Electric Field Applications in Chromatography, Industrial and Chemical Processes
Edited by Takao Tsuda
Wiley-VCH
Ele...
94 downloads
1877 Views
16MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Electric Field Applications in Chromatography, Industrial and Chemical Processes
Edited by Takao Tsuda
Wiley-VCH
Electric Field Applications in Chromatography, Industrial and Chemical Processes Edited by Takao Tsuda
4b
VCH
Weinheim . New York . Base1 * Cambridge . Tokyo
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Electric Field Applications Edited by T. Tsuda
VCH Verlagsgesellschaft mbH, D-69451 Weinhelm, (Federal Republic of Germany). 1995 Distribution: VCH. P. 0. Box 10 I 1 h l 1)-69451 ~ Wcinheim (Federal Republic of Germany) Switzerland: VC'H, P 0.Box, CH-4020 Basel (Switzerland) United Kingdom and Irland: VCH. X Wellington Court, Cilmbridge CBI I H Z (United Kingcknii) USA and Canada: VCH, 220 East 23rd Street, New York, NY 10010-4606 (USA) Japan: VCH, Eikow Huilding. 10-1) Flongo I-chorne. Bunkyo-ku, Ibkyo 113 (Japan) ISBN 3-527-28687-X
Electric Field Applications in Chromatography, Industrial and Chemical Processes Edited by Takao Tsuda
4b
VCH
Weinheim . New York . Base1 * Cambridge . Tokyo
Prolessor Takao Twda Nagoya lnstltute of Technology Ciokiso, Showa, Nagoya 466 Japan
This book was carefully produced. Nevertheless. the editor, authors and publisher do not warrant the information contained therein to bc free of errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that statements, data. illustrations, procedural details or other items may inadvei-lcntlybe inaccurate.
Puhlishcd jointly by VCH Verlagsgcscllschalt mbII, Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany) VCH Publishers, Inc., New York, NY (IJSA)
Editorial Directors: Dr. Christina Dyllick-Brcnzinger, Karin Sora Production Manager: Peter J. Die1
Library of Congress Card N o . applicd for British Library Cataloguiiig-in-Publication Data: A catalogue record lor this book is available from the British Library. Die I k u t s c h c Bibliothck CIP-Einheitsaufnahinc Electric field applications in chromatography, industrial and chemical processes / cd. by Takao Tsuda. - Weinheim ; New York ;Basel : C:anihridgc ; Tokyo : VCH, 1995 ISBN 3-527-28687-X NE: Tsuda, Tikao [Hrsg.] ~
0 VCI1 Verlag5gc~cllschaltmhH, D-69451 Weinhelm (Federal Republic of Germany), 1995 Printed on acid-ti ee and low-chlorine paper All rights reservcd (including those of translation into other languages). No part of this hook may be reproduced in any form - by photoprinting. microfilm, or any other incans - nor lransmitted or trailslated into a machine language without writtell permission from the publishers. Kegistcrcd narncs. trademarks, etc. used in this book. cvcn when not specifically marked as such, arc not to be considered unprotected by law.
Composition: Mitterweger Werksatz GmhH,D-68723 Plankstadt Printing: Bctzdruck GmbH, D-642 19 Ilarmstadt Hnokhiiiding: Grolibuchbinderei J. Sch2ffer CmhH & Co. KG, D-67269 Criinstadt Printcd i n the Federal Republic of Oernlany
To my parents, Sukesaburo and Tamiko Tsuda, for their encouragement throughout my life.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface
Research and development in both academic and industrial laboratories frequently involves sophisticated methods and techniques often based on the application of electrical, magnetic, centrifugal, or adsorptive forces. Electrical forces are probably the most widely used since they are very flexible in the sense that they can (1) generate a great number of chemical and physical phenomena (including magnetism, heat and light), (2) affect both inanimate and living matter in many different ways and (3) easily be regulated, by means of constant or (extremely rapidly) pulsating direct voltage, or alternating voltage of almost any frequency. If an electric field is combined with a magnetic field the area of application is still larger. Such combinations are not used as widely as they deserve to be; the area is almost virgin soil for truly basic research! Rotation of a liquid or liquid droplet is only one instance of what can be done by this approach to solve several technical problems. This book is divided into three parts: 0 Electrochromatography (Chapters 2-6) , 0 Applications of electric fields in industrial processes (Chapters 7-11), and 0 Applications of electric fields for concentration, immunoassay and molecular
orientation (Chapters 12-14). At first glance, the scope of the book seems very broad, but the unifying feature is that the electric field causes primarily either a displacement of solvent (a phenomenon called electroosmosis) or an orientation andor a migration of solute (electrophoresis). The contents of the book are, from this point of view, relatively limited but are broad on practical topics. This is an attractive approach, since it shows the analogy among and the interplay between various techniques, which gives a creative reader many new ideas. It is quite natural that several chapters (Chapters 2-6) deal with electrochromatography, since the editor of the book, Professor Takao Tsuda, introduced this powerful separation method in 1982. An attractive feature of the method is that the mobile phase moves through the bed by means of electroosmosis; no expensive pump is required. Another advantage is that the electroosmotic flow profile is flatter than the hydrodynamic one and thus causes less broadening of the solute zone. Packed or opentubular capillary columns are commonly used for this purpose. We introduced recently so-called continuous beds and they might be preferable in electrochromatography. As far as detection methods are concerned, one can expect mass spectrometry to become the method of choice in the near future in electrochromatography as well as in many other microchromatographic techniques, as pointed out in Chapter 6. Most chemical syntheses and extraction processes are performed by the mechanical mixing of solutes. To decrease the reaction or equilibration time (i.e., to increase the collision frequency among solute molecules) the experiments are often carried out
VIII
Preface
with stirring. This approach is not always convenient, for example when the reaction volumes are extremely small or large, when dilution of the solutes is to be avoided, or when the reaction vessel must have a certain shape, for instance a thin disk or sheet. In such cases “electrophoretic or electric mixing” may be preferable. Examples are presented in the chapters dealing with immunoassay (Chapter 13), solvent extraction (Chapters 10 and 11) and the manufacture of ceramics (Chapter 8). The latter two are examples of industrial applications. It is fascinating to see how an electric field can increase the reaction (extraction) speed by its capacity to produce small droplets and nonlaminar streaming. It is well-known that free-draining polymers, such as DNA molecules, align themselves in parallel chains in strong electric fields. For a variety of reasons one can expect such oriented structures with specifically adsorbed molecules and lined up carbon particles to be studied in the near future. The chapters on photochemistry (Chapter 14) and electro-rheological fluids (Chapter 9) present these topics. Removal of water by electroosmosis is a method which dates back to 1809, but has recently come back into use for large-scale industrial operations (Chapter 7). Desalting is another industrial application of the electric field (Chapters 11 and 12). By means of a voltage gradient one can also control the viscosity of a liquid, and this technology is useful in car production (Chapter 9). The experiments described in this book refer to outer, artificial electric fields. It is, however, fascinating to consider whether the electric fields in biological systems are of any importance. One should remember that a small voltage over a small distance, such as the dimensions of a living cell, gives rise to a high electric field strength. In preparing this preface I have become more convinced than ever that one should encourage publication of scientific - and popular - books of interdisciplinary nature. Together with interdisciplinary symposia, books such as this serve the important function to stimulate to discussions between people with different areas of expertise. Stellan Hjerttn Department of Biochemistry Uppsala University Sweden
Table of Contents
1
Introduction and Summary 1 Takao Tsuda
Part 1 Electrochromatography 11 2
Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry 13 Takao Tsuda, Shinya Kitagawa
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5
Theory of Band Broadening 13 Apparent Mean Linear Flow Velocity and Elution Time 14 Processes in Band Broadening 14 Electrochromatography Zones 17 Profiles of Pressurized Flow, Electroosmotic Flow, and Zones of Ionic Solutes 18 Flow Profiles of Pressurized Flow 18 Flow Profiles of Electroosmosis in an Open Tube 19 Flow Profiles for Charged Molecules 27 Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromatography on Microlcolumns 29 Instrumentation 29 Features and Operational Factors 31 Chromatographic Behavior in Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromatography 32 Chromatographic Variation due to the Application of High Voltage 35 Relation between Elution Time Ratio and pH 35 Variation of Electrophoretic and Electroosmotic Flow Velocities with pH 37 Dependence of Electrophoretic and Electroosmotic Velocities on the Composition of Eluents Containing Methanol 39 Ion-Exchange Chromatography in an Electric Field 40 Voltage-Programmed Electrochromatography 42 References 45
2.5.1 2.5.2 2.5.3 2.6 2.6.1 2.6.2 2.6.3 2.6.4 2.6.5 2.6.6 2.6.7 2.6.8 2.6.9 2.7
3
Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography 47 Takao Tsuda
3.1 3.1.1 3.1.2 3.1.3
Electroosmosis 47 Surface Charge of Silica Gel and Packing Support 47 Electrical Potential in the Vicinity of a Solid Surface 48 Origin of Electroosmotic Flow 50
X
Table of Contents
3.1.4 3.1.5 3.1.6
Thickness of the Double-Layer 51 Charge Density on Silica Gel Surfaces 53 Chemical Modification of the Inner Surface by Adsorption in Open-Tubular Capillary Columns 54 3.1.7 Effect of pH on Electroosmosis 55 3.1.8 Electroosmotic Mobility in Open-Tubular Capillary Columns 56 3.1.9 Electroosmotic Flow Velocity in Packed Columns 56 3.2 Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography and Electrochromatography 59 3.2.1 Electroosmotically Driven Electrochromatography 59 3.2.2 Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography 61 3.2.2.1 Open-Tubular Capillary Columns 61 3.2.2.2 Packed Microcapillary (Drawn Packed Capillary) Columns 66 3.2.2.3 Slurry-Packed Capillary Columns 70 3.2.3 Advantages of Electroosmotic Flow for Liquid Chromatography 72 References 73 3.3 4
Electrochromatography with Radial Applied Voltage : Ion Separation by Electrochemical Approach 75 Tsutomu Nagaoka
4.1 4.2 4.2.1 4.2.2 4.3
Introduction 75 Experimental Details 76 Design of the Electrode Column 76 Preparation of Stationary Phases 77 Redox Separation of Electroactive Metals on the Conductive Stationary Phase 79 Direct Electrostatic Interactions for Potential-Dependent Separation of Electroinactive Species 80 Pretreated Carbon for the Separation of Metal Ions 80 Stationary Phase Coated with Crown Ether for the Separation of Alkali Metal Ions 80 Electrosorption for the Separation of Neutral Organic Compounds 82 Indirect Electrostatic Interactions for Potential-Dependent Separation of Electroinactive Species 83 Conducting Polymers for Separation of Anions 83 Summary 88 References 88
4.4 4.4.1 4.4.2 4.4.3 4.5 4.5.1 4.6 4.7 5
Electrochromatography in Biomolecular Analysis 91 Daniel H. Shain
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.6.1 5.6.2
Introduction 91 Significance 91 Characteristics of Biomolecules 92 Development of Electrochromatographic Techniques 94 Gel Electrophoresis 96 Electrochromatography in Preparative Columns 97 Sequential Electrochromatography 97 Electrochromatography with Modern Adaptions to Liquid Chromatography 99 Focusing in Columns 104
5.6.3
XI
Table of Contents
5.7 5.7.1 5.7.2 5.7.3 5.7.4 5.8 5.9
Electrochromatography in Microcolumns 108 Electro-Osmotically-Driven Electrochromatography 109 Pressurized Flow Driven Electrochromatography 111 Micellar Electrokinetic Capillary Chromatography 111 Capillary Gel Electrophoresis 111 Conclusions and Future Directions 112 References 113
6
Electrochromatography for Focusing, Counter-Current, Mass Spectrometry, and Tho-Dimensional Separation 117 Takao Tsuda
6.1 6.1.1
Continuous In-Column Sample Focusing 117 Multiple Injection for Accumulating a Charged Component in the Column 117 Continuous Sample Introduction for In-Column Sample Focusing 118 Rotation Locular Counter-Current Electrochromatography 120 Instrumentation 120 Preparative-Scale Electrochromatography with a Counter-Current Chromatographic Column 122 ElectrochromatographylMass Spectrometry 123 Instrumentation 123 Combination of Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromatography and Mass Spectrometry 124 Two-Dimensional Preparative Chromatography with Continuous Injection 126 Continuous Preparative Electrochromatography : a Large Cylindrical Column with Rotation 127 Separation of a Test Mixture 128 References 129
6.1.2 6.2 6.2.1 6.2.2 6.3 6.3.1 6.3.2 6.4 6.4.1 6.4.2 6.5
Part 2 Applications of Electric Fields in Industrial Processes 131 7
Electroosmotic Dewatering 133 Masashi Iwata
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.4.1 7.4.2 7.4.3 7.4.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8
Introduction 133 Electroosmotic Flow through a Capillary 134 Electroosmosis in Porous Media 136 Electroosmotic Dewatering of Compressible Solid-Liquid Mixtures Experimental 137 Theory 137 Physical Properties of the Material 141 Comparison of Theory and Experiment 142 Industrial Applications 147 Conclusions 149 Nomenclature 150 References 151
137
XI1
Table of Contents
8
Electrophoretic Forming of Ceramics 153 Takao Tsuda and Hideki Ishida
8.1 8.2
Electrophoretic Behavior of Inorganic Particles in Aqueous Solution 154 Selection of Organic Solvents for Electrodeposition of Inorganic Particles Dispersed in Organic Solution 155 Electrophoretic and Electroosmotic Forming 156 History 156 Industrial Applications of Electrophoretic and Electroosmotic Forming 158 Control of Particle Diameter for High Productivity and a Low Water Content in Electrical Forming 161 Zeta-Potential of Raw Materials 164 Electrodes 164 Electrophoretic Forming Continuous Ceramic Sheet 166 References 169
8.3 8.3.1 8.3.2 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7 8.8 9
Control of Viscosity by Electric Fields: Novel Materials for ElectroRheological Fluids and their Applications 171 Yuichi Ishino, Tasuku Saito, Norio Goshima, and Kazuya Takano
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.3.1 9.3.2 9.3.3 9.4 9.5 9.6
Introduction 171 Fundamental Characteristics of ERF 171 Development of the Dispersed Phase 175 Chelate Resin 175 Porous Silica Microspheres 178 Carbonaceous Particulate Phases 179 Applications 181 Conclusion 184 References 184
10
Application of Electric Fields to Solvent Extraction 185 Manabu Yamaguchi
10.1 10.2 10.2.1 10.2.2 10.2.3 10.3 10.3.1 10.3.2 10.3.3 10.4 10.5
Introduction 185 Theory 186 Hybrid Flow and Enhanced Mass Transfer Around Drops 187 Electrostatic Liquid Dispersion 192 Electrostatic Drop - Drop Coalescence 194 Electrostatic Liquid-Liquid Extraction 195 Electrostatic Spray Column 195 Electrically Assisted Mixer - Settler Extractor 196 Electrostatic Pseudo-Liquid Membrane Extractor 200 Nomenclature 201 References 203
Table of Contents
11
XI11
Applications of the Electric Fields to the Resolution of Water-in-Oil Emulsions 205 Manabu Yamaguchi
Introduction 205 Fundamental Relationships 206 Dielectrophoresis 206 Computational Simulation of Chain Formation 208 Observation of Chain Formation 209 Electrophoresis 211 Effect of Electric Fields on Resolution of Water-in-Oil Dispersions 212 Electrostatic Resolution of Emulsion in the Oil Industry 213 Dehydration 213 Desalting 215 Electrostatic Phase Separation of Rich Water-in-Oil Emulsions in Liquid Membrane Separation 219 11.4.1 Membrane Recovery in Liquid Membrane Separation 219 Conclusions 226 11.5 Nomenclature 226 11.6 References 227 11.7
11.1 11.2 11.2.1 11.2.2 11.2.3 11.2.4 11.2.5 11.3 11.3.1 11.3.2 11.4
Part 3 Applications of Electric Fields for Concentration, Immunoassay and Molecular Orientation 229 12
Dynamic Electroconcentration Processes in Analytical Chemistry 231 Takao Tsuda
12.1
Collection of Metal Ions from Acid Solutions by Hydrodynamic Recycling 231 Electrodialysis for Desalting or Concentration of Metal Ions by Multiple Ion-Exchange Chambers 233 Counter-Current Electroconcentration 236 Principles 236 Apparatus 239 Examples 240 Operational Stability 241 Electroosmosis and Electrophoretic Mobility for Counter-Current Electroconcentration 241 Electroosmosis for Sample Transfer 242 Electrodeposition of Metal Ions and their Selective Release 244 Electrochromatographic Solid-Phase Extraction 245 Operational Procedure 245 Use of Electrochemical Reactions for Decomposition of Metal Complexes 247 Conclusions 248 References 248
12.2 12.3 12.3.1 12.3.2 12.3.3 12.3.4 12.4 12.5 12.6 12.7 12.7.1 12.8 12.9 12.10
XIV
Tuble of Contents
13
Pulse Immunoassay and Pulse Electrovoltage for Cell Manipulation and Analytical Coagulation Processes 249 Eiichi Tamiya
13.1 13.2 13.2.1 13.2.2 13.2.3 13.2.4 13.3
Introduction 249 Pulsed Immunoassay for Pathogenic Cells 249 Experimental Procedures 250 Effect of Pulse Conditions on Linear Agglutination 251 Agglutination by Immunoreaction in an Electric Field 251 Calibration for C. albicans 254 Alternating Current Field Enhancing Latex Immunoassay for Human Myoglobin 254 Experimental Procedures 255 Agglutination Induced by a.c. fields 256 Time Course of Immunoreactions 258 A Micromachined Reactor for Latex Immunoassay Enhanced by a.c. Fields 260 Experimental Procedures 260 Design of Micromachined Reactors 260 Application to Immunoassay for AFP 261 Conclusions 263 References 263
13.3.1 13.3.2 13.3.3 13.4 13.4.1 13.4.2 13.4.3 13.5 13.6 14
Molecular Orientation of Organic Compounds in Electric Fields: Organized Photochemistry 265 Katsuhiko Takagi
14.1 Introduction 265 14.2 Photochemical Reactions 266 14.2.1 Applied Electrostatic Fields 266 14.2.2 Spontaneous Electrostatic Fields 270 14.2.3 Micelles 270 14.2.4 Energy and Electron Transfer 271 14.2.5 Miscellaneous Reactions 277 14.2.6 Reversed Micelles 280 14.2.7 Vesicles 282 14.2.8 Mono- and Multilayer Membranes 283 14.2.9 Polyelectrolytes 286 14.2.10 Inorganic Solid Surfaces 287 14.3 References 295
Index 301
List of Contributors
Norio Goshima Research & Development Division Bridgestone Corp. 3-1-1 Ogawahigashicho, Kodaira-shi, Tokyo 187 Japan Chapter 9 Stellan HjertCn Department of Biochemistry, University of Uppsala P.O. Box 576, S-75 123 Uppsala Sweden Preface Hideki Ishida Basic Research Center, INAX Corporation Koiehonmachi, Tokoname, Aichi 479 Japan Chapter 8 Yuichi Ishino Research & Development Division Bridgestone Corp. 3-1-1 Ogawahigashicho, Kodaira-shi, Tokyo 187 Japan Chapter 9 Masashi Iwata Department of Industrial Chemistry, Suzuka National College of Technology Shiroko-cho Suzuka 510-02 Japan Chapter 7
Shinya Kitagawa Nagoya Institute of Technology Gokiso, Showa, Nagoya 466 Japan Chapter 2 Tsutomu Nagaoka Department of Applied Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering Yamaguchi University 2557 Tokiwadai, Ube 755 Japan Chapter 4 Tasuku Saito Research & Development Division Bridgestone Corp. 3-1-1 Ogawahigashicho, Kodaira-shi, Tokyo 187 Japan Chapter 9 Daniel H. Shain Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Colorado State University Fort Collins Collorado 80523 United States Chapter 5 Katsuhiko Takagi Department of Applied Chemistry School of Engineering, Nagoya University Chikusa-ku Nagoya 464-01 Japan Chapter 14
XVI
List of Contributors
Kazuya Takano Original Equipment Industrial Products Division Bridgestone Corp. Kashiwao-cho, Tozuka-ku, Yokohama 244 Japan Chapter 9 Eiichi Tamiya Japan Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (JATST) Asahidai, Tatsunokuchi, Nomi-gun, Ishikawa, 923-12 Japan Chapter 13
Takao Tsuda Nagoya Institute of Technology Gokiso, Showa, Nagoya 466 Japan Chapters I , 2, 3, 6, 8, 12 Manabu Yamaguchi Department of Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering Science Osaka University 1-3 Machikaneyama, Toyonaka 560, Osaka Japan Chapters 10,11
1
Introduction and Summary Takao Tsuda
The applications of electric fields are one of the most exciting topics in Science today. The introduction of electric fields in chromatography, industrial processes, and unit chemical processes offers the prospect of remarkable advances with its application in areas ranging from separation technology to the oil industry. When we apply an electric field to a column or a solution by using two electrodes, a microelectric field is induced at every point. The value of the induced potential gradient depends on the characteristics of the local matrix. Under these potential gradients a charged molecule moves (electrophoretic mobility). The local electric field on a solid surface induces surface charges, and hence electroosmosis [1.11, [1.21. A high local potential gradient imposed on the surface adsorption layer leads to orientation of organic molecules. A droplet of water or oil is deformed and dispersed into a group of small droplets under an applied electric field. The micro particles of solid in a medium line up in the electric field, keeping their energy to a minimum. This book is divided into three sections: I) Electrochromatography 11) Application of electric fields for industrial processes 111) Application of electric fields for concentration, immunoassay, and molecular orientation Electrochromatography is a unique separation method with high selectivity and efficiency and has potential for a wide range of applications. There are a number of remarkable industrial applications, where electric fields induce unique phenomena. Some processes, including the application of voltage have energy-saving potential. The third section presents: a) a unique concentration method based on electrochemistry and electrical phenomena; b) agglutination induced by electric fields, which is very useful for rapid immunoassay; and c) induced molecular orientation including stereospecific alignment within micro cavities. Throughout this book, the electric field, in macro- or micro-spaces plays a key role.
Part 1 Electrochromatography Liquid chromatography is now commonly used for the separation of mixtures and is well established as a very efficient method [1.3]. Separation relies on the partition between a mobile and stationary phase. The mobile phase, containing the solute, moves through the column by pressurized flow. During this period the solute moves between the stationary phase and the mobile phase by diffusion. The partition ratio of a solute, the distribution of a solute between staionary and mobile phase, depends on its molecular nature.
2
1 Introduction and Summary
Electrophoresis is also used for the separation of biomolecules. The separation obtained with gel electrophoresis has the highest resolution, especially for the nucleotides and proteins. The separation process in electrophoresis is based on the electrophoretic mobility of a solute. Sometimes the solute will temporarily be in contact with or be adsorbed by the matrix i. e., when partition occurs. TGavoid these contacts, salts and/or urea are added to the medium to decrease the adsorptive ability of the matrix. To some extent there is an interaction between solute and matrix in electrophoresis. It is, therefore, reasonable to consider that the separation sometimes proceeds with electrophoretic mobility and partition between medium and gel network. Electrochromatography is a combined form of chromatography and electrophoresis [ 1.41. Its separation processes include both phase partition and solute electrophoretic mobility. Therefore, electrochromatography can be a very efficient separation method [1.5], 11.61. The term was first used by Berraz [1.7] in 1943, in referring to a primitive form of paper electrophoresis. Paper electrochromatography has been applied to the separation of metal cations by Strain and coworkers [1.8], [1.9]. They used the electrophoretic mobilities of metal ions and their sorptive interaction with paper. The sorptive interaction was confirmed by the observation of the effect of sample concentration on elution time, (nonlinear isotherms) [1.81. Polysaccharides have been separated by paper electrochromatography by using an electroosmotic flow as a driving force [1.10]. Amino acids and carboxylic acids have been separated on paper impregnated with stannic arsenate [1.11], hydrated zirconium oxide [ 1.121, and titanium tungstate [ 1.131. In these separations two factors, ion exchange and electrophoretic mobility, both contributed. Thin layer elcctrochromatography has also been attempted [1.14]-[1.16]. The bed was agar gel deposited on a glass plate. Plain agar gel already has cation-exchange properties, and separation of hemoglobins below their isoelectric points have been performed by both electrophoretic mobility and ion exchange in parallel [1.14], y1.151. Yaron and Sober [ 1.161 provided conclusive evidence that ion exchange increases the resolving power of electrophoresis of oligonucleotides and oligopeptides. These authors insisted on the importance of working at a pH close to the pK value of the ionexchange group. Haber [ 1.171employed a cellulose filter (5 x 10 cm) or layers of other adsorbents as a flat bed. He applied a very high voltage, e. g., 10 kV. He separated the mixture of Rhodamine B and 6G in 3 s with a migration distance of 0.2 cm under the following conditions: separation medium: 40 % propylene carbonate, 40 % propylene glycol, 16 % N-methylacetamide, 4 % tetrahydrofurfuryl alcohol; bed: Whatman No. 1 paper; applied voltage 12 kV (1.2 mA) [1.17]. Haber reported very rapid separations at high applied voltage. The method has commercial potential [1.18]. In the very early days of electrochromatography, continuous paper electrochromatography was used for separation of cobaltous and ferric ions with continuous injection. The stabilization medium for the pressurized flow (2-direction) of a medium and concomitant transverse electrical migration (x-direction) is attained in a tapered filter paper [1.19].The separation depends on differences in electrophoretic mobility and ion exchange equilibrium constant. In the present book we have tried to focus on advanced column electrochromatography. Chromatography on columns is generally more reliable than paper or thin layer chromatography. Column chromatography involes elution; the solute is transferred to the end of a column and then detected. Most chromatographic processes are confined by the wall of a column. Therefore, column chromatography generally gives better qualitative and quantitative information, better reproducibility, and better resolution than paper chromatography. In elcctrochromatography, the use of a column also gives enhanced performance. Otsuka and Listowsky [ 1.201 pioneered the set up technique.
1.4 Electrochromatography with Radially Applied Voltage
1.2
3
Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry (Tsuda and Kitagawa)
The theory of the separation by electrochromatography is somewhat different from ordinary liquid chromatography. There are two new factors, electrophoretic mobility in the mobile phase and electroosmosis generated by the applied electric field [1.4], [1.21], [1.22]. These new factors can be used to improve separation. The apparent theoretical resolution depends on the flow profiles of pressurized flow, the electroosmotic flow, and the zone profile due to electrophoretic mobility. In electrochromatography, we need to apply high voltage along the column to get high migration of a solute due to electrophoretic mobility. By using a high applied voltage, e. g., 1-20 kV (200-2000 Vkm), we can separate the mixture with high resolution within 30 min, the same as conventional liquid chromatography. However, it is necessary to dissipate the Joule heat from the column. As micro- and capillary columns have high heat dissipation, they are recommended for use in analytical electrochromatography. Electrochromatography with pressurized flow is a fine method since it can be operated with good stability, and it is easy to determine the characteristic points by conventional liquid chromatography. In Chapter 2 the state-of-the-art of pressurized flow-driven electrochromatography is described.
1.3
Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography (Tsuda)
Theoretical consideration of electroosmosis and factors which affect electroosmosis, such as pH and the amount of surface charge are described. Then electroosmosis is used as the driving force for transferring solute in the column without pressurized flow. The characteristic nature of electroosmotically driven electrochromatography is compared with conventional liquid chromatography. Open-tubular capillary, packed microcapillary (drawn packed capillary), and slurry-packed capillary columns are used. The flow velocity of electroosmosis in packed capillary columns depends on the pH of the medium (namely, the number of surface charges of SiO-), and on the tortuous and constricted channels within the packing support. Fine and rapid separations are demonstrated.
1.4
Electrochromatography with Radially Applied Voltage: Electrochemical Separation of Ionic Substances (Nagaoka)
In Chapters 2 and 3, a high voltage is applied along the column. In Chapter 14 the applied voltage is between 1 and -1 V, applied in a radial direction [1.23]-[1.26]. The column is generally packed with carbon or modified carbon powders, and an electrode is inserted inside the column. In a Vycor glass tube wall there are a lot of very fine pores (30 A) passing from the inside to the outside. It is possible to position another electrode outside the column [ 1.231 or to use a stainless steel column so that the wall itself forms the electrode [1.25]. There are two kinds of solute: electroactive and electroinactive. Electroactive solutes can be deposited onto carbon packing powders under
+
4
1 Introduction und Summary
an applied voltage, and then released on removal of the applied voltage. For electroinactive solutes, it is possible to have an electrostatic interaction between the solute and charged powders.
1.5
Biomolecular Analysis by Electrochromatography (Shain)
For the separation of biochemical solutes, such as proteins and DNA fragments, acrylamide or agar gels on a flat bed show splendid separation ability. In liquid chromatography, proteins can be separated by gradient elution, but both separation modes have drawbacks. Chapter 5 introduces several applications of electrochromatography columns filled with gels [1.20], [1.27], [1.28]. Columns filled with acrylamide or agar gels are coupled with modern instrumentation for the fractionation or separation on a semipreparative and analytical scale. Related techniques for the separation of biomolecules are described, in detail.
1.6
Electrochromatography for Focusing, Counter-Current, Mass Spectrometry, and Two-Dimensional Separation (Tsuda)
This chapter includes four unique technologies which are possible only by electrochromatography. First, a charged solute, introduced stepwise or continuously in a liquid chromatographic column can be accumulated in the column when its electrophoretic velocity is sufficiently large and its flow opposes the pressurized flow [1.5], [1.29]. Second, a voltage is applied along a rotation locular counter-current column (12 X 1000 mm), which has 100 loculi. Kabasawa has demonstrated the effective separation of dyes [1.30]. Third, the combination of electrochromatography and mass spectrometry has been demonstrated by van der Greef et al. t1.311. This is a unique method. The electrochromatogram obtained shows a sharper, higher peak compared with conventional liquid chromatography (the solute is concentrated in a narrow zone). This is an important advantage for electrochromatography/mass spectrometry. Fourth, Scott proposed instrumentaion for two-dimensional separation with a continuous introduction of the sample solution [1.32]. The system is composed of an annular column of adsorbent that is slowly rotated past a stationary feed and eluate take-off points. The position of the exit points of the solute are defined by their electrophoretic mobility and distribution coefficient. In electrochromatography the applied voltage has a direct effect on a solute in a mobile phase, not in a stationary phase. However the latter might be also affected by alteration of the nature of the stationary phase or the increased amount of charge. I would like to add a comment on the method of using two different beds in a column for enhancing the separation of a mixture [1.22]. The time taken the solute to run through column is equal to the period given by [(column void volume)/(flow rate due to pressurized and/or electroosmosis)]. Each solute can stay in the mobile phase for a time period to.The electrophoretic mobility of a solute p, does not depend on the column packing material, but is constant. The ratio pJpb is always constant even for
1.8 Electrophoretic Forming of Ceramics (Tsuda and Ishida)
5
different columns, where suffixes a and b refer to different solutes. Therefore, we cannot store the solute in the column just by using a different column bed under a constant flow rate of the mobile phase, in which the column is packed with column support A and B at the upper and lower portion of the column [1.33]. From these considerations we can obtain new ideas for the column focusing of a solute. For example, when we remove a portion of the mobile phase from the centre of the column and recycle it to the top, the flow rate at the bottom of the column becomes less than at the top. Therefore, it is possible to store solute in the middle of the column if its electrophoretic mobility is smaller than the pressurized flow at the top of column and larger than the pressurized flow at the bottom.
Part 2 Applications of Electric Fields in Industrial Processes Electric fields are used in accelerating ion beams and controlling liquid crystals. They can be used for industrial processes, such as dust removal or obtaining salts from seawater by ion-exchange membranes. In Part 2, we focus on several new processes in which it is essential to use an electric field. These “electroprocesses” have advantages over processes which do not use an electric field. The electroprocesses are based on charged molecules or neutral molecules with a partial induced charge, charged particles, charged droplets, or droplets with induced charges, or dispersions of large droplets in many small droplets, or in distorted liquid droplets. Each electroprocess has a unique character, and may suggest further ideas for advanced processes.
