Modifying lipids for use in food Edited by Frank D. Gunstone
CRC Press Boca Raton Boston New York Washington, DC
WOODHEAD
PUBLISHING LIMITED
Cambridge, England
Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Abington, Cambridge CB1 6AH, England www.woodheadpublishing.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC, 6000 Broken Sound Parkway, NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton, FL 33487, USA First published 2006, Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC © 2006, Woodhead Publishing Limited The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Woodhead Publishing ISBN-13: 978-1-85573-971-0 (book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN-10: 1-85573-971-2 (book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN-13: 978-1-84569-168-4 (e-book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN-10: 1-84569-168-7 (e-book) CRC Press ISBN-13: 978-0-8493-9148-4 CRC Press ISBN-10: 0-8493-9148-2 CRC Press order number: WP9148 The publishers’ policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elementary chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publishers ensure that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Typeset by Replika Press Pvt Ltd, India Printed by T J International Limited, Padstow, Cornwall, England
Contributor contact details (* = main point of contact)
Chapters 1, 2 & 7 Professor Frank Gunstone 3 Dempster Court St Andrews Fife KY16 9EU Scotland UK
Chapters 4, 14 & 24 Professor Gudmundur G Haraldsson Science Institute University of Iceland Dunhaga 3 107 Reykjavik Iceland
Tel: +44 1334 479 929 Email:
[email protected]
Tel: +354 525 4818 Fax: +354 552 8911 Email:
[email protected]
Chapters 3 & 13 Dr Martin RL Scheeder ETH Zurich Institute of Animal Sciences ETH Zentrum LFW 56.1 CH-8092 Zurich Switzerland
Chapters 5 & 23 Professor Colin Ratledge Department of Biological Sciences University of Hull Hull HU6 7RX UK
Tel: +41-44-632 32 78 Fax: +41-44-632 11 28 Email:
[email protected]
Tel: +44 1482 465 243 Fax: +44 1482 465 822 Email:
[email protected]
xiv
Contributor contact details
Chapter 6 K Warner US Department of Agriculture National Center for Agricultural Utilization Research Peoria, IL USA
Chapter 11 Xeubing Xu BioCentrum-DTU Building 221 Technical University of Denmark DK – 2800 Lyngby Denmark
Email:
[email protected]
Tel: 45-45252773 Fax: 45-45884922 Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 8 Dr Alejandro G Marangoni Department of Food Science Guelph Ontario, N1G 2W1 Canada Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 9 Gary R List 1815 N. University Street Peoria, IL 61604 USA Tel: 309-681-6388 Fax 309-681-6340 Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 10 Dr Véronique Gibon Project Manager R&D De Smet Techologies and Services Da Vincilaan, 2, Bus G1 1935 Zaventeus Belgium Tel: + 322 716 1390 Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 12 Professor Denis J Murphy Biotechnology Unit School of Applied Sciences University of Glamorgan Treforest CF37 1DL Wales UK Tel: +44 1443 483 747 Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 15 Professor Jan Pokorný Department of Food Chemistry and Analysis Institute of Chemical Technology Prague Czech Republic Email:
[email protected]
Contributor contact details Chapter 16 Dr HM Premlal Ranjith* and Miss Upuli Wijewardene Diotte Consulting and Technology The Conifers 36 Bishops Wood Nantwich Cheshire CW5 7QD UK
xv
Chapter 19 Dr Earl Hammond Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition Food Sciences Building Iowa State University Ames, Iowa 50011 USA Email:
[email protected]
Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 17 Dr Gerrit van Duijn* and Eckhard Flöter Unilever Research PO Box 114 3130 AC Vlaardingen Holland Email:
[email protected] [email protected]
Chapter 18 Professor William E Artz Dept Food Science and Human Nutrition 382 Agricultural Engineering Sciences Bldg University of Illinois 1304 West Pennsylvania Avenue Urbana, Illinois 61801-4726 USA Tel: (217) 333-9337 Fax: (217) 333-9329 Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 20 Staffan Norberg AarhusKarlshamn (AAK) SE-374 82 Karlshamn Sweden Tel: +46 454 829 77 Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 21 Dr Christian Gertz Chemiedirektor Chemisches Untersuchungsamt Hagen Pappelstrasse 1 D-58099 Hagen Germany Tel.: +49-2331-2074726 Fax.: +49-2331-2072454 Email:
[email protected]
Chapter 22 Kaustuv Bhattacharya International Food Science Centre A/S Herredsvej 60C, Apt 12 8210, Aarhus V Denmark Email:
[email protected]
1 Introduction: Modifying lipids – why and how? F. Gunstone, Scottish Crop Research Institute, UK
1.1
Introduction
Annual production of oils and fats was 136 million tonnes in 2004/05 and is forecast to be 141 million tonnes in 2005/06. In the quarter-century 1976– 2000 consumption (virtually the same as production) rose at an average rate of 3.7 %, equivalent to doubling every 20 years or so (Anon, 2005). This marked increase has come mainly from five vegetable oils (soybean, the two products of the oil palm – palm oil and palmkernel oil – rapeseed/canola and sunflower) and to a lesser extent from eight other vegetable oils (cottonseed, groundnut/peanut, sesame, corn, olive, coconut, linseed and castor) and four animal fats (butter, lard, tallow and fish oil). These increases result partly from larger areas being devoted to their cultivation and partly from rising yields. The composition of these oils is described in selected chapters in Part I of this book. It is estimated that ~ 80 % of total oil and fat production is used for food and the balance for animal feed and by the oleochemical industry. The major food uses include frying oils, baking fats, cooking fats, shortenings, spreads, salad oils, mayonnaise, confectionery fats and ice cream. However, there are additional dietary fats not counted by market analysts in their assessment of commodity oils and fats. For example, figures for groundnut (peanut) oil do not include the commodity eaten as nuts, figures for butter do not include milk consumed as such or as cheese, and figures for lard, tallow and fish oil do not include fat consumed when eating meat (beef, lamb, pork, chicken) or fish. The consumption of oils and fats varies considerably between developed, developing and under-developed countries and demand is expected to grow. This is illustrated in the figures for selected affluent and non-affluent countries/
2
Modifying lipids for use in food
regions (Table 1.1). Increasing consumption in highly populated countries such as China and India will fuel the demand for oils and fats for many years to come. Apart from low levels of minor oils described in Chapter 2, consumption is confined to fewer than 20 commodity oils. These are not always ideal for food purposes, and have to be modified for their end use. It is useful in this preliminary chapter to consider the important properties required of an oil or fat for its use in foods, and to review briefly the major modifying procedures. The latter will be detailed in chapters in Part II and the application of modified lipids in foods is covered in Part III.
1.2
What properties are desired?
An oil or fat should have the optimum physical, chemical and nutritional properties dictated by its end use. The more important of these properties are indicated below, and some of the topics will be developed in later chapters. However, these factors are not always mutually compatible and compromises have to be made. The best physical and chemical properties may be achievable only at the sacrifice of some nutritional excellence. This provides an important challenge for food technologists, and this book will show how these challenges have been met in the past, how they are being met today and how they may be met in the future. Because nutrition is a developing science new problems appear, and what is practised and accepted today may be less so in the future. This is illustrated in the present concern about fats containing unsaturated acids with trans configuration. These are produced (among other ways) by partial hydrogenation, a process developed and exploited throughout the 20th century. Only in recent years have there been nutritional concerns about such acids that are now being addressed with greater or lesser urgency.
Table 1.1 Consumption of oils and fats for food and non-food purposes in selected countries in 1990/2000 and 2004/05. World
USA
EU-25
China
India
Personal (kg/person/year) 1999/00 2004/05
18.4 21.0
49.9 49.0
43.2 50.2
13.6 19.6
11.4 11.7
Total (million tonnes/year) 1999/00 2004/05
113.4 136.4
15.7 15.5
17.1 17.4
14.7 18.0
6.6 8.0
Source: Anon (2005).
Introduction: Modifying lipids – why and how?
3
1.2.1 Physical properties The most important physical properties of oils and fats for the food industry are thermal properties associated with crystallization and melting, with the formation of solids and liquids and with the behaviour of plastic fats that are mixtures of solid and liquid components. It is mandatory, for example, that salad oils do not contain lipids that will crystallize during storage in a refrigerator. Most frying oils and oils used as food coatings (and lubricants) should also be free of solid components. Few natural oils meet this requirement and appropriate modification has to be carried out. The successful production of spreads, on the other hand, depends on having appropriate levels of solid fat at refrigerator temperature, at ambient temperature and at mouth temperature. The solid fat content at 4 °C should not exceed 30–40 % if the fat is to be spreadable from the refrigerator; at 10 °C it should be 10–20 % so that the fat will ‘stand up’ (not collapse to a puddle of oil); and at mouth temperature the spread should melt completely to avoid a waxy mouth feel. Crystalline triacylglycerols, such as those present in spreads, show polymorphism. They exist in different crystalline forms with differing thermal properties and may change – quickly or slowly – from a physically less stable to a more stable form. It is important that solid triacylglycerols in a spread are in the most appropriate form (β′) and that this will not change during storage to the more stable β-form. β′-Crystals are relatively small, can incorporate large volumes of oil (liquid) and give the product a glossy surface and a smooth lustre. β-Crystals, on the other hand, though initially small, grow into needle-like agglomerates less able to incorporate oil and producing a grainy texture. Oils comprising acids of mixed chain length (generally C16 and C18) are more likely to remain in the β′ form while those containing almost entirely C18 acids are β-tending. 1.2.2 Chemical properties Food lipids are not usually considered to require defined chemical properties, but without oxidative stability of their lipid components foods would quickly become rancid and have a short shelf life. For this reason they should be oxidatively stable. An account of the deteriorative oxidation processes and of conditions under which these changes may be inhibited is an important part of Chapter 7.
1.2.3 Nutritional properties The selection and use of oils and fats in foods is strongly influenced by a range of nutritional properties. •
The total level of fat in a food with its marked effect on calorific value is important to consumers and has led to a demand for foods with lower fat content or for the use of fat or fat substitutes with reduced calorific value.
4
Modifying lipids for use in food
•
An appropriate balance between saturated, monounsaturated and polyunsaturated acids is desirable. There are many dietary recommendations given in terms of numbers (energy %) of total fat and of these three types of acids. This makes for simple messages that can be understood by the consumer and for relatively simple labelling. It has been argued, however, that this message is too simple and can be misleading (Gurr, 1999; Taubes, 2001). Saturated acids represent a group of acids that are of concern because they raise serum cholesterol levels. They can be described as cholesterolraising. The human diet contains saturated acids with 4–24 carbon atoms of which palmitic acid (16:0) dominates. Starting with Ancel Keys in 1957 (he died in November 2004, just two months short of his 101st birthday) several equations have been produced to correlate changes in serum cholesterol levels with changes in fatty acid dietary intake. Early equations took account only of changes for total saturated acids and total polyunsaturated acids, but the most recent include information for changes in (only) three individual saturated acids (lauric, myristic and palmitic), oleic acid, trans acids from partially hydrogenated vegetable oils and from partially hydrogenated fish oils and linoleic and linolenic acids taken together (Pedersen et al., 2001). This suggests that saturated acids outwith the 12:0–16:0 range are not cholesterol-raising. Among monounsaturated acids a clear distinction must be made between cis and trans isomers with the former being cholesterol-lowering and the latter cholesterol-raising. As is apparent in later chapters, much effort is now being put into producing high quality spreads with levels of trans acids approaching zero. There is also a growing concern about the quota for polyunsaturated fatty acids. In particular, the ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 acids should be between 5 and 10 to 1 (or less) but exceeds 25 in many countries. Since the presence of α-linolenic acid leads to oxidative instability and reduced shelf life, there is a need for development of more efficient antioxidant systems. Related to this is the efficiency or otherwise of the elongation–desaturation systems required to metabolize linoleic acid and linolenic acid to their very important C20 and C22 metabolites – arachidonic, eicosapentaenoic, and docosahexaenoic acids. Are materials containing these C20 and C22 polyunsaturated fatty acids a necessary part of the human diet or will the C18 members suffice? This question is discussed further in Chapter 7.
•
•
•
1.3
Methods of modifying oils and fats
It is convenient to divide the techniques for modifying oils and fats into technological and biological groups. In the former we accept what nature provides and seek to change fatty acid and/or triacylglycerol composition,
Introduction: Modifying lipids – why and how?
5
thereby modifying nutritional, chemical (mainly oxidative stability) and physical (mainly melting behaviour) properties to make them more suitable for their end-use. In the latter, we interfere at an earlier stage and either seek new and better sources or take plants which already produce large quantities of oil efficiently and try to modify the composition of the oils by conventional methods of seed breeding or by exploiting newer methods based on increasing genetic understanding.
1.4
Technological methods
Lipid technologists have developed several methods of modifying oils and fats. None of these is very new, but they are subject to incremental improvement either based on a better scientific understanding of the process or through the development of improved equipment. The oldest method is blending. This is a simple mixing of existing oils to provide a mixture with improved qualities. Examples include: • • • •
adding a small proportion of an oil with high oxidative stability (such as sesame oil or rice bran oil) to a less stable commodity oil to enhance its stability; mixing oils to get a fatty acid composition believed to have optimum nutritional value – an increasing number of such blends are appearing in the market place (see Chapter 22 on speciality oils); blending oils prior to interesterifacation to get a product with different triacylglycerol composition; blending oils to give a product with desired properties at minimum cost (Block et al., 1997).
Fractionation is a procedure by which a commodity oil or one that has already been modified is divided into two or more fractions differing in fatty acid and triacylglycerol composition. This can be achieved without loss of material and without need for further refining. The two fractions extend the range of usage of the original oil. This technique is used mainly for palm oil but has other applications also (Chapter 10). It is not always easy to predict what happens to minor components during fractionation, and this may have unforeseen consequences for oxidative stability. Hydrogenation of an unsaturated oil gives a product of higher melting point (more suitable for spreads and cooking fats) and of enhanced oxidative stability through having less polyunsaturated fatty acid. These benefits are achieved only at some nutritional cost. The level of essential fatty acid is lowered and acids with trans configuration are produced. These modifications follow the molecular changes resulting from partial hydrogenation which include saturation of some unsaturated centres, stereomutation of unsaturated centres (conversion of cis to trans isomers), double bond migration and conversion of linoleate mainly to trans 18:1 isomers (Chapters 7 and 9).
6
Modifying lipids for use in food
Interesterification is a procedure for rearranging the fatty acids of an oil or a blend of oils so that triacylglycerol composition is changed. When an alkaline catalyst is used, fatty acids are randomly distributed in the product. This is in contrast to the natural vegetable oils produced by (enzymaticallycatalysed) biological processes where the fatty acids are not randomly distributed. These changes affect thermal behaviour and may also have nutritional consequences (Chapters 7 and 11). Interesterification can also be carried out with lipases. The enzymatic processes have several advantages in that they occur under milder conditions, may require less costly equipment and produce less by-product so that there is less waste and less effort is required to purify the product. However, the major benefit of using a lipase is the added control over the nature of the product as a consequence of the specificity shown by many lipases. Fatty acidspecific lipases relating to chain-length or double bond position can be used to confine changes to a particular group of acids, while other lipases are specific for glycerol esters (mono-, di- or triacylglycerols) or distinguish between the different glycerol ester groups. Thus many lipases are described as being 1,3specific implying that changes can be made at positions 1 and/or 3 but not at position 2 where the ester group remains unchanged (Chapters 7 and 11). Interesterified products are generally less stable than the original oils, probably through changes – not yet fully understood – in the balance of pro- and antioxidants. This holds with both chemical and enzymatic catalysts.
1.5
Biological methods
1.5.1 Domestication of wild crops The oil and fat business is based almost entirely on a limited number of commodity oils which vary in their fatty acid composition, but there are many other plant species with fatty acid composition not very different from the commodity oils. These could be used as food lipids, but there would have to be a special reason for developing them through the long chain of events from agronomical improvements to retail marketing. A few of these will be discussed in Chapter 2 under the section on minor oils. There are also plants producing uncommon acids such as epoxy acids, acids with conjugated unsaturation, or oils with a very high level (> 80 %) of a single acid. Attempts to domesticate and commercialize such plants and their seed oils have taken longer than originally thought, with some niche products of this kind taking 20 and more years to develop. Most, but not all, of these oils are of interest to the oleochemical rather than the food industry.
1.5.2 Oilseeds modified by conventional seed breeding or by genetic engineering As a consequence of the difficulties in domesticating wild plants, greater
Introduction: Modifying lipids – why and how?
7
effort has been directed to the modifying of plants that are already sown and harvested on a commercial scale and where the best agronomic procedures are well known. This has the disadvantage of minimizing the range of important plant species (limiting biodiversity). The changes to be sought are partly agronomic but, of greater interest for this book, they include changes in fatty acid composition, triacylglycerol composition and minor components. These changes should be achieved without sacrifice of yield and must be biologically stable from season to season. They have to be accompanied by procedures of identity preservation. The modified seed must be kept separate at all times from its more conventional form. This has consequences for harvesting, transporting and extracting the seed and for the subsequent handling of the oil. Such changes may be effected by conventional seed breeding or by newer procedures of genetic engineering. It is important to know which method has been used because of the concerns expressed by some about procedures involving transgenic modification. Modifications to fatty acid composition which have been sought include: reduced levels of saturated acid for nutritional reasons; reduced levels of linolenic acid and/or higher levels of saturated acids to avoid hydrogenation (with consequent formation of undesirable trans acids); and higher levels of oleic acid. These are detailed in Chapter 12. One exciting possibility is to develop plant systems that will produce long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids such as arachidonic acid, eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). There have been interesting developments in a number of research laboratories but such plants, which probably have to be genetically modified, are 10–20 years from commercial development (Chapter 12) (Drexler et al., 2003; Green, 2004; Qi et al., 2004).
1.5.3 Animal fats modified through nutritional changes From a nutritional viewpoint land animal depot fats are perceived as having several disadvantages. They are generally rich in serum cholesterol-raising saturated acids, frequently contain acids with trans unsaturation, and have high levels of cholesterol. Their level of essential fatty acids is low, and they contain little if any antioxidant. Further, animal fats are not acceptable to vegetarians and to some ethnic groups. Nevertheless animal fats contain low levels of long-chain PUFA (polyunsaturated fatty acid) and are a valuable source of such acids in the human diet. Some of the perceived disadvantages in ruminant animals are the consequence of biohydrogenation processes taking place within the rumen, and dietary regimes have been proposed to circumvent these changes. There is also an interest in modifying the fatty acid composition of chicken eggs and meat by appropriate changes to the diet of the chicken. This has been seen as a way of enhancing the (human) dietary intake of CLA (conjugated linoleic acid) and of EPA and DHA (long-chain omega-3 acids) (see Chapter 13).
8
Modifying lipids for use in food
1.5.4 Single-cell oils As indicated at the beginning of this chapter, oils and fats produced by the agricultural supply industry come mainly from plant sources and also to a minor extent from animals. An alternative approach is to seek new lipid sources from micro-organisms. Some of these can be made to produce high levels of lipids with an interesting fatty acid composition. While it is unlikely that these will replace the more conventional commodity oils for traditional use, nevertheless, they are already providing supplies of high quality longchain PUFA for infant formula and other special purposes (Chapters 5 and 23).
1.6
References
(2005), Oil World Annual 2005, Hamburg, ISTA Mielke GmbH. and GOMIDE F A C (1997), Blending process optimisation into special fat formulation by neural networks, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 74, 1537–1541. DREXLER H, SPIEKERMANN P, DOMERGUE F, ZANK T, SPERLING P, ABBADI A and HEINZ E (2003), Metabolic engineering of fatty acids for breeding of new oilseed crops: strategies, problems and first results, J Plant Physiol., 160, 779–802. GREEN A G (2004), Producing essential fatty acids in plants, Nat Biotechnol, 22, 680–682. GURR M I (1999), Lipids in Nutrition and Health – a Reappraisal, Bridgewater, Oily Press. PEDERSEN J I, MULLER H and KIRKHUS B (2001), Serum cholesterol predictive equations with special emphasis on trans and saturated fatty acids. An analysis from designed controlled studies, Lipids, 36, 783–791. QI B, FRASER T, MUGFORD S, DOBSON G, SAYANOVA O, BUTLER J, NAPIER J A, STOBART A K and LAZARUS C M (2004), Production of very long chain polyunsaturated omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids in plants, Nat Biotechnol, 22, 739–745. TAUBES G (2001), The soft science of dietary fat, Science, 291, 2536–2545. ANON
BLOCK J M, BARRERA-ARELLANO D, FIGUEIREDO M F
Part I Understanding food lipid structure and composition
2 Vegetable sources of lipids F. Gunstone, Scottish Crop Research Institute, UK
2.1
Introduction
This chapter is devoted to the most important source of lipids, namely those derived from vegetable sources. The major commodity oils are described first, covering their fatty acid and triacylglycerol composition and their minor components. This is accompanied by some indication of the ways in which each oil is modified and the major food uses. There follows a shorter account of some significant minor vegetable oils after which the procedures by which all these oils may be extracted and refined are detailed. Finally there is a brief discussion of future trends in the supply of vegetable-based lipids. Dietary lipids may be ingested as part of a food as when nuts are eaten or when green vegetables are consumed. Although these last contain only low levels of lipids, they are frequently of high nutritive quality and are accompanied by valuable minor components. All living material contains membrane lipids that are mainly phospholipids. However, larger in quantity are those oils and fats of vegetable or animal origin consumed as frying oils, salad oils, spreads, baked goods or chocolate. Over the last half-century the availability of vegetable oils has increased much more than that of animal fats. One important commodity analyst reports weekly on 17 oils and fats of which 13 are of vegetable origin and make up 80 % of total supply while four of animal origin (butter, lard, tallow and fish oil) provide the balance. It is estimated that ~ 80 % of the total supply is used for food and the remainder as animal feed (~ 6 %) or by the oleochemical industry (~ 14 %). Details of the nature of the vegetable oils are given in Section 2.2 but it is appropriate to provide some production data in order to give balance to the ensuing discussion (Table 2.1). The major oils (soybean, palm and palmkernel,
12
Modifying lipids for use in food
Table 2.1 Commodity oils and fats: production levels (million tonnes) and major producing areas in 2004/05. Oil/fat
Production
Food use (%)a
Major producing countries/regionsb
Soybean
32.57
90
Palm Rape/canola
32.50 16.11
70 75
Sunflower
9.08
95
Cottonseed
5.00
95
Groundnutc Palmkernel Coconut Olive Corn Sesame Linseed Castor Cocoa butterd Four animal fatse World total
4.50 3.80 3.01 2.73 2.05 0.77 0.60 0.52 1.20
95 70 70 95 95 95 0 0 95
USA 8.60, Br 5.74, Ch 5.11, Arg 5.03, EU-25 2.63 Mal 15.16, Indon 12.90 EU-25 5.47, Ch 4.56, Ind 2.08, Can 1.36 CIS 3.20, EU-25 1.76, Arg 1.41 Cent Eur 0.72 Ch 1.55, Ind 0.69, Pak 0.51, CIS 0.44, USA 0.42 Ch 2.05, Ind 1.13, Nig 0.32 Mal 1.83, Indon 1.31 Pp 1.27, Indon 0.74, Ind 0.40 EU-25 2.06, Syria 0.20, Tun 0.13 USA 1.10, EU-25 0.23 Ch 0.20, Ind 0.14, My 0.11 EU-25 0.15, Ch 0.13, USA 0.13 Ind 0.32, Ch 0.11 Ivory Coast, Ghana, Indon, Br, Mal
23.16 136.4
(80)
a
These values are estimates made by the author based, in part, on information provided by USDA for 2001/02 [www.fas.usda.gov/oilseeds/circular/2000/oilstats.html]. b These are not necessarily the countries in which the plants are grown. Oils may be produced from imported seeds as well as from domestic supplies. c Also called peanut oil. d Not included in Oil World publications – information added by the author. e Total of tallow (8.19), lard (7.43), butter (6.47) and fish oil (1.07). Abbreviations: Arg = Argentina, Br = Brazil, Can = Canada, Cent Eur = Central Europe, Ch = China, CIS = Commonwealth of Independent States (Former Soviet Union), Indon = Indonesia, Mal = Malaysia, My = Myanmar (Burma), Nig = Nigeria, Pak = Pakistan, Pp = Philippines, Syr = Syria, Tun = Tunisia Source: Anon (2005).
rapeseed and sunflower seed) total 94.1 million tonnes (69 % of total production) (Anon, 2005). They represent an even larger proportion of trade (imports/exports) as many of the oils produced at lower levels are consumed predominantly in the country/region where they grow. Table 2.1 shows the total production of each oil in 2004/05, an estimate of the share of each oil used for food purposes and the major countries of production of the oil from domestic and/or imported oilseeds. Gunstone (2005) has reworked these production figures and calculated the annual production (from 13 vegetable oils, cocoa butter and four animal fats) of the major fatty acids. These total figures have been adjusted for the 80 % consumed as human food and for the changes that occur during partial
Vegetable sources of lipids 13 hydrogenation. Adjustment has not been made for wasted and discarded oil nor for the lipid consumed in forms not counted by market analysts, such as fat in nuts or cheese, or consumed as meat or fish. The results suggest that production of linoleic is in excess of our dietary needs and that production of linolenic is much below the desirable level leading to an omega-6/-3 ratio of ~ 30 that is far too high (Table 2.2).
2.2
Major vegetable sources of food lipids
The major vegetable oils are pressed and/or extracted from seeds or pressed from fruits such as olive or oil palm (Section 2.4). Crude oils are mainly triacylacylglycerols (usually > 95 %) accompanied by lower levels of free acids, monoacylgycerols, diacylglycerols, phospholipids (1–3 %), free and/ or acylated sterols (1000–5000 ppm in total), tocols (300–2000 ppm) and hydrocarbons such as alkanes, squalene and carotenes. Oils from different sources differ in fatty acid and triacylglycerol composition and in the detailed composition of the various minor components. Most oils used in the food industry have been subject to refining processes to raise the triacylglycerol level and to reduce the levels of other components. Ideally, refining (Section 2.4) should remove undesirable components as efficiently as possible but leave suitable levels of the desirable minor components. In some refining procedures materials such as free acids, phospholipids, sterols and tocols are recovered as valuable by-products and find further use in the food, feed, cosmetics, pharmaceutical and oleochemical industries.
Table 2.2 Annual production (million tonnes) for seven major fatty acids in the total oils and fats produced by the agricultural industry. Column 1 relates to total production in 2004/05, column 2 to that used for human food and column 3 after adjustment for changes accompanying partial hydrogenation of soybean oil and rapeseed oil. Fatty acid
1
2
Lauric Myristic Palmitic Stearic Oleic Linoleic Linolenic Other Total n-6/n-3
3.4 2.6 27.4 7.2 47.8 37.5 4.5 6.0 136.4 8.3
2.0 1.8 21.7 5.5 38.4 31.9 3.5 3.9 108.7 9.1
*After hydrogenation this figure includes significant quantities of trans isomers. Source: Gunstone (2005).
3 2.0 1.8 21.7 5.9 48.8* 23.8 0.8 3.9 108.7 29.8
14
Modifying lipids for use in food
2.2.1 Soybean oil Soybeans provide two important materials: oil extracted from the beans and a residual meal containing high quality protein. Whole beans contain protein (40 %), carbohydrate (34 %), oil (21 %), and ash (5 %) (Wang, 2002) with the levels of oil and meal produced commercially being 18 and 79 % respectively. Soybean meal is such an important commodity for animal feed and, to a lesser extent, for human food that the oil has been described as a byproduct. However, as already indicated, soybean oil is produced at a higher level than any other oil and is better described as a co-product. The major fatty acids in soybean oil are linoleic (53 %), oleic (23 %), palmitic (11 %), linolenic (8 %) and stearic (4 %) (Wang, 2002). The widelyaccepted view is that this is a healthy oil, low in saturated acids and rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA), especially linoleic acid. However, attempts to modify this fatty acid composition by partial hydrogenation or by plant breeding suggest that it would be better to have less saturated acids and less linolenic acid. Opinion on linolenic acid is contentious. This triene acid is easily oxidized, and food products with linolenic acid have a short shelf life, which is a matter of concern for the food industry, the retailer, and the consumer. However, there is also a matter of nutritional concern. There is a growing awareness that omega-6/omega-3 ratios (Section 7.5) at levels exceeding 20:1 in some countries are far too high and that values of 5:1 or lower (Crawford, 2004) are desirable. It has been argued (Gunstone, 2005) that, compared with nutritional recommendations, the agricultural supply industry as a whole (plant and animal) provides too much linoleic acid and too little linolenic acid. According to Gunstone’s calculations the only significant commodity sources of linolenic acid for food purposes are soybean oil and rapeseed oil, and this is largely destroyed by partial hydrogenation (Table 2.2). He argues that more effort should be devoted to developing antioxidant packages that will allow the safe use of linolenic acid. Because of its high level of linoleic acid (> 50 %), over half the triacylglycerols in soybean oil contain two or three linoleic chains, and most of the remainder have one linoleic chain. In a typical analysis, triacylglycerols exceeding 4 % were LLL 17.6 %, LLO 15.3 %, LLP 10.2 %, LLLn 7.9 %, LLSt 4.2 %, PLO 6.9 %, OLO 6.3 %, LnLO 4.8 %, other 26.8 %. (These three-letter symbols stand for all the isomeric triacylglycerols containing the three acyl groups indicated, where Ln = linolenic acid, L = linoleic acid, O = oleic acid, St = stearic acid and P = palmitic acid.) Soybeans producing oil with a different fatty acid composition have been developed both through traditional seed breeding and by introduction of genes from other plant species. These important developments are discussed in Chapter 12. Crude soybean oil contains several valuable minor components that are recovered in some measure during refining. Degumming produces lecithin – a fraction rich in phospholipids which serves as the main industrial source of these materials. Deodorizer distillate contains tocopherols (vitamin E) (0.15– 0.21 % in the oil raised to ~ 11 % in the distillate) and phytosterols (~ 0.33 %
Vegetable sources of lipids 15 in the oil raised to ~ 18 % in the distillate). Both of these are valuable byproducts. For more details see Wang (2002). Soybean phospholipids (1.5–2.5 %) are removed during the degumming stage of refining. The crude lecithin obtained by this process is a mixture of triacyglycerols (35–40 %), phosphatidylcholines (10–15 %), phosphatidylethanolamines (9–12 %), phosphatidylinositols (8–10 %) and other minor components. The phospholipid content can be increased by ‘deoiling’ with acetone to remove triacylglycerols, and individual phospholipid classes can subsequently be concentrated by dissolution in ethanol. The desired amphiphilic properties of natural phospholipids can be further improved by chemical manipulation, such as partial lipolysis/hydrolysis to produce some lysolecithin or partial hydroxylation of double bonds to increase the polarity of the molecule (Chapter 15). Wang (2002) further reports that the difference between crude and refinedbleached-deodorized (RBD) oil is such that tocopherols are reduced by 36 %, sterols by 32 % and squalene by 38 %. However, the ‘lost’ materials can be trapped in the deodorizer distillate and be recovered for further use. The major sterols are β-sitosterol (125–236), campesterol (62–131) and stigmasterol (47–77) out of a total of 235–405 mg/100 g. Tocopherols in solvent-extracted soybean oil are given as 1370 ppm divided between the α (11 %), β (1 %), γ (63 %), and δ (25 %) compounds. Soybean oil in its native but refined form or in some partially hydrogenated form is widely used for food purposes such as frying and salad oils, margarine and shortening, and mayonnaise and salad dressing. It is used universally for these purposes, especially in those countries where soybeans are grown and extracted. For example, it is reported that in the USA 86 % of all food lipids are derived from soybean oil and that no other oil attains a level above 3 %.
2.2.2 Palm oil The oil palm produces two different oils – palmkernel oil (Section 2.2.5) and palm oil. The latter is extensively fractionated into palm olein and palm stearin. These differ in composition and so extend the range of uses for palm oil. The plant grows in wet tropical regions. Malaysia and Indonesia are the major producing and exporting countries (Table 2.2). Supplies of palm oil have increased rapidly in the last 20–30 years, mainly through increasing the area under cultivation. World average annual production of palm and palmkernel oils together for selected five-year periods is: 6.6 million tonnes in 1981–85 and 15.1 million tonnes in 1991–95 (Anon, 2002), and 31.0 million tonnes in 2001–05 (Anon, 2005). Though second to soybean oil in total production, palm oil exceeds it in volumes traded. Current figures for palm oil production and exports are given in Table 2.3. The average production of palm oil (3.5 tonnes/hectare) and of palmkernel oil (0.4 tonnes/hectare) makes the oil palm the most productive source of oil/
16
Modifying lipids for use in food
fat. These are average figures, and significantly higher yields are obtained from the best plantations. The fatty acid composition, triacylglycerol composition and iodine value for Malaysian palm oil and its fractions are listed in Table 2.4. Palm oil is unusual in containing about 5 % of diacylglycerols. In terms of molecular species, the major triacylglycerols in palm oil are given as POP 29 %, POO 23 %, PLO 10 %, PLP 9 % (Siew Wai Lin, 2002). Palm oil is considered as a saturated fat in comparison to the more highly unsaturated vegetable oils. With almost the same levels of saturated and unsaturated acids, the description saturated can be misleading. The oil is rich in nutritionally important minor components. Because of its fatty acid composition and its minor components which act as antioxidants, palm oil has high oxidative stability. Palm oil is not much used in North America, but it makes a significant contribution to dietary fat intake in the rest of the world. Table 2.3 Production and exports (million tonnes and percentage of world total) of palm oil and palmkernel taken together in 2004–05.
World Malaysia Indonesia Other
Production
Exports
36.30 16.99 13.91 5.40
27.44 14.57 9.93 2.94
(46.8 %) (38.3 %) (14.9 %)
(53.1 %) (36.2 %) (10.7 %)
Source: Anon (2005).
Table 2.4
Compositional data for palm oil and selected fractions.
Major fatty acids 16:0 18:0 18:1 18:2 othera
Oilc
Oleind
Stearind
Mid-fractiond
44.1 4.4 39.0 10.6 1.9
40.9 4.2 41.5 11.6 1.8
47–74 4–6 16–37 3–10
41–55 5–7 32–41 4–11
12–56 34–50 5–37 0–8 22–40
1–11 45–74 19–42 2–8 34–55
Major triacylglycerols by carbon numberb C48 8.1 3.3 39.9 39.5 C50 38.8 42.7 C52 C54 11.4 12.8 Iodine value 52.1 56.8 a
Other acids present at low levels include 12:0, 14:0, 20:0, 16:1 and 18:3. These tricacylglycerols consist mainly of 3, 2, 1, and 0 palmitic acid chains with 0, 1, 2, and 3 C18 chains respectively. c Mean of 244 Malaysian samples. d Mean of many Malaysian samples. Source: Siew Wai Lin (2002). b
Vegetable sources of lipids 17 Palm oil, palm olein and palm stearin contain 500–700, 600–760 and 380–540 ppm, respectively, of mixed carotenes (almost entirely a mixture of the β and α forms) when crude, but this is lost in RBD oils. Red palm oil, obtained by an alternative refining process, and still containing ~ 80 % of the carotenes originally present, is marketed as an oil with added nutritional value because of the carotenes which serve as pro-vitamin A. Crude palm oil is rich in tocols (600–1000 ppm), with the level of tocotrienols (~ 70 %) exceeding that of tocopherols. Refined oil still has ~ 70 % of the original tocols. Some loss occurs during deodorization, and palm oil fatty acid distillate (PFAD, equivalent to deodorizer distillate) is enriched in tocols (750–8200 ppm) and can be used as a source of tocotrienol-rich tocols. Many health claims have been put forward for these compounds. Palm oil contains sterols (200–600 ppm in crude oil) that are mainly β-sitosterol, campestrol and stigmasterol. These are present at lower levels in refined oil (70–300 ppm) and concentrate in PFAD at an average level of 6500 ppm. The acyclic C30 hydrocarbon squalene is present in crude palm oil (200–500 ppm) and concentrates in PFAD during refining (5000–8000 ppm). Palm oil is used for a wide range of food purposes including frying, in spreads and vanaspati and in shortenings. Palm olein is a major frying oil, and palm stearin finds increasing use as hard stock in fat blends which are interesterified to produce spreads with no hydrogenated oil and therefore containing little or no trans acids. The presence of palm oil or palm stearin in a spread helps to stabilize the β′-crystal form because of the mixed C16 and C18 chains. 2.2.3 Rapeseed/canola oil Rapeseed production is second only to soybeans, and rapeseed/canola oil is third after soybean and palm. Production levels have grown steadily in recent years and peaked in 1999/2000 at 14.5 million tonnes. Thereafter production declined somewhat through reduced planting and/or poor weather that reduced yield. After falling to 12.3 million tonnes in 2002/03 production is now rising steadily with figures of 14.4 and 16.1 million tonnes for 2003/04 and 2004/05, respectively (Anon, 2005). Rapeseed and canola are terms describing the seed and extracted oil from Brassica species including B. napus (formerly B. campestris), B. rapa and B. juncea. The seed oil from these species was typically rich in erucic acid (22:1), and the seed meal had an undesirably high level of glucosinolates. These components reduced the value of both the oil and the protein meal, but they have been bred out of the modern rapeseed, now known as double zero or canola. It is grown mainly in Western Europe, China, India and Canada (where the canola varieties were developed). Typically it contains palmitic (4 %), stearic (2 %), oleic (62 %), linoleic (22 %) and linolenic (10 %) acids and has less saturated acids than any other commodity oil. In one example its major triacylglycerols were LnLO (8 %), LLO (9 %), LnOO (10 %), LOO
18
Modifying lipids for use in food
(22 %), LOP (6 %), OOO (22 %) and POO (5 %) (Przybylski and Mag, 2002). With its low level of saturated acids, its high level of oleic acid and the presence of linoleic and linolenic acids at a favourable ratio (~ 2:1) rapeseed oil rates highly in the classification of healthy oils. Also, the plant system lends itself to genetic modification, and rapeseed varieties with modified fatty acid composition have been developed, although it is still not clear how many of these will be economically viable. Rapeseed oils with less linolenic acid, or enhanced levels of lauric acid, stearic acid, oleic acid, or with unusual acids such as γ-linolenic acid, ricinoleic acid or vernolic acid have all been developed for commercial exploitation. Oleic-rich varieties have about 84 % oleic acid. For more details see Przyblski and Mag (2002), Gunstone (2004b) and Chapter 12. Rapeseed oil contains ~ 3 % of phospholipid which is removed during degumming. Rapeseed oils contain sterols and sterol ester together at levels between 0.45 and 1.13 %. These are mainly β-sitosterol (47–52 % of total sterols) and campesterol (28–34 %). All brassica seeds are characterized by the presence of brassicasterol (12–16 %), a sterol virtually absent from other seed oils. Tocopherols occur in rapeseed oils at levels of 430–2680 mg/kg oil with the γ- (60–74 % of total tocols) and α-compounds (26–35 %) predominating. Brassica oils, particularly those grown during short seasons in Canada and Scandinavia, frequently contain chlorophyll (and related compounds) at levels up to 50 ppm, although RBD oil usually has a chlorophyll (and derivatives) specification of less than 25 parts per billion. High-erucic rapeseed is still grown with the high-erucic oil being used for a range of industrial purposes and particularly for the preparation of erucamide used in ‘clingfilm’ (Temple-Heald, 2004). Rapeseed oil is generally accepted as a healthy oil by virtue of its fatty acid composition, and is widely used for food purposes, sometimes after brush hydrogenation to reduce the level of linolenic acid and sometimes after partial hydrogenation in spreads. The oil is used as a salad oil and salad dressing and mayonnaise, in margarine and other spreads, as a frying oil, and in many minor food applications. The oil is widely used, particularly in China, EU-15 and India – all countries where the plants are grown extensively. Canada and Australia are major exporting countries of seed and/or oil. Both these countries have modest populations and therefore limited local demand.
2.2.4 Sunflower seed oil Oil obtained from sunflower seeds (Helianthus annuus) occupies the fourth position in the ranking of vegetable oils by production levels (Table 2.1). It became popular as the major lipid constituent of many margarines when animal fats were first replaced by linoleic-rich vegetable oils, but in recent years it has had to compete with increasing use of soybean oil.
Vegetable sources of lipids 19 Sunflower oil is available in three ranges of fatty acid composition. The traditional and still major sunflower oil is linoleic-rich, but two other forms have been produced by conventional seed breeding; these are a high oleic oil and a mid-oleic oil. The latter (NuSun™ oil – National Sunflower Association, USA) is much favoured in the USA where attempts are being made to replace the traditional oil. The fatty acid composition of these sunflower types is given in Table 2.5. Their oxidative stability increases as the ratio of oleic to linoleic acid increases. The major triacylglycerols of the traditional linoleicrich oil are typically LLL (14 %), LLO (39 %), LLS (14 %), LOO (19 %), LOS (11 %) and other (3 %) (S = saturated) (Gunstone, 2004a). Crude sunflower oil contains phospholipids (0.7–0.9 %), tocopherols (630– 700 ppm), sterols (~ 0.3 %) and carotenoids (1.1–1.6 ppm). The phospholipids removed during refining are mainly phosphatidylcholines (55–64 % of total phospholipids), with lower levels of phosphatidylinositols (15–24 %) and phosphatidylethanolamines (17–20 %). The tocols are almost entirely αtocopherol which makes sunflower seeds and the extracted oil good sources of vitamin E. The seeds are also a rich source of selenium compared to most other seeds and nuts. Sunflower seed oil contains some wax (esters of longchain alcohols and long-chain acids) coming from an outer protective seed coat. This makes the oil appear cloudy on standing and is usually removed by winterization if the oil is to be used as a salad oil. This is achieved by filtering oil that has been held at 7–8 °C for 12–24 hours. 2.2.5 Lauric oils (coconut, palmkernel) Coconut oil and palmkernel oil are similar to one another in their fatty acid composition and differ so much from other commodity oils that they can be considered together. Both have high levels of medium-chain saturated acids, especially lauric acid (12:0), hence the term lauric oils. As a consequence they have only low levels of unsaturated C18 acids and low iodine values. They are used extensively both as food and as non-food oils and serve as the major source of C8 (caprylic or octanoic) acid and C10 (capric or decanoic) acid. These short-chain acids are concentrated by distillation of the hydrolyzed oils. The production of coconut oil has generally exceeded that of palmkernel Table 2.5
Typical fatty acid composition of sunflower oils.
Saturated Oleic Linoleic Linolenic Iodine value (approx) Source: Gupta (2002).
Traditional
Mid-oleic
High oleic
11–13 20–30 60–70 <1 128
< 10 55–75 15–35 <1 108
9–10 80–90 5–9 <1 79
20
Modifying lipids for use in food
oil, but the latter has increased along with the production of palm oil. It now exceeds that of coconut oil and is likely to continue to do so. Details of fatty acid and triacylglycerol composition are presented in Table 2.6. The two lauric oils differ in that coconut oil contains slightly higher proportions of the C8 and C10 acids while palmkernel oil has higher levels of oleic acid. As a consequence, palmkernel oil has the higher iodine value (Codex range of 14–21 for palmkernel oil and 6–10 for coconut oil) and accordingly will show the greater change on hydrogenation. Coconut oil is the preferred source of octanoic and decanoic acids. These differences in fatty acid composition are reflected in triacylglycerol composition. As expected of such saturated oils, the content of tocopherols in the crude oils is low (coconut: a range 0–44 and mean of 10 mg/kg of oil, palmkernel: a range of 0–257 and a mean of 34 mg/kg of oil). Sterols are around 1000 ppm in both oils. Both oils may be subject to fractionation, hydrogenation and interesterification (often in a blend with a conventional C16/18 oil) to extend their range of use. The two oils have been reviewed by Pantzaris and Yusof Basiron (2002).
2.2.6 Other vegetable food oils (groundnut, cottonseed, corn, olive, sesame, rice bran, linseed) Sections 2.2.1 to 2.2.5 have covered the four dominant vegetable oils and the two lauric oils. There remain a number of other oils produced and traded at lower levels (see Table 2.1). Their fatty acid compositions are detailed in Table 2.7. Linseed differs from the others in its high level of linolenic acid. Table 2.6
Fatty acid and triacylglycerol composition of coconut and palmkernel oils.
Fatty acid compositiona
8:0 10:0 12:0 14:0 16:0 18:0 18:1 18:2
a
Triacylglycerol composition by carbon number
Coconut
Palmkernel
7.3 6.6 47.8 18.1 8.9 2.7 6.4 1.6
3.3 3.5 47.8 16.3 8.5 2.4 15.4 2.4
Trace fatty acids include 6:0 and 20:0. Source: Pantzaris and Basiron (2002).
C30 C32 C34 C36 C38 C40 C42 C44 C46 C48 C50 C52 C54
Coconut
Palmkernel
3.5 13.4 17.1 19.1 16.5 10.2 7.3 4.1 2.5 2.1 1.5 1.2 0.8
1.4 6.5 8.5 21.6 16.4 9.8 9.1 6.6 5.4 6.1 2.6 2.7 2.7
Vegetable sources of lipids 21 All the other oils are rich in oleic and/or linoleic acid. Cottonseed and rice bran oils have higher levels of palmitic acid than is usual in vegetable oils. Linseed is used mainly as an industrial oil. Its use as a food oil is discussed as a minor oil in Section 2.3. Groundnut (peanut), cottonseed and corn oils are used for the usual range of foods (frying, baking, salad oils, etc.) and may be partially hydrogenated, fractionated or interesterified to improve their properties for these purposes. Olive, sesame and rice bran oils are more usually used without modification as liquid oils. Sesame and rice bran oils are marked by high oxidative stability and are sometimes added to other oils or oil blends to enhance this property. In addition to the tocol mixtures found generally in vegetable oils, these two oils and also olive oil contain other types of powerful antioxidants. Sesame oil contains sesamin, sesamolin, and related lignans, rice bran oil has several oryzanols (sterol esters of ferulic acid) and olive oil is rich in a range of polyphenols. Further details for cottonseed, groundnut (peanut), olive, corn and sesame oils sare available in appropriate chapters of a recent book on vegetable oils (Gunstone, 2002).
2.2.7 Cocoa butter Cocoa butter is not generally cited by market analysts covering the usual range of oils and fats, perhaps because it has virtually only one use – the production of chocolate and related confectionery. A small amount is used in the cosmetics industry. Annual production is about 3 million tonnes of beans providing about 0.7 million tonnes of cocoa butter (Timms, 2003). The cocoa bean (Theobroma cacao) is the source of two important ingredients of chocolate: cocoa powder and a solid fat called cocoa butter. The usefulness of cocoa butter for this purpose is related to its fatty acid and triacylglycerol composition. It consists mainly of palmitic (26 %), stearic (34 %) and oleic acids (35 %). The major triacylglycerols are symmetrical disaturated oleic glycerol esters of the type SOS and include POP (18–23 %), POSt (36–41 %) and StOSt (23–31 %). This mixture shows characteristic Table 2.7
Groundnuta Cottonseed Corn Olive Sesame Rice bran Linseed a
Fatty acid composition of selected vegetable oils (typical values). 16:0
18:0
18:1
18:2
18:3
11 23 13 10 9 20 6
2 2 3 2 6 2 5
52 17 31 78 41 42 17
29 56 52 7 43 32 14
– tr 1 1 tr 1 60
Also known as peanut – this oil also contains C20 – C24 acids at a combined level of 6 %. tr (trace): levels < 0.6 %. Source: Gunstone (2004a).
22
Modifying lipids for use in food
melting behaviour with a sharp melting point just below mouth temperature. Cocoa butter generally commands a premium price and cheaper alternatives have been developed (see Section 2.3.2) These may or may not have similar chemical composition to cocoa butter, but they must display similar melting behaviour (Timms, 2003).
2.3
Minor vegetable sources of food lipids
In addition to the commodity vegetable oils detailed in Section 2.2, there are many minor seed oils which find a use in niche markets. Some used for food purposes are selected for discussion here, but those used industrially will not be covered. Many are found in the ‘health’ market and may be pressed oils rather than solvent-extracted. Some are not refined (beyond filtering) and others are refined only by the mildest possible procedures so as not to modify any of the fatty acids and to retain the greater part of the nutritionally important minor components, especially the antioxidants. Such oils are generally not modified by the procedures discussed in this book but are used in their native state as salad oils or for shallow frying. Some, for which health claims are made, are supplied as supplements in encapsulated form. 2.3.1 Oils containing γ-linolenic acid and/or stearidonic acid γ-Linolenic acid (∆-6,9,12-18:3) and stearidonic acid (∆-6,9,12,15-18:4) are metabolic intermediates in the conversion by animals of dietary linoleic acid to arachidonic acid and of dietary α-linolenic acid to eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and dodosahexaenoic acid (DHA) (Section 7.5). They occur only rarely among vegetable oils. It is thought to be beneficial to include γlinolenic acid and stearidonic acid in the diet in situations where ∆-6-desaturase is not operating effectively. This is usually achieved by supplying appropriate oils in capsule form. The oils most used for this purpose are borage seed oil, evening primrose seed oil and blackcurrant seed oil for γ-linolenic acid and echium oil for stearidonic acid. The fatty acid compositions of these oils are given in Table 2.8.
2.3.2 Cocoa butter alternatives Because of the high cost of cocoa butter, other tropical fats with similar physical properties are sometimes used as alternatives. There are strict rules (legal rather than technical) about what changes can be made if the product is still to be called chocolate (Chapter 20). Chocolate-like products that do not meet the full specifications for chocolate are described as confectionery. According to a recent EU directive, chocolate may contain up to a limited amount of palm mid-fraction or of one or more of five tropical oils. These have the compositions indicated in Table 2.9. This illustrates their resemblance
Vegetable sources of lipids 23 Table 2.8 Component acids of oils containing γ-linolenic acid (γ-18:3) and stearidonic acid (18:4) (typical results, % wt).
