NAN0 AND MICROSTRUCTURAL DESIGN OF ADVANCED MATERIALS A Commemorative Volume on Professor G. Thomas’ Seventieth Birthday
Elsevier Internet Homepage: http://www.elsevier.com ScienceDirect Homepage: http://www.sciencedirect.com
To contact the Publisher Elsevier welcomes enquiries concerning publishing proposals: book, journal special issues, conference proceedings, etc. All formats and media can be considered. Should you have a publishing proposal you wish to discuss, please contact, without obligation, the publisher responsible for Elsevier’s material science programme: David Sleeman Publishing Editor Elsevier Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 lGB, UK
Phone: +44 1865 843265 Fax: +44 1865 843920 E.mai1:
[email protected]
General enquiries, including placing orders, should be directed to Elsevier’s Regional Sales Offices - please access the Elsevier homepage for full contact details (homepage details at the top of this page).
NAN0 AND MICROSTRUCTURAL DESIGN OF ADVANCED MATERIALS A Commemorative Volume on Professor G. Thomas’ Seventieth Birthday Edited by M.A. MEYERS University of California, San Diego, USA R.O. RITCHIE University of California, Berkeley, USA and M. SARIKAYA University of Washington, USA
2003 ELSEVIER Amsterdam - Boston - Heidelberg - London - New York - Oxford Paris - San Diego - San Francisco - Singapore - Sydney - Tokyo
ELSEVIER Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 lGB, UK
02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier, and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all f o r m of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone: (+44) 1865 843830, fax: (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. You may also complete your request on-line via the Elsevier Science homepage (http://www.elsevier.com), by selecting ‘Customer Support’ and then ‘Obtaining Permissions’. In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) (978) 7508400, fax: (+1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P OLP, UK; phone: (+44) 207 631 5555; fax: (+44) 207 631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of Elsevier Science is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier’s Science &Technology Rights Department, at the phone, fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made. First edition 2003 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record from the Library of Congress has been applied for. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record from the British Library has been applied for ISBN:
0-08-044373-7
@ The paper used in this publication meets the requirements of ANSUNIS0 239.48-1992 (Permanence of Paper). Printed in The Netherlands.
Preface The importance of the nanoscale effects has been recognized in materials research for over fifty years. The understanding and control of the nanostructure has been, to a large extent, made possible by new atomistic analysis and characterization methods. Transmission electron microscopy revolutionized the investigation of materials. This volume focuses on the effective use of advanced analysis and characterization methods for the design of materials. The nanostructural and microstructural design for a set of targeted mechanicaVfunctiona1properties has become a recognized field in Materials Science and Engineering. This book contains a series of authoritative and up-to-date articles by a group of experts and leaders in this field. It is based on a three-day symposium held at the joint TMS-ASM meeting in Columbus, Ohio. The book is comprised of three parts: Characterization, Functional Materials, and Structural Materials. The book is dedicated to Gareth Thomas who has pioneered this approach to materials science and engineering area over a wide range of materials problems and applications. Professor Thomas’ lifetime in research has been devoted to understanding the fundamentals of structure-property relations in materials for which he has also pioneered the development and applications of electron microscopy and microanalysis. He established the first laboratory for high voltage electron microscopy, at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. His research has contributed to the development and nano/microstructural tailoring of materials from steels and aluminum alloys, to high temperature and functional ceramics and magnetic materials, for specific property performances, and has resulted in a dozen patents. Professor Thomas is a pioneer and world leader in the applications of electron microscopy to materials in general. Following his Ph.D. at Cambridge in 1955, as an ICI Fellow, he resolved the problem of intergranular embrittlement in the AVZn/Mg high strength alloys which failed in the three Comet aircraft crashes and became identified with Prof. Jack Nutting as the “PFZ’ -precipitate-free-zones, condition, now in wide general use to describe grainboundary morphologies leading to intergranular corrosion and mechanical failure. This work prompted Dr. Kent van Horne of Alcoa to invite him to spend the summer of 1959 in their research labs at New Kensington, Pa. From there and after a trans-USA lecture tour he was invited in 1960 to join the Berkeley faculty, (becoming a full professor in 1966), where he started a major research program within the newly formed “Inorganic Materials Research Division” of the (now) Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. It was there, after nine years’ effort, that he founded the National Center for Electron Microscopy, which opened in 1982 and which he directed until he resigned in 1993, to spend 1.5 years helping establish the University of Science & Technology in Hong Kong. There he also set up and directed the Technology Transfer Centre. He returned to Berkeley in 1994 to continue teaching and research, and in his career has over 100 graduates. With his students and colleagues he has over 500 publications, several books, including the first text on Electron Microscopy ofMetals (1962), and in 1979 -with M.J. Goringe, a widely used referenced text- Transmission Electron Microscopy of Materials which was also translated into Russian and Chinese. His academic career in Berkeley has included administrative services as Associate Dean, Graduate Division, Assistant and Acting Vice-Chancellor-Academic Affairs, in the turbulent years of student unrest (1966-72). He was the Chair faculty of the College of Engineering (1972/73), and Senior Faculty Scientist, LBNL-DOE, which sponsored most of his research V
Vi
Preface
funding. In 1995 he received the Berkeley Citation for “Distinguished Achievement” at UC Berkeley. Professor Thomas was Associate Director, Institute for Mechanics and Materials, UC San Diego, from 1993 to 1996. In this capacity, he formulated new research directions and stimulated research at the interface of Mechanics and Materials. He is currently Professor in the Graduate School, UC Berkeley, Professor-on-Recall, UC San Diego, and VP R&D of a new company, MMFX Technologies, founded in 1999, to utilize steels for improved corrosion resistant concrete reinforcement. In the USA the infrastructure repair costs are in the trillion dollar range. In 2002 the company received the Pankow award (American Inst. of Civil Engineers) for innovation in Engineering, based on Prof. Thomas’ patents on nano microcomposite steels. Professor Thomas has also played an important role in promoting the profession. He was president of the Electron Microscopy Society of the US in 1974, and in 1974 he became Secretary General of the International Societies for Electron Microscopy for an unprecedented 12 years, and was president in 1986-90. He lectured extensively in foreign countries and helped promote microscopy and materials in developing countries, also serving as advisor in China, Taiwan, Korea, Singapore, Poland, Mexico, et al. He also served on many committees of the ASM and TMS, and the National Research Council. After reorganizing the editorial structure of Acta and Scripta Metallurgica (now Materialia), when in 1995 he took over as Editor-in-chief, he became Technical Director, Acta Mat. Inc. 1998 until April 2002. He was Chairman of the Board in 1982/84. In recognition of his many achievements, Professor Thomas has received numerous honors and awards, including, besides his Sc.D.-Cambridge University in 1969: Honorary Doctorates from Lehigh (1996) and Krakow (1999); The Acta Materialia Gold Medal (2003), The ASM Gold Medal (200 l), Sauveur Achievement Award (ASM- 199l), Honorary Professor, Beijing University of Sci. & Technology (1958), Honorary Memberships in Foreign Materials societies (Japan, Korea, India, etc.), E.O. Lawrence Award (US Dept. of Energy-l978), Rosenhain Medal (The Metals Soc-UK-1977), Guggenheim Fellow (1972), von Humboldt Senior Scientist awards (1996 & 1981), the I-R Award (R&D Magazine-1987), Sorby Award, (IMS- 1987) and the Distinguished Scientist Award (EMSA-1980). He received the Bradley Stoughton Teaching Award (ASM) in 1956, and the Grossman (ASM), and Curtis-Mcgraw (ASEE) research awards in 1966. He is a Fellow of numerous scientific societies. In recognition of these achievements, Professor Thomas was elected to both the National Academy of Sciences (1983) and the National Academy of Engineering (1982). Professor Thomas, born in South Wales, UK, is also a former rugby and cricket player (member, MCC), enjoys skiing and grand opera. The editors thank the speakers at the symposium and the authors of the scholarly contributions presented in this volume. A special gratitude is expressed to Prof. S. Suresh for having enabled the publication of this volume by Elsevier. All royalties from the sale of this book are being donated to the TMS/AIME and ASM societies for the establishment of an award recognizing excellence in Mechanical Behavior of Materials. November, 2003
Curriculum Vitae of Professor Thomas
Date and Place of Birth: 9 August 1932, Maesteg, Glamorgan, U.K. Academic Qualifications B.Sc. with First Class Honors in Metallurgy, University of Wales (Cardiff), 1952. Ph.D. University of Cambridge, 1955; Sc.D. University of Cambridge, 1969.
Career Details 1956-59 ICI and St. Catharine’s College Fellow, University of Cambridge 1960 Visiting Assistant Professor, University of California, Berkeley 1961-Present University of California, Berkeley: Full Professor (1966); Associate Dean, Graduate Division (1968-69); Assistant to the Chancellor (1969-72); Acting Vice Chancellor, Academic Affairs (1971-72); Chairman, Faculty of the College of Engineering (1972-73); Senior Faculty Scientist, Materials Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory; Founder and Scientific Director, National Center for Electron Microscopy, Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory (198 1-93); on special leave as Director, Technology Transfer Centre, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Kowloon, Hong Kong (1993-94); Professor in the Graduate School, University of California, Berkeley (1995-present).
Awards and Honors 2003 2003 200 1
Silver Medal in honor of Prof. C. S. Barrett, ASM Intl. Rocky Mountain Chapter Acta Materialia Gold Medal First Albany Int. Distinguished Lecture in Mat. Sci. & Eng. (RPI). Vii
Curriculum vitae of Professor Thomas
Viii
200 1 1999 1998 1996 1996 1996 1996 1995 1994 1994 1991 1987 1987 1987
1985 1983 1983 1982 1981 1980 1979 1978 1977 1976 1976 1973 1971-72 1966 1966 1965 1964 1953
American Society for Materials International, Gold Medallist Doctorate honoris causa, University of Krakbw, Poland Honorary Member, Japan Institute of Materials Honorary D.Sc., Lehigh University, Bethlehem, PA, USA, 1996 Honorary Member, Indian Institute of Metals Honorary Member, Korean Institute of Metals and Materials Alexander von Humboldt Senior Scientist Award, IFW, Dresden, Germany The Berkeley Citation for Distinguished Achievement, U. C. Berkeley Honorary Member, Mat. Res. SOC.of India Medal of Academy of Mining and Metallurgy, Polish Acad. of Sciences, Krakow Albert Sauveur Achievement Award (ASM International) I-R 100 Award, Research and Development Magazine Elected, Fellow, Univ. Wales, Cardiff, UK Henry Clifton Sorby Award, International Metallographic Society Honorary Professorship-Beijing University of Science & Technology Confucius Memorial Teaching Award, Republic of China (Taiwan) Elected to the National Academy of Sciences, U.S.A. Elected to the National Academy of Engineering, U.S.A. Alexander von Humboldt Senior Scientist Award, Max Planck Institute, Stuttgart EMSA Distinguished Scientist Award for Physical Sciences Fellow, Metallurgical Society of AIME Ernest 0. Lawrence Award (US. Department of Energy) The Rosenhain Medal (The Metals Society, U.K.) Fellow, Royal Microscopical Society, U.K. Fellow, American Society for Metals Visiting Professor at Nagoya University, Japan Society for Promotion of Science Guggenheim Fellow; Visiting Fellow, Clare Hall, Cambridge University Curtis-McGraw Research Award (American Society for Engineering Education) Grossman Publication Award (American Society for Metals) for paper “Structure and Strength of Ausformed Steels”, Trans. ASM, 58,563 (1965) Bradley Stoughton Teaching Award, American Society for Metals Miller Research Professor, UC Berkeley National Undergraduate Student Prize, Institute of Metals (London)
Professional Activities 19981995-98 1992 1991-95 1986-90 1974-86 1991-94 1987-88 1982-85
1985-90
Managing Director, Acta Metallurgica, Inc. Board of Governors Editor in Chief, Acta Materialia and Scripta Materialia Founder Member, Editorial Board, NanoStructured Materials (Elsevier) Vice President, International Federation of Societies for Electron Microscopy President, International Federation of Societies for Electron Microscopy Secretary General, International Federation of Societies for Electron Microscopy Reappointed, Member, Board of Governors Acta Metallurgica, Inc. Member, US Department of Energy E. 0.Lawrence Award Selection Committee Chairman, Acta Metallurgica, Inc. Board of Governors Member, Acta Metallnrgica, Inc. Board of Governors
Curriculum vitae of Professor Thomas
ix
1978-8 1 1975 1972-73 1961-present
TMS-AIME Board of Directors President, Electron Microscopy Society of America UC Convenio Program Visiting Professor, University of Chile, Santiago, Chile Served on many national and international committees including National Research Council (USA), International Federation of Electron Microscopy Societies, EMSA, ASM, TMS, University of California, editorial boards, etc. Served on science and technology boards (Taiwan, Singapore, Korea, South Africa and Mexico) as materials advisor. Publications Over 550 papers, 2 books, numerous book chapters. Selected Publications 1. “Structure-Property Relations: Impact on Electron Microscopy,” in Mechanics and Materials: Fundamentals and Linkages, Marc A. Meyers, Ronald W. Armstrong and Helmut Kirchner, eds. New York: J. Wiley & Sons, 1999, pp. 99-121; LBNL 40317. 2. “Nd Rich Nd-Fe-B Tailored for Maximum Coercivity,” Er. Girt, Kannan M. Krishnan, G. Thomas, C. J. Echer and Z. Altounian, Mat. Res. SOC.Symp. Proc. 577, Michael Coey etal., eds. Warrendale, PA: The Materials Research Society, 1999, pp. 247-252. 3. “Some Relaxation Processes in Nanostructures and Diffusion Gradients in Functional Materials,” G. Thomas, in Deformation-Induced Microstructures: Analysis and Relation to Properties (Proc. 20th Ris# International Symposium on Mat. Sci.,), J. B. Bilde-S#rensen, J. V. Carstensen, N. Hansen, D. Juul Jensen, T. Leffers, W. Pantleon, 0. B. Pedersen and G. Winther, eds., Ris# National Laboratory, Roskilde, Denmark, 1999, pp. 505-521. 4. “Origin of Giant Magnetoresistance in Conventional AlNiCo, Magnets,” A. Hiitten, G. Reiss, W. Saikaly and G. Thomas,Actu Muteriuliu 49, 827-835 (2001). 5. “Novel Joining of Dissimilar Ceramics in the Si3N4-Al2O3 System Using Polytypoid Functional Gradients,” Caroline S. Lee, Xiao Feng Zhang and Gareth Thomas, Acta Materialia vo1.49,3767-3773, & 3775-3780 (2001). See web-site (below) for more details: Internet: http://www.mse.berkeley.edu/faculty/thomas/thomas.html Patents Process for Improving Stress-Corrosion Resistance of Age-Hardenable Alloys, U.S. Patent 3,133,839 (1964). High Strength, High Ductility Low Carbon Steel (J. Koo and G. Thomas), U.S. Patent 4,067,756 (1978). High Strength, Tough Alloy Steels (G. Thomas andB. V. N. Rao), U.S. Patent4,170,497 (1979). Method of Making High Strength, Tough Alloy Steels (G. Thomas and B. V. N. Rao), U.S. Patent 4,170,499 (1979). High Strength, Low Carbon, Dual Phase Steel Rods and Wires and Process for Making Same (G. Thomas and A. Nakagawa). U.S. Patent 4,613,385 (1986).
X
Curriculum vitae of Professor Thomas
Controlled Rolling Process for Dual Phase Steels and Applications to Rod, Wire, Sheet and Other Shapes (G. Thomas, J. H. Ahn, and N. J. Kim), U.S. Patent 4,619,714 (1986). Method of Forming High-Strength, Corrosion-Resistant Steel (G. Thomas, N. J. Kim, and R. Ramesh), U.S. Patent 4,671,827 (1987). Method of Producing a Dense Refractory Silicon Nitride (Si3N4) Compact with One or More Crystalline Intergranular Phases (G. Thomas, S. M. Johnson, and T. R. Dinger), U.S. Patent 4,830,800 (1989). High Energy Product Permanent Magnet Having Improved Intrinsic Coercivity and Method of Making Same (R. Ramesh and G. Thomas), U.S. Patent 4,968,347 (1990). Giant Magnetoresistive Heterogeneous Alloys and Method of Making Same (J. J. Bernardi, G. Thomas, and A. R. Huetten), U S . Patents 5,824,165 (1998) and 5,882,436 (1999).
Table of Contents
Preface
V
vii
Curriculum Vitae of Professor Thomas
Part 1: Characterization 3
Characterization: The Key to Materials
R. Gronsky
Nanochemical and Nanostructural Studies of the Brittle Failure of Alloys D.B. Williams,M. Watanabe, C. Li and V.J. Keast
11
Transmission Electron Microscopy Study of the Early-Stage Precipitates in Al-Mg-Si Alloys H.W. Zandbergen, J.H. Chen, C.D. Marioara and E. Olariu
23
Laser Surface Alloying of Carbon Steels with Tantalum, Silicon and Chromium J. Kusinski and A. Woldan
35
In-Situ TEM Observation of Alloying Process in Isolated Nanometer-Sized Particles H. Mori, J.-G. Lee and H. Yasuda
49
Characterization of MetaVGlass Interfaces in Bioactive Glass Coatings on Ti-6A1-4V and Co-Cr Alloys E. Saiz, S. Lopez-Esteban, S. Fujino, T. Oku, K. Suganuma and A.P. Tomsia
61
Development of Advanced Materials by Aqueous Metal Injection Molding S.K. Das, J.C. LaSulle, J.M. Goldenberg and J. Lu
69
Part 2: Functional Materials Microstructural Design of Nanomultilayers (From Steel to Magnetics) G.J. Kusinski and G. Thomas Effects of Topography on the Magnetic Properties of Nano-Structured Films Investigated with Lorentz Transmission Electron Microscopy J.Th.M. De Hosson and N.G. Chechenin
81
93
Slip Induced Stress Amplification in Thin Ligaments
109
Materials, Structures and Applications of Some Advanced MEMS Devices Sungho Jin
117
X. Markenscogand V.A.Lubarda
xi
xii
Table of contents
Microstructure-Property Evolution in Cold-Worked Equiatomic Fe-Pd During Isothermal Annealing a t 500 O A. Deshpande, A. Al-Ghaferi, H. Xu, H. Heinrich and J.M.K. Wiezorek
Part 3: Structural Materials Microstructure and Properties of In Situ Toughened Silicon Carbide L.C. De Jonghe, R.O. Ritchie and X.F. Zhang Microstructure Design of Advanced Materials Through Microelement Models: WC-Co Cermets and Their Novel Architectures K.S. Ravi Chandran and Z. Zak Fang
145
157
The Ideal Strength of Iron D.M. Clatterbuck, D.C. Chrzan and J. W.Morris Jr.
173
Microstructure-Property Relationships of Nanostructured Al-Fe-Cr-Ti Alloys L. Shaw, H. Luo, J. Villegas and D. Miracle
191
Microstructural Dependence of Mechanical Properties in Bulk Metallic Glasses and Their Composites U. Ramamurty, R. Raghavan, J. Basu and S. Ranganathan
199
The Bottom-Up Approach to Materials by Design W.W. Gerberich, J.M. Jungk and W.M.Mook
21 1
The Onset of Twinning in Plastic Deformation and Martensitic Transformations M.A. Meyers, M.S. Schneider and 0. Voehringer
221
Crystal Imperfections Seen by X-Ray Diffraction Topography R.W.Armstrong
233
Synthetic Multi-Functional Materials by Design Using Metallic-Intermetallic Laminate (MIL) Composites K.S. Vecchio
243
Taylor Hardening in Five Power Law Creep of Metals and Class M Alloys M.E. Kassner and K. Kyle
255
Microstructural Design of 7x50 Aluminum Alloys for Fracture and Fatigue F.D.S. Marquis
273
Elastic Constants of Disordered Ternary Cubic Alloys C.S. Hartley
287
Index
299
PART 1: CHARACTERIZATION
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
CHARACTERIZATION: THE KEY TO MATERIALS R. Gronsky Department of Materials Science & Engineering, University of California Berkeley, California 94720-1760 USA
ABSTRACT His seventieth birthday offers this special occasion to recall the many seminal contributions made by Professor Gareth Thomas to the field of materials science and engineering. A brief reckoning of his career, his dedication to the development of electron microscopy techniques, his applications of high precision characterization methods to numerous engineering materials systems, and his successes as both researcher and educator are recounted here.
INTRODUCTION The development of advanced materials is guided by assessment at appropriate levels of resolution. This has always been the preferred protocol, and hallmark, of materials science and engineering. Our discipline seeks to understand all of the links connecting the synthesis and processing of materials with the evaluation of their properties, with their performance in engineering applications, and with their internal structure and composition. However, as modem engineering progresses towards increased complexity and reduced dimensionality, our discipline places ever higher demands on the diffraction, spectroscopy, and microscopy techniques used for microstructural analysis. There was a time when “pearlite” was an acceptable designation for a microstructural constituent associated with certain mechanical properties of steels. Thirty years ago, it became essential to know the composition of both the ferrite and the cementite in “pearlite,” including whether or not there were any gradients in carbon concentration at their contiguous interfaces. And as this manuscript is being written, hundreds of scientists around the world are struggling to sort out carbon nanotubes as single-walled or multi-walled, spiral or concentric, vacant or filled, with what species, at which specific locations. Consequently, the levels of resolution appropriate for contemporary materials science and engineering are those that reveal individual atomicpositions in the spatial domain, and individual atomic identities in the temporal or energy domain. It is now generally accepted that atomic level characterization is the essential key to materials, old and new. Today’s symposium highlights many of the triumphs of advanced materials development based upon this singular tenet of microstructural design, which has been championed by Professor Gareth Thomas throughout his long and illustrious career. It was just over thirty (30) years ago that I came to Berkeley to begin my graduate studies in Professor Thomas’s group, and I’m honored to offer this contribution in celebration of his seventieth (70th)birthday.
3
4
R. Gronslcy
BACKGROUND Gareth Thomas was born on August 9, 1932. He completed his Bachelor of Science degree with First Class Honors in Metallurgy from the University of Wales, Cardiff, in 1952. Three years later, in 1955, he obtained his Ph.D. from the University of Cambridge, where he stayed through 1959 as an ICUSt. Catherine’s College Fellow. In 1960 he arrived in Berkeley as a Visiting Assistant Professor and joined the ladder rank faculty as an Assistant Professor in 1961. During his first year on the faculty, when other assistant professors seeking tenure were buried in labs or libraries struggling to solidify their academic careers, Professor Thomas chose instead to organize an international conference. Securing a prime location on the Berkeley campus, he hosted “The Impact of Transmission Electron Microscopy on Theories of the Strength of Metals” in 1961, providing an aggressive examination of the Orowan and Petch equations as well as new insights into the mechanisms of strengthening by finely dispersed (TEM-sized) obstacles. Many of the luminaries in the fledgling field of transmission electron microscopy were there (Figure l), taking note of both the ambition and the dedication their colleague Gareth Thomas, who would continue this tradition of global congresses to advance the practice of electron microscopy in applications to engineering materials throughout his career.
Figure 1: A few of the attendees at the 1961 Berkeley conference on the “Impact of TEM on Theories of the Strength of Metals.” L to R first row, R.B. Nicholson, M.J. Whelan, G . Thomas, J. Washbum; L to R second row, K. Melton, A. Kelly, G. Rothman, P.R. Swann.
Also during his first year on the faculty, Professor Thomas found time to draft and edit a complete textbook, Transmission Electron Microscopy of Metals, published by Wiley only one year later, in 1962. This treatise was the first of its kind, a practical, pedagogical, “hands-on” treatment of the transmission electron microscopy technique, annotated with instructions on how to prepare representative samples worthy of scientific investigation. It served generations of students for the next 17 years, until his second edition, co-authored with M.J. Goringe, was released in 1979. Thomas’s early emphasis on high-resolution microstructural characterization of metals was born of his notable successes during his time at Cambridge. One of the most perplexing problems of the day was the catastrophic failure of the Comet aircraft, prompting many investigations into the relationship between the microstructure and deformation behavior of aluminum-based alloys. Thomas’s work [ 1,2] showed quite clearly (Figure 2) the occurrence of a precipitate-free zone (PFZ) adjacent to grain boundaries, and a coarser precipitate distribution adjacent to the PFZ, when compared to the surrounding matrix. Implicating such inhomogeneities in microstructure as the likely cause for inhomogeneities in mechanical response, the path forward was revealed through microstructural design. Subsequent development of thermomechanical processing cycles to eliminate the formation of PFZs and their attendant problems was facilitated by electron microscopy, the only technique with sufficient spatial resolution to verify success. Professor Thomas developed similar processing methodologies to protect age-hardening alloys against stresscorrosion cracking (Figure 3), resulting in his first patent [3], also issued within a few short years of his debut on the faculty.
5
Characterization: The key to materials
Figure 2: Heterogeneous precipitation and precipitate-free zones (PFZs) in AI-6Zn-3Mg, after reference [2].
BI
I
.s
n 3% r ; -
*li
Figure 3: Plot of average stress corrosion life (days) vs aging time (hours) for aluminum alloys subjected to step agmg process, after reference [3].
EARLY DEVELOPMENTS In his quest for precision during diffraction analysis, Professor Thomas became an early advocate for the technique of Kikuchi electron diffraction [4],which results from an inelastic scattering event that is subsequently elastically scattered. Thomas and co-workers released a series of publications in the 1960s explaining the method and demonstrating its superior advantages over conventional (spot) electron diffraction for precise determination of crystalline orientations. By painstakingly assembling photo collages combining hundreds of Kikuchi electron diffraction patterns, they also generated “Kikuchi maps” to assist investigators in navigating reciprocal space. Figure 4 shows one such map for the diamond cubic structure [ 5 ] , but others were published for both body-centered cubic [6] and hexagonal close-packed [7] structures. Diffraction also figured prominently in the analysis of spinodal decomposition, but there was no more convincing evidence of structural modulation that the images published by Thomas and co-workers [S], Figure 5(a). Coarsening of the spinodally-decomposed product resulted in a square wave compositional profile seen in Figure 5(b), which was much less obvious, and sometimes completely obscured, in diffraction results. Thomas was also first to point out that microstructures generated by spinodal decomposition were not
6
R. Gronslcy
susceptible to the formation of detrimental PFZs, and he proposed employing spinodal decomposition where possible in alloy systems with known miscibility gaps as another method of intelligent microstructural design.
Figure 4. Kikuchi map of the diamond-cubic structure (silicon) after reference [ 5 ] The top pole is readily identified by its four-fold symmetry as 001, the bottom center pole is 113, representing an angular range of 25 2” East-west extremes are 102 and 012 poles, at 36 9” apart
Figure 5 : Spinodally decomposed Cu-Ni-Fe alloy showing (a) early stage and (b) later stage product resulting from aging within the temary miscibility gap. The light phase i s Cu rich, the dark phase, Ni-Fe rich.
Yet another method of microstructural analysis pioneered about this time was the application of phase contrast ‘‘lattice’’ imaging to directly assess the local lattice parameter in close-packed metallic alloys. The resolution performance of transmission electron microscopes was limited thirty years ago to approximately 0.25 nm, consequently a two-beam “sideband imaging method was the only feasible option for extracting phase contrast, generating images of a single spatial frequency. Figure 6 shows how the technique yielded the modulation wavelength in a spinodally decomposed Au-Ni alloy, the first such demonsbation of its type. Thomas and co-workers continued to apply lattice imaging to a range of spinodal and ordered alloys during the late 1970s, coupled to the development of subsidiary analytical techniques such as optical microdiffraction [9]. As specimen preparation procedures for non-metallic materials also improved in Thomas’s laboratories, phase contrast methods yielded new insights into novel polytypoid formation in the non-oxide ceramics. The example shown in Figure 7 documents the substructure of a beryllium silicon nitride, BesSi3Nl0, as alternating stacking sequences of three layers of BeSiN2 followed by two layers of Be3N2.
I
Characterization: The key to materials
24t
12
0
30
60 I
90
*
120 i
20 40 60 DISTANCE (NO OF FRINGES)
Figure 6 Lattice image (top) and plot of d-spacing vs distance in a spinodally-decomposed Au-Ni alloy The “average” modulation wavelength IS 2.9 nm, after reference [9].
INNOVATIONS These successes with a growing number of applications of electron microscopy in materials engineering were clearly noticed by the scientific community at large. Consequently Professor Thomas chose to convene another gathering of participants in 1976 for the purpose of addressing what had become a burning question for him and many others: “Should the US support a National Center for Electron Microscopy?’ The question originated in the understanding that electron microscopy had taken on the earmarks of “big” science, requiring multi-million dollar investments in order to construct, maintain, and run the high voltage electron microscopes that exhibited superior performance at the time. Attendees included eighteen (18) from Berkeley, forty-one (41) from elsewhere in the US, and seven (7) from abroad, and at the end of the workshop, all concurred that the time was right to seek a national, shareable, user resource in the model of the photon beam lines and es that had recently been funded by the federal government. The original estimate for this facility was a modest $5M. In rapid succession, the Energy Research and Development Administration (later DOE) held two national Materials Sciences Overview meetings, the proceedings of which were published as ERDA 77-76-1 and ERDA 77-76-2 . In these reports, the Office of Basic Energy Sciences identified a “critical need” for state-of-the-art fa in transmission electron microscopy. Thomas and collaborators submitted their proposal that year, and the Atomic Resolution Microscope (ARM) became a line item in the FY 1980 Congressional Budget at $4.3M [ I l l . The ARM was installed in 1982 and sustained the best imaging
8
R. Gronsky
performance of any transmission electron microscope in the world for the next decade. With a top operating voltage of 1 MeV, a biaxial tilt stage of*45’ range, and an instrumental resolution limit of 0.16 nm, it’s utility extended to many new materials engineering problems requinng microstructural assessment at the atomic level. Moreover, the technological innovations funded by the federal government dunng this project spawned a new generation of “medium voltage” instruments with enhanced performarxe and smaller footpnnt, so they could be placed in a “normal” laboratory setting, instead of the three-story silo architecture needed by the larger megavolt units.
Figure 7: Phase contrast image of Be9Si3NIo(left) and structural model (right) showing three layers of BeSiNl interspersed with two layers of Be,N2, after [lo].
One of the most widely publicized images from the ARM is shown in Figure 8, showing the atomic structure of the double-layer defect in the high Tc superconductor, YBCO.
Figure 8: Phase contrast image of YBa2Cu3O,.* (left) and structural model (right) showing double layer CuO defect running horizontally through center of micrograph, after [ 1 I]. Only cations are visible.
It is instructive to compare Figures 7 and 8 for their historical significance since they represent best practice in
“contemporary” transmission electron microscopy, published in the world’s premiere scientific journals, one decade apart. The legacy of innovation that has distinguished Professor Gareth Thomas’s career is clearly revealed in these images.
Characterization: The key to materials
9
LEGACY But Professor Thomas’s legacy extends well beyond his contributions to the field of electron microscopy. His innovations in the development of novel materials and processing procedures have resulted in a dozen patents. The first, described above, was issued for a process to enhance resistance to stress corrosion cracking in A1 alloys. Six more patents cover his development of new steels, some high-strength, some dual phase [14], and some corrosion-resistant. Another patent was granted for a method to produce dense refractory ceramics [15]. And his four most recent patents are for magnetic materials, to enhance intrinsic coercivity and to enhance their giant magnetoresistive (GMR) response [16]. Professor Thomas’s contributions to the scientific literature number over five hundred (500) and counting. Even more impressive than this number is the range of topics on which he’s written. Metals and alloys, ceramics, semiconductors, superconductors, magnetic materials, composite materials, polymeric materials, and even organic materials appear in his manuscripts, along with a widely varied range of electron microscopy, diffraction, and spectrometry methodologies used for their characterization. One of very few individuals to have been elected to membership in both the National Academy of Engineering (1982) and the National Academy of Sciences (1983), Professor Thomas’s recent awards include the Gold Medal from ASM International (2001), a Doctorate Honoris Causa from the University of Krakow, Poland (1999), election as an Honorary Member of the Japan Institute of Metals (1998), an Honorary D.Sc. from Lehigh University (1996), election as an Honorary Member of the Indian Institute of Metals (1996), election as an Honorary Member of the Korean Institute of Metals and Materials (1996), a Humboldt Senior Scientist Award (1996), and the highest award given by his home campus, the Berkeley Citation for Distinguished Achievement (1995). Professor Thomas’s dossier of service is equally rich. He devoted four years as Editor in Chief of Acta Materialia and Scripta Materialia, currently continuing as a Technical Director (1998-), another four years as President of the International Federation of Societies of Electron Microscopy, four years as a Member of the Board of Governors of Acta Metallurgica, Inc., another four years as Chairman of the Acta Metallurgical, Inc., Board of Governors, and four more years as a member of the TMS-AIME Board of Directors, among other appointments of lesser duration, such as his one year (1993) term as Director of the technology Transfer Center at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, and one year (1975) reign as President of the Electron Microscopy Society of America. As he engages his seventy-first year, Professor Thomas is enjoying his honorable emeritus status on the faculty after having supervised more than one hundred (100) students through the pursuit of their graduate degrees. He has taught thousands more, undergraduate, graduate, and post graduate, in lectures and seminars at home and abroad. But, as expected, Gareth Thomas is not “retired.” He currently holds the position of Vice President of Research and Development for MMFX Steel Corporation of America, returning to one of his favorite metallurgical pastimes: enhancing the performance of steel. In an aggressive campaign to extend the lifetime of rebar used in concrete construction, Thomas has claimed another success through clever microstructural design. By replacing the ferrite/carbide microstructure common to low carbon rebar-stock steels with a “dualphase” microstructure (ferrite/martensite, or austenite/martensite) through simple adjustments in processing, an astoundingly superior corrosion resistance has been demonstrated, with high payoff potential for applications in marine environments. There can be little doubt that Professor Thomas’s legacy will continue to live on through these and other advances made by materials characterization in the Thomas tradition.
R. Gronsky
10
SUMMARY
Accomplished in science, accomplished in engineering, and accomplished in academia, Gareth Thomas has certainly made his mark on the historical record. It is also clear that he leaves all of us a timeless message. It first appeared in the preface to his textbook Transmission Electron Microscopy of Metals, dated 1961. “Over the last twenty-five years electron microscopy has become an increasingly popular technique for examining materials. ...The tremendous advantage of the transmission technique is, of course, that the results obtained are visual and therefore convincing.” Over the intervening forty-one years, the message has remained the same. Advancing the state of the art demands results that are both visual and convincing. Making the case for new and improved materials requires evidence that is both visual and convincing. And, as he continues to demonstrate so effectively, the execution of his successful brand of microstructural design is stunningly visual and convincing. Happy birthday to very visual and convincing guy! ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I shall always be grateful to Gareth Thomas for accepting me into his group during the early summer of 1972. Thanks to my colleagues Prof. M.A. Meyers, Prof. R.O. Ritchie, and Prof. M. Sarikaya for their kind invitation to contribute to this commemorative volume. Thanks also to the stalwart program managers at OBES in DOE and ERDA before them who recognized the wisdom of microstructural design and funded this nation’s effort in electron microscopy through all of these years. REFERENCES
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
Thomas, G., and Nutting, J. (1959-60) J. Inst. Metals 88, 81. Nicholson, R.B., Thomas, G., andNutting, J. (1960) ActaMet. 8, 172. Thomas, G. (1964) “Process for Improving Strength and Corrosion Resistance of Aluminum Alloys,” U.S. Patent # 3,133,839. Kikuchi, S. (1928) Jupnn J. Phys. 5, 83. Levine, E., Bell, W.L., and Thomas, G. (1966) J. Appl. Phys. 37,2141. Okamoto, P.R., Levine, E., andThomas, G. (1967)J. Appl. Phys. 38,289. Okamoto, P.R., and Thomas, G. (1968) Phys. Stat. Sol. 25, 81. Butler, E.P., and Thomas, G. (1970) Acta Met. 18, 347. Sinclair, R., Gronsky, R., and Thomas, G. (1976) AcfuMet. 24,789. Shaw, T.M., and Thomas, G. (1978) Science 202,625. Gronsky, R., (1980) in 38th Annual Proc. Electron Microscopy SOC.Amer., G.W. Bailey (ed.), p 2. Gronsky, R., and Thomas, G. (1983) in 41st Annual Proc. Electron Microscopy SOC.Amer., G.W. Bailey (ed.), p. 310. Zandbergen, H., Wang, K., Gronsky, R., and Thomas, G. (1988) Nature 331,596. Thomas, G., and Nakagawa, A. (1 986) “High Strength, Low Carbon, Dual Phase Steel Rods and Wires and Process for Making Same,” U S . Patent # 4,613,385. Thomas, G., Johnson, S.M., and Dinger, T.R. (1989) “Method of Producing a Dense Refractory Silicon Nitride Compact with One or More Crystalline Intergranular Phases,” U.S. Patent # 4,830,800. Bemardi, J.J., Thomas, G., and Heutten, A.R. (1999) “Giant Magnetoresistive Heterogeneous Alloys and Method of Making Same.” U.S. Patent # 5,882,436.
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
NANOCHEMICAL AND NANOSTRUCTURAL STUDIES OF THE BRITTLE FAILURE OF ALLOYS D.B. Williams’,M. Watanabe!, C. Li’ and V.J. Keast’ ‘Department of Materials Science and Engineering and The Materials Research Center, Lehigh University, Bethlehem PA 18015, USA ’Australian Key Centre for Microscopy and Microanalysis, Madsen Building University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
ABSTRACT Controlling the brittle intergranular failure of metals and alloys requires understanding the structure and chemistry of grain boundaries at the nanometer level or below. Recent developments in the analytical electron microscope (AEM) permit such studies. It is now feasible to determine, in a single AEM specimen, the grain boundary chemistry (using X-ray mapping), crystallographic characteristics (using automated crystallographic analysis) and the localized bonding changes that may accompany segregation (using fine structure changes in the electron energy loss spectrum). Computerized mapping techniques permit such information to be gained from dozens of grain boundaries. Integration of this knowledge may permit the design of new alloys and new heat treatments to create materials inherently resistant to the brittle failure often caused by nanometer level grain boundary segregation of impurities and alloying elements.
INTRODUCTION Gareth Thomas is primarily responsible for the development of the transmission electron microscope (TEM) as the most versatile and integrated technique for the solution of materials problems. Throughout his long and distinguished career Gareth has always stressed the essential need to use the TEM as one of a range of techniques to solve the problem at hand, rather than selecting a problem simply to suit the TEM’s capabilities. Nevertheless, he has also pushed the development of the TEM to its fullest capabilities, particularly in the exploration of its high-resolution imaging limits, embodied in the Atomic Resolution Microscope at the National Center for Electron Microscopy at Berkeley. At Lehigh, we have taken a similar approach to attacking materials problems, but emphasized the analytical side of the TEM, particularly elemental analysis via X-ray and electron spectroscopy. So we can perhaps talk about “Microchemical Design of Advanced Materials” in this article, in line with the theme of this book. This paper will review our implementation of Gareth’s philosophy to the long-standingissue of brittle failure. Brittle failure of metals and alloys remains a serious limitation to the development of new technologies and the improvement of existing ones. The record of brittle failure studies starts in the 19‘h century [ l ] and has encompassed classic examples such as the Titanic’s rivets [2], the Boston Molasses Tank [3], the SS Schenectady Liberty Ship [4], the Hinckley Point power-generation turbine [5] and the United Airlines DClO
11
D.B. Williamset al.
12
crash at Sioux City [6] Despite such a long and painful history, the problem of bnttle failure remains as current as ever in its societal effects For example, during 2001, the space shuttle fleet was grounded twice, first by the discovery of cracking in the liquid hydrogen flow liners and second by beanng cracks in the crawlers that transport the shuttles to the launch site Similarly, the high-speed Amtrak Acela trams were pulled out of service following the discovery of cracks and breaks in brackets on the wheel sets of at least 8 of the 18 trains Brittle failure in metals takes many forms, e g hydrogen embrittlement [7,8], temper embrittlement [9], environmental degradation [ 101 and associated stress-corrosion cracking [ 111, fatigue failure [ 121, irradiationinduced embnttlement [ 131, liquid-metal embnttlement [ 141 and, more recently, such new phenomena as quench embnttlement [ 151 Two key factors transcend this diverse array of failure phenomena, namely the role of the grain boundary and segregation of undesirable elements to the boundary, as epitomized in Figure 1 There is a long history of research relating the structure of the grain boundary to vanous properties, including the tendency for segregation e g [ 16,171 Some studies have shown correlations between individual grain-boundary misonentation and the local chemistry, or related aspects such as grain-boundary precipitation [18,19] Such correlations have been few and have rarely been carried out on undisturbed (I e non-fractured) grain boundanes or on enough grain boundanes to permit any statistical correlation to be inferred In general it has not proven possible to relate directly the properties of grain boundanes to their structure While structure-property correlations are very strong at the structural extremes of coherent twins (C = 3 ) and random high-angle boundaries (C > -29), intermediate special boundaries (e g C = 5 , 7, 9 etc ) do not always correlate well with properties Part of the reason for this is undoubtedly that the grain-boundary structure is not the pure elemental construction that is commonly assumed, but is modified senously by local changes in the grain-boundary chemistry The analytical EM (AEM) is uniquely configured to study these phenomena because it combines high-resolution imaging, diffraction and nanometer-scale analysis of the same specimen at the same time, permitting correlation of the grain-boundary structure, misonentation, chemistry and bonding - all at the nanometer or sub-nanometer scale No other technique is so versatile at such a high resolution At Lehigh, we have been using the AEM to correlate the chemistry, structure and bonding of embnttled grain boundaries by a) performing quantitative analysis of nanometer-scale segregation to many grain boundanes using X-ray mapping (XRM) via energy dispersive spectrometry (EDS), b), for those same grain boundanes, determining their crystallographic misonentation via the latest computenzed diffraction techniques and c) relating the occurrence of segregation to changes in the atomic bonding at the grain boundary via electron energy-loss spectrometry (EELS) This paper gives an overview of the results of our integrated AEM studies in model embnttling systems such as Cu Bi, Cu-Sb and Fe-P We will first introduce bnefly the techniques used r
Figure 1: SEM images of the fracture surface of a) pure Cu and b) Cu doped with 20 ppm Bi
Nanochemical and nunostructural studies of the brittle failure of alloys
13
EXPERIMENTAL TECHNIQUES X-ray Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy (XEDS) XEDS has been the most extensively used technique for measuring segregation in the AEM, starting with the pioneering studies of Dog and Flewitt [20], who first demonstrated that monolayer-level segregation was detectable in thin foils. Subsequent work has been performed, for example, by Wittig et al. [21,22], Brummauer et al. [10,11,13,23], Rtihle and co-workers [24-261 and the Lehigh group [27-301. Today, with a field emission gun scanning transmission electron microscope (FEG-STEM) the spatial resolution of XEDS can be < 2 nm and segregation can be quantified with a sensitivity approaching 0.01 monolayer [31]. In contrast with the more widespread surface- analysis techniques, in the AEM it is possible to study both brittle and ductile grain boundaries since the boundaries are contained within the thin foil and do not need to be fractured. It is of course, also possible to determine the grain boundary crystallography at the same time via routine TEM diffraction methods, as amplified in the following section. A common approach is to acquire a segregation profile by stepping the electron beam along a line perpendicular to the grain boundary. For equilibrium segregation, the width of this profile will be determined by the size of the electron probe. Two-dimensional X-ray mapping (XRM) of segregant distributions has, until recently, rarely been performed but the unique 300kV ultra-high vacuum, field emission gun VG HB 603 FEG STEM permits the acquisition of compositional maps at high spatial resolution (< 2 nm) and high sensitivity (< 0.1 monolayer) [31-331. XRM offers the advantage that any compositional variations along a grain boundary plane or other complex elemental distributions are easily observed. Many (>30) boundaries can be studied in a single smallgrained sample and it is now possible to directly relate the segregation to the grain-boundary crystallography (misorientationand plane) via computerized diffraction pattern indexing as discussed below.
Automated Crystallographyfor TEM (ACT) While significant progress has been made in XRM and related AEM methods, most studies of grain-boundary crystallography still use standard TEM methods of selected-area or convergent-beam diffraction (SAED or CBED) which are generally non-computerized, labor-intensive and rarely produce statistically valid data. Recently, however, there have been attempts to characterize grain orientations automatically in the TEM [34371. This was stimulated by the success of electron back-scatter diffraction (EBSD) in the scanning electron microscope (SEM) [38,39], which gives computerized orientation of hundreds or even thousands of grains, thus permitting full microtexture analysis and other applications [40-431. Much EBSD work has been done exploring the effects of grain-boundary misorientation (and thus local texture if sufficient grain boundaries are analyzed) on materials properties (e.g. see texts [42.43]). Unfortunately, EBSD cannot be combined with the study of grain-boundary chemistry, because it is not possible to measure grain-boundary chemistry in the SEM. Both the spatial resolution and analytical sensitivity of SEM-XEDS are too coarse [44] to detect and quantify monolayerlevel grain-boundary segregation. To overcome these limitations we have used ACT in which the beam is scanned across the specimen and, when it satisfies the Bragg condition for a given grain, the corresponding area in the dark-filed image appears bright. The intensity of each pixel is recorded as a fbction of beam tilt and rotation angle (i.e. a diMaction pattern). A grain-orientation map is constructed and the misorientation between adjacent grains is calculated from the diffraction patterns, as in the EBSD technique. Eleetron Energy Loss Spectroscopy (EELS) The ionization edges in the EEL spectrum are also used to identify and quantify segregating elements [45.46], although the technique has been less frequently applied than XEDS. However, the fine structure on the ionization edges (the energy-loss near-edge structure (ELNES)) contains information about the unoccupied density of states (DOS) and can thus probe the interatomic bonding which is possibly affected when segregants induce intergranular brittle failure or, conversely, induce ductile behavior in otherwise brittle materials (e.g. B segregation to grain boundaries in NijAI;). There have been several recent examples where ELNES has been used to elucidate such changes in the atomic bonding at grain boundaries produced by segregating elements [45,47-501. The reliability and interpretation of ELNES at grain boundaries remains controversial. The main
D.B. Williamset al.
14
Figure 2: XRM of Bi segregation to grain boundaries in Cu a) localization of Bi to one grain boundary out of a complex intersection of multiple grain boundaries (see corresponding TEM bright field image in b) The grain boundary with Bi is a C=9 while all the others a e C=3 coherent or incoherent twins. In c) there are detectable differences in Bi level at the two different facets of the high angle grain boundary, indicating a role for the grain boundary plane in determining the degree of segregation The upper facet has 10 6 2 1 atoms/nm2while the lower facet has 12 4 + 1 3 atoms /nm2 In d) the map clearly reveals the presence of Bi segregation at a level of 0 8 Bi atomsinm' (reproduced from refs [3 11 by permission of Elsevier Science) expenmental difficulties are the limited spatial resolution and/or statistics It is anticipated that the introduction of sphencal-aberration correctors in STEMS [51] will increase current densities by and order of magnitude and ELNES of interfaces will become considerably more reliable (as indeed will XRM) RESULTS & DISCUSSION
XRM of Brittle Failure in Cu-Bi and Low-alloy Steels Using XRM it is possible to discern numerous aspects of the behavior of segregants that are not routinely accessible via more traditional point and line analyses As summanzed in Figure 2, it is possible to discern a), b) the absence of segregation on certain low-Z boundaries, c) differences in segregation levels between different facets and d) the detection of levels of segregation far below the monolayer level A monolayer in Cu approximates to 18 atoms/nm2 on the grain boundary so the presence of < 1 atom of Bi/nm2 as shown in Fig 2d would probably not cause bnttle failure and, therefore, would not be detected by classical surface-analysis techniques Perhaps the most intriguing result from the use of XlZM for the study of segregant distnbution on dozens of grain boundanes was the discovery that, in a highly embnttled system such as Cu-Bi, significant numbers ofthe grain boundanes exhibited NO detectable segregation [31] (see the histogram in Figure 3) This
-
Nanochemical and nunostructural studies of the brittle failure of alloys
Quenched Tempered
Stress relieved
15
embrittled
Detectabesegregation
1 1.5 x Detectable segregation 1 2.0 x Detectable segregation 1 Figure 3: A histogram of grain boundary coverage of Bi in Cu (atoms/nm2).-30% of the grain boundaries have no detectable Bi segregation. (One monolayer corresponds to -18 atoms/nm2. Reproduced from [31] by permission of Elsevier Science.
Figure 4: Pie charts showing the amount and degree of P and Ni segregation in a low-alloy steel The grain boundary segregation behavior vanes as a function of the heat treatment and the P is never present at all grain boundaries (courtesy A.J Papworth) Modified from [54].
result contradicts much of the common wisdom on the distnbution of Bi, which has traditionally been thought to be present on all grain boundanes in embnttled Cu (e g [52]) This conclusion anses probably because of the prevalence of surface analytical data (e g Auger Electron Spectroscopy (AES)) which, by its nature, pre-selects embnttled grain boundanes for analysis Parallel work [53] showed that minimum detection limits in the VG HB 603 field emission gun (FEG) AEM approached the single atom level in ideal conditions and that the detection limit for mapping of grain-boundary segregants was < 0 1 monolayers [31] So the absence of detectable grain-boundarysegregant was not a limitation of the AEM technique The distribution of P at grain boundaries in low-alloy steels was then studied to see if similar behavior occurred The evolution of grain-boundary segregation of a range of elements, subject to heat treatments that give rise to temper embnttlement was studied Typical results are summarized in Fig 4, which shows pie charts indicating changes in the amount (gray level) and degree (number of grain boundanes (30 per full pie chart)) of segregation dunng the heat treatments [54] The results indicate that, in t h s temper-embnttled condition (when the alloy shows 100% intergranular bnttle failure), P is present on some grain boundanes but it is neither present on all grain boundanes, nor is it the primary segregant In fact, both the amount and degree of P segregation has decreased from the pnor (more ductile) condition This fact in isolation strongly confirms the data from Cu-Bi in Fig 3, that bnttle matenals need not have 100% grain-boundary segregation for failure to occur, but also highlights the complexity of bnttle failure in multi-element systems So there is now corroborating evidence that embntthng species are not necessanly present at all grain boundanes Therefore, grain-boundarycharacteristics may play a greater role than hitherto believed 111 controlling the distnbution of Bi in Cu and P in steel CombinedXRMand ACT of Sb Segregation in Cu It is well known that grain boundary misorientation plays a role in segregation, accounting in part for the vanation from boundary to boundary [55] A widely accepted view is that high-angle grain boundaries are more accommodating than low-angle grain boundaries and strong segregants are present at all high-angle gram
D.B. Williamset al.
16
(a) BF TEM ima!
