PROCEEDINGS OF THE
Sixteenth International Cryogenic Engineering Conference] International Cryogenic Materials Conference
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PROCEEDINGS OF THE
Sixteenth International Cryogenic Engineering Conference] International Cryogenic Materials Conference PART 1
Kitakyushu, Japan 20-24 May 1996
Editors: T. Haruyama, T. Mitsui and K. Yamafuji
ELSEVIER
U.K.
Elsevier Science Ltd, The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford, OX5 1GB, England
U.S.A.
Elsevier Science Inc., 660 White Plains Road, Tarrytown, New York, 10591-5153, U.S.A.
JAPAN Elsevier Science Japan, Tsunashima Building Annex, 3-20-12 Yushima, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113, Japan
Copyright © 1997 Elsevier Science All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means; electronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior permission in writingfrom the publisher. First edition 1997 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalogue record for this tit!e is available from the Library of Congress. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library.
ISBN 0-08-042688-3
Printed and bound in Great Britain by BPC Wheatons Ltd, Exeter
CONTENTS LIST
PART ONE Committee members Exhibitors Foreword Greetings from the ICE Committee Greetings from the ICMC Board
oo
XXXVll
xxxix xli xliii xlv
Mendelssohn Award
xlvii
Mendelssohn Award Winner
xlix
Plenary Lectures A way to commercialization of high-Tc superconductors S. Tanaka Development of the superconducting Maglev system in Japan M. Ozeki
13
Cryogenic properties of advanced composites and their applications S. Nishijima
19
122-Channel SQUID neuromagnetometer for studies of information processing in the human brain O. V. Lounasmaa
27
Advances in cryocoolers R. Radebaugh
33
The Large Hadron Collider project L. R. Evans
45
Overview of the ITER project R. A ymar
53
Large Scale Refrigeration Refrigeration Plants
Design and construction of cryogenic components for LHD S. Satoh, T. Mito, S. Yamada, J. Yamamoto, O. Motojima and LHD Group
63
vi
Contents
The constituent hardware of the large helium refrigeration plant for LHD H. Matsuda, I. Ushijima, M. Katada, S. Satoh, J. Yamamoto and O. Motojima
67
Simulation of the large helium refrigeration plant for LHD M. Nobutoki, K. Iwamoto and H. Matsuda
71
Construction report of 10 kW class helium refrigerator for LHD S. Satoh, T. Mito, S. Yamada, A. Iwamoto, R. Maekawa, S. Moriuchi, T. Baba, K. Ooba, H. Sekiguchi, J. Yamamoto, O. Motojima and LHD Group
75
Cryogenic control system for the large helical device T. Mito, S. Satoh, R. Maekawa, S. Yamada, K. Takahata, A. Iwamoto, H. Yamada, K. Watanabe, T. Baba, S. Moriuchi, K. Oba, H. Sekiguchi, K. Murai, K. Iimura, K. Nakamura, J. Yamamoto, O. Motojima and LHD Group
79
Liquefaction control of 10 kW class cryogenic system for the LHD S. Yamada, S. Satoh, T. Mito, R. Maekawa, A. Iwamoto, S. Moriuchi, T. Baba, J. Yamamoto, O. Motojima and LHD Group, H. Matsuda, I. Ushijima, K. Nakamura, T. Kukano and M. Katada
83
Study of optimum operating condition for the helium refrigeration system of the LHD with a dummy load apparatus R. Maekawa, T. Mito, S. Yamada, S. Satoh, A. Iwamoto, T. Baba, S. Moriuchi, K. Ohba, H. Sekiguchi, I. Ohtake, H. Yamada, J. Yamamoto, O. Motojima and LHD Group, K. Chida and T. Fukano
87
Cryogenic operation and testing of the extended LHC prototype magnet string A. BOzaguet, J. Casas-Cubillos, H. Guinaudeau, B. Hilbert, Ph. Lebrun, L. Serio, A. Suraci and R. van Weelderen
91
Demands in refrigeration capacity for the Large Hadron Collider Ph. Lebrun, G. Riddone, L. Tavian and U. Wagner
95
Simulation program for cryogenic plants at CERN E. Melaaen, G. Owren, A. Wadahl and U. Wagner
99
Operation of the cryogenic system for superconducting cavities in LEP M. Barranco-Luque, S. Claudet, Ph. Gayet, N. Solheim and G. Winkler
103
Thermodynamic booster for the CERN Omega cryoplant F. Haug, J.-P. Dauvergne, H. Rieder and P. Chaffard
107
Refrigeration system for the ATLAS experiment F. Haug, J. I.-P. Dauvergne, G. Passardi, D. Cragg, C. Cure, P. Pailler, C. Mavri and A. Yamamoto
111
The cryogenic system of the ATLAS experiment end cap toroids D. Cragg
115
Cryogenic design of the ATLAS thin superconducting solenoid magnet K. Tanaka, A. Yamamoto, Y. Doi, Y. Makida, T. Haruyama and T. Kondo
119
Barrel toroid cryogenic system for the ATLAS detector C. Mayri, C. Cur~, R. Duthil, D. Cragg, F. Haug and G. Passardi
123
Performance study of the cryogenic system for ITER CS model coil T. Kato, K. Hamada, K. Kawano, K. Matsui, T. Hiyama, K. Nishida, T. Honda, M. Taneda, S. Sekiguchi, K. Ootsu, H. Tsuji, S. Shimamoto, H. Yamamura, I. Kawashima, Y. Nakayama and Y. Watanabe
127
Contents vii Engineering design of cryoplant for ITER K. Hamada, T. Kato, T. Honda, K. Matsui, K. Nishida, H. Tsuji, S. Shimamoto, K. Yoshida, M. E. P. Wykes, V. Kalinin, M. Mori and A. Miyake
131
Interface detail design for ITER coil system T. Honda, F. Iida, K. Matsui, Y. Yasukawa, K. Nishida, K. Hamada, T. Kato, H. Tsuji, K. Yoshida, K. Sakaki, H. Hiue and S. Shimamoto
135
Development and operating experience of the nuclotron cryogenic system N. Agapov, H. Khodzhibagiyan, A. Kovalenko, A. Smirnov and A. Sukhanova
139
Mathematical modeling of a Fermilab helium liquefier coldbox M. G. Geynisman and R. J. Walker
143
HERA at lower temperatures?- Operational test of the HERA cryogenic system at subatmospheric pressure H. Lierl and H. Herzog
147
Cryogenics for tokamak HT-7 SC toroidal magnet Y.-F. Bi, N. Qiu and J.-R. Wang
151
Theoretical calculation of the large hydrogen liquefaction process K. Iwamoto
155
Development of helium refrigeration systems for 70 MW class superconducting generators H. Yanagi, M. Ikeuchi, A. Machida and Y. Ikeda
159
Long Term Operation Reliability of helium refrigeration systems for the TRISTAN detector magnets Y. Doi Technical analysis and statistics from long term helium cryoplant operation with experimental superconducting magnets at CERN D. Delikaris, J. L-P. Dauvergne and F. Haug
165
169
Cryogenics for CERN experiments. Past, present and future J. Bremer, J. I.-P. Dauvergne, D. Delikaris, N. Delruelle, F. Haug, G. Kesseler, G. Passardi, J. M. Rieubland and J. Tischhauser
173
Present state of Tevatron lower temperature operation B. L. Norris
179
Cryogenic system for TRISTAN superconducting RF cavities: Description and operating experience K. Hosoyama, K. Hara, A. Kabe, Y. Kojima, T. Ogitsu, Y. Morita, Y. Sakamoto, H. Nakai, T. Fujita and T. Kanekiyo
183
Compressors High power refrigeration at temperatures around 2.0 K G. Gistau-Baguer
189
A cryogenic axial-centrifugal compressor for superfluid helium refrigeration L. Decker, K. LO'hlein, P. Schustr, M. Vins, I. Brunovsk, L. Tt~cek, Ph. Lebrun and L. Tavian
195
Upgrade of the CERN cryogenic station for superfluid helium testing of prototype LHC superconducting magnets V. Benda, J. I.-P. Dauvergne, F. Haug, S. Knoops, Ph. Lebrun, F. Momal, V. Sergo, L. Tavian and B. Vullierme
199
viii
Contents
Performance analysis of multistage 80 K centrifugal compressors for helium refrigerator
203
H. Asakura, N. Saji, Y. Kaneko, S. Yoshinaga, M. Mori, J. Sato, A. Miyake, T. Iwasaki, I. Nishimura, T. Hosoya and T. Umeda
Design manufacture and consideration for test result of centrifugal cold compressor for TEVATRON lower temperature upgrade
207
N. Saji, Y. Kaneko and H. Asakura
Development of helium oil free screw compressor
211
K. Kitagawa, Y. Hirao, Y. Yanagi and Y. Ikeda
Turboexpanders The experimental study of self-acting gas-lubricated tilting-pad thrust bearings for cryogenic turboexpander
217
C.-Z. Chen, H. Yao and Y. Wu
A genetic algorithm based optimization design method for cryogenic turboexpander
221
C.-H. Gao, H. Yao, and C.-Z. Chen
Predicting performance of helium expansion turbines using similarity principles
225
L.-Q. Liu and C.-Z. Chen
Stability study of herringbone-grooved, journal gas bearing for small cryogenic expansion turbine
229
L.-Q. Liu, G.-L. Zhou and C.-Z. Chen
Development of foil journal bearing for small high speed cryogenic turboexpander
233
H. Yao, H.-Y. Quan and C.-Z. Chen
Cryocoolers Pulse Tube Coolers Evaluation of experimental pulse tube refrigerator data with predictions of the thermoacoustic theory
239
A. Hofmann, S. Wild and L. R. Oellrich
Spontaneous oscillations of gas in a glass resonator: Observation of the local velocity and the simulation
243
A. Tominaga and T. Yazaki
Linear model of flow pattern for a valved three-stage pulse tube refrigeration
247
Z.-M. Xia, L.-M. Qiu, G.-B. Chen, L. Zhao, J.-Y. Zheng, J.-P. Yu and Z.-X. Huang
Radial temperature and velocity profiles of oscillating flows in a pulse tube refrigerator
251
K. Seo, M. Shiraishi, N. Nakamura and M. Murakami
Investigation of velocity profiles in oscillating flows inside a pulse tube refrigerator
255
M. Shiraishi, N. Nakamura, K. Seo and M. Murakami
Intrinsic behaviour of a four valve pulse tube refrigerator
259
M. Thfirk, H. Brehm, J. Gerster, G. Kaiser, R. Wagner and P. Seidel
Anomaly of one-stage double-inlet pulse tube refrigerator T. Shigi, Y. Fujii, M. Yamamoto, M. Nakamura, M. Yamaguchi, Y. Fujii, T. Nishitani, T. Araki, E. Kawaguchi and M. Yanai
263
Contents Temperature stability of pulse tube refrigerators
ix 267
N. Seki, S. Yamasaki, J. Yuyama, M. Kasuya, K. Arasawa, S. Furuya and H. Morimoto
Pulse tube refrigerator with low temperature switching valve
271
J.-T. Liang, C.-Q. Zhang, L. Xu, J.-H. Cai, E. Luo and Y. Zhou
On-off timing computer control system for valved refrigerator
275
L. Zhao, T. Sun, J.-Y. Zheng, Z.-X. Huang and G.-B. Chen
Increase in reservoir pressure of orifice pulse tube refrigerators
279
F. Kuriyama and Y. Fukasaku
Operation of a high-Tc SQUID gradiometer by use of a pulse tube refrigerator
283
G. Thummes, R. Landgraf, M. Mfick, K. Klundt and C. Heiden
Analysis and investigation of large diameter pulse tube refrigerator
287
Y.-Y. Guo, X.-X. Wang, S.-X. Bian and Y.-Z. Li
Active-buffer pulse-tube refrigerator
291
S.-W. Zhu, Y. Kakimi, K. Fujioka and Y. Matsubara
An inter-phasing pulse tube refrigerator for high refrigeration efficiency
295
J. L. Gao and Y. Matsubara
Experimental research on two-stage pulse tube refrigerator
299
T. Inoue, T. Matsui, S. Kawano and Y. Ohashi
Performance of the hybrid two-stage refrigerator
303
K. Tanida, J. L. Gao, Y. Hiresaki and Y. Matsubara
Improvement of the two stage pulse tube refrigerator reaching to 4 K
307
M. Tanaka, T. Nishitani, T. Kodama, T. Araki, E. Kawaguchi and M. Yanai
Nitrogen precooled multi-stage pulse tube refrigerator reaching 2.1 K
311
G. Thummes, S. Bender and C. Heiden
Thermodynamic calculation of three-stage pulse tube refrigerator
315
G.-B. Chen, Z.-M. Xia, L. Zhao, L.-M. Qiu, J.-Y. Zheng and J.-P. Yu
Three-staged pulse tube refrigerator with linear motor compressor
319
N. Yoshimura, Y. Matsubara, Y. Ohtani, H. Nakagome and H. Okuda
G - M Coolers
Effectiveness of magnetic regenerator material with low T~ below ~20 K regenerative character of magnetic materials
Very effective 325
T. Hashimoto
Development of a 4 K GM/JT refrigerator for Maglev vehicle
331
S. Fujimoto, S. Taneya, T. Kurihara, K. Miura, K. Tomioka, M. Okamoto, T. Yamaguchi, S. Kasahara, M. Terai, A. Miura, H. Nakao, T. Fujinami and Y. Nakamoto
Development of 2W class 4 K Gifford-McMahon cycle cryocooler
335
I. Takashi, N. Masashi, N. Kouki and Y. Hideto
Optimization of intake and exhaust valves for 4 K Gifford-McMahon cryocooler
339
R. Li, A. Onishi, T. Satoh and Y. Kanazawa
Investigation of the performance of a 4.2 K G-M refrigerator X.-D. Xu, L.-H. Gong, Z.-Y. Zhang and L.-A. Zhang
343
U.K.
Elsevier Science Ltd, The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford, OX5 1GB, England
U.S.A.
Elsevier Science Inc., 660 White Plains Road, Tarrytown, New York, 10591-5153, U.S.A.
JAPAN Elsevier Science Japan, Tsunashima Building Annex, 3-20-12 Yushima, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113, Japan
Copyright © 1997 Elsevier Science All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means; electronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior permission in writingfrom the publisher. First edition 1997 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalogue record for this tit!e is available from the Library of Congress. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library.
ISBN 0-08-042688-3
Printed and bound in Great Britain by BPC Wheatons Ltd, Exeter
Contents Cooling performance of a pressurized HeII cryogenics system for the superconducting magnet test facility at KEK N. Kimura, Y. Ajima, Y. Doi, T. Haruyama, N. Higashi, M. Iida, S. Kato, M. Kawai, H. Kawamata, S. Kim, Y. Kondou, Y. Makida, K. Mimori, S. Mizumaki, T. Nakamoto, T. Ogitsu, H. Ohhata, N. Ohuchi, S. Sugawara, T. Shintomi, K. Tanaka, A. Terashima, K. Tsuchiya, H. Yamaoka and A. Yamamoto
A supercritical/superfluid He-cryostat for STEP
xi
419
423
D. Mohr, A. Seidel, M. Sander, G. Jochimsen, A. Wagner, J. Wolf, J. Weber and K. Petersen
Design of thermal shield for the ITER cryostat K. Hamada, K. Nishida, T. Kato, T. Honda, H. Tsuji, A. Itoh, M. Nakahira, S. Shimamoto, M. E. P. Wykes, R. Bourque, I. Ohno and Y. Miyauchi
427
Design of superfluid-cooled cryostat for 1 GHz NMR spectrometer A. Sato, T. Kiyoshi, H. Wada, H. Maeda, S. Itoh and Y. Kawate
431
A variable temperature cryostat to measure Jnoncu(T) of ITER strands up to 20 teslas B. Jager, A. Bocquillon, P. Chaussonnet, A. Martinez, S. Nicollet, J. P. Serries and J. C. Vallier
435
Tests of the cryostat for 1.3 GHz superconducting cavity at T _< 1.8 K Yu. P. Filippov, A. M. Kovrizhnykh, V. I. Batin and S. V. Uchaikin
439
Comparison of floating and thermalized multilayer insulation systems at low boundary temperature G. Ferlin, B. Jenninger, P. Lebrun, G. Peon, G. Riddone and B. Szeless
443
Cooling Technique A LHE economiser at 1.8 K S. Buhler
449
Low noise gas flow cryosystem for cooling high-Tc squid J. Troell and C. Heiden
453
Compact dilution refrigerator S. Yoshida, S. Mori, T. Umeno, Y. Kamioka, M. Watanabe and Y. Ootuka
457
Experimental study of the dilution refrigerator without 1 K pot M. Maeda, T. Shigematsu, Z.-M. Li, T. Shigi, Y. Fujii, M. Yamaguchi and M. Nakamura
461
Numerical simulation of countercurrent heat exchangers in cryogenic systems M. Kauschke and H. Quack
465
The operation experience with the dual cooling system of the POLO coil (two phase-supercritical He) W. Herz, M. Siitier, A. Ulbricht and F. Wiichner
469
A vortex refrigerator for NMR experiments
473
M. Fujii, K. Nakamura, X. Xu, K. Kawano and K. Okada
Analytical model to calculate the transient thermo-mechanical behaviour of long thin structures cooled from a pipe: Application to the LHC dipole thermal shield G. Pe6n, G. Riddone and L. R. Williams Characterization of bonnetless cryogenic valves K. Daido, K. Yoshikawa, R. Maekawa and S. Satoh Flexible corrugated cryotransferlines, long term experience at JET and the experience with supercritical helium flow conditions W. Obert and C. Mayaux
477
481
485
xii
Contents
Experimental results with superinsulated cryogenic transfer line test modules in THISTA IV. Lehmann, M. Seidler and M. Stamm
489
Design and construction of long cryogenic piping lines K. Kawano, K. Hamada, T. Kato, T. Honda, K. Nishida, K. Matsui, T. Hiyama, K. Ohtsu, S. Sekiguchi, H. Tsuji, M. Ando, T. Hiyama and K. Ichige
493
Calculating radiation exchange factors of radiant cryocooler by the Monte Carlo method H. Yao, C.-H. Gao, C.-Z. Chen and Y.-Z. Li
497
Development of loop heat pipes for cryogenic applications R. Chandratilleke, Y. Ohtani, H. Hatakeyama and H. Nakagome
501
New cryosurgical probe suitable for endoscopic application in the minimal invasive therapy B. Schumann, A. Binneberg and R. Herzog
505
Thermosiphon cooler: A low microphonic cooling system for HTC-devices; especially for SQUIDs A. Binneberg, H. Buschmann, R. Herzog, J. Neubert and G. Sp6"rl
509
What happened to cryogenic and superconducting equipment in the Great Hanshin Earthquake? Final report A. Sato, K. Fujioka, T. Haruyama, H. Hirabayashi, T. Ishigohka, A. Ishiyama, Y. Kawate, K. Nishigaki, S. Nishijima, T. Noguchi, O. Ogino, H. Ogiwara and O. Okazaki
513
Superfluid Helium Thermohydraulic behaviour of HelI in stratified co-current two-phase flow B. Rousset, A. Gauthier, L. Grimaud, A. Bezaguet and R. van Weelderen
519
Influence of fountain pressure on heat transfer to superfluid helium Y.-Z. Li, U. Ruppert, L Arend and K. Lfiders
523
Analysis and characterization of saturated bath He II heat exchangers S. W. Van Sciver and S. J. Welton
527
Experimental study of propagation characteristics of He i-He II interface K. Kamiya, M. Murakami and N. Yanagise
531
Steady and unsteady heat transfer from a horizontal wire with a wide range of diameter in a pool of subcooled He II at pressures M. Shiotsu, K. Hata, Y. Takeuchi, K. Hama and A. Sakurai
535
Two dimensional heat transport in He II channel including a copper wall T. Okamura, S. Hamaguchi, S. Sakuma, T. Suekane and S. Kabashima
539
Numerical investigation of evolution of vortex line density in the case of transient heating T. Kanari and M. Murakami
543
Heat transfer from superconductor wire to superfluid helium Y.-Z. Li, Y.-Z. Wu, Y.-Y. Wu, U. Ruppert, I. Arend and K. Lfiders
547
The effect of spacer arrangement on the heat transfer in He I and He II channels H. Kobayashi and K. Kawakami
551
Pressure effect on the heat transfer in bath of superfluid helium R.-Z. Wang, P. Zhang and J.-Y. Wu
555
Kapitza conductance of niobium for S. R. F. cavities A. Boucheffa, M. X. Franqois and J. Amrit
559
Contents
xiii
Thermal behaviour of electrical multilayer insulation permeable to superfluid helium B. Baudouy, A. Boucheffa, M. X. Fran,cois and C. Meuris
563
Pressure gradient caused by quantized vortex in superfluid helium M. Yamaguchi, Y. Fujii, M. Nakamura, T. Shigematsu and T. Shigi
567
Heat and mass transfer between two saturated He II baths X. Huang, J. Panek and S. W. Van Sciver
571
Measurement of characteristic time of quantized vortex development using a thermal shock wave T. Shimazaki and M. Murakami
575
Heat Transfer Non-dimensional correlation for boiling heat transfer from sintered porous layer surface R.-S. Wang, A.-Z. Gu, Z. Li and J.-H. Huang
581
Critical heat fluxes in pool boiling of subcooled liquid nitrogen at elevated pressures K. Hata, M. Shiotsu and A. Sakurai
585
The measurement of vapor bubble vibration during noisy film boiling in superfluid helium M. Yamaguchi and M. Murakami
589
Influence of surface roughness on transient nucleate boiling of cryogens S. Fuchino, N. Tamada, I. Ishii and M. Okano
593
Superheating of liquid mixtures of 3He and 4He K. Nishigaki, M. Takeda and Y. Maruno
597
Nucleate pool boiling heat transfer to slush hydrogen K. Ohira and H. Furumoto
601
Heat transfer characteristics of a prototype pool boiling superconductor to liquid helium A. Iwamoto, T. Mito, K. Takahata, N. Yanagi and J. Yamamoto
605
Temporal deterioration of helium heat transfer at moderate pulse heat load Y. P. Filippov and I. A. Sergeyev
609
Cryogenic characteristic investigation on heat transfer between gas and solids of an adiabatic moving-bed Y.-Y. Guo, Z.-Z. Li, L. Wang and L.-A. Zhang
613
Transient heat transfer from a silver sheathed high-Tc superconducting tape in liquid nitrogen M. Shiotsu, K. Hata, A. Sakurai, C. Suzawa, S. Isojima and K. Sato
617
Surface treatment of aluminum heat switch T. Shigematsu, M. Maeda, M. Takeshita, Y. Fujii, M. Nakamura, M. Yamaguchi, T. Shigi and H. Ishii
621
The study on the solid thermal contact resistance at low temperatures L. Xu, S.-L. Zhou, J. Yang and J.-M. Xu
625
Experimental study on thermal contact conductance at liquid helium temperature K. Sunada and Y.-M. Kang
629
Gas Properties On the Joule-Thomson integral inversion curves of helium-3, helium-4 and hydrogen B.-Z. Maytal and A. Shavit
635
xiv
Contents
A modified Patel-Teja equation of state for cryogenic fluids G.-M. Chen, Z.-Z. Yin and G.-B. Chen
639
Helium extraction from thermal spring gases D. Ghose, B. Sinha, R. Dey, S. K. Das and D. G. Bhattacharya
643
Measurements Temperature measurement under high magnetic fields around 1.8 K by using CGR thermometers T. Haruyama, N. Kimura, K. Tanaka and A. Yamamoto
649
New type of thin-film germanium resistance thermometer for use in a wide temperature range V. Mitin, Y. Tkhorik and E. Venger
653
Thermoacoustic Taconis oscillations in helium-4 liquid level sensors S. Yoshida, K. V. Ravikumar, J. Williamson, N. Papavasiliou and T. H. K. Frederking
657
Use of strain gages for low temperature thermal expansion measurements R. P. Walsh
661
Strain measurements of stainless steel at low temperatures using electronic speckle pattern interferometry S. Nakahara, H. Sakiyama, S. Hisada and T. Fujita
665
Friction and wear testing at cryogenic temperatures T. Gradt, W. Hfibner and H. B6rner
669
A flexible and extensible monitoring system for large scale experiments J. Kariya, H. Okumura, M. Emoto, M. Shoji, Y. Teramachi, T. Ohska, Y. Shamoto, S. Yamaguchi, O. Motojima and J. Yamamoto
673
Development of a low temperature measurement and control system for measuring liquid oxygen density D. Wang, Z.-X. Huang, G.-B. Chen, J.-Y. Zheng, J.-P. Yu, Y.-Y. Li, M. Shen, H.-Y. Chen, R.-L. Xu, G.-W. Cui and R.-M. Liu
677
Investigation of thermal and vacuum transients on the LHC prototype magnet string P. Cruikshank, N. Kos, G. Riddone and L. Tavian
681
Innovative device producing double-layer cryogenic pellet H. Itoh and S. Sudo
685
A new concept to detect He leaks on TORE SUPRA cryogenic plant F. Minot, G. Bon Mardion, B. Jager, B. Gravil, J. L. Marechal and J. L. Violet
689
One consideration for recovery heat flux of directly heated wires Y.-Z. Li, Y.-Z. Wu, Y.-Y. Wu, U. Ruppert, L Arend and K. Lfiders
693
A novel superconductor V-I simulator for 77 K B. ten Haken and H. H. J. ten Kate
697
The estimation of critical current density using SRPM and AC methods S. Koto, H. Nakane, E. S. Otabe, T. Matsushita, S. Nagaya and S. Yoshizawa
701
Contents
xv
PART TWO Space Cryogenics ISO
707
ISO in-orbit cryogenic performances, system aspects
711
Half a year on orbit Th. Paflvogel, A. Seidel, U. Sagner, G. Jochimsen, M. Sander, J. Wolf, E. Ettlinger and K Petersen B. Collaudin, Th. Passvogel, A. Seidel and J. J. Juillet
The FIRST-cryosystem with ISO-technology Th. Paflvogel, A. Seidel, J. Schupp, M. Sander and G. Jochimsen
715
Study of cryodeposition contamination of radiant coolers D. Dong and W.-Y. Wang
719
Application of Superconductivity Fusion Large helical device project for SC steady-state fusion experiment O. Motojima
725
Superconducting coil system for the LHD and its R&D J. Yamamoto and LHD Group
731
Cooling and excitation experiments of a single inner vertical coil (EXSIV) for the large helical device T. Satow, T. Mito, K. Takahata, J. Yamamoto, S. Satoh, A. Nishimura, S. Tanahashi, S. Yamada, H. Chikaraishi, H. Tamura, N. Yanagi, S. Imagawa, A. Iwamoto, R. Maekawa, K. Yamazaki, S. Yamaguchi, K. Watanabe, N. Inoue, H. Suzuki, T. Morisaki, S. Masuzaki, Y. Katoh, S. Sakakibara, K. Nishimura, M. lima, H. Hayasi, T. Baba, S. Moriuchi, K. Ohba, H. Ogawa, H. Sekiguchi, I. Ohtake, O. Motojima, M. Takeo, A. Ninomiya, S. Ioka and T. Uede Hydraulic characteristics and stability for the experiments on a single inner vertical coil (EXSIV) for the large helical device K. Takahata, T. Mito, T. Satow, A. Nishimura, S. Yamada, H. Chikaraishi, N. Yanagi, A. Iwamoto, R. Maekawa, S. Imagawa, H. Tamura, S. Satoh, S. Tanahashi, J. Yamamoto, O. Motojima, EXSIV Group, T. Kai, K. Nakamoto, M. Ono and T. Yoshida
735
739
Test facilities of the experiments on a single inner vertical coil (EXSIV) for the large helical device T. Mito, K. Takahata, T. Satow, S. Satoh, A. Nishimura, S. Yamada, N. Yanagi, H. Chikaraishi, A. Iwamoto, R. Maekawa, S. Tanahashi, T. Kai, T. Yamamoto, Y. Wachi, T. Uede, H. Hiue, I. Itoh, N. Saji, A. Miyake, I. Ohno, O. Motojima, J. Yamamoto and EXSIV Group
743
Electrical power system for EXSIV H. Chikaraishi, S. Yamada, T. Mito, T. Satow, S. Tanahasi, O. Motojima, J. Yamamoto, EXSIV Group, T. Uede, H. Hiue, Y. Yonenaga and S. Araki
747
Development, fabrication, testing and joints of aluminum stabilized superconductors for the helical coils of LHD N. Yanagi, T. Mito, S. Imagawa, T. Satow, K. Takahata, A. Nishimura, S. Yamada, A. Iwamoto, S. Yamaguchi, H. Chikaraishi, J. Yamamoto, O. Motojima, LHD Group, Y. Kuchiishi, T. Tamaki, T. Senba, K. Asano, S. Suzuki, T. Miyaji, S. Inaba, M. Seido and H. Moriai Deformation analysis for coil pack simulating large scale pool-boiling superconducting coil H. Tamura, A. Nishimura, S. Imagawa, J. Yamamoto, K. Asano, T. Tamaki, K. Nakanishi and S. Suzuki
751
755
xvi
Contents
Deformation behavior of coil pack for helical coil in large helical device A. Nishimura, H. Tamura, S. Imagawa, J. Yamamoto, K. Asano, T. Tamaki, K. Nakanishi and S. Suzuki
759
ITER CS model coil project N. Mitchell, K. Okuno, R. Thome, H. Tsuji, T. Ando, S. Shimamoto, J. Jayakumar and J. Minervini
763
Design of the ITER-CS model coil ~
767
Joint development of the CS insert coil M. Sugimoto, A. Terasawa, H. Nakajima, T. Kato, Y. Nunoya, K. Matsui, Y. Takahashi, T. Ando, T. Isono, N. Koizumi, H. Tsuji, S. Shimamoto, T. Ichihara, T. Sasaki, M. Hasegawa and T. Minato
771
Development of 46 kA layer to layer joint for INTER-CS model coil Y. Nunoya, Y. Takahashi, T. Ando, H. Nakajima, T. Kato, M. Sugimoto, M. Oshikiri, T. Isono, N. Koizumi, K. Matsui, Y. Miura, H. Tsuji, S. Shimamoto, H. Ogata and J. Shibuya
775
AC loss measurement of 46-kA conductor joint for CS model coil K. Matsui, T. Ito, Y. Takahashi, Y. Nunoya, M. Sugimoto, H. Fujisaki, H. Tsuji, and S. Shimamoto
779
Fabrication R & D of outer module of ITER CS model coil T. Sasaki, S. Yanaka, M. Ushijima, S. Murai, T. Hirumachi, J. Inagaki, H. Ogata, Y. Sumiyoshi, O. Ohsaki, T. Fujioka, T. Ando, Y. Takahashi, H. Nakajima, M. Sugimoto, K. Hamada and H. Tsuji
783
Consideration of current sharing temperature measurement for ITER CS model coil T. Honda, T. Ando, H. Tsuji and S. Shimamoto
787
Cool-down simulation of 46 kA and 13 T Nb3A1 insert N. Koizumi, T. Ito, T. Ando, M. Sugimoto, A. Terasawa, M. Nozawa, L Watanabe, H. Tsuji, S. Shimamoto, K. Okuno, H. Tsukamoto and M. Otsuka
791
Experimental results and design of 50-kA forced-cooled current leads for fusion machines Y. Takahashi, M. Sugimoto, K. Matsui, K. Takano, M. Nozawa, Y. Nunoya, N. Koizumi, H. Nakajima, T. Kato, K. Nishida, T. Honda, T. Ando, H. Tsuji, Y. Yasukawa, L Itoh, K. Sakaki and M. Konno
795
RF jacketing line for manufacturing ITER cable-in-conduit conductor
799
outer module T. Ando, Y. Takahashi, H. Nakajima, T. Kato, T. Isono, M. Sugimoto, K. Hamada, N. Koizumi, Y. Nunoya, K. Matsui, A. Terasawa, K. Nishida, T. Honda, H. Tsuji, S. Shimamoto, T. Fujioka and O. Osaki
V. Sytnikov, I. Peshkov, A Taran, I. Semeonov, A. Rychagov, V. Mitrohin, P. Dolgosheev and L Chensky Fast ramp 50 kA superconducting transformer for testing full-size ITER cable joints
803
H. G. Knoopers, S. Wessel, H. J. G. Krooshoop, O. A. Shevchenko, A. Godeke, H. H. J. ten Kate, B. A. Smith, R. J. Camille and J. V. Minervini Plasma disruption simulation test facility
807
T. Ando, S. Iwamoto, I. Itou, H. Tsuji and S. Shimamoto Cool down and charging tests of a double-conduit type forced-flow superconducting coil H. Morita, Y. Wadayama, Y. Hotta, K. Kouriki, Y. Murata, R. Takahashi, K. Asano, A. Shigenaka, Y. Takahashi, K. Yoshida and H. Tsuji
811
Cooling of the W7-X superconducting coils F. Schauer
815
Contents Test facility in support of the SST-1 CICC
xvii 819
B. Sarkar, S. Pradhan, C. P. Dhard, V. Tanna, A. K. Sahu, A. Amardas, Y. C. Saxena and S S T Team
Analysis of CICC behaviour in the SST-1 magnets
823
S. Pradhan, S. Das, B. Biswas, Y. C. Saxena and S S T Team
Energy dissipation in SST-1 coil joints
827
S. Pradhan, S. Das, B. Biswas, Y. C. Saxena and S S T Team
Stabilization and confinement of discharge plasma with high-Tc bulk superconductor tubes (Supertrons) H. Matsuzawa, Y. Mizutani, J. Ishikawa and S. Suganomata
831
Accelerators and Detectors
Power test results of the first LHC second generation superconducting single aperture lm long dipole models
837
A. Siemko, G. Kirby, J. Ostler, D. Perini, N. Siegel, D. Tommasini and L. Walckiers
Testing of TRISTAN insertion quadrupole magnet in superfluid helium
843
K. Tsuchiya, T. Ogitsu, N. Ohuchi, K. Sasaki, Y. Doi, T. Haruyama, S. Kato, H. Kawamata, S. Kim, N. Kimura, N. C. Bhattacharya, T. Shintomi, K. Tanaka, A. Terashima and A. Yamamoto
A superconducting wiggler magnet for the National Laboratory of Synchrotron Radiation
847
Q. L. Wang, Y. F. Bi, B. Z. Li, L. R. Din, F. T. Wang, C. W. An and L. Z. Lin
Fabrication and testing of a 13 m-long SSC model dipole magnet K. Hosoyama, K. Hara, N. Higashi, A. Kabe, H. Kawamata, Y. Kojima, Y. Morita, H. Nakai, A. Terashima, T. Takahashi, T. Shintomi, H. Hirabayashi and Y. Kimura
851
Design study of the injection system of the RIKEN superconducting ring cyclotron
855
H. Okuno, T. Tominaka, T. Kubo, J.-W. Kim, T. Mitsumoto, T. Kawaguchi, Y. Tanaka, S. Fujishima, K. Ikegami, A. Goto and Y. Yano
Design study of sector magnet for RIKEN superconducting ring cyclotron
859
T. Kawaguchi, T. Kubo, T. Mitsumoto, T. Tominaka, S. Fujishima, H. Okuno, Y. Tanaka, J.-W. Kim, K. Ikegami, A. Goto and Y. Yano
The aluminum stabilized conductor for the Fermilab DO solenoid
863
R. P. Smith, H. E. Fisk, K. Krempetz, R. Yamada, S. Mine, T. Kobayashi, L L. Horvath, H. P. Marti, J. Neuenschwander, D. Grman, R. Huwiler, H. Eriksson, J. Seppala, J. Teuho, W. B. Sampson, A. K. Ghosh, B. Seeber, L. Erbuke and R. Flukiger
Ten year operational experience of the TRISTAN detector selenoid magnets
867
T. Haruyama, Y. Doi, Y. Makida, K. Aoki, T. Kobayashi, Y. Kondo, M. Kawai, K. Tsuchiya, M. Wake and A. Yamamoto
Cryogenic system for the Muon g-2 Superconducting Magnet
871
X.-J. Lin, G. Bunce, J. R. Cullen, M. A. Green, C.-I. Pai, L. P. Snydstrup and T. Tallerico
Forced two-phase helium cooling of four 15-meter-in-diameter superconducting solenoids
875
X.-J. Lin, G. Bunce, J. R. Cullen, M. A. Green, C.-I. Pai, L. P. Snydstrup and T. Tallerico
Gas cooled cryogenic power leads for the relativistic heavy ion collider M. L. F. Rehak and A. Nicoletti
879
xviii
Contents
Motors and Generators Present status and future prospect of research & development of superconducting technology for electric power apparatuses- mainly on R&D for superconducting generator S. Nakayama, M. Kazumori and K. Komatsu
885
Applications of superconducting technology to electric power systems Y. Aiyama, S. Nakayama, M. Nishikawa, T. Ageta and T. Nitta
891
Investigation of superconducting turbogenerator operation in the network L. I. Chubraeva
895
R&D project on superconducting generators in Super-GM T. Ageta
899
Development of 70MW class superconducting generators K. Yamaguchi, K. Suzuki, K. Miyaike, K. Toyoda and T. Ichikawa
905
A series of studies on superconducting generator with high response excitation T. Kisida, Y. Imai, T. Nitta, T. Okada, H. Hasegawa and H. Nagamura
909
Investigation of superconductor for 70 MW class model superconducting generator of quick response type H. Takigami, H. Nakamura, E. S. Yoneda, M. Sugimoto, A. Kimura, H. Sakamoto, Y. Furuto, K. Inoue and K. Sato Analysis of AC losses for superconductors for 70 MW class model superconducting generator of quick response type A. Kimura, M. Sugimoto, H. Sakamoto, Y. Furuto, H. Takigami, H. Nakamura, E. S. Yoneda, K. Inoue and K. Sato
913
917
AC losses in a double-stranded Nb-Ti cable for a quick-response-type superconducting generator M. Sugimoto, A. Kimura, H. Sakamoto, Y. Furuto, H. Takigami, H. Nakamura, E. S. Yoneda, F. Sumiyoshi, S. Kawabata, K. Inoue and K. Sato
921
Experimental investigation of helical armature winding for a light cryoalternator of 1-3 MW class L. I. Chubraeva and D. V. Sirotko
925
Combination of HTSC, high-purity aluminum and Nd-Fe-B in a synchronous alternator L. I. Chubraeva, I. S. Ganzinov, S. N. Pylinina, V. A. Sapozhnicov, V. E. Sigaev and V. A. Tutaev
929
Critical current and strain of in-situ processed Nb3Sn superconductor under cyclic mechanical load K. Goto, S. Iwaski, N. Sadakata, T. Saitoh, O. Kohno, S. Torii, H. Kasahara, S. Akita and J. Yoshitomi
933
Design and construction of an HTSC synchronous machine with permanent magnet excitation L Vajda, A. G. Mamalis and A. Szalay
937
Machine constants of 30 kVA superconducting synchronous motor with rotating field windings K.-D. Choi, T. Hoshino, H. Tsukiji, M. Tsukiyama, T. Nishiya, I. Muta, E. Mukai and S.- Y. Hahn
941
HTSC bulk magnet motor Z. Szfics and U. Ruppert
945
Rotating helium transfer coupling for a 200 KVA superconducting generator S. Jacob, S. Kasthurirengan, R. Karunanithi, T. Suryanarayana, K. A. Durga Prasad, K. S. N. Raju and J. L. Bhattacharya
949
Contents
xix
Test of high-voltage output magnetic flux pump for superconducting magnet H. Tsukiji, K.-D. Choi, M. Tsukiyama, T. Nishiya, T. Hoshino, I. Muta and E. Mukai
953
Dielectric breakdown of liquid helium in a rotating cryostat L Ishii, S. Fuchino, M. Okano and N. Tamada
957
Power Cables Research and development of compact high-Tc superconducting cables T. Hara, H. Ishii and S. Honjo
963
The development of HTS cable technology T. Shibata, M. Watanabe, C. Suzawa, S. Isojima, J. Fujikami, N. Saga, K. Ohmatsu, K. Sato, H. Ishii, S. Honjyo and T. Hara
967
Development of the termination for the 77 kV-class high Tc superconducting power cable T. Masuda, S. Isojima, T. Shimonosono and S. Nagaya
971
Development of long length HTSC cable conductor J. Fujikami, N. Saga, K. Ohmatsu, T. Shibata, M. Watanabe, C. Suzawa, S. Isojima, K. Sato, H. Ishii, S. Honjo and T. Hara
975
Research and development of 50 m-long high-Tc superconductor for power cables S. Mukoyama, K. Miyoshi, H. Tsubouti, M. Mimura, N. Uno, Y. Tanaka, N. Ichiyanagi, H. Ishii, S. Honjo and T. Hara
979
1.5 kA-class multilayered Bi-2223/Ag conductors: DC and AC characterizations M. Luciano, C. Franco, M. Ernesto and O. Vanni
983
Fabrication and evaluation of the high-Tc conductors using Bi-2223 Ag sheathed tapes A. Kume, S. Nagaya, T. Shimonosono, M. Nakagawa, M. Nagata, N. Sadakata, T. Saitoh, O. Kohno and M. Ono
987
R&D on oxide superconducting wires for application to power apparatuses N. Yoshida, K. Sato, J. Yoshitomi and T. Ichikawa
991
Fabrication of YBCO superconducting tape by continuous MOCVD technique K. Onabe, S. Nagaya, T. Shimonosono, Y. Iijima, N. Sadakata, T. Saito and O. Kohno
995
Alignment of unidirectionally grown YBCO S. Asakura, S. Nagaya, T. Shimonosono, M. Nakagawa, N. Sadakata, T. Saitoh and O. Kohno
999
Fabrication of high Jc YBCO tapes using YSZ buffer layers deposited by IBAD method M. Hosaka, Y. Iijima, N. Sadakata, T. Saito, O. Kohno and J. Yoshitomi
1003
Power Devices Design and construction of a 500 kVA-class oxide superconducting power transformer cooled by liquid nitrogen K. Funaki, M. Iwakuma, M. Takeo, K. Yamafuji, J. Suehiro, M. Hara, M. Konno, Y. Kasagawa, K. Okubo, Y. Yasukawa, S. Nose, M. Ueyama, K. Hayashi and K. Sato
1009
Characteristics and AC losses of coreless superconducting autotransformers K. Kajikawa, K. Kaiho, M. Yamamoto, H. Fuji, N. Sadakata, T. Saito and O. Kohno
1013
Design study for the development of a 1 kA persistent-current-switch in a type of transformer H. Hayashi, T. Imayoshi, K. Tsutsumi, M. Takeo, S. Sato, H. Morimoto, K. Asano and K. Yamaguchi
1017
xx
Contents
Inductive superconducting fault curren[ limiter development J. R. Cave, D. W. A. Will, n, R. Nadi, W. Zhu and Y. Brissette
1021
Magnetic shield type high Tc superconducting fault current limiter T. Onishi, S. Yamasaki and A. Nii
1025
Development of 6.6 kV/1 kA single-phase superconducting fault current limiter loss reduction T. Yazawa, T. Kurusu, M. Takahashi, K. Yamamoto, S. Nomura, M. Urata, T. Ohkuma, M. Nakade and T. Hara
AC 1029
Development of a 6.6 kV class compact fault current limiter M. Takahashi, H. Nakagome, M. Urata, T. Ohkuma, M. Nakade and T. Hara
1033
Electrical application of a HTS saturable magnetic core fault current limiter J. X. Jin, C. Grantham, X. Y. Li, Z. Y. Liu, Y. C. Guo, T. R. Blackburn, H. L. Liu, J. N. Li, H. K. Liu, Z. J. Zeng, J. Y. Liu and S. X. Dou
1037
Progress of 480 MJ/40 MW SMES component development project Y. Murakami, O. Tsukamoto, T. Sato, E. Masada, K. Ogiso, S. Neo and M. Hosokawa
1041
A conceptual design of a concentric double spherical coil system for a medium scale SMES T. Ezaki, N. Watanabe and I. Kamiya
1045
Design study for the development of 1 kWh/1 MW module type SMES T. Imayoshi, K. Tsutsumi, F. Irie, M. Takeo, K. Funaki, H. Okada, T. Ezaki, R. Itoh, F. Sumiyoshi, Y. Satoh, K. Asano and S. Nose
1049
Experimental results of cryogenic stability of the superconductor for SMES A. Tomioka, T. Bohno, S. Nose, M. Konno, K. Sakaki, M. Takeo, K. Funaki, S. Sato and M. Matsuo
1053
Fundamental study of a HTS coil for SMES T. Masuda, S. Isojima, K. Ohkura, K. Sato, A. Ryouman, T. Kaito, T. Kishida and S. Uno
1057
Advanced mechanical switch for persistent current of SMES S. Nozaki, M. Masuda and M. Hamada
1061
Design and considerations on superconducting shunt reactors T. Nitta, S. Nogawa, Y. Nisiwaki and H. Nomura
1065
A proposal of new excitation method of superconducting magnet using LC resonance T. Ishigohka, K. Shimizu, A. Ninomiya and T. Koga
1069
Test results of a 200 A class fast response magnetically controlled persistent current switch H. Kimura, K. Noto, M. Matsukawa, S. Fujinuma, T. Segawa, T. Takahashi, N. Sadakata, T. Saito, K. Goto, O. Kohno, H. Honma and C. Takahashi
1073
Magnetic Levitation Design study of a superconducting bulk magnet for attractive-type magnetic levitation H. Ohsaki, A. Senba and E. Masada
1079
Magnetically levitated transport system in vacuum using high-Tc superconductors H. Minami, N. Ueda, T. Koike and J. Yuyama
1083
High Field Magnets High field magnets of Tsukuba Magnet Laboratories K. Inoue, T. Kiyoshi, T. Asano, Y. Sakai, G. Kido, H. Wada and H. Maeda
1089
Contents xxi Development of 18 T high magnetic field superconducting magnet O. Ozaki, M. Yoshikawa, R. Hirose, T. Miyazaki, T. Miyatake, M. Shimada, K. Matsumoto, M. Hamada and K. Takabatake
1095
N R I M R&D program on HTS coils for 1 GHz N M R spectrometer
1099
T. Kiyoshi, K. Inoue, M. Kosuge, H. Kitaguchi, H. Kumakura, H. Wada and H. Maeda
Development project of 1 GHz N M R spectrometer K. Inoue, T. Kiyoshi, A. Sato, K. Itoh, H. Wada, H. Maeda, R. Ogawa, Y. Kawate, K. Takabatake, T. Horiuchi, J. Kida and K. Higuchi
1103
Cryocooler-cooled Magnets A cryocooler cooled 10.7 T superconducting magnet with a room temperature bore of 52mm K. Jikihara, K. Watazawa, J. Sakuraba, T. Hasebe, H. Mitsubori, M. Ishihara, Y. Yamada, K. Watanabe and S. A waji
1109
Development of a 11.5 T liquid helium-free superconducting magnet system Y. Ohtani, H. Hatakeyama, H. Nakagome, K. Koyanagi, T. Yazawa and S. Nomura
1113
A cryofree superconducting magnet for industrial applications K. Timms, P. Daniels, M. Wade and J. Boehm
1117
Cryocooler-cooled large bore NbTi superconducting magnet using high temperature superconducting current leads K. Watanabe, T. Masumoto, S. Awaji, L Mogi, M. Motokawa, K. Watazawa, J. Sakuraba, T. Hasebe, M. Ishihara and Y. Yamada
1121
A superconducting magnetic separator with an integral refrigerator for blue-green algae H. Isogami, N. Saho and M. Morita
1125
Design and fabrication of cryogen free superconducting magnet K. Shibutani, S. Itoh, T. Takagi, O. Ozaki, R. Horise, S. Hayashi, M. Shimada, R. Ogawa, Y. Kawate, Y. Inoue, K. Matsumoto and N. Kimura
1129
Persistent current switch for a conduction cooled superconducting magnet T. H. Kim, S. Yokoyama and S. Yamamoto
1133
Current Leads Potential of high-temperature superconductor current leads for LHC cryogenics A. Ballarino, A. Ijspeert and U. Wagner Design of 12.5 kA current leads for the Large Hadron Collider using high temperature superconductor material A. Ballarino, A. Ijspeert, M. Teng, U. Wagner, S. Harrison, K. Smith and L. Cowey
1139
1143
Design and tests on the 30 to 600 A HTS current leads for the Large Hadron Collider A. Ballarino and A. Ijspeert
1147
Development of HTS current leads for 1 kWh/1 MW module type SMES system T. Bohno, A. Tomioka, S. Nose, M. Konno, K. Sakaki, T. Uede, T. Imayoshi, H. Hayashi, K. Tsutsumi and F. Irie
1151
Development of kA-class superconducting assembly conductor and current lead O. Kasuu, K. Takahashi, K. Sato and N. Yoshida
1155
A proposal for a Peltier current lead
1159
S. Yamaguchi, K. Takita and O. Motojima
xxii
Contents
Transient analysis of high-temperaturesuperconducting current leads T. Nishioka, K. Maehata, K. Ishibashi, M. Takeo, T. Mito and J. Yamamoto
1163
SQUID and Electronic Devices A plastic molded DC-SQUID for biomagnetic measurement Y. Utaka and T. Kido
1169
Development of SQUID based systems cooled by GM/JT cryocoolers K. Sata, S. Fujimoto, N. Fukui, E. Haraguchi, T. Kido, K. Nishiguchi and Y.-M. Kang
1173
Ferromagnetic fluxgate for measurement of the weak magnetic field structure with the use of HTSC - SQUID S. I. Bondarenko
1177
Multichannel high-Tc SQUID based heart scanner H. J. M. ter Brake, J. Flokstra, D. Veldhuis and H. Rogalla
1181
High current density NbN/A1N/NbN tunnel junctions as submillimeter wave SIS mixers Z. Wang, Y. Uzawa and A. Kawakami
1185
Fabrication of SrTiO3/YBa2Cu307_x heterostructure by ion beam sputtering T. Saito, X. Cai, K. Usami, T. Kobayashi and T. Goto
1189
Normal current controllability of JOFETs using InAs-inserted-channel InA1As/InGaAs inverted HEMTs T. Akazaki, H. Takayanagi, J. Nitta and T. Enoki
1193
Andreev reflection spectroscopy of superconducting mesoscopic devices Y. Misaki, A. Saito, K. Goto, M. Mikawa and K. Hamasaki
1197
Infrared radiation detector using YBCO thin film Y. Kakehi, T. Yotsuya, T. Kusaka, Y. Suzuki, S. Ogawa and H. Imokawa
1201
YBCO thin film terahertz radiator excited by femtosecond laser pulse M. Hangyo, S. Tomozawa, Y. Murakami, M. Tonouchi, M. Tani, Z. Wang and K. Sakai
1205
YBCO thin film bow-tie antenna for terahertz radiator
1209
N. Wada, M. Hangyo, Y. Murakami, M. Tonouchi, M. Tani, Z. Wang and K. Sakai
Stability and AC Loss Current redistribution in multistrand Nb3Sn CICC due to current ramp V. Vysotsky, M. Takayasu, S.-K. Jeong, P. Michael, J. Schultzand and J. Minervini Direct measurements of current distribution in a 12 strand Nb3Sn CICC (Part 1, experimental set-up) V. Vysotsky, M. Takayasu, S.-K. Jeong, P. Michael, J. Schultz and J. Minervini Direct measurements of current distribution in a 12 strand Nb3Sn CICC (Part 2, experimental results) V. Vysotsky, M. Takayasu, S.-K. Jeong, P. Michael, J. Schultz and J. Minervini
1215
1219
1223
Effects of current distribution on the stability of a triplet NbTi/Cu superconductor N. Hirano, T. Mito, K. Takahata, A. Iwamoto, R. Maekawa and J. Yamamoto
1227
Voltage spikes in ramped field experiments S.-K. Jeong, V. Vysotsky, M. Takayasu, J. H. Sehultz, P. C. Michael, S. Shen and W. Warnes
1231
Contents
xxiii
Contact resistance measurement of superconducting strands T. S. Jaffery, M. Wake, R. Scanlan and P. Mclntyre
1235
Measurements of cross contact resistance in Rutherford cables T. Suzuki, T. Shioiri, A. Ishiyama and K. Hosoyama
1239
Effect of Cr plating on the coupling current loss in cable-in-conduit conductors P. Bruzzone, A. Nijhuis and H. H. J. ten Kate
1243
AC loss measurement of superconducting dipole magnets by the electrical method Y. Morita, K. Hara, N. Higashi, K. Hosoyama, A. Kabe, H. Kawamata, Y. Kojima, H. Nakai, T. Shintomi and A. Terashima
1249
Measurement of time constants for coupling losses in the LHD superconductors N. Yanagi, S. Tak6cs, T. Mito, K. Takahata, A. Iwamoto and J. Yamamoto
1253
Coupling losses, time constants and current distribution in superconducting cables in spatially changing magnetic field S. Takfcs AC losses measurement in cable-in-conduit conductor by calorimetric method Y. Wadayama, H. Morita, K. A ihara and R. Takahashi
1257
1261
Void fraction effect on stability in cable-in-conduit conductor for varying field due to plasma disruption A. Terasawa, Y. Miura, T. Ando, M. Nozawa, T. Isono, Y. Takaya, H. Tsuji and S. Simamoto
1265
The influence of Cu/SC ratio on the stability of superconducting magnet impregnated by epoxy-resin Q.-L. Wang, C.-W. An, Y.-Q. Wang and L.-Z. Li
1269
Relaxation of superconducting wire tension and magnet stability H. Moriyama, F. Sawa, H. Mitsui, M. Arata, S. Nishijima and T. Okada
1273
Calculation of wire motion in a superconducting magnet T. Kushida, S. Nishijima, Y. Honda and T. Okada
1277
Numerical experiments for transient stability in dry-winding superconducting magnets S.-B. Kim and A. Ishiyama
1281
One dimensional simulation of normal state propagation in a superconducting cable M. Emoto, T. Senba, S. Yamaguchi, N. Yanagi and O. Motojima
1285
Stability of synthetic enameled superconducting wires K. Seo, M. Morita and S. Yamamoto
1289
Quench behavior in superconducting solenoid magnets R. Hirose, T. Kamikado, 0. Ozaki, M. Yoshikawa, M. Hamada and K. Takabatake
1293
A study on stability of conductors under a high gravitational field N. Higuchi, K. Kaiho, I. Ishii, H. Nomura, H. Tateishi, S. Fuchino, K. Arai, S. Sekine, N. Natori, K. Kajikawa, N. Tamada, K. Tsugawa and K. Fujima
1297
Evaluation of inductive heating energy of quench experiment on a long length (QUELL) conductor with the calorimetric method T. Ito, N. Koizumi, Y. Miura, K. Matsui, H. Wakabayashi, Y. Takahashi, H. Tsuji and S. Shimamoto Distribution of superconducting currents in NbTi/Nb/Cu multilayered cylinder S. Kakugawa, N. Hino, N. Hara, K. Mori, T. Tominaka, M. Kitamura, N. Maki, H. Kawano, H. Takeshima and T. Honmei
1301
1305
xxiv
Contents
Magnetizing properties of NbTi/Nb/Cu multilayer composite tubes H. Takeshima, H. Kawano, T. Hommei, N. Hara and N. Maki
1309
Reduction rate of magnetic field generated by magnetized NbTi/Nb/Cu multilayer composite tubes H. Kawano, H. Takeshima, T. Hommei, N. Hara and N. Maki
1313
Dependence of quench current and AC losses on twist directions and annealing of AC superconducting cables T. Taniguchi and R. Takahashi
1317
Recent progress of NbTi 46.5 Wt% superconductor strands at GEC alsthom C. E. Bruzek, P. Moca~'r, P. Sulten, F. Peltier, C. Kohler, E. Sirot and G. Grunblatt
1321
A new concept for the composition of oxide superconducting wires for Ac windings operating at LN2 temperature M. Iwakuma, K. Funaki, M. Takeo, K. Yamafuji, M. Konno, Y. Kasagawa, K. Okubo, L Itoh and S. Nose
1325
AC loss and current distribution in parallel conductors for Bi2223 HTS transformer windings M. Iwakuma, K. Funaki, K. Kanegae, H. Shinohara, T. Wakuda, M. Takeo, K. Yamafuji, M. Konno, Y. Kasagawa, K. Okubo, I. Boh, S. Nose, M. Ueyama, K. Hayashi and K. Sato
1329
Mutual correlation factor based high speed quench detection K. Nakamura, T. Kasuga and Y. Abe
1333
A proposal system of monitoring of multi-coil superconducting magnets system using hierarchy fuzzy theorem Y. Uriu, A. Ninomiya, Y. Kanda, T. Ishigohka, J. Yamamoto and T. Mito
1337
A typical velocity for heat destruction and restoration of S-state of short sample HTSC film M. Lutset
1341
Oxide Superconductors Tapes and Wires Bismuth-based HTS wires and their application progress K. Sato, K. Hayashi, K. Ohkura, K. Ohmatsu, T. Hikata, T. Kaneko, T. Kato, T. Sashida, M. Ueyama, J. Fujikami, M. Ito, S. Kobayashi, N. Saga, S. Hahakura, T. Shibata, T. Masuda and S. Isojima
1347
Improvement of electromagnetic properties of Ag-clad bi-based superconducting tapes through process control S. X. Dou, M. Ionescu, W. G. Wang, J. Horvat, Y. C. Guo, H. K. Liu, K. H. Mfiller and C. Andrikidis
1353
Influence of oxygen partial pressure on critical current density of Ag/Bi2223 tapes K. Osamura, S. Nonaka and Y. Katsumura
1357
The effect of stress on energization of the coils made of Ag sheathed and high strength Ag-Mg alloy sheathed Bi-2223 tape K. Tasaki, Y. Yamada, K. Yamamoto, H. Onoda, A. Tanaka, M. Urata, O. Horigami, T. Hasegawa, T. Koizumi, T. Kiyoshi and K. Inoue
1361
Electromagnetic strain of a BSCCO-2223 silver-sheathed tape reinforced by a stainless steel tape K. Ohkura, M. Ueyama, K. Sato, S. A waji and K. Watanabe
1365
Contents
xxv
Effects of hot press on critical currents in Ag-sheathed Bil.8Pbo.4Sr2Ca2.2Cu3Ox tapes J. Chikaba and K. Samoto
1369
Fabrication and properties of silver sheathed mono- and multi-filamentary Bi-2223 tapes X. Wu, Z. Duan, X. Tang and L. Zhou
1373
Influence of doping Ti, Zr or Hf into Ag-Cu alloy sheath of Bi-2223 tapes M. Ishizuka, Y. Tanaka, T. Hashimoto and H. Maeda
1377
Influence of the phase distribution on the properties of Ag-sheathed Bi-2223 tapes N. Futaki, S. Nagaya, T. Shimonosono, A. Kume, M. Nakagawa, N. Sadakata, T. Saitoh and O. Kohno
1381
Alloy sheath effects of (Bi,Pb)2Sr2Ca2Cu3Oy tapes H. Ikeda, Y. Tanaka, R. Yoshizaki, M. Ishizuka and H. Maeda
1385
Fabrication and properties of Ag-Mg-Ni alloy sheathed (Bi,Pb)2SrzCa2Cu3Ox tapes J. Sato, K. Nomura and S. Kuma
1389
Effect of Ca2PbO4 in precursor powder on the heat treatment of Bi2223/Ag superconducting tapes Y. C. Guo, W. G. Wang, H. K. Liu and S. X. Dou
1393
Advances in the fabrication of multifilamentary Bi(Pb)-2223/Ag tapes N. V. Vo, H. K. Liu, S. X. Dou and E. W. Collings
1397
Improvement of strong links in Ag/Bi-2223 superconducting tapes J. Horvat, Y. C. Guo and S. X. Dou
1401
Fabrication of multilayered composite wire of Bi-based superconductor M. Mimura, K. Kosugi, H. Ii, N. Uno, Y. Tanaka and K. Satou
1405
Fabrication of double-sheathed Bi-2212 multifilamentary wire T. Hase, K. Shibutani, S. Hayashi, M. Shimada, R. Ogawa, Y. Kawate, T. Kiyoshi and K. Inoue
1409
In-plane aligned YBCO thin film tape fabricated by pulsed laser deposition K. Hasegawa, N. Yoshida, K. Fujino, H. Mukai, K. Hayashi, K. Sato, T. Ohkuma, S. Honjyo, H. Ishii and T. Hara
1413
Modified solution-sol-gel process to synthesize ultrafine BiPbSrCaCuO powder with low carbon content C. B. Mao, L. Zhou, X. Z. Wu and X. Y. Sun A new chemical process to synthesize ultrafine BiPbSrCaCuO powder L. Zhou, C. Mao, X. Wu
1417
1421
PART THREE Bulk and Thin Film Superconducting properties and structures in Bi-2212 oxide synthesized by a diffusion process Y. Yamada, Y. Hishinuma, F. Yamashita, K. Wada and K. Tachikawa Influence of composition on microstructures and formation of the (Bi,Pb)-2223 phase in the partial-melting and sintering process X. Y. Lu, A. Nagata, M. Yasuda, K. Sugawara and S. Kamada Effect of silver addition on superconducting properties of Bi-2223 K. Kawasaki, H. Ikeda, R. Yoshizaki and K. Yoshikawa
1427
1431
1435
xxvi
Contents
The effect of the nominal composition On seeded melt grown Y-Ba-Cu-O crystals S. Takebayashi, I.-Y. Sang and M. Murakami
1439
Effect of Pt addition on Y-Ba-Cu-F-O superconductors T. Akune, K. Mizusaki, S. Iwaski, N. Sakamoto, T. Hamada and T. Ogushi
1443
Kinetics of YBa2Cu3Ox formation and crystal defects in PMP-processed superconductor L.-A. Zhou, K.-G. Wang, P.-X. Zhang, P. Ji, X.-Z. Wu, S.-K. Cheng
1447
Synthesis of 90 K superconductor Yo.9Cao.~Ba2Cu4Os at ambient pressure X. G. Zheng, H. Kuriyaki, M. Suzuki, M. Taira, C. Xu and K. Hirakawa
1451
New process to control critical currents of NdBa2Cu307_A Y. Shiohara, M. Nakamura, T. Hirayama, Y. Yamada and Y. Ikuhara
1455
Microstructure and superconductive properties of NdBa2Cu3Ox superconductor prepared by floating zone melting method S. Matsuoka, M. Sumida, T. Umeda and Y. Shiohara
1459
Critical-current densities of twin-free Nd(Ba~_x,Ndx)2Cu307_A single crystals grown by the traveling-solvent floating-zone method T. Egi, J.-G. Wen, T. Machi, K. Kuroda, H. Unoki and N. Koshizuka
1463
NdBa2Cu307_A single crystal growth by the traveling-solvent floating-zone method K. Kuroda, I.-H. Choi, T. Egi, H. Unoki and N. Koshizuka
1467
Improvement in Ic-B performance of Tl-base high-Tc oxides prepared by a diffusion process K. Tachikawa, A. Kikuchi and M. Ogasawara
1471
The effects of V2O 5 addition on the superconducting properties of YBa2Cu307.A Z.-Q. Yang, X.-Z. Su, H. Tang, D. Zeng, C. Zhang, Y.-Z. Wang and G.-W. Qiao
1475
Influence of the substrate on the anisotropy of the critical current in sputtered YBCO films O. Sarrhini, J. Baixeras and A. Kreisler
1479
Effect of early stage deposition conditions on properties of Y-Ba-Cu-O thick films prepared by laser ablation K. Shingai, Y. Yamagata, T. Ikegami and K. Ebihara
1483
Significant improvement in the surface morphology of off-center magnetron sputtered EuBa2Cu3Ov_A films on MgO K. Tsuru, S. Karimoto, S. Kubo and M. Suzuki
1487
Fabrication of Hg-Ba-(Ca)-Cu-O thin films by DC sputtering S. Koba, T. Ogushi, S. Higo, Y. Hakuraku and I. Kawano
1491
Preparationof BiSrCaCuO thin films on
1495
Improvement of magnetic shielding effect for an YBCO thick-film cylinder by using a hybrid ferromagnetic cylinder M. Itoh, F. Pavese, M. Bianco, M. Vanolo, K. Mori and T. Minemoto
1499
R-plane sapphire substrates with MgO buffer layer Y. Hakuraku, K. Maezono, H. Ueda, S. Koba, S. Higo and T. Ogushi
Magnetic Properties Flux pinning and flux dynamics in high-T~ superconductors T. Fujiyoshi, T. Sueyoshi, T. Yatsuda and R. Nishihara
1505
Entrapment of Y211 particles and Jc properties in melt-processed Y123 crystals A. Endo, H. S. Chauhan and Y. Shiohara
1509
Contents Thermomagnetic behaviors related to pulse excitation for HTS permanent magnets
xxvii 1513
M. Qiu, S. Han and L.-Z. Lin
Effect of crossed flux on magnetization and magnetization dynamics in melt-textured Y1BazCu3OT_A
1517
S. Manzoor and S. K. Hasanain
Electronic structure calculations of impurities pinning magnetic flux lines in oxide superconductors
1521
K. Fukushima
Flux-line depinning of vibrating ceramic YBa2Cu307_A
1525
Y. Fujii, H. Hamada, K. Takahashi, Y. Yamamoto, T. Shigematsu, M. Nakamura, M. Yamaguchi and T. Shigi
Critical state and magnetization property of thin YBCO films in perpendicular magnetic fields
1529
Y. Mawatari, A. Sawa, H. Obara and H. Yamasaki
Surface morphology of oxygen-deficient YBa2Cu307_Athin films
1533
G. Samadi Hosseinali, Y. Meslmani, H. W. Weber, E. Stangl, S. Proyer and D. Bduerle
Magnetic response of a single-crystal YBa2Cu3Oy thin film
1537
H. Yasuoka, S. Tochihara, H. Mazaki, M. Komatsu and M. Nagano
Intergranular coupling and secondary phases in (Bi2_x,Pbx)Sr2Ca2Cu3Olo+A/Ag tapes
1541
C. M. Friend, L. Le Lay, T. P. Beales, M. Penny and C. Beduz
Intergranular magnetization of Pb-Bi-Sr-Ca-Cu-O/Ag tapes
1545
C. Andrikidis, K.-H. Mfiller, H. K. Liu and S. X. Dou
Intergranular and intragranular AC hysteresis losses in monofilamentary Pb-Bi-Sr-Ca-Cu-O/Ag tapes
1549
K.-H. Mfiller, C. Andrikidis, H. K. Liu and S. X. Dou
Flux flow and flux creep for circulating current in Bi(2223) and Bi(2212) cylindrical bulk superconductors
1553
T. Yasunaga and D. Ito
Critical currents and irreversibility in (Bi,Pb)2Sr2Ca2Cu3Ox/Ag tape
1557
K. Zadro, E. Babi(, I. Kt~sevi(, J. Horvat, H. K. Liu and S. X. Dou
Reversible fluxoid motion in superconducting fullerene Rb3C60
1561
N. Sakamoto, Y. Ide, T. Akune, M. Baenitz and K. Liiders
Transport Properties On the scaling of the transport characteristics in high Tc superconductors from the view point of pin-fluctuation
1567
T. Kiss, T. Nakamura, M. Takeo, F. Irie and K. Yamafuji
Transport properties of Bi-2212 single crystals
1571
T. Tsukamoto, H. Andoh, T. Sugiura, G. Triscone, J.-Y. Genoud, E. Walker and N. Hase
Electrical properties of Ag sheathed Bi-2223 tapes
1575
H. Ii, A. Kimura, M. Mimura, N. Uno, Y. Tanaka, H. Ishii, S. Honjo and T. Hara
Irreversible properties of Tl-based high-Tc superconductors G. Brandstdtter, G. Samadi Hosseinali, K. Kundzins, Y. Meslmani, F. M. Sauerzopf, W. Stra!f, B. Starchl and H. W. Weber
1579
xxviii Contents Scaling behavior of current-voltage characteristics in single- and poly-crystalline YBCO films H. Ishii, S. Singo, S. Harada, S. Hirano, N. Yoshida, K. Fujino, K. Sato and T. Hara
1583
Temperature and magnetic-field scaling of transport characteristics in high quality Y IBa2Cu307_A thin films T. Nakamura, T. Kiss, M. Takeo and K. Yamafuji
1587
Superconductivity of YBa2Cu3Ox on Lao.7Cao.3MnO3 T. Yotsuya, Y. Kakehi and S. Ogawa
1591
AC Loss Self field AC transport properties and losses in high-Tc superconducting wires H. Ishii, J. Fujikami, S. Hirano, N. Yoshida, K. Sato and T. Hara
1597
AC losses in silver sheathed Bi-2223 wires M. Nakagawa, S. Nagaya, T. Shimonosono, A. Kume, N. Futaki, N. Sadakata, T. Saitoh and O. Kohno
1601
AC loss characteristics of Ag-sheathed Bi-2223 tapes in transverse external magnetic field M. Sugimoto, A. Kimura, M. Mimura, Y. Tanaka, H. Ishii, S. Honjo and T. Hara
1605
Eddy current and creep-based losses in CTFF-type Bi:2223/Ag multifilamentary tapes M. D. Sumption, N. V. Vo, S. X. Dou and E. W. Collings
1609
AC power loss of Bi-2223 tapes in self-field S. Fleshier
1613
Analysis of AC losses in high Tc superconducting wires N. Amemiya, T. Yamazumi and O. Tsukamoto
1617
A sensitive calorimetric AC-loss measurement technique for high-Tc superconducting wires J. R. Cave, P. Dolez, M. Aubin, D. W. A. Will~n and R. Nadi
1621
Other Properties Electronic properties of Hg-1201 oxide superconductors determined by NMR and STM investigations W. Hoffmann, H. Breitzke, M. Baenitz, M. Heinze, K. Lfiders, A. A. Gippius, E. V. Antipov, P. Jess, U. Hubler, H. P. Lang and H.-J. Gfintherodt
1627
Characterization of femtosecond time-transient nonequilibrium state in YBCO thin films M. Tonouchi, M. Tani, Z. Wang, K. Sakai, S. Tomozawa, M. Hangyo and Y. Murakami
1631
The research of thermal expansion of high-Tc-superconductors L. Xu, S.-L. Zhou, J. Ye and J.-M. Xu
1635
Tunneling spectroscopy in high T¢ Y-system ceramic superconductor M. Suzuki, M. Taira, X.-G. Zheng and T. Hoshino
1639
Characterization of intrinsic Josephson junction made of 60 K phase YBCO thin films M. Tonouchi, A. Itoh, T. Yasuda, H. Shimakage, Z. Wang and S. Takano
1643
Reentrant transport behavior in CaLaBaCu3Oy M. Akinaga
1647
Application of 3D-Josephson junction array model to critical temperature of high T¢ oxide superconducting under uniaxial pressure and under hydrostatic pressure C. Kawabata
1651
Contents Flexural strength and fracture toughness of YBaCuO superconductors
xxix 1655
H. Fujimoto and T. Ban
Metallic Superconductors Nb3AI Effect of static and cyclic strain on Jc of Nb3A1 CIC conductors: A comparison with Nb3Sn
1661
W. Specking, T. Ando, H. Tsuji, A. Mikumo and Y. Yamada
Experimental result of 13T-46kA Nb3A1 conductor in SULTAN
1665
Y. Nunoya, M. Oshikiri, T. Ando, Y. Takahashi, H. Nakajima, M. Sugimoto, H. Tsufi, S. Shimamoto, Y. Yamada, M. Konno, B. Blau, I. Rohleder, G. Vecsey, S. Shen and H. Katheder
Critical current density of Nb3A1 superconducting wire for high field magnet by rapid-quenching process
1669
K. Fukuda, G. Iwaki, M. Kimura, S. Sakai, Y. Ioima, T. Takeuchi, K. Inoue, N. Kobayashi, K. Watanabe and S. A waji
Development of practical Nb3A1/Cu multifilamentary superconducting strand
1673
A. Mikumo, N. Ayai, Y. Yamada, K. Takahashi, K. Sato, N. Koizumi, M. Sugimoto, T. Ando, H. Tsuji and S. Shimamoto
Improvement of critical current density and residual resistivity on jelly-roll processed Nb3AI superconducting wires
1677
N. Ayai, A. Mikumo, Y. Yamada, K. Takahashi, K. Sato, N. Koizumi, T. Ando, M. Sugimoto, H. Tsuji and S. Shimamoto
Fabrication and superconducting properties of Nb3A1 composite wire using the jelly roll process
1681
Y. Sakagami, T. Yamazaki, N. A oki, M. Ichihara, T. Masegi, S. Murase, K. Matsui, K. Ushigusa, M. Kikuchi and Y. Takahashi
Development of multifilamentary Nb3A1 superconducting wires by the jelly-roll method
1685
K. Aihara, Y. Hanaoka, T. Suzuki, T. Nabatame, G. Iwaki, K. Fukuda, S. Sakai, K. Sasaki and K. Kikuchi
Superconducting properties and microstructure of Nb3A1 wire fabricated by the jelly-roll method
1689
Y. W. Hanaoka, T. Suzuki, T. Nabatame, K. Aihara, G. Iwaki, S. Sakai and K. Kikuchi
Superconducting properties of Nb3A1 by reaction between a-phase Nb2A1 and Nb powders
1693
N. Harada, Y. Fukuda, H. Ichikohara, K. Osaki, N. Tada, S. Sakai and K. Watanabe
Critical current density characteristics of Nb3A1 multifilamentary wires continuously fabricated by rapid-quenching
1697
Y. Iijima, M. Kosuge, T. Takeuchi and K. Inoue
Nb3A1 thin films made by RF magnetron sputtering process with a single target
1701
K. Agatsuma, H. Tateishi, K. Arai, T. Saitoh, N. Sadakata and M. Nakagawa
Nb3Sn Development of the alumina-copper reinforced Nb3Sn wire for coil fabrication S. Murase, S. Nakayama, K. Koyanagi, T. Masegi, S. Nomura, M. Urata, K. Shimamura, K. Amano, N. Shiga, K. Watanabe and N. Kobayashi
1707
xxx
Contents
Effects of the strain on the critical current of the powder metallurgy processed Nb3Sn superconducting wires N. Matsukura, T. Miyazaki, Y. Inoue, T. Miyatake, M. Shimada, R. Ogawa and M. Chiba
1711
Improvements in the properties of internal-tin Nb3Sn strands E. Gregory, E. Gulko, T. Pyon and L. F. Goodrich
1715
Critical current density at high fields for bronze-processed (Nb.Ti.Ta)3Sn superconducting wires G. Iwaki, M. Kimura, S. Sakai, N. Kobayashi, K. Watanabe and S. A waji
1719
Mechanical and superconducting properties of multifilamentary Nb3Sn wires with CuNb reinforcing stabilizer S. Iwasaki, K. Goto, N. Sadakata, T. Saito, O. Kohno, S. A waji and K. Watanabe
1723
The effects of coated film on (NbTi)3Sn wire on friction and electric contact resistance A. Iwabuchi, H. Funayama, T. Shimizu, M. Ono and T. Hamashima
1727
Manufacture of Nb3Sn strands for ITER by internal tin diffusion process K. Egawa, Y. Kubo, T. Nagai, M. Wakata, F. Uchikawa, 0. Taguchi, K. Wakamoto, M. Morita, T. Isono, Y. Nunoya, K. Yoshida, M. Nishi and H. Tsuji
1731
Development of NbTi and Nb3Sn conductors for 1 GHz NMR spectrometer K. Itoh, M. Yuyama, T. Kiyoshi, T. Takeuchi, K. Inoue, H. Maeda, T. Miyatake and M. Shimada
1735
Comparison of properties between bronze-processed Nb3Sn wires with different tin content T. Miyazaki, T. Miyatake, M. Shimada, H. Kurahashi, I. Tatara and N. Kobayashi
1739
Reduction of critical current in Nb3Sn cables as a function of transverse p r e s s u r e - A comparison with a finite element model J. M. van Oort, R. M. Scanlan and H. H. J. ten Kate
1743
Other Materials Superconductivity of reactively sputtered TaN film for ULSI process H. Kubota, K. Wakasugi, M. Tokunaga, T. Sumita and M. Nagata
1749
Preparation of 1 m long superconducting NbN tapes by DC magnetron sputtering M. Suzuki, T. Kiboshi and K. Sugawara
1753
SN-interface flux pinning in bronze processed V3Siconductor Y. Nemoto, T. Takeuchi, H. Maeda and K. Togano
1757
A C Loss and Electromagnetic Properties AC losses of proximity-induced superconducting Cu in NbTi filamentary composite T. Moriya, H. Kubota, K. Yasohama, Y. Kubota and T. Ogasawara Suppression of eddy current loss in bare-copper Rutherford cables using stainless steel cores of various thicknesses E. W. Collings, M. D. Sumption, S. W. Kim, M. Wake, T. Shintomi and R. M. Scanlan
1763
1767
Improvement of hysteresis-losses in internal tin diffusion processed Nb3Sn wires Y. Kubo, K. Egawa, T. Nagai, M. Wakata, F. Uchikawa, O. Taguchi, K. Wakamoto, M. Morita, T. Isono, Y. Nunoya, K. Yoshida, M. Nishi and H. Tsuji
1771
AC losses of Nb3Sn AC multifilamentary superconducting wires due to transport current S. Fukui, M. Ito, N. Amemiya, O. Tsukamoto and M. Hakamata
1775
Contents
xxxi
Proximity-effect-induced filament coupling in NbTi wires K. Yasohama, N. Azuma, Y. Kubota and T. Ogasawara
1779
Exploration of micro-bridging effect in Nb3Sn superconductors D. Mao, M. Yuyama, K. Itoh, H. Wada and Y. Murakami
1783
Round robin test for the method for critical current measurement of Nb3Sn composite superconductors K. Itoh, Y. Tanaka and K. Osamura
1787
Standardization of the method for the room temperature tensile test of Cu/Nb-Ti composite superconductors S. Sakai, K. Osamura, M. Hojo, T. Ogata and M. Shimada
1791
Standardization of the method for the determination of the residual resistance ratio (RRR) of Cu/Nb-Ti composite superconductors S. Murase, T. Saitoh, T. Matsushita and K. Osamura
1795
Standardization of the test method for critical current measurement of Cu/Cu-Ni/Nb-Ti composite superconductors R. Ogawa, Y. Kubo, Y. Tanaka, K. Itoh, K. Ohmatsu, T. Kumano, S. Sakai and K. Osamura
1799
Third harmonic AC susceptibility in multifilamentary wires E. S. Otabe, R. Kitamura and T. Matsushita
1803
RRR evaluation of niobium using AC susceptibility measurement M. Wake and K. Saito
1807
Pinning and Stability Orientational dependence of critical current density of NbTi thin film in a magnetic field M. Takeda, K. Nishigaki and H. Toda Computer simulations of vortex pinning properties by line pins O. Ichimaru and E. Kusayanagi Flux pinning properties of ultrafine multifilamentary NbTi superconducting wires with Nb island-type artificial pins O. Miura, C. Tei, D. Ito and S. Endo
1813
1817
1821
Evaluation of recovery current of the helical coil for LHD S. Imagawa, N. Yanagi, T. Mito, T. Satow, J. Yamamoto, O. Motojima and the LHD Group
1825
Delayed ramps in composites described in a two-layer model A. Akhmetov, M. Takeo and T. Imayoshi
1829
Normal zone at the edge of a flat two-layer superconducting cable A. A. Akhmetov, K. Kuroda, H. Tanaka and M. Takeo
1833
Statistical analysis of scattering in quench current of ac superconducting wires N. Hayakawa, M. Wakita, M. Hikita and H. Okubo
1837
Minimum quench energy and normal zone propagation velocity of bronze processed (Nb,Ti)3Sn superconducting wire with CuNb reinforcing stabilizer T. Onodera, K. Watanabe, K. Noto, T. Sugiura, M. Matsukawa, S. Awaji, K. Goto, S. Iwasaki, N. Sadakata, O. Kohno and J. Yamamoto
1841
xxxii
Contents
Applications R&D on NbTi and Nb3Sn superconductors for AC use in the super-GM M. Chiba, M. Hakamata, H. Chiba, N. Yoshida and T. Ichikawa
1847
Nb-Ti superconducting strands with Cu-Ni-Mn matrix and 2kA-class cables for AC use K. Miyashita, K. Sugiyama, S. Sakai, K. Kamata and H. Chiba
1851
Stability and AC losses of l kA class multifilamentary Nb3Sn superconducting cables for AC applications K. Ohmatsu, H. Yumura, K. Takahashi, K. Sato and N. Yoshida Development of kA class multifilamentary Nb-Ti superconducting cables for AC applications K. Ohmatsu, H. Yumura, K. Takahashi, K. Sato and N. Yoshida Some properties of bronze process Nb3Sn superconducting wires with Cu-Sn-Ge matrix and Nb-Ta cores for AC use S. Sakai, K. Miyashita, K. Sugiyama, K. Kamata, K. Tachikawa and H. Chiba Development of in-situ Nb3Sn wires for AC use H. Fuji, K. Goto, N. Sadakata, T. Saito, O. Kohno and J. Yoshitomi Development of industrially produced composite quench heaters for the LHC superconducting lattice magnets B. Szeless, F. Calvone and F. Rodriguez Mateos
1855
1859
1863
1867
1871
Metallic Materials Mechanical Properties Fracture toughness of SUS 316 and weld joint at cryogenic temperature A. Nishimura, R. L. Tobler and J. Yamamoto Effects of pre-cracking condition on fracture toughness of SUS 304L steel in an 8 tesla magnetic field at 4K K. Shibata, T. Shimonosono and T. Tanaka
1877
1883
Cryogenic effects on the fracture behavior of forged JJ1 type austenitic stainless steel plate Y. Shindo, K. Horiguchi, K. Sanada, T. Kobori, H. Nakajima and H. Tsuji
1887
The 4 K tensile and fracture toughness properties of a modified 316LN conduit alloy R. P. Walsh, L. T. Summers and J. R. Miller
1891
4 K mechanical properties of pure titanium for the jacket of Nb3Sn superconductors H. Nakajima, Y. Nunoya, K. Takano, T. Ando, H. Tsuji, S. Konosu, O. Ivano, T. Nakaniwa, T. Horiya and S. Ohkita
1895
Load-control tensile test of steels and alloys in liquid helium T. Ogata and T. Yuri
1899
Residual stresses in superconducting jackets after compaction F. M. G. Wong, N. A. Mitchell, M. M. Morra, P. H. Titus and R. N. Randall
1903
Vickers hardness properties of metals at cryogenic temperatures Y. Yoshino, T. Abe, A. Iwabuchi, A. Chiba and T. Shimizu
1907
An aluminium alloy for the coil clamping collars of the prototype LHC dipole magnets T. Kurtyka, M. Bona, S. Sgobba, S. Marque and B. Skoczen
1911
Contents Evaluation tests of structural materials used for liquid hydrogen storage and transportation system (Study on low temperature materials used in WE-NET, 1) T. Horiya, N. Yamamoto, T. Iida, A. Yamamoto, S. Okaguchi, N. Yaegashi, T. Doko, M. Saito, K. Yokogawa and T. Ogata Development of materials testing equipment in high-pressure hydrogen at cryogenic temperatures and effect of temperature on hydrogen environment embrittlement of steels G. Han, J.-H. He, S. Fukuyama and K. Yokogawa Hydrogen embrittlement of austenitic stainless steels at low temperature (Study on low temperature materials used in WE-NET 2) S. Okaguchi, T. Horiya, K. Ishige, M. Saito, N. Yaegashi, A. Yamamoto, H. Nakagawa, K. Yokokawa and T. Ogata
xxxiii 1915
1919
1923
Physical Properties Absolute measurements of linear thermal expansion coefficients of copper SRM 736 and some commercially available coppers in the temperature range 20 - 300 K M. Okaji, N. Yamada, H. Kato and K. Nara
1929
Possibility of AC applications of composite high-purity aluminum wires L. I. Chubraeva, S. N. Pylinina, V. E. Sigaev and V. A. Tutaev
1933
Development and investigation of composite high-purity aluminum wires L. I. Chuhraeva, V. E. Sigaev, E. A. Phtshkin, N. 1. Sahmin and E. N. Aksenova
1937
Temperature structures at high Hall drift in aluminum V. R. Sobol, O. N. Mazurenko and A. A. Drozd
1941
Inhomogeneity and local negative magnetoresistance of aluminum V. R. Sobol, O. N. Mazurenko and A. A. Drozd
1945
Magnetic field of cyclic current in cylinder conductors B. B. Boiko, V. R. Sobol and O. N. Mazurenko
1949
Magnetism due to Hall current in aluminum and copper conductors B. B. Boiko, V. R. Sobol, O. N. Mazurenko and A. A. Drozd
1953
Effects of high magnetic field and tensile stress on martensitic transformation behavior and microstructure at 4.2 K in Fe-Ni-C shape memory alloys H. Ohtsuka, G. Ghosh, K. Nagai, H. Kitaguchi and M. Uehara
1957
Analysis of temperature rises in point and line contact slidings in liquid helium I. Nitta, A. Iwabuchi, T. Takao and M. Minami
1961
Round robin tests on frictional characteristics of cryogenic materials T. Takao, A. Iwabuchi, M. Minami and I. Nitta
1965
Galvanic chrome coating of copper wire for the ITER program Y. Ipatov, V. Sytnikov, A. Rychagov and G. Svalov
1969
Non Metallic Materials Mechanical Properties Overview of the fatigue behaviour of fiber composites at low temperatures G. Hartwig and R. Hiibner
1977
xxxiv
Contents
Nonlinear fracture behavior of G-10 woven glass-epoxy laminates at liquid nitrogen temperature K. Sanada, Y. Shindo and K. Horiguchi
1981
Effects of friction on shear/compressive strength of high-density GFRP at low temperature T. Suzuki, S. Usami, H. Tsukamoto and M. Otsuka
1985
Effect of contiguity of glass bundles on the inter-laminar shear strength changed of ILSS induced by low-temperature electron irradiation Y. Tsukazaki, S. Nishijima, T. Nishiura, T. Okada and K. Asano
1989
Frictional characteristics of high strength polyethylene fiber reinforced plastics T. Takao, T. Nemoto, H. Konda, T. Kashima and A. Yamanaka
1993
Cryogenic material properties in tension and shear of reactor irradiated GFRPs K. Humer, S. M. Spiebberger, H. W. Weber, E. K. Tschegg, N. A. Munshi and P. E. Fabian
1997
Shear compression strength of organic insulation systems after reactor irradiation at 4 K H. Gerstenberg, E. Kriihling, H. Katheder, R. Maix and M. SO'll
2001
Scaling experiments and mechanical properties of CFRPs at 293 K and 77 K after room temperature reactor irradiation S. M. Spieflberger, K. Humer, E. K. Tschegg, H. W. Weber, S. Valthe, K. Noma and IT. Iwasaki
2005
Properties of candidate insulation systems for ITER CS model coils at low temperatures H. Mitsui, H. Hirai, H. Moriyama, Y. Sumiyoshi, T. Sasaki, M. Sugimoto, T. Ando, H. Tsuji and R. Vieira
2009
Enhanced creep of epoxy-resin during electron beam irradiation T. Nishiura, S. Nishijima, T. Okada and Y. Tsukasaki
2013
Possible hazards following irradiation of superconducting magnet insulation D. Evans, R. P. Reed and N. J. Simon
2017
Physical Properties Low-temperature thermal properties of amorphous Polycarbonat and Polystyrene M. Jiickel, F. von Schoenebeck, U. Escher and A. Gladun
2023
Experimental measurement on the specific heat of highly porous materials W. Shi, J.-Y. Wu, R.-Z. Wang and Z.-M. Tang
2027
Low-temperature thermal conductivity of amorphous Polycarbonat under high pressure M. Jd'ckel, F. Weise and R. Geilenkeuser
2031
Composite matrix for low thermal contraction down to cryogenic temperature K. Nojima, T. Ueki, K. Asano, S. Nishijima and T. Okada
2035
Functional Materials Mechanical and thermal properties of zirconia at cryogenic temperature S. Ueno, S. Nishijima, A. Nakahira, T. Sekino, T. Okada and K. Niihara
2041
Strength characteristics of alumina ceramics at cryogenic temperatures N. Suzuki, K. Suzuki, T. Murakami and T. Uchida
2045
Residual strain of pipes composed with high strength polyethylene fiber reinforced plastics at cryogenic temperature T. Kashima, A. Yamanaka, S. Nishijima and T. Okada
2049
Contents
xxxv
Advanced composite materials for cryogenic support structures R. K. Giesey
2053
Fracture toughness of epoxy filled with nano-scale silica at cryogenic temperature S. Ueno, S. Nishijima, M. Hussain, A. Nakahira, F. Sawa, T. Okada and K. Niihara
2057
Improvement of fracture toughness of epoxy resin for cryogenic use T. Ueki, K. Nojima, K. Asano, S. Nishijima and T. Okada
2061
Magnetothermal properties of amorphous Gd7oCu3oand Dy7oCu3oalloys X.-Y. Liu, J. A. Barclay, R. B. Gopal, M. Ffldegtki, R. Chahine and T. K. Bose
2065
Crystal axis dependence of magneto-thermal properties in RA103 (R: Dy, Ho and Er) single crystals using for magnetic refrigeration H. Kimura, T. Numazawa, M. Sato, T. lkeya, T. Fukuda and K. Fujioka
2069
Magnetic field dependence of thermal conductivity in rare-earth oxides for heat switch application T. Numazawa, H. Kimura, M. Sato, A. Sato, K. Shimamura and T. Fukuda
2073
Author Index
I1
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Organized under the auspices of International Cryogenic Engineering Committee - ICEC International Cryogenic Materials Committee- ICMC International Institute of Refrigeration, Commission A 1/2 - IIR We acknowledge the support and sponsorship of Cryogenic Association of Japan Kitakyushu City Association for Promotion of Electrical Electronic and Information Engineering Commemorative Association for the Japan World Exposition (19 70) Kyushu Bureau of International Trade and Industry Fukuoka Prefecture Fukuoka Science & Technology Foundation ORGANIZING COMMITTEES INTERNATIONAL CRYOGENIC ENGINEERING COMMITTEE P. Komarek (Chairman) (Vice Chairman) T. Mitsui C. Rizzuto (Vice Chairman) P. Berglund A.F. Clark G. Gistau H. Hirabayashi G. Klipping (Honorary Member) P. Lebrun L.Z. Lin K.G. Narayankhedkar H. Quack H. Rogalla R.S. Safrata R.G. Scurlock A.J. Steel VoV. Sytchev S. Van Sciver M. Wood (Honorary Member) K. Yamafuji K.A. Yushchenko L. Zhang INTERNATIONAL CRYOGENIC MATERIALS COMMITTEE E.W. Collings (Chairman) A.F. Clark D. Evans F.R. Fickett H.C. Freyhardt G. Hartwig K.T. Hartwig Y.Y. Li H. Maeda T. Okada R.P. Reed D.B. Smathers L.T. Summers K. Tachikawa H.H.J. Ten Kate G.R. Wagner H.W. Weber K.A. Yushchenko L. Zhou xxxvii
LOCAL ORGANIZING COMMITTEE
T. Mitsui (Chairman) K. Yamafuji (Vice Chairman) M. Akiyama Y. Akiyama A. Hikita H. Hirabayashi J. Hosoda Y. Kawate K. Kitazawa S. Kosaka N. Koshizuka H. Maeda T. Matsushita H. Nakashima K. Nagata Y. Nakano N. Noda O. Ogino H. Ogiwara T. Okada S. Shimamoto T. Shintomi K. Tachikawa M. Takeo T. Tashiro O. Tsukamoto J. Yamamoto K. Funaki (Conference Secretariat)
LOCAL PROGRAMME COMMITTEE
(ICEC) H. Hirabayashi(Chairman) O. Tsukamoto (Vice Chairman) N. Amemiya T. Haruyama D. Itoh H. Maeda Y. Matsubara M. Nishi Y. Okuda Y. Takata
(~CMC)
T. Okada (Chairman) H. Maeda (Vice Chairman) K. Enpuku T. Hashimoto S. Kosaka T. Matsushita S. Nishijima T. Ogata M. Suzuki
INDUSTRIAL EXHIBITION COMMITTEE
M. Takeo (Chairman) T. Itoh Y. Kamioka T. Noguchi
xxxviii
EXHIBITORS Aisin Seiki Co. Ltd Arisawa Mfg Co. Ltd Cryogenic Association of Japan, Refrigeration Commission Dowa Mining Co. Ltd Engineering Research Association for Superconducting Generation Equipment and Materials (Super-GM) Fuji Electric Co. Ltd Fujikin Incorporated The Furukawa Electric Co. Ltd Gec Alsthom Hitachi Cable Ltd Hitachi Ltd International Superconductivity Technology Center, Superconductivity Research Laboratory Ishikawajima-Harima Heavy Industries Co. Ltd Iwatani International Corporation /Iwatani Plantech Corporation Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute Japan High Tech Co. Ltd Kabelmetal electro GmbH Kobe Steel Ltd Koike Sanso Kogyo Co. Ltd Kyushu Electric Power Co. Inc Kyushu University, Research Institute of Superconductivity Linde AG. Lydall Corporation Mitsubishi Electric Corp Nagase & Co. Ltd National Institute for Fusion Science National Laboratory for High Energy Physics, KEK Niki Glass Co. Ltd Nippon Automatic Control Company Nippon Sanso Corporation Oxford Instruments Ltd Railway Technical Research Institute Sumitomo Heavy Industries Ltd Suzuki Shokan Co. Ltd Taiyo Toyo Sanso Co. Ltd Teisan K.K. Tokyo Electric Power Company Toshiba Corporation Weka AG.
xxxix
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Foreword
The joint conference of the 16th International Cryogenic Engineering Conference (ICEC) and 1996 International Cryogenic Materials Conference (ICMC) was held in Kitakyushu, Japan during 20-24 May 1996. For this joint conference, a Local Organizing Committee, a Local Programme Committee and an Industrial Exhibition Committee took care well for preparation and management of the conference under the strong support of the Cryogenic Association of Japan (CAJ). The conference was also co-sponsored by the International Institute of Refrigeration (IIR) -Commission A1/2. The conference was the largest so far with over 700 registered delegates from 21 countries. The scientific programme consisted of nearly 490 papers for oral (110) and poster (380) presentation accompanied by an interesting and innovating Industrial Exhibition of cryogenic equipment by 39 exhibitors. Seven plenary invited talks gave overviews to light up the most significant topics to the progress of Cryogenic Engineering and Cryogenic Materials. All the papers in this proceedings have been reviewed by the authorized review coordinators nominated by the Local Programme Committee. This proceedings is not a supplement issue of Cryogenics, however, in order to keep good relationship between the conference and the journal, we asked the session chairmen to recommend high quality papers for Cryogenics. We hope that such papers with amplified and extended contents will soon appear in Cryogenics. During the conference, the International Cryogenic Engineering Committee presented the 1996 Mendelssohn Award to Prof. O.V. Lounasmaa of the Helsinki University for his great contributions to cryogenics society. It is our pleasure to inform all of you that the next conference, ICEC17, will be held from 14 to 17 July 1998 in Bournemouth, England under the chairmanship of Professor R.G. Scurlock, Institute of Cryogenics, Southampton University.