Evening primrose Borage Blackcurrant Echium plantagineum
16:0
18:0
18:1
18:2
γ-18:3
18:4
Other
6 10 7 6
2 4 2 3
9 16 11 14
72 38 47 13
10 23 17 12
tr tr 3 17
1 9a 13b 35c
a
Including 20:1 (4.5), 22:1 (2.5), and 24:1 (1.5). Including α-18:3 (13). Including α-18:3 (33). tr (trace): levels 0.6/%. Copied with permission from Gunstone F D, The Chemistry of Oils and Fats, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing (2004), 14. b c
Table 2.9 Typical values for major triaylglycerols in tropical fats used as partial replacements for cocoa butter. Common name
Cocoa butter Palm mid-fraction Borneo tallow (Illipe) Kokum butter Mango kernel stearin Sal stearin Shea stearin
Botanical name
Theobroma cacao Elaies guinensis Shorea stenoptera Garcinia indica Mangifer indica Shorea robusta Butyrospermim parkii
Major triacylglycerols (%) POP
POSt
StOSt
16 57 6 1 2 1 1
38 11 37 5 13 10 7
23 2 49 76 55 57 71
Abbreviations: O = oleic acid, P = palmitic acid, St = stearic acid. Copied with permission from Gunstone F D, The Chemistry of Oils and Fats, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing (2004), 13.
to cocoa butter in that they are all rich in SOS triacylglycerols, although the proportion of palmitic and stearic esters varies (Stewart and Kristott, 2004).
2.3.3 Other minor oils The fatty acid compositions of a selection of minor seed oils are listed in Table 2.10. As is common in seed oils, the major fatty acids are palmitic, oleic and linoleic sometimes accompanied by linolenic. They attract interest because of their convenient availability as a by-product of some other material or process or because they contain a high level of oleic acid (almond, avocado, hazelnut, macadamia, safflower), linoleic (hemp, passionfruit, pumpkin, high oleic safflower, wheatgerm, linola/solin) or linolenic acid (camelina, hemp, perilla), or because they contain other acids of interest. In many cases their value is enhanced by the minor components that are also present, such as
24
Modifying lipids for use in food
Table 2.10
Typical fatty acid composition of selected minor oils. 16:0
Almond (Prunus dulcis) Avocado (Persea americana) Camelina (Camelina sativa) Hazelnut (Corylus avellana) Hemp (Cannabis sativa) Macadamia (Macadamia integrifolia) Nigella sativa (also called black cumin) Passionfruit (Passiflora edulis) Perilla (Perilla frutescens) Pumpkin (Cucurbita pepo) Safflower (Carthamus tinctorius) Wheatgerm (Triticum aestivum)
18:1
10–20 4–9 10
65–70 60–70 10–20 65–75 8–15 35 8–12 13–15 21–47 14 60
4–14
18:2 10–15 16–24 16–23 53–60 55–65 45 13–20 14–18 35–59 75
18:3
Other
30–40
a
15–25
b c
65–75 57–64 35–59 5
d
a
C20 acids (mainly 20:1) 15–23. γ-18:3 0–5, 18:4 0–5. 16:1 16–23, 20:1 1–3. d Saturated 10, also a variety containing ~ 74 % of oleic acid. Source: adapted from Gunstone (2006) b c
Table 2.11 Fatty acid composition (% wt mean of 21 samples) of seed oil and berry oil from sea buckthorn.
Seed oil Berry oil
16:0
9–16:1
18:0
9–18:1
11–18:1
18:2
18:3
7.7 23.1
– 23.0
2.5 1.4
18.5 17.8
2.3 7.0
39.7 17.4
29.3 10.4
Source: Yang et al. (2003).
Table 2.12
Fatty acid composition of linseed oil and of linola.
Linseed Linola Solin High palmitic High oleic
Saturated
18:1
18:2
18:3
10 10 10 31 19
16 16 14 11 49
24 72 73 7 22
50 2 2 44 9
Source: Adapted from information given by Oomah and Mazza (1998).
tocopherols (vitamin E) or carotene. Sea buckthorn yields different oils from the berry and the seed, although these are not usually kept separate (Table 2.11). The oil is a rich source of palmitoleic acid (16:1) and of carotenoids (up to 1 % w/w of oil), tocopherols (0.3–0.5 %) and phytosterols (2–3 %) (Yang et al., 2003). Linseed has been modified to give a linoleic-rich oil (Table 2.12).
Vegetable sources of lipids 25
2.4
Extraction and uses
The commodity oils are generally extracted by pressing, by solvent extraction, or by both of these processes. Pressing produces a ‘virgin’ oil which may only need to be filtered. Further refining may not be necessary or is only carried out under very mild conditions. Pressed oils are perceived as being premium products. Pressing is appropriate for endosperm oils (palm, olive, avocado). Oil-rich seeds may also yield oil by pressing, but this is less efficient as an extraction process than solvent extraction and oil is left in the pressed cake. This is particularly true for soybeans and for cottonseeds which contain only low levels of oil (18 and 15 %, respectively). The residual cake may be fed to animals as a high-energy (expensive) product or may subsequently be extracted with solvent to give a second batch of oil. These batches may be kept separate and sold in two grades, but more usually they are combined and refined together. There are technological reasons why it is sometimes more efficient to carry out the extraction in two stages of pressing followed by solvent extraction. Refining occurs in several stages and is designed to make the crude oil more appropriate for its end use. The objective is to combine the removal of undesirable components such as free acids, phospholipids, oxidized material, coloured materials, metals and undesirable flavours with the retention of desirable minor components such as antioxidants. Several refining steps are combined in processes described as chemical refining and physical refining. The latter has several advantages but is not appropriate for oils rich in phospholipids (like soybean oil) nor for cottonseed oil containing gossypol that is not removed by physical refining. Both refining sequences furnish side streams containing valuable by-products which are recovered for use elsewhere. Chemical refining requires four major steps. Degumming involves reaction with water, dilute phosphoric acid or citric acid to remove phospholipids and trace metals. The former are powerful emulsifying agents that increase refining losses. Neutralization with sodium hydroxide solution or other alkali then removes free acids (and phospholipids, pigments, trace metals and sulphur compounds), and this is followed by water washing to remove soap. Bleaching is the most expensive refining step because of lost oil and the cost of obtaining and disposing of bleaching earth. Oil is heated with bentonite or other bleaching earth at 80–180 °C to remove coloured impurities. Finally, deodorization requires treatment with steam at reduced pressure to remove volatile oxidation products responsible for undesirable flavour and odour. During this process, the oil may be heated at temperatures up to 250 °C which may cause stereomutation of polyunsaturated fatty acids – especially linolenic – to trans isomers. It is desirable, therefore, not to exceed 220 °C and to compensate for this by further reducing the pressure. In physical refining, applied to oils with low phospholipid levels, there are only two steps – bleaching and deodorization – with the latter removing free acids, mono- and di-acylglycerols, oxidation products and pesticides.
26
Modifying lipids for use in food
This is now the usual way of refining palm oil and increasingly other oils also. It has environmental advantages, not least because it avoids the large aqueous waste stream characteristic of chemical neutralization that raises disposal problems. In order to preserve the oil from oxidative rancidity during transport and storage it may be necessary to add some antioxidant at an appropriate stage in the refining sequence (see Chapter 7). A fuller account of extraction and processing has been provided by Hamm and Hamilton (2000). The commodity oils, usually in the form of RBD oils and after appropriate modification, are ready for a wide range of food uses. These include frying oils, cooking oils, baking fats, shortenings, salad oils, mayonnaise, salad dressings, spreads, confectionery goods, ice creams and other minor uses. Most of these are described in Part III of this book.
2.5
Future trends
Future trends are likely to be related to changing ideas of the nutritional role of fats – which fatty acids need to be limited in consumption and which should be increased? There is general acceptance of the link between diet and health/disease and it is known that fat plays an important role in this link. There are many factors – dietary and otherwise – which have to be considered, but this book is concerned only with fats and not with other important factors such as smoking and exercise levels. In the media, fat has a bad image and this has to be countered. We need to emphasize the essential role of fat in our diet and, through collaboration with the food industry, provide foods containing fat in the appropriate quantity and of the optimum quality. To achieve these aims, there will be developments in both the technological and biological methods outlined in Chapter 1 and developed in Part II of this book. As discussed elsewhere, we need to change the omega6/omega-3 ratio in favour of the latter and, at the same time, to improve our antioxidant systems (see Chapter 7). Much of what is written about fat is written from the viewpoint of the affluent, over-fed, under-exercised members of the developed world. It must not be forgotten that there are many in the under-developed world as well as elsewhere who suffer from lack of calories. This need is best met by fat and, for many years to come, there will be a growing demand for fats of all kinds to feed the millions who are still hungry. Agronomists must, therefore, continue the search for increased yields.
2.6
Sources of further information and advice
Information on vegetable oils is available in several books included in the
Vegetable sources of lipids 27 reference list. Data on production of commodity oils is available from Oil World (www.oilworld.biz) and from USDA (www.fas.usda.gov/oilseeds). Websites for most of the commodity oils are listed in Gunstone (2002). Other useful websites include: www.lipidlibrary.co.uk, www.cyberlipid.org and www.bagkf.de/sofa.
2.7
References
(2002), The Revised Oil World 2020, Hamburg, ISTA Mielke GmbH. (2005), Oil World Annual 2005, Hamburg, ISTA Mielke GmbH. CRAWFORD M A (2004), Docosahexaenoic acid and the evolution of the brain – a message for the future, Lipid Technol, 16, 53–57. GUNSTONE F D (2002), Vegetable Oils in Food Technology, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing. GUNSTONE F D (2004a), The Chemistry of Oils and Fats, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing. GUNSTONE F D (2004b), Rapeseed and Canola Oil, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing. GUNSTONE F D (2005), Fatty acid production for human consumption, INFORM, 16, 736– 737. GUNSTONE F D (2006), ‘Minor Specialty Oils, in Shahidi F, Nutraceutical and Speciality Lipids and Their Co-products/New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 91–125. GUPTA M K (2002), Sunflower oil, in Gunstone F D, Vegetable Oils in Food Technology, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing, 128–156. HAMM W and HAMILTON R J (2000), Edible Oil Processing, Sheffield, Sheffield Academic Press. OOMAH B D and MAZZA G (1998), Flaxseed products for disease prevention, in Mazza G, Functional Foods – Biochemical and Processing Aspects, Lancaster, PA, Technomic, 91–138. PANTZARIS T P and BASIRON Y (2002), The lauric (coconut and palmkernel) oils, in Gunstone F D, Vegetable Oils in Food Technology, England, Blackwell Publishing, 157–202. PRZYBYLSKI R and MAG T (2002), Canola/rapeseed oil, in Gunstone F D, Vegetable Oils in Food Technology, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing, 98–127. SIEW WAI LIN (2002), Palm oil, in Gunstone F D, Vegetable Oils in Food Technology, England, Blackwell Publishing, 59–97. STEWART I and KRISTOTT J (2004), European Union Chocolate Directive defines vegetable fats for chocolate, Lipid Technology, 16 11–14. TEMPLE-HEALD C (2004), High-erucic oil: its production and uses, in Gunstone F D, Rapeseed and Canola Oil, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing, 111–130. TIMMS R E (2003) Confectionery Fats Handbook, Bridgewater, Oily Press. WANG T (2002), Soybean oil, in Gunstone F D, Vegetable Oils in Food Technology, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing, 18–58. YANG B, GUNSTONE F D and KALLIO H (2003), Oils containing oleic, palmitoleic, γ-linolenic and stearidonic acids, in Gunstone F D, Lipids for Functional Foods and Nutraceuticals, Bridgewater, Oily Press, 263–290. ANON ANON
3 Lipids from land animals M. R. L. Scheeder, ETH Zurich, Switzerland
3.1
Introduction
There are two major sources of land animal derived lipids used for human nutrition: the lipids in animal body tissues, commonly referred to as animal fats or meat fats, and the milk lipids. Eggs contribute to the supply with very long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids but only a little to total fat intake. The origin and means of obtaining lipids from body tissues and milk, as well as their composition and characteristics, differ in principle. On the other hand, there are common basic endogenous mechanisms and external, mainly dietary, influences which affect animal lipids in a similar way. Furthermore, due to their common animal origin, animal lipids often share a similar public perception and image. This image and the role of land animal derived lipids in human nutrition seems somewhat paradoxical. In a historical context, meat fats and, later on, milk lipids were for long the only readily available and highly appreciated source of fats that was available in substantial amounts for human nutrition. With changes in lifestyle and consumer preferences, arising from health-related concerns about saturated fats and cholesterol on one side, and advances in the technology for obtaining and processing plant oils on the other side, the image of animal lipids changed dramatically, and the food industry is currently endeavouring to replace animal lipids in their products. Animal lipids, nevertheless, possess some desirable, and even beneficial, characteristics. Therefore, it still seems worth while to give an overview on production, characteristics, and use of animal lipids in order to provide some background for assessing potential trends in the use of animal lipids in food.
Lipids from land animals 29
3.2
Animal fats
3.2.1 Historical considerations Adipose tissue of animals has probably been used as food since the dawn of mankind. Meat already made up a big portion in the diets of early hominids (Sponheimer and Lee-Thorp, 2003; Plummer, 2004) and there is strong evidence that foods of animal source, obtained by scavenging or hunting, providing a dense packet of energy and functional nutrients, in the long run promoted human evolution. It is interesting to speculate that with the use of stone tools to crack bones and skulls of mammal carcasses left by larger predators from their kill, early hominids gained access not only to nutritious bone marrow but were also provided with the physiologically functional fatty acids arachidonic (ARA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), which are practically absent from terrestrial plants, but which are the predominant polyunsaturated fatty acids and indispensable building blocks in the brain. An increased consumption of animal derived foods and the resulting improved dietary quality obviously supported the evolutionary development of a large brain (Cordain et al., 2001). Meat made and makes up a major part of hunter-gatherer diets (Cordain et al., 2000), and in these societies the choicest parts of the animals are the fatty tissues (Stefansson, 1945). It has been observed that, particularly under conditions of scarcity, hunter-gatherers may refuse to eat certain parts or even whole animals when they are too lean. This seemingly irrational practice can be explained by the fact that living on a lean meat diet only will actually lead to starvation (Harris, 1985). Stefansson vividly described this phenomenon observed under arctic conditions as ‘rabbit starvation’: when transferred from a diet normally rich in fat to one consisting wholly of rabbit, which contains very little fat, signs of starvation and protein poisoning will appear after a few days and, if no additional fat can be provided, diarrhoea will start and death will occur within weeks (Stefansson, 1945). The human hunger for meat, therefore, can actually be interpreted as hunger for meat fat (Harris, 1985), and it may be assumed that producing fat animals to gain animal fat was originally a major goal of planned livestock production. However, with ongoing industrialization (also in agriculture and animal production) and the already mentioned concomitant changes in affluent societies, the image of animal fats turned from a highly appreciated foodstuff to a by-product of the livestock industry. The technical term ‘animal fats’ or ‘meat fats’ actually refers to fat obtained from adipose tissues of land animals by a process called rendering (Love, 1996). At one time, animal fats also served purposes other than food, e.g. as fuels for torches (and later candles), cosmetics, and even as early oleochemicals for lubricants and soaps (Dugan, 1987). The Celts are known to have manufactured soap from boiling animal fats and ashes, and they probably transmitted their knowledge of fat processing to the Romans (Tufft, 1996). The variety of uses of rendered animal fats grew into manifold areas, and an
30
Modifying lipids for use in food
impressive list of non-food uses of animal fats or fatty acids produced therefrom is given by Dugan (1987). The major edible animal fats are tallow, derived from ruminant species (mainly cattle but also sheep and goat), lard, which is derived from pigs, and poultry fat, derived from poultry offal. More detailed descriptions of named animal fats are given in the Codex Alimentarius Standard 211–9 (FAO/ WHO, 1999). It has to be mentioned that ‘edible’ in this context means fit for human consumption since ‘inedible’ grades still are used as feed for animals.
3.2.2 Sources of animal fats Anatomical sites of fat depots In contrast to plants, fat is found throughout all tissues in animal organisms, although there are specific sites were fat is preferentially stored as so-called depots when meat animals are continuously fed above energy maintenance levels. Fat is typically deposited in the abdominal cavity, particularly around the kidneys and the stomach (internal fat), peripheral under the skin (subcutaneous adipose tissue), between muscles and between muscles and bones (intermuscular fat) and within skeletal muscles (intramuscular fat). In the muscle, lipids are also present as intracellular lipid droplets (particularly in red fibres) and in the form of phospholipids as important components of cell membranes (Wood, 1990). The fatty tissues obtained in the course of ‘dressing’, the part of the slaughter process in which the animal is separated into carcass, offal, and byproducts, are mainly the internal fats from the abdominal cavity. These fats are called slaughter fats, killing-floor fats, or killing fats. Adipose tissue obtained later during the butchering process, when the chilled carcasses are divided into prime cuts and the meat is further being prepared for final consumption, is subcutaneous and intermuscular fat. These are called butcher fats, cutting-floor fats, or simply cutting fats. The intramuscular fat is perceived as marbling when a fat level of about 2 % is exceeded. The degree of marbling is still a major element of the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) beef grading scheme with higher quality grades demanding higher marbling scores, although a direct and relevant cause and effect relation with sensory beef quality traits like tenderness is to be questioned (Savell et al., 1987) and the amount necessary to ensure a good eating quality is often over-estimated (Kempster, 1990). The intramuscular fat, however, is the only fat eaten in carefully trimmed lean-only cuts, and its dietetic value and contribution to the supply of specific fatty acids will be discussed later in Chapter 15. Beside these major sources of edible animal fats, animal lipids can be obtained from bones and rind (e.g. from gelatine production). Bone stock may contain 10–15 % fat (Williams and Hron, Sr, 1996), while bone marrow itself is reported to be the fatty tissue with the highest fat content (about
Lipids from land animals 31 97 %) in its dry matter (Foures, 1996). It is not only a rich but obviously also a tasty source of energy. Stefansson (1945) pleasantly described that Inuit, although they are very fond of their dogs, keep the best parts of hunted animals for human use and he states: ‘one thing dogs never get is the marrow bones’. Under industrial conditions, however, bone fats are rarely extracted and refined for use in food for human consumption, but, ironically, used as feeding-stuff for enhancing the palatability of pet foods (Foures, 1996). Another specific product extracted from bones is neat’s-foot oil, which is used as preferred leather dressing and fine lubricant. Bone marrow is harder the farther it is from the hoof. Toward the toes it is a liquid oil (Stefansson, 1945), because of the high proportion of monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFA), which have melting temperatures below 20 °C. In the bovine digital cushion (specific anatomical structures, which serve as shock absorbers) in the claws, MUFA levels as high as 82 % were found (Raeber et al., 2005). Proportion of adipose tissue and fat in the carcasses The amount of fat in the whole body or carcass depends on genetic factors like species, sex, breed, or even progeny group (i.e. genotype), as well as age and, of course, nutrition. At birth, most animals have only little fat but, when well nourished, body composition will markedly change towards a higher fat content with increasing age and weight. Fat accretion particularly increases in later stages of advancing age. When compared at a comparable physiological age and level of nutrition, females (heifers) are fatter than castrated males (steers), which are fatter than intact males (bulls) in cattle while the order in hogs is castrated male (barrow), female (gilt), male (boar) and in poultry female, male. Species also differ considerably in the distribution of fat deposits. Summarized data from various studies show that in young bulls of about 550 kg live weight internal fat makes up 25–30 % of total fat, subcutaneous fat 15–20 %, intermuscular fat 50–55 %, and intramuscular fat 2–3 %. For barrows of 100 kg live weight the respective figures are 5, 70–75, 20, and 1–2 % (Goutefongea and Dumont, 1990), which means that the major fat depot in pigs is subcutaneous fat while in cattle it is internal fat. The partition of fat, however, does not differ much between sexes, although it is reported that females have slightly more subcutaneous and less intermuscular fat than males (Fisher, 1990). Breeds, in contrast, can differ largely in fat partition. Traditional British beef breeds, for example, have relatively high proportions of subcutaneous and are low in internal fat compared with typical dairy breeds (Fisher, 1990). Selection for animals able to withstand feed shortage during wintertime by using fat depots in the case of traditional British beef breeds on the one hand and the necessity of getting rid of the heat produced by high metabolic rates, demanding a thin subcutaneous fat layer in dairy cattle, on the other may explain these differences. Similarly it has been reported that under influence of high ambient temperatures, subcutaneous fat depots will be diminished in favour of internal fats in pigs (Lefaucheur et al., 1991).
32
Modifying lipids for use in food
Considerable differences in total amount of fat deposits exist between breeds. The 179 German Landrace boars tested in Germany in 2003, for example, showed an average backfat thickness of 12.1 mm at 120 kg live weight, while 2207 Piétrain boars tested under the same conditions averaged 5.9 mm only (Gatzka, 2004). Young bulls of the Limousin breed, a typical continental beef breed, have been reported to contain about 12 % fat in the carcass while Herefords, a typical British beef breed, have on average 20.9 % fat in the carcass (Goutefongea and Dumont, 1990). For young cows (< 5 years) of the same breeds the values were 16.9 and 26.5, respectively. However, a major impact on the amount of fat in meat animals has been exerted by consumer demand for lean meat and the efforts undertaken by animal breeders to meet this demand. The lean-to-fat ratio in meat animals steadily decreased due to successful breeding for leaner carcasses during the last decades. According to reports of the Swiss pig performance testing station (SUISAG), the proportion of dissectible subcutaneous fat in the animals tested decreased from about 17.5 % in 1978 to about 12 % in 2003. It seems worth mentioning that the intramuscular fat (IMF) content had been introduced in the breeding index (because of its assumed positive effect on eating quality) and Swiss pig breeding stock has been selected also for IMF since 1987. From then on IMF increased from about 0.9 % to 2 % in 2003 (Schwörer, 2004). The genetic correlation between the amount of subcutaneous fat and intramuscular fat, therefore, must not be as narrow as one might expect. On the other hand, a linear relation between dissectible carcass fat and lipids in the lean have been reported by Kempster (1986, cited by Wood, 1990) with an increase of 4 % or 6 % dissectible fat for 1 % more lipids in lean beef or pork, respectively. Increasing the IMF content by increasing the feed intensity will, therefore, go along with an excessive increase of the other fat depots. In scientific investigations, very detailed separation between muscle and adipose tissues, nearly anatomical dissection, is often performed to gain precise information about the adipose tissue content in the carcass. Under commercial conditions, some of the bigger muscles might be cleaned from all adhering connective and adipose tissue (peeled, denuded), but some fat will remain with several other meat cuts. Furthermore, parts of the cutting fats are used in processed meat products and not delivered to renderers or fat processors. According to records of commercial slaughter and cutting plants in Switzerland, the proportions of killing fats removed during the slaughter process amounted roughly to 3.25 % of carcass weight for pigs and 4.5 % for cattle. Cutting fats left to fat processors were 7.4 % of cattle carcass weight, 5.5 % for lamb, and only 0.5 % for veal, while the cutting fat from pork was completely used in processed products. For poultry we found in several experiments with broiler chicken an overall average of about 1.75 % abdominal fat in the carcasses. According to records of a Swiss poultry slaughter plant, the actually collected and
Lipids from land animals 33 commercialized amount of fat was about 1.4 % of the chicken carcass weight. Part of this fat is not rendered but directly processed into poultry meat products. On a global scale, however, the proportion of poultry fat available for fat processing might be higher (Section 3.2.3).
3.2.3 Production and supply figures The total production of animal fats depends of course on the number of animals slaughtered and the proportion of fat in the carcasses. Global meat production doubled during the last quarter of a century from 127 million tonnes in 1978 to 257 million tonnes in 2004 (faostat.fao.org). Production of all varieties of meat increased, but the growth rate differed considerably between the meat animal species. Calculated on a per capita base, production of beef and veal even slightly declined while poultry meat production has been growing fastest and the per capita production meanwhile exceeds beef and veal (Fig. 3.1). The biggest share of meat, however, is still coming from pigs. The non-ruminant species therefore clearly dominate meat production. Given the pressure on available grazing areas and the reduced proportion of non-grain biomass of modern hybrid crops, this trend is likely to be continued. While meat consumption in the wealthy, industrialized nations has obviously reached a level of saturation and will hardly grow further, it is predicted that livestock production, and particularly meat animal production, will grow with rather high rates in transition and developing countries (Delgado et al., 1999). This might be particularly interesting in terms of a potential local use of animal fats.
25
50
Beef and veal Pigmeat Chicken meat Mutton and lamb Meat, total
20
45 40
15
kg
30 25
10
20 15
5
10 5
0
2004
2002
2000
1998
1996
1994
1992
1990
1988
1986
1984
1982
1980
1978
0
Years
Fig. 3.1
Changes in annual per capita meat production (faostat.fao.org).
kg, total meat
35
34
Modifying lipids for use in food
In line with the growth in meat animal production, tallow and grease and lard production steadily increased from about 6300 and 4180 thousand tonnes (kt) in 1978 to 8000 and 7270 kt in 2004, respectively. The production per capita, however, slightly declined for tallow and grease from 1.46 to 1.26 kg per year. Lard production only slightly increased from 0.97 to 1.14 kg (Fig. 3.2), although pork production increased from 10.6 to 15.8 kg per person per year during the same period (Fig. 3.1). The breeding and feeding of leaner pigs surely is one explanation. Figure 3.2 also reveals that animal fats are next in importance after the big four plant oils (soybean, palm, canola, and sunflower oil). However, when looking at the share of animal fats relative to the summarized production of the big four plant oils plus animal fats, it becomes evident that animal fats are successively replaced, particularly by palm oil (Fig. 3.3). Poultry production also increased enormously from 23 million tonnes in 1978 to 81 million tonnes in 2005 or, expressed as per capita production, from 5.3 to 12.6 kg per year (faostat.fao.org). Despite this growing importance of poultry, data on the development of poultry fat production during the last decades is not readily available. Recent data from the European Fat Processors and Renderers Association (EFPRA) indicate that poultry fat production in the EU increased from 181 kt in 2001 to close to 200 kt in 2003 (Table 3.1), 18
Soyabean oil Palm oil Rapeseed oil Sunflower oil Tallow and grease Lard Accumulated
7 6 5
16 14 12
kg
10 4 8 3 6 2
kg, accumulated
8
4
03/04
01/02
99/00
97/98
95/96
93/94
91/92
89/90
87/88
85/86
83/84
0
81/82
0
79/80
2
77/78
1
Years
Fig. 3.2 Development of the global production per capita of the four major plant oils, the two major animal fats and the total of all these items (reported on the righthand axis) [sources: oil and fat production: ISTA Mielke GmbH, Oil World (www.oilworld.biz/app.php); world population: US Census Bureau (www.censusgov/ ipc/www/world.html)].
15
10
10
5
5
0
0
93/94
89/90
03/04
15
01/02
20
99/00
20
97/98
25
95/96
25
91/92
30
87/88
30
85/86
35
83/84
35
81/82
40
79/80
40
77/78
[%]
Lipids from land animals 35
Years Soybean oil Palm oil Rapeseed oil Sunflower oil Tallow and Grease Lard
Fig. 3.3 Changes in the proportion of the major oils and fats relative to the annual production of the total of these items [ISTA Mielke GmbH, Oil World (www.oilworld.biz/app.php)]. Table 3.1 Annual production of the different categories of animal fats in EU-15 between 2001 and 2003 (× 1000 tonnes).
2001 2002 2003
Mixed animal fats
Lard
Tallow
Poultry fats
Bone fats
1427 1421 1378
543 518 430
368 378 343
181 186 198
106 127 118
Source: Woodgate (2004).
which is about 7.6 % of all animal fats produced (Woodgate, 2004). According to figures from the US Census Bureau (provided by the National Renderers Association in the USA – www.renderers.org), poultry fat production was 405 and 417 kt in 2003 and 2004, respectively, which is 9.5 % and 9.9 % of total animal fats and greases produced in the USA. These figures imply that poultry fat obtained in the EU and the USA constantly makes up about 2.3 % of poultry meat production. Tallow and grease expressed as proportion
36
Modifying lipids for use in food
of beef and veal produced is, on a global scale, about 13.5 %, quite constant over the last 25 years, while lard obtained from pork production declined from about 9.2 % in 1978 to 7.2 % in 2004.
3.2.4 The rendering process Rendering is the general term for a variety of processes applied to obtain animal fats from fatty animal tissue by separating the fat from proteins (mainly connective tissue) and water. In a more general meaning, the term rendering applies to all the processes of animal by-product processing and is often linked to the ‘invisible industry’ (Tufft, 1996) valorizing inedible animal by-products. Woodgate and Veen (2004) therefore recommend clear differentiation between processing of inedible and edible grade by-products. They suggest using the term ‘fat processing’ as an alternative to rendering when food grade products are produced. This is considered in the name of the European Fat Processors and Renderers Association. The principle of rendering is a rather old technique which has been applied for hundreds or thousands of years. A simple example of rendering (or better fat processing) on a household kitchen scale is the preparing of goosedripping (in this case, however, the proteinaceous ‘residues’, i.e. cracklings or greaves may be the choicest part for some and are often left with the spread). In general, the raw material is first mechanically cut or ground into small pieces with a heat treatment subsequently applied. The main objectives of the heat treatments are to denature the proteins and to achieve cell rupture in order to release the fats. Furthermore, the viscosity of the fats is lowered, facilitating the separation from the solids. The various rendering methods can be classified according to the basic system (continuous or batch), the fat level (natural fat, added fat, de-fatted), process conditions (atmospheric, vacuum, pressure) (Woodgate and Veen, 2004), and, depending on additionally added water or steam, into wet or dry processes. Williams and Hron (1996) describe four general methods in more detail: wet rendering, dry rendering, slurry rendering, and digestive rendering. Dry rendering is the simplest method and can be performed in continuous or batch processes. Fat and solid residue are both dehydrated in heated (steam-jacketed) vessels and then separated by passing over a drainage screen and subsequent pressing of the residues. After settling, centrifuging, and filtering, the fats are ready for market. For slurry rendering, the material is ground to a slurry and pumped through an evaporator for moisture removal under vacuum. The fat is then obtained by two steps, centrifugation and pressing of the solid residue in a screw press. Digestive rendering promotes the release and separation of the fat by adding chemicals or enzymes to hydrolyze or dissolve the connective tissue. Digestion by sodium hydroxide at 85–95 °C and following washing steps is described to recover fat at least equivalent to steam rendering and to yield fat of better quality. However, if the raw material is not fresh, already hydrolyzed fatty acids may form soaps in the aqueous phase. Several further approaches
Lipids from land animals 37 using enzymes are described but are rarely applied commercially, mainly due to the high cost. When lard and edible tallow are produced, wet rendering methods are preferably applied, because the milder conditions yield fats which are light in colour, mild in flavour, and low in free fatty acids compared to dry rendered fats. Water is commonly added in the form of live steam to the cut or ground fatty tissue. The use of water in wet melting processes provides several advantages. The steam displaces the air in the system, reducing oxidative stress. Elevated moisture helps to ensure proper denaturation and hardening of the proteins and rupture of the fat cells. Solid residues, which are mainly proteins, have a greater affinity for the ‘polar solvent’ water than to fat, thus less proteins will migrate into the fat in the presence of water. When quality and source of the raw material are appropriate, the fats resulting from wet melting may be suitable for use as food without further processing. Specific regulations, however, may require further heat treatment; e.g. in Switzerland rendered animal fat must be heated to 133 °C for 20 minutes when used as animal feeding stuff to comply with the regulations (VTNP, 2004). The yield from steam rendering of the usual killing and cutting fats is reported to be 80 and 70 % lard, respectively (Williams and Hron, Sr, 1996), but these figures may vary depending on the raw material and the processes applied. To give an example, the proportion of fats ready for market rendered from fatty tissue has been 71 % for premier jus from beef kidney fat, 46 % rendered fat from beef cutting fats, 61 and 57 % from pork killing and cutting fats, respectively, according to production figures from a Swiss fat processing plant, applying a continuous wet melting process with temperatures slightly below 100 °C (Widmer, 2005). 3.2.5 Composition and properties of animal fats The fatty acids deposited in animal tissues are derived from various sources: from endogenous synthesis or directly from the feed, and from microbial synthesis or modification in the digestive tract. Endogenous synthesis results predominantly in saturated C16 and C18 fatty acids, which in a second step can be desaturated to monounsaturated fatty acids. Dietary fatty acids can be absorbed and deposited as such. In particular, the essential fatty acids, linoleic acid (18:2n-6) and linolenic acid (18:3n-3) with a double bond at the 6th or 3rd carbon from the methyl end (which cannot be introduced by the animal organism and which is the actual essential component) can be further desaturated and elongated to very long chain (C20–C24) highly unsaturated fatty acids like arachidonic acid (20:4n-6), eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA, 20:5n3), and docosahexaenoic acid (22:6n-3). Part of the dietary polyunsaturated fatty acids (and in ruminants it is generally by far the biggest part of the essential fatty acids ingested) will undergo partial or complete microbial biohydrogenation resulting in a variety of conjugated, trans-unsaturated and saturated fatty acids. Branched fatty acids with the methyl group attached to
38
Modifying lipids for use in food
the n-1 (iso) or n-2 (anteiso) carbon, or odd-chain fatty acids originate from microbial synthesis in the rumen or the intestines. The fatty acid composition of animal fats is, therefore, far more complex and variable than in the major plant oils. Tallow, in particular, contains hundreds of different fatty acids, although most of them occur only in trace amounts. In the Codex Alimentarius Standard 211 (FAO/WHO, 1999), characteristic ranges of the fatty acid composition of lard and tallow are defined. Table 3.2 gives these ranges together with the ranges for 1993 (Love, 1996), indicating that the ranges accepted for compliance have been reduced between 1993 and 1999. Due to ruminal biohydrogenation and microbial synthesis, the proportions of saturated, branched, and odd-chain fatty acids are higher in tallow than in lard, while the proportion and range of polyunsaturated fatty acids are lower. In non-ruminants such as pigs and poultry the dietary fatty acids more directly influence the body fat composition, making nutrition an effective tool to manipulate animal lipid composition (as discussed in Chapter 13). Another factor is the amount of body fat. When animals grow fatter, either due to genetic disposition or feeding intensity, the endogenously synthesized fatty acids, i.e. saturated and monounsaturated, will ‘dilute’ the polyunsaturates of dietary origin. Vice versa, the leaner an animal is, the higher the proportion of polyunsaturated fatty acids, with the consequence of lower oxidative stability and consistency. As mentioned above, farm animals are bred and selected for lean body mass. This already causes problems with soft pork fat in the meat processing industry. Another general observation is that animal fats are softer the closer the adipose tissue is situated to the periphery of the body. Internal fats are more saturated than intermuscular fat, which is somewhat more saturated than subcutaneous fat. The lower temperature at the body surface obviously requires a lower melting temperature of the fats, which is achieved by a higher proportion of unsaturated fatty acids. Indeed, it was shown that the ambient temperature directly affects the fatty acid composition of backfat in pigs, most likely by regulating the activity of the enzyme stearoyl-CoA-desaturase, which is the endogenous tool to desaturate stearic to oleic acid and thus adapt fat consistency to the ambient conditions. There is even a difference between the inner and the outer backfat layer, but this might be of more academic interest than practical importance. In modern pigs, the proportion of polyunsaturated fatty acids can easily reach 20 % in leaf fat when plant oils are included in the diet (Eder et al., 2001), and in the subcutaneous backfat linoleic acid can reach 12 %, which is the upper level in the current Codex standard for lard and rendered pork fat, even when no additional oil or fat is supplemented to the feed (Gläser et al., 2002). Poultry fat, as shown in Table 3.3, is even higher in polyunsaturated and lower in saturated fatty acids than pork fat (Foures, 1996). Therefore, although animal fats are often generally blamed as saturated fat, it has to be emphasized that lard clearly contains less than 50 % saturated fatty acids and poultry fat hardly exceeds 30 %. In a survey on rendered animal fats in
Lipids from land animals 39 Table 3.2 Ranges of fatty acid composition (expressed as percentages) and definitions of rendered, named animal fats according to Codex Alimentarius.
6:0 8:0 10:0 12:0 14:0 14:ISO 14:1 15:0 15:ISO 15:ANTI ISO 16:0 16:1 16:ISO 16:2 17:0 17:1 17:ISO 17:ANTI ISO 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3 20:0 20:1 20:2 20:4 22:0 22:1
Lard1/Rendered pork fat2
Premier jus3/Tallow4
19995
19936
19995
19936
< 0.5 in total
< 0.5 in total
< 0.5 in total
< 2.5
1–2.5 < 0.1 < 0.2 < 0.2 < 0.1 < 0.1 20–30 2–4 < 0.1 < 0.1 <1 <1 < 0.1 < 0.1 8–22 35–55 4–12 < 1.5 <1 < 1.5 <1 <1 < 0.1 < 0.5
0.5–2.5
2–6 < 0.3 0.5–1.5 0.2–1 < 1.5 in total
1.4–7.8 < 0.3 0.5–1.5 0.5–1 < 1.5 in total
20–30 1–5 < 0.5 <1 0.5–2.0 <1 < 1.5 in total
17–37 0.7–8.8 < 0.5 <1 0.5–2 <1 < 1.5 in total
15–30 30–45 1–6 < 1.5 < 0.5 < 0.5 < 0.1 < 0.5 < 0.1 not detected
6–40 26–50 0.5–5 < 2.5 < 0.5 < 0.5
< 0.2 < 0.1 < 0.1
20–32 1.7–5 < 0.1 < 0.5 < 0.5
5–24 35–62 3–16 < 1.5 <1 <1 <1 <1 < 0.1
< 0.5
Note: Samples falling within the appropriate ranges specified below are in compliance with this standard. 1 Pure rendered lard is the fat rendered from fresh, clean, sound fatty tissues from swine (Sus scrofa) in good health, at the time of slaughter, and fit for human consumption. The tissues do not include bones, detached skin, head skin, ears, tails, organs, windpipes, large blood vessels, scrap fat, skimmings, settlings, pressings and the like, and are reasonably free from muscle tissues and blood. 2 Rendered pork fat is the fat rendered from the tissues and bones of swine (Sus scrofa) in good health, at the time of slaughter, and fit for human consumption. It may contain fat from bones (properly cleaned), from detached skin, from head skin, from ears, from tails and from other tissues fit for human consumption. 3 Premier jus (oleo stock) is the product obtained by rendering at low heat the fresh fat (killing fat) of heart, caul, kidney and mesentery collected at the time of slaughter of bovine animals in good health at the time of slaughter and fit for human consumption, as well as cutting fats. 4 Edible tallow (dripping) is the product obtained by rendering the clean, sound, fatty tissues (including trimming and cutting fats), attendant muscles and bones of bovine animals and/or sheep (Ovis aries) in good health at the time of slaughter and fit for human consumption. Sources: 5FAO/WHO (1999); 6 Love (1996).
40
Modifying lipids for use in food
Table 3.3 Average proportion of major fatty acids in poultry fat as well as maximum and minimum mean values reported in a total of seven studies.
14:0 16:0 16:1 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3
Average
Maximum
Minimum
21.7 6.4 6.2 41.7 18.4 0.9
6 26.7 10.2 7.7 44.7 22 1.8
0.3 19.4 4.1 4.5 39.3 10.1 0.7
Source: Foures (1996).
Germany, a proportion of saturated fatty acids from 36–55 % saturated fatty acids was found (Bahadir et al., 2004). The fatty acid composition of various uncommon animal fats is given by Foures (1996). Horse fat, for example, contains extraordinarily high proportions of linolenic acid, which may be explained by the fact that the predominant polyunsaturated fatty acid in green forage is linolenic acid, and the horse, being a hind-gut fermenter (and not a ruminant), is therefore able to absorb and deposit this fatty acid unmodified and in quite large quantities. The triacylglycerol (TAG) structure also shows some species specificity. During TAG synthesis in pigs, the acyltransferases arrange a very typical positional distribution of fatty acids in TAG with predominantly 16:0 at the central sn-2 position (Christie and Moore, 1970), while the most abundant fatty acid in the sn-1 and sn-3 positions is oleic acid. In subcutaneous fat of cattle 16:0 is located with 41, 17, and 22 mol% in all of the positions 1, 2, or 3, respectively, while 18:1 makes up 41 mol% in the sn-2 position and 20 or 37 mol% at positions 1 and 3 (Christie, 1986). This pattern is similar for poultry fat, where only 15 % of all fatty acid at position 2 is 16:0, but 43 % is 18:1. In both position 1 and position 3 about 25 % is 16:0 and 34 % is 18:1 (Foures, 1996). The ratio of 16:0/18:1cis9 in sn-2 position of lard TAG is about 5, while it is about 0.4 in tallow. The analysis of fatty acids at the sn2 position would, therefore, allow for detecting lard in tallow if lard exceeds 5 % in the blend (Kirk and Sawyer, 1991, cited in Love, 1996). Another unique, even distinctive, property of animal tissues and fats is its cholesterol content. Cholesterol is not found in plants, except for very small traces e.g. in olive oil. Lard, tallow, and poultry fat contain about 86, 89, and 107 mg cholesterol per 100 g fat, respectively; butter contains about 238 and butter fat 286 mg/100 g (Souci et al., 2005). Cholesterol is controversially discussed as a health risk factor and there is widespread belief that dietary cholesterol causes coronary heart diseases (CHD). This belief goes back to Anitschkow’s studies (Anitschkow and Chalatow, 1913) with cholesterol-fed rabbits, in which atherosclerotic lesions were found. The current state of knowledge, however, reveals that dietary
Lipids from land animals 41 cholesterol has no effect on serum LDL:HDL cholesterol ratio, and there is little if any evidence that cholesterol increases the risk of CHD (Parodi, 2004). On the other hand, cholesterol is an inevitable constituent of cell membranes (Mouritsen and Zuckermann, 2004). Its importance for eukaryotic membrane functions is also emphasized by the fact that the biggest part of the cholesterol body pool is endogenously synthesized while dietary cholesterol makes only a modest contribution to it (Parodi, 2004). Cholesterol might nevertheless be of concern because heat treatment in the presence of oxygen may form cholesterol oxidation products, which are considered to promote CHD and cancer. The Codex standard also defines further quality characteristics and maximum levels of undesirable constituents which may result from improper handling, storage, or processing. A low content of free fatty acids (FFA) and a low peroxide value (POV) indicate appropriate raw material and fresh product. Typical commercial specifications, as described by Woodgate and Veen (2004), require a FFA content below 0.5 %, POV below 4 meg/kg, moisture below 0.2 % and insoluble impurities below 0.02 %, which is stricter than the Codex definitions. It is interesting to mention that commercial specifications, particularly for animal fats destined for use in calf milk replacers and pet food, traditionally are more rigorous than legal specifications. Physical characteristics of animal fats One of the most important properties of fats in terms of its technological use is the melting and crystallization behaviour (the dietetic value of animal source fats will be discussed in Chapter 13). The melting behaviour and related traits such as solid fat content and plasticity as well as the crystal habit are determined by the fatty acid composition and the TAG structure. The more saturated and the longer fatty acids are, the higher the melting temperature will be. The melting point is usually measured in an open tubecapillary and given as temperature when all solid disappears. Characteristic melting temperatures for animal source fats are given in Table 3.4. Butter, despite the rather low iodine value (i.e. high degree of saturation), shows a comparably low melting point due to the high proportion of short- and mediumchain fatty acids (high saponification number). Within the animal fats with a comparable saponification number (i.e. mean chain length), the melting point is negatively correlated with the iodine number. Neat’s-foot oil, due to its high quantity of monounsaturated fatty acids, is still liquid below the freezing point of water. This also underlines the fact that it is not only the number of double bonds but the proportion of unsaturated fatty acids which determines the melting behaviour (Gläser et al., 2004). Furthermore, fatty acids with double bonds in trans configuration have melting temperatures above those of the corresponding cis fatty acids. In lard, trans fatty acids normally occur only in trace amounts, but when fed to pigs, trans fatty acids not only accumulate in adipose tissue but also inhibit the endogenous
42
Modifying lipids for use in food
Table 3.4
Characteristics of typical animal derived fats.
Butter Lard Neat’s-foot oil Beef tallow Mutton tallow
Iodine value
Saponification number
Melting point [°C]
25–42 53–77 69–76 40–48 35–46
210–233 190–202 190–199 190–199 192–197
28–35 33–46 –4 40–48 44–51
Source: Dugan (1987).
desaturation of stearic to oleic acid, which tremendously increases firmness of the lard (see Chapter 13). The melting point, however, is not the temperature at which all solid turns to liquid. Even at temperatures fairly below the melting points, the fats contain some liquid phase. Meat and milk fats, therefore, appear to be solid at room temperature, but actually only part of the fat is crystallized while the other part is trapped as liquid oil in the crystal network. This is one of three requirements for a plastic fat. When, additionally, there is a proper proportion between the two phases and a sufficiently fine dispersion of the solid phase then a plastic fat results (Metzroth, 1996). Satisfactory plasticity is achieved when the solid fat resists small stress but, when sufficient forces are applied to cause deformation, it acts like a viscous liquid (as when spreading a ‘solid’ fat on bread or toast the fat is deformed by the pressure applied). Therefore, to maintain the desired solid fat content over a wide temperature range, flat melting curves are desired. Due to their high variety of fatty acids and TAG, animal derived fats generally have flat melting curves. Fats solidify in several crystalline polymorphic forms. It is agreed that at least three forms exist, α, β and β ′ (beta-prime), with β and β ′ being the two desirable stable forms. β ′ forms small, uniform, needle-like crystals, exhibits smooth texture and is able to enmesh a higher amount of liquid phase than the β polymorphic form, which is more coarse textured with large granular crystals. For use as shortening with high plasticity, the preferred polymorphic form is β ′. Animal derived fats typically tend to crystallize in β ′-form (Table 3.5). Only unmodified lard tends to crystallize in β-form, building large and grainy crystals, although lard contains a high proportion of palmitic acid, which usually promotes β ′-type crystallization (Wiedermann, 1978). This is due to the specific TAG structure of lard, with palmitic acid preferentially attached to the sn-2 position, while shorter fatty acids at the sn-1(3) positions and symmetrical TAG promote β ′ polymorphic form. On the other hand, unmodified lard is specifically used to give pie crusts a desirable flaky texture (Metzroth, 1996). Modifying lard by interesterification will result in a β ′-type shortening.
Lipids from land animals 43 Table 3.5
Classification of fats and oils according to crystal habit.
Beta-type ( β )
Beta-prime-type (β ′ )
Soybean Safflower Sunflower Sesame Peanut Corn Canbra (canola) Olive Coconut Palmkernel Lard Cocoa butter
Cottonseed Palm Tallow Herring Menhaden Whale Rapeseed Milk fat (butter oil) Modified lard
Source: Wiedermann (1978).
3.2.6 Use of animal fats in food Rendered or processed animal fats fit for human consumption have traditionally been used as shortenings in baked goods, spreads and margarine, and as (deep-) frying fats – in industry or the catering business as well as in private households. Traditionally, yellow grease acquired by renderers from food service establishments was of animal origin (Kiepper, 2001). Although they are still commercially offered for these purposes, the use of animal fats in food has declined. The major part of rendered animal fats is currently used as livestock feeds, cosmetics and industrial oils, and fats for producing fuel, lubricants and soaps. Only 10 % of the 2.77 million tonnes of animal fats in Europe were used as food in 2002 (Woodgate, 2004). In 2003 the amount of animal fats produced decreased slightly to 2.6 million tonnes and the proportion used for food fell considerably to 6 %, which was below the amount used for pet food (7 %). The share used as feed remained constant at 25 %. About 31 % was used for soap and oleochemicals and another quarter (24 %) as energy substitute. According to figures from the US Census Bureau (M311K series for Fat and Oils: Production, Consumption and Stocks), provided by the National Renderers Association (www.renderers.org), only a small and decreasing part of edible tallow produced is actually consumed for edible use (from 17.3 % in 1998 to 11.8 % in 2004) in the USA. The proportion of lard consumed for edible uses increased in the same time from about 55 to 73 % but, due to the overall decrease in lard production, the total amount of lard used for edible purposes declined from 135.9 to 84.2 kt. The share of lard and tallow consumed as food, therefore, decreased from 6.5 % of all animal fats and greases produced in the USA in 1998 to 4.4 % in 2004. However, an important contribution to the intake of animal lipids is its consumption as part of meat and meat products. The contribution of fresh meat to the consumption of fat might nevertheless be over-estimated because
44
Modifying lipids for use in food
fat is lost during cooking and visible subcutaneous and intermuscular fat is often discarded on the plate. Cooking loss and leftovers can reduce the actual fat intake by 35–65 % of the original fat content of the raw cut (Sheard et al., 1998; Gerber et al., 2004). Processed meat products, in contrast, may contain a fair bit of added cutting fats, particularly from pork, and killing fat (abdominal fat) in the case of poultry, which is directly used in products like salami or frankfurter type sausages. The composition of animal fat is, therefore, still of relevance for human nutrition.
3.2.7 Legal issues A useful overview of fat processing and rendering, including regulations and directives concerning meat by-product processing, is given by Woodgate and Veen (2004). The most relevant regulations concerning animal fats fit for human consumption or use in feed are the ‘Meat Products Directive’ 77/ 99/EEC (EU, 1977; EU, 1992) and the ‘Animal By-products Regulation’, ABPR, 1774/2002/EC (EU, 2002). Health scare issues, in the first instance transmissible spongiform encephalopathies e.g. BSE and scrapie, also led to intensive scientific investigation of tallow as a potential transmission vector. Woodgate and Veen (2004) summarized the state of knowledge concisely, concluding that there is no scientific evidence supporting the hypothesis that tallow might be risk factor for BSE transmission. However, the fact that in Germany the use of even edible grade animal fats as feeding stuff is prohibited leads to the conclusion that political and marketing decisions rather than scientific evidence will, to a large extent, determine the current and future use of animal fats in feed and food industry.
3.3
Milk fat
Milk is secreted by the mammary gland of female mammals after parturition to nourish the progeny. This biological concept evolved a great compositional variety of milk (Oftedal, 2005). The content of lipids, which is the milk’s most energy dense constituent, can be as low as 1.4 % for example in equines (ass, horse), and as high as 54 % in seals (Kirk and Sawyer, 1991). Milk became available as another valuable food source with the domestication of animals in the course of the neolithic revolution, and the first signs indicating the use of sheep, goats, and cattle for milking date back to 5000 BC (Teuber, 2000). The first documented evidence for dairy products was found in Sumerian bookkeeping documents from about 3200 BC, and it can be assumed that butter oil was among the earliest processed products because of its preferable storage characteristics due to microbiological stability (Teuber, 2000).
