LIQUID CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS
This page intentionally left blank
LIQUID CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS
Xin-Jiu Wang Avery Research Center, USA
Qi-Feng Zhou Peking University, China
rp World Scientific NEW JERSEY LONDON SINGAPORE SHANGHAI - HONG KONG - TAIPEI BANGALORE
Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224 USA office: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
LIQUID CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS Copyright © 2004 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN 981-238-410-3 ISBN 981-238-411-1 (pbk)
Typeset by Stallion Press Email:
[email protected]
Printed in Singapore.
Contents
Preface
xi
1 Liquid Crystal States of Matter 1.1 Liquid Crystal States 1.2 Appearance and Light Scattering of Liquid Crystals 1.3 Chemical Structure of Liquid Crystals 1.3.1 Basic molecular structure of rodic liquid crystals 1.3.2 Discotic liquid crystals 1.3.3 Amphiphilic liquid crystals 1.4 Polymorphism of Liquid Crystals 1.4.1 No translational order — Nematics 1.4.2 One-dimensional translational order — Smectic A and C phases 1.4.3 Two-dimensional translational order within layers with weak correlation along the third dimension — Hexatic phases 1.4.4 Three-dimensional translational order but correlation is weaker than that in crystals 1.4.5 Chiral liquid crystals 1.4.6 Cubic phases 1.4.7 Discotic liquid crystals 1.4.8 Lyotropic liquid crystals 1.4.9 Induced liquid crystals v
1 1 4 6 6 7 9 11 12 13
15 17 19 21 23 25 26
vi
Contents
1.5 Continuum Theory of Liquid Crystals 1.5.1 Order parameter 1.5.2 Distortions of liquid crystals 1.5.3 Frederiks transitions 1.5.4 The twisted – and supertwisted – nematic liquid crystals 1.6 Defects in Liquid Crystals 1.6.1 The Volterra process 1.6.2 Strength of disclination in nematics 1.6.3 Point disclinations 1.6.4 Defects in smectic A phase 1.6.5 Defects in the smectic C phase 1.6.6 Dispiration in the smectic C* phase 1.6.7 Defects in the cholesteric phase 1.6.8 Textures 1.6.9 Homotopy classification of defects in liquid crystals
2 Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers 2.1 Onsager Theory for Rigid – Rod Liquid Crystalline Polymers 2.1.1 The partition function 2.1.2 The excluded volume 2.1.3 The equilibrium of liquid crystals 2.2 Flory Theory for Rigid – Rod Liquid Crystalline Polymers 2.2.1 Partition function of a rigid rod solution 2.2.2 Formation of the liquid crystal phase 2.2.3 Two phase equilibrium 2.2.4 Effect of “soft” interaction between molecules 2.2.5 Semi-rigid chains 2.2.6 Discussion of the Flory theory 2.3 Comparison of the Onsager and Flory Theories 2.4 Maier-Saupe Mean Field Approach 2.4.1 Maier-Saupe mean field theory for small molecular mass liquid crystals 2.4.2 Freely-jointed-rod chains 2.4.3 Elastically-jointed-rod chains 2.4.4 Discrete and continuum chain models
27 27 29 31 34 35 36 38 42 44 47 47 47 49 50
53 54 55 61 62 65 65 69 71 74 78 79 81 86 86 88 90 95
Contents
2.5 Worm Chain Model of Liquid Crystalline Polymers 2.5.1 Path integral description for polymers 2.5.2 Anisotropic conformation 2.5.3 Order parameter 2.5.4 Dependence of N–I transition on polymer chain length 2.5.5 Latent entropy at transition 2.6 Main Chain Liquid Crystalline Polymers with Spacers 2.6.1 Molecularly non-homogeneous liquid crystalline polymers 2.6.2 Pseudo-second-order-phase-transition temperature 2.6.3 Hinge effect 2.7 Side Chain Liquid Crystalline Polymers 2.7.1 Model 2.7.2 Phase classification of side chain nematic polymers 2.7.3 Order parameter and phase transitions 2.7.4 Conformations 2.8 Liquid Crystalline Networks 2.8.1 Conventional networks 2.8.2 Model of liquid crystal networks 2.8.3 Relation of stress and strain 2.9 Liquid Crystal Network Gels 2.9.1 Nematogetic network swollen by isotropic solvent 2.9.2 Nematogetic network swollen by nematic solvent 2.9.3 The shift of phase equilibria under the presence of force
3 Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Low Mass Liquid Crystalline Compounds and Mesogenic Units 3.2.1 Poly(1,4-phenylene)s 3.2.2 Incorporation of “side-steps”
vii
96 96 99 101 101 102 103 103 108 108 110 110 111 112 115 116 117 119 121 124 124 126 131
133 133 138 139 139
viii
Contents
3.3 3.4 3.5
3.6
3.7
3.2.3 Incorporation of kinked elements 3.2.4 Incorporation of flexible spacers 3.2.5 Terminal or end-on substitution 3.2.6 Lateral or side-on substitution Molecular Weight and Molecular Weight Distribution Main Chain Liquid Crystalline Polymers Liquid Crystalline Polymers of the Side-Group Type with End-on Attachment 3.5.1 Synthesis 3.5.2 Structure and properties Liquid Crystalline Polymers of the Side-group Type with Side-on Attachment and “Mesogen-jacketed Liquid Crystal Polymers” Liquid Crystalline Polymers without Mesogenic Units
4 Characterization of Liquid Crystalline Polymers 4.1 Polarizing Optical Microscopy (POM) 4.1.1 Optical basics for POM 4.1.2 Orthoscopic observation 4.1.3 Conoscopic observation 4.1.4 Textures of polymeric liquid crystals 4.2 Differential Thermal Analysis (DTA) and Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) 4.3 X-Ray Diffraction 4.4 Other Methods 4.4.1 Miscibility testing 4.4.2 Infrared dichroism 4.4.3 NMR study 4.4.4 Small-angle neutron scattering 5 Liquid Crystalline Polymers as High Performance Fiber and Structural Materials 5.1 Introduction 5.2 Liquid Crystalline Aromatic Polyamides 5.3 Liquid Crystalline Aromatic Heterocyclic Polymers 5.4 Thermotropic Liquid Crystalline Polymers 5.4.1 Type-1 copolyesters 5.4.2 Type-2 copolyesters 5.4.3 Type-3 copolyesters 5.5 Composites Reinforced by Liquid Crystalline Polymers
142 143 143 145 147 155 166 166 171
177 188
195 197 198 201 206 209 221 228 237 237 238 240 241
245 245 246 254 259 261 264 268 271
Contents
6 Physical Properties and Applications of Liquid Crystalline Polymers 6.1 Elastic Properties of Liquid Crystalline Polymers 6.2 Viscosity and Rheology of Liquid Crystalline Polymers 6.3 Cholesteric Liquid Crystalline Polymers 6.3.1 Optical properties of cholesteric liquid crystals 6.3.2 Lyotropic cholesteric liquid crystalline polymers 6.3.3 Thermotropic cholesteric liquid crystalline polymers 6.4 Non-Linear Optical Liquid Crystalline Polymers 6.5 Ferroelectric Liquid Crystalline Polymers 6.6 Applications of Liquid Crystalline Polymers in Information Storage 6.6.1 Nematic liquid crystalline polymers 6.6.2 Smectic liquid crystalline polymers 6.6.3 Cholesteric liquid crystalline polymers 6.6.4 Photo-isomeric change
ix
285 285 300 315 315 318 326 329 341 350 350 352 353 354
References
355
Index
371
This page intentionally left blank
Preface
The liquid crystal and the polymer are two different disciplines of science and technology. They meet together producing the liquid crystalline polymer or, if you prefer, the polymeric liquid crystal. The liquid crystalline polymer combines mesogenic units and high molecular weight, and thus exhibits excellent anisotropic physical properties while possessing the advantage of easy processing and convenient molecular tailoring. The liquid crystalline polymer not only possesses the individual properties of each of its parents, but also exhibits intrinsic features that its parents do not have. In such a sense, the liquid crystalline polymer is a new state of matter. Both the liquid crystal and the polymer are of about the same age, but the polymer has successfully penetrated every walk of human life. On the other hand, the liquid crystal had kept itself quiet for a half century until the early 70’s. Since then, it has caught the vast interest of both science and industry. It has been applied especially in the display industry, such as in portable TVs and notebook and desktop computers. Two important events symbolized the liquid crystal’s coming of age: Professor P. G. de Gennes, a French physicist, won the Noble Prize in 1991 and Professor G. W. Gray, a British chemist, was awarded the Kyoto Prize in 1995. In tracing back the history of the liquid crystalline polymer itself, the German scientist D. Vorlander should be mentioned. It was he who first pointed out that the long shape of the polymer does not prevent the polymer from exhibiting liquid crystallinity. The polymeric liquid crystallinity was first found in the tobacco mosaic virus in solution around 1940, and later found in the poly-peptide solution. The initial theoretical basis for the rigid liquid crystalline polymer is attributed to the xi
xii
Preface
efforts of Onsager and Flory, both Noble Prize laureates. The liquid crystalline polymer has been a constant challenge to theoretical scientists to fully explain and exactly predict the behaviors of it and its substantial members, i.e., network and gel. In addition, the understanding of liquid crystalline polymers may provide an insight into biological systems. S. L. Kwolek, a woman scientist of DuPont, invented the liquid crystal aromatic polyamides which eventually paved the way to the first commercial liquid crystalline polymer product—poly-p-phenyleneterephthalamide under the trade name Kevlar. She recently recalled, “When I dissolved the PBA (poly-p-aminobenzamide) polymer at 10% concentration in tetramethylurea with 6.5% LiCl, the solution was unusually fluid, turbid, stiropalescent, and butter-milk-like in appearance.” The fiber that was spun turned out to be extremely strong with a modulus of 430 gpd! This discovery in 1964 remains a milestone of this field. In recognition of her contribution, the American Society of Chemistry Industry awarded Kwolek the 1997 Perkin Medal. The liquid crystalline polymer has since developed far beyond imagination that a decade ago. The liquid crystalline polymer family has so far included the main chain-, side chain-, and crosslinked- (i.e. network or elastomer) types, and their solutions and gels. The liquid crystal phases cover nematic, cholesteric and smectics. Although the science of the liquid crystalline polymer is not fully mature, it has attracted significant research interests and has already made tremendous progress. As investments and human resources continue, the liquid crystalline polymer is expected to have an even brighter future. The liquid crystalline polymer industry now covers diverse products, from high modulus rope to high strength composite, from the tennis racket to the radial tire cord, from the cover layer of the optical fiber to the microwave oven, from the bullet-proof vest to thermal insulated clothing, and from the electro-optic display to non-linear optical material, etc. The authors, X. J. Wang (XJW), a condensed matter physicist, and Q. F. Zhou (QFZ), a polymer chemist, have found joint research interest in this fascinating material since the middle of the 80’s. They have collaborated on several projects. In 1994, they successfully organized an IUPAC conference on liquid crystalline polymers in Beijing. XJW is now working as a senior research scientist in Avery Research Center, Avery Dennison Company, USA. While QFZ is working as a professor in the Department of Polymer Science and Engineering, Peking University, China.
Preface
xiii
This book consists of six chapters. The first chapter highlights the concept of liquid crystals, including chemical structure, phase classification, defect and texture, and continuum theory. This chapter is carefully prepared in order to meet the needs of readers who are not specialized in liquid crystals. The second chapter is associated with the theoretical descriptions of liquid crystalline polymers, networks, and gels which deal with subjects such as the formation of liquid crystallinity in polymer system, phase transition and phase diagram, the molecular weight effect, chain conformation, physics properties, etc. In Chapter 3, the molecular engineering of liquid crystalline polymers is introduced. The molecular composition and the molecular weight play essential roles in the molecular design, which are reviewed in detail. In addition, some unusual liquid crystalline polymers are discussed in the chapter. Chapter 4 is devoted to the phase identification of liquid crystalline polymers. The techniques involved cover polarizing microscopy, thermal analysis, X-ray diffraction and others. Chapters 5 and 6 summarize the properties and applications of liquid crystalline polymers. Chapter 5 deals mainly with mechanical performance in fiber and composites. Chapter 6 introduces the elasticity and viscosity and rheology of liquid crystalline polymers, as well as other important properties. XJW would like to thank Professor M. Warner who has been one of pioneers in the theoretical aspect of liquid crystalline polymers. The collaboration of XJW with Professor Warner has continued for more than a decade at Oxford and Cambridge, UK. Some contexts in Chapter 2 are in fact based on their joint research. Thanks are also due to Professors J. A. Zhao and A. J. Leadbetter for introducing him into this fascinating area when XJW studied liquid crystals in Tsinghua University, China, and the Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, UK. The assistance of C. H. Wang in the diagrams is also acknowledged by XJW. Special thanks of QFZ are given to Professors X. D. Feng, R. Y. Qian, R. W. Lenz, and J. I. Jin for introducing him into the sciences of polymer and polymeric liquid crystals. QFZ also acknowledges the assistance of D. Zhang, Y. G. Ma and X. H. Wan. Our families are worth special mention. We are indebted for their encouragement—that is what we need. Xin-Jiu Wang and Qi-Feng Zhou Pasadena, CA, USA, 2002
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 1
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
1.1.
LIQUID CRYSTAL STATES
As we know, there are three basic states of matter, solid, liquid, and gaseous states. These states of matter can be transformed into each other at appropriate conditions. In the solid state (generally meaning the crystalline state), the building blocks, such as atoms, or molecules, or clusters of molecules are packed closely and regularly, forming a crystal lattice. The X-ray diffraction of the state shows many regular diffraction spots. Over 95% of matter on the earth exist in the form of the crystalline state. The types of crystal structure are enormous. The physical properties of crystals are basically anisotropic. The crystals have a constant melting temperature (except for amorphous solids). Two different crystal planes make a constant angle. As the temperature of matter increases the thermal movement of atoms or molecules become so severe that the crystal lattice is dissolved and fluidity appears. At this temperature, matter does not have a regular shape and anisotropic properties any more. It becomes a liquid. In the liquid state, the atoms or molecules are no longer arranged in a regular order, but they are still bonded to each other tightly, though not in the tightest packing. Compared with the crystal state, the volume change of a liquid is not great but the liquid does not have a regular shape and can flow. Because of gravity the surface of liquids is usually flat. Increasing the temperature further up beyond the melting point, matter is transformed to the gaseous state. In the gaseous state, no short-range order exists. The interaction between the constituent molecules is extremely weak. Due to thermal excitation the molecules fill the container uniformly and hence the 1
2
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
gas no longer has a flat surface. Generally, as the temperature increases progressively, matter at first appears in the form of a crystal solid, and then a liquid and finally the gaseous state. Exceptionally, a few materials may be heated directly from the solid into the gas state, that is, by sublimation, such as for iodine. Conversely, some substances may be transformed directly from gas to solid, which is called sublimation as well. Water vapor condensing to ice is an example of sublimation. As the understanding about the states of matter became deeper, people had found that in addition to the above mentioned well-known three states, there exist other states of matter in nature, such as the plasma state, amorphous solid, liquid crystal state, superconductor, neutron state, etc. Among them the liquid crystal state is the subject of this book. The liquid crystal state is a kind of state whose order is between the crystal solid and isotropic liquid states. In the crystal state, there is a long range order in position and orientation, while in the liquid state there are no long range ordering in either of them. Figure 1.1 is a comparison of the crystal (a), the liquid crystal (b) and the liquid (c) states. The liquid crystal was once considered a rare state in the nature, but so far over eighty thousand liquid crystalline compounds have actually been found, making them a great family of matter. The discovery of the liquid crystal state should be traced back to a story taking place one hundred years ago. Austria botanist F. Reinitzer observed a peculiar phenomenon in 1888 — under a microscope (Reinitzer, 1888), cholesteryl nonanoate melted into a cloudy liquid at 145.5 ◦ C; as the temperature rose to 178.5 ◦ C, it suddenly became clear. When cooling down, the substance briefly appeared violet-blue just before becoming an
Figure 1.1.
The schematics of (a) crystal, (b) liquid crystal and (c) liquid.
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
3
opaque liquid, and then finally a white solid crystal. Reinitzer was puzzled about what he observed: why were there two melting points between the crystal (solid) and clear (liquid) states. He sent the sample together with his observation to German physicist Otto Lehmann who later made detailed observations by means of the polarizing microscope equipped with a heat stage. He at last concluded that cholesteryl nanonoate in the temperature range of 145.5 ◦ C and 178.5 ◦ C must be in a new state of matter. After a few years of hesitation, he finally named this state of matter, the liquid crystal (Lehmann, 1900). Later somebody proposed that the term “mesogenic state” might be an appropriate nomenclature for the new state, because it may avoid possible confusion. In spite of this problem, people have seemed to prefer the term liquid crystal due to its vivid description and the term liquid crystal has since been widely adopted, while the term mesogen or mesogenic is now used for a compound that is able to show the liquid crystal state. Contemporary knowledge tells us that cholesteryl nanonate actually exhibits two liquid crystal phases in the temperature range of 178.5 ◦ C and 145.5 ◦ C. As the temperature decreases, the first blue color is that of the blue phase of the liquid crystal, and the second violetblue color results from the cholesteric phase of the liquid crystal. More than twenty liquid crystal phases have since been discovered. The blue phase and cholesteric phase are two of them. One enlightenment that can be drawn from the discovery of the liquid crystal is that despite the fact that Reinitzer and Lehmann pursued different fields and were in different countries, the cooperation between them inaugurated a new field of science — the liquid crystal. Actually the whole development of the field of the liquid crystal has demonstrated this type of cooperation. As early as 1850, a German scientist discovered, in fact, the possibility of the liquid crystal when he found that natural fats exhibited two melting points. With increasing temperature, the substance starts to become cloudy at around 52 ◦ C and is completely opaque at 58 ◦ C, and then becomes clear at 62.5 ◦ C. This observation should be the earliest record of the “discovery” of the liquid crystal. At around the same time, the cholesterol derivative exhibited a striking color when it cooled from the isotropic liquid state. Unfortunately, these phenomena were not given enough attention or correctly explained. The researchers themselves did not realize that they were approaching the entrance of a new field of science. Therefore, the discovery of the liquid crystal should be attributed to Reinitzer and Lehmann.
4
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
1.2.
APPEARANCE AND LIGHT SCATTERING OF LIQUID CRYSTALS
The liquid crystal state is a state of matter which is different from the liquid and solid states. Liquid crystals can flow as a liquid does. Typically, the viscosity of the liquid crystals such as the nematic liquid crystal is in the order of magnitude of 1 × 10−2 Pa.s., a value greater than that of water whose viscosity is about 1 × 10−3 Pa.s. Some liquid crystals, such as high order modifications — smectic liquid crystals, are very viscous. A liquid is transparent, but a liquid crystal is normally milky. This is because the fluctuation of the orientation of the molecular long axes of the liquid crystals causes strong light scattering. The scattering of liquid crystals is as high as one million times that of conventional isotropic liquids. The milky appearance becomes one of the identifications of the liquid crystals. As we know, the scattering of matter is caused by the fluctuation of their refractive index (or optical dielectric constant). The local compression or dilution of mass density in bulk isotropic liquids modifies in turn the local refractive index. The change can be expressed in the form of the dielectric constant as ε(r) = ε + ε φ(r), (1.1) where ε is the average dielectric constant, φ(r) is the bulk compressibility and r is the distance vector of a point in the material, ε is the fluctuation of the dielectric constant. According to light scattering rules, the cross-section of light scattering of isotropic liquids, σI , is given by σI ∝ ε2 |φ(k)|2 ,
(1.2)
where φ(k) is the Fourier transformation of φ(r), and . . . indicates the statistical average. The average in the bracket can be written as |φ(k)2 | =
V kB T , B
(1.3)
where V is the volume of the sample, 1/B is the isothermal compressibility coefficient, and kB is the Boltzmann constant. Liquid crystals are optically anisotropic media with the exception of the cubic phases, such as the D-phase and blue phase. The refractive index or dielectric constant of liquid crystals varies according to the orientation of the molecular axes (or the optical axes). For example, the nematic liquid crystals are optically uniaxial and exhibit remarkable birefringence, that
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
5
is, their refractive indices of ordinary and extraordinary light, no and ne , are different. The difference of these two refractive indices, the birefringence denoted as ∆n = ne − no , is generally great, say, about 0.1. Due to the thermal fluctuation, the optical axes of nematic molecules always vary from point to point and from time to time. The effect of this phenomenon is much more significant than the density fluctuation. Little energy is required for causing the fluctuation of the optical axes of nematic molecules, so that the thermal fluctuation of the refractive index is significant even at the ambient temperature. This effect results in strong light scattering. The cross-section of light scattering in the nematics is expressed by σN ∝ ε2a |δn(k)|2 ,
(1.4)
where εa is the optical dielectric anisotropy (ε − ε⊥ ), i.e., the difference of dielectric constants parallel and perpendicular to the optical axis. δn(k) is the Fourier transformation of the optical axis fluctuation δn(r). The detailed calculation gives the statistical average of |δn(k)|2 as follows |δn(k)|2 ∝
V kB T , Kq 2
(1.5)
where K is an elastic constant associated with the change of optical axis. According to the estimate made by de Gennes (1973) K ∼ U/a and B ∼ U/a3 (a is the molecular dimension, about 1 nm, U is the binding energy), q is the difference between the incident and scattering wave-vectors of light. 2π/q is about the order of visible light’s wavelength. Suppose ε ∼ εa ∼ 1, thus the ratio of scattering cross-sections of nematic liquid crystal and isotropic liquid is ε 2 B σN 1 a ∝ · ≈ ≈ 105 –106 . (1.6) σI ε Kq 2 (aq)2 The ratio reaches up to one million times. This explains why the liquid crystal is in fact very turbid while ordinary liquid is transparent. The light scattering varies for different phases of the liquid crystals. For example, owing to the suppression of molecules into layers the light scattering of the smectic A phase is less than the nematic liquid crystal. For the smectic C phase, the fluctuation of the projection of tilted molecules onto smectic layers (the c-vector) causes stronger scattering than that in the smectic A phase. The above analysis is one example of the anisotropic properties of liquid crystals. It is these anisotropic properties that make liquid crystals and provide for its wide applications.
6
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
1.3. 1.3.1.
CHEMICAL STRUCTURE OF LIQUID CRYSTALS Basic molecular structure of rodic liquid crystals
Most liquid crystalline molecules are highly anisotropic, and to a good approximation they can be regarded as rigid rods or ellipsoids of revolution with lengths l greater than their widths d. The molecular weight ranges from a few hundreds Daltons for low molecular mass liquid crystals to hundreds of thousands Daltons for polymeric liquid crystals. The basic structure of low molecular mass liquid crystals or monomers of liquid crystalline polymers is schematically shown below
where X is a side group, R is a terminal group, A and B are aromatic rings, and H is a linking group. 1. Side group: The following side chains are extensively studied: alkyl group (Cn H2n+1 ); alkoxy group (Cn H2n+1 O) and alkenyl (Cn H2n−1 ) or alkenyloxy (Cn H2n−1 O) group. The length and flexibility of the side chain affect the type of liquid crystal phases and the phase transition. In general, for homologues, the compounds with small n show no mesogenic phase. As n increases, the monotropic liquid crystal phase appears. As n further increases the nematic phase occurs and thereafter smectic phases may appear. As n varies the even-odd alternation occurs: the compounds in odd carbon numbers in the side chains have the higher transition temperature whereas compounds in even numbers have lower transition temperatures. 2. Terminal group: The terminal group primarily contributes to the dielectric anisotropy and the refractive indices, which in turn affects the threshold voltage and optical properties in display applications, respectively. Common terminal groups are alkyl, alkoxy, cyano, nitro, isocyanate (NCS), sulfide and halides such as F, Cl, CF3 and OCF3 .
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
7
3. Aromatic rings: Most liquid crystal compounds consist of two or more aromatic rings. Those aromatic rings can be a totally saturated cyclohexane, a cyclocyclohexane, an unsaturated biphenyl, terphenyl, or combinations of them. Usually, the longer the ring, the higher the melting temperature. 4. Linking group: The linking group makes an important contribution to the phase transition and physical properties such as the birefringence. The following linking groups have been well studied (1) Saturated groups, such as ethylene (C2 H4 ) (2) Esters (3) Unsaturated groups containing a double bond or a triple bond such as stilbene, azoy, schiff base, tolane or acetylene, and diacetylene. 5. Lateral group: By substituting the hydrogen in the 2-, 3-, or 4-position of a phenyl ring by cyano, fluoro, or chloro polar group, one can modify the physical properties of liquid crystals. In most cases, the lateral substitution will broaden the molecule, thus reducing lateral attractions and lowering the nematic and smectic phase stability. Not only do the nature and size of the substitution affect the liquid crystal properties, but also the position of the group can have a significant effect. 6. Chiral center: Replace the terminal group by a chiral center and the chiral nematic and smectic phases can be obtained. The liquid crystal molecules or monomers are generally 2–4 nm in length and 0.4–0.6 nm in width. Experiments and theories demonstrate that for compounds showing the liquid crystal phase, their axial ratio or ratio of length to width (or to diameter) must be greater than a certain value, approximately 4. 1.3.2.
Discotic liquid crystals
Disc-like molecules may also exhibit the liquid crystal phase. de Gennes predicted this possibility in his famous book “The Physics of Liquid Crystals”
8
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
(1973). A few years later Chandrasekhar (1977) successfully synthesized this kind of discotic liquid crystal. There is a rigid flat aromatic core connected with 3, 4, 6, 8, 9 flexible side chains. Some examples of the discotic liquid crystal molecules are shown in Figure 1.2. Generally, the
Figure 1.2.
Examples of discotic liquid crystal molecules.
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
9
discotic liquid crystal molecules are about 1 nm in thickness and a few nm in diameter.
1.3.3.
Amphiphilic liquid crystals
Another important member of the liquid crystal family is the solution of amphiphilic molecules. The amphiphilic molecules are tadpole-like. A polar, hydrophilic group is at one end of the amphiphilic molecule while a nonpolar, hydrophobic group is at the other end. Two examples are shown in Figure 1.3. Soap in solution, for example, is a liquid crystal. One end of this molecule, –COO–Na+ is a polar group and is soluble in water, while the other end is a hydrocarbon paraffin group CH3 (CH2 )14 − , dissolved in water. The liquid crystalline materials exhibit the liquid crystal phase in different ways. Some of them exhibit the liquid crystal phase at a certain range of temperatures, while some exhibit the liquid crystal phase according to their concentration in solution. The former are called thermotropic liquid crystals, and the latter lyotropic liquid crystals. The –
+
O Na
C – C15 – H31 O
(a) +
–
CH3
O
CH3 –N–CH2 CH3
CH2
O O
O–P–O O
CH CH2
C
C – C15 H31 O
CH2
C – C15 H31 O
(b) Figure 1.3. Two amphiphilic liquid crystal molecules: (a) sodium laurate; (b) dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine. (From Collings, 1990.)
10
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
above-mentioned rod-like molecules are mainly thermotropic liquid crystals, and the amphiphilic molecules are lyotropic liquid crystals. But, very long, very rigid polymer solutions can exhibit the lyotropic liquid crystal phase. Liquid crystalline polymers are a kind of polymer that show liquid crystal phases. They are composed of low molecular mass liquid crystals, which can be either rod-like or disc-like, or rod- and disc-like together in one. The constituent blocks may be of very complicated two-dimensional or three dimensional shape. They may be composed of amphiphilic molecules as well. According to the way the mesogenic units are incorporated into the polymers, the liquid crystalline polymers can be classified as main chain liquid crystalline polymers in which the mesogenic units are connected in the backbone, or side chain liquid crystalline polymers in which the mesogenic units are attached to the backbone as side pendants. The mesogenic units may be incorporated in both ways, that is, a part as the backbone and the other part as side groups attached to the backbone. This kind of liquid crystalline polymer is called the combined liquid crystalline polymer. The side groups may be attached to the backbone through their centers (side-on mode or laterally attached), or through their ends (end-on or terminally attached), or off-center attached (shoulderly attached). Figure 1.4 depicts some examples of liquid crystalline polymers. Liquid crystalline polymers may be crosslinked to each other to form a network that retains the liquid crystal feature. The liquid crystal networks deform when a stress is applied as rubber does. They exhibit rubber elasticity. A typical example of a thermotropic liquid crystalline polymers is the polyesters and the mesogen substituted polysiloxane. The aromatic amide, the super strength fiber known commercially as Kevlar belongs to the lyotropic liquid crystalline polymers. The other important lyotropic liquid crystalline polymers are poly(γ-benzyl-L-glutamate), abbreviated as PBLG, cellulose derivatives, the tobacco mosaic virus, etc.
Figure 1.4.
The liquid crystalline polymers.
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
1.4.
11
POLYMORPHISM OF LIQUID CRYSTALS
MBBA, 4-methoxybenzylidene-4’-butylaniline was the first compound which showed the liquid crystal phase at room temperature. The chemical formulae of MBBA is as follows
MBBA shows only the nematic liquid crystal phase (denoted as N phase), its phase sequence being 47 20 I ←→ N ←→ K where I denotes the isotropic liquid phase, and K the crystal phase. The figures are the transition temperatures in degrees Celsius between adjacent phases. We will apply this expression when dealing with the phase sequences hereafter. A few liquid crystals have a more complicated phase behavior, showing more than one liquid crystal phase. The series of terephthalylidene-bisalkylanilines (TBnA) is particularly interesting in presenting an unusually broad polymorphism. For example, TPBA
has a phase sequence as follows 233
212
179
149
140
61
I ←→ N ←→ SA ←→ SC ←→ SF ←→ SG ←→ SH ←→ K, where SA , SC , SF , SG and SH denote the smectic A, smectic C, smectic F, smectic G and smectic H phases. Molecules with non-symmetric carbon atoms may exhibit a chiral structure, e.g., the compound (8SI) of chemical formulae
shows a phase sequence as follows I ←→ Ch ←→ SA ←→ SC ∗ ←→ SI ∗ ←→ SJ ∗ ←→ SG ∗ ←→ K,
12
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
where Ch or N* denotes the cholesteric phase, and SI , SJ are the smectic I and J phase. The asterisk denotes the counterpart chiral phases. The names smectic A, B, C, etc. were named purely in the chronological sequence in which the phases were discovered. The letter designation does not imply any information about the arrangement of the molecules, the symmetry, or other features. We now introduce the classification of the liquid crystal phases and their structural features. There are two fundamental orderings in the materials: positional order and orientational order. At low temperatures, matter exhibits a crystal state. The atoms or molecules are arranged regularly and periodically. Both position and orientation exhibit a long range order. When heated, matter may become an isotropic liquid through two ways, by losing the orientational order first while retaining the translational order, and hence becoming a plastic crystal, or alternatively, by losing the translational order while keeping the orientational order. These latter materials are liquid crystals. In fact, with increasing temperature, these materials may not completely lose their translational order while retaining their orientational order. All liquid crystals are characterized by their orientational order, but liquid crystal phases show varying amounts of translational order with the only exception of nematics. Apart from the above basic symmetries, there is another important symmetry — bond orientation symmetry. This symmetry is important when dealing with hexatic phases. Liquid crystals are classified in terms of following criterion: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
translational order bond orientational order correlation between smectic layers with chirality? cubic structure?
1.4.1.
No translational order — Nematics
The nematic liquid crystal, N phase, is the only liquid crystal phase without any long range translational order. Nematics are the most important member in the family of the liquid crystals and are widely used in the display industry. In nematics, the molecules tend to be parallel to each other. The preferred direction of parallel orientation is characterized by the director,
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
13
n
Figure 1.5.
The nematic liquid crystals.
denoted by a unit vector n. The director n actually has the up and down symmetry. The nematic liquid crystal is shown in Figure 1.5. This phase has a symmetrical axis C∞ along the director. In addition, there is a reflection-symmetry plane perpendicular to the axis C∞ and a mirror-symmetry plane through the C∞ axis. Therefore, the local symmetry of nematics can be expressed by the D∞h group. Of course, nematics have three dimensional translational symmetry. The structural factor of the nematic phase reflects the breaking of the rotational symmetry. The large X-ray scattering angle sphere (short distance) shrinks toward the circle perpendicular to the director while the small scattering angle intensity is compressed along the n axis. There are two X-ray diffuse spots at q = q0 n with q0 = 2π/l (l the molecular length) and two diffuse rings around q = q1 n × k with approximately q1 = 2π/a (a the distance between neighboring molecules).