1.7
Electroosmotic Dewatering (Iwata)
Electroosmosis is applied for the process of dewatering porous materials, such as a sludge of colloidal particles. Although mechanical dewatering is the conventional method, it is impeded by the hydrodynamic resistance of the sludge. In electroosmotic dewatering, there is no accumulation of pressure resistance during the process, because the phenomenon is a molecular one. In Chapter 7, the principal theory of electroosmotic dewatering for both ideal capillary and compressive porous media are presented, followed by model experiments 11.341. Finally, industrial applications are described. The commercial equipment for sludge treatment based on this principle is characterized by its high performance [1.35]. Electric dewatering is deemed superior to conventional dewatering processes, such as pressure-driven filtering.
1.8
Electrophoretic Forming of Ceramics (Tsuda and Ishida)
In the ceramic industry, pressure forming and slip casting by capillary attraction are generally used as production processes. In Chapter 8, electrophoretic forming is introduced as an alternative method. The brief history of this method is reviewed from the viewpoint of production conditions and raw materials. A new continuous forming method is described 11.361. When natural clay and nonplastic fine materials are mixed with water, a very viscous solution (slip) can be obtained. On application of a voltage,
6
1
Introduction and Summary
the slip is electrophoretically gathered on the surface of an electrode as a thin layer, and at the same time the thin layer is dewatered electroosmotically. By rotating the electrode, a continuous thin film is formed and subsequently fired. This unique process for obtaining a continuous fine ceramic sheet offers maximum energy saving. Physical phenomena encountered during the process are also discussed.
1.9
Control of Viscosity by Electric Fields (Ishino, Saito, Goshima, and Takano)
Electrorheological fluid (ERF) consisting of dielectric powders and insulating oil, shows a large viscosity change when a high voltage is applied [1.37]. ERF has been considered for the application to car production processes [1.38], [1.39]; a number of patent applications reflect this interest. Ishino and colleagues have also publically announced a product which is to be made available commercially. The dispersed dielectric particles line up when a voltage is applied. The selection of particles, the dependence and the rapid response of viscosity to applied voltage, and a possible geometrical design for practical application are discussed.
1.10
Applications of Electric Fields to Solvent Extraction (Yamaguchi)
Solvent extraction technologies in the hydrometallurgy, chemical, and oil industries are vcry important. The extraction processes dealing with liquid drops can be enhanced by producing a large interfacial area of drops for diffusion and a higher degree of turbulence outside the drops for eddy diffusion. The application of an electric field meets these requirements [1.40], and this technique promises become an extremely efficient industrial extraction process. Yamaguchi describes the theoretical treatment of drops in an electric field with photographs and figures which show clearly what is going on [1.41], [1.42]. Several model towers for solvent extraction processes also are discussed.
1.11
Applications of Electric fields to the Resolution of Water-in-Oil Emulsions (Yamaguchi)
This chapter describes the recovery of water from emulsions of water-in-oil or oil-inwater, specially applicable to demulsification processes in the oil industry. The electrical treatment used for these processes is highly successful and operates at lower cost compared with other demulsification processes, and with increased adaptability [1.43]. There are a number of ways of forming oil emulsions in oil production and refining. The application of electrostatic field in the demulsification process increases the rate of collision of water drops, and makes them rapidly coalesce, aiding the phase separation. The method may be used for solvent extraction to accomplish fast recovery.
I.I 4 Orientation of Organic Molecules in Electric Fields: Organized Photochemistry
7
Part 3 Applications of Electric Fields for Concentration, Immunoassay, and Molecular Orientation In chemical unit processes, electric fields can play unique roles. For example, in concentration processes we can use the transfer of molecules directed to an electrode. This movement can be utilized to create new concentration methods. Particles dispersed in the solution can be made to form aggregations. Molecular orientation results from applied electric fields or spontaneous electrostatic fields. These phenomena, resulting from electric fields, are not difficult to visualize. The chemical processes are reviewed and essential experimental conditions are given.
1.U
Dynamic Electroconcentration Processes in Analytical Chemistry (Tsuda)
Analytical chemistry generally concerns the determination of an unknown sample qualitatively or quantitatively. When the sample is very dilute, it may be necessary to concentrate it. The use of electric fields has unique results. We can use the electrophoretic mobility of a solute, the oxidation-reduction potential of a solute, and electrodeposition. They are combined with pressurized flow, electroosmotic flow generated by applied electric field, ion-exchange membranes, silver powders for the bed and chemical reactions, etc. These combinations produce high selectivity and analytical enhancement [1.44], [1.45]. The sample can be of small or large volume. Eight different concentration methods with applied electric fields are described.
1.13
Electric Field Enhancement of Immunoassays (Tamiya)
Often in immunoassays we encounter an antigen-antibody agglutinating reaction governing the rate of the whole process. The application of an electric field is effective for the acceleration of this reaction. When an alternating current or pulsed electric field is applied to a solution containing particles modified with antigens, the dispersed particles begin to form linear linkages, like that of a necklace. This phenomenon promotes the agglutination reaction, because the frequency of the contact between antigen and antibody is increased [1.46]. We can see the same phenomenon in the formation of linked carbon powders in oil (Chap. 9). In Chapter 13, examples of model experiments are rather limited. However, the great possibilities of applied electric fields are presented. The method can be also applied to micro-volume samples.
1.14
Orientation of Organic Molecules in Electric Fields: Organized Photochemistry (Takagi)
An electric field induces molecules to arrange themselves. If the field is confined to a micro-cavity, it can produce stereospecific arrangements. The introduction of photochemical methods gives a unique reaction field for specific synthesis.
8
1
Introduction and Summary
The author describes two electrostatic fields: applied and spontaneous. Under a strong applied field, ionic guest molecules are arranged in parallel. Spontaneous fields are generated in micelles, reversed micelles, vesicles, mono- and multilayered membranes, silica surfaces, clay interfaces, etc. [1.47]. The author gives many examples and offers mechanisms for photochemical reactions under these natural electrostatic fields. Throughout this book, electric fields play a unique role in separations, industrial processes, and molecular processes. Sometimes the introduction of an electric field is quite troublesome, but understanding how to control these fields properly, opens up new areas in which this technology promises great advances in the future. Acknowledgements I greatly thank Mr. Gramham van Zwoll, Mr. D . Boe Hamillton, Jr., HirofumiTanaka, Masakuni Nakashima, Shinya Kitagawa, Chizuko Tsuda and my co-workers for their help, and Mrs. Karin Sora and Dr. Christina Dyllick of VCH for their assistance.
1.15
References
S . Hjcrtcn, Chromatogr. Rev., 9, 122 (1967). R. J. Hunter, Zeta potential in colloids science, Academic Press, New York, 1981. J. C. Giddings, Dynamic of Chromatography, Dekker, New York, 1965. E. Heftman fed.), Clzrornatography,3rd ed., Van Norstand, New York, 1975, Chaps 2 and 10. [lS] T. Tsuda, Anal. Chem. 9, 521-523 (1987). [1.6] T. Tsuda, LC-GC Intl. 5 (9), 26-36 (1992). [1.7] G. Berraz, Anales Asoc. Quim. Arg., 31, 96 (1943). [1.8] T. R. Sato, W. P. Norris, H. H. Strain, Anal. Chern., 27, 521-525 (1955). 11.91 G. H. Evans, H. H. Strain, Anal. Chem. 28, 1560-1563 (1996). [1.10] D. L. Mould, R. L. M. Synge, Biochem. J . , 58, 571-585 (1954). [1.11] S. S. Sandhu, P. S. Thind, J. Indian Chem. Soc., 55, 1002-1007 (1978). [1.12] A. K. Misra, D. K. Misrd, V. K. Maheshwari, J. Liq. Chrornatogr., 14, 1469-1481 (1991). [1.13] S. D. Sharma, S . Misra, J. Planer Chromatogr., 3, 399-401 (1989). [1.14] R. Consden, A. H. Gordon, A. J . P. Martin, Biochem. J., 40, 33 (1946). [1.15] W. B. Gratzer, G. H. Beaven, J. Chrornatogr., 5 , 191 (1960). [1.16] A. Yaron, H. A. Sober, Anal. Biochern., 12, 173 (1965). [1.17] N. Haber, Proc. Nad. Acad. Sci. USA, 79,272-276 (1982). [1.18] Chem. Eng. News, April 22, 36 (1991). [1.19] H. H. Strain, Anal. Chem., 30, 228-231 (1958). [1.20] S. Otsuka, L. Listowsky, Anal. Biochern., 102, 419-422 (1980). [1.21] T. Tsuda, Anal. Chem., 60, 1677-1680 (1988). [1.22] P. H. O’Farrell, Science, 227, 1586-1589 (1985). [1.23] T. Nagaoka, M. Fujimoto, Y. Uchida, K. Ogura, J. Electroanal. Chem., 336,45-55 (1992). [1.24] T. Fujinaga,T. Nagai, S. Okazaki, C. Takagi, Nippon Kugaku Zasshi, 84,941-942 (1963). [1.25] R. Antrim, R. A. Schemer, A . M. Yacynych, J. Chrornatogr., Anal. Chirnica Acta, 164, 283-286 (1984). [1.26] H. Ge, P. R. Teasdale, G. G. Wallace, J . Chrornatogr., 544, 305-316 (1991). [1.27] D . H. Shain et al., Anal. Biochern., 200, 47-51 (1992). [1.28] L. Saso, T3. Silverstrini, C. Y. Cheng, Anal. Riochern., 212, 315-369 (1903). [1.29] T. Tsuda, Y. Muramatsu, J . Chrornatogr., 515, 645-652 (1990). [1.30] Y. Kabasawa, J. Cliem. Soc. Jpn, Chem. Ind. Chem., 1355-1359 (1990). [1.1] [1.2] [1.3] 11.41
I .I5 References
9
[1.31] E. R. Herheij, U. R. Tjaden, W. A. Niessen, J. van der Greef, J . Chromatogr., 554, 339-349 (1991). [1.32] C. D. Scott, Sep. Sci. Technol., 21, 905-917 (1986). [1.33] See also comments in the section of column focusing (Chapter 6). [1.34] M. Iwata, H. Imagi, T. Murasse, H. Yoshida, J . Chem. Eng. Japan, 24, 4.5-50 (1991). [1.35] Shinko Pantec Co, Ltd., Catalog No. 8902-1. [1.36] H. Ishida, J . Mineralogicul Soc. Japan, 22 (2), 79 (1993). [1.37] W. M. Winslow, US Patent 2417850 (1947). [1.38] R. Pool, Science, 247, March. (1990). [1.39] T. Ushima, K. Takano, T. Noguchi, Annual meeting of SOC.Automobile Eng., Technical Paper No. 880073 (1933). [1.40] J. D. Thronton, J. E. Porter, Symp. Electrochem. Eng., 3,3-38 (1971). [1.41] T. Takamatsu, M. Yamaguchi, T. Katayama, J. Chem. Eng. Japan, 15 (1982). [1.42] M. Yamaguchi, H. Sugaya, T. Katayama, J . Chem. Eng. Japan, 21, 179-183 (1988). [1.43] M. Yamaguchi, A. Kobayashi, T. Katayama, Kugaku Koguku Ronbunshi, 11, 729-734 (1985). [1.44] Yu. A. Zolotov, N. M. Kuz’min, “Preconcentration of trace elecments”, Comprehensive Analytical Chemistry X X V Elservier, Amsterdam, 1990. [1.45] A. Hori et al.,Anal. Chem., 65, 2882-2886 (1993). [ 1.461 E. Tamiya, I. Kaube, “Electric Pulse Accelerated Immunoassay” in Electrochemical Sensors in Immunological Analysis T. T. Ngo (ed.) Plenum Press, 1987. [1.47] K. Takagi, K. Aoshima, Y. Sawaki, J . Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans, II, 1771 (1986).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Part 1 Electrochromatography
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
2
Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry Takao Tsuda, Shinya Kitagawa
2.1
Theory of Band Broadening
Chromatography is one of the main tools for separating mixtures, and it is widely accepted as the most important. There are many types of chromatography (partition, adsorption, affinity, size-exclusion, ion-exchange, etc.) in each of which equilibria between the mobile phase and the stationary phase are attained. In this book, we introduce an additional method, the application of an electric field to a column. This leads onto using the electrophoretic mobility of a solute and the influence of the electric field on the stationary phase. We call this method electrochromatograph y. Electrochromatography introduces two new factors, electrophoretic mobility and electroosmotic flow, that do not exist in ordinary liquid chromatography; the band broadening of a solute in electrochromatography is different from that in ordinary chromatography [2.1]-[2.8]. Sample movement in the column under applied voltage is shown schematically in Figure 2.1. The direction of the flow velocity depends on the sign of the surface charge of the packing material, and its magnitude depends on the amount of surface charge, pH, the concentration of electrolyte in the effluent, the composition of the effluent, etc. [2.91-[2.14].
Figure 2.1. Movement of solute in a packed column under high voltage applied along the column.
14
2
2.2
Apparent Mean Linear Flow Velocity and Elution Time
Electrochromatograplzy in Analytical Chemistry
The apparent mean linear flow velocity of a solute, vaPp, in electrochromatography under pressurized flow is: vapp
= Vprcs
+ vmub + V o m
(1)
where vprc5, vmCthr and v,,,, are mean linear flow velocities due to pressurized flow, mobility of solute (electrophoretic velocity), electroosmotic flow (electroosmotic velocity), respectively [2.4]. Elution time, te, is: t,
=
L [R vdpP]-'
(2)
where t and R are column length and the retardation factor by (1 + k')-', where k' is the capacity factor. Vmnh
v,,
=
L ( R k)-' - Vprea - vosm
is estimated from a nonretained peak ( R vosm
=
(3) =
1, v,,,,h
(L/G,) - vprcs
=
0) as: (4)
where to is the elution time of the nonretained peak.
2.3
Processes in Band Broadening
In general chromatography, four processcs contribute to the band broadening of component zones as they migrate through the column; axial molecular diffusion; resistance to mass transfer in the stationary phase; resistance to mass transfer in the mobile phase; and eddy diffusion. The plate height is given by Giddings [2.15] as: H
=
Blv
+ C,V+ C,,V + (Z/A + l/C,V)~'
(5)
where v is the mean linear velocity and A , B, C,, and C, are the coefficients for eddy diffusion, axial molecular diffusion, resistance to mass transfer in the stationary phase, and resistance to mass transfer in the mobile phase. Only the Cmvvalue in Equation (3) is affected by the shape of the velocity profile in the column. Considering flow profiles in electrochromatography, the flow of vpreqoperates with a Poiseuille flow profile, and we suppose that the flow profile of v,& is a plug flow profile. The flow profile of v,,, is also a pseudo-plug flow. (These flow profiles are discussed below.) Therefore, the velocity inequality in the radial direction is due only to laminar flow, vpres;the flow pattern in electrochromatography is assumed to be mixed Poiseuillelplug flow (see Fig. 2.2). If the solute and eluent diffusion coefficients are assumed zero, the flow profile at time t , will resemble F ( t , , , ) in the absence of an applied voltage. As every point on F (tl,,)receives an additional contribution from vmOh, the actual electrochromatographic flow profile is F (t,,2) at time tl. The process of mass transfer in the mobile phase is a hybrid of lateral diffusion and velocity inequality of the flow pattern. The application of a random walk model for
-i
v(mob)
15
Processes in Band Broadening
2.3
Figure 2.2. Addition of a flow velocity due to electrophoretic mobility to a Poiseuille flow profile.
+
estimation of band broadening in general chromatography has been well by Giddings [2.15]. With a random walk model, the contribution of mass transfer in the mobile phase, the third term in Equation (9,is calculated as follows. A molecule must diffuse a distance wad, to reach one extreme velocity from another. The multiplying term w, takes values ranging from well below to well above unity [2.15]; dpis the particle diameter. Giddings [2.15] considered five or six different w values for various eluent nonequilibrium conditions, not all of which are equally important. For simplification, we will not discuss them individually. The average time t, needed to diffuse the distance at one of the velocity extremes is:
(6)
t, = w;d,2/2Dm
where D, is the diffusion coefficient in the mobile phase. The length of step 1is the distance gained or lost with respect to the mean (peak center) because of temporary residence at one of the velocity extremes.
I
= W/3Vpres
4
(7)
where ws = Avpres/vpres and A v is the difference between the extreme and the mean. The number of random steps while a solute passes through the total pass length (column length L ) is: n
=
L',f
+ V,,JL
(vpres
(8)
On combining these expressions with 3 and H tion of the zone length, we obtain H3:
f&
= vprw w:
where Cm= (w, wp d:)' H
=
wj (d:
vpreq)
(2DJ'.
(2 D
m vpres)-'
=
d I L , where
=
Cm
CT
is the standard devia-
~ p r e ? Vap;'
(9)
Therefore, H in electrochromatography is:
(Blvapp)+ C, vapP+ H 3 + (1IA
+ 1/H3)-'
(10)
Equation (10) is valid in the region vapp> 0. H as given by Equation (10) is different from that in general chromatography, given by Equation ( 5 ) , in the following respects. First, the flow velocity of a solute is (vpres v,,, vmoh).Second, H3 in electrochromatography is completely different from H3 in general chromatography, given by C, vpres. When vapp > vpres, flow velocities due to electroosmosis and electrophoretic mobility
+
+
16
2
Electrochrornutogrccyhy in Analyticul Chemistry
0.01
-3 u
(
Figure 2.3. Relation between H a n d “am.
reduce the values of the first and third terms of Equation (10) compared with general chromatography. When vdPp< vprc,,owing to the negative value of v , , ~ the solute will remain in the column longer than in general chromatography. Hence the second term in Equation (10) becomes smaller and the other terms larger compared with the corresponding terms when ( v , , ~+ v , , ~ ) = 0. Variations of Equation (10) with different vpresand vapp are shown in Figure 2.3 [2.16]. Curve 1 is for (v,,,, + v,,,) = 0; curves 2 and 3 are for vpres= 0.1 and 0.2 cmh, respectively. As the application of a voltage along the column generates v,,,b and vOsm, curves 2 and 3 correspond to the H-v relations in electrochromatography. The values of B, C,,C,, andA are as 2.0 x lo4, 5.0 x lo-?, 5.0 x lo”, and 7 x lo-’, respectively. These values for curve 1 are approximated from the H-v relation given for conventional liquid chromatography by Reese and Scott in the following conditions: Partisil as packing material; particle diameter 10 km; ethyl acetateln-hexane (5 :95) as effluent; benzyl acetate sample [2.17]. In the region vdPP> vpreq,the value of H (height equivalent to a theoretical plate) is always lower than for conventional chromatography, (curve 1).The contributions of v,,, and vmOhto band broadening are less than vprcSper unit time, mostly because of their flow profiles. However, in the region vaPp< vpres,H increases because retarded flow velocity prolongs the stay of solute in the column, and the effects of both diffusion and pressurized flow cause band broadening. The differcnce between curves 2 and 3 is due to the different sum of v,,,,, and v,,,,. From Figure 2.3, H depends on vapp,like vpresin ordinary chromatography, but H in electrochromatography is generally less than the H value at the same value of vpresin ordinary chromatography.
2.4 Electrochromatography Zones
17
-v(mo b)=v(pres)
T 0
-v(mob)=2v(pres)
7 0
z -v(mob)=3v(pres)
0
2.4
Figure 2.4. Assumed flow profile for pressurized flow-driven electrochromatography at time tl (unit period after injection) with zero diffusion coefficient and zero electroosmotic flow [2.15]. Z” indicates direction of flow.
Electrochromatography Zones
A charged solute is transported under an applied voltage. The movement of a solute zone in a column is dependent on the value of vaPp.The assumed flow profile and its position in the column is shown in Figure 2.4..These assumed flow profiles are obtained under the assumption that: a) the diffusion coefficient of solute in the medium and the flow velocity due to electroosmosis are assumed zero; b) the profile of injected solute is a plug; c) the profile of a solute due to electrophoretic mobility is also a plug [2.5]. If vpresIv,,,b, the solute is partially or completely trapped in the column. Therefore we can continuously introduce the dilute sample solution which contains a charged solute, and concentrate the solute at the column head, see also Section 1 of Chapter 6. The greatest advantage under an applied voltage is that the flow velocity in the very vicinity of the inner wall has a finite speed. This will reduce the band broadening of a zone in the mobile phase, which is mainly due to the different values of the extreme flow velocities at the edge and central region.
18
2
2.5
Profiles of Pressurized Flow, Electroosmotic Flow, and Zones of Ionic Solutes
Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry
It is well known that the flow profile of electroosmosis is very different from that of pressurized flow. This leads to a very narrow zone in capillary zone electrophoresis. The charged solute is transported owing to its electrophoretic mobility under an applied voltage. If the electric field strength is the same at any local position in a column cross-section, the flow velocity due to electrophoretic mobility under an applied field may be the same at every location in the column. Thus, in electrochromatography these additional flow velocities can decrease the zone broadening compared with the zone broadening in ordinary liquid chromatography. For a discussion of zone broadening, it is essential to know the zone profile of these flows.
2.5.1
Flow Profiles of Pressurized Flow
Zone Front Profile. For the analysis of zone broadening under pressurized flow, Taylor [2.18] used a method in which a colored solution was introduced continuously into a narrow capillary tube at several different velocities. The concentration of the colored solute at each axial point of the tube was measured after the zone had passed the central part of the capillary tube. A glass tube, 0.5 cm internal diameter and a length of 152 cm was used, and 1% potassium permanganate aqueous solution was used as the colored solution. The diffusion coefficient for potassium permanganate in water is 7 x 10“ cm2/s. The colored solution was poured continuously into the glass tube at a different travel period, at linear flow velocity u,,,,. The mean linear flow velocity is given by 0.5 vmax,where v,, is the flow velocity in pressurized flow. The travel periods of the colored solution are 4, 12, 240, and 11220 s, with mean linear flow velocities 8.25,6.67,0.263, and 0.00283 cm/s, respectively. The observed values of C/Cn are plotted against Z”, [Z” = (0.5 vnlaxt)-’] (Fig. 2.5). Z”, vmax,t, C , and C o are 2”-axis (flow direction), maximum flow velocity at the central line of the open tube due to Poiseuille flow, travel period (s), concentration of solute, and its initial concentration, respectively. Figure 2.5 demonstrates the effect of molecular diffusion on the concentration distribution in the transition zone between clear water and solution. In other words,
* rn
t 0
: 11 220 : 240 : 12 :4
0604 02-
0
04
08
16
12
20
2Figure 2.5. Distribution of concentration about point Z ”
=
0.5 vprcs,maxt[2.15].
2.5 Profiles of Pressurized Flow, Electroosmotic Flow,and Zones of Ionic Solutes
19
pressurized flow broadens the sample zone considerably. At high linear velocity of pressurized flow, the zone is broadened almost equally from 26 (original point) to the point v,,, t = 2. The concentration profile corresponds directly to the value of the local flow velocity, v, = v,,, (1-?/R2), where R and r are the radius of the circular tube and the distance from its central line.
Dispersion of Sample Injected as a Plug Under Pressurized Flow and Molecular Diffusion. When a sample is injected as a plug into a laminar flow, the concentration of the sample Ci along the z-axis and r can be calculated by solving Equation (ll), based on diffusionkonvection flow: aC/dt
= - v,,,
+
(1 - r2/R2)( d ~ / a z ) (DJr) d ( r X / a r ) / d r
(11)
The followin! parameters are introduced for the calculation: K = v,, R2/LD,; Co = 1; z’ = I.’,,,t L- , where L is the length of the plug; the contour line of concentration A Ci is given by ACi = Co 2” (n is an integer). The contour lines a-p in Figure 2.6 correspond to 1, %,I 1/2, t/4, %, %, 5/16, 3/16, N6, 5/32, 3/32, 1/32, 7/64, 5/64, 3/64, and v64 times c,, respectively. The calculated result is shown in Figure 2.6 for K = 30 [2.19], [2.201. This K value means that, for example, v,, = 0.5 cm/s, L = 0.5 cm, D, = 1 x 10“ cm /s and R = 55 pm. These values are not appropriate for capillary liquid chromatography. In capillary liquid chromatography the K value might be 0.25, under the following conditions: v,, = 0.1 cm/s, L = 0.1 cm, D,= 1 X 10“ cm2/s, and R = 5 pm. Therefore, the K value in Figure 2.6 is about 100 times larger compared with capillary liquid chromatography [2.16]. The arrows in Figure 2.6 depict the front position given by v,, t/L. The most concentrated part in the dispersion of the zone is located at the half-value of z’ for each zone. The band broadening of Figure 2.6 clearly shows the contribution of convection flow (pressurized flow) and mutual molecular diffusion. In Figure 2.6, B travels the distance L from A . The back of the B zone is broadened to the region of -Z”, owing to molecular diffusion, and its front is also more advanced than 2L, since, in this case, the solute concentration gradient is high. From B to F in Figure 2.6, the contribution of v,, bends the zone convexly, so that the central region of the zone is forced to advance more, compared with the edge region (near the inner wall). As vmg, is too fast in Figure 2.6, molecular diffusion cannot attain the zone profile of a Gaussian distribution. However the position of 2” of the central high concentration of the zone is located half-way along the zone front, owing to mutual molecular diffusion during the zone migration. If we look at the leading edge of the band, we might expect that the zone front profile for continuous introduction of samples to be similar, i. e., the front zone profile of pressurized flow is due to convection flow and diffusion, and differs greatly from the flat profile of plug flow. In chromatography, we are always very careful to reduce the contribution of convection. We try to use very fine packing materials to reduce the radius of the channels between them, in which diffusion can reduce band broadening.
2.5.2
Flow Profiles of Electroosmosis in an Open Tube
The electroosmotic flow profile has been discussed for electroosmotically driven opentubular liquid chromatography [2.8], [2.21], [2.22], capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) [2.24]-[2.26], and electroosmotically driven electrochromatography (EO-EC) [2.26].The electroosmotic flow profile differs from the parabolic laminar velocity pro-
20
2 Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
32
28
24
20
16
17.
8
4
z ' - a x i s ,
0
L
Figure 2.6. Zone broadening under pressurized flow [2.16]. Arrow indicates the front position of v,,,tlL.
of pressurized flow. The former flow profile is much flatter, so that very narrow peaks are obtained in electroosmotically driven chromatography and CZE. In early experiments, Pretorius et al. [2.21] and Tsuda et al. [2.8] obtained 10- und 30-fold less band broadening in electroosmotically driven liquid chromatography than expected with pressurized flow. Pretorius et al. [2.21] suggested that the profile is flat except in the region of the diffuse double-layer near the column inner wall, where the flow has a quadratic velocity profile owing to friction between the viscous liquid and the wall. The diffuse double-layer of fused silica capillary (50-100 pm) is supposed to be 30-300 nm [2.12], [2.27]. Jorgenson and Lucacs [2.24] assumed that the zone broadening in CZE was generated only by axial molecular diffusion of solute and medium. Tsuda et al. [2.8] found it difficult to explain the experimental results purely by axial molecular diffusion, and proposed that the flow profile might be a combination of plug and Poiseuille flow. Rice et al. [2.29] and Guiochon et al. [2.27], [2.28] also assumed that electroosmotic flow is a combination of plug and Poiseuille flow, and proposed an equation to calculate the contribution of electroosmotic flow profiles by using experimental data. Guiochon et al. [2.27], [2.28] proposed equations describing the electroosmotic flow profile as a combination of plug and Poiseuille flow under an applied voltage in a capillary tube. The average flow profile u can be computed as:
2.5 Profiles of Pressurized Flow, Electroosmotic Flow, and Zones of Ionic Solutes
u (vOs,J1 = 1- (2/3) p - (1/6)e2
21 (12)
Guiochon et al. use an adjustable parameter e which can be related to the thickness of the double-layer relative to the column radius. The boundary value p = 1 corresponds to the usual Poiseuille flow (parabolic flow) and e = 0 to plug flow. One may estimate e as: p = (3/xr) 11
+ 1/(4xr) + 1/[4 (xr)’] + 19/[64(~r)~]}
(13)
where r and x are the column radius (channel radius) and the reciprocal of the diffuse double-layer. Their result (dashed curve) is shown in Figure 2.7, with xr = 10 and e = 0.3083. One typically uses as fused silica capillary of 50-100 pm inner diameter and 10 mM buffer solution. Under these conditions, the diffuse double-layer is assumed to be 30-300 nm; the value of m is 83-830 for a 50 pm inner diameter capillary column. Zone Front Profiles in Rectangular Capillary lhbes. n u d a et al. [2.30] used a method similar to Taylor’s experiment [2.18], in which a fluorescent solution (Rhodamine 590 in methanol) is continuously introduced into a capillary, with the front profile being observed through a microscope charged-coupled device (CCD) video recording system. A rectangular capillary tube, 50 x 1000 pm, which has been used for CZE, is used because the flat sides cause fewer distortions in the observed zone front [2.30], [2.31]. Since Rhodamine may be neutral in methanol, the electroosmotic flow profile obtained by using a Rhodamine 590-methanol solution will give a general answer. The arrangement of the experiment is shown in Figure 2.8. The procedure for the introduction of the sample solution is as follows. One end of the empty rectangular capillary (height 50 pm,width 1 mm, length 164 mm, these dimensions defined as the Y-, X- and Z-axes), is inserted into reservoir A, and the medium in the reservoir is introduced via capillary action. Then the other end is inserted into another reservoir B. Subsequently, the end of the rectangular capillary is inserted into the outlet of the syringe containing sample solution (reservoir A) with gentle smooth motion of stage 2. This procedure is very important for producing a sharp zone front. A voltage is then
.8
.6
x/r
.4
c
X
2
z
Figure 2.7. Velocity profile versus relative distance from column axis. Solid curve, electroosmotic flow; dashed curve, partially parabolic flow; xr = 10 and e = 0.3083; dotted curve, Poiseuille parabolic profile (@ = 1) [2.25].
22
2 Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry
t
///
U
Figure 2.8. Schematic diagram of the instrumentationfor visual observation of zone front [2.31].
applied. Immediately after the application of the voltage, the colored solution travels into the rectangular capillary and its zone front is followed under the microscope system, by continuous or stepwise operation of stage 1. The sample solution is continuously introduced into the rectangular capillary in a similar fashion to frontal analysis in chromatography [2.32]. With the dye zone front illuminated, its fluorescent image was recorded. The zone front was observed through the 1000 pm wide section of capillary (the XZ surface of the capillary). The current is low (ca. 0.12 pAper 97 Vkm) and very stable during the run; there is only a small difference in conductivity between pure methanol and lo4 M Rhodamine-methanol solution. Thc use of a rectangular capillary for the observation of flow profiles in electroosmosis has several advantages. The flow velocity in electroosmosis depends on the amount of charge on the wall [2.11], [2.12]. The medium in a rectangular capillary is surrounded by two sets of parallel plates, two X Z plates and two YZ plates. At the center of the X-axis of the rectangular capillary the medium is affected mainly by the two parallel XZ plates. The medium near the YZ plates is affected by both the two 1-mm parallel plates ( X Z ) and a 50+m plate (YZ). Therefore, the geometric difference between the edge and center of the 1-mm plate shows the effect of the wall on the flow profile. The difference in flow at the edge of the 1-mm width (X-axis) compared with the center is caused by the 50-pm plates (YZ), because the effect of charges on the 1mm plate and its diffuse double-layer influence the flow profile equally at all points in the X Z plate. Photographs and computer images of the zone front taken from video tapes are shown in Figures 2.9 and 2.10. The distance between each line on the X-axis in Figure 2.10 corresponds to 59 km. The time interval between the pictures is 1 s. The advance of the zone between two pictures can be measured from photographs by matching the positions of the stationary marks on the rectangular capillary. The zone front shown in Figure 2.9 is flat at the center with small bends at both ends of 1000 pm axis, near the 50+m plates. The progress of the zone front recorded on video tapes was analyzed by computer software. The resulting images of the advancing zone front are shown in Figure 2.10. The four images are successive 4-s intervals, with the 1-mm axis divided into seventeen sections. Both edges in the Z-direction correspond to zone fronts.
2.5 Profiles of Pressurized Flow, Electroosmotic Flow,and Zones of Ionic Solutes
23
Figure 2.9. Photographs of the zone front in elcctroosniotic flow 12.311. Colored sample solution: 0.1 mM Rhodaniine 590 in methanol; Applied voltage and current, 1.59 kV and 0.12 PA. The period between photographs is 1 s.
