Desert Peoples Archaeological Perspectives Edited by
Peter Veth (Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait I...
80 downloads
1940 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Desert Peoples Archaeological Perspectives Edited by
Peter Veth (Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies), Mike Smith (National Museum of Australia), and Peter Hiscock (The Australian National University)
Desert Peoples
Desert Peoples Archaeological Perspectives Edited by
Peter Veth (Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies), Mike Smith (National Museum of Australia), and Peter Hiscock (The Australian National University)
ß 2005 by Blackwell Publishing Ltd BLACKWELL PUBLISHING 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148-5020, USA 108 Cowley Road, Oxford OX4 1JF, UK 550 Swanston Street, Carlton, Victoria 3053, Australia The right of Peter Veth, Mike Smith, and Peter Hiscock to be identified as the Authors of the Editorial Material in this Work has been asserted in accordance with the UK Copyright, Designs, and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs, and Patents Act 1988, without the prior permission of the publisher. First published 2005 by Blackwell Publishing Ltd Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Desert peoples: archaeological perspectives / edited by Peter Veth, Mike Smith, Peter Hiscock. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1-4051-0090-7 (hardcover: alk. paper) — ISBN 1-4051-0091-5 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Desert people. 2. Archaeology. I. Veth, Peter Marius. II. Smith, M. A. III. Hiscock, Peter, 1957– GN390.D47 2005 306’.09154—dc22 2004014009 A catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library. Set in 10.5/13pt Minion by Kolam Information Services Pvt. Ltd, Pondicherry, India Printed and bound in the United Kingdom by T J International Ltd, Padstow, Cornwall The publisher’s policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp processed using acid-free and elementary chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publisher ensures that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. For further information on Blackwell Publishing, visit our website: www.blackwellpublishing.com
Contents
Notes on Contributors
vii
1 Global Deserts in Perspective
1
Mike Smith, Peter Veth, Peter Hiscock, and Lynley A. Wallis
Part I Frameworks
15
2 Theoretical Shifts in the Anthropology of Desert Hunter-Gatherers
17
Thomas Widlok
3 Pleistocene Settlement of Deserts from an Australian Perspective
34
Peter Hiscock and Lynley A. Wallis
4 Arid Paradises or Dangerous Landscapes: A Review of Explanations for Paleolithic Assemblage Change in Arid Australia and Africa
58
Peter Hiscock and Sue O’Connor
Part II Dynamics
79
5 Evolutionary and Ecological Understandings of the Economics of Desert Societies: Comparing the Great Basin USA and the Australian Deserts
81
Douglas W. Bird and Rebecca Bliege Bird
6 Cycles of Aridity and Human Mobility: Risk Minimization Among Late Pleistocene Foragers of the Western Desert, Australia
100
Peter Veth
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
v
________________________________________________________________________________
Contents
7 Archaic Faces to Headdresses: The Changing Role of Rock Art Across the Arid Zone Jo McDonald
116
8 The Archaeology of the Patagonian Deserts: Hunter-Gatherers in a Cold Desert Luis Alberto Borrero
142
Part III Interactions
159
9 Perspectives on Later Stone Age Hunter-Gatherer Archaeology in Arid Southern Africa Anne I. Thackeray
161
10 Long-Term Transitions in Hunter-Gatherers of Coastal Northwestern Australia Kathryn Przywolnik
177
11 Hunter-Gatherers and Herders of the Kalahari during the Late Holocene Karim Sadr
206
12 Desert Archaeology, Linguistic Stratigraphy, and the Spread of the Western Desert Language Mike Smith
222
13 People of the Coastal Atacama Desert: Living Between Sand Dunes and Waves of the Pacific Ocean Calogero M. Santoro, Bernardo T. Arriaza, Vivien G. Standen, and Pablo A. Marquet
243
14 Desert Solitude: The Evolution of Ideologies Among Pastoralists and Hunter-Gatherers in Arid North Africa Andrew B. Smith
261
15 Hunter-Gatherer Interactions with Sheep and Cattle Pastoralists from the Australian Arid Zone Alistair Paterson
276
16 Conclusion: Major Themes and Future Research Directions Peter Veth
293
General Index
301
Index of Archaelogical Features and Subjects
303
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
vi
________________________________________________________________________________
Notes on Contributors
Bernardo T. Arriaza is Professor of Physical Anthropology at the University of Nevada, Department of Anthropology and Ethnic Studies, Las Vegas, and Visiting Researcher at Centro de Investigaciones del Hombre en el Desierto, Universidad de Tarapaca´ Arica, Chile. The focus of his research is the bio-cultural adaptation and evolution of prehistoric Andean populations. He has taught bio-anthropology at both undergraduate and postgraduate levels in the Unites States, Chile, Argentina, and Mexico. Douglas W. Bird is an Assistant Research Professor in the Climate Change Institute and Department of Anthropology at the University of Maine. He grew up in the Great Basin and has spent the last few years working with Martu peoples in Australia’s Western Desert. He was educated at the University of Utah and University of California, Davis. His research focuses on foraging ecology and its archaeological implications in small-scale societies. Rebecca Bliege Bird is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Anthropology at the University of Maine. She received her PhD in Anthropology from the University of California, Davis in 1996. After a long-term ethnographic project in the Torres Strait, she began working with the Martu community in 2000. She is especially interested in the ecology of foraging and gender, and the role of women’s economic activities in shaping Martu land management strategies. Luis Alberto Borrero received his PhD from the Universidad de Buenos Aires in 1986. He is a Senior Archaeologist at the Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Cientificas y Tecnicas and Professor at the Universidad de Buenos Aires. He has worked widely in Patagonia, with an active research interest in hunter-gatherers.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________
vii
______________________________________________________________________________
No t e s o n C o n t r i b u t o r s
Peter Hiscock is a Reader in the School of Archaeology and Anthropology at The Australian National University. He is a leading researcher into prehistoric stone technology, with a record of developing models about prehistoric (Paleolithic) technology, both in Australia and elsewhere. He has worked extensively in, and published widely on, the Australian deserts, although his current focus is the analysis of European Paleolithic technologies. Jo McDonald is Managing Director of Jo McDonald Cultural Heritage Management Pty Ltd. She completed her PhD at The Australian National University in Canberra. Her thesis used information exchange theory to understand the regional variability in a dual media art system in the Sydney Basin, in southeastern Australia. In addition to managing a cultural heritage consultancy business in Sydney, her current research interests lie in the prehistoric graphic systems of the Western Desert. Pablo A. Marquet is Associate Professor in the Center for Advanced Studies in Ecology and Biodiversity and Departamento de Ecologı´a, Pontificia Universidad Cato´lica de Chile, Santiago. The focus of his research is in the emergent discipline of macroecology, centered in the search for general principles that underlie the structure and function of ecological systems. Sue O’Connor is a Senior Research Fellow in the Department of Archaeology and Natural History at The Australian National University in Canberra. Her research interests include issues of colonization and technological and subsistence change in northern Australia and Island Southeast Asia. Alistair Paterson is an archaeology lecturer at the University of Western Australia. He researches the archaeology of colonial Australia and culture contact. He has published in a range of leading Australian journals and contributed to the Encyclopedia of Historical Archaeology. Kathryn Przywolnik completed her PhD at the University of Western Australia in 2000. Her thesis explored issues of long-term hunter-gatherer occupation and mobility on the arid Cape Range Peninsula in coastal northwest Western Australia. She has worked on a range of historic and precolonial archaeological excavations and field surveys throughout Australia, and her current research interests include environmental and social constructions in archaeology. She is currently employed as an archaeologist with the Department of Environment and Conservation (NSW) in Sydney. Karim Sadr’s PhD is based in the School of Geography, Archaeology, and Environmental Studies at the University of the Witwaterstrand in Johannesburg. His current research interest is the transition to food production in Southern Africa.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
viii
______________________________________________________________________________
Notes on Contributors
Calogero M. Santoro is a Full Professor of Archaeology, Executive Director of the Centro de Investigaciones del Hombre en el Desierto, Universidad de Tarapaca´ Arica, Chile and co-editor of the journal Chungara Revista de Antropologı´a Chilena. His research focuses on late prehistoric farming societies and the Inka state, and Holocene hunter-gatherers in the Atacama Desert. Andrew B. Smith is Associate Professor in the Department of Archaeology, University of Cape Town, Rondebosch. His research interests include the origins and development of herding societies in Africa, the prehistory of modern Saharan pastoralists, relations between hunters and herders at the Cape, and the origins of Khoekhoen. Mike Smith is Director of Research and Development at the National Museum of Australia. He is an internationally recognized field archaeologist, researcher, lecturer, and museum curator, having pioneered research into late Pleistocene settlement of the Australian desert. He has published widely in leading international journals. Vivien G. Standen is Professor of Bioarchaeology at the Centro de Investigaciones del Hombre en el Desierto, Universidad de Tarapaca´ Arica, Chile and co-editor of the journal Chungara Revista de Antropologı´a Chilena. Her research focuses on both the cultural and environmental factors that shaped the prehistoric populations that inhabited the Atacama Desert, examining both hunter-gatherers and farmers. Anne I. Thackeray is an Honorary Research Associate in the Archaeology Division of the School of Geography, Archaeology, and Environmental Studies at the University of the Witwaterstrand in Johannesburg. Her research interests focus on the stone tools of the southern African Middle and Later Stone Ages, and she writes on wide-ranging African archaeological topics for non-specialist readers. Peter Veth is Head of the Research Section at the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies in Canberra. He has conducted extensive archaeological research throughout the arid zone of Australia and has produced over 200 academic articles, chapters, books, and peer-reviewed reports focusing on desert archaeology, ethno-economics, cultural heritage issues, and native title. Peter has given invited lectures on these topics in the USA, UK, Europe, and Southeast Asia. Lynley A. Wallis is a Visiting Research Fellow in the Department of Archaeology and Natural History at the Australian National University in Canberra, where she completed her PhD in 2001. She is currently researching the timing and nature of Aboriginal occupation in the semi-arid region of northwest Queensland, human– paleoenvironmental interactions during the Late Quaternary, and the application
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
ix
________________________________________________________________________________
No t e s o n C o n t r i b u t o r s
of phytolith analysis to archaeological and paleoenvironmental research questions in northern Australia Thomas Widlok completed his MSc and PhD in anthropology at the London School of Economics, where he has also taught. Currently he lectures in anthropology at the University of Heidelberg and leads an interdisciplinary research project at the Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics in Nijmegen (Netherlands). He has conducted long-term ethnographic field research in Namibia and Australia and has published on these regions as well as comparative work on settlement patterns, language change, and ritual dynamics.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
x
________________________________________________________________________________
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Global Deserts in Perspective Mike Smith, Peter Veth, Peter Hiscock, and Lynley A. Wallis
Introduction For centuries, deserts have captured the public imagination as places of extremes. These are landscapes that might be perceived as impenetrable barriers to human occupation or instead as the domain entered into by individuals pursuing a revelatory experience. They are of course also the same terrain through which the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers passed and which, when hydraulically ‘‘tamed,’’ became the agricultural powerhouses of the Near East. Desert societies have also been central to the anthropological imagination. The classic ethnographies of hunter-gatherer societies – of the Ju/’hoansi (!Kung), the Paiute and Shoshone, the Arrernte, Pitjantjatjara, and Pintubi – all deal with desert peoples. Surprisingly, very few analyses have adopted a comparative perspective on a global scale (however, see Peterson 1979). This volume aims to bring together studies which, as a corpus, allow us to take a comparative approach to the emergence and diversity of global desert societies. Over the last century, hunter-gatherer studies have moved from a social evolutionary perspective at the close of the nineteenth century (Spencer and Gillen 1899), to structural-functionalist or cultural ecology frameworks in the twentieth century (Gould 1969; Lee 1979; Steward 1938). The Man the Hunter symposium (Lee and DeVore 1968) promulgated a now popular model of hunter-gatherer society, the ‘‘generalized forager’’ model, which was based substantially on these desert hunter-gatherer groups. Under this model, generalized foragers shared five basic characteristics: egalitarian society; low population density; lack of territoriality; minimal food storage; and fluid band composition with changes in residential mobility used to maintain social ties and reduce intragroup conflict – though it remains to be determined whether these are characteristic of foragers in desert environments, rather than hunter-gatherers in general. The elements of this socioeconomic model had been formulated in Steward’s (1938) pioneering study of
____________________________________________________________________________________
1
________________________________________________________________________________
S mith , V e t h, H is c oc k , W a l l i s
Great Basin Shoshone and Paiute foragers. This model was reinvigorated during the 1970s, and at that time !Kung bushmen came to be seen as the quintessential hunter-gatherers. A review of social and behavioral variability in hunter-gatherers shows that there is a wide spectrum of hunter-gatherer societies if groups living in other types of habitats are included in the analysis (Kelly 1995). Over the last 20 years, hunter-gatherer research has shifted towards either behavioral ecology (Smith and Winterhalder 1992) or historical analyses of these societies (e.g., Schrire 1984; Wilmsen 1989). (For accessible interdisciplinary overviews of hunter-gatherer studies, see Lee and Daly 1999 or Panter-Brick et al. 2001.) In putting this volume together, we felt that it was time to reframe questions about the structure and dynamics of foraging groups, using the desert environment as a frame of reference and comparison. Deserts have a special role in human evolution and adaptation. They appear to be the major terrestrial habitat that channeled early human dispersal, representing barriers at some times, corridors at others (cf. Gamble 1993). Studies of desert societies have also provided some of the most fertile ground for debates about human adaptability and how societies cope with marginal – often precarious – environmental circumstances, and about the effects of these environmental conditions on human land use, mobility, and dispersal (Kelly 1995). How do societies in marginal environments actually deal with risk in either a reactive or strategic sense? Many desert foragers in the ethnographic record appear to have responded by changing their diet-breadth and residential mobility. For others, such as in the Old World deserts of the Northern Hemisphere, the proximity of deserts to the major zones of plant and animal domestication appears to have provided a mutual ecology for change, in both the mode and relations of production. The long-term dynamics of both desert societies and the desert environment are not readily accessible to analysis using standard ethnographic or historical approaches. For this, the longer perspective provided by archaeology is necessary. The emphasis of this volume is therefore squarely on deserts as a major world habitat, on hunter-gatherer peoples in deserts, and on the rapidly growing body of archaeological data on the deep history of these groups.
Deserts: A Modicum of Facts and Figures Deserts are one of the world’s major habitats, forming large bands of drylands along the tropics in both the Northern and Southern Hemispheres (see Mares 1999 and Middleton and Thomas 1997 for overviews of world deserts). A recent map of the extent of world deserts has been produced by the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) (see Middleton and Thomas 1997) and is reproduced here as Figure 1.1. Deserts cover around 25,500,000 sq km, approximately 20 percent of the land area of the world (see Table 1.1). The boundaries of these drylands are neither static nor abrupt: they have changed throughout the Quaternary in response to shifts in global climate and weather systems – and will no doubt change over the next century as human-induced global warming takes effect. The defining
____________________________________________________________________________________
2
________________________________________________________________________________
Gl ob a l D e s e r t s i n P e r s p e c t i v e Table 1.1 Area of world deserts by region and zone. Figures are square kilometers x 1,000,000 (after Middleton and Thomas 1997: table 1.1). Zone
Africa
Asia
Australia
Europe
North America
Arid Hyperarid Total
5.04 6.72 11.76
6.26 2.77 9.13
3.03 0.00 3.03
0.11 0.00 0.11
0.82 0.31 1.13
South America
Total
0.45 0.26 7.02
15.69 9.78 25.47
characteristic of world deserts – aridity – can be measured in a number of ways. The current UNEP definition is that it represents a moisture deficit under normal climatic conditions where P/PET <0.20; that is, where rainfall is less than 20 percent of potential moisture loss through evaporation. Several factors interact to determine the intensity of aridity: . Atmospheric stability. Most deserts are low latitude deserts, made of two latitudinal bands along the tropics (238N and 238S) produced by patterns of atmospheric circulation. . Continentality. Deserts are often found in the interior of continents where the reach of maritime air masses is less pronounced. This is often accentuated by topography and by cold ocean currents. . Topography. High mountain ranges can form barriers to moist maritime air masses and create rain-shadow deserts, as in the case of central Asia and Patagonia. . Cold ocean currents. Low sea-surface temperatures along the west coasts of continents reduce sea-surface evaporation and contribute to aridity, such as along the Namib and Atacama coasts, by reducing the effectiveness of maritime air masses. This highlights the extreme variability in these habitats, which range from great continental deserts (such as the Sahara, Kalahari, and Australian deserts) to basinand-range or montane deserts (such as North America’s Great Basin or the Puna in northwestern Argentina), coastal deserts (like the Namib or Atacama), or regions where aridity is substantially increased by the rain-shadow effect of nearby mountains (such as in the central Asian deserts, or in the Patagonian deserts). There is also great variability in the intensity of aridity in world deserts. The eastern Sahara in North Africa, the Atacama in northern Chile, and the Namib in southwestern Africa all receive little or no rainfall today and are referred to as hyperarid regions. In these environments life revolves around springs or shallow groundwater seepages, stream flows from the Andes Cordillera (in the case of the Atacama), or moisture from coastal fogs (in the case of the Namib). Outside of the scattered oases or well-watered ravines, absolute desert has few resources for a huntergatherer population. In contrast, the Kalahari Desert receives relatively good rainfall (250–500 mm per annum) but the deep porous Kalahari sands mean that
____________________________________________________________________________________
3
________________________________________________________________________________
S mith , V e t h, H is c oc k , W a l l i s
NORTH AMERICA Atlantic Ocean Great Basin Deserts (Bird & Bliege Bird, Chapter 5)
Sahara Desert (Hiscock & O'Connor, Chapter 4; A. Smith, Chapter 14)
Pacific Ocean SOUTH AMERICA Atlantic Ocean
Atacama Desert (Santoro et al., Chapter 13)
0
Patagonian Deserts (Borrero, Chapter 8)
5000 km
Hyperarid
____________________________________________________________________________________
4
________________________________________________________________________________
Gl ob a l D e s e r t s i n P e r s p e c t i v e
ASIA
EUROPE Pacific Ocean
Western Desert (Bird & Bliege Bird, Chapter 5; Veth, Chapter 6; McDonald, Chapter 7; M. Smith, Chapter 12)
AFRICA
Indian Ocean
NW Coastal Desert (Przywolnik, Chapter 10) AUSTRALIA Namib & Kalahari Deserts (Widlok, Chapter 2; Hiscock & O'Connor, Chapter 4; Thackeray, Chapter 9; Sadr, Chapter 11)
Southern Ocean Australian Deserts (Widlok, Chapter 2; Hiscock & Wallis, Chapter 3; Paterson, Chapter 15)
Arid
Semi-arid
Figure 1.1 Map of world drylands based on UNEP aridity index (after Middleton and Thomas 1997: figure 6). Hyperarid ¼ areas that have very limited and highly variable rainfall amounts, both interannually and on a monthly basis; Arid ¼ areas that have mean annual precipitation up to about 200 mm in winter rainfall areas and 300 mm in summer rainfall areas; interannual variability in the 50–100 percent range; Semi-arid ¼ areas with highly seasonal rainfall regimes and mean annual values up to ca. 800 mm in summer rainfall areas and ca. 500 mm in winter rainfall areas; high (25–50 percent) interannual variability.
____________________________________________________________________________________
5
________________________________________________________________________________
S mith , V e t h, H is c oc k , W a l l i s
this is quickly lost: in effect, the Kalahari ‘‘thirstland’’ is an edaphic desert. The Australian deserts also receive comparatively good rainfall and like the Kalahari are well vegetated: the challenge here for people is the pronounced interannual and decadal variability in rainfall in such deserts, which are subject to a ‘‘boom and bust’’ cycle over decades.
Desert People: Some Issues Current UNDP/UNSO statistics indicate that around 313 million people (about 13 percent of the total population) currently live in the world’s arid zones, with 92 million alone residing in hyperarid deserts. These figures include significant urban populations, reliant on resources (and often water) imported from outside the zone, especially in Africa, South America, Arabia, and central Asia. It is likely that prior to the rise of cities and agricultural or pastoral communities, the proportion of world population in deserts would have been significantly greater. Deserts are difficult environments for hunter-gatherers not just because scarcity of water and other resources are limiting factors. These are environments where resources are patchy and highly variable in both time and space. Often, small parts of the wider landscape – springs, groundwater discharge zones, run-on areas – are the key to utilization of the wider region. Rainfall events create pulses of biological productivity separated by long dormant periods and these are largely unpredictable in time and space. Desert environments are characteristically subject to high interannual, decadal, and millennial variability in rainfall. In deserts, much of the ecosystem is geared towards a pattern of ‘‘pulse and reserve’’ (a term coined by the desert ecologist Immanual Noy Meir) or ‘‘boom and bust’’ that people also use and exploit for their own needs – social as well as economic. Deserts are also highly patchy environments in which nutrients and/or water are concentrated in patches within a larger, less productive landscape. Most desert hunter-gatherers are water-tethered to some degree, but in the Australian and southern African deserts, where there are significant plant and animal resources thinly distributed throughout the desert, it is the distribution of small surface waters, seepages, wells, and springs that provides access to the desert hinterland and a means of stepping through the country; like navigating through islands on the sea (cf. Veth 1993). Hunter-gatherers in these environments have strategies which involve high residential mobility, broad-spectrum foraging, and a high degree of organizational and technological flexibility. Not all contemporary deserts, however, conform to this pattern. In the Atacama, for instance, the desert hinterland is absolute desert with no appreciable biological resources. All productivity is concentrated in the widely separated oases and ravines. Such an extreme environment favors greater investment in territoriality, ‘‘landesque’’ infrastructure such as semi-sedentary villages and storage facilities, and a higher level of management of wild herd animals and wild plant foods. Generalities about the relationship between the economic/social strategies of human groups and the nature of deserts in which they live provide an insight into
____________________________________________________________________________________
6
________________________________________________________________________________
Gl ob a l D e s e r t s i n P e r s p e c t i v e
the historical patterns of human existence in arid lands. However, the present is not simply an iteration of the past, and explorations of ancient human colonization and settlement of deserts must deal with at least two complexities. First, past environments in which humans lived were often different, sometimes radically so, to those where people were observed in recent times. The opportunities and constraints of those different ecosystems provided the context for early settlement strategies, and archaeological interpretations of past desert lifeways must therefore be set within a framework of the environmental history of each landscape. The second complexity involves the question of what adaptive strategies equipped people to move into deserts for the first time; what kinds of economic tactics had emerged in other landscapes that prepared human groups for survival in the variable and extreme conditions of a desert. A related question is when, and in what conditions, did the economic and social systems visible in historic desert settlement arise; and how far back in time can we recognize those forms of cultural organization? When did people first settle these precarious environments? Archaeological evidence indicates that people have a long presence in the African deserts. Early Stone Age or Acheulian sites are reported from the Namib and Kalahari, where they are associated with ancient river courses, and in the eastern Sahara, where they are associated with artesian springs and lake deposits (e.g. at Bir Tarfawi). One of the perennial difficulties with the interpretation of such data is in determining whether this reflects exploitation of favorable patches within a desert environment or whether these areas were semi-arid savannas at that time. By the Middle Stone Age (ca. 60,000 years ago) there is good evidence for establishment of a resident hunter-gatherer population in the southern Namib Desert. The Australian deserts were widely occupied by 40,000–30,000 bp, though the nature of this occupation is still being worked out – and most researchers agree that early settlement may have been patchy. Any discussion of the initial colonization of deserts now draws on a significant body of archaeological and biological theory about the likely pattern of dispersal into new environments and the use of patchy or mosaic environments such as deserts (for overviews, see Clobert et al. 2001; Forman 1995; Rockman and Steele 2003; Shigesada and Kawasaki 1997). In both the archaeological and biological literature, a distinction is conventionally made between the exploratory or pioneer phase of initial colonization and later establishment of a full settlement system. For instance, Beaton (1991) distinguishes between ‘‘transient explorers’’ and ‘‘estate settlers.’’ Where settlement of the desert took place early, this distinction is hard to isolate using current archaeological data. Our best chance of analyzing the process of settling a new desert is in the Americas, given the relatively short prehistory of these regions. A recent review of the early settlement of North America (Haynes 2002) suggests that this two-phase model of desert colonization may be applicable there. During the Clovis period, hunters used lake and spring sites within the desert southwest (including the Mojave Desert), but wider settlement of the desert – and adaptation to desert plant resources such as seeds – did not occur until later during the early Archaic phase. Most deserts have also seen periods of enhanced rainfall, fluvial activity, groundwater discharges, and greater biological activity in
____________________________________________________________________________________
7
________________________________________________________________________________
S mith , V e t h, H is c oc k , W a l l i s
the past. There is an opportunity here – provided we can get a clear definition and resolution of these changes in time and space – to look at how human societies have dealt with these periods of expanding or contracting living space and opportunities.
Outline of this Book The chapters in this volume help shape a fresh and more comparative perspective on desert archaeology. When approached by Blackwell Publishing to commission a series of comparative chapters on this topic we quickly found that, except for pockets of research, this was largely a new area. Much of the archaeological research in deserts has simply been framed in other terms – responding either to general questions embedded in national and regional prehistories, or dominated by wider debates (e.g. the great Kalahari debate; megafaunal extinctions; the emergence of complexity in hunter-gatherer society; interpretation of lithic assemblages, etc.). Only in Australia, the world’s driest continent, with more than 3,000,000 sq km of desert or drylands, has the desert become an explicit focus for research into the dispersal and adaptation of humans, and the long-term dynamics of huntergatherer settlement in desert environments. The chapters in this volume have been written to introduce a new generation of students and general readers to broad issues in the archaeology of desert huntergatherers, complementing an earlier book, The Archaeology of Drylands (Barker and Gilbertson 2000), that looked at the archaeology of agricultural societies in drylands. The focus here is on hunter-gatherers. Over half of the case studies presented draw on Australian data, reflecting the level of interest in desert research there. About half the chapters look at southern African or American deserts (the Great Basin, the Atacama, and Patagonia). The major gaps in global coverage are the Middle Eastern and central Asian deserts, despite the editors’ attempts to commission material on these areas. The book is organized into three parts, which are developed further as introductory comments before the relevant chapters. In summary, the parts are: Frameworks. This part provides wide-ranging discussion of key temporal, ethnographic, and interpretive frameworks employed in studies of desert huntergatherer groups from around the world. Dynamics. This part provides a range of archaeological perspectives on the longterm dynamics of desert societies. Archaeology now provides a finer-grained historical picture of desert hunter-gatherers, showing long-terms shifts in economy and land use – but as these chapters caution, such changes are not necessarily incremental or directional. Interactions. Clearly, there are a range of factors shaping desert societies that are not environmental. Some are social and/or political, and derive from the position of desert societies on the margins of demographically dominant populations surrounding the deserts, and their interactions with these groups.
____________________________________________________________________________________
8
________________________________________________________________________________
Gl ob a l D e s e r t s i n P e r s p e c t i v e
Further themes which emerge from many of these chapters include the nature of early desert hunter-gatherer societies, the technological and organizational responses of such groups to encroaching aridity, the role of art as a mediating factor in desert occupation, the relationship between language spread and huntergatherer settlement patterns, and the timing of occupation of all desert habitats and the climatic backdrop against which people’s estates became established. One of the fundamental issues addressed by this volume is the degree to which landscapes were indeed ‘‘marginal’’ or challenging when first explored/occupied by humans (e.g. Chapters 3 and 5). We know from regional paleoenvironmental records in Australia that climate has changed significantly since colonization by anatomically modern humans approximately 50,000 years ago and importantly that phases of aridity have followed more lacustral regimes (and vice versa). The freshwater lakes of western New South Wales which once supported abundant fish and shellfish resources are now salt lakes bordered by shifting sand fields (Johnston et al. 1998). In many regions early colonists will likely have experienced desert landscapes which were less ‘‘marginal’’ than their contemporary configurations. Indeed, it has been argued that early colonists of Australia were competent exploiters of the interior portions of the world’s most arid continent and were not effectively tethered to the coast (cf. O’Connor and Veth 2000). Critical to any such review is the global timing for desert occupation and what this implies about the competencies of anatomically and culturally modern humans. Do in fact humans occupy deserts early on, or only where these were semi-arid and less ‘‘marginal’’ landscapes? Is there evidence for occupation of all desert habitats early on? Are these occupations as early as other modern behaviors, such as the first sea crossings (from the Wallacean islands to the landmass of Greater Australia) or the earliest dated expression of art? The complexities of addressing this question are raised in Hiscock and O’Connor’s discussion (Chapter 4) of the ambiguities found in many identifications of modernity, revealing that this is not merely an issue that can be resolved by substantive investigations of the timing of desert occupation but which is additionally entangled in our conception of modernity in humans. Another critical issue is the degree to which deserts are actually homogeneous and represent a uniform bloc of physical attributes. Do they have uniform characteristics both across subregions and through time? How real is the concept of the desert culture bloc and the conservative nature of the societies occupying such a monolithic construct? The chapters from Australia, Africa, and the Americas suggest that this assumption needs to be challenged at a number of levels. When an ecological and biogeographic approach is taken in an examination of desert systems (after Smith 1989; Veth 1993) it becomes apparent that adjacent areas are likely to have presented a variety of optimal situations for huntergatherers to establish different kinds of habitation loci, to target varied prey, to engage in different forms of residential and logistical mobility patterns, and to engage in different rhythms of aggregation and dispersion depending on local and regional climate patterns. For Aboriginal groups to structure their use of the Lake Eyre Basin of Australia, which only receives floodwaters from the north on average
____________________________________________________________________________________
9
________________________________________________________________________________
S mith , V e t h, H is c oc k , W a l l i s
once every ten years, is a very different scenario to the persistence of human occupation in the central Australian ranges, where permanent water ‘‘oases’’ have been present since the Tertiary period (cf. Hughes and Hiscock in press). Not only is physical variation across desert systems arguably of relevance to hunter-gatherers; there are also the different climate histories which will have impact at both the regional and local levels and which will serve to make conditions either more marginal and ‘‘risky’’ or increase the productivity and reliability of economic resources – both inviting changes in social and technological organization. The need to accurately contextualize the archaeological record against an environmental framework has, in the past, been hampered by our rudimentary knowledge of the impacts of changing climatic conditions on arid regions across the world (Veth et al. 2000; see also Chapter 3, this volume). This is largely seen as a direct consequence of the general absence of appropriate, uninterrupted data-sets on which to base interpretations, and environmental conditions that are often not conducive to the preservation of organic materials. While dry, arid conditions can be excellent for the preservation of macroscopic organic remains in sheltered archaeological sites, they usually result in extreme degradation of fragile pollen grains in open contexts that otherwise would serve as vegetation markers allowing inferences to be made about climatic change. Reconstruction of climate based on pollen analyses in arid regions is further frustrated by the absence of useful indicator types and the generally non-specific nature of the grassland pollen types which usually dominate such assemblages. Nevertheless, in recent decades a more sophisticated understanding of environmental change in arid regions has begun to emerge. Forced by necessity, paleoenvironmental researchers interested in the arid zone have focused on sedimentary, stratigraphic, geochemical, mineralogical, and geomorphological investigations of fluvial and lacustrine systems (e.g., Bowler 1998; Magee and Miller 1998; Vogel 1989). In addition, recent developments in luminescence and U-series dating have greatly assisted the study of aeolian sediments, tufa formations, and speleothems in arid landscapes (e.g., Brook et al. 1996; Brook et al. 1999). More novel data-sets relevant to paleoenvironmental research in lowaltitude deserts within Australia, South America, and North America include botanical materials preserved in stick-nest rat middens (e.g., Betancourt et al. 1990; Latorre et al. 2002; Pearson and Dodson 1993). Tufa formations, speleothems, and mud-wasp nests have also been recently recognized for their value in preserving vegetation indicators, such as pollen and phytoliths, in arid regions of the world (e.g., Burney et al. 1994; Roberts et al. 1997; Wallis 2002, 2003). Other data of relevance to reconstruction of desert environments may sometimes be available from offshore marine cores that preserve indicators such as diatoms, foraminifera, pollen, phytoliths, isotopes, and charcoal, as well as from high resolution coral records. Similarly, ice cores in or adjacent to high-altitude deserts offer unique insights into climate change, often at a much higher resolution than is typically afforded by the archaeological record (e.g., Shimida et al. 1991; Thompson et al. 1998). Proxy data from archaeological cave sites (such as faunal remains, macrofloral material, phytoliths, and charcoal) may also provide valuable clues as to what the
__________________________________________________________________________________
10
_______________________________________________________________________________
Gl ob a l D e s e r t s i n P e r s p e c t i v e
environment was like in the past (e.g., Bowdery 1998; Esterhuysen and Mitchell 1996; McConnell and O’Connor 1997; Robbins et al. 1996; Smith et al. 1996; Wallis 2001). However, the interpretation of such assemblages in terms of paleoenvironmental reconstruction is considerably more difficult, owing to the potential bias in the materials present caused by anthropogenic behaviors. In summary, there is still an enormous amount of work to be carried out in placing archaeological sequences from what are now deserts in to accurately reconstructed past environmental contexts. Overall, this book is intended as an issues-based volume, rather than a series of regional overviews, but each chapter includes extended case studies illustrating key issues. A similar interdisciplinary approach (but on a different topic) was successfully adopted in The Archaeology of Prehistoric Coastlines (Bailey and Parkington 1984) and we believe that a comparable examination of human life in deserts provides an equally productive and provocative framework for future work. There is a strong international demand for knowledge about the dynamics of human settlement in arid regions. The history of humans in arid lands can be used as a tool for developing knowledge about the evolution of desert systems, and understanding environmental changes currently underway there or likely to take place in the near future. We hope this volume satisfies at least some of this demand. Finally, the editors wish to pay special thanks to Carrie Robson and Lynley Wallis from the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies for their expertise during final preparation and copy-editing of the manuscript; and also to Emily Martin and Jane Huber from Blackwell Publishing. References Bailey, G. and Parkington, J. (eds) 1984: The Archaeology of Prehistoric Coastlines. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Barker, G. and Gilbertson, D. (eds) 2000: The Archaeology of Drylands. London: Routledge. Beaton, J. M. 1991: Colonizing continents: Some problems from Australia and the Americas. In T. D. Dillehay and D. J. Meltzer (eds), The First Americas: Search and Research, Boca Raton: CRC, 209–30. Betancourt, J. L., Van Devender, T. R., and Martin, P. S. (eds) 1990: Packrat Middens: The Last 40,000 Years of Biotic Change. Tuscon: University of Arizona Press. Bowdery, D. 1998: Phytolith Analysis Applied to Pleistocene–Holocene Archaeological Sites in the Australian Arid Zone. Oxford: BAR International Monograph Series no. 695, Hadrian Books. Bowler, J. M. 1998: Willandra Lakes revisited: Environmental framework for human occupation. Archaeology in Oceania, 33, 120–55. Brook, G. A., Cowart, J. B., and. Marais, E. 1996: Wet and dry periods in the southern African summer rainfall zone during the last 300 kyr from speleothem, tufa, and sand dune age data. Palaeoecology of Africa, 24, 147–58. Brook, G. A., Marais, E., and Cowart, J. B. 1999: Evidence of wetter and drier conditions in Namibia from tufas and submerged cave speleothems. Cimbebasia, 15, 29–39. Burney, D. A., Brook, G. A., and Cowart, J. B. 1994: A Holocene pollen record for the Kalahari Desert of Botswana from a U-series dated speleothem. The Holocene, 4 (3), 225–32.
__________________________________________________________________________________
11
_______________________________________________________________________________
S mith , V e t h, H is c oc k , W a l l i s Clobert, J., Danchin, E., Dhondt, A. A., and Nichols, J. D. 2001: Dispersal. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Esterhuysen, A. B. and Mitchell, P. J. 1996: Paleoenvironmental and archaeological implications of charcoal assemblages from Holocene sites in western Lesotho, southern Africa. Palaeoecology of Africa, 24, 233–40. Forman, T. T. 1995: Land Mosaics: The Ecology of Landscapes and Regions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Gamble, C. 1993: Timewalkers: The Prehistory of Global Colonization. Phoenix Mill: Alan Sutton Publishing. Gould, R. A. 1969: Subsistence behavior among the Western Desert Aborigines of Australia. Oceania, 39, 253–74. Haynes, G. 2002: The Early Settlement of North America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Hughes, P. and Hiscock, P. in press: The archaeology of the Lake Eyre South area. In Aboriginal Occupation of the Lake Eyre South Region: Ethnography and Archaeology, Adelaide: Lake Eyre Monograph Series no. 6, Royal Geographical Society of South Australia. Johnston, H., Clarke, P., and White, J. P. (eds) 1998: The Willandra Lakes: People and Palaeoenvironments. Sydney: Archaeology in Oceania no. 33 (3), Oceania Publications. Kelly, R. L. 1995: The Foraging Spectrum: Diversity in Hunter-Gatherer Lifeways. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Latorre, C., Betancourt, J. L., Rylander, K. A., and Quade, J. 2002: Vegetation invasions into absolute desert: A 45,000 year rodent midden record from the Calama-Salar de Atacama basins, northern Chile (lat 220 – 240S). Geological Society of America Bulletin, 114 (3), 349–66. Lee, R. B. 1979: The !Kung San: Men, Women, and Work in a Foraging Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Lee, R. B. and Daly, R. 1999: The Cambridge Encyclopedia of Hunters and Gatherers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Lee, R. B. and DeVore, I. (eds) 1968: Man the Hunter. Chicago: Aldine. McConnell, K. and O’Connor, S. 1997: 40,000 year record of food plants in the southern Kimberley ranges, Western Australia. Australian Archaeology, 45, 20–31. Magee, J. W. and Miller, G. H. 1998: Lake Eyre paleohydrology from 60 ka to the present: Beach ridges and glacial maximum aridity. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 144, 307–29. Mares, M. A. 1999: Encyclopedia of Deserts. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press. Middleton, N. and Thomas, D. 1997: World Atlas of Desertification (2nd edn). London: Arnold. O’Connor, S. and Veth, P. (eds) 2000: East of Wallace’s Line: Studies of Past and Present Maritime Cultures in the Indo-Pacific region. Rotterdam: Modern Quaternary Research in South East Asia no. 16, A. A. Balkema. Panter-Brick, C., Layton, R. H., and Rowley-Conwy, P. 2001: Hunter-Gatherers: An Interdisciplinary Perspective. Cambridge: Biosocial Symposium Series no. 13, Cambridge University Press. Pearson, S. and Dodson, J. R. 1993: Stick-nest rat middens as sources of paleoecological data in Australian deserts. Quaternary Research, 39, 347–54. Peterson, N. 1979: Territorial adaptations among desert hunter-gatherers: The !Kung and Australians compared. In P. Burnham and R. Ellen (eds), Social and Ecological Systems, London: Academic Press, 111–29.
__________________________________________________________________________________
12
_______________________________________________________________________________
Gl ob a l D e s e r t s i n P e r s p e c t i v e Robbins, L. H., Murphy, M. L., Stevens, N. J., Brook, G. A., Ivester, A. H., Haberyan, K. A., Klein, R. G., Milo, R., Stewart, K. M., Matthiesen, D. G., and Winkler, A. J. 1996: Paleoenvironment and archaeology of Drotsky’s Cave: Western Kalahari Desert, Botswana. Journal of Archaeological Science, 23, 7–22. Roberts, R. G., Walsh, G., Murray, A., Olley, J. M., Jones, R., Morwood, M., Tuniz, C., Lawson, E., Macphail, M., Bowdery, D., and Naumann, I. 1997: Luminescence dating of rock art and past environments using mud-wasp nests in northern Australia. Nature, 387, 696–9. Rockman, M. and Steele, J. (eds) 2003: Colonization of Unfamiliar Landscapes: The Archaeology of Adaptation. London: Routledge. Schrire, C. (ed.) 1984: Past and Present in Hunter Gatherer Studies. Orlando, FL: Academic Press. Shigesada, N. and Kawasaki, K. 1997: Biological Invasions: Theory and Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Shimida, I., Schaff, C. B., Thompson, L. G., and Mosley-Thompson, E. 1991: Cultural impacts of severe droughts in the prehistoric Andes: Applications of a 1,500 year ice core precipitation record. World Archaeology, 22 (3), 247–70. Smith, E. and Winterhalder, B. (eds) 1992: Evolutionary Ecology and Human Behavior. New York: Aldine. Smith, M. A. 1989: The case for a resident human population in the central Australian ranges during full glacial aridity. Archaeology in Oceania, 24, 93–105. Smith, M. A., Vellen, L., and Pask, J. 1996: Vegetation history from archaeological charcoals in central Australia: The late Quaternary record from Puritjarra rock shelter. Vegetation History and Archaeobotany, 4, 171–7. Spencer, B. and Gillen, F. J. 1899: The Native Tribes of Central Australia. London: Macmillan. Steward, J. 1938: Basin-Plateau Aboriginal Sociopolitical Groups. Smithsonian Institution, Bureau of American Ethnography Bulletin 120. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. Thompson, L. G., Davis, M. E., Mosley-Thompson, E., Sowers, T. A., Henderson, K. A., Zagorodnov, V. S., Lin, P. N., Mikhalenko, V. N., Campen, R. K., Bolzan, J. F., Cole-Dai, J., and Francou, B. 1998: A 25,000 year tropical climate history from Bolivian ice cores. Science, 282, 1858–64. Veth, P. M. 1993: Islands in the Interior: The Dynamics of Prehistoric Adaptations within the Arid Zone of Australia. International Monographs in Prehistory, Archaeological Series no. 3, Ann Arbor, MI. Veth, P. M., O’Connor, S., and Wallis, L. A. 2000: Perspectives on ecological approaches in Australian archaeology. Australian Archaeology, 50, 54–66. Vogel, J. C. 1989: Evidence of past climate change in the Namib Desert. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 70, 355–66. Wallis, L. A. 2001: Environmental history of northwest Australia based on phytolith analysis at Carpenter’s Gap 1. Quaternary International, 83–5, 103–17. Wallis, L. A. 2002: AMS dates and paleoenvironmental data from mud-wasp and bird nests at Carpenter’s Gap 1, northern Australia. Australian Archaeology, 55, 35–9. Wallis, L. A. 2003: Phytoliths and other microfossils in tufa formations as a novel source of palaeoenvironmental data. In D. M. Hart and L. A. Wallis (eds), Proceedings of the Stateof-the-Art in Phytolith and Starch Research in the Australian, Pacific, and South East Asian Regions, The Australian National University: Pandanus Press, 31–42. Wilmsen, E. N. 1989: Land Filled with Flies. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
__________________________________________________________________________________
13
_______________________________________________________________________________
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Part I
----------------------------------------------------------------
Frameworks
The authors of part one provide a series of fundamental chronological, ethnographic, and interpretive frameworks that reveal patterns of desert hunter-gatherer life. The case studies are diverse, with Thomas Widlok (Chapter 2) employing African and Australian ethnographies; Peter Hiscock and Lynley Wallis (Chapter 3) focusing on the archaeology of Australian foragers; and Peter Hiscock and Sue O’Connor (Chapter 4) comparing the African and Australian archaeological sequences as a way of evaluating explanatory frameworks for tool assemblage changes in deserts and beyond. Despite the different case studies presented in these chapters a series of underlying themes connect them, and these themes are reinforced by their presentation and representation in diverse explorations of desert life. For instance, each of the chapters contains an exploration of the reality of the ‘‘eternal character’’ (Widlok) so often attributed to deserts. The illusory nature of images of unchanging and invariant adaptations to uniformly harsh and static desert environments is clearly explicated in the different arguments of each chapter. While Hiscock and Wallis (Chapter 3) discuss the consequences of long-term climatic shifts for human occupation in the late Pleistocene, Widlok (Chapter 2) neatly explores the complex interaction of social alterations in hunter-gatherer practices in recent times and the nature of anthropological activities. Rejection of normative and fixed pictures of desert life is essential in our search to understand the complexity of human existence in deserts across the globe. In their consideration of cyclical archaeological phenomena, Hiscock and O’Connor (Chapter 4) raise critical questions about the explanation of archaeological changes and the complexities of employing ethnographic models for ancient archaeological materials. These contributions explicitly raise questions about the way in which ethnographic information can be employed in reconstruction of desert lifeways, and challenge archaeologists to develop a critical awareness of the issues involved in employing ethnographic information as an aid to archaeological interpretation. The themes of part
___________________________________________________________________________________
15
_______________________________________________________________________________
Frameworks
one – awareness of the variability in desert life and of the intricacy of employing ethnographic images of that life in archaeological reconstructions – are also displayed in the chapters studying the long-term dynamics of human life in arid lands.
