Image quality measurement using the Haar wavelet


  



   !"#%$&')(*,+,- .0/2135476859;:<859=851?>A@'BC4@'BEDF8HGI6/J

LK 1NMOH3QPR85MSOT>VUWOX>N9Y8[ZFG\]MSOH^_\@-OH1`MSOHP abOdcE85PMS^VOH1`MJXe-f;ghOXi MSP9jiH8Xgf;13k9l1OHOdPS9l12354ZFG\]MSOH^_\ mb19lnFOdP\o9hM]GpJ5eqZFJQ/MrOHP1A@,8Xgl9setJQPS129j8 :EJF\'ub13QOdglOX\wvx@,u)yQzkzQ{QyH4]|k}Q~Q € ‚Eƒ'„p€#…ƒ # †‡Xˆ-‰‹ŠŒŽX‘‰t‘’w“kŒ”F•'ˆŒ“H–j—t˜H™kŒŠ‹ˆ]ŽH–jˆ]ŠtŠ‹’wŠšh›œXxž’wŠŸQˆŒ w–j—t‘¡ “kŒ”¢–j‰t’–j“X’ £—‹ˆL–jŠŒ‰‹‘’šl¤EœH¥=¦žˆ]ŠtŠ‹’wŠ;•'ˆSŒ—t™5Štˆ]—§ŒŠtˆ-•Œ‘“X”‘¨-©l’dªo™X—tˆ]Ž ’w“0‰t‡XˆŸX‘«Hˆ]”¢–j¬d¨ –jŸX‘«Hˆ]”wŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆo“Xª]ˆ¬Qˆ]‰j®<ˆoˆ]“¯‰t‡Xˆ’wŠ‹‘¡w‘“kŒ”HŒ“XŽª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹ˆ]Ž,‘•Œ¡wˆo—°FœH™XªL‡•'ˆ]‰‹Št‘ª]—EŒŠ‹ˆ<‘•'Ÿ5Št’wŸQˆ]ŠQ©h’ Š—t™X¬w±Lˆoª]‰t‘²wˆ ˜H™kŒ”‘‘‰j¨’wŠ´³kŽXˆ]”‘‘‰j¨µŒ—‹—tˆ]—‹—t•bˆ]“H‰¶N—t‘“Xª]ˆ‡H™X•Œ“ŸkˆoŠtª]ˆ]Ÿ5‰t‘’w“#‘—;²wˆ]Š‹¨—tˆo“X—t‘‰t‘² ˆ¯‰t’'ªo’wŠtŠ‹ˆ]”sŒ‰‹£’ “X—-¬Qˆ]‰j®ˆ]ˆ]“·ŒŽS±]Œª]ˆo“d‰;ŸX‘«Hˆ]”‘—°0¸j“ ‰t‡5£—®<’ Št F¶X®ˆˆ]«HŸX”‘’wŠtˆ0‰t‡Xˆ-¹;ŒwŒŠ§®ŒS²wˆ]”‘ˆ]‰‰t’'•b’HŽXˆ]”F‰t‡5ˆ-—tŸkŒª]ˆL–l©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨#”‘’HªŒ”‘‘ºŒ‰t‘’w“bŸXŠt’ Ÿkˆ]Š‹‰j¨’©E‡H™X•Œ“'²H‘—t™QŒ”`—‹¨H—t‰tˆo• šs¹»=œXžo°H¸j‰<‘——t‡X’®“‰‹‡kŒ‰‰t‡Xˆ;ŸX‡H¨H—t‘ªŒ”kªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰‘“bŽX¢­¼ˆ]Š‹ˆ]“H‰Štˆ]—‹’w”‘™X‰‹£’ “X—ªŒ“¬Qˆ§ˆŒ—t‘”‘¨¯Štˆ]ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—tˆo“d‰‹ˆ]Žp£“b‰tˆ]Š‹•'—’©`‰‹ŠŒ“5—j©h’ Št• ª]’HˆL½'ª]‘ˆ]“H‰‹—°b¾#ˆ,•b’dŽ5ˆ]”¹§»=œp®‘‰‹‡µ‰‹‡Xˆ¯¹=Œ ŒŠ³k”‘‰tˆ]Š0®£‰‹‡µ—‹ˆ]²wˆoŠŒ”²H‘—t™kŒ”2•bˆ]ªL‡kŒ“5£—‹•'—;Œ“XŽpŽXˆ]² ˆ]”‘’wŸ·Œb—t™X¬w±7ˆ]ª]‰t‘² ˆ¯˜d™QŒ”‘‘‰j¨ •'ˆSŒ—t™5Štˆ;®‡X‘ªL‡‘—•'’ Štˆ§ªo’w“X—‹£—‹‰tˆ]“H‰®£‰‹‡‡d™5•Œ“¯’ ¬X—tˆoŠt²wŒ‰‹‘’w“ˆ]«HŸkˆoŠt‘ˆ]“Xª]ˆ ° ¿bÀHÁFÂ-ÃkÄwÅƏǷ‘•Œ¡wˆ'˜H™kŒ”‘£‰j¨·Œ—t—‹ˆ]—t—‹•'ˆ]“H‰¶´ª]’w•bŸXŠtˆ]—‹—t‘’w“WŒŠt‰‹¢©YŒª]‰¯•bˆŒ—‹™XŠtˆ ¶‡H™X•Œ“·²H‘—t™kŒ”§—t¨H—‹‰tˆ]•È•b’dŽ5ˆ]”-šs¹»=œXžo¶<¹;ŒwŒŠ ®ŒS²wˆ]”‘ˆ]‰S° 2É ÊpËÌ ƒ'„ ÍÏÎ#Ð[…ƒ Ë Í Ì ¸j•Œ¡wˆ˜H™kŒ”‘‘‰j¨IŒ—‹—tˆ]—‹—t•'ˆo“d‰‘—Œ“I‘•bŸk’ Št‰Œ“H‰¯‰Œ—‹ V©h’ Šˆo²wŒ”‘™kŒ‰‹‘’w“V’©,ˆ7­¼ˆ]ªo‰t‘²wˆ]“5ˆ]—t—·Œ“XŽIŸQˆ]Šj©h’ Št•Œ“Xª]ˆp’©²wŒŠt‘’ ™X—'”‘’w—‹—t¨ ‘•Œ¡wˆ;ª]’w•bŸXŠtˆo—t—t‘’ “‰tˆ]ªL‡X“5£˜H™Xˆo—°ѧ“pˆ]ŠtŠ‹’wŠ-•bˆŒ—‹™XŠtˆ0£—;“Xˆoˆ]ŽXˆ]Ž#‰‹’ªo’w•'Ÿ5™X‰tˆ-‰‹‡XˆŽX‘—t‰t’ Št‰‹£’ “µ’ Š§‰‹‡Xˆ¯ŽX‘—t‰LŒ“Xª]ˆ¬Qˆ]‰j®<ˆoˆ]“#‰t‡Xˆ ’wŠ‹‘¡w‘“kŒ”`Œ“XŽª]’w•bŸXŠtˆo—t—tˆoŽµ‘•Œ¡wˆ]——t’¯‰‹‡kŒ‰‰t‡Xˆ0˜d™QŒ”‘‘‰j¨'’©E‰‹‡Xˆ-ª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹£’ “‰tˆ]ªL‡X“X‘˜H™XˆªŒ“¬Qˆ,ˆo²wŒ”‘™kŒ‰‹ˆ]Ž`°Ñ‰ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—tˆ]“H‰S¶F‰t‡Xˆ •'ˆSŒ“H–j—t˜H™kŒŠtˆ]ŽH–jˆ]Š‹Št’wŠ-šl›œXEž´’wŠŸkˆSŒ  –Y—‹‘¡w“kŒ”Ò–j‰t’–Y“5’w‘—tˆL–jŠŒ‰t‘’'šl¤EœH¥=¦žˆ]ŠtŠ‹’wŠ•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ]—§ŒŠ‹ˆ=•b’w—‹‰<®‘ŽXˆ]”‘¨¯™X—‹ˆ]Ž`°x†‡Xˆ]¨'ªSŒ“¬kˆ ˆŒ—t‘”‘¨µª]’ •'ŸX™5‰tˆ]Ž#‰‹’Štˆ]Ÿ5Štˆ]—‹ˆ]“H‰¯‰t‡XˆbŽXˆ]²HsŒ‰t‘’ “µ’©§‰t‡XˆbŽX‘—t‰t’ Št‰‹ˆ]Ž·‘•Œ¡wˆ;©lŠt’w•Ó‰‹‡Xˆ¯’wŠ‹£¡ ‘“kŒ”E‘•Œ¡wˆ0£“#‰‹‡Xˆ'Ÿ5£«Hˆ]”‘®‘—tˆ¯—‹ˆ]“X—‹ˆw° ¹§’®ˆ]² ˆ]Š¶H‘“'Ÿ5ŠŒªo‰t‘ªŒ”F²H‘ˆ]®‘“X¡—t‘‰t™QŒ‰t‘’ “X—¶ ‡H™X•Œ“¯¬kˆ]‘“X¡ —ÔŒŠtˆ;™X—‹™kŒ”‘”‘¨,“5’w‰’w“5”£¨ª]’ “Xª]ˆ]“H‰tŠLŒ‰‹ˆ]Ž’w“bŸX‘«Hˆ]”FŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“Xªoˆ]—°Õ5Št’w• ‰t‡5ˆ-²H£ˆo®Ÿk’ £“H‰’©?‡H™X•Œ“bŸkˆ]Š‹ª]ˆ]ŸX‰‹‘’w“`¶FŸQˆ]Š‹ª]ˆ]ŸX‰‹™kŒ”³QŽXˆ]”‘‘‰j¨'‘“Xª]”‘™XŽXˆo—§—t™5Šj©YŒª]ˆ,—‹•'’H’w‰‹‡X“Xˆ]—‹—¶Qˆ]ŽX¡ ˆ-—t‡QŒŠtŸ5“Xˆ]—t—-Œ“XŽª]’ “d‰‹‘“d™5£‰j¨H¶ ŸXŠ‹’wŸQˆ]Š,¬QŒªL H¡wŠt’ ™X“XŽ[“X’w‘—tˆb”‘ˆ]²wˆ]”j¶Œ“XŽ[—t’’ “`°µÖ¢­Fˆ]Štˆ]“H‰‘•Œ¡ ˆ,ªo’w•'Ÿ5Štˆ]—‹—t‘’w“#‰‹ˆ]ªL‡X“X‘˜H™Xˆ]—¯‘“XŽX™Xªoˆ'²wŒŠ‹‘’w™X—-‰j¨HŸQˆ]—’©§²H‘—t™kŒ” ŒŠ‹‰t¢©YŒª]‰t—‰‹‡kŒ‰§ŒR­¼ˆ]ªo‰§‡H™X•Œ“¯²H£ˆo®£“5¡,ˆ]«HŸQˆ]Št‘ˆ]“5ª]ˆ¯‘“'•Œ“H¨,ŽX‘—‹‰t‘“Xª]‰®ŒS¨H—¶Xˆo²wˆ]“¢©2‰‹‡Xˆ,›œX[’ Š§¤EœH¥=¦W”‘ˆ]² ˆ]”‘—§ŒŠ‹ˆ×ŒŽ±L™X—‹‰tˆ]Ž ‰t’0¬kˆ;Œ¬Q’w™X‰Eˆo˜d™QŒ”j°`¸j‰x£—x¡wˆ]“XˆoŠŒ”‘”‘¨¯Œ¡wŠ‹ˆ]ˆ]Žb‰t‡kŒ‰<›œXp’ Š<¤EœH¥;¦VŽX’Hˆ]—“X’w‰Eªo’wŠtŠ‹ˆ]”sŒ‰‹ˆ§®ˆ]”‘”k®‘‰t‡¯‰‹‡Xˆ²H‘—t™kŒ”k˜H™kŒ”£‘‰j¨;ŸQˆ]Štª]ˆo£² ˆ]Ž ¬H¨¯‡H™X•Œ“¯¬kˆ]‘“X¡ —¶H—‹£“5ª]ˆ-›œX#‘—ª]’w•bŸX™X‰‹ˆ]Ž'¬H¨'ŒŽ5ŽX‘“X¡,‰‹‡Xˆ§—‹˜H™kŒŠ‹ˆ]ŽŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆ]“5ª]ˆ]—§’©2‘“XŽX‘²H‘ŽX™kŒ”XŸX‘«Hˆ]”‘—<®‘‰t‡5’w™X‰ª]’w“5—t‘ŽXˆ]Š‹£“5¡ ‰t‡5ˆ,²H‘—t™kŒ”£“H‰‹ˆ]ŠŒª]‰t‘’w“pŒ•'’ “X¡¯ŒŽ±]Œª]ˆ]“H‰;ŸX‘«Hˆ]”‘—°;¸j“’ ŠtŽXˆ]Š;‰‹’’ ¬X‰Œ‘“µŒ“’ ¬w±Lˆ]ª]‰‹‘²wˆ•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ;©h’wŠŽX‘¡w‘‰Œ”`‘•Œ¡wˆ;ŸQˆ]Štª]ˆoŸX‰t™kŒ” ˜H™kŒ”‘‘‰j¨H¶•b’HŽXˆ]”‘—’©`‡H™X•Œ“-²H‘—t™kŒ”k—‹¨d—‹‰tˆ]•Øšs¹§»;œXžx—t‡X’ ™X”‘Ž¯¬kˆ‰LŒ wˆo“'‘“H‰t’-Œª]ªo’w™X“H‰°¸j‰‘—E®ˆ]”‘”X H“X’®“¯‰t‡kŒ‰E¹§»;œ¯‡kŒ—EŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆ]“H‰ —tˆo“X—t‘‰t‘²H‘‰j¨;‰t’§—‹‘¡w“kŒ”£—N®‘‰t‡-ŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆo“d‰?©hŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆo“Xª]‘ˆ]—°†‡5ˆ<’² ˆ]ŠŒ”£” ¹§»;œ-‘—`‰‹‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆL©h’wŠ‹ˆ”‘’dªSŒ”‘‘º]ˆ]Ž-‘“-¬Q’w‰‹‡,‰‹‡Xˆ<—‹ŸkŒªoˆÔŒ“XŽ-©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨ ŽX’ •Œ‘“X—S¶wŒ“5Ž“5ˆ]‘‰t‡Xˆ]Š‰t‡Xˆ;—‹ŸkŒª]ˆ7–Y¬kŒ—tˆ]Ž#›œX[“X’ Š‰t‡Xˆ0¡w”‘’w¬kŒ”¼Õ5’w™5Št‘ˆ]Š§Œ“QŒ”‘¨H—t‘—<Ÿ5Št’²H‘ŽXˆ]—§Œ0¡w’H’HŽ‰‹’H’w”Q©h’ Š£‰‹—<•b’HŽXˆ]”‘‘“X¡k° †‡Xˆ¯•Œo±L’wŠŽX¢½'ª]™X”‘‰j¨‘“µ•b’HŽXˆ]”‘‘“X¡¯¹§»;œF¶F‡X’®ˆ]²wˆoŠ-’©h‰‹ˆ]“#“Xˆ]¡ ”‘ˆ]ª]‰tˆoŽ#¬d¨p—t™5¬w±Lˆ]ª]‰‹£² ˆ¯˜H™kŒ”‘‘‰j¨µŒ—‹—tˆ]—‹—t•bˆ]“H‰-Štˆ]—‹ˆŒŠ‹ªL‡Xˆ]—¶x‘— ’w“[‰t‡Xˆbª]’w•bŸX™X‰LŒ‰t‘’ “#’©§‰t‡5ˆ'ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰¯‘“·ª]’ •'ŸX”‘ˆ]«£•Œ¡ ˆ]—°¸j“·‰t‡5£—®’wŠt F¶®ˆ'ˆ]«HŸX”‘’ Štˆ‰t‡Xˆb¹=Œ ŒŠ®ÔŒS² ˆ]”‘ˆ]‰¶®‡X‘ªL‡·‡QŒ—¯Œ ¡w’H’HŽ·—‹ŸkŒªoˆL–h©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨I”‘’HªŒ”‘‘ºŒ‰‹‘’w“#ŸXŠ‹’wŸQˆ]Št‰j¨H¶‰t’#ˆ]²wŒ”£™QŒ‰tˆb‰t‡XˆŸX‡H¨H—t‘ªŒ”§ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰S°V¸j‰¯£——t‡5’®“Ù‰‹‡kŒ‰¯‰‹‡Xˆª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰'ªŒ“ ¬Qˆ'ˆŒ—t‘”‘¨µŠ‹ˆ]ŸXŠtˆo—tˆ]“H‰tˆoŽI‘“·Œ“·ˆo«dŸ5Štˆ]—‹—t‘’w“[’©§‰tŠLŒ“X—Ú©h’wŠ‹•Óª]’HˆL½'ª]‘ˆ]“H‰t—S° œT’w•'ˆ¯²H‘—t™QŒ”EŸX‡5ˆ]“X’w•bˆ]“kŒªSŒ“ÙŒ”‘—t’¬Qˆ'•b’dŽ5ˆ]”‘ˆ]Žµ¬H¨ •¯™X”‘‰t‘Š‹ˆ]—t’ ”£™5‰t‘’w“kŒ”dŒ“kŒ”‘¨H—t‘—E—‹£“5ª]ˆ;‰t‡Xˆª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰<‘—EŽXˆ7³k“Xˆ]Ž‘“¯ˆ]²wˆoŠt¨¯Štˆo—t’w”‘™X‰‹‘’w“`°EÛ’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰t—‘“¯ŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“H‰Štˆo—t’w”‘™X‰‹‘’w“X—<ŒŠtˆ‰t‡Xˆ]“ ª]’ •¯¬X‘“Xˆ]Ž#®‘‰t‡[²d‘—‹™kŒ”ˆL­Fˆ]ª]‰t—b‰t’#¨H‘ˆ]”‘Ž·Œ“5ˆ]®Ü¡ ŠŒS¨ –j—tªŒ”£ˆb‘•Œ¡ ˆ,˜H™kŒ”‘£‰j¨p•'ˆSŒ—t™5Štˆw°#†‡5ˆ'“Xˆ]®Ý’w¬w±7ˆ]ª]‰t‘² ˆˆoŠtŠt’ Š¯•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ ‘—-ŽXˆL³Q“Xˆ]Ž·Œ—0‰t‡Xˆ'Œ¡w¡wŠ‹ˆ]¡dŒ‰tˆ¯ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰-•b‘—t•Œ‰tªL‡¬kˆo‰j®<ˆ]ˆo“Ù‰‹‡Xˆ¯’wŠ‹‘¡w‘“kŒ”EŒ“XŽµªo’w•'Ÿ5Štˆ]—‹—tˆ]Ž[£•Œ¡ ˆ]—°0†‡X‘—-•'ˆ]‰‹Št‘ª]—;‘—-•'’ Štˆ ª]’ “X—t‘—t‰‹ˆ]“H‰§®‘‰t‡‡H™X•Œ“¯—t™5¬w±Lˆ]ª]‰‹£² ˆ,ŠLŒ“X H‘“X¡¯Œ“XŽªŒŸkŒ¬5”£ˆ;’©?Ž5ˆ]—tª]Š‹‘¬X‘“X¡¯²wŒŠ‹£’ ™X—ª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹ˆ]Ž£•Œ¡ ˆ=ŒŠ‹‰t¢©YŒª]‰t—S°†‡X‘—ˆL­¼’ Št‰ —t‡5’w™X”‘ŽVª]’w“H‰‹Št‘¬X™X‰‹ˆ‰t’#‰‹‡XˆŽXˆ]² ˆ]”‘’wŸX•bˆ]“H‰,’©-“Xˆ]®Ýª]’w•bŸXŠtˆ]—‹—t‘’w“V‰‹ˆ]ªL‡X“X‘˜H™Xˆ]—'‰‹‡kŒ‰ŒŠ‹ˆ•b’wŠ‹ˆ'ª]’ “Xª]ˆ]“H‰tŠLŒ‰‹ˆ]ŽÞ’ “V‰t‡Xˆ’² ˆ]ŠŒ”‘” ŸQˆ]Štª]ˆoŸX‰t™kŒ”N³kŽXˆ]”‘‘‰j¨'ŠLŒ‰t‡5ˆ]Š‰t‡kŒ“ŸX‘«dˆo”£®‘—‹ˆ=ˆoŠtŠt’ Š§•b£“5£•¯‘ºŒ‰t¢’w“`° †‡X‘—;ŸkŒŸQˆ]Š-‘—;’wŠ‹¡dŒ“5£ºoˆ]Ž Œ—©h’w”‘”‘’®—°¾#ˆ-³QŠt—t‰0ŽX‘—tª]™X—‹—-¹§»;œ•b’HŽXˆ]”‘—§‘“µœHˆoª]‰t‘’w“·ß5°-¸j“#œHˆ]ª]‰‹‘’w“#àX¶F®ˆ,Ÿ5Št’wŸQ’w—‹ˆ'Œb“Xˆ]® ŽXˆL³Q“X‘‰t‘’w“b’©2ªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰®‘‰t‡'Š‹ˆ]—tŸQˆ]ª]‰;‰‹’¯ª]’w•bŸX”‘ˆ]«,‘•Œ¡wˆo—<¬H¨¯‰Œ H£“5¡,‰‹‡Xˆ;¹=ŒwŒŠ®ÔŒS² ˆ]”‘ˆ]‰‰tŠŒ“X—j©l’wŠt•Ý’©‰t‡Xˆ;‘•Œ¡wˆw¶HŒ“5Ž'™X—‹£“5¡