Lipids from land animals 45 3.3.1 Sources of milk fat The synthetic and secretory tissue of the mammary gland is composed of millions of alveoli connected and drained via terminal ducts to progressively larger ducts and ultimately to the collecting spaces, the gland and the teat cisterns. The alveoli are lined with a single layer of mammary epithelial cells that synthesize and secrete the milk. The TAG secreted with the milk are esterified in the mammary epithelial cells and originate either from fatty acids derived from de novo synthesis via acetyl-CoA carboxylase and fatty acid synthase in the cells or exogenously supplied as plasma lipids. The exogenously supplied fatty acids in plasma can be non-esterified fatty acids, which primarily originate from adipose tissue stores, or from the TAG in lipoproteins that originate from enterocytes of the gut [chylomicrons and very low-density lipoprotein (VLDL)] or from the liver (VLDL). The TAG in lipoproteins have to be hydrolyzed extracellularly by lipoprotein lipase to release the fatty acids. Since ruminant diets commonly contain only little fat, VLDL and chylomicrons from the gut contribute only modestly to the TAG synthesized in the epithelial cells compared with conditions prevailing in non-ruminant mammals (Clegg et al., 2000). The mechanism by which intracellular lipid droplets, the precursors of milk lipid globules, are formed is still a matter of conjecture. It has been hypothesized that TAG accumulate in between the bilayer membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and are released surrounded by the outer, cytoplasmic membrane of the ER (Keenan and Patton, 1995). These droplets with a TAG-rich core fuse to larger cytoplasmic lipid droplets. It is suggested that the lipid droplets become surrounded by the apical membrane of mammary epithelial cells as they bud from the epithelial cells and are released as milk lipid globules. The size of the globules in raw bovine milk ranges from 0.1 to 15 µm (with about 90 % of all globules ranging between 1 and 8 µm). These globules make up about 95 % of total milk lipids, present as an oil-in-water emulsion (Tong and Berner 1994). The term ‘milk’ commonly refers to bovine milk, because the bulk of the milk produced for human consumption originates from cows (Bos taurus or Bos indicus). Milk from other species is described by adding the species of origin, e.g. buffalo milk. According to Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) statistics, 84 % of global milk production in 2004 was from cows, 12.5 % from buffalo, 1.3 % from sheep, 2 % from goats, and 0.2 % from camels (faostat.fao.org). While the share of production from sheep and camels remained quite constant and goat milk only slightly increased its share over the last decades, a clear shift from cow milk, which made up 91 % of total milk production in 1978, to buffalo milk (5.7 % in 1978) can be observed. Total milk production increased during that time from about 452 to 613 million tonnes. The production per capita, however, declined from about 96 kg cow milk per year to 81 kg (Fig. 3.4). Concomitantly the supply of butter decreased, while, according to the increased share of buffalo milk, production of ghee from buffalo milk constantly increased from 1986 on.
46
Modifying lipids for use in food 2.0
100
80
60 1.0 Butter of cow milk Ghee, buffalo Butter and ghee, total Cow milk, fresh
0.0
20
1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
0.5
40
Fresh milk [kg]
Fat [kg]
1.5
0
Years
Fig. 3.4 Development of the annual production per capita of milk, butter (cow milk) and ghee (buffalo) and total milk fat from 1978 to 2004 (faostat.fao.org).
3.3.2 Composition of the milk lipids The milk lipids mainly consist of TAG (about 97 %) and much smaller proportions of phospholipids and sterols, which are mainly associated with the membrane of milk lipid globules (Table 3.6). Mono- and diacylglycerols, free fatty acids, cholesteryl esters, lipid-soluble vitamins, carotenoids, and squalene also occur in minor amounts as well as trace amounts of hydrocarbons (Bitman and Wood, 1990; NDC, 2005). The proportions of cholesterol, and to a certain extent also phospholipids, tend to decline during lactation (Table 3.6), while the proportions of TAG and also of the phospholipid classes remain quite constant (Bitman and Wood, 1990).
Table 3.6
Lipid class composition of cows’ milk during lactation. Percentage at day of lactation
Lipid class
3
7
42
180
Phospholipid Cholesterol Triacylglycerol 1,2-Diacylglycerol Free fatty acids Monoacylglycerol Cholesteryl esters Fat content [g/dl]
0.72 0.53 97.35 1.01 0.26 0.06 0.05 3.45
1.06 0.41 97.11 1.16 0.19 0.06 0.03 3.97
1.11 0.46 95.8 2.25 0.28 0.08 0.02 3.25
0.56 0.3 97.17 1.72 0.18 0.03 0.04 3.13
Source: Bitman and Wood (1990).
Lipids from land animals 47 The fatty acid composition and TAG structure of milk fat is exceptionally complex. To give an example of the major fatty acids in milk fat, the composition of the EU BCR-Standard for anhydrous milk fat is given in Table 3.7. However, over 400 different fatty acids have been described in milk fat, ranging from chain length of four to 28, including odd- and branchedchain fatty acids, unsaturated fatty acids with one to six double bonds, and various positional and geometrical isomers including conjugated fatty acids (Jensen and Newburg, 1995). As a consequence of this impressive number of fatty acids, thousands of different TAG may occur. The structure and proportion of more than 220 TAG have been investigated and described in detail (Gresti Table 3.7 Fatty acid composition of the EU Food and Agriculture Anhydrous milk fat standard (BCR-164). Fatty acids
Mass fraction fatty acid (g/100 g)
Butyric acid
3.49 ± 0.06
Other 6:0 8:0 10:0 10:1 ω1 12:0 12:1 ω9 14:0 iso 14:0 14:1 ω5 15:0 iso 15:0 anti-iso 15:0 16:0 iso 16:0 total 16:1 ω7 16:1 total 17:0 iso 17:0 anti-iso 17:0 17:1 18:0 iso 18:0 total 18:1 total 18:2 ω6 cis1 18:2 conj 18:2 total 18:3 ω3 cis 20:0 20:1 ω9 cis Other
Mass fraction fatty acids (g/100 g) 2.36 ± 0.19 1.36 ± 0.10 2.89 ± 0.12 (0.3) 4.03 ± 0.10 (0.1) (0.1) 10.79 ± 0.35 (1.1) (0.3) (0.5) (1.0) (0.2) 26.91 ± 0.84 (1.5) (1.5) (0.5) (0.4) (0.5) (0.3) (0.1) 10.51 ± 0.40 24.82 ± 0.61 (1.8) (0.9) 2.68 ± 0.40 0.51 ± 0.04 (0.1) (0.2) (2.5)
Note: Values in brackets are not certified. 1 Includes isomers.
48
Modifying lipids for use in food
et al., 1993; Jensen and Newburg, 1995). None of the TAG exceeded a proportion of 5 %, indicating the high variability, but the proportion of observed TAG deviated significantly from the proportions expected from a random distribution of fatty acids to the three positions in the TAG. Obviously TAG with one short-chain fatty acid (4:0 or 6:0) and two fatty acids in the range C12 to C18 are preferentially synthesized by the mammary epithelial cells. This highly diverse composition and structure give milk lipids their characteristic properties. Melting of milk fat occurs over a very wide range starting at around –30 °C and being completed at about 37 °C (Hettinga, 1996), although some TAG with melting points up to 75 °C might be present (Tong and Berner, 1994). Together with the tendency to crystallize in the β ′ polymorphic form (Table 3.5), milk fat fulfils the preconditions for a plastic fat, making it a desirable shortening, which moreover may provide a characteristic flavour. Mimicking the flavour of milk fat remains a challenge to food chemists. Oxo- and hydroxy fatty acids are precursors of flavouractive ketones and lactones. Aldehydes, oxidation products of unsaturated fatty acids, also contribute to the flavour as do volatile short-chain fatty acids and branched fatty acids directly (Jensen and Newburg, 1995).
3.3.3 Obtaining milk fat The short-chain fatty acids, on the other hand, can produce a highly unpleasant flavour in raw milk when milk fat globules are destroyed and the released TAG left prone to the hydrolyzing action of lipase. Severe pumping or agitation of the raw milk and unfavourably designed pipelines causing turbulent flow should therefore be avoided. The milk fat globule membrane also prevents instant flocculation. For obtaining butter, the milk fat globules have to be destabilized to break the oil-in-water emulsion and to form fat granules. In early times this was achieved by churning the milk. Commonly, the first basic step in butter manufacture is the separation of cream from milk, which is possible due to differences in the specific gravity between fat globules and milk serum. Globules below 0.8 µm are considered as non-separable (Hettinga, 1996). The next steps are churning, aggregation of the fat granules, separating the buttermilk, formation and stabilization of the water-in-oil emulsion, and finally packaging. Butter manufacture can be performed in batch systems but, except for small butter plants, butter is today commonly produced in continuous systems (Hettinga, 1996; Tong and Berner, 1994). According to the Codex standard for butter [Codex Alimentarius Standard A-1 (FAO/ WHO, 1971)], butter must be derived exclusively from milk and/or products obtained from milk and must contain at least 80 % fat and a maximum of 16 % moisture. Spreadability is an important trait for butter, and several approaches to achieving the desired characteristics have been described (Hettinga, 1996), including mechanical treatment, temperature profiling of the cream, blending
Lipids from land animals 49 winter and summer butter, fractionation, interesterification, and the diet of the cow. To further concentrate butter or cream to anhydrous milk fat it is necessary to break the emulsion and to remove non-fat solids and water. For this purpose, disruption of the milk fat globule membrane has to be achieved mechanically by homogenization or with citric acid as a chemical measure to destroy the membranes. In several steps, applying elevated temperatures up to 95 °C under vacuum, the butter oil is then separated and dehydrated to a minimum fat content of 99.8 %. The physical properties may than be adapted by applying the fractionation technique. Ghee is another product obtained exclusively from milk or fat-enriched milk products, which, may however, originate from various species. Water and non-fat solids are removed as with anhydrous milk fat but at higher temperatures. This also leads to a strong (desired) buttery flavour. Ghee is also produced from anhydrous milk fat by adding ethyl butyrate or alternate synthetic flavours (Hettinga, 1996).
3.3.4 Uses of milk fat in foods Butterfat is used as ingredient in a variety of foods such as pastry, cake and biscuit products, ice cream, and confectioneries. Its major role is probably to provide the highly esteemed organoleptic sensations like flavour and texture. As a plastic fat, it serves as shortening in bakery applications, therefore helping to achieve the desired texture in the products. Its melting behaviour (modified by fractionation if required) is favourable for use in confectioneries and it is able to inhibit fat bloom in chocolate (see Chapter 20). Milk fat, therefore, fulfils nutritional, technological, and organoleptic functions in processed non-dairy foods. Milk fat is of course also consumed as such in milk and dairy products. Regarding recent trends to replace milk fat in ‘yoghurt’ by plant oils and fats, it should be mentioned that according to the Dictionary of Dairy Terminology (IDF, 1996), dairy or milk products must be derived ‘…exclusively from milk including added substances necessary for the manufacturing process, provided that these substances are not intended to take place in part or in whole of any milk constituents.’ Yoghurt with the milk fat replaced by sunflower oil may, therefore, no longer seriously be called a dairy product. Such approaches by the food industry obviously aim to meet public health concerns related to milk fat, particularly its content of saturated fatty acids and cholesterol. As the issue of nutritional health cannot be discussed here in detail, it will suffice to refer to the excellent review given by Parodi (2004). In brief, metabolic control of endogenous synthesis of cholesterol compensates for dietary intake in healthy subjects. Only for people with the inherited defect familial hypercholesterolaemia might dietary cholesterol intake be of concern. The impact of dietary cholesterol has been over-emphasized (Parodi, 2004). Potential health benefits related to the fat composition of milk fat and fats of animal origin in general will be discussed later (Chapter 13).
50
3.4
Modifying lipids for use in food
Future trends
A basic assumption for speculating about future trends in the use of animal derived fats is that animal production will grow, particularly in developing countries (Delgado, 2003). Fats of animal origin will, therefore, be available in growing quantities. The prevailing conditions might further support meat production with monogastric animals and, to a lesser extent, meat and milk from ruminants. In the recent past, a clear decline in the use of animal source fats in food has been observed. In a situation where marketing rather than scientific evidence is assumed to rule decisions in the food industry, it is expected that the amount of animal fat used in food will remain on a low but constant level in the developed countries, indicating the growing importance of ways to valorize meat fats via animal feed or even oleochemical and technical uses. The use of meat fats in animal feed – from an economical point of view the second best solution – will surely require the same, very high standards as for animal fats destined for use in human nutrition. In view of the overall increasing demand for food of animal origin (particularly meat), recycling of animal fat as feeding-stuff is surely a reasonable way to contribute to the sustainability of animal production systems. Separate processing of bovine, porcine, and poultry material will help the industry to be prepared for potential restrictions concerning intra-species recycling. Intraspecies recycling of processed animal protein as feed component is already prohibited. This will also help to cope with religious taboos on nutrition, an aspect which should not be under-estimated. Processed food products containing lard as ‘hidden fat’ will be rejected by members of Jewish and Islamic communities. On the other hand, a certain revival of meat and milk fat for use in food could be expected for several reasons. The major drawback for animal derived fats, dietary health concerns, may be weakened by results of ongoing reevaluations of the actual role of saturated fatty acids in diseases of affluence and a more differentiated view on the effects of specific saturated fatty acids. Upcoming production and marketing approaches making use of feeding strategies to improve the nutritional value of meat and milk fats by modifying the fatty acid composition may further help to change the reputation of animal source fats. Modern trends towards so-called low-carb-diets are also a sign of a changing perception of the role of fats. In the case of meat fats, high quality assurance and traceability standards in combination with potential control tools (like use of staining or/and invisible (chemical) markers in banned material) to avoid incorporation of banned products in the feed or food chain could increase safety and confidence (Woodgate and Veen, 2004). At the same time, the pressure on partly hydrogenated oils, which have replaced animal fats in several applications, is likely to increase due to the content of trans fatty acids, which are identified as a potent health risk factor. The discussion about the relevance of the origin of trans fatty acids (ruminal biohydrogenation in animals vs technological hydrogenation) will continue and probably trigger scientific work. There is
Lipids from land animals 51 at least some evidence that the intake of trans fatty acids from ruminant products generally is too low to exert negative effects in comparison to trans-intake from technological sources (Weggemans et al., 2004). It may also be expected that outside Europe, North America and Oceania, the use of animal fats for food will face less aversion and restrictions. However, the supply of animal derived fats directly by consuming animal source food (meat, milk, and their products) will be much more relevant for human nutrition than the supply by ‘hidden fats’ as ingredients in, for example, bakery products, frying fats, etc. Measures to improve the composition of animal lipids will, therefore, be of lasting relevance.
3.5
Sources of further information and advice
The present chapter can give only a brief summary and selected topics in the field of lipids of animal origin. For more detailed information about specific aspects of history, production, processing, nutrition, etc. the reader is advised to refer to more detailed and focused sources, some of which are listed and briefly introduced below. As a general source of further information and advice, Bailey’s Oil and Fat Products, the comprehensive reference work on the food chemistry and processing technology related to edible oils and fats and their non-edible by-products, has to be mentioned (now available as a sixth edition, 2005). Those who are interested in more specific information about meat and meat fats can find details in The Science of Meat and Meat Products (Price and Schweigert, 1987). This book provides timeless basic knowledge by combining fundamental scientific information about meat biology, physics, and chemistry with applied aspects in production and processing, including an extensive chapter about meat animal by-products also covering meat fats with a lot of basic data, definitions, and explanations (Dugan, 1987). In the context of meat science, of course, the standard work Lawrie’s Meat Science has to be mentioned (Lawrie, 1998). A great deal of specific information about the historical background of breeding leaner animals, fat metabolism, and measures which can be taken to control fat accretion in farm animals is given in Reducing Fat in Meat Animals (Wood and Fisher, 1990). This book also covers marketing aspects and implications for human nutrition and health. For a deeper insight in the evolutionary background of human nutrition in terms of physiological as well as social adaptation and how ‘meat eating and human evolution’ are related, an entertaining collection of essays can be recommended (Stanford and Bunn, 2001). Vividly written explanations about the background of more recent nutritional taboos and habits and the historical and socio-economic reason why some foods are ‘good to eat’ and some apparently are not are given by Marvin Harris (Harris, 1985).
52
Modifying lipids for use in food
Exhaustive information about milk composition, not only from bovine origin but also human milk can be drawn from the Handbook of Milk Composition (Jensen, 1995)
3.6
References
ANITSCHKOW N,
and CHALATOW S (1913), Ueber experimentelle Cholesterinsteatose und ihre Bedeutung für die Entstehung einiger pathologischer Prozesse, Centralbl Allg Pathol Pathol Anat, 24, 1–9. BAHADIR M, BOCK R, DETTMER T, FALK O, HESSELBACH J, JOPKE P, MATTHIES B, MEYER-PITTROFF R, SCHMIDT-NÄDERL C, and WICHMANN H (2004), Chemisch-analytische Charakterisierung technischen tierischen Fettes aus einer Tierkörperbeseitigungsanstalt, Umweltwissenschaften und Schadstoff-Forschung: Zeitschrift für Umweltchemie und Oekotoxikologie, 16 (1), 19–28. BAILEY A E, (1996), Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 5th edn, New York, Wiley Interscience. BAILEY A E, (2005), Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 6th edn, Hoboken, NJ, Jossey-Bass / John Wiley and Sons, Inc. BITMAN J, and WOOD D L (1990), Changes in milk fat phospholipids during lactation, J Dairy Sci, 73 (5), 1208–1216. CHRISTIE W W, (1986), The positional distribution of fatty acids in triglycerides, in Hamilton R. J. and Russel J. B, Analysis of Fats and Oils, New York, Elsevier Science Publishing Co., Inc., 313–339. CHRISTIE W W, and MOORE J H (1970), A comparison of the structures of triglycerides from various pig tissues, Biochim Biophys Acta, 210 (1), 46–56. CLEGG R A, BARBER M C, POOLEY L, ERNENS I, LARONDELLE Y, and TRAVERS M T (2000), Milk fat synthesis and secretion: molecular and cellular aspects, Livestock Prod Sci, 70, 1–2, 3–14. CORDAIN L, MILLER J B, EATON S B, MANN N, HOLT S H, and SPETH J D (2000), Plant-animal subsistence ratios and macronutrient energy estimations in worldwide hunter-gatherer diets, Am J Clin Nutr, 71 (3), 682–692. CORDAIN L, WATKINS B A, and MANN N J (2001), Fatty acid composition and energy density of foods available to African hominids – evolutionary implications for human brain development, World Rev Nutr Dietet, 90, 144–161. DELGADO C L (2003), Rising consumption of meat and milk in developing countries has created a new food revolution, J Nutr, 133 (11), 3907S–3910. DELGADO C L, ROSEGRANT M W, STEINFELD H, EHUI S, and COURBOIS C, (1999), Livestock to 2020. The next food revolution, 2020 Vision for Food, Agriculture, and the Environment, Discussion Paper No. 28, Washington, DC, International Food Policy Research Institute. DUGAN L R JR, (1987), Meat animal by-products and their utilization, Part 1. Meat fats, in Price J. F. and Schweigert B. S., The Science of Meat and Meat Products, 3rd edn, Westport, CT, Food and Nutrition Press, Inc., 507–530. EDER K, NONN H, and KLUGE H (2001), The fatty acid composition of lipids from muscle and adipose tissues of pigs fed various oil mixtures differing in their ratio between oleic acid and linoleic acid, Eur J Lipid Sci Technol, 103, 668–676. EU (1977), Council Directive 77/99/EEC of 21 December 1976 amended and updated into council directive 92/5 EEC of February 10,1992 on health problems affecting intraCommunity trade in meat products, Official Journal, L026, no. 31/01/1977, 85–100. EU (1992), Council Directive 92/5/EEC of 10 February 1992 amending and updating Directive 77/99/EEC on health problems affecting intra-Community trade in meat products and amending Directive 64/433/EEC, Official Journal, L057, no. 02/03/ 1992, 1–26.
Lipids from land animals 53 (2002), Regulation (EC) No 1774/2002 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 3 October 2002 laying down health rules concerning animal by-products not intended for human consumption, Official Journal, L273, no. 10/10/2002, 1–95. FAO/WHO (1971), Codex Standard A1 Butter, revised 1999, amended 2003, Rome/Geneva, FAO, WHO, available at: www.codexalimentarius.net/web/index_en.jsp. FAO/WHO (1999), Codex Standard 211 Named Animal Fats, Rome/Geneva, FAO/WHO, available at: www.codexalimentarius.net/web/index_en.jsp. FISHER A V (1990), New approaches to measuring fat in the carcasses of meat animals, in Wood, J. O. and Fisher, A. V., Reducing Fat in Meat Animals, London and New York, Elsevier Science Publishing Co., Inc., 255–343. FOURES C (1996), Animal tissues – fats from land animals, in Karleskind, A and Wolff, J P, Oils and Fats Manual, vol. 1, Paris, Lavoisier Publishing, 247–266. GATZKA E M (2004), Zahlen aus der Deutschen Schweineproduktion 2003, Alfter-Witterschlick, Druckerei Martin Roesberg. GERBER N, WENK C, and SCHEEDER M R L (2004), Influence of cooking and trimming on the actual intake of nutrients from meat, in British Society of Animal Science, Pig and Poultry Meat Quality Genetic and Non-genetic Factors, Nottingham, Nottingham University Press, 59. GLÄSER K R, WENK C, and SCHEEDER M R L (2002), Effect of dietary mono- and polyunsaturated fatty acids on the fatty acid composition of Pigs’ Adipose Tissues, Arch Anim Nutr, 56, 51–65. GLÄSER K, WENK C, and SCHEEDER M R L (2004), Evaluation of pork backfat firmness and lard consistency using several different physicochemical methods, J Sci Food Agric, 84 (8), 853–862. GOUTEFONGEA R, and DUMONT J P (1990), Developments in low-fat meat and meat products, in Wood, J. D. and Fisher, A. V., Reducing Fat in Meat Animals, Elsevier Science Publishing Co., Inc., 398–436. GRESTI J, BUGAUT M, MANIONGUI C, and BEZARD J (1993), Composition of molecular species of triacylglycerols in bovine milk fat, J Dairy Sci, 76 (7), 1850–1869. HARRIS M, (1985), Good to Eat. Riddles of Food and Culture, Long Grove, IL, Waveland Press, Inc. HETTINGA D, (1996), Butter, in Hui, Y.H. Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 5th edn, vol. 3, New York, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., 1–63. IDF (1996), Dictionary of Dairy Terminology, 2nd edn, Amsterdam, Elsevier Science B V. JENSEN R G, (1995), Handbook of Milk Composition, San Diego, CA, Academic Press. JENSEN R G, and NEWBURG D S (1995), Milk Lipids. B. Bovine milk lipids, in Jensen R. G. Handbook of Milk Composition, San Diego, CA, Academic Press, 543–575. KEENAN T W, and PATTON S, (1995), The structure of milk: implication for sampling and storage. A. The milk lipid globule membrane, in Jensen, R. G., Handbook of Milk Composition, San Diego, CA, Academic Press, 5–49. KEMPSTER A J, (1990), Marketing procedures to change carcass composition, in Wood J. D. and Fisher, A. V., Reducing Fat in Meat Animals, London and New York, Elsevier Science Publishing Co., Inc. 437–458. KIEPPER B, (2001), Characterization of the generation, handling and treatment of spent fat, oil, and grease (FOG) from Georgia’s food service industry, available at: http:// www.engr.uga.edu/service/outreach/FOG%20Report%20Final.pdf. KIRK R S, and SAWYER R, (1991), Dairy products I, in Kirk, R.S. and Sawyer, R., Pearson’s Composition and Analysis of Foods, Harlow, Longman Scientific and Technical, 530– 574. LAWRIE R A, (1998), Lawrie’s Meat Science, 6th edn, Cambridge, Woodhead Publishing. LEFAUCHEUR L, LE DIVIDICHE J, MOUROT J, MONIN G, ECOLAN P, and KRAUSS D (1991), Influence of environmental temperature on growth, muscle and adipose tissue metabolism, and meat quality in swine, J Anim Sci, 69 (7), pp. 2844–2854. LOVE J A, (1996), Animal fats, in Hui, Y. H., Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 5th edn, vol. 1, New York, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., 1–18. EU
54
Modifying lipids for use in food
METZROTH D J, (1996), Shortening: science and technology, in Hui, Y. H., Bailey’s Industrial
Oil and Fat Products, 5th edn, vol. 3, New York, Wiley Interscience., 115–160. and ZUCKERMANN M J (2004), What’s so special about cholesterol?, Lipids, 39 (11), 1101–1113. NDC (2005) Newer knowledge of dairy foods, available at http:// www.nationaldairycouncil.org/NationalDairyCouncil/Nutrition/Products/table18.pdf. OFTEDAL O T, (2005), Milk composition, species comparison, in Pond, W. G. and Bell, A. W., Encyclopedia of Animal Science, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 625–628. PARODI P W, (2004), Milk fat in human nutrition, Aust J Dairy Technol. 59, 1, 3–59. PLUMMER T, (2004), Flaked stones and old bones: biological and cultural evolution at the dawn of technology, Yearbook of Physical Anthropology, 47, 118–164. PRICE J F, and SCHWEIGERT B S, (1987), The Science of Meat and Meat Products, 3rd edn, Westport, Food and Nutrition Press, Inc. RAEBER M, SCHEEDER M R L, OSSENT P, LISCHER CH. J, and GEYER H (2005), The content and composition of lipids in the digital cushion of the bovine claw with respect to age and location – a preliminary report, The Veterinary Journal, vol. in press. SAVELL J W, BRANSON R E, CROSS H R, STIFFLER D M, WISE J W, GRIFFIN D B, and SMITH G C (1987), National consumer retail beef study: palatability evaluations of beef loin steaks that differed in marbling, J Food Sci, 52, 517–519. SCHWÖRER D, (2004), Lipide im Schweinefleisch – Herausforderung für die Zucht, in Kreuzer M., Wenk C. and Lanzini T., Lipide in Fleisch, Milch und Ei – Herausforderung für die Tierernährun, Schriftenreihe Institut für Nutztierwissenschaften, ErnährungProdukte-Umwelt, ETH Zürich, 25, 22–36. SHEARD P R, WOOD J D, NUTE G R, and BALL R C (1998), Effects of grilling to 80 °C on the chemical composition of pork loin chops and some observations on the UK National Food Survey estimate of fat consumption, Meat Sci, 49 (2), 193–204. SOUCI FACHMANN, and KRAUT (2005), Food composition and nutrition tables. Deutsche Forschungsanstalt für Lebensmittelchemie, Garching, available at: http://www.sfkonline.net/cgi-bin/sfkstart.mysql?language=english. SPONHEIMER M, and LEE-THORP J A (2003), Differential resource utilization by extant great apes and australopithecines: towards solving the C4 conundrum, Comp Biochem Physiol A Mol Integr Physiol, 136 (1), 27–34. STANFORD C B, and BUNN H T (2001), Meat Eating and Human Evolution, Oxford, Oxford University Press. STEFANSSON V, (1945), Arctic Manual, New York, The Macmillan Company. TEUBER M, (2000), Fermented milk products, in Lund, B. M., Baird-Parker, T. C. and Gould, G. W., Microbiological Safety and Quality of Food, Gaithersburg, MD, Aspen Publishers, Inc., 535–589. TONG P S, and BERNER L A, (1994), Dairy processing and products, in Arntzen C. J. and Ritter, E. M., Encyclopedia of Agricultural Science, San Diego, CA, Academic Press, 557–574. TUFFT L A, (1996), Rendering, in Hui, Y. H., Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 5th edn, vol. 5, New York, Wiley Interscience, 1–20. VTNP (2004), Verordnung über die Entsorgung von tierischen Nebenprodukten, available at: www.admin.ch/ch/d/Sr/916–441–22/. WEGGEMANS R M, RUDRUM M, and TRAUTWEIN E A 2004, Intake of ruminant versus industrial trans fatty acids and risk of coronary heart disease – what is the evidence?, Euro. J Lipid Sci Technol, 106, 390–397. WIDMER B, (2005), Nutriswiss AG, Lyss, Switzerland, Personal Communication. WIEDERMANN L H, (1978), Margarine and margarine oil, formulation and control, J Am Oil Chem Soci, 55, 823–829. WILLIAMS M A, and HRON R J, SR. (1996), Obtaining oils and fats from source materials, in Hui, Y. H., Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 5th edn, vol. 4, New York, Wiley Interscience, 61–156. MOURITSEN O G,
Lipids from land animals 55 WOOD J D,
(1990), Consequences for meat quality of reducing carcass fatness, in Wood, J. D. and Fisher, A. V., Reducing Fat in Meat Animals, Elsevier Science Publishing Co., Inc. 344–397. WOOD J D, and FISHER A V, (1990), Reducing Fat in Meat Animals, Elsevier Science Publishing Co., Inc. WOODGATE S, (2004), Overview of the European animal by-products industry in 2003, EFPRA congress 2004; Industry Information. WOODGATE S, and VEEN J V D (2004), The role of fat processing and rendering in the European Union animal production industry, Biotechnologie, agronomie, société et environnement, 8 (4), 283–294.
4 Fish oils and lipids from marine sources B. Hjaltason, EPAX AS, Iceland and G. G. Haraldsson, University of Iceland, Iceland
4.1
Introduction
Eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and other omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) are characteristic of marine fat. Fish oils are by far the most important sources of these fatty acids. For centuries the Icelandic and Scandinavian populations have used various types of fish oil as a household remedy to fight against malnutrition, night blindness, etc. Fish oil was also an important energy supplement in the diet. It is still a common practice among Norwegians and Icelanders to take cod liver oil as a daily spoonful or in soft gelatin capsules. Fish oils were also used as animal feed and to treat various animal diseases (Hjaltason, 1989; Haraldsson and Hjaltason, 2001). Fish oil served as an essential illuminant in indoor lamps for centuries in Iceland and Scandinavia and it was used in Copenhagen to light the streets. The Icelandic name for fish oil, lysi, meaning light, refers to this important role. In the 14th century cod liver and shark liver oils were the second most valuable exports from Iceland (Hjaltason, 1989). The first known clinical test on fish oil was from a report of a study by Samuel Key, a physician at the Manchester Infirmary (Stansby, 1990). It was carried out between 1752 and 1784 and demonstrated that cod liver oil gave relief to patients suffering from rheumatoid arthritis. It was not until the beginning of the 20th century that doctors realized that cod liver oil cured rickets, which was a common disease at that time. In the 1920s it became evident that cod liver oil was a major source of vitamins A and D. Soon after, there was a strong demand for cod liver oil as a vitamin source, which peaked during and after the Second World War for the war suffering countries.
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 57 When scientists managed to produce vitamins A and D synthetically, this meant a dramatic setback for fish liver oil consumption. That situation changed considerably in the 1980s when the beneficial health effects of fish oil and fish consumption on heart diseases were observed. Fish body oil from industrial fish has been available since the beginning of the 20th century for various industrial purposes, such as in the leather industry and for making soaps and manufacturing paints. During the early decades of the 20th century, whale oil was the most valuable marine oil, but it was replaced in the 1950s by fish oil. In the 1940s fish oil became commercially available for human consumption when process technology became more sophisticated, and food manufacturers started to use partially hydrogenated fish oil in a variety of shortenings, margarines and fats for the baking and confectionery industry (Bimbo, 1987, 1989; Hjaltason, 1989; Haraldsson and Hjaltason, 2001). During the 1970s, epidemiological studies were conducted with Inuit and Japanese living by the sea. The studies showed that both populations had a relatively low incidence of coronary heart disease. This gave fish and fish oil consumption a boost in the 1980s when it became evident that the omega-3 PUFA might have beneficial effects on the heart and on cardiovascular diseases (Stansby, 1990; Simopolous, 1991; Nettleton, 1995; Lands, 2005). Several associations, such as the International Society for the Study of Fatty Acids and Lipids (ISSFAL) (www.issfal.org.uk) have now recommended intakes of marine-based omega-3 fatty acids. The American Heart Association (AHA) recommends that those that do not eat a fish meal at least two times a week should take EPA and DHA as dietary supplements (www.americanheart.org). The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the USA also approved a qualified health claim for reducing the risk of coronary heart disease for food and supplements containing omega-3 PUFAs (www.fda.gov). The new five-year dietary guidelines from the US Department of Agriculture (USDA), issued in January 2005, advise consumers to double their intake of oily fish consumption, citing evidence linking fish consumption with a reduction in cardiovascular diseases (www.health.gov/dietaryguidelines/). Finally, very recently, the Ministry of Health and Welfare in Japan issued new dietary guidelines stating minimum content of EPA and DHA that should be consumed on a weekly basis (www.mhlw.go.jp/houdou/2004/11/h1122-2.html#betu). During the 1980s scientists focused on the beneficial effects of EPA on heart diseases and inflammatory diseases. Consequently, consumers demanded concentrates with high EPA content, placing less emphasis on DHA. During the 1990s the focus turned to DHA for its beneficial effects during pregnancy and its importance in neonatal development and on development of the brain and the nervous system (Jumpsen and Clandinin, 1995; Haumann, 1997; Oski, 1997; Alexander, 1998; Newton, 1998) and various mental disorders (Soderberg et al., 1991; Horrobin, 1998). Three large epidemiological studies have clearly demonstrated that people with a regular intake of omega-3 PUFAs from seafood do not develop Alzheimer
58
Modifying lipids for use in food
dementia (AD) to the same extent as those who do not eat fish (Kalmijn et al., 1997; Barberger-Gateau et al., 2002; Editorial, 2003; Morris et al., 2003). In patients with AD the concentration of DHA is significantly lower compared with age-matched controls. Concentrated DHA has been proven to have a positive effect in clinical studies, and a number of these are still ongoing (Calon et al., 2004; Lim et al., 2005; Lukiw et al., 2005). There have also been studies indicating that DHA can be effective in weight management (Kunesova et al., 2004; Ruzickova et al., 2004). It is believed that the DHA molecule increases the oxidation of fat by switching on genes responsible for breaking it down in the body. In the last few years, new clinical studies have shown the importance of EPA to the brain. Joseph Hibbeln at National Institutes of Health (NIH) conducted a survey comparing the prevalence of severe mental depression with intake of seafood (Hibbeln, 1998). There was a clear correlation between low intake of seafood and being diagnosed with depression. When the content of omega-3 PUFAs was measured in the blood of depressive patients, it was observed that their values of EPA were significantly lower than in mentally healthy controls. Several clinical studies on the effect of EPA in treating psychotropic diseases have been published or are in progress (Tanskanen et al., 2001; Nemets et al., 2002; Peet and Horrobin, 2002; Su et al., 2003; Frasure-Smith et al., 2004). In this chapter, fish oils as a source of EPA and DHA will be discussed. The most common industrial fish oil types will be described, together with the raw material they are made from, their quantities and quality, how they are produced and refined, their availability, the reliability and stability of their sources, their stability, composition, characteristics and pollutants and their current and past utilization, future development and prospects.
4.2
Fish oils, their main characteristics and composition
Three characteristic features of fish oil make it unique compared to other commercially available oils. These are (i) the high degree of unsaturation and number of carbon atoms of the constituent fatty acids; (ii) the high content of the long-chain omega-3 type PUFAs; (iii) the great number and variety of fatty acids present in the triacylglycerols (Ackman, 1982; Ackman and Lamothe, 1989). There are more than 50 different fatty acids present in a typical fish oil. Many of them are listed in Table 4.1. They range from C14 to C24 and include saturated, monounsaturated, polyunsaturated, omega-3, omega-6, branched, odd-numbered, etc. members. In fact, several more fatty acids may be included in the table because the monounsaturated fatty acids normally exist as a mixture of several positional isomers. The omega-3 long-chain PUFAs originate in the lipids of photosynthetic micro-algae that constitute phytoplankton (Haraldsson and Hjaltason, 2001).
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 59 Table 4.1
Fatty acids found in fish oils.
12:0 14:0 14:1 15:branched 15:0 16:0 16:1 16:2 ω-7 16:2 ω-4 16:3 ω-4 16:3 ω-3 16:4 ω-4 16:4 ω-1
17:branched 17:0 17:1 18:branched 18:0 18:1 18:2 ω-9 18:2 ω-6 18:2 ω-4 18:3 ω-6 18:3 ω-3 18:4 ω-3 19:branched
19:0 19:1 20:0 20:1 20:2 20:2 20:3 20:3 20:4 20:4 20:5 21:0 21:5
ω-9 ω-6 ω-6 ω-3 ω-6 ω-3 ω-3
22:0 22:1 22:2 22:3 22:4 22:5 22:6 23:0 24:0 24:1
ω-3 ω-3 ω-3 ω-3
ω-2
They are passed up the food chain through zooplankton to the fish (Sargent et al., 1995; Henderson, 1999). Until recently, scientists believed that 22:5 omega-3 arising from the elongation of EPA was converted to DHA by the direct action of a ∆4 desaturase. Now it has been shown that in mammals and fish the 22:5 omega-3 is actually elongated to 24:5 omega-3, which in turn is ∆6 desaturated to 24:6 omega-3. Peroxisomal chain-shortening finally yields DHA (Sprecher et al., 1995). There has also been discussion about the conversion rate of α-linolenic acid (ALA) from flax seed oil into EPA in the human body. It is now clear that only a relatively small amount of ALA can be converted into EPA (and even less to DHA) and therefore ALA cannot replace fish oil as a source of EPA (Emken et al., 1994). Fish oils are virtually only triacylglycerols (TAG), but generally they contain small amounts of mono- and diacylglycerols (MAG and DAG) and minor amounts of various other non-triacylglycerol substances (Breivik and Dahl, 1992; Bimbo, 1998). Some of these minor substances may influence the flavour and odour quality of the oil and affect the stability of the oil as well as its safety. Refining of the oil aims at removing these substances while retaining desirable features. Undesirable substances include moisture, insoluble impurities, free fatty acids, trace metals, oxidation products, sulfur, halogen and nitrogen compounds, pigments, sterols and organic contaminants from the environment such as polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and dioxins. Several different chemical parameters are used to judge the quality of fish oil. In the European Pharmacopoeia there are monographs for different fish oils as well as fish liver oils. There are monographs for plain fish oils as well as omega-3 PUFA concentrates, either as TAG or as ethyl esters (European Pharmacopoeia, 2005). In 2001, the Council for Responsible Nutrition (CRN) in the USA formed an omega-3 working group consisting of 18 ingredient suppliers and manufacturers of omega-3 PUFA. The first action of this group was to define a quality standard which led to a CRN voluntary (unofficial and not obligatory) monograph on fish oil (www.crnusa.org). The US
60
Modifying lipids for use in food
Pharmacopoeia is now planning to adopt fish oil and fish oil concentrate monographs similar to the EU monographs. These give maximum values on quality-related issues such as colour, acid value and oxidative parameters as well as content of environmental pollutants such as organochlorine pesticides and heavy metals. Fish oils contain unsaponifiable matter which varies largely with the type of fish oil and includes sterols, hydrocarbons, glyceryl ethers and fatty alcohols as well as traces of pigments, vitamins and oxidized oil. Total cholesterol (free cholesterol and its fatty esters) is often a major part of the unsaponifiables of fish oils. It is possible to remove the free cholesterol by vacuum stripping of the oil, but this does not remove the esterified cholesterol. The potential use of cholesterol esterase to convert the esterified cholesterol into free cholesterol, that can be removed, is under investigation by the industry. Fish oils from different sources have different ratios of esterified cholesterol and free cholesterol, although the total cholesterol is usually of comparable content (de Koning, 1992). Besides environmental pollutants which are defined in the Pharmacopoeias, new pollutants have been coming up, although maximum limits have not yet been defined. This applies to brominated compounds used as fire retardants. When released into the marine environment, these slow-degrading fat-soluble compounds accumulate in fat tissues of fish and other marine organisms. Other pollutants include trace metals such as iron and copper which are considered as pro-oxidants in fish oils, but these are removed during degumming and refining. Heavy metals include arsenic, lead, mercury, selenium and cadmium which are present in trace amounts but are largely removed by refining. Most fish oils used for human consumption now undergo molecular distillation in order to remove all environmental pollutants down to negligible levels. It is usual to distinguish between industrial fish body oil and fish liver oil such as cod liver oil. Lean fish species such as cod and pollack possess a large liver from which fish liver oil is produced. This is usually a high quality oil used as medicinal fish oil, cod liver oil being one example (Hjaltason, 1992). Sprat and blue whiting belong to the same family as cod. Fatty fish species such as herring, capelin, sardine, mackerel, anchovy, sand eel, menhaden, sprat and blue whiting usually have a small liver and the bulk of the fatty oil is present in the fatty flesh of the fish. This is the main source of commercial fish oil. A minor source is the scrap which remains after edible fish has been filleted, the most important products being tuna oil and salmon oil. The bulk of the fish body oil is produced in association with fish meal by the wet-rendering process (Hjaltason, 1989; Bimbo, 1998; Haraldsson and Hjaltason, 2001). There is a considerable variation of fatty acid composition of fish oils among different fish species. This is apparent from Table 4.2, which shows the typical fatty acid composition of most common types of commercially available fish and other marine oils. For the sake of interest, typical whale
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 61 Table 4.2
Typical fatty acid composition of various commercially available fish oils.
Fatty acid
Anchovya
Jack Menhadena mackerela
Sardine/ pilcharda
Capelina
Herringa
14:0 15:0 16:0 16:1 17:0 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3 ω-3 18:4 ω-3 20:1 22:1 20:5 ω-3 22:5 ω-3 22:6 ω-3 Others
9 1 17 13 1 3 10 1 1 2 1 1 22 2 9 7
8 1 18 8 1 3 16 1 1 2 2 1 13 2 15 8
9 1 19 12 1 3 11 1 1 3 1 – 14 2 8 14
8 1 18 10 1 3 13 1 1 3 4 3 16 2 9 7
7 – 10 10 – 1 14 1 1 3 17 15 8 – 6 7
7 – 17 6 – 2 14 1 2 3 15 19 6 1 6 1
Fatty acid
Mackerel
Norwaya pout
Sand eela
Sprata
Tunaa
Cod liver oilb
14:0 15:0 16:0 16:1 17:0 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3 ω-3 18:4 ω-3 20:1 22:1 20:5 ω-3 22:5 ω-3 22:6 ω-3 Others
8 – 14 7 – 2 13 1 1 4 12 15 7 1 8 7
5 – 12 4 – 3 10 1 1 3 13 17 9 1 14 7
7 1 13 5 – 2 7 2 1 5 12 18 11 1 11 4
– – 17 7 – 2 16 2 2 – 10 14 6 1 9 14
3 1 22 3 1 6 21 1 1 1 1 3 6 2 22 6
3 – 10 7 – 2 24 1 1 2 13 10 8 1 11 7
Continued overleaf
oil, seal oil and shark liver oil have been included in the table. Earlier, certain types of shark liver oil together with the liver oils of various other species of elasmobranch fish such as dogfish were important sources of squalene which was hydrogenated into squalane for the cosmetics industry. Shark and dogfish livers also contain glyceryl ethers which are of interest to the health industry (Mangold and Palthauf, 1983; Kayama and Mankura, 1998; Sargent, 1989). With increased farming of fish types such as salmon
62
Modifying lipids for use in food
Table 4.2 Continued Fatty acid
Minke whalec
Harp sealc
Greenland sharkd
Farmed salmond
Blue whitingb
14:0 15:0 16:0 16:1 17:0 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3 ω-3 18:4 ω-3 20:1 22:1 20:5 ω-3 22:5 ω-3 22:6 ω-3 Others
7 – 10 10 – 2 21 – 1 – 16 10 4 2 5 10
7 – 9 13 – 1 18 – 1 – 13 6 8 3 10 11
1 – 7 5 – 2 27 1 – 1 23 14 3 2 6 8
5 – 12 6 – 3 20 3 1 2 10 9 7 3 11 7
4 – 12 6 – 2 16 1 1 2 14 16 9 1 10 6
a
Bimbo (1998) with kind permission of A P Bimbo J Ogmundssen, Lysi hf, Iceland (unpublished, 2004) c Myrnes et al. (1995) d S Viglundsdottir and B Hjaltason, Lysi hf quality control laboratory (unpublished). b
and cod, new sources of salmon oil and cod liver oil are available. The composition of fish oil made from farmed fish may be quite different from that made from wild fish, and this reflects the different fatty acid composition of their feed. New monographs for farmed fish oils and fish liver oils are in preparation (European Pharmacopoeia, 2005). Although the fatty acid composition of each species in Table 4.2 should not be looked upon as absolute, the profiles of each species can usually be used as a fingerprint characteristic of the type of fish oil (European Pharmacopoeia, 2005). When fish oil is sold based on fish types it is made from, it is not uncommon to mix in cheaper low quality fish oils to match the fatty acid composition of the original oil. This applies particularly to more expensive liver oils such as cod liver oil. One way of investigating the origin of fish oils is to employ 13C NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance) analysis technique to determine the distribution of certain fatty acids including EPA and DHA into the sn-1/3 and sn-2 positions of the triacylglycerols (Aursand et al., 1994). This distribution can be quite characteristic of certain species of fish oil and may be used together with the fatty acid composition as a protection against adulteration. The new monograph for farmed salmon oil in the EU Pharmacopoeia includes this method to minimize the risk of blends (European Pharmacopoeia, 2005). In some respects, the fatty acid profiles of these oils differ considerably, in other respects there is a strong resemblance between them. This has been discussed in detail by Ackman (Ackman, 1986; Ackman et al., 1988). There
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 63 is a very high content of 20:1 and 22:1 in some of the fish oils from the North Atlantic, such as capelin, blue whiting and herring, while fish oils originated from South American fish are instead higher in EPA and DHA. This makes anchovy and sardine oils the best starting material to make concentrated omega-3 PUFA. These high levels of monounsaturates are believed to be of dietary origin (Ackman, 1982). Generally in fish the mid-position of the glycerol moiety is more enriched with the PUFA, especially DHA. It is interesting that in the TAG oil of marine mammals, including whale oil and seal oil, this is reversed and the mid-position is less enriched with the PUFA. This was established by Brockerhoff and published in numerous papers and has been summarized in a concise form (Ackman and Lamothe, 1989; Ackman and Ratnayake, 1989; Hölmer, 1989). In the light of the fact that the Inuit ate seal fat, not fish, as pointed out by Ackman (Ackman and Ratnayake, 1989; Ackman, 1988), this may be significant. It may also become interesting with regard to structured lipids. Another interesting fact about the marine mammal oils is their high content of docosapentaenoic acid, 22:5 omega-3 (DPA), which is almost equal in quantity to DHA. Possible beneficial health effects of that fatty acid have been pointed out in relation to the Inuit diet (Ackman and Eaton, 1988). In fish the omega-3 fatty acids are not only confined to the TAG, but can be also found as phospholipids (PL) (Vaskovsky, 1989), which are major constituents of the cell membranes. In fish they are much more highly enriched with EPA and particularly DHA, than the TAG, with 40–55 % EPA plus DHA content not uncommon. Phosphatidylcholine (PC) and phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) are two of the main phospholipid constituents in fish. The former usually accounts for 60–70 % of the phospholipids whereas the latter counts for 20–30 %. Phosphatidylinositol (PI) and phosphatidylserine (PS) are usually far less abundant. Based on body weight, the total PL content of fish is much lower than the TAG, usually around 1–1.5 % as compared to 10–15 %, roughly. The percentage fatty acid composition of cod phospholipids as typical fish phospholipids (Haraldsson et al., 1993) is shown in Table 4.3. It is noteworthy that only four fatty acids account for most of the fatty acids in fish phospholipids, 16:0, 18:1, EPA and DHA, with 18:0 very high in the PI/ PS fraction. It is of particular interest to notice that the DHA content of PC is 30 % and nearly 47 % in PE. It is unlikely that the marine derived phospholipids will be viable as a bulk source of EPA and DHA due to their low content in fish. Today, there is a small commercial production of marine-based phospholipids extracted from krill, fish roes and squid (www.neptunebiotech.com; www.bizen.co.jp; www.nof.co.jp; www.phosphotech.com; www.eximo.no). This is used as an ingredient in special feed formulas for fish larvae and also to some extent as a dietary supplement. In the latter case, the marine-based PLs are then blended with other types of oil, due to high price of the phospholipids and also to make them more fluid since pure PLs are in the form of a paste. Marine
64
Modifying lipids for use in food
Table 4.3 Fatty acid composition of total phospholipids and individual phospholipid classes from cod fillets. Fatty acid
Total PL
PC
PE
PS/PI
14:0 16:0 16:1 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:4 ω-3 20:1 20:4 ω-6 20:5 ω-3 22:1 22:5 ω-3 22:6 ω-3 Others
1.2 20.9 1.7 2.6 9.2 1.4 0.4 1.5 2.3 17.2 0.1 1.2 34.6 5.7
1.5 27.5 1.7 0.8 9.9 0.2 0.2 1.1 1.7 18.6 0.1 1.0 29.6 6.1
0.5 7.8 0.8 5.0 14.2 0.7 0.1 3.6 1.4 10.6 0.2 1.7 46.8 6.6
1.0 3.5 1.1 30.5 12.8 0.3 0.3 3.5 3.3 7.3 0.6 0.9 27.3 7.6
Abbreviations: PC = phosphatidylcholine, PE = phosphatidylethanolamine, PL = phospholipids, PS/ PI = phosphatidylserine/phosphatidylinositol.
phospholipids have been observed to play an important role as a feed ingredient in halibut and fish aquaculture. When such marine PL were included in the lipid feed constituent, the survival rate of halibut larvae going through the complicated metamorphosis phase to healthy halibut juveniles increased dramatically (Hjaltason et al., 2005). There might also be an interesting application of marine-based PL for use in infant formula since DHA in the mother’s milk is in the PL form.