___________________________________________________________________________________
16
_______________________________________________________________________________
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Theoretical Shifts in the Anthropology of Desert Hunter-Gatherers Thomas Widlok
Introduction: Hunter-Gatherer Studies and Anthropological Theory Hunter-gatherer studies have been critical to anthropological thinking in different ways and at various points in the history of the discipline. There have been discernible shifts in the relationship between hunter-gatherer studies, anthropological theory, and public imagery for well over 150 years (Barnard 1999). Huntergatherers played an important role in the imagination and theorizing of many thinkers of the enlightenment period and more specifically in the development of various kinds of evolutionary theories. These emerging relationships were fueled and intensified through early ethnographic work on hunter-gatherers, such as that of Boas (1888) and Spencer and Gillen (1899). However, by the time that the practice of extended fieldwork was firmly established in social and cultural anthropology, interest had moved away from hunter-gatherers to the study of villages or segmentary clan structures. None of the classic ethnographic monographs in the ‘‘golden age’’ of British social anthropology, for instance, deal with a hunter-gatherer group (for example, Radcliffe-Brown’s 1922 study on the Andamans is far less widely read than his other work). This was due to the mutually reinforcing relations between the early twentieth century theoretical focus on social and cultural structures and the preparation of village case studies exemplifying these structures. Scholarly fascination with hunter-gatherers seems to have only returned in full force towards the latter half of the twentieth century. Although this shift was initially against dominant anthropological interests in issues such as complex symbolic systems and lineage structures, it became increasingly informed by new theoretical interests in process, flexibility, and the dynamics of social and cultural forms.
___________________________________________________________________________________
17
_______________________________________________________________________________
T h o m a s Wi d l o k
There are good historically oriented surveys that outline this broad pattern of the shifting role of hunter-gatherer studies within anthropology (e.g., Barnard 1983; Bender and Morris 1988). This chapter will highlight some of the key features that characterize theoretical shifts in the anthropology of desert huntergatherers and the ways in which these are linked to more general developments in hunter-gatherer studies and in anthropology.
Entering the Field – Leaving the Desert When anthropological work based on long-term ethnographic field research became the standard research strategy in the early twentieth century, ironically many desert hunter-gatherers were moving in the opposite direction, leaving their home habitat and coming to live as fringe dwellers at the margins of the colonized world. At the same time many anthropologists, and especially those who relied on diffusion to explain the spread and change of culture, continued to talk about desert hunter-gatherers as ‘‘retreating’’ into the desert. The characterization as Rest-und Ru¨ckzugsvo¨lker (remaining and retreating peoples), as they were known in German anthropology (cf. Schott 1956), led to one of the first major theoretical debates in the study of desert hunter-gatherers. In the first Kalahari Debate, branches of the German culture history school of anthropology were divided on the issue of whether or not the Bushmen of the Kalahari were ‘‘secondary primitives.’’ Were the Bushmen dislocated remnants of a more complex original hunter-gatherer culture in the ecologically more fertile areas of the Cape or, instead, ‘‘original’’ hunter-gatherers (see Szalay 1986)? The original scenario that Bushmen had retreated to previously uninhabited desert regions was seriously flawed mainly because there was no evidence that the communities of living hunter-gatherers of the Kalahari had moved there in recent times. Indeed, there is archaeological evidence to clearly show that the opposite was the case (see Chapter 11, this volume). What remains a critical issue to this day, however, is to what extent their desert dwelling lifestyle is representative for a hunter-gatherer way of life more generally, especially with regard to the hunter-gatherers who have inhabited the moderate and cold zones in Europe in the remote past. The fact that most hunter-gatherers in more moderate climates were culturally and physically destroyed or absorbed before systematic ethnographic field research began is one of the major and given limitations for research in this field. The question of representativeness is therefore one that can only be resolved in small steps with an investigation into the details of various aspects of hunter-gatherer life and with full recognition of the large spectrum of historical and regional variation that has undoubtedly occurred. Speculations about a ‘‘retreat’’ of hunter-gatherers into the remote deserts notwithstanding, many hunter-gatherers de facto moved out of the desert as ethnographers began to move into the field to gain a better understanding of this way of life. For instance, one of the most influential representations of desert hunter-gatherers, namely Ian Dunlop’s oeuvre of films, was made possible only because the filmmakers took two Aboriginal families back into the desert that they
___________________________________________________________________________________
18
_______________________________________________________________________________
T he A n t h r o p o l o g y o f D e s e r t H u n te r -G a t h e r e r s
had decided to leave. In the 1960s the last remaining desert dwelling Aborigines were leaving their traditional lands in the Western Desert, although some have returned more recently under changed conditions (Tonkinson 1991; see also Berndt and Berndt 1979). This exodus was partly for reasons to do with drought, but also because the continuous trickle of people into settlements had gained momentum as those remaining in the desert found it increasingly difficult to find appropriate marriage partners (Gould 1969). Dunlop’s team initially located a Western Desert family of ten individuals who had experienced minimal contact with European settlers. This group left after three days, however, and a newly constituted group from Warburton Mission returned to carry out various subsistence activities (Tindale 1968). Blankets, tins, and rubbish were removed from the scene before filming started (Dunlop 1966a: 43). The result of the filming was People of the Australian Western Desert – Dunlop’s series of short thematic films – and Desert People, the synthesized account of one day in the desert based on the same material. In a striking parallel in southern Africa, John Marshall achieved a similar role as filmmaker in the field of ‘‘Bushman’’ or San studies (cf. Ruby 1993). His work was based on expeditions by the Marshall family and associated researchers into remote parts of the Kalahari Desert. The Marshalls, too, at this stage were thinking of the Ju/’hoansi as supporting themselves ‘‘with the economy that cradled human evolution.’’ Marshall, like Dunlop, was initially ‘‘cleaning tin cans out of shots to make Ju/’hoansi in Nyae Nyae look real.’’ He later attributed the fact that he was cutting out the presence of what seemed to be ‘‘non-hunter-gatherer’’ features to his ‘‘illusion of filming in the Pleistocene’’ (Marshall 1993: 23, 32, 56). The Marshalls’ representation of San life, similar to Dunlop’s representation of Australian desert Aborigines, remains very influential. The film and photographic material that they have produced is still used to illustrate a wide range of ethnographic works on southern African and Australian hunter-gatherers. These images extend temporally as well as spatially beyond the setting in which the material was originally collected. In other words, they came to represent not only ethnographic and archaeological work of later decades, but also the San and Aborigines beyond the desert environment. General works on Aboriginal people (e.g., Elkin 1981) and Bushmen (e.g., Barnard 1978) use photographic material from desert settings produced by Dunlop and the Marshalls, respectively. Moreover, their style of representation, showing hunters in their habitat without reference to the world of non-hunter-gatherers, dominated ethnographic works until the 1980s (see the work of Lee 1999a, Silberbauer, and Valiente-Noailles for southern Africa and Meggitt, Gould 1969, and Tindale 1968 for Australia). The visual media, therefore, not only had a particular impact on public imagination and made these hunting and gathering people famous, they also provided a template and a prototypical image of what African or Australian hunter-gatherers are like. Anthropologists working in the tropical north of Australia and outside the Kalahari Desert in southern Africa have occasionally objected to this strong prototypical image, which makes the groups they are dealing with appear either to be ‘‘abnormal’’ or ‘‘hybrid’’ if they do not conform to it. In part, the fiercenes of the revisionist critiques of the 1980s and 1990s may
___________________________________________________________________________________
19
_______________________________________________________________________________
T h o m a s Wi d l o k
also be seen as reactions against the way in which stereotyped and harmonious images of remote desert dwellers came to dominate not only first year anthropology courses, in general, but also hunter-gatherer studies more specifically. Another effect of southern African Bushmen and central Australian Aborigines becoming prototypical foragers is that other regions of the world came to be underrepresented in comparative works in hunter-gatherer studies. While today there is again a resurgence of tropical and arctic forager studies, especially with Siberian research since the collapse of the Soviet Union, current desert huntergatherer ethnography is predominantly located in Australia and southern Africa (cf. Burch and Ellanna 1994; Schweitzer et al. 2000; Williams and Hunn 1982). Studies of North American desert hunter-gatherers, which played an important role up to the 1950s in the works of Steward, Eggan, and others (see contributions in Lee and DeVore 1968), have largely disappeared from current debates. Within North America as an ethnographic region, the Northwest Coast overshadows the role that Plains or Californian hunter-gatherers may have had in anthropological theory of the past. This is because the Northwest Coast provides a theoretically productive contrast to hunter-gatherers elsewhere and because, comparatively speaking, very little ethnographic work is currently carried out among desert hunter-gatherers in North America (see Fowler 1999) such that anthropological work in the region is largely reduced to archaeological work. Another issue worth considering is that because North American desert Indians were equipped with horses and firearms and entangled in intensive trade relations they were no longer considered to be foraging peoples. Kent (2002) has recently argued that, by the standards now applied to southern Africa, most North American foragers would not be considered hunter-gatherers because they include some material culture otherwise associated with farmers. Kent uses this comparison to criticize those who deny a hunter-gatherer identity to occupants of sites that show any pastoral or horticultural products, such as the bones of cattle and sheep or the remains of pottery (see also Chapter 11, this volume). What is true at the level of a continent may also apply within regions. Kalahari Bushmen studies came to stand for southern African hunter-gatherer studies more generally, with little attention given for instance to Namib foragers (who could no longer be studied ethnographically) or to hunter-gatherers with a long record of interaction with agropastoralists such as the Hai//om (see Widlok 1999). In Australia the situation is slightly more complicated, given a growing presence and dominance of Arnhem Land Aborigines in anthropology and in public life (as in art and music performances) over the last decade. There is also the noticeable and growing influence of desert cultures in areas such as the southern Kimberley region of northwest Australia (see Kolig 1989: 66; Widlok 1992). The ethnographic work on desert peoples collected in the twentieth century continues to be an important and irreplaceable basis for anthropological studies of desert hunter-gatherers. The 1960s and 1970s have not only produced outstanding individual contributions of lasting value, but the density of work during this period also provides the opportunity to pursue comparative questions and to see recurrent patterns in theoretical debates.
___________________________________________________________________________________
20
_______________________________________________________________________________
T he A n t h r o p o l o g y o f D e s e r t H u n te r -G a t h e r e r s
Research Approaches and Comparative Theory Comparison relies on a theoretical framework that allows defining ‘‘cases’’ and the parameters according to which the cases are compared. Along with larger developments in anthropology these frameworks have shifted over time and so has the classification of frameworks. One of the most recent classifications of approaches within hunter-gatherer studies distinguishes ‘‘classic,’’ ‘‘adaptionist,’’ ‘‘revisionist,’’ and ‘‘indigenist’’ perspectives (Lee and Daly 1999a), a distinction that can also be applied to the study of desert foragers. ‘‘Classic’’ approaches in hunter-gatherer studies today, in Lee and Daly’s sense, do not simply continue old topics but have a holistic interest in hunter-gatherers, covering history, ecology, economy, settlement patterns, social and political organization, and religion (see contributions in Lee and Daly 1999b). Characteristically, research highlights the internal working between different cultural domains, that is between social or economic stress and ritual activity, between property rules and egalitarian social organization, and between land use patterns and forms of corporate organization. Work is based on the assumption that these questions can be pursued comparatively, that key terms and categories can be transferred from one context to another. Systematic comparisons involving a well defined sample of cases for testing hypotheses are nevertheless rare. Instead, comparisons are exploratory, and are aimed at clarifying conceptual tools and elucidating the specificities of one case vis-a`-vis others. These comparisons can involve desert versus non-desert foragers, but also two or more desert forager groups. A typical theoretical result of this approach is the critique of the patrilocal band model (see Hiatt 1996) and the distinction between range (land used by coresidents) and estate (land owned by a descent or totemic group). ‘‘Adaptationists’’ may base their work on the ‘‘classic’’ record. In practice, however, there is a clear focus on areas of research most closely related to hunting and gathering subsistence and most amenable to science-oriented methodology, above all, quantification. Recurrent research topics are mobility patterns (dispersal and aggregation), the exchange and distribution of resources, demographic questions of group size and reproduction, the division of labor, and time allocation (cf. Kelly 1995). Typically, research stresses interaction with the natural environment and comparisons involving a larger number of cases are frequently made. Comparisons are explicitly utilized to test existing theories or to develop new theories. The cases involved are often situated in similar habitats, but not necessarily so, and comparisons may also be based on simulation. A typical example is the critique of Sahlins’ notion of ‘‘original affluence’’ on the basis of simulated production, distribution, and consumption dynamics which show that, under certain demographic and ecological conditions, foraging more will sustain less people because of resource depletion (Winterhalder 1993). ‘‘Revisionists’’ were often converted to this approach, after having worked within the classic genre, in that they have reinterpreted their own data as well as that of their adversaries (cf. Solway and Lee 1990; Wilmsen and Denbow 1990). While
___________________________________________________________________________________
21
_______________________________________________________________________________
T h o m a s Wi d l o k
revisionist debates concerning hunter-gatherers in tropical forests were firmly grounded on ecological arguments, such as the suggested ‘‘impossibility’’ of surviving in forests solely by hunting and gathering, the revisionism concerning desert foragers turned away from ecological arguments towards questions of outside contact leading to political and economic domination. Characteristically, revisionist research foregrounds interaction with dominant non-hunter-gatherer societies (agropastoralists, traders) and its effects. Revisionist arguments of this sort are not necessarily new (see Passarge 1997) and not limited to the Kalahari or to questions of economic dominance (see Swain 1993 for a revisionist debate in Australia on issues of religion). Comparisons are not so much drawn between different huntergatherer cases (since this category is rejected) but between different groups within a region. A useful example is a critical examination of prevalent views about Bushmen, including the seemingly neutral typology into ‘‘tame’’ (farm) and ‘‘wild’’ (veld) Bushmen. These categories have been used by colonists to impose their interests on San who came to be named as cattle thieves and blamed for loss of livestock, the misappropriation of whose land was justified through the process of ‘‘domestication,’’ and whose ‘‘instinct’’ was exploited for psychological warfare (Gordon 1992: 90). The ‘‘indigenist’’ approach, in the sense described by Lee and Daly (1999a), is not to be confused with the Indigenous perspective, since there are still very few desert foragers who are also anthropologists. Rather, the indigenist approach puts ‘‘the people studied, their goals and aspirations, firmly into the center of the scholarly equation’’ (Lee and Daly 1999b: 11). In other words, this approach would cover much of what is now known as applied anthropology. This approach has become strong in hunter-gatherer studies for a number of reasons, such as the vulnerability of many of these groups to increasing land pressure and the strategies adopted by these groups to exploit their contacts with outsiders. Characteristically, this research is carried out as consultancy work, highlighting relations between (former) foragers and state or non-governmental agencies and their effects on internal social relations. This may involve a comparative perspective insofar as similar nation-states (such as Australia and Canada) lend themselves to comparison, but also because the descendents of hunter-gatherers now visit one another and meet at international Indigenous rights conferences. An interesting recent example is the joint work by an Indigenous North American Indian, a therapist/ consultant, and an anthropologist on San spirituality (Katz et al. 1997). This project resulted in young Ju/’hoansi generating new knowledge about healing, which then led the authors to emphasize that Indigenous culture is not static, nor is the way in which it was practiced in the past or by the elders more pristine than in the present. The foregoing discussion is but one way of classifying dominant theoretical trends in hunter-gatherer studies and is, at least implicitly, based on the point in time when these schools of thought came into being. It is true that these approaches have emerged from a process of mutual delimitation. That is to say, it only makes sense to talk about a revisionist direction in relation to a classic perspective and vice versa. Moreover, within each of these approaches there is a
___________________________________________________________________________________
22
_______________________________________________________________________________
T he A n t h r o p o l o g y o f D e s e r t H u n te r -G a t h e r e r s
considerable spectrum of views and tendencies. For instance, typologies of huntergatherers, in themselves a feature of the classic approach, differ considerably (cf. Barnard 1983). In most cases, ‘‘desert foragers’’ is not an analytic category; instead, various desert hunter-gatherers are grouped differently within different typologies and cut across major distinctions such as that between immediate versus delayedreturn foragers (see Woodburn 1982). Therefore, there is not only a ‘‘foraging spectrum’’ (Kelly 1995) covering a diversity of hunter-gatherer groups, but there is also a spectrum of forager studies arising from the work of individual scholars which is not always easily subsumed under a single approach. It is reasonable to conclude that for every tendency within anthropology at large an example can be found in the field of desert hunter-gatherer studies. Although debates have at times been fierce, and despite the declared intention of major proponents to either debunk an old paradigm or defend appropriate research procedures, I am not persuaded that shifts between the foregoing approaches can be construed as paradigm shifts at a macrolevel. I argue, below, a new paradigm has yet to emerge from the current situation of uncertainty and of dissatisfaction with theoretical approaches of the past. The existing approaches show considerable continuities and share some of their premises with one another. There are clear connections between the classic approach and that of the adaptationists because both were inspired by ideas arising in evolutionary ecology. At the same time, a large number of the classic approaches relied, directly or indirectly, on Marxist theories. They shared many of the same assumptions as the political economy oriented work of the revisionists, although the two schools disagree, for instance, on how to identify classes and underclasses. All three approaches share a materialist perspective with a tendency towards economic determinism, even though proponents may arrive at diverging conclusions depending on whether internal dynamics or external pressures are considered to be crucial. The indigenist perspective most clearly points at something radically new, but in practice it is frequently an extension of the existing research agenda rather than a clear break with ideas from the past. For instance, existing interests in exchange and sharing have been successfully extended to accommodate questions dealing with cash flow and commoditization (see Peterson and Matsuyama 1991). Current issues like deforestation and Indigenous human rights are investigated through the framework of human ecology (Headland and Blood 2002). There are clearly continuities between these approaches. Recent revisionist debates, which have occasionally been announced as challenging the framework of hunter-gatherer studies, have in fact brought together research from archaeology, linguistics, and sociocultural anthropology in a classic fashion. While the category ‘‘hunter-gatherers’’ has been questioned at regular intervals (see, for instance, Burch 1994), the field of hunter-gatherer studies remains a vital one. Some of the theoretical models, such as that of the patrilocal band proposed by Service and Steward, have recently been critically revisited (BirdDavid 1994) after having fallen into disuse for several decades, not least because their prime ethnographic cases turned out to be anomalous and aberrant (see Barnard 1983).
___________________________________________________________________________________
23
_______________________________________________________________________________
T h o m a s Wi d l o k
While the polemics of the Kalahari Debate may continue, arguing about how ‘‘deep’’ or ‘‘remote’’ the Kalahari Desert was at different points in time, it is clear that revisionism is much less of a serious challenge than was initially thought. Archaeological evidence from sites at the margin of the desert show that despite prolonged contact there is considerable continuity between Later Stone Age Indigenous hunter-gatherers of the area and the historically known Bushman population (Sadr 2002). Similarly, comparative ethnohistorical evidence from areas with a long record of interaction between hunter-gatherers and their neighbors suggests overwhelming continuity for a long time in the historical record, in terms of material culture and the persistence of certain social institutions (see Marlowe 2002). As for the situation in northern Australia, where historical contact with non-foragers is now considered more seriously than it used to be (e.g., Povinelli 1993; see also Chapter 15, this volume), the point has been made that the question to be raised is not so much why the Aborigines did not engage in agriculture but, rather, ‘‘Why should they?’’ (Triesch 2001). In this regional context researchers find it much less problematic to accept that hunting-gathering and horticulture are historically a continuum, and also represent a gradient extending across the Torres Strait to Papua New Guinea (Rumsey 2001). Thus, while the Kalahari Debate became heated on the question as to whether certain groups in the northern or central Kalahari had contact with non-foragers, it lost sight of the fact that contact in itself does not say anything about the relations between the parties involved or about the effects and implications of that contact. By contrast, focusing so much on the question of contact, revisionists at least implicitly subscribe to the notion of pristine and pure hunter-gatherers who must have lived some time somewhere – but not in the Kalahari (see Marlowe 2002). As Barnard and Taylor (2002: 246) have put it: ‘‘It is as if exposure to a non-foraging lifestyle should inevitably lead to cultural corruption and social instability.’’ This point is of particular relevance to desert hunter-gatherers insofar as a lack of contact cannot be considered necessary or sufficient for drawing analogies between contemporary hunter-gatherers and those of the distant past. In other words, depending on the research question under consideration (diet, labor organization, settlement patterns), it may be valid and insightful to compare even ‘‘secondary foragers’’ (who previously had livestock) with those of the past, while taking account of the fact that the pace of change cannot be easily predicted and need not be the same for every arena of life and for every environment. The representativeness of contemporary hunter-gatherers (or some aspects of their lives) for situations in the past is no longer an unquestioned assumption or a self-inflicted taboo, but has become a ‘‘normal’’ research question, that is one that has to be empirically investigated and argued about. In view of this situation of diversity, the theoretical landscape of hunter-gatherer studies is appropriately depicted as neither a mosaic of isolated schools nor as a ladder of progress, but as a dynamic research field. A new emerging paradigm that may help solve the diversity of problems at hand will necessarily be much broader than the four approaches listed above. Such a paradigm shall be called, for want of better terms, a ‘‘reflecting’’ and an ‘‘inflecting’’ paradigm.
___________________________________________________________________________________
24
_______________________________________________________________________________
T he A n t h r o p o l o g y o f D e s e r t H u n te r -G a t h e r e r s
A Reflecting Mode of Research Despite claims from the revisionists to the contrary, reflexivity in desert huntergatherer studies is not a recent phenomenon. Given the prominent place that deserts have in European thinking, there has always been an element of reflexivity in desert studies. European naturalists have been attracted by the ‘‘eternal character’’ of the deserts, which seem to preserve the past particularly well but at the same time seem almost paradoxically to be particularly fragile environments. This ambivalence is also found in the popularized anthropology of the deserts. Deserts and the cultural life of desert people have been presented as particularly pristine and harsh and at the same time the fragility of this environment, and the people who are adapted to it, have been highlighted (cf. Marshall-Thomas 1960; Mountford 1950). Given the relative absence of ‘‘third parties,’’ apart from the desert dwellers and the anthropologists themselves, researchers seem to have been much more aware of the influence they had on the people they were researching. For instance, when Dunlop was filming the Aboriginal man Minma digging out a bandicoot he was wondering whether the hunter would have shown the same effort in a situation where there was no film crew (Dunlop 1966b; see also Marshall 1993). In other words, the mere presence of the film crew, however non-intrusive it aimed to be, may have altered the record, leaving a wrong impression about the very basic subsistence activity of digging up a bandicoot. James Woodburn, who was working with the Hadza in Tanzania in the same period, had similar questions about the effects of his presence, especially while he was shooting game for them (see Widlok 2002). Recurrent considerations of this sort are not merely a matter of anthropological ethics or of methodological concern. Rather, they go together with questions concerning the resilience of hunting and gathering in a world of nonhunter-gatherers more generally. It has recently been pointed out that the attention the Hadza have received from anthropologists has probably helped them to continue their hunting and gathering lifestyle for longer than would have otherwise been possible. At the same time, ironically, the increasing popular interest in the Hadza as hunter-gatherers is likely to lead to a demise of hunting and gathering subsistence activities and related social and cultural features, because some Hadza have begun to subsist on regular tourist visits. Similarly, the struggle of southern African hunter-gatherers for recognition by governments and by non-governmental organizations, initiated mainly by anthropologists, certainly has had an effect on policy making in southern Africa and on the policy of donor agencies in the region (cf. Marshall and Ritchie 1986). The integration of human rights and Indigenous peoples’ networks has also produced its specific dilemmas. As Ingold (2000: 133) has pointed out, huntergatherers who claim special rights to their land because of a relationship of immediacy, sharing, and personalization now have to adopt the hegemonic genealogical model of transferring rights to land by descent in an attempt to make their claims heard with regional, national, and international power holders. Thus, there are feedback processes whereby hunter-gatherer life is changed by the dominant
___________________________________________________________________________________
25
_______________________________________________________________________________
T h o m a s Wi d l o k
environment, not necessarily through direct force or domination, although this has also occurred frequently, but simply because in a nationalized and globalized setting there may be more to be gained by becoming like the ‘‘others.’’ At the same time, there is a strong tendency within anthropology, and within some NGO development circles to advocate that cultivating difference is the more promising prospect for people with a hunter-gatherer background (cf. Gowdy 1998). With opportunities for field research in a hunting and gathering context dwindling, social and cultural anthropologists have given increasing attention to questions of stereotyping, myth making, and interethnic relations, not only with regard to interaction between hunter-gatherers and the (colonial/national) state, but also between hunter-gatherers and (agro-) pastoralists. While these questions have always been a topic in hunter-gatherer studies, there seems to be a marked divide now between researchers with an interest in transitions (primarily from foraging to farming) as opposed to those with an interest in interactions (again, primarily between foragers and farmers). Potentially, both questions are of interest to archaeologists and anthropologists alike, but de facto ethnographers tend to think of foraging and farming as interactive systems, while archaeologists tend to ask questions about long-term transformation. Only one strand of research within social and cultural anthropology has so far remained largely unaffected by the reflective questions outlined above and by the revisionism of the last two decades, and that is optimal forager theory (see Martin 1983). This approach focuses on questions of demography and the systemic features of foraging as an adaptive system and has a special interest in desert foragers as an extreme form of adaptation. Although this strand of research has a long tradition in hunter-gatherer studies and continues to thrive, it is today a minority position in hunter-gatherer studies. The breadth of (desert) huntergatherer studies may be usefully viewed within the framework of international conferences on hunting and gathering societies (CHAGS), which have become a major bracket that unifies the field and that provides a founding genealogy for its constituent discussions and debates. The genealogy is usually traced back to the Man the Hunter conference of 1966 (Lee and DeVore 1968) and includes nine CHAGS conferences and numerous conference volumes which cover all regions of the world (desert, tropical, and arctic foragers) utilizing a wide spectrum of theoretical approaches. With few exceptions, CHAGS volumes include some contributions to optimal forager theory (or other strongly science oriented research) as well as humanities oriented work, but in more recent volumes there is a clear tendency towards the latter and recent CHAGS have always made an effort to include Indigenous voices. An increase in reflectivity does not automatically or necessarily mean a decrease in other research activities (cf. Barnard 1992). Indeed, reflectivity in huntergatherer studies is not altogether new (see above), and pursuing other research activities does not necessarily mean propagating old theories (see below).
___________________________________________________________________________________
26
_______________________________________________________________________________
T he A n t h r o p o l o g y o f D e s e r t H u n te r -G a t h e r e r s
An Inflecting Mode of Research While reflecting requires the researcher to alter and adapt research tools referring back to the relationship between researcher and the researched, ‘‘inflecting’’ requires the researcher to alter and adapt research tools to a variety of contexts to which they can be applied. To illustrate the point, consider the question of huntergatherer mobility, which is a major issue for ethnography and archaeology. The matter has been succinctly put by Brody (2001: 7): [A] crucial difference between hunter-gatherers and farmers is that one society is mobile . . . whereas the other is highly settled, tending to stay firmly in one particular area or territory. This difference is established in stereotypes of ‘‘nomadic’’ hunters and ‘‘settled’’ farmers. However, the stereotype has it the wrong way round. It is agricultural societies that tend to be on the move; hunting peoples are far more settled.
Brody provides a good example of reflecting about the relationship between hunter-gatherers and farmers (and anthropologists coming from a society with a farming background). He then goes on to invert the dominant stereotype depicting the farmer as ‘‘displaced from his home, roaming the harsh earth looking for land to till’’ (Brody 2001: 76). While this, again, may simply be another stereotype, it does point to a major issue in hunter-gatherer studies. In southern Africa the agropastoralists consider themselves fairly recent arrivals in the area, while most San groups maintain that they have been in the same region all along. This is also reflected in the way in which maps are drawn by, or on behalf of, agropastoralist groups in the region, which look very different from maps drawn by, and for, San groups. The former use arrows to indicate migration routes and the history of settlement; the latter show regular, partly overlapping paths that radiate out from waterholes like rays of the sun. In the process of land claim politics, these interlocking routes are represented as blocks of land, similar to the way in which farms and ‘‘native homelands’’ have been mapped on European maps (see Widlok 1999). The same process can be observed in Aboriginal Australia, where the delimitation of territories has led to similar discussions (cf. Sutton 1995). Aboriginal maps with interlocking routes have – under legislative pressure and with the assistance of anthropologists – been changed into maps with ideally nonoverlapping boundaries (Sutton 1995: 36). However, this reflexivity about dominant images and practices of mobility and the hunter-gatherer response needs to be complemented with new research that ‘‘inflects’’ some of the parameters that have been identified. Among these is the fact that many hunter-gatherers exhibit particular skills of spatial orientation (see Widlok 1997). Comparative research examining data from southern Africa as well as Australia (Pederson et al. 1998) suggests that in both cases foragers operate with a strong absolute orientation frame. Excellent orientation skills seem to be linked to topographical gossip in which relative orientation terms such as left/right
___________________________________________________________________________________
27
_______________________________________________________________________________
T h o m a s Wi d l o k
and front/back are replaced with absolute (i.e., speaker-independent) terms, especially cardinal terms. The 6¼Akhoe Hai//om San of northern Namibia use directional terms which make use of complex landscape terms based on soil types, characteristic vegetation, and topography; a system that clearly differs from that of agropastoralists in the area (see Widlok 1997). This example underlines the stationary and regional aspect of hunter-gatherer mobility pointed out by Brody. A regional mode of mobility and integration has also been described for Australian desert people (see Myers 1986). Characteristically, this regional mode consists of a network that is larger than a single local group but not as expansive as the migrations of pastoralists and farmers. Based on comparative ethnographic data with hunter-gatherers, Ingold (2000) has recently further synthesized ideas on forager orientation and mobility systems into a more dynamic picture. He argues that the existing maps of hunter-gatherer territories and movements are flawed, but not only because they privilege delineated expanses in favor of interlocking routes and networks. His critique is more radical in that he argues against ‘‘the cartographic illusion . . . that the world is preprepared as a stage upon which living things propel themselves about, from one location to another’’ (Ingold 2000: 242). According to this phenomenology-inspired theoretical approach, forager skills of orientation, and of mobile adaptation more generally, are not a cultural heritage that is transferred like a blueprint out of context, but the skills themselves are only realized in the process, unfolding as they are practiced. Following hunter-gatherers in different contexts and realizing their skill of mobility in different contexts is an example of inflecting which has been described in abstract terms, above. There is not one default or ‘‘standard’’ mode of spatial organization and of mobility, nor necessarily clearly distinguishable types, but regular inflections do emerge in comparative perspective. Ingold develops this theoretical outline further in a comprehensive theory of life as ‘‘laid down along paths of movement, of action and perception’’ instead of the ‘‘internal property of objects’’ (2000: 242). Whatever the philosophical merits or problems of this approach, hunter-gatherer scholars will note that this perspective can accommodate valuable aspects of what hitherto appeared to be conflicting schools in huntergatherer studies. It bridges the classic and adaptionist perspectives insofar as it no longer separates the sociocultural and the natural environment, or history and evolution, but considers all these elements in a more holistic framework. Rather than continue to assume the existence of a cultural core that is subsequently altered through its environment, human beings, culture, and nature are assumed to form a developmental system that is transformed over time and ‘‘inflected’’ differently across the world. This approach also creates bridges between revisionist and other perspectives because it is strongly non-essentialist while not denying difference. In other words, it no longer requires the assumption of an ideal-type forager culture that is instilled within forager groups or individuals. Hunter-gatherers do many things differently from non-hunter-gatherers, but this is due to the momentum that practices gain by being practiced, it is not due to a forager template conceived of as a cultural or behavioral program. This also solves a recurrent puzzle in the study of egalitarian hunter-gatherers, namely how social systems that provide
___________________________________________________________________________________
28
_______________________________________________________________________________
T he A n t h r o p o l o g y o f D e s e r t H u n te r -G a t h e r e r s
considerable personal autonomy can maintain sufficient stability to have lasting social relations at all (Brunton 1989). Or to put it differently: How to maintain the cultural obligation not to impose obligations on one another? In this approach there is no need to assume that rules of sharing and so forth are formulated as abstract rules which are then executed more or less rigorously in a variety of contexts. Rather, the recurrent practice of sharing itself creates the environment, for instance in terms of spatial settlement layouts and kin or friendship ties, that fosters further acts of sharing and an extension of these ties to include other persons (and personalized non-human beings). Finally, it also includes the indigenist perspective in a new way, not simply as an intensification of contact between scholars and ‘‘locals,’’ but also by intensifying and facilitating new debates among these groups. By de-essentializing what constitutes a hunter-gatherer way of life it can do away with the genealogical mode that presses hunter-gatherers to identify ultimately through bloodlines or ethnicity and to base their claims on this hereditary identity. It directs attention to hunter-gatherer practices as developmental systems that may involve some persons more than others and that flourishes in some political environments better than in others.
Conclusion: Future Shifts Although desert hunter-gatherers have played an important part as the subjects of anthropological theorizing, it is fair to say that theory in hunter-gatherer studies is still an emerging and open field. This means that it is difficult to speculate about future shifts in the theory of desert hunter-gatherer studies. However, if the combination of a reflecting and an inflecting mode, as outlined above, succeeds, it could also lead to a productive reappraisal of analogy as a research tool, thereby also reconnecting work in archaeology, linguistics, physical anthropology, and sociocultural anthropology. So far, archaeologists have confronted the question of analogy much more forcefully than social and cultural anthropologists and there is a certain degree of asynchrony between the two subdisciplines. In an early phase, ethnographers were keen to make analogies with the archaeological past. The emergence and subsequent disappearance of the phrase ‘‘stone age man’’ in the ethnographic discourse on hunter-gatherers is indicative. Towards the middle of the twentieth century anthropologists made uncritical use of this label (see Sahlins 1988; Spencer and Gillen 1927), and reluctance to accept these analogies initially came from archaeologists. They came to envisage their work to be a self-contained enterprise relying on the recovered materials only, not needing any non-material (and therefore dubious) anthropological analogies, but restricting themselves to middle range research (see Bettinger 1991). Today, the situation in some ways is almost reversed. It is the archaeologists who are rediscovering the importance of ethnographic analogies to make sense of their data (see Eggert 1998), whereas anthropologists now largely reject the use of analogies. A transfer of considerations concerning analogy as a research tool from archaeology back into social and cultural anthropology may be very instructive for future
___________________________________________________________________________________
29
_______________________________________________________________________________
T h o m a s Wi d l o k
theoretical models in the anthropology of desert hunter-gatherers. Archaeologists know that not all aspects of life are equally well captured through archaeological data. This is quite clear in the case of the analysis of settlement patterns, for instance. For those aspects that leave little material traces, ethnographic analogies are therefore most welcome. What is frequently overlooked, however, is that the same holds true for ethnography. Not all aspects of life are equally well captured through standard ethnographic methods, in particular given the tendency to privilege interview material. Complementing an ethnographic perspective with a discussion of historical data (see Sahlins 1985) is one attempt to deal with the problem, but it does not suffice. Ethnographers gather a lot of information on past and present discourses, but the effects of long-term practices, economic transfers, and mobility or marriage patterns are not as easily grasped by standard ethnographic field research or by standard historical research. Social and cultural anthropology may have a focus on contemporary issues, but this is largely due to the methods that are being employed and it is not because the past or the future is without importance in the process of generating anthropological knowledge. A productive study of desert hunter-gatherers always needs to be based on the explanatory potential of analogies and other forms of comparison.
References Barnard, A. 1978: Bushmen. London: Museum of Mankind. Barnard, A. 1983: Contemporary hunter-gatherers: Current theoretical issues in ecology and social organization. Annual Review of Anthropology, 12, 193–214. Barnard, A. 1992: The Kalahari Debate: A Bibliographic Essay. Edinburgh: Centre for African Studies, University of Edinburgh. Barnard, A. 1999: Images of hunters and gatherers in European social thought. In R. Lee and R. Daly (eds), The Cambridge Encyclopedia of Hunters and Gatherers, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 375–83. Barnard, A. and Taylor, M. 2002: The complexities of association and assimilation: An ethnographic overview. In S. Kent (ed.), Ethnicity, Hunter-Gatherers, and the ‘‘Other’’: Association and Assimilation in Africa, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 230–46. Bender, B. and Morris, B. 1988: Twenty years of history, evolution, and social change in gatherer-hunter studies. In T. Ingold, D. Riches, and J. Woodburn (eds), Hunters and Gatherers 1: History, Evolution and Social Change, Oxford: Berg, 4–14. Berndt. R. and Berndt, C. (eds) 1979: Aborigines of the West: Their Past and Present. Perth: University of Western Australia Press. Bettinger, R. 1991: Hunter-Gatherers: Archaeological and Evolutionary Theory. New York: Plenum. Bird-David, N. 1994: Sociality and immediacy: Or, past and present conversations on bands. Man, 29, 583–603. Boas, F. 1888: The Central Eskimo, vol. 6. Washington, DC: Bureau of American Ethnology. Brody, H. 2001: The Other Side of Eden: Hunter-Gatherers, Farmers, and the Shaping of the World. London: Faber and Faber.
___________________________________________________________________________________
30
_______________________________________________________________________________
T he A n t h r o p o l o g y o f D e s e r t H u n te r -G a t h e r e r s Brunton, R. 1989: The cultural instability of egalitarian societies. Man, 24, 673–81. Burch, E. 1994: The future of hunter-gatherer research. In E. Burch and L. Ellanna (eds), Key Issues in Hunter-Gatherer Research, Oxford: Berg, 441–55. Burch, E. and Ellanna, L. (eds) 1994: Key Issues in Hunter-Gatherer Research. Oxford: Berg. Dunlop, I. 1966a: People of the Western Desert. Film leaflet. Dunlop, I. 1966b: Technical and production problems of ethnographic films: Some aspects of filming in Australia’s Western Desert. In Round Table on Ethnographic Film in the Pacific Area, Sydney: Australian Institute of Aboriginal þ Torrer Strait Islander Studies. Eggert, M. 1998: Archa¨ologie und Analogie: Bemerkungen zu einer Wissenschaft vom Fremden. Mitteilungen der Anthropologischen Gesellschaft in Wien, 128, 107–24. Elkin, A. 1981: The Australian Aborigines. London: Angus and Robertson. Fowler, C. 1999: The Timbisha Shoshone of Death Valley. In R. Lee and R. Daly (eds), The Cambridge Encyclopedia of Hunters and Gatherers, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 66–70. Gordon, R. 1992: The Bushman Myth: The Making of a Namibian Underclass. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Gould, R. 1969: Subsistence behavior among the Western Desert Aborigines of Australia. Oceania, 39, 253–74. Gowdy, J. 1998: Limited Wants, Unlimited Means: A Reader on Hunter-Gatherer Economics and the Environment. Washington, DC: Island Press. Headland, T. and Blood, D. 2002: What Place for Hunter-Gatherers in Millennium Three? Dallas, TX: SIL. Hiatt, L. 1996: Arguments about Aborigines: Australia and the Evolution of Social Anthropology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Ingold, T. 2000: The Perception of the Environment: Essays in Livelihood, Dwelling, and Skill. London: Routledge. Katz, R., Biesele, M., and St Denis, V. 1997: Healing Makes our Hearts Happy: Spirituality and Cultural Transformation among the Kalahari Ju/’hoansi. Rochester: Inner Traditions. Kelly, R. 1995: The Foraging Spectrum: Diversity in Hunter-Gatherer Lifeways. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Kent, S. 2002: Autonomy or serfdom? Relations between prehistoric neighboring huntergatherers and farmer/pastoralists in southern Africa. In S. Kent (ed.), Ethnicity, HunterGatherers, and the ‘‘Other’’: Association and Assimilation in Africa, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 48–92. Kolig. E. 1989: Dreamtime Politics: Religion, World View and Utopian Thought in Australian Aboriginal Society. Berlin: Reimer. Lee, R. and Daly, R. 1999a: Introduction: Foragers and others. In R. Lee and R. Daly (eds), The Cambridge Encyclopedia of Hunters and Gatherers, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1–19. Lee, R. and Daly, R. (eds) 1999b: The Cambridge Encyclopedia of Hunters and Gatherers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Lee, R. and DeVore, I. (eds) 1968: Man the Hunter. New York: Aldine. Marlowe, F. 2002: Why the Hadza are still hunter-gatherers. In S. Kent (ed.), Ethnicity, Hunter-Gatherers, and the ‘‘Other’’: Association and Assimilation in Africa, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 248–75. Marshall, J. 1993: Filming and learning. In J. Ruby (ed.), The Cinema of John Marshall, Amsterdam: Harwood, 1–133.