The advance of the zone front along the Z-axis is summarized numerically in Table 2.1. The average numbers at each X-section were similar. The flow profile is pluglike in the center of the capillary from section 1 to 15. Unfortunately, the numerical values of the progress at sections 0 and 16 were not stable enough to estimate. To examine the profile in the vicinity of the 50-pm plate, we focused on the movement of the zone front at high magnification. One of the photographs obtained is shown in Figure 2.11. The zone front near the wall, near sections 0 and 16 of the X-axis, has traveled further than the zone front in the central portion of the capillary. It was concluded that the advances of the central portion are almost equal to the results of Figures 2.9, 2.10 and Table 2.1. The zone front at the edges of the 1000-pm axis in Figures 2.9 and 2.10 is ahead of the central portion. This phenomenon was observed in every experiment which we recorded.
24
2 Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry
A
P
C
D
Figure 2.10. Computed images of the zone front on the Z-axis over a l-s span [2.31].
Zone Front Profile in Fused Silica Capillary lhbings. The flow profile of electroosmosis in 50-75 pm fused silica capillary tubings were also recorded. Photographs of the zone front are shown in Figure 2.12. The experimental conditions were as follows: fused silica capillary, 65 pm inner diameter, 16 cm long; applied voltage 1 kV (62.5 V1 cm); ca. 17 nA. The image obtained is reflected at the region focused by the microscope; the focal plane is ca. 2.7 mm long (Z) and less than the depth of 5 pm (Y). From Figure 2.12 the total advance is 420 pm per 2.69 s. We can see the flow profile in a round capillary tubing in Figure 2.12, and it is concluded that the frontal zone profile is similar to those of rectangular shape shown in Figure 2.10, i. e., the central portion of the zone is retarded compared with its edge, and generally the profile is very flat. From these experimental results, we proposed that the zone front profile in a narrow straight tubing of 100-50 pm internal diameter would appear as shown in Figure 2.13. The central portion of the zone front is retarded compared with the edge, as with a rectangular capillary. We therefore suggest the following: the edge portion of the zone front advances at the very start, immediately after application of the voltage. From then on the zone will maintain equal velocity at every point along the Z-axis.
2.5 Profiles of Pressurized Flow, Electroosmotic Flow, and Zones of Ionic Solutes
25
Table 2.1. Advance of zone front along the X-axis over A 1-s period
Section (y-axis)
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Experiment
Average value
1
2
3
4
7.8 7.2 8.0 8.1 8.0 7.6 7.0 7.7 8.1 7.5 8.0 7.4 7.8 6.8 6.0
8.3 7.6 8.3 6.9 7.8 8.3 8.0 8.2 8.0 8.1 8.4 7.7 7.6 7.5 8.0 8.6 8.0
8.0 7.6 8.4 8.0 6.7 7.4 7.8 6.5 7.4 8.0 7.6 8.5 8.2 8.3 7.6
7.5 7.0 7.2 7.8 7.1 8.5 7.8 7.4 8.5 7.6 7.5 7.7 7.0 7.5 6.9 7.7
7.6 7.58 7.78 7.75 7.88 7.7 7.63 7.68 7.8 7.85 7.75 7.63 7.75 7.5 7.48
Mean of average value and its standard deviation are 7.69 and 0.12, respectively, unit of X-axis: 57.8 wrn
To our knowledge, this is the first time that the zone front pattern in electroosmosis has been directly observed. The central part is retarded compared with the edges. This finding is unique. The flow profile observed is a reverse parabolic and very different from that suggested by Pretorius et al. [2.21]. This unique result could be explained in two ways. First, when the osmotic flow exits from the capillary outlet into the reservoir, some pumping power is required. Since there is not enough potential gradient to accept the flow coming from the column, pumping power due to the electroosmotic flow is necessary. This causes the zone front in the central portion of the capillary to be forced back, owing to the hydrostatic backpressure of the reservoir. A second explanation might be as follows. The distribution of positive and negative ions is such that positive ions are extremely abundant in the region of the double-layer
26
2 Electrochrornatography in Analytical Chemistry
Figure 2.12A. Zone front profiles in a fused silica capillary tube [2.14]. Profiles taken from 40.6 to 41.8 sec.
A
6
C
D
Figure 2.l2B. Sketches of zone front profiles in round capillary tubing [2.14]. Profiles A-D taken at 39.22, 40.22, 41.71, 41.91 s.
up to 3 / x (x is the reciprocal of the length of the diffuse double-layer), with the abundance of positive ions decreasing toward the center of the capillary tubing. In other words, negative ions, molecules which have a partial negative charge, or partially polarized molecules, are concentrated at or near the center of the capillary, and their abundance in the region of the double-layer is extremely small or zero. Charge balance must be maintained over the whole XYZ space. Some of the molecules in the central part have a flow direction opposite to that of the wall regions, causing the apparent flow velocity in the central part to be reduced somewhat compared with that at the edges. Therefore, the central region will lay behind the edge.
2.5 Profiles of Pressurized Flow,Electroosmotic Flow,and Zones of Ionic Solutes
27
1 Figure 2.W. Proposed zone front in open-tube capillary [2.14].
Flow Profiles for Charged Molecules
2.5.3
Charged solutes are forced to move by their electrophoretic mobility under an applied electric field. If the electric field is uniform at every local cross-section of the column, and is not affected by the charges on the inner wall, the flow velocity of each solute should be equal. Thus, they form a sharp zone front, with a plug flow profile. As the inner wall of the flow channel may have a charge on its surface and in the vicinity of its wall, a diffuse double-layer will be formed; the charged solute near the wall will be affected by the charged inner surfaces and a radial potential gradient generated.
1mm
1mm
0
1
2
3
4
5 I
s
e
c.
1
Figure 2.14. Photographs of zone fronts of a positively charged solute under electroosmosis [2.17].
28
2 Electrochromatogruphy in Anulyticul Chemistry
Figure 2.15. Photograph of the zone front of a negatively charged
solute [2.31]. We observed the zone front flow profile by using the same apparatus, shown in Figure 2.8. Colored charged solutes Rhodamine 590 and disodium fluorescein were used. In 5 mM phosphate buffer (pH 6.8) with 5 % ethylene glycol, Rhodamine 590 has one positive charge and disodium fluorescein two negative charges, although the former is neutral in methanol. The zone front of these two ionic solutes in the buffer is shown in Figures 2.14 and 2.15. From Figure 2.14, it is clear that the advances at each time interval do not affect the pattern of the zone front. Almost similar zone fronts of positively charged solutes under electroosmotic flow are observed. The charged color molecules migrate with almost equal speed at every point on the X-axis. Therefore, both profiles of electroosmosis and the zone formed by charged solutes are almost plug over a short period, such as a few seconds. If we overlap two front profiles for more precise observation of the advance, we find that the advances in 2 at local points along X are not equal, and we can observe the advances in the neighborhood of both edges, where they are a little larger compared with the central part of X [2.16], [2.30]. A negatively charged ionic solute may experience an electrostatic repulsion from the surface charge on the inner wall in its vicinity, while the positively charged ionic solute is attracted to the wall. The zone fronts of both ionic solutes are different from those of neutral solutes. The difference is particularly pronounced at the ends of the l-mm axis (X)of the rectangular capillary. The zone front at both ends of the X-axis moves forward or back, owing to the positive or negative charge of the solute. Therefore, the zone front profile might be induced by electrostatic forces between ionic solutes and the charge on the surface of the inner wall under a potential gradient. The zone front profile of ionic solutes is not flat [2.30]. The zone fronts of ionic dyes depend on their charges. The front zone profiles in electroosmosis of ionic dyes each have a specific pattern. These findings are not explained by the general equation proposed for electroosmosis. Although the diffuse double-layer and the amount of surface charge on the inner wall are important, they may not be sufficiently strong to affect molecules over distances of several micrometers. The change in the nature of the medium under a potential gradient may be a key factor.
2.6 Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromratographyon Microcolumns
2.6
29
Pressurized How-Driven Electrochromatography on Microcolumns
There are two methods of generating a pressurized flow. The first uses a modern LC pump [2.3]-[2.5], [2.7], [2.33], [2.34], and the second uses gravity [2.1], [2.2], [2.35]. A high-flow velocity is easy to control with an LC pump, and an analysis time of 10-30 min can be obtained. Analysis time for the gravity method is much longer (1-10 h), owing to the slow velocity [2.1], [2.2], [2.35]. High efficiency can be obtained at high voltage, providing effective heat dissipation is achieved. The advantage of using microcolumns or capillary columns (50-500 pm inner diameter) is their ability for high heat dissipation and relatively low electric current compared with columns of 2-6 mm inner diameter.
2.6.1
Instrumentation
A schematic diagram of the instrumentation used for electrochromatography with pressurized flow is shown in Figures 2.16A and B (instruments with nonsplit and split injection). In Figure 2.16A, one electrode is placed in front of the injector and the other electrode is placed between the analytical column and a resistant column (not shown). To prevent the evolution of bubbles, 15 cm of 50 pm fused silica capillary tubing was connected in-line after the electrode and UV detector. A microcolumn (0.5 mm inner diameter, Teflon tubing column body) was used [2.4]. In Figure 2.16B, a pump, an injector (60 nL or 0.5 pL), a home-made column with a frit, a UV detector, and a high-voltage power supply (maximum 50 kV) were used. As a resistance tube, a fused silica capillary (100 pm internal diameter) was used [2.7], [2.34]. The column used had a 50 pm inner diameter and a length of 7.5-18 cm. The polyimido coating of the fused silica capillary, located just after the center frit, was removed with a fine blade for 1 mm of its length for UV detection. A split-sample injection method was used. High voltage was applied between a split and a reservoir in Figure 2.16B. A frit 0.1 mm in length was prepared at the center part of the fused silica capillary (total capillary tube length 12.5 cm, frit positioned 7.5 cm from the inlet) [2.36]. Silica gels modified with octadecylsilane (ODS-silica, particle diameter 7 pm, Capcell 120 SG, Shiseido, or TSKgel IC-Anion-SW, particle diameter 5 pm, Toso) was packed using ethanol or methanol-water as solvent under high pressure. Figures 2.16C and 2.16D show the micro-LC (gradient) system used by Tjaden et al. [2.36]. A pre-injector split was applied, as the generation of reproducible and smooth flow rates appeared possible only at flow rates above 250 pL/min with a conventional pump. The flow was split in the desired ratio by a T-piece fitted to a 100 x 3 mm inner diameter packed column as a dummy column for a restrictor. A 100 pm inner diameter fused silica capillary from the gradient system was passed through the splitting T-piece and a stainless steel tube, and ended 5 mm short of the injector. Samples were injected with an injector fitted with a 0.5 pL loop. The capillary column, 200 mm x 220 pm inner diameter, packed with Nucleosil 100-5 C18 was directly connected to the injector by means of a nut, a Vespel ferrule, and a Teflon linear tube (4 mm x 1/16 in outer diameter X 0.35 inner diameter) to fill up the void space [2.37]. The column effluent was monitored at 260 nm by a UV detector equipped with a home-made capillary flowthrough cell, using 50 pm fused silica with a volume of about 4 nL.
30
2 Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry
resistance
Electrical resistance
-
Pump
Figure 2.16A. Electrochromatographic system for a microcolumn t2.101.
3
I filter
UV-detector
injector
reservoir
-
r e s i s t a n t tube -
0
0
A
restrictor
4
Figure 2.16C. Electrochromatographic system with a gradient device.
2.6 Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromatography on Microcolumns
1
\
\6 7
31
Figure 2.16D. End-fitting device [2.35]. 1) Capillary column, 220 pm inner diameter; 2) 1/16 inch female nut; 3) Drilledthrough union; 4) PTFE union insert; 5) 50 pm inner diameter fused silica capillary; 6) silcanized quartz-wool; 7) Vespel ferrule.
For electrochromatographic experiments, the injector was grounded in order to allow injection during high-voltage operation, while the high voltage was applied to the end of the packed fused silica column by means of a drilled-through union used as an electrode. It is preferable to have a device to exclude bubbles from the end-frit connector, as shown in Figure 2.16D.
2.6.2
Features and Operational Factors
The instrumentation for electrochromatography should have the following features: 1) Any heat generated should be effectively reduced or dissipated: this is a key factor. If a capillary column with small internal diameter (50-500 pm) is used, most of the heat generated will be effectively dissipated from the outside surface of the column. 2) The detector and pump must be protected from damage that may be caused by the application of a high voltage. For example, a long fused silica capillary is used as an electrical resistance between the pump and the capillary column. If a column of large internal diameter (2-4 mm) is used, design geometry should be such as to ensure effective heat dissipation, or a low-potential gradient should be used. Other alternatives include reducing the current by using an eluent of low conductivity (e. g., an eluent containing an organic buffer and/or a weak acid, or a weak alkali, such as ammonium acetate). 3) An amphoteric electrolyte is the preferred reagent for buffer components. When the pH of the effluent is varied, the sign of the charge of an amphoteric electrolyte is changed, which reduces the variation of effluent pH at or near the electrode. This buffering action stabilizes the electric current in the column. 4) To reduce the analysis time and to increase the contribution of mobility to the separation process, a high applied voltage is a key factor. 5 ) Noise caused by bubbles generated at the electrodes must be minimized, or the bubbles must be eliminated from the system. When bubbles form in the system, the current is often stopped, and the system shuts down. In pressurized flow-driven electrochromatography the problem can be overcome by using pressurized flow. This either carries the bubbles out of the system or because the system is kept under relatively high pressure, it facilitates dissolution of the hydrogen and oxygen generated at the electrodes. In electroosmotically driven electrochromatography (electroosmosis as the sole driving flow) it is very difficult to remove bubbles from the system. In this case, it is common practice to use pressurized flow to exclude them. In electrochromatography, care should be taken to control the gases generated at the electrodes to ensure continuous operation of the system [2.3]-[2.5], [2.7], [2.33], [2.34].
32
2 Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry
ov
1 OkV
Figure 2.17A. Chromatograms obtained by pressurized flow-driven electrochromatography at different currents and voltages [2.13]. Solutes uracil and ck-Nrnethyl-4-/%styrylpyridium iodide (CSI), eluted in that order.
-4P-
1 rnin
2.6.3
Chromatographic Behavior in Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromatography
Effect of Applied Voltage. Ppical separations obtained from applying a high voltage are shown in Figure 2.17 and Table 2.2 [2.3], [2.4]. The applied voltage was varied from 0 to 15 kV or 0 to -15 kV. The electric current was set at 0.2,4,7,10 and 17 pA at applied voltage 0, +2,5, +5, +7,5, 10, and 15 kV, respectively. A 7.5 cm x 0.5 mm tetrafluoroethylene microcolumn packed with 3 pm ODS-silica was used with methanoY1.5 x N phosphate buffer (pH 6.7) (88:12) as eluent. A high voltage was applied to the column (up to +2 kV/cm). The cis-N-methyl4-/?-styrylpyridium iodide solute was significantly retarded, although uracil was unaffected, owing to its lack of charge. Baseline separation of both solutes was obtained at
+
+
+
Table 2.2. Effect of voltage on retention time
Voltage
Current
Rentention time (x lo-’ rnin)
a
kV
PA
Uracil
CSI
R ,C S I ~ Rurnnl ~,
0 - 1.0
0 1 2 3 3 6 10 0 2 4 7 10 17
10.7 10.7 10.6 10.4 10.0 10.0
20.7 18.7 17.3 15.3 12.5 11.5 9.5 17.5 20.2 23.0 27.1 33.0 51.0
1.93 1.74 1.63 1.47 1.25 1.15 (1.0) 1.62 1.83 2.07 2.73 2.00 4.63
-2.5 -5.0 -7.5 - 10.0 - 15.0 0 f2.5 +5.0 +7.5 + 10.0 15.0
+
10.8 11.0 11.1 9.9 11.0 11.0
2.6 Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromatography on Microcolumns
33
M -
Y -
10-
L o -
0 -16
-I2
-I
-4
0
*4
I6
A P P L I E D VOLTAGE
+I2
I KVI
*la
Figure 2.17B. Retention times versus applied voltages [2.3]. Solute A) were uracil; solute B) CSI.
(ii)
3
(ii)
w 3
-+It 2 rnin
Figure 2.18. Chromatograms showing the effect of applied voltage on pressurized flow-driven electrochrornatography of PTH derivatives of (i) asparagine and (ii) 2naphthalenesulfonic acid, obtained (a) with no applied voltage and (b) with applied voltage [2.4]. Applied voltage for (i) and (ii) 7.4 and 11.8 kV,respectively.
34
2 Electrochromntogruphy in Analytical Chemistry
a positive voltage above 5 kV. Table 2.2 lists the retention times of the pyridium salt and uracil at different applied voltages, and its variation is shown in Figure 2.17B. The solute can be eluted over a shorter or longer period (compared with no applied voltage), if the applied voltages at the end of the column are positive or negative, respectively. Figure 2.18 shows separations of phenylthiohydantoin (PTH) derivatives of asparagine (A) and 2-naphthalenesulfonic acid (B) with and without applied voltage. In the chromatogram of PTH derivatives, two unknown peaks (1 and 2 in Fig. 2.18) are well separated with applied voltage, and in the chromatogram of 2-naphthalenesulfonic acid, peak 3 is retarded; its elution time is 3.5 times longer. However, peak 2 is not retarded with applied voltage and, therefore, may represent a neutral compound. This shows that electrochromatography is a good method for separating a group of charged components from a group of neutral compounds. Time Lag for Constant Elution Time. In electrochromatography, elution time and peak height of a solute depend on the time from the beginning of the voltage application. Variation of these values for methanol and adenosine-5'-monophosphate (AMP) are shown in Figure 2.19. A PTFE microcolumn and M phosphate buffer as eluent were used. Pure methanol was used as solute, which produces a UVdetector response. Elution times and peak heights for solutes were measured before, during, and after the application of voltage. Elution times of methanol and AMP stabilized 20 min after the application of the voltage, and when the voltage was released, the elution times became constant after 10 min. These time lags may be equal to the period necessary to alter the nature of column supports by the voltage.
10
0
______OFF
10 20 30 40 0 10 20 TIME (min) [m1 n) - - - - - - - - - - - ON OFF ELECTRO VOLTAGE
-
--
Figure 2.19. Variation of elution time and peak height with period of voltage application [2.4]. Peak height of methanol (squares); elution times, AMP (triangles) and methanol (crosses); applied voltage, 2.5 kV.
2.6 Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromatography on Microcolumns
35
Effect of Application of Voltage for Peak Height. With no applied voltage, the methanol peak in Figure 2.19 is low and broad, but, with applied voltage, it becomes high and sharp of twice the area obtained with no applied voltage. These phenomena, also observed in the case of AMP, may be due to the alteration of the column support; they were also observed in other experiments [2.33].
2.6.4
ChromatographicVariation due to the Application of High Voltage
Variations of elution times due to the applied voltage are shown in Figures 2.20 and 2.21 for benzoic acid, phenol, and trimesic acid at pH 6.3 and 8.0. The apparatus used for this experiment is shown in Figure 2.16B. The column used was a fused silica capillary (50 vm inner diameter, 7.5 cm long, with a frit, total capillary tubing 12.5 cm with a section for on-column detection) packed with ODs-silica (particle diameter 7 pm, Capcell 120 SG, Shiseido). The eluent was a mixture of methanol, a buffer of 10 mM malonic acid, and sodium hydroxide aqueous solution with a constant pressure operation mode, e.g., 50 atm. The chromatogram with applied voltage was obtained after the elution time of the solute had stabilized (usually ca. 15 min after applying the high voltage). In Figure 2.20, methanol and buffer (1:l) are used as eluent. At pH 6.3, benzoic acid is completely dissociated (pKa = 4.21) [2.38]. With application of a high voltage along the column, the elution time of benzoic acid increases in proportion to the voltage. The elution time of ethanol, shown as a negative peak, is also affected by the applied voltage; it is used as a marker of voltage-generated electroosmosis. The elution time of benzoic acid is delayed owing to its electrophoretic mobility at high applied voltage along the column, even though vosmincreases. Phenol does not dissociate at pH 8.0 (pKa = 10.0) [2.38], its elution time is affected by R , vpresrand vosm,and decreases when voltage is applied along the column. The mutual separations of benzoic acid and trimesic acid with and without applied voltage are shown in Figure 2.21. As the dissociation constants for trimesic acid are pK1 = 3.12, pK, = 4.10, and pK, = 5.18 [2.39], trimesic acid dissociates completely at pH 8.0. The elution order is reversed when voltage is applied. As the trimesic acid has three carboxylic groups, the electrophoretic mobility is larger than that of benzoic acid. Therefore trimesic acid can be drawn back and stays longer in the column at high applied voltage than benzoic acid.
2.6.5
Relation between Elution Time Ratio and pH
The elution time ratio e, is defined as: er = t e , benzlfe, ethanol
(14)
where te,ethanol is the elution time of ethanol in the same run, and the subscript benz means benzoic acid. The elution time ratio of benzoic acid with and without applied voltage is shown in Figure 2.22. Although e, is not directly related to applied voltage, this factor is expressed as follows,
lniii
lnin
_1
E
R
B
C
1
A
4-
1
Figure 2.21. Electrochromatograms for mixtures of benzoic (1) and trimesic acids (2) [2.7). Eluent: as Figure 2.20 except buffer pH 8.0. Applied voltage: 0 (A); 7.5 kV (B); 8.8 kV (C).
Figure 2.20. Electrochromatograms of benzoic acid and phenol [2.7]. Eluent: mixture (1:l) of methanol and the buffer (pH 6.3) of 10 mM malonic acid - sodium hydroxide aqueous solu-
tion; sample: ethanol solution of benzoic acid (A-D) or phenol (E, F). Applied voltage: 0 (A, E); 5 kV (B, F); 7.5 kV ( C ) ; 10 kV (D).
I
I
I
I
I
I
2.00
-
-
1.00
-
-
.: =
Y
\ Y
I 4.0
I
1
I
I
8.0
6.0
I
10.0
PH
Figure 2.22. Elution time ratio versus p H [2.7]. Eluent: mixture (1:1) of methanol and 10 mM malonic acid - sodium hydroxide buffer. Applied voltage: 0 (full circles); 5 kV (open circles); 7.5 kV (full squares); 10 kV (open squares).
The ratios are shown in Figure 2.22. The values of elution time ratio is larger at high applied voltage, and the value at applied voltages of 7.5 and 10 kvdecreases when pH of the eluent varies from 5 to 9.4. These tendencies derive partly from the increase of vosmin the alkaline region. The three curves shown in Figure 2.22 are focused at a same value, ca. pH 4, because benzoic acid does not form a dissociated ion in acidic conditions (pH < 4). The variation of the ratio with no applied voltage shown in Figure 2.22 corresponds well with the curve for the relation between the capacity factor of benzoic acid and the pH obtained with ODS columns [2.40].
2.6.6
Variation of Electrophoretic and Electroosmotic Flow Velocities with pH
The relations between the electroosmotic and electrophoretic velocities of benzoic acid versus pH are shown in Figures 2.23 and 2.24. To calculate v,,, from Equation (4), it is necessary to determine vpresand R for ethanol. We assume that R = 1 for trimesic acid at pH 9.4, because the three carboxylic acid groups of trimesic acid are completely dissociated. Thus, vpresis calculated by using the elution time of trimesic acid at pH 9. This valve of vpres= 0.103 cm/s at the constant
38
-
2 Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry L
i
I
i
I
I
I
I 4.0
I
I 6.0
I
I 8.0
I
6 . 0 0 ~
;. Y
0
* X
4.00:
h
E
-
u)
0 v
>
2.00
-
t
.o
PH Figure 2.23. Relation between electroosmotic velocity and pH [2.7]. Experimental conditions as Figure 2.22 except applied voltage: 5 kV (full circles); 7.5 kV (open circles); 10 kV (full squares).
inlet pressure of 50 atm, is assumed the same as in other experiments in which the composition of the eluent is the same, but the pH of the buffer varies. For example, R for ethanol is estimated as 0.82 from the chromatogram at pH 9.4. We calculate the values of R for ethanol and benzene at every pH. From these values, vOsmat different pH is estimated (Fig. 2.23). The curve first shows a steep increase from pH 3.5 to 4.8, and then changes to a gentle increase from pH 5 to 9. The value of vosmdepends on pH, owing to dissociation of unmodified silanol groups on the surface of the ODs-silica gel (the initial steep increase may correspond to that of the dissociation constant of silanol on the gel surface). The pK, may be around 4.3; it is estimated by using the relation between pH and electroosmotic flow velocity in capillary electrochromatography. The value of vmobis calculated from Equation ( 3 ) , in which vprea,v,,,, and the retardation factors of both ethanol and benzoic acid are included. The three former values are estimated in the same way as for calculating v,,,, and the last value is estimated as 0.85 at pH 9.4. The relation between vm,b and pH is shown in Figure 2.24. The value of vb , at pH 3.5 is almost zero, owing to the absence of the ionized form of benzoic acid; it increases very sharply according to the dissociation of the carboxylic acid group between pH 4 and 5. The value then becomes almost constant between pH 6 and 8. The value of v , , ~obtained is nearly proportional to the applied voltage.
2.6 Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromatography on Microcolumns
39
m
t 0.00 4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
PH Figure 2.24. Relation between electrophoretic velocity of benzoic acid and pH [2.7]. Experimental condition and symbols as Figure 2.23.
2.6.7
Dependence of Electrophoretic and Electroosmotic Velocities on the Composition of Eluents Containing Methanol
The dependence of electrophoretic and electroosmotic velocities on the percentage of methanol in the mixture of methanol and buffer is shown in Figure 2.25. For these values, it is assumed that vPresis inversely proportional to the eluent viscosity, with vpresof the 1:l mixture taken as a standard. The values of v,,, and V,,b for benzoic acid are almost constant between 30 and 90 % methanol in the eluent. They increase markedly at more than 90 % methanol. Values at 99 % methanol content, were unstable, nearly one and a half times those at 95 % methanol. From Figure 2.25, the benzoic acid in the region 30-90 % methanol is completely ionized, and the value of v,,, and v,,~,benz are independent of the methanol content in this range. Increasing methanol content increases the dissociation constants of malonic acid and benzoic acid. The electrophoretic mobility of benzoic acid has a relatively high value at 95 % methanol, suggesting that the benzoic acid buffer is completely ionized. In general, v,,,,, and V,,,ob are expressed as [2.12], [2.42]: vnsm= A E & l ~ v,,,,b
=
d E c*DC q-'
(16) (17)
40
2 Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry
10.00 Q ,-I
Y
I
n 0
E
5.00
*
Y
40
60
vol.% of methanol
80
in
effluent
Figure 2.25. Dependence of electrophoretic velocity (full circles) and electroosmotic velocity (open circles) of benzoic acid on the percentage of methanol in the eluent [2.7]. Eluent: mixture of methanol and buffer (pH 4.92) composed at 10 mM malonic acid and sodium hydroxide aqueous solution.
where E = E~ D;D is the dimensionless dielectric constant (relative permittivity) and .c0 is the permittivity of free space; A E , I;, r ] , and C* are the potential gradient, zeta potential, viscosity, and a constant. The value of r] for a 40 % methanol-water solution at 20 "C is ca. 1.8 cP, and gradually decreases to ca. 0.6 CP at 100% methanol [2.43]. The dielectric constant of 40 % methanol-water at 20 "C is 61,and decreases gradually to 32 at 100 % methanol. These two parameters do not vary significantly between 80 and 90% methanol-water. Therefore, the marked increase of v,,,,, and vmObbeyond 90 % methanol may derive from the increase in zeta potential.
2.6.8
Ion-Exchange Chromatography in an Electric Field
Electrochromatography is also applied to ion-exchange chromatography [2.44]. The apparatus (Fig. 2.16 B) consists of a fused silica capillary (50 pm inner diameter, column length 18 cm, total capillary length 25 cm) packed with anion-exchange resins (TSKgel IC-Anion-sw, Toso) and a mixture (10: 90) of methanol and a buffer of 3 mM phthalic acid + 3 mM hexamethylenediamine + 0.15 mM 2-[4-(2-hydroxyethyl)-lpiperazinyl] ethanesulfonic acid (HEPES) aqueous solution as eluent. Indirect UV absorption (236 nm) was employed for detection of anions, except iodide.
2.6 Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromatographyon Microcolumns
I\ I
I 0
0.01
O.D.
41
f
I
I
I
I
5
10
15
18
mi
Figure 2.26. Electrochromatograms of inorganic anions [2.45). (a) C1-; (b) NO,; (c) I-; (d) C104; (e) SOP Eluent: mixture of methanol (10 %) and buffer (pH 6.4) composed of 3 mM phthalic acid - 3 mM hexamethylenediamine aqueous solution (90 %).
In Figure 2.26, the elution time of sulfonate double charged anion is reduced more than that of singly charged anions when the applied voltage along the column is increased from zero to + 2 kV (positive electrode was at the column outlet). The elution order of perchlorate and sulfonate anions is reversed at 2 kV. Figure 2.27 shows electrochromatograrns of five organic carboxylic acids. By applying voltage along the column, the separations between acetic and lactic acids and between tartaric and malonic acids are improved, and the retardation ratios, [(elution time with -3 kV)/(elution time without -1 kV)] 1.23, 1.59, 1.69 and 2.03 for lactic, acetic, tartaric, malonic and oxalic acid anions.
42
2 Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry
- 3 K V
vv
0
10
20
E
30
(min)
Figure 2.27. Electrochromatograms of carboxylic acids [2.45] (A) acetic acid, (B) lactic acid, (C) tartaric acid, (D) malonic acid, (E) oxalic acid Elucnt: mixture of methanol (10%) and buffer (pH 6.8) composed of 3 mM phthalic acid, 3 mM hexamethylcnediamine; applied voltage -3 kV (lower diagram); -1 kV (upper diagram).
Figure 2.28 shows the relationship between capacity factor and applied voltage. The capacity factor is [(elution time of anion)/(elution time of nonretained peak)]. The peak of the solvent in the sample solution was taken as a nonretained peak. The eluent was a mixture of 3 mM phthalic acid, 3 mM hexamethylenediamine, and 0.15% HEPES acid, aqueous solution. It is very interesting that the elution time of each of the monovalent anions has its own constant value when the applied voltage is increased to +7 kV. However, the elution times of these anions are increased when negative voltages are applied. The sulfonate anion value is increased by the application of positive voltages, and vice versa, like the ions in ODS-silica column chromatography. The effect of application of electrovoltage is clearly observed in the electrochromatography using ion exchange resins, as shown in Figure 2.27.
2.6.9
Voltage-Programmed Electrochromatography
Tjaden et al. [2.33] compared electrochromatography with constant and programmed applied voltages. They also tried to compare chromatograms obtained with isocratic and gradient modes in conventional chromatography and electrochromatography. Figure 2.29A shows the chromatogram of a test mixture of alkaloids run under isocratic conditions. Alkaloids are basic compounds that are neutral at high pH (pK, > 9). Although good efficiency was obtained for neutral compounds, the charged alkaloids showed severe tailing, resulting in a disappointing performance of the separation system. The use of an end-capped packing material improves the performance, but this study was not focused on optimum separation of. By applying a voltage over the separation column, an electrophoretic component is be superimposed on the chromato-
2.6 Pressurized Flow-Driven Electrochromatography on Microcolumns
43
. so,'-
c10,-
-
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
I
L - 3 - 2 -1 0 +1 + 2 + 3 +4 + 5 +6 +7
APPLIED VOLTAGE [KV] Figure 2.28. Variation of capacity factors of inorganic anions with applied voltage [2.45]. Eluent as Figure 2.27.
graphic migration. Figure 2.29B shows the chromatogram of the same test mixture, but with a applied voltage along the column. It is clear that a voltage influences the separation characteristics considerably. For the separation of nucleotides, triethylamine, an ion-pairing reagent, is added above 10 mM in order to achieve sufficient retention of nucleotides. For LC-MS, such a high concentration of triethylamine causes excessive ion-source contamination. Tjaden et al. [2.33] found the longer alkyl chains of dibutylamine (DBA) gave sufficient retention of nucleotides when used at concentrations as low as 1-2 mM. Figure 2.30A shows the chromatogram of three adenosine phosphates, separated under isocratic conditions. Retention was obtained, but ADP and ATP are eluted with poor performance. In Figure 2.30B the chromatogram of the same mixture is shown, with applied voltage + 5 kV on the electrode at the column end; anionic compounds are accelerated. Although the symmetry of the later eluting compounds is far from ideal, a real peak compression can be seen. The influence of the application of a voltage over the capillary column is even clearer in Figure 2.30C, in which a stepwise gradient of applied voltage is used. After the elution of AMP, the applied voltage was increased from 5 to 10 kV. The ATP peak is really compressed and becomes very sharp. The programmed applied voltage is very effective for improving chromatograms, like the solvent gradient elution used in conventional liquid chromatography.