(b) diffraction patterns (c) orientation map
I 400nm
H
Figure 5: (a) BF image in Cu-0.08 wt%Sb alloy. (b) Diffraction patterns reconstructed from the DF images (c) Reconstructed onentation map. boundanes In fcc materials, e g , segregation is suppressed only at C=3 (the most close-packed) grain boundanes (as shown in Figs 2b and c) A possible reason for our observed lack of segregation at other highangle gram boundanes in Cu-Bi and Fe-P is that crystallography plays an even more important role than hitherto suspected and some high-angle grain boundanes are inherently resistant to segregation, perhaps because of a low density of ledges, intnnsic dislocations, etc To prove this hypothesis will require measurement of nanometer-level chemistry and local misonentation from many gram boundanes and companson with segregation in controlled textures and misonentations However, to date, it has proven extremely challenging to measure both these charactenstics from significant numbers of grain boundanes in the same specimen In order to pursue the details of the relationship between the occurrence (or absence) of segregation and the gramboundary characteristics, it is necessary to map the segregation of an embrittling species at a range of grain boundanes whose misonentation is determined, e g via ACT Figure 5a is a TEM image of a Cu-0 08 wt% Sb alloy, analyzed by ACT The diffraction patterns and onentation map are shown in Figs 5 (b) and (c) and the onentation relationship between adjacent grains is shown in Table 1 XRM was performed on these grain boundanes and the Sb images are shown in Figure 6 Clearly the segregation varies, while Sb is detectable on most gain boundanes, it is not detectable on #3, 4,s and 10 (and it has been shown this is not simply due to factors such as tilt of the grain-boundary plane) Again the crucial point is that a major embnttling agent is not present on many grain boundanes, supporting our data from Cu-Bi and Fe-P From Table 1 only one grain boundary (#3) is close to a E=3 structure, the rest are random high-angle grain boundanes Thus it has been demonstrated via a combination of XRM and ACT that a significant fraction (> -30%) of highangle grain boundanes, in 3 different strongly-segregating systems, Cu-Bi, Fe-P and CuSb exhbit no detectable segregation Therefore, it is reasonable to conclude that alloys in which such segregant-free grain boundanes are more prevalent should show enhanced resistance to segregation and any associated bnttle failure One method by which an increased fraction of segregation-resistant grain boundanes could be produced is grainboundary engineenng (GBE) which produces textures with a majonty of low-C grain boundanes, Such grain boundanes would shifi the distnbution of gram-boundary chemistry m Figure 3 towards the left-hand end of the spectrum, thereby significantly reducing the number of gram boundanes to which segregation can occur The concept of selectively enhancing the number of low-C grain boundanes through GBE, in order to reduce embnttlement was first proposed by Watanabe [41] As well as the pioneering work of Watanabe, GBE has also been implemented by other groups including, e g Lehockey et a1 156 571 and Kumar et a1 [58 591 GBE has
Nanochemical and nunostructural studies of the brittle failure of alloys
17
Sk Nt%)
Figure 6: Sb composition maps. The segregation between different grain boundaries is clearly not homogeneous and several grain boundaries have no detectable segregation although they are high-angle grain boundaries. TABLE 1 Axidangle pairs calculated from the ACT results for the grain boundaries numbered in Fig. 6 Boundary 1 2 3 4 5
Angle-axis 52'@[-11 -5 61 45"@[4 -2 -31 59"@[8 9 -81 -60°@,[1 1-11 28'@[15-1 I ] 49"@[-7 -8 121
Boundary 6 7
Angle-axis 43"@[9 -8 51 47"@[-2 -1 -51
8
47'@[2 5 -11
9 10
29'@ 12 -3 -71 40"@[-17 1-61
revealed the strong effect of the dzstnbutzon of grain boundary structures on properties, including embnttlement, and shown how, via thermo-mechanical processing (TMP), it is possible to engineer the distnbution of low-C grain boundaries to improve greatly the mechanical and other (e g corrosion) properties Implicit in GBE is the concept that manipulating the gramn=boundary structure may result in manipulating the chemistry, given the long-understood relationship between the two Since GBE produces a large fraction of
D.B. Williams et al.
18
2=3 grain boundaries (which exhibit no segregation) the possibility that GBE techniques will produce an inherently segregation-resistanttexture are now ripe for study using a combination of XRM and ACT. Energy Loss Near-Edge Fine Structure (ELNES) Studies of Embrittled GBs In addition to the role of the boundary crystallography in governing segregation it is important to discern the role of the segregant when it reaches the boundary plane. As has been noted, while this article emphasizes the segregant's role in brittle failure, segregants can also act to improve the ductility of otherwise brittle materials such as B in Ni3Al. So the segregation itself is not a necessary prerequisite for brittle failure. Clearly the segregant must be changing the character of the bonding at the grain boundary to induce either brittle failure or, conversely, ductilization. To probe the bonding changes at the nanometer level is also possible in the AEM using energy-loss spectrometry fine structure studies. We have demonstrated a clear relationship between the presence of Bi at grain boundaries in Cu and a change in the ELNES. The presence of Bi changes the electronic structure of the Cu but only within <1 nm either side of the grain boundary [29] and a small increase in intensity at the Cu L23 edge onset is observed, as shown in Figure 7. While the change in the ELNES intensity is small, it is consistently reproducible and is not due to spectrometer misalignment, oxygen segregation or specimen thickness effects, all of which can produce changes in ELNES intensity [49]. The peak is not detected at C=3 coherent twins where no Bi segregates (see Figure 2). We originally calculated that this increase in ELNES intensity at the edge onset arises from hybridization between Bi-p and Cu-d states, creating empty d states above the Fermi level and a narrowing of the filled d states [31]. Recently, Muller [60] proposed that the extra intensity arises from a core-level shift induced by the narrowing of thefilled d states, which also explains the embrittling effect. This latter proposal is also consistent with our calculations and we now believe that this is perhaps the best explanation of both the experimental data and the calculations. Similar changes have been observed in Sbdoped Cu and S-doped N, both of which embrittle the Cu while Ag segregation, which has no effect on the Cu, produces no detectable change. In contrast, studies by Muller and co-workers [61] on the ductilizing effect of B in brittle Ni3Al reveal the reverse effects to that in Cu-B, Cu-Sb and Ni-S. The Ni L23 edge from grain boundaries with B segregation is similar to the Ni L23 edge from Ni in bulk Ni3A1, i.e., the ELNES intensity decreases with B additions. Muller et al. show how these changes relate to differences in hybridization of the Ni d states and also how bond energies can be estimated directly 920 930 940 950 960 from the EELS spectrum. This is consistent with a rule of thumb for alloys with a d shell Energy Loss (eV) more than half full, that the larger the increase in ELNES intensity, the weaker the Figure 7: Change in the Cu L23 ELNES between a Cu grain bond. boundary with Bi segregated to it and pure Cu. The slight increase in the ELNES can be interpreted in terms of a These data imply that changes in the Cu L23 change in the Cu bonding at the boundary. Reproduced from ELNES are not due simply to segregation, [27] by permission of Elsevier Science. but onlv to seeregation that causes embrittlement. A simple interpretation of the effect of Bi on the Cu bonding leads to the conclusion that a cosegregant at the GB, which has the opposite effect on the ELNES (i.e. depending on whose theory is correct, U
"
Nanochemical and nunostructural studies of the brittle failure of alloys
19
broadens the filled 3d states, reverses the core-level shift, or fills in the empty Cu 3d states, or reverses the transfer of charge to the Cu) should also result in the restoration of ductility. According to the work of Muller et al., already cited, B has just this effect in Ni3A1. While early work [62] indicates that Fe lowers the amount of Bi segregation, Fe was not detectable on the grain boundaries. More recent studies by Muthiah [63] show that P does not de-embrittle Cu-Bi, so no effective co-segregant has been found. However, no comparative study of co-segregation of B in Cu-Bi has been performed and this is also an area in which combined X R M and ELNES may produce a significant improvement in our knowledge of the role of grain-boundary chemistry controlling mechanical properties. The ability to nullify embrittling species by controlled additions of co-segregants would indeed be a major step on the way to scientific tailoring of grain boundary chemistry to control the mechanical properties of materials.
SUMMARY Analytical electron microscopy now permits the simultaneous mapping of the grain-boundary chemistry and grain boundary misorientation. Studies of dozens of grain boundaries in several systems indicate that embrittling segregants are absent at a significant fraction of high-angle grain boundaries, contradicting current theories. This opens the possibility of controlling brittle failure by developing segregant-resistant textures via GBE or some similar process. Alternatively, it has been shown that segregants cause embrittlement by slight changes in the local electronic structure of GBs. Such changes in electronic structure might be reversed by careful choice of co-segregating species. These two approaches offer novel methods for designing advanced materials that are inherently resistant to the age-old problem of brittle intergranular failures. In either case the process will be considerably less expensive than current methods which rely on removing the offending segregant by removing the undesired element($ from the alloys during processing.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS DBW and VJK acknowledge the financial support of the National Science Foundation through grant DMR 99072670. MW acknowledges the support of the Materials Research Center at Lehigh University.
REFERENCES 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8
9
10 11 12 13
Hampe, W.Z. (1874) Berg-Hutten u. Salinen-Wese 22,93. http://www.tms.or,~lpubs/iournals/JOM/~8Ol/Felkins-~8Ol .html ht~://www.civ.toronto.edu/f~stuffldisaster/boston.htni htto://web.mit.edulcourse/3/3.11 /www/vri/shin.pdf http://www.shuclint.com/tekbrefs/0407pefeat4.pdf http://www.cndc.iastate.edu/ncce/K12/aircrash.htm Gaudett, M.A. and Scully, J.R. (2000) Metall. Mat. Trans. A 31A, 81. Kolman, D.G. and Scully, J.R. (2000) Corrosion Science 42(11), 1863. Lalam, S.H., Bhadeshia H.K.D.H. and MacKay, D.J.C. (2000) Science and Technologyof Weldingand Joining 5,338. Bruemmer, S . (1999) Materials Science Forum 294-296, 75. Gertsman, V.Y. and Bruemmer, S.M. (2001) Acta mater. 49,1689. Gasem, Z.M. and Gangloff, R.P. (2000) Materials Science Forum 331-337, 1479. Bruemmer, S.M., Simonen, E.P., Scott, P.M., Andresen, P.L., Was, G.S. andNelson, J.L. (1999)J. Nucl. Mat. 274,299.
20
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53
D.B. Williamset al. Wynblatt, P. and Takashima, M. (2001) Interface Science 9, 265. Krauss, G. (2001) Metall. and Muter. Trans. A 32A, 861. Howe, J.M. (1997). Interfaces in Materials. Wiley, New York, NY. Sutton, A.P. and Ballufi, R.W. (1995). Interfaces in Crystalline Materials. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK. Williams, D.B. and Edington, J.W. (1976) Acta metall. 24, 323. Michael, J.R. and Williams, D.B. (1986). In: Interface Migration and Control of Microstructure, pp. 7381, Pande, C.S., Smith, D.A., King A.H. and Walter, J. (Eds.). American Society for Metals, Metals Park, OH. Doig, P. andFlewitt, P.E.J., (1978)J. Microsc. 112, 257. Wittig, J., Sinclair, R. and Viswanathan, R. (1985) Scripta metall. 19, 111. Wittig, J., Bentley, J., Al-Sharab, J.F. and Evans N.D. (2001). In: Electron Microscopy and Analysis, 168, pp. 429-432, Institute of Physics, Bristol and Philadelphia. Brummauer, S.M. and Thomas, L.E. (2001) Surface and Interface Analysis 31, 571. Albers, A,, Mullejans, H. and Riihle, M. (1997) Ultramicroscopy 69, 105. Riihle, M., Gemming, T., Kienzle, 0. and Schweinfest, R. (1999). In: Electron Microscopy and Analysis, 161, pp.1-8, Institute of Physics, Bristol and Philadelphia. Schmidt, S., Sigle, W., Gust, W. and Riihle, M. (2002) Z. Metallk. 93, 428. Baumann, S.F. and Williams, D.B. (198)J. Microsc. 123,299. Michael, J.R. and Williams, D.B. (1984)Metall. Trans. 15A, 99. Bruley, J., Keast, V.J. and Williams, D.B. (1996)J. Phys. D. (Appl. Phys.) 29, 1730. Keast, V.J., Bruley, J., Rez, P., Maclaren, J.M. and Williams D.B. (1998) Acta mater. 46,481. Keast, V.J. and Williams, D.B. (1999) Acta mater. 47, 3999. Williams, D.B., Watanabe, M., Carpenter, D.T. and Barmak, K. (1998) Mikrochim. Acta S15 49. Cqenter, D.T., Watanabe, M., Barmak, K. and Williams D.B. (1999) Microsc. Microanal. 5,254. Jensen, D.J. (1997) Ultramicroscopy 67,25. Schwarzer, R.A. (1997) Ultramicroscopy 67, 19. Wright, S.I. and Dingley, D.J. (1998) Materials Science Forum 273-275,209. Dingley, D.J. (2000). In: Electron Backscatter Diffraction in Materials Science, pp. 1-18, Schwartz, A.J., Kumar, M. and Adams, B.L. (Eds.). Kluwer Academic Press, New York, NY. Adams, B.L., Wright, S.I. and Kunze, K. (1993) Metall. Trans. A A24, 819. Field, D.P. (1997) Ultramicroscopy 67, 1. Goyal, A., Specht, E.D., Wang, Z.L. and Kroeger, D.M. (1997) Ultramicroscopy 67,35. Watanabe, T. and Tsurekawa, S. (1997) Acta muter. 47,4171. Randle, V. (1996.) The Role of the Coincidence Site Lattice in Grain Boundary Engineering. Institute of Metals, London. Schwartz, A.J. Kumar, M. and Adams, B.L. (Eds.) (2000). Electron Bachcatter Diffraction in Materia1.s Science. Kluwer Academic Press, New York, N Y . Goldstein, J.I., Newbury, D.E., Echlin, P., Joy, D.C., Romig, Jr. A.D., Lyman, C.E., Fiori, C. and Lifshin, E. (1992). Scanning Electron Microscopy andX-ray Microanalysis. Plenum Press, New York, NY. Muller, D.A., Subramanian, S., Batson, P.E., Silcox, J. and Sass, S.L. (1996) Acta muter. 44, 1637. Bruley, J., Cho, J., Chan, H.M., Harmer, M.P. andRickman, J.M. (1999)J. Amer. Ceram. SOC.82,2865. Ozkaya, D., Yuan, J., Brown, L.M. and Flewitt, P.E.J. (1995)J Microsc. 180,300. Keast, V.J., Bruley, J., Rez, P., MacLaren, J.M. and Williams, D.B. (1998) ActaMater. 46, 481 Bruley, J., Keast, V.J. and Williams, D.B. (1999) Acta muter. 47,4009. Browning, N.D., Buban, J.P., Prouteau, C., Duscher, G. and Pennycook, S.J. (1999) Micron 3,425. Krivanek, O.L., Delby, N. and Lupini, A.R. (1999) Ultramicroscopy 78,l. Wolski, K., Laporte V., Marie, N. and Biscondi, M. (2001) Interface Science 9, 183. Watanabe, M. and Williams, D.B. (1999) Ultramicroscopy 78, 89.
Nanochemical and nunostructural studies of the brittle failure of alloys
54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62
21
Williams, D.B., Watanabe, M., Papworth, A.J. and Li, J.C., (2002) Thin Solid Films (in press, publication expected 12/02). Briant, C.L. (1983) Actu metull. 31,257. Lehockey, E.M., Palumbo, G. and Lin, P. (1998) Scriptu muter. 39,353. Lehockey, E. M., Palumbo, G. and Lin, P. (1998) Metall. andMater. Trans. A, 29A, 3069. Kumar, M., Schwartz, A.J. and King, W.E. (2002) Actu muter. 50,2599. Kumar, M., King, W.E. and Schwartz, A.J. (2000) Acta muter. 48,2081. Muller, D.A. (1998) Phys. Rev. B58,5989. Johnson,W.C., Joshi, A. and Stein, D F. (1976) Metall. Trans. 7A, 949. Muthiah, R.C. (1995) Project Report to International Copper Assoc., University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
Transmission Electron Microscopy Study of the Early-Stage Precipitates in Al-Mg-Si Alloys H. W. Zandbergen, J. H. Chen, C. D. Marioara, and E. Olariu National Centre for HREM and Netherlands Institute for Metals Research, Delft University of Technology, Rotterdamseweg 137,2628 AL Delft, The Netherlands
ABSTRACT Early-stage precipitates in the Al-Si-Mg based 6xxx alloys include solute clusters, GP-zones (including the pre-p’ phase), the p” phase as well as the so called Q particles (if a small amount of Cu is added in the alloys). Using high-resolution transmission electron microscopy and quantitative electron diffraction, these precipitates are studied in details. The p” phase has a monoclinic structure with the composition MgSSih. The structure of thc pre-P” phase is quite similar to that of the p” phase but the atom positions are more close to that of the A1 lattice. It is pointed out that Al poorly-develops many of the structures of the precipitates, due to the presence of defects and substitutions of Mg and Si.
INTRODUCTION The precipitation behaviour in Al-Si-Mg system has been extensively studied. Although there are still disagreements on the sequence, structure, and chemistry of the metastable precipitate, it is generally accepted that the precipitation in this alloy system can be described as [ 1-21:
SSSS + Solute clusters -+ GP(1) (including pre-p”)
-+ GP(II)/p’ -+ p’ -+ p ,
where SSSS = Super Saturated Solid Solution. The latter two stages are over-aged conditions. If the alloy contains excess Si, the formation of more Si-rich phases will overlap with the above precipitation sequence. Small additions of copper to these alloys may introduce some additional phases, e.g., Q - AlsCu2MgsSi6, in the equilibrium condition [3], but the major ageing sequence is basically the one shown above. The maximum hardness in these alloys is obtained when the alloys contain a combination of Guinier Preston (GP-I) zones [4-51 with diameters of about 2.5 nm and larger needles of p’ [6-81 with a typical size of about 4 3 4 x 4 ~ 5 0nm3. The number density of both precipitates is high; for the p” needles a number density of 10 /pm is normal, corresponding to a volume fraction of only nearly 1%. The GP-I zones are assumed to be strongly enriched in Si and Mg and to have a structure very similar to that of the surrounding Al matrix, whereas the p’ phase has a different structure. The monoclinic unit cell of p’ is reported to have the cell dimensions a = 1.53(1) nm, b = 0.405 nm, c = 0.67(2) nm, p = 106(2)’. For a full understanding of the mechanisms of strength enhancement, knowledge of the structures of the various phases is essential. Because of the small size of the j3” precipitates, their low volume fraction and their occurrence in 24 orientations in the Al matrix conventional structure determination (for example by X-
23
24
H. W. Zandbergen et al.
ray and neutron diffraction) is not possible. Conventional high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HREM) also does not provide sufficient detail to elucidate the structure. Therefore we applied two techniques: i) exit wave reconstruction from a through focus series of HREM images [9-111, which was used to construct a rough structure model and ii) a least-squares structure refinement [12-131 using electron diffraction data and taking dynamic diffraction fully into account. Dynamic diffraction occurs for electrons even in very thin crystals because the electron-matter interaction is very strong (about lo5 times larger than for X-rays). The dynamic diffraction results in changes in the relative intensities of the reflections as a function of the specimen thickness. Therefore kinematical diffraction, which is valid for almost all X-ray and neutron diffraction, cannot be applied. As shown in this paper the inclusion of dynamic scattering in the refinement procedure leads to much more reliable results in particular for specimen thickness above 10 nm. For the GP-I zones or other poorly-developed particles, however, the electron diffraction technique is difficult to apply. Hence through-focus exit-wavefunction reconstruction (TF-EWR) was employed to access the structural details of the ill-defined precipitates [ 14-161, which are technologically relevant. For example, these poorly-developed particles play a role in the fast increase in hardness of Al alloys for automotive body panel applications [17-221. Further more, to detect the solute clusters, which are fully coherent with the matrix, atom probe field-ion microscopy (APFIM) plays an important role [23, 1-21. MATERIALS AND EXPERIMENTALS DETAILS All Al alloys were prepared following a standard procedure including casting, hot rolling, cold rolling, homogenization, solution treatment at around 540”C, quenching to room temperature, natural ageing at room temperature, and final hardening ageing or annealing at temperatures between 150°C and 185°C. Three types of Al-Mg-Si alloys were investigated (i). For the structure determination of the p” phase we used an A1-0.5Mg-0.53Si (weight percent) alloy, hardening aged at 185°C for 5 hours. (ii). For the structure determination of the pre-P” phase (GP-I) we used an A1-0.6Mg-0.9Si alloy, hardening aged at 150OC for a time varying from 4 hours to 9 days. The annealing temperature, 150°C, falls in the temperature interval in which the p’ phase is still stable. (iii). For the structure analysis of poorly-developed GP-I zones and poorly-developed Q particles we used an A1-0.43Mg-1.2Si-0.15Cu alloy, aged at 180°C for 30 minutes. All these alloys contain small amounts of Mn and Fe. The HRTEM foils were prepared by electropolishing in a Tenupol-3 machine using an electrolyte consisting of 1/3 HNO3 in methanol. The samples were examined in a high resolution Philips CM30UTIFEG operating at 300 kV. Through-focus series of HREM images of precipitates were recorded for constructing exitwavefunctions [ 14-161. Electron nanodiffraction patterns of precipitates were taken for structure refinement using MSLS software [12-131. The through focus exit wave reconstruction uses the focus dependence of the image distortion by the electron microscope to correct for this distortion [lo]. A major advantage of the exit wave is that the information, which is delocalized in the HREM images resulting in a blurred image, is restored to its origin [lo-111. In addition to the advantage of the deblurring, the noise level of the exit wave is less than for a single image since 15-20 HREM images are used for the reconstruction. In the present work, the BriteEuram meeting software package written by Coene and Thust was used for the reconstruction. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS The P p h a s e
EDX element analysis of about 50 p’ precipitates indicates a Mg/Si atomic ratio of approximately 0.8. Some precipitates showed a considerable higher Mg/Si ratio. Such a higher ratio is in agreement with the presence
H. W. Zandbergen et al.
26
From Figure la a trial model for the structure refinement was obtained in the following way. From the coherency of the interface between the p’particle and the A1 matrix it was concluded that the Si and Mg atoms are located at or close to the y = 0 and y = 1/2 planes. From the unit cell volume it was concluded that the number of atoms in the unit cell is 22. Taking into account the Mg/Si ratio as determined by element analysis it follows that the composition is probably MgS Si,. Next, atoms were placed at the dark spots in the exit wave image. The darkest spots were assumed to be two Si atoms in different layers, being so close together in projection that they merge into one spot. The dark spot with the largest distances to the other black dots was assumed to be Mg, since Mg has a larger radius (0.155 nm) than Si (0.115 nm). The remaining Mg and Si atoms were assigned to the other black dots based on the radii of Mg and Si. This model was used as the starting model for the MSLS refinement using simultaneously 7 electron diffraction data sets along [OlO] or [OOl]. These data were collected from p” particles containing no defects, because the presence of defects results in streaking or extra peaks. Because the electron diffraction data were recorded from areas containing p” and the A1 matrix, the A1 reflections were omitted and with that about 10% of the p” reflections [12-131. The refinements were done in space groups C2/m, C2, Cm and C1, which were suggested by the systematically absent reflections [ 131. The refinements in the lower symmetric space groups did not lead to significantly better fits nor to different atom positions, indicating that the space group is C2/m. The resulting atomic parameters arc given in Table 1. The overall R-value after refinement was 3.1%. Table 2 lists the number of reflections, the refined crystal misorientation and the R-values of each diffraction pattern. TABLE 1 Atomic positional parameters and isotropic temperature factors, B, for MgsSi,, with a = 1.516(2) nm, b = 0.405 nm, c = 0.674(2) nm, p = 105.3(5)’ and space group C2/m X
Y
Z
B
Mg( 1)
0
Mg(2)
0.3459(8)
0
0
0.5(2)
0
0.21 7(1)
1.0(2)
Mg(3)
0.4299(10)
0
0.652(3)
0.8(2)
Si(1)
0.0565(7)
0
0.652(3)
1.1(2)
Si(2) Si(3)
0.1885(8)
0
0.224(2)
0.5(2)
0.617(2)
2.5(4)
I 0.2171(9) I
0
1
Table 2 also gives the R-values when only kinematical diffraction is taken into account [12-131. Obviously for the thicker specimen areas these R-values are much higher than those obtained by including dynamic diffraction. This indicates that even for a material like MgsSi, with only light elements the dynamic diffraction is very significant for small specimen thickness (about >10 nm). Consequently, it is important to include the dynamic scattering in the structure refinement. Moreover, the use of diffraction data from areas with different thickness adds substantially to the reliability of the structure refinement. A perfect p’atomic structure [ 131 overlapped on a simulated exit wave is shown in Figure 2. Figure 2 shows the amplitude of the exit wave, where the black dots represent the atomic positions. The p” can be derived from a FCC Al lattice by relatively small shifts of the atoms, except for one Mg atom (Mgl). The atoms 2,4, 6 and 8 atoms in Figure 3 (A1 replaced by Mg) are shifted inwards while the atoms 3 , 5 , 7 and 9 (replaced by Si) are shifted outwards. This change in atom positions forces the middle atom (Mgl) to change its height over 0.2 nm. These Mg( 1) Mg4Si4 clusters are distributed such that a monoclinic unit cell is formed.
Transmission electron microscopy study of the early-stage precipitates in Al-Mg-Si alloys
21
TABLE 2
Data on the diffraction sets used for the refinement of Mg,Si, listed in Table 1. The kinematical R-values are obtained after refinement of only the scale factors keeping all other parameters fixed and using occupancies of only 1% [I21 zone
number
refined
obs. refl. thickness
crystal misorientation x
Y
2
R-value (%) MSLS
kinematic
[OlO]
50
6.7(5)
8.3
0
-2.3
3.0
3.7
[OlOl
56
15.9(6)
2.6
0
-1.8
4.1
8.3
[OlO]
43
16.1(8)
-1.7
0
0.3
0.7
12.4
[OlO]
50
17.2(6)
-5
0
-1
1.4
21.6
roioi
54
22.2~)
-5.9
0
2.5
5.3
37.3
[OOl]
72
3.7(3)
-3.9
4.5
0
4.1
4.5
[OOl]
52
4.9(6)
3.6
-1.9
0
6.8
9.3
m--
-7
0 Mg z=O, 0 Mg z=1/2 0
Alz=O,
0 Alz=1/2
Si z=O,
0
Si z=1/2
Figure 2: A perfect p’ atomic structure overlapped on a simulated exit wave The p r e - p or GP-Z zones
Conventional TEM reveals a high density of very fine precipitates formed in the very beginning of the precipitation process, as shown in Figure 3. The precipitates are needles oriented along <100>Al, like the p’ phase.
H. W.Zundbergen et al.
28
I
m
.---Y
W 8
P . .
e
Figure 3: Bright field images of samples with different annealing time: (a) 4 hours, (b) 11 hours (c) 2 days and (d) 9 days. All images are taken along the
A1 zone axis, as well as Selected Area Diffraction Patterns from: (e) a 4-hours -sample and (0 2-days-sample. The volume fraction of particles (estimated from the number of particles and their average dimensions) is 0.5%-1.6%. Although the samples with short ageing time have a twice as high particle density they show a lower hardening effect. This indicates that the precipitates in these samples are more coherent with the matrix. This is in agreement with the fact that the diffuse streaks in the SADPs are less pronounced and more diffuse in the 4-hours and 11-hours aged specimens (Figure 3). If all Mg and Si atoms from the SSSS form p” (MgsSih), then the volume fraction of precipitates must be 1.3%. Because our data suggest that this value could be exceeded it is very likely that A1 is a constituent of the precipitates. In exit waves of p” in [OlO] orientation the dominant image feature is a black dot (the Mgl atom) successively surrounded by a white and a black oval around it (see Figure 2). This image feature looks like an ‘eye’. In [OlO] orientation the p” structure image is composed with these ‘eyes’ linked together by Si-Si bonds. Reconstructed exit waves of the samples aged at 150°C for 11 hours or 9 days are shown in Figures 4 and 5 . As in Figure 2 the amplitude of the exit wave is shown in these figures, such that black dots represent atomic positions. The reconstructed exit waves also show eye-like image features although less pronounced than in the exit wave for p”.
Transmission electron microscopy study of the early-stage precipitates in Al-Mg-Sialloys
29
Figure 5: Two exit waves of particles of the 11 days aged sample imaged along 4 0 0 2 Al
The particle in Figure 5a is composed of 1.5 x 3 p’ unit cells [13], and it has interatomic distances being in good agreement with literature data. Because of this we conclude that after annealing at 15OOC for 9 days the precipitates have a p’ structure despite their small size. In contrast, the particles in the 1I-hour specimen must have a different atomic arrangement, based on a detailed analysis on these images. The analysis of the interatomic distance [ 141, leads to two structural models for the two particles of the 11-hour aged specimen, as shown in Figures 6 and 7. It is very probable that the A1 content varies in the different precipitates in particular in the 11-hour aged sample. For example the particle in Figures 5a and 6 is more coherent with the matrix than that of Figures 5b and 7 and therefore it may contain more A1 as this fits better with the interatomic distances observed. If this is the case, some of the Si atoms around the Mg(1) atom might be replaced with Al. However, we did not substitute Si atoms by A1 in Figures 6 and 7, because this might also vary along the viewing direction.
H. W.Zandbergen et al.
30
Averaged interatomic distances: 1-2=1-6=271pm; 1-4=1-8=282pm; 1-3=1-7=288pm; 1-5=1-9=287pm; 5-10=270pm Unit cell:
a=1,457nm, b=0.40nm, c=0.683nm, p=104.9”
O M g
OW
Al z=O,
0 Al
0
Si z=O, 0 Si
Figure 6: Atomic structural model proposed for the particle in Figure 5 (left) for the 1Ih sample Averaged interatomic distances: 1-2=1-6=255pm; 1-4= 1-8=276pm; 1-3=1-7=302pm; 1-5=1-9=297pm; 5-10=272pm Unit cell: a=1.478nm, b=0.405nm, c=0.674nm, !3=106.8’
.Ms
Ow
.A1
z=O.
0 A1
0 Si z=O.
o Si
Figure 7: Atomic structural model proposed for the particle in Figure 5a for the 1ih sample Thepoorly-developedpre-p” or highly coherent GP-I zones We have seen that when the age hardening time is getting short, the hardening precipitate structures formed can be deviated far from the standard p’, as presented in Figure 1. In general, the precipitates formed in the very early stage have poorly developed crystal structures, which are more coherent with the Al matrix. These structures have to be studied because of their significance to automotive industry, where a quick paint bake response of the A1 alloys is required. Here we will show some different forms of the poorly developed or highly coherent GP-I zones, which appear upon a 30-minute hardening age at about 180’C. Figure 8 shows a highly coherent GP-I zone formed in half an hour of age hardening after a very short natural ageing. The interesting points of this precipitate are the following: (i). It still has a P”-like monoclinic unit cell with a = .460nm, b = 0.405nm, c = 0.653nm, and P = 105.4’. (ii). It is highly coherent with the Al matrix with [loo] p // [270]~1,[OlO] p // [001]AI, and [001] p // [ ? i O ] A l .
Transmission electron microscopy study of the early-stage precipitates in Al-Mg-Si alloys
31
Since the structure is more coherent with the A1 matrix, as compared with the p” phase, there should be more A1 atoms remained in the structure, as discussed in the previous section. Since these particles are poorly-developed in terms of crystal structure, both through-focus exitwavefunction reconstruction and image simulation are needed, in order to determine their atomic structures.
Figure 8: A highly coherent p-like monoclinic GP-I zone Thepoorly-developed Q particles
Figure 9 is a typical high-resolution image of another type of poorly-developed precipitates with a lath shape. Owing to the fact that these precipitates are poorly-developed in one of the three dimensions, the periodic arrangement of alloy elements in the particles cannot be seen clearly in the images. By combining the high-resolution images with their diffiactograms (Fourier transform of the image), we can deduce that these particles take ( 5 1 0 ) as ~ their ~ habit planes. They grow rapidly along the directions parallel to the habit planes, but their development along the directions perpendicular to their habit planes is very much restricted. According to the characteristic crystallographic relations between these particles and the matrix, they can be identified as the precursors of the Q phase (e.g., Weatherly et al. 2000 [3]). However, we should mention that the Q particles are not found everywhere in the matrix. It is also found that when a Burgers circle is drawn around such a particle in HRTEM images, the circle is not closed, indicating a dislocation as the nucleation site of the Q particle.
Figure 9: Poorly-developed Q particles (a and c images) with the diffractogram of a image in the middle
32
H. W. Zandbergen et al.
Again for such ill-defined Q particles, diffraction techniques are not suited to determine the atomic structural details of these clusters. Atomic imaging with ultra-high resolution is therefore needed to fulfill the tasks. Further work is on the way to investigate the atomic structures of such ill-defined precipitates, in order to fully understanding their forming mechanisms in the A1 matrix. CONCLUSIONS Using high-resolution transmission electron microscopy and quantitative electron diffraction, we have studied a number of the early-stage precipitates in the Al-Si-Mg based 6xxx alloys, including different GPzones (the pre-p’ phase), the p” phase as well as the so called Q-phase particles (if a small amount of Cu is added in the alloys). From the obtained results, we can draw the following conclusions: In the structure refinement of the p’(MgsSib) dynamic diffraction was fully taken into account, (i) allowing the accurate elucidation of an unknown structure, in particular by using data sets from various orientations and thicknesses. Since the crystal misorientation is also refined, a mistilt can be used to enhance the resolution in certain directions in diffraction space. The results from the MSLS refinement are more reliable than those from the TF-EWR (and HREM), because the diffraction information extends about twice as far (0.14 nm for TF-EWR versus 0.07 nm for electron diffraction). The structure of MgSSi6is very likely to be correct given the low R-values obtained. TF-EWR is a powerful tool for accessing the atomic structural details of nano-scale precipitates, (ii) especially those studied here. It can provide a good starting model for a further structural refinement based on microdiffraction data sets taken from the small precipitate crystals. Moreover when precipitates to be studied become very small (a few nanometers in size) or ill-defined in terms of their crystalline structures, TF-EWR is a usehl method for the structure determination. GP-I zones may have different structures depending on the temperatures and ageing times used, (iii) but our study indicates that all these structures have a close relation with the standard monoclinic structure of the p” phase. In general, GP-I zones are more coherent with the A1 matrix, indicating A1 atoms are incorporated in their structures. We have proposed two atomic models for GP-I zones. Incomplete Q-phase particles appear around dislocation sites even for a short annealing time (30 (iv) minutes). To study these poorly-developed precipitates, advanced HREM techniques with ultra-high resolution, e.g., TF-EWR, must be applied in association with image (exit-wavefunction) simulation. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This research was carried out under project number MC4.98047 in the Framework of the Strategic Research program of the Netherlands Institute for Metals Research in the Netherlands (www.nimr.nl). Dr. L. Zhuang (Corus R & D, The Netherlands) is appreciated for providing some of the samples. REFERENCES 1. Murayama, M. and Hono, K., Pre-precipitate clusters and precipitation processes in Al-Mg-Si alloys, Acta Mater. 47 (1998), 1537-1548. 2. Edwards, G . A,, Stiller, K., Dunlop, G . L. and Couper, M. J., The precipitation sequence in Al-Mg-Si alloys, Acta Mater. 46 (1998), 3893-3904. 3. G . C. Weatherly, A.Perovic, N. K. Mukhopadhyay, D. J. Lloyd and D. D. Perovic, The precipitation of the Q phase in an AA6111 alloy, Metall. Mater. Trans. A (2001), 213-218. 4. A. H. Geislet and J. K. Hill, Acta Cryst. 1,238 (1948). 5 . G. Thomas, The ageing Characteristics of Aluminium Alloys: Electron transmission study of Al-Mg-Si alloys, J. Inst. Met. 90 (1961), 57-62. 6. L. Zhen, W.D. Fei, S.B. Kang, H.W. Kim: Journal ofMuterial Science, Precipitation behavior of Al-MgSi alloys with high silicon content, 32 (1997), 1895-1902.
Transmission electron microscopy study of the early-stage precipitates in Al-Mg-Sialloys
33
7. M. Takeda, F. Ohkubo, T. Shirai, K. Fukui: Journal of Materials Science, Stability of metastable phases
and microstructures in the ageing process of Al-Mg-Si ternary alloys, 33 (1998), 2385-2390. 8. S. J. Andersen, Quantification of the MgzSi p" and p' phases in AlMgSi alloys by transmission electron microscopy, Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A , 26 (1995), 1931-1938. 9. D. Van Dyck and M. Op De Beeck, Proc. 12th Int. congress on Electron Microscopy, p.26 San Francisco Press, Seatle (1992). 10. Coene, W., Janssen, G., Op De Beeck, M. and Van Dyck, D., Phase retrieval through focus variation for ultra-resolution in field-emission transmission electron microscopy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 69 (1992), 37433146. 11. C.L. Jia and A. Thust, Investigation of atomic displacements at a 1 3 { 1111 twin boundary in BaTi03 by means of phase-retrieval electron microscopy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82 (1999), 5052-5055. 12. H.W. Zandbergen, S.J. Andersen and J. Jansen, "Structure determination of MgsSis particles in A1 by dynamic electron diffraction studies", Science Vol. 277 (1997), 1221-1225. 13. S.J. Andersen, H.W. Zandbergen and J. Jansen et al., "The crystal structure of the p" phase in Al-Mg-Si alloys", Acta Mater. Vol. 46 (1998), 3283-3298. 14. Marioara, C. D., Andersen, S. J., Jansen, J. and Zandbergen, H. W., Atomic model for GP-zones in a 6082 Al-Mg-Si system, Acta Mater. 49 (2001) 321-328. 15. J. H. Chen, K. Urban, B. Kabius, M. Lentzen, J. Jansen and H. W. Zandbergen, Atomic imaging in aberration-corrected HRTEM with application to A1 alloys, Microsc. Microanal. 8 (Suppl. 2) (2002), 46 8-469. 16. J.H. Chen and H.W. Zandbergen, Atomic imaging of solute clusters in Al alloys, Proc. of thel5th Int. Congr. for Electron Microscopy, Durban (2002), vol. I, 71 1-712. 17. L. Zhuang, J.E. Janse, P. De Smet, J.H. Chen and H.W. Zandbergen, Natural Ageing Effect on the Bake Hardening Response in Al-Si-Mg Alloys, Proc. of the 2001TMS Annual Meeting: Automotive Alloys, pp. 77-91, (New Orleans, Louisiana, USA). 18. J. Bottema, C. Lahaye, R. Baartman, L Zhuang and P. De Smet, "Recent development in AA6016-T4 aluminium type body sheet product", SAE International Congress and Exposition, 1998, SAE Paper No. 981007. 19. J.D. Bryant, "The effects of pre-ageing treatments on formability and paint bake response", Automotive alloys 11, Ed. by S.K. Das, TMS'97, 19-36. 20. H. Uchida and H. Yoshida, "Improvement in paint bake response of an Al-Mg-Si alloy by reversion", Aluminium and Magnesium for Automotive Applications, Ed. by J.D. Bryant and D. White, TMS Publ. (1996), 97- 104. 21. M. Saga, Y.Sasaki, M. Kikuchi, Y. Zhu and M. Matsu, "Effect of pre-ageing temperature on the behaviour in the early stage of ageing at high temperature for Al-Mg-Si alloy", ICAA-5, Mater. Sci. Forum, Vols. 2 17-222 (1996), 82 1-826. 22. L. Zhuang, R. de Haan, J. Bottema, C.T.W. Lahaye and P. De Smet, "Improvement in bake hardening response of Al-Si-Mg alloys", ICAA-7, Mater. Sci. Forum, Vols. 331-337 (2000), 1309-1314. 23. P. Ringer and K. Hono, "Microstructural evolution and age hardening in aluminium alloys: atom probe field-ion microscopy and transmission electron microscopy studies", Materials Characterization 44 (2000), 101-131.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
LASER SURFACE ALLOYING OF CARBON STEELS WITH TANTALUM, SILICON AND CHROMIUM J. Kusinski and A. Woldan
Faculty of Metallurgy and Materials Science, University of Mining and Metallurgy, 30 Mickiewicza Ave., 30 059 Krakow, Poland
ABSTRACT The paper presents results of laser alloying that use laser beam in order to change the surface layer properties by changing its chemical composition and microstructure. The microstructure, chemical and phase composition and selected properties (microhardness, wear resistance) of the carbon steel laser alloyed with tantalum, silicon and chromium, were investigated. The surface alloyed zones varied in microstructure, depth, width and Ta, Si and Cr contents which depends on the thickness of pre-coated powder layer, binder type in the powder slurry and the process parameters (laser power and scanning velocity). The electron microprobe analysis of the alloyed layer showed that higher alloying element content in the melted zone resulted from the thicker pre-coated layer, lower laser power as well as higher scanning velocity Scanning electron microscopy examinations revealed that dendritic structure of the melted zone becomes evident when an organic binder was used as one of the slurry components. It was also found that the higher alloying element content in the alloyed zone resulted in lower weight loss during wear tests. Wear resistance analysis showed in general that the lowest weight loss of the surface alloyed samples was obtained for the thicker chromium pre-coated layer and for higher laser power used during the process of laser alloying.
INTRODUCTION There exists an increased demand for more producible and infallible tools and machinery components. Destruction process of such elements depends not only on the exploitation conditions but also on the hardness, wear, and fatigue and on the erosive and corrosive resistance of the surface layer. Generally speaking, materials should show a high resistance to different kinds of degradation. Wear of materials, which may be caused by adhesion or abrasion, is a surface or sub-surface phenomenon and can be reduced by modification of its surface layer [1,2]. Because wear and corrosion cost the economy many millions of dollars per year products with enhanced surfaces (i.e. friction, wear and corrosion resistance) are required [I]. The steels and cast irons used for high resistance to wear applications are usually composed of expensive alloying elements such as: Cr, Si, Ni, Co, Mo, Ta, Ti, V, or W. The high cost of using these materials for production of machinery components and tools are the main disadvantage. Since the durability of tools and machinery components depends strongly on the properties of the surface layer, this has led to the development and practical application of new technologies in the field of surface engineering. It can be noticed that the old surface technologies (e.g. thermochemical treatment, arc and induction hardening) are being replaced by new, energy saving, ecological and easily automated technologies (e.g. ion-assisted coatings, ion implantation, thermal spraying, as well as electron and laser beam treatments) [ 1,2]. Not all of these methods involve hardening of the surface layer. The change of the
35
J. Kusinski and A. Woldun
36
surface layer properties can also be obtained by changing its microstructure and/or chemical composition. Laser surface melting found many practical applications, as a method of formation of rapidly resolidified surface layers with many advantageous properties. Indeed, laser melting can harden alloys that cannot be hardened so effectively by laser transformation hardening. Application of the laser beam in materials processing lead also to the development of techniques changing chemical composition of the material surface layer, e.g. lasers cladding and laser alloying [3-61. Laser alloying of the material surface layer with selective elements, allows for modification of the properties of inexpensive products, instead of using very expensive highly alloyed materials [1,3-61. The potential of surface alloying to reduce consumption of expensive alloying elements is both strategically and commercially significant. The principal aim of the application of laser alloying technique in materials surface processing is to improve their properties due to formation of hard, homogenous and ultrafine structure of the surface layer by changing its chemical composition. Metallurgical changes that occur in the laser-modified layer are in the form of grain refinement, supersaturated solid solutions, and fine dispersions of particles. These can contribute to the hardening and strengthening of the surface layer. This technique is more and more popular, as there are several different ways to introduce alloymg elements into the thin surface layer melted by the laser beam [2-5,8]: direct injection into the melt pool at time of the treatment (powder, wire, gas); pre-placed adherent coatings deposited prior to laser treatment (electroplating, diffusion coating, thermal spraying, sputtering, etc.); pre-placed non-adherent coatings (foils, pastes, powder slurries). Recent results [2-71 showed that laser surface alloying of carbon inexpensive steels and cast iron with Cr, Si or C can convert microstructure and properties of the surface layer into ones characteristic of highly alloyed steels. Also, laser alloying of metallic substrates with alloying compounds, such as: W-Co-Cr-V, Ni-Cr-B-Si or Ni-Cr-Al-Fe [2-71, has been demonstrated as an effective method that modifies their surface layer properties significantly. To date, a variety of surface coatings have been easily achieved by using this noncontact and clean method [7]. One of the main interests in the surface alloying of Fe-base substrates is the production of a stainless steel surface equivalent [2]. Indeed, by laser alloying of iron or ordinary carbon steels, it is possible to obtain surface layers possessing chemical composition, microstructure and properties matching those of stainless, as well as tool, steels. After such treatment, alloyed surface layers, rich in alloying elements show higher hardness, better fatigue resistance, as well as better tribological properties and corrosion resistance than the substrate. Surface engineering of soft materials such as low carbon steels and other non-ferrous materials pose difficult problems. A main limitation is the lack of load bearing capacity of the substrate to support a thin surface layer whose hardness and other mechanical and physical properties are much different from its substrate. A solution to this problem is to strengthen the substrate by thermal treatment. The aim of this research was to study microstructure, chemistry and wear properties of carbon steels after laser surface alloying with tantalum, silicon and chromium.
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE The composition of investigated carbon steel is given in Table 1. The samples were available in the form of TABLE 1. NOMINAL CHEMICAL COMPOSITION OF EXAMINED CARBON STEEL
C I M n / Si 0.17 0.55 0.21
I
I
1 I
Chemical composition [wt %] P I S I Cr Ni 0.006 0.006 0.08 0.13
I
1
1 I
I I
Mo 0.04
I I
Cu 0.19
1 1
A1 0.028
10 mm thick, 26 mm wide and 300 mm long slabs. Before laser alloying the specimens were pre-coated with Cr, Ta and Sic powder slurries. The organic and inorganic components were used as binders during predeposition of these powder slurries on the sample surface. The thickness of the pre-coated layers was in the range of 0.08 - 0.40 mm (see Figure 1).
Laser surjuce alloying of carbon steels with tantalum, silicon and chromium
31
Figure I: Schematic showing the laser alloyng process
The Photon Sources VFA 2500 C02 CW laser of nominal power of 2 5 kW was used for laser alloyng The laser power (P) was varied from 1 35 to 2 18 kW and the process speed (V) from 12 to 20 m d s Such a laser treatment permitted to achieve different melt depths combined with a reasonably smooth surface without cracks The laser alloying was performed under an argon atmosphere (see scheme in Figure 1) Optical (OM), scanning electron (SEM) and transmission electron microscopes (TEM), microprobe (EDS), X-ray diffractometry, microhardness and wear resistance measurements have all been applied to analyze microstructure, chemical and phase composition as well as a hardness of the laser alloyed surface layer TEM examinations were carried out on thin foil specimens obtained from - 0 5 mm slices cut parallel to the heated surface and carefully polished down to about 0 05 mm The 3 mm discs were punched from these slices and mechanically dimpled and polished using a Gatan dimple After dimpling, all discs were electolytically polished using a Tenupol jet electro polisher and a 95% acetic acid + 5% perchlonc acid electrolyte The polishing conditions were as follows T = 16 - 17"C, U = 25 V TEM examinations were performed using the JEOL lOOCX electron microscopy operated at lOOkV
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Alloying with tantalum Figures 2a and b are the typical optical microscopy images showing the microstructure of Ta alloyed samples. The surface layer consisted of well-defined two zones: the zone that was laser melted and alloyed (LAZ) with Ta, and the heat affected zone (HAZ). The influence of the laser output power, the pre-
Figure. 2: Optical microscopy micrographs showing the microstructure of the alloyed samples in crossection; (a) - Ta + inorganic binder, g = 0.16 mm; V = 12 m d s ; P = 1.35 kW, (b) - Ta + organic binder, g = 0.16 mm; V = 20 mm/s; P = 1.8 kW.
38
J. Kusinski and A. Woldun
deposited layer thickness and the scanning velocity on the dimensions and the microstructure of the lasermelted layer was evident With increased scanning velocity, the laser beam-sample interaction time decreases and less laser energy is absorbed by irradiated matenal The same was observed with decreased output power Indeed, the size of the laser alloyed ( L a ) and heat affected zones (HAZ) decreased, too In such case, the laser beam melts only the pre-deposited layer of Ta and a limited thin layer of the base material As a result, the melted zone was rich in Ta The SEM microscopy examinations found a dendntic structure of the alloyed zone when an organic binder was used, while the structure has typically martensitic when inorganic binder was used for powder pre-deposition (Figures 3a and b) Two areas were well defined in the heat-affected zone The first one near the alloyed zone where during the laser treatment the matenal reachcd the austcnite rangc (betwccn sohdus and Az), contained martensite, and the second one near the matrix, where the material was heated to the A, - A3 range, contained ferrite and martensite (formed in the areas where the pearlite colonies were present before laser treatment) Samples covered with Ta and the organic binder showed higher hardness after laser alloymg than the samples covered using inorganic binder (Figures 4a and b) The electron microprobe analysis of the laser alloyed layer showed a higher tantalum content for a thicker original Ta coating as well as a slower scanning velocity (Figure 5 )
Figure 3: SEM images showing the details of the laser alloyed zone; (a) - Ta + inorganic binder and @) - Ta + organic binder
o
160
320
480
640
Distance from the surface [um]
Figure 4: The microhardness profiles of the surface layers after alloying with different conditions; (A) - Ta
+ organic binder, (B) - Ta + inorganic binder; g = 0.16 mm; a - V = 12 mm/s, P = 1.8 mmls, b - V = 12 mm/s,P=2.4 kW,c- V=20mm/s, P = 1.35 kW, d - V = 1 2 m m / s , P = 1.35 kW.
Laser surjuce alloying of carbon steels with tantalum, silicon and chromium
t.
39
Alloyed
F e - lo4
m
> P
-E
-
Mstnr
x /n
Ta
E
- 10'
I
I
Distance from the surface
-
Figure 5: Microanalysis showing the linear distribution of Fe and Ta in the crossection of laser alloyed layer; Ta + inorganic binder; g = 0.16 mm; V = 12 mmfs, P = 2.4 kW.
Alloying with silicon The SEM microphotographs in Figure 6a and b show the cross-section of the surface layer after laser alloying with chromium, when using following parameters: P = 2.18 kW, V = 20 m d s , g = 0.39 mm. The laser-affected layer is composed of two zones: laser alloyed zone (LAZ) and the heat-affected zone (HAZ). The macrostructure of the LAZ consisted of three well defined areas: an area where the planar crystals grow epitaxially on the partially remelted matrix grains (about 20 pm thick layer containing large martensitic needles, see Figure 6b), an area of columnar crystals (central part of alloyed zone) and an area of mixed dendritic/columnar crystals near the surface. These were the ferrite and austenite - crystals transforming after crystallization to martensite during rapid cooling of the material to room temperature. Indeed, the internal structure of the former austenite crystals consisted of martensite and retained austenite. The martensitic structure vaned in the needle sizes (Figure 7). The martensitic needles formed during the beginning stages of martensitic (y 3 a') transformation were very large, crossing several prior austenite crystals. Needles appearing in the later stages of martensitic transformation were fine. Their size was limited by the coarse martensite needles (Figures 7 and 8a) or austenite/ferrite interfaces (Figure 6b).
50 pm Figure 6: SEM micrographs showing. (a) - the microstructure of the laser alloyed and heat affected zones and (b) at the boundary of the laser alloyed and heat affected zones, (P = 2 18 kW, V = 20 mm/s, g = 0 39 mm).
-
40
J. Kusinski and A. Woldun
Figure 7: SEM micrograph showing acicular martensite in the laser alloyed zone with silicon, (P = 2 18 kW, V = 20 m d s , g = 0 39 mm)
Figure 8: TEM bright - field micrographs showing martensitic structure in the silicon laser alloyed zone; (a) - acicular martensite and @) - layer of retained austenite present between two martensite plates.
Figur ! 9: TEM micrographs: (a) - bright field; (b) - dark field images and related electrc n diffraction pattern taken from the laser-alloyed zone.