1.4.2.
One-dimensional translational order — Smectic A and C phases
As the temperature is further cooled, the molecules begin to segregate into planes giving rise to a smectic A or smectic C phase. In addition to the orientational order that the nematic phase shows, the smectic A and C phases exhibit a one-dimensional translational order, and can therefore form layered structures. There is a liquid-like motion of the rods in each layer and no correlation of the molecular positions from one layer to the next. In each layer, the mass centers of the molecules are randomly distributed as
14
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
n
n
Figure 1.6.
The smectic A and C phases.
in isotropic liquids. The layers can easily slide. The molecular arrangement in the smectic A and C phases are schematically shown in Figure 1.6. In the smectic A phase, molecules tend to be perpendicular to the smectic layers. The layer thickness d is roughly the same as the molecular length l. The thickness of the layers in the case of liquid crystalline polymers is about the order of the monomer’s length. But in the smectic C phase, the molecules in the layers are parallel and tilted in arrangement with respect to the normal of the layers by a tilt angle θ. The layer thickness of the smectic C phase is d = l cos θ. The ordering of the smectic A and C phases are both higher than the nematic phase so that they appear at a lower temperature than the nematics do. The smectic A phase appears first as the temperature decreases if a compound shows both the smectic A and C phases. The positional correlation in the smectic A phase can be described as a sinusoidal modulation of the average mass density n(r) = n0 + 2nq0 cos(q0 z),
(1.7)
where q0 = 2π/l and the z axis is along the layer normal. The Fourier transformation of this function leads to two Bragg peaks away from q = 0 in the structural factor: S(q) ∝ |nq0 |2 [δ(qz − q0 ez ) + δ(qz + q0 ez )].
(1.8)
The thermal fluctuations destroy the ideal long-range periodic order of the smectic phase and there are power-law singularities rather than the
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
15
delta function in S(q) at q = ±q0 ez . Thus, the peaks in the smectic structural factor are called quasi-Bragg peaks, and the smectics are thus said to be characterized by quasi-long-range order (QLRO) in one dimensional position rather than a true long-range order (LRO). As the smectic phase is approached on cooling from the nematic phase, the diffuse spots in the nematic structural factor are sharpened and eventually become the quasiBragg peaks of the smectic phase. The experimental structural factor of the smectic phase has basically confirmed the expectation in Equation (1.8) which has only two quasi-Bragg peaks (at ±q0 ). The local symmetry of smectic A phase is the same as that of the nematics, i.e., its point group is D∞h , while the symmetry of the smectic C phase is C2h (a C2 symmetry axis plus a reflection plane perpendicular to the axis). In addition, both smectic phases exhibit a one-dimension translational order. Owing to the difference in symmetry, the smectic phases show different optical properties. The smectic A phase is optically uniaxial, but the smectic C phase is optically biaxial.
1.4.3.
Two-dimensional translational order within layers with weak correlation along the third dimension — Hexatic phases
There are the smectic B, F and I phases belonging to this kind of liquid crystal, the so-called hexatic phase. The newly discovered smectic M phase is also catalogued to the hexatic liquid crystal phase. These hexatic phases have a six-fold symmetry which can be observed from the X-ray scattering intensity at q = 2π/a. In addition to the one-dimensional order which forms the layer structure, there is a two-dimensional translational order within the layers. The molecules of this class of liquid crystals are arranged into a hexatic lattice with a correlation length of tens of nm that is one order of magnitude higher than that in the SA and SC phases within layers. In addition, there is two dimensional, long range bond symmetry. In the literature, the SB , SF , SI phases are sometimes called stack hexatic phases. Assuming θ is the angle that the vector connecting neighboring molecules makes with respect to the x-axis, the hexatic order is defined by Ψ6 = exp(6iθ).
(1.9)
16
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
b
a
b a
(a)
Figure 1.7.
(b)
(c)
The smectic liquid crystal (a) B, (b) F and (c) I phases.
The Fourier transformation of the smectic B phase is characterized by its six-fold bond-orientational order, expressed as a Fourier series in χ S(q) =
S6p (q , q⊥ ) cos(6pχ).
(1.10)
p
There is a long-range orientational order in the plane but no long-range positional order. In the smectic B phase, only the first harmonic S6 (q , q⊥ ) is significant. As the temperature is further reduced to that of the smectic crystalline L phase, which is going to be mentioned in a later section, more and more harmonics in χ become important. Figure 1.7 schematizes the three phases. In the hexatics, there is no chemical bond between neighboring molecules. The hexatic bond order can be viewed as resulting from the loss of the long-range positional but not orientational order of a hexagonal crystal. The molecular tilt order of the smectic C phase can coexist with the hexatic order, leading to smectic F and I phases depicted in Figure 1.7. In the smectic B phase, the molecules within the layers are aligned perpendicularly to the layers, but the molecules of the SF and SI phases within layers are tilted with respect to the layer normal by a tilt angle. The azimuthal of the tilt direction or the projections onto the smectic layers of the SF and SI phases are different. In the former, the projections of molecules onto the layer point to the edge of the hexatic, while in the latter, to the apex. The difference seems not so significant, but SF and SI liquid crystals are not miscible, and there is a phase transition between them when the temperature varies. The SB phase can be regarded as a hexatic structure. SF and SI phases have the base-centered monoclinic structure in the nomenclature
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
17
of crystallography even though the correlation between layers in these two smectic phases is weak. The smectic M phase, discovered in 1990, may be classified as a hexatic phase. The molecules are tilted within layers but are not miscible with the SF and SI phases. The structural details are under investigation.
1.4.4.
Three-dimensional translational order but correlation is weaker than that in crystals
This class of liquid crystals includes the smectic liquid crystal L, G, and J phases, and the higher ordered ones: the smectic liquid crystal E, H, and K phases. Compared with the previously mentioned class of liquid crystals, SB , SF , SI , and SM , this class of liquid crystals exhibits a stronger correlation between smectic layers, the correlation length ranging from tens to hundreds of layers. The way of stacking of successive layers may be either AAA . . . , ABABAB . . . . or ABCABC . . . . These six smectic liquid crystals are actually very similar to real crystals, but they do exhibit a significant disorder in both translation and orientation. Dynamic experiments demonstrated that they exhibit rather different characteristics from real crystals, such as the dielectric relaxation and the Mossbauer spectrum. The X-ray diffraction of these liquid crystals shows reflections of only less than five orders. In addition, as the transition to a real crystal happens, a relatively large amount of transition enthalpy and volume change occurs. These variations are in general one order of magnitude greater than those transitions occurring between liquid crystals. In the SL phase, the molecules are perpendicular to layers and are arranged in a hexatic lattice within layers. This symmetry is the same as that of the SB phase. Both of the SL and SB phases are optically uniaxial, their molecules within smectic layers rotate more freely around their long axes or rotate in groups simultaneously. In some of the literature, the SB phase is called the hexatic B phase while the SL phase is named the SB phase or crystal B phase. The molecules within the SG and SI phases are tilted with respect to the layers while the molecules of the SL phase are aligned more or less perpendicularly to the layers. The stacking of molecules within the layer of the SL , SG and SJ phases is similar to those shown in Figure 1.7 as well. The crystallography classifications of these three liquid crystal phases are the same as those of the SB , SF and SI phases.
18
Liquid Crystalline Polymers b a a b
(a) H
(b) K
(c) E
Figure 1.8.
The smectic (a) H, (b) K and (c) E phases.
The structural relation of the SG and SJ phases with the SL phase is similar to that in the hexatic series, i.e. of the SF and SI phases with the SB phase. The molecules of the SE phase within the smectic layers tend to be perpendicular to the smectic layers, but they are unable to rotate freely with respect to the long molecular axis. This phenomenon has been verified by X-ray diffraction experiments that demonstrated that the packing of molecules within layers in the SE phase is too close for them to rotate freely. Incoherent quasi-elastic neutron scattering has illustrated that the molecules of the SE phase can vibrate at a frequency of 1011 Hz within a 180 degree range. Only those molecules with enough energy can go over the energy barrier from one hemi-circle to the other hemi-circle. The molecular packing within the SE layer is schematically shown in Figure 1.8. In order to demonstrate that the molecules cannot rotate freely they are depicted as ellipses in the figure where the cross-section of the molecules are arranged herringbone-like. The SE phase is of a monoclinic structure. The SH and SK phases differ from the SE phase only in their tilted molecules within the layers. The molecules of the SH phase are tilted to the
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
19
edge of the hexatic while in SK phase to the apex. Both of the SH and SK phases are of a monoclinic structure.
1.4.5. 1.4.5.1.
Chiral liquid crystals Cholesterics
In this liquid crystal phase, the molecules have non-symmetrical carbon atoms and thus lose mirror symmetry. Otherwise optically active molecules are doped into host nematogenic molecules to induce the chiral liquid crystals. The liquid crystals consisting of such molecules show a helical structure. The most important chiral liquid crystal is the cholesteric liquid crystals. As discussed in Section 1.2, the cholesteric liquid crystal was the first discovered liquid crystal and is an important member of the liquid crystal family. In some of the literature, it is denoted as the N* phase, the chiral nematic liquid crystal. As a convention, the asterisk is used in the nomenclature of liquid crystals to mean the chiral phase. Cholesteric liquid crystals have beautiful and interesting optical properties, e.g., the selective reflection of circularly polarized light, significant optical rotation, circular dichroism, etc. The molecules in cholesteric liquid crystals are arranged as thin layers. The molecules lie in the layers and are parallel to each other, but the director rotates along the helical axis continuously and uniformly. The helical pitch is much greater than the spacing of successive molecular layers. In general the helical pitch of cholesteric liquid crystals is of the order of visible light’s wavelength — about a few hundreds nm. The pitch of those cholesteric liquid crystals induced by doping with optically active molecules is larger, e.g., up to a few microns. A schematic of cholesteric liquid crystals is illustrated in Figure 1.9. 1.4.5.2.
Chiral smectic liquid crystals
Almost all the smectic phases, in which the molecules are arranged in layers and are tilted with respect to the layers, have counterpart chiral phases. The most important one of this class is the chiral smectic C phase — SC∗ phase. In these chiral liquid crystal phases, the molecules are tilted at a constant angle with respect to the layer normal but the tilt azimuthal rotates uniformly along the chiral axis and forms a helical structure.
20
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Pitch
Figure 1.9.
The cholesteric liquid crystal.
The local symmetry group of the SC ∗ phase is a C2 group and thus the SC ∗ phase has helical electricity. The spontaneous polarization, Ps , is perpendicular to the layer normal and molecular axis. Due to its helical structure Ps changes its direction uniformly, evolving along the helical axis so that the SC ∗ phase does not show a measurable ferroelectricity except in the unwinding of its helical structure. The SC ∗ phase is one of the very important liquid crystal phases that has a prospective application in fast response display. The detailed structure of the SC ∗ phase will be shown in Chapter 6. Once the helical structure of the SC ∗ phase is unwound, ferroelectricity is displayed (see Chapter 6 for the details). In recent years, many experimental studies have revealed that some liquid crystal compounds show new types of smectic phases with complex tilt and dipole order, such as the antiferroelectric smectic C phase, SCA ∗ phase, and the ferrielectric smectic C phase, SCγ ∗ phase. For instance, in the SCA ∗ phase, the spontaneous polarization Ps is opposite for successive layers. It was found experimentally that the chiral SO phase is in fact similar to the anti-ferroelectric SCA ∗ phase. The twisted-grain-boundary phase, TGB (Renn and Lubensky, 1988) was discovered recently in which topological defects create a new symmetry rather than simply destroy the old one. It occurs in some chiral liquid crystals (Goodby et al., 1988) and is characterized by an array of equally spaced twist-grain boundaries in the smectic A or C liquid crystal as shown in Figure 1.10. In this phase, the average director twists like a cholesteric while regularly spaced molecular planes are configurated like a smectic. One
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
21
Helix Direction
Screw Dislocations Grain Boundaries
Molecules
Smectic Layers
Figure 1.10. The TGB phase of liquid crystals. (From Goodby et al., 1993. Reproduced by permission of Taylor & Francis,
)
would reasonably expect it to appear between the cholesteric and smectic A, or smectic C phases. 1.4.6. 1.4.6.1.
Cubic phases D phase
The D phase is the one cubic liquid crystal phase which was discovered independently in 1957 by G. Gray (Gray et al., 1957) and D. Demus (1957) when they were studying the following compounds
where R is either −NO2 or −CN, and n = 16 or 18. These compounds display a phase between the SA (or N) and SC phase and were called the Smectic D, SD phase. Actually the D phase does not have a layered structure that is characteristic of all smectic phases. The structure has been studied in detail by Etherington et al. (Etherington et al., 1985, 1986) through X-ray diffraction, a second-harmonic-generation experiment and modeling. The space group and molecular packing of the phase was proposed. It was thus suggested that it was better to call the SD phase the D phase.
22
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
The D phase had been found in only four compounds until recently (Paschke et al., 1994). The four compounds are the 16 and 18 members of the 4 -n-alkoxy-3 -nitrobiphenyl-4-carboxylic acids (AnBC) synthesized by Gray et al. in 1957 and the n = 16 and 18 members of the analogous 3 -cyano compounds (ACBC) prepared by Goodby and Gray (1980). Detail experiments (Etherington et al., 1985, 1986) verified that the compound (CN:18) is of space group P23 or Pm3, and is optically isotropic with no apparent optical rotation. Recently, Paschke et al. (1994) found that the D phase appears in more members of the above series of cyano compounds with n = 15 to 22. The temperature range of the D phase becomes wider as n increases. 1.4.6.2.
Another D-like cubic phase
Later Demus et al. (1984) found that the following compounds exhibits the cubic phase as well
where n ≥ 8. The cubic phase appears at a temperature below the SC phase and is not miscible with the above D phase. Recently some CN-substituted analogous compounds were found to show this phase. It is clear that the cubic unit cell is very large and accommodates more than 100 molecules. It can be assumed that the molecules are aligned in parallel in micelles or in bundles, and the preferred direction is randomly oriented in dynamic equilibrium. The lattice elements form a three-dimensional cubic lattice with a long-range order. The molecular packing and the mechanism of phase transition of the cubic phases have been attracting much research interest worldwide. 1.4.6.3.
Blue phase
Some cholesteric materials show the blue phase as the temperature increases from that of the cholesteric phase and before it reaches that of the isotropic phase. The blue phase is a cubic phase. There have been three blue phases found so far: BP I, BP II and BP III phases. It is now understood that the BP I phase is a body-centered cubic, the BP II phase is a primitive cubic and the BP III phase is a fog phase with no structural symmetry. Generally the temperature range of the blue phase is quite narrow, less than 1 degree
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
23
centigrade. The blue phase possesses a helical structure and its pitch is less than that of the corresponding cholesteric phase. It is optically isotropic, but with remarkable optical activity. The molecules in the blue phase are packed into a double helical structure. The networks of defects is believed to play an important role in constructing the structure. The blue phase has a similar structure to that of the D phase, in spite of the remarkable difference in the lattice parameter. The lattice parameter of the former is hundreds of nm while that of the latter is less than 10 nm. In general, if all the liquid crystal phases would exist together for a particular material, the phase sequence would be as follows I ←→ N ←→ BP ←→ Ch ←→ SA ←→ D ←→ SC ←→ SB ←→ SI ←→ SL ← → SF ←→ SJ ←→ SG ←→ SE ←→ SK ←→ SH ←→ K.
The chiral counterparts should appear in the sequence immediately following their non-chiral phases i.e., at a lower temperature. The re-entrant phase is an exception. They may appear in reverse order, e.g., as temperature decreases the re-entrant nematic phase appears at a temperature lower than that for the SA phase N ←→ SA ←→ Nre ←→ SAre , where Nre and SAre are the re-entrant N and SA phase, respectively. Only those liquid crystal materials with strong polar group are able to show the re-entrant phases.
1.4.7.
Discotic liquid crystals
The liquid crystals discussed so far are composed of rod-like molecules. As discussed in the last section, disc-like molecules may show liquid crystal phases and are called discotic liquid crystals. The first discotic liquid crystal was synthesized by Chandrasekhar (1977) and many more discotic liquid crystals have since been discovered. The simplest discotic liquid crystal phase is the nematic discotic phase, ND , in which the normals of the molecular discs tend to align with respect to a preferred direction, i.e., the director, but the mass centers of molecules do not have any positional order. The discs in Figure 1.11 represent the disclike molecules, the molecules are packed in the way a pile of coins is packed randomly. The discotic nematic phase has its chiral counterpart, i.e., the
24
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
(a)
Figure 1.11.
(b)
The discotic nematic (a) and column phases (b).
Figure 1.12.
An example of a typical disc-like molecule.
ND ∗ phase. A phase similar to the rod-like smectic liquid crystal phase is the column phase in which molecules are packed as columns parallel to each other. The columns are arranged in a hexatic or rectangular array. Inside the columns, the spacings of the molecules are either constant or random. The axes of the columns may be tilted with respect to the normal of discotic molecules. Figure 1.12 sketches the chemical formulae of one example of a discotic liquid crystal molecule. There is another class of liquid crystals, the bowlic liquid crystal phase, whose molecules are bowl-like or pyramid-like, as is shown in Figure 1.13. Because of the breaking down of the up-down symmetry, the bowlic phase shows an even higher order and may be able to show ferroelectricity (Lam, 1986; Wang et al., 1989).
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
R R
R
R
R
25
R
R = C9H19COO R = C11H23COO R = C12H25O
Figure 1.13.
COO
A bowlic liquid crystal molecule.
1.4.8.
Lyotropic liquid crystals
1.4.8.1.
Amphiphilic liquid crystals
Liquid crystal phases also appear in response to changes in the concentration of water, oil, surfactants, or other species in a wide variety of molecular mixtures. These are called lyotropic liquid crystals. When amphiphilic molecules dissolve in water, their polar heads tend to be close to each other while the non-polar hydrophobic tails are as far away from water as possible. Depending on the concentration, the amphiphilic molecules aggregate to form spheres, or columns, or a laminar structure, see Figure 1.14. In Figure 1.14 the tadpoles represent amphiphilic molecules, and the solid circles are the polar heads of amphiphilic molecules, i.e., the hydrophilic parts, while the zig-zag lines are the hydrophobic groups. The typical phase diagram is depicted in Figure 1.15. As the concentration increases, the amphiphilic molecules form micelles and then form columns. The columns are arranged into a hexatic array. As the concentration further increases, the system forms a laminar structure, i.e., a smectic liquid crystal phase. Sometimes, a cubic phase may appear between the micelle and hexatic phases. In fact, the micelles are packed to form a cubic phase. The three phases are all liquid crystal phases: hexatic phase, laminar phase and cubic phase. As seen in the figure, the phase diagram of amphiphilic molecules actually depends on the temperature as well. TK in Figure 1.15 is the Kraft temperature, below which the system is phase separated into crystal and water.
26
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 1.14.
1.4.8.2.
The amphiphilic liquid crystals. (From Collings, 1990.)
Lyotropic liquid crystals consisting of long rigid molecules
A few non-amphiphilic molecules are able to show liquid crystallinity in solution at a certain range of concentration, such as PBLG, DNA, the tobacco mosaic virus, etc. They are of great molecular mass, very rigid, rod-like and have a very long anisotropic shape. They are typical macromolecules and are lyotropic liquid crystals. This class of liquid crystals does not aggregate to form sphere, column or laminar structures. These lyotropic systems depend on the properties of the solvent. They are one of major interest of this book and will be discussed in detail later. 1.4.9.
Induced liquid crystals
Some materials are themselves not liquid crystals, or do not display the liquid crystal phase at a certain temperature or solvent concentration. But,
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
Figure 1.15. 1990.)
27
The typical phase diagram of amphiphilic molecules. (From Collings,
they may become liquid crystals when subjected to certain external conditions, such as pressure, electric field, magnetic field, irradiation, etc. The liquid crystal phase may also be induced when two non-liquid crystalline materials are mixed together.
1.5. 1.5.1.
CONTINUUM THEORY OF LIQUID CRYSTALS Order parameter
The atoms in crystals are not always fixed in a perfectly ordered position except at the absolute temperature! Due to the thermal movement, atoms more or less deviate from their equilibrium position. For the same reason, the orientational order in liquid crystals is not perfect either. Because of the thermal fluctuation, the orientation and position of liquid crystals vary constantly. If the positions and orientations of liquid crystal molecules are frozen at a moment in time, the picture should look like that shown in Figure 1.5. The molecules tend to align along a preferred direction, but imperfectly. This preferred direction is defined as the director n. Because the molecules are moving all the time, they are not fixed at a constant
28
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
position and do not point in a constant direction, although they have a greater chance of orienting along the director. In other words, at a certain moment more molecules are oriented along the director than otherwise. How close are the molecules aligned along the director? A parameter is needed to quantitatively describe the extent of the molecules’ being oriented along the director. This statistical quantity is the order parameter, denoted conventionally as S. Because the liquid crystals are up and down symmetrical, obviously cos θ (θ is the angle the molecular long axis makes with respect to the director) is not an appropriate candidate for the order parameter. What if cos2 θ is adopted? If so, for perfect alignment, the order parameter S = 1; but for the disordered distribution S = 1/3. For the sake of convenience, it is hoped that for the random distribution, i.e., the isotropic phase, S = 0, and for the perfect orientation, S = 1. Therefore, the statistical average of the second Legendre polynomial P2 is chosen as the order parameter S = P2 (cos ϑ) =
3 2
cos2 θ −
1 2
.
(1.11)
If the liquid crystalline molecules are not cylindrically symmetrical, S must be expressed by a tensor (traceless tensor). The nematic liquid crystal state (a uniaxial symmetrical system) is the main concern of the book. For such a phase, the order parameter can be denoted by the scalar in Equation 1.11. The order parameter S is a very important quantity in a partially ordered system. It is the measure of the extent of the anisotropy of the liquid crystal physical properties, e.g., elastic constants, viscosity coefficients, dielectric anisotropy, birefringence, and so on. S is temperature dependent and decreases as the temperature increases. The typical temperature dependence of S is shown in Figure 1.16. As the temperature reaches the clear point Tc or isotropization temperature Ti , S jumps abruptly down to zero. The phenomenon implies that the nematic-isotropic transition is of first order. The combination of S and n appropriately describes the ordering of liquid crystals. S is the microscopic feature of molecular orientation while n is the macroscopic characteristic of liquid crystal orientation. In general, the molecular dimension of liquid crystals is about a few nm in length and a few tenth of a nm in width. The range of variation of n(r) is in the order of the magnitude of microns. n(r) is in fact the average orientation of a
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
29
S
1.0
0.5
0 T
Figure 1.16.
TC
The order parameter versus temperature.
small bulk sample of a hundred of thousand molecules, whose scale is much greater than the molecular dimension. When dealing with the orientational distortions and defects in liquid crystals, the analysis of n(r) is appropriate.
1.5.2.
Distortions of liquid crystals
The liquid crystals can be deformed by applying external fields. Even a small electric or magnetic field, shear force, surface anchoring, etc., is able to make significant distortion or deformation to liquid crystals. Thus, n is actually a function of position r. According to the symmetry of liquid crystals there exist three kinds of deformations in liquid crystals: splay, twist and bend deformations, shown in Figure 1.17. The short bars in the figure represent the projections of the local directors. The three kinds of deformations are associated with the variation of n, i.e. ∇n. For the splay deformation, the divergence of the n vectors, ∇ · n, is not zero; for the twist deformation, n · ∇ × n = 0, and for the bend deformation, n × ∇ × n = 0. In order to describe the meaning of the three formulae, it is supposed that in the undeformed sample, n points along the z direction. These three deformations can hence be written in the form of components as follows ∂nx ∂ny + , ∂x ∂y
∂ny ∂nx , − ∂x ∂y
∂ny ∂nx j. i+ ∂z ∂z
(1.12)
30
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
(a)
Figure 1.17. (c) bend.
(b)
(c)
Three basic deformations in liquid crystals: (a) splay; (b) twist and
The strain increases the energy of the solid as a stress is applied. The distortion of the director in liquid crystals causes an additional energy in a similar way. The energy is proportional to the square of the deformations and the correspondent coefficients are defined as the splay elastic constant, K11 , twisted elastic constant K22 and bend elastic constant K33 , i.e., the respective energies are the half of K11 (∇ · n)2 ;
K22 (n · ∇ × n)2 ;
K33 (n × ∇ × n)2 .
(1.13)
These three elastic modulii are different in liquid crystals. Generally, K11 and K33 are greater than K22 , which implies that the twist deformation is the easiest one to occur. K33 is the largest constant for rod-like polymers while for semi-flexible polymers in a concentrated solution and for thermotropic polymers K11 is usually the largest. K22 for liquid crystalline polymers is about the same in values as those for small molecular mass liquid crystals. But the above conclusion is not always valid. Kii (i = 1, 2, 3) are functions of the temperature. The ratios between them varies with temperature. For example, at temperatures near the transition to the SA phase, K22 may become the greatest term of the three elastic constants. The three elastic constants are all small, that is the reason why liquid crystals deform easily. For the liquid crystal compound MBBA, the three elastic constants at 20 ◦ C are: K11 = 5.8 × 10−12 N, K22 = 3.3 × 10−12 N and K33 = 7.0 × 10−12 N. The reorientation of the liquid crystal as a bulk does not give off energy and the spatial orientation of liquid crystals may be determined by an electric or a magnetic field, or by surface alignment agents (SiO, lecithin, B-L films, etc.), or by a surface rubbing polyimide and so on. The elasticity theory of liquid crystals was proposed by Oseen (1933) and Zocher (1933), and then modified by Frank into the form that has since
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
31
been accepted (1958). According to the Frank theory, the elastic energy of a deformed nematic liquid crystal can be expressed as 1 F = F0 + d3 r[K11 (∇ · n)2 + K22 (n · ∇ × n)2 2 V + K33 (n × ∇ × n)2 ],
(1.14)
where F0 is the constant term for an undeformed sample. Because of the spontaneously helical structure in the cholesteric liquid crystals, the second term in the integral must be revised to 2 1 2π K22 n · ∇ × n + , (1.15) 2 P0 where P0 is the intrinsic helical pitch. The supplement favors the molecular twist. The form illustrates that without an external field, the director of liquid crystals is naturally twisted with the period of the helix being the pitch P0 . The form of free energy for smectic liquid crystals is different. If there are no defects in the smectic liquid crystals, the curl of n, ∇ × n, must be zero. Thus, no twist and bend deformations exist in the smectic liquid crystals. In addition, there is an energy penalty associated with the translational deformation. For example, the displacement of smectic layer u will cause an additional term of elastic energy 2 du 1 B , (1.16) 2 dz where B is the elastic modulus, assuming that the z axis is perpendicular to the layers for the undeformed sample. The elasticity theory has been used in dealing for example with the response of liquid crystals to external fields (electric, magnetic, mechanical force), defects, etc. The above argument is suitable for polymer liquid crystals as well. In fact, the static properties of polymer liquid crystals are basically the same as those for the low molecular mass liquid crystals. But their dynamics are quite different because of their polymeric structure. 1.5.3.
Frederiks transitions
We now apply the elasticity theory of liquid crystals to analyze the deformation of liquid crystals under an external magnetic field.
32
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
H < Hc
H > Hc
+
+
H < Hc
H > Hc
H < Hc
H > Hc
(I)
(II)
(III)
Figure 1.18. The Frederiks transitions I, II and III. The arrows represents the direction of the applied magnetic field H .
A sheet of nematic liquid crystals sandwiched between two parallel glass plates that have been surface treated to align the liquid crystal molecules on the glass plates in the homogeneous configuration is shown in Figure 1.18(I). The applied magnetic field H is perpendicular to the director. Because the nematic liquid crystals are paramagnetic, without surface anchoring the liquid crystal molecules would all be reoriented along the magnetic field. In the presence of surface anchoring, the competition between surface anchoring and the external magnetic field will cause the director of the liquid crystal to undergo a deformation. The magnetic contribution to the free energy density of the liquid crystal has the form 1 χa (n · H)2 , (1.17) − 2 where χa is the anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility. Then the free energy of the liquid crystal is 1 d3 r[K11 (∇ · n)2 F = 2 V + K22 (n · ∇ × n)2 + K33 (n × ∇ × n)2 − χa (n · H)2 ].
(1.18)
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
33
Using a coordinate system with the z axis along the H direction and the x axis along the n direction of the undeformed sample, the director is written as n = (cos θ, 0, sin θ), and the magnetic field as H = (0, 0, H). Substituting n and H into Equation 1.18, the free energy of a unit area of a liquid crystal sheet of thickness d, Fs is 2 dθ 1 d/2 2 2 [(K11 cos θ + K33 sin θ) − χa H 2 sin2 θ]dz. (1.19) Fs = dz 2 −d/2 It is noted that there is no twisted deformation in liquid crystals, thus the K22 term does not appear in Fs . If the deformation is not so great, the splay deformation is dominant. When the deformation becomes greater, the bend deformation becomes more important. The free energy is at its minimum when the liquid crystal is at equilibrium. One can obtain the minimum by means of the Euler-Lagrange functional method. From the symmetry of the liquid crystal layer the following boundary condition exists z = ±d/2, θ = 0; and
dθ = 0, dz where θm is the deformation angle of the liquid crystal director at the midplane of the sample, and, in fact, is the maximum deformation angle of the sample. By substituting them into the Euler-Lagrange differential equation, the dependence of θm on the external magnetic field can be implicitly expressed as θm K11 cos2 θ + K33 sin2 θ Hd √ dθ = χa · . (1.20) 2 2 2 sin θm − sin θ 0 z = 0,
θ = θm
and
As θm approaches zero, the magnetic threshold field H c is then given by
π K11 . (1.21) Hc = d χa
34
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Since the applied magnetic field H is less than H c no deformation occurs. If H is greater than H c , θm depends on the value of H. The elastic constant K11 may be determined through measuring Hc . The ratio of K11 to K33 can be evaluated from the curve of θm versus H, or accordingly from the transmittance versus H or the electric capacitance versus H. The reorientation of liquid crystals in this geometrical arrangement is named Frederiks transition I (Frederiks & Zolina, 1933). By appropriately designing the alignment of undeformed liquid crystals and the direction of the magnetic field, as shown in Figure 1.18 II and III, the Frederiks transition II and III occur. From them, K22 and K33 can be determined through the magnetic threshold field. In fact, K22 is more difficult to measure than K11 and K33 . The Frederiks transition may also occur when an electric field is applied instead. Because of the large dielectric anisotropy of liquid crystals, the electric threshold field is very small, about 0.1 volt/micron. In the above argument, the formulae are valid as long as the liquid crystal sample is pure enough, otherwise the conduction effect will cause other effects.
1.5.4.
The twisted — and supertwisted — nematic liquid crystals
The twisted nematic (TN) and supertwisted nematic (STN) liquid crystals are widely used in liquid crystal displays. The former is used in wrist watches and calculators while the latter is used in notebook computers. The TN cell is schematically shown in Figure 1.19. The liquid crystal sandwiched between two indium-tin-oxide (ITO) coated glass plates is about a few microns in thickness. The liquid crystal molecules on the top and bottom plates are homogeneously aligned and twisted by an angle of π/2. The liquid crystal molecules have a positive dielectric anisotropy εa > 0 so that an electric field will rotate the liquid crystal director up. The threshold voltage is given by Vc = π
K11 +(K33 −2K22 ) 4
εa
.
(1.22)
Vc is typically of order of one volt. Now, polarizers are mounted on the top and bottom glass plates such that their polarization directions are along or normal to the neighboring liquid crystal molecules on both plates. When
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
35
2 P2 n^ 2 d
V
Twist angle n^ 1
P1
1 Figure 1.19. The twisted nematic cell. The twist angle θ = π/2 and the two polars make an angle Ψ = 0 or π/2.
the voltage is off, the cell is transparent. When the voltage is on, the cell becomes dark. STN has a twist angle greater than 180 degrees and its electric-optical response is much steeper so that they can be driven in the multiplexing displays such as those found in the SVGA format color notebook computers. 1.6.