//a..,~ ~
.,
T. Mitsui
(Chairman of the Local Organizing Committee)
K. Yamafuji (Vice-chairman of the Local Organizing Committee)
xli
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
INTERNATIONAL
CRYOGENIC
ENGINEERING
COMMITTEE Chairman: Prof. Dr. P. Komarek KfK-ITP Postfach 3640 ,., . . . . . ,ors, . . . . . Germany Tel.: 49-7247-823500 Fax.: 49-7247-822849
Secretary: Dr. H. Quack Bodenackerstrasse 48 CH-8330 Pf&ffikon ZH Switzerland Tel.: 41-1-950 3110 Fax.: 41-1-951 0221
D-76021 Karlsruhe
Dear Conference Participants It is a groat honour and pleasure for me to welcome you on behalf of the International Cryogerlic Engineering Committee to this conference. After having the conference two times in Europe and before in China, it came back to Japan now, one of its birth places. Here this conference serie has already been hosted with an extraordinary spirit of hospitality for three times. Being again in Japan is well justified, if one regards the amount of contributions by Japanese scientists and engineers to the progress in superconductivity and cryogenics. It also became a good tradition to hold ICEC from time to time jointly with ICMC, recognizing the need for a joint effort of material specialists and project specialists to proceed with applications of superconductivity and cryogenics. I hope, that at this time again the discussions among both societies will be vital and fruitful for a mutual benefit. The foundation for the success of this conference is layed by your participation and submitted contributions, more than 600, forming the seed for a rich scientific harvest. In that spirit, let me thank you all for coming and let me encourage you to support the progress of this conference very actively. Before concluding with best wishes to you for a nice and fruitful stay in Kitakyushu, let me thank our hosts, conducted by Dr. Mitsui, Prof. Hirabayashi, Prof. Yamafuji and Dr. Okada for their excellent preparatory work to make this conference possible. I hope that those who were not able to come to Japan this time, will at least benefit from studying the Proceedings. Let me conclude in that sense with best wishes to all of you.
/lJ ~
._.i .
..
P. Komarek Chairman of the ICEC
xliii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
GREETINGS FROM THE CHAIRMAN OF ICMC
The International Cryogenic Materials Conference (ICMC) board together with the Cryogenic Engineering Conference (CEC) jointly holds the well-known biennial series of "CEC/ICMC" conferences, in the odd-numbered years. Between these large UnitedStates-based meetings, ICMC generally organizes topical symposia held in various parts of the world in response to the wishes of ICMC's numerous international board members. Over the years such meetings have taken place worldwide. But in place of a topical meeting ICMC has from time to time joined with the International Cryogenic Engineering Conference in the sponsoring of the joint ICEC/ICMC meetings in countries other than the US. The first of such meetings was held in Kobe, Japan, in May, 1982. The second took place ten years later in Kiev, Ukraine, in June, 1992, and we are very pleased to be holing the 1996 joint ICEC/ICMC meeting again in Japan, in the City of Kitakyushu. A splendid program of papers in cryogenic engineering, cryogenic structural materials (both metallic and nonmetallic), and low-temperature and high-temperature applied superconductivity in its various forms is offered along with a very impressive commercial exhibition of cryogenic equipment, materials, and machines. In introducing the ICEC16/ICMC conference, we must not forget that although ICEC and ICMC offer their names to it, the conference owes its success to the small army of engineers, scientists, and their assistants who make up the Local Organizing Committee (chaired by T. Mitsui and K. Yamafuji, both members of the ICEC Board), the Local ICEC Program Committee (chaired by H. Hirabayashi, ICEC Board, and O. Tsukamoto), the Local ICMC Program Committee (chaired by T. Okada and H. Maeda, both members of the ICMC Board), the Industrial Exhibition Committee (chaired by M. Takeo) other essential groups led by the Conference Secretary, K. Funaki. To all of these, the ICMC Board offers its thanks and congratulations, and trusts that the planned three-volume Conference Proceedings will provide a valuable record of the states of cryogenic engineering and materials as of May, 1996. E. W. Collings Chairman, ICMC Board
xlv
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
INTERNATIONAL
CRYOGENIC
ENGINEERING
COMMITTEE Chairman Prof. Dr. P. Komarek KfK-ITP Postfach 3640 ,~ t - - D - 7 5 0 0 N a ,.... o, L,, .L_ Germany Tel. 49-7247-823500 F a x . 49-7247-822849
Secretary: Dr. H. Quack Bodenackerstrasse 48 CH-8330 Pf&ffikon ZH Switzerland Tel. 41-1-950 3110 Fax." 41-1-951 0221
D-76021 Karlsruhe
Mendelssohn Award
This award was astablished by the International Cryogonic Engineering Committee (ICEC) in memory of Kurz Mendelssohn (1906-1982), the founder of ICEC. Persons to be honoured by this award are selected based on their outstanding work in the field of cryogenic engineering, e.g. concerning new solutions to difficult problems, promotion of work in new fields and stimulating the community's interest in such fields and long-standing superior contributions to cryogenics. Earlier award winners were K. Oshima, P. Roubeau, J. Gardner, P. Mason, D. Petrac and H. Desportes. Based on the decision in the ICEC the Mendelssohn Award is presented at this conference to Prof. Olli V. Lounasmaa in recognition of this outstanding contributions over many decades to the worldwide development of cryogenics. As an excellent scientist in fields reaching from nuclear cooperative phenomena at pico-Kelvin temperatures to the use of SQUID's for studies in neuromagnetism, as a gifted teacher of young researchers at universities around the world and as organizer of several conferences he became famous in shaping the international cryogenic community and in stablishing cryogenics as an accepted field of physics and engineering. The International Cryogenic Engineering Committee is proud to present the Mendelssohn Award to Prof. O. V. Lounasmaa at the occasion of ICEC 16 in Kitakyushu.
E/
- _._.____.~
P. Komarek Chairman of the ICEC
xlvii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Olli V. Lounasmaa CURRICULUM VITAE BREVE May, 1996 Prof. Olli Viktor L o u n a s m a a, born August 20, 1930, earned his Bachelor's Degree in physics from the University of Helsinki in 1953 and his D. Phil. Degree from the University of Oxford in 1958. His thesis was on the thermodynamic properties of fluid 4He. After two years of research on liquid 4He at the University of Turku in Finland he became, in 1960, Resident Research Associate at the Argonne National Laboratory near Chicago. There he built a 3He refrigerator and completed an extensive series of measurements on the nuclear heat capacity of rare earth metals. During this period he also did some research on liquid 4He near the )~-transition. In 1965 Lounasmaa returned to Finland. He was appointed Professor of Technical Physics at the Helsinki University of Technology where he founded the Low Temperature Laboratory and became its director. Since then he has specialized in research at milli-, micro-, nano-, and even picokelvin temperatures. In 1970 he was appointed Professor of the Academy of Finland. He retired in January 1996. Three refrigerators, employing adiabatic nuclear demagnetization techniques for cooling, are currently operating in the Low Temperature Laboratory. In two of them, rotating 3He can be investigated between 0.4 and 3 mK: extensive NMR, superfluid flow, ion mobility, ultrasonic, and optical measurements have been carried out on vortices in rotating 3He-A and 3He-B. The third cryostat, intended for research on nuclear cooperative phenomena in metals, has two nuclear cooling stages working in series. This apparatus has held many world's low temperature records, currently 280 pK in the nuclear spin system of rhodium. The same cryostat has produced "record-high" negative spin temperatures, first in silver and then in rhodium (-750 pK). Three antiferromagnetic phases have been discovered in copper and antiferromagnetic and ferromagnetic phases in silver. Another double nuclear refrigerator, constructed in Helsinki for neutron diffraction studies at nanokelvin temperatures, was operating first at the Rise National Laboratory in Denmark and is now working at the Hahn-Meitner-Institute in Berlin; this is a joint Danish-Finnish-German research effort, partially financed by the European Community's SCIENCE program. Nuclear ordering in copper at T > 0 was studied in Rise (the three antiferromagnetic phases were confirmed) and will be investigated in silver at T > 0 and at T < 0 in Berlin. The Low Temperature Laboratory is also participating in the Spin-Muon Collaboration at CERN by being responsible for the construction of a very powerful dilution refrigerator. Much work has also been done by Lounasmaa and his students on the M6ssbauer effect, on thermometry below 1 K, and on the use of SQUIDs for low temperature and brain research. Large scale uses of superconductivity have been investigated as well, including the construction of a 0.17-T superconducting solenoid for whole-body MR imaging. A 1.5 T magnet, 2 m long and with an 0.8 m bore, was completed in 1988. A magnetically shielded room was built in 1980 into the Low Temperature Laboratory. With this facility, Lounasmaa's attention was partly turned to measurements of the weak magnetic signals produced by the human brain; in fact, neuromagnetism has now become his secondary field of interest. After several smaller instruments, a SQUID magnetometer with 24 simultaneously operating channels was put to use in 1989. A 122-SQUID device, which covers the whole head and is the first instrument in this category, has been operational in the Low Temperature Laboratory since the summer of 1992. Many extensive series of magnetoencephalographic (MEG) experiments, such as studies of basic neurophysiology, localizing epileptic foci, investigating cognitive processes, and studies of signal processing in the human brain have been carried out. In 1977 Lounasmaa worked for a year at Sacley near Paris. He has also spent 1 to 2 months as Visiting Professor in the United States, Japan, India, Germany, and Denmark. The Academic Year 1 9 8 2 - 8 3 he pursued research first at the University of California in Berkeley and later at New York University. Most of 1996 he will be working at the Hahn-Meitner-Institut in Berlin. xlix
Prof. Lounasmaa is the author of over 200 scientific papers, including a book entitled "Experimental Principles and Methods below 1 K". He has given well over 200 seminar or colloquium talks at low temperature laboratories throughout the world and attended about 100 international conferences, presenting over 40 plenary or invited papers. He has also given 16 series of lectures abroad, many of them at international schools of physics. Lounasmaa has supervised the Ph.D. theses of 40 students and written expert's opinions on the qualifications of candidates for many professorships in Finland and abroad. Lounasmaa is the Director of two Large-Scale Facilities, BIRCH in neuroand cardiomagnetism and ULTI in ultralow temperature physics, established by the European Union's Human Capital and Mobility Program in 1994. He has also been active in science policy in Finland having served, for example, in 1980 and in 1984 as Chairman of Ministry of Education working groups on basic research. At the Ministry's request he made in 1995 an evaluation of the departments of mathematics, physics, chemistry, and computer sciences in Finnish universities. In 1965 Lounasmaa was elected to the Finnish Academy of Technical Sciences, in 1969 to the Finnish Academy of Sciences and Letters (President 1992), in 1974 to the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, in 1976 to the Societas Scientiarum Fennica, and in 1989 to the Academia Europaea; in 1986 he became Fellow of the American Physical Society. He is also past President of the Finnish Physical Society and Honorary Member since 1990. In 1969 Lounasmaa received the Th. Hom6n Prize of Societas Scientiarum Fennica, in 1973 the Emil Aaltonen Foundation Prize, in 1978 the Finnish Cultural Foundation Prize, in 1980 Tekniska F6reningen i Finland 100-year Jubileum Medal, and in 1984 the Fritz London Memorial Award, presented at the 17th International Conference on Low Temperature Physics in Karlsruhe. In 1987 he was, together with three of his colleagues, given the Award for the Advancement of European Science by the K6rber-Stiftung of Hamburg. In 1990 he received the Finnish Government's Inventors Prize and in 1991 the "Professor of the Year" title. In 1990 he was promoted to the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy h o n o r i s c a u s a by the University of Helsinki in connection with the TT ~nlversity t s 350-year celcbrations. In 1992, he received the Degree of Doctor of Technology h o n o r i s c a u s a by the Tampere University of Technology. He is Commander 1st Class of the Order of the White Rose of Finland and Commander of the Order of the Lion of Finland. In 1993 he was honored by the Forschungspreis of the Alexander von Humboldt-Stiftung of Germany and in 1994 he was awarded the Wihuri International Prize. In 1995 he received the Finnish Government's Decoration for XXX Years of Service, the first Kapitza Gold Medal, founded by the Russian Academy of Sciences on the occasion of Pjotr Kapitza's 100th birthday, and the Italgas Prize in physics, donated by the Italgas Company and awarded in collaboration with the Academy of Sciences of Torino. He also received the Espoo medal. In 1996 he was honored by the Mendelssohn Prize awarded by the International Cryogenic Engineering Committee. "
9
Prof. Lounasmaa has participated in international collaboration among low temperature physicists. He has been President of the Commission on Cryophysics of the International Institute of Refrigeration and Chairman and Member of the Very Low Temperature Physics Commission of the International Union of Pure and Applied Physics; he has also been a member of the International Cryogenic Engineering Committee. For four years he served on the Executive Committee of the European Physical Society. In 1992 he became member of Comit6 International des Poids et Mesures. He was in 1975 President of the 14th International Conference on Low Temperature Physics (LT14) and in 1984 President of the 10th International Cryogenic Engineering Conference (ICEC-10). He was President of the 7th General Conference of the European Physical Society (EPS-7), held in Helsinki in 1987. He has organized six smaller international conferences and several winter schools with foreign participation. He has been a member of the International Committees of over 20 scientific conferences held abroad. He also belongs to the Editorial Boards of two scientific journals. Lounasmaa is married and has two daughters and four granddaughters.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Plenary lectures
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
A Way to Commercialization of High-Tc Superconductors
Shoji Tanaka Superconductivity Reseach Laboratory, International Superconductivity Technology Center 10-13 Shinonome 1-chome, Koto-ku, Tokyo 135, Japan
Since the discovery of high-Tc superconductivity in 1986, the research and developments have been made big progress. In the past ten years, we learned that the oxide superconductors have completely different characters from metallic superconductors in crystal structures, conduction properties both in normal and superconducting states and so on. Therefore, it is expected that any future applications of these materials are strongly bound by such special characters. At present, directions of application research are classified into three categories ; (a) Developments of high quality superconducting wires and tapes. (b) Developments of large bulk superconductors having high critical currents. (c) Developments of new superconducting electronic devices. All these application research must be based on how we can control those materials in quality and functions. In this report, the basic problems in research and development of high-Tc superconductors will be discussed and the prospect of future applications will be shown.
INTRODUCTION In the past ten years, more than twenty different kinds of high-Tc superconductors were discovered, and more than a half of them have critical temperature beyond 100K. The highest critical temperature is obtained in Hg-compound as high as 136K in ordinary atmosphere. This means that the operating temperature for future superconducting devices is widened from 4.2K to beyond 100K. On the other hand, the refrigeration technology has shown also a remarkable progress in its development, and this gives us a wide range of selections of the operating temperature. Generally speaking, the specific heats of solids depend on temperature strongly at low temperature regions, and the superconducting system operating at 77K has much larger heat capacity, sometimes more than 100 times, than that operating at 4.2K. This means that any systems or devices of high-Tc superconductivity are much more stable than that of low-Tc. Furthermore, the serious instability problem in the case of the low-Tc superconducting system, that is the quenching phenomena, may not be encountered in the high-Tc superconducting systems. These facts indicate that the market for the high-Tc superconducting systems must be quite wide enough for transportations, many industrial factories, electricity and electronics, and medicals. The high-Tc superconducting materials, however have several difficulties to reach real applications. This is due to the specific characters of high-Tc superconducting oxides. In this paper, it will be discussed how we have been overcoming those difficulties in high-Tc superconductors.
4
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
REQUIREMENTS ON MATERIALS FOR PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS Before discussing the requirements on materials for applications, we have to settle the operating temperature. From both, the economical and technological points of view in the refrigeration system, the higher operating temperature is better. However, the requirement to materials becomes severe in high temperature, since the characteristics of the material depend strongly on temperature. It seems to be plausible to chose 20K and 77K as the operating temperature. At 20K, the most of the characteristics of high-Tc superconducting oxides, Hg -, T1-, and Bi-based compounds and 1-2-3 compounds are, even at present, comparable or rather superior to those of low-Tc materials at 4.2K except the problem of thermal noise. Therefore, it is reasonable to settle the operating temperature for applications in the near future as 77K, and to discuss the requirements or targets of developments of high-Tc superconductors. Superconducting wires and tapes Taking into account the very wide future applications of superconducting wires and tapes, the requirements for critical current density must exceed 105 Amp / cm 2 at the magnetic field of 5T. This is rather moderate, if we consider the application to the nuclear fusion, however it covers still fairly a wide range of applications ; power cable, electric motor, maglev-cars and so on. At present, the silver-sheathed Bi-compound tape showed rather higher value in its critical current density at 20K, but the value is still lower at 5T, 77K. Bulk superconductors There are two kinds of applications of bulk superconductors ; one is using the magnetic levitation force in combination with ordinary permanent magnets, and the other is using the trapped magnetic field occurred by magnetic excitation. Both phenomena appear as the results of the pinning effect of quantized magnetic flux in the bulk. For consideration of the capability of the materials, the trapped magnetic field is a better measure. The trapped magnetic field is also strongly temperature dependent; it is roughly proportional to (Tc-To) 2, where To is the operating temperature. The requirement for the trapped magnetic field is 5T at 77K. It must be mentioned that the strength of the trapped magnetic field depends on the size of the bulk ; although it increases with the thickness of the bulk, it is assumed that here the thickness of the bulk is roughly 1 cm. The strength of the magnetic field at the surface of the ordinary permanent magnet is less than 1T, so it can be said that our requirement on the superconducting bulk is more than five times stronger than that of the ordinary permanent magnet. Superconducting electronic devices The requirements for the superconducting electronic devices are still not clear at present, since the image of future devices is not firmly established yet, eventhough many kinds of proposed ideas have been announced. But the basic needs for superconducting devices are very high speed operation and very low power consumption. In that sense, the single flux quantum (SFQ) device may be the most plausible candidate. This is simple extension of rf-or dc-SQUID and originally proposed by Likharev [1 ]. The simple logic devices were tried by Likharev [2], Okabe [3], Goto [4] and others by using Low-Tc materials (Nb) at 4.2K. This logic device is expected to have very high speed operation (10 psec) and very low power consumption (10pW). The logic devices using high-Tc materials have been tried recently by Westinghouse Co. [5], Hitachi Co. [6] and our laboratory [7]. The future image of the construction of the SFQ logic circuit is shown in Figure 1. In this figure, the superconducting single crystal is used as ground plane for the circuit and also as substrate for constructing the multilayer system, in which logic devices and wiring are included. In order to realize such a system, it is necessary to develop single crystal growth technology and high quality thin film technology.
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings PROBLEMS IN MATERIAL DEVELOPMENT In order to respond to the requirements of the future applications of high-Tc superconductor, we have to solve many problems in materials. The high-Tc superconducting oxides are composed of many different kinds of elements from three to five, and the crystal structures are also complicated. Then before discussing problems, several specific features of these material must be mentioned. Some of them are shown in Table 1 in comparison with low-Tc metallic superconductors. Passivation
Dimensionality Crystallinity
Metals
Oxides
Three Dim.
Two Dim.
not
sensitive
very
sensitive
Coherence Length Long ( > 1O0 A ) very short (< 30 A ) Boundary Effect
small
very large
Table 1. Superconductivity in Metals and HTSC
Insulater
Superconductor
Technologies (1)Single Crystal V///f//////////~f~///f////~/~/f~ Growth I .... ~-" IT_ ._-.., - ( 2 ) Homoepita xia I r/.l-././-j-./-.1-/-jj-./-/-./~/-~./.cjfj//////~jfjfj/~ Growth of High 12 ? '-Quality Thin Film (3)Multilayer Structure (4)Junction Fabrication (5)Passivation Basic
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Fig. 1. Image of Future SFQ
All high-Tc superconductors, discovered until today, include so-called C u - O 2 planes in the crystal lattice, and the superconductivity occurs in these two-dimensional Cu-O 2 planes. Then, any lattice defect or impurity in the Cu-O 2 planes disturbs sensibly the superconductivity. Therefore, in any application, the Cu-O 2 planes in the crystal must be kept perfect as much as possible. Another specific feature is the short coherence length in these superconductors. It is estimated that the coherence length in a-b plane is around 2 0 ~ 3 0 A and less than 10 * along c-axis. This indicates that even very thin barriers among grains prevent the flow of supercurrent. These specific features suggest that the story of material problems must begin from the growth technology of pure single crystals of high-Tc superconductors. Single Crystal Growth Thin flakes of single crystal of YBCO and other 1-2-3 materials can be made by the flux method. But large single crystal of these materials can be grown only by the pulling method. Since those materials are incongruent, the special technology is necessary in growing large single crystals. A new method was invented in our laboratory in 1992 and it is called as the SRL-CP method. Single crystals of YBCO, NdBCO, SmBCO and PrBCO were grown by this method. Figure 2 shows a photograph of a typical single crystal of YBCO [8], and the cristallinity of this crystal investigated by X-ray diffraction reaches almost the same level as that of commercial single crystals of S r T i O 3 and MgO. It is rather surprising that the single crystal of YBCO reaches such grade of perfection nevertheless of its very complicated structure. It was also shown that these single crystals have also very high quality in electronic properties. We expect that we can obtain pure single crystals of 25 • 25 • 25mm 3 in the size in near future. Pinning Centers and Critical Currents The most important imperfections in superconductor are pinning centers, which pin the magnetic vortex. By this pinning effect, the critical current of superconductor increases. At present, it is considered that many kinds of imperfections can be pinning centers ; domain boundaries, dislocations, stacking faults and so on. However, it becomes clear that some kinds of the lattice defects having macroscopic size, from 100 .a. to several thousands A, survive as pinning centers at liquid N 2 temperature. This was confirmed in the YBCO bulk material containing finely dispersed particles of the Y2Ba~CuO5 phase [9]. The traces of ion bombardments in YBCO also increase the critical current.
6
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings Pinning Center
Matrix ( V e r y Good Single Crystal)
lOmm
Figure 3 Image of "Pseudo Single Crystal"
Figure 2 Y123 single crystal grown along the c-axis
On the other hand, those materials having high critical currents showed rather good superconducting characteristics ; the critical temperature is almost the same as that of pure single crystals and the super-normal transition is also fairly sharp. These facts lead us to the new concept of pseudo-single crystal. The image of the pseudo-single crystal is shown in Figure 3. It is expected that the large pinning force comes from the boundary between the pinning center and the matrix, and the sharper the boundary, the larger the pining force. Probably this sharp change in crystal structure at the boundary (and also sharp change in order parameter) may be the origin of strong pinning force. In the field of applications, the magnetic field dependence of the pinning force is essentially important. Usually, the critical current decreases with increasing magnetic field and this prevents the wide range of applications of superconductivity. In 1993, Yoo. et al. in our laboratory [10] found that bulk of Nd~Ba2Cu30 v and Sm~Ba2Cu307, which were made by the OCMG (Oxygen Controlled Melt Growth) method, showed a prominent peak in magnetic field dependence of critical currents at 77K as shown in Figure 4, and a peak current density much higher than the Jc of the YBCO bulk in the high magnetic field region was observed. Further, they succeeded in increasing critical current of NdBCO in the lower magnetic field region (0 ~-2T) by introducing Nd4Ba2Cu20~0 particles. By those processes, it becomes possible to control the critical current in a wide magnetic field range ( 0 ~ 5 T ) at liquid N 2 temperature. They also found that the irreversibility field, which is the measure of pinning force of pinning centers, reached more than 10T at 77K. SOxlO 3
I...................................
/,)ii
I ........................ [................
I............
i..........
t ...........
I ..........
i ..................... I.............
I--
!
i
I
I
t
!
I
t
i
i,
i,
i,
it
~i
!i . . . . . . . .
Li
I
II
i
I
l)
i
I
I
I-I//c-axis,
I ..............
] ............
l._
]
i
i
I~
,i0 - ~ ' ~ .................... ~. . . . . . . .
i
77
l(~
i
i ....................... r . . . . . . . . . . .
[ . . . . . . .~ . . . ] . . . . .
~. . . .
o,
i
t
i
i"..."
i
I
[
,
I
,.7
i
".. ) ~ ,
i
J
i
i/
'
i ,
" !'.
! '~ , ..,
t ,
i
.............
i--
0
.,=,
:.
:
,.
,,
9 ~176176
li.
0
'
I~, \
.,=( I=~
',
i
"-,_i
'
/
, ~.~i''~,.._
P ........-~:"- ..............!........................ i.........- ~
r,.2
i~.
i
}
1.0
1.S
ii
I
,
.... i ....."-;'.~::i ........... -~'~-
~i
I
2.5
3.0
i~
,
..... ~
i
\.I.
!
0 0.0
0.3
2.0
3.S
,1.0
4.5
5.0
Figure 4 Magnetic field dependence of critical current density for different materials
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings 0.2
7
40000
0.0,
FC
-0.2
c//H H=10G
"13
at 77K
NK, 96.1K
30000
-0.4
N
E
E
-0.6
1,,,..
O Z
20000
|
O
ZFC
oo0~ 9
c//H
|
|
|
O|
Oe|
-0.8
e
9
0
10000 J
-1.0
e 9
a//H
e~182 .1.2 L
60
70
80
90
100
110
0
0
20000
40000
60000
H[G] T[K] Figure 5 Results of Meissner effect and Jc/H curves measurements of NdBCO single crystal. After quenching as-grown crystal, followed the heat treatment (600-350~ for 200h, 340~ for 200h in 02)
Even in single crystals of NdlBa2Cu307 grown by the pulling method, Shiohara. et al. found the strong peak effect near 4T after suitable annealing process as shown in Figure 5 [11]. It is the most striking fact that very strong pinning centers are introduced even in single crystals simply by the thermal annealing process, even though the structure of pinning centers is still under investigation at present. The finding of the remarkable peak effect in the magnetic field dependence of the critical currents in NdBCO and SmBCO at 77K gives us a good hope to be able to reach the requirements (a) and (b) in just before section, in very near future, eventhough the technology of making wires or tapes using these materials is still left in future. Films and Boundaries Problems in films and boundaries are very important for future developments in superconducting electronics. The multi-layer system consisting of several different kinds of thin layers is also important in semiconductor electronics, especially in semiconductor lasers consisting of several films of III - IV compounds.
100 90 8O
.- _.L_ru'
----~
-O
~ 70 ,...,
~2 60 E 50 [-, 40
r
,,._.
~ 30
]
.-..
~ 20
MgO,
10 _
i
_
.,I
10
15
I
20
-
25
Deposition Times Figure 6 Reproducibility of critical temperature measured by the dc four-probe method
Figure 7 a-YBCO film grown on a-YBCO single crystal by MOCVD
8
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
PBCO
YBCO ..........................................................................
misfit dislocation
i 9. ~
Figure 8 TEM image of the misfit dislocation at the interface of heteroepitaxially grown Y 123/Pr 123
Figure 9 Multi-layer system of PrBCO and NdBCO
The film preparation is the first problem to be solved. There are several methods in preparing oxide superconductor films; sputtering method, laser ablation method, molecular beam method, MOCVD method and liquid phase epitaxy (LPE) method. Selection of substrate materials is also critical. Recently, liquid sources were introduced to the MOCVD method instead of solid sources, and high quality thin films of YBCO can be prepared steadily as shown in Figure 6 [12]. As to the LPE method, we already reported that a thick film (10"-- 50 tz m) of single crystalline YBCO is grown on MgO substrates. Both of these methods are performed under nearly thermal equilibrium conditions and this may be the reason of obtaining high quality films. This fact is in good correspondence to the fact that in semiconductor technology only MOCVD method and LPE method survived in obtaining high quality thin layers of compound semiconductors. Recently, it becomes possible to grow films of the 1-2-3 material on the surface of the single crystal of 1-2-3 materials. We can call this as homoepitaxial growth. This success will lead to the growth of the multi-layer system with the highest quality. Figure 7 an example of a TEM photograph of homoepitaxial growth of an a-axis oriented YBCO single crystal [ 13]. In this figure, the boundary is hardly recognized. On the other hand, the lattice parameters of YBCO are slightly different from PrBCO, and consequently a beautiful array of misfit dislocations can be observed as is shown in Figure 8 [14]. This kind of misfit dislocations are frequently observed in semiconductor devices like semiconductor lasers. The lattice misfit between NdBCO and PrBCO is rather small, and so we can make the multi-layer system using both materials. In Figure 9, very thin films of NdBCO and PrBCO were deposited alternately, but no boundary can be observed [15]. Furthermore, only one pattern of 1-2-3 structure, which differs slightly from either material, is observed in X-ray diffraction. Therefore, it can be said this is a so-called strained-super-lattice, which is also used in semiconductors electronics. These results indicate that most of the basic material technologies necessary for developing superconducting electronic devices, especially for SFQ logic devices, are ready at present. Future problem is how to integrate these technologies to real circuits. Surface As to surfaces of oxide superconductors, we know very little at present.
Atomic structures and also
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings ~] [llc
9
TgpolActdx SPM VJ.04 Edit
Duffers
Di.play~Proccss
,~eiysl$
SetUp
~i~indow
I"1_; Help
9
.
Ra: Rp:
Rpm" RI: Rim: i..--': Qo, "I , 9. t .
,
;~
..... " I
9
,'o
9
Standaml Rounhness RI:
Rp:
0.0:~ 0.03
Rpm: Rt:
0.03 0.01
.
'oo
0.03 0.0] 0.0] 0.01 0.01
9
.:.
2
.
.
9
.
.'~
0 . 2 0 n m l - ....... ?i 0.00 -;
. .:: .~:L.
:. ~ : ~ - ! ~ . 7 - ' : " / ~ .
. -
- ".
[.~;.,-:i~"~;:!-,.,,,.:
"
9 11 o.2onm 12:0.1Tnm /
.~:~:~ ~. o.oo : ;"~" '. 0 . 0 0
all.spin
!l
:
.
. '
..
.:
:,.-
-:. '
I
,0..
C-"r----~ .'. J r , ~ r
:i ..............
J~. r T I
li["aL~J~./r~er]Lr'/"|
91 1 [ Irt~ l,-._.+~m,,.- -,-- . -
,
x , - U . I ~ ~ ..a..,,,i
St.e~l,e,dR,ouohne~ ~" H,'~ht ~" 6e,~n 0 R-";o
"OPEIMETRIX TI'IX-2910
J"- lrlactal
S.R.L.
Figure 10 Atomically resolved AFM image and its line profile obtained from a flat terrace of the NdBCO thin films showing atomic rows 2.0 ,~ spacing
electronic structures of these materials must be very complicated and sometimes unstable. Accordingly, it is necessary to study quite a lot of things on treatments of surfaces of single crystals. Even though the surface problem must become very important for future applications, only the facts are written in this paper due to page limitation. If we assume the possibility of application of S-N-S Josephson junctions, the roughness of the surface of oxide superconductors must be hopefully less than 10 .~. In single crystals of YBCO, it was found that the roughness of the polished surface measured by AFM is nearly 10 ,~. Thisresult indicates the possibility of making a very thin insulating layer on the superconductor surface, with a thickness as small as a coherence length. Detailed investigation on such surfaces is now in progress. Very recently, it was found that the surfaces of NdBCO films deposited by the laser ablation method and also by the sputtering method are very flat and very stable even in the ambient atmosphere. The roughness of the film is nearly 10 .~ and arrays of surface atoms (probably Cu ions) can be observed by AFM as is shown in Figure 10 [16]. Later it was also found that similar arrays were also observed on the surface of NdBCO single crystals. Reasons of such peculiar phenomena are not clear yet, but it is somewhat indicative that the surface problems of these materials are very interesting and important, though they are still mysterious at present. PROSPECTS FOR FUTURE APPLICATIONS As were mentioned in just before section, the basic material technologies have been developed quickly in these past few years, and is approaching the requirements mentioned in the preveous section day by day. This means that many kinds of applications will come out in near future. In ISTEC, the prospects for future applications of high-Tc superconductors were investigated in 1995, and the results are shown in Figures 10, 11 12 and 13. These results indicate that some real applications begin to appear around the year of 2000, and the superconductivity industry will rise sharply between the years of 2000 and 2010. It is hoped that this will give prosperity to the world of human beings of the 21 st. century.
10
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings 10' F: x
< v
9
10
o
.
.
.
.
i
.
.
.
.
i
9
,
9
'
10s
9
10
10
(2
,:~~~"gle cry=el t 1 ! ~ eticSeparator
10'
!
t=-I!ctrtc Power Cable
10
4
L
E 10 2 ._m t_ E
Separator
i Ei;ctricP~
3 0
1
lO
! Current Lead ,..,...j
....
~ ,
1990
'
" Current Lead
,.~-~...:
--
1995
,
. . . .
,
....
,
2000
ME
•
Cable 10 0
o
~
~
10
10
u
O O
Laboratory ~MRI ]~ Lev,'tation_.iLaboratory MRI ]~ Levitation wlagne~t ~ ~ / Magnet /__~ / / \ (:steel /~teel~~ ~[ ~' r' ~' -'rC~~Set emei lc a ' l -'~j Chemical " ~teel l'~J,rrP-'~n,, I "/Current~-Reaction / ~ o n Plant "--"~ Limiter) (Laboratory): ~ - ' ~ , ' ~ ' , ~ i . . . . . ~,, U ~'~Si single c r y s t a , ~ : "{ ...... ~. . . . ~r....
10 3
E
G~enerator
4i
r"
E L_ I,.
i
Bi-based
r"
X
,
Ge~nerator
s~
D3
t..
9
10 "1
2005
o .~ E to
2010
AGE Figure 11 Technology of Wire - A prospect" Period of developing materials available for systems
[
Levitated )
/
-o
o~ LL (9 r E~ . m
z~
kUSagnet _ Liquid I/Hydr~ ~,Clamp 1 [{Pump ~ ~I--~. ] ~~J' - //~xitation "v" Magnetic u=,.,~ .L_ F
~ 1
,
I
!
1996
apacity
lOkWh
I
I
!
!
!
2000
,
I
I
2005
AGE Figure 12 Technology of Bulk Materials - A prospect" Period of developing materials available for systems ~> 10000 N T
- -
9
&..
o n
1000
x
>'O 100 /~iii~~~~ F of ~r e q u / e n c y gH c-heri n (1) :::3 ET ~_ ~k~W- 300:// Higher Tc LL
lO
1995
2000
2005
AGE
2010
2015
Figure 13 Applications to Passive Devices-A prospect: Period of developing materials available for systems
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
or) c~O 0 c-" ~,.,,~
..,,
i
i
High speed Low power High sensitivity '
"lpslgate :nW :fT/d'Hz~
~
I
103
0 l
(1.) ,..s
102
E 7
/ _~,%.4" 10
1
9S Q U I D - - - * N o n d e s t r u c t i o n Test, Magnetocardiometer ital Circuit--* S a m p l e r
~g 1990
, 1995
~"
J, 2000
~)'~"'~ -"~"~
,
I
2005
2010
II
AGE Figure 14 Applications to Active Devices - A prospect: Period of developing materials available for systems REFERENCES 1 K.K. Likharev and V.K.Semenov : IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. 1, (1991) 3 ; K.K.Likharev, in "I'he New Superconducting Electronics, edited by H. Weinstock and R.W. Ralston (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Netherlands 1993) p.423. 2 V.K.Kaplunenko, M. I. Khabipov, V.P.Koshelets, K.K. Likharev, O.A.Mukhanov, V.K. Semenov, I.L.Serpuchenko, and A.N. Vystavkin : IEEE Trans. on Magn.25, (1989), 861. 3 T. Tamura, Y. Okabe, and T. Sugano : Appl. Phys Lett.39, (1981) 761. 4 E. Goto and K.F. Loe : DC "Flux Parametron. Singapore, World Scientific, (1986). 5 D.L. Miller, M.G. Forrester, J. X.Przybysz, B.D.Hunt, and J. Talvacchio : Extended Abstracts 5th of Int. Superconductive Electronics Conf., (Nagoya), (1995) 27. 6 H. Hasegawa, Y. Tarutani, U. Kabasawa, N. Sugii, T. Fukazawa, and K.Takagi : Extended Abstracts of Int. Workshop on Superconductivity, (Hachimantai), (1996) 147 7 H. Fuke, K. Saitoh, M. Kataoka, T. Utagawa, and Y. Enomoto 9submitted to Appl. Phys. Lett.; K. Saitoh, H. Fuke, T. Utagawa, and Y. Enomoto : submitted to Japanese Jornal of Appl. Phys. 8 Y. Namikawa, M. Egami and Y. Shiohara, J.J.Metals 59, 1053 (1995) 9 H. Fujimoto, M. Murakami, S. Gotho, N. Koshizuka, and S. Tanaka 10 S.I Yoo, N. Sakai, T. Higuchi, and M. Murakami, Appl. Phys.Lett., 65, 633 (1994) 11 N. Nakamura, Y. Yamada, T. Hirabayashi, Y. Ikuhara, Y. Shiohara and S. Tanaka, Physica C, Physica C 259 (1996) 12 Y. Yoshida, Y. Ito and I. Hirabayashi, Submitted for publicationin Appl. Phys. Lett. 13 J.G.Wen, T. Zama, T. Morishita, and N. Koshizuka, to be submitted 14 M. Tagami and Y. Shiohara, to be submitted 15 G.A. Alvarez, J.G. Wen, F.Wang and Y. Enomoto : submitted for publication in Appl. Phys. Lett. 16 M.Badaye, Wu. Ting, K. Fukushima, N.Koshizuka, T. Morishita and S.Tanaka, Appl. Phys. Lett.67, 2155(1995)
11
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Development of the Superconducting Maglev System in Japan
Masanori OZEKI Railway Technical Research Institute, 27F Stec johou Bldg 1- 24-1 Nishishinjuku Shinjuku- ku Tokyo 160, J a p a n
The superconducting Maglev system has been under development for the past 25 years in Japan. The vehicle can be magnetically levitated as much as 100 m m from the guideway surface using the superconducting magnets on board. Also, the vehicle can be propelled by a linear motor using the same superconducting magnets. In 1990, the maglev system gained status as one of the nationally-funded projects in Japan. The government authorized the 42.8-km test line in Y a m a n a s h i Prefecture and R&D entered a new phase. This new test line is planned to go through an area near Tokyo'on the proposed Chuo line, which is expected to be a new important line connecting Tokyo and Osaka, the central part of Japan. The current state of the technical development of the Maglev system is reviewed.
INTRODUCTION The applied technology of superconductivity is such an important technology as will bring about revolution in the industrial structure of the world in the next century. As well known, current superconducting applied technologies have recently made rapid progress, especially in terms of electronic equipment and communication system. However, in the area of energy for which the application of superconducting technology will have a great impact on society, there will yet be a need for many more difficult technology developments. We have been developing J R ' s version of Maglev using superconducting magnets with a 7 km long test track at Miyazaki since the establishment of RTRI (Railway Technical Research Institute.) Six years ago, we started the construction of a new test line of 42.8 km in Y a m a n a s h i Prefecture, of which an 18.4 km section will be completed within this year and a test run is scheduled to begin next spring. This test line occupies the transportation field's most advanced position in the world among superconducting applied technologies. The speed of Maglev we are trying to attain at Y a m a n a s h i test line is 550 k m / h (or 343 mph.) We plan to manufacture 2 train sets, consisting of 3 and 5 cars respectively, for an vehicle dynamics test by letting them pass each other at a combined speed of 1000 k m / h . The ultimate purpose of this test line is to construct a superconducting Maglev railroad in the mostpopulated section between Tokyo and Osaka, a distance of 500 km (or 330 miles), so that passengers can make the trip in one hour. 13
14 IMPORTANT
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings TECHNOLOGIES
To promote the development of superconducting Maglev, following four steps of verification is necessary. 1) Verification of theoretical possibilities. 2) Verification of technical possibilities. 3) Verification of reliability. 4) Verification of economic feasibility, The Japanese National Railway Technical Research Institute, the predecessor of the current RTRI, constructed a 400 m experimental line in 1975 in order to conduct Maglev experiments. These experiments proved the theoretical possibility. Following the experiments at RTRI, we pursued the technical possibility of Maglev by constructing 7 km of test track at Miyazaki in 1977. We were able to attain a record of 517 km/h run with an unmanned Maglev vehicle. Also, we achieved a test run of 411 k m / h with a manned vehicle. These test runs were carried out for the verification of the technical possibility. Now we are planning to test practicality next spring on the Y a m a n a s h i test line, which has been under construction since 1990. Then we will move on to verify economic viability. The characteristics of the J R type Maglev we have been developing, which have already been made public, are as follows. 1) The m a x i m u m speed is above 500 km/h. 2) Levitation is maintained at approximately 10 cm in consideration of safety in the event of an earthquake, and also for ease of maintenance. 3) It is capable of negotiating tunnels and steep gradients because the Maglev line must be constructed over mountainous terrain. 4) It is capable of comfortably transporting 10,000 passengers per hour one way. In order to prove the reliability and practicality of Maglev on the Y a m a n a s h i test line, the following six important technologies are required" 1) A strong and reliable superconducting magnet. 2) Strong and highly reliable ground coils and power supply facilities. 3) A light weight car body with a reliable braking system. 4) An on - board refrigeration system to steadily maintain liquid helium. 5) A safe guide way system which would not adversely influence the superconducting magnets. 6) To provide a comfortable environment to passengers.
O U T L I N E OF Y A M A N A S H I
TEST LINE
It is planned to construct the Yamanashi test line in the mountainous region of Yamanashi Prefecture, 100 km west of Tokyo (fig.l). The test line is planned as a 42.8 km stretch mainly under tunnels. Out of the 42.8 km, an 18.4 km long section has already been completed, and we will start testing next spring. Some important facilities at the Yamanashi Test Line are as follows. Control Center The control center is a nucleus for controlling the operation of test vehicles and is equipped with operation control facilities and operation management devices. Car Maintenance Depot The car maintenance depot is an important facility to provide maintenance for test vehicles. Devices to re-liquefy helium gas, the storage of liquefied helium, and also facilities to energize superconducting magnets are located here.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
15
Substation The power supply facility is to provide a variable power to ground coils by adjusting frequencies so that a travelling magnetic field is created to synchronize the speed of a moving train. For this, we have installed a converter to rectify commercial power to direct current; and an inverter to convert it back to alternating current with appropriate frequencies corresponding to speed. Guideway Guideway corresponds to rail to railroads, and equipped with coiIs for levitation and guiding, and coils for propulsion of vehicles Also at the Y a m a n a s h i Test Line, there are t u r n - out devices at three locations. Test Trains Two sets of trains consisting of three and five cars respectively are to be manufactured for tests at Yamanashi. One train set with three cars has already been completed and delivered to the car maintenance depot (fig.2). We have designed two different head shapes to compare aerodynamic characteristics. JRCHUO LINE J "~ ~" ~ ~ - N A G ~ _ % KOFUCITY NAGANO K O F U C ~ ~ ~:..:.::
,THEPRIORITYSECTIO~ ! 1S.,km ] I TESTCENTER I CHUOEXP.WAY
:.:i
"
..
OHTSL~I
;OA~EgNCONVERSION~
OkmOOOm
~
TSURU-ClTY
A
Mt.FUJI
Fig. 1 Outline of Yamanashi Test Line
Fig. 2 Test train with 3 cars
C/'~
TOKYO-,,-
~ P - O T
' .... ~kmsoom-- ' ~
TUNNELSECTION
16 SUPERCONDUCTING
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings MAGNETS
Superconducting magnets to be used at the Yamanashi Test Line are attached with 4 pieces of superconducting coils of a racetrack shape as shown in the fig.3. These superconducting magnets must accept the load necessary for the levitation, propulsion and guidance of c a r bodies, and also electromagnetic oscillation with fluctuating magnetic fields during train operation. It has come clear that this electromagnetic oscillation makes troubles of quenching or heat generation in the superconducting magnets. In order to solve quenching problems of superconducting magnets, we conducted: 1) vibration test of superconducting coil by mechanical outer force. 2) vibration test of superconducting coil by electromagnetic oscillating force. By conducting the tests, we have confirmed that no quenching occurs even beyond the "worst likely case" range of exterior disturbances that superconducting magnets might be exposed to at the Y a m a n a s h i Test Line. We found out that the heat generated from relative sliding between the superconducting coils and spacers was critical. Improvement of this portion helped upgrade stability tremendously. Another problem of superconducting magnets was heat generation by eddy current within superconducting magnets. This eddy current was caused by mechanical oscillation inside of superconducting magnets due to magnetic field fluctuation from ground coils. Heat generation by oscillation from superconducting magnets in the earlier days reached 100 watts in certain frequency ranges and created serious problems. We have now solved these problems by restraining mechanical oscillation and eddy current generation.
ON- BOARD REFRIGERATOR The important superconducting applied technology of the J R type Maglev is an on-board refrigerator. For the Yamanashi Test Line, we are now pursuing the development of Gifford McMahon cycle refrigerator and Starling cycle refrigerator with advanced regenerator material. The current on- board refrigerator is designed to secure approximately 8 watt capability at 4.3 K. A refrigerator with durability exceeding 10,000 hours is about to be realized now.
9 .4.~
. ~:.:
~"":'::::.i.
:
::::::: 9 ...... ::.-:: .. .:.:.
Fig. 3 Superconduct ing magnet
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings APPLICATION
OF H T C
Currently, the coil used for superconducting magnets of the J R type Maglev has adopted fine multi - wires using NbTi and is cooled to approximately 4.3 K by liquefied helium. The superconducting magnets made by bulk material or wire of high temperature superconductivity now under examination will be made available in the near future, though further assurance of current density and stability is needed. When this technology is developed properly, there will be little technical difficulty to transfer the current facility to high temperature superconductivity. We hope to develop high temperature superconducting magnets as soon as possible.
REALIZATION
OF M A G L E V IN J A P A N
The J R type Maglev we are currently developing using superconducting magnets is meant to be a transportation system to carry a voluminous n u m b e r of passengers at a super high speed. We are aiming to construct the system between Tokyo and Osaka at the beginning of the 21st century. The Pacific Ocean coast between Tokyo and Osaka is the most populated region in Japan, where major cities are located creating a belt. The 30 year old Tokaido Shinkansen - -the Bullet T r a i n - is currently carrying 360,000 passengers a day on average with 280 trains a day in this region. During rush hours, a 16 car train is dispatched every 5 minutes with full load at the speed of 270 km per hour. Such a massive passenger transportation system is the main artery to support Japanese society and the economy; however, its transportation capacity is approaching its threshold and m a k i n g it difficult to deal with future demand increase. It is also getting rather difficult to find time between operations to repair and restore over 30 year old structures like bridges to healthy conditions. Moreover, the need for a 2nd h i g h - s p e e d transportation system between Tokyo and Osaka is becoming more apparent. It is next to impossible to construct domestic airports in those highly populated regions and therefore a superior ground transportation system such as the J R type Maglev is considered to be most appropriate to play a role as the second passenger transport system. The Maglev system under development will be tested at Y a m a n a s h i for its reliability and practicality, however, in order to become a viable transportation system, its economic feasibility must be proved. The Y a m a n a s h i Test Line is being constructed as a national project in the planned Chuo Shinkansen route between Tokyo and Osaka with a pilot role to develop into the future Maglev Shinkansen Line. In 2001, when the test is completed, it is expected to provide fruitful results to help make decisions on constructing a profitable business service line. The Maglev we are now developing certainly has the most pertinent capability as a future highspeed passenger transportation system between Tokyo and Osaka, however, in order to proceed to a construction of a profitable Maglev line, economic feasibility must be proved, The test line near completion is only 18.4 km long. It may be difficult to extrapolate or estimate the construction cost of the revenue service line accurately based on construction costs of such a short test line. We can at least say now that the Maglev construction cost should not overly exceed conventional Shinkansen construction costs. In comparison of Maglev facilities with those of conventional rail/wheel railroad, the major differences are ground coils, superconducting magnets and substation facilities. In order to make Maglev construction costs as close as possible to the conventional railroad costs, it is imperative to lower the costs of these facilities. Especially, the cost of ground coils becomes enormous, because
17
18
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
they are installed all the way along the Maglev line. The ground coils we constructed at Y a m a n a s h i are installed in three layers to minimize impact to superconducting magnets. A layer of levitating and guiding coils on the side walls are superposed on the 2 layer propulsion coils. In order to reduce the construction cost of ground coils, it is necessary to simplify the structure of coils and reduce their m a n u f a c t u r i n g costs. The R&D to simplify coil structure is now underway, and a single layer of ground coils which does the job of propulsion, guidance, and levitation all in one is being proposed. To realize such coils, superconducting magnets that are even more stable and powerful are needed, and further development of superconducting applied technologies is highly desired.
CONCLUSION We are finally starting a test of J R type Maglev next spring at Y a m a n a s h i aiming at the realization of the Maglev system as the m a j o r artery of the Pacific Ocean Corridor in Japan. I cannot stress enough the importance of the advancement of superconducting applied technologies, which hold the key to successful realization of our Maglev system. Especially to reduce Maglev construction costs to make it a commercially viable system, the realization of more stable and powerful superconducting magnets is strongly anticipated. I would like to ask continued support from all of researchers engaged in superconducting magnets and refrigeration technologies.
Cryogenic Properties of Advanced Composites and Their Applications Shigehiro Nishijima* *Institute of Scientific and Industrial Research, Osaka University, Ibaraki, Osaka 567, Japan The cryogenic properties of advanced composites are compared with those of conventional glass fiber reinforced plastics(GFRP) and the advantages of the advanced composites are discussed. The thermal properties such as thermal contraction and thermal conductivity of advanced composites are different from those of GFRP. The organic fiber reinforced plastics show negative thermal contraction behavior that is they show expansion with decreasing temperature in the fiber direction. The composites with organic fiber can be used as the former of the superconducting magnets to increase the stability. The pitch-carbon fiber reinforced plastics show high thermal conductivity and high electric resistivity. The composites have been applied to the thermal shield to prevent the eddy current in the magnet system. The thermal conductivity of alumina fiber reinforced plastics was found to be small all temperature range down to liquid helium temperature. The composite was used as the thermal supporting system with high performance in the magnet. The high glass content GFRP or 3 dimensionally reinforced plastics were developed to decrease the thermal contraction especially in the thickness direction. These materials are promising as the spacer in superconducting magnet.
INTRODUCTION The cryogenic characteristics of glass fiber reinforced plastics(GFRP) have been investigated in order to apply for the cryogenic machinery such as a superconducting magnet. The thermal conductivity of GFRP is much lower than that of metals and hence GFRPs are suitable for thermal insulating members. However the mechanical properties such as Young's modulus in the laminated direction or interlaminar shear modulus are much lower than those of metals. The thermal contraction in laminated direction is very large compared with those of metals. To solve such problems advanced composite materials(ACMs) have been developed. The characteristics of ACMs at cryogenic temperatures were evaluated and found to be unique. Taking advantage of the characteristics of ACMs the performance of cryogenic machineries were found to be improved markedly. In this paper, the characteristics of ACMs will be presented and the special application of some A CMs are discussed. DFRP (POLYETHYLENE FIBER REINFORCED PLASTICS) A high strength and high modulus polyethylene fiber (DyneemaR) has been produced by gel drawing method and was found to show high specific strength and modulus. The large negative thermal expansion coefficient (TEC) is also its characteristics. The thermal vibration perpendicular to highly oriented polymer chain contributes to the negative TEC in longitudinal direction.[ 1,2] DFRP has been shown to exhibit negative TEC because the reinforcement Dyneema R fiber has a negative TEC. [3,4] The negative TEC means not shrinkage but expansion take place during cooling down process. Taking advantage of the phenomena, the thermal contraction at the composite can be controlled. Fig.1 shows the thermal contraction of various unidirectional reinforced composites(UD-FRPs) in the longitudinal (or reinforcement) direction. In the figure GEFRP, GTFRP, AFRP, CFRP and DFRP stand for E-glass fiber reinforced plastics, T-glass fiber reinforced plastics, alumina fiber reinforced plastics, carbon fiber reinforced plastics, and polyethylene fiber reinforced plastics, respectively. Except DFRP conventional materials present the positive TEC, that is, thermal contraction with decreasing temperature. The volume fraction of reinforcement of these materials was set at 50%. CFRP shows small thermal contraction. DFRP have the unique properties of large negative thermal contraction, that is expansion with decreasing temperature. In the transverse direction, however, large thermal contraction was observed in DFRP. Taking advantage of the negative TEC, the pipes showing negative TEC may be fabricated. 19
20
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
UD// ,
!
i
,
I
0.2
a ,~ 0 |
| o DFRP/~,.' A GtFRP/~,," mDFRP Cut P i p e / t , , " oDFI~P Cut P i p e / t , . '
GeFRP G-rFRP AFRP CFRP
Ix G t F R P / ~ , . " .'~, :l/2(t,,-r
~ ,,).
8000
0.1 6000
Calcd A
(D .ca
4.a
Calcd B
4000
0
o r,..)
.r-I
2000
_
13 I.-,
b--,
-0. I
-2000
i
-0.2
o
1
.
2oo Temperature (K)
I
300
Fig. 1 Thermal contraction(strain) of various unidirectional fiber reinforced plastics parallel to reinforcement.
0
1
I
1
5
10
15
20
Di/t Fig.2 Dependence of thermal circumferential strain
(0=6O*).
In order to study the effect of pipe shape on the thermal strain of inner( e yi) and outer( E yo) surface of pipes were measured, varying the ratio of inner diameter to thickness, Di/t. The winding angle was set at 60 degree. Fig.2 shows the Di/t dependency of e yi or e yo of DFRP pipes down to liquid nitrogen temperature(LNT). The large difference comes to be small at larger Di/t region. It was found the circumferential thermal strain was positive that is the outer diameter of the pipes increased with decreasing temperature. Taking advantage of the phenomena, the DFRP pipes were employed as the coil bobbin to reduce the wire motion. The superconducting coils having DFRP bobbin was found to show higher stability compared with those having GFRP bobbins. PITCH CFRP Down to cryogenic temperatures CFRP has been found to possess good thermal conductivity and mechanical strength comparable to structural metals. While maintaining reasonably high electrical resistivity it also has exhibited very low thermal expansion. These results are presented and indicate the feasibility of pitch CFRP for thermal shielding in a wide variety of cryostats hsed for superconductivity applications. Figure 3 and 4 show temperature dependency of thermal conductivity and electrical resistivity, respectively. In Fig.3, the thermal conductivity, ~, decreased with temperature. At T > 77K it showed the same order of magnitude as aluminium and copper, a higher value than SUS and two orders higher than polyacrylonitrile(PAN) CFRP and other ACM's. In Fig.4, electric resistivity, ,o rose with decreasing temperatures, reaching values over three orders of magnitude higher than aluminum at LNT. Thermal contraction for pitch CFRP was negative with a value -0.02% at LNT. This is twice the value for PAN CFRP but still much lower than the other ACM's and notably one order lower than the 0.29% value for SUS. Measurement of the liquid helium evaporation rate of an aluminum shielded tail-type cryostat (Fig.5 (a)) was made in actual. Superinsulation was of nylon-net spaced double-aluminized mylar applied at an average of 30 layers inside and 40 layers outside the shield. The aluminum was then substituted for a carbonfiber/epoxy composite shield (Fig.5 (b)). The fibre was of elastic modulus 773 GPa at a volume fraction of 54.5%. The cryostat, made entirely of glass FRP, was evacuated throughout the experiments at a pumphead pressure of 9.3 • 10 -5 Pa. Measurements involved monitoring the surface level of the cryogen, the corresponding evaporation rate and, in the CFRP shield case, the temperature distribution along the shield.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings 9
"
''
[
"
"
"
'
1
10l~,,..
. . . .
~ ~ '
~
Cu
,,
21
,-,
l,
. . . .
"".~
I~
,
~Z'---
,
"Ic
" F?0
l~l
>r
T :x:
'
- .J
)
"'-.< ~ r
I
O U'
-~
a
f 2 .--
,,,~11 I "
9
. '
,,/,1~
/ ~'" .~~.,/"
I
u
P~Q)
PC~O 4
2
f
'
v Q. >Z
~d Cu
9
.
.
z~
d~
it
Terr~,T(K)
T~mp0T(K)
Fig.3 Temperature dependency of thermal conductivity for pitch-CFRP (P60 R and P80R). Select metallic resistivity for pitch-CFRP materials included for comparison.
Fig.4 Temperature dependency of electrical resistivity for pitch-CFRP (F60 R, F70 R and F80R). Select metallic resistivity for pitch-CFRP materials included for comparison.
(a)
(b),
I (I) 182
1 06
l<
>--<
.
I I I
Shield anchor
I
(Aluminum)
Vacuum Vessel
dL'eclion
9
Axial ' 7 ply
I I
156
(GFFe)
184
Radiation shield
I
( AV CFP,P)
i
258
/Fibre
I
I
o
.
/
~176 90~
Cryogen c o n l ainer
(GFFP)
(sl y c a s t
.fixed)*
1 ply
Axial 94 ply
T2(K) %(K)
Fibre direcl ion 0
i
i
'
" ~
90
9
2-D "2ply
All join;s lixed by slycasl N o . 1 2 6 6
Fig.5 The cr3,ostat (a) and CFRP thermal radiation shield (b). T 1, T2 and T3 are the values of shicld temperature monitored. Places are shown in Fig.5 (a) and data are shown in Fig.6. The evaporation loss rates for both the aluminum and CFRP shields are shown in figure 6 as a function of the fall of the liquid surface taken as the ration of surface drop(from the neck bottom) to the height of the container's pot section. The corresponding temperature variations of three points on the CFRP shield are also shown. The evaporation rates in both the aluminum and CFRP cases decrease with liquid level, with CFRP higher. With the cryostat operating point(COP) taken at the point where the CFRP shield bottom(its warmest part, T3(K)) is coldest the evaporation rate is only 7% larger. The level drop is 0.33 at this point. The measured liquid holding times (to tail top level) were 1330 and 1400 minutes for the CFRP and aluminum cases respectively.
22
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings 120
9
'
.E 8 E 7
o~
T2
t~6
.
"r~ 5 c 0
T3
'-,,,,~ ' ~
_
- ~
...~ ~ ~--" e
....4:]~ _ _
.~1
4
, - .
0 > UJ
3 2
I
Ik-
/ Er
"& "&~_
L ~-'- tr "B
CFRP. CFRP
"6.
--
/
1
1
0
0.2
0.4
-A . &
1
AI
-
110
"," ~J I---
-
100
d
-
90
k.,.
-
80
1:3.. E
-
70
-
60
-P'-I'B--5 0.6
0.8
I
Ii,....
I-
x~ ~:
O0
5O
Liquid s u r f a c e drop
Fig.6 Shield temperature and evaporation loss rate variation with liquid level. It will be noticed that at pre-COP liquid surface levels the evaporation rates are equivalent for both cases and the CFRP shield temperatures are falling. This is simply due to the cryostat cooling process as this was the first liquid helium(LHe) transfer after precooling with liquid nitrogen(LN2) in both cases. With LN2 in the cryostat the shield temperature at the three points was an area-weighted mean of 205K with T 3 - T 1 " " 5 K . It is presumed that subsequent LHe transfers will show evaporation rates of around COP value. HIGH GLASS CONTENT GFRP The GFRP have been used as the spacers for forming cooling channel, transmitting electro-magnetic forces to structural materials and insulating voltage in the superconducting magnets[5,6]. The good mechanical and thermal properties, such as thermal dimensional stability, compressive modulus and compressive strength in the thickness direction are requested to the spacers. The characteristics of GFRP in the thickness direction, however, are not so superior to those in the in-plane direction because the reinforcements are not oriented. The improvement of the characteristics, therefore, should be important not to decrease the rigidity of the magnet[7,8]. The glass cloth laminates with high performances in thickness direction have been developed and the applicability and/or availability were also examined. The targets for the development were set as, (i) thermal contraction down to cryogenic temperature in thickness direction should be decreased to approximately 0.3 %, (ii) compressive modulus at room temperature(RT) in thickness direction should be increased to 15 GPa, and (iii) compressive strength in thickness direction should be higher than 300 MPa at RT. The thermal contraction of aluminum, copper and conventional GFRP in thickness direction are 0.4%, 0.3% and 0.6% respectively while their respective Young's modulus are 70 GPa, 120 GPa, and 5 GPa. The compressive strength of 300 MPa can be attained by conventional GFRP. The mechanical targets were set for RT conditions considering the actual conditions of the spacer in the superconducting magnets. In large scaled magnets are usually applied forces at RT which are equivalent to the thermal and electromagnetic forces to keep the rigidity even at cryogenic temperatures. [9] The insulating spacers, therefore, should show high mechanical properties even at RT. The mechanical properties are known to increase with decreasing temperature. They are the reasons why the targets were set at RT. Two methods to the GFRP with high performances in thickness direction were considered, that is (i) GFRP with filled matrix or (ii) those with high glass content. Young's modulus and thermal contraction of matrix were shown in Table 1. Table. 1 Glass content in composite versus thermal contraction and Young's modulus. Glass content S a dt Young's modulus in composites (%) (%) (GPa) 50 0.51 10 60 0.62 7 70 0.80 5
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
23
Based on experimentals it was decided to increase the glass content for improving the properties of GFRP. The satin woven cloth was also employed as the reinforcement. The woven angle of the fiber in satin cloth is smaller than that in plane cloth and hence the resin rich area in the GFRP with satin clothes was expected to be small. The GFRP having plane woven clothes was named HG-1A R and that having satin woven clothes HG-1B R. The produced materials were confirmed to show lower than 0.3 % of thermal contraction and higher than 15 GPa of compressive modulus as shown in Table 2. The producibility and reproducibility were confirmed. The developed high glass content GFRP was employed as insulating materials in large helical device(LHD). Table.2 Characteristics of developed GFRP at RT. Name Volume Type of Thermal Compressive Fraction(%) Cloth Contraction(%) Modulus(GPa) HG-1A R 71.5 Plain 0.29 18.7 __. 2.1 HG-1B R 71.5 Satin 0.31 18.4 4- 1.4
Compressive Strength(MPa). 710 __.9 761 __.4
BORON FREE GFRP Fusion superconducting magnets are 'series machines' in the sense that the complete magnet may decrease in overall performances when even one component does not deliver the expected performance, such magnets are often operated under severe conditions, such as radiation environments and those materials which are most prone to damage under such radiation environments demand particular attention. The component most sensitive to radiation damage in the fusion magnet is the organic composite material used for insulation[10], usually GFRP. Development of radiation resistant GFRPs, therefore, is very important for fusion magnets. Figure 7 shows the effects of irradiation on the interlaminar shear strength under three different conditions: (i) RT gamma irradiation - RT test; (ii) 25 K reactor irradiation - LNT test; and (iii) 360 K reactor irradiation RT test. To convert the neutron input into absorbed dose, the conversion factor of 1 Gy = 1015 n/m 2 was used when considering the neutron spectrum. When this conversion factor is used, the absorbed dose administered by neutron irradiation is estimated to be smaller by approximately one order of magnitude than that given by gamma irradiation in this case, and hence the absorbed dose contributed by neutron irradiation can be neglected. It was found (see Figure 7), however, that the effects of gamma irradiation were small compared with those of reactor irradiation. At the 10 MGy absorbed dose, the gamma irradiation causes only 17% decrease in interlaminar shear strength, compared to 65 and 83% degradation in 360 and 20 K reactor irradiation, respectively. This difference is caused by the different effects on neutron irradiation. Different effects were found between gamma and neutron irradiation as described above. This means that the neutron fluence could not be converted into absorbed dose in the usual way. The effects of neutrons has been neglected because the absorbed neutron dose is usually much smaller than the gamma dose. The data obtained here, however, suggest that the effect of neutron irradiation is larger than expected. The difference between gamma and neutron irradiation was assumed to be the neutron induced internal irradiation from boron in E-glass fibres. Boron is known to react with thermal neutrons. E-glass fibres contain 8 - 12% by weight of boron oxide and are thus an internal radioactive source ( 0t -particles). -
1
O
L/3 u3 ._J
0
,
!
5
1I
1
10 15 Dose (M Gy)
,
1
20
25
Fig.7 Change of interlaminar shear strength(ILSS) with irradiation dose. 9 Gamma irradiated at RT; C ) , neutron irradiated at RT, tested at RT; / ~ , neutron irradiated at 20 K, tested at LNT.
24
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
O
~~'n~I00 _ ~
"~ O...._
5
0
Dose
I0
(MGy)
Fig.8 Change of interlaminar shear strength induced by reactor irradiation on TGFRP(Q) and EGFRP(O) at 15K. The T-glass, which does not involve boron at all, was employed as reinforcement in radiation resistant GFRP. The epoxy matrix is cured using an aromatic amine which is thought to be radiation resistant.[11] If the assumption made above is correct, a radiation resistant composite could be developed. The degradation of interlaminar shear strength due to reactor irradiation is shown in Figure 8. The degradation in the TGFRP is considerably smaller than that in the EGFRP, as expected. The results mean that the boron free glass fibre should be preferable under a neutron environment. Boron free glass fibre has decided to use as the reinforcement of GFRP which will be used under neutron environments. ALFRP (ALUMINA FIBER REINFORCED PLASTICS) ALFRP shows its peculiar properties in thermal conductivity in parallel direction to fiber down to liquid helium temperature. Moreover, considering the specific modulus and the ratio of breaking stress to thermal conductivity, ALFRP are found to be suitable for cryogenic structural support members. Figure 9 shows the temperature dependency of the thermal conductivity in the fiber direction for four composite specimen and for 304 stainless steel from 300 K to 4.2 K. The thermal conductivities of composite materials are lower than that of 304 stainless steel throughout the temperature range and it is obvious that the thermal insulating ability of composites is superior to that of 304 stainless steel even though stainless steel has a relatively low thermal conductivity among the metals. '
E
10 -: 57 .
..,.-"4"
E
"
'
,i
....
0 Glass
o~
[] AI203
A A
'
A
j,J,
8
,Ao o
0.1
d
"
-
3
sic
-
'
~
A Carbon~
v
I
1.0
u Q5 -i2 ruo .,...
"' .... I
-
//
I,.,,.
.120.05 I--
-
7
5
10
50 100
Temperature , K
300
Fig.9 Temperature dependence of the thermal conductivity of ACMs in the fiber direction.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
25
In Fig.9, the thermal conductivity of composite in fiber direction depends on that of the fibers and temperature range. For example, the thermal conductivity of CFRP is about 4 times as much as that of GFRP at RT, but lower than that of GFRP below 40 K. Fig.9 shows that ALFRP has its advantage of low thermal conductivity throughout all temperature range. Based on the experimental results, an evaluation was made as to the performance of each material from the viewpoint of the structural members. The ordinate of Fig. 10 shows the specific modulus, and the abscissa demonstrates the ratio of average breaking stress to average thermal conductivity in the fiber direction, / ~ , between LNT and RT. A high a / ~ means durability against load with unit thermal penetration through the materials.[12] Consequently, larger values in both axes are desirable for support members. It is found that all the present ACMs are better structural materials than the 304 stainless steel. GFRP has high value of o"/~ and low specific modulus. CFRP has high specific modulus but small o"/ g conversely. It appears that SiC fiber reinforced plastics and ALFRP are well-balanced and suitable for structural materials in this temperature range. Figure 11 shows the performance of each ACM between LHeT and LNT. In this temperature range, ALFRP are also superior to GFRP or 304 stainless steel. It shows that the penetrating heat through ALFRP is about half as much as that through GFRP. Taking all into consideration, the choice of ALFRP as support materials should be desirable. In actual ALFRP has been used as the support member in superconducting magnet system such as levitation train. I
I
5O U
E
1
I ,Ik
Carbon
LHeT- LNT
~o
40
lad
" 3O
I/1
SiC ~7
t.D
Si C 19,
o
"o o
I
5O
%
Carbon
tt~
ea
1--
L N T - RT
A
N
o
,,,,,-
o A1203
O SS. 304
AI203 D
. 930 O S.S. 30/.,
"~ 2o
2O O Glass
. U~ o~ U
O Glass
52
t/3
0
! 1
..1 2
O/14..
GPamK/W
! 3
! I0
0
O'/'K
Fig.10 Specific modulus versus between LNT and RT.
,.,! 20
,
! 30
GPamK/W
Fig. 11 Specific modulus versus between LHeT and LNT.
3DFRP To develop the radiation resistant composites, three dimensional fabric reinforced plastics(3D FRP) are tested. The reactor irradiation was performed at the Low Temperature Irradiation Loop at Kyoto University Reactor Institute. The irradiation temperature was 20 K. The change of interlaminar shear strength(ILSS) after irradiation are shown in Fig. 12. -
/
AT
'
o 30 GFRP 92D GFRP
,
,,
LNT
- - -
t m
.J l
Ix
.
0
.
.
.
.
.
1
.
.
.
.
I0 OOSE ( NGy )
20
Fig. 12 Change of interlaminar shear strength(iLSS) induced by low temperature reactor irradiation.
26
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings I
R~ACTOR I RRAD.
E E
AT 20K
v
I o I00 z l,I.
[
o--
uJ
_3
_J
1[
so o 30- GFRP
_./
92D-GFRP
z
.\
TESTED AT LNT..
:z
0
1
5 D O S E (NGy)
Fig. 13 Effect of low temperature reactor irradiation on nominal flexural strength obtained at LNT. The ILSS test was performed at LNT without warming up to RT. The tensile shear test was carried out to obtain the ILSS. In this figure, the change of ILSS of the usual laminates reinforced glass fabric made of identical fiber and epoxy matrix is also presented as 2D-GFRP. The difference between the two is remarkable and the 3D-GFRP show less degradation of ILSS. It appears that the fibers in thickness direction in 3D-GFRP prevent the degradation of ILSS effectively. In Fig.13, the change of nominal flexural strength against dose is presented both on 2D-GFRP and 3DGFRP. The nominal flexural strength means the strength calculated by simple beam theory without considering the change of fracture mode due to the degradation of ILSS. The flexural tests were made on the specimen having the dimension of 4 mm in thickness and 5 mm in width with 40 mm span length. The specimen used in this test and the irradiation conditions were identical with the ones in Fig. 12. After the irradiation the flexural tests were performed at LNT without warming up to RT. The nominal flexural strength of conventional 2D-GFRP showed approximately 70% degradation at 8 MGy absorbed dose. On the other hand, that of 3D-GFRP was smaller than 20% and further more even the degraded strength was almost equal to that of 2D-GFRP before irradiation. The 3D-GFRP shows the radiation resistant characteristics compared with 2D-GFRP though all component materials are identical. This results strongly suggest the validity of our suggested degradation mechanism[13] and the rightfulness of the methodology developing the radiation resistant organic composites. CONCLUSIONS Several kinds of A CMs have been developed and the characteristics at cryogenic temperature were evaluated. Taking advantage of the characteristics the real application of the ACMs were examined. The ACMs were found to improve the performances of cryogenic machineries why they are used properly. Close collaboration between researchers and system designers is inevitable to develop the advanced cryogenic systems in the future. REFERENCES 1. Davis G. T., Eby R. K. and Colson J.P., ,I. Appl. Phys., (1970) 41 4316-4323 2. White G. K. and Choy C. L., J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Phys. Ed., (1984) 22 835-840 3. Govaert L. E., Brown B. and Smith P., Macromolecules~ (1992) 25 3480-3487 4. Choy C. L., Wong S. P. and Young K., J. Polvm. Sci. Polym. Phys. Ed., (1984) 22 979-988 5. Nakamura Y., Nagao A., Hiraki N. et. al., Proc. 11 th Int. Conf. Magn. Technol. (1989) 767-770 6. Tsuda Y., Toyoda K., Hirayama T. et. al., ibid, (1989) 789-792 7. Hattori Y., Yoshida K., Nakajima H. et. al., Proc. 9th Int. Conf. Magn. Technol. (1985) 371-374 8. Fukushi K., Nagai M., Kamata Y. et. al., "Nonmetallic materials and Composites at Low Temperature 3", Plenum Press, New York (1986) 9. Turck B. and Supra T., IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG25 (1989) 1473-1476 10. Okada T. and Nishijima S., Adv. Crx'og.. Eng.. (1988) 34 917-924 11. Nishiura T., Kamgiri K., Nakahara S. et. al., Adv. Cryo~. En~. (1988) 34 43-50 12. Kawate Y., Horiuchi T., Sonoi H. et. al., Crvo~. En~ Jap. (1979) 14 164-177 13. Nishijima S., Nishiura T. and Okada T., SMIRk' 11 qPrans, vol. L (1991) 307-312
122-Channel SQUID Neuromagnetometer for Studies of Information Processing in the Human Brain
Olli V. Lounasmaa Low Temperature Laboratory, Helsinki University of Technology, 02150 Espoo, Finland, and HahnMeitner-Institut, 14109 Berlin, Germany
Magnetoencephalography (MEG) is a completely non-invasive brain imaging technique, suitable for basic and clinical studies of human subjects. Time resolution of MEG is 0.5 ms and spatial accuracy 5 ... 6 mm. Large SQUID arrays, operating at liquid helium temperatures, are employed for detecting and localizing magnetically the active cortical regions modelled by current dipoles. Two recent experiments are described. Commercial multiSQUID instruments are now available from several manufacturers.
INTRODUCTION The human brain is, by far, the most complex instrument in existence. There are about 1011 neurons in the cerebral cortex. These nerve cells are the active units in a vast network, consisting on the order of 10 ~4 interconnections or synapses. This is more than in the world's entire telephone system. Activity of the brain involves small electric currents which flow in the neural network. These currents, in turn, generate tiny magnetic fields which can be measured outside the skull, using large arrays of sensitive SQUIDs. Magnetoencephalography (MEG) is a technique which has emerged to enable non-invasive utilization of the magnetic data in basic research and in clinical studies [ 1 - 5]. Time resolution of the MEG method is 0.5 ms and spatial accuracy 5 ... 6 mm under favorable conditions. Neuromagnetic fields are only 50 ... 500 fT in strength. It is, therefore, necessary to carry out the measurements in a magnetically shielded room, to use gradiometric flux transformers, and to employ signal averaging techniques. From the measured magnetic field distribution it is possible, by making suitable assumptions, to calculate backwards the cortical area which was activated by a sensory stimulus, such as a sound, a picture, or a touch. Spontaneous brain activity, like the 10-Hz a-rhythm and the 20and 40-Hz rhythms can be investigated as well.