4.3
Production of fish oil
Almost all the fish oil produced today can be considered as a by-product of the fish meal industry. The main emphasis is on the meal production which is usually more valuable and has higher demand than fish oil. The quality of the crude fish oil has improved considerably in recent years. The main reason for this is a demand from the fish feed industry that fish meal produced for aquaculture feed should be produced only from very fresh fish. Some of the farmed fish species such as salmon are sensitive to meal produced from stale raw material. The use of fresh raw material also offers a better quality of fish oil. Crude fish oil is produced in the following manner (Hjaltason, 1989; Bimbo, 1998; Haraldsson and Hjaltason, 2001): after the fish have been caught and landed, they are stored in holding pits at the factory until fed into the cooker. The raw fish material is heated to 100°C by steam as it passes through the cooker. Next, the liquid consisting of water, oil and fine solids
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 65 is removed. A decanter removes the small particles from the oil and water before going into a centrifuge which separates the oil from the water. Occasionally, an extra centrifugation step is added to purify the oil, since traces of protein and moisture affect the stability of the oil during storage. Finally the oil is cooled and stored. The oil from this process is crude fish oil. Figure 4.1 illustrates the crude fish oil production. Most of the fish oil required for fish and animal feed is used in the crude form. If used for human consumption, such as raw material for concentrated omega-3 products, or as an ingredient in functional food, it goes through classical processing. The crude oil is occasionally pre-treated with acid to remove any gum material or phospholipids that might interfere with the quality of the final product, although this step is often eliminated for fish oil. The next step is neutralization, where the free fatty acids are removed from the oil. The amount of free fatty acids varies, mainly in accordance with the freshness of the raw material used in the fish oil production. If they are not removed, the taste of the oil will be affected. The most common way to remove the free fatty acids from the fish oil is to add caustic soda to the oil in order to neutralize the free acids. The soap is then removed with water in a centrifuge. Finally, the oil is dried before bleaching. The bleaching process is used to remove undesirable colour compounds from the oil as well as other impurities and, to some extent, pollutants. This is done by adding powdered clay or earth that adsorbs the undesirable compounds. Afterwards, the oil is filtered for removal of the bleaching material. This process is also used to standardize the colour of the oil. In recent years, it has become more common to use silica material and activated carbon besides the bleaching earth. The activated carbon removes dioxins and, to some extent, PCBs from the oil while selected silica material removes metals such as iron and copper. In some cases the oil is winterized. This process removes the higher melting triacylglycerols (stearin) from the oil. The oil is slowly cooled to aid formation of suitable crystals of higher melting glycerol esters that are then separated from the liquid. After this process the oil can be stored at low temperature without becoming cloudy. The final step in classical processing of fish oil is deodorization. This process removes the volatile compounds that are the main cause of the strong fishy odour and flavour of the oil. The concentration of these compounds is usually between 200 and 1000 ppm before deodorization. During this process the oil is heated up to 150–190 °C, depending on the degree of unsaturation of the oil, at a vacuum of 1–3 Torr. Then, the oil is stripped with steam which removes the unwanted components. Afterwards, the oil is cooled and is ready for use. In recent years another processing step has been added to the fish oil that is used (non-hydrogenated) for human consumption or as starting material for the concentration process of omega-3 fatty acids. This is molecular distillation. Due to increased pollution of the oceans, fish oils contain some
Cooker Raw fish tank
Strainer Press
Conveyer Press cake Press liquid
Raw material Decanter
Weighing
Sludge Soluble Evaporator
Centrifuge Oil
Concentrate
Oil tank
Mixer
Oil centrifuge
Meal tanks
Dryer
Meal Screener
Fig. 4.1
Tank
Stickwater
Mill
Meal cooler
Flow sheet of crude fish oil production from fish meal process (courtesy of Professor Sigurjon Arason).
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 67 pesticides and other organic pollutants (MAFF UK, 1997). This includes dioxins, PCBs, hexachlorobenzene (HCB), hexachlorocyclohexane (HCH), lindane and DDT. With better analytical methods and more concern about the long-term effect on human health of those compounds, the authorities are declaring new and lower maximum limits for such contaminants. Unfortunately new threats are on the horizon, such as brominated compounds used as flame retardants. These are now found in crude fish oil, but no maximum values have yet been defined for them. They are also efficiently removed by molecular distillation. Some companies have developed their own purification technology such as Pronova Biocare’s based on molecular distillation (Breivik and Thorstad, 2005) and Lysi hf that holds a patent on purification technology based on adsorption instead of distillation (Hjaltason, 2002). This method needs less investment than that based on molecular distillation. Croda in the UK is using a method based on super-refining to purify their oils (Coupland and Langley, 1995). Some of these methods remove not only the pollutants, but also certain oxidation products. In most cases there are also some losses of oil. The cost varies between methods, and it limits what kind of oils these techniques can be applied to. High vacuum distillation is a very effective way to remove all contaminants towards detection limits. However, investment in equipment is rather high and in addition both vitamins and natural antioxidants are very often removed from the oil. Table 4.4 shows the maximum limits on pollutants in fish oil according to the CRN voluntary fish oil monograph (www.crnusa.org) and the European Pharmacopoeia. Crude fish liver oil such as cod liver oil is processed in a very similar manner as crude fish oil. The raw material is the liver of the fish. Formerly, most of the fish was gutted on land and the liver separated from the viscera Table 4.4 Limits on pollutants according to the European Pharmacopoeia (PhEur/EU) and the USA voluntary monograph (USA vol. mono.). Pollutant
Units
PhEur/EU
USA vol. mono.
As Cd Hg Pb DDD1 DDE2 DDT3 HCB PCBs Dioxins
mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg mg/kg pg/g
NA NA 0.5 0.1
0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.09 2
1
2
Sum: o,p′+ p,p′ p,p′ 3 Sum o,p′+ p,p′ Abbreviations: DDD = dichlorodiphenyldichloroethane, DDE = dichlorodiphenyldichloroethene, DDT = dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane, DCB = dichlorobenzene, HCB = hexacholorobenzene. 2
68
Modifying lipids for use in food
and trucked to the rendering plant. Nowadays, more and more fish are gutted at sea and the livers collected in containers that are then transported to the rendering plant after the boats have landed their catches. This is a very fresh material. After arriving at the rendering plant the liver is ground and then heated to a certain temperature in order to release the oil from the liver residue. Then, the liver mass is put through a decanter that removes solid parts before it goes to the centrifuges. The centrifuges are three-phase, separating the liver mass into crude oil, water and sludge. The crude oil is taken for further processing, but the residue can be dried and used in feed. Today, most of the cod liver meal is used in Southeast Asia as a chemoattractant for the shrimp feed industry due to its strong smell and taste. Omega-3 oils can also be extracted from oil-rich algae (Haumann, 1998; Henderson, 1999). The algae have been modified to increase the oil content and, subsequently, the amount of omega-3 fatty acids. The oil contains almost exclusively DHA which is used in infant formula. This is a rather costly ingredient and can be used only in expensive products. The American-based company Martek has a patented technology to produce DHA-rich algae oil that is now used in at least 70 % of the global infant formula market (www.martek.com). With improved technology and lower production costs, the functional food and dietary supplement market is starting to use algaebased oil to some extent. The whole algae can also be used as a feed ingredient for animals. Omega-3 eggs are today produced by hens given feed that includes omega-3 rich dried algae (Haumann, 1998).
4.4
Fish oil stability and protection
Antioxidants are very important to prevent both the crude as well as the fully-processed oil from being oxidized. Crude fish oil always contains some natural antioxidants. The most common is vitamin E, but it also contains colorants such as astaxthanthin which has been shown to be effective as an antioxidant. Eight different substances that have vitamin E activity occur in nature. They belong to two familes with the generic names tocopherols and tocotrienols. The members of each family are designated with the names α, β, γ or δ, depending on the position and number of the methyl groups attached to the chromane ring (Schuler, 1990). α-Tocopherol displays the highest vitamin E activity. It is also most effective in vivo as a radical scavenger but offers limited protection against oxidation in the oil. The most effective in vitro protectant is the δ-tocopherol. Fish oil and fish liver oil have different amounts of each type of tocopherol. Cod liver oil contains more than 90 % of its vitamin E as α-tocopherol. During processing, some of the natural antioxidants are removed. Figure 4.2 shows how fish oil becomes less and less stable after each processing step (Bragadottir M, Thorisson S and Hjaltason B, unpublished results).
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 69
Oxygen uptake (µg/mol)
200 180
Crude Bleached
160
Deodorized
140
Neutralized
120 100 80 60 40 20 0 0.000
0.050
Fig. 4.2
0.100
0.150 0.200 Time (h)
0.250
0.300
0.350
The effect of processing on capelin oil stability.
Crude capelin oil was taken through the processing stages of refining, bleaching and deodorization. At each step, a sample was taken and the oxygen uptake measured with a Warburg apparatus. Oxidative stability was considerably lower in the fully-processed oil compared to the crude oil. This indicates the importance of the oil being well protected during processing and stabilizing the final product. Traces of metal ions such as copper and iron are strongly pro-oxidant. They are partly removed during bleaching, but it is possible to bind these ions to compounds such as EDTA that inactivate them. Therefore, it is always important to use equipment made of stainless steel, work as much as possible under an inert nitrogen atmosphere, and keep the temperature low during processing where possible. Antioxidants are always added to processed fish oil for human consumption to protect the oil against oxidation and keep the taste and smell of the oil as good as possible. Natural antioxidants are preferred. Blends of α-, β-, γ- and δ-tocopherols are most commonly used. Other natural antioxidants used include ascorbic acid, spice extracts, such as rosemary, and citric acid (Rajalakshmi and Narasimhan, 1996). Many producers of fish oil use their own antioxidant formulas based on different blends of the available natural antioxidants. In most cases they are looking for synergistic effects of the individual antioxidants. Some of the antioxidants also seem to have different degrees of efficiency in keeping down the undesirable smell and taste of the oil caused by compounds such as volatile ketones and aldehydes. The synergistic effect permits the reduction of the level of antioxidants added to food formulation considerably (Coppen, 1989). Synthetic antioxidants are also available and are, in most cases, more effective than natural antioxidants. Although some of them have been available
70
Modifying lipids for use in food
for almost half a century, very few have gained widespread approval or popularity. The most commonly used synthetic antioxidants are butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA), butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT), tertbutylhydroquinone TBHQ and propyl gallate (Frankel, 1998). TBHQ has been shown to be a very effective antioxidant for fish oils. Unfortunately, TBHQ is not approved for use in Europe so its use is confined to the USA. Uses of synthetic antioxidants are in decline due to the perception that natural food ingredients are better and safer than synthetic. There are other ways to protect the oil from oxidation that are based on eliminating access of oxygen to the oil. One is soft gelatine capsules, which are commonly used in the dietary supplement industry. This is also a convenient dosage form. Studies have shown that the oil is stable for at least three years based on analysis of oxidative parameters (Nutrition Industry Executive, 2005: www.niemagazine.com). Recently, smaller gelatin beadlets are gaining popularity since they can be mixed into food products. Microencapsulation technology has advanced very much in recent years (Newton, 1996; Shelke, 2005). This technique provides an oxidatively stable free-flowing powder. The main problem has been that the microencapsulated product picks up a fishy smell and taste during storage, giving it a relatively short shelf life. Therefore, microencapsulated fish oil products are used in products that have a short shelf life in the shops such as bread, milk and yoghurt. Another limiting factor has been the bioavailability of the powder. If the coating material or matrix used is too ‘strong’, the bioavailability is less but the product has a longer shelf life. So far, this technology has mainly been used on non-concentrated fish oil, but technological improvements have opened up the potential to microencapsulate highly concentrated omega3 fish oils. There are also other methods available to protect PUFAs against oxidation, such as liposomes (Haumann, 1995). Emulsions are also promising for uses in fresh and pasteurized milk as well as enrichment of UHT (ultra high temperature) milk (www.dsmnutritionalproducts.com).
4.5
Commercial fish oils
Compared to the worldwide production of fats and oils, global production of fish oil is rather small (1–2 %). Since 1995, the average world production of fish oil has been around 1.14 million tonnes (ISTA Mielke GmbH, Oil World, Hamburg, www.oilworld.biz). There have been some fluctuations in fish oil production, basically due to the El Niño phenomenon (www.elnino.noaa.gov) which changed conditions in the ocean along the coastline of Peru and Chile, causing the fish to move to deeper waters. This caused a 34 % reduction in pelagic fisheries and fish oil production in South America between 1997 and 1998 (Oil World Annual, 1998; www.gafta.com/fin/finfacts3.html). This can be clearly seen in Figure 4.3 showing the world fish oil production 1990–
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 71 1600
1505
Thousand tonnes
1200
1417
1336 1381
1400 1264 1237
1354 1194
1142
1065
1042 1000 865
993 904
887
800 600 400 200 0 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 Year
Fig. 4.3
World fish oil production in 1990–2004.
2004 (Stuart Barlow and Ian Pike, personal communication; ISTA Mielke GmbH, Oil World, Hamburg, www.oilworld.biz). Very little is known about what causes the El Niño phenomenon and, therefore, it is very difficult to predict when it may happen. Peru and Chile are the leading producers of fish oil in a normal year, followed by the USA, Iceland, Denmark and Norway. In the 1980s Japan was a large producer of fish oil, but sardines disappeared in 1992 from Japanese waters. Today, Japan is an importer of fish oil instead of being one of the biggest exporters as it was only 20 years ago. The largest users of fish oil are Chile and Norway, since major application of crude fish oil is in salmon feed. Chile has now to import fish oil from Peru in order to meet its needs and Norway is now the largest single importer of fish oil in the world. Peru is by far the largest exporter of fish oil due to low domestic uses of fish oil. The fish oil export from Peru is around 39 % of worldwide export of fish oil for 2004 (ISTA Mielke GmbH, Oil World, Hamburg, www.oilworld.biz), but the average fish oil production for the last 20 years has ranged between 1.0 to 1.7 million tonnes, except for 1992 and 1998, when the effect of El Niño caused reduced production (www.gafta.com/ fin/finfacts3.html). Fish oil is produced mainly from pelagic fish and is a by-product of the fish meal industry. The landings of industrial feed grade fish have according to the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) been fairly stable since 1985 at around 20–25 million tonnes per year apart from the years when the effects of El Ninjo reduced these numbers considerably. In general, feed grade fish are short-lived and fast growing and are therefore less vulnerable to overfishing compared to other species. Due to the rapid growth of aquaculture which creates a greater demand for fish oil for feed production, there has been an increase in focus and
72
Modifying lipids for use in food
discussion on sustainability of these fisheries. Sustainability was defined by the World Commission on Environment and Development in 1987 as ‘Development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs’ (Shepherd et al., 2005). Table 4.5 shows the status of feed grade fish stocks in Europe and South America based on information from the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES), Institutio del Mar del Peru (IMARPE) and FAO’s report on the ‘State of World Fisheries and Future Sustainability Issues’ (see Shepherd et al., 2005). The European and South American feed grade fish stocks are monitored by government agencies. Overfishing from these feed grade fish stocks is prevented by fishing quotas as well as periodic fishing bans during spawning. There are, however, cases where fish stocks have been overfished, as is the case with blue whiting in Europe, due to disagreement between governments and consequent failure to set up official quotas. In late 2005 the governments involved finally agreed on official quotas which it is hoped will help the stock of blue whiting to recover. Fish liver oil, where the raw material is only the liver, is also produced. This is produced in relatively small quantities for speciality uses such as vitamins A and D. Today, cod liver oil and shark liver oil are the most common commercially available fish liver oils on the market. Earlier, halibut liver oil was commercially produced as a vitamin A supplement, but it is no longer economical to collect and produce that oil. The world production of cod liver oil today for human uses is around 10000 tonnes, but figures for shark liver oil are not available. Historically, marine mammal oils, such as whale oil and seal oil, were produced in large quantities. Today, there is no commercial supply of whale oil due to the ban on whale hunting and the sale of whale products, but seal oil is still produced in small amounts. With increasing production of farmed salmon, farmed salmon oil has become available. It is produced from waste from the salmon processors and is of high quality due to the freshness of the raw material. Using farmed salmon oil in fish feed is not allowed so the main application has been in the pet food industry. There is some interest in finding an application for farmed salmon oil as a food ingredient, an area in which Norway is in lead. Although the wild salmon catch is rather large in areas like Alaska, commercial salmon oil from wild salmon has never been produced to any great extent. Recently, tuna oil has also become commercially available. However, production remains rather small, mainly based on tuna heads and trimmings from the tuna canning factories. Thailand and Australia are two of the biggest producers of tuna oil today. The basic use of tuna oil is in infant formula and as a food ingredient. The main interest in tuna oil is related to its high DHA and low EPA content. Companies with products based on omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil have also started to look for supplies other than fish oil for these fatty acids. The
Table 4.5
Status of feed grade fish stocks.
Europe Capelin Blue whiting Sandeel
Whether used for human consumption
Commentary on status of fish stocks at December 2004
Source of status info
Roe used for human consumption. Frozen capelin for specific markets. Mainly used for fish meal. Potential use for human consumption although there are processing difficulties. Mainly used for fish meal. Not used for human consumption.
Icelandic – present state not known. Barents Sea – reduced reproductive capacity – no fishing recommended Spring 05. Stock classified as having full reproductive capacity, but harvested unsustainably. Spawning stock has remained stable at a high level 2002–2004. Stock classified as having reduced reproductive capacity. 21 % reduction in quota on 2005 over 2004. State of the stock is unknown. Indications of a good 2003 class recruiting to the 2004 fishery. 4 % increase in quota. There are five herring stocks. Three have full reproductive capacity, harvested sustainability, one has full reproductive capacity but harvested unsustainably and the 5th has very low abundance.
ICES
Sprat
Potential uses for human consumption, but mainly used for fish meal.
Herring
Primarily used for human consumption, but non-food grade fish and trimmings may be used for fish meal.
Trimmings
Trimmings generally comprise small pelagic species (50 %), i.e. mackerel and herring and trimmings from the food fish processing sector i.e. cod (50 %).
South America Anchovy
Very small amount for human consumption. Majority used for fish meal.
Jack mackerel
Used for human consumption (Africa). Majority used for fish meal.
Horse mackerel Sardine
Primarily used for human consumption. Primarily used for human consumption.
Biomass increasing following 97/98 El Niño. Controlled by licensing, satellite tracking, closed seasons, minimum landing size. Biomass increasing following 97/98 El Niño. Controlled by catch limits, satellite tracking, closed seasons and minimum landing size. Closed seasons, company catch limits. Closed seasons, company catch limits.
ICES ICES ICES ICES
FAO/IMARPE FAO/IMARPE FAO/IMARPE FAO/IMARPE
Abbreviations: FAO = Food and Agriculture Organization, ICES = International Council for Exploration of the Seas, IMARPE = Peruvian Institute of the Sea. Source: European Aquaculture Society Special Publication No 35, June 2005, 59–66 (www.easonline.org/home/en).
74
Modifying lipids for use in food
most interesting are the marine organisms that produce omega-3 fatty acids (Haumann, 1998; Henderson, 1999). Bacteria, eukaryotic micro-algae, fungi and zooplankton are all interesting options. In terms of alternatives to fish oil as a source of omega-3 fatty acids, single-cell marine organisms offer the most realistic potential in the near future. Major US companies have also laid out their plans to genetically modify plant seeds in order to accumulate significant levels of EPA and DHA in the seed (Napier, 2004; Qi et al., 2004; Wu et al., 2005). Such oils might reduce the dependence of the fish feed industry on fish oil as a feed ingredient, although no cost structure is available yet. It is likely that such oils will be available commercially in 5–10 years’ time. Although such oils might be acceptable in the USA, consumers in Europe might reject them due to hostility towards the idea of genetic modification.
4.6
Fish oil application
There have been dramatic changes in the uses of fish oil in the last ten years. In 1990 around 76 % of the fish oil was used as raw material in margarines (after partial hydrogenation). Due to new information concerning negative health aspects of consumption of trans fatty acids (Katan, 1995; Ascherio et al., 1999) produced during the hydrogenation process, their use in margarine has fallen dramatically. Some countries have also enacted legislation stating maximum amounts of trans fatty acids in products such as margarines. The USA has set up a regulation from 1st of January 2006 that trans content must be declared on labels (Federal Register, 2003). In 2002 only 14 % (Barlow S and Pike I, personal communication) of fish oil was hydrogenated for uses in margarine and this is expected to fall to less than 1 % in the year 2012. This has, however, not affected the fish oil market too badly since at the same time the aquaculture industry is demanding more and more fish oil as a fish feed ingredient. The fish oil is not only used as an inexpensive energy source, but also as an omega-3 source for the farmed fish. In 1990 the aquafeed industry used 16 % of the fish oil production and in 2002 this number was up to 81 % (Stuart Barlow and Ian Pike; International Fish Meal and Fish Oil Organization: www.iffo.net). In 2012 it might rise to 88 %. Today, Norway is the biggest user of fish oil in their salmon feed. Their estimated annual need is around 190 000 tonnes. China is, however, the biggest producer of farmed fish. So far, their fish farming is not very industrialized and is based very much on fresh water fish species or species that do not need fish meal or oil in their diet, such as tilapia. However, China is becoming a larger buyer of fish meal and fish oil which might affect the balance between supply and demand of fish oil in near future. Figure 4.4 compares the use of fish oil for the years 1990, 2002 and 2012. The market for non-hydrogenated fish oil as functional food or food ingredient as well as for dietary supplements, fish oil concentrates and
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 75 2002
1990 Aquafeed 16 %
Edible 76 %
Edible 14 %
Industrial 8%
Total production 975 TT
Industrial 8%
Total production 1.3 MT
Aquafeed 78 %
2012 Industrial + other animals 7%
Edible 5% Total production 1.1 MT
Aquafeed 88 %
Fig. 4.4 Summary of global fish oil use for the periods 1990, 2002 and 2012 (TT = thousand tonnes, MT = million tonnes).
pharmaceuticals is still very small. Only 1–2 % of the world production of fish oil goes into this application. So far, the main application of fish oil as an omega-3 source has been in the dietary supplement industry. At present most of the oil sold for this application is non-concentrated oil containing 18 % EPA and 12 % DHA. In recent years, more concentrated omega-3 products have been on the market with specific amounts and ratios of EPA and DHA intended to treat certain medical conditions such as arthritis and CVD or to enhance mental health. The fastest growth is likely to be in the food ingredient sector or as an ingredient for functional food. Organizations and government bodies are now giving specific recommendations and advice about intake of omega-3 fatty acids. Different bodies (Hornstra, 2004), such as British Nutrition Foundation, Nordic Council of Ministers, Health and Welfare in Canada, American Heart Association as well as the Ministry of Health and Welfare in Japan (www.mhlw.go.jp/houdou/2004/11/h1122-2.html#betu) have issued guidelines regarding intake of omega-3 fatty acids and also, in numerous cases the omega-6/omega-3 ratio. Generally, 0.6–1.0 g of omega-3 fatty acids in the form of EPA and DHA is recommended as a daily intake, but if the omega-3 fatty acids are used to treat specific diseases, a higher dosage is needed. Today, the situation is such that a ‘normal’ diet in the Western world only supplies about 10–15 % of the recommended daily intake of the omega-3 fatty acids. The challenge for the oil and fats industry is to close this ‘nutritional gap’ by increasing the consumption of omega-3 fatty acids, either by adding omega-3 oil into food products or by dietary supplements. With improved quality, new technology to protect the oil and increasing consumer awareness of the health benefits of the omega-3 fatty acids, it is probable that a larger
76
Modifying lipids for use in food
part of the fish oil will be used for food application as an omega-3 source in the near future. Government regulations that limit the use of health claims might slow down the use of omega-3 in fortified food products. Research into the biological and clinical effects of omega-3 fatty acids has created several pharmaceutical products. Most of them are highly concentrated products, but one of the first was MaxEPA® (Sevenseas Healthcare Ltd, UK, www.sseas.com) containing 18 % EPA and 12 % DHA, which was registered as a drug for hyperlipidemia. Epadel was developed by the Japanese company Mochida in cooperation with Nippon Suisan Kaisha (www.nissui.co.jp). This is a highly concentrated EPA product. It was first approved in 1990 for arteriosclerosis obliterans (ASO) and in 1994 for hyperlipidemia. Recently, Pronova Biocare from Norway gained approval for their highly concentrated EPA pharmaceutical product named Omacor® (www.pronova.com). This is an 85 % EPA + DHA ethyl ester concentrate. This drug is now sold in Europe for secondary myocardial infarction and recently gained marketing approval in the USA for lowering blood fat. Clinical trials on the effects of highly purified EPA on schizophrenia and against Hodgkinson’s disease are now going on. Although these products are highly concentrated, they will not need large volumes of crude fish oil for their production. Makers of fish oil for the food, dietary supplement and pharmaceutical industries will always be able to compete in price with the feed makers. Since sustainability of pelagic fisheries is also responsibly managed, we should not face any shortage of fish oil in the coming years. Also, new sources as from algae or genetically modified plant seeds will be more commercially available and feasible in coming years.
4.7
References
(1982), Fatty acid composition of fish oils, in Barlow S M and Stansby M E, Nutritional Evaluation of Long-Chain Fatty Acids in Fish Oils, New York, Academic Press, 25–88. ACKMAN R G (1986), Perspectives on eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA), n-3 News, 1(4), 1–4. ACKMAN R G (1988), Some possible effects on lipid biochemistry of differences in the distribution on glycerol of long-chain n-3 fatty acids in the fats of marine fish and marine mammals, Atherosclerosis, 70, 171–173. ACKMAN R G and EATON C A (1988) Docosapentaenoic acid in blubber of dam and pup grey seals (Halichoreus grypus): implications in the Inuit diet and for human health’, Can J Zool, 66, 2428–2431. ACKMAN R G and LAMOTHE F (1989), Marine mammals, in Ackman R G, Marine Biogenic Lipids, Fats and Oils, Vol. II, Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press, Inc., 179–381. ACKMAN R G and RATNAYAKE W M N (1989), Fish oils, seal oils, esters and acids – are all forms of omega-3 intake equal?, in Chandra R K, Health Effects of Fish and Fish Oils, St John’s, Newfoundland, ARTS Biomedical Publishers, 373–393. ACKMAN R G, RATNAYAKE W M N and OLSSON B (1988), The ‘basic’ fatty acid composition of Atlantic fish oils: potential similarities useful for enrichment of polyunsaturated fatty acids by urea complexation, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 65, 136–138. ACKMAN R G
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 77 (1998), Immunonutrition: the role of n-3 fatty acids, Nutrition, 14, 627–633. and WILLETT W C (1999), Trans fatty acids and coronary heart disease, New England J Med, 340, 1994–1998. 13 AURSAND M, RAINUZZO J R and GRASDALEN H (1994), Quantitative high resolution C high1 resolution and H nuclear magnetic resonance of ω-3 fatty acids from white muscle of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar), J Am Oil Chem Soc, 70, 971–981. BARBERGER-GATEAU P, LETENNEUR L, DESCHAMPS V, PERES K, DARTIGUES J F and RENAUD S (2002), Fish, meat and risk of dementia: cohort study, BMJ, 325, 932–933. BIMBO A P (1987), The emerging marine oil industry, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 64, 706–715. BIMBO A P (1989), Fish oils: past and present food uses, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 66, 1717– 1726. BIMBO A P (1998), Guidelines for characterizing food-grade fish oil, INFORM, 9, 473–483. BREIVIK H and DAHL K H (1992), Production and control of n-3 fatty acids, in Frölich J C and von Schacky C, Fish, Fish Oil and Human Health, Clinical Pharmacology, Vol. 5, München, W. Zuckschwerdt Verlag, 25–39. BREIVIK H and THORSTAD O (2005), Removal of organic environmental pollutants from fish oil by short-path distillation, Lipid Technol, 17, 55–58. CALON F, LIM G P, YANG F, MORIHARA T, TETER B, UBEDA U, ROSTAING P, TRILLER A, SALEM JR. N, ASHE K H, FRAUTSCHY S A and COLE G M (2004), Docosahexaenoic acid protects from dendritic pathology in an Alzheimer’s disease mouse model, Neuron, 43, 633–645. COPPEN P P (1989), The use of antioxidants, in Allen J C and Hamilton R C, Rancidity in Foods, 2nd edn, London, Elsevier Applied Science, 83–104. COUPLAND K and LANGLEY N (1995), Modifying natural oil by adsorption chromatography, in Haraldsson, G G, Gudbjarnason S and Lambertsen G, Proc of the 18th Nordic Lipid Symposium, Reykjavik, Iceland, June 1995, Bergen, Norway, Lipidforum, 67–72. DE KONING A J (1992), The cholesterol content of South African fish oil and its seasonal variations, Fat Sci Technol, 94, 60–63. EDITORIAL (2003), Fish consumption and the risk of Alzheimer disease. Is it time to make dietary recommendations?, Arch Neurol, 60, 923–924. EMKEN E A, ADLOF R O and GULLEY R M (1994), Dietary linoleic acid influences desaturation and acylation of deuterium-labeled linoleic and linolenic acids in young adult males, Biochem Biophys Acta, 1213, 277–288. EUROPEAN PHARMACOPOEIA, 5th Edn, 2005, Strasbourg, Council of Europe. FEDERAL REGISTER (2003), July 11, Volume 68, No. 133. FRANKEL E N (2005), Antioxidants, in Lipid Oxidation, Bridgewater Oily Press, 209–258. FRASURE-SMITH N, LESPÉRANCE F and JULIEN P (2004), Major depression is associated with lower omega-3 fatty acid levels in patients with recent acute coronary syndromes, Biol Psychiatry, 55, 891–896. HARALDSSON G G and HJALTASON B (2001), Fish oils as sources of polyunsaturated fatty acids, in Gunstone F D, Structured and Modified Lipids, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 313–350. HARALDSSON G G, KRISTINSSON B and GUDBJARNASON S (1993), The fatty acid composition of various lipid classes in several species of fish caught in Icelandic seawaters, INFORM, 4, 535. HAUMANN B F (1995), Liposomes offer hope as medical tools, INFORM, 6, 793–802. HAUMANN B F (1997), Nutritional aspects of n-3 fatty acids, INFORM, 8, 428–447. HAUMANN B F (1998), Alternative sources for n-3 fatty acids, INFORM, 9, 1108–1119. HENDERSON R J (1999), The production of n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids in marine organisms, Lipid Technol, 11, 5–10. HIBBELN J R (1998), Fish consumption and major depression, Lancet, 351, 1213. HJALTASON B (1989), New frontiers in the processing and utilization of fish oil, in Somogoyi J C and Muller H R, Nutritional Impact of Food Processing, Bibl Nutr Dieta No. 43, Basel, Karger Publishing, 96–106. HJALTASON B (1992), Fish oils as vitamin sources, AOCS Short Course Manual on Modern Applications of Marine Oils, May 8–9, Toronto, Canada. ALEXANDER J
ASCHERIO A, KATAN M B, ZOCK P L, STAMPFER M J
78
Modifying lipids for use in food
(2002), Method for producing marine oils with reduced levels of contaminants, Patent, EP 1303 580 A1. HJALTASON B, HARALDSSON G G and HALLDORSSON O (2005), Rearing of aquatic species with DHA-rich prey organisms, Patent US 6 959 663 B2. HORNSTRA G (2004), LCPUFA in Maternal Nutrition, Basel, DSM Nutritional Products Ltd. Available at
[email protected]. HORROBIN, D F (1998), The membrane phospholipid hypothesis as a biochemical basis for the neurodevelopmental concept of schizophrenia, Schizophr Res, 30, 193–208. HÖLMER G (1989), Triglycerides, in Ackman R G, Marine Biogenic Lipids, Fats and Oils, Vol. I, Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press, Inc., 139–173. JUMPSEN J and CLANDININ M T (1995), Brain Development: Relationship to Dietary Lipid and Lipid Metabolism, Champaign, IL, AOCS Press. KALMIJN S, LAUNER L J, OTT A, WITTEMAN J C, HOFMAN A and BRETELER M M (1997), Dietary fat intake and the risk of incident dementia in the Rotterdam study, Ann Neurol, 42, 776– 782. KATAN M (1995), Exit trans fatty acids, Lancet, 346, 1245–1246. KAYAMA M and MANKURA M (1998), Natural oleochemicals in marine fishes, INFORM, 9, 794–799. KUNESOVA M, BRAUNEROVA R, HLAVATY P, MATOULEK M, KOPECKY J, SKRHA J, HAINER V, PARIZKOVA J and SVACINA S (2004), Weight reduction with VLCD and n-3 PUFA lead to higher decrease of weight and BMI in severely obese women, NAASO’s 2004 Annual Meeting, November 14–18, Las Vegas, NV, Obesity Research, 12, October 2004, Supplement Program Abstracts, A66. LANDS W E M (2005), Fish, Omega-3 and Human Health, 2nd edn, Champaign IL, AOCS Press. LIM G P, CALON F, MORIHARA T, YANG F, TETER B, UBEDA O, SALEM JR. N, FRAUTSCHY S A and COLE G M (2005), A diet rich with the omega-3 fatty acid docosahexaenoic acid reduces amyloid burden in an aged Alzheimer mouse model, J Neurosci, 25, 3032–3040. LUKIW W J, CUI J-G, MARCHESELLI V L, BODKER M, BOTKJAER A, GOTLINGER K, SERHAN C N and BAZAN N G (2005), A role for docosahexaenoic acid-derived neuroprotectin D1 in neural cell survival and Alzheimer disease, J Clin Invest, 115(10), 2774–2783. MAFF UK (1997), Dioxins and polychlorinated biphenyls in fish oil dietary supplements and licensed medicines, MAFF UK Food Surveillance Information Sheet, no. 106, London, Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. MANGOLD H K and PALTHAUF F (1983), Ether Lipids. Biochemical and Biomedical Aspects, New York, Academic Press. MORRIS M C, EVANS D A, BIENIAS J L, TANGNEY C C, BENNETT D A, WILSON R S, AGGARWAL N and SCHNEIDER J (2003), Consumption of fish and n-3 fatty acids and risk of incident Alzheimer disease, Arch Neurol, 60, 940–946. NAPIER J A (2004), Production of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids in transgenic plants: a sustainable source for human health and nutrition, Lipid Technol, 16, 103– 107. NEMETS B, STAHL Z and BELMAKER R H (2002), Addition of omega-3 fatty acid to maintenance medication treatment for recurrent unipolar depressive disorder, Am J Psychiatry, 159, 477–479. NETTLETON J A (1995), Omega-3 Fatty Acids and Health, New York, Chapman and Hall. NEWTON I S (1996), Food enrichment with long-chain n-3 PUFA, INFORM, 7, 169–177. NEWTON I S (1998), Long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids – the new frontier in nutrition, Lipid Technol, 10, 77–81. NUTRITION INDUSTRY EXECUTIVE (2005), The soft sell, September, 51–52. OIL WORLD ANNUAL (1998), Hamburg, ISTA Mielke GmbH. OSKI F (1997), What we eat may determine who we can be, Nutrition, 13, 220–221. PEET M and HORROBIN D F (2002), A dose-ranging study of the effects of EPA in patients with ongoing depression despite apparently adequate treatment with standard drugs, Arch Gen Psychiatry, 59, 913–919. HJALTASON B
Fish oils and lipids from marine sources 79 QI B, FRASER T, MUGFORD S, DOBSON G, SAYANOVA O, BUTLER J, NAPIER J A, STOBART A K
and (2004), Production of very long chain polyunsaturated omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids in plants, Nature Biotechnol, 22, 739–745. RAJALAKSHMI D and NARASIMHAN S (1996), Food antioxidants: sources and methods of evaluation, in Madhavi D L, Deshpande S S and Salunkhe D K, Food Antioxidants. Technological, Toxicological, and Health Perspectives, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 65–159. RUZICKOVA J, ROSSMEISL M, PRAZAK T, FLACKS P, SPONOROVA J, VECKA M, TVRZICKA E, BRYHN M and KOPECKY J (2004), Omega-3 PUFA of marine origin limit diet-induced obesity in mice by reducing cellularity of adipose tissue, Lipids, 39, 1177–1185. SARGENT J R (1989), Ether-linked glycerides in marine animals, in Ackman R G, Marine Biogenic Lipids, Fats and Oils, Vol. I, Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press, Inc., 175–197. SARGENT J R, BELL M V, BELL J G, HENDERSON R J and TOCHER D R (1995), Origins and functions of n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids in marine organisms, in Cevc G and Paltauf F, Phospholipids: Characterization, Metabolism and Novel Biological Applications, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 248–258. SHELKE K (2005), Hidden ingredients take cover in a capsule, available at: www.foodprocessing.com/articles/2005/421.html. SCHULER P (1990), Natural antioxidants exploited commercially, in Hudson B J F, Food Antioxidants, London, Elsevier Applied Science, 99–170. SHEPHERD C J, PIKE I H and BARLOW S M (2005), Sustainable feed resources of marine origin, European aquaculture society special publication No 35, June 59–66. SIMOPOULOS A P (1991), Omega-3 fatty acids in health and disease and in growth and development, Am J Clin Nutr, 54, 438–463. SODERBERG, M, EDLUND C, KRISTENSSON K and DALLNER G (1991), Fatty acid composition of brain phospholipids in aging and Alzheimer’s disease, Lipids, 26, 421–425. SPRECHER H, LUTHRIA D L, MOHAMMED B S and BAYKOUSHEVA S P (1995), Reevaluation of the pathways for the biosynthesis of polyunsaturated fatty acids, J Lipid Res, 36, 2471– 2477. STANSBY M E (1990), Nutritional properties of fish oil for human consumption – early development, in Stansby M E, Fish Oils in Nutrition, New York, van Nostrand Reinhold, 268–288. SU K-P, HUANG S-Y, CHIU C-C and SHEN W W (2003), Omega-3 fatty acids in major depressive disorder. A preliminary double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, Eur Neuropsych, 13, 267–271. TANSKANEN A, HIBBELN J R, TUOMILEHTO J, UUTELA A, HAUKKALA A, VIINAMÄKI H, LEHTONEN J and VARTIAINEN E (2001), Fish consumption and depressive symptoms in the general population in Finland, Psychiatric Services, 52, 529–531. VASKOVSKY V E (1989), Phospholipids, in Ackman R G, Marine Biogenic Lipids, Fats and Oils, Vol. I, Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press, Inc., 199–242. WU G, TRUKSA M, DATLA N, VRINTEN P, BAUER J, ZANK T, CIRPUS P, HEINZ E and QIU X (2005), Stepwise engineering to produce high yields of very long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids in plants, Nature Biotechnol, 23, 1013–1017. LAZARUS C M
5 Lipids from microbial sources C. Ratledge and S. Hopkins, University of Hull, UK
5.1
Introduction
It is only since the 1980s that the commercial production of microbial oils has taken place, in spite of the fact that detailed knowledge of the occurrence of oils and fats in various micro-organisms has been available for well over a century. The major factor which has changed this perception has been the appreciation of the key roles of particular polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) in human nutrition (Carlson et al., 1993a,b) which has created a specific demand for such materials. The supply of these desirable PUFAs has then posed additional problems as the main acids, arachidonic (ARA, 20:4n-6) and docosahexaenoic (DHA, 22:6n-3), are not available from any plant source and can only be isolated from animal materials at considerable cost. Arachidonic acid is obtainable from egg yolk, but thousands of eggs are needed to produce a gram of pure ARA; similarly, DHA can be obtained from various marine sources, including a number of fish liver oils, but it always occurs along with eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA, 20:5n-3) which then necessitates extensive and expensive fractionation, eventually involving large-scale high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), to produce DHA without the presence of EPA or any other PUFA. Thus, as the nutritional information concerning the requirement for these two PUFAs for the development of brain and eye functions in newly born infants appears irreproachable (Huang and Sinclair, 1998), a clear need for a commercial source of these fatty acids has arisen. (The nutritional aspects of oils rich in ARA and DHA are discussed in greater detail in Chapter 24.) Identifying possible commercial sources of PUFA has not been a major problem as it has been known for many years that numerous micro-organisms,
Lipids from microbial sources
81
including most marine micro-algae (that is algae growing as simple, singlecelled organisms as opposed to the macro-algae which are also known as seaweeds and grow accordingly), do produce such materials. A few species, moreover, produce ARA and DHA as their sole PUFA making them ideal starting materials from which oils rich in these materials could be produced. However, before considering the current production processes used for the synthesis of these PUFAs, a short background to the concept of using microorganisms for lipid production needs to be given to allow present-day developments to be seen within their appropriate context.
5.2 Oleaginous micro-organisms, fatty acids and lipid accumulation Table 5.1 gives the fatty acid profiles of a number of micro-organisms to illustrate the diversity and variation that can occur in lipid composition in these unicellular organisms. Micro-organisms can be divided into bacteria, yeasts, fungi and algae, although in some cases the boundaries can be uncertain. Bacteria are prokaryotes without a defined nucleus and include some algae formerly known as the blue-green algae but now referred to as the cyanobacteria. Yeast and fungi, together with the algae proper, are eukaryotic phyla as they have defined nuclei; yeasts are non-filamentous whereas the fungi are mostly filamentous and may have complex life-cycles that can include differentiation. Algae are essentially water-borne organisms, the majority of which (but not all) are capable of carrying out photosynthesis to obtain energy which they can then use to fix CO2 from the atmosphere. There are both micro-algae, i.e. unicellular algae similar in size to yeasts and fungal cells, and macro-algae, which are readily identified as various seaweeds in the marine environments. It is only the micro-algae that will be of interest in this context of lipid production. Those micro-organisms capable of accumulating intracellular lipids as storage oils are confined to the eukaryotic group; bacteria do not in general accumulate useful amounts of lipid although some can produce small amounts of PUFAs in their membrane lipids. These bacteria may, therefore, be potentially useful, not as a source of oil per se, but as a source of genes which could be isolated from the bacterial DNA and transferred, by genetic engineering, into another microbe or even plant (see Section 5.7). These inserted genes would cause the recipient organism to synthesize PUFA of its own volition. This prospect of using genetic engineering taking genes from micro-organisms and inserting them into plants is discussed in the final section of this chapter. Micro-organisms that accumulate more than about 20 % of their own weight as lipid – usually in the form of triacylglycerols to act as a store of carbon and energy – are known as oleaginous species. These represent a small minority of the total number of species and are able to do this because they possess biochemical mechanisms not found in the other non-oleaginous
Table 5.1
Lipid content and fatty acid profiles of selected oleaginous yeasts, fungi and micro-algae
Species
Maximum lipid content [% (w/w)]
Major fatty acyl residues [relative % (w/w)] 14:0
16:0
16:1
18:0
18:1
18:2
18:3 n-6
20:4 n-6
20:5 n-3
22:6 Important n-3 others
Yeasts1 Cryptococcus albidus var. aerius Cryptococcus curvatus D Lipomyces starkeyi Rhodosporidium toruloides
65
–
12
1
3
73
12
–
–
–
–
–
58 63 66
– – –
32 34 18
– 6 3
15 5 3
44 51 66
8 3 –
– – –
– – –
– – –
– – –
– – 23:0 (3 %)
Fungi1 Mortierella elongata Mucor alpina-peyron Aspergillus terreus Tolyposporium ehrenbergii
> > > >
– 10 2 1
7 15 23 7
– 7 – –
2 – Tr 5
18 30 14 81
12 9 40 2
25 1 21 –
16 – – –
15 – – –
– – – –
– – – –
NA NA NA NA
8 12 12 –
63 13 10 10
2 21 11 21
– – – –
4 1 3 1
9 2 2 4
12 – – 1
– 3 <1 –
– 45 25 33
– – 11 4
– – – –
NA NA NA
– – –
– 12 34
– 1 1
– – –
– 2 2
– 1 12
– 3 –
– 20 40
– – 7
– 24 –
– 18:4n-3 (19 %) –
Micro-algae Spirulina maxima2 Chlorella minutissima2 Isochrysis galbana2 Phaeodactylum tricornutum2 Nitzschia laevis Amphidinium carterae3 Porphyridium cruentum3 1
25 25 25 25
% % % %
Yeast data from Ratledge (1991). Selected micro-algae from Ratledge (2001). Lipid contents are not available (NA) but are typically less than 10 % (w/w). 3 Selected micro-algae from Cohen and Khozin-Goldberg (2005). 2
Lipids from microbial sources
83
species (for further information on this aspect of fatty acid biosynthesis the interested reader is referred to the review of Ratledge and Wynn, 2002). Oleaginous micro-organisms, however, will only accumulate lipid when they are grown in a culture medium which has a limiting amount of a key nutrient, other than carbon. Usually, this is nitrogen in the form of NH4. When this is exhausted, the cells can no longer synthesize proteins and nucleic acids, but any carbon source still present continues to be assimilated and, instead of being used to make new cell material (which is now no longer possible because of the lack of nitrogen), it is converted into lipid. The accumulated lipid, usually in the form of triacylglycerols, is therefore a reserve storage material and will be mobilized by the cells should they be subsequently starved of a supply of carbon. An outline of this process of lipid accumulation is shown in Fig. 5.1. Clearly, when the accumulated lipid in the cell contains commercially desirable fatty acids, and especially if these are present as triacylglycerols, then the organism becomes a potential target for commercial development. The oil extracted from such sources is referred to as a single cell oil (SCO), which is something of a euphemism to avoid mentioning microbe, yeast or fungus which might have negative connotations to a potential consumer Balanced growth phase
Lipogenic phase
40
Microbial biomass Glucose + NH4
Lipid (% dry wt)
Biomass (wt l–1) Nutrients (wt l–1) Arbitrary units
60
20
Lipid
0
10
20
30 40 Time (hours)
50
60
0 70
Fig. 5.1 Diagram showing the course of lipid accumulation in an oleaginous organism. The organism is grown in a culture medium which is so formulated that one nutrient, usually nitrogen in the form of NH4, becomes quickly exhausted but with an excess of carbon, usually glucose or another sugar, remaining in plentiful supply. On nitrogen exhaustion, cells can no longer multiply but continue to assimilate the glucose which is then converted into a storage material. In the oleaginous organism, this is in the form of a triacylglycerol oil.
84
Modifying lipids for use in food
of the oil. The term SCO is now in general use (see Kyle and Ratledge, 1992; Cohen and Ratledge, 2005).
5.3 Large-scale cultivation of oleaginous micro-organisms, costs, oil extraction and refinement Micro-organisms, of course, have to be grown on a large scale if they are going to produce tonne quantities of oils and fats at affordable prices. Although many algae might be useful for PUFA production – see Table 5.1 – most of them are photosynthetic and will only grow as if they were miniature plants; that is in sunlight (as the source of energy) and in air with CO2 being the source of carbon. Although this sounds a cheap system, it is in fact very expensive as such organisms need to be grown in sealed culture systems (or photobioreactors) to prevent contamination from air-borne organisms. In such systems, the biomass yield is low because the penetration of light into the bioreactor is severely limited by the self-shading effect of the cells and, consequently, the cell density rarely exceeds 3–5 g dry wt/l. Even this low yield may take three to four weeks to achieve. The algae also have an unfortunate tendency to attach themselves to surfaces which then makes light penetration into a photobioreactor even more difficult. Large areas of land need to be covered with these photobioreactor systems (which may be nothing more than kilometres of polythene tubing, of no more than 2 cm diameter, stretched out on racks) in order to achieve even a modicum of production. There is also a requirement for these reactors to be located in warm, sunny climates where, preferably, the ambient temperature is about 30 °C and sunshine is available 12 hours per day for an average of 250 days per year. A supply of clean water is also a requirement. All these factors restrict the possible locations for large-scale algal culture to just a few places around the world (Israel, Australia, southern California, North Africa, perhaps southern Italy, Spain and Portugal, Mexico, Namibia and parts of South America). The cost of oil production is higher than that of cultivating a micro-organism heterotrophically. A heterotrophic organism is one which requires a fixed source of carbon, e.g. glucose or sucrose also acting as a source of energy, coupled with a supply of fixed nitrogen (usually an ammonium salt, nitrate or urea) and other essential nutrients such as phosphate, sulphate, K+, Mg2+, etc. The technology of large-scale microbial cultivation is now extremely well developed as such systems are used extensively in the production of many materials, ranging from citric acid to antibiotics. Therefore, although such systems are clearly energy-intensive and require the carbon source (or feedstock) to be purchased, their overall costs are within an affordable limit. The scale of operation for modern fermentation processes is to use stirred tank reactors up to 500 m3, although both larger and smaller units may be employed. Very often, groups of four or more fermentors are used as they
Lipids from microbial sources
85
can then be run sequentially and the product can be recovered using the same downstream equipment (e.g. harvesting systems, dryers, etc.) which otherwise might stand idle in between runs when only a single fermentor is used. A typical large-scale fermentation system for microbial oil production is shown in Fig. 5.2, and the various unit operations that go to make up the whole process are shown in Fig. 5.3. The process invariably begins with the transfer of the desired organism from a storage vial into a culture flask – as would be used in any microbiological laboratory. Cultivation is then scaled up by a series of transfers of the organism into increasingly large fermentors. The final production fermentor is usually inoculated with about 10 % of its volume of a rapidly growing culture so that full growth and lipid accumulation can be accomplished in the shortest possible time. The scale-up protocols are usually kept as industrial know-how but may involve the organism being grown in the earlier, seed fermentors in medium that contains a balanced source of carbon and nitrogen so as to achieve maximum cell numbers as quickly as possible. It would then be only in the final fermentor that the medium would be nitrogen limited in order to effect lipid accumulation – as shown in Fig. 5.1. It is clearly desirable to produce as much oil as possible in the fermentor in the shortest possible time, and this means producing the highest density of cells that the fermentor can achieve. Whilst cell densities of up to 100 g dry cells per litre are not unusual, and in some cases up to 200 g/l has been recorded (see below), this may mean that the necessary amount of glucose or sucrose that has to be added into the fermentor may be considerable. If a final biomass density of about 100 g/l is to be achieved, this will require about 250 g sugar/l to be added. However, many micro-organisms would find such a concentration too high for them to grow. Consequently, the sugar has to be gradually fed into the fermentor during growth in what is known as a fed-batch process. The rate of adding the glucose is carefully monitored to ensure that it does not exceed the concentration at which cell growth would be retarded. Some of the nitrogen (usually an ammonium salt) may also be added along with the glucose feed in the initial stages of the fermentation although, towards the end of the process when sufficient numbers of cells have been created, the supply of nitrogen should be stopped and only the sugar then added. The cells enter the final lipid storage phase as depicted above (see Fig. 5.1). Various aspects of the large-scale cultivation of SCO-producing micro-organisms have been covered in a recent monograph on this topic (Cohen and Ratledge, 2005). Costs of SCO production are, of course, closely guarded industrial secrets, although some idea of the likely costs may be gathered by looking at other biotechnologically derived materials. Microbial products, such as citric acid and some amino acids, can be produced as cheaply as $2000 per tonne (figures in dollars could be converted into Euros without change), including the cost of the starting substrate. Biomass material can probably be produced
86
Modifying lipids for use in food
Temperature control
Continuous sterilization
Glucose Other nutrients, e.g. nitrogen
Acid Alkali pH control
Compressed air (01–0.2 vvm)
Cooling/ refrigeration
Seed fermenter (10–20 m3)
Vial
Shake flask
Waste treatment and disposal
Fermentation scale-up
Main fermenter (100–200 m3)
Centrifuge
Holding tank with heating
Moist heatstabilized cells
Oil
Downstream processing
Spray dryer Hexane extraction
Fig. 5.2 Diagram showing a typical fermentation process for SCO production. Cultivation of the organism begins with transfer of a culture from cryovial into a small shake flask which is then transferred through a series of ever-larger fermenters until the final production fermenter is reached. The final fermenter is usually inoculated at about 10 % of its volume with a rapidly growing culture of cells. It is only in the final fermenter that the medium needs to be formulated with a high C:N ratio to commence lipogenesis (see Fig. 5.1). Cells need to be heat-stabilized before harvesting. They may be extracted as a screw-pressed (moist) biomass or be spray-dried prior to extraction. Oil extraction, refining and deodorization follow conventional process technology.