___________________________________________________________________________________
31
_______________________________________________________________________________
T h o m a s Wi d l o k Marshall, J. and Ritchie, C. 1986: Where are the Ju/wasi of Nyae Nyae?: Changes in a Bushman Society, 1958–1981. Rondebosch: Communications Centre for African Studies, University of Cape Town no. 9, University of Cape Town. Marshall-Thomas, E. 1960: The Harmless People. London: Secker and Warburg. Martin, J. 1983: Optimal foraging theory: A review of some models and their applications. American Anthropologist, 85, 612–29. Mountford, C. 1950: Brown Men and Red Sand. London: Phoenix House. Myers, F. 1986: Pintupi Country, Pintupi Self: Sentiment, Place, and Politics among Western Desert Aborigines. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Passarge, S. 1997: The Kalahari Ethnographies (1996–98) of Siegfried Passarge, ed. E. Wilmsen (first published in German 1907). Ko¨ln: Ko¨ppe. Pederson, E., Danziger, E., Levinson, S., Kita, S., Senft, G., and Wilkins, D. 1998: Semantic typology and spatial conceptualization. Language, 74, 557–89. Peterson, N. and Matsuyama, T. 1991: Cash, Commoditization, and Changing Foragers. Osaka: Senri Ethnological Studies vol. 30, National Museum of Ethnology. Povinelli, E. 1993: Labor’s Lot: The Power, History, and Culture of Aboriginal Action. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Radcliffe-Brown, A. 1922: The Andaman Islanders. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Ruby, J. 1993: The Cinema of John Marshall. Amsterdam: Harwood. Rumsey, A. 2001: Introduction. In A. Rumsey and J. Weiner (eds), Emplaced Myth: Space, Narrative, and Knowledge in Aboriginal Australia and Papua New Guinea, Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press, 1–18. Sadr, K. 2002: Encapsulated Bushmen in the archaeology of Thamaga. In S. Kent (ed.), Ethnicity, Hunter-Gatherers, and the ‘‘Other’’: Association and Assimilation in Africa, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 28–47. Sahlins, M. 1985: Islands of History. London: Tavistock. Sahlins, M. 1988: Stone Age Economics. London: Routledge. Schott, R. 1956: Anfa¨nge der Privat-und Planwirtschaft. Wirtschaftsordnung und Nahrungsverteilung bei Wildbeutervo¨lkern. Braunschweig: Limbach. Schweitzer, P., Biesele, M., and Hitchcock, R. (eds) 2000: Hunters and Gatherers in the Modern World: Conflict Resistance and Self-Determination. New York: Berghahn. Solway, J. and Lee, R. 1990: Foragers genuine or spurious? Situating the Kalahari San in history. Current Anthropology, 31, 109–46. Spencer, B. and Gillen, F. 1899: The Native Tribes of Central Australia. London: Macmillan. Spencer, B. and Gillen, F. 1927: The Arunta: A Study of a Stone Age People. London: Macmillan. Sutton, P. 1995: Country. Aboriginal Boundaries and Land Ownership in Australia. Canberra: Aboriginal History Monograph vol. 3, The Australian National University. Swain, T. 1993: A Place for Strangers. Towards a History of Australian Aboriginal Being. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Szalay, M. 1986: Zur Frage der ‘‘sekunda¨ren Primitivita¨t’’ der ’Buschma¨nner. In R. Vossen and K. Keuthmann (eds), Contemporary Studies on Khoisan, Hamburg: Buske, 257–69. Tindale, N. 1968: Review of Desert People. American Anthropologist, 70, 437–8. Tonkinson, R. 1991: The Martu Aboriginies: Living the Dream of Australia’s Desert. Forth Worth, TX: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston. Triesch, C. 2001: ‘‘Warum sollten sie . . . ?’’ Die Frage nach der Verbreitung des Bodenbaus und die pra¨koloniale Nutzung von Nahrungsressourcen in Australien und Neuguinea. Herbholzheim: Centaurus.
___________________________________________________________________________________
32
_______________________________________________________________________________
T he A n t h r o p o l o g y o f D e s e r t H u n te r -G a t h e r e r s Widlok, T. 1992: Practice, politics, and ideology of the ‘‘traveling business’’ in Aboriginal religion. Oceania, 3 (2), 114–36. Widlok, T. 1997: Orientation in the wild: The shared cognition of Hai//om bush people. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 3, 317–32. Widlok, T. 1999: Living on Mangetti: ‘‘Bushman’’ Autonomy and Namibian Independence. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Widlok, T. 2002: The long walk IV – Hunter-gatherers and anthropology: An interview with James Woodburn. Nomadic Peoples, 6, 7–22. Williams, N. and Hunn, E. (eds) 1982: Resource Managers: North American and Australian Hunter-Gatherers. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Wilmsen, E. and Denbow, J. 1990: Paradigmatic histories of San-speaking peoples and current attempts at revision. Current Anthropology, 31, 489–507. Winterhalder, B. 1993: Work, resources, and population in foraging societies. Man, 28, 321–40. Woodburn, J. 1982: Egalitarian societies. Man, 17, 431–51.
___________________________________________________________________________________
33
_______________________________________________________________________________
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pleistocene Settlement of Deserts from an Australian Perspective Peter Hiscock and Lynley A. Wallis
Introduction: Deserts and Desert Colonization One of the surprising characteristics of deserts is their environmental diversity. Far from the monolithic uniformity of the popular imagination, deserts typically display variation in topography, hydrology, and resources. Within Australian deserts these differences are displayed at a variety of scales. While some areas have coordinated drainage, others have no coherent and articulated drainage systems; some desert areas are principally rocky outcrops, others largely mantled with sand, and still others are a mixture; some have permanent water sources, while many do not; and so on. Within any single desert area the availability of water, stone, and wood suitable for tool making, as well as the nature and abundance of plants and animals, varies across the landscape. All of these features have varied through time as climatic shifts, geological processes such as erosion and sedimentation, and changes in floral and faunal composition have altered the structure of resources across the landscape. A single landscape may even become or cease being a desert with the passing of time. Variation in the distribution and reliability of resources through time and space is likely to have had a critical influence on the colonization and settlement of these desert landscapes. Adaptations to deserts by humans are also far from being monolithic. Within Australia images of ethnographic desert dwellers have often dominated discussions of possible lifeways within arid and semi-arid lands. These images of historic Aboriginal desert life often emphasize features like the intensive use of vegetable foods such as seeds, and maintenance of long distance social networks involving reciprocity and rights to territorial access (Gould 1977; Tonkinson 1991: 40). Most importantly, the ethnographic desert dwellers were renowned for their intimate knowledge of the landscapes in which they lived; however, these features are unlikely to have been traits of the colonizers of these desert landscapes! Initial colonization must have been accomplished by foragers who did not know the terrain or the
___________________________________________________________________________________
34
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s
distribution patterns of resources and therefore the early settlement of the Australian deserts is likely to have been undertaken by people who had economic and subsistence strategies that were different from those of the historic period. Some researchers have suggested that the ethnographic forms of desert economy and subsistence are relatively recent, and have emerged only since the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) and in the Holocene (e.g., Veth 1989). This chapter tackles two of the key problems in archaeological investigations of early occupation of the Australian deserts: (1) How different was the settlement system of early settlers of the inland from that found in recent times and (2) how did foragers colonize the interior without the adaptive strategies of historic desert peoples? In answer to these questions we advance the propositions that much of the Australian interior was initially colonized during a period of higher rainfall and more abundant surface water and food resources – a period in which a dedicated desert adaptation of the historic kind was not in place – and that elements of this pattern of early subsistence continued until the LGM, hence supporting a model in which some of the key features found in historic desert life have accumulated only since the terminal Pleistocene. We argue that in Australia Pleistocene foragers did not move into deserts fully equipped with a modern desert adaptation, but rather that climate change created deserts in areas where huntergatherers already lived and those human groups adapted their existing strategies to the new situations or else abandoned the landscape – a ‘‘desert transformation’’ model. A review of deserts around the world suggests that similar colonization models may have broad applicability. Note that the following review incorporates age estimates derived from a range of dating techniques. To reconcile these different estimates we have adopted the approach of expressing all ages as solar (calendar) years rounded to the nearest 500 years, including those derived from radiocarbon dates. To achieve this, age estimates based on uncalibrated radiocarbon dates presented in the cited literature have been calibrated using the procedures developed by the University of Cologne in its CalPal software and by the formula of Miller et al. (1997). Although such calibrations are of uncertain accuracy they facilitate the synthesis of different data sources, such as luminescence and radiocarbon assays. Using this approach our review of the Pleistocene occupation of Australian deserts requires consideration of the question as to when humans first arrived in the Australian continent.
Arrival of Humans in Australia Archaeological evidence demonstrates that humans arrived in Australia 60,000–45,000 years ago (Bowler 1998; Bowler and Magee 2000; Bowler and Price 1998; Gillespie 1998; Gillespie and Roberts 2000; Gru¨n et al. 2000; Pearce and Barbetti 1981; Roberts et al. 1990, 1993, 1994). The precise date of initial arrival of humans in Australia has been the subject of vigorous debate, principally between a group of researchers advocating a likely landfall of approximately 45,000 years ago (e.g., O’Connell and Allen 1998, in press) and those preferring an estimate of approximately 55,000 years ago (e.g., Roberts et al. 1990, 1993, 1994).
___________________________________________________________________________________
35
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s
We consider these debates of little value given a number of factors. Firstly, they have tended to ignore the uncertainty attached to many age estimates, thereby acting as though the various estimates were more precise than they are. For instance, many of the luminescence, U-series, and ESR dates have uncertainties in the order of 5,000–10,000 years (see O’Connell and Allen, in press, for data summaries), often making debates as to whether material at a specific site was 50,000 or 45,000 years old merely a speculative adventure. In another context the consequences of these uncertainties have been discussed by Rindos and Webb (1992), and we concur with their conclusion that high resolution models of the initial period of colonization may never be able to be tested using current dating techniques. Although the radiocarbon estimates have higher precision, doubts remain about their accuracy, with even the most recent advances in radiocarbon dating techniques failing to resolve all complications created by contamination or calibration. A second factor we will mention that creates difficulties for pinpointing a date for initial human entry into Australia is the lack of systematic sampling of archaeological sites. The probability of finding archaeological traces of the earliest occupation of Sahul, even within a specific region, is very small; and the identification of one or two old archaeological deposits in any region should be considered evidence of minimum antiquity rather than a definitive statement of the antiquity of occupation. This factor is exacerbated by the tendency of archaeologists to repeatedly target specific kinds of site – such as large caves – and the focus of redating investigations during the last decade on those atypical sites. In light of this factor it is noteworthy that the oldest potentially sustainable estimate of human occupation comes not from a cave deposit but from the open lake margin site of Lake Mungo, where ESR, U-series, and OSL techniques have indicated a burial may date to 62,000 6,000 years ago (Thorne et al. 1999). Although a date in excess of 50,000 years appears unlikely for this skeleton, based on the well established age of the sediments in which it was found (Bowler and Magee 2000), the unresolved debate about the antiquity of the Mungo material highlights two aspects of the investigation of human antiquity in the Australian continent: that since the nature of human landscape use may have varied through time, some landscape features may not provide residues of the initial movement of humans into a region, and that even the lowest reasonable estimates of the lowest artifacts at Lake Mungo deny conservative claims of continental colonization of 43,000 bp or less. The third significant concern when interpreting age estimates for early Australian occupation is the lack of detailed taphonomic/formational studies for almost every deposit cited in these debates. Formational/disturbance processes, which can be presumed to occur in every archaeological site, create ambiguities in age estimation that are not expressed in the uncertainties provided by dating laboratories. The failure of Australian archaeologists to make taphonomic investigations a high research priority is compounded by the regular dating of non-archaeological components of these old deposits – materials such as sand grains – thereby raising questions of stratigraphic association. Where the formation processes of early sites have been subjected to scrutiny they have often proved problematic and in need of further study (see Hiscock 1990; O’Connell and Allen in press; Richardson 1992).
___________________________________________________________________________________
36
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s
Given these complexities in the use of existing chronological evidence we conclude that Australia was most likely colonized by Homo sapiens sapiens at a date of 50,000 10,000 years ago, that is 60,000–40,000 years ago. We consider this estimate to be imprecise but reliable, and to define the earliest chronological period in which humans were present on the continent and in which occupation of desert landscapes might have occurred. Accepting this estimate of the arrival of humans in Australia, we now turn to the evidence for colonization of desert areas.
Initial Human Penetration of the Australian Deserts In evaluating the timing of initial human movements into the Australian deserts we have identified the earliest, apparently reliable age estimate for archaeological materials in each region that today is arid or semi-arid. The data-set that we have drawn on is that prepared by O’Connell and Allen (in press), and the following discussion is restricted to those sites from which dates exceeding 35,000 years have been retrieved. Again, the reader is reminded that ages provided here are in solar years, with radiocarbon values calibrated and rounded to the nearest half a millennium. This procedure currently yields seven sites across Australia (see Figure 3.1). In the Kimberly region of northwestern Australia radiocarbon assays at two rock shelters have very similar ages for their lowest occupation levels: Carpenter’s Gap 1 with a date of 45,000 years, or 46,500–43,500 years ago at two standard deviations (Fifield et al. 2001); and Riwi with a date of 45,500 years, or 47,500–44,000 years (Balme 2000). Further to the southeast, in the MacDonnell Ranges of central Australia the Puritjarra rock shelter has evidence of occupation at 39,000 years ago, or 42,500–36,500 years (Smith et al. 1997). Even further south, on the Nullarbor Plain and edge of the Great Australian Bight, Allen’s Cave has yielded an OSL date of 40,000 years, or 43,000–37,000 years (Roberts et al. 1996). Far to the east of Allen’s Cave, the stratigraphically lowest artifacts in the aforementioned Lake Mungo site complex are estimated, using OSL, to have an antiquity of at least 50,000–46,000 years (Bowler et al. 2003). Further northeast, Cuddie Springs appears to have archaeological material dated using OSL techniques to 35,500 years, or 38,500–32,500 years ago (Roberts et al. 2001). Finally, in the northeast of the continent, in the gulf fall zone of the Barkley Tablelands, the GRE 8 shelter has produced a radiocarbon sample of 41,500 years, or 44,500–37,500 years (O’Connell and Allen in press). Although the radiometric estimate from Cuddie Springs is somewhat younger than the demonstrated antiquity at the other sites, we interpret these data as indicating broadly similar dates for human presence in widely separated regions. Humans are archaeologically visible in each of these locations 50,000–40,000 years ago, a pattern that must be taken to reveal the widespread distribution of huntergatherers across inland Australia at that time. These dates could be seen to imply that occupation of these inland regions took place substantially later than the original landfall, if claims for dates of 55,000 years or more in Arnhem Land
___________________________________________________________________________________
37
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s
Figure 3.1 Early Australian sites in landscapes arid or semi-arid today (after O’Connell and Allen in press).
(Roberts et al. 1990, 1993, 1994) are accepted at face value, thereby supporting a modified version of Bowdler’s (1977) model of coastal colonization; however, as we have already discussed, the imprecision of dates older than 45,000 years makes such a conclusion unsustainable, and we argue that models such as coastal colonization are currently untestable. Imprecise dates also constrain consideration of whether these inland regions were initially occupied contemporaneously or sequentially; the precise rate of human spread across the inland cannot be calculated, although the current evidence of broadly similar antiquities in each region does not favor a spread of people extended over tens of millennia. Nevertheless it is worth noting that there is no obvious directionality in these dates – the northwest and southeast have returned similar ages for occupation; hence, no directional pattern of dispersion can reasonably be read into the pattern described here. Although the dating evidence fails to provide definitive tests of fast versus slow models of population
___________________________________________________________________________________
38
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s
dispersion across the Australian interior, it not only reveals that relatively early (pre-40,000 years) occupation was widespread and not restricted to coasts, but also provides the necessary chronology with which to assess the environmental context of the initial movement of people into the Australian deserts. During the period when humans become archaeologically visible in regions of Australia that are now deserts, the climatic and hydrological regimes created landscapes that were different from those found today. Any consideration of the colonization of Australian deserts must be understood in that environmental context. Three regional paleoenvironmental records are summarized below as exemplars of the context of colonization: the strongly seasonal Kimberley region of northwest Australia; the weakly seasonal Lake Eyre and its catchment; and the relatively aseasonal Willandra Lakes (see Figure 3.2). In the Kimberley the long-term climatic pattern has been reconstructed from northwest shelf marine cores, terrestrial lake sequences, and botanical materials from archaeological sites. The Lombok Ridge marine core indicates that the period from 130,000 until 38,000 years ago was one of high sea level and relatively wet conditions in northern Australia, with rainfall estimated to fall in the range of 500–1000 mm per year (van der Kaars 1991; Wang et al. 1999). Bowler’s (1983a; Bowler et al. 2001) investigations at Lake Gregory, located on the northern fringes 130
SUMMER RAIN
140
0
500 km
Strongly seasonal (S/W >3) Weakly (S/W 1.3-3) seasonal
15
UNIFORM DISTRIBUTION
1 20
2 L Eyre
30
3 35
WINTER RAIN Weekly seasonal (W/S 1.3−3) Strongly seasonal (W/S >3)
135
150
Figure 3.2 The contemporary Australian arid zone (thick line), where potential evaporation exceeds actual evaporation (modified from Gentilli 1986 and Hesse et al. 2004). Rainfall seasonality is shown as the ratio of summer to winter rainfall. Three broad regions are numbered as (1) Kimberley and the northwest, (2) Lake Eyre and its catchment, and (3) Willandra Lakes.
___________________________________________________________________________________
39
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s
of the Great Sandy Desert, have revealed increasing aridity during the last 300,000 years, with several lacustral phases prior to 40,000 years ago. The record from Lake Wood to the east shows similar trends, but differences in the precise timing and extent of high water conditions, indicating interregional and local variations (Bowler et al. 1998). The long-term trend towards increasing aridity is also reflected in vegetation change during the late Quaternary. Studies of soil organic matter from Lake Gregory have indicated a trend, over the last 100,000 years, away from exclusively tree and shrub floral assemblages towards a grass dominated flora as increasing water stress developed (Pack et al. 2003). These data are consistent with the evidence for vegetation change available from the phytolith record at Carpenter’s Gap 1 where, 45,000 years ago, there was a diverse grassland ecology and palms outside their modern geographical range, suggesting the existence of wetter conditions at that time than in any more recent period (Wallis 2001). In the Lake Eyre Basin of central Australia, a region in which water availability reflects not only local conditions but also seasonal rainfall patterns in its northerly catchment, broadly similar trends towards desiccation have been well documented. As evidenced by the nature of regional vegetation patterns, the Australian monsoon was more effective before 45,000 years ago than at anytime since (Johnson et al. 1999). This is also seen within Lake Eyre itself, which was for the most part a permanently wet lake until about 60,000 years ago, when it changed to a groundwater dominated system as it progressively dried out (Magee and Miller 1998). Up until about 30,000 years ago enhanced winter westerly circulation might have penetrated more regularly to the Lake Eyre region than under the present climate, bringing with it enhanced winter rainfall and wetter conditions than at any time since. Preserved tree roots and trace fossils of large roots replaced by secondary gypsum also reveal that trees were more common during that period than today (Hesse et al. 2004). These climatic differences in the Lake Eyre Basin probably stem from an interaction of enhanced winter rainfall, greater inflow from enhanced storms in northern Australia, and reduced evaporation associated with substantially lower temperatures than at present (Magee and Miller 1998; Miller et al. 1997). In contrast, far from the influence of monsoonal rainfall in southeastern Australia the archetypal locality for describing arid/semi-arid environmental history and archaeology is the Willandra Lakes, and especially Lake Mungo. Bowler (1998) has demonstrated the alternation of dry and wet phases at Lake Mungo during the late Pleistocene, with a long-term drying trend. Prior to 45,000–42,000 years ago there was a prolonged lacustral phase with high water levels. A further series of water bodies were also present 36,000–22,000 years ago, although low and fluctuating lake levels are features of the period following 42,000 years. Other lake systems in the arid southeast have been shown to display somewhat similar trends, although with distinct hints of local variations in the timing and pattern of high water levels (Harrison 1993). This overall pattern of drying since 50,000–40,000 years ago is also visible in the activation of linear dunes, particularly during the last 25,000 years (Wasson 1984). These brief pictures of surface hydrology and vegetation in widely separated regions of the Australian interior provide an image of the landscapes into which we
___________________________________________________________________________________
40
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s
believe the first human colonists moved. Prior to about 45,000 years ago conditions were similar to, but probably cooler than, those of today, with a long-term trend towards aridification and increased aeolian activity. In many regions it is likely that up until about 45,000 years ago – and perhaps to 30,000 years ago in some locations – the availability of fresh surface water would have been at least as good, if not better, than during the Holocene. Hence at the time humans began exploring these landscapes they were still drier than many parts of the continental margins, but they were noticeably different from their contemporary state. In each of the three regions reviewed above, and many others not summarized here, seasonal floods and large standing water bodies were common and comparatively predictable prior to 45,000–40,000 years ago in ways that they have not been over the last 35,000 years. We hypothesize that human colonization of these landscapes involved a number of general patterns that reflect the environmental conditions and are likely to be unique to this particular period (a point also made by Thorley 1998). The greater relative availability and predictability of resources, including large permanent water bodies, prior to 45,000–40,000 years ago, would have facilitated exploration and exploitation of these unique interior landscapes. It is likely that the pattern and rate of exploration and colonization varied between regions in response to the specific nature and distribution of landscape features within each region. Both ethnographic and biogeographic perspectives indicate that colonization is most likely to have taken place along corridors of distinct landscape features such as rivers or mountain ranges (Kelly 2003; Veth 1989). Since such features vary between regions we suggest that there is unlikely to have been a uniform pattern of colonization across these diverse interior landscapes. More significantly, the movement of people into the interior of Australia prior to 40,000 years ago would have meant that their economic and social systems were developed in response to the existing environmental conditions. Hence, interior colonization may not have required a refined or specific adaptation to extreme aridity. Thorley (1998, 2001) has previously discussed this proposition for the initial human occupation of the central Australian ranges and plains, where Lake Amadeus and the Finke and Palmer rivers catchment would have provided more regular and more abundant resources at the time of colonization than today. Our review suggests that this notion should be extended to many of the inland regions for which we now have evidence. Without doubt the gradual desertification that followed the period of interior colonization (post-35,000 years ago) would have required modifications to foraging and social strategies. However, these modifications would have been made by forager groups which by that time had established familiarity with the landscape structure of each region. Readjustment of economic systems to even rapid trends towards aridity would have been facilitated by local group knowledge of the environment; these groups would have been advantaged by modifying their existing systems in situ, building new economic and technological strategies based on knowledge of the local landscape. In this sense we hypothesize that the widespread colonization of the Australian interior prior to the pronounced drying of the late Pleistocene meant that many foraging groups with generalized
___________________________________________________________________________________
41
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s
terrestrial economic strategies probably evolved more dedicated desert economic strategies in situ. This ‘‘desert transformation’’ model removes the paradox of explaining how people were able to migrate into Australian deserts in the late Pleistocene; in some important ways the modern deserts of Australia came to inland dwelling people, rather than the reverse. Of course, there is no connection of this model with the idea of coastal colonization (contra Thorley 1998), since the process we hypothesize implies that groups moving into interior lands had effective terrestrial foraging strategies suited to a variety of dry, semi-arid, and arid landscapes. These were not coastally adapted peoples (also as argued by O’Connor and Veth 2000); but our model predicts they were also foragers without many of the specific desert economic and social traits observable in the late Holocene and historic period. This prediction is consistent with features of the archaeological record in these interior lands. For instance, a number of the strategies taken to be risk reduction responses in the late Holocene desert economies are either absent or little utilized in the archaeological residues of the colonists moving into those regions more than 40,000 years ago. No compelling evidence for trade or long distance transportation of resources has been identified, perhaps not surprising given the exploratory nature of occupation and the indications in extremely low artifact discard rates that population densities may have been very low and perhaps territories large. Furthermore, although grinding stones are likely to have been a technology employed to exploit plant foods throughout Australian prehistory (Fullagar and Field 1997; Gorecki et al. 1997), the earliest archaeological assemblages contain few grindstones. This pattern probably reveals that the intensive processing of seeds, a key characteristic of risk minimization in historical arid zone economic strategies, emerged in response to specific conditions in the Holocene and was neither a central nor a universal feature of the initial occupation of the interior. The exploitation of the large lacustrine and riverine resources that existed at the time, plus the low densities of people occupying many inland territories, may be cited as likely reasons that seed processing was not given the same prominence during the pre-40,000 year old colonizing phase as it was in much later times. These earliest inland economies were based on a broad spectrum and flexible foraging strategy. Although not all of the early archaeological sites spread across the Australian interior have good faunal preservation, the key characteristics of hunting and animal foods can be defined as follows. A wide range of small to medium sized game was hunted, including marsupials, reptiles, and, near lacustrine systems, fish and mussels. The taxa represented varied between sites and regions in response to local conditions. Plant foods were also exploited, but as explained above, the discovery of grindstones at only one locality to date also indicates variation in the way these broad spectrum systems were implemented. A radically different view on the economy of colonizing groups proposes that early foragers targeted large land animals and were responsible for the extinction of all megafauna in Australia, during the first millennia of human occupation of the continent (e.g., Miller et al. 1999; Roberts et al. 2001). Many kinds of megafauna (species of animals exceeding 44 kg at adult weight) have become extinct in Australia
___________________________________________________________________________________
42
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s
over the last 100,000 years; however, the claim that all megafauna became extinct soon after humans colonized Australia is fraught with sampling problems and fails to consider the discovery of sites where megafaunal species existed until only 30,000–20,000 years ago (Field and Dodson 1999; Wroe et al. 2002). More significantly, not a single ‘‘kill’’ site from the initial period of interior colonization has been identified, and it seems doubtful that there could have been enough humans in interior Australia around 50,000–45,000 years ago to cause the extinction of multiple species (Hughes and Hiscock in press). A more likely explanation is that the environmental transformation of the Australian interior through the process of aridification was the trigger for faunal changes of many kinds, including local extinctions. Humans were not immune to those environmental changes and the archaeological sequence records the impact of desertification on inland foragers.
Subsequent Use of Desert Areas of Australia One consequence of our ‘‘desert transformation’’ model of pre-hyperarid colonization of the interior by generalist foragers concentrating on riverine and lacustrine resources is that desert adaptations emerged during the subsequent period. In this chapter we are concerned with two aspects of the modification of economies: the nature of economic life in the Pleistocene deserts prior to the LGM, and the impact of the LGM on desert dwellers. Archaeological evidence now reveals dynamic and varied subsistence and settlement responses to the onset of desert conditions, and suggests that these responses are not identical to the desert adaptation that emerged in the Holocene. Following a gradual cooling and drying trend initiated at about 45,000 years ago, the last glacial cycle intensified rapidly with the onset of what is called Oxygen Isotope Stage 2 (OIS2) approximately 30,000 years ago. At that time sea levels dropped rapidly by nearly 50 m over perhaps 1,000 years or less, exposing large areas of the continental shelf and making many inland areas even more continental than they had been (Chappell 1991; Lambeck and Chappell 2001; Lambeck et al. 2002; Yokoyama et al. 2001). From 30,000 to about 20,000 years ago the monsoon was the least effective it had been over the last 100,000 years or so (Johnson et al. 1999); and average air temperatures in low latitude regions, including the continental interior of Australia, appear to have been at least 6–98C lower than at present (Miller et al. 1997). Many inland areas show pronounced reductions in the availability and reliability of surface water, and of related food resources. For instance, by 35,000 years ago Lake Eyre had become dry and remained so until around 10,000 years ago (Magee and Miller 1998). During the same period there were lower and fluctuating lake levels in the Willandra system and the activation of dune building processes (Bowler 1983b, 1986, 1998). In many other lacustrine systems across Australia lake levels show significant decreases in this period, although the timing varies locally (Harrison 1993). The radically reduced precipitation/evaporation indices in OIS2 had severe consequences for not only water availability but also for vegetation patterns. Transitions to landscapes with reduced
___________________________________________________________________________________
43
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s
amounts of vegetation, floral assemblages with fewer trees/shrubs, and an increased grassland component have been inferred across many inland regions as extreme desert conditions emerged. Examples of such transformations include Carpenter’s Gap 1 in the northwest (Wallis 2001), Puritjarra rock shelter in central Australia (Bowdery 1998; Smith et al. 1995), and Cuddie Springs and Ulungra Springs in northern and western New South Wales (NSW) (Dodson and Wright 1989; Dodson et al. 1993). Changes in precipitation, temperature, and surface water availability acted in concert to enlarge the portion of Australia that would be regarded as desertic, with the semi-arid zone expanding laterally towards the continental margins, the previously semi-arid zone becoming fully arid, and deserts becoming far more inhospitable than they are today (see Jones and Bowler 1980). At least in the early portion of OIS2 some inland forager groups appeared to have continued and even consolidated their occupation, perhaps refining their generalist economic strategies to suit the landscapes in which they found themselves and in response to the desiccation of those landscapes. Adjustment of groups to different environments implies that localized adaptations were probably emerging at this time. For instance, in some localities, such as the central Murray–Darling lake systems, the number of dated archaeological sites was greater for the period 35,000–25,000 years ago than for earlier periods (Hope 1993). In other regions, such as northwestern Australia, increases in artifact discard rates have been observed within some rock shelters during this period (Morse 1993; O’Connor et al. 1993, 1999). These patterns of increased debris have been interpreted as population growth in some interior localities (e.g., Beaton 1985; Jones 1979; O’Connor et al. 1993). While models of population increase prior to 25,000 years ago are plausible, interpretations of the evidence from some localities indicate the nature and uniformity of occupation clearly varies, and no single trend can be inferred for settlement across the inland. The question of population size raises the unresolved issue of what comprised inland occupation at this time. Although numbers of sites or numbers of artifacts are notoriously unreliable indicators of the amount of human activities or number of people visiting a site, archaeological investigations of Pleistocene rock shelters and lake margins in some regions of interior Australia, such as the northwest and southeast, may indicate relatively high levels of occupation during OIS2 (Balme 1995; O’Connor et al. 1998). In contrast, other landscapes show archaeological sequences with very low artifact discard rates in this period compared to the Holocene (O’Connor et al. 1993; Smith 1989). In some sites artifact discard rates are as low as a few specimens per meter per millennium – rates which are so slow that it is unclear whether this really represents permanent occupation of the territory, or whether occasional but extended excursions by mobile foragers from adjoining landscapes during favorable seasons might be a more accurate interpretation. Irrespective of whether these differences reflect the number of people in residence or their mobility, these indicators of occupation intensity may reveal substantial differences in occupation between regions. For instance, while occupation of lake lunettes in several localities shows systematic, intensive, and sometimes dedicated exploitation of lacustrine resources (Balme 1995; Bowler 1998), there is
___________________________________________________________________________________
44
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s
minimal evidence of continuing occupation in many of the sandy deserts, except where they are bounded by other kinds of landscapes (see Hughes and Hiscock in press; O’Connor et al. 1998, 1999; Veth 1989). This variation in whether or not we have archaeological evidence for continued occupation probably reflects environmental differences between regions. This is an indication that the colonizing economic strategy, perhaps dependent on reliable access to surface water and focusing on the exploitation of riverine and lacustrine resources supplemented with nearby terrestrial resources, continued to form the core theme of many inland foragers in the period after 35,000–30,000 years ago. In a number of landscapes which retained these features, such as desert regions containing uplands, major coordinated drainage, and/or extant lake systems, archaeological evidence for occupation is found from the start of OIS2; in contrast, archaeological investigations in regions without those features have found little or no evidence of occupation. This contrast parallels Veth’s (1989) model that proposed sandy deserts without coordinated drainage and large permanent lakes often acted as barriers to occupation during the Pleistocene and early Holocene. In view of the now apparent widespread colonization of inland Australia, including sandy deserts (O’Connor et al. 1998, 1999), we hypothesize that this pattern of abandonment/avoidance of barriers of sandy deserts arose only during the period of extreme desiccation marking OIS2. If current archaeological evidence can be interpreted as revealing abandonment or greatly reduced use of some desert areas at the start of OIS2, then apparent responses of inland foragers to the intensification of arid conditions around 25,000 years ago can be viewed as an exaggeration of the existing land use strategies. The intensity of desiccation and consequent geographical expansion of arid interior Australia peaked towards the end of OIS2, during a relatively short phase spanning approximately 25,000–18,000 years ago, which we refer to as the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM). During this period conditions were both exceptionally cold and dry, and it is likely that evaporation was more effective and windiness enhanced compared to today, at least on a seasonal basis (e.g., Chappell 1991; Hubbard 1995; Magee and Miller 1998). Estimates of rainfall typically suggest levels approximately half that of today across interior Australia (Dodson and Wright 1989; Singh and Geissler 1985). The consequences of these extreme conditions must not be underestimated. Across the continent reduced vegetation cover was probably one trigger of a major phase of dune building initiated at this time (Ash and Wasson 1983; Bowler 1986; Bowler and Wasson 1984; Nanson et al. 1991; Wasson 1984) and aeolian dust storms were intense (Hesse 1994; Hesse and McTainsh 1999). Drying of lakes, and more general decline of surface water, was frequently linked to reductions in the level of water tables and, in some localities, formation of salt crusts on lake surfaces (Magee et al. 1995). These extreme conditions during the LGM caused widespread environmental stress, triggering massive – sometimes irreversible – changes to the landscape and to plant and animal resources. Some of these changes involved the temporary disappearance of food resources, such as in the Willandra Lakes where alterations to temperature, salinity, and water levels caused the loss of fish and freshwater mussels (Bowler 1998). Other kinds of changes may have involved a reduction in
___________________________________________________________________________________
45
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s
the predictability of resources, such as greater periodicity or irregularity in the refilling of water sources from rainfall. During this period it is likely that many portions of inland Australia were substantially drier than today, and archaeological research has yielded many instances of sites in which the absence of cultural material during the LGM indicates local or regional abandonment (Hiscock 1988; O’Connor et al. 1993, 1998, 1999; Veth 1989). Yet in other isolated inland regions occupation persisted, apparently within better resourced refuges. Sometimes these refuges were ranges or desert tablelands with aquifer-recharged water sources which provided plentiful, and more importantly unvarying, sources of water, as well as plants and animals (Hiscock 1984, 1988; Lamb 1996; Smith 1987, 1989). People may have exploited broader territories from these reliable bases, but in at least the case of Lawn Hill and Louie Creek Gorges in northern Queensland a contraction of territory has been demonstrated, with the residents abandoning high risk portions of the landscape from approximately 22,500 until 16,500 years ago (Hiscock 1988). Similar patterns of territorial contraction have been observed on Cape York and in northwestern Australia (Lamb 1996; Marwick 2002). These refuges would have supported only small groups of humans, and perhaps only on a semi-permanent basis, depending on the number of people and resource abundances in and around the refuge. The lake systems of western NSW represent another, perhaps shorter lived kind of refuge; there the appearance of grinding stones in archaeological deposits, either during or immediately after the LGM, is an example of the use of technological means to broaden resource use and obtain reliable access to food (Bowler 1998). Another predicted strategy would have been for groups of foragers to retreat to the semi-arid margins of inland Australia and to undertake long range trips to explore the arid zone during favorable conditions. One implication of decreased exploitation or abandonment of many deserts is that at some time following the termination of the LGM and coincident with the amelioration of climatic conditions foragers recolonized all portions of interior Australia. The timing and process of such recolonization events appear to be complex. In some localities, such as the JSN site in the Strzelecki Desert, there may be near immediate, if fleeting, exploration or exploitation of the desert (see Hughes and Hiscock in press). Another rapid resumption of land use occurred around the Lawn Hill and Louie Creek Gorges, where resource exploitation in once-abandoned landscapes was reinitiated approximately 17,000–16,000 years ago (Hiscock 1988). However, there are regions of the arid zone in which the earliest dated evidence of human reoccupation takes place many millennia after the end of the LGM (Hughes and Hiscock in press; Morse 1988; Veth 1989). These differences may reflect the environments being recolonized, especially in the favorable climatic conditions of the early Holocene. However, they also probably reflect the historical circumstances of the colonizing groups, namely whether they derived from an LGM refuge or from non-arid lands on the continental periphery, whether the colonizing groups possessed specific economic or technological capacities that might enhance their ability in the new desert landscapes, and so on. When desert occupation recommenced and/or intensified in the Holocene the distinctive recent desert economy is clearly visible, most easily recognized by the frequent use of
___________________________________________________________________________________
46
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s
grindstones to process reliable and abundant grass seeds, the abundant discard of tula adzes reflecting standardized woodworking, and the ramified long distance social and economic networks (Veth 1989). We can therefore date the emergence of that late Holocene strategy for desert adaptation to the terminal Pleistocene or early Holocene; that is, the period after the LGM. Like Veth (1989), we suspect that the roots of these Holocene adaptive systems may eventually be traced to the experiences of foragers in the refuges of the LGM.
Australian Desert Colonization in a Global Perspective Our synthesis indicates that an arid zone adaptation, of the kind observed historically, was absent from the initial colonization of the Australian deserts, and indeed from inland economies prior to the LGM. We therefore support Veth’s (1989) suggestion that the ethnographic forms of desert economy and subsistence are relatively recent, rather than representing features of inland occupation from the start (contra Gould 1977). Our hypothesis is that the historic form of desert adaptation in Australia emerged subsequent to the LGM, perhaps as a consequence of heavy selection/experimentation during the hyperarid conditions of that period and the later recolonization of desert areas. Because the evidence from Australia, both archaeological and environmental, is exceptional in its extent and detail, we have developed these propositions in reference to the Australian landmass. We now turn to a consideration of whether the pattern of early desert occupation in other parts of the globe displays similarities with the Australian situation. The following review briefly examines available evidence from current desert regions of Africa, North America, and South America. In southern Africa the environmental and archaeological history of the Kalahari Desert is known from only fragmentary records (Deacon and Lancaster 1988). As in Australia, the period leading up to the onset of OIS2 was wetter and more humid than today, while cold, dry, and arid conditions persisted through OIS2, and wetter and more humid conditions returned in the terminal Pleistocene and early Holocene (Blumel et al. 1998; Brook et al. 1996; Lancaster 1989; Robbins et al. 1996; Scott 1989; Shaw and Thomas 1996; Thomas and Shaw 2002; Thomas et al. 2003). Archaeological data from the Tsodilo Hills in the northwest Kalahari (which, it should be noted, is currently considered sub-humid rather than arid) reveals human occupation throughout the last 100,000 years, irrespective of climatic conditions (Robbins et al. 2000). Nevertheless, during periods of higher relative precipitation and more permanent water resources (such as during the terminal Pleistocene) there is evidence for more substantial occupation, with foragers exploiting nearby lacustrine resources. This image of Kalahari foragers with knowledge of the local environment adjusting to the onset of aridity offers some similarity with our interpretation of Australian prehistory. By contrast, while it is often stated that the Namib Desert situated along the southwest coast remained hyperarid throughout the late Quaternary, there is
___________________________________________________________________________________
47
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s
evidence to indicate it experienced periods of relatively increased humidity prior to the LGM and in the terminal Pleistocene–early Holocene period (Heine 1992, 1998; Lancaster 2002; Vogel 1989). Current archaeological evidence from within the Namib indicates use of the area during posited periods of relatively greater moisture availability, although given the lack of resolution about local impacts of climatic changes it is unclear whether this represents a permanent or intensive desert adaptation prior to the Holocene (Deacon and Lancaster 1988: 51–2). At the other end of the African continent the also fragmentary archaeological and climatic records from the Sahara–Sahel Desert for the period between 100,000 and 50,000 years ago tentatively reveal a positive relationship between the timing of lacustrine phases and presence of Acheulian and Levallois-Mousterian sites, although the timing of the lacustral phases is not necessarily in concert with those in the south (Petit-Maire 1991). Unfortunately, despite good climatic records of a hyperarid LGM–terminal Pleistocene followed by a substantial wet phase during the early Holocene (Gasse 2002; Haynes et al. 1989; Hoelzmann et al. 2001; Pachur and Hoelzmann 2000; Pachur and Wunnemann 1996; Salzmann 1996), the response of foragers to these environmental changes prior to the introduction of cattle domestication in the Holocene is little known. These three African areas share a pattern of long-term human occupation, perhaps extending back to and beyond the emergence of modern Homo sapiens sapiens, and there is evidence, albeit tentative, for continued occupation in some regions despite dramatic changes in climate, water availability, and food resources. Although current archaeological and paleoenvironmental evidence is limited, it appears that each region displays occupational histories that share both similarities and differences to the one reconstructed for Australia, as well as similarities and differences between each other. This perhaps suggests that no single process of desert colonization is displayed and that settlement patterns reflect the environmental and historical features of each landscape. This proposition is clarified by summaries of the situation in the New World. Desert adaptations in the Americas offer a different context in which to test models of desert colonization, primarily because the generally accepted antiquity of humans in the New World dates to only 14,000–12,000 years ago, following the end of the LGM. Our review of the terminal Pleistocene occupation of American deserts examines three landscapes: the Great Basin of North America, the cold deserts of Patagonia and Tierra del Fuego, and the high altitude deserts of the Atacama and Peruvian coast. In the Great Basin available evidence indicates lower temperatures and higher average annual precipitation rates in the terminal Pleistocene period compared to today (Grayson 1993; Thompson 1990; Wells 1976; Woodcock 1986). Under these conditions there would have been greatly expanded water resources available within the Basin, with one estimation suggesting there would have been perhaps ten times more surface water than at present (Grayson 1993: 84–6). When combined with the presence of glaciated mountainous regions (Osborn and Bevis 2001) these lacustrine and riverine features meant that late Pleistocene huntergatherers in the Great Basin operated in a very different environment to the one
___________________________________________________________________________________
48
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s
that exists today. Archaeological evidence indicates people had moved into the Basin by 11,000 years ago and continued to be archaeologically visible and widespread until ca. 7,500 bp (see Chapter 5, this volume). During this period they were utilizing a broad array of resources from a wide range of environmental settings, although there seems little doubt ‘‘the lakes and marshes were key to the adaptations of these people’’ (Grayson 1993: 242). In contrast, high temperatures and low annual precipitation produced substantially more arid conditions during the midHolocene and marked economic change involving a settlement focus on remaining permanent sources of water and the emergence of seed grinding technology (Elston 1986; Grayson 1993; Thomas 1982; Warren and Crabtree 1986). This pattern of a late emergence of the historic desert economic system, during a phase of Holocene aridification, parallels the Australian experience. In Patagonia and Tierra del Fuego people probably colonized now arid regions in the terminal Pleistocene as highly mobile foragers concentrating on forest resources, with initial colonization delayed in some deserts until climate change at the Pleistocene/Holocene boundary increased precipitation and water availability (Borrero 1999; Markgraf 1989, 1993; McCulloch et al. 1997; see also Chapter 8, this volume). The Atacama Desert and adjacent Peruvian coastline is today a high altitude desert. Initial occupation of this desert region apparently occurred about 13,000 years ago, when environmental conditions can be characterized as relatively humid, with extensive grass cover, abundant flowing rivers, and high lake levels (Betancourt et al. 2000; Grosjean and Nun˜ez 1994; Latorre et al. 2002, 2003; Nun˜ez et al. 2002; Rech et al. 2002; Sandweiss 2003; see also Chapter 13, this volume). The extensive occupation of the region during a period prior to the transition to current environmental conditions may have facilitated the in situ development of a more specific desert economic strategy, a mechanism with similarities to the process apparent in Australia.