®ŒS²wˆ]”‘ˆ]‰Eªo’dˆ7½'ª]‘ˆ]“H‰t—‰t’0ˆ]—t‰‹£•Œ‰‹ˆ‰t‡Xˆª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰ÔŒ‰<ˆŒªL‡'Štˆo—t’w”‘™X‰‹‘’w“¯‘“¯‰t‡Xˆ‘•Œ¡ ˆw°
¨,™5—t‘“X¡‰t‡Xˆ•¯™X”‘‰t‘Štˆ]—‹’w”‘™X‰‹£’ “,Œ“5Ž¯—tŸkŒª]ˆL– ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨b”‘’dªSŒ”‘‘ºŒ‰‹£’ “,Ÿ5Št’wŸQˆ]Š‹‰t‘ˆ]—’©`®ŒS²wˆo”£ˆo‰t—¶H—‹ˆ]²wˆoŠŒ”F’ ¬X—tˆoŠt²wˆoŽ‘“Xªo’w“X—‹£—‹‰tˆ]“5ª]‘ˆ]—§‘“¯‰t‡5ˆ§ŸX—‹¨dªL‡X’ ŸX‡H¨H—t‘ªŒ”F”‘‘‰tˆoŠŒ‰‹™XŠtˆªŒ“b¬kˆ ˆ]«HŸX”sŒ‘“XˆoŽ“kŒ‰‹™XŠŒ”‘”£¨H°¹»=œ•'ˆ]ªL‡kŒ“X‘—t•'—•'ˆo“d‰‹‘’w“Xˆ]Ž£“œHˆoª]‰t‘’w“#߯—‹™XªL‡ Œ—;‰t‡Xˆ—t™XŸ5ŠŒ‰‹‡XŠtˆo—t‡X’ ”£ŽpŸQˆ]Štª]ˆoŸX‰t‘’w“#Š‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“5—tˆw¶N‰t‡Xˆ ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨b•Œ—t H‘“X¡;ˆL­¼ˆoª]‰¶FŒ“5Ž'‰t‡5ˆ§ŽX‘Štˆoª]‰t‘’w“QŒ”FŸXŠ‹ˆL©hˆ]Š‹ˆ]“Xª]ˆ-ªSŒ“¬kˆª]’w“H² ˆ]“X‘ˆ]“H‰t”‘¨¯‘“Xª]’ ŠtŸQ’wŠŒ‰tˆ]Ž‘“'‰‹‡Xˆ§®ŒS²wˆo”£ˆo‰E©hŠLŒ•bˆ]®<’ Št F° Œ—tˆoŽÙ’ “·‰‹‡X‘—-©hŠLŒ•bˆ]®<’ Št F¶®ˆ'ŸXŠ‹’wŸQ’w—tˆŒ“·’w¬w±7ˆ]ª]‰t‘² ˆ•bˆ]‰tŠ‹‘ª'‘“·œHˆ]ª]‰‹‘’w“IàX° à‰‹’µª]’ •'ŸX™5‰tˆ'‰‹‡Xˆˆ]«H‰tˆ]“H‰¯’©=‰t‡5ˆ'ŸQˆ]Štª]ˆo£² ˆ]Ž ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰£“¯ˆo²wˆ]Š‹¨'Štˆo—t’w”‘™X‰‹‘’w“`¶HŒ“XŽ¯Ž5ˆ]Št‘²wˆ;Œ“bˆ]ŠtŠ‹’wŠ•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ§¬H¨,ˆo«TŒ•'‘“X‘“X¡‰t‡Xˆ®<ˆ]‘¡ ‡d‰‹ˆ]Ž'Ž5Ò­Fˆ]Š‹ˆ]“Xª]ˆ]—’©`ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰‹—¬kˆ]‰j®ˆ]ˆ]“ ‰t‡5ˆ’wŠ‹£¡ ‘“kŒ”§Œ“XŽVª]’w•bŸXŠtˆ]—‹—tˆ]Ž £•Œ¡ ˆ]—qŒ‰¯ˆŒªL‡IŠ‹ˆ]—t’ ”‘™X‰t‘’w“N° ¤?—t¨HªL‡X’wŸX‡H¨H—t‘ªŒ”§ˆ]«HŸQˆ]Št‘•bˆ]“H‰t—ŒŠtˆªo’w“XŽX™5ª]‰tˆ]Ž £“IœHˆoª]‰t‘’w“ ‰t’#Ž5ˆ]•'’ “X—t‰‹ŠŒ‰‹ˆ‰t‡Xˆ²wŒ”‘‘ŽX‘‰j¨#Œ“XŽVˆL­Fˆ]ª]‰‹£² ˆ]“Xˆ]—‹—’©=‰‹‡Xˆ¹;ŒwŒŠ³Q”£‰‹ˆ]Š°V¾#ˆŒ”£—‹’µ™5—tˆ‰‹‡Xˆ]—tˆˆ]«HŸkˆ]Š‹‘•'ˆ]“H‰t—¯‰‹’#ª]’w“5ª]”‘™XŽXˆ‰t‡Xˆ ‘“XŽXˆ]ŸQˆ]“XŽ5ˆ]“Xª]ˆ’©k‰j®’;²d‘—‹™kŒ”H•Œ—t H‘“X¡²wŒŠ‹sŒ¬X”‘ˆ]—S°F¹§™X•Œ“;ŸQˆ]Štª]ˆoŸX‰t‘’w“bŽXˆL³kªo£ˆo“Xª]¨¯Œ‰’w¬X”‘‘˜H™XˆE’ Št‘ˆ]“H‰Œ‰t‘’w“X—ŒŠ‹ˆ§Œ”‘—t’•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ]Ž ‘“'‰‹‡Xˆ]—tˆ0ˆ]«HŸkˆ]Š‹‘•'ˆ]“H‰t—S°†‡Xˆ-ŸXŠ‹’wŸQ’w—‹ˆ]Ž£•Œ¡ ˆ˜d™QŒ”‘‘‰j¨,•bˆŒ—‹™XŠtˆ;‘—ÔŒŸXŸX”‘‘ˆ]Ž'‰‹’¯“kŒ‰‹™XŠŒ”F‘•Œ¡ ˆ]—E‰‹’,‰‹ˆ]—t‰£‰‹—ˆL­Fˆ]ª]‰t‘² ˆ]“Xˆ]—‹—°¾#ˆ Œ”‘—‹’§ŽX‘—tªo™X—t—‰t‡5ˆ<²H‘ˆ]®‘“X¡ŽX‘—t‰LŒ“Xªoˆ<ˆL­Fˆ]ª]‰x‰t‡kŒ‰2ŒS­Fˆ]ª]‰‹—‰t‡XˆŸkˆoŠtª]ˆ]Ÿ5‰t‘’w“¯’©T‘•Œ¡wˆNª]’w•bŸXŠtˆo—t—t‘’ “,ŒŠ‹‰t¢©YŒªo‰t—°Û’w“5ª]”‘™XŽX‘“X¡Štˆo•ŒŠ‹ H— ŒŠ‹ˆ;¡w‘²wˆ]“‘“œTˆ]ª]‰t‘’  “ 5° EÊ Ð

€ Ì ·Ë ‚EÐ#€

݂V‚?ƒ   ‚ ØÍÎ  ;‚ »§‘—‹™kŒ”ŸQˆ]Štª]ˆoŸX‰t‘’w“#‘—‰t‡XˆŠtˆ]—‹™X”‘‰©hŠt’ • Œ¯—tˆoŠt‘ˆ]—-’©?’ ŸX‰t‘ªŒ”EŒ“XŽ“5ˆ]™XŠŒ”E‰tŠLŒ“X—Ú©h’wŠ‹•Œ‰t‘’w“X—S°†‡Xˆ”‘£¡ ‡H‰£—ŸXŠt’S±Lˆ]ª]‰‹ˆ]Ž#’w“H‰t’b‰t‡Xˆ Štˆo‰t‘“kŒ‰t‡5Št’w™5¡w‡‰t‡Xˆ0ª]’wŠ‹“XˆŒ'Œ“XŽ'”‘ˆ]“5—§‰t’©l’wŠt•ÝŒ“’wŸX‰‹‘ªŒ”F‘•Œ¡wˆw° †‡Xˆ-Štˆo‰t‘“kŒ‘•Œ¡wˆ‘—‰t‡Xˆo“—tˆ]“5—tˆ]Ž¬H¨bŸX‡X’w‰‹’wŠ‹ˆ]ª]ˆ]ŸX‰‹’wŠ‹—=’ “ ‰t‡5ˆŠtˆ]‰‹£“QŒ-Œ“XŽ‰tŠLŒ“X—Ú©h’wŠ‹•'ˆ]Ž‘“H‰t’;“Xˆ]™XŠLŒ”XŠ‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“5—tˆ]—‰‹’-ŠtˆŒªL‡¯‰t‡Xˆ’ ŸX‰t‘ª“Xˆ]Š‹²wˆw°†‡5ˆ’wŸX‰‹£ª“Xˆ]Š‹²wˆªŒŠ‹Št‘ˆ]—E‰‹‡Xˆ]—tˆ—t‘¡w“QŒ”‘—‰t’;‰t‡Xˆ ‰t‡5ˆ§²H‘—t™kŒ”Xª]’wŠ‹‰tˆ]«¯‘“¯‰‹‡Xˆ§¬XŠLŒ‘“©h’ Š©h™XŠ‹‰t‡Xˆ]ŠŸXŠ‹’dªoˆ]—t—‹£“5¡k°EœH‘“Xª]ˆ¬k’ ‰t‡¯ŸX‡5’w‰t’ Štˆ]ªoˆ]ŸX‰t’ Št—;Œ“XŽ¯ª]’ Št‰‹£ªSŒ”Qª]ˆ]”‘”‘—E‰tŠLŒ“X—Ú©h’wŠ‹• ‘“Xªo’w•'‘“X¡ —t‘¡ “kŒ”‘—E‘“H‰t’-—‹’w•bˆŸkŒŠ‹‰t‘ª]™X”sŒŠŠtˆoŸXŠtˆ]—‹ˆ]“H‰Œ‰t‘’w“`¶5‰t‡Xˆo¨©h’wŠ‹• ‰‹‡Xˆ;ª]’wŠ‹ˆ§’©`‰t‡Xˆ;²H‘—t™kŒ”k—‹¨d—‹‰tˆ]•p°`†‡5ˆ§’w¬w±7ˆ]ª]‰t‘² ˆ=’©`ŸX—t¨HªL‡X’ ŸX‡H¨d—‹‘ªŒ” Štˆo—tˆŒŠtªL‡£—‰t’0•'’HŽXˆ]”X‰‹‡Xˆ§’² ˆ]ŠŒ”‘”X‰tŠLŒ“X—Ú©hˆ]Š©h™X“5ª]‰t‘’w“¯’©¼‰‹‡Xˆ;²H£—‹™kŒ”5—t¨H—t‰‹ˆ]•µ¶ ®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ=•Œ“H¨;’©`‰‹‡Xˆ§ª]’ •'ŸQ’w—‹£“5¡=•bˆ]ªL‡kŒ“5£—‹•'—EŒŠ‹ˆ ’wŠ‹‘¡w‘“kŒ‰‹‘“X¡;©hŠ‹’w• ˆ]‘‰‹‡Xˆ]Š§’©2‰‹‡Xˆ]—tˆ0‰j®<’¯ª]’ Štˆ-ˆo”£ˆo•'ˆ]“H‰t—S¶XŒ—®ˆ]”‘”`Œ—‰‹‡Xˆ;’wŸX‰‹£ªSŒ”`•bˆ]ªL‡kŒ“5£—‹• ’©2‰‹‡Xˆ-ˆ]¨ ˆw° EÊlÉÊ …  !#"$%'& (
"'&*),+-!+."/(0"213 1541576

†‡Xˆ-Œ¬5£”‘‘‰j¨’©2‰‹‡Xˆ-ˆ]¨ ˆ;‰t’¯ŽXˆ]‰‹ˆ]ª]‰”£‘¡ ‡d‰‘—<Ž5ˆ]Ÿkˆo“XŽXˆ]“H‰;’w“b¬k’ ‰t‡‰t‡XˆŒ•'’ ™X“H‰E’©”‘£¡ ‡H‰E˜H™kŒ“H‰Œ¯Œ“XŽ'‰‹‡Xˆ-¬kŒªL d¡ Št’ ™X“XŽ'”‘‘¡w‡H‰‹£“5¡k° †‡Xˆ¯ˆ]¨ ˆ,ªSŒ“#—tˆo“X—tˆ'Œb²wˆoŠt¨p—t•Œ”‘”2Œ•b’w™X“H‰’©Ô”‘‘¡w‡H‰§®‡5ˆ]“µ‘‰;‘—©h™X”‘”‘¨ŽQŒŠt pŒŽkŒŸX‰tˆ]ŽN¶F¬X™X‰-ªSŒ“X“X’ ‰;—tˆ]“X—‹ˆ'‰‹‡Xˆ¯—Œ•'ˆ,Œ•'’w™5“d‰ ’©§”‘‘¡w‡H‰;®‡Xˆ]“[‰t‡Xˆ¯—‹™XŠtŠ‹’w™X“5ŽX‘“X¡w—‘—-Štˆ]”sŒ‰t‘²wˆ]”‘¨p¬XŠt‘¡ ‡d‰S°†‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆL©h’wŠ‹ˆw¶E‡H™X•Œ“²H‘—t™QŒ”Ÿkˆ]Š‹ª]ˆ]ŸX‰‹‘’w“·‘—,Œ©h™X“Xª]‰‹‘’w“#’©§¬Q’w‰‹‡#‰t‡Xˆ ”‘™X•'‘“kŒ“Xª]ˆŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆo“Xª]ˆ¬kˆ]‰j®ˆ]ˆ]“‰t‡Xˆ-¬QŒªL H¡wŠt’ ™X“XŽŒ“5Ž'‰t‡5ˆ-—t‰‹£•¯™5”£QŒ“XŽ‰t‡5ˆ-¬kŒªL H¡wŠ‹’w™X“5ŽŒŽQŒŸX‰LŒ‰t‘’ “'”‘ˆ]²wˆo”Y° 8Fˆ] ‰ 9:<;>=µŒ“X? Ž 90:@BAp¬kˆ¯‰‹‡Xˆ¯•Œ«d‘•¯™X•ÝŒ“XŽp•'‘“X‘•™X• ”‘™X•'‘“kŒ“Xª]ˆ]—;’©<‰t‡Xˆ¯®ŒS²wˆ7©h’wŠ‹• ŒŠ‹’w™X“5Žµ‰‹‡Xˆ¯Ÿk’ ‘“d‰;’©Ô‘“H‰tˆ]Š‹ˆ]—t‰S° ›‘ªL‡Xˆ]”‘—t’ #“ C —ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰¶5ŽXˆL³k“XˆoŽµŒ— D Lš TSž E ,š 9:F;G=IH?9:J@BAkLž K5Mš 9:F;G=ONP9:J@QAQSž R ‘—-©l’w™X“XŽ#‰‹’µ¬Qˆ“XˆŒŠt”‘¨#ª]’w“5—t‰Œ“H‰,®‡Xˆo“Ù™5—tˆ]ŽV‰t’Štˆ]ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—tˆo“d‰‰‹‡Xˆ=±L™5—t‰¯“X’ ‰t‘ª]ˆŒ¬X”‘ˆ'”‘™X•'‘“kŒ“Xª]ˆŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“XªoˆwV° UXW Õ5’wŠ—t‰‹‘•¯™X”‘E’© ™X“X¢©h’ Št• ”‘™X•b‘“kŒ“Xªoˆ—tˆ]ˆ]“pŒ¡dŒ‘“X—t‰Œ™X“X¢©h’ Št• ¬kŒªL d¡ Št’ ™X“XŽ`¶H¾#ˆ]¬Qˆ]YŠ C —´©hŠŒª]‰t‘’ “`¶H®‡X‘ªL‡'‘—ŽXˆL³k“5ˆ]ŽµŒ— D

E[Z 9K 9\R

šhß ž

®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ Z 9W£—‰t‡5ˆ'”‘™X•'‘“kŒ“Xª]ˆŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“XªoˆµŒ“XŽ?9A‘—,‰‹‡Xˆ'¬kŒªL d¡ Št’ ™X“XŽ·”‘™X•b‘“kŒ“Xªoˆw°¾#ˆ¯—tˆ]ˆ‰‹‡kŒ‰;©l’wŠ—t‘•'ŸX”‘ˆŸkŒ‰‹‰tˆ]Š‹“X—¶x‰t‡Xˆ ¾#ˆ]¬Qˆ]Š7C —©hŠLŒª]‰‹£’ “µŒ“5Ž‰t‡Xˆ¯›‘ªL‡Xˆ]”‘—t’ “#C —§ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰;ŽX¢­Fˆ]Š;¬d¨Œq©YŒª]‰‹’wŠ’©Ôß5°=¤‡H¨H—t‘’ ”£’ ¡w‘ªŒ”`ˆ]«HŸQˆ]Št‘•'ˆo“d‰‹—§—‹‡X’®<ˆoŽµ‰‹‡kŒ‰ˆ]²wˆ]Š‹¨ ª]’ Št‰t‘ªŒ”Hª]ˆ]”‘”X‘—F©h’Hª]™5—tˆ]Ž¯’ “,Œª]ˆ]Št‰LŒ‘“Štˆ]¡ £’ “-‘“-‰t‡5ˆŠtˆ]ª]ˆoŸX‰t‘²wˆ³Qˆ]”‘Ž,Œ“XŽ’w“5”£¨;—‹ˆ]“X—t‘‰‹£² ˆ<‰‹’§‰‹‡Xˆª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰£“Œ§ªoˆ]Št‰LŒ‘“-©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨ ¬kŒ“XŽ`°†‡Xˆ0’²wˆ]ŠLŒ”‘”`²H‘—t™kŒ”`ŸQˆ]Štªoˆ]ŸX‰t‘’ “µ’©?’ ¬w±Lˆ]ª]‰;”‘™X•b£“QŒ“Xª]ˆ’wŠª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰§‘—§‰‹‡Xˆ]Štˆ7©h’wŠ‹ˆ,‰‹‡XˆqŒ¡w¡ Štˆ]¡HŒ‰tˆ0Ÿkˆ]ŠÚ©h’wŠ‹•Œ“Xª]ˆ;’©EˆŒª‡ ª]ˆ]”‘]” C —©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨Štˆo—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆw_° ^a` œH‘“Xª]ˆ¹§»;œªŒ“5“X’w‰ŸXŠt’²H‘ŽXˆ,Œ“‘“H³Q“X‘‰tˆ-ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰Štˆ]—‹’w”‘™X‰t‘’ “`¶FŒ¯ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰§‰‹‡XŠtˆo—t‡X’ ”£Žpˆ]«H‘—t‰‹—=Œ‰ˆ]²wˆoŠt¨—‹ŸkŒ‰‹ Œ”F©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨d° †‡X‘—-‰‹‡XŠtˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Ž#Š‹ˆ]ŸXŠtˆo—tˆ]“H‰t—¯‰‹‡Xˆ=±7™X—t‰-“5’w‰t‘ª]ˆSŒ¬X”‘ˆª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰,‘“pˆŒªL‡p©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨#¬QŒ“XŽ`°b¸j“p’w‰t‡5ˆ]Š,®’wŠ‹ŽX—¶Œ“H¨—‹‰t‘•¯™X”‘`®‡5’w—tˆ ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰¯‘—,”‘’®ˆ]Š-‰‹‡kŒ“[‰t‡Xˆ‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Ž·ªSŒ“X“X’ ‰,¬QˆŽXˆ]‰‹ˆ]ª]‰tˆoŽI‘“·“X’ Št•Œ”ª]’w“XŽ5£‰‹‘’w“X—S°µ†‡5ˆªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘ŽV²wŒ”‘™Xˆ¯‘—¯Œ ©h™X“5ª]‰t‘’w“V’©×‰‹‡Xˆ—‹ŸkŒ‰‹ Œ”©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨V®‡X‘ªL‡IªŒ“Ù¬QˆŽXˆo‰tˆ]Š‹•'‘“Xˆ]ŽVˆ]«HŸQˆ]Št‘•'ˆo“d‰LŒ”‘”‘¨d°VÑ ‰j¨HŸX‘ªŒ”ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰'—‹ˆ]“X—t‘‰‹£²H‘‰j¨·ªo™XŠt² ˆw¶ ŽXˆL³Q“Xˆ]Ž·Œ—;‰‹‡Xˆ,Š‹ˆ]ª]‘ŸXŠ‹’dªSŒ”’©<‰‹‡Xˆ¯ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰;ª]™XŠt² ˆw¶N£—;—‹‡X’®“µ‘“µÕN‘¡k° T b° ^]`Vѧ—0—t‡X’®“‘“p‰t‡Xˆ0³k¡ ™XŠtˆw¶N¹§»;œ‡QŒ—;‰t‡Xˆ¯‡5£¡ ‡Xˆ]—‹‰ ”‘™X•'‘“kŒ“Xª]ˆ—tˆ]“X—‹‘‰t‘²H£‰j¨ŒŠt’w™5“XŽµàSS– T7cªo¨dªo”£ˆo—=ŸQˆ]Š;ŽXˆ]¡ Štˆ]ˆ ¶`Œ“XŽ‰t‡Xˆ—tˆ]“5—t‘‰t‘²H‘‰j¨Œ‰‹‰tˆ]“H™kŒ‰tˆ]—Œ‰¬Q’w‰t‡p‡X‘¡w‡Œ“XŽ”‘’®I©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨ ˆ]“XŽ5—°p¸j‰,‘—-—‹‡X’®“·¬H¨#ÛŒ•bŸX¬kˆo”£e ” d7fhg/iBjbk¯‰‹‡kŒ‰S¶’²wˆ]ŠŒ®‘ŽXˆ¯ŠLŒ“X¡ ˆ'’©§—‹ŸkŒ‰‹sŒ”x©hŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆo“Xª]‘ˆ]—¶x‰t‡Xˆª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡5’w”‘Ž·’©=Œ ¡wŠLŒ‰‹£“5¡‘—,ŽXˆo‰tˆ]Š‹•'‘“Xˆ]Ž[’w“X”‘¨p¬d¨#‰‹‡XˆŒ•bŸX”‘£‰‹™XŽXˆ’©§‘‰t—0©h™X“5ŽkŒ•bˆ]“H‰Œ”ÕX’ ™XŠt‘ˆ]Šª]’w•bŸk’ “Xˆ]“H‰t—S ° Ԍ—tˆ]ŽV’w“[‰t‡X‘—’w¬X—‹ˆ]Št²wŒ‰t‘’w“N¶ Õ5’w™XŠ‹£ˆoŠ©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨'Œ“kŒ”‘¨H—t‘—‘—2®‘ŽXˆo”£¨™X—‹ˆ]Ž¯‘“¯²d‘—‹£’ “,Š‹ˆ]—tˆSŒŠtªL‡`°xѧª]ªo’wŠtŽ5£“5¡-‰t’-‰‹‡X‘—E•'’HŽXˆo”Y¶Œ“,‘•Œ¡wˆ<ŒŠt‰‹Ò©jŒª]‰EªSŒ“¯¬Qˆ—tˆ]“X—‹ˆ]Ž ’w“5”£¨¯¢©£‰‹—ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰§‘—Œ¬Q’²wˆ;‰t‡Xˆ0‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡X’ ”‘ŽÏŒ‰—t’ •'ˆ§—‹ŸkŒ‰‹sŒ”Q©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]‘ˆ]—’©E‘‰t—ª]’w•bŸk’ “Xˆ]“H‰t—S°