+
+
44
2 Electrochromatography in Analytical Chemistry
(B)
(A)
moi
ine codeine
L
dimethyl-morphine thebaine
1
0
20
10
30
min O
-10 kV
T
Figure 2.29. Chromatograms of some morphine alkaloids [2.3.5]. Column, 1.50 mm X 220 pm inner diameter packed with 5 pm Nucleosil 100 CIS;mobile phase: mixture of acetonitrile and 2 mM ammonium acetate (2:3, voYvol); applied voltage: 10 kV starting at t = 9 min; UV detection at 220 nm, 0.01 a.u.f.s.; amounts injected, ca. 50 ng of each compound.
IADP
0
10 20 30 40
min
0
10 20 30 40
min
Figure 2.30. Separation of 17 ng of AMP, ADP and ATP [2.35]. Column: 200 mm x 220 pm inner diameter packed with 5 pm Nucleosil 100 C18;mobile phase: mixture of methanol and 2 mM dibutylamine at pH 5.0 (1:9); UV detection 260 nm, 0.0025 a.u.f.s. (A) Isocratic conditions with no applied voltage; (B) With applied voltage +S kV, (C) Starting voltage + 5 kV, increased to 10 kV at t = 9 min.
+
Voltage-programmed electrochromatography can be carried out in the isocratic mode. Therefore it is convenient to connect a microcolumn liquid chromatograph with a mass spectrometer, because the latter is sensitive to the change in solvent composition [2.33], (see also Chap. 6, Section 3).
2.7 References
2.7
45
References
[2.1] S. Otsuka, L. Listowsky, Anal. Biochem., 102, 419-422 (1980). [2.2] P. H. O’Farrell, Science, 227, 1586-1589 (1985). [2.3] T. Tsuda, Anal. Chem., 59, 521-523 (1987). [2.4] T. Tsuda, Anal. Chem., 60, 1677-1680 (1988). t2.51 T. Tsuda, Y. Muramatsu, J . Chromatogr., 515, 645-652 (1990). 12.61 T. Tsuda, 1. Chem. SOC. Jpn, Chem. Indu. Chem., 937-942 (1986) (CA 105: 126484r). [2.7] S. Kitagawa, T. Tsuda, J. Microcol. Sep., 6,91-96 (1994). [2.8] T. Tsuda, K. Nomura, G . Nakagawa, J . Chromatogr., 248,241-247 (1982). [2.9] J. H. Knox, I. H. Grant, Chromatographia, 24, 135 (1987). [2.10] T. Tsuda, LC-GC Zntl. 5 (9), 26-36 (1992). [2.11] T. Tsuda, J . Liquid Chromatogr., 12, 2501-2514 (1989). [2.12] T. Tsuda, “Control of electroosmotic flow in capillary electrophoresis”, Chap. 22, in Handbook of capillary electrophoresis, J. P. Landers (ed.), CRC, Ann Arbor, 1993. [2.13] J. H. Knox, I. H. Grant, Chromatographia, 32,317-328 (1991). [2.14] T. S . Stevens, H. J. Cortes,Anal. Chem., 55, 1356-1370 (1983). [2.15] J. C. Giddings, Dynamics of chromatography, Dekker, New York, 1965. [2.16] S. Kitagawa, T. Tsuda, 1994 unpublished. [2.17] C. E. Reese, R . P. W. Scott, J . Chromatogr., 18,479 (1980). [2.18] G. Taylor, Proc. R. SOC.London, Ser. A , 219, 186 (1953). [2.19] K. Ando, Thesis for bachelor degree, Nagoya Institute of Technology (Nagoya), 1984. [2.20] H. Wada, S. Hiraoka, A. Yuchi, G. Nakagawa, Anal. Chimica Acta, 179, 181-188 (1986). [2.21] V. Pretorius, B. J. Hopkins, J. D. Schieke, J . Chromatogr., 99, 23 (1974). [2.22] W. D. Pfeffer, E. S. Yeung, Anal. Chem., 62, 2178 (1990). [2.23] E E. P. Mikkers, E M. Everaerts, P. E. M. Verhaggen, J . Chromatogr., 169, 11 (1979). [2.24] J. W. Jorgenson, K. D. Lukacs, Anal. Chem., 53, 1298 (1981). [2.25] T. Tsuda, K. Nomura, G. Nakagawa, J. Chromatogr., 264,385 (1983). [2.26] W. D. Pfeffer, E. S. Yeung, J. Chromatogr., 557, 125-136 (1991). [2.27] M. Martin, G. Guiochon, Anal. Chem., 56, 614 (1984). [2.28] M. Martin, G. Guiochon, Y. Walbroehl, J. W. Jorgenson, Anal. Chem., 57, 559 (1985). [2.29] C. L. Rice, R. Whitehead, J . Phys. Chem., 69 (ll), 4017 (1965). [2.30] T. Tsuda et al., J . Chromatogr., 632, 201 (1993). [2.31] T. Tsuda, J. W. Sweedler, R. N. Zare, Anal. Chem., 62, 2149 (1990). [2.32] A. B. Littlewood, Gas Chromatography, Academic Press, New York, 1970. 12.331 E. R. Verheij, U. R. Tjaden, W. M. A. Niessen, 3. van der Greef, J . Chromatogr., 554, 339-349 (1991). [2.34] M. Nakashima, T. Tsuda, 1994 unpublished. [2.35] D. H. Shain et al., Anal. Biochem., 200, 47-51 (1992). [2.36] S. Kitagawa, M. Inagaki, T. Tsuda, Chromatography (Kuromatoguraphi), 14, 39R-43R (1993). [2.37] S. Hoffmann, L. Blomberg, Chromatographia, 24,416 (1987). [2.38] G . Kortun, W. Vogel, K. Andrussov (eds.), Dissociation Constants of Organic Acids Aqueous Solution, Buttenvorths, London, 1961. [2.39] N. Purdie, M. B. Thomson, N. Riemann, J. Solution Chem., 1, 465-476 (1972). [2.40] C. Horvath, W. Melander, I. Molr, Anal. Chem., 49, 142-152 (1974). [2.41] S. Kitagawa, T. Tsuda, J. Microcol. Sep. 7, 59-64 (1995). [2.42] R. J. Hunter, Zeta potential in colloid science, Academic Press, London, 1981. [2.43] S. Hjerten, Chromatogr. Rev., 9, 122-219 (1967). [2.44] International Critical Tables of Numerical Data Physics, Chemistry and Technology, McGram-Hill, Inc., New York, 1929, p. 22. [2.45] H. Watanabe, S. Kitagawa, T. Tsuda, 1995 unpublished.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
3
Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography Takao Tsuda
3.1
Electroosmosis
In electrochromatography, an electroosmotic flow is generated if three essential elements are satisfied: a) there is an applied voltage along the column; b) there are charges on the surface of the packing support or the inner surface of a open-tubular capillary column; c) the eluent conducts electricity. Electroosmosis has ben studied by a number of workers [3.1]-[3.31]. It is affected by eluent pH, electrolyte concentration, temperature, applied voltage and current, column material, and surface adsorption.
3.1.1
Surface Charge of Silica Gel and Packing Support
In liquid chromatography, columns have been classified as: 1) open-tubular capillary columns [3.32]; 2) packed microcapillary columns [3.33], [3.34]; 3) slurry-packed capillary columns [3.35]; 4) microcolumns [3.36]; and 5) conventional columns. Microdimensional columns are preferable for electrochromatography, because of their abilitiy for effective heat dissipation. Electroosmosis has been studied by using open-tubular capillaries in capillary zone electrophoresis, in which electroosmosis is used as the essential solute driving power. Chromatography performed with electroosmosis as the only driving power has a great deal of similarity with capillary zone electrophoresis. Since the silica gel used as packing support has 3-10 silanol groups on an area of 10 A2 [3.37], it is easy to understand that the surface will be charged by SiO- groups resulting from dissociation of SiOH. The amount of SiO- groups depends on pH. However, the total charge on the surface cannot be explained solely by the dissociation of silanol groups [3.7], I3.301. The surface itself has a charge induced on it by surrounding electrostatic fields. For example, silica gels, glass beads, fused silica and tetrafluoroethylene tubing, have negative surface charges [3.7], while charcoal has a positive charge. Under applied voltage, electroosmotic flow will be generated provided the three essential elements set out above are met. Another way of inducing a surface charge is by means of a voltage along the crosssectional direction of the column, i. e., a radial field [3.21]-[3.29]. Even with no externally applied radial field, a certain radial voltage will be generated by applying a voltage along the column; at every site along the capillary column, a certain current will be released from the outer surface of the capillary to the medium, e.g., air or water, through the glass wall (resistance ca. 1015Q [7.27]). Experimentally we can observe, especially at high applied potential gradients along the column, e . g., 500-1000 Vkm, that a great deal of dust is forced onto the outer surface. As dust has
48
3 Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography
opposite charges, the current will be released every time a dust particle attaches to the surface. The applied potential along the column induces a potential gradient across the column, and hence some charge on its inner surface (i.e., a zeta potential).
3.1.2
Electrical Potential in the Vicinity of a Solid Surface
To understand the origin of electroosmotic flow, it is necessary to discuss briefly electrical potential and the physical environment of the interface. The discussion follows the approach of Hunter [3.38]. The electrostatic potential near an isolated charged object in vacuum is defined by Coulomb's law. If the object is a sphere of radius r the potential at a distance a from its surface is:
q = Q / [ e m o(r+a)]
(1)
where Q is the total charges on the surface and q,is the permittivity of free space [3.38]. The potential very close to the surface (less than 100 A) cannot be measured, because of interactions between the probe and the charge on the object. For r = 1 cm, the potential in vacuum is constant up to 100 pm from the surface of object and equal to:
Vo = Q / ( 4 n ~ )
(2)
where q0 is the potential at the surface of the object. Then the potential q then decreases with increase of the distance from the sphere [3.38]. The simplest model, attributed to Helmholtz, has two layers of charge at the interface between two phases (solid surface and liquid) fixed in parallel planes to form a molecular condenser, called an electrical double-layer (Fig. 3.1). Although the charge on a solid surface may be assumed to be located in a plane, the electrical forces on the ions in a liquid phase compete with the thermal diffusive forces, forming a diffuse double-layer [3.39], [3.40]. With this model, the fundamental electrostatic equation for the system is: V2 = -(4n%)-' [(4ne)/D]
(3)
where D is the relative permittivity and p is the volume charge density:
e = Cn,z,e
(4)
where z is the valency of type i ions and n, is the number of type i ions per unit volume:
n, = n,"exp (- z,e$dkT)
(5)
when q = 0, n, = n,". Substituting Equations (5) and (4) into Equation (3), we obtain the complete Poisson-Boltzman equation: V2q = d@/dx2 = - (4n~&'(4n/D) Cn,"z,e exp (-z,eqlkT)
(6)
This equation is simplified to one dimension because W varies only with x . If q!~is small everywhere in the double-layer (i.e., z,eq << kT), we approximate exp x by l-x and use the preservation of electroneutrality in the bulk electrolyte to obtain:
3.1 Electroosmosis
49
(7) where x = [(e' Xn~z?)/ ( E ~ T ) ] ' . ~
Equation (7) can be solved to give: dW/dx
=
-*
(9)
since dV/dx = 0 and qj = 0 in the bulk solution, far from the solid surface ( x -+ A second integration of Equation (9) using q~ = qjo at x = 0 gives:
1~ = vIIexp
co).
(10)
This shows the approximate form of the potential distribution near the wall. The general Equation (6) can be integrated, and treats most electrolytes as symmetric. It gives: dV/dx
=-
[(2xkT)/(ze)] sinh [zeq)/(%kl")]
(11.1)
The integrated form of Equation (11) can be expressed in many ways, the most compact of which [3.38] is: tanh(zq*/4) = tanh(zqo*/4)exp(-kx)
(11.2)
x
along cD1umn radial applierj
diffuse double layer
an electric double layer [an elertrrc or Lnner
Hs 1 mho I t L p l a n e ( IHP) 1
olid surface
B)
Electrostatic
Potential
Figure 3.1. A) Electrical double-layer. B) Schematic expression for the distribution of ions at, near, and within a solid surface, and for the variation of electrostatic potential from the surface of the solid to the liquid (x-direction).
50
3 Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography
where q~ = ely*/kTis a dimensionless potential parameter, which we will refer to as the reduced potential (at 25 "C, qI* = 1 when q~ = 2.57 mV). Figure 3.1 shows the electrical potential zq* in the double-layer versus xx according to Gouy and Chapman [3.41]. The distance l/x is referred to as the thickness of the double-layer (namely xx = l), although the varying potential extends to 2 % beyond its original value. The potential drop across the inner region of the double-layer (inner Helmholtz plane, IHP, Stern layer) is often around 0.1 V and since this occurs across a distance of less than 1 nm, the field strength is about 1O8V/rn.This is sufficiently high to polarize molecules, appreciably.
3.1.3
Origin of Electroosmotic Flow
The theory for electroosmosis was developed by von Smouluwski [3.38], [3.42], who considered the movement of a liquid adjacent to a flat, charged surface under the influence of an electric field applied parallel to the interface. The velocity of the liquid in the direction parallel to the wall v, rises from a value of zero in the inner Helmholtz plane to a maximum value v,, at some distance from the wall (ca. 314. The forces on unit volume of the liquid, which is generated by the friction of liquid, is equal to the force due to the attraction of ions under the applied voltage (Fig. 3.2):
E, Q = E,@Adw= VA (dv,/&), - VA(dv,/&),+~ or:
E,
@X =
-
-V(d2vZ/dx2)&
Electric
F i e l d
Area:A
m8 m8@-&+ +
Figure 3.2. Electroosmotic flow generated by movement of partial charge of molecules due to an electric field (2-direction).
3. I
Electroosmosis
51
where E,, Q, A, and v are the potential gradient applied parallel to the solid surface, number of charges in the liquid (ions), unit area which experiences the friction and local velocity of electroosmosis, respectively. The z-axis is parallel to the surface. Substituting for e gives: E , ( 4 n ~ )(D/4n) (d2q/dx2)dx = q(d2v,/d x2)&
(14)
This equation can be integrated from a point far from the solid surface where q = 0 and v, = vosmup to the inner Helmholtz plane where v, = 0 and = f. At first, both dq/& and dv,/dx are zero far from the solid surface. The result is: v0SmiE7
= pe = =-
- 4 n ~[ ( ~ ~ ) 4 4 ~ ~ ) 1
(&r)
(15)
(16)
where pe is electroosmotic mobility. In several reports, Equation (16) is expressed as follows [3.2], [3.6], [3.12], [3.431-[3.45] : vosm = [(DW(4nv)lf =
[(~fW(4n7~~~q)l
(17) (18)
According to Hunter (p. 357 of [3.38]),Equation (18) is not “rationalized”, and he recommends replacing D by 4 n D~ or 4 n ~Equation . (18) is still satisfactory, but it is better to use Equation (16). There are two equations for electroosmosis: vosm =
(DW(4nr)
vosm = ( 4 x 4 [ ( D M ~ =~ ( EI W V
(A.1) (A3
Hunter describes the reason (p. 357 of [3.34]), as follows. The factor 4 n appears because the original units were “unrationalized”. After rationalization by defining the force between two charged particles in a dielectric, the factor 4 n appears in formulae involving spherical symmetry and disappears for flat plates. Whenever D appears in the old formulae it should be replaced by 4nq, D or 4 n ( ~E = %D).They remark that D is a dimensionless quantity.
3.1.4
Thickness of the Double-Layer
The thickness of the double-layer 6 depends on the electrolyte concentration which enters through its effect on the parameter x (= 1/6), and for water at 25 “C [3.38] is: x = [(2000F2)/ (QDRT)]”.~ p 5 nm-’ = 3.288 p5
(19)
where Fand R are the Faraday (96485 C) and the molar gas constant, respectively. The ionic strength, I (mol/L), is: I
=
0.5 Fc,z/
(20)
52
3
Electroosmosis and Electrochrornatography
Table 3.1. Electrolyte concentration and double-layer thickness [3.38] ~
_
_
_
_
_
~
Electrolyte, moVL
Thickness*, nm
lo-‘
1.04 3.04 9.62 30.4
10-2 10-3
10
* Calculated from Equation (21) moYL, the value of l l x is 3.04 nm, and where ci is the concentration of ion i. At I = moYL (Table 3.1). These values are estimated for a flat chanit is 30.4 nm at I = nel. Another estimation of the thickness of the double-layer is given by Delahy [3.32]: S = (3 x 10-~1 zi 1 c , ’ ~ ) - cm ’
(21)
In slurry-packed capillary columns, the channels between packing supports are very narrow, estimated at one-tenth of the particle diameter [3.46], ca. 1-0.3 pm when the particle diameter of the packing supports is 10-3 pm. As the surface charge will affect up to ten times the thickness of the diffuse double-layer, its length will reach almost half the thickness of the channels in some cases. This will reduce the flow velocity of electroosmosis. The overlap of central flow with the diffuse double-layer may cause plug and laminar flow profiles. The cross-section of channels between packing supports may be square or rectangular, not flat or round. Rice and Whitehead [3.45] proposed that the equation for the planar model should be modified for application to a cylindrical model by the correction factor F ( x r ) :
F(xr)
=
1 - “ 2 z i ( x r ) ] / [ x rI,(xr)]j
(22)
The value of F ( x r ) , plotted as a function of log xr ( I = radius), is shown in Figure 3.3. Its value deviates from 1 when xr is less than 10. Thus, the electroosmotic flow velocity in a cylindrical capillary is given by:
0.0 I 0.0
J 0.2
0.4
0.8
0.8
1.0
Log
Kr
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
Figure 3.3. Correction factor for electroosmotic flow velocity; cylindrical geometry [3.45].
3.1 Electroosmosis
53
The parameter x is equal to the reciprocal thickness of the diffuse double-layer, b-', and is given by Equation (21). Correction factors for the cylindrical geometry are shown in Figure 3.3. Although the cross-section of the channels between packing supports in the column is not circular, the use of this correction factor gives a better approximation for the channels in silica gels. In open-tubular capillary columns, we usually use 100-25 pm inner diameter capillary. It is not necessary to use the geometric factor for the electroosmotic flow, because the thickness of the double-layer is less than 1 pm in general. However if we use a very narrow capillary tube (less than 5 pm inner diameter), the flat model geometry is no longer valid, and we should be very careful about the effect of the double-layer on flow profile, since the potential from the solid surface is generally effective up to 3 / x , i.e. ca. 1 pm at lo4 moVL (Table 3.1).
3.1.5
Charge Density on Silica Gel Surfaces
The estimation of charge density on the wall surface is the key to the calculation of q, capacitance, thickness of double-layer, and electroosmotic mobility. It is clear that the charge density can be controlled by a radially applied voltage. The charge density is also affected by its chemical environment, e. g., pH. The number of silanol groups per unit area of the surface, [SiOH],, depends on the dissociation.
c,
[SiO-] + [H']
[SiOH],
(24)
These ionized silanol groups generate a surface charge density a(SiO-), which is related to the solution pH by: a(SiO-)
=
[SiOH], ([SiO-],/{[SiOH],
+ [SiO-Is]) = f'/[l+ [H+]/K]
+
(25)
where f' = [SiOH], [SiO-1, and K is the dissociation constant. When there are 5 SiOH groups in an area of 10 A', the density of silanol groups, b(Si0H) b(SiO-) = 5 x 1014cm-', and a(SiO-) = 5 X lo7 cm-' at pH 7 ( K is estimated as The total charge density 4,is assumed to be given by the summation of the charges due to silanol groups and the radially applied voltage:
a, = a,,,, + a",+ a(SiO-)
+
(26)
where onatand a", are the charge density generated by the natural electric field (i. e., the electric field of the Earth or the radial electric field generated when a voltage is applied along the column) and the radially applied voltage, respectively. Equation (26) assumes that the electrostatic charges and the ionization of surface hydroxyl groups do not interact. The relation between a,and u,,, is derived [3.18] as follows: u,,,,, =
E,(~dq-)exp (-xx)(2kT/e) sinh-' [(a,,, + a,, + o(SiO-))] (500 ~ / E ~ c R T ) ~ . ~
(27)
where suffix b refers to the solution buffer. Although a,,, + u,, was originally defined as the density of the double-layer [3.19], it can be identified with the surface charge. From Equations (24) and (27) it is possible to estimate the pK, values for silanol groups on the surface of silica gels. Figure 2.23 of Chapter 2 gives pKa = 4.2 for silanol groups on the surface of silica gel modified with octadecylsilane [3.47].
54
3
3.1.6
Chemical Modification of the Inner Surface by Adsorption in Open-'Ibbular Capillary Columns
Electroosmosis and Electrochromatogruphy
Since E.- = ilk, where i and k denote current density (A/cm2) and specific conductance (Q-' cm-'), Equation (16) can be written in the form: vom
=
( i d ) (kq1-I
(28)
As R (resistance in Q) depends on the temperature in the medium, E (= RI) varies
with temperature, where I is the current. The zeta potential and diffuse double-layer thickness 6 , have the following relationship [3.48]:
c = (6 n,,,e)
(29)
($I
where n,,, is thc number of charges on the inner surface of the open-tubular column. Substituting Equations (29) and (21) into Equation (28) gives: v,
= (i n,,,e) I [3 x 10'
I z 1 c"* kq]
(30)
The product of k and q , called the Walden product, is independent of temperature 13.121. We obtain: v,,,
=AI
(i 4,,,e) 1 ( I z
I C''7
(31)
where A , is a constant. From Equation (30), the electroosmotic flow velocity depends on a,,, and its dircction depends on the sign of the charges. On the inner wall of the capillary there are two kinds of surface charge: I) surface charges which are induced by the Earth's field a,,d,; 2) surface charges due to the dissociation of SiOH groups, u(SiO-). These surface charges may be covered partially or completely by surface-active reagents, such as cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) I3.101, [3.12] or tetrabutylammonium hydroxide (TBA) [3.20]. From the relation between the concentration of these surface-active reagents and electroosmotic flow velocity (Fig. 3.4), it is clear that the original surface has a certain amount of negative charge, a,,,, which decreases as increasing amounts of CTAB or TBA are adsorbed on the surface of the glass wall. The sign of the surface charge changcs from negative to positive at 3.5 x lo4 mol/L for CTAB. The number of positive charges increases, until the surface is completely covered. On the other hand, when we use a strong surface-active reagent with negative charges, such as sodium dodecylsulfonate, the amount of negative charge on the inner surface of capillary column may become more negative [3.12]. Therefore, we can control the amount of the surface charge and its sign by the addition of surface-active reagents. This is often done in capillary electrophoresis to obtain a short elution time of negative ions, since both solute mobility and electroosmotic flow operate in the same direction, to decrease the adsorption of protein on account of the electrostatic repulsion between the surface and the solute [3.24], [3.30], [3.31].
3.1
Electroosrnosis
55
=-N
I
E V u
+, 4 2
. 3
t
V .3
c,
0
E In
0
-10-
a
F
Figure 3.4. Variation of electroosmotic mobility v with concentration of cetylammonium bromide (CTAB). (Open circles) buffer for points 1-3 was 0.02 M-(N-morpholine) ethanesulfonic acid-L-histidine aqueous solution with 0.5 % ethylene glycol (pH 6.2); buffer for points 4-7 was 0.01 M phosphate buffer with 5 % ethylene glycol (pH 8.3). FEP (0.2 or 0.3 mm) and a fused silica capillary (50 pm inner diameter) were used for points 1-3 and 4-7, respectively L3.121; (Triangles) pH 3, 10 mM phosphate buffer containing 10% acetonitrile, 10 pm fused silica capillary [3.19]; (Squares) pH 7, 10 mM phosphate buffer, 10 pm fused silica capillary [3.20].
3.1.7
Effect of pH on Electroosmosis
The effect of pH, as described by Ewing et al. [3.28] is given by Equation (27) which includes the contribution of dissociated silanols on the glass inner surface. However, the estimate does not correspond to experimental values [3.27], [3.28]. It is possible that their estimation of other factors andor the additive law of charge densities are not valid. As shown in Figure 3.5, at pH > 8, most of the silanol groups on the inner surface of an uncoated capillary are dissociated, and the electroosmotic flow velocity is independent of pH. For pH < 4, v,,, is independent of pH because most of the silanols are indissociated. Therefore, v,,, varies at pH between 4 and 8. It is necessary to note that
56
3 Electroosmosis and Electrochrornatography 7.53 -
h
.--* .-
6.53
a
0
E
.V
-d
4.5.
Y
0
E v1
-
0
0
.l
w V Y
0.d
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
0
1
1
PH Figure 3.5. Dependence of electroosmotic mobility on pH for uncoated and coated capillary. (m) uncoated capillary; (A) Briji-35/0DS coated capillary [3.30]; ( 0 ) uncoated [3.7]; (*) uncoated, theoretical estimated value, and ( 0 ) experimental value [3.50].
the pK, of silanol is always dependent on the surface conditions and the buffer employed [3.7], [3.30]. Teflon tubing is also used for electroosmosis, and its pH dependence is similar to that of as fused silica capillary tubing [3.7], [3.49].
3.1.8
Electroosmotic Mobility in Open-Tubular Capillary Columns
The linear flow velocity in electroosmosis depends on the physical parameters of the solvent and also on the electrolyte concentration, from Equations (28)-(32). Electroosmotic mobility is listed in Tables 3.2A and 3.2B, in which data were obtained by using an uncoated Pyrex glass capillary column and coated fused silica capillary respectively. The order of the velocities of acetonitrile, water, and methanol is readily understood from the ratios of their dielectric constants to the viscosity of the solvent, 10, 7, and 6 , respectively. The effect of the concentration of disodium hydrogen orthophosphate in water on the electroosmotic mobility is also understandable from Equation (30). The electroosmotic mobility is shown in Figure 3.5.
3.1.9
Electroosmotic Flow Velocity in Packed Columns
The values of electroosmotic mobility kSosm are listed inTables 3.2A, 3.2B and 3.3 [3.7], [3.9], [3.47], [3.51], [3.52], in which both the references and our measured data are summarized. Cortes [3.53] found that the electroosmotic mobility depends on the size of the channels, because there is an effect from the diffuse double-layer, for extremely small channels, e.g. < 1 pm . However, Knox et al. [3.52] deny this effect. This contradiction may arise from the differences in experimental conditions. Coretes et al. used a neutral medium and Knox et al. used an alkaline buffer. Erni et al. [3.51] admit that
3.1 Electroosmosis
57
Table 3.2A. Linear flow velocity of electroosmosis at 100 V/cm Solvent
Linear velocity, cm/s
Experimental conditions*
Distilled water Methanol Acetonitrile 0.05 % Methanol-n-hexane 0.01 M NazHPO,-water 0.025 M Na2HP04-water 0.05 M Na2HP04-water 0.075 M Na,HPO.+-water 0.1 M NazHP04-water Methanol-benzene (1 :9)
0.061 0.034 0.14
1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 Ref. [3.70]
0.0006
0.12 0.093 0.087 0.077 0.057 0.01
* 1) Capillary column, Pyrex, 57.6 cm x 132 pm; solute, benzene or pyridine; power supply, constant-voltage mode, 13 kV; 2) Capillary column, Pyrex, 60 cm X 132 pm; solute, as above; power supply, constant-currentmode, 200 pA (voltage gradient was varied from 302 to 96 Vlcm). Table 3.2B. Electroosmotic mobiliy KO, measured in various fused-silica capillaries Capillary
b,x
VPe
Q, pm
Acetonitrile-buffeP (2:3)
ODS ODS PSL-ODS~ ODS ODS Etched
5 10 10 25 50 50
2.40 2.38 2.18 2.49 2.43 2.37
a
cm2V-' s-' Methanol-buffer" (1:l) 1.16
1.13
0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH 7). PSL, capillary with a porous silica layer.
electroosmotic mobility depends on pH, increasing in the region pH 6-8 and then remaining constant for pH > 8. The same phenomenon is observed in the region pH 4-8 in open-tube capillaries by Regnier et al. [3.30]. In other words, Erni et al. [3.51] and Knox et al. [3.52] did their experiments with a high density of surface charge, due to the dissociation of the silanol groups on the silica packing materials. Although Erni et al. used a silica-modified packing material (silicaODs), they assumed that 50% of the silanol groups on the surface of the silica gel remain unreacted, and the groups may dissociate in alkaline medium following an increase in the electroosmotic mobility [3.28], [3.29]. The diffuse double-layer affects electroosmotic mobility, reducing the flow velocity by factors of 0.3 and 0.8 when 2 and 10 times the thickness of the diffuse double-layer are equal to the radius of the channels [3.29], [3.38], [3.45]. The estimate of the diffuse double-layer is 1 pm [3.14] to 3 nm [3.38] for 10-20 mM aqueous electrolyte solutions. The data in Table 3.3 can be explained as follows: in a pure medium (it does not contain electrolyte) the thickness of the diffuse layer is larger, and this may decrease the electroosmotic mobility in narrow channels. As in a buffer of pH > 4, the density of charge of the silica solid surface due to the dissociation of silanol groups is larger than that in an organic medium, and also in a buffer of pH < 4, it increases the electroosmotic mobility markedly, even though there is a small reduction from the effect of the
58
3 Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography
Table 3.3. Electroosmotic mobility in the packed microcapillary column
Packing
Supposed channel", Pm
Bio-Sil-A [3.53]
1 10 10 1 0.5
Patisil 10-Sil [3.53] Hypersil [3.52]
DeverosiK8 [3.53]
0.3 0.15 0.5
Capcell-ODS [3.54]
0.7
Develosil-ODS [3.9] Hypersil ODS [3.51]
0.3 0.3
Monospher ODS [3.51] 0.16
Electroosmotic mobility, X lo4 cm2V-' s-l 2.8 1.2 3.2 0.7 1.9 1.2 2.6 0.49 0.47 0.46 0.15 0.16 0.085 0.41 0.28 0.13 -0.088 0.48 0.16 4.1 2.9
Medium
methanol acetonitrile water methanol 2 mM NaH2P04+ H20 acetonitrile (3:7) as above as above ethanol ethano1:water (8:2) ethano1:water (95:s) with additivesb ethanol:water (80:20) with additivesb ethano1:water (70:30) with additivesb ethanol:water (80:20) with additives' methanol ethanol acetonitrile 20 mM CTAB ethanol (3:7) methanol 2 mM B4Na207(pH 8.7): acetonitrile (2:8) 4mM Na2B407(pH 9.2) H 2 0 4 mM Na2B407(pH 9.2): acetonitrile (4:6)
Channels estimated as one-tenth of particle diameter, d,. Ethylenediamine and polyoxyethylene lauryl ether (PELE) 5 mM and 0.1 YO,respectively. Ethylenediamine and PELE, 20 mM and 0.1 % , respectively.
a
diffuse double-layer. The coverage of silanol groups on the surface of silica gels by reaction with ODS decreases the electroosmotic mobility by a factor of half to one-sixth of the value for untreated silica materials, owing to the low charge density (Table 3.3). The relation between applied voltage and linear velocity of electroosmosis in a packed capillary column is shown in Figure 3.6 [3.51]. Electroosmotic flow velocity at a given potential gradient, v,,~,is given by kosm A E . Therefore, if we apply 1000 V/cm to a column packed with Capcell-ODS and methanol is used as eluent, v,,, = 0.4 mml s. This is a moderate flow rate for liquid chromatography. If more than 50 kVis applied to a 143 mm long capillary column, the system becomes unstable. This could be considered to be the result of heating [3.51]. In general the speed of electroosmosis is high enough to operate liquid chromatography with a 10-20 min analysis period, and application of a high potential gradient may yield high-speed analysis, in spite of the use of very small particles as column supports. Usually, the use of column supports of very fine particle diameter needs a high inlet pressure when operating liquid chromatography with pressurized flow, but not in the case of the use of electroosmosis. The another consideration for the estimation of electroosmotic mobility in packed columns is that the channels in a packed column are both tortuos and constricted [3.46]. Therefore it is necessary to estimate the structural parameter fst when we compare the value of electroosmotic mobility in a packed capillary with the value in an open-tubular capillary column.