Laser surjuce alloying of carbon steels with tantalum, silicon and chromium
41
Such structure is characterized by a relatively high hardness level ranging from 700 - 1600 pHV, depending on quantity of silicon in the alloyed layer [8] The TEM microscopy studies revealed that there were three structural components acicular martensite, femte and retained austenite in the LA2 As was already mentioned, femte and austenite crystals were formed during crystallization of the silicon rich laser melted zone Microprobe analysis showed that silicon distnbution in that zone was not uniform The highest Si quantity was measured in the central areas of the alloyed zone (about 6 5% of Si), whereas, near the surface and near the bottom of the alloyed zone Si concentration was = 4% [8] Ihe I b M examinations did not show presence of SIC powder particles It seems that SIC dissolved completely in the melted pool Figure 8b shows a thick plate of retained austenite present between two martensitic needles Presence of retained austenite was confirmed by SAD patterns Figures 9 are the bright (9a) and dark field (9b) images presenting, interlath, thin films of retained austenite Alloying with chromium Similar to the case of laser alloying with tantalum and silicon, the influence of laser output power and scanning velocity on dimensions and microstructure of the chromium laser-alloyed layer (LML) was
Figure 10: a) - Optical image of the crosssection of the surface alloyed layer and SEM images of b) - the laser-alloyed zone (LAZ) and c) - the heat affected zone (HAZ), laser surface alloying with chromium using non-organic binder in the slurry
evident With increased scanning velocity, the laser beam-sarnple interaction time decreases and less laser energy is absorbed by irradiated matenal The same was observed with decreased output power Indeed, the size of the laser-alloyed (LAZ) and heat-affected zones (HAZ) decreased too In such case, the laser beam melts only the pre-deposited layer of Cr and a limited, thin layer of the base material As a result, the melted zone was highly enriched with chromium and carbon (in the case of using an organic binder in the slurry) The OM and SEM micrographs in rigure 10 show typical cross-section of the surface layer after laser alloying Lath martensitic structure, coarser than that observed in the heat-affected zone, was characteristic for the matenal alloyed with chromium (for pre-deposited chromium layer with non-organic binder) Figures 11 a - c are the microprobe line scans showing chromium distribution in the laser-alloyed layers The analysis was done for samples laser treated at constant g = 0 13 mm and V = 12 mmis, and with variable laser power (a) - P = 1 35 kW, (b) - P = 1 5 kW and (c) - P = 1 8 The depth of the substrate melted layer increase with the laser power, hence, for the same scanning velocity and the same thickness of the pre-deposited chromium powder layer, the alloyed zone was thicker and contained less chromium The dendritic structure of the melted zone was again evident when an organic binder was used (Figures 12a and b) The chemical compositions in the dendritic and the interdendritic regions at the middle part of the
J. Kusinski and A. Woldun
42
melted zone were analyzed by EDS. The average Cr content in the interdendritic regions was found to be higher than that in the dendrite center (the dendrite center - 8.22 wt% Cr; interdendritic regions -
LAZ
-of
Zi
0
Distance [pml
-+-+ 400
0
200
Distance [pm]
400
Distance [pm]
Figure 11: Microprobe line scannes showing chromium distribution in the laser alloyed layers; for constant: g = 0.13 mm and V = 12 m d s , and for variable laser power: (a) - P = 1.35 kW, (b) P = 1.5 kW and (c) - P = 1.8
Figure 12: SEM images of the sample alloyed with chromium using an organic binder: (a) - the central area of the laser-alloyed zone (LAZ) and @) at the boundary of laser-alloyed and hcat-affected (HAZ) zones. ~
10 08 wt% Cr, for the thickness of the pre-coated layer g = 0 26 rnm, V = 20 mm/s, P = 1 5 kW) The crystallization of the LAZ starts with planar epitaxial growth (Figure 12b) and, after 3 pm, changes to cellular and dendritic The cell dimensions were about 2 pm, corresponding to an approximate cooling rate The dispersion of the crystals and orientation in the laser alloyed zone depended on the of lo5 Ks direction of heat transfer and solidification velocity The TEM analysis showed that rapid cooling after solidification resulted in transformation of austenite to martensite, mainly lath martensite (Figures I0 and 14) However, regions of acicular martenslte were evident inside some cells - those containing higher carbon and chromium content (Figure 13, for 0 13 mm Cr pre-coated layer) This trend in martensite
'
Laser surjuce alloying of carbon steels with tantalum, silicon and chromium
43
formation is associated with the known reduction in M, with increasing Cr content, an effect enhanced by the extended solid solubility of Cr in austenite with rapid solidification The TEM analysis elucidated that martensite laths are separated by a thin film of retained austenite (see dark- field image in Figure 14b) Presence of plate-like &-carbidesin large martensite laths gives evidence that the process of auto-tempering occurs in the laser-alloyed layer This effect is due to the reversal of heat transfer from the warm substrate to the cold surface through the laser-alloyed layer In contrast, fully martensitic structure was observed in the laser-melted zone in case when uncoated samples were laser treated The microhardness within the laser-melted zone was constant for each analyzed layer, apart from fluctuations in the level of Cr due to microstructural heterogeneities The increase in hardness of the laser-melted zone wlth increased Cr content (Figure 15) was evident due to the presence of martensite and M7C3 carbides in the structure The high I
' I "
1
Figure 13: TEM micrograph showing microstructure in the chromium laseralloyed zone in low carbon steel; g = 0.13 mm, V = 12 mm/s and P = 1.5 kW.
Figure 14: TEM micrographs showing microstructure in the chromium laser-alloyed zone in low carbon steel: (a) -bright field; (b) - dark field images and related electron diffraction. hardness (1 720 pHV65) of the laser-alloyed zone (maximal for the thickness of the pre-deposited coating, g = 0.39 mm) may be attributed to the microcrystalline scale of the cell structure and to the extended solid solubility of the Cr in the matrix. In the heat-affected zone, hardness of 740 pHV65 (for samples heated with laser power, P = 1.8 kW) was measured, as is shown in Figure 15. The lowest hardness (650 pHV65) of the HAZ corresponded to a deeper melted zone and can be explained by the reduction in quench rate In order to examine wear resistance, various specimens were tested and their weight-losses were measured periodically. Figure 16 shows the weight loss for the various specimens Wear resistance analysis showed in general that the lowest weight loss was obtained for the thicker chromium pre-coated layer and for
44
J. Kusinski and A. Woldun
+V +V
=20 m,%; P -1.35 kW
=20m,k; P =1.5 kW
Figure 15: Microhardness of the laser alloyed layer of low carbon steel samples pre-coated with chromium-organic binder mixture.
Figure 16: Diagram shows wear resistance of the conventionally hardened low carbon steel and laser-alloyed layers with chromium: g = 0.13 mm and V = 12 m d s - constant, and variable laser power: P = 1.35, 1.5 and 1.8 kW.
higher laser power used during the process. It seems that alloying element content plays an important role in abrasive wear.The laser alloyed samples, having high chromium content in the surface alloyed zone, exhibit much better wear properties than those of the laser treated matrix (low carbon steel). Laser alloying of high carbon steel (1.25 wt% C) with chromium, under the same conditions as during the alloying process of low carbon steel formed different structures and properties of the chromium-alloyed layer. Optical microscopy examinations (Figures 17a and b) show structural inhomogeneity, which is due to the presence of well visible vortexes. The vortexes appear when the fluxes of Cr and C, that are present in the liquid material due to the convectional heat transfer that accompanies laser melting, are rapidly frozen during rapid cooling after. The cellular and dendritic crystals form in such chromium alloyed layers in high carbon steel (see Figures 18a and b). The measured cell size was in the range of 2 - 5 pm. Internal structure consisted of martensite and austenite (Figures 18b and 19). The inter-cell areas consisted of M7C3 and Mz3Cs (M = Cr, Fe) primary carbides precipitated during solidification due to segregation of carbon and chromium to the cell boundaries. Presence of martensite, M7C3, M23C6 carbides and retained austenite in the laser-alloyed zone was confirmed by XRD analysis (Figure 20). Such fine structure composed of martensite, M7C3, M& carbides and retained austenite, permitted to get relatively high hardness (1 8001900 pHV) in the alloyed zone (Figure 21) and good wear resistance (see Figure 22).
Laser surjuce alloying of carbon steels with tantalum, silicon and chromium
45
Figure 17: Optical images showing microstructure of the high carbon steel surface layer after laser alloying with chromium, (a) - P = 1 kW, (b) - P = 1,5 kW and V = 20 mm/s and g = 0.17 mm = const.
Figure 18: SEM images show microstructure in the central area of the high carbon steel surface layer after laser alloying with chromium; Cr powder mixed with an organic binder; P = 1,5 kW and V = 20 mm/s and g = 0.17 mm, (b) -magnified image of (a).
J. Kusinski and A. Woldun
46
Figure 19: TEM bright - field images showing microstructure of the chromium laser alloyed zone of high carbon steel; Cr powder mixed with an organic binder; P = 1.5 kW and V = 20 mm/s and g = 0 17 mrn; (b) - magnified image of (a)
548 7 I
M-martensite A-austenite
.-s E
v1
c,
E
n
0. ou
Figure 20: X-Ray diffraction pattern of chromium laser alloyed zone of high carbon steel.
41
Laser surjuce alloying of carbon steels with tantalum, silicon and chromium
I
2500
kw
+PP=l -P=1,35
lcJv
- a- P = 1 , 5 W
I
0
zoo
0
400
600
DistancehPm the surface [urn]
so0
Figure 21: Microhardness of the laser alloyed layer of high carbon steel samples pre-coated with chromium-organic binder mixture. 6 ,
I
El Matrix
a g = 0,17 mm, V = 12 rnm/s mg = 0,17 mm, V = 20 mmls
g = 0,37 mm, V = 12 mmls H g = 0,37 mm, V = 20 mmls
,
-
~~
_____
Figure 22: Diagram showing wear resistance of the conventionally hardened high carbon steel and laser-alloyed layers with chromium: g = 0.17 and 0.37 mm and V = 12 and 20 mmis, P = 1.5 kW - constant.
SUMMARY The structure of the LAZ depends on its chemical compOsition (Ta, Si or Cr contents). In all studied cases, two characteristic zones were distinguished in the laser processed material: laser alloyed zone (LAZ) of the resolidified matenal, Cr, Si or Ta nch, heat affected zone (HAZ) of the solid state hardened material. In addition, two areas were well defined in the heat-affected zone. The first one, near the alloyed zone, where during the laser treatment the material reached the austenite range (between solidus and A3), contained coarse martensite; and a second one, near the matrix, where the material was heated to the A, - A3 range, contained femte and martensite (formed in the areas where the pearlite colonies were present before
J. Kusinski and A. Woldun
48
laser treatment). The presence of cellular solidification structure in LAZ containing high carbon and alloying elements contents may be a consequence of solute segregation, which is determined by the shape of the solidus and liquidus of the constitution diagrams and cooling rate [6-81. The highest level of alloying elements in LAZ was reached when thick predeposited layers were remelted with substrate during laser treatment with high scanning velocity. Examinations showed that the microstructure and Ta, Si and Cr contents in the laser alloyed layer depends on the thickness of predeposited layers and treatment parameters, both influencing the S,/S, ratio (where S, and S, are the crossection areas of laser melted pre-deposited powder layer and the matrix, respectively). Studies by X-ray microprobe analysis indicated that the alloying occurs only in the laser melted zone. The tantalum, silicon and chromium contents varied from the cell boundaries and cell centers. However, inside the cells a fairly uniform composition was achieved in the case of all elements. The alloying elements content measured in the HAZ were at the same level as in the untreated matrix. Higher hardness was found in the alloyed layers containing average or higher contents of Ta, Si and Cr. Hence, it seems that solid solution hardening is less effective than transformation and precipitation hardening. Transmission electron microscopy examinations revealed that in the case of chromium alloying, the microstructures of LAZ are composed of lath martensite (frequently internally twinned) with some amount of plate-like E-carbide precipitates (present in large martensite laths) and retained austenite. In the laser chromium alloyed zones containing more carbon and chromium (characteristic for treatments when an organic binder was used for pre-deposition of powder layer on the sample surface) pnmarly M7C3 and M23C6 carbides in the cell boundaries were present. In the alloyed zones containing more Cr and high carbon content the martensite, austenite, carbides and 6 femte were present in the structure. Indeed, the hardness level of these zones, rich in Cr and C, was lower than that of the zones with martensitic structure containing less Cr and high carbon content. Research shows that, laser surface alloyed layers rich of silicon on the carbon steel can be easy produced with S i c powder. Acicular martensite, ferrite and austenite were identified in the laser-alloyed zones containing high C and Si concentrations, while lath martensite and retained austenite were identified in the zones containing low C and Si contents. Wear resistance analysis showed, in general, that the lowest weight loss of the surface alloyed samples was obtained for the thicker chromium pre-coated layer and for higher laser power used during the process of laser alloying. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The Faculty of Metallurgy and Materials Science, University of Mining and Metallurgy supported this work under grant No. 11. I 1.110.249. REFERENCES
1. Rickerby D.S., Matthews A. (1991) Advanced Surface Coatings: a Handbook of Suvfuce Engineering. Blackie & Son Limited, Glasgow. 2. Dahotre N. B. (1998) Laser in Suvface Engineering, Emptek Inc., Ontario. 3. Steen W.M. (1991) Laser Material Processing, Springer Verlag, Berlin. 4. Draper C.W. (1982) Journal of Metals, 34,6, p.16. 5. Draper C.W., Patoe J.M. (1985) Int. Met.Rev. 30,2, p.85. 6. Singh J.( 1994) Journal of Materials Science, 29, p. 5232. 7. Steen W.M. (1985) Metals and Materials 12, p. 730. 8. Kusinski J. (2000) Lasers - an Application in Materials Engineering, Akapit, Krakow.
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
IN-SITU TEM OBSERVATION OF ALLOYING PROCESS IN ISOLATED NANOMETER-SIZED PARTICLES H. Mori'. J-G. Lee' and H. Yasuda' 'Research Center for Ultra-High Voltage Electron Microscopy, Osaka University, Yamadaoka, Suita, Osaka 565-087 1, Japan 'Department of Mechanical Engineering, Kobe University, Rokkodai, Nada, Kobe 657-8501, Japan
ABSTRACT Alloy phase formation in nanometer-sized particles has been studied as a function of the particle size by in-situ transmission electron microscopy, using particles in the Sn-Bi and In-Sn systems. When the size of particles is larger than about 10 nm in diameter, essentially similar phase equilibrium has been observed in both particles and bulk materials in either system. When the size of particles is approximately lOnm o r below, however, the finite size effect has become significant. In particles in the Sn-Bi system, a thermodynamically stable, fluid amorphous phase has been formed even at room temperature (RT). Namely, an amorphous phase which goes to melt without crystallization upon heating and solidifies into an amorphous solid with no traces of crystallization upon cooling, has been formed. The Gibbs free energy of the fluid amorphous phase is then supposed t o be lower than that of a crystalline counterpart(s) at least at temperature near and above room temperature. This is a situation never happens in bulk materials. In particles in the In-Sn system, a liquid phase has been formed even at room temperature. It is emphasized here that neither the fluid amorphous phase in the former system nor the liquid phase in the latter system is the equilibrium phase at RT in bulk materials. These phases can be present at RT as phases more stable than the crystalline counterpart(s) only when the size of the system is in the nanometer range. INTRODUCTION In recent years, much attention has been focused o n small particles in the size range from a few to several nanometers. This is because these nanometer-sized particles often exhibit structures and properties that a r e different from those of the corresponding bulk materials [ 1,2]. For example, with regard to structures, it is well known that the stable structure of indium undergoes a change
49
50
H. Mori, J.-G. Lee and H. Yasudu
from bct for bulk to fcc when the size of particles is reduced down to several n m [3]. Also, it is well established that such phase transition temperatures as a melting point are significantly reduced with decreasing size of particles [4,5,6].Most of these studies are concerned with nanometer-sized pure substances, and in the related experiments temperature (T) and size (d) of particles were employed as experimental parameters. O n the other hand, studies o n nanometer-sized alloy particles, examined as a function of temperature (T), size (d), and composition (C), are quite limited [7-lo]. For example, studies o n the phase transformation in nanometer-sized alloy systems are rare [ I l l . The lack of studies o n nanometer-sized alloy particles is mainly due to the fact that it was rather difficult to control and measure the three experimental parameters, temperature (T), size (d), and composition (C), at the same time in a particle. However, recent remarkable progress in transmission electron microscopy (TEM) enables us to study not only the structure but also the chemical composition of an isolated nanometer-sized target material at a fixed temperature. Namely, with the use of this technique it now becomes possible t o examine the alloy phase formation in isolated nanometer-sized particles as a function of temperature (T), size (d), and composition (C) of the system [12]. This situation would open a wide, unexplored research field on the structure stability of nanometer-sized condensed matter in two- (or multi-) component systems. In fact, quite recently it was found with this technique that a unique amorphous phase that goes to melt without crystallization upon heating and solidifies into an amorphous solid with n o traces of crystallization upon cooling [lo], which has never been observed in bulk materials, does appear in isolated Au-Sn alloy particles when the size of particle is smaller than about 7 n m [lo]. The observation is of interest because the amorphous phase appearing in nanometer-sized alloy particles may provide an effective means for investigating the liquid-to-glass transition, the elucidation of which at an atomic level is one of the outstanding problems in modern condensed-matter physics [ 131. In the present work, in an attempt to have a better understanding of factors controlling the phase equilibrium in nanometer-sized systems, a series of in situ TEM experiments were carried out on alloy phase formation in isolated nanometer-sized particles in the Sn-Bi and In-Sn systems.
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES Preparation of nanometer-sized alloy particles was carried out using a double-source evaporator installed in the specimen chamber of a Hitachi H-800 type 200kV transmission electron microscope (TEM). The evaporator consisted of two spiral-shaped tungsten filaments. The distance between the filaments and a supporting film (substrate) for particles was approximately 100mm. An amorphous carbon film was used as the supporting film, and was mounted on a molybdenum grid. Using this evaporator, tin (or indium) was first evaporated from one filament heated by the Joule effect onto the supporting film kept at ambient temperature, and nanometer-sized tin (or indium) particles were produced on the film. Next, bismuth (or tin) was evaporated from the other filament onto the same film kept at ambient temperature. Alloy phase formation in the nanometer-sized particles associated with bismuth (or tin) deposition was studied
In-situ TEM observation of alloying process in isolated nanometer-sized particles
51
by both bright-field image (BFI) and selected area electron diffraction pattern (SAED). The microscope was equipped with a turbo-molecular pumping system t o achieve a base pressure of around 5 X 1 0 ' Pa in the specimen chamber. The electron flux used was approximately 1.5 X 102" e * m z s'.
-
A series of alloy formation experiments were additionally carried out i n a 200kV high resolution electron microscope (HREM) of Hitachi HF-2000 type, using a unique side-entry holder equipped with a double-source evaporator at the tip. T h e experiments were performed to study the atomistic structure of alloy phases formed A photograph of t h e holder used in the present experiment is shown in Fig.1. Figure I ( a) and (b) show a low-magnificatlon photograph of the holder and a high-magnification photograph of the part enclosed with a square i n Fig.1 (a), respectively. It essentially consisted of three spiral-shaped tungsten filaments, t h e middle filament of which was attached with a flake of graphite used as a supporting substrate Prior to experiments, the flake of graphite was baked at 1073 K for 6 0 s to get a cleaned surface of graphite. After being baked, the graphite substrate was cooled down to room temperature T h e preparation of nanometer-sized alloy particles was carried out in a similar way as that mentioned above. In this holder, the temperature rise of substrate during evaporation was estimated to he below 10 K. The base pres5ui-e of this electron microscope was below 5 X 10 Pa. For in situ H R E M observation of alloying process, a television Lamera and video tape recorder (VTR) system was employed. T h e chemical composition o f individual particles on the substrate was analyzed by energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS).
'
Figure 1: Side-entry holder equipped with a double source evaporator at the tip. (a) A whole view, (b) High-magnification photograph of the part enclosed with a square in (a).
52
H. Mori, J.-G. Lee and H. Yasudu
RESULTS The Sn-Bi system A typical example of alloying process of bismuth atoms into tin particles examined by a conventional transmission electron microscope (Hitachi H-800 type TEM) is shown in Fig 2 [ 141 Figure 2 (a) and (a’) show a BFI of as-produced tin particles on an amorphous carbon film and the corresponding SAED, iespectively The mean diameter of tin particles is approximately 6 nm. The Debye-Scherrer rings can consistently be indexed as those of pure B -Sn with a tetragonal structuie with lattice constants of a=O 581 n m and b=0.318 n m The structure is the same a s that of bulk [j -Sn Figure 2 (b) and (b’) show a BFI of particles after bismuth deposition and the Lorresponding S A E D , respectively The particle size increased from 6 nm to 10 nm by bismuth deposition The size increment partially came from the coalescence among particles. It was revealed by electron probe micioanalysis (EPMA) that particles shown in Fig.2 (b) contained, on average, about 60 at % Bi It should be noted here that n o interfaces weie recognized i n the interior of individual particles in Fig.2 (b) and only halos appeared in the S A E D (Fig 2 (b’)) This fact indicates that when bismuth atoms were vapor-deposited and came in contact with tin particles they dissolved quickly into tin particles to form either amorphous or liquid Sn-Bi alloy particles. To examine the atomic structure of the noncrystalline alloy particles as shown in Fig 2 (b), a series of in situ alloying experiments were carried out i n the HREM. The results will be shown later in Fig.3 Figure 2 (c) and (c’) shows a BFI of particles after additional deposition of both bismuth and tin and the corresponding SAED, respectively. T h e mean particle size incieased to approximately 20 n m In this additional deposition, the amounts of bismuth and tin deposited were controlled so that t h e composition of particles was kept constant at about 60 at. % Bi, i e , at the s a m e composition as that in Fig 2 ( b ) . It is evident i n F i g 2 (c) that there appeared definite
Figure 2. Alloy phase formation in nanometer sized particles i n the Sn-Bi system at room temperatuie. (a) BFI of as-produced tin particles on an amorphous carbon film, and (a’) t h e coiresponding SAED. (b) BFI of particles after bismuth deposition, and (b‘) the corresponding SAED. Particles shown in (b) contained, o n average, about 60 at. % Bi. (c) BFI of particles after additional deposition of both bismuth and tin, and (c’) the corresponding SAED. In this additional deposition, the amounts of bismuth and tin deposited were so controlled that the composition of particles remained unchanged as compared to that of particles shown in (b).
In-situ TEM observation of alloying process in isolated nanometer-sized particles
53
Figure 3: A sequence from a video recording of the alloying process of bismuth into a nanometer-sized tin particle. A crystalline-to-amorphous transition took place during deposition of bismuth onto the tin particle kept at room temperature (compare Fig. (b) with (c)). interfaces (arrowed) within individual particles. The Debye-Scherrer rings in the SAED can consistently be indexed as those of tin superimposed with those of bismuth. All these observations in Fig.2 (c) and (c’) indicate that in approximately 20 nm-sized particles of a Sn-60 at. % Bi alloy, each isolated particle was composed of two phases (i.e., tin and bismuth), which is the same phase equilibrium at RT in the bulk alloy of the same composition. Thus, I t seems safe to conclude the following from Fig.2. When the size of particles of a Sn-60 at. % Bi alloy is approximately 20 nm or above, a mixture of tin and blsmuth is the equilibrium microstructure at RT as in the case of bulk materials, but when the size of particles is approximately 1 0 nm or below, such a noncrystalline phase as shown in Fig.2 (b) and (b’) appears as the stable phase. This fact clearly indicates a strong finite size effect on the phase equilibrium in the binary alloy system. Figure 3 shows a typical sequence of alloying process of bismuth into a nanometer-sized tin particle as observed by HREM [14]. This observation was carried out to see whether such a noncrystalline phase as shown in Fig.2 (b) and (b’) was in an amorphous state or in a liquid state. The images were reproduced from the videotape. Figure 3 (a) shows an as-produced pure tin particle on a graphite substrate. The 0.291 nm-spaced fringes seen in this particle is the (020) lattice fringes of [j -Sn. Figure 3 (b) shows the same particle after bismuth deposition. The particle increased from 5 nm to 6 nm in diameter by bismuth deposition, but remained being a single crystal, indicating a solid solution is formed in the particle. With continued deposition of bismuth, the structure of the particle changed from crystalline to amorphous, as shown in Fig.3 (c). Namely, granular contrast, which is often called the “salt-pepper contrast” and is characteristic of an amorphous structure, appeared in the particle after bismuth deposition (Fig.3 (c)), instead of the lattice fringes characteristic of a crystalline solid solution (Fig.3 (b)). This fact indicates that a crystalline-to-amorphous (C+A) transition was induced in the tin particle by alloying of bismuth. The particle increased to 9 nm in diameter, and EDS analysis of the particle revealed that it contained 70 at. % Bi. One point to be noted here is the observation that the bright and dark spots in the granular image changed in position and intensity with time during observation. This is in sharp contrast to the feature of images obtained from the conventional amorphous material, in which these spots remain unchanged with time. An example of such fluctuation in granular contrast is shown in Fig.4 [14], photographs in which were reproduced from the videotape. Figures 4 (a) to (d) show sequential micrographs of one particle taken at a time interval of looms, keeping the objective lens excitation constant. The particle depicted in
54
H. Mori, J.-G. Lee and H. Yasudu
Figure 4: In situ observation of fluid amorphous formed in a 9-nm-sized Sn-Bi alloy particle. Sequential micrographs (a) to (d) were taken at a time interval of 100 ms. It is shown that bright and dark spots in the granular contrast in the particle changed in position and intensity with time whereas such lattice fringes in the graphite substrate as those encircled, remained fixed. This fluctuation in the granular contrast reflects a high atomic mobility in the particle. Fig 4 is the same as in Fig.3 (c). It is evident from Fig.4 that the bright and dark spots in the granular contrast exhibited continuous changes in position and intensity with timc whcrcas lattice fringes i n the graphite substrate remained fixed with time (for example, refer to such fringes as enclosed with a circle). This fluctuation in the granular contrast reflects fluctuation of the electron-optical phase shift, which comes from the fluctuation of local mass-thickness Therefore, the observed fluctuation in granular contrast provides evidence for the high atomic mobility enough to induce the mass-thickness variation in the nanometer-sized particle in a time interval less than 100 ms In other words, such high atomic mobility is responsible for the fluid amorphous structure observed in the particle in Fig.4. In an attempt to study the thermal stability of the fluid amorphous structure, annealing experiments were carried out. Figure 5 shows a sequence from a video recording of the melting and the subsequent solidification of a Sn-40 at. % Bi alloy particle heated and subsequently cooled in-situ i n the HREM [14] Figure 5 (a) shows an as-produced alloy particle at RT with a fluid amorphous structure, sitting on a flake of graphite (bottom). With increasing temperature, the time frequency ot tluctuation in the granular contrast became high, suggesting an enhanced atomic mobility (Fig.5 (b)) With continued heating, the particle eventually melted, and in the molten state there appeared only a quite uniform contrast typical of a liquid state (Fig.5 (c)). It is noted that prior to the melting no traces of crystallization were observed Upon cooling to room temperature, the liquid particle solidified again into the fluid amorphous phase, as illustrated in Fig 5 (d) N o traces of crystallization were again recognized prior to the solidification It is evident from Fig.5 that the fluid amorphous phase possesses a high phase stability so that upon
Figure 5: A sequence from a video recording of the melting and subsequent solidification of a ,911-40 at. % Bi alloy particle heated and subsequently cooled in situ in a HREM.
In-situ TEM observation of alloying process in isolated nanometer-sized particles
55
heating it melts without prior crystallization and upon cooling the melt solidifies directly into the amoiphous phase. This fact indicates that at least at temperatures near and above room temperature the Gibbs free energy of the fluid amorphous phase is lower than that of a crystalline counterpart(s) and in this context the amorphous phase 15 thermodynamically more stable than a crystalline phaTe(T), which is not the case for conventional amorphous alloys in bulk. Namely, in the case of conventional bulk materials, the Gibbs free energy of an amorphous phase is higher than that of a crystalline counterpart(s) and therefore crystallization always takes place once the atomic mobility in the amoiphous phase becomes high. It can be said that the thermodynamically stable, fluid amorphous phase observed here is an alloy phase characteristic to materials in the nanometer range. The In-Sn system A typical example of alloying behavior of tin atoms into indium particles is shown in Fig 6 [15]. Figure 6 (a) and (a’) show a bright-field image (BFI) of as-produced indium particles on a
supporting film and the corresponding selected area electron diffraction pattern (SAED), respectively The mean diameter of indium particles is approximately 7 nm The Debye-Scherrer rings in the SAED can consistently be indexed as those of a crystal with the face-centered cubic (fcc) structure with a lattice constant of a=0.471 nm (i.e , fcc pure indium). Figure 6 (b) and (b’) show a BFI of particles after tin deposition and the corresponding SAED, respectively. These photographs were taken immediately after tin deposition, that is, in less than 20 s after the tin-atom beam was turned off The particle size increased from approximately 7 nm to 16 nm in the mean diameter, as seen from a comparison of Fig.6 (a) with (b) Electron probe microanalysis (EPMA) of the same sample shown in Fig 6 (b) revealed that the material on the supporting film contained, on the whole, about 70 at. % Sn One point to be noted here is the fact that a distinct heterointerface is present in individual particles (as indicated with arrows in Fig 6 (b)) This fact suggests that individual particles are composed of two phases. The Debye-Scherrer rings shown in Fig 6 (b’) can consistently be indexed as those o f In?Sn (which has a tetragonal structure
Figure 6 Alloying behavior of tin atoms into indium particles at ambient temperature (a) BFI of as-pioduced indium particles on an amorphous carbon film, and (a’) the corresponding SAED (b) BFI of particles after depositing tin atoms, and (b’) the corresponding SAED. The mean Tize of particles in (b) was 16nm in diameter. The chemical composition of the particles was evaluated to be approximately Sn-30 at. % In.
56
H. Mori, J.-G. Lee and H. Yasudu
belonging to the space-group 14/mmm with lattice constants of a=0.346 nm and c = 0 . 4 7 ~nm) superimposed on those of InSn4 (which has a hexagonal structure belonging to the space-group P6/mmm with lattice constants ot a=O 72" nm and c=0.299 nm) These two phases are nothing but the conjugate phases predicted from the bulk equilibrium phase diagram [16] All these observations indicate that when tin atoms were vapor-deposited onto 7 nm-sized indium pai ticles, rapid spontaneous alloying of tin atom5 into indium particles took place and a5 a result a mixture of two phases, one was InqSn and the other InSn4, foimed within each particle The formation of the two-phase mixture in individual particles is in agreement with alloy phase formation expected from the phase diagram for the bulk. The above ohservdtion is consistent with a recent iesult that when t h e size of particles is larger than about 10 nm essentially similar phase equilibrium was observed both in paiticles and bulk materials in the Au-Sn binary system [17] Therefore, it seems safe to consider that the finite size effect on the phase stability in alloy particles is rather small when the size of particles is larger than approximately 10 nm. An example of alloying behavior of tin atoms into relatively small indium particles is presented in Fig.7 LlS]. F i g u r e 7 (a) and ( a ' ) s h o w a B F I of as-produced i n d i u m particles a n d t h e corresponding SAED, respectively. The mean diameter or indium particles is approximately S nni. The Dehye-Scherrer rings in the S A E D can again be indexed as those of fcc pure indium. Figure 7 (h) and ( b ' ) show a BFI of particles after tin deposition and the corresponding S A E D , respectively. The particle size has increased from approximately 5 nm lo 10 n m in the mean diameter, as seen from a comparison of Fig.7 (a) with (h). It should he noted here that no interfaces are recognized i n the interior of individual particles in Fig.7 (b), in conlrast to the observation depicted in Fig.6 (b). In t h e S A E D (Fig.7 (h')), halos are recognized. This fact indicates that vapor-deposited tin atoms c a m e in contact with indium particles and dissolved quickly into the particles to form eilher amorphous o r liquid In-Sn alloy particles. The formation of a noncrystalline phase is consistent with the observation that n o interfaces are present within individual particles (Fig.7 (h)). EPMA of the same sample shown in Fig.7 (h) revealed that the material on the supporting film contained, on the whole, about 7 0 at. 76 Sn. The stable phases in the In-70 at. % S n bulk alloy at room temperature are InlSn and InSn4. as mentioned before. Accordingly, it can be said that in In-70
Figure 7: Alloying behavior of tin atoms into indium particles at ambient temperature. (a) BFI of
as-produced indium particles o n an amorphous carbon film, and (a') the corresponding SAED. (h) BFI of particles after depositing tin atoms, and ( h ' ) the corresponding SAED. The mean size of particles in (b) was lOnm in diameter. The chemical composition of the particles was evaluated to be approximately Sn-30 at. % In.
In-situ TEM obyewation of alloying process in isolated nanometer-sized particles
51
I
Figure 8: In situ observation of alloying process of indium atoms into an approximately 5.2 nm-sized tin particle. A crystalline-to-liquid (C-L) transition took place during deposition of indium onto the nanometer-sized tin particle kept at room temperature (compare Fig(b) with (d)). The three numbers inserted in each micrograph indicate the time in units of minutes, seconds, and one-sixtieth seconds. at. % Sn alloy particles of approximately 10 nm in the mean diameter, stable phases in the corresponding bulk material are not realized. A series of in situ alloying experiments were carried out in a HREM to investigate whether the structure of alloy particles shown in Fig.7 (b) is amorphous or liquid. Figure 8 is a typical sequence of alloying process in an approximately 5 . 2 nm-sized particle. Figure 8 (a) shows an as-produced, pure tin particle on a graphite substrate. The 0.291 nm-spaced fringes seen in this particles is the (020) lattice fringes of il -Sn. The same particle after indium deposition is shown in Fig.8 (b). The particle remains being a single crystal, indicating a solid solution is formed in the particle. The diameter of the particle has increased from approximately 5.2 nm (Fig.8 (a)) to 6.7 nm (Fig.8 (b)) during indium deposition. The indium concentration in the solid solution estimated from the size increment is approximately 53 at. % In. With continued deposition of indium, the particle underwent a crystalline-to-liquid (C-L) transition, as shown in Figs.8 (c) and (d). Namely, all the lattice fringes in the particle disappeared abruptly and there appeared only a uniform contrast typical of the liquid state (Fig.8 (d)). The time interval between Fig.8 (b) and (d) is 1/15 s, indicating that the C+L transition took place very quickly.
In an attempt to confirm that such droplets as the one shown in Fig.8 (d) are not a solid amorphous phase but a liquid phase, a series of detailed HREM observations on alloy droplets were carried out. An example of the results is depicted in Fig.9 [15]. Figure 9 (a) shows an as-produced alloy particle. The particle is in a crystalline state and therefore in a state of a solid solution. The 0.292 nm-spaced fringes seen in the particle can consistently be assigned as the (020) lattice fringes of the solid solution with the B -Sn structure, while the 0.278 nm-spaced fringes as the (101) lattice fringes. It is noted that the foimation of facets can be clearly recognized on the surface of the particle. With continued deposition of indium, all the lattice fringes abruptly disappeared and at the same time the shape of the particle changed from faceted, polygonal to round. semispherical, ds seen in Fig.9 (b). It is worthy o f note that no salt-pepper contrast characteristic of a solid amorphous phase is present in the particle in Fig.9 (b). It is also worth noting in Fig.9 (b) that the Fresnel ring ( m o w e d ) appears almost symmetrically around the particle, which indicates that astigmatism is satisfactorlly corrected and therefore the absence of any contrast features does not come from such an extrinsic factor as the astigmatism but is of i n t r i n s i c n a t u r e Fig.9 ( c ) s h o w s t h e s a m e f i e l d as in F i g . 9 ( b ) but t a k e n in a c o n d i t i o n
58
H. Mori, J.-G. Lee and H. Yasudu
Figure 9: A series of HREM observations on an alloy droplet. (a) HREM of an asproduced, crystalline alloy particle, ( b ) HREM of the same particle after a melting transition, ( c ) the same field as in (b) but taken in a condition underfocused by an additional amount of 20 nm. underfocused by an additional amount of 20 nm. The fact that Fig.9 (c) was taken in a further underfocused condition compared to Fig.9 (b) can be confirmed from the observation that the width of the Fresnel maximum (the bright band double-arrowed) along the edge of the graphite substrate is large in Fig.9 (c) than in Fig.9 (b). It is evident that again no salt-pepper contrast can be observed in the particle in this varied defocus condition. All these observations clearly indicate that the droplet shown in Figs.9 (b) and 9 (c) is not a solid amorphous phase but a liquid phase. The results shown in Fig.9 indicate that such a droplet as in Fig.8 (d) is in the liquid state. The indium concentration in the liquid droplet in Fig.8 (d), estimated from the size difference between the particle shown in Fig.8 (a) and that in Fig.8 (d), is approximately 5 5 at. % In. Therefore, it can be said that the stable phase of approximately 5.2 nm-sized Sn-55 at. 70 In alloy particles at room temperature is liquid, and this is in sharp contrast with the equilibrium phase(s) in bulk materials (i.e., a two phase mixture of In3Sn and InSn4). Through the HREM observations shown in Fig.8 and 9, i t is verified that the structure of such alloy particles as depicted in Fig.7 (b) is not amorphous but liquid. One point to be noted here is the fact that the formation of liquid phase is in disagreement with a previous result that an amorphous phase was formed in alloy particles in the In-Sn system when the size of particles were less than approximately 20 nm [8]. The reasons for the disagreement are not clear at this moment, but it is worth noting that in the previous report [8] the formation of the amorphous phase was concluded only from the SAED showing diffuse rings and no complementary HREM study was done to draw the conclusion. So, there may be a possibility that the diffuse rings observed in the previous study came from not an amorphous but a liquid phase.
CONCLUDING REMARKS As shown in the preceding section, the finite size effect on alloy phase formation is not so strong when the size of particles I S larger than approximately 10 nm. In particles in the Sn-Bi system, a two-phase microstructure composed of tin and bismuth was formed at near eutectic compositions, whereas in those in the In-Sn system a two-phase microstructure composed of ln$n and InSn4 was formed. In both systems, the formation of the two-phase mixture is in agreement with alloy phase formation expected from the phase diagram for the hulk.
In-situ TEM observation of alloying process in isolated nanometer-sized particles
59
When the size of particles is approximately lOnm o r below, however, the finite size effect becomes significant. In particles in the Sn-Bi system, a thermodynamically stable, fluid amorphous phase was formed even at room temperature (RT). Here, the wording of “thermodynamically stable amorphous phase” comes from the fact that upon heating it went to melt without crystallization and upon cooling it solidified into an amorphous solid with n o traces of crystallization. T h e Gibbs free energy of the fluid amorphous phase is then supposed to be lower than that of a crystalline counterpart(s) at least at temperature near and above room temperature. This is a situation never happens in bulk materials. S u c h a situation is considered to be realized by q u i t e large suppression of the eutectic temperature, Teu, down to a temperature even below the glass transition temperature, Tg (i.e., T p T e u ) . This is a phenomenon induced by the system-size reduction down to a several-nm range [18]. In case the three temperatures, Teu, Tg, and RT (where the observation is carried out) lie in such an order as RT-Tg>Teu in nanometer-sized particles in the Sn-Bi system, it is then postulated that a crystalline-to-fluid amorphous (C+fluid A ) phase transition would be induced by simply adding solute atoms ( i x . , Bi atoms) onto nanometer-sized crystalline particles of a pure substance of tin. This postulation is in agreement with what is observed in the present work. In particles in the In-Sn system, the liquid phase was formed even at room temperature. The glass transition temperature, Tg, in this In-Sn system is supposed to be lower than that in the Sn-Bi system, since the liquidus line in the former system locates always below that in t h e latter system in the bulk phase diagrams. In case the three temperatures, Teu, Tg, and RT lie in such an order as RT>Tg>Teu in nanometer-sized particles in the In-Sn system, it is then postulated that a crystalline-to-liquid (C+L) phase transition would be induced by simply adding solute atoms (i.e., In atoms) onto nanometer-sized crystalline particles of a pure substance of tin. This postulation is again in agreement with what is observed in the present work. It is of interest to note here that in nanometer-sized particles in the Au-Sn system where the three temperatures lie in such an order a s Tg>RT>Teu, a crystalline-to-amorphous (C-A) phase transition has been induced by simply adding tin atoms onto nanometer-sized crystalline particles of a pure substance of gold [17]. Based upon the discussions, it seems that although different types of transitions are observed in particular systems ( i x . , C + A in the Au-Sn system, C+fluid A in the Sn-Bi system, and C + L in the Sn-In system), all the behaviors are consistently explained in terms of the relative position among Tg, RT, and Teu in the systems, and that these observations provide concrete evidence for the formation of a thermodynamically stable amorphous phase in nanometer-sized alloy particles over a temperature range from Tg to Teu.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS A part of this work was supported by “Nanotechnology Support Project” of the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT), Japan.
H. Mori, J.-G. Lee and H. Yasudu
60
REFERENCES
I.
2. 3. 4. 5.
6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11.
12. 13. 14. 15.
16. 17. 18.
Andres, R. P., Averback, R. S . , Brown, W. L., Brus, L. E., GoddardIII, W. A., Kaldor, A,, Louie, S . G., Moscovits, M., Peercy, P. S . , Riley, S . J., Siegel, R. W., Spaepen, F. and Wang, Y. (1987) J . Mater. Res. 4, 704. Halperin, W. P. (1986) Rev. Modern Phys. 58, 533. Yokozeki, A. and Stein, G. (1978) J . Appl. Phys. 49, 2224. Sambles, J. R. (1971) Proc. R . SOC.Lond. A 324,339. Buffat, Ph. and Borel, J-P. (1976) Phys. Rev. A 13, 2287. Allen, G. L., Bayles, R. A., Gile, W. W. and Jesser, W. A. (1986) Thin Solid Films 144, 297. Palatnik, L. S. and Boiko, B. T. (1961) Phys. Met. Metallogr. 11, 119. Allen, G. L. and Jesser, W. A. (1984) J . Cryst. Growth 70, 546. Jesser, W. A . , Shiflet, G. J., Allen, G. L. and Crawford, J. L. (1999) Mater. Res. Innovations 2,211. Mori, H. and Yasuda, H. (2001) Scripta muter. 44, 1987. Asaka, K., Tadaki, T. and Hirotsu, Y. (2000) Philos. Mag. A 82(3), 463. Yasuda, H. and Mori, H . (2002) J . Crystal. Growth 237-239, 234. Stillinger, F. H . (1995) Science 269, 1935. Lee, J. G., Mori, H. and Yasuda, H. (2002) Phys. Rev. B 66, 012105. Lee, J . G., Mori, H. and Yasuda, H. (2002) Phys. Rev. B 65, 132106. Binary Alloy Phase Diagrams, edited by Massalski, T. B. et a l . (American Society for Metals, Metals Park, OH, 1986). Yasuda, H., Mitsuishi, K. and Mori, H. (2001) Phys. Rev. B 64, 094101. Lee, J. G. (2003) Diploma Thesis, Osaka University.
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
CHARACTERIZATION OF METAL/GLASS INTERFACES IN BIOACTIVE GLASS COATINGS ON Ti-6A1-4V AND Co-Cr ALLOYS E. Saiz,' S. Lopez-Esteban,' S. Fujino,' T. Oku,' K. Suganuma3and A. P. Tomsia' 'Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA 2KyushuUniversity, Kasuga-shi, Fukuoka 816-8580, Japan 'Institute of Scientific and Industrial Research, Osaka University, Osaka 567-0047, Japan
ABSTRACT Coating metallic-based implants with bioactive materials promotes joining between the prostheses and the bone as well as increases long-term implant stability. In the present work, the interface between different alloys (Ti-6AI-4V and Co-Cr) and bioactive silicate glass coatings, prepared using a simple enameling technique, is analyzed at the nanolevel. Transmission electron microscopy and associated chemical analysis of the glassialloy interface show the formation of thin Ti& or CrO, reaction layers (-150 nm thick). These nanostructured interfaces facilitate the formation of a stable joint between the glass coating and the alloys.
INTRODUCTION Nowadays, biomaterials such as Ti or Co-Cr alloys are widely used in orthopedic and dental implants. However, their long-term effectiveness needs improvement [ 1-41, In particular, metallic implants have a variety of shortcomings related to their affixation, and in many cases, failures are caused by poor adhesion of the implant to the tissue or bone. A commonly used strategy to improve osseointegration is to coat the alloys with a bioactive material that will accelerate the stabilization of the implant and extend its duration. The fabrication of coatings for medical applications involves a compromise between adhesion, mechanical stability, and bioactivity, but coatings that satisfy all these requirements are extremely difficult to develop. For example, the most commonly used coating, plasma-sprayed hydroxyapatite (HA) [5, 61, shows several problems associated with its low crystallinity and adhesion that result in poor stability. Clearly, new coatings for implant materials are needed. Recently, we have developed a simple enameling technique to fabricate bioactive glass coatings on Ti- and Cr-based alloys. Using silicate glasses, it has been possible to fabricate coatings with a thickness ranging between 25 pm and 150 pm, which showed good adhesion to the metal and formed HA crystals on their surface during in vitro testing in simulated body fluid (SBF) [7-91. In order to design and control the interface between the glasses and the alloys, we must understand their bonding mechanism, which requires analysis of the interfacial microstructure at the nanoscopic scale. The purpose of the present work is to analyze the glassialloy interface formed during enameling. To understand the nature of the interfaces that showed optimum adhesion, microstructural analysis was carried out by transmission electron microscopy (TEM), a powerful method for structural analysis of advanced materials at the nanoscale [lo, 111. These studies will provide a guideline for designing and controlling the interfaces between metals and bioactive glass coatings that can be used in future prosthetic implants.
61
E. Suiz et al.
62
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES Silicate glasses in the system Si02-Na20-K20-CaO-MgO-P~0~ were prepared using a standard procedure described in detail elsewhere [7-91. The composition and properties of the glasses used in this study are shown in Table 1. The thermal expansion (a)and softening temperature (T,) were measured in a calibrated dilatometer with an alumina holder and push rod, using glass bars 25 mm long. Glass 6P50 was used to coat Co-Cr-based alloys, whereas glasses 6P57 and 6P64 were used to coat Ti-based alloys. These glasses have thermal expansions similar to the alloys. In that way, the generation of large thermal stresses during fabrication is avoided. To manufacture the coatings, the glass was milled in a planetary agate mill, and a suspension of the glass powder (particle size < 20 pm) in ethanol was deposited on flat metallic substrates -10 mm x 10 mm x 1 mm (Ti, Ti6A14V or Vitallium@,a Co-Cr alloy), which had been previously polished with diamonds (1 pm particle size) and cleaned in acetone and ethanol. Additionally, suspensions of the glass powders in ethanol with a 75 wt% solid content were used to coat cylindrical Ti6A14V samples (1 mm radius, 10 mm long) and titanium internal hexagonal cylinder dental implants (3.3 mm diameter and 10 mm length from 3iiimplant innovation) by dip coating, using a coating speed of 1,000 mndmin. The coatings on Ti-based alloys were annealed at temperatures ranging between 800°C to 820°C for 0 to 30 s in air, whereas the coatings on Co-Cr were fired at 750°C for 30 s. The adhesion between the coating and the alloy was qualitatively evaluated using Vickers indentations on the coating surfaces and polished cross sections in air, with loads up to 6.2 kg. TABLE 1 GLASSCOMPOSITIONS (w%) AND PROPERTIES
'Measured between 200400 "C Samples for TEM were prepared by cutting cross sections of the glass/alloy interface. The sections were ground to a thickness of -100 pm with emery paper, and then fixed into a Cu mesh with a 3 mm diameter. The disks were polished with a dimple grinder (Gatan, Model 656) to a less than 20 km thickness, and milled by argon ion milling. TEM observations were performed with a 1,250 kV electron microscope (ARM-1250 kV) having a point-to-point resolution of 0.12 nm, and a FEI TECNAI 20 electron microscope operated at 200 kV. Chemical analysis of the interface was performed using electron probe microanalysis (EPMA). In the elemental line analysis, the focused incident beam (-4 nm in diameter) was positioned across the glass/alloy interface, and an x-ray spectrum was acquired for 1 s at each position.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION After firing, the coatings exhibited good adhesion to the alloys. In indentations performed at the coating surfaces and the glasdmetal interfaces on polished cross sections, cracks did not propagate along the interface, but rather tended to be driven into the glass (Figure 1).
Characterization of metal/gluss intefaces in bioactive glass coatings
63
Ti6A14V
1
I
'
%
Figure 1. Vickers indentations at the glass 6P57/Ti6A14V (1.2 kg) and 6P50Ko-Cr (0.6 kg) interfaces performed in ambient air. The cracks were driven towards the glass, and the coating did not delaminate A TEM image of the 6P57iTi6A14V interface annealed at 800°C for 30 s is shown in Figure 2. An
interfacial titanium silicide (TiS&) layer, -150 nm thick, can be observed. The Ti& layer is divided into two regions: a continuous nanocrystalline layer in contact with the alloy and, on top of it, a zone with isolated Ti5Si3nanoparticles dispersed in the glass. The appearance of isolated particles on the TEM image can also result from the growth of elongated silicide grains, or dendrites, from the continuous layer into the glass. Consequently, they may appear as isolated particles (in the TEM samples) wherever the dendrite intersects the cross section. On the other hand, a thin (-150 nm) continuous CrOx layer can be observed at the interface between the Co-Cr alloy and the 6P50 coating (Figure 3). Figure 4 shows the Ti5Si3/alloy and TisSi3/glass interfaces. The lattice fringes of Ti (100) and TisSi3 { 121) are visible. See Figure 2 (a). A good lattice match exists between them, which can help in obtaining good adhesion. The glass/TisSij interface is shown in Figure 2(b). The size of the particles is in the range of -20 nm, and Ti& lattice fringes can be observed-{120}, { O l O } and (012). Following the experimental observations, the evolution of the glassimetal interfacial nanostructure can be summarized as follows. During heating, gas easily diffuses through the porous deposited glass coating, and a thin oxide layer forms on the surface of the metal. Thin-film x-ray diffraction showed the presence of an oxide layer on substrates annealed at temperatures below the glass softening point (550°C-650°C) [8]. At temperatures higher than the softening point of the glass, the glass layer sinters and flows. The inner glasdmetal interface becomes sealed from the external atmosphere, and the glass dissolves the oxide layer and starts to react with the substrate. TEM showed the formation of a -150 nm silicide or oxide layer after annealing. Coatings fired under these conditions did not delaminate during the indentation tests of adhesion [7, 81. TisSi3 and CrOx were also detected by x-ray diffraction and scanning electron microscopy in samples annealed at higher temperatures for longer times [8]. According to the previous discussion, the main reactions (formation of TisSi3 on Ti-based alloys, and formation of chromium oxide on Co-Cr alloys) can be written as:
8 Ti + 3 SiOz {glass} -+Ti5Si3 + 3 Ti02 {glass} 5 Ti + 3 SiOz -+TisSij + 3 0
2
?
(1)
(2)
Cr + 3/2 Na2O + 112 Cr203 + 3Na(g) ?
