two singers lagging behind the rest in some of the more poignant phrases, but as the session conductor was heard to quip, 'If there is a choir who can sing at perfect zero all the time, firstly give me their number; and secondly you can't afford to sample them!' However, far from being detrimental, this adds to the natural feel of the library. All this realism will be off-putting for those that want absolute perfection in every note, but if all music were perfect every session muso would already have been replaced by a synthesizer. To pitch-correct every note of a choir would be rather like strictly quantising a jazz drummer — it's just not the done thing! Pardon the paradox, but it's the impurities that make it pure. I can't be the only one thinking this way, as the first production run sold out in four days! My biggest gripe with The Giovani Edition is that it sounds so good you can't help but cry out for more — namely adult voices. Thankfully, Bela D Media are hard at work on a sister library featuring adult choirs. The two together will be a powerful combination, and now that my appetite has been whetted, I can't wait! Hilgrove Kenrick Gigastudio 3 or Kontakt 2-DVD-ROM set, £229 including VAT. Time + Space +44 (0)1837 55200. +44 (0)1837 55400. Click here to email www.timespace.com www.beladmedia.com Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/sampleshop.htm (5 of 5)10/19/2005 9:41:50 PM
SE Electronics Titan
In this article:
Titan Trials Verdict
SE Electronics Titan Multi-pattern Condenser Microphone Published in SOS November 2005
SE Electronics Titan £999
Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
pros Flattering, musical sound. Good transient response without harshness. Distinctive appearance should impress the clients! High-quality packaging and shockmount.
The capsule within this microphone has a diaphragm coated with titanium, rather than the usual gold. We find out whether it makes a difference.
cons Because the mic seems to pick up more room ambience in cardioid mode than the other models I compared it with, more care may need to be taken over the local acoustic environment when recording.
Paul White
Most large-diaphragm condenser microphones doing the rounds today are based around a gold-coated mylar diaphragm, where the gold is either evaporated or sputtered onto mylar film prior to capsule assembly. This is also true of most of the SE summary I still don't know how much of Electronics microphone range, though their new and distinctively styled multi-pattern Titan is something of this mic's sound is down to the use of titanium, but it a departure from this tradition, because it uses certainly has a subtly titanium rather than gold for the conductive flattering musicality of its own. diaphragm coating. information £999 including VAT. Sonic Distribution +44 (0) 1582 470260. +44 (0)1582 470269. Click here to email www.sonicdistribution.com www.seelectronics.com
Apparently, titanium is much more dimensionally stable than gold when subjected to temperature change. Vocal mics in particular have to exist in a fairly harsh environment, where warm, damp air is Photos: Mike Cameron being breathed over them all the time, so if the gold expands at a different rate to the mylar beneath it, then it's reasonable to assume that the mic's character will change. Another issue is that gold-coated diaphragms can wrinkle over time due to the unevenly matched expansion coefficients of gold and mylar, whereas the SE Electronics designers expect titanium to give better longevity in this respect. Beyond such matters of stability, I can't see why the choice of metal should affect the tonality of the microphone in any significant way, as its primary function is to act as a charge-carrying electrode, though the designers believe that it is a significant contributory factor. The bulk of the moving mass is made up of the
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/setitan.htm (1 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:55 PM
SE Electronics Titan
mylar —the metallic coating is typically only a few atoms thick, whereas mylar membranes tend to be between three and six microns thick — so I would have thought that the mechanics would have been dominated by the physical properties of the mylar rather than its conductive coating. The casework and shockmount design are certainly eye catching, but other than the new diaphragm material the rest of the engineering design is unashamedly traditional. Centre termination has been used for the dual-diaphragm, multipattern capsule, while the onboard preamp is based around tried-and-tested Class-A FET circuitry with a transformerless balanced output stage. The mic needs only standard 48V phantom power, and there are horizontal toggle switches below the basket to bring in a 10dB pad and a low-frequency rolloff filter. A further switch selects cardioid, omni, or figure-of-eight polar patterns. According to the manual, the microphone has a particularly good transient response, so in addition to its obvious application as a vocal microphone it should also be well suited to recording percussive instruments. On paper, the Titan's frequency response covers 20Hz-20kHz, but checking the frequency plot reveals a gently rising response with a presence peak up at around 10kHz, which no doubt helps the microphone resolve transient detail. The sensitivity of the microphone is 40mV/Pa ±2dB (reference 1V/Pa at 1kHz), which puts it in about the same ball park as other studio capacitor microphones, but the 18dBA EIN, while typical of many competing products, is not nearly as quiet as the best. The maximum SPL for 0.5 percent THD at 1kHz is 128dB, which again isn't particularly high by modern standards, but should be adequate for anything other than close-miking exceptionally loud sources such as kick drums and some brass instruments. The mic's circuitry is mounted on two small circuit boards, with surfacemount components appearing alongside discrete FETs and transistors to increase the board density. The capsule, which is around one inch in diameter, is perched on an isolation mounting inside the dual-layer, spherical steel basket, while the body itself is made from machined brass. I feel the basket could have been made a bit tougher, but provided that you take reasonable care with the mic, it should stand up fine to normal usage and it could be argued that anything heavier might have interfered with the sound. A further machined locking ring secures the microphone to the included shockmount, and the whole kit is shipped in a foam-lined camera case, complete with an XLR cable.