Conclusion Colonization of deserts is a widespread and varied human experience. Our review of selected desert areas has revealed that the timing and process of colonization has varied within and between continents, but that there are themes that are displayed in the initial movement of people into landscapes that are currently deserts. This exploration of these processes has centered on what we believe to be the most comprehensive environmental and archaeological data-set, the extensive Australian deserts. Prehistoric patterns in Australia are explicable in terms of the ‘‘desert transformation’’ model advanced herein, in which people colonize terrestrial landscapes using flexible and generalized broad spectrum foraging focused on available riverine and lacustrine resources. This model posits that following the adjustment of these foragers to the local resources climatic trends towards aridification transformed these landscapes into desert, or more extreme desert, environments. This process of foragers developing modified economic behaviors in response to
___________________________________________________________________________________
49
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s
changes to their familiar environment provides an explanation for the development of diverse practices suited to different Australian deserts. Similar processes have been observed elsewhere in the world, particularly in the Americas, and represent one mechanism by which Pleistocene foragers colonized deserts. Distinctive desert adaptations of the kind seen in historical records arose much later than the period of initial desert colonization, in many cases only well into the Holocene. The emergence and form of specific historic desert economic and social systems also varied around the globe in response to specific contingent environmental and cultural histories. For instance, the occupation of Australian deserts was interrupted, and perhaps fundamentally altered, by the severe, hyperarid conditions of the LGM. In contrast, while it seems likely that the onset of desertic conditions in the Holocene of North and South America was not as extreme as those experienced during the LGM, they were apparently still dramatic enough to precipitate substantial shifts in American forager strategies. While archaeology and paleoenvironmental data from African deserts are not as yet sufficiently detailed to allow such interpretations, we have little doubt that future sustained research in these localities will reveal unique histories of desert dwellers and their cultural responses to periods of extreme climatic change during the late Pleistocene and Holocene periods. Exploring the dynamic and changing relationship between climate, landscape, and the human colonization and occupation of dry regions is likely to refine our understanding of the processes by which people moved into and adapted to these landscapes. The central limitation archaeologists currently face in refining models of ancient desert dwellers is the rarity of detailed, paired environmental and archaeological sequences (cf. Veth et al. 2000). As high resolution paleoenvironmental and archaeological information is obtained, the choices that past peoples made about their survival strategies, and the context in which they made them, will become increasingly clear.
References Ash, J. E. and Wasson, R. J. 1983: Mobility of Australian desert dunefields: 182 KA. In J. M. Chappell and J. Grindrod (eds), CLIMANZ: Proceedings of the First CLIMANZ Conference, Howman’s Gap, Victoria, 1981, Canberra: Department of Biogeography and Geomorphology, Research School of Pacific Studies, The Australian National University, 46–7. Balme, J. 1995: 30,000 years of fishery in western New South Wales. Archaeology in Oceania, 30, 1–21. Balme, J. 2000: Excavations revealing 40,000 years of occupation at Mimbi Caves, south central Kimberley, Western Australia. Australian Archaeology, 51, 1–5. Beaton, J. M. 1985: Evidence for a coastal occupation time lag at Princess Charlotte Bay (north Queensland) and implication for coastal colonization and population growth theories for Aboriginal Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 20, 1–20. Betancourt, J. L., Latorre, C., Rech, J. A., Quade, J., and Rylander, K. A. 2000: A 22,000 year record of monsoonal precipitation from northern Chile’s Atacama Desert. Science, 289, 1542–6.
___________________________________________________________________________________
50
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s Blu¨mel, W. D., Eitel, B., and Lang, A. 1998: Dunes in southeastern Namibia: Evidence for Holocene environmental changes in the southeastern Kalahari based on thermoluminescence data. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 138, 139–49. Borrero, L. A. 1999: The prehistoric exploration and colonization of Fuego-Patagonia. Journal of World Prehistory, 13 (3), 321–55. Bowdery, D. 1998: Phytolith Analysis applied to Pleistocene–Holocene Archaeological Sites in the Australian Arid Zone. Oxford: BAR International Monograph Series no. 695, Hadrian Books. Bowdler, S. 1977: The coastal colonization of Australia. In J. Allen, J. Golson, and R. Jones (eds), Sunda and Sahul: Prehistoric Studies in Southeast Asia, Melanesia and Australia, London: Academic Press, 205–46. Bowler, J. M. 1983a: 325KA Northern Australia: Hydrologic evidence. In J. M. Chappell and J. Grindrod (eds), CLIMANZ: Proceedings of the First CLIMANZ Conference, Howman’s Gap, Victoria, 1981, Canberra: Department of Biogeography and Geomorphology, Research School of Pacific Studies, The Australian National University, 4–6. Bowler, J.M. 1983b: 325KA Southern Australia; Hydrologic evidence. In J. M. Chappell and J. Grindrod (eds), CLIMANZ: Proceedings of the First CLIMANZ Conference, Howman’s Gap, Victoria, 1981, Canberra: Department of Biogeography and Geomorphology, Research School of Pacific Studies, The Australian National University, 6–9. Bowler, J. M. 1986: Quaternary landform evolution. In D. N. Jeans (ed.), The Natural Environment – A Geography of Australia, vol. 1, Sydney: Sydney University Press, 117–47. Bowler, J. M. 1998: Willandra Lakes revisited: Environmental framework for human occupation. Archaeology in Oceania, 33, 120–55. Bowler, J. M. and Magee, J. W. 2000: Redating Australia’s oldest human remains: A sceptic’s view. Journal of Human Evolution, 38, 719–26. Bowler, J. M. and Price, D. M. 1998: Luminescence dates and stratigraphic analyses at Lake Mungo: Review and new perspectives. Archaeology in Oceania, 33, 156–68. Bowler, J. M. and Wasson, R. J. 1984: Glacial age environments of inland Australia. In J. C. Vogel (ed.), Late Cainozoic Paleoclimates of the Southern Hemisphere, Rotterdam: A. A. Balkema, 183–208. Bowler, J. M., Duller, G. A. T., Perret, N., Prescott, J. R., and Wrywoll, K.-H. 1998: Hydrologic changes in monsoonal climates of the last glacial cycle: Stratigraphy and luminescence dating of Lake Woods, NT, Australia. Palaeoclimates, 3 (1–3), 179–207. Bowler, J. M., Johnston, H., Olley, J. M., Prescott, J. R., Roberts, R. G., Shawcross, W., and Spooner, N. A. 2003: New ages for human occupation and climatic change at Lake Mungo, Australia. Nature, 421, 837–40. Bowler, J. M., Wyrwoll, K.-H., and Lu, Y. 2001: Variations of the northwest Australian summer monsoon over the last 300,000 years: The paleohydrological record of the Gregory (Mulan) Lakes System. Quaternary International, 83–5, 63–80. Brook, G. A., Cowart, J. B., and Marais, E. 1996: Wet and dry periods in the southern African summer rainfall zone during the last 300 kyr from speleothem, tufa, and sand dune age data. Palaeoecology of Africa, 24, 147–58. Chappell, J. 1991: Late Quaternary environmental changes in eastern and central Australia and their climatic interpretation. Quaternary Science Reviews, 10, 377–90. Deacon, J. and Lancaster, N. 1988: Late Quaternary Paleoenvironments of Southern Africa. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Dodson, J. R. and Wright, R. V. S. 1989: Humid to arid to sub-humid vegetation shifts on Pilliga Sandstone, Ulungra Springs, New South Wales. Quaternary Research, 32, 182–92.
___________________________________________________________________________________
51
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s Dodson, J. R., Fullagar, R., Furby, J., Jones, R., and Prosser, I. 1993: Humans and megafauna in a late Pleistocene environment from Cuddie Springs, northwestern New South Wales. Archaeology in Oceania, 28, 94–9. Elston, R. G. 1986: Prehistory of the western area. In W. L. d’Azevedo (ed.), Handbook of North American Indians vol. 11, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 135–48. Field, J. and Dodson, J. 1999: Late Pleistocene megafauna and archaeology from Cuddie Springs, southeastern Australia. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society, 65, 1–27. Fifield, L. K., Bird, M. I., Turney, C. S. M., Hausladen, P. A., Santos, G. M., and di Tada, M. L. 2001: Radiocarbon dating of the human occupation of Australia prior to 40 ka bp – successes and pitfalls. Radiocarbon, 43, 1139–45. Fullagar, R. and Field, J. 1997: Pleistocene seed grinding implements from the Australian arid zone. Antiquity, 71, 300–7. Gasse, F. 2002: Diatom-inferred salinity and carbonate oxygen isotopes in Holocene waterbodies of the western Sahara and Sahel (Africa). Quaternary Science Reviews, 21, 737–67. Gentilli, J. 1986: Climate. In D. N. Jeans (ed.), The Natural Environment – A Geography of Australia vol. 1, Sydney: Sydney University Press, 14–48. Gillespie, R. 1998: Alternative timescales: A critical review of Willandra Lakes dating. Archaeology in Oceania, 33, 169–82. Gillespie, R. and Roberts, R. G. 2000: On the reliability of age estimates for human remains at Lake Mungo. Journal of Human Evolution, 38, 727–32. Gorecki, P., Grant, M., O’Connor, S., and Veth, P. 1997: The morphology, function, and antiquity of Australian grinding implements. Archaeology in Oceania, 32 (2), 141–50. Gould, R. A. 1977: Puntutjarpa Rockshelter and the Australian Desert Culture. New York: Anthropological Papers of the American Museum of Natural History no. 54, American Museum of Natural History. Grayson, D. K. 1993: The Desert’s Past: A Natural Prehistory of the Great Basin. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Grosjean, M. and Nun˜ez, L. A. 1994: Late glacial, early, and middle Holocene environments, human occupation and resource use in the Atacama (northern Chile). Geoarchaeology, 9, 271–86. Gru¨n, R., Spooner, N. A., Thorne, A., Mortimer, G., Simpson, J. J., McCulloch, M. T., Taylor, L., and Curnoe, D. 2000: Age of the Lake Mungo 3 skeleton – reply to Bowler & Magee and to Gillespie & Roberts. Journal of Human Evolution, 38, 733–42. Harrison, S. P. 1993: Late Quaternary lake level changes and climates of Australia. Quaternary Science Reviews, 12, 211–31. Haynes Jr, C. V., Eyles, C. H., Pavlish, L. A., Ritchie, J. C., and Rybak, M. 1989: Holocene paleohydrology of the eastern Sahara: Selima Oasis. Quaternary Science Reviews, 8, 109–36. Heine, K. 1992: On the ages of humid Late Quaternary phase in southern African arid areas (Namibia, Botswana). Palaeoecology of Africa, 23, 149–64. Heine, K. 1998: Climate change over the past 135,000 years in the Namib Desert (Namibia) derived from proxy data. Palaeoecology of Africa, 25, 171–98. Hesse, P. P. 1994: The record of continental dust from Australia in Tasman Sea sediments. Quaternary Science Reviews, 13, 257–72. Hesse, P. P. and McTainsh, G. H. 1999: Last Glacial Maximum to early Holocene wind strength in the mid-latitudes of the Southern Hemisphere from aeolian dust in the Tasman Sea. Quaternary Research, 52, 343–9.
___________________________________________________________________________________
52
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s Hesse, P. P., Magee, J. W., and van der Kaars, S. 2004: Late Quaternary climates of the Australian arid zone: A review. Quaternary International, 118–19, 87–102. Hiscock, P. 1984: Preliminary report on the stone artifacts from Colless Creek Cave, northwest Queensland. Queensland Archaeological Research, 1, 120–51. Hiscock, P. 1988: Prehistoric settlement patterns and artifact manufacture at Lawn Hill, northwest Queensland. Unpublished PhD thesis, Brisbane: University of Queensland. Hiscock, P. 1990: Comment: How old are the artifacts at Malakunanja II? Archaeology in Oceania, 25, 122–4. Hoelzmann, P., Keding, B., Berke, H., Kro¨pelin, S., and Kruse, H. J. 2001: Environmental change and archaeology: Lake evolution and human occupation in the eastern Sahara during the Holocene. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 169, 193–217. Hope, J. H. 1993: Pleistocene archaeological sites in the central Murray Darling Basin. In M. A. Smith, M. Spriggs, and B. Fankhauser (eds), Sahul in Review: Pleistocene Archaeology in Australia, New Guinea, and Island Melanesia, Canberra: The Australian National University, 183–96. Hubbard, N. N. 1995: In search of regional palaeoclimates: Australia 18,000 yr bp. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 116, 167–88. Hughes, P. and Hiscock, P. in press: The archaeology of the Lake Eyre South area. In Aboriginal Occupation of the Lake Eyre South Region: Ethnography and Archaeology, Adelaide: Lake Eyre Monograph Series vol. 6, Royal Geographical Society of South Australia. Johnson, B. J., Miller, G. H., Fogel, M. L., Magee, J. W., Gagan, M. K., and Chivas, A. R. 1999: 65,000 years of vegetation change in central Australia and the Australian summer monsoon. Science, 284, 1150–2. Jones, R. 1979: The fifth continent: Problems concerning the human colonization of Australia. Annual Review of Anthropology, 8, 445–6. Jones, R. and Bowler, J. M. 1980: Struggle for the savannah: Northern Australia in ecological and prehistoric perspective. In R. Jones (ed.), Northern Australia: Options and Implications, Canberra: The Australian National University, 3–32. Kelly, R. L. 2003: Colonization of new land by hunter-gatherers: Expectations and implications based on ethnographic data. In M. Rockman and J. Steele (eds), Colonization of Unfamiliar Landscapes: The Archaeology of Adaptation, New York: Routledge, 44–58. Lamb, L. 1996: Investigating changing stone technologies, site use, and occupational intensities at Fern Cave, north Queensland. Australian Archaeology, 42, 1–7. Lambeck, K. and Chappell, J. 2001: Sea level change through the last glacial cycle. Science, 292, 679–86. Lambeck, K., Yokoyama, Y., and Purcell, T. 2002: Into and out of the Last Glacial Maximum: Sea level change during Oxygen Isotope Stages 3 and 2. Quaternary Science Reviews, 21, 343–60. Lancaster, N. 1989: Late Quaternary paleoenvironments in the southwestern Kalahari. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 70, 367–76. Lancaster, N. 2002: How dry was dry? Late Pleistocene paleoclimates in the Namib Desert. Quaternary Science Reviews, 21, 769–82. Latorre, C., Betancourt, J. L., Rylander, K. A., and Quade, J. 2002: Vegetation invasions into absolute desert: A 45,000 year rodent midden record from the Calam-Salar de Atacama basins, northern Chile (lat 228–248S). Geological Society of America Bulletin, 114 (3), 349–66.
___________________________________________________________________________________
53
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s Latorre, C., Betancourt, J. L., Rylander, K. A., Quade, J., and Matthei, O. 2003: A vegetation history from the arid prepuna of northern Chile (22–238S) over the last 13,500 years. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 194, 223–46. McCulloch, R., Clapperton, C., Rabassa, J., and Currant, A. P. 1997: The natural setting – The glacial and post-glacial environmental history of Fuego-Patagonia. In C. McEwan, L. A. Borerro, and A. Prieto (eds), Patagonia: Natural History, Prehistory, and Ethnography at the Uttermost Ends of the Earth, London: British Museum Press. Magee, J. W. and Miller, G. H. 1998: Lake Eyre paleohydrology from 60 ka to the present: Beach ridges and glacial maximum aridity. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 144, 307–29. Magee, J. W., Bowler, J. M., Miller, G. H., and Williams, D. L. G. 1995: Stratigraphy, sedimentology, chronology, and paleohydrology of Quaternary lacustrine deposits at Madigan Gulf, Lake Eyre, South Australia. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 113, 3–42. Markgraf, V. 1989: Paleoclimates in central and South America since 18,000 based on pollen and lake level records. Quaternary Science Reviews, 8, 1–24. Markgraf, V. 1993. Paleoenvironments and paleoclimates in Tierra del Fuego and southernmost Patagonia, South America. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 102, 53–68. Marwick, B. 2002: Milly’s Cave: Evidence for human occupation of the inland Pilbara during the Last Glacial Maximum. In S. Ulm, C. Westcott, J. Reid, A. Ross, I. Lilley, J. Prangnell, and L. Kirkwood (eds), Barriers, Borders, Boundaries: Proceedings of the 2001 Australian Archaeological Association Annual Conference, St Lucia: University of Queensland, 21–33. Miller, G. H., Magee, J. W., and Jull, A. J. T. 1997: Low latitude cooling in the Southern Hemisphere from amino-acid racemization in emu eggshells. Nature, 385, 241–4. Miller, G. H., Magee, J. W., Johnson, B. J., Fogel, M. L., Spooner, N. A., McCulloch, M. T., and Ayliffe, L. K. 1999: Pleistocene extinction of Genyornis newtoni: Human impact on Australian megafauna. Science, 283, 205–8. Morse, K. 1988: Mandu Mandu Creek rock shelter: Pleistocene human coastal occupation of North West Cape, Western Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 23 (3), 81–8. Morse, K. 1993: Who can see the sea? Aboriginal occupation of the Cape Range Peninsula. Records of the Western Australian Museum Supplement, 45, 227–42. Nanson, G. C., Price, D. M., Short, S. A., Page, K. J., and Nott, J. F. 1991: Major episodes of climate change in Australia over the last 300,000 years. In R. Gillespie (ed.), Quaternary Dating Workshop 1990, Canberra: Department of Biogeography and Geomorphology, Research School of Pacific Studies, The Australian National University, 45–50. Nun˜ez, L., Grosjean, M., and Cartajena, I. 2002: Human occupations and climate change in the Puna de Atacama, Chile. Science, 298, 821–4. O’Connell, J. F. and Allen, J. 1998: When did humans first arrive in Greater Australia and why is it important to know? Evolutionary Anthropology, 6, 132–46. O’Connell, J. F. and Allen, J. in press: Dating the colonization of Sahul (Pleistocene Australia–New Guinea): A review of recent research. Journal of Archaeological Science. O’Connor, S. and Veth, P. 2000: The world’s first mariners: Savanna dwellers in an island continent. Modern Quaternary Research in Southeast Asia, 16, 99–137. O’Connor, S., Veth, P., and Barham, A. 1999: Cultural versus natural explanations for lacunae in Aboriginal occupation deposits in northern Australia. Quaternary International, 59, 61–70.
___________________________________________________________________________________
54
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s O’Connor, S., Veth, P., and Campbell, C. 1998: Serpent’s Glen rock shelter: Report of the first Pleistocene-aged occupation sequence from the Western Desert. Australian Archaeology, 46, 12–21. O’Connor, S., Veth, P., and Hubbard, N. 1993: Changing interpretations of postglacial human subsistence and demography in Sahul. In M. A. Smith, M. Spriggs, and B. Fankhauser (eds), Sahul in Review: The Archaeology of Australia, New Guinea and Island Melanesia, Canberra: The Australian National University, 95–105. Osborn, G. and Bevis, K. 2001: Glaciation in the Great Basin of the Western United States. Quaternary Science Reviews, 20, 1377–410. Pachur, H. J. and Hoelzmann, P. 2000: Late Quaternary paleoecology and paleoclimates of the eastern Sahara. Journal of African Earth Sciences, 30 (4), 929–39. Pachur, H. J. and Wunnemann, B. 1996: Reconstruction of the paleoclimate along 308E in the eastern Sahara during the Pleistocene/Holocene transition. Palaeoecology of Africa, 24, 1–32. Pack, S. M., Miller, G. M., Fogel, M. L., and Spooner, N. A. 2003: Carbon isotopic evidence for increased aridity in northwestern Australia through the Quaternary. Quaternary Science Reviews, 22, 629–43. Pearce, R. H. and Barbetti, M. 1981: A 38,000 year old archaeological site at Upper Swan, Western Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 16, 173–8. Petit-Maire, N. 1991: Recent Quaternary climatic change and man in the Sahara. Journal of African Earth Sciences, 12 (1/2), 125–32. Rech, J. A., Quade, J., and Betancourt, J. L. 2002: Late Quaternary paleohydrology of the central Atacama Desert (lat 228–248S), Chile. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 114 (3), 334–48. Richardson, N. 1992: Conjoin sets and stratigraphic integrity in a sandstone shelter: Kenniff Cave (Queensland, Australia). Antiquity, 66, 408–18. Rindos, D. and Webb, E. 1992: Modeling the initial human colonization of Australia: Perfect adaptation, cultural variability, and cultural change. Proceedings of the Australasian Society of Human Biology, 5, 441–54. Robbins, L. H., Murphy, M. L., Brook, G. A., Ivester, A. H., Campbell, A. C., Klein, R. G., Milo, R. G., Stewart, K. M., Downey, W. S., and Stevens, N. J. 2000: Archaeology, paleoenvironment, and chronology of the Tsodilo Hills White Paintings rock shelter, northwest Kalahari Desert, Botswana. Journal of Archaeological Science, 27, 1085–113. Robbins, L. H., Murphy, M. L., Stevens, N. J., Brook, G. A., Ivester, A. H., Haberyan, K. A., Klein, R. G., Milo, R., Stewart, K. M., Matthiesen, D. G., and Winkler, A. J. 1996: Paleoenvironment and archaeology of Drotsky’s Cave: Western Kalahari Desert, Botswana. Journal of Archaeological Science, 23, 7–22. Roberts, R., Flannery, T., Ayliffe, L., Yoshida, H., Olley, J., Prideaux, G., Laslett, G., Baynes, A., Smith, M., Jones, R., and Smith, B. 2001: New ages for the last Australian megafauna: Continent-wide extinction about 46,000 years ago. Science, 292, 1888–92. Roberts, R. G., Jones, R., and Smith, M. A. 1990: Thermoluminescence dating of a 50,000 year old human occupation site in northern Australia. Nature, 345, 153–6. Roberts, R. G., Jones, R., and Smith, M. A. 1993: Optical dating at Deaf Adder Gorge, Northern Territory, indicates human occupation between 53,000 and 60,000 years ago. Australian Archaeology, 37, 58–9. Roberts, R. G., Jones, R., Spooner, N. A., Head, M. J., Murray, A. S., and Smith, M. A. 1994: The human colonization of Australia: Optical dates of 53,000 and 60,000 years bracket
___________________________________________________________________________________
55
_______________________________________________________________________________
P e t e r H is c oc k a n d L y n l e y A . W a l l i s human arrival at Deaf Adder Gorge, Northern Territory. Quaternary Science Reviews, 13, 575–83. Roberts, R. G., Spooner, N. A., Jones, R., Cane, S., Olley, J. M., Murray, A. S., and Head, J. 1996: Preliminary luminescence dating for archaeological sediments on the Nullarbor Plain, South Australia. Australian Archaeology, 42, 7–16. Salzmann, U. 1996: Holocene vegetation history of the Sahelian zone of NE Nigeria: Preliminary results. Palaeoecology of Africa, 24, 103–14. Sandweiss, D. 2003: Terminal Pleistocene through mid-Holocene archaeological sites as paleoclimatic archives for the Peruvian coast. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 194, 23–40. Scott, L. 1989: Climatic conditions in southern Africa since the Last Glacial Maximum, inferred from pollen analysis. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 70, 345–53. Shaw, P. A. and Thomas, D. S. G. 1996: The Quaternary paleoenvironmental history of the Kalahari, southern Africa. Journal of Arid Environments, 32, 9–22. Singh, G. and Geissler, E. A. 1985: Late Cainozoic history of vegetation, fire, lake levels, and climate at Lake George, New South Wales, Australia. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, B311, 379–447. Smith, M. A. 1987: Pleistocene occupation in arid central Australia. Nature, 328, 710. Smith, M. A. 1989: The case for a resident human population in the central Australian ranges during full glacial aridity. Archaeology in Oceania, 24 (3), 93–105. Smith, M. A., Prescott, J. R., and Head, M. J. 1997: Comparison of 14C and luminescence chronologies at Puritjarra rock shelter, central Australia. Quaternary Science Reviews, 16, 299–320. Smith, M. A., Vellen, L., and Pask, J. 1995: Vegetation history from archaeological charcoals in central Australia: The late Quaternary record from Puritjarra rock shelter. Vegetation History and Archaeobotany, 4, 171–7. Thomas, D. H. 1982: An overview of central Great Basin prehistory. Society for American Archaeology Papers, 2, 156–71. Thomas, D. S. G. and Shaw, P. A. 2002: Late Quaternary environmental change in central southern Africa: New data, synthesis, issues, and prospects. Quaternary Science Reviews, 21, 783–97. Thomas, D. S. G., Brook, G., Shaw, P., Bateman, M., Haberyan, K., Appletone, C., Nash, D., McLaren, S., and Davies, F. 2003: Late Pleistocene wetting and drying in the NW Kalahari: An integrated study from the Tsodilo Hills, Botswana. Quaternary International, 104, 53–67. Thompson, R. S. 1990: Late Quaternary vegetation and climate in the Great Basin. In J. L. Betancourt, T. R. Van der Devender, and P. S. Martin (eds), Packrat Middens: The Last 40,000 Years of Biotic Change, Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 200–39. Thorley, P. B. 1998: Pleistocene settlement in the Australian arid zone: Occupation of an inland riverine landscape in the central Australian ranges. Antiquity, 72, 34–45. Thorley, P. B. 2001: Uncertain supplies: Water availability and regional archaeological structure in the Palmer River catchment, central Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 36, 1–14. Thorne, A., Gru¨n, R., Mortimer, G., Spooner, N. A., Simpson, J. J., McCulloch, M., Taylor, L., and Curnoe, D. 1999: Australia’s oldest human remains: Age of the Lake Mungo 3 skeleton. Journal of Human Evolution, 36 (6), 591–612. Tonkinson, R. 1991: The Martu Aboriginies: Living the Dream of Australia’s Desert. Forth Worth, TX: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.
___________________________________________________________________________________
56
_______________________________________________________________________________
P l e i s t o c en e S e t t l e m e n t o f D e s e r t s van der Kaars, S. A. 1991: Palynology of eastern Indonesian marine piston cores: A late Quaternary vegetational and climatic record for Australasia. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 85, 239–302. Veth, P. 1989: Islands in the interior: A model for the colonization of Australia’s arid zone. Archaeology in Oceania, 24 (3), 81–92. Veth, P., O’Connor, S., and Wallis, L. A. 2000: Perspectives on ecological approaches in Australian archaeology. Australian Archaeology, 50, 54–66. Vogel, J. C. 1989: Evidence of past climate change in the Namib Desert. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 70, 355–66. Wallis, L. A. 2001: Environmental history of northwest Australia based on phytolith analysis at Carpenter’s Gap 1. Quaternary International, 83–5, 103–17. Wang, X., van der Kaars, S., Kershaw, A. P., Bird, M., and Jansen, F. 1999: A record of fire, vegetation, and climate through the last three glacial cycles from Lombok Ridge core G64, eastern Indian Ocean, Indonesia. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 147, (3–4), 241–56. Warren, C. N. and Crabtree, R. H. 1986: Prehistory of the southwestern area. In W. L. d’Azevedo (ed.), Handbook of North American Indians vol. 11, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 183–93. Wasson, R. J. 1984: Late Quaternary paleoenvironments in the desert dunefields of Australia. In J. C. Vogel (ed.), Late Cainozoic Paleoclimates of the Southern Hemisphere, Rotterdam: A. A. Balkema, 419–32. Wells, P. V. 1976: Macrofossil analysis of wood rat (Neotoma) middens as a key to the Quaternary vegetational history of arid America. Quaternary Research, 6, 223–48. Woodcock, D. 1986: The late Pleistocene of Death Valley: A climatic reconstruction based on macrofossil data. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 57, 272–83. Wroe, S., Field, J., and Fullagar, R. 2002: Lost giants. Nature Australia, 27 (5), 54–61. Yokoyama, Y., Purcell, A., Lambeck, K., and Johnston, P. 2001: Shoreline reconstruction around Australia during the Last Glacial Maximum and Late Glacial Stage. Quaternary International, 83–5, 9–18.
___________________________________________________________________________________
57
_______________________________________________________________________________
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Arid Paradises or Dangerous Landscapes A Review of Explanations for Paleolithic Assemblage Change in Arid Australia and Africa Peter Hiscock and Sue O’Connor
Introduction An inspection of archaeological studies from the arid and semi-arid regions of Australia and sub-Saharan Africa reveals very different images of the human occupation of each continent. Since the human history of each landmass is obviously distinct, many aspects of these images of the human past may reflect divergent cultural processes being played out in dissimilar arid environments. Such arguments fail to explain why the archaeological record in each continent displays parallel patterns, and discount fundamental questions about our characterization and explication of archaeological changes in the two continents. For example, in both Africa and Australia ancient humans employed a particular technology that involved backing of flakes to produce distinctive and regularly shaped stone implements that we will call backed artifacts. (The term microlith has often been used for these forms but is applicable only to small size variants.) In both continents this technological behavior has been present for extended periods of time, but was emphasized in some periods but not in others. Rather than presume these parallel patterns must be unrelated or are uninteresting, this chapter examines the explanations that have been offered for the periodic emphasis on backed artifacts by archaeologists exploring the human history of these two continents. Our examination reveals that the formulation of seemingly similar themes of archaeological change has been radically different in each continent, and we employ that insight to both evaluate the viability of various kinds of explanations and to demonstrate that the inferred histories of humans in each landmass are founded on different images of human life in deserts.
___________________________________________________________________________________
58
_______________________________________________________________________________
Ar i d P a r a d i s e s o r D a n g e r o u s L a n d s c a p e s
Depicting the Archaeological Changes Our starting point in this exploration is to describe the broad chronological and spatial patterns of backed implements on each continent and to discuss the way archaeologists have described changes in lithic assemblages. Our review includes sites that are presently in arid and semi-arid environments, but is of course not limited to those places, since the location of environmental boundaries has shifted through time.
Assemblage Change in Australia Backed artifacts have been reliably dated to the early Holocene (9,000–6,000 bp) in Australia, but may have been present in the terminal Pleistocene (Hiscock and Attenbrow 1998). However, prior to the mid-Holocene backed artifact production was clearly occurring at low levels and may have been regionally restricted (Hiscock 2002). For at least some regions in eastern Australia these early examples of backed artifacts appear to be extremely similar to the size and morphological patterns found in later backed artifacts in each region, although the size and manufacturing strategies vary between regions. The relationship between these terminal Pleistocene/early Holocene specimens and later backed artifacts was unclear until Hiscock and Attenbrow (1998) emphasized the importance of distinguishing between the appearance of backed artifacts and subsequent periods of increased rates of production. The importance of this distinction is that low rates of backed artifact production may be hard to detect archaeologically and such a period might be mistaken for one without such implements, while a subsequent period in which backed artifacts were frequently manufactured will be highly visible in the archaeological record and may appear to signal the ‘‘introduction’’ of backed artifacts to a region when in fact it represents the ‘‘efflorescence’’ of production. This methodological issue was accentuated by the low discovery probabilities for backed artifacts in small assemblages that were common in the early Holocene levels of a number of key sites (Hiscock 2001). These considerations have removed doubts about the existence of early Holocene backed artifacts and clarified the emergence of intensive backed artifact production following an extended period of low level backed artifact manufacture (Hiscock 2002). During the mid- and late Holocene the production rate for backed artifacts increased dramatically (Hiscock 2002). The timing of this proliferation appears to vary between regions, with some regions displaying marked increases in discarded backed artifacts around 4,000 bp, while other regions show the increased rate of backed artifact production at about 3,000 bp or less. This phase of high rates of backed artifact manufacture was brief in Australia, and in most localities was concluded by 1,000 bp. In some regions the chronology of these changes is not yet precisely known. The regionalized nature of these patterns is displayed on a continental scale. Backed artifacts are absent from the tropical north-central and northwestern
___________________________________________________________________________________
59
_______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r H i s c o c k a n d S ue O’ C o n n o r
portions of the continent, landscapes in which bifacial points were manufactured. The island of Tasmania also has no recorded backed artifacts. Elsewhere on mainland Australia backed artifacts are known, although their relative and absolute abundance varies regionally. One broad scale spatial pattern involves the differential distribution of symmetrical and asymmetrical variants. Asymmetrical backed artifacts are very common on the east coast and in the southwest of the continent, while symmetrical crescent, triangle, and trapeze forms are abundant in the arid and semi-arid landscapes. The significance of these geographic differences for explanations of assemblage variation is currently being debated.
Assemblage Change in Africa By comparison to the Australian situation the history of backed artifacts in subSaharan Africa is both long and complex. Large, thick backed artifacts have been present in very low quantities in at least some African assemblages during the initial phases of the Middle Stone Age (MSA) more than 300,000–200,000 years ago, although they were often infrequent. However, in central Africa the Lupemban Industry comprised assemblages dominated by backed artifacts dated to 300,000– 250,000 bp (Barham 2002; Clark 1988; Cornelissen 2002). This demonstrates that backing of small flakes is a technical process that is present in sub-Saharan Africa from the very start of the MSA. In southern Africa backed artifacts are known from sites such as Klasies River during the last interglacial and are present in assemblages designated as Phases 1 and 2 of the MSA, labeled MSA 1 and MSA 2 (Wurz 2002). However, although present, backing is comparatively infrequent in MSA 1/2 assemblages of southern Africa. Nevertheless, backed artifact production proliferates approximately 80,000– 70,000 bp in a series of southern African assemblages. Termed the Howieson’s Poort Industry, these assemblages are best known for their numerous backed artifacts, although they also contain a range of other retouched artifacts including bifacially and unifacially flaked points with bulb thinning (Deacon and Wurz 1996). As represented at sites such as Klasies River these backed objects were regular in shape and were often made from non-local, fine-grained siliceous raw materials (Ambrose 2002; Wurz 2002). Following the Howieson’s Poort Industries the subsequent culture historical periods, Phases 3 and 4 of the MSA, labeled MSA 3 and MSA 4, have no recorded backed artifacts. Although the MSA 3/4 assemblages are rare and low density phenomena, creating questions of sample adequacy in assessing assemblage composition, the consensus is that backed artifacts are absent from the MSA 3 and MSA 4 assemblages that succeed Howieson’s Poort (Ambrose 2002). However, this interpretation is not universally supported by archaeological evidence and in eastern African assemblages backed artifacts are present in the MSA, from at least 65,000–50,000 bp (McBrearty and Brooks 2000). We therefore suggest that MSA 3/4 assemblages have very few backed specimens, but that it is not clear that such implements were absent from all sites during those phases.
___________________________________________________________________________________
60
_______________________________________________________________________________
Ar i d P a r a d i s e s o r D a n g e r o u s L a n d s c a p e s
In southern Africa archaeologists classify assemblages containing small backed artifacts, points, bipolar cores, and denticulates, often making extensive use of good quality fine-grained raw material, as the Later Stone Age (LSA). The chronological and culture-historical coherence of early LSA assemblages is a matter of uncertainty, with most examples dating to less than 25,000 bp while a few sites display these characteristics at approximately 40,000 bp (Ambrose 2002). The early LSA assemblages have been classified into a variety of industries, including the Robberg and Albany, but the relevant feature is that although they typically contain backed artifacts these are infrequent elements in these assemblages (although see Mitchell 1988). Transitional and LSA industries in east Africa, such as the Nasera and Lemuta Industries of Tanzania and Kenya, also have backed artifacts and high quality non-local raw material imported a considerable distance (Ambrose 2002). In the early LSA industries of east Africa the proportional frequency of backed artifacts is highly variable. While backed specimens are extremely frequent in some assemblages, such as the Nasampolai as represented in Enkapune Ya Muto shelter, they are minor elements in many other east African LSA assemblages of the period prior to 25,000 bp. In both eastern and southern Africa during the LGM/terminal Pleistocene (20,000–13,000 bp) backed artifacts are less common in most industries than at earlier and later times (Ambrose 2002). Backed artifacts are again a dominant element in some Holocene industries, most notably that called the Wilton, which is concentrated in the more arid period of the mid-Holocene. Wilton assemblages have high frequencies of regular, usually small backed artifacts and fine-grained raw materials. Volman (1984) and others have suggested that both the MSA and LSA backed artifacts were produced for hafting. Direct evidence is sparse, although a few examples have been found with mastic traces. Because of the relative difference in size it has been suggested that MSA backed artifacts were hafted in spears, whereas their LSA counterparts were inserted into arrows. Employing the distinction advocated by Hiscock and Attenbrow (1998) between periods representing a proliferation or efflorescence of backed artifacts and periods in which they are present but not emphasized, the sub-Saharan African sequence can be read as having multiple phases in which backed artifacts were produced at relatively high rates (measured as a proportion of retouched flakes), interspersed with phases in which backed artifacts were either absent or produced in relatively lower frequencies. While the patchy nature of high quality assemblage information through time and space makes it difficult to unambiguously specify the nature and duration of periods it is clear that we can talk of at least three or four efflorescence phases. The earliest is the early MSA backed artifact proliferation discussed by Barham (2002) for sites such as Twin Rivers and Kalambo Falls in central Africa. A distinct efflorescence is represented by Howieson’s Poort (ca. 70,000 bp), which is usually thought to be chronologically far earlier than LSA assemblages and therefore ‘‘is not considered to be transitional to the LSA’’ (Ambrose 2002: 12). A third period of intensified backed artifact production is found in some regional variants of the early LSA (50,000–30,000 bp). The fourth obvious efflorescence is represented by the Wilton and similar Holocene industries
___________________________________________________________________________________
61
_______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r H i s c o c k a n d S ue O’ C o n n o r
(8,000–3,000 bp). It is not our intention to hypothesize that there are only four periods in which assemblages have large quantities of backed implements, that during a period of high backed artifact production rates every assemblage in a region will display that pattern, or that this sequence applies across all of subSaharan Africa. What is important here is the recognition of the reoccurrence of technological patterns emphasizing backed artifacts. In Africa, assemblages dominated by backed artifacts are neither randomly situated in time and space nor restricted to a single culture-historical horizon. It is not merely the existence of early backed artifacts in the African sequence that contrasts with Australia and requires explanation, but also this reoccurring pattern of backed artifact efflorescence through time.
Explanations for Backed Artifact Efflorescence We now turn to different explanations that archaeologists have offered for ancient backed artifacts in these two continents. Our concern is to characterize influential explanations and to evaluate their capacity to explicate the archaeological patterns as we have described them. Mitchell (1995) has presented a classification of ‘‘approaches’’ to Paleolithic studies in south Africa, in which he describes four kinds of models: organizational, functional, sociological, and techno-environmental. Rather than engage in a classificatory exercise of this kind our critique proceeds by examining specific explanations that have been offered for changes in backed artifact frequency.
Cognitive Capacity as an Explanation One widely discussed explanation for the proliferation of backed artifacts in Africa is the emergence of modern human behavior or ‘‘cultural modernity’’ (Wadley 2001; see also Ambrose 2001). This explanation is based on the notion that earlier hominids had little or no capacity for language and symbolism and the social interactions that follow from those capacities. It is often argued that these capacities define modern human social life and that they must have emerged rapidly, as a revolution in human evolution (Wadley 2001). Authors such as Klein (2000: 27) have suggested a biological basis for the revolutionary shift in cultural capacities, arguing that we are observing a change in the ‘‘neural capacity for language or for ‘symboling.’ ’’ The archaeological signatures of such modern behavior are typically argued to be the manipulation and storage of symbolic information, represented by works of art and ornamentation, by campsite structures that reveal group interaction, by ritualized burials, and by stylistic expression in artifacts (e.g., Henshilwood et al. 2001a, 2002; Wadley 2001). It is this final feature that has been invoked in explaining patterns of backed artifacts in Africa. Some researchers have argued that the nature of backing, perhaps being preparation for insertion in a composite tool, and the precise and repeated form of backed artifacts, makes them indicators of specifically designed and style-laden behavior indicative of
___________________________________________________________________________________
62
_______________________________________________________________________________
Ar i d P a r a d i s e s o r D a n g e r o u s L a n d s c a p e s
cultural modernity. For instance, Barham (2001, 2002) concludes that the existence of large numbers of backed artifacts in the Middle Pleistocene Lupemban Industry indicates a new suite of behaviors were present approximately 300,000 bp. Other archaeologists demand more stringent evidence and therefore place the transition to cultural modernity at more recent dates. For example, a number of archaeologists have hypothesized that the standardized and rather modern looking backed specimens common in the Howieson’s Poort Industry are a better signal that modern-like tool concepts and social networks are present, and therefore argue that the Howieson’s Poort represents the transition point to modern behavioral systems at approximately 70,000 bp (Wurz 1999, 2002). Even more conservative arguments are presented by archaeologists such as Wadley (2001), who require archaeological evidence for multiple forms of symbolic behavior as an indicator that the ‘‘package’’ of symbolic behaviors was present (but see Henshilwood et al. 2001b for claims of an early ‘‘package’’). Wadley (2001) rejects the Howieson’s Poort Industry because she concludes that it does not display the rapid turnover of styles she anticipates in modern behavioral systems, and instead argues that the LSA assemblages of sites such as Rose Cottage Cave and Sibudu Cave reveal the origins of cultural modernity in southern Africa about 40,000 years ago. Thackeray (1992) has likewise argued that the Howieson’s Poort backed artifacts (or any MSA examples) do not constitute evidence of modern behavior as they lack the standardization seen in the later LSA assemblages and what standardization as occurs is due to the functional requirements of hafting. Wurz (1999) has countered this with a metrical analysis that demonstrates that the backed artifacts of the Howieson’s Poort are as standardized as that of the Wilton and with the addition that the focus on exotic raw materials during the Howieson’s Poort is superfluous to hafting requirements. There are several dilemmas associated with these vigorous debates about the origins of modern behavior in sub-Saharan Africa and the explanation of backed artifact proliferation in terms of the transition to cultural modernity. One potential weakness of such an explanation is that it is not applicable to later episodes of backed artifact proliferation in Africa, since all later industries are presumed to have been created by behaviorally modern humans. Indeed, the bold Foley and Lahr (1997, 2003) argument that modern behavior is associated with Mode 3 technologies would imply that such an explanation is not even applicable to the first episode of backed artifact proliferation. Reference to the onset of behavioral modernity as an explanation must also be invalid in the Australian situation where modern humans colonized the continent, and where backed artifact proliferation occurs in the Holocene. Consequently, only one of the multiple episodes of backed artifact proliferation can be understood with this explanation, and it follows that other causes must exist for the emphasis of such a technological strategy by a hunter-gatherer group. Torrence (2002) is correct in arguing that there may be multiple reasons for hunter-gatherer groups to emphasize backed artifacts, and hence the cause of an industry such as the Howieson’s Poort may be different to the cause of later backed artifact
___________________________________________________________________________________
63
_______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r H i s c o c k a n d S ue O’ C o n n o r
proliferations. While this argument has merit it is nevertheless puzzling to see archaeologists invoke a major evolutionary shift to explain an archaeological phenomenon on one occasion, being obliged to seek more mundane explanations for the same technological shift on other seemingly similar occasions. Avoiding explanations of cognitive capacity by substituting models of demographic intensification (Shennan 2001) offers the theoretical advantage that population densities may increase and decrease through time and therefore provide a mechanism for multiple proliferation events. Furthermore, it is curious that archaeologists have on the one hand advocated that backed artifacts acted as symbols in prehistoric African societies, but have not identified the first proliferation of those implements as the point at which symbolic behavior was initiated (e.g., Wadley 2001; Wurz 1999, 2002). Unless archaeologists adopt the argument that the earliest episode of backed artifact proliferation marks the onset of modern behaviors, at more than 300,000 years ago, we are left with a scenario in which backing was a strategy employed prior to modern behavior, and therefore modern behavior/cognition is not a necessary explanatory condition of implement backing. On the other hand, if the Middle Pleistocene examples of backed artifact proliferation are taken as an indication of cultural modernity in the absence of other evidence of symbolic activity, one of two conclusions must be reached. The first is that backed artifact production might be taking place in contexts without symbolic storage, in which case the conclusion that modern symbolic behavior is evidenced is unnecessary. The second possible conclusion is that backed artifacts alone demonstrate modern human symboling. If this inference is advocated the question that is raised is how to explain the subsequent appearance/proliferation of art and other symbolic paraphernalia if those phenomena do not emerge with the onset of cultural modernity but appear substantially later. This discussion reveals the fundamental limitation of this explanation citing cognitive capacity. The shortcoming demonstrated above is that in invoking the ‘‘capacity’’ for symboling such an explanation has obvious constraints. Such an explanation can be employed on only one instance in any region without hypothesizing the displacement of behaviorally modern populations by non-symboling ones. Furthermore, since the development of a capacity does not require it to be used, this model does not adequately explain why in some situations the capacity was employed to make large numbers of backed artifacts while on other occasions the ability to construct symbols was directed towards other ends. If backed artifacts were symbols, the capacity for symbolic expression is a precondition of their production, but not a sufficient explanation for high rates of backed artifact production at any particular time. In other words, this model can be used as an explanation of the appearance/existence of these implements but not of their numerical proliferation or decline through time and space. As we have discussed, this model, by itself, cannot explain either the proliferation of backed artifacts in Australia or the pattern of multiple proliferations that occurred in Africa. For that reason archaeologists should seek additional or alternative explanatory models for these phenomena.