DEFECTS IN LIQUID CRYSTALS
The local translational and orientational order of atoms or molecules in a sample may be destroyed by singular points, lines or walls. The discontinuities associated with the translational order are the dislocations while the defects associated with the orientational order are the disclinations. Another kind of defect, dispirations, are related to the singularities of the chiral symmetry of a medium. The dislocations were observed long after the research on them began. The dislocations in crystals have been extensively studied because of the requirement in industry for high strength materials. On the contrary, the first disclination in liquid crystals was observed as early as when the liquid crystal was discovered in 1888, but the theoretical treatment on disclinations was quite a recent endeavor. There is only the orientational order in nematics so that only disclinations may appear with no dislocations. In the other kinds of liquid crystals,
36
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
the dislocation may appear because of the discontinuity of the translational order. 1.6.1.
The Volterra process
Both dislocation and disclination can be produced by the well-known Volterra process. Take a cylinder of a medium and do the following operations in sequence on it: (1) cut off a thin cylinder of diameter rc along the axis of the cylinder; (2) cut a plane via the axis of cylinder and then move two opposite slips of the cut plane by a displacement of either translation b or rotation ω, or both together. Hence the relative displacement of two slips is d(r) = b + ω × r;
(1.23)
(3) If b or ω is consistent with the translational or orientational symmetrical element of the matter, the gap resulting from the displacement d can be filled by a piece of bulk medium and two slips will fit perfectly with the filled piece. If the operation (2) makes the medium overlap, we need to take away an additional piece of medium instead and thus still keep the perfect fit of the two slips. (4) The medium will then relax to a new state owing to the internal interactions. Consequently, a singular line L is left. The six basic Volterra processes are depicted in Figure 1.20, among them the three intrinsic processes on b produce dislocations while the three intrinsic operations associated with ω produce disclinations. In Figure 1.20, assuming σ is the normal of the cut plane, (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f)
b⊥L, but b σ, the line L is an edge dislocation; b⊥L, and b⊥σ, L is an edge dislocation; b L, L is a screw dislocation; ω L, L is a wedge disclination; ω⊥L, but ω σ, L is a twist disclination; ω⊥L, and ω⊥σ, L is a twist disclination.
The dislocations have been extensively studied so we limit ourselves mainly to the disclination. Figure 1.21 sketches a sample of nematic liquid crystals, the short bars denoting the directors which all lie on the sheet of paper. Now cut the sample along the normal and via the line L, see
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
a
b
c
d
e
f
Figure 1.20.
(a)
L
37
The Volterra process.
A1 A2
A1
(b)
L L (d) A2
(c)
L (e)
Figure 1.21.
L
The Volterra process generating ±1/2 disclinations (c and e).
Figure 1.21(a), and rotate the two opposite slips of the cut A1 and A2 by π. π is a symmetry element. Insert a new sample piece of liquid crystals and arrange their director to fit the directors on the A1 and A2 slips, as shown Figure 1.21(b). The liquid crystals then relax themselves to the configuration shown in Figure 1.21(c). A disclination with the strength of −1/2
38
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
appears. It is a wedge disclination. If the same amount of liquid crystals is needed to be moved, as shown in Figure 1.21(d), the final picture of the director field will look like that shown in Figure 1.21(e). The disclination line L is then +1/2 in strength. There is a simple process to produce a disclination: rotate the directors on two slips respectively by ω1 and ω2 and make ω1 − ω2 = ω. Thus the same disclination line is produced. The process is named the de Gennes-Friedel process. One can prove that the de Gennes-Friedel process is equivalent to the Volterra process for nematic liquid crystals. The operation Pv of the Volterra process can in fact be divided into the translation and rotation steps, i.e., first, translate the directors (T ) and then rotate them around themselves (Pg ). The latter is actually the de Gennes-Friedel process. In other words Pv = Pg + T. (1.24) Because there is no dislocation in nematics which have only translational symmetry, consequently (1.25) Pv = Pg .
1.6.2.
Strength of disclination in nematics
The relative rotation of two opposite slips is ω = 2mπ where m is the strength of the disclination, which can be either an integer or semi-integer, i.e., ±1/2, ±1, ±3/2, etc.. The general definition of the strength of the disclination is the sum of the deformation angles, in radian measure, made with respect to a laboratory axis when going along a closed contour around the disclination 1 dψ, (1.26) m= 2π L where ψ is the angle of the director with respect to a certain direction, e.g., the x axis and L is the closed contour. For convenience, we calculate instead the sum of the angles θ of the directors with respect to the tangents of the closed contour, i.e. 1 dθ. (1.27) m=1+ 2π L The sign of m depends on whether n and the closed contour (i.e., the Burger’s circle) have the same direction. The algebraic sum of the disclinations are not arbitrary, and the sum of all the strengths in a medium is a topological constant, i.e., the Euler
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
Figure 1.22.
39
The Poincare theorem on a soccer ball.
characteristic. This is the so-called Poincare theorem. For example, for a spherical surface or any smooth surface that is topologically equivalent to a spherical surface, the sum of strengths of all disclinations must be equal to 2, the Euler characteristic of a spherical surface. We give some examples to demonstrate the theorem. For a terrestrial globe, either the longitude or latitude lines’ distribution, construct at the south and north poles, a m = 1 disclination each. A soccer ball, shown in Figure 1.22, consists of twelve black mosaic pentagons and a number of hexagons. Each pentagon actually corresponds to a +1/6 disclination, the total strength of the twelve pentagons counts to +2. A −1/6 disclination shown in the same figure only produces a locally saddle surface. A buckminster fullerene molecule is a similar example. For a volleyball and a basketball, one observes the same rule. For a bulk sample, the sum of all the disclinations should be about zero. In liquid crystals, m = ±1/2 and ±1 disclinations appear frequently but the disclinations with high strength are seldom observed because they cause large energy. The director configuration in the vicinity of various strength disclinations are depicted in Figure 1.23. Assume the nematic liquid crystals to be a homogeneous planar structure, i.e., the directors lie in the x–y plane, making an angle φ with respect to the x axis. For simplicity, we further suppose that all the three elastic constants are equal, i.e., K11 = K22 = K33 = K. Thus the energy density
40
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
(a) +1/2
Figure 1.23.
(b) –1/2
(c) –1
(d) +1
(e) +1
(f) +1
(g) –1
(h) +1
(i) +2
(j) +5/2
(k) –3/2
(l) +3/2
The director configurations of disclinations with various strengths.
1 F = K(∇n)2 . 2 Hence the equilibrium condition is defined by the equation of the director field is
∆φ = 0.
(1.28)
(1.29)
The solutions may be as follows φ = 0,
the uniform nematic; or
(1.30a)
φ = qz + φ0 ,
the uniform cholesteric; or
(1.30b)
φ = mθ + φ0 , the singular solution.
(1.30c)
If the disclination line is a wedged one and is along the z axis, then the solution of Equation (1.30c) is y +C (1.31) φ = m · tg −1 x and if the disclination is along the y axis, then the solution is z + C. (1.32) φ = m · tg −1 x The configuration of Equation (1.32) is associated with a twist disclination. Both twist and wedge disclinations are shown in Figure 1.24, where the disclination line is normal to this sheet of paper.
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
(a)
Figure 1.24.
41
(b)
A wedge (a) and a twist (b) disclination.
Substitute the solution back into Equation (1.28). The energy per unit length of an isolated disclination in a cylindrical sample of a diameter R is given by
F = Ec + πKm2 ln
R rc
,
(1.33)
where Ec is the core energy of the disclination, whose contribution is not so significant, presumably equal to πKm2 . This equation indicates that F tends to infinity as R approaches infinity. It is not the case because the disclinations likely appear in pairs with opposite signs. The energy of such a pair is hence
2
F = 2πKm ln
d 2rc
,
(1.34)
where d is the separation of the two disclinations. Thus, the deformation area is confined to a limited dimension. The disclinations with the opposite signs tend to approach each other in order to reduce the energy, and may eventually annihilate together. Figure 1.25 shows an example that a + 1 and a − 1/2 disclination annihilating to become a + 1/2 disclination. An important conclusion obtained from Equation (1.33) is that the deformation energy is proportional to the square of the disclination strength m. The equation is derived for a special case but the above conclusion is universal, with only the coefficient being different. It is expected that a m = 2 disclination is likely to divide into two m = 1 disclinations or so, in order to achieve a more stable configuration.
42
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 1.25. A + 1 and a − 1/2 disclinations annihilate to become a + 1/2 disclination. (From Shiwaku et al., 1995)
1.6.3.
Point disclinations
Assume a point disclination located in a nematic droplet of radius R. The point disclination can be classified according to their Poincare characteristic angle α as a knot point (α = 0), focus point (0 < α < π/2), center (α = π/2), saddle-focus point (π/2 < α < π) or saddle point (α = π/2). For a knot point, one has a spherically symmetrical radial configuration and then F = 8πKR. For a center point, one has a tangential bipolar configuration and F = 5πKR. While for a saddle defect, i.e., a hyperbolic configuration 8 F = πKR. 5 More complex configurations with a tilted director orientation at the surface have also been reported by Hobdell & Windel (1995) and Madhusudana & Sumathy (1983). It is illustrated that the knot defect has the highest energy while the saddle defect gives the lowest.
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
43
Figure 1.26. A point singularity escape in the third dimension. (From Collings, 1990. Reproduced by permission of Taylor & Francis, )
The bulk energy of the point defects is proportional to the dimension of the sample. On the other hand, the planar structure of a disclination line contributes to the bulk energy in proportion to the logarithm of the ratio R to rc . The latter term is much greater than unity if R is large enough for optical observation. In a capillary of radius R, the directors are homeotropically aligned with the wall. The planar solution would lead to a line disclination of m = +1, as shown in Figure 1.26(c). But the directors are likely to escape from the center of the disclination m = 1 towards a series of point defects of m = 1 and m = −1, see Figure 1.26(a), the knot and saddle points and may eventually become a non-singular configuration, shown in Figure 1.26(b). It is the so-called escape in the third dimension. The disclination line of m = ±1/2 and disclination point of m = ±1 are frequently observed in liquid crystals. In some cases high strength disclinations may be observed, such as in a thin layer of small molecular mass liquid crystals, polymer liquid crystals, lyotropic liquid crystals, binary thermotropic liquid crystals, etc. If the inequality of the three elastic constants is taken into account, the disclination configurations are slightly different. Even though the energy for same |m| is different. The integration of defects produces the textures of liquid crystals. Owing to the thermal fluctuation of the molecules and
44
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
the temperature dependence of the elastic constants and birefringence, the optical textures of liquid crystals are significantly associated with temperature. The disclinations may split or annihilate due to interactions. The disclinations of the same sign tend to repel each other while those of opposite signs attract each other and may eventually annihilate. Because of the additional translational order, the dislocations can exist in the cholesteric and smectic liquid crystals, which makes the texture of these liquid crystals even more complicated. Each liquid crystal phase shows characteristic textures and thus the optical texture becomes an important means to differentiate the phase of the liquid crystals. Liquid crystalline polymers have the same topologically stable defects as small molecular mass liquid crystals do, but the textures may be different due to the difference in the energetic stability of the same topological defects in both low molecular mass and polymeric liquid crystals (Kleman, 1991). In Chapter 3 we will discuss the textures in detail.
1.6.4.
Defects in smectic A phase
The homotopy group of the smectic A phase is Π0 (SA ) = 1, Π1 (SA ) = Z ⊗ Z2 , Π2 (SA ) = Z,
(1.35)
Π3 (SA ) = Z, where Z is the translational dislocation normal to the smectic layers with the Burger vector being the multiple layer thickness; Z2 , is a cyclic group of two elements. There is no topological stable singular wall, but there are topological stable singular lines, composed not only of the disclination lines associated with Z2 but also of the dislocation lines associated with Z. Π3 (SA ) = Z implies that there are topological solitons. The deformations in the smectic A phase liquid crystals are the bending of the smectic layer (accordingly to the splay of the directors) and the dilation or compression of the layers. The energy is thus 2 ∂u 1 1 + K11 (∇ · n)2 , (1.36) F = B 2 ∂z 2
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
b
a
d
45
c
e
f
Figure 1.27. Typical dislocations (a, b) and disclinations (c–f) in smectic A liquid crystals. (From Kurik & Lavrentovich, 1988.)
where u is the displacement of the layer and B is the elastic modulus. The equilibrium state is governed by (assuming λ2 = K11 /B) 4 ∂2u 2∂ u − λ = 0. ∂z 2 ∂x4
(1.37)
The typical dislocations (a, b) and disclinations (c-f) are shown in Figure 1.27. The edge dislocation Suppose the edge dislocation is along the y axis and the Burger vector has a thickness of one layer. The smectic layer is in the x–y plane. At equilibrium, the displacement u is expressed by d dq d exp(iqx − λ|z|q 2 ) (1.38) u(x, z) = + 4 4π iq and the deformation angle θ between the layer normal and the z axis is given by 1 x2 d θ= √ exp − . (1.39) 4λ |z| 4 π (λ |z|)1/2 It is illustrated that the deformation disappears rapidly in the x-direction and decays slowly in the z-direction. The deformation energy is independent of sample dimension. It is concluded that the dissolution of the dislocation doesn’t reduce the energy.
46
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
The screw dislocation There is a helical structure surrounding the screw dislocation line. The screw dislocation is perpendicular to the smectic layer and the deformation is b −1 y tg . (1.40) u= 2π x The screw dislocation affects neither the lattice dilation nor the bending of the layer. Thus it isn’t associated with an energy penalty. The focal-conic texture The smectic layers are flexible, i.e., it is relatively easy for bending deformation, but the layers are difficult to compress. The bending of the smectic layers can be expressed by two principal curvatures R1 and R2 , i.e., 2 1 1 1 F = K11 + dτ. (1.41) 2 R1 R2 For a point on an ellipse, R1 ·R2 > 0; for a point on a hyperbolic, R1 ·R2 < 0. For a defect point forming a spherical surface, see Figure 1.28(a), where R = R1 = R2 = ∞, the energy is F = 8πK11 R. For a Dupin cyclide comprised a circle base and a straight line core, shown in Figure 1.28(b),
2R 2 −2 . F = 2π K11 R ln rc If the base is an ellipse and the core is a hyperbolic curve, shown in Figure 1.28(c), the Dupin cyclide has the energy F = πK11 (1 − e2 )p ln(a/rc ), (a) point (b)
(c) ellipse
circle
Figure 1.28. The Dupin cyclides (a) a point and sphere; (b) a circle and a straight line; (c) an ellipse and a hyperbolic curve.
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
47
where e, p and a are the eccentricity, perimeter and semi-principal diameter. The last case is favorable from the energy point of view. The three possibilities are shown in Figure 1.28. A series of the Dupin cyclides are knitted to each other to construct the focal-conic texture. 1.6.5.
Defects in the smectic C phase
The projections of the director on the smectic C layer construct a c-vector (or c-director) field. The distortion of the c-director and the displacement of the layer are two parts of the defects in the smectic C phase. Because the c-director is apolar, there are only the integer disclinations. In addition, there is no escape in the third dimension because the c-director is confined in layers. Neither topological stable singular walls nor points exist in the smectic C sample according to the homotopy argument. 1.6.6.
Dispiration in the smectic C* phase
The helical structure of the c-director in the smectic C* phase makes the defects different from those in the smectic C phase. As the Volterra process produces a screw dislocation, for example, along the z axis and the Burger vector b = d, it must be accompanied by a parallel wedge disclination in the c-director, in the form y b φ = − tg −1 + qz. (1.42) p x It is named the wedge dispiration, designated as (b, −b/p). Similarly, an edge dislocation of the Burger vector b must be accompanied by a partial twist disclination, designated as the twist dispiration (b, b/p).
1.6.7.
Defects in the cholesteric phase
The χ-, λ- and τ -disclinations The order tensor of the cholesteric liquid crystal is a symmetrical matrix, or a set of three orthogonal vectors: n, q and n × q. It is known that there is no topological stable singular wall and point but there are topological stable singular lines which are characterized by the Q group, Q(C0, C0, C1, C2, C3). The classification of the cholesteric
48
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
(a)
(b)
Figure 1.29. The schematics of (a) χ-disclination, (c) τ -disclination. (Modified from Collings, 1990.)
(c) (b)
λ-disclination
and
liquid crystal was made by Kleman & Friedel (1969) as the χ-, λ- and τ -disclinations shown in Figure 1.29: (1) χ-disclination: semi-integer turn (i.e., the multiple π rotation) around the helical axis; (2) λ-disclination: multiple π rotation around the director; (3) τ -disclination: multiple π rotation around n × q. Compared with the homotopy classification, each element in the homotopy Q group corresponds to the above defects in the following way C0: C0: C1: C2: C3:
λ(2n), τ (2n) and χ(2n) λ(2n + 1), τ (2n + 1) and χ(2n + 1) λ(n + 1/2) τ (n + 1/2) χ(n + 1/2)
It is apparent that the two classifications are consistent, but the homotopy approach is more powerful in further analysis because there is a relation between the group elements, which is associated with the interactions between the defects. The cholesteric liquid crystal can be regarded as a layered structure so that it also shows the focal-conic texture, especially for large pitch cholesteric liquid crystals. The texture of cholesteric liquid crystals is rather complicated. Both disclination and dislocation exist together. The typical texture is shown in Figure 1.30.
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
(a)
(b)
49
(c)
Figure 1.30. Typical finger-print textures in cholesteric liquid crystals: schematics (upper) and images (lower). (From Bouligand & Kleman, 1970.)
The Cano wedge The Cano wedge can be used to measure the cholesteric pitch. Two substrates are wedged by a small angle 2γ. The cholesteric liquid crystal between the substrates is homogeneously aligned. Under polarized microscopy, the equally spaced disclinations appear at the middle of the wedge. The separation of the lines 2d is associated with the pitch P P = 8d tan γ.
(1.43)
This technique has been applied to measure the pitch of cholesteric liquid crystals.
1.6.8.
Textures
Under the polarized optical microscope, the liquid crystal films show colorful patterns, i.e., the optical textures. Each liquid crystal phase shows its typical texture which provides the means to identify the phase of the liquid crystals. The typical textures are the Schlieren, threadlike, homeotropic, homogeneous, marble, finger-print, focal-conic, Dupin cyclide, fan-shape, sanded, mosaic, and so on. They are the integrations of many typical defects mentioned above. Demus & Richter (1978) were the first to review
50
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
the textures of liquid crystals in detail. Later, Gray and Goodby (1984) summarized the textures of the smectic liquid crystal phases.
1.6.9.
Homotopy classification of defects in liquid crystals
Now we briefly discuss the topological homotopy theory that classifies defects in liquid crystals and judges the stability of the defects according to the symmetry of liquid crystals. The singularities in the liquid crystals cause the deformation of the director field of liquid crystals and thus affect the symmetry of liquid crystals. This idea provides an approach to analyze the characteristics of the defects. The order vectors (or scalars, or tensors) of various liquid crystals are not the same. The director n is the order vector of the nematic liquid crystals, but the order for the cholesteric liquid crystals is a symmetric matrix, i.e., a tensor. Because the order vector space is thus a topological one, any configuration of the director field of liquid crystals is thus represented by a point in the order vector space. The order vector space (designated by M ) is associated with the symmetry of liquid crystals. The topologically equivalent defects in liquid crystals constitutes the homotopy class. The complete set of homotopy classes constitutes a homotopy group, denoted Πr (M ). r is the dimension of the sub-space surrounding a defect, which is related to the dimension of the defect (point, line or wall) d , and the dimension of the liquid crystal sample d by d = d − r − 1.
(1.44)
For a three-dimensional nematic liquid crystal for example, the r = 0 case corresponds for example to a defect with d = 2, which means a disclination wall; for r = 1, d = 1 corresponds to a disclination line; for r = 2, d = 0 corresponds to a disclination point. It is known that the order vector space of three dimensional nematic liquid crystals is the projection plane P2 . Its homotopy group of the zero rank (r = 0) is Π0 (P2 ) = 1. In the other words, there is no topologically stable disclination wall. The homotopy group of the first rank (r = 1) is Π1 (P2 ) = Z2 .
Liquid Crystal States of Matter
51
This is a cycle group of two elements, one of two elements is in fact the disclination line of |m| = 1/2, the other element corresponds to the |m| = 1 disclination line, which is not topologically stable. The homotopy group of the second rank is Π2 (P2 ) = Z, where Z is the integer group and corresponds to the topologically stable disclination points of integer strength. The conclusions are consistent with our knowledge of the defects in nematic liquid crystals. Similarly, homotopy theory can be applied to other liquid crystal phases, such as the cholesteric and smectic liquid crystals (Mermin, 1979; Wang, 1986).
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 2
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
The purpose of this chapter is to explain theoretically the formation of liquid crystal phases in polymer systems and to provide the basic concepts for designing and synthesizing liquid crystalline polymers. Liquid crystalline polymers combine features of both polymers and liquid crystals, thus we discuss the materials from two sides: liquid crystallinity and polymer properties. Theoretical descriptions have encountered many difficulties in the past. One is that the present theoretical understanding of neither polymers or liquid crystals is complete. The initial understanding of liquid crystalline compounds is attributed to German chemist Daniel Vorlander who proposed in 1908 an empirical rule (Vorlander, 1908): liquid crystal phases can be formed by molecules of the utmost linear shape. This revealed his insight into the relationship between the formation of liquid crystal phases and the shape of molecules. At that time, the empirical rule aided in the design and synthesis of liquid crystalline compounds, especially in the Halle Group. In the period from the discovery of liquid crystals in 1888 to 1908 when Vorland proposed his rule, less than 200 liquid crystalline compounds were found. In the next fifteen years, the number of synthetic liquid crystalline compounds reached as many as 2000. Vorland assumed the existence of liquid crystalline polymers in his paper in 1923 (Vorland, 1923). Under the subheading “The Nature of ‘Infinite’ Long Molecules” in this paper, he asked “What happens to the molecules when they become longer and longer?”, and then answered “According to my experiences, a border for this (liquid crystal) state does not exist as the length of molecule increases.” A few years later, the liquid crystal phase was first discovered in the solution of the tobacco mosaic 53
54
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
virus (Bawden & Pirie, 1937). This virus is a rigid polymer a few hundreds nanometers long. Another typical example of a long rigid polymer is poly(γ-benzyl-L-glutamate) (PBLG) which exhibits the liquid crystal phase in solution (1950). A few efforts have been made to establish the theoretical basis of this class of liquid crystalline polymers. Among those, the most important theories were the virial expansion by physicist L. Onsager in 1949 (Onsager, 1949) and the lattice model by chemist P. J. Flory in 1956 (Flory, 1956). These two scientists were both made Noble Laureates in chemistry for their contributions in thermodynamics and polymer science, respectively. Their theories propose that liquid crystal phases arise for purely steric reasons; relatively dense systems of long rigid rods easily form a liquid crystal phase. These two theories will be introduced in the first two sections of this chapter. Rigid polymers are not the only class of polymers which can show liquid crystal phases. These phases are also found in the melts of polymers in which mesogenic units are incorporated in the backbone (main chain polymers) or attached as pendants to the backbone (side chain polymers). These liquid crystalline polymers will be discussed in later sections. Three main kinds of liquid crystal states: nematic, cholesteric and smectic can occur in polymer systems. However, we will restrict the discussion to nematic polymers below, since it may be too early to adequately elaborate on the other two phases.
2.1.
ONSAGER THEORY FOR RIGID — ROD LIQUID CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS
Onsager (1949) was the first to study theoretically the rigid-rod system in solution which is composed of identical long cylindrical rods with length L and diameter D, and where L much greater than D. Only the steric interaction is considered in this theory and the following requirements must be met: (1) No penetration between rods, so that the steric interaction can be expressed as
∞, if molecule i and j overlap Vij = 0, otherwise
(2.1)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
55
(2) The rods are long enough. The molecules can be cylindrical, semisphero-cylindrical or even lathe. The basic conclusions for these molecular shapes are quite similar. In the text below, only the solutions of cylindrical molecules are described. The calculation can be easily extended to deal with disc-like molecules by varying the length-to-breadth ratio. (3) The solution is dilute. In a dilute solution, the density of the system, ρ = N/V , with N being the total number of rods in a solution of volume V , is small. Thus the volume fraction of rods in the solution is Φ=
2.1.1.
πD2 Lρ. 4
(2.2)
The partition function
The orientational distribution function of rods with long axis a is designated by f (a). ρf (a)dΩa is the number of rods which point to the solid angle dΩ centered at a. First of all, we examine the partition function Z — an important function in thermodynamics and statistics, and calculate the free energy of the system according to the formula F = −kB T ln Z,
(2.3)
where T is the Kelvin temperature and kB is the Boltzmann constant. The thermodynamical quantities associated with the equilibrium state can then be obtained. The calculation is similar to that for a simple fluid with N identical spherical particles, however it is more complicated because of the anisotropic shape. The partition function is the volume in the phase space or the summation over all the possible configurations that the system adopts. For the system of cylindrical molecules, the partition function is given by 1 · · · exp(−βU )dτ1 dτ2 · · · dτN , (2.4) Z= N !h6N where β = 1/(kB T ). The Planck constant h is introduced in the denominator to make Z dimensionless. The factor of 1/N ! arises from the indistinguishability of N molecules. A rigid rod has 6 degrees of freedom, three from translational motion and the rest from rotational motion. The infinitesimal volume element τi of the phase space is dτi = dri · dpi · dθi · dφi · dψi · d pθi · dpφi · dpψi ,
56
Liquid Crystalline Polymers z
z⬘
y⬘
x
y
Figure 2.1.
The Euler angle definition for a rigid rod.
where r is the positional coordinates and θ, φ and ψ are the Euler’s angles (see Figure 2.1), p, pθ , pφ , and pψ are the conjugate momenta. The total energy of the system, U , is the sum of the kinetic energy of each rigid rod Ti (translation and rotation) and potential energy Vi . The translational kinetic energy of a rigid rod Tti is simply Tti =
1 2 (p + p2y + p2z ), 2m x
(2.5)
where m and p(px , py and pz ) are the mass and kinetic momenta (components). The rotational kinetic energy of a rigid rod is more complicated and we adopt the form from the literature as follows
Tri
p2ψ p2θ (pφ − pψ cos θ)2 = + , + 2I1 2I2 2I1 sin2 θ
(2.6)
where I1 and I2 are principal inertial moments around the long and the short axes, respectively. The total energy of the system is the sum of the two contributions
T =
N i=1
(Tti + Tri ) =
N i
Ti .
(2.7)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
57
The potential energy of rigid rods is not only a function of the relative distance (r ij ) of the mass centers of two rigid rods but is also associated with the orientations of two molecules (ai and aj ). It is expressed as Vij = Vij (r ij ; ai , aj ).
(2.8)
The total potential energy is the sum of the interaction of all pairs of rods not repeatedly counted. There are N (N − 1) terms of such interaction potentials, and is written as V =
N i
Vij (r ij ; ai , aj ),
(2.9)
j>i
where the summation is made for all i and j (j must be greater than i). The partition function is then given by 1 · · · d3N xd3N p Z(N, V, T ) = N !h6N × · · · dN θdN φdN ψdN pθ dN pφ dN pψ
× exp
−β
N
Ti (p) +
i
N
Vij (r; ai , aj )
,
(2.10)
i<j
where dxdydz is written as d3 x and dpx dpy dpz is written as d3 p. The integral for translational moments is (2πmkB T )3N /2 while the integration for the angular moments gives (2πI1
N 2πI2 )N sin θi . i
The integrad in Equation 2.10 is independent of the Euler angle ψ and thus the integral with respect to ψ is (2π)N . Substituting these integrals back into Equation 2.10, the partition function is reduced to the form
N 1 N 3N Z(N, V, T ) = · · · d Ωd x exp −β Vij , (2.11) N !AN i<j
58
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
where A=
h6 {(2πmkB T )3/2 (2πI1 kB T )(2πI2 kB T )1/2 (2π)}
and is dependent on the molecular mass m, the inertial moments I1 and I2 and is a function of the temperature. Ω is the solid angle dΩ = sin θdθdφ. The remaining integrad is associated with the potential only. Two tricks are adopted here: (1) Substitute the integration over angles into the summation. Divide the unit spherical surface into K solid angles of ∆ω, the number of molecules whose axes point to each solid angle ∆ω being Nα (Nα is an integer). The integral over dΩ is then equivalent summing all the possible combinations to k {N1 , N2 , . . . , Nα , . . . , Nk }, and α=1 Nα = N . The partition function in Equation 2.11 becomes Z(N, V, T ) =
N !(∆ω)N 1 N !AN N1 !N2 ! . . . Nα ! . . . Nk ! {Nα }
×
···
d
3N
x exp −β
N
Vij
≡
Z({Nα }),
{Nα }
i<j
(2.12) where (∆ω)N Z({N }) = k AN α=1 Nα !
···
d3N x exp −β
N
Vij
.
(2.13)
i<j
Denote the maximal term in Equation 2.12 by Z({Na })max . Apparently the following inequality exists Z({Na })max < Z(N, V, T ) < N k Z({Na })max . Take the logarithm of each term in the inequality and divide by N . The following inequality is obtained 1 1 1 ln Z({Nα })max < ln Z < [ln Z({Nα })max + k ln N ]. N N N As N approaches infinity, ln N/N approaches zero. Therefore, ln Z/N can be replaced by (1/N ) ln(Z{Nα })max . As a result, one needs only to calculate
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
59
Z({Nα }) and minimize with respect to {Nα }. Z({Nα }) hence has the form
(∆ω)N Z({Nα }) = k AN α=1 Nα !
···
d
3N
x
N
exp(−βVij ).
(2.14)
i<j
(2) Introduce the Mayer function Qij , replace exp(−Vij /kB T ) by 1 + Qij . When i and j molecules are not overlapped the term Qij vanishes; otherwise Qij = −1. Substituting into Equation 2.14, the multi-products in the equation are reduced to the power expansion of Qij . Here the cluster expansion is used. When the density of molecules is not very high the quadratic term of φ is very small and the higher terms of φ must be further reduced. So that we retain only the linear term and then
N (∆ω)N Z({Nα }) = V N + V N −2 Qij d3 ri d3 rj k i<j AN Nα !
=
α=1
∆ω · V A
N
1 k
Nα !
N 1 1+ Qij d3 rij 2V
.
(2.15)
i=j
α=1
The factor 12 in the second term is present because the summation in Equation 2.15a is carried out only for i less than j. It is shown that φij is a function of the distance of i and j molecules, rij , and the relative orientation angles (α and β respectively) of the two molecules. It may be more accurate if we write φij as φαβ (rij ). The orientations of Nα rigid rods within the α-th tiny solid angle are the same. The summation with respect to i and j in the second term in Equation 2.15b can be further reduced to the summation with respect to α, i.e., N i=j
Qij (rij )d3 rij =
k
Nα (Nβ − δαβ )
Qαβ (r)d3 r,
(2.16)
α,β=1
where δαβ is the Knoneck Delta: δ = 1 as α = β; δ = 0 as α is not equal to β. If N is very large, Nβ is large as well, so that the term of δαβ is negligible. The integral in Equation 2.16 is the second virial coefficient β1 . Qαβ = −1 when the rods collide, otherwise Qαβ = 0. Therefore, β1 is,
60
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
in fact, the negative of the exclusion volume V ex of the two rigid rods. Substituting into Equation 2.15 then
N N ∆ω · V 1 1 ex Z({Nα }) = 1− Nα Nβ V . (2.17) k A 2V N ! α α=1 i=j Take the logarithm for the partition function Z and apply the Sterling formula ln Nα ! ≈ Nα ln Nα hence
k Nα Nα Nα ∆ω · V ln Z({Nα }) = ln − ln + ln N N A N N N α=1
k 1 N 2 Nα Nβ ex ln 1 − + . V N 2V N N
(2.18)
α,β
Introducing the orientation function f (Ω) of rods Nα = f (Ωα )(∆ω). N We transfer the summation back to an integration. Note that ρ = N/V . Finally Equation 2.18 is reduced to 1 ln Z({Nα }) = − ln(Aρ) − f (Ω) ln f (Ω)dΩ N ρ dΩdΩ f (Ω)f (Ω )V ex (Ω − Ω ), (2.19) − 2 where the orientation function is normalized to unity f (Ω)dΩ = 1.