(3)
Cr + 1/2Si02 + CrO + li2Si
(4)
E. Suiz et al
64
6P57
A
=!
m .0 cn c 8 r v
0
200 400 Distance (nm)
Figure 2. TEM image of the cross section of a 6P57 Figure 3. TEM image and associated line glass coating on Ti6A14V annealed at 800°C for 30 s. analysis of the interface between glass 6P50 and a Co-Cr alloy after firing at 750°C for 30 s. If reactions (2) and (3) take place, the liberation of gas would form the bubbles observed in the overreacted samples [8,91 The bubbles and the thick, brittle interfacial reaction layers result in weak coatings with poor adhesion to the metal As an example, Figure 5 summarizes the evolution of the Ti6A14V16P57 interface during heating In conventional enameling theory, it is proposed that in order to achieve optimum glassimetal bonding, the glass should be saturated with the lowest valence oxide of the metal, without the presence of interfacial layers In this way, according to the theory, a transition region will form between the metallic bonding of the substrate and the ionocovalent bonding of the glass, providing a “continuity of electronic structure” that will result in good adhesion [12] However, the lack of characterization of enamel interfaces at the nanolevel precludes a complete confirmation of this theory More recent analysis of metalioxide interfaces tries to explain bonding in terms of fundamental contributions of image (electrostatic) forces and localized atomic bonding [13] In this work, optimum adhesion had been achieved through the formation of nanostructured interfacial layers For the coatings on Ti6A14V, the bond between the thin sihcide layer and the metal can be helped in part by the good lattice matching Also, if Ti5S13 dendrites grow into the glass, they can provide some mechanical interlocking that can contribute to the adhesion Consequently, control of the interfacial reactions at the nanolevel is a key fabrication step, and care must be taken to prevent excessive reaction, which can result in loss of adhesion due to the formation of a thick interfacial layer accompanied by bubbles in the glass
Characterization of metal/glass intefaces in bioactive glass coatings
65
Figure 4. High-resolution TEM image of (a) the Ti~Sij/Ti6A14Vinterface, and (b) the 6P57iTi~Si3interface formed after annealing at 800°C for 30 s. The optimum firing temperature is related to the temperature at which the glass softens and flows. The higher the softening point, the higher the temperature of the glass to flow, and higher processing temperatures are needed. For example, 6P68 coatings should be fired at 800°C in order to achieve the optimum adhesion, whereas, for the same firing times, 6P64 should be fired at 820°C.
Temoerature
o i', Ti-GAI4V Tc637 "C
I
Ti,Si, 150 nm
Ti,Si,
Ti-6AI-4Y
800"C,30seconds Optimum conditions
I
7
Gas bubbles
850 "C
Figure 5. Schematic illustration of the Ti6A14V/6P57 interface evolution during firing. Using the conditions described in the experimental section, it was possible to use dip coating to prepare -100 pm thick coatings on Ti dental implants with good adhesion to the alloy (Figure 6). During preparation of the ethanol-based slurries for dip coating, additional organics such as dispersants were not used in order to avoid additional problems related to burning of the organic materials (such as the formation of bubbles that cannot be eliminated in the short firing times required for Ti-based alloys). The firing conditions are similar to those used for the preparation of coatings on flat Ti6A14V substrates.
E. Suiz et al.
66
Figure 6. Original and coated titanium internal hexagonal cylinder dental implants. The -100 pm thick coating has been prepared using the enameling technique described in this work. SUMMARY The interfacial structure between Ti and Co-Cr alloys and bioactive glass coatings prepared using an enameling technique was investigated by TEM In coatings fired under the optimum conditions, reaction between the SiOz in the glass and Ti or Cr resulted in the formation of nanostructured interfacial layers (-150 nm thick) at the glass/alloy interface and optimum adhesion Control of the interfacial reactions between the glass and the alloys at the nanolevel was crucial.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors would like to acknowledge Prof K Hiraga and Mr B. Aoyagi for allowing us to use the ARM1250 kV microscope, and Drs S Hata and K Kaneko for TEM assistance. S Fujino wishes to thank the Japanese Ministry of Education, Culture and Science for a Young Researcher's Fellowship given to him in 2000, by the National Program of FelIowships for Young Researchers in Foreign Countnes S LopezEsteban was partly supported by a Fulbright Grant, and wishes to thank the Spanish Ministry of Education, Culture and Sports for financial sponsorship This work is supported by the Center of Excellence Project in the Institute of Scientific and Industnal Research, Osaka University, and the National Institutes of Health/ National Institute of Dental Research, Grant lROlDEll289, at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
REFERENCES 1 2
3 4
NIH Technology Assessment Conference on "Improving Medical Implants Performance through Retrieval Information Challenges and Opportunities" January 10-12,2000 Bzomaterials and Medical Implant Science Present and Future Perspectives A National Institutes of Health Workshop, October 16-17, 1995, Summary Report Bzomzmetzcs,Tissue Engineering and Biomaterzals, Nahonal Institute of Dental Research Workshop, September 24-26, 1996 Annual Meeting of the Amencan Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons 1999 Anaheim, California u.n n aaos coni
Characterization of metal/glass inter$aces in bioactive glass coatings
5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13.
61
Chae, J. C., Collier, J. P., Mayor, M. B., Surprenant, V. A. and Dauphinais, L. A. J. Biomed. Mat. Res. (1992) 26, 93. Tisdel, C. L., Goldberg, V. M., Pam, J. A,, Bensusan, J. S., Staikoff, L. S. and Stevenson, S. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery American Volume(1 994) 16, 159. Gomez-Vega, J. M., Saiz, E., Tomsia, A. P., Oku, T., Suganuma, K., Marshall, G. W. and Marshall, S. J. Advanced Materials (2000) 12,894. Gomez-Vega, J. M., Saiz, E. and Tomsia, A. P. J. Biomed. Mat. Res, (1999) 46, 549. Pazo, A,, Saiz, E. and Tomsia, A. P. Acta Mater. (1998) 46,2551. Oku, T. and Nakajima, S. Surf Sci. (1998) 407, L647. Oku, T. and Nakajima, S. J. Mat. Res. (1998) 13, 1136. Pask, J. A. Ceram. Bull. (1987) 66, 1587. Finnis, M. W.J. Phys.: Cond. Mat. (1996) 8, 5811.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
DEVELOPMENT OF ADVANCED MATERIALS BY AQUEOUS METAL INJECTION MOLDING
S. K. Das I , J.C. LaSalle
', J. M. Goldenberg ' and J. Lu2
Polymer Technologies Inc., Clifton, NJ 07013 Honeywell International, Tempe, AZ 85285
ABSTRACT
Metal Injection Molding (MIM) is a well known technique for the cost effective production of complex multidimensional components. In general, such components are small, less than 25 grams, and often made in high production volumes. They are employed in a variety of industry sectors, for example, automotive and firearms. Application to aerospace industry has been limited due to demanding specifications, relatively low production runs, and difficulty in working with relatively advanced materials such as nickel-based superalloys. The development of a water based agar metal injection molding binder has allowed us to mold and sinter large superalloy components with mechanical properties exceeding those of investment cast superalloys. Tensile and fatigue properties of nickel-based superalloy IN718 exceed cast properties and meet aerospace specifications. INTRODUCTION
Traditional applications for metal injection molding (MIM) have been small (<25 gram) net shape parts exhibiting design and economic benefits over wrought or cast components. The traditional MIM process consists essentially of injection molding of metal powderhinder feedstock into a cavity to produce a net shape green part. The binder is then removed and the component is then sintered to full density. The process is shown schematically in Figure 1 . The firearm, medical and electronics industries are traditional users of MIM components with the firearm industry historically being a prime producer. Advances in binder systems and instrumentation for injection molding and sintering equipment are resulting in a dramatic expansion of MIM into new components and markets. Recently, Honeywell [1,2] developed
69
70
S.K. Das et al.
Figure 1: Schematic of metal injection molding process using the aqueous based agar binder a new binder system for MIM that is an agar based aqueous binder. It eliminates the need for separate debinding and environmental liabilities associated with the debinding step. The result is cycle time reduction and cost savings compared with polymeric binders. The aqueous binder also molds at significantly lower pressures than traditional MIM feedstocks. As a result, longer thinwalled components can be molded as comparedwith traditionalMIM feedstocks. The low molding pressures also allow the use of soft epoxy/polymerictooling fabricated by rapid prototyping equipment. New component development times are thus shortened. Additionally,it offers the ability to produce large, thick parts more commensurate with those produced by investment casting. Net shape stainlesssteels components as large as 2 kg have been molded and sintered using the aqueous binder system. The advantages of the aqueous binder system are summarized in Table I. As a result of these advantages, the aqueous binder system is dramatically expanding the application of MIM to automotive, industrial, consumer, and aerospace components by moving MIM into parts traditionally manufactured by investment casting or wrought plus machining, Figure 2. Polymer Technologies is a licensee of the aqueous based agar binder and is now producing MIM parts on a commercial basis.
DESCRIPTION OF THE AGAR BASED AQUEOUS BINDER Traditional MIM binders are based on wax or polymeric systems that require the binder to be removed in a separate debind step, often taking many tens of hours. This debind step often requires acids or other noxious chemicals which present an environmental penalty and add significant process time. The aqueous binder is based on agar, a polysaccharidederived fiom seaweed used as a common food additive. It is hydrophilic, readily absorbing water. Metal powder is mixed with the water, agar and minor additionsto form feedstock pellets that can be easily fed into conventional plastic injection molding equipment. The metal powder
Development of advanced materials by aqueous metal injection molding
71
employed is typically under about 20 micrometers and is made by gas or water atomization. Compounding into feedstock is done by twin screw extrusion at rates 200 to 1,000 1bs.k. TABLE I COMPARISON OF AQUEOUS BINDER SYSTEM WITH TRADITIONALMIM SYSTEMS
I
Limitations of Todays Wax-Based Powder Injection Molding Systems
Benefits of Aqueous Based Agar Binder/ Molding System
+ Binder content - 10-20 Wt.%
+ Binder content - 2-3 Wt.%
+ Debindmg times - many hoddays
+ No separate debinding step required (Thick parts may require use of a 400 C/lhr hold BS part of sintering cycle)
+ Extra Steps - Special Operations
+ Water is the fluidizingagent - 8 wt. YO
(Powder pacWs0lvent extraction/bumout)
(evaporates &r molding leaving intergranularpores
+ Part Thickness < 1/4”
(for furepowdersyielding skong products)
+ No part thickness lhitations
+ Brittle as-molded part
(determines drying time)
+ Stiff but elastic as-molded part
+ Typical tolerance control to +/- 0.3%
+ Typical tolerance control to +/- 0.3%
+ Environmental Concern
(Explosive. toxicoutgas products or solvent requiring disposal)
+ No Environmental Concerns
i
8
lo*
‘S 104
s
a
E
a
Machining 103
Low
1 Medium
Investment casting
High
Complexity Figure 2: Schematic of market shift made available by the aqueous based agar binder
S.K. Das et al.
12
Typical metal solids loading of the feedstock is near 91wt% (61vol%), with approximately 2% agar and the balance consisting of water. The feedstock is relatively fluid at 85"C, having the consistency of toothpaste, Figure 3, and is thus easily injection molded into a net shape mold in a manner similar to plastic injection molding. Primary differencesare lower molding temperaturesand pressures. Upon cooling in the mold to near room temperature, the now molded feedstockdrops below its gelationtemperature, setting into a greenpart and allowing it to be removed. Cycle times are on the order of half a minute, depending on part size.
t
E
4 1
Figure 3 :Schematic of viscosity behavior of aqueous based agar binder
After approximately 1 hour in ambient air,the green part will have dried and is now ready to be sintered. No separate debind step is required as is necessary for traditional MIM feedstocks. Rather, a dwell time of approximately 1 hour is incorporated into the beginning of the sintering cycle. This step pyrolizes the binder, allowing the carbon to be removed during the sinteringcycle which is typically done in hydrogen or vacuum dependingon alloy. Sintering temperatures in the range of 1300-1400°Care typically employed for stainless steel alloys. Total debindinglsintering time is on the order of 14 hours using a large commercial batch furnace. Depending on part size, part loading quantities on the order of a thousand can be sintered in such furnaces, keeping per part sintering costs low.
MECHANICAL PROPERTIES 1 7-4 PH Stainless steel Many of the applications require demanding mechanical properties and dimensional tolerances. Figure 4 lists the average tensile properties of the stainless steel alloy 17-4PH,
14
S.K. Das et al.
Figure 5: Core and near surfme areas of 17-4 PH showing uniform formation of martensite Nkkel-Based Superalloy Inconel 718 One of the earliest nickel based superalloys developed is IN718. It is a precipitation hardened alloy strengthened by the y” phase, Ni3Nb, but it also has a host of competing phases which can form. IN718 is attractive for aerospace application because it has good high temperature oxidation resistance and strength to 650°C as well as good ductility and toughness. These positive service attributes,however, are a debit with respect to traditional forming techniques such as casting and machining, adding cost to complex shape components. Tensile properties are shown graphically in Figures 6a-d, which compare properties of Tensile Strength
0.2% Yield Strength
200
150
180
140
160
;; 130
‘
140
120
120
110
100
100
Figure: 6a Comparison of Ultimate Tensile Strength
Figure: 6b Comparison of Yield Strength
Development of advanced materials by aqueous metal injection molding
Elongation
15
Reduction of Area
25 20
s
15 10 5
0
Figure: 6c Comparison of Tensile Elongation
Figure: 6d Comparison of Tensile Reduction of Area
conventional cast, conventionalwrought, MIM and HIPed MIM components. In these figures, cast and wrought show specification minimum while MJM shows minimum and maximum values on the bars. Investment casting properties are the target of MIM components, since many of the aerospace components are conventionally cast and machined.HIPingof the MIM test bars to 111density does improve the tensile properties, as would be expected. It was found that the HIPed bars had superior ductility compared with wroughtproduct, although wrought had higher strength. Most notable, however, is that both the unHIPed and W e d tensile properties of the MIM IN718 easily surpassed the cast IN718 in both strength and ductility. High cycle fatigue properties were performed using an R= -1 (tensiodcompression)and k=l (smooth bar). The results are shown in Figure 7. Again, both the unHIPed and HIPed MIM IN718 surpassed the cast test bars, even when the cast bars were HIPed. Surprisingly, the UnHIPed MIM fatigue bars were comparable to wrought processed IN718 while the HIPed MIM bars exceeded wrought values. The superior properties are most likely a result of the refined grain structure observed in the MIM components
16
S.K. Das et al.
I10
m
B
m
m
m
m W
m 4
a rn
103
104
105
106
Cycles to Failure
107
108
Figure 7: High Cycle Fatigue IN718
AEROSPACE COMPONENT EXAMPLE Metal injectionmolding was thus explored as an alternative forming method for an aerospace flow body in alloy IN718. The flow body, essentially a butterfly valve housing, is extremely large by conventionalMIM standards,having an 8.8cm inner diameterand weighing approximately 1600grams. By formingthe thin wall ofthe body byMIh4 to the required final part thickness, significantlyless machining is required compared to a conventional cast machining blank, which must be cast thick to fully fill the part. The water based agar binder (1) was employed to utilize its low flow stress as well as its rapid and clean debind attributes. Before building a tool for such a large and novel MIM part, it was useful to mold and sinter a smaller prototype. Fortunately, prototype tool of a 7 cm ID tool existed for experimentation in plastic. Parts were successfullymolded and sintered, producing a sintered component 6.7cm ID. Excellent roundness was maintained during sintering through the use of proprietary setters. Before cutting a tool for the larger component, it was also desirable to employ mold flow simulation to explore gating options. Figure 8 shows the mold flow analysis applied to parameters commensuratewith the water based agar feedstock on the 8.8 cm ID flow body housing. After establishinga baseline by prototypingthe smaller flow body and performing simulation, a tool was cut and parts were molded and sintered. Water based agar feedstock of alloy IN718 was molded by Polymer Technologies, Inc. using an 350 ton Van Dorn Injection molding machine. Nominal chemistry of the alloy powder is 52.5Ni-18.5Fe-18.5Cr-5.1Nb-3Mo-0.9Ti-O.5Al-O.04C. Sintering was performed in batch sintering fiunaces, both Elnik and AVS. Proprietary setters were employed in a near net shape part requiring only minor finishingmachining. The green and sintered (8.8 cm ID) flow body are shown in Figure 9.The wall thickness of the green parts was typically 3 mm, filling a circumference of approximately 60 cm.
Hot Isostatic Pressing (HIP) was performed on one set of material to obtain full density and mechanical properties required by the aerospace industry. Solutionizingwas performed at 970°C for 30 minutes followed
I1
Development of advunced materials by aqueous metal injection molding
by a rapid gas cool. Aging was performed at 720°C for 8 hrs ramped down at a 4OoC/Hrrate to 620°C for an 8 hr hold, followed by an air cool to room temperature.
M
.
Figure 8: Moldflow analysis simulating time distribution as a function of different gating.
Figure 9: Green and sintered IN718 aerospace flow body housing
Densitiesof the test bars, as measured by Archimedes,are approximately99%. Carbon and oxygen values are 0.2 and 0.2wt??,respectively. It is noted that carbon for the cast and wrought alloys is nominallyO.O4wt%. An optical micrographs of sintered+heat treated material is shown in Figure 10. A refined microstructure is observed with equiaxed grains approximately20 micrometers. Some second phase precipitates are present, which are most likely carbides resulting from the carbon level.
‘IOUNO3 WNOISN3JUIa
PART 2: FUNCTIONAL MATERIALS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MICROSTRUCTURAL DESIGN OF NANOMULTILAYERS (FROM STEEL TO MAGNETICS) Greg Jan Kusinski and Gareth Thomas MMFX Technologies Corporation Irvine, CA 92612, USA
ABSTRACT The development of high-tech materials requires functional, multicomponent microstructures including multilayers, designed, processed and controlled at the micron and nanometer levels. It is now quite well recognized that to optimize and design materials for specified properties, materials are best utilized as composites. The nature of the components, their structures, morphologies and interfacial characteristics are most important. In particular, multilayered nano-structures are attractive for mechanical and many functional properties (e.g. magnetic). In order to understand the properties of any such multilayered system, and hence to be able to design pre-determined sets of properties, it is necessary to h o w their structure. For this reason, characterization of physical, chemical, and magnetic structures at relevant length scales is of particular importance. In this paper, attention is drawn to multilayered retained austenite/martensite (yret/MS) steels and multilayered Co/Pt films for high density magnetic recording.
INTRODUCTION Materials Science and engineering is concerned with understanding the relationships between processing, microstructure, and properties. With this understanding it is now possible to manipulate the microstructure down to the nano size, so as to achieve a set of defined properties. Since it is normally impossible to obtain such sets of properties in a monotonic monolayer, it is necessary to design the needed properties via composites within which the multilayer becomes an attractive morphology, and one in which control of the interfacial structure and bonding can be achieved. Clearly, the ability to characterize such nano materials requires advanced imaging and probe methods, within which high resolution (now at the atomic level), is essential. The results given in this paper, have involved detailed applications of electron microscopy, diffraction and microanalyses [ 1,2]. There are size limits that must be considered. Often no recognizable structures can be resolved when layer thicknesses are about 4 0 8, [3] and nano sized components do not necessarily have the same crystal structure as in bulk. Crystal structure determination is non-trivial and atomic imaging for real space analysis is becoming a viable approach [4]. Also as the dimensions of the components in the multilayers, approach nano scale and below, there is a marked increase in surface to volume ratios. Thus unique properties would be logically expected in such small scale composites
81
G.J. Kusinski and G. Thomas
82
In this paper we present results to show the microstructural similarity of nano composite structures in “traditional matenals” such as steels (to improve the mechanical and corrosion properties) and in the currently developing vertical magnetic recording materials for improving the information storage capacityof magnetic recording materials. The following abbreviations will be used through out this paper: Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM); Bright Field imaging in TEM (BF); Dark Field imaging in TEM (DF); Selected Area Diffraction (SAD ); High Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy (HRTEM); Multilayer (ML); Perpendicular Magnetic Anisotropy (PMA); martensite (Ms), austenite (y) martensite start transformation temperature (TMs),growth temperature (TG),Co layer thickness (tco),coercivity Hc.
NANO-LAYER MICROSTRUCTURES Steels-microcomposite martensite The austenite + martensite reaction in steels produces two main types of transformation products:- twinned plates when the transformation occurs at low temperatures (below about 250C), and packets of dislocated laths at higher temperatures (above about 320C). Figure 1 shows a schematic of the multilayer structure that is desired for improved properties. Crystallographic analysis, see Figure 2, shows that the orientation relationship is that of the Kurdjumov-Sachs (WS) with { 11l}y habits. Thus there is a maximum of four martensitic packets of laths per prior austenite grains. Notice also that the microstructure is designed to be free from precipitates such as carbides, carbonitrides etc. The basis for this is to greatly reduce the formation of microgalvanic cells between particles and ferritic matrix, which is necessary to improve corrosion resistance, especially in saline solutions. The current steels used in construction are generally femteipearlite mixtures such as in ASTM A615 steels, which are unsatisfactory for good corrosion resistance (see [5]).
Microcomposite Steels, Packet Lath Martensite
(Dislocated lath martensite enveloped by stable retained austenite films)
1 - Untransformed Nan0 Sheets of retained
BOUNDARIES WITHOUT CARBIDES
2 -Dislocated Laths
Figure 1 . Schematic of Microcomposite steels.
Microstructural design of nanomultilayers
83
Figure 2 shows an actual example of the multilayered austenite/martensite compostie -note the scale of the multilayer structure in the packet. Many investigations have been carried out on martensitic steels, but it was not until 1973 that the microcomposite nature of packet martensite was elucidated [6-81. The microstructure can be rationalized in terms of the temperature dependence of the resolved shear stresses for slip vs. twinning-the latter being preferred at low temperatures [S]. Twinned martensites are relatively brittle, and are generally to be avoided in designing for toughness at high strength levels [9,10]. However since the relationship between composition and martensite start transformation temperature (TMs) is quite well known, it is possible to design a packet multilayer martensitic steel by choosing compositions which keep TMSabove about 320°C [S]. This restricts the %C to be usually below about 0.35 wt%. Typical alloys include the Fe/Cr/Mn/C and Fe/Si/C systems [7-lo]. A model to explain the multilayer martensite/austenite composite has been published recently and is illustrated in Figure 3 [l 11. The multilayer composite contains the tough work-hardened laths of martensite linked coherently (with the Kurdjumov-Sachs WS orientation relation) to the untransformed, ductile austenite, giving a packet of alternating layers of austenite (-50 atoms wide) and dislocated martensite laths. Unlike pearlitichainitic microstructures, there are no carbides or other particles, and the high strength, high toughness derives from this microstructure. A variant would be dual/triple phase steels (DFM) in which the packets are mixed with ferrite. In all these alloys, the key to attractive properties is in maintaining the multilayer austenitemartensite composites in the packets by keeping TMSabove -320"C, and cooling fasl enough lo avoid nonmartensitic products. Such microstructures offer a range of attractive properties [ 12-14], and some examples are summarized below and in Figure 4, which compares some properties of the multilayered steels with commercial ASTM A615 steel (ferrite - pearlite).
Figure 2: Transmission electron micrographs showing the interlath retained austenite. (a) Bright field image - packet lath martensite. (b) Corresponding dark field image formed with fil y reflection -thin films of retained austenite reverse contrast. (c) SAD pattern showing K-S relationship of martensite and austenite and hence, coherent interfaces. DF image @) was formed with iil y reflection.
G.J. Kusinski and G. Thomas
84
Martensite dislocations
Solute ennched stabilized austenite
Figure 3: Schematic to illustrate the transformation of austenite (y) to martensite (Ms) and the stabilization of untransformed austenite between martensite laths. (a) “entrapment” of stabilized untransformed austenite between laths in the martensite packets, (b) “Final State”, Martensite and austenite layers not to scale. (b) Fatigue (rebar samples) 140
-
2
4
-
I
Typical Fatigue Llmtt MMFX .80 KSI
120 100 80
eo 40
20
aw
0
a12
OCS
QB
1000
, 10‘
7 0s
I 0‘
10’
Life (Cycles]
aslrniw
(c) Charpy impact energy TO
MFX
80
&,j 50
;
40
Y
2
50
P
1
20 10 0
.140
-110
40
-10
-20
10
40
70
100
TEMP deg F
Figure 4: (a) The tensile properties of Microcomposite steels compared to ASTM A615-ferrite pearlite steel, (b) the superior fatigue properties compared to A615, (c) superior DBTT and low temperature Charpy toughness, (c) corrosion samples after several weeks in 3% chloride. Note the A615 steel is almost totally destroyed by corrosion.
Microstructural design of nanomultilayers
85
Some properties (A) Variable strength may be designed by varying the %C in the laths since this is a linear relationship, or in DFM steels by varying the % packets+femte. Note there is no strict yield point, Figure 4(a), in the stressstrain curves from such structures since the laths are already rich in dislocations, and so the steel is already in the plastic condition. Typically the 0.2% offset in the stress-strain curve is taken as the “yield stress”, and the high tensile to yield ratios (1.5 or more), indicate excellent cold formability, e.g. for sheets (autos), wire and strands. This microstructure and its coherency allows plastic relaxation ahead of cracks, giving Klc values > 100 ksiJns [&lo]. (B) The multilayered structure contains no precipitates (carbides etc.) and hence there are few microgalvanic corrosion pitting centers. Thus there is a considerable gain in corrosion resistance especially in saline conditions. These benefits are now being utilized in new and repaired infrastructures in which corrosion limits the lifetime of steel in concrete structures (See the web site: [ 5 ] ) . It is an astounding fact that infrastructure repair costs are estimated to be approximately 4 trillions $ over the next decade. ColPt MAGNETIC MULTILAYERS Basis The realization in the past decade or so that many important magnetic properties are microstructure sensitive has led to rapid developments in the field of magnetic devices, involving atomically engineered thin films, nanostructures and multilayers. In these composites the structure of the interfaces between dissimilar materials or/and at the grain boundaries governs the novel properties (e.g. perpendicular magnetic anisotropy, giant magnetic resistance, etc.) [ 151. In particular, magnetic multilayers (MLs) composed of modulated ferromagnetic-nonmagnetic layers such as Copt MLs [ 16,171 with large perpendicular magnetic anisotropy (PMA) and high coercivity have recently been proposed as future magnetic media in Terabit/in* magnetic recording systems [18]. In addition, recent interest in Co/Pt was sparked by the discovery that the magnetic properties can he locally modified by ion-beam irradiation [ 19,201. Characterization of the microstructure and the magnetic domain structure in such films is important from a technological as well as a fundamental perspective [21-231. In this paper, the influence of growth temperature and multilayer thickness on the structure and magnetic properties of Co/Pt MLs are discussed. Other parameters which affect the magnetic performance of the MLs include magnetic patterning by ion irradiation which allows the separation of the vertical and in-plane magnetization. Further details can be found elsewhere [21,24-261. Microstructural characterization For the specific experiments discussed here, Co/Pt multilayers with representative structure: / 20 nm Pt seed / Nx(t nm Co/l nm Pt) / 1 nm Pt cap layer /, were fabricated by electron beam evaporation using a Torr base pressure deposition system [27,28]. Figure 5 shows a plan-view, bright field Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) image and Selected Area Diffraction (SAD) patterns of a Co/Pt multilayer grown at 250°C. The fine structure visible in some of the grains is attributed to Moirk fringes caused by the small lattice mismatch between Co and Pt. The plan-view SAD pattern shows the typical ring spacing associated with polycrystalline face-centered cubic fee) Pt except for ring splitting due to the presence of highly strained Co layers, which will be addressed later. The intensity distribution of the rings indicates a strong <111> texture with only some grains oriented randomly and contributing to the (1 11) and (002) ring intensities.
86
G.J. Kusinski and G. Thomas
Figure 5: (a) Plan-view TEM micrograph and (b) SAD pattern of a lOx(3 8, Co / 10 A Pt) multilayer grown at TG= 25O”C, (c) SAD with 30” sample tilt showing arcing of the rings. One of the questions to be resolved by careful characterization is whether the multilayers are alloyed or not, i.e. are the Co/Pt “pure” components. Careful examination of the SAD patterns revealed that all of the rings associated with thefcc structure were split, with separation Ag increasing with the diffraction vector g. For each doublet, the inner ring corresponding to a larger real space parameter is always more intense and the outer ring is weaker. This implies two distinctive lattice parameters through the thickness of the Copt multilayer stack. Figure 6 shows (a) the SAD pattern for the discussed Co/Pt multilayer and simulated ring diffraction patterns of (b) Ptf,, and Co Pt3, (c) Ptf,, and Cohcp,(d) Ptf,, and Cof,,. On all patterns, triangles label Pt rings: (11 l), (200), (220), (1 13) and (222). By comparing the simulated SADs to the experimental data shown in Figure 6 , it is clear that the layers must be “pure” Co-Pt both fcc. No evidence for alloying or ordered compound formation was detected. However, the ratio of the equilibrium Cofccto Ptf,, spacing in the simulated pattern is not correct. As shown, any two Co and Pt rings on the recorded diffraction pattern, for example Co(220) and Pt(220), are much closer to each other than on the simulated pattern (d). This implies that the Co layers are strained. Figure 6 (e) and shows simulated diffraction rings as a function of increasing tensile strain of the Co layers, with image (f) showing a good match. Hence, Starting from the seed Pt layer, the Pt(ll1) layers are stacked according to the equilibriumfcc stacking sequence observed in bulk Pt. The Co layers, which, in bulk are hcp, follow thefcc stacking sequence of underlaying Pt.
(a
Microstructural design of nanomultilayers
87
Figure 6: SAD pattern for the Co/Pt multilayer and simulated plan-view diffraction patterns for (b) Ptpc and Copt,, (c) PtP, and Cq,,,, and (d) Ptfccand Cof,, tnaiigles label Pt rings. (e) and (0 Simulated plan-view diffraction patterns of Ptrccand Cotccat various strains: (e)qo= 3.65 A, u= +2.85%, acJap, = 0.92 and (f) ac0= 3 85 A, u= +8.45%, aco/ap,= 0.98 Numbers label rings. 1) Pt(lll), 2) Co(1 ll), 3) Pt(002), 4) C0(002), 5) Pt(022), 6) C0(022), 7) Pt(l13), 8) Pt(222), 9) Co(113), 10) C0(222), (see text).
Figure 7 shows a lattice image with fcc multilayers stacking and good coherency across the CoiPt interfaces Ihis (1 11) stacking further implies a small volume anisotropy of Co Thus the perpendicular easy axis of magnetization is attributed to the interface anisotropy and in particular to strain contributions [29] d(,,,,,, - 2 265
A, d(,,,,c o =
2 047 A
Figure 7: Cross-sectional micrograph of a IOx(3 8, Co and 10 8, Pt) multilayer grown at T,
= 250°C.
88
G.J. Kusinski and G. Thomas
Analysis of the multilayers as a function ofgrowth temperature The microstructural evolution of multilayers as a function of growth temperature (TG)is presented in Figure 8, which shows plan-view BF images, SAD patterns and DF-hollow cone images obtained using (111) rings, (1 11)DF, of ML's grown at T, = 190"C, T, = 250°C and T, = 390°C. As depicted in the BF images, Figure 8(a), (e) and (i), all of the investigated samples were polycrystalline. The average grain size was found to increase with increasing T,. As discussed above the SAD patterns, Figure 8(d), (h) and (1) showed typical ring spacing associated with the polycrystalline fcc Pt structure. For all samples, a strong out-of-plane 4 11> texture was measured, as seen from very weak (111) and (002) rings and an intense (022) ring. Only some grains oriented randomly contributed to (1 11) and (002) rings. The SAD patterns from larger areas showed a uniform intensity distribution around all rings, indicating random in-plane orientation and only out-of-plane <111> texture.
Figure 8: Plan-view BF TEM images, SAD patterns and (1 1 1)DF images of the Copt ML's grown at TG= 190°C, TG= 250°C and TG= 390oC, displayed in rows. All SAD'S were collected with a 5 pm aperture ~41.
The (1 1I)DF images, Figure 8(b), ( f ) and (d), show the same areas as the respective BF images and display only the grains without the - 4 1 1> texture. Figure 8(c), (g) and (k) are lower magnification images showing the distribution of such grains. As presented, samples grown at the low temperature of 190"C, @) and (c), had a large number of grains lacking the < l l 1 > texture. The distribution of such grains was very uniform. With increasing T,, the number of such misoriented grains decreased. For the T, = 250°C sample, ( f ) and
Microstructural design of nanomultilayers
89
(g), the majority of misoriented grains were smaller than the average grain size, although a few, large misoriented grains were also found. For samples grown at 390°C, a good < l l 1 > texture was observed, with only very few grains lacking the <111> texture, as shown in (i) and (k). Moreover, such misoriented grains were much smaller than the <111> textured grains. Hence, as clearly shown by the set of (1 1l)DF images the <111> texture was found to improve with an increase in sample growth temperature. For samples grown at TGup to 300°C, all diffraction rings were split, indicating two distinctive lattice parameters for the Co and Pt layers, as discussed above. For samples grown at TG= 390°C above a critical transition temperature, T,,,,, the ring splitting attributed to the two separate Pt and Co parameters was not detectable, indicating a continuous gradient in lattice parameter between that of strained Co and that of Pt.
Structure as a function of Co thickness
The structure of Co/Pt multilayers was also investigated as a function of Co layer thickness (b).In agreement with previously published data [30], it was found that the stacking sequence in the Co layers changes with increasing Co thickness. At 0.2 nm - 0.6 nm Co thickness, the (Co/Pt) multilayer structure showed fcc stacking with 2.2 8, layer spacing. When the Co thickness increased beyond -0.6 nm, hcp stacking faults (SF) were observed and their density increased with increasing Co layer thickness. Above approximately tco = 15 A,the Co layer stacking is mainly hcp. Co/Pt multilayers with Co layer thickness below approximately 6 A were uniform and relatively defect free. The only indication of the Co vs. Pt layer in the HRTEM image was a slightly higher intensity in the Co layer due to preferential thinning of the Co layer during specimen preparation by ion-milling and a lower atomic number contrast. This intensity variation had a periodicity of the analyzed multilayers. With increasing tco, roughening of the MLs was observed, with increased number of defects (Figure 9). As shown, the measured intensity is much higher within the Co layer; however, the precise location of the CoiPt interface is not known. The (1 11) stacking sequence in some of the locations isfcc, (same vertical atom position for every third layer, ABCABC), but some hcp stacking (same vertical atom position for every second layer, ABAB) is also seen.
Figure 9: Cross-section HRTEM image of (1 11) 15 A, Co layer in the C o p t multilayer.
G.J. Kusinski and G. Thomas
90
Magnetic properties In addition to affecting the grain size and the <111> texture, TG is also known to influence the magnetic properties, such as coercivity (Hc). Magnetic hysteresis loops of the Co/Pt multilayers grown at different growth temperatures are shown in Figure 10. As shown, the perpendicular HC of the C o p t ML's was found to increase with increasing TG [27,24]. The coercivity increases by almost a factor of two on increasing the TG from 200°C to 300°C. However, when TG is increased beyond a critical transition temperature, Tc,it, a decrease in perpendicular coercivity is observed, and the HC for samples grown at 390°C is reduced to 5.8 kOe. A further increase in multilayer growth temperature results in loss of perpendicular anisotropy.
1
1
' d
05
' d
o .0.5
I
-15
I
I -10
0
-5
5
10
-1 5
15
H We1
(d)
45
1
05
0.5
' %
-0.5
1
-1.5 I .I5
40
-5
0
5
10
15
5
10
15
H LOel
1 -
1
i o
'
o .0.5
1
1 -1 .5
0.5
o -0.5 1
I
I -10
-5
0
H
60el
5
10
15
-1.5
I
.I5
I
I
.I0
0
-5 H
We1
Figure 10: Mgnetic hysteresis vs. multilayer growth temperature. (a) TG= 19OoC,(b) Tc = 250°C, (c) TG= 300°C and (d) TG= 390°C. These results show that the magnetic properties of such multilayer films depend on microstructure. With an increase in Tc up to a certain critical temperature, Tcrit, an increase in grain size and an improved <111> texture were found, both contributing to an increase in Hc. For ML's grown at TG = 390°C > Tait, a decrease in HC was measured, and small magnetically decoupled domains were observed. The size of these domains was similar to the grain size. This correlates well with Co depletion at the column grain boundaries and with the diffuse Co/Pt interfaces, measured as one set of Co-Pt rings. Such diffuse interfaces are known to reduce the PMA and, hence, reduce H,. Also with increasing Co layer thickness, a decrease in H, was observed. The coercivity is therefore a function of both the microstructure (grain size and texture) and interface quality, which is strongly influenced by Tc. Thus the magnetic properties can be engineered by appropriate choice of growth parameters and multilayer repetition. CONCLUSIONS
In this brief review we have shown that controlled multilayer structures provide superior properties such as mechanical and corrosion in austeniticllath martensitic steels, and magnetic properties in Co/Pt multilayers.
Microstructural design of nanomultilayers
91
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Work at NCEM/LBNL was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC0376SF00098. The authors acknowledge contributions from K.M. Krishnan, E.C. Nelson and G. Denbeaux of Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory and B.D. Terris, C.T. Rettner, A. Kellock and J.E.E. Bagglin of IBM Almaden Research Center.
REFERENCES 1.
2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
Williams, D.B. and Carter, C.B. (1996). Transmission electron microscopy: a textbookfor materials science. Plenum Press, New York and London. Thomas, G. (1998). In: Boundaries and Interfaces in Materials: The David A. Smith Symposium, pp. 3-17, Pond, R.C., Clark, W.A.T., King, A.H. and Williams, D.B. (Eds). The Minerals, Metals and Materials Society, Warrendale. Walton, C.C., Thomas, G. and Cortright, J.B. (1998), ActaMaterialia, 46,3767. Thomas, G. (1999). In: 20th Ris0 Int. '1 Symposium on Materials Science, pp. 505-521, www.mmfxsteel.com Krauss, G. and Marder, A.R. (1971), Metallurgical Transactions A , 2,2243. McMahon, J.A. and Thomas, G. (1973). In: 3rd Int'l Conference on the Strength of Metals and Alloys, pp. 180-184, LBL-1490 Thomas, G. (1973), Iron and Steel International, 46,451. Thomas, G. (1978), Metallurgical Transactions A , 9A, 439. Rao, B.V.N. and Thomas, G. (1980), Metallurgical Transactions A , 11A, 441. Thomas, G . and Kusinski, G. (2000). In: ASMHeat Treat Conference, An International Symposium in Honor of Professor George Krauss, pp. 515-518, Koo, J.Y., Young, M.J. and Thomas, G. (1980), Metallurgical Transactions A , 11A, 852. Kim, N.J. and Thomas, G. (1981), Metallurgical Transactions A, 12A, 483. Kusinski, G. and Thomas, G. (1999). In: Proceedings of 1st Int. Con$ on Automotive Heat Treating, pp. 17-25, ASM International Ultrathin Magnetic Structures I: an introduction to the electronic, magnetic, and structural properties, edited by Bland, J.A.C. and Heinrich, B., Springer-Verlag,Berlin, Heidelberg (1994) Carcia, P.F. (1988), Journal ofApplied Physics, 63, 5066. Weller, D., Farrow, R.F.C., Marks, R.F., Harp, G.R., Notarys, H. and Gorman, G. (1993), Materials Research Society Symposium Proceedings, 313, 791. Wood, R. (2000), IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 36,36. Chappert, C., Bernas, H., Ferre, J., Kottler, V., Jamet, J.-P., Chen, Y . ,Cambril, E., Devolder, T., Rousseaux, F., Mathet, V. and Launois, H. (1998), Science, 280, 1919. Weller, D., Baglin, J.E.E., Kellock, A.J., Hannibal, K.A., Toney, M.F., Kusinski, G.J., Lang, S., Folks, L., Best, M.E. and Terris, B.D. (2000), Journal OfAppliedPhysics, 87, 5768. Kusinski, G.J., Krishnan, K.M., Denbeaux, G., Thomas, G., Weller, D. and Terris, B.D. (2001), Applied Physics Letters, 79, 221 1. Thomas, G. and Hutten, A. (1997), NanoStructuredMateriab, 9, 271. Denbeaux, G., Fischer, P., Kusinski, G., Gros, M.L., Pearson, A. and Attwood, D. (2001), IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 37,2764. Kusinski, G.J., Thomas, G., Denbeaux, G., Krishnan, K.M. and Terris, B.D. (2002), Journal of Applied Physics, 91, 7541. Kusinski, G.J. and Thomas, G. (2002), Microscopy and Microanalysis, 8, 319. Kusinski, G.J., Krishnan, K.M., Denbeaux, G. and Thomas, G. (in press), Scripta Materialia, Weller, D., Folks, L., Best, M., Fullerton, E.E., Terris, B.D., Kusinski, G.J., Krishnan, K.M. and Thomas, G. (2001), Journal of Applied Physics, 89, 7525. Kusinski, G.J. (2001). Ph.D. Thesis, University of California, Berkeley. Zhang, B., Krishnan, K.M., Lee, C.H. andFarrow, R.F.C. (1993), Journal OfAppliedPhysics, 73, 6198. Li, Z.G., Carcia, P.F. and Cheng, Y. (1993), Journal OfAppliedPhysics, 73, 2433.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
EFFECTS OF TOPOGRAPHY ON THE MAGNETIC PROPERTIES OF NANO-STRUCTURED FILMS INVESTIGATED WITH LORENTZ TRANSMISSION ELECTRON MICROSCOPY Jeff Th.M. De Hosson and Nicolai G. Chechenin 'Department of Applied Physics, Materials Science Centre and Netherlands Institute for Metals Research, University of Groningen, Nijenborgh 4,9747 AG Groningen, The Netherlands. Skobeltsyn Institute of Nuclear Physics, Moscow State University, 118899 Moscow, Russian Federation.
ABSTRACT This paper concentrates on a detailed analysis of Lorentz transmission electron microscopy (LTEM) observations in the study of the magnetic properties of soft magnetic films. The nano-crystalline (Fe99Zrl)l-,NX, films have been prepared by DC magnetron reactive sputtering with a thickness between 50 and 1000 nm. The grain size decreased monotonically with N content from typically 100nm in the case of N-free films to less than 10 nm for films containing 8 at% N. Besides ripple fringes in the LTEM image that are commonly observed in nanocrystalline soft magnetic films also a dotted contrast apears along the ripple fringes. A theory of LTEM images for films with 1D- and 2D periodical topographies in combination with the micro-magnetic oscillations of the magnetization is presented. The theory predicts the 2D-pattern in LTEM in agreement with experimental observations. We show that in contrast to the traditional point of view not only the direction of the magnetization vector in nano-crystalline films makes a correlated small-angle wiggling but also the magnitude of the magnetization modulus fluctuates. LTEM studies were performed using JEOL 201 OF transmission electron microscope equipped with a post-column energy filter that provides an additional magnification of around 20 at the plane of the CCD camera with respect to the maximal attainable magnification by using a low field objective minilens.
INTRODUCTION In the early sixties of last century Gareth Thomas stood on the threshold of the development of transmission electron microscopy [ 11 and indisputably he became an inspiring and enthusiastic world leader in the application of this technique to solve materials problems. Only a few of us have pioneered so much in the structure-property relationship and in so many different areas of materials science. His research covered an extraordinarily broad range of topics, but it was and still is, characterized by a deep penetration into each subject to provide a thorough understanding. His seminal work stimulated hundreds of investigations over the last 40 years, clarifying structural aspects and thereby permitting analysis of the structural properties. Through these studies our understanding of the relationship between microstructure and property became more satisfactory and new concepts have been developed further. Besides structural properties Gareth Thomas showed great interest in the application of transmission electron microscopy to the field of functional materials. For instance he focused on a connection between the microstructure of various nano-structured alloys and the Giant Magneto-Resistive (GMR) properties [2,3] that also stimulated later our own scientific work [4,5]. Along these lines of his own interests this contribution concentrates on the application of transmission electron microscopy to functional materials, such as ultra-soft magnetic films for high-frequency inductors, to reveal the structure-property relationship. There exists an increasing demand for further miniaturization in portable appliances (e.g. mobile phones, palmtops), that is to say in communication tools. To this end the use of
93
94
J.Th.M. De Hosson and N.G. Chechenin
high-frequencies (e.g. 10-1000 MHz) in combination with thin magnetic materials is desirable. The use of magnetic films allows the integration of transformers and inductors into silicon 1C circuitry. Soft-magneticfilms are also widely used in modem electromagnetic devices as a high-frequency (>I00 MHz) field-amplifying component, e.g. in read-write heads for magnetic disk memories for computers and as a magnetic shielding material, e.g. in turners. The main requirements for the film material are: a high saturation magnetization, combined with a low coercivity and a small but finite anisotropy field. In addition the material should have a reasonably high specific electrical resistivity to reduce eddy currents, and also appropriate mechanical properties. To obtain the desired properties (low coercivity, little strain and very small magnetostriction) the use materials with grain size of the order of 10 nm nanometers, like nano-crystalline iron, becomes attractive [6]. Knowledge of local magnetic properties is essential for the development of new magnetic nano-sized materials. One of technique that is suitable for the measurement of local magnetic structures is Lorentz-Fresnel (or defocused) imaging mode of transmission electron microscopy. This rather classical TEM technique [7,8] has several outstanding advantages: uncomplicated application to various parts of thin foil, possibility of dynamical studies and good spatial resolution. Nevertheless, to obtain quantitative information from Lorentz micrographs is relatively difficult due to an in-direct link between image contrast and spatial variation of magnetic induction, which is problematic in regions of abrupt magnetization changes [9]. In this paper the possibility of a quantitative analysis of the magnetic properties of nano-crystalline iron using transmission electron microscopy is presented. The goal is to delineate a more quantitative way to obtain information of the magnetic induction and local magnetization. In particular the latter physical quantities affect the functional properties of ultra-soft magnetic materials for high-frequency inductors. One of the magnetic features that can provide quantitative magnetic information are the so-called magnetization or magnetic ripples, caused by local variation of magnetic induction that deviate from the mean magnetization direction [lo]. Besides Lorentz Fresnel (LTEM) also (off-axis) electron holographic modes can be used to analyze the magnetic structures [ 1I , 12,13,14,15]. For quite some time it is known that in polycrystalline and in nanocrystalline soft magnetic films with an induced uni-axial anisotropy, the direction of the magnetization wiggles around the easy axis producing a socalled micromagnetic ripple (see for example [lo] and references therein). The local variation of the magnetic field in a thin film influences the out-of-focus image in the transmission electron microscopy (TEM) via variation of the Lorentz force that acts perpendicular to directions of the electron beam and to the magnetic induction. Consequently, in Lorentz transmission electron microscopy (LTEM) the quasi-periodic oscillation of the transversal component of the local magnetization leads to almost parallel (1D) fringes in under- or overfocused images. From the spacing between the fringes the wavelength and the amplitude of the angular spread of the magnetization direction can be estimated using a simplified relation [I61 0.059-
C
Bt3,
where & is in degrees, B represents the magnetic induction in Tesla, f and Ax are the thickness of the film and the periodicity of the ripple structure (in micrometers), respectively. C = 2AUZo is the contrast of the LTEM image, where l o is the average intensity and AZ is the rms variation of the intensity due to ripples. This relation follows from both a classical approach of the LTEM imaging of micromagnetic ripple developed by Fuller and Hale [8] and a diffraction approach developed by Wohlleben [17], based on the theory of Aharonov and Bohm [18]. In both approaches the film is assumed to be flat and only the transversal component of the magnetization oscillates in the longitudinal direction. Often more complicated, e.g. bending or branching, Fresnel patterns are observed around magnetic domain walls, film edges, or for films with grain sizes larger than -50 nm [8,10,16,17]. The influences of the grain size and inhomogenieties on the periodicity and dispersion angle of the magnetization have been discussed in a number of papers [ 10,16,19,20]. Several of the studies has come to a quantitative analysis of Fresnel images of more realistic micromagnetic structure than proposed in [17], e.g. for a review reference is made to [21]. Here we focus on the analysis of an interesting complication of the Fresnel image, namely the variation of the contrast along the ripple fringes, which is visible in many LTEM micrographs, e.g. [17,22,23] but this has so far not been discussed in great detail. As an interpretation of this 2D contrast we suggest a model where the micromagnetic oscillations of the magnetization compete with oscillations due to topography of the film. Note
Effects of topography on the magnetic properties of nano-structured filmr
95
that the fluctuations or variations discussed here are only related to space modulations either of magnetization in the film or of intensity in the LTEM image. Any time dependence is neglected.
EXPERIMENTAL OBSERVATIONS Nano-crystalline Fe-Zr-N films have been prepared by DC magnetron reactive sputtering with a thickness between 50 and 1000nm. The presence of zirconium is to catch the nitrogen in the iron matrix. Iron was chosen because it is easy to prepare and cheaper than other soft magnetic materials, e.g. cobalt. The nitrogen is added to get a small (nano-sized) grain size. Pure (99.96 at%) Fe sheets partially covered with Zr wires were used as targets. The N and Zr contents were controlled by varying the sputter power andor the ArlN2 gas mixture. A 64 k N m magnetic field was applied in the plane of the samples during deposition to induce uni-axial anisotropy of up to 1.6 kA/m. More details on the film deposition can be found in [6,20]. The films have been deposited on a glass or silicon substrates at several temperatures between room temperature and 200 "C. The DC-sputtered samples were deposited on either a silicon substrate covered by a polymer, which was removed in acetone after sputtering, or on a silicon substrate covered by a Si3N4 layer. The former samples were extracted on copper TEM-grids for support, while the latter samples kept their substrate because the layers were very thin. The deposition conditions were chosen to obtain a composition (FessZrl)l.,N, ,where the concentration of nitrogen was in the range x I 2 5 at%. The best films as far as nano-size dimensions are concerned have been obtained for 8 at%<x<20 at%. The nitrogen concentration has been measured with Elastic Recoil Detection technique, Neutron Depth Profiling methods and compared with shifts in the XRD pattern. Standard 8 - 28 XRD scans showed that up to x=10 at% as sputtered films were bcc-phase materials with a strong (110) fiber texture. The grain size estimated from the width of the (110) peak decreased monotonically with N content from typically 100 nm in the case of N-free films to less than 10 nm for films containing 8 at%. The specimens were examined with a JEOL 201 OF 200 kV transmission electron microscope equipped with a post column energy filter (GIF 2000 Gatan Imaging Filter, with a resolution of 1024~1024pixels),which provides an additional magnification around 20 at the plane of CCD camera with respect to the maximal attainable magnification by using the objective minilens (magnification: 6 103).Grain size determination was done with several tilting experiments using an ACT: Automated Crystallography for the TEM, from TSWEDAX and a Gatan dual-view CCD camera. A single-tilt specimen holder and a double-tilt heating specimen holder were used. The images are acquired and edited using DigitalMicrograph (DM) 3.3 and 3.4 on both Apple Macintosh and Microsoft Windows PCs. Furthermore an additional script package for DM was used: the NCEM Package Image that was developed at the national center at Lawrence-Berkeley National Laboratory-USA. XRD as well as conventional TEM and selected area diffraction (SAD) reveal a 2-30 nm size of crystallites after various tilting experiments for most of the investigated sputter deposited films and in the diffraction pattern the allowed reflections for the bcc structure were found (1 10,200,211). No signs of F e 8 or Fe16N2 were detected in XRD. The average measured grain size is approximately 34 nm as shown in Figure 1. The grain size distribution is rather broad, even for sputtered films. Indeed one should be careful with this analysis when the film thickness is much larger than the grain size. The information of more grains on top of each other may cause the ACT to measure an incorrect grain size and a different orientation distribution. It should be stressed that the grain size distribution depends on the exact condition of the deposition process, i.e. on the nitrogen concentration. There are many defects in individual grains. With in-situ annealing till 25OoCthe grain size distribution becomes sharper and this phenomenon is related to the crystallization of the inter-granular amorphous-like phase. Figure 2 shows a cross-tie wall imaged with LTEM. Because the magnetization is perpendicular to the magnetic ripple structure within the magnetic domains, magnetic induction vectors can be drawn in the image(s). The magnetic ripples are characterized by the mean wavelength and the mean angle of deviation of the local magnetization variation. These could be scrutinized by a careful analysis of the Lorentz images in Fourier space. The procedure of image analysis is as follows and has been displayed in Figure 3. First an image containing homogeneous ripples is acquired. To determine the ripple wavelength the rotational average of the modulus of the fast Fourier transform (FIT) is calculated (Figure 3 B and 3 C). If a line profile from the center of the image is taken the wavelength can be determined. This is done by looking at the first order maximum (indicated by a vertical line in Figure 3 D). Using the distance between this peak and the central peak the average ripple wavelength can be calculated [24].