EXPERIMENTAL ARRANGEMENTS The neuromagnetometer in the LTL of HUT is illustrated in Figs. 1 and 2 [6]. The instrument employs 122 planar, figure-of-eight flux transformers, located in pairs on 61 chips. This device records the entire magnetic field pattern at once. The vulnerability of the system to external magnetic noise can be reduced greatly by a gradiometric design of the superconducting flux transformers which gather the magnetic signal and transmit it to the SQUIDs. In addition, MEG measurements are carried out inside a magnetically shielded enclosures. In HUT the experimental room employs for noise reduction three layers of aluminum, which attenuate very effectively the high frequency band of the external magnetic disturbances, and three layers of mu-metal for rejection of noise at low frequencies. Magnetoencephalographic measurements were first made with one-SQUID systems, and the number of sensors increased only slowly. In the LTL, a pioneer in the field of multi-SQUID instrument construction, the sequence of development was 1 --~ 4 --~ 7 --~ 24 --~ 122 channels [3]. The latest version is now manufactured by Neuromag Ltd; this first whole-head-coveting MEG device has been in regular 27
28
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
use since September 1992. Its commercial version is illustrated in Fig. 3 [7]. A similar device is manufactured by CTF Systems Inc. of Vancouver [8]. Biomagnetic Technologies Inc. of San Diego will soon have a whole-head neuromagnetometer on the market as well [9]. A 250-channel system was under construction in Japan, but the project has been abandoned. A complete MEG installation, with a shielded room and computer software, costs US$ 2 - 3 million. Top plate \
Dual gradiometer unit
Neck plug Dewar Connector boards~
i
i
9Pl
Wiring unit
Gradiometer chips
Figure 1. MEG installation in HUT. The concave, helmet-shaped bottom of the helium dewar, with its 122 flux transformers and SQUIDs near its tip, is brought as close as possible to the subject's head. During actual experiments the double doors to the shielded room must be tightly closed. Figure 2. Schematic drawing of the neuromagnetometer in Fig. 1 [6]. The instrument employs 122 planar, figure-of-eight flux transformers, located in pairs on 61 chips. Each dual gradiometer unit records the orthogonal tangential derivatives c)Br/Oy and OBr/OX, respectively, of the magnetic field component Br normal to the dewar bottom. Planar figure-of-eight flux-transformer coils, 8 (white) and oo (black), couple strongest to currents directly underneath; the measured signal is thus maximal fight above the source. The two independent components of the magnetic field gradient measured at each site give both the magnitude and the direction of the current dipole.The distance between liquid helium in the dewar and the outer room temperature surface is 16 mm. In the prototype system, the flux transformer loops are connected to dc-SQUIDs fabricated by IBM. The company has loaned the sensors to HUT as part of an ongoing research program.
INTERPRETATION OF MEG DATA In interpreting MEG data, one is dealing with the electromagnetic inverse problem, i.e., with the calculation of the source currents in the brain which are responsible for the externally measured magnetic field. Hermann von Helmholtz already showed, about 140 years ago, that this problem has no unique solution. One must, therefore, use a suitable model to interpret the data. When the neural currents are confined to a small region in the cortex one may assume that the source, looking from the outside, is a current dipole. The magnitude, direction, and position of the active brain area can then be deduced unambiguously with a least-squares fit of the experimental data. Owing to spontaneous brain activity and incoherent 'noise', individual signals resulting from 30 to 500 successive sensory stimuli must be averaged. In this way the evoked response, for example after beeps of sound, emerges from the background. In order to collect enough data for calculating the magnetic field distribution, measurements must be made at many, typically at 30 to 60 different locations. In earlier MEG experiments this was done sequentially, over one or a few sites at a time.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
29
Figure 3. Commercial version of the Neuromag rM-122 instrument [7]. Three of these devices are in use in Japan, two in Germany, one in the US, and one in Finland.
SQUIDS Since the late 1960's, after the pioneering work by James Zimmerman, SQUIDs have been familiar devices in most low temperature laboratories. Multi-SQUID applications, however, have materialized only quite recently, owing to slow progress in fabrication technology. Today, reliable and stable thin-film Josephson junctions can be produced in large quantities and at reasonable cost. This Conference, for example, includes a fair number of papers on SQUIDs. To avoid the problems of wire-wound flux transformers, which are expensive to manufacture and have only a modest balance, planar integrated sensors offer an elegant solution (see Fig. 2). The main advantages of flat thin-film gradiometers are their compact structure and excellent dimensional precision. Figure 4 depicts a SQUID-system designed and fabricated by Prof. Heikki Seppa and his group at the Technical Research Centre of Finland [10]. The sensor is optimized for the frequency range between 0.1 and 1000 Hz, which is important for biomagnetic measurements. The white flux noise corresponds to an intrinsic energy resolution of 5h, where h is Planck's constant, the theoretical limit.
to Pick-up C0il
! []
Capacitor
SQUID I = un SQUID Sensor
m n
Nb Resistor Wire
SQUID 2 = hg SQUIDPreamplifier " ~ l mm
I I
Figure 4. Example of an advanced integrated sensor [ 10]. The un-SQUID (1), based on unshunted Josephson junctions, is monitored with the high gain hg-SQUID (2) which also provides damping at low frequencies. Both SQUIDs are resistively damped at high frequencies using capacitors in series with resistors. The rest of the circuitry is for damping the LC and microwave resonances created by the input coils and by the pick-up coil. The integrated heater is employed to free the chip from trapped flux. The un- and hg-SQUIDs both differ markedly from a conventional dc-SQUID: Owing to the reduced resistive damping the noise level is lower and the current-voltage characteristics differ from that of an ordinary dc-SQUID. The figure shows the layout for one channel; the 2 x 2 mm 2 chip includes four such units. The Josephson junction itself has an area of 5 x 5 lxm2. The illustration was prepared by Prof. Heikki Seppa.
30
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
The discovery of superconducting ceramic compounds, with critical temperatures above 77 K, has raised hopes for practical high-To SQUIDs; they would greatly simplify measurements in hospitals. Today the best single-channel high-Tc SQUIDs are approaching the noise performance of conventional 4K sensors. However, at the present time commercial multichannel systems working at 77 K are too expensive and, because of flux trapping problems, too difficult to use.
AIR PUFF EXPERIMENT Figure 5 shows somatosensory brain responses which resulted from air puffs to the back of the subjects fight hand [ 11 ]. One can clearly see how the active cortical region changes with time in the sequence A B ~ C ~ D while the air puff is analyzed by the brain. The hand area of the left primary somatosensory cortex (A) responds first, with opposite deflections at 32 and 65 ms after the stimulus onset, followed by the second somatosensory cortex at left (B, 85 ms) and at fight (C, 98 ms). An additional late response arises in the posterior parietal cortex (D, 108 ms). The data in Fig. 5 illustrates how the MEG method is capable of separating the four brain regions which became evoked as the result of air puffs. In a similar experiment, responses from individual fingers could be separated, for example.
48ms
B
A
100 ms
~ ~.~
0
I
@
l
~
~
~
~
[100 fT/cm 98 ms
0
0
C
48 ms
108 ms
Figure 5. Left: Somatosensory responses elicited by air puffs [11 ]. Two independent recordings are superimposed. The head is 'flattened' using the zenithal equidistant projection. The subject's nose is pointing up. Right: Enlarged magnetic field vs. time recordings and topographic field patterns on the head (A and B from the left side, C from fight, D from the back); the field emerges in the gray regions and enters the head in the white areas. The evoked locations of the brain are in the centers of the black arrows. The isocontours are separated by 40 fT.
SIGNAL PROCESSING DURING PICTURE NAMING Figure 6 illustrates results of a picture-naming experiment [ 12]. Drawings of common items were presented on a computer screen, seen through a hole in the wall of the shielded room. The subjects were instructed to pronounce, as soon as possible, the names of the objects shown. Normally 800 ... 900 ms were
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
31
needed, after the picture had been flashed on the computer screen, before the subject said its name. The magnetic responses were averaged and scanned over a period of 2 s to detect, by a least-squares analysis of the data, temporally and spatially separate active source areas. Up to 100 responses were needed to extract the task-related signals from other activity. The early response from the primary visual cortex at the back of the head (Source 1) was followed by more lateral posterior signals in the left and fight hemispheres (Sources 2 and 3), suggesting a contribution from Wernicke's area, which is important for understanding a language, and its fight-sided counterpart. At about the same time a left frontal site (Source 4), close to the cortical face representation area, showed activation, as in preparation for mouth movements. At 500 ms signals emerged from Broca's area (Source 5), which is known to be involved in vocalized word production, and from its homologue in the fight hemisphere (Source 6). These signals were immediately followed by activity at the top of the brain (Source 7), probably generated in the supplementary motor cortex which programs complex tasks such as articulation. Information processing in the brain during picture naming is beautifully demonstrated in the experimental sequence of Fig. 6. Only the MEG technique has sufficient spatial and temporal resolution to reveal the order of events.
41Xl
3 :':5
9sensory projection cortices
,,i
:'--~
'""
'
~
' ~ 1 ~t
picture
LI
7 J~j
peech
Yv,: 0
500 ms
Figure 6. Information processing in the brain during picture naming [ 12]. Fox explanations, see text. The locations of the primary visual (V), auditory (A), and somatosensory (S) cortices are marked by small squares. The cortical surfaces were generated from magnetic resonance images of the subject. The figure was prepared by Docent Riitta Salmelin.
COMPARISONS WITH OTHER IMAGING METHODS Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and positron emission tomography (PET) are well known, relatively novel methods of brain studies. MEG has two important advantages over MRI and PET: 1) The MEG method is completely non-invasive; high magnetic fields or radioactive marker substances are not needed; one only measures what comes out of the brain, spontaneously or as a result of natural stimuli. 2) Time resolution of MEG is 0.5 ms, many orders of magnitude better than what is obtainable with functional MRI or PET which depend on metabolic changes in cells. In comparison with electroencephalography (EEG), i.e., the measurement of scalp potentials, MEG has a better spatial resolution because the magnetic field is less affected by inhonogeneities in the head than electric potentials measured on the scalp. In EEG, accurate positioning of many electrodes is a time-consuming procedure. In MEG, the subject's head just has to be brought inside the helmet. An overview on the state-of-the-art in biomagnetism is well reflected in a recent conference proceedings [ 13].
32
ICECI 6/ICMC Proceedings
CONCLUDING REMARKS Eploration of the human brain is of utmost intellectual interest: The whole humanity depends on our minds. A great deal has been learned already about the cerebral anatomy and physiology, but the fundamental question of how the brain stores, retrieves, and processes information is still largely unknown. Neural computers, which handle data in a similar way as the brain does, are the future tools of designing and decision making. Recent developments in this new field of computing are one important source of inspiration to study the functional principles of the human brain, in addition to many interesting questions of basic and clinical neuroscience. PET and functional MRI do not have sufficient time resolution to investigate information processing in the brain. This is the field of neural research where MEG will have an important future, especially because whole-head-covering instruments are now commercially available. Clinical studies may also develop sufficiently to justify purchases of MEG equipment to major hospitals.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am indebted to Matti H~im~ilainen, Riitta Haft, Jukka Knuutila, Jyrki Makel~i, Riitta Salmelin, and Heikki Sepp~i for providing data, graphics, and/or comments on the manuscript. The work was financially supported by the Academy of Finland, by EU's Human Capital and Mobility Programme, and by the Alexander von Humboldt Stiftung. I also thank the IBM Company for successful collaboration, implemented through Prof. Claudia Tesche.
REFERENCES [1] [21 [31
[41 [51 [61
[7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [131
Williamson, S.J. and Kaufman, L., "Biomagnetism", Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials 22, 129- 139 (1981). Had, R. and Lounasmaa, O.V., "Recording and interpretation of cerebral magnetic fields", Science 244, 4 3 2 - 436 (1989). H~im~il~iinen, M., Had, R., Ilmoniemi, R.J., Knuutila, J., and Lounasmaa, O.V., "Magnetoencephalography- theory, instrumentation, and applications to non-invasive studies of the working human brain", Reviews of Modern Physics 65, 413 - 497 (1993). Wikswo, J.P., "SQUID magnetometers for biomagnetism and nondestructive testing: important questions and initial answers", IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity 5, 74 (1995). Lounasmaa, O.V., H~im~il~iinen, M., Had, R., and Salmelin, R., "Information processing in the human b r a i n - magnetoencephalographic approach", Proceedings of the US National Academy of Sciences (to be published in 1996). Ahonen, A.I., H~im~il~iinen, M.S., Kajola, M.J., Knuutila, J.E., Laine, P.P., Lounasmaa, O.V., Parkkonen, L.T., Simola, J.T., and Tesche, C.D., "122- SQUID instrument for investigating the magnetic signals from the human brain", Physica Scripta T49, 198- 205 (1993). Neuromag Ltd, P.O. Box 68,00511 Helsinki, Finland. CTF Systems Inc., 15-1750 McLean Avenue, Port Coquitlam, BC, Canada V3C 1M9. Biomagnetic Technologies Inc., 9729 Pacific Heights Boulevard, San Diego, CA 92121. Sepp~i, H. and Kiviranta, M., "DC SQUID based on unshunted Josephson junctions; experimental results", IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity 5, 3248- 3251 (1995). Forss, N., Salmelin, R., and Had, R., "Comparison of somatosensory evoked fields to airpuff and electrical stimuli", Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology 92, 5 1 0 - 517 (1994). Salmelin, R., Hari, R., Lounasmaa, O.V., and Sams, M., "Dynamics of brain activation during picture naming", Nature 368, 4 6 3 - 465 (1994). "Biomag96", Proceedings of 10th International Conference on Biomagnetism, University of New Mexico, February 1996 (to be published in 1996).
Advances in Cryocoolers Ray Radebaugh National Institute of Standards and Technology, Boulder, Colorado 80303, U.S.A.
Cryocooler problems such as poor reliability and high cost have limited the application areas for cryogenics. Recent advances in cryocoolers are beginning to alleviate some of these problems. Applications for such cryocoolers are presented and the requirements which these applications impose on the cryocoolers are reviewed. Most applications require improved reliability. For space applications the additional requirement of high efficiency is needed, whereas for commercial applications low cost is also a primary factor. Developments within the last 10 years to meet some of these requirements include the use of flexure and gas bearings to eliminate rubbing contact, pulse tube refrigerators to eliminate the moving displacer in Stirling and Gifford-McMahon refrigerators, the use of gas mixtures to improve efficiency of Joule-Thomson refrigerators and to allow the use of commercial compressors, the use of sorption compressors and thermoacoustic drivers to replace mechanical compressors and pressure oscillators, and the use of new high heat capacity materials to allow Gifford-McMahon and pulse tube refrigerators to reach temperatures below 4 K. A new cycle, known as the Boreas cycle, provides improved efficiency in small 4 K refrigerators and is also discussed. The status and future trends of these developments are presented.
INTRODUCTION New applications of cryocoolers are appearing, and the requirements for old applications are often undergoing changes. These new and changing cryocooler requirements have been the impetus for the recent developments in cryocoolers. The lack of a suitable cryocooler to meet the requirements of a particular application has hampered the advancement of many applications. For example, superconductivity most likely would be in widespread use now if it were not for the problems associated with the cryocoolers needed to cool the superconductors. The main problems associated with cryocoolers are: unreliability, inefficiency, size, weight, vibration, and cost. The seriousness of each of these problems depends on the application. Within the last 10 years satellite applications for cooled infrared sensors have become much more important. Obviously these applications require a cryocooler with very high reliability (5 to 10 year lifetimes and no maintenance), high efficiency, small size, low weight, and low vibration. A significant amount of cryocooler development in the last 10 years has been focused on space applications. Because only a few cryocoolers are needed for this application at this time, cost has not been a serious problem. However, both cost and unreliability have been the major problems for most commercial applications. The application areas for cryocoolers are discussed first and then the recent advances made in the various types of cryocoolers are described. APPLICATIONS AND REQUIREMENTS Table 1 lists the major applications for cryocoolers that are currently in use or have some potential for large impacts. A more complete list is given by Radebaugh [1 ]. For many years the largest application 33
34
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
for cryocoolers (>100,000 manufactured to date in U.S. for this application) has been for use by the military in cooling infrared sensors to about 80 K for tactical applications. Refrigeration powers range from about 0.25 W to about 2 W. Stirling cryocoolers, used primarily for this application in the last ten years, have been able to meet the requirements, but their mean-time-to-failure (MTTF) of about 4000 hours is far short of the requirement for satellite and most commercial applications. Most of the new developments on Stirling cryocoolers has been in techniques to improve reliability. The rapid growth of research and development on pulse tube refrigerators in the last 5 years has been because of its potential for improved reliability and lower cost. The largest commercial application of cryocoolers has been for cryopumps (currently -20,000/yr), which require a few watts of refrigeration at a temperature of about 15 K. Gifford-McMahon refrigerators have been used for this application. In the last year or two the vibration due to the moving displacer in the Gifford-McMahon refrigerator has become a problem in semiconductor fabrication as the circuit linewidths become narrower. A two-stage pulse tube refrigerator for such an application is now being studied at several laboratories.
9 Military 1. Infrared sensors for missile guidance 2. Infrared sensors for surveillance (satellite based) 9 Police and Security
1. Infrared sensors for night vision and rescue 9 Environmental
1. Infrared sensors for atmospheric studies of ozone hole and greenhouse effects 2. Infrared sensors for pollution monitoring 9 Commercial 1. Cryopumps for semiconductor fabrication 2. High temperature superconductors for cellular-phone base stations 3. Superconductors for voltage standards 4. Semiconductors for high speed computers 5. Infrared sensors for process monitoring 9 Medical 1. Cooling superconducting magnets for MRI systems 2. SQUID magnetometers for heart and brain studies 3. Liquefaction of oxygen for storage at hospitals and home use 4. Cryogenic catheters and cryosurgery 9 Transportation 1. LNG for fleet vehicles 2. Superconducting magnets in maglev trains 9 Energy 1. LNG for peak shaving 2. Infrared sensors for thermal loss measurements 3. Supercond. mag. energy storage for peak shaving and power conditioning 9 A g r i c u l t u r e and Biology
1. Storage of biological cells and specimens
Table 1. Applications of cryocoolers TYPES OF CRYOCOOLERS Figure 1 shows the schematics of the most common recuperative and regenerative cryocoolers. The recuperative types utilize a continuous flow of the refrigerant in one direction, analogous to a DC electrical system. As a result, the compressor and any expander must have inlet and outlet valves to control the flow direction, unless rotary or turbine compressors and expanders are used. The recuperative heat exchangers have two separate flow channels. In regenerative cycles the refrigerant undergoes an
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
35
oscillating flow and an oscillating pressure analogous to an AC electrical system. The compressor, or pressure oscillator, for the regenerative cycles needs no inlet or outlet valve. However, an oscillating pressure can be generated from a valved compressor by using another set of valves to switch between the high and low pressure sides of the compressor, as is done in the Gifford-McMahon refrigerator. The regenerator has only one flow channel, and the heat is stored for a half-cycle in the regenerator matrix, which must have a high heat capacity. Recent advances have occurred in all of these cryocooler types, which are discussed below. A new cryocooler type, known as the Boreas cryocooler [2], is a hybrid between a Gifford-McMahon and a Brayton cryocooler. Its use of recuperative heat exchange at low temperatures allows it to reach 4 K more efficiently than a pure regenerative cryocooler. JOULE-THOMSON CRYOCOOLERS Until recently closed-cycle Joule-Thomson cryocoolers have not been used in many applications because of low cycle efficiency and poor reliability of the compressor. Significant developments have occurred in the last few years regarding both of these problems, which have now brought this cycle from one of neglect to one of a serious contender for several applications. Plugging of the JT valve is still a persistent problem, but the use of self-regulating valves has eased the problem somewhat [3]. The Joule-Thomson cycle has an intrinsic inefficiency associated with the irreversible expansion in the JT valve or orifice. The efficiency of the expansion process becomes high only when the refrigerant is in the liquid or nearliquid state before passing through the JT valve, as in the vapor-compression cycle. The use of gas mixtures instead of pure nitrogen or argon gives rise to much greater enthalpy changes in the gas and a resulting improvement in the cycle efficiency, even at rather low pressures. An advantage of the JouleThomson cryocooler is the very low level of vibration because there are no moving parts or oscillating pressures in the cold head.
Mixed Refrigerants The use of mixed refrigerants in the Joule-Thomson cycle has a fairly long and somewhat obscure history. Missimer [4] and Radebaugh [1] review some of this history and discuss some recent trends regarding mixed refrigerants. Joule-Thomson refrigerators using mixed refrigerants can be divided into two categories: those with phase separators and those without phase separators. In 1959 Kleemenko [5] used phase separators in a single flow stream which consisted of a gas mixture for the liquefaction of natural gas. The best performance was obtained with a mixture of 65 mol% methane, 20 mol% ethane, and 15 mol% normal butane. This single flow cycle had an efficiency better than that with two flow streams. The single stream cycle is now known as the mixed refrigerant cascade (MRC) cycle and is commonly used for the liquefaction of natural gas. It is sometimes referred to as the auto-refrigerated cascade
RECUPERATIVE CYCLES
REGENERATIVE CYCLES i I
9
6h ,Th~
' 6~ Orifice
_.~Qht,~
i
d~c ,Tc t (a) Joule-Thomson
IReset.
I tP~ese
!enerator t-V% _
_
(b) Brayton
(c) Stirling
Figure 1. Schematics of five common cryocooler types.
(d) Pulse Tube (e) Gifford-McMahon
36
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
(ARC) or the Kleemenko cycle. It can provide cooling at any number of stages through the use of phase separators and expansion valves. The phase separators allow only the liquid phase to be expanded at each stage, thus maintaining a high efficiency in the expansion process. The phase separators also are useful in reducing the amount of impurities, like water and oil, that are passed on to lower temperatures. In 1972 Missimer [6] used this same cycle with the addition of flow restrictions for added stability, but he replaced most of the hydrocarbons in the gas mixtures with CFCs and used oil lubricated air conditioning compressors for the cycle (known as the Polycold cycle) to provide about 300 W of refrigeration at 140 K. Recently the CFCs in this cycle have been replaced with non-CFCs. The Polycold cycle has been widely used for cold-trapping water vapor in vacuum systems. Little and Sapozhnikov [7] discuss progress on the use of the MRC or Kleemenko cycle for the cooling of CMOS multichip modules and other semiconductor electronic devices. They used a small domestic refrigerator unit with an appropriate multicomponent refrigerant and a single phase separator. They report success in maintaining temperatures down to 120 K for over 1000 hours before observing partial clogging due to oil carryover. Further work on gas mixtures and phase separators should lead to longer running times before clogging occurs. In 1969 Fuderer and Andrija [8] were granted a German patent on a mixed refrigerant cycle in which there were no phase separators or intermediate expansion valves. The entire mixed refrigerant was cooled in the heat exchanger at which point it became 100% liquid before expanding through the orifice. This cycle is useful for applications where there is little need for refrigeration at intermediate temperatures. Temperatures down to 103 K were obtained by Fuderer and Andrija using a gas mixture of equimolar amounts of nitrogen, methane, ethane and propane and a 40:1 pressure ratio. They pointed out that because the mixture is in the two phase region in the heat exchanger, much greater heat transfer coefficients are possible compared with pure gas streams. In 1973 Alfeev et al. [9] from the Soviet Union used a similar mixture (30 mol% nitrogen, 30 mol% methane, 20 mol% ethane, 20 mol% propane) to achieve a temperature of 78 K using a 50"1 pressure ratio. The system efficiency was 10 to 12 times better than for pure nitrogen. Temperatures below 70 K were reached by adding neon, hydrogen or helium to the mixture. The application was for cooling infrared sensors to about 80 K, and there was no need for any significant cooling at intermediate temperatures. Even though methane, ethane, and propane have individual freezing points in the range of 85 to 90 K, some mixtures of these fluids have freezing points at least as low as 70 K [ 10]. Little [ 11] reviewed the Soviet work and discussed further advances with gas mixtures. In 1994 Longsworth [12, 13] described a closed-cycle system using a commercially available oillubricated compressor (rolling-piston type) with a gas mixture of 36 mol% nitrogen, 20 mol% methane, 12 mol% ethylene, 20 mol% propane, and 12 mol% isobutane to obtain 1 W of cooling at 80 K and 10 W at 93 K with a high pressure of about 2 MPa. Compressor input power was about 350 to 400 W. At 80 K the maximum COP for the ideal JT cycle using the gas mixture described by Longsworth is about 50% of the Camot COP. Further studies of optimum mixtures and of heat transfer in multicomponent, two-phase mixtures are needed to increase efficiency and to reduce the pressure needed to reach 80 K. When no phase separators are used, the solubility of oil in the refrigerant at low temperatures must remain fairly high. The use of hydrocarbons in the mixture helps to ensure a relatively high oil solubility. At present there is little published information on the solubility of oil in mixed refrigerants at low temperatures. Sorption Compressors In an effort to eliminate the only moving part in the Joule-Thomson cycle and improve the reliability of this cycle, the mechanical compressor has been replaced by sorption compressors in many recent studies. The sorption compressors also eliminate any vibration. Alternate heating and cooling of the sorption compressors cause a circulation of the refrigerant. This subject has been reviewed recently by Wade [ 14]. The only moving parts in the sorption compressors are check valves which operate once every few minutes to cause steady flow in one direction. Unfortunately, the sorption compressors have only been used with pure gases, which limits their efficiency unless many stages are used. Sorption of mixed gases may be possible, in principle, if the selective nature of sorption can be overcome. Chemisorption of hydrogen with hydrides (e.g., V and LaNis) and oxygen with praseodymium cerium oxide (PCO) can be done with the compressors operating at 300 K or even higher. Most other gases require the use of physisorption on microporous carbon. Low boiling point gases are difficult to adsorb at 300 K, so
ICECI 6/ICMC Proceedings physisorption compressors are generally limited to systems with cold temperatures above about 120 K. Alvarez et al. [15] discuss progress on an advanced sorption compressor system to reach 125 K using krypton with a xenon precooling stage at 170 K. They expect to achieve specific power inputs of 40 W/W at 125 K with a rejection temperature of 260 K. High efficiency in sorption coolers is only possible with the use of regenerative heating of the sorbent bed in which heat from one compressor module in a cool-down state is used to heat another compressor module in a warm-up state. Several modules are needed for high efficiency [16]. For temperatures down to about 65 K, Bard and Jones [17] proposed the use of a PCO compressor for an oxygen stage precooled with krypton and xenon stages using physisorption compressors. Specific powers of 50 W/W have been predicted for cooling to 65 K when using regenerative configurations [14]. Johnson and Jones [18] proposed the use of hydride beds pumping on solid hydrogen to reach temperatures down to 10 K in a periodic mode. A prototype space flight experiment (Brilliant Eyes TenKelvin Sorption Cryocooler Experiment or BETSCE) of this concept has been developed and ground tested [ 19] and flown on the Space Shuttle in May 1996. During the ground tests a heat load of 100 mW was maintained at 9.5 K for over 20 minutes and the system could be recycled in under 5.5 hours. In this experiment Stifling cryocoolers were used to precool the hydrogen to about 65 K. BRAYTON CRYOCOOLERS The use of an expansion engine to carry out a reversible expansion of the gas as shown in Fig. 1(b) leads to higher efficiencies than are possible with Joule-Thomson cryocoolers. Most Brayton cryocoolers use turboexpanders with gas bearings to provide high reliability and very low vibration. The turboexpanders are very efficient in large sizes and are used in large liquefaction plants. For small cryocoolers the challenge is in fabricating the small turboexpanders and maintaining a high expansion efficiency. Recent advances in Brayton cryocoolers pertain to their miniaturization. Swirl [20] discussed the latest developments in a single stage turbo-Brayton cryocooler designed to provide 5 W of cooling at 65 K. Turbomachines with gas bearings are used for both the compressor and the expander. The working fluid is neon with an inlet pressure of 0.11 MPa and a pressure ratio of 1.6. A specific power of 43 W/W was obtained with the engineering model Brayton cryocooler. With a cold temperature of 65 K and a reject temperature of 280 K, the Camot efficiency is 7.7%. Though the turbomachines are very small (15 mm diameter compressor impeller and 3.2 mm diameter expander rotor), the slotted-disk heat exchanger is quite large (90 mm diameter by 533 mm in length). The total system mass is 11.9 kg, with the heat exchanger comprising 52% of the total mass. The high cost of miniature turbo-Brayton cryocoolers generally limits their use to space applications in which high reliability, high efficiency, and very low vibration are needed. An even smaller turbo-Brayton cryocooler is now being developed by McCormick et al. [21]. Their goal is to provide 2 W of refrigeration at about 65 K with less than 100 W of input power. STIRLING CRYOCOOLERS Most of the recent developments in Stirling cryocoolers have involved methods to improve reliability. Linear motor drives have replaced rotary motor drives in most applications because they eliminate many moving parts and reduce side forces between the piston and cylinder. Lifetimes of about 4000 hours are now routine for linear compressors with dry rubbing contact. Recent work by Pruitt [22] showed lifetimes in excess of 15,000 hours in linear compressors with rubbing contact. Wearout times of 3 years may be possible in some cases using improved materials for the rubbing contact. Such lifetimes may be sufficient for many commercial applications. The 5- to 10-year lifetimes needed for satellite applications as well as for some commercial applications can only be achieved when all rubbing contact is eliminated. Non-rubbing operation is achieved with piston devices by using flexure, gas, or magnetic bearings, or with diaphragm devices in which a flexing diaphragm causes compression and expansion of the working gas. Magnetic bearings are no longer being used in Stifling cryocoolers and will not be discussed further. Efficiencies for the conversion of electrical power to PV power have been as high as 85% in these linear compressors when operating at resonant frequencies. Vibration caused by the reciprocating motion is reduced by using dual opposed pistons, a passive
37
38
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
balancer, or an active balancer. Vibration forces of about 1 N are typical in such cryocoolers that have input powers of the order of 100 W. Significant advances have been made in further vibration suppression in flexure-bearing cryocoolers by using active harmonic nulling with dual opposed pistons [23]. Axial vibration forces are often reduced to less than 0.1 N with this technique, though radial vibration forces remain unchanged at about 1 N [24]. Flexure Bearings The most common technique for eliminating rubbing contact uses flexure bearings to support the piston and displacer inside their corresponding cylinders without any contact. A clearance gap of 10 to 20 lam provides the necessary flow impedance to serve as a dynamic seal. Figure 2a shows a simplified crosssection of a typical Stirling compressor with flexure bearings. A similar arrangement is used to support the displacer. In practice most compressors use two opposed pistons to eliminate most of the vibration. The flexure bearings provide a stiff support in the radial direction and act as a weak spring in the axial direction. The spiral geometry shown in the upper part of Fig. 2b is the geometry originally used by Davy of the University of Oxford in the early 1980s. Davy [25] reviews the development of these Oxford-style cryocoolers, which are now manufactured for space applications by several companies. The lower part of Fig. 2b shows a new flexure geometry proposed by Wong et al. [26] that offers a higher radial stiffness and less arm vibration than that of the spiral design. Gas Bearings Gas bearings have also been investigated for the elimination of rubbing contact between piston and cylinder. Work in France has focused on the use of hydrodynamic gas bearings, first in a Vuillemier cryocooler for space applications [27] and more recently in a two-stage Stirling cryocooler [28]. The linear motor used moving magnets and the rotation to drive the gas bearing was provided with a brushless motor. A rotational frequency of 5 to 10 Hz was used to provide the gas bearing effect in a 10 lam gap. A reciprocating frequency of about 35 Hz was used. Hydrostatic gas bearings have been used in the U. S. for a Stirling cryocooler [29]. The gas flow for the bearing is driven by the oscillating pressure in the working space through a one-way valve (port
Spiral flexure bearing To coldhead~' Clearance~ gap ~ ~ / ' / / / / ~ ~
earing
~V//,/.///~ r ~ ~ ~1~~ ~ ~
XINIX
Permanent magnet St
Position
I~~:~ ~ sensor
Moving spider Linear flexure bearing Figure 2.
a b (a) Cross-section of the Oxford-style linear compressor showing the use of flexure bearings. (b) Two types of flexure bearings.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
39
alignment between piston and cylinder could also be used to provide one-way flow) and flow restriction. An oscillating frequency of 60 Hz was used for this cooler. Diaphragm Compressors and Expanders A Ti-6AI-4V diaphragm with a flexible outer ring (similar to loudspeaker construction) has been used in both the compressor and expander assemblies of a single-stage 65 K Stirling cryocooler [30] and in a two-stage 30 K Stirling cryocooler [31 ]. This construction eliminates the need for clearance gaps and precise alignment. Such diaphragm devices tend to have short strokes and large diameters. The diaphragms were made double acting, which meant that the regenerator also functioned as a recuperative heat exchanger between the gas flowing in opposite directions in the two separate systems. PULSE TUBE CRYOCOOLERS The three main types of pulse tube refrigerators as discussed by Radebaugh et al. [32] are the basic, resonant (or thermoacoustic), and orifice. The orifice pulse tube refrigerator (OPTR) is the only one which achieves cryogenic temperatures (T<120 K) and is the only one considered in this review. Many versions of the OPTR now exist with various orifices or valves. Because the OPTR has no moving parts at the cold end, it has the following advantages over the Stirling cryocooler: (a) more reliable, (b) lower cost, (c) lower vibration, (d) lower EMI, (e) less sensitive to side loads, and (f) better launch survivability. However, until the last few years, its efficiency was much less than that of the Stirling refrigerator. The OPTR operates with an oscillating pressure, which can be provided with a compressor like that of the Stirling refrigerator or with a Gifford-McMahon compressor and valves, with a sacrifice in efficiency. When using a Gifford-McMahon compressor the primary orifice and reservoir can be replaced by a set of switching valves connected to the compressor[33]. The OPTR operates on a cycle similar to the Stirling cycle except the proper phasing between mass flow and pressure is established by the passive orifice or switching valves instead of the moving displacer. The pulse tube provides a buffer volume of gas to maintain a temperature gradient between the hot and cold ends of the pulse tube. Any mixing within the buffer volume introduces a heat load on the cold end. The analytical model developed at NIST in the late 1980s [34] for the OPTR solved the conservation of mass and energy equations with the assumption of simple harmonic pressure, mass flow, and temperature oscillations within the entire pulse tube refrigerator. That model also assumed adiabatic processes occurred within the pulse tube. Recent thermoacoustic theories [35-37] also use a harmonic approximation, but they include a linear approximation with higher harmonics and realistic heat transfer and viscous effects between the gas and tube walls. The non-adiabatic effects generally account for only a few percent loss in refrigeration power compared with the adiabatic model, unless the tube size is quite small. Other losses inherent in these models appear to result in a time-averaged enthalpy flow within the pulse tube that is about 70 to 80% of the ideal value [36, 37]. Improved Efficiencies Because the expansion work is dissipated in the orifice instead of being recovered as in the Stirling cryocooler, the efficiency of an ideal OPTR compared with Carnot is given by
q,<,~<,, :
( T h- T )ITh .
(1)
Kittel [38] discusses this derivation. For Tc = 75 K and Th = 300 K, ]]ideal-- 75%, whereas for Tc = 250 K, Tlideal 17%. Thus, for cryogenic temperatures, practical inefficiencies dominate the intrinsic orifice inefficiency, but, for near-ambient temperatures, the intrinsic inefficiency severely limits the O P T R efficiency. The maximum possible COP for the OPTR is 1 when T~ = Th. At the time of the latest review of pulse tube refrigerators in 1990 [34], efficiencies of the OPTR were still several times less than that of Stirling refrigerators. Since 1990 several advances have been made in pulse tube refrigerators which have allowed them to achieve efficiencies nearly as high as that of Stirling refrigerators. A large OPTR constructed at NIST in 1991 produced 31.1 W of refrigeration at 80 K with a PV power input of 602 W at a rejection temperature of 316 K. The relative Carnot efficiency was 15.3% for PV work and 13% for electrical input power if the compressor were 85% efficient (typical of recent linear compressors). The average operating pressure was 2.5 MPa, and the ~-
40
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
frequency was 4.5 Hz. Improved efficiencies at higher operating frequencies were made possible by the introduction of the double inlet concept in 1990 by Zhu et al. [39]. They added a second orifice (often referred to as the secondary orifice or bypass orifice), as shown in Figure 3. (The intermediate orifice in this figure is discussed in the section on multiple stages.) With this orifice the gas flow needed to compress and expand the gas at the warm end of the pulse tube is taken directly from the compressor instead of passing through the regenerator and pulse tube. The reduced mass flow through the regenerator reduces the regenerator loss, particularly at high frequencies where the regenerator loss becomes quite large. A very efficient miniature pulse tube using the double inlet concept was reported by Chan et al. [40] in 1993. Their integral, inline pulse tube cryocooler operated at a frequency of 55 Hz and produced 0.53 W of cooling at 80 K with a compressor input power of 17.8 W and a reject temperature of 287 K (7.7% Camot). Recent research on high frequency OPTRs of sufficiently large size (larger than a few watts of gross cooling power) have shown that the inertia of the oscillating gas in a long tube (either the pulse tube [41 ], or the connecting tube between the pulse tube and the reservoir [42]), can be used to provide significant phase shifts between pressure and mass flow. The inertia produces a pressure component in phase with the acceleration of the gas. Because this pressure component leads the mass flow by 90 ~ it provides a beneficial phase shift between the pressure and the mass flow (pressure leading mass flow) like that produced by the secondary orifice but without the disadvantage of additional lost work and the potential for DC flow. The resistive component of the flow impedance in the long connecting tube (inertance tube in Fig. 3) can be made large enough, if desired, to eliminate the discrete primary orifice. In an optimally designed inertance tube the inertance (inductive) component of flow impedance is larger than that of the compliance (capacitance) component, so the pressure can be made to lead the mass flow at the warm end of the pulse tube. For gross cooling powers of a few hundred watts in a 45 Hz pulse tube, phase shifts in the inertance tube are large enough to eliminate the need for any secondary orifice. Also, with large, high frequency OPTRs the mechanical driver can be replaced with a thermoacoustic driver (TAD) to produce cryogenic refrigeration with no moving parts[I,43]. A temperature of 90 K has been achieved with such a device, known as a TADOPTR. A comparison of efficiencies for pulse tube refrigerators with Stifling refrigerators is shown in Fig. 4. The shaded band represents the efficiency range for most of the recent Stifling refrigerators. The circles in Fig. 4 show the efficiency of recent pulse tube cryocoolers which have achieved high efficiency. The highest power and highest efficiency pulse tube refrigerator is the NIST OPTR previously discussed. The lowest power OPTR is the miniature one by Chan et al. [40]. The two mid-size OPTRs are the same device, but with different input powers and different cold end temperatures [44]. Fig. 4 shows that the efficiencies of the latest pulse tube cryocoolers is almost as high as the best Stifling cryocoolers of a comparable size. Because of their high efficiency as well as many advantages over Stirling refrigerators, pulse tube refrigerators have been selected to cool the Atmospheric Infrared Sounder (AIRS), an important instrument used for the Earth Observing System (EOS) satellites in the study of the ozone hole and greenhouse effects.
Aftercooler Intermediateorifice Compressor / ................ ! . ~ l r'~
-_
i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i: "_~----:.:.:.:.:.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'.','.'.:.:.:.:.:
F!i!i!i!Regenerator i; :i:i:i:::
./
Primary_ _ ~
Pulse tube
~ 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1. 7. 6 1. 7. 6 .1 7. 6 .1 7. 6 .1 7. 6 .1 7. 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6 1 7 6
i!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
Cold Hx Figure 3.
Hot/ Hx Inertancetube Reservoir
Secondary orifice
Schematic of the double inlet pulse tube refrigerator in which a secondary orifice is used. The multi-inlet concept for staging and the inertance tube are also shown.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings Multiole Stages 25 For temperatures below about 80 K, two or more stages are normally used to maintain high efficiency. Two methods ~ 20 zx 3, ~ S t i f l i n g ~ J exist for the staging arrangement with pulse tube refrigerators. The first uses "6 15 a separate pulse tube and regenerator for each stage with the warm end of each pulse tube at ambient temperature ~ 10 (parallel arrangement). If the pulse tube ,,z, losses are too great for the second and -_o lower stages, then their warm ends can ft. be thermally anchored to the cold end of ~ 5 the next higher stage (series arrangement). These two arrangements, J I J I~llml I I I JllJ~l I J I l llJll I I , l l,:l o or a combination of the two, lead to the lO 0 101 102 103 104 use of many pulse tubes, which may be COMPRESSOR INPUT POWER (W) cumbersome. Figure 4. Efficiency of pulse tube refrigerators A new orifice arrangement, used by compared with that of Stirling refrigerators. Zhou and Han in 1992 [45] and called a multi-inlet pulse tube, is in fact a new technique for staging. This arrangement, as shown in Fig. 3 and known as the multi-inlet arrangement, uses a middle or intermediate orifice to allow a portion of the gas to enter the pulse tube at an intermediate temperature, thereby producing refrigeration at that location. This staging arrangement maintains the simple geometry of a single pulse tube. Zhou and Han showed that the use of this intermediate orifice lowered the cold end temperature from 59 K to 33 K. The lowest temperature achieved with a pulse tube refrigerator (PTR) was 3.6 K by Matsubara and Gao in 1994 [46] using a three-stage parallel arrangement. A low temperature of 2.07 K was just achieved by Thummes, et al. [47] with a two stage PTR precooled with liquid nitrogen. Some laboratories are now reaching 15 K with two stage PTRs [48]. These two stage PTRs have the potential of replacing the two stage Gifford-McMahon refrigerator in cryopump applications. Most of the two and three stage PTRs operate at about 2 Hz with switching valves and a Gifford-McMahon compressor. The reservoir volume is replaced with another switching valve connected to the compressor [33]. _
-
GIFFORD-McMAHON (GM) CRYOCOOLERS Gifford-McMahon (GM) cryocoolers use oil-lubricated compressors made by the millions for the air conditioning industry. Even though they are modified for use with helium gas, their cost is quite low. The oil removal equipment is placed in the high pressure line ahead of the switching valve that generates the oscillating pressure. These cryocoolers are most commonly used in two-stage 15 K versions for cryopumps primarily for semiconductor fabrication. This is the largest commercial application of cryocoolers. The GM cryocooler is also used for cooling shields to 10 to 15 K in MRI systems to reduce the boiloff rate of liquid helium or for direct cooling of Nb3Sn superconducting magnets to 10 K. Most of the recent developments in GM cryocoolers have involved the use of high heat capacity regenerator materials to reach temperatures below 5 K without the aid of a Joule-Thomson stage. Rareearth materials which undergo magnetic transitions in the 5-20 K range are generally used for these new regenerators. With Pb spheres replaced by Er3Ni spheres in the second stage, Kuriyama, et aL[49] achieved a minimum temperature of 4.5 K with a two stage GM cryocooler in 1989. In the same year Nagao et al.[50] reach 3.3 K in a three stage GM cryocooler using crushed GdxErl_xRh powder. The development in Japan of the technique [51 ] to produce high quality spheres of many different rare-earth materials greatly aided the advancement of 4 K GM refrigerators. The lower porosity of 38% which spheres yield compared with about 50% for crushed powder decreases the regenerator loss at these low temperatures. Many different rare earth materials have been used in GM refrigerators since 1990. An excellent review of these materials and their applications is given by Hashimoto et al. [52]. Refrigeration
41
42
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
powers above 1 W at 4.2 K were first produced in 1993 by using two different materials in the second stage regenerator [53]. The highest efficiency, obtained with ErNi0.gCo0.1 spheres in the second stage, produced 1.6 W of refrigeration at 4.2 K with 7.1 kW of input power, or 1.6% of Camot [54]. To date 2.2 W of refrigeration at 4.2 K is the most refrigeration produced by a GM cryocooler [55]. If a Joule-Thomson (JT) stage is added to the cold end of a GM cryocooler, much higher efficiencies are possible, but with higher cost and a sacrifice in reliability due to clogging of the JT valve. The highest efficiency for a combined GM/JT cryocooler at 4.5 K was reported by Fujimoto, et al.[56] where they produced 8.3 W at 4.4 K using 7.9 kW input, or 7.1% of Carnot. BOREAS CRYOCOOLERS The Boreas cryocooler was developed in the late 1980s specifically to fill the need for a small and efficient cryocooler for 4.2 K operation [2]. This cryocooler is a hybrid utilizing a three-stage GM cryocooler in which most of the fluid in the last stage, after expanding from 2 MPa to nearly atmospheric pressure, passes through a cold exhaust valve and returns through an outer concentric tube heat exchanger back to the compressor inlet. The returning cold gas precools the incoming steady flow of gas in the annular gap between the displacer and tube wall. Regenerative heat exchange in the gap also takes place simultaneously involving the oscillating component of gas flow. The gap regenerator is sufficient for precooling the gas to about 20 K, but for the last stage the recuperative heat exchanger dominates the overall heat transfer. The use of the recuperative heat exchanger removes the need for high heat capacity matrix materials like those used in a 4 K GM cryocooler. Because the expanded one atmosphere gas returns in a separate flow channel, this channel can be optimized for flow at one atmosphere to provide only a small pressure drop. The combination of using recuperative heat exchange at the low temperature end and the high pressure ratio (about 20:1) gives this cryocooler a higher efficiency than the GM cryocooler. For 1.1 W refrigeration at 4.2 K the input power is 2.9 kW, or 2.7% of Carnot. By contrast, the most efficient GM cryocooler has an efficiency of 1.6% of Carnot [54]. However, the Boreas cryocooler is not as efficient as the GM/JT cryocooler, which has an efficiency of 7.1% of Carnot [56]. The disadvantages of the Boreas cryocooler are the use of the moving cold exhaust valve in which there is little lifetime experience and the low refrigeration power at the upper stages caused by the use of a gap regenerator. Currently a smaller (0.25 W at 4.2 K) model is being developed which should have an input power of less than 1.5 kW and be air cooled. Potential application areas would be cooling of MRI magnets for the larger unit and the cooling of superconducting electronics for the smaller unit. REFERENCES
,
~
~
o
,
,
9. 10.
R. Radebaugh, Recent Developments in Cryocoolers, Proc. 19th International Congress of Refrigeration, (1995), p. 973. J. A. Crunkleton, A New Configuration for Small-Capacity Liquid-Helium-Temperature Cryocoolers, Proc. 7th Int'l Cryocooler Conf., A.F. Report PL-CP--93-1001 (1993) p. 187. W. Prentice, G. Walker, and S. G. Zylstra, Recent developments in clog resistant and demand flow cryostats, Proc. 6th Int'l Cryocooler Conf., Navy Report DTRC-91/002 (1991) p. 257. D. J. Missimer, Auto-refrigerating Cascade (ARC) Systems - an overview, Tenth Intersociety Cryogenic Symposium, AIChE Spring National Meeting (March, 1994). A. P. Kleemenko, One flow cascade cycle (in schemes of natural gas liquefaction and separation), 10th Int'l Congress of Refrigeration (1959), Pergamon Press, London, p. 34. D. J. Missimer, Mechanical system can reach -140 C, Research/Development, July 1972, p.40; Self balancing, low temperature refrigeration system, U.S. Patent 3,768,273 (1973). W. A. Little and I Sapozhnikov, Low Cost Cryocoolers for Electronics, Cryocoolers 9, Plenum Press, NY, to be published. M. Fuderer and A. Andrija, Verfahren zur Tiefkfihlung, German Patent 1426956 (1969). V. N. Alfeev, V. M. Brodyanski, V.M. Yagodin, V. A. Nikolsky, and A. V. Ivantsov, Refrigerant for a cryogenic throttling unit, UK Patent 1,336,892 (1973). L. B. Robinson, Phase equilibria in cryogenic mixtures" Part II, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 559.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
16. 17. 18. 19. 20.
21. 22. 23.
24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
31. 32.
33.
34.
W. A. Little, Advances in Joule-Thomson cooling, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 35, Plenum Press, New York (1990) p. 1305. R. C. Longsworth, Cryogenic refrigerator with single stage compressor, U.S. Patent 5,337,572 (1994). R. C. Longsworth, M. J. Boiarski, and L. A. Klusmier, 80 K closed-cycle throttle refrigerator, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 537. L. A. Wade, An overview of the development of sorption refrigeration, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 37, Plenum Press, New York (1992) p. 1095. J. A. Alvarez, R. J. Krylo, R. D. Snapp, C. Weston, P. Sywulka, and G. C. Abell, Development of an advanced sorption compressor and its application in a 125 K cryocooler, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 569. S. Bard and J. A. Jones, Regenerative sorption compressors for cryogenic refrigeration, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 35, Plenum Press, New York (1990) p. 1357. S. Bard and J. Jones, Development and testing of an 80 K oxide sorption cryocooler, Proc. 5th Int'l Cryocooler Conf. (1988)p. 13. A. L. Johnson and J. A. Jones, Evolution of the 10 K periodic sorption refrigerator concept, Proc. 7th Int'l Cryocooler Conf., Air Force Report PL-CP--93-1001 (1993) p. 831. S. Bard, J. Wu, P. Karlmann, P. Cowgill, C. Mirate, and J. Rodriguez, Ground testing of a 10 K sorption cryocooler flight experiment (BETSCE), Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 609. W. L. Swift, Single-stage reverse Brayton cryocooler: Performance of the engineering model, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 499; W. L. Swift and H. Sixsmith, Performance of a long life reverse Brayton cryocooler, Proc. 7th Int'l Cryocooler Conf., Air Force Report PL-CP-93-1001 (1993) p. 84. J. A. McCormick, W. L. Swift, and H. Sixsmith, Miniaturization of components for low capacity reverse Brayton cryocoolers, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, N u (1995) p. 507. G. R. Pruitt, Hughes long-life linear Stirlings: A status report, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 113. B. G. Johnson, D. B. Eisenhauer, F. J. Flynn, D. L. Johnson, and R. G. Ross, Jr, Demonstration of active vibration reduction on a Stirling-cycle cryocooler testbed, Proc. 7th Int'l Cryocooler Conf., Air Force Report PL-CP--93-1001 (1993) p. 820. G. R. Mon, G. T. Smedley, D. L. Johnson, and R. G. Ross, Jr., Vibration characteristics of Stirling cycle cryocoolers for space applications, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 197. G. Davey, Review of the Oxford cryocooler, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 35, Plenum Press, New York (1990) p. 1423. T. E. Wong, R. B. Pan, and A. L. Johnson, Novel linear flexure bearing, Proc. 7th Int'l Cryocooler Conf., Air Force Report PL-CP--93-1001 (1993) p. 675. A. Ravex, G. Claudet, and P. Rolland, A Vuillemier refrigerator for long-life spaceborne applications, Proc. 13th Int'l Cryogenic Engineering Conf., Cryogenics vol. 30, (1990) p. 277. L. Duband, A. Ravex, and P. Rolland, Development of a Stirling cryocooler using hydrodynamic gas bearings, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 47. G. T. Smedley, R. G. Ross, Jr., and D. M. Berchowitz, Performance characterization of the Sunpower Cryocooler, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 149. D. Stacy, J. McCormick, and J. Valenzuela, Development and demonstration of a diaphragm Stirling 65 K Standard Spacecraft Cryocooler, Proc. 7th Int'l Cryocooler Conf., Air Force Report PL-CP--93-1001 (1993) p. 40. W. D. Stacy, W. R. Baschnagel, and D. B. Lussier, 30 K diaphragm Stirling cryocooler demonstration, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 103. R. Radebaugh, J. Zimmerman, D. R. Smith, and B. Louie, A comparison of three types of pulse tube refrigerators: New methods for reaching 60 K, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 31, Plenum Press, New York (1986) p. 779. Y. Matsubara, K. Tanida, J. L. Gao, Y. Hiresaki, and M. Kaneko, Four-valve pulse tube refrigerator, Proc. 4th Joint Sino-Japanese Seminar on Cryocoolers and Concerned Topics, Chinese Academy of Sciences (1993) p. 54. R. Radebaugh, A review of pulse tube refrigeration, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 35,
43
44 35. 36.
37.
38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46.
47. 48. 49.
50.
51.
52. 53.
54.
55. 56.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings Plenum Press, New York (1990) p. 1191. G. W. Swift, Thermoacoustic engines, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 84, 1145 (1988). A. Tominaga, Basic notion of thermoacoustic theory and some results of simulations, Proc. 4th Joint Sino-Japanese Seminar on Cryocoolers and Concerned Topics, Chinese Academy of Sciences (1993) p. 79. J. H. Xiao, Thermoacoustic theory for regenerative cryocoolers: A case study for a pulse tube refrigerator, Proc. 7th Int'l Cryocooler Conf., Air Force Report PL-CP--93-1001 (1993) p. 305; Thermoacoustic heat transportation and energy transformation, Part 1: Formulation of the problem, Cryogenics 35, 15 (1995); Part 2: Isothermal wall thermoacoustic effects, Cryogenics 35, 21 (1995); Part 3: Adiabatic wall thermoacoustic effects, Cryogenics 35, 27 (1995). P. Kittel, Ideal orifice pulse tube refrigerator performance, Cryogenics 32,843 (1992). S. Zhu, P. Wu, and Z. Chen, Double inlet pulse tube refrigerators: an important improvement, Cryogenics 30, 514 (1990). C. K. Chan, C. B. Jaco, J. Raab, E. Tward, and M. Waterman, Miniature pulse tube cooler, Proc.7th Int'l Cryocooler Conf., Air Force Report PL-CP--93-1001 (1993) p. 113. K. M. Godshalk, C. Jin, Y. K. Kwong, E. Hershberg, G. Swift, and R. Radebaugh, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 41, Plenum Press, New York (1996), in press. S. W. Zhu, S. L. Zhou, N. Yoshimura, and Y. Matsubara, Phase shift effect of the long neck tube for the pulse tube refrigerator, Cryocoolers 9, Plenum Press, NY, to be published. G. W. Swift, R. A. Martin, R. Radebaugh, Acoustic Cryocooler, U.S. patent 4,953,366 (1990). W. W. Burt and C. K. Chan, Demonstration of a high performance 35 K pulse tube cryocooler, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 313. Y. Zhou and Y. J. Han, Pulse tube refrigerator research, Proc. 7th Int'l Cryocooler Conf., Air Force Report PL-CP--93-1001 (1993) p. 147. Y. Matsubara and J. L. Gao, Novel configuration of three-stage pulse tube refrigerator for temperatures below 4 K, Cryogenics 34, 259 (1994); Mult-stage pulse tube refrigerator for temperatures below 4 K, Cryocoolers 8, Plenum Press, NY (1995) p. 345. G. Thummes, S. Bender, and C. Heiden, Nitrogen precooled multi-stage pulse tube refrigerator reaching 2.1 K, Proc. ICEC 16/ICMC, Japan (1996), to be published. T. Inoue, T. Matsui, S. Kawano, and Y. Ohashi, Experimental research on two-stage pulse tube refrigerator, Proc. ICEC 16/ICMC, Japan (1996), to be published. T. Kuriyama, R.Hakamada, H. Nakagome, Y. Tokai, M. Sahashi, R. Li, O. Yoshida, K. Matsumoto, and T. Hashimoto, High efficient two-stage GM refrigerator with magnetic material in the liquid helium temperature region, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 35, Plenum Press, New York (1990) p. 1261. M. Nagao, T. Inaguchi, H. Yoshimura, T. Yamada, and M. Iwamoto, Helium liquefaction by a Gifford-McMahon cycle cryocooler, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 35, Plenum Press, New York (1990) p. 1251. M. Sahashi, Y. Tokai, T. Kuriyama, H. Nakagome, R. Li, M. Ogawa, and T. Hashimoto, New magnetic material R3T system with extremely large heat capacities used as heat regenerators, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 35, Plenum Press, New York (1990) p. 1175. T. Hashimoto, R. Li, T. Kuriyama, and M. Nagao, Recent progress in application of magnetic regenerator material, Cryogenic Engineering 31,131 (1996), in Japanese. T. Kuriyama, M. Takahashi, H. Nakagome, T. Hashimoto, H. Nitta, and M. Yabuki, Development of 1 watt class 4 K GM refrigerator with magnetic regenerator materials, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 39, Plenum Press, New York (1994) p. 1335. T. Satoh, A. Onishi, R. Li, H. Asami, and Y. Kanazawa, Development of 1.5 W, 4 K G-M cryocooler with magnetic regenerator material, Adv. in Cryogenic Engineering, vol. 41, Plenum Press, New York (1996), in press. T. Inaguchi, M. Nagao, K. Naka, and H. Yoshimura, Development of 2 W class 4 K GiffordMcMahon cycle cryocooler, Proc. ICEC 16/ICMC, Japan (1996), to be published. S. Fujimoto, S. Taneya, T. Kurihara, K. Miura, K. Tomioka, M. Okamoto, T. Yamaguchi, S. Kasahara, M. Terai, A. Miura, H. Nakao, T. Fujinami, and Y. Nakamoto, Development of a 4 K GM/JT refrigerator for maglev vehicles, Proc. ICEC16/ICMC, Japan (1996), to be published.
The Large Hadron Collider Project
Lyndon R. Evans European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN), CH - 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland
The Large Hadron Collider (LHC), approved by the CERN Council in December 1994, will be the premiere research tool at the energy frontier of particle physics. It will provide proton-proton collisions with a centre-of-mass energy of 14 TeV and an unprecedented luminosity of 1034 cm -2 s-1. The most critical technologies of the LHC are the superconducting magnet system, with a dipole field above 8 Tesla, and the huge cryogenic system operating at below 2 K needed to achieve such high fields. A brief overview of the project is presented and the main technological challenges are discussed.
INTRODUCTION The LHC will be a unique facility for basic research, providing the world's highest energies to probe the mysteries of matter and the forces that control it. The machine will be located in the existing 27 km circumference tunnel that presently houses the Large Electron Positron collider (LEP). It will provide proton-proton collisions with a centre of mass energy of 14 TeV and an unprecedented luminosity of 1034 cm -2 s-1. It will also be capable of providing heavy ion (Pb-Pb) collisions with a luminosity of 1027 c m -2 s-1 using the existing CERN heavy ion source. In view of the fact that the machine will be installed in the existing tunnel, a very high bending field (8.4 Tesla) is needed to achieve the nominal energy. In order to achieve this goal at acceptable cost, the design is based on superconductors consisting of well developed mass produced Nb-Ti alloy operating in pressurised superfluid helium below 2 K. Space constraints as well as cost considerations dictate a novel two-in-one design of the main magnetic elements, where the two beam channels are incorporated into a single magnetic structure with the two apertures separated by only 194 mm. The main technical challenge of the project is the exploitation of applied superconductivity and large capacity helium cryogenics on an unprecedented scale, to develop them well behind the present state of the art and to integrate them in a reliable way into an accelerator environment.
MACHINE LAYOUT The basic layout [ 1] of the LHC mirrors that of LEP, with eight long straight sections each approximately 500 metres in length available for experimental insertions or utilities (Figure 1). Two high luminosity proton-proton experiments are located at diametrically opposite straight sections, Point 1 (ATLAS) and Point 5 (CMS). Two more experimental insertions are foreseen at Point 2 (ALICE Pb- ions) and Point 8 (B-physics). These insertions also contain the two injection systems. The beams cross from one ring to another at these four locations. The remaining four long straight sections do not have beam crossings. Points 3 and 7 are identical and are used for "beam cleaning". The role of the cleaning insertions is to allow for the collimation of the beam halo in order to minimise the background in the experimental detectors as well as beam loss in the cryogenic parts of the machine. These insertions contain only classical warm magnets robust against the inevitable beam loss on the primary collimators. The use of warm magnets also permits a low-current design so that their power supplies can be located in surface buildings instead of in specially constructed underground caverns as is the case for high current superconducting magnets. 45
46
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings CMS
mp
Cleaning
ALICE ~ / /
Cleaning
Octant1 \ \ ~ ~ ~ "
LHC-B
ATLAS
Figure 1 Global layout of the LHC
Point 4 contains the Radio-Frequency acceleration systems. In an earlier version of the machine design the RF system was based on common cavities for the two beams. A more flexible design has now been adopted with separate cavities for each of the two beams, alleviating the problem of transient beam loading and damping of injection oscillations. This requires the beams to be separated from the 194 mm in the ares to 420 mm in order to provide the transverse space needed. Finally, Point 6 contains the beam abort insertion. The purpose of this insertion is to dump the beams in a safe and reliable way at the end of physics runs or in case of hardware failure. The principle of the beam dump system is the use of a combination of horizontally deflecting fast-pulsed kicker magnets and vertically deflecting steel septum magnets to extract the beams vertically from the machine. They are then transported along 700 metre long transfer tunnels and dumped into two massive absorbers. Between long straight sections the arcs contain 23 regular lattice periods with a dispersion suppressor at each end. A lattice half-period, 53.5 m long, contains 3 dipoles and a short straight section incorporating a quadrupole, correction elements, a beam pick-up monitor and a cryogenic connection unit.
MAGNETS The magnet system contains many innovative features [2] in order to reduce cost and to fit the two beams into the constrained geometry of the tunnel. The basic structure of both dipoles and quadrupoles is the two-in-one design, where the two beam channels are incorporated into a single iron yoke and cryostat (Figure 2), operating in pressurised superfluid helium. In order to retain the large bursting force of more than 500 tonnes per metre the coils must be firmly clamped in a rigid mechanical structure. For the dipoles, combined aluminium collars have been chosen in order to minimize the pre-stress at room temperature and to ensure the best possible parallelism between the dipole fields in the two channels. The main characteristics of the dipole are shown in Table 1. The principle differences compared with the earlier machine design are an increase in coil aperture from 50 to 56 mm, an increase in length from 10 to 14.2 m and increased intra-beam separation from 180 to 194 mm. The machine will contain 1232 main dipoles.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
47
SC 8US B ~ S
HEAT EXCHANGERPiPE IRONYOKEICOLOMRSS,tgKI SUPERCONOUCTINGCOILS SHRINKINGCYLINDER, HE II-VESSEL BERMSCREEN r . E R m s.lELO 15s 75K
" ~
.._to P-
- " - "t
MAGNET_~ E CRYOSTRT_~
9
NON-MAGNETICCOLLARS VACUUMVESSEL
sTo
He 4-.5K 3 bar
~
~
He 50K ~~_
I
9
-
SUPPORT POST
I
I
Figure 2 Dipole magnet cross section
Table 1 Main dipole parameters Operational field Coil aperture Magnetic length Operating current Operating temperature Coil turns per beam channel: inner shell outer shell Distance between aperture axes Outer diameter of cold mass Overall length of cold mass Outer diameter of cryostat Overall mass of cryomagnet Stored energy for both channels Self-inductance for both channels Quantity
(T) (mm) (m) (A) (K)
(mm) (ram) (mm) (mm) (t) (MJ) (mH)
8.36 56 14.2 11500 1.9 30 52 194 570 15140 980 31 7.4 119 1232
The dipole coil is of a two-layer graded cable design in order to optimize the use of super-conductor. The main parameters of the cable for inner and outer layers are shown in Table 2. The filament size of 7 ~tm for the inner strand and 6 ~m for the outer strand allows fabrication by a single stacking process whilst keeping persistent current sextupole and decapole components small enough to be corrected by small eorrector magnets in the dipole ends. More than 25 tons of cable of the required quality has now been made by four European manufacturers. The cables are insulated by two half-overlapping wraps of 25 micron thick polyimide tape and a third wrap of adhesive-coated polyimide tape wound in "barber pole" fashion with a 2 mm space between windings in order to leave channels for helium penetration. A perforated glass-epoxy spacer is placed between inner and outer coil shells to provide further channels for superfluid helium. The insulation to ground is composed of superposed polyimide films including quench protection heater strips. Quench protection is assured by cold diodes connected to each dipole cold mass. The main lattice quadrupole design uses the same cable as the dipole outer layer. The detailed design, being carried out at CEA-Saclay is similar to that of the dipole but since the electromagnetic forces are considerably smaller, it is possible to contain the forces by the collar structure alone as long as they are made from austenitic steel laminations. The main parameters of the arc quadrupole are given in Table 3.
48
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
Table 2 Strand and cable parameters
Inner layer
Outer layer
Strand Diameter Copper to superconductor ratio Filament size Number of filaments RRR Twist pitch (after cabling) Critical current Cable Number of strands Cable dimension thin edge thick edge width Critical current Ic
(ram) (~tm)
(mm) (A)
(mm) (mm) (mm) (A)
1.065 1.6 7 8900 2 70 25 > 115 (10 T, 1.9 K)
0.825 1.9 6 6500 > 70 25 > 380
28
36
1.72 2.06 15.0 > 13750
1.34 1.60 15.0 > 12950
(10 T, 1.9 K)
(9 T, 1.9 K)
(9 T, 1.9 K)
Table 3 Arc quadrupole parameters
Operational gradient Coil aperture Magnetic length Operating current Operating temperature Coil turns per aperture Outer yoke diameter Stored energy for both channels Self inductance for both channels Quantity
(T/m) (mm) (m) (A) (K) (mm) (kJ) (mH)
223 56 3.1 11750 1.9 96 456 784 11 376
The magnet cryostats must be of an advanced design in order to minimize the heat in-leak at the 1.9 K level. Two intermediate heat intercept levels at 5-20 K and at 50-75 K limit the steady-state operational heat loads to 6.4 W/m at 50-75 K, 1.5 W/m at 5-20 K and 0.43 W/m at 1.9 K.
CRYOGENICS Although the general principles of the LHC cryogenic system [3] have not changed since the early design, the detailed layout has considerably evolved as more information becomes available through prototype work and model testing. General architecture An important principle of the LHC design is to make the maximum possible use of the technical infrastructure of the LEP machine including the cryogenic system. LEP uses four cryogenic plants, each of 12 kW at 4.5 K capacity, located at the four even points. Consequently the even points are much more developed than the odd points, equipped with cooling towers and heavy electrical infrastructure. For the LHC, the four existing plants will need to be upgraded to 18 kW and supplemented by a further four 18 kW plants. These new plants will also be located at the even points with a consequence that the refrigeration power must be transported over a full octant of 3.3 km length.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
49
The general architecture of the LHC cryogenics scheme is shown in Figure 3. The large plants are concentrated in pairs at the even points, with two split cold box refrigerators of the LEP type. The upper cold box (UCB) located on the surface cools helium gas to 20 K and the lower cold box (LCB) located some 80 m underground, to 4.5 K. The close proximity of the plants allows some redundancy to be built in by means of the cryoplant intereonnection box (CIB). Refrigeration at 1.8 K is provided by two cold compressor boxes (CCB), consisting of multi-stage axial centrifugal compressors, installed underground and fed from the 4.5 K refrigerators through the CIB. No infrastructure or utilities are needed at the odd points apart from 1000 m 3 storage at 2 MPa for recovery of gaseous helium after a full sector quench.
Odd Point
Even Point er ! Supply
L
.
+.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Even Point
[stommel 9HP
I
!
-"1,:--..~ I
~lcoonngl
HP |
lsto~.t s.pL~~~
[stommel
J
,
,
i CI: 11p.
1 I
o
'
i
E
-ll lmc lillvln~nnnlnll i ,~
ti!lJIlllllUl
Even Octant
9
', '
i
iron i_
g,
_1_
,
Sector(~3.3krn)
Odd IOctant
_ i_ 9" - -
I]
i,
1
9 ! [llll/llOtf
_[_
Even Octant'-" ~_~
Sector(~3.3km) ,
_-
I
Cryogenic Transfer Une Warm Une
Figure 3 General architecture of the LHC cryogenic scheme
Ring cooling system The magnets operate in a static bath of pressurized superfluid helium, cooled through a linear heat exchanger in which the heat is absorbed quasi-isothermally by gradual vapourisation of flowing two-phase saturated superfluid helium (Figure 4). The linear heat exchanger extends over each half cell, 53.5 m in length, containing three dipoles and a short straight section. Sub-cooled helium from the sector refrigerator distributed through line A (Figure 4) is expanded to saturation through valve TCV 1 and fed to the far end of the heat exchanger tube, gradually vapourizing as it flows back. The low saturation pressure (16 mbar) is maintained on the flowing two-phase helium by pumping the cold gas through line B. Lines C and F provide cooling of the cryostat thermal shields at two temperature levels. In case of a quench the resulting pressure rise is contained below the 2 MPa design level by opening the quench discharge valve SRV and discharging into line D at the level of the short straight section. The decision to concentrate the refrigerators at the even points has had a profound effect on the design of the cryogenic distribution. In particular, the diameter of the cold pumping line B (267 mm) needed to attain the required pressure over a full sector makes it no longer possible to integrate all piping into the magnet cryostat. Instead, a separate cryogenics distribution line (CDL) carries most of the piping, connecting to the short straight section cryostat every 53.5 m (Figures 5 and 6). The extra cost of the CDL is offset by the savings in infrastructure cost at the odd points and better decouples the problems of the magnets from those of the cryogenic system+
50
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings HALF-CELL COOUNG LOOP !
L
(53.46m)
Thermal Shield & Magnet Supports
E(so'K, 20 bo,-) I
MQ
MB
MB
MB
I
Magnet Supports
I
i
c' 1 Beam Screen 1
Beam Screen 2
!
I
I
1
!
Magnet Cryostat
I
r! D(20 K. 1.3 bar)
I
I_
I
!
I
1- ~ "
B
r
S I
A(2.2 K, 1.3 bar) F(75 K, 19 bar)
_J
1 J
I
!
-j
i
Figure 4 Cryogenic flow scheme of an LHC half-cell
I
r
/
f,/ /
J
j -
J
'\
// roLoo~
1300 800
Figure 5 Transverse cross-section of the LHC at a short straight section
I
h,
!
COL Thermal Shield
l _ : _l__
!
I
B(1.83 K, 16 mbar)
'I
---J
: i
,,t I
I
E
I
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
51
Figure 6 Perspective view of the LHC with separate cryogenic distribution line
VACUUM The LHC beam vacuum poses particular problems. Due to the synchrotron radiation emitted by the protons (-- 4 kW per ring at 7 TeV) and the heating due to the image currents in the wall of the vacuum chamber, the magnet cold bore at 1.9 K must be shielded from the beam, otherwise the required cryogenic power would become excessive. An inner liner cooled to around 20 K through tubes carrying high pressure gas will therefore be installed inside the cold bore. Synchrotron radiation impinging on this liner will cause gas to be desorbed from the bulk material which would in turn be cryopumped to the surface of the liner. This is particularly undesirable especially for hydrogen. Once a surface layer of this gas builds up the pressure will rise to that of the vapour pressure of hydrogen at the temperature of the liner, more than two orders of magnitude higher than required for an adequate beam lifetime. In order to avoid this, slots must be cut in the liner so that hydrogen can be cryopumped by the cold bore surface at 1.9 K.
HARDWARE STATUS A considerable amount of development work on the dipole and quadrupole have already been done. More than a dozen short models have been constructed and tested. All have exceeded 9 Tesla with the best reaching 10.5 Tesla. The main purpose of the short model programme is to optimize the coil end design and the difficult "layer jump" region, where the two different cables of the inner and outer coils are spliced together. Seven long dipoles of the first generation (10 m long, 50 mm aperture) have been constructed in industry and five of these have been tested at CERN. All have exceeded 9 Tesla with some training. The measured field harmonics are as expected. In addition, two full size quadrupoles have been constructed under a CERN/CEA collaboration agreement. Both magnets have reached their design gradients with very few training quenches. A number of other prototypes have been constructed and tested including a combined dipole/sextupole, an octupole and the sextupole-and-decapole spool pieces for the correction of persistent current effects in the main dipole. Recently, a short model of a large aperture insertion quadrupole (70 mm aperture, 235 T/m) of a novel four-layer coil design h~s been successfully tested. Six dipoles with the final aperture are under construction, two with the full 14.2 m magnetic length and four of 10 m length, restricted by the length of the heavy presses available at the time. All CERN-owned tooling is now being extended to the final length in preparation for pre-series production. Three of the 10 in dipoles together with a short straight section containing one of the quadrupoles have been assembled into a "string test facility", a simulated half-cell of the real machine (Figure 7). This
52
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
facility has been operational for more than a year and has yielded extremely valuable information feeding back into the optimization of the machine design. In particular it has validated the superfluid helium cooling scheme as well as the principle of discharging helium gas in case of a quench only at the ends of a half cell and not at each individual dipole as originally foreseen. The string [4] is now being prepared for a long life test, where it will be continuously cycled up to operational field.
iii i .~II~~Iii)(~
Figure 7 Overall view of the LHC string test facility
Considerable progress has been made in the definition and validation of the cryogenic cooling system and a number of papers are presented at this conference [4, 5]. One of the key developments has been the successful demonstration of an axial-centrifugal cold compressor operating with a nominal flow rate of 18 g/s at 1 kPa inlet pressure and a compression ratio of 3" 1, a prototype of the first stage of the multistage cold compressor box (CCB) [5].
CONCLUSIONS The considerable amount of R&D accomplished over the last years has validated the main technical choices for the construction of the LHC. In the key technologies of superconductivity and cryogenics progress has been such that the detailed engineering design and procurement may now commence.
REFERENCES The LHC Study Group, The Large Hadron Collider Conceptual Design, CERN/AC/95-05 (LHC) (1995). Perin, R., Superconducting Magnets, Proc. 1995 Part. Ace. Conf., Dallas (1995). Lebrun, P., Superfluid Helium Cryogenics for the Large Hadron Collider, Cryogenics 34 ICEC Supplement (1994). B6zaguet, A. et al, Cryogenic Operation and Testing of the Extended LHC Prototype Magnet String, this conference. Decker, L. et al, A Cryogenic Axial-Centrifuge Compressor for Superfluid Helium Refrigeration, this conference.
Overview of the ITER Project Robert Aymar ITER San Diego Joint Work Site, 11025 N. Torrey Pines Rd. La Jolla, CA 92037, U.S.A
The ITER project is being designed through a collaborative agreement between E.U, Japan, Russian Federation and USA. It is an experimental fusion reactor with tokamak at its core and supporting plant facilities including a Tritium Plant, Heat Transfer System, Cryogenic plant. A large R&D programme is in place in the four partners' laboratories and industries to qualify the retained technologies. Among them, the designed superconducting magnets deserve an important role. The toroidal magnetic field will be produced by a set of 20 large superconducting magnets with a total magnetic stored energy of 100 GJ and a maximum field at the winding of 12.5 T. A plasma current of 21 MA will be induced and maintained by the Central Solenoid. The magnet system requires a cryoplant with a heat load removal capacity of about 75 kW at 4.5 K and liquid helium supply of about 6000 1/h.
INTRODUCTION The International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) is the subject of an international collaboration among the European Atomic Energy Community, the Government of Japan, the Russian Federation and the United States of America to design during six years (1992-1998) an experimental fusion reactor for a possible decision on construction in 1998. The main objective of ITER, as defined in the ITER EDA Agreement [ 1], is to demonstrate the scientific and technological feasibility of fusion energy for peaceful purposes. ITER would achieve this by demonstrating controlled ignition and extended fusion burn, in inductive pulses with a flat-top duration of approximately 1000 s and an average neutron wall loading of about 1 MW/m 2. An important assumption underlying the detailed technical objectives, is that there will be an adequate supply of tritium from external sources of around 2-3 kg/year throughout operation. During the first 10 years of operation (the Basic Performance Phase), the machine should achieve a few thousand hours of burn. During the subsequent Enhanced Performance Phase, a more extensive burn time with improved performance and progress towards steady state operation are expected. BASIC MACHINE PARAMETERS AND PHYSICS PERFORMANCE The main parameters of ITER are shown in Table 1: Total Fusion Power 1.5 GW Average Neutron Wall loading 1 MW/m 2 Plasma inductive burn time 1000s. Plasma major radius* 8.1 meters Plasma minor radius 2.8 meters 21 MA Plasma Current Ip 1.6 k95 (ellipticity @95% flux surface) q95 (safety factor @95% flux surface) 3 Toroidal field B0 @ 8.1 m radius 5.7 T Toroidal field B @ TF coil 12.5 T 2% at the separatrix Maximum Toroidal Field Ripple 100 MW Auxiliary Heating power *Plasma major radius is measured to the center of the last closed flux surface. Table 1 Main parameters of ITER 53
54
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
To fulfill its objectives of ignition and extended burn, ITER must satisfy a number of physics requirements, especially: 9 sufficient confinement to allow for sustained ignition (Plasma confinement); 9 plasma heating power compatible with operation in an enhanced mode of confinement (H-mode power threshold); 9 resistive flux consumption compatible with the plasma maintained purely inductively for 1000 s (Burn duration); and 9 compatibility with operation limits such as the maximum tolerable value of plasma pressure (Beta limit). The overall assessment [2] is that, with the present values for the plasma confinement, beta limit, sustained H-mode power threshold, and burn duration based on extrapolation from current tokamaks operating in near thermonuclear grade plasmas, there is high probability that ITER will achieve the objectives of ignition and sustained burn for 1000 s with 1.5 GW of fusion power without needing auxiliary heating. In addition, the availability of 100 MW of auxiliary heating provides a robust backup against lower than expected energy confinement or higher equilibrium impurity levels. OVERALL ITER PLANT CONFIGURATION The ITER plant is an experimental heat generation plant with a tokamak reactor at its core. The plant comprises the tokamak, its auxiliaries, and supporting plant facilities including a Tritium plant, Heat Transport Systems and Electrical Power systems. The major components of the tokamak are the superconducting toroidal and poloidal magnetic field coils, which confine, shape and control the plasma inside an evacuated torus (vacuum vessel). The coils are superconducting and cryogenically cooled by a supercritical helium flow; they are powered from the grid via a large AC/DC power supply. Inside the vacuum vessel are internal, removable components; these include the first wall and shield/blanket modules and the divertor cassettes. These components serve respectively to absorb heat lost by the plasma through radiation and particles, to absorb most of the neutron energy and protect the vessel from excessive neutron radiation, and to control impurities in the plasma. Provisions are also made to install test modules for breeding blankets inside the vessel. The initial shield/blanket can be replaced with a breeding blanket in the Enhanced Performance Phase. The heat deposited in the internal components and the vacuum vessel is transported and released to the environment via a set of pressurized water loops designed to preclude releases of tritium and other radionuclides to the environment. The tokamak is housed in a cryostat, with a thermal shield system as a thermal barrier around cryogenic temperature structures. Cryogenic pumping systems provide the necessary plasma particles exhaust and vacuum to the vessel and the cryostat. The tokamak is fueled by a dual fueling system, capable of gas and solid pellet injection. The tritium plant processes the plasma particles exhaust, separates the tritium and deuterium, and returns them to the fueling system. This process will also recover the tritium produced in breeding blanket modules. The tritium plant also detritiates the heat transport system coolant and the atmosphere in spaces where potential contamination can occur. Lastly, it provides the vacuum vessel and attached spaces with inert gas for maintenance operations, and detritiates the gas upon exhaust. Other systems maintain proper chemistry and inventory control of the water coolant and the liquid helium needed for the cryogenic structures (cryoplant). They also distribute fluids (water, cryogenic fluid) and gases (compressed air, inert gases) to various points in the plant. Steady-state electrical power is distributed throughout the facility and uninterruptible power supplies will drive those systems that require power for safety and reliability reasons.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
55
Figure 1 shows the ITER Tokamak in cross-section. Pressurized Water C o o l i n g
Bioshield
25 -
C r y o s to t
20
15
10
0
Remo v ab I e Blanket Modu I e s
Voc u um Vesse I
Equatorial Port Extension
Central Solenoid
P r e l o o d _, Structure
Oivertor Port Extension
-5
-10
FF C o i l Gr o v i ty Suppor t
-15 PF Coi Is -20
b .... ~
9 "
7
I O'
"
75
I
.
.
.
me t r e s
.
2'0 .
2'5
Figure 1 VER T I CA L CROSS SEC T I ON OF
I TER
MAGNET SYSTEMS The ITER superconducting magnet systems consist of twenty Toroidal Field (TF) magnetic coils, seven Poloidal Field (PF) magnetic coils, a Central Solenoid (CS) coil, and related structures. They are combined in an integrated overall assembly which simplifies the equilibration of electromagnetic loads. All coils are cooled by a supercritical helium flow maintained by cryogenic circulation pumps. Figure 2 shows key features of the main Magnet Systems and Structures.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
56
UPPER CROWN
TF COIL
,..I...............~ .... "~"~"~"
~
. -/- ...............
OUTER CYLINDER
~N
\,,,,,~
CS
r4
i INNER CYLINDER
Ii i i
INTERCOIL STRUCTURE MONORAIL SLOT
LOWER CROWN LATCH
Figure 2 3-D View of the Magnet systems The TF Coil has a welded case and each case contains a winding pack of 7 radial steel plates with machined grooves supporting circular conductors in a pancake configuration. These radial plates transfer the forces acting on each conductor directly to the casings without accumulation of forces on the turn insulation. The plates and the case protect insulation during assembly, increase structural stiffness for the TF coils and eliminate the need for an external mechanical structure to support the PF coils. The nose of each TF coil along the inner straight leg is machined as circular scallop and is to engage with a fluted groove of the outer cylinder on the CS assembly. Monorails on the top and bottom of the TF coil cases interface with slots in upper and lower crowns which have 20 gear teeth on their inner radii that will engage with the outer cylinder of the CS assembly. The three outer structures coupling the TF coils together, identified as upper, intermediate and lower intercoil structures, are integral parts of the welded cases. Table 2 shows the main parameters for TF coil system.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
57
Geometrical Data
No. of Radial Plates and double pancakes Overall Height
18m
Overall Width
12.2 m
Average Turn Length
45 m
Total weight per Coil
750 Tons
Electromechanical
Data
192 12.3 T
Number of Turns per Coil Max. Toroidal Field at Conductor Total Ampere Turns per Coil
11.5 MAT
Coil Current Centering Force per coil Vert. Tensile Force per Half Coil Total Stored Energy Table 2 Main parameters of TF system
60 kA 762 MN 378 MN 100 GJ
The Central Solenoid is layer wound with heavy walled Incoloy 908 square conductors along its entire height. Each layer is wound with four conductors in hand to reduce cooling channel lengths. Layers are alternatively wound from bottom to top and top to bottom, to allow series connections. Electrical terminals are located at the bottom about 1.5 meters below the winding pack, and interlayer series : connections are at the top and bottom, about 1.5 meters above and below the ends of the windings. With this arrangement all joints are located in low field regions ( = 5 T). The CS is divided into three modules corresponding to the three conductor grades. This allows for modules to be fabricated separately and subjected to factory acceptance tests before the entire solenoid is nested. After nesting, the 1.0 cm radial clearance between adjacent modules must be filled with resin and glass filler to allow transmission of radial loads during machine operation. Tables 3 show the parameters for the CS. Geometrical Data Height of Winding Inner and Outer Radii of Winding Total Weight. Preload Structure Weight E l e e t r o m e c h a n i e a l Data Number of Turns Maximum Field at Conductor Total A.T. Current per Conductor Flux at Outer Radius at Mid-Plane Total Vert. Comp. Force at Mid-Plane Total Stored Energy Table 3 Main parameter of CS .
.
.
.
12.1 m 1.92 m / 2.7 m 1350 Tons 500 Tons
.
.
.
3356 13 T 129 MAT 39 kA 233 Wb 1000 MN 12.3 GJ
The PF coil system (PF2 to PF8) consists of seven poloidal field coils built with heavy walled stainless steel square conductors in double pancake configuration. PF2 and PF7 will use Nb3Sn conductors, while all other coils will use NbTi conductors. The PF coils are vertically supported by clamps linked to the TF cases through flexible members, which allow free radial expansion of the coils. All coils will be connected to superconducting bus and cooling lines which provide services from the terminal boxes outside the cryostat where they are linked to the normal power supply bus and to coolant lines from the cryogenic plant. All conductors are cooled by supercritical He (with temperature 4.5-6 K). Helium flow is forced by the cryogenic pumps.
58
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
Table 4 shows the parameters for the PF coils. PF Coil No.