___________________________________________________________________________________
64
_______________________________________________________________________________
Ar i d P a r a d i s e s o r D a n g e r o u s L a n d s c a p e s
Ethnicity and Social Interaction as an Explanation A longstanding explanatory model that has been applied to variation in lithic assemblages is that implement forms denote not merely the capacity for symbolic behavior but the use of those symbols as markers of group identity. This kind of model explains the proliferation of specific implement types in terms of the immigration of a group into a region, the spread of a cultural system, or change in the intensity and nature of cultural contact between groups. In Australia it has been models of diffusion of socioeconomic organization, with accompanying symbols, that have commonly been discussed. Specifically, the Holocene proliferation of regular implement forms, including backed artifacts and unifacial and bifacial points, has been linked by many authors to either migrations of people or diffusion of symbolic systems through cultural contacts (e.g., Evans and Jones 1997; McConvell 1996). A dominant form of this argument has conventionally been based on a supposed coincidence in the timing of the arrival of the dingo and the appearance of these types of implement (Bowdler and O’Connor 1991; Flood 1983: 195). For example, Bowdler (1981) has argued at length that backed artifacts were a symbol of new religious and economic systems introduced with the dingo during the mid-Holocene. However, although this idea has been popular with Australian archaeologists, the notion that a mid-Holocene culture contact event explains the proliferation of backed artifacts in Australia is doubtful. For instance, the demonstration that the introduction of the dingo, economic change, and the first production of backed artifacts are not contemporary, and that backed artifacts were occasionally produced for millennia prior to a widespread proliferation, has removed the empirical basis for a hypothesis of midHolocene contact as a viable explanation (Hiscock 1994, 2001; Hiscock and Attenbrow 1998). A further cause for skepticism about such diffusionist explanations arises because the mere existence of contact with different cultural systems and new forms of material culture does not explain their adoption across Australia; theories of external introduction still require an explanation for the acceptance of traits by recipient groups. One mechanism hypothesized to trigger the acceptance and/or spread of symbols in Holocene Australia is the reorganization of social units. For instance, David and Lourandos (1998) have argued that the emergence of compartmentalized cultural landscapes created a context in which symbols that assisted groups in the negotiation of resource rights would have been advantageous, and backed artifacts were one of the objects employed in more intensive social interactions. Ethnic or social symbolic explanations for the intensive use of backed artifacts have been much more extensively employed in African archaeology. In considering the criteria necessary to identify discrete social entities in the archaeological record, Clark (1988) contended that differences between social entities will be expressed in the types of material culture which groups carry and distribute. He advocated the view that distinctive styles embodying social identity would be applied to the items common to different groups. This view, long held in European archaeology, has also been explored in archaeological investigations of backed artifacts in Africa over
___________________________________________________________________________________
65
_______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r H i s c o c k a n d S ue O’ C o n n o r
the last 30 years. For example, Singer and Wymer (1982: 107–9, 209–10) argued that the Howieson’s Poort, with its backed artifacts of non-local raw materials, was so unlike the preceding (MSA 2) and succeeding phases (MSA 3) of the MSA that it most likely represented the tool kit of an incoming or invading group whom they call the ‘‘Howieson’s Poort people’’ who, having occupied Klasies River Mouth for a relatively short period, moved on, taking their tool kit with them. The Indigenous population then reverted to producing the types of tools they had made during MSA 2. Singer and Wymer (1982: 107) explicitly rejected the notion that the technological emphasis on backing could have resulted as a response by the ‘‘Indigenous population . . . to a change of circumstances.’’ Less direct social explanations, such as those interpreting stylistic differences in terms of social communication and signaling, have become especially popular in the African literature since the Bleek and Lloyd historical accounts of !Kung were ‘‘rediscovered’’ in the 1980s. An example is Mazel’s (1989) argument that changes in the distribution of backed artifacts and steep scrapers across the Thukula Basin during the LSA from 9,000–2,000 bp reflect alterations in social regions and in the extent and complexity of regional alliance/exchange networks. Backed implements dominate the assemblages region wide in the early phase, beginning about 9,000 years ago and continuing until sometime after 5,000 bp, when three distinct regions emerge: those whose diagnostic component is dominated by backed segments, those dominated by backed points and blades but which also have segments, and those dominated by backed points and blades but which lack segments. The variations in assemblages through time and space were interpreted by Mazel as demarcating social regions. He proposes that through time a single social network disintegrated and separated into three distinct social regions and alliance networks. Mazel’s model invokes Clark’s proposition that backed artifacts function to mark material cultural boundaries and thus express and maintain difference between social entities. What is clear in Mazel’s argument is the detailed and extensive use of ethnographic images from historic Africa. Broadly similar models have also been advanced for the earlier proliferation events in southern Africa. For example, Deacon and Wurz (Deacon 1992; Deacon and Wurz 1996; Wurz 1999) have proposed that the backed artifacts of the MSA Howieson’s Poort assemblages were manufactured to be given as gifts in formal exchange systems and themselves functioned as symbols of mutual reliance and reciprocity in much the same way as the ethnographic projectiles produced and used by the San, discussed by Wiessner (1982, 1983). While such arguments are plausible in the historic and recent period, the basis for positing these social interactions in the distant past is insubstantial. Barham (1993) has argued that these models of social symbolic behavior are unjustified. In particular he argues that as expedient tools there is minimal capacity for these objects to store and convey social information. However, since the actual usage of these objects is unclear the conclusion that small expedient artifacts could not have performed social purposes should not be considered to have been established. A critique of such symbolic models can nevertheless be offered. To begin with, if they are to be comprehensive these models must also be capable of explaining the
___________________________________________________________________________________
66
_______________________________________________________________________________
Ar i d P a r a d i s e s o r D a n g e r o u s L a n d s c a p e s
decline in backed artifact production that has occurred in both continents. Hypotheses explaining backed artifact proliferation in terms of social interaction rarely suggest that subsequent declines indicate substantial decline in social connectivity, perhaps revealing a unilinear and progressivist image of cultural evolution. Symmetry in the logic of these models can be expected here; if the decline of backed artifact production is not indicative of reduced intensity of social networking, then the necessity of explaining backed artifact proliferation in these terms is diminished. The difficulty can be outlined as follows. If declining rate of backed artifact production reveals decreased social interaction or identity symboling, then the relevance of recent ethnographic accounts becomes a central question. On the other hand, if the nature and level of social information is undiminished when backed artifact production rates drop, the social value of high backed artifact production is called into question. These questions need to be explored if models of style are to be adopted. Added to these questions is an elementary issue of establishing the veracity of statements about ancient social interaction. The point about these models of social uses of symbolism in stone implements is the difficulty of providing independent tests of the hypothesized mechanisms for assemblage differences. In the absence of independent measures of group identity or the nature and intensity of social uses of symbolism these discussions have often relied only on untested assertions of the symbolic nature of archaeological implements.
Economics as an Explanation An alternative form of explanation is reference to the economic function of backed artifacts in foraging life. There are a large number of studies exploring this issue generally, and specific applications to both Australia and Africa. These explanations typically revolve around the technological responses by foragers to changing provisioning costs and risks. Costs are incurred because the rapid consumption of stone material creates a regular need to replenish the supply available to the individual or group, creating a provisioning cost. These provisioning needs may not only influence the structure of landscape use; they may also have involved a considerable expense in effort or required rescheduling of activities to enable resupply of materials (see Bamforth 1986; Hiscock 1986, in press; Jeske 1992; Torrence 1983, 1989a). In addition, the economic context of a foraging group involved the costs and returns for those tasks in which stone tools were involved. In response foragers employed technological strategies that lowered provisioning costs or facilitated greater returns. A distinctive form of economic explanation that has been employed to explain backed artifacts is the cultural response to ‘‘risk.’’ Archaeologists often think of risk as the probability and consequence of being unsuccessful in procuring resources (see Hiscock in press). For ancient foraging groups the magnitude of risk reflected the frequency or likelihood with which a group failed to procure adequate resources, representing the failure probability, and the consequences for the group of not obtaining adequate resources in an efficient manner, representing
___________________________________________________________________________________
67
_______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r H i s c o c k a n d S ue O’ C o n n o r
the failure cost (see Bamforth and Bleed 1997). The proposition advanced in risk models is that at least in some contexts ancient foraging groups may have adopted economic, social, and technological strategies that reduced the failure probabilities and costs (see Bamforth and Bleed 1997; Bousman 1993; Hiscock 1994; Kelly 1988; Nelson 1996; Torrence 1989b). Such models have been employed in both Africa and Australia for the emphasis of backed artifacts in tool kits, but with a different explanatory emphasis in each continent. In Australia the focus has been on models of technological responses to environmentally induced foraging risk. For example, Hiscock (1994) hypothesized that the movement of foragers into new landscapes created contexts in which resource availability was relatively unpredictable and foragers responded with an emphasis on reliable and maintainable multifunctional technologies, reflected archaeologically in the high production rates of standardized stone implements. His argument was that although backed artifacts could have had emblematic qualities their extensive use was probably caused by their capability as a technological device that reduced the level or consequence of economic risks. Subsequently, Hiscock (2002) argued that the onset of the ENSO controlled climate was one factor acting to increase foraging risk in the mid-Holocene, and that the increased production and use of backed artifacts, perhaps as part of a composite tool kit, was one response to the new context. More recently he has hypothesized that there were probably multiple environmental and social triggers to increased foraging risk, with the nature and timing of factors varying regionally and chronologically (Hiscock in press). These risk focused models typically cite the onset of heightened foraging risk as a key cause for the proliferation of backed artifacts and the reduction of foraging risk as allowing shifts to other technological strategies. In Australia less developed theories have proposed that social decisions may have been an integral part of both the construction of risk and the selection of responses to risk (see David and Lourandos 1998), although Hiscock (2002) has pointed out that environmental causes are embedded even in those theories. Dealing with Aboriginal occupation of the deserts of Western Australia, Gould (1977) inferred a multifaceted risk reduction system operating throughout the Holocene. He claimed technological strategies enhanced energy extraction from the landscape by permitting both high mobility and effective tool use, and that risk was additionally reduced through the maintenance of social networks displayed archaeologically in the circulation of raw material from distance sources. Gould did not explore possible connections between these risk minimizing strategies and the proliferation of backed artifacts in the Australian deserts, but explanatory models attempting to do that have been offered outside Australia. In the archaeological discussions of prehistoric sub-Saharan Africa, foraging risk has also been considered from a variety of perspectives ranging from ecological cost-benefit models to those that emphasize social relations. For instance, Ambrose and Lorenz (1990: 25) view the assemblage changes from MSA 2 to Howieson’s Poort, and from Howieson’s Poort to MSA 3, as ‘‘a technological response to shifting patterns of raw material resource procurement’’ resulting from changes in territorial organization; most probably expansion and contraction of foraging
___________________________________________________________________________________
68
_______________________________________________________________________________
Ar i d P a r a d i s e s o r D a n g e r o u s L a n d s c a p e s
range. They argue that a change from warmer moister conditions, such as those that prevailed during MSA 1 and MSA 2, towards a cooler climate at the end of the last interglacial, would have resulted in more open environments or a mosaic of open and closed habitats which would have reduced the exploitable game biomass and thus ‘‘the spatio-temporal abundance and predictability of faunal and floral resources’’ (Ambrose and Lorenz 1990: 25). In response to the reduced game biomass and increased risk, people enlarged their territorial range, thereby gaining access to better quality raw materials, thus allowing them to make more finely retouched tools. Ambrose and Lorenz (1990) dismiss the possibility that exotic fine-grained raw materials were acquired in order to produce backed artifacts because they argue that the archaeological record indicates that abrupt changes in lithic technology are imposed on more gradual changes in raw material, whereas the reverse would be expected if fine-grained raw materials were acquired in order to produce hafted backed blades. There are several problems with the Ambrose and Lorenz model. Firstly, the Howieson’s Poort faunal assemblages provide only partial support for the model in that, while they contain small numbers of large grazing open grassland species, they are dominated by small to medium-sized non-gregarious species that prefer closed habitats. Secondly, the model fails to explain the relationship between climate/environment change, territorial expansion, and the proliferation of backed artifacts at this time, except to the extent that because better raw material was available people used it to make more backed artifacts. Where recent evidence has been presented backing technologies appear to be associated with a variety of environments and not explicable in terms of the existence of a single niche or environmental change (e.g., Cornelissen 2002). Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, as Ambrose and Lorenz (1990) themselves acknowledge, the model fails to account for the demise of backed artifacts in the MSA 3. During this time conditions became colder and drier, and more open vegetation communities prevail. The model predicts that this ecological scenario should result in higher territorial and logistic mobility and therefore an increase in exotic raw material and backed artifacts. While the MSA 3 faunal assemblages do indicate an increasing reliance on gregarious nomadic ungulates, the lithic assemblage of the MSA 3 runs entirely counter to the prediction, with no or few backed artifacts and a significant decline in the use of exotic material. Rather than question the relevance of the modern huntergatherer analogs they use to derive the model to the MSA, Ambrose and Lorenz interpret the non-compliance of MSA hunters with the predictive model (derived from modern hunter-gatherer behaviors) as proof of their lesser cognitive capabilities compared with their LSA counterparts or later modern humans. Recent and influential models propose that the solution to unpredictable and unproductive environments was not an increase in foraging range or an economically beneficial technology, but a socially advantageous one. For instance, Deacon and Wurz (1996), while concurring with Clark (1992) that the backed blades of the Howieson’s Poort functioned as projectiles, have specifically argued against the use of the backed artifacts in composite tools to increase hunting efficiency. They follow Klein (2000) in proposing that any differences in prey species hunted during
___________________________________________________________________________________
69
_______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r H i s c o c k a n d S ue O’ C o n n o r
this phase of the MSA can be ‘‘linked to ecological factors rather than the effectiveness of projectile equipment’’ (Deacon and Wurz 1996). Instead, they (Deacon 1992, 1995; Deacon and Wurz 1996) advance the proposition that backed artifacts in the Howieson’s Poort were symbolic items that were central to delayed reciprocal exchange systems that evolved into the ethnographically documented San hxaro gift system. The production of backed artifacts on non-local stone materials is seen as having no technological or practical advantage given backed artifacts were also made on local coarser materials; but as ‘‘value adding’’ to their use as exchange items. By exchanging ornaments the foragers are inferred to have promoted social solidarity that maintained these social networks during periods of heightened environmental risk, and that the continuation of these social interactions facilitated resource sharing, thereby reducing the consequences of resource failure for foraging groups. Wurz (1999), in a slightly different slant on this position, has demonstrated (contra Thackeray 1992: 423) that the MSA backed artifacts are as standardized as those of the LSA and argued that the degree of standardization is independent of functional requirements or the form/size of the raw material, but is due rather to social stylistic conventions intrinsically linked to symboling. Deacon (1992, 1995; Deacon and Wurz 1996), Ambrose (2002), and Wurz (1999) have hypothesized that such reciprocity-based risk minimizing systems, literally symbolized by backed artifact manufacture, were one of the key innovations in the evolution of modern human behavior and a contributing factor in the success of our species at the expense of other hominids. These ethnographically derived social models fail to explain variability seen in the archaeological record. Why, for example, during the most arid phase of the LSA age, the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM), when social reciprocity and reliance networks should have been most highly developed, is the Robberg Industry almost totally devoid of backed artifacts or indeed any standardized retouched tool form? Although citing foraging risk as the context in which these innovations emerge, such models are less about economic responses to environmental circumstances than they are economically situated variants of models emphasizing ethnicity and social interaction. For instance, by interpreting backed artifacts as functioning symbolically and identifying symbol use as a distinctively modern behavioral trait, archaeologists like Ambrose (2002: 21–2) have explicitly viewed backed artifacts as an archaeological marker of the movement and dispersal of behaviorally modern populations. Other researchers have seen long-term cultural continuity in southern Africa in the inferred emergence of the hxaro system from MSA occupation. These models raise the same questions (discussed above) of other symbolic interpretations of these stone artifacts: Why are images of behavioral modernity applied to one backed artifact proliferation event but not to the earliest one, and how do models of continuous symbolic activity explain declines in the production of, or the disappearance of, those symbols? By linking assemblage variation to changing economic contexts a mechanism for explaining increases and decreases in backed artifact production rates is created, but if backed artifacts are primarily symbols the interpretation of those changes in social terms requires further exploration.
___________________________________________________________________________________
70
_______________________________________________________________________________
Ar i d P a r a d i s e s o r D a n g e r o u s L a n d s c a p e s
Research Programs as Reflections of Desert Images We have described and evaluated a number of the models offered to explain the chronological and spatial changes in backed artifacts in Australia and Africa. Although we could have chosen a number of other traits we have focused on those which illustrate that the emphasis given to archaeological explanations has varied between these continents. Since these two regions are both dominated by arid and semi-arid lands, characterized by rich ethnographic records, and studied by schools of archaeological thought with strong historical links to the British paleoeconomy approach, we argue that these contrasts are worth considering further. Specifically, we suggest that these differences exemplify distinctive research programs (pace Lakatos 1978) that have built on divergent images of archaeological material and different images of deserts and human life in them, largely derived from historical and modern ethnographic sources. Perhaps most influential and formative were the images of African desert dwellers arising from the Man the Hunter conference held in 1966. Its ethnographic studies of the Kalahari !Kung San groups, emphasizing the affluence of their subsistence base and the abundance of their leisure time (at least for the males), fostered a view of deserts as relatively benign landscapes for hunter-gatherers. In particular, the abundance of the wondrous, tasty, and highly nutritious plant food staple, the mongongo nut (Schinziophyton rautanenii) (Lee 1968, 1979), led to characterizations of the !Kung as enjoying ‘‘a kind of material plenty’’ (Marshall 1961: 243, as cited in Sahlins 1974: 9), a theme taken up and developed by Sahlins (1974: 1–39) in his essay on hunter-gatherer material existence entitled ‘‘The original affluent society.’’ While such generalized forager models stressed notions of egalitarianism, neoMarxist anthropologists emphasized the way in which the social structures of hunter-gatherer groups were reinforced by delayed return systems such as gift exchange which acted to ensure reciprocal access to territory, acted as buffers against subsistence failure and thereby provided ‘‘each individual !Kung with reciprocal and guaranteed access to the material conditions of production’’ (Keenan 1981: 18). These images of African deserts as arid paradises have been powerful influences on archaeological thinking. As mentioned above, recent archaeological models for the context of backed artifact production in sub-Saharan Africa have been inspired by historic ethnographic images (e.g., Bleek and Lloyd n.d.), but have emphasized the structural rather than materialist position of social relations. Although they have stimulated archaeological analogies it is difficult to see why these images of historical Kalahari Desert life have any relevance to the context under which backing took place in the MSA or for that matter most of the LSA in sub-Saharan Africa. Cultural continuity from MSA or LSA to historic cultures has not been demonstrated, and evidence independent of ethnographic analogy for the moderation of environmental risk by reciprocal social relationships is a moot point. Even the claim that backed artifact production is a social response to lower and less predictable environmental productivity is not clearly established in the southern African case. Indeed, simple
___________________________________________________________________________________
71
_______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r H i s c o c k a n d S ue O’ C o n n o r
functional associations between backed artifacts and a single environment or environmental productivity seem unfounded. For example, there is no strong association between production of backed artifacts and aridity. The archaeological assemblages indicate that when backed artifacts made of exotic material were first produced in large numbers, hunter-gatherers were living in close proximity to the coast in relatively warm humid conditions, and exploiting the resources of predominantly closed vegetation communities. There is little evidence to suggest these environments were extremely unproductive. As noted earlier, backed artifacts are also absent from the Robberg lithic assemblages made during the heightened arid conditions of the LGM by LSA hunter-gatherers. This suggests that citing historic environmental conditions and cultural responses will not be an effective framework for exploring MSA patterns. Similar complexities exist in explaining patterns of Australian backed artifact production in simple environmental terms. Ethnoarchaeological studies of arid zone foragers in Australia, also carried out in the 1960s to 1980s, created an image diametrically opposite to the one developed in Africa. Australian researchers emphasized that desert life could be harsh and precarious and that social behavior and subsistence decisions were dominated by a variety of stress factors, primary among them being drought. Studies of Australian foragers typically adopted this image and described desert lifeways as marginal and conservative, stressing economic necessity rather than social advantages as the stimulus for reciprocity. These images of Australian deserts as dangerous landscapes have been powerful influences generally on archaeological models of Sahul. The dominant proponent of the dangerous desert explanation for prehistoric Australia, Richard Gould, argued these strategies were reflected in the long-term archaeological sequences from the Western Desert demonstrating conservative unchanging technologies, and emphasizing risk-minimizing economic strategies throughout the Holocene. Following this lead some subsistence models for Pleistocene hunter-gatherers assumed that desert dwelling was a late adaptation only possible during the Holocene and that earlier foragers would have avoided arid inland areas (Bowdler 1977), or that the arid center of Australia may have initially sustained human life but must have been abandoned with onset of aridity during the late Pleistocene (e.g., Horton 1981). Models of Holocene arid zone settlement and technology as consequences of harsh and unpredictable environments also reflect the image of Australian deserts as dangerous landscapes (Hughes and Hiscock in press; Ross et al. 1992; Veth 1995). Some recent research into the archaeology of Australian deserts has argued against inferences of conservative technologies and uniform economic systems (Hiscock and Veth 1991; Hiscock 1994; O’Connor and Veth 1996; O’Connor et al. 1998; Veth 1993), and has instead argued that both archaeological and historical evidence suggests that diverse and flexible economic and social systems were employed. These revisionist models of Australian desert culture and cultural evolution were based more on archaeological patterns than ethnohistoric images, but most explanations for assemblage change in Australia remain based on ethnohistorical images whose relevance to the past is questionable.
___________________________________________________________________________________
72
_______________________________________________________________________________
Ar i d P a r a d i s e s o r D a n g e r o u s L a n d s c a p e s
Having characterized the desert images embedded in archaeological models from each continent in this way it is necessary to pose the obvious question: Are the dissimilar pictures of African deserts of abundance and Australian deserts of danger reflections of genuine environmental differences? Without doubt the environments found on the two continents are different. As Gould (1991: 16) points out, differences in physiography and rainfall predictability in the two continents underlie divergent images of their deserts. For example, the Kalahari has some coordinated drainage networks and catchments, whereas the Western Desert of Australia has none and all water supplies depend entirely upon rain capture in impermanent surface and sub-surface catchments. More importantly, rainfall in the Western Desert is not only lower than that for the Kalahari, but also extremely unpredictable. Even the central deserts of Australia, which have limited catchments, display annual rainfall patterns that are less predictable than the Kalahari. There may therefore be an empirical basis for the images of deserts generated on each continent, although the complexity of socially mediated economic strategies makes any simple equation of environmental characteristics and social or economic hazard difficult. However, if such an argument is sustained, and the Australian deserts are and have been inherently more difficult for foragers, archaeologists will be compelled to return to the question with which we began this chapter, namely, why does the archaeological record in each continent display parallel patterns of backed artifact proliferation and decline? Comprehending in more detail the environmental and social contexts of technological change in each continent, and testing models of the prehistoric past against the archaeological rather than modern cultural evidence, will be one path forward in exploring not only the differences in ancient desert life between Australia and southern Africa but also the similarities. This quest should form one agenda of the research programs on each continent, and as we have demonstrated in this chapter archaeological model building will benefit by moving away from local scales of explanation to a broad intercontinental comparative approach.
References Ambrose, S. H. 2001: Paleolithic technology and human evolution. Science, 291, 1748–53. Ambrose, S. H. 2002: Small things remembered: Origins of early microlithic industries in sub-Saharan Africa. In S. Kuhn and R. Elston (eds), Thinking Small: Global Perspectives on Microlithization, Washington, DC: Anthropological Papers of the American Anthropological Association (AP3A) no. 12, American Anthropological Association, 9–29. Ambrose, S. H. and Lorenz, K. G. 1990: Social and ecological models for the Middle Stone Age in southern Africa. In P. Mellers (ed.), The Emergence of Modern Humans, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 3–33. Bamforth, D. B. 1986: Technological efficiency and tool curation. American Antiquity, 51 (1), 38–50. Bamforth, D. B. and Bleed, P. 1997: Technology, flaked stone technology, and risk. In C. M. Barton and G. A. Clark (eds), Rediscovering Darwin: Evolutionary Theory in Archaeology, Washington, DC: Archaeological Papers of the American Anthropological Association no. 7, American Anthropological Association, 109–40.
___________________________________________________________________________________
73
_______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r H i s c o c k a n d S ue O’ C o n n o r Barham, L. S. 1993: Comment: Reply to Wadley and Mazel. South African Archaeology Bulletin, 48, 51. Barham, L. S. 2001: Central Africa and the emergence of regional identity in the Middle Pleistocene. In L. S. Barham and K. Robson-Brown (eds), Human Roots: Africa and Asia in the Middle Pleistocene, Bristol: Western Academic and Specialist Press, 65–80. Barham, L. 2002: Backed tools in Middle Pleistocene central Africa and their evolutionary significance. Journal of Human Evolution, 43, 585–603. Bleek, W. H. I. and Lloyd, L. n.d.: Unpublished notes. Capetown: Jagger Library, University of Cape Town and South African Public Library. Bousman, C. 1993: Hunter-gatherer adaptations, economic risk, and tool design. Lithic Technology, 18, 59–86. Bowdler, S. 1977: The coastal colonization of Australia. In J. Allen, J. Golson, and R. Jones (eds), Sunda and Sahul: Prehistoric Studies in Southeast Asia, Melanesia and Australia, London: Academic Press, 205–46. Bowdler, S. 1981: Hunters in the highlands: Aboriginal adaptations in the eastern Australian uplands. Archaeology in Oceania, 16, 99–111. Bowdler, S. and O’Connor, S. 1991: The dating of the Australian Small Tool Tradition, with new evidence from the Kimberley, W.A. Australian Aboriginal Studies, 1, 53–62. Clark, J. D. 1988: The Middle Stone Age in East Africa and the beginnings of regional identity. Journal of World Prehistory, 2, 235–305. Clark, J. D. 1992: African and Asian perspectives on the origins of modern humans. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, B337, 201–15. Cornelissen, E. 2002: Human responses to changing environments in central Africa between 40,000 and 12,000 bp. Journal of World Prehistory, 16, 197–235. David, B. and Lourandos, H. 1998: Rock art and socio-demography in northeast Australian prehistory. World Archaeology, 30, 193–219. Deacon, H. J. 1992: Southern Africa and modern human origins. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, B337, 177–83. Deacon, H. J. 1995: An unsolved mystery at the Howieson’s Poort name site. South African Archaeology Bulletin, 50, 110–20. Deacon, H. J. and Wurz, S. 1996: Klasies River main site, cave 2: A Howieson’s Poort occurrence. In G. Pwiti and R. Soper (eds), Aspects of African Archaeology: Papers from the 10th Congress of the PanAfrican Association for Prehistory and Related Studies, Harare: University of Zimbabwe Publications, 213–18. Evans, N. and Jones, R. 1997: The cradle of the Pama-Nyungans: Archaeologic and linguistic speculations. In N. Evans and P. McConvell (eds), Linguistics and Archaeology: Aboriginal Australia in Global Perspective, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 385–417. Flood, J. 1983: Archaeology of the Dreamtime. Sydney: Collins. Foley, R. and Lahr, M. 1997: Mode 3 technologies and the evolution of modern humans. Cambridge Archaeological Journal, 7, 3–36. Foley, R. and Lahr, M. 2003: On stony ground: Lithic technology, human evolution, and the emergence of culture. Evolutionary Anthropology, 12, 109–22. Gould, R. A. 1977: Puntutjarpa Rockshelter and the Australian Desert Culture. New York: Anthropological Papers of the American Museum of Natural History no. 54, American Museum of Natural History. Gould, R. A. 1991: Arid land foraging as seen from Australia: Adaptive models and behavioral realities. Oceania, 62, 12–33.
___________________________________________________________________________________
74
_______________________________________________________________________________
Ar i d P a r a d i s e s o r D a n g e r o u s L a n d s c a p e s Henshilwood, C. S., d’Errico, F., Marean, C. W., Milo, R. G., and Yates, R. 2001a: An early bone tool industry from the Middle Stone Age at Blombos Cave, South Africa: Implications for the origins of modern human behavior, symbolism, and language. Journal of Human Evolution, 41, 631–78. Henshilwood, C. S., Sealy, J. C., Yates, R., Cruz-Uribe, K., Goldberg, P., Grine, F. E., Klein, R. G., Poggenpoel, C., van Niekerk, K., and Watts, I. 2001b: Blombos Cave, Southern Cape, South Africa: Preliminary report on the 1992–1999 excavations of the Middle Stone Age levels. Journal of Archaeological Science, 28, 421–48. Henshilwood, C. S., d’Errico, F., Yates, R., Jacobs, Z., Tribolo, C., Duller, G. A., Mercier, N., Sealy, J. C., Valladas, H., Watts, I., and Wintle, A. G. 2002: Emergence of modern human behavior: Middle Stone Age engravings from South Africa. Science, 295, 1278–80. Hiscock, P. 1986: Technological change in the Hunter River Valley and the interpretation of late Holocene change in Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 21 (1), 40–50. Hiscock, P. 1994: Technological responses to risk in Holocene Australia. Journal of World Prehistory, 8 (3), 267–92. Hiscock, P. 2001: Sizing up prehistory: Sample size and composition of artifact assemblages. Australian Aboriginal Studies, 1, 48–62. Hiscock, P. 2002: Pattern and context in the Holocene proliferation of backed artifacts in Australia. In S. Kuhn and R. Elston (eds), Thinking Small: Global Perspectives on Microlithization, Washington, DC: Anthropological Papers of the American Anthropological Association (AP3A) no. 12, American Anthropological Association, 163–77. Hiscock, P. in press: Blunt and to the point: Changing technological strategies in Holocene Australia. In I. Lilley (ed.), Archaeology in Oceania: Australia and the Pacific Islands. Oxford: Blackwell. Hiscock, P. and Attenbrow, V. 1998: Early Holocene backed artifacts from Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 33, 49–63. Hiscock, P. and Veth, P. 1991: Change in the Australian Desert Culture: A reanalysis of tulas from Puntutjarpa. World Archaeology, 22 (3), 332–45. Horton, D. R. 1981: Water and woodland: The peopling of Australia. Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies Newsletter, 16, 21–7. Hughes, P. and Hiscock, P. in press: The archaeology of the Lake Eyre South Area. In Aboriginal Occupation of the Lake Eyre South Region: Ethnography and Archaeology, Adelaide: Lake Eyre Monograph Series vol. 6, Royal Geographical Society of South Australia. Jeske, R. 1992: Energetic efficiency and lithic technology. American Antiquity, 57, 467–81. Keenan, J. 1981: The concept of the mode of production in hunter-gatherer societies. In J. S. Kahn and J. R. Llobera (eds), The Anthropology of Pre-Capitalist Societies, London: Macmillan Press, 2–21. Kelly, R. L. 1988: The three sides of a biface. American Antiquity, 53, 717–34. Klein, R. G. 2000: Archeology and the evolution of human behavior. Evolutionary Anthropology, 17, 18–36. Lakatos, I. 1978: Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes. In I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave (eds), Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 91–196. Lee, R. B 1968: What hunters do for a living, or, how to make out on scarce resources. In R. B. Lee and I. De Vore (eds), Man the Hunter, New York: Aldine, 30–48. Lee, R. B. 1979: The !Kung San. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
___________________________________________________________________________________
75
_______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r H i s c o c k a n d S ue O’ C o n n o r McBrearty, S. and Brooks, A. S. 2000: The revolution that wasn’t: A new interpretation of the origin of modern human behavior. Journal of Human Evolution, 39, 453–563. McConvell, P. 1996: Backtracking to Babel: The chronology of Pama-Nyungan expansion in Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 31, 125–44. Mazel, A. D. 1989: Changing social relations in the Thukela Basin, Natal 7,000–2,000 bp. Southern African Archaeological Society Goodwin Series, 6, 33–41. Mitchell, P. J. 1988: The late Pleistocene early microlithic assemblages of southern Africa. World Archaeology, 20, 27–39. Mitchell, P. J. 1995: Stories in stone: A review of south African lithic research. Lithics Studies Society Occasional Paper, 5, 71–88. Nelson, M. 1996: Technological strategies responsive to subsistence stress. In J. Tainter and B. Tainter (eds), Evolving Complexity and Environmental Risk in the Prehistoric Southwest, New York: Addison-Wesley, 107–44. O’Connor, S. and Veth, P. 1996: A preliminary report on recent archaeological research in the semi-arid/arid belt of Western Australia. Australian Aboriginal Studies, 2, 42–50. O’Connor, S., Veth, P., and Campbell, C. 1998: Serpent’s Glen rock shelter: A Pleistoceneaged archaeological sequence from the Western Desert. Australian Archaeology, 46, 12–21. Ross, A., Donnelly, T., and Wasson, R. 1992: The peopling of the arid zone: Human– environment interactions. In J. Dodson (ed.), The Naive Lands, Melbourne: Longman Cheshire, 76–114. Sahlins, M. 1974: Stone Age Economics. London: Tavistock. Shennan, S. 2001: Demography and cultural innovation: A model and its implications for the emergence of modern human culture. Cambridge Archaeological Journal, 11, 5–16. Singer, R. and Wymer, J. 1982: The Middle Stone Age at Klasies River Mouth in South Africa. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Thackeray, A. I. 1992: The Middle Stone Age south of the Limpopo. Journal of World Prehistory, 6, 385–440. Torrence, R. 1983: Time budgeting and hunter-gatherer technology. In G. Bailey (ed.), Hunter-Gatherer Economy in Prehistory, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 11–22. Torrence, R. 1989a: Tools as optimal solutions. In R. Torrence (ed.), Time, Energy, and Stone Tools, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1–6. Torrence, R. 1989b: Retooling: Towards a behavioral theory of stone tools. In R. Torrence (ed.), Time, Energy, and Stone Tools, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 57–66. Torrence, R. 2002: Thinking big about small tools. In S. Kuhn and R. Elston (eds), Thinking Small: Global Perspectives on Microlithization, Washington, DC: Anthropological Papers of the American Anthropological Association (AP3A) no. 12, American Anthropological Association, 179–89. Veth, P. M. 1993: Islands in the Interior: The Dynamics of Prehistoric Adaptations Within the Arid Zone of Australia. International Monographs in Prehistory, Archaeology Series no. 3, Ann Arbor, MI. Veth, P. 1995: Marginal returns and fringe benefits: Characterizing the prehistory of the lowland deserts of Australia. Australian Archaeology, 40, 32–8. Volman, T. P. 1984: Early prehistory in southern Africa. In R. G. Klein (ed.), Southern African Prehistory and Paleoenvironments, Rotterdam: A. A. Balkema, 169–220. Wadley, L. 2001: What is cultural modernity? A general view and a South African perspective from Rose Cottage Cave. Cambridge Archaeological Journal, 11, 201–21.
___________________________________________________________________________________
76
_______________________________________________________________________________
Ar i d P a r a d i s e s o r D a n g e r o u s L a n d s c a p e s Wiessner, P. 1982: Risk reciprocity and social influences on !Kung San economics. In E. Leacock and R. B. Lee (eds), Politics and History in Band Societies, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 61–94. Wiessner, P. 1983: Style and social information in Kalahari San projectile points. American Antiquity, 48, 253–76. Wurz, S. 1999: The Howieson’s Poort at Klasies River – an argument for symbolic behavior. South African Archaeological Bulletin, 54, 38–50. Wurz, S. 2002: Variability in the Middle Stone Age lithic sequence, 115,000–60,000 years ago at Klasies River, South Africa. Journal of Archaeological Science, 29, 1001–15.
___________________________________________________________________________________
77
_______________________________________________________________________________
----------------------------------------------------------------
Part II
--------------------------------------------------------------
Dynamics
The chapters in part two give an archaeological perspective on the long-term dynamics of desert societies. Both the regional and evidential focus of these chapters is varied, but each examines chronological change in human activities within deserts over a period of at least ten millennia. Douglas Bird and Rebecca Bliege Bird (Chapter 5) contrast the ecological strategies of North American and Australian hunter-gatherers. Pursuit of sophisticated understandings of life in arid lands is reflected in the modeling of forager response to environmental and social variability through time and space offered by both Bird and Bliege Bird (Chapter 5) and Veth (Chapter 6). Peter Veth’s chapter focuses on the key concepts of risk and marginality in desert life. Jo McDonald (Chapter 7) characterizes the nature and variability of rock art in the Australian deserts to explore the role of art and symbols in the adaptation of foragers to deserts. Luis Borrero (Chapter 8) examines Patagonian archaeology as an exemplar of hunter-gatherer adaptations to cold deserts. One of the significant outcomes of these diverse investigations is the demonstration of the mechanisms by which humans have adapted to changing desert landscapes. For instance, each of the chapters in part two presents detailed arguments about how technological, foraging, and social strategies were employed by human groups to enhance their lives in desert environments. Each chapter also describes the dynamic nature of these desert adaptations, with regionalization and reorganization of social and subsistence patterns being widely observable in the archaeological record. Importantly, these chapters also reveal the complicated and historically contingent processes of cultural evolution in these desert landscapes. In particular, there are clear examples of the fact that change is not inevitably directional. Additionally, each of the chapters provides unambiguous evidence that ancient life in deserts was in some ways distinctively different from that observed in historic occupation of arid lands, reinforcing at a global level the inference that historically observed desert societies and adaptations are relatively
___________________________________________________________________________________
79
_______________________________________________________________________________
D yn amic s
recent consequences of evolving systems. These chapters build on that understanding to demonstrate how awareness of variability in desert life, and of the intricacy of employing ethnographic images of that life in archaeological reconstructions, can enhance our study of the long-term dynamics of human life in arid lands.
___________________________________________________________________________________
80
_______________________________________________________________________________
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Evolutionary and Ecological Understandings of the Economics of Desert Societies Comparing the Great Basin USA and the Australian Deserts Douglas W. Bird and Rebecca Bliege Bird
Introduction In this chapter we provide a comparative synthesis of evolutionary and ecological analyses of economic life among Indigenous peoples in the Great Basin of North America and the central deserts of Australia. We review the development of research in human–environmental dynamics and look at current approaches in these regions that draw on theory in ‘‘evolutionary ecology.’’ In keeping with a long tradition of research in both areas, we focus primarily on introducing readers to factors that influence variability in subsistence strategies, especially those related to sex-linked differences in hunting and gathering. The goal is to provide students and non-specialists with a broad understanding of the issues regarding subsistence strategies in two desert regions of the world that are very similar in some respects and very different in others.
Background Discussion The central theme of this chapter is that the economic lives of desert huntergatherers are arranged around variability in sex-linked foraging strategies. Twenty years ago, Thomas (1983: 439), an archaeologist working the Great Basin, wrote that despite their central economic role, ‘‘Female hunter-gatherers are almost invisible archaeologically.’’ While reflecting on this, James O’Connell (2003: pers. comm.), an anthropologist who has worked for many years in Australia and the Great Basin, commented: ‘‘If women are archaeologically invisible in the Great
___________________________________________________________________________________
81
_______________________________________________________________________________
D o u g l a s W. Bir d a nd R e b e c c a B l i e g e B i r d
Basin and Desert Australia, it is only because their economic presence is so large that we can’t see the forest through the trees.’’ The arid Great Basin of North America and the Western and Central Deserts of Australia provide a comparative setting for testing hypotheses about variability in this key component of desert hunter-gatherer socioeconomy (see Figures 5.1 and 5.2). Anthropologists have often noted a number of parallels among the Indigenous inhabitants of these two regions. One of the most obvious is the presence of a traditional subsistence economy based on a broad spectrum of resources acquired mostly by women. Ethnographic and archaeological studies that illustrate this pattern include Beck (1999), Cane (1987), Elston and Zeanah (2002), Fowler and Liljeblad (1986), Fowler and Fowler (1971), Gould (1969, 1991), Gould et al. (1972), Grayson (1993), I. Kelly (1932), R. Kelly (1995), Liljeblad and Fowler (1986), Meggitt (1957, 1964), O’Connell and Hawkes (1981, 1984), O’Connell et al. (1983), Peterson (1977, 1978), Service (1962), Steward (1933, 1936, 1938,
Hydrographic boundary Language boundary 200 km
old
r
Rive
Shoshone
alt
ts
L.