3

10

Sensitivity Threshold

2

10

1

10

0

10 −1 10

0

1

10 10 Spatial Frequency (cycles/deg)

2

10


ÄÀ ;Ñ ‰j¨dŸ5£ªSŒ”`ªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰—‹ˆ]“X—‹£‰‹‘²d‘‰j¨bª]™XŠt² ˆ-’©‡H™X•Œ“¯¬kˆ]‘“X¡ —° œHˆ]² ˆ]ŠŒ”§ˆL­F’wŠ‹‰t—'®ˆ]Š‹ˆŽXˆ]² ’w‰tˆoŽÙ‰‹’#ŸkŒŠLŒ•bˆ]‰tˆ]Š‹‘º]ˆ'‰‹‡Xˆª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰¯—tˆo“X—t‘‰t‘²H‘‰j¨·ª]™5Št²wˆ °IÖ=Œ”‘¨ bŒ“XŽ ŒŠ‹‰tˆ]
“ ^7Ub—‹™X•'•ŒŠt‘º]ˆoŽ ²wŒŠ‹‘’w™X—;ˆ]«HŸQˆ]Št‘•'ˆo“d‰LŒ”EŠ‹ˆ]—t™5”£‰‹—-©lŠt’w•Ø‰t‡Xˆ¯”‘‘‰tˆoŠŒ‰‹™XŠtˆŒ“XŽpŽXˆ]‰‹ˆ]Št•b‘“Xˆ]Ž#‰t‡5ˆ¯ª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰,—‹ˆ]“X—t‘‰‹£²H‘‰j¨#Œ—;‰t‡Xˆ©h™X“Xªo‰t‘’w“p’©—tˆ]² ˆ]ŠŒ” ²wŒŠ‹sŒ¬X”‘ˆ]—S°F†®<’²wŒŠ‹ Œ¬X”‘ˆ]—2ŒŠtˆ’©kŸQŒŠt‰‹‘ª]™X”sŒŠN£•bŸk’ Št‰LŒ“Xª]ˆ ¶j° ˆw°FŽ5£—‹ŸX”sŒS¨;—t‘º]ˆŒ“XŽ-¬QŒªL H¡wŠt’ ™X“XŽ”‘™X•'‘“kŒ“Xª]ˆ`”‘ˆ]² ˆ]”j°2?«dŸQˆ]Š‹£•bˆ]“H‰Œ” Štˆo—t™X”‘‰t—0©hŠ‹’w• 0—t™X¡ ¡wˆ]—‹‰tˆ]Ž[‰t‡kŒ‰-‰t‡Xˆ'Œ“X¡w™5” ŒŠ§ŽX‘—‹ŸX”sŒS¨—t‘º]ˆ¯’©Ô¡ ŠŒ‰‹‘“X¡w—;ŽX’Hˆ]—¯ŒS­Fˆ]ª]‰-‰‹‡Xˆ¯ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰—tˆ]“X—‹‘‰t‘²H£‰j¨pŒ‰;”‘’® —tŸQŒ‰tsŒ” ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]‘ˆ]—S°E¹’®<ˆ]² ˆ]Š¶H‰‹‡X‘—EŽXˆ]²HsŒ‰‹‘’w“¯•ŒS¨;¬Qˆ§ŽX™5ˆ§‰t’0‰t‡XˆŸXŠtˆ]—‹ˆ]“H‰Œ‰t‘’w“b•'ˆ]‰‹‡X’HŽ¯—t‘“Xª]ˆ;Œ;—t•Œ”‘”‘ˆ]Š“d™5•¯¬kˆ]Š’©`—t‰t‘•¯™X”‘Hª]¨Hª]”‘ˆ]— ŸXŠ‹’dŽ5™Xª]ˆ]——‹•Œ”‘”‘ˆ]ŠNŸkˆ]Š‹ª]ˆ]‘²wˆoŽªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰Œ‰x‰t‡Xˆ‰‹‡XŠtˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Ž`°b¸j“'ŒŽ5ŽX‘‰t‘’w“`¶ ¤`ˆo”£3 U—t‡5’®<ˆ]Ž¯‰‹‡kŒ‰‰t‡5ˆ—t™XŸXŠLŒ‰‹‡XŠtˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘ŽŸQˆ]Štª]ˆoŸX‰t‘’w“ ‘—E™X“kŒR­¼ˆoª]‰tˆ]Ž®‘‰t‡¯²wŒŠtsŒ¬5”£ˆ¡ ŠŒ‰t‘“X¡;—t‘º]ˆ]—™5Ÿ¯‰t ’ -ŽXˆ]¡ Štˆ]ˆ]—S°E¾#ˆ‰‹‡d™5—<ŽX’0“X’w‰Eªo’w“X—‹£Ž5ˆ]Š‰t‡XˆŽX‘—tŸX”sŒS¨-—‹‘º]ˆ=Œ—ÔŒ;²wŒŠtsŒ¬5”£ˆ‘“¯‰t‡Xˆ ª]™XŠ‹Štˆ]“H‰®’wŠ‹ ¼°“b‰t‡Xˆ;’w‰‹‡Xˆ]Š‡kŒ“5Ž`¶XŒ”‘‰t‡5’w™X¡ ‡¯‰t‡Xˆ;ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡X’ ”‘Ž‘—ŒŸXŸ5Št’«H‘•Œ‰‹ˆ]”‘¨-ª]’ “X—t‰LŒ“H‰E©l’wŠ²wŒŠt‘’ ™X—E¬kŒª H¡ Št’w™5“XŽ ”‘™X•'‘“kŒ“Xª]ˆ;”‘ˆ]²wˆo”£—©h’ Š;ˆ]«H‰tŠtˆo•'ˆ]”‘¨”‘’®W©hŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆo“Xª]¨#ŸkŒ‰t‰tˆoŠt“X—-—‹™XªL‡ Œ—;‰t‡Xˆ¯—‹‰Œ‘Š‹ªŒ—‹ˆ¯¡wŠŒ‰t‘“X¡ —¶Q‰t‡X‘—;ª]’ “X—t‰LŒ“Xª]¨pŽX’Hˆ]—-“5’w‰;‡X’w”‘Ž ©h’ Š<‰‹‡Xˆ;‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡X’ ”‘Ž'—tˆo“X—t‘‰t‘²H‘‰j¨¯ª]™XŠ‹²wˆ,Œ‰ÔŒ;®‘ŽXˆ;ŠLŒ“X¡ ˆ§’©—tŸkŒ‰tsŒ”5©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]‘ˆ]—S°E†EŒ H‘“X¡-‰‹‡X‘—<²wŒŠtsŒ¬5”£ˆ‘“H‰t’ª]’ “X—t‘ŽXˆ]ŠLŒ‰‹£’ “Œ“XŽ ™X—‹ˆ,Œ-ŸQŒŠŒ¬k’ ”sŒ-‘“”‘’w¡–j”‘’w¡;ª]’H’wŠ‹ŽX‘“kŒ‰‹ˆ]—=Œ—§ŒŠtˆŒ—t’ “kŒ¬X”‘ˆ-ŒŸ5ŸXŠt’«H‘•Œ‰t‘’w“¯Œ—‘“'¾·Œ‰t—‹’w#“ C —®<’ Št F¶ `7^®<ˆ0’w¬X‰LŒ‘“ D

”‘’w¡Xš T7K  W ž E š ^ ”‘’w¡kš,9Ež#N ^ ž]š ”‘’w¡kž U NWš U ”‘’w¡QšM9EžN U žH”‘’w¡NIš ` ”£’ ¡kš,9Ež
N ` ž šhà ž EÊ3xÊ …%&!( ) 1]#/(
2!'  15" ѧ”‘‰‹‡X’w™X¡ ‡,ªoˆ]”‘”£—x“kŒŠ‹Št’®”‘¨;‰t™X“Xˆ‰‹’-ŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆ]“H‰©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨¯¬kŒ“5ŽX—¶‰‹‡Xˆ]¨¯ŒŠ‹ˆ“X’w‰—t‰‹Št‘ª]‰‹”£¨¬kŒ“XŽH–j”£‘•b£‰‹ˆ]Ž`¶SŒ“XŽ‘“d‰‹ˆ]ŠŒª]‰t‘’ “X—<Œ•b’w“X¡ ŒŽS±]Œª]ˆo“d‰©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨#ª‡QŒ“X“Xˆo”£—0®<ˆ]Š‹ˆ¯®<ˆo”£”x’w¬X—‹ˆ]Št² ˆ]Ž#‘“µ‰‹‡Xˆ¯”‘£‰‹ˆ]ŠŒ‰t™XŠ‹ˆw°¯†®’ŸXŠt‘•ŒŠt¨bˆL­¼ˆoª]‰t—¯®ˆ]Štˆ¯’©h‰tˆo“µŽX‘—‹ª]™X—t—‹ˆ]Ž·‘“p‰t‡Xˆ ”‘‘‰tˆ]ŠLŒ‰t™5Štˆw°0†‡Xˆ]¨µŒŠtˆ‰t‡Xˆ—t™X•b•Œ‰t‘’w“¯ˆL­Fˆ]ª]‰¯Œ“5Ž‰t‡Xˆ•Œ—t H‘“X¡¯ˆL­Fˆ]ª]‰S°,†‡5ˆ,—‹™X•'•Œ‰t‘’ “¯ˆL­¼ˆoª]‰,‘—;Œ“‘“H‰tˆ]ŠÚ–YªL‡kŒ“X“Xˆ]”xˆL­¼ˆoª]‰ —ŒS¨H‘“X¡‰t‡kŒ‰§‰‹‡Xˆ-“Xˆ]‘¡ ‡d¬Q’wŠ‹‘“X¡-©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨ªL‡kŒ“5“Xˆ]”‘—ª]’w“H‰‹Št‘¬X™X‰‹ˆ-‰t’¯‰‹‡Xˆ-‰t’ ‰Œ”`ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰°†‡XˆoŠtˆL©h’ Štˆw¶FŒ—‹™X¬X‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Žª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰ •ŒS¨p—t‰‹‘”£”Ÿ5Št’HŽX™Xª]ˆpŒp—t•Œ”‘”EŠtˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—tˆp¢©=‰‹‡Xˆ]Štˆpˆ]«H‘—t‰¯’ ‰t‡Xˆ]Šbˆ]«Hª]‘‰t’ Št¨·—‹‰t‘•¯™X”‘E‘“V“XˆŒŠt¬H¨#©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨ÙªL‡kŒ“X“Xˆ]”‘—S°I¹§’®ˆ]² ˆ]Š¶ ‰t‡5ˆ—‹™X•'•Œ‰‹£’“ˆL­¼ˆoª]‰'‘—0©YŒŠ-”‘ˆ]—‹—¯‘•'ŸQ’wŠt‰LŒ“H‰;‰t‡kŒ“·‰‹‡Xˆb©h’w”‘”‘’®‘“X¡'•Œ—t H‘“X¡ˆL­Fˆ]ª]G‰ U ωt‡H™X—£—“X’ ‰,ŽX‘—‹ª]™X—t—‹ˆ]ŽV‘“·ŽXˆ]‰LŒ‘”‘—-‘“ ‰t‡5£—0®<’ Št F°'†‡5ˆ'•Œ—t H‘“X¡'ˆ7­¼ˆ]ªo‰,‘—,Œ“X’w‰‹‡Xˆ]Š£“H‰‹ˆ]Šj–jªL‡kŒ“X“5ˆ]”<ˆ7­¼ˆ]ªo‰¯®‡X‘ª‡p—t‰LŒ‰‹ˆ]—¯‰t‡kŒ‰-‰t‡5ˆ¯²d‘—‹£¬5£”‘‘‰j¨’©=Œb—t‰‹‘•¯™X”‘?Œ‰-—t’ •'ˆ ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨¯ªo’w™X”‘Ž¯¬Qˆ§‘•'ŸkŒ‘Štˆ]Ž¬H¨,‰‹‡Xˆ§ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—tˆo“Xª]ˆ;’©`’ ‰t‡Xˆ]Š—t‰‹‘•¯™X”‘d‘““XˆŒŠt¬H¨©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨¯ªL‡kŒ“X“Xˆ]”‘—°“Xˆ®<ˆo”£”¢–j H“X’®“,ˆo«TŒ•'ŸX”‘ˆ ‘“,ªo’w•'Ÿ5Štˆ]—‹—tˆ]Ž¯‘•Œ¡wˆEŒŠ‹‰t¢©YŒª]‰EŒ“kŒ”£¨H—‹£—‘—‰t‡kŒ‰‰t‡Xˆ¬X”‘’HªL H£“5¡=ŒŠ‹‰t¢©YŒª]‰’©F¬X”‘’dªL  –j¬kŒ—‹ˆ]Ž,ªo’w•'Ÿ5Štˆ]—‹—t‘’w“—tªL‡Xˆ]•bˆ]—¶ ®‡X‘ªL‡,ªo’w“X—‹£—‹‰t— ’©‡X‘¡w‡H–l©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨ˆ]ŽX¡ ˆ,ªo’w•'ŸQ’w“5ˆ]“H‰t—¶Q‘—§”‘ˆ]—‹—;²d‘—‹£¬5”£ˆ;‘“‰‹‡Xˆ,‰‹ˆ]«H‰t™XŠ‹ˆ¯Štˆ]¡ ‘’w“X—S°§†‡X‘—ˆL­¼ˆoª]‰¶N‰t‡XˆoŠtˆL©h’ Štˆw¶ ªŒ“p¬kˆ²H‘ˆ]®<ˆoŽµŒ—;Œ ŠtˆoŽX™Xª]‰‹£’ “’©ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰§—‹ˆ]“X—t‘‰‹£²H‘‰j¨¯‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘ŽµŒ‰<ª]ˆoŠt‰Œ‘“—tŸkŒ‰tsŒ”Q©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]‘ˆ]—§‘“ª]ˆ]Š‹‰Œ‘“Štˆo¡w‘’w“X—S° †‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆÏŒŠtˆb—tˆ]² ˆ]ŠŒ”•Œ—‹ H£“5¡•b’HŽXˆ]”‘—-Œ—£“H² ˆ]—t‰‹£¡HŒ‰‹ˆ]Ž·¬H¨"!=”‘ˆ]‘[ “ d7fhg/iBjbU `#;ˆ]“XˆoŠŒ”‘”‘¨p—tŸQˆŒ H‘“X¡k¶‰‹‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ‘—“X’’ “Xˆ'—‹£“5¡w”‘ˆ •'’HŽXˆo”2®‡5£ªL‡pªŒ“p¬Qˆ¯™X—tˆ]Ž#‰‹’Œª]ª]’ ™X“H‰;©h’ Š×Œ”‘”2•Œ—‹ d‘“X¡¯Ÿ5‡Xˆ]“X’ •'ˆ]“kŒ5°,Õ5’wŠ;‰t‡5ˆ¯•¯™X”‘‰t‘ŸX”‘ˆL–j—tŸkŒ‰tsŒ”¢–hªL‡kŒ“X“Xˆ]”N¹§»=œ•'’HŽXˆo”Y¶FŒ‰ ”‘ˆŒ—‹‰,‰j®’²wŒŠtsŒ¬X”‘ˆ]—ŒŠtˆbŠtˆ]˜H™X‘Š‹ˆ]Ž·‰‹’µ•b’dŽ5ˆ]”E‰t‡5ˆ'•Œ—t H‘“X¡'ˆ7­¼ˆ]ªo‰°#†‡Xˆo¨·ŒŠtˆb‰t‡Xˆ©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨[—tˆ]ŸkŒŠŒ‰t‘’w“·Œ“XŽ·‰‹‡Xˆ'•Œ—t  ˆ]Š ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰°†‡5ˆŠtˆ]ŽX™5ª]‰t‘’w“b’©F—tˆ]“5—t‘‰t‘²H‘‰j¨-‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡5’w”‘Ž'‘“Xª]Š‹ˆŒ—‹ˆ]—®‡Xˆ]“¯‰t‡5ˆ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨¯—‹ˆ]ŸkŒŠŒ‰‹‘’w“¯’©F‰t‡5ˆ•Œ—‹ wˆ]ŠEŒ“XŽ¯‰t‡Xˆ—‹‘¡w“kŒ” ŽXˆ]ªoŠtˆŒ—tˆ]—S¶<Œ“5Žµ®‡Xˆo“µ‰‹‡Xˆ¯•Œ—t wˆoŠ§ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰-‘—;”sŒŠt¡ ˆ]Š;®‘‰t‡pŠtD ˆ]—‹Ÿkˆ]ªo‰,‰‹’‰‹‡Xˆ¯—t‘¡ “kŒ”ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—tS‰ ^LU V° U $_¸l©Ô®ˆqŒ—t—‹™X•'ˆ‰t‡Xˆo—tˆ¯‰j®’ ²wŒŠ‹sŒ¬X”‘ˆ]—ŒŠ‹ˆ=—‹ˆ]ŸkŒŠŒ¬5”£ˆ ¶k‰‹‡Xˆ]“‰t‡5ˆ-“Xˆ]®Wª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰§‰‹‡XŠtˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Ž  ŒS©l‰tˆ]Š•Œ—t H‘“X¡-‘— D D D D % & @ @ R W ž,+ @ š- @ R W ž R š 3š Hž E   W @(' ^*)

®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ

D

)

Œ“5Ž

D

@š @R Wž E

D

D

¢© D @
 W D W  ^ š @ K W ž U ¢ © @   W W T

D

D

šM ž

 šY@aK  ž  ¢© Y@  + @Lš-Y@GR W ž š ž E   ` š  @ K  W ž k ¢©  @   W $ W W D D D Œ“5Ž'®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ  ‘—<‰‹‡Xˆ;’wŠ‹£¡ ‘“kŒ”Xªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰‰‹‡XŠtˆo—t‡X’ ”£ŽN¶ ‘—‰t‡Xˆ;ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰’©2‰t‡5ˆ§—t‘¡ “kŒ”j¶ @2‘—‰t‡Xˆ;ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰’©`‰t‡Xˆ;•Œ—t  ˆ]ŠE‘“ ‰t‡5ˆs‰‹‡'ªL‡kŒ“5“Xˆ]W ”j¶  W Œ“XŽ Y@2ŒŠtˆ‰t‡Xˆ—‹ŸkŒ‰‹ Œ”H©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]‘ˆ]—W ’©¼‰‹‡Xˆ—t‘¡ “kŒ”XªL‡kŒ“X“Xˆ]”FŒ“5Ž¯‰t‡Xˆ –Y‰‹‡'•Œ—t H‘“X¡ªL‡kŒ“X“Xˆ]”j¶ Štˆ]—‹Ÿkˆ]ªo‰t‘²wˆ]”‘¨H° ’w‰t‡‰t‡Xˆ-—‹ˆ]ŸkŒŠŒ¬5£”‘‘‰j¨'Œ—‹—t™X•bŸX‰t‘’ “'’©§5š dž§Œ“XŽŸkŒŠLŒ•bˆ]‰tˆ]Š‹ —  W ‰t‡XŠ‹’w™X¡  ‡  $ ®£”‘”F¬Qˆ-ˆ]«XŒ•b‘“Xˆ]ŽŒ“XŽŽXˆ]‰‹ˆ]Št•b£“5ˆ]Ž‘“œHˆ]ª]‰‹£’ “ k° ß5° EÊxÊ ‚J !
'&2( " &*)M+ ' # 2!#"/

†‡Xˆ-—‹™X¬X‰‹‡XŠtˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Ž—‹‰t‘•¯™X”‘j¶wj° ˆw°—‹‰t‘•¯™X”‘k®‘‰‹‡ÏŒªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰”‘’®<ˆ]Š‰‹‡kŒ“‰‹‡Xˆ-‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Ž`¶QªŒ“X“X’w‰¬Qˆ-—‹ˆ]“X—tˆoŽµ¬H¨'‡H™X•Œ“b¬kˆ]‘“X¡ —° †‡Xˆ—t™XŸXŠLŒ‰‹‡XŠtˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Žª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰£—’©`ªo’w“Xª]ˆoŠt“‘“¯‰t‡Xˆ;‘•Œ¡wˆEŸQˆ]Štªoˆ]ŸX‰t‘’ “Š‹ˆ]—tˆSŒŠtªL‡`°Ñ—<‰‹‡Xˆ§—‹™XŸXŠŒ‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡5’w”‘Žª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰¬kˆ]ªo’w•'ˆo— ”sŒŠ‹¡wˆ]ŠS¶F‰t‡Xˆˆ]˜H™kŒ”Ò–jŠtˆo—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ¯ª]™XŠt² ˆ,•b’wŠ‹ŸX‡X—©lŠt’w• ‰‹‡Xˆ£“H² ˆ]Št—‹ˆL–  —t‡kŒŸkˆ“XˆŒŠ=‰‹‡Xˆ‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡X’ ”‘Ž`¶2Œ—§—‹‡X’®“µ‘“µÕN‘¡k° T ¶k‰‹’ Œ ¼Œ‰ ‡X’ Št‘º]’w“H‰LŒ”Q”£‘“Xˆ;Œ‰E‡5£¡ ‡'ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰”‘ˆ]²wˆ]”‘—S°¸j“'’w‰‹‡Xˆ]Š®’wŠ‹ŽX—¶XŒ‰E‡X‘¡w‡b—t™XŸXŠLŒ‰‹‡XŠtˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Žª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰”‘ˆ]²wˆo”£—S¶w‰‹‡Xˆ;²H£—‹™kŒ”QŠtˆo—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ]—§‰‹’ Œ”‘”F—‹ŸkŒ‰‹ Œ”Q©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]‘ˆ]—¬kˆ]ªo’w•'ˆo—§ŒŸXŸXŠ‹’«H£•Œ‰‹ˆ]”‘¨,‰‹‡Xˆ;—Œ•bˆw_° ^  œH‘“Xª]ˆp²H£—‹™kŒ”Štˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—tˆo—µ‰‹’#‰t‡Xˆp—t™XŸ5ŠŒ‰‹‡XŠtˆo—t‡X’ ”£Ž ªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰b‘“d² ’w”‘²wˆo—'‡H™X•Œ“·—‹™X¬w±Lˆ]ª]‰‹‘²wˆpŠŒ‰‹‘“X¡k¶‘‰b£—bŽX¢½'ª]™X”‘‰¯‰t’[™X—tˆ ŸX—‹¨dªL‡X’ ŸX‡H¨H—t‘ªŒ”Q•'ˆo‰t‡X’HŽX—E‰‹’,•bˆŒ—‹™XŠtˆ‘‰S°`¹’®<ˆ]² ˆ]Š¶Hˆo²wˆ]“b‰t‡X’ ™X¡w‡b£‰x£—xŽX¢½'ª]™X”‘‰E‰t’׳k“XŽŒ×ŸXŠtˆ]ªo£—‹ˆ©h’wŠ‹•¯™X”sŒ©h’ ŠE‘‰t—•'’HŽXˆ]”‘‘“X¡k¶ ‘‰<‘—¡wˆ]“5ˆ]ŠŒ”£”‘¨¯Œ¡ Štˆ]ˆ]Ž‰‹‡kŒ‰‰t‡Xˆ;ˆ]—‹‰t‘•Œ‰tˆ]ŽbŠtˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—t ˆ I‘—Œ;©h™5“Xª]‰t‘’ “'’©`‰‹‡Xˆ;—tŸkŒ‰tsŒ”5©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨Œ“XŽ©h’w”‘”‘’®—<Œ0Ÿk’®ˆ]Š”sŒS® U  D