Titan Trials I set up the Titan in its shockmount and tried it first on vocals. Its resistance to popping seemed rather better than that of most capacitor mics, no doubt due to
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/setitan.htm (2 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:55 PM
SE Electronics Titan
the larger than usual basket. Because there are very few physical obstructions close to the capsule, the sound is also rather less constricted and more threedimensional than I'm used to hearing from a large-diaphragm microphone, especially when in cardioid mode, which is the most challenging in this respect. Having said that, a separate pop shield is still a good idea, as you can make the mic pop if you try. When working fairly close to the microphone, the proximity effect adds a degree of warmth without making the sound boomy or over-coloured, though the low-cut switch can be brought in if necessary to counter this. While the low end is warm and solid, the high end is open and airy, but in a very smooth way. Overall, the sound is flattering and intimate, but not at all hard or harsh. My tests with acoustic guitar were interesting, because right away I felt the mic was picking up rather more of the room ambience in cardioid mode than the other cardioid mics I was using for comparison. In the right room, this conjures up a nice sense of space, but where the room is less than ideal it may be necessary to take a little more care than usual setting up acoustic absorbers around the recording area. I can only assume from this that the cardioid pattern is on the wide side of normal, and though this means that the angle of capture is wider, it also tends to produce a more open sound with better rear rejection than a tightly focussed cardioid. The tonal change between cardioid and figure-of-eight is subtle, and moving to omni opens the sound up more, involving the room ambience to a greater extent. Finally I tested the mic on some hand percussion and found that it captured the transient character of the sound in a very convincing and natural way. As with acoustic guitar, you get the impression of accuracy, though in reality there is some subtle flattery going on. What the Titan doesn't do is add an artificial edge to transient sounds as some mics seem to do — the result is always very musical and spacious.
Verdict The Titan comes towards the top of the SE Electronics price range and is aimed at professional users and very serious project studios. I can't say for sure that the mic would sound any different if a conventional gold coating had been used in place of titanium, but, whatever the technical reasons, this microphone has a distinct and very musical character.
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/setitan.htm (3 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:55 PM
SE Electronics Titan
As a vocal mic, the Titan should suit a wide range of singers and styles, as its presence peak is above that part of the spectrum responsible for harshness, while its subtle flattery really makes for a classy and intimate sound. What struck me most on a subjective level was the spacious and involving sound in cardioid mode, though the silky top end is equally impressive in its ability to open up the sound and enhance detail without adding hardness or sounding in any way brash. Overall, the Titan certainly doesn't sound like a 'me too' microphone, and I'm sure it will take its place alongside the Gemini as a serious contender that people choose because of its distinctive sonic character. Published in SOS November 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///F|/SoS/SoS%2011-2005/setitan.htm (4 of 4)10/19/2005 9:41:55 PM
SSL AWS900
In this article:
What Exactly Is The AWS900? Superanalogue Circuitry Channel Facilities Cues & Auxes Meters & Routing Options Channel Fader & Rotary Encoder Master Section Assignable Dynamics Processors Monitoring DAW Control On Session With The AWS900
SSL AWS900 Mixer & Control Surface Published in SOS November 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Mixer
With their latest Superanalogue console, SSL bring the sonics and functionality of their flagship SL9000K to studios with smaller rooms and budgets. In the process, they've incorporated comprehensive controlsurface facilities for driving computer DAWs remotely. But can the AWS900 really live up to its pedigree?
SSL AWS900 £58163 pros Superanalogue signal paths. Switchable E/G-series EQ. Flexible dynamics facilities. Extremely versatile signal routing. HUI-format interfacing maximises DAW compatibility. Superb DAW integration ergonomics. Comprehensive monitoring and talkback.
cons Only two channel dynamics processors. No channel surround panning facilities. AWSomation and Total Recall are cost options.
summary A fully featured SSL console in looks, sound, and facilities, but at a price that makes it affordable for mid-range studios, tracking rooms, and post houses. The superbly engineered DAW interface and integrated automation and recall facilities are the
Hugh Robjohns
The acronym SSL is likely to be recognised immediately by everyone re