Western Shoshone
Washoe
Goshute
da M
eva
Wa
ra N
sat
Sier
San Francisco
tS
t
ea
mb
Gr
Hu
Mn
Northern Paiute
ch
40 N
nts
Ute
Mono Owens Valley Paiute
Panamint
Pacific Ocean
Southern Paiute
Colorado Plateau
Kawaiisu
N 120 W
Figure 5.1 The hydrographic Great Basin in North America indicating languages and groups discussed in the text.
___________________________________________________________________________________
82
_______________________________________________________________________________
The Economics of Desert Societies
Hydrographic boundary Language boundary
Alawa
Kimberley Plateau
400 km Karajarri Walpiri Gugadja
20 S
Alyawara
R. Pilbara Plateau
Ru
Central Desert
Pintupi
ll da
L. Mackay
Mardu
Ngatatjara
Macdonell Ranges
Luritja
L. Disappointment
Pitjantjara
Western Desert
S
d an
ov
e r R.
Arrernte Fi
nk
e
R. Lake Eyre Basin
L. Carnegie
Nyanganyatjara Kokatha
Indian Ocean Perth
N 130 E
Figure 5.2 The hydrographic Western and Central Deserts in Australia indicating languages and groups discussed in the text.
1941, 1955), Stewart (1941), Tonkinson (1991), Veth and Walsh (1988), and Walsh (1987, 1990). Studies such as these have also led to a greater appreciation of how flexible socioeconomic life actually was, and in some cases still is, among foraging societies in these regions. In this chapter we explore the ecological underpinnings of such variability. At this point, a word of caution is in order. Comparing any two groups of people is problematic for at least two reasons. Firstly, by definition, we are analyzing different social contexts with different histories and environments. In comparing Great Basin and Australian subsistence strategies, we should not discount the influence of specific historical circumstances on social behavior. On the contrary, variability in these social and historical contexts is what we are trying to explain. Secondly, cross-cultural comparisons reflect our theoretical positions and the way we pose questions. The Great Basin and arid Australia invite comparison partly because they both have relatively long histories of research focused on subsistence
___________________________________________________________________________________
83
_______________________________________________________________________________
D o u g l a s W. Bir d a nd R e b e c c a B l i e g e B i r d
from a common theoretical approach. We need to keep in mind that this can be a potential source of bias. However, as long as we state our assumptions and methods clearly, working from a single theoretical approach (here, evolutionary ecology) can greatly facilitate comparative analyses.
Adaptation: A Key Concept Ecological questions about subsistence variability within groups, between groups, and through time in the Great Basin and arid Australia have often been framed by the concept of adaptation. Steward’s (1938) ethnographic synthesis of Numic speaking groups in the Great Basin was especially influential, and one of the first to explicitly apply an adaptive model to hunter-gatherer social groupings (cf. Fowler 1986). He was particularly interested in moving away from attempts to define large culture areas to focus on the actual behavior of people. How do desert hunter-gatherers maintain social organization without large scale centralized institutions? Steward argued that in the Great Basin, ethnographic patterns of low population density, flexible local organization and mobility, and a highly portable technology, were closely articulated with specific features of the natural environment, which in turn structured the nature of subsistence and kin-based social organization. Due to the scarcity of large game (the focus of men’s subsistence) in the Great Basin, people relied extensively on dependable wild seeds and roots collected by women. Groups of many families congregated when certain resources were abundant enough at particular times and places. But these larger groups were ephemeral and would soon disperse into small family units to wander across overlapping ranges exploiting a wide array of plants and small game. Thus, for Steward (1955), the ‘‘family’’ (a ‘‘patrilineal band’’) was a basic adaptive unit, organized around sex-linked differences in foraging and extensive food sharing. Steward (1938: 230–1) argued this sexual division of labor was an adaptation to efficiently provide food for the patrilineal band. In the 1950s Jennings began to develop the argument that the pattern of ‘‘adaptation’’ described by Steward had deep temporal roots and a large geographic distribution in western North America. Commonly referred to as the ‘‘Desert Culture’’ or ‘‘Desert Archaic’’ (Jennings 1957, 1964, 1974), Jennings posited that a pattern of low population density, hunting and gathering based on annual resource cycles, and mobile band social organization lasted for over ten millennia in the Great Basin. He proposed that this Desert Culture was a regional variant of a continent wide culture stage based on a foraging economy closely adapted to local resource abundance and variability (Jennings 1974). Traditional approaches to Australian prehistory and ethnography have also placed a heavy emphasis on the influence of local resource ecology (cf. Lourandos 1997). Cultural variability, especially subsistence and mobility, has often been seen as an adaptation to particular environmental circumstances. Stanner (1965) considered the ecological basis of Aboriginal territorial organization in terms of cultural adaptation to varying resource abundance. This approach was developed
___________________________________________________________________________________
84
_______________________________________________________________________________
The Economics of Desert Societies
further by Peterson (1976), who argued that large adaptive units of Aboriginal society were scaled to major continental drainage basins. The approach is analogous to Jennings’ Desert Culture concept: similarities in basic forms of subsistence and technology were adaptations to the abundance and variable distribution of key resources across large areas. With similar logic, Gould (1982, 1991) argued that many aspects of Ngatatjara Aboriginal society were adapted to ensure success in unpredictable environments. He proposed that open-ended kin-based social organization, highly flexible band composition, and group mobility were adaptations to minimize the risks associated with unpredictable droughts. Periods of drought required social organization and mobility strategies that allowed either intensified use of reliable water sources within the ‘‘home’’ area, or complete abandonment of an estate for an extended period of time. This would require an extensive network of classificatory kin and sharing. Gould hypothesized that if sharing is an adaptation to reduce temporal and spatial fluctuations in important resources, food sharing should be especially important in highly variable environments, where it can build social bonds that can be relied on in times of need. Among the Ngatatjara where resources are highly unpredictable and the environment especially austere, sharing is extensive, as opposed to other groups where resources are more reliable and sharing is restricted to a much smaller social radius.
Critiques of the Use of ‘‘Adaptation’’ from Evolutionary Ecology What do the above studies mean by ‘‘adaptation’’? The general argument is that groups of people in the Great Basin and desert Australia adapted to local environments to ensure some measure of success. But success in terms of what (nutritional needs, social bonds, survival, reproduction) and for whom (the individual, the group)? Do the studies simply conclude there is often a correlation between large scale environmental constraints and patterns of behavior; or, by adaptation do they mean specific traits that are designed to ensure survival and reproduction? If the former, why does the correlation take on the observed pattern as opposed to some alternative? If the latter, what is the adaptive unit: the ‘‘individual,’’ the ‘‘family,’’ the local ‘‘band,’’ or the ‘‘society’’? Units above the level of the individual are very difficult to define, especially in the Great Basin and Australia, where local organization is fluid, and groups are made up of individuals with varying degrees of competing interests. So by adaptation do we mean ‘‘shaped by natural selection’’ or rather that there is some observed benefit in a specific behavior? A pattern of behavior may have a beneficial outcome, but this does not necessarily mean that the behavior was designed for that purpose. These issues have been significantly clarified over the last 30 years with the development of ‘‘evolutionary ecology’’ and its application toward understanding human diversity (cf. Winterhalder and Smith 2000). Evolutionary ecology is the study of adaptive design in particular ecological contexts. In the framework of evolutionary biology, behavior is adaptive when it tracks environmental variability in ways than enhance an individual’s inclusive
___________________________________________________________________________________
85
_______________________________________________________________________________
D o u g l a s W. Bir d a nd R e b e c c a B l i e g e B i r d
fitness, most generally defined as an organism’s propensity to survive and reproduce (Williams 1966). Behavioral ecology is the subset of evolutionary ecology that studies fitness-related decisions that individuals face in particular social and physical environments (Krebs and Davies 1997). The working assumption is that an individual’s success at surviving and reproducing depends on its behavior; thus natural selection will favor variants with the capacity to solve fitness related tradeoffs efficiently. This capacity may involve various kinds of decision making, based on information obtained through individual effort or social learning; behavioral ecology does not rest on the claim that behavior is genetically determined. The optimal outcome of these tradeoffs is shaped by the opportunities and constraints of local environments (Krebs and Davies 1993: 4–22). The focus of behavioral ecology is on individuals: selection generally creates adaptive design through differential reproductive success of individuals within a population. This is simply because individuals reproduce at higher rates and with higher fidelity than groups. As a result, individual level selection tends to swamp the effects of group selection (Williams 1966). Thus (except under special circumstances) traits are adaptive only when they are designed to contribute to the inclusive fitness of individuals, regardless of their effect on the group. No trait is absolutely adaptive; individuals continually face fitness related tradeoffs whose parameters change with variable ecological circumstances. For people, those circumstances are often defined by an individual’s social and cultural situations (Cronk 1991). ‘‘Human behavioral ecology’’ (HBE) applies evolutionary ecology concepts to study human behavioral diversity through systematic hypothesis testing (Smith and Winterhalder 1992). HBE does this through the use of formal modeling tools that analyze behavior in terms of a stated goal in relation to (1) a decision (fitness related tradeoff) of interest; (2) a currency (e.g., energy) in which to analyze the various choices; and (3) the proposed constraints on an individual’s choices (the intrinsic and extrinsic factors that define the relationship between the decision and currency) (Stephens and Krebs 1986: 5–12). Formal models provide a systematic guide for investigating the interaction of a limited number of variables (justified on theoretical grounds) and their predicted outcome relative to observable behavior; they clearly isolate mismatches between hypothetical expectations and observations. As we will discuss below, HBE analyses of desert socioeconomic life in Australia and the Great Basin have developed in tandem over the last 25 years, and have made important contributions to the way we think about the adaptive nature of human–environmental dynamics.
Subsistence Strategies Many researchers have noted broad social similarities between Great Basin groups and Australian desert Aborigines. Gould et al. (1972) presented a detailed account of parallels in the economic and colonial histories of the two regions. They noted that environmental constraints of these arid and unpredictable environments are
___________________________________________________________________________________
86
_______________________________________________________________________________
The Economics of Desert Societies
linked to similar social responses: low population density; high residential mobility with highly portable technology; flexible local organization, with fluid dispersal and coalescence of groups of people; and open-ended, widely extended social organization based on classificatory kinship. These similarities are especially striking in the economy where foraging is based on sex-linked differences in subsistence activities.
Links between Sex, Foraging, and Sharing Prior to European contact, socioeconomic life in the Great Basin and the Australian deserts revolved around collecting seeds from grasses and trees, seasonal fruit, insects, and small game. In arid Australia at least 92 plant species are identified as edible (Latz 1995; O’Connell et al. 1983; Veth and Walsh 1988; Walsh 1987), while in the Great Basin over 150 plants have been catalogued as edible (Fowler 1972). In both regions, plants and small game were mainly supplied by women. Men focused on the (infrequently encountered) larger game, which often gave very low returns given the time required for pursuit (Bliege Bird and Bird in press; Gould 1969; Gould et al. 1972). In both regions, the resources acquired by women were usually directed to a small group of dependants. Conversely, men’s efforts were often focused on providing more public goods. In the Great Basin, especially south of the Humboldt River, annual subsistence and mobility revolved around harvesting pine nuts in the fall. These provided staple resources stored through the winter, when family groups in some areas would congregate in ‘‘villages’’ of up to 200 people. Villages would break up in the spring when smaller groups would disperse to focus on roots, grass seeds, and small game. North of the Humboldt River, more abundant roots and berries took the place of pine nuts which were not locally available (see Fowler and Liljeblad 1986; Thomas et al. 1986). In his classic ethnography of Great Basin Paiute and Shoshone people, Steward (1938) stressed the daily importance of women’s activities, and the more public nature of men’s subsistence labor: Seeds [for Owens Valley Paiute] were the most important food (52) . . . A woman gathered seeds only for her immediate family (59) . . . Migrations during the year depended upon local abundance of seeds (60) . . . Animal foods were of secondary importance . . . Game procured by individual [male] hunters was divided among all members of the village, the hunter keeping only the hind quarter for himself and family (66) . . . [Among western Shoshone] seeds gathered were private property. Women shared them only with their husbands, children, and sometimes parents whom they supported . . . Large game, on the other hand, was shared communally with all village members, whether they were related or not (74) . . . Relative scarcity of animals made meat a minor importance . . . Hunting was relatively of greater importance during seed shortage, but considerable reliance was placed on rodents (83) . . . Large game was of secondary importance (90) . . . [In the northern Great Basin] there are more roots and berries [harvested by women] in proportion to seeds (103–4) . . . Big game hunting was carried out by individual hunters in accessible mountains. Meat was distributed freely to one’s neighbors (115) . . . [Among Gosiute
___________________________________________________________________________________
87
_______________________________________________________________________________
D o u g l a s W. Bir d a nd R e b e c c a B l i e g e B i r d Shoshone] The importance of rodents [for women] was considerable in this region (138) . . . Communal hunts [of antelope and rabbits] were organized by a local chief, but he received no more meat than other participants [which included men, women, and children] (163) . . . It was customary if not obligatory for a hunter to share large game with his neighbors. (184)
Similar accounts are common for Australian Aborigines. In the cool-dry season (April–August) grass seeds, roots, Solanum fruit, and goannas were daily staples. During the late spring and summer (September–March), if water supplies were replenished with isolated rains, larger groups would congregate for religious purposes. Acacia tree seeds and goannas made up much of the diet during this time (Bliege Bird and Bird in press; Cane 1987; Gould 1969, 1991; Tonkinson 1991; Walsh 1987, 1990). Gould et al. (1972: 266) noted: the Pitjantjatjara [Western Desert] peoples subsisted mainly on vegetable foods, including eight staple varieties of fruits, berries, and seeds as well as a multitude of supplemental or occasional varieties. Nearly all these foods were collected by women. Except for after a successful hunt (a fairly rare event), vegetable foods comprised ‘‘ . . . 70 or 80 percent of the total food supply’’ (Meggitt 1964: 33). Protein was supplied primary by various lizards (mainly goannas [Varanus spp.]) and small ground-dwelling marsupials . . . Most small game was collected by women; men concentrated on larger game.
Gould (1982) also observed that sharing patterns among Western Desert peoples were similar to those recorded by Steward in the Great Basin. The results of women’s efforts were directed toward a narrow range of dependants, whereas men focused on game that was shared widely beyond a single hearth group.
Flexible Hunting and Sharing Strategies It is important to recognize that in both regions, sex-linked differences in subsistence were flexible with variable seasonal, environmental, and social contexts. For example, among contemporary Martu of Australia’s Western Desert, during the cool-dry season (May–August) women spend a great deal of their foraging time hunting burrowed goannas and collecting Solanum fruit in the sandplains and dunes. In contrast, men spend almost all their foraging time hunting mobile game (bustard, kangaroo, and emu) across a range of habitats (Bliege Bird and Bird in press). During this season women’s resources are ‘‘owned’’ by the acquirer and shared with a relatively small group of dependants. Conversely, if successful, male hunters make no claim to the animal – the game is usually given to an elder (often to a spouse’s father) who takes responsibility for wide distributions (Tonkinson 1991). Primary sharing of kangaroo and emu is often dictated by kinship categories, but thereafter the appropriate recipient shares freely with anyone who desires a portion. The pattern of Martu subsistence is notably different during the hottest part of the year (January–April). During this time, sand goanna (Varanus gouldii) and perenti (V. giganteus) are more commonly encountered on the surface, and women
___________________________________________________________________________________
88
_______________________________________________________________________________
The Economics of Desert Societies
and men sometimes coordinate their hunting activities. If men have been unsuccessful in hunting larger game, they sometimes shift strategies and search for game resources targeted by women, something they very rarely do at other times of the year (Bliege Bird and Bird in press). Large game is encountered less often during this season, and sharing patterns for men during the hot season tend to be more narrowly focused. Ethnographers have noted similar variability in Great Basin hunting. During the fall, especially in areas south of the Humboldt River, large groups of men, women, and children would cooperate in game drives for both antelope and rabbits. Brush structures were constructed in a long V-shape and flanked by people. Large crowds would then drive the game into a corral (for antelope) or nets (for rabbits) at the far end of the drive. The game acquired was shared among all participating families, with the organizer receiving no more than anyone else (Steward 1938: 163). Throughout the rest of the year, men independently hunted deer and mountain sheep, which when successful, were shared widely with all families in the local group and their neighbors. Outside of communal drives, women’s game acquisition was focused on trapping and snaring small mammals (especially ground squirrels) for immediate family consumption. Game drives were less important north of the Humboldt River. There men focused on deer and mountain sheep, but in the fall, men and women would sometimes cooperate in trapping and snaring small game (groundhogs, ground squirrels, rabbits), fishing, and netting waterfowl (Kelly 1932; Steward 1938; Stewart 1941).
Hypotheses about Subsistence Variability Human behavioral ecology in Australia and the Great Basin is to some extent an attempt to put previous ecological approaches (such as those of Steward and Gould discussed above) on a solid theoretical foundation; in a sense, to make their assumptions explicit and hypotheses testable. As we noted previously, Steward (1938, 1955, 1968) had argued that many of the socioeconomic similarities discussed above were adaptations designed to benefit a narrowly defined affinal and consanguineal corporation (a man, his wives, and their offspring). These were selfsufficient units: without cooperation, individuals would not survive, and larger cooperative groups were rarely advantageous or feasible. Steward (1938: 230–7) surmised this was determined by the abundance and distribution of the subsistence resources discussed above. The ‘‘family organization of the local band’’ was based in a sexual division of labor, which served as a mini-economy of scale, by which men and women specialized in different kinds of subsistence to more effectively provision their common interests. Cooperative groups larger than this were ephemeral because they would quickly depress the local resource base. ‘‘The functional basis of band organization, then, was the habitual cooperation of its members in joint enterprises and its objective expression was the common name, chieftainship, and ownership of territory’’ (Steward 1938: 51).
___________________________________________________________________________________
89
_______________________________________________________________________________
D o u g l a s W. Bir d a nd R e b e c c a B l i e g e B i r d
O’Connell, Hawkes, and colleagues were the first to formally apply HBE to questions about subsistence in the Great Basin and desert Australia (Hawkes and O’Connell 1981; Madsen and O’Connell 1982; O’Connell and Hawkes 1981, 1984; O’Connell et al. 1982). Their analyses, along with the more recent work discussed below, have brought into question two essential assumptions of previous ecological work in these areas: 1 2
That there is a straightforward relationship between resource abundance and subsistence/mobility patterns. That local groups are units of adaptation (i.e., that labor is designed to serve the common interests of the members of the group).
HBE in Desert Australia Initial HBE investigations in Australia were based on O’Connell’s measurements of the efficiency of hunting and gathering among Arandic-speaking Alyawara in the Central Desert in 1974–5. On the assumption that natural selection has shaped decision-making capacities, and that efficient foraging will enhance individual fitness, O’Connell and Hawkes (1981, 1984) generated specific predictions about the range of activities and prey types that would maximize foraging returns relative to the options available. They used two formal models from behavioral ecology to predict foraging decisions: the ‘‘prey choice model’’ (PCM) and the ‘‘patch utilization model’’ (PUM). The PCM assumes that the goal of foraging is to maximize energy (the currency) per unit time spent foraging (searching and handling). The decision it analyzes is whether a forager should handle an encountered resource, or pass it over to search for other resources. The most important constraint of the PCM is that it assumes that resources are distributed randomly; more accurately, that an encounter with an item of one type does not change the probability of encountering other items. The model ranks resources according to their ‘‘profitability’’ – the ratio of energy gained relative to its expected post-encounter handling time (pursuit, capture, and processing). It assumes that foragers will take an encountered item only if its profitability is greater than that expected by searching for and handling more profitable resources. The main predictions of the PCM are: . The decision as to whether a resource will be handled when it is encountered is determined by the abundance of the more profitable resource, rather than the abundance of the resource encountered per se. . Lower encounter rates with the most profitable resources serve to expand dietary breadth to include less profitable resources (Stephens and Krebs 1986: 17–24). The PUM relaxes the random distribution constraint of the PCM to consider situations where resources are patchy in time or space. The model ranks patches
___________________________________________________________________________________
90
_______________________________________________________________________________
The Economics of Desert Societies
according to their profitability (yield for time spent foraging within a patch) and predicts the threshold at which a forager should exploit additional patches. Lower ranked patches will be exploited when the marginal gain of continuing to forage in a given patch drops its profitability below the overall return rate of the habitat (yield for time spent traveling and foraging) (Stephens and Krebs 1986: 24–34). O’Connell and Hawkes (1981, 1984) have considered two questions about Alyawara foraging: 1 Why did women select a particular set of resources and ignore others that were abundant and formerly important in the diet? 2 Why did men pick particular hunting locales and ignore others that were at least equally accessible? Contrary to the conventional wisdom of cultural ecology, Alyawara socioeconomic patterns were not directly determined by sheer abundance or seasonality of subsistence resources. The difference in energy yields between the sandplain (3,200 kcal/hr searching and handling) and mulga woodland (652 kcal/hr) were such that when women traveled to these patches, if they chose to handle the abundant ripe acacia and grass seeds (<600 kcal/hr handling) of the latter, they would have reduced their foraging efficiency. The PCM predictions are consistent with the observation that women avoided these high-cost seeds. Cane (1987) found similar results among the Gugadja of the Western Desert: here too, seeds were costly, providing only 340 kcal per hour. These resources would be efficient options only if encounter rates with resources like goanna and cossid larvae were significantly reduced. O’Connell and Hawkes (1981) hypothesized that the availability of commercial flour reduced pressure on the more profitable resources, which in turn increased overall foraging efficiency and narrowed the range of resources exploited. As predicted by the PUM, Alyawara men did not sample potential hunting patches at random or simply as a function of proximity. When hunting on foot, men chose to travel to either the mulga or open woodland patches, and completely avoided the local floodplain. Average return rates from traveling to and hunting in the mulga and open woodland patches were not significantly different (roughly 2 kg/hr traveling, searching, and pursuing). However, the efficiency of traveling to hunt in these patches is significantly higher than that possible from hunting in the floodplain, where despite its accessibility, game was rare and inpatch return rates were predictably very low. Similar results were obtained from hunting trips in vehicles. As expected, the open grassland patch, which was visited most frequently, also had the highest average return rate. Traveling to this patch was significantly more efficient than the in-patch return rates from a wide range of locally available areas in the woodland, rocky ranges, and floodplain. Occasionally, hunters did use other patches, but usually en route to the open grassland, or when in the process of hunting in the grassland, certain conditions reduced their return rates to the point at which switching to an adjacent patch was a more efficient option.
___________________________________________________________________________________
91
_______________________________________________________________________________
D o u g l a s W. Bir d a nd R e b e c c a B l i e g e B i r d
The Alyawara data are consistent with these hypotheses: . Women adjusted prey choice in ways consistent with maximizing efficiency while foraging within a given patch. . Men behaved as if their goal was to maximize their rate of energetic capture while hunting. However, the ways in which people did not meet the expectations of the models may be just as informative. Firstly, Alyawara men and women had very different foraging strategies. It is unlikely that both strategies were designed for the same purpose (e.g., reliably delivering the same currency to a household). In many cases we do not know whether foragers could have been more efficient by exploiting resources or patches that they chose to pass over. Secondly, certain kinds of foods were more likely to be shared more widely than others, which (from the perspective of the acquirer) would significantly change the expected efficiency of these resources. As mentioned above, traditional ecological explanations of sharing have almost always assumed it functions for the benefit of the group. Behavioral ecologists tend to focus on the potential conflicts of interest between individuals and groups. If a hunter concentrates on acquiring goods that are shared widely and indiscriminately (surely a group benefit), what keeps everyone else from free-riding off his labor, allowing them more time to focus on more reliable resources that are more narrowly shared? Over the last decade in HBE there has been a great deal of debate about the role of food sharing and sex-linked differences in foraging activities (see Bliege Bird 1999; Bliege Bird et al. 2003; Gurven et al. 2000; Hawkes 1993; Hill 2002; Kaplan et al. 2000; Winterhalder 1996). Some scholars have argued that specialized foraging and sharing activities are designed to provision highly dependant offspring. Accordingly, women tend to focus on activities that are compatible with childcare and resources that provide dependable daily income, while men specialize in skill-based activities that target large package resources whose acquisition is more variable, but widespread reciprocal sharing ensures efficient provisioning (Kaplan et al. 2000). The problem is that ‘‘men’s resources’’ (e.g., large game) are not usually shared reciprocally. As noted above, the common pattern is one in which resources continually flow from good hunters to others who do not return the favor, making large game hunting an unreliable provisioning strategy (e.g., Hawkes et al. 2001). This has led some researchers to suggest that men and women may not always have similar foraging goals (see review in Hawkes and Bliege Bird 2002). Along with Hawkes and Smith, we have recently argued that in some circumstances men may choose particular foraging activities and patches that maximize the efficiency of social display rather than some nutritional currency (e.g., Bliege Bird et al. 2001; Smith et al. 2003). Certain foraging activities, especially those that require a high degree of skill and cost, can be an important means of advertising underlying, difficult to detect qualities of the forager (in HBE parlance, these activities serve as ‘‘costly signals’’, sensu Grafen (1990) and Zahavi and Zahavi
___________________________________________________________________________________
92
_______________________________________________________________________________
The Economics of Desert Societies
(1997)). Such displays are especially efficient when they draw a large audience, by providing widely shared ‘‘public goods’’ for example. Both the signaler and the recipient can benefit when the cost of the activity ensures the ‘‘honesty’’ of the information advertised in the display. We have suggested that certain aspects of men’s foraging among Martu Aborigines in the Western Desert may be consistent with a costly signaling hypothesis. During the cool-dry season men would increase their foraging return rates significantly if they stopped their search for larger game (2,125 kcal/hr searching and handling) to dig for sand goanna and pick Solanum fruit (post-encounter returns ¼ 5,318 and 4,217 kcal/hr handling, respectively). Only on very rare occasions did we observe men discontinue their search to pursue these resources. We hypothesized that during this season the benefits of displaying the skills of tracking mobile animals may make larger game especially attractive to certain men; and the fact that these game are shared widely ensures a broad audience (in spite of the extreme modesty of the hunters). In the hot season small game is more mobile and the opportunities to track them greatly increase. During this time men often interrupt their search for larger game to pursue sand goanna. We have hypothesized that men may prefer mobile game in all seasons because only tracking has the potential to discriminate skill levels among hunters. While Martu ascribe no political power to skilled trackers, they do make overt distinctions in skill for male and female trackers (Bliege Bird and Bird in press).
HBE in the Great Basin Rather than searching for something essential or universally typical of all huntergatherers, the arid Australian examples are especially instructive in drawing our attention to the causes of variability in foraging strategies. While the cases discussed above focused on variability within groups, applications of HBE in the Great Basin have generally investigated variability in subsistence through time. The range of HBE applications to Great Basin human prehistory is well beyond the scope of this chapter – syntheses can be found in Beck (1999), Bettinger (1991), Elston (1986), Elston and Zeanah (2002), Grayson (1993), Madsen and O’Connell (1982), and Simms (1987). Here we focus on an issue that we feel can be enriched by comparison with the Australian data discussed above: subsistence variability in the early to mid-Holocene. In the transition from the late Pleistocene/early Holocene (ca. 11,200–8,000 bp) to the mid-Holocene (ca. 8,000–4,000 bp), patterns in the Great Basin archaeological record shift dramatically (Beck and Jones 2001; Elston and Zeanah 2002; Grayson 1993; Simms 1987). Archaeological assemblages of technology prior to about 8,000 bp (commonly referred to as ‘‘Paleo-Indian’’) are dominated by large projectile points and formal flaked stone tools. Grinding stones, which were historically used to process seeds, are rare until about 8,000 bp. While there continues to be debate about the diversity of the Paleo-Indian archaeological sites, a strong case can be made that, through the early Holocene, more extensive lakes and marshes were central to the subsistence economy of the people living in the Great Basin. When these pluvial lake systems disappeared,
___________________________________________________________________________________
93
_______________________________________________________________________________
D o u g l a s W. Bir d a nd R e b e c c a B l i e g e B i r d
so did the lowland sites with large projectile points. At roughly the same time, grinding stones became more common throughout the region. Many archaeologists have suggested that this may indicate a shift from an economy based primarily on hunting larger game to one based on a broad spectrum of plants and small animals, commonly referred to as the ‘‘Archaic.’’ Partly based on experience among the Alyawara, O’Connell et al. (1982) used the framework of the prey choice model (PCM, described above) to explain some of these archaeological changes. They hypothesized that if, in the late Pleistocene and early Holocene, encounters with large game were sufficiently common, overall foraging returns may have been high enough for foragers to bypass resources that would entail extensive processing with grinding stones (i.e., seeds). This hypothesis was based on the assumption that large game were the most profitable (energy for time spent in pursuit and processing) option, and that seeds ranked lower than most other resources (small game, roots, berries, etc.). Simms (1987) tested this assumption with processing experiments on a wide array of Great Basin foods. Simms found that, indeed, grass seeds had the lowest profitability of all major food resources – as in Australia, grass seeds from the Great Basin had on-encounter return rates usually less than 300 kcal/hr. Thus, based on the predictions of the PCM, it was reasonable to infer that seeds, and the technology required to process them, would only become important archaeologically with reductions in more profitable prey, especially large and medium-sized game. This work has since inspired more detailed investigations into the nature of the Paleo-Indian/Archaic material record and our assumptions about the goals and efficiency of acquiring different kinds of resources. Two issues are especially relevant here. Firstly, there are very few Paleo-Indian sites in the Great Basin associated with large mammal remains, and we now have clear evidence that diets from this time included a wide array of small animals, fish, and seeds (see reviews in Elston and Zeanah 2002 and Grayson 1993). Secondly, large game is not always very profitable. While each animal represents a large package of meat that requires relatively little processing, they commonly entail long pursuits and widespread sharing which can translate into very low returns for the hunter (e.g., Bliege Bird and Bird in press; Bliege Bird et al. 2001; Hawkes et al. 2001). As discussed above, hunting large game may often incorporate goals related to social display that may conflict with efficient provisioning. If foragers in the Great Basin harvested a broad spectrum of subsistence resources through this long period of time, what accounts for the variability in the technological record of the Paleo-Indian/Archaic transition? Elston and Zeanah (2002) have recently proposed that the significant changes in lithic technology reflect the change from an earlier condition characterized by low human population density, higher residential mobility, and men and women performing sex-specific tasks in a landscape that was very different from that known historically. Recent paleoenvironmental research indicates that the late Pleistocene was cooler and drier than today, while the early Holocene was warmer and wetter and possibly more variable. Based on a series of ecological simulations, Elston and Zeanah (2002) suggest that through the early Holocene, large animals
___________________________________________________________________________________
94
_______________________________________________________________________________
The Economics of Desert Societies
should have been relatively abundant in the low to mid-elevation foothills from fall to spring, and abundant wetlands would have provided reliable late winter–early spring foraging patches. Even if men and women may have had different foraging goals, basing camps in the lowlands would have provided local patches for women to acquire small game, fish, roots, and seeds, as well as opportunities for men to travel to hunting locales: The abundance of expansive wetlands, and lack of competition throughout the Great Basin, allowed Prearchaic foragers high mobility that maximized men’s encounters with large game without sacrificing women’s foraging interests . . . our simulations suggest that the known Prearchaic record is biased toward sites positioned primarily to access women’s resources, but bearing a technology reflecting men’s [activities] . . . (Elston and Zeanah 2002: 120–1)
If this is so, the rarity of grinding stones in the early sites may be in part an epiphenomenon, the outcome of low population densities and high mobility (i.e., there would have been fewer chances for grinding stones to become part of the archaeological record). This case has also been made for the early Holocene record of Australia (Gorecki et al. 1997). Testing this hypothesis will require better experimental and archaeological data. For example, we still have much to learn about variability in the efficiency of different hunting techniques that may have been used in the past, return rates for collecting different kinds of vegetable foods in different settings, and changes in efficiency due to things like forager age, experience, and size.
Conclusion The long history of HBE research in arid Australia and the Great Basin demonstrates a close relationship between different aspects of the socioeconomic life and environmental circumstances of groups. Societies in both regions have much in common – fluid and highly mobile local organization depending heavily on resources acquired by women. The parallels are not necessarily a description of something ‘‘essential’’ about arid hunter-gatherers; rather, they are similarities in the way that people vary their behavior under changing and sometimes unpredictable physical and social circumstances. Sex-linked differences in foraging strategies are especially instructive for exploring factors that influence this variability. In both regions, women focused on a broad spectrum of resources. A growing body of behavioral ecology originating from studies in the Great Basin and desert Australia suggests that women’s decisions about prey and patch choice closely track environmental variability in ways that increase their individual energy returns. Relative to this pattern, men’s decisions often seem idiosyncratic. Ethnographic accounts, quantitative data, and some archaeological patterns indicate that sometimes variability in men’s strategies may conflict with efficient food provisioning. However, their strategies may be better understood if we take into account that men and women may have different goals in acquiring and sharing food.
___________________________________________________________________________________
95
_______________________________________________________________________________
D o u g l a s W. Bir d a nd R e b e c c a B l i e g e B i r d
Human behavioral ecology is a useful framework for investigating aspects of such variability. It provides a coherent theory of human behavioral adaptation; not simply a description of how people respond to environmental variability, but a logical means by which we can generate and test hypotheses about why a pattern of behavior is maintained or varies in a particular way. Ethnographically, it provides a set of formal models, with a limited set of variables, that when tested against observable social behavior, can isolate variability that does not meet our theoretical expectations. For example, in this chapter we have demonstrated that the way in which men’s and women’s subsistence decisions fail to match the predictions of simple models promises to lead us in novel directions with new and very testable hypotheses. For issues about prehistoric subsistence, it can be argued that human behavioral ecology frees us from relying only on ethnographically known cases for models of the past. It does this by focusing on hypotheses designed to address issues of variability independent of specific ethnographic analogs (O’Connell 1995; Winterhalder and Smith 2000). In a sense, this is simply the process of doing good science related to human behavior; testing theoretically justifiable ideas against observations, with the goal of producing useful hypotheses that lead to new questions and new directions for exploring human–environmental dynamics.
References Beck, C. (ed.) 1999: Models for the Millennium: Great Basin Anthropology Today. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press. Beck, C. and Jones, G. T. 2001: Lithic source use and foraging patterns in the Great Basin Paleoarchaic. New Orleans: Unpublished paper presented at the 66th Annual Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology. Bettinger, R. L. 1991: Hunter-Gatherers: Archaeological and Evolutionary Theory. New York: Plenum Press. Bird, D. W. and Bliege Bird, R. in press: Martu children’s hunting strategies in the Western Desert, Australia: Implications for the evolution of human life histories. In B. Hewlett (ed.), Hunter-Gatherer Children Senri Ethnological Studies: Papers from the 9th International Conference on Hunting and Gathering Societies. Bliege Bird, R. 1999: Cooperation and conflict: The behavioral ecology of the sexual division of labor. Evolutionary Anthropology, 8, 65–75. Bliege Bird, R. and Bird, D. W. in press: Human hunting seasonality: A case from Australia. In D. Brockman and C. van Shaik (eds), Primate Seasonality, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Bliege Bird, R., Bird, D. W., Smith, E. A., and Kushnick, G. C. 2003: Risk and reciprocity in Meriam food sharing. Evolution and Human Behavior, 23, 297–321. Bliege Bird, R., Smith, E. A., and Bird, D. W. 2001: The hunting handicap: Costly signaling in male foraging strategies. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 50, 9–19. Cane, S. 1987: Australian Aboriginal subsistence in the Western Desert. Human Ecology, 15, 391–434. Cronk, L. 1991: Human behavioral ecology. Annual Review of Anthropology, 20, 25–53. Elston, R. G. 1986: Prehistory of the western area. In W. L. d’Azevedo (ed.), The Handbook of North American Indians vol. 11, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 135–48.
___________________________________________________________________________________
96
_______________________________________________________________________________
The Economics of Desert Societies Elston, R. G. and Zeanah, D. W. 2002: Thinking outside the box: A new perspective on diet breadth and sexual division of labor in the Prearchaic Great Basin. World Archaeology, 34, 103–30. Fowler, C. S. 1972: Comparative Numic ethnobiology. Unpublished PhD thesis, Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh. Fowler, C. S. and Fowler, D. D. 1971: Notes on the history of the southern Paiutes and western Shoshonis. Utah Historical Quarterly, 39 (2), 95–113. Fowler, C. S. and Liljeblad, S. 1986: Northern Paiute. In W. L. d’Azevedo (ed.), The Handbook of North American Indians vol. 11, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 435–48. Fowler, D. D. 1986: History of research. In W. L. d’Azevedo (ed.), The Handbook of North American Indians vol. 11, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 15–30. Gorecki, P., Grant, M., O’Connor, S., and Veth, P. 1997: The morphology, function, and antiquity of grinding implements in northern Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 32, 141–50. Gould, R. A. 1969: Subsistence behavior among the Western Desert Aborigines of Australia. Oceania, 39, 253–74. Gould, R. A. 1982: Comparative ecology of food sharing in Australia and northwest California. In R. S. O. Harding and G. Teleki (eds), Omnivorous Primates, New York: Columbia University Press, 344–421. Gould, R. A. 1991: Arid land foraging as seen from Australia: Adaptive models and behavioral realities. Oceania, 62, 12–33. Gould, R. A., Fowler, D. D., and Fowler, C. S. 1972: Diggers and doggers: Parallel failures in economic acculturation. Southwestern Journal of Anthropology, 28, 265–81. Grafen, A. 1990: Biological signals as handicaps. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 144, 517–46. Grayson, D. K. 1993: The Desert’s Past: A Natural Prehistory of the Great Basin. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Gurven, M., Hill, K., Hurtado, A. M., and Lyles, R. 2000: Food transfers among Hiwi foragers of Venezuela: Tests of reciprocity. Human Ecology, 28, 171–218. Hawkes, K. 1993: Why hunter-gatherers work: An ancient version of the problem of public goods. Current Anthropology, 34, 341–61. Hawkes, K. and Bliege Bird, R. 2002: Showing off, handicap signaling, and the evolution of men’s work. Evolutionary Anthropology, 11, 58–67. Hawkes, K. and O’Connell, J. F. 1981: Affluent hunters? Some comments in light of the Alyawara case. American Anthropologist, 83, 622–6. Hawkes, K., O’Connell, J. F., and Blurton Jones, N. G. 2001: Hadza hunting and the evolution of nuclear families. Current Anthropology, 42, 681–709. Hill, K. 2002: Cooperative food acquisition by Ache foragers. Human Nature, 13, 105–28. Jennings, J. D. 1957: Danger Cave: A progress summary. El Palacio, 60, 179–213. Jennings, J. D. 1964: The Desert West. In J. D. Jennings and E. Norbeck (eds), Prehistoric Man in the New World, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 149–74. Jennings, J. D. 1974: Prehistory of North America (2nd edn). New York: McGraw-Hill. Kaplan, H., Hill, K., Lancaster, J., and Hurtado, A. M. 2000: A theory of human life history evolution: Diet, intelligence, and longevity. Evolutionary Anthropology, 9, 156–85. Kelly, I. T. 1932: Ethnography of the Surprise Valley Paiute. Berkeley: University of California Press. Kelly, R. L. 1995: The Foraging Spectrum: Diversity in Hunter-Gatherer Lifeways. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press.
___________________________________________________________________________________
97
_______________________________________________________________________________
D o u g l a s W. Bir d a nd R e b e c c a B l i e g e B i r d Krebs, J. R. and Davies, N. B. 1993: An Introduction to Behavioral Ecology (3rd edn). Oxford: Blackwell Scientific. Krebs, J. R. and Davies, N. B. (eds) 1997: Behavioral Ecology: An Evolutionary Approach (4th edn). Oxford: Blackwell Scientific. Latz, P. 1995: Bushfires and Bushtucker: Aboriginal Plant Use in Central Australia. Alice Springs: IAD Press. Liljeblad, S. and Fowler, C. S. 1986: Owens Valley Paiute. In W. L. d’Azevedo (ed.), The Handbook of North American Indians vol. 11, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 414–34. Lourandos, H. 1997: Continent of Hunter-Gatherers: New Perspectives in Australian Prehistory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Madsen, D. and O’Connell, J. F. 1982: Man and Environment in the Great Basin. Washington, DC: Society for American Archaeology. Meggitt, M. J. 1957: Notes on the vegetable foods of the Walbiri of central Australia. Oceania, 28 (2), 143–5. Meggitt, M. J. 1964: Aboriginal food gatherers of tropical Australia. In Proceedings and Papers of the IUCN 9th Technical Meeting, part 1, Nairobi, 30–7. O’Connell, J. F. 1995: Ethnoarchaeology needs a general theory of behavior. Journal of Archaeological Research, 3, 205–55. O’Connell, J. F. and Hawkes, K. 1981: Alyawara plant use and optimal foraging theory. In B. Winterhalder and E. A. Smith (eds), Hunter-Gatherer Foraging Strategies: Ethnographic and Archaeological Analyses, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 99–125. O’Connell, J. F. and Hawkes, K. 1984: Food choice and foraging sites among the Alyawara. Journal of Anthropological Research, 40, 504–35. O’Connell, J. F., Jones, K. T., and Simms, S. R. 1982: Some thoughts on prehistoric archaeology in the Great Basin. In D. B. Madsen and J. F. O’Connell (eds), Man and Environment in the Great Basin, Washington, DC: Society for American Archaeology, 227–41. O’Connell, J. F., Latz, P., and Barnett, P. 1983: Traditional and modern plant use among the Alywara of central Australia. Economic Botany, 37, 80–109. Peterson, N. 1976: The natural and cultural areas of Aboriginal Australia: A preliminary analysis of population groupings with adaptive significance. In N. Peterson (ed.), Tribes and Boundaries in Australia, Canberra: Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies, 50–71. Peterson, N. 1977: Aboriginal uses of Australian Solanaceae. In J. G. Hawkes, R. N. Lester, and A. D. Skedling (eds), The Biology and Taxonomy of the Solanaceae, London: Linneaus Society, 171–88. Peterson, N. 1978: The traditional pattern of subsistence to 1975. In B. S. Hetzel and H. J. Frith (eds), The Nutrition of Aborigines in Relation to the Ecosystem of Central Australia, Melbourne: CSIRO, 25–35. Service, E. 1962: Primitive Social Organization: An Evolutionary Perspective. New York: Random House. Simms, S. R. 1987: Behavioral Ecology and Hunter-Gatherer Foraging: An Example from the Great Basin. Oxford: BAR International Monograph Series no. 381, Hadrian Books. Smith, E. A. and Winterhalder, B. (eds) 1992: Evolutionary Ecology and Human Behavior. Hawthorne: Aldine de Grutyer. Smith, E. A., Bliege Bird, R., and Bird, D. W. 2003: The benefits of costly signaling: Meriam turtle hunters and spearfishers. Behavioral Ecology, 14, 116–26.