3.2 Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography and Electrochromatography I
.
I
'
l
h
P
P
. '
59
I
6-
Y
-
h .rl c,
:: 4 -
r(
2 2
:2 -
.3
4
I
0
,
I
,
I
,
I
4
Potential Gradient (KV/cm)
Figure 3.6. Dependence of electroosmotic flow velocity on applied voltage. Capillary column, 50 pm internal diameter, 143 mm long; packing material, Hypersil ODS (3 pm); mobile phase, 2 mM sodium tetraborate (pH 8.7) 80% Acetonitrile; sampling 1.5 kV for 4 s; sample, thiourea [3.51].
Comparing the values listed Table 3.2 and Table 3.3, the electroosmotic mobility obtained for open-tubular capillary columns is generally higher compared with packed columns and it is reasonable to employ structural parameters for comparing the values.
3.2
Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography and Electrochromatography
In the following discussion, electrochromatography means that the solute is charged, and the electrophoretic mobility contributes to the separation. Chromatography means that the solute is neutral, and separation depends on partition under electroosmotic flow. Without pressurized flow, separation proceeds by electroosmosis, electrophoretic mobility, and partition with respect to the stationary phase. The separation efficiency is governed by the electroosmotic flow profile and by the velocity profile due to electrophoretic mobility. The plug-like flow profile of electroosmosis is advantageous for separation, especially if the capacity factor of the solutes is < 2. This effect on column efficiency decreases gradually to capacity factor > 2 [3.56], [3.57].
3.2.1
Electroosmotically Driven Electrochromatography
A typical example of electroosmotically driven electrochromatography is shown in Figure 3.7, in which a 50 cm X 10 pm open-tubular capillary column coated and crosslinked with 0.9 % (wthol) PS-264 (Petrarch Systems) was used with a laser-based fluorescence detector. Yeung et al. [3.20] have separated anions, using both their partition coefficients and electrophoretic mobilities under electroosmosis. They were able to separate anionic compounds with identical mobilities. The different separations obtained with capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE), electroosmotically driven electrochromatography, and open-tubular capillary liquid chro-
60
3 Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography
matography are also shown in Figure 3.7. CZE does not provide effective separation of naphthalensulfonic acid isomers, and open-tubular liquid chromatography has difficulty separating 2-amino-1-naphthalenesulfonicacid and 8-amino-2-naphthalenesul-
(4
4A1 N, 5A2N
-8A2N, 1H4N
-
-2A1N
c
.
1
2
0
4
6
10
8
1H4N
-
I
I
I
2
0
4
(4
1H4N
6
-I 2AiN
4AlN-
Y
0
2
k
.
4 Time (min)
-
iLI.
6
8
Figure 3.7. Comparison of elution profile obtained using A) CZE; B) Electroosmotically driven electrochromatography; C) Open-tube liquid chromatography 13.201. A) Column, 50 cm X 10 pm, uncoated, 40 cm separation distance; eluent, 10 mM phosphate buffer, pH 7.0, containing 1.25 mM tetrabutylammonium hydroxide; applied voltage, +21 kV; B) Column, 50 cm x 10 pm, coated with PS264; applied voltage, +21 kV; other condition as for (A); C) Column, as for (B); applied voltage, 0; Peaks, 4A1N = 4amino-1-naphthalenesulfonic acid, 5A2N = 5-amino-2naphthalenesulfonic acid, 8A2N = 8-amino-2naphthalenesulfonic acid, 1H4N = 1-naphthol-4-sulfonic acid.
3.2 Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography and Electrochrornatography
61
fonic acid (there is only a small difference in the partition coefficients and electrophoretic mobilities of these two peaks). Electrochromatography can solve this problem, providing complete separation.
3.2.2
Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography
Electroosmotic elution of neutral compounds has been used in open-tubular capillary columns 13.71, 13.191, 13.551, packed microcapillary (drawn packed capillary) columns [3.5],[3.62], and slurry-packed capillary columns [3.9], [3.51], [3.64] as an alternative method to pressurized flow elution.
3.2.2.1 Open-Thbular Capillary Columns Contribution of Flow Profile to Theoretical Plate Height. In an open-tubular column, the channels are completey straight and the separation mechanism is easy to treat theoretically. Pretorius et al. 13.21 used a column of 1mm inner diameter and 50 cm long, and found that the theoretical plate height H for the nonretained peak (benzene) in electroosmotic flow is half that obtained with pressurized flow. However, they did not show any chromatograms. Tsuda et al. [3.7] used an open-tubular capillary column, 42 cm long and 30 pm inner diameter, in which the inner surface was modified with ODS, to separate aromatic compounds (Fig. 3.8). The relation between H a n d vosmis shown in Figure 3.9. If we calculate the value of H for pyridine as: H = ?v124Dm
(32)
This equation is for open-tubular liquid chromatography; v = 0.09 c d s , column radius r = 61 pm, and the diffusion coefficient of pyridine in pure water D , = 9.2 X lo4 cm2s (estimated value), the calculated value of H = 152 pm [3.7]. If we assume that the flow profile in the capillary tube is plug-type and molecular diffusion alone is responsible for zone broadening, (i. e., axial diffusion), the value of H for a nonretained solute is obtained as follows:
d=2Dt
(33)
H = dlL
(34)
where t and L are the elution time and column length. The calculated value is 2 pm; the value obtained by experiment is 5.2 pm, about one-thirtieth the value in pressurized flow, and more than twice the calculated value. Therefore the assumption does not hold; the band broadening for a nonretained solute is due, not only to molecular diffusion, but also to the electroosmotic flow profile in the capillary tube. Although these experimental values were obtained in the early days of electroosmotically driven chromatography, it is clear that the electroosmotic flow profile is much flatter compared with pressurized flow and a little less flat than plug flow. This flow profile raises the question of the true nature of electroosmosis. Comparison of Plate Height for Pressure-Driven and Electroosmotically Driven Systems. Axial diffusion and slow equilibrium in the mobile and stationary phases are the main processes contributing to band broadening in open-tubular liquid chromatography. This is expressed in the theoretical plate height equations derived by Golay [3.59]
62
3 Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography
I
I
15
20
I
I
I
10
5
0
Elution
I
,
30
20
Time
( min)
I
I
0
10
Elution Time
b i n )
Figure 3.8. Separation of aromatic compounds on ODS capillary column [3.7]. A) Column, 42 cm X 30 pm inner diameter; eluent, acetonitrile-water (40:60); voltage, 13 kV, samples: (1) benzene, (2) naphthalene, (3) biphenyl, (4) fluorene + anthracene, (5) p-terphenyl, (6) chrysene, and (7) 1,3,5-triphenyIbenzene; B) Eluent: acetonitrile-water (30: 70); sample, as in (A) except ( 5 ) pyrene; other conditions as above.
for a pressurized flow system (PD), and by Martin and Guiochon [3.56] and Giddings [3.46] for an electroosmotic flow system (ED). The overall plate height equation for open-tubular capillary liquid chromatography is valid in both PD and ED systems: H
=
2 0 , (v)-’ + C,d;v ( D J 1
+ C, d:v
(DJ’
(35)
where D, and D,are the diffusion coefficients in the mobile and stationary phases, d, is the inner diameter of the column, and df is the thickness of the stationary phase layer. For the pressurized flow system: C,,,,
=
(1
+ 6k’ + Ilk’) [96 (1 + k’)]-’
(36)
3.2 Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography and Electrochromatography
0
0.1
v
0.2
(cm/sec)
63
Figure 3.9. Relationship between H and v [3.7]. Pyrex capillary tube, 60 cm x 132 pm;solvent: (circles) 0.025 M Na2HP04-H20,(triangles) 0.1 M Na2HP04-H20;solute, pyridine; applied voltage, (1) 193, (2) 136, (3) 96, and (4)96 V/crn.
and for the electroosmotic flow system, assuming a perfectly flat flow profile: C,,,,
=
k’2 [16 (1
+ k’)2]-1
(37)
The main difference between the ED and PD systems is the flow profile. This is expressed in different plate height curves, calculated by equations (35)-(37), and shown in Figure 3.10A, B for a 25 and a 10 pm inner diameter capillary and three k’ values. For a 25 pm inner diameter capillary the gain in efficiency by using E D instead of a PD system is almost threefold [3.55]. For a 10 pm inner diameter capillary, the same phenomenon occurs, but the slow mass transfer term is much less significant. In Figure 3.11, the term C,,, is plotted against k’. Both functions increase with increasing retention. It is also clear that C,,,, ED is always smaller than Cm, PD. The improvement is very large at low k’, but is still greater by a factor of 11/6 for k’ up to infinity. The lower C,,,, ED results in a lower plate height for the E D system when the flow profile of electroosmosis is plug-type [3.55]. Optimization of capillary columns based on the theory of capillary gas chromatographic operational conditions shows that a capillary column of inner diameter 2.5 to 10 pm is suitable in laminar flow when the mean linear flow velocity of open-tubular capillary liquid chromatography is the same or one-tenth of the valve for capillary gas chromatography. If a 25 pm inner diameter capillary E D system is compared with a 10 pm inner diameter PD system (Fig. 3.11), the increase in plate height is only a factor of three 13.551. This opens up the possibility of using larger diameters in electroosmotically driven open-tubular liquid chromatography, which has the advantage of fewer practical problems with regard to detection, loadability, and column preparation, again provided that the flow profile is plug-type [3.7], [3.55]. Relationship Between Reduced Plate Height and Linear Velocity. The real flow profile is supposed to be a little different from the plug profile [3.29], [3.69] [Chapter 2, Section 51, and the above supposition should be checked by experiment. Comparison of the reduction in plate height due the type of flow profile and column are examined in
64
3 Electroosmosis and Eiectrochromatography A
80
60
n
E5.
W
40
*aw
k' = 1 70
X
k' = 0
0
€3
n
E
3. W
n b
w
X
k' = 3
k' = 1 / k ' = O 0
08
0.4
v
1.2
1.6
(mm/s)
Figure 3.10. Theoretical HETP ( H ) curves for an electrosomotically driven system (ED) (solid lines) with A) 25 mm inner diameter capillary and B) 10 ym inner diameter capillary for three different k' values, f3.551.
65
3.2 Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography and Electrochromatography
a W
5
6
0.M
8 \
a
nd
4 0
0
k’ Figure 3.U. C, functions for a pressurized flow-driven system (dashed line) and for an electroosmotically driven system (solid line), plotted versus k’ [3.55]. Dot-dashed line, Cm, pdCm,ED.
Figure 3.12. Electroosmotic flow gives a slightly lower plate height. From the curves obtained by electroosmotic flow, we can see: 1) in the region below 1m d s , the effect of diffusion; 2) in the region above 1-3 m d s , the effect of mass transfer in both mobile phase and stationary phases, and between them. Clearly, there is some advantage in using electroosmotic flow to reduce plate height. An excellent chromatogram obtained by electroosmotically driven chromatography with a 10 pm open-tubular capillary column is shown in Figure 3.13 [3.55],for a capillary column with a porous silica layer and on-column laser-induced fluorescence detection [3.59]. Eight polycyclic aromatics (k’ = 0.0-0.24) are separated in less than 400 s, with baseline resolution in only 90 s. Town and Regnier [3.30] reported the separation of proteins using an octadecylsilane-modified capillary column with 0.01 M phosphate buffer (pH 7) containing 0.001 % surfactant (10-100 times less than the critical micelle condition; Fig. 3.14). Although they classify their report as capillary electrophoretic separation, it is really electroosmotically driven electrochromatography. Even though the inner diameter of capillary tubing is as large as 75 pm, the chromatograms show very fine separation. The differences in the chromatograms of Figure 3.14A and B may be due the different stationary phase conditions, as the TWEEN 20 and BRIJ are adsorbed on the ODS stationary phases. From their experiments, we can not estimate how much contribution the electrophoretic process and partition process each make during the solute travel in the column. At least it is certain that the partition process plays some role in the separation. We need to determine the optimum inner diameter for open-tubular capillary column chromatography with electroosmosis only. We must also keep in mind that if the capacity factor is greater than 2, the contribution of the mobile phase becomes relatively smaller compared with the contribution of the stationary phase, and
66
3 Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography
a
I
I
0
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
2 4 6 Linear V e l o c i t y (mm/s)
1I
Figure 3.12. Relation between reduced plate height and flow velocity. Slurry-packed capillary column 143 mm long, 50 pm inner diameter, packed with Hypersil ODS (3 pm); driving force, electroosmotic flow; mobile phase, 2 mM sodium tetraborate (pH 8.7) + 80 % acetonitrile; sampling, 1.5 kV for 4 s; sample, thiourea [3.51]; B) Slurry-packed capillary column 620 mm long, 50 pm inner diameter, packed with 1.6 pm Monospher ODS; driving force, electroosmotic flow; applied voltage, 5-35 kV; mobile phase, 4 mM sodium tetraborate + 60 % acetonitrile; sample, thiourea t3.511; C) Drawn packed capillary column 40 pm inner diameter; packing support, Hypersil 5 pm; driving force, pressurized flow; mobile phase, 70 % acetonitrile + 30% water containing sodium dihydrogen phosphate 2-6 mM (plate height independent of electrolyte concentration); sample, fluorene, non-retained under these conditions [3.52]. D) Driving force, electroosmotic flow; other experimental conditions as C t3.521; E) A slurry packed capillary column of 50 pm inner diameter, packed with 1.5 km Monospher; driving force, electroosmotic flow;other conditions as C t3.521.
the important factor to obtain good separation depends on the quality of the stationary phase, in which the diffusion coefficient between solute and molecules composed of stationary phase needs to be relatively high. The stationary phase must also be very thin for rapid equilibrium with the mobile phase (i. e., minimal mass transfer between stationary and mobile phases). 3.2.2.2 Packed Microcapillary (Drawn Packed Capillary) Columns
Characteristics of Packed Microcapillary Columns. Packed microcapillary columns (PMC) were proposed by Tsuda and Novotny [3.33], [3.34]. Their preparation is described in [3.34] and [3.52]. In principle, PMCs are made by first packing a thickwalled tube with a packing such as silica gel (the particle size can be 3-SO pm), and then drawing this tube down to the required final diameter. All packing procedures should be carried out very carefully to maintain the dryness of the packing materials and the glass tubing [3.33], [3.34], [3.52]. Electron micrographs of a cross-section of drawn packed capillary, ca. SO pm inner diameter and packed with 10 pm silica gel, are shown in Figure 15, and the plane of cross-section was inclined at 25". The packing state of silica gel in the PMC has been considered to be loose packed compared with
3.2 Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography and Electrochromatography
67
2
6
5
3
Figure 3.W. Chromatograms of eight polycyclic aromatics with 10 pm PSL (etched porous silica
.. I
I
0
5
I 6 ___ct
(rnin)
L_
I 7
layered)-ODS capillary. Applied voltage, 20 kV, column length 49 cm (from injection to detection 26.5 cm); current 0.7 FA; temperature, 25 “C; injection volume, 9 pL; mobile phase, 0.05 M phosphate buffer (pH 7) + methanol (1: 1). Peaks are (1) naphthoquinone (k’ = 0); ( 2 ) 9-anthracenemethanol ( k ” = 0.03); (3) 9-anthracenecarbonitrile; (4) anthracenecarbonitrile; (4) anthracene; (5) 7,8benzoflavone; (6) fluoranthene; ( 7 ) pyrene; (9) 9-vinylanthracene (k’ = 0.24) [3.55].
the packing state of conventional columns, but electron micrographs show it to be rather like that of a slurry-packed conventional column. However, flow resistance parameters Qi [3.60], [3.61] of the columns are about 100 [3.34], [3.52], very low compared with those of conventional columns (usually 500-1000). So the present column has a very desirable feature; it is well packed, but highly permeable. Some silica gel particles in Figure 3.15 are observed to have been inserted partly in the glass. For a more precise view of these conditions, an electron micrograph at higher magnification, ~ 7 5 0 0is, shown in Figure 3.15B. About one-tenth of the silica gel particles per cross-section were held in the glass wall, stabilizing the other silica gel particles; this is why the drawn capillary column was stable under a pressure of 200 atm per metre of column length. As silica gel is stabilized by the column materials, no frit was necessary at the ends of the PMC.
68
3
Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography
A
T O0IAU
z
8 c! W
V
T
,002AU
1
W
0
z
2
a
U
51 m
v,
m
m a
[L
0
m
a
a
.r.A
u I
I
1
I
I
4
8
12
16
20
Time (rnin)
Figure 3.14. Electrochromatograms obtained with an ODS capillary column doped with surfactants. Protein samples are: 1) Lysozyme; 2) Cytochrome c, 3) Ribonuclease A, 4) a-chromotrypsinogen; 5) Myoglobin. Columns preparation: inner surface modified with ODS, and doped with 0.5 % surfactant-aqueous solution for 2 h, followed by wash-out. A) Tween 20; B) BRIJI 35 [3.30].
Application of Drawn Packed Microcapillary Columns for Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography. The first application of this column was descried by Tsuda et al. (Fig. 3.16) [3.62]. Knox et al. have obtained good chromatograms by using an ODs-column t3.521, [3.63]. They used on-column fluorescence detection. In Figure 3.17, two chromatograms obtained by pressurized flow and electroosmotic flow are shown. Electroosmotic flow gives better peaks, with a slightly increased theoretical plate height. The effects of electrolyte concentration on electroosmotic velocity and plate height for a drawn capillary column packed with 5 pm Hypersil were examined. The electrolyte concentration in this case has little effect on the electroosmotic flow - 2 x lo-' M, but a significant improvement in plate velocity over the range 4 x efficiency occurs with increasing electrolyte concentration. Thus, with the 5 pm Hypersil, the reduced plate height is from 3-4 to about 1 as the electrolyte concentration is increased. The compromise which best maintains a high electroosmotic velocity and yet gives a minimum HETP is around 0.002 M. When they applied the voltage at electrolyte concentration > 0.006 M, they encountered the problem of bubble formation [3.52]. The electrolyte concentration depends on the efficiency of heat dissipation of the column. With a mixture of water and organic solvent as eluent, it is possible to use a concentration up to 20 mM [3.47].
3.2 Electroosmoticalfy Driven Chromatography and Electrochromatography
69
Figure 3.15. Electron micrographs of a cross-section of a packed microcapillary column. A) Magnification x 1500; B) detail of A x 7500 [3.34].
' I
I
2 0
1 0
'
Elution Time
(min)
Figure 3.16. Electrochromatogram from a packed microcapillary column 40 cm long, 42 pm inner diameter. Applied voltage, 10 kV; sample, aromatic compounds[3.62].
70
3 Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography
0
0
10
10
20
20 Elullon tlme
30
I
40
(mln)
Figure 3.17. Separation of an aromatic test mixture with pressurized (A) and electroosmotically driven chromatography (B). Column: drawn capillary packed with 3 pm Hypersil and subsequently derivatized by ODS, inner diameter 30 pm, 900 mm (A) and 800 mm (B) long. Solutes in order of elution: 1) Naphthalene; 2) 2-Methylnaphthalene; 3) Fluorene; 4) Phenanthrene; 5) Anthracene; 6) Pyrene; 7) 9-Methylanathracene [3.52].
3.2.2.3 Slurry-Packed Capillary Columns Electroosmotically driven chromatography using a slurry-packed column (its packing procedure was described in I3.351) was first reported by Pretorius et al. [3.2] for a packed column of 50 cm x 1mm inner diameter. Jorgenson et al. [3.15] used a narrow packed capillary column (68 cm x 0.17 mm inner diameter, packed with 10 pm ODSsilica), and a reduced plate height of 1.9 was obtained for a peak eluting at ca. 30 min. Tsuda et al. [3.9], [3.64] have demonstrated the possibility of separating aromatic compounds in a short analysis period by applying 12.4 kV (1.3 kV/cm) across a 9.1 cm x 400 prn capillary column, slurry-packed with 3 pm ODS (Fig. 3.18). Another group produced an excellent chromatogram obtained with a slurry-packed capillary column (Fig. 3.19) [3.65]. These columns and a system for electrochromatography, are commercially available. The fastest analysis by the present method has been demonstrated by Erni et al. [3.51] for a packed capillary column (143 mm long and 50 pm inner diameter, slurrypacked with Hypersil ODs, 3 pm particle diameter, Fig. 3.20). They examined the relation between applied voltage and linear velocity due to electroosmosis (Fig. 3.12). They found an almonst linear relationship, and remarked that it is possible to apply up to 2 kV/cm (total applied voltage 55 kVfor the packed column 143 mm long and 50 pm inner diameter) and obtain ca. 6 m d s electroosmotic flow. However they admitted that the electroosmotic flow became unstable above 50 kV applied voltage and higher than expected velocity (Fig. 3.12). In references [3.16] and [3.17], this curve is not linear in the region of high applied electrovoltage and is generally lower than expected.
3.2 Electroosmotically Driven Chromatography and Electrochromatography
71
A
1
I
Figure 3.18. Chromatogram showing separation of neutral compounds by electroosmotically driven chromatography. Columns: 9.1 cm X 0.4 mm, slurry-packed with 3 pm ODS (Develosil); eluent, 100 % methanol; applied voltage, 12.4 kV (current 2 FA). Peaks: A) Methyl benzoate; B) Anthracene; C) Pyrene (capacity factor 1.2) [3.9].
I
3 6 Time (min)
0
3 N = 176,000 plares/metet
J
I
I
1
I
I
I
0
3
6
9
12
15
Elution Time
= 178,000
Figure 3.19. Separation of aromatic mixture by electroosmotically driven chromatography. Mobile phase: acetonitrile + 4 mM borate buffer pH 8.0 (80:20); applied voltage, 20 kV, column: Electrochrom, 50 pm X 30 cm, packed with ODS 3 pM; ambient temperature; injection: electrokinetic at 20 kV, 0.08 min; detection: U V 254 nm, 50 pm on column. Samples: 1) Benzene; 2) Naphthalene; 3) Biphenyl; 4) Fluorene; 5) Anthracene; 6) Fluoranthene [3.65].
1 (
I
I
18
21
min)
72
3 Electroosmosisand Electrochromarography m
.-Ca
F
5
Figure 3.20. Rapid separation by electroosmotically
0
N
Q.!
driven chromatography.
a u
3E:
5!
,
!
Elution Time
3.2.3
(min)
Mixture of Isradipin, its byproducts, and thiourea. Column: 50 pm inner diameter, 143 mm long, packed with Hypersil ODS (3 prn); applied voltage, 30 kV;other conditions as in Figure 3.6. Flow velocity of electroosrnosis, 2.6 m d s (1.8 PA).
Advantages of Electroosmotic Flow for Liquid Chromatography
The use of the electroosmosis as the driving force has the following advantages: 1) Its flow profile is much flatter compared with the flow profile of pressurized flow (a high theoretical plate number is obtained especially for samples with capacity factor less than 2). 2) We can generate electroosmotic flow simply by applying high voltage along the column. This is a superior characteristic compared with pressurized flow. Therefore it is possible to use soft gels, such as agarose or polyacrylamide. These experimental conditions are used in capillary zone electrophoresis [3.66], [3.67]. However, in the field of liquid chromatography, we may have a chance to develop extremely useful columns by using soft gels or packing supports which could not be used for conventional liquid chromatography owing to their lack of hardness. Hjerten et al. [3.68] have used a solidified polyacryamide gel for electroosmotically driven chromatography. 3) Electroosmotic flow can pass through very fine micropores, unlike pressurized flow under ordinary pressure. Therefore it is possible to use crays or sludges [see also Chapter 7 and 81. 4) We can operate liquid chromatography without a mechanical pump. Therefore we may construct a very tiny liquid chromatography system. This might be helpful in a specialized field such as clean rooms for producing semiconductors. There are also disadvantages in using electroosmotic flow: 1) On applying a high voltage along a column, we always generate heat. Therefore it is necessary to dissipate it effectively. If we use a high potential gradient to obtain a high linear electroosmotic velocity, we need to use a capillary column. When we use a column of more than 1 mm inner diameter, we should be very careful to avoid bubble formation inside the column. It is essential to use a moderate or low potential gradient along the column. 2) Once a bubble is formed inside the column, we have to use pressurized flow to exclude the bubble from the column. The formation of bubbles means that we cannot continue operation because the electric current through the column will be unstable or stopped, and electroosmotic flow inside the column ceases. 3) We need to pay attention to the safety with the use of high voltages. Disadvantage (2) can be overcome by using a low pressurized flow during the run. For disadvantage (l),if we use an organic solvent as developing eluent or an aqueous
3.3 References
73
solvent with a low electrolyte concentration, generally the current falls to a low value, and we can avoid excessive heating inside the column. We still need to improve the stability of electroosmotically driven electrochromatography. The potential advantages of the technique encourage its development for use in specific fields.
3.3
References
[3.1] S. HjertCn, Chromatogr. Rev., 9, 122 (1967). [3.2] V. Pretorius, B. J. Hopkins, J. D. Schieke, J. Chromatogr., 99, 23 (1974). [3.3] E E. P. Mikkers, F. M. Everaerts, T. P. E. M. Verhaggen, J. Chromatogr., 169, 11 (1979). [3.4] J. W. Jorgenson, K. D. Luckacs, Anal. Chem., 53, 1298 (1981). [3.5] J. W. Jorgenson, K. D. Lukacs, J. Chrornatogr., 218, 209 (1981). [3.6] T. Tsuda, K. Nomura, G. Nakagawa, J. Chrornatogr., 264, 385 (1983). [3.7] T. Tsuda, K. Nomura, G. Nakagawa, J. Chromatogr., 248,241 (1982). [3.8] T. Tsuda, G. Nakagawa, M. Sato, K. Yagi, J. Appl. Biochem., 5, 330 (1983). [3.9] T. Tsuda, J . Chem. SOC.Jpn. Chem. Ind. Chem., 937 (1986). [3.10] T. Tsuda, J. High Resolut. Chromatogr. Chromatogr. Commun., 10, 622 (1987). [3.11] T. ’ISuda, Shimadzu Sci. Instrum. News, 28, 14 (1987). [3.12] T. Tsuda, J. Liq. Chromatogr., 12, 2501 (1989). [3.13] T. Tsuda, Chromatography, Maruzen, Tokyo (1989). [3.14] M. Martin, G. Guiochon, Anal. Chem., 56, 614 (1984). [3.15] M. Martin, G. Guiochon, Y. Walbroehl, J. W. Jorgenson, Anal. Chem., 57, 559 (1985). [3.16] C. Terabe, K. Otsuka, T. Ando, Anal. Chem., 57, 834 (1985). [3.17] X. Huang, W. F. Coleman, R. N. Zare, J . Chrornatogr., 48, 95 (1989). [3.18] X. Huang, M. J. Gordon, R. N. Zare, Anal. Chem., 60, 1837 (1988). [3.19] W. D. Pfeffer, E. S. Yeung, Anal. Chem., 62,2178 (1990). [3.20] W. D. Pfeffer, E. S . Yeung, J. Chromatogr., 557, 125 (1991). [3.21] C. S. Lee, W. C. Blanchard, C.-T. Wu, Anal. Chem., 62, 1550 (1990). [3.22] C. S. Lee, D. McManigill, C.-T. Wu, B. Patel, Anal. Chem., 63, 1519 (1991). [3.23] C. S. Lee, C.-T. Wu, T. Lopez, B. Patel, J. Chromatogr., 559, 133 (1991). [3.24] C.-T. Wu, T. Lopez, B. Patel, C. S. Lee, Anal. Chem., 64, 886 (1992). [3.25] C.-T. Wu, C. S . Lee, Anal. Chem., 64, 2310 (1992). [3.26] K. Ghowski, R. J. Gale, J . Chromatogr., 559, 95 (1991). [3.27] M. A. Hayes, A. G. Ewing, Anal. Chem., 84, 512 (1992). [3.28] M. A. Hayes, I. Kheterpal, A. G . Ewing, Anal. Chem., 65, 27 (1993). [3.29] T. Tsuda, “Control of electroosmotic flow in capillary electrophoresis”, Chap. 22, in Handbook of capillary electrophoresis, J. P. Landers (ed.), CRC, Ann Arbor, 1993. [3.30] J. K. Towns, F. Regnier, Anal. Chem., 63, 1126 (1991). [3.31] J. K. Towns, F. Regnier, Anal. Chem., 64, 2473 (1992). [3.32] T. Tsuda et al. J. Chromatogr., 158, 227 (1978). [3.33] T. Tsuda, M. Novotny, Anal. Chem., 50,271 (1978). [3.34] T. Duds, I. Tanaka, G. Nakagawa, Anal. Chem., 56, 1249 (1984). [3.35] Y. Hirata, K. Jinno, J. High Resolut. Chromatogr. Chromatogr. Commun., 6, 196 (1983). [3.36] D. Ishii et al. J. Chrornatogr., 151, 147 (1978). [3.37] K . K. Unger, “Porous silica”, J. Chromatogr. Library, 6, 1979; K. Nobuhara, private communications, 1993. [3.38] R. J. Hunter, Zeta potential in colloid science, Academic Press, New York, 1981. [3.39] G. Gouy, J. Phys. Chem., 9, 457 (1910). [3.40] D. L. Chapman, Phil. Mag., 25,475 (1913). [3.41] H. G. Th. Overbeek, in Colloid Science, vol. 1, H. R. Kruy (ed.), Elservier, Amsterdam, 1952. [3.42] M. Smoluchowski, in Handbuch der Elektrizitat und des Magnetismus (Graetz), vol. 11, Barth, Leipzig, 1921, p. 366.
74
3 Electroosmosis and Electrochromatography
[3.43] P. Delahay, Double layer and electrode kinetics, Wiley Interscience, New York, 1965. [3.44] R. A. Wallingford, A. G. Ewing, ...Capillary electrophoresis”, Adv. Chromatogr., 29, 1 (1989). [3.45] C. L. Rice, R. Whitehead, J. Phys. Chem., 69 (ll), 4017 (1965). [3.46] J. C. Giddings, Dynamics of Chromatography, Dekker, New York, 1965. [3.47] S. Kitagawa, T. Tsuda, J . Microcol. Sep. 6, 91 (1994). [3.48] P. Velaha, Double layer and electrode kinetics, Interscience, New York, 3rd ed., 1976. [3.49] T. Tsuda, 1983, unpublished work. [3.50] K. D. Lukas, J. W. Jorgenson, J. High Resolut. Chrornatrogr., 8,407-411 (1985). [3.51] H. Yamamoto, J. Baumann, F. Erni, J. Chromatogr., 593,313,319-328 (1991). [3.52] J. H. Knox, I. H.Grant, Chromatographia, 32, 317-328 (1991). [3.53] H. J. Cortes, C. D. Pfeffer, B. E. Richter, T. S. Stevens, J. High Resolut. Chromatogr. Chromatogr. Commun., 10,446-448 (1987). [3.54] T. Tsuda, M. Inagaki, 1993, unpublished work. [3.55] G. J. M. Bruin, P. P. H. Tock, J. C. Kraak, H . Poppe, J. Chromatogr., 517, 557-572 (1990). [3.56] M. Martin, G. Guiochon, Y. Walboel, J. W. Jorgenson, Anal. Chem., 57, 559-561 (1985). [3.57] M. Martin, G. Guiochon, Anal. Chem., 56, 614-620 (1984). [3.58] M. J. E. Golay, in D. H. Desty (ed.), Gas Chromatography 1958, Butterworths, London, 1958, p. 36-55. [3.59] P. P. H. Tock et al., Chromatographia, 24,617 (1987); J . Chromatogr., 477, 95 (1989). [3.60] J. H. Knox, M. T. Gilbert, J. Chrornatogr., 186, 405-418 (1979). [3.61] J. H. Knox, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 18, 453-461 (1980). [3.62] T. Tsuda, I. Isao, G. Nakagawa, 3rd Symp. Liquid Chromatography (Ekitai Kuronmatogurafi Toronkai), Abstracts p. 41-42, Oct. 20-21, 1982, Tokyo. [3.63] J. H. Knox, I. H. Grant, Chromatographia, 24, 135 (1987). [3.64] T. Tsuda, 2nd Symp. Liquid Chromatography (Ekitai Kuronmatogurafi Shotoronkai), Abstracs, p. 13-14, May 10, 1985, Osaka. [3.65] J. P. Chervet, brochure published by LC Packings, Switzerland, p. 16, 1992. [3.66] A. S. Cohen, A. Paulus, B. L. Karger, Chromatographia, 24, 15 (1987). [3.67] J. P. Landers (ed.), Handbook of capillary electrophoresis, CRC, Ann Arbor, 1993. [3.68] S. H j e r t h et al., 17th Intern. Symp. Column Liquid Chromatogr., Hamburg, May 9-14, 1993. [3.69] T. Tsuda et al., J. Chromatogr., 632, 201-207 (1993). [3.70] D. L. Mould, R. L. Synge, Biochem. J., 58, 571 (1954).