Turns
Max. A.T (MA)
weight (ton)
Outer Diameter
(m) PF-2 PF-3 PF-4 PF-5 PF-6 PF-7 PF-8 Table 4 Parameters of
624 240 432 432 320 624 50 PFs
27.1 10.4 18.6 18.9 14.0 27.1 2.3
590 400 981 1200 578 590 96
13.3 26.6 31.6 27.7 20.5 13.3 30.8
The SC cable has to combine operation in a high field with high current density and low AC losses. The super conducting strands are cabled with a multi-stage arrangement around a central cooling tube formed from a perforated tube or spiral. A total of five stages are used, with the first always being a triplet and the last always a sextuplet. Copper strands are incorporated into the cabling layout by replacing one of the super-conducting strands in the first stage triplet and/or by adding a central core in the second, third and/or fourth stages. The total amount of copper is therefore continuously adjustable in order to provide the necessary quench protection and a fully transposed cable layout. All the strands, both superconductor and pure copper, are chromium coated with a 2 micron thick layer. CRYOGENIC SYSTEM The cryogenic system consists of three types of equipment: the cryoplant, the cryodistribution system, and individual cooling loops that use cryogens. 9 The cryoplant produces liquid and 60-100 K gaseous helium for components, such as the superconducting magnet system, the cryopumps of the divertor, of the cryostat and of the high energy Neutral Beam Injectors, the pellet injectors. 9 The cryodistribution system transfers the liquid and 60-100 K gaseous helium to the auxiliary cold boxes of the cryogenic users. 9 The main function of the cryogenic equipment for the user cooling loops is to distribute the forced-flow helium among the individual cooling loops. The main ITER cryoplant parameters are summarized in Table 5. Maximum cooling capacity at 4.5 K Cooling capacity at 80 K (range of T = 60 -- 100 K) Re-liquefaction rate of LN 2 subsystem
100 kW 300 kW 10t/h
Total He inventory of cryoplant Total He inventory of ITER machine Heat load of ma~;net system Heat load of other ITER cryogenic users Heat load to cryoline system Power consumption of LHe plant P o w e r c o n s u m p t i o n of 60 - 100 K plant
20 tons 30 tons 75 kW 20 kW 5 kW 45MW 10 M W
P o w e r c o n s u m p t i o n of LN 2 re-liquefaction
5 MW
Table 5 ITER cryoplant p a r a m e t e r s
MAGNET R&D The necessary technology developments to qualify the design are incorporated in ITER EDA R&D programs which are carried out in the four ITER partners laboratories and industries. They have been formulated to focus on key demonstrations and on establishing procedures to ensure feasibility and reliability of components and systems, including their remote maintenance. Manufacturing of the magnets
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings is one of the most time-critical items in ITER construction as well as technically challenging. Also, completion of the major magnet development with high levels of industrial involvement in the EDA is crucial for ITER. A Conductor & Model Coil Program is underway to : 9 upgrade production capacity for conductors, develop QA methods and equipment, 9 develop and demonstrate manufacturing processes for the full scale coils, including structural & insulation materials, wind-react-insulate-transfer, QA methods and equipment, 9 validate performance of significant lengths of full size conductors under relevant conditions of field, field change, current density, and mechanical strain. Presently obtained results of this project are : 9 approximately 10 T of NB3Sn strand have been produced, another 16 T being processed. 9 a 420 m jacketing line has been set up for the TF type of conductor and will be expanded to 1 0 0 0 m.
9 a 1000 m dummy cable is available for a 1000 m pull-through and compaction demonstration on the TF type of conductor. 9 about 1100 m of the 908 jacket material for the CS Model Coil has been delivered to the Jacketing line and the balance of about 4600 m will be delivered in 1996. 9 The CS Model Coil is being manufactured in two coaxial modules, through industrial contracts in the US and in Japan respectively. 9 The test facility of CS Model Coil will be ready in May, 1996 at the Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute, Naka, Japan. 9 The conceptual design of the TF Model Coil is complete and an industrial contract has been placed in Europe. 9 The test facility modification for the TF Model Coil are underway at Forschungscentrum Karlsruhe and will be ready in April 1997. CONSTRUCTION SCHEDULE The design for ITER has been developed on the presumption that the ITER EDA will lead to a construction starting as soon as practicably possible after the end of EDA. An integrated technical plan has been developed for the Project which sets out a timetable, resources and related logic for all the design, engineering and R&D activities necessary to carry ITER through procurement and construction to reach first plasma operation. Under the assumption that the regulatory review process places no strong constraint on the start of site work and on site construction, the critical path runs through the procurement and delivery of magnets and other major tokamak components. The construction could possibly be completed by late 2006, with first plasma occurring by end 2008. CONCLUSION ITER is a necessary and inevitable step towards the use of controlled thermonuclear fusion power. ITER, although it remains to be an experimental device, will produce 1500 MW power output, which is at a power reactor size. The design as a whole offers high confidence of meeting the technical and programmatic objectives. The technological needs and challenges for ITER are well characterized and rely on established approaches. Focused R&D programs are in place to apply the relevant technologies to ITER's specific needs, including, in particular, manufacturing demonstration and testing, and remote handling of key components. ITER will be only possible through international collaboration and it represents a technical challenge which is being met by the international fusion community.
REFERENCES 1 "Relevant Documents Initiating the EDA", ITER EDA Documentation Series No. 2, IAEA, 1993 2 "Technical basis for the ITER Interim Design Report, Cost Review and Safety Analysis", C h a p t e r 5, IAEA, to be p u b l i s h e d 1996
59
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Large scale refrigeration
Refrigeration plants
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Design and Construction of Cryogenic Components for LHD
Sadao Satoh, Toshiyuki Mito, Shuichi Yamada, Junya Yamamoto, Osamu Motojima and LHD Group National Institute for Fusion Science, Nagoya 464-01, Japan
The Large Helical Device (LHD) is a heliotron fusion experimental device in which magnetic fields are controlled exclusively by superconducting magnet : a pair of helical coils and three pairs of poloidal coils. The refrigerator for the 3 Tesla experiments (phase I) has already been constructed and is being put to trial operations without LHD magnets. Its current status is reported elsewhere [1,2]. On the other hand, construction of other key cryogenic components have progressed as well. The paper reviews their design and heat load measurements obtained in NIFS experiments. Developments on some new technologies are also described. The results are encouraging and are expected to contribute to the operation of LHD cryogenic system significantly.
INTRODUCTION Because a cryogenic system requires comparatively a long construction time and some machine training period before a whole superconducting system is put into operation, the cryogenic heat load of LHD has to be estimated with some uncertainty in the beginning of its construction. The design work for the cryogenic system was initially made by the study group on "Cooling and Refrigeration Technology of Superconducting Magnets of LHD" in which nearly 60 scientists, engineers and researchers from universities and industries discussed on the design of LHD cryogenic system. About 115 various proposals were inspected through 20 meetings held during a two year period preceding the start of LHD construction. The sum of the heat loads is shown in pevious papers [ 1,2] and it becomes the basis of the capacity of the refrigerator / liquefier for LHD. In parallel with the construction progress, a real and revised heat load became clear by the improved designs and actual scale bench test at NIFS. Several examples are reviewed below. HEAT LOAD MEASUREMENTS ON KEY COMPONENTS Joule Heat at Conductor Joints The conductor joints of Cable-in-Conduit-Conductors for the poloidal coils are bonded by a solid state bonding method [3]. The purpose is to obtain a joint resistance less than 10-9 ~ per a soldered joint and a contact area as small as possible. 486 NbTi strands were taken out from a conduit end, their Cu matrix was removed, groups of filaments were mutually arranged, and pressure and heat were applied in a vacuum chamber. They demonstrated a twice higher quench current than operation current at a rated bias field and at 4.2 K. A total of 42 joints of three poloidal coil pairs were fabricated by this technique. No measurable resistance was obtained. Similarly, a joint soldering method was applied to the aluminumstabilized composite superconductor of the helical coils. It's Cu sheath removed, the inside NbTi 63
64
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
composite strands were mutually laid in parallel and soldered with a superconducting spacer bar standing in-between [4]. The resistance was measured as 0.7 nO at 9 T, which is 0.21 W / joint at a rated 17.3kA and a total of 6.7 W was calculated for 32 joints of the helical coils. This is one sixth smaller than originally assumed. Conduction to Superconducting Bus-line To reduce the load of the power supply system and the steps of on-site assembling, 9 pairs of prefabricated, flexible superconducting bus-lines were adopted for LHD [5]. A pair of SC cables consisting each of 9 NbTi / Cu, A1 stabilized compacted strands, is inserted into the center corrugated tube which is assembled coaxially with other 4 corrugated tubes of 220 mm outermost diameter and 50 m length. The rated current is 31.3 kA at 1 T, 4.2 K and the critical current is 180 kA. A full scale model of 20 m length 4 corrugated tube assembly, was put to an excitation test [8]. Because the construction has no radiation heat shield except vacuum insulation, 4.55 W/m at 5 K heat load into the return cold gas was obtained from the model experiment. To reduce the heat load on the 5 K level, a 80 K helium gas channel will be added for the SC buslines of LHD as mentioned above. This leads to a 3 W / m load at 80 K and 0.3 W / m at 5 K. SC wires are embedded in the flexible cable joints which connect each two ends of the bus-line to the coil or the current lead. 2 W /joint were obtained and 144 watt is required for 72 joints of 9 paires. Additional 650 L/h liquid helium is evaporated and heated up to 300 K through the gas cooling type current leads. Transfer Tubes Cryogenic transfer tubes are grouped according to their destination and each group is enclosed in a 80 K radiation heat shielded, vacuum insulated transfer tube line, TRT 1 to TRT 3. Their design descriptions may be referred to [6]. During the combined runs of the refrigerator with the dummy heat load cryostat [7], measurements were made of the heat leak into TRT 2 (5 lines-550mmOX50m) and TRT 3 (6 lines650mmOX68m) altogether. As shown in Figure 1, the measured value for the radiation heat load was about 1450+50 W between 40 and 45 K. Because the size, length and number of contained tubes, partitions, bayonet joints and junction boxes attached are different in the two transfer tubes, 8.5 W/m 2 of the heat flux was calculated by averaging the heat load with the total internal shield surface area of two tubes. The figure may not be claimed as excellent, but still a fair amount of heat load is saved from the original design. Measurement of the heat leak at the 4.5 K level failed mainly due to an inadequate comparison of temperature readings from two different types of sensors. Heat Isolation Columns 10 heat isolation columns support a full assembly of the cryogenic part of LHD. They are the superconducting coils and their support structure. The overall weight is about 800 ton. The column stand upright on the base plate of the LHD cryostat at room temperature and support the 4.5 K cold assembly at its bottom. 8 CFRP square plates of each column can carry 95 ton in compression stress and their double folded shapes with thermal anchor are expected to limit heat load within 3W / column at 4.5 K, whereas a cooling rate of 82 W / column is required at the 80K level which is a 3 times larger heat load than initially estimated.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
65
DEVELOPMENTS ON NEW TECHNOLOGIES Supercritical Helium Circulation Pump Recently, a supercritical helium (SHe) circulation pump has been appreciated in the usage of cooling CCIC type SC magnets for its compact size and comparatively robust performance. Cooling and excitation tests with a centrifugal type supercritical pump were made on one of the poloidal coils for LHD, the inner vertical coil IV-L [8]. Inside the pump cryostat there is a liquid helium dewar containing an aluminum brazed plate-fin heat exchanger which precools the SHe to 4.5K. Nearly 2 m above the top plate of the cryostat a 50 g/s pump is mounted, which is surrounded by a 40 mm thick iron magnetic shield [9]. The arrangement limitation would force the pump to run under a magnetic field of 1000 Gauss unless the magnetic shield is adopted. At the excitation test, the pump ran at a speed of 55000 rpm without any problem thanks to the magnetic shield, under which the attached Hall effect sensor detected no magnetic field strength of importance. Figure 2 shows the hydraulic performance of the SHe pump. The adiabetic efficiency of the pump was measured to be 63 % at maximum. 1200 cycle on-off Endurance Test on three Bonnet-less Cryogenic Valves in Liquid Helium Cryogenic valves with a long extended bonnet is commonly used with the benefit of maintainability and demerits of large size and inherent heat leaks. Three different designs of plug position and seat material combination were put to endurance test both in liquid nitrogen and helium for 1200 cycle open and close activation [ 10]. The mass leaks through the valve seat under the closing position were compared before and after the endurance run, but no change was observed for neither of the three valves. The heat loads carried in by actuating helium gas at room temperature were compared among the three designs, the normally closed type showing a higher heat leak. The bonnet-less cryogenic valves provide the possibilitiy for a switching usage, where actuator helium gas is not necessary for normal operation and/or when it is beneficial to put a valve directly at a local position in a piping system. A possible application for LHD is the switching and balancing of the flow to the magnetic force support structure, which needs to be active only in the period of the initial cool down process from ambient temperature. REMARKS AND ACKNOWLEDGMENT The current status in the construction of certain cryogenic components for LHD was described especially in the aspect of thermal performances. The construction is not completed until all of the superconducting magnets are assembled and connected to the refrigerator, that is in the end of 1997. The authors acknowledge Dr. A. Iiyoshi for his leadership in promoting LHD construction. We are also indebted to scientists, engineers and researchers from universities, institutes and industries who joined to the NIFS Study Group on "Cooling and Refrigeration Technology of Superconducting Magnets of LHD" for their discussions and cooperation in the design of LHD cryogenic system. REFERENCES 1 Satoh, S. et.al. Construction of a 10kW Class Helium Cryogenic System for the large Helical Device Cryogenics (1994) 34. 95-98 2 Satoh, S. et.al. Construction and Commissioning Tests of a 10-kW-Class Helium Refrigerator for the Large Helical Device Proceeding WE-B 1-3 CEC/ICMC (1995) or to be published 41
66
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
_Advances in Cryogenic Engineering 3 Hanawa, S. et.al. Development of a Superconducting Joint Technique between CIC Conductors for Poloidal Coil of Large Helical Device (LHD) 5 . 2 IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. (1995) 757-760 4 Yanagi, N. et.al. Development, Fabricacation, Testing and Joints of Aluminum Stabilized Superconductors for the Helical Coils of LHD PS3-e2-37 ICEC16/ICMC Kitakyushu (1996) 5 Yamada, S. et.al. Superconducting Current Feeder System for the Large Helical Device B72 MT-14 Tampere (1995) 6 Matsuda, H. et.al. The Constituent Hardware of the Large Helium Refrigeration Plants for LHD PS 1-e 1-08 ICEC 16/ICMC Kitakyushu (1996) 7 Satoh, S. et. al. Construction report of 10-kW-Class Helium Refrigerator for LHD PS 1-e 1-10 ICEC 16/ICMC Kitakyushu (1996) 8 Mito, T. et.al. Test Facilities of the Experiments on a Single Inner Vertical Coil (EXSIV) for the Large Helical Device PS3-e2-28 ICEC16/ICMC Kitakyushu (1996) 9 Miyake, A. et.al. Development of a Supercritical Helium Circulation Unit for Testing SC Magnets (in Japanese)35.4 Ishikawajima-Harima Engineering Review (1995) 10 Daido, K. et.al. Characterization of Bonnetless Cryogenic Valves PS2-e 1-26 ICEC16/ICMC Kitakyushu (1996)
1996/4/17-18
LT1-2021
.....
50
LTI-2022
I
-'--I
2500
q
4O
2000
30
1500
t"'
i ~ E
[ ~
9
o
~. o
HeatLoad ] 1000
20
_]
[500
0
~_
5/17
:
5/18
l
22:(1(1
18:0(I
:
I ,__,__-,_~__,_ ,
9 i .....
2:1111
j ,__,...
6:1)0
~,:~
0
l(l:l)(I
TIME
Figure 1 Heat load to radiation shield measured at transfer tubes TRT 2 and TRT 3 altogether.
g. E
1.5
................................ ~.S. ............................................................................................................ i ........................ 9
;
a < u..l -r"
1
i
...............................
50, 4atm 30 ,Coil
45 , C o i l
60,Coil 60,Coil,4atm
60,Coil,2.5atm
13.. D ix.
so ,60
o~
0.5
.......1i " "atm,= - " ' " i ' ' "1.033 ' " k~,/cm2 , 0.10I' ! -MPa " . '"..... I,........~........, .....",.........]...1 20
40 MASS
60 FLOW
RATE
80 (g/sec)
Figure 2 Hydraulic performance of SHe pump
100
The Constituent Hardware of The Large Helium Refrigeration Plant for LHD
Hiroshi Matsuda*, Isamu Ushijima*, Minoru Katada* Sadao Satoh, Junya Yamamoto, Osamu Motojima *Nippon Sanso Corp., 6-2, Kojima-cho, Kawasaki-ku, Kawasaki-city, 210 Japan National Institute for Fusion Science, Furo-cho, Chikusa-ku, Nagoya, 464-01 Japan
The helium refrigeration plant which has been installed to cool down the superconducting magnets of the Large Helical Device(LHD) is the largest plant in Japan. Design of the plant was started in September 1992 and the construction at site was completed in December 1994. Meetings were held periodically to manage this large and long project. The plant consists of 2 cold boxes, 8 single stage compressors, a LHe dewar, 2 buffer tanks, a purifier system, and 3 large cryogenic transfer lines. The commissioning was done early spring in 1995 and it was confirmed that the plant satisfied the requirement.
SCHEDULE Design work was started in September 1992. Manufacturing of components was started in the mid-1993 at the factory of Nippon Sanso and ended in the mid-1994. At Toki site, in March 1994, construction of a 7 0 0 m 3 buffer tank was started and then installation of compressors, a 1 0 0 m 3 buffer tank was followed. The installation work of all the components was ended in July 1994. After that, piping work, electrical and instrumentation work was initiated and completed in December 1994. After precommissioning, from April to June in 1995, the commissioning was conducted to confirm the plant performance. In order to manage the project from the beginning, we held meetings periodically for information exchange. Especially the magnets to be cooled were still under design, these meetings were essential to clarify requirement from the magnets and to discuss the optimum solutions. PROCESS The performance required at the same time for this plant is as follows: Refrigeration capacity below 80K 9 20.6kW Refrigeration capacity at 4.4K 9 5650W Liquefaction rate : 650L/h At first, the process had been designed as shown in Figure 1 to get high process efficiency. But due to the following limitations, the process had to be reconsidered. One limitation was the supply pressure of 80K shield gas, which had been 1.77MPa according to our original design, but requested to less than 1MPa. This limitation came from the design pressure of the electrical insulating material used at the 80K shield line at the magnets. The other limitation was the supply pressure of SHe, which cools Poloidal Coils. The higher SHe pressure was required for the higher stability in operation. Both pressure limitations affected the process efficiency. The process had to be redesigned to fulfill these requirement about pressures, while maintaining the efficiency as high as possible. The final process flow is indicated in Figure 2. The supply pressure of 80K shield gas and SHe was changed to 0.78MPa and 1.01MPa respectively. As a result, the process efficiency was still high, 22.5% Carnot. Compared with the original process in Figure 1, the reduction in the effciency is only 2.5%. 67
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings
68
Compressor Expansion Turbine
Expansion Turbine
l8OK S h i e l d 1 I for 1 / S.C. M a g n e t !I I 4
1.77 M P a S u p p I y
J
LHe D e w a r
LHe Dewar
%Car n o t : 25,O %
Figure 1 Original Process Flow
%Car n o t : 22,5%
Figure 2 Actual Process Flow
HARDWARE
Table 1 indicates the items of main components. Table 1 Item of main components ComDonent Cold Box
Number Main Dimension q5 3.8m x h7.5m each 2
He Buffer Tank
1 1 1 1 1 1
LHe Dewar Transfer Line
l l m x h13.5m q5 3m x h15.5m q5 2.8mxh7m d OSm(Vacuum Jacket) q5 0.56m q5 0.66m
TvDe Vertical Cylinder 7 turbines, 43 valves, 15 heat exchangers 700m3, spherical type 100m3, vertical cylinder type 20,00OL, vertical cylinder type Multilayer Insulation Multilayer Insulation Multilayer Insulation
Cold Box In the cold box 7 turbines, 4 3 valves and 15 heat exchangers had to be installed. On the other hand, due to the transportation limitation from the factory (Kawasaki city) to the site (Gifu Pref.), the diameter of the cold box had to be less than 4m. This led to the solution to devide the cold box into 2 pieces, Cold box A and Cold box B, each of which had the diameter of 3.8m. In the Cold box A helium gas is cooled down from room temperature to around 80K level and in the Cold box B it is cooled down to liquefaction temperature. Other important point to be considered was the weight of the cold boxes because the floor
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
69
strength had been fixed. Other factors such as leakage which might occur during the transportation, enormous thermal stress, and minimization of heat-inleak had to be considered in design and manufacturing of cold boxes. At Toki site, the 2 cold boxes were connected with each other with a vacuum insulated line where interconnecting cryogenic pipes were installed. After He leak test, required multilayer insulation (SI) was done. Helium Compressors The plant has 8 single-stage compressors of oil injection type and one oil separation unit. According to the requirement of the process these compressors were divided into 2 groups, Group A for low pressure line and Group B for middle pressure line[l]. This compressor system is the largest in Japan and applies the largest frame size of the manufacturer. The system flow is indicated in Figure 3. As shown in Figure 3, each group was made up of 1st stage compressor unit(s) and 2nd stage compressor unit(s). Oil separation and oil recovery/distribution was carefully examined. The oil separation was accomplished by 4 oil separators. Each compressor unit had the 1st oil separator, while the 2nd, the 3rd, and the 4th oil separator were commonly used for all the compressor units. Oil collected at the 2nd and/or the 3rd oil separator was forced back to the suction of the 2nd stage compressor unit by pressure difference. Similarly oil collected at the 1st oil separator of the 2nd stage compressor unit was forced back to the 1st oil separator of the 1st stage compressor unit. According to oil level at the 1st oil separator of each compressor unit, oil reciever unit was chosen. Transfer Line for Cold .Gas and Liquid Helium There are 3 main transfer lines(TRT1, TRT2, and TRT3) to connect Cold box A to other equipment. TRT1 was for connection with the LHe Dewar, TRT2 for connection with a cryostat of power current leads, and TRT3 for connection with valve boxes for Helical and Poloidal coils. Each TRT is vacuum multilayer insulated type and has required cryogenic pipings for LHe,GHe,and SHe in the same vacuum. Total length of TRT was about 120m. TRT2 and TRT3 have 80K shield cooled by return GHe from associated valve box or cryostat. The cross section of TRT3 is shown in Figure 4. In order to get the best performance of this kind of heat insulation, we divided each TRT into 3 sections, one of which was manufactured, evacuated, and leak tested at the factory. After that this section of each TRT was tested by supplying cold nitrogen gas to inner piping including 80K shield and assured its insulation performance. The other 2 sections of each TRT were connected to the prefabricated section and were evacuated to high vacuum and leak tested at site. 80K-R r ~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
i . . . .
80K-S / ~ 40A
Stle-R
Group A
\
,
/
50
No. 1
Outer
ipe
Inner P
S.I. ..............
~. . . . . . .
_
Shield
550
No. 4 p - ......
@
iI.
_2nd stage Figure 3
1
st s t a q Q
Flow of compressors
Glte-R/J i S.I. 125A LHe:Liquid Helium SIle:Supercri tical Helium Glle:Boil off Gaseous Helium at 4.4 K 8OK:Gaseous Helium at 80 K S :Supply Gas Line R :Return Gas Line
Figure 4
Cross section of TRT3
70
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
REGULATIONS This plant was manufactured and constructed in accordance with Refrigeration Safety Regulations which belongs to High Pressure Gas Control Law in Japan. This regulation is usualy applied to freon refrigerators. Compared with freon refrigerators, this plant is far large, and therefore we were requested to conduct much more severe inspection than usual case for this regulation. Final authorized inspection was finished in March 1995. COMMISSIONING From January to March in 1995, software to control the plant was debugged and parameters we~c adjusted. From April to June,the commissioning was conducted to confirm the performance of the plant. Dummy heat load was added to 80K shield line in Cold box A and the LHe Dewar with associated electrical heaters. In this condition liquefaction rate at the Dewar was checked. The results are shown in Table 2. It was confirmed that the plant fulfilled the required performance. We are looking forward that coils will be completed and be connected with this plant.
Table 2
Result of Commissioning
Requirement Result
Refrigeration capacity 20.60kW below 80K 5650W at 4.4K 20.77kW below 80K 5670W below 4.4K
Liquefaction rate 650L/h at 4.4K 704L/h below 4.4K
CONCLUSION Nearly 3 years were required to complete the largest helium plant in Japan. Though the process design had to be changed at the first stage of the design phase, the plant was designed, manufactured ,and completed as required. All the constituent hardware have shown expected performance, which leads to the commissioning results that the total plant capacity has satisfied the requirement. To manage the large and special project, it is important to hold meetings between the cryogenic user and the cryogenic supplier to find the optimum solution. REFERENCE
1
Satoh, S, In:International Cryogenic Engineering Conference -15, Butterworth, Guildford, UK(1994)95-98
Simulation of the Large Helium Refrigeration Plant for LHD
Minoru Nobutoki, Kazuho Iwamoto, Hiroshi Matsuda Nippon Sanaso Co. Kojima-cho 6-2, Kawasaki-ku, Kawasaki-city, 210, Japan
Performance at off-design conditions of a large scale helium refrigerator is estimated by the simulation model that has been developed for a study of a standard helium liquefier. The process simulation model is based on characteristics of hardware such as heat exchangers and expansion turbines. Required input data to the simulation model are process variables that can be fixed or controlled. Simulation results of the large refrigerator for LHD, which has 7 expansion turbines and 15 heat exchangers, agree with the data observed at the commissioning. As an extreme off-design condition, performance without 3 upper expansion turbines is studied.
INTRODUCTION The Large Helical Device (LHD) has been being under construction at National Institute for Fusion Science (NIFS) at the Toki site in Gifu prefecture[ 1]. Due to its size superconducting magnets of LHD need large refrigeration system. Because the magnets and the large cryostat for the magnets are still under design or construction, heat load and heat load distribution might be changed from the figures given now. In order to estimate the plant condition in such cases, the plant performance at off-design condition has to be simulated. To estimate performance of a cryogenic process at offdesign condition, we have developed a simulation model[2], which can treat a standard process. The standard process is composed of 2 expansion turbines and less than 10 heat exchangers of maximum 3 fluid. However the refrigeration process for LHD is more sophisticated to get high process efficiency. We have applied the simulation model to the LHD refrigerator which is equipped with 7 expansion turbines and 15 heat exchangers[3] and compared the results with the operating data at the commissioning of the plant. CALCULATION MODEL Fig. 1 shows a calculation model of a plate fin heat exchanger. The heat exchanger model simulates heat transfer performance of its core only, with the following assumption. Warm fluid layer and cold fluid layer are overlapped alternately. Fluids are equally distributed for each layer. Wall temperature is common to all the fluids. Heat loss is already known and its distribution is uniform. We can obtain differential equations respect to the exchanger axis(x) based on these assumptions and solid conduction along the axis is integrated into the equations. These equations are converted to finite difference equations by dividing the heat exchanger into 10 to 30 pieces along the axis. Required data for the model are characteristic dimensions such as length and width, and data of used fins and numbers of layers. Expansion turbines are supplied by Linde Kryotechnik AG. The adiabatic efficiency and the flow rate of the turbine are estimated according to Trepp[4]. Required input data for the model are the flow coefficient, the diameter of the impeller, and the rotational speed. 71
I C E C 1 6 / I C M C Proceedings
72
Once the process flow is fixed, the process can be described by combination of these models and we can obtain simultaneous non-linear equations which describe heat and mass balance in the process. To solve these equations, a versatile solver, SPEEDUPa~a[ *] is employed. Required fluid properties are obtained by linking Fluids Pack developed by NBS(now NIST)[5]. Pressure drops are not estimated but considered by giving the fixed values.
Y
F i n Tube plate/
/
~
__E
NX6
Fig. 1 Heat exchanger calculation model.
HX7
, __#',,
I
4000
I
I
"1
250
I
s m
~ v,,,,,4
=
HXIO
200
c>
I
3600
I /
' "~
H• 1 1
]
./
o
150 .~
0 ~
~
r~
3200 '1 100
! 150
I
I 200
i
100 250
80K shield outlet temperature [K]
Fig. 3
Off-design simulation of T1 to T3 failure.
t < Fig. 2
PFD of refrigerator for LHD
WHOLE PROCESS SIMULATION Fig. 2 shows a flow diagram of calculation model. As shown in Fig.2, there are 15 heat exchangers in the process. Among these heat exchangers HX15 is not used at the steady state operation. Total number of the variables is about 15,400 and the number of the equations become over 14,900. The difference between total variable number and total equation number, approximately 500, equals to
t
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
73
the number of the variables which must be input as known variables. Almost all the known variables are characteristic parameters of the hardware such as the heat exchanger length and width. Input Data To see how our simulation model describes the actual plant condition, the whole process simulation was carried out based on the process data in Table 1. These were taken from the commissioning data conducted in May 1995. As shown in Table 1, process variables of all the controlled points, such as TIC, PIC, and PDIC in Fig.2, were given to the simulator as known variables. Since the T1 inlet pressure is much lower than the inlet pressure of the cold box(HP), this operating condition was not optimized for the maximum capacity. Heat load to the 80K shield and the liquid helium dewar were fixed as the commissioning procedure. Table 1 Input parameters for calculation Parameter Temperatur[K] Pressure[bar]
Heat load[W] revolution[RPS]
Variable Cold-box inlet(HP) Liqued helium dewar 80K shield return Cold-box inlet(HP) Cold-box outlet(LP) Cold-box outlet(MP) Turbbine inlet(T1,T4,T6,T7) Super-critial pressure 80K shield pressure drop Heat exchanger pressure drop 80K shield Liqued helium dewar T1,T2,T3,T4,T5,T6,T7
Values 300 4.4 79.36 17.88 1.07 2.03 14.53 17.26 13.78 17.25 10.3 2.48 0.02-0.2(HP), 0.01-0.06(MP), 0.001-0.02(LP) 20770 5670 1639 1 6 5 0 1 7 0 9 2451 1 6 4 2 1 5 6 2 1498
Simulation Results Table 2 shows a comparison between the simulation results and the actual operating data. The flow rate of high pressure gas at the cold box inlet was measured with a orifice meter. As shown in Table2, relatively good agreement was obtained. Rather large difference in flow rate and temperature was observed. However simulated pressures and liquefaction rate agreed well with the operating data. We think one of the reason is that the measurement accuracy is different in instrumentation. Table 2 Parameter Pressure[bar]
Comparison of calculation and actual data.
Variable T1 outlet T2 outlet T4 outlet Temperature[K] T1 inlet T3 outlet T4 inlet T5 outlet T6 outlet T7 outlet Cold box outlet(LP) Flow rate[g/s] Cold box inlet(HP) Liquefaction rate[L/h]
Calculation 10.38 5.14 7.67 186.2 59.4 54.5 15.0 11.9 9.0 298.4 837.5 703.8
Data Error[%] -0.19 10.40 0.00 5.14 0.92 7.60 0.11 186.0 -7.76 64.4 59.7 -8.71 -3.85 15.6 -8.46 130 -10.00 10.0 -0.07 298.6 6.19 788.7 -0.04 704 1
Operation without T1 to T3 Since we have obtained good simulation results, we decided to conduct a very extreme off-design simulation. The simulation results is indicated in Fig.3. This is the simulation in case of turbine failure. This time it is assumed that no refrigeration is available at upper 3 turbines, T1 to T3. To compensate the lack of the cold, cold helium gas cooled by liquid nitrogen can be supplied to the low
74
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
pressure line between HX5 and HX6. Heat transfer performance of HX1 to HX5 is modified because there is no flow in the middle pressure line. The heat load to 80K shield is fixed to 20kW and the liquefaction rate is adjusted to be about 90% of the nominal value, 650L/h. Fig.3 indicates how the refrigeration capacity at 4.4K will change according to the return temperature from 80K shield. It is indicated if the larger refrigeration capacity at 4.4K is required, the higher return temperature, namely the higher shield temperature, has to be admitted by the reduction of the supply flow to the shield. To obtain more refrigeration capacity at 4.4K, liquid helium stored in the LHe Dewar can be used and this simulation is well possible by adding the required model at the dewar. As mentioned here, the simulation model can be a powerful tool to foresee the process conditions in a specific operation mode. When the reduced capacity is required, the simulation model can indicate the optimum operating condition. CONCLUSION The simulation model that has been developed for a simple cryogenic process is effective to the much larger process. It can be noted that simplified model for the heat exchanger is sufficient to simulate the performance of the process, even if the process is a complicated one such as the refrigerator for LHD. REFERENCE 1 Satoh, S, In:International Cryogenic Engineering Conference -15, Butterworth, Guildford, UK(1994)95-98 2 Nobutoki, M. "Study of helium Refrigeration/Liquefaction Process at Off-design Points". Nippon Sanso Engineering Report, Kanagawa, Nippon Sanso. Co., 1994, 13, p. 10-16. 3 Satoh, S, preprints of CEC/ICMC1995, Columbus, Oh, USA 4 Trepp, Ch. Characteristics of industrial scale helium refrigerators with turbo-expanders. Proceedings of the first international cryogenic engineering conference, London, Heywood Industrial Publications, 1967, p.277-279 5 McCarty, R. D. Interactive Fortran IV Computer Programs for the Thermodynamic and Transport Properties of Selected Cryogenics(Fluids Pack), NBS Technical Note 1025, 1980 * SPEEDUP TM is a registered trademark of ASPEN Technology Inc.
Construction Report of 10 kW Class Helium Refrigerator for LHD
Sadao Satoh, Toshiyuki Mito, Shuichi Yamada, Akifumi Iwamoto, Ryuuji Maekawa, Sadatomo Moriuchi, Tomosumi Baba, Kouki Ooba, Haruo Sekiguchi, Junya Yamamoto, Osamu Motojima and LHD Group National Institute for Fusion Science,Nagoya 464-0 l,Japan
A 10 kW class helium refrigerator has been constructed for LHD at National Institute for Fusion Science. In the previous papers, the authors have reported about its design, shop test results on its key components and on-site performance measurement.
During the last twelve months between 1995 and 1996, the
refrigerator has been put to the training operations without connecting to any of the superconducting magnets of LHD. As one of its series report, the paper reviews on significant events and major observations which were experienced during that period and makes a brief discussion about several interesting topics on preliminary base.
INTRODUCTION The Large Helical Device (LHD) is a heliotron fusion experimental device in which magnetic fields are controlled exclusively by superconducting magnets: a pair of helical coils and three pairs of poloidal coils. The helium refrigerator in the LHD cryogenic system has a design capacity of 5700 W refrigeration at 4.4 K, plus 650 L/h liquefaction and 20600 W refrigeration between 40 and 80 K. amounts to be the largest refrigerator ever made in Japan.
This combined capacity
The contract was signed in July 1992 and the
construction at the site (Toki-city, Japan) was completed at the end of FY 1994. Subsequently a series of commissioning runs was made and various performances were obtained with a stand-alone mode of the refrigerator.
In the previous papers [ 1,2], the authors have reported about its design, shop test results on
some key components and the on-site refrigerator performance measurement.
During the last twelve
months between 1995 and 1996, the refrigerator is connected to a "dummy" heat load simulator which can partially simulate LHD heat load and so far four stand-alone runs and two combined runs with dummy heat load have been performed. Every run contains liquefaction and gas recovering back into gas strages and therefore each run took more than one hundred continual operation hours.
The paper reviews several
significant events experienced and major observations during the period and makes a brief discussion about several interesting topics on preliminary base. 75
76
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
Table 1 Operation Record of LHD Refrigerator ( March 1995-April 1996 ) II
Date
Calender
I
II
14-March- 1995
Date
Calender
III
Application for Official's
2~6-Oct.-'95
Manual Operation By NIFS
COMPLETION INSPECTION
8-Nov.-'95
3 Turbine Operation By Vender
24-March-'95
COMPLETION INSPECTION
22-Jan.~9-Feb.-'96 C Box SAFETY INSPECTION
23-April-'95
Manual Operation,
19--23-Feb.-'96
Capacity Measurement
26-~27-Feb.-'96 Auto. Switch Ope.Test from Master
Sift Organizing and Job Training
22--26-May -'95 Automatic Operation
to Slave VME
12--18-June-'95 Tuning Operation 19~23-June-'95 Operator Training Operation
Connect Dummy Heater Cryostat 25~29-March-'96 #1 Combined Ope. with Dummy
4-Aug.-'95
Compressors Turning for 24 Hr
15-- 19-April-'96 #2 Combined Ope. with Dummy
27-Sep.-'95
C.E. SAFETY INSPECTION
IIIm
CONSTRUCTION AND OPERATION RECORD A refrigerator operation calender is shown in Table 1. In Japan, there is a national code and standard for equipments producing and handling high pressure gas. It is required for any equipment to be inspected by officials and the equipment user must obtain a permission before starting his operation management. Therefore, a date of COMPLETION INSPECTION, March 24th 1995, indicates a completion of hardware construction. Before that date each of the helium compressors was accumulated 95 hours of running time. One month later the first refrigerator operation was made by manual control for 4 days. Automatic control operation was made for 5 days and emergency shut-down from full refrigeration run was also confirmed by the NIFS witnesses. Those were basically the manufactures trial and tuning runs. A commissioning run to confirm the rated capacity was made for 12 days from June 12th.
The run of the latter week was
dedicated to the hands-on training and demonstration to the NIFS operators.
After one day compressor
turning run and the first annual and official inspection for safety and security control were made, the first refrigeration run only by owner's operator was made for 5 days beginning from 2 October. supervising engineers were chartered from the manufacturer.
However,
One day turbine turning was conducted in
November for load re-tuning of No. 1 turbine brake circuit. Up to here the refrigerator ran as a stand-alone mode of operation which means a run with a mere combination of refrigerator and a 20000 liter liquid helium storage that has a built-in electrical heater. The accumulated compressor running hour was close to 770 h. In the meantime a "dummy" heat load simulator was constructed and connected to one end of the transfer tube, TRT-2, which contains 5 cryogenic lines inside of 550 mm dia., 50 m long, vacuum insulated and radiation heat shielded duct. The purpose of the dummy heater is to give the refrigerator the various patterns of heat load with the different time constant and the different amount of heat input. By the combined operation of the dummy heat load with the refrigerator, one can quickly and easily simulate LHD cryogenic operation at least in its substantial aspects and therefore collect a data-base of the refrigerator, so that many algorythms can be established for the computer controlled operation of the LHD cryogenic system. After a second annual and voluntary inspection of equipments was made for safety and security, a first combined operation was planned as a trial run for one week in February 1996. However, a computer software defect, and also a simple ill-manipulation of the control system interrupted the refrigerator
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
77
operation. As will be shown later this event posed the most significant defect in the design concept of the cryogenic control system though no apparent damage to the hardware resulted. The last two runs in March and April 1996 are also a combined operation, during which a well known and a rather unfavourable phenomenon of density wave originated instability was observed between the dummy load and the refrigerator. In the following section this observation will be briefly discussed on preliminary base. The total operation time is 1055 h at present. EVENTS AND OBSERVATIONS Considering its short run time, it might be natural that except protection trips only one emergency shutdown is counted for runs during past twelve months after the construction. system design forced the operator to pull the shut-down button.
Two insufficient control
One was the external intervention to the
engineering workstation through the ISDN line between the manufacturer and the operator.
Although
these EWS does not directory control operation, they receive operation data every few seconds from VME which are the controller. A manufacture's unintended close-off on his EWS made the NIFS VME to keep on straging the huge data without overwriting until the occupied terminals brought about a down of the DP1000 which is the CRT at the operator terminal during a refrigeration run. The other was due to the insufficient computer program proof inspection before loading on the VME.
Switching algorithm from
master VME to slave VME sent a conflicting instruction to the control valves in the event of switch operation. These substantial deficiencies in design concept were promptly removed and the program has been revised. At a combined run with the dummy heat load, an instability in pressures and temperature was observed. In Figure 1, a typical pattern of pressure oscillation is shown with the behavior of automatic pressure control JT expansion valve.
Here, the pressure oscillation in the dummy cryostat (noted
by • symbols) seems to precede one cycle ahead and to lead other oscillation (other symbols) in the refrigerator. Flow rate and turbine speed also showed similar pattern. This phenomenon might be defined as density wave originated system
instability. As shown in the flow diagram attached in the figure,
.~_~_ __ lie C(m~pre~sor(RT) 100
i
8'20"=500sec~i 0 . 0 9 8 M P a . = l k ~ c m 2
,~ ,..
1st
~
~,,
.,-, :)'~
~ /'~
ililo
18 ,-~ ~._ ~-~,~ / ~
~, / ~
9th Inlet Pressure of ;~,_ TurbineT6
1
g > (.)
,-.1
60
@Stle Expanders Expander,,
<
t",!
2
E
zo
...... i ~"
Ixa
~e
,.d
1st
:
i
-
Turbine T6
~
.d~
"" "
"" ....
0
. . . . . . . . . . . . 4/19 1 3 : 4 0 : 0 0 1 3 : 4 8 : 2 0 1 3 : 5 6 : 4 0
~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14:05:00 14:13:20 14:21:40 14:30:00
] .... 14:38:20
16 14:46:40
D
DATE TIME
20000L
Figure 1 Example of Instability in Cold-Box and Dummy Heater Cryostat
X-D
78
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
supercritical helium is divided into two flows at the outlet of cold-box of the refrigerator.
Through JT
valve one goes into a liquid helium storage which has a level control electrical heater. The other flows into the dummy load cryostat which has the precooling heat exchanger HX-D immersed in liquid helium. The cycle time of oscillation can be read as 4 to 5 minutes, which roughly corresponds to the time necessary for the supercritical helium to flow down the transfer tube TRT-2 and refrecting-back as the saturated vapour via. liquid heat exchanger HX-D.
Any thermal disturbance in the supercritical helium originating at the
dividing point which is also the outlet of heat exchanger HX-14 of the cold-box, could be converted into an increased amount of the vapour at the dummy load HX-D and retured to the heat exchanger HX-14. This composes a feedback loop and nearly the same model with which Tamada and Tomiyama showed theoretically that such instability could be possible [3]. The thermal disturbance is inferentially to originate from a hot line of other transfer tube, TRT-3, which is again connected to the same dividing point. It was observed that an activation of built-in heater to LHe strage suppresses the instability. Furthermore, any of such phenomena was not observed when the heat exchanger HX-D of dummy heater cryostat is not filled with liquid helium.
The former may be attributed to a much larger cold bunch from the LHe storage (
4.4K cold return corresponding to 6 to 8 kW heater input ) which might dissipate the smaller negative feedback from the dummy heat load.
However, before this presumptions are confirmed a more detailed
investigation is necessary through coming runs. In addition, it should be noted that the observation above is an extreme example caused partly by insufficient tuning of controls and the unskilled initial operation as well. The same authors are reporting its stable operations on the same system [4]. REMARKS AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The current status in the construction of the refrigerator of LHD was shown especially in its operational aspect. The construction is not completed until all of the superconducting magnet will be connected that is in the end of 1997. The authors acknowledge Dr. A Iiyoshi for his leadership in promoting LHD construction and to the NIPPON SANSO Co.,Ltd. for their assistance in operation of the LHD refrigerator. REFERENCES 1 Satoh, S. et.al. Construction of a 10kW Class Helium Cryogenic System for the large Helical Device Cryogenics (1994) 34 95-98 2 Satoh, S. et.al. Construction and Commissioning Tests of a 10-kW-Class Helium Refrigerator for the Large Helical Device Proceeding WE-B 1-3 CEC/ICMC (1995) or to be published in 4__!Advances in Cryogenic Engineering 3 Tamada, N. and Tomiyama, S. Temperature Oscillation Caused by Coupling of Heat Exchangers (in Japanese) Cryogenic Engineering (Japan) 1__334 (1978) 198-204 4 Maekawa,R et.al. Study of the Optimum Operating Condition of the Helium Refrigerator with a Dummy Load Appratus for the Large Helical Device PS l-e 1-13 ICEC 16/ICMC Kitakyusyu (1996)
C R Y O G E N I C C O N T R O L S Y S T E M FOR THE L A R G E H E L I C A L DEVICE
Toshiyuki Mito*, Sadao Satoh*, Ryuji Maekawa*, Shuichi Yamada*, Kazuya Takahata*, Akifumi Iwamoto*, Hiroshi Yamada*, Kiyomasa Watanabe*, Tomosumi Baba*, Sadatomo Moriuchi*, Kouki Oba*, Haruo Sekiguchi*, Katsuji Murai*, Ken Iimura**, Katsuhiro Nakamura**, Junya Yamamoto*, Osamu Motojima*, LHD Group*, *National Institute for Fusion Science, Oroshi, Toki, Gifu 509-52, Japan **Nippon Sanso Corporation, Tsukagoshi, Sawai-ku, Kawasaki 210, Japan We have been constructing the cryogenic control system for the Large Helical Device (LHD). The cryogenic control system consists of workstations, VME (Versa Module Europe) controllers, Local Area Networks (LAN), operating graphic consoles, peripherals and signal terminals. The control system is composed as a duplex system which significantly improves the reliable operation with fault diagnoses of each component. Primarily, the overall control system can be expandable, using standard hardware and operating software. Furthermore the software tool packages are being developed based upon them, which provide us more flexible and easy construction of a control program. INTRODUCTION The Large Helical Device (LHD) is a fully superconducting heliotron type fusion experimental device under construction at the National Institute for Fusion Science (NIFS). The superconducting coils for the LHD consists of two helical coils and three pairs of poloidal coils. The helical coils are cooled by the pool boiling of liquid helium. The poloidal coils are cooled by the forced flow of supercritical helium. The construction of the LHD was started in 1991 and will be completed in 1997. The cryogenic system consists of the helium refrigerator/liquefier, the superconducting helical and poloidal coils and the peripheral equipment, such as superconducting bus-lines, control-valve-boxes and cryogenic transfer-lines. The engineering design and construction of the helium refrigerator/liquefier was started in 1992 and was completed at the end of 1994. We have been conducting test operations of the helium refrigerator/liquefier with a dummy heat load to gather data on cooling characteristics of a large-scale cryogenic system. The cooling scheme of the LHD is fairly complicated. It is necessary to construct automatic control system for a safe and reliable operation of the cryogenic system. The control system for the cryogenic system has two features; one is highly reliable system such as a large-scale chemical plant, the other is very delicate and sensitive system such as a laboratory instrument. The development of a new control system, which is highly flexible and expandable concerning both hardware and software, is crucial for the LHD cryogenic system. CRYOGENIC SYSTEM FOR THE LHD Figure 1 shows the flow diagram for the cooling objects of the LHD cryogenic system. The conditions of cryogen at the numbered points in the flow diagram are listed in Table 1 In the steady state operation of the LHD, there are four kinds of cryogen; 1) supercritical helium for the poloidal coils, 2) two phase helium for the coil supporting structure and the superconducting bus lines, 3) liquid helium for the helical coils and the current leads, 4) 40K - 80K gaseous helium for the thermal radiation shields of the LHD cryostat, the helical valve box, the poloidal valve box, the current-leads cryostats and the transfer-lines. The helium refrigerator/liquefier has cooling capacities of 5.65 kW at 4.4 K, 20.6 kW from 40 K to 80 K and 650 L/h liquefaction. The poloidal coils are separated two group; the upper coils and the lower coils. The supercritical helium from the helium refrigerator is supplied to the poloidal valve box, in which it is cooled 79
80
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
by a heat exchanger, goes through the upper poloidal coils and returns to the poloidal valve box and is cooled again by a heat exchanger, then is supplied to the lower poloidal coils. The liquid helium is supplied from the 20,000 L Dewar to the helical valve box and goes through the cooling pipes of the coil supporting structure as the forced flow of two phase helium, then is separated to liquid and gas at a phase separator in the helical valve box. The helical coils is connected to the phase separator and is cooled by the pool boiling liquid helium. The superconducting bus lines are cooled by the forced flow of two phase helium. The two phase helium from 20,000 L Dewar is subcooled by a heat exchanger at the current-leads cryostat, then is supplied to the superconducting bus lines. The returned two phase helium from the bus lines is separated at a phase separator at the current-leads cryostat. The liquid helium baths of the current leads are connected to the phase separator, and the current leads are cooled with helium vapor from the liquid helium baths. The total cold mass of the LHD at 4.4 K is 822 ton in which the helical coils, the poloidal coils, the coil supporting structure and others are 240 ton, 182 ton, 390 ton and 10 ton, respectively. He R efrigerator
i-
II III R'r-G He Return
I I
i~, .......... ~!;,..............
~,-
I
,
111
'~)~ 80KShield Supply ' -~-.----~- 80K Shield Return 0)_~_ LHe ] ~. Supply
i i ,
(;~
GHe Return
,if!ii!" SH. ~ .
.
-(',3b~a;;'s'e~176
'
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
SHe Return
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
~ i~ ,-~;,,:~Heat Exchanger . . . . . . . . . . . .
p~ U ~C:eU:=Hnt ''1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
!
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Superconducting Bus-Lines Current Lead Cryostats
.
o
ii
_ _
i ~ -
.
.
Helical V a l v e - B o x
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Poloidal V a l v e - B o x
Figure 1. Flow diagram for the cooling objects of the LHD cryogenic system. Table 1. Conditions of cryogen at the numbered points in the flow diagram (Figure 1). No.
Kind of
Press.
Temp.
Flow
Entlmlpy
He
arm
K
rote
J/g
LHe-S GHe-R LHe-S GHe-R GHe-R LHe-S GHe-R LHe-S GHe-R SHe-S SHe-R
1.6 1.174 1.5 1.174 1.05 1.5 1.174 1.5 1.174 10.0 6.6
4.8 4.7 4.7 4.4 300 4.7 4.4 4.7 4.4 5.5 4.9
334.6 310.9 108.8 85.1 23.7 75.8 75.8 150.0 150.0 300 300
Quality
No.
Kind of
Press.
Temp.
Flow
He
aim
K
rate
SHe-S SHe-R 80K-S 80K-R 80K-S 80K-R 80K-S 80K-R 80K-S 80K-R
9.9 6.8 7.7 5.2 7.2 5.7 7.2 5.7 7.2 5.7
5.7 4.8 40.0 80.0 49.5 67.5 42.5 74.4 48.5 67.6
300 300 105.2 105.2 20.3 20.3 69.3 69.3 15.6 15.6
gs 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 It) 11
E ~ J/g
Quality
e,/s 13.1 32.7 15.1 30.0 1574 15.0 30.0 14.5 30.0 18.1 14.8
0.00 1.00 0.153 1.00 0.149 1.00 0.094 1.00 -
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
19.0 13.9 222.2 431.2 272.2 366.0 235.5 402.0 267.0 366.6
-
CRYOGENIC CONTROL SYSTEM System configuration Figure 2 shows the system configuration of the cryogenic control system. The cryogenic control system consists of workstations, VME (Versa Module Europe) controllers, Local Area Networks (LAN),
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings
81
operating graphic consoles, peripherals and signal terminals. The work stations are used for making and debugging control programs for VME controllers. Usually, the programming environment of a VME controller is not user-friendly. We can construct control programs easily with the aid of the work stations. The control programs made by the work station are down loaded to the VME controllers and are executed on the VME controllers. The VME controllers are the main control parts of this control system in which the real-time control programs are running. The VME controllers consists of CPU boards, analogue input/output boards, digital input/output board, network communication boards and reflective memory boards. These boards perform their duties; 1) data acquisition from various sensors of the cryogenic system such as pressure gauges, flow meters, temperature sensors, level meters, etc., 2) data conversion from voltage signals to engineering values and execution of sequential and loop control programs, 3) control operation for control valves, ON/OFF valves, heaters, compressors, etc., 4) communication with the work station and the operating graphic consoles, 5) equalization of control data between the VME controllers. The LAN connects each component of the control system for data communication, remote operation, file transmission, data output to the printers, etc. The optical duplex link type LAN, which is compatible with Ethernet, is used for high reliability because the LAN is a lifeline of this control system. TCP/IP and UDP/IP, which are world standard like Ethernet, are used as protocol. They are versatile communication protocol not only for a work station but also for a personal computer, and are utilized in various fields. These features make it easy to integrate this cryogenic control system to the other system such as the central control system. The operating graphic consoles are man-machine interface hardware by which we can operate and monitor the cryogenic system. Same function could be done by a work station. However the refreshing speed of a display is not so fast as that of the operating graphic console. The operating graphic console, which is an exclusive machine for the plant operation, consists of CRT, keyboards and CPU board computers supporting VME bus communication. The peripherals are a hard-copy for the operating graphic consoles, a line printer for alarm and event logging, laser printers for data output and X-terminals and personal computers for monitoring and data management. The signal terminals are sets of signal conditioners and relay terminals to unify level and kind of input/output signals. The control system is based on what is called 'open system'. The operating system of workstations and VME controllers are the UNIX and the Vxworks, respectively. Primarily, the overall control system can be expandable, using standard hardware and operating software. Workstations for Programming D
[~
Intelligent Graphic Terminals for Operation Printer O
CO _ _~
O _1_C ~71r------n 7 661 7 61
Intelligent Graphic Terminals for Operation 7
6O __
_O_
__
Z~
r'-"-"l Printers , ~ , ~
~
in Service in VCaiting in Service in Waiting in Service in Waiting
lin Waiting
VME Controllers for Helical Valve-Box
VME Controllers Memory for He Refrigerator
V
He Refrigerator Workstations for Remote Maintenance
["~
Cryogenic Control LAN for Heat Loads
Cryogenic Control LAN for He Refrigerator in Servicel
Personal Computers Workstationstbr & X-Terminals Programming for Monitering
Integrated VME Controller
Helical Coil Helical Valve-Box
VME Controllers for Poloidal Valve-Box
VME Controllers for SC Bus-Lines
Poloidal Coil Poloidal Valve-Box
SC Bus-Lines Current Leads
\r
Re flective Memory
to LHD Main Control System
Figure 2. Cryogenic control system for the LHD. Redundancy system The control system is composed as a duplex system which significantly improves the reliable operation with fault diagnoses of each component. The VME controllers are used as a pair of one in service and the other in waiting. Two VME controllers in service and in waiting are identical in both hardware and software configuration. In case the VME controller in service has trouble, the service is instantly switched over to the VME controller in waiting. The work stations are also duplicated and can be switched over from the master work station to the
82
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
back-up work station when there are any failures. The LAN is duplex and link type, which is protected from the interruption of communication even when the lines are down out in two positions at the same time. Figure 3 shows typical case of the failures. Usually, the master work station communicates with the VME controller in service as shown in Figure 3a. There are failures on the master work station and the VME controller in service and two lines of the LAN are also cut off. The work station is switched over to the back-up one, the VME is switched to one in waiting and the LAN continues its communication with loop back as shown in Figure 3b. Work Station Master
Il ~.-I
Work Sta
on
Back-up
Work Station [ ~ ~ l Master ~,~a~~1~21~
It!r
II II Work Station [ ~ Back-up
Cut-~
V m S,
:, Jng a) Nonnal Operation
tng b) FailuresofWS, VME and LAN
Figure 3. Duplex control system; a) in normal operation, b) in failure. Software configuration Furthermore the software tool packages are being developed based upon the hardware and software configuration mentioned above, which provide us more flexible and easy construction of a control program. These software tool packages have the function of system configuration, easy making of graphic control panels, reporting and programming sequential control and loop control. The development of the control program can be done on the work station with no disturbance on the actual real-time control of the VME controller. The completed program is down loaded to the VME controller from the work station. In case of the modification of the control program on the VME controllers, however, there is no necessity to stop the running program on the VME controllers. This is important feature for the cryogenic system because the cryogenic system cannot be reset to the initial state easily. Therefore we can revise the control programs continuing the operation of the cryogenic system. CONCLUSION The development of a new control system is crucial for the cryogenic system because of fairly complicated cooling scheme of the LHD. The control system must be highly reliable and flexible to handle a delicate cryogenic system. The control system is based on open system and consists of work stations, VME controllers, LAN and operating graphic consoles, etc. The control system is composed as a duplex system which significantly improves the reliable operation with fault diagnoses of each component. The fault diagnoses of the VME controllers are now limited to the CPU and communication boards. However we will extend them to every board including analogue input/output boards and digital input/output boards. Based on above cryogenic control system, the overall operating scenario of the cryogenic control system; such as, a cool-down, a steady-state operation, a warm-up, a power failure and a coil quench, are being considered to develop a fully automatic control program for the LHD cryogenic system. REFERENCES 1.Satoh, S. et al. Construction of a 10 kW Class Helium Cryogenic System for the Large Helical Device Cry_ogenics (1994) 34 95-98.
Liquefaction Control of 10 kW Class Cryogenic System for the LHD
Shuichi Yamada, Sadao Satoh, Toshiyuki Mito, Ryuuji Maekawa, Akifumi lwamoto, Sadatomo Moriuchi, Tomosumi Baba, Jyunya Yamamoto, Osamu Motojima and LHD Group *Hiroshi Matsuda, *lsamu Ushijima, *Katsuhiro Nakamura, *Takashi Fukano, *Minoru Katada National Institute for Fusion Science, 322-60roshi, Toki, Gifu 509-52, Japan *Nihon Sanso Corporation, 6-2 Kojima-cho, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 210, Japann
The cryogenic system has an equivalent design capacity of 9.1 kW refrigeration at 4.4 K, and will refrigerate all sets of superconducting coils, their supporting structures and superconducting bus-lines for the fusion experimental device, LHD. The refrigerator is controlled by two sequential programs ; for the start-up control of the eight compressors in sequence, and for the driving control of the seven turbines and the liquefaction control of the cryogenic system. Automatic liquefaction operation is demonstrated. Measured refrigeration power of each turbine is in good agreement with that of design values.
INTRODUCTION The Large Helical Device, LHD, is a fusion experimental device of heliotron/torsatron type [ 1]. It consists of a fully superconducting coil with a total stored magnetic energy of 1.6 GJ during phase II operation, and it will be completed in 1997. Liquid helium for the pool-boiling cooled helical coil, supercritical helium for the forced flow cooled CICC of the poloidal coils, and two-phase helium for the support structure and the SC bus-lines are necessary in order to sustain the steady refrigeration for the LHD. The weight of the cold mass of LHD exceeds 800 tons. The liquefier refrigerator system with an equivalent design capacity of 9.1 kW at 4.4 K was constructed at the end of 1994. The commissioning runs were made and various design performances were confirmed, including a thermodynamic performances of the coldbox, percent Carnot efficiency of the plant and so on [2,3]. Now, we have been developing the automatic refrigeration operation for the LHD. The control scenario for the full automatic operation is based on the simple liquefaction operation. A total plant control system with a fault tolerant specification was installed, developing the special software and using a distributed computer system with the VME. In this paper, we describe the liquefaction control method of 10 kW class cryogenic system. The test results of the refrigeration power of each turbine are also discussed. CRYOGENIC SYSTEM Figure 1 shows a flow diagram of liquefier refrigerator system for the LHD. The system consists of two gas helium holders of 700 m 3 and 100 m 3, an external gas purifier, eight circulating oil injected screw type compressors, a coldbox with seven turbines and fifteen heat exchangers, and a 2 m 3 liquid helium dewar. The characteristics of this cryogenic system are : 1) liquid nitrogen free system for a simple liquefaction or for the steady refrigeration for the LHD, and 2) high Carnot efficiency plant system by using two different circulation lines for the compressors. Three turboexpandars T I to T3 driven through middle pressure line of 0.203 MPa refrigerate the helium to liquid nitrogen temperature. The heat load of the radiation shield between 40 K to 80 K is covered by the flow exhausting from turbine T4 and coming back to T5. Two supercritical turbines T6 and T7 are equipped to improve the thermal efficiency of the J-T expansion line. A heater H1 is used to control the heat loads to T4 and T5 in constant. The heater H2 in the liquid helium storage is installed for adjusting the liquid level and the return cold to the coldbox in constant. The system has a design nominal refrigeration capacity of 5.65 kW at 4.4K, 20.6 kW at 40 K to 83
84
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings 0.203 MPa , __ O.103___MPa/
,
]1.79 MPa
-L-t
.~...:[.............l.................... ~
IT 1
LHD JI S-He (S)--] .......
[ S-.e (R~ l -----t G-He (R) ]
Compressors
] Pulifier ]
l ~~
]
e'2:-
Figure 1 Flow diagram of liquefier refrigerator system for the LHD. Table 1 Designed process values of turboexpanders. Turbine TI T2 T3 T4 T5 T6 T7
Mass Flow Rate (~s) 210 210 210 260 260 184.5 160
Pressure (MPa) /in/out) 1.77 / 1.22 1.22 / 0.59 0.59 /0.21 1.77 / 0.76 0.51 / 0.10 1.77 /0.98 1.77 / 0.98
Temperature (K) (in/out) 186.2 / 170.0 87.4 / 72.6 72.6 / 57.0 50.8 / 40.0 22.2 / 14.8 13.7 / 11.7 10.3 / 8.9
Refrigeration Power (kW) 18.0 16.5 17.14 14.98 9.72 1.531 1.456
80 K including 650 liter per hour liquefaction. The design parameters for the process control of the steady state operation are listed in Table 1. START-UP CONTROL OF THE SCREW COMPRESSORS Figure 2 shows a block diagram of the sequential control for the circulating compressors. The program is divided into three sub-programs: 1) start-up and control for the main circulating compressors of group A, 2) control for a external purifier, and 3) start-up and control for the auxiliary compressors of group B. Impurity gases of N2, H20 and CxHy are continuously monitored using an optical emission spectroscopy gas analyzer. Impurity level, 20 ppm of N2 and 10 ppm of H20 are taken into consideration as a inter-lock signal for the line connection from the compressors to coldbox. Typical examples of the start-up control of the compressors are shown in Figure 3. Upper curves indicate the strokes of the slide adjusting valves of the first staged compressors, middle curves for the suction and discharge pressures of the compressors, and lower for the impurity densities in the system. In the actual liquefaction operation, the start-ups for the turbines are made, when the total impurity densities decrease to less than 5 ppm. The setting-up time of all compressors with full load is about 1.5 hours. LIQUEFACTION CONTROL A liquefaction is controlled in sequence by the five staged sequential sub-programs as shown in Figure 4. Each turbine floats by an auxiliary jugging gas at the initial rotation speeds less than 400 rps. When the speed exceeds 400 rps, the turbine floats by itself (the dynamic gas-bearing). The rated number of rotations and their trip conditions of each turbines are listed in Table 2. The rates of 100 rps larger than the rated values are used to the overspeed protection for the turbines. Measured typical cool-down curve and rotation speed of each turbine are shown in Figure 5. Turbines T6 and T7 were driven at 8:30 and
ICEC16/ICMC
Proceedings ~.,
85
.. .. .. .. ..
t
-~ 1oo
" A-I :
o
|,
.- . - . . .
1) A-5 Compressor ON (100% load) 2) A-1 Compressor ON ( 80% load) 3) A-2 Compressor ON ( 80% load) 4) Pressure Control (Pin :0.147 MPa, Pout :1.78 MPa) 5) A-6 Compressor ON (100% load) 6) A-3 Compressor ON ( 80% load) 7) A-4 Compressor ON ( 80% load) 8) Pressure Control (Pin :0.103 MPa, Pout :1.78 MPa) 9) Capacity Control of A- 1 & A-2 (100% load) 10) Capacity Control of A-3 & A-4 (100% load) [2] Impurity Reduction Control Standard Impurity Levels: N2 ; 20 ppm, H20 ; 10 ppm 1) If exceeding, Purifier on 2) If decreasing, Purifier off
;>
60
~
40
< o
N
~'/~'" B-2
"
-~ ..... ~
..... l - ....... : 1 - - - - , , - , I
20 o
iiiiii i....i....
2
10/5/95 10:00
. . . . . . . .
1.5
10/5/95 11:00
, . . . . . . . .
10/5/95 12:00
i . . . . . . . .
Discharge Pressure
1
:] . . . . . P i n - A ]
i _
!l . . . .
Suction Pressure! o f C o m p r e s s o r B
Pin-B ]
t
::
J
0.5 [- ............... \- ...... Su0"ion-PressttreofCompres.-sorA-. ............ J
0I-.v::.~-~ 1015195 7:00
4O
,,
~.i,,
10/6/95 1:00
?a,,_t 10/6/95 10:00
~
.........1..................i.............................! --~N2 [
30
...'.~.
10/5/95 16:00
50 ~ ~' ca,
[3] Sequential Control of Group-B Compressors 1) B- 1 Compressor ON (100% load) 2) B-1 Compressor ON (80% load) 3) Pressure Control (Pin=0.203 MPa, Pout=l.78 MPa) 4) B-1 Compressor (100% load)
3
10/5/95 9:00
~" o,.,
. . . . .
[ 1 ":
"A~ 2
[ 1] Sequential Control of Group-A Compressors
;
i
!
~H20
I....... |
.........ti~il ...........~:.............................i-~-Cxttv ].......
20 E
-'
10 0 10/5/95 7:00
10/5/95 16:00
10/6/95 1:00
10/6/95 10:00
DATE T1ME F i g u r e 2 Block d i a g r a m o f the sequential control for the screw c o m p r e s s o r s .
F i g u r e 3 T y p i c a l w a v e f o r m s o f load a d j u s t m e n t s , suction and discharge pressure, and impurity densities.
9:00, respectively, and final pressure adjustments were finished at 10:30 in this experiment. The time from the start-up of the compressor to the production of liquid helium is approximately 36 hours. It was confirmed that the all turbines rotate stable and the coefficient of speed fluctuation is less than +50 rps at the steady state. The refrigeration power P of the turbine is estimated by the following equation: P = F(Hin
- Hout)
(1)
where F 9mass flow rate through the turbine, Hin 9enthalpy of the inlet gas helium, H o u t enthalpy of the outlet gas helium. The enthalpy of the helium gas is calculated from measured temperature and pressure. Measured refrigeration powers of the turbines are shown in Figure 6. The large amplitudes of fluctuations were observed at turbines T6 and T7. This fluctutational error is caused by the estimations of [1 ] Starting up of T I-T3 Turbines
[3] Starting up ofT6 Turbine
1) Warming up for 10 minutes 2) Speed control to rated rotation 3) Pressure control of T 1 input gas 4) Temp. control of T3 output gas
1) Warming up for 10 minutes 2) Speed control to rated rotation 3) Pressure control of T6 input gas 4) Temp. control ofT6 output gas
[2] Starting up ofT4 & T5 Turbines 1) Warming up for 10 minutes 2) Speed control to rated rotation 3) Heater control of returned thermal shielding gas 3) Pressure control of T5 input gas 4) Temp. control of T5 output gas 5) Pressure control of thermal shielding gas 6) Pressure control of T4 input gas
[4] Starting up of T7 Turbine 1) Warming up for 10 minutes 2) Speed control to rated rotation 3) Pressure control of T7 input gas 4) Temp. control ofT7 output gas [5] Liquefaction Control 1) Line making to L-He storage 2) Pressure control of J-T valve 3) Heater control in L-He storage
F i g u r e 4 Block d i a g r a m o f sequential control o f the liquefaction.
I C E C 1 6 / I C M C Proceedings
86
Table 2 Rated rotation speeds and trip conditions of turboexpanders. Turbine
rmed rotation speed wanning-up steady stme 1400 (rps) 1650 (rps) 1400 1650 1400 1650 2000 2450 1400 1650 1800 1800 1900 1800
T1 T2 T3 T4 T5 T6 T7
trip conditions over speed output temp. 1750 (rps) 110 (K) 1750 35 1750 25 2550 27 1750 9 2550 2550 250O0
300
............................. ;t~}.~nts o f ad
250
...... ~
200
iiiiiii
150
100 ["
iiiiiii
50 0
,
4/16/96 22:00
4/17/96 6:(}0
................ - ~ 1 ] ......... ~ Ttu-bine 2 | - - * - Turbine 3 ] .
5o0o 0
,
4/! 7/96 8:00
4/17/96 14:00
4/i 7/96 10:00
,
I
,
,
4/17/96 12:00
,
4/17/96 14:00
20000
2000
"
~" 15oo
"
7 "7 7 -
"
!
. . . . . . . . . .
~- !o00 . . . . . 500
0
i : i
.............................
|
"
:
.~, "
! 0(10(1
~ ~
i
,
4/16/96 14:00
TI-T3
"2" 2{){)o{) 9 o 150011
u,~ I ............
,
,
"
"--
'~k.)"
i
"
15000
":
~1
"
9~
[ .... Turbine I ' " + Turbine 2 I [ ---*--- Turbine 3 ]
,
.
4/17/96 10:00
.
.
.
Pressure Adjustments 9
1"4 & T5 i , A
~/v-,
! 0000
0
.
4/17/96 12:00
,
4/17/968:00
4/17/96 14:00
,
4/'17/96 10:()0
i
,
4;17/96 12:00
4;17/96 14:00
5000
2500 g 1~ 2000
of
g 50oo
: ....................................................
,
4/17/96 8:00
"
............................ i ............................. i ............................. ,
.
. . . . . . . . . . 6,-d,, 4000
[+Turbine6l
---l- ........ +~'O~; ........... ' .............. t
]
~" ""u~Uin~Vt .... ~
,
3000 = ?-'
1000 500 0
. . . . . . . . . . . . . +Turbine 4 | .............. ? 1 :: . . . . Turbine 5 |I ...... -j...... ~............ i . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Turbine 6 | .............. 1 ~ ....... l'urbine 7 ] 9. :
,l
4/17/96 g:O0
.
.
.
.
4/17/96 I0:00 DATE
i
,
4/17/96 12:00 TIME
,
,
4/17/96 14:00
Figure 5 Measured waveforms of a temperature of JT-valve and speeds of the turbines.
-~.. 9
2000
~
1000
~
0
4/17/96 8:00
4117/96 10:00 DATE
4/17/% 12:00 TIME
4/I 7/96 14:0
Figure 6 Refrigeration powers of the turbines.
enthalpy, because of the changes of temperature (+1 degree) and mass flow rate (5 %). The averaged refrigeration powers show good agreements with that of the designed values as shown in Table 1. SUMMARY An automatic liquefaction control scheme of 10 kW class cryogenic system for the LHD is developed and demonstrated. The results summarized are as follows: (1) The setting-up time of all compressors with full load is about 1.5 hours. (2) All turbines rotate stable and the rate of speed fluctuation is less than +50 rps at the steady state. (3) The averaged refrigeration powers show good agreement with that of the designed values. REFERENCES Motojima, O, Akaishi, K., Fujii, K., Fujiwaka, S. et al, Physics and engineering design studies on the Large Helical Device, Fusion Engineering and Design, Vol. 20 (1993) pp.3-14. Satoh, S., Mito, T., Yamada, S. et al, Construction of a 10 kW class helium cryogenic system for the Large Helical Device, Cryogenics, Vol.34 (1994) Supplement 95-98. Satoh, S., Mito, T., Yamada, S. et al, Construction and commissioning tests of a 10-kW-class helium refrigerator for the Large Helical Device, CEC/ICMC (1995) Columbus, WE-B1-3.
Study of Optimum Operating Condition for the Helium Refrigeration System of the LHD with a Dummy Load Apparatus R. Maekawa, T. Mito, S. Yamada, S. Satoh, A. Iwamoto, T. Baba, S. Moriuchi, K. Ohba, H. Sekiguchi, I. Ohtake, H. Yamada, J. Yamamoto, O. Motojima and LHD Group National Institute for Fusion Science, Toki, Gifu 509-52, JAPAN K. Chida and T. Fukano Nippon Sanso Corp., 6-2 Kojima, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 210, JAPAN
A dummy heat load experimental apparatus has been developed to establish a fullautomatic operating scenario of the helium refrigeration system for the Large Helical Device (LHD). The apparatus primarily consists of a forced-flow low temperature helium line, a liquid helium supply line and a liquid helium bath. The design philosophy of apparatus is to simulate two dominant cooling schemes of the LHD: pool-boiling for a helical coil and a forced-flow supercritical helium for the poloidal coils. Mass flow rates can be controlled by control valves adjusted with electro-pneumatic actuators. A process control computer system was used for data acquisition, valve control and a PID control of liquid helium in the bath. Experiment were conducted under steady state condition with heat inputs from two heaters which induce unbalanced operating condition to the refrigeration system.
INTRODUCTION The National Institute for Fusion Science is developing a large heliotron/torsatron type experimental fusion apparatus, Large Helical Device (LHD), to study currentless, steady state toroidal plasmas. The LHD has two types of superconducting coils; a pair of pool-boiling helical coils and three sets of forced-flow poloidal coils. Reliable and safe operation of superconducting coils is essential to provide successful operation of the LHD. A 10 kW class helium refrigerator/liquefier has been developed to satisfy all refrigeration requirements for the LHD. Various design aspects of the refrigeration system and the test operation results have been reported.[ 1] However, it is still essential for the refrigeration system to test its capability under variable heat inputs. The present paper will describe a test operation of the system with a dummy load apparatus. EXPERIMENTAL DESCRIPTION 1. Experimental Apparatus A dummy heat load experimental apparatus is developed to test a refrigeration system of the LHD. As shown in Figure 1, the apparatus consists of a supercritical helium (SHe)line, a liquid helium (LHe) filling line, a gaseous helium (GHe) return line. Each line is connected to the refrigeration system via a joint box. Approximately 40 m long 0.55 m diameter transfer line (TRT-2) attached the joint box with a cold box of the refrigeration system. A TRT-2 has five transfer tubes; 80 K shield GHe supply and return, LHe and SHe supplies and return. The SHe line is connected to an outlet of the turbine #6 and #7, while the LHe-fill line is connected to the 20,000 liter liquid helium reservoir. The GHe return line eventually reaches at a suction side of compressors. The apparatus was mounted to a 3m long, 200 mm diameter cryostat which has a liquid nitrogen shield. Fig. 2 shows flow diagram of a cold box of the refrigeration system as well as a dummy-load apparatus. The SHe line has a finned-tube heat exchanger, approximately 30 m long and 22 mm diameter, wound about 1m diameter coil and immersed in a liquid helium bath. Heat inputs to the line are achieved with a 7 kW heater located down stream side of the heat exchanger. A mass flow rate and static pressure of supercritical helium can be adjusted with control valves located at inlet and outlet of the line. The LHe line is made of approximately 22 mm diameter and 2 m long stainless steel tube reaching at the bottom of a cryostat. Mass flow rate of liquid helium is adjusted with a control valve. A 50 mm diameter, 1 m long stainless steel tube was used for the GHe return line 87
88
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings He comp. suction LHe reservoir turbine #7
SHe
LHe
GHe
~
~
~)
|
i
~
P~
~
L t ~ _T,
?N2shield
9
.0W.max
9 C) ,,
9
-I
. Heat exchenger
. . . . . . . . . . . . . L..He bath
H2" 2.8 kW.max. T: Germanium Thermometer P: Pressure Transducer
F: Flow Meter LI: Level indicator
Figure 1. Dummy load experimental apparatus. Two orifice flow meters are used to measure mass flow rates of supercritical helium and gaseous helium, respectively. Germanium resistance thermometers (GRTs) and absolute pressure transducers are used to estimate thermophysical properties of low temperature helium. Since all apparatus is in just above the atmospheric pressure environment, thermometry of fluids is crucial. To avoid any influence from surrounding, a 4.7 mm diameter hole was drilled through the line and a copper tube was silver soldered in it. A GRT was placed in the copper tube with Crycon grease to ensure thermal contact between them. Leads wires of the GRT were wound around the line and fixed with a Teflon tape for an additional heat sink as well as protection. Both differential and absolute pressure transducers are located at room temperature, 0.32 mm stainless steel capillary tube connect between transducers and lines. A bath pressure is used to estimate properties of the helium gas. A 2.8 kW heater was also immersed in the liquid helium bath for a heat load. Compressors
m
]
~. ~IIIIIIIII[I:I:I:I:I:I:I:I:I:~....:T:.:,,T#1
o
~ .............l..................... 1.........
I
ff
IT#2
-I i
I H~:~...~z.. i~l.~
lIT#4
II
I
......?:.
:
........~...............l;..:+.:,
O
/
.
.
.
.
.
|
.
.
.
!
.
v
J
1
.
k
]
1~ ~ I I .
TRT-2 I SHe GHe j LHe
.
,,, LHe (20000 L)
,..........................;Heat .. Exchanger Figure 2. Schematic of a flow diagram.
H2 ta.A Dummy Load Apparatus
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
89
A process control computer system, CENTUM, was used to control electro-pneumatic actuators and heaters as well as for data acquisition system. CENTUM basically consists of a operator's console and a field console station. Both process control commands and data acquisition performed from the console to the apparatus via the control station or vice versa. One of the versatile feature of CENTUM is its ability to set up various PID controls with corresponding sequence program. Two types of PID controls were used to adjust LHe level in the bath as well as to regulate mass flow rate of SHe with a control valve. Communications from CENTUM to the apparatus is performed with one second period. Therefore, the process operation/data acquisition can be considered as continuous. In addition to CENTUM, data acquisition system consists of HP3852A data acquisition/control unit operated with a controller (HP Visual Engineering Environment) over the HP-IB. The 3852A was used as mainframe of data acquisition combined with two accessories; a integrating voltmeter and a relay multiplexer. A total of 20 differential analog input channels can be used for data acquisition. Analog-todigital conversion is performed in the voltmeter and data are stored in the on-board voltmeter buffer. General signal path for the data acquisition system is following. Outputs from temperature and pressure sensors are collected in the voltmeter through the multiplexer. Data were then transferred to the mainframe memory and finally to the controller via interface (HP-IB). VEE program converts raw data to temperatures, pressures and mass flow rate of low temperature helium. Results are plotted on the graph as real time basis. 2. Experimental Procedure The dummy load apparatus was isolated until the refrigerator/liquefier produces about 10,000 litter of liquid helium in the 20,000 liter reservoir. At the same time, liquid nitrogen was transferred to the liquid nitrogen jacket of a cryostat. The helium bath was filled and maintained with exchange helium gas at approximately 1 atm. Control valves of the refrigeration system and the apparatus were opened to cool down the apparatus and the TRT-2. Approximately 1 m long liquid helium level indicator monitored the helium level. Primarily three types of refrigeration scenario can be established with the apparatus; precooling mode, steady state mode and extra heat input mode. For a precooling mode, simulating precooling of poloidal coils, supercritical helium is the only refrigerant to the apparatus so that no liquid helium is in the bath. The experiment was focused on 15K level refrigeration condition since turbines have to provide maximum work to maintain the condition. The heat input to the supercritical helium line was set at 7.0 kW. For steady-state mode, a total heat input to the refrigeration system is approximately 1/3 of the LHD under steady state operating condition. Thus, the mode requires approximately 1/3 of total refrigeration capacity. Mass flow rates of liquid helium and supercritical helium are set at about 120 g/s and 100 g/s, respectively. Heat inputs are 1.3 kW for the bath and 1.6 kW for the supercritical helium line. In this case, mass flow rate of gaseous helium return is balanced with those of liquid helium and supercritical helium. The extra heat input mode is the most crucial operating condition to the refrigeration system. While operating the LHD, additional heat loads to the system will be present because of AC losses, emergency shut down of superconducting coils and control valve adjustment. Under these circumstances, extra helium gas will return to the refrigeration system which induces significant impact to the refrigeration system. The mode will induces extra helium gas in terms of heat inputs to the helium bath and the supercritical helium line. The heat inputs are set at 3 kW for the bath and 1.6 kW for the supercritical helium line. Mass flow rate of the supercritical helium and liquid helium is adjusted at 100 g/s and 120 g/s, respectively. However, helium gas return is approximately 292 g/s because of unbalanced heat input to the apparatus. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Figure 3 shows a result of dummy heat load experiment conducted on March 28, 1996. Three types of refrigeration schemes were tested and maintained until the steady-state condition was established. N.H. denotes no heat input to the LHe bath. This mode was operated to confirm overall system. Following the N.H. operation, two refrigeration modes were simulated. For S.S mode, mass flow rates of gas helium were not fully stabilized since the LHe level in the bath was controlled under a PID-control coupled with a heater #2 (H2). The fluctuation in the mass flow rate is proportional to the heater power as shown in Figure 4. Absolute pressures of LHe and GHe lines are also plotted, which was stabilized after 20 min. of operation. The PID-control was then turned-off to proceed the E.H (extra-heat-input) mode. The system reached at steady state condition after 5 min. Any fluctuation of the system was not observed. The mode was maintained about 10 min. because of time constrain. As shown in Figure 5, some instabilities were observed when the experiment was conducted on April 17. Although heat inputs to the apparatus was kept constant, the GHe line was substantially fluctuated. It was unlikely for the apparatus to induce overall fluctuation to the refrigeration system. One possibility is that the LHe level in 20000-liter reservoir was computer controlled, which in turn affected the suction side of compressors and spread to the overall system fluctuation.
90
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings E.H mode ~ F 1 . F2 3 0 0 f
-
. . . . . . . .
I 200
!: . . . . . . S.S . . mode
'
....
:: , ~ . _ ~
] 10
< .^ :
NH
:
.
.
.
XA T2T1
198
.
/""'[::::'~U'~'"[y:v '0 ""-~"~" [Dr. ,,~,../',O "^-
---o-
l
-
T4
..,
~
N
100
6
50
5
0 0
50
~.
4 150
100
Time (rain) Figure 3. Experimental result of two refrigeration modes.
o.,;
[ -- GHeline[ l .- '. - .u .~. . . ~= I . . . .
[~
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
GHe line ] = LHeline] n21
2000
//
0.15
0.135
=
k~
m 1000 ~"
"ff 0.14 0.13
,~
500 0.12
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I =="- H1 [ ..... HE .
. . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1200
.
800 ~-
~"
~ 0.120 '~' ~
600 ~" 400
0.110 0.105
0
I0
20
30 40 Time (min)
50
60
Figure 4. Heat input and absolute pressure changes.
200 0
10
20
30 40 Time (rain)
50
60
Figure 5. Fluctuation during the experiment.
The heat input to the SHe line was compared with enthalpy change of supercritical helium, using T3 and T4. Temperature based calculation is about 10% smaller than the total heat input. Furthermore, the heat extracted by the heat exchanger was approximately 140 W which is one-third of designed value. Those discrepancy might be caused by a location of T3 which set at next to the heater. In addition, the quality factor of two phase helium flow was estimated with a heat balance in the apparatus. The quality factor x is estimated to be 0.22 which is 1.4 times larger than that of design. This may be caused by the radiation heat leak from other transfer tubes in the TRT-2. CONCLUSION The helium refrigeration system was operated with three refrigeration modes under steady-state condition. It was confirmed that the refrigeration system maintain reliable operation with a dummy load apparatus. However, the system was not fully satisfied its full-automatic operating mode. In other words, control valves of the refrigerator/liquefier are required some adjustment by an operator while operating with various refrigeration modes. Additional experiments are still necessary to establish full-automatic condition of the refrigeration system. REFERENCE 1. S. Sato et al. "A 10kW class helium refrigeration system for the LHD", presented at CEC in Colombus, 1996.
Cryogenic Operation and Testing of the Extended LHC Prototype Magnet String
A. Brzaguet, J. Casas-Cubillos, H. Guinaudeau, B. Hilbert, Ph. Lebrun, L. Serio, A. Suraci and R. van Weelderen LHC Division, CERN, CH- 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland
After the assembly, commissioning and successful first operation of a full-scale superconducting magnet string, and as a new prototype dipole magnet was added to approach final configuration, the cryogenic system has been slightly modified to allow the verification of the performance of the superfluid helium cooling loop in counter-current two-phase flow. At the same time the control system strategies have been updated and only two quench relief valves have been installed, one at each end of the string. We report on the cryogenic operation of the extended version of the string and the response of the system to transients.
INTRODUCTION A major milestone in the validation of the basic technical choices for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) project [1], as far as main accelerator systems - magnets, cryogenics and vacuum- are concerned, is the testing and operation of a full-scale superconducting magnet string, representing a half-cell of the machine lattice. The first version of the LHC test string was assembled, commissioned and successfully operated for the ftrst time at the end of 1994 [2], confirming the basic design choices of the LHC cryogenic system [3]. We report on the cryogenic operation of an extended and modified version of the string and in particular the counter-current flow cooling, the response to transients such as current ramp and d;'charge, as well as magnet resistive transitions.
EXTENSION AND MODIFICATION OF THE STRING As a new prototype dipole magnet was added to lengthen the string towards its final configuration, the cryogenic system has been slightly modified to allow the verification of the performance of the superfluid helium cooling loop in counter-current two-phase flow, an option which would greatly simplify the cryogenic layout of the LHC machine. The main modification was the introduction of a Joule-Thomson valve, a phase separator from which liquid overflows down the 1.4 % slope, and a connection to the pumping line at the higher end of the string as shown in figure 1. In this configuration, pumping is shared between both ends of the helium II heat exchanger tube. Pumping from the higher end dominates because of pressure drop in the heat exchanger tube. The liquid and gas velocities are opposite one another giving rise to flow instabilities above certain flow rates. At the same time the control system strategies have been updated profiting from the operational experience gained during the first run, in order to prepare the cryogenic system for the forthcoming experiment, that will validate the long term performance of the system during uninterrupted current cycling at nominal LHC rates. In line with previous results, only two quench relief valves have been installed, one at each end of the string. In this fashion, the quench relief valve scheme proposed for the LHC can be better approximated, and the requirements for the relief valves validated. 91
92
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
_• i.., ?i! ,..
,
WPU >
I cwu
99
- ......