J.Th.M. De Hosson and N.G. Chechenin
96
t.
681 890116 1 1 2 1 3 8 2 5 3 3 3 8 U 2 5 7 7 7 5 4 G f a Durm(a Inn1
c) Figure 1: a) Nano-crystalline iron and b) SA diffraction pattern of nano-crystalline Fe94N~Zrl c) grain size distribution
Figure 2: LTEM observations: a) Cross-tie wall with alternating circular and cross Bloch ; b) LTEM image for a tilt angle of 2.8', with the tilt axis parallel to the easy axis.
A. Lorentr micrograph of magnetic ripples
B, FFT of
C.Rotaoonal average of
image 4
FFT of Lorenn image
E. Band pass mask on FFT of Lorena image
D. Lineprofile (fmm centre) of rotational average of FFT of Lorentz image
F. Rotational profile in band passed area
Figure 3: Schematic description of the quantification method
Effects of topography on the magnetic properties of nano-structured filmr
97
The deviation angle of the ripple spectrum can also be found by calculating the modulus of the FFT [23]. The FFT contains two triangular shapes, from which the mean deviation angle can be obtained (Figure 3). A band pass mask is applied on the FFT at the distance from the origin where the first order maximum lies. Then a rotational profile is taken within this filtered FIT. Then, the ratio between the peak width (indicated by the rectangular shape in Figure 3F) and the entire profile determines the angle. The peak width is determined by looking at the maximum intensity and by finding the points where the intensity falls to 5542 (-70%) of the maximum intensity. As revealed by atomic force microscopy (AFM) the films with Cu and with polymer substrates had often a roughness with a height variation up to 10 nm and a quasi-periodicity in the roughness of 100-200nm, in contrast to the films deposited directly on the Si, which were atomically smooth. An example of an LTEM image with a ripple structure is depicted in Figure 4. The thickness of the film was about 70 nm. The film deposited on a Cu substrate has a granular or hillock type of roughness with an rms amplitude of o = 5 nm, with the base of the hills between 100-200 nm and with the distance between hills around 200 nm as revealed by AFM scans depicted in Figure 5. The in-focus bright-field TEM image in Figure 6 shows a variation of contrast that is not due to finite grain size: the diffraction pattern in the inset in Figure 6 indicates that the film is in an amorphous state. The contrast of the LTEM digital micrograph in Figure 4 was analyzed taking linear scans at various places and in different directions within the image. A linear scan perpendicular to the ripple fringes (T-profiles) shows a quasi-periodic arrangement of the fringes, Figure 4b-d, with a wavelength h, = 0.22f0.02 km and a contrast of C = 0.5fo.1, see Table 1. This type of fringes corresponds to the wiggling of the magnetization vector, perpendicular to the easy axis, called here the transverse component of magnetization (TCM). With B =,uOMs =1.7 T, t = 70 nm Eq. (1) gives the amplitude of the wiggling angle ~ 1 . 2 ’or the amplitude of the TCM ,&AMoY = ,uOM& = 1.03x10”Ci(tAx) = 36 mT. In addition, the intensity of the image is rather inhomogeneous along the ripple direction, seen as a dotted contrast in Figure 4a, and demonstrated in the longitudinal scan (L-profile) in Figure 4 , e . This variation cannot be explained by longitudinal oscillations of the TCM, but requires a variation of the magnetization along the main direction, i.e. an oscillation of longitudinal component of magnetization (LCM). The periodicity of this mode is in between A, = 0.11-0.12 pm, the contrast C = 0.3-0.4, Table 1. If we write analogously to Eq. 1 for the oscillation of the LCM
then ,&AMoX = 41 -43 mT, which is only slightly higher than the amplitude of the transversal oscillation obtained before. In the next section we analyze a possible influence of the topography of the film on the LTEM contrast.
Scan TI T2 L1 L2
A,I*m 0.24 0.23 0.11 0.12
C 0.57 0.55 0.30 0.34
MAM, mT 36 36 41 43
PIO,820, degrees 1.2 1.2 8.9 9.1
zmax,nm 2.7 3.0
J.Th.M. De Hosson and N.G. Chechenin
98
wn
vm
Figure 4: a) LTEM image of micro-magnetic ripple; b) intensity profile in the transverse direction T1; c) intensity profile along the ripple in the longitudinal direction L1; d) intensity profile in the transverse direction T2; e) intensity profile along the ripple in the longitudinal direction L2.
Figure 5: AFM image of the (Fe99Zrl)l.,NX sputtered film deposited on a Cu substrate
Effects of topography on the magnetic properties of nano-structured films
99
Figure 6: Bright field TEM image and diffraction pattern.
THEORETICAL ANALYSIS A. Fresnel contrast of LTEM image. Following the theory of Aharanov and Bohm [ 181the phase shift between two points of the image is determined by the magnetic flux through the area within lines connecting the corresponding points on the upper and lower surfaces of the films and the trajectories of electrons passing these points, see e.g. [8,17]. If one of the points is at the origin of the coordinates we write for the phase shift
where @” = h/2e = 2.06.10 l5 Wb = 2.06 mT p 2 i s the magnetic flux quantum, e is the electron charge, h is Planck’s constant, t is the film thickness, B(r,t) is the local magnetic induction and dS is an element of the area, bounded by the two electron trajectories in consideration, and represented by the vector oriented along the normal to this element. For a uniform thickness Eq. (3) can be rewritten as
The intensity of the diffracted beam at the plane of LTEM image can be evaluated using the Fourier transforms technique, e.g. [25]: ~ ( x : y =IjjF(k~,k,)T(k,,k,)exp(i(k,x’+k,y?dk~dk, > 1’
where T(k,, ky) is a transfer function and
(5)
100
J.Th.M. De Hosson and N.G. Chechenin
is the Fourier transform of the exit electron wave function. Assuming that a plane electron wave exp(ik0z) enters the film, where k0=27r/& and & is the electron wave length (& = 2.5 pm for the 200 keV-electrons), and only the phase is modified by the magnetic film, the z-dependent part of thef(x,y) can be omitted in Eqs.(5,6), and then
Neglecting effects of the aperture and of the spherical aberration in the Fresnel mode of LTEM the transfer function in Eq.(5) can be written as [26]
where Az is a defocus value (- for overfocus, + for underfocus). A nonzero value of dz makes the ripple image observable. In this case Eq.(5) can be represented in the form of a convolution betweenf(x,y) in Eq.(6) and the Fourier transform of T(kx,ky),which gives
It should be emphasized that the theoretical analysis presented here is restricted to the case of uniform thickness and no external stray fields.
B. Effect of the micromagnetic ripple and 2D-topography of thefilm on LTEM pattern
A first contribution to the modulated magnetic induction, entering Eqs. (3,4), stems from the wiggling of the magnetization around the easy axis (EA), taken to be the x-axis. In the simplest approximation we have BY=&AMy(x)=,@Moys i n ( 2 n ~ / A , ~ )
(10)
The variation dMy(x)is the longitudinal oscillations of the TCM. A transversal fluctuation of dMy(y)was shown to be energetically unfavorable [ 10,161because it costs exchange energy. Therefore, oscillations of dMy in y- nor in z-directions do not appear in flat homogeneous films. The wiggling induces an internal stray field oriented parallel and antiparallel to the main magnetization direction. The magnitude of the stray field can be easily estimated as mst,,x -w$ Bi c o s ( 4 n ~/ 1 (11) Recently we have shown [20] that the internal stray field can strongly affect the FMR width and high frequency properties of the ultra-soft magnetic films. The presence of this stray field induces a small oscillation in the magnitude of the Lorentz force, acting perpendicular to the magnetization direction on electrons moving in the z-direction. As a second source of the magnetic induction variation we consider the contribution due to a 2D topography of the film. We consider a thin film deposited on a rough substrate with a two-dimensional periodical variation of roughness. The thickness of the film is constant and is smaller than the wavelength of the topography modulations. Due to demagnetizing effects the magnetization vector will follow the film zmodulation, so that projection of the magnetic induction will be
B,, = &M cosp,
&M(l-
8,’ / 2)
Effects of topography on the magnetic properties of nano-structured films
101
where the angle & = dz/dx describes the 2D-surface modulation in the x-direction with an amplitude &O and periodicities A2, and & in x- and y-directions, respectively. At this step we assume that the angle follows a periodic dependence on n- and y- coordinates in the form of:
which corresponds to the film surface modulation
shown in Figure 7 as a contour plot. In Eq. (1 4), zmx =&,I&J2n and for an rms amplitude of the substrate roughness of about 5 nm, zmar = 0, and a periodicity of 200 nm, the modulation angle amplitude is &O = 9’. Integrating Eq. (4), with Eqs. (10-12) we obtain
q ( x ,y ) =
{a (I
2nx
Q,
2n
- cos -)
4ZY 2 . 2 2n.X y 4, . 4ny +npf0ycos - y + p,, sin (-)[---sin 14x Ax 2 8n 4,
}
(15)
JlX
-6.4
-6.1
i
6.a
okx
Figure 7: Topography of the surface in the 2D-calculation Integration of Eq. (9) with Eq. (13) for the phase shift is not difficult but rather tedious. Assuming small values of S,, and S, and skipping all intermediate steps we arrive at the final intensity as a sum of five terms: I ( x ’ , y ’ ) = x Z n ,with
102
J.Th.M. De Hosson and N.G. Chechenin
where k = np&ftl@o,S, = ,&MtA,,P,012@o, S, = ~ t A ~ , & ~ l 2 @ 1 . It follows from Eqs. (16) that the intensity of the LTEM image varies in both x- and y-directions, responding to the modes of magnetic oscillations of TCM and LCM Eqs. (10)-(12). The second term, Iz, corresponds to the longitudinal oscillations of the TCM, Eq. (10). It gives a phase contrast for the fringes oriented perpendicular to the main magnetization vector. The period of these fringes is the same as for the micromagnetic ripple Eq.(lO). From Eq. (16) the predicted contrast of the ripple image is
The maximum contrast occurs when the defocusing conditions correspond to a situation where the sin term in Eq. (17) equals unity, leading to
This relation is just the same as Eq. (2) used before [ 16,201. The last contribution in Eqs. (16) corresponds to a variation of the magnetization due to the topography and gives a periodic contrast in bothx- and y-directions, i.e. a 2D-contrast similar to that observed in Figure 4. The wavelength of the intensity variation in the image is two times shorter than the wavelength of topography modulation, Eq. (13). The maximum contrast is
The third term I3 is due to stray field variation. It gives a contrast in the x-direction and no oscillating contrast in the y-direction, similar to the fourth term I,, which is due to the main, non-oscillating component of magnetization. Both these terms originate from the phase component with a linear dependence on the ycoordinate in Eq. (15), which appears after integration in Eq. (4) over dy’ of the x’-component ofB (which does not oscillate in the y’-direction). Removing non-oscillating terms, linear in y, Eq. (15) can be simplified to a form 2nx 1 2nx . 4ny p(x,y) = S , ( 1 - c o s - - ) - - ~ , s i n ~ ( - ) s i n ~ ix 8 4 Y 4Y
Taking only the first order terms in S, and S,, the intensity consists of three contributions:
Effects of topography on the magnetic properties of nano-structured films
103
The f i s t two are the same as I,, 12 , and the third one is similar to 15 in Eq (16). An example of the contour map of the intensity in Figure 8 illustrates the 2D type of the contrast calculated using Eq. (21). The parameters for the plot were chosen close to those for the film in Figure 4 t = 0.07 m, A,x = 0.2 pm, Azx= ?Q = 0.1 pn, zmlu= 5 nm, p&i = 1.5 T, B l 0 = lo, dz = 0.5 mm. The relations for the maximum contrast, Eqs. (17) to (19), are valid also for Eq. (21). Using the experimental data derived from Figure 4, C = 0 . 2 , s = 0.1 and t, p&i,listed above, from Eq. (19) we can obtain zmox= 3 nm, which is smaller than the rms amplitude of roughness of substrate and film surfaces, Figure 5. Evidently one of the reasons for such discrepancy is that the real topography differs from the simple periodical oscillations, Eq. (13), we used in the model calculations. A second reason could be a deviation of demagnetizing factor from one, resulting in smaller effective oscillations of Bx2,Eq. (12). Further, the linear approximation (1.e. weak phase object) may not be safely applicable with the high contrast values over the entire range 1
Y 0.5
0
-0.5
0
-0.5
0.5
x
1
Figure 8: Contour map of the LTEM image intensity according to Eq.( 19).The x and y coordinates are in micrometer. C. ID-wavefilm topography A 2D- contrast in LTEM can also be induced by a ID-wave-like film topography, e.g. such as described by z = z,,
sin(2lrx”i
(22)
as is illustrated by Figure 9. We suppose that x” -axis deviates by an angle y from x-axis (EA) in the xyplane.
104
J.Th.M. De Hosson and N.G. Chechenin
-0.4 -0.2
0
0.2
0.4 X
Figure 9: 1D-wave topography Since x” = xcos y + ysin y the tilt angle of the magnetization direction in the xz-plane with respect to thexy-plane is
A=-&= dz z,,,
2n
-cosycos
:[
-(xcos
1
y + ysin y >
Neglecting non-oscillating terms linear in y the phase shift is 2nx S, q ( x , y) = Sx(l - cos -) +-sin[ .1, 8siny
2n(xcosy+sin ysin y)
4
]-&sin(8siny
2nxcos y
4
1
(25)
Four major terms determine the intensity contrast in this case:
It follows from these equations and Figure 10 that the compromise between the micromagnetic (12) and topography (13 and 1 4 ) oscillations depends not only on the combination of the micromagnetic and topography
Effectsof topography on the mugnetzcpropertzes of nu?io-structuredfi~~?~
105
parameters but It also critically depends on the tilt angle?. When the topography wave vector IS parallel to the EA, PO, then there is no y-oscillations, but at y >O the topography component can be even more pronounced than the micromagnetlc component and could lead to fringes whlch are oriented perpendlcular to the topography wave vector as illustrated in Figure 10. Consequently for this reason one must be careful in asslgnlng the direction of the m a n magnetlzation.
-0.5
0 1
Y 0 .s
-0J
-0 J
0
Figure 10: a) Calculated LTEM contrast for the ID-wave topography with a wave vector that deviates by an angle y of 30' form the EA; b) calculated LTEM contrast for the 1 D-wave topography with a wave vector that devlates by an angle of 30' form the EA; c) calculated LTEM contrast for the 1D-wave topography with a wave vector that deviates by an angle of 90' form the EA.
106
J.Th.M. De Hosson and N.G. Chechenin
DISCUSSION Deviations of thin film interfaces from flatness may have a substantial effect on their physical properties, e.g. magnetic coercive field, demagnetizing field, giant magetoresistance and domain walls [27, 28, 29, 301. Recently the effects of roughness on magnetic properties have been examined describing the roughness in terms of a self-affine fractal scaling but these studies are focused on the theoretical description rather than on an experimental validation. The purpose of this paper is to promote transmission electron microscopy not only as a tool for observing structural defects at the highest possible resolution but to employ the technique for measuring the effect of topology on physical properties as well. In this way the linkage between structural information and functional properties can be made. We emphasize that the 2D LTEM patterns considered here refer to the dotted contrast along the ripple fringes and not to two-dimensional features due to a bending, crossing, or branching of the fringes itself, as considered elsewhere, e.g. [25,26]. With this bending-crossing-branching the Fresnel images are always 2D patterns. The micromagnetic oscillation of magnetization in nanocrystalline materials is driven by the coupling volume of the exchange interaction. Estimations [16] show that the longitudinal size of the coupling volume (along the EA) according to Hoffmann [lo] is of the order of the ripple wavelength and orders of magnitude smaller than the transversal sizes of the coupling volume (perpendicular to the EA) 1251. (We agree with [25] that quantitative estimates based on Hoffmann theory should be taken with precaution). With the dotted contrast the wavelength ratio is reversed: the periodicity of dotted contrast is usually smaller than that for micromagnetic ripple. This supports the idea that transversal oscillations of TCM cannot be considered as a possible source of the dotted contrast reported here. As a matter of course our simulated images Figures 8,lO are rather idealized. If we include for example terms with higher orders of S, , S, the images become more complicated but resemble more the experimental ones. In this paper we do not pursue the goal to reproduce fully the experimental images, but to find analytical relations between selected features of the LTEM images and the magnetic features so as to find the physical reason. We have demonstrated that the model of TCM plus topography oscillations developed here predicts reasonable values for parameters of both the ripple fringes and dotted contrast. Relating our analysis to the values of the contrast we eliminate the problem caused in another approach [3 11, in which an out-of-focus image is divided by the in-focused image. In our case one obtains the contrast value from neighboring peaks of intensity in a single out-of-focus image. Nevertheless it may produce problems in the analysis of emulsion micrographs due to a possible non-linearity of emulsion contrast with respect to the recorded electron density. It is also evident from simulations and Eqs. (15), (20) and (25) that variation of the intensity in ydirection occurs not only at maximum intensity in x-direction, but at all possible x-values. This is also in agreement with experimental observations. Dotted contrast appears on the top of the fringes only because of an intensity threshold to demonstrate the image contrast. Similar variations of intensity exist in any scan between the ripple fringes.
CONCLUSIONS We have shown that in addition to the quasi-periodic ripple structure of the Fresnel contrast caused by an oscillation of the magnetization around the easy axis, there exists a dotted contrast along the ripple fringes. This type of contrast can be simulated within a model of image comprising the oscillations of magnetization around easy direction and a wavy topological structure; the former mode gives periodical ripples with the wave vector parallel to the easy axis, whereas the latter one gives the dotted contrast along the ripple fringes. The observed and simulated contrast of both longitudinal and transversal modes of the ripple is in reasonable agreement for the case of significant ripple structure. It is also shown that at a large surface roughness the LTEM ripple fringes can follow the direction of the topography oscillations and not the micromagnetic ripple what can cause considerable mistakes in interpretation of LTEM patterns. However, in most practical cases the topologyinduced contrast is negligible, because it is proportional to the square of the amplitude of the angle variation, & ,: which is usually small enough.
Effectsof topography on the magnetic properties of nano-structured films
107
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thanks are due to Professor Gareth Thomas for his stimulus provided over the years to the microscopy research in our Department of Applied Physics at the University of Groningen, the Netherlands. The work is part of the research program of the Priority Program on Materials of the Netherlands Organization of Research (NWO- The Hague) and supported by the Netherlands Foundation for Technical Sciences and the Netherlands Institute for Metals Research. Discussions with Tomas Vystavel, Daan Hein Alsem, Toni Chezan, Bart Kooi, George Palasantzas and Dik Boerma are gratefully acknowledged. References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28.
Thomas,G. and Goringe, M.J. (1979) Transmission Electron Microscopy of Materials. Wiley, New York. Berkowitz, A.E., Mitchell, J.R., Carey, M.J., Young, A.P., Zhang, S., Spada, F.E., Parker, F.T., Hutten, A., Thomas, G. (1992) Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 3745. Hutten, A,, Bemardi, J., Friedrichs, S., Thomas, G. (1995) Scripta Metull. 33, 1647. Vrenken, H., Kooi, B.J., De Hosson, J.Th.M. (2001)J. Appl. Phys. 89,3381. Kooi, B.J., Vystavel, T.,De Hosson, J.Th.M. (2001)J. Nanoscience and Nanotechnology 1,65. A.R. Chezan (2002).PhD Thesis, University of Groningen, The Netherlands. Grundy, P.J., Tebble, R.S. (1968)Advances in Physics 17: p. 153. Fuller, H.W., Hale, M.E. (1960)J. Appl. Phys. 31,238. De Graef, M. (2000). In: Experimental Methods in the Physical Sciences, Volume36: Magnetic Imaging and its Applications to Materials, Chapter 2, pp.27, M. De Graef and Y. Zhu (Eds), Chapter 2, pp.27. Academic Press, New York. Hoffmann, H. (1964)J. Appl. Phys. 35,1790. McCartney, M.R., Dunin-Borkowski, R.E., Smith,D.J. (2000).In: Experimental Methods in the Physical Sciences, Volume36: Magnetic Imaging and its Applications to Materials, Chapter 4, pp.111, M. De Graef and Y. Zhu (Eds). Academic Press, New York. Cowley, J. ( 1 992)Ultramicroscopy 41,335. Midgley, P.A.(2001) Micron 32,167. Tonomura, A. (1999).Electron Holography. Berlin, Germany: Springer Series in Optical Sciences. De Hosson, J.Th.M., Chechenin, N.G., Alsem, D.H., Vystavel, T., Kooi B.J., Chezan, A.R., Boerma, D.O. (2002) Microscopy and Microanalysis 8,274. Chechenin,N.G., Chezan,A.R., Craus, C.B.,Vystavel,T.,Boerma,D.O.,DeHosson, J.Th.M.,Niesen.L. (2002)J. Magn. Magn. Muter. 180,242. Wohlleben, D. (1967)J.Appl.Phys.38,3341. Aharanov, Y., Bohm D. (1958) Phys. Rev. 115,485. Hoffmann, H. (2000) Thin Solid Films 373 ,107. Chezan , A.R., Craus, C.B., Chechenin, N.G., Niesen, L., Boerma, D.O. (2002)Phys. Stat. Sol (a) 189, 833 De Graef, M. and Zhu Y. (2001)ExperimentalMethods in Physical Sciences, Magnetic imaging and its applications to materials, volume 36, Academic Press, New York. Aitchison, R.P., Chapman, J.N., Gehanno, V., Weir, L.S., Schenfein, M.R., McVitie, S., Marty, A. (2001)J. Magn. Magn. Muter. 223, 138 Gillies, M.F., Chapman, J.N., Kools,.J.C.S. (1995)J. Magn. andMugneticMaterials 140-144:,721. Henmann, M., Zweck, J., Hoffmann, H.(1994) ICEM13, p.245. Jeong, IS., Walser, R.M. (1988)IEEE TransMugn. 24, 1725. Chapman,J.N. (1984)J. Phys. D:Appl. Phys. 17,623. Zhao, Y-P., Wang G-C. and Lu T.M., (2000) ExperimentalMethods in the Physical Sciences, Vol. 37, Academic Press, New York. Palasantzas, G., Zhao, Y-P., Wang, G-C., Lu T-M., Bamas, J., De Hosson ,J.Th.M. (2000)Phys. Rev. B
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
SLIP INDUCED STRESS AMPLIFICATION IN THIN LIGAMENTS X. Markenscoff and V. A. Lubarda Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering University of California, San Diego; La Jolla, CA 92093-041 1, USA
ABSTRACT The solution for a screw or edge dislocation in a multiply connected solid containing two cavities is not unique, but depends on the selected cut used to impose the displacement discontinuity and to create the dislocation. The Peach-Koehler force and the location of the equilibrium dislocation position is determined for screw dislocation in the ligament. The dislocation induced stress amplification in the ligament between two approaching cavities of equal or unequal sizes is then derived.
INTRODUCTION The stress fields and dislocation forces for a screw or edge dislocation in a multiply connected region depend on the cut used to create a dislocation, and if the connectivity of the region is n, there are as many possible solutions (Lubarda [l]). A screw dislocation between two cavities in an infinite medium is considered in this paper. By using the method of image dislocations, three different solutions are derived depending on the cut used to impose a displacement discontinuity and create a dislocation. The slip induced stress amplification in a ligament between two approaching cavities is then calculated, thereby extending the earlier studies by Markenscoff [2], and Wu and Markenscoff [3]. It is shown that in a ligament of small thickness d, the shear stress amplifies at the order of d-'lz.
SCREW DISLOCATION BETWEEN TWO CAVITIES A screw dislocation between two cavities in an infinite medium is shown in Fig. 1. The radii of the cavities are R1 and R z ,and their distance is c. Two infinite sets of image dislocations are required to achieve the traction free conditions on the surfaces of both cavities. One set of image dislocations is entirely within the region of the first cavity, and the other is entirely within the region of the second
109
110
X. Murkenscoff and V.A.Luburdu
Figure 1: Screw dislocation between two cavities in an infinite medium. Image dislocations pile-up at two conjugate points at distance x1 and z2 from the centers of the cavities. cavity. The stresses are obtained by superposition as [4] Y
+ y2
-
Y
(x - u2n-1)2 + y2
+ (x -xc +c + + y2 - (x xc +c + bzn-i + yz -
a2n
azn)2
-
-
bzn-1)2
I>
’
where p is the shear modulus, and b, is the Burgers vector of the dislocation. The recursive formulas
apply for n = 1 , 2 , 3 , .. . , with a1 = RT/a, and bl = R;/(c - u ) . As n goes to infinity, the image dislocations in the first cavity pile up at the distance x1 from its center, while image dislocations in
Slip induced stress amplification in thin ligaments
111
4.0
3.0
-3.0/ -4.0
,J,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
-
,
____
;
I
/
-5.0
_,,
,
,
Cut 2
cm 3
I ;
-6.0
1 1
1.0
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
am 1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.8
,I
Figure 2: The variation of the dislocation force (scaled by pb2/27rR1) as the dislocation moves along horizontal direction between the two cavities in an infinite medium. the second cavity pile up at the distance 2 2 from the center of the second cavity. The two points are conjugate to each other with respect to both cavities, and are thus specified by c - x 2 = - ,R: 51
This gives 21
=
1 ( c~ C; 2c
-
+ RI - Ri) ,
where C:
= [c2 - (Ri
c-x1=-
R,2 x2
52
1
= - (c' - C;
+ R2)'] [c2
2c
-
+ R;
(R1- R z ) ~. ]
-
R;) ,
(6) (7)
The contributions from the pairs of positive and negative image dislocations are summed in Eqs. (1) and ( 2 ) ,which ensures the convergence of the series, and implies a displacement discontinuity along the cut
from a to infinity. If Rz = 0.5R1 and c = 2.5R1,for example, we find that dislocation is at an unstable equilibrium position for a E 1.535R1. The variation of the dislocation force, as the dislocation moves between the two cavities, is shown by a solid curve in Fig. 2.
SOLUTIONS FOR DIFFERENT DISCONTINUITY CUTS The previously derived solution is associated with a displacement discontinuity along the cut from the point a to infinity. One such cut is shown in Fig. 3a. Two other solutions are, however, possible since the considered region is triply connected. One solution corresponds to a displacement discontinuity along the cut from a to the surface of one cavity, and the other is associated with the cut from a to the surface of another cavity (Fig. 3b,c). To obtain these two solutions and to relate them to the solution derived in the previous section, we need to solve two auxiliary problems. The first is the problem of an infinite body with two cavities, and a displacement discontinuity imposed along the cut from one cavity
X. Murkenscoff and V.A.Luburdu
112
Figure 3: Three different ways of creating the screw dislocation by imposing a displacement discontinuity along the three indicated cuts. to the other. The solution is obtained by placing two opposite dislocations at two points conjugate with respect to both cavities (Fig. 4a). The second problem is the problem of an infinite body with two cavities and a displacement discontinuity imposed along the cut from a point on one cavity to infinity (Fig. 4b). In the latter case we need to consider two infinite sets of image dislocations, situated in the region of each cavity. These are created by starting with two alike dislocations at the centers of each cavity, and proceeding with a built-up of image dislocations at the conjugate points with respect to the boundary of each cavity. A sequence of negative and positive image dislocations within the first cavity pile up at the distance z1from the center of the cavity, while a sequence of negative and positive dislocations in the second cavity pile up at the distance z2 from the center of that cavity. After enough image dislocations is introduced to cancel the traction on both boundaries, we end with equal number of positive and negative dislocations in the first cavity, and with one more positive than negative dislocation in the second cavity. This ensures a displacement discontinuity from the point on the surface of the second cavity to infinity, and provides the solution of the second auxiliary problem. The stresses are, therefore, given by
cJzz
=
2
-${ [
Y
(z - B,)2
+ (z - C + Yb,)2 + y2] -
+ y2
2
N-l
-
Y
(z - a,)2
Y
+
+ y2
(z - c + A , ) ~ y2
Slip induced stress amplification in thin ligaments
113
’f
’f
Figure 4: Image dislocations required to solve the problem in which a displacement discontinuity is imposed: (a) along the cut between the two cavities, and (b) along the cut from the surface of one cavity to infinity.
x - B, (X - B,)2
+ y2
-
x - a,
(x - a,)2
N-1
+ y2
x-c+~, x-c+A, ’ ( x - c b,)2 +y’]- n=l (x - c + A,)2 + y2
I
+
}’
for large N . The conrdinates R-,‘ define nemtive and nnsitive .-.sufficientlv - _.. -. .. .._ ,.. ._ -. - .._ - - -- - n- and _______the distances of _ _ the ____ ___ 0---- ---- r-----__,I
I___
I__ -___I_____
image dislocations in the region of the first cavity from its center, while A, and b, are the corresponding distances of the image dislocations in the second cavity from its center. They are defined by the recursive formulas b,=-, R; a, = R: c - b, ’ c - a,-l ~
RZ
R2
bl lL2 B, = A, = (11) C-B,’ c - An_l ’ which apply for n = 2,3,4,. . . . For n = 1, we have a1 = R l f c , A1 = R;/c, and bl = B1 = 0. ~
Numerical evaluations reveal that the convergence is reached with only few terms included, typically N = 5 or 6. The solid and dashed curves in Fig. 5 show the variation of the shear stress czy(x,0) along the x axis, corresponding to imposed displacement discontinuities along the cuts from Fig. 4. The remaining (dotted) curve in Fig. 5 is obtained as the sum of the values corresponding to solid and dashed curves, and represents the shear stress associated with a cut from the first cavity to infinity. The solution for the dislocation between two cavities in the case when a displacement discontinuity is imposed as in Fig. 3b is obtained by subtracting from the solution of the problem in Fig. 3a the
X. Murkenscoff and V.A.Luburdu
114
2.0
1.o
bb
0.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0 -3.0
-2.0
1.0
0.0
1.0
x/R.
2.0
3.0
4.0
I
5.0
Figure 5: The variation of the shear stress (scaled by pb,/27rR1) along the x axis, corresponding to imposed displacement discontinuity along the two cuts shown in Fig. 4. The dotted curve is the sum of the values from the solid and dashed curves, and corresponds to the cut from the first cavity to infinity. Linear segments span across the region of cavities and should be discarded. stress distribution corresponding to the cut shown in Fig. 4b. Thus, we subtract from Eqs. (1) and (2) the stresses defined by Eqs. (8) and (9). The variation of the corresponding dislocation force with a dislocation position between two cavities is shown by a dashed curve in Fig. 2. The results are for
Rz = 0.5R1 and c = 2.5R1. Dislocation is in an unstable equilibrium for a M 1.220R1.This is smaller than the equilibrium distance in the previous case because the closest added image dislocation to the left is positive, and to the right negative, so that they exert a force on the positive dislocation directed toward the second cavity.
Finally, by subtracting from the last solution the solution associated with a cut shown in Fig. 4a, i.e., by subtracting the stress field of two opposite dislocations at x1 and x2 from the centers of respective cavities, we obtain the solution for a dislocation between the cavities created by a displacement discontinuity along the cut shown in Fig. 3c. The variation of the dislocation force in this case is shown by a dotted curve in Fig. 2. Dislocation is in an unstable equilibrium for a z 1.695R1. This is greater than the equilibrium distance for the cut from Fig. 3b because the added negative dislocation to the left and positive to the right exert a force on the positive dislocation between two cavities directed toward the left cavity.
SLIP INDUCED STRESS AMPLIFICATION IN THIN LIGAMENTS The problem depicted in Fig. 4a can be used to derive an analytical solution for the slip induced stress amplification in thin ligaments. A comprehensive analysis of stress amplification in vanishingly small geometries due to remote stress or thermal loading was given by Markenscoff [3]. Let d be a thickness
Slip induced stress amplification in thin ligaments
of the ligament, so that c = (I
115
+ P + OR1,
where The shear stress r ( x )= ozy(x,0) across the ligament is
The image dislocations needed to impose a displacement discontinuity across the ligament are approximately located at the distances
from the centers of respective cavities. The terms that are proportional to higher order exponents of the small ratio = d/R1are neglected in Eq. (15). It readily follows that the shear stresses at the end points of the ligament are
c
(T)
r l = r ( R 1 ) = iPbZ 7RI 1 + P
1'2c-
(1 + - - () 1 P 2 l+p
1
c) This establishes the (-'I2 order of singularity in the region of thin ligament between two cavities in an infinite solid, produced by the relative sliding of two faces of the ligament along the cut between two end points of the ligament. We retained the term proportional to in Eq. (16) to quantify the difference in the shear stresses at the end points of the ligament between the cavities of unequal sizes. If the cavities are identical ( R , = R2 = R ) ,we obtain in the limit
c
51
= x2 = (1 -
(17)
and
Two numerical examples reveal the following. First, suppose that R1 = 30b,, R2 = lob,, and d = 2b,. The image dislocations are approximately located at x1 = 25b, and x 2 = 4.98bZ, while the shear stresses at the end points of the ligament are rl = 0 . 0 5 8 9 ~and r2 = 0 . 0 6 2 5 ~ .The shear stress r2 is about 6% greater than 7-1. In the second case, consider two equal cavities of radius R = lob, at a distance d = b,. The image dislocations are located at z1= x2 = 7.34b,, while the shear stresses
X. Murkenscoff and V.A.Luburdu
116
are T~ = r2 = 0 . 1 ~ If . the cavities were at a distance d = lob,, the shear stresses would have been 71 = rz = 0 . 0 3 6 ~ .This is calculated from the exact results
and
In the limit of infinitely distant cavities the stress 71 approaches the value pbZ/2.irRcorresponding to a single dislocation at the origin. An analysis of the slip induced stress amplification in thin ligaments associated with other geometries is presented by Lubarda and Markenscoff [4].
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Lubarda, V.A. (1999). J. Elasticity 52,289. Markenscoff, X. (1996). Comput. Mech. 19,77.
6.
Wu, L. and Markenscoff, X. (1997). J. Mech. Phys. Solids 45,2033. Lubarda, V.A. and Markenscoff, X. (2003). J. Matel: Sci. Engng., to appear. Seeger, A. (1955). In Handbuch der Physik, VW1: Crystal Physics I, pp. 383-665, S. Flugge (Ed). Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Nabarro, F.R.N. (1967). Theory of Crystal Dislocations, Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford.
7.
Hirth, J.P. and Lothe, J. (1982). Theory ofDisZocations (2nd ed). John Wiley, New York.
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
MATERIALS, STRUCTURES AND APPLICATIONS OF SOME ADVANCED MEMS DEVICES Sungho Jin University of California, San Diego, 9500 Gilman Dr., La Jolla, CA 92093-0411
ABSTRACT Since the famous lectures by Richard Feynman, “There is Plenty Room at the Bottom” in 1959 and “Infinitesimal Machinery” in 1983, the drive toward nano- and micro- materials and devices has been one of the most fascinating scientific and technological goals. The MEMS technology owes much of its base to modem silicon fabrication and lithography processes. While the design and fabrication of standard MEMS devices can relatively easily be accomplished through available MEMS foundries, differential advantages such as new functionalities and improved reliability may more readily be obtained by incorporating newladvanced materials, for example, nano materials or active functional materials. In this presentation, some unique approaches related to the advanced materials, design of MEMS structures and potential applications of electron-emitting MEMS will be discussed. Careful considerations of physical and materials structure and properties are needed to ensure high performance of the devices. The R&D and applications of the MEMS devices offer exciting and challenging opportunities for materials scientists.
INTRODUCTION The interesting and unique characteristics of carbon nanotubes come mostly due to their nanoscale geometry of elongated tube shape. While substantial progress has been made in the growth of nanotubes, the management of key nanotube geometries such as the diameter, height, inter-nanotube spacing, alignment, etc. and the processing to optimize them are yet to be fully understood and controlled. Currently, a promising source of electrons in vacuum microelectronic devices is field emission apparatus which releases electrons into vacuum from suitable cathode materials. These devices include flat panel displays, klystrons and traveling wave tubes used as effecient microwave power amplifiers, ion guns, electron beam lithography, high energy accelerators, free electron lasers, and electron microscopes and microprobes. A typical field emission device consists of a cathode including one or more of field emitter tips and an anode spaced from the cathode. A voltage applied between the anode and cathode induces the emission o i electrons towards the anode. In a triode type configuration, a gate electrode is added near the cathode to facilitate the extraction of the electrons.
117
118
Sungho Jin
Carbon nanotubes [ l ] have recently emerged as promising field emitters that can emit very large current densities at relatively low electric fields [2 - 51. The carbon nanotubes are composed of cylindrically arranged graphitic sheets with diameters in the range of 130 nm and lengthldiameter aspect ratios greater than 1,000. Of particular interest is the capability of nanotube emitters to stably deliver very high emission currents, as individual nanotubes can emit up to 1 micro ampere [3] and nanotube layers can generate current densities in excess of 4 Nc m2 [4,5]. Carbon nanotubes are a stable form of carbon which exhibits high mechanical strengths and chemical stability as well as a very high aspect ratio (>1,000) and small tip radii of curvature (-1 0 nm). These geometric characteristics provide a tremendous local concentration of applied electric field, which makes carbon nanotubes very attractive as electron field emitters as relatively low and practical voltages can be applied to induce significant electron emission. There are three important geometric issues that influence the behavior and performance of carbon nanotubes for field emission applications. They are i) the alignment perpendicular to the substrate surface, ii) the density of nanotube packing, and iii) the diameter of nanotubes. CVD nanotube growth methodologies need to be adjusted to optimize the nanotube configurations. We report here a novel method for fabricating fully integrated, on-chip, vacuum microtriodes using carbon nanotubes as field emitters via silicon micromachining of MEMS (Micro-Electro-Mechanical Systems) device fabrication.
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES Our new microtriodes were fabricated using a three-layer polysilicon micromaching process on a silicon nitride coated silicon substrate [6]. The triode structure was chosen because, despite its simple device geometry, its characterization can be easily parameterized and its behavior can provide important insight to the design and performance of more sophisticated devices. The triode here is a drastically miniaturized, micrometer-scale version of a conventional vacuum triode, consisting of a cathode, a grid, and an anode. Each electrode here is made of a hinged polysilicon panel that can be rotated and locked into position. Well-aligned carbon nanotubes were selectively grown on the cathode regions by first depositing a thin, nanotube-nucleating catalyst layer of iron (50 A) through a shadow mask, and then growing the nanotubes in a microwave plasma of ammonidacetylene mixture at 750°C at a growth rate of about 10 micrometers per minute. The microwave plasma-enhanced CVD system was operated with a 2.45 GHz, 5 KW microwave power supply and inductively heated substrate stage [7,8].
Materials, structures and applications of some advanced MEMS devices
119
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION As is well known, the birth of modem communications industry was instigated by the development of gridded vacuum tube amplifiers [9]. These vacuum devices made broadcast radios and television possibles. The vacuum tubes generally suffered from various limitations, all related to the use of thermionic cathodes, which typically had to be heated to above 800°C for electron emission to occur. In low power applications (lo GHz) and low control voltage (50-100 V) operation. In beam forming tubes, density modulation of electron beams by the grid through gated emission thus becomes possible so that a long beam interaction section is no longer required, and the tubes can be shortened substantially. A cold cathode vacuum tube amplifier system is 'thus attractive to the commercial wireless communications industry, as the highly efficient and miniaturized vacuum devices can help move the amplifier electronics to the tower tops of antennas. They are also especially valuable for
Sungho Jin
120
space operation where radiation is strong, available power and space is limited, and heat can only be dissipated by radiation. Over the years, there have been considerable efforts spent in building cold cathode microwave power tube amplifiers [11,12]. All devices have been based on Spindt-type field emitter array cathodes that were used as the electron source for triodes, klystrodes and traveling wave tubes (TWT). TWT devices operating at 10 GHz with molybdenum field emitter arrays emitting at current densities of 50 A/cm2 for a period of 5000 hours (at 1% duty cycle) have been demonstrated [13]. However, density modulation at microwave frequencies through gated emission has proven to be difficult due to inadequate emission stability and reliability of the FEA cathodes. As a result, continuous operation of beam tube devices has not been possible, and no practically useful triodes have been reported. If effecient and reliable cold-cathode vacuum tube amplifiers can be fabricated, and also miniaturized into microscale, on-chip integrated devices, then they could become the amplifier of choice for many applications, not necessarily limited to communications area. Carbon nanotubes, which have recently emerged as promising field emitters that can emit large current densities at relatively low electric fields, in combination with a micromachining concept, can provide a possibility for such efficient amplifiers as described below.
Nanotubes
Cathode
Poly-Si
Gate
Anode
Figure 1. Assembly of on-chip micro vacuum tube. Shown in Fig. 1 is a schematic illustration of the process used for fabricating the carbon nanotube based MEMS microwave amplifier structure. Silicon micromaching process
Materials, structures and applications of some advanced MEMS devices
121
generated a flat substrate containing three panels, the cathode, the gate, and the anode, as illustrated in Fig. l(a). All three panels are connected to the silicon substrate by hinges and springs. The gate panel is made to contain many apertures for electrons to pass through and accelerate toward the anode. On the cathode surface, vertically aligned carbon nanotubes are deposited by CVD processing. The three panels are then raised to the vertical position, Fig. 1(b), so that they are placed in a parallel configuration relative to each other. The carbon nanotubes nucleate from metal catalyst islands of Co or Fe. A thin layer (e.g., 2-5 nm thick) of such a metal is deposited on a desired silicon substrate (for example, on the cathode panel only in Fig. l(a)) by sputtering or evaporation. On heating to the CVD deposition temperature of 700 - 800"C, the layer naturally and conveniently breaks up into islands and forms a multiplicity of nucleating sites for carbon nanotubes as illustrated schematically in Fig. 2 (left). For better control of nanotube size and distribution, a more intentional arrangement of nucleation sites is desirable, for example, by patterning the Co or Fe layer prior to the CVD process. This produces a finer and further spaced apart nanotube configuration as illustrated in Fig. 2 (right). Such a refined nanotube arrangement is being pursued and the results from such an improved structure will be reported in future publications. Spaced-apart field emitter arrangement such as illustrated in Fig. 3(c) or (d) are in principle better than the structures of Fig. 3(a) or (b) because of electric field concentration possible in more isolated sharp emitters.
Thick Crowded C N T Planar / catalyst (Co, Fe)
(a) L
Substrate
(b) O n heating
I
P a rt ic u late
/'
T h n Separated C N T
(a)
r I
, , ,
Subdivided catalyst
I
(b) On heating
CNT
Figure 2. Growth of carbon nanotubes on catalyst metal islands formed by heating a thin film (left) and those formed by patterning of the metal layer (right).
Sungho Jin
122
Field-Concentrating Nanotube Configuration
Substrate
Substrate
Figure 3. Carbon nanotube growth with varying degree of inter-nanotube spacing. Such a lateral configuration of Fig. l(b) obtained by MEMS fabrication is in contrast to the conventional, horizontally arranged structures based on field emitter arrays [ 11,121 or metal nanopillar cathodes [ 14,151. Our approach offers greater flexibility in designing sophisticated microwave devices and circuitries, employs simpler and more precise fabrication processes, and produces completely integrated structures. The technique combines high-performance nanomaterials with MEMS-based solid state fabrication technology to produce miniaturized vacuum tube devices in an on-chip form, which could have important and far-reaching scientific and technological implications. Shown in Fig. 4 as an SEM micrograph is the actual device of miniaturized, on-chip, vacuum microwave amplifier structure obtained by combining the MEMS and the nano technology. The structure here was assembled under a microscope using a mechanical microprobe. Various self-assembly techniques could be used to achieve better manufacturability for future devices. The carbon nanotubes grown here are multi-walled and highly oriented, with diameters ranging from 20 - 50 nm. Their length was determined by controlling the growth time, which, in turn, controlled the spacing between the cathode and grid (and hence the emission field). From this device, we obtained a dc power gain of 16 dB by operating the carbon nanotube cathodes at a record emission current density of 16 Alcm2. The cutoff frequency for such devices is currently at 216 MHz. With improved designs and optimized materials, we expect to achieve cutoff frequencies in excess of 20 GHz in future devices. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of incorporating carbon nanotube field emitters in a MEMS design to create power-amplifying vacuum devices on silicon [ 5 ] . The inset in Fig. 4 shows a magnified view of the cathode region. The nanotubes were typically patterned on the cathode according to the grid geometry in order to minimize the
Materials, structures and applications of some advanced MEMS devices
123
intercepted grid current. The aligned and patterned nanotubes point toward the apertures in the grid structure.
Aligned and Patterned Nanotubes
Figure 4. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) micrograph of a completely assembled vacuum microtriode.
The dc characteristics of the triodes was evaluated by measuring how the anode current (Ia) changes as a function of both the grid voltage (V,) and the anode voltage (V& These measurements were performed at room temperature within a vacuum chamber with a base pressure of lo-* torr. A triode is the vacuum equivalent of a field effect transistor, in which electrons are emitted from the cathode into vacuum, and a grid (or gate) electrode varies the electric field between the cathode and grid to control the emission current. Some of the electrons pass through apertures in the grid, accelerate towards the anode, and are collected to give a current through the device. The devices can have substantial current gain (I&) if the grid intercepts only a small fraction of the emitted current. As this grid-controlled current goes to the anode and passes through external loads, it can produce a voltage larger than the control voltage at the grid, resulting in a voltage gain
Sungho Jin
124
(AV,/AV,). Therefore, if the device geometry is designed correctly, this can yield an overall power gain. 30
'
2.0
. 1.5 . 1.0 a, 10 U 0
2
0 3
- 0.5
5 0
80
100
140
120
160
180
200
- 0.0
Grid Voltage (V)
25
U, = 200 V
10 MQ load line 20
3W 4-l
F
15
U, = 190 U
10
U, = 180 U
L
5
U,
= 160 U
U,= 1 4 Q U 0
U,=QU
0
100
200
300
400
500
Anode Voltage (V) Figure 5. (a) Grid current, anode current and transconductance vs gnd voltage with the anode voltage held at 1OOV. (b) Anode current vs anode voltage at various grid voltages. The lOMR load line indicates the voltage gain that can be achieved by this device.
Materials, structures and applications of some advanced MEMS devices
125
In the data of Fig. 5(a), the variation of grid current (I,), anode current (Ia), and transconductance (g,,,=61a/6V,) with grid voltage, while the anode voltage was held at 100 V, is shown. It is observed that the grid and anode currents increase exponentially with the grid voltage, as is expected from the Fowler-Nordheim emission tunneling theory 11161. Under reverse bias conditions, no current was observed until electric breakdown of the silicon nitride layer occurred at approximately 200 V. The plateau in the Fowler-Nordheim plot, shown in the inset in Fig. 5(a), is associated with the desorption of adsorbates present at the nanotube tips, as described in detail elsewhere [3,17]. The grid and anode currents were observed to follow each other closely, with a current gain (IJI,) of roughly 3 for this particular device tested but varying between 1-10 from device to device. The anode current was plotted only up to 28 pA in the figure; however, the maximum currents we have measured so far were I, = 100 pA and I, = 50 pA, meaning a total emission current of 150 pA from the cathode. This corresponds to a peak emission current density (Jpeak) generated by the cathode (effective emission area of nanotubes = 9x(lOxlO) pm2) of 16 A/cm2, exceeding the previously published record emission current density from carbon nanotubes [4]. The MEMS microtriode device was operated continuously without degradation for 24 hours at a current density of approximately 2 A/cm2 (I, = 12 PA). It was also found that the microtriode device remained robust while running at an elevated pressure of tom. Considering that field emitter arrays typically have to be operated at a vacuum under 10-9 ton: to achieve lifetimes of even a few minutes [7], the data from the microtride represents a significant improvement. This impressive behavior of our microtriodes may be attributable to the excellent chemical and mechanical properties of carbon nanotubes. The use of small-area (-pm’) cathodes in our microtriodes also contributes to the emitter stability by reducing the impact of extreme emission non-uniformity (i.e. hot spots) that is frequently encountered and often unavoidable in large-area (e.g. -mm2 and larger) cathodes [ 17-19].
As shown in Fig. 5(a), the transconductance of the microtriode is low, about 1.3 pS at the anode current of 28 pA. It should be correspondingly much higher at the maximum anode current level of 100 pA that we observed. On a normalized basis with respect to the emission area, our number (0.15 S/cm2)is about half of but potentially much better (at higher current levels) than the thermionic triode (0.3 S/cm2) [ 101. If normalized to the emission current, our number (0.05 S/A) is comparable or even better than Spindt cathode-based structures (-0.03 S/A). While it is clearly important to have a high transconductance for successful high frequency device operation, such a high transconductance is desirably achieved at relatively low emission currents and voltages in order to reduce the probability of emitter failure due to overheating or arcing and to minimize the heat dissipation at the anode. Because the fields required for emission from nanotubes are typically low [20], our nanotube based triode structure is likely to perform well in this regard.
126
Sungho Jin
Shown in Fig. 5(b) is the characteristic curves measured at the anode. It is observed that an electric breakdown occurrs across the thin silicon nitride layer on the Si substrate at voltages above 200V. To circumvent this problem, an external metallic anode was brought into close proximity to the original polysilicon anode, and data at voltages above 200 V were subsequently collected. The internal anode resistance (Ra=6V,/6I,), measured in the linear region above anode voltages of 200 V, was approximately 100 MQ. Also included in the figure is a 10 MQ load line. Operating at the point of V, = 325 V and I, = 16 pA, a peak-to-peak voltage swing of 10 V on the grid induces a peak-to-peak anode voltage change of 75 V, resulting in a voltage gain of 17.5 dB. Assuming that the load resistance (R1) is equal to the internal anode resistance (Ra), we can conveniently calculate the power gain by GPO,, = ?4 (AIa/AIg)g,,,Ra. Using a current gain (I,/&) of 10, a transconductance (g,) of 1.2 pS, and an anode (and load) resistance (R, and RI) of 100 MQ, we obtain a power gain of 18 dB. Because of the breakdown of the silicon nitride layer, the total output power at the integrated anode is currently limited in the range of 110 mW. Assuming that these devices will eventually be built on a better substrate with a much larger breakdown voltage, we expect that an output power of 100 mW (100 pA at 1000 V) per device is obtainable. In a distributed amplifier system (which can be easily designed and fabricated through MEMS), this would require only 100 devices to generate 10 watts of power. Normalized to a linear dimension of the anode, this kind of power level would be comparable to state-of-the-art GaAs HBT (heterojunction bipolar transistor) and GaN HEMT (high electron mobility transistor) devices that typically generate 4 W per millimeter gate length [21].