4
Electrochromatography with Radial Applied Voltage: Ion Separation by Electrochemical Approach Tsutomu Nagaoka
4.1
Introduction
This chapter describes electrochemical chromatography with a conductive stationary phase, which allows one to apply voltages in the direction normal to the stationary phase surface, not along the column as in standard electrochromatography [4.1]-[4.10]. The technique introduces the stationary phase potential as a parameter to control chromatographic separation, with several new features such as optimal retention (adjusted by the potential), concentration and elution of analyte on a single column, and potential gradient elution. This chapter focuses on the separation of electroinactive species that cannot be separated electrochemically. Electroinactive species are not reduced or oxidized at electrodes because their redox potentials are too low or too high. Figure 1 gives the basic principles of electrochemical chromatography, illustrating the conductive station-
layer Figure 4.1. Separation of ionic substances on conductive stationary phases. A) The direct electrostatic interaction; B) The indirect electrostatic interaction with the functional layer.
76
4
Electrochromatography with Radial Applied Voltage
ary phase particles. In this technique, the total charge at the surface can be controlled externally. Thus, as the potential of the stationary phase becomes more negative, the stationary phase accumulates negative charge (electrons). Similarly, the stationary phase accumulates positive charge as the potential increases. The voltage applied between a stationary phase and counter-electrode is usually less than a few volts thanks to a supporting electrolyte (an indifferent electrolyte) added to the mobile phase. Figure 4.1A illustrates a model for direct electrostatic interaction between an analyte cation and the charged stationary phase. As the potential of the stationary phase decreases, the interaction becomes strong, resulting in a larger elution volume. Both ionic species and neutral compounds can be separated on the conductive column; neutral molecules should adsorb most strongly at the zero charge potential (i. e., the potential at which no charge accumulates at the solution/electrode interface). The direct electrostatic model can be extended to the indirect model (Fig. 4.1B). The functional layer on the surface can be reduced or oxidized to take up ionic or neutral species, and enhanced selectivity is expected because of specific interaction with such species. The conductive stationary phases discussed here are confined mostly to carbonaceous materials, because their porous surfaces are easily modified with the various functional substances that have been studied extensively in electrochemistry [4.11].
4.2
Experimental Details
4.2.1
Design of the Electrode Column
The electrode columns usually contain carbon particles packed in a separator tube, with a counter-electrode and a reference electrode placed near the tube. The chromatographic system (Fig. 4.2) consists of standard HPLC components, the column electrode, and a potentiostat to control the potential of the stationary phase (the working electrode) versus the reference electrode. Figure 4.3 shows the electrode column used in our laboratory [4.2]-[4.6]. The column is made up of the conductive stationary
Drain Figure 4.2. Block diagram of an electrochemical chromatographic system. Conditions used in our experiments are given in the figure.
4.2 Experimental Details
77
Figure 4.3. Cross-sectional diagram of the electrode column. A) Counter-electrode (SUS316 stainless steel net); B) Vycor glass tube; C) Conductive stationary phase; D) Pt wire for stationary phase; E) PTFE tube; F) PTFE plug; G) Ag/AgCl wire; H) Counter-electrode compartment filled with 10 mM KCl, H20; I) 0-Ring; J) F'TFE porous filter.
phase, tightly packed into a Vycor glass tube separator (internal diameter 4.5 mm, effective length 4-16 cm), a counter-electrode (stainless steel net) encircling the separator, and reference electrodes. The counter-electrode compartment is filled with 10 mM tetraethylammonium perchlorate (TEAP) aqueous solution unless otherwise stated. The positions of the reference electrodes are important to obtain a uniform distribution of potential throughout the column. The reference electrodes keep to potential of the stationary phase constant; the potential of the counter-electrode varies during an experiment. The reference electrode used in our system is Ag AgCl I saturated KC1 I (SSE) placed every 4 cm along the column or an AgC1-coated Ag wire coiled around the Vycor glass. With the latter, open electrode, the counter-electrode compartment is filled with 1M KCI to keep the potential of the wire constant. The capacity factors of halide ions on a polyaniline-coated stationary phase, which is discussed later, are almost independent of the column length (k' = 8.6 k 0.2) [4.6]. The independence suggests that the potential is fairly even. The steady state of current the column is about 100 FA. The mobile phase used in this technique should contain a supporting electrolyte, which increases the magnitude of the electric field at the mobile phase/stationary phase interface. In addition, the separator tube must be porous to establish the ionic conductivity between the counter-electrode and stationary phase. A tube of Nafion, Vycor glass, or porous stainless steel has been used for this purpose [4.2]-[4.10].
I
4.2.2
Preparation of Stationary Phases
Table 4.1 summarizes the characteristics and preparation procedures of the stationary phases that have been reported in the literature. To achieve high selectivity, the stationary phases are modified with functional substances such as oxidized carbon, crown ethers, or conductive polymers. The substrate is usually carbon powder and can be modified electrochemically after being packed (columns 4, 6, 7, 9 in Table 4.1), or either chemically or electrochemically before being packed (2, 3, 5 , 8).
a
ion-exchange with polymer
Vinylferrocene/ maleic anhydride copolymer Crown ether on carbon
Polypyrrole on carbon
n-x interactions with
Polypyrrole on carbon
+
anion insertion into the oxidized polymer cathodic stripping
the polymer
anion insertion into the oxidized polymer
Polypyrrole on carbon
Polyaniline on carbon
carbon particlese (- 40 pm) coated by percolating a polymer solution through the column activated carbon' powder (- 45 pm) covered with a DCEgsolution containing 50 mM dibenzo-18-crown-6 50 mM TBA . TPhBh polymer deposited at +0.95 V on GC' (- 75 pm) from aqueous 0.5 M aniline and 1 M HCI for 5-20 min polymer deposited at + 1.0 V on G C powder (- 75 pm) from aqueous 0.1 M pyrrole and 0.1 M NaCl for 10 min polymer electrodeposited on RVC' (< 40 pm) from aqueous 0.2 M pyrrole and 0.1 M sodium dodecylsulfate
direct electrostatic adsorption
Oxidized carbon
electrostaic ion transfer induced by formation of a crown ether complex anion insertion into the oxidized polymer
carbon powderb modified with trimethyl chlorosilane after oxidation with r. f. plasma GC' powder (- 45 pm) oxidized in air at 400 "C for 4 h
electrosorption on hydrophobic surface
polymer deposited on GCa (70-230 pm) from 0.1 M pyrrole and 0.1 M sodium p-toluenesulfonate
+
GC" (60-100 mesh), Ag (30-40 mesh) grain
Silated carbon
+
electrodeposition anodic stripping
Glassy carbon
Preparation
Separation
Stationary phase
Mobile phase
anthracene, naphthalene, m-toluic acid, benzoic acid adenosine triphosphate, monophosphate
halides, SCN-, carboxylate,
halides, SCN-, [Fe(CN)6]4"-
alkali metal ions
10 mM TEAPd in H,O
H', alkali metal ions, alkaline earth ions methylviologen
+
-
10 mM LiC104 (pH 5.0)
CH30H/H20 CH3CNm20 NaOAc
H20
10 mMTEAP 10 mM HCIOl in H 2 0 (pH 2) 10 mM TEAP in
+
0.005 M NaCIO, (70:30 HzO :CH,CN) 10 mM TEAP + saturated DCE in H20
0.1 M NaCIO, in CH3CH
toluene, phenol, pyridine
Pb2+,Cu2+,CdZ+ 0.1 N HCI + 1Yo N&HCI
Analyte
[4.10]
[4.25]
Reference
'
Glassy carbon, grade unknown, Tokai Carbon. Ambersorb XE-347,270-325 mesh, Rohm and Haas. Grade GC-20 glassy carbon, Tokai Carbon. Tetraethylammonium perchlorate. Carbopack C, Supelco. Katayama Chemical. 1,2-Dichloroethane. Tetrabutylammonium tetraphenylborate. Vitreous carbon, Energy Research Generation.
No.
Table 4.1. Characteristics and preparation procedures of the conductive stationary phases and the compositions of the mobile phases
4 00
4.3 Redox Separation of Electroactive Metals on the Conductive Stationary Phase
79
Redox Separation of Electroactive Metals on the Conductive Stationary Phase
4.3
The idea of separation of electroactive metal ions with a conductive column is relatively old [4.1], [4.12], [4.13]. It is based on the electrodeposition of analyte metal ions on a conductive stationary phase that consists of carbon or noble metal particles. When the stationary phase potential is more negative than the standard redox potential (E") of the metal ion, the ion is reduced and deposits on the column as a metal film; it does not deposit when the potential of the stationary phase is more positive than E". The deposited metal can be eluted (oxidized) by stepping the potential to a value more positive than E". The partition coefficient (K,) in this technique can be related to the Nernst equation if the redox process is reversible. In this case, for electron transfer equilibrium between metal (M) and its ion (M"') is
{
nF K D = Cs/CM= [M]/[M"'] = exp -117'(E - Z?') where R is the gas constant, Tis the temperature, Cs is the concentration of the metal in the stationary phase, C, is its concentration in the mobile phase, E is the stationary phase potential, and E"' is the formal potential of the M/M"' couple. The formal potential, which is a practical version of E", involves the effect of the ionic strength and/or complex formation in a given medium [4.14]. It is important to point out here that K , is extremely sensitive to a small change in potential. For example, when n = 1and T = 298 K, Equation (2) predicts that a decrease in E by only 59 mV brings about a ten-fold increase in KD. Since the E"' values of metal ions span more than 3 V, this technique would often result in either too long or too short elution times, even if the stationary phase potential were carefully selected.
El
+ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \
W
! [ / \ A A E N
L
M,
M2 Distance from inlet
M3
-
Figure 4.4. Redox separation for metal ions. A) Porous tube; B) Spiral counter-electrode. C) Carbon powder. Potential E is referred to the counter-electrode, and bias voltage, El, is applied across the column. Tis the surface concentration of a deposited metal, and the Ep' of metals is assumed to be in the sequence M 3 < M2 < M,. After deposition, E l is removed, and the ions then elute in the sequence of M3, Mz, MI.
80
4 Electrochromatography with Radial Applied Voltage
To overcome this difficulty, a variety of stripping techniques have been examined. First, the potential is set to a value sufficiently negative for any ion in a sample to deposit quantitatively. After deposition, each metal is stripped by a potential scan in the positive direction, eluting the metal ion with the most negative F"' first. Fujinaga et al. took a different approach (Fig. 4.4). They used a column with a potential gradient (column 1 in Table 4.1) [4.1], [4.15], [4.16]; analyte ions deposit at different positions according to their E"', and the deposited metals elute after the removal of the bias potential. Separation of metal ions such as CdZ+,Pb2+, and Cu2+ have been reported by this method. These techniques are extensions of stripping analysis, and the separation mechanism is quite different from what we expect for chromatography.
4.4
Direct Electrostatic Interactions for Potential-Dependent Separation of Electroinactive Species
All the studies outlined in the previous section have been based on redox reactions, so that analytes are limited to electroactive species. However, electroinactive species can also be separated by the electrostatic field. Such direct electrostatic interactions can occur on charged stationary phases, irrespective of whether the species have a net charge or not.
4.4.1
Pretreated Carbon for the Separation of Metal Ions
Figure 4.1A illustrates the interaction in this category. Studies on glassy carbon have revealed that oxidative treatment of the carbon creates a polar, porous layer on the surface, which can adsorb ionic species when the surface is oppositely charged [4.2], [4.17]-[4.21]. The amout of adsorbed anion increases exponentially with an increase in potential, and the amount of the cation increases exponentially with a decrease in potential. Therefore, this potential-dependent adsorption can be applied to chromatographic separation (column 3 in Table 4.1) [4.2], [4.3]. Indeed, the chromatographic peaks display a potential dependence for Li+ and K', and K + is retained on the column to a higher degreee than Li'. The k' values for Li' and K + are 0.4 and 1.0 at f0.25 V versus SSE, and 1.8 and 4.5 at -0.25 V [4.22]. The longer retention of K+ is attributed to the smaller hydration sheath of K+, leading to a stronger interaction with the negatively charged carbon surface.
4.4.2
Stationary Phase Coated with Crown Ether for the Separation of Alkali Metal Ions
A stationary phase coated with a crown ether layer (column 5 in Table 4.1) can separate metal ions when the ions are transferred to the layer at negative potentials [4.3]. Here, the carbon particle is covered with a 1,Zdichloroethane (DCE) solution containing dibenzo-18-crownd (Fig. 4.1B). Alkali metal ions can be separated at negative potentials (Fig. 4.5) and the elution time of each ion depends on the potential (Fig. 4.6). The
4.4 Direct Electrostatic Interactions for Potential-Dependent Separation
2oo
6oo
' 2oo
I\ 400
Time s
Time s
6oo
81
Figure 4.5. Separations of alkali metal ions with dibenzo-18-crown-6 at stationary phase potentials of A) +0.35V and B) -0.1 V for 20-pL injections of 10 mM (solid line) Li', (dashed line) Na+, (dashed-dotted) K+.
DCE layer plays an important role here, because there is a much smaller potential dependence if DCE is removed in vacuum before the particles are packed in the column. Results are similar if the DCE phase without the crown ether is used. Since K+ fits the dibenzo-18-crown-6best of all the alkali metal ions [4.23], the greatest elution time for K+ is explained in terms of a potential-induced extraction. The equilibrium of K+ with the crown ether at the interface of the aqueous/organic phases can be written:
KZ,
+ crownorg= {K+crown}org
(3)
where the suffixes aq and org stand for the aqueous and organic phases, respectively. The complex ion formed in the organic phase has a positive charge, so that the complex interacts with the negative charge of the carbon particle. In this case, the crown ether adds selectivity for the transfer of K'. Samec and Papoff have studied the ion transfer voltametry of alkali metal ions at a water I DCE interface in the presence of dibenzo-18-crown-6, reporting that the halfwave potentials (El,*)for the transfer of K+, Na', and Li+ from water to DCE are 0.43, 0.54, and 0.61 Vversus Ag I AgCl 1 0.01 M C1- [ , [4.24]. Our results cannot be compared quantitatively to their data because measurement of the potential difference between the aqueous and thin DCE layers is difficult. However, the sequence of the potentials at which elution time rises is consistent with that of the Ela values.
Potential
/ V vs. AglAgCl
Figure 4.6. Potential dependence of elution time for injections of: K+ (open squares); Na' (circles); and Li+ (full squares). The experimental conditions are the same as in Figure 4.5.
82
Electrochromutography with Radial Applied Voltage
4
As seen in Figure 4.6, the elution time of all the ions is independent of potential in the positive region, and K+ is retained there much longer than Na’ and Lit. The otential-independent retention of K+ suggests that a neutral ion pair such as K+crown)TPhB-is extracted to the organic phase, irrespective of potential (TPhB- = tetraphenylborate). It has been shown that Li+, Na’, and K+ ions are extracted by 0 YO, 1.6 YO, and 25.2 % to DCE in an H,O/CDE system with dibenzo-18-crown-6 and picrate, [4.23], which explains the retention time at positive potentials.
P
4.4.3
Electrosorption for the Separation of Neutral Organic Compounds
The principle of electrosorption coupled with chromatographic processes has been applied to the separation of electroneutral organic molecules. Antrim and Yacynych attempted separation of such compounds (toluene, phenol, and pyridine) and found that their capacity factors increase with an increase in the potential (column 2 in Table 4.1) [4.8]. Usually, organic compounds adsorb on electrodes most strongly at potcntials close to the zero charge potential and desorb at both positive and negative potentials that are remote from the zero charge potential, because of competitive adsorption of polar water molecules. It is not certain if their results follow this rule because the zero charge potential is unknown for their system. However, the high dependence of k’ on potential suggests that potential-controlled separation is feasible. The k’ values reported for toluene and phenol are 1.3 and 16.6 at +0.8 V versus an Ag quasireference electrode and 0.6 and 2.0 at -0.8 V, while the k’ of pyridine does not change significantly with potential. Ge and Wallace have discussed the potential effects for a polypyrrole-coated stationary phase, which gives a favorable z-zinteraction with organic molecules (Fig. 4.7, column 8 inTable 4.1) [4.25]. The k’ of caffeine increases with a decrease in the applied potential, while k’ values for more acidic compounds decrease. Beyond + 1.0V k’ for all compounds decreases markedly, which may be due to oxidation of polypyrrole.
1
-2 0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
-1 0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
+20
E (V)
Figure 4.7. Effects of potential on the capacitance factor of 1) Caffeine; 2) Theophylline; 3) Benzoic acid; 4) mToluic acid. Elucnt: 50:50 CH3CN:0.2 M CHICOONa buffer (pH 4.5); flow rate, 1 mWmin [4.25].
83
4.5 Indirect Electrostatic Interactions for Potential-Dependent Separation
4.5
Indirect Electrostatic Interactions for Potential-Dependent Separation of Electroinactive Species
Applied voltages can induce chemical changes of functional materials on stationary phases (Fig. 4.1B), and, indeed, materials such as conducting polymers create an ionexchange site as a result of redox reactions. If the site formation is reversible, the number of the sites can be varied with the potential, controlling the mean velocity of analyte in the column.
Redox Polymer with Ion Exchange. The modification of the carbon surface with a functional substance such as a redox polymer is an attractive way to achieve controlled separation. Ghatak-Roy and Martin have studied ion-exchange chromatography using a stationary phase coated with a film of vinylferrocene/maleic anhydride copolymer, which is conductive after swelling in solution [4.7]. H
H
H
Fc
I
H
H
I
H
H
I I I fc-c-j(-c I I I H Fc+ L o - 0 C +o
H
o//c'o-j
,,
\ \
\ \
Red
H
'M"2'
'
ox
When the ferrocene unit in the polymer is in the reduced state (Red), methylviologen (MV2+)as analyte is eluted in the eighth through thirteenth volume fractions (8-12 mL). In contrast, when the polymer is in the oxidized state (Ox), MV" is not retained on the column, eluting in the first fraction ( 5 1 mL).
4.5.1
Conducting Polymers for Separation of Anions
Ion-Exchange Mechanisms of Polyaniline. Conductive polymers such as polyaniline and polypyrrole are insulators in their reduced forms, while conductive in the oxidized forms via doping anions. Thus, the polymers are expected to exchange anion in the oxidized states and the number of ion-exchange sites can be controlled by the potential applied to the polymers. Insertion of anions from solution to polyaniline films has been studied extensively [4.26]-[4.28]:
84
4 Electrochrornatography with Radial Applied Voltage
(B)
0 0
4.0u
6.0
2.0
0.00,
20
10
'
Deposition time
30
I
min
Figure 4.8. Cyclic voltammograms for a column electrode coatedwith (solid line) and without (dashed line) polyaniline films obtained at a flow rate of 0.5 mL min-' and at a sweep rate of 5 mV/s. A) Polyaniline was deposited from an aqueous solution containing 0.5 M aniline 1 M HCI at +0.95 V vs. SSE for 5 min, and the voltammogram was recorded in the same aniline solution at 0.5 mL m i d . The base line voltammogram (dashed line) wasrecordedin 1 M HCI. B)The dependenceof loading Q on deposition time. The hatched area of the voltammetric peak defines Q (C cm-').
+
1
-0.2
1
.
I
0.2
I
I
0.6
.
I
-
I
Potential / V vs. AglAgCl
Figure 8 shows the cyclic voltammograms of the polyaniline film recorded at the electrode column. The first (less positive) anodic and cathodic peaks have been assigned to the insertion and release of anion as a result of film oxidation and reduction, respectively (Eq. 4). The second peaks have been ascribed to the degradation of the film, which involves release of anion from the polymer [4.26].
Potential Dependence of Anion Separation. The oxidized polyaniline (PAN04*+)film exchanges analyte anion A- in the mobile phase according to the equation: PAN04X'(c10q)4X
+ 4~ A-M
+ 4~ ClO,
= PAN04' +(A-).lX
M
(5)
where the suffix M denotes an ion in the mobile phase. We have shown that the potential-dependent separation can be done on a stationary phase coated with polyaniline (Fig. 4.9, column 6 in Table 4.1). Since the mobile phase contains TEAP in our experiments, the film initially contains C104- as dopant. The elution time of I- and SCN- depends on the potential because the number of the cationic sites (PAN04X ') increases with increase in potential. Table 4.2 lists the potential dependence of elution time for various organic and inorganic ions. Figure 4.10 shows that the larger the ionic size of the inorganic ion, the greater the elution time. However, organic acid ions such as CF,COO-, which are much larger than the inorganic ions, show virtually no retention on the column, even at positive potentials (Table 4.2), and the potential dependence of retention is quite similar to that of C1-. Since polyaniline film displays a dramatic decrease in the diffusion coefficient for ions with ionic radii greater than 0.37 nm [4.29], the short elution time for the organic acid anions would result from the exclusion of such ions from the film. The decreases in elution time at potentials above 0.3 V in Figure 4.10 are probably due to a release of anion via the second oxidation step for the polymer (Fig. 4.8).
4.5 Indirect Electrostatic Interactions for Potential-Dependent Separation
-1500
0 500
2500
0 500
Time 1 s
1500
2500
Time s
85
Figure 4.9. Potential dependence of chromatographic peaks for 20-pL injections of: 10 mM CF3COO- (solid line); 1 mM I- (dashed line); 10 mM SCN(dashed-dotted line). Potential: A) -0.3 V, B) 0.3 V; mobile phase, 10 mM TEAP 1.0 mM HC104; Q = 0.17 C cm-'. CF3COO-, I-, and SCN- were detected at 200,220, and 240 nm, and absorbance values (arrowed) are given in each figure.
+
Table 4.2. Elution of anionic species on polyaniline-coated and polypyrrole-coated stationary phases as a function of potential"
PoIyaniIineb
Polypyrroie"
ATRJAE", Elution time, s sV-' -0.3V +0.3V
Anion*
Elution time, s -0.3V +0.3V
Fumaric acid Malonic acid Succinic acid Tartaric acid Citric acid Benzenesulfonic acid 1,3-Benzenedisulfonic acidg Acetic acid' Trifluoroacetic acid CIBrI- k SCN[Fe(CN),l"
142 142 140 138
148 148 145 140
172 364
(186)' N. D.h
(47)
156 141 148 156 162 192
188 146 216 304 438 (336)'
53 8.3 113 247 460 (262)
10 10 8.3 3.3
A TRIAF , sV-'
130
168
125 124 135 154
162 172 166 (406)'
63 80 51 (630)
130 133
191 151
102 30
152 152 166 132
203 246 412 (161)'
85.7 156 411 (73.8)
65
a Flow rate 0.5 mL m i d ; UV detection 200-250 nm; potential vs. SSE. Deposition at +0.85 V for 10 min (Q = 0.12 C cm-'); mobile phase 10 mMTEAP + 10 mM HCIO4aqueous solution (pH 2). Deposition at + 1.0 V for 10 min; mobile phase 10 mM TEAP aqueous solution (pH 5.5 at +0.3 V). Injection 20 pL of 10 mM analyte ions + mobile phase solution. Organic acids exist mainly as monoanions in the mobile phase used with the polyaniline column. Average potential dependence of elution time A TR/AE = (TR, - TR,x2) I (x, - xz), where TR,I is elution time at potential x; Elution time at +O.O V, no peak detected at +0.3 V. Disodium salt. No peak detected at -0.1 V, Retention time at +0.1 V, no peak detected at +0.3 V. Sodium salt. kInjection 20 pL of 1.0 mM I- + mobile phase solution. Retention time at +0.25 V, no peak detected at +0.3 V.
'
'
86
4 Electrochromatography with Radial Applied Voltage 2000
v)
1500
.-E
.I-
c
.-0
I000
4-
C
a)
4-
$
Figure 4.10. Potential dependence of the elution time. Analyte: SCN- (lozenges); 1- (squares); Br- (triangles); CI- and CF3COO- (circles, both showed 0 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 virtually the same behavior). Q = 0.22 C cm-'; other experimental conditions are the same as in Potential " ~Ag,AgC, . Figure 4.9.
500
,
1.2
, l . l . l . l . l . l . l .
0.8
3c
0.4
D l
-0
0
-0.4
0
-0.8 -18
-14
-10
-6
log (C, / mol g-carbon-')
-2
Figure 4.11. Dependence of the capacitance factor, k', on the site concentration CR. ?I = 0.240 V; n = 1; T = 298 K. CRis calculated for: oxidatively treated carbon (full circles); and untreated carbon (lozenges, squares). CRwas also obtained experimentally (open circles). Q = 0.22C cm-' (lozenges); Q = 11 C cnid othenviese. Other experimental conditions are the same as in Figure 4.9.
Figure 4.11 shows the dependence of the capacitance factor on the concentration of the cationic site, = N'H. The dependence is linear over wide ranges of concentration [4.5]. When polyaniline is deposited on oxidatively treated carbon particles, the slope becomes much gentler, suggesting that the film structure created on such particles is very different from that for untreated particles. In contrast, the loading of polyaniline Q (Fig. 4.8) does not greatly influence the slope, so that the film structure is not very sensitive to the loading. The linear dependence can be analyzed by the equilibrium: A-
K + ( = N + H ) . C104 - + (-N+H). A- + ClO,
(6)
4.5 Indirect Electrostatic Interactionsfor Potential-Dependent Separation
87
-
where (= N’H) . C10,- and (= N+H) A- show Clod- and analyte bound to the stationary phase. The capacity factor can be related to the equilibrium constant K as follows [4.30]: log k’ z lOg(V,/V,)
+ log K + lOg(CR/CL)
(7)
where V,and V,,, are the volumes of the stationary and mobile phases, CRis the concentration of the cationic sites (= N’H), and C, is the concentration of C10,- in the mobile phase. CR can be evaluated both theoretically and experimentally. Theoretically, CRcan be calculated by the following equation, if the redox reaction of the polymer is reversible:
where C, is the total concentration of the oxidized (cationic) and reduced (neutral) sites in the film and should be equal to Q/nE Since Equation (4) suggests an n value of unity for the electron transfer at each site, the relationship between log k’ and log CR can be plotted from an experimental elution time and potential via Equations (7) and (8). CRat potential E can also be obtained experimentally by integration of the voltammetric peak from Eo to E (Fig. 4.8). Equation (7) predicts that the log k’-log C, plots should have unit slope, but slopes of 0.1-0.2 were obtained experimentally. Since an n value smaller than unity reduces potential dependence of C,, the deviation from theory may be attributed to the formation of triple ions such as ( 3 N0.’+H)&, which have been reported [4.26].
Irreversible Uptake of Highly Charged Large Anions into the Film. Large and/or highly charged ions are taken up irreversibly into the oxidized film at positive potentials [4.5]. Since such ions can be eluted by a potential perturbation in the negative direction, the uptake allows both concentration and separation on a single column. The mechanism is quite similar to that described in Section 4.3, and the procedures explained there can be applied. Deinhammer et al. have separated adenosine monophosphate (AMP) and adenosine triphosphated (ATP) on a polypyrrole-coated stationary phase (column 9 in Table 4.1), using potential-step stripping techniques [4.10]. Both AMP and ATP are totally retained at -0.3 Vversus SSE, a potential which corresponds to the moderate oxidation of polypyrrole film. Since ATP interacts more strongly with the polymer, AMP elutes at a smaller elution volume than ATP, when the potential becomes more negative in the stripping stage. The irreversible uptake is predominant for polypyrrole (column 7 in Table 4.1) than for polyaniline (column 6 in Table 4.1) and most ions studies in Table 4.2 are taken up in the polypyrrole film, at leat to a certain degreee, which would make it difficult to use this polymer in quantitative analysis. For these irreversible uptake, the application of the continuous pulse technique is more attractive [4.31].
88
4
4.6
Summary
Electrochromatography with Radial Applied Voltage
Although chromatography has been developed as one of the most commonly used separation techniques, the virtually unalterable properties of separation columns allow only a limited number of experimental parameters to be varied. In this connection, the idea of the stationary phase potential has attracted many electrochemists to the introduction of an additional parameter for controlled elution. To see if this idea is feasible, columns comprising conductive stationary phases have been constructed. The discussions in this chapter mainly focus on the separation of electroinactive species which cannot be separated by redox reactions at an electrode. The separation mechanisms have also been discussed from the point of view of direct and indirect electrostatic interactions between analyte and stationary phase. The direct interaction occurs between analyte ion and charged stationary phase, and changes in the field strength at the stationary phase alter the retention of analyte. Alkali metal ions have been separated on stationary phases coated with oxidized carbon and with crown ethers, by varying the potential. The separations of neutral organic compounds by electrosorption have also been discussed. Separations with indirect interactions are based on changes in the number of ion exchange sites, which is controlled by the potential of the stationary phase. The separation of ionic species by redox polymer and conducting polymer stationary phases has been discussed. Acknowledgements I express my sincere thanks to Dr. J. Yano, Professor S. Yamamoto, and Professor K. Ogura for many helpful comments and discussions. Many students have also contributed their talent to our work: Y. Uchida, K. Kakuno, H. Nakao, and, especially, M. Fujimoto. Grant support was obtained from the Ministry of Education.
4.7 [4.1] (4.21 [4.3] [4.4] [4..5] [4.6] [4.7] [4.8] [4.9] [4.10] [4.11] [4.12] [4.13] [4.14] [4.15] [4.16] [4.17]
References T. Fujinaga, T. Nagai, S . Okazaki, C. Takagi, Nippon Kugaku Zasshi, 84,941-942 (1963). T. Nagaoka, M. Fujimoto, H. Nakao, K. Ogura, Runseki Kagaku, 40,785787 (1991). T. Nagaoka, M. Fujimoto, Y. Uchida, K. Ogura, J. Electroanal. Chem., 336,4555 (1992). T. Nagaoka et al., J. Electroanal. Chern., 350, 337-344 (1993). T. Nagaoka et al., J. Electroanal. Chern., 364, 179-188 (1994). T. Nagaoka et al., J. Electrounal. Chem., 368, 31.5-317 (1994). A.R. Ghatak-Roy, C. R. Martin, Analytical Chemistry, 58, 1574-1575 (1986). R. F. Antrim, R. A. Scherrer, A. M. Yacynych, Anal. Chim. Acta, 164, 283-286 (1984). H. Ge, P. R. Teasdale, G. G. Wallace, J. Chrornatogr., 544, 305-316 (1991). R. S. Deinhammer, K. Shimazu, M. D. Porter, Anal. Chern., 63, 1889-1894 (1991). M. Fujihira, in Topics in Organic Electrochemistry, A. J. Fry, W. E. Britton (eds.), Plenum Press, New York, 1986, pp. 25.5-294. W. J. Blaedel, J. H. Strohl, Anal. Chem., 36, 1245 (1964). D. K. Roe, Anal. Chem., 36,2371-2372 (1964). A. J. Bard, L. A. Faulkner, Electrochemical Methods, Wiley, New York, 1980, pp. 51-52. T. Fujinaga, C. Takagi, S. Okazaki, Kogyo Kagaku Zasshi, 67, 1798-1801 (1964). T. Fujinaga, S. Kihara, CRC Crit. Rev. Anal. Chem., 6, 223-254 (1977). J. Schreurs, J. van den Berg, A. Wonders, E. Barendrecht, Recl. Trav. Chim. Pays-Bas,
103,251-259 (1984). [4.18] G. E. Cabaniss et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc., 107, 1845-1853 (19x5).