(2.20)
N The fourth term in Equation 2.14, i<j,l<m Qij Qlm contributes the term ρ2 − β2 (Ω, Ω , Ω )f (Ω)f (Ω )f (Ω )dΩdΩ dΩ , 3 where β2 is the third virial coefficient. The third virial term can be neglected if |β1 |ρ |β2 |ρ2 . This holds in the second virial approximation.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
61
Figure 2.2. Schematic for excluded volume (shadowed area) of the rod 1: (a) parallel to the neighbor rod 2; (b) perpendicular to the neighbor rod 2.
2.1.2.
The excluded volume
The second virial coefficient β1 is actually the excluded volume of the ai molecule to another rod with orientation aj . According to the definition, the exclusion volume is the volume occupied by one molecule in which the mass centers of other molecules are not allowed to touch. For cylindrical rods with length L and diameter D, the exclusion volume is schematically shown in Figure 2.2. In this figure the two particular cases are depicted, i.e., two cylinders are parallel or perpendicular to each other. β1 is dependent on the shape of the rigid rods. The expression for cylinders can be approximately expressed by β1 (ai , aj ) = −2L2 D| sin γ|, (2.21) γ is the angle that ai makes with respect to aj . The third virial coefficient β2 (ai , aj , ak ) can be neglected if ρc β2 << 1, β1 where ρc is the minimum concentration for forming the liquid crystal state, i.e., ρc β2 ρc L3 D3 ln(L/D) ∼ ρc LD2 ∼ φc << 1, ∼ β1 L2 D where φc is the volume fraction of rigid rods as ρ = ρc . It is shown that the Onsager approach is valid when the solution is dilute, i.e., φc is much less than unity.
62
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
In order to obtain the maximum Z({Nα }), we minimize Equation 2.19 with respect to the orientation distribution function while retaining the normalization condition 2.20. The Euler–Lagrange equation is 1 + λ + ln f (Ω) + ρ f (Ω )V ex (Ω − Ω )dΩ = 0, (2.22) where λ is an unknown multiple. Equation 2.22 and the normalization 2.20 together give the orientation distribution function f (Ω) at the equilibrium state. The orientation distribution f (Ω) will be discussed later in this section.
2.1.3.
The equilibrium of liquid crystals
According to Equation 2.19 the free energy of the system is written as F = N kB T ln(Aρ) + f (Ω) ln f (Ω)dΩ +
ρ 2
dΩdΩ f (Ω)f (Ω )V
ex
(Ω − Ω ) .
(2.23)
The first term is the contribution of translation, the second term results from entropy reduction due to the orientational order of rigid rods, and the third term is the second virial term. The higher virial terms are neglected. From the free energy (see Equation 2.23), the equation of state at equilibrium and the chemical potential can be determined accordingly. For instance, when the free energy is differentiated with respect to volume V , P = −∂F/∂V , the pressure–volume relationship shown in Figure 2.3 is obtained. The ordinate is the reduced pressure P V0 /kB T (V0 is the volume of rod) and the abscissa is the reduced volume V /N V0 (or the reciprocal of volume fraction of rods in solution). In a system of axial ratio 10, the change of density at the transition is 0.15 while the order parameter jumps by 0.7361. By means of the Maxwell equal area rule, the dashed line in the figure is replaced by an equal pressure solid line. The regime of low pressure and low density is the isotropic phase while the regime of high pressure and high density corresponds to the anisotropic phase — nematic liquid crystal phase. The order parameter is determined by S = f (Ω)P2 (cos θ)dΩ. (2.24)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
63
Figure 2.3. The pressure vs. volume of Onsager rigid rod system. (Modified from Onsager, 1949.)
When the isotropic–nematic transition occurs the concentration of rods changes abruptly and the order parameter jumps from zero to a value Sc . The conclusions are dependent on the shape of rigid rods and hence the second virial coefficient. Thus, the concentration difference and the critical order parameter differ at the nematic — isotropic transition for different shapes of rods. For simplicity, Onsager suggested that the orientation distribution function f (Ω) has the form as follows f (Ω) =
α ch(α cos θ) , 4π shα
(2.25)
where α is the variational parameter. At the phase transition, the osmotic pressure and chemical potential are equal for the two phases. The results associated with the phase transition are (1) The nematic to isotropic transition of rigid rods in solution is of the first order. If the axial ratio L/D is great, the concentration of rods φ ∼ D/L << 1, even at the N − I transition, meets the condition of the second virial approximation.
64
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
(2) When the N − I transition occurs, the critical volume fractions in the nematic and isotropic phase are respectively D , L D = 4.49 . L
φI = 3.34 φN
(2.26)
For φ < φI , the solution is in the isotropic phase; for φ > φN the solution is in the nematic phase; for φN > φ > φI the nematic and isotropic phases coexist. (3) At the nematic to isotropic transition the critical order parameter Sc = 0.84. The numerical solution of Equation 2.22 gives the critical volume fractions in the two phases and the critical order parameters at the N − I transition are respectively D ; L D φN = 4.191 ; L Sc = 0.792. φI = 3.290
(2.27)
It has been shown that Onsager’s approximation (Equation 2.25) on the orientational distribution function works well (error is within 7%). The Onsager theory first examined the theoretical basis of long rigid rods’ forming of a liquid crystal phase: the steric repulsion and the long molecular shape are essential to forming the liquid crystal phase. The theory successfully explains the nematic to isotropic transition of very long rigid polymers, such as the PBLG in dioxane water and the two-phase coexistence. It was found that as the concentration of a solution of tobacco mosaic virus (Bawden & Pirie, 1937; Bernal & Fankuchen, 1941) approaches a critical value, biphasic coexistence occurs. One of the two phases is an isotropic phase of low concentration, while the other is the nematic phase of higher concentration. The Onsager theory has played an important role in the development of liquid crystalline polymers. It can be easily extended to disc-like molecules (de Gennes, 1973) that form a liquid crystal phase because of their anisotropic shape. The Onsager theory has also been extended to treat the poly-disperse polymer system (Parsons, 1979) and semi-rigid chain systems (Lekkerkeker et al., 1984).
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
65
The contribution from Russian scientists is worthy of special mention. We will introduce their theory later. It should be pointed out that to meet the second virial approximation, molecules must have a large L/D so that at the transition the solution is dilute. For molecules of axial ratio less than 10 the theory does not work well. In addition, the Onsager value of the density difference at the nematic — isotropic transition is greater than the experimental data. Introducing higher virial terms may extend the Onsager theory to concentrated solutions (Khokhlov & Semenov, 1981). The Flory theory discussed in the next section is another important theory on rigid liquid crystalline polymers. Because of its clear picture of the lattice model and the incorporation of the Onsager theory, it has become a basic method for the theoretical study of liquid crystalline polymers. As a result of the constant efforts of Flory and his co-workers, the theory has been applied to binary and poly-disperse systems and also includes the “soft” interactions.
2.2.
2.2.1.
FLORY THEORY FOR RIGID — ROD LIQUID CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS Partition function of a rigid rod solution
Flory (1956, 1984) adopted the lattice model. The Flory theory starts with the partition function of systems consisting of rigid rods and solvent molecules. Assume the long axis of the rigid rods makes an angle ψ with respect to the director of the system and the director is along one principal axis of the cubic lattice. Divide each rod into x basic units of equal width. Each basic unit occupies one cell in the lattice. x is actually the axial ratio of the rods. For simplicity, suppose that the dimension of a solvent molecule is compatible to the size of a cell lattice. In this section we adopt the same assignations as Flory. These may be different from those used in the preceding section by Onsager. In order to put a rod into the lattice, a postulate is made, which suggests that each rigid rod be divided into y sub-particles as shown in Figure 2.4b y = x sin θ.
(2.28)
Each sub-particle has x/y basic unit and its long axis is along the director. If a particle is perfectly aligned along the director, y is zero. As a
66
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
x
Ψ
x/y
x
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.4. A rigid rod in the Flory lattice. (a) a rod making an angle Ψ to the director; (b) the rod divided into y sub-particles.
particle is aligned off the director the value of y increases. Therefore, y can be regarded as a measure of a rod’s deviation off the director. y is called the off-orientation degree or disorder degree. Assume that the total number of cells in the system is n0 and (j − 1) rods have been placed in the lattice. They have occupied x(j − 1) lattice cells and hence n0 − x(j − 1) lattice cells remain unoccupied. In this case, there are νj ways to put the j-th rod into the lattice (x−yj )
νj = [n − x(j − 1)]Nj
(yj −1)
Pj
,
(2.29)
where yj is the number of the sub-particles of the rod; the first term represents the number of ways of putting the first basic unit of the first sub-particle into the lattice which is the number of unoccupied cells. Pj is the ways of putting the first unit of remaining (y − 1) sub-particles; Nj is the number of ways of placing the remaining (x − yj ) units entering into the lattice. First we will work out Pj . Once the first sub-particle’s position is determined each of other sub-particles must be the closest neighbor to the preceding sub-particle shown in Figure 2.4. In addition, the first unit must be immediately next to the last unit of the preceding sub-particle. The probability of such an arrangement is the volume fraction of unoccupied cells in the system, so that Pj =
[n − x(j − 1)] . n
(2.30)
All units of each sub-particle must be in same row of the cell. Once the first unit has been put into the lattice (the cell must be unoccupied and is allowed to put in) each of remaining units must be positioned immediately next to preceding unit (the cell must be unoccupied). There are two possibilities: the cell may be unoccupied and is allowed to enter in; the other possibility is that it has been occupied by the first unit of a sub-particle
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
67
of another rod and is not allowed to enter in. The possibility Nj of emptiness for the cell is the fraction of empty cells in both empty cells and total number of sub-particles. Thus Nj is Nj =
[n − x(j − 1)] [n − x(j − 1) − y¯(j − 1)]
[n − x(j − 1)] = , [n − (x − y¯)(j − 1)]
(2.31)
where y¯ is the average of y of the (j − 1) rods already in the system, y¯(j − 1) is the total number of sub-particles already in the lattice, i.e., the total number of the first unit of all the sub-particles. Substitute Pj and Nj to Equation 2.29 one obtains (x−yj )
νj = [n − x(j − 1)]Nj
(yj −1)
Pj
=
[n − x(j − 1)]x {[n − (x − y¯)(j − 1)](x−yj ) n(yj −1) }
≈
[n − x(j − 1)]![n − (x − y¯)j]! . (n − xj)![n − (x − y¯)(j − 1)]!n(¯yj −1)
(2.32)
Assume there are np identical rigid rods in the system and the contribution of the np rods to the partition function of the system can be written as np 1 Zcomb = νj , (2.33) np ! j=1
where the factor of (1/np !) is introduced to avoid repeatedly counting identical rods. Substituting Equation 2.32 into Equation 2.33 gives Zcomb =
(ns + y¯np )! , ns !np !nnp (¯y−1)
(2.34)
where ns = n − xnp is the number of empty cells left in the system which are occupied by solvent molecules. It is shown that both the numerator and denominator in Equation 2.34 increases as the off-orientation degree y¯ increases, but the denominator increases more rapidly. As a result, Zcomb decreases with increasing y¯. It illustrates that if the disorder of configuration of rods in the system increases, the excluded volume occupied by each rod increases and the space
68
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
in which rods can move freely decreases. Therefore, the collision between particles increases and the entropy decreases, reducing the stability of the system. Inversely, if y¯ decreases, the degree of orientation along the director becomes high, hence Zcomb becomes great and the contribution to the energy reduction accordingly becomes important. In fact, the above-mentioned equation is valid only for the perfectly ordered case, i.e., the rods are all aligned in parallel. This illustrates that the Flory theory works well for concentrated solutions. Another contribution to the total partition function of the system arises from the orientation, i.e., Zorient ωy np npy Zorient = , (2.35) npy y
where npy is the number of rods with off-orientation degree y, ωy is the solid angle fraction associated with y¯, and npy /np represents the orientation distribution function. The average of y is given by ynpy y¯ = (2.36) np y
It is illustrated from Equation 2.35 that if the system is in a perfectly ordered state, y = 1; thus npy = np , Zorient becomes very small. Otherwise, the system is in disorder (¯ y = x) then ωy = npy /np and Zorient = 1. According to the Flory’s (1956) approximation, when the orientational order is high, npy /np is important only in the range θ θ . Assume that npy /np is uniform within the range. When θ > θ , npy /np is zero. In the y /x)2 . Therefore, range θ ≤ θ the solid angle becomes approximately (¯ Zorient ≈ (¯ y /x)2np .
(2.37)
The fact that the orientational partition function Zorient increases as y¯ increases can be understood. Suppose the next neighbor of each cell in a lattice is six. If the orientation is random each basic unit of a particle has five ways and hence the particle of x units has 5x ways to enter into the lattice and thus the contribution to the entropy of the system is kB x ln 5. In the perfectly ordered state, after the first unit is put into the lattice the remaining units enter the lattice via the same direction. The contribution to the system entropy is about zero, and thus is not favored, taking only the orientational entropy into account. Therefore, the fundamental reason
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
69
for rigid rods to form a liquid crystal phase must be attributed to the steric repulsion effect between the rods. Consequently, the partition function is given by 2n (ns + y¯np )! (¯ y /x) p . (2.38) Z = Zcomb Zorient = ns !np !nnp (¯y−1) The equation describes the dependence of the partition function on np (the number or concentration of rods), x (the axial ratio or degree of polymerization of rods), and y¯ (the averaged off-orientation degree). From the partition function one can find the critical concentrations of phase separation of the underlying system as a function of the axial ratio and other quantities which are of interest.
2.2.2.
Formation of the liquid crystal phase
From the partition function in Equation 2.38 the free energy can be obtained as
F φ = − ln Z = ns ln(1 − φ) + np ln + np (¯ y − 1) kB T x
y¯ 1 − y¯ − (ns + y¯np ) ln 1 − φ − 2np ln . (2.39) x x For the isotropic system y = x and Equation 2.39 becomes
φ F = ns ln(1 − φ) + np ln + np (¯ y − 1), kB T x
(2.40)
where xnp n ns 1−φ= n φ=
are the volume fractions of solvents and rods, respectively. The relation of the partition function and off-orientation degree y¯ in Equation 2.39 is depicted in Figure 2.5 where x = 100. Each curve corresponds to a different volume fraction. As shown in Figure 2.5, for the volume fraction of rods less than critical value φ∗ (here φ∗ = 0.0784) e.g., φ = 0.060, Z increases monotonously with increasing y. In other words, the more disorder the higher Z.
70
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.5. The partition function vs. off-orientation degree of a rod system of axial ratio x = 100. (Modified from Flory, 1956.)
As φ > φ∗ there is a maximum Zmax with y¯. If Zmax is greater than Z0 , the value for y¯ = x, then Zmax gives the equilibrium state; otherwise, it is the meta-equilibrium state. Another conclusion from Figure 2.5 is that the y¯ value at Z = Zmax is much less than x/2, even for φ = φ∗ . As φ increases, y¯ at Z = Zmax decreases. It is illustrated that when the system transforms from the disordered state (¯ y = x) to the liquid crystal state, y¯ changes abruptly to x/2. If φ and x are great enough, there are two extremes in Z. The maximal value is associated with the stable (or meta-stable) states, in which y¯ is less than that at the minimum Z. Differentiate F in Equation 2.39 with respect to y¯ and make d(− ln Z)/d¯ y equal to zero. The y¯ for the two extremes are given by
x −2 φ= 1 − exp . (2.41) (x − y¯) y¯ There are two solutions for y¯. The smaller solution corresponds to the stable or meta-stable state in which Z is at a maximum, as shown in Figure 2.5. The dependence of φ on y¯ can be obtained numerically.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
71
To obtain the critical value of φ∗ when the system starts to appear in the meta-stable state, i.e., the minimum value of φ for the existence of liquid crystal state, let dφ =0 d¯ y and φ∗ is given implicitly by x = y∗ + y∗
2
[exp(2/y ∗ ) − 1] , 2
where y ∗ is the value at φ = φ∗ , or
−2 2 ∗ φ = 1 − 1 − ∗ exp y y∗
(2.42)
(2.43)
Substituting 2.42 into 2.41 Flory et al., in their 1956 approximation, obtained the critical φ∗ as the function of the axial ratio x
8 2 φ∗ ≈ 1− . (2.44) x x If x > 10, the error of the approximation in the above equation is less than 2%. It is concluded from Equation 2.44 that the larger the axial ratio of rods x, the less is φ∗ . Equation 2.44 is the well-known Flory formula which is widely used in the study of liquid crystalline polymers. It should be pointed out that φ∗ is only the minimal solution of Equation 2.41 at which the partition function first shows a maximum. At this volume fraction φ∗ , Zmax is actually less than the Z at the disordered state (¯ y = x). The system is at a meta-stable state only when the volume fraction further increases to a greater value in which the system is indeed at a stable state. It is shown in Equation 2.43 that as φ∗ increases up to φ∗ = 1, i.e., the neat polymer system, y ∗ = 2. Substituting y ∗ = 2 into Equation 2.42 the axial ratio is x = 2e = 5.44, which is approximately the minimum axial ratio of rods that the systems are able to show a liquid crystal phase.
2.2.3.
Two phase equilibrium
According to the above analyses, when the concentration of rods in the solvent increases beyond φ∗ , phase separation occurs, and the biphasic
72
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
coexistence of liquid crystal and isotropic phases appears. The chemical potentials of each component must be equal at the coexistence of two phases, i.e., µs = µs (2.45) µp = µp , where the subscript “s” is designated for the solvent while p is for the rigid rods, and µ and µ are the chemical potentials at the isotropic and liquid crystal phase, respectively. According to Equation 2.38, the derivative of (− ln Z) with respect to the volume fraction ns of the solvent gives
(µs − µ0s ) y − 1) φ (¯ y¯ = ln(1 − φ ) + − ln 1 − φ 1 − . RT x x
(2.46)
At equilibrium d(− ln Z)/d¯ y = 0. Replace the last term by 2/¯ y from Equation 2.41 and thus Equation 2.46 becomes (µs − µ0s ) y − 1) 2 φ (¯ = ln(1 − φ ) + + . RT x y¯ The chemical potential for solvents in the isotropic phase is
(µs − µ0s ) 1 = ln(1 − φ) + φ 1 − . RT x
(2.47)
(2.48)
Similarly, the chemical potential of rods in the liquid crystal and in the isotropic phase are given respectively by
y¯ (µp − µ0p ) φ = ln + φ (¯ y − 1) + 2 − 2 ln (2.49) RT x x and
(µp − µ0p ) = ln RT
φ + φ(x − 1). x
(2.50)
The equilibrium state of coexistence of two phases is governed by the following set of equations
y − 1) 2 φ (¯ 1 ln(1 − φ ) + + = ln(1 − φ) + φ 1 − x y¯ x (2.51)
φ y¯ φ ln + φ (¯ y − 1) + 2 − 2 ln = ln + φ(x − 1). x x x
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.6.
73
Phase diagrams for various rod axial ratios. (From Flory & Ronca, 1979a.)
and Equation 2.43, where φ and φ are the volume fraction of rods in the liquid crystal and isotropic phase, respectively. For various axial ratios x of the rods the numerical solutions of the above set of equations are summarized in Figure 2.6. The following important conclusions can be obtained from Figure 2.6: (1) Those rigid molecules capable of showing a stable liquid crystal phase must have the axial ratio greater than x = 6.7. This value is somewhat greater than the estimated value of x = 5.44. We have emphasized that the estimate of the minimum axial ratio for forming a liquid crystal phase (x = 5.44) is that at which the partition function starts to take a maximum. (2) At the equilibrium state, the volume fraction of rods in the two phases decreases as the axial ratio x increases. The volume fraction of the liquid crystal phase is slightly greater than that of the isotropic phase, the ratio between these two critical volume fractions increases with increasing x, but is always less than 1.56. For enough large x, the critical volume fractions are respectively φ=
8 , x
φ∗ =
12.5 . x
74
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.7. Critical volume fraction vs. axial ratio. (Modified from Flory, 1961. Reproduced by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.)
(3) y¯/x increases smoothly as x increases, however, the variation is not great. The value of y¯/x is very small which illustrates that the ordering in the liquid crystal phase is very high. An experiment was carried out for PBLG to verify the theory. PBLG molecules in solution adopt an extended α-helical conformation so that they are rigid rods. In Figure 2.7, the critical volume fractions of PBLG in solvents (Flory, 1961) were depicted as a function of the axial ratio. The curve A is for φ at which the liquid crystal phase starts to appear while the curve B is for φ at which the isotropic phase completely disappears and the system becomes entirely a liquid crystal. The solid curve is the theoretical expectation while the dashed line is the experimental result. Both are in good agreement. 2.2.4.
Effect of “soft” interaction between molecules
Later Flory further took the two “soft” interactions between the molecules into account. The anisotropic interaction is associated with molecular orientations while the isotropic one is irrelevant of the molecular orientation. In fact, the anisotropic interaction was the basis of another well-known theory in liquid crystals — Maier–Saupe theory (Maier & Saupe, 1959). Flory successfully captured the essence of the theory.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
75
First we introduce the isotropic interaction which results from the mixing of rods and solvents. The previous theory, without the mixing contribution to entropy, is only applicable to an athermal system. If there is a mixing entropy contribution, the free energy in Equation 2.39 is implemented by a term χφns , where χ is the Flory–Huggins interaction parameter. Flory called the mixing term the isotropic “soft” interaction to distinguish it from the steric interaction of rods. At the coexistence of the two phases the chemical potentials of the rods and solvents in both the liquid crystals phase and isotropic phase must be equal and thus the following set of equations for φ, φ and y¯ holds
y − 1) 2 φ (¯ 1 2 + + χφ = ln(1 − φ) + φ 1 − + χφ2 ln(1 − φ ) + x y¯ x
y¯ φ ln + φ (¯ y − 1) + 2 − 2 ln + χx(1 − φ )2 x x
φ = ln + φ(x − 1) + χx(1 − φ)2 . (2.52) x
Figure 2.8 shows the numerical result of the rod/solvent system for the rod axial ratio x = 100. The ordinate is the Flory–Huggins parameter χ and the abscissa is the volume fraction of rigid rods. For negative χ, the two phase equilibrium is basically independent of χ. A positive χ has a significant effect on the two-phase equilibrium. The diagram can be divided into three regions: in Region I the concentration is small and the system is in a single isotropic phase; in Region II the system is in the liquid crystal phase; and in Region III both the liquid crystal and isotropic phases coexist. For χ less than, say, 0.07, the region of biphasic coexistence is narrow, φ∗∗ /φ∗ = 1.5. For χ greater than 0.07 the volume fraction difference between the two phases becomes larger. Figure 2.9 shows the experimental results of the PBLG/dimethyl formamide(DMF)-methanol system (Nakajama et al., 1968). The axial ratios were 150 and 350, respectively, and the χ value was controlled by varying the concentration of methanol. The more methanol the greater is χ. It was shown that for small concentrations of methanol, the biphasic range is narrow. As the volume fraction of methanol increases (up to 0.10–0.12) the biphasic range becomes wider.
76
Liquid Crystalline Polymers –0.2
I
–0.1
II
LC
I + LC⬘
0
LC⬘ LC⬘ + LC⬙
LC⬙
0.1 III
I + LC⬙ 0.2 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Figure 2.8.
Phase diagram for rod axial ratio of 100. (From Flory, 1956.)
Figure 2.9. Experimental phase diagram of PBLG/dimethyl formamide(DMF)methanol system. (Modified from Nakajama et al., 1968.)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.10.
77
The phase equilibrium vs. temperature. (From Miller et al., 1974.)
The value of χ varies with the temperature, i.e., χ decreases as the temperature increases. Wee & Miller (1971) examined the phase equilibrium as a function of temperature. The results are shown in Figure 2.10. For temperatures below 35 ◦ C the phase diagram is basically the same as the Flory theory; while at higher temperatures, the curve deflects to a high concentration regime. This phenomenon was observed in a system of cellulose derivatives (Navard et al., 1981). Warner and Flory (1980) found that the introduction of the anisotropic attractive force predicts this effect. This anisotropic interaction associated with molecular orientation is expressed by
xnp φS 2 T ∗ 1 − , (2.53) 2 T where S is the order parameter and T ∗ is the characteristic temperature which is a function of the anisotropy of the longitudinal and transverse electric susceptibilities kB T ∗ ∝ r−6 (∆α)2 , where r is the distance of neighboring rods.
78
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
2.2.5.
Semi-rigid chains
The completely extended chain is not essential for formatting a liquid crystal phase. In fact, most liquid crystalline polymers are semi-rigid chains, having more or less flexibility. The structural distortion during the polymerization and the flexible parts (introduced in polymer synthesis for the purpose of reducing the melting point and to improve solubility), etc., all reduce the rigidity of the polymer chains while retaining the liquid crystal phase. Flory (1978) pointed out that the above theory is applicable to the semi-rigid chains in terms of the Kuhn length vs. the repeated length. The axial ratio of the Kuhn segment can be expressed by
2 1/2 r 0 ρNA lk = , xk = D n l u Mu
(2.54)
where lk is the Kuhn length; r2 0 is the mean square end-to-end distance r2 0 = nk lk2 = (nlu )lk ,
(2.55)
where nk is number of Kuhn segments along a chain, nk lk is the extended length of the chain, n is the number of repeated units of a real chain, lu is the projection of a repeated unit onto the extended chain. D is the diameter of chain and
1/2 Mu , (2.56) D= ρNA lu where Mu is the molecular mass of a repeat unit; ρ is the density of the polymer and NA is Avogadro’s constant. The conformational distortions give rise to some flexibility of the molecules of cellulose derivatives. Tanner and Berry (1974) measured the mean square end-to-end distance of diacetate cellulose in trifluoroacetic acid r2 0 ≈ 1100 ˚ A n
(n → ∞).
3 ˚, Mu = 265, one obtains the Kuhn Assuming ρ = 1.3 g/cm , lu = 5.2 A length and the critical volume fraction as
xk = 26,
φ∗ = 0.284.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
79
Table 2.1. Comparison of theory and experimental data of various cellulose derivative solutions. (From Flory, 1978.) Derivative
Solvent
φ∗ (theory)
φ∗ (experiments)
diacetate cellulose
acetone dimethyl formamide dioxane∗∗ m-cresol trifluoroacetic acid acetate dichloroacetate water methanol ethanol acetate dimethylacetylamide
0.284 0.284 0.284 0.284 0.284 0.32 0.32 0.38 0.38 0.38 0.38 0.38
0.33 0.37 0.35 0.28 0.25 0.39 0.28 0.33, 0.37, 0.30 0.33 0.37, 0.39 0.27 0.32, 0.35
ethyl cellulose hydroxypropyl cellulose
3
For ethyl cellulose, assume ρ = 1.3 g/cm , lk = 180 ˚ A and one obtains xk = 23 and φ∗ = 0.32. 3
For hydroxypropyl cellulose ρ = 1.2 g/cm , lk = 180 ˚ A: xk = 19,
φ∗ = 0.38.
Table 2.1 summarizes the above calculations and compares them with the experimental data. Good agreement was found.
2.2.6.
Discussion of the Flory theory
Equation 2.28 was suggested in Flory’s 1956 approximation which is actually valid for a two-dimensional lattice. As shown in Figure 2.11, y is the projection of a rod’s length onto the plane (X–Y) perpendicular to the director in a three-dimensional lattice. But one would find that the system shows some orientational order at all concentrations even though for isotropic phase. To overcome the contradiction, Flory and Ronca (1979) made the following improvement for the three-dimensional lattice y = x sin θ(| sin φ| + | cos φ|)
(2.57)
80
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.11.
The Projection of a rod on X–Y plane. (From Flory & Ronca, 1979a)
where φ is the azimuthal angle of the rod’s projection onto the x axis. For a uniaxial nematic phase, the system is independent of φ. Averaging over φ y = (4/π)x sin θ.
(2.58)
It is more reasonable to adopt Equation 2.58 instead of Equation 2.28. It was pointed out that the approximation form in Equation 2.37 used for Zorient (valid only for high degrees of orientation) leads to the incorrect result that an isotropic phase can exist in a solution of rods in an external orienting field. Free energy resulting from the orientational distribution was precisely defined in the Onsager model (Equation 2.19) instead of Equation 2.35
Forient = kB T np
f (Ω) ln f (Ω)dΩ,
(2.59)
where the orientational function of rods f (n), similar to the function already applied in the Onsager model. Hence the off-orientational degree is expressed by
4 x sin θf (Ω)dΩ. y¯ = π
(2.60)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
81
In this modified Flory model, the liquid crystal–isotropic transition of rods in a solution occurs at D , L D φN = 11.57 , L Sc = 0.92. φI = 7.89
(2.61)
Only a minor change was found. No matter which Equation, 2.28 or 2.58, is used, y is zero if θ is zero. However, for perfectly oriented rods parallel to the z axis, y should be 1 in the lattice. The theory has omitted orientations with y < 1. Because x is generally large, the above approximation does not cause a significant error. Only for a small x regime does a modification become important. For the isotropic phase, one has y¯ = x, which implies that y may take values greater than x. This is forbidden in the lattice model. Fortunately, we apply here the Flory–Huggins model for the isotropic phase and we do not need to use the quantity y. In the liquid crystal phase y < x and the lattice model holds. It is worth pointing out that some assumptions of the Flory theory are valid only in a perfectly ordered phase, i.e., the Flory theory is more applicable in the case of high order and of large concentration.
2.3.
COMPARISON OF THE ONSAGER AND FLORY THEORIES
The Onsager and Flory theories are both statistical theories on rigid rod liquid crystalline polymers, but the former is a virial approximation while the latter is a lattice model. The first is more applicable to dilute solutions while the latter works especially well for high concentrations and a highly ordered phase. These theories with experiments, especially critical volume fractions φi and critical order parameter Sc at nematic–isotropic transition are made below. The Onsager theory points out that liquid crystalline polymers enter from the liquid crystal phase to the isotropic phase at the volume fraction φI =
3.3 x
(2.62)
82
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.12. Critical volume fraction vs. axial ratio: comparisons of Onsager and Flory theories with experimental data. (Modified from Ciferri, 1991. Reproduced by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.)
while Flory predicts that the critical volume fraction is
8 2 1− . φI = x x
(2.63)
These two predictions are depicted in Figure 2.12 together with some experimental data. In this figure, the dashed lines are the expectations from the Onsager and Flory theories. The points are for PBLG (molecular diameter D = 15.6 ˚ A in m-cresol (Hermans, 1962), marked “” and in dioxane, “ ” (Robinnov et al., 1958). In addition, the data of PBA (D = 5 ˚ A in DMAC (+3% LiCl) (•) (Bruzone, 1986) and in H2 SO4 () (Kwolek et al., 1977) and schizophylian (D = 16.7 ˚ A) dissolved in H2 O ( ) (Itou et al., 1985) were compared in Figure 2.12. It is shown that the predictions of the Onsager theory are smaller than that of the experimental data. This discrepancy is due to the second virial approximation. Adopting higher terms of virial coefficients may improve the predictions. Meanwhile, Flory predicts a higher critical volume fraction. It is thought that the Flory lattice model is comparatively simple, even though the addition of the soft interactions does not change this shortcoming. The real liquid crystalline polymers exhibit finite flexibility. This kind of polymer was studied extensively by Khokhlov and his co-workers. Assume that the semiflexible chain has the total contour length L, and Kuhn length l and diameter D, and L l D. Analogous to the Onsager model, the free energy of the polymer in solution is composed of the conformational
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
83
contribution Fconf and the steric interaction Fster . Khokhlov and Semenov (1982) defined Fster and Fconf for the semiflexble polymers as Fster
4 Lφ = NT π D
f (Ω1 )f (Ω2 )2l2 D| sin γ|dΩ1 dΩ2
and Fconf
L = NT l
[(∇n f )2 /4f ]dΩ.