D

š" ž  ž!
R ®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ £—‰t‡Xˆ—t™5ŸXŠŒ‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡X’ ”‘Ž#ª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰¶  £—‰t‡Xˆª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰;‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡5’w”‘ŽµŒ‰;‰‹‡Xˆ-—tŸQˆ]ª]¢³kª©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨d¶NŒ“XŽ‰‹‡Xˆˆ]«HŸk’ “Xˆ]“H‰  ²wŒŠ‹‘ˆ]—<¬Qˆ]‰j®ˆ]ˆ]“ c$# qŒ“XŽc$#  ßX°¯Ñ²wŒ”‘™Xˆ’©0c$# '-‘—™X—tˆoŽ‘“b‰t‡X‘—®’wŠt F° £—Œ—tªSŒ”‘‘“X¡,’ Š<“5’wŠt•Œ”‘‘ºŒ‰‹‘’w“0©YŒª]‰‹’wŠŒ“XŽ‘——tˆ]‰ ‰t’%T ° D

D

 E  š

H

EÊ&%Ê Î 1M2( ' 15!#)'J2()( ( 2( '(

ˆ]—t‘ŽXˆ]—¯—‹ŸkŒ‰‹sŒ””£’HªŒ‰t‘’w“5—׌“XŽ·—‹ŸkŒ‰‹sŒ”©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo£ˆo—¶¹§»;œ#Œ”‘—t’Š‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“5ŽX—¯ŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“H‰t”‘¨#‰‹’²wŒŠ‹£’ ™X—-’ Št‘ˆ]“H‰Œ‰t‘’w“X—0’©§—t‰‹‘•¯™X”‘Y° ÛŒ•bŸX¬Qˆ]”‘” dYf#g$iQjs¶ $Ž5ˆ]•'’ “X—t‰‹ŠŒ‰‹ˆ]Ž¯ŸX—‹¨dªL‡X’ ŸX‡H¨H—t‘ªŒ”‘”‘¨-‰‹‡kŒ‰E¹»=œ‘—•'’ —t‰—tˆ]“5—t‘‰t‘²wˆ‰‹’;—t‰t‘•¯™X”‘ £“¯‰‹‡Xˆ²wˆoŠt‰t‘ªŒ”kŒ“5Ž¯‡X’wŠ‹£ºo’w“H‰Œ” ŽX‘Štˆoª]‰t‘’w“5—¶FŒ“XŽ”‘ˆŒ—t‰—tˆo“X—t‘‰t‘² ˆ-‰t’b—t‰t‘•¯™X”‘X‘“‰t‡5I ˆ  +*-Œ“X

Ž TSà ,*׎X‘Štˆ]ª]‰‹‘’w“X—S°Ô֐¢­Fˆ]Štˆ]“H‰´©hŠt’ •Ü—‹ŸkŒ‰‹ Œ”Q©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨—‹ˆ]”‘ˆ]ª]‰‹£²H‘‰j¨H¶ ‰t‡5ˆ¯¬kŒ“XŽ5®£Ž5‰t‡p’©<’ Št‘ˆ]“H‰Œ‰t‘’w“kŒ”—tˆ]”‘ˆ]ª]‰‹‘²d‘‰j¨p²wŒŠ‹£ˆo—=ªo’w“X—‹£Ž5ˆ]ŠŒ¬X”‘¨©hŠt’ • ª]ˆo”£”x‰t’ª]ˆ]”‘”j°¯Û’wŠt‰‹‘ªŒ”ª]ˆ]”‘”‘—;©hŠ‹’w•Ý©h’² ˆŒ”EŒ“XŽµ“5ˆŒŠ “X’ “H©h’²wˆSŒ”Qª]’wŠ‹‰t‘ªŒ”NŠtˆ]¡ ‘’w“X—‡kŒS² ˆ=Œ®‘ŽXˆŠŒ“5¡wˆ;’©’wŠt‘ˆ]“H‰LŒ‰t‘’ “'¬kŒ“XŽX®‘ŽX‰t‡b©hŠ‹’w• TYc-‰‹’,’² ˆ]I Š T-2c-Ž5ˆ]¡wŠ‹ˆ]ˆ]—¶Q®‘‰t‡b‰t‡Xˆ0•'ˆ]ŽXsŒ“ ¬kŒ“XŽX®‘ŽX‰t‡¯¬Qˆ]‘“X¡,Œ¬k’ ™X‰ ',*_° ^]`¤‡5£”‘”‘‘ŸX—EŒ“XŽ¾I‘”‘—t’ “ U™X—tˆ]Ž¯•Œ—‹ d‘“X¡ˆ]«HŸkˆoŠt‘•'ˆ]“H‰‹—<‰‹’-—t‡X’®V‰‹‡kŒ‰E’ Št‘ˆ]“H‰Œ‰t‘’w“¬kŒ“XŽX®‘ŽX‰t‡5— ŒŠ‹ˆ§²wŒŠt¨H‘“X¡©hŠt’ • Œ¬k’ ™X/ ‰ .=2à c,*Œ‰ c5° ת]ŸkŽb‰t' ’ .TY,*;Œ‰ T2Tw° à;ª]ŸQŽ`° ’w‰‹‡'Štˆo—t™X”‘‰t—Œ“5Ž'‰t‡5ˆ©YŒª]‰E‰t‡QŒ‰¹§»=œ‘—E”‘ˆŒ—‹‰<—‹ˆ]“X—t‘‰‹£² ˆ§‰‹’ ‰t‡5I ˆ  +*-Œ“X

Ž TSà ,*’ Št‘ˆ]“H‰Œ‰t‘’w“X—ˆo“Xª]’w™5ŠŒ¡ ˆ-‰t‡5ˆ-™X—tˆ0’©³k”‘‰tˆ]Š‹—§‘“¯©l’w™XŠŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆo“d‰’wŠ‹£ˆo“d‰LŒ‰‹£’ “X—  c,* '¶  +*w1¶ 0 c,*¶kŒ“5Ž TSà +*w°x†‡Xˆ ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰§—‹ˆ]“X—‹£‰‹‘²d‘‰j¨©h™5“Xª]‰t‘’ “‘“b‰t‡Xˆ-’ ¬X”‘‘˜d™5ˆ§ŽX‘Štˆoª]‰t‘’w“5—§Œ”‘—t’¯‰LŒ wˆo—‰t‡Xˆ©h’ Št•Ý—t‘•'‘”sŒŠ‰t’šlàwž®‘‰t‡bŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“H‰§ŸQŒŠŒ•'ˆ]‰‹ˆ]Št—S° xÊ €

Ì 32

2܀   ƒ54]€[‚,Î76ÏÐ#€

Ë ƒ 

EÊlÉÊ ‚8 !'(149(X2(;:<*(  6 )5  !#)M1>= !
 15



€[‚?Ð#„

8F‘•b£‰‹ˆ]Ž¬H¨‰‹‡Xˆ]‘Š,—‹ŸkŒ‰‹sŒ””‘’dªSŒ‰t‘’ “µ’ “#‰t‡Xˆ¯Š‹ˆ]‰t‘“kŒ5¶`ŸX‡5’w‰t’ Štˆ]ªoˆ]ŸX‰t’ Št—¯ªŒ“#’w“X”‘¨©l’dªo™X—-’w“#‰‹‡Xˆ]‘Š-’®“pª]ˆ]Š‹‰Œ‘“#Š‹ˆ]¡w‘’w“5—-’©‰t‡Xˆ H² ‘—t™kŒ”³kˆ]”‘Ž`°V†‡Xˆªo’wŠt‰‹‘ªŒ”ª]ˆo”£”‘—bŸk’H’w”‰‹‡XˆŠ‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ’©,Œ”£”ŸX‡X’ ‰t’ Štˆ]ª]ˆoŸX‰t’ Št—b©h’Hª]™X—‹ˆ]ŽI’w“V‰‹‡Xˆ—Œ•bˆ'Š‹ˆ]‰t‘“kŒ”§”‘’HªŒ‰‹£’ “ÙŒ“XŽ ©h’ Št•Ý’w“Xˆ-ªL‡kŒ“X“Xˆ]”j°†‡5ˆ]Štˆ¯ŒŠ‹ˆ,“H™X•bˆ]ŠŒ”Fª‡QŒ“X“Xˆo”£—‰t™X“5ˆ]Žµ‘“‰t‡5ˆ,—LŒ•'ˆ;—‹ŸkŒ‰‹ Œ”F©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨¬kŒ“5Ž`¶X—LŒS¨d¶Q߯ª]¨Hª]”‘ˆ]—9?ŽXˆ]¡ Štˆ]ˆ ¶`¬X™5‰ ©h’Hª]™X—‹ˆ]Žp’w“pŽX¢­¼ˆ]Š‹ˆ]“H‰;”£’HªŒ‰t‘’w“5—§‘“‰t‡5ˆ,Š‹ˆ]ª]ˆ]ŸX‰‹‘²wˆ³kˆ]”‘Ž`°;†‡5ˆ]ŠtˆL©l’wŠtˆ ¶`‰‹‡Xˆ-©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨µŠ‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“5—tˆ¯’©²d‘—‹™kŒ”—t‰‹‘•¯™X”‘F£—“X’w‰;’ “X”‘¨ ¬kŒ“XŽH–j”£‘•b£‰‹ˆ]Ž‘“µ‰‹‡Xˆ¯©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨#ŽX’w•Œ‘“¬X™X‰,Œ”£—‹’—tŸkŒª]ˆL–j”£’HªŒ”‘£ºoˆ]Ž#‘“µ‰‹‡Xˆ'—‹ŸkŒ‰‹ Œ”ŽX’w•Œ‘“`°¯ÕX’ Š;ˆ]«XŒ•'Ÿ5”£ˆ ¶k‰‹‡Xˆ¯©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨ Štˆo—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ=’©`‰t‡Xˆ´³k«XŒ‰‹£’ “¯Ÿk’ ‘“d‰x£—xª‡QŒŠŒª]‰tˆoŠt‘º]ˆ]Ž¬H¨,‰‹‡Xˆ§‰j¨HŸX‘ªŒ”kªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Ž¯©l™X“Xª]‰‹£’ “'Œ——t‡X’®“¯‘“'ÕN‘¡k° T ¶w¬5™X‰E©lŠt’w• ‰t‡5ˆ§—tŸQŒ‰tsŒ”X‘“X‡X’w•b’w¡ ˆ]“Xˆ]‘‰j¨ ^LkEŸX‡5ˆ]“X’w•bˆ]“X’ “`¶‰t‡5ˆ§‡X‘¡w‡©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨¯Štˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—tˆ;®‘”‘”H©h™XŠ‹‰t‡XˆoŠ§Œ‰t‰‹ˆ]“H™kŒ‰‹ˆ=Œ—E‰t‡Xˆˆ]ª]ª]ˆo“d‰‹Št‘ª]‘‰j¨¯©lŠt’w• ‰t‡5ˆ©h’HªŒ”XŸk’ ‘“d‰x£“5ª]ŠtˆŒ—tˆ]—S°E†‡X‘—E•bˆŒ“5—2‰‹‡kŒ‰xŠtˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—tˆ]—;Œ‰E‰‹‡Xˆ§—LŒ•bˆ=š ‡X‘¡w‡kž—‹ŸkŒ‰‹sŒ”H©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨¯£“¯Ž5Ò­Fˆ]Š‹ˆ]“H‰<”‘’HªŒ‰‹‘’w“X—E‘“‰t‡Xˆ Štˆoª]ˆ]ŸX‰‹£² ˆ-³Qˆ]”‘ŽµŒŠ‹ˆ-¡w’² ˆ]Št“XˆoŽ¬H¨Ž5Ò­Fˆ]Š‹ˆ]“H‰§ªL‡kŒ“5“Xˆ]”‘—¶Q‰t‡H™X—ŸXŠt’²H‘ŽX‘“X¡'Œ“ˆo²d‘ŽXˆo“Xª]ˆ‰t‡kŒ‰§‰t‡5ˆ-²H£—‹™kŒ”NªL‡kŒ“X“5ˆ]”‘—׌Štˆ-“QŒŠtŠ‹’®”‘¨ ‰t™5“Xˆ]Ž‘“'—‹Ÿkˆoª]¢³kª-—tŸQŒ‰tsŒ”F”£’HªŒ‰t‘’w“5—°

†‡Xˆª]’w•b•'’w“5”Ò¨™X—tˆ]Ž#Õ5’w™XŠ‹£ˆoŠ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨pŒ“kŒ”£¨H—‹£—‘—¶X‡5’®<ˆ]² ˆ]Š¶NŒ¡w”‘’w¬kŒ”`ŸXŠ‹’Hª]ˆ]—t—0®‡X‘ª‡¡w‘²wˆ]—§Œ”‘”`—tŸQŒ‰tsŒ”`ª]’ •'ŸQ’w“Xˆ]“H‰‹— ‰t‡5ˆ§—Œ•'ˆ®ˆ]‘¡w‡H‰t‘“X¡Q°`¸j‰x£—®ˆ]”‘”k H“X’®“'Œ—<¹ˆ]‘—tˆ]“H¬Qˆ]Št¡ C —™5“Xª]ˆ]Š‹‰Œ‘“H‰j¨¯ŸXŠ‹£“5ª]‘ŸX”‘ˆ§‰t‡QŒ‰E‰‹‡Xˆ;ˆ]«XŒª]‰”‘’dªSŒ”‘‘ºŒ‰‹£’ “,‘“¯¬Q’w‰‹‡'—tŸQŒ‰tsŒ” Œ“5Ž-©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨¯ŽX’w•Œ‘“X—`ªSŒ“X“X’ ‰E¬Qˆ§ŒªL‡X‘ˆ]²wˆoŽ¯—t‘•¯™X”‘‰Œ“Xˆ]’w™5—t”‘¨F° UGU;†‡5ˆ #-Œ¬Q’wŠ‰tŠLŒ“X—Ú©h’wŠ‹•µ¶_^ $E®‡5£ªL‡‘—<Œ #-Œ™X—‹—tsŒ“T–Y®‘“XŽX’®ˆ]Ž Õ5’w™XŠ‹£ˆoŠ=‰‹ŠŒ“X—j©h’ Št•p¶F®ÔŒ—;ŸXŠt’² ˆ]Ž#‰t’ŒªL‡X‘ˆ]² ˆ¯‰t‡Xˆ¯”‘‘•'‘‰’©<‰t‡Xˆ¯¹ˆ]‘—tˆ]“H¬Qˆ]Št¡p‘“Xˆ]˜H™kŒ”£‘‰j¨H° #-Œ¬k’ Š;¡wŠŒ‰t‘“X¡ —=®ˆ]Š‹ˆ'‰t‡H™X—0®£Ž5ˆ]”‘¨ ™X—‹ˆ]Žµ‘“•b’HŽXˆ]Št“ŸX—‹¨Hª‡5’wŸX‡H¨H—t‘ªŒ”Eˆ]«HŸkˆoŠt‘•'ˆ]“H‰‹—°;¤2ŒŠŒ•'ˆ]‰‹ˆ]Št—’©<‰‹‡Xˆ #0Œ™X—‹—tsŒ“®‘“XŽX’® ®ˆ]ŠtˆªL‡X’w—‹ˆ]“#Œ‰§Š‹ˆ]—tˆSŒŠtªL‡XˆoŠt7— CŸ5ŠtˆL©s– ˆ]Š‹ˆ]“Xª]ˆ]—S¶`Œ“5Ž²wŒŠt‘’w™5—<ŽXˆo¡wŠtˆoˆ]—;’©2”‘’HªŒ”£‘ºŒ‰t‘’w“¯®ˆ]Š‹ˆ,ŒªL‡X‘ˆ]² ˆ]Ž`V° U, †‡QŒ‰‘—¶H¬H¨'²wŒŠt¨H‘“X¡‰t‡Xˆ #0Œ™X—‹—tsŒ“bˆ]“H²wˆ]”‘’wŸQˆ;ŸkŒŠLŒ•bˆ]‰tˆ]Š‹—¶ ‰t‡5ˆ'ŸkŒ—t—t¬QŒ“XŽX—’© #-Œ¬k’ Š-¡wŠLŒ‰t‘“X¡ —-®ˆ]Štˆb’²wˆ]Š‹” ŒŸXŸQˆ]Ž#‰t’µŒÏŽX¢­¼ˆ]Š‹ˆ]“H‰¯ˆ]«H‰tˆ]“H‰S°†‡Xˆ]ŠtˆŒŠtˆ¯—t’ •'ˆ¯”‘‘•'‘‰Œ‰t‘’“X—£“#‰‹‡Xˆ#-Œ¬k’ Š ŠtˆoŸXŠtˆ]—‹ˆ]“H‰Œ‰t‘’w“`°pÕN£Š‹—t‰S¶£‰0£—0ŽX¢½'ª]™X”‘‰;‰t’µŒ“kŒ”‘¨Hº]ˆ¯‰t‡5ˆ'—t‰‹‘•¯™X”‘2®‡5’w—tˆ©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨#Š‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ]—©YŒ”£”x£“#‰‹‡Xˆ¯’²wˆoŠt”sŒŸXŸQˆ]Ž[¬kŒ“XŽN° œHˆ]ªo’w“XŽ`¶—‹£“5ª]ˆ‰t‡5ˆ #0Œ¬Q’wŠ0³k”‘‰tˆ]Š¯‘—'Œ“[¸t¸t¦Øšs‘“H³k“5£‰‹ˆ£•bŸX™X”‘—tˆ¯Š‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“5—tˆž³k”‘‰tˆoŠ¶‰tŠ‹™X“XªŒ‰t‘’w“[£—¯—‹‰t‘”‘”“Xˆ]ˆ]Ž5ˆ]ŽV©h’ Š,ŸXŠLŒª]‰‹‘ªŒ” ‘•'ŸX”‘ˆ]•bˆ]“H‰Œ‰t‘’“`°Q†‡H™X—¶5‰t‡Xˆ-”‘’HªŒ”£‘ºŒ‰t‘’w“¯‘—“X’ ‰E©l™X”‘”£¨¯ˆo“X—t™XŠ‹ˆ]Ž#ŒS©h‰‹ˆ]Š‰tŠ‹™X“XªŒ‰t‘’w“`° EÊ3xÊ …  !#"$ '

 */!
 15 0"21]
'&(  !
!# ! 4(
)3( 

†‡Xˆ;•Œo±L’wŠEŽ5Ò½'ªo™X”‘‰j¨¯’©2¹»=œb•'’HŽXˆo”£‘“X¡Q¶‰t‡5’w™X¡ ‡'’©l‰tˆ]““Xˆ]¡ ”‘ˆ]ª]‰tˆoŽ¬H¨'Štˆo—tˆŒŠtªL‡Xˆ]Š‹—¶F‘—’w“‰t‡Xˆ;ª]’ •'ŸX™5‰Œ‰‹‘’w“¯’©‰t‡Xˆ;ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰ ‘“µªo’w•'Ÿ5”£ˆo«‘•Œ¡ ˆ]—°›‘ªL‡Xˆ]”‘—t’ #“ C —-ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰,Ž5ˆL³k“Xˆ]Ž#‘“Iš Tž‘—-¬kŒ—‹ˆ]Ž#’w“#‰‹‡Xˆ¯—t‰LŒ‘ŠtªSŒ—tˆbŸkŒ‰‹‰tˆ]Š‹“#®‡X‘ªL‡#‡kŒ—;ŽX‘—t‰‹‘“Xª]‰9:F;G= Œ“5Ž 9:J@BA`°¯¸j“pŸX—t¨HªL‡X’ ŸX‡H¨d—‹‘ªŒ”ˆ]«HŸkˆoŠt‘•'ˆ]“H‰‹—=®‘‰‹‡µ—‹£“H™X—‹’w‘ŽkŒ”E¡wŠLŒ‰t‘“X¡ —¶F‰‹‡Xˆ¯—t‰‹‘•¯™X”‘2Œ”‘—‹’'‡kŒS² ˆ¯™X“X‘˜H™Xˆ,ŸQˆŒ Ùš •Œ«H‘•™X•'ž Œ“5Ž‰‹Št’ ™X¡w‡#šs•b‘“X‘•,™X•'žN”‘™X•b£“QŒ“Xª]ˆo—°F¸j“#-Œ¬k’ Šˆ]«HŸkˆ]Š‹‘•'ˆ]“H‰t—S¶H’w“‰t‡5ˆ-’w‰‹‡Xˆ]Š‡kŒ“XŽ`¶X‰‹‡Xˆ;ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰§‘—ŽXˆL³k“XˆoŽµŒ‰‰‹‡Xˆ-”sŒŠ‹¡wˆ]—‹‰ Št‘ŸXŸ5”£ˆ ¶w®‡X‘ªL‡¯‘—”£’HªŒ‰tˆ]ŽŒ‰‰t‡5ˆ©h’HªŒ”XŸk’ ‘“d‰S°2Õ5’wŠx“kŒ‰‹™XŠŒ”X‘•Œ¡ ˆ]—¶S‡X’®ˆ]² ˆ]Š¶H‘‰‘—Eˆ]«H‰tŠ‹ˆ]•'ˆ]”‘¨ŽX¢½'ª]™X”‘‰‰t’-Ž5ˆL³k“Xˆ‰t‡Xˆª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰ —t‘“Xªoˆ¯‰t‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ'‘—;“X’™X“X‘˜H™Xˆ¯’wŠ;’ ¬d²H‘’w™5—§•Œ«H£•¯™5•ÜŒ“XŽp•'‘“X‘•™X• ”‘™X•b£“QŒ“Xª]ˆ0²wŒ”‘™Xˆ]—;‰t’¬Qˆ¯Štˆ]ªo’wŠtŽ5ˆ]Ž`°ÕX’ Š=ˆo«TŒ•'ŸX”‘ˆw¶5©h’ Š-Œ ’w“5ˆL–YŽ5£•bˆ]“X—‹£’ “kŒ”Q¡wŠLŒ‰‹£“5¡,ª]’ •'ŸQ’w—‹ˆ]Ž'’©?‰j®’—t‘“H™X—t’ £ŽQŒ”F®ŒS²wˆL©h’ Št•b—E®‘‰t‡'Ž5Ò­Fˆ]Š‹ˆ]“H‰©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]‘ˆ]G— UGk  Nš R ž E W š TN  ^ ª]’ —2š ^ Q
ž N U ª]’w—š U Qžj#ž R š - ž ®‡Xˆ]Š‹ ˆ T  <ß5°`†‡Xˆ¡ ŠŒ‰t‘“X¡;‘—E—t‡X’®“‘“qÕN‘¡k° ßX°N¾#ˆ<—‹ˆ]ˆ§‰‹‡kŒ‰EŒ‰xŸk’ £“H‰ÑV®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ§‰t‡5ˆ—t”‘’®–Y²wŒŠt¨H‘“X¡§®ŒS²wˆ7©h’wŠ‹ •  ^ ª]’w—š ^ Qž ‘—<Œ‰‘‰t—•'‘“X‘•™X•Þ”‘™X•b‘“kŒ“Xªoˆw¶‰t‡5ˆ§ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰‘—<ŒŸ5ŸXŠt’«H‘•Œ‰tˆ]”‘¨;ˆ]˜H™kŒ”Q‰t ’  U K5Lš TH ^ ž]¶H®‡X‘”‘ˆ§Œ‰Ÿk’ ‘“d‰ Ù®‡5ˆ]Št ˆ  ª]’w—š Qž ‘—-Œ‰§‘‰‹—=•Œ«H‘•ŒH¶H‰‹‡Xˆ¯ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰;£—-Œ¬k’ ™X ‰  U KXLš TFN ^ žo°-†‡XˆoŠtˆL©h’ Štˆw¶N‰t‡5ˆ¯ª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰=’©<‰t‡5£—;¡ ŠŒ‰‹‘“X¡'‘—;ŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“H‰-ˆ]^² ˆ]Št¨H®‡X^ˆoŠtˆ Œ”‘’ “X¡,‰‹‡X ˆ H–jŽX‘Štˆoª]‰t‘’w“N¶XŒ“XŽŒ¡w’H’HŽ'Ž5ˆL³k“X‘‰t‘’ “’©2ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰—t‡X’ ™X”‘Ž'¬Qˆ,Œ¬X”‘ˆ‰t’¯‡kŒ“XŽX”‘ˆ;—t™XªL‡ªŒ—‹ˆ]—°