___________________________________________________________________________________
98
_______________________________________________________________________________
The Economics of Desert Societies Stanner, W. E. H. 1965: Aboriginal territorial organization: Estate, range, domain, and regime. Oceania, 36, 1–26. Stephens, D. W. and Krebs, J. R. 1986: Foraging Theory. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Steward, J. H. 1933: Ethnography of the Owens Valley Paiute. University of California Publications of American Archaeology and Ethnography, 33, 233–350. Steward, J. H. 1936: The economic and social basis of primitive bands. In Essays in Anthropology Presented to A. L. Krober, Berkeley: University of California Press, 331–50. Steward, J. H. 1938: Basin-Plateau Aboriginal Sociopolitical Groups. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Bureau of American Ethnology. Steward, J. H. 1941: Culture element distributions: XXVIII: Nevada Shoshone. University of California Anthropological Records, 8, 263–392. Steward, J. H. 1955: Theory of Culture Change. Urbana: University of Illinois Press. Steward, J. H. 1968: Causal factors and processes in the evolution of pre-farming societies. In R. B. Lee and I. DeVore (eds), Man the Hunter, Chicago: Aldine, 321–34. Stewart, O. 1941: Culture element distributions: XIV: Northern Paiute. University of California Anthropological Records, 4, 361–446. Thomas, D. H. 1983: The Archaeology of Monitor Valley 2. Gatecliff Shelter. New York: Anthropological Papers of the American Museum of Natural History vol. 59, American Museum of Natural History. Thomas, D. H., Pendleton, L. S., and Cappannari, S. C. 1986: Western Shoshone. In W. L. d’Azevedo (ed.), The Handbook of North American Indians vol. 11, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 260–75. Tonkinson, R. 1991: The Martu Aborigines: Living the Dream of Australia’s Desert. Fort Worth, TX: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston. Veth, P. M. and Walsh, F. J. 1988: The concept of ‘‘staple’’ plant foods in the Western Desert region of Western Australia. Australian Aboriginal Studies, 2, 19–25. Walsh, F. J. 1987: The influence of spatial and temporal distribution of plant food resources on traditional Martujarra subsistence strategies. Australian Archaeology, 25, 88–101. Walsh, F. J. 1990: An ecological study of traditional Aboriginal use of ‘‘country’’: Martu in the Great and Little Sandy Deserts, Western Australia. Proceedings of the Ecological Society of Australia, 16, 23–37. Williams, G. C. 1966: Adaptation and Natural Selection: A Critique of Some Current Evolutionary Thought. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Winterhalder, B. 1996: Social foraging and the behavioral ecology of intragroup resource transfers. Evolutionary Anthropology, 5, 46–57. Winterhalder, B. and Smith, E. A. 2000: Analysing adaptive strategies: Human behavioral ecology at twenty-five years. Evolutionary Anthropology, 9, 51–72. Zahavi, A. and Zahavi, A. 1997: The Handicap Principle: A Missing Piece of Darwin’s Puzzle. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
___________________________________________________________________________________
99
_______________________________________________________________________________
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cycles of Aridity and Human Mobility Risk Minimization Among Late Pleistocene Foragers of the Western Desert, Australia Peter Veth Introduction Australia is the most arid continent to have been colonized by modern humans and the Western Desert is arguably the most marginal landscape within it. This is largely due to its high temperatures, lack of coordinated drainage, paucity of permanent waters, and patchy and unpredictable resources (cf. Mabbutt 1977; Veth 1993a). These factors have historically created conditions of high risk and stress for arid land foragers (cf. Yellen 1976). Remarkably, there are now firm dates for occupation of the Western Desert in excess of 30,000 bp (cf. Smith et al. 1997; Thorley 1998a) and increasing evidence for early and widespread use of most landforms. There is also mounting evidence that major changes in settlement and mobility patterns occurred with the onset of hyperarid conditions associated with the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) (O’Connor et al. 1999; Veth in prep.). In this chapter I discuss the central role of mobility in the risk minimizing strategies employed by Western Desert foragers and examine assemblages from three sites dating to the first phase of occupation from between 32,000 to 22,000 bp (Smith et al. 1997; Thorley 1998a; Veth 2000). I will examine eight different lines of archaeological evidence that may be used to infer residential mobility from these Pleistocene assemblages.
Risk Minimization and the Role of Mobility in the Australian Deserts There is increasing evidence from the Western Desert that conditions were more favorable for humans during the first phase of occupation and then worsened
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
100
______________________________________________________________________________
C y c l es o f A r i d i t y a n d H u m a n M o b i l i t y
significantly towards the height of the LGM by approximately 18,000 years ago (Smith 1996; Thorley 1998a; Veth 2000). This period saw the likely loss of a considerable number of permanent water sources and food staples (Smith 1989). Increasing aridity associated with the LGM probably represented the first test of human adjustment to truly arid conditions with a majority view that humans were unable to cope with the ensuing hyperarid conditions and restricted their territory in response (Hiscock 1988; Thorley 1998b; Veth 1995; see also Chapter 3, this volume). I propose that during the terminal Pleistocene Western Desert foragers engaged in a pattern of settlement dominated by high residential mobility to low logistical mobility (after Binford 1980) coupled with a ‘‘territorial’’ mobility strategy whereby adjacent localities were abandoned for varying periods of time (after Kelly 1992, 1995; Varien 1999). Mobility configurations likely had great dynamism given the ethnographically observed patterns for Western Desert Aborigines, whereby strategy switching occurred in response to drought. Strategy switching describes how groups responded by either withdrawing into their ‘‘home’’ territory or, alternatively, avoided areas altogether through temporary abandonment (cf. Gould 1991). This extreme flexibility in mobility is seen to underpin a raft of risk minimizing strategies in the Western Desert (cf. Tonkinson 1991). The nature of Pleistocene arid zone adaptations may be examined using a resource structure model, such as that proposed by Ambrose and Lorenz (1990), where the archaeological correlates of hunter-gatherer behaviors in an unpredictable and scarce resource regime are defined (see Table 6.1). The marginality of the Western Desert for humans is largely a function of poor rainfall reliability and generally impoverished species diversity in comparison to other desert regions of the world (cf. Gould 1991). The archaeological predictions of the resource structure model are examined in the following sections. Table 6.1 The behavioral and archaeological correlates of an unpredictable and scarce resource structure (after Ambrose and Lorenz 1990: 10). Behavioral Correlates
Resource Structure-Unpredictable and Scarce
Residential mobility Territorial strategy Information exchange Group size Population density Diet breadth
Very high, opportunistic Undefended, very permeable High Very small Very low Very high Archaeological Correlates
Occupation site intensity Macro-regional assemblage variability Raw material sources Intra-site spatial organization Faunal and floral diversity
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Very low at home base High stylistic uniformity Local and distant exotics Poorly structured Very high, mostly plant
101
______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r V eth
Pleistocene Sites of the Western Desert The sites of Serpent’s Glen (O’Connor et al. 1998), Puritjarra (Smith 1989, 1996), and Kulpi Mara (Thorley 1988a, 1988b) all have occupational deposits dating to before 23,000 bp (see Figure 6.1). While this sample is not large it does provide early sites from a range of different settings located within and on the margins of the Western Desert. All dates discussed here are uncalibrated. Serpent’s Glen rock shelter is located within quartz sandstone ranges among an expanse of low relief dunes. The uplands contain several springs that provide reliable and potable water (O’Connor et al. 1998). Excavation revealed three major stratigraphic layers; the lower layer has a minimum date of 23,550 bp and contains a sparse assemblage of stone artifacts, ocher, charcoal, and bone. The
Figure 6.1 Location of the Western Desert showing key sites mentioned in the text (after Gould 1980, 1985; Morse 1994; O’Connor et al. 1998; Smith 1989; Thorley 1998a; Veth 1993a, 1993b).
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
102
______________________________________________________________________________
C y c l es o f A r i d i t y a n d H u m a n M o b i l i t y
middle layer is culturally sterile, while the upper layer dates from 4,710 bp to the modern period and contains over 98 percent of the site’s lithic materials, in addition to significant quantities of ocher, charcoal, bone, and minor quantities of emu eggshell, bird eggshell, and macrofloral remains. Puritjarra rock shelter is located within a western outlier of the central Australian ranges, and has a major permanent water source nearby. Puritjarra has a Pleistocene layer that contains a sparse flaked stone, charcoal, ocher, and bone assemblage dated to as early as 32,000 bp (Smith et al. 1998). While occupation at Puritjarra has been argued by Smith (1989) to span the subsequent period of 22,000 to 13,000 bp coinciding with peak glacial aridity, this has been challenged by Hiscock (1988) and Thorley (1998a, 1998b) on both theoretical and empirical grounds. Sparse assemblages are certainly registered by 12,000 bp and by approximately 6,500 bp the quantity of flaked stone increases substantially with an efflorescence in both quantity and breadth of cultural materials dating to the last millennium. Kulpi Mara is a large sandstone rock shelter on the escarpment of the central Australian ranges and, in contrast to the two previous sites, has no permanent water source nearby (Thorley 1998a, 1998b). The excavation revealed three layers, the lower dating to approximately 24,000 to 30,000 bp. Cultural assemblages in this unit are typically sparse. A chronological hiatus is then recorded with the middle layer dating from approximately 12,000 bp, when an increase in site use is registered. The middle of the upper layer is dated to 2,500 bp with the upper spits containing abundant lithics, charcoal, and also ocher, wooden and resin artifacts, and spun fibers. At all three sites the passage of time coinciding with peak glacial aridity is registered as either culturally sterile sediments or very slow rates of sediment and artifact accumulation, suggesting abandonment or, at most, several minor episodes of ephemeral occupation (cf. Thorley 1998b). This pattern is evident in other desert lowland sites surrounding the Western Desert, such as at Noala Cave which dates to 27,000 bp and Mandu Mandu rock shelter dating from 34,000 bp (Morse 1994; O’Connor et al. 1999; Veth 1993b, 1995; see Figure 6.1). As a first step it is necessary to establish that some level of resource stress was experienced at these sites and ideally this should be independent from other categories of archaeological data. This is required to support assumptions that patchy and unpredictable resource structure in the terminal Pleistocene would have resulted in stress to Western Desert foragers.
An Independent Index of Stress It is possible to calculate an independent index of relative protein stress from selected Western Desert and central Australian sites. On the basis of ethnographic accounts indicating that Western Desert Aborigines pulverized whole game and extracted marrow to maximize protein yield, high levels of bone reduction in arid zone sites are seen to be an indicator of protein stress. Where these patterns can be reliably associated with processing and pulverizing of game, as opposed to
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
103
______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r V eth
taphonomic factors, then it is possible to consider relative levels of stress (Gould 1978, 1996; Haley 1999; O’Connor et al. 1998). Indices of fragmentation (IoF) can be calculated for combined fractions of economic fauna from all spits (total bone weight/number of fragments) for the sites of Kaalpi, Serpent’s Glen, and the Holocene-aged sites of Puntutjarpa and Intitjikula (see Figure 6.1). Although Holocene data are included here, the sites show long-term consistencies in the degree of bone comminution (cf. Gould 1996: 74, 81). A related index of protein stress is found in the ratio of broken to whole macropod teeth. Breakage of these robust elements has been documented as a byproduct of the crushing and pulverizing of crania and mandibles (Gould 1996; O’Connor et al. 1998). Paleoenvironmental models for the Australian arid zone would predict for greater resource scarcity and unpredictability, and hence stress, in the lowlands of the Western Desert and less so on the periphery and within the central Australian ranges (e.g. Gould 1991; Ross et al. 1992; Veth 1993a). It follows that the degree of bone reduction should be greater within the lowlands and this should be registered in lower values for IoF and higher ratios of broken to whole macropod teeth. Some consideration must be made of relative species distributions between sites, although this is problematic as the levels of taxonomic assignment are low, ranging between 8.8 to 12 percent. There is some evidence that the proportion of larger macropods present on the lowland sites is lower than those of the ranges and this will likely serve to inflate the differences in IoFs between these sites (cf. Gould 1996). These predictions of relative protein stress are generally met when the faunal assemblages are analyzed. The sites of Serpent’s Glen and the nearby site of Kaalpi, both located within expansive dunefields, register IoFs of 0.063 gm/fragment and 0.104 gm/fragment, respectively (Haley 1999; O’Connor et al. 1998). Over 98 percent of macropod teeth are broken. The site of Puntutjarpa to the east registers an average IoF of 0.530 gm/fragment with 100 percent of macropod teeth being fractured. In contrast, the site of Intirtekwerle within the central Australian ranges registers an IoF of 0.500 gm/fragment (similar to Puntutjarpa), but only 60 percent of macropod teeth have been broken (see Table 6.2). A number of conclusions can be drawn from this comparison. Firstly, conditions of protein stress have obtained throughout the history of occupation at all of these Table 6.2 Values for Index of Fragmentation and macropod tooth breakage from the sites of Serpent’s Glen, Kaalpi, Puntutjarpa, and Intirtekwerle (from Gould 1996; Haley 1999; O’Connor et al. 1998). Site name
Index of fragmentation
% macropod teeth broken
Serpent’s Glen Kaalpi Puntutjarpa Intirtekwerle
0.063 0.104 0.530 0.500
100 >98 100 60
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
104
______________________________________________________________________________
C y c l es o f A r i d i t y a n d H u m a n M o b i l i t y
sites and are predicted to have been present also at the sites of Puritjarra and Kulpi Mara. Secondly, the cline in increasing protein stress away from the ranges lends support to models of marginality which predict that the highest levels of residential mobility will occur on the desert lowlands (cf. Smith 1989).
Archaeological Indices of High Residential Mobility The intensity of stone reduction On the assumption that occupation was by small groups and for a short duration it is expected that the intensity of reduction of locally available lithics will be relatively low. Locally available and abundant stone materials account for between 90 to 100 percent of the Pleistocene assemblages. The intensity of utilization of these materials is seen to be a product of occupation intensity and to reflect group mobility. Assuming that assemblage variability can be strongly determined by occupation intensity (after Rolland and Dibble 1990), this factor is examined by considering changes in artifact discard rates (Smith 1988), degree of artifact curation (cf. Shott 1989: 26), and the presence of economizing strategies, such as bipolar knapping (after Hiscock 1996). The number of artifacts clearly ascribed to the pre-glacial layers of the Western Desert sites is small and contrasts, in two of the three cases, markedly with numbers of artifacts from the Holocene units. Estimates of artifact discard rates for the three sites are provided in Table 6.3. Differences of this high order in themselves must indicate that different settlement patterns have operated through time. With reference to curation at Serpent’s Glen there are no retouched/utilized artifacts in the Pleistocene layers (O’Connor et al. 1998). At Puritjarra there are only amorphous retouched artifacts in Layer 2 and these are substantially larger than those in the upper Holocene layer (Smith 1988); see Table 6.4. Size reduction is evident in both local (silcrete/silicified sandstone) and exotic (chert/chalcedony) raw materials (see Table 6.5). There are only three retouched/utilized artifacts in the pre-LGM layer from Kulpi Mara (Square C) with Thorley (1998a: 235) concluding: ‘‘Use of local materials appears to have been predominantly opportunistic and the production Table 6.3 Estimated artifact discard rates from pre-LGM and Holocene layers from Pleistocene Western Desert sites. Site Serpent’s Glen Puritjarra Kulpi Mara
Pre-LGM number of artifacts/kyr
Late Holocene number of artifacts/kyr
5 6 140
1600 2087 250
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
105
______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r V eth Table 6.4 Mean weight of amorphous retouched artifacts in grams, Puritjarra (after Smith 1988: 119). Pit Layer Ia Layer Ib Layer II
N9
N10
QR9
Z10
Total number
6.9 18.2 17.0
8.0 8.0 75.5
37.7 10.8 691.7
14.1 8.0 104.1
51 33 9
Table 6.5 Mean weights of total artifacts in grams, Puritjarra, Pit N19 (after Smith 1988: table 4.10). Pit
Local lithics
Exotic lithics
2.3 3.5 24.0
0.7 1.1 15.3
Layer Ia Layer Ib Layer II
of whole silcrete/quartzite flakes . . . independent of [later] backed artifact manufacture and discard.’’ The combination of low numbers of artifacts and their low degree of modification attests to a low intensity of site occupation with expedient use of locally available raw materials. It is possible that tools brought into these sites as part of a high residential mobility pattern were made from higher quality ‘‘exotics’’ and that these were extensively curated and transported until a preferred resupply zone was encountered, thereby increasing the expedient use of local lithics. Available data from Puritjarra and Kulpi Mara do not presently allow an assessment of reduction stages; however, the small assemblage from Serpent’s Glen is typical of other assemblages in the Western Desert dominated by early stages of reduction of local raw materials (see O’Connor et al. 1998; Veth 1993a). None of the site reports indicate any bipolar reduction in the Pleistocene, argued to be an indicator of lower residential mobility from other parts of northern Australia (Hiscock 1996).
The Diversity of Artifacts A number of studies have illustrated that there is an inverse relationship between assemblage diversity and level of residential mobility (cf. Andrefsky 1998: 204; Shott 1986: 25). This relationship is shown in Figure 6.2. Assemblage diversity equates with the number of artifact types (tools) recovered from an assemblage. A more sensitive index of technological diversity may be defined by measuring the number of tool classes used during daily activities (Shott 1986: 23). Shott’s analysis was based on artifact data and mobility information from 12 ethnographic studies of hunter-gatherer groups. Base camps (after Binford 1980) where a more logistical strategy was practiced showed a positive correlation between artifact diversity and length of stay.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
106
______________________________________________________________________________
C y c l es o f A r i d i t y a n d H u m a n M o b i l i t y
Figure 6.2 Proposed relationship between artifact diversity and residential mobility (Andrefsky 1998: figure 8.5, adapted from Shott 1986: 25).
Andrefsky (1998: 206) contrasts this pattern with the low diversity expected at task specific sites and states: Although no ethnographic data on artifact diversity were available for special-taskoriented or field camps, it would be logical to assume that special-task-oriented camps, such as hunt camps, plant collecting stations, or butchering sites, would have a relatively low diversity of artifacts. In other words, if a narrow range of activities were performed at a particular location, one would expect to find a relatively low number of artifact types.
Such data are available, however, from ethnoarchaeological work carried out by the author from 1986 to 2004 with Martu Aborigines of the Western Desert (see Veth 1987, 1989, 1993a, 1996, unpublished notes). A range of artifact sites which had been used by Martu before contact with Europeans from the 1920s to the 1960s (cf. Tonkinson 1991) was analyzed. Because of these historical associations, localities could be reliably ascribed, at least for the historic period, as (a) major residential base camps which were used for aggregations; (b) smaller residential camps used predominantly in an ephemeral mode; and finally, (c) those which were clearly taskspecific or field camps. A combination of high water permanency and high diversity of economic plant species predicted for greater permanency of occupation at sites and often by larger groups of people. Localities near ephemeral water sources and less diverse plant patches witnessed the highest residential mobility. Assumed aggregation sites located near permanent waters had the highest values for artifact diversity, the highest proportion of exotic materials, evidenced a greater proportion of artifacts in later reduction stages, contained more tools exhibiting high levels of curation and recycling, and had significantly more basal grinding stones (Veth 1993a, 1996). The sites used by Martu custodians as ephemeral residences and which were referred to as ‘‘passing-through places’’ generally reflected the converse pattern.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
107
______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r V eth
I am not suggesting here that the late Holocene assemblages are directly comparable to those of the Pleistocene. Rather, I argue that the material outcomes of different mobility configurations in the Western Desert are tangible and do not support previous models arguing for the homogeneity of residential sites (Hayden 1976). Tools identified in sites which had been used by Martu in the historic period included retouched/utilized flakes, amorphous grindstones, millstones, groundedge axes, backed blades, backed geometrics, tula adzes, and burren adzes. Artifact diversity values for these three classes of sites are shown in Table 6.6. It was expected that the Pleistocene assemblages of the three Western Desert sites would have diversity values closer to those of the ephemeral and task specific sites in contrast to the base camps. It must be noted, however, that the introduction of new standardized tools from the mid-Holocene, such as the adzes and backed pieces, will inflate the diversity values for the Holocene sites (cf. Hiscock and Veth 1991). Diversity values for the Pleistocene-aged sites are provided in Table 6.7. The tools located from these three sites may be incorporated into the category of retouched/utilized flakes (referred to as ‘‘amorphous retouched’’ by Smith 1988: 126) where clear evidence of modification to a blank is visible through retouch/ use-wear. These artifacts are made on a wide variety of blank morphologies and are consistent with the expedient tools recorded by Hayden (1979) from the Western Desert. Another category is also recognized here: primary flakes that may have microscopic evidence for use-wear. This is simply a cautionary category that serves to inflate the artifact diversity values in lieu of use-wear analyses that are clearly in order. These values are clearly very low and stand in stark contrast to those recorded from the major aggregation sites, as shown in Table 6.6. It should be stressed that sample size effect and the known increase in formal tools by the mid-Holocene will serve to exaggerate this difference. It is reasonable to conclude on the basis of the
Table 6.6 Artifact diversity from Western Desert sites (from Veth 1993a, in prep.). Site type
Number of sites
Artifact diversity
9 34 15
8 4 2
Residential base camp Ephemeral residence Task specific
Table 6.7 Artifact diversity values for Pleistocene assemblages from Western Desert sites. Site
Layer
Artifact diversity
Serpent’s Glen Puritjarra Kulpi Mara
3 2 3
1 2 2
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
108
______________________________________________________________________________
C y c l es o f A r i d i t y a n d H u m a n M o b i l i t y
available data, however, that there is a low diversity of tools in the Pleistocene assemblages.
The Presence of Local and Exotic Lithics It is expected that large foraging ranges associated with a high residential mobility strategy will result in the curation, maintenance, and occasional discard of lithics which may come from distant sources and hence be termed exotic – especially where suitable alternative sources are not readily available. The presence of abundant though highly variable quality silcretes and quartzites in the vicinity of all three Western Desert sites will have provided the range of blanks generally required for expedient maintenance tools in the Western Desert. The majority of artifacts from the three sites are from local materials (90–100 percent), with the presence of exotics likely a reflection of the scale of territorial range (Binford and Stone 1985 vs Gould 1985). Increases in the proportion of exotics are associated with the later appearance of standardized hafted tools, such as tula adzes and backed blades, by the midHolocene (e.g., Hiscock 1994; Hiscock and Veth 1991; Thorley 1998a: 235) and particularly during the subsequent emergence in the late Holocene of what are argued to be intensifying long distance exchange and ritual networks (Thorley 1998a). Major aggregation sites that served as centers of ‘‘production’’ for such regional networks evidence a significant increase in the proportion of exotics. This increase in exotics is argued to be a reflection of longer distance exchange networks and the higher number of source areas from which participating groups traveled (e.g. Cane 1984; Thorley and Gunn 1996; Veth 1993a).
The Quantity of Grinding Material Pleistocene assemblages from arid Australia rarely contain seed grinders (e.g., Gorecki et al. 1997) and this may be linked to a range of factors, including the function and permanency of site use, assemblage size effect, and a general lack of intensive seed/food processing (see, however, Edwards and O’Connell 1995). Grindstones conforming to a wide range of morphologies are commonly found in stratified contexts from the arid and semi-arid zone from after approximately 3,500 bp (Smith 1986). This has been argued to represent one of the major transitions in the economy and settlement of arid land peoples as they shift towards the exploitation of unpredictable yet densely clustered resources, with consequent changes in mobility strategy (Thorley 1998a). At the site of Serpent’s Glen, Veth and O’Connor (1996) have recorded hundreds of whole and fragmented formal millstones, mullers, and amorphous grindstones on the surface and surrounding sandplains which are assumed to date to the late Holocene. In contrast, there are no ground artifacts in the Pleistocene layer of Serpent’s Glen. Equally, there are no grinding implements before the midHolocene in the sites of Puritjarra and Kulpi Mara (Thorley 1998a: 323). There is abundant ethnohistorical evidence (cf. Smith 1986) that seed grinding stations
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
109
______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r V eth
were established at major aggregation sites and that these helped to underpin larger gatherings of people for extended periods of time. The mobility configuration of such sites was clearly more towards a logistical strategy. The lack of any seed grinding materials in the Pleistocene layers of the three Western Desert sites is consistent with their use as ephemeral occupation sites. Data collected by Veth (1993a) from occupation sites adjacent to water sources of varying permanency show a clear correlation between water permanency and number of intact grindstones (see Table 6.8). Martu Aborigines noted that the sites adjacent to more reliable waters had acted as major aggregation venues and that groups from many linguistic affiliations had come to such places, sometimes traveling hundreds of kilometers in small family groups.
Stylistic Uniformity of Rock Art Patterning in art has been used by a range of researchers to indicate aggregation and dispersion patterns resting largely on interpretations of inside/outside (exclusive/inclusive) access to information networks (Conkey 1980; Galt-Smith 1997; Gould 1980). The high residential mobility scenario of the Pleistocene would predict for high stylistic uniformity and the predominant use of outside symbols. Both the Serpent’s Glen site, and the sites of Kaalpi and Durba Springs to the north in the Little Sandy Desert, have extensive rock art galleries comprising both petroglyphs and pictographs. Although dating the rock art is in its early stages, the majority of paintings are thought to date to the late Holocene, with ocher specimens from the site of Kaalpi dating from 1,300 bp and essentially absent from before this time (Haley 1999: 61). Recent dates from a shelter with paintings at Durba Springs also support a relatively recent origin for the paintings (Veth in prep.). In contrast, a large number of the engravings occur on quartz sandstone panels which have been significantly weathered, chemically altered, and in some cases covered in very thick coatings of natural varnish and other crusts. It is quite likely that many of these engraved motifs date to the Pleistocene. Preliminary recording of motifs at these three sites suggests there are significant differences in the style, spatial patterning, and frequency of different classes of motifs between the engravings and the paintings. It is suggested that these reflect a change in site function from the Pleistocene to the late Holocene (Veth et al. 2001). This is seen to be due to their changing nature as ephemeral residential sites in the Pleistocene to major aggregation sites in the late Holocene. The engravings include
Table 6.8 Mean number of whole grindstones located at sites adjacent to permanent, semi-permanent, and ephemeral water sources (from Veth 1993a). Water permanency Permanent Semi-permanent Ephemeral
Number of sites
Mean number of grindstones
8 23 16
16.625 4.739 1.188
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
110
______________________________________________________________________________
C y c l es o f A r i d i t y a n d H u m a n M o b i l i t y
a range of tracks, circles, concentric circles, and arcs, in addition to a range of naturalistic motifs including macropods, marsupials, and various birds. Noticeable are some very large anthropomorphs which have extensive infilling and the socalled archaic faces – disembodied faces which have a distribution through the arid zone from the coastal Pilbara to the Cleland Hills of central Australia, where Puritjarra is located (Dix 1977; see Chapter 7, this volume). The geometric motifs, archaic faces, and large anthropomorphs can be found in differing proportions at Kaalpi, Serpent’s Glen, and Durba Hills. The majority of the motifs appear to refer to foraging themes with the geometric motifs typical of those that have been documented as acting as mnemonic devices for mapping both water hole and ancestral routes at the regional level (after Gould 1980). This is assumed to reflect an outside or inclusive symbolic configuration. In contrast, the paintings display greater assemblage diversity and contain a higher proportion of complex designs, although many of the fundamental geometric motifs are also present. Several Martu with whom I have worked had participated in ceremonies and gatherings at Kaalpi and Durba before contact with Europeans and were able to provide some mythological referants for the figurative paintings. Very detailed anthropomorphs are depicted with expanded headdresses, these only being recorded from this specific locality of the Western Desert – as such they may be signifiers of corporate identity. The use of inside/outside symbols is consistent with the increasing role of these sites for aggregation, rather than dispersion (cf. Galt-Smith 1997).
Changes in Sedimentary Records A shift from ephemeral occupation of a site under a high residential mobility regime to greater permanency may be registered in the matrix of a deposit. Such a process has been identified in the Pleistocene-aged occupation horizons at Puritjarra. Smith (1989: 99) concluded, a major change in the use of the shelter is clear from changes in the character of the sediments, with large amounts of finely divided charcoal and fine rock fragments and a more open fabric.
Equally, short duration and low intensity occupation episodes are more likely to leave intact living surfaces due to longer periods of site abandonment and ongoing sedimentation processes and the decreased likelihood of disturbance during subsequent occupations (cf. O’Connor et al. 1993). Shorter site visits will also result in lower indices for artifact breakage due to treadage, as has been demonstrated by Hiscock (1988) for the Colless Creek sites.
Changes in Ocher Provenance The study of ocher distributions from Puritjarra dating to the terminal Pleistocene demonstrates changing provenance (Smith et al. 1998). From 32,000 to 13,000 bp
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
111
______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r V eth
the red ocher source is located 125 km across major dunefields of the Western Desert. The occupants of Puritjarra were either moving over large portions of the desert lowlands to obtain ocher or were in contact with groups that had access to this quarry. The pattern changes significantly after 13,000 bp and particularly between 7,500 and 1,000 bp, with the ocher supply shifting to a much closer source located in the central Australian ranges. More intensive use of the rock shelter and increased quantities of ocher are registered after 7,500 bp. Smith et al. (1998: 287) synthesize both the changes in ocher source and other archaeological signatures of territoriality to conclude: If we see the production of pigment art . . . at the site as reflecting an increasing need to assert corporate rights and relationships to the site, and the more restricted catchment reflected in the ochers as reflecting an actual reduction in residential mobility, we get a picture of a shift from an open spatially extensive pattern of land use to a more closed system with smaller group territories after 13,000 bp.
Continuity of Occupation at Sites The three Western Desert sites all evidence a decrease, if not an absence, of occupational material during the LGM (O’Connor et al. 1998: 16; Smith 1988: table 4.4; Thorley 1998a: 239). At least two of the sites are located adjacent to permanent water sources, a rare commodity in the Western Desert at any time of its human occupation. The expectation for groups continuing to occupy a region as conditions became harsher and semi-permanent water sources are lost would be for greater tethering at permanent waters. This is not the case for any of the three sites. As Thorley (1998a: 323) concludes: As a site near permanent water, Puritjarra would be expected to show indications of more intensive occupation around the time ephemerally watered sites such as Kulpi Mara ceased to be occupied. This would be consistent with a model of populations falling back on more reliable ‘‘refuge’’ sites. Yet like Kulpi Mara, Puritjarra also shows a slowing of sediment and artifact deposition rates during the glacial maximum.
The late glacial record from all three sites sits more comfortably with groups who have restricted their territorial range rather than those who continue to occupy a landscape employing a high residential mobility strategy.
Implications of Mobility Indicators In this chapter I have examined eight different lines of archaeological evidence which may be used to infer residential mobility from Pleistocene assemblages in the Western Desert. Such assemblages are relatively intractable when compared to similar aged assemblages from tropical northern Australia. Clearly, multiple lines of evidence are preferable and can act as potential cross-checks on each other. The Pleistocene assemblages conform to the behavioral and archaeological predictions
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
112
______________________________________________________________________________
C y c l es o f A r i d i t y a n d H u m a n M o b i l i t y
of Ambrose and Lorenz (1990: 10), where the archaeological correlates of huntergatherer behaviors in an unpredictable and scarce resource regime are defined. I have argued that the identification of changes in configurations of residential mobility is central to understanding variability in the assemblages of these three Western Desert sites. Assumptions that early occupation was by small and highly mobile groups finds empirical support in this analysis. Independent lines of evidence for resource stress, such as the Index of Fragmentation, help to calibrate differences in resource scarcity and hence stress from different regions. Detailed analyses of the intensity of stone reduction, the provenance of stone artifacts and ocher, the diversity of tools and art, and sedimentary records all have the potential to inform on mobility strategies. It is clear from this review that flexibility in mobility patterns, including territorial abandonment and strategy switching, will always have been a necessary part of risk minimization in Western Desert foraging behavior.
References Ambrose, S. H. and Lorenz, K. G. 1990: Social and ecological models of the Middle Stone Age in southern Africa. In P. Mellars (ed.), The Emergence of Modern Humans, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 3–33. Andrefsky, W. 1998: Lithics: Macroscopic Approaches to Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Binford, L. R. 1980: Willow smoke and dog’s tails: Hunter-gatherer settlement systems and archaeological site formation. American Antiquity, 45, 4–20. Binford, L. R. and Stone, N. M. 1985: ‘‘Righteous rocks’’ and Richard Gould: Some observations on misguided ‘‘debate.’’ American Antiquity, 50, 151–3. Cane, S. 1984: Desert camps: A case study of stone artifacts and Aboriginal behavior in the Western Desert. Unpublished PhD thesis, Canberra: The Australian National University. Conkey, M. W. 1980: The identification of hunter-gatherer aggregation sites: The case of Altamira. Current Anthropology, 21, 609–30. Dix, W. 1977: Facial representations in Pilbara rock engravings. In P. J. Ucko (ed.), Form in Indigenous Art, London: Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies Prehistory and Material Culture Series no. 13, Duckworth, 277–85. Edwards, D. A. and O’Connell, J. F. 1995: Broad spectrum diets in arid Australia. Antiquity, 69, 769–83. Galt-Smith, B. 1997: Motives for motifs: Identifying aggregation and dispersion settlement patterns in the rock art assemblages of central Australia. Unpublished BA (Hons) thesis, Armidale: University of New England. Gorecki, P., Grant, M., O’Connor, S., and Veth, P. 1997: The morphology, function, and antiquity of grinding implements in northern Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 32, 141–50. Gould, R. A. 1978: Archaeological signatures of stress in the Australian Desert. Los Angeles: Unpublished paper presented at the 1978 Annual Meeting of the American Anthropological Association. Gould, R. A. 1980: Living Archaeology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Gould, R. A. 1985: The empiricist strikes back: Reply to Binford. American Antiquity, 50 (3), 638–44.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
113
______________________________________________________________________________
Pe t e r V eth Gould, R. A. 1991: Arid land foraging as seen from Australia: Adaptive models and behavioral realities. Oceania, 62, 12–33. Gould, R. A. 1996: Faunal reduction at Puntutjarpa rock shelter, Warburton Ranges, Western Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 31 (2), 72–86. Haley, M. 1999: Kaalpi: Investigation of archaeological assemblages from the Calvert Ranges Western Desert, Western Australia. Unpublished BA (Hons) thesis, Townsville: James Cook University. Hayden, B. 1976: Australian Western Desert lithic technology: An ethno-archaeological study of variability in material culture. Unpublished PhD thesis, Toronto: University of Toronto. Hayden, B. 1979: Paleolithic Reflections. Canberra: Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies. Hiscock, P. 1988: Prehistoric settlement patterns and artifact manufacture at Lawn Hill, northwest Queensland. Unpublished PhD thesis, St Lucia: University of Queensland. Hiscock, P. 1994: Technological responses to risk in Holocene Australia. Journal of World Prehistory, 8 (3), 267–92. Hiscock, P. 1996: Mobility and technology in the Kakadu coastal wetlands. Indo-Pacific Prehistory Association Bulletin, 15 (2), 151–7. Hiscock, P. and Veth, P. 1991: Change in the Australian Desert Culture: A reanalysis of tulas from Puntutjarpa. World Archaeology, 22, 332–45. Kelly, R. L. 1992: Mobility/sedentism: Concepts, archaeological measures, and effects. Annual Review of Anthropology, 21, 43–66. Kelly, R. L. 1995: The Foraging Spectrum. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Mabbutt, J. A. 1977: Desert Landforms vol. 2. Canberra: The Australian National University Press. Morse, K. 1994: West Side Story: Towards a prehistory of the Cape Range Peninsula. Unpublished PhD thesis, Perth: University of Western Australia. O’Connor, S., Veth, P., and Barham, A. 1999: Cultural versus natural explanations for lacunae in Aboriginal occupation deposits in northern Australia. Quaternary International, 59, 61–70. O’Connor, S., Veth, P., and Campbell, C. 1998: Serpent’s Glen rock shelter: Report of the first Pleistocene-aged occupation sequence from the Western Desert. Australian Archaeology, 46, 12–21. O’Connor, S., Veth, P., and Hubbard, N. 1993: Changing interpretations of postglacial human subsistence and demography in Sahul. In M. A. Smith, M. Spriggs, and B. Fankhauser (eds), Sahul in Review: The Archaeology of Australia, New Guinea, and Island Melanesia, Canberra: The Australian National University, 95–105. Rolland, N. and Dibble, H. L. 1990: A new synthesis of Middle Paleolithic variability. American Antiquity, 55 (3), 480–99. Ross, A., Donnelly, T., and Wasson, R. 1992: The peopling of the arid zone: Human–environment interactions. In J. Dodson (ed.), The Naı¨ve Lands, London: Longman, 76–114. Shott, M. J. 1986: Technological organization and settlement mobility: An ethnographic examination. Journal of Anthropological Research, 42, 15–51. Shott, M. J. 1989: On tool class use lives and the formation of archaeological assemblages. American Antiquity, 54 (1), 9–30. Smith, M. A. 1986: The antiquity of seed grinding in central Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 21, 29–39. Smith, M. A. 1988: The pattern and timing of prehistoric settlement in central Australia. Unpublished PhD thesis, Armidale: University of New England.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
114
______________________________________________________________________________
C y c l es o f A r i d i t y a n d H u m a n M o b i l i t y Smith, M. A. 1989: The case for a resident human population in the central Australian ranges during full glacial aridity. Archaeology in Oceania, 24, 93–105. Smith, M. A. 1996: Prehistory and human ecology in central Australia: An archaeological perspective. In S. R. Morton and D. J. Mulvaney (eds), Exploring Central Australia: Society, Environment and the 1894 Horn Expedition, Chipping Norton: Surry Beatty and Sons, 61–73. Smith, M. A., Fankhauser, B., and Jercher, M. 1998: The changing provenance of red ocher at Puritjarra rock shelter, central Australia: Late Pleistocene to present. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society, 64, 275–92. Smith, M. A., Prescott, J. R., and Head, M. J. 1997: Comparison of 14C and luminescence chronologies at Puritjarra rock shelter, central Australia. Quaternary Science Reviews, 16, 1–22. Thorley, P. B. 1998a: Shifting location, shifting scale: A regional landscape approach to the prehistoric archaeology of the Palmer River catchment, central Australia. Unpublished PhD thesis, Darwin: Northern Territory University. Thorley, P. B. 1998b: Pleistocene settlement in the Australian arid zone: Occupation of an inland riverine landscape in the central Australian ranges. Antiquity, 72, 34–45. Thorley, P. B. and Gunn, B. 1996: Archaeological research from the eastern border lands of the Western Desert. Canberra: Unpublished paper presented at the Western Desert Origins Workshop, Australian Linguistic Institute. Tonkinson, R. 1991: The Martu Aborigines: Living the Dream in Australia’s Desert. Fort Worth, TX: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston. Varien, M. D. 1999: Sedentism and Mobility in a Social Landscape. Tucson: University of Arizona Press. Veth, P. 1987: Martujarra prehistory: Variation in arid zone adaptations. Australian Archaeology, 25, 102–11. Veth, P. 1989: Islands in the interior: A model for the colonization of Australia’s arid zone. Archaeology in Oceania, 24, 81–92. Veth, P. 1993a: Islands in the Interior: The Dynamics of Prehistoric Adaptations within the Arid Zone of Australia. International Monographs in Prehistory, Archaeology Series no. 3, Ann Arbor, MI. Veth, P. 1993b: The Aboriginal occupation of the Montebello Islands, northwest Australia. Australian Aboriginal Studies, 2, 39–50. Veth, P. 1995: Aridity and settlement in northwest Australia. Antiquity, 69, 733–46. Veth, P. 1996: Current archaeological evidence from the Little and Great Sandy Deserts. In P. Veth and P. Hiscock (eds), Archaeology of Northern Australia: Regional Perspectives, Tempus: Archaeology and Material Culture Studies in Anthropology no. 4, Anthropology Museum, University of Queensland, St Lucia, 50–65. Veth, P. 2000: Origins of the Western Desert language: Convergence in linguistic and archaeological space and time models. Archaeology in Oceania, 35 (1), 11–19. Veth, P. in prep.: Durba Springs and the emergence of the Wati language. Veth, P. and O’Connor, S. 1996: A preliminary analysis of basal grindstones from the Carnarvon Range, Little Sandy Desert. Australian Archaeology, 43, 20–2. Veth, P., Smith, M., and Haley, M. 2001: Kaalpi: The archaeology of a sandstone outlier in the Western Desert. Australian Archaeology, 52, 9–17. Yellen, J. E. 1976: Long-term hunter-gatherer adaptation to desert environments: A biogeographical perspective. World Archaeology, 8 (3), 262–74.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
115
______________________________________________________________________________
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Archaic Faces to Headdresses The Changing Role of Rock Art Across the Arid Zone Jo McDonald
Introduction The art systems of the Australian arid zone have long been thought of as culturally and stylistically homogeneous. Rock art, sand paintings, shields, body painting, and headdresses have been seen as different expressions of the same graphic systems from a region which is essentially culturally homogeneous (Tonkinson 1991). The rock art, in particular, is seen as a longstanding graphic tradition (Rosenfeld 2002). The Western Desert peoples engaged in a settlement pattern marked by high residential mobility across vast territories. This kind of mobility was dynamic. The environment required periodic spatial dispersal and aggregation. This necessitated maintaining relationships with people in one’s own residence group as well as with those from ‘‘far away’’ (Myers 2002). This extreme flexibility in mobility is seen to underpin a raft of risk minimizing strategies in the Western Desert (Veth 2000a). It is generally understood that this type of mobility was accommodated by widely ramified open social networks with institutionalized kinship, marriage exchange, and ceremonial organization, and reciprocal rights to country. These different institutions of identity and exchange are the media for sustaining political relations over space and time in conditions that combine aggregation and dispersal (Myers 2002: 47). A common signal for this type of mediated social network would be the homogeneity of the arid zone art systems (Jochim 1983; Munn 1966; C. Smith 1989; Wiessner 1990). The central Australian and Western Deserts encompass lands which fall within the ‘‘Western Desert Cultural Bloc,’’ its people all speaking the Western Desert language (see Figure 7.1). The current linguistic model (McConvell 1996) sees this language moving from northwest to east across the arid zone possibly as recently as 1,500– 1,000 years ago (Veth 2000b). It has been argued (Veth and McDonald 2002) that
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
116
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s
alliance networks must have already been in place throughout the Western Desert to enable the rapid transmission of this language. By 5,000 years ago, then, the domestic and totemic landscapes would have been established across all landscapes and habitats of the Western Desert. Implicit in this proposition is that such long distance exchange networks were present well before the Holocene, and could have been in operation from the earliest period of occupation ca. 30,000 bp. Australia is the most arid continent on earth and the Western Desert arguably its most marginal populated landscape. A paucity of permanent water, absence of coordinated drainage, high temperatures and patchy resources are factors in this marginality. Despite this, we know that humans have lived in this region for at least 25,000 years. Key sites such as Serpent’s Glen, Puritjarra, Katampul, and further afield at Kulpi Mara and Allen’s Cave (see Figure 7.1) have evidence for occupation between 30,000–22,000 bp. These sites have varying records for subsequent occupation during the peak aridity of the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM). All sequences, however, register occupation from 5,000 years ago and at the majority of stratified
Jalijbang
tC
k.