(2.64)
(2.65)
They obtain the following quantities at the N–I transition D , l D φN = 11.39 , l Sc = 0.49. φI = 10.48
(2.66)
It has been illustrated that the jump of the order parameter at the transition is smaller in semiflexible polymers. When dealing with semiflexible polymers with L ∼ l they reported the results (Khokhlov & Semenov, 1982; Odijk, 1986)
2 D 3.34 + 11.3 Ll + 4.06 Ll φI = , L 1 + 0.387 Ll 2
1.07 + 14.4 Ll + 84.1 Ll φN =− , ln 1 − 2 φI 1 + 34.5 Ll 2 D 0.166 + 3.56 Ll + 15.9 Ll . ln Sc = 2 L 1 + 22.5 L
(2.67)
l
It is shown that only very rigid or very short polymers behave like rigid chains. For flexible chains the ratio of the Kuhn length or the persistence length to the molecular diameter (l/D) plays the same role that the axial ratio of molecules (L/D) does in the rigid rods. Figure 2.13 shows the expectations of Onsager and Flory theories (dashed lines) and the experimental data: hydroxypropylcellulose (HPC) (D = 10.4 ˚ A) dissolved in DMAc denoted as HPC/DMAc (Conio et al., 1988);
84
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.13. Critical volume fraction vs. ratio of persistence length to molecular diameter (l/D): comparisons of the Onsager and Flory theories with experimental data. (Modified from Ciferri, 1991. Reproduced by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.)
poly(n-hexyl isocyanate) (PHIC) (D = 10.3 ˚ A)/1-CN (Bianchi et al., 1987); PHIC/toluene (Krigbaum et al., 1985); acetoxypropylcellulose (APC)/DCM (Conio et al., 1984); APC (D = 12.0 ˚ A)/DMPh (Laivins & Gray, 1986); HPC/DCAc (Aden et al., 1984); cellulose acetate (CA) (D = 8.1 ˚ A)/DMAc (Bianchi et al., 1986); cellulose (D = 5.8 ˚ A)/DMAc (McCormick et al., 1985). Most experimental data fall between the two theoretical expectations with the Flory model representing the upper limit and the Onsager limit representing the lower limit. The two theories are in reasonable agreement with experimental data if the uncertainty of the molecular diameter D and Kuhn length l is taken into account. A comparison of the theoretical expectations of worm-like liquid crystalline polymers and experimental data is made in Figure 2.14. The abscissa is the ratio of total length to persistence length L/l; the ordinate is the critical volume fraction in the unit of the ratio of molecular diameter to persistence length. The theoretical expectation is taken from Khokhlov et al.’s theory (Khokhlov & Semenov, 1982; Odijk, 1986) on the worm-like chains.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
85
Figure 2.14. Critical volume fraction (in the unit of D/l) vs. the total length (in the unit of l): the curve for Khokhlov theory (Equation 2.67); the data taken from experimental data. (Modified from Ciferri, 1991. Reproduced by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.)
The experimental data are from the following solutions: PHIC(D = 12.5 ˚ A)/toluene, l = 750 ˚ A, PHIC/DMC, l = 370 ˚ A at room temperature (Conio et al., 1984) and PHIC/toluene at 25 ◦ C (Itou & Teramoto, 1984). It can be seen that the theoretical prediction of the worm-like chain is in good agreement with experiments. The diagram illustrates the relationship of the critical volume fraction and molecular length or molecular weight to the formation of a liquid crystal phase. Another important parameter is the critical order parameter Sc at the nematic-isotropic transition. The predictions of the Flory and Onsager theories for rigid rods are in good agreement with the experimental data of PBLG/PMF (30 ◦ C) (Abe & Yamazaki, 1989) and PBA/DMAc +3% LiCl (Sartirana et al., 1986). The order parameter of PBLG was measured by means of NMR on a deuteriated sample; while that for PBA was investigated via the dichroism ratio using polarizing IR spectroscopy. The Onsager theory seems to be in better agreement with the experiments. The worm-like chains allows continuous conformational deviations and thus significantly reduces the order parameter. In summary, the Flory theory is appropriate in dealing with critical volume fractions while the Onsager theory is better in predicting the order parameter at transition.
86
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
2.4. 2.4.1.
MAIER-SAUPE MEAN FIELD APPROACH Maier-Saupe mean field theory for small molecular mass liquid crystals
Liquid crystalline polymers can be regarded as a long chain with rods connected in sequence, each rod being, in some sense, equivalent to a small molecular mass liquid crystal. This is the so-called freely-jointed-rod chain, the simplest model of polymers. It is understood that the constituent units — small molecular mass liquid crystals play an essential role in liquid crystalline polymers. Here, we introduce an important theory for small molecular mass liquid crystal — the Maier–Saupe mean field theory (Maier & Saupe, 1959, 1960). In contrast to the Onsager and Flory theories, the Maier–Saupe theory no longer takes into account molecular steric effects as the basic interaction but instead proposes that the van der Waals interactions between molecules are the basis for forming a liquid crystal phase. The van der Waals interaction depends on molecular orientations. The Maier–Saupe theory adopts a rather simple mathematical treatment and can easily take into account the relationship of system properties to temperature. This theory has been successfully applied to a thermotropic system of small molecular mass liquid crystal. In this system, a molecule is subjected to the van der Waals attractions of other molecules in the system which is related to the relative orientations of the pair molecules. Suppose the Z axis is the reference direction. Then, the potential for each molecule is a function of orientation Ui = −a P2 (cos θij ) j P2 (cos θi ),
(2.68)
where θi is the angle of the molecular long axis made with respect to the Z axis, θij is the angle molecule j interacting with molecule i makes with respect to the Z axis. P2 = 3x2 /2− 12 is the second Legend polynomial. The bracket denotes the statistical average over all the molecules in the system and according to the definition the averaged quantity is actually the order parameter. Therefore, the mean field potential of a molecule is given by U = −aSP2 (cos θ),
(2.69)
where a is the constant of a van der Waals type interactions which is associated with the mean distance r between the molecules, being proportional
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
87
to r−6 . The coupling constant a depends on the molecular properties. For the nematic phase, which has no positional order and is uniaxially symmetrical, the potential U is independent of the position of the molecular masses and the azimuthal of the molecular orientations. The orientational distribution function is thus expressed by f (Ω) =
exp(−βU ) exp[βaSP2 (cos θ)] , = Z exp[βaSP2 (cos θ)]dΩ
(2.70)
where the denominator, Z, is the partition function. The order parameter S can be evaluated in terms of the orientational function 1 [P2 (cos θ)] exp[βaSP2 (cos θ)] sin θ dθ S = −1 1 (2.71) exp[βaSP2 (cos θ)] sin θ dθ −1 Equation 2.71 is the self-consistency equation for S. S depends on the combination kB T /a only, shown in Figure 2.15, and thus is a function of temperature and the coupling constant a. As kB T /a = 0.22019, a nematic to isotropic transition occurs. The temperature Tc is the N–I transition temperature at which S jumps from 0.4289 to zero.
Figure 2.15. The order parameter vs. reduced temperature for small molecular mass liquid crystals. (Modified from Maier & Saupe, 1959.)
88
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
The free energy in the nematic phase is F = ln N kB T
1
−1
exp[βaSP2 (cos θ)] sin θ dθ +
aS 2 . 2
(2.72)
The last term avoids double counting of the pair interaction in the mean field theory. At the transition, the free energy of both nematic and isotropic phases are equal. The latent change at the N–I transition is ∆E(Tc ) aSc2 = = 3.47 J/mol. K. N 2Tc
(2.73)
It is illustrated that the N–I transition is of first order. Experimentally, the latent entropies of small molecular mass liquid crystals, ∆E(Tc ), are very diverse, ranging from 1.25 to 7.55 J/mol. K. Most fall in the range of 2.50–3.35 J/mol. K. The Maier–Saupe prediction for the latent entropy at transition is in reasonable agreement with experiments. It is worthwhile to point out that the Maier–Saupe theory has been successful in analyzing the behavior of small molecular mass liquid crystals at transition, such as the temperature change of the order parameter. The jump of the order parameter at transition, Sc = 0.43 is in reasonable agreement with most experiments. The Onsager and Flory theories, which take into account the steric effects predict a higher critical order parameter.
2.4.2.
Freely-jointed-rod chains
In a very crude sense, liquid crystalline polymers can be regarded as a freely-jointed-rod chain, shown in Figure 2.16. The freely-jointed-rod chain consists of a series of repeated segments of length l0 . Each segment is able to rotate freely. It is assumed that the freely-jointed-rod chain is a replica of its small molecular mass liquid crystal counterpart in the liquid crystalline properties. 2.4.2.1.
Liquid crystallinity
The application of the Maier–Saupe theory to the polymer system results in the nematic to isotropic (N–I) transition temperature, Tc , the order
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
89
parameter, Sc , and the latent entropy of each repeated segment, ∆E(Tc )/N , at the transition as follows kB Tc = 0.2202, p Sc = 0.4289,
(2.74)
∆E(Tc ) = 0.42R, N where N is the degree of polymerization. R is the Gas constant. 2.4.2.2.
Polymer conformations
Molecular conformation is an important subject of concern in liquid crystalline polymers. It is also the basic subject of polymer science. The mean square end-to-end distance or the radius of gyration is often used to characterize the size of a polymer molecule. According to the definition, the end-to-end distance is the sum of each rod’s vectors in sequence R = l1 + l2 + · · · + lN =
N
li .
(2.75)
i
The statistical mean over all possible conformations is zero, so that only the mean square R2 (or mean square root) is meaningful. The radius of gyration is used often and is defined as follows Rg2 =
N mi r2 i
i
M
,
(2.76)
where r is the position vector of the i-th segment from the mass center of the polymer. The mean square end-to-end distance is related to the radius of gyration for a homogeneous, long random walk chain by R2
. (2.77) 6 The conformation of a freely-jointed-rod chain in the nematic liquid crystal is anisotropic and its end-to-end distance component along the z axis is evaluated as follows N
2 N N 2 2 liz = liz
+ liz ljz = N liz Rz2 = Rg2 =
i
i
N l (2S + 1) = N l2 cos2 θ = , 3
i,j
2
(2.78)
90
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
N where the summation i,j liz ljz is zero as the projections of each rod onto the z axis cancel each other. Similarly, the end-to-end distance component along the x or y axis is Rx2 = Ry2 = N l02
(1 − S) , 3
(2.79)
where sin2 φ = 12 . S is always positive so that the conformation of liquid crystalline polymers is of a prolate shape. In the isotropic phase S = 0 and the components of end-to-end distance are all equal, i.e., N l2 /3. It is understood that the extension of a freely-jointed-rod chain along the director is due to the preferred orientation of each segment. The maximum Rz2 is less than N l2 , which is a result of random walk. In other words, a freely-jointed rod chain cannot produce the rod-like conformation expected for liquid crystalline polymers at low temperature.
2.4.3.
Elastically-jointed-rod chains
As is expected, at low temperatures liquid crystalline polymers have, to a great extent, a rod-like conformation. This is not predicted by a freelyjointed-rod chain. To overcome this shortcoming Warner and Wang (1992c) proposed the theory of elastically-jointed-rod chains in which any deviations of consecutive rods’ orientation causes an energy penalty. The jointed-rod chain is one-dimensional system of a series of repeated segments and we naturally apply the Transfer matrix technique in the Ising model to obtain the partition function for both the freely-jointed-rods and the elastically-jointed-rods. We will not go into the details of this model but instead will show some results derived from the model. Wang (1995a) calculated the N–I transition temperature, the critical order parameter and the latent entropy at transition according to the model kB Tc = 0.541, p Sc = 0.500,
(2.80)
∆E(Tc ) = 0.25R. N It is noted that the same conclusions are not reached by using previous results derived from the Maier–Saupe method. The transfer matrix
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
91
approach predicts higher transition temperatures and less latent entropy at transition. One reason is the simplicity of the discrete orientation approximation in the transfer matrix approach. The difference may also result from the fact that the Maier–Saupe method is actually specified for small molecular mass liquid crystals and does not take into account that connections of consecutive segments reduce the system entropy. Experimentally, the N–I transition temperature increases as the degree of polymerization increases. The higher Tc prediction for a freely-jointed-rod chain of liquid crystalline polymers is expected from the same argument. Meanwhile, the latent entropy at transition is reasonably less than that of the Maier–Saupe results. For the elastically-jointed-rod chain, the nematic mean field energy is expressed as pSP2 (ni ), (2.81) Un = − i
where p is the Maier–Saupe coefficient of one monomer and ni denotes the orientation of the i-th segment. In addition, there is an elastic energy associated with the bending of the successive rods, q (ni+1 − ni )2 , (2.82) UB = 2 i
where, q is the bend elasticity. Thus the Hamiltonian of a polymer is expressed as q −pSP2 (ni ) + (ni+1 − ni )2 . Hi = 2
(2.83)
i
In principle, ni can be any orientation in three-dimensional space. For simplicity, we limit the orientation of each segment to six directions, i.e., the three orthogonal axes in a cubic lattice. The six orientations are: n = 1 for pointing up, n = −1 for pointing down and n = 0 for four transverse directions, rightward, leftward, forwards and backward, the degeneracy being four, as shown in Figure 2.16. Split the Maier–Saupe potential into two terms and express the partition function as a b 2 [P2 (ni+1 ) + P2 (ni )] − (ni+1 − ni ) , Z= exp (2.84) 2 2 ni
i
where a = βpS and b = βq. b is actually the ratio of persistence length to repeated unit length, l/l0 . We assume that b is constant. The summa tion is made over all possible orientations of each segment while the
92
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
i–2
i–1
i–1 i
i
i+1 i+1
(a)
Figure 2.16.
(b)
The discrete orientations of rods in Warner and Wang’s model (1992c).
multiplication is the product over all segments along the chain. To meet the requirement of the transverse matrix method, we assume nN +1 = n1 . Because there are many segments in a chain the assumption does not affect the results. The partition function can be further written as a matrix form (i−1)
Z = · · · Mξη
(i)
(i+1)
Mηζ Mζδ
··· ,
(2.85)
where the repeated subscript ηη, ξξ, . . . indicates the summation over all orientations of n and the superscript i is the index for the respective segment. The 6 × 6 matrix M is (i) (i+1) Mηζ = nη(i) |exp[−βH(ni , ni+1 )]| nξ . (2.86) The operator H(ni , ni+1 ), given by Equation 2.83, on |n > generates the Boltzmann factor of Equation 2.86. The degeneracy g = 4 makes it possible to project the 6 × 6 matrix M to a 3 × 3 one. This deduction significantly simplifies the underlying problem and allows one to have analytic solutions of the eigenvalues of the matrix. The transfer matrix M of 3 × 3 is accordingly expressed as ea 2ea/4−b/2 ea−b/2 M = 2ea/4−b/2 (1 + 2e−b/2 + e−2b )ea/2 2ea/4−b/2 , (2.87) ea−2b 2ea/4−b/2 ea where a = pS/kB T , b = q/kBT . b is actually associated with the chain rigidity. The coefficients of the matrix elements result from the degeneracy.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
93
Because each matrix is the same and thus the partition function is the trace of the product of the N matrices, M N Z = Tr M
N
=
3
λN j ,
(2.88)
j=1
where Tr denotes the trace and λi is the i-th eigenvalue of the matrix. The trace of N -power of matrix, M N is the sum of the N -power of all eigenvalues. Because N is very large, Z is dominated by the largest eigenvalue, λmax . The free energy of a nematic polymer is associated with the largest eigenvalue, λmax , of the matrix M F T p2 = − ln λmax + , N kB T 2
(2.89)
where T ≡ kB T /p is the reduced temperature. Substituting λmax into the equation, we obtain the free energy which is a function of the nematic coupling a, the chain rigidity (l/l0 ) and the temperature T . The transition temperature can be obtained from the form of free energy. The form of free energy is rather complicated. We apply the Landau-de Gennes theory to analyze it. Landau used a very simple form of free energy to describe systems such as the para-magnetic system where the magnetic polarization M is the order parameter. The idea has been extended by de Gennes (1973) to deal with nematic liquid crystals. The free energy is given in the extended Landau-de Gennes form as F = a(T − T ∗ )S 2 − BS 3 + CS 4 , (2.90) where a, B and C are positive coefficients. Figure 2.17 depicts the relationship of free energy and the order parameter S for various temperatures. When temperature is high, the isotropic state is stable. If the temperature is low, the minimum free energy exists at a non-zero order parameter, i.e., the nematic phase is stable. When the temperature is between T and T there are two minimums of free energy. The one with zero free energy corresponds to the isotropic phase while the other corresponds to the nematic phase. T is the limit of temperature at which the super-cooled isotropic phase exists while T is the limit at which the nematic phase completely vanishes. There is a temperature at which the two minima have the same free energy for the nematic to isotropic transition. At the N–I transition, the order parameter jumps from zero in the isotropic phase to a finite value
94
Liquid Crystalline Polymers F
T > Tc
T = Tc
T=T*
0
Sc
S
Figure 2.17. Free energy vs. order parameter S for various temperatures according to Landau–de Gennes theory.
of the nematic phase. This is the first order phase transition. At temperature T where the quadratic term vanishes, i.e., T = T ∗ , is the pseudo second phase transition temperature. In fact, the N–I transition is a weak first order transition. We quantitatively analyze the problem below. The stable state of the system is given by 2a(T − T ∗ )S − 3BS 2 + 4CS 3 = 0.
(2.91)
This is a cubic equation. One solution S = 0 is for the isotropic phase. The second solution is for the nematic phase which is a function of temperature $ 3 32a(T − T ∗ )C S= 1+ 1+ . (2.92) 8 9B 2 The third solution corresponds to the maximum free energy at which the system is not stable. At the N–I transition, the free energy is the same for both isotropic and nematic phases with different order parameters, 0 and Sc . Thus the N–I transition temperature is obtained as Tc = T ∗ +
B2 . (4aC)
(2.93)
The first term in the formula is the pseudo second order phase transition temperature T ∗ . The coefficient B is not great, therefore the second term is not significant. The difference of Tc and T ∗ is small, experimentally only a few degrees difference.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
95
Expanding the free energy in Equation 2.89 to the fourth power gives the Landau–de Gennes form. One can evaluate the thermodynamic properties accordingly. In the elastically-jointed-rod chain, the mean square end-to-end distance along the director tends to be a rod as q approaches infinity or T is very small, i.e., Rz2 → N 2 l02
2.4.4.
b → ∞.
as
(2.94)
Discrete and continuum chain models
If we take the limit of the rod length l0 → 0 and the number of rods N → ∞ such that the polymer length is kept constant L = N l0 , we have an integral instead of a summation: L L= hi → ds, (2.95) i
0
where hi is the length of each segment along the jointed-rods and s is the contour length of a point along a continuous chain. The discrete elasticallyjointed-rod chain thus evolves into a continuous elastic chain or the worm chain. In this case, the bending elastic energy becomes
2 1 θi+1 − θi 2 dθ 1 L h qh → dsε , Uel → 2 h 2 0 ds
(2.96)
i
where the elastic constant ε = ql0 as q → ∞ and l0 → 0. Meanwhile, the nematic part, Unem , becomes Unem
L p →− h SP2 (cos θi ) → − dsvSP2 (cos θ(s)), h 0
(2.97)
i
where v = p/l0 as l0 → 0 and p → 0. v is the nematic coupling constant per unit length. These two parts constitutes the energy for a worm-like nematic polymer. The first part (Equation 2.96) demands a slow reversal as a chain evolves and favors parallel alignment, but the second term (Equation 2.97) prefers both anti-parallel and parallel alignments, and a rapid reversal of
96
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
orientations. A natural scale of length ξ emerges to balance the two effects. In terms of the parameters p and q of the discrete chain $ q ξ= (2.98) pS or in terms of v and ε of the worm chain $ ε ξ= . vS
(2.99)
If ξ < l0 , it becomes the case of the discrete picture and jointed-rods are applicable. If ξ > l0 , however, the elastically discrete polymer evolves into a worm chain, i.e., an elastically homogeneous chain. The orientation change can then take place over a length comparable to l0 . With this continuum of allowed orientational states, the worm chain accurately represents the angular entropy of the real polymer.
2.5.
2.5.1.
WORM CHAIN MODEL OF LIQUID CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS Path integral description for polymers
The path integral technique was first proposed by Feynmann (Feynmann & Hibbs, 1965). The purpose of this technique was to deal with questions in quantum mechanics. It has been applied to the study of the statistical mechanics of polymer systems (Kreed, 1972; Doi & Edwards, 1986) and liquid crystalline polymers as well (Jahnig, 1981; Warner et al., 1985; Wang & Warner, 1986). The path integrals relate the configurations of a polymer chain to the paths of a particle when the particle is undergoing Brownian or diffusive motion. The path integral for a jointed-chain polymer, with a step length c, is given by
r(L)=R
G(R, R ; L) =
D[r(s)] r(0)=R
× exp −
0
L
3 2 ds r˙ (s) + U (r(s)) 2c
(2.100)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
which is also described by the differential equation c 2 ∂ − ∇ + U (r) G(R, R ; L) = δ(R − R )δ(L), ∂s 6 r
97
(2.101)
where Dt = c/6 is the translational diffusion coefficient. G(R, R ; L) is the Green function for the diffusion equation or propagator, and δ(R − R ) the Dirac delta function. If the chain is worm-like, the bending of the chain will cost the energy
Uel =
L
0
2 ε du(s) ds, 2 ds
(2.102)
where ε is the bending constant, u is the tangent along the chain at contour length s, u ≡ r˙ = ∂r/∂s, and is a unit vector. This elastic energy give rise to the Boltzmann factor of Equation 2.100, therefore the path integral becomes the case of a worm-like chain, u˙ ≡ ∂u/∂s,
G(R, R ; U , U ; L) =
r(L)=R
D[r(s)] r(0)=R
×
u(L)=U
u(0)=U
× exp −
0
where
R=
0
D[u(s)]δ R − L
L
dsu(s)
0
3 2 βε 2 u (s) + u˙ (s) ds 2c 2
(2.103)
L
u(s)ds = r(L) − r(0).
(2.104)
The unit vector u, enables Equation 2.103 to be rewritten as, by taking D[R(s)], u(L)=U L βε 2 D[u(s)] exp − ds u˙ (s) , (2.105) G(U , U ; L) = 2 0 u(0)=U where the uninteresting term exp(−3L/2c) is absorbed into the normalization factor.
98
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Analogous to Equation 2.101, G satisfies the diffusion equation ∂ 1 2 (2.106) − ∇u G(U, U ; L) = δ(U − U )δ(L), ∂s 2βε where 1/(2βε) is a rotational diffusion constant which we denote by Dr , or D below. The Green function G can be expressed as an infinite series in the eigen-functions Ylm (θ, φ), the Spherical harmonics. θ and φ are the polar and azimuthal angles that u makes with respect to a reference direction, e.g., the z axis. Having sketched the concepts of the path integral approach in conventional polymers, we now shift to the nematic liquid crystalline polymers. In the smectic phase of polymers, the positional order term is expected to become important (Renz & Warner 1986). We are concerned here only with polymers in their nematic phase with no positional potential and with a uniaxial system. The path integral for nematic polymers is given by (Warner et al., 1985) 2 du(s) Z = D[u(s)] exp βaS dsP2 (cos θ) − (βε/2) ds . ds (2.107) Note that the path integral in Equation 2.107 is in fact the same as that for diffusion of a point on the surface of a unit sphere with diffusion constant D = 1/(2βε). The reciprocal of this diffusion constant is actually the persistence length l. In the presence of a potential −vSP2 (cos θ), Equation 2.107 reduces to a “Schrodinger type” differential function: ∂ (2.108) − D∇2u − βvSP2 G(U, U ; s, s ) = δ(U − U )δ(s − s ). ∂s If we relax the unit vector condition of u, we can obtain an analytical solution to the differential equation. The relaxation of this condition allows the use of the Wiener integral in the case. Unfortunately, this does not give a good description of a polymer. It fails to reproduce rod-like behavior when an isotropic chain is short (Freed, 1972). The green function G can be expressed in the Spheroidal wave functions, Spn (z), i.e.,
G(z, z ; s, s ) =
∞ 2n + 1 n=0
2
Spn (z)Spn (z ) exp(−λn D|s − s |),
(2.109)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
99
where z = cos θ and λn = (2/3)∆2 are the eigenvalues where ∆2 = −3vεSβ 2 =
−3S T 2
√ with T = kB T / vε, the reduced temperature. G is Markovian. The partition function is the integral of G over all orientations Z= dzdz G(z, z ; L) =
∞ 2n + 1
2
−λn L dzSpn (z) exp . l
2
n=0
(2.110)
If the chain is reasonably long, compared to the persistence length, only the ground state where n = 0 is dominant and taken into account. Therefore, the free energy is expressed by F = λ0 +
2.5.2.
S2 . (T )2
(2.111)
Anisotropic conformation
In the isotropic phase, differential Equation 2.106 is simplified to the Legendre equation with eigenfunctions, the Legendre polynomials Pn (cos θ) and the eigenvalues n(n + 1). The mean square end-to-end distance component parallel to the director is given by L L 2 dsds cos θ cos θ
Rz = 0
=
1 3
0
0 L L
dsds exp
0 −2L/l
[Ll − l2 (1−e 2 = 3
)
]
−(λ1 − λ0 )|s − s | l
.
(2.112)
The three components of the mean square end-to-end distances are the same. If the chain is long enough, the chain conformation is of random walk R2 = Ll
(2.113)
100
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
and the step length is the persistence length l. If L/l is very small then R2 = L2 .
(2.114)
The chain becomes a rod. For nematic polymers, their conformation is no longer spherical, but a prolate ellipsoid. The mean square end-to-end distance of the chain at its nematic phase is anisotropic. For large L/l, the components parallel and perpendicular to the director are given respectively by 1 2 3 Ll 2 Sp0 (z)Sp1 (z)zdz , (2.115) Rz = 4 λ1 − λ0 −1 1 2 3 Ll 2 2 1 2 Rx = Ry = Sp0 (z)Sp1 (z) 1 − z dz , (2.116) 8 λ11 − λ0 −1 where Sp11 and λ11 are the eigenfunction and eigenvalue, respectively, of the first rank Spheroidal wave equation. The two mean square end-to-end distance components vs. the intermediate parameter −∆2 are shown in Figure 2.18. The abscissa is normalized by the value in the isotropic phase.
Figure 2.18. The mean square end-to-end distance of worm chains vs. −∆2 . (From Wang, 1997.)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
101
As polymers enter from the isotropic phase into the nematic phase, −∆2 jumps from zero to a finite value of about 7. The corresponding ratio of the mean square root of the end-to-end distance component parallel to the director is about 3.
2.5.3.
Order parameter
In terms of the Spheroidal wave function, the order parameter may be re-expressed as 1 [Sp0 (z)]2 P2 (z)dz. (2.117) S= 0
Sp0 (z) is a function of ∆2 , hence, S and T . Thus, the equation is self-consistent. The nematic-isotropic transition occurs when the free energies of the nematic and the isotropic phases are equal, i.e., λ0 +
S2 = 0, (T )2
(2.118)
where λ0 is the eigenvalue of the ground state of the Spheroidal wave function. The S vs. T relationship (Wang & Warner, 1986) is similar to the well√ known Maier-Sauipe shape, the temperature scale being T = kB T / νε instead of T = kB T /p. The order parameter decreases as T increases until the critical temperature Tc = 0.388. The order parameter discontinually jumps from 0.356 to zero. Because T is the reduced temperature the transition temperature Tc is a function of the geometric mean of ν and ε. The greater v, the higher Tc . The more ε, the more stable the nematic phase. These conclusions are consistent with experiments. It was found that the critical order parameter for the semi-flexible liquid crytalline polymers ranges from 0.3 to 0.45.
2.5.4.
Dependence of N–I transition on polymer chain length
It is worth pointing out that after expanding the free energy in the Landau– de Gennes form and taking into account the entropic contribution of the free ends of the chain (contrary to circle polymers) and the n = 2 term in
102
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.19. N–I transition temperature Tc against the chain length L. (From Wang & Warner, 1986.)
Equation 2.110, we obtain the analytical expression for the pseudo-secondphase-transition temperature (Wang, 1995a) T ∗ =
6L 2 1 − l/6L(1 − e− l ) , 15
(2.119)
which is reminiscent of the numerical calculation of the N–I transition temperature vs. the chain length or the degree of polymerization, shown in Figure 2.19. The N–I transition temperature, or the pseudo-second-phase-transition temperature, increases as the chain length increases and then saturates to a finite value when L/l is greater than, e.g., about 1.5. Griffin et al. (1989) and Blumstein et al. (1984) found that for a monomer, dimer, oligomer as well as a polymer with the same building units displaying a nematic phase, the transition temperature increases with an increasing degree of polymerization and then rapidly saturates, as shown in Figure 2.20. Good agreement was found for the above theory and experimental data. 2.5.5.
Latent entropy at transition
Ignoring the temperature dependence of ε, as justified by Jahnig (1979), the latent entropy ∆E for a repeat unit at the transition (Wang & Warner, 1986) is
∆E(Tc ) l0 , (2.120) = 1.69R N l
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
103
Figure 2.20. N–I transition temperature Tc against the molecular weight. (From Blumstein et al. 1984.)
where N is the degree of polymerization and l0 and l are lengths of the repeat unit and persistence length. It is known that the persistence length is normally about 2–10 times that of the repeat units for polymers, depending on the real structure of polymers. It is seen that the latent entropy is no longer a universal value, as in the Maier–Saupe theory. Some experimental results has been reviewed by Luckhurst (1986). The worm chain in a possible polar nematic phase was discussed as well (Wang & Lam, 1992). The dipolar interaction was taken into account in addition to the quadrupolar interaction. It results in the complexity of the phase diagram.
2.6.
2.6.1.
MAIN CHAIN LIQUID CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS WITH SPACERS Molecularly non-homogeneous liquid crystalline polymers
Most main chain liquid crystalline polymers are composed of mesogenic units linked by spacers with varying degrees of flexibility, such as repeated methylene, oxyethylene, or siloxane groups, etc., in order to reduce the
104
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.21. Schematic of liquid crystalline polymers with spacers where i denotes the i-th segments (the i-th spacer and the i-th rod).
mesomorphic temperature of liquid crystalline polymers and to be able to process them. The participation of flexible spacers dramatically changes the properties of liquid crystalline polymers. These properties depend not only on the mesogenic units but also on the type of flexible spacers. The theoretical basis for these liquid crystalline polymers has been studied by, for example, Matheson & Flory (1981), Yurasova & Semenov (1991) and Wang & Warner (1992a,b). Flexible spacers are constrained by the mesogenic units to which they are linked in order to have some orientational order. In turn, they affect the order of the mesogenic units which are not decoupled. It is also expected that the spacers have an order that differs from that of the mesogenic units. The liquid crystalline polymer with spacers is schematically shown in Figure 2.21. In this polymer, the mesogenic units are modeled as rigid rods in a quadrupolar potential while the spacers are regarded as a worm chain according to the Spheroidal approach. The physical linkage is examined. Meanwhile, the molecular parameters such as the self and cross couplings between the rods and spacers (denoted by constants va , vb and vab ), the lengths of the two components, a and b, and the persistence length of spacer l, are also taken into account. In all that follows, the subscripts A and B denote rod and spacer segments, respectively. The partition function Z of a polymer chain of this kind results from summing over all orientational angles θi for the rods and over all choices of the contours of chains, u(θ) or θ(s), for the worm spacers: z=
N i=1
×
N −1
δ(zbi − z0i+1 )
i=1
−λ0 b [Sp0 (z0i )Sp0 (zbi ) exp dz0i dzbi ]. l
N i=1
exp[βv UA P2 (z0i )]
(2.121)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
105
The Dirac delta functions, δ, ensure that the ends of spacers, B, have the same orientation as the consecutive A rods to which they are attached. UA and UB are the linear transformations of φSa and (1 − φ)Sb , Sa and Sb are the orders of A and B components, respectively, the tranformation matrix being associated with the self and cross couplings:
UA va vab φSa = . UB vab vb (1 − φ)Sb The volume fractions of rods and worms, φ and (1 − φ), as prefactors in each term are due to the dilutions of each component. Performing the summation over the rod’s direction, the partition function becomes, for large N N
λ0 N b 2 Z = exp exp[βvUA P2 (z)[Sp0 (z)] dz . (2.122) l We are now able to evaluate the order parameters of rods and spacers vs. temperature (Figure 2.22), the transition temperature as a function of the molecular parameters, such as the geometrical lengths a, b and l (it has the length dimension but is actually the rigidity of the worm spacers), and the coupling constants va , vb and vab , shown in Figure 2.23(a–e). In these figures, the transition temperature Tred is relative to the N–I transition temperature of the pure rods, i.e., T0 = 0.22va /kB .