[ BP >
-
X (}-~7 >
Q
"~~~--~i
: "
Q
[
D
I :-t
0
f 4 :t
E
F
::::::::::::I " I::::.:::: ::::J
0
B
~JT>
. I_._ 1
E I.::.:: :::l
F I::::::+:+:::.:I ::::::::::::::::::::::::::: I:::+::::::::::::I I:::::::::::::::::::::::::I
SFB
SRB
Fig.1 Cryogenic flow-scheme of extended and modified string
OPERATIONAL PERFORMANCE During 1995 and the beginning of 1996 the cryogenic system has reliably provided the nominal cryogenic conditions necessary to perform experiments concerning the main systems of the LHC, operating for more than 1500 hours at 1.9 K and recovering from more than 50 resistive transitions. The temperature increase in the pressurised helium II bath was limited to 6 mK during nominal current ramping (10 A/s) and 50 mK during nominal discharge (-130 A/s), with steady-state temperature stability at 1.9 K better than a few mK, both in co-current and counter-current operation of the saturated helium II loop. In spite of the limitations reached in counter-current mode, the capability of cooling down the string from ambient temperature to 1.9 K in just more than a week has been maintained. The operational experience gained during the first run has allowed us to define control strategies such that all stand-by and transient operations can be performed unattended in fully automatic mode. In the same way the magnet powering does not require presence of skilled cryogenic operator. Opportunity was taken to perform other cryogenic test, such as the validation of basic instrumentation for LHC and the assessment of heat loads at different temperature levels.
COUNTER-CURRENT FLOW OF TWO-PHASE SUPERFLUID HELIUM Since the superfluid helium cooling loop is now fed by overflow from the phase separator (figure 2), acting as a weir at the upper end, the neighboring section of the corrugated heat exchanger tube sees countercurrent flow of liquid and vapor phases at saturation. As the heat load, and thus the mass flow-rates are gradually increased, the velocity of the vapor flow rises up to the point where it transfers sufficient momentum to block the gravity-driven, counter-current liquid flow, and thus prevents wetting of the heat exchanger tube. As the conditions of flow blocking are approached, the liquid level in the phase separator must sharply rise to compensate for the decrease in liquid velocity, and an instability develops. This phenomenon has been extensively studied in vertical or quasi-vertical flows of conventional boiling fluids, and is known as "flooding" in boiler tubes [4], but no experimental work had been done on superfluid helium in quasi-horizontal geometries.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
pressurizedHe 11,static saturated He 11,flowing / heatexchangertube ~
93
LHe Qav'~ ~ |!
...=-..--
~v
I 1.42 %
~'/Zf/'/,//'/f/',/f//~
GHe
magnet
heliumvessel
sc bus bar connection
GHe
Fig.2 Superfluid helium cooling loop In order to assess limitations to the superfluid helium cooling loop brought by this effect, experiments were performed by increasing heat loads, while maintaining magnet temperatures stable, at different values of saturation temperature (i.e. vapor density) between 4.5 and 1.8 K. The onset of flow blockage can be clearly diagnosed from the sharp rise in the phase separator level, and the subsequent drift in the magnet temperatures (figure 3). The most critical conditions occur at low temperature, i.e. when the vapor density is lowest. On the 1.4 % slope, the 1.8 K liquid flow in the 4.15-cm inner-diameter corrugated tube is blocked at a vapor velocity of 6 m/s, corresponding to a heat load of 46 W, i.e. above the nominal demand of the LHC half-cells [3]. Although occurring at higher mass flow-rate between 4.5 and 2.2 K, blocking of the liquid flow in the heat exchanger tube may increase time for cool-down of the string from 4.5 K. Strategy for fast cool-down is to optimize the saturation conditions as a function of magnet temperature, in order to work with high-density, low velocity vapor, while preserving sufficient driving temperature difference. In this fashion, cool-down from 4.5 to 1.8 K could be achieved in 6 hours, only slightly longer than Joule-Thomson valve sizing could permit.
MAGNET RESISTIVE TRANSITIONS Coping with resistive transitions in superconducting magnets is a concern of main importance for the safe operation of the LHC. When occurring, it provokes the discharge of the magnetic energy stored in the coils (several MJ) into the static liquid helium bath, provoking rapid thermohydraulic transients At a current of 13.1 kA, corresponding to the LHC ultimate magnetic field of 9 T, rates of pressure increase up to 140 bar/s and pressure peaks reaching 12 bar are commonly observed. A fast responding protection system was designed at CERN to trigger electrically the opening of two quench relief valves after 120 ms, with full opening less than 170 ms after quench detection. During the latest experimental run, it was shown that one quench relief valve, located either on the lower part and low end of the cold mass (discharging liquid helium) or on its upper part and high end (discharging mainly in gaseous or supercritical phase) is sufficient to prevent the 1000 litres of the magnet helium inventory from reaching the design pressure of 20 bar. As shown in figure 4 the opening of the quench relief valve located on the upper part of the cold mass (the other being mechanically blocked) was delayed, in step of 10 ms, up to a total delay of 200 ms. In the dipoles (where the rate of pressure increase are the highest), the pressure peak increased by 2 bar with respect to no delay, still well below the 20 bar design pressure of the cold mass vessel. While keeping the maximum delay time for the electrical trigger, we lowered the pressure force on the valve seat down to 10 bar in order to force the valve to open on pressure. The pressure actuated opening gave a total delay time of 165 ms and a cold mass peak pressure of 13.5 bar. These tests were aimed at investigating the use of modified commercial valves in order to avoid the use of specially designed, fast-opening prototype valves as the ones in use [5]. The final tests were done using a standard and commercially available industrial valve, modified to fully open in less than 300 ms, mounted on the upper part and high end of the cold mass as one of the two fast opening valves. The test of this valve showed comparable discharge rates and pressure peaks in the cold mass.
94
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings I
I
1.82
I
I
String Lower End
70 ~
!
,..,...,.,..~_;-/
1.8
/
"C 15 14..5
/
13.5
..,,.A...rr . . . . . . . . . . . . .
String Upper End
1.78
12.5
1.76
13 4
11.5
Phoso s op%o2L
1.72
,e, -
1"720
215
~
;5
410
:5
Fig.3 Flow instability test performed at 1.8 K
10
50 0
Q [W]
10100
120
140
160
180
200
220 [ms]
Fig.4 Cold mass peak pressure versus opening time
CONCLUSION The basic design technical choices for LHC and the modifications introduced after the first experimental tests have been validated, giving us confidence on the cryogenic system that is going to be built for LHC. The practical limitations of the counterflow system have been investigated and will give useful information for the definition of the final design which respect operational constraints. The tests performed on the prototype quench relief valves have given decisive information for the specification of the quench relief valves to be used in LHC. Analysis and simulation work is under way to understand the physics behind the process of energy transfer to the helium bath after a quench and its subsequent discharge and recovery. The string is now being prepared to assure 3000 hours of uninterrupted and fully automated operation at 1.9 K with continuous ramping and de-ramping to and from nominal current, to gain information on long-term behaviour of key components over the complete lifetime of the future machine.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors wish to thank the LHC String Team, B. Gaillard-Grenadier and Th. Goiffon for the valuable work performed during the operation and maintenance of the LHC test string.
REFERENCES ~
2
e
o
5.
Evans, L.R., The Large Hadron Collider Project, paper presented at this conference B6zaguet, A., Casas-Cubillos, J., Flemsaeter, B., Gaillard-Grenadier, B., Goiffon, Th., Guinaudeau, H., Lebrun, Ph., Marquet, M., Serio, L., Suraci, A., Tavian, L. and van Weelderen, R., The superfluid helium cryogenic system for the LHC test string: design, construction and first operation, paper presented at CEC 1995, Columbus (1995) Lebrun, Ph., Superfluid helium cryogenics for the Large Hadron Collider Project, Cryogenics ICEC Supplement (1994) 34 1-8 Wallis, G.B., One-dimensional two-phase flow, McGraw-Hill (1969) Danielsson, H., Ferlin, G., Jenninger, B, Luguet, C., Milner, S.E. and Rieubland, J.M., Cryogenic performance of a superfluid helium relief valve for the LHC superconducting magnets, paper presented at CEC 1995, Columbus (1995)
Demands in Refrigeration Capacity for the Large Hadron Collider Ph. Lebrun, G. Riddone, L. Tavian and U. Wagner LHC Division, CERN, CH-1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland The capacity demands on the cryogenic installations for the Large Ha&on Collider (LHC) at CERN have been recently updated [ 1]. Unlike the LEP energy upgrade using superconducting acceleration cavities LHC will require high power refrigeration at 1.9 K, as well as non-isothermal cooling at 4.5 K to 20 K and at 50 K to 75 K. This paper presents the assessment of cryogenic capacity that has to be supplied by the eight refrigerators for LHC in relation with the foreseen operating modes of the machine. INTRODUCTION Based on today's knowledge the LHC collider will demand a total about 6.6 MW exergetic capacity. Half of this total capacity is to be supplied at 1.8 K for cooling the cold mass of the superconducting magnets. The rest is distributed mainly for non isothermal loads at 4.5 K to 20 K and 50 K to 75 K as well as for the cooling of current leads. Due to the exergetic losses which result from refrigeration at 1.8 K, the eight cryogenic plants will have a total equivalent capacity of 150 kW at 4.5 K. The reference design for the current leads is based on the use of high temperature superconductor (HTS) material leaving open the choice of cooling methods [2]. The precise assessment of the heat loads is an important task during the planning phase of the project and has to be kept under fight control. TEMPERATURE LEVELS The staging of temperature levels envisaged for the LHC cryogenic system are" - thermal shielding between 50 K and 75 K as a first major heat intercept, sheltering the cold mass from the bulk of heat inleaks from ambient; -- non-isothermal cooling of the beam screens between 4.5 K and 20 K which will shield the cold mass from synchrotron radiation and image currents produced by the high-energy, high-intensity hadron beams; quasi-isothermal superfluid helium cooling the magnet cold mass at a maximum temperature of 1.9 K; isothermal helium cooling special superconducting magnets in insertion regions, superconducting acceleration cavities, and the lower sections of HTS current leads at a saturation temperature between 4~ K and 4.7 K, gaseous helium cooling the resistive upper sections of HTS current leads, in forced flow between 20 K and ambient.
-
-
-
STATIC AND DYNAMIC LOADS The term "static loads" is used for all heat loads which are not dependent on the machine operation. This comprises the heat inleaks due to conduction and radiation to the low temperature part inside the cryostats plus the thermal load by pure conduction in all feedthroughs. The term "dynamic loads" is used for all heat loads which are dependent on the machine operation. This includes loads induced either by the excitation current of the superconducting magnets i.e. in current leads or residual resistive areas of coil splices, or by the circulating particle beams i.e. synchrotron radiation, resistive heating due to image currents or geometrical singularities in the beam channels and 95
96
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
particle losses. These loads depend strongly on the energy and intensity of the circulating beams and are estimated for the nominal and ultimate operating conditions defined below. MODES OF OPERATION The modes of interest for the cryogenic system are: - "nominal operation" at 7 TeV beam energy, 2 x 0.536 A beam current and 1 x 1 0 34 c m "2 s "1 luminosity; - "ultimate operation" at 7 TeV beam energy, 2 x 0.848 A beam current and 2.5 x 1034 c m 2 s 1 luminosity; "low beam intensity operation", still with full beam energy and thus full excitation current in the magnets but negligible beam current; "injection standby", characterised by negligible resistive dissipation and beam-induced heat loads in the magnets.
-
-
THE ARCS The eight arcs, which form the regular part of the LHC will be composed of 46 half-cells, each consisting of three main dipoles, one main quadrupole plus a number of correction magnets [1]. The expected static loads of the main elements in the half cells has been assessed with good confidence and experimentally verified through several independent, yet converging approaches [3-6]. Parallel to the magnet cryostats in the arc runs the cryogenic distribution line from which each halfcell is supplied with cryogenic fluids. The heat loads of this line are estimated based on conceptual design drawings and will have to be validated in future prototype tests. Table 1 shows the total heat load budgeted for an LHC arc in the four machine operation modes described above. Table 1 Total heat load for an LHC arc (no contingency included) Operating mode
Nominal operation Ultimate operation Low-beam-intensity Injection standby
Temperature levels 50- 75 K 4.5 - 20 K 1.9 K
[w]
[w]
[w]
15800 15800 15800 15700
1930 3630 310 310
1070 1040 920 660
Comments
static & dynamic nominal static & dynamic ultimate static & magnet current induced pure static load
THE INSERTIONS The insertions consist of 0.5 km long sections connecting the arcs. They include dispersion suppressor, beam separation and recombination, RF acceleration and beam focusing sections on each side of the collision points. Each cryogenic sector includes two half insertions at the both ends of an arc. Since the detailed design of the superconducting magnets in the insertions has not yet been finalised, their expected heat loads have been assessed by approximate scaling from the better defined arc magnets. The results, displayed in Table 2, reflect the variations in geometry, layout, functions and operating modes of the different LHC insertions. They also include specific components- for example, superconducting acceleration cavities, which require significant amounts of cryogenic refrigeration as well as reference magnets for field tracking measurements. Also appearing in these tables are the localised heat loads in the current leads of the different excitation circuits, and based on the use of high-temperature superconductors. Special heat loads have to be accounted for all elements close to the high luminosity physics experiments due to absorption of secondary particles in the cold mass of the superconducting magnets located close to the experimental areas. The values for the whole machine are" - at the 1.9 K level, from 500 W (nominal) to 1250 W (ultimate) in the inner triplets of low-beta quadrupoles, as well as from 54 W (nominal) to 134 W (ultimate) in the dispersion suppressor magnets;
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
97
- at the 4.7 K level, from 240 W (nominal) to 600 W (ultimate) in the beam separation and recombination dipoles. Table 2 Total heat loads for the half insertions of the LHC machine at nominal operating conditions (no contingency included) Temperature Levels 5 0 - 75 K
4.5 - 20 K
4.7 K
1.9 K
Gas helium consumption 2 0 - 300 K
1300 1350 800 1250 1150
125 130 120 130 120
100 50 5 380 5
300 150 80 100 120
11 13 2 13 12
Half Insertion
[w]
High-luminosity insertion Low-luminosity insertion Beam-cleaning insertion RE insertion Beam-dump insertion
[w]
[w]
[w]
[g/s]
DEMANDS ON THE SECTOR CRYOPLANTS The LHC sectors stretch over 3.3 km between the insertion points. The cryogenic load for each sector comprises those a full arc and two half insertions at each end. A special load to be added for each sector is that resulting from a continuous loss of particles escaping the collimation sections, which may result in a locally deposited heat load estimated at 55 W (nominal) and 92 W (ultimate), over a length of a few tens of metres corresponding to the region of aperture restriction. The total installed cryogenic power to cope with the expected loads for the sectors is determined using a contingency calculation to include for uncertainties and overcapacity. For the heat loads at the 50 75 K and the 20 to 300 K level: Qinstalled = Max [ Fov" Qnominal ; Qultimate]; for the heat loads at the 4.5 - 20 K, 4.7 K and 1.9 K level: Qlnstalled = Max [ Fov" (Fun" Qstatic + Qdynamic nominal) ; Fun" Qstatic + Qdynamic ultimate ].
As factor for overcapacity, Fov, 1.5 is used, for uncertainty, Fun, 1.25. Table 3 shows the installed cryogenic power which results for the two types of sectors of the machine. About 250 W of the load at 1.9 K listed in Table 3 result from superheating the helium vapour in the 3.3 km long cryogenic distribution line and do not contribute to the cold compressor flow. Table 3 Installed cryogenic power requirements of the LHC Temperature Levels
Sector 5 0 - 75 K
[kW]
High-load sector Low-load sector
31.0 30.0
4.5 -20 K
[kW] 4.30 4.30
4.7 K
[kW] 0.80 0.65
1.9 K
Gas helium consumption 20 - 30O K
[kW]
[g/sl
2.80 2.45
35 23
DAILY LOAD VARIATIONS The operation phases which the machine will undergo during a 24 hour period will be four hours of injection standby, during which the storage ring will be adjusted and filled with particles, half an hour of current ramping to reach the operating energy, 19 hours of operation at nominal or eventually ultimate conditions, half an hour of current ramp down to prepare for the new injection. Current ramping will generate an additional heat load due to resistive dissipation in the superconducting magnet splices.
98
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
Figure 1 shows the development of the load on the 1.9 K level during the injection and ramp phase leading from the "injection stand-by" to the "nominal" operation mode. Although the rapid changes will be partially buffered by the heat capacity of the pressurised helium II bath, the variations in demand require load adaptation of the cryogenic system over a large dynamic range. 160
......................................................................................................
2600
14o
2400
"6 120
2000
E
i0
2200
1800
100
1600
80
j j f ~ f
r 0
~
'
1200
60 ..........
. ..........................
1000
r m ~J
20 ~J !
-5 Injection Stand-by
0 I I I
[ ,,
5 Injection
'10
800
"~ 40 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~
g
1400
-- "- - - Current
..............
6O0
Load at 1.9 K
J
400 200
I
t
10
15
I I I
>.s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
"1 20 Acceleration
I
I
25
30
I 35 I I I Beam Squeeze/ I I
t 40
0 45
Nominal Operation
Time [rain]
Figure 1 Development of the 1.9 K load of a high luminosity sector from "injection standby" over magnet ramping to "nominal" capacity operation (no contingency)
CONCLUSIONS The demands of refrigeration capacity for the LHC machine have been assessed with increasing accuracy during the recent years. As the project definition is finalised further updates of the heat loads will be necessary. Special attention has to be given to all components which at the moment are still uncertain in their performance like the insertion magnets or assessed by theoretical calculations like the HTS current leads. REFERENCES The LHC study group, The Largo Hadron Collider, Conceptual Design CERN/AC/95-05(LHC) Ballarino, A., Ijspeert, A. and Wagner, U., Potential of high-temperature superconducter current leads for LHC cryogenics, paper presented in this conference Jenny, B., Cameron, W., Riddone, G., Rohmig P. and van Weelderen, g., Design and construction of a prototype superfluid helium cryostat for the short straight sections of the CERN Large Hadron Collider, Adv. Cryo. Eng. (1994) 3 9A 663-670 Benda, V., Dufay, L., Ferlin, G., Lebmn, Ph., Rioubland, J.M., Riddone, G., Szeless, B., Tavian L. and Williams, L.R., Measurement and analysis of thermal performance of LHC prototype dipole cryostats paper presented at CEC'95 Columbus (1995) B6zaguet, A., Casas-Cubillos, J., Flemsaeter, B., Gaillard-Grenadier, B., Goiffon, Th., Guinaudeau, H., Lebrun, Ph., Marquet, M., Serio, L., Suraci, A., Tavian L. and van Weelderen, R., The superfluid helium cryogenic system for the LHC Test String: design, construction and first operation paper presented at CEC'95 Columbus (1995) Dufay, L., Ferlin, G., Lebrun, Ph., Riddone, G., Rieubland, J.M., RijUart, A., Szeless B. and Williams, L.R., A full-scale thermal model of a prototype dipole cryomagnet for the CERN LHC project Cryogenics 34 ICEC Supplement, (1994),. 693-696
Simulation Program for Cryogenic Plants at CERN
E. Melaaen, G. Owren*, A. Wadahl and U. Wagner LHC-Division, CERN, CH-1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland *Department of Refrigeration and Air Conditioning, NTNU, 7034 Trondheim, Norway
A steady-state simulation program for helium refrigeration plants at CERN has been developed. The objective was to have a tool available for analysing existing plants in connection with the LEP project, but also for studying system solutions for future plants in the LHC project. The program can simulate from single components up to complete cycles, but it can also be used for closer study of heat exchangers and expanders in a specified process. Each component is modelled by writing its energy balances, the equations are put into a unique matrix and solved. Since refrigeration cycles are mainly closed-loop processes, the program solves the complete equation system simultaneously.
INTRODUCTION To reach the necessary beam energy in the Large Electron Positron collider (LEP2) at CERN, superconducting cavities operating at 4.5 K are installed. Four 12 kW @ 4.5 K helium cryogenic plants, supplied by LINDE and L'AIR LIQUIDE, are installed for the task [1 ]. There are also other cryoplants at CERN used in connection with test facilities. During his stay at CERN, G. Owren started to develop a tool (CryoSim) for analyses and studies of existing refrigeration plants. This is the continuation and development of his work. The tool is now used to simulate existing plants, but also for process evaluation of future cryoplants for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) project. SCOPE AND CAPABILITIES OF CRYOSIM CryoSim is a robust steady-state simulation program developed for cryogenic plants, but can also be used for process simulations in general. Thermophysical properties for helium given in the commercially available package HEPAK [2] are installed. Data from HEPAK are based on fundamental state equations. Since only helium data are implemented, the program has limitations for an extended use. Other process fluids can be installed in the future. CryoSim is especially developed for off-design calculations of existing plants. The program is a useful tool for process calculations and optimization of helium liquefiers, and has been helpful in understanding and assessing the performance and efficiency for various cryoplants. Other tasks for the program can be thermodynamics studies and as a tool during specification of cryoplants. The first version of CryoSim had some limitations since the turbine efficiencies (11) were taken constant and independent of the operation conditions. In the same way the heat-transfer impedance in the heat exchangers (UA) did not vary with the mass flow. This is improved, and new models for turbine efficiency and heat-transfer coefficient varying with the flow rate are implemented. The program can now be used for simulating situations with varying cooling power or at off-design conditions with better results. 99
100
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
For a given process the flow-scheme has to be described in an input file following a predefined structure. The input file is mainly divided into two parts. The first part describes each component such as heat exchanger, valve, etc., and all necessary characterizations of the component such as pressure drops and efficiencies are given here. In addition inlet and outlet streams for each component and the connections between all components are specified. The second part of the input file gives the information about all the mass streams in the process. To specify a stream, flow rate, pressure together with enthalpy or temperature have to be given. From the given data in the input file, the program understands if a specified stream represents a boundary or an initial condition. The following components are modelled and included in the program; boiler, brake, compressor, expander, flash drum, heater, heat exchanger, mixer, pipe, splitter, subcooler and valve. The principle for modelling each component is the same, and the structure of the program makes it easy to install new component models. Heat exchangers are modelled in two different ways; one is based on a LMTDmethod (called hx), while the second method is more rigorous (called rhx). The rigorous method divides the heat exchanger into a specified number of blocks, and each heat-exchanger pass in a block is modelled separately. With this method it is possible to get out a thermodynamic description of the condition in the heat exchanger (e.g. temperature profile). Also a control facility is available in the program which can be used to update boundary conditions until specified set-points (e.g. temperature or pressure) are reached. The program can calculate the flow sheet specified in the input file in two different modes; simulation or design. In the simulation mode the process is solved as a steady-state simulation from boundary conditions and specified component parameters. Design mode uses the specified stream data to calculate the heat-transfer coefficient for heat exchangers and isentropic efficiency for expanders. The calculated results are stored in a specific output file. This file contains flow sheet data, balances for mass and energy, exergy analyses, stream data (temperature, enthalpy, entropy, density, pressure, flow rate and quality), component data (pressure drop, UA, efficiency e.g.), calculation time and information about iterations. Temperature profiles, pinch and NTU for heat exchangers are also available. To work with CryoSim it is necessary to have some basic knowledge about UNIX | and one editor available at UNIX | (e.g. emacs). For the moment the program is only running on UNIX | Figure 1 shows an example of one process together with part of its input file. The process can be regarded as the lower end of the cold box for one of the 12 kW plants at CERN. The first line in the input file describes the main cluster of components here called EXAMPLE. The second line indicates if the calculation mode is design or simulation. After this line starts a list of all member components in the cluster EXAMPLE. All components with their characterization are written in a general and fixed structure. The first line for a component starts with an identification of the component type (such as expander and rhx) and an identification name. The information describing a component is finished by the word end. The example shows the structure of one heat exchanger and one expander model. The last part of the input file specifies information of each stream in the process. Every line starting with mass gives either boundary or initial condition for one stream. PROGRAM STRUCTURE CryoSim is based on an object-oriented technique and written in the program language ANSI C | which gives the program large flexibility. The equation system for each component is set up in a unique matrix coveting the equations for the whole plant. Since refrigeration cycles mainly are closed-loop processes, the program solves the total number of equations as one large system (simultaneously) with a type of Gauss-Jordan elimination method. The results is a robust program. The components are modelled by the energy balances; therefore, the enthalpy for each stream is solved. The mass flows and pressures are updated separately by following the streams from boundary conditions and further through all the streams in the flow-scheme. For stream splitters and flash drums either split factor or draw-off rate have to be specified in the input file. Similarly must the pressure drop inside each component or outlet pressure for
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings
101
a component be specified in the input file. For a heat exchanger an option will later be available for calculating the pressure drop dependent on the flow rate.
compound EXAMPLE mode simulation rhx HE1 feeds mass str l mass str5 prods mass str2 mass str6 paraml 101-1 pspec 1 0.1 0.05 design 0 38000.0 design 1 38000.0 end expander T 1 feeds mass str2 prods mass str3 work wb 1 pspec 1 4.5 param 1 0.7 end
str9
M1
strl str6
str8
~~..'.,,. HE1
~~.:..:.
::::::::::::::::::::::::~ . . . ' . . . . ' : ' : "
~-:-:-...::,,
str2
r"wbl
I
~HI
str3
str5 i
end end mass strl tp mass str2 tp
i
7.17 4.72
V1
t
6.36 524.0 6.36 524.0
str4
I
str7
mass str8 hp 11.12 1.20 524.0 mass str9 tp 7.10 1.20 524.0 end
Figure 1 Shows the principle for an input file describing a given process [3] The equations based on the energy balances are put into the matrix and solved. A matrix solved by the Gauss-Jordan method normally requires constant coefficients, but a matrix system for a thermodynamic process has non-constant coefficients. An iteration procedure is therefore necessary for solving the system. For each iteration the coefficients are kept constant and the matrix is solved. The coefficients are updated between each iteration. When the solution vector has not changed between two iterations, the solution is reached. Figure 2 shows the program structure. Each box represents one directory, and subroutines in one directory are compiled in a library. All libraries are compiled together in the directory steady, and the result is the executable file sire. Directory CryoSim is organized into three main parts. The mat library represents the mathematical library with equation solvers, while cryodata and hepak contains the libraries for thermophysical properties. Basic contains the main structure of the program and describes the organization and storing of data. Two important structures defined in basic are the organization of streams and components. The two sub directory steady and dynsim contain respectively a steady-state
102
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
and a transient simulation program, dynsim is under preparation and, therefore, not discussed in this paper. In the directory steady steady-state models of the components are stored, and here is the main program compiled to the executable file sire. To run the program, sire must be available for the user. Plot is meant to be a tool for graphical presentation of calculated results as temperature profiles inside heat exchangers and TS-diagram for a calculated process. Plot is still under development. i
ii ii
main CryoSim directory
I I matHbrary
dynsim
l' In
'
-
-
m
m
m
m
m
m
m
m
m
m
m
m
|
!
basic i
steady
hepak
executable program sire Figure 2 Shows the directory structure of the program and links to other applications [3] CryoSim is partly tested out at CERN by comparing simulated results and measured data from running plants. These studies show good validity for the program, but a closer study is required and will be done in the near future. Especially important is it to test the heat-exchanger models and expander models at design and off-design situation. A thorough description of the program CryoSim and documentation of the validity of the models are given in [3-5]. CONCLUSION CryoSim is a robust calculation program for helium processes and cryoplants, which can be used for simulation and for limited design cases. The program is useful during analyses of existing plant and for evaluation of new processes. Since the total equation system is solved simultaneously, the program is adjusted to solve closed-loop processes as refrigeration cycles. The object-oriented structure gives the program large flexibility and possibilities for further development. CryoSim is tested at CERN, and preliminary results show good validity [3-5]. REFERENCES G0sewell, D. et al., Cryogenics for the LEP200 Superconducting Cavities at CERN, Particle Accelerator Conference (PAC93), Washington D.C., 1993 Cryodata inc., User's Guide to HEPAK, Version 3.21, Colorado, January 1993 H~ye, G.K., A Simulation Program for Helium Cryoplants, Thesis, Norwegian Institute of Technology, Trondheim, 1994 Wadahl, A., CryoPlant Process Simulation Program, Thesis, Norwegian Institute of Technology, Trondheim, 1995 Melaaen, E., User's Guide to CryoSim and System Documentation for CryoSim, in preparation, CERN, Geneva, 1996
Operation of the Cryogenic System for Superconducting Cavities in LEP
M. Barranco-Luque, S. Claudet, Ph. Gayet, N. Solheim, and G. Winkler LHC Division, CERN, CH-1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland
At CERN the upgrade of the LEP e+e - collider towards higher beam energies is under way by installing superconducting cavities in the ring. In 1995 superconducting cavity modules have been operated together with ambient temperature copper accelerating cavities allowing for a first step of energy increase. We report on the experience with the operation of the LEP cryogenic system. Particular attention is given to stability, automatic control, and reliability. Failure analysis and redundancy programs are presented which should further increase the availability of the cryogenic system in the environment of a large high energy particle collider.
INTRODUCTION The upgrade of the LEP e+e - collider from 45 GeV to 96 GeV per beam is under way by installing gradually up to 272 superconducting cavities on both sides of the four interaction points in the ring. These 352 MHz cavities are assembled in 4-cavity modules and cooled by four large cryoplants with 12kW equivalent capacity at 4.5 K. In 1995 a total of 16 modules have been operated at three LEP points in addition to the ambient temperature copper accelerating cavities allowing for a first step of energy increase from 45 to 70 GeV. After the LEP winter shut-down 1995/96 all four 12 kW/4.5 K refrigerators will be in operation with 35 out of the final 68 cavity modules, the totality of which will be operational in 1998. THE LEP2 CRYOGENIC SYSTEM The cryogenic system at each of the four interaction points of LEP, described in [1] and earlier publications, consists of a cryoplant [2,3,4] with an equivalent cooling capacity of 12 kW at 4.5 K and its associated liquid helium distribution system, a pair of about 200 m-long supply-and-return transfer lines to feed the 8 or 9 superconducting (sc) acceleration cavity modules on each side of the point. First experience with the 12 kW plants was reported in [5,6]. A description of the liquid and gaseous helium circuits inside the 11 m long 4-cavity modules, which are treated as independent cryogenic units for cooling and controls, is given in [7]. In addition to the sc cavities the low-beta quadrupoles at two LEP points are also being cooled by the 12 kW plants. As an example of the layout the cryogenic system of LEP point 2 is shown in Figure 1. CONTROLS AND AUTOMATIC OPERATION The industrial process control system [8], purchased by CERN apart from the cryoplants, has to handle equipment at 4 points evenly-spaced around the 27 km long LEP ring, with a central control room in the office building of the operation team. At each point a local control room is installed and 5 programmable control units are distributed on the surface and under ground. 1800 input/output channels are connected to the process of each cryoplant and the associated modules. The control system is programmed for fully automatic operation including cool-down, warm-up, restart 103
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
104 Surface
Transfer lines connecting upper and lower cold box
12 KW Upper Cold Box ( 300- 20K ) j
Machine tunnel RA 27
Helium
Service Tunnel UA 27 Transfer lines terminal by-pass Suoerconductino cavitv module LHe distribution system in machine tunnel RA 27
Low beta Superconducting quadrupoles 12 KW Lower Cold Box ( 20 - 4.5 K ) in US 25
LHe distribution system for 32 sc cavities in machine tunnel RA 23
Figure 1 after utility failure and adaptation of the plant capacity to reduced load. Operation can be efficiently supervised from the central control room by a small operator team, on duty only during normal working hours or on automatic call in case of failure or alarm on sensitive parameters. OPERATING CONDITIONS FOR CAVITY MODULES The inlet and outlet valves of each module are controlling the level and the pressure of the liquid helium bath. In addition a compensation of the induced dynamic radio frequency (RF) load is implemented by means of electrical heaters. An algorithm is calculating the necessary compensation power directly from a RF field strength signal and the pre-set cavity quality factor. It is important to note that the outlet valve of the module throttles the flow and thus attenuates the influence of pressure variations from one module to its neighbours, as well as variations possibly induced by the compressors suction pressure. Table 1 presents the operating conditions achieved during steady state operation and when a RF field step with typically 400W load change is applied. Table 1 Cavity module operation conditions and stability
Pressure Level
Nominal conditions 1250 mbar 800 mm
Steady state variations +/- 2 mbar +/- 5 mm
Variations by RF steps +/- l0 mbar +/- 10mm
RELIABILITY AND AVAILABILITY The four 12 kW plants have now accumulated a total of 34000 hours of operation. Fault statistics for the complete cryosystem operation (including control system) during last years' LEP runs are presented in Table 2. This includes the final 12 kW plants, as well as the now replaced 6 kW plant. It turns out that interruptions of operation were mostly related to utility failures (electricity, cooling water, etc.) and not to specific cryogenic problems. As a consequence of the failures in 1995, the non-availability of the cryosystem for RF operation of the cavities was 32 h, including normal recooling and refilling time, or 0.4 % of the total LEP running time.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
105
Table 2 Cryosystem fault statistics Year
Number of installed modules 1992 2 1993 3 1 1994 4 3 .....i995 ......................................4................................ 8 4 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
LEP point 2 2 6 2 6 2 6 8 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Cryoplant type & operation time during LEP run 6 kW 6200 h 6 kW 3800 h 12 kW 1400 h 6 kW 4600 h 12 kW 1500 h 12 kW -3900 h 12 kW 3900 h 12 kW 840 h .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Cryoplant stops cryo faults-total faults 1-7 2-8 0-2 3-14 1-3 0-3 0-4 0-0 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
After plant stops the cryogenic system will introduce unavoidable delays to the RF operation during reestablishing of steady state conditions. Table 3 shows the recovery times experienced during the last years with a small number of modules (4 to 6) and the extrapolation for 16 modules connected to one plant. It also indicates the characteristic times of the cryosystem for the most relevant operation modes. Table 3 Characteristic times for the cryosystem
t'-
2 4 T ...... " ...... r . . . . Comp. stop + 10 h ? ~ 2 0 ]Estimation for 16 m o d u l e s ~ ~
"O
1 6 T
. . . . . .
r,
1 2 +
. . . . . .
n-
o < r
I
/
r . . . . . . '
'
8 t--'~~~,
4
9. . . .
~
r-%~e~l~I~-'---~ ; ~
-
~ " J ~ ' i ' -
~
T
~
~
-"
~ ' ~
""
,
. . . . . .
'
. . . . .
" . . . . . .
,
. . . . Measured with4modules
I
I
2
4
| '
'
,
"!
I
I
I
I
6
8
10
12
0
0
Action
time
Cryoplant cool down Cryoplant warm-up Module cool down Module filling Module warm-up Module emptying (only static losses)
30 h 48 h 5h 1h 4h 1h 5h
Compressor stop (h)
CONSOLIDATION TASKS Lame storage tanks In addition to the present 10 helium gas storage tanks (each 75 m 3, 20 bar, vertical axis) at each of the four LEP points, 3 large tanks (each 250 m 3, 20 bar, horizontal axis) will be installed to allow for one complete refill of the modules in case of accidental loss of helium. Redundanev and maintenance For cost reasons the plants where originally specified and built without redundancy for critical items. To ensure minimum downtime most spares are now on stock. In view of the rather long intervention time for compressor repairs and future needs of increased flowrates for plant upgrades for the next accelerator project LHC, fully equipped redundancy compressors, one for each of the two pressure stages of each plant, are being procured from industry. It is also planned to install redundancy for vital components of the cooling water system, similar to those already in place for the compressed air supply. Most crucial for the reliability of components is the future preparation of detailed maintenance plans and the thoroughly executed preventive maintenance during the winter shut-downs of LEP. H~lium management An operating 12 kW plant is filled with 2500 Nm3 of helium. During installation, commissioning and testing about 4 times this amount has been used for each plant. The total contents of the running v
106
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
cryosystem at one point with 18 modules (550 Nm3 each) will be 15000 Nm3, 10% of this amount were lost last year during maintenance or module installation, 15% for leaks and incidents with incomplete helium recovery. Efforts must be spent on reducing these losses during next years. Ootimisation of ooeration mode~ Further work is planned to optimise the operation modes, in particular the recooling and refilling, to reduce restarting delays of the increasing number of modules. A close follow-up of the dynamic thermal losses in the modules will be implemented to minimise unnecessary load induced by the RF compensation heaters. Organi sation of operation CERN has established a contract with an experienced company to ensure operation and maintenance of all cryogenic installations at CERN. The intention is that this company gradually during a three years period will take over the operation and maintenance responsibilities with guarantee of results. While this outsourcing policy, which is now also applied to operation tasks on complex technical equipment, gives promising results after the first 9 months of the contract, much further training of new personnel and transfer of specific experience will still be necessary in the coming years. CONCLUSIONS AND OUTLOOK Operating experience with the LEP2 cryogenic system, which is at present the most powerful and efficient helium system world-wide, is very encouraging. After replacement of a defective heat exchanger in the upper coldbox of one plant, roughly the same cooling capacities have been reached at all four points. Reliability of the cryoplant components and of the control system turned out to be remarkably good. Some further work on automatic procedures, redundancies and preventive maintenance, should allow to face successfully the future demands for full capacity and high availability of the cryogenic system as part of the upgraded LEP collider. REFERENCES Gfisewell, D., .Barranco-Luque, M., Claudet, S., Erdt, W., Frandsen, P.K., Gayet, Ph., Schmid, J,, Solheim, N.O., Titcomb, C. and Winkler, G., Cryogenics for the LEP200 Superconducting Cavities at CERN, Proc. of thr P~rticlr Accel. Conf, 1993, 2956-2958 Chromec, B., .Erdt,W.K., Gfisewell ,D., LOhlein ,K., .Meier, A., .Senn, A.E., Saugy, T., Solheim, N.O., Wagner, U., Winkler, G., Ziegler, B., et. al, A High Efficient 12 kW Refrigerator for the LEP200 Project at CERN, Proc. of the IISSC 1993. Supercollider 5. Plenum Press (1994) 95-100 Gistau, G. and Veaux, J., A 12/18 kW at 4.5 K Helium refrigerator for CERN's LEP superconducting accelerating cavities, Cry_ogenics (1994) 34 ICEC Supplement 103-106 Claudet, S., Erdt, W., Frandsen, P-K., Gayet, P., Solheim, N.O., Titcomb, C. and Winkler, G., Four 12 kW/4.5 K Cryoplants at CERN, Cry_ogenics (1994) 34 ICEC Supplement 99-102 Winkler, G., Gayet, Ph., Gtisewell, D. and Titcomb, C., Cryogenics Operation and On Line Measurements of RF Losses in the SC Cavities of LEP2, Particle Accel, t~0nf, 1995 Dallas Barranco-Luque, M., Claudet, S., Dauvergne, J.P., Erdt, W., Frandsen, P-K., Gayet, P., Gtisewell, D., Lebrun, Ph., Schmid, J., Solheim, N-O., Titcomb, C., Wagner, U. and Winkler, G., Conclusions from Procuring, Installing, and Commissioning six large-scale Helium Refrigerator at CERN, CEC/ICMC 1995 Columbus Barranco-Luque, M. and Gfisewell, D., Thermal Loss Analysis of Cryostats and Accessories for the Superconducting Cavities of the LEP Energy Upgrade, Proc.of the European Particle Conf. (1994) 2455-2457 Gayet, Ph., Claudet, S., Frandsen, P-K., Juillerat, A., Kuhn, H.K., Solheim, N.O., Titcomb, Ch., Winkler, G., Wolles, J.C. and Vergult, P., "Architecture of the LEP2 Cryogenics Control System' Conception, Status, and Evaluation", Cry_ogenics (1994) 34 ICEC Supplement 83-86
Thermodynamic Booster for the CERN Omega Cryoplant
F. Haug, J.-P. Dauvergne, H. Rieder, P. Chaffard CERN - LHC Division, CH-1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland
The 800 W @ 4.5 K cryoplant, commissioned in 1971 for the superconducting magnet of the OMEGA particle detector, uses a large reciprocating compressor designed for the delivery of helium at a rate of 216 g/s at 20 bar. A recurrent problem, which overshadowed the good performance of the plant, was the rapid wear of the labyrinth-type, compressor piston seals. This was due to the high temperature of the compressed gas, a consequence of the rather high compression ratio per stage. Even very frequent maintenance did not prevent progressive loss of efficiency and lack of cooling power. A costly replacement of the compressor, by a better suited modern machine, was foreseen. Eventually, however, the problem was solved in a much cheaper way by inserting an auxiliary cooling stage between the compressor and the cold box. This was done with a commercial, fully automated, R22 refrigerator which reduced the helium temperature, at compressor suction and delivery, from ambient to about 10~ The result was not only an increase in cooling power of nearly 10 %, but also a reduction in the labyrinth wear to a level hardly expected - even by optimists!
INTRODUCTION The first large superconducting magnet installed at CERN was for the OMEGA multipurpose particle detector which permits experiments in a magnetic space of about 1.5 m height and 3 m diameter with a central field of 1.8 T. The cryoplant for its cooling was supplied by Sulzer, Switzerland and has been in operation for 25 years since its commissioning in 1971. The rapid wear of the labyrinth-type pistons seals of the compressor became a recurrent problem. This led to deficiencies in the cooling performance of the refrigerator such that it was barely sufficient to cool the magnet. After a brief description of the OMEGA refrigeration cycle, the problems encountered are analysed and the technical approach of "thermodynamic boosting" is explained. The flow scheme of the cycles are presented. The system has been successfully in operation for more than five years. THE OMEGA MAGNET AND THE CRYOGENIC SYSTEM The OMEGA magnet is made of two coils with a 3m inner diameter. They are mounted in a horizontal plane 1.5 m apart on a vertical axis. The coil is split into six, identical, double pancakes, all electrically connected in series. Each coil is powered via a set of two current leads at 4800 A. The coils are wound with a hollow superconductor, 18 x 18 mm 2, which has a central, rectangular, cooling hole of 9 x 9 mm 2. The refrigerator was designed for 500 W @ 4.5 K, 2.5 g/s for the current lead cooling, and 4000 W at 77 K for shield cooling (power is withdrawn from the helium cycle to a LN2 circuit via a He/N2 heat exchanger). The liquid nitrogen is circulated with a rotary pump. The forced flow cooling at 4.5 K is done with a J.T. flow of 45 g/s of supercritical, subcooled, helium. This at a pressure of 10 bar at the inlet to the coil system and 5 bar at its outlet. The flow is split into four branches i.e. two per coil and is subcooled three times in a cryostat by boiling helium at 1.25 bar each time before flowing through an individual section of the coil. Reference is made to publication [ 1]. An additional particularity, which adds to the complexity of the refrigerator process, is the "artificial" increase of delivery mass flow of the piston compressor. This is done by reinjection of part of the total flow at the exhaust of the first turbine back to the suction side of the third compression stage permitting to adjust and maintain the mass flow of the first turbine. The delivery mass flow is, therefore, in this case higher than the suction mass flow. The compressor is a labyrinth sealed, 3-stage, 4-piston machine, where two pistons form the first stage to provide the rather large mass flow of around 215 g/s (design value!). The helium gas is chilled after each compression stage - at interstage and after coolers with water from cooling towers to ambient temperatures. 107
108
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings :~]~III~:~I]~:]: 4 I: :] I]:I::I:::::] ::I:.~]I~I 5
II:II:- : 4
I I IIII4 ....
:I If:Ill Ill III
.....]II I] :I.... I :IIII I
I :I I
N 1/ Standard (normal) maintenace 12/ replacement of piston labyrinth seal 3d stage [] 31 replacement of piston labyrinth seal 1st, 2d, 3d stages
Il II
5
~ ~:: I I] I I
~:
: ] :I ) :
l I
~ ;: I ] IlllI:I::II I II:III ]
Ii
I:: II : IlI~:I:II ] ::III I ::I"ll
:: I :III
[] 4/remachining of 1st stage cylinders 95/remachining of 1st and 2d stages cylinders
Figure 1 Maintenance of labyrinth sealed piston compressor TECHNICAL SOLUTION Our thermodynamic boosting system was designed to help overcome the problems described above. The intentions were to: reduce wear and compression temperature, increase the mass flow, increase the thermodynamic efficiency of the refrigerator cycle, ease the of operation of the plant and reduce the maintenance costs to a minimum. Two helium/Glycol-water heat exchangers were inserted into the helium circuits between the compressor and the cold box (see schematic of fig.2). Both are of longitudinal tube type with semicounterflow of the cooling agent Glycol-water. The heat exchanger at the 1.0 bar suction level, named "WT2", with length 1.8 m and 325 mm outer diameter, consists of 189 parallel tubes each of 16 mm diameter and 1 mm wall thickness, with an active core length of 1500 mm. The heat exchanger at the 20 bar delivery side contains 48 tubes of the same type and an active core length of 1800 mm. Both provide a cooling capacity of around 20 kW with a heat exchange coefficient, between helium gas and cooling agent, of 142 W/m2K for the low pressure side and 400 W/m2K for the high pressure side. In order to minimise additional entropy production in the helium flow the pressure drops for both heat exchangers were specified to be below a constringent value of 1% of the absolute pressure. For the suction side the pressure drop was observed to be 8 mbar and for the delivery side it was even lower.
i
-
~~
Lt r - L.- . . . .
"'J
tI
LLImgIIII''J I -- ql~ IeIIJ
I
PISTON i_ ~ r . . . .WTl" . --I~
11
II
I I I
I
I 0 .
.
.
I
.
- - ~ - , -
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
WAIER GL~OL r. . . . . . .
I
~
Figure 2 Flow scheme of thermodynamic booster
i I I
I
tx~----4
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
I RETURN
I I I
HE/WATER GLYKOL HEAT EXCHANGERS (WT2/WT1)
HeHP I'l 18.Sbor
A
/
I I I
~JJXl~
l
HELIUM/WATER INTE~TAGECO01FRS
' I
I
-II I
TO OI~EGAMAGNET
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
109
PROBLEMS AND THEIR ANALYSIS Despite the sophisticated, thermodynamic approach, to refrigeration requirements in the "early days" of large scale cryogenics, it was observed over the years of operation that the performance reserve of the refrigerator was very narrow and was continuously decreasing. This was particularly apparent in the warm seasons when ambient temperatures went above 25~ causing a parallel temperature rise in the cooling water for the compressor. This water being chilled by a cooling tower. As a consequence, the helium temperature at the suction side of the compressor and at the other two compression stages increased. Hence the mass flow decreased and the compression temperature, after each stage, increased. This at a constant pressure ratio caused progressively faster wear of the compressor labyrinth piston seals and the cylinder walls. Also the performance of the refrigerator decreased. In order to avoid a break down of the cryoplant an upper limit of compression temperature had to be respected. To achieve this the pressure ratio was reduced by the operators to obtain a delivery pressures of 18.5 bar and less instead of 20 bar. The wear of these seals produced another negative effect which was the reduced sealing efficiency of the labyrinth pistons. This led to a gas flow from the compression side to the suction side of the double acting pistons which added to the wake space of the remaining, not expulsed gas in the cylinder. The decreasing compression efficiency could be measured again by an increase of temperature. Thermodynamically this can be expressed in terms of the polytropic exponent "n" which increases. Following costly maintenance work, data was finally taken in the 1990's, during the running of the compressor, and the situation was then analysed. We have observed that with 6 months of operation, after maintenance of the compressors, the following: a) a loss in mass flow of 6.5 % occurred, b) increase in the polytropic exponent n (decrease of compression efficiency) by 7.0 % for the first stage, 8.6 % for the second and 7.5 % for the third stage, leading to increased temperatures. PERFORMANCE LIMITS The negative changes of the cryogenic performances were perceptible: 1) At the level of the mass flow rate which decreased sometimes as low as 86 % of the design value to 186 g/s during critical periods. 2) By the performance reserve of the refrigerator, at the 4.5K level, which in a normal case should be situated above 100 W reached 0 Watt. 3) By the liquid nitrogen cooling agent for magnet screens and mechanical supports which could not be maintained at the normal value of 76K by the helium/LN2 heat exchanger and approached temperatures of close to 80K. This endangered the nitrogen turbo pump which may fail by cavitation of boiling LN2 and stop pumping. 4) By the frequent interventions of the cryogenics operations crew. Occasionally the current of the magnet had to be reduced to levels which would have prevented the operation of the experiment. WEAR/MAINTENANCE The number of interventions and the cost for corrective maintenance increased with time and reached a peak in the second half of the 1980's. The type of maintenance intervention carried out during the experiment shut down periods between 1985 and 1995 are listed and plotted as illustrated in fig.1. We have defined 5 types of interventions which are: 1) standard (normal) maintenance, 2) replacement of piston labyrinth seal 3d stage, 3) replacement of piston labyrinth seal 1st, 2d, 3d stages, 4) remachining of 1st stage cylinders, 5) remachining of 1st and 2d stage cylinders. In fact not only the labyrinth seals of the piston underwent wear but also the cylinder walls. Therefore, in this period, almost every year the cylinder breech block had to be dismounted and delivered to Sulzer workshops for machining and repair. These were costly and cumbersome exercises. At each machining intervention the cylinder walls were reduced in thickness and its critical minimum value for the integrity of the mechanical structure was approached. As even these very frequent and costly maintenance operations were insufficient to prevent progressive loss of efficiency and guarantee the correct functioning of the plant in 1990, the replacement of the compressor by a better suited, modern machine, was envisaged. However, not only would this solution have been expensive (more than one million Swiss francs) it would have necessitated the interruption of the Omega's experimental programme for a full physics period while the new compressor was installed. Eventually, the problem was solved in a much cheaper and quicker way by inserting an auxiliary cooling stage between the compressor and the cold box. This to reduce the helium temperature at the suction side and at the delivery stage of the existing piston compressor.
110
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
THE REFRIGERATOR, FUNCTIONING The R-22 Freon based refrigerator, AERMEC type RAX212, with cooling capacity of 50 kW, is driven by two Maneurop compressors of 9 kW electric input power each. For condensation of the R-22 Freon the refrigerator has a twin condenser battery (heat sink) with air heat exchangers of 132 m 2 cooling surface cooled by two air ventilators delivering 20000 m3/hr. The condensed Freon is expanded through thermally isolated evaporator/heat exchanger where the Glycol-water mixture is recooled. The refrigerator circuit is internally regulated by means of a thermostatic expansion valve which modulates the evaporation rate of Freon as a function of the thermal load. The water-glycol temperature is in turn controlled by an electronic, multistage, thermostat driven by a temperature sensor located at the input of the evaporator and acting on a three-way bypass control valve. The water-Glycol mixture is circulated with a pump. The hydraulic scheme of the system is presented in fig.2. The cooling system, i.e. the auxiliary refrigerator RAX and the two heat exchanger are installed in the compressor hall adjacent to the piston compressor at a distance of some 80 metres from the cold box. The auxiliary refrigerator RAX is in operation during the complete run of the OMEGA main helium cryoplant. The helium gas temperatures are regulated to the desired values as adjusted by the operators. PERFORMANCE Comparative measurements of the performance of the OMEGA refrigerator have been made, with and without the auxiliary refrigerator RAX, and observations of the benefits made. At nominal operation conditions, i.e. a fully charged magnet at 4800 A and at 25 ~ ambient, the temperature of the suction flow was cooled to 10 ~ while the high pressure delivery gas was at 13~ An increase in refrigeration spare capacity from 40 W to 120 W was measured, i.e. a net gain at the 4.5K level of 80 W. Also, due to the increase in mass flow, the re-injection rate to the third stage of the compressor could be reduced by 10 %. The gain on the 80 K level was approximately 350 W. At the same time the temperature of the LN2 circuit dropped from around 79 down to 76 K, thus reducing the risk of boiling nitrogen and failure of the pump. Just in case of necessity the RAX refrigerator could operate at much lower temperatures providing helium gas, for example, at close to 0~ This would further increase the performance of the OMEGA refrigerator. However, we have found that in normal cases this additional performance is not needed and the gas temperature is in general maintained between 8 and 12~ ECONOMICS/MAINTENANCE As can be seen in the graph of fig. 1, the number of interventions for maintenance was drastically reduced from the date of installation of the booster. In fact, in the years 1992, 93, 94 only standard maintenance was required. In the year 1995 a 3d stage labyrinth seal was exchanged in addition. The cost saving, due to greatly reduced maintenance, is noticeable, as is the ease of operation with reduced rates of troubleshooting which has also become an important factor. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We would like to thank D. Campi for his assistance in the selection of the auxiliary refrigerator. The important contributions of G. Cuccuru, M. Bongiovanni and F. Rodriguez to the success of this plant are acknowledged. REFERENCE Morpurgo, M., " The Design of the Superconducting Magnet for the 'Omega' Project", Particle Accelerators, Gordon and Breach, Science Publisher LTD, Glasgow, Scotland, 1970
Refrigeration System for the Atlas Experiment
F. Haug 1, j.p. Dauvergne 1, G. Passardi 1, D. Cragg 2, C. Cure 3, P. Pailler 3, C. Mayri 3, A. Yamamoto 4 1CERN - LHC Division, CH-1211, GENEVA 23, Switzerland 2RAL, Chilton, DIDCOT OX11 0QX, UK 3CEA, Saclay, Gif-sur-Yvette, F-91191, France 4KEK, Tsukuba 305, Japan
The ATLAS detector of the 27 km circumference LHC collider is of unprecedented size and complexity. The magnet configuration is based on an inner superconducting solenoid and large superconducting air-core toroids (barrel and two end-caps) each made of eight coils symmetrically arranged outside the calorimetry. The total cold mass approaches 600 tons and the stored energy is 1.7 GJ. The cryogenic infrastructure includes a 6
[email protected] K refrigerator, a precooling unit and distribution systems and permits flexible operation during cool-down, normal running and quench recovery. A dedicated LN2 refrigeration system is required for the three liquid argon calorimeters (84 m 3 of LAr). Magnets and calorimeters will be individually tested prior to their definitive installation at a large scale cryogenic test area. The experiment is scheduled to be operational in 2005.
INTRODUCTION ATLAS [1 ] will be one of four particle detectors designed for the exploitation of the LHC's capabilities for experiments with colliding protons and heavy ions. All of them envisage solutions with superconducting coils at 4.5 K [2]. The extent to which the ATLAS will use superconducting technology is unprecedented in complexity. This complexity is reflected in the associated helium cryogenic system. An equally complex refrigeration system is needed for the cooling of the three liquid argon calorimeters. The paper describes the cryogenic infrastructure to be installed at the LHC's collider point 1 at CERN, the refrigeration system and the operational scenarios we have studied and defined to date. The design of the ATLAS magnets and calorimeters is an intemational undertaking with contributions from laboratories in Europe, Japan and the USA. THE TOROIDAL MAGNET COMPLEX AND ITS CRYOGENICS The Barrel Toroid (BT) and the two End Cap Toroid magnets (ECT) produce a large volume toroidal magnetic field for the muon spectrometry. The BT is made of 8 rectangular coils with a length of 26 m and a height of 5 m. They are arranged around the central beam axis in the form of a cylinder with 19.5 m outer diameter [3]. The ECT's consist each of 8 rectangularly shaped coils housed in a common vacuum vessel of an outer diameter of 10.5 m. Peak field is 4 T at nominal current of 20 kA. The refrigerant flow is split in eight parallel circuits for each of the three magnet subsystems [4]. The cooling mass flow under normal operation conditions is ~600 g/s of two-phase helium for the BT magnets and ~300 g/s for each ECT circulated by means of a turbo pump backed up with a second identical one for redundancy [5]. For the BT a 5000 liter dewar and for each ECT a 1600 liter dewar provide sufficient autonomy for slow discharge in case of failure of the refrigerator. In case of fast discharge the stored energies of 1.1 GJ for the BT and 0.25 GJ for each ECT will be dumped in the cold mass of the magnets which heat up to 58 K (BT) and 53 K (ECT's) respectively. 111
112
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
THE SOLENOID AND ITS CRYOGENICS The comparatively small solenoid of length 5.3 rn and inner diameter of 2.4 m is designed to provide an uniform magnetic field of 2 T at 8 kA for the inner tracker. Supercritical helium from common refrigerator is sub-cooled in a control dewar (250 liter) and expanded by using a J.T. valve to provide two-phase helium (7 g/s) close to full liquid phase. The liquid helium in the dewar also serves for secure slow discharge of the magnet. The solenoid is housed in the same vacuum vessel of the liquid argon barrel calorimeter to minimise the amount of material along the particles trajectories. THE HELIUM CRYOGENICS INFRASTRUCTURE A dedicated helium cryogenic plant and infrastructure is proposed to be installed at CERN's LHC point 1 (see fig. 1). It mainly consists of 1) at surface level: screw compressors, He storage tanks, a recuperation and purification system 2) at underground cryogenics service cavern: cold box, precooling unit 3) at main detector cavern: distribution system, local cryogenics for the four magnet subsystems. Based on the thermal budget of the magnets (see table 1) we presently foresee a refrigerator of 6
[email protected] and a compressor flow of 500 g/s (1-20 bar). Detailed studies are envisaged taking various scenarios into account such as precooling, baseline operation, recovery from fast discharge, permitting an optimisation of the thermodynamic cycle. The thermal budget of the four magnets is 2550 W of isothermal refrigeration at 4.5 K, 10.3 g/s of liquefaction for cooling of four pairs of current leads, and 10600 W for the thermal shields (feed 40 K, return 80 K). For the cooling of the magnets from 300 to 100 K, a dedicated precooling unit with a LN2/He heat exchanger will be installed. The 23 m3/d of LN2 required during cool down is supplied from two 50 m 3 storage tanks at the surface and the helium mass flow is withdrawn from the compressor/refrigerator circuit. COMPRESSORBUILOING SURFACE BUILDINGS
[LN2STORBGE HELIUM GAZ STORFEE. FICCESSSISqFTS TO EXPERIMENTCAVERN \
~;~ IBm
,,j~1
CRTLRS EXPERIMENT~) CONTROL
'\
/
SIDE GALLERY FOR CRYOGENICLINES
ENO-EAP TOROIO CONTROL OEWAR 9PUMP
SOLENOID OEWAR
HELIUM REFRICERATORS KW MAC;NETSPRECOOLINGUNIT LAR PRECOOLINQUNIT LN2 REFRIGERATOR HELIUIN-AIRHEAT EXCHANGER
\
BARREL TOROIO CONFROLDEWFIR .SIDE . . CAVERN . .
BARRELE CNFoIp_TOROIOToRO Nt:::~NE ID ~ TS ~
'
_L~~. - I -
'
I I I ~
l I / ~ -i ~ ' ~"~~ ' ~~W
MP~NET
r ~~
~ v~
~
~
CON PUMP TRoLENOE -F#~OEWFR IO I ROO I
0
~He o~, BARREL OaLORIMETER_~_// END-CAP CALORIMETER
}-Clip TOROIO MAGNET
UNOERr-ROUND CFIVERN
mTeO'ZOOPL 27-oe-gs o~J~o~-r
Figure 1 3-D view of cryogenics areas of the ATLAS experiment; surface buildings, side cavern and main detector cavern. Cut out view of the detector showing the superconducting magnets and liquid argon calorimeters arrangement.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings Table 1
113
Cryogenics parameters for the refrigeration systems of the ATLAS magnets and calorimeters. BT = Barrel Toroid Magnets, ECT = End Cap Toroid Magnet, ECC = End Cap Calorimeter.
Helium Cryogenics
Argon Calorimeter Cryogenics
Baseline operation Conditions BT 2 ECT Solenoid Liquid volume m3 Cold mass tons 350 214 5.5 Cold mass Shield tons 25 45 0.5 Stored energy GJ 1.1 0.5 0.04 Load 40 to 80K kW 6.3 4.02 0.28 Load4.5 K kW 1 . 2 4 1.22 0.09 Current leads g/s 3 6 1.3 Total equiv. 4.5 K kW 2.03 2.13 0.24 Refrigerator (with contingency)@4.5 equiv, kW Compressor mass flow (1-20 bar) g/s Cool down operation conditions
Total 15 570 71 1.7 10.6 2.55 10.3 4.50 6 500
Time 300/i00 K (pre-cooling unit) Time 100/4.5 K (refrigerator) (AT max = 40K) total Average cool-down power He mass flow pre-cooling unit (300-100 K) LN2 consumption
days
28
days
]2
days kW g/s m3/d
40 43 220 23
.
.
.
.
.
.
,,
Liquid volume Cold mass Isoth.load 89 K
Barrel 44 130
m3 tons kW
2 ECC 40 440
Total 84 570 19.1
LN2 refrigerant flow
I m3/d
I 14
LN2 refrigerator
[kW
[25
Time 300 K/89 K (He/LN2 pre-cooler) (AT max = 40K)
total
days
40
HELIUM DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM The refrigerants are distributed via a low loss transfer line system linking the precooler unit and the refrigerator of the side cavern to the cryogenics equipment of the main cavern. Our modular design of connecting the magnet subsystem as shown in fig.2 permits operational flexibility in cool down, baseline running and recovery modes. Feed and return flows of any defined temperature level at baseline load (supercritical He at 4.5 K, shield cooling 40/80K) form a closed circuit via a bypass at the end of the transfer line. For the precooling we foresee an independent line following the same principle. For reasons of thermodynamic optimisation, the enthalpy of the cold return gas is utilised in the refrigerator and/or the precooler (no heaters will be installed for warming up the helium gas flows). Pre-Cooler ,, .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
i..
40K
P
,[,~
,,
BOK
z .
.
.
.
.
i.
4.5K I]
I'
]__E~ ,o,o,d
Barrel Toroid
+ Current Leads . . . .
I
'LI
i
I
.
9
=__
!
P
1
H Compressors] it.. _ | ]High Pressure
End Cop Toroid 1 ,
....
I
.......
Solenoid
{
M
.
30OK- Low Pressure l bar ..... =
.....
I
.....
20bar r
Figure 2 Helium Distribution System for the ATLAS Magnets. FUNCTIONING The normal cool down procedure foresees all magnet subsystem cooled in parallel from ambient to -~100 K by means of the LN2 precooler unit (limits on magnets: temperature gradients of 40 K and 2.5 K/h). From -~100 K to 4.5 K the refrigerator's J.T. flow will be used. However, sequential cooling of the magnets can be carried out. In both cases the total cool down time will be -~40 days.
114
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
The modular design of the He distribution system permits the magnet subsystem to be run under different conditions if required. For example, one magnet could be in cool down mode from ambient while the remaining are already operating at 4.5 K. In another configuration one or more magnet(s) may be in quench recovery mode while the others are kept cold. Recovery time for any quenched magnet subsystem will not exceed four days. Various post-quench situations will be studied and optimal solutions investigated for different operational scenarios. THE LAR CALORIMETERS AND REFRIGERATION SYSTEM The three liquid argon calorimeters, with a total liquid inventory of 84 m 3 are: the barrel electromagnetic calorimeter (dimensions of vessel 4.5 m o.d., length 6.8 m) and the two end cap (both electromagnetic and hadronic) calorimeters 4.5 m o.d., length 3.3 m. The equipment of the dedicated LAr refrigeration system are located at 1) floor level: nitrogen compressor (for the LN2) refrigerator, LN2 storage tanks, helium compressor 2) the underground cryogenics service cavern: LN2 refrigerator (25 kW), precooling unit (He/LN2) 3) the main cavern: 2 LAr storage tanks each 50 m 3, LN2 buffer tank of 20 m 3, local auxiliary cryogenics. Precooling of the calorimeters from ambient temperature to 89 K in 40 days uses He/LN2 heat exchange. Helium at 1-3 bar is circulated with a compressor. At operational temperatures, the calorimeters are purged and filled with LAr delivered by truck from the surface area. Internal cooling of the LAr is done either directly with LN2 or indirectly with an intermediate LAr circuit (design decision pending) in horizontally heat exchanger tubes. The LN2 refrigerator provides the cooling for all operational modes (cool down, normal operation at 89 K) of the detectors. The 20 m 3 of LN2 in the main cavern is designed to give more than a day of autonomy in case of failure of the LN2 refrigerator. An additional back-up utilises the LN2 (2 x 50 m 3) from the tanks at the surface level. If necessary, the complete liquid inventory of any or all cryostats can be drained into the 100 m 3 LAr storage tanks near to the detector in the main cavern. THE ATLAS TEST FACILITY HALL All the cryogenic components must be tested prior to their final installation in the underground cavern. This will be carried out in a large experimental hall with 10.000 m 2 of surface area which will be transformed into a cryogenics test facility permitting individual tests of BT and ECT magnets and the three liquid argon calorimeters. Four test stands will be required for the BT magnets which will be operated in parallel. Helium precooling units both for the magnets and calorimeters will be provided. A helium cryoplant already existing at CERN with a capacity of 1200
[email protected] K will be used. The stringent schedule, especially the arrival of a pre-series prototype barrel magnet coil with approximately 1/3 of the length of the final magnets requires this test facility to be available in 1999, well before the start of delivery of the series magnets planned for 2001. REFERENCES 1 ATLAS collaboration, "ATLAS Technical Proposal", (~ERN/LHCC/94-43, Geneva, 1994 2 Bremer J., Dauvergne J.P., Delikaris D., Delmelle N., Haug F., Passardi G., Rieubland J.M., Kesseler G., "Cryogenics for CERN Experiments. Past, Present and Future", this conference 3 Baze J.M. et al., "Progress in the Design of a Superconducting Toroidal Magnet for the ATLAS Detector of LHC", 14th Int. Conference on Magnet Technology, Tampere, Finland, 1995 4 Cragg D., "The Cryogenic System of the ATLAS Experiment End Cap Toroids", this conference 5 Mayri C., Cur6 C., Duthil R., Cragg D., Haug F,.Passardi G., "Barrel Toroid Cryogenic System for the ATLAS Detector", this conference 6 Tanaka K., Yamamoto A., Doi Y., Haruyama T., Kondo T., Makida Y., "Cryogenic Design of the ATLAS Thin Superconducting Solenoid Magnet", this conference
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
115
The Cryogenic System of the ATLAS Experiment End Cap Toroids
Derek Cragg Applied Science Department, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Chilton, Didcot, Oxon, OX11 0QX, UK.
The ATLAS Experiment proposed for the Large Hadron Collider will use a toroidal magnet system to achieve high efficiency muon momentum resolution. The End Cap Toroids (ECT's) are designed to provide bending powers in the range 4-8 Tesla-metres over the rapidity span 1.5-2.8 in the important forward/backward regions. Each ECT will have an outer diameter of approximately 11 metres, a length of 5 metres and a weight of 190 tonnes. They will each have eight separate coils and a single integral radiation shield which will all be contained in a common cryostat.
INTRODUCTION The muon spectrometer of the ATLAS general-purpose pp detector will be based on the configuration of large superconducting air-cored toroids shown in Figure 1 and will consist of a long barrel toroid (BT) and two inserted ECT's to generate the large field and strong bending power required. One ECT is shown withdrawn from its normal operating position to allow access to internal detectors. The Rutherford Appleton Laboratory will be responsible for the design of the ECT's [1] and this paper describes the cryogenic design.
END CAP TOROID WITHD RAWN
E N D CAP TOROID IN S E R T E D
BARREL TOROID
Figure 1 ATLAS superconducting toroid magnet system. The ECT's will be designed to provide bending powers in the range 4-8 Tesla metres over the rapidity span 1.5 - 2.8 in the forward/backward regions. While the BT design will be based on an open structure with 8 coils in individual cryostats the ECT design will be based on mounting 8 coils in a single large vacuum vessel approximately 11 metres in diameter and 5.6 metres in length.
116
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
HELIUM REFRIGERATION SYSTEM The ATLAS helium refrigeration system will supply the BT, the two ECT's and a cemrally located solenoid. It will be designed to have the capacity to cool the whole ATLAS magnet system down in 40 days and to supply the peak demand required during base temperature operation, i.e. all the magnets charging at the same time. In order to give the necessary flexibility of operation, the system will be divided into two discrete components: a liquid nitrogen cooled pre-cooler and a helium refrigerator. The pre-cooler covers the temperature range from 300K to ~100K and will cool down and warm up the magnets: - both relatively infrequent processes. The helium refrigerator will cover the temperature range below ~100 K and will supply helium gas at 40K to the radiation shields and supercritical helium at---4.5K to the coil system during cool down and operation at base temperature.
CRYOGENIC DESIGN The main structural components of an ECT are shown in Figure 2. The current leads, which are not shown, will be installed vertically inside the services turret. SERVICES TURRET
VACUUM SEL
\
I
RADIATION SHIELD
/
/ ~
"~'..,,.\~//~"~'~-~~'-.-~
COIL COLD MASS
Figure 2 Main cryogenic components of an ECT. The heat load into the radiation shields will be minimised by using 30 layers of superinsulation. It will not be considered necessary to superinsulate the coil structure, only to reduce the emissivity of the surfaces by mechanically polishing the metal components and by covering the exposed plastic surfaces with aluminium foil. This has proved to be the most cost effective solution in the past for large cryogenic systems and will give a low value for the radiative heat leak into the system [2]. The current leads will be designed to take the high pressures developed during a fast discharge and will be cooled directly by using two-phase helium returning to the buffer/storage dewar from the coil cooling circuits. The cryogenic parameters of a single ECT cryogenic system are given in Table 1. Cool Down During cool down from 300K to ~100K it will be important to avoid thermally induced stress caused by imposing too high a temperature differential across the cold mass. The limits chosen for the ECT's are a cool down rate not to exceed 2.5 K/hour and a temperature differential not to exceed 40K. In order to simplify the control system and to avoid problems met by cooling the radiation shields and coils separately their cooling circuits will be connected in series during this period. The mass flow rate required from the pre-cooler to cool an ECT down from 300K-100K in 33 days will be --40 grams/second.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
117
Table 1 Cryogenic parameters of a single ECT. Parameter Cold mass Radiation heat load Conduction heat load from supports Coil charge/discharge Heat load from local cryogenics Maximum heat load from helium pump Operating current Current lead helium consumption Refrigerator demand at base temperature Helium pump mass flow rate
Radiation Shield 22500 kg (22.5 tonnes) 1380 W 330 W 75W
Coil 107000 kg (107 tonnes) 300 W 29 W 56W 25W
-
125 W
0.0086 kg/s (8.6 gm/sec) -
20000 A 0.003 kg/s (90 litres/hr) 0.028 kg/s (28 gm/sec) 0.28 kg/s (280 gm/sec)
Below 100K these thermal restrictions will not apply so it will be possible to connect the radiation shields and the coils directly to the refrigerator, cooling down the shields with 40K helium gas and the coils with supercritical helium. The coils will be cooled in the same way during the recovery from a fast discharge. If the helium refrigerator capacity needed to run the ECT coils at base temperature is used to cool them down from ~100K and recover them from a fast discharge the cool down times will be ~7 days and ~2 days respectively. Base Temperature Operation The radiation shields will be designed to run with a temperature differential across them of 40K, i.e. they will return helium to the refrigerator at a temperature of 80K. In order to avoid a fast discharge when a refrigerator fault occurs, the coils will be cooled during base temperature operation by pumping two-phase helium round the cooling circuits from a buffer/storage dewar. The two phase helium will be produced by expanding supercritical helium from the refrigerator through a JT valve. Flow instabilities in the coil cooling circuits will be prevented by pumping the twophase helium at a mass flow rate which will return it to the dewar with a liquid content of not less than 90% (quality factor 0.1).
CRYOGENIC SYSTEM The proposed layout of the cryogenic system is shown in Figure 3. Internal Cryogenic System The internal cryogenic system of an ECT will not contain a significant volume of helium and will consist simply of the current leads and the cryogenic cooling circuits of the radiation shields and the coils. Local Cry.ogenic System The local cryogenic system of an ECT will consist of a valve box, a buffer/storage dewar, two helium pumps and the connecting transfer lines. Because space within the experimental cavern will be at a premium and high magnetic fields will be present in the detector region, the valve boxes, buffer/storage dewars and the helium pumps will be placed at the wall of the cavern on a high level gantry. The proposed flow diagram of the local cryogenic system for a single ECT is shown in Figure 4. The valve box will contain all the control valves required to cool down/warm up and run an ECT at base temperature and all the pressure relief valves needed to protect the system during fault conditions and fast discharges of the coil. In the event of a refrigerator failure the buffer/storage dewar will have sufficient capacity to enable the coil to be discharged from full current in about 2 hours.
118
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings LOCAL CRYOGENICS
TOROIDS
REFRIGERATION PLANT
BUFFER DEWAR AND HELIUM PUMPS
END CAP TOROIDS
TRANSFER LINES
GROUND LEVEL
VALVE BOXES
i
.....................
GANTRY
]!Zi :!iU~i:i!iiii! ~li:i:i!ii;i~i:.i.i.i.i:.;.i.U..i.ii:iil;!i!ii:ii DEWA AND HELIUM V::~:i~::.i:i~:~:~i;.:i~) [~ii
......9.................:.....:................~...................9....... [,':.I:!::[:::':::"~:::'::~":"::":::::"LiQU' ...............I..::;....l......i.../ eumps ~ H H NITROGEN [:::!:::~~ .................................. ~.~:i'!~-!. . . . . . . .').:: PRE-COOLER :.:"~.~...... :! RIGID 1i[.:.:.,.:.,:i.;~!::,~.,:i:;.~.U: :.:,:?.:7:.i.:;i. : ....:...:..[.:i:t::.,;:::=.=. . . . . ===========7==================]======= TRNSFER LINE [!i[. . . . . . . . . . . . . ]"/1 HELIUM ]:~ MAIN I E IOE AZO I HALL BUFFER
TOROID AND SOLENOID
i
t
!
Figure 3 Layout of the ECT cryogenic system. v1 1 END CAP TOROID
VALVE BOX
300K - 80K
V2
V
7
~
300K -4.5K 9 40K
. I
RADIATION SHIELDS
J
v4
80K 4.5K
COIL
~]:
9 4.5K 2
HELIUM PUMPS
....
-+v-!-4 LIQUID HELIUM / STORAGE/BUFFER .... ] DEWAR
Figure 4 Flow diagram of the local cryogenic system for a single ECT. The two helium pumps will be proprietary centrifugal pumps and each will have the capacity necessary for normal operation. One will be on line while the other will be held in reserve should the first develop a fault. Since the ECT's will need to be moved out of their operating positions during shut down periods they will be connected to their respective valve boxes by flexible cryogenic transfer lines. All the other transfer lines will be of the conventional rigid, tube-in-tube variety.
REFERENCES The AECT reference design report, RAL report AECT/5 5/96 (1996). Cragg, D., Thermal and vacuum insulation for large cryostats, RAL report AECT/56/96 (1996).
Cryogenic Design of the ATLAS Thin Superconducting Solenoid Magnet Ken-ichi Tanaka, Akira Yamamoto, Yoshikuni Doi, Yasuhiro Makida, Tomiyoshi Haruyama, Takahiko Kondo, National Laboratory for High Energy Physics, KEK 1-10ho, Tsukuba, Ibaraki, 305, Japan Cryogenic characteristics of a thin superconducting solenoid magnet has been studied for a high energy particle-detector, ATLAS, in the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) project at CERN. The thin solenoid wound with aluminum stabilized superconductor is indirectly cooled by forced flow of two-phase helium in serpentine cooling tube on the outer support cylinder of the coil. This report describe a cryogenic design of the thin solenoid magnet and its cooling system. INTRODUCTION A thin superconducting solenoid magnet is planned to be developed for the ATLAS detector which is one of major particle detector systems in the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) project at CERN [1, 2]. It is designed to provide a central magnetic field of 2T in a warm-bore volume of 2.3 m in diameter and 5.6 m in length for precise momentum measurement of secondary particles produced in 14 GeV proton-proton head-on collisions in the LHC accelerator. Since the solenoid is required to be as thin ( and transparent) as possible in terms of radiation length for particles to traverse the solenoid magnet wall with minimum interaction. The solenoid coil is wound with aluminum stabilized superconductor on inner surface of an outer support cylinder, and is cooled indirectly by using two-phase helium flow in serpentine cooling pipe welded on outer surface of a coil support cylinder. The resource cryogen is supplied by a common large refrigerator for whole ATLAS detector magnet system consisting of toroidal magnets and a solenoid magnet [3,4,5].This report describes a cryogenic design of the ATLAS solenoid and associated interface to the expected common refrigerator system for the ATLAS superconducting magnet system. SOLENOID COIL AND CRYOSTAT The solenoid coil consists of a single layer-coil wound with aluminum-stabilized superconductor and an outer support cylinder as shown in Fig. 1. The coil is directly wound inside the support cylinder made of high-strength aluminum alloy. A total cold-mass thickness of 43 mm resulting in a cold mass of 5 tons has been determined with an optimization of E/M (stored energy / cold mass) ratio of 8.4 kJ/kg [6]. It enables to absorb a full stored energy of 42 MJ into the cold mass with an averaged coil temperature rise of about 80 K, in case of quench. The temperature rise may be homogenized with fast thermal propagation given by axial pure-aluminum strips placed on inner coil surface [6]. Major coil design parameters are summarized in Table 1. Fig. 2 shows an isometric view of the coil structure. A cooling pipe with an inner diameter of 18 mm is welded to the outer surface of the outer support cylinder. The single serpentine path has 24 axial passes with a circumferencial pitch of 33 cm. The cold mass is supported by 12 triangle-supports made of glass fiber reinforced plastic (GFRP) at each axial end of the coil structure. The triangle supports are designed to provide combined functions in supporting against the expected maximum load within 3 G. A coil end is axially fixed by the support and the other end is axially free to allow axial thermal shrinkage according to the coil cool-down. The radial shrinkage may be allowed by radial tilting of all triangle supports. .... Table 1. Design parameters of the ATLAS solenoid. Coil Inner Radius 1.218 m Coil Half Length 2.65 m Central Field 2.0 T Peak Field 2.6 T Nominal Current 8,000 A Stored Energy 42 MJ FJM Ratio 8.4 kJ/kg 119
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
120
\',\\,i", i i\\ ",\~,\\ SUPPER INSURATION COOLING TUBE " \ -,, ',,'\ \ ", \-.~... TRIANGLE SUPPORT L ~ CURRENT RETURN B US ,,",. ",.. ....., ~.--_____~ . . . . ~ ..... Xx__ \ _f /" " ",,X "..... ", "'~ ....::-_~EI]Hiil[I]~[~III~[~iil~U~-~I~IINIlL[[fflJ-L1;~__~-_-~_~--- i \~ "9 ~ " ~
~
~
-'~...._
~ - - - - - - - - - _ _ _ ~ l a -~--=------=" . . . . . \\ II 1-771 ----=_,_'C2-AL , , [.)(.:.:..) :.:.:.:.:;.:.:. : :...:.: qk.:-..~:.,.,:2..........~.::.:.i'::' . ' . . . . . . . ......
TL."--:-~[ "
[-t. . . .
IR1 o05,. ,.
3000
-/12"-1 I, .(d / . _ (~ 3o0p" ......."
2800
- "~--~,"~,-~---.-~_-~-------~-I--R1300 ' '[ ( ; I k.., i
~ ......... I ~ _ = _ ~ _ C Q I L - _
|R1150i SUPPER INSURATIO~|R1305 ~ ......... ~............. ~. . . . . . . . . . .
' ......
R1400
r
~
--__
-1--R1200
JR1215lR1923_ / /; \,., 1(1910) 1(1218)
t - 2 6 ,~, . . +- _ _ _ _ ~
2600
(1320)
.i .... .}., ; " - " : '
. . . . . " RADIATION SHIELD.
Rll00
(
2400
I dimension " room temperature (cold condition)
I
Fig. 1. Cross section of the axial end of the ATLAS solenoid coil and cryostat. Cooling pipe
.....~.
Triangle support
,...,
..j
:~iii
!
"~r ..... ,=_a:~___.....
Fig. 2. An isometric view of the cooling tube and the coil support scheme. To save material to be used in the cryostat, the coil is installed into a common vacuum vessel with another cold detector component, Liquid-Argon Calorimeter (LAr-Cal) and its cryostat. No outer radiation shield is provided because of the inner wall of the Liquid-Argon calorimeter cryostat which may provide a thermal boundary at 80 K. The inner radiation shield is provided for an intercept against thermal radiation from the inner vacuum warm bore tube. As shown in Fig. 3, the cryogen lines and the superconducting leads of the solenoid extend through other detectors in an 10 m long chimney to a control dewar, which is located outside top of the muon detector at the axial detector-center. The control dewar provides optimized cryogen flow into the solenoid magnet in various cooling modes, and supplies cold gas flow to current leads passing through the control dewar. CRYOGENIC DESIGN Thermal loads In a steady state, the net thermal load into the ATLAS solenoid magnet is estimated to be about 50 W at 4.2 K and about 450 W at a radiation shield temperature of 6 0 - 80 K. An eddy current loss of about 20 W in the support cylinder is additionally required during a magnet charging/discharging period of 20 rain., and a cold helium gas flow of 1 g/s is required for a set pair of current leads during the solenoid excitation. For a purpose of liquid helium level control, a heater of about 10 W may be consumed in the control dewar. As a result, a total thermal load of 100 W including a contingency of 20W is considered in the coil and the control dewar at 4.2 K. A summary of the thermal load is given in Table 2. Table 2. Thermal load of the ATLAS thin solenoid. 4.2 K 80 K 50 W (coil) 10 W Radiation 50 (chim. & C/D) 5 50 (coil) 5 Conduction 250 (chim. & C/D) 30 20 Eddy current loss (coil) (C/D) 10 Control heater Current leads (C/D) 20 100 Contingency 100 W 500 W
Lhe
1 g/s 0.2g/s 1.2 g/s (_40 l/h)_
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings 14mT
12m
SIDE-A _
CON
02000-
" " i
S U P P O R T STRUCTURE: lOm
!
l
TROID -
-::::::::::,: 4m
-
SIDE-C ,__ -,1. . . . . . -,1 1 1t 3 3 0 0 1-2000 / l 1-2500 s i
t
::: : ::: ::: :::::::: : : /~| : ~:::ltlll:~ t.:::~ / I V CHIMNEY [~I 00324
- :::~AND
2m
-I
84 -::::::
8m
6m
CRANE LOWER LIMITI
:; ., . . . . . ~" _ , [_t__.:'
TROL DEWAR
CHAMBER SYSTEM : ::
I
:II,
.... :
::::
~
::
-"
::,~/:::~:
I
0 0 3 8 0 - - ~ } BARREL TILEi--~, (JOINT)~,-~, ~ CALORIMETER ~-.............. ~ ~;.,,.i , ,
121
l
Fig. 3. A cross sectional layout of solenoid, chminey and control dewar in the ATLAS detector.
':
k-----,! j~: .......
END CAP _~_.---_~
SOLE~NOID C R Y O S T I T METER
Cooling scheme and parameters Figure 4 shows a planned schematic flow diagram for the ATLAS solenoid cooling system. Table 3. gives major cooling characteristics for the solenoid. The helium gas as cryogen resource is given by a common large refrigerator and a pre-cooler system for the ATLAS magnet system at CERN [4]. The solenoid is precooled by using a cold helium gas flow of about 20 g/s, supplied by the pre-cooler under safety constraints given in Table 3 to eliminate excessive thermal stress during a transient pre-cooling period. Depending on the operational condition, warm helium gas may be mixed with the cold gas, as an optional mode, to ensure the temperature control of the cold gas. In a steady state operation at 4.4 K, the two phase helium flow is supplied to keep the coil temperature at about 4.5 K(<5 K). The supercritical helium from the common refrigerator is expanded by using a J-T valve and sub-cooled in the control dewar to provide two phase helium close to full liquid helium phase (helium quality of X=0) through this process. The two-phase helium is supplied into the serpentine cooling path in the solenoid magnet and is returned back to the control dewar with keeping two-phase condition (at X< 0.8). The helium mass flow rate in the cooling path is about 7 g/s with a helium quality factor changing of about 0.4 (from 0.2 to 0.6) in the net coil part and of about 2 x 0.2 in the chimney part. The inner radiation shield is cooled by gas helium flow, with an intermediate temperature of 60 - 80 K, provided by the common refrigerator. The outlet gas from the current leads may be transferred either to (i) a low pressure line returning to the compressor, (ii) a gas recovery line at atmospheric pressure, or (iii) a direct vent line, depending on safety conditions of the current leads. EXIERNLL CRYOGENICS To
line
recovery
To low p r e s s u r e
line
REFRIGERATOR Room temp.
[
"]
~ POWER J
SUPPLY
L,_
i
PRE-COOLER
2222:
I --Heater
SERVICE/CONTROL 9 ("I ("1 I__v_r_r_n~l
d,,, I
I
I
V I
I
I
=
250
DEWAR L
I II
I I ', I I I ', I L
L__~ SOLENO
lD
gas
REFRIGERATOR ( Radiation Shield
MAGNET
Fig. 4. Schematic flow diagram for the ATLAS solenoid cryogenic system.