Lipids from microbial sources
87
Fermentation
Heat stabilization (pasteurization)
Harvesting (holding tank with heating)
Centrifugation
OR
Filtration
Spent fermenter liquor
Moist cells Disposal Spray drying
Dry cells
Solvent extraction (e.g. hexane)
Disposal or animal feed?
Refining
Removal of coloured materials
Deodorization
Oil
Fig. 5.3
Outline of the various unit processes involved in an SCO production.
for not much more than this and thus, if the biomass contains oil at, say, 40 % of its weight then, theoretically at least, a tonne of oil might cost no more than $5000, or $5 per kilogram. To this has to be added the cost of oil extraction and refinement (see below). Also, the process of oil accumulation
88
Modifying lipids for use in food
may be slightly more costly than just growing a micro-organism for optimum biomass yield rather than optimum oil yield as a longer growth period would be needed to allow lipid accumulation to be complete. For an oil-producing micro-organism grown to a density of 50 g dry mass/l with an oil content of 40 %, the ensuing oil might reasonably be expected to cost no more than $10/kg. This value would be increased if the oil content of the cells was less than 40 %. For example, if the oil content of the cells was only 25 %, then four tonnes of cells would be needed to yield one tonne of oil; if one tonne of cells then cost, say, $3000 to produce, the oil would cost $12/kg with extraction and refining costs still to be added. However, these costings, it must be emphasized, are very much estimations and final costs may well exceed this value if a slow-growing organism is being used, or if any of the unit processes (such as harvesting or drying the cells – see Fig. 5.3) are found to require specialized equipment. Again, waste disposal of the spent fermentor broth may add a significant cost as it will probably have a high biological oxygen demand and will not be dischargeable into any river without infringing local environmental laws. Some simple, but cost incurring, process for its disposal may have to be incorporated into the overall unit operations and therefore added to the final costs of the oil. In the final stages of the fermentation process, the culture broth is normally heated (pasteurized) to about 60–65 °C to inactivate lipases, either within the cells themselves or secreted into the medium. This is needed so that during the subsequent harvesting of the cells, degradation of the oil within the cells is minimized. It is during the harvesting process that the cells become removed from their carbon source (or this may have been entirely consumed just prior to terminating the fermentor run) and, consequently, the cells then mobilize their accumulated lipids to meet this imposed starvation. If left unchecked, the lipases would cause deterioration in the quality of the lipid and would result in the appearance of free fatty acids in the final product. These would not only be undesirable but would impart unwanted odours and tastes into the final oil. Thus it is essential to inactivate lipase activity prior to commencing the final harvesting of the cells. In some processes, the entire culture may be discharged from the fermentor into a holding tank (see Fig. 5.2) as this then enables the principal fermentor to be cleaned and prepared for the next run with the minimum of delay. Heating of the culture may occur, therefore, either in the main fermentor, or during the transfer of cells (using a heat exchanger) or in the holding tank itself. The heat-stabilized biomass in the holding tank can be processed over a number of hours (if not a day or two) without deterioration of the oil. Cells may be harvested by centrifugation or more likely by rotary drum filtration – the choice will largely depend on what equipment is already available to the company carrying out the fermentation work. The freshly harvested cells can be either screw-pressed to give a moist mass of material (perhaps with a 30 % water content) or subjected to spray-drying to give a powder. The method used will largely depend on the proximity of the oil extraction process
Lipids from microbial sources
89
to the fermentation plant; moist cells can be directly extracted with solvent (see below), but if some time is expected to elapse before oil extraction commences then spray-dried cells may be the preferred option. Also, if some of the oil-rich biomass is to be used as such, then spray-dried cells would be the final product as these would have long-term stability with respect to their oil content. Extraction of oil from oleaginous micro-organisms has been covered in two recent reviews (Ratledge et al., 2004, 2005). In spite of the microbial biomass representing a complete novel source of lipids, and one which had never hitherto been processed for oil extraction, it was found that conventional solvent extraction systems, using existing commercial machinery, were sufficient to effect good oil recoveries. However, because the amount of microbial cells being processed at any one time would not exceed, perhaps, 20 tonnes dry wt, conventional oil extraction equipment used in conjunction with plant oilseeds would be entirely inappropriate. Here several hundreds of tonnes of plant seed can be processed in one day; a mere 20 tonnes of microbial biomass would literally be lost in the extraction machinery and the ensuing oil severely adulterated with plant oils already in the system. Consequently, small-scale extraction equipment has to be employed such as may be used in the extraction of essential oils and fragrances from various plants. Here, the emphasis is on complete extraction of the very valuable oils from plant tissue material and not just plant seeds. It is, therefore, a matter of choosing the correct size of existing solvent extraction unit rather than having to construct a purpose-built extraction facility to handle microbial oils. Extraction of microbial oils is usually by solvent extraction, with hexane being the preferred solvent. Isohexane may also be used. Moist, pressed cells may be directly extracted if these are immediately available from the fermentor. Where there may be a storage period involved before the cells can be extracted then it may be prudent to use spray-dried cells which will be stable much longer than moist cells, even though these will have been heat treated. Following oil extraction, the solvent is removed and the crude oil is then purified using both conventional techniques and process equipment for refinement, bleaching (removal of coloured materials) and the final deodorization step (see Fig. 5.3). At all stages, because the SCO is one that contains a valuable PUFA, care must be taken to prevent unwanted oxidation reactions. The oil should preferably be kept chilled whenever possible and exposure to air is minimized. To help in such measures, an antioxidant, such as one of the tocopherols (for example vitamin E), is usually added. However, microbial oils have, almost without exception, been found to have a high natural content of antioxidant coming from the original microbial cells. This serves to stabilize the oil during the initial stages of extraction but, as this may be removed from the oil during one of the final refining stages, it is advisable that extra antioxidant is added to the final oil to ensure its stability. The nature of the microbial antioxidants associated with the SCO is not
90
Modifying lipids for use in food
known – apart from them being oil-soluble; they are probably related to the tocopherols themselves and this could include them being a related flavanoid material (Shahidi et al., 1997). Oil-extraction from microbial biomass using supercritical CO2 has been considered (Wisniak and Korin, 2005) and, although this appears to be effective both in efficiency of oil-extraction and in maintaining the structural integrity of the PUFA material, it is nevertheless probably too expensive to use in comparison with the standard solvent-extraction protocols.
5.4 The production of an SCO rich in γ-linolenic acid (Oil of Javanicus) The first commercial production of a microbial oil was one containing γ-linolenic acid (GLA, 18:3n-6) as the major PUFA. This process was developed in the late 1970s and early 1980s as an alternative oil to evening primrose (Oenothera biennis) oil which, at that time, was the sole commercial oil available that contained GLA. GLA was considered to be useful for the alleviation of multiple sclerosis, a claim which is no longer made, and also for the treatment of a variety of other ailments, including pre-menstrual tension. A range of other benefits arising from the ingestion of GLA-containing oils is still recognized (Huang and Mills, 1996; Huang and Ziboh, 2001). Perhaps the least controversial of these benefits of GLA is in the prevention of diabetic retinopathy (Horrobin, 1996) and in the treatment of atopic eczema (Horrobin and Morse, 1995). It is, however, the possible prevention of premenstrual tension that leads to its greatest volume of present-day consumption in the UK and in some other European countries. As the price of evening primrose oil in the mid-1970s was in excess of $50 per kilogram, and as it contained only 9–10 % GLA in its total fatty acids, an opportunity was recognized for producing an oil from a microorganism that would be superior in quality and less expensive. The occurrence of GLA in the oils of the group of organisms known as the lower fungi, or Zygomycetes and sometimes referred to as the Mucorales, had been known since 1948 (Bernard and Albrecht, 1948). A survey of the occurrence of GLA in filamentous fungi by Shaw (1965, 1966b) had revealed that GLA rather than the n-3 isomer of 18:3 occurred throughout the zygomyces fungi. From this prior knowledge, it was then a matter of screening a large number of possible organisms to find one which grew quickly and could achieve a high cell density in a laboratory fermentor and had a high content of lipid and a high content of GLA in the fatty acids. This work was carried out in the authors’ laboratory and led to finding that, of some 300 organisms, the best one appeared to be a strain of Mucor circinelloides (formerly known as Mucor javanicus). This fungus had an oil content of approximately 25 % with a GLA content of between 18 and 20 % of the total fatty acids. Other Zygomycetes fungi were found that had higher
Lipids from microbial sources
91
lipid contents and some with higher GLA contents but never together. Consequently, a compromise had to be reached between oil content and GLA levels and the chosen organism appeared to be the best available, bearing in mind the need for the organism to grow quickly and to a high cell density. Production of the oil using M. circinelloides was undertaken by J. & E. Sturge Ltd at Selby, North Yorkshire, UK and the first oil was released for sale in 1985 (Meers and Prescott, 1987). The fungus was grown in a nitrogenlimiting medium (see Fig. 5.1) and used stirred tank fermentors of 220 m3. These fermentors were normally used for the production of citric acid using the filamentous fungus, Aspergillus niger. The technology for the large-scale production of the first SCO product was, therefore, already in place within this company who used their expertise to develop a successful protocol within about two to three years. This time included carrying out all safety checks on the oil (see also Chapter 23). The fungus was grown to a cell density in excess of 50 g/l in about three days; the cells had a final oil content of about 25 % with oil containing about 18 % GLA (see Table 5.2). Higher cell densities could be attained in the fermentor, but this led to difficulties in removal of the cells from the fermentor due to limitations in the pumps and other ancillary downstream process equipment. A pasteurization step was included in the final stages of the fermentation process (see Fig. 5.3) in order to stabilize the cells. Extraction was carried out using the pressed but still moist cells. The oil was marketed under the brand name of Oil of Javanicus and was sold to various health companies as an alternative, over-the-counter nutraceutical to evening primrose oil. A full account of the development of the GLA-SCO process has been given elsewhere (Ratledge, 2005) and this should be referred to for further information. The specification of the refined oil is given in Table 5.2 together with a comparison of the major plant sources of oils rich in GLA. It is relevant to point out that, although a number of surveys of microorganisms have been carried out subsequently to find better GLA producers (Ratledge, 2005), there has only been one report of a significant improvement over M. circinelloides. This was the discovery by Weete et al. (1998) of an unusual species of zygomycetous fungus, Syzygites megalocarpus, that could produce an oil with up to 62 % GLA. This is the highest GLA content ever recorded for any micro-organism or plant. However, the oil content of this fungus was less than 10 % of the biomass and there were difficulties in growing it above 3.5 g/l, and even this level was only attained after six days. When compared with M. circinelloides, which can reach over 50 g/l in about three days with 25 % oil and approximately 20 % GLA, the overall productivity (that is grams GLA produced/litre of fermentor/day) is still in favour of the Mucor process. Nevertheless, this unusual fungus is worthy of note as a potential alternative source of a GLA-SCO. The fatty acid profile of the oil from this fungus is also given in Table 5.2. A rival process to that of Oil of Javanicus was developed by Idemitsu Kosan Co. Ltd, Tokyo, Japan and the ensuing oil was released for sale in the
Table 5.2
Fatty acid profiles of various fungi and plants used, or considered, for GLA production. Relative % (w/w) of major fatty acids
Mucor circinelloides1 Mortierella isabellina2 Mortierella ramanniana2 Syzgites megalocarpus3 Evening primrose1 Borage1,4 Blackcurrant 1
Oil content (% w/w)
16:0
16:1
18:0
18:1
18:2 (n-6)
18:3 (n-6) GLA
18:3 (n-3)
20:1
25 ~ 50 ~ 40 10 16 30 30
22 27 24 14 6 10 6
1 1 – – – – –
6 6 5 1 2 4 1
40 44 51 12 8 16 10
11 12 10 1 75 40 48
18 8 10 62 8–10 22 17
– – – – 0.2 0.5 13
– 0.4 – – 0.2 4.5 –
Ratledge (1992) and Sinden (1987) Ratledge (2001) 3 Weete et al. (1998) 4 Borage oil also contains small amounts of 22:1 (~ 2%) and 24:1 (~ 1%). Abbreviation: GLA = gamma-linolenic acid. 2
Lipids from microbial sources
93
late 1980s, five or six years after the launch of Oil of Javanicus. The Japanese process used mainly Mortierella isabellina although it would appear that Mortierella ramanniana may also have been used (Nakahara et al., 1992). Both organisms produced substantially less GLA in the final oil than M. circinelloides (see Table 5.2) although the oil content was about twice that of the Mucor. Sales of the Mortierella oils appear to have ceased by the early 1990s shortly after Oil of Javanicus ceased production. Production of Oil of Javanicus ceased in 1990 due to the falling prices of evening primrose oil and to the advent of borage oil (also known as starflower oil). Borage oil was developed as a further alternative to evening primrose oil and, being an agricultural crop and therefore enjoying EU subsidies as a non-edible plant, could be produced for less than the equivalent biotechnological product. It also had a slightly higher content of GLA than Oil of Javanicus (see Table 5.2). Thus, by 1990 the SCO process was no longer economical and, with the take-over of the production company, J. & E. Sturge, by RhonePoulenc, it was decided that the oil no longer fitted with the new company’s product profile and no further production was carried out. It was clearly evident, however, that SCO could be produced in high tonnage quantities and represented a product to rival the highest quality plant oils: SCO were oils that could be produced to an unvarying specification; their production did not depend on the vagaries of the climate, or even political changes in some of the countries producing rival plant oils. They could be produced all round the year and did not have to be stored for up to 12 months as did the plant products which, of course, are only harvested at one time of the year. Also, they could be classed as ‘organically grown’: they were not sprayed with herbicides, pesticides or fungicides. The content of pesticide residues in Oil of Javanicus was miniscule and far below the levels found in rival oils (the levels of pesticide residues in these plant oils were, however, below the levels permitted by law and did not represent any hazard to health). In spite of these numerous advantages, it was clear that a microbial oil, no matter how good, cannot compete economically with a plant oil – even rather exotic ones such as evening primrose oil or borage oil where volumes of production are relatively low and costs of harvesting and processing are high. When SCOs have been successful, as discussed below, it has been to provide PUFAs which are not available from plant sources and which cannot be satisfactorily produced from animal sources. Selection of the PUFA to be produced microbiologically therefore depends upon the absence of alternative sources.
5.5
Production of arachidonic acid-SCO
The occurrence of arachidonic acid (ARA, 20:4n-6) in zygomycetes fungi was noted during the extensive survey by Shaw (1966a) for PUFA in microorganisms. A number of subsequent surveys of this family of fungi identified
94
Modifying lipids for use in food
Mort. alpina as probably the most prolific producer of ARA (Totani and Oba, 1987, 1988; Higashiyama et al., 2002). Processes for the production of ARA were developed in the early 1990s by Suntory Ltd and Lion Corporation in Japan, although only the former process seems to have gained any significant market. It remains in operation in Japan today. ARA was originally produced in Japan as a nutraceutical fatty acid but without any well-defined role and, consequently, sales of the SCO-ARA do not appear to have been particularly high during the early years of production. It was only when it was appreciated that ARA was an important and essential fatty acid in infant nutrition, especially in neonatal babies and ones born slightly premature (Carlson et al., 1993, 1994; Lanting et al., 1994, Crozier et al., 1996), that serious attempts were made to develop production of ARA for infant nutrition (Kyle, 1996). A commercial process was developed in the mid-1990s by Martek BioSciences, Maryland, USA, in conjunction with the Dutch company of Gist-brocades, now DSM (Dutch State Mines), for the production of an SCO rich in ARA using Mort. alpina as production organism. This process has been described by a number of authors including both Kyle (1997) and Streekstra (2005) who have been directly involved in the production, and it currently accounts for more than 95 % of the world’s production of ARA. However, a rival process has been developed in China by Wuhan Alking Bioengineering Co. Ltd also using Mort. alpina (Yuan et al., 2002). The company (http://www.alking.com.cn/english) has now entered into an agreement with Cargill Co. of the USA for marketing and sales of the oil in countries not covered by the various patents taken out by Suntory and Martek. Both the Martek and Wuhan Alking processes, and probably the Suntory one too, produce an oil with a content of ARA of over 40 % of the total fatty acids and, consequently, after being refined and deodorized, it is mixed with a vegetable oil, usually sunflower oil, to bring the ARA content down to a standardized level of 40 %. The fatty acid profiles of both these oils are given in Table 5.3. Because of the rapidly-growing demand for ARA (in conjunction with DHA) for the infant formula market (see Chapter 23 and also Wynn and Ratledge, 2005), expansion of the current DSM process has led to a new production unit being opened in Belvidere, NJ, at the end of 2004. Although this doubles the production of ARA, further expansion in its production, as well as that of DHA, can be anticipated during the next two or three years to keep pace with the demand for these fatty acids. The DSM/Martek oil is used exclusively by Martek in a 2:1 combination with the DHA oil from Crypthecodinium cohnii (see Section 5.6) and is sold under the trade name of Formulaid® (Martek Biosciences Corp, USA) exclusively for the infant formula market. This is now sold in over 60 different countries. The exact details of the commercial processes remain industrial secrets, although Mort. alpina grows more slowly than M. circinelloides (see Section
Table 5.3
Fatty acid profiles of oils rich in arachidonic acid available commercially. All oils are produced by strains of Mortierella alpina. Relative % (w/w) of major fatty acids
Alking1 Martek/DSM
2
14:0
16:0
16:1
18:0
18:1
18:2
18:3
20:0
20:3
20:4
22:0
24:0
0–2
4–15
0–3
4–15
5–20
3–10
1–5
0–3
3–10
40–45
0–2
0–5
0–2
3–15
0–2
5–20
5–38
4–15
1–5
0–1
1–5
38–44
0–3
0–3
Note: Analysis taken from (FSANZ, 2003). Product specifications from Wuhan Alking Bioengineering Co., Ltd. See http://www.alking.com.cn/english/AA%20OIL%2040%25%20SPEC.pdf. 2 Currently Martek Biosciences Corporation’s ARASCOTM is produced by DSM under licence. 1
96
Modifying lipids for use in food
5.3) and it probably takes five to six days before the cells reach their final lipid levels. Also, because these cells are somewhat sensitive to high concentrations of glucose, the glucose, together with NH3, is added to the medium in a fed-batch system so that the cells are able to grow at their maximum rate without inhibition by excess glucose. In the fermentation process itself, it is very important that clumping, or aggregation, of the cells is prevented. The cells should grow preferably as small discrete pellets rather than as dispersed hyphae which makes oxygen transfer into the culture broth extremely difficult. These constraints mean that it is imperative that the aeration and mixing in the fermentor are closely monitored and also controlled to ensure maximum cell formation with maximum ARA content. The concentration of glucose in the fermentor is also another factor that may influence morphological changes in the cells, and it has been suggested that optimum growth (and lipid accumulation) may be achieved by maintaining the glucose no higher than 5 g/l (Park et al., 2002), thereby showing the importance of using a fed-batch system for production. The nature of the nitrogen source may also be a significant factor influencing growth and ARA production, with soy bean meal seemingly giving higher productivities than yeast extract (Park et al., 1999) but, whatever nitrogen source is used, it seems evident that the C:N ratio is of key importance (Koike et al., 2001), with values within the range 15–32:1 being the best for lipid accumulation and ARA production. Because of the unstable nature of the ARA oil, pasteurization of the culture broth is carried out prior to harvesting and this effectively kills all the cells as well as inactivating hydrolytic enzymes, including lipases, in the cells and broth. The cells are extracted with hexane without using a spray-drying step (see Fig. 5.2), but probably much excess water is first removed from the biomass using a screw press. The final oil ‘… is a translucent yellow oil with a distinctive but not strong flavour’ (Wynn and Ratledge, 2005). This latter review, together with that of Streekstra (2005) should be consulted for further details about the Martek ARASCO® process.
5.6
Production of DHA-rich SCOs
With the realization in the early 1990s that DHA was of crucial importance in infant nutrition for both neural and retinal membrane development, a clear demand for an oil rich in this PUFA was created. (Further information concerning the nutritional and functional role of DHA is given in Chapter 23.) The only reasonable source of DHA at this time was from fish oils where it occurs together with eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA 20:5n-3) in varying proportions. However, to produce an oil containing only DHA starting with fish oil was prohibitively expensive; in addition, EPA as an additional n-3 PUFA was thought to be inadvisable for infant nutrition, partly due to its lessening the effectiveness of DHA and partly due to doubts
Lipids from microbial sources
97
about the intrinsic safety of using fish oils. For these reasons alternative sources were required.
5.6.1 DHA-SCO production using Crypthecodinium cohnii Micro-algae have long been known to contain very long-chain PUFAs (see reviews by Shifrin, 1984; Wood, 1988; Yongmanitchai & Ward, 1989) and, indeed, these represent the origin of most DHA and EPA present in fish as they are the major feeding materials of many fish in their natural environments (Ackman, 1982). Of key relevance was the knowledge that the marine dinoflagellate, known as Crypthecodinium cohnii (also called Gyrodinium cohnii and Gymnodinium simplex which are now regarded as synonyms for C. cohnii) produced lipids in which the sole PUFA was DHA (Harrington and Holz, 1968; Beach and Holz, 1973; Henderson et al., 1988). This organism appears to be one of very few organisms that produces DHA as its sole PUFA (Yongmanitchai and Ward, 1989) but, initially, being a dinoflagellate of which no example of biotechnological exploitation had taken place, it did not seem an attractive proposition for becoming an SCO producer. However, with the increasing interest in finding an oil rich in DHA, research was carried out by Martek Biosciences Corp. of Maryland, USA to identify a possible amendable strain of C. cohnii and develop it as a source of DHA oil. Some of this initial work was reported by Kyle and Ratledge (1992) where the organism was only described as ‘microalga MK8805’ and no mention was made of it even being a dinoflagellate. This early work involved a thorough examination of the organism’s growth requirements and, somewhat surprisingly, it was found to be an obligate heterotrophic organism of a rather robust character allowing it to be grown without too much difficulty in stirred tank fermentors using glucose as sole source of carbon and energy. A nitrogen source other than NH4, which was toxic even in low concentrations to C. cohnii, was also needed. Although a high salt concentration would have been required for its growth in the initial phases of the work (because of the marine origins of the organism), this requirement seems to have been partially overcome either by adaptation to a low salt medium or by substituting salts with chloride ions by various sulphates (Wynn et al., 2005). The use of a high salt medium is regarded as detrimental to large-scale cultivations in stainless steel fermentors which suffer corrosion in the presence of high amounts of chloride ions; using sulphate salts in place of the chlorides does not cause the same problems, although clearly a low salt medium is preferred to a high salt medium even if Cl– is at a low concentration. In the C. cohnii process, a high grade of stainless steel is used in the construction of the fermentors to minimize corrosion as, although only a fraction of the original chloride ion content of seawater is used in the production medium, it is nevertheless still included in the medium, and this would still be detrimental to low-grade stainless steel.
98
Modifying lipids for use in food
Once an appropriate strain of C. cohnii had been identified, it was grown successfully in stirred tank fermentors with biomass yields after six days of up to 10 g/l having an oil content of about 15% and with DHA at about 30 % of the total fatty acids (Kyle and Ratledge, 1992). Four years later, Kyle (1996) was reporting cultivation of the organism in 120 m3 fermentors yielding an oil with over 40 % DHA; at this stage, the other details of the process were not declared, but production of the first SCO since the advent of Oil of Javanicus was underway. The oil that was accumulated by C. cohnii during its lipid accumulation phase (see Fig. 5.1; with the organism behaving as a typical oleaginous one) was principally in the form of triacylglycerols; consequently, the oil was ideally placed to be an edible oil as it could be extracted and purified by standard protocols. Had the DHA been found to be mainly present as phospholipids (as occurs with the lipids in many microalgae) these would not have been such an acceptable source of DHA. Triacylglycerol oils are, of course, the form of all commercial plant oils and are the desirable type of oil destined for human consumption. It is this organism and this process which today provide over 95% of the total DHA market, and it is exclusively produced by Martek. As mentioned above, the DHA-SCO is used in conjunction with ARA-SCO as the source of these key fatty acids in infant formulae. The two oils are mixed at 2:1 (ARA:DHA) and sold under the name of Formulaid®. Some further details of the production process have been provided in a recent review by Wynn et al. (2005), although information concerning the final cell density, the time of the fermentation process itself and the oil content of the cells is not disclosed. From other work, the cells would appear to take between five and seven days to reach their maximum density which is probably in excess of 50 g/l. The oil content is about 50 % of the cell dry wt (Wynn et al., 2005) with a DHA content of between 44 and 50 %. The oil is extracted with hexane (Ratledge et al., 2005) and the final material is diluted with a vegetable oil, sunflower oil or high oleic sunflower oil, to give a standardized content of the oil of 40 % DHA. The fatty acid profile of the oil, known as DHASCO® (Markek Biosciences Corp, USA), is shown in Table 5.4. Although an antioxidant is added to the oil, it is nevertheless quite stable without such addition (Kyle, 1996), but the nature of the endogenous antioxidant of the organism has not been published. Like that of other SCOs, it is probably a derivative of tocopherol or a flavanoid-like material. Sales of this SCO dominate the total SCO market (see Table 5.5). The demand for the oil appears to have doubled every year since 2003. Martek currently has over 1000 m3 of fermentation capacity dedicated to DHASCO production (Wynn et al., 2005), and this will clearly need to be increased several times more if demand for the oil is to be met over the next few years. The oil is sold in over 60 countries for use in infant formulae. The Food and Drug Authority of the USA have accepted Martek’s submission that this is a Generally Recognized As Safe (GRAS) oil suitable for incorporation into infant formulae along with the ARA-SCO. The DHA-SCO has been shown
Table 5.4
Fatty acid composition of DHA-rich oils available commercially. Relative % (w/w) of major fatty acids 14:0
16:0
16:1
18:0
18:1
18:2
18:3
20:0
20:3
20:4
22:5
22:6
Martek1 (DHASCO®)
10–20
10–20
0–2
0–2
10–30
0–5
–
0–1
–
–
0–1
40–45
OmegaTech2 (DHASCO-S®)
–
13
29
12
1
1
1
2
3
12
25
Nutrinova3 (DHActive®)
3
30
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
12
46
1 2 3
0
Oil produced by Crypthecodinium cohnii by Martek Biosciences Corporation. Fatty acid analysis data was taken from FSANZ (2003). Formerly OmegaTech but is now part of Martek Biosciences Corporation. Analysis data from Barclay et al. (2005) and Ratledge et al. (2005). Nutrinova DHActive® is possibly Ulkenia sp. For fatty acid analysis data see Kiy et al. (2005).
100 Modifying lipids for use in food Table 5.5
Worldwide single cell oil (SCO) production.
Single cell oil
Percentage of SCO production total SCO (tonnes) (1980–2002) (1980–2002)
Percentage of SCO production total SCO (tonnes) (2003 estimated) (2003 estimated)
ARASCO® DHASCO® DHA-S GLA-SCO Other Total
52.1 26 7.3 7.3 7.3 100
64 32 2 0 2 100
360 180 50 50 50 690
360 180 10 0 10 560
Source: Adapted from Kyle (2005).
to be completely non-hazardous and free of all deleterious materials; the oil is probably the most stringently tested oil of any origin and has been shown to be of the highest quality in every single respect (see also Chapter 23). Some small amounts of the oil are sold as a neutraceutical for adults under the trade name of Neuromins® (Martek Biosciences Corp, USA), as there are strong suggestions that DHA may be important in relieving such conditions as hypertension, arthritis, arteriosclerosis, depression and thromobosis (Horrocks and Yeo, 1999a,b).
5.6.2 DHA-SCO production using Schizochytrium sp. Such has been the demand for DHA that other processes using alternative organisms have been developed since the start of the Martek process. The major rival process was developed by OmegaTech Ltd in Boulder, Colorado, USA and was based on using a marine organism known as a species of Schizochytrium. This genus, together with several related genera including Thraustochytrium, Japonochytrium, Ulkenia and Aplanochytrium (Mo et al., 2002), forms a group of organisms known as the thraustochytrids or, more correctly, the family of the Thraustochytriidae. They were originally thought to be fungi because of their lack of any photosynthetic machinery, but subsequent molecular biology protocols have identified them as heterotrophic micro-algae known as stramenopiles (Honda et al., 1999; Kumon et al., 2003). They are now regarded as part of a larger phylum referred to as the Labyrinthulomycota which comprises just two families: the Thraustochytriidae and the Labyrinthulidae (also referred to as the labyrinthulids). The taxonomy of organisms in this group is still poorly understood but, overall, in their marine environments, it is believed that they may constitute a greater amount of the phytoplankton biomass than previously suspected (Kimura and Naganuma, 2001; Barclay et al., 2005). They all produce DHA in their lipids. However, as far as current information allows, this DHA appears to be always accompanied by a significant amount of docosapentaenoic acid (DPA, 22:5n-6). [Note that this fatty acid is of the n-6 series and how it fits in with
Lipids from microbial sources
101
the biosynthesis of the n-3 series of PUFA is still uncertain (Ratledge et al., 2004).] The first report of the occurrence of DHA and also of DPA in these organisms was by Ellenbogen et al. (1969) who considered these PUFAs of possible phylogenetic significance. The process developed by OmegaTech (initially called Phycotech, which was part of the Kelco group of companies) was first patented in 1991 (Barclay, 1991; also Barclay, 1992) and then described, though somewhat vaguely in key areas regarding yields of biomass, etc., by Barclay et al. (1994). A more recent account of the development of the entire process, including reasons for exploring the thraustochytrids as possible DHA producers, has been given by Barclay et al. (2005). Schizochytrium species and the related Thraustochytrum spp. had been independently investigated by Bajpai et al. (1991a,b) and by Kendrick and Ratledge (1992), but with the conclusion that this group of organisms were an unlikely source of SCOs because of their poor growth performances and low oil contents. The work of Barclay et al. (1994), however, had started by isolating organisms directly from the marine environment and had not relied upon microbial culture collections for providing stock cultures. It would seem, in retrospect, that the work of Bajpai et al. (1991 a,b) and of Kendrick and Ratledge (1992) had failed to achieve good cell growth and good oil production because the organisms being used were much less vigorous than the original strains and clearly had lost much of their potency during their time in storage. By going directly to the marine environment for new isolates, Barclay avoided this problem and was able to identify rapidly growing strains that exhibited high levels of lipid accumulation (Barclay, 1992; Barclay et al., 1994). Production of the first batches of oil from Schizochytrium sp. commenced in the mid-1990s. The specifications of the oil are given in Table 5.4. Although this oil has a high DHA content, it also contains docosapentaenoic acid (DPA, 22:5n-6). Because at the time the role of DPA in human metabolism was uncertain, this appears to have deterred OmegaTech from trying to incorporate it into infant formula as an alternative to the Martek oil; instead, the oil was incorporated into poultry feed with the resulting incorporation of DHA but not DPA into the eggs. These eggs were then marketed as SeaGold® eggs and the oil itself was named as DHAGold® (Martek Bioscience Corp, USA). It is now known (see Chapter 23) that DPA is not contra-indicated in being included with DHA in various neutraceuticals as it does not interfere with the incorporation of DHA into neural or retinal lipids in either infants or adults. This new information has enabled its direct use for human consumption. The DHA-rich oil (now referred to as DHASCO-S® – Martek) was accorded GRAS status by the FDA of the USA in 2004 for its incorporation into a number of foods; similar approval was given in Australia and New Zealand in 2002 and in Europe in 2003 (Barclay et al., 2005). Its incorporation into various functional foods is, therefore, under active development. In addition, the entire biomass, without oil-extraction, is being used extensively
102 Modifying lipids for use in food in aquaculture for feeding to fish larvae and shrimp (www.aquafuana.com/ diets&feeds.htm). It thus competes directly with fish meal for this purpose, although it probably costs about three to four times as much to produce. Schizochytrium biomass production is, in fact, one of the success stories of SCO. It grows very rapidly and to very high cell densities: far greater than any other oleaginous organism. Using a fed-batch mode of production, the production organism of OmegaTech has been grown to cell densities in excess of 200 g/l in 72 hours (Bailey et al., 2003; Barclay et al., 2005) with an oil content of about 35 % and a DHA content of the lipid of between 35 and 45 %. Strains of the organism have been selected that no longer require a high salt concentration to grow which is particularly important to keep the total Cl– content as low as possible (see also Section 5.6.1), thereby preventing corrosion of the stainless steel fermentors used in the large-scale production process. Although the size of the OmegaTech production process has not been declared, it is reasonable to assume that this will be using fermentors of at least 100 m3 and, if the current plans for expanding production both of the DHASCO-S® oil and the DHA-rich biomass are to be fulfilled, the overall scale could be expected to double and double again over the next few years. The company itself was taken over by Martek in 2002 and, consequently, the applications for the DHASCO-S® are kept separate from those of the DHASCO from C. cohnii. Because of the very high productivities that can be attained by the Schizochytrium process, this oil is by far the cheapest SCO available; the biomass too is highly competitive with other biomass productions and, if further economies of scale can be realized, it may well prove to be the material of choice for fish feeding.
5.6.3 Other processes for the production of DHA-rich SCOs Such has been the success of the Martek and OmegaTech processes that rival ones have subsequently been developed. These have also explored the applications of the thraustochytrid and labyrinthulid organisms (see previous section). Of significant note is the process developed by Nutrinova GmbH, Frankfurt am Main, Germany. This uses an organism known as Ulkenia sp. and has recently been described by Kiy et al. (2005). The organism is now grown commercially in large-scale stirred tank fermentors in the same way as other SCO-producing micro-organisms. The fatty acid profile of the oil is shown in Table 5.4. This, like the Schizochytrium sp. oil, also contains a substantial proportion of DPA. The oil was initially sold under the trade name of DHActive but this has now been changed to NutrinovaDHA® (Nutrinova, Germany) (see also Chapter 23). Applications of the Ulkenia oil, which do not appear to include its addition into infant feeding formulae, are mainly as an additive to a variety of foods and drinks. Such DHA-enriched foods appear to be stable and the DHA does not apparently oxidize nor does it impart any fishy after-taste (Kiy et al.,
Lipids from microbial sources
103
2005). With the specification of the Ulkenia oil being similar to that of the Schizochytrium oil (see Section 5.5.2), it is perhaps not surprising to find that the two companies producing these oils are in dispute about possible patent infringement (www.martekbio.com/corporate/company_profile.asp). It may, though, be some time before this issue is resolved. Another recent patent that has been filed for DHA production using a related organism is that of Yokochi et al. (2002) which features an organism belonging to the genus of Labyrinthula. This is grown with oleic acid, linoleic acid or linolenic acid, or even with an oil such as soybean oil to produce an SCO which contains ARA, EPA, DPA and DHA as well as some docosatetraenoic acid (22:4). However, such a complex spectrum of fatty acids would inevitably limit the applications of the oil. In addition, this organism has fastidious growth requirements and needs a bacterium to be included in the medium for the Labyrinthula sp. to grow. Consequently, this would make the entire process completely unrealistic for commercialization. An account of this work has also been published conventionally (Kumon et al., 2002). A patent has also been filed by Suntory Ltd and Nagase & Co. Ltd (Tanaka et al., 2003) for the production of a DHA and/or DPA oil using a species of Ulkenia which is similar to the process already underway by Nutrinova GmbH. The profile of this oil would appear to be similar to the oils described in Table 5.4. It is uncertain at the time of writing (Spring 2006) whether this represents a potentially serious rival process for the production of these oils to that which uses the thraustochytrid/labyrinthulid group of organisms.
5.7
Prospects for other PUFA-SCOs
5.7.1 Eicosapentaenoic acid The major outstanding PUFA which is currently in demand, but is not easily available from any source, is eicosapentaenoic acid (20:5n-3). This fatty acid has strong anti-inflammatory properties and it has been suggested that it could be useful for the treatment of a number of clinical disorders including schizophrenia, bipolar disorder (manic depression), and possibly conditions such as Alzheimer’s disease as well as certain types of cancer (see Chapter 23). The only present source of this PUFA is from fish oils, but these always contain a mixture of EPA and DHA and are not suitable for clinical applications as DHA is contra-indicated for many of the effects that are brought about by EPA on its own. Thus, to produce an EPA-only oil (or methyl or ethyl ester of it), expensive and extensive purification protocols, eventually involving preparative-scale HPLC, are required. Although there would appear to be a clear commercial need for an EPAonly oil, searches for an EPA-producing, heterotrophic micro-organism, which would seem the best prospect for realising this aim, have so far not revealed any likely candidate for large-scale production. Possible candidates all appear
104 Modifying lipids for use in food to be photosynthetic micro-algae (Gill and Valivety, 1997; Vazhappilly and Chen, 1998a,b; Cohen and Khozin-Goldberg, 2005; Wen and Chen, 2005). Many produce EPA along with either ARA or DHA, but none produces EPA on its own. The large-scale cultivation of phototrophic micro-algae, moreover, is very expensive, as has been discussed in Section 5.3, and even the best ones are not realistic propositions for SCO production (see Cohen et al., 1992; Yongmanitchai and Ward, 1992; Wen and Chen, 2000a, 2001, 2002; Cohen and Khozin-Goldberg, 2005). Even when attempts have been made to grow algae under heterotrophic conditions (i.e. in the dark with glucose as carbon and energy source), these have not met with success. For example, Wen and Chen (2000b) grew the diatom Nitzschia laevis under heterotrophic conditions and phototrophically and also mixotrophically, providing both light and glucose simultaneously. Under heterotrophic conditions and mixotrophic conditions, about 2.5 g cells were produced over five to six days but less than 0.5 g was produced under phototrophic conditions. Lipid contents of the former cells were about 12 % with between 15 and 19 % EPA. Thus improvements by two orders of magnitude would be needed before such processes would rival the other SCO processes in terms of productivity. Admittedly, phototrophic processes enjoy a free carbon source (CO2) and free energy (sunlight) but these do not make up for the intrinsic very low productivities of growth and lipid production. We still await, therefore, the advent of a good, heterotrophic organism for an EPA-SCO that would rival either C. cohnii or Schizochytrium sp. being used for DHA production in terms of productivity, efficiency and cheapness. Although it has been suggested that Mort. alpina, as used for ARA production (see Section 5.2), could also be used to produce EPA (Shimizu et al., 1988, 1989), this does not seem to be a realistic proposition. The organism needs to be cultivated with α-linolenic acid (18:3n-3) or linseed oil and at a lower temperature (~ 12 °C) than is normally used for ARA production (~ 26– 28 °C). At the end of growth, the culture is allowed to stand for several days during which some lipolysis occurs and the level of EPA in the final oil goes up to about 12–15 %. The total growth period is now about two weeks but, even in this case, the EPA is still produced along with ARA so that it is still not an EPA-only oil.
5.7.2 Other PUFAs Other PUFAs that might be produced by micro-organisms have been recently reviewed by Sakuradani et al. (2005). These fatty acids include stearidonic acid (18:4n-3), dihomo-γ-linolenic acid (DHGLA, 20:3n-6), eicosatrienoic acid (20:3n-3; also known as Mead acid), and eicosatetraenoic acid (20:4n3). All these can be produced using various mutants of M. alpina (Certik et al., 1998) but, apart from DHGLA, yields are rather low (see also Ratledge, 2001) and, without further development work, are unlikely to represent realistic commercial sources. For DHGLA, however, the content of this fatty acid
Lipids from microbial sources
105
reaches about 23–25 % of the total fatty acids, and this might represent a reasonable route to obtaining oils rich in this particular PUFA. The main problem, however, with all of these PUFAs lies in their nutritional applications not being sufficiently clear, even although it has been stated that oils rich in DHGLA and Mead acid are in current production in Japan (Sakuradani et al., 2005). Docosapentaenoic acid (DPA, 22:5n-6) has already been mentioned as a component of the DHA oils produced by Schizochytrium sp. and other related organisms (see Table 5.4). It is thought that this fatty acid may be produced in Japan by Suntory Ltd (see Tam et al., 2000), possibly as a by-product of the purification of a DHA-enriched oil from one of the production organisms (see Section 5.5) already mentioned. Interestingly, DPA as the sole PUFA has been reported in a new isolate of a labyrinthulid (Kumon et al., 2003), but it is unlikely to be the commercial source of DPA as the organism can only be grown on agar plates with a dead bacterium added as a food source. As with other PUFAs mentioned above, nutritional applications of DPA are uncertain, although it has been suggested that it may be useful for it to be included with ARA and DHA as it can serve to maintain DHA at a higher circulating concentration in the blood stream (at least in rats) thereby allowing more DHA to be taken up by neural tissues (Tam et al., 2000). It would seem unlikely that there is a specific process for the production of DPA itself when the main market still remains for DHA.
5.8
Future trends
Without doubt, the very high level of current interest in DHA and other PUFAs of nutritional value will make the next decade of SCO production very exciting. In the short term, micro-organisms for the production of DHA and ARA are likely to hold centre stage probably for the next six to eight years and possibly more. A lot will depend on how successful the genetic engineers will be in producing genetically modified crops that could produce these desirable PUFAs in their seed oils as these would be cheaper than the SCOs. Martek Biosciences Corp., Maryland, USA are likely to remain the major player in this field, particularly following their acquisition of OmegaTech in 2002. However, other industrial companies will not let this position go unchallenged, especially when the various key patents begin to run out in the next five years or so. These activities will be primarily focussed, one would imagine, on establishing alternative microbial routes to DHA and ARA. The infant formula market for these oils is already established, but the market in general is capable of considerable expansion as more people become aware of the advantages of their inclusion in the diet. The incorporation of DHA into various functional foods is also likely to see considerable expansion over the next decade. Here, the benefits of DHA for the prevention of cardiac
106 Modifying lipids for use in food problems is likely to be the major driving force. To meet these demands it is likely that the Schizochytrium oils will be to the fore as these oils can be produced even more cheaply than the C. cohnii DHA-SCO and could therefore be expected to compete with the highest quality fish oils on an equal price basis. Their incorporation into a wide variety of foods and drinks should, therefore, allow considerable market penetration of these oils in the next few years. After ARA-SCO and DHA-SCO, the next likely target is probably an EPA-SCO (see Section 5.7.1). There are clear reasons why oils high in this fatty acid would find a ready and lucrative market as its major uses are in various clinical applications (see also Chapter 23). This means that high purity oils with a high content of EPA will be needed. These will probably have to be produced by fractionation of an appropriate microbial oil so that levels of EPA in the final oil would exceed 90 %. This will make the EPAoil extremely concentrated and allow consumption of multiple gram quantities without difficulty; also, any contra-indicated PUFA will be removed in such fractionation protocols. It may be anticipated that the high costs of producing and processing such an oil will not detract from its sales as products with clear medical benefits are likely to be in considerable demand and not limited by price. All that is needed to realize this target of an EPA-SCO is to find an appropriate organism, preferably one which can be grown efficiently in stirred tank fermentors, and produce an oil with at least 40 % EPA as the sole PUFA. Such an organism would then parallel the existing commercially used microorganisms for ARA and DHA oils. However, as various groups have been searching for such an organism for a number of years, it may be that such an organism does not exist and would then have to be created by genetic manipulation. This may be a formidable task, although the simplest option would appear to start with Mort. alpina which produces ARA (20:4n-6) in abundance and then clone into this organism a gene coding for a ∆17-desaturase (perhaps better termed an n-3 desaturase) so that the ARA is then converted into EPA (20:5n-3) in a single step (see Fig. 5.4). Until recently, a gene coding for an n-3 desaturase has been very elusive and difficult to find in any organism. Khozin-Goldberg et al. (2002) considered that EPA synthesis in the alga Monodus subterrraneus was via n-6 fatty acids which involved a non-specific desaturase that did act at the n-3 position but which probably could not be described as being strictly an n-3 desaturase. Huang et al. (2004) has indicated that these n-3 desaturases have a limited distribution occurring only in a few plants, some lower eukaryotic organisms (such as Mortierella) and cyanobacteria, and, moreover, may only act on C18 substrates. It is, therefore, of considerable importance in this connection to note the recent finding of Pereira et al. (2004) who reported the presence of a novel n-3 fatty acid desaturase in the EPA-producing lower fungus, Saprolegnia diclina. When the gene for this desaturase was cloned into the yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisae (which only has one desaturase, the ∆9 one
Lipids from microbial sources n-6 Series 18:2 (9, 12) (linoleic acid)
n-3 Series n-3 DS
18:3 (9, 12, 15) (α-linolenic acid)
∆6 DS
∆6 DS
18:3 (6, 9, 12) (GLA)
n-3 DS
18:4 (6, 9, 12, 15) (stearidonic acid) EL
EL 20:3 (8, 11, 14) (DHGLA)
n-3 DS
n-3 DS
n-3 DS
22:5 (7, 10, 13, 16, 19) ∆4 DS
∆4 DS 22:5 (4, 7, 10, 13, 16) (DPA)
20:5 (5, 8, 11, 14, 17) (EPA) EL
EL 22:4 (7, 10, 13, 16)
20:4 (8, 11, 14, 17) ∆5 DS
∆5 DS 20:4 (5, 8, 11, 14) (ARA)
107
n-3 DS
22:6 (4, 7, 10, 13, 16, 19) (DHA)
Fig. 5.4 Pathway for the biosynthesis and interconversion of polyunsaturated fatty acids of the n-3 and n-6 series. EL = elongase enzyme system; n-3DS = n-3 desaturase. This is the ‘conventional’ route of formation, although an alternative route known as the polyketide synthetase pathway exists in some bacteria, in Schizochytrium sp. (Metz et al., 2001) and Ulkenia sp. (Kiy et al., 2005) for the formation of EPA and DHA (see also Ratledge, 2004). In the pathways shown, the participation of the n-3 desaturases for some substrates is uncertain (see text).
for synthesizing oleic acid), and the yeast was fed with arachidonic acid, a 26 % conversion took place to EPA. The amount produced, however, was extremely small. Nevertheless, the opportunities for genetically engineering a micro-organism, such as Mort alpina, in order to achieve EPA production are now opened up. It is, however, much more likely that genetic modification of organisms will be with plants rather than with micro-organisms where there is now intense activity. These are the long-term goals of the key industrial groups active in this area. Such companies include BASF, Ross Foods, Monsanto, DuPont and others. Plants, of course, represent the ultimate cheapest source of oils and fats and thus would be the preferred route to obtain DHA, ARA, EPA and, indeed, any other desirable long-chain PUFA. Unfortunately no plant produces any PUFA longer than C18, with the best producer probably being Echium that produces stearidonic acid (18:4n-3). Other plants only produce PUFAs up to 18:3. Therefore, genetically-modified (GM) plants will be necessary to achieve these target oils.
108 Modifying lipids for use in food The problems of gene cloning into plants are considerable. Not only have the right genes to be identified and cloned, and we have seen how difficult this was with the n-3 desaturase gene mentioned above, but more than one gene will need to be put into a plant to achieve long-chain PUFA production. Even for plants such as sunflower, which is rich in linoleic acid (see Fig. 5.6), or flax, which produces α-linolenic acid (ALA), several genes would have to be inserted into them. For example, to convert ALA into EPA, two desaturases would be needed, a ∆6 and a ∆5, as well as an elongase for increasing the chain-length from C18 to C20 (see Fig. 5.4). These genes must then be expressed (i.e. the DNA must be transcribed into messenger RNA and then translated into a protein) and the resultant protein must be enzymatically active. This, in itself, may not be without difficulty as many recombinant proteins fold incorrectly and are inactive. Moreover, the genes have to work in conjunction with the existing plant fatty acid biosynthetic system and work only in plant seeds during their development and oil accumulation. The genes, thus, need to be spatially and temporally controlled. If the genes were to produce PUFAs throughout the plant, then the plant would probably be unable to function properly. To achieve this control over the expression of these foreign genes will require other genes to be inserted alongside them to ensure the correct location of the new proteins and the operation of them (switching on) at the correct time. This is a formidable task. The reports which have been issued to date (Huang et al., 2004; Napier, 2004; Napier et al., 2004; Qi et al., 2004; Sayanova and Napier, 2004) have indicated some small measure of success in getting some PUFA formation to occur in plants, but a careful inspection of the data indicates that the amounts being produced are very small indeed and would suggest that significant advances are still need to achieve even a modicum of success. An alternative strategy to cloning multiple genes from various sources is, however, possible by the discovery of a new pathway for EPA and DHA biosynthesis. EPA is synthesized in a few bacteria of marine origin by an alternative route to the conventional fatty acid synthetase system using a polyketide synthetase (PKS) (Metz et al., 2001). The same PKS route is also used in Schizochytrium sp. to produce DHA. This pathway has also been reported in Ulkenia sp. (Kiy et al., 2005), and the PKS route may be a common property of all the thraustochytrids. Whether DHA synthesis follows a similar route in C. cohnii is not yet known, but all the indications are that this is so (see for example Sonnenborn and Kunau, 1982). The PKS is an aggregate of five different proteins which together carry out 11 different reactions (Metz et al., 2001). The PKS system still uses acetyl-CoA units as the building units for fatty acid biosynthesis, but it produces a series of unsaturated intermediates where the double bond is not reduced in situ but is retained in the correct configuration so that the final product, DHA, is produced intact (see Ratledge, 2004). No further desaturation is required. No desaturases are needed and no elongases. The prospect of then cloning the intact genetic sequence coding for the
Lipids from microbial sources
109
entire PKS system thus opens up opportunities for achieving PUFA biosynthesis in a plant without having to clone in a number of different and disparate genes: however, this task is likely to be formidable. The genetic sequence of the PKS system is likely to be a number of times larger than even the largest genes that have been successfully cloned to date and may, therefore, pose problems for which solutions may not yet exist. Again, the PKS genes will need to be spatially and temporally expressed so that DHA is produced only in the maturing plant seed. How long this is likely to take is impossible to predict. When, or perhaps, if, this happens then it would be the virtual end of SCO production. Just as was seen with GLA production (see Section 5.4), it is not possible for even the cheapest SCO process to compete against plant oils. However, we should not forget that the costs of producing the Schizochytrium oil (DHASCO-S®), because of the very high productivity of the process, are likely to be reasonably low and so this will be the bottom line against which any GM-plant DHA oil will have to compete. Finally, and not insignificantly, there is always going to be the problem of the acceptance of any GM plant product by the general public. It will thus be an interesting sociological dilemma as to whether the public would prefer to consume a product from dead animals, i.e. fish, or take something from a GM crop. Perhaps, though, they may prefer to stay with SCOs – organically produced using only the purest of ingredients!