Figure 2.22. The order parameters S vs. reduced temperature Tred . (From Wang & Warner, 1992a.)
106
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
(a)
(c)
a:b:l=a:2:1
a:b:l=2:2:l
(e)
(b)
(d)
a:b:l=2:b:1
va : vab : vb = 1 : 0.5 : vb
va : vab : vb = 1 : vab : 0.2
Figure 2.23. The transition temperature against the molecular parameters: (a) rod’s length a; (b) spacer’s length b; (c) persistence length of spacer l; (d) self coupling constant of spacers vb ; (e) cross coupling constant vab . (From Wang & Warner, 1992a.)
The following conclusions can be obtained from these plots. The transition temperature Tc increases significantly as va increases, and increases at an intermediate speed with vab , but is weakly dependent on vb . Tc increases as the length of the rods a and the persistence length l of the worm spacers increase, while Tc decreases with increasing spacer length, b. The order of mesogenic units is generally greater than that of spacers.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers (a)
107
1R2z2/N2(a + b)2
b/l=
0.8
Worm chain 0.5
0.6 1
0.4 2
0.2
Freely-jointed-rods 0 (b) 1R2 2/ p
2 3
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Tred
N(a + b)2
0.5 Freely-jointed-rods
0.4 0.3
b/l Worm chain
0.2
2 1
0.1 0.5 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Tred
2 Figure 2.24. The mean square end-to-end distance (a) < Rz2 > and (b) < Rp > against the reduced temperature Tred . (From Wang & Warner, 1992a.)
The latter’s order is enhanced by the former. Experiments are being carried out on polymers with deuteriated spacers, and/or deuteriated mesogenic groups. The results of such experiments can be used to test the theory. In Figure 2.24(a,b), the mean square end-to-end distance components along and perpendicular to the director are plotted respectively against the temperature relative to the transition temperature of the pure rods. In order to emphasize their features, we apply different vertical scales for Rz2 and Rp2 , the former is reduced by N 2 (a + b)2 , the value in perfect order; while
108
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
the latter is relative to the random walk value in the isotropic phase. For comparison, the mean square end-to-end distance of both the freely-jointedrod chain and worm chain is plotted in the same figures. Rz2 and Rp2 are no longer universal curves, depending on the molecular parameters. One of the advantages is that this non-homogeneous model connects the statistical properties of main chain liquid crystalline polymers to their molecular parameters.
2.6.2.
Pseudo-second-order-phase-transition temperature
For simplicity, assume that vab is the geometrical mean of va and vb , i.e., the Berthelot law, and extend the free energy derived from Equation 2.122 in the power series of Sa and Sb . The zero determinant of the quadratic coefficients gives the pseudo-second-phase-transition temperature as follows (Wang, 1995a)
∗
kB T =
√ 3a2 va + blvb + 2al va vb . 15(a + b)
(2.123)
In the second-order approximation of the free energy, above T ∗, Sa and Sb are both zero. Below T ∗, the order parameters are non-zero. At T ∗, the quadratic terms vanish. This formula illustrates the pseudo-secondphase-transition temperature vs. the molecular parameters that shows the same shapes as those of the numerical calculations of the N–I transition temperature Tc , mentioned above.
2.6.3.
Hinge effect
On the basis of this argument, we may be able to deal with the hinge effect, i.e., the effect of the orientational deviation α of the conjunctive mesogen and spacer on the phase transition. The picture is depicted in Figure 2.25. The free energy becomes dependent on the deviation α, i.e.,
2 F 1 β(va UA Sa + vb UB Sb ) λ0 b = + − dφdφ N kB T 2 l 2π × exp[βvUA P2 (cos θ)]Sp0 (cos θ)Sp0 (cos γ)dθ,
(2.124)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
109
n
(a)
n –
(b)
Figure 2.25. Schematic of the hinge effect of the main chain liquid crystalline polymers. (From Wang, 1995b.)
where γ is the angle of the spacer at the conjunction to the director which is associated with the mesogenic rod’s orientation θ, the deviation angle α and their azimuthal angles φ and φ cos γ = cos θ cos α + sin θ sin α cos(φ − φ ).
(2.125)
If the Spheroidal wave function Sp0 (cos θ) is expanded in terms of the Legendre polynomials as Sp0 (cos θ) =
∞
an Pn (cos θ)
(2.126)
n=0
and the integral of Sp0 (cos γ) over φ and φ in Equation 2.124 gives
1 2π
2
dφdφ Sp0 (cos γ) =
∞
an Pn (cos θ)Pn (cos α)
(2.127)
n=0
then the pseudo-second-phase-transition temperature can be deduced. The transition resulting from the hinged case is √ l2 vb + 6al va vb T ∗ (α) − T ∗ (0) sin2 α = − , (2.128) √ T ∗ (0) 4 3a2 va + blvb + 2al va vb where T ∗ (0) and T ∗ (α) are for non-hinged and hinged cases, respectively. The difference is proportional to the square of sin α. For example, as
110
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
a = b = l and vb /va = 0.1, α = 45◦ , the left hand side of Equation 2.128 is −1/15. If the transition temperature of the non-hinged T ∗ (0) = 180 ◦ C, the hinged temperature will be 150 ◦ C. The well known even-odd effect in liquid crystals may be attributed to the hinge effect. For liquid crystalline polymers with the even carbon atoms in their spacers, the overall contribution of even –CH2 –CH2 – bonds makes the conjunctions bent. The odd counterparts do not have such an effect. Thus, the transitions for even ones are lower than those of odd ones. This hinge effect offers an explanation for the even-odd effect.
2.7.
SIDE CHAIN LIQUID CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS
In this section, we are concerned with another kind of liquid crystalline polymer – side chain liquid crystalline polymers. According to the ways in which the side chains are connected to the backbone, they are classified into two main categories—the end-on side chain liquid crystalline polymers (Ringsdorf & Schneller, 1981) in which the side chains are terminally attached to backbone, and the side-on (laterally attached) side chain liquid crystalline polymers (Hessel & Finkelmann, 1985). Recently, shoulderly attached liquid crystalline polymers (Gray et al., 1989) were synthesized in which the side chain attachment is off-set from the center of the side chain. There is a kind of side chain liquid crystalline polymers where both backbones and side chains are comprised of mesogenic groups, i.e., the combined liquid crystalline polymers. More recently, a co-polymer (Dumon et al., 1995) combining end-on mesogenic groups and side-on chromophores was prepared which exhibits a liquid crystal phase. We will limit ourselves to the end-on side chain nematic polymers in this discussion.
2.7.1.
Model
A model presented by Wang & Warner (1987) quantitatively describes the statistical mechanics of side chain nematic polymers with a semi-flexible backbone and stiff mesogenic side chains. In general, side chains and backbones have different orders, the former denoted by SA and the latter denoted by SB , respectively. The phase types, phase diagrams and backbone conformations in each phase is dependent on the competition of side chains of various lengths, x, and backbone of various stiffness, ε. Mesogenic
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
111
side chains prefer to align parallel to each other because of anisotropic interactions, characterized by va , while the backbones behave like worm chains, characterized by ε and vb . In addition, there is the hinge elasticity vf , which forces side chains and backbones to be perpendicular, and the van der Waals attraction vc , compelling two parts to be parallel. The side chains are regularly attached to the backbone with the gap n. Assuming the cross-sections of the side chains and backbones are equal, the maximum possible value of the volume fraction is φ = x/(x + 1). φ varies at fixed x by changing n, or equally at fixed n by changing x, or equally by changing x and n together. The lengths of backbones L and side chains x are all relative to the cross-section d and these lengths are equivalent to the number of cells with dimension d in the lattice. In terms of the above five interaction constants (va , vb , vc , vf and ε), we can write the mean field potential of a side chain as US = −{φva xSA + [(1 − φ)vc x − vf ]SB }P2 (z). Meanwhile the nematic energy of a backbone is given by L UB = −{(1 − φ)vb SB + [φvc − vf /n]SA } dsP2 [uz (s)].
(2.129)
(2.130)
0
2.7.2.
Phase classification of side chain nematic polymers
According to the competition of all the interactions in the side chain nematic polymers, there are three uniaxial nematic phases: NI , NII , NIII . The three phases, each having a special conformation, may transform each other when the free energies are equal. These phases are shown in Figure 2.26 with the director pointing upward. In the NI phase, SA > 0, but SB < 0. The conformation of the backbone chain is discus-like, i.e., is oblate shape, in which the mean square end2
is less than the perpendicular to-end distance along the director, RZ 2 component RP . In the smectic phase the anisotropy of two components is greater than that in the nematic phase. At the extreme case the backbone is surpassed in a plane, which was predicted by Renz & Warner (1986) to exist in smectic polymers where backbones become confined between smectic layers formed by side chains, and has been seen by Moussa et al. (1987). In the extreme case, the backbone becomes a two-dimensional random walk when SB = − 12 and SA = 1.
112
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.26. The three nematic phases of side chain nematic polymers: NI , NII , NIII . (From Wang & Warner, 1987.)
In the NII phase, SA < 0, but SB > 0, the conformation is bottle brush-like. In the NIII phase, both SA and SB are positive. In the latter two phases backbones have the spindle-like conformation, 2 2 i.e., the prolate shape with RZ
> RP
, the characteristic of main chain liquid crystalline polymers. Important means of investigating the conformations of side chain liquid crystalline polymers include small angle neutron scattering from deuterium-labeled chains (Kirst & Ohm, 1985), or small angle X-ray scattering on side chain liquid crystalline polymers in a small molecular mass liquid crystal solvent (Mattossi et al., 1986), deuterium nuclear resonance (Boeffel et al., 1986), the stress- or electro-optical measurements on crosslinked side chain liquid crystalline polymers (Mitchell et al., 1992), etc. Actually, the nematic (or smectic modifications) phases of the side chain liquid crystalline polymers have been substantially observed by experiments.
2.7.3.
Order parameter and phase transitions
Figure 2.27(a) is an example of order parameters vs. temperature in which the length of the side chain is x = 5 and the volume fraction of the side chains is φ = 0.5. Figure 2.27(b) shows S vs. T for x = 3 and φ = 0.4, where T0 is the N–I transition temperature of a neat backbone system. There are NIII , NI and I phases in the former case while NII , NI and I phases are in the latter.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
113
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.27. Orders vs. temperature of side chain nematic polymers (a) x = 5, φ = 0.5 and (b) x = 3, φ = 0.4. (From Wang & Warner, 1987.)
Experimental results of the order parameter SA of side groups of side chain liquid crystalline polymers are shown in Figure 2.28, where the chemical formulae of the side group polymers are CH3 (CH3)3Si O Si O Si(CH3)3 (CH2)mO
COO
OCH3
114
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.28. Order parameter of side groups of side chain liquid crystalline polymers and small molecular mass liquid crystal vs. temperature. (Modified from Finkelmann, 1991. Reproduced by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.)
where m = 3, marked by “•”; m = 4, by “◦”; m = 6, by “”. The order parameter data of the counterpart small molecular mass liquid crystal, marked by “”, is drawn in the same figure. The phase diagram for a system of x = 5 and φ = 0.5 is plotted in Figure 2.29 where the relative ratio of the coupling constants va : vb : vc : vf : ε/d = 3 : 2 : 1 : 3 : 2. If all parameters are kept constant but vc increased by a factor 2, NII phase disappears while the NIII phase comes out, see Figure 2.29. The phase diagram of the side chain systems depends on the interactions and dimensions of the backbone and side chains. Generally, a high volume fraction φ favors the NI phase as the side chain effect becomes important; otherwise the NII and NIII phases appear, likely owing to the presence of the backbone. SA is positive for the NI and NIII phases which have opposite SB . Either NI or NIII phase is likely to appear, depending on the value of (φvc − vf /n). Large (φvc − vf /n) favors the NIII phase; otherwise the NI phase is likely to appear. The length of the side groups is important in determining the phase diagram as well. Longer side chain favors the NIII phase, otherwise the NII phase is favored, see Figure 2.29. va and φ, vb and (1 − φ) play a similar role in the competition. A high vc favors the NIII
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
115
Figure 2.29. Phase diagrams of side chain nematic polymers: va : vb : vc : vf : ε/d = 3 : 2 : 1 : 3 : 2 and va : vb : vc : vf : ε/d = 3 : 2 : 2 : 3 : 2. (From Wang & Warner, 1987.)
phase. For a small vc , the effect of vf becomes important and the NII phase is likely to appear, as shown in Figure 2.29.
2.7.4.
Conformations
The backbones in the NII and NIII phases are prolate, the same as that of main chain liquid crystalline polymers. In the NI phase, the backbone is oblate. If the side chain liquid crystalline polymers goes into the smectic A phase from the nematic phase, the backbone chain is confined between two successive smectic layers, occasionally jumping into the neighboring layer gap. See Figure 2.30 where the cylinders denote side groups and thick lines represent backbones. The mean square end-to-end distances parallel and perpendicular to the director differs more than that in the nematic phase. The components of the mean square end-to-end distance were given in the last section. If the temperature is low and |∆2 | is much greater than zero, the mean square end-to-end distance in the NII and NIII phases have the forms
1 2 2 , Rz = L 1 − |∆| Rp2 =
Ll . |∆|
(2.131)
116
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.30. Backbone of side chain liquid crystalline polymer confined between smectic layers. (From Finkelmann, 1991. Reproduced by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.)
The conformation is rod-like in the direction along the director, while in the NI phase both conformations along the two principal directions, expressed in the following equation, are random walks. In the z direction it is greatly depressed, as seen from the following equations
Ll 1 2 Rz = 1+ , 2∆ 2∆2 (2.132)
3 2 Rp = 2Ll 1 − . 2∆
2.8.
LIQUID CRYSTALLINE NETWORKS
Liquid crystalline polymers can be crosslinked to form a network, or an elastomer, while retaining liquid crystallinity. This section is devoted to both the liquid crystallinity and the rubber elasticity of the crosslinked polymers. Figure 2.31 is an example of a liquid crystalline polymer network which is the crosslinked product of crosslinkable liquid crystalline polymers and the crosslinking agents. de Gennes suggested a free energy of the Landau–de Gennes form and discussed qualitatively the properties of nematic networks, such as the
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
117
O H
O
[
O
O
O(CH2)10O ]x
O
O
N
Figure 2.31. 1993.)
H2N
O(CH2)5O
NH2
O O
O
+
H
H
O
O
O
N O
An example of forming a liquid crystalline polymer network. (From Sirigu,
discontinuous stress-strain relation, etc. (de Gennes, 1975). Several other models have been presented to attack this subject (Jarry & Monnerie, 1979; Deloche & Samulski, 1981; Abramchuk & Khokhlov, 1988; Warner et al., 1988; Warner & Wang, 1991). Warner and Wang (1991) started from the anisotropic Gaussion chain and applied the worm chain model to envisage the properties of nematic networks.
2.8.1.
Conventional networks
In order to emphasize the additional phenomena resulting from liquid crystallinity, we adopt the following postulates of a classical polymer network (Treloar, 1975): (1) The strands between crosslinks are long enough so that they remain essentially Gaussian, though anisotropic in the nematic network; (2) The strand chains in the network deform affinely with the bulk deformation due to the constraint of crosslinks;
118
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
(3) The free energy of the network is the sum of that of each strand’s chains. Thus, the probability of R, the end-to-end vector of a strand of a polymer network, is given by 3R2 − 32 , (2.133) P (R) = (2πl0 L) exp − 2l0 L where l0 is the persistence length in the isotropic phase. The mean square end-to-end distance of the undeformed sample is R20 = Ll0 .
(2.134)
The three orthogonal components of the mean square end-to-end distance are equal. According to the affine deformation postulate for the bulk deformation λ, a symmetrical rank two tensor, the end-to-end distance vector deforms from R0 to R = λR0 . (2.135) Define the extension ratio along the extension direction, Z axis, by λ = λz , then 1 λx = λy = λ− 2 . (2.136) Accordingly, the elastic free energy of a strand chain of a network with the deformed span R is given by
1 2 2 Fel = −N kB T ln P (R) = N kB T λ + , (2.137) 2 λ where P is the probability of R. Here we apply the third assumption, i.e., the total free energy is the sum of all the strands of network. We omit the irrelevant terms of λ. The external stress energy adds an energy term Fext = −σ ln λ.
(2.138)
The equilibrium deformation λ can be obtained by minimizing the total energy and thus
1 2 . (2.139) σ = N kB T λ − λ If the deformation is not great, it is usually helpful to define an extension deformation, e, rather than use the deformation λ, i.e., λ = 1 + e. As e is small λ2 − 1/λ ≈ 3e and then σ = 3N kB T e.
(2.140)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
119
The Young’s modulus for the isotropic networks is E = 3N kB T
(2.141)
and we can deduce the Poison’s ratio from the impressibility condition δ = 12 .
2.8.2.
(2.142)
Model of liquid crystal networks
Now we return to liquid crystal networks. In addition to the above three postulates, we further assume: (4) The total free energy of the network is comprised of elastic, nematic and external stress contributions, i.e., F = Fnem + Fel + Fext .
(2.143)
The nematic networks are composed of strands whose conformation is uniaxial with two end-to-end distance components not all being equal which read L L Rz2 = lz , Rp2 = lp , (2.144) 3 3 where L is the contour length of a strand. Two distinct persistence lengths lz and lp are different from the isotropic value li . Under the Gaussian assumption, the probability of the end-to-end distance vector being R is −3/2
P (R) = (2πl0 L)
l03 lz lp2
12
2 3Rp2 3Rz + exp − . 2lz L lp L
(2.145)
For uniaxial deformations, two distinct principal extension ratios λz and λp , along and perpendicular to the director respectively, satisfy the relation λz · λ2p = 1 because of the incompressibility of rubbers. If the chains are crosslinked in the isotropic state and P0 is an isotropic Gaussian distribution, the additional elastic free energy of a strand of the network with deformed span R is given by (denoting λz by λ)
3 Fel li 2 li 1 1 2 li λ + − ln . (2.146) = kB T 2 lz λ lp 2 lz lp2
120
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
The nematic contribution to free energy is
Fnem L S2 =N λ0 + 2 , (2.147) kB T l T √ where T = kB T / vε. Without the external stress, the nematic network has to deform to minimize free energy and thus the optimum deformation λm is
13 lz λm = lp
(2.148)
The lz and lp are functions of temperature and thus λm is dependent on 1 temperature. λm differs from the natural extension of the strand, (lz /l0 ) 2 , which results from the confinement of crosslinks. The elastic free energy can thus be reduced, if assuming w = li (lz lp2 )−1/3 3 Fel = N (w − ln w). kB T 2
(2.149)
The external stress energy adds an energy term Fext = −σ ln λ.
(2.150)
The total free energy of the system in the absence of external stress is the sum of the elastic term (Equation 2.149) and the nematic contribution (Equation 2.147). We are dealing with only a single domain sample. To achieve a single domain sample, the following techniques may work: (1) Crosslinking polymers in a single domain liquid crystal phase, as demonstrated by the Mitchell group (Legge et al., 1991); (2) Crosslinking polymers under an external field. To achieve good effect, crosslinking may occur in two steps: first crosslink lightly and then apply a stress while completing the whole crosslinking process. This technique was applied by the Finkelmann group (Schatzle et al., 1989). The order parameter of nematic networks is obtained as a function of temperature and the crosslink density. For nematic networks crosslinked at the isotropic phase, the nematic to isotropic transition is lower than that of the constituent nematic polymers which are the same length as the strands in the networks, while the transition temperature increases for the
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
121
nematic network crosslinked at the liquid crystal phase. Mitchell et al.’s experiments demonstrate this effect (Legge et al., 1991). The difference of the N–I transition temperature between the nematic networks and the counterpart nematic polymers is insignificant as long as the concentration of the crosslink agent is low enough. The reason for the small difference is that the conformation of the network strands differ from the crosslink-free nematic polymers by a factor of w−1/2 , which is not far from unity at the transition.
2.8.3.
Relation of stress and strain
Small molecular mass liquid crystals do not respond to extension and shear stress. Liquid crystalline polymers may exhibit a high elastic state at some temperature due to the entanglements. However, the liquid crystalline network itself is an elastomer, showing rubber elasticity. In the presence of external stress, liquid crystalline networks deform remarkably and then relax back after the release of stress. The elasticity of liquid crystalline networks is more complicated than the conventional network, such as the stress induced phase transition, the discontinuous stress-strain relationship and the non-linear stress optical effect, etc. The stress–strain relationship of nematic networks is given by li 1 li σ . = λ2 − N kB T lz λ lp
(2.151)
This relationship is shown in Figure 2.32(a) where reduced stress σ ∗ ≡ σ/N kB T , and curves are drawn for various reduced temperature T /Tc . This is in good agreement with the experimental data (Schatzle et al., 1989), shown in Figure 2.32(b). It is shown that the elasticity of the nematic networks is catalogued into three temperature ranges: (1) T Tc , e.g., T /Tc = 1.5, the network is in the isotropic phase. This curve is actually the same as that for the conventional networks. (2) T Tc , the polymer network is in the nematic phase. The free stress nematic networks display significant extension, i.e., a natural anisotropic shape. The extension increases as stress persists. (3) T ≥ Tc , e.g., T /Tc = 1.02, an external stress induces a phase transition accompanied by spontaneous extension. The discontinuous stress-strain relationship and an associated critical point are observed.
122
Liquid Crystalline Polymers (a)
(b)
Figure 2.32. Stress–strain relations of the nematic networks (σ ∗ ≡ σ/N kB T ) for various temperatures (a) (From Warner & Wang, 1991); and experimental stress–strain relations of the nematic networks (b) (Modified from Schatzle et al., 1989.)
Disagreement between classical network theory and experimental data occurs. The entanglement effect was thought to be responsible for the deviation. According to the classical network theory, the stress–strain relationship should follow Equation 2.139. The plot of the reduced force, σ ∗ /(λ2 − 1/λ), against the reciprocal strain, 1/λ, should be constant, i.e., unity. But experiments show that the reduced force is a function of the extension ratio λ. Figure 2.33 shows the typical experimental data of PDMS
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
123
Figure 2.33. The reduced force, σ ∗ /(λ2 − 1/λ), against reciprocal strain, 1/λ. (Modified from Warner & Wang, 1991.)
with 3% DCP () and 2% DCP (+) (Pak & Flory, 1979), and natural rubbers (◦) (Rivin & Saunders, 1951). 1/λ < 1 is the case of extension, while 1/λ > 1 means compression. The solid lines in the figure are theoretical predictions for L/l = 20, 40 and T /Tc = 1.1 and 1.2. The polymer network is in fact in the isotropic phase and is far from the nematic-isotropic transition. For instance, for a network with a transition temperature Tc = −23 ◦ C, T /Tc = 1.02 means T = 27 ◦ C. The curve apparently deviates from a straight line and is in agreement with experimental data. This demonstrates that liquid crystallinity is not exhibited by many polymer networks because their liquid crystal to isotropic transitions are too low to be observed. But the residual liquid crystallinity affects the stressstrain relationship at higher temperatures. These results form a deviation from classical rubber elasticity theory. We have only dealt with the main chain nematic networks so far. Actually many liquid crystalline networks are formed by crosslinking the backbones of side chain liquid crystalline polymers. The side chain nematic polymers have three nematic phases and their backbones have either prolate or oblate conformations, depending on their phase. It is expected that the rubber elasticity of a side chain nematic polymer network is more complex. For instance, the stress-induced NI –NIII phase transition is predicted as the network shape transforms from oblate to prolate. Liquid crystalline networks have a bright potential in industry.
124
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
2.9.
LIQUID CRYSTAL NETWORK GELS
The swelling of a nematogenic network by either an isotropic or nematic solvent is more complex than that of a classical network. In the swelling case, the volume conserving constraints need not be applied, as the volume fraction of the network is able to change by solvent exchange. The change in the degree of swelling thereby offers alternative routes to lower the free energy. As we know, the unique feature of nematic polymers is that molecules change their shape, in contrast to simple nematic rods. Shape changes of the constituent polymers of a network mean that the network too changes its shape. This is further reflected in its macroscopic properties. The nematic behavior couples to volume change and makes swelling of these networks more complex than the swelling of isotropic networks. For simplicity, we restrict our consideration to nematic polymers of prolate shape. This includes (i) main chain nematic polymers and (ii) side chain nematic polymers, but in such a way that they preferentially align with the backbone, thus giving the features of (i). This has been called the NIII phase. The other prolate possibility in the NII phase is that the backbone takes a prolate shape while the side chains are forced to have oblate symmetry. We shall only discuss the nematic polymers of (i), but the method and the conclusions are quite general. There are three combinations of the two components of nematic network gels: (1) an isotropic network swollen by a nematic solvent, reminiscent of the polymer dispersed liquid crystal systems (PDLC). This case (1) was discussed by Brochard (1979) and Ballauff (1991); (2) a nematic network swollen by an isotropic solvent was actually studied experimentally by Carudo et al. (1992) and theoretically by Warner and Wang (1992a); (3) both components can order at a temperature above the glass transition. Actually the first two systems are special cases of the last one which has been experimentally investigated (Zentel, 1986; Barnes et al., 1989; Kishi et al., 1994) and theoretically studied (Wang & Warner, 1997). We now start the case (2) to focus on the new effects of nematic gels, and then discuss the general case (3).
2.9.1.
Nematogetic network swollen by isotropic solvent
The free energy per site of gels consists of three parts F = Fmix + Fel + Fnem ,
(2.152)
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
125
where the free energy of mixing has the Flory-Huggins form Fmix = (1 − φ) ln(1 − φ) + χφ(1 − φ) kB T
(2.153)
with φ the network volume fraction. For simplicity χ is assumed to be temperature-independent. Therefore, the shape of the phase diagram of the conventional isotropic gels is expected to be temperature independent accordingly. The elongations of the gel, are λz and λp , and are related to the swelling by 1 (2.154) λz λ2p = . φ We can retain λz and φ as variables, writing λ for λz , by taking λ2p = 1/λφ. The elastic free energy is thus written as
3 Fel li φ 2 li 2 li λ + − ln , (2.155) = kB T 2L lz λφ lp lz lp2 which depends on the current state of nematic order of the network, S. In all that follows we shall define li , lz and lp to be the number of sites associated with these persistence lengths. The equilibrium elongation of the gel, λm , is
λm =
lz lp φ
13 ,
and the elastic free energy becomes:
1 Fel 3 = [φ 3 w(S) − ln w(S)]. kB T 2L The nematic contribution to the free energy is
φ φS 2 Fnem = λ0 + 2 , kB T l0 T
(2.156)
(2.157)
(2.158)
where the φ terms account for the reduction of the energy per site and the dilution of the relevant nematic interaction. The nematic free energy Fnem √ is the function of the combination ∆2 = −3φS/T 2 and T = kB T / aε. In these units, Tc = 0.388, the N–I transition temperature in the undiluted network.
126
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
The extent of solvent up-take is governed by the equality of the chemical potential (µ) of the solvent in the gel, either with µ for the solvent reservoir (for gel/solvent equilibrium), or with µ for solvent in another gel phase (for gel/gel equilibrium). The chemical potential is defined as
dF (2.159) µ=F −φ dφ which yields 1
µ w(S)φ 3 = φ + ln(1 − φ) + χφ2 + . kB T L
(2.160)
The gel/gel equilibrium requires the common tangent condition on the F − φ plot which is satisfied both by equal chemical potential, and by equal exchange potential, i.e., ∂F/∂φ. The numerical solutions of the phase diagram are shown below. We employ the convention of upper case N and I to denote the nematic and the isotropic phases of a gel, and the lower case n and i for the phases of the neat solvent. Moreover, we adopt the convention that in A–B coexisting phases, the first letter denotes the less concentrated of the coexisting phases. At low temperatures the nematic gel coexists with excess solvent, i.e., the i–N biphasic coexistence. Above the triple point Tt , excess solvent coexists with an isotropic gel, i.e., the i–I coexistence. Also, above this temperature, the isotropic and the nematic phases of a gel can coexist, i.e., I–N phases. Beyond the phase gap, a single nematic phase exists. The I–N (x) region terminates at the φ = 1 axis. This is at Tni , the N–I transition temperature of the undiluted network which, in turn, is close to Tni , the transition temperature of the uncrosslinked polymer melt from which the network derives. The nematic order is not expected for any φ for T above (x) Tni . This is the limit of stability for even the undiluted case.
2.9.2.
Nematogetic network swollen by nematic solvent
The addition of a nematic solvent yields more complex possibilities, depen(s) (x) dent on the relationship between Tni of the solvent and Tni of the network. (s) Because the solvent can also order, at temperature Tni in the neat state, the nematic tendencies of the solvent prevent it from acting directly to destroy the nematic state of the network it is swelling.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
127
It is possible to envisage three regimes of relative nematicity for the (s) (x) (s) (x) network and solvent: (a) Tni Tni , (b) Tni ∼ = Tni (with various deli(s) (x) cate cases we treat below) and (c) Tni Tni . Additionally, the magnitude of the nematic cross coupling between the solvent and the network polymers will be discussed. All of the above cases will be discussed, illustrating the qualitative features that emerge by presenting representative phase diagrams that correspond to the various choices of the nematic coupling constants. (x) An extreme case of (c) where Tni = 0 has been treated by Ballauff (s) (1992). As T is lowered below Tni , the network rapidly de-swells as isotropic chains are highly incompatible with a nematic solvent. By giving the chains some (variable) degree of nematicity, we allow for the possibility that they can order in response rather than de-mix. The total free energy of the nematic gel still consists of mixing, elastic and nematic parts; with the nematic energy resulting from both the network and solvent. For greater simplicity, the network chains are to be treated as freely-jointed rod chains instead of the worm chains, with each segment behaving like a Maier–Saupe rod similar to that of the solvent. The qualitative features of the phase diagrams should not be changed by adopting this simplification. A qualitative understanding of why new phase equilibria are possible can be seen from a plot of the free energy of nematic gels with such a common tangent drawn in, see Figure 2.34. F 0.5
0
1.0 φ
I T' > T't III T'< T't II
(s)
Figure 2.34. The free energy of nematic gels vs. volume fraction where Tni = 0. (I) isotropic gel; (II) and (III) nematic gel. Tt is the i–I–N triple-point temperature. (From Warner & Wang, 1992a.)