B

A


- ÄÀ ,Û’w•bŸk’ —t‘‰tˆ¡ ŠŒ‰‹‘“X¡,ˆo«TŒ•'ŸX”‘ˆ´©h’wŠª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰§ª]’ •'ŸX™5‰Œ‰‹‘’w“`° œH‘“Xª]ˆpLš Tž×£—0ŽXˆL³k“XˆoŽÙŒ—0‰t‡Xˆ¯ŠLŒ‰t‘’’©Ô‰‹‡Xˆ'”‘™X•b‘“kŒ“Xªoˆ-ŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“XªoˆÏŒ“XŽ#‰t‡5ˆ¯¬kŒªL H¡wŠ‹’w™X“XŽ·ŒŽkŒŸ5‰Œ‰‹‘’w“p”£ˆo²wˆ]”j¶N¬k’ ‰t‡#²wŒ”‘™Xˆo— —t‡5’w™X”‘Ž'¬Qˆ;’w¬X‰LŒ‘“Xˆ]Ž¢©`’w“5ˆ=®‘—‹‡Xˆ]—‰t’¯Ž5ˆ]²H£—‹ˆ-Œ-¡ ’d’HŽbŽXˆL³k“X‘‰‹£’ “’©`ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰§‘“bª]’w•bŸX”‘ˆ]«,‘•Œ¡wˆo—°F¹ˆ]—t—d7fJg/iBj U ^ ŽXˆL³Q“Xˆ]Ž‰t‡Xˆ D ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰=Œ‰<‰‹‡X' ˆ  –Y‰‹‡—tŸkŒ‰tsŒ”Q©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨¬QŒ“XŽŒ— D  D @ @ E š 0 ž  D D ®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ  @ ‘—§‰‹‡Xˆ;³k”‘‰tˆoŠtˆ]ŽpѧÛWª]’HˆL½'ª]‘ˆ]“H‰-Œ‰‰‹‡kŒ‰—tŸQˆ]ª]¢³kª0©hŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆo“Xª]¨¬kŒ“XŽ`¶FŒ“5 Ž  £—‰t‡Xˆ¯Ö;Û š º]ˆ]Š‹’–l©hŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆo“Xª]¨Xž;²wŒ”‘™Xˆ ° †‡Xˆ'Ö;Û ²wŒ”‘™Xˆ,‘—;ª]’ •'ŸX™X‰‹ˆ]Ž©hŠt’ • ‰t‡5ˆ¯®‡X’w”‘ˆ£•Œ¡ ˆw¶Q’w“XˆL–j˜H™kŒŠ‹‰tˆ]ŠS¶`’ Š-’w“5ˆL–Y—‹‘«d‰‹ˆ]ˆ]“#—‹™X¬X‘•Œ¡wˆ]—S°,†‡5ˆ]ŠtˆL©l’wŠtˆ ¶‰t‡X‘—;²wŒ”‘™Xˆ‘— ŸXŠ‹ˆL–YŽ5ˆ]‰tˆ]Š‹•'‘“Xˆ]ŽŒ“XŽ¯“X’w‰ŒŽQŒŸX‰‹£² ˆ§‰‹’,•b’dŽ5ˆ]”X‰t‡5ˆ=ªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰§Œ‰EŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆ]“H‰Š‹ˆ]—t’ ”£™5‰t‘’w“X—®‘‰‹‡¯‰t‡Xˆ]‘ŠŠ‹ˆ]—tŸQˆ]ª]‰‹£² ˆ-—tŸQŒª]ˆL–l©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨ ”‘’HªŒ”‘‘ºŒ‰‹‘’w“`°`¤Nˆ]”‘3 UGk™X—tˆ]Ž”£’HªŒ”‘£ºoˆ]Ž'ª]’ —t‘“Xˆ-”‘’ ¡-³k”‘‰‹ˆ]Št—‰‹’¯ŽXˆL³k“Xˆ0D‰t‡Xˆ;ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰=Œ‰‰t‡Xˆ  –Y‰‹‡—tŸkŒ‰tsŒ”Q©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨¬kŒ“5ŽŒ— D

 @ D @ E  @   ' ^  @ W

š T7c ž

†‡XˆŽXˆ]“X’ •'‘“kŒ‰t’wŠ—‹™X•'—Štˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—tˆo—-©hŠ‹’w• Œ”£”N©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo£ˆo—-”‘’®<ˆ]Š;‰‹‡kŒ“‰‹‡Xˆ¯‰ŒŠt¡ ˆ]‰©hŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆo“Xª]¨p¬kŒ“XŽN°;¸j‰=‡QŒ—;¡w’H’HŽµŒŽQŒŸX‰‹£² ˆ ŸXŠ‹’wŸQˆ]Št‰j¨—t‘“Xªoˆ=‰‹‡Xˆ;³k”‘‰‹ˆ]Št—;ŒŠtˆ;®ˆ]”‘”¢–Y”‘’HªŒ”‘‘º]ˆ]ŽŒ“XŽbŸkˆoŠj©hˆ]ªo‰t”‘¨Štˆ]ª]’ “X—t‰‹Št™Xªo‰t‘²wˆw° <’ ‰t‡I’©=‰‹‡XˆµŒ¬Q’²wˆŒŸXŸXŠt’HŒªL‡Xˆ]—¯—‹™X¡w¡ ˆ]—t‰‹ˆ]ŽW‰t‡kŒ‰¯‰t‡Xˆ¬QŒªL H¡wŠt’ ™X“XŽIŒŽQŒŸX‰LŒ‰t‘’ “·”‘ˆ]²wˆo”ªŒ“I¬Qˆ—t‘•¯™X”sŒ‰‹ˆ]Ž·¬H¨#‰‹‡Xˆ”‘’®– ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨WŠtˆo—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆw¶;—t‘“Xª]ˆp‘‰'Š‹ˆ]ŸXŠtˆo—tˆ]“H‰t—p•'’ Štˆ¡ ”‘’w¬kŒ”²wŒŠtsŒ‰t‘’w“`° §“W‰t‡5ˆµ’ ‰t‡Xˆ]Š‡kŒ“XŽ`¶‰‹‡Xˆp‡X‘¡w‡H–l©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨IŠ‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“5—tˆ Œªo‰t—¯•'’ Štˆ¯”‘‘ wˆŒŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆo“d‰‹sŒ”’wŸQˆ]ŠLŒ‰t’ Š°#†‡5ˆŽ5£—LŒŽX²wŒ“H‰Œ¡ ˆ'’©§‰t‡Xˆ]—‹ˆµŒŸ5ŸXŠt’HŒªL‡Xˆ]—S¶<‡5’®<ˆ]² ˆ]Š¶x‘—,‰‹‡kŒ‰‰t‡Xˆ•Œ‰t‡5ˆ]•Œ‰t‘ªŒ” ©h’ Št•¯™X”sŒ‰‹‘’w“‰t’¯—t‡5’® £‰‹—ª]’w‡5ˆ]Štˆ]“5ª]ˆ¯‰t’¯‰‹‡Xˆ-ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰§Ž5ˆL³k“X‘‰t‘’ “‘—™X“QŒS²wŒ‘”sŒ¬X”‘ˆw°N¸j“‰t‡5ˆ;©h’w”‘”‘’®‘“X¡k¶®<ˆ;—t‡5’® ‰t‡kŒ‰‰t‡Xˆ-¹;ŒwŒŠ ®ŒS²wˆ]”‘ˆ]‰ŸXŠ‹’²H£Ž5ˆ=Œ¡w’H’HŽ'‰‹’H’w”F©l’wŠ‰t‡kŒ‰©h’wŠ‹•¯™X”sŒ‰t‘’ “`° †‡Xˆ§®ŒS²wˆo”£ˆo‰E‰tŠLŒ“X—Ú©h’wŠ‹• Ÿ5Št’²H‘ŽXˆ]—Œ;¡w’H’HŽ¯—tŸkŒª]ˆL–l©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨b”£’HªŒ”‘£ºSŒ‰t‘’ “,ŸXŠ‹’wŸQˆ]Št‰j¨ ^LW§Œ“XŽ'ªSŒ“¯¬Qˆ§‘•'ŸX”‘ˆ]•bˆ]“H‰tˆ]Ž0¬d¨™X—‹£“5¡ ‰t‡5ˆ,•¯™X”‘‰‹£ªL‡kŒ“X“Xˆ]” ³k”‘‰tˆ]Š;¬kŒ“X H—°-Û’ •'ŸkŒª]‰t”‘¨'—‹™XŸXŸQ’wŠ‹‰tˆ]Žp®ÔŒS² ˆ]”‘ˆ]‰t—;—‹™XªL‡ Œ—=‰‹‡Xˆ¯Ö=Œ™X¬Qˆ]ªL‡X‘ˆ]—;³k”‘‰tˆoŠtS— ^LW0ªŒ“p¬Qˆ,‘•'Ÿ5”£ˆo•'ˆ]“H‰tˆoŽ ®‘‰t‡,ÕN¸t¦Wš‘³Q“X‘‰tˆ£•bŸX™X”‘—tˆŠ‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆž?³k”‘‰tˆ]Š‹—°†‡Xˆ—tŸkŒª]ˆL–l©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨¯”‘’HªŒ”‘‘ºŒ‰t‘’w“;‘—`’ ŸX‰t‘•'‘º]ˆoŽ,Œ•b’w“X¡Œ”‘”HŸk’ —t—‹£¬5”£ˆÕN¸t¦p³k”‘‰‹ˆ]Št— ®‘‰t‡‰‹‡Xˆ¡w‘²wˆ]“”£ˆo“X¡w‰‹‡©h’ Š§‰‹‡XˆqÖ;Œ™X¬kˆoª‡5£ˆo—§³Q”£‰‹ˆ]Št—S°-†‡Xˆ¹=Œ ŒŠ®ÔŒS² ˆ]”‘ˆ]‰§‘—;‰t‡Xˆ—t‘•bŸX”‘ˆ]—t‰¬kŒ—t‘—©h™X“Xªo‰t‘’w“‘“‰‹‡Xˆª]’w•bŸkŒª]‰‹”‘¨ —t™5ŸXŸk’ Št‰‹ˆ]Ž·®ŒS²wˆ]”‘ˆ]‰©YŒ•'‘”‘¨w°;¸j‰;ŸXŠt’²H‘ŽXˆ]—Œ'ªSŒŸkŒ¬X‘”£‘‰j¨b‰t’ª]’ •'ŸX™5‰tˆ-‰‹‡Xˆ¯ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰-ŽX‘Štˆoª]‰t”‘¨©hŠt’ • ‰t‡5ˆ¯Štˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—tˆ]—’©‰t‡5ˆ¯”£’® Œ“5Ž¯‡X‘¡w‡©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨b—t™X¬5¬kŒ“XŽ5—°EÕ5’wŠE‰‹‡Xˆ§¹;ŒwŒŠ®ŒS²wˆ]”‘ˆ]‰S¶w‰‹‡Xˆ³k”‘‰‹ˆ]Š<ªo’dˆ7½'ª]‘ˆ]“H‰t—x©h’wŠE‰‹‡Xˆ;”‘’®ÙŒ“5Ž¯‡X‘¡w‡©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨³k”‘‰tˆ]Š¬kŒ“X H— ŒŠ‹ˆ;¡w‘²wˆ]“¬H¨ + W
 E

^U c

+ ^
 E

 ^   H U ^  c U


E HIT RGc R

’w‰‹‡Xˆ]Š‹®£—‹ˆ
E c R


E HIT R

’ ‰t‡Xˆ]Š‹®‘—tˆw¶

š T TSž š Tß ž

Štˆo—tŸQˆ]ª]‰t‘² ˆ]”‘¨d°xѧ—t—‹™X•'ˆ;‰‹‡kŒ‰§Œ0ŽX‘—tª]Š‹ˆ]‰tˆ7–Y‰‹£•bˆ;£“5ŸX™X‰—t‘¡ “kŒ”  
 £—‰t‡5ˆ-—t‰LŒ‘ŠtªŒ—tˆ-ªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰ŸQŒ‰t‰‹ˆ]Št“ 9 :<;G= 9 :@BA

 
 E


c
c'R

†‡Xˆ;Štˆo—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ]— W  W 
 Œ“XŽ  ^  W 
 Œ‰‰t‡5ˆc‰‹‡Š‹ˆ]—t’ ”‘™X‰t‘’w“ŒS©h‰‹ˆ]Š³k”‘‰tˆoŠt‘“X¡¯®‘‰t‡+ W 
 Œ“XŽ+ ^ 
 ¶HŠ‹ˆ]—tŸQˆ]ª]‰‹‘²wˆ]”‘¨H¶kŒŠ‹ˆ
HIT  2ß 9 :F;G=  W W 
 E    ^ Mš 9 :F;G= N 9 :@BA ž
E HIT U
 c R 2ß 9 :J@QA 
E HIT  ^ U ]š 9 :F;G= H?9 :J@BA ž  ^  W 
 E c ’w‰‹‡Xˆ]Š‹®£—‹ˆw° †‡Xˆ]“N¶X‰t‡5ˆ-ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰ Œ“5Ž  W W 
 

š Tà ž

š TSHž š T7 ž

D

W Œ‰‰t‡5ˆ-‘“d‰‹ˆ]Št²wŒ”Eš]HIT RGcwžŒ“5Ž‰‹‡Xˆc‰t‡µš ³k“Xˆ]—‹‰žŠtˆo—t’w”‘™X‰‹‘’w“ªŒ“¬Qˆ;ª]’w•bŸX™X‰tˆoŽ¬H¨¯‰‹‡Xˆ-ŠŒ‰t‘’’©  ^  W 
 D 9 :F;G= H 9 :J@BA  ^  W HIT  # W E 9 :F;G= N?9 :J@BA E   W  W HIT щ§‰‹‡Xˆ T]—t‰šs—‹ˆ]ª]’w“5Ž³k“5ˆ]—t‰Lž;Štˆ]—‹’w”‘™X‰‹£’ “`¶X‰‹‡Xˆ”£’® ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨p¬kŒ“XŽŠtˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—tˆ  W  W
 ‘—§ŽX’®“X—LŒ•bŸX”‘ˆ]Ž'¬H¨‰j®<’Q¶FŒ“XŽb©hˆ]Žp‘“H‰t’

‰t‡5ˆ=—LŒ•bˆ³k”‘‰tˆoŠ§¬kŒ“X F°†‡Xˆ;Štˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—tˆ]—-ŒŠtˆ

E

 ^ V^ 
 E

 ß29 :<;>=   9 :F;G= N?9 :J@BA

 WV^ 


ß29 :@BA

9:F;G=IH?9:J@BA c


[H T
E H T

š T ž


E HIT

š T" ž


 H T2R

’ ‰t‡Xˆ]Š‹®‘—tˆw°

ѧ¡HŒ‘“`¶H®ˆ;ªŒ“ª]’ •'ŸX™X‰‹ˆ§‰‹‡Xˆ-ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰§Œ‰‰‹‡X‘—Štˆ]—‹’w”‘™X‰‹£’ “Œ— D

: @BA 9 :F;G= H 9 J  ^ V^ I H T # ^ E 9 F : ;G= N?9 :JB@ A E  W V^ I H T

Õ5’w”‘”‘’®£“5¡=‰‹‡X‘—®ÔŒS¨H¶ ‰t‡Xˆ-ªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰;Œ‰‰t‡Xˆ‘–j‰t‡Štˆo—t’w”‘™X‰‹‘’w“ªŒ“¬Qˆ;ª]’w•bŸX™X‰tˆoŽÏŒ— D

9:F;G= H 9:J@BA  ^  @ I H T @ E R E 9:F;G=hN?9:J@BA  W  @ I H T

š T- ž

j° ˆw°pŽX‘²d‘ŽX‘“X¡‰‹‡Xˆ'‡X‘¡ ‡·¬kŒ“XŽ·Š‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ¬d¨#‰‹‡Xˆ”‘’® ¬QŒ“XŽ#Š‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆµŒ‰
E H T °#Õ`‘¡Q°2à‘”‘”‘™X—t‰‹ŠŒ‰tˆ]—‰t‡X‘—ª]’w“5—t‰Œ“H‰j–jŠŒ‰‹‘’ Štˆo” Œ‰t‘’w“5—t‡X‘ŸŒª]Št’ —t—Štˆ]—‹’w”‘™X‰t‘’ “X—° L max L min ...............

................ –1 (a) 1 ------- ( L max + L min ) 2

2L max

2L min ................

..............

1 ------- ( L max – L min ) 2 ........

........ –1

–1

(c)

(b) L max + L min

2L max

L max – L min

2L min ..............

..............

.......

........

–1

–1

(d)

(e) 2 ( L max + L min )

2 2L max

2 ( L max – L min )

2 2L min ..............

..............

.......

........

–1

–1

(f)

(g)