SUMMARY It is demonstrated, for the first time, that a completely integrated, laterally built, MEMS triode incorporating carbon nanotube field emitters can be constructed. Such a device can provide a powerful, on-chip, power-amplifying capability. The fact that the MEMS structure and materials withstood the high temperature nanotube growth processing and the device demonstrated impressive dc power gain is encouraging enough for us to further explore device structures that are more compatible with high frequency operation. Additional improvements in nanotube configuration and distribution are likely to further improve the performance of the MEMS based vacuum microtriode type devices.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author wishes to thank Drs. W. Zhu, C. Bower, D. Shalom, D. Lopez, and P. L. Gammel of Agere Systems and Dr. G. P. Kochanski of Bell Laboratories, New Jersey for collaborations and helpful discussions.
Materials, structures and applications of some advanced MEMS devices
127
REFERENCES
1. Ijima, S (1991), Nature, 354, 56. 2. de Heer, W. A., Chatelain, A., and Ugarte, D. (1995), Science 270, 1178 (1995). 3. Dean, K. A. and Chalamala, B. R. (2000), Appl. Phys. Lett., 76,375. 4. Zhu, W., Bower, C., Zhou, O., Kochanski, G., and Jin, S. (1999), Appl. Phys. Lett., 75, 873. 5. Bower, C., Zhu, W., Shalom, D., Lopez, D., Chen, L. H., Gammel, P. L., and Jin, S. (2002), Appl. Phys. Lett., 80, 3820. 6. http://wn~w.meinsrus.com: The Design Handbook of MUMPS (Multi-User MEMS Processes), Cronos Integrated Microsystems, a JDSU Company, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, 2000. 7. Bower, C., Zhu, W., Jin, S., and Zhou, 0. (2000), Appl. Phys. Lett., 77, 830. 8. Bower, C., Zhu, W., Werder, D. J., Jin, S., and Zhou, 0. (2000), Appl. Phys. Lett., 77, 2767. 9. Gilmour, A. S. Jr., Microwave Tubes (1986), Artech House. 10. Morton, J. A. and Ryder, R. M. (1950), Bell System Tech. J. 29,496. 11. Brodie, I. and Spindt, C. A. (1979), Appl. Surf. Sci., 2, 149. 12. Neidert, R. E., Phillips, P. M., Smith, S. T., and Spindt, C. A. (1991), IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, 38, 661. 13. Makishima, H., Imura, H., Takahashi, M., Fukui, H. and Okamoto, A. (1997), Proc. 10'' Int. Conf. Vacuum Microelectronics, Kyongju, Korea, p. 194. 14. Takemura, H., Yomihari, Y., Furutake, N., Matsuno, F., Yoshiki, M., Takada, N., Okamoto, A. and Miyano, S. (1997), Tech. Digest ofIEDM, p. 709. 15. Driskill-Smith, A. A. G., Hasko, D. G,. and Ahmed, H. (1999), Appl. Phys. Lett., 75, 2845. 16. Fowler, R. H., and Nordheim, L. (1928), Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A , 119, 173. 17. Zhu, W., Bower, C., and Jin, S. (2001), Solid State Electronics, 45,921. 18. Nilsson, L., Groening, O., Emmenegger, C., Kuettel, O., Schaller, E., Schlapbach, L., Kind, H., Bonard, J. M., and Kern, K. (2000), Appl. Phys. Lett., 76,2071. 19. Andrienko, I., Cimmino, A., Hoxley, D., Prawer, S., and Kalish, R. (2000), Appl. Phys. Lett., 77, 1221. 20. Zhu, W., Baumann, P. K., and Bower, C. A., (2001), Chapter 6 in Vacuum Microelectronics, edited by Zhu, W., John Wiley and Sons, p. 247. 21. Hadaway, R., Surridge, R., Greshishchev, Y., Schvan, P., Voinigescu, S., and MacElwee, T. (1999), GaAs Mantech Digest of Papers.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MICROSTRUCTURE-PROPERTY EVOLUTION IN COLD-WORKED EQUIATOMIC FE-PD DURING ISOTHERMAL ANNEALING AT 50OOC A. Deshpande, A. Al-Ghaferi, H. Xu, H. Heinrich' and J.M.K. Wiezorek Department of Materials Science and Engineering, University of Pittsburgh, 3700 O'Hara Street, 848 Benedum Hall, Pittsburgh, PA 15261, USA; ' on sabbatical leave from ETH Zurich, Institute of Applied Physics, CH-8093 Zurich, Switzerland;
ABSTRACT In this work the evolution of magnetic properties and microstructure in cold-deformed equiatomic Fe-Pd during isothermal annealing at 500°C has been studied, The magnetic age hardening behavior has been determined using a vibrating sample magnetometer. The microstructures have been characterized by a combination of X-ray diffraction and scanning and transmission electron microscopy experiments. During annealing of the cold-deformed Fe-Pd concomitant recrystallization and ordering produces a complex microstructure that exhibits enhanced coercivity relative to conventionally processed material. The maximum coerciviy observed here was associated with a partially recrystallized or combined reaction transformed microstructure. The magnetic age hardening behavior of the combined reaciton processed fePd has been attributed to a grain size hardening effect. The experimentally observed microstructural evolution of the cold-deformed Fe-Pd during annealing has been rationalized in terms of the competition between the combined reaction mode, which is associated with the discontinuous mode of ordering, and the continuous ordering transformation. The release of the stored strain energy during annealing of the colddeformed Fe-Pd appears to accelerate the kinetics of a discontinuous ordering mode with respect to those of the usually dominant continuous ordering mode.
129
130
A. Deshpande et al.
INTRODUCTION At room temperature Fe-Pd alloys of near equiatomic composition form a stable tetragonal L1,-ordered intermetallic phase, y,-FePd, that exhibits high uniaxial magnetocrystalline anisotropy with an “easy” caxis, large theoretical B-H products and good mechanical and corrosion properties. This combination of properties renders the FePd based L1,-intermetallics very attractive for a range of permanent magnet and thin film applications [ 11. However, while the intrinsic properties of the intermetallic y,-phase are comparable to those of rare-earth magnets, the technical magnetic properties reported for conventionally processed FePd based alloys are disappointingly low [2, 31. This indicates that the technical properties of the FePd alloys are very sensitive to microstructure. Hence, property optimization relies on the development of a basic knowledge of the evolution of microstructure and defect structure during processing. In conventionally processed FePd based alloys, the L1,-ordered phase forms upon cooling below the order-transition temperature via a thermodynamically first-order type order-disorder transformation from the disordered high-temperature solid solution, the y-(Fe,Pd) phase with Al(FCC) structure [3,4]. During conventional processing a continuous ordering reaction involves the nucleation of coherent precipitates of the tetragonal y,-phase throughout the grains of the disordered y-matrix followed by growth [3, 41. As the ordered precipitates grow, the attendant transformation strains are relaxed by the formation of self-accommodating arrays of dodecahedrally conjugated twins, i.e. the polytwin structure characteristic of the L1,-ordered FePd alloys develops [3-51. It has been shown [3] that the surprisingly low technical magnetic properties of these alloys are associated with the presence of the polytwin structure. In fact, more recent studies [6, 71 reported thermomechanical processing schemes that resulted in FePd based alloys with improved hard magnetic properties by successfully suppressing the formation of the polytwin structure. These processing schemes involved the annealing of alloys that had been cold-rolled in the disordered state at temperatures below the ordering temperature in order to induce transformation of the microstructure by a combined reaction of concomitant recrystallization of the cold-deformed state and ordering, y(FCC) => y,(Ll,). The combined reaction (CR) transformed alloys exhibit significantly more heterogeneous microstructures than conventionally processed FePd alloys, which is expected to alter the magnetic hysteresis behavior. It has been proposed [7] that the increased coercivity of the CR transformed alloys relative to the conventionally processed FePd alloys originates from a combination of a domain wall drag effect resulting from the reduced grain size (grain size hardening) and domain wall pinning by planar faults [7]. The intriguing interplay of recrystallization processes, which are driven by the stored energy of cold-work, and the ordering processes, which, interestingly, have been shown to include both continuous and discontinuous mechanisms [6], promises the potential to generate new microstructural morphologies in intermetallic FePd alloys with enhanced technical magnetic properties. However, in order to optimize properties intelligently a better basic understanding of processing-microstructure-property relationships for CR transformed FePd alloys has to be developed. To date, microstructural studies of CR transformed microstructures have been rather limited and only included results from transmission electron microscopy (TEM) [6, 71. Hence, here a systematic investigation the microstructure-property evolution during annealing of Fe-Pd alloy after cold-deformation by equal-channel angular pressing (ECAP) has been undertaken. The advantages of using ECAP for the cold-deformation prior to annealing are the preservation of the cross-sectional dimension and the controlled accumulation of very large amounts of total effective strain larger than 1.0 [8]. The latter enables the exploration of a wider range of driving forces for recrystallization than is attainable with cold-rolling for instance and expands the matrix of processing
Microstructure-property evolution in cold-worked equiutomic Fe-Pd
131
parameters. The evolution of properties and microstructure is observed by experimental studies using magnetic hysteresis measurements together with a combination of microstructural characterization methods of x-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and TEM. The combination of complementary methods of XRD, SEM and TEM enables a more complete microstructural characterization of the transforming Fe-Pd alloys that bridges the length scales from mesoscopic to nanoscopic. In his paper preliminary results regarding the evolution of microstructure and magnetic properties of equiatomic FePd that has been cold-deformed by a single pass of ECAP during isothermal annealing at 500°C are reported. Implications for structure-property relationships and the mechanisms of microstructural transformation of cold-deformed Fe-Pd during isothermal annealing are discussed.
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE The equiatomic Fe-Pd alloy used in this study has been prepared from high-purity elemental starting materials using vacuum arc melting in an atmosphere of purified argon gas. Sections from the as-cast buttons have been cold-rolled to about 50% reduction in thickness, followed by a homogenization treatment at 950°C (1223K) for 6 hours (21.6ks) and quenching into ice-brine. In the as-quenched state the material consisted of grains of the disordered FCC y-(Fe,Pd) solid solution with an average diameter of approximately 130 pm. Billets of the as-quenched material 36mm long with square cross-sections of 6x6 mm2 have been cold-deformed at room temperature by a single ECAP-pass, 120" inner-die angle. Isothermal anneals after ECAP have been performed for up to 50 hours (180ks) at 500°C (773K), well below the critical ordering temperature TC=650"C(923K), in order to induce the combined reaction of concomitant recrystallization and ordering. The evolution of the magnetic properties was then documented as a function of annealing time using a vibrating sample magnetometer (VSM) producing a maximum field of 15 kOe at room temperature. The evolution of the microstructure as a function of annealing time has been studied by XRD, SEM and TEM using a Philips X'pert XR-diffractometer, a field-emission gun equipped Philips XL30 SEM and a Jeol 2000 FX TEM, respectively. Thin foils for TEM have been prepared by twin-jet electropolishing using an electrolyte of 82% acetic acid, 9% perchloric acid and 9% ethanol, all by volume, at approximately 0°C (273K) and 30 V.
RESULTS Figure 1 shows SEM micrographs obtained in the backscatter electron mode (BSE) of the microstructure of the Fe-Pd material in the as-quenched and as-deformed states respectively. The contrast observed is not associated with differences in elemental composition but rather purely due to differences in crystallographic orientation. The compositional homogeneity of the nominally equiatomic material has been confirmed by energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) of selected as-cast and as-quenched specimens. In Figure l a grains, including many annealing twins, can be distinguished for the as-quenched state. The average grain size after homogenization and quenching has been determined by computerassisted image analysis as approximately (130?5)p. After ECAP the microstructure consisted of heavily deformed grains that exhibited deformation bands at various length scales, i.e. shear, micro- and transition bands. The local rotations of the crystal lattice resulted in fairly rapid orientation changes and a mosaic
132
A. Deshpande et a1
Figure 1: SEM BSE micrographs of a) as-quenched Fe-Pd, scale marker 200pm, and b) as-deformed Fe-Pd, scale marker 50 pm.
b
Figure 2: a) TEM bright-field multi-beam micrograph of the dense dislocation cell-structure in a grain in the Fe-Pd after ECAP and b) SADP of the grain with beam approximately parallel to [loo]. Note the diffuse L1,-structure superlattice spots and spot splitting.
structure or cell structure inside a given deformed grain, which is reflected by the much more complex contrast in SEM BSE micrographs (e g Figure lb). The TEM micrograph in Figure 2 presents a typical example of the dense defect structure developed in the deformed grains. Using diffraction contrast images the dislocation density, pdlal=,has been estimated as pdlrloc = 10” - 10”cm ’. The accompanying selected area diffraction pattern (SADP) in Figure 2b clearly indicates the presence of a mosaic structure associated with the frequent small orientation changes across the dense dislocation walls between cells of lower dislocation density (Figure 2a). The matrix of the as-deformed material has the FCC crystal structure of the disordered y-phase and diffuse intensities for superlattice spots (e g. 110) in SADP’s indicate the presence of L1,-type either short-range order (SRO) or of very small (< 2nm) coherent precipitates of L1,-ordered orientation variants (Figure 2b) VSM experiments have been performed with the material prior to and after annealing to monitor the development of the magnetic age hardening curve. Some representative data collected from the VSM runs is collated in Table 1. The coercivity, H,, of the as-quenched disordered y-(Fe,Pd) solid solution was 27 Oe.
Microstructure-property evolution in cold-worked equiutomic Fe-Pd
133
The deformation induced during the single ECAP pass enhanced the coercivity to 37 Oe. During annealing the coercivity, H,, increases from a minimal value of the as-deformed state (37 Oe) to a maximum (523 Oe) after 12 hours of annealing at 5 0 0 ° C (673K) before decreasing again at longer annealing times to a lower value (349 Oe) (Table 1). Interestingly, coercivities of about 180 to 350 Oe have been reported previously [6, 71 for undeformed L1,-ordered FePd after long-time annealing at 5 0 0 " C , which had developed polytwin microstructures typical of the continuous ordering reaction. The type of magnetic age hardening behavior documented in Table 1 is consistent with previous studies [6, 71, which included a different mode of cold-deformation and different annealing temperatures. Thus this behavior appears to be characteristic of cold-deformed FePd during annealing at T
TABLE 1 COERCIVITY,
H,,
VERSUS TIME OF ANNEALING AT 5 0 0 ° C .
A Q AND A D IN 0 HOURS OF TIME OF ANNEALING REFER TO THE AS-QUENCHED STATE AND THE AS-DEFORMED STATE, RESPECTIVELY.
Time[hours] H, [ O ~ I
I
I
O(AQ) 27
I I
O(AD) 37
I I
1.5 239
1 I
3 261
I I
5 442
I I
12 523
I I
24 349
XRD experiments have been performed in order to monitor the changes of the lattice parameters during annealing. The { 113) and (1311 diffraction peaks have been used to determine changes in the (c/a)-ratioor tetragonality as a function of annealing time at 500°C as summarized in Table 2. For annealing times of less than 3 hours the quality, peak width and signal-to-noise ratio, of the XRD signal was insufficient to determine with confidence apparent changes in the prominent lattice parameters. This lack of useful XRD data for the shorter annealing times can presumably be attributed to the small sample size, the small fraction of ordered material and the small size of the ordered domains or grains. The data collated in Table 2 indicates that the (c/a)-ratio decreases from unity prior to annealing towards the equilibrium value of 0.966 within 24 hours and remains constant thereafter. Hence, it appears reasonable to conclude that, while significant LI,-type the long-range order (LRO) certainly develops within the first 5 hours of annealing at 500"C, the maximum LRO parameter is attained only after between 12 to 24 hours of isothermal annealing.
TABLE 2 TETRAGONALITY VERSUS TIME OF ANNEALING AT 500°C: TIME [HOURS]
5
12
24
50
1.154
1.157
1.157
1.157
1.135
1.130
1.128
1.128
n 911
n 968
n 966
n 966
{ 131) PLANE SPACING [A] [113) PLANE SPACING [A] TETRAGONALITY (c/a\
134
A. Deshpande et a1
SEM and TEM investigations of the annealed samples have been conducted in order to document the microstructural evolution during isothermal annealing of the cold-deformed Fe-Pd. TEM allows detailed local probing of structural, morphological and compositional changes on a nanoscopic to microscopic scale ( = l o to 10’ pm). Compared to TEM, SEM studies can provide information on the microstructural evolution for much larger fields of view and also at the larger length scales, namely from the sub-micron scale to the meso-scale (=lo-’ to lo3 pm). Hence, by combining SEM and TEM complementing data sets regarding the microstructural evolution during annealing of the cold-deformed Fe-Pd could be obtained across the relevant length scales. Figure 3 and Figure 4 present SEM BSE micrographs representative of the pertinent features of the microstructural changes observed during isothermal annealing at 500°C. Even at the shortest annealing times (1 hour) small (<5pm), morphologically irregular grains of the L1 ,-ordered y,phase emerged initially at grain boundaries (GB’s) between the large (=130pm) deformed grains and somewhat later also at transition and micro-bands within the deformed grains (Figure 3). These new grains are the product of the nucleation and growth processes of the combined reaction of concomitant recrystallization and ordering and are referred to in the following as the recrystallized (Rex) grains or combined reaction product (CRP) grains. Conversely, the grains of the deformed material that do not transform by the combined reaction are referred to in the following as unrecrystallized (Unrex). Figure 3a shows a typical example of the morphology after 3 hours of annealing. The CRP grains (Rex in Fig. 3a) formed heterogeneously preferentially at or near GB’s between the unrecrystallized deformed grains (Unrex 1 to Unrex 3 in Fig. 3a). Figure 3b depicts an example of the microstructre after 5 hours of annealing. Now a significant fraction of CRP grains is also present at micro-bands within an unrecrystallized grain in addition to CRP grains at GB’s. During up to 12 hours of annealing this process of heterogeneous nucleation of CRP grains at GB’s and deformation bands and their growth into the surrounding unrecrystallized volume continued. Figure 3d depicts a typical example of CRP grains at transition bands, which separate regions of differently oriented deformed crystal with shear bands. Planar faults, akin to stacking faults or microtwins, are discernible in the largest of the CRP grains in the annealed FePd (e.g. Figure 3a and 3d). Furthermore, the population of CRP grains consists of a very large number of grains with sizes of less than 1.0 I”and very few large grains up to about 10 pm in size (e.g. Figure 3c and 3d). Comparison of Figures 3a-c clearly indicates qualitatively that the volume fraction transformed by the combined reaction, the recrystallized fraction, increases with annealing time up to 12 hours. Computer assisted image analyses of SEM micrographs covering fields of view of approximately 500pm by 500pm for each annealing state have been used to determine the recrsytallized area fraction. Accordingly, the fraction recrystallized increased from = 2%, = 12% and ~ 3 6 % after 3 hours, 5 hours and 12 hours after 24 hours annealing. Hence, recrystallization remained annealing, respectively, to a maximum of ~ 4 5 % incomplete even after 24 hours annealing. Figure 4 presents SEM micrographs of the microstructures typical of annealing for 12 hours and 24 hours at 500°C. While the microstructural morphology, namely heterogeneously distributed, irregularly shaped, small CRP grains and a majority volume fraction of unrecrystallized grains, remained essentially the same up to 12 hours of annealing (Figures 3 and 4 4 , a significantly different microstructure emerged after 24 hours of annealing at 500°C (Figure 4b). After 24 hours of annealing the microstructure appears to be more homogeneous, since the heterogeneously distributed small CRP grains that decorated GB’s between and deformation bands within unrecrystallized grains are no longer observed (Figure 4b). Instead, many much larger recrystallized grains (Rex in Figure 4b), that contain tell-tale annealing twins, and unrecrystallized grains (Unrex in Figure 4b) constitute the
Y
a
4
ij
c
F E
136
w
A. Deshpande et a1
1
Figure 4: SEM BSE micrographs of the microstructures after a) 12 hours and b) 24 hours of annealing. TEM studies have been performed to determine in detail the local microstructural changes in the unrecrystallized and the recrystallized grams in the cold-deformed Fe-Pd during the isothermal annealing at 500°C The TEM micrographs in Figure 5 have been obtained from unrecrystallized grains i n FePd samples after annealing at 500°C for 5 hours and 24 hours, respectively The complex contrast exhibited by the unrecrystallized grains (Figure 5) is characteristic of the nucleation and growth processes associated with t h e continuous ordering reaction [3] Strain contrast features of lenticular or nearly lamellar morphology align approximately parallel to the traces of dodecahedral planes, namely the directions [l-111 and [l-1-11 marked in the lower magnification bright field micrograph of Figure 5a The superlattice dark field micrograph in Figure 5b shows the same region as in Figure 5a at higher magnification and reveals in bright contrast very small (5 1Onm) coherent precipitates of one of the three orientation variants of the L1,ordered phase that emerge within the FCC matrix Under the influence of the attendant transformation strain variant selection occurs locally during growth and the small coherent L1,-precipitates coalesce to form larger ordered domains aligned parallel to traces of dodecahedral planes [e g 31 These observations are consistent with the emergence of an incipient polytwin structure I n the unrecrystallized grains during annealing of the cold-deformed Fe-Pd [3, 41 The continued ordering and coarsening of these aligned ordered domains during continued isothermal annealing at 500°C produces a fairly well developed polytwin structure i n the unrecrystallized grains after 24 hours (Figure 5c) The accompanying [OOI] zone axis SADP inset in Figure 5c exhibits eight superlattice spots surrounding the central spot, which indicates the presence of all three possible orientation variants of the tetragonal ordered phase in the unrecrystallized gram Effects of the internal strains associated with the defect structure introduced by cold-deformation are still detectable in SADP's after 24 hours of annealing at 500°C i n the unrecrystallized grains (inset in Figure 5c) Hence, during isothermal annealing of the cold-deformed Fe-Pd at 500°C the unrecrystallized grains transform from heavily deformed FCC y-(Fe,Pd) to Ll,,-ordered y,-FePd with a polytwinned morphology via the continuous ordering reaction that is characteristically observed for the undeformed material [4-71 Figure 6 presents an example multi-beam bright field TEM micrograph of the early stages of growth of CRP grains (marked A, B and C in Figure 6) after heterogeneous nucleation at a grain boundary between two unrecrystallized grains i n a sample of the deformed Fe-Pd after10 hours annealing. The bright field
Microstructure-property evolution in cold-worked equiatomic Fe-Pd
137
a
C
Figure 5: Example TEM micrographs depicting the evolution of L1,-type LRO in the unrecrystallized region. a) Bright field, g=002, off 11 101, b) corresponding dark field with g=OOl, both for 5 hours annealing at 5OO'C. Traces of dodecahedra1 planes parallel to [l-1 I] and [l-1-11 are marked in a). c) multi-beam bright field, beam direction = [OOl], inset SADP, for 24 hours annealing at 500°C. TEM micrograph of Figure 7a depicts i n more detail the CRP grain marked A in the overview presented i n Figure 6 The small CRP grain is essentially free of defects and diffraction experiments in the TEM confirmed it to have the ordered L1,-structure of y,-FePd The segment of GB between the CRP grain and
A. Deshpande et a1
138
the upper unrecrystallized gram (Unrex 1 i n Figure 6) contains numerous interfacial defects, most of which presumably are dislocations Microdiffraction patterns (pDP's) obtained from the regions marked X, Y and Z i n Figure 7a are shown in Figures 7b, 7c and 7d, respectively The pDP's indicate that regions X and Y exhibit similar orientations off [110] with only a small misorientation (< 3 " ) relative to each other (Figure 7b and 7c) Hence, the short segment of GB between the CRP grain (A i n Figure 6) and the upper unrecystallized grain (Unrex 1 in Figure 6) is consistent with a segment of low-angle GB (LAGB) The pDP obtained from the lower unrecrystallized grain (Unrex 2 in Figure 6 and label Z in Figure 7a) indicates a much larger misorientation with respect to the CRP grain (compare Figures 7b and 7d) Therefore, the GB segments between the CRP grain and the lower unrecrytallized grain appear to be consistent with highangle GB's (HAGB's) These observations are quite typical for the CRP grams that heterogeneously nucleated at GB's
25 t
I
t
Figure 6: Multi-beam bright field TEM micrograph depicting an example of new LI,-ordered CRP grains, near letters A, B, C, at a grain boundary between two unrecrystallized grains, marked Unrex 1 and Unrex 2, in the cold-deformed Fe-Pd after 10 hours of annealing at 500°C DISCUSSION The increase i n the maximum magnetic hardness, e g coercivity, attainable during annealing of cold-rolled Fe-Pd has been attributed to changes in microstructural morphology associated with the transformation of the cold-deformed, disordered material by the combined solid state reaction of concomitant recrystallization and ordering [6, 71 Here the magnetic age hardening behavior and microstructural evolution of equiatomic Fe-Pd cold-deformed by a single ECAP pass dunng isothermal annealing at 500°C has been determined experimentally In the initial stages of annealing the coercivity increases monotonically to a maximum (523 Oe) followed by a decrease to values typically exhibited by polytwinned L1,-FePd (349 Oe) (Table 1) This behavior is consistent with previous work 171 The XRD data (Table 2 ) indicated that the vgnificant increase i n coercivity from the initially very low value associated with the as-
Microstructure-property evolution in cold-worked equiatomic Fe-Pd
139
.-
Figure 7: Details of the new LI,-ordered grain marked A in Figure 7. a) Bright field TEM, g=-l1-1, off [I lo], b) low camera length SADP from the new grain at X in a), c) SADP from unrecrystallized grain 1 at Y in a), p l 1 - 3 off [110], and d) SADP from unrecrystallized grain 2 at 2 in a), g is of type (111) and beam direction is far off [I 101. deformed state (37 Oe) to the maximum value (523 Oe) correlates with the development of significant fractions of the ordered tetragonal L1,-structure The SEM and TEM observations (Figures 3 to 7) are consistent with the LRO evolution documented by the XRD data (Table 2) However, the subsequent decrease in coercivity to about 350 Oe cannot be attributed to the LRO parameter alone, which, as would be expected, continues to increase to the equilibrium value at 500°C with annealing time (Table 2). Similarly, the fraction recrystallized increased monotonically with annealing time to a maximum of about 45% after 24 hours (e.g Figures 3 and 4) Thus, the charactenstic magnetic age hardening behavior of colddeformed Fe-Pd (TabIe 1) cannot be attributed solely to the evolution of LRO and/or the evolution of the fraction recrystallized Furthermore, recrystallization remained incomplete, even after 24 hours of annealing The microstructure responsible for the maximum coercivity (523 Oe after 12 hours annealing at 500°C) contained about 64% of unrecrystallized volume and only 36% of recrystallized or combined reaction transformed volume (e g Figures 3 and 4). The former consists of the LI,-ordered phase with nearly the equilibrium LRO parameter and exhibits an incipient polytwin structure after annealing for 5 hours or more (Table 2 and Figure 5) The latter is comprised of heterogeneously distributed, perfectly L1,ordered and nearly defect-free, monolithic CRP grains with maximum grain sizes of less than = 10 pm and average grain size of about l p m (e g. Figures 3 and 4) It has been proposed [7] that the increased coercivities of combined reaction transformed FePd alloy3 originates from a superposition of magnetic hardening by a greatly reduced grain size (grain size hardening) and by pinning of magnetic domain walls by planar defects According to Klemmer et al [7] the grain size hardening contribution to the coercivity enhancement, AHD, in the combined reaction transformed FePd can be given approximately by AHD= 6 (y /DM,) Here fi is a geometrical term with a value between 1 to 5, y is the domain wall energy (17 ergkm’), M, is the saturation magnetization (1 100 emukm’) and D is the grain size [7] Considering the range for 6 and a grain size of 1 pm, the approximate upper and lower bounds of AH, are estimated as about 155 Oe to 775 Oe. For grain sizes of 30pm or larger the grain size hardening effect becomes negligible (I e for 80 pm AH, = 2 Oe to 10 Oe) After 24 hour? annealing at 500°C the fraction recrystallized increased to a
140
A. Deshpande et al
maximum of = 45%, i.e. recrystallization was incomplete, and the CRP-grains increased dramatically in size to = 80pm (e.g. Figure 4). Hence, it appears reasonable to conclude that the significant grain growth in the fraction of CRP grains documented here for the first time (e.g. Figures 3 and 4) is responsible for the observed drop in coercivity for annealing times in excess of 12 hours (Table 1). Conversely, the coercivity increase in the first 12 hours of annealing may be attributed chiefly to the monotonic increase in the volume fraction of CRP grains with an average size of approximately 1 pm (Figures 3 to 7). Of course, an additional contribution to the coercivity increase over the first 12 hours of annealing is associated with the increases in LRO from the transformation of the unrecrystallized grains by the continuous ordering reaction. At longer annealing times the development and coarsening of the polytwin structure should further reduce the coercivity of the material. In conclusion, a grain size hardening effect as proposed in [7] appears to be most suitable to rationalize the magnetic hardening behavior observed here. The SEM and TEM observations of the microstructural evolution of the CR transformed fraction in the FePd alloys are very similar to those reported for the early stages of annealing of cold-deformed FCC metals with low stacking fault energy [9-111. For instance, the large strain energy gradients present at deformation (shear, micro- and transition) bands and at large angle GB's in the cold-deformed microstructure appear to enhance the probability for the formation of the essentially strain-free CRP grains (Figure 3), just as in recrystallization of disordered metals. Furthermore, small CRP grains growing at GB's between unrecrystallized grains exhibit an approximate orientation relationship with one of the unrecrystallized grains, with which they share a segment of LAGB (Figures 6 and 7). The CRP grains grow predominantly into the other unrecrystallized grain, with which they share HAGB's, while growth into the unrecrystallized grains with which they share a LAGB is negligible (Figures 6 and 7). Based on the TEM observations (Figures 6 and 7) it is tempting to propose that the formation of stable embryonic CRP grains can occur by processes similar to a bulge mechanism for recrystallized grains in disordered metals [lo, 121. Thus, the recrystallization front or more precisely the CR transformation front propagates by migration of HAGB's. Therefore, mechanisms similar to those proposed for stacking fault and microtwin formation at the migrating HAGB's during the recrystallization of cold-deformed FCC metals with low stacking fault energy [13, 141 appear to be suitable to explain the origin of the planar defects observed in the larger ordered CRP grains. The usual definition of recrystallization is the formation and migration of HAGB's driven by the stored strain energy of cold-deformation [e.g 111. During the CR transformation in equiatomic Fe-Pd HAGB's form and migrate. Hence, in this sense the CR is similar to recrystallization of disordered metals and alloys. However, the change in crystal structure facilitated by the CR is usually not a feature of concern in recrystallization of disordered metals and alloys. It is interesting to note that the ordering transformation in equiatomic Fe-Pd can be achieved by both the usually kinetically dominant continuous ordering mode and/or by a discontinuous ordering mode, akin to a massive transformation 114, 151. Indeed, during isothermal transformation of undeformed Fe-Pd at sufficiently low temperatures a limited volume transformed by the discontinuous mode of ordering has been observed [6]. Therefore, an important effect of cold-deformation on the ordering transformation of equiatomic Fe-Pd appears to be the acceleration of the kinetics of the discontinuous mode with respect to those of the continuous mode of ordering. Hence, it is likely that the experimentally observed accelerated ordering kinetics in cold-deformed equiatomic Fe-Pd relative to the undeformed material [16-181 can be attributed to the CR mode of transformation. The driving force for the CR mode is a combination of the difference in Gibbs free energy of the ordering reaction, y(FCC) => y,(Llo), and the stored strain energy of cold-deformation. This driving
Microstructure-property evolution in cold-worked equiutomic Fe-Pd
141
force diminishes with increasing time during annealing mainly because the continuous mode of ordering is operative in the unrecrystallized volume and to a lesser degree because recovery processes lower the stored energy of cold-deformation. Thus, once the LRO parameter reaches the equilibrium value the recrystallization process or the CR transformation essentially comes to a halt. Then the annealing phenomenon of grain growth becomes significant in the CR transformed fraction of the material. This scenario is consistent with the experimental results presented here.
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION 1)
2) 3) 4)
Isothermal annealing of the cold-deformed FePd at 500°C produces complex, hetcrogencous microstructures that exhibit significantly enhancd coercivities with respect to conventionally processed FePd with the polytwin structure. For the processing condition utilized here, the maximum coercivity (523 Oe) is associated with a partially recrystallized (=36%) microstructure of fully ordered y,-FePd with the L1,-structure. The magnetic age hardening behavior of the combined reaction transformed FePd observed here has been attributed to a grain size hardening effect. The observed microstructural evolution during annealing of the cold-deformed FePd has been rationalized in terms of the competition between the combined reaction, which may be considered as a discontinuous ordering mode with kinetics enhanced by the stored energy of cold-deformation, and the continuous ordering mode.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors gratefully acknowledge support for this work from the National Science Foundation, DMRMetals (NSF-0094213), with Dr. K. L. Murty as program manager. One of the authors (HH) also gratefully acknowledges support from the Department of Materials Science and Engineering, University of Pittsburgh, during his sabbatical stay in Pittsburgh during the summer 2002.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Weller, D., and Moser, A. (1999) IEEE Trans. Magn. 35,4423. Magat, L.M., Yermolenko, AS., Ivanova, G.V., Makarova, G.M., and Shur, YAS. (1968) Fiz. Metal. Metalloved. 26,511. Zhang, B., Lelovic, M., and Soffa, W.A. (1991) Scripta met. mat. 25, 1577. Khachaturyan, A.G. (1983) In: Theory of Structural Transformations in Solids”, p. 368, John Wiley & Sons, New York. Yanar, C., Wiezorek, J.M.K., and Soffa, W.A. (2000) In: Phase Transformations and Evolution of Microstructure in Materials, pp. 39-54, Turchi, P. et a1 (Eds).TMS, Warrendale. Klemmer, T., and Soffa, W.A. (1994). In: Solid-Solid Phase Transformations, pp. 969-974, Johnson, W.C., Howe, J.M., Laughlin, D.E., and Soffa, W.S. (Eds). TMS, Warrendale.
142 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.
A. Deshpande et a1
Klemmer, T., Hoydick, D., Okumura, H., Zahng, B., and Soffa, W.A. (1995) Scripta met. mat. 33, 1793. Segal, V.M. (1999) Mat. Sci. Eng. A 271, 322. Berger, A,, Willbrandt, P.-J., Emst, F., Klement, U., and Haasen, P. (1988) Progr. Mat. Sci. ??, 1. Willbrandt, P.-J., and Haasen, P. (1980) Z. Metallkde 273. Doherty, R.D., Hughes, D.A., Humphreys, F.J., Jonas, J.J., Jensen, D.J., Kassner, M.E., King, W.E., McNelley, T.R., McQueen, H.J., and Rollett, A.D. (1997) Mat. Sci. Eng. A 238, 219. Reed-Hill, R.E., and Abbaschian, R. (1992) In: Physical Metallurgy Principle, p 247, PWS Pub. Co., Boston. Gleiter, H. (1969) Acta met. 12,1421. Yanar, C., Radmilovic, V., Soffa, W.A., and Wiezorek, J.M.K. (2001) Intermetallics 9, 949. Yanar, C.,Wiezorek, J.M.K., Radmilovic, V., and Soffa, W.A., (2002) Met. Mat. Trans A 33, 2413. Greenberg, B.A., Volkov, A.Y., Kruglikov, N.A., Rodionova, L.A., Grokhovskaya, L.G., Gushchin, G.M., and Sakhanskaya, I.N. (2002) Phys. Met. Metallog. 92,167. Kulovits, A. (2002) Diploma thesis, University of Vienna. Peiler, W. (2002) priv. comm. at MRS Fall Mtg, Boston.
a,
PART 3: STRUCTURAL MATERIALS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) Published by Elsevier Ltd.
MICROSTRUCTURE AND PROPERTIES OF IN SITU TOUGHENED SILICON CARBIDE Lutgard C. De Jonghe
R. 0. Ritchie
and Xiao Feng Zhang
'
' Materials Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA Department of Materials Science and Engineering, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA
ABSTRACT A silicon carbide with a fracture toughness as high as 9.1 MPa.ml' has been developed by hot pressing pSic powder with aluminum, boron, and carbon additions (ABC-Sic). Central in this material development has been systematic transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and mechanical characterizations. In particular, atomic-resolution electron microscopy and nanoprobe composition quantification were combined in analyzing grain boundary structure and nanoscale structural features. Elongated Sic grains with 1 nmwide amorphous intergranular films were believed to be responsible for the in situ toughening of this material, specifically by mechanisms of crack deflection and grain bridging. Two methods were found to be effective in modifying microstructure and optimizing mechanical performance. First, prescribed postannealing treatments at temperatures between 1100 and 15OO0Cwere found to cause full crystallization of the amorphous intergranular films and to introduce uniformly dispersed nanoprecipitates within Sic matrix grains; in addition, lattice diffusion of aluminum at elevated temperatures was seen to alter grain boundary composition. Second, adjusting the nominal content of sintering additives was also observed to change the grain morphology, the grain boundary structure, and the phase composition of the ABC-Sic. In this regard, the roles of individual additives in developing microstructure were identified; this was demonstrated to be critical in optimizing the mechanical properties, including fracture toughness and fatigue resistance at ambient and elevated temperatures, flexural strength, wear resistance, and creep resistance. INTRODUCTION Silicon carbide (Sic) offers many intrinsic advantages as a structural ceramic, including a high melting temperature, low density, high elastic modulus and hardness, excellent wear resistance, and low creep rates at elevated temperatures. This remarkable combination of features make Sic one of the most promising advanced structural ceramic materials for a variety of advanced engineering technologies. An imperative in these structural applicationsis high fracture toughness, which for commercially available Sic is typically on the order of 3 MPa.m'", well below that of grain-elongated Si3N4 and yttria-stabilized ZrOz, for example. This low toughness clearly limits its utility. The toughening of ceramic materials can best be induced by crack bridging mechanisms (i.e., extrinsic toughening by crack-tip shielding), which can result from crack paths bridged by unbroken reinforcement fibers in composite ceramics (ex situ toughening) [l-31, or by self-reinforcement from elongated grains in monolithic ceramics (in situ toughening) [4]. The latter approach was exploited in the present work by hot pressing Sic with Al, B and C additives (ABC-Sic [ 5 ] ) . Two strategies, specifically post-annealing heat treatments and changes in the additive content, were used to optimize the microstructure.
145
146
L.C. De Jonghe, R.O. Ritchie and X.F. Zhang
In this paper, we review the microstructure and mechanical properties of in situ toughened Sic. In particular, atomic-resolution TEM in conjunction with nanoprobe chemical analyses were employed to determine the structure and chemistty of the grain boundaries. Such atomic-scale characterization was correlated with materials processing and mechanical testing with the objective of optimizing the structural performance of ABC-Sic.
It is perhaps fitting that this work is presented in a symposium dedicated to the career of Professor Gareth Thomas, who was a pioneer in the development of materials through the use of transmission electron microscopy and intelligent microstructure design - this paper is dedicated to him in recognition of his leading contributionsto this field of materials science [e.g., [6,7]].
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES Submicron P-SiC powder was mixed with 3 w P ? aluminum metal powder, 0.6 wt% boron, and 2 wt% carbon sintering. The slurry was stir dried, sieved, and uniaxially pressed at 35 MPa. The green bodies were hot pressed at 50 MPa at 190OOC for 1 hr in an Ar atmosphere. The final product, which was produced as 99% dense (3.18 g/cm3),4 mm thick and 38 mm diameter disks of polycrystalline Sic, was compromise of predominantly 4H and 6H a-Sic phases, with a minor fraction of 3C p-Sic. Some as-hot-pressed ABCSic samples were further annealed in a tungsten mesh furnace under flowing Ar, at temperatures between 1000 and 15OO0C, for times typically ranging from 72 to 168 hr. Structural and mechanical characterizations were performed for both as-hot-pressed and annealed samples. Structural and chemical analyses were carried out in a 200 kV Philips CM200 transmission electron microscope equipped with a windowless detector and corresponding X-ray energy-dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) system. A spatial-difference methodology was developed to determine the concentration of the impurities in the Sic grain boundaries using a nanoprobe with a diameter varied between 3 and 20 nm [8,9]. Indentation hardness, four-point bending strength, creep resistance, abrasive wear properties, R-curve fracture toughness, and cyclic fatigue-crack growth behavior at ambient and elevated temperatures were all evaluated for ABC-Sic. Experimental procedures for each of these mechanical property assessments are described in detail in the respective references quoted in this paper.
RESULTS General Aspects Some typical mechanical properties for as-processed ABC-Sic are summarized in Table 1. Of particular note is the fracture toughness, which has been measured to be as high as 7 to 9 MPa.m’”; this is the highest 4,value recorded for Sic to date.
Sample
ABC-Sic
4-Point Bending Strength (MPa)
691+12
Hardness* (GPa)
561f13
Fracture Toughness (MPa.mIn)
6.8-9.1 (iO.4)
Microstructure and properties of in situ toughened silicon carbide
147
Using X-ray diffraction, 70 vol.% of the hot-pressed structure was identified as hexagonal 4H-Sic and the remaining 30% as cubic 3C-Sic. TEM studies revealed that the 3C-to4H phase transformation, which is presumed to have occurred during hot pressing, promoted anisotropic grain growth [lo], resulting in high area density of plate-like, elongated S ic grains (Figure la); the length and width of these grains ranged from 3 to 11 pm and 1 to 3 pm, respectively, with an aspect ratio for 90 % of them between 2 and 5. Interlocking between the elongated Sic grains was often observed, as shown in Figure lb. Equiaxed 3CSic grains with a submicron size were also found in ABC-Sic. It is believed that the unusually high toughness of ABC-Sic results from a combination of crack deflection and principally frictional and elastic bridging by the elongated Sic grains in the wake of the crack tip [5,11]. To optimize this toughening mechanism, an understanding of the grain boundary properties and structure is crucial; consequently, extensive TEM studies were focused on this feature of the microstructure.
Figure 1: (a) Bright-field TEM images showing elongated Sic grains in ABC-Sic. (b) Two elongated grains are interlocked
Figure 2: (a) High-resolution electron micrograph showing a typical intergranular film between two Si c matrix grains. An amorphous structure is observed with a width of about 1 nm. (b) Distribution of amorphous grain boundary widths determined by high-resolution electron microscopy. The grain boundary width ranges from 0.75 nm to 2.75 nm, with a mean of about 1 nm. Figure 2a shows a high-rcsolution TEM image of a typical grain boundary area in as-pressed ABC-Sic. An amorphous intergranular film is seen between two adjacent Sic grains, about 1 nm in width. Using highresolution electron microscopy, the statistical width of these films was determined; results are shown in Figure 2b. Specifically, the amorphous grain boundary films range in width from about 0.75 to 2.75 nm, with a mean of -1 nm. This width is consistent with the values found in other ceramic materials [12,13], and with theoretical explanations developed by Clarke [14]. In some particularly wide films (e.g. -2.75 nm), nanoscale crystallites were recognizable, indicating local ordering in the glassy films. Earlier work on Sic sintered with boron and carbon showed a solid-phase sintering procedure with no grain boundary films being formed [ 15,161. The formation of the current films was due to liquid-phase sintering promoted by the A1 additives. The liquid phase allowed for densification of the Sic at temperatures roughly 200°C lower than Al-free compositions, i.e., at -1900°C instead of -2100°C. The amorphous intergranular films provide the preferred crack path, which is an essential element for the development of crack bridging and hence toughening in ABC-Sic.
148
L.C. De Jonghe, R.O. Rztchie and X.F. Zhang
Nanoprobe EDS analyses revealed that the grain boundary films contained substantial Al, 0, Si, and C. The oxygen came mainly from the SO2 surface oxidation of the Sic starting powder, and is one of the features responsible for difference in the behavior of different starting powders. Boron was below the detectability limit at the grain boundaries and in the interior of the Sic grains. In fact, boron was largely involved in forming A1&C7 secondary phases. Other secondary phases identified in ABC-SIC include A120C-Sic, mullite, A1203, A14C3, A1404C,and Al-0-C-B crystalline phases. These secondary phases were submicron in dimension and were present as triple-junction particles [8,17]. A1 in solution in the Sic matrix grains was also detected. Similar to Sic studied here, A1 and 0 concentrations in grain boundaries and their effects on Si3N4 phase transformation were reported by Goto and Thomas [ 181. Effects of Post-annealing The most significant phenomenon that we observed in the efforts of modifying microstructure of ABC-Sic was crystallization of amorphous intergranular films in post-annealing. While no significant change in the overall, large-scale microstructure was recognized, annealing at 1000°C for only 5-30 hours was sufficient to transform about half number of the amorphous grain boundary films into more ordered structures. Apparently, 1000°C was about the threshold temperature for activation of grain boundary diffusion. Annealing at higher temperatures for prolonged hours fully crystallized the intergranular films [8]. For example, whereas about 90% of the grain boundaries were amorphous in as-hot-pressed samples, 86% of the intergranular films in the annealed material were found to be crystalline. Figure 3a shows a highresolution TEM image of a grain boundary film crystallized after annealing at 1200°C for 500 hrs. In this image, the crystallized grain boundary film is not readily distinguishable because the grain boundary phase was strictly epitaxial with the 6H-Sic grain on the left-hand side. However, corresponding EDS detected substantial AI-0-Si-C segregations between the two Sic grains, confirming the existence of the boundary phase. An enlarged image from the framed area is shown in Figure 3b for closer inspection. The two adjacent Sic grains in this image show very different orientations. Due to a large deviation from the [l 1 201 type zone-axes, only (0004) lattice fringes, with the lattice spacing of 0.25 nm, could be resolved for the 4H-Sic grain on the upper-right side, while a two-dimensional [llZO] zone-axis lattice can be recognized in the 6H-Sic grain on the other side of the grain boundary. Under the imaging conditions for Figure 3, the black dots in the image correspond to cationic columns along the incident electron beam direction. Some black dots in the 6H-Sic grain were marked with black circles. The zigzag stacking of the dots correspond to the ...ABCACBABCACB... hexagonal structure of the 6H-Sic. The closest layer spacing along the c-direction is 0.25 nm.
Figure 3: (a) High-resolution electron microscopy image for a grain boundary area in ABC-Sic annealed at 12OO0Cfor 500 hrs. Amorphous intergranular film is crystallized. (b) Enlarged image from the framed area in (a). Atomic stacking in 6H-Sic grain on the bottom-left side is marked by black circles. 2Hwurtzite atomic stacking in grain boundary film (GB) are marked by white circles. Note the epitaxial orientation relationships between the grain boundary film and the 6H-Sic matrix grain.
Microstructure and properties of in situ toughened silicon carbide
149
The grain boundary layer outlined in Figure 3b can be distinguished by the abrupt change in the atomic arrangement. Some lattice points in the boundary region are marked with white circles. The projection distance between adjacent lattice dots in the grain boundary layers is very close to that in the neighboring 6H-Sic grain, and the characteristic zigzag lattice arrangement is also apparent in the boundary layer. These observations would suggest a grain boundary film structure similar to 6H-Sic. However, instead of the ...ABCACBABCACB.. . periodic stacking for every six layers in the 6H-type structure, the stacking period in the grain boundary phase contains only two layers in one period, resulting in ...ABABAB... stacking with an 0.5 nm repeat length, within a grain boundary width of about 1.25 nm. In conjunction with the quantitative analysis of the grain boundary composition and computer image simulations, we concluded that one of the intergranular crystalline phases was aluminosilicate with a AIzOC-SiC solid solution composition and a 2H-wurtzite structure (hexagonal unit cell, a = 3.1 8, c = 5.0 A) [8,19]. The crystallized structure usually has an epitaxial structural relationship with Si c matrix grains when the (0001) habit plane is available. As shown in Figure 3, the typical grain boundary width after crystallization remains about 1 nm.
To further study the crystallization process in intergranular films at elevated temperatures, an ABC-Sic sample was heated in situ in a 300 kV JEOL 3010 transmission electron microscope equipped with a hot stage. Figure 4 shows high-resolution images €or the same intergranular film before and after in sifu heating, respectively. The amorphous film prior to heating crystallized discretely after 25 hrs at 1200°C, as indicated by arrowheads in Figure 4b. The crystallization tended to proceed epitaxially on the (0001) plane of the adjacent 6H-Sic matrix grain, with a 2H-wurtzite structure similar to that observed in ex situ annealed Sic samples. No discemable features could be identified as potential preferential sites for nucleation at the SiCifilm interface. Presumably, local compositional fluctuations in the intergranular films serve as nucleation sites.
Figure 4: (a) High-resolution image of an amorphous intergranular film in as-hot-pressed ABC-Sic. (b) The same film as in (a) but after in situ heating in a transmission electron microscope at 1200°C for 25 hrs. Arrowheads indicate the discrete, crystallized boundary segments. Another significant consequence of the thermal treatment was coherent nano-precipitation within Si c matrix grains, as seen in Figure 5a. Although Figure 5a was taken from a sample annealed at 14OO0C,the plate-like nanoprecipitates first formed at 130OOC. The precipitates were uniform in size and shape, and dispersed within the Sic matrix grains. The projected dimension of the precipitates after 1300°C annealing is -4 x 1 nmz with a volumetric number density of 5x1OzZ/m3. The precipitates coarsened with annealing temperature, accompanied by decrease in the number density. Detailed high-resolution electron microscopy characterization and nanoprobe EDS analysis determined an AlbCs-based structure and composition for the nanoprecipitates [20]. A comparison between 6H-Sic and A14C3 structures projected along the [OOOl] direction is shown in Figure 5b. The similarity between the two structures caused coherent precipitation with the (0001) habit planes. The formation and coarsening of the precipitates at 1300 to 1600°C was a
L.C. De Jonghe, R.O. Rztchie and X.F. Zhang
150
consequence of lattice-diffusion-controlled classic nucleation and growth [20]. The diffusion of Al-rich species through Sic lattice starting at 130OoCresulted in At-enrichment in grain boundary films, as revealed by EDS.
Figure 5: (a) A14C3-based nanoprecipitate formed in a 6H-Sic grain annealed at 1400'C. The viewing directions are marked. (b) Atomic models for 6H-Sic and Al&3 projected along the [OOOl] direction. The similarity between the two structures can be seen.
The A1 content in intergranular films as a function of annealing temperature was analyzed with EDS. The results are plotted in Figure 6. It is apparent that Al solution in Sic grains decreased at llOO°C and especially above 1300'C, consistent with TEM observations that Al solutions formed nano recipitates &) changed exsolved from the Sic lattice. Not surprisingly, the A1 site density in the grain boundaries (NAI as well upon annealing. Below 12OO0C,the composition of intergranular films was virtually invariant, even while the intergranular films crystallized. The N*yB value was doubled at 1300°C, which can be readily correlated with diffusion of the Al-rich chemical species into the grain boundary films. The Al content in intergranular films after annealing at 1300°C is in agreement with All lSi0 @ c , a solid solution between 2Hwurtzite AlzOC and Sic [19]. At even higher annealing temperatures up to 16OO0C, N A ? ~changed marginally taking the standard deviation into account.