4.7 References
[4.19] [4.20] [4.21] [4.22] [4.23] [4.24] 14.251 [4.26j
89
E. Hollax, D. Sh. Cheng, Carbon, 23, 655-664 (1985). T. Nagaoka,Y. Uchida, K. Ogura, J . Chem. Soc., Furaday Trans. I , 85,3757-3765 (1989). T. Nagaoka et al., Anal. Chem., 60,2766-2769 (1988). T. Nagaoka, H. Nakao, unpublished work. C. J. Pedersen, H. K. Fresndorff, Angew. Chem. Internat. Edit., 11, 16-25 (1972). Z. Samec, €? Papoff, Anal. Chem., 62, 1010-1015 (1990). H. Ge, G. G. Wallace, Anal. Chern.. 61. 2391-2394 f1986). W . 4 . Huang, B. D. Humphrey, A. G. MacDiarmid,'J. &ern. Soc., Faraday Trans. I, 82, 2385-2400 (1986). I4.271 D. Orata, D. A.'Buttry, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 109, 3574-3581 (1987). [4.28] C. Barbero, M. C. Miras, 0. Haas, R. Kotz, J . Electrochem. Soc., 138, 669-672 (1991). [4.29] K. Tsubaki, A. Kitani, K. Sasaki, Ann. Meet. Chem. Soc. Jpn., Chugoku-Shikoku and Kyushu Branch, Tottori, Oct. 1991, Paper 2L07. [4.30] S. Yamamoto, K. Nakanishi, R. Matsuno, Zon Exchange Chromatography of Proteins, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1988. [4.31] T. Nagaoka et al., J. Electroanal. Chem., 371, 283-286 (1994).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
5
Electrochromatography in Biomolecular Analysis Daniel H. Shain
5.1
Introduction
A fundamental problem in the biological sciences is the identification and purification of molecules which appear to be interesting. In most cases, this is accomplished by employing some form of chromatography or electrophoresis. Both of these techniques have become highly developed and diversified in recent years and are each capable of remarkable resolutions. As the details of biochemical pathways are explored further, however, it has become necessary to analyze complex mixtures and to distinguish between closely related molecules which cannot always be resolved by conventional procedures. In these instances, it is often effective to combine two separative dimensions into a single technique. For example, two-dimension (2-D) electrophoresis separates proteins according to their isoelectric point and also by their molecular weight. The number of proteins which can be resolved by coupling these two dimensions far exceeds the number resolved when using each dimension alone E5.11. When electrophoresis and chromatography are combined into a single system, the resulting technique is called electrochromatography (EC). In EC, a substance migrates according to its electrophoretic mobility as well as its interaction with a supportive matrix [5.2]. Recently, EC has been expanded to encompass a myriad of related techniques [5.3], all of which utilize some aspect of chromatography and electrophoresis. In this chapter, EC methodologies which pertain to the analysis of biomolecules will be examined. These will include a number of earlier experiments which have provided the foundation for more modern EC technologies. The goal of this chapter is to demonstrate the practical aspects of EC in the biosciences and its potential advantages over conventional techniques.
5.2
Significance
Perhaps one of mankind’s most challenging problems is to understand the processes which constitute life. In its simplest sense, life may be considered as a network of biochemical interactions that result in a replicating unit, a process which is poorly understood. When considering higher eukaryotic organisms, such as ourselves, the problem becomes quite complex. Highly organized systems, including the circulatory, immune, respiratory and nervous systems, all have specialized roles yet they are dependent upon each other for survival. The different systems are comprised of tissue specific cells, each of which contains numerous compartments and organelles. These cellular structures can be broken down further and further until one arrives at the individual biomolecules which provide the foundation for cellular activity. It is at this level that
92
5 Electrochromatography in Biomolecular Analysis
scientists are beginning to unravel what took billions of years of evolution to achieve. Nevertheless, it is astounding that processes such as ontogeny or consciousness can arise from the interaction and spatial organization of a finite number of molecules. Understanding these processes represents a formidable obstacle at the present time; however, much progress can be made in this direction by identifying the individual components of each system and then determining their function. In this case, it is the properties of individual biomolecules which need to be studied. Thus, it becomes necessary to obtain, in pure form, biomolecules which are suspected to play important roles in higher biological processes. In molecular evolution, ancestral molecules are modified by random mutations and those mutations which are favorable are maintained by natural selection. Since evolution proceeds in small steps, the similarities between two functionally distinct molecules may far outweight their differences. For example, a single amino acid substitution in the active site of a protein can completely abolish its activity. If the mutant and wild type proteins are compared at the structural level, however, they are essentially identical. While this represents an extreme example, within the cell there are numerous molecular families which have all evolved from recent common ancestors. As a result, closely related biomolecules abound in living organisms, yet many of these have distinct roles within the cell (e.g., transcription factors, olfactory receptors, etc.). As the intricacies of cellular mechanisms are gradually explored, it is of paramount importance that interesting biological molecules can be identified and purified to homogeneity so that the system may be understood in its entirety. The applications of such knowledge will be invaluable to basic research, biotechnology, medical science and many other disciplines.
5.3
Characteristics of Biomolecules
An emphasis will be placed on the analysis of macromolecules such as nucleic acids (deoxyribonucleic acid - DNA and ribonucleic acid - RNA) and proteins since they constitute the majority of the cell’s dry weight [5.4]and are representative of types of separations which can be achieved by electrochromatography. Smaller biomolecules, which are often precursors to macromolecules, will be considered when appropriate. The structure of double standed DNA (dsDNA) is shown in Figure 5.1. DNA is a polymer of deoxyribonucleotides, each of which contains a phosphate, a deoxyribose sugar and a nitrogenous base (adenine, cytosine, guanine or thymidine). In the cell,
Figure 5.1. Structure of dsDNA. DNA is a polymer of deoxyribonucleotides linked together by phosphodiester bonds. In most cases, DNA has a continuous double helical structure containing a major and a minor groove.
5.3 Characteristics of Biomolecules
93
Figure 5.2. Representation of mRNA. RNA is a polymer of ribonucleotides linked together by phosphodiester bonds. mRNA is often found as a linear molecule while transfer RNA (tRNA), ribosomal RNA (rRNA) and ribozymes have highly folded structures. RNA has numerous functions within the cell including its most recently discovered role in enzyme catalysis.
DNA is organized into chromosomes, each of which contains hundreds to thousands of individual genes. Chromosomal DNA is often digested by restriction endonucleases into fragments which are relatively easy to manipulate. These DNA fragments provide the foundation for molecular biology and are used, for example, in the construction of libraries which facilitate the cloning and characterization of individual genes. Almost all recombinant DNA techniques require size fractionating DNA. Two inherent features make DNA suitable for such analysis. First, DNA is negatively charged due to its phosphodiester backbone. Second, since dsDNA has a continuous double helical structure (with some exceptions), its charge-to-mass ratio is constant regardless of its length. Thus, dsDNA fragments are readily separated by size exclusion matrices in both electrophoresis and chromatography. DNA contains the archives of information necessary to build a living organism. By itself, however, DNA does very little in the cell and must first be transcribed into messenger RNA (mRNA) before its information is translated into proteins. RNAis chemically very similar to DNA with a few exceptions. Most notably, RNA contains a ribose sugar group in place of the deoxyribose found in DNA. In addition, the base thymidine (present in DNA) is replaced by uracil in RNA. RNA is a single stranded molecule (Fig. 5.2) that can acquire unique structures upon folding (e.g., ribozymes, ribosomal RNA). RNA is typically fractionated by size ecxlusion matrices under denaturing conditions (to remove 2' and 3' structures) using electrophoresis, chromatography or density gradients. Proteins represent the most diverse group of biomolecules and are associated with almost every structural and functional aspect of life. In contrast with DNA and mRNA, they fold into complex three-dimensional structures and often interact among themselves. A molecular model of hemoglobin is shown in Figure 5.3 to demonstrate the complexity of a typical protein. Each protein folds into a particular conformation depending upon its linear sequence of amino acids, of which only twenty are used by living organisms on Earth. Once folded, each protein assumes a specific role whether it is, for example, in the recognition of antigens (antibodies), capturing photons of light (rhodopsins) or in the transport of ions across the plasma membrane (i.e., Na+/K+pump). Proteins migrate in an electric field due to the presence of charged amino acid residues within their polypeptide chain. The net charge of a protein is largely dependent upon which types of amino acids are most abundant.Proteins rich in lysine, arginine
94
5 Electrochromatography in Biomolecular Analysis
Figure 5.3. Structure of hemoglobin. Hemoglobin and other proteins are polymers of amino acids linked together by peptide bonds.
or histidine tend to carry a positive charge while proteins abundant in aspartic acid or glutamic acid are generally electronegative. Thus, the amino acid composition of a protein usually determines which direction it migrates in an electric field. The exceedingly large number of polypeptide conformations and compositions found in nature presents the greatest challenge in the development of macromolecular separative techniques. Nonetheless, many proteins can be separated, to some extent, by conventional chromatographic and electrophoretic procedures.
5.4
Development of Electrochromatographic Techniques
The origins of chromatography and electrophoresis are controversial [5.5]-[5.8]and, as might be expected, the time at which the two techniques were first used in combination is also questioned [5-21, [5.7], [5.8].The term electrochromatography appears to have been used first by Berraz in 1943 in describing a form of paper electrophoresis [5.9]. Four years prior to this, however, Strain performed the technique by inserting electrodes into an alumina column and separating dyestuffs using an applied voltage [5.10]. Also in 1939, Coolidge conducted electrophoresis of proteins in a tube packed with glass wool [5.11]. Numerous experiments followed which used alumina [5.12],
5.4 Development of Elecfrochromafographic Techniques
95
[5.13], asbestos fiber 15.141, glass [5.15], [5.16], silica [5.17]-[5.21], filter paper [5.22]-[5.24], cellulose [5.25]-[5.28], pevikon C-870 [5.29], [5.30] or sephadex [5.31] as a supporting material to which an electric field was applied. Although many of these matrices introduced a sorptive component into the separation, it should be noted that some were used in an effort to control the problem of convection which plagued free solution electrophoresis [5.11], [5.15]. The supportive matrix, however, directly influenced all of these separations by interacting with the sample, even though these interactions were not always favorable. In fact, some materials
-
+
Sickle ccll Luemoglobln
e 5
Figure 5.4. “Finger prints” of human normal and sickle-cell hemoglobins. Electrophoresis at pH 6.4, chromatography with n-butyl alcohoUacetic acidwater (3: 1:1). The shaded and the stippled spots are those belonging to the peptide showing the difference. (Reproduced with permission from Macmillan Magazines Limited)
96
5 Electrochromatogrriphy in Biomolecular Analysis
were chemically modified to suppress electro-osmosis and adsorption [5.25], two properties which have been exploited in modern EC techniques. Nevertheless, it is clear that the benefits of combining electrophoresis and chromatography have been recognized for almost half a century. This is demonstrated by the experiments of Hauguord and Kroner who, in 1948, performed a two dimensional separation of amino acids by simultaneously performing chromatography and electrophoresis at right angles to each other [5.22]. Of the supportive matrices mentioned above, paper and thin-layer electrochromatography became the most popular since they were simple to use, inexpensive and they separated materials into distinct bands which could be identified and isolated. Consequently, a variety of conditions were developed for the analysis of proteins [5.30], [5.32]-[5.34], peptides [5.19]-[5.21], [5.24], [5.28], [5.30], [5.35]-[5.37], amino acids [5.7], [5.37], nucleic acids [5.7], [5.30] and other biological compounds [5.7]. Of particular interest is the two dimensional separation of hemoglobin peptide fragments by Ingram in 1957 [5.24]. Using a combination of electrophoresis and chromatography on Whatman No. 3 MM paper, trypsinized hemoglobin was resolved into approximately 30 different peptide fragments as shown in Figure 5.4. When the finger print of normal hemoglobin was compared to that of a sickle cell anemia patient, it was found that one peptide fragment was consistently displaced. This change was later found to be the result of a single amino acid substitution,thus demonstrating the sensitivity of this technique and its applications as a diagnostic tool. The technology of combining electrophoresis with paper and thin-layer chromatography underwent a period of rapid development and a wide range of experimental conditions were established. Although these techniques are still in use [5.38]-[5.44] and sophisticated systems are available today (see Chapter 1) the development of this field was overtaken by revolutionary advances in gel electrophoresis.
5.5
Gel Electrophoresis
The idea of electromigration through a gelatinous material dates back more than a century I5.451. The field received limited attention, however, until 1955 when Smithies introduced starch gels as a method for separating serum proteins L5.461. Since starch provided a molecular sieving effect, a protein migrated according to its size and shape in addition to its electrophoretic mobility. In 1959, the field was revolutionized with the development of polyacrylamide gels [5.47]. In contrast with starch gels, polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) enabled a wide range of pore sizes to be selected, each of which yielded high resolution [5.37]. As a result, PAGE became the method of choice for separating biomolecules ranging in size from small peptides to viruses. Subsequent modifications to PAGE greatly expanded its versatility. For example, sodium dodecycl sulfate-PAGE (SDS-PAGE) denatures and swamps a protein with negative charges, causing it to migrate according to its approximate molecular weight [5.48]. Isoelectric focusing separates proteins according to their isoelectric point [5.49], [SS O ) , while 2-D electrophoresis combines isoelectric focusing and SDS-PAGE (perpendicular to each other) and is one of the most powerful techniques currently available for protein separation [5.1], [5.4]. Gel electrophoresis has had such an enormous impact on biochemical analyses that it is generally placed into a category of its own. However, gels cast of polyacrylamide or agarose provide a molecular sieving effect (and in some cases a sorptive component [SSl]) which constitutes a major separative factor. Consequently, gel electrophoresis is
5.6 Electrochromatography in Preparative Columns
97
classified as a form of electrochromatography [5.2]. It may be more appropriate, however, to consider gel electrophoresis as an extreme form of EC called EC with infinitely slow pressurized flow since the system operates in the absence of a solvent flow [5.52]. No attempt will be made to cover the plethora of techniques which have been developed in this field; however, some particularly relevant applications in the analysis of macromolecules will be considered in later sections.
5.6
Electrochromatography in Preparative Columns
The successful application of electrophoresis performed on filter paper, thin layers of sorptive material and in gels prevented its extensive exploration in packed columns [5.31], [5.53], [5.54]. Nonetheless Neremberg and Pogojeff used a Sephadex G-100 preparative column with a specialized adapter which permitted chromatography to proceed by gravity, while an electric field was applied in either direction. Significantly, higher resolution of serum proteins was achieved when chromatography and electrophoresis were performed simultaneously as compared with each technique used alone [5.31]. In 1980, a preparative column which performed electrophoresis and chromatography in sequential steps was described by Otsuka and Listowsky [5.55]. The resolving power obtained by this apparatus sparked a new interest in EC which has been influential in the rapid development of EC over the past decade.
5.6.1
Sequential Electrochromatography
In electrochromatography, electrophoresis and chromatography can be performed simultaneously or in sequential steps, both of which have been utilized in paper and thin-layer electrochromatography (see Section 5.4). One of the first examples of sequential EC performed in a column is that described by Otsuka and Listowsky [5.55]. In their apparatus, a polyacrylamide gel is deposited on top of a column packed with a chromatographic support, as shown in Figure5.5. A sample is electrophoresed through the polyacrylamide layer and into the chromatographic support. At this point the applied voltage and the upper, polyacrylamide layer are removed. The sample now begins the chromatographic phase of the separation in which the flow rate is controlled by gravity. In the experiment done by Otsuka and Listowsky, the H and L subunits of human liver ferritin were separated using a 7.5 % polyacrylamide gel (in 9 M urea, 0.125 M Tris buffer, pH 6.8) and Bio-Gel P-300 (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Gaithersburg, MD) as the chromatographic support. Since these subunits have similar molecular weights (H subunit = 21,000; L subunit = 19,000), similar isoelectric points and are structurally related, they provide an example of closely related macromolecules which are difficult to separate by conventional methods, including ion-exchange and gel-filtration chromatography. Although separation is achieved using 2-D electrophoresis, this technique cannot be used effectively on a preparative scale. Using the conditions described above, approximately 7mg of dissociated ferritin was resolved in a single run as demonstrated by Figure 5.6. Recoveries of each subunit ranged from 70-90 % of the total protein applied. The main drawback to this system is the duration of the run which took more than 60 h (18 h electrophoresis and >40 h chromatography) to complete. When considering the amount of pure protein that is recovered, however, the time factor becomes somewhat less significant.
98
5 Electrochromatogruphy in Biomoleculur Analysis
Figure 5.5. Apparatus used for electrochromatography procedures. The column was packed with Bio-Gel P-300, and the layer of polyacrylamide above the resin is indicated by (A). The graduate cylinder and the funnel above the column contained the electrophoresis and eluting buffer 9 M urea, 0.125 MTris, pH6.8. Platinum wires were immersed in the electrode buffers and connected to the terminal leads. This photograph was taken 14 h after the sample was applied for electrophoresis. (D) indicates the position of the tracking dye. (Reproduced with permission from Academic Press)
ELUTION VOLUME (ml)
Figure 5.6. Elution pattern for ferritin subunits after electrochromatography. Human liver ferritin samples were treated with 9 M urea, pH2.5, for dissociation into subunits. Electrophoresis was carried out until most of the tracking dye migrated into the cathode buffer chamber. The column was then fitted with a stopcock and the elution pattern from the Bio-Gel P-300 chromatographic step was monitored using 0.5 mL fractions. Sodium dodecyl sulfatepolyacrylamide gel electrophoretic analysis of the protein containing fractions (within the dotted lines) are shown above the elution pattern. Each channel in the gel represented one 0.5 mL fraction and lanes were numbered to correspond to the volume in the elution pattern shown below the gel. (Reproduced with permission from Academic Press)
5.6 Electrochromatography in Preparative Columns
99
By using different combinations of electrophoretic and chromatographic conditions, it is likely that this form of EC could separate a variety of closely related biomolecules on a preparative scale. The key feature in this technique is its smooth transition from polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis to gel filtration chromatography. Without efficient coupling a significant loss in resolution is inevitable. This was accomplished by electromigrating the ferritin subunits from the polyacrylamide gel directly into the gel filtration column. It may also be possible to employ a system whereby solutes are transported from one separative dimension to the next via a peristaltic pump or an alternative pressure source, as examined below.
5.6.2
Electrochromatographywith Modem Adaptations to Liquid Chromatography
Numerous attempts have been described which combine electrophoresis with some aspect of liquid chromatography. This group of techniques typically employs a pressurized flow which follows electrophoresis and thus enables an eluted solute to be transported for detection and/or recovery. A commercially available apparatus which utilizes this idea is called high-performance electrophoresis chromatography (HPECTM)
Figure 5.7. Schematic of the HPEC apparatus. A sample is applied to a gel electrophoresis column mounted between two specially designed blocks housing the electrodes and the upper and lower buffers. A continuous flow of elution buffer, under helium pressure, carries the separated bands to the detection and fraction collection systems. A specialized elution trap fitted with dialysis membrane enables macromolecules to be recovered quantitatively. (Reproduced with permission from Applied Biosystems)
100
5
Electrochromatography in Biomolecular Analysis
Figure 5.8. Purification of synthetic oligonucleotides. HPEC successfully resolves and allows recovery of a 90-mer from 2.0 O D of crude synthetic product. Recovery of the fractions shown is 0.18OD, compared to a theoretical yield of 0.32 OD. The fractions are further analyzed on a 12 % polyacrylamide gel and their purity is confirmcd by the autoradiograph of the gel. Gel: 2.5 x 100mm. 20 ‘Xu polyacrylamide. Power: 0.8 mA, constant current. Detector: 260nm. (Rcproduced with permission from Applied Bi osyst e ms)
75-517
Figure 5.9. Separation of double-ctanded DNA fragments. Excellent peak resolution is achieved when separating 1 pg of a 1-kilobase ladder, from yeast 2 pm circle, on the Model 230A (HPEC). lZun conditions can be further optimized for the collection of specific peaks. Since fractions from the enlire \ample can be collected, additional peaks are available without the need to run additional gels or manually cut bands. Gel: 3.5 X 100mm, 0.4 Yo agarose. Power: 0.5 mA, constant current. Detector: 260nm. (Reproduced with permission from Applied Biosystems)
1
RNA-re 8 8
Figure 5.10. Analysis of the low molecular weight polypeptides of a bovine pancreatic ribonuclease R preparation. Using the Model 2 3 0 h , ribonuclease B is resolved from ribonuclease B”. The two compounds differ only by the extent of glycosylation. The mixture is analyzed by HPEC and on a 15 % SDS-PAGE slab gel. Gel: 2.5 x SO m m , 7.5 % SDS gel. Power: lSOV, constant voltage. Detector: 280 nm. (Reproduced with permission from Applied Biosystems)
5.6 Electrochromatography in Preparative Columns
n
101
Crude
I\
340 nm
J L
GBPDH activity
I
Figure 5.U. On-line activity assay. For on-line detection of enzyme activities, substrates and enzyme cofactors can be added to the elution buffer system of the Model 230A (HPEC). In this example, G3PDH is monitored by adding sodium phosphate, glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate and NAD to the elution buffer. NADH is monitored at its extinction coefficient of 340nm. Gel: 2.5 x 50mm, 5 % alkaline gel. Power: 300V, constant voltage. Detector: 340nm. (Reproduced with permission from Applied Biosystems)
(Model 230A, Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). The HPEC apparatus is shown schematically in Figure 7. HPEC is similar to high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) except that an electrophoretic column is used in place of a conventional HPLC column. Although the HPEC apparatus is somewhat complex in design, requiring three buffer chambers under helium pressure and a specialized elution trap which is fitted with dialysis membrane, it is also quite functional [5.56]-[5.58]. For example, more than ten proteins have been purified to apparent homogeneity from rat cerebrospinal fluid using HPEC as a final purification step [5.58]. Following a buffer exchange, these proteins are suitable substrates for microsequencing without further manipulations. Electropherograms demonstrating the capabilities of HPEC in resolving oligonucleotides, double-stranded DNA fragments and polypeptides are shown in Figures5.8, 5.9, and 5.10, respectively. HPEC has also be used for on-line activity assays by adding enzyme cofactors and substrates to the elution buffer (Fig. 5.11). A number of systems similar in function to high-performance electrophoresis chromatography have been developed, many of which can be assembled from standard laboratory equipment [5.59]-[5.65]. The system that will be described, called electrofractionation (EF), represents an efficient and versatile example of such an apparatus [5.65]. A schematic of the EF system is shown in Figure 5.12. Construction and operation of the apparatus were performed as follows. Teflon tubing (0.d. = 1.52mm7 i.d. = 0.86mm) was fitted into the bottom of a 3mL syringe (Becton-Dickinson, Rutherford, NJ). A nylon mesh filter with a pore size of about 1mm was cut so that it fit exactly inside the syringe. One end of a glass column (i.d. = 4 or 6mm, od. = 8 mm, length = 120mm) was sealed with parafilm and a polyacrylamide or agarose gel was cast inside. After polymerization the parafilm was removed and the glass column was placed into the column holder (syringe). Four symmetrically oriented holes ( l m m in diameter) were made with a heated needle 1cm from the bottom of the column holder to permit current and buffer flow. (A potential problem of EF appears to be the restriction in current flow between the column and column holder. This has been circumvented by increasing the distance between these surfaces [5.66], or by eliminating the column holder altogether [5.67].) Due to the design of the elution trap no dialysis membrane was required. An Eldex (San Carlos, CA) Model A-30-S pump was used to draw buffer from the lower reservoir into the column holder, across the bottom of the
102
5 Electrochromatogruphy in Biomoleculur Analysis
Power
supply
1
I
>
Buffer
Glass Column
el
Figure 5.12. Schematic of the electrofractionation (EF) apparatus. The EF system is similar to a conventional column gel system except that the column gel is enclosed by a column holder. Buffer is pulled through the intake holes and across the bottom of the gel which allows the electrical current to be maintained. As a sample elutes off the column it is carried by the buffer to the detection and fractionation systems. (Reproduced with permission from Academic Press)
gel, and into the outlet tube. As a substance eluted from the gel it entered the continuous buffer flow which resembles that found in HPLC. Buffer containing the eluent then passed through a detection system (Hitachi (Tokyo, Japan)) 655 A variable wavelength monitor and a Fisher (Pittsburg, PA) Recordall Series 5000 recorder) which was coupled to an automated fraction collector (Isco Retriever 11, Lincoln, NE). Samples were loaded onto the column using a capillary tube and run at ambient temperature. The flow rate of elution buffer was between 25-100pL/min and the applied electric field ranged from 1-20 V/cm depending upon the sample. Electrophoretic columns were used repetitively (as in HPLC) and recoveries were generally greater than 80 % . Typical electropherograms of oligonucleotide, DNA fragments and protein separations using the E F apparatus are shown in Figures5.13, 5.14 and 5.15, respectively. A modified EF apparatus was also used successfully for separating biologically active proteins in a non-denaturing separative gel [5.66]. Interestingly, this analysis was not successful using HPLC due to protein adsorption in the dialysis membrane. Electrofractionation has also been used successfully to size fractionate DNA for the construction of lambda bacteriophage libraries (Fig. 16) which are used widely for the cloning of genes (see Section 5.3). Subsequent ligations and packaging of lambda, two sensitive steps associated with library construction, are uninhibited by the EF procedure [5.66]. Since almost all libraries, whether they are genomic, sub-genomic or cDNA libraries, require size fractionation of nucleic acids, E F seems particularly well suited for this application in molecular biology. High-performance electrophoresis chromatography and electrofractionation are versatile techniques in that they may be scaled up or down by adjusting the diameter of the column. For strictly analytical purposes, however, these techniques do not compare with capillary electrophoresis (CE) (see Section 5.7). Nevertheless, both techniques are capable of detecting nucleic acids in the nanogram range which is comparable
5.6 Electrochromatography in Preparative Columns
103
2
1
A264
n
io
30 80 Minutes (A)
(B)
Sb !A
1;o
Minutes (C)
Figure 5.W. EF analysis of oligonucleotides. A) Electropherogram of an unpurified 42 base pair oligonucleotide (peak 2) with a significant failure sequence at 15base pairs (peak 1). The small middle peak represents failure sequences between 16-41 base pairs in length; 25 pg of sample was loaded onto a 30 X 4mm, 20 % acrylamide/7M urea column gel (TBE buffer) and electrophoresed at 20V/cm. The flow rate was 50 pWmin. B) Autoradiogram of the unpurified oligonucleotide sample (lane 1) and the radioactivity corresponding to the 42base pair species recovered from peak2 (lane2). Electrophoresis was performed on a 0.75 mm, 20 % polyacrylamide/7 M urea slab gel. C) Electropherogram of oligonucleotides 18 (peak2), 20 (peak3), 25 (peak4) and 33 (peaks) base pairs in length. Peakl, bromophenol blue. The sample conditions used were the same as described in (a) except the gel length was 75 mm. (Reproduced with permission from Academic Press)
to that of conventional methods, e.g., ethidium bromide stained agarose gels. Thus, HPEC and EF are suited for routine analytical procedures such as determining concentration or purity. Sensitivity could be increased significantly if on-column detection units were used, as demonstrated by automated sequencing [5.69] and CE procedures. The most applicable feature of high-performance electrophoresis chromatography and electrofractionation lies in their ability to separate macromolecules on a micropreparative or a preparative scale. Approximately 300 pg of protein have been purified by HPEC in a single run [5.56] and up to 1mg of partially purified proteins analyzed using modified EF [5.66]. These amounts may be increased if the diameter of the column is enlarged with the limiting factor being the dissipation of heat from the center of the column. Since electrophoretic mobility increases approximately 2 % per "C [5.2], differential heating within the column results in a parabolic flow profile and a subsequent loss of resolution. This problem has been circumvented to some extent in the Model 491 Prep Cell (Bio-Rad, Gaithersburg, MD) which circulates buffer through a tube within the gel. Although horizontal gel systems provide an attractive alternative to columns with regard to heat dissipation [5.70], [5.71], these apparatuses have other limitations (i.e., lack of operation ease). Recently, several analytical techniques have coupled HPLC with capillary electrophoresis [5.72], [5.73] or SDS-PAGE [5.74]. Others have coupled gel electrophoresis
104
5 Electrochromutogruphy in Biomoleculur Analysis
3 2 1
1
3
2
4
A26( I
\
L
Ir (B)
Figure 5.14. EF analysis of DNA fragments. A) Electropherogram of DNA fragments generated from a Pstl digestion of pcDNAllneo. Peak 1, bromophenol blue; peak2, 922 base pairs (130ng); peak3, 2054 base pairs (290ng); and peak 4, 4147 base pairs (580ng); 1pg of sample was loaded onto a 30 X 6mm 1% agarose (TAE buffer) column gel and electrophoresed at 7 Vlcm. The flow rate was 50 pL/min. B) Collected fractions were ethanol precipitated and electrophoresed on a 1% horizontal agarose gel. Lane 1, pcDNAll neo digeted with Pstl; lane 2, DNA recovered from peak 2; lane 3, peak 3; and lane 4, peak 4. (Reproduced with permission from Academic Press)
with liquid chromatography [5.75], and size-exclusion chromatography with capillary zone electrophoresis. These systems have resolved a number of complex protein mixtures which could not be separated when using each technique alone. An appropriate step for the improvement of high-performance electrophoresis chromatography or electrofractionation would be adaptations to include additional separative dimensions. In this way, it is likely that the components of complex mixtures could not only be detected but they could also be purified to homogeneity at a micropreparative level. To date, separations of biological materials using high-performance electrophoresis chromatography and electrofractionation have employed the inert matrices of polyacrylamide or agarose [5.56]-[5.68]. There are no restrictions, however, with regard to its supportive matrix and it is likely that conventional chromatographic matrices could enhance the quality of some separations (see Sections 5.7 and 5.8).
5.6.3
Focusing in Columns
The development of carrier ampholytes [5.77] provided the foundation for isoelectric focusing, the conventional method which has been used to focus proteins according to their isoelectric point. Despite the elegance of this technique [5.49], [55.0], isoelectric
5.6 Electrochromatography in Preparative Columns
105
2
1
2
3
Ovalbumin-
A28
!
.
I
.
Lysozyme-
.