ÄÀ ×Û’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰ª]’w•bŸX™X‰Œ‰t‘’w“™X—‹£“5¡;³k”‘‰tˆ]ŠŠtˆo—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ]—¶Q®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ¯šhŒwž?£—‰t‡5ˆ§’wŠ‹‘¡w‘“kŒ”5—t‰Œ‘ŠtªŒ—tˆ;—t‘¡w“QŒ”j¶Xšs¬Qž<Œ“XŽšsªžŒŠtˆ”£’® Œ“5Ž‡5£¡ ‡'¬kŒ“XŽŠtˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—tˆo—׌‰‰t‡XˆIc‰t‡Štˆ]—‹’w”‘™X‰‹£’ “`¶FšsŽQž]¶`š ˆž]¶Nš‘©]žŒ“XŽ#šs¡HžŒŠ‹ˆ=Š‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“5—tˆ]—-Œ‰‰‹‡Xˆ T]—‹‰§Œ“XŽß“5ŽŠ‹ˆ]—t’ ”‘™X‰t‘’w“5—° †‡X’w™5¡w‡‰t‡Xˆ;ŽXˆoŠt‘²wŒ‰‹£’ “'‘—¬kŒ—tˆ]Ž™5Ÿk’ “'‰t‡5ˆ-—t‰LŒ‘ŠtªŒ—tˆ-ŸQŒ‰t‰‹ˆ]Št“N¶X‘‰ªŒ“Œ”£—‹’,¬Qˆ-ŒŸXŸ5”£‘ˆ]Ž‰‹’¯•'’wŠ‹ˆª]’w•bŸX”‘ˆ]«¯ªŒ—tˆ]——t™XªL‡µŒ— ‰t‡5ˆ-ˆ]«XŒ•bŸX”‘ˆ§‘“Õ`‘¡Q°X߯—t‡5’®“ÏŒ¬k’² ˆw°E¾#ˆ;‰LŒ wˆ ^ E c #Vc2c/k¶ U E c$# c+wß2-Œ“XŽ ^ E  U E c # ß 5°†‡Xˆ]Štˆ7©h’wŠ‹ˆw¶F‰t‡5ˆ-ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰t— Œ‰;ŸQ’w‘“H‰t—;Ñ܌“XŽ ‘“#ÕN£¡Q°Fß'—‹‡X’w™5”£Žp¬QˆcX° ß'Œ“XŽ?cX° àwà5¶QŠtˆ]—‹Ÿkˆ]ªo‰t‘²wˆ]”‘¨H°'Õ5Št’w• ‡QŒ”¢©s–j¬kŒ“XŽŽXˆ]ª]’ •'ŸQ’w—t‘‰‹£’ “`¶Q‰t‡Xˆ©jŒ—t‰Ú–Y²wŒŠt¨H‘“X¡  ª]’w—š U Qž®‘”‘”X¬Qˆ§—tˆoŸkŒŠLŒ‰tˆoŽ'©lŠt’w•  ^ ª]’ —2š ^ Qž<Œ‰E‰t‡5ˆ=àŠ‹Ž'Š‹ˆ]—t’ ”£™5‰t‘’w“`°EÕN‘¡k°$-—t‡X’®—‰t‡5ˆ§”‘’®–?Œ“XŽ¯‡X‘¡w‡H–l©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨¯¬QŒ“X  ŠtˆoU —tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ]—§ Œ—®ˆ]”‘”kŒ—E‰‹‡Xˆª]’ •'ŸX™X‰‹ˆ]Žª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰°¾#ˆ—tˆ]ˆ‰t‡kŒ‰2‰‹‡Xˆ¹=Œ ŒŠ®ŒS²wˆ]”‘ˆ]‰EªSŒ“ŸXŠtˆ]Ž5£ªo‰<‰‹‡Xˆª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰<Œ‰ŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆo“d‰—tŸQŒ‰tsŒ” ”‘’HªŒ‰‹£’ “X—˜d™5£‰‹ˆ-Œª]ª]™5ŠŒ‰‹ˆ]”‘¨d° †‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆqŒŠtˆ-—‹ˆ]²wˆ]ŠLŒ”EŠ‹ˆŒ—‹’w“X—‰t’bŽXˆL³k“Xˆ•¯™X”‘‰t‘ŸX”‘ˆª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰‹—=‘“ŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆ]“H‰;Štˆo—t’w”‘™X‰‹‘’w“X—S°§ÕN£Š‹—t‰’©<Œ”‘”j¶X—‹£“5ª]ˆ-‡H™X•Œ“'ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰ —tˆo“X—t‘‰t‘²H‘‰j¨,‘—‡X‘¡w‡5”£¨0ŽXˆ]ŸQˆ]“XŽXˆ]“H‰’ “,‰‹‡Xˆ§—‹ŸkŒ‰‹ Œ”H©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨H¶ •¯™X”‘‰t‘ŸX”‘ˆEª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰t—ªŒ“¯¬kˆ™X—tˆ]Ž¯‰‹’,ŒŽ5ŽXŠtˆ]—‹—<Ž5Ò­Fˆ]Š‹ˆ]“H‰<²wŒŠtsŒ‰‹£’ “X— Œ‰bŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“H‰Štˆ]—‹’w”‘™X‰‹£’ “X—Œª]Š‹’w—‹—‰‹‡Xˆp£•Œ¡ ˆwV° UXk*œHˆ]ª]’ “XŽ`¶‰t‡Xˆp™X“Xª]ˆoŠt‰Œ‘“d‰j¨ ŸXŠt‘“Xª]‘ŸX”‘ˆŠ‹ˆ]˜H™X‘Štˆ]—‰‹‡XˆµŠ‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“5—tˆ#‘“IŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆ]“H‰ ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨¬kŒ“XŽ5—§‰t’b‡kŒS²wˆ;ŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆo“d‰;—‹™XŸXŸQ’wŠt‰‹ˆ]ŽpŠŒŽ5£j°Õ5™XŠt‰‹‡Xˆ]Št•b’wŠ‹ˆw¶Q£‰®Œ——t‡X’®“‰t‡kŒ‰§ˆŒª‡Ï©hŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆo“Xª]¨ªL‡kŒ“X“Xˆ]”‘“¹§»;œ ‡kŒ—E‰t‡Xˆ¬kŒ“5ŽX®‘ŽX‰t‡¯’©2Œ¬Q’w™X‰ T´’dªo‰ŒS²wˆ ° UGk†‡XˆŽX¨dŒŽX‘ª®ÔŒS² ˆ]”‘ˆ]‰E‰‹ŠŒ“5—j©h’ Št• —Œ‰t‘—j³kˆo—<‰‹‡Xˆ]—tˆ;Š‹ˆ]˜H™X‘Štˆ]•bˆ]“H‰t—“kŒ‰‹™XŠŒ”£”‘¨H°`ÕN‘“kŒ”‘”‘¨d¶ ŸQˆ]Šj©hˆoª]‰Štˆ]ªo’w“X—‹‰tŠt™5ª]‰t‘’w“b‘—EŸk’ —t—‹£¬5”£ˆ®‘‰‹‡¯Štˆ]—‹Ÿk’ “X—tˆ]—’ ¬X‰Œ‘“Xˆ]Ž©hŠ‹’w• Ž5Ò­Fˆ]Š‹ˆ]“H‰<—‹ªŒ”‘ˆ]—S¶XŒ“XŽ¯“X’0²d‘—‹™kŒ”X‘“H©l’wŠt•Œ‰‹£’ “;®£”‘”X¬Qˆ”‘’w—‹‰ ŽX™XŠ‹‘“X¡'‰‹‡Xˆ-ŸXŠ‹’dªoˆ]—t—S°-¸j“ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰S¶k‰‹’'ŸQˆ]Šj©lˆ]ª]‰t”‘¨Š‹ˆ]ª]’ “X—t‰‹Št™Xª]‰‰t‡5ˆ-²H£—‹™kŒ”N‘“H©h’wŠ‹•Œ‰t‘’w“¯™X—‹‘“X¡'‰‹‡Xˆ #0Œ¬Q’wŠ§Œ“QŒ”‘¨H—t‘—¶QŒ”‘”F³k”‘‰‹ˆ]Št— •¯™X—‹‰<‡kŒS² ˆ;‰t‡Xˆ;—Œ•'ˆ”£ˆo“X¡w‰‹‡ÏŒ“XŽ`¶XŒ—§ŒŠtˆ]—‹™X”‘‰¶X‰‹‡Xˆ;—tŸkŒª]ˆL–l©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨”‘’HªŒ”£‘ºŒ‰t‘’w“bŸXŠt’ ŸkˆoŠt‰j¨'‘—”‘ˆ]—‹/ — kˆ]«H‘¬X”‘ˆw°

300

200

100 0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500

250

900 800

200

700

150

600 500 0

200

100 0

400

200

400

0.33 0.3 0.25 0.2 0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500


ÄÀ Þ¹=Œ ŒŠ-Ž5ˆ]ª]’w•bŸk’ —t‘‰t‘’ “µ’©=Õ`‘¡ ™XŠtˆ'ß5°†2’ Ÿ  ‰‹‡Xˆ'®ŒS²wˆ7©h’wŠ‹•
F•b£Ž5ŽX”‘ˆL–Y”‘ˆL©l‰  ‘” ’® ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨·Štˆo—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆÏŒ‰-‰t‡5ˆàŠ‹Ž Štˆo—t’w”‘™X‰‹‘’w“
N•'‘ŽXŽX”‘ˆL–jŠt‘¡ ‡d‰  ‡X‘¡w‡©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨#Š‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“5—tˆŒ‰-‰t‡5ˆ'àŠtŽ#Š‹ˆ]—t’ ”‘™X‰t‘’w“
`¬Q’w‰‹‰t’w•  ‰‹‡Xˆ¯ŠŒ‰t‘’#šsª]’ •'ŸX™5‰tˆ]Žpª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰ž0’© ‰t‡5ˆ]—tˆ-‰j®’¯Štˆo—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ]—°

Original Image

Wavelet Decomposition

Masking Effect

Suprathreshold R o Computation D

Compressed Image

Masking Effect

Wavelet Decomposition

Suprathreshold Computation Rc


ÄÀ h”£’HªL 'Ž5 Œ¡wŠLŒ• ’©E‰t‡5ˆ=Ÿ5Št’wŸQ’w—‹ˆ]Ž˜H™kŒ”£‘‰j¨•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ;—t¨H—t‰‹ˆ]•µ° EÊxÊ 2 J"/(
+ : *!#),1576

( !#" 02( "/6"$/(

†‡XˆbŸXŠt’ Ÿk’ —tˆ]Ž[˜d™QŒ”‘‘‰j¨•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ'—‹¨d—‹‰tˆ]•*£—0—t‡X’®“[£“·ÕN‘¡k°X° ’w‰t‡[‰t‡Xˆb’wŠ‹£¡ ‘“kŒ”<Œ“XŽ#‰t‡5ˆ'ŽX‘—tD ‰‹’wŠ‹‰tˆ]Ž[£•Œ¡ ˆ]—-ŒŠtˆbŸkŒ—‹—tˆ]Ž ‰t‡5Št’w™5¡w‡¯‰t‡5ˆ—t¨H—t‰‹ˆ]• ©h’wŠEŽ5¨dŒŽ5£ª¹=Œ ŒŠE®ŒS²wˆo”£ˆo‰2Ž5ˆ]ª]’w•bŸk’ —t‘‰t‘’ “-‘“©h’w™XŠ’ Št‘ˆ]“HD ‰Œ‰t‘’w“X—S°2Û’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰‹— C —EŒŠtˆªo’w•'Ÿ5™X‰tˆ]Ž'Œ‰ˆ]²wˆ]Š‹¨ ŸX‘«Hˆ]”<Œ“XŽµˆo²wˆ]Š‹¨µŠ‹ˆ]—t’ ”£™5‰t‘’w“#’©<‘“d‰‹ˆ]Štˆo—t‰®£‰‹‡Ùš T- ž]°¯Û’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰-‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡5’w”‘ŽX— D  W Œ‰;ˆŒª‡#Š‹ˆ]—t’ ”‘™X‰t‘’w“·ŒŠtˆª]’w•bŸX™X‰‹ˆ]Žµ²HsŒpšhà ž ®‘‰t‡pŠtˆ]—‹Ÿkˆoª]‰,’©Ô‰‹‡Xˆ]‘Š;ª]ˆ]“H‰tˆoŠ-©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo£ˆo—  C —°†‡Xˆ¯ª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰-‰‹‡XŠtˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Ž  W ‘—;‰t‡5ˆ]“·ŒŽ±7™X—t‰‹ˆ]Ž Œª]ª]’ ŠtŽX‘“X¡‰t’#š5dž;Œ‰;ˆŒª‡ Štˆo—t’w”‘™X‰‹‘’w“'‰‹’,‘“Xªo’wŠtŸQ’wD ŠLŒ‰‹ˆ=‰‹‡Xˆ§•Œ—‹ d‘“X¡;ˆL­Fˆ]ª]‰S°˜H™kŒ‰‹£’ “š " žE‘—‰t‡XD ˆ]“™X—‹ˆ]Ž‰t’¡w‘²wˆ‰‹‡Xˆ;—t™XŸ5ŠŒ‰‹‡XŠtˆo—t‡X’ ”£ŽŠ‹ˆ]—tŸQ’w“X—‹ˆ;©hŠ‹’w• ‰t‡Xˆ ª]’ •'ŸX™X‰‹ˆ]Ž'ªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰‹— C —§Œ“XŽ‰t‡Xˆ-ŒŽS±L™X—t‰‹ˆ]Žª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰§‰‹‡XŠtˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘ŽX—  C —° 8Fˆ]‰0—t™X¬X—‹ª]Št‘ŸX‰‹ — Œ“5 Ž bŠtˆoŸXŠtˆ]—‹ˆ]“H‰,‰‹‡Xˆ¯ª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹ˆ]Ž·Œ“XŽp‰t‡5ˆ¯’wŠt‘¡ £“QŒ”`‘•Œ¡wˆo—¶QŠtˆ]—‹Ÿkˆoª]‰t‘²wˆo”£¨H°¯†‡Xˆo“`¶`‰‹‡Xˆ¯˜H™kŒ”‘‘‰j¨ˆ]ŠtŠ‹’wŠ •'ˆSŒ—t™5Štˆ;‘—  %   # T    š   š LR0ž H   š  Rwžtž "! R  E š T0 ž    ' ^  ' ^ @(' ^   ®‡Xˆ]Š‹ ˆ _Œ“X$ Ž ŒŠ‹ˆ‰t‡Xˆ²wˆ]Š‹‰t‘ªŒ”kŒ“XŽ0‡X’wŠ‹£ºo’w“H‰Œ”d—‹‘º]ˆ]—E’©k‰t‡Xˆ‘•Œ¡wˆ ¶]Štˆo—tŸQˆ]ª]‰t‘² ˆ]”‘¨d%¶  ‘—‰t‡Xˆ“H™X•¯¬kˆoŠ`’©Q³k”‘‰tˆoŠt‘“X¡§ªL‡kŒ“X“Xˆ]”‘—‘“ ‰t‡5ˆ©h’ ™XŠEŽX‘Štˆoª]‰t‘’w“5—¶HŒ“X' Ž &‘—<Œ“¯ˆ]•'Ÿ5£Š‹‘ªŒ”XŸQŒŠŒ•'ˆ]‰‹ˆ]ŠEŠ‹ˆ]”sŒ‰tˆoŽ'‰t’0‰t‡XˆŸX—‹¨Hª‡5’w•'ˆo‰tŠt‘ª´©h™X“Xª]‰‹‘’w“¯Œ“XŽbŸXŠt’ ¬kŒ¬X‘”‘‘‰j¨;—t™X•b•Œ‰‹‘’w“ Œ“5Ž¯£——‹ˆ]‰<‰‹h ’ -‘“,‰‹‡X‘—E®<’ Št F° `'†‡XˆŠ‹ˆ]—t™5”£‰‹‘“X¡-ˆ]Š‹Št’wŠx•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ  ‘—EŽ5£•bˆ]“X—‹£’ “X”‘ˆ]—t——‹£“5ª]ˆ‰t‡Xˆª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰E‘‰t—‹ˆ]”¢©`£—ŽX‘•bˆ]“X—t‘’ “X”‘ˆ]—t—S° %<Ê )(



,„ Ë

 Ì ƒ;€

 „ ¯‚EÐ

ƒ‚ †‡Xˆ©h’w”‘”‘’®‘“X¡¯ŸX—t¨HªL‡X’ ŸX‡H¨d—‹‘ªŒ”ˆ]«HŸkˆoŠt‘•'ˆ]“H‰‹—,®ˆ]Štˆbª]’w“5ŽX™Xª]‰‹ˆ]ŽV’w“·Œ T "+*œH‘”‘£ªo’w“ #;ŠŒŸX‡X‘ª]—ª]’w”‘’wŠ0¡wŠŒŸX‡X‘ª¯ŽX‘—tŸ5” ŒS¨"#-Ö;›b– T" FT T °;†‡Xˆ”£™5•'‘“kŒ“5ª]ˆ-ŠŒ“X¡wˆ’©‰t‡Xˆ¯ŽX‘—‹ŸX”sŒS¨'®Œ—-ŒŽ±7™X—t‰‹ˆ]Žp©hŠt’ • ¯ c ‰‹’ -2, c .-'0K / U šsªSŒ“XŽXˆo” Œ+?—‹˜d™QŒŠtˆoŽµ•bˆ]‰tˆ]ŠLž¬d¨™X—t‘“X¡Œ ¤‡X’ ‰t’ Štˆ]—‹ˆŒŠ‹ª‡p—tŸQˆ]ª]‰‹Št’ ŠŒŽ5£’ •'ˆ]‰‹ˆ]Š°´†‡Xˆ]Štˆ®ˆ]Štˆ,ß2, ŽX‘—‹ª]Štˆ]‰‹ˆ,¡ ŠŒS¨b—tªŒ”£ˆo—§ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—tˆ]“H‰;‘“‰t‡Xˆ-ˆo«dŸQˆ]Š‹£•bˆ]“H‰t—S°†‡Xˆ;Štˆ]”sŒ‰t‘’w“X—‹‡X‘Ÿ

’©E‰‹‡Xˆ-”‘™X•'‘“kŒ“Xª]ˆ²wˆ]Š‹—t™X—;‰t‡5ˆ,¡ ŠŒS¨'—‹ªŒ”‘ˆ-‘—•bˆŒ—‹™XŠtˆ]ŽpŒ“XŽ‰LŒ¬X™5” Œ‰tˆ]Ž‰‹’'¬Qˆ-™X—tˆoŽ‰t’b‰tŠŒ“X—j©lˆ]Š;‰t‡Xˆ-Ž5£—‹ŸX”sŒS¨wˆ]Ž¡ ŠŒS¨H”‘ˆ]²wˆ]”‘—‰‹’ Œªo‰t™kŒ”`”‘™X•'‘“kŒ“Xª]ˆw° %<ÊlÉÊ  !#),1M+ !
 15. (I'&(  !
!# ! 4(
)3(  œH‘“Xª]ˆ0ª]’wŠ‹‰t‘ªŒ”ª]ˆo”£”‘—‡kŒS²wˆ,Œ #0Œ™X—‹—tsŒ“H–j—t‡QŒŸQˆ]ŽŠtˆoª]ˆ]ŸX‰‹£’ “µŸ5Št’³Q”£ˆ ¶b^G^§‘‰£—’©h‰tˆo“™X—tˆoŽ Œ—=Œ“ˆ]²H£Ž5ˆ]“Xª]ˆ‰t‡kŒ‰§‰‹‡Xˆ #-Œ¬k’ Š³k”‘‰tˆoŠ ‘—;ŸXŠtˆL©lˆ]ŠŒ¬X”‘ˆ¯£“p‰t‡5ˆ¯²d‘—‹£’ “ˆ]«HŸQˆ]Št‘•'ˆo“d‰S°¯œH‘“Xª]ˆ¯‰t‡5ˆ¯¹=ŒwŒŠ³k”‘‰tˆ]Š-Ž5’dˆo—-“X’w‰;ŸQ’w—‹—tˆ]—‹—,‰‹‡Xˆ¯—Œ•'ˆ #-Œ™X—t—‹sŒ“H–j—t‡kŒŸkˆoŽµŸkŒ—t—‹¬kŒ“XŽ Œ—0‰t‡Xˆ #-Œ¬Q’wŠ³k”‘‰tˆoŠ-ŽX’Hˆ]—¶’ “Xˆ¯•ŒS¨—‹™X—tŸQˆ]ª]‰¯‰‹‡Xˆ'²wŒ”£‘ŽX‘‰j¨’©™X—‹£“5¡‰t‡Xˆ¯¹;ŒwŒŠ;³k”‘‰tˆ]Š0£“#²H‘—t‘’ “ Œ“kŒ”‘¨H—t‘—°†2’²wŒ”‘‘ŽkŒ‰‹ˆ-‰t‡Xˆ ™X—‹ˆ,’©<‰t‡Xˆ¹=Œ ŒŠ;®ŒS²wˆ]”‘ˆ]‰S¶k®ˆ•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ]Ž‰t‡5ˆ,ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰-‰‹‡XŠtˆo—t‡X’ ”£Žp¬H¨™X—t‘“X¡b¬k’ ‰t‡ #-Œ¬Q’wŠ;Œ“XŽp¹=Œ ŒŠ³Q”£‰‹ˆ]ŠtˆoŽµŸkŒ‰tªL‡Xˆ]—S°†‡Xˆ —tŸQŒ‰tsŒ”`©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨#ŠŒ“X¡wˆ’©‰tˆ]—‹‰-ŸkŒ‰tªL‡Xˆ]—®ÔŒ—©hŠt’ • cXV° c+,0‰tP ’ T0X° ߪ]¨Hª]”‘ˆ]—-ŸQˆ]Š-ŽXˆ]¡ Štˆ]ˆ ¶®‡X‘ª‡pª]’² ˆ]Št—-²H‘Št‰‹™kŒ”‘”‘¨‰t‡Xˆ¯®‡5’w”‘ˆ ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨¬kŒ“XŽ®<ˆ-®’w™5”£Ž—‹ˆ]“X—tˆ©lŠt’w•ÝŽX‘¡w‘‰LŒ”`‘•Œ¡wˆo—°E†‡5ˆ,Š‹ˆ]—t™X”‘‰;‘——t‡X’®“£“pÕ`‘¡Q)° X¶5®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ,‰‹‡Xˆ,—‹ˆ]“X—‹£‰‹‘²d‘‰j¨‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘Ž`¶ ŽXˆL³Q“Xˆ]ŽÙŒ—-‰t‡5ˆ'Štˆoª]‘ŸXŠt’HªŒ”<’©§‰t‡Xˆ¯ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡5’w”‘Ž`¶‘—-ŸX”‘’w‰‹‰tˆ]Ž·Œ—,Œb©h™5“Xª]‰t‘’ “#’©—tŸkŒ‰tsŒ”©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨d°†‡5ˆ'ª]”‘’w—‹ˆ]“Xˆ]—‹—¯’© ‰t‡5ˆ]—tˆ;‰j®’-ª]™XŠ‹²wˆ]——‹‡X’®—<‰‹‡kŒ‰‰t‡5ˆ§¹=Œ ŒŠx³k”‘‰tˆ]Š‡kŒ—ÔŒ;ªo’w•'ŸQŒŠŒ¬X”‘ˆ<ŸQˆ]ŠÚ©h’wŠ‹•Œ“5ª]ˆ§‘“¯ª]’ •'ŸkŒŠt‘—t’ “,®‘‰t‡b‰t‡Xˆ #-Œ¬Q’wŠ?³k”‘‰tˆ]ŠS°†‡X‘— ˆ]«HŸQˆ]Št‘•'ˆo“d‰LŒ”FŠ‹ˆ]—t™X”‘‰ª]”‘ˆŒŠ‹”£¨¯Ž5ˆ]•'’ “X—t‰‹ŠŒ‰‹ˆ]—§‰‹‡kŒ‰‰‹‡Xˆ;¹=Œ ŒŠ³k”‘‰tˆoŠªŒ“Œ”‘—‹’,¬Qˆ-™X—‹ˆ]Ž‘“'‰‹‡Xˆ-˜H™kŒ”‘‘‰j¨¯Œ—t—‹ˆ]—t—‹•'ˆ]“H‰—t¨H—t‰‹ˆ]•µ° 2

Sensitivity threshold

10

1

10

Haar filtering Gabor filtering

0

1

10

10 Spatial frequency (cycle/deg)


ÄÀ %<Ê3xÊ ‚J !
'&2( " &*)M+

-Û’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰—tˆ]“X—‹‘‰t‘²H£‰j¨b‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡5’w”‘Ž¬d¨b™X—t‘“X¡¯‰‹‡Xˆ #-Œ¬Q’wŠ§Œ“XŽ'¹;ŒwŒŠ³k”‘‰tˆ]Š‹—° !#"
1 