- . ; i
0
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.-
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 Anneallng Temperature ( O C )
0
Figure 6: Plots of EDS-determined Al site density in grain boundary films @A?*) (AVSiC, wt??)as a function of annealing temperature.
and in Sic matrix grains
The structural evolutions in intergranular films during thermal treatment demonstrated a profound influence on mechanical properties. It was found that the high strength, cyclic fatigue resistance, and particularly the fracture toughness of A3C-Sic at ambient temperature were not severely compromised at elevated temperatures. For example, the fatigue-crack growth properties up to 130OoC were essentially identical to those at 25OC. Figure 7 illustrates the variation in fatigue-crack growth rates, du/dN, with applied stressintensity range, AK, at a load ratio (minimum to maximum load) of R = 0.1 for ABC-Sic under different test conditions. It can be seen that at both 2% and 13OO0C,crack-growth rates display a marked sensitivity to the stress intensity but little effect is from change of loading frequency over the range 3 to 1000 Hz [21-231. Mechanistically, the lack of a frequency effect in ABC-Sic is expected as crack advance occurs via predominantly intergranular cracking ahead of the tip, as shown in Figure 8. Grain bridging in the crack
Microstructure and properties of in situ toughened silicon carbide
151
wake is a common feature. However, the absence of a frequency effect at elevated temperatures is surprising, particularly since comparable materials, such as Si3N4, A1203 and silicide-matrix ceramics, show a marked sensitivity to frequency at above 1000°C [24-281. In these later materials, softening of the intergranular films, grain boundary cavitation and viscous-phase bridging are common. In contrast, TEM studies of regions in the immediate vicinity of the crack tip in ABC-Sic (e.g. Figure 8) provided direct confirmation of fracture mechanisms which were similar at ambient and elevated temperatures, with no evidence for grain boundary cavitation (creep) damage or viscous-phase bridging at temperatures as high as 1300°C. We conclude that the unique high-temperature mechanical characteristics of ABC-Sic appear to be a result of the thermal-induced crystallization of intergranular glassy films. vZ25Hz. R=0.1 1 0 25% o 850°C A 1200°C 0 13OO0C F 3 H z . R=0.1 U 850°C 6 A 1200’C % 1300°C F25Hz. R=0.5 @ @ 1300°C
i
8
2 3 4 5 6 stress intensity Range, AK (MPam”‘)
Figure 7: Cyclic fatigue-crack growth rates, da/dN, in ABC-SIC as a function of the applied stress-intensity range, AK,for the tests conducted at temperatures between 25 and 13OO0C,load ratio R = 0.1, and frequencies between 3 and 1000 Hz.
Figure 8: TEM images of the intergranular crack profiles at the crack tip region in ABC-Sic at 1300°C under (a) cyclic loading (25 Hz, R = O.l), and (b) static loading. Arrows indicate the general direction of crack propagation. No evidence of viscous grain boundary layers or creep damage. The structural evolutions in grain boundary and matrix grains at elevated temperatures also benefit other mechanical properties of ABC-Sic. For example, the steady-state creep rate at high temperature of 1500°C was still impressively low (5 x 10-9/sat 100 MPa), and the creep rates at 120OoC in ABC-Sic was about three orders of magnitude slower than in single-crystal Ni-base superalloy tested under the same conditions [29]. In addition, 80% strength loss at 1300°C was restored by post-annealing [20]. Abrasive wear resistance was improved as well by formation of nanoprecipitates and by structural and compositional changes in grain boundaries after annealing [30]. These structural and mechanical characterization results demonstrate that the prescribed annealing is an effective way in tuning the microstructure and in turn optimizing the mechanical properties of ABC-Sic.
L.C. De Jonghe, R.O. Rztchie and X.F. Zhang
152
Effects of Additive Content Parallel to the post-annealing, another effort in tailoring microstructure and mechanical properties of ABCSic was in adjusting the nominal contents of the Al, B, and C sintering additives. A series of samples were prepared by changing content of one of the three additives. For example, the A1 content was 3 w f ?in most ABC-Sic samples. This was then increased to 4 np to 7 wt%, while boron and carbon contents remained at 0.6 and 2 wt%, respectively. The samples were referred to as 3ABC-, 4ABC, up to 7ABC-SiC, according to the weight percentage of the A1 content. Structural characterizations showed that A1 variations between 3 and 7 wt% did not reduce the densification of Sic samples under the same processing conditions. However, changing the A1 content did alter the microstructure, as illustrated in Figure 9 (only images for the 3ABC5ABC-, and 7ABC-Sic are shown). Although all samples were composed of plate-like, elongated Sic grains and equiaxed Sic grains, the size, aspect ratio and area density of the elongated grains varied significantly with increasing A1 content. The length of the elongated grains was found to be at a maximum in the 5ABC-Sic, with the aspect ratio increasing almost linearly up to 6 wt% Al. Compared to 3ABC-SiC, the aspect ratios in the 4ABC- to the 7ABC-Sic are much higher, but the area density of these elongated grains continuously decreases. A distinct bimodal grain distribution is seen in the 5ABC-Sic, with elongated a-Sic grains and submicron-sized equiaxed p-Sic grains [3 11.
Figure 9: Morphologies of the 3ABC-, 5ABC-, and 7ABC-Sic are shown in images in (a) to (c), respectively. Note the significant changes in dimension and area density of the elongated Sic grains. Note also the bimodal grain systems with 5ABC-Sic.
Samples 3ABC-Sic 4ABC-Sic
I
Phase and Volume Fraction 70% 4H 30% 3 c 19% 6H, 23% 4H 58% 3 c 67% 3C 24% 6H 76% 3C 20% 6H
Toughness Hardness* (GPa) 6.8fO.3 24.1
4-Point Bending Strength (MPa) 691f12
I
561k13
(MPa.ml’*)
I
6.3f0.7
480f30
8.9f0.4
598f34
3.2f0.2
533f58
3.9f0.4
I
23.9
*Vickers indentation, Load = 10 kg. E = 430 GPa (for calculation). Changing of the A1 content by 1 wt% not only caused a considerable change in the grain morphology, but also induced different degrees of 3C-to-4H and/or 6H-to-4H Sic phase conversion during hot-pressing. Xray diffraction spectra were collected from polished surfaces of the 3ABC- to 7ABC-Sic samples and from the starting powder for comparison. The spectra were matched with standard 3C-, 4H-, 6H-, and 15R-Sic phase spectra; results are summarized in Table 2. It was found that the 3 wt% A1 addition in the 3ABC-Sic was sufficient to transform all of the 20% preexisting 6H-phase seeds in 3C-dominanted starting powder
Microstructure and properties of in situ toughened silicon carbide
153
into 4H-SiC, with more than 50% of the p-3C transforming into a-4H phase as well. However, a 1 wt% higher A1 content resulted in a completely different phase composition by retarding the 3C-to-4H transformation. Further increases in A1 monotonically decreased the extent of the 3C-to-4H transformation, and apparently inhibited the preexisting 6H phase to be transformed into 4H. These results imply that the 3C-to-4H transformation was mainly promoted by boron and carbon, and the transformation was retarded when boron and carbon were compensated by increasing the A1 content. The experimental data also suggest close relationships between the phase composition and grain morphology, which would be expected if the pto-a transformation promotes the grain elongation [ 101.
In addition to the grain morphology, a factor that may have a determining influence on mechanical properties of dense, polycrystalline ceramic materials is the grain boundary structure and composition, as noted above. High-resolution TEM showed that about 90% of the intergranular films examined in the 3ABC-Sic processed an amorphous structure. In contrast, this fraction dropped to about 50% in the 5ABCSic, and all grain boundary films examined in the 7ABC-Sic were crystalline in structure. Quantitative EDS analyses indicated that increasing the nominal A1 content enhanced A1 concentration in the intergranular films, as well as in the Sic grains bulk, but the concentrations saturated in 5ABC-Sic. More than 5 wt?? A1 resulted in precipitation of excessive free Al, as observed in the 6ABC-and 7ABC-Sic. It should be pointed out that crystalline grain boundaries were prevalent in as-hot-pressed SABC-, to 7ABCSic without any post-treatment. It is thus plausible that enhanced A1 facilitates formation of crystalline intergranular films. These changes in microstructure can be expected to affect mechanical properties. Table 2 lists various mechanical properties for the sample series. The mechanical data illustrate the tradeoff mechanical performance which is often encountered in developing advanced ceramic materials. While the highest strength was obtained in the 3ABC-SiC, the hardness was at maximum for the 6ABC-Sic. As for toughness, it is clear that 5 wt% A1 resulted in the best toughness whereas 6 wt?? or higher A1 additions significantly degraded the toughness so that the materials became extremely brittle. Cyclic fatigue tests revealed that the 3ABC- and particularly the 5ABC-Sic displayed excellent crack-growth resistance at both ambient (25T) and elevated (1300'C) temperatures. Again, the crack propagation in both 3ABC- and 5ABC-Sic was intergranular, and crack bridging was observed in the crack wake. No evidence of viscous grain boundary layers and creep damage, in the form of grain-boundary cavitation, was seen at temperatures up to 13OO0C. The substantially enhanced toughness in the SABC-Sic was associated with extensive crack bridging from both interlocking grains, as in 3ABC-SiC, and uncracked ligaments, which only occurred in 5ABC-Sic. No toughening by crack bridging was apparent in 7ABC-SiC, concomitant with a transition from intergranular to transgranular fracture [32]. Similar to the aluminum concentration variations, changes in boron and carbon contents also alter the microstructure and phase composition. Typical results are shown in Figure 10. In this case, the A1 content was fixed at 6 wt%, while either the B or the C concentrations were changed. The phase composition determined by X-ray diffraction is noted in each image. It is clear that at fixed A1 (6 wt??)and B(0.6 wt%) contents, 1 wt?hadditional carbon promoted the formation of more elongated grains and enhanced the 3Cto-4H transformation (most of the 6H phase should originate from starting powder). This effect of carbon on 3C-to-4H transformation was also reported before by Sakai et al [33]. Growth of the equiaxed grains was found to be limited. With the A1 and C contents kept constant, increasing the boron content from 0.6 wt?? to 0.9 wt% largely increased the number density of elongated grains, but reduced their aspect ratio. In addition, boron promoted the 3C-to-4H and 6H-to-4H phase transformations more effectively than carbon. The positive effect of boron on the 6H-to-4H transformation is consistent with the previous observations of Huang et a1 [34].
-
L.C. De Jonghe, R.O. Rztchie and X.F. Zhang
154
6 Wt% A1
0 6 wt% Boron
0.9 wt% Boron
2wt%C
1 3wt%C
Figure 10: Microstructural changes with fixed A1 (6 wPh) and adjusted boron or carbon contents. Phase compositions are marked in each image. Effects of boron and carbon additions in changing microstructure and phase composition are clear. The systematic processing and characterizations of a series of ABC-Sic described above also allowed for the determination of the roles of Al, B, and C additives in developing the microstructures of silicon carbide. The observed effects may be summarized as follows: in terms of developing phase composition, boron is more effective in promoting the p-to-a phase transformations than carbon. Aluminum retards the p-to-a phase transformation,but promotes the 6H-to-4H transformation. As for the developing grain morphology, aluminum and carbon both promote anisotropic grain growth, whereas boron tends to coarsen the volume fraction, but reduce the aspect ratio, of the elongated grains. It should be noted that during processing, the combined roles of the Al, B and C additives often override their individual roles. For example, B and C together favor of the P-to-a phase transformation associated with grain elongation; however, the final microstructure does not necessarily have strongly elongated grains as B and C have opposite effects on anisotropic grain growth. Actually, the B:C ratio determines the final grain configuration. Aluminum has a different effect: when the B:C ratio favors the anisotropic grain growth, Al-rich liquid phase accelerates such growth so that the aspect ratio is hrther increased. However, if the AI:B and AI:C ratios are reduced, less liquid phases are expected to be present after the Al-B-C reactions so that the effects of A1 are diminished. Further experiments have indicated that even at constant A1:B:C ratios, a change in total amount of additives can still alter the grain configuration and phase composition significantly. This emphasizes the fact that the optimization of the mechanical properties of many structural ceramics such as ABC-Sic is a strong function of the absolute and relative amounts of the sintering additives.
SUMMARY ABC-Sic ceramics with unprecedented toughness values as high as 9 MPa.m'" have been developed by hot pressing @-Sicpowder with additions of Al, B and C. Such high fracture toughnesses were attributed to an in situ toughening mechanism primarily involving crack bridging by interlocked and elongated Sic grains. The anisotropic growth of Sic grains, which promoted such toughening, was the result of the liquid-phase sintering in which A1 additives acted to form a liquid phase. The existence of this liquid phase also lowered the sintering temperature to 190OoC. The toughening mechanism also requires intergranular cracking which was aided by the presence of amorphous intergranular films (typically 1 nm in width) in the grain boundaries of the as-processed ABC-Sic. Two effective methods for modifying the grain boundary structure and chemistry, as well as the overall microstructure, were investigated using post-processing annealing and adjustments in the nominal contents of sintering additives. Prescribed post-annealing treatments at higher than 1OOO°C were found to activate grain boundary diffusion and consequently caused the crystallization of most of the glassy intergranular films (not simply the
Microstructure and properties of in situ toughened silicon carbide
155
“pockets” at the grain boundary triple points). This led to superior high temperature strength, creep and fatigue properties at elevated temperatures with no evidence of creep damage in the form of grain boundary cavitation until temperatures above 14OO0C were reached. Using atomic-resolution electron microscopy and quantitative nanoprobe EDS, one of the crystallized intergranular structures was identified as 2H-wurtzite ahminosilicate. Heating at 13OO0C or higher also resulted in uniformly dispersed nanoprecipitates as a result of lattice diffusion. In addition, the lattice diffusion almost doubled the segregation of A1 into the intergranular films. It is believed that this significant microstructural evolution, which occurs during postannealing and is not characteristically observed in other advanced ceramics such as Si3N4, and A1203, is the origin of the many outstanding mechanical property attributes of ABC-Sic at elevated temperatures. These include high resistance to crack growth at temperatures between ambient and 13OO0C,far superior steadystate creep resistance than in single-crystal Ni-base superalloys, enhanced resistance to abrasive wear, and high-temperature strength loss recovery. Changing the nominal contents of the sintering additives, Al, or B, or C, was also used as an effective means to modify the microstructure. In particular, the area density and dimensions of the elongated Sic grains, their phase composition, and the grain boundary structure were all found to be sensitive to small variations in additive content. Using this approach, a series of materials processing with systematic changes in sintering atom additions were used to develop optimal microstructures for ABC-Sic. Compositions with superior fracture toughness, or creep properties or abrasive wear resistance were all defined. Such methods, in conjunction with prescribed post-annealing heat treatments, permit the tailoring of microstructures in ABC-Sic to achieve and optimize a wide range of mechanical properties in a highly controlled manner. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported by the Director, Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Division of Materials Sciences and Engineering of the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC0376SF0098. Part of this work was made possible through the use of the National Center for Electron Microscopy facility at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. Thanks are due to Da Chen, Mark E. Sixta, Qing Yang, Rong Yuan, Jay J. Kruzic, and Rowland Cannon for their assistance and discussion in this work. REFERENCES
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
Faber, K.T. and Evans, A.G. (1983) Acta Metall. 31,565. Faber, K.T. and Evans, A.G. (1983) Acta Metall. 31,577. Becher, P.F. (1991)J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 74,255. Becher, P.F., Sun, E.Y., Plucknett, K.P., Alexander, K.B., Husueh, C.-H., Lin, H.-T., Waters, S.B. and Westmoreland, C.G. (1998) J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 81,2821. Cao, J.J., MoberlyChan, W.J., De Jonghe, L.C., Gilbert, C.J. and. Ritchie, R.O. (1996)J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 79,461. Thomas, G. (1994) Ultramicroscopy 54,145. Thomas, G. (1996) J. Euro. Ceram. Soc. 16,323. Zhang, X.F., Sixta, M.E. and De Jonghe, L.C. (2000) J. Am. Cerum. Soc. 83,2813. Zhang, X.F., Yang, Q., De Jonghe, L.C. and Zhang, Z. (2002) J. Microsc. 207,58. MoberlyChan, W.J., Cao, J.J., Gilbert, C.J., Ritchie, R.O. and De Jonghe, L.C. (1998), In: Ceramic Microstructure: Control at the Atomic Level, pp. 177-190,Tomsia A.P. and Glaeser A. (Eds). New York Plenum Press. Gilbert, C.J., Cao, J.J., De Jonghe, L.C. and Ritchie, R.O. (1997) J. Am. Cerum. Soc. 80,2253. Kleebe, H.-J., Cinibulk, M.K., Cannon, R.M. andRuhle, M. (1993)J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 76, 1969. Chiang, Y.-M., Silverman, L.A., French, R.H. and Cannon, R.M. (1994) J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 77, 1143. Clarke, D.R. (1987) J. Am. Ceram. SOC.70, 15.
156
15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34.
L.C. De Jonghe, R.O. Ritchie and X.F. Zhang
Hamminger, R., Grathwohl, G. and Thummler, F. (1983) J. Muter. Sci. 18,3154. Lane, J. E., Carter, C.H. and Davis, R. F. (1988)J. Am. Cerum. Soc., 71,281. Zhang, X.F., Sixta, M.E. and De Jonghe, L.C. (2001) J. Am. Cerum. SOC.84,813. Goto, Y. and Thomas, G. (1995) J. Muter. Sci. 30,2194. Cutler, I.B., Miller, P.D., Rafaniello, W., Park, H.K., Thompson, D.P. and Jack, K.H. (1978) Nature 275,434. Zhang, X.F., Sixta, M.E. and De Jonghe, L.C. (2001) J. Muter. Sci. 36,5447. Chen, D., Gilbert, C.J., Zhang, X.F. and Ritchie, R.O. (2000) Actu Muter, 48,659. Chen, D., Zhang, X.F. and Ritchie, R.O. (2000) J. Am. Cerum. SOC.83,2079. Chen, D., Sixta, M.E., Zhang, X.F., De Jonghe, L.C. and Ritchie, R.O. (2000) Actu Muter. 48,4599. Hansson, T., Miyashita, Y. and Mutoh, Y. (1996), In: Fracture Mechanics of Ceramics, Vol. 12, pp. 187-201, Bradt R.C. (Ed). Plenum Press, New York. Zhang, Y.H. and Edwards, L. (1998)Muter. Sci. Eng. A256, 144. Edwards, L. and Suresh, S. (1992) J. Muter. Sci. 27,5181. Liu S.Y., Chen, I.W. andTien, T.Y. (1994)J. Am. Cerum. SOC.77, 137. Ramamurty, U., Kim, A.S., Suresh, S. (1993) J. Am. Cerurn. SOC.76, 1953. Sixta, M.E., Zhang, X.F. and De Jonghe, L.C. (2001) J. Am. Cerum. SOC.84,2022. Zhang, X.F., Lee, G.Y., Chen, D., Ritchie, R.O. and De Jonghe, L.C. (2003) J. Am. Ceram. Soc., in press. Zhang, X.F., Yang, Q. and De Jonghe, L.C. (2003) Actu Muter.,in press. Yuan, R., Kruzic, J. J., Zhang, X. F., De Jonghe, L. C. and Ritchie, R. 0. (2003) Actu Muter., in review. Sakai, T. and Aikawa, T. (1988) J. Am. Cerum. SOC.71, C-7. Huang, J.-L., Hurford, A.C., Cutler, R.A. and Virkar, A.V. (1986) J. Muter. Sci. Lett. 21, 1448.
Nano and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritche and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MICROSTRUCTURE DESIGN OF ADVANCED MATERIALS THROUGH MICROELEMENT MODELS: WC-COCERMETS AND THEIR NOVEL ARCHITECTURES K. S. Ravi Chandran’ and Z. Zak Fang Department of Metallurgical Engineering 135 South 1460 East, Room 412, The University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT 841 12
ABSTRACT Design and development of advanced materials for superior strength and toughness is a perpetual effort in meeting the material needs for demanding applications. The WC-Co cermet is one of the truly advanced materials, due to its unique combination of properties. Although such cermets are widely used, further improvements require a good mechanistic understanding of the microstructural aspects that govem the mechanical properties. The broad goal of this research is to establish such a mechanistic basis that enables a sound explanation of their excellent properties. The origins of the unique mechanical properties of traditional and novel cermets are closely examined using some microstructure-based models. It is shown that the superior properties arise as a result of the spatial arrangement of WC grains within Co, the strength and stiffness of W C and the constrained plastic deformation behavior of ductile Co layer binding the WC grains. It is also shown that the high toughness of “functional” cermets with hierarchical microstructures can be understood on the basis of the microstructure-based mechanistic models. The microstructure-based models illustrate the key aspects in traditional WC-Co microstructures that make them unique as well as the pathways for designing advanced composites materials following the architecture of WC-Co cermets.
INTRODUCTION WC-Co cermets as a class are one of the truly advanced materials, with their processing, microstructure and mechanical properties having been optimized through several decades of research and development. Cermets such as WC-Co, WC-Ni and WC-Tic-Co are successfully produced commercially with a high degree of control and reliability in mechanical properties [l-51. Owing to the large industrial demands, their continued development is an active area of research [6-101. It may, to some extent, be surprising to note that although empirical correlations between microstructural parameters and properties exist, a complete mechanistic basis for their superior mechanical properties is yet to be developed. The WC-Co microstructure is made of angular and hard WC grains that are nearly completely surrounded by ductile Co binder formed either by liquid phase sintering (LPS) of WCiCo under vacuum or by LPS followed by a low pressure hot isostatic pressing (sinter-HIP). Figure 1 illustrates typical microstructures of WC-Co at two different volume fractions of Co. When a comparison is made between several hard materials listed in Table 1, the general superiority of WC-Co is clearly evident: the possession of high elastic modulus, high hardness and flexure strength and acceptable toughness that is unique to WC-Co cermets. The objective of this study is to demonstrate the micromechanisms behind the unique properties of WC-Co cermets by using the approach termed, ‘microelement-modeling’ that captures the effects of the relevant microstructural parameters on properties. Idealized geometrical models consisting of microelements and ’ Author for correspondence, ernail r.i\icu.inincsiuIi cdu. Ph 1-801-581-7197. Fax I-801-581-4937
157
K.S. Ruvz Chundran and Z. Zak Fang
158
simple relationships of stress and strain from the mechanics of materials have been employed for this purpose The goal IS to develop simple yet reasonably accurate analytical models that allow insight into the aspects of the microstructural factors pertaining to WC and Co that lead to the superior properties This work also illustrates the fracture toughness characteristics of hierarchically structured “functional” WC-Co cermets through modeling It is shown that the present modeling approach is very effective in illustrating the microstructural effects on strength, creep resistance and fracture toughness of WC-Co cermets and their derivatives The approach may be useful in designing the microstructures of advanced materials, in general
WC-G%Co
wc-1O%Co
Figure 1: Microstructures of WC-Co cermets
MICROELEMENT MODELS OF WC-CO
In WC-Co cermets, the microstructure morphology can be idealized as WC grains enveloped by Co binder forming a nearly continuous matnx In such an arrangement, the ductile Co binder sandwiched between strong and stiff WC grains is in a physically constrained state during deformation and any modeling attempt should capture this aspect accurately and consistently In this work, the WC-Co microstn~cture idealized as a periodic arrangement of cubic WC inclusions in a continuous Co matrix as illustrated in Fig 2(a) Fig 2(b) illustrates the three dimensional geometry of the WC-Co unit cell. This unit cell can be thought of built upon the parallel and series arrangements of WC and Co phases, identified generally as A and B in Figures 3(a) and (b) The modeling approach basically involves first dividing the unit cell into such parallel and senes microelements and deducing the composlte behavior from the behavior of the elements It is first essential to determine the appropnate volume fractions of the microelements at different levels of division The division of the WC-Co unit cell can be done as illustrated in Figure 3(a-d) First, the two microelements of volume fractions V3 (WC) and V4 (Co) in Fig 3(d) add up in senes to form a composite, which in turn forms an effective microelement of volume fraction V1 (WC+Co) in Fig 3(c) Then, microelements of volume fractions V2 (Co) and V1 in Fig 3(c) add up in a parallel arrangement to complete the unit cell Hence, if the deformation behavior of parallel and series loading arrangements of WC and Co
WC-Cocermets and their novel architectures
159
are known, the macroscopic properties of the unit cell and hence the cermet can be derived using the appropriate volume fractions of the microelements at different levels.
Figure 2: Schematics of the idealized unit cell of the WC-Co microstructure
4 A co
Figure 3: Schematics of the division of WC-Co unit cell into microelements; (a) the parallel arrangement, (b) the series arrangement, (c) the parallel arrangement of microelements 1 and 2, and (d) the series arrangement of microelements 3 and 4. First, from geometric considerations of Figure 2(b), a microstructure parameter “c” can be defined in terms of the bulk volume fraction of Co, V, e o , as.
This definition allows the determination of volume fractions of the microelements as:
v,=
volume of element 1 1 volume of the unit cell (1 + c)’
v, =
volume of element 2 volume of the unit cell
v, = volume of element 3
volume ofelement 1
v4 =
-
1--
1 (1 + c)’
- 1
(1 + c)
volume of element 4 c -volume ofelement 1 (1 + c )
160
K.S. Ravi Chandran and Z. Zak Fang
It is to be noted that VI, V2, V3 and V4 are defined such that VI+V2=1 and V3+V4=1 to enable consistent division of microelements at different levels. The applicable mechanics of materials equations for the parallel arrangement of a two phase material, with the loading parallel to the interface are
E,, = EAVA+ EBVR
(3)
where Ell is the elastic modulus, EA and Eg are the modulus of phases A and B respectively, oapp is the applied stress, OA and CSB are the average stresses in A and B, respectively, cappis the composite strain and EA and EB are the average strains in phases A and B. respectively. VA and VB are the volume fractions of the respective phases. A similar set of equations for the series arrangement of phases A and B are
where E,, is the elastic modulus of the series composite loaded with the applied stress normal to the interface. Equations (3) through (8) along with equation (2) were used to determine the elastic modulus of WC-Co cermets and the results have been published elsewhere [l 13. Here we focus on the determination of the strength and creep resistance of the WC-Co cermets.
STRENGTH OF WC-COCERMETS In order to determine the strength of WC-Co cermets incorporating the constitutive properties of WC and Co, the plastic deformation behavior of the unit cell needs to be constructed. The deformation behavior of Co matrix can be represented in the Ludwik form as m=Eco~e
for the elastic part
d =K,,(E~)"
for the plastic part
with the total strain in the plastic regime being given by E = + .sP where E,,, 8 and B are the elastic modulus of Co, elastic strain and plastic strain in Co, respectively. K,, and n are constants of power law fit to the plastic part of the stress-strain curve of Co. Since the WC grains are much stiffer and harder than Co, to a first approximation, they can be considered to be rigid and the elastic strain contribution from microelement 3 is neglected leading to c3= 0 . The calculation of elastic stress-strain characteristics of WCCo cermet is straightforward and this is discussed elsewhere [12]. With the WC-Co unit cell deforming in the plastic regime, the following relationships can be written for the microelements 1, 3 and 4:
WC-Cocermets and their novel architectures
161
where & I , EZ, ~3 and 6 4 are the average plastic strains in the respective microelements. The superscript “p” is omitted hereafter for brevity CT{and C T ~ are the A ow stresses in microelements 1 and 2 resulting from the strain compatibility and the partitioning of the applied stress between microelements 1 and 2 according to the relation:
Simplification of the set of equations (1 1) leads to
At this stage, the physical constraint of Co deforming between WC grams should be considered. In the microelement scheme, this means that the plastic deformation of microelement 4 will be influenced by the constraint of rigid WC particles forming microelement 3, located above and below microelement 4 in the actual cermet. As the raho (hc,,/dwc) of thickness of Co in the microelement 4, ‘hc:, to the size of WC forming element 3, Idw:, decreases, the constraint expenenced by the Co matrix during plastic deformation would increase [13,14]. Murray [15] noted that through this effect the in-situ flow stress of Co is several times higher than that is observed in the bulk Co specimen It was suggested that the theoretical shear strength of Co is influenced by the presence of WC particle boundaries limiting the mean-free-path of shear deformation in Co as illustrated in Figure 4(a). To accurately represent the WC-Co plastic deformation behavior, this constraint effect should be incorporated in the model
Figure 4: (a) Schematic o f a ductile layer deforming under rigid WC grains [ 151 and (b) the normalized flow stress as a function of d/h as predicted by the plasticity solutions of Unksov [16]. One way to introduce the constrained deformation of Co is to modify the expression for in equation (13) to give a lower effective plastic strain for a given stress (in this case, 5,)acting on this element (see ref 12 for details):
K.S. Ravi Chandran and Z. Zak Fang
162
Equation (15) is an approximation for the constrained deformation of Co, based on the analogy of Co deforming between WC grains to that of a ductile metal layer deforming between two rigid platens, as illustrated in Figure 4(b). Since there should be strain compatibility between microelements 1 and 2 , ~ & ~= : ,E, ,, = E~ and from equations (1 1) and (14)
From equations (12), (14) and (16) the plastic strain in the cermet is given by
The flow stress of Co is related to the plastic strain in Co as
Combining the equations (17) and (18), the normalized flow stress of the WC-Co cermet is given by
A
9
8
21
f
17
L,
v
Eqn. (19)
tn tn
13
5
9
zE ii
E x p t . Data (0.02 e p ) E x p t . Data (0.002 e p )
-a
-.Bm
5
z
1
E
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
W C V o l u m e Fraction, V p
Figure 5 : Comparison of the predictions from equation (19) with the experimental data of flow stress of WC-Co cermets normalized with the flow stress of Co. The experimental data is from: H. Doi, Elastic and Plastic Properties of WC-Co Composite Alloys, Freund Publishing Inc., Israel, 1974 Figure 5 illustrates the comparison of the normalized flow stress of the WC-Co cermet as a function of the volume fraction of WC. Both the predictions according to the microelement model (lines) for different strain hardening exponents of Co as well as the experimental data on compression strength of a variety of cermets are presented. The increase in flow stress, or alternatively the strength, comes from the fact that as WC
WC-Cocermets and their novel architectures
163
content increases, the extensive plastic deformation must be generated in the Co binder, especially the constrained region of Co present in the form of microelement 4. Equation (19) captures most of the dominant microstructural parameters that determine the strength of WCCo cermets, including, the size of WC grains, d,,, the thickness of the Co binder h,,, the volume fraction of Co, Vf,,, and the strain hardening behavior of Co, n, as well as the geometric constraint effect due to WC grains through the parameter For a given volume fraction of WC grains, increasing the constraint by manipulating the ratio h,,/d,, or the strain hardening characteristics of Co should lead to stronger WC-Co cermets. In particular, exceptionally high strength levels can be achieved if the WC volume fraction is increased as much as possible while ensuring a continuous layer of Co around WC grains throughout the microstructure. It is worth noting that the above conclusions are general and can be applied to any hard particle-ductile matrix composite system to achieve very high strength levels.
CREEP DEFORMATION BEHAVIOR OF WC-CO While a large fraction of commercial interest is in near-room-temperature applications of WC-Co, there are also research and developmental efforts [ 17, 181 in the area of high temperature deformation resistance in order to extend the temperature range of application of WC-Co cermets. Therefore, it is also of interest to examine the high temperature or creep deformation characteristics of WC-Co cermets. The microelement model for the creeping cermet can be devised following the same approach outlined in the previous section. The essential difference is that the strain rate takes the place of strain in the microelements. The strain rate compatibility between microelements 1 and 2 is expressed as
Since the WC grains can be considered as rigid and non-creeping due to its excellent strength retention at high temperature, the only constitutive relationship that is relevant here is that of the Co matrix:
where k,, and ncoare the constants characterizing the steady-state creep behavior of bulk Co. The complete details as well as extensive comparisons with the experimental data on several composites are published elsewhere [19]. The steady-state creep rates of WC-Co cermets can be derived as
The creep rate of the cermet, normalized with respect to that of Co is then expressed as
+=kcol E CO
r (1+ c)"
1
1"co
q 5 c +(1+c)2 o ( -1 y f l c o
K.S. Ravi Chandran and Z. Zak Fang
164
Figures 6(a) and (b) illustrate the predicted normalized creep rates as a function of the volume fraction of rigid particles or second phase, in the general sense. In Figure 6(a) the effect of not including versus including &o in equation (23) is illustrated. It can be seen that without the constraint (i$co=l), there is virtually no difference between the creep rates of composites having matrices of with different creep exponents. In contrast, when the constraint factor, i$,, is included in the model, the effects of matrix creep exponents are differentiated. The predicted data are also in good agreement with the numerical results obtained by the self-consistent method, as illustrated in Figure 6(b), attesting to the reliability of the microelement modeling approach. For detailed comparisons involving other composite systems, ref. 19 may be consulted.
W
Unit cell model
E
...--.... Self-consistent Model
-
.WU
0
0.4
0.2
0.6
1
0.8
Vf of Second Phase, V
(a) (b) Figure 6: The predicted creep rates from the microelement model (equation (23)). (a) illustration of the effect of the WC grain constraint on Co and @) comparison with the data from a numerical model 0
,
--
,
,
,
/
,
-CO(8Oo"C) - - w c - c o (WC V( =o 81)
~
,
,
,
,
0
. I
,
.
,
co (8OOT)
I
I
I
,
I
I
,
w c - c o (WC V f =o 9)
0
-
T=800"C -12
"
1
"
2
1
'
"
3
Log Stress, MPa
'
:...
-
"
4
-12
"
1
'
I
2
"
"
3
T=800"C '
"
4
Log Stress, MPa
(a) (b) Figure 7: Comparisons of the predictions from equation (22) with the experimental data on steady state creep of WC-Co cermets Figures 7(a) and (b) illustrate the predicted steady-state creep rates compared with the experimental creep data of WC-Co cermets. The reasonable agreement is quite encouraging, given the idealizations employed in the microelement modeling. It is to be noted that according to the model, the creep exponent of WC-Co
WC-Cocermets and their novel architectures
165
cermet (equation (22)) is necessarily the same as that of Co. This is the result of the geometrical arrangement of Co as continuous matrix material nearly surrounding every WC grain in the cermet by a complex term that microstructure. The effect of WC grains is to modify the proportionality factor, to, includes most of the microstructural parameters, d,,, h,,, Vtca and $ca as in equation (22). As can be seen from Figure 7, the effect of WC grains is to decrease the value of proportionality factor, k, leading to a downward shift in the steady-state creep curve, relative to that of Co. FRACTURE TOUGHNESS OF WC-COCERMETS
Modeling of fracture toughness of WC-Co cermets is not only useful in developing an understanding of the microstructural factors that control the resistance to fracture, but also enables designing better cermets to mitigate cracking. This is of particular importance in cermets as a class, since the major constituent, WC, is nearly completely brittle and the cermet applications involve severe loading conditions, often leading to chipping. Fracture in WC-Co systems has been found [2,4,14] to occur mainly by the ductile rupture of Co through void nucleation and coalescence. Other fracture modes such as fracture along WC-Co interface and WCWC grain boundary decohesion as well as cleavage across WC grains were also noted [20,21]. These mechanisms occur especially at low volume fractions of Co binder in the composite at which the contiguity of WC grains begins to increase. The effect of the contiguity of WC skeleton on fracture toughness has also been demonstrated [22]. In a fracture toughness experiment, in a given crack plane, the crack propagation is easy along the relatively weak WC-WC boundaries and final fracture is primarily controlled by the area fraction of WC grains and Co regions intact across the crack plane ahead of the tip. Many studies have confirmed that the plastic deformation at the crack tip is restricted to a single binder layer in the crack plane located immediately ahead of the crack tip. Since the WC grains are nominally elastic under load, the deformation of Co at the crack tip will be highly constrained. Although there are a few fracture toughness models such as that developed by Nakamura and Gurland [23], these models do not explicitly consider this constraint effect in terms of microstructural parameters. More recently, a simple model to predict the fracture toughness of WC-Co cermets, incorporating the microstructural parameters was developed by one of the authors [24]. In that study, the total fracture energy of the WC-Co cermet is taken as the sum of the weighted fracture energies of WC and Co:
where Gwc is the critical strain energy release rate of WC phase and Vf, oeff,co and hco are respectively the volume fraction, the in-situ flow stress and the thickness of the Co phase. The parameter p represents the extent of plastic stretch of Co before fracture and is usually between 1 and 2. The first term accounts for the energy due to fracture along WC while the second incorporates the resistance arising from the plastic rupture of the ductile Co. Recalling
oeff,co
Kc,w,co
=
=
+
EW,,,
0.3(k)]
(1 - v/ )&,wc(l,2
(26)
where &,WCCO, Ewcco and vwcco are respectively the cermet fracture toughness, modulus and Poisson's ratio, and &.wc, Ewc and vwc are the fracture toughness, modulus and Poisson's ratio of WC respectively.
K.S. Ravi Chandran and Z. Zak Fang
166
It can be seen that knowing Oeff,co, from equation (25), in addition to the properties and sizes of WC and Co phases, fracture toughness of the WC-Co cermet can be estimated. Equation (26) is not only considerably simpler, but also provides a direct correlation of fracture toughness to the microstructure parameters of the cermet.
rfiin
5
-
”
s
50
40
(II
Y
6
30
u)
0
9 C
c
20
0
0
10 20 30 40 50 M e a s u r e d Toughness, K c , e x p ,(MParn”2)
Figure 8: Comparison of the fracture toughness of WC-Co cermets calculated from equation (26) with the experimental data. The experimental data include over 100 data points from diverse studies, a listing of which may be found in ref. 24. The calculated fracture toughness according to equation (26) for a variety of WC-Co cermets reported in literature is plotted as a function of the experimentally measured fracture toughness data in Figure 8. An average value of 850 MPa for the bulk flow stress of Co in equation (25) and a value of p=2 in equation (26) were for these calculations. A study [25] confirms that the bulk flow stress of the Co may vary from 700 MPa to about 1100 MPa depending on the degree of dissolution of W and C as well as the nature and distribution of carbide precipitates in Co. Since the amount of W and C in solution would depend on a number of processing parameters such as that in hot pressing and heat treatment, the use of a more accurate value for the Co flow stress is not possible. Nevertheless, a reasonable agreement between the measured and the calculated toughness values, with only a few data points falling outside the +lo% confidence level, can be seen. The experimental data is from WC-Co microstructures having a wide variation of WC particle diameter from 0.66 pm to 7.8 pm and the mean free path in binder varying from 0.04 pm to 1.9 pm. The volume fraction of Co varied from 0.05 to 0.4 in these cermets. These represent a reasonably wide variation in the microstructural conditions of WC-Co cermets. Therefore, equation (26) may be taken as a fairly accurate representation of fracture toughness of WC-Co cermet class as a whole and may be used as a predictive tool in the microstructure design of two-phase cermets in general. DESIGNING CERMETS SUPERIOR TO WC-CO
Although WC-Co cermets occupy the largest share of tool applications, there have been considerable efforts in designing cermets with other hard materials and binders, but with a microstructural architecture similar to that of WC-Co. Noteworthy in this regard are the systems containing TaC or T i c or TiBz or A1203 as the hard component and Co, Ni, Fe or Cr as the binder component. With the increased availability of synthetic diamond, Co bonded diamond, with or without WC additions, has also become one of the contenders. It is of interest to examine where the level of fracture toughness that can be achieved in these cermet combinations lie relative to the WC-Co system. Equation (26) was used to calculate the fracture toughness values for the systems listed in Table 2 using the constitutive data also listed in the table. In the calculations, a hard particle size, d = 3 Fm and a binder volume fraction, Vf = 0.1 were assumed.
WC-Cocermets and their novel architectures
167
The calculated fracture toughness data is interesting for two reasons. First, all of the systems based on carbides and borides of Ti or Ta offer fracture toughness levels lower than that of WC-Co. Secondly, only the fracture toughness diamond-Co system was higher than that of the WC-Co system. The fracture toughness of the cermet is also influenced by the elastic modulus of the brittle phase, in addition to the volume fraction and properties of the binder. In fact, in table 2, the fracture toughness can be seen to increase in general with an increase in the modulus of the hard phase. This, although may seem to be unusual, is entirely consistent with fracture mechanics principles. The fracture toughness, K, is related to the critical strain energy released for an infinitesimal increase in crack length, G,, during unstable fracture as K,
=JG,E
and
where ys is the surface energy of the solid. The surface energy is indirectly related to the atomic cohesion in solids. It is known that the elastic modulus of solids in general increases with an increase in the melting point. The increase in melting point is generally thought to arise from an increased cohesion between in solids. Therefore, it is not unreasonable to expect that in principle, the surface energy should also be higher in a solid having a high stiffness, although this interesting aspect needs to be verified. Thus, the effect of increased elastic modulus should work to increase the fracture toughness directly through equation (27) and indirectly through equation (28).
TABLE 2. Calculated fracture toughness levels for different cermet systems
L
"
'
"
"
'
"
"
"
'
"
'
"
'
J
14
E
2
12
y'-
10
a
E
4
u
2
Single crystal
5
E
0
diamond
N ~ C
SIC (CVD)
...... .._..._..-
_....' ._.. ._..
. . .
I 0
I
200
.
.
.
,
.
400
:
.
,
.
600
.
Elastic Modulus (GPa)
.
I
800
.
.
.
\
L
.
.
1000
Figure 9: Fracture toughness of ceramics as a function of elastic modulus
i
168
K.S. Ruvz Chundran and Z. Zak Fang
In order to venfy the above hypothesis, the experimental fracture toughness data of a wide variety of ceramics are plotted as a function of elastic modulus in Figure 9 A reasonable correlation is obvious, with the fracture toughness increasing with an increase in elastic modulus Figure 9 may explain why only the diamond-Co system is supenor to WC-Co in terms of the calculated fracture toughness In equation (26), both the higher fracture toughness of diamond, together with its high value of modulus around 1000 MPa contribute to the increased value of the calculated toughness It also implies another remarkable fact to design cermets with fracture toughness levels higher than WC-Co, one should resort to hard constituents having elastic moduli higher than that of WC, with all other vanables in the cermet system being invariant HlERARCHlCALLY STRUCTURED “FUNCTIONAL” WC-COCERMETS In the past few years, a new approach that involves hierarchical structuring of microstructure constituents is used to design WC-Co cermets Figure 10 illustrates a “double cemented tungsten carbide (DC carbide)”, consisting of WC-Co granules (usually containing a very low cobalt content) embedded in a matnx of ductile Co Figure 11 illustrates an idealized schematic of this class of microstmctures This unique microstructure is functionally designed to boost the fracture toughness of the materiaIs without comprising its wear resistance Figure 12 illustrates the combination of superior toughness and abrasive wear resistance in the DC carbide The hierarchically structured DC carbide provides another degree of freedom that is not available in conventional WC-Co cermets One of the consequences of equation (26) is the fact that the fracture toughness of conventional WC-Co is derived nearly equally from WC as well as Co phases If the fracture resistance of WC can be increased by replacing it with a tougher WC-Co granule, the properties of DC carbide can then be augmented Additionally, the sizes of WC grains in the granules are much finer than that in the equivalent WC-Co cermet The contributions of the WC-Co granules to the overall properties of the DC carbide are two fold First, when compared to conventional WC-Co cermets, the fracture energy of the hard component in DC carbide, i e the term G,, in equation (24), is significantly higher The higher fracture energy of the hard component particles Contribute to increasing not only the overall fracture toughness, but also the micro-chipping resistance, which in turn is manifested in the form of good overall abrasive wear resistance Secondly, the WC-Co granules in DC carbide resist the tendency of being dug-out in an abrasive wear environment. Therefore, the excellent wear resistance of WC-Co can be preserved even though a significantly larger amount of Co is present in this matenal, relative to the conventional WC-Co cermet
Figure 10: Microstructures of a hierarchically structured “functional” WC-Co cermet. The microstructure contains a total of 27 wt. % Co. The fracture toughness of hierarchically structured DC carbide can be modeled using the same approach described in the previous section. This requires calculating first the fracture toughness of WC-Co granules, & grr according to equation (26) as:
WC-Cocermets and their novel architectures
169
50
WC grains Co matrix
-
*€
z
z
'x
40
30
8
-
-
-
2
a
u.
10
.
I
1 xv -1.
rconventlonal W C C O
;*
A DC Carbtde ( - 3 0 0 i t 7 5 urn)
= D C Carbide (-75 rrn)
The fracture toughness of the DC carbide, &,Dc, can then be calculated as:
where Eoc is the elastic modulus of the DC carbide, V; is the volume fraction of Co in the matrix (not including the Co in granules) surrounding the granules, and cr>,co is the flow stress of Co in the matrix, hz,, is the thickness Co matrix and p=2. The
g&,co can
be expressed as
where oi,coand d,, are the unconstrained (bulk) flow stress of the Co matrix surrounding the WC-Co granules and the granule size The microstructures of two types of hierarchically structured DC carbides made in a recent study [26] are illustrated in Figures 13 and 14. Microstructures of DC carbides with a constant WC-Co granule size, but with a varying volume fraction of the matrix Co, are presented in Figure 13. Microstructures of DC carbides
K.S. Ruvz Chundran and Z. Zak Fang
170
1
having constant a volume fraction of Co in the matrix as well as in the WC-Co granules, but with varying sizes of granules are presented in Figure 14
I I
I.
Figure 13: Microstructures of hierarchically structured DC carbide cermets with varying Co volume fraction and constant WC-Co granule size. The matrix Co volume fractions from left to right are: lo%, 20% and 30%. In the granules, the WC grain size is 3 pm and the Co volume fraction is 10%.
Figure 14: Microstructures of hierarchically structured DC carbide cermets with constant Co volume fraction (30%) in the matrix and varying WC-Co granule size. The average granule sizes from left to right are. 130 pm, 90 pm and 60 pm. The size of WC grains in the granules is 3 pm,
35 -
c
,
30 -
-Eqn. (WC-1O%Co Granule) -- Eqn. (WC-l8%Co Granule) Eqn. (WC-25YoCo Granule) A Expt. (WC-iO%Co Granule) 0 Expt. (WC-l8%Co Granule) Expt (WC-25%Co Granule)
lo'? 5 -
O?
--
~~~~~~~~~
'005
'
0'1
'0;5
'
Oh
Vf of Co Matrix
(a)
'025
'
01
0
= 75 MPa) .
Eqn. (Matrix
--Eqn
(Matrixnoco=IOOMPa)
Eqn (Matrix no
0
50
~~
100
= 200 MPa) 150
Granule Size, pm
(b)
Figure 15 Comparisons of the predicted and experimental fracture toughness data for the hierarchically structured DC carbide cermets, as a function of (a) the volume fraction of matnx Co and @) the WC-Co granule size The effect of volume fraction of matrix Co on the fracture toughness of DC carbides with a constant WC-Co granule size is illustrated in Figure 15(a) The points are from expenments and the lines are the predictions
WC-Cocermets and their novel architectures
171
from equation (30). In these calculations, the value of C T : , ~ ~was taken as 87 MPa, based on the agreement between the experimental data and the theoretical predictions as illustrated in Figure 15(b). The effect of WC-Co granule size on the fracture toughness at a constant matrix Co volume fraction is illustrated in Figure 15(b). In this figure, the data predicted using equation (30) for four different o,',,, values is illustrated. It appears that the reasonable value of oi,,that can result in a good agreement between the experiment and theory is between 75 and 100 MPa. This choice of strength for the matrix Co surrounding WC-Co granules is not unreasonable, since a powder processing route was employed in the making of DC carbide cermets.
CONCLUDING REMARKS The present study has shown that the key aspects of the microstructure design of WC-Co cermets and its mechanistic basis can be understood by modeling with microelements. The microelements seem to capture important microstructure details such as the WC particle size, thickness and volume fraction of the Co binder, the constrained deformation behavior of Co as well as the fracture characteristics of WC and Co. The following conclusions may be drawn. 1. The strength of WC-Co cermets is largely controlled by the volume fraction of WC and is supplemented by the constrained plastic deformation of Co between the rigid WC grains. The expected functional form of this strength can be predicted using the microelement model that consistently incorporated the local average stresses and strains as well as the physical constraint experienced by the ductile Co during plastic deformation. 2. The creep or high temperature deformation behavior of Co is controlled primarily by the deformation characteristics of Co. The steady-state creep exponent of WC-Co is necessarily the same as that of Co. The effect of WC content is to shift the creep curves down in proportion to the WC volume fraction. An accurate prediction of creep deformation behavior requires consideration of the constrained deformation behavior of Co.
3. Fracture toughness of WC-Co cermets can be predicted quite accurately by considering fracture processes in WC and Co and is determined by the fracture properties of both phases. A large share of fracture toughness is contributed by the WC itself. Further, the constrained deformation behavior of Co during fracture, where the in-situ flow stress is several times larger than that of bulk Co significantly affects the fracture toughness. This latter aspect is responsible for the increase in the cermet toughness with an increase in Co content. Decreasing the WC particle size and increasing the strength of Co by alloying would help to increase the fracture toughness further.
4. A surprising finding of this study is that for designing cermets with toughness levels beyond WC-Co requires the use of hard materials with stiffness and fracture toughness levels higher than that of WC. The diamond-Co system is particularly attractive in this regard.
5 . Hierarchically structured WC-Co cermets with fracture toughness levels higher than that of the traditional WC-Co cermets are possible. The fracture toughness levels of such novel cermets can be predicted reasonably well using two-level models that consistently incorporate the microstructure details at different levels. These models explain well the effects of granule size and the Co volume fraction on fracture toughness.
6. The microelement models, having been validated by the extensive experimental data on WC-Co, suggest pathways for designing advanced composites with high strength and creep resistance and with reasonable fracture toughness. The simplest is to have a high volume fraction of hard and stiff constituent completely surrounded by a ductile and binding phase with good interface strength between them. Further, following the hierarchically structured WC-Co cermet design, different binder types at different levels of the structure may be chosen to enhance the combination of properties.
K.S. Ravi Chandran and Z. Zak Fang
172
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26.
Pickens J.R., and Gurland, J. (1978) Muter. Sci. Eng. 33, 135. Viswanatham, R.K., Sun, T.S., Drake, E. F. and Peck, J.A. (1981) J. Mat. Sci. 16,1029. Lindau, L. (1977). In: Proc. 4th Int. Con$ Fracture, Fracture 1977, 2,215. Sigl, L.S. and Fischmeister, H.F. (1988) Acta Metall. 36, 887. Ravichandran, K. S. (1994) Acta Metall. Muter. 42, 143. Fang, Z. and Easton, J.W. (1995) Int. J. Refractory Metals and HardMaterials 13, 297. Fang, Z., Lockwood, G. and Griffo, A. (1999) Metall. Mater. Trans. 30A, 3231. Sommer, M., Schubert, W. and Warbichler, P. (2002) Int. J. of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials 20,41. Kinoshita, S., Kobayahsi, M. and Hayashi, K. (2002) J. Jpn. Soc. of Powder and Powder Metallurgy 49, 299. Carroll, D.F. and Conner, C.L. (1997). In: Advances in Powder Metallurgy and Particulate Materials, Proceedings of the I997 International Conference on Powder Metallurgy and Particulate Materials 2, 12-61, Metal Powder Industries Federation, Princeton, NJ, USA Ravichandran, K.S. (1994) J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 77, 1178. Ravichandran, K.S. (1994) Acta Metall. Mater. 42, 1113. Drucker, D.C. (1964). In: High Strength Materials, Zackay, V.F. (Ed), John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, NY. Evans, A.G. and Hirth, J.P. (1992) Scr. Metall. Mater. 26, 1675. Murray, M.J. (1977) Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. 356A, 483. Unksov, A.P. (1961) An Engineering Theory of Plasticity, Buttenvorths, London. Mari, D., Ammann, J.J., Benoit, W. and Bonjour, C. (1988). In: Mechanical and Physical Behaviour of Metallic and Ceramic Composites, Proceedings of the 9th Riso International Symposium on Metallurgy and Materials Science, Published by Riso National Laboratory, Roskilde, Denmark, 433. Lee, I.C. and Sakuma, T. (1997) Metall. Mater. Trans. 28A, 1843. Ravichandran K.S. and Seetharaman, V. (1993) Acta Metall. Mater. 41,3351 Hong J. and Gurland, J. (1981). In: Science of Hard Materials, p. 649, Viswanatham, R.K., Rowcliffe D. J. and Gurland, J. (Eds) Plenum Press, New York. Slesar, M., Dusza, J. and Parilak, L. (1986). In: Science ofHard Materials, p. 657, Almond, E.A., Brookes, C. A. and Warren, R. (Eds), Inst. Phy. Conf. Series No. 75, Adam Higler Ltd., Bristol, UK. Chermant, J.L. and Osterstock, F. (1976) J. Mat. Sci. 11, 1939. Nakamura, M. and Gurland, J. (1980) Metall. Trans. 11A, 141. Ravichandran, K. S. (1994) Acta Metall. Mater. 42, 143. Roebuck, B., Almond, E. A. and Cottenden, A.M., (1984) Muter. Sci. Eng. 66,179. Deng, X., Patterson, B. R., Chawla, K.K., Koopman, M. C, Fang, Z., Lockwood, G. and Griffo, G, (2001) Int. J. Refiactory Metals and Hard Materials 19, 547.