5.9
References
(1982), The composition of fish oils, in Barlow S M and Stansby M E, Nutritional Evaluation of Long-Chain Fatty Acids in Fish Oil, London, Academic Press, 21–88. BAILEY R B, DIMASI D, HANSEN J M, MIRRASOUL P J U, RUECKER C M U, VEEDER G T U, KANEKO T U and BARCLAY W R U (2003), Enhanced production of lipids containing polyenoic fatty acid by very high density cultures of eukaryotic microbes in fermentors, Patent, US6,607,900. BAJPAI P, BAJPAI P K and WARD O P (1991a), Production of docosahexaenoic acid by Thraustochytrium aureum, Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 35(6), 706–10. BAJPAI P K, BAJPAI P and WARD O P (1991b), Optimization of production of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) by Thraustochytrium aureum ATCC 34304, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 68(7), 509–54. BARCLAY W R (1991), Process for the heterotrophic production of products with high concentrations of omega-3 highly unsaturated fatty acids, Patent, WO 91/07498. BARCLAY W R (1992), Process for the heterotrophic production of microbial products with high concentrations of omega-3 highly unsaturated fatty acids, Patent, US 5,130,242. BARCLAY W R, MEAGER K M and ABRIL J R (1994), Heterotrophic production of long-chain omega-3-fatty-acids utilizing algae and algae-like microorganisms, J Appl Phycol, 6(2), 123–29. BARCLAY W R, WEAVER C and METZ J (2005), Development of a docosahexaenoic acid production technology using Schizochytrium: a historical perspective, in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 36–52. ACKMAN R G
110 Modifying lipids for use in food and HOLZ G G, JR. (1973), Environmental influences on the docosahexaenoate content of the triacylglycerols and phosphatidylcholine of a heterotrophic, marine dinoflagellate, Crypthecodinium cohnii, Biochim Biophys Acta, 316(1), 56–65. BERNHARD K and ALBRECHT H (1948), Die lipide aus Phycomyces blakeslaeeanus, Helv Chim Acta, 31, 977–988. CARLSON S E, WERKMAN S H, PEEPLES J M, COOKE R J and TOLLEY E A (1993), Arachidonic acid status correlates with first year growth in preterm infants, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 90(3), 1073–107. rd CARLSON S E, WERKMAN S H, PEEPLES J M and WILSON W M 3 (1994), Growth and development of premature infants in relation to omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acid status, World Rev Nutr Diet, 75(1), 63–69. CERTIK M, SAKURADANI E and SHIMIZU S (1998), Desaturase-defective fungal mutants: Useful tools for the regulation and overproduction of polyunsaturated fatty acids, Trends Biotechnol, 16(12), 500–505. COHEN Z and KHOZIN-GOLDBERG I (2005), Searching for PUFA-rich microalgae, in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 53–72. COHEN Z and RATLEDGE C (2005), Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press. COHEN Z, DIDI S and HEIMER Y M (1992), Overproduction of γ-linolenic and eicosapentaenoic acids by algae, Plant Physiol, 98(2), 569–72. CROZIER G, FLEITH M and SECRETIN M-C (1996), γ-Linolenic acid in infant formula, in Huang Y-S and Mills D E, γ-Linolenic Acid: Metabolism and its Roles in Nutrition and Medicine, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 246–251. ELLENBOGEN B B, AARONSON S, GOLDSTEIN S and BELSKY M (1969), Polyunsaturated fatty acids of aquatic fungi: Possible phylogenetic significance, Comp Biochem Physiol, 29, 805–811. FSANZ (2003), DHASCO and ARASCO oils as sources of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids in infant formula: A safety assessment, Technical report series No. 22, Food Standards Australia New Zealand, available at: http://www.foodstandards.gov.au/ _srcfiles/DHASCO%20and%20ARASCO%20in%20infant%20formula.pdf. GILL I and VALIVETY R (1997), Polyunsaturated fatty acids 2. Biotransformations and biotechnological applications, Trends Biotechnol, 15(11), 470–478. HARRINGTON G W and HOLZ G G (1968), The monoenoic and docosahexanenoic fatty acids of a heterotrophic dinoflagellate, Biochim Biophys Acta, 164, 137–39. HENDERSON R J, LEFTLEY J W and SARGENT J R (1988), Lipid-composition and biosynthesis in the marine dinoflagellate Crypthecodinium cohnii, Phytochemistry, 27(6), 1679–1683. HIGASHIYAMA K, FUJIKAWA S, PARK E Y and SHIMIZU S (2002), Production of arachidonic acid by Mortierella fungi, Biotechnol Bioprocess Eng, 7, 252–262. HONDA D, YOKOCHI T, NAKAHARA T, RAGHUKUMAR S, NAKAGIRI A, SCHAUMANN K and HIGASHIHARA T (1999), Molecular phylogeny of labyrinthulids and thraustochytrids based on the sequencing of 18S ribosomal RNA gene, J Eukaryot Microbiol, 46(6), 637–647. HORROBIN D F (1996), Essential fatty acids in the management of diabetic neuropathy, in Huang Y-S and Mills D E, γ-Linolenic Acid: Metabolism and its Roles in Nutrition Medicine, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 273–281. HORROBIN D F and MORSE P F (1995), Evening primrose oil and atopic eczema, Lancet, 345(8944), 260–261. HORROCKS L A and YEO Y K (1999a), Health benefits of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), Pharmacol Res, 40(3), 211–225. HORROCKS L A and YEO Y K (1999b), Docosahexaenoic acid-enriched foods: Production and effects on blood lipids, Lipids, 34, S313–S13. HUANG Y-S and MILLS D E (1996), γ-Linolenic Acid: Metabolism and its Roles in Nutrition and Medicine, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press. HUANG Y-S and SINCLAIR A (1998), Lipids in Infant Nutrition, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press. HUANG Y-S and ZIBOH V A (2001), γ-Linolenic Acid: Recent Advances in Biotechnology and Clinical Applications, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press. BEACH D H
Lipids from microbial sources HUANG Y-S, PEREIRA S L
111
and LEONARD A E (2004), Enzymes for transgenic biosynthesis of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids, Biochimie, 86(11), 793–798. KENDRICK A and RATLEDGE C (1992), Lipids of selected molds grown for production of n3 and n-6 polyunsaturated fatty-acids, Lipids, 27(1), 15–20. KHOZIN-GOLDBERG I, DIDI-COHEN S, SHAYAKHMETOVA I and COHEN Z (2002), Biosynthesis of eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) in the freshwater eustigmatophyte Monodus subterraneus (eustigmatophyceae), J Phycol, 38(4), 745–756. KIMURA H and NAGANUMA T (2001), Thraustochytrids: A neglected agent of the marine microbial food chain, Aquatic Ecosystem Health and Management, 4(1), 13–18. KIY T, RUSING M and FABRITIUS D (2005), Production of docosahexaenoic acid by the marine microalga, Ulkenia sp., in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 99–106. KOIKE Y, CAI H J, HIGASHIYAMA K, FUJIKAWA S and PARK E Y (2001), Effect of consumed carbon to nitrogen ratio on mycelial morphology and arachidonic acid production in cultures of Mortierella alpina, J Biosci Bioeng, 91(4), 382–389. KUMON Y, YOKOCHI T, NAKAHARA T, YAMAOKA M and MITO K (2002), Production of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids by monoxenic growth of labyrinthulids on oil-dispersed agar medium, Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 60(3), 275–280. KUMON Y, YOKOYAMA R, YOKOCHI T, HONDA D and NAKAHARA T (2003), A new labyrinthulid isolate, which solely produces n-6 docosapentaenoic acid, Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 63(1), 22–28. KYLE D J (1996), Production and use of a single cell oil which is highly enriched in docosahexaenoic acid, Lipid Technol, 8(5), 107–110. KYLE D J (1997), Production and use of a single cell oil highly enriched in arachidonic acid, Lipid Technol, 9, 116–121. KYLE D J (2005), The future development of single cell oils, in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 99–106. KYLE D J and RATLEDGE C (1992), Industrial Applications of Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press. LANTING C I, FIDLER V, HUISMAN M, TOUWEN B C L and BOERSMA E R (1994), Neurological differences between 9-year-old children fed breast-milk or formula-milk as babies, Lancet, 344(8933), 1319–1322. MEERS J L and PRESCOTT W (1987), Development of γ-linolenic acid, Chemspec Europe, 87, 1–3. METZ J G, ROESSLER P, FACCIOTTI D, LEVERING C, DITTRICH F, LASSNER M, VALENTINE R, LARDIZABAL K, DOMERGUE F, YAMADA A, YAZAWA K, KNAUF V and BROWSE J (2001), Production of polyunsaturated fatty acids by polyketide synthases in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, Science, 293(5528), 290–293. MO C Q, DOUEK J and RINKEVICH B (2002), Development of a PCR strategy for thraustochytrid identification based on 18S rDNA sequence, Mar Biol, 140(5), 883–889. NAKAHARA T, YOKOCHI T, KAMISAKA Y and SUZUKI O (1992), γ-Linolenic acid from genus Mortierella, in Kyle D J and Ratledge C, Industrial Applications of Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 61–97. NAPIER J A (2004), Production of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids in transgenic plants: a sustainable source for human health and nutrition, Lipid Technol, 16(5), 103– 107. NAPIER J A, BEAUDOIN F, MICHAELSON L V and SAYANOVA O (2004), The production of long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids in transgenic plants by reverse-engineering, Biochimie, 86(11), 785–792. PARK E Y, KOIKE Y, HIGASHIYAMA K, FUJIKAWA S and OKABE M (1999), Effect of nitrogen source on mycelial morphology and arachidonic acid production in cultures of Mortierella alpina, J Biosci Bioeng, 88(1), 61–67. PARK E Y, HAMANAKA T, HIGASHIYAMA K and FUJIKAWA S (2002), Monitoring of morphological development of the arachidonic-acid-producing filamentous microorganism Mortierella alpina, Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 59(6), 706–712.
112 Modifying lipids for use in food PEREIRA S L, HUANG Y S, BOBIK E G, KINNEY A J, STECCA K L, PACKER J C
and MUKERJI P (2004), A novel omega3-fatty acid desaturase involved in the biosynthesis of eicosapentaenoic acid, Biochem J, 378(Pt 2), 665–671. QI B, FRASER T, MUGFORD S, DOBSON G, SAYANOVA O, BUTLER J, NAPIER J A, STOBART A K and LAZARUS C M (2004), Production of very long chain polyunsaturated omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids in plants, Nat Biotechnol, 22(6), 739–745. RATLEDGE C (1991), Microbial lipids, in Kleinkauf H and Dèohren H V, Products of Secondary Metabolism, Weinheim, VCH, 133–197. RATLEDGE C (1992), Microbial lipids: commercial realities or academic curiosities, in Kyle D J and Ratledge C, Industrial Applications of Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 1–15. RATLEDGE C (2001), Microorganisms as sources of polyunsaturated fatty acids, in Gunstone F D, Structured and Modified Lipids, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 351–400. RATLEDGE C (2005), Single cell oils for the 21st century, in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 1–20. RATLEDGE C and WYNN J P (2002), The biochemistry and molecular biology of lipid accumulation in oleaginous microorganisms, Advances in Appl Microbiol, 51, 1–51. RATLEDGE C, STREEKSTRA H and COHEN Z (2004), Processing aspects of single cell oils, in Dunford N T and Dunford H B, Nutritionally Enhanced Edible Oil Processing, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 279–297. RATLEDGE C, STREEKSTRA H, COHEN Z and FICHTALI J (2005), Down-stream processing, extraction, and purification of single cell oils, in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 202–219. SAKURADANI E, TAKENO S, ABE T and SHIMIZU S (2005), Arachidonic acid-producing Mortierella alpina: Creation of mutants and molecular breeding, in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 21–35. SAYANOVA O V and NAPIER J A (2004), Eicosapentaenoic acid: biosynthetic routes and the potential for synthesis in transgenic plants, Phytochemistry, 65(2), 147–158. SHAHIDI F, AMAROWICZ R, ABOUGHARBIA H A and SHEHATA A A Y (1997), Endogenous antioxidants and stability of sesame oil as affected by processing and storage, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 74(2), 143–148. SHAW R (1965), The occurrence of γ-linolenic acid in fungi, Biochim Biophys Acta, 98, 230–237. SHAW R (1966a), The polyunsaturated fatty acids of microorganisms, in Paoletti R and Kritchevsky D, Advances in Lipid Research, New York, Academic Press, 107–174. SHAW R (1966b), The fatty acids of phycomycete fungi, and the significance of the γlinolenic acid component, Comp Biochem Physiol, 13, 325–331. SHIFRIN N S (1984), Oils from microalgae, in Ratledge C, Dawson P S S and Rattray J, Biotechnology for the Oils and Fats Industry, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 145–162. SHIMIZU S, KAWASHIMA H, SHINMEN Y, AKIMOTO K and YAMADA H (1988), Production of eicosapentaenoic acid by Mortierella fungi, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 65, 1455–1459. SHIMIZU S, KAWASHIMA H, AKIMOTO K, SHINMEN Y and YAMADA H (1989), Conversion of linseed oil to an eicosapentaenoic acid-containing oil by Mortierella-alpina 1s-4 at lowtemperature, Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 32(1), 1–4. SINDEN K W (1987), The production of lipids by fermentation within the EEC, Enzyme Microb Technol, 9(2), 124–125. SONNENBORN U and KUNAU W H (1982), Purification and properties of the fatty acid synthetase complex from the marine dinoflagellate, Crypthecodinium cohnii, Biochim Biophys Acta, 712(3), 523–534. STREEKSTRA H (2005), Arachidonic acid: fermentative production by Mortierella fungi, in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 73–85. TAM P S Y, UMEDA-SAWADA R, YAGUCHI T, AKIMOTO K, KISO Y and IGARASHI O (2000), The metabolism and distribution of docosapentaenoic acid (n-6) in rats and rat hepatocytes, Lipids, 35(1), 71–75.
Lipids from microbial sources TANAKA S, YAGUCHI T, SHIMIZU S, SOGO T
113
and FUJIKAWA S (2003), Process for preparing docosahexaenoic acid and docosapentaenoic acid with Ulkenia, Patent, US6,509,178. TOTANI N and OBA K (1987), The filamentous fungus Mortierella alpina, high in arachidonicacid, Lipids, 22(12), 1060–1062. TOTANI N and OBA K (1988), A simple method for production of arachidonic acid by Mortierella alpina, Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 28(2), 135–137. VAZHAPPILLY R and CHEN F (1998a), Eicosapentaenoic acid and docosahexaenoic acid production potential of microalgae and their heterotrophic growth, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 75(3), 393–397. VAZHAPPILLY R and CHEN F (1998b), Heterotrophic production potential of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids by microalgae and algae-like microorganisms, Botanica Marina, 41(6), 553–558. WEETE J D, SHEWMAKER F and GANDHI S R (1998), γ-Linolenic acid in zygomycetous fungi: Syzygites megalocarpus, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 75(10), 1367–1372. WEN Z Y and CHEN F (2000a), Heterotrophic production of eicosapentaenoic acid by the diatom Nitzschia laevis: effects of silicate and glucose, J Ind Microbiol Biotechnol, 25(4), 218–24. WEN Z Y and CHEN F (2000b), Production potential of eicosapentaenoic acid by the diatom Nitzschia laevis, Biotechnol Lett, 22(9), 727–733. WEN Z Y and CHEN F (2001), Optimization of nitrogen sources for heterotrophic production of eicosapentaenoic acid by the diatom Nitzschia laevis, Enzyme Microb Technol, 29(6–7), 341–347. WEN Z Y and CHEN F (2002), Continuous cultivation of the diatom Nitzschia laevis for eicosapentaenoic acid production: physiological study and process optimization, Biotechnol Prog, 18(1), 21–28. WEN Z and CHEN F (2005), Prospects for eicosapentaenoic acid production using microorganisms, in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 138–160. WISNIAK J and KORIN E (2005), Supercritical fluid extraction of lipids and other materials from algae, in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 220–238. WOOD B J B (1988), Lipids of algae and protozoa, in Ratledge C and Wilkinson S G, Microbial Lipids, vol. 1, London; San Diego, CA, Academic Press, 807–867. WYNN J P and RATLEDGE C (2005), Microbial production of oils and fats, in Shetty K, Food Biotechnology, Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press, Inc., 443–472. WYNN J P, BEHRENS P, SUNDARARAJAN A, HANSEN J and APT K (2005), Production of single cell oils by dinoflagellates, in Cohen Z and Ratledge C, Single Cell Oils, Champaign, Ill, AOCS Press, 86–98. YOKOCHI T, NAKAHARA T, YAMAOKA M and KURANE R (2002), Method of producing a polyunsaturated fatty acid containing culture and polyunsaturated fatty acid containing oil using microorganisms, Patent, US6,461,839. YONGMANITCHAI W C and WARD O P (1989), Omega-3 fatty-acids – alternative sources of production, Process Biochem, 24(4), 117–125. YONGMANITCHAI W and WARD O P (1992), Growth and eicosapentaenoic acid production by Phaeodactylum tricornutum in batch and continuous culture systems, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 69(6), 584–590. YUAN C L, WANG J, SHANG Y, GONG G H, YAO J M and YU Z L (2002), Production of arachidonic acid by Mortierella alpina I49–N18, Food Technol Biotechnol, 40(4), 311–315.
6 Methods of analysis to determine the quality of oils K. Warner, National Center for Agricultural Utilization Research, USA
6.1
Introduction
As discussed in other chapters in this book, the compositions of oilseeds are modified for various reasons, such as improving oxidative stability or nutritional quality. For these purposes, the fatty acid composition is the commonly altered attribute of oilseeds, although geneticists are working on changing the profiles of tocopherols too. The fatty acid composition unique to each oilseed type is most often not optimum for its end use. For example, traditional rapeseed oil contained erucic acid that was not nutritionally acceptable, so work was undertaken to decrease the erucic acid content from a range of 2– 60 % to less than 2 % in order to produce a low erucic acid rapeseed oil (also known as canola oil in North America). This oil still contained high levels (5–14 %) of linolenic acid, so additional work was done to decrease the linolenic acid to approximately 3 % to improve oxidative stability. The result was low linolenic acid canola oil. Geneticists based their early fatty acid composition targets on results from research studies on improving the oxidative stability of oils. Increasing oleic acid and decreasing linolenic and linoleic generally enhance the stability of oil compared to the unmodified oil. Examples of modified oilseeds include high oleic acid sunflower, high oleic acid safflower, high oleic acid peanut, high oleic acid soybean, and high oleic acid canola (rapeseed). Sunflower, corn and soybean have been modified to have moderate levels of oleic acid. Linolenate-containing oils such as soybean, canola and flax have cultivars with reduced linolenic acid levels. Many of these oils are suitable to replace hydrogenated vegetable oils for high-stability applications such as frying. Hydrogenated oils are also important for functionality in margarines and
Methods of analysis to determine the quality of oils
115
shortening, so oilseeds such as soybean have been bred with higher levels of palmitic and stearic acid. No matter what modifications are made to oilseed compositions, there are basic tests that need to be conducted with the resulting oil. Not only do plant geneticists want to know how successful they were in modifying the oilseeds, but also the oil processor and food manufacturer want to know the composition and characteristics of the oil before deciding to process the oilseeds or to use the oil in food applications. Finally, when fatty acids are modified, other attributes and compositional characteristics such as minor constituents of the oils may change, so it is important to evaluate the oil for more than fatty acids. As compositional changes in oilseeds become more and more intricate, accurate and reproducible methods of determining quality and composition will be important. This chapter will review the analytical methods used to measure the compositional changes from oilseed modification and to evaluate oil quality. Complete analytical details will not be provided in this chapter; however, methods will be referenced.
6.2
Methods to measure compositional attributes
6.2.1 Oil extraction Using authentic samples of seeds that are extracted by solvent or pressing without further processing provides the purest form to measure oilseed composition. In fact, Codex Alimentarius requires that oil composition analyses be conducted on crude, unprocessed oils from authentic seed samples. If crude oil is used without knowing the complete history of the sample, then contamination of the oil with unknown oil can give misleading results for the oil composition. Therefore, oil should be extracted from a known lot of seeds. In addition, processing steps can alter some compositional factors. For example, deodorization can remove various amounts of tocopherols depending on the conditions of deodorizing. No further processing beyond extraction is necessary if only the effects of oilseed modification are needed. Oil may be collected from the seeds by pressing or solvent-extraction. If oil yield information is needed then a solvent-extraction of ground seeds is necessary (AOCS, 1998).
6.2.2 Fatty acids and trans fatty acids Fatty acid composition is the primary attribute measured in altered oilseeds. Two methods for fatty acid composition by gas–liquid chromatography (GLC) of vegetable oils are ISO 6321:1991 (ISO, 2005) plus Amendment 1:1998 (ISO, 2005) and AOCS Ce 1e-91(97) (AOCS, 1998). The AOCS has method Ce 1e-91(97) (AOCS, 1998) for fatty acid composition by GLC of vegetable oils. If the oil is hydrogenated or refined, then AOCS Method Ce 1f-96 (97) (AOCS, 1998) or ISO 15304:2002 (ISO, 2005) can be used to determine cis
116 Modifying lipids for use in food and trans fatty acids by capillary GLC. This method is designed to identify and quantify the trans fatty acid isomers in vegetable oils using a capillary column with a highly polar stationary phase, according to their chain-length, degree of unsaturation and geometry and position of the double bonds. Data on all other fatty acids can be obtained at the same time. A spectrophotometric method to determine trans fatty acids is available as AOCS Method Cd 1495(97) (AOCS, 1998) and is appropriate for natural or processed long-chain acids, esters and triglycerides with trans levels greater than 0.5 %. It is not applicable for oils with over 5 % of conjugated unsaturation. The Codex Alimentarius Committee on Fats and Oils has a Named Vegetable Oil Standard (Codex Alimentarius, 2001) with the primary compositions of 21 oils including four modified oils (low erucic acid rapeseed, high oleic safflower, high oleic sunflower and mid-oleic sunflower). The fatty acid compositions of the modified oils and their corresponding traditional oils are shown in Tables 6.1 and 6.2. Two soybean oils (low linolenic acid soybean and mid-oleic soybean) were proposed for inclusion in the standard at the February, 2005 meeting of the Fats and Oils Committee. Codex Alimentarius quotes minimum and/or maximum limits for some of the fatty acids of modified oilseeds. For example, low erucic acid rapeseed oil must not contain Table 6.1 oils.
6:0 8:0 10:0 12:0 14:0 16:0 16:1 17:0 17:1 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3 20:0 20:1 20:2 22:0 22:1 22:2 24:0 24:1
Fatty acid compositions of crude regular and modified soybean and rapeseed
Soybean
Soybean (low linolenic acid)
Soybean (mid-oleic acid)
Rapeseed
Rapeseed (low erucic acid)
ND ND ND ND–0.1 ND–0.2 8.0–13.5 ND–0.2 ND–0.1 ND–0.1 2.0–5.4 17.7–28.0 49.8–59.0 5.0–11.0 0.1–0.6 ND–0.5 ND–0.1 ND–0.7 ND–0.3 ND ND–0.5 ND
ND ND ND ND–0.1 ND–0.2 8.0–13.5 ND–0.1 ND–0.1 ND–0.1 2.0–5.4 22.0–33.0 48.0–60.0 0.5–4.5 ND ND–0.5 ND–0.1 ND–0.7 ND–0.3 ND ND–0.5 ND
ND ND ND ND–0.1 ND–0.2 5.0–13.5 ND–0.2 ND–0.1 ND–0.1 2.0–5.4 45.0–70.0 15.0–40.0 0.5–4.5 ND ND–0.5 ND–0.1 ND–0.7 ND–0.3 ND ND–0.5 ND
ND ND ND ND ND–0.2 1.5–6.0 ND–3.0 ND–0.1 ND–0.1 0.5–3.1 8.0–60.0 11.0–23.0 5.0–13.0 ND–3.0 3.0–15.5 ND–1.0 ND–2.0 > 2.0–60.0 ND–2.0 ND–2.0 ND–3.0
ND ND ND ND ND–0.2 2.5–7.0 ND–0.6 ND–0.1 ND–0.1 0.8–3.0 51.0–70.0 15.0–30.0 5.0–14.0 0.2–11.2 0.1–4.3 ND–0.1 ND–0.6 ND–2.0 ND–0.1 ND–0.3 ND–0.4
ND = not detectable Source: Codex Alimentarius (2001).
Methods of analysis to determine the quality of oils
117
Table 6.2 Fatty acid compositions of crude regular and modified safflowerseed and sunflower oils. Fatty acid
Safflowerseed
Safflowerseed (high oleic acid)
Sunflower
Sunflower (mid-oleic acid)
Sunflower (high oleic acid)
6:0 8:0 10:0 12:0 14:0 16:0 16:1 17:0 17:1 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3 20:0 20:1 20:2 22:0 22:1 22:2 24:0 24:1
ND ND ND ND ND–0.2 5.3–8.0 ND–0.2 ND–0.1 ND–0.1 1.9–2.9 8.4–21.3 67.8–83.2 ND–0.1 0.2–0.4 0.1–0.3 ND ND–1.0 ND–1.8 ND ND–0.2 ND–0.2
ND ND ND ND–0.2 ND–0.2 3.6–6.0 ND–0.2 ND–0.1 ND–0.1 1.5–2.4 70.0–83.7 9.0–19.9 ND–1.2 0.3–0.6 0.1–0.5 ND ND–0.4 ND–0.3 ND ND–0.3 ND–0.3
ND ND ND ND–0.1 ND–0.2 5.0–7.6 ND–0.3 ND–0.2 ND–0.1 2.7–6.5 14.0–39.4 48.3–74.0 ND–0.3 ND ND–0.3 ND 0.3–1.5 ND–0.3 ND–0.3 ND–0.5 ND
ND ND ND ND ND–0.1 4.0–5.5 ND–0.05 ND–0.05 ND–0.06 2.1–5.0 43.1–71.8 18.7–45.3 ND–0.5 ND 0.2–0.3 ND 0.6–1.1 ND ND–0.09 0.3–0.5 ND
ND ND ND ND ND–0.1 2.6–5.0 ND–0.1 ND–0.1 ND–0.1 2.9–6.2 75.0–90.7 2.1–17.0 ND–0.3 ND 0.1–0.5 ND 0.5–1.6 ND–0.3 ND ND–0.5 ND
ND = not detectable Source: Codex Alimentarius (2001).
more than 2 % erucic acid as a percentage of the total fatty acids. High oleic acid safflower oils cannot contain less than 70 % oleic acid as a percentage of the total fatty acids, and high oleic acid sunflower oil cannot contain less than 75 % oleic acid as a percentage of the total fatty acids. When oleic acid content of mid-oleic sunflower was added to the Named Vegetable Oil Standard (Codex Alimentarius, 2001) its composition for oleic was between that of sunflower oil and high oleic acid sunflower oil. Oleic acid ranges are for sunflower 14–39.4 %, 43.1–71.8 % for mid-oleic sunflower oil and 75–90.7 % for high oleic sunflower oil. Although the ranges of fatty acids for these oils for the Codex standard provide valuable information, they are the result of hundreds of crude oil samples. Several researchers have published fatty acid compositions of modified oilseeds that have been processed into edible oils through the traditional processes of refining, bleaching and deodorizing (Fuller et al., 1971; Purdy, 1985; Warner and Knowlton, 1997; Petukhov et al., 1999; Pokorny, 2000; Tompkins and Perkins, 2000; Warner et al., 2003; Hosseinian, 2004). The fatty acid composition data in these papers is for individual oils rather than many samples as in the Codex tables.
118 Modifying lipids for use in food 6.2.3 Tocopherols and tocotrienols It is important to measure the tocol content of an oil because of both nutritional quality and oxidative stability. In addition, the tocopherol profile is sometimes used as an identity characteristic for an oil. Tocopherols and tocotrienols are important bioactive constituents in vegetable oils. They are vitamin-E-active substances derived from a chromanol structure. In vivo, α-tocopherol is the primary precursor to vitamin E; however, δ- and γ-tocopherol are the most potent antioxidants in vitro. Although plant geneticists are currently modifying some oilseeds to optimize the amounts, types and ratios of tocopherols, the effect of fatty acid modification on tocopherol contents is the present objective in measuring tocopherols. Mounts (1996) compared the tocopherol contents of 12 soybean oils with modified fatty acid compositions. The soybeans with high palmitic acid and high stearic acid had higher levels of β-tocopherol; however, few differences in tocopherol contents were reported in modified and unmodified canola oils (Abidi et al., 1999). AOCS method Ce 8-89 (AOCS, 1998) describes a procedure to determine tocopherols and tocotrienols in vegetable oils and fats by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Calibration curves are determined for each tocopherol from tocopherol standards, and the calibration factors for tocotrienols are considered to be equivalent to that of the corresponding tocopherols. The ISO 9936:1997 (ISO, 2005) method can also be used. Normal-phase HPLC techniques are most commonly used to separate tocol peaks because β-tocopherol and γ-tocopherol can be resolved. However, reverse-phase (RP)HPLC methods with an octadecylsilica (ODS) column cannot resolve the β- and γ-tocopherols. Abidi (2003) found that a polar RP-HPLC column (pentafluorophenlylsilica) system could separate these homologues. The tocopherol contents of crude low linolenic acid soybean, mid-oleic acid soybean, low erucic acid rapeseed, high oleic acid sunflower, mid-oleic acid sunflower and high oleic acid safflower oils are given in Tables 6.3 and 6.4 along with the original oils. Few differences in the ranges of the compositions are seen between the regular and modified oils with the exception of the αtocopherol contents of the sunflower oil. The range of α-tocopherol is wider for sunflower oil and high oleic acid sunflower oil than for mid-oleic sunflower oil, probably because the seeds for the mid-oleic sunflower were only collected from the USA but the seeds for sunflower and high oleic sunflower were obtained from various parts of the world. Tocotrienols are important nutritionally as well as for improving oxidative stability. They are found at only low levels in most vegetable oils with higher levels in palm, maize (corn), and rice bran oils.
6.2.4 Sterols Desmethylsterols are often measured for the purposes of oil identity because oils have distinct patterns of sterols. Sterol contents can be measured by methods ISO 12228:1999 (ISO, 2005) or AOCS Ch 6-91 (97) (AOCS,
Methods of analysis to determine the quality of oils
119
1998). Gas chromatography (GC) is the most frequently used technique for the analysis of sterols. Fused-silica capillary columns contain chemically bonded stationary phases of variable polarity and are widely used because of their durability and flexibility. When high-temperature capillary GC columns (e.g. phenylmethylsilicone) are used, sterol sample assays can be conducted with high sensitivity and good resolution. In a typical analysis, GC is coupled with flame ionization (FID) to monitor analytes in the column effluents or with mass spectrometry (MS) for structural identification and quantitation. Other detectors such as electron capture and thermal conductivity detectors are less commonly used because FID has the best GC features in terms of detection sensitivity, response linearity, and response generality (Abidi, 2001). Mounts et al. (1996) found no correlations of sterol content changing with changes in fatty acids of 13 crude soybean oils. On the other hand, Abidi et al. (1999) reported that sterol composition was affected by modification of fatty acids in canola oil. For example, brassicasterol, campesterol, and β-sitosterol levels were consistently lower in high oleic/low linolenic acid canola oils than in regular canola oils. The phytosterol contents of crude modified soybean, rapeseed, sunflower, and safflower are given in Tables 6.3 and 6.4.
6.2.5 Phospholipids Phospholipids are important minor constituents of crude oils that are removed to varying degrees during oil processing. Mounts et al. (1996) found little effect on the phospholipid contents of 13 crude soybean oils as fatty acid compositions were altered compared to a control with traditional composition. In contrast, Abidi et al. (1999) found that crude high oleic/low linolenic acid canola oils had higher amounts of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidic acid than regular canola oil. In another type of soybean that was bred to be resistant to glyphosate-based herbicides, List et al. (1999) reported no differences in amounts of phospholipids in crude glyphosate-tolerant soybean oil vs regular crude soybean oil. Phospholipids can be analyzed by AOCS method Ja 7b-91 (AOCS, 1998).
6.3
Methods of measuring characteristics of edible oils
6.3.1 Chemical and physical characteristics A group of chemical and physical characteristics that may vary with fatty acid modification include relative density, refractive index, saponification value, iodine value, and unsaponifiable matter. The values for crude sunflower oil and its two modified fatty acid composition counterparts are given in Table 6.5. There are few differences in the ranges of values for the various characteristics with the exception of iodine value for which differences would be expected. Appropriate methods for these procedures are available from
Table 6.3
Compositions of tocopherols and sterols in crude regular and modified soybean and rapeseed oils. Soybean
Soybean (low linolenic acid)
Soybean (mid-oleic acid)
Rapeseed
Rapeseed (low erucic acid)
Tocopherols (mg/kg) Alpha tocopherol Beta tocopherol Gamma tocopherol Delta tocopherol Alpha tocotrienol Gamma tocotrienol Delta tocotrienol Total tocols
9–352 ND–36 89–2307 154–932 ND–69 ND–103 ND 600–3370
84–138 ND–30 356–424 262–392 ND–45 ND–85 ND 740–945
139–168 ND–30 271–324 266–303 ND–45 ND–85 ND 676–778
234–660 ND–17 ND–12 ND ND ND–12 ND 240–670
100–386 ND–140 189–753 ND–22 ND ND ND 430–2680
Phytosterols (% total) Cholesterol Brassicasterol Campesterol Stigmasterol Beta sitosterol Delta 5-avenasterol Delta 7-stigmasterol Delta 7-avenasterol Total sterols (mg/kg)
0.6–1.4 ND–0.3 15.8–24.2 14.9–19.1 51.0–60.0 1.9–3.7 1.4–5.2 1.0–4.6 1800–4100
0.2–0.5 ND–0.2 22.4–25.7 19.6–20.4 47.5–51.8 0.6–1.6 0.3–1.9 0.2–1.1 1967–2997
0.2–0.5 ND–0.2 22.2–24.1 20.0–25.2 44.1–45.4 1.8–2.0 1.3–1.9 0.3–0.5 1569–2568
ND–0.7 ND–0.4 24.7–38.6 ND–0.9 45.1–57.9 3.1–6.6 ND–1.3 ND–0.8 4800–11 300
0.5–1.3 5.0–13.0 24.7–38.6 ND–0.9 45.1–57.9 3.1–6.6 ND–1.3 ND–0.8 4800–11 300
ND = not detectable Source: Codex Alimentarius (2001).
Table 6.4
Compositions of tocopherols and sterols in crude regular and modified safflowerseed and sunflower oils. Safflowerseed
Safflowerseed (high oleic acid)
Sunflower
Sunflower (mid-oleic acid)
Sunflower (high oleic acid)
Tocopherols (mg/kg) Alpha tocopherol Beta tocopherol Gamma tocopherol Delta tocopherol Alpha tocotrienol Gamma tocotrienol Delta tocotrienol Total tocols
234–660 ND–17 ND–12 ND ND ND–12 ND 240–670
234–660 ND–13 ND–44 ND–6 ND ND–10 ND 250–700
403–935 ND–35 ND–34 ND–7 ND ND ND 440–1520
488–668 19–52 2.3–19.0 ND–1.6 ND ND ND 509–741
400–1090 10–35 3.0–30.0 ND–17.0 ND ND ND 450–1120
Phytosterols (% total) Cholesterol Brassicasterol Campesterol Stigmasterol Beta sitosterol Delta 5-avenasterol Delta 7-stigmasterol Delta 7-avenasterol Others Total sterols (mg/kg)
ND–0.7 ND–0.4 9.2–13.3 4.5–9.6 40.2–50.6 0.8–4.8 6.5–24 2.2–6.3 0.5–6.4 2100–4600
ND–0.5 ND–2.2 8.9–19.9 2.9–8.9 40.1–66.9 0.2–8.9 7.7–7.9 ND–8.3 4.4–11.9 2000–4100
ND–0.7 ND–0.2 6.5–13.0 6.0–13.0 50.0–70.0 ND–6.9 6.5–24.0 3.0–7.5 ND–5.3 2400–5000
0.1–0.2 ND–0.1 9.1–9.6 9.0–9.3 56.0–58.0 4.8–5.3 7.7–7.9 4.3–4.4 5.4–5.8 2200–4500
ND–0.5 ND–0.3 5.0–13.0 4.5–13.0 42.0–70.0 1.5–6.9 6.5–24.0 ND–9.0 3.5–9.5 1700–5200
ND = not detectable Source: Codex Alimentarius (2001).
122 Modifying lipids for use in food Table 6.5 Chemical and physical characteristics of crude regular and modified sunflowerseed oils. Sunflowerseed oil
Sunflowerseed oil (mid-oleic acid)
Sunflowerseed oil (high oleic acid)
Relative density (x°C/water at 20°C)
0.918–0.915 x = 20°C
0.914–0.916 x = 20°C
0.909–0.915 x = 25°C
Refractive index
1.461–1.468
1.461–1.4671
1.467–1.471
Saponification value (mg KOH/g oil)
188–194
190–191
182–194
Iodine value
118–141
94–122
78–90
Unsaponifiable matter (g/kg)
≤15
≤15
≤15
ND = not detectable Source: http://www.codexalimentarius.net (Official Standards: CXS_210_2003e [1].pdf).
ISO or AOCS. Refractive index can be conducted according to ISO 6320:2000 (ISO, 2005) or AOCS Cc 7-25 (02) (AOCS, 1998). Saponification value procedures are available as ISO 3657:2000 (ISO, 2005) or AOCS Cd 3-25 (02) (AOCS, 1998). Unsaponifiable matter can be conducted according to ISO 3596:2000 (ISO, 2005), or ISO 18609:2000 (ISO, 2005), or AOCS Ca 6b-53(01) (AOCS, 1998). Oils intended for margarines and shortenings must have suitable fatty acid composition either present naturally or obtained by processing/treatments such as hydrogenation and interesterification. Slip point and solid fat index can provide information as to the suitability of an oil for margarines and shortenings. List et al. (1996) used solid fat index (AOCS method Cd 10-57) (AOCS, 1998) to show that some soybean oils modified by plant breeding to have increased amounts of stearic acid could be used for margarines. The melting point of oils for margarines and shortenings is also of interest. The slip point can be measured using ISO 6321 (1991) (ISO, 2005) or AOCS method Cc 3b-92 (AOCS, 1998), which is adopted from the ISO method. Triacylglycerol (TAG) composition is an additional compositional analysis that can provide information on the potential functionality of an oil as well as its potential oxidative stability. Reversed-phase HPLC with various detection methods such as FID, refractive index, evaporative light scattering, or atmospheric chemical ionization (coupled with mass spectrometry) can be used to determine TAG composition (Neff et al., 1994, 2001).
6.3.2 Quality characteristics According to the Codex Alimentarius Committee’s Named Vegetable Oil Standard (Codex Alimentarius, 2005), there are quality characteristics that each oil must meet. For example, each oil should be characteristic of the
Methods of analysis to determine the quality of oils
123
designated product and be free of foreign and rancid odor and taste. Maximum levels of matter volatile at 105 °C [ISO 662:1998 (ISO, 2005)] should be 0.2 % m/m, insoluble purities [ISO 663:1998 (ISO, 2005)] 0.05 % m/m, and 0.005% m/m soap content [AOCS Ce17-95 (97) (AOCS, 1998)]. Limits for metals are 1.5 mg/kg iron (Fe) in refined oils and 5.0 mg/kg Fe in virgin oils, whereas only 0.1 mg/kg of copper (Cu) are allowed in refined oils and 0.4 mg/kg Cu in virgin oils. Methods to use for measuring Fe and Cu include ISO 8294:1994 (ISO, 2005) or AOCS Ca 18b-91 (97) (AOCS, 1998). Limits for oil deterioration include peroxide value and acid value. Codex allows up to 10 meq/kg oil for refined oils and up to 20 meq/kg of cold pressed or virgin oil. Acid value limits range from a low of 0.6 mg/KOH/g oil for refined oils to 4 mg/KOH/g cold pressed or virgin oils. There are two quality characteristics specific for low erucic acid rapeseed oil. The Crismer value is used to identify oils through their miscibility with a standard reagent [AOCS Cb 4-35 (97) (AOCS, 1998)]. The value for low erucic acid rapeseed (canola) oil should be in the range of 67–70. Also, the brassicasterol content should not be greater than 5 % of the total sterols [ISO 12228:1999 (ISO, 2005) or AOCS Ch 6-91 (97) (AOCS, 1998)].
6.3.3 Oxidation The oxidative stability of oil can be determined in the crude stage, although it is much more common to evaluate the oil after complete processing through the deodorization step. AOCS has a recommended practice (AOCS method Cg 3-91) (AOCS, 1998) for assessing oil quality and stability. The practice lists procedures that measure either directly or indirectly some of the primary and secondary oxidation products. For example, peroxide value analysis (AOCS method Cd 8-53) (AOCS, 1998) determines the hydroperoxide content and is a good analysis of primary oxidation products. To determine secondary oxidation products, the procedure recommends p-anisidine value (AOCS Method Cd 18-90) (AOCS, 1998), volatile compounds by GC (AOCS Method Cg 4-94) (AOCS, 1998), and flavor evaluation (AOCS Method Cg 2-83) (AOCS, 1998). The anisidine value method determines the amount of aldehydes (principally 2-alkenals and 2,4-dienals) in fats and oils, by reaction in an acetic acid solution of the aldehydic compounds in oil and the p-anisidine. The mixture is examined at an absorbance of 350 nm. The volatile compound analysis method measures secondary oxidation products formed during the decomposition of fatty acids. These compounds can be primarily responsible for the flavors in oils. The flavor evaluation of oils by tasting is the best method for determining oil quality and stability, although the procedure must be done using trained sensory judges. The Oil Stability Index (OSI) is another method to measure oil stability that can be conducted using AOCS Method Cd 12b-92 (AOCS, 1998) with a Rancimat instrument or an Oxidative Stability instrument. In this method for determining an induction period for oxidation, a stream of purified air is passed through a sample of oil held in
124 Modifying lipids for use in food a heated bath. The effluent air from the oil is then bubbled through a vessel with deionized water and the conductivity of the water is continually monitored. The effluent air contains volatile organic acids such as formic acid, swept from the oxidizing oil, that increase the conductivity of the water as oxidation continues. The OSI is defined as the point of maximum change of the oxidation. The OSI may be run at temperatures of 100, 100, 120, 130, and 140 °C. It can be used to analyze crude oils or fully processed oils.
6.4
Future trends
Plant geneticists have revolutionized the vegetable oil industry with modified fatty acid composition oils. This is an opportune time for these new oils as we are looking for more healthful oils that are stable without the need for saturated fatty acids and/or hydrogenation. Some oils with modified fatty acid compositions such as low linolenic soybean oil and low linolenic acid canola oil are potential substitutes for hydrogenated oil; however, these oils are not as stable as hydrogenated oil. On the other hand, some vegetable oils such as rice bran have enhanced stability, probably because of naturally occurring phytochemicals. The next stage of oil modification will probably be focused on altering the types and amounts of minor oil constituents in oilseeds. Although plant geneticists relied on oil stability research conducted in the 1950s and beyond to decide which fatty acids to target for change, they now need information on optimum phytochemical compositions to breed oilseeds with altered levels and ratios of these natural antioxidants. Not enough information is available on how these antioxidant phytochemicals affect product quality, stability, and end use performance. Basic research is needed to determine the relationship between product composition and desired flavor quality and stability attributes in soybean, sunflower, corn, and other oilseeds. An ideal substitute for hydrogenated oil would combine the positive attributes of both modified fatty acid composition and phytochemicals. Methods of evaluating oil quality and stability also must evolve and change with the need to measure minor oil constituents more accurately and reproducibly. Oil processors and food manufacturers are always interested in rapid measurements of oxidation. The oxidative stability index is the newest technique to measure stability of oil quickly; however, the high temperature that the procedure is conducted at may not be relevant to ambient temperature at which most oils are stored. Frankel (1993) has suggested that the variation in results at 110 °C with the rapid analysis and ambient temperature storage may be because of differences in the oxidation mechanisms at the two temperatures. New procedures that are rapid but do not have this problem must be developed. The ability to distinguish between the seeds modified by genetic engineering and those modified by traditional plant breeding may be of concern to lipid chemists. Presently, a molecular geneticist can distinguish
Methods of analysis to determine the quality of oils
125
between seeds using molecular analysis of the sequences of DNA bases to detect the presence or absence of the gene in the DNA of the plant cell’s nucleus. Distinguishing between oils derived from a transgenic plant versus a traditonally developed plant was not thought to be possible because oil does not usually have any DNA in it. However, if some plant cells are present in the oil, the DNA in the nucleus can be analyzed to find out what plant produced that oil – either a transgenic plant or a traditionally developed plant.
6.5
Sources of further information and advice
Original research papers in scientific journals and review papers in books are a primary source of information about methods used to measure oil quality. Official methods and recommended practices are available from AOCS, ASTM, IUPAC, AOAC, and ISO. In addition, the Codex Alimentarius Committee on Fats and Oils has developed compositional tables of crude vegetable oils. Their Standard for Named Vegetable Oils is available through the Codex Alimentarius web site as listed in the reference section. In addition, extensive information about lipid structure, composition, and methods of analyses is available in The Lipid Handbook (Gunstone et al., 1994). The third edition of W.M. Christie’s Lipid Analysis: Isolation, Separation, Identification and Structural Analysis of Lipids (2003) is a good resource for analyzing classes of lipids. In Trans Fatty Acids in Human Nutrition by Sebedio and Christie (1998), Ratnayake discusses several methods for measuring trans fatty acids. For extensive information on measuring lipid oxidation, the second edition of Lipid Oxidation (Frankel, 2005) is recommended.
6.6
References
(2001), Chromatographic analysis of plant sterols in foods and vegetable oils, J Chromatogr A, 935, 173–201. ABIDI S L (2003), Tocol-derived minor constituents in selected plant seed oils, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 80, 327–333. ABIDI S L, LIST G R and RENNICK K R (1999), Effect of genetic modification on the distribution of minor constituents in canola oil, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 76, 463–467. AOCS (1998), Official Methods and Recommended Practices, Champaign, IL, AOCS Press, 5th edn. CHRISTIE, W M (2003), Lipid Analysis: Isolation, Separation, Identification and Structural Analysis of Lipids, Bridgewater, Oily Press. CODEX ALIMENTARIUS (2001), Codex Standard 210 Named Vegetable Oils, amended 2005, available at: www.codexalimentarius.net. FRANKEL E N (1993), In search of better methods to evaluate natural antioxidants and oxidative stability in food lipids, Trends Food Sci Tech, 4, 220–225. ABIDI S L
126 Modifying lipids for use in food (2005), Lipid Oxidation 2nd edn, Bridgewater, Oily Press. and APPLEWHITE T H (1971), High-oleic safflower oil stability and chemical modification, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 44, 266–271. GUNSTONE F D, HARWOOD J L and PADLEY F B (1994), The Lipid Handbook, London, Chapman and Hall. HOSSEINIAN F S, ROWLAND G G, BHIRUD P R, DYCK J H and TYLER R T (2004), Chemical composition and physicochemical and hydrogenation characteristics of high-palmitic acid Solin (low-linolenic acid flaxseed) oil, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 81, 185–188. ISO (1994), ISO Standard 8294, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of copper, iron and nickel contents – Graphite furnace atomic absorption method, Geneva, ISO. ISO (1997), ISO Standard 9936, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of tocopherols and tocotrienols contents – Method using high-performance liquid chromatography, Geneva, ISO. ISO (1998), ISO Standard 662, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of moisture and volatile matter content, Geneva, ISO. ISO (1999), ISO Standard 12228, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of individual and total sterols contents – Gas chromatographic method, Geneva, ISO. ISO (2000a), ISO Standard 6320, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of refractive index, Geneva, ISO. ISO (2000b), ISO Standard 3596, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of unsaponifiable matter – Method using diethyl ether extraction, Geneva, ISO. ISO (2000c), ISO Standard 18609, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of unsaponifiable matter – Method using hexane extraction, Geneva, ISO. ISO (2000d), ISO Standard 663, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of insoluble impurities content, Geneva, ISO. ISO (2002a), ISO Standard 6321, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of melting point in open capillary tubes (slip point), Geneva, ISO. ISO (2002b), ISO Standard 3657, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of saponification value, Geneva, ISO. ISO (2002c), ISO Standard 15304, Animal and vegetable fats and oils – Determination of the content of trans fatty acid isomers of vegetable fats and oils – Gas chromatographic method, Geneva, ISO. LIST G R, MOUNTS T L, ORTHOEFER F and NEFF W E (1996), Potential margarine oils from genetically modified soybeans, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 73, 729–732. LIST G R, ORTHOEFER F, TAYLOR N, NELSEN T and ABIDI S L (1999), Characterization of phospholipids from glyphosate-tolerant soybeans, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 76, 57–60. MOUNTS T L, ABIDI S L and RENNICK K A (1996), Effect of genetic modification on the content and composition of bioactive constituents in soybean oil, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 73, 581–586. NEFF W E, MOUNTS T L, RINSCH W, KONISHI H and EL-AGAIMY M A (1994), Oxidative stability of purified canola oil triacylglycerols with altered fatty acid compositions as affected by triacylglycerol composition and structure, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 71, 1101–1109. NEFF W E, BYRDWELL W C and LIST G R (2001), A new method to analyze triacylglycerol composition of vegetable oils, Cereal Foods World, 46, 6–10. PETUKHOV I, MALCOLMSON L J, PRZYBYLSKI R and ARMSTRONG L (1999), Frying performance of genetically modified canola oils, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 76, 627–632. POKORNY J (2000), Resistance of high-oleic acid peanut oil against autoxidation under storage and deep frying conditions, Czech J Food Sci, 18, 125–126. PURDY R H (1985), Oxidative stability of high oleic sunflower and safflower oils, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 62, 523–525. SEBEDIO J L and CHRISTIE W W (1998), Trans Fatty Acids in Human Nutrition, Dundee, Oily Press. FRANKEL E N
FULLER G, DIAMOND M J
Methods of analysis to determine the quality of oils
127
and PERKINS E G (2000), Frying performance of low-linolenic acid soybean oil, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 77, 223–229. WARNER K and KNOWLTON S (1997), Frying quality and oxidative stability of high oleic corn oils, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 74, 1317–1322. WARNER K, VICK B, KLEINGARTNER L, ISAAK R and DOROFF K (2003), Compositions of sunflower, NuSun (mid-oleic sunflower) and high oleic sunflower oils, available at: http:// www.sunflowernsa.com/research_statistics/research_workshop/documents/107.PDF, 1–7. TOMPKINS C
7 Selected topics in the chemistry and biochemistry of lipids F. Gunstone, Scottish Crop Research Institute, UK
7.1
Introduction
This book is not a primer devoted to the chemistry and biochemistry of fatty acids. However, the concepts described in several chapters require some basic information, and selected topics are presented in this chapter to facilitate understanding elsewhere.