128
Liquid Crystalline Polymers (s)
In Figure 2.34 where Tni = 0, the N branch of the free energy is defined only to a lowest φ since the nematogetic network is diluted with a nonnematic solvent. If we dilute with a nematic solvent it is possible for the (s) (s) nematic branch of F to extend all the way to φ = 0 if T < Tni . If Tni > (x) T > Tni , the nematic branch of F may extend from φ = 0 to a maximum with φ < 1. How far it can be extended depends partly on how much greater (x) T is than Tni as well as on the cross-coupling vc . The precise structure of the phase diagram depends on the relative of the couplings, more precisely on the coupling matrix
strengths va vc . We will now consider a variety of representative examples of vc vb self and cross couplings and their effect on the phase diagrams. First of all, we will treat the simple case where det(v) = 0, i.e., vc is the geometrical mean of the self couplings and, except for unusual molecules, it approximates the order of that expected for a van der Waals mediated nematic interactions. Next, we will deal with more unusual behavior where det(v) < 0 and det(v) > 0, respectively. In all that follows we shall reduce all coupling constants by va , that is when (va , vb , vc ) are quoted they will be quoted as (1, vb /va , vc /va ). Temperatures will be reduced by the transition temperature of pure solvents which is at Tred = 0.22va /kB T . As a result, in this reduction scheme, the neat solvent has its transition at T = 1. Phase diagram with det(v) = 0 Figure 2.35(a) shows the phase diagram for vc = 1.1 and thus vb = 1.21, that is where the network is a stronger nematic than the solvent. The strand length L = 10 and the isotropic Flory-Huggins parameter χ = 0.4, correspond to a good solvent. These values will be used through out this section. It is shown qualitatively, as in Figure 2.35(a), that the I–N phase coexistence extends downwards from the transition at T = 1.21 of the neat network. There is a triple point i–I–N. If the network is less nematic than the solvent with vc = 0.9 and thus vb = 0.81. Now the N–I coexistence extends upward from the neat network’s transition at T = 0.81. Diluting with such a solvent stabilizes the nematic phase of the network against a temperature increase. The triple point is now n-N–I, instead and from this point upwards to T = 1, there is n-I coexistence. The vertical phase “chimney” (i–I) extends above T = 1. Figure 2.35(b) shows the opposite limit.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
129
Temperature
(a)
Temperature
(b)
Figure 2.35. The phase diagrams of nematic gels (a) vc = 1.1, vb = 1.21 and (b) vc = 0.9, vb = 0.81. (From Wang & Warner, 1997.)
Phase diagram with det(v) < 0 Figure 2.36 is a phase diagram for vb = 1.1 and vc = 1.2, i.e., det(v ) <0. This is where the network is more strongly nematic than the pure solvent. Since vc > vb , dilution initially stabilizes the nematic phase of the network. Thus, N–I coexistence initially extends upwards from T = 1.1, φ = 1.0 (the N–I transition of the neat network) as in Figure 2.36(b). As dilution
130
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 2.36. The phase diagram of nematic gels where det(v) < 0 and vb = 1.1, vc = 1.2. (From Wang & Warner, 1997.)
Figure 2.37. The phase diagram of nematic gels where det(v) > 0 and vb = 1.1, vc = 0.9. (From Wang & Warner, 1997.)
continues, the trend is reversed and the coexistence extends downwards as I–N, more appropriate to when va < vb (as found in Figure 2.34 and is truly the case here). The triple point region is therefore as in Figure 2.36. The reversal point on dilution occurs at a special value of φ where the N–I and I–N phase gaps each shrink to points and merge with each other. This azeotropic phenomenon is discussed by Brochard et al. (1979). It mimics a pure phase since heating the N gel at this volume fraction yields an I gel at the same volume fraction. Phase diagram with det(v) > 0 Figure 2.37 shows the case where the cross coupling is relative weaker, namely vc2 < va vb , this is where det(v) > 0.
Theories of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
131
The values chosen for the couplings are vb = 1.1 and vc = 0.9. One sees from Figure 2.37 that the central region of the diagram, from the vertical chimney to the triple point now slopes downward, reflecting the loss of nematic stability in intermediate regions of φ where the weakness of vc is most felt. Since vc is also less than vb , dilution from φ = 1 causes a reduction in the nematic phase stability, requiring lower temperatures, and thus causing the phase gap to extend downward from Tni .
2.9.3.
The shift of phase equilibria under the presence of force
In the presence of an applied force, that is, a fixed nominal stress σ, the phase diagrams change accordingly, as shown by dotted curves in Figure 2.35(a) and (b). For simplicity we deal only with the stress applied along the director and adopt the reduced nominal stress σ∗ = σL/va . It is known that strain imposed at an angle to the director in a neat nematic network is more complicated and can cause nematic rotational and mechanical instabilities (Mitchell et al., 1993), and the formation of striped states (Kundler & Finkelmann, 1995). In Figure 2.35(a) and (b), the applied longitudinal stress is shown to stabilize the nematic phase, shifting phase lines (x) to higher temperatures. The shift in Tni for the neat network does occur but is too small to display on the figures. This is known from earlier studies of the effect of stress on the transitions of neat networks (Warner & Wang, 1991, 1992b). The stress is more effective when acting on swollen networks, since it competes with the osmotic modulus of the network to up-take solvent, osmotic moduli being ∼kB T per unit volume, and the elastic moduli being ∼kB T /L per unit volume, as in the reduction of σ to σ ∗ . The low temperature limits of this behavior are particularly sensitive to the application of stress. Nematic gels are very interesting systems, thus deserving further study. Actually, these systems are being studied experimentally for applications. Examples are: polymer dispersed liquid crystal displays are sometimes dispersed not in a polymer, but in a polymer network. Displays by means of the polymer stabilized cholesteric texture change, are also achieved in crosslinked systems. In addition, the chiral smectic phase has been obtained in such systems as well. Other types of liquid crystal gels have been applied or are expected to be applied in such devices.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 3
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
3.1.
INTRODUCTION
The molecular theories introduced in Chapter 2 are the principal guidelines for any successful molecular design of liquid crystalline polymers. According to the theories, rigid molecules with an anisotropic shape, rod-like in particular, are able to form nematic phases even if no soft interactions are included in the consideration. Thermal stability (characterizable by Ti , the clearing temperature) of the liquid crystal phase is a function of the axial ratio of the molecules. Those molecules with higher length-to-diameter ratios will result in nematic phases of a higher clearing temperature. When the ratio is large enough, the nematic phase is always more stable than the isotropic liquid phase and the clearing temperature will be infinite. Different theoretical treatments have reached the same conclusion, although they have resulted in different critical axial ratios. In the literature of polymeric liquid crystals, the most cited value for the critical axial ratio of rigid rods is 6.4, given by Flory. Actual molecules always have certain flexible elements and are not as rigid as a true rod. Taking the rod-like poly(1,4-phenylene) as one example,
3.1 n
rotation of phenylene rings about the interphenylene bonds, together with vibrations of the bonds, have brought about flexibility of the molecule even 133
134
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
though a rod-like shape has persisted. The formability of a liquid crystal phase and the phase transition temperatures of the homologous compounds of poly(1,4-phenylene) are characterized and shown in Table 3.1. Two conclusions may be drawn from the data in Table 3.1. First, only the homologues with sufficiently large values of length-to-diameter ratio can form a liquid crystal phase. Secondly, both the melting point and the clearing temperature of the liquid crystal phase increase very fast with an increasing degree of polymerization (n + 2). The compound with only six 1,4-phenylene units and an axial ratio of 5.5 has a melting point of 438 ◦ C and a clearing temperature of 565 ◦ C, which is already too high a temperature for organic molecules to survive. It is therefore not practical to synthesize liquid crystal forming polymers by the simple linking-together of rigid structures into rod-like molecules, even if certain flexible elements are present. By inserting in between every two phenylene rings a linking unit with a certain flexibility, such as an ester group, the flexibility of the molecules will be increased. For example, if an ester group is used as the linking unit, it will not only allow the crankshaft type movements in the molecule, but also serve as a separation between the phenylene rings and thus reduce the hindrance for a free rotation of the rings. As a result, poly(4-hydroxybenzoic acid), PHA, with the following formula does have much lower transition temperatures than poly-phenylenes as shown in Table 3.2. Specifically, the compound with n = 3 has a melting point of 220 ◦ C and a clearing temperature of 464 ◦ C. The calculated axial ratio l/d is 6.4. In comparison, this compound has slightly higher axial ratio but much lower transition temperatures than the poly(1,4-phenylene) with n + 2 = 6 (l/d = 5.5, m.p.
Table 3.1. The Axial ratio and Phase Transition Temperature of Poly(1,4-phenylene)s∗ . n+2 1 2 3 4 5 6 ∗
Axial Ratio, l/d
Melt. Point, ◦ C
1.0 2.0 3.0 3.9 4.8 5.5 Source: Irvine and Flory, 1984.
5.4 70.5 213 320 388 438
Clearing Point, ◦ C non-liquid-crystalline non-liquid-crystalline non-liquid-crystalline non-liquid-crystalline 418 565
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Table 3.2. Axial ratio hydroxybenzoic acid)∗ .
and
Transition
Temperature
of
Poly(4-
n
Axial Ratio, l/d
Melt.Point, ◦ C
Clearing Point, ◦ C
1 2 3 13 100
3.8 5.1 6.4 19
132 176 220 415 600
100 monotropic 254 464
∗
135
Source: Ballauff and Flory, 1984; Economy, et al. 1988.
438 ◦ C, T i = 565 ◦ C. Table 3.1). Thus, PHA can have a higher degree of polymerization than poly(1,4-phenylene) before the transition temperatures become infinite. However, studies on PHA have shown that its melting point is already higher than its decomposition temperature if the degree of polymerization reaches only such a low value as 13 (Table 3.2). CO
O
CO
O n
3.2
In Table 3.2, the compound with n = 1 has a monotropic liquid crystalline phase. In the literature of liquid crystals a monotropic phase is a metastable phase which forms only in the process of cooling but not when the sample is heating. On the other hand, if a liquid crystalline phase forms not only in the process of cooling but also in the process of heating, the phase is termed enantiotropic. For example, a nematic phase is monotropic if the melting point, T m, of the sample is higher than the clearing temperature, T i, of the liquid crystal phase. It is enantiotropic if T i is higher than T m. It is worthwhile pointing out that the critical axial ratio 6.4 given by Flory’s theory is based on assumptions that include zero free volume and zero net interaction energy between the rods (Chapter 2). By increasing the free volume, for example, the ratio will be increased accordingly. It is thus also understandable that the critical axial ratio will become larger when the temperature is increased. On the other hand, no actual system will meet these assumptions to any perfection. In addition, the flexibility of an actual molecule such as poly(1,4-phenylene) and PHA will increase with increasing temperature. In other words, the axial ratio of a molecule is not a constant,
136
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
but a function of temperature. The actual axial value of a compound will deviate from what was calculated for a standard condition, and will become lower and lower with the increase of experimental temperature. Therefore, no direct comparison may be made between the critical axial ratio given by the theory and the axial ratio of an actual compound for evaluation of the liquid crystalline properties of the compound. We have shown that polymers formed by the simple linking together of rigid rod-like mesogenic units, such as poly(1,4-phenylene) and poly(4hydroxybenzoic acid) formed by linking together the phenylene rings with single bonds or ester units, have melting temperatures so high that no liquid crystalline phase can actually exist above melting. To achieve liquid crystallinity, the melting point of the polymers has to be decreased. The most convenient way to achieve this is to mix the rod-like polymer with a solvent. Blades (1973, 1975) discovered that with sulfuric acid the high molecular weight poly(1,4-phenylene terephthamide) is able to form crystalline solvates with finite melting temperatures. The solvate formed with about one mole polymer and 10 moles of sulfuric acid melts and forms the lyotropic liquid crystalline phase at 70 ◦ C, a very convenient temperature for processing. Other rod-like polymers may form solvates also. Poly(γ-benzyL-glutamate), for example, forms crystal solvates with DMF. Watanabe et al. (1981) found the melting point of the solvates increases with the increasing of the polymer content. The lyotropic liquid crystal phase can form only when the polymer content is higher than 18 wt%. Papkov (1982) has given a phase diagram for the two-component system of a rigid rod polymer and a solvent. According to this researcher, with the addition of a solvent to the polymer, a two-phase system (crystal C + crystal-solvate CS) is first formed. A single CS phase, then the second two-phase system of CS and the isotropic liquid phase will form with the further addition of the solvent. Thus in principle, liquid crystals of rigid rod-like polymers can be obtained by solvent incorporation and formation of crystal solvates with finite melting points. As a matter of fact, lyotropic liquid crystal phases are achieved not only with poly(1,4-phenylene terephthamide) (PPTA) and Poly(γ-benzy-L-glutamate), but also with such rigid rod-like polymers as poly(1,4-phenylene benzo-bis-thiazole) (PBT) and poly(1,4phenylene benzo-bis-oxazole) (PBO). PPTA, PBT and PBO are important lyotropic liquid crystal polymers that result in materials with very high tensile strength and modulus. Unfortunately, because of the very low mixing entropy, not many of the rigid rod-like high polymers have sufficient solubility and form solvates. For example, among many others, poly(1,4-phenylene) and
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
137
poly(4-hydroxybenzoic acid) hardly dissolve in any solvent. Therefore, these high-melting polymers are not able to form any liquid crystalline phase, neither thermotropic nor lyotropic, if no substantial chemical modifications of the molecules are made. It has been indeed the focus of molecular engineering in this scientific area to design and synthesize polymers with desirable liquid crystallinity in desirable temperature regions. To achieve the goal, two principal ideas have been developed. The first is to disrupt the chain sequence of mesogenic units by inserting into the chain, different structural moieties, so as to incorporate in the chain certain irregularity and flexibility. The result of this practice are main-chain type liquid crystalline polymers. The second idea is to use the mesogenic units individually as side groups attached to the main chain of the polymer molecules, resulting in side-group type liquid crystalline polymers. Depending on the extent of disruption in the sequence of mesogenic units, main-chain type liquid crystalline polymers of very different properties can be synthesized. The polymers can still be rather rigid and have very high, but acceptable melting temperatures if only rigid moieties are used as the disruptions. Copolyesters of 4-hydroxybenzoic acid (HBA) with 6-hydroxy-2-naphthalic acid (HNA), and copolyesters of HBA with terephthalic acid (TA) and biphenol, are famous examples of these polymers. Properties of these copolyesters will be further discussed in Section 3.3 and Chapter 5. On the other hand, main-chain type liquid crystalline polymers can be very flexible with very low melting points if flexible spacers are frequently incorporated along the chain. By comparison, side-group type liquid crystalline polymers usually are flexible polymers with low T g or low melting temperatures because the rigid mesogenic units with only limited length-to-diameter ratio are used only as individual side groups (Section 3.4). However, side-group type liquid crystalline polymers can have properties similar to that of rigid or semi-rigid main-chain type liquid crystalline polymers if unusual molecular designs are adopted (Section 3.5). Naturally, different molecular designs result in different polymer properties and different applications. Liquid crystalline polymers with higher chain rigidity and melting points may find applications as high-strength, high-modulus, and heat-resistant materials (Chapter 5). Those with very low chain rigidity and transition temperatures may be used in display or information process devices (Chapter 6). Liquid crystalline polymers have been classified in a variety of ways according to the style of incorporation of mesogenic units in the molecules. The most basic types are shown in Figure 3.1, in which the squares are representative of mesogenic units. Mesogenic units are structural moieties with sufficient rigidity and are mostly in the shape of straight rods. Other
138
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Figure 3.1.
Basic types of liquid crystalline polymers.
anisotropic shapes such as discotic and bowl-like ones are rare but can also be found in certain liquid crystalline polymers. It is commonly believed that mesogenic units are essential to the formation of the liquid crystal phase. Liquid crystalline polymers without mesogenic units are rare and will be discussed in Section 3.6. 3.2.
LOW MASS LIQUID CRYSTALLINE COMPOUNDS AND MESOGENIC UNITS
By and large, mesogenic units make up most of the principal components in a liquid crystalline polymer. The structure and property of mesogenic units are of primary importance in determining properties of a polymer. It is thus very instructive to have a brief study of the structure and its influence on the property of mesogenic units with low mass liquid crystalline compounds as models and references.
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
139
Gray (1961) has had a good account for the structure and properties of low molecular mass liquid crystals. In this section we discuss only a few structural elements having the most impact on the properties of liquid crystals. The structural elements include those imposing on molecules, the “side-steps”, the kinks, the flexible spacers, the bulky substituents, and others. The discussion starts with poly(1,4-phenylene)s as the parent or reference molecules.
3.2.1.
Poly(1,4-phenylene)s
Most, if not all, the liquid crystal compounds have the 1,4-phenylene unit in the molecules. This structural brick has all the most desirable characteristics for liquid crystals: stiffness, polarizability, and linear orientation. The simplest, although very difficult at the same time, construction of a liquid crystal with this moiety is the synthesis of poly(1,4-phenylene)s, 3.1. In Table 3.1 the number of the phenylene rings and the length-to-diameter ratio are related with the liquid crystallinity of these compounds. Conformational analysis of 3.1 has reached the conclusion (Laupretre and Noel, 1991) that the most stable conformations of the molecules are linear and rod-like. Because of the steric interactions between the hydrogen atoms of the neighboring phenylene rings, in solution and in the melt state, the coplanar forms have higher energy than the forms with two neighboring rings rotating from each other by an angle of approximately 20–25 degrees. Therefore, the molecules are expected to be more rod-like than coplanar or plate-like in the liquid crystalline phases. On the other hand, the flexibility of these molecules stems basically from only the hindered rotation of the rings. The flexibility is thus very limited. In other words, poly(1,4-phenylene)s can be characterized as rigid and rod-like molecules. As shown in Table 3.1, poly(1,4-phenylene) becomes liquid-crystalforming when five rings are present and the molecular rod is sufficiently long. The property of this polymer is most predictable by the Flory theory because of its rod-like nature.
3.2.2.
Incorporation of “side-steps”
In the literature of liquid crystals, “side-steps” have been used to describe the structural moieties that will change the shape of a rod-like molecule
140
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
−COO− −, − −CH=N− −, into a stairlike one. The side-step units may include − − −N=N(O)− −, trans − −CH=CH− −, − −CONH− −, and 2,6-naphthalene. The molecule will depart one step aside at such units, but a linear contour of the molecule can be maintained (Figure 3.2). In such molecules, the crank-shaft type movements shown by Figure 3.3 are possible, rendering the molecules with significant flexibility. Poly(4-hydroxybenzoic acid), 3.2, is an example of these molecules. In this case, the ester groups serve as side-steps. Because of the steric repul−COO− − tend to take sion, the two phenylene rings on the two ends of − −O bond. The phenylene ring the trans-configuration relative to the CO− −COO− − takes approximately a attached directly to the carbon atom in − coplanar configuration with the COO plane. The other ring attached to the −COO− −, on the other hand, deviates from the coplanarity with oxygen in − the COO plane by an angle of about 67 degrees (Laupretre and Noel, 1991), required by the steric interactions between the hydrogen at the ortho position on this ring and the oxygen of the carbonyl. We see in this example the combination of linearity with side-steps and the combination of coplanarity with non-coplanarity in the molecule. With these characteristics, poly(4hydroxybenzoic acid)s have on the one hand sufficient linearity and rigidity of the rod-like nature for formation of liquid crystalline phases, they have on the other hand much higher flexibility than the corresponding poly(1,4phenylene)s. With a comparison between the data in Tables 3.1 and 3.2, one finds immediately the much lower phase transition temperatures of the former than of the latter. With five phenylene rings, for example, the axial ratio of the poly(4-hydroxybenzoic acid) was 6.4, higher than the value 4.8 for the poly(1,4-phenylene). Both the compounds form a nematic liquid crystalline phase. However, because of the higher flexibility, the melting point and the isotropization temperature of the liquid crystal phase for the former are 220 ◦ C and 464 ◦ C respectively, much lower than that for
Figure 3.2.
Figure 3.3.
“Side-steps” incorporated in a liquid crystal molecule.
“Crank-shaft” movement created at the side-steps.
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
141
the latter. Poly(4-hydroxybenzoic acid) with a sufficiently high molecular weight (n ∼ 100) has been synthesized and processed to products of very high mechanical properties (Chapter 5). Because of the unique character, the availability, and the high polymerizability, 4-hydroxybenzoic acid has become one of the most popular monomers used in the synthesis of liquid crystalline polymers. −COO− − are also found in liquid crysThe side-step linkages other than − − − − was not used until very tals. Among them, the amide linkage CONH− recently in low mass liquid crystals. Amide linkages are to bring about strong hydrogen bonding and very high melting temperature for the compounds. By lateral substitution with suitable substituents, e.g., Br and nitro-, on the phenylene ring, Zhou, Zhang and coworkers (1995) were able to synthesize thermotropic liquid crystals with the following general formula 3.3: Br
O RO
C
NH
O NH
OR
C
3.3
In this case, lateral substitution plays an important role in weakening hydrogen bonding and significantly depresses the melting temperature of the compound. As a result, the potential of this type of rod-like molecule to form liquid crystal phases is revealed. In Table 3.3 are shown the liquid crystalline property of a few of the 2-bromo-1,4–bis(4alkoxybenzamido)benzene.
Table 3.3.
Liquid crystallinity of 3.3.
R
Heating
(cooling)
1 2 3
Methoxy Ethoxy n-Octoxy
K 232-233 N 239-240 I K 233-234 N 245-247 I K 165-166 S 190-191 N 192 I
(I 237-238 N) (I 243-242 N) (I 192 N 190 S 165 K)
4
R1 = ethoxy R2 = cyano
K 234-235 N 269-270 I
(I 269-267 N)
Note: compound 4 is the unsymmetrically substituted homologue: 2-bromo-1-(4-ethoxybenzamido)-4-(4-cyanobenzamido)benzene.
142
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
3.2.3.
Incorporation of kinked elements
The most significant consequence of the incorporation of kinked elements in the molecules is the destruction of the linearity and the shortened length of the rod-like structural sequence of the molecules. Naturally, the type and the amount of the kinked elements have to be carefully decided in the molecular engineering of liquid crystals. For example, Vorlander (1923) −X− − elements in the following molecules studied the influence of different − 3.4: R
CH=N
X
N=CH
R
3.4
−X− − is none, the molecules will have If in 3.4 the central linking unit − a linear rod-like shape with a length to diameter ratio somewhat larger than five. All the compounds, including those with R either being an H, a methyl, or a methoxy group, were found to be able to form a stable liquid −X− − is − −O− −, or − −S− −, or − −HCH− − crystal phase. On the other hand, if − unit, a kinked structure is introduced (Figure 3.4): The molecule becomes two short rods linked by the kink. The linearity is destroyed. The compounds are no longer liquid crystals. In contrast, if − −X− − is − −Hg− −, the linearity of the molecules can be maintained because the −Hg− − is 180 ◦ . The mercury derivatives are all liquid crystals bond angle at − with the following data for phase-transition temperatures: for R = H, T m = 18 ◦ C, T i = 22 ◦ C; for R = methyl, T m = 217 ◦ C, T i = 229 ◦ C; for R = methoxy, T m = 209 ◦ C, T i = 285 ◦ C. −O− − also served as separators between two phenyKinked units such as − lene rings. As a result, the rotation of the rings about the linking unit becomes less hindered. Studies on the conformations for diphenyl ether, diphenyl sulfide, diphenylmethane, and diphenyl ketone have reached the conclusion that these molecules all have very low energy barriers for internal rotations. According to the summary of Laupretre and Noel (1991), a large portion of conformation space lies in the 1 kcal/mol region in these molecules. Besides, the energy barrier between any of the low-energy regions is also very small. In other words, the molecules are flexible and can easily X
Figure 3.4.
Kinked structure destroys chain linearity.
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
143
go from one conformation to any other. However, there are also kinks that are much more rigid. The rigid kinked units often found in liquid crystal polymers are 2,2-diphenylpropane as well as 1,2-and 1,3-phenylenes. 3.2.4.
Incorporation of flexible spacers
−O− − Some of the kinked units discussed in the previous section, such as − −S− −, are simple examples of flexible spacers that space the mesoand − genic units into separate structural sequences of smaller length-to-diameter ratios. Other segments often used as flexible spacers include oligomeric polymethylenes, polyoxyethylenes, polysiloxanes, and so forth. The following series of molecules, 3.5 with n = 1–8, make up one of the oldest examples of the flexible spacer concept in the molecular design of liquid crystals (Vorlander, 1927):
3.5 All the compounds in the series 3.5 form nematic liquid crystals, of which the clearing temperature decreases in an odd–even manner with the number n of the methylene unit in the spacer. Later studies have repeatedly confirmed this odd–even effect in different series of liquid crystals. Not only does the clearing temperature change in this way, the enthalpy, entropy and the molecular order parameter all have similar changes with the number of chain atoms in the spacer. Usually, the homologue with an even number of chain atoms in the space has a higher value of these parameters than that of the two neighboring homologues with odd numbers. It is believed that the spacers of even numbers of chain atoms are able to approximately maintain the linear shape of the molecules, while those with odd number atoms are not. This concept has frequent applications in the design of polymeric liquid crystals, and will be discussed further in the corresponding section. 3.2.5.
Terminal or end-on substitution
Terminal substitution is another factor having significant impact on the properties of liquid crystals. Taking the following homologues of hydroxybenzoate, 3.6 and 3.7, as examples, these two compounds have the
144
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
same chemical structure as rod-like cores but are different in terminal substitutions. Compound 3.6 has no substituents at the ends. It melts at 132 ◦ C and does not form a liquid crystalline phase. In contrast, 3.7 has two alkyls as end groups. It has a lower melting point (114 ◦ C) and is able to form a stable nematic phase in the temperature range from 114 ◦ C to 231 ◦ C. O
O
C
O
C
O
O
C
C2H5
3.6
O
O
C
C4 H9
O
3.7
The comparison of the following two compounds, 3.8 and 3.9, is even more remarkable. In this case, only a small end methoxy substitution changes the nature of the compound from non-liquid crystalline to liquid crystalline. 3.8 melts at 162 ◦ C and no liquid crystal phase will be formed. On the other hand, 3.9 melts at a somewhat lower temperature (157 ◦ C) forming a nematic phase with the clearing point of 165 ◦ C. O CH=N
CH2O
C OCH3
O CH3O
CH=N
CH2O
C OCH3
3.8
3.9
We see in these examples that great effect can be created by substitutions on the two ends of the mesogenic cores. The consequence includes not only the formability of liquid crystal phases and transition temperatures, but also the types of the liquid crystalline phase. It is well known that substitution on the end with longer linear alkyls and alkoxyls favor the formation of smectic phases. One example for this remark has been given in Table 3.3. In the design of liquid crystal polymers, especially in the cases of side-group type and molecular shish-kebabs, the concept of end-substitution has been fully utilized.
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
3.2.6.
145
Lateral or side-on substitution
The most significant consequence of lateral substitution on the mesogenic cores of a liquid crystal compound is the increase of diameter and the decrease of the length-to-diameter ratio. In addition, in comparison with the unsubstituted parent molecules, the molecular interactions will not be as strong and the packing of the molecules in both the crystal and the liquid crystal phases will not be as dense and compact. All these factors have negative effects on the thermal stability of the liquid crystal phase. Nevertheless, lateral substitution can bring down the melting point to a large extent, so large in cases as to be able to reveal the potential of a compound to form a liquid crystal phase. In Section 3.2.2 we have given one such example, 3.3, in which the lateral substitution of a bromo or nitro group on the central phenylene ring of the molecules has changed the non-liquid crystalline parent compounds into liquid crystals. Another interesting example is 1,4-phenylene dibenzoate 3.10 and its vinyl substituted homologue 2-vinyl-1,4-phenylene dibenzoate 3.11 (Zhou et al., 1993): O C
O O
O
CH
O O
3.10
CH2
O C
C
O
3.11
C
1,4-phenylene dibenzoate is a rod-like molecule with a length-todiameter ratio of about 3.8. It should have the potential of liquid crystal forming. Ballauff and Flory (1984) reported that the compound 3.6 had a latent liquid crystal phase with a clearing temperature of about 100 ◦ C. The two compounds 3.6 and 3.10 are very much alike in molecular structure. They all have three phenyl rings separated by two ester linkages. The only difference in them is the orientation of the ester groups, with two − −CO− −O− − in 3.6 but one − −CO− −O− − and one − −O− −CO− − in 3.10. It is therefore reasonable to expect that 3.10 has a very similar potential as 3.6 to form a liquid crystal phase of very similar thermal stability and clearing point. However, 3.10 has a very stable crystalline state with a melting temperature as high as 207 ◦ C, so far above the clearing point of
146
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
its latent liquid crystal phase that no such phase can be possibly observed. The substitution on the central ring with a bulky vinyl group gives the compound 3.11. To the researcher’s pleasant surprise, by this substitution the melting point has been depressed to 88 ◦ C, a value well below the clearing point of the latent liquid crystal of the parent molecule. A nematic liquid crystalline phase is indeed formed, the clearing point of which is 95, lower but very close to the prediction of Ballauff and Flory. It is also interesting to mention that the compound 3.11 is the first published example that has lateral but no terminal substitutions and yet forms a liquid crystal phase. By and large, the studies on substitution effect have shown that while the terminal substitutions are favorable to the thermal stability and the formation of a liquid crystal phase, the lateral substitutions are not. The larger the lateral substitution, the more harm it can do to the thermal stability of the liquid crystalline phase. A typical and very convincing example for this idea is given by homologues of the well known para-substituted azoxyanisole 3.12: CH3O
N=N(O)
OCH3
3.12
Para-azoxyanisole is the terminally substituted homologue. It melts at 118 ◦ C and forms a nematic phase. The clearing temperature is 135 ◦ C. However, its laterally substituted meta- and ortho-forms both are nonliquid crystals. The meta-form melts at 51 ◦ C, the ortho-form melts at 80 ◦ C. In addition to the negative effect the lateral substitution may have on the thermal stability of a liquid crystal phase, one more important aspect has to be considered, for liquid crystal polymers especially when high strength and high modulus material are the goals. Thus, e.g., if a fibre is made of the polymer, the tensile strength is a function of the number of polymer chains per unit cross section. Obviously, the lateral substitution and thickening of the chains will result in a lower strength. Besides, crystallinity can be affected to a great extent. A lower crystallinity often means a lower mechanical property and a lower heat deflection temperature. All the negative aspects have to be taken into consideration when lateral substitution is used to bring down the melting points. In this section we have discussed several structural aspects of liquid crystal compounds. However, these are not the only aspects that have a significant impact on the formation and property of liquid crystals. For
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
147
successful molecular engineering, an integrated analysis of these and certain other factors are required. In polymer systems, the molecular weight is of special importance and is accounted for in Section 3.3.
3.3.
MOLECULAR WEIGHT AND MOLECULAR WEIGHT DISTRIBUTION
Polymers, including liquid crystal polymers, distinguish themselves from low mass compounds by their high molecular weight and the existence of a distribution of molecular weights. In contrast to low mass compounds, polymers usually have limited solubility, slow chain motion and high viscosity, extensive chain entanglements, slow relaxation process, retarded and non-equilibrium phase transitions, less perfect crystallization and a lower degree of crystallinities, as well as the existence of the glassy state and glass transitions. Thus, a thermotropic liquid crystal polymer may be noncrystalline and forms a liquid crystal phase in the temperature region above T g (the glass transition temperature) and below T i (the isotropization temperature). On the other hand, the polymer may be a semi-crystalline two-phase system that has such a sequence of the transition processes: the two-phase state (amorphous plus crystalline) transfers at T g to the second two-phase state (liquid crystalline plus crystalline) that transfers at the melting temperature T m to the one-phase liquid crystalline state that in the end transfers at T i to the one-phase isotropic liquid state. This is actually a simplified picture of the process. For example, above the glass transition there may also be a crystallization process. Yet because of the distribution of molecular weights and other reasons, the melting as well as the isotropization process are usually not sharp, but happen in a broad temperature range in which at least two phases coexist. The situation becomes even more intricate if the structure and property of each phase and the multiphase state are to be considered. The consequence brought about by high molecular weights and by the molecular weight distributions are profound but only a few remarks are made in this short account. For lyotropic liquid crystals, the relationships between the chain length (molecular weight) and the formability of liquid crystals have been formulated. According to Onsager and Flory (Chapter 2), for any solutions of rigid rods there is a critical concentration ν (the volume fraction of rods in the solution) determined by the length-to-diameter ratio (L/d) of the rods
148
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
[Equations (3.1) and (3.2)]. 3.29 (L/d) 7.89 ν = (L/d)
Onsager: ν = Flory:
4.19 . (L/d) 11.57 ν = . (L/d) ν =
(3.1) (3.2)
Above ν , the solution separates into isotropic and anisotropic phases. If the concentration is further increased to above the value ν , the solution becomes a single liquid crystal phase. The longer the rods, the lower the ν and ν values. On the other hand, if dilution is made for the liquid crystalline solutions of rigid rods, the solution of longer rods will transfer into the isotropic liquid at a higher dilution. In other words, the rods with higher length-to-diameter ratios are predicted by the theories to have higher formability of a more stable lyotropic liquid crystal phase. In order to have a better fit with experimental data for polymers of a different nature, some modified forms of the original Onsager and Flory theories have been derived. For the worm-like chains, for example, the KSO theory (Odijk, 1986) gives the following form (Equation 3.3) to correlate ν with the chain length L, diameter d, and persistence length q: 2 L L 3.34 + 11.3 + 4.06 2q 2q d ν = (3.3) . 2q L L 1 + 0.387 2q 2q The experimental data of ν for several polymer systems have been compared with the calculated values of the KSO theory. The two are found to be in very good agreement (e.g., Ciferri and Marsano, 1987). For thermotropic systems, such parameters as the temperature of phase transitions, the enthalpy and entropy changes at the transitions, as well as the order parameter of the liquid crystal phase are all affected by molecular weight. In general, these parameters all increase with molecular weight until leveling off when the molecular weight becomes high enough. This is true for both the main-chain type and the side-group type liquid crystal polymers. Portugall et al. (1982) noticed that the phase transition temperature and enthalpy of the following side-group type liquid crystal polymer, 3.13, were dependent on the degree of polymerization n. The polymer was noncrystalline. If n = 13, the glass transition temperature was 53 ◦ C, the clearing point of the liquid crystal phase was 100 ◦ C, the enthalpy of
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
149
the isotropization was 0.6 kJ/mol; If n = 41, the corresponding parameters increased to 59 ◦ C, 114 ◦ C, and 0.6 kJ/mol respectively. These parameters were found to increase to 62 ◦ C, 116 ◦ C, and 0.9 kJ/mol with the further increase in the degree of polymerization to n = 114. CH2
CH
n
COO
O
CH2CH2
COO
OCH3
3.13
Stevens et al. (1984) carried out a more detailed study on the effect of molecular weight. Several side-group type polymers, 3.14, with polysiloxane backbones and flexible spacers of different number of methylene units were studied: CH3 CH3 Si
O
Si
3
CH2
O
n
Si CH3
CH2
m
2
3
CH2
m=
3
O
COO
OCH3
3.14
6.