30 60 90 120 Minutes (A)
(B)
Figure 5.15. EF analysis of protein. A) Electropherogram of lysozyme (14,400 Da, peak 2) and ovalbumin (45,00ODa, peak3). Peak 1, bromophenol Blue; 8pg of lysozyme and 14mg of ovalbumin were loaded onto an 18 (15 mm resolving gel and 3 mm stacking gel) X 6 mm 12 % SDS-PAGE column gel and electrophoresed at 7.5 V/cm. the flow rate was 50 FL/min. B) Collected fractions were dialyzed against water and aliquots were electrophoresed on a 12 % SDS-PAGE slab gel and stained with Coomassie brilliant blue. Lane 1, lysozyme and ovalbumin standards; lane2, lysozyme (peak2); and lane 3, ovalbumin (peak 3). (Reproduced with permission from Academic Press)
focusing is not readily adapted to separate proteins on a preparative scale. Consequently, a novel approach has been developed which can potentially concentrate milligrams of material at unique positions on a chromatographic column. In this method, called counteracting chromatographic electrophoresis (CACE) [5.74], chromatography and electrophoresis oppose each other in a manner similar to what has been described by Neremberg and Pogojeff [5.31]. With an appropriate combination of chromatographic matrices, electrophoresis dominates in one part of the cotumn while the solvent flow dominates in another. As a result, a substance becomes concentrated at the point where these two opposing forces equal each other. The mechanism by which this process occurs has been described by O’Farrell in referring to Figure 5.17 [S.74]. “A column (Fig. 1)was packed with a restrictive matrix, BioGel P-10 (Bio-Rad), on top of a bed of a much more porous matrix, BioGel A-50m. The colored protein ferritin is found to chromatograph rapidly downward through the upper part of this column (where it is excluded from the matrix beads) but more slowly through the lower part of the column (where it is included in the matrix beads). As illustrated in Figure 1, at the appropriate applied voltage, the upward electrophoresis rate, RE, will exceed the downward rate of movement with solvent flow, RF, in the bottom matrix but will be
106
5
Electrochrornatography in Biornolecular Analysis
L8.W 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9101112
Row A
Row B
Row c
Figure 5.16. Size fractionation of genomic DNA using EF. Rat genomic DNA (10 pg) was digested with EcoR1, applied to a 15 X 6mm 1% agarose (TAE buffer) column gel and electrophoresed at 0.8 V/cm. The flow rate was 40 pWmin. Fractions (2.50~1)were collected, ethanol precipitated and electrophoresed on the horizontal agarose gel shown. The size marker UHind 111 appears in lane 1 in all rows. Row A,lane 2 is an aliquot of rat genomic DNA digested with EcoR1. Row A, lane 3-12 correspond to aliquots from fractions ranging in size from about 0.3 kb-1.5 kb; rowB, lanes2-12 correspond to fractions from 1.5 kb-3.0 kb; and row C, lanes 2-12 correspond to fractions from 3.0 kb-4.5 kb. Following electrophoresis, the DNA was blotted onto nylon and probed with a radiolabeled oligonucleotide. DNA fractions which showed a positive signal were used for constructing a sub-genomic library in the vector hGem 4 (Promega).
insufficient to counteract the more rapid downward RF in the top matrix. At this voltage, the net movement (R,)of ferritin is downward in the top part of the column and upward in the bottom part of the column. The ferritin is thereby highly concentrated at an equilibrium position adjacent to the interface of the P-10 and A-50m gel beds.” Reproduced with permission from the AAAS. Copyright 1985 by the AAAS. Once concentrated, a sample can be recovered from a port located at the equilibrium zone or by removing the electric field and eluting as in liquid chromatography. CACE also has the advantage of a continuous buffer flow which effectively removes heat from the column, a problem which has plagued other preparative methods. The column described above demonstrates the fundamental principle of CACE, but this column could not resolve a complex protein mixture since almost all proteins would focus at the same interface. Resolution is achieved in CACE by increasing the number of chromatographic layers within the column. Under the appropriate conditions, a protein will concentrate at a particular interface while closely related proteins will concentrate at another interface or will be removed from the column either by electrophoresis (RE) or by the pressurized flow (RF).A relatively simple column containing six different layers (different compositions of BioGel A-5m and P-300) is shown in Figure 5 -18. Four different proteins (hemoglobin, myoglobin, ferritin and cytochrome C) were readily focused on this column and, in fact, no two proteins could be forced to reside on the column at the same time [5.78]. The sensitivity of the column
5.6 Electrochrornatography in Preparative Columns
107
t e of movement w l t h - R afluld flow RE - R a t e o f movement b y electrophoresle
RF
RM
- Net
rate: balance o f R f and R g
voltage drlvee 0 Applled components u p w a r d
1 1 11
Fluld f l o w c a r r l e e c o m p o n e n t s down t h e column
Equ I ilb r l u m z o n e
0
Figure 5.17. Schematic representation of the CACE apparatus. A 50-cm glass column (0.7 cm internal diameter) was packed to a height of 25 cm with BioGel A-50m (Bio-Rad), and the remainder of the column was filled with BioGel P-10. The column was connected to electrode reservoirs by short sections (1cm) of large-bore (1.2cm internal diameter) tubing plugged with 15 % polyacrylamide gel. Additional ports allowed the column to be connected to a peristaltic pump to give a regulatable flow of the carrier solvent (10mM tris acetate, pH7.4) through the column. Ferritin loaded on this column was brought to equilibrium with the flow rate set at about 0.17mUmin and the applied voltage adjusted to 600 V. The flow of the carrier solution is indicated by the group of arrows at the top. Vectors to the right indicate the magnitudes and directions of the electrophoretic rate (RE), the rate of solvent flow (RF), and net (RN) solute mobilities. In the equilibrium zone, RE and RF are equalized by concentrationdependent effects. (Reproduced with permission from the AAAS. Copyright 1985 by the AAAS)
was estimated by the percent change in voltage required to shift a protein from one interface to another. Using this criteria, it was determined that a 4 % difference in RE,which corresponds to a difference of a few charged amino acids, was sufficient to focus myoglobin at an adjacent interface. When considering the wide variety of chromatographic matrices available and the potential of using continuous gradients, CACE could have applications in a wide range of preparative fractionations (see Sections 1.6 and 6.1). At present, the main drawback to CACE in the biosciences appears to be in its lack of establishment. Although the idea is relatively simple, the development of the optimal conditions for focusing a particular protein represents a formidable task. Thus, it seems that some fundamental parameters of CACE need to be established before its potential can be realized.
108
5 Electrochrornatography in Biomoleculur Analysis
@
c lnterface
A- . 6 m l P - 3 0 0 1100
A
20100 B 40/80
C
D
60140 80120
E
1001
t
0 Figure 5.18. Use of a multilayered column to measure resolution. A column (20cm by 0.7cm internal diameter) was packed with BioGel A-5m, BioGel P-300, and mixtures of these matrices to produce a series of layered beds as indicated. This layering gives rise to subtle but discontinuous changes in properties so that the rate of movement of myoglobin with solvent (50mM tris acetate, pH7.4) flow (RF) differs in each layer. A protein will be focused at the interface between any of these pairs of layers if REis between the RFvalues of the two bounding layers. RE is determined by the product of the electrophoretic mobility (M) of the solute and the voltage gradient [dVldD), where D is the distance]. The fractional change in dVldD required to change RE to a value, RE', that will cause myoglobin to move from one interface to another provides a direct measure of the resolving power of the method. That is, as shown by the formulas at the right, REand RE' can be related, respectively, to M and M ' , the mobilities of two proteins that differ in electrophoretic mobility by the smallest amount that will permit complete resolution. (Reproduced with permission from the AAAS. Copyright 1985 by the AAAS)
5.7
Electrochromatography in Microcolumns
Most macromolecular separations are currently performed by slab gel electrophoresis or some form of column chromatography (HPLC, anion exchange, size exclusion etc.). Although these methods are quite functional, they all have drawbacks of being either labor intensive, expensive, semiquantitative or a combination of all the above. These problems have been reduced substantially in recent years with the development of capillary electrophoresis (CE). CE is typically performed in fused silica capillary tubes having an i d . <200 pm. Due to their large surface area to volume ratio, capillaries dissipate heat very efficiently and thereby allow high voltages (15-30 kV) to be applied without overheating. As a result, both high resolution and rapid analysis times can be obtained with essentially any biological material. In addition, CE is readily automated and on-column detection (e.g., laser-induced fluorescence) can provide sensitivity in the attomole/zeptomole (10-'8/10~*o) range using injection volumes of only a few nanoliters [5.79]-[5.82].
5.7 Electrochromatography in Microcolumns
109
Not surprisingly, the use of fused silica capillaries in the biological sciences is becoming quite popular. Many have utilized the technique of capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) which separates molecules according to their electrophoretic mobility in blank capillary tubes [5.83]-[5.85]. CZE has produced many exceptional separations of biological materials, but it is mentioned here only for completeness and the reader is referred to several sources which describe this technique in detail [5.80]-[5.82]. It should be noted that a problem which has emerged in CZE is the adsorption of molecules to the inner wall of the capillary. To counteract this problem the interior wall has been coated with a variety of substances [5.86]-[5.91], some of which have sorptive properties and therefore constitute a form of electrochromatography. These separations will be considered in the following section. While CZE can be tuned by modifying the conditions of electrophoresis I5.791-[5.82], [5.92], its resolving power is limited to a single, electrophoretic dimension. As the need to separate complex biological mixtures becomes increasingly important, the idea of modifying existing CE techniques by introducing additional separative dimensions is receiving considerable attention. Since many of these methods introduce a sorptive component into the system, they have been classified as capillary E C (CEC). Within this group there are a number of subcategories [5.3] which have been described in detail elsewhere in this book (see Chapters2 and 3). Relevant techniques will be mentioned briefly here to demonstrate their potential in the analysis of biomolecules.
5.7.1 Electro-Osmotically-Driven Electrochromatography Electroosmosis is the flow of liquid which ensues following the application of an electric field to a solution containing stationary, charged particles; for example, the walls of a capillary tube or packing material which has been immobilized in a column. This phenomenon has been described in detail elsewhere [5.89]-[5.91]. The fundamental principle of electro-osmosis involves the formation of an electrical double layer between oppositely charged ions at all surfaces. If the surface bears a negative charge, then an excess of positive ions accumulate and form a sheath which surrounds a core of uncharged liquid. When an electric field is applied, the positive ions within the sheath migrate and propel the core along with it towards the negative electrode. In contrast with the parabolic flow profile observed in pressure driven systems, electroosmotic flow exhibits a flat flow profile similar to that of plug flow [5.93]. As a result, electro-osmotically driven systems have sharper bands and are less sensitive to matrix irregularities since flow is uniform throughout the system [5.84], [5.93]. In addition, oppositely charged and neutral molecules can be analyzed in a single run [5.84], [5.93]. The potential of using electro-osmosis in the analysis of macromolecules was first demonstrated by Mould and Synge in the early 1950s [5.96], [5.97]. Polysaccharides of various lengths were carried by electro-osmotic flow and separated according to their differential adsorption to collodion membranes [3.97]. This method of generating electro-osmotic flow was later applied to both thin-layer and column chromatography using microparticulate silica 15.931 and, in 1981, Jorgenson and Lukas described it in conjunction with their paper on capillary zone electrophoresis [5.84]. In their report, an electro-osmotically driven separation of peptides from a tryptic digest of chicken ovalbumin was demonstrated (Fig. 5.19). While many peptides are resolved by this analysis, it is likely that others have been masked under larger peaks. To obtain a complete separation of this peptide mixture the conditions of the separation could be modified (i.e., pH, salt concentration, etc.) or an additional separative component could be introduced. In many cases, the latter approach has been more effective. For exam-
110
b
5 Electrochromatography in Biomolecular Analysis
1
I
1 0
20
Time (min)
Figure 5.19. Electropherogram of fluorescamine labeled peptides obtained from a tryptic digest of chicken ovalbumin. (Reproduced with permission from Elsevier Science Publishers B.V.)
ple, closely related naphthalensulfonic acids have been resolved by capillary electrochromatography using capillaries coated with cross-linked PS-264 (a sorptive reagent) [5.98], while CZE and open tubular liquid chromatography have been unable to separate these compounds. Matriccs such as Chirasil-Dex [5.89], silica [5.99] and octadecylsilane (ODS) [5.100]-[5.103] have also demonstrated superior resolving power (see Chapter 3). Despite their potential in analytical procedures, electroosmotically driven systems may make their greatest contribution in the purification of macromolecules on a micropreparative or preparative scale. Since electroosmotic flow can be generated in packed columns of large diameter [5.84], [5.85], conditions which have been optimized analytically could be scaled up for preparative applications. In addition, the problem of heat dissipation is substantially reduced in electroosmosis due to the continuous flow of buffer through the column. Taken together, these features make electroosmotically driven EC an attractive alternative to the conventional preparative methods currently used to separate macromolecules (e.g. , column chromatography, HPLC, column electrophoresis, etc.). Despite its great potential, electroosmotically driven EC has undergone limited experimentation in the biosciences. This is due in part to the rapid developed and wide success of CZE and its related techniques [5.79]-[82], [5.85], [5.90], [5.91]. Since E C introduces a chromatographic component into the system, however, it is quite possible that electroosmotically driven EC techniques will some day outperform strictly electrophoretic procedures in a variety of biochemical applications.
5.7 Electrochromatographyin Microcolumns
5.7.2
111
Pressurized Flow Driven Electrochromatography
Solvent flow in pressurized flow driven EC is generated either by gravity or by an LC pump. Early experiments in this area utilized large columns (i.d. >2cm) in which the flow rate was determined by gravity [5.31], [5.55]. Recently, Tsuda has introduced an HPLC-like apparatus which contains additional hardware to accommodate an electric field [5.104], [5.105]. In this system, much smaller columns are used (i.d. <0.5mm) and pressure is generated by an LC pump. Columns which have been packed with chemically bonded ODS and subjected to a high voltage (up to 15 kV) have produced high quality separations in a fraction of the time it has taken previous systems (see Chapter 2). If mobility is equal to or greater than the pressurized flow velocity, then a sample may be injected continuously and concentrated on the column [5.105], [5.106] in a manner similar to that of CACE (see Section5.6.3). Pressure driven E C is also suited for applications on a preparative scale and, at the present time, may have advantages over electroosmotically driven EC since the solvent flow is more readily controlled. A variation of this technique, called electrochromatographic solid phase extraction (SPE), has been used to concentrate and partially purify cimetidine from serum by employing a C-18 cartridge with voltage assisted eluteion [5.107]. This technique may have general applications as a pretreatment and preconcentration step in the analysis of crude biological samples.
5.7.3
Micellar Electrokinetic Capillary Chromatography
Micellar electrokinetic capillary chromatography (MECC) may be considered an extreme form of EC, although it has already been placed into a category of its own [5.3], [5.81]. Since its introduction in 1984 [5.108], MECC has developed into a powerful tool for separating both charged and uncharged compounds [5.109]-[5.111]. MECC is unique in that it employs an electroosmotically pumped mobile phase and a moving stationary micellar phase [5.111]. Micelles are generated in the system by the addition of detergents such as sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) or cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) [5.111], [5.112]. Once the critical concentration is reached, individual detergent molecules aggregate to form micelles containing 20-100 or more monomers [5.111]. A solute migrates in free solution due to both electrophoresis and electroosmosis (as in CZE) while, at the same time, partitions between the free solution and the pseudo-stationary micellar phase (as in micellar liquid chromatography). Exceptional separations have been obtained using MECC in the analysis of oligonucleotides [5.113], vitamins [5.110], drugs [5.114], glucosinolates [5.112] and peptides I5.1151. It can be expected that other biological molecules will be equally amenable to this technique.
5.7.4
Capillary Gel Electrophoresis
As with conventional gel electrophoresis, capillary gel electrophoresis (CGE) has been placed into a category of its own [5.81], [5.82], although it may be considered as a form of electrochromatography. CGE is essentially a scaled down version of tube gel electrophoresis and all the benefits of conventional gel electrophoresis apply to CGE. With the added feature of efficient heat dissipation, CGE has produced among the highest separation efficiencies of any analytical method to date [5.81]. Despite its attractive features, CGE has several practical limitations including the sensitivity of gels (particularly agarose) to high temperatures and the difficulties currently associated with cast-
112
5 Electrochromatography in Biomolecular Analysis
ing gels inside capillary tubes. In addition, CGE can not separate oppositely charged or neutral compounds since electroosmosis is suppressed. This drawback is likely to hamper CGE considerably in the analysis of complex biological mixtures. Nevertheless, for the analysis of linear biomolecules such as double stranded DNA and denatured proteins, it is doubtful that any technique will surpass the efficiency of CGE in the near future. It is possible that CGE will soon replace conventional procedures used for DNA sequencing, restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs), SDSPAGE and Southern blot analysis.
5.8
Conclusions and Future Directions
We are currently in an exciting period of growth and development in the biological sciences with discoveries being made almost daily. As our knowledge advances, however, we are constantly reminded of the complexity which underlies the fundamental processes of life. From viral replication to consciousness, evolution has engineered highly regulated pathways by selecting biomolecules having unique properties. It has been the goal of modern researchers to identify and isolate these biomolecules so that their roles in higher biological processes may be determined. It can be expected that progress in this direction will contribute immensely to basic research, biomedicine, and industrial sciences. Nested deeply in these efforts are the fundamental techniques of chromatography and electrophoresis. In most cases these methods are used independently of each other. Due to the complexity of natural samples, however, the idea of combining electrophoresis and chromatography into a continuous system (EC) is receiving considerable attention. The primary advantage of EC, in comparison with each technique used alone, is relatively simple. If two different molecules have identical electrophoretic mobilities, there is a good chance that their partition coefficients will differ. Likewise, two molecules having identical partition coefficients are likely to have different electrophoretic mobilities. Thus, in the analysis of complex mixtures or closely related molecules, the chances of obtaining a complete separation are enhanced when two separative components are employed instead of only one. The pioneering experiments of electrochromatography were performed almost half a century ago using filter paper [5.22]-[5.24] and thin layers of sorptive material I5.181, [5.97]. In the past decade, EC has experienced rapid growth which has produced a variety of new methodologies [5.3].These range from preparative columns [5.55], [5.76] to electro-osmotic E C separations performed in microcolumns [5.89], [5.98]-[5.107]. As the field continues to grow, it can be expected that new innovations will be introduced. For example, two dimensional separations within capillary tubes are being explored [5.114], [5.116] and additional separative dimensions, such as mass spectroscopy, have already been coupled with EC [5.117]. Despite the early success of electrochromatography in analytical chemistry, most EC procedures are still in their infancy in the biosciences. This is due to the dominance of capillary zone electrophoresis and high-performance liquid chromatography which have experienced tremendous success in the separation of biological molecules. It suffices to say, however, that EC may be used in parallel with CZE and HPLC, and with potentially greater resolving power since two separative components are employed instead of one. In addition, EC is capable of separating oppositely charged and neutral molecules which is a major limitation of CZE. While CE techniques proved numerous advantages in analytical applications, capillary tubes can not be used practically on a preparative scale. Due to this limitation,
5.9 References
113
electrochromatographic techniques may be among the most efficient procedures for obtaining biomolecules in preparative quantities. In contrast with CZE, several E C techniques which have been utilized in capillary tubes have the potential to be scaled up. These include electro-osmotically driven EC, pressure driven EC and capillary gel electrophoresis. In addition, the unique separation method used by CACE is also well suited for preparative applications. Of these methods, capillary gel electrophoresis is the most developed in the biosciences due largely to its similarities with conventional gel electrophoresis. Scaled up versions of CGE have been used effectively for macromolecular separations in high-performance electrophoresis chromatography, electrofractionation and other preparative apparatuses (e.g., Bio-Rad Model 491 Prep Cell). While these techniques have been developed for the inert matrices of polyacrylamide and agarose, they also provide excellent systems for exploring the potential of other EC methods on a preparative scale, such as electro-osmotically driven EC. Modern electrochromatography is in its early stages of development and is only beginning to make its way into the biological sciences. As the resolving power of conventional techniques become inadequate for the analysis of complex biological mixtures, it is likely that the benefits of combining electrophoresis and chromatography will gain popularity. Progress in this direction could revolutionize the methodologies for capturing biomolecules in their pure form, but this should be expected only after a period of considerable progress in the field. It has taken billions of years of evolution to put the molecules of life together and we are only beginning to develop methods to separate them.
Acknowledgements I thank Randy DeBey for assistance with molecular structures, and Dr. Jakyoung Yo0 for helpful comments on the manuscript.
5.9
References
[5.1] P. H. O’Farrell, J. Biol. Chem. 250,4007-4021 (1975). [5.2] R. J. Weime, in Chromatography: A Laboratory Handbook of Chromatographic and Electrophoretic Methods, E. Heftmann (Ed.), New York, Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., 1975, 3rd ed., chap. 10. [5.3] T. Tsuda, LC-GC Intl., 5 (9), 26-36 (1992). [5.4] B. Alberts, et al., Molecular Biology of the Cell, NewYork, Garland Publishing, Inc., 1989, 2nd ed. [5.5] H. Weil, T. I. Williams, Nature, 166, 1000-1001 (1950). [5.6] T. I. Williams, H. Weil, Nature, 170, 503 (1952). [5.7] M. Lederer, Paper Electrophoresis, Houston, Elsevier Publishing Company, 1955. [5.8] E. Lederer, M. Lederer, Chromatography: A Review of Principles and Applications, Amsterdam, Elsevier Publishing Co., 1957. [5.9] G. Berraz, Anales Asoc. Quim.Arg., 31, 96 (1943). -5.101 H. H. Strain, J . Amer. Chem. SOC.,61, 1292 (1939). -5.111 T. B. Coolidge, J. Biol. Chem., 127, 551 (1939). y5.121 H. Lecog, Bull. SOC.Roy. Sci. Liege, 13, 20 (1944). [5.13] D. V. Lopiekes, E R. Dastoli, S. Price, J . Chromatogr., 23, 182-183 (1966). y5.141 J. A. V. Butler, J. M. L. Stevens, Nature, 160, 469 (1947). y5.141 H . Haglund, A.Tiselius, Acta Chem. Scund, 4, 957 (1950). -5.161 S. Winsten, H. Friedman, E. E. Schwartz, Anal. Biochem., 6,404-414 (1963). .5.17] A. J. P Martin, R. L. M. Synge, Adv. in Protein Chemistry, 2, 1-83 (1945).
114
5 Electrochromatography in Biomolecular Analysis
[5.18] R. Consden, A. H. Gordon, A. J. P. Martin, Biochem. J. 40, 33-41 (1946). [5.19] W. J. Ritschard, J . Chromatogr., 16, 327-333 (1964). [5.20] E. Moczar, J. Chromatogr., 76,417-423 (1973). [5.21] D. L. Bates, R. N. Perham, Anal. Biochem., 68, 175-184 (1975). [5.22] G. Haugaard, T. D . J. Kroner, Amer. Chem. Soc., 70,2135 (1948). [5.23] T. Wieland, E. Fischer, Naturwissenschaften, 35, 29 (1948). [5.24] V. M. Ingrim, Nature, 178,792-794 (1956). [5.25] P. Flodin, D. W. Kupke, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 21, 38 (1956). [5.26] E. A. Peterson, H. A. Sober, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 78,751 (1956). [5.27] A. Yaron, H. A. Sober, Anal. Biochem., 12, 173-188 (1965). [5.28] D. J. W.Burns, N. A. Turner, J . Chromatogr., 30, 469-475. [5.29] V. Bocci, J. Chromatogr., 8, 218-226 (1962). [5.30] A. M. Tometsko, N. Delihas, Anal. Biochem., 18, 72-80 (1967). [5.31] S. T. Nerenberg, G. Pogojeff, Am. J. Clin. Path., 51 (6), 72-740 (1969). [5.32] E. L. Durrum, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 72,2943 (1950). [5.33] D. V. Lopiekes, E R. Dastoli, S. Price, J . Chromatogr, 23, 182-183 (1966). [5.34] B. Gutte, J. Biol. Chem., 250, 889-904 (1975). [5.35] J. Holbrook, R. Jeckel, Biochem. J., 111,689-694 (1969). [5.36] G. R. Stark, L. V. Crawford, Nature NewBioZogy, 237, 146-147 (1972). [5.37] E. q i h a k , in Methods of Protein Analysis, I. Kerese (ed.), Chichester, Ellis Horwood Limited, 1984, chap. 5 . [5.38] N. Feuerstein, P. K. Chan, J. J. Mond, J. Biol. Chem., 263(22), 10608-10612 (1988). [5.39] W. P. Sullivan, B. J. Madden, D . J. McCormick, J. Biol. Chem., 263(29), 14717-14-723. [5.40] C. W. Turck, J. W. Tom, P. W. Kennedy, E. J. Goetzl, J . fmmunol., 141(4), 1225-1230 (1988). [5.41] H. C. Jr. Hemming et al., J. Biol. Chem., 264(13), 7726-7733 (1989). (5.421 W. J. Boyle, P. van der Geer, T. Hunter, Methods in Enzymology, 201, 110-149 (1991). [5.43] S. Ferrari et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 89, 7282-7286 (1992). [5.44] M. Nakao et al., Biochem. Biophys, 298(2), 340-348 (1993). [5.45] 0. Lodge, Brit. Assoc. Reports, 38 (1886). [5.46] 0. Smithies, J. Biochem., 61, 629 (1955). [5.47] S. Raymond, L. Weintraub, Science, 130, 711 (1959). [5.48] J. V. Maizel, Science, 151, 988 (1966). [5.49] J. I? Arbuthnott, J. A. Beeley, Isoelectric Focusing, London, Butterworths &Co., 1975. [5.50] N. Catsimpoolas, Zsoelectric Focusing, New York, Academic Press, 1976. [5.51] J. S. Krauss, M. H. Jonah, Clin. Chem., 28(8) 2000-2001 (1982). [5.52] T. Tsuda, personal communication. [5.53] J. Porath, E. B. Lindner, S . Serstedt, Nature, 182, 744-745 (1958). [5.54] H. Fasold, G. Gundlach, F. Turba, in Chromatography, E. Heftmann, (ed.), NewYork, Reinhold Publishing Corp., 1961, chap. 15. [5.55] S. Otsuka, I. Listowsky, Anal. Biochem., 102,419-422 (1980). [5.56] D. G. Sheer et al., Peptide Res., 3(2) 97-104 (1990). [5.57] P. G. Parnell, J. Wunderlich, B. Carter, J. Halper, Growth Factors, 7(1) 65-72 (1992). [5.58] L. Saso, B. Silverstrini, C. Y. Cheng, Anal. Biochem., 212, 315-324 (1993). [5.59] T. Jovin, A. Chrombach, M. A. Naughton, Anal. Biochem., 9, 351-369 (1964). [5.60] A. D. Brownstone, Anal. Biochem, 27,25-46 (1969). [5.61] M. Popescu, L. H. Lazarus, N. Goldblum, Anal. Biochem, 40, 247-253 (1971). [5.62] A. Jacobson, H . F. Lodish, Anal. Biochem., 54, 513-517 (1973). [5.63] M. A. Hediger, Anal. Biochem, 142,445-454 (1984). [5.64] T. M. Cao, Y. H. Ing, Anal. Biochem., 192, 251-253 (1991). [5.65] D . H. Shain et al., Anal. Biochem., 200, 47-51 (1992). [5.66] D. Ruggiero-Lopez et al., Anal. Biochem., 212,247-252 (1993). [5.67] J. Pyun et al.,Anal. Biochem., 223, 59-61 (1994). [5.68] D. H. Shain, unpublished work. [5.69] L. M. Smith et al., Nature, 321, 674-679 (1986). [5.70] F. Polsky et al., Anal. Biochem. 87, 397-410 (1978). [5.71] E. M. Southern, Anal. Biochem. 100, 304-318 (1979).
5.9 References
115
[5.72] M. M. Bushey, J. W. Jorgenson, Anal. Chem., 62, 978-984 (1990). [5.73] H. Yamamoto, T. Manabe, T. Okuyama, J . Chromatogr., 515,659-666 (1990). [5.74] W. G. Burton et al., J . Chrornatogr., 443, 363-379 (1988) [5.75] D. J. Rose, G. J. Opiteck, Anal. Chem., 66, 2529-2536 (1994) [5.76] A . V. Lemmo, J. W. Jorgenson, J. Chromatogr., 633, 213-220 (1993) [5.77] H. Svensson, Acta Chem. Scand. 16, 456-466 (1962). [5.78] P. H. O’Farrell, Science 227, 1586-1589 (1985). [5.79] C. Schwer, E. Kenndler, Chromatographia, 30(9/10), 546-553 (1990). [5.80] Z. Deyl, R. Struzinsky, J. Chromatogr., 569, 63-122 (1991) [5.81] S. E Y. Li, Capillary Electrophoresis: Principles, Practice and Applications, Amsterdam, Elsevier Science Publishers, 1992. [5.82] J. P. Landers et al., Biotechniques, 14(1), 98-11 (1993). [5.83] J. W. Jorgenson, K. D. Lukas, Anal. Chem. 53, 1298-1302 (1981). [5.84] J. W. Jorgenson, K. D . Lukas, J . Chromatogr. (1981) 218,209-216. [5.85] J. W. Jorgenson, K. D. Lukas, Science, 222,266-272 (1983) [5.86] Y. Tanaka, W. Thormann, Electrophoresis, 11, 760-764 (1990). [5.87] L. R. Gurley, J. E. London, J. G . Valdez, J. Chromatogr., 559,431-433 (1991). [5.88] W. Nashabeh, Z. E. Rasi, J. Chrornatogr., 559, 367-383 (1991). [5.89] S. Mayer, V. Schurig, J. High Resolut. Chromatogr., 14, 129-131 (1992). [5.90] J. T. Smith, Z. E. Rassi, J. High Resolut. Chrornatogr., 15, 573-578 (1992). [5.91] J. K. Towns, J. Bao, F. E. Regnier, J . Chromatogr., 599, 227-237 (1992). [5.92] W. D. Pfeffer, E. S. Yeung, Anal. Chem, 62, 2178-2182 (1990). [5.93] V. Pretorius, B. J. Hopkins, J. D . Schieke, J. Chrornatogr., 99,23-30. (1974) [5.94] A. W. Adamson, Physical Chemistry of Surfaces, New York, Wiley-Interscience, 1976,3rd ed., chap. 4. [5.95] J. H. Knox, I. H. Grant, Chromatographia, 24, 135-143 (1987). [5.96] D. L. Mould, R. L. M. Synge, Analyst (London), 77, 964 (1952). [5.97] D. L. Mould, R. L. M., Biochem. J., 58,571-585 (1954). [5.98] W. D . Pfeffer, E. S. Yeung, J . Chromatogr., 557, 125-136 (1991). [5.99] T. S. Stevens, H. J. Cortes, Anal. Chem. 55, 1365-1370 (1983). [5.100] T. Tsuda, K. Nomura, G . Nakagawa, J . Chromatogr. 248,241-247 (1982). [5.101] N. Tanka, H. Kinishita, M. Araki, T, Tsuda, J. Chromatogr., 332, 57-69 (1985). [5.102] J. H. Knox, I. H. Grant, Chromatographia, 32, 317-328 (1991). [5.103] H. Yamamoto, J. Baumann, F. Erni, J. Chromatogr., 593,313-319 (1992). [5.104] T. Tsuda, Anal. Chem., 59, 521-523 (1987). [5.105] T. Tsuda, Anal. Chem., 60, 1677-1680 (1988). [5.106] T. Tsuda, Y. Muramatsu, J. Chromatogr., 515, 645-652 (1990). [5.107] H. Soini, T. Tsuda, V. Novotny, J. Chromatogr., 559, 547-558 (1991). [5.108] S. Terabe et al., Anal. Chem., 56, 111-113 (1984). [5.109] S. Terabe, K. Otsuka, T. Ando, Anal. Chem., 57, 834-841 (1985). [5.110] H. Nishi, N. Tsumagari, T. Kakinoto, S. Terabe, J . Chromatogr., 465, 331-343. [5.111] K. Kleparnik, F? Bocek, J. Chromatogr., 569, 3-42 (1991). [5.112] S. Michaelsen, P. Moller, H. Sorensen, J. Chromatogr., 608, 363-374 (1992). [5.113] A. S. Cohen, S. Terabe, J. A. Smith, B. L., Karger, Anal. Chem. 59, 1021-1027 (1987). [5.114] R. Weinberg, I. S . Lurie, Anal. Chem., 63, 823-827 (1991). I5.1151 S. H. Swedberg, J. Chromatogr., 503, 449-452 (1990). [5.116] W. Nashabeh, Z . E. Rassi, J . High Resolut. Chromatogr., 15, 289-292 (1992). [5.117] E. R. Verheij, U. R. W. M. A . Niessen, J . Chromatogr., 554, 339-349 (1991).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
6
Electromatography for Focusing, Counter-Current , Mass Spectrometry, and Two-Dimensional Separation Takao Tsuda
6.1
Continuous In-Column Sample Focusing
Electrochromatography uses two processes in the development of a sample in the column. If we can adequately control these two processes, we can achieve in-column focusing. A solute will remain in the column when the velocity due to mobility, V,,,&, is larger than the flow velocity due to pressurized flow, vpres, and the two flows are in opposite directions. Figure2.4 in Chapter2 illustrates one condition in which a solute will be retained in the column. In this instance, the diffusion coefficient of the solute in the mobile phase is assumed zero for simplicity, X,, is the point of injection and the region X > 0 corresponds to the column; for X < 0 is necessary to work out the retarded solute at the column inlet. At time to the solute is introduced as a plug. The sample remaines in the column under the condition 2 vpresC - V,b because the highest laminar flow velocity is twice the mean linear-flow velocity. For any chromatographic process, there is a diffusion coefficient, and a narrow zone is always formed. Here, the center of the zone occurs equal to vpres.Therefore, most of the sample remains under the condition vpres< - y,,,&, if vpresis slow enough to produce a sharp distribution of the sample zone.
6.1.1
Multiple Injection for Accumulating a Charged Component in the Column
A typical example is shown in Figure6.1, where N 1 , N,, and N3 are a series of experiments [6.1]. Experiment N , involved an applied voltage; the chromatogram shows three minor peaks. After several injections with the voltage applied, the voltage was switched off (N, at time to) and a chromatogram was immediately obtained. After a large peak was eluted, the baseline became straight and chromatogram N3 was obtained for injection with no applied voltage. The N-methylphenylpyridinium perchlorate peak was eluted only when no voltage was applied. Under the applied voltage, only minor components in the sample of N-methylphenylpyridinium perchlorate were eluted. During injections with the applied voltage, the main peak of Nmethylphenylpyridinium perchlorate remained in the column. After the voltage was removed, it emerged, it emerged as a large peak, N z . The reverse phenomenon was also observed: after application of a voltage to the column, several peaks were eluted without any injection. These peaks may be from