)
122
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings Table 3. Design parameters required for the ATLAS solenoid cryogenic system. Cool-down Cold mass (coil) 5 tons (chimney & control-dewar) 1 tons Cooling speed <3 K/h dT (T-coil- T-gas) <40 K dT (T-He-in- T-He-out) <30 K He-gas mass flow rate 20-30 g/s Supplied helium pressure >1 MPa Steady State (during excitati) Heat load at 4.2 K 80 W + 40 1/h Two-phase helium flow rate 7 g/s dX (coil) 0.4 dX (chimney & control dewar) <2 x0.2 Magnet charging/discharging Heat load at 4.2 K 100-160 W + 40 1/h Two-phase helium flow rate 6-10 g/s Quench Recovery Energy Dump into the coil Recovery time Helium flow rate Required LHe
21 MJ (50 %) 4 hr. 20 g/s 3,000 1
When the magnet quenches, the solenoid system is immediately disconnected from the common refrigerator system to minimize a disturbance to the refrigerator, and is re-cooled down according to a quench recovery sequence. In case of a refrigerator problem during the magnet excitation, the solenoid magnet is to be deenergized under a controlled slow-discharge, with eliminating a quench by using remaining liquid helium (-2 kg) in the cooling path in the coil and by using own enthalpy in the cold mass below the critical temperature. The current lead gas flow may be maintained during the discharge by using liquid helium in the control dewar. SUMMARY A conceptual design study of a cryogenic system for the ATLAS thin superconducting solenoid magnet has been made. The solenoid provides a central magnetic field of 2 T in a warm bore diameter of 2.3 m and an axial length of 5.6 m. The solenoid with a cold mass of 5 tons is indirectly cooled by using forced flow of two phase helium, passing through a serpentine cooling tube welded on the outer surface of the coil support cylinder. Resource cryogen is supplied by a common large refrigerator system to be provided by CERN, and the operational conditions of the cryogen may be optimized by using a control dewar dedicated to the solenoid system. The helium mass flow rate of < 10 g/s is required to keep the steady operational condition in the magnet excitation with keeping quality factor of X << 1 in the coil, and it may include a redundancy to enable the magnet to be discharged without quench by using remaining liquid the cooling parth and by using own enthalpy below the critical temperature. REFERENCES 1 2 3 4 5 6
ATLAS Collaboration, ATLAS Technical Proposal, CERN/LHCC/94-43. (1994) p. 19 - 22. Evans, L., The Large Hadron Collider Project, to be presented in this conference, ICEC-16.(1996). The LHC Study Group, The Large Hadron Collider, Conceptual Design, CERN/AC/95-05. (1995). Haug F., Refrigeration system for the ATLAS experiment, to be presented in this conference, ICEC16 (1996). Mayri C.,Barrel toroid cryogenic system for ATLAS detector, to be presented in this conference, ICEC- 16 (1996) Cragg D.,The cryogenic system of the ATLAS experiment end cap toroids, to be presented in this conference, ICEC- 16 (1996) Yamamoto, A., etal., Development of a Prototype Thin Superconducting Solenoid Magnet for the SDC Detector, IEEE Trans. on Appl. Superc., Vol. 5, No. 2, (1995) p.849 - 852.
Barrel Toroid Cryogenic System for the ATLAS Detector
C. Mayri, C. Cur6, R. Duthil CEA Saclay, DSM/DAPNIA/STCM, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette Cedex France D. Cragg RAL, Applied Science Department, Chilton Didcot, Oxfordshire OXl 1 0QX England F. Haug, G. Passardi CERN, Accelerator Technology Division, 1211 Geneva 23 Switzerland
The ATLAS barrel toroid is a superconducting magnet assembly of eight independent coils. Each coil comprises a cryostat, a 60 K helium gas shield and a two-phase 4,5 K cooling circuit. The helium supply of each one is regrouped in a common cryogenic ring which includes also the 20 kA bus. After a 30 days cooldown, the running mode is based on two 600 g/s cryogenic pumps. The first one delivers this nominal mass flow of subcooled liquid helium and the second one runs slowly in case of default on the running one. In order to avoid a fast dump of the magnet, the rapid commutation of the pumps is necessary. The paper describes the different cryogenic subsystems.
GENERAL The cemral air toroid consists of 8 superconducting coils supported by a warm mechanical structure. It operates at an average temperature of 4.5 K. This temperature is obtained by a two-phase helium circulation. The vapor quality in the coils is controlled around 10 %. Helium is provided by cryogenic pumps, which deliver a 600 g/s mass flow rate, through a cryogenic ring. This ring supplies helium to all the coils, all the shields at an average temperature of 60 K and contains the bus bar to power the magnet. This ring is connected to the coils in their central part. This ring is connected to a power cryostat which includes the 20 000 A current leads. This connection is located in the low and straight section between the ring and the main valve box. This part is called main cryogenic line. The main valve box is located in the experimental cavern. It provides the magnet with the different fluids by a lot of valves and contains the two liquid helium pumps. A 5000 litre dewar is connected to this box to supply the helium loop. A two-phase separator is placed at the top of the magnet to recuperate the two-phase helium. This 800 litre dewar contains the control system of the mass flow in each coil and supports the safety valve. The roughing and primary pumping-out of the coil vacuum chambers is provided by a 2000 ma/h pumping set situated in the experimental cavern through the cryogenic ring. The secondary pumping is carried out by nine 3000 1/s diffusion pumps (one per coil and one on the main valve box) connected to the primary one. The refrigerating system, composed of a nitrogen precooler and of a refrigerator, supplies helium at different temperatures during the different cryogenic phases of the magnet. The expansion is done in the valve box and produces liquid helium in the 5000 1. dewar. All these items are shown in the figure 1. 123
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
124
7-wo;~hase m?ar~ to?
grT#G~~Ac A~g (29 6 5 0 ~ ) 5000 I. U~3c
\
\
\
\
\
Figure 1 The cryogenic components are divided into three parts 9 -the external cryogenics which includes all the components in relation with the refrigeration system and the cryogenic lines down to the main valve box. CERN is totally in charge of this part, -the close cryogenics which includes the differents elements mentionned above located in the experimental cavern and the control process equipements, -the internal cryogenics which concerns the coil equipements.
COOL-DOWN Cool-down involves the gradual cooling of the heat shields from 300 to 60 K and of the coils from 300 to 4,5 K. It takes place in a general process of the magnet cool-down and must follow three criteria : a mechanical one which involves a maximum temperature difference between the coil inlets and outlets of 40 K, a thermal one which involves that the shields follow the coils in temperature, an experimental one which involves that the cool-down gradient do not exceed 0,5 K/hour above 100 K. -
-
-
Cool-down is a gradual process, taking some 30 calendar days, into two stages : from 300 to 100 K for coils and shields with gaseous helium gradually cooled from 300 to 80 K by liquid nitrogen in a pre-cooler (-~ 20 days). from 100 K to 5 K for coils directly by supercritical helium at 5 K from the refrigeration system (~- 10 days). -
-
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
125
POWER REQUIREMENTS 4,5 K level Cold mass (kg) Cold mass area (m 2) Radiation and shields supports (W/m 2) Conduction in cold mass supports (W) Close cryogenics (W) Pump heat load (W) Conduction in the pumps (W) Total (W) 60 K level Shield mass (kg) Shield mass area (m 2) Radiation and shields supports (W/m2) Conduction in cold mass supports (W) Close cryogenics (W) Total (W)
350000 1800 0.3 70 30 250 40 930
25000 1800 3 1580 450 7430
Each coil is hang on eight rods which support each between 100 and 200 tons due to the magnetic forces. The weight of the coil in any direction is supported by 32 cryogenic thrust blocks along the coil box which are linked to the shields. The stored energy of the barrel is 1130 MJ.
Currem leads Mass flow (g/s) Power (W)
3 60
RUNN1NG MODE The shields run at an average temperature of 60 K b y 4 0 K cold gaseous helium from the refrigerator. The eight shields are connected in parallel from the supplying pipe in the cryogenic ring. The total mass flow is regulated by a valve located in the main valve box at the inlet of the circuit. The mass flow repartition between the shields is obtained by a calibrated pressure drop on each shield circuit. The coils are kept at an average temperature of 4.5 K by a forced liquid helium flow circulation.The liquid helium circuit is made of two 600 g/s circulators connected in parallel as shown in figure 2. The circulator in use provides the nominal mass flow rate and the second one is on stand-by only kept cold at a low rate of operation. An analysis system controls the running pump behaviour and switches on the other in few seconds in case of default.
Figure 2
The flow rate in each coil is monitored by a regulating valve located in the main valve box at the inlet of the circuit. Each one is controlled by a pair of flowmeters. The first, aiter the regulating valve, is a diaphragm system which measures the total mass flow and the second, in the two-phase separator at the end of the circuit, is a sink-type system which measures the liquid part of the two-phase helium. This measurement cross-check gives the vapor quality and allows to adjust the mass flow rate in each coil. The fluid liquid part falling in the separator returns to the inlet of pumps through the cryogenic ring. The fluid gaseous part returns to the refrigerator by the same way. The 5000 litre dewar provides the loop with liquid helium in order to compensate the losses. This contribution is monitored by a regulating valve which is controlled by the total level in the separator. The filling up of this dewar is ensured by the refrigerator and its level is regulated by the JT valve. This tank must be pressurized and this pressure is controlled by the returned gaseous helium regulating valve. Its size allows a slow dump in case of refrigerator failure. The cooling circuk of the currem leads is connected to the returned liquid helium pipe at the bottom of their cryostat. The superconducting bus bar going through the cryogenic ring is also cooled by this pipe.The mass flow on each current lead is controlled by a gas flowmeter at the warm outlet tube after the flag.
126
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
INSTRUMENTS The overall control of this magnet (cool-down, running mode, discharge) needs a large number of sensors and valves. In order to avoid many cables in the cavern, we propose to use a field bus to relay the measurements. Boxes on each coil, the main valve box, the current lead cryostat and the two-phase separator convert analogic signal into numerical data. Then these data are treated by a dedicated programmable automatic system as shown in figure 3. The pump commutation is specially ensured by a software process which increase the system availability. ETHERNET
BUS
] ~ To Vacuum
PLC
(CERN)
Gateway
Supervision
DEPENDENCY
RACK
i~-ilk~]
',lMotor Drivel', #1 , ~! ,' " ;~ "' ' :,~ V ', i.~ ]i I ,~- = I, ' ,J
CRYOGENIC
INSTRUMENTATION
(Experimental hall) .................................................. i ;' I H e a t e r ]1 ,t/u^ ~rressures : I Power ! : [ Con t rol Main Valve Main Valve ' [Or:@ O r l e [ Box Box
Field
I CRYOGENIC INSTRUMENTATIONS* RACK (Cryogenic cavern)
RACK
8 Coils A1 s i d e z
Box 9.1 Levels--] r ]' ] Pres+s. . . . [ [ I II Te-mper~t ..... ' ' Two-phase I ~ P t ' b
Levels ..... 5000 1He Tank Pre~
~! Voltages]i
I ' ~ - - ~ Vacuum
Sensor
Field
BUS
N
1
PLC
i i
I
I
I
1
ICireuHeHleaon t~
ro
To E l e c t r i c a l Instrumentation PLC
Bus
i
I
I
~
Sensor
Field
Bus
~
,
N-2
! 1 1
' - ~ !' i~ d ~ :, I
--] Motor Drive[
,~....
~ 1,0 Power I Control i Main Valve I Main Val,,e [: !Gr2| G r 2 e [ Box ', Box L.................................................. 'He
.a
I
Levels I "1~. . . . . .1. . He . i] 5000 Tank I
'i
Levels
'1
,
I Two-phase !~rc~ . . . . I[ Separator
Box
9.2 8 Coils A2 s i d e
..............
Figure 3
T
To E l e c t r i c a l Instrumentation PLC
Performance Study of The Cryogenic System for ITER CS Model Coil
Takashi Kato, Kazuya Hamada, Katsumi Kawano, Kunihiro Matsui, Tadao Hiyama, Kazuhiko Nishida, Tadaaki Honda, Masanobu Taneda, Syuichi Sekiguchi, Kiichi Ootsu, Hiroshi Tsuji, Susumu Shimamoto, Hidemasa Yamamura*, Iwao Kawashima*, Yoshihiro Nakayama*, and Yukio Watanabe* Department of Fusion Engineering Research, Naka Fusion Research Establishment, Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute, 801-1, Mukaiyama, Naka-machi, Naka-gun, Ibaraki-ken, 311-01, Japan *Development & Engineering Department, Energy & Chemical Plant Group, Engineering & Machinery Division, Kobe Steel, LTD., 1-6-14, Edobori, Nishi-ku, Osaka-fu, 550, Japan A large scale helium cryogenic system, rated power of 5 kW at 4.5 K or 800 liter/h, has been constructed, used as a key component of the test facility of a large superconducting magnet development on the International Thermonuclear Fusion Experimental Reactor Engineering Design Activity. System performance studies are going on to measure the change of liquefaction rate when controlling the operation pressure of the turbo-expanders. As a result, the maximum liquefaction rate has been experienced to be around 920 liter/h, being 15-% higher than the rated value.
INTRODUCTION Engineering Design Activity (EDA) of International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) is now going on in the ITER represented countries, such as Japan, United States, European Union, and Russia. A superconducting model coil of the ITER Center Solenoid (CS) coil[1 ][2] has actively developed at their countries, which is one of the key R&D issues to verify the ITER construction technology. Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute (JAERI) is the Japanese representative of lTER and has the following charges: a half of the model coil fabrication, development and preparation of the model coil test facility, and implementation of the model coil experiment. A cryogenic system for ITER CS model coil is the key components of the model coil test facility[3] to cool the model coil down and to supply supercritical helium up to 500 g/s. The maximum coil cooling condition simultaneously requires both the refrigeration and the liquefaction capacity of around 3 kW and 360 liter/h, respectively. Therefore, the system capacity has been designed to be a 5-kW refrigeration or a 800-1iter/h liquefaction where the maximum cooling point can be superposed on the line that linearly connects both points of 5 kW and 800 liter/h in the refrigeration-liquefaction diagram [4]. The system performance study has been carried out, tried to control the system to agree with the design liquefaction condition. The data were analyzed and checked. As a result, the obtained liquefaction performance is compared to the design estimation. COLD BOX LAYOUT Claude cycle, contained with liquid-nitrogen precooling, the series arrangement of two turbines, and double Joule-Thomson (JT) valve system [5], is adopted as a refrigeration cycle as shown in Fig. 1. A relatively simple and well-experience cycle is applied to be able to study the cold box performance. However, the first JT valve can be replaced by a turbine operated at supercritical helium condition when the refrigeration power will be intended to increase more than 8 kW at 4.5 K [6]. 127
128
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings First turbine control valve
iquid nitr~
I
~_~
_
~:
_
~ F
Second turbine control valve
~
Second turbine
!
First JT valve
Second JT valve
/
Compressor E31 E32
Fig. 1
E33
E34
E35
E36
E37
E38
Cold box layout of the cryogenic system
PERF ORMANCE STUDY The system was completed in July of 1995 when the specified refrigeration and liquefaction capacity had successfully satisfied in the commissioning test. The liquefaction rate of 801 liter/h had been achieved even in the first-turbine inlet pressure of 1.45 MPa, which is smaller by 0.17 MPa than the design of 1.62 MPa, due to limitation of the thrust bearing [7]. After modification of the thrust bearing expecting higher stiffness, the first turbine can operate at the design point of the inlet pressure. Then, the liquefaction rate was carefully measured again, controlling the first turbine inlet condition close to the design condition. As a result, the liquefaction rate was drastically increased up to 920 liter/h. A temperature-entropy (T-S) diagram at the 920-1iter/h operation is plotted from the obtained process data as shown in Fig. 2. To compare with the designed process, the T-S diagram of the design process is superposed on the measured diagram as shown in Fig. 3 The following comparisons are indicated: (1) the cold-box supply pressure of 1.81 MPa from the compressor is higher than the design pressure of 1.66 MPa. (2) The JT pressure point is different from the design. The inlet pressure of the second JT valve was practically set to be around 0.8 MPa instead of 400
400
measured design
---1 O0
100
z
I--
I
3
0
10
/
i
i
5
10
15
20
25
30
s[J/gK] Fig. 2
T-S diagram for the practical liquefaction
35
3
I
0
Fig. 3
i
5
I
10
I
15
t
20
s[J/gK]
Comparison of T-S diagrams
25
30
35
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings Table 2
129
Comparison of the turbine condition between the design and the measured liquefaction
Condition parameters Inlet pressure (MPa) Inlet temperature (K) Outlet pressure (MPa) Outlet temperature (K) Mass flow rate (g/s) Pressure ratio Blade-jet speed ratio: U/Co Isentropic efficiency (%) Turbine work (kW) Liquefaction rate (liter/h)
First turbine Design . Measured 1.62 1.62 48.0 48.9 0.69 0.81 38.2 38.3 154.4 147.6 2.35 2.00 -0.55 0.528 70 68 8.06 6.33 800 920
Second turbine Design Measured 0.66 0.613 24.8 23.2 0.122 0.113 16.1 13.9 154.4 147.6 5.40 5.42 -0.57 0.601 70 80.5 6.78 7.16 800 920
the design of 0.5 MPa, which was intended not to increase the liquefaction rate but to cool the JT heat exchanger quickly in the cold-box cooldown. (3) The final JT expansion point is shifted to a lower entropy region, bringing about higher liquefaction. (4) The inlet condition of the first turbine is similar to the design but the attained pressure ratio is slightly smaller. (5) The second turbine operation point is shifted to the lower temperature region. The second turbine work is, however, higher than the design value. (6) The cold-box supply mass flow was measured to be 320.5 g/s, which was much smaller than the design of 405.5 g/s, even to achieve the liquefaction rate of 920 liter/h. The obtained turbine operation condition is listed in Table 2 in detail, comparing with the designed values. It can be seen that the inlet condition of the first turbine is almost same as the design and the second turbine is working better. The measured turbine work for both the first and the second turbine is different. A blade-jet speed ratio (U/Co) of the first turbine is smaller than the design. It, accordingly, suggests that the work of the first turbine should be increased to operate with higher pressure ratio by more opening of the second turbine control valve indicated in Fig. 1 and that the revolution of the first turbine should be increase by adding the pressure drop in the turbine brake blower circuit to attain higher U/Co. Note that the temperature measurements of the turbine inlet and outlet were carefully performed. Especially, the temperature measurement around 20-K region should require higher accuracy where the temperature measurement is difficult due to low signal noise ratio (S/N) region for every thermometer. In order to understand that the 920-1iter/h liquefaction was attained with the total cold box mass flow rate of only 320.5 g/s, the heat and mass balance was calculated to substitute the obtained liquefaction process date into the developed computer code[7]. As a result, the calculation has proved that such heat and mass balance should exist. Then, UA values for each heat exchanger are compared for both the designed UA and the calculated UA as shown in Table 3. Note that the designed UA means the required UA at the designed 800-1iter/h liquefaction mode and that the calculated UA means also the required UA at the obtained process data. The UA values on the heat-exchanger fabrication design are much larger than them. The comparison shows that the first and fifth heat exchangers are active, the forth and the eighth heat exchangers are similar to the design, and the remnant heat exchangers are almost half of the design. It Table 3
Comparison of UA values for both the liquefaction design and the practical liquefaction
Heat exchanger No. * E31 E33 E34 E35 E36 E37 E38 * Refer to Fig. 1.
Designed UA (1) 65785 47240 7437 22541 15924 14440 977
Calculated UA (2) 177469 27724 6715 27272 7396 6026 847
UA ratio (2)/(1) 2.7 0.59 0.9 1.21 0.46 0.42 0.87
130
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
is understandable that the fifth heat exchanger is so active that the inlet temperature of the second turbine is lower than the design as referred in Fig. 3. It is also suggested that the first heat exchanger should effectively work to generate high liquefaction rate. Consequently, the reasons of producing the larger liquefaction are considered as the following factors; (1) The isotropic efficiency of the second turbine is much higher than that of the design mode. (2) The heat exchanger capacity has much margin, attaining the smaller temperature difference. (3) The operating pressure is higher than that of the design mode. Finally, a liquefaction ratio of the JT flow is calculated to be 18.9 % compared with the design of 10.7 %.
CONCLUSION Practical performance has been studied for the developed cryogenic system, observing the liquefactionrate change to bring the inlet turbine condition close to the design condition. As a result, the liquefaction rate has been achieved to be 920 liter/h which is much higher than the design of 800 liter/h. The measured process data at the 920-1iter/h operation were substituted into the developed mass and heat balance calculation code, and the process performance could be estimated. Consequently, it was cleared that the second turbine should have high efficiency and that the heat exchangers should have enough margin, as the reasons why the larger liquefaction capacity was achieved with the lower mass flow rate. However, it was also understood that there would be still feasible to increase the liquefaction capacity if the first turbine work would be increased to slightly open the second turbine control valve and the first turbine revolution would be increased by controlling a pressure drop in the blower brake circuit.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors would like to thank Drs M. Ohta, T. Nagashima, and S. Matsuda for their continuous encouragement and support this work. This report is an account of work undertaken within the framework of lTER EDA Agreement. REFERENCES 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Thome, R. J., Design & development of the ITER magnet system, Cryogenics (1994) 34 38-46 Okuno, K., Model coil for the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) magnet system, IEEE Trans. Magn. (1994), Vol. 30, No. 4, 1621-1626 Shimamoto, S. et al., Construction of ITER common test facility for CS model coil, Proc. ICEC 14, Tempera, Finland (1995) Hamada, K., et al., Final design of a cryogenic system for ITER CS model coil, Cffogenics (1994) 34 65-68 Tada, E. et al., 350-1/h, 1.2-kW helium cryogenic system for the development of fusion technology, Proc. ICEC 8 (1982) 93-96 Kato, T. et al., Design of a 8-kW refrigerator system for ITER common test, Proc. ICEC 14 (1992) 60-63 Kato, T. et al., Cryogenic system for ITER CS model coil, to be published in Advanced in Cryogenic _Engineering (1996) 41
Engineering Design of Cryoplant for ITER
Kazuya Hamada, Takashi Kato, Tadaaki Honda, Kunihiro Matsui, Kazuhiko Nishida, Hiroshi Tsuji, Susumu Shimamoto, Kiyoshi Yoshida*, Michael E.P Wykes*, Vladimir Kalinin*, Mikirou Mori** and Akihiro Miyake** Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute, Naka Fusion Research Establishment, 801-l, Muko-yama, Nakamachi, Naka-gun, Ibaraki, 311-01, Japan, *ITER Joint Central Team, Naka Joint Work Site, 801-1, Muko-yama, Naka-machi, Naka-gun, Ibaraki, 311-01, Japan, **Ishikawajima Harima Heavy Industry Co., Ltd., 3-2-16 Toyosu, Koto-ku, Tokyo, 135, Japan
Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute is studying a cryoplant for International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER). ITER consists of twenty Toroidal field coils, eight Poloidal field coils and the total weight is more than 25,000 tons. The cryoplant provides liquid helium, supercritical helium and 80-K helium gas for cooling the coils, structure, cryopump and thermal shield. The required capacity of cryoplant to cool the superconducting coil and the thermal shield is 110 kW + 6,618 liters/hour at 4.5K and 350-kW at 80K. Cryogenic pump is applied to circulation system of supercritical helium. The cryoplant is designed on the basis of Demo Poloidal test facility and CS model coil test facility.
INTRODUCTION Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute (JAERI) participates in design activities for the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) in collaboration with European Union, Russian federation and United states of America. From 1993, ITER engineering design activity (EDA) has started and ITER is designed so as to realize construction, based on the latest technology at the end of EDA. ITER has twenty Toroidal field (TF) coils and eight Poloidal field (PF) coils and Total cold mass is 25,000 tons. The function of the ITER cryoplant is to cool all cold elements. The cryoplant design requirements are summarized as follows; @to operate continuously up to three year @to cool down the coils and the structure from room temperature to 4K or 80K within 30 days. @to allow a 24 hours plasma operation of ITER with sequential plasma pulsing @to operate stably in response to all transient heat loads arising in the various cold mass elements @to recover the cold helium gas at the quench @in the events of failure of one helium refrigerator cold box, continued plasma operation must be possible, albiet at reduced availability. @to achieve a high energy efficiency and low running cost for minimal capital cost To accomplish above requirements, the cryoplant components such as turbine, helium compressor and cryogenic pump are designed based on the existing components and parallel system.
CRYOPLANT SYSTEM The block diagram of the cryoplant is shown in Figure 1. Cryoplant mainly consists of five cold boxes and thirteen cryogenic pump systems. The system is based on the Demo Poloidal Test Facility[2] and CS model coil test facility[3]. The coils and structures are cooled by supercritical helium at 4.5K, 131
132
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
0.6 MPa. Heat load conditions are listed in Table 1. It is assumed that the adiabatic efficiency of cryogenic pump is 0.7 which is based on the JAERI's R&D and pressure drop of TF coil and PF coil are 0.15 and 0.02~0.075 MPa. Current lead cooling is assumed to be by helium vapor.
Buffer Tank
(13unit3s X [ 3000m at \ 1.8MPa) ~
~ HeliumCompressor(Total f--" Mass Flow Rate:12,250g/s) [ I Cold Box ~ Gas Purifier ] (5 units: 22kW
l Recovery C~176
l
i
~~~'~231iters/h~
9
[ Rec~
] Heater
.eat
~ ' ~ I--] / Exchanger I I [ ~ [ ,I ,[ ~ I I ['--='q ] ILiquidHelium Tank[ I [ ~ [ [ 1~ 1(250,000liters) } ] L [""-..~'t-~'---~ ~ ' [ I }",,.. ~ ~ = ~ ~ ~ ~ _ _ _ _ ~ ] 1 1 f ,I .......l
[ '-.. ~ [ ~ [ [
Cryogenic Pump System-t..... ,
13 units (26.07kg/s at 4.5K,0.6MPa)
Table 1
:3,359g/s ~ , Liquid Nitrogen ] I [--- Supply System H 80 K Helium --
Low PressureGas Holder(3000m3)
Figure 1
Helium Compressor
[
[ ITERHeat Load [ 110kW+6618 liters/hour .~ [ at 4.5K "-I 350 kW at 80K
I
Block diagram of lTER cryoplant Heat load condition at plasma operation
4-K Heat Load Coil and structure 52.8 kW Cryogenic pump 24.7 kW (including 10% margin) Cold compressor 6 kW Cryopump 20 kW Heat leak of cryoplant 5 kW Total 108.5 kW Current lead 6,618 liters/hour
80-K Heat Load Plasma Vacuum vessel 220 kW Cryostat 45 kW Cryogenic piping 25 kW Gravity support 10 kW Contingency 50 kW Total 350 kW
Total refrigeration and liquefaction capacity is 110 kW + 6,618 liters/hour and 350 kW at 80K, for the superconducting coil and thermal shields. To achieve a cooling power for 80-K operation of coils and structure, a liquid nitrogen refrigerator with air separator is applied. The capacity of the gas storage tank is designed to recover all helium gas in the ITER. Total helium inventory of the coil and cryoplant is 27,993.1m 3 and the helium gas weight is 93.7 tons. Accordingly thirteen units of gas storage tanks, which the capacity per one unit is 1,800m 3 at 1.8MPa, are required. The buffer tank acts as a quench buffer tank for coil quenches. The capacity of liquid helium tank is 250,000 liters and determined from operation scenario such as fault mode of one cold box. One train of cryoplant will be provided early in the construction phase to supply the magnet cold test facility at the ITER site. This will allow some early validation of cryoplant components. COLD BOX DESIGN
The thermal process of the cold box is a Claude cycle with two series of turbines and a cryogenic turbine as shown in Figure 2. The capacity of one cold box is determined as less than 30 kW because the size of 30-kW cold box defines an upper limitation of transportation and installation at the ITER site. The nominal capacity per one cold box is 22 kW + 1,324 liters/hour. The cold box also generates the 30-kW maximum refrigeration power or 5,000-liters/ hour liquefaction rate. The mass and heat balance calculation have been performed and a Figure of Merit, which is defined as the fraction of 1-W refrigeration power to electrical input power such as compressor motor and liquid nitrogen consumption,
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
133
is larger than 1/300. It is assumed that adiabatic efficiency of the turbine and cryogenic turbine are 0.7 and 0.6, respectively, and isothermal efficiency of the compressor is 0.6. The liquid nitrogen consumption is 272 g/s. The total mass flow rate and turbine mass flow rate are 2,450g/s and 580g/s, respectively. Although such a large scale turbine is not conventional, the turbine is feasible using current technology data base. 27.67kW LN2:272g/s
3.Pa
33.33K 0.66MPa
i,
23.61K 0.66MPa
23.38kW 15.57K 6"-- " ~ " 0 ' 1 3 M P a
i
580.Sg/s
! i
12.83kW i
I 1869g/s '. I
245%, ~ 1.8MPa
j : I
/
i | |
8.298K - . 6.182K 1.63MPa 0.407MPa
......
1,324 liters/hour
Figure 2
Flow diagram of cold box
HELIUM COMPRESSOR The helium compressor is one of the most important component of the cryoplant. The total mass flow rate of the helium compressor is 12,250 g/s at the ITER plasma experiment. For a large mass flow rate and down sizing, the turbo-compressor is ideal. Research and development of the turbo-compressor, however, is needed. Thus, two types of conventional compressors are estimated and the results are listed in Table 2. Table 2
Comparison with Screw and Reciprocating Compressor
Mass flow rate per one set Configuration Motor Power per one set Total unit number for ITER Installation Area per one set Actual results for helium refrigerator Feature
Screw Type Compressor 3,300 g/s Low press, stage 9 units + High press, stage 9 units 11,700 kW 72 units 450m 2 leading conventional
Reciprocating Compressor 3,150 g/s 3 units 9,600 kW 15 units 450m 2 not leading large size is used for LNG plant conventional
The total installation area is the same for each type and there is not a large difference for the initial cost between the two types. A reliability and running cost, such as maintenance and utility consumption are a key parameter and a more detailed study is needed for decision.
C R Y O G E N I C PUMP S Y S T E M A cryogenic pump system has an advantage for down sizing itself because of 4-K operation. JAERI has developed a reciprocating and centrifugal cryogenic pump and applied them to large scale forced flow cooling pulse coil operation[4]. In ITER, centrifugal type cryogenic pump is selected to achieve a high pump head (0.3 MPa), high adiabatic efficiency (more than 0.7) and controllability. Required mass flow rate for each coil is listed in Table 3. Such large cryogenic pump technology is not as conventional as that of turbine. It is estimated that a 3-kg/s cryogenic pump can be developed on the basis of the latest
134
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
technique. However, considering existing cryogenic pump technology (Pump head: 0.1 MPa at 720g/s), an improved of bearing system is needed in order to accomplish a higher mass flow rate and pump head. Table 3
Mass flow rate of coils TF winding and the case
Mass flow Rate
Pump unit
TF winding: 3.1kg/s TF case: 13.1 kg/s Total: 16.2 kg/s TF winding: 1.55kg/s • 2 units TF case: 2.62 kg/s • 5 units
PF-1 (central solenoid coil) 1.4 kg/s
1 unit
PF-2& PF-7
PF-3, PF-4, PF-5, PF-6 and PF-8
Support and structure
Total : 0.7kg/s
Total: 4.8 kg/s
Total: 6 kg/s
l unit
2.8kg/s • 2 units
3kg/s • 2 units
The system has a gas separator and supercritical helium heat exchanger. The piping line between coils and cryogenic pump system is separated from the refrigerator main line to reduce the influence on heat balance of cold box from transient heat load caused by pulse operation or quench. The inlet temperature of coil is required as 4.5K. Taking account of heat leak (2W/m) at cryogenic piping between coil cryostat and cryogenic pump system, the helium bath which contains a heat exchanger, is evacuated by using cold compressor and around 4.3K is achieved. The required mass flow rate of cold compressor is in the range from 200 g/s to 1,000 g/s. As with the cryogenic pump, improvement of the bearing system is a key factor for achieving a larger capacity. CONCLUSION The design of the ITER cryoplant is being performed and it is estimated that ITER requirement of 110 kW + 6,618 liters/hour for the superconducting coils and thermal shield can be realized. The large scale mass flow rate cryogenic components, such as turbine, helium compressor, cryogenic pump and cold compressor, is required. Basic technology is existing and the some research and development for these high speed turbo machine, such as bearing, are needed. ACKNOWLEGMENT The authors would like to thank Drs. M. Ohta, T. Nagashima and S. Matsuda for their continuous encouragement and support on this work. This report is an account of work for undertaken within the frame work of the ITER EDA agreement. The view of authors do not necessarily reflect those of the ITER Director, the parties to the ITER EDA agreement, or the International Atomic Energy Agency. REFERENCE
1 Yoshida, K and Kalinin, V., Requirements and Interface to Cryogenic and Power Supply Plants for ITER Magnet System, Proceeding of Cryogenic Engineering Conference (1995) 2 Kato, T. et al., Operation Performance of DPCF in The Test of The Nb-Ti Demo Poloidal Coil (DPCU1,U2], Proceeding of 1 lth International Conference of Magnet Technology Vol. 2, 1989, 1350-1354 3 Shimamoto, S and Hamada, K. et al., Construction of ITER Common Test Facility for CS model coil, Proceeding of 14th International Conference of Magnet Technology 1995 4 Kato, T et al, "Cryogenic Helium Pump System for the Development of Superconducting Magnets in a Fusion Experimental Reactor, Proceeding of 17th Symposium on Fusion Technology Vol. 1 1992 887-891
Interface Detail Design for ITER Coil System Tadaaki Honda,* Fumio lida,** Kunihiko Matsui,* Yukio Yasukawa,*** Kazuhiko Nishida,* Kazuya Hamada,* Takashi Kato,* Hiroshi Tsuji,* Kiyoshi Yoshida,** Kizen Sakaki,*** Hisaaki Hiue, and *Susumu Shimamoto *Superconducting Magnet Laboratory, Department of Fusion Engineering Research, Naka Fusion Research Establishment, Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute, Mukouyama, Naka-machi, Naka-gun, Ibaraki-ken, 311-01 JAPAN *"::ITER Joint Central Team, Naka Joint Work Site, Naka-machi, Naka-gun, Ibaraki, 311-01 JAPAN *:~:*Fuji Electric Co., Ltd., Kawasaki-shi, Kanagawa, 210 JAPAN The ITER superconducting magnet system requires 45 pair of current leads and cryolines for supply of electricity and forced-flow supercritical helium at 4.5K and 6.0 bar. The interface components between coil system and operating facilities such as electricity supply system and cryogenic plant consist of feeder and cryoline, coil terminal box and cryostat feedthrough. These components satisfied the required design condition. In this paper, their feasibility and detailed design results are introduced. INTRODUCTION The engineering design activity (EDA) of International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) [1] is carried out jointly by the United States of America, the European Atomic Energy Community, the Government of Japan, and the Russian Federation. The ITER superconducting(SC) magnet system consists of 20 toroidal field (TF) coils, a central solenoid (CS) coil and 7 poloidal field (PF) coils.J2] These coils are installed in a cryostat and cooled by forced-flow supercritical helium at 4.5K and 6.0 bar. Each coil is connected to operating facilities such as cryoplant and electrical power supply system.J3] Interface components between the SC coils and the operating facilities consist of feeders and cryolines, cryostat feedthroughs and coil terminal boxes. The feeders and cryolines connect the SC coils to the coil ler~ninal boxes interfacing with the operating facilities as shown in Figure 1. The inlet and outlet coolant pipes fi'om the cryoplant branch off into small pipes connected to a manifold at the coil terminal. Since each branched pipe has a different high voltage, each branched pipe must have an insulation break between the manifold and the branched pipe. The insulation breaks are located in the break boxes in order to reduce the length of the high potential coolant pipes. The feeders and cryolines 9
i;
_1
TokamakHall ical Shield Biologics
Cryostat
-~4.0 m
Feeder and Cryoline Central Solenoid Coil ~ .
__l' . ~ ~ 1 1 ! lJ , ._~_ ~ } % ~
Toroidal Field Coil
Poloidal Field Coil
Figure
I
Elevation of ITER magnet system and interface 135
.Coil Terminal Box Cryostat Feedthrough F,
136
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
consist of coolant pipes and SC busbars which connect each SC coil to a coil terminal box through a break box and a cryostat feedthrough. The SC busbars are cooled by forced flow supercritical helium. In the reference paper [3], the coil terminal boxes were located in the terminal building near the tokamak building. Therefore, long feeders and cryolines were required. However, the long feeders and cryolines complicated the layout of the tokamak hall. Then, the electrical switching units for the TF coils were installed in the tokamak hall pit in order to reduce the number of the TF coil feeder. According to their location, the coil terminal boxes had to be installed in the limited space of the tokamak hall pit, which has a height of 4m. The coil terminal boxes and the cryogenic feedthroughs are installed around the cryostat on two floors. 15 units are installed on the upper floor and 10 units on the lower floor. COIL TERMINAL BOXES AND CRYOGENIC FEEDTHROUGHS The coil terminal boxes contain SC busbars, current leads, cryogenic valves, coolant pipes, and sensors. The coil terminal box functions are as follows; (1) Interface between the SC busbars and the normal busbar. (2) Interface between the cryolines and the cryogenic plant. (3) Vacuum separator between the coil terminal box and the SC coil. A coil terminal box is shown in Figure 2. Since the coil terminal boxes are located in a limited space, 24 of the 25 coil terminal boxes contain two set of interface equipment such as current leads, cryogenic valves, SC busbars. The cryogenic feedthrough design details are as follows. Firstly, since the magnet system shrinks at cryogenic temperature, the SC busbars and the coolant pipes in the cryostat feedthrough are bent in order to accommodate thermal contraction. At cryogenic temperature the SC coils deform radially by -50 mm and pull the SC busbars. In order to investigate the SC busbar design, a FEM analysis for the SC busbars was carried out. In this case, the maximum Tresca stress of the SC busbar in the cryogenic feedthrough reaches 326MPa in bending. This value is less than the allowable Tresca stress of 570MPa. It is clear that the SC busbar remains structurally stable at cryogenic temperature. Secondly, the neutron and radiation barrier, whose thickness is 300mm, surrounds the cryogenic feedthrough in order to prevent the neutron and radiation through the penetration of the cryostat making the coil terminal box radioactive. ~
~
-~. . . . . . . . L.,
-
j
~
Neutron and radiation barrier --,\
-------x.r-
r'~.~~~
/ ....
~: . . . . . . . .
~'-~--~ F::':=
\
Feeder and Cryoline t
Figure
2
Vacuum Separator ~-~ry--~ge nic Valves ~'"'---..~,"~',~1 ~ ~ ~ ~ Current Lead "
Cryogenic Feedthrough
I
Coil Terminal Box
Configuration of the double type coil terminal box and cryostat feedthroughes for TF coils
FEEDERS AND CRYOLINES The SC busbars and the coolant pipes between the break box and the cryostat feedthrough are installed in the feeder and cryoline. The feeder and cryolines, the break boxes and the cryostat feedthroughs have a common vacuum separate from the cryostat vacuum to get sensitive helium leak detection inside of the feeder and cryoline. The vacuum space is pumped out at the cryostat feedthrough, and the pumped gas is monitored by helium detector. The SC busbars are directly connected to the terminal of the SC coils through the break box. Grounding separators are installed between the SC busbars in order to avoid short circuit accidents between the SC busbars. The grounding separator is grounded with a few hundred ohm resistor. The cross section of a feeder and cryoline for the TF coils is shown in Figure 3. SUPERCONDUCTING BUSBARS The SC busbars connect the current leads to the break boxes. The superconducting busbars consist of conduit, superconducting NbTi strands and extra pure copper strands to allow a longer current carrying
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
Outlet coolant pipe for TF coil case
,,~,,~~~ '
Outletfor Coolant pipe TF co, wi~176
6OO
Grounding Separator SC busbar ~ \\ Inlet coolant p i p e ~ for TF coil winding Inlet coolant pipe for TF coil case Figure 3
137
~
FSC !
x
/(( t.~i_~** ~ ) ~**~. , . ..../ / ~ /'"~.~'\,
Copper d s ( 4 )stran 0x. 7 5 2592) Voild fraction "36 % Conduit
j~"~
~'.-t ~
~ Insulation
,
SC busbar for TF coil
Cross section of feeder and cryoline for TF coil
Table 1 Design parameter for SC busbars Item Parameter 1. Rated current 60kA for TF coils 43kA for CS/PF coils 2. Maximum current 120kA for TF coils 71.8kA for CS/PF coils 3. Proof voltage 30kV 4. Design pressure 100bar 5. External magnetic field 1.5T
strands
Figure 4
SC busbar for TF coil
Item 6. Bath temperature 7. Temperature margin 8. Hot spot temperature 9. Dumping time 10. Coolant pressure temperature
Parameter 5K more than 2K less than 300K 200 second 4 bar 4.5K
capacity in the event of a quench. It is necessary that the superconducting busbars are more stable than the superconducting coils in order to prevent coil quench caused by the SC busbar. Therefore, only the copper area of the SC strand contribute to the limited current. Pure copper strands, on the other hand, contribute to the hot spot temperature. The design conditions of the SC busbars are shown in Table 1. Also, the superconducting strand specification is as follows; strand material: NbTi, critical current density at 5T, 4.5K: 2000A/mm2, filament diameter: less than 5~tm, strand diameter: 0.75mm, Cu ratio: 1.5, RRR: more than 100, external field 3T. From the analysis results, many copper strands are needed in the SC busbar. For manufacturing, mixed cabling of SC strands and many pure copper strand is not acceptable due to differences in their mechanical properties. Therefore, the SC strands are concentrated at the center of the SC busbar and the pure copper strands surround the central SC strand. The conduit thickness and the material of the SC busbar, determined by using the equation of the high pressure gas control law of Japanese domestic law, are 5mm and SS316L, respectively. Electrical insulation consists of the multi-layer kapton films (Kapton - Glass - Kapton). The total thickness of the insulation is 5mm against proof voltage (30kV). The SC busbars cross sectional view for the TF coil is shown in Figure 4. CURRENT LEAD The SC coils require 45 pairs of current leads which connect the normal busbars to the SC busbars. The twenty pairs of current leads for the TF coils are operated up to 60kA and the twenty five pairs for the central solenoid and PF coils are operated up to 43kA, respectively. The current leads are pulled from the coil terminal box for maintenance. According to the space requirement, the forced-cooled current lead design is selected because the current leads must be installed horizontally. The major design parameter are as follows; (1) rated current : 60kA for TF coils, 43kA for PF/CS coils, (2) current density: 11A/mm2, (3) void fraction: 20%, (4) copper area 5457mm2 for TF coils, 4094mm2 for CS/PF coils, (5) calculation length: 2.1 m, (6)strand diameter: 2mm, (8)RRR: 100, (9)high temperature end: 300K, (10)low temperature end: 4.5K. (11) inlet helium pressure: 4bar. The characteristics of the current lead for TF and Table 2 Characteristic of current leads. Item Rated flow rate during operation Heat leak at the rated current Diameter
For TF coils 3.3 g/s 36.3 W 93.2 mm
For PF coils 2.1 g/s 25.8 W 80.7 mm
138
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings 400 x,, t__ .i-.J
E Q) F-
350
o
300
9
250
A .-. =
200 150
O(min) 2(min) 4(min) 6(min) 8(min)
100
Initial Temperature Profile
50 0 0
Figure
5
0.5
1
Length (m)
1.5
2
Temperature profile of current lead for TF coil at zero-flow
PF/CS coils are shown in Table 2. The force-cooled current lead design is not dependent on the installation direction. However, it causes heat leak to the main flow. Therefore, removal of the heat leak is required to avoid warming of the main coolant flow. As the force-cooled current leads don't have a coolant reservoir, we must investigate the current lead behavior when the coolant is not supplied to the current lead as an accident mode. The analysis conditions are as follows; (1) The initial temperature profile of the current lead is defined at normal operation. (2) The temperature at the room-temperature end rises from the initial temperature (300K) to the final temperature (400K). (3) The operating current will not be dumped after the zero flow operation. (4) The basic equation is analyzed by the finite differential method. Temperature profiles for the TF coil are shown in Figure 5. From the analysis of the current leads, it is found that, since the temperature of normal busbar is generally allowed to be up to about 340 K, in case of coolant supply stop to the current leads, the full current of the SC coils should be dumped within 6 minutes to prevent the SC coils burn out. CONCLUSION The SC magnet system requires interface components between the SC coils and the operating facilities. They consist of the feeders and cryolines, the coil terminal boxes and the cryostat feedthroughs. The conceptual design of the coil terminal boxes is completed and their installation in the tokamak hall pit is acceptable. Accordingly, the length of the feeders and cryolines is shorter than in the reference paper[2] and a neutron and radiation shield is needed around the cryogenic feedthrough to prevent the neutron and radiation through the penetration of the cryostat making the coil terminal box radioactive. The SC busbar design takes into consideration manufacturing. Force-cooled current leads are used for connection between normal busbar and the SC busbar on consideration of space requirement. However, removal of its heat leak to the main coolant flow is needed. ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors would like to thank Drs M.ohta, T.Nagashima and S.Matsuda for their continuous encouragement and support on this work. This report is an account of work undertaken within the framework (MD249) of the ITER EDA Agreement. The views of the authors do not necessarily reflect those of the ITER Director, the Parties to the ITER EDA Agreement, or the International Atomic Energy Agency. REFERENCES 1 R.J.Thome, Design & Development of the ITER Magnet system, Cryogenics (1994) 34 39-46 2 K.Yoshida, V.Kalinin, S.Storner and T.Kato, Requirements and interfaces to cryogenic and power supply plants for ITER magnet system, to be published in ad_vanced cryogenic engineering 41 3 K.Yoshida, M.Shimada, M.Matsukawa, et al., Design of the Outer poloidal Field coil system for ITER, proceedings 14th Magnet technology
Development & Operating Experience of the Nuclotron Cryogenic System
Nikolai Agapov, Hamlet Khodzhibagiyan, Alexander Kovalenko, Anatoly Smirnov, Asiya Sukhanova Laboratory of High Energies, Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna 141980, Russia
The 6 GeV superconducting synchrotron was commisioned in March 1993 at the Laboratory of High Energies of the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research in Dubna. Nine runs of a total duration of about 2200 hours were provided from March 1993 to March 1996. The cooling of the accelerator magnetic system 250 meters long was performed by two helium refrigerators with a capacity of 1.6 kW at 4.5 K each. The magnets were refrigerated by a twophase helium flow. All 160 magnets are connected in parallel to the supply and return helium headers. The description and operational characteristics of the Nuclotron cryogenic system are presented.
INTRODUCTION The Nuclotron [1, 2] is intended to accelerate nuclei and heavy ions of all elements up to uranium. The maximum design energy of particles with the charge to mass ratio Z/A = 1/2 is 6 GeV per nucleon. A high (up to 1 Hz) frequency of accelerating cycles at the Nuclotron offers wide possibilities of using it also as a booster . The ring of the Nuclotron comprises 96 dipole magnets 1.5 m long, 64 quadrupole lenses 0.4 m long, 28 multipole correctors 0.31 m long with 3 or 4 types of coils in each, twelve 6 kA helium-cooled main current leads, 234 leads of a 100 A current for correcting coils and speciM-purpose magnets, 32 special units of beam injection, acceleration, diagnostics, and extraction, and also about 1300 sensors of cryogenic temperatures. CRYOGENICS OF THE RING The Nuclotron magnetic system is based on a magnet of the "Dubna" type [3, 4]. That is a pulsed SC magnet with a "cold" iron yoke and a hollow superconductor winding. The main performances of the magnets are presented in [5, 6].The magnet is fastened in a vacuum shell of the cryostat r m m by 8 suspension parts of stainless steel (see Fig. 1). A nitrogen shield r m m covered with 20 layers of superinsulation is placed in the insulation vacuum space between the magnet and the vacuum shell. The supply and return helium headers, which the magnets of the accelerator half-ring are connected in parallel to, are placed inside the nitrogen shield. The internal diameters of the supply and return headers are 36 m m and 52 mm, respectively. The cooling of the magnets is performed by a two-phase helium flow. The mass vapour content of helium in the supply and return headers is measured by means of 4 void fraction sensors [7]. The mass vapour content of helium varies from 0 at the inlet of the magnet to 0.9 at its outlet (see Fig. 2). Helium in the supply header of each half-ring is kept in a liquid state by means of a phase separator, a main subcooler, and a large number of small subcoolers (see Fig. 3). The temperature sensors are placed at the helium inlet and outlet of the winding and also at the helium outlet of the iron yoke of each magnet. 139
140
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
x=O 0.2,
.,~
0
4.7
~" 4.5
C
0.9/1
............ x ....../ .................. - : : < ~
,,~
~-~:.'.-'iiiNi!ii~'ii~i~iii~--:--_ ...........2_._.~\.,J" #'.:'i'.'iii""!!i.:.':ii~# -.. \ i~::::::" lii~iii{ili{i{iiiiiiii ======================== Entropy
Eigure 2 T-s diagram, ql, q 2 - heat release in the helium flow from the winding and the yoke, respectively
Figure 1 The magnet in its cryostat
COMPRESSORS
S COLD BOXES KGU- 1600/4.5
2 PHASE SEPARATORS
L
1.
---
~~
~ ~
main subeooler supply header /7.
ItALF-RING~ ~ t ~ d:~ ~,t~', t___~___l~ rl [ ~ k--rJ,
--~heat shield small . . . . subcooler
___/ f.... ~"
-" [
t._ . . . . . .
] I
.1 ,
m agn ets)X// ~ r e t u r n
Eigure 3 General configuration of the Nuclotron cryogenic system
header
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings ,
1
141 170 g/s
i
)
150 r
4
~50
v
3
< O
~19 <
2
,
/4,,,
=
0.1
;:
~
5.5
t
T
0.2 0.3 0.4 REPETITION FREQUENCY(Hz)
[..(
_
0.5
Entropy
Figure 5 The refriregator cycle
Figure 4 Heat load for the Nuclotron at 4.5 K versus the repetition frequency of accelerating cycles
Figure 4 presents the values of heat load for the Nuclotron at 4.5 K versus the repetition frequency of accelerating cycles. These data have been obtained from the measured values of heat releases in individual components of the magnetic system. In addition, about 4.44 g/s of liquid helium are needed to cool the twelve 6 kA current leads. CRYOGENIC SUPPLY SYSTEM The cryogenic supply system is based on three refrigerators/liquefiers [8] of a design capacity of 1600 W at 4.5 K or 500 liters of liquid helium per hour made by the NPO "GELYMASH". Two refrigerators are connected to its own half-ring, respectively (see Fig. 3). The third one is aimed to run in the liquefaction mode with liquid helium fed to any refrigerator in the case of its failure or Nuclotron operation at a maximum frequency of accelerating cycles. The refrigerator includes three turboexpanders, double- and triple-flow heat exchangers, a wet turboexpander, and a liquid helium receiver with a volume of 1000 L. The refrigerator cycle is shown in Figure 5. The nominal pressure of compressed helium at the entrance of the refrigerator is 2.5 MPa. The pressure in the liquid helium receiver is about 0.13 MPa. The basis of the compressor system is a two-stage screw compressor [9] of a 5040 m3/h capacity designed and constructed by the Russian enterprise "KAZANCOMPRESSORMASH". Three piston compressors with a capacity of 1200 m a / h each and four piston compressors of a 900 ma/h capacity each are used for step variation of the compressed
2.0
i
i
l
i
i
,
300
|
Left half- ring
wet piston expander
ander
x 1.6
Outlet of tke windinf
Right half- ring
Outlet of theyoke
_
"-" 200
0
z 1.2
o
<
100
Y
0.8
0.4 0
O
b~
I
I
20
40
,
I
I
I
60 )30 100 LIQUEFACTION RATE ( l / h )
I
I
120
140
Figure 6 Characteristics of the refrigerator/liquefier
80
40
0 40 Ordinalnumber of the magnet
80
Figure 7 Temperature distribution for different points of the Nuclotron ring. 30 hours after cooldown starting
142
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
helium flow and its redundancy. Gaseous heluim is stored in 10 vessels of a 20 m 3 each at 3 MPa. The characteristics of the "mixed" mode: refrigeration/liquefaction are presented in Figure 6. OPERATING EXPERIENCE Nine runs of a total duration of 2200 hours were carried out from March 1993 to March 1996. The magnetic system cooldown time varying from 78 to 126 hours was determined by a given cooldown rate. The temperature distribution under cooldown is presented in Figure 7. The investigation of the accelerator systems with a gradual increase of stored energy in the magnetic system, particle acceleration and physics experiments were performed in the runs. The value of the magnetic field was increased up to 1 T what is equal to 50% of the maximum design value and deuterons were accelerated up to an energy of 2.56 GeV per nucleon. Different operation modes during data taken runs for physics were provided: variation of supply current over a range of 0,1-2,9 kA, rise time of (0,6+1,8) kA/s, flat top of current pulse (0,1+10) sec. The cooling of the magnets was stable. No flow rate oscillations in the parallel cooling channels and no quenches in magnetic elements were observed under the pressure difference above 15 kPa between the supply and return headers and complete immersion of the heat exchanger of the separator into liquid helium. The Nuclotron-type cryomagnetic system can be considered also for multi-TeV range synchrotron or collider. The first estimates in connection with this problem were presented at the American Physical Society Meeting in May this year [10]. REFERENCES Baldin, A.M. et al., Nuclotron status report, IEEE Trans. on Nucl. Sci. (1983) NS-30 4:32473249 Baldin, A.M., Status and physics programme at the Nuclotron, JINR Comm. (1992) E1-92487 Smirnov, A.A. et al., A pulsed superconducting dipole magnet for the Nuclotron, Journal de Physique (1984) C1 45:279-282 Khodzhibagiyan, H.G. and Smirnov, A.A., The concept of a superconducting magnet system for the Nuclotron, Proc. of the Twelfth Int. Cryog. Eng. Conf. (1988) 841-844 Baldin, A.M. et al., Cryogenic system of the Nuclotron- a new superconducting synchrotron, Adv. Cryog. Eng. 39 501-508 Baldin, A.M. et al., Superconducting fast cycling magnets IEEE Trans. on Appl. Superconductivity. (1995) Vol.5 2:875-877
of
the
Nuclotron,
Alexeyev, A.I. et al., Application of radio frequency method to measurements in cryogenic, Cryogenics (1991 ) 31:1020 Pron'ko, V.G. et al., JINR Comm. (1979) P18-12147 Agapov, N.N. et al., Test results of the screw oil-filled compressor "Cascade-80/25", JINR Comm. (1990) 8-90-304 10
Baldin, A.M. and Kovalenko, A.D., A 100 TeV Synchrotron/Collider based on the Nuclotrontype Cryomagnetic System. Mini-Symposium on New Low-Cost Approachers to High Energy Hadron Colliders at Fermilab. Indianapolis, May 2-5, (1996) http://www.ap.fnal.gov/PIPE/.
Mathematical Modeling of a Fermilab Helium Liquefier Coldbox
Michael G. Geynisman and Ronald J. Walker Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory , P.O.Box 500, MS313, Batavia, Illinois, 60510, USA
A mathematical model was developed to describe the thermo- and gas-dynamic processes for the equipment included in the Fermilab Central Helium Liquefier coldboxes. The model is based on a finite element approach, opposite to a global variables approach, thus providing for higher accuracy and conversion stability. Though the coefficients used in equations are unique for a given coldbox, the general approach, the equations, the methods of computations, and most of the subroutines written in FORTRAN can be readily applied to different coldboxes. The simulation results are compared against actual operating data to demonstrate applicability of the model.
INTRODUCTION The Fermilab Central Helium Liquefier (CHL) facility supplies liquid helium at 4.6K for the Fermilab Tevatron superconducting proton-antiproton collider ring and recovers warm return gases. The CHL includes two independent helium cold boxes rated at 4000 liters/hour and 5400 liters/hour with LN2 precool [ 1]. Both coldboxes have heat exchangers manufactured by ALTEK International, Inc. Coldbox-I has three oil bearing turbo-expanders manufactured by Sulzer Brothers, Ltd. Coldbox-II has three oil bearing turbo-expanders manufactured by Atlas Copco Rotoflow Corp. The Tevatron cryogenics demand for higher helium supply from CHL was the driving force to investigate an installation of an expansion engine in place of the Joule-Thomson valve. This solution is thermodynamically viable, though needs to be evaluated in terms of overall cycle efficiency and production increase versus required capital investment. Some helium liquefier facilities have reported this type of successful conversion in the past [2]. To evaluate this conversion, as well as to have a reliable simulation tool in the future, the authors have developed the mathematical model and implemented it in FORTRAN code. The model describes mathematically the thermodynamic processes in the coldbox equipment and final subcooler at steady-state conditions. The model is a set of non-linear algebraic equations, which describe the links between thermodynamic variables within the coldbox's flow paths. The FORTRAN code of the HEPAK [3] of the Cryodata Inc. is used in the model to calculate helium properties. The heat transfer in the coldbox's heat exchangers is computed by using the ALTEC plate-fin geometric data and a customized finite element analysis (FEA) method. In this method every heat exchanger is considered as a set of sections of equal length with a known geometrical data and calculated mass and heat transfer properties. Each section is calculated separately, and then all sections are laced together through "in-out" variables. The gas expansion in the turbo-expanders is computed by using relationships for each turbine's efficiency versus its speed and flow, as per data provided by turbines' manufacturer. The model allows for stable conversion to new conditions at 100% step change of any of the input variables. The overall heat balance of the coldbox is checked to determine the accuracy of conversion. The number of iterations to provide for accurate conversion is less then 10,000. The full description of the model and FORTRAN code can be found in Fermilab technical memo [4]. * Work supported by U.S. Department of Energy under contract No. DE-ACO2-76CH03000 143
144
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
COLDBOX LAYOUT AND MODEL ASSUMPTIONS Coldboxes' layout and the graphical representation of the model are shown on Fig. 1 below. One more 3path heat exchanger is not shown on Figure 1 and located on the warm end. This is a LNz-to-GHe precool heat exchanger. Though the pressure drops are the most significant for this heat exchanger, its helium gas exit temperature stays at the preset level due to fine regulation via temperature control loop. Therefore we excluded this heat exchanger from the coldbox model, but instead shifted the input variables one heat exchanger down the coldbox. WE JT2
Iso ,
sp4
I d2x(8) 12e(8,50) :12eh(50)
3
I
4
7
1
pring
m 2
tlow
d3x(8) d3e(8,50) d3eh(50) pmw
mix
d7x(8) d7e(8,50) d7eh(50)
p2 d4x(11)
d5x(11)
d4e(12,50)
d5e(12,50)
d4eh(50) d4em(50)
d5eh(50) ~ d5em(50)
I
d8x(8) d8e(8,50: d8eh(50)
r
d6x(11) d6e(12,50 d6eh(50) d6em(50)
Figure 1 Layout of t h e F e r m i l a b C H L C o l d b o x The model includes 7 heat exchangers, numbered as n from 2 to 8. The heat exchangers 2,3,7,8 are 2-path exchangers, and 4,5,6 are the 3-path ones. A heat exchanger n consists of k sections and is represented with one-dimensional array d,x of geometrical, flow and heat loss parameters, and 2dimensional arrays d,e, dneh, d,em of process parameters and fin data. The number of cross-sections k for each heat exchanger can be set independently. Iteration results have shown that 50 cross-sections are sufficient for most heat exchangers, though the model allows to set that number up to 100. The following parameters are defined as inputs and can be read from an external file for every run of the simulator: fh=dn2x(1), high path flow; spl=fl/fh, ratio of turbine 1 flow to the coldbox flow; sp2=f2/fl, ratio of turbine 2 flow to turbine 1 flow; sp3=fwe/(1-spl), ratio of wet engine flow to coldbox high side flow; phw=d2e(1,1), thw=d2e(2,1), parameters of the high path warm end; pmw=d4e(3,1), midline pressure; plw=d2e(3,1), pressure of the coldbox low path warm end (compressor suction); pring, pressure of the subcooler tube-side flow to the Ring (demand pressure); tlow, temperature of the subcooler tube side flow to the Ring (demand temperature); effwe, efficiency of wet engine. Notations are: h - high, 1 - low, m - middle pressure path; w - warm, c - cold end. For example, thw- temperature at the high pressure path warm end of a heat exchanger, or its section. The following nomenclature is used" t - temperature, K; p - pressure, Pa; n - rpm; h - enthalpy, J/kg; s - entropy, J/kg-K; f - mass flow, kg/s; p - density, kg/m3; la - viscosity, Pa-s; cp - specific heat, J/kg-K; q - quality; qh, ql, qm - heat transferred from high, middle, and to the low pressure paths, watt; ac cross section area of flow, m 2", aw - wetted fin area, m 2", flen - effective length of the heat exchanger section and the plate fins, m; de - equivalent diameter, d~ = 4. a c . f l e n + a w , m; qloss - heat load from -
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
145
outside, watt; tfin- temperatures of a fin, K; hh, hm, hlh, h i m - heat transfer coefficients between bulk temperatures in the high path and tfinh, mid path and t r i m , low path and tfinh, and low path and tfinm. Heat transfer from middle to high path is negligible. The ql = qh + q m as shown on Fig.2. The heat transfer coefficients h and the pressure drops Ap for the section of the length dx of the given heat exchanger are calculated with the following equations: h = j, "cp" G" ( P r ) -2/3 A p = f . ( d x I de). (G 2 / p)
In the above equations: G =f/ac is a mass flow per unit of area, and Pr = Cp ~t / k, k is thermal conductivity. The coefficients Jt and ft are functions of Reynolds number, where Re = de G / It. The numerical correlation between Jt and ft Re are defined per manufacturer test data. In case of the Fermilab coldbox heat exchangers ALTEC provided the authors with the tabulated data for Jt and ft vs. Reynolds numbers ranging from 40 to 40,000 for each type of its brazed aluminum plate-fin heat exchangers. Then the authors plotted the tabulated data and fitted it with non-linear fits.
tfinh
I
Lo
i
I t'
/
ql = 0.5. A . h l h . ( t f i n h - tl)
tfinh tfinm tfinm
qh - A . h h . (th - tfinh )
I
I
I
I MID
[
I
I" ~
qm=A.hm.(tfinm-tl)
Figure 2 Model of heat transfer in the 3-path plate-fin heat exchanger To obtain isentropic efficiency of the turbo-expander the authors have used the set of equations and graphical correlation between efficiency, speed and flow provided by Atlas Copco Rotoflow Corp. The equations are: 11,o, = flu - rlv P~ ]~.s ( f . Ah . q,o ' ),c,,~, n~c'"a' = nae'~ig"" [ P o w e r ae'ig" = nde"ig"" [ ( f Ah r I,,,, )a~.,.ig,,]~.s
In these equations: qu is a function of U/C 0 and rlv is a function of (flow/n) actual / (flow/n) design '
where U = ~ "n. d~h~
is a peripheral blade tip speed, and Co =
2. (/~ - / 5 ) is an ideal expansion
speed. Then the authors have fitted the graphical dependencies for flu and rlv for each turbo-expander with 3rd order polynomial equations.
STRUCTURE OF THE FORTRAN CODE The model uses the geometry of each heat exchanger to calculate the heat transfer at each point in the heat exchanger, unlike the programs which use an overall UA and a log mean temperature difference formulation. This is why it is necessary to go to a relaxation method, because the number of unknowns and equations becomes two times the number of steps or elements, typically 50 to 500. The intention of
146
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
the authors was to make a program that uses the high pass temperature at the warm end and the low pass temperature at the cold end as inputs. That generates a logical and stable calculation to use the incoming flow parameters as inputs. Each element is stored and solved, using the above parameters as input parameters. Afterwards, all the elements are relaxed by replacing the low path, middle path, and high path process parameters of the i-th section with the corresponding path process parameters of the adjacent upstream (i-1)-th or (i+l)-th section. Similarly, the same approach is used for the whole heat exchangers train by propagating calculation results as inputs for next heat exchangers after each step of iteration. The simulator reads in eight data files, one for each heat exchanger with geometrical data and guess values of process parameters for each section, plus a data file for the rest of the input data discussed above. The guess values for each section process parameters are generated with a separate FORTRAN code based on the known heat exchanger design process data, number of sections, and liner distribution. The structure of the input data files read into the simulator is identical to the structure of the output data files of the code.
RESULTS OF THE SIMULATION The simulator generates eight data files, one for each heat exchanger, geometrical data and final values of process parameters for each section, plus a data file for the coldbox global input data. The simulation model has been checked upon several sets of experimentally known process conditions for 2-compressors and 3-compressors flows. The model has proven to be accurate within 5% when allowed to converge with sufficient number of iterations (normally greater than 7500). Then multiple runs have been performed to evaluate the coldbox liquid helium production to the ring at different inlet conditions. Inlet pressure, midline pressure, exit pressure, and inlet flow are the limiting factors of the CHL coldbox. These limiting factors reduce the overall potential increase of production resulting from JT valve replacement with an expander. The pressure drop across the expansion engine in the CHL case is only 54% of that reported in [2]. Also, it must be understood that the potential increase of production due to JT valve replacement with an expansion engine is a relative number, which is dependent upon the base conditions, e.g. how close the coldbox thermodynamic efficiency to the Carnot efficiency. If a coldbox is designed and operated far below its optimum for a given set of inlet/outlet conditions, then such a replacement would produce a greater relative increase of production than for an optimized coldbox. Therefore the increase of production as much as 28% reported in [2] should be understood in this context. In case of the CHL coldbox, the potential increase of production due to wet expander installation is calculated as 10.8%.
CONCLUSION A mathematical model based on a finite element approach has been developed to describe the thermo- and gas-dynamic processes for the equipment included in a helium coldbox. The model provides for high accuracy and conversion stability. Though the coefficients used in thermo- and gas-dynamic equations are unique for a given coldbox, the general approach, the equations, the methods of computations, and most of the subroutines written in FORTRAN77 can be readily applied to different coldboxes.
REFERENCES 1. Makara, J.N., et al, Fermilab Central Helium Liquefier Upgrade Advances in Cryogenic Engineering (1994) 39A 523-529 2. Ganni, Venkatarao., et al, Capacity Upgrade of the Exell Helium Liquefier Plant by the Addition of a Wet Engine Advances in Cryogenic Engineering (1985) 31 699-707 3. HEPAK, Cryodata Inc., P.O.Box 558, Niwot, Colorado 80544, USA 4. Geynisman, M.G., Walker, R.J., Mathematical Modeling of a Fermilab Helium Liquefier Coldbox F ermil ab- C onf- 95/382
HERA at Lower Temperatures? - Operational Test of the HERA Cryogenic System at Subatmospheric Pressure.
H. Lierl*, H. Herzog** * DESY, Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron, 22607 Hamburg, Germany ** LINDE Kryotechnik A.G., 8422 Pfungen, Switzerland, postal address: *
Tests were made to lower the magnet temperatures of the HERA superconducting proton accelerator. In order to figure out the limitations for a possible energy upgrade of the proton machine from 820 GeV to 1 TeV it was tested, how far the quench limit of the magnets could be increased by lowering the magnet temperatures with the existing cryogenic system. Going to subatmospheric pressure operation by just lowering the suction pressure of the ambient temperature screw compressors showed that there are now serious limitations to go down as far as 600 mbar corresponding to 3.7 K.
INTRODUCTION In the electron proton storage ring HERA at DESY in Hamburg, Germany, protons are collided with electrons/positrons of 27.5 GeV. The 646 superconducting magnets of the HERA proton ring normally operate at 4.4 K with a magnet current of 5024 A, which corresponds to a beam energy of 820 GeV. Thinking on limitations for a possible energy upgrade to 1 TeV (6150 A), it was tested to increase the quench current limit of the magnets by lowering the operating temperature of the magnets. For the HERA magnets the average critical current at 4.4 K is higher than 6600 A, that means a safety margin of more than 1500A. The measurement of the quench current limit at some HERA magnets[l] showed a temperature dependence of about 115 A / 0.1 K (Fig. 1). 8000
j
1
T
T
F
~
]--
l
I ]
.....
7500 c-
O
7000
cO
6500
6000
3,7 3,8 3,9 4,0 4,1 4,2 4,3 4,4 4,5 4,6 4,7 4,8 4,9 M a g n e t T e m p e r a t u r e (K)
Figure 1
HERA magnets: Quench Current vs. Temperature
Decreasing the magnet temperatures would preserve this safety margin also at higher accelerator energies. With the existing cryogenic system[2] we tested the possibility to operate 147
148
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
HERA at lower temperatures. We performed this test with the total 6.4 km long magnet ring just before a scheduled warming up at the end of 1993 and a second time with a half-ring of HERA in december 1995.
THE MAGNET COOLING SCHEME The superconducting magnets are normally operated at a temperature around 4.4 K [3]. In order to avoid bubbles of helium gas, the magnet coils are cooled by supercritical, one phase helium at 4.4 K and 2.3 bar. 53 dipoles and 26 quadrupoles are cooled in series within a 623 rn long magnet octant which represents the smallest cooling loop of the accelerator ring, Fig. 2.
----~ 13,5 I ~ r I
~
106
:~)
Coldbox
I
I
Valvebox ,:,
Itgt :., /??t
/
StC<x)oler >2,3 bar
Octant -- 623m
...........................
Figure 2 The HERA cooling scheme All octants can be cooled in parallel or seperately by means of cryogenic feed and end boxes. The one phase helium passing through the magnet string is expanded in a Joule Thomson (J. T.) valve at the end of an octant and returns as two phase helium at 1.05 bar through the magnets back to the precooler in front of the octant and from there into the vapour return tube of the transfer line. A recooling of the one phase helium is performed in each dipole where one third of the single phase helium stream is in heat contact with the counterflowing two phase helium. Starting with about 90% of liquid and 10% of gas behind the J.T. valve, the two phase helium is vaporized by the transfered heat on its way back to the feed box where the then remaining 10% of liquid is collected in the precooler vessel. This liquid is used to precool the incoming one phase helium in an immersed heat exchanger. Optimal stationary cooling conditions are reached if the liquid level in the precooler vessel remains constant. This is done by the level controlled inlet valve. A heater and a J.T. refilling valve at the precooler itself allow for a quick restabilization of the liquid level in case of rapid or unforeseen load changes in the magnets. Before the cold helium leaves the central cryogenic plant into the transferline of the ring tunnel it passes a cooler within a 10 000 1 liquid helium dewar which is also used as a liquid buffer for
I
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
149
the cold box to compensate for load changes. The temperature of the magnets corresponds to the equilibrium vapour pressure in the two phase helium volumes of the precoolers and the magnets. This pressure is defined and controlled by the suction of the corresponding low stage compressors in the central cryogenic hall. SUBATMOSPHERIC TEST OPERATION In order to lower the magnet temperatures we lowered the pressure in the two phase helium volumes of the oetants to subatmospheric pressure as indicated in Fig.2. Warm gas lines like the existing quench gas collection line around the tunnel, the dewar subeooler and some other components like experiment magnets and superconducting cavities which are also supplied by the cryogenic plant remained to be operated at the normal temperature of 4.4 K and pressures around 1.03 bar. The lowering of the pressure was done with the existing ambient temperature, slide valve controlled screw compressors[4]. There are groups of four compressors (Fig. 3), which compress the helium in two steps up to 18 bar. Besides a turbine compressor there are two other low stage compressors working in parallel on the Joule Thomson circuit of the 1.03 bar down to
~ 0.6bar 4.4 bar
from coldbox
/,~
..< 18 bar
I ,nil__
TURBINE FLOW
!-
'
~
2.0 bar
first stage compressors
oil seperator
gas cooler
second oil stage sepecompressor rator
gas cooler
final oil removal
Figure 3 The HERA compressor stages magnet ring. The suction pressure is adjusted by the slide valves of these two compressors with an accuracy of + 3 mbar. They work in a split range. During normal 4.4 K operation of the system the slide valve of the second J.T. compressor is only 15 % dosed, whereas all the others are normally 100 % closed, which means maximum volume flow. By increasing the flow in the second J.T. machine to 100% we looked for the minimum pressure in the system which could be achieved. The system adjusted itself to 600 mbar corresponding to 3.7 K in the two phase circuit. The lower temperature level was reached within about 3 hours, stable conditions after another 20 hours (Fig 4). The total mass flow rate and the final high pressure practically did not change. The power consumption of the second J.T. compressor increased by about 80%, which was 7 % of the consumption of all four compressors. The compressor efficiencies measured before and after lowering the suction pressure were 44% for the JT-compressors and 56 % for the high pressure machine. Our main concern about the subatmospheric pressure operation was the potential contamination of the helium by leaks in the system. Since we loose about 40 % of the helium inventory within one year of operation, we expected an increase especially of the nitrogen contamination. Whereas in the first test the N2 detectors showed an increase from 2 vpm to 30 vpm already during subatmospheric operation, we saw in the second test no increase but during warming up of the magnets the nitrogen fraction went from 2 to about 60 vpm. Compared to an earlier warm up in 1994 this was no increase. In the last test,
150
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
1995, the other half-ring of HERA which did not operate at subatmospheric pressure showed about the same contamination during warm up. The total duration of the first test in 1993 was 2 days, the second test in 1995 lasted 10 days. 1,1 -
.~
vo,9 f/)
IX"
I
1,0
I
1
I
I
Failure and restart of ___
compressors
~
I
0,8
A
5
r 4,5 I._
0,7
...
L
_
o 0,6
QE I.--
4
~ 3,5 i-
"~0,5
ra
0,4
................
0
5
[. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 TIME ( hours )
3
0
5
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 TIME ( hours )
b.) Magnet temperature within the HERA half-ring a.) Suction pressure Figure 4 Going to subatmospheric cryogenic operation CONCLUSION Because of the ease of these tests it was worth to look for the limitations of a subatmospheric HERA operation. Since the whole cryogenic system and the compressors were not assigned for such an operation these tests nevertheless showed that it is easy and without risk to operate the suction side of the ambient temperature compressors at values down to 600 mbar. A future operation of HERA at lower temperatures might be possible by just lowering the suction pressure as described but with some additional changes like i.e. including the dewar/subcooler (Fig. 2) into the subatmospheric circuit. Though there is no obvious problem with air contamination at least within the helium circuit which was at subatmospheric pressure, there is still a potential risk for contaminations and it may be necessary to further improve the system's tightness. These tests showed to us the practicability of a subatmospheric operation with ambient temperature compressors. In addition this kind of operation is worth to be considered for other cryogenic systems if they for example use cold compressors and if it is advantageous to let the screw compressors downstream of the cold compressors operate at subatmospheric or variable pressure values, as for example suggested in reference [5]. REFERENCES 1 Lange tL, Wolff S., DESY, private communication. 2 Barton jr. H. R., Clausen M., Horlitz G., Lied H., Central Refrigeration System for the Superconducting HERA Proton Magnet Ring, Proceed.ings IC.FA Workshop on Superconducting Magnets and Cryogenics, Brookhaven Nat. Lab., Upton, N.Y., May 1216, 1986. 3 Lied H.,Wolff S., Superconducting Magnet and Cryogenic System of HERA. Review Article in Japanese Cryogenic Engineering (TEION KOGAKU), to be published, June 96. 4 Oil lubricated screw compressors: Aerzener Maschinenfabrik, Aerzen, Germany, types VMY 536 M and H. 5 Kauschke M., Haberstroh C., Quack H., Safe and Efficient Operation of Multistage Cold Compressor Systems. Contribution to the CEC/ICMC '95, Columbus, Ohio, and TESLAReport 95-21, DESY, August '95.
Cryogenics for Tokamak HT-7 SC Toroidal Magnet
Yanfang Bi, Ning Qiu, Jinrong Wang Institute of Plasma Physics, Academia Sinica, Hefei 230031, China
The superconducting toroidal magnet of tokamak HT-7 consists of 48 double pancake coils and is cooled with supercritical/two-phase helium flow. The cryogenic system is equipped with two 500W/4.5K refrigerators. During the engineering tests of tokamak the cryogenic system backed up the magnet running at the toroidal field of 1.2-1.5T for a month in 1995. After the problem of helium leak in the cryostat was solved the device can be operated at toroidal fields of 1.6-2.0 T steadily. A plasma current of 140kA amplitude and 1.3s pulse duration was achieved in March 1996.
INTRODUCTION The tokamak HT-7 is a reconstructed device from the tokamak T-7 [1]. It has the same major radius of 122cm and minor radius of 35cm, but HT-7 has much more and larger ports for heating and diagnosing plasma. In order to add 26 new larger ports the toroidal magnet (TM) was rearranged to a symmetry distribution of 24 two-double-pancake windings, and the plasma chamber, coil cases, 80K shields and cryostat shell had to be modified or rebuilt. So that the heat load at 4.6K zone increases to 130W. The TM is cooled with supercritical/two-phase helium flow. The NbTi/Cu superconductor of the coils contains nine 2mm-diameter channels. 48 double pancake coils are connected in series electrically and in parallel hydraulically. All LHe and LN2 tube lines in the cryostat were renewed and the tube joint leaks must be small enough. A primary cryogenic test for the cryostat vacuum and TM performance check was carried out before final welding the two halves of the plasma chamber in July 1994. The maximum TM current reached was 4650A. From the end of 1994 till the March 1995 the engineering tests to obtain plasma were performed. Plasma currents of 160kA amplitude and 250ms pulse duration were achieved. But the cryogenic system could back up TM current below 3000A only because of helium leak in the cryostat section for the current leads. After a leaking ceramic electrical insulator on the downstream tube line was detected and changed, the residual gas pressure in the cryostat was reduced to 4xl0-apa and tenfold smaller than before. To minimize the mass flow requirement for TM current leads (design maximum current 7000A) a couple of initial leads which require 2g/s mass flow [2] were renewed and achieved the optimized performance. The transfer lines between the refrigerator and tokamak were improved and shortened. During the normal plasma physics experiments in March 1996 the system can provide enough refrigeration and mass flow for TM operating at higher than 3000A (toroidal field > 1.5T) due to reduced heat loads. Fig.1 shows the last test site. CRYOGENIC SYSTEM DESCRIPTION The cryogenic system for HT-7 tokamak includes a helium refrigeration system and two liquid nitrogen plants as well as a LN2 distribution system. The helium system is equipped with two similar 151
152
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
500W/4.5K refrigerators/liquefiers having four piston expanders each and three piston compressors ( a small one of 6Nm3/min and two big ones of 20Nm3/min, the maximum outlet pressure of 3 MPa ). The actual capacity of the refrigerators is lower than rated data because surfaces of the heat exchangers are not big enough. Adding a 6Nm3/min compressor is a way to reach nominal capacity. For tokamak normal operation one refrigerator and one big compressor or adding a small one is required. The rest are used as spare machines. The refrigerators are located 80m away from the compressors, but only 6m distance from the HT-7 current lead unit.
Fig. 1 Tokamak HT-7 and partial cryogenic equipmen The flow diagram of refrigerator No.1 is shown in Fig.2. the refrigerator has flexible running modes" two or three stages of engine expansion, one or two J-T expansions, using injector 1 to reduce the supply helium temperature and using injector 2 to enhance the mass flow cooling the tokamak. During TM cool down the four expanders work in two stages at a return helium temperature range of 100-40K. In the range of 40-4.6K the three-stage expansion can increase the cooldown speed. If refrigerator No.1 is operated in liquefaction mode, the liquefying rate of the three-stage engine expansion increases up to 160L/hr, about 26% higher than that in two-stage expansion. While TM ramping the mass flow of > 35g/s is required. Using injector 2 can increase mass flow up to 40g/s. If injector 1 is on line, pressure in the subcooler may decrease to 0.05MPa, the temperature of outlet helium flow falls to 3.6K, but the mass flow through TM has to be reduced. According to our experience large mass flow is more effective for the HT-7 TM stability than supplying lower temperature helium flow. The 80K copper shields in the cryostat are cooled with LN2 fed from a lm3 storage vessel. The height of the vessel is 2m above the tokamak. For plasma chamber baking regime the LN2 is driven by a pump. According to the LN2 consumption rate the shield heat load is about 3.5kW/80K. The two LN2 plants can produce 300L/hr each. COOLDOWN The HT-7 TM (--14000kg weight) has been cooled down five times successfully for the primary test, engineering tests and normal plasma experiments. It takes a total of 90-100 hours from room temperature to 4.6K. The cooldown speed is limited by three factors: the helium flow temperature difference between TM outlet and inlet < 70K to avoid mechanical stress damage in TM, the supply helium pressure < 1MPa to ensure the electrical insulator safety on the helium supply tube lines in the cryostat, and the refrigeration capacity. When the return flow temperature is above 200K the mass flow
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
153
is less than 17g/s and is driven by a small compressor. While the temperature below 200K a big compressor instead of the small one. A LN2 pre-cooler in the refrigerator provides refrigeration until return gas temperature falls down to 120K. When the return flow temperature reaches 120K four expanders start and cool the heat exchangers in the refrigerator. While the mass flow temperature falls to < 100K the expanders provide refrigeration and make supply gas temperature < 80K. From 80K to 4.6K it takes 7 hours only. When the return flow temperature reaches 6K the flow enters a 250L LHe vessel in the refrigerator. Then LHe from the tokamak will accumulate more and more in the vessel within a few hours thus the TM is cooled down completely and ready for charging. The thermal radiation shields (--8000kg) in cryostat is pre-cooled with cold nitrogen gas until the maximum temperature of the shields falls to 120K, then LN2 is supplied to continue cooling the shields. The shield cooldown speed must be similar with TM and be carefully controlled. Fig.3 shows a typical cooldown process of TM and shields.
Gas bag LN2
LN2
E2
( ~ Comp. Current lead unit
J-T3
HT-7
,rl
Fig.2 Flow diagram HEAT LOADS AND STEADY STATE OPERATION When TM is cooled down to 4.6K the vacuum in cryostat should reached --4xl0-4pa if the leak level is normal. The total heat load of TM is about 130W/4.6K. To cool a couple of 7000A current leads 0.7g/s mass flow from the return line is required. The heat loss on the transfer line between the refrigerator and current lead block is estimated total 20W including 12m-length transfer tube, five bayonet connections and a bypass valve. The detail items of heat load are listed in Table 1. Because the 48 NbTi/Cu superconducting strands embedded in HT-7 conductors are parallel arrangement without twist. When magnetic field changing the coupled eddy currents can cause TM premature transition to the normal state. So to ensure TM steady operation a mass flow of 35-40g/s is required and the current ramping speed is limited while the toroidal field >0.5T. Running two expanders and a big compressor can back up the tokamak steady operation at the toroidal field < 1.6T. Injector 2 on line is necessary to increase mass flow. When the toroidal field > 1.6T a small compressor must run to enhance refrigeration and mass flow. At the mass flow of 35-40g/s the inlet pressures are 0.24-0.26MPa, and the return pressure is 0.13-0.135MPa. So the upstream flow is
154
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
supercritical and the downstream is two-phase flow. Fig.4 illustrated a T-S diagram for the steady state operation mode of refrigerator No.1. The parameters of pressure, temperature and mass flow are marked in the diagram. Table 1 Heat loads Thermal Radiation Gas Conduction at 5xl0-apa Conduction through Support Structure and Measurement Wires 50 Soldered Joints between the Windings at 6000A Current Mass Flow Cooling the Current Leads Transfer Line
70 W 15W 25 W 20 W 0.7 g/s 20 W
Total
150 W + 0.7 g/s Resistance ( O h m )
Temperature (K) ..... ]---
300
--[.....
I
l-
I
1
1
1
I
0owtemp.
.,~~
200
Copper
temp. ers
Magnet r e s i s t a n c e ~ " ~ ~
ta--
1
...... 1
--\'~",~,,,,~
three-,ta.e exuansion I
I
20
-
I__.......A
40
-I
"~_ :-.:.<-----------~
""~,,~, - \ _XL--.~-L-__-_ i---~I~~'~
60
.
.
.
.
.
.
/66.3g,s /
35g/s/ "~ f_ 1 v ~112K 5.4K~ ~ ow 7-- ...... 4 4-5~~~/~/" 126MPa
-
80
Time (hr)
Fig. 3 Cooldown of the magnet and shield
.
-
100
trans, tQ suDerconductin~ staie
290-300K 2 45MPa/- "63K / 6 7 g / s ~
I
100
0"25MPa~4(~ / 0 _ ; 1 M ~ 0"7g/s Fig. 4
T-S diagram
SUMMARY The low leak rate of cryostat, short and low heat loss transferline and the optimum current leads minimize the total heat load effectively. The last tokamak operation has confirmed that the capacity of HT-7 cryogenic system has some margin for the superconducting toroidal magnet cooldown and steady operation at 1.5-2.0T toroidal fields for a term longer than one month. ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors wish to express their gratitude to Russian cryogenic team of engineers, designers and workers from I.V. Kurchatov Atomic Energy Institute helping us to set up HT-7 cryogenic system and carry the preliminary refrigerator test during 1992-1993. REFERENCES 1 2
Ivanov D. P. et al., Some results from the T-7 tokamak superconducting magnet test program IEEE Trans. On Magnetics (1979) MAG-15 550-553 Babaev I. V. et al. Construction and test results of the cryogenics system for TOKAMAK-7 (in Russian) I.V. Kurchatov Institute of Atomic Energy, Moscow, Russia (1981) 1
Theoretical Calculation of the Large Hydrogen Liquefaction Process
Kazuho Iwamoto Nippon Sanso Corp. 6-2, Kojima-cho, Kawasaki-ku, kawasaki-city, 210 Japan
Large hydrogen liquefaction processes of capacity of 300t/day have been studied. Neon is applied as refrigerant because of its large atomic weight which is suitable for the application of a centrifugal compressor. We found that Neon Brayton cycle had the same level as Hydrogen Claude cycle in respect of the process efficiency. Applying a cold pump and reverse ortho-para conversion are effective to improve the efficiency.