The degree of polymerization of these polymers varied from n = 1 to n = 100. A few conclusions were obtained from this study. For all four systems with m = 3 to 6, the properties change most significantly when the degree of polymerization increases from 1 to 10. For example, for the polymer of m = 3, the monomer and the dimer do not form liquid crystals. The trimer forms a nematic liquid crystalline phase between the glass transition (T g = 270 ◦ K) and isotropization (T i = 285 ◦ K). The mesophase is stable within this temperature interval. With the further increase of n to 10, both T g and T i shift to higher temperatures, but the latter increases much faster than the former so that the temperature range of the stable liquid crystalline phase also increases with n. Above n = 10, the transition temperatures increase only slightly until stable values are reached at approximately n = 100. For the polymer of m = 3 and n = 95, T g and T i were found to be 290 ◦ K and 356 ◦ K respectively. The other polymers with different m have similar behavior. However, the polymer with the longest spacer in the series, m = 6, forms a smectic phase in addition to a nematic phase. The influence the flexible spacer has on the property of the side-group type liquid crystalline polymers will be discussed in Section 3.5. Stevens and coworkers
150
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
proposed that the increase in thermal stability of the mesophase with molecular weight was attributed to progressively denser packing of the mesogenic side groups of the oligomers with a growing degree of polymerization. This effect is macroscopically seen in a decrease of specific volume at the phase transformation temperature with a degree of polymerization. Another interesting phenomenon found by Stevens et al. is the monotropic mesophase formed by the dimer and trimer of the polymer with m = 6. The dimer has a monotropic nematic phase, the trimer has a monotropic smectic phase. These metastable monotropic phases become stable enantiotropic phases with the increase of n by 1. At about the same time, Blumstein et al. (1984) found the low mass model compound of a main-chain type liquid crystalline polymer was monotropic while the mesophase of the polymer was enantiotropic. Zhou et al. (1986) studied the transformation of monotropic to enantiotropic mesophase of the main-chain type liquid crystalline polymer, 3.15, in terms of the molecular weight effect. O O
CH2
10
O C
O C O
O
O
O C
C
3.15
CHO
Some of the results are shown in Table 3.4. In this study, the inherent viscosity was used as the measure of molecular weight. We see in Table 3.4 that the transition temperatures, especially T i change with molecular weight in a relatively wide range of molecular weights. The first three samples with inherent viscosity lower than 0.19 dl/g are monotropic liquid crystals. They form liquid crystals only in the course of cooling from an isotropic liquid state. It is so because the melting point is higher than the clearing temperature of the latent mesophase. It is only possible for a polymer to transform from monotropic to enantiotropic if the isotropization temperature increases faster than the melting point with increasing molecular weight. This is the case for the polymer in consideration. When the viscosity has increased from 0.14 to 0.20, the increase in T m is from 144 ◦ C to 159 ◦ C. At the same time, the increase in T i has been from below 144 ◦ to 160 ◦ C. T i increases faster than T m and starts to surpass the latter at the viscosity of 0.197 dl/g. Care was taken to determine T i for the samples just starting to show the enantiotopic property. Thus the samples were heated to 200 ◦ C, a temperature well above T i so as to guarantee an isotropic liquid phase. Taking advantage of the large extent
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
151
Table 3.4. Inherent viscosity and phase transition temperatures of polymer 3.15. Viscosity
Tm
Ti
T i–T m
T lc
Tc
T lc–T c
Remark
0.140 0.150 0.158 0.197 0.198 0.254 0.301 0.355 0.474 0.596 0.712
144 139 144 159 158 156 160 158 159 155 153
— — — 160 161 167 170 176 180 180 176
0 0 0 1 3 11 10 18 21 25 24
139 122 129 160 160 163 169 174 173 172 167
107 — 102 112 119 102 103 102 102 102 103
32 — 17 48 41 61 66 72 71 70 70
monotropic monotropic monotropic transitive transitive enantiotropic enantiotropic enantiotropic enantiotropic enantiotropic enantiotropic
Note: The inherent viscosity is in dl/g; T m: melting point; T i: isotropization temperature; T lc: isotropic liquid to liquid crystal transformation temperature in cooling; T c: crystallization temperature. All the T s are the peak temperatures in the DSC curves and are all in ◦ C.
of super cooling, the samples were quickly cooled to 130 ◦ C, a temperature much lower than T lc but sufficiently higher than T c, so that the samples were in the metastable mesophase. As soon as the mesophase was obtained, the samples were heated up to find T i. The determinations were carried out by DSC and by polarizing microscopy. Both the techniques have given the same result. In Table 3.4, one is able to see the increasingly higher thermal stability of the liquid crystal phase with the increase of molecular weight. While T m is about the same for polymers of viscosity higher than 0.2 dl/g, T i keeps increasing until above 0.35 dl/g. As a result, the temperature range (T i–T m) of the mesophase is also broadened. From this study, we see that the influence of increasing molecular weight is stronger on the mesophase than on the crystalline phase. The melting point of the crystal stops increasing much earlier than the clearing point of the mesophase. The reason for this result is still to be deduced, but one hint is given below. For thermotropic liquid crystalline polymers, it has been found that the thickness of the crystal lamella increases with increasing molecular weight until a thickness of about 100 nm is reached. Crystals of thinner lamellae have a lower thermal stability and a lower melting temperature. Since the finite value of lamella thickness is about
152
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
100 nm and the polymer chain in the crystalline state is oriented along the thickness of the lamella, only a few tens of the repeating units can be accommodated by the thickness. Thus in principle, a perfect lamella of 100 nm thick can be formed by a polymer with a degree of polymerization of only a few tens. If no chain ends are included inside the lamella, only thinner lamellae are formed by polymers of lower molecular weights. If chain end inclusion is allowed in the lamella, lamella with more defects will result from samples of lower molecular weight. On the other hand, for samples of high degrees of polymerization, extensive chain folding may occur, otherwise the polymer chain has to travel through two or more lamellae. Nevertheless, the limited low value of lamella thickness gives reason for the fast attainment of the limited melting point of the polymer crystals. In order to study the general applicability of the above principle for the transformation of the monotropic liquid crystals to the enantiotropic ones by increasing the molecular weight of the monotropic liquid crystal polymers, the polymer, 3.16, reported by Ober et al. (1983), was restudied (Duan et al. 1987). O
O
C
O C
O C O
CH2
10
O
3.16
According to Ober et al., the polymer with an intrinsic viscosity of 0.17 dl/g is monotropic. In this restudy, a sample with a viscosity of 0.30 dl/g was obtained. The sample melts at 148 ◦ C and forms a nematic phase. The clearing point of the liquid crystal is 170 ◦ C. The sample was fractionated to obtain three fractions with viscosity of 0.14, 0.39 and 0.61 dl/g respectively. In agreement with Ober et al., the sample of the lowest intrinsic viscosity (0.14 dl/g) is monotropic, melts at 140 ◦ C and forms the liquid crystal phase only in the circle of cooling. However, the fractions with higher viscosity are all enantiotropic liquid crystals. The one of 0.39 dl/g melts at 149 ◦ C, the clearing temperature of the liquid crystal phase is 159 ◦ C. The fraction of the highest viscosity also melts at 149 ◦ C, but the clearing point is somewhat higher (164 ◦ C). At about the same time, Percec and Nave (1987) also found that the transformation of the monotropic liquid crystalline polymers to the enantiotropic ones could be achieved by increasing molecular weight. The polymer studied by these authors has the following structural formula
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
153
(3.17): O
C
CH
O ( CH2 )
11
3.17
CH3
Some of the results for the polymer 3.17 are shown in Table 3.5. As shown in Table 3.5, the low molecular weight polymer of M n 1100 is non-liquid-crystalline. The sample of M n 3500 is monotropic while those with M n of 10200 and higher are enantiotropic. The thermal stability of the mesophase increases with increasing molecular weight as shown by the higher clearing temperature T i of the sample with higher molecular weight. Percec et al. (1989) also studied the effect of molecular weight in side-group type liquid crystal polymers. The similar monotropic to enantiotropic transformation was found in these systems. The crystallization of side groups was considered to be responsible for the transformation in these cases. The polymer with a higher molecular weight has a lower crystallizability of the side groups. In contrast, the crystallization of the main-chain type polymers seems not to be affected in such a way by the molecular weight. In the latter case, samples with higher molecular weights have a higher melting point in the region of low molecular weights. The principle of the monotropic to enantiotropic transformation by increasing molecular weight has been demonstrated by the above examples. However, for a full understanding of this phenomenon, further studies are required. For the main-chain type liquid crystal polymers with alternating sequences of the rod-like and the flexible segments, Kohlhammer et al. (1989) have found that the orientational order of the flexible segments is higher in the samples of higher molecular weights. In other words, the contribution by the flexible segments to liquid crystalline ordering is higher in Table 3.5. Phase property and molecular weight of the polymer 3.17∗ . Mn 1100 3500 6700 10900 29400 ∗
Mw
Tm
Ti
T lc
Tc
2300 6700 10200 15200 92300
101.5 117.9 121.6 124.0 126.2
– – 134.0 147.9 152.0
– 111.5 129.7 143.6 139.0
89.8 97.5 104.8 107.5 93.3
Source: Percec and Nave (1987).
Remark non l.c. monotropic enantiotropic enantiotropic enantiotropic
154
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
samples of higher molecular weights. This and related findings have rendered partial explanations for the molecular weight effect on the stability of the polymeric liquid crystal phase. Very few reports have been given on the effect of molecular weight distribution. In the restudy on Ober’s polymer mentioned above in this section, we see also the influence of the molecular weight distribution on the thermal stability of the liquid crystal phase. The unfractionated sample has a broader molecular weight distribution and a broader temperature range of the nematic phase (148 ◦ C to 170 ◦ C). On the other hand, the fractionated sample with a little higher viscosity (0.39) has narrower distribution and a narrower temperature range of the mesophase (149 ◦ C to 159 ◦ C). However, in another study on a side group type liquid crystalline polymethacrylate, the two samples with very close values of molecular weight (M n = 9860 and 10300) but significantly different molecular weight distributions (M w/M n = 4.21 and 1.70) were found to have the same T g (= 206 ◦ C) and the same T i (= 344 ◦ C). For polymers, not only is the thermal stability of the mesophases important, the consequence of molecular weight and its distribution on the process and application properties is also of primary significance. For instance, higher polymers result in higher melt viscosity and slower response to applied physical fields. Thus, for certain applications where fast responses are essential, high molecular weight liquid crystals may not have any superiority. On the other hand, higher molecular weight polymers usually result in superior mechanical properties. It is known that, e.g., the strength of the fiber spun from 2-phenyl-1,4-phenylene terephthalate with the molecular weight of 5000 is 0.6 Gpa, only about one sixth of that with a molecular weight of 40000, or that from the polymer of m.wt. 30000 is only one third of the one from m.wt. 300000 (Jackson, 1988). High molecular weight is thus required for polymers used as high-strength and high-modulus materials. However, things are more complicated even in this case. In a study on the copolymers from 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylic acid (20 mol%), terephthalic acid (20 mol%), 1,4-phenylene diacetate (40 mol%) and 4-acetoxybenzoic acid (60 mol%), Jackson (1992) found that the tensile strength and flexural properties of the injection-molded liquid crystalline polymer first increased with molecular weight as would have been expected, but decreased markedly when the absolute molecular weight was over 40000. Light scattering data indicate that this polymer behaves as a rigid rod at lower molecular weights. It becomes worm-like and forms chain entanglements at the higher molecular weights. The measurement of the Hermans orientation factors through
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
155
wide angle X-ray diffraction of the samples resulted in a higher value (0.51) for the sample having the highest tensile strength and a lower value (0.40) for that having the highest molecular weight (∼65000). Thus the reduction in tensile strength can be explained by the reduction in molecular orientation because of the increased extent of entanglement in samples of the highest molecular weight. In summary, the nature and property of a polymer can be varied simply by the variation of molecular weight. Most significantly, some polymers may change from non-liquid-crystalline to monotropic liquid crystalline and to enantiotropic liquid crystalline with the increase in molecular weights. The phase transition temperatures also increase with molecular weight at lower values, especially where the isotropization process is concerned. Therefore, no reliable analysis for the structure-property relationship can be made for any liquid crystalline polymer if there is no reliable information on its molecular weight. At the same time, no reliable comparison on the structure and property can be made for two polymers if the molecular weights are not high enough and if the property is still a function of the molecular weight. In the literature of the side-group type liquid crystal polymers, there have been some suggestions that the property becomes stable when the degree of polymerization is higher than 10, others suggest that the d.p. value must be over 200 before the property is stabilized. Keeping in mind the effect imposed by molecular weight, our discussion in the following sections will be in principle based on data for polymers having sufficiently high molecular weights.
3.4.
MAIN CHAIN LIQUID CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS
As discussed in Section 3.1, the rod like main chain type polymers can form only lyotropic liquid crystals on the condition that a solvent with sufficient solubility is present. In order to obtain liquid crystalline melts of the polymers, effective structural modification has to be made, so as to reduce the structural regularity and rigidity of the molecular chains. The polymers with higher irregularity and flexibility will have lower crystallinity and a lower melting point. The general approach of molecular modification include the introduction of the substituents, the side-step moieties, the kinked units, the flexible segments, as well as the copolymerization of different structural units. Utilization of two or more of the methods has become the common practice so that the crystallinity and melting point can be brought down sufficiently.
156
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Taking poly(1,4-phenylene terephthalate) as an example, the basic constitutions of this polymer is the regularly positioned 1,4-phenylene rings and the ester linkages. Because of the very high structural regularity and lack of flexible elements, it is highly crystalline with no melting before decomposition. Thus no mesophase is formed on heating to melt the sample. The most convenient and very effective way to bring down the melting temperature has been the introduction of a substituent group on one of the two rings in the repeating unit as demonstrated by the polymers 3.18 (Jackson and Kuhfuss, 1976) and 3.19 (Payet, 1979): O
O CL
O
O
O
O
C
C
O
O
C
C
m.p. 370◦ C
3.18
m.p. 343◦ C
3.19
In these two cases substitution of an H of the ring with a chlorine atom or a phenyl group resulted in a remarkable decrease in the melting point. Both polymers are thermotropic liquid crystals and are melt. Because of the larger size of the phenyl substituent, polymer 3.19 has an even lower melting point and can be melt-spun to form high strength fibers. A simple substitution such as that in 3.18 and 3.19, not only has the consequence of broadening the molecule and separating the neighboring chains, but also brings in certain irregularities for the chain. One type of the irregularities is shown by 3.20 where two types of incorporation of the phenyl substituted 1,4-phenylene moieties are demonstrated for the polymer 3.19. Obviously in the chain there is a distribution of these two types of bonding. In other words, this polymer, though generally considered to be a homopolymer, is actually a random copolymer consisting the two different building blocks. The substitution thus has a higher efficiency in decreasing crystallinity and transition temperature than one might have realized if only the broadening and separation effects are considered. O
O
O
O
C
C
O
O
O
O
C
C
3.20
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
157
The effectiveness of random copolymerization in depressing crystallization and melting point can be further demonstrated by the polymer 3.21 (Jackson & Kuhfuss, 1982). In comparison to the polymer 3.19, the polymer 3.21 has an even lower melting point (330 ◦ C) even though the extent of the substitution is lower by 25%.
O
O
O
O
C
C
O
O
O
O
C
C
3.21
0.25
0.75
Similarly, copolymerization of a certain amount of 4-hydroxybenzoic acid (HBA) with phenyl-1,4-hydroquinone and terephthalic acid also gives rise to a remarkable decrease in the melting point. The general structural formula and the melting points of the copolymers with different HBA content are given respectively by 3.22 and Table 3.6. In this particular case, the incorporation of 20 mol % of HBA into the polymer 3.19 has resulted in a polymer with a melting point as low as 229.
O
O
O
O
C
C
O O
C
x
y
3.22
It is interesting to make a comparison of the polymer 3.19 with 3.23 shown below. The only difference in structure of these two polymers is that in 3.19 the phenyl substituent is on the
O
O
O
O
C
C
m.p. 278◦ C 3.23
hydroquinone moiety while in 3.23 (Harris, 1981) the substitution is on the terephthalic moiety. However, the difference in melting point of the two is a remarkable 343 ◦ C to 278 ◦ C. Because of the very high similarity in
158
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Table 3.6.
Melting point and composition of polymer 3.22∗ .
y (mol %)
0
5
10
20
30
50
60
70
100
m.p. (◦ C)
343
335
317
229
309
325
373
379
∼600
∗
Source: Jackson et al. 1980.
molecular structure of the two, we can expect a very high similarity for the two in chain thickness and chain irregularity. Thus there must be other reasons for such a high difference in the melting property of the two. For one thing, the sample of 3.23 has a somewhat lower intrinsic viscosity (0.51) than the sample of 3.19 (1.03), for the other, substitution on the phenylene ring of terephthalic moiety will interfere with the coplanarity between the ring and the two ester groups. As discussed by Laupretre and Noel (1991), the ring in terephthlic moiety takes the coplanar conformation with the ester groups as the lowest energy form, while the lowest energy conformation in 1,4-hydroquinone diesters is not coplanar but has its plane of the phenylene ring and the plane of the ester group rotated from one another by an angle of approximately 60 degrees. Thus, the substitution on the ring of hydroquinone moiety in 3.19 should have only minor interference with the already non-coplanar conformation, but the substitution on the ring of terephthalic moiety in 3.23 should have changed the conformation from a coplanar one to a non-coplanar one because of the steric interactions between the bulky substituent and the ester group. This noncoplanarity caused by the bulky substitution on the terephthalic moiety may have explained the relatively lower melting point of this (3.23) and other polymers of phenylterephthalic acid. The following polymer 3.24 serves as one more example to show the effect (Harris, 1981). This polymer has a very similar intrinsic viscosity (0.99) as that (1.03) of 3.19, but has a much lower melting point (270 ◦ C compaired with 343 ◦ C) regardless of the presence of the longer rod-like moiety biphenyl.
O
O
O
O
C
C
m.p. 270◦ C 3.24
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
159
Zhou and Lenz (1983) and Zhou et al. (1985) discussed the substitution effect from the point of view of steric and polar effects. However, from above discussions one sees a more intricate picture. A full understanding of the effect demands further study. Nevertheless, substitution is so effective that a lot of studies have used this concept in the molecular engineering of liquid crystalline polymers in order to have desired phase properties. Back to copolymerization. Even though such monomers as 4-hydroxybenzoic acid (HBA), monomer pairs as 1,4-hydroquinone (HQ) and terephthalic acid (TA) or 4,4 -dihydroxybiphenyl (BP) and terephthalic acid can result in only unmeltable rigid polymers, their copolymerizations have resulted in meltable polymers. The melting points of the HBA-HQTA copolymers were reported to be around 400 (Inai et al., 1982), that of the HBA-BP-TA was also only 380 ◦ C–420 ◦ C. Based on the latter together with isophthalic acid, the products “Xydar” and “Ekonol” have been commercialized as high strength high modulus and flame resistant materials. The heat deflection temperature (HDT) of these materials is in the range of 317 ◦ C–355 ◦ C (at 1.82 MPa). The excellent mechanical and thermal properties have qualified these thermotropic liquid crystalline aromatic polyesters for advanced engineering materials (Suenaga, 1990). Another famous type of liquid crystalline aromatic polyesters are those copolymers based on 6-hydroxy-2-naphthoic acid (HNA) and 4hydroxybenzoic acid (HBA). These polymers have been commercialized by Hoechst-Celanese as “Vectra”. The incorporation of 2,6-naphthalylene moieties brings into the polymer chains with “side-steps” and with the crank-shaft movements (Figures 3.2 and 3.3). As mentioned in Section 3.2.2, this type of structural modification will result in less chain rigidity. Calundann (1979) had a systematic study on the relationship of property and the ratio of HNA/HBA in the copolymers prepared from the melt polycondensations of 4-acetoxybenzoic acid and 6-acetoxy-2-naphthoic acid. The result is shown in Table 3.7. Although the homopolymers of these two monomers are both crystalline with melting points over 400 ◦ C, the copolyesters all have a much lower melting point and can be processed by melt spinning at about 310 ◦ C. Table 3.7. HNA/HBA m.p. ◦ C ∗
Melting point of HNA/HBA copolyesters∗ .
0/100 ∼600
25/75 302
Source: Calundann (1979).
30/70 275
40/60 245
50/50 260
60/40 263
100/0 ∼440
160
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
The effectiveness of 2,6-naphthalene moiety in depressing melting temperature is also demonstrated by copolymers containing 2,6dioxynaphthalene or 2,6-naphthoyl units. It was reported, e.g., the melting point of the polymer of terephthalic acid and 2,6-dihydroxynaphthalene was only 210 ◦ C (Harris, 1981); that of the copolymer of 2 mol 4-hydroxybenzoic acid with 1 mol of 2,6-dihydroxy-naphthalene and 1 mol of terephthalic acid was 285 (Calundann, 1980); that of the copolymer of 1 mol hydroquinone, 1 mol of 2,6-naphthoic acid and 3 mol 4-hydroxybenzoic acid was 325 ◦ C– 340 ◦ C; and that of 1 mol 2,6-naphthoic acid, 1 mol 4,4 -dihydroxybiphenyl, 3 mol 4-hydroxybenzoic acid was 385 ◦ C–390 ◦ C (Calundann, 1978). As shown by the above examples, with the substitution and incorporation of side-step moieties such as 2,6-naphthalene side-steps the melting point of the fully aromatic polyesters can be depressed to below 400 ◦ C. But because of the high degree of chain rigidity of the fully aromatic polymers, the clearing point of the liquid crystalline phase of these copolyesters is not observable before decomposition takes place. In order to further increase the chain flexibility and realize the clearing temperature of the liquid crystalline phase, flexible aliphatic or siloxane segments are often used in the practice of molecular engineering of liquid crystalline polymers. The flexible element may be applied as substituent on the aromatic rings as in the polymers 3.25 reported by Berger and Ballauff (1988): O
O
O
O
C
C
3.25
C n H2 n + 1
The unsubstituted parent polymer does not melt without decomposition. The methyl-substituted polymer, n = 1 in 3.25, melts at 381 ◦ C. With longer alkyl substitution, the melting point will be decreased to a larger extent. When n is 10, the polymer melts in the range of 250 ◦ C–310 ◦ C and begins to show the clearing point of the liquid crystal phase (T i ∼ 400 ◦ C). The clearing point will decrease with a longer alkyl substituent, but the temperature range of the liquid crystal phase will also narrow because the extent of depression of the melting point is not as large as T i. The polymer is no longer liquid crystalline when n is 16 and larger. The other and most popular way is to copolymerize the flexible segment into the polymer main chains. De Gennes (1975) predicted that incorporation of both a rigid and a flexible segment in the repeating unit should afford semi-flexible polymers exhibiting thermotropic liquid crystallinity,
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
161
and allow control of the transition temperatures. Studies on the mainchain type liquid crystalline polymers with flexible segments along the chain (Figure 3.1) have been active and extensively reviewed by Ober et al. (1984) and by Sirigu (1991). Accordingly, we will make only a few remarks on the three principal structural elements of the polymers, namely the mesogenic units, the flexible segments, and the way in which the mesogenic units and the flexible segments are connected. In Table 3.8, the structure and property are shown for a few polymers with different mesogenic units and/or different connecting groups but all with decamethylene as flexible segments. These polymers are so selected that the influence of the structure of mesogenic units and of the way of connecting may be demonstrated. The mesogenic units in polymer 3.26 are of the type based on conformational isomerism (Percec, 1988, and Section 3.7). Although they take the extended linear shape as one of their lowest energy conformations and thus are capable of forming liquid crystalline phases, they are rather flexible in comparison with what is mostly used in liquid crystalline polymers such as the one in polymer 3.27. The calculated length of the extended shape of the two mesogenic units in 3.26 and 3.27 is almost the same (∼1.8 nm). However, because of the significant difference in rigidity of the two types of mesogenic units, polymer 3.26 has a much lower phase transition temperatures than 3.27. In addition, the mesophase of the latter is nematic, that of the former is smectic. The reason for the difference in the type of liquid crystalline phase has not been analyzed in literature. We believe that the polymer 3.27 also has the potential of forming a smectic phase with a similar or somewhat higher thermal stability than that of 3.26. However, because the melting point (237) of 3.27 is significantly higher than the clearing point (211) of the smectic phase of 3.26, it may also be higher than the transition temperature of the latent smectic phase of 3.27. The high melting temperature might have prevented polymer 3.27 from forming a smectic phase. The polymer 3.29 is obtained if the central 1,4-phenylene moiety in 3.27 is replaced by 4,4 -biphenylene that is as rigid but longer than the former. Such a replacement increases the length and the length-to-diameter ratio of the mesogenic unit. More stable mesophase and higher mesophase transition temperatures can be expected (Section 3.1). As a matter of fact, not only are the melting and the clearing temperatures of the mesophase are higher for 3.29 than 3.27, the temperature range of the mesophase is also broader for the former by 39 ◦ C.
162
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
The substitution effect on liquid crystals has been discussed for low mass and fully aromatic polymers. The comparison of 3.28 with 3.27 shows the effect of substitution in mesogenic units on the properties of polymers with flexible segments in main chains. Again, the substituted polymer has a lower melting point, a lower clearing temperature, and a narrower temperature
Table 3.8. Property of polymers with mesogenic units separated by flexible decamethylene segments. Mesogenic moiety together with the connecting group 3.26
O
3.27
O
O
CH 2
CH2
O C
3.28
O
O
C 195 S 211 I (Josson et al., 1989)
O O
O
O
O
O
C
C 237 N 294 I (Antoun et al., 1981)
O
O C
O
Transition, ◦ C
C 151 N 168 I (Jo et al., 1982)
O
C
C6 H5 O
3.29
C
O
O O
O
O
3.30
O
C
C
3.32
O
N
N
C
O
C
N
N
N
N (O )
O
C
C 225 N 245 I (Iimura et al., 1981)
C
O C
O
C 200 I (Iimura et al., 1981)
O O
N
N (O )
CH 3
O
3.34
C 210 I (Iimura et al., 1981)
O
O C
C 258 N 354 I (Van Luyen et al., 1980)
O
O
3.33
O
O
O
3.31
C
O
N
O
CH 3 N (O )
C
C 216 N 265 I (Blumstein et al., 1982)
O O
C
C 118 N 162.5 I (Blumstein et al., 1982)
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Table 3.8.
Continued
Mesogenic moiety together with the connecting group CH 3
O
3.35
C
3.36
O
3.37
O
CH 3
O
O
O
C
C
O C
N (O )
N
O
O
O
O
O
O
C
C
O
Transition, ◦ C
C 196 N 218 I (Blumstein et al., 1982)
C
O
O
C
C
O
O O
163
C
O
C 231 N 265 I (Zhou and Lenz, 1983)
C 220 S 267 I (Ober et al., 1983)
range of the mesophase. The same is seen for the polymers 3.33, 3.34 and 3.35. The two methyl substituted polymers have lower mesophase transition temperatures and narrower mesophase ranges than the parent polymer 3.33. In addition, the comparison between 3.34 and 3.35 shows the importance of the position of substitution in the mesophase stability of the polymers. The methyl substitutions in 3.34 are at the 2-and 2 -positions relative to the central azoxy group, while that in 3.35 are at the 3, and 3 -positions. Because the 2,2 -substitutions are in the vicinity of azoxy and thus have stronger steric interactions with the azoxy group, they should have deviated the two phenylene rings from coplanarity with azoxy to a larger extent than the 3,3 -substitutions should have. Thus, the melting and clearing temperatures as well as the mesophase range of the 2,2 -disubstituted polymer 3.34 are significantly lower and narrower than those of the 3,3 -disubstituted 3.35. Recall the properties of the low mass compound 3.12 and its 2,2 -(ortho-) and 3,3 -(meta-) isomers. Another interesting result is obtained when the way of connecting the mesogenic units and the flexible segments is varied. This is shown by the polymer pairs of 3.30 and 3.31, and 3.32 and 3.33. The end phenylene rings of the mesogenic units are connected to the flexible segments −O− − or through − −CO− − (Figure 3.5): through − A large number of studies show that the former way of connection helps the formation of the nematic mesophase. For instance, of the four −O− − polymers, 3.30 to 3.33, the two with the connection through − −CO− − connection are are liquid crystalline; the other two with the −
164
Liquid Crystalline Polymers
O Mesogenic unit
C
Flexible segment
C O
Flexible segment
O O
Mesogenic unit Figure 3.5.
−O− − (top) or − −CO− − to flexible segment. Mesogenic unit attached through −
non-liquid-crystalline even though their melting points are lower than that of the former two. Conformational analysis has been used to rationalize the result in terms of the population of extended chain conformers. Yoon and Bruckner (1985) stated that the distribution of chain sequence extension depends strongly on the specific groups or atoms connected at the ends of the two parts. When the linear rigid mesogenic units are attached to flexible −O− − (or − −O− −CO− −), the chains have segments (polymethylene) through − a higher population of highly extended conformers than when the attach−CO− −O− −. This is especially so when flexible segments ment is through − have an even numbers of chain atoms. With the first type of attachment, chains having even-numbered methylene units in a flexible polymethylene segment exhibit a significant population of highly extended conformers that allow nearly parallel alignment of rigid units along the major extension axis. Chains with odd-numbered methylenes attached in the same way offer few conformers in which the polymer as a whole is highly extended. With the second type of attachment, the difference in the population of extended conformers for even- and odd-numbered methylenes is less significant. Giving an example, in Table 3.9 the odd-even effect of a polymethylene segment on the nematic-to-isotropic transition of the polymer 3.38 (Buglione et al., 1983) is demonstrated. Even though the phase transition temperature and the enthalpy have a tendency of decreasing with a lengthening of the flexible segment, the clearing temperature and the enthalpy of isotropization are higher for polymers with even-numbered methylene units than for the two neighboring polymers having odd-numbered methylenes. CH3 O
C
O CH
O
O
C ( CH 2 ) n C
.
3.38
Molecular Engineering of Liquid Crystalline Polymers
Table 3.9. 3.38∗ .
Odd-even effect in liquid crystalline property of
n
6
7
8
9
T i, K ∆H, kJ/mol
575 9.59
503 2.72
528 8.66
479 3.18