¸j“œHˆ]ª]‰‹‘’w“µß5° ß5¶H®<ˆ×©h’wŠ‹•¯™X”sŒ‰tˆoŽ¯‰t‡Xˆ-•Œ—‹ d‘“X¡×©h™X“Xª]‰‹‘’w“#3š Hž¬d¨Œ—t—t™5•'‘“X¡-‰‹‡kŒ‰‰t‡Xˆ-‰j®’²wŒŠtsŒ¬X”‘ˆ]—’©E•Œ—t H‘“X¡k¶ “kŒ•'ˆ]”‘¨H¶‰t‡Xˆ ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨¯—‹ˆ]ŸkŒŠŒ‰‹‘’w“¯Œ“XŽ¯‰‹‡Xˆª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰EŠŒ‰t‘’;¬kˆo‰j®<ˆ]ˆo“'‰t‡5ˆ‰ŒŠ‹¡wˆ]‰Œ“XŽ¯•Œ—t  ˆ]Š¶ŒŠtˆ‘“XŽXˆ]ŸQˆ]“XŽ5ˆ]“H‰ÔŒ“XŽ¯—tˆ]ŸQŒŠŒ¬X”‘ˆw°†’§² ˆ]Št¢©h¨ ‰tD ‡5£—EŒ—t—t™5D •'ŸX‰‹£’ “`¶SŸXD —t¨HªL‡X’ ŸX‡H¨d—‹‘D ªŒ”Xˆo«dŸQˆ]Š‹£•bˆ]“H‰t—®ˆ]Štˆª]’ “XŽX™Xªo‰tˆ]Žb‰t’³k“XŽ‰t‡XˆŸQŒŠŒ•'ˆ]‰‹ˆ]Št—’©k‰t‡X‘—E•b’HŽXˆ]”j°Q†‡Xˆª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰EŠŒ‰t‘’ :F; K ¶H®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ :F; Œ“XŽ Štˆ]ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—tˆo“d‰‰t‡Xˆ;ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰’©2•Œ—t H‘“X¡-Œ“XŽb‰ŒŠt¡wˆo‰—t‘¡w“kŒ”‘—¶HŠtˆo—tŸQˆ]ª]‰t‘² ˆ]”‘¨d¶5ŠŒ“5¡wˆ]Ž©hŠt’ • cXV° ;‰‹’ ßXV° 5°E† ‡Xˆ;©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨ŠŒ‰t ‘’Y :F;  K*N¶X‘“‰t‡5ˆ-•'ˆŒ“H®‡X‘”£ˆ ¶wŠLŒ“X¡ ˆ]Ž©hŠ‹’w• H´à‰t’'à’Hª]‰LŒS²wˆ]—S°†’¯£—‹’w”sŒ‰‹ˆ;£“5ŽX‘²d‘ŽX™QŒ”QˆL­¼ˆoª]‰t—S¶`®ˆ ³kŠ‹—t‰³k«Hˆ]Ž#‰t‡5ˆ-©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨µŠLŒ‰t‘’Q¶¼Œ“XŽ²wŒŠt‘ˆ]Ž‰‹‡Xˆ¯ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰;’©<ˆŒªL‡µ—‹£¡ “kŒ”‰‹’'‘“H²wˆ]—‹‰t‘¡dŒ‰tˆ‰t‡XˆˆL­Fˆ]ª]‰-’©<‰t‡Xˆ¯ªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰;ŠLŒ‰t‘’Q° †‡Xˆ;Štˆo—t™X”‘‰£——t‡5’®“'‘“ÕN‘¡k° "'šlŒwžo¶dŒ“XŽŒ“'ˆ]«HŸQ’w“Xˆ]“H‰‹ Œ”Q³k‰t‰‹‘“X¡-©l™X“Xª]‰‹£’ “¯®ÔŒ—<Ž5ˆ]‰tˆ]Š‹•'‘“Xˆ]Žb©hŠ‹’w• ‰t‡5ˆ§ŽkŒ‰ŒX°¾#ˆ‰t‡Xˆo“'²wŒŠ‹‘ˆ]Ž ¬Q’w‰t‡¯‰‹‡Xˆ§ªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰Œ“5Ž¯‰t‡Xˆ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo¨¯ŠŒ‰‹‘’w—E’©`‰ŒŠ‹¡wˆ]‰Œ“XŽ¯•Œ—t H‘“X¡—t‘¡w“kŒ”‘—°Ö§™5Št‘“X¡;‰t‡Xˆª]’w•bŸX™X‰LŒ‰t‘’ “-ŸXŠt’Hª]ˆo—t—¶5®<ˆ—‹ªŒ”‘ˆ]Ž ˆ]«HŸQˆ]Št‘•'ˆo“d‰LŒ”ŽkŒ‰Œ¯®‘‰‹‡Štˆ]—‹Ÿkˆoª]‰,‰‹’'‰‹‡Xˆ]‘Š;ª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰=ŠLŒ‰‹£’ —-Œª]ª]’ ŠtŽX‘“X¡b‰t’Õ`‘¡Q;° "šhŒ ž]°;†‡Xˆ—tªŒ”‘ˆ]ŽµŽQŒ‰Œ—t‡X’®ˆ]Žp²wˆ]Š‹¨”‘‘‰t‰t”‘ˆ ŽXˆ]²HsŒ‰‹‘’w“`¶H‰‹‡d™5—£“5ŽX‘ªŒ‰‹£“5¡,‰‹‡kŒ‰-5š dž‘—§Œ-² ˆ]Št¨¡ ’d’HŽŒŸXŸXŠ‹’«H£•Œ‰‹£’ “,‰‹’¯‰t‡Xˆ;•Œ—t H‘“X¡-•b’HŽXˆ]”j°`†‡5ˆ=•bˆŒ“5—<’©?ˆo«dŸQˆ]Š‹£•bˆ]“H‰Œ” ŽkŒ‰ŒpŒ“XŽp³k‰‹‰t‘“X¡©h™X“Xªo‰t‘’w“X—¯ŒŠ‹ˆ'—‹‡X’®“·‘“ÙÕN‘¡k° "·š ¬kž]¶x®‡X‘ª‡VŒŠ‹ˆ'‘“#¡w’H’HŽÙŒ¡wŠtˆoˆ]•'ˆ]“H‰®‘‰t‡#‰t‡5’w—tˆ‘“`_° ^LU.¨p³k‰t‰‹£“5¡‰t‡Xˆ ˆ]«HŸQˆ]Št‘•'ˆo“d‰LŒ”FŠ‹ˆ]—t™X”‘‰‹—¶Q®<ˆ;’ ¬X‰Œ£“  W E c # ßwß5¶  ^ E T,#VX¶  U E c$# ,ß "X¶  ` E T+# /à k¶  E c$#BT-X¶  $ E T,#V ßX¶XŒ“5Ž  k E H c$# 2ß cX° Î 1M2( '  15!#)   (1(L(
2(#' ( %<Ê xÊ

†‡Xˆª]’ “d‰‹ŠŒ—t‰‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡X’ ”‘Ž·©l™X“Xª]‰‹£’ “X—¯Œ‰0©h’w™XŠ’wŠ‹‘ˆ]“H‰Œ‰‹‘’w“X—Mš c+*w¶ ',* ¶ 0 c+*¶<Œ“XŽ TSà +*]ž,ŒŠtˆ•'ˆSŒ—t™5Štˆ]Ž`° ¸j‰,‘——t‡X’®“[¬d¨#ˆo«w– ŸQˆ]Št‘•'ˆo“d‰LŒ”NŠtˆ]—‹™X”‘‰t—;‰t‡kŒ‰;‰t‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ,‘—“X’'—‹£¡ “X¢³kªŒ“d‰ŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“Xªoˆ¯¬kˆ]‰j®ˆ]ˆ]“p‰t‡5ˆ,ª]’ “H‰tŠŒ—t‰;‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘ŽX—;’F © c,*bšs‡X’ Št‘º]’w“H‰LŒ”sžŒ“XŽ 0 c,* šs² ˆ]Št‰‹‘ªŒ”sž—‹‰t‘•¯™X”‘j¶H“Xˆ]‘‰t‡5ˆ]Š;¬kˆ]‰j®ˆ]ˆ]“p‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘ŽX—;’J©  ,*Œ“5Ž TSà +*-—‹‰t‘•¯™X”‘j°E†‡XˆŽX¢­¼ˆoŠtˆ]“Xªoˆ¯¬kˆ]‰j®ˆ]ˆ]“p‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘ŽX—;’F © c,* ?,0 c+* Œ“5Ž ' * ? T2à  * —‹‰t‘•¯™X”‘`‘—-—‹‡X’®“µ‘“#ÕN£¡Q° -X¶N®‡Xˆ]Š‹ˆ¯®<ˆ¯—‹ˆ]ˆ'‰‹‡kŒ‰0‰t‡Xˆ¯—‹ˆ]“X—t‘‰‹£²H‘‰j¨p‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡X’ ”‘Ž#£—;”‘’®ˆ]Š;©h’ Š=Ž5 Œ¡w’ “kŒ”—t‰‹‘•¯™X”‘Y° ¤ŒŠLŒ•'ˆo‰tˆ]Š‹—<‘“µšlàwžŒŠtˆ;’w¬X‰LŒ‘“Xˆ]Ž©hŠt’ • ‰t‡5ˆ§³Q‰t‰t‘“X¡0©h™X“5ª]‰t‘’w“5—°†‡Xˆ]¨'ŒŠtˆ  ^ E H c #Vc c+wß5¶  U E c #BT5¶  ` E c$# /ß k¶  ^ E H c #Vwà5¶  U E c #V ßX¶ ` E $à # ,ß -שh’wŠ‡X’wŠ‹£ºo’w“H‰Œ” ?²wˆ]Š‹‰t‘ªŒ”F‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡X’ ”‘ŽX—°;ÕX’ Š’w¬X”‘‘˜H™Xˆ;‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡5’w”‘ŽX—¶ —Œ•bˆ;ŸkŒŠLŒ•'ˆo‰tˆ]Š‹—§ŒŠtˆ™X—‹ˆ]Ž©h’ Š ^ ¶* U Œ“5Ž  ` ¶X®‡5£”‘ˆ  ^ E H c$# 2X¶  U E c # "+X¶  ` E à #Vc,5°

0.9

1 Experimental data Exponential fitting function

0.8

Sensitivity threshold change

Sensitivity threshold change

0.9

0.7

0.6

0.8

0.7 Experimental data Fitting function 0.5 0.5

1 1.5 Contrast ratio (Cmask/C)

2

2.5

3

šhŒ ž

0.65 −3

−2

−1 0 1 Frequancy ratio f_mask/f (octaves)

š ¬kž

2

3


Ä
À  ¸j”‘”‘™X—‹‰tŠŒ‰t‘’w“[’©;‰t‡Xˆ•Œ—t H‘“X¡ˆL­Fˆ]ª]‰  —‹ˆ]“X—t‘‰‹£²H‘‰j¨#‰t‡5Štˆ]—‹‡X’w”‘ŽIªL‡kŒ“X¡wˆ]—¯™5“XŽXˆ]ŠbŽX¢­¼ˆ]Š‹ˆ]“H‰šhŒ žª]’w“H‰tŠLŒ—‹‰'Œ“XŽ šs¬Qž ©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xª]¨ŠLŒ‰t‘’ —°

2

Sensitivity threshold

10

1

10

0/90 degrees 45/135 degrees

0

1

10

10 Spatial frequency (cycle/deg)


 2ÄÀ ;¹§’ Št‘º]’ “d‰LŒ”?² ˆ]Št‰‹‘ªŒ”`Œ“XŽŽXsŒ¡w’ “kŒ”Q—tˆo“X—t‘‰t‘²H‘‰j¨¯‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡5’w”‘ŽX—° %<Ê&%Ê € J),1-'!
 15./ '

2(
" 2" 13  1 !
( !#2 1>(L!' " Û’w•bŸXŠtˆo—t—tˆoŽ 8 ˆ]“kŒ‘•Œ¡wˆo—F’©X—t‘º]ˆß + Ôß2,´®<ˆ]Š‹ˆ<™5—tˆ]Ž0©h’wŠN‘•Œ¡ ˆ`˜H™kŒ”£‘‰j¨;Œ—t—‹ˆ]—t—‹•'ˆ]“H‰¬kŒ—tˆ]Ž’w“-’ X™ Š“Xˆ]®#˜H™kŒ”£‘‰j¨;Œ—t—‹ˆ]—t—‹•'ˆ]“H‰



—t¨H—‹‰tˆ]•p°†®<’-‰j¨HŸQˆ]—’©ª]’w•bŸXŠtˆo—t—t‘’ “'—tªL‡Xˆo•'ˆ]—®ˆ]Štˆ-ŒŸXŸX”‘‘ˆ]Ž`° §“5ˆ=‘—‰t‡Xˆ-Ö;Û†–jª]’w•bŸXŠtˆ]—‹—tˆ]Žb™X—t‘“X¡‰t‡5ˆH¤E# Œ”‘¡ ’wŠt‘‰‹‡X• Œ‰ ‰j®’-¬X‘‰EŠŒ‰tˆ]—  cX° /à ;¬XŸ5Ÿ'®‘‰t‡'¤EœT¥=¦ E ß+X° dàŽ ;¶XŒ“XŽc5° à c¬XŸXŸb®£‰‹‡'¤EœH¥;¦ E ß 5° c TŽ =° †‡Xˆ’w‰t‡5ˆ]Š<‘—®ÔŒS² ˆ]”‘ˆ]‰j–jª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹ˆ]Ž 8Fˆo“kŒ¬d¨0™X—t‘“X¡;‰t‡5ˆ 8`ŒS¨wˆo Š QˆoŠt’w‰‹Štˆ]ˆ;ª]’HŽX‘“X¡¯,š 8 FÛžŒ”‘¡w’ Št‘‰t‡5• ª]’HŽXˆ]Ž'Œ‰ c5° 2ß c¬XŸ5Ÿ,®‘‰t‡¯¤EœH¥;¦ E ß,5°  TEŽ =°†‡5ˆ‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]ˆ§‘•Œ¡wˆ]— ®ˆ]Štˆ-’ ¬X—tˆoŠt²wˆoŽµŒ‰‰‹‡Xˆ;ŽX‘—t‰Œ“Xª]ˆ-’©`³k² ˆ;‰t‘•'ˆ]—‰t‡5ˆ-‘•Œ¡ ˆ<®‘ŽX‰‹‡`° ÕX’ Š§‰‹‡Xˆ,—LŒ•bˆ=ªo’w•'Ÿ5Štˆ]—‹—t‘’w“‰‹ˆ]ªL‡X“X‘˜H™Xˆw¶`¤xœH¥=¦A™X—t™kŒ”‘”£¨‘“XŽX‘ªŒ‰tˆ]—‰t‡Xˆ²H‘—t™kŒ”`ŸQˆ]Šj©h’ Št•Œ“Xª]ˆ0˜d™5£‰‹ˆ,®ˆ]”‘”j¶X—‹£“5ª]ˆ,‰‹‡Xˆª‡QŒŠj– Œªo‰tˆ]Š‹£—‹‰t‘ª]—¯’©§‰t‡XˆŒŠ‹‰t¢©YŒª]‰t—,ŒŠtˆ¡wˆo“Xˆ]ŠŒ”‘”£¨p‰t‡5ˆ'—Œ•'ˆw°"“Xˆ'ªŒ“·—LŒS©hˆ]”‘¨#—LŒS¨µ‰‹‡kŒ‰0©h’wŠ0‰t‡Xˆ‰j®’µÖ;Û†–Yª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹ˆ]Ž·‘•Œ¡wˆo—¶ ‡X‘¡w‡5ˆ]Š=¤EœT¥=¦ Štˆ]Ÿ5Štˆ]—‹ˆ]“H‰t—¬kˆ]‰‹‰tˆ]Š0˜d™QŒ”‘‘‰j¨d°¹§’®ˆ]² ˆ]Š¶Q©l’wŠ§Ž5Ò­Fˆ]Š‹ˆ]“H‰=ªo’w•'Ÿ5Štˆ]—‹—t‘’w“‰‹ˆ]ªL‡X“X‘˜H™Xˆ]—S¶2¤EœT¥=¦ ’©h‰tˆo“©YŒ‘”£—‰‹’'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]ŽX‘ª]‰ ‰t‡5ˆ˜H™kŒ”‘£‰j¨p’wŠ‹ŽXˆ]ŠS°·¾#ˆbª]’w•bŸkŒŠ‹ˆ]Ž·‰‹‡Xˆ˜d™QŒ”‘‘‰j¨µ•bˆ]‰tŠ‹£ªo—-©h’ Š,‰‹‡XˆÖ;Û†–Yª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹ˆ]ŽV‘•Œ¡ ˆšl¤EœH¥;¦ E ,ß 5° HàŽ ž¯Œ“XŽ[‰t‡Xˆ 8 FÛx–jª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹ˆ]Ž#‘•Œ¡ ˆ,šl¤EœH¥=¦ E ,ß X°  T-Ž ž]°Qѧ”‘‰‹‡X’w™X¡ ‡‰t‡5ˆ]—tˆ¯‰j®’£•Œ¡ ˆ]—§ŒŠ‹ˆ,ª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹ˆ]Ž#Œ‰=ŒŸXŸXŠ‹’«d‘•Œ‰tˆo”£¨b‰t‡Xˆ—Œ•'ˆ ¤EœH¥;¦[”£ˆo²wˆ]”j¶‰‹‡Xˆ]¨—t‡X’®VŽX¢­Fˆ]Štˆ]“H‰E²H‘—t™QŒ”XŒŠ‹‰t¢©YŒªo‰2ªL‡kŒŠŒª]‰tˆ]Š‹‘—t‰t‘ª]—S°E†‡Xˆ•Œ‘“-ŒŠ‹‰t¢©YŒªo‰©h’wŠ®ŒS²wˆ]”‘ˆ]‰Ú–Y¬QŒ—tˆoŽ,ª]’HŽX‘“X¡-Œ”£¡ ’wŠ‹£‰‹‡X•'— ‘—‰t‡Xˆ0Št‘“X¡w‘“X¡'ŒŠt‰‹Ò©jŒª]‰S¶X®‡X‘ªL‡ŒŸXŸQˆŒŠ‹—=Œ—§Št‘ŸXŸ5”£ˆo—=ŒŠ‹’w™X“5Ž‰‹‡Xˆ-ˆ]Ž5¡wˆ]—S°†‡X‘—§ŒŠ‹‰t¢©YŒªo‰¶kŒ”‘‰t‡X’ ™X¡w‡Œ”‘—‹’¯ˆ]«H£—‹‰t—£“Ö;Û†–j¬kŒ—‹ˆ]Ž ª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹£’ “`¶N£—”‘ˆ]—t—²H‘—t™kŒ”£”‘¨µŒ“X“X’¨H‘“X¡‰t‡kŒ“#‰t‡Xˆb¬X”‘’Hª H‘“X¡µŒŠt‰‹Ò©jŒª]‰S°¹§’®ˆ]²wˆ]ŠS¶‘‰-ªŒ“5“X’w‰¬kˆbŸXŠtˆoŽX‘ª]‰tˆ]ŽV¬H¨#¤EœH¥=¦ ²wŒ”¢– ™Xˆ]—S°;†‡XˆŽX‘—t‰t’ Št‰‹£’ “²wŒ”‘™Xˆo—§’©‰t‡Xˆ]—‹ˆ¯‰j®<’bª]’w•bŸXŠtˆo—t—tˆoŽµ‘•Œ¡wˆ]—¬H¨™X—‹£“5¡'’w™5Š=Ÿ5Št’wŸQ’w—‹ˆ]Žp•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆw¶FŒŠtˆ cXV° c ß ,0¯Œ“XŽ c5° c T+-X¶