INTRODUCTION According to WE-NET project started in 1994, hydrogen gas is generated by electrolysis, and then liquefied, transported, stored, and utilized as fuel with oxygen gas for electric power generation by a combustion turbine. For this purpose a large scale hydrogen liquefaction plant, which has the capacity of 300 t/day, has to developed. It is nearly 10 times larger than the largest existing plant in the world. One of the key issues of the liquefaction process is high process efficiency, which have been set over 40% Carnot as target. The studied cycles are based on the Hydrogen Claude cycle and the Neon Brayton cycle. PROCESS CONDITIONS Liquefaction process is based upon the following assumed conditions: Liquefaction condition Liquefaction rate 9300 t/day Liquid hydrogen pressure : 1.05 atm Parahydrogen concentration : more than 95% Utilization of nitrogen For liquid nitrogen or cold nitrogen gas used in the liquefaction process as auxiliary cold, equivalent energy of nitrogen is treated as power consumption. Nitrogen condition is fixed to be 1.2atm and 78.9K(saturated temperature), and equivalent energy is 1.44kW per g/s of liquid nitrogen and 0.39kW per g/s of saturated nitrogen gas. Compressor The adiabatic efficiency of compressor is assumed to be 80%. 155
156
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
Turboexpander The adiabatic efficiency of the turboexpander is assumed to be 85%. The generated power by the turboexpanders is assumed to be recovered, with efficiency of 90%. The application of two phase expanders(wet expanders)is not considered. Ortho-para converter Mainly continuous ortho-para conversion is applied, isothermal and adiabatic conversion are also applied. Conversion efficiency is assumed to be 100%(equilibrium on that temperature) Boil-off gas(BOG) Evaporating ratio for a liquid hydrogen tank of 50,000m 3 is assumed to be 0.1%/day and boil-off gas(BOG) is recovered to the low pressure line of the process. Pressure drops and heat in leak These are ignored this time. THE CHARACTERISTIC OF NEON Neon has characters as shown as the following. atomic weight" 20.2 boiling point" 27.3K(at atmosphere) critical pressure" 2.723MPa critical temperature : 44.5K triple point 90.043MPa, 24.6K To be compared with hydrogen, neon is approximately 10 times larger in atomic weight and has near boiling point, to that of hydrogen. To considered the application of a centrifugal compressor for both feed gas and recycle gas, larger atomic weight is preferable. Therefore, neon can be considered to be suitable for hydrogen liquefier except that the boiling temperature is slightly higher than that of hydrogen. HYDROGEN CLAUDE CYCLE(Case 1) The Hydrogen Claude cycle studied as the base process is shown in Fig.1. The feed gas is compressed to approximately 5.07MPa, cool-down near 80K by liquid nitrogen, and is installed at the same time, converted isothermally to 47.7% para hydrogen. A supercritical turboexpander(T4) in the feed line and its outlet pressure is limited to a minimum 1.28KPa(critical pressure). A warm temperature turboexpander(T1) and a cold temperature turboexpanders(T2) is installed in the recycle line. In the temperature range between 80 and 30K, ortho-para hydrogen conversion is done continuously. By a final expansion at a J.T.valve liquid hydrogen is produced at 0.11MPa, 20.4K, with para concentration 99.8%. BASIC NEON BRAYTON CYCLE(Case2) The Neon Brayton cycle studied as the base process is shown in Fig.2. With respect to the pressure of the feed gas and installation of T4, this cycle is the same as the Hydrogen Claude cycle. But in this cycle there are middle and cold temperature turboexpanders (T2,T3) in series installed in the recycle line.
157
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings N E O N BRYATON CYCLE USING COLD PUMP(Case3)
In addition to above-mentioned process, a process with a cold pump is the recycle line is shown Fig.3. The pump outlet pressure and temperature are 0.05MPa, 25K respectively. The result is indicated in Table l with those of Case1 and Case2. It is indicated that this process has higher efficiency than Casel. REVERSE ORTHO-PARA CONVERSION(Case4) A process in which reverse ortho-para conversion is applied in the BOG recovery line is shown Fig.4. The result is indicated in Tablel. The efficiency is slightly improved. It is to be noted that the reverse conversion is effective when recovered para hydrogen flow rate is large. CONCLUSION Several hydrogen liquefaction processes of 300t/day have been studied. Each process has over 40% Carnot efficiency based on assumed condition. The cold pump installation is effective to improve the process efficiency in Neon Brayton cycle and when the flow rate of BOG recovery line is relatively large, reverse ortho-para conversion will be also be effective.
[-12Feed
Gas
f"-~
,q
! r
~
.....
I
I)
LiquidNitrogenDe,,'ar ! ~)[I
~
-~ HydrogenRecycle
~ '
I
Recycle
I .x,
~X3
Mxl
)
Neon
LiquidNltr
/-
I
.x2
H2FeedG
+
-
T
:~
I
Mxs
Nx6
Mx6 XJrl
!
LiquidHydrogenTank A
1
LM2
Fig. 1 Hydrogen Claude Cycle(Case1)
L
t.~2
Fig.2 Basic Neon Brayton Cycle(Case2)
158
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings - ~ ~
NeonRecycle
H2 Feed Gas
I_
.r--"
I
!
Liquid Nitro ;, ,n Dewar g
-
l
I
.,.s
~--
i 1 ~_
t---'
Neon Recycle ,]
I
t
J_~---a
~
~
i
t
N ,,.3
~z~
i
!
t
!
L
I
I
3
t.~._
13
~
g Liquid Neon Dewar
Liquid Neon Dewar i id Hydrogen Dewar rz
Liquid 'Hydrogen Tank
uid tt~,~lrogen Ta
!
1
Lwlt
Fig.3 Neon Brayton Cycle Using Cold Pump(Case3)
Table1
Fig.4 Reverse Ortho-para Conversion(Case4)
Comparison of Studied Processes
Process No. Compressor Total Power [MW] Input Power by Nitrogen [MW] Recovered Generated Power [MW] Total Power [MW] Minimum Work [MW] Percent Carnot [%]
Case I
Case2
Case3
Case4
74.95 35.07 -3.40 106.6 49.5 46.4
82.97 28.36 -3.93 107.2 49.5 46.2
79.10 29.82 -3.70 105.2 49.5 47.1
76.75 31.06 -3.53 104.3 49.5 47.5
Acknowledgment The author thanks Professor H.Hirabayashi of KEK and NIFS, who is the chairman of the large hydrogen liquefaction subcommittee, MHI, and Teisan, for the discussion. The author also thanks ENAA and NEDO for the opportunity and the permission of the presentation.
Development of Helium Refrigeration Systems for 70 MW Class Superconducting Generators H.Yanagi,* M. Ikeuchi,* A. Machida,* and Y. Ikeda** *Mayekawa Mfg.Co.Ltd, Aza-Okubo, Moriya-Machi, Kita-Sooma-gun, Ibaraki 302-01, Japan **Super-GM, 5-14-10, N i s h i t e n m a , Kita-ku, O s a k a 530, J a p a n
Super-GM has been conducting R&D of 70 MW class superconducting generators ( model machines ), refrigeration system and superconducting wkes to apply superconducting technology to electric power apparatuses. Mycom has designed a refrigeration system which meets all requkements of a specified cryogenic capacity, an automatic control to different modes of operation and reliability. This paper represents a p l a ~ g of its refrigeration system, the results of performance testing at the factory and a discussion on its reliability is also given.
INTRODUCTION Super-GM (Engineering Association for superconducting Generation Equipment a n d Materials ) was established in September, 1987 to develop technology for superconducting generation equipment and materials as a national project. Since then we have been developing two types of high reliable refrigeration system for the SCG ; a conventional refrigeration system using oil injected screw compressors and an advanced refrigeration system using oil flee compressors. The main subjects in developing its refrigeration system for verification tests on site of the SCGs are to develop technology for removing impurities in helium gas which largely affects its reliability and to fu~her improve the reliability and efficiency of its components. Through factory testing a developed refrigeration system was so far confirmed to meet its requirements as a liquefaction capacity, a precooling capacity, an automatic control to different modes of operation ( cool-down, steady-state, etc. ). This paper represents a planning of the refrigeration system for the SCGs, the results of performance testing at the factory and a discussion on reliability is also given. REFRIGERATION SYSTEM REQUIRMENTS A cooling stream of 4 g / s of Liq. He is required for cooling of the three types of rotor. The Liq. He is fed to the rotor with a pressure of 0.12 MPa and a temperature of 4.4 K. It returns with a pressure of 0.1 MPa and a temperature of about 300 K. The cool-down time of the rotors is to be less than 3 days. The masses that have to be cooled down to 4.4 K are 15 to 26 metric tons. Between the reference temperature of the rotor and the cooling gas stream a temperature difference of 100 to 150 K is permitted during cool-down. Liquid nitrogen precooling can be used during cool-down. Operation of the refrigeration system is to be fully automatic. The reliability of the refrigeration system has to guarantee an uninterrupted Liq. He supply to the SCG for more than 10,000 hours, as required in power plant operation. 159
160
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
DESIGN OF THE REFRIGERATION SYSTEM As our works of the years 1986 and 1987, the reliability of helium refrigeration systems which were in operation since 1975 in Japan was investigated and analyzed, and then a conceptual design has been chosen for the refrigeration system of 70 MW SCG, applying for redundant units to a compressor unit, a 80 K cold box and a 4.5 K cold box. Figure 1 shows a block diagram of the system and its main components. A compressor unit is composed of two staged oil injected screw compressors connected with canned motors ( Hermetic canned compressors ), which allows a direct coupling without any shaft seals, and oil and moisture separators for removing down to 50 ppbw of oil and - 9 0 ~ of water vapor, respectively. A high temperature cold box ( 80 K ) houses a low temperature adsorber for removing air contaminants less than 0.1 ppmv, which might penetrate into the cryogenic region, with a capacity of purifying all the amount of circulated helium gas. For prccooling, a ffeon refrigerator is employed instead of liquid nitrogen in a steady state operation mode. A low temperature cold box ( 4.5 K ) is equipped with MYCOM developed expansion turbines with high efficiency and high expansion ratio. A storage volume of Liq. He dewar is a 2000 L. The J-T valve is installed inside at the top of the dewar to decrease evaporating loss from liquefied helium as much as possible due to a long transfer line between 4.5 K cold box and SCG. The Liq. He dewar and a distribution valve box located near the SCG are installed onto the same foundation at the field test site. Hence a coaxial three fold vacuum-jacketed and super-insulated transfer line from the dewar to the cold box is chosen so as to decrease heat leak and pressure loss. In addition a recovery and purification unit ( 200 m S / h ) is provided to the refrigeration system, which is used for a regeneration of 80 K cold box, a clean-up of the helium gas insidc the refrigeration cycle at start up operation and a warm up helium gas through the SCG besides purifb,ing recovcry gas. A gas storage tank consists of three vessels, one is used for a buffer volume of the compressors, the others arc for impure and pure helium gas storage, cach having a volume of 40 rn 3. It is dcsigned for storing all the gas present in the refrigeration system and the rotor at a pressure of 2 MPa. 1.5MPa,3OOK t
__~
~
High tempreature cold
box
I............ Heat
T~-< ...... r<>>
exihanger L_~ Charcoai
~ MPa~3OOK . . . . . .
k.._J Compressor il separator ~ m
adsorber
I. 5 M P a , 8 0 K
] > /
w
]
i
1,ol
" e
<
1--
>4 >
<
>
<
|
... 1
lO, box
Dewar Fig.1 System flow diagram
....................
i i
[-~ Transfertube ! ...............................
i @ ~
~
9
I
tempreature
cold
Low temp. stage turbo expander
[A~]__
q' Low temperature Dewar cold box
Valve dummyload Heat Box apparatus exchanger
Fig.2 Testing flow diagram
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
161
In case of a temporary shut-down of the liquefier due to failures, the Liq. He supply of the SCG can be maintained for more than 20 hours by means of the Liq. He dewar resevoir. The Liq. He is fed to the rotor by means of a heater provided inside the dewar for pressure build-up. For computer control safety a communication cable and a control processor are duplicated, and against power failures an emergency power source is provided. The recovery compressor is also connected with it. PERFORMANCE In FY 1994, a comprehensive test program was started at the factor), to confirm the refrigerator performance, using a simplified dummy load apparatus which simulates heat load during operation of the test rotors as shown in Figure 2. This program included pretesting of components, start-up procedures, precooling and warm-up capacity measurements, liquefaction capacity measurements, Liq. He supplying test and many accompany tests, and was finished in early 1995. The test results were reported in detail in C E C / I C M C 95 since we demonstrate here a transfer loss measurements due to the Liq. He transfer line between the Liq. He dewar to the dummy load apparatus via the valve box. Those transfer lines above were fabricated so as to be the same heat loss as that of the field testing on-site. Transfer Loss Measurements The transfer loss measurements were carried out
by means
of controlling the Liq. He supply valve in keeping
the liquid level in both the Liq. He dewar and the dummy load constant, and also keeping the dewar pressure constant at 0.13 MPa, while a heat load of the dummy apparatus was varied 30 to 80 W. The transfer loss ( W ) was obtained by subtracting the electric heat input of dummy load fi'om the measured mass flow rates of its outlet that is converted to an electric output. Figure 3 shows a relation between the electric heat input and output of the dummy load apparatus. It was confirmed that overall transfer loss including flush loss was 19.9 W lower than the desincd value. (w) 100 ~
s
=o
9
......................................
,-;-;
_
.... :............. : ........ . . : r
60-
..... . -
.,~
+~ z 0 9
_,
,i.,,al l' ~ , , , ~ J l ~ l l l i ~ l i b l l
'i,i
..... heat loss ~
9
~
~,
--.-.;,>, ..................
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
...... ~............. : ....
.
""~" -~e~ ! -~~
i!
40
60
'
. . . . . . . . . . . .
-!
' . . . . . . . . . . . . .
' ....
...................... i ............. L............. :,_.... l
0
20
80
Heat input
100
(w)
Fig.3 Transfer loss measurements RELIABILITY OF THE REFRIGERATION SYSTEM Evaluation of Reliability We have reported already the test results of reliability on the main components ; 1) estimation of life time
of
bearings of the screw compressors by means of a 100 times repeated start and stop operation, and a 500 hours continuous operation, 2) estimation of breakthrough of 80 K adsorber and regeneration procedure of 80 K cold box including a switch over operation to a redundant using 1 / 4 scale model, 3) an overload operation of turbo- expanders and 100 times repeated start and stop operation. It was found rxom the tests above that the MTBF of components themselves is guaranteed larger than 10,000 hours.
162
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
Provided that the compressor unit, the 80 K cold box and the 4.5 K cold box are redundant, taking into a repair time, a switching time of 80 K cold box is 1000 hours, the reliability of dewar, and computer control system and other components are 50,000 and 30,000 hours, respectively which are obtained from achievements in operation of helium refrigeration systems for accelerators or magnets. For the 4.5 K cold box the reliability is dependent on a running continuous operation time combined with the rotors. Figure 4 shows a result of evaluation taking a continuous operation time of 3000 hours. The overall reliability can be obtained 0.387 corresponding to 10,533 hours of MTBE R 2 =0.995
R 1 =0.717
I/ /2 =50 h r
I I s~w Comp~o~ .....................
R 4 =0.895
R a =0.741
Screw Compressor I 0 , 0 0 0 hr
Computer control system & Other Components 3 0 , 0 0 0 hr
High Temp. Stage Coldbox 1 , 0 0 0 hr
l
1/ /2 = 3 0 hr
I I
I
I
High Temp. Stage Coldbox
Low Temp. Stage ColdBox 3 , 0 0 0 hr (Continuous Operation Time) I
[
!
I 1/ /2 = I 0 0 hr
I
I
I
)
I
Low Temp. Stage Coldbox
.............................
RT = R I*R2"Ra'R4"R6
/2
R r --~ 0.37
1/ /2
SCG
: Repair Rate Function : Repair Time R s =0.818
Dewar
50,000 hr
Fig.4 Verification scheme of the reliability of the refrigeration system CONCLUSION The factory performance testing has been carried out successfully to confirm the specified cryogenic capacity of the helium refrigeration system for 70 MW class SCG and its system has been delivered to the verification test site. Now it is read), for a field testing combined with the rotors which will be started from October, 1996. ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work has been performed as a part of " R&D on Superconducting Technology for Electric Power Apparatus " under the New Sunshine Program of Agency of Industrial Science and Technology, MITI, being consigned by NEDO. REFERENCES Arai, K. and et al., R&D of high reliability refrigeration system for superconducting generators Advances in Cryogenic Engineering, Vol. 39 (1994) 581 Yanagi, H. and et al., The planning of a low temperature purifier for Super-GM helium refrigeration, Advances in Cryogenic Enginccring, Vol. 37 (1992) 771 Hosoya, T., Yanagi, H. and et al., R&D of high reliable refrigeration system for supcrconducting generators, Proc. of CEC/ICMC95 conference, Columbus, Ohio, USA ( 1995 )
Large scale refrigeration
Long term operation
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
R E L I A B I L I T Y OF H E L I U M R E F R I G E R A T I O N S Y S T E M S FOR THE T R I S T A N D E T E C T O R MAGNETS
Yoshikuni Doi National Laboratory for High Energy Physics (KEK) 1-10ho, Tsukuba 305 Japan
The He refrigeration systems for the TRISTAN detector magnets were constructed for cooling the superconducting solenoid magnets that are used in high energy particle physics experiments at the TRISTAN e § e- collider. Three superconducting magnets and the He refrigeration systems (VENUS, TOPAZ and AMY) are situated at different locations around the 1 km diameter TRISTAN ring. Test operations of the He refrigeration system and magnetic field measurements were carried out between 1985 and 1986. The TRISTAN physics experiments started at the end of 1986 and ended in May 1995. By the end of May 1995, the total cumulative operation hours reached 137,000 hrs. The failures during this long running period were analyzed and the reliability of He refrigeration systems was examined. The result ofanalysis : MTBF 909 hrs and MTTR 7.1 hrs. The calculated availability was 0.992 by using these values. This shows that the He refrigeration systems had a very high reliability.
INTRODUCTION
The detector magnets for electron-positron collider experiments had been installed for carrying out high energy particle physics experiments at 3 out of 4 collider experiment sites of TRISTAN electron-positron collider in KEK. Incorporating in the detectors large solenoid superconducting magnets for determination of the momentum ofparticles, helium refrigeration systems were set up with each ofthe detectors. The TRISTAN physics experiments ended in May 1995. From 1985 to May 1995, the cumulative hours of operation reached 137,000 hours (VENUS 49,000 hrs., TOPAZ 46,000 hrs., and AMY 42,000 hrs.). The failures during this long period have been analyzed and their reliability has been examined. For future improvement of the reliability of the helium refrigeration systems, the method of verifying reliability is described.
OUTLINE OF THE R E F R I G E R A T I O N SYSTEM, O P E R A T I O N A L R E C O R D S AND F A I L U R E DATA
Three refrigeration systems (VENUS, TOPAZ, AMY)[1-3] are used for cooling the superconducting magnets. The He refrigeration systems are designed such that they can be operated remotely from a central control station. Specifications of refrigeration systems are shown in Table 1. The important features commonly shared by the three refrigeration systems are as follows: (1) Claude cycle is used as refrigeration cycle with refrigeration capacity of 300--500W at 4.4 K. (2) Oil injection type screw compressor and gas-bearing expansion turbine of the rotating type are used for reliable continuous operation over a long period. (3) Medium pressure purification (pressure 1.6 MPa) is used. For cooling of superconducting magnets, both VENUS and TOPAZ, 2-phase forced flow cooling and for AMY, pool boiling cooling is adopted. Fig. 1 shows cumulative hours of operation attained by the three systems over a period of 10 years till May 1995. Each system operated roughly 42,000 -~ 49,000 hours. The figure shows test operation and operation conducted for measurement of magnetic field of the superconducting magnet till 1986 and continuous operation for 3 -~6 months since 1987 for TRISTAN physics runs. 165
166
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
Table 1 Main specifications of He refrigeration systems for the TRISTAN detector magnets
Cold box: Refrigeration Compressor : Flow rate Control dewar: LHe Storage capacity Magnet : Cold mass Thermal load Cool down time
VENUS Refrigeration system 500 W at 4.2 K 2300 Nm3/hr 1000 l 4.3 ton (A1) 40 W + 17 l/hr 14 days
TOPAZ Refrigeration system 300 W at 4.4 K 1800 Nm3/hr 800 1 4.5 ton (AI) 30 W + 17 l/hr 5 days
AMY Refrigeration system 300 W at 4.4 K 1500 Nm3/hr 2400 l (Dewar) 17 ton (Cu, SUS) 35 W + 25 l/hr 6 days
Table 2 Summary of the He refrigeration system failures Origin of failures Numbers of failure Origin of failures Numbers of failure A) Utility 34 (12) C) Impurities 19 19 (3) Cooling water line 15 (9) Electric power line D) Operation failure 15 B) Equipment 84 25 Compressor E) Construction work failure 9 (2) 12 Cold box 7 Control device F) Others 8 23 Monitor (flow meter, thermometer, etc.) Machine element 17 (operated valve, check valve, etc.) Total failure times (Mar. '85 --- May. '95) 169 (14) ( ) : Numbers of inevitable failure Table 2 shows number of failures of the systems during each period of operation. The failure data have been arranged according to the date of failure, nature of failure, causes, solution and repair times. Cumulative number of failures is 169 times. Table shows the failures arranged according to their origin in which as many as 50 % failures originated from the equipment followed by utility services and impurities. The failures also include those caused by external factors and 14 inevitable failures (failures due to power shut down in the power supply system and others which are uncontrollable within operation and maintenance management limits). For the above reasons, the following analysis is restricted to the failures of 155 cases of the refrigeration system with the exclusion of failures due to inevitable causes. The purpose is to evaluate true reliability of the refrigeration systems on the basis ofthe observations noted below.
R E L I A B I L I T Y A N A L Y S I S OF T H E R E F R I G E R A T I O N S Y S T E M S
Based on the data on the refrigeration system failures, evaluation of the reliability is conducted. The reliability of the refrigeration systems provided with repair techniques is evaluated in terms of mean time between failures (MTBF) and mean time to repair (MTTR) by calculating working rate and availability (A). Computation of MTBF, MTTR and A, based on the results of refrigeration system analysis have been described below. M T B F (Mean Time Between Failures) Fig. 2 shows the relationship between failure occurrence rate (failure rate) and cumulative operation hours. It becomes apparent from the failure rate change pattern in figure that the failure rate undergoes significant decrease from the start of test operation up to the cumulative operation hours of 15,000 hrs. The period during which this decreasing failure rate (DFR) occurs is called early failure period. [4] Due to some variations occurring since the cumulative operation hours of 15,000 hrs, the failure rate becomes nearly constant and the period of this constant failure rate (CFR) is called random failure period. Mean failure rate during this random failure period is ~ - 1.1 • 10 3/hr. Since the following equation is valid for MTBF in CFR form, MTBF ofthe refrigeration systems will amount to 909 hours.
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings MTBF -
1 )x
where
x =
167
Random failure Number Cumulative operation Time
Decrease of failure rate occurring during early failure period, i.e., the reliability growth can be evaluated with the help of reliability growth test technique [5]. Applying the concept of reliability growth test, Duane [6] of G. E. Co. plotted on bi-logarithmic co-ordinates, the relationship between failure rate and test period at the start of operation of the engine, generator, fluid machines, etc. and formulated a quantitative relationship assuming almost a linear expression. This can be expressed as follows: TCt Cumulative MTBF =
K
Where, T represents cumulative test period (cumulative operation period), ct, growth rate and K a constant. Duane found reliability growth rate inadequate when a is 0.1 - 0.2. Taking strong correction measures when tx is 0.6 -~ 0.7, a standard was found at 0.5. Following the above test method, the present data on failures are presented as reliability growth rate curve of the relationship between cumulative operation hours and cumulative MTBF in Fig. 3. Calculating strong linearity of the logarithmic relationship at a = 0.65, it may be shown that suitable repair of failures and effective maintenance management of improvements can be carried out. M T T R (Mean Time To Repair) The repair time includes time for thorough examination of the causes of failure and the time for executing remedial measures and restoration of the system operation. For example, restoration time includes completion of re-excitation in failures occurring during excitation of superconducting magnet and re-cooling operation in the refrigeration mechanism failure during cooling ofthe magnet. Fig. 4 shows the relationship between repair time (shown as mean time) and cumulative operation hours during every operation period. Considering repair time from the figures as random time since the cumulative operation hours of 31,000 hrs, its mean repair rate is calculated as la- 0.14/hr. Further, the following equation holds when the repair time becomes random. MTTR -
1
where
~ =
Total Number of Repair Cumulative Repair Time
la MTTR ofthe refrigeration system can be evaluated at 7.1 hours.
Availability Availability of refrigeration system (A) is obtained by the following equation: A
__
MTBF MTBF+MTTR
Applying the values of MTBF and MTTR obtained in the previous section, A = 0.992. This high availability shows that there would be practically no failures during the latter half period of continuous operation conducted for TRISTAN physics experiments.
SUMMARY
Failures during long period of operation were analyzed to examine the characteristics of reliability of the TRISTAN refrigeration system and its availability. The results of the analysis of the refrigeration systems are summarized below. (1) Although these refrigeration systems (having the same maintenance and operation management) are different from each other, they may be treated as similar refrigeration systems so far as reliability is concerned. Failures are classified into early failure period (when reliability shows constant growth rate) and random failure period (constant failure rate). (2) An early failure period of the refrigeration systems amounts to nearly 5.000 hours (i.e., 15,000 cumulative hours of operation ofthe three systems put together). Refrigeration systems equipped with repair systems such as the present ones provide reliability growth during early failure period. The refrigeration systems have a high growth rate of 0.65. (3) The availability of the refrigeration systems during random failure period is calculated at 99.2% on the basis of MTBF (909 hours) and MTTR (7.1 hours) of the same period. The achievement of such high availability is a result of using rotating type compressors, expansion turbines and intermediate pressure method for purification, as well as appropriate maintenance management. The availability level of these helium
168
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
refrigeration systems is considered higher than that of other refrigeration systems now working in Japan.
A C K N O W L E D G E M E N T
The author expresses his gratitude to Prof. H. Shiomi, Science and Engineering Facuky, Chuo University for his valuable advice regarding the concept of reliability of the helium refrigeration systems. Especially I thank the Cryogenics Group members, physics department of National Laboratory for High Energy Physics who participated in the operation and maintenance of helium refrigeration systems.
8000
i
10
'~ VENUS
= o
7000
.......
6000
: ......................................
sooo
=
9
:
..................
[]
topaz
t
i ................................
1 ........................
i i
!
i i
-................... ,.....................]
i
9
i!
2000. ..................~I1 ........... ~ i o0o
: ......... t
:
i 9
i
i
.............
i
ii
i
i
................
i
; i i
i
~
.......... i
i
i !
z ~
i i
...............................................
i i
I
5.
~
......... i
.... ~ .............
7i /i
~
~, ~
i :~
i!
i
:i
.....~i.............
~ i
~
i
~
i. . . . . . .
/~]; i
/~
i;
;i
iI~
~:i
~
!
i
!
i
9 ti i i i i i ...................... i,........................... ii 4000 . 1 i 3000
% ~ e~
.......~................. i ............................. i..................................... ~................. ~................................. .1
O 9--
0
3
~~i
~l ~ ~ • • ~": •
~.
5 •
1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992
ii
5x10
9
2
iii,i:iliiiiii':iiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
l
.i--i
!i
10 2 ~J -
i
.........i../.....
5xlO
,,-
10 2
993 1994 199!
Year
.............................................................................................
. . . . . . . . . . . .
10 3
,
....
10 4
10 5
Cumulative Operation Hours
Figure 1 Annual operation hours of the three He refrigeration systems
(H)
Figure 3 Reliability growth curve
20
180
160
?
x
,
(362)
i
140
15
120
100
10
80
.~
5
....
r.r.-,
60
.
i
.................................... i ......... ! ......... T........ i....................................... i...............i...............i ..............
40 20
0
,-,i
........
i ........
0
i ....................................
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Cumulative Operation Hours
(n) x lO 4
Figure 2 Failure rate of the He refrigeration systems
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Cumulative Operation llours (11) x 104 Figure 4 Repair times during every operation period
R E F E R E N C E S
.
.
.
.
6.
Arai, R., Araoka, O., Doi, Y., Haruyama, T., Ishihara, N. et al., Test operations of the VENUS superconducting magnet at KEK Nucl. Instrum. Methods A.254 (1987) 317 Doi, Y., Mito, T., Haruyama, et al., Cryogenic system of the TOPAZ thin superconducting solenoid Proc. ofICEC 11 (1986) 424 Doi, Y., Haruyama, T., Mito, T., Tsuchiya, et al., Cryogenic system of a 3 tesla superconducting solenoid for the AMY particle detector at TRISTAN Adv. Cryog. Eng. 33 (1987) 551 Shiomi, H., Reliability and Maintenance Concepts and their Advancement, Gijutsu Hyoronsha, Tokyo (1985)52 MIL-STD-1635 Reliability Growth Testing (1978) Duane, J. T. IEEE Trans Aerosp. 24-2 (1964) 563
Technical analysis and Statistics from Long Term Helium Cryoplant Operation with Experimental Superconducting Magnets at CERN D. Delikaris, J.-P. Dauvergne, F. Haug CERN, CH- 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland CERN regularly uses a large number of liquid-helium cryoplants for cooling the superconducting magnets of large particle detectors. They are installed in the experimental areas of the electron-positron collider LEP and the proton (and heavy ion) accelerator SPS for the observation of high-energy interactions of elementary particles. The typical cold mass of a detector magnet ranges from 1 to 40 tons, and typical cryoplant cooling capacities are between 400 and 800 W/4.5 K entropy equivalent. Operation must be very flexible to meet the varying experimental requirements. We intend to present technical data of the system and statistics from over 180'000 running hours during the four years from 1992 to 1995. Operation includes phases of cool-down, steady-state cooling, recovery after magnet quench or other incidents and warm-up of the superconducting magnets. Emphasis will be laid on the analysis of fault conditions, multiple interaction between perturbations and consequences for the users of liquid-helium supply interruption.
INTRODUCTION CERN began using superconducting magnets at a very early stage (in the 1970s), integrating them into its various high-energy physics experimental detectors [ 1]. Most of these magnets are still in operation today, having been used by several physics experiments in succession. The cryogenic installations have been modified over the years to meet the needs of the various users of the magnets. Today, nine cryoplants are exclusively allocated to experimental superconducting magnets. The important parameters for cryogenics are the cold mass of the magnets, which can vary according to type from 1 to 40 tons, and their stored energy, which ranges from 0.6 to 140 MJoules. The total cryogenic power used is 5,200W at 4.5K (entropy equivalent). The cryoplant cooling capacity varies from 400 to 800W at 4.5K, entropy equivalent. This paper summarises four years of cryogenic operation on all of CERN's experimental physics installations (except those used solely for the accelerators). It will be interesting to note the diversity and origin of incidents that led to stoppages in the production of liquid helium for users. It will be particularly interesting to analyse the data from stoppages directly linked to faults in the cryogenic equipment in order to gain a better understanding of the necessary improvements to the various systems when the new cryogenic installations are designed for future experiments using superconducting magnets [ 1]. SPECIFICATION OF THE CRYOGENIC SYSTEMS Helium cryogenics are currently used by two types of physics experiment at CERN: -The experiments installed on the LEP e+e - collider. Two of these (ALEPH and DELPHI) have a solenoid [2]. All the experiments (ALEPH, DELPHI, L3 and OPAL) have superconducting focusing magnets (low-g) on either side of the beam interaction point [3]. The LEP cryogenic system is divided into two main parts: at the surface can be found the helium storage, compression and purification equipment, while in the underground experiment and accelerator chamber are located the cold boxes and the liquid helium storage and distribution systems. 169
Table 1 Statistics from the last four years operation
Cryoplant Function
Cryoplant commis-
sioned in
Nominal cooling power at 4.5K (entropy equivalent)
Running Hours
Number and (Duration in hours) of accidental full stops
1992 1993 1994 1995
Total
1992
Cryogenic Origin 1993 1994 1995
TotalA
1992
1993
Other Origin 1994 1995
TotalB
(W
All Origin Total A + Total B
LEP Collider experiments ALEPH(inc1uding low-0 quadrupoles) DELPHI(inc1uding low-0 quadrupoles) OPAL low-B quadrupoles L3 low-0 quadrupoles
1988
800
6400
6480
5892 6624
25396
9(25)
22(27)
8(10)
3(23)
42(85)
50(95)
1988
800
6800
6480
6322 6696
26298
7(12)
14(11) 9(12)
7(7)
37(42)
45(59)
1976-79
400
6200
5760 6074
18034
7(17)
1206)
7(10)
0
26(43)
28(48)
1976-79
400
5950
5760
5904 6144
23758
6(15)
lO(13)
8(7)
4(5)
28(40)
37(63)
400 400 400 400 400 800
2200 0 2900 5700 3200 6200
2160 0 4320 7560 5400 5500
1464 2184 3312 5544 2760 6362
3168 3168 4152 5760 4152 6011
8992 5352 14684 24564 15512 24073
O(0)
5(4) 0
2(2) 4(4) 6(7) 5(5) l(2) 3(4)
lI(44) 2(4) 5(5) 2(3) 2(2) 4(4)
18(50)
O(0) O(0)
20(55) 7(9) 23(22) 25(61) 6(W 27(155)
5200
15550 49420 45818 45875
186663
O*
SPS Fixed Target Experiments NA35mA49.1 NA49.2 NA44l45 NA47 CMS-RD5 R&D OMEGA
Total
1976-79 1976-79 1979-1991 1976-79 1976-79 1971
TOTAL NUMBER OF LOST HOURS =
6(36) O(0) 6(17)
7(6) 5(5) l(12) 8(4)
205
*for the1995 run, the quadruples were connected to a 12kW cryogenic plant used for the cooling of the superconducting cavities in the LEP accelerator
18(18) 18(49) 4(16) 21(29) 218(380)
50(205) Cryogenic Origin
6(8)
Other Origin
380
268(585) 585
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
171
-The fixed-target experiments, installed in the areas where the various SPS particle beams are extracted. For these experiments, the cryogenic equipment (helium gas storage, compression and central purification systems) are located in buildings adjacent to the experimental halls (North Area for experiments NA35/49.1, NA49.2, NA44, NA47, CMS/RD5 and West Area for OMEGA, the oldest of all the installations). The cold boxes and the liquid helium distribution systems are installed close to the magnets they supply. All the cryogenic installations (except those of OMEGA) are entirely automated for the various operating phases of the superconducting magnets (draining, cooling, normal operation, reheating). From a central control room connected to the equipment by data networks, a team of five operators runs the installations during working hours. Outside normal working hours one operator is on stand-by duty, and in the event of a technical problem on the installations is directly alerted by an automatic paging signal, visible from the CERN Technical Control Room. It may be noted that, with the exception of OMEGA which was built in 1972, most of the others were built at the end of the 1970s (for the SPS experiments) and 1980s (for the LEP experiments). From the cryogenic point of view, it is interesting to note the diversity of magnet cooling modes to which the "external" cryogenics have had to adapt each time on initial installation (circulation by liquid helium piston pumps, supercritical liquid helium, thermosyphon or saturated boiling liquid helium bath). The first part of Table 1 shows the cryogenic installation's commissioning year and its rated power at 4.5K (entropy equivalent). It may be noted that all the cryogenic systems were first installed between 1971 and 1979 except those for the ALEPH and DELPHI experiments, which were commissioned in 1988. TECHNICAL STATISTICS AND FAULT ANALYSIS FROM OPERATIONAL DATA The second part of Table 1 shows two types of data for the periods of cryogenic operation from 1992 to 1995 inclusive. Firstly, the number of hours of operation of the installations by experiment and by year, followed by the number (and duration in hours) of accidental stoppages that led to an interruption in the supply of liquid helium to users. The cryoplants allocated exclusively to physics experiments accumulated a total of 186,663 hours of operation in four years. Table 1 also gives a more detailed view of the number and duration of liquid helium production stoppages, with a separate summary of the interruptions caused by a fault of cryogenic or other origin (essentially the related utilities). It should be noted that out of the 268 stoppages that occurred, only 50 were due to cryogenic equipment faults. More specifically, closer examination of the duration of those incidents which caused time to be lost by the accelerators and physics experiments reveals that 205 hours were associated with cryogenic equipment faults. Compared with the total number of 186,663 hours of operation, the breakdown rate was 3.13 10 -3 for all stoppages and only 1.1 10 -3 for interruptions caused by cryogenic faults. This low breakdown rate is essentially due to the rigorous annual preventive maintenance of the cryogenic installations. All maintenance procedures and spare parts management are controlled by computerised preventive and remedial maintenance systems. In the context of these figures for breakdowns caused by the cryogenic systems, it is nonetheless important to point out two major incidents: On the oldest installation, OMEGA, a helium leak from an exchanger inside the cold box brought the experiment to a halt for four weeks while repairs were made. Coincidentally, the incident occurred only five days before the end of the physics run, and therefore only cost the experiment 120 lost hours. This one incident accounts for 120 of the 205 hours lost due to the cryogenic installations in four years of operation. On the L3 installation (low-g), during the annual shutdown and after the maintenance of the 3.3kV electric cells, a phase inversion led to the destruction of the cryogenic system's helium compressor screw. Repairs took some three weeks but no lost hours were accounted for since the physics run had not yet begun. As for the other incidents caused by cryogenic equipment faults, the major technical causes were: 24V power supply cut, fault in the control and regulating valves, fault in the electrical heating systems for helium, impurities in the helium cycle and a process software crash. The other interruptions in liquid helium production were essentially due to main electrical 3.3 kV and/or 220/380V power supply failures, to the compressor and turbine water-cooling system failures and finally to faulty signals from the users' safety systems. -
-
It is important to remember that the magnets do not have sufficient liquid helium reserves to last for very long in the event of a cryoplant breakdown. Only a small number of installations such those at NA47 (reserves for 20 hours' operation) and at the low-B quadrupoles (reserves for 2 hours' operation) can be switched to standby in the event of a fault in liquid helium production. Given the physical nature of a cryogenic system, an
172
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
average utilities shutdown of 1.5 hours requires approximately 4 hours of cryogenic recovery to thermal equilibrium before the user can restore his magnet to operation. This demonstrates the importance of investment to boost the reliability of the cryogenic system utilities. Although production stoppages, whatever their origin, cannot be totally eradicated, it is important to reduce their duration as far as possible. Moreover, a moderate liquid helium buffer could give users a certain autonomy and, more specifically, allow a normal discharge of the magnet current, pending repairs to the various systems. The last point is that the various outside disturbances often cause fast current discharges (quenches). The cryogenic recovery after these quenches takes a long time and causes physics hours to be lost. The availability of the systems for physics experiments would be considerably increased by an improved selection system for triggering normal current discharges, where the cryogenics are not affected, more often than rapid discharges. REFERENCES Bremer J., Dauvergne J.-P., Delikaris D., Delruelle N., Haug F., Kesseler G., Passardi G., Rieubland J.-M., Tischhauser G., Cryogenics for CERN Experiments.Past, Present and Future, paper submitted to this Conference Dauvergne J.-P. et al, Helium Cryogenics at the LEP Experimental Areas, 1989, Cryogenic Engineering Conference, UCLA, Los Angeles, USA, Advances in Cryogenics 1990, Vol.35, p.901 Lebrun Ph. et al, Operational Experience with the LEP Low-13 Superconducting Quadrupoles, 1992,Third European Particle Accelerator Conference, Berlin, Vol.2, p. 1641
CRYOGENICS FOR CERN EXPERIMENTS. PAST, PRESENT AND FUTURE.
Johan Bremer, Jean Pierre Dauvergne, Dimitri Delikaris, Nicolas Delruelle, Friedrich Haug, Gerhard Kesseler, Giorgio Passardi, Jean Michel Rieubland, Johann Tischhauser. European Organisation for Nuclear Research, CERN, CH- 1211 Geneva 23.
Use of cryogenics at CERN was originated (in the 1960s) by bubble chambers and the associated s.c. solenoids. Complex cryoplants were installed to provide cooling at LH2 and LHe temperatures. Continuity (in the 1970s) in He cryogenics for experiments was provided by spectrometer magnets for fixed target physics of the SPS accelerator. More recently (in the 1980s), large "particle-transparent" s.c. solenoids for collider experiments (LEP) have been built demanding new cryoplants. The LHC experiments (in the 2000s) will continue the tradition with s.c. dipoles (ALICE and LHC-B), solenoids (CMS, ATLAS) and toroids (ATLAS) of unusual size. Cryogenics for experiments using noble liquids follows the same trend since the development (in the 1970s) of the first shower LAr detectors. A LKr calorimeter (about 10 m 3) will be operated in 1996 and the ATLAS experiment foresees a set of three huge LAr calorimeters (almost 90 m 3 total volume of liquid) to be installed underground.
INTRODUCTION Cryogenics for CERN accelerators, limited to some application in the past, has expanded considerably following the recent development of superconducting (s.c.) accelerating cavities and high field bending magnets. Cryoplants for a total entropy equivalent capacity of 48 kW/4.5K are in operation for the LEP2 phase of the Large Electron-Positron Collider (LEP). A factor three increase of the equivalent capacity is foreseen for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) [1 ] leading to the world's largest cryosystem. Cryogenics for experiments behaves differently and indicates a rather continuous use of cooling capacity (Fig. 1) during the entire CERN evolution. Future outlook for the LHC experiments shows that the need of cryogenics will extend well beyond the year 2005 with an increase of the expected total entropy equivalent load up to 15 kW/4.5 K. 16000
W a t t e q u i v a l e n t at 4.5 K
14000 12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 0 1960
1972
1974
1975
l
1983
m m_
1988
Figure 1 Evolution of cooling capacity for CERN experiments 173
1997
1999
2003
174
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
CRYOGENICS IN THE PAST Cryogenics at CERN was originated by bubble chambers using several fluids" LH2, LD2, LNe and their binary mixtures. Sensitive volumes ranged from 35 m 3 (BEBC) down to a few litres of the rapid cycling (30 Hz) chambers (LEBC) [2, 3]. Particle momentum analysis requested s.c. magnets adding LHe refrigeration. The complexity (as a single unit) of the cryogenic system of BEBC is still unequalled at CERN and only the LHC will lead to cryosystems of comparable diversification. Bubble chambers magnets were He bath cooled, a technique requiring large quantities of liquid with considerable safety and inventory drawbacks. BEBC had a 3.5 T, 4.7 m inner diameter magnet with a stored energy of 750 MJ. The cold mass (250 t) was immersed in a 20 m 3 bath. Refrigeration of the chambers was carried out by two-phase flow of LH2 providing isothermal cooling in the range 22 to 30 K. Only the rapid cycling chamber (RCBC, 200 litres of LH2) used gaseous He refrigeration for the internal heat exchanger(s). BEBC complex was cooled by a combined He/H2 refrigerator concentrating most of the capacity (turbines) on the He side pre-cooling the H2 circuit at 42 K. In the combined mode of operation (4.5 K and 22 K), the system had an entropy equivalent capacity of 6.7 kW/4.5 K. The most challenging additional experimental facility of BEBC was a 3 m 3 LH2 track sensitive target (TST). The TST, immersed in the chamber filled with Ne/H2 mixture (75% mole Ne), was made of a thermoplastic polycarbonate having the desired mechanical properties at low temperatures to allow pressure cycling in synchronisation with the chamber [3]. Studies of interaction of incident beams with simple and high density nuclei led to the construction of LH2 and LD2 non sensitive targets with volumes ranging again from large (35 m 3) down to a few litres. Common characteristics of the cryogenic facilities were condensation in gravity based systems by means of cryocoolers (both Stirling and Gifford-McMahon cycles). Cryogenics at LN2 temperatures followed the development of calorimeters utilising the principle of sampling ionisation chambers filled with LAr. Several calorimeters (typical LAr volumes 2 to 4 m 3) were built for proton-proton experiments in the Intersecting Storage Ring (ISR) [4, 5] and for fixed target physics of the Super Proton Synchrotron (SPS) [6]. They used a variety of cooling methods" forced flow of LAr kept sub-cooled to prevent boiling inside the sensitive volume, gas re-condensation by LN2 cooled heat exchanger(s) integrated at the top of the cryostat, re-condensation of gas in an heat exchanger located outside the cryostat and immersed in a bath of LN2 maintained at constant pressure by cryogenerator(s) (Stirling cycle). At the exception of a few small LH2 targets, all these facilities have been dismantled. PRESENT SITUATION In parallel or following the bubble chambers, SPS fixed target and p-p ISR physics required the construction of 6 s.c. magnets for particle momentum analysis (Table 1). Table 1 Superconductin~ particle MAGNET: BEBC OMEGA Field" T Stored energy: MJ Cold mass:
~ectrometers ISR SPS/NA SPS/NA SPS/NA Vertex Vertex Dipole 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.9
3.5
1.8
750
50
___50
<50
250
50
25
25
EHS [ALEPH RCBC I
DELPHI
3
I
1.5
1.2
20
55
I
130
120
40
24
I
30
30
t
Cooling principle Institute Operation
Helium bath CERN no
Super- Heliurr critical bath He with recoolin~ CERN CERN end 96 no
Helium two-phase circulated by pumps
q
t
Indirect He two-phase Thermosyphon
CERN yes
CERN yes
CERN yes
Saclay yes
Pumps
Ral yes
I C E C 1 6 / I C M C Proceedings
175
Bath cooling was progressively abandoned in favour of forced flow of He in hollow conductors [7], simplifying the cryogenic system and the cryostats. The magnet for OMEGA experiment [8] uses supercritical He flow supplied by the refrigerator with periodic bath re-cooling. A concept applied or foreseen for long string of accelerator s.c. magnets (RHIC at BNL and SSC). Forced flow of two-phase He, providing isothermal cooling, was more recently introduced [9]. Possible flow instabilities were overcome by assuring a low outlet vapour content and high flow rate per unit area by means of reciprocating LHe pumps [10]. This solution will be adopted by the s.c. magnets of the ATLAS experiment of LHC. Following the physics program, the use and location of most of the 6 magnets have frequently changed. The layout flexibility was achieved thanks to the distributed cryosystem of the SPS North Area consisting of 7 cold boxes (total entropy equivalent capacity 3 kW/4.5 K) having in common a central compression station (6 reciprocating + 1 screw compressors) [ 11 ]. A further advantage offered by this distributed system is the operational flexibility in matching the different time schedule. One of the North Area cryoplants is used by a new polarised target experiment. The target containing 5 litres of matter is made of irradiated ammonia kept at 50 mK and immersed in a field of 2.5 T to provide the same spin direction of all the protons. This experiment continues the tradition of high energy physics experiments at very low temperatures initiated with the development of dilution refrigerators [ 12]. Of the four experiments of LEP in operation since 1989, two (ALEPH and DELPHI) required s.c. "particle-transparent" high field large solenoids (Table 1) for momentum resolution of the secondary particles produced in the collisions. For both solenoids, indirect cooling method was adopted and He flow with low vapour content at coils outlet was provided by two totally different systems. ALEPH used an innovative thermosyphon concept [ 13] whereas DELPHI preferred an active system using LHe pumps. Refrigeration is provided by two identical cryoplants [14] for a total entropy equivalent of 2 kW/4.5 K. Main characteristics were the adoption, for the first time at CERN, of oil-lubricated screw compressors and of highly automated control system. Moreover, each cryoplant is capable of matching different thermal situations imposed by the operation in parallel of the low B quadrupoles associated to the experiments. The use of noble liquids is continuing for a novel SPS experiment (first operation planned in 1996) based on a LKr calorimeter (total volume of liquid about 10 m 3) [ 15]. To minimise risks of krypton losses because of lack of refrigeration, both the storage dewar and the calorimeter have two separate heat exchangers cooled by LN2" one external and the other internal. The first one re-condenses the evaporated gas via an intermediate bath of LAr and feeds by gravity the corresponding vessel. The second one exchanges heat directly with krypton and will be used only for emergency situations. The intermediate LAr bath allows to operate the LN2 system at about 0.5 MPa because Ar has a triple point (84 K) lower than Kr (116 K). Both gaseous (in the re-condensing circuit) and liquid (via a circulation pump) on-line purification have been implemented. FUTURE PERSPECTIVES The LHC project foresees four new experiments (Fig.2). HLOW B(pp) ~'~ ighLuminosity~
fcMs?
~&FutuRFeExp3
Dump)
/ /
N
(Cleaning)_.
..3
~LICE~ (Low B(Ions))
/
\
i
Low B(pp) HighLuminosity
Figure 2 LHC Layout
.
CLHC-B~ Low B (B physics)
176
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
ATLAS and CMS [ 16, 17], recently approved, include large cryogenic components. ALICE and LHC-B, in the proposal stage, envisage s.c. solutions respectively for the magnets of a muon arm and for the spectrometer analysing particles in a small solid angle forward direction. ATLAS is the most demanding in term of cryogenics [18], since the detector is based on three toroidal s.c. magnets, three LAr calorimeters and one central solenoid surrounding the inner detector. A system of s.c. toroidal magnets is justified by the high quality of the muon spectrometer, one of the guiding design criteria of ATLAS. Each toroid consists of eight coils. They are made of flat pancakes in a racetrack configuration and are assembled radially and symmetrically around the beam axis. The barrel s.c. toroid extends over 25 m and has an i./o. diameter of 9.4 and 20 m. Each of the two end-caps s.c. toroid has an axial length of 5 m and an i./o. diameter of 1.6 m and 10.6 m. The 2 T solenoid (5.3 m long, inner diameter 2.3 m) is positioned in front of the barrel calorimeter and is integrated into its vacuum vessel to avoid degrading detector performance because of additional walls. The barrel part of the LAr calorimeter (a 6.8 m long, 2.3 and 4.5 m i./o. diameter cryostat) is an e.m. "accordion" [16]. The LAr endcaps combine in the same cryostat an e.m. "accordion" and an hadronic calorimeter with flat absorber plates. Each of them extends over 3.2 rn and has an external diameter of 4.5 m. The total cold mass of the calorimeters is 570 t. CMS is based on a solenoid (13 m long, inner diameter of 5.9 m) with an uniform field of 4 T. The design is such that the associated muon spectrometer uses a single magnet simplifying the detector design. The required number of ampere-turns introduces new important features to resist the greater magnetic forces and carry the higher current: a four layer winding as opposed to one or two layers in most coils and a larger and more complex reinforced conductor. ATLAS and CMS s.c. magnets have in common He indirect cooling method and enthalpy stabilisation using high purity aluminium. CMS solenoid will be cooled by a thermosyphon system whilst the complex geometry of ATLAS toroids imposes the use of circulating pumps [ 19] to ensure hydraulic stability of the two-phase He. In the ATLAS solenoid, liquid excess in coils circuit will be provided directly by the refrigerator without the use of pumps [20]. The very large magnet cold masses and e.m. stored energies respectively 570 t, 1.6 GJ for ATLAS and 260 t, 2.5 GJ for CMS add extra cooling requirements to the basic thermal load (Table 2). Table 2 Coolin~ capacities for LHC Experiments LHC Experiment ATLAS Toroids and Liquid argon calorimeters solenoid 25000 Isothermal load at 89.3 K: watt 10600 Load 40 to 80 K" watt Isothermal load at 4.5 K: watt 2550 Liquefaction load" g/s 10.3 Total entropy equivalent load 6000 at 4.5 K including contingency'watt Precooling power 43000 9000 300 - 100 K 9watt
CMS Solenoid
ALICE Dipole
LHC-B Dipole
3400 540 2.5
-
-
m
m
1500
1000
1000
18000
The present design foresees 40 days for cool down from ambient, 4 days (ATLAS) and 12 days (CMS) thermal recovery from post-fast discharge temperatures. To satisfy the 40 days requirement and the envisaged sequential cool down from ambient to 100 K of ATLAS magnets, a cold box with a separate LN2 cooled pre-cooler are foreseen. Below 100 K, cool down or re-cooling after a fast energy dump will be carried out preferentially in parallel mode. An integrated cryosystem (pre-cooler and main cold box forming a single unit) is proposed for CMS having only one magnet. The LAr system of ATLAS consists of: a LN2 underground refrigerator (25 kW at 89 K) with a back-up of two surface LN2 dewars (each 50 m3), a pre-cooling unit, two 50 m 3 LAr tanks linked to calorimeters via a bottom line and a 15 m 3 underground LN2 buffer. Furthermore, a complex system of flexible cryogenic transfer lines is being studied to allow movements of the end-caps, for access to internal detectors without disconnecting the pipes. All these facilities should allow operation of calorimeters without any interruption since liquid transfer or re-filling might affect its purity and,
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
177
therefore, calorimeter performance. The underground dewars near the detector will make easier the emptying (total liquid volume of calorimeters is 90 m 3) in case of large liquid spillage. Operation of calorimeters requires temperature homogeneity and absence of bubbling through the high voltage gaps of the read-out plates. Internal heat exchangers fed with two-phase LN2 or LAr near or below atmospheric pressure will control the temperature distribution. To prevent boiling, the LAr will be kept sub-cooled at any level by means of an hydrostatic external head obtained by positioning the envisaged liquid expansion volumes two meters above the highest calorimeters points. The cryogenics for the other two experiments (ALICE, LHC-B) is still in a preliminary phase of definition and expected entropy equivalent capacities for each of them range from 0.5 to 1 kW/4.5 K. REFERENCES 1. L.Evans, "The Large Hadron Collider Project", Invited paper to this Conference. 2. F.Birchler et al., "Cryogenic Aspects of the 3.7 m European Bubble Chamber", Proceedings 3th Int. Cryogenic Engineering Conference, pp.244-250. 3. H.Leutz, "Track Sensitive Targets, Hybrid-and Rapid Cycling Chambers", Proceedings Supplements Nuclear Physics B, 36 (1994), pp.203-228. 4. C.W.Fabjian et al., "Iron Liquid-Argon andUranium Liquid-Argon Calorimeters for Hadron Energy Measurement", Nuclear Instruments and Methods, 141 (1977), pp. 61-80. 5. J.H.Cobb et al., "A large Liquid-Argon Shower Detector for an ISR Experiment", Nuclear Instruments and Methods, 158 (1979), pp. 93-110. 6. H.Burckardt et al., "The Beam and Detector for a High Precision Measurement of CP Violation in Neutral-Kaon Decays", Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, A268 (1988), pp. 116143. 7. M.Morpurgo, "A Superconducting Solenoid Cooled by Forced Circulation of Supercritical Helium", CERN report Nuclear Physics Division, 69-25 (September 1969). 8. M.Morpurgo, "The Design of the Superconducting Magnet for the Omega Project", Particle Accelerators, 1 (1970), pp. 255-263. 9. M.Morpurgo, "A Large Superconducting Dipole Cooled by Forced Circulation of two Phase Helium", Cryogenics, (July 1979), pp.411-414. 10. M.Morpurgo, "Design and Construction of a Pump for Liquid Helium", Cryogenics, (February 1977), pp.91-93. 11. D.Delikaris, J.P.Dauvergne, F.Haug, "Technical Analysis and Statistics from Long Term Helium Cryoplant Operation with Experimental Superconducting Magnets", Paper submitted to this Conference. 12. T.O.Niniikoski, "Dilution Refrigeration: New Concepts", Proceeding 6th Int. Cryogenic Engineering Conference, (1976) Grenoble, pp. 102-111. 13. J.C.Lottin and R.Duthil, "Aleph Solenoid Cryogenic System", Proceedings 12th Int. Cryogenic Engineering Conference", (1988), pp.117-121. 14. J.P.Dauvergne et al., "Helium Cryogenics at LEP Experimental Areas", Advances in Cryogenic Engineering, 35b (1989), pp.901-908. 15. NA48 collaboration, "The NA48 Liquid Krypton Calorimeter", Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, A316 (1992), pp. 1-7. 16. ATLAS collaboration, "Atlas Technical Proposal", CERN/LHCC 94-43, (1994) Geneva. 17. CMS collaboration, "CMS Technical Proposal", CERN/LHCC 94-38, (1994) Geneva. 18. F.Haug, J.P.Dauvergne, G.Passardi, D.Cragg, C.Cure, C.Mayri, A.Yamamoto, "Refrigeration system for the Atlas Experiment", Paper submitted to this Conference. 19. C.Mayri, C.Cure, R.Duthil, D.Cragg, F.Haug, G.Passardi, "Barrel Toroid Cryogenic System for Atlas detector", Paper submitted to this conference. 20. K.Tanaka, A.Yamamoto, Y.Doi, T.Haruyama, T.Kondo, Y.Makida, "Cryogenic Design of the Atlas Thin Superconducting Solenoid Magnet", Paper submitted to this conference.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Present State Of Tevatron Lower Temperature Operation Barry L. Norris Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory*, P.O. Box 500, MS 347, Batavia IL 60510, USA Fermilab continues to work on raising the particle energy of the Tevatron by lowering magnet temperatures using cold vapor compressors. In 1995, another two rounds of power tests were completed. These power tests, although showing significant improvement over the initial tests of 1993-94, have led to the conclusion that 1000 GeV operation cannot be attained without replacing/rearranging magnets with lower quench currents before the next Collider Run in 1999. Development of more cold compressor control strategies also continues.
INTRODUCTION Since the installation of an upgraded Tevatron Cryogenic System in the summer and fall months of 1993 [ 1], engineers at Fermilab have been working on achieving reliable 1000 GeV (4444 amp) operation of the Tevatron accelerator in Colliding Beam mode. From December 1993 until late February 1996, during a 900 GeV physics run, engineers spent dedicated periods of time on two items: 1) power testing the magnets at lower temperatures in an effort to attain reliable 1000 GeV operation and 2) determining how to make cold compressor operations in the Tevatron reliable. The results have led to the creation of better control algorithms for cold compressor pumpdowns and cold compressor reaction to system disturbances such as a quench. Further, we have concluded that to achieve 1000 GeV operation in our next Collider Run (1999) we must: remove known "limiting" magnets from our lattice, continue power testing after replacement, and optimize our temperature profile in each house. REVIEW OF LOWER TEMPERATURE POWER TESTING Since December of 1993, there have been three lower temperature ringwide power testing study periods. The initial test period [2] resulted in a steady state Colliding Beam energy of 975 GeV, operating at a cold compressor inlet condition of 3.93K (75.82 kPa). During this test period the Tevatron was also powered in a "ramp-to-quench" mode over a two day period. In this mode the magnets trained (nine training quenches total) and then peaked at 997 GeV. Scheduled power testing was concluded and the physics program began at 900 GeV. In July 1995 a second power test period took place. Again the Tevatron was tuned for a uniform cold compressor inlet temperature of 3.93K at each satellite. Several changes were made in our methods for cold compressor operation and powering. First, when pumping down each of the systems, the helium flow was kept constant for each string by lowering magnet JT valve settings as we lowered two-phase pressure. In the previous tests we had not adjusted these valve settings and thus flow rates were considerably higher (see "New Controls Strategies"). Second, instead of ramp-to-quench power testing, the energy of the machine was raised in increments of 5 GeV after successfully ramping three times. This second round of tests resulted in six meaningful quenches (twice we had heater firing unit failures resulting in quenches). This time the peak quench energy was 990 GeV. After a two month shutdown period for maintenance, a third round of power testing occurred in October, 1995. This time our results were very encouraging. We began by tuning the Tevatron to a uniform 3.93K temperature while also using the constant mass flow techniques previously discussed. It was at this time that we began to see the same set of cells quench repeatedly. The first two quenches occurred at magnet cells E24 and C42. These cells had also quenched in the July tests. This pointed to these magnets as being limiting elements. When a house contained a cell that repeatedly quenched, we adopted a strategy of lowering it's temperature to eliminate it from quenching. This allowed us to find the next limiting magnet cell. The combined results of the July 1995 and October 1995 tests are shown in Table 1 and in Figure 1. In this third round of tests the machine successfully reached a quench energy of 1010 GeV. Although considered quite an achievement, it must be noted our goal is to attain a quench energy level of 1030 GeV to guarantee reliable 1000 GeV operation. In total we tuned 11 of the 24 houses to temperatures lower than the initial 3.93K. Fig. 2 shows the temperature profile we used in the final 1010 GeV quench. * Work supported by U.S. Department of Energy under contract No. DE-ACO2-76CH0300
179
180
I C E C 1 6 / I C M C Proceedings
Table 1 1995 P o w e r Test Quench Data
Quench Number
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Quench Current (Amps)
Cold Compressor Inlet Conditions at Quenching House 2r 2r Press Temp (kPa) (K)
Date
Time
Quenching Cell
Energy (GeV)
Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct
13:03 16:08 20:01 22:55 00:44 02:37 09:00 12:13 18:38 21:42 03:49 09:16 15:36 18:25 21:26 05:03 10:59 13:56 21:26 03:54
B32U E22U F42U C42L F42U C42L C42L E24U E24U C42L C15L D19U D28L B19U E24U C32L D28L C48U E24U BI9U
930 4129 127.5 4.476 961 4267 75.81 3.928 on ramp up, very slow quench 980 4355 75.81 3.928 at flattop of 3rd ramp Heater Firing Unit Problem. Data Invalid. 990 [4390 [ 75.81 [ 3.928 I 10 sec into flattop Heater Firing Unit Problem. Data Invalid. 990 4390 75.81 3.928 10 sec into flattop 990 4390 75.81 3.928 10 sec into flattop 990 4390 75.81 3.928 20 sec into flattop 980 4355 75.81 3.928 20 sec into flattop 985 4373 75.81 3.928 22 sec into flattop 992 4404 75.81 3.928 on ramp up to 995 GeV flattop 995 4418 75.81 3.928 on ramp uo to 1000 GeV flattop 1000 4440 75.81 3.928 10 sec into flattop 1000 4440 75.81 3.928 end of flattop 1005 4462 55.13 3.635 10 sec into flattop 1003 4455 75.81 3.928 on rampup to 1005 GeV flattop 1010 4484 68.92 3.837 12 sec into flattop 1000 4440 62.03 3.740. 5 sec into flattop of 3rd ramp 1010 4480 48.25 3.521 12 sec into flattop 1010 4484 68.92 3.837 end of flattop
0 1
Quench
).7 ).7 ).7 ).7 ).8 ).8 ).8
).8 12 12 13 13 13 13 13 14 14 14 14 15
Comment
1020 iii n
1010
|l
1000 ~ 9 = O'
II
"-'
990, 980
U
/
/
/
lll
m II
"'-i-" m II
~ 3.5 > .~ 3.4
0
970
~
960
3.7 [-. 3.6
II
o
~
3.8
E ~
um~
"
3.9
iiill Ill
~ 3.3
II
m 3.2
950
3.1 3
940 2, 0
2
4
6
8 10 12 14 Quench Number
Figure 1 Quench Results of J u l y P o w e r Tests
16
18 20
October 1995
Tevatron House
Figure 2 Tevatron Temperatuare Profile on the Final 1010 G e V Quench
U n d e r s t a n d i n g and optimizing the temperature at each refrigerator is of vital importance as we are capacity limited at the Central H e l i u m Liquefier (CHL). As discussed previously [3], the C H L provides liquid helium to each satellite refrigerator to boost its capacity. The a m o u n t of liquid helium required at each building is a function of the t w o - p h a s e pressure and the speed of the cold compressor. If we do not optimize our t e m p e r a t u r e distribution at each refrigerator we risk needing m o r e liquid helium than C H L can produce. B e f o r e the conclusion of our tests, we purposely raised the temperature of a few select houses in an effort to identify, specifically, the m a g n e t in each house that was causing the quench. This effort led to the identification of five m a g n e t s that will have to be replaced before we can expect to go to higher energies.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
181
PLAN FOR ACHIEVING 1000 GeV OPERATION The next Colliding Beam Physics Run, scheduled for 1999, is to be at a beam energy of 1000 GeV. In order to meet the goal of 1030 quench energy, a general plan has been developed and is presented here. Magnet Replacement & Relocation 9 The 1995 power testing identified five limiting magnets. During a two month shutdown in the Spring of 1996 we replaced two of these. While doing so we also identified and replaced two other magnets that are potentially limiting. The remaining three limiting magnets will be replaced during a future maintenance period. 9 Using known Magnet Test Facility (MTF) test data we will continue to identify magnets in each of the 24 houses that we may want to remove or relocate (see Tevatron Configuration Analysis below). Removing or relocating these limiting magnets can only be done when problems arise in the Tevatron that necessitate warming up a house to 300K. Magnet Test Facility Testing 9 Test the thermal performance of the single phase and two phase circuits of a dipole magnet. One dipole has been highly instrumented and testing is on-going. 9 Retest the removed "limiting" magnets from the Tevatron. More Tevatron Power Testing 9 Power test in May 1996 after a two month shutdown to understand the issue of re-training. During this shutdown 21 houses were at 80K and three houses were at 300K. 9 Continue power testing as in 1995. Testing will start at 3.93K uniformly. Houses will be decreased in temperature as they quench. While power testing, we will identify the next set of limiting magnets. Tevatron Configuration Analysis Engineers are developing a precise Thermal Simulator for the Tevatron magnet strings. This simulator takes a much closer look at the thermal characteristics of dipole, quads, and specialty pieces than the normal instrumentation used to operate the machine. This simulation and old MTF quench analysis data are being used in combination to develop a magnet reshuffling program. A limiting magnet may not have to be removed from a house but merely relocated. This work has already been used in identifying potentially limiting magnets in a warm house (see Magnet Replacement and Relocation above). NEW CONTROLS STRATEGIES A new distributed control system was designed and installed as part of the Low Temperature Upgrade in 1993 [4,5]. The increase in complexity of each refrigerator required more sophisticated hardware and software capabilities than the original system, installed in the early 1980's. Our approach to the new system was to develop it in two phases. During Phase 1 our plan was to design and install the system to make daily operations reliable and equivalent to where we were with the original system. Phase 2 addressed issues like software to handle the impact of 24 cold compressors operating in the Tevatron. To date, we have accumulated 130,249 hours (average of 5427 per cold compressor) since the initial installation. This includes operating hours in powered and non-powered times. During this time we have slowly developed software to assist cold compressor operations reliability. From years of experience operating the satellites, we know it is vitally important to develop very accurate and precise automatic programs for our major transient conditions. In the past this has included 300K to 4.5K cooldown and recovery from quenches. Our limited cold compressor experiences have made it obvious to us that automatic pumpdown to lower temperatures is even more crucial. Using our Finite State Machine (FSM) software, a cryogenic engineer developed an algorithm that turns on the cold compressor and marches the machine up in speed in a controlled manner until the final pressure point is reached. As this is done, magnet string JT valves are tuned back to maintain a constant mass flow in the string while the refrigerator's dewar liquid level is adequately held within a margin. If liquid is boiled off too quickly, the program pauses, waits for dewar level to be within proper tolerances, and pumpdown resumes. Total pumpdown from 4.6K to 3.9K at the inlet of the cold compressor takes approximately 45 minutes and another 10-15 minutes to reach equilibrium at the far end of the magnet strings [6] (see Fig. 3). In the future each refrigerator could operate at a different two-phase pressure point with different JT valve settings. It is important to have an easy method for remembering such items as JT valve settings with cold compressors on or off and final cold compressor inlet pressures. We have developed a MicroVAX application program that resides on the control network containing this ringwide information. An operator, before starting a pumpdown of a house, can automatically download this table to that house. The list is used by the FSM described above. As critical parameters change they can be edited within the MicroVAX application. Multiple files are made possible if needed. An important note is that JT valve settings need to be adjusted back to the 4.5K tune if, for any reason, the cold compressor is turned off.
182
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
We have spent many hours studying cold compressor behavior during Tevatron quench events. All 24 refrigerators have common supply pressure and return pressure piping. As a result, whenever a quench of a magnet occurs, every refrigerator sees a highly elevated suction pressure. This has led to trips of the cold compressors. The scenario is as follows: 1) a quench occurs, 2) suction side pressure elevates rapidly which translates into the compressor intake elevating, 3 ) a dedicated PID control loop tries to speed the machine up to pumpdown, 4) the machine takes a large step in speed and suddenly appears to stop pumping, and 5) finally the machine trips on very high current draw. We have taken two steps to eliminate this problem. First we have changed our PID loop to limit ourselves to 100 rpm changes per step (a step change is allowed every 6 seconds). Second, during a quench, magnet pressures peak in 250 msec. This means suction pressure will also rise very quickly. To avoid nuisance trips due to quenching we have found that we can lock the speed of each cold compressor until suction pressure returns to nominal values. We accomplish this by interfacing our refrigerator microprocessors to a Tevatron Clock Event system. This event system broadcasts a quench occurance. The refrigerator processors read this event and then disable PID loops from updating. Tests of this method have shown we can eliminate unnecessary trips due to quenches. 140
90 ~, ~
essure 120
o ( ',old Corn ~
"2"
~eed
..... "
80
_m___ _ 70 ~
_ o
o
~]i~
~. 60 ...__ ~.,
80
ImP
ream lVl~Ignel[ J
40
1
~.
30 E r,.)
__
.
20 "6
.
r,..)
20
10 o
0
....... 8.4
8.6
0 rm 8.8
9.2 9.4 Time of day (hours) 9
9.6
9.8
10
Figure 3 Automatic Cold Compressor Pumpdown with Magnet JT Tuning CONCLUSION Power Testing at lower temperature over the past year has surpassed the 1000 GeV energy barrier with our ultimate goal being 1030 GeV. Plans are to continue testing while identifying and replacing/relocating limiting magnets. We continue to gain experience with operating cold compressors in the Tevatron. With this experience specialized controls features are developed to address our needs. These efforts will continue so that we may operate reliably at higher energies beginning in 1999. REFERENCE 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Theilacker, J.C., Upgrade of the Tevatron Cryogenic System, In: Advances in Cryogenic Engineering, (1994) Vol. 39A, 517 Norris, B.L., Status Report on the Tevatron Lower Temperature Upgrade, In: Cryogenics, (1994) Vol. 73,517 Fuerst, J.D., et al, Increasing the Energy of the Fermilab Tevatron Accelerator, In: 4th European Particle Accelerator Conference, (1994) Vol. 3, 2458-2460. Norris, B.L., et al., New Cryogenic Controls for the Tevatron Low Temperature Upgrade In: Advances in Cryogenic Engineering, (1994) Vol. 39B, 1185 Norris, B.L., Control system for Fermilab's Low Temperature Upgrade, Presented at the Particles Accelerator Conference 1995 Theilacker J.C., Cryogenic Testing and Analysis Associated With Lower Temperature Operation, Presented at the Cryogenic Engineering Conference 1995
CRYOGENIC
SYSTEM
9 DESCRIPTION
AND
FOR
TRISTAN
OPERATING
SUPERCONDUCTING
RF
CAVITIES
EXPERIENCE
Kenji Hosoyama*, Kazufumi Hara*, Atsushi Kabe*, Yuuji Kojima*, Tohru Ogitsu*, Yoshiyuki Morita*, Yutaka Sakamoto*,Hirotaka Nakai*, Tsuneo Fujita**, and Takayuki Kanekiyo** * KEK, National Laboratory for High Energy Physics Tsukuba, Ibaraki, 305 Japan ** Hitachi Ltd., Kudamatsu, Yamaguchi, Japan A large scale helium refrigeration system was constructed and operated for about 7 years for superconducting RF accelerating cavities (SCC) in TRISTAN electronpositron collider at National Laboratory for High Energy Physics (KEK). The 32 x 5 cell 508 MHz SCC in 16 cryostats were installed in TRISTAN electron-positron collider at KEK for further upgrading of the beam energy, from 27 GeV to 32 GeV. A short description of the main components of the cryogenic system will be given together with the operating experience gained during the commissioning and 7 years operation.
INTRODUCTION Installation of SCC in the TRISTAN was proposed for further upgrading of the beam energy and authorized as two years project in April 19861. The design study of the cryogenic system 2 was started in August 1986 and the construction was started end of 1987. The operational and upgrading histories of the cryogenic system are shown in Fig. 1. In October 1988 the first cool down test of the cryogenic system with 4 kW refrigeration power (2 turbo-expanders and liquid nitrogen precooling) and 16 x 5-cell SCC in 8 cryostats was performed successfully 3. Commissioning of SCC to TRISTAN electron-positron collider was started in November 1988. After 6 months operation additional 16 x 5-cell SCC in 8 cryostat was installed to increase the beam energy to 32 GeV and the helium refrigerator was upgraded to increase the cooling capacity from 4 kW to 8 kW and to reduce the consumption of liquid nitrogen by adding a supercritical turbo-expander, two 80 K turbo-expanders respectively 4. The operation of the cryogenic system with full 32 x 5 cell SCC was started in October 1988 and continued until end of the TRISTAN physics run in June 1995. The total operation time of the cryogenic system is abut 38,000 hours. SYSTEM OVERVIEW The flow diagram of the cryogenic system is shown in Fig. 2. The helium refrigerator with 5 turboexpanders (T1- T5) has cooling capacity about 8 kW at 4.4 K without liquid nitrogen precooling. The total required electic power is 2.6 MW including 130 kW for cooling water and oil pumps. The supercritical
1988 J Cryo. System Operation
(days)
1989 EJ
E3 F1 O i--q 138
86 64
178
Superconducting Cavity ( 5-cell x 16 in 8 Cryostats) Cryo. System Upgrade He Refrigerator LN2 Refrigerator
A
4 kW
1991
1990 DJ
( 5-cell x 16 in 8 Cryostats)
A
8 kW
EJ
1992 DJ
1993 DJ
1994 DJ
1995 DJ
O I-I r--1DI--I Ol-3158 103 13 r-1 159 86 104 181
95
D
153 100
see Test Stand ( 5-cell x 4 in 2 Cryostats)
SCC Removal
80 K Charcol Filter LN2 Turbine
Fig. 1 Operational history of the cryogenic system for TRISTAN superconducting RF cavities 183
184
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings Screw Compressor Unit
<----
Medium Pressure Gas Storage r -
100 m3x 9 = 900 m3
L
15 MPa
/~r'erl~!~l L I ~
3- C Z ~ D
9 He Gas
l 400 kPa
1.7 MPa .--->
110 kPz
"
~
"'"4Recovery
~'
Compressor 150 Nm;J/hr
High Pressure Purifier Gas Storage 0.5 m3x 18 x 4 = 36 m 3
/
Heater
/'/~__ ' ~ ' ~ ' | ,~, ~
LN2 Circulation System Cold Box
6.5 kW at 80 K
LN2 Screw Compressor Unit
<..__. 80K Charcoal Fitter
~__
Main Transfer Line
Recovery Line Header Transfer Line
~/"
.---> 6.5 kW Refrigerator
Cold Box
Liq. H e l i u ~ ~ Dewar
12,000 L
Heater
End
I.._~
120 kPa ~ 1 ~ Superconducting RF Cavity Cryostat 2 Units
Superconducting RF Cavity Cryostat 16 Units
Fig. 2 Flow diagram of the cryogenic system for TRISTAN superconducting RF cavities.
turbo-expander T3 was installed just before J-T valve to increase the cooling capacity from 4 kW to 8 kW. The helium compressor unit consists of 6 oil flooded screw compressors and 4 stage oil filters. Liquid helium produced in a 12,000 L liquid helium dewar is distributed to 16 SCC cryostats installed in about 200 m long straight section of underground TRISTAN tunnel through large size about 250 m long multi-channel transfer line. The liquid helium is also supplied to SCC test stand where we could cool down and test the spare SCC in 2 cryostats. Each cryostat contains two 5-cell 508 MHz SCC made of about 2mm thick pure niobium sheet. The cold mass and amount of liquid helium stored in a cryostat are about 1,000 kg and about 830 L respectively. The total amount of liquid helium handled in the system is about 16,500 L. For the helium gas recovery 9 x 100 m 3 medium pressure (1.9 MPa ) helium gas storage tanks are connected to the system. A 6.5 kW at 80 K liquid nitrogen circulation system with a turbo-expander and 2 screw compressors supply liquid nitrogen to 80 K thermal shield in the 16 cryostats in parallel through mutichannel transfer line. A off-line helium gas recovery system consists of a 5 stage air-cooled oil lubricated reciprocating compressor (15 MPa, 150 Nm3/hr ), high pressure low temperature purifiers (80 K, 15 MPa, 150 Nm3/hr ), and high pressure storage vessels (4 x 1350 Nm3). The whole cryogenic system is controlled by means of a process control computer system. MAINTENANCE The inspection and maintenance of the cryogenic system were performed regularly once a year during summer shut down of the system. The cryogenic system is obligated to inspect the gas tightness of the system, to measure the thickness of the vessel and pipe walls, to check the operation of safety valves and to correct pressure gauges and thermometers once a year by high pressure regulation law. During this period mechanical machines with wearing parts, such as the compressors, including the air compressors, motors, oil pumps, turbines and valves were inspected carefully and repaired if necessary. The charcoal adsorber of the main helium compressor unit was also changed. In addition the maintenance of the process control computer system were carried out. Compressors Figure 3 shows the history of the replacement and the lifetime of the mechanical shaft seals of the compressors. At an early stage in the operation the mechanical seals of the compressors had to be replaced due to leakage of oil from it. These replacements are shown by black bars in Fig. 3. The oil leaka__~a~!e ...... was
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings :
~
6
o
4
~ E =
3
....
2
z
1C
~
4
-i9
1
o
o
,9
8
12
16
20
24
28
operation hours (1000 hr)
32
36
40
2 c
:
.....
:
....
185 :
.....
:
....
:
.....
:
....
:
.....
:
....
..... i ..... i .... i ..... i .... i ..... i ....
:
.....
:
....
: ~
:
.....
:
....
;
;......ik
....
'
....
'
- - O - -
-
....
-
i : ~ i ~:
,, .... i-:: i ....... i .... '~ : i .... i ~ .... .... .... i .... i ..... .... ~ .... ' ..... i .... ..... i ......... .... i ..... ..... ..... ..... ....
0
4
8
12
16
20
24
28
Operation hours (1000 hr)
32
36
40
Fig. 3 Replacement and Lifetime of screw compressor's shaft seals
caused by worn out of pins used for fixed the seal by the mechanical vibratioo of me compressors. These failures were overcome by improving the hardness of the pins. After the adoptio,, of new type pins lifetime of the seals increased as shown in Fig. 3. The mechanical shaft seals of the main compressors were replaced at annual regular maintenance for precaution. These replacements are shown by white bars. The compressors of the 2nd stage were send to the factory for detailed inspection including the beating every three years. The checks revealed no damage. Oil Adsorbers The oil adosorber consists of 4 stages oil removal filter : mesh demister coarse oil removal just behind the compressors, 2 fine oil coalescence filters (BALSTON BX) and charcoal adsorbers. Typical measured values of the oil concentrations of outlet gas from the 1st, 2nd and 3rd were 4,000 ppm, 63 ppm and 2.5 ppm in weight. The oil recovered at the oil filters are recycled into the systems. The oil adsorber 4th filters remove the rest of oil aerosols from the helium. The adosorber of the main compressor unit is filled with 1580 L of charcoal and 400 L of molecular sieve. The oil concentration of the outlet gas from the adosorber was less than 52 ppb in weight. The charcoal adosober had to be changed every year (about 7,000 hours Table 1. List of fatal failures during 7 years operation of TRISTAN SCC cryogenic system No.
.
.
.
4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
Item
Da~
Failure (Action)
Cold Box Low bearing gas pressure of T2 turbine Nov.7, 1988 (Restart) Helium Compressor (C3) Oil leakage at the mechanical seal of the compressor unit Dec. 29, 1988 (Replace of mechanical seals) Helium Compressor (C2) Oil leakage at the mechanical seal of the compressor unit (Replace of mechanical seals and Restart) Jan. 14, 1989 High discharge pressure of the compressor unit Helium Compressor (Restart) Jan. 26, 1989 High temperature of oil due to failure of the cooling water Cooling Water [Repair of cooling water unit and Restart] Jan. 28, 1989 Electric power outage due to thunderstorm Electric Power (Restart) May 3, 1989 High temperature of oil due to incorrect set of thermal Helium Compressor switch for interlock Jun.22, 1990 (Set correct value and Restart) Erroneous removal of a control relay during the operation Cold Box (Restart) May 29, 1991 High discharge gas temperature due to incorrect set value Helium Compressor of thermal switch for interlock Jul. 8, 1991 (Set correct value and Restart) Turbine T1 trip due to excess amplitude of radial vibration Cold Box (Restart) Oct. 1, 1991 Electric power outage due to failure at transformer room Electric Power (Restart) Mar. 25,1992 Low pressure of instrument air due to valve failure Air Compressor (Repair and Restart) Feb. 11, 1993 Malfunction of unloaders due to failure of controller Helium Compressor (Manual control of unloaders and Restart) Nov. 25, 1993 Electric power outage due to failure at substation Electric Power (Restart) Mar. 24, 1994
Downtime Cryo. System Beam 4 hr + 36 hr*
--
14 hr* 8 hr* 2 hr + 7 hr* 0.3 hr + 5 hr 2 hr 7 hr + 59 hr*
59 hr
0.5 hr + 3 hr*
3 hr
4 hr + 35 hr*
39 hr
1 hr + 4 hr* 1 hr + 8 hr*
9 hr
0.5 hr + 5 hr* 1 hr + 5 hr*
6 hr
0.5 hr + 8 hr*
8.5 hr
186
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings 24 ...........i........ m
rI,..ffl 20 "~ 16 U0 ~
IJ
.... ii
1" Helium Refrigerator 2:Compressors
Ii": 3 " ~ 1
l+,:~.5~~llk
.o4 . . . :coo,,o0w.. . , ~ N,,ro0enC"cu"~ ,.--.,. i 'i
~ []
6: Imstrument Air 7: Electric Power
.
85
~, ............
. . . . . . . . . . .
T,,,, . . . . . . . . . . . .
o
E 8
i m~_f. ~'~ii . . !i_ ~! . umlmn=e~ !~ " J 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40 Opration hours (1000hr)
. . . . . . . . . .
...........
............
............
~, .
.
.
.
.
.
|
Air
Ooo,,'no~Va,or
ii!! i i!i!i! i li i i ii ! i i!i!
......~'i ... i......:i ............ !............ i"........i ................. i............ i" i ileltri ci~
12
4
. . . . . . . . . . .
I
"~ .~
/mstrur i
=,
_
..Q
z
~ 5
0 r
4
,,
8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40 Operation hours (1000 hr)
Fig. 4 Statistics of the failures and fatal failures during 7 years operation of the system
intervals), because the guaranteed lifetime of the charcoal adosorber is 8,000 hours. The replaced new charcoal filter was activated by removing the water using 120 ~ dry nitrogen gas. FAILURES OF THE CRYOGENIC SYSTEM The total number of failures in the cryogenic system during about 7 years operation was 85. This number includes 71 failures which did not interrupt the operation of the system and 14 fatal failures which caused the whole system stop. Figure 4 shows the statistics of failures and fatal failures as the function of the operation hours. We classified the failures into seven categories : 1) helium refrigerator (coldbox, turboexpanders, distribution system), 2) compressors (mechanical seals, oil pump, oil valves etc.), 3) computer control system, 4) liquid nitrogen circulation system, 5) cooling water, 6) instrument air, 7) electric power (main power failure by thunderstorm etc.). The fatal failures and down time of the cryogenic system and the beam of TRISTAN are summarized in table 1. In the table * indicate the recovery time i.e. time require the cryogenic system recovered to the same condition as just before the system down. SUMMARY The cryogenic system for the TRISATN superconducting RF cavity was operated very stably and reliably for about 38,000 hours in 7 years. The experience in long operation of the large cryogenic system shows the compressor is the key component and the regular maintenance of the system including utilities is essential to attain the system reliability. ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors wish thanks Professors S. Kurokawa and Y. Kimura for thier continuous support and encouragement and the operation crew, the staff of the superconducting cavity group and Mr. M. Noguchi of Mayekawa for their devoted support and many helpful discussions. REFERENCES 1. Y. Kimura, TRISTAN project and KEK activities, in: Proc.XIII the International conference on high energy accelerators", Novosibirsk, U.S.S.R., (1986) 2. K. Hara et al., Cryogenic system for TRISTAN superconducting RF cavity, in: "Advances in Cryogenic Engineering", Vol.33, Plenum Press, New York (1988),p.615 3. K. Hosoyama et al., Cryogenic system for the TRISTAN superconducting RF cavities: performance test and present status, in: "Advances in Cryogenic Engineering", Vol.35, Plenum Press, New York, (1990) p.933 4. K. Hosoyama et al., Cryogenic system for TRISTAN superconducting RF cavities: upgrading and present status, to be published in: "Advances in Cryogenic Engineering", Vol.37, Plenum Press, New York,(1992)
Large scale refrigeration
Compressors
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
High Power Refrigeration at Temperatures Around 2.0 K
Guy Gistau-Baguer Air Liquide, Advanced Technology Division, BP 15, 38360 Sassenage, France
The possible technologies for pumping on the liquid helium bath are reviewed. An emphasis is put on cryogenic dynamic compressors, their bearings and their wheels. Arrangement of the compressors and their behaviour during transient situations are analysed. Information on existing machines is given. I thank companies which provided me with data concerning their machines. However, I may not be aware of all developements or applications and some wrong information may have crept into my paper.