7.2
Partial hydrogenation
Following the invention of a replacement spread for butter by Mège Mouriés in 1869, there was an increased demand for semi-solid fat to replace the beef tallow olein used in the original recipe. This requirement was met by the development and use of partially hydrogenated vegetable oils following the discovery of catalytic hydrogenation of fatty oils by Normann in 1902. Vegetable oils subjected to partial hydrogenation are mixtures of triacylglycerols (Chapter 2). Most of these are liquid at room temperature. During hydrogenation the proportion of solid triacylglycerols increases and eventually a plastic solid is produced. This is a mixture of solids and liquids that appears to be solid but deforms under pressure as when spreading with a knife. During partial hydrogenation there is a fall in the level of polyunsaturated acids and a rise in the level of monounsaturated and saturated acids. The lower levels of linoleic and linolenic acid result in a product with higher oxidative stability (Section 7.3). However, these benefits are gained at a price. The partially hydrogenated oil has lower nutritional value compared with the original vegetable oil since it contains less essential fatty acids (linoleic and α-linolenic acid) and has unsaturated acids with trans configuration.
Selected topics in the chemistry and biochemistry of lipids
129
These changes are a consequence of molecular alterations that occur during partial hydrogenation viz. saturation of double bonds (reduction) and double bonds changing position in the carbon chain and configuration (isomerization). The control and balance of saturation and isomerization during partial hydrogenation are important to get a good quality product and to get it repeatedly. Dijkstra (2002) has proposed a modification of the Horiuti–Polanyi mechanism to explain the changes that occur during partial hydrogenation of fatty acids and their esters. In the following sequence the horizontal line shows the conversion of diene to monoene and of monoene to saturated acid/ ester via the half-hydrogenated states DH and MH. The steps shown vertically are the reverse processes whereby DH goes back to D and MH goes back to M. It is during these stages that trans and positional isomers are formed. There are six stages altogether, and it is important to understand their relative rates. In the conversion of D to M the first step is rate-determining and the second step is fast. Accordingly, the concentration of DH is never high, and the conversion of DH back to D is slow and is only important in the unusual situation that hydrogen is present in very low concentration. In the conversion of M to S the final stage is slow and rate-determining, thus making it more likely that there will be considerable recycling of M and MH leading to formation of stereochemical and positional isomers. D → DH → M → MH → S ↓ ↓ D M On a commercial scale the catalyst most commonly employed is nickel. This is usually deposited on an inert support and is supplied encased in a hardened fat. Reaction is generally conducted at 180–200 °C and 3 bar pressure in vessels containing up to 30 tonnes of oil. In a batchwise operation 8–10 batches can be hydrogenated in a 24 hour period. Forty years ago catalyst was used at a level of 0.2 %, but now this is generally 0.025–0.05 %. This reduction has been achieved through improved catalyst and through increasing awareness of the need to use highly refined oils and pure hydrogen (Berben, 2002). During partial hydrogenation, competition between reduction (saturation) and isomerization is controlled by the relation between the supply and demand of hydrogen at the catalyst surface. A good supply of hydrogen leads to reduction while isomerization is more significant when hydrogen supply is inadequate. Hydrogen supply and demand depend on reaction temperature and pressure, agitation, catalyst quantity and quality, and the level of unsaturation of the oil being hydrogenated. Agitation is linked to transfer of hydrogen through gas, liquid (dissolved in oil) and solid phases (adsorbed on the catalyst). Attempts are being made to modify hydrogenation procedures so that less
130 Modifying lipids for use in food trans acids are formed, such as the development of catalysts based on platinum or palladium, but these are not yet being used on an industrial scale. A major purpose of partial hydrogenation is to harden fats, and this is presently achieved through a small rise in the level of saturated acids and a larger rise in trans acid content. It is difficult to see how, if trans acids are to decline, the necessary hardening can be achieved without raising levels of saturated acids which is also considered to be undesirable (Kellens, 2000).
7.3
Autoxidation, photo-oxidation and antioxidants
The unsaturated components in oils and fats and in materials such as rubber and paint films deteriorate as a consequence of their reaction with oxygen. In food lipids these changes are noticeable, even at modest levels, because they lead to rancidity which is apparent to the olfactory senses and is a matter of concern for the food industry, the retailer and the consumer. Most food systems contain some built-in protection against oxidation, but once this barrier is overcome oxidation proceeds steadily. The period of time during which oxidation is slow is called the induction period, and ideally this should be as long as possible. It is important to understand what causes oxidation, what are its consequences and how it can be inhibited. In any of the modification procedures discussed in this book, it is important to consider what effect the changes might have on potential oxidation resulting either from alterations in the nature of the fatty acids or in the (generally unassessed) levels of pro- and antioxidants. Two processes of oxidative deterioration occur in unsaturated lipids. Autoxidation involves reaction with normal triplet oxygen and photo-oxidation occurs through reaction with the more reactive singlet oxygen formed in the presence of light and a sensitizer such as chlorophyll. Although similar in many respects, these two reactions are not identical. In both, olefinic esters react with oxygen to give unsaturated hydroperoxides (RCH=CHCH(OOH)R′). These are not themselves the direct cause of off-flavour, but they are unstable molecules which break down and yield, among other products, short-chain compounds, particularly aldehydes, responsible for undesirable odours and flavours. The situation is complicated in that at certain concentrations and in certain mixtures a flavour may be considered to be desirable, but under other circumstances it is seen to be undesirable. Oxidative deterioration is associated with olefinic unsaturation, but there are significant differences between monoene and polyene acyl chains because the latter, but not the former, contain one or more reactive doubly allylic sites. Oxidation is promoted by heat, light, metals and several initiators (all classed as pro-oxidants) and inhibited by a range of compounds acting in different ways and described as antioxidants. Natural lipids, whether crude or refined, may contain both prooxidants and antioxidants.
Selected topics in the chemistry and biochemistry of lipids
131
–CH2CH=CHCH2–
monoene with two monoallylic CH2 groups –CH2CH=CHCH2CH=CHCH2– diene with one diallylic CH2 group and two monoallylic CH2 groups For a more detailed account of oxidation see Gunstone (2004a).
7.3.1 Autoxidation Autoxidation is a radical chain reaction occurring through initiation, chainpropagation and termination processes. The first product is usually a mixture of allylic hydroperoxides which may be oxidized further to more complex products. The hydroperoxides break down to compounds of lower molecular weight. When a C18 chain in a glycerol ester is fragmented in this way, one portion is volatile but the other fragment remains as part of the former triacylglycerol and may affect its subsequent behaviour. The initiation step is not clearly understood, but a hydrogen atom is removed from an acyl chain (represented here as RH) to produce the alkyl radical R• by breaking a C–H bond. The ease of removing the hydrogen atom is given by the sequence: doubly allylic as in linoleate > allylic as in oleate > non-allylic as in saturated esters. The propagation sequence involves two steps; a quick reaction of R• with triplet oxygen to give a peroxy radical ROO• followed by a ratedetermining hydrogen abstraction to produce the hydroperoxide and another radical. Normally this hydrogen will come from another olefin molecule, and the resulting alkyl radical can enter another cycle of reactions. This process will continue until interrupted by a termination sequence which generally involves union of two radicals to produce a dimer that does not react further (Fig. 7.1). As will be discussed later, this reaction cycle can be hindered by reducing the rate of initiation and/or by shortening the propagation sequence, usually by addition of molecules which act as antioxidants reacting with R• to give species that cannot continue the cycle. (Porter et al., 1995). One important initiation step involves the reaction of pre-formed hydroperoxide with metals, and in oxidatively stable systems it is desirable to avoid these compounds – which may be difficult – or to keep them apart Initiation
RH
R•
Propagation
R• + O2
resonance-stabilized alkyl radical RO2•
RO2• + RH Termination
R• + R•
Fig. 7.1
RO2H + R• rate-determining step
RO2• + RO2• RO2• + R•
fast reaction to a peroxy radical
stable products (dimers) stable products (dimers)
stable products (dimers)
Olefin autoxidation. RH represent an olefinic compound in which H is attached to an allylic carbon atom.
132 Modifying lipids for use in food by control of the surface charge on emulsion droplets which may be possible in some emulsions (Min Hu et al., 2004). Interesting and surprising results have shown that the order of reactivity of olefinic esters differs between bulk systems (for which most studies have been made) and emulsions such as commonly exist in foods (Miyashita, 2002). 7.3.2 Photo-oxidation Photo-oxidation involves reaction between olefin and singlet oxygen. The latter is a highly reactive but short-lived species (half life 50–700 µs), produced when the more common triplet oxygen is activated through reaction with light and a sensitizer such as chlorophyll or a range of coloured substances. The mechanism of photo-oxidation differs from the radical autoxidation reaction. Singlet oxygen is a powerful electrophile and reacts with an electronrich double bond at either olefinic carbon atom. The reaction is accompanied by double bond migration and stereo conversion to the (mainly) trans configuration (Fig. 7.2). The product is an unsaturated hydroperoxide, but its detailed structure may differ from that obtained by autoxidation. There is also a marked difference between the reaction rates for the two processes (Table 7.1). Photo-oxidation is dependent on the presence of olefinic groups and less dependent on the presence of the 1,4-dienes so important for autoxidation. Once formed, photo-oxidized hydroperoxides may initiate the autoxidation process. Most antioxidants that inhibit autoxidation have little effect on photo-oxidation which is inhibited mainly by singlet oxygen quenchers such as carotenes.
7.3.3 Hydroperoxide structure In photo-oxidation, methyl oleate and other oleate esters give C18 products with oxygen attached to C-9 or C-10. The double bond shifts along the chain and is mainly trans. In autoxidation, because of resonance in the radical R•, the oxygen may appear on carbon atoms 8, 9, 10 or 11. The distinction cis RCH==CHCH2R′ + 1O2
Fig. 7.2
trans RCH(OOH)CH==CHR′
Reaction of olefin with singlet oxygen to give allylic hydroperoxides with double bonds in different position and of changed configuration.
Table 7.1 Relative rates of autoxidation and photo-oxidation of oleate, linoleate and linolenate. Reaction
Oxygen
18:1
18:2
18:3
Autoxidation Photo-oxidation Ratio
triplet singlet
1 3 × 104 30 000
27 4 × 104 1500
77 7 × 104 900
Selected topics in the chemistry and biochemistry of lipids
133
between these two sets of hydroperoxides is important because each will break down to a different set of volatile aldehydes with different flavours and different threshold values. With linoleate, photo-oxidation gives four major hydroperoxides associated with each olefinic carbon atom (C-9, 10, 12 and 13). Double bond shift and steroisomerism accompany the oxidation. Some of the resulting dienes are conjugated and some are not. With autoxidation there are two major products resulting from the radical formed at the doubly allylic center (C-11). Because of resonance the initially formed hydroperoxides are mainly 9-hydroperoxy 10t12c-18:2 and 13-hydroperoxy 9c,11t-18:2, although sometimes these change to yet other isomers. (13)
(9)
–CH=CHCH 2 CH=CH– → linoleate ( ∆ 9,12)
–CH(OOH)CH=CHCH=CH– and –CH=CHCH=CHCH(OOH)– hydroperoxides with conjugated diene systems
7.3.4 Cholesterol oxidation The possible link between cholesterol oxidation products and coronary heart disease and other disease states makes it appropriate to discuss the source and formation of such compounds. Cholesterol (Fig. 7.3) contains a cyclic double bond (∆5) and some tertiary carbon atoms in its side chain (C-20 and C-25); all sites where oxidation may occur. Cholesterol oxides are produced as part of the normal metabolism of cholesterol, but at higher levels they affect human health by contributing to the development of atherosclerosis. When cholesterol oxides replace cholesterol in the cell membrane they alter its fluidity, permeability, stability and other properties. Oxidised animal-based foods represent a primary source of oxidized cholesterol. Such products are not present in fresh foods but are formed during handling prior to consumption, mainly through autoxidation. Between 0.5 and 1.0 % of dietary cholesterol may be oxidized, and the levels increase with unsaturation of associated phospholipids. The primary oxidation products include 7-α-hydroxy-, 7-β-hydroxy- and 7-keto-cholesterol, cholesterol αand β-epoxides, 3,5,6-trihydroxycholesterol and 20- and 25-hydroxycholesterol (Cuppett, 2003).
H
HO
Fig. 7.3
Cholesterol.
134 Modifying lipids for use in food 7.3.5 Decomposition of hydroperoxides to short-chain products Hydroperoxides contain a weak O–O bond which is easily broken to give an alkoxy radical. This unstable intermediate furnishes aldehydes by a series of processes shown in Fig. 7.4. As typical examples, the two major linoleate hydroperoxides give hexanal (from the 13-hydroperoxide) and decadienal (from the 9-hydroperoxide) as volatile aldehydes.
7.3.6 Antioxidants Because of the ease with which fats undergo oxidation and become rancid, it is important to develop systems which will slow this process down when it occurs in food, feed, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals. In addition to avoiding access to air and, where possible, keeping products in the dark and at a reduced temperature, this requires the addition of chemicals known as antioxidants which inhibit oxidative deterioration. Rancidity is caused mainly by short-chain aldehydes and, since these are formed as a consequence of a series of processes, it is possible to tackle the problem at each stage. There are thus antioxidants which act at different stages of the total process. These are often classified as primary and secondary antioxidants. Mixtures of antioxidants are often more effective than single substances, either because they operate at different stages of aldehyde production or because one component is able to convert reacted antioxidant back to its reactive form. For food use, antioxidants themselves must be nutritionally acceptable, and that applies also to the quinones and dimers which are formed from them during the antioxidative process. Among synthetic antioxidants, only permitted material may be used and then only at levels below a prescribed maximum. Regrettably not all countries have made the same decision in these matters. For example TBHQ (tert-butylhydroquinone) is not permitted in EU countries although it may be used elsewhere. Some antioxidants act twice because the first-formed oxidised molecule can act a second time in this capacity. Sometimes a compound is added to an antioxidant which can regenerate its effectiveness. Antioxidant molecules act sacrificially, and when all the antioxidant has been expended then unprotected unsaturated lipid will oxidise rapidly. This stage represents the end of the induction period. Autoxidation and photo-oxidation occur by different mechanisms and are inhibited in different ways. To inhibit photo-oxidation, materials should be kept in the dark with added singlet oxygen quenchers such as carotene. This RCH==CHCH(OOH)R′ (allylic hydroperoxide) RCH==CHCH(O•)R′
RCH==CH• + R′CHO and RCH==CHCHO + R′•
RCH==CH2 or RCH2CHO
R′H or R′OH
Fig. 7.4 Homolytic breakdown of allylic hydroperoxides to short-chain compounds. The alkyl radicals are converted to hydrocarbons or alcohols by reaction with H• or HO•. The aldehyde on the last line is a 2-enol written in ‘keto’ form.
Selected topics in the chemistry and biochemistry of lipids
135
last substance can also inhibit autoxidation, but compounds used to inhibit autoxidation do not generally influence photo-oxidation. It is important to restrict photo-oxidation because the reaction is so rapid and because it leads to hydroperoxides which can themselves initiate autoxidation. Oxidative rancidity through autoxidation requires initiation, propagation, the possibility of isomerization of the hydroperoxides first formed and cleavage of hydroperoxides to short-chain aldehydes. It should be possible to inhibit each of these stages with appropriate compounds. Primary antioxidants (also known as radical acceptors or radical scavengers) inhibit both initiation and propagation (the latter by promoting termination) by trapping active radicals R• or RO2•. They do this by providing a ready source of hydrogen and furnishing a product which does not react further. Many phenols act in this way. Molecules with extended conjugated unsaturation show the same effect through formation of an addition product. RO2• + AH → ROOH + A• → products RO2• + B → ROOB• → products AH represents a phenolic molecule and B a molecule like carotene Secondary antioxidants are mainly metal chelators such as ethylene diamine tetra-acetic acid (EDTA), citric acid, phosphoric acid, and certain amino acids. These remove the metal ions (mainly iron and copper) that promote initiation by interaction of existing hydroperoxide with metal ion (Min Hu et al., 2004). In emulsions it may be possible to keep these species apart by control of pH or by use of appropriate surfactants. Vitamin C (ascorbic acid) acts as an oxygen scavenger, removing traces of residual oxygen in a packed and sealed product. It is a water-soluble molecule but can be supplied in a lipid-soluble form as ascorbyl palmitate. Phospholipids show ill-defined antioxidant activity, possibly acting as a chelating agent and/or as an emulsifier. Antioxidants may be natural or synthetic compounds with the latter often cheaper and more effective. There is, however, a growing demand for natural antioxidants, even although the quantities available are insufficient and even these are frequently subject to minor chemical manipulation. Most vegetable oils contain tocopherols which serve as powerful antioxidants. In addition, some seed oils contain other antioxidants such as sesamol and its derivatives in sesame oil and oryzanols (sterol esters of ferulic acid) in rice bran oil. Many herbs and spices also show antioxidant properties, and this may be part of their long-known preservative properties. Some natural antioxidants may be lost during refining, but it is often possible to trap them in a side stream which then becomes a source of these valuable commodities. Deodorizer distillate from soybean oil refining and palm fatty acid distillate both serve as commercial sources of tocol mixtures with both antioxidant and vitamin E properties. Synthetic antioxidants are mainly phenolic compounds such as BHA (butylated hydroxyanisole, E320), BHT (butylated hydroxytoluene, E321),
136 Modifying lipids for use in food PG (propyl gallate, E310), and TBHQ (tertiary butylhydroquionone, no E number) with the structures shown in Fig. 7.5. The best-known and most widely used natural antioxidants are the tocols (tocopherols and tocotrienols) which are widely distributed in plant products but not in those which are animal-derived. There are eight natural tocols – four tocopherols with a phytyl side chain and differing from one another in the number and disposition of methyl groups, and four tocotrienols which are similar to the corresponding tocopherols but have a tri-unsaturated side chain (Fig. 7.6). Natural tocol mixtures are usually used at levels up to 500 ppm along with ascorbyl palmitate (200–500 ppm) which has a sparing activity on vitamin E. Above ~ 1000 ppm α-tocopherol acts as a pro-oxidant. Since most vegetable oils already contain tocols at levels of 200–800 ppm, further addition shows little effect. In contrast, the oxidative stability of lard, with little or no natural antioxidant, is markedly enhanced with tocopherol. Lard has an induction period of only 2.5 hours when heated to 100 °C with blown air, but this is extended to 18 hours with added tocopherol (0.01 %). In comparing antioxidant activity several factors have to be considered. 1. Effects vary with different oils and fats because of their varying fatty acid composition and the differing levels of antioxidants already present. 2. Results obtained at different temperatures may not be directly comparable because mechanisms of hydroperoxide formation and breakdown change with temperature, as does the volatility of the antioxidants. 3. Results vary with the method of assessment: some measure primary OH
OH But
But
OMe
Me
BHA (E320)
OH But
BHT (E321)
HO
OH But
OH
COOC3H7 PG (E310)
OH TBHQ (no E number)
Fig. 7.5 The structures and E-numbers of synthetic antioxidants. TBHQ has no E number because it is not a permitted antioxidant in EU-15. R HO
5 7
8
R
O R
Fig. 7.6 Tocopherols and tocotrienols. Tocopherols have a saturated C16 side chain, tocotrienols have three double bonds at the positions indicated by the arrows, R = H or CH3. α = 5,7,8-trimethyltocol, β = 5,8-dimethyltocol, γ = 7,8-dimethyltocol, δ = 8-methyltocol.
Selected topics in the chemistry and biochemistry of lipids
137
products (hydroperoxides) and others measure secondary products (carbonyl compounds and/or volatile compounds). 4. Mixtures of antioxidants are influenced by synergistic effects, and it is difficult to disentangle these. 5. Solubility factors have to be considered especially when there is a distribution between aqueous and lipid phases.
7.4
Reactions of esters and other acyl compounds
In its simplest form esterification is the reaction of a carboxylic acid (RCOOH) with an alcohol (R′OH) to produce an ester and water. The ester (RCO–OR′) contains an acyl group (RCO) derived from the carboxylic acid and an alkoxy group (OR′) derived from the alcohol. RCOOH + R′OH ===` RCOOR′ + H2O
`
The reaction is reversible and the four reactants establish an equilibrium. There are standard methods of shifting the equilibrium in the desired direction. Those most commonly employed involve using an excess of one of the reactants and/or removal of one of the products. For example, the reaction can be carried out with an excess of alcohol, under conditions where a volatile product is removed, or in a two-phase system such that one product is transferred from the phase in which reaction occurs to the second phase where reaction does not take place, thereby disturbing the equilibrium in the reaction phase. Establishment of the equilibrium state is generally attained only slowly so a catalyst is required to achieve a useful speed of reaction. Depending on the acylation process being conducted the catalyst may be acidic such as H2SO4 or BF3, basic such as NaOH or NaOMe or an enzyme (generally a lipase). The union of an acyl group (RCO) with an alkoxy group (OR′) to produce the ester RCOOR′ can be achieved in a variety of ways, depending on the source of these two groups and on the fact that the reaction is reversible. The more important of these processes are listed in Table 7.2. For example, when an ester is mixed with an alcohol in the presence of an appropriate catalyst there is an exchange of alkoxy groups between that in the alcohol and that in Table 7.2
Acid Ester Ester Ester
Esterification and related reactions. Reagents
Reaction types
Alcohol Alcohol Acid Ester
Esterification Alcoholysis Acidolysis Interesterification
All the reactions using an ester as a reagent are also called transesterifications.
138 Modifying lipids for use in food the ester. Two examples of alcoholysis widely used with lipids have their own specific names (methanolysis and glycerolysis). Reaction with methanol (methanolysis) to convert glycerol esters to methyl esters is carried out on a mg scale as a preliminary to gas chromatographic analysis and on a tonne scale for the production of methyl esters used as solvents, as biofuels or as intermediates in the production of alcohols. When natural oils and fats interact with free glycerol there are not enough acyl groups to react with all the hydroxyl groups present and the final product is a mixture of partial glycerol esters – mainly monoacyglycerols and diacylglycerols (glycerolysis). An exchange of acyl groups by reaction of triacylglycerols with acids is termed acidolysis. This may be used, for example, to introduce lauric acid into oils and fats which do not contain this acid. When two esters react together then new equilibria are established between all the acyl groups and all the alkoxy groups. When an oil/fat is used then the reaction starts with a complex mixture of glycerol esters. This process is usually catalysed by alkali, but the nature of true catalyst is still a matter of debate (Dijkstra, 2004; Liu, 2004). There is a growing interest in using enzymes (lipases) to catalyze these reactions. Such processes occur under milder process conditions so there is a saving of energy. There is also less by-product and therefore less loss in recovering the major product. However, of greater importance is the fact that many lipases show specificities which make it possible to carry out these reactions with an element of control which would be difficult to achieve with normal chemical catalysts. Since the reaction being catalyzed involves an acyl function and an alkoxy function, specificity may appear as a consequence of the interaction of the lipase with either or both of these and as a consequence of the conditions under which the reaction is carried out. Acyl components vary according to the structure of the fatty acid [in terms of chain length and the position and configuration of the unsaturated centre(s)] and according to whether the acylating agent is a free acid or an ester (of which there are many kinds). The alkoxy component can be a free alcohol or be present in an ester. For example, among hydroxy compounds free glycerol, monoacyglycerols and diacylglycerols may react differently. In any particular reaction more than one selectivity may be operating leading to further complications. Examples of interesterification by chemical catalysts or by lipases are detailed in Chapter 11 (see also Kellens, 2000).
7.5
Metabolism of linoleic and linolenic acids
The polyunsaturated fatty acids generally contain 1,4 patterns of unsaturation with two to six cis olefinic groups and are frequently described as methyleneinterrupted. They are grouped into families depending on the position of the first unsaturated centre with respect to the end methyl group. The two most
Selected topics in the chemistry and biochemistry of lipids
139
important families are the omega-6 family based on linoleic acid and including arachidonic acid (20:4) and the omega-3 family based on α-linolenic acid and including eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA, 20:5) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA, 22:6). The C20 and C22 members of each family are metabolically linked with the first (C18) member by a series of enzymatically catalyzed and controlled desaturation and elongation processes. Animals, including humans, cannot make linoleic or α-linolenic acid which must themselves have a plant origin. An animal in good health can then usually metabolize the C18 acids to long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) (Fig. 7.7) Animals are not generally able to interconvert omega-6 and omega-3 acids and therefore it is important to consume dietary omega-6 and omega-3 acids in an appropriate ratio. But what should that be? The omega-6/omega-3 ratio in the human diet has changed through history. It is widely accepted that when humans were hunter-gatherers the ratio was between 1:1 and 3:1. The polyunsaturated acids are important in lipid membranes, particularly in the brain where the ratio is around 2:1. It is further accepted that the ratio in the diet has changed markedly since the 1950s. Prior to that time fats were largely animal-derived, but since then linoleic-rich vegetable oils have become more dominant (Chapter 2) and one authority has written of a thousand-fold increase in supplies of linoleic acid (Crawford, 2004). Virtually the only dietary omega-6 acid is linoleic acid present in unsaturated Omega-6 family 18:2 (9, 12) linoleic ∆6-desaturase 18:3 (6, 9, 12) γ -linolenic elongation 20:3 (8, 11, 14) ∆5-desaturase 20:4 (5, 8, 11, 14) arachidonic
Omega-3 family 18:3 (9, 12, 15) α-linolenic ∆6-desaturase 18:4 (6, 9, 12, 15) stearidonic elongation 20:4 (8, 11, 14, 17) ∆5-desaturase 20:5 (5, 8, 11, 14, 17) eicosapentaenoic elongation 22:5 (7, 10, 13, 16, 19) elongation 24:5 (9, 12, 15, 18, 21) ∆6-desaturse 24:6 (6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21) β-oxidation 22:6 (4, 7, 10, 13, 16, 19) docosahexaenoic
Fig. 7.7 The omega-6 and omega-3 families of polyunsaturated fatty acids and their metabolic relationships. The most significant acids in these sequences are linoleic and arachidonic in the omega-6 family and α-linolenic, eicosapentaenoic and docosahexaenoic acid in the omega-3 family. The two C20 acids are precursors of an important group of eicosanoids including the prostaglandins and leukotrienes. The numbers in parenthesis indicate the positions of the double bonds, all of which have the cis configuration.
140 Modifying lipids for use in food oils such as soybean, sunflower, cottonseed and corn oils. Supplies of omega3 acids are confined almost entirely to α-linolenic acid derived from soybean and rapeseed (canola) oils. Unfortunately much of this is destroyed by hydrogenation before it is consumed. Gunstone (2005) has calculated that out of 136 million tonnes of oils and fats produced by the agricultural supply industry in 2004/05, 109 million tonnes was used for human food, and this provided 31.9 million tonnes of linoleic acid and 3.5 million tonnes of αlinolenic acid – a ratio of 9.1:1. After allowing for hydrogenation, these figures change to 23.8 and 0.8 million tonnes giving a ratio of ~ 30:1. This predominance of linoleic acid in the diet leads to concern over the effect that this has on the efficiency of metabolism of α-linolenic acid and over the consequences of this for health and disease. It has long been considered that the omega-6/omega-3 ratio should be between 5 and 10 to 1. There is a growing preference for the lower end of this range, but some have argued for a figure of 2:1 or even lower (Okuyama, 2000). The figures cited above suggest that it is difficult to attain these low levels, although it should be remembered that the ratio can be lowered by increasing the intake of αlinolenic acid and/or by lowering the intake of linoleic acid. The second target may be the easier to achieve. The omega-6 and omega-3 acids and their long-chain metabolites have important physiological functions. Omega-3 acids are major components of biological membranes. DHA, for example, is present in high concentrations in the retina, the brain and in sperm. They can also alter gene expression – down-regulating some enzymes and up-regulating others – and EPA has an important role in the regulation of eicosanoids produced from arachidonic acid through competition for the metabolising enzymes. Eicosanoids from EPA and AA show different properties. However, α-linolenic acid is not converted efficiently to EPA and, more particularly, to DHA. Feeding α-linolenic acid leads to some increase in tissue α-linolenic acid, to small increases in EPA (20:5) and DPA (22:5) and to a still smaller increase or to a decrease in DHA. The best way to increase levels of DHA in tissue is to consume DHA itself from fish and for most people intakes of long-chain PUFA are considerably below recommended levels. Other routes to the C20 polyunsaturated acids have been identified as for example in the production of arachidonic acid from linoleic acid by elongation followed first by ∆-8 desaturation and then by ∆-5 desaturation (Drexler et al., 2003; Qi et al., 2004).
7.6
Sources of further information and advice
These topics are reported in most books devoted to lipid chemistry and technology and lipid biochemistry, such as those of Hamm and Hamilton (2000), Akoh and Min (2002) and Gunstone (2004a).
Selected topics in the chemistry and biochemistry of lipids
7.7
141
References
and MIN D B (2002), Food Lipids: Chemistry, Nutrition, and Biotechnology, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc. BERBEN P (2002), Hydrogenation of fats and oils: trends in catalyst development, Lipid Technol Newsletter, 8, 133–137. CRAWFORD M A (2004), Docosahexaenoic acid and the evolution of the brain – a message for the future, Lipid Technol, 16, 53–57. CUPPETT S L (2003), Cholesterol oxides: sources and health implications, Lipid Technol Newsletter, 9, 9–13. DIJKSTRA A J (2002), Hydrogenation and fractionation, in Rajah K H, Fats in Food Technology, Sheffield, Sheffield Academic Press, 123–158. rd DIJKSTRA A J (2004), The interesterification mechanism revisited, Lecture at the 3 Euro Fed Lipid Congress, Edinburgh, September. DREXLER H, SPIEKERMANN P, DOMERGUE F, ZANK T, SPERLING P, ABBADI A and HEINZ E (2003), Metabolic engineering of fatty acids for breeding of new oilseed crops: strategies, problems and first results, J Plant Physiol, 160, 779–802. GUNSTONE F D (2004a), The Chemistry of Oils and Fats, Blackwell Publishing, Oxford. GUNSTONE F D (2004b), Agricultural supplies of oils and fats do not meet nutritional demands, 9th Tan Sri Dato’ B Bek-Nielsen Foundation Lectureship, delivered in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, September, 2004. See also Inform 2005, 16, 736–737. HAMM W and HAMILTON R J (2000), Edible Oil Processing, Sheffield, Sheffield Academic Press. KELLENS M (2000), Oil modification processes, in Hamm W and Hamilton R J, Edible Oil Processing, Sheffield, Sheffield Academic Press, 129–173. LIU L (2004), How is chemical interesterification initiated: nucleophilic substitution or α-proton abstraction? J Am Oil Chem Soc, 81, 331–337. MIN HU D, MCCLEMENTS J and DEKKER E A (2004), Emulsion droplets engineered to improve the oxidative stability of n-3 acids in functional food emulsions, Lipid Technol, 16, 79–82. MIYASHITA K (2002), Polyunsaturated lipids in aqueous systems do not follow our preconceptions of oxidative stability, Lipid Technol Newsl, 8, 35–41. OKUYAMA H (2000), Prevention of excessive linoleic acid syndrome, Lipid Technol Newsl, 6, 128–132. PORTER N A, CALDWELL S E and MILLS K A (1995), Mechanisms of free radical oxidation of unsaturated lipids, Lipids, 30, 277–290. QI B, FRASER T, MUGFORD S, DOBSON G, SAYANOVA O, BUTLER J, NAPIER J A, STOBART A K and LAZARUS C M (2004), Production of very long chain polyunsaturated omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids in plants, Nat Biotechnol, 22, 739–745. AKOH C C
8 Structure and properties of fat crystal networks S. Martini, T. Awad and A. G. Marangoni, University of Guelph, Canada
8.1
History and introduction
Fats provide fundamental structural and textural attributes to a wide range of consumer products including lipstick, chocolate, and everyday products such as butter and margarine (Milosav, 1985; Halmos, 1997). Within these fatbased products, certain ‘textural’ properties are required to meet desirable sensory attributes, in order to gain consumer acceptance (de Bruije and Arjen, 1999). This has led to an increase in research efforts on the physical properties of fats, particularly their rheology. Over the past 50 years, most of the research on fat texture has concentrated on the examination of triacylglycerol (TAG) composition, polymorphism, solid fat content (SFC), and their individual effects on macroscopic properties. Unfortunately, none of these components in isolation can fully describe the macroscopic properties of a fat. Therefore, the ultimate goal is to examine the parameters and any potential interactions that may exist between them to determine how they affect the physical properties of fats. A model that can be used to describe the formation and interaction of the elements that affect the final properties of a three-dimensional fat crystal network is shown in Fig. 8.1. This hierarchical model suggests that when fats are crystallized, lipid composition, directly under the influence of the processing and storage conditions, will affect the SFC polymorphism and microstructure of the fat crystal network. The model also suggests that polymorphism, SFC and microstructure may have interactive effects. All of these properties affect the final three-dimensional fat crystal network, and in turn influence the macroscopic properties and sensory perception. The objective of this chapter is to review the properties of fat crystal
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks Processing conditions
Molecular/lipid composition
143
Storage conditions (time and temperature)
Crystallization
Solid fat content
Polymorphism
Morphology
Microscopic properties
Fat crystal network
Macroscopic properties
Fig. 8.1 Model used to describe the formation and interaction of the elements that affect the physical properties of a three-dimensional fat crystal network.
networks and their relationship with microstructure, rheology and processing conditions in order to optimize the quality of the final product.
8.2
Crystallization and melting
Crystallization is an important process during the manufacture of edible fatrich products such as margarine, butter, chocolate, whipped cream and ice cream. In food emulsions where the oil droplets are partially or fully crystallized, the degree of crystallinity of the oil in the droplets affects the rate of creaming (Dickinson and McClements, 1996). In margarine, the properties of melting, spreadability, texture, and consistency are dominated by the fat crystals, which control the quality, shelf life and stability of the product. The consistency of fat spreads is derived from interactions between fat crystals, which determine network structure and rheology (Heertje, 1993; deMan and deMan, 2001). By controlling crystallization kinetics, it is possible to modify fat crystal network structure and control macroscopic rheological properties. Crystallization occurs through three stages; achievement of supercooling, nucleation and crystal growth (Boistelle, 1988). Below the equilibrium melting point of a liquid, crystallization is favored because the free energy of the solid phase is lower than that of the melt phase. The degree of supercooling (∆T) is defined as the difference between the temperature of the material (T ) and its melting point (Tm): ∆T = Tm – T. Nucleation involves the transition
144 Modifying lipids for use in food from a metastable to a stable phase in which crystal formation is controlled by temperature and cooling rate. By increasing the supercooling of the melt, molecules start to form clusters that eventually transform into an ordered crystallite. Other molecules continue to incorporate into the new nucleus until it reaches a critical size (n*) and then the nucleus can develop into a three-dimensional and/or two-dimensional ordered aggregate (Aquilano and Squaldino, 2001). The rate of formation of critical nuclei formed in the melt per unit time is called the nucleation rate (J). There are two types of nucleation, namely homogeneous and heterogeneous. The total change in the free energy associated with the formation of the new solid phase is different between these two nucleation types. While homogeneous nucleation occurs in the bulk of the mother phase (the melt), heterogeneous nucleation occurs onto substrates such as catalyzing impurities, substrates and oil/water (O/W) interface. Interfacial heterogeneous nucleation can occur in O/W emulsions where droplets are surrounded by high melting surfactant molecules and other additives. The O/W emulsion interface may itself act as a catalytic impurity (McClements et al., 1994; Awad et al., 2001; Awad and Sato, 2002). In both cases, nucleation can be initiated at lower degrees of supercooling than homogeneous nucleation. Hence, the total free energy change for heterogeneous nucleation (∆Ghet) is less than that of homogeneous nucleation (∆Ghom). After the formation of a stable nucleus, molecules move through the supercooled melt towards the stable solid–liquid interfaces. The growth rate of the crystal is mainly based on the melt viscosity, which retards the mobility of molecules (diffusion). A molecule must have a specific size, shape and orientation to be incorporated into crystal surfaces. The growth rate is also temperature dependent. As the degree of supercooling increases, the growth rate also increases to a maximum. Below a certain temperature, the rate decreases due to the increasing melt viscosity, which slows down molecular diffusion. This leads to a decrease in crystal growth (Timms, 1994). Incorporation of specific emulsifiers (P-170, S-170 and DAS-750) strongly enhances the rate of nucleation but retards the rate of crystal growth in emulsions with palm mid-fraction (PMF) and palmkernel oil (PKO), mainly due to a poisoning effect (Awad and Sato, 2001 and 2002a, respectively). PMF is a product of the double fractionation of palm oil that is used in its bulk state as shortening or in the emulsion state as margarine and vegetable oil-based creams. PMF rich in POP (where P is palmitic acid and O is oleic acid) is suitable for blending with SOS (where S is stearic acid) fractions to prepare cocoa butter equivalents (Sontag, 1979). PKO is a co-product of the palm oil industry and is regarded as high quality oil for food use and a valuable component for margarine formulation, giving rapid meltdown in the mouth. Figure 8.2 shows the effect of the addition of sucrose oligoester emulsifier additive on the nucleation (i) and crystal growth (ii) of PMF (Awad and Sato, 2001). Additionally, several authors studied the effect of processing conditions
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
145
1530 1520 1510
V (m/s)
1500 1490 1480 1470 1460 1450 0
200
400 600 Time (min)
800
1000
800
1000
(a) 1500 1490
V (m/s)
1480 1470 1460 1450 1440 1430 0
200
400 600 Time (min) (b)
Fig. 8.2 Ultrasonic velocity measurements showing the effect of a sucrose oligoester (S-170) on (a) nucleation of PMF/water emulsion at 10 °C and (b) crystal growth of PMF melt supercooled and left to crystallize at 25 °C after adding seed crystals of PMF. ■: no additives, 䉭: with S-170 (0.5 wt %), 䊊: with S-170 (1.0 wt %).
on the crystallization behavior of different bulk fat systems with and without the addition of emulsifiers. For example, Herrera and Marquez Rocha (1996) found that the addition of P-170 delayed the nucleation of hydrogenated sunflower oil and also delayed the polymorphic transformation from β′ to β. Martini et al. (2002c) together with Puppo et al. (2002) and Cerdeira et al. (2003) found that the addition of sucrose esters (0.5 % of S-170 and P-170) to high melting milk fat fraction/sunflower blends (HMF/SFO) mixtures influenced the crystals’ microstructure and rheology. The addition of emulsifiers also delayed the crystallization kinetics (nucleation and growth); which was
146 Modifying lipids for use in food evidenced by longer induction times of crystallization and lower maximum solid fat contents (SFCmax), especially at higher crystallization temperatures. The effects of emulsifiers on the crystallization kinetics of different fat systems in bulk and emulsions are due to differences in the chemical structure of the emulsifiers and fats. Two mechanisms have been reported in the literature to interpret the effects of emulsifiers on fat crystallization in bulk systems. First, the emulsifiers can act as heteronuclei, accelerating nucleation through the catalytic actions of such impurities. During crystal growth, the emulsifiers are adsorbed at steps or kinks on the surface of the growing fat crystal and thereby inhibit crystal growth and modify crystal morphology. Second, fats and emulsifiers are able to co-crystallize because of their somewhat similar chemical structures. However, the structural dissimilarities between triacylglycerols and emulsifiers can delay nucleation and inhibit growth. In general, an emulsifier with a high molecular weight and the above-mentioned chemical characteristics has the potential to be a good inhibitor of crystallization (Garti, 1988). The crystallization behavior of oils depends on their chemical composition as well as on processing conditions (Herrera and Hartel, 2000b). When the oil becomes dispersed as in oil-in-water emulsions (e.g. whipped-cream) or forms the continuous phase as in water-in-oil emulsions (e.g. margarine), the crystallization process becomes much more complicated due to the effect of other additional factors such as emulsifiers, droplet size and distribution and droplet–droplet interactions (Awad and Sato, 2002b), as shown in Table 8.1. Emulsifiers strongly affect the stability of the emulsion interface as well (Goff and Jordan, 1989; Dalgleish et al., 1995). Temperature, cooling rate and shear are the major factors that influence the crystallization kinetics of fats during processing. After production, temperature fluctuation during transport and consumption becomes a significant factor that must be taken into account. Product mistreatment and/or improper storage will thus cause many problems, which leads to a decline in product quality such as blooming in chocolate, graininess in margarine and hardness in ice cream. A very common phenomenon that occurs during post-processing storage is Ostwald-ripening, which consists in the coarsening of crystals. Table 8.1 Factors affecting crystallization of oil in bulk and emulsion states. Bulk
Emulsion
Temperature Cooling rate Impurity Polymorphism
Temperature Cooling rate Impurity Polymorphism Droplet size and distribution Droplet–droplet interaction Emulsifiers
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
147
This process may occur spontaneously or due to temperature cycling, e.g. during transportation or during use, as a result of the lower surface free energy of bigger crystals. The process is greatly accelerated by temperature cycling, because the re-dissolution of crystallized fat in oil at higher temperatures followed by subsequent crystallization at lower temperatures helps the transport of fat molecules from the smaller crystals to the bigger ones. Therefore, a specific temperature–time profile is usually applied to control crystallization during the manufacture of margarine. When crystallization conditions are tightly controlled, it is relatively easy to achieve good and well-defined margarine texture. The effect of cooling rate is also important both in margarine and in bulk systems. Slowly crystallized fats will continue to crystallize after packaging, resulting in a firm product, while a fast crystallization rate results in a soft and overworked product (Heertje, 1993; Herrera and Hartel, 2000a). The control of crystallization is a key factor in the processing of W/O emulsions. Control of heat, mass and momentum transfer rates is the main tool to manipulate crystal size, mainly by balancing crystal nucleation and growth processes. This balance can be influenced through changes in supersaturation, typically by the degree of supercooling, or changes in flow conditions by shear. Other means to stimulate nucleation, though less common in spread manufacture, are ultrasonic radiation or seeding. Application of shear and ultrasound is also used during the processing of fat spreads, which offers good emulsification and controls the size of the crystal/aggregates. Thus, rapid cooling followed by intense stirring (which promotes secondary nucleation) leads to small crystals, e.g., margarine; slow cooling with gentle stirring leads to large crystals, e.g. fractionation of palm oil (Timms, 1994). Recently, our group has found that shear accelerates the rate of polymorphic transformation and can cause the orientation of fat crystallites in milk fat, palm oil and cocoa butter (Mazzanti et al., 2003; 2004a,b). Melting and crystallization are reversible. The melting behavior of fats in foods is important for both consumer perception and product stability. For example, the melting of margarine is an endothermic process where the release of heat from the mouth to the product melts the fat crystals, imparting a pleasant cooling sensation. The steeper the melting profile of a fat (e.g., coconut and palm kernel fats), the greater the cooling sensation. Complete melting of the fat phase will result in a rich mouth feel product, but fat components that melt at or above mouth temperature will impart a waxy mouth feel.
8.2.1 Chemical composition The complexity of the crystallization process of natural fats and oils may be due to the multi-component nature of the material and the molecular interactions between the different fat molecules. Fats are mainly composed of TAGs together with diacylglycerols (DAGs), monoacylglycerols (MAGs), free fatty acids (FFA) and minor lipid components such as phospholipids and glycolipids.
148 Modifying lipids for use in food A TAG consists of a glycerol backbone and three fatty acids. Each fatty acid has its own chain length, degree of unsaturation and position of the double bond. Figure 8.3 shows the basic structure and the structural characteristics of TAGs. Fats with high content of long-chain fatty acids will crystallize at high temperatures; meanwhile, the presence of unsaturated fatty acids in TAG molecules will result in lower crystallization temperatures. The molecular diversity of the TAGs, including the symmetry (mono-acid or mixed-acid) and the number, position and the configuration of the double bond (i.e., cis or trans) will also result in different crystallization and polymorphic behaviors (Sato, 2001b). Several authors have studied the effect of chemical composition on the crystallization behavior of the fats and on their microstructure. Rousseau et al. (1996a,b,c) studied the melting behavior of interesterified butterfat mixed with canola oil together with the microstructure, polymorphism and rheology of these blends. Wright et al. (2000) studied the effect of minor components on the crystallization of milk fat. The effect of DAG on milk fat crystallization, microstructure and rheology was also studied by Wright and Marangoni (2002, 2003) and by Herrera et al. (1999). In addition, Martini et al. (2001, 2002a,b) have studied the effect of processing condition on the nucleation, growth and microstructure of mixtures of high melting milk fat fractions and sunflower oil blends. Independently of the type of fat used to perform the experiments, all the studies mentioned above found that chemical composition has a very significant influence on the crystallization behavior, the microstructure and the rheology of the fat systems.
8.2.2 Polymorphism TAGs exhibit polymorphism, which is defined as the ability of a compound to form different crystalline structures with various states of molecular conformation and molecular packing. The crystallization rate, crystal size, crystal morphology and degree of crystallinity are directly influenced by TAG molecule
H
H
H
H
C
C
C
O R
1
O R
Chain length structure
H
O
2
R3 double
R = Fatty Acids Monoacid: R1 = Mixed acid: R1 ≠ R1 = R2 ≠
Fig. 8.3
R2 R2 R2 R1
= R3 (PPP, SSS) ≠ R3 (POS) ≠ R3 (PPO, OOP) = R3 (POP, SOS)
triple
Degree of un-saturation Monounsaturated (SOS, SSO) Polyunsaturated (OSO, PLO)
Basic structure and the structural characteristics of triacylglycerols (TAGs).
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
149
polymorphism (Sato, 2001a). Figure 8.1 shows the interrelationship between polymorphism and the physical properties of fats. As shown in this figure, the polymorphism phenomenon relates to molecular properties such as TAG composition, presence of DAGs, MAGs or other minor components and molecular interactions. Crystallization conditions influence the polymorphism and polymorphic transitions, which in turn affect morphology. All of these parameters will influence fat crystal network structure, its texture and rheological properties. Three basic polymorphs of mono-acid TAGs have been identified by powder X-ray diffraction, on the basis of their subcell structure (Larsson, 1966). A subcell is defined as the cross-sectional packing mode of the aliphatic chains in TAGs. Ten types of subcells have been identified in crystalline lipids (Small, 1986; Hernqyist, 1988). Among those, the three major polymorphs namely, α, β′ and β, have been identified (Larsson, 1966), as shown in Fig. 8.4. The α form is metastable, with hexagonal packing (H). The β′ form is more stable with orthorhombic perpendicular packing (O⊥) and β is the most stable form, with triclinic parallel packing (T//). TAGs often crystallize initially in the α or the β′ forms, although β is the most stable form. This can be explained by the fact that the form has a higher free energy of activation for nucleation ( ∆G *n ) compared with the other two forms. The melting temperature increases from the less stable to the more stable form (i.e., in the order of α- β′-β), owing to the difference in their molecular packing densities (Fig. 8.5a). The polymorphic transformation is an irreversible process from the least to the most stable form, depending on temperature and time (monotropic phase transformation). At constant temperatures, the α and β′ forms transform, as a function of time, to the β form through solid–solid or solid–liquid–solid transformation mechanisms (Fig. 8.5b) (Herrera and Marquez Rocha, 1996). The polymorphism of fats described here influences the textural characteristics of fats and emulsions. The polymorphic behavior of the TAG components in margarine is important for improving the functional properties of a spread. The β′ form is the most functional form in many food emulsions because it usually comprises of a large number of small crystals that are needle or platelet-like in shape. For margarine it is desirable to form crystals Hexagonal (H)
α
Orthorhombic (O⊥)
Triclinic (T// )
β′
Fig. 8.4 TAG major polymorphic forms.