Štˆo—tŸQˆ]ª]‰t‘² ˆ]”‘¨d° œH‘“Xª]ˆ‰‹‡Xˆ<¹»=œ0ª]’w“H‰‹ŠŒ—‹‰E—tˆo“X—t‘‰t‘²H‘‰j¨;‰t‡XŠ‹ˆ]—t‡X’ ”‘Ž¯£—NªL‡kŒŠLŒª]‰‹ˆ]Št‘º]ˆ]Žb¬H¨-‰t‡Xˆ—tŸQŒ‰tsŒ”w©lŠtˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“5ª]¨d¶ ŽXˆL³Q“Xˆ]Ž'Œ—Nª]¨Hª]”‘ˆ]—EŸQˆ]ŠEŽXˆo¡wŠtˆoˆw¶ ’w“5ˆ=—‹‡X’w™5”£Žˆ]«HŸQˆ]ª]‰‰t‡Xˆ;˜H™kŒ”‘‘‰j¨¯•'ˆSŒ—t™5Štˆ;²wŒŠ‹£ˆo—<®‘‰t‡‰‹‡Xˆ;ŠŒ‰‹‘’,’© ¶5‰t‡Xˆ;ŽX‘—‹‰Œ“5ª]ˆ-¬Qˆ]‰j®<ˆoˆ]“‰t‡5ˆ=’ ¬X—tˆoŠt²wˆoŠ=Œ“5Ž‰‹‡Xˆ;‘•Œ¡ ˆw¶ Œ“5
Ž ¶ ‰t‡Xˆ®‘ŽX‰‹‡¯’©F‰t‡Xˆ‘•Œ¡wˆ °k¾#ˆ™X—‹ˆ]ŽŒ;Ö;Û†–Yªo’w•'Ÿ5Štˆ]—‹—tˆ] Ž 8 ˆ]“kŒ;‘•Œ¡wˆ§š,cX° à/¬XŸXŸ`¶H¤EœH¥;¦ E ß,5° dàŽ ԞŒ“XŽ¯Œ®ÔŒS² ˆ]”‘ˆ]‰j– ª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹ˆ]? Ž 8Fˆ]“QŒ'‘•Œ¡wˆ0™X—t‘“X¡•¯¬kˆoŽXŽXˆ]Ž Qˆ]Š‹’w‰‹Štˆ]ˆb¾·ŒS²wˆ]”‘ˆ]‰šh Q¾Þž0Œ”‘¡w’ Št‘‰t‡X•ÓMš c5° àw߯¬5ŸXŸ`¶¤EœH¥=¦ E ß,-X°  "wž§Œ—;‰t‡Xˆ¯‰‹ˆ]—t‰ ‘•Œ¡wˆ]—S°EÕ`‘¡Q° 0—t‡X’®—‰‹‡Xˆ-Štˆo” Œ‰t‘’w“¬Qˆ]‰j®ˆ]ˆ]“‰‹‡Xˆ-ŠŒ‰t‘’'Œ“5Ž‰‹‡Xˆ-˜H™kŒ”£‘‰j¨¯•bˆŒ—‹™XŠtˆw°xѧ—‰‹‡Xˆ-ŽX‘—t‰LŒ“Xªoˆ-¬kˆo‰j®<ˆ]ˆo“µ‰‹‡Xˆ-’w¬5—tˆ]Š‹²wˆ]Š Œ“5Ž‰t‡Xˆ‘•Œ¡wˆ;‘“Xª]ŠtˆSŒ—tˆo—¶N‰t‡Xˆ—tŸkŒ‰tsŒ”N©hŠ‹ˆ]˜H™Xˆ]“Xªo£ˆo—-’©<‰‹‡XˆŽXˆ]‰Œ‘”£—šs‡X‘¡ ‡©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]¨pª]’w•bŸk’ “Xˆ]“H‰t—Lž¬Qˆ]ª]’ •'ˆ-ˆ]² ˆ]“p‡X‘¡w‡Xˆ]Š;—‹’ ‰t‡QŒ‰-‰‹‡Xˆ¯²H£—‹™kŒ”—‹¨d—‹‰tˆ]•)Œ‰t‰tˆo“d™QŒ‰t‘’ “p©YŒ‘”‘—§‰‹’ªSŒŸX‰‹™XŠtˆb‰t‡Xˆ¯ª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹‘’w“#ŒŠt‰‹¢©YŒª]‰S°†‡Xˆ]Štˆ7©h’wŠ‹ˆw¶‰t‡Xˆ¯ˆoŠtŠt’ Š,®‘”‘”ŽX‘•'‘“X‘—t‡Œ— ‰t‡5ˆ,²H‘ˆ]®‘“X¡'Ž5£—‹‰Œ“Xª]ˆ£“5ª]ŠtˆŒ—tˆ]—S° §“p‰t‡5ˆ,’ ‰t‡Xˆ]Š;‡kŒ“XŽ`¶Q’w“5ª]ˆ¯‰t‡Xˆ²H‘ˆ]®‘“X¡'ŽX‘—‹‰Œ“5ª]ˆ,‘—ŽXˆ]ª]Š‹ˆŒ—‹ˆ]Ž·‰‹’Œbª]ˆ]Š‹‰Œ‘“pˆ]«H‰tˆ]“H‰S¶F‰t‡Xˆ ®‡X’ ”£ˆŽXˆ]‰LŒ‘”‘—§’©Ô‰‹‡Xˆ,‘•Œ¡wˆ;‰‹’‰‹‡XˆŸX‘«dˆo”2”‘ˆ]² ˆ]”<ŒŠtˆŸkˆ]Š‹ª]ˆ]‘²wŒ¬5”£ˆ °,†‡5ˆ,˜H™kŒ”£‘‰j¨•'ˆSŒ—t™5Štˆ®£”‘”N¬kˆ‰t‡H™X—-ªo”£’ —tˆ‰t’Œ¯ªo’w“X—‹‰Œ“H‰ ®‡Xˆ]“p‰t‡5ˆ,²H‘ˆ]®‘“X¡¯ŽX‘—t‰LŒ“Xªoˆ,‘—;—t•Œ”‘”‘ˆ]Š<‰‹‡kŒ“p‰t‡5£—ŽX‘—t‰LŒ“Xª]ˆ ¶F™X“H‰t‘”`‰‹‡Xˆ¹§»=œpŒ‰‹‰tˆ]“H™kŒ‰t‘’w“pŒ‰§”‘’® ©hŠtˆo˜d™5ˆ]“Xª]‘ˆ]—-‰LŒ  ˆ,’² ˆ]Š=Œ‰ ˆ]«H‰tŠ‹ˆ]•'ˆo”£¨¯ªo”£’ —tˆ;ŽX‘—t‰LŒ“Xªoˆ]—¶5®‡X‘ª‡®‘”‘”k”‘’®ˆ]Š‰t‡Xˆ;ŸQˆ]Štª]ˆo£² ˆ]Žˆ]Š‹Št’ Š¬d¨Œ-˜H™X‘‰‹ˆ§—t•Œ”‘”Qˆ]«H‰tˆ]“H‰°†‡5 ˆ ‹¬kˆo—t‰ *b²H£ˆo®£“5¡-ŽX‘—t‰LŒ“Xª]ˆ —t‡5’®“‘“‰‹‡Xˆ;³k¡ ™XŠtˆ0£—;Œ¬Q’w™X‰  TYc‰t‘•'ˆ]—’©E‰t‡Xˆ-‘•Œ¡wˆ®‘ŽX‰‹‡`¶X®‡5£ªL‡‘—ª]’ “X—t‘—‹‰tˆ]“H‰;®‘‰t‡‰‹‡Xˆ-Št™5”£ˆ0’©E‰t‡H™X•¯¬b£“ŸXŠLŒª]‰‹‘ªŒ” ‘•Œ¡wˆ²H‘ˆ]®‘“X¡,—‹‘‰t™kŒ‰t‘’w“X—S° 0.03

0.025

Quality measure

0.02

0.015

0.01

0.005

0 0

JPEG−compressed Lena image EZW−compressed Lena image 5

10 15 20 Ratio of viewing distance to image width

25

30


 2ÄÀ ™kŒ”‘£‰j¨¯•bˆŒ—‹™XŠtˆ;Œ—§Œ0©h™5“Xª]‰t‘’ “’©2‰‹‡Xˆ;²d‘ˆ]®‘“X¡ŽX‘—t‰LŒ“Xªoˆ-‰t’¯‰‹‡Xˆ;£•Œ¡ ˆ®£Ž5‰t‡ŠŒ‰t‘’k°

¾#ˆ;ªŒ“Œ”‘—‹’,—‹ˆ]ˆ;©hŠ‹’w•ÜÕN‘¡k° 00‰t‡kŒ‰‰t‡Xˆ Q ¾V–jª]’w•bŸXŠtˆ]—‹—tˆ]Ž£•Œ¡ ˆ<‡kŒ—§Œ”‘’®<ˆ]Š˜H™kŒ”‘‘‰j¨¯ˆ]Š‹Št’wŠ•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ§‰‹‡kŒ“‰t‡QŒ‰’©‰t‡Xˆ d¤x#–jª]’w•bŸXŠtˆ]—‹—tˆ]Žp‘•Œ¡wˆw¶XŒ”£‰‹‡X’w™5¡w‡‰t‡Xˆª]’ •'ŸXŠ‹ˆ]—t—‹£’ “ŠŒ‰‹‘’'‘——t•Œ”‘”‘ˆ]Š°†‡X‘—§‘—ª]’w“X—‹‘—t‰tˆo“d‰;®‘‰t‡‰t‡Xˆ-—‹™X¬w±Lˆ]ªo‰t‘²wˆ¯ŠLŒ“X H‘“X¡ ’©‡H™X•Œ“¯’w¬X—‹ˆ]Št² ˆ]Št—S°

xÊ …Í Ì … Ð[‚ Ë Í Ì

¸j“‰‹‡X‘—Štˆ]—‹ˆŒŠ‹ª‡N¶F®<ˆ0ŸXŠt’ Ÿk’ —tˆ]ŽµŒ®ÔŒS² ˆ]”‘ˆ]‰§ŒŸ5ŸXŠt’HŒªL‡‰t’'•b’HŽXˆ]”F‰t‡5ˆ-‡H™X•Œ“'²H‘—t™kŒ”F—t¨H—t‰‹ˆ]• š ¹§»=œ5ž]°X†‡5ˆ-¹=Œ ŒŠ§®ŒS²wˆo”£ˆo‰®ÔŒ— —t‡5’®“¯‰t’;ŸXŠt’²H‘ŽXˆˆ]«XŒª]‰E”‘’HªŒ”Xªo’w“H‰tŠLŒ—t‰x²wŒ”‘™Xˆ]—E‘“ˆŒªL‡¯Š‹ˆ]—t’ ”£™5‰t‘’w“`¶HŒ“5Ž¯ª]’w•bŸX™X‰Œ‰t‘’w“QŒ”w•b’HŽXˆ]”‘—`’©¼²H‘—t™kŒ”X•'ˆoª‡QŒ“X‘—t•b—`®ˆ]Štˆ ‘“Xª]’ ŠtŸQ’wŠŒ‰tˆ]Ž#‘“H‰t’pŒ'“5ˆ]® ˜d™QŒ”‘‘‰j¨•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹ˆ]•'ˆo“d‰—t¨H—t‰‹ˆ]•µ°«HŸQˆ]Št‘•'ˆo“d‰‹—-—t‡5’®<ˆ]Ž#‰‹‡kŒ‰0¹=ŒwŒŠ³k”‘‰tˆ]Š‹—,‡kŒS² ˆ¯¡w’H’HŽ Œ¬X‘”‘£‰j¨‰‹’ —t‘•¯™X”sŒ‰tˆ‰t‡5ˆ-¹§»;œF¶XŒ“XŽ‰‹‡Xˆ-Štˆo—t™X”‘‰t‘“X¡¯“5ˆ]®Þ•bˆ]‰tŠ‹‘ª§®Œ——t™5ª]ª]ˆ]—‹—j©h™X”x£“b•'ˆŒ—t™XŠ‹‘“X¡,ªo’w•'Ÿ5Štˆ]—‹—tˆ]Ž‘•Œ¡wˆ§ŒŠ‹‰t¢©YŒª]‰t—S°

xÊ € … Ì Í

2

Î   Ì ƒ‚

†‡X‘—Štˆ]—‹ˆŒŠ‹ª‡‡kŒ—¬kˆoˆ]“b©h™X“XŽXˆoŽ¬H¨¯‰‹‡Xˆ§¸j“H‰tˆo¡wŠŒ‰tˆ]Ž›ˆoŽXsŒ,œH¨H—‹‰tˆ]•b—ÔÛˆ]“H‰‹ˆ]Š¶QŒ-¥;Œ‰t‘’ “kŒ”kœTª]‘ˆ]“Xª]ˆ,Õ5’w™5“XŽkŒ‰‹‘’w“'“X¡ ‘“Xˆ]ˆ]Š‹£“5¡ ¦ˆo—tˆŒŠtªL‡qÛˆo“d‰‹ˆ]Š`®‘‰‹‡×ŒŽXŽX‘‰t‘’ “kŒ”—‹™XŸXŸQ’wŠt‰ ©hŠt’ •I‰t‡5ˆEѧ“X“5ˆ]“H¬kˆ]Š‹¡-Ûˆ]“H‰tˆ]Š ©h’wŠ`Û’ •'•¯™X“X‘ªŒ‰t‘’w“Œ‰F‰‹‡Xˆ“X‘²wˆ]Š‹—t‘‰j¨§’©5œT’w™X‰‹‡Xˆ]Št“ ÛŒ”‘¢©h’ Št“XsŒ§Œ“XŽ¯‰t‡5ˆ=ÛŒ”‘¢©h’ Št“XsŒ†ŠLŒŽXˆ§Œ“XŽ'Û’w•b•'ˆ]Š‹ª]ˆ<Ñ¡wˆ]“5ª]¨d°†‡5ˆ§Œ™X‰‹‡X’wŠ‹—<®’w™X”‘Ž”‘£  ˆ‰t’-‰‹‡kŒ“5 qÖŠ° k'° 8FQ’©`œH‡kŒŠtŸ 8`Œ¬N° ©h’ Š‡X‘—<²wŒ”£™QŒ¬X”‘ˆ§Ž5£—‹ª]™X—‹—t‘’w“X—;Œ“XŽb—t™XŸ5Ÿk’ Št‰©l’wŠ‰t‡5£—®’wŠ‹ F° „ I„  Ì … ¯‚

!#"%$#&('*),+-.!/102",354.&64!78,09;:%$=<>",35-$?35@ABC$D02!/135",EGF35",HI",HJ$?8%D02!#$LKM#4N4C"31&;"%$>B!#./@A$>",H24NOP' QSRNTVUPWXMTY[Z.\.T^]V_*T]`' a 4!/M[bN'Jc4(=d'Ne;e(f.dNf!g.h;f.diC'>jCjd

f ;N!#"%$#&(')  H;EN8,35<=!/@ 4NO$L/27M4! ",HJ$ <>4.&;",#8%"8%$L&28,35",35-35",E4.7",HJ$HN02@A!& $>EC$' Q 31&
Y 
 Z.\        ;_   Z ! " #$%&  Z.\ $ $ ' ( )+*, - X.&/* # W0&# 1


'Ne;e(32b h bfN'>jjf  i J[$L#B$#&
!&2O54/6V07I31/58%4!&I.&JO
)8094.F.&(' );:0#",H2$L $>-35O$#&J<>$*7M4!7M4!0;V@A$=< H2!&;358%@A8V@A$>ON35",31&2B -358,354!& " ",H#$=8,HJ4./5O=< 8%$L&28,35",35-35",3 $=8"%4A<=4@e;/5$$ >B.#",31&2B8V.&JO !e[$L%354NON35<=",35-35",ES4!7 ",HJ$HN02@A.&S-358,02!/V8%EN8%"%$=@' Q6RNT I 1B Z&5T ' a 4./M ANb ' e;e([gCiNb hgJg 2 '(=j ?K? 2C  :L 7 9 C@e;9[$L/1/M' ( E 0;/1-3 FN4.F G8 FN3M'!&2OI0 M($=-31&J8%4.&('*G) NH2$? $ O[$><>"V4.7 4!%35$#&;"%",354!&G4.&I",HJ$ -358,0J./#$>8%4!/102",354!&G4.7 B!#C",31&JBC8>' QGRNT I 1B Z &5T ' a 4!/M$ ANbN'e;e(2gNfCb hNgCi ?;'>j ?K? ?C  :0 7L 9C@e9 $L/1/.&JO/ 6 4.9J8%4.&('V;) P e;e/135<=",354!&G4.Q7 :4.0%35$L*.&J./5EN8,358A"%4?",HJ$*-358,319;31/ 35" E4!7 B!#C",31&JBC8>' QIRNT I 1B Z &5T ' a 4!/M=jNb ' e;e(L 2K2 LRh 2B?K?'[.&(>Kj ?A b C SL 7 9 .&&24!&'!.5' ) $L#<>$L35-C$>OI<>4!&;",#C8%" 31&I",H2$7M4.-$> .&JO e[$L%31e;H2$L#E' QSRNT UPWXMT^Y Z!\.T]V_*T]`' a 4!/M f '[e;e( Bb ?Cd!hJ Bb ?KA' H <>"> >Kj A 2N A,  9 " 6V" 9.%/58%4!&'A) T31&2$LK F.-$",H;#$>8,H24!/5OG<>4!&;",#C8%",K,8%$#&J8,35",35-35" E 7 0;&J<=",354!L& $ 4!&GON358,e/5.EI8,#3 U>$' W Q VX[Y ] VQ@Z@ @[(' a 4!/M gi' e;e(0 ?b 2 Jh ?ACi'(=j Af  j, TJ0 8 !/5EC' G) NHJ$V-358,319;/5$?O -3 O $L#$L&2<>$>8 e;#$>O 35<="%4!@< !&
./5B4.%35",HJ@ 7 4!",HJ$*8%8%$=8%8%@A$L&;" 4.735@ABC]$ \2O;$L/135",E' Q 31&IY ^
_Q Z! \    JJC    ;` _  a"  Z !b" #$%&  Z. \ $ $ ' ( )* - .X &/*, M0W &# 1


'Ne;e(LhJc 2 '>jjf  >d, d ) 8 .09[$=< H;35$>8>,' e!@gf0#\!.X   $ Z ahi ZB$&#.X LR' T!d.PS'[>jCjNf    8 .0JBC@A!&'A;) N F4!K ON35@A$L&28,354!&2!/*8,e[$><=",#!/!&2!/5EN8,358 4!7",HJ$ <>4!#",35<=!/ #$><>$Le2",35-g$ \2$L/5OIe#4@\/5$>8>' j Q "  Z V$$   \ I ' a 4./M f!d' e;e(0 ACgNb Jh A 2@?0' H <=">(>Kj Ad; .f C EA  EAK 8 $ a ./54!358.&JO?+ % T F35G" F$>8>') T35@`0;/5"%!&2$>4!028 @ G8 FN31&2B31&;"%$L#<=",354!&28 9 $>",F$=$L& < H;#4@AC",35< .&JOA/102@31&J.&J<=$B.#",31&2B8>' Q RNTUPWXMT Y[Z.\.T[]V_T ' a 4!/M b!i';ee(CLh2$ A' !&(=j Ai; >iC 6V/ M/ 8 $ a !/54.358 .&J5O EA% EA% 8 $ a ./54!358>'Y)W N.X &"  Z J' H>7M4.#O5k &;35-$L#8,35" E#$>8%8>'(=j AA; >g L S" :J4!/5$=E'*G) 4 02@A.&/10J@*31&J.&J<>$e2"%"%$#%&K -358,354!&6@ $>< H2!&;358%@A$8 e[$#%35@A$L&;"%8A#$>D0;31#$ &2$>F @A4NO$#/M' QGRNTU[WX TY[Z.\!T ]V_T]`' a 4!/M';ee( b =d!hJ b =j'!0;&J$A=jjg; @2 C 8  !9[4..' G) NH2$>4!#E?4!7<=4@A@V0&;35<>C",354!&' QIRNT
!=XMT  &#L\.XMT   NT lmf[ Z )N Z n!' a 4!/M2ji;'e;e(2gNf!j.hNJg 2b '=jKg ? $?C SL P  !#< p o .K,q $Lo #$$UC'm) Te2<=$LK -!.%35!&;"A-358,02!/ e;#4N<>$>8%8,31&2!B < 8,eJC",35!/1/5E/135@35"%$>OG-358,0J./ < H2!&;&2$L/58>' QGY)W NrX '&s  Z ' a 4!/Mi'c 4 f ' e;e( f!j!h2>gf '(=j AKA .b C SL P !#< p o !K q $#o #$$U'V;) N H2$e[$##<>$L35-$=O 35@ABC$ jjf  $AC S/ P*2 $>4!#BC$>8%4!&' ) 94!&;",#C8%" 4.-$##<>4!&28%"%!&2<>E' Q
RNT U[WX T(Y Z!\.T2]`_*T]`' a 4./M/ A;' e;e0 2b.j!Rh 2BA?;0' S !.>jj; >jC S0 P $=4!#B$=8%4!&!&2O0 8*L T0;/1/135-.!&'*) 94.&;",#8%" <=4!&28%"%!&2<>/E D02$L&2<>E < H2!&;&2$L/58>' Q RNT "I 1@$ Z &5T5' a 4!/M f 2fN'e;e(0 ?fb> h ? 2@?'>jNKb 2  f!d, TJ/ 4 $=< H;">' G) NHJ$V-358,02!/ON358%< H;&2$L /5.FV' v Q ubB2T "I 1@$ Z &5T5' a 4!/M b 'e2f!g;'(=jNf.g f C 6V( :L 4 $=8%8>(' P*[^#ON/5$>E'!&2 O M[ 354C",#4!F G8 FN3M'*) 94.&;",#8%",K <>4NON31&JB 31&I@V9;/5E4!e;35D d 0 8 -3 O[$L#$L&2<>$>831& ",HJ$&2$L0;#!/928,358*4!7 HN0J@A.& @V9;/5E4!e;35' Q  Z.\.(T V T(Y Z!\.(T f[ Z )N Z  3Y   (T w' a 4./M[f  b ';eeJiCdj!hiiCd'>Kj Ai; ff  / EV.358%$L.'a ] x  @/!
b %  VXMyZ [" ZB$&#.X L'^31FN"H .z 0J8%$#.'^=jjg; f!i, TJ^ P*" E /5$L31&b' NV 9!%&2$>E' M^ !#B!H24!02",mK T "%$#31&('!&2_ O 9  7 NE/5$L.' ) TN$>-$L_ & S 4NO;$L/584.C7 S G8 FN31&2B' Q 31& Y 
{Q Z. \    ' |%}   ;` _  a"  Z y /  &##\.X  Z / \
_ @ J

!' :2$L9(>jCjNb  f!g J+ / M$>BBC$';) P e 4!F $L /5.FS7M4!<>4.&;",#8%" O 358%<#%35@31&JC",3 4.&(' { Q " #$ Z yVQ$   \ I ' a 4!/M f ';eeJJg 2b>hNg ?b '=j AC f2  J+ / M$>BBC$V!&2O
% S/ :J4./5$>E'm) 94!&;",#8%" @ACG8 FN31&JB?31& HN0J@ !&
-358,354!&' QRNTUPWXMT(Y[Z.\.T[]V_T5' a 4!/M b!d;'e;e(> g 2@A!h2>gNbN'=j Ad; fB?+ J$L/13M' m) 9 4.&;",#8%"31&
<>4C@e/5$ >35@ABC$>8>' Q
RNTU[WX T(Y Z!\.T[]V_*T[]`' a 4./M[bN'e;e( f!dif h f!dgCdL' H <>">[=jjd; fb + ^$#/13M'?) T0e;#",H;#$>8,H24!/5O <>4.&;",#8%"e $L#<>$Le2",354!&6C$>8?31&S@A$>.& /102@31&2!&2<>$ <
$ O[$><="%8 4.7V8%",35@V0/10288,#3 U=$'ON35< H24!e2",35< e;#$>8%$L&;"%",354.&('!&2O/5$L&2B",H
4.7O;!e2",354!&' QRNTUPWXMT Y Z!\.T2]`_*T[]`' a 4!/M.f ';ee/ A;.b> h ANf.i0' S .E >jC j 2  fBA+  $L/13M' M^ +  P #$L&2O['Vb S ~^4.0&2B'!&2 O 6V    4./5O8%"%$L31&'
) 94!&;",#C8%"8%$L&28,35",35-35",E "%4 e2"%<%H68%",35@V0/1.3 <>"%84.7A8,e2",35./ 92!&2OF35O;",H.&JO "%$>@*e[4!#./(e;#$>8%$L&;"%",354.&(' Q YC/W N.X &"  Z ' a 4./M[bN'Jc 4;['e;e(Lh2>g;'(>jCji; f!j  9 H31/1/131e28?!&2 O 4L 6V0 7 31/58%4!&'Am) H %35$L&;"%",354.&I9J.&JO;F35O",H28?4!7 8,e2",35./ @A$><%HJ.&358%@ 8A@A$>C8,0#$>O
9;E @AG8 FN31&2B' QSRNT U[WX TY[Z.\!T ]V_T]`' a 4!/M'Neef@f ?!h f!iNfN/' :J$#9(>j ACg idC 6VL T ">4.H&'[ 0 N35@&2$>EL' EAJ+ 0 P #@A8%",#4.&JB;'[!&2 O P*J L T ULe2B F[') 9^H2!&2B$>8 31&
e[$L#<>$#35-$>O<=4!&;",#8%"V4.78,0e;#",H;#$>8,H24!/5OIB!#C",31&JBC8 87 0;&J<=",354!&
4!74.%35$L&;"%",354.&.&JO 8,e2",35./7 #$>D02$L&2<>E' QY)W N.X &Q" #$ Z ;' a 4!/M f 'Jc4;i';ee[fCf!i.h;f!if '=j ANbN iC P2 0 7
"%8%4!&
.&JO% P3 T 4./54@A4.&('V;) P @A4NO;$L/4!7-358,02!/ <>4.&;",#8%" BC!31&<>4!&;",#4./!&2OeJC"%"%$L%&
@ACG8 FN31&JB;'  Q e;gZ LWN)W     RNT UPWXMT Y[Z.\.T[]V_T[]*T ' a 4./M(>g;'(=jjNbN