INTRODUCTION There are very good reasons for operating magnets and resonant cavities at temperatures lower than T(k) (2.17 K). The saturation curve of helium shows that the pressure on the bath is 3129 Pa (0.03129 b) at 2.0 K and 1638 Pa (0.01638 b) at 1.8 K. This means that the theoretical compression ratio to reach atmospheric pressure is between 32:1 to 61"1. When taking real pressure drops into consideration, the tree compression ratio is higher, and can reach 100:1. Plants of power higher than 200 W are considered. HOW TO GET TEMPERATURES AROUND 2.0 K ? In order to achieve the required high compression ratios, pumping on the liquid helium bath can be made : 1) at room temperature, 2)at cryogenic temperatures or 3)partially at cryogenic then at room temperatures (see figure 1). Possible technologies are of the volumetric or dynamic type : see Table 1. At room temperature, all machines which are used for helium compression have to cope with its subatmospherlc \ ~ ~oots
subatmospherlc ~ Llould rl CycLe ~ rLi uld rln9 OIMPQ. , compressor
CycLe O~M I, P~ compressor b) rl?lers
Cycte
O,iMP)~pressor(lb
Purl?lers
29K
240g/s
IA
~L
og
~=L
I
o~L ~u
4'17~b)
f.
......
i rJ
I 300W
1600P~ (0,016b)
300W
II II 1300Pa (0,013b)
Figure 1. Pumping on the helium bath 189
5000W
3100Pa (O.031b)
190
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings
Table 1. Possible technologies for operation at temperatures around 2.0 K (legend : best suited, low compression ratio, limited volumetric flow rate) ~_-==_
.
.
.
.
.
-
.
.
.
.
.
~
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Volumetric Dynamic _R__o_omTempera_ture_ ..................C~pg_e_m___c_.................................................R_POmTempe_rature ..........................C~_o_g_e__m__c .................................................
Roots Rota~ vane Piston Scroll Mquid ring
Ejector Piston
Ejector Radial Axial-radial
Scroll ?
Screw significant heat of compression. Rotary vane pumps have limited volumetric flow and they must be specially cooled. The Roots pumps are well suited for high compression ratio when processing air at very low mass flow rate, but helium operation actually limits the pressure difference to about 3000 Pa (0.030 b). Roots pumps have been used in a number of situations, either alone, with up to 5 stages in series by BOC (UK) [ 1], or in combination with rotary vane pumps : 3 Roots in series followed by 1 stage of 3 rotary vane pumps in parallel by Leybold (Germany) [2]. Existing piston and scroll compressors have insufficient volumetric flow. The ejector has insufficient compression ratio [3]. Liquid cooled machines like liquid ring pumps or oil lubricated screw compressors can withstand reasonable compression ratios. The reasonable suction pressure of liquid ring pumps is about 3000 Pa (0.030 b), therefore they must be used in combination with a first stage which can be a Roots. They are operated with the same kind of oil that is used in the screw compressors. Up to now, screw compressors have only been used for operation at higher temperatures [4]. They also need a booster stage. Room temperature pumping has the great disadvantage of having part of the circuits 9piping and machines, operating at sub-atmospheric pressure in the air. It is very likely that air leaks will appear and plug cold parts, which is not compatible with long term operation. It is therefore necessary to incorporate purification means which can be regenerated during operation of the plant, such as a dryer at the inlet of the cold box and adsorbers inside it. The heat exchangers operating at very low pressure are difficult to build : they must have a low pressure drop in order to keep the size of the first stage pumping machine reasonable, but have also to be efficient. Helium compression can also be made partially at cryogenic temperatures and partially at room temperature [5]. The heat exchanger becomes easier to design and make because its operating pressure is higher. For operation at cryogenic temperatures, a piston compressor has been developed by CCI and Fermilab (USA) [6] aiming at a temperature around 3.5 K, but volumetric flow and reliability are limited. Today, no system of this type is in operation. The cryogenic ejector, which is a tricky device, has insufficient compression ratio [7]. A scroll volumetric cryogenic compressor is presently been developed by the French Atomic Energy Commission [8]. The concept seems promising in that it shows its reliability. Finally, for temperatures around 2.0 K, cryogenic dynamic compressors are the most commonly used machines at the present time, which warrants a more-detailed analysis. Dynamic compression" a reminder Figure 2 is a customary method of presentation of a typical performance map for a compressor [9,10] : the pressure ratio across the whole machine is plotted as a function of (( reduced ~ flow 9rh * T ~ / P (rh 9mass flow rate, T 9inlet temperature, P 9inlet pressure), for fixed values of ~( reduced ~ speed " N / T ~ (N : rotational speed). At the left upper limit of the map, the stall line shows the limit of stable operation, unstable operation being characterised by a severe oscillation of the mass flow rate through the machine. The fight part shows the choked region where the constant speed lines tend to the vertical. No further increase in reduced flow is possible since sonic velocity is attained through some section of the machine. The efficiency hill can also be plotted on the compressor map. The characteristic number" k, = co * Q0.5 / AHO.75(co 9rotational speed, Q~ 9inlet volume flow, AH" enthalpy difference), is used as an index to flow path shape and type of machine in a range of applications. A low number means that the energy change is high, relative to the flow rate (high compression ratio) 9a radial impeller is needed. A high number means that the energy change is low, relative to the flow rate (low compression ratio) : an
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
191 C("'
~
I..F~.,,
llml~Pl.l,.,+,'~im
m
/ linesofconstantefficiency
]
linesof constant ~~
++++],; ~
maximumefficiency
LN2 I I
~ ~
reducedflow"~ ~~
Figure 3. Cross section of a cryogenic centrifugal compressor with active magnetic bearings
Figure 2. Overall characteristic map of a dynamic compressor
axial impeller is needed. The radial wheel structure is best suited to high compression ratio which is what we are seeking. However, in the case of a cryogenic compressor, there are other parameters to be taken in consideration. For example, an axial-radial wheel has a lower diameter than a radial one ; therefore, phenomena like heat inleak and energy dissipation due to friction, which are both linked to the overall dimensions are reduced, sometimes giving a higher isentropic efficiency. The bearing system The bearing system required for a dynamic compressor must have similar characteristics to an expansion turbine : high rotational speed, no pollution, high reliability, low maintenance. Present machines incorporate 91) ball, 2) gas and 3) magnetic bearing types. The improvements to ceramic ball bearings has given running speeds compatible with operation of dynamic compressors. The life time is somewhat limited, but current expectations are in the order of a few thousands operating hours between maintenance. Linde/PBS (Germany/Czech Republic) produced such a machine operating at 1000 Pa (0.010 b) suction pressure [11]. Barber Nichols (USA) also produces such machines which operate at higher suction pressure [12]. Dynamic gas bearings are used in machines which are operating at suction pressures not lower than 0.05 MPa (0.5 b), therefore, the operating pressure of the bearing is about atmospheric. ]HI (Japan) produced such machines with foil bearings for FNAL [13]. However, there is a concern about the load bearing capability of the bearing system, when the suction pressure of the compressor is as low as 1000 Pa (0.010 b). Static gas bearings and a turbine drive are used in a cryogenic compressor developed by Air Liquid: for CERN. It seems to be a promising concept, and it is not yet in the final phase. The problem of the leaktightness between the bearings and the cycle has been solved by means of a labyrinth, a special chamber of which is connected to a mechanical pump. Magnetic bearings can operate at room or cryogenic temperature (see figure 3). They incorporate an electrical drive. Up to now, the active magnetic beating cryogenic compressors are the only type to have been "industrially" used in large scale refrigeration at 2.0 K or lower (see Table 2). Table 2. Comparison of bearing systems
Oil Ball Gas static Gas dynamic M:.::_:+a~netic
speed speed no low pressure
::::::
labyrinth labyrinth
? good good H i
g
h
High 8000 h ? High High ....................
192
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
CRYOGENIC COMPRESSOR ARRANGEMENTS. The simplest cryogenic compressor arrangement is the pure series one, as used for CEBAF. The last stage discharge temperature is about 30 K for a 2.0 K operation and as high as 40 K for a 1.75 K operation. Operation of the last stage requires a high rotational speed because of the high inlet temperature and the small volumetric flow rate. The "high" discharge temperature makes it essential to connect the discharge side of the last stage compressor to the correct temperature level in the main cold box heat exchangers. If the design of the last stage is difficult, due to excessive power or rotational speed, or when a lower discharge temperature is sought, interstage cooling becomes necessary. It can be achieved by means of some boiling fluid or gas withdrawn from the cold box. Decreasing the suction temperature of a cryogenic compressor reduces the size of the machine and its power input, but such cooling power is still provided by the refrigerator. Therefore, the optimum efficiency of the system requires a delicate trade-off. Interstage cooling must be compatible with transient situations like cooldown. Different arrangements are possible. Up to now, none of them have yet been incorporated into a refrigerator. THE COOLDOWN PROCESS The cooldown process consists of changing the overall compression ratio from 1"1 up to the nominal value i. e. 40:1 or 100:1. Volumetric machines are slightly affected by a change in compression ratio within their operating range : when it increases, the volumetric efficiency is reduced. Therefore, the cooldown process is an easy operation. In the case of dynamic machines, it is necessary to keep the operating point of each of the stages inside the stable region of the compressor map, keeping in mind the peculiarities of a cryogenic compressor" the operating temperatures and pressures at the beginning of the cooldown process are different from the nominal operation ones, the mass flow is the same for each machine (except if partial bypasses are used). Consequently, the only parameter which is free is the rotational speed of each stage [ 14]. If we compare with the usual problem of starting a train of compressors operating at room temperature, we can identify the differences : the temperatures during the startup process do not differ very much from the nominal ones, therefore recycling is easier, but generally, the rotational speed of all stages is the same. If at least one stage of volumetric machine is incorporated downstream of the dynamic compressors, it makes the situation easier because the almost constant volumetric flow of the volumetric machine allows the dynamic ones to operate with a compression ratio which is reducing with flow, so, the operating point of the dynamic compressor stays in the correct region of the map. TRANSIENT SITUATIONS The equipment to be cooled at temperatures around 2.0 K generate heat loads which are lower during periods when the system is not operating at nominal. During turn-down situations it is generally required that the pressure on the helium bath is kept constant, so the compression ratio is to be kept constant when the mass flow rate is lower. For volumetric machines, there is no problem. However, the situation is delicate with dynamic compressors 9the operating point on the map is moving to the lett and hits the stall line. One easy, but thermodynamically non satisfactory, way is to compensate the missing flow by injection of electrical power into the liquid bath. H. Quack proposes to allow the discharge pressure of the dynamic compressors to decrease with the mass flow [ 15], in combination with a temperature Table 3. Comparison of pumping methods ..................................................................................................
Cryogenic power Sub-atmospheric circuit Low pressure heat exchanger Stability Reduced flow operation ..Ma!ntenanc_e
..........................
limited yes delicate natural natural
................................................................ .!mpo
xed..dut.y. ................................... C
unlimited yes easy easy easy
ant ................................................. r e d u c e d
o.
..e..nic .....
unlimited no none reasonable delicate
............................................ l o w
...................
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
193
stabilisation at the inlet of the third stage compressor. The disadvantage is to have part of the room temperature system operating at sub-atmospheric pressure. CERN proposes to operate at a lower first stage suction pressure [ 16]. There is still a significant amount of work to be done on this topic. EXISTING MACHINES, PROJECTS Today, few large refrigerators are operating. The Stanford refrigerator was the very first one. Let's imagine what a challenge it was at that time ! Then, 3 similar machines were built by Messer Table 4. Existing machines and projects. (legend ; R" Roots, CC 9cryogenic compressor, V 9vane pump, LR" liquid ring pump, s 9series, p 9parallel) Temperature Power
Pumping system
.............................................................................................................................................................
CERN BNL CERN TTF Tore Supra CEBAF
1.8 K 2.6K 1.8 K 1.8 K 1.75 K 2.0 K
300 W 13700W 360 W 200 W 320 W 4800 W
1.8 K 2.0 K
2400 W 3720 W
Efficiency vs..Camot
5 Rs 4CCs 1 CC + 3 Rs + 3 Vp 2 Rp + 2 Rs + 4 Vp 0.140 2 CCs + 2 LRs 4 CCs 0.185
Elapsed
....... a t . .......
time Remark ...........................................
not operating not operating
22700 h 16000 h
avail. > 98%
Projects
LHC TESLA
x 8 plants x 14.pl.a..nt.s........
Griesheim, Linde and BOC. All of them were based on room temperature pumping with Roots. Today, none of them are being operated at the original design temperature. The large plant at Brookhaven National Laboratory (USA) : 13.7 kW @ 2.6 K, had a very innovative design, incorporating different cryogenic compressors and circulators with room temperature oil bearings [ 17]. Unfortunately, the accelerator which was to be cooled by this refrigerator was cancelled and consequently, as the refrigerator had some difficulty in reaching its nominal performance, there was no further attempt to fix the situation. The first plant to have been "industrially" operated is Tore Supra : 320 W @ 1.75 K incorporating cryogenic compressors (with cryogenic active magnetic beatings) and liquid ring pumps. Operational experience is good : since 1986, 22700 hours of operation at temperatures lower than T()~) have been accumulated [18]. High reliability of cryogenic compressors and liquid ring pumps has been demonstrated. The second large refrigerator was built for CEBAF : 4800 W @ 2.0 K, where the pumping system is totally cryogenic. After a quite long startup period, experience has been really positive : since the start of the operation of the accelerator 16000 hours have been accumulated at temperature around 2.0 K during runs of more than 80 consecutive days and the total availability of the cryogenic system is more than 98 % [19]. The CERN LHC cryogenic test stand is a room temperature pumping system (Roots and rotary vane pumps) for 120 W @ 1.8 K which can be boosted with a cryogenic compressor in order to triple the power. CERN is presently evaluating two cryogenic compressor technologies 9ball and static gas beating [8] in view of the LHC project. The Tesla Test Facility (TTF) at DESY Hamburg (Germany) 9 200 W @ 1.8 K, is a room temperature pumping system, very smilar to the CERN one. There is also a project for boosting the present system with a cryogenic compressor. Current active projects are LHC at CERN and TESLA. Both require a large amount of power 9about 20 kW @ 1.8 K for LHC and about 52 kW @ 2.0 K for TESLA. For both projects, extensive studies by laboratories and industry are being conducted in order to decide what would be the best suitable structure for the refrigeration system. In case of LHC, one has to take into consideration that the existing large LEP refrigerators will be part of the LHC system. It seems that a prudent approach could be to build and test full-size sensitive components before incorporating them into the system. Such full-size tests would allow to experience the operation of the whole refrigeration system, i.e. the pumping system and the refrigerator. All such tests should be conducted with test equipment which can be included into the cold box to simulate the steady state and transient situations.
194
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
CONCLUSION. Today, refrigerators operating at temperatures around 2.0 K are demonstrating their capability to cool large cryogenic systems in an <
>way. This is a very important and positive input for projects as LHC and TESLA the size of which is about one order of magnitude larger. However, there is still some thought to be given to the problem of operating such refrigerators at reduced capacity in an optimized thermodynamic way. REFERENCES. Steel, A. J., Bruzzi, S. and Clarke, M. E., A 300 W 1.8 K refrigerator and distribution system for the CERN superconducting RF particule separator. International Cryogenic Engineering Conference 6 (1976) editeur, pages 2 Benda, V. and al, Cryogenic infrastructure for superfluid helium testing of LHC prototype superconducting magnets. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering, Vol 39A, 641-648 3 Quack, H. International Cryogenic Engineering Conference (1978) London 4 Spath, F. and al., A 2 kW He refrigerator for SC magnets tests down to 3.3 K, International Cryogenic Engineering Conference 14 (1992) 56-59 5 Gistau, G. M. The Tore Supra 300 W - 1.75 K refrigerator. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering, Vol 31 607-615 6 Fuerst, J. D., Design, construction and operation of a two cylinder reciprocating cold compressor. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering, Vol 37B 795-800 7 Mulder, J., The use of an expansion ejector in a 5 W refrigerator at 1.8 K. International Cryogenic Engineering Conference 4 (1972) 111-114 s Lebrun, Ph., Claudet, G. and Tavian, L., Development of large capacity refrigeration at 1.8 K for the Large Hadron Collider. Kryogenika, Praha April1996, 54 -59. 9 Dixon, S. L., Fluid mechanics. Pergamon Press. ~0 Gistau, G. M., Villard, J. C. and Turcat, F., Application range of Cryogenic Centrifugal Compressors. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering Vol 35B 1031-1037 ~ Schustr, P., Vins, M., Brunowsky, I. and Tucek, L. Helium low temperature compressor. Proceedings of Kryogenika April 96, 78-82 ~zProduct catalog of Barber Nichols ~3Fuerst, J. Selection of cold compressors for the Fermilab Tevatron. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering, Vol 39A 863-869 14 Bevins, B. S. and al, Automatic pumpdown of the 2K cold copmpressors for the CEBAF central helium liquefier. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering Vol 40 (to be published) ~5Kauschke, M., Haberstroh, C. and Quack, H. Safe and efficient operation of multistage compressors systems. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering Vol 40 (to be published) ~6 Guignard, J. Ph. Contribution h l'rtude de la stabilit6 de fonctionnement et de l'adaptation de charge des compresseurs centrifuges multi-&ages. Internal note CERN 1993. ~7 Brown, D. P., Schlafke, A. and Wu, K. C. Cycle design for the Isabelle helium refrigerator. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering Vol 27 501-508 ~s Gravil, B. 10 years of operation of the Tore Supra Cryogenic system. NIFS Symposium on Cryogenic systems, Mai 1996 Toki, Japan ~9Chronis, W. C. and al, Commissioning of the CHL refrigerator at CEBAF. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering Vol 40 (to be published)
A Cryogenic Axial-Centrifugal Compressor For Superfluid Helium Refrigeration
L. Decker, K. L6hlein, P. Schustr* M. Vine*, I. Brunovsk3~ § L. Tucek , Ph. Lebrun + and L. Tavian + Linde Kryotechnik, CH-8422 Pfungen, Switzerland * ATEKO,Resslova 13, CS-50010 Hradec Kr~ilov6, Czech Republic § PBS, CS-59512 Velk~i Bite~, Czech Republic + LHC Division, CERN, CH-1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland
CERN's new project, the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), will use superfluid helium as coolant for its high-field superconducting magnets and therefore require large capacity refrigeration at 1.8 K. This may only be achieved by subatmospheric compression of gaseous helium at cryogenic temperature. To stimulate development of this technology, CERN has procured from industry prototype Cold Compressor Units (CCU). This unit is based on a cryogenic axial-centrifugal compressor, running on ceramic ball bearings and driven by a variable-frequency electrical motor operating under low-pressure helium at ambient temperature. The machine has been commissioned and is now in operation. After describing basic constructional features of the compressor, we report on measured performance.
INTRODUCTION CERN's new project, the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) [1] now under construction, will use superfluid helium as coolant for its high-field superconducting magnets and therefore require large capacity refrigeration at 1.8 K. This may only be achieved by subatmospheric compression of gaseous helium at cryogenic temperature. To stimulate development of this technology, CERN has procured from Linde, with ATEKO and PBS as subcontractors, a prototype Cold Compressor Unit (CCU) with a nominal flowrate of 18 g/s @ 1 kPa inlet pressure, with a pressure ratio of 3 and with an isentropic efficiency better than 60 %. These specifications also meet the need for a booster stage enabling to triple the capacity of an existing warm pumping unit (WPU) which provides 1.8 K refrigeration to the CERN cryogenic test station, an upgrade described in a companion paper [2]. The compliance of the system allows to handle low flow continuously varying over the range from 6 to 18 g/s, with a pressure ratio of 1 to 3 and with an isentropic efficiency better than 0.5. For a given mass-flow, the gas inlet temperature may vary depending upon the number of test stations in operation. Table 1 summarizes the main specifications of the CCU. Table 1 Main specifications of CCU Capacity Helium flow-rate [g/s] Suction Pressure [kPa] Discharge pressure [kPa] Pressure ratio Helium suction temperature [K] Isentropic efficiency 195
Nominal
Low-flow
18
6 to 18
1
<1
3 3 3.5 to 4.4 >0.6
lto3 5.3 to 3.5 >0.5
196
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
BASIC CONSTRUCTIONAL FEATURES General Layout The main constituent of the CCU is a cold box which houses all components at low temperature. On the top flange, the cold compressor is mounted with vertical axis. A cartridge design allows to remove the rotating part of the compressor without breaking the vacuum of the CCU enclosure. Two bayonet connections to the compressor inlet and outlet constitute the interface with a separate valve box which contains two insulation valves and a bypass valve. Figure 1 shows the general layout of the CCU.
Vacuum guard
Connection bayonet . ~ o l d compressor cartridge
i
~
Frequency converter
Cold box abinet
Figure 1 General layout of the CCU Cold compressor description [3] The axial-centrifugal unshrouded wheel with a diameter of 118 mm is fixed to the bearing shaft by a titanium tube giving reduced heat inleaks. Ceramic ball bearings and a variable-frequency electrical motor drive operate under low-pressure helium at ambient temperature. Motor drive, bearings and wheel compose the cartridge. The cold part constituted by the diffuser and volute remains inside the CCU cold box and is supported from the top flange by a thin-walled stainless steel tube. Instrumentation Efficiency assessment of the cold compressor requires accurate temperature and pressure measurements at inlet and outlet. Two calibrated germanium temperature sensors and two absolute pressure gauges have been chosen to fulfill this requirement. Other standard pressure and temperature measurements allow to monitor purge, cooldown, pumpdown and warmup. To avoid risk of air inleaks, all warm components which are working below atmospheric pressure are placed in a vacuum guard.
COMMISSIONING PROGRESS Commissioning was performed in two steps. During August 1995, pressure and leak tightness tests as well as piping integrity were checked. Cooldown and warmup were also performed. Initial problems of electrical breakdown in very-low pressure helium in the motor housing precluded performance tests. After improving electrical insulation, a second test campaign took place in November 1995 to complete commissioning.
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
197
RESULTS Cooldown and warmup These two operations take a few hours each. Cooldown is produced by the helium flow pumped by the WPU in series with the CCU. During this phase, the two insulation valves are open, the drive speed is fixed to 100 Hz and the bypass valve controls the pressure difference between inlet and outlet of the compressor. For warmup, the CCU is completely stopped. A small flow of warm helium gas is injected at the CCU inlet and discharged at the outlet in a recovery line. Static heat inleaks Heat inleaks were assessed by inlet-outlet temperature difference measurement with the compressor stopped and for different flow rates, yielding a value of 50 W. Due to an increased thickness of the volute support tube during manufacturing (to avoid uncertainties from assembly and unexpected problems during tests), the heat load is 16 W higher and thus affects the global isentropic efficiency. Nominal and low-flow operation In steady-state operation, the compressor controls its suction pressure Pin by adjusting the motor drive speed N. The inlet pressure then stays stable within 10 Pa, better than the required value of 50 Pa. For a given mass-flow rh, the volumetric characteristic of the WPU fixes the CCU outlet pressure and consequently the pressure ratio of the cold compressor. Several measurements were done varying mass flow from 6 to 18 g/s and inlet temperature Tin from 3.5 K to 5.3 K. Table 2 summarized the main results and figure 2 shows the measured points on the calculated compression field. The operating conditions of turbomachines are expressed in terms of reduced mass-flow rhr and speed Nr, defined as follows:
m/ in in0
r / in0 VTin
Tin 0 Pin
with subscript 0 for design conditions
Table 2 Nominal and low-flow measurements Point
rh [g/s]
Tin [K]
Pin [kPa]
Tout [K]
Pressure ratio
Isentropic efficiency
N [Hz]
Nr [Hz]
fiar [g/s]
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
8.1 10.2 12.2 14.2 16 18 18 18.2 18
4.42 3.85 4.68 4.34 3.69 3.46 4.17 3.31 2.87
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0.95
6.55 6.09 7.74 7.60 6.80 6.75 8.16 6.52 6.03
1.25 1.57 1.92 2.27 2.57 2.95 2.95 2.98 3.40
0.19 0.34 0.46 0.52 0.54 0.57 0.56 0.56 0.57
228 265 353 376 367 381 430 375 366
203 252 306 338 358 384 394 385 404
9.10 10.70 14.11 15.81 16.43 17.90 19.65 17.70 17.16
Isentropic efficiency The measured isentropic efficiency is slightly below specification. The measurement error, which depends on those on temperature and pressure, is estimated to +_ 0.02. The higher static heat inleaks to the cold compressor, which account for a loss of efficiency between 0.03 and 0.06, depending upon their exact location, may thus explain the difference to the specified efficiency. Possible corrective actions are being investigated by the manufacturer. At low flow, the relative proportion of the static heat loads in the loss of efficiency increases and below 14 g/s, it is no longer possible to obtain the specified value of 0.5. Stall line measurement By adjusting a bypass valve on the WPU, it was possible to run the cold compressor at constant pressure ratio with smaller mass flow. In this way, one can reach and explore the stall limit of the wheel. Figure 2 shows the good agreement between the calculated and measured stall limits.
198
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings _
9
f 3 . 5
-
8_ ~
_
'q
Z
417 9\
-Iz
400 Hz
O
.m
t~
2.5-
-
-._.,..
o~
- 333 Hz
4
IX.
.I
.,_.cO---r,
_
3
I
1 . 5
367 Hz
I
-
i
Measurement points
m 300 Hz
Nominal Iso-Nr calculation
267 Hz
Stall calculation
1
Stall measurement
_
6
8
10
12
14
16
Reduced mass-flow [g/s]
18
20
22
i
Figure 2 CCU reduced compression field (parameter is reduced speed Nr). Endurance test In the course of the second test campaign, the CCU was operated in fully automatic mode, for a total of 50 hours without interruption. This test gives confidence in the future use of the CCU but more operating experience is required in order to qualify the long-term reliability of the bearings and motor drive. Identical motor and bearings installed in a test rig simulating operating conditions at Linde's have so far gone through more than 6000 hours of continuous operation without any problem.
CONCLUSION With the exception of a slightly lower than specified isentropic efficiency, the CCU supplied by Linde, ATEKO and PBS fulfills the technical requirements. Studies to improve its performance are under way. Moreover, additional tests are in progress to qualify long-term performance and reliability of the drive and bearing system.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors wish to acknowledge contributions of A. B6zaguet, S Claudet, D. Lavielle, and B. Vullierme to the preparation and execution of the cold compressor tests.
REFERENCES The LHC Study Group, The Large Hadron Collider, Conceptual Design, CERN Report AC/95-05(LHC) (1995). Benda, V., Dauvergne, J.P., Haug, F., Knoops, S., Lebrun, Ph., Sergo, V., Tavian, L., and Vullierme, B., Upgrade Of The CERN Cryogenic Station for Superfluid Helium Testing of Prototype LHC Superconducting Magnets, paper presented at this conference. Schustr, P., Vine, M., Brunovsk3~, I. and Tu'~ek, L., Helium Low Temperature compressor, Proc. Kryogenika 96, Prague (1996)
Upgrade of the CERN Cryogenic Station for Superfluid Helium Testing of Prototype LHC Superconducting Magnets
V. Benda, J.P. Dauvergne, F. Haug, S. Knoops, Ph. Lebrun, F. Momal, V. Sergo, L. Tavian and B. Vullierme LHC Division, CERN, CH-1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland
The cryogenic infrastructure of the station for testing LHC prototype superconducting magnets in superfluid helium below 2 K has been upgraded. Liquid nitrogen precooling has permitted to increase the liquefaction capacity of the refrigerator. The addition of cold centrifugal compressors with a pressure ratio of 3:1 has boosted the capacity of the warm pumping unit. To ensure adaptation of the pumping capacity, a heater-and-valve box allows to bypass the cold compressors. This box also comprises a 32 kW electrical heater for warming up the low-pressure gaseous helium before it enters the volumetric warm pumping unit. Possible impurities in the helium returning from the subatmospheric circuits are trapped in a freeze-out helium cleaner. Automatic process control and supervision permit unattended operation and optimal management of the helium inventory.
INTRODUCTION In preparation for CERN's new project, the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) [ 1], we have been operating since 1993 a cryogenic station [2] for testing prototype superconducting magnets in superfluid helium below 2 K. In view of the development of full-scale magnet tests, as well as the operation of a 50-m long prototype magnet string, we have now upgraded the cryogenic infrastructure of the test station.
LIQUID NITROGEN PRECOOLING A liquid nitrogen precooler was ordered to Air Liquide in 1995 and commissioned at CERN at the beginning of 1996. This device, connected to the 6 kW @ 4.5 K Air Liquide refrigerator, permits to increase the liquefaction capacity from 18 to 37 g/s. To reach this liquefaction capacity, a 1.85 MPa helium flow of 40 g/s coming from the high-pressure side of the refrigerator cycle, is precooled down to 81 K by means of a liquid nitrogen economizer, and reinjected at the corresponding temperature level in the refrigerator. As it is preecooled, this flow is purified in a 260 1 "Silicagel" adsorber. Figure 1 shows the flow-scheme of the precooling system, which consumes 700 1/h of liquid nitrogen. The adsorber is designed for 250-hour autonomy but the overall autonomy is still limited bythe main refrigerator adsorber. The impurity level is continuously analyzed at the bottom of the adsorber bed and a 3-hour regeneration cycle is initiated after impurity detection. The "Silicagel" bed is warmed up by gaseous nitrogen flow and cleaned by pumpdown and flushing with pure helium. The precooler is designed for a maximum mass flow of 80 g/s, which would yield a liquefaction capacity of 75 g/s. To reach this, a supplementary upgrade of the refrigerator is required. In particular, the expansion turbines have to be modified for higher flow and cycle compressors have to be added. Rapid cooldown and warmup of the superconducting magnet under test are performed by forced flow of gaseous helium under pressure, presently tapped from the cycle compressors of the refrigerator. 199
200
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings GHe, 300 K, 1.85 MPa
~12VENT LINE
EVACUATION GHe RECOVERY "SILICAGEL" A GN2 SUPPLY ANALYSER
LN2 SUPPLY PRECOOLED He, 81 K, 1.85 MPa (TO REFRIGERATOR) PURE HP He SUPPLY
Figure 1 Flow-scheme of the liquid nitrogen precooling unit
PUMPING CAPACITY UPGRADE Figure 2 shows the upgraded flow scheme of the pumping system which integrates two alternately used cold compressor units (CCU1 and 2), a heater-and-valve box (HVB), the existing warm pumping unit (WPU) and a freeze-out cleaner. HVB He REFRIGERATOR~ LP LINE
- I
FREEZE-OUT CLEANER
WARM PU MPI NG UNIT
iii!~iii~iELECTRICnL~iiiiii!iiiii~,i!ii~,ii':iiiiiii~,!i'~!i!i~:i:....... :::::::::::::::::::: ::i:ii:iiii:i~:i:!~i!~!:....ii:i~::i:~:i ~::, i~::~:i~::i;!:i:~i!~i!i~i:~ii~i~i!i~i~!i!!i?iii~~,ii:~i~iii!,!:~i:~'i:~!~i!~!i:i~i~i~i~i~i!!i!ii:!!iii!:!i~i~!:::~i~iii!~!i:~!i!~i~i~:i~i[
TEST STATIONS
CCU 1
~
CCU2
Figure 2 Flow-scheme of the pumping system Heater-and-valve box To ensure continuous adaptation of the pumping capacity over the range of flow-rate produced by the user devices, the HVB allows to bypass the low-pressure gaseous helium from the cold compressors. Below 6 g/s the WPU can handle the pumping flow alone; for higher flow, the coupling of one CCU is required. Two DN125 mm isolation valves, connection bayonets and U-tube transfer lines permit to connect alternately either CCU. For CCU commissioning, a dedicated helium test cryostat (HTC) is connected to the HVB to generate adjustable helium flow. This cryostat is also used for testing special 1.8 K components. The HVB also comprises a low-pressure drop, 32 kW electrical heater [3], for warming up the gaseous helium at 1 to 3 kPa before it enters the WPU. This heater is constituted of two 16 kW cartridges in series. Longitudinal copper plates, with a total exchange surface of 10 m 2, are heated by coaxial heating elements, brazed under vacuum to the plates for good thermal contact. To avoid electrical breakdown in very-low pressure gaseous helium, the coaxial heating elements are helium-tight and all electrical connections are outside the low-pressure vessel. Figure 3 shows the heater cross-section and Figure 4 the HVB. This heater has to handle large flow variations and due to its big thermal inertia, is controlled by the combination of a PID algorithm and an open loop calculating heating demand from measured flow. The heater is powered by a pulse-width modulation, 3-phase 400 V power converter.
201
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings i
I
E
f
]
]
,]
E IE,t
]
/
I HEATING ELEMENT ~ CuBAR x~
I /
/
/
/
/
"
BRAZING ALLOY /,~
/
/
/
/
,/',/"
I
Figure 3 Heater cross-section
Figure 4 Heater-and-valve box
Cold compressor units The addition of cold centrifugal compressors with a pressure ratio of 3:1 has boosted the flow capacity of the warm volumetric pumping unit (WPU) from 6 to 18 g/s at 1 kPa suction, thus providing a useful refrigeration capacity of 360 W @ 1.8 K. The CCU supplied by Linde [4] is now commissioned, the other CCU supplied by Air Liquide has run and is being improved. Freeze-out helium cleaner Possible impurities in the 18 g/s helium flow returning from the subatmospheric circuits are trapped on-line in a freeze-out cleaner operating at atmospheric pressure, the design of which has been described in reference [5]. Figure 5 shows the flow-scheme of this purifier. The contamination is removed by cryotrapping sequentially in a freeze-out element and in a filter operating at a temperature of 30 K. Cooling of the gas is obtained by injection of liquid helium at a rate of 10 % of the main stream. GN2 SUPPLY GN2 VENT LINE GHe RECOVERY
/
/
REFRIGERATOR GHe HP LINE
r~ z
@
'L r
REFRIGERATOR GHe LP LINE
Figure 5 Flow-scheme of the freeze-out cleaner
LHe SUPPLY
202
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
The system is designed to trap 1 kg of air before saturation, resulting to a minimum autonomy of about 300 hours. Regeneration is initiated when the purifier pressure drop increases up to 15 kPa. The system is warmed up to 90 K and purged with gaseous helium. Such a cleaning takes 30 minutes. High temperature regeneration, with nitrogen circulation, is not automatic and is only used in case of water contamination. During the regeneration, the pumping flow can be directly injected into the suction side of the cycle compressors if the impurity level is acceptable, or else is recovered in gas bags.
PROCESS CONTROL AND SUPERVISION All additions to the upgraded system are automatically controlled, thus allowing unattended operation. The liquid nitrogen precooler and the freeze-out cleaner are controlled by the existing ABB system of the refrigerator. The cold compressor units have their own Siemens programmable logic controller (PLC). A new "Utility" PLC controls the heater-and-valve box and the liquid helium distribution to the different test stations. An Ethernet| network interconnects the different PLCs, so that the "Utility" PLC is able to manage the helium inventory as well as the instantaneous consumption and availability of fluids and utilities for each test station. Operator interface is constituted by local operator panel and/or by workstations and X-terminals running a FactoryLink| supervision software. In total, 11 PLCs are simultaneously operating, while 3 workstations and 5 X-terminals manage the supervision of the test station area.
CONCLUSION With a total liquefaction capacity of 37 g/s and with a total pumping flow of 18 g/s at 1 kPa suction which provides a useful refrigeration capacity of 360 W @ 1.8 K and allows the parallel supply of 4 test stations, the cryogenic infrastructure of the test station has now reached the required capacity for testing full-scale magnets and the 50-m long prototype magnet string for the coming years. Comprehensive process control and supervision permits to operate the test stations with minimum staff. The next step will be to install a second 6 kW @ 4.5 K refrigerator available at CERN and to add dedicated circulation compressors for magnet cooldown and warmup.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We would like to acknowledge the contributions of our colleagues S. Claudet, P. Bernard, G. Bonfillou, G. Bochaton, A. Delattre, L. Herblin, J.P. Lamboy, D. Lavielle, H. Rieder, A. Tovar and A. Wiart of CERN, as well as M. Bonneton and D. Nuzzo of Air Liquide.
REFERENCES The LHC Study Group, The Large Hadron Collider, Conceptual Design, CERN Report AC/95-05(LHC) (1995). Benda, V., Duraffour, G., Guiard-Marigny, A., Lebrun, Ph., Momal, F., Saban, R., Sergo, V., Tavian, L. and Vullierme, B., Cryogenic Infrastructure for Superfluid Helium Testing of LHC Prototype Superconducting Magnets, paper presented at CEC, Albuquerque (1993). Benda, V., Sergo, V. and Vullierme, B., Electrical Heater for very-low pressure helium gas, Proc. Kryogenika 96, Prague (1996) Decker, L., L6hlein, K., Schustr, P., Vine, M., Brunovsk3~, I., Tu~ek, L., Lebrun, Ph. and Tavian, L., A Cryogenic Axial-Centrifugal Compressor For Superfluid Helium Refrigeration, paper presented at this conference. Dauvergne, J.P., Delikaris, D., Haug, F. and Knoops, S., A Helium Freeze-out Cleaner Operating at Atmospheric Pressure, paper presented at CEC, Colombus (1995).
Performance Analysis of Multistage 80K Centrifugal Compressors for Helium Refrigerator
Hiroshi Asakura,* Nobuyoshi Saji,* Yukio Kaneko,* Shoichiro Yoshinaga,* Mikio Mori,* Junichi Sato,* Akihiro Miyake,* Tsutomu Iwasaki,* Izumi Nishimura,* Takashi Hosoya,* and Tomohiro Umeda** *General Machinery Division, Ishikawajima-Harima Heavy Industries Co.,Ltd., 3-2-16,Toyosu, Kotoku, Tokyo, 135 Japan **Super-GM, 5-14-10, Nishitenma, Kita-ku, Osaka, 530 Japan
A completely oil-free centrifugal compressor system which has 4 stages for advanced helium refrigerator has been developed under the Japanese national project 'SuperGM.' A high performance of each stage compressor was confirmed by the aerodynamic performance test at 80K. The multistage performance test has been carried out for the purpose of studying the flow adjustment method to control the liquefaction rate. With the multistage performance data, the simulation analysis of refrigeration system has been done, and appropriate controllability of liquefaction rate by varying the 1st stage compressor speed has been confirmed.
INTRODUCTION An advanced type helium refrigeration system for a superconducting generator is now being developed in Japanese national project 'Super-GM.' The features of this refrigeration system are high reliability which is attained by adopting complete oil free cold compressors, and simple controllability of liquefaction rate by varying compressor speed. We have already developed single cold compressor unit which is the key component of this system, and confirmed that it can meet with each specification sufficiently both in mechanical and in aerodynamic performance. [ 1,2] In this paper, we will report the multistage characteristic attained by combined compressor performance test and simulation analysis of the refrigeration system when the compressor speed is varied.
ADVANCED TURBO TYPE REFRIGERATION SYSTEM General Features The flow sheet of the refrigeration system is shown in Figure 1. This system is so designed as to provide a liquid helium of 120 L/h with two expansion turbines and a J-T valve. Helium gas pressure is raised by 4 compressors from 0.1 MPa to 0.8 MPa. The gas from the high temperature expansion turbine returns to the inlet of the 2nd stage compressor. The purpose is to prevent efficiency drop caused by too small volumetric flow in the latter stage compressors. Since each compressor is independent, and its speed can be varied with the inverter, the liquefaction rate of the refrigeration system can be varied by changing compressor speed with constant J-T valve opening. Oil Free Centrifugal Cold Compressor Each stage compressor has a common structure that a vertical rotor with a impeller at bottom end is rotated 203
204
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings GN~
LN~
1.4 1.2 r
= .8MPa
O.1MP=B
l.o
[
I
4th stage 87440 rpm constant
I . . . . . .
- Ope_r" !ing qN. I pint
g i ~ i(~------.~
L
"d" 0.6
"~a,,..
\
9
,_
o.4
-"
t).2
80K [J~
~Centrifugal Compressor
I
J
.....
]
+High temper, Expans
31 .6K
ature ion turbin,e
i
i lg.3K
I
I 13.1K
,--',
~j
0.8
~'~
0.6
~
0.5
.
.
.
l~nt
N.
1~
o.s
"
~~
0.4 . . . . . . . .
\
~D
o.2
2nd ~a e 9137-0- 'm const'an-t
'
,--'-/-~ .~1 '
~.
"
,-,~.... ;,s. ~ ~mm
[.-., 0.1
I
I
.
stage 98670 rp . . . . . . t;nt ]
0.2
:::: r.~
Low temperature Expansion turbine
F.... 3rd
.
-
.
0.9
It,
40.6K
I
O.25
SuperconOuctlng Generator L
-
120
, ~ J-T valve
O
I st s :age
Ope:ating 0.2
.
%
LHe
Llhl
I
II\
J= 0.12MPB 4.4K
Figure 1 Advanced helium refrigeration system flow
100000 rpm
D 60000 rpm
oo
[
o
o 80000 rpm
point
.~,~
A 40000 rpm
0.15
0.1 2(1
40
60
go
100
120
140
160
Flow rate [g/s] Figure 2 Multistage characteristics of cold compressors
by an electric motor located in the center and all of them are hermetically sealed in one casing. Magnetic bearing which is employed as an oil free bearing contributes to reduce the vibration which may be caused by a distorted shaft at low temperature, thanks to its automatic balancing system. The electric motor can get a high power density of 25 kW at 100,000 rpm by adopting a claw-pole type synchronous motor excited externally.[ 1] The impeller is of a shroudless and high efficiency three dimensional blade, and is made from high strength aluminum alloy. The maximum peripheral speed reaches 560 m/s that contributes to increase pressure ratio. The aerodynamic performance of each stage compressor was tested in a closed loop of low temperature helium gas and was confirmed to exceed the specific point sufficiently.J2]
LIQUEFACTION RATE CONTROL BY VARYING COMPRESSOR SPEED Multistage Performance of The Compressors We carried out tests by combining each two of the four compressors to catch characteristics extending the whole flow range of the compressor system with intermediate flow between the 1st and the 2nd stage. Since the surging that is unstable phenomenon at the low-flow rate range of the turbocompressor depends on the characteristics of the circulating piping system, the consideration was paid so that the combined compressor test apparatus gave equivalent circulating volume to the actual refrigeration system. Though the speed of each stage can be changed independently, it is efficient to keep the pressure
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
205
ratio for the high temperature expansion turbine. Therefore, characteristics of the compressors were tested by varying the 1st stage compressor speed with the 2nd through the 4th stage compressor speed kept at each rated speed. Figure 2 shows the test results in the form of multistage characteristics of 4 stages. Figure 3 shows isothermal efficiency in the form of 4 stage compressor system.
~~
0.7
The st sta~e com[ ressor Ispeed 600C0 800,30 10C000 rpm
~
9~
0.6
~
0.5
41)000
~
!
o
0.4 0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
Flow rate [g/s] Figure 3 Isothermal efficiency of cold compressor
Refrigeration System Simulation We constructed a simulation program of the refrigeration system including the multistage characteristics of the compressor system to examine how liquefaction rate and compressor power consumption vary when the compressor speed varies. The characteristics of each stage compressor was described in non-dimensional function based on the test results. Opening of the J-T valve was kept constant. Figure 4 shows analyzing result with simulation, that is change of liquefaction rate and compressor power consumption per unit liquefaction rate which stands for the figure of merit in this system when the 1st stage compressor speed was changed. As shown in the figure, the liquefaction rate can be controlled over the range of 50 - 160 L/h only by changing the 1st stage compressor speed in the range of 40,000 - 100,000 rpm. And it is found that liquefaction rate can be varied in the range of 100 - 160 L/h with almost constant power per liquefaction rate. 0.70
.
.
.
.
.
0.60
.
~D .
.
.
.
.
0.50
.
.,=.~
04o
200
~D ~D
150
o
O
100 O
,r
~D
~
so
.1
o
/
3rd stage N = 9 8 6 7 0 rpm
|
/
[ _ _ 2rid s t a g e N = 9 1 3 7 0 rpm ......... ~ 1 ....... 5
6
7
8
9
O
10
The 1st stage compressor speed * 10000 [rpm] Figure 4 Simulation analysis of the advanced refrigeration system
206
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
When the system balances after compressor speed was changed, the operating point of each stage compressor is automatically fixed. The black points in Figure 2 and 3 show the operating points at each speed. As shown in Figures, it is confirmed that each operating point is in the stable range sufficiently apart from the surge line and that isothermal efficiency is almost at the peak point.
CONCLUSION We carried out performance tests by combining oil free cold compressors and clarified multistage compressor characteristics when the 1st stage compressor speed was varied. We made a simulation program of the refrigeration system including the compressor characteristics and analyzed variation of liquefaction rate and compressor power consumption when the speed was varied. As a result, it was found that liquefaction rate can be controlled over the range of 40 - 130 % of the rated liquefaction rate by varying the 1st stage compressor speed and that compressor power per liquefaction rate did not vary so much at that time. It was also confirmed that the operating point of each stage compressor is in the stable range sufficiently apart from the surge line.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT This research has been carried out as a part of R&D on superconducting technology for electric power apparatus under the New Sunshine Project of AIST, MITI, being consigned by NEDO.
REFERENCES 1 2
Asakura,H. et al. 80K centrifugal compressor for helium refrigeration system, In: Advances in Cryogenic Engineering 37B, Plenum Press, New York (1992) 787-794 Asakura,H. et al. Performance test results of 80K centrifugal compressor for helium refrigerator, In : Advances in Cryogenic Engineering 39A, Plenum Press, New York (1994) 893-900
Design, Manufacture and Consideration for Test Result of Centrifugal Cold Compressor for TEVATRON Lower Temperature Upgrade
Nobuyoshi Saji, Yukio Kaneko, Hiroshi Asakura Development Department,General Machinery Division,Ishikawajima-Harima Industries Co.Ltd.,2-16 Toyosu 3-chome, Koto-ku, Tokyo 135 Japan
Ten years have passed since Tevatron first operation. In 1994, Fermilab completed to grade up the refrigeration system including capable of lowering two-phase temperature down to 3.5K with the satellite refrigerators equipped with cold compressors. Since we supplied cold helium compressors, we will report the process of upgrade, structure of the cold compressor and operating situation up to date.
INTRODUCTION In April 1994, Fermilab announced that it discovered top Quark. Also it was announced in February 1996 that the Japan, U.S. and Europe research team acquired the data that smaller particles constituting Quark possibly exist. In Tevatron, about 800 superconducting magnets were arranged and forcedly cooled by supercritical helium (SHE) in the underground tunnel of 6km circumference. The refrigeration system for Tevatron used since 1984 is composed of 4000 L/h central helium liquifire and 24 satellites refrigerator. A satellite refrigerator cools each left and right 125m strings of superconducting magnets. JT valve located at the remotest place from the cold compressor as shown in Fig. 1. If the cold compressors should not be operated, the temperature of helium would be 4.54K at the two-phase dewar and approx. 4.9K at 125m upstream point of the JT valve outlet, showing approx. 400 mK higher temperature because of pressure loss of two-phase helium. Limited acceleration energy for the dipole magnet to quench at this temperature is 900
I SATELLITE REFRIGERATOR} COLD BOX
~
-'
EXPANDER
WET
PHASE SEPARATOR
1'2. ~6atm]
ABOVE GROUND TUNNEL
SUB COOLERS l_
I-
MAGNET
STRING
+ 10ink
125m
MAGNET STRING
Fig 1 Satellite Retrigerator with Cold Compressor
_1
-I
+400ink
Fig 2 Appearance of Tevatron Cold Compressor 207
208
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings
Gev. The energy can be raised up to 1050 Gev when liquid helium is depressurized by the cold compressor and helium temperature is lowered down to 3.56K at the entrance of the compressor. [1 ] However, when cold compressors are installed, the driving power plus heat leak through the shaft and casing become thermal load to the refrigerator. Therefore, refrigeration capacity was increased to meet with the power of 24 compressors.
COLD COMPRESSOR The apparatus to depressurize liquid helium by directly inhaling evaporated gas and lower its temperature is the cold compressor. Its appearance is shown in Fig.2. The specification of the cold helium compressors installed in Fermilab is shown in Table 1. The crossection of the machine is shown in Fig. 3. The shaft is supported by the dynamic gas bearings in the complete oilfree structure. The motor is air-cooled by a fan to eliminate possible trouble in the cooling water system and to get better maintenance. The cold section is in the vacuum chamber and both the inlet and outlet pipes are so made to be vacuum multi-layer insulation. The very small impeller made with aluminum alloy precision casting was proved, by Fermirab who operated a prototype delivered in 1990, to attain a high performance in the wide flow range. [2] The impeller inhaling cold helium and the motor driven at room temperature are placed in the distance and the shaft was of a hollowed shape for Insulation. The periphery of the aluminum die casting endrings placed at the both ends of the motor rotor was enforced by titanic alloy to produce a high speed motor with the maximum rotating speed of 95,000 rpm. A thin cylinder was used to connect between the compressor casing and drive section casing. Heat capacity coming into the compressing section from the driving unit throughthe shaft and casing is 30 W. However, its influence to efficiency remained approx. 3 %. Dynamic Gas Bearing The journal bearing is a foil type dynamic gas bearing of a simple structure made by triple-coiled 0.04 mm thick stainless sheets and the thrust bearing is a spiral groove type. The section which contacts the shaft at start and stop is coated with Teflon. Satellite refrigerator often inhales liquid helium along with evaporated gas into the cold compressor. Since this happening is difficult to prevent, Fermilab made the several times test to have liquid helium inhaled into the fast revolving impeller which used prototype cold compressor. The compressor stopped without noise and could be started again immediately after reset the invertor. Coo
Table 1 Specification of Tevatron cold compressor Inlet pressure Inlet temperature Outlet pressure Mass flow rate Rotating speed Operation range Motor power Impeller diameter Type of Bearing
I. I n 9
F~3n
--
- .....
'. . . . .
1
0.5 atm (min. 0.4 atm) 3.56 K (min. 3.38 K) 1.4 atm 60 g/s (range 40 to 70 g/s) 80000 rpm (max. 95000 rpm) 20000 to 95000 rpm 1.4 kW (maximum) 33 mm Dynamic gas bearing
,l"
/
'
"lll IF
1111
!iI ' :JI!ILllr _ " 11 Ir
Fig 3. Crossetion of Tevatron Cold helium Compressor
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
209
Cryostat The cryostat is designed with the utmost attention to compactness. The inlet and outlet pipes are double pipes each with an external diameter of 35mm. The compressor is connected with bayonet joints to the valve box rising, on a 220 mm-diameter pipe, from the strings of superconducting magnets located in the 6.5 m underground. The valve box is of a stainless make with a diameter of 800 mm and a height of 1,500 mm equipped with a heat exchanger with a capacity of 130 litters liquid helium and ten or more valves or ports. Since these equipment is arranged on the 6 m pipe, the structure is unstable. Influence of vibration of the valve box to the cold compressor was anticipated from the planning. The root of the valve box is secured with three turnbuckles, but vibration far larger than the permissible value of l~tm prescribed by us was felt by hand. OPERATION The 27 cold compressors delivered in autumn 1992 were operated in December 1993, built in the whole 24 satellite refrigerators of Tevatron. Several problems occurred with operations made before and after the incorporation. At the first operation the rotor was forced to stop one day after the start, caused by impure gas from the motor. [4] Fermilab baked the motor section at 330 K for 24 hours before operation. However, the problem should have been solved by baking at 100 ~ for approx. 100 hours. The electric insulation of the motor can resist up to 125 ~ The rotating speed of the cold compressor is controlled by the computer which keeps pressure at the compressor inlet or two-phase helium dewar at constant. When the set of the temperature of two-phase helium in the magnets is changed from low to high temperature, helium in the magnets temporarily subcooling and has come not to evaporate. The level of liquid helium in the dewar rises, liquid helium overflows and the cold compressor trips by inhaling its. As countermeasures, enlarging the capacity of the two-phase dewar or changing temperature slowly are considered. However, Fermilab took the method to install a heater in the two-phase dewar. Trips of the Cold Compressor at the Times of Quench of the Magnets As an incident of magnet quench, the outlets of the cold compressors are connected by the common pipe and the motor tripped at the opposite place of Tevatron ring approx. 3km apart from the magnet which caused quench. In the compressor operated at 42,000 rpm, outlet pressure first increased and inlet pressure also increased 4 seconds later. Further 5 seconds later compressor rotating speed began to rise, reaching 80,000 rpm in 15 seconds. Further 15 seconds later, the motor stalled and tripped. In this instance, the flow rate of evaporated gas from the two-phase dewar decreased when inlet pressure began to increase and the compressor entered low-flow rate operation. Since the compressor was in slow speed operation, apparent surge phenomenon did not occur. However, since rotating speed was sharply increased, the compressor entered a strong surge, inhaled liquid helium and tripped. After the trip, rpm did not change because frequency generated by the invertor was plotted. The rotor remained at stop. began to lower, the computer gave a direction to lower speed to 80,000 rpm. Since rotating speed was reduced in haste, inlet pressure (dewar pressure) increased suddenly, evaporation volume decreased and the compressor entered surge. Each of the above cases was solved by making the control inch by inch and slowly and effect the heater in the two-phase dewar. However, it is difficult to explain why the motor tripped frequentry at the opposite point of the ring 3 km apart from the quenched magnet. Lately Operation After the cold compressor was operated for 28,626 hours by August 1994, the journal bearings were changed to bearings possible for low-speed operation at standby time to reduce refrigerator load and the minimum speed was changed from 40,000 rpm to 20,000 rpm. The used bearings were in good conditions. After that, the compressor was operated for 93,000 hours by April 1995. [5] During the time after the minimum speed was lowered to 20,000 rpm, bearing failure occurred three times. The possible cause is that by reducing rotating speed, load capacity of the dynamic pressure gas bearings decreased and the shaft and bearings slightly contacted when the valve box vibrated. Some countermeasure to stop vibration is required. How-
210
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings
ever, after the minimum speed was raised to 30,000 rpm temporarily, no failure has been reported yet so far. According to Felmilab's report in April 1996, total operating time of 24 satellites was 130,249 hours and average operating time of one satellite was 5,427 hours. Efficiency of the Cold Compressor The adiabatic efficiency measured during the operation in autumn 1993 was a very low value of 40- 50 %. The designed efficiency of 70 % at the design point and 60 % or more at the working area had been cleared with allowance even with the prototype operation. [2] The difference between the prototype and 27 compressors lies in adoption of aircooling for the latter motors and inlet and outlet pipes for the cold compressors. One of the causes is that Fermilab inserted a suction filter in the inlet pipe to prevent recurrence of the accident that cuttings were inhaled during prototype operation. The adiabatic efficiency increased by 10 15 % by removing the filter. [3] Table 2 shows the difference of pipe bore between the prototype and 27 compressors concerning the inlet and outlet pipes. The reason of the change was based on Fermilab's request for downsizing with light weight of the cryostat including bending sections. According to calculation, pressure loss at the pipe sections reaches 13 % of the compressor head at the maximum flow rate. If the pipe size is made similar to that of the prototype, efficiency will be increased by 10 %. Table 2 Comparision of inlet and outlet pipe bore between prototype and 27 machines Inlet pipe
Outlet pipe
Prototype
mm
30.7
23.9
27 machines
mm
20.45
17.5
2.25
1.87
Ratio of velocity (1.0 for prototype)
CONCLUSION The cold compressors for Tevatron have been confirmed their reliability for a long operation and become practical machines that can be operated in great numbers at the same time. However, the cryostat vibration must be solved.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT We express our thankfulness to the fact that Fermilab decided to choose cold compressors for Tevatron satellite refrigerators and persistently continued operations despite several troubles. Also we appreciate their kindness to provide some data for this paper.
REFERENCES 1 2 3 4 5
Fuerst, J. In:Advances in Cryogenic Engineering Vol.35 Plenum Press, New York (1990)1023-1030 Fuerst, J. In:Advances in Cryogenic Engineering Vol.39 Plenum Press, New York (1994)863-870 Theilacker, J., Tevatron Cold Compressor Operating Experience Criogenics (1994) 34 ICEC supplement 107-110 Norris, B. L.,Status Report on the Tevatron Lower Temperature Upgrade Criogenics (1994) 34 ICEC supplement 73-76 Norris, B. L., Initial Performance of Upgraded Tevatron Cryogenic Systems (WE-BE-6)
Development of Helium Oil Free Screw Compressor
K. Kitagawa, Y. Hirao, Y. Yanagi and Y. Ikeda* Mayekawa Mfg. Co. Ltd., Aza-Okubo, Moriya-Machi, Kita-Sooma-gun, Ibaraki 302-01, Japan *Super-GM,5-14-10, Nishitenma, Kita-ku, Osaka 530, Japan
It is well known that impurities originated in oil lubricants of helium compressors markedly affect on the reliability of refrigeration system. Hence Mycom has been concentrated on development of an oil free screw compressor since FY 1987. This paper will represent performance data of the oil free screw compressor which was comprised of non contact tapered rotors, taking into thermal deformation applying for high rotational beatings and seal systems based on R&D of an elementaw technology. In addition we demonstrate that it can be attained an isothermal efficiency of 50 % under a throughput of 125 g / s , an outlet pressure of 0.8 MPa and an inlet pressure of 0.1 MPa and a suction temperature of 250 K.
INTRODUCTION Super-GM ( Engineering Association for superconducting Generation Equipment and Materials ) was established in September, 1987 to develop technology for superconducting generation equipment and materials as a national project. Since then we have been developing two types of high reliable refrigeration system lbr SCG ; one is a conventional refrigeration system for a 70 MW class SCG using oil injected screw compressors, and the other is an advanced refrigeration system for a 200 MW pilot machine using oil free compressors which perfectly prevents from the troubles due to impurities. MYCOM has much concentrated to develop an oil free screw compressor which compresses helium gas over retaining a clearance inbetween screw rotors under a high rotational speed. So that the main subjects are to develop technology, for non contact tapered rotors taking into a thermal deformation, beating and seal systems for a high speed rotation as 25,000 rpm.. This paper represents a planning of test machine using air, pertbnnance testing and operational control. Furthermore, based on the results of test machine we discussed planning of a trial helium compressor. DEVELOPMENT OF ELEMETAL TECHNIQUE A test stand using air was planned to obtain the per~brmance of main components as beatings, seals and rotors under the high rotational speed. Figure 1 shows the cut out view of the test stand, where timing gears was equipped at the end of the shaft to maintain a non contact condition, with ball and roller bearings suitable for a high speed operation, and two staged seals composed of an oil and a gas seals were provided to prevent lubricant oil of the beating from penetrating into the rotors. In addition tapered rotors were applied to ease the thermal deformation due to a temperature difference between inlet and outlet temperatures. The test rotor diameter was 102 mm. .High Speed Bearings For the oil screw compressor ball and roller beatings with a very high accuracy of positioning were chosen in order to maintain an infinitesimal rotor-lobe clearance in operation. A cylindrical roller beatings were applied for radial beatings and 4 point contact ball beatings for thrust beating. Especially for the thrust beatings a wpe of low pre-load was employed to keep an adequate contact angle under a high speed operation. The roller bearing has a high accuracy of positioning while it has not enough damping capacity of 211
212
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
vibration to sustain a rigidity, so that it must be operated in the region far from the shaft critical speed. Its performance testing resulted in less than 5 u m of shaft vibration up to a 25,000 rpm and a stable operation and the thrust beating for M rotor was very stable until a maximum speed, whereas that of F rotor could be operated stably by setting a rather high pre-load. Gas seal 0il seal / /~ Radial b e a r i n g T h r u s t bearingi-(pTe -- load) \, , , Speed up R e a r \ [-~ ~ / Drive -shiaf--L-t\, ~ - ~ ~--~~3
Suction
e_n_nd cover_/ / Female rotor
Male r o t o r i 3a8 seal / Oil seal / Radial b e a r i n g / / Thrust bearinR / / //1 Timing gear 1
/
g ~ O i l seal r e t a i n e r / D i s c h a r g e en d c o v e r Eddy p r o v e
Figure 1 Cut out view of the test oil free screw compressor Gas Seal For the gas seal we tested a labyrinth, a honeycomb and an aerodynamic pressure seals as a non contact seal. An aerodynamic pressure seal was chosen to prevent the gas leakage into the rotor casing from the intermediate chamber, since it gave us a lower temperature of the intermediate chamber than that in using a honeycomb seal. Figure 2 shows a photo of the used aerodynamic seal. Oil seal For the oil seal a magnetic fluid seal of contact type was applied in order to seal tight which is useful for vacuum and high speed. The temperature of magnetic fluid seal in the seal region was found to greatly affect the seal pressure toughness. Hence the cooling method was improved by modifying a fin on the cooling side. It was confirmed that its seal toughness was 0.05 MPa under the conditions of a speed of 25,000 rpm and a compression ratio of 3.0. Figure 3 shows a photo of the used magnetic fluid seal.
::.:.::::::::~.!..:=": : :a'+
!+7:i!;i+i+!++i~" i+i :i!~i:+il~i+!~~i7i+++:
~....." "~;~:'~;i~ '<
++i~+~~:i:,:. .+:<+~:+~::.
<..o ..
~,......
Ii i ~ '~ T i~ , i i : +k% ; : ~, ~}i<.7;t~.+"i~[
...i>~2!~:?:::i+~:, i i:i! ".;,,;:j~;~:iS
:C7:77L;:.J~Q!i"4,.:.L.+,"~7~ .Figure 2 Aerodynamic seal for gas
Figure 3 Magnetic fluid seal for oil
Countermeasured Rotor The delivery temperature of the oil flee screw compressors becomes higher than that of the suction side due to an adiabatic compression. To maintain an adequate clearance between rotors, in case of using a conventional parallel rotor the rotor-lobe clearance of suction side becomes larger than that of delivery due to a thermal deformation. This induces markedly a degradation of volumetric efficiency. Hence a tapered rotor based on a thermal deformation analysis by FEM was planned so as to be homogeneous clearance at the both sides. Figure 4 shows a general view of the tapered rotor. It was found that it can be obtained a volumetric efficiency rj ,. of 0.75 under the condition of a rotational speed N of 25,000 rpm and a compression ratio Pr of 4 and that an available range for its control range can be changed a 75 to 100 %of load rate by changing a rotational speed of 25,000 to 20,500 rpm allowing a 100(3 increase of delivery temperature.
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings
213
Sue[ion Discharge ConvenLional rotor- ~
)--
~--~) ~ - Gr O O
Taperedrotor k_-------"
[
9 C.)
~3 0)
in assembly
r.)
in operation
Figure 4 General view of the taperedrotor
Operation Test An overall running test was conducted regarding to compressor elements during the different operation modes as start-up, setting of running condition, volumetric control and shut- down. During the series of operation from start-up to shut-down, the temperature change of bearing, magnetic fluid seal and gas seal was measured. An outlet test temperature at the steady state operation was taken as 468K in consideration of estimated performance for a trial helium machine, while the volumetric control operation the outlet temperature at the rotation of 20,500rpm was set by 10~ higher than that of steady state. Figure 5 demonstrates a behavior of overall running test operation. The test results showed that influences of outlet temperature change on that of beating and magnetic fluid seal were small and that the temperatures were well followed up to the change of rotation. Notice that the temperature of gas seal was well followed up to the change of outlet temperature. It was confirmed from the test results that the compressor elements as bearing, magnetic fluid seal and gas seal was well followed up to the different conditions of the series of operation. 250
200
.
Di:
.
charge
Te~"~Ltu-~ur"~
30000
,oo,
20000
i
z
tO000 ~ c~
0
/
L
St
} C stant Pressure Set Up
t Up
Co
..
,
0 00
ant +oi DoWn
Figure 5 Behavior of overall running test operation DESIGNED OF TRIAL HE OIL FREE SCREW COMPRESSOR Based on the study of the test stand using air, a trial helium oil screw compressor was planned to apply an advanced refrigeration system for a 200 MW pilot superconducting generator. Figure 6 illustrates an cut out view of designed compressor. The proposed compressor is specified as a two staged compressor, possessing a mass flow rate G of 125 g / s with a I st stage rotor diameter D~ of 204 mm and a 2rid stage diameter D 2 o f 127 mm. It will be operated under the condition of a suction pressure Ps of 0.1 MPa, a suction temperature Ts of 250 K, a discharge pressure Pd of 0.8 MPa and a discharge temperature Td of 468 K, respectively. Its
214
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
throughput to a cold box are regulated by changing a revolution of each stage at the same ratio over keeping a constant pressure. The nominal operating condition is a compression ratio Pr of 2.9 for both stages, a 1st stage revolution N~ of 11,000 rpm and a 2nd stage revolution N2 of 19,000 rpm with an isothermal efficiency E0 of 0.49.
Thurust
Side bearing casinng . . . . . . . . -lr ro{-or \ Ga--s-seal ~\ \ Magnetic fluid- s e a l ~ \ \\ \ Radial bearin_n_g \ \ \ \ bearing~rel-o-a-d-)-\ \ \ \ \ . \ \ \,\ \
,, ,,, \ \,
,, ,
Rotor \_. . . . '\ -"\ \ \,
casing_ l~a-m-- bearingLg casing \ Gas se seal "~ [---bta---~ Ma-~-n-e.tic fluid seal \ / / 1: a_l bea riLn_g_ Radi \ / / /T h u r u s t bearing '\ , i / / /r---~ T]haing gear
? m ,1 3
1
Oil seal r e t a i n e r / / Suction cover/
Oil eemale rotor
seal
J
3
retainer
Figure 6 Cut out view of the designed helium oil free screw compressor CONCLUSION The performance testing of the oil tree screw compressor which was comprised of non contact taper rotors, high rotational bearing and seal systems was successfully carried out to obtain its behaviors under the high rotation speed of 25,000 rpm. Furthermore, based on the results of the test stand a trial helium oil screw compressor was planned with an isothermal efficiency E,, of 0.49. ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work has been pertbrmed as a part of " R&D on Superconducting Technology for Electric Power Apparatus " under the New Sunshine Program of Agency of Industrial Science and Technology, MITI, being consigned by NEDO. REFERENCES
Arai, K. and et al., R&D of high reliability refrigeration system tbr superconducting generators ,Advances in Cryogenic. Engineering, Vol. 39 (1994 ) 581 Hosoya, T., Yanagi, H. and el al., R&D of high reliable refrigeration system for superconducting generators, Proc. of C E C / ' I C M C ' 95 conference, Columbus, Ohio, USA (1995)
Large scale refrigeration
Turboexpanders
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Experimental Study of Self-Acting Gas-Lubricated Tilting-Pad Thrust Beatings for Cryogenic Turboexpander
Chunzheng Chen,*
Hai Yao* and
Yinong Wu**
*Institute of Cryogenic Engineering, Xi' an Jiaotong University, Xi'an 710049, China **Institute of Technical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Shanghai 200083, China
The experimental study of static and dynamic performance of self-acting gaslubricated tilting-pad thrust beatings has been described in this paper. The effects of beating structural parameters on the bearing performance have been studied in detail. As a result, the optimum ranges of these parameters have been obtained. Also, the effects of the beating surface condition on the beating performance were considered. A new surface coating has been developed. The maximum rotor-speed 200,000 rpm of the experimental turboexpander with tilting-pad thrust gas beatings on the test rig was obtained. The experimental results proved that the self-acting gas-lubricated tilting-pad thrust bearing is a good option for small high speed cryogenic turboexpander.
INTRODUCTION The stable operation of the cryogenic turboexpander which is currently used as the main equipment for providing refiigeration and obtaining cryogenic temperatures in cryogenic installation is very important to the long-life operation and economy of cryogenic installation. In recent years, externally pressurized (EP) gas beating cryogenic turboexpander has been widely used in small air separation plant in China. Along with the developing of cryogenic technique, it is necessary to develop self-acting (SA) gas bearings for cryogenic turboexpander. We have studied the various types of SA gas beatings and have made some progress[I-4]. Now, the experimental results of SA tilting-pad thrust gas bearing are presented in this paper. The effects of bearing structural parameters, including circular pivot position, radial pivot position and height of curved surface of the tilting-pad, on the bearing performance have been studied in detail. Furthermore, some surface coatings have been developed, and one of them has excellent performance. These experimental results provided valuable data and experiences for developing small cryogenic turboexpander products with SA gas bearings in the future. EXPER/MENTAL APPARATUS The experimental high-speed miniature turboexpander on which the test of any types of SA thrust gas bearings can be done is designed and shown in figure 1. Two EP journal gas beatings are adopted in the turboexpander. The diameter of shaft is 16mm and the weight of rotor is 149g. The experimental turboexpander is operated by the turbine wheel when the expansion gas is supplied. Rotational speed was measured by a fiber optic probe. A digital frequency counter measured the output of the probe speed pickup. Axial motion was measured using eddy-type displacement probes. The test pads of tilting-pad thrust gas beating are shown in figure 2. The outer radius of the test pads is r2= 17mm~ and the inner radius is rl=7.5mm. A point pivot structure was adopted in the test bearings. The maximum speed 200,000rpm of turboexpander on the test rig has been obtained. 217
218
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
Figure 1 Experimental expansion turbine
Figure 2 Test pads of tilting-pad thrust gas bearings
EXPEKIMENTAL KESULTS AND ANALYSIS Load Capacity Performance The load capacity tested is different from the results calculated by flat pad theory[5] as shown in figure 3. It is found that the test pads are not fiat and there is crown height from 3/,on to 5 bun by measurement. Figure 3 shows that the sudden loss of load capacity at high compressibility number A may be prevented for the convex pad bearing. It is an ideal characteristic for high speed turboexpander. In fact, the pad used in practice is not fiat one because of the tolerance of manufacture. Therefore, it is necessary to study the performance of convex pad bearing.
o.4 t i
ee/~:0.65
3
/.* 9
~- @. 3 -,_,
--]heory 4 - E_• i ment
/
/
,"
/-
i
,//~
0.4
z-al
0
.....
i/"
0.3 r-o
O
/ /
/
._.0. .....
~.
//
O. 0,_
9
i
./
0.2
t.D
0
/
0"
/ 9,---~
+
"~
f-[1J
/"
./
0.1
A:50
80 ]30
--.-
-,,-
Ii-3--Sum .........
0.0
28.(1
40.0
60.0
Eampressibility
80.0
number
100.0
A
120.0
0.5
I .........
0.%
I
l
0.6
0.65
t
I
I
0.7
I
I
. . . . .
I
9.75
0
F i N e 3 Difference of load capacity between tested and calculated data
Figure 4 Influence of circumferential pivot position 00/fl on load capacity W
Figure 4 shows the influence of the circumferential pivot position
0o/fl on
the dimensionless load
capacity W. It may be shown from figure 4 that the range of 00/fl for maximum load capacity is from 0.63 to 0.65. Figure 5 shows that the optimum radial pivot position ro/r2 is 0.71 - 0.74. The influence of the crown height 6 on the load capacity W is shown in figure 6. It is clear that the bearing has maximum load capacity for the crown height t~om 4 ;an to 7 ;~m at the optimum pivot position. The film thickness at pivot position
hp is less than 5/an.
The optimum ratio 6 / hp is 0.8 - 1.4.
I C E C 1 6 / I C M C Proceedings 9,49
219
8,4
8~
+
0//~=8o53 0
--~ A=29 -,50
0o//3-8,53
A=58
+
88
--~
199
83
8,38
I
8 , 2 5
8~
81
f j ~ J
8o15 8o18 8o66 .
.
.
.
I
. . . .
8, 68
I
.
.
.
.
1
8o 78
. . . .
8, 72 r /r 0
I
. . . .
I
8,74
,
,
O
(3~76
8
18
5
15
28
6(~m)
2
Figure 5 Influence of radial pivot position ro/rz
Figure 6 Influence of crown height 6 on load capacity
on load capacity W
Pad Surface Coating Test The geometrical parameters of the test bearings are fl=51 ~
00/]3=0.63, r1/r2=0.44,
r0/r2=0.72. The
surface of the test pad is covered with a layer by spraying or chemical treatment. The effects of two methods on the bearing performance are studied by limit load test, robbing test and start-stop test. The results of the limit load test and rubbing test are shown in table 1, and the relationship between the turbine inlet pressure PT and the times of start-stop cycles is shown in figure 7. From the test results, it can be seen that the performance of treated bearings is much better than the performance of untreated bearings. Especially, the new chemical treatment coating (N~+PTFE) has excellent performance and is very suitable for the turboexpander. Table 1 Test results of limit load test and rubbin~ test Treat Method Spray grapithe Spray PTFE
......................
..............................................................................................
Chemical Treatment
..........................................................................................................................................................................................
Untreated
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Limit load (kg)
3.8
4.5
No_ o f rub.b.ing" test
4
3
_
_
3.9
2.6
8
1
...--.... L
_.IE3
18o9 Load W= 538q
L
t_f-I CLJ L
n
._~_~,,,-_,,a~ ~
5~
r
L
b--
--
m
~
~ . , ~
Q
/
__ -
c-
_8
....4~,- - ' ~
8~
, Spray grapithe ~Chemo Ni+PTFE - - ~ Unt r eat~ed .
.
.
.
I
5
,
,
,
[
18
.
.
.
.
i
.
15
.
.
.
1
.
.
.
.
28
Times Figure 7 Relationship between times of start-stop test and turbine inlet pressure
I
25
,
38
220
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
CONCLUSION (1) An experimental high-speed miniature turboexpander on which the test of any types of SA thrust gas bearing can be done is designed and manufactured. The maximum rotor speed is up to 200,000rpm. (2) For convex tilting-pad bearing at high A, the performance is better than that of flat tilting-pad bearing. (3) As to convex pad bearing, the ranges of geometrical parameters of optimum load capacity are 0o/fl=0.63 "-- 0.65, r0/r2=0.71 -" 0.74, 8 / hp =0.8 -- 1.4. (4) A new chemical treatment coating (Ni+PTFE) has excellent performance. REFERENCES Zhou, G.L., The study of the stability of herringbone gas bearing, Dissertation for Master Degree(DMD), Xi'an Jia0tong Univ.,(1988) Xu,W.X., The research of the static and dynamic performance of spiral-grooved thrust gas bearhlg, DMD, Xi'an Jiaotong Univ.,(1989) Dong,Z.H., The research of three tilting-pad journal gas beating for expansion turbine, D.MD, Xi' an Jiaotong Univ.,( 1991 ) Wu,Y.N.,The research of self-acting tilting-pad thrust gas bearing for expansion turbine, DMD, Xi'an Jiaotong Univ.,(1993) Yao,H., Study and development of new type foil bearings for cryogenic turbo-machinery, Dissertation for Doctor Degree, Xi'an Jiaotong Univ.,(1996) Shapiro,W., Analysis and Performance of the gas-lubricated tilting-pad thrust bearing, Trans. ASME(1969)12
A Genetic Algorithm Based Optimization Design Method for Cryogenic Turboexpander
Chunhua Gao,*
Hai Yao**
and
Chunzheng Chen**
* Institute of Systems Engineering, Xi'an Jiaotong University, Xi'an 710049, China ** Institute of Cryogenic Engineering, Xi'an Jiaotong University, Xi'an 710049, China
To increase the efficiency of cryogenic turboexpander, it is very important to appropriately choose the design variables. This paper provides a new type of optimization design method based on the genetic algorithms (GAs) and shows the use of GA to optimize the design variables of turboexpander. Compared with ordinary optimization methods, GAs are computationally simple, powerful and not limited by restrictive assumptions about the parameter space. Examples are presented for optimizing the design variables of small flow rate turboexpander used for reverse Brayton cycle refrigerator. The results show the validity and robustness of this optimization method.
INTRODUCTION In order to increase the efficiency of cryogenic turboexpander, it is very important to appropriately choose the main parameters that have significant effects on performance during the design process. In the radialaxial flow turboexpander, these main parameters in one-dimension flow design are reaction p (the ratio of enthalpy decrease in nozzle to total enthalpy decrease in turbine), diameter ratio/~ (the ratio of rotor tip diameter to average diameter at rotor outlet) and velocity ratio ~1 (the ratio of rotor tip velocity to isentropic spouting velocity). Due to the existence of turbine design requirements and aerodynamic or structural constraints, to explicitly build the mathematic model between the isentropic efficiency and the above design parameters is not an easy task. In the past, the maximum flow efficiency design method which based on a simplified model use traditional optimization method to choose the design variables. The results are perfect in theory, but can cause illegal phenomenon such as slowdown motion of gas flow in the wheel. So, this kind of method is not practical in real engineering design case. This paper provides a new type of optimization design method which is based on the genetic algorithms (GAs). Compared with the ordinary optimization method, GAs are computationally simple and powerful. GA requires from the environment only an objective function explicitly or implicitly, and no other information nor assumptions such as derivatives and ditferentiability. Furthermore, it is convenient to add experts' experiences into the algorithm to increase the search efficiency. Because the design requirements and constraints are comprehensively considered during the GA optimization process, the results can be used directly in practice. In fact, based on GA we have developed an easy CAD tool for optimization design of turboexpander. GENETIC ALGORITHMS 221
222
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
GAs are search and optimization technique based on natural evolution[I]. They are robust, not problem specific and particularly suited to optimizing multi-parameter problems. GAs represent a parameter set as a continuous binary string, similar to chromosomes in nature, formed by joining together the individual parameters in binary form. Several of these binary parameter strings, known as individuals, make up a generation. The performance of each individual is evaluated and new, or child, individuals created by combining pairs of the current individuals. The probability of an individual being used as a parent is based on its performance rating. Fit individuals are likely to be selected more than once as parents, while poor, or unfit, individuals might not be selected at all. The individuals selected as parents are randomly paired and two children produced using the genetic operators of crossover and mutation. Crossover causes the child binary strings to be made up of binary sequences from both parents. The position for crossover is chosen randomly for each pair of parents. Figure 1 gives an example in which crossover is to occur after the nhlth bit. parent~ =
100011010
parent 2 = O11010
Figure 1
^ 11100
crossover
0 01 ^00111~
>~ c h i l d ~ =
100011010^00111
[child 2 = O11010001
^ 11100
Scheme of standard crossover operator
Crossover occurs with a probability Pc (typically, Pc e [0.6,0.8]). The mutation operator swaps the value of a bit (its value is changed from 0 to 1, or vice versa) with a probability Pm (typically, Pm C[0.001,0.01]). Usually, mutation has a negative effect on an individual, but occasionally it can change a poorly performing individual into a fit individual. Once the new generation of individuals is complete, the fitness of each individual is evaluated and a new generation formed, again based on the fitness of the parent individuals of the current generation. Usually, the algorithms terminated after a predetermined number of generations. OPTIMIZING THE DESIGN VARIABLES BY GA In our discussion, the objective function is chosen to maximize the isentropic efficiency of turboexpander subject to a set of constraints. It can be expressed as max r/s (p, ~t ) s.t. a set of constraints
(1)
where the optimization variablesare reaction p and diameter ratio/z. In 900 inward flow radial turbine the following relationship exists between the velocity ratio h-1and reaction p u-~ = ~/(1- p)~o: cos 2 a ,
(2)
where ~p represents nozzle velocity coefficient and ct I represents flow angle at nozzle outlet. At the same time, the constraints considered in (1) are totally 6 items: 9 difference between flow angle a 1 and vanes angle at nozzle outlet a~ less than 3 ~ 9 9
absolute Mach number at nozzle outlet less than 1.2. difference between flow angle at rotor inlet fll and blade angle at rotor inlet fl~ less than 3 ~
9 9
relative Mach number at rotor inlet less than 0.5. relative velocity at rotor outlet WE greater than relative velocity at rotor inlet Wl.
ICEC 16/ICMC Proceedings
223
l
flow angle at rotor outlet ranging in 800 - 100 ~ The working procedure of GA to optimize the design variablesp and/~ is shown as figure 1. During the process, the isentropic efficiency r/s is calculated by one-dimension flow method[2]. In the cases that calculations from the chosen individual of /9 and/~ do not satisfy the above constraints, we simply let qs be a small value, such as r/s =0.1%, then the corresponding individual in GA will have a low probability to reproduce. <
/
/
-...
.
begin .
...... ~:~r
.
z-
input parameters of GA and the given optimization problem
/
/
generate the 1st generation of chromosome strings ..................
~ .......
.................. ex-ceed maximoi~ ..................... <:::i~ii 9 ............ .......... generation?
...... ~ 7 _ : : >
i calculate isentropic efficiency of each I
individual as fitness value
generate the new generation: select the individuals having high J fitness to reproduce crossover operation
mutation operation I
i
/
f
output optimum results
end
..... .,
Figure 1
Flow chartof G A o p t ~ g
I
/
/
/
">
z
procedure
CALCULATION EXAMPLE We use GA to optimize the design variables of small flow rate turboexpander for reverse Brayton cycle refrigerator as an example. The known parameters of the small turbine are given in table 1 and the setting values of GA are shown in table 2. Table 1 Parameters o_f_t_he_exa_mp!e_turbm__e_. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Working Inlet Inlet Outlet Flow rate Vane angle Blade angle Blade angle substance pressure temperature pressure at nozzle at rotor inlet at rotor outlet outlet air 0.4 253 0.11 14.365 16 ~ 90 ~ 30 ~ ................................ ~ . a .........................K .........................~ a
.........................g__/__S...................................................................................................... _
T_ab!e2.......sett_m__gvalues of GA Length of chromosome Individual number in ~eneration 30 50
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
- . - _._ - - - - , . . - . - . - . - .
Probability of crossover
Probability of mutation
0.8
0.008
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
224
ICEC16/ICMC Proceedings
According to the given data, the characteristic curved surface of the optimization problem is shown in figure 2. When GA is applied to this problem, the search efficiency of GA is very high. In the 50 individuals of the first generation, there are 47 individuals not satisfying the constraints, while after one time of evolution individuals not satisfying the constraints reduce to 8. After the evolution of 15 generations, the optimum results are obtained and given in table 3. From comparison between figure 2 and table 3, it is evident that the optimum design variables p andp by GA based optimization method are truly the optimum solution of the given turbine optimization problem. At the same time, the 6 constraints are all satisfied.
ii
0.9
0.~3 ................... ................... _ -
.......... i ~ - - ~ .......... 0.7 "-- ..... 0.6
._.__ "---~.._
-............ 0. 4
.
"~~,
Table_.3......_~t~um_.re.~lts;o.fs._n~...._!! turboexp.ander isentropic efficiency 63.95 % /'Is
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
reaction /9 0.4635 diameter ratio p, 0.4895 velocity ratio Ul 0.5774 rotor speed n 209491 ~9m rot.:::::::::_ort:::ip diamet.:::_:erD! ......................:.21.m m . . . . . . . . . .
~
p
Figure 2
Characteristic curved surface
CONCLUSION The results of example turbine optimization problem show that the GA based optimization method presented here is valid and reliable. It is very useful in the field of optimization design of turboexpander. REFERENCES Goldberg, D.E., Genetic algorithms in search, optimization and machine learning, MA: Addison Wesley (1989) Ji, G.H., Turboexpander, Machinery Industry Press (1989) (in Chinese)
Predicting Performance of Helium Expansion Turbines Using Similarity Principles
Liqiang Liu
Chtmzheng Chen
Department of Refrigeration and Cryogenic Engineering, Xi'an Jiaotong University, Xi'an, 710049,China
The problem associated with performing tests at the manufacturer's plant under process conditions and the lack of an exact method of performance transformation are discussed. A performance prediction program based on an one-dimensional analysis of expansion turbines (abbr. ETs) has been developed and on the basis of which a method of selecting similarity criteria (abbr. SC) to deal with the simulate modeling tests (abbr. SMTs) on air and helium is presented. Test data provided by others has demonstrated that the prediction method using similarity principles is effective.
INTRODUCTION When a small helium gas bearing ET is developed, users demand that the performance curve of the ET should be provided before it is installed to realize normal operation of the whole reffigeration system. Since the theoretical prediction method is not mature at present, the only way to solve the problem is to do experiments on the machine directly. But for the reasons that working fluid (abbr. WF) is expensive and very low temperature environment is not easily available for manufacturer, the experiments have to be done on air under the atmosphere temperature. Because of the difference of the ratio of specific heats to, ET performance is different when tests are performed on air or helium. Unfortunately the question how to translate ET performance from one WF to another has never been perfectly answered in the ET field. For the purpose of solving this problem, we have