β
150 Modifying lipids for use in food (a)
∆Gc#
Melt α
∆Gc
β′ β (b)
Melt
α
β′
β
Fig. 8.5 Free activation energy of nucleation change (∆Gn ) for the three major polymorphs. (∆Gn# ) is the free energy barrier that must be exceeded before stable nuclei can be formed (a). Polymorphic transformation pathways (b).
in the β′ polymorph during processing; however, the transformation towards the most stable and undesired β form is usually favored during storage and distribution. The presence of large grains (graininess) in margarine is associated with the crystallization of the most stable β polymorph. In addition, the surface sheen of margarine becomes dull because the β crystals are less able to incorporate liquid oil, and when the crystals become very large the surface appears mottled and the texture becomes brittle (deMan and deMan, 2001). It has been demonstrated that the presence of certain TAGs retards the formation of large crystals in margarine by modifying the structure of crystals and retarding their polymorphic transformation (Heertje, 1993; Herrera and Marquez Rocha, 1996). In mixed TAG systems, the re-crystallization behavior is more complex, because different TAG molecules have to be incorporated in the crystal lattice. This incorporation occurs less readily at higher packing densities of the crystal, which implies that the transition from a less stable to a more stable polymorphic form has to involve a change in composition of the crystalline phase. It has been empirically established that the rate of a polymorphic transition is a function of temperature and, in particular, of the molecular composition of a fat mixture. However, the details of this process at a molecular level are still unclear, and may involve either melt-mediation
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
151
or a solid-state transformation, or a simple competitive crystallization process.
8.2.3 Fat crystal network A fat crystal network is the product of the aggregation process of molecules into particles, and of particles into larger clusters, until a space-filling threedimensional network is formed. Work by Heertje and coworkers originally demonstrated that fat crystal networks of fat spreads can display such structural hierarchy (Heertje et al., 1987; Juriaanse and Heertje, 1988; Heertje, 1993). When triacylglycerols are cooled from the melt to a temperature below their melting point, i.e. when they are supercooled, they undergo a liquid–solid transformation to form primary crystals with characteristic polymorphism. These primary crystals aggregate, or grow into each other, to form clusters, which further interact, resulting in the formation of a continuous threedimensional network. The macroscopic rheological properties of networks formed by lipids are of great importance in food products that contain significant amounts of fats. Such products include margarine, butter, chocolate, peanut butter, many spreads such as cream cheese, and ice cream. Many sensory characteristics such as spreadability, hardness, appearance and mouth feel are dependent on the mechanical strength of the underlying fat crystal network (Marangoni and Rousseau, 1996, 1998; Narine and Marangoni, 1999a; Marangoni, 2002). Therefore, the firmness and solid-like properties of manufactured plastic fats, such as margarine, are established during the formation of a fat crystal network.
8.2.4 Mesoscale structure The mesoscale structure of fat crystal networks includes elements in the length range between 0.5 and 500 µm. Note that the term ‘mesoscale structure’ will be used interchangeably with the term ‘microstructure’. At the lower range of this mesoscale structure, one may encounter crystallites; whilst at the upper ranges, one decidedly is observing aggregates of microstructural elements (clusters of crystallites). This level of structure has an enormous influence on the macroscopic rheological properties of the network, noted as early as 1987 by deMan and Beers. Other researchers have also noted the importance of the mesoscale level on the rheological properties of the network, and the fact that the microstructure is properly changed with processing conditions of crystallization (Heertje et al., 1987, 1988; Herrera and Hartel, 2000c; Martini et al., 2002b), as well as with interesterification (Marangoni and Rousseau, 1996). Figure 8.6 shows the different levels of structure present in a cocoa butter crystal network, from primary crystallites (Fig. 8.6a) to microstructural elements – or particles (Fig. 8.6b) to microstructures – or flocs or clusters (Fig. 8.6c). These images were acquired using an atomic force microscope (AFM) operated in tapping mode.
152 Modifying lipids for use in food
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 8.6 Tapping-mode atomic force micrograph of cocoa butter at different magnifications. The micrographs on the left-hand side correspond to height view and those on the right-hand side to the phase view.
In order to truly understand, and eventually predict, the macroscopic properties of soft materials, it is necessary to characterize and define the different levels of structure present in the material and their respective relationship to a macroscopic property. Knowledge of the relationships between molecular composition and phase behavior, solid-state structure, growth mode, static structure and macroscopic properties will eventually allow for the rational design of specific macroscopic properties.
8.3
Mechanical properties and structure
Fat crystal growth is dictated by external processing conditions and TAG composition. The TAGs crystallize from the melt into certain polymorphic
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
153
states that then aggregate into larger microstructures or crystal aggregates. Aggregation continues until a three-dimensional network is formed, with a structure that can be described using fractal geometry principles (Narine and Marangoni, 1999a,b, 2002; Marangoni, 2000, 2002). The formation of a fat crystal network is of key importance in the manufacture of plastic fats because it provides firmness or solid-like properties (viscoelasticity). This network can be visualized as being built from aggregates rather than straight chains of fat particles, and can be thought of as a colloidal aggregate, analogous to a protein gel. Each of the fat particles in turn comprises several aggregated fat crystals. The quantitative description of such a complex and ‘random’ system is difficult. Recently, fractal geometry has proven to be extremely helpful in the characterization of these fractal objects (Marangoni and Rousseau, 1996; Narine and Marangoni, 1999c).
8.3.1 Fat crystal network as a particle gel Figure 8.7 shows the formation of a crystal network in a cocoa butter (CB) sample highly diluted with canola oil (CO) when crystallized statically at 5 °C. We can observe how the flocs, size and the interfloc links increase with time. Originally suggested by van den Tempel (1979), Vreeker and coworkers (1992) proposed that the structure of a fat crystal network resembles that of a flocculated colloid, i.e., a colloidal gel. Subsequently, our group developed this concept further (Marangoni and Rousseau, 1996, Narine and Marangoni, 1999a). The solid-like macroscopic properties of materials structured as flocculated colloids, in particular elasticity, are highly dependent on their structure at the nanometer range (nanoscale), as well as micrometer range (mesoscale). Early developments of a theory to explain the elastic properties of colloidal gels from their structure were carried out by Brown and Ball (1985). They proposed a power law dependence of the shear elastic modulus (G) of a colloidal network on the volume fraction (Φ) of network mass G ~ Φµ
[8.1]
where the exponent of the volume fraction term (µ) is related to the mechanism of particle aggregation. Based on the seminal work of Kantor and Webman (1984), Brown and Ball (1985), Shih et al. (1990) outlined the development of a scaling theory to explain the elastic properties of colloidal gels by again considering the structure of the gel network as a collection of close-packed fractal flocs of colloidal particles (Fig. 8.8). However, these authors also defined two separate rheological regimes depending on the relative strength of the inter-floc links vis-à-vis those within the flocs. Their formulation of the strong-link regime (applicable at low volume fractions, Φ < 0.1), where the flocs yield under an applied stress, was identical to that of Brown and Ball (1985). Their formulation of the weak-link regime (applicable at high volume fractions, Φ > 0.1), where the inter-floc links yield under an applied stress, differed from that
154 Modifying lipids for use in food (b)
(a)
(d)
(c)
200 µm
Fig. 8.7 Polarized light images of crystalline structures of a mixture of cocoa butter and canola oil at 5 °C after (a) two hours; (b) six hours; (c) 12 hours and (d) 20 hours. Cluster
Particle
ξ
Link
a
Fig. 8.8 Idealized structure of a gel network, where ξ is the diameter of the microstructure and ‘a’ is the diameter of each particle that forms the microstructure.
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
155
suggested by Brown and Ball (1985). The forms of the equations for the strong-link and weak-link regimes are, respectively: d+x
GSLR ~ Φ d – D
[8.2]
and 1
GWLR ~ Φ d – D
[8.3]
where d is the Euclidean dimension, D the fractal dimension and x the chemical length exponent, backbone fractal dimension, or the tortuosity of the effective chain of stress transduction within a cluster of particles yielding under an externally applied stress. The parameter x is difficult to estimate and is usually assumed to be in the range [1–1.3]. The fractal dimension is a parameter that describes the spatial distribution of mass within the network. It is possible to judge whether a system is in the weak-link or strong-link rheological regimes by determining the dependence of the strain at the limit of linearity (γo) on the solids’ volume fraction (Φ). According to the model of Shih et al. (1990), γo increases as a function of Φ for the weak-link regime (γo ~ Φ1/(d–D)), while γo decreases as function of Φ for the strong-link regime (γo ~ Φ–(1+x)/(d–D)). In all these treatments, the macroscopic elastic constant of the network is merely the product of the elastic constant of a basic mechanical unit (the flocs, the links between flocs, or a combination of both) and the number of these units present in the direction of an externally applied force (Shih et al., 1990). In the weak link regime, the fractal dimension merely defines the size of the cluster. Thus, for example, a higher fractal dimension will result in a larger cluster size. A larger cluster size translates to less cluster–cluster interactions per unit volume, resulting in a decrease in the elastic modulus of the material. At higher volume fractions, the average cluster size decreases, thus increasing the number of cluster–cluster interactions, which leads to an increase in the value of the elastic constant.
8.4
Fat crystal networks and microstructure
The physical properties of fats are influenced by all levels of structure, but particularly by microstructure, since this is the level of structure closest to the macroscopic world. Microstructure includes the spatial distribution of mass, particle size, inter-particle distance and particle shape. Two methods for characterizing microstructure in fat systems have been developed by our group. These methods include small deformation rheology and microscopy techniques, employing a fractal approach (Marangoni and Rousseau, 1996; Narine and Marangoni, 1999c).
156 Modifying lipids for use in food 8.4.1 Determination of the fractal dimension of fat crystal networks by microscopy The determination of the fractal dimension of a fat crystal network can be carried out using light scattering techniques (Vreeker et al., 1992), but only at very low volume fractions of solid fat. Microscopy is another technique that can be used to determine the fractal dimension of fat crystal networks. Polarized light microscopy (PLM) is by far the most popular and practical microscopy technique used in studies of fat microstructure. Particle counting method Our group has developed a PLM-based technique for the determination of the fractal dimension of fat crystal networks. Lipid films of about 20 µm thickness are imaged using a standard light microscope equipped with crossed polarizers using 4x, 10x or 40x objective lenses. The choice of magnification will depend on the scale at which a non-homogeneous distribution of mass is observed. This region should theoretically correspond to the intra-cluster region of the fat crystal networks. As stated above, mass will be distributed in a homogeneous fashion at scales above the size of a particle cluster. Having said this, the growth of fat crystals crystallized as a thin film on a microscope slide is somewhat restricted to two-dimensional growth and most probably does not correspond to the bulk situation. This does not decrease its usefulness in detecting relative changes. The particle-counting procedure is based on counting the number of crystal reflections or ‘particles’ within boxes of increasing size placed over a properly thresholded and inverted image (Fig. 8.9). Thresholding converts a grayscale image into a binary image, a necessary step in any image analysis, while inversion (white crystals become black) is necessary since features to be analyzed are considered to be black. The relationship between the number of particles (Np) and the fractal dimension (Dp) is: N p ~ ( L / a ) Dp
[8.4]
where L corresponds to the diameter of the region of interest (ROI) and a to the diameter of the particle. Therefore, the slope of the log–log plot of the number of particles versus the box size corresponds to the fractal dimension of the network. In this procedure, it is necessary to count the number of particles within a ROI, including as well as excluding particles that touch the edge of the boxes. The estimate of the fractal dimension of a network is obtained by averaging the fractal dimensions obtained from counts including and excluding particles touching the edge of the boxes. In our experience, values will range from approximately 1.5 to 2.5 (Marangoni, 2002). Box counting method The box dimension is defined as the exponent Db in the relationship:
N (d ) ≈
1 d Db
[8.5]
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
157
6
Log (N)
5 4 3 2 3.5
D = 2.01 (0.06) r2 = 0.0994 4.0
4.5 5.0 Log (length)
5.5
6.0
Fig. 8.9 The particle-counting method for the determination of mass fractal dimension from polarized light micrographs of fat crystal networks. The grayscale image of milk fat crystallized at 15 °C is inverted and thresholded. The slope of a log– log plot of the number of ‘particles’ counted in the different regions corresponds to the mass fractal dimension in d = 2 space.
where N(d) is the number of boxes of linear size d necessary to cover a data set of points distributed in a two-dimensional plane. The basis of this method is that, for objects that are Euclidean, equation [8.5] defines their dimension. In practice, to measure Db count the number of boxes of linear size d necessary to cover the set (i.e., the microstructures) for a range of values of d; and plot the logarithm of N(d) on the vertical axis versus the logarithm of d on the horizontal axis. If the set is indeed fractal, this plot will follow a straight line with a negative slope that equals –Db. Depending on the fat structure, the relationship is sometimes not entirely linear and the progression line deviates near the small boxes range, as shown in Fig. 8.10. The ‘Benoit’™ software package (Trusoft Int’l, USA, www.trusoftinternational.com) is one of the best tools on the market available for performing box counting determinations. Features to be analyzed have to be white, rather than the usual black. We also recommend users to threshold their images prior to the analysis using Adobe® Photoshop® (Adobe, USA) or other similar software to make sure that the thresholded image actually represents what is depicted in the grayscale image.
158 Modifying lipids for use in food
100 000
Number of occupied box
Db = 1.853 10 000
1000
100
10
1 1
10 100 Box side length
1000
Fig. 8.10 The box dimension method for the determination of mass fractal dimension from polarized light micrographs of fat crystal networks. The slope of a log–log plot of the number of occupied boxes ‘particles’ to the box side length corresponds to the mass fractal dimension in d = 2 space.
8.4.2 Determination of the fractal dimension of fat crystal networks by rheology (Dr) Most rheological investigations of fats involved empirical tests designed for quality control and attempt to simulate consumer sensory perception (de Bruijne and Arjen, 1999; Wright et al., 2001). These experiments involve large deformation techniques that measure hardness-related parameters, which are then directly compared to attributes evaluated by a sensory panel (de Bruijne and Arjen, 1999; Rousseau and Marangoni, 1998). Large deformation
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
159
techniques have included penetrometry using cone, pin, cylinder and several other geometries (Haighton, 1959; Prentice, 1972; Davey and Jones, 1985; deMan and Beers, 1987; deMan et al., 1989; Fearon and Johnston, 1989; Rousseau et al., 1996c; de Bruijne and Arjen, 1999), compression (Kawanari et al., 1981), extrusion (Kawanari et al., 1981; Rohm and Ulberth, 1989), spreadability (Huebner and Thomsen, 1957; Pompei at al., 1988), texture profile analysis (Halmos, 1997) and shear tests (Kawanari et al., 1981). Each of these methods offers analytical benefits and rapid evaluation and utilizes relatively inexpensive equipment (Lawless and Heymann, 1999). The majority of these tests are based on the breakdown of structure and single parameter measurement of the rheological properties of ‘hardness’, ‘yield stress’, ‘relative spreadability’, etc. (Szczesniak, 1966; Corey, 1970; Mortensen and Danmark, 1982; Lawless and Heymann, 1999). The elastic properties of fats are not solely influenced by the amount and spatial distribution of network mass, but also by particle properties, including size, shape and particle–particle interactions. A general formulation for the relationship between the shear elastic modulus (G′) of networks of particle clusters in the weak-link regime was recently derived by our group (Marangoni and Rogers, 2003). For spherical clusters interacting exclusively via Van der Waals forces, the expression is: 1
G = λΦ d – D λ is a constant, where A λ~ 2 πad o2 ε*
[8.6]
[8.7]
or
λ~
2δ a ε*
[8.8]
In these expressions, A corresponds to Hamacker’s constant, a to the diameter of the primary particles and do, to the inter-cluster separation distance; ε* is the extensional strain at the limit of linearity and δ is the crystal-melt interfacial tension. In order to estimate the fractal dimension of a colloidal gel-like material, it is necessary to determine the elastic modulus (G′) at different volume fractions of network material. This can be done by diluting the material with an appropriate solvent in a temperature range where solids are not significantly solubilized by the solvent and the structure is not altered by the dilution process. The slope of a log–log plot of G′ versus Φ can then been used to determine the fractal dimension of a network assuming a particular rheological regime (strong-link, weak-link). The pre-exponential term (λ), which is influenced primarily by particle properties and their interactions, can be determined from the y-intercept [8.6]. In all of our work, we have considered that fat crystal networks, at relatively high solid fat contents, are in the
160 Modifying lipids for use in food weak-link rheological regime. This is based on the fact that crystal clusters are relatively ‘hard’ structures, not likely to yield at small deformations. In addition, in our system we observed a positive dependence between the solids’ volume fraction and the strain at the limit of linearity. It is more likely that the links between these clusters yield instead. As well, the value for the fractal dimension obtained assuming a weak-link regime agrees with our physical model of such networks. Figure 8.11 shows one such plot for cocoa butter (CB). Molten CB at 80 °C was mixed with canola oil at different ratios, ranging from 17 % to 50 % CB, and allowed to crystallize at 5 °C for 24 hours prior to measurement (Awad et al., 2004). The effects of cooling rate on Dr are shown in Table 8.2. In general, an increase in the cooling rate results in a decrease in the Dr value (Herrera and Hartel, 2000a). Previous work in our laboratory has also established that higher fractal dimensions occur in networks that are more ordered; thus it can be expected that lower cooling rates would display this trend. The higher the Dr value, the more ‘ordered’ the crystal packing is said to be. For this reason the value for Dr is expected to vary in the order of Dr–0.1°C/min > Dr–1°C/min > Dr–5°C/min. When observed by time-lapse microscopy, the samples cooled slowly (0.1 °C/min) yielded less numerous (Fig. 8.12) and more sporadically formed nuclei relative to the more rapidly cooled samples. This allows for a more ordered crystal growth. The 1 °C/min sample initially 8
12 %
Log G ′
7
SFC range
6
y = 4.1338x + 8.9167 r2 = 0.9622
40 %
5 Slope (s) = 1/3 – D D = 3 – (1/s) = 3 – (1/4.1338) = 2.75 4 –0.3
–0.4
–0.5
–0.6 –0.7 Log (SFC/100)
–0.8
–0.9
–1
Fig. 8.11 Log–log plot of the storage modulus (G′) vs the solids volume fraction (Φ) used to determine the fractal dimension (D) of cocoa butter network. The fat was mixed with different canola fractions to achieve 12–40 % SFC (solid fat content) values.
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
161
Table 8.2 Rheological determination of fractal dimension Dr, λ, yield force and storage modulus G′ values for 80 % milk fat in canola cooled to 5 °C at different cooling rates after one and seven days. Cooling rate (°C/min)
Storage time (days)
SFC (%)
Dr
λ (Pa)
0.1 0.1 1 1 5 5
1 7 1 7 1 7
34.2 36.3 40.1 39.6 39.6 39.6
2.82 2.77 2.67 2.59 2.57 2.50
1.15E 3.74E 9.12E 6.50E 6.53E 5.20E
+ + + + + +
09 08 07 07 07 07
Yield force (N)
G′ (Pa)
14.7 18.2 26.7 28.7 37.4 31.9
3.72E 3.61E 4.82E 5.26E 7.21E 8.94E
+ + + + + +
06 06 06 06 06 06
Abbreviation: SFC = solid fat content.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
Fig. 8.12 Polarized light micrographs of AMF crystallized to 5 °C at cooling rates of (a, b) 0.1, (c, d) 1 and (e, f) 5 °C/min. Micrographs were taken immediately (a, c, e) and after storage for one day (b, d, f).
162 Modifying lipids for use in food demonstrated sporadic nucleation until reaching 13 °C. Below 13 °C, a burst in nucleation took place and crystalline mass rapidly filled the space, resulting in a more disordered system. Finally, samples cooled at 5 °C/min immediately nucleated extensively and spontaneously at 16 °C, resulting in an even more disordered system, with lower fractal dimension Dr than at lower cooling rates. The values for λ shown in Table 8.2 were also affected by cooling rate and storage time at 5 °C. As with the Dr value, the values for λ decrease with increasing cooling rate. It may be possible that significant changes in the Hamaker’s constant occur as a result of differences in crystal composition due to different cooling rates. During storage at 5 °C the λ-values decrease moderately at each cooling rate then appear to equilibrate at seven days, with only minor differences detectable between the seven and 14 days values. Recently, the fractal dimensions of fats calculated by image analyses and rheology were compared (Awad and Marangoni, 2004). For CB, the Dr was 2.75, while the Dp was 1.88 (± 0.06) and the one calculated by box dimension was 1.64 (± 0.003) for the same CB sample. These D values belong to twodimensional Euclidean space and by adding ‘1’ to the values we can thus translate them to three-dimensional space (Russ, 1984). However, the validity of this procedure still remains to be proven.
8.5
Structuring fat crystal network using processing
The aggregation state of fat crystal networks as a collection of microstructures similar to the structuring of particles in colloidal gels suggests that the mechanical properties of fats are dependent on microstructural properties. Early work by Heertje and co-workers (1987, 1988) has shown that characterization of the microstructure can facilitate the choice of composition and processing conditions necessary for the production of functional fat spreads. The mechanical properties of fats and fat-structured materials are mainly controlled by the amount of solids (SFC) and the microstructure or mesoscale structure of their fat crystal network, including both size and shape of flocs and particles and spatial distribution of mass. The SFC and microstructure can be controlled by altering the composition (blending), varying temperature as well as varying cooling and shear rates. Figure 8.13 shows a SFC-temperature diagram that demonstrates the manufacturing process of a typical margarine. First, the mix is quenched (rapidly cooled) to a temperature where crystallization occurs in the α polymorph. As shown in the figure, crystals will be formed upon further cooling, which lead to an increase in SFC along the α SFC line. Adiabatic (re)-crystallization from α to β modification leads to an increase in temperature. Since it is usually impossible to extract all the thermal energy from the crystallizing emulsion, repeated cooling (A) and resting steps (C) can be combined. The optimal process will depend always on the fat blend used, to give a final product with the desired final microstructure, plasticity and droplet size distribution. Recent
Solid fat content (%)
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
163
C
A C α
A
β′
Tα Temperature (°C)
Fig. 8.13 Schematic representation of a crystallizing fat during margarine processing conditions in a SFC vs temperature diagram. The solid line labeled with α refers to the conditions under which α crystallization occurs. The dashed path describes a system which is cooled below the α crystallization temperature, Tα in an A-unit. Subsequently, adiabatic re-crystallization to the β′ modification in a C-unit results in an increase in temperature, but new crystallites are formed as long as the system remains below the β′ crystallization temperature. The A–C sequence is repeated once more in this diagram.
work in our lab has shown that varying the SFC can lead to changes in the crystallization kinetics and network structure in three natural fats (anhydrous milk fat, palm oil and cocoa butter) (Awad et al., 2004). Figure 8.14 shows the different types of microstructures obtained for cocoa butter diluted with different amounts of canola oil as a function of SFC at 5 °C. 8.5.1 Effect of shear The effect of shear rate at different temperatures on the fractal dimension of milk fat is shown in Fig. 8.15. The fractal dimension obtained by rheology (Dr) decreased by decreasing the shear rate (Vanhoutte, 2002). The linear relationship at 26.5 °C is quite significant and indicates a strong correlation between the mass spatial distribution and shear rate. However, this behavior is likely to change under different temperatures and storage conditions. Temperature will influence the crystallization kinetics while storage may induce polymorphic transitions, which entail molecular rearrangements and restructuring of the fat crystals causing a decrease in the microstructural parameters as shown in Table 8.2. Therefore, the control of processing is not an easy task but a critical one.
8.5.2 Effect of cooling rate The effects of cooling rate on the spatial distribution of mass (D) and the particle properties (λ) of AMF are shown in Table 8.2 (Rye, 2003). The D and λ values were obtained by rheology from the slope of the log–log linear relationship between G′ and SFC. As shown in the table, the microstructural
164 Modifying lipids for use in food (a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
Fig. 8.14 Polarized light micrographs of cocoa butter diluted with canola oil crystallized in 20 µm films at 5 °C for 24 hours. The SFC values are (a) 16 %, (b) 22 %, (c) 39 %, (d) 49 %, (e) 57 % and (f) 67 %.
3.0 26.5 °C 21 °C
2.8
Dr
2.6
D = 2.8–29 · SR–1 2.4 2.2 2.0 0.000
D = 3.0–50 · SR–1 0.005
0.010 0.015 0.020 1/Shear rate (RPM–1)
0.025
Fig. 8.15 Effect of shear rate at different temperatures on the fractal dimension of milk fat.
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
165
parameters (i.e., D and λ) decreased upon increases in the rate of cooling. For example, the D value for AMF samples cooled to 5 °C at cooling rates of 0.1, 1 and 5 °C/min and then stored for one day at that temperature were 2.82, 2.67 and 2.57, respectively. Figure 8.12 demonstrates the difference in microstructure after applying different cooling rates immediately and after storage for one day. Large microstructures were shown at low cooling rate (0.1 °C/min) while small homogeneous microstructures were obtained when the cooling rate was increased to 5 °C/min. Small deformation rheology data obtained at different cooling rates showed that the loss modulus (G″) and the tangent of the phase angle tan (δ) decreased while the storage modulus (G′) increased by increasing the cooling rate (Rye, 2003). In a brief description, G′ is a measurement of the elastic or solid component of the energy applied to the system, G″ is a measure of the viscous dissipation of energy of the system and tan (δ) indicates whether the system behaves like a solid, liquid or viscoelastic structure. In addition, large deformation rheology measurements indicated that the cooling rate affected the hardness and that the harder sample was more brittle than the softer one. From a rheological point of view, a higher cooling rate will result in a more solid-like behavior and thus more rigid and harder fats. It was suggested that the links between larger particles will yield more than those between smaller particles (Alberola et al., 1994).
8.6
Future trends
One of the most important applications of structured fats is margarines. Margarines have come a long way since their invention for the French army in the late 1860s. It has been possible for many years to make margarines having a neutral effect on blood cholesterol by balancing the ratio of polyunsaturated, monounsaturated and saturated fatty acids in the fat blend. Nowadays, the latest generation of healthy margarines is actively lowering blood cholesterol levels significantly with repeated use. Additionally, there are now fortified (containing vitamins and essential minerals) variants focused on delivering a balanced nutrition. A recent successful development to lower the saturated fatty acid content (the structuring component in the fat network) is the introduction of liquid margarine. We cannot call this product a particle gel, but rather a liquid emulsion. The consumer has also expressed an increasing interest to move away from processed foods to natural or organic products. Whilst margarine at first sight may appear to be the archetypal processed food, there is a very difficult challenge in the establishment of a good sustainable raw material supply chain to develop an organic margarine. This pushes the technology to its limits since the raw materials should not have fertilizers or pesticides, oil has to be free of solvents or chemical processing and no chemically derived emulsifiers are allowed. Despite these severe limitations, the first high fat level products are already on the market. A much greater
166 Modifying lipids for use in food challenge lies ahead to make the first low fat variants of such organic products. Proper structuring via modulation of fat crystal network structure will play a central role in the manufacture of such products.
8.7
References
ALBEROLA N, BAS C
and MELE P (1994), Composites particularizes: modelisation du comportement viscoelastique, assortie du concept de percolation, C R Acad Sci Ser, 2319, 1129–1134. AQUILANO D and SQUALDINO G (2001), Fundamental aspects of equilibrium and crystallization kinetics, in Garti N and Sato K, Crystallisation Processes in Fats and Lipid Systems, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 1–51. AWAD T and MARANGONI A G (2004), Comparison between the image analyses methods for quantifying the spatial distribution of mass in plastic fats, in Marangoni A G, Fat Crystal Networks, Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press, Inc., 381–411. AWAD T and SATO K (2001), Effects of hydrophobic emulsifier additives on crystallization behaviour of palm mid fraction (PMF) in Oil-in-Water emulsion, J Am Oil Chem Soc., 78, 837–842. AWAD T and SATO K (2002a), Acceleration of crystallization of palm kernel oil in Oil inWater emulsion by hydrophobic emulsifier additives, Coll & Surf B, 3, 55–74. AWAD T and SATO K (2002b), Control of fat crystallization in O/W emulsions, in Marangoni A and Narine S, Physical Properties of Lipids, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 37–62. AWAD T, HAMADA Y and SATO K (2001), Effects of addition of diacylglycerols on fat crystallization in oil-in-water emulsion, Eur J Lipids Fat Technol, 11, 735–741. AWAD T, ROGER M and MARANGONI A G (2004), Scaling behavior of the elastic modulus with SFC in fats, J Phys Chem B, 108, 171–179. BOISTELLE R (1988), Fundamentals of nucleation and crystal growth, in Garti N and Sato K, Crystallization and Polymorphism of Fats and Fatty Acids, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 189–226. BROWN W D and BALL R C (1985), Computer simulation of chemically limited aggregation, J Phys A, 18, L517–L521. CERDEIRA M, MARTINI S, HARTEL R W and HERRERA M L (2003), Effect of sucrose ester addition on nucleation and growth behavior of milk fat-sunflower oil blends, J Agric Food Chem, 51, 6550–6557. COREY H (1970), Texture in foodstuffs, CRC Crit Rev Food Technol, 1, 161–198. DALGLEISH D G, SRINIVASAN M and SINGH H (1995), Surface properties of oil-in-water emulsion droplets containing casein and Tween 60, J Agric Food Chem, 43, 2351–2355. DAVEY K R and JONES P N (1985), Evaluation of a sliding pin consistometer for measurement of the hardness and spreadability of butter and margarine, J Texture Studies, 16, 75– 84. DE BRUIJNE D W and ARJEN B (1999), Fabricated fat-based foods, in Rosenthal A, Food Texture Measurement and Perception, Gaithersburg, M D, Aspen Publishers, Inc., 185–227. DEMAN J M and BEERS A M (1987), Fat crystal networks: structure and rheological properties, J Texture Studies, 18, 303–318. DEMAN J M and DEMAN L (2001), Texture of fats in Marangoni A and Narine S, Physical Properties of Lipids, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 191–217. DEMAN L, DEMAN J M and BLACKMAN B (1989), Physical and textural evaluation of some shortenings and margarines, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 66(1), 128–132. DICKINSON E and MCCLEMENTS D J (1996), Fat crystallization in oil-in-water emulsions, in Dickinson E and McClements D J, Advances in Food Colloids, London, Blackie Academic and Professional, 211–246.
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
167
and JOHNSTON D E (1989), A comparison of three instrumental techniques to evaluate butter spreadability, J Food Quality, 12, 23–38. GARTI N (1988), Effects of surfactants on crystallization and polymorphic transformation of fats and fatty acids, in Garti N and Sato K, Crystallization and Polymorphism of Fats and Fatty Acids, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 267–303. GOFF H D and JORDAN W K (1989), Action of emulsifiers in promoting fat destabilization during the manufacture of ice cream, J Dairy Sci, 72, 18–29. HAIGHTON A J (1959), The measurement on the hardness of margarine and fats with cone penetrometers, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 36, 345–348. HALMOS A L (1997), Food texture and sensory properties of diary ingredients, Food Australia, 49(4), 169–173. HEERTJE I (1993), Microstructural studies in fat research, Food Structure, 12, 77–94. HEERTJE I, LEUNIS M, VAN ZEYL W J M and BERENDS E (1987), Product microscopy of fatty products, Food Microstructure, 6, 1–8. HEERTJE I, VAN EENDENBURG J, CORNELISSEN J M and JURIAANSE A C (1988), The effect of processing on some microstructural characteristics of fat spreads, Food Microstructure, 7, 189–193. HERNQVIST L (1988), Crystal structures of fats and fatty acids, in Garti N and Sato K, Crystallization and Polymorphism in Fats and Fatty Acids, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 97–137. HERRERA M L and HARTEL R W (2000a), Effect of processing conditions on physical properties of a milk fat model system: rheology, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 77, 1189–1195. HERRERA M L and HARTEL R W (2000b), Effect of processing conditions on crystallization kinetics of a milk fat model system, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 77, 1177–1187. HERRERA M L and HARTEL R W (2000c), Effect of processing conditions on physical properties of a milk fat model system: microstructure, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 77, 1197–1204. HERRERA M L and MARQUEZ ROCHA F J (1996), Effects of sucrose ester on the kinetics of polymorphic transition in hydrogenated sunflower oil, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 73, 321– 326. HERRERA M L, DE LEON GATTI M and HARTEL R W (1999), A kinetic analysis of crystallization of a milk fat model system, Food Res Int, 32, 289–298. HUEBNER V R and THOMSEN L C (1957), Spreadability and hardness of butter. I. Development of an instrument for measuring spreadability, Am Dairy Sci, 40, 834–838. JURIAANSE A C and HEERTJE I (1988), Microstructure of shortenings, margarine and butter – a review, Food Microstructure, 7, 181–188. KANTOR Y and WEBMAN I (1984), Elastic properties of random percolating systems, Phys Rev Lett, 52, 1891–1894. KAWANARI M, HAMANN D D, SWARTZEL K R and HANSEN A P (1981), Rheological and texture studies of butter, J Texture Studies, 12, 483–505. LARSSON K (1966), Classification of glyceride crystal forms, Acta Chemica Scandinavia, 20, 2555–2260. LAWLESS H T and HEYMANN H (1999), Texture evaluation, in Heymann H and Lawless H, Sensory Evaluation of Food, Gaithersburg, M D, Aspen Publishers Inc., 379–405 MARANGONI A G (2000), Elasticity of high volume fraction fractal aggregate networks: a thermodynamic approach, Phys Rev B, 62,13951–13955. MARANGONI A G (2002), The nature of fractality in fat crystal networks, Trends Food Sci Techol, 13, 37–47. MARANGONI A G and ROGERS M (2003), Structural basis for the yield stress in plastic disperse system, Appl Phys Lett, 82, 1–3. MARANGONI A G and ROUSSEAU D (1996), Is plastic fat rheology governed by the fractal geometry of the fat crystal network?, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 73, 991–994. MARANGONI A G and ROUSSEAU D (1998), The influence of chemical interesterification on the physicochemical properties of complex fat systems. 3. Rheology and fractality of the crystal network, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 75, 1633–1636. FEARON A M
168 Modifying lipids for use in food MARTINI S, HERRERA M L
and HARTEL R W (2001), Effect of cooling rate on nucleation behavior of milk fat–sunflower oil blends, J Agric Food Chem 49, 3223–3229. MARTINI S, HERRERA M L and HARTEL R W (2002a), Effect of cooling rate on crystallization behavior of milk fat–sunflower oil blends, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 79, 1055–1062. MARTINI S, HERRERA M L and HARTEL R W (2002b), effect of processing conditions on microstructure of milk fat fraction/sunflower oil blends, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 79, 1063–1068. MARTINI S, PUPPO M C, HARTEL R W and HERRERA M L (2002c), Effect of sucrose ester and sunflower oil addition on crystalline microstructure of a high melting milk fat fraction, J Food Sci, 67, 3412–3418. MAZZANTI G, GUTHRIE S E, SIROTA, E B, MARANGONI A G and IDZIAK S H (2003), Orientation and phase transitions of fat crystals under shear, Crystal Growth and Design, 3 (5), 721– 725. MAZZANTI G, GUTHRIE S E, SIROTA E B, MARANGONI A G and IDZIAK S H (2004a), Novel shearinduced phases in cocoa butter, Crystal Growth and Design, 4(3), 409–411. MAZZANTI G, GUTHRIE S E, SIROTA E B, MARANGONI A G and IDZIAK S H J (2004b), Crystallization of bulk fats under shear, in Dutcher J R and Marangoni A G, Soft Materials – Structure and Dynamics, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc., 279–299. MCCLEMENTS D J, DUNGAN S R, GERMAN J B, SIMONEAU C and KINSELLA J E (1994), Droplet size and emulsifier type affect crystallization and melting of hydrocarbon-in-water emulsions, J Food Sci, 58, 1148–1151. MILOSAV K (1985), Microstructure of dairy foods. 2. Milk products based on fats, J Dairy Sci, 68, 3234–3248. MORTENSEN B K and DANMARK H (1982), Consistency characteristics of butter, Milchwissenschaft, 36, 393–395. NARINE S and MARANGONI A G (1999a), Relating structure of fat crystal networks to mechanical properties: a review, Food Res Int, 32, 227–248. NARINE S and MARANGONI A G (1999b), Mechanical and structural model of fractal networks of fat crystal at low deformations, Phys Rev E, 60, 6991–7000. NARINE S and MARANGONI A G (1999c), Fractal nature of a fat crystal network, Phys Rev E, 59 (2), 991–994. NARINE S and MARANGONI A G (2002), Structure and mechanical properties of fat crystal networks, Adv Food Nut Res, 44, 33–145. POMPEI C, CASIRAGHI E, LUCISANO M and ZANONI B (1988), Development of two imitative methods of spreadability evaluation and compression with penetration tests, J Food Sci, 53(2), 597–602. PRENTICE J H (1972), Rheology and texture of dairy products, J Texture Studies, 3, 415– 458. PUPPO M C, MARTINI S, HARTEL R W and HERRERA M L (2002), Effect of sucrose ester on crystallization and rheological behavior of blends of milk fat fraction sunflower oil, J Food Sci, 67, 3419–3426. ROHM H and ULBERTH F (1989), Use of magnitude estimation in sensory texture analysis of butter, J Texture Studies, 20, 409–418. ROUSSEAU D and MARANGONI A G (1998), The effect of chemical and enzymatic interesterification on the physical and sensory properties of butterfat-canola oil spreads, Food Res Int, 31, 381–388. ROUSSEAU D, FORESTIERE K, HILL A R and MARANGONI A G (1996a), Restructuring butterfat through blending and chemical interesterification. 1. Melting behavior and triacylglycerol modification, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 73, 963–972. ROUSSEAU D, HILL A R and MARANGONI A G (1996b), Restructuring butterfat through blending and chemical interesterification. 2. Microstructure and polymorphism, J Am Oil Chem Soc 73, 973–981. ROUSSEAU D, HILL A R and MARANGONI A G (1996c), Restructuring butterfat through blending and chemical interesterification. 3. Rheology, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 73, 983–989.
Structure and properties of fat crystal networks
169
(1994), Fractal Surfaces, New York, Plenum Press. (2003), The effects of processing conditions and storage time on the physical properties of anhydrous milk fat, M.Sc. Thesis, Guelph University, Canada. SATO K (2001a), Crystallization behavior of fats and lipids – a review, Chem Eng Sci, 56, 2255–2265. SATO K (2001b), Molecular aspects in fat polymorphism, in Widlak N, Hartel R W and Narine S, Crystallization and Solidification Properties of Lipids, Champaign, IL, AOCS Press, 1–16. SHIH W H, SHIH W Y, KIM S I, LIU J and AKSAY I A (1990), Scaling behavior of the elastic properties of colloidal gels, Phys Revi A, 42, 4772–4779. SMALL D M (1986), The Physical Chemistry of Lipids, 2nd edn, New York, Plenum Press, pp. 345–394. SONNTAG N O V (1979), Composition and characteristics of individual fats and oils, in Formo M W, Jungermann E, Norris F A, Sonntag N O V and Swern D, Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 4th edn, New York, Wiley-Interscience, 289–477. SZCZESNIAK A S (1966), Texture measurements, Food Technol, 52–58. TIMMS R E (1994), Physical chemistry of fats, in Moran D P J and Rajah K K, Fats in Food Products, London, Blackie Academic and Professional, 1–24. VAN DEN TEMPEL M (1979), Rheology of concentrated suspensions, J Colloid Interface Sci, 71, 18–20. VANHOUTTE B (2002), Milk fat fractionation: fractionation and texturisation, PhD Thesis, Ghent University. VREEKER R, HOEKSTRA L L, DEN BOER D C and AGTEROF W G M (1992), The fractal nature of fat crystal networks, Coll & Surf, 65, 185–189. WRIGHT A J and MARANGONI A G (2002), Effect of DAG on milk fat crystallization, J Am Oil Chem Soc 79, 395–402. WRIGHT A J and MARANGONI A G (2003), The effect of minor components on milk fat microstructure and mechanical properties, J Food Sci, 68, 182–186. WRIGHT A J, HARTEL R W, NARINE S and MARANGONI A G (2000), The effect of minor components on milk fat crystallization, J Am Oil Chem Soc, 77, 463–475. WRIGHT A J, SCANLON M G, HARTEL R W and MARANGONI, A G (2001), Rheological properties of milk fat and butter, J Food Sci, 66(8), 1056–1071. RUSS J C RYE G R
Part II Modifying lipids for use in food
9 Hydrogenation of lipids for use in food G. R. List, National Center for Agricultural Utilization Research, USA and J. W. King, University of Arkansas, USA
9.1
Introduction
An edible oil quality triangle has been described as having functionality, oxidative stability and health/nutrition as the three vertices (Lui, 1999). An ideal oil would have enough solid fat for use in spreads and shortenings, be resistant to oxidation at frying temperatures and contain no saturated or trans fatty acids (TFA). Thus, in order to satisfy these requirements, edible oils require modification most usually by catalytic hydrogenation. Since the 1970s, the health/nutrition leg has received considerable attention since both saturated and trans fatty acids are formed during hydrogenation (Sebedio and Christie, 1998). Trans fatty acids were reported as cholesterol-elevating agents raising low-density lipoproteins (LDL) (bad cholesterol) and lowering high-density lipoproteins (HDL) (good cholesterol) in humans (Mensick and Katan, 1990; Judd et al., 1994). Epidemiological studies have suggested a link between TFA consumption and coronary heart disease (CHD) risk (Hennekens and Willett, 1997; Hu et al., 1997). Other workers have questioned the results of CHD risk reports (Hegsted, 1998; Ockene and Nicolosi, 1998). Some reports, however, reject the link between TFA consumption and CHD risk (Kris-Etherton et al., 1995; Anon, 1996). Nonetheless, despite being a controversial issue, the US Food and Drug Administration enacted rules for trans fatty acids labeling to meet requirements for the Nutrition Labeling and Education Act passed by the US Congress in 1990. Since January 1 2006, food labels must contain TFA content as a separate line. A product containing less than 0.5 g TFA/serving may be declared as zero (Anon 1999, 2003). In 1995, the International Margarine Association of the Countries of Europe
174 Modifying lipids for use in food (IMACE) introduced a code of practice recommending a level of > 5 % TFA (equivalent to butter) that, by 2002, was reduced to > 1 % in spreads, while processed foods should not exceed the 5 % previously recommended. Denmark has enacted the most stringent regulation with a maximum of 2 % TFA with a trans-free claim only below 1 % TFA and including all C14–C22 trans isomers (Robinson, 2004). Under US regulations, conjugated linoleic acid is excluded for labeling purposes. Worldwide consumption of fats and oils in 2004–2005 (Anon, 2006) accounted for about 108 million tonnes, of which 57 % can be accounted for by soybean oil (29.6 million tonnes) and palm oil (31.6 million tonnes). While soybean oil is relatively low in saturated acids (15 %), it represents a major source of trans fatty acids in our food supply because it must be hydrogenated to achieve functional properties and oxidative stability in food oils. On the other hand, palm oil, while containing no trans acids, contains about 50 % saturated acids, making it attractive for use in these products, particularly when modified by fractionation and/or interesterification. Thus, just two fats and oils dominate and dictate oil processing worldwide and strategies to reduce trans and saturated acids must focus on soybean and palm oils. This chapter will review the hydrogenation process with emphasis on trans fatty acid formation and their occurrence in food oils.
9.2
Trans fatty acid contents of food oils
Reviews of margarine/spread formulations in North America have been published by Mag (1994), Chrysam (1996) and Pelloso (2001). European practices have been reviewed by Moran (1994) and Podmore (1994). A survey of the trans content of soft tub margarine/spreads taken over a seven year period in the USA is shown in Table 9.1 (List et al., 2000a). The samples reported are premium products taken from grocery store shelves and, according to their label, were formulated from hydrogenated and liquid soybean oil. Over the seven year period, trans reduction ranged from about Table 9.1 Brand
Trans content of soft margarines/spreads by year [US samples, List (2000a)]. Year
Overall
1992
1995
1999
reduction (%)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
19.4 10.3 12.2 31.4 11.6 24.6 29.5
15.9 18.2 7.8 16.2 19.5 14.7 20.2
14.5 7.9 2.6 14.6 6.1 10.5 5.3
25.3 23.4 79.7 53.6 47.5 57.4 82.1
Average
19.9
16.1
8.8
55.8
Hydrogenation of lipids for use in food
175
25 % to 82 % with an average reduction of nearly 56 %. The 1992 data indicates an average of nearly 20 % trans, whereas the 1999 data shows less than 9 % trans in soft tub products. Stick/spreadable products have shown decreased trans acid contents over the past decade. In 1989 (Postmus et al.) trans acids averaged 26.8 %, but by 1999 the average had dropped to 16.9 % or a 37 % overall reduction (List et al., 2000a). Thus, the domestic edible oil industry has made concerted efforts to reduce trans acids in edible products. This has been accomplished through reformulation methods in which a multiple basestock system, employing three hydrogenated oils, has been replaced with a single component. Typically, soybean oil hydrogenated to an iodine value of about 65 (40 % trans) is blended with liquid soybean oil (25–50 %) to yield components suitable for a wide variety of spreads, including soft tub, spreadable stick or stick products. The trans acid contents of margarines and spreads taken from the literature over a seven year period (1995–2002) are shown in Table 9.2 (Bayard and Wolff, 1995; Oveson et al., 1998; Ratnayke et al., 1998; Tsanev et al., 1998; Alonzo et al., 2000; List et al., 2000a; Tekin et al., 2002). Low trans products are arbitrarily defined as those having 5 % or less while zero trans products may have smaller amounts of trans acids (1–2 %). Of the 228 samples reported, 87, or 38.2 %, may be considered zero or low trans. The largest number of samples reported include those from Canada and the USA, where 10 of the 126 are zero/low trans type. These results indicate that margarine/ spreads formulated in North America are formulated primarily from hydrogenated components rather than by interesterification. The products produced in Denmark are formulated from fractionated or interesterified oil components and represent the only country surveyed where hydrogenation has been replaced entirely. However, if the 59 samples from Denmark are excluded, 28 of 169, or 16.6 %, are of the low/zero trans composition. Thus, it would appear that hydrogenation remains the technology of choice to formulate margarine/spread products throughout most of the world. Table 9.2
Zero/low trans margarines formulation trends across the world. Zero/low trans*
Year
Country
No. samples reported
No
%
1995 1998 1998 1998 2000 2000 2002
France Denmark** Bulgaria Canada USA Spain Turkey
12 59 5 109 17 12 14
5 59 3 8 2 6 4
41.7 100 60 73 11.8 50 28.6
228
87
38.2
Total
*5 % or less. **Excluding Denmark, only 16.6 % are zero/low Trans.
176 Modifying lipids for use in food A recent report (Matsuzaki et al., 2002) analyzed margarines marketed in Scandinavia and 11 other European countries and in the USA for trans fatty acids and other compositional data. Their data confirm that any decrease in trans fatty acids is achieved at the expense of increased saturated acid content. Compared to the rest of the world, stick margarines produced in the USA had the lowest trans/saturated acid content (41.4 %) and the highest ratio of PUFA (polyunsaturated fatty acids)/trans fatty acids (TFA) + saturated acids (SA). The same trend was observed for soft tub margarines. Extensive surveys of the TFA content of European fats/oils, bakery products and dietary fats have been published by ARO et al. (1998), Van Erp-Baart et al. (1998) and Van Poppel et al. (1998). An extensive compilation of the TFA content of 117 foods manufactured in the USA has recently appeared along with saturated and unsaturated fatty acid data. Eight food groups, including breads and cakes, margarines, cookies and crackers, frozen potato products, salty snacks, vegetable oil/shortenings, salad dressings and breakfast cereals were reported (Satchithanandam et al., 2004). Worldwide trends in trans acid consumption have been extensively covered (Craig-Schmidt, 1998).
9.3 Formulation of food oils by hydrogenation (soybean based) A detailed discussion of hydrogenation is beyond the scope of this chapter. For further information the reader should consult reviews listed in the bibliography (Patterson, 1994; Erickson and Erickson, 1995; Hastert, 1996). Temperature, pressure, agitation and catalyst concentration are the most important factors governing the course and speed of hydrogenation. However, with other factors being equal, temperature has the largest effect on trans acid formation (Stingley and Wrobel, 1961; Puri, 1980). Industrially, hydrogenation is carried out under selective conditions favoring reduction of polyunsaturated groups over that of monoenic acids. Typically, selective conditions involve high temperature (160–220 °C), low hydrogen pressure (10–40 psi) in the presence of 0.02–0.04 % nickel metal (Table 9.3). Typically the catalysts are supplied as 25 % nickel on a support. Although selective conditions promote trans fatty acid formation, it is imperative that the amount of stearic acid formed at lower iodine values be kept at a minimum since any tristearin formed in the reaction will unduly raise the melting point of the finished oil such that the sharply melting trans functionality is compromised. 9.3.1 Margarine basestock and formulation of spreads Excellent reviews of basestock systems have been published by O’Brien (1998), Latondress (1980) and Erickson and Erickson (1995). Margarine oil basestocks require ‘selective conditions’ where stearic acid formation needs
Table 9.3
Fatty acid content and properties of partially hydrogenated soybean oils.
Oil
Original soybean oil Hydrogenated soybean oila Stearine HW SBO Margarine oilb Shortening oilc
Fatty acid composition C16
C18
C18:1
C18:2
C18:3
11.2 11.4 12.8 10.5 11.3 11.3
3.7 4.7 6.5 4.4 13.6 5.1
22.1 40.3 48.4 42.0 75.2 72.6
55.0 40.5 30.3 40.0 0.0 11.0
6.8 3.0 1.9 2.9 0.0 0.0
160 °C, 40 psi H2 pressure, 0.02 % nickel. 216 °C, 20 psi H2 pressure, 0.03 % nickel. c 221 °C, 20 psi H2 pressure, 0.03 % nickel. Abbreviation: HW SBO = hydrogenated, winterized soybean oil. a
b
Iodine value 132.0 112.6 97.2 109.5 64.7 81.5
% Trans
0.0 8.7 13.3 9.1 39.7 31.8
Melting Solid fat content at temperature (°C) point (°C) 10 21.1 26.7 33.3 40 –14.3 16.7 27.6 –7.5 41.3 29.3
0.0 0.0 14.2 0.9 73.7 36.3
0.0 0.3 5.5 0.0 54.1 13.7
0.0 0.0 1.7 0.1 44.7 4.6
0.0 0.2 0.0 0.0 22.3 0.0
0.0 0.2 0.0 0.0 3.3 0.0
178 Modifying lipids for use in food to be controlled very carefully. Generally, low pressure and high temperatures are used. Typically, the preparation of multi-purpose margarine basestocks involves reducing the iodine value (IV) of soybean oil