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
THE IDEAL STRENGTH OF IRON D. M. Clatterbuck, D. C. Chrzan and J. W. Morris Jr. Department of Materials Science and Engineering, UC Berkeley and Materials Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Lab, Berkeley CA 94609 ABSTRACT
The ideal strength of a material can be defined as the stress that causes an infinite defect-free perfect crystal to become mechanically unstable. The ideal strength is of interest because it sets a firm upper bound on the mechanical strength the material can attain. It is also approached experimentally in situations where there are few mobile defects. The present paper is concerned with the ideal strength of iron. We specifically compute the ideal tensile strength of iron for tension along cool>, the weak direction, and the ideal shear strength for relaxed shear in the <111>{ 112) and 4 11>{110) systems. We also consider the influence of pressure on the strength. The computation is done ab initio using the Projector Augmented Wave Method within the framework of density functional theory and the generalized gradient approximation in order to account for the magnetism of the material. The fact that iron can have a high tensile strength is puzzling. Because Fe has a stable fcc phase (at least at moderate temperature) simple models suggest that it should be very weak in tension on . That it is not turns out to be due to the difference in magnetic character between the bcc and fcc phases, which has he consequence that iron behaves like a “typical” bcc metal in both its tensile and shear behavior. INTRODUCTION
For almost three millennia the element Fe and its alloys have provided the most commonly used structural metals, and remain the materials of choice for a large fraction of all engineering structures and devices. There are three basic reasons why this is true. First, Fe is common in the earth’s crust, and is relatively easy to extract from its ores. Second, Fe has reasonable inherent strength, and can be alloyed or processed so that it becomes even stronger. Third, Fe (or steel) is a very flexible material that can be made soft for forming, or hard for structural strength by fairly straightforward changes in the way it is processed. The strength of Fe is a prerequisite. If it did not lend itself to the creation of alloys that are “as strong as steel”, it would not be widely used. Advances in computational techniques and computing machines have recently made it possible to compute the ideal strength of a crystalline material - the stress that drives the crystal lattice itself unstable and sets an upper bound on the strength the material can possibly have [1,2]. When these techniques are applied to Fe, as was done for the first time in the work reported here [3,4], a couple of surprises emerge. First, Fe is not really all that strong. Second, it is surprising that Fe is as strong as it is. These statements can be based on a simple model that is derived from the dominant role of symmetry in determining the ideal strength, as is well established from first-principles calculations [2,5]. The energy of a deformed crystal depends on the six independent components 173
174
D.M. Clatterbuck, D.C. Chrzan and J.W. Morris Jr.
of the strain and is, hence, a 6-dimensional hypersurface in a 7-dimensional space. The local extrema and saddle points on this hypersurface almost always correspond to structures with high symmetry. The configurations of greatest interest are the saddle points on the energy surface that neighbor the initial state. For a given load geometry (stress state) the crystal deforms along a particular path on the strain-energy surface as the load is increased. The stress required to dnve the system is related to the local slope of the energy surface in the direction of travel. The ideal strength is determined by the steepest slope along the path between the initial state and the first saddle point. The steepest slope corresponds to the maximum stress; the crystal is elastically unstable as soon as the point of maximum stress is passed. To understand the ideal strength it is necessary to identify the relevant saddle point structures. Four such structures have been identified in studies of the ideal strengths of bcc metals: the fcc structure, the simple cubic (sc) structure, a body centered tetragonal (bct) structure, and a base centered orthorhombic structure [6-81. For example, relaxed shear of a bcc metal in the “easy” 4 1 1 > direction on the (112) or (110) plane generates a stress-free bct structure [8]. Because the <111>{112} shear system is not symmetric in the sign of the shear direction, it is also possible to move from a bcc structure to a base centered orthorhombic structure by shearing in the “hard” direction. Uniaxial tension in the 4 1 1 > direction takes a bcc structure to a sc structure [6,8], while cool> tension moves it from bcc either to fcc (the Bain transformation in Fig. 1 [2]) or to bct (the same stress-free bct structure encountered in shear [7]). The competition between the two possible paths that can be reached by 4 0 1 1 tension has the result that, while most bcc crystals (Mo, W) are governed by the instability associated with the fcc structure and, ideally, fail in cIeavage, at least one (Nb) becomes unstable with respect to evolution toward the bct saddle point and fails in shear [7].
Figure 1: The bcc crystal structure becomes the fcc structure after elongation along the direction. Ab initio total energy calculations of the ideal tensile strengths of unconstrained bcc metals show that they are weakest when pulled in a <001> direction [2] (unsurprisingly, {OOl} is the dominant cleavage plane in bcc metals). A constant volume tensile strain along <001> converts the bcc structure into fcc at an engineering strain of about 0.26 (the ’Bain strain‘, Fig. 1). Since both structures are unstressed by symmetry, the tensile stress must pass through at least one maximum along the transformation path. If we follow Orowon [9] in assuming a single extremum (the solid line in Fig. 2), and fit the stress-strain curve with a sinusoid that has the correct modulus at low strain, the ideal tensile strength is approximately
in good agreement with ab initio calculations (for example, om = 30 GPa = 0.072 E<100> for W [lo]). Since the modulus of Fe is significantly less than that of other transition metals, such as W, Mo and Ta, the upper bound on its strength is smaller as well.
The ideal strength of iron
0.00
0.10
0.20
Engineering Strain
0.30
0.00
175
0.10
0.20
Engineering Strain
0.30
Figure 2: The energy as a function of strain has an extremum at the fcc structure which can be a local maximum (solid line) or minimum (dotted line). Assuming sinusoidal form, the inflection point governing the ideal strength falls at a much lower strain in the latter case, and the ideal strength is significantly less. But a second problem intrudes when we extend this analysis to iron [3]. The fcc phase in Fe is known to have an energy only slightly above that of bcc and is at least metastable at low temperature. In fact, the thermomechanical treatments that are used to process structural steel (particularly including the many developed or explored by Gareth Thomas) rely on the ease of transforming it from bcc to fcc and back again. If we assume a metastable fcc phase connected by a continuous strain-energy curve (the dotted line in Fig. 2), the tensile instability intrudes at a much smaller strain, and the ideal strength should be only about 6 GPa (versus 12 GPa based on an unstable fcc). This number is too small to be credible. Since tensile stresses that are several times the yield strength are developed ahead of crack tips in elastic-plastic materials, steels with yield strengths much above 1 GPa would necessarily be brittle. In fact, steels with much larger yield strengths have high fracture toughness and considerable ductility. A possible resolution of this paradox is suggested by the work of Herper et al. [ 111. They computed the energies of Fe for various magnetic states and lattice strains. Their calculations suggest that the energy of ferromagnetic Fe increases monotonically if it is distorted toward an unstable, ferromagnetic fcc, which can be stabilized by transforming into a complex antiferromagnetic state. This has the consequence that the low energy antiferromagnetic fcc phase is a minimum rather than a saddle point on the strain-energy surface of Fe. While Herper, et al. [ 111 did not investigate the point (they had other interests), this suggests the possibility that ferromagnetic Fe may become mechanically unstable under 4 OO> tension before encountering the magnetic transition that converts it into the antiferromagnetic state that stabilizes fcc. If this is the case, Fe can have the mechanical behavior of a typical bcc metal, while still having a metastable fcc structure that is stabilized by a late magnetic transition. That is, it can be both strong and easy to process.
As we shall show below, this is the apparent explanation for the fact that Fe has both a useful tensile strength and an fcc phase that facilitates processing. Going further, we shall establish that Fe naturally fails in cleavage on (100) planes and compute its tensile and shear strengths. Finally, we consider how the strength of Fe is affected by superimposed hydrostatic stress as encountered, for example, at the tip of a sharp crack.
116
D.M. Clatterbuck, D.C. Chrzan and J.W. Morris Jr.
COMPUTATIONAL METHODS To compute the ideal strength of Fe we must include magnetic interactions. These are non-local, and considerably complicate the problem. In particular, the non-local magnetic interactions have the consequence that the local density approximation cannot be used. In fact, computations based on the local density approximation predict that the ground state of Fe should be a non-magnetic close packed structure rather than a bcc ferromagnet. The use of the generalized gradient approximation (GGA) has been shown to correct this problem [ 121. Full Potential Linearized Augmented Plane Wave (FLAPW) calculations which make no further approximations beyond the GGA (assuming convergence of the basis set, charge density representation and Brillouin Zone integration) are probably the most reliable [13]. Unfortunately, in order to efficiently relax the stresses orthogonal to the applied stress, the stresses on the unit cell must be directly computable, and there are no implementations of the FLAPW method known to us that can do this in a straightforward way. For this reason we selected the Projector Augmented Wave (PAW) method, originally developed by Blochl [ 141, for this work. PAW is an approximation to FLAPW that captures most of its important features and can be formulated to calculate local stresses by the Hellman-Feynman method. We also performed some calculations using the FLAPW method as a check on the accuracy of the results. The two methods are in reasonable agreement. The details of the computation are given in ref. [4]. The ideal strength was computed for uniaxial stress in tension or shear. The lattice vectors were incrementally deformed in the direction of the imposed stress, and at each step the structure was relaxed until the stresses orthogonal to the applied stress vanished, as indicated by those components of the Hellman-Feynman stresses being less than 0.15 GPa [15]. Because there is no unique measure of strain for a given finite deformation, we describe our deformations in terms of the engineering strain from the equilibrium structure. The initial set of lattice vectors ra (a=!,2,3) in an orthogonal coordinate system become the vectors ra' after homogeneous deformation by the transformation :r = rla + D, rJa . From this transformation, we define the strain to be e,=[D,,+DJ,]/2. As is customary, we redefine the shear strains to be yIJ=2elJfor i#j. While the engineering strain is convenient for describing the change in the lattice vectors from their original configuration, the Cauchy (true) stress cannot be calculated from the derivative of the free energy with respect to this strain measure. To compute the Cauchy stress we take the derivative of the free energy with respect to the incremental strain from a nearby reference state, yielding a stress that converges to the thermodynamic definition of the Cauchy stress in the limit of small incremental strain. It should be noted that the ideal strengths determined from these calculations are for quasi-static deformation at OK, and that other dynamic instabilities such as soft phonons may lower the ideal strength.
EQUILIBRIUM STRUCTURES We chose to compute the ideal strength with the Projector Augmented Wave (PAW) method because of its computational efficiency and its ability to treat lattice stress. To check the accuracy of the method, we computed the energy as a function of volume for several magnetic structures and compared the results to calculations done using the FLAPW method as well as
The ideal strength of iron
111
with available experimental data. The magnetic structures included the following: bcc ferromagnet (FM), fcc ferromagnet (FM), fcc antiferromagnet (AFM), fcc non-magnetic (NM). The results are plotted in Fig. 3. The results for the ferromagnetic bcc phase are tabulated in Table 1 .
%
a: E
I
45
-
40
.
35
.
30
-
25
.
+BCC-NM +BCC-FM +FCC-NM +-JFCC-FM -c- FCC-AFM * FCC-DAFM
20 .
60
P
64
68 72 76 80 Vdurneiatom (au')
84
88
Figure 3: The energy and magnetic moment per atom as functions of volume computed using the PAW method for Fe in the bcc (filled symbols) and fcc (open symbols) crystal structures for several magnetic states: (diamonds) non-magnetic (NM), (squares) ferromagnetic (FM), (circles) anti ferromagnetic (AFM), and (triangles) double period anti ferromagnetic (DAFM). The discontinuity in the fcc FM curve separates two distinct phases with different magnetic moments. In general the agreement between the two computational methods is good. Comparing the PAW and FLAPW methods, the equilibrium volumes of the various phases agree to within 1%. The elastic constants of the bcc FM phase agree to within 3% with the exception of c44, which has a discrepancy of 13%. Compared with experimental measurements of the bcc phase at 4 K, the PAW calculations predict a lattice parameter that is too small by 1% and elastic constants which are generally about 10% too large suggesting a slight over-binding (the only discrepancy being c44 which is 18% too small). From the computed elastic constants, the relaxed tensile modulus in the <001> direction, E<,00>= l/sll, is found to be about 29% too large, while the relaxed shear modulus in the 4 11> direction, G= 3c44(c1I-c12)/(4c44+c~ I - C I ,~is) about 18% too large.
D.M. Clatterbuck, D.C. Chrzan and J.W. Morris Jr.
178
In regards to the magnetic properties, both the PAW and FLAPW methods correctly predict that the ground state is the bcc ferromagnetic phase with a magnetic moment of 2.20 pg and 2.15 p~ respectively as compared to the experimental value of 2.22 pg [. Both sets of calculations also predict that the ferromagnetic fcc phase undergoes a pressure-induced, first order phase transformation at a volume of 76-77 au3/atom from a low-volume, low-moment phase to a highvolume, high-moment phase. The groundstate magnetic structure of fcc Fe has been debated on theoretical grounds extensively in the literature. While bulk fcc Fe is difficult to achieve experimentally at low temperature, there is some probative experimental data on the magnetic state of nearly pure Fe in the fcc crystal structure. It is possible to stabilize fcc Fe by growth as a thin epitaxial film or as small precipitates in a copper matrix. Tsunoda [17,18] found that small fcc precipitates in Cu that are almost pure Fe have a spiral spin density wave (SSDW) ground state. Knopfle et al. [19] have recently published calculations using the modified augmented spherical wave method that show good agreement with this experimental data. Their minimum energy fcc structure has a spiral vector of q=(0.15,0,1) with an energy which lies <1 mRy below the AFM phase and has a slightly larger equilibrium volume than the AFM phase. Due to the complexity involved in treating non-collinear magnetism, in the present work we have used collinear structures as approximate representations of the true magnetic ground state. Herper, Hoffmann, and Entel [ 1I] proposed using a collinear double period antiferromagnetic structure (DAFM) as an approximate to the non-collinear ground state in fcc Fe. In this structure the spins on (002) planes are oriented up-up-down-down. The energy as a function of volume of this structure is plotted in Figure 4 and we see that it is located <1 mRy below the AFM phase and has a similar equilibrium volume. The spiral spin density wave studied by Knopfle, et al. [ 191 has an energy only slightly below this. TABLE 1 Lattice parameters, volumes, relative energies and elastic constants from PAW and FLAPW calculations as well as experiment. All energies are relative to the FM bcc phase which is taken as 0. Experimental elastic constants at 4K are from [20] and the experimental lattice parameter extrapolated to 4 K is from Ref. [21]. PAW
FLAPW
PAW-FLAPW
Experiment (4K)
%Enor
PAW-Experiment %Error
bcc-FM V, (au3)
76.47
76.20
0.4%
78.94
-3.1% -1.1%
a0 (4
2.830
2.827
0.1%
2.86
0 (GPa)
194
196
-1.0%
174
11.5%
C I I (GPa)
286
289
-0.9%
245
16.9%
c12@Pa)
147
152
-3.43%
139
5.9%
c44 (GPa)
99
114
-12.8%
122
-18.5%
EclOO>
P a )
G
187
184
1.5
144
29.2%
77
78.9
-1.9%
65
18.4%
The ideal strength of iron
179
IDEAL STRENGTH IN TENSION We first consider the ideal strength in tension. Since previous calculations and symmetry arguments suggest <001> is the weakest direction in tension for bcc metals [2], we have focused on the ideal strength in this direction. Tetragonal versus orthorhom bic instability
There are two possible deformation paths for uniaxial tension in the <001> direction (Fig. 4). An infinitesimal strain in the Cool> direction distorts the crystal into a body centered tetragonal (bct) configuration. If we compute the deformation path under the constraint that the cell maintain tetragonal symmetry we obtain the results shown in Fig. 5. The energy reaches a local maximum at 28% strain in the fcc structure (c/a ratio = &, and then it reaches a local minimum at 42% strain in a stress-free bct structure with a c/a ratio of 1.66. The plot of tensile stress versus strain along this path has a maximum of 12.6 GPa at 15% strain. The maximum locates the elastic instability along the bcc-fcc (Bain) deformation path and corresponds, physically, to cleavage on the {OOl} plane.
,ao:
0
Bain Path 40 0'
0
bcl (black) fcc (while)
'pi3 0
0
0 -
bcc (black) fco (while) 0
bcc (black) bcl (black) ico (while) Orlhorhombic Path
Figure 4: The geometry of the Bain path and the orthorhombic instability. If tetragonal symmetry is maintained the Bain path is followed from the bcc structure to the fcc, which is equivalent to a bct structure with a c/a ratio of 62. If the tetragonal symmetry is broken the orthorhombic path is followed and a maximum energy is reached at a special bct structure that has a c/a ratio of 1.66. The orthorhombic path eventually produces a bcc cell that is rotated relative to the original bcc cell. The initial bct structure can also be treated as a special case of a face centered orthorhombic (fco) structure that is rotated by 45' (Fig. 4) and has a:b:c ratio of 62: 62:1, where we take the caxis to lie in the direction of the applied strain. If we preserve orthorhombic symmetry (which allows the tetragonal symmetry to be broken) the deformation is coincident with the Bain path up to a strain of -18%, but then diverges from it. The evolution of the ratios of the orthorhombic lattice parameters along the loading path is shown at the bottom of Fig. 5 and the geometric relationship between the special crystal structures is shown in Fig. 4. At a strain of 18% the crystal spontaneously develops an orthorhombic distortion. The energy reaches a maximum at 21% strain, then falls off into a local minimum at a strain of 42%. The energy maximum along the orthorhombic path occurs at the "special" bct structure with a c/a ratio of 1.66, and the energy
180
D.M. Clatterbuck, D.C. Chrzan and J.W. Morris Jr.
minimum is a bcc structure that is rotated relative to the initial bcc cell (see Fig. 4). If one refers the structure back to the bct structure with the deformation in the [OOI] direction, the orthorhombic instability corresponds to the elastic constant c66 vanishing, which causes the crystal to become unstable with respect to a shear. Although the crystal is pulled in tension this instability initiates a shear failure on the 4 11>( 112) system of the bcc crystal. The competition between tetragonal and orthorhombic instabilities in bcc crystals was first noted by Luo, et al. [7], who found that the tetragonal instability dominates in Mo (as in W) while the orthorhombic instability intrudes in Nb. The issue is physically important, since the tetragonal instability leads to failure in tension ((001) cleavage) while the orthorhombic instability leads to failure in shear 4-( 1l>{ 112) shear). Ferromagnetic Fe behaves like the conventional bcc metals, W and Mo. Its ideal strength in <001> tension, 12.6 GPa, is determined by the tetragonal instability and, hence, by cleavage on (001). In keeping with this result, Fe cleaves on (001) when tested at low temperature. We also computed the ideal tensile strength of Fe using the FLAPW method; however, in those calculations only tetragonal structures were considered. A slightly higher ideal strength, 14.2 GPa was found, which is consistent with the larger energy difference between the bcc FM and fcc FM structures found with the FLAPW method as compared to the PAW method. The energy difference may be due to the differences in the treatment of the GGA or errors introduced by the PAW potential. The conditions of stability developed by Morris and Krenn [xx] were tested at 14% strain to check for orthogonal instabilities. No orthogonal instabilities were found at that strain, consistent with the PAW calculations. However, the elastic constant c66 was found to be only -30 GPa, quite a bit smaller than in bcc Fe (114 GPa), which is an indication of the close proximity of the orthorhombic instability. Assuming a sinusoidal stress-strain curve that returns to zero at the actual strain needed to reach the fcc phase, 0.286, we have
o = omsin(ed0.286). (2) = 0.091E, Requiring that Hooke's law be satisfied for small strains: om = 0.286E<001>/n: where E<001, is Young's modulus for elongation in the <001> direction. Eq. 2 agrees well with the results calculated here: om/E=0.087 with the experimental value for E<001>,or o,lE=0.068 with the calculated value.
The ideal strength of iron
0
01
02 03 Engneering %an
.15
-20
C
0
01
0
01
05
04
05
04
05
"
02 03 Engheer~ngStrain
02
04
181
03
Engineering Strain
Figure 5 : (a) Energy and (b) stress as a function of applied tensile strain along cool>: (filled squares) Bain Path with tetragonal symmetry, (open square) orthorhombic path. (c) Ratios of the lattice parameters along the orthorhombic path: (filled diamond) ah,(filled triangle) d c , (filled circle) b/c. Numbers and open circles an (a) and (c) indicate special structures with high symmetry that are shown schematically in Figure 6. Magnetic instabilities
The results to this point have only considered ferromagnetic (FM) states; however, the fact that Fe has a metastable, antiferromagnetic fcc phase at low temperature suggests that it must become unstable with respect to magnetic transitions at large strains. We will now consider this possibility.
As discussed above, we approximate the magnetic structures of fcc Fe by collinear structures for computational simplicity. In addition, we used a scalar relativistic approximation that does not include the effects of spin-orbit coupling. However, our earlier calculations using the FLAPW method showed that this makes a negligible effect on the energy differences between various magnetic structures. In the actual calculation we fix the magnetic structure and relax the lattice into the required stress state. We then increment the strain to obtain the energy and stress as a function of the strain, relaxing the lattice at each step along the path. This entire process is then repeated for various magnetic structures.
D.M. Clatterbuck, D.C. Chrzan and J.W. Morris Jr.
182
Fig. 6 shows the calculated energy as a function of strain for Fe in the FM, AFM, DAFM and low-spin FM structures. We have studied both bct and fco structures and found that the AFM and LSFM structures remain tetragonal while the DAFM and FM structures undergo a transformation to the fco structure at different points along the loading path. The DAFM structure is preferred to FM Fe for strains above about -20%. This result suggests that the ideal strength is not compromised by magnetic instability since the structural instability ((001 } cleavage) occurs at about 15% strain, well before the magnetic transition intrudes. Thus, the ideal strength in <001> tension is -12.6 GPa and is set by a tensile elastic instability along the Bain path from bcc to fcc. The stability of fcc iron is made possible by a magnetic phase transition at larger strains that does not affect the ideal strength. 20
-E
16
$14E
2 P x
* BCTFM
12-
10-
p 80
6-
0
.
.
/
FCOFM ,,-:* BCTAFM ‘,a BCTDAFM *$’ FCODAFM .t BCT LSFM
;
P ~ ’
:a,
i
0.1
rn
* .*+<: ;(I. -. I..
*
a
0.2 0.3 Engineering Strain
*
-cA
0.4
Figure 6: Energy versus strain in the <001> direction for various magnetic structures: (solid square) bct-FM, (open square) fco-FM, (filled triangle) bct-DAFM, (open triangle) fco-DAFM, (filled circle) bct-AFM, (filled diamond) bct-LSFM. The fco-AFM and fco-LSFM structures follow paths identical to bct-AFM and bct-LSFM respectively and are not shown. A magnetic phase transformation is seen near 20% strain. Comparison with previous calculations and experiment
Several previous authors have studied the energy as function of tetragonality for Fe, but have not determined the ideal strength [ 11,221. Friak et al. [23] independently calculated the ideal tensile strength along the tetragonal loading path using the FLAF’W method and found a strength of 12.7 GPa, in good agreement with our results from the PAW method and slightly lower than our calculations using the FLAF’W method (14.2GPa). While the use of different GGA formulations in the three cases makes exact comparison difficult, the differences are within the error range for density functional methods. To our knowledge, the only attempt to measure the ideal tensile strength of Fe was by Brenner [24] who tested Fe whiskers in tension. He measured a value of -5GPa for tension in the c o o l > direction. While this value is considerably lower than the calculated ideal strength, the failure initiated at the surface and, therefore, does not represent bulk strength. The measured value of the strength in the <111> direction was 13GPa, but it is expected that the ideal strength of bcc metals in the 4 11> direction is significantly larger than in the cool> direction [2].
The ideal strength of iron
183
IDEAL STRENGTH IN SHEAR Shear strength of FM bcc Fe
We computed the ideal shear strength of Fe for two common slip systems: <111>{112) and 41I>{ 110). The energy and the stress are plotted as functions of the shear strain for the two systems in Fig. 7. We note that the ideal strength in the easy direction is very similar for the two slip systems, 7.2 GPa for 411>{ 112) and 7.8 GPa for <1 11>{110). The energy curves for the two systems also have the same maximum. These results, which are common in bcc metals, have their origin in the symmetry of the "saddle point" structures that govern the shear strength [7,10]. The saddle point structures for the two slip systems are identical. Moreover, the saddle point structure in shear is precisely the bct saddle point structure that governs the orthorhombic instability in tension. The convergence of the three strain paths to the same saddle point simply shows that the nearby saddle points on the energy hypersurface act as "attractors" to which the various deformations are drawn.
080
-060
040
-020
000
EngneeiingStain
020
040
-0 8 0
-OW
040
020
000
Engineering Stran
020
Figure 7: (a) Energy versus shear strain and (b) absolute value of the stress versus strain for (filled square) < I 1 I>{ 112) shear and (open square) 4 1 I>{ 110) shear.
Table 2 Summary of stresses and strains associated with instabilities and saddle points. The tensile strains are referred to a bct cell with the [OOI] axis along the z-axis. For <11 l>{ 112) shear, the reference structure is a base centered monoclinic cell with its 2-fold axis parallel to the x-axis, one orthogonal lattice vector parallel to the shear direction which coincides with the y-axis, and the other orthogonal lattice vector in the y-z plane. For 411>{110} shear, the reference structure is a triclinic cell with one lattice vector in the shear direction which coincides with the y-axis, the second lattice vector in the shear plane which coincides with the x-y plane, and third vector with some component in the z-direction.)
040
D.M. Clatterbuck, D.C. Chrzan and J.W. Morris Jr.
184
Tension
<111>{112}
Shear <112>{112)
tetragonal
orthorhombic
(hard)
(easy)
12.6
12.6
15.0
7.2
7.8
bct
bct
monoclinic
monoclinic
triclinic
< I l l > { 110)
-.042
-.049
,037
-.008
-.002
-.042
-.049
-0.26
-.006
-.001
,150
,176
,042
,028
.029
-.374
,140
,059 ,020 ,035
fcc
bct
-.091
-.070
-.091
-.070
,286
,209
bct
bct
,046
,004
-.014
-.03 1
-.016
-.015
,088
,044
,033
-.726
,288
,339
orthorhombic
,022 ,154
While the saddle point structure for the two slip systems is the same, the strain paths on the energy hypersurface are slightly different. This difference is responsible for the fact that the strain at which the bct structure occurs is slightly larger for the 4 1l>{ 110) system, and the ideal strengths for the two systems differ by -8%. The relaxation of the crystal lattice during strain is also distinctly different. A constant volume shear on the 4 1l>{ 112) system (with no relaxation in the slip plane) produces a body centered orthorhombic structure at a engineering shear strain of 33%. Allowing relaxation, the special bct structure is reached after a strain of 29% with a 4% expansion perpendicular to the slip plane, and relaxation strains in the slip plane of < 2% (see Fig. 8 and Table 2). On the other hand, a <111>{ 110) shear reaches the bct structure at 34% strain, but requires a significant relaxation in the slip plane, the largest component being a 15% shear. The reason for the differences between (112) and (110) shear lies in the fact that while both paths begin at bcc and end at the bct saddle-point structure, the very different applied stresses cause them to diverge from one another at intermediate strains and produce significantly different atomic configurations near the point of instability.
The ideal stvength of iron
185
Base Centered Monoclinic Cell
Base Centered Ort horhoinbic Figure 8: Geometry of the <111>{112} shear system. The base centered monoclinic cell is shown inside the initial bcc structure (left). A { 110) projection of the structure shows the how the monoclinic cell becomes a bct cell upon applying a -33% shear in the easy direction (top). A shear in the opposite (hard) direction generates a base centered orthorhombic structure after a shear strain of -66% (bottom). The monoclinic structure's two fold axis is pointed out of the page. Black atoms are those in the closest plane and the gray atoms are in the following plane of atoms.
As suggested by Frenkel [25], we model the ideal strength by assuming the that the stress-strain relation is sinusoidal with an amplitude z,,,and period 2 YB:
If we require that Hooke's law be satisfied for small strains, this implies that
where G<11p is the shear modulus in the < I l l > direction. (Note that the shear moduli are the same for both shear systems.) If we take YB to be 0.34, then Eq. 4 predicts z, = 0.1 ~ G < I I Our ~>. results give dimensionless strengths which are very close to this, for { 112) t,,,/G=O. 11 and for { 110 ) tm/G=O.12, where we have used the experimental value of G from Table 1. Using the calculated value of G < I I ~the , reduced strengths are 0.10 and 0.094 for shear on the { 112) and (1 10) planes respectively. The shear strength in the hard direction for the 4 11>{112) system is 15.0 GPa. It follows a path toward a different saddle point that is much higher in energy (see Figs. 7 and 8). The saddle point structure is base centered orthorhombic with an a:b:c ratio of 1: 1.06:1.77. This structure can also be pictured as a simple tetragonal structure with a c/a ratio of 2.42 that has undergone an (engineering) shear strain of 6% in the plane perpendicular to the unique axis. Figure 9 demonstrates the geometry and the fact that the strain needed to reach this saddle point is approximately twice that for shear in the easy direction.
186
D.M. Clatterbuck, D.C. Chrzan and J.W. Morris Jr.
To test the numerical accuracy of the PAW method, the energies of several structures along the 4 11>{112) "easy" shear path were also computed with the FLAPW technique. The energy differences were less than 0.2 mRy. While we have not confirmed that the stress states of these structures are uniaxial when computed with the FLAPW method, the close agreement in the energies along the deformation path suggests that the PAW method is quite accurate in this regime. Magnetic instabilities
We also investigated the possibility that finite shear strain would induce magnetic instabilities that would limit the shear strength. This was done by testing several different magnetic structures and relaxing the stresses, as in the ferromagnetic case. The energy was only computed at a few interesting points along the i l l 1>{112) loading path. The magnetic structures were chosen to mimic the DAFM structure used for the tensile strength calculations, but because the crystal is monoclinic along the loading path, there are several inequivalent ways of arranging the up and down spins in such a fashion. The 5 structures we studied are shown in Fig. 9. They include superlattices made up of one or two base centered monoclinic cells, with different arrangements of the up and down spins occupying the sites.
BCTDAFM 0
0
DAFM-x 0
DAM-Z
0
0
DAFM-Y
AFh4
DAFM-Y?
Figure 9: The magnetic structures used to describe complex magnetic ordering in <111>{ 112) shear. The structures are supercells made up of I or 2 body centered monoclinic cells whose 2fold axes are oriented out of the page. The bct-DAFM structure is shown for reference. 50-
-E 40 -; SO'
'
0
K
-6 2 0 ' P
W
10.
o i
A
-
0
FM o DAFMX
Y
.... . D
.. ..
.
o DAFMZ A DAFMY o DA-MY2
'6
.'. o
O
9.
__
x
AFM
". os, c m&..w-
... -.
0
I
The ideal strength of iron
187
Fig. 10 shows the energy as a function of strain for the relaxed structures. There is a magnetic transformation at -20% strain to the magnetic structure denoted DAFMX. However, this strain is beyond the point of elastic instability, so this transformation does not affect the ideal shear strength. The energy as a function of strain for the DAFMX structure was confirmed by FLAPW calculations using a method similar to that described above. We again note that we have only considered here a set of collinear structures which we hope approximate the ground state magnetic structure; however, the introduction of non-collinear magnetic ordering may further reduce the energy of some of these structures. IDEAL STRENGTH IN MULTIAXIAL LOADING The previous two sections have described the ideal strength of iron under simple loading configurations: uniaxial tension and pure shear. However, in many engineering applications the stress state experienced by a material is more complex. In this section we study the strength of iron for uniaxal tension in the [OOl] direction in combination with biaxial tension or compression in the (001) plane. The case of unbalanced triaxial tension is commonly encountered in front of a crack tip and is thus of practical importance. The ideal strength calculations were carried out in a manner similar to that used for uniaxial tension; however, in this case the structure is relaxed to achieve the multiaxial stress state desired. For triaxial tension the stress state was taken to be ol1=2022=2033 while for uniaxial tension plus biaxial compression the stress state was taken to be (TI]=- ( ~ 2 2 = - 0 3 3 . In practical terms, the desired stress state was said to be achieved when the Hellman-Feynman stresses obeyed the above equalities to within 0.1 GPa.
.
. . 'I' .
Tension
150
1 20t 10
7.5. 5.0.
25'
OodoO
. m
.: . . 'I' '
' t c
' a
c
e
0.05
0;O
0;5
020
0.25
. OiO
Engineering Strain
Figure 11: Stress as a function of strain for FM Fe under three different multiaxial loads: uniaxial tension plus biaxial compression (triangle), uniaxial tension (square), triaxial tension (diamond). In all cases the largest tensile stress is in the [OOl] direction. The large symbols with arrows indicate the location of tetragonal to orthorhombic instabilities. (The load configuration that includes biaxial compression was not tested for this type of instability.) The weak direction in tension for bcc metals is known to be the <001> direction, so we focus our attention on this orientation. Fig. 11 shows the stress as a function of engineering strain in the ~ 0 0 1 direction 2 for the three different stress states considered. We see that the application of a tensile stresses perpendicular to the primary tensile direction raises the ideal tensile strength while compressive stresses decrease the ideal strength. In conjunction with this we note that the
188
D.M. Clatterbuck, D.C. Chrzan and J.W. Morris Jr.
strain corresponding to the ideal strength is increased in the tensile case and decreased in the compressive case. These results are in contrast to the often held assumption that the tensile strength of a material should decrease in a triaxial stress state. However, the reason for this result becomes clear if one examines the effect of these stresses from the perspective of their associated strains. The application of a [OOl] tensile strain to a bcc metal causes the symmetry to be broken and the crystal structure becomes body centered tetragonal (bct). When the c/a ratio of the bct crystal is increased to $2 it becomes the fcc structure. Cubic symmetryrequires that the [OOl] tensile stress vanish for both the bcc and fcc structures (at least, if we ignore the magnetic effect, which is small). As such, these structures are symmetry-induced extrema (or saddle points) on the multidimensional energy-strain surface. We can model the stress-strain curve between the two energy extrema by a sinusoid as suggested by Orowon [ 9 ] : D = cm sin(e xiemax),
(5)
where omis the ideal strength, e is the engineering strain, and emaxis the engineering strain of the second stress-free structure. Requiring that the Hooke's law be obeyed at small strain, one finds that D m = emaxE/~, (6)
where E=1/sll is the Young's modulus in the <001> direction. Now consider the effect of the triaxial stress state on the bct structure. The addition of the orthogonal tensile stresses increases the length of the crystal in the [loo] and [OlO] directions. Because of this, a larger strain is needed in the [OOl] direction to reach the fcc structure, increasing emax.Given this, Eq. 6 implies that the ideal strength should be increased in tension. In a similar way, the addition of compressive stresses orthogonal to the tensile direction will have the opposite effect and decrease the strain needed to reach the fcc saddle point structure. In this analysis we have assumed that the stress-strain curve remains sinusoidal under multiaxial loads. An additional effect not explicitly included in Equation 6 is caused by the pressure dependence
of the Young's modulus. It would be possible for triaxial tensile stresses to lower the ideal tensile strength of a bcc metal if the additional stresses decreased the Young's modulus more than they increased the strain needed to reach the fcc structure. From the initial slopes in Fig. 11, we see that triaxial tensile stresses increases the Young's modulus in iron, which increases the ideal strength even more than if the Young's modulus were independent of pressure. This increase in the Young's modulus with pressure is consistent with the experimentally determined pressure dependence of the elastic constants [ 2 6 ] .
As discussed in above, the body centered tetragonal structure can become elastically unstable with respect to transformation to a face centered orthorhombic structure. For uniaxial tension in iron, this shear failure occurs at strains larger than the elastic instability associated with the
The ideal strength of iron
189
tetragonal Bain path. We find that the triaxial stress state studied here increases the strain at which the tetragonal to orthorhombic transition occurs; however, the increase is less than the increase in the strain associated with the peak in the stress-strain curve (see Fig. 11). The effect is to cause the orthorhombic instability to occur closer to the maximum in the stress-strain curve of the tetragonal structure for triaxial tension. We have not studied the effect of pressure on the magnetic transformations that can occur along the Bain path. In the uniaxial case, the elastic instability occurs at smaller strains than these magnetic transitions and thus it dictates the ideal strength. To a first order we expect that the addition of orthogonal tensile stresses would enhance the stability of the ferromagnetic phase due to a narrowing of the bandwidth, while the addition of compressive stresses would tend to favor antiferromagnetic or non-spin polarized (paramagnetic) phases. This suggests that even under multiaxial loading the ideal strength is governed by the elastic instability rather than the magnetic instability; however, a more detailed study would be needed to verify this claim as it is not known whether the change in the strain associated with the magnetic phase transitions would be larger or smaller than the change in the strain associated with the elastic instability. CONCLUSIONS
Ab initio total energy calculations using the PAW method were used to calculate the ideal strength of iron in tension and shear. The ideal tensile strength in the <001> direction is 12.6 GPa and is associated with an elastic instability at 15% strain along the Bain path from bcc to fcc. At this strain the structure is stable with respect to both orthogonal elastic instabilities and magnetic instabilities. However, if it were possible to reach larger strains, both an elastic instability toward a face centered orthorhombic structure occurs and a magnetic instability from the bct FM to a DAFM magnetic structure would be encountered. The ideal shear strengths of the two shear systems, <111>{112} and <111>{110}, are 7.2GPa and 7.8 GPa respectively. The ideal shear strengths are very similar because they are determined by the same body-centered tetragonal "saddle point structure". (This bct "saddle-point structure" is also responsible for the orthorhombic instability in tension). Along the <11 l>{ 112) shear path, a magnetic instability toward a complex magnetic structure is found at -20% strain. Like the magnetic instabilities in tension, it does not compromise the ideal strength because it occurs at larger strains than the elastic instability in the ferromagnetic phase. The ideal tensile strength in the <001> direction is increased when one applies a biaxial tensile stress in the (001) plane while the strength is decreased when the additional stress is biaxial compression. This effect can be understood based on a simple crystallographic model. The triaxial stress state increases the strain needed to reach the fcc saddle point structure, which results in a higher strength. The tetragonal to orthorhombic instability is found to move closer to the peak in the stress strain curve, a result similar to what is found in Nb despite the fact that they undergo different failure modes under uniaxial tension. Despite its complex magnetic behavior and its metastable fcc phase, the ideal strength of Fe is governed by the same elastic instabilities that are found in typical bcc transition metals like W and Mo.
190
D.M. Clatterbuck, D.C. Chrzan and J.W. Morris Jr.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work was supported by the Director, Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Division of Materials Sciences and Engineering, of the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC03-76SF00098. REFERENCES 1. A. Kelly and N. H. MacMillian (1986). Strong Solids. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 3rd ed. pp. 1-56. 2. J. W. Morris Jr., C. R. Krenn, D. Roundy, and Marvin L. Cohen (2000). In: Phase Transformations and Evolution in Materials. P. E. Turchi and A. Gonis (eds.). TMS, Warendale, PA., pp. 187-207. 3. D. M. Clatterbuck, D. C. Chrzan, and J. W. Morris Jr. (2002). Phil. Mug. Lett. 82, 141. 4. D. M. Clatterbuck, D. C. Chrzan, and J.W. Morris Jr. (2003). Actu Muteriulia, 51,2271. 5. M. Sob, L. G. Wang, and V. Vitek (1998). V. Kovove Muteriuly 36, 145. 6. M. Sob, L. G. Wang, and V. Vitek (1997). Mat. Sci. Eng. A 234-236, 1075. 7. W. Luo, D. Roundy, M. L. Cohen, and J. W. Morris Jr. (2002). Phys. Rev. B 66,094110. 8. F. Milstein and J. Marschall(l988). Phil. Mug. A 58, 365. 9. E. Orowon(1949). Rept. Prog. Phys. 12, 185. 10. D. Roundy, C. R. Krenn, Marvin L. Cohen, and J. W. Morris Jr. (2001). Phil. Mug. A 81, 1725. 11. H. C. Herper, E. Hoffman, and P. Entel(l999). Phys. Rev. B 60, 3839. 12. D. J. Singh, W. E. Pickett, and H. Krakauer (1991). Phys. Rev. B 43, 11628. 13. D. J. Singh (1994). Planewaves, Pseudopotentials and the LAPWMethod.Kluwer Academic, Boston 14. P. E. Blochl(l994). Phys. Rev. B 50, 17853. 15. D. Roundy, C. R. Krenn, Marvin L. Cohen, and J. W. Moms Jr. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 2713. 16. B. D. Cullity (1972). Introduction to Magnetic Materials. Addison-Wesley, Reading Mass., p 617 17. Y .Tsunoda (1989). J. Phys. Condens. Mutter 1, 10427. 18. Y. Tsunoda, Y. Nishioka, R. M. Nicklow (1996). J. Mugn. Mug. Mat. 128, 133. 19. K. Knopfle, L. M. Sandrastskii, and J. Kubler (2000). Phys. Rev. B 62, 5564. 20. M. Acet, H. Zahres, E. F. Wassermann, and W. Pepperhoff (1994). Phys. Rev. B 49,6012. 21. J. A. Rayne and B. S. Chandrasekhar (1961). Phys. Rev. 122, 1714. 22. L. Stixrude, R. E. Cohen, and D. J. Singh (1994). Phys. Rev. B 50,6442. 23. M. Friak, M. Sob, V. Vitek (2001). In: Proc. Znt. Con$ Juniormat 2001, Institute of Materials Engineering, Bmo University of Technology, Bmo, p. 117 24. S. S. Brenner (1956). J. Appl. Phys. 27, 1484. 25. J. Frenkel(l926). Z. Physik 7, 323. 26. F. Nelson (ed.) (1992). Landolt-Bornstein LBIIV29a -- Low Frequency Properties of Dielectric Crystals: Second and Higher Order Elastic Constants, Springer-Verlag, Berlin
Nan0 and Microstructural Design of Advanced Materials M.A. Meyers, R.O. Ritchie and M. Sarikaya (Editors) 02003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MICROSTRUCTURE-PROPERTY RELATIONSHIPS OF NANOSTRUCTURED Al-Fe-Cr-Ti ALLOYS L. Shawl, H. Luol, J. Vilegas' and D. Miracle' Department of Metallurgy and Materials Engineering University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT, USA Air Force Research Laboratory, Materials and Manufacturing Directorate Wright-PattersonAFB, OH, USA
ABSTRACT Nanostructured Al93Fe3TizCr2 alloys were prepared via mechanical alloying (MA), followed by extrusion to form bulk materials. The microstructure of the alloy was characterized using a variety of analytical instruments including X-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Compression tests were conducted as a function of temperature ranging from 25 to 40OoC. It was found that the MA-processed A193Fe3Ti2Cr2 alloy had excellent compressive strength and ductility. High temperature strengths were especially impressive with the ratio of the ultimate strength to density equivalent to that of Ti-6Al-4V up to about 30OoC. The enhanced strength at both ambient and elevated temperatures was attributed to grain refinement, formation of supersaturated solid solutions, and presence of intermetallic precipitates. INTRODUCTION Aluminum alloys and their composites with greater strength at elevated temperatures are needed for applications in aerostructure, aeropropulsion and rocket propulsion. Current commercial alloys provide high strength at room temperature, but at 200 - 35OoCthe strength of these materials decreases rapidly. Consequently, other materials are used for high temperature load carrying applications with a resultant penalty of weight. Recent progresses in studies of bulk amorphous and nanostructured alloys have offered opportunities to improve the strength of aluminum alloys at both room and elevated temperatures. It has been shown that amorphous A1 alloys could possess high tensile strength coupled with good bending ductility [ 141. The strengths obtained from the amorphous A1 alloys are much higher than those of the best conventional coarse-grained A1 alloys. Furthermore, the primary crystallization of the amorphous A1 alloys could lead to a microstructure of a high density of A1 nanocrystals in an amorphous matrix that offers even higher strengths than those of the parent amorphous A1 alloys [5-lo]. When the primary crystallization is carried out to completion, the nanocrystalline A1 alloys still exhibit superior tensile strengths (e.g., 800 - 1000 MPa) that are much higher than those of the best conventional crystalline
191
192
L. Shaw et a1
A1 alloys [lo]. A1 alloys with quasicrystalline phases (e.g., icosahedral structure) or a nanoscale mixture of quasicrystalline phases surrounded by a continuous fcc-A1 phase have also been shown to possess high tensile strengths ranging from 500 to 1300 MPa [5,11-131. In this study we have investigated the feasibility of making nanocrystalline A193Fe3TizCrz alloys via mechanical alloying (MA) starting from elemental powders, and examined the potential of the MAprocessed A193Fe3TizCrz alloy for high-temperature structural applications. A193Fe3Ti~Crzalloys have been chosen for investigation because Fe, Cr and Ti all have very low difisivity and equilibrium solubility in fcc-A1 (0.03 at.% Fe, > 0.01 at.% Cr, and > 0.2 at.% Ti) [14-171. Low difisivity and solubility are the basic requirements for preventing Ostwald ripening [181. Thus, Al93Fe3Ti~Cr2alloys are expected to have good microstructural stability at elevated temperatures and therefore superior high-temperature strengths. Al93Fe3TizCrz alloy has been prepared previously by Inoue, et al. [5] using the gas atomization approach followed by extrusion. They have indeed found that this alloy possesses superior high temperature strength. The reported ultimate tensile strength at 3OO0C is 360 MPa [5]. This high temperature strength compares very favorably against the current commercial Al alloys, most of which lose their useful strengths at temperatures above 25OoC (typically becoming lower than 200 MPa) [ 191. In contrast to the gas atomization approach, we have utilized the MA approach to prepare the nanostructured A193Fe3Ti~Cr2alloy. The potential advantage using MA over rapid quenching (i.e., gasatomization) to prepare nanocrystalline Al93Fe3TizCrz alloys is the possibility of making nanocrystalline A1 matrix composites with nano-reinforcements (i.e., nano/nano-A1 composites) through blending the elemental constituents of the metallic matrix or pre-alloyed metallic powder with insoluble nano-reinforcements such as nano-SiC particles. Nanohano-A1 composites are expected to have better microstructural stability and thus higher elevated temperature strengths than those exhibited by the corresponding nanocrystalline A1 alloys.
EXPERIMENTALPROCEDURES Crystalline elemental powders were used to prepare A1 alloys with a nominal composition of A193Fe3TizCr2. The aluminum powder had a purity of 99.5 wt% with a mean particle size of 70 pm, while the corresponding values for iron, chromium and titanium powders used were 99.0%, 98.5% and 99.5% as well as 50, 30 and 30 pm, respectively. The as-received aluminum powder was made via atomization, whereas the iron powder was manufactured via a vapor phase chemical decomposition process, the chromium powder via electrolytic plating and milling, and the titanium powder via the hydride technique followed by a dehydride process. Mechanical alloying was performed in a Szegvari attritor. The canister of the attritor was made of a stainless steel and the charge consisted of stainless steel balls with a diameter of 4.76 mm. A ball-topowder weight ratio of 20:l and a milling speed of 600 RPM with the milling duration of 30 hours were employed in all the experiments. During milling the canister was cooled using circulation water with a flow rate of about 770 mVmin throughout the process and an argon atmosphere was employed in all the experiments. To prevent excessive cold welding of A1 alloys, 1.2 wtYo stearic acid [CH3(CH2)&0OH] was added to the powder mixture as the process control agent. The MA-processed powder was used to make bulk materials via extrusion technique. Prior to extrusion, the MA-processed powder was containerized within a metal can and subjected to degassing which was carried out in a temperature ranging from 300 to 55OoC until the pressure of the can was reduced to lo-’ ton. The parameters controlled during extrusion included the included angle of the
Microstructure-property relationships of nunostructured Al-Fe-Cr-Tialloys
193
extrusion dies, extrusion temperature, extrusion ratio and strain rate. The extruded Al93Fe3Ti2Crz bulk material was used to prepare cylindrical compressive specimens 6-mm in diameter and 9-mm in height. Both ends of the compressive specimens were coated with MoS2 before tests and the strain rate sec-' for all the tests. All the compressive tests were displacement controlled and empolyed was terminated if the specimen did not fracture at -0.45 true strain. The test temperature investigated ranged from 25 to 40OoC. Powders received and milled as well as extruded bulk A1 alloys were analyzed using X-ray dimaction (Rigaku RU-200B series) with CuKa radiation. In addition to monitoring phase transformations, XRD was also used to measure the crystallite size and internal strains of fcc-Al. The detailed procedure for estimating the crystallite size and internal strain can be found elsewhere [20,21] and will not be repeated here. The microstructure of the extruded A1 alloy was examined using a field-emission SEM (Leica Cambridge Stereoscan 360FE) equipped with energy dispersive spectrometry (EDS). Analyses of the gain size, crystal structure and chemical composition within the microstructure of the Al alloy were also performed using a TEM (Philips CM200 FEG) operating at 200kV. In the TEM analysis, both bright and dark field image techniques coupled with selected area difhction (SAD), convergent beam electron d i M o n (CBED) and EDS with an electron beam of 3.5 nm were used to characterk the MAprocessed Al alloy. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Figure 1 shows typical true stress-true strain curves of extruded A193Fe3Ti~Cr2alloys obtained from compressive tests with a strain rate of lo5 sec-*.The different stress-strain curves in Figure 1 are due to different extrusion ratios with Sample C having the largest extrusion ratio. For Sample A tested at 25'C, the specimen cracks laterally after a small compressive plastic strain (-0.02). The cracking is accompanied by a sudden drop in the stress, as shown in the stress-strain curve of 25'C in Figure l(a). As compression continues, more cracks form on the lateral surface of the specimen. Eventually the entire specimen breaks into pieces at the true compressive strain of -0.37, indicating that Sample A is quite brittle at 25OC. However, the ductility of Sample A improves as the test temperature increases. As shown in Figure l(a), Sample A does not form lateral cracks even after a true strain of -0.45 when the test temperature is 300'C. The ductility of Sample A at 200'C is between those exhibited at 25 and 300'C.
(4
Testing Temperature = 25%
0
005
01
015
02
025
Ture Stain
03
Figure 1. Overleaf.
035
04
045
0.1
L. Shaw et a1
194
Mw)
4
Testing Temperature = 25'C
0
005
01
015
02
025
03
035
04
(c)
045
05
True Strain
Figure 1. True stress-true strain curves of the MA-processed A1 alloys obtained from compression tests with a strain rate of 10" sec-'. (a) Sample A, (b) Sample B and (c) Sample C have different extrusion ratios. Sample B is also brittle at 25OC; however, it appears