KIMBERLEY PLATEAU
TANAMI DESERT
Forte
sue
ey R.
MACDONELL RANGES
R.
HAMMERSLEY RANGES Ashb urto nR i v er Gascoyne River
Lake Disappointment
Cleland Hills
Durba Springs Kaalpi
GIBSON DESERT
Puritjarra Kulpl Mara
Serpents Glen
Alice Springs
SIMPSON DESERT
Puntutjarpa
iver
GREAT VICTORIA DESERT
M
ur
ch iso nR
St
ur
De Gr
Burrup Penninsula
GREAT SANDY DESERT
N U L L A R B O R
P L A I N
PERTH
Approximate boundary of the Western Desert 0
1000 km
Figure 7.1 The Western Desert in the context of the Australian arid zone (after Veth 2000b).
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
117
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d
sites there are increases in discard rates and changes in lithic technology during the last 2,000 years through to the contact period. All arid zone researchers agree that Aboriginal culture has undergone significant transformation during this recent period (O’Connor et al. 1998; Smith 1996; Thorley 1998; Veth 1993). Ongoing archaeological research in the Western Desert indicates an early date for occupation of all landscapes by groups employing a high residential mobility pattern. Dynamism in both residential mobility and the nature and size of territories is assumed for much of this history. While there is some evidence for long distance exchange from the terminal Pleistocene onwards (e.g., pearl and baler shell from the coast; see Ackerman and Stanton 1994), there are signs of increasing circumscription of territory by the early to mid-Holocene (see Table 7.1). These trends are supported by ocher distribution patterns (Smith et al. 1998) and the efflorescence of group identifying behavior as inferred from the in situ development of regionally unique localized pigment art styles (Galt-Smith 1997; Gunn 1995, 2000a). A number of workers have now argued for changes in the function and intensity of occupation in major habitation sites during the last 2,000 years. Across the Western Desert for much of the year, groups are highly nucleated and dispersed across vast areas of country, and there is evidence for this being longterm behavioral patterning. Major aggregation events occur during times of resource stress, when group territories contract into refugia (Veth 1993), or for major ceremonial activities during periods of resource abundance. At such times, it has been predicted that there will be a greater diversity of activities, both everyday economic, as well as religious and ceremonial. These types of sites occur where there are permanent water sources and where there is a range of other resources nearby. Recent work at one such location indicates a long period of art production and a changing graphic structure over the period of this area’s occupation. The art of the Calvert Ranges – an outlier in the midst of the vast sand dunes of the Little Sandy Desert – will be used as exemplar of the issues raised in this chapter (see Figure 7.1). Table 7.1 Occupation phases and key elements for the Western Desert (after Veth 2000b). Phase 1 2
3 4 5
Features
Timing
Early colonization of Western Desert; all landscapes used with high residential mobility Period of instability in population levels; subregional abandonment and/or more opportunistic use of marginal lands Onset of climatic amelioration; territorial expansion from ‘‘refuges’’ Occupation of all desert ecosystems; (re)establishment of information networks Increased intensity of occupation; accelerated ritual and ceremonial cycles
>25,000–22,000 bp
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
118
22,000–13,000 bp
13,000–5,000 bp 5,000 bp to contact 1,500 bp to contact
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s
In this chapter I am interested in tracking diachronic changes in the artistic systems of the arid zone. I will explore how the role of art has transmogrified along with changes in stone tool technologies and subsistence strategies. The ways that art might be used to recognize changing mobility and territoriality are discussed. To demonstrate the changing graphic system over time and space, I will focus on a particular engraved figurative motif – the so-called ‘‘archaic face’’ – and look at its distribution, likely antiquity, and possible role within the Western Desert graphic system. The implications of a ‘‘shared’’ motif over a very extensive area and through many millennia will be examined. The way that this motif has been transformed, both into engraved anthropomorphic motifs and painted forms, is discussed. The development of headdresses as localized group identifying behavior across various arid desert and coastal style regions is shown to be part of the in situ development of local group identifying behaviors and a traceable factor in the changing graphic from the Panaramitee to a myriad of localized, mostly figurative styles.
The Arid Zone Art Graphic It is generally understood that Aboriginal painters from the arid zone paint their Dreamings (Gunn 1995, 2003; Kimber 1977; Layton 1992; Megaw 1982; Myers 1989, 2002; Spencer and Gillen 1899). Painters involved in the production of Western Desert acrylic art state that their paintings represent the Dreaming (Tjukurrpa) and their country (ngurra). They insist that the representations and images that they use ‘‘come from the Dreaming’’ (tjukurrtjana), and are more valuable than anything humans might invent (Myers 2002: 32–3). These paintings are representational and make use of a system of graphic signs: Munn’s ‘‘visual categories.’’ The iconic elements of this system are circles, arcs, lines, and meanders. In the Warlpiri graphic systems each visual element conveys a number of possible meanings. The ability to interpret the meaning depends on having the knowledge of relevant mythological information. It has been argued that this ambiguity provides a degree of this art’s aesthetic force (Morphy 1991). We have a relatively good appreciation of how rock art functioned in the recent past, based on solid anthropological and ethnographic evidence. The production of art is known to have taken place in a number of social contexts – from secular and casual, to sacred and ceremonial (Gunn 2000b). A number of researchers have noted the interconnectedness of art (or graphic) systems with other social institutions in this arid environment where the social networks were widely ramified. The interdependent relationship between the environment, belief systems, social structure, politics, and graphic system served to integrate and reinforce knowledge of the landscape into a holistic body of meanings; the graphic systems interweave the social, physiographic, and spiritual knowledge of society (Chewings 1909; Frederick 2000; Gillen 1968; Layton 1986, 1992; Myers 1986, 2002; C. Smith 1989). All members of society, regardless of levels of practice and cognizance of encoded meaning, have some involvement in the production and maintenance of the graphic system (Morphy 1989, 1991; Munn 1973).
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
119
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d
The graphic systems of the Western Desert were an important tool for promoting and controlling the exchange of information. They functioned at a multitude of levels, to identify and integrate as well as to demarcate social boundaries (David and Chant 1995; Dickens 1996; Frederick 2000; Galt-Smith 1997; Jestribek 1997; C. Smith 1989; and in other regions Lewis 1988; McDonald 1994, 1999). The application of a graphic system in the production of rock art served a number of functions and operated within a variety of social contexts (Frederick 2000). It was a way of marking place and concomitantly an individual’s affiliation to it; it had a significant storytelling or instructive context; it was recorded as being used in initiation ceremonies (Spencer and Gillen 1899), and also often provided a physical manifestation of an ancestral being or event. Rock art was also a way of ‘‘marking country’’ by the identification and naming of nodes in the social geography (Rosenfeld 2002).
Arid Zone Rock Art Research Rock art research in the Australian arid zone has had a recent efflorescence with a number of rock art specialists commencing or expanding research interests in this area (Frederick 2000; Galt-Smith 1997; Gunn 1995, 2000b; Rosenfeld 1993, 2002; Rosenfeld and Smith 2002; Ross 2003). There have also been a number of recent archaeological analyses of other arid zone graphic systems which have broadened our understanding of the social context of art production (Dickens 1996; Jestribek 1997; C. Smith 1989). Revealed by this increased research activity is the amount of localized stylistic variability apparent in rock art, particularly in the recent past, across the arid zone. This had not been documented previously, and like early views of Aboriginal occupation of this continent, people had identified only homogeneity and assumed a broad continuity and unchanging nature of rock art production across the arid zone (e.g., Dix 1977; Edwards 1968; Gould 1969; Maynard 1977; McCarthy 1979). Spencer and Gillen (1899) recorded that the primary difference between ‘‘ordinary and sacred’’ rock art was the location in which they were painted (Gunn 2000b, 2003). They commented: ‘‘motifs painted in sacred places were sacred: those painted elsewhere were not, even if visually the two motifs were identical’’ (Spencer and Gillen 1899: 618). Rosenfeld (2002) has pointed to a difference in design structure as indicative of which art was socially restricted. The Emily Gap (Ntherrke) painting site (which has recently had its restricted access lifted to allow public visitation) comprises a series of large formally structured bichrome designs, which Gunn (2003) calls Dreaming (or atywerrwenge) designs. Rosenfeld notes that striped designs such as these mark localities with powerful mythological significance to informants (Stirling 1896: 67). Projecting the mythological significance of motifs into the archaeological past is of course the nub of the problem (see Gunn 2003). This problem is of relevance when it comes to interpreting the social messaging potential of art in its social context (e.g., Wiessner 1990). Galt-Smith’s (1997) work on aggregation locales in central Australia demonstrates that the social context of the art’s production does affect social messaging.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
120
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s
For instance, pigment art (and engravings) that occur in rock shelters (or open contexts) where there is other evidence for domestic habitation (stone tools, hearths, grinding stones or patches, and so on) was art largely produced in a public context. On the other hand, pigment and engraved art less tangibly connected with habitation sites may equate with a less public art medium (see McDonald 1999). Of course, through time, sites may have periods where they were closed access and other episodes of open context. The longevity of rock art sites means that these can demonstrate changing social contexts and record past social geographies (Rosenfeld 2002; Rosenfeld and Smith 2002). Both the archaeological evidence, from occupation deposits and an art graphic that varies over time, can demonstrate such changes.
Rock Art Chronology Determining the age of rock art across the arid zone has not been well researched at this time, and we have few dates to help in establishing a firm chronology. There are, however, a number of dates from surrounding regions, including a small number of direct dates on art motifs and several dated art contexts. Broad temporal trends can be defined on the basis of the excavated evidence. Fairly recent developments have resulted in the successful use of Accelerator Mass Spectrometry (AMS) to date very small samples of carbon directly from rock art motifs (David et al. 1999; McDonald 2000; Watchman et al. 1997). Carbon is found within the actual art matrix (e.g., charcoal, organics in the binders) or as organics within skins which have formed on top of the art (e.g., oxalate crusts and desert varnish). Optically Stimulated Luminescence (OSL) has also been used in the Kimberley region to date mud-wasp nests which have been constructed on top of (Bradshaw style) pigment motifs (Roberts et al. 1997). We can assume that the pigment art of the arid zone is mostly relatively recent. Pigment and ochers generally do not have the same long-term survival potential presented by engravings as these materials fade and weather (although the probability of red pigment surviving is greater; see Cook et al. 1990; Roberts et al. 1997) and many rock shelter surfaces are unstable. Engravings, on the other hand, unless created on very soft friable surfaces, can survive for considerable periods of time. Most of the arid zone bedrock consists of case-hardened rocks. High levels of iron in the soils and extreme temperatures mean that the greatest threat to most engraved art comes from cracking of the matrix over time. At Puritjara, the use of ocher has been dated back to ca. 32,000 bp, and the earliest period of the site’s occupation. It has been argued that pigment use here was initially for body painting and that rock art production only commenced after 13,000 bp when a prevalence of ochers was located close to the back wall of the shelter (Smith et al. 1998; Rosenfeld and Smith 2002). While much of the arid zone pigment art is arguably recent, very old pigmented motifs are found in locations where there are good conditions for preservation. The Bradshaw figures in the Kimberley region have been dated to greater than 25,000 bp (Roberts et al. 1997)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
121
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d
and pigment on buried rock fragments at the Carpenter’s Gap rock shelter has been dated to >40,000 bp (O’Connor 1995). Pecked and highly weathered Panaramitee style engravings (after Maynard 1977) are found throughout virtually the entire arid zone. This longstanding graphic tradition comprises circles, tracks, lines, and arcs, and the occasional figurative motif – the same visual categories identified by Munn (1973) in contemporary Warlpiri iconography and recent arid engraving traditions, albeit with the addition of a number of new motifs (Rosenfeld 2002). It has generally been considered that the pecked petroglyphs of the Panaramitee date to the Pleistocene. Engravings of this style have been dated (elsewhere) to 30,000 bp (Nobbs and Dorn 1988, 1993; although see Watchman 1992), and the weathering condition and patina of many of these sites indicate that they are indeed ‘‘ancient’’ in their production. Regional variants of this style are found elsewhere across the continent, with eastern variants being found in Laura (Queensland) and Sydney (New South Wales), where they have been found to predate the more recent regional art styles (McDonald 1998; Rosenfeld et al. 1981). It has been maintained that this multivalent and largely iconic art system connected groups over hundreds and indeed thousands of kilometers. Certainly, this graphic system crosses currently recognized geographic, language, and cultural boundaries. Increasingly apparent as a result of detailed current research is that across the arid zone recent rock engraving styles have also developed. These are largely figurative, but still contain track and geometric components. While not dated, it is assumed (on the basis of regional coastal trends) that these are a Holocene development. In those areas where there has been recent research (e.g., the Calvert Ranges, Burrup Peninsula, and the western portion of the central Australian ranges) these engraving styles can be seen as associated with developing localized pigment traditions. Not all recent pigment traditions, particularly those in central Australia, however, have associated highly developed engraved components (Ben Gunn, pers. comm.). This, too, would appear to be one of the traits of more recent localized artistic behavior – a mosaic of pigment and engraved components. While there is a paucity of direct dating, it is clear that art has probably been produced throughout the arid zone, from the time of its earliest occupation (at least ca. 30,000 bp), in both engraved and pigment forms. While there is little evidence of ancient pigment art surviving on rock surfaces across the arid zone proper (cf. the Bradshaws in the Kimberley region), the evidence from Carpenter’s Gap and Puritjarra indicates that pigments were being used on rock surfaces early and that this may have increased substantially by 13,000 bp. While we have no direct dates from the arid zone proper for engraved art, dates in excess of 30,000 bp for the oldest Panaramitee art style are posited.
Correlating Rock Art with Other Arid Zone Land Use Patterns So how can patterns in rock art production throughout the arid zone be correlated with archaeological models and linguistic evidence across the arid zone?
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
122
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s
‘‘Centralian’’ and Western Desert art are rarely linked (e.g., Gould 1969), although researchers recognize that the Western Desert Cultural Bloc, which describes the extent of this specific language area, transcends other geographic divisions (that is, the more marginal Western Desert compared with the better watered central uplands). Numerous researchers have identified close similarities in both the style and execution of Western Desert and Pilbara engravings and have documented mythological narratives which clearly link the two areas and their art (e.g., Dix 1977; Maynard 1977; Tonkinson 1991; Veth 2000b). While sharing a number of traits, distinctive styles are found on the Burrup Peninsula, within the central Pilbara uplands, and at several ranges along the Canning Stock Route. Engraved gracile anthropomorphic figures, elaborate headdresses, and a range of painted and engraved naturalistic motifs and geometrics would appear to link these areas in a stylistic sense. The Wandjina/Bradshaw styles of painting from the southern Kimberley region do not occur in the Western Desert, although it is notable that many of the early Wandjina motifs bear striking similarity to the archaic faces found across the arid zone (e.g., Crawford 1977; and see below). The mythological sagas of Wati Kutjarra (the two men), Papa (dingo), and Seven Sisters (Pillades), to name a few, connect specific sites (often with art) between the Pilbara and the Western Desert (cf. Tonkinson 1991; Peter Veth, pers. comm.). These narratives do not necessarily extend to the central Australian ranges or the Kimberley. While all the art regions being discussed still require reliable dating, it is reasonable to assume that the recent ‘‘maintained’’ art sites, and those forming an integral part of the mythological narrative, can be treated as recent, and connected. The distribution of these sites in the recent period gives us insight into the scale of the interrelatedness of sites throughout prehistory. While there are early connections evident throughout the northwest and arid zone proper, throughout time there has been a changing focus of contacts into and across the arid zone. Based on regional patterns in stratified archaeological sites and shared cultural attributes, Veth (2000b) has shown that the Western Desert language probably originated in the vicinity of the Pilbara uplands and that its spread occurred in the late Holocene (see also Chapter 12, this volume). This conclusion supported the linguistic models (e.g., McConvell 1996) which indicated that the homeland of Wati was located in or near the Hammersley (Karijini) Ranges and that the homeland of Western Desert was very close to the Calvert Ranges (see Figure 7.1). The linguists argue that proto-Wati moves out of the Hammersley Ranges after 3,000 bp, with initial Western Desert unity in the southern Pilbara dating from about 2,000 bp. It is proposed that with the spread of the Western Desert language came an increased intensity of site occupation, an accelerated ritual and ceremonial cycle, and an increase in long distance exchange. The proposed correlation of the linguistic and archaeological data gives a clear indication of how you might model the role of art within this changing social system (see Table 7.2). It is likely that the ramified social networks described by current anthropological research have functioned for at least 1,000–1,500 years and possibly for as much as 5,000 years (Veth 2000a, 2000b).
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
123
______________________________________________________________________________
>22,000 bp
22,000–13,000 bp
13,000–5,000 bp
5,000–1,500 bp
1,500–500 bp
500 bp to contact
2
3
4
5
6
Timing
1
Occupation phase
Western Desert speakers encroach into central Australia
Spread of Western Desert languages; loan words from northern languages; some evidence of Arandic contact
Pama-Nyungan occupation of Western Desert
Non-Pama-Nyungan speakers
Linguistic correlations
Increased interaction with social networks in central Australia
Early colonization; all land systems in use; broadly based economy Changes in residential patterns; shifts in demography (LGM); lowlands used more opportunistically Climatic amelioration; marginal lands used more systematically Occupation of all desert ecosystems; reestablishment of regional exchange/information networks Increased intensity of site occupation; accelerated ritual and ceremonial cycle; increase in long distance exchange
Occupation model
Table 7.2 Occupation phases and language movements (after Veth 2000b) and likely art correlates.
Increased use of art to negotiate broad scale and local group identity with distinctive localized style regions evolving – art influences at this time come from the north As above – art influences also appear from the east and further afield
Art used to negotiate broad scale and local group identity
Broad scale social cohesion with perhaps increased localized identifying behavior – territorial tethering
Sporadic art production; widespread group cohesion
Likely art correlate
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s
It is also plausible that a tightening of social and territorial organization occurred just before the LGM following a long phase of high mobility and multivalent art. Groups could have become more tethered to uplands like the Calvert Ranges due to intensified aridity. A likely consequence of this would have been an inevitable intensifying process in those locations where occupation was maintained. Using this model, and information exchange theory, it is proposed that art was used to negotiate identity within this time frame. It is likely that networks functioning across the arid zone throughout the Pleistocene were more open and far reaching than observed at present, reflecting an extreme form of residential mobility (Veth 2000b). It is plausible that the initial occupation of the region was accompanied by the use of rock art. Low intensity, sporadic art production at this time would have demonstrated widespread group cohesion, resulting in a visually homogenous multivalent art graphic. The Panaramitee art fits within this schema, supported by the various early dates around the continent. Extensive art networks functioned in the European Paleolithic at a similar time. Equally, the very early dates for the Bradshaw (pigment) art of the Kimberley region and art production at Carpenter’s Gap reinforce such a proposition. The addition of the so-called archaic face into the graphic system would appear to date to the earliest period of Panaramitee art. All examples are heavily weathered, highly patinated, and many are geologically altered. Since their earliest documentation, every rock art researcher who has observed these motifs has commented on their obvious antiquity (David et al. 1992; Dix 1977; Edwards 1968; McCarthy 1979; Terry 1932; Walsh 1988). One of the characteristics of the Panaramitee is the small proportion of figurative motifs which occur among the largely non-figurative and track repertoire. Interestingly, it is this minor figurative component of the style which provides insight into what could be classed ‘‘localized style regions’’ among this early art form. The distribution of archaic faces does not reflect the overall distribution of Panaramitee rock engravings. In other regions there are other unique forms which contribute to the small proportion of unusual motifs, such as the spoked concentric circles at Sturt’s Meadows (see Walsh 1988: 65). With the LGM and changes in residential patterning (Phases 2 and 3, from 22,000–13,000 bp), it is likely that there was broad scale social cohesion. Increased localized identifying behavior may well have resulted from territorial tethering during this period. Perhaps it was at this time that the large decorative infilled motifs at the Calvert Ranges and localized variants of the archaic faces (many with bodies) were developed across the Western Desert. In the Calvert Ranges this type of motif is geologically old – the tops of the heads of one panel having weathered away. In this location, this style (on the basis of patination and weathering) appears at least as old as the other elements of classic Panaramitee art at this location. Three ancient-looking simple archaic faces (minus bodies) are also found among this assemblage. In other localities within the arid zone and its coastal margins, similar trends within developing local styles appear to have occurred. It is suggested that the use of rangeland systems such as the Calverts may have intensified with the onset of heightened aridity during the latter phase of the LGM. In coping with increased stress and the imperative to maintain ties to country,
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
125
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d
obvious responses would be to make shifts in residential mobility and to signal increasing boundedness as groups’ ranges were reconfigured. This is just the sort of catalyst that would create an artistic vocabulary signifying corporate identity (or identity of any kind) in the Western Desert during the Pleistocene (viz Rosenfeld 1993). Prior to the arrival of the Western Desert language, from around 5,000 years ago, it has been suggested that antecedent regional social networks would have developed (Veth 2000b). At this time, art would again have been used to negotiate both broad scale and local group identity. It would still be expected to have been relatively homogenous, given the requirements of ramified open social networks, although it is likely that there was an increased use of art to negotiate broad scale and local group identity with distinctive localized style regions evolving. Art influences at this time would be expected to have come from the northwest, coinciding with a range of archaeological and linguistic evidence. This pattern could have continued during the spread of the Western Desert language. In the period between 1,500 and 500 years ago one would expect that the regionally specific art provinces in operation at contact would have developed. Anthropological and archaeological evidence (e.g., Smith et al. 1998) supports a flow of artistic (social) influences from the West to the East across the arid zone during the last 500 years. This set of correlates identifies the likely triggers and social mechanisms that would have resulted in a complex graphic system, particularly one involving figurative motifs (cf. Rosenfeld 1993) developing in some areas before others. It also takes account of the ‘‘pulses’’ of artistic activity which are indicated by the (so far) limited archaeological evidence (e.g., Smith et al. 1998). This suggested patterning for diachronic change in the social context of art production and the likely manifestations of this in the graphic system, illustrating local versus regional patterns of land use, rest largely on interpretations of information exchange networks. The geographic scale at which these arid zone information networks are operating is colossal by world standards (see Gamble 1982), and the nature of the arid zone (with focalized rock art locations interspersed by vast tracts of sand dune country) provides us with a unique opportunity to investigate the dynamics of information exchange. The notion of style as social strategy (following Wobst 1977) is based on stylistic principles of communication processes. The major function of stylistic behavior is seen as linking members of a community who are not in constant verbal contact with each other, making their interaction more predictable and less stressful. ‘‘Style’’ here is defined as the particular way of doing or producing material culture which signals the activity of a particular group of people who distinguish themselves from other, similarly constituted groups. Style is non-verbal communication which negotiates identity (Wiessner 1990). ‘‘Stylistic heterogeneity’’ is perceived here as being the variability in style which demonstrates widely dissimilar artistic components; the end result of doing or producing material culture which signals either a less culturally fettered activity by a certain group of people, or the activity of a certain group which has less rigorous
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
126
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s
stylistic rules. In either case the heterogeneity needs to be ‘‘relative’’; that is, it can only be defined in comparison to more homogeneous stylistic activity. Previous rock art studies using information exchange theory have correlated stylistic variability with the nature of prehistoric social networks. Studies of art in fertile regions, where social networks are closed, have demonstrated a high degree of social information, and distinctive group identifying and bounding behavior (e.g., McDonald 1998). In the arid zone, where there are widely ramified open social networks, it has been argued that a stylistically homogeneous art form will demonstrate broad scale intergroup cohesion (C. Smith 1989). Current work indicates that not all arid zone art is homogeneous, but that information exchange theory can be used to explain the recent proliferation of localized style regions throughout the arid zone (Veth and McDonald 2002). The model presented here for the changing role of arid zone art throughout different phases of territorial mobility has also been based on these precepts. The rock art of the Calvert Ranges (Figure 7.2) encapsulates the changes in rock art production which have arguably occurred throughout the human occupation of the arid zone. The Calvert Ranges (or Kaalpi) are on the Canning Stock Route, south of Lake Disappointment. They comprise a series of well watered gorges in a small outlier of conglomerate quartz sandstone in the otherwise vast dune fields of the Little Sandy Desert. This location characterizes one of the more marginal landscapes to have been occupied by people in the Western Desert. The engraved art in this location is stylistically diverse, with time accounting for much of the variability inherent in the overall assemblage. The use of this art province extends back over a vast period of time. Here we find intaglio/classic Panaramitee style art of mainly bird and macropod tracks, circles, arcs, and dots. There are cupules (deeply pecked hollows arranged across vertical – or horizontal – surfaces), archaic faces, and small anthropomorphic figures based around the theme of archaic faces, including decorated body and disembodied archaic face with headdress. There is a suite of very large (>3 m) pecked and decoratively infilled anthropomorphic figures (these too appear to have considerable antiquity). And there are small infilled terrestrial animals, battered figurative motifs, pecked outline and infilled animals, and abraded outline figurative motifs. One site in the Calvert Ranges has been excavated previously (Veth et al. 2001). This decorated living site yielded an engraved plaque with a minimum age of 2,500 bp. At another site found during the current work an engraved motif was observed extending beneath the occupation deposit. A test probe next to the wall in this shelter revealed that the motif – an archaic face with headdress – did indeed extend beneath the deposit. Preliminary dates are equivocal, but one from ca. 20 cm below the current surface suggests that the upper portion of this buried motif was initially covered by deposit around 1,000 years ago (1,050110 bp, Wk-8807). This would suggest the actual production predated this date considerably (that is, enough time to allow at least 40 cm of deposit to accumulate). More extensive excavations are planned to explore the possible age and association of this motif.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
127
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d
N 400 km
Jalijbang2
E
R
LE
Y
S
0
Burrup Penninsula
KI
M
B
Depuch Island Port Hedland P
I
Abydos L
Durba Hills
B
A
R
N. T.
Cleland Hills
Kaalpi
A
S. A.
Perth
Figure 7.2 Distribution of archaic faces across the arid zone.
Archaic Faces Archaic faces have a predominantly arid zone distribution (see Figure 7.2). They are found between the coastal and eastern Pilbara region to Wardaman country in the north, and between Cleland Hills in the east and the Calvert Ranges in the southwest. The site at which this motif type was originally recorded is some 200 km west of Alice Springs (Edwards 1968). The engravings here are found around a semipermanent rock hole in the Cleland Hills. The Cleland Hills site has the largest recorded concentration of this motif (n ¼ 16), although illustrations for only nine have been published (David et al. 1992; Dix 1972, 1977; Edwards 1968; Morwood 2002; Walsh 1988).
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
128
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s
Generally, these engravings have pecked eyes, comprised of dots surrounded by concentric circles, mouths (these are sometimes natural cavities on the rock surface), and some have noses and ears. The face is generally heart- (or pear-) shaped – and there are various examples which have no upper face outline above the eyes (see Figure 7.3). At Cleland Hills there are three examples which also have bodies. One of these comprises simple lines, while the other two are more complex designs. Several are found as part of more complex non-figurative (CXNF) engraved designs. It is the embodiment of the faces, and development of more complex design structures, which suggests the development of localized stylistic traits – a pattern which can be observed at other sites which also have the simple archaic face present. We do not know how old the archaic faces are, but the extensive geological alteration to the substrate on which they have been engraved and their generally
Figure 7.3 Examples of archaic faces used in the current analysis.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
129
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d
Figure 7.4 Archaic face with body – the development of localized group identifying behavior (an example from the Calvert Ranges).
high degree of weathering is strongly suggestive of at least a terminal Pleistocene age (ca. 25,000–10,000 bp) for many of them. More than 1,000 km north of Cleland Hills is Wardaman country. Here, in a secluded sandstone gorge at a site known as Jalijbang 2, are three large complex pebraded (pecked and abraded) anthropomorphs on vertical sandstone walls. Nearby on large boulders are three pecked, highly weathered faces (David et al. 1992; Lewis and McClausland 1987). Nearby occupation evidence was found to be 4,000–3,000 years old, but none of the engravings was in a directly dateable context. It was concluded that ‘‘their precise antiquity remains a matter for speculation’’ (David et al. 1992: 74). An earlier analysis of the archaic face was undertaken using multidimensional scaling to compare the 21 motifs in the sample (David et al. 1992). This indicated strong regional clustering, although the Jalijbang 2 boulder and wall faces (located within 20 m of each other) are separated significantly. Diachronic as well as synchronic variability would appear to account for these differences. For this chapter I analyzed a sample of 39 archaic faces from the Burrup Peninsula (n ¼ 18), Cleland Hills (n ¼ 10), the Calvert Ranges (n ¼ 4), Durba Hills (n ¼ 1), and Jalijbang 2 (n ¼ 6).1 A total of 19 variables were defined and counted on this sample. Of these variables, 14 were binary (presence/absence) and 5 were metrical (see Table 7.3). Details of associated body, headdress, or other CXNF features were not measured, since these traits were not present on all motifs. Because the sample size is relatively small, a simple cluster analysis (using squared Euclidian distance on binary data) was undertaken to identify any grouping within the sample. The analysis found that the simple archaic faces could be classified on the basis of just six of the non-metrical traits (see Table 7.3). These traits demonstrated a clustering of the archaic faces from Cleland Hills, the Burrup Peninsula,
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
130
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s Table 7.3 Variables used in the analysis of the archaic faces and codes used for the analyzed sample (see Figure 7.5). Variable 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Codes
Pecked dot eye Concentric circle around eyes Head enclosed by outline? Pear/heart-shaped head Hair or headdress Nose Ears Distinctive mouth Associated body (simple) Intaglio elements Concentric facial elements Neck Associated body (complex) Part of complex-non-fig? Length of head Width of head Distance between center eyes Number of concentric rings (left eye) Number of concentric rings (right eye) Burrup Peninsula Cleland Hills Calvert Ranges Durba Hills Jalijbang 2 wall and boulder
Binary
Metrical
B1-B12 CH1-CH10 CR1-CR4 DH1 JW1-JW3; JB1-JB3
and the Calvert Ranges. When a further two variables are included in the analysis a separation [is achieved] which broadly can be defined on the basis of complexity of association and degree of embellishment (see Figure 7.5). There is a slight separation of the Burrup motifs, but generally there is a development of complexity across the sample area which creates patterning within the sample. And this cannot be explained purely in terms of geographic separation. It is considered significant that this analysis did not demonstrate a geographic split and that all archaic faces (as generally defined in the literature), regardless of provenance, clustered together. It is only when we consider the development of the face into full body figures and/or other associations that geographic emphasis appears to emerge. The absence of clear geographic divisions indicates that there are stylistic similarities between all areas analyzed. This is hardly surprising since the basis for selection within the sample was the presence of an archaic face! Regionalization is, however, present and the observed differences between the style provinces can be summarized as follows:
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
131
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d Label
0
5
10
15
20
25
CH7 B17 B18 CH1 JW1 DH1 JB2 B2 JW2 JW3 CH6 CR1 CR3 B8 CH3 JB1 CH2 CH9 CH10 B4 CR2 B11 B12 B10 B13 CH8 B14 CH4 CH5 B6 B7 B3 B5 B15 CR4 B16 JB3 B1 B9
Figure 7.5 Dendrogram showing results of analysis on archaic faces (refer to Table 7.3 for codes).
Burrup Peninsula: Small overall motif size, strong intaglio component, highly complex graphic with strong decorative infill component, highly variable body shapes (human and animal), many faces have hair or headdress (Figures 7.6 and 7.7). Cleland Hills: Incorporation of one face into complex non-figurative engraved panel (see Figure 7.8), highly variable body shape (simple and more complex), in situ development of simple face (maybe an artifact of sample size).
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
132
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s
Figure 7.6 Burrup Peninsula. Fish motif (B17) with archaic face (courtesy Peter Kendrick).
Figure 7.7 Burrup Peninsula. Two archaic faces (B15 and B16) in complex non-figurative graphic (courtesy Peter Kendrick).
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
133
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d
Figure 7.8 Cleland Hills (CH1) archaic face (courtesy Mike Smith).
Calvert Ranges: Development of pecked complex body association (small and large; see Figure 7.4), incorporation of natural features (e.g., large quartz clasts) into motif design, complex decorative infill, anthropomorphs have hands and feet (some with digits), some have a square head shape incorporating headdress, some have headdresses similar to the local painted varieties. Durba Hills: This single example looks more like several of the Burrup variants, but clusters most strongly with one of the boulder faces from Jalijbang 2. Wardaman Country: The simple pecked and highly weathered faces on the boulders are differentiated from those on the wall by both technique and traits. The three anthropomorphs on the wall are characterized by concentric infill, the use of pebrading (pecking and abrading), and the addition of small koala-like ears; limbs are shown (some incomplete) and fingers indicated. The embellishment of these faces in the various localities in which they are found raises the possibility that the faces are a common and shared theme over a huge area, acting initially to connect groups over long distances. The introduction and variations in body form and infill and headdress style over time serve to signify a development of local identity and territoriality. So what are the likely circumstances that might have resulted in the development of individual identifying behavior within a social system which generally encour-
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
134
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s
Figure 7.9 Calvert Ranges. Panel of more recent anthropomorphs with pecked eyes and intaglio decorative infill.
aged stylistic homogeneity? When does individual identity override the practice of group identity? Wiessner (1989) has modeled the different social situations that might stimulate a different identity emphasis. She proposed that group identity will be emphasized where there is real or potential intergroup competition and/or aggression, and a need for cooperation to achieve goals and impose political control. Individual identity, on the other hand, will dominate when there is real competition between individuals, when there are options for individual economic gain or status, or where there is a breakdown in the social order that would require individuals to seek solutions to their own problems. Similarly, Myers’ (2002: 48) work on contemporary Western Desert acrylic paintings concluded that artists elaborate certain representational templates motivated by the politics of personal and social identity. In a system of dynamic mobility, one might also suggest that periods of aggregation would result in the intense interaction of both groups and individuals seeking to establish themselves in the social order. Aggregation locales, then, are likely sites for stylistic innovation to occur. Across the arid zone the art that we find at aggregation sites appears to record the interaction of neighboring (frequently dispersed) groups, but we should also expect to be able to identify innovation in stylistic traits (Conkey 1980). This is exactly what we appear to be seeing in the development of the more complex graphic based on the archaic face. Since their earliest usage, then, aggregation locales have allowed groups to assert identity and difference.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
135
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d
The early graphic form, the archaic face, is generally found at the type of refugia generally assumed to have functioned as arid zone aggregation locales – Cleland Hills, Calvert Ranges, and Durba Hills. This would appear to have had a dual signaling purpose, to both connect and differentiate people. The distribution of this motif not only demonstrates that the ancient pecked Panaramitee art provided an essential underpinning for groups with extreme forms of residential and territorial mobility, but it also shows us that the likely range of this connection was over thousands of kilometers. The widespread presence of the archaic face – a clearly identifiable and relatively uniform graphic element – so early in the history of occupation of the Western Desert suggests groups were in contact over vast tracts of country. It also suggests that long distance arid zone information exchange networks appear to have considerable antiquity. Similar evidence occurs in the terminal Pleistocene from other archaeological evidence (e.g., the movement of ochers around the arid zone; Smith et al. 1998), in the late Holocene (e.g., exotic lithics such as Wingelina porphyry at Puntutjarpa; Gould 1977), and during the last 2,500 years with pearl shell and baler (from the Pilbara and/or Kimberley coastline) at rainmaking and ceremonial sites along the Percival Lakes and Canning Stock Route (Ackerman and Stanton 1994; Smith and Veth, 2004). The well watered gorges of the Calvert Ranges have evidence of extraordinary stylistic heterogeneity in the recent art (pigment and engraved) as well as demonstrating long-term diachronic change. The high degree of stylistic variability displayed here indicates that this place has acted as an aggregation locale over a considerable period of time [(Veth and McDonald 2002)]. We know that aggregation sites have served as important centers of ritual production, as well as facilitating the rapid exchange of language, material culture, and genes. During their periodic coalescences groups would renegotiate social contracts and reciprocity relations that set the necessary conditions for subsequent dispersal (Gibbs and Veth 2002). Aggregation locales in the Western Desert provide vital evidence for long-term patterns of mobility and exchange across the arid zone. They provide the foci in the landscape where changes in economy, intensity of site use, and the graphic systems signifying both local identity and long distance alliances are demonstrated. It is in these locations that changes in a complex and far reaching social system can be observed. Multiple phases of occupation at arid zone aggregation locales are most clearly demonstrated by multiphase rock art assemblages. This analysis of archaic faces has been based on their widespread distribution and assumption of great antiquity and the subsequent regional development of different stylistic signatures. It is suggested that there has been a change in the signifying role of rock art across arid zone social systems throughout its 30,000þ years of human occupation. The archaic face, developed out of a representational graphic into a simple but evocative figurative form, appears to have served a dual role. It initially connected people within a huge cultural bloc. Its figurative nature then allowed the development and demonstration of individual and local group identity. The development of individual traits and innovation within a representational graphic must have been triggered by the types of social factors that would be
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
136
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s
expected in the ‘‘hot tub’’ environment of periodic aggregation. By viewing the art of the arid zone in terms of its information potential and likely role in mediating social situations, it is suggested that this is not a conservative and unchanging graphic. Indeed, the art of the arid zone has played a fundamental role in the success of extreme mobility and human adaptation to the most marginal landscapes of this most arid of continents.
Note 1 I have excluded two of the motifs used by David et al. (1992) in the current analysis. The Sturt Creek sample (Walsh 1988) was excluded on the basis of its non-comparable appearance, and the Yingalarri example because I could not find a published scaled drawing. Sources for the current sample are attributable to Edwards (1968), David et al. (1992), and Dix (1972, 1977). Unpublished material was provided by Peter Kendrick and Peter Veth, as well as my own recording work.
References Ackerman, K. and Stanton, J. 1994: Riji and Jakoli: Kimberley Pearl Shell in Aboriginal Australia. Darwin: Northern Territory Museum of Arts and Science. Chewings, C. 1909: ‘‘About the blacks’’: Natives of central Australia. The Register, 1 (16), 1–11. Conkey, M. W. 1980: The identification of hunter-gatherer aggregation sites – the case of Altimira. Current Anthropology, 21 (5), 609–30. Cook, N., Davidson, I., and Sutton, S. 1990: Why are so many ancient rock paintings red? Australian Aboriginal Studies, 1, 30–2. Crawford, I. M. 1977: The relationship of Bradshaws and Wandjina art in northwest Kimberley. In P. J. Ucko (ed.), Form in Indigenous Art, London: Duckworth, 357–69. David, B., Armitage, R. A., Hyman, M., Rowe, M. W., and Lawson, E. 1999: How old is north Queensland rock art? A review of the evidence with new AMS determinations. Archaeology in Oceania, 34, 103–20. David, B. and Chant, N. 1995: Rock art and regionalization in north Queensland prehistory. Memoirs of the Queensland Museum, 3 (2), 357–528. David, B., Chant, N., and Flood, J. 1992: Jalijbang 2 and the distribution of pecked faces in Australia. Memoirs of the Queensland Museum, 32 (1), 61–77. Dickens, J. 1996: Change and continuity in central Australian graphic systems. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology, 15, 20–40. Dix, W. 1972: Rock art along the Stock Route. Hemisphere, 16 (7), 18–25. Dix, W. 1977: Facial representations in Pilbara rock engravings. In P. J. Ucko (ed.), Form in Indigenous Art, London: Duckworth, 277–85. Edwards, R. 1968: Prehistoric rock engravings at Thomas Reservoir, Cleland Hills, western central Australia. Records of the South Australian Museum, 15 (4), 647–70. Frederick, U. 2000: Keeping the land alive: Changing social contexts of landscape and rock art production. In R. Torrence and A. Clarke (eds), The Archaeology of Difference: Negotiating Cross-Cultural Engagements in Oceania, London: Routledge, 300–30.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
137
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d Galt-Smith, B. 1997: Motives for motifs: Identifying aggregation and dispersion settlement patterns in the rock art assemblages of central Australia. Unpublished BA (Hons) thesis, Armidale: University of New England. Gamble, C. S. 1982: Interaction and alliance in Palaeolithic society. Man, 17 (1), 92–107. Gibbs, M. and Veth, P. 2002: Ritual engines and the archaeology of territorial ascendancy. In S. Ulm, C. Westcott, J. Reid, A. Ross, I. Lilley, J. Prangnell, and L. Kirkwood (eds), Barriers, Borders, Boundaries: Proceedings of the 2001 Australian Archaeological Association Annual Conference, St Lucia: University of Queensland, 11–19. Gillen, F. J. 1968 [1901–2]: Gillen’s Diary: The Camp Jottings of F. J. Gillen on the Spencer and Gillen Expedition Across Australia. Adelaide: Libraries Board of South Australia. Gould, R. A. 1969: Yiwara: Foragers of the Australian Desert. London: Collins. Gould, R. A. 1977: Puntutjarpa Rockshelter and the Australian Desert Culture. New York: Anthropological Papers of the American Museum of Natural History no. 54, American Museum of Natural History. Gunn, R. G. 1995: Regional patterning in the Aboriginal rock art of central Australia: A preliminary report. Rock Art Research, 12, 117–27. Gunn, R. G. 2000a: Central Australian rock art: A second report. Rock Art Research, 17 (2), 111–26. Gunn, R. G. 2000b: Spencer and Gillen’s contribution to Australian rock art studies. Rock Art Research, 17 (1), 56–64. Gunn, R. G. 2003: Arrernte rock art: Interpreting physical permanence in a changing social landscape. Australian Aboriginal Studies, 1, 52–73. Jestribek, K. 1997: Different domains. An examination of gender relations and motif use in contemporary art from Balgo, Western Australia. Unpublished BA (Hons) thesis, Perth: University of Western Australia. Jochim, M. A. 1983: Paleolithic cave art in ecological perspective. In G. Bailey (ed.), HunterGatherer Economy in Prehistory: A European Perspective, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 212–19. Kimber, R. 1977: Mosaics you can move. Hemisphere, 21 (1), 2–7. Layton, R. 1986: Uluru: An Aboriginal History of Ayers Rock. Canberra: Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies. Layton, R. 1992: Traditional and contemporary art of Aboriginal Australia: Two case studies. In J. Coote and A. Shelton (eds), Anthropology, Art and Aesthetics, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 137–59. Lewis, D. 1988: The Rock Paintings of Arnhem Land, Australia: Social, Ecological, and Material Culture Change in the Post-Glacial Period. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports International Series no. 415, Hadrian Books. Lewis, D. and McClausland, B. 1987: Engraved human figures and faces from Wardaman country, eastern Victoria River District, Northern Territory. Australian Aboriginal Studies, 1, 67–79. McCarthy, F. D. 1979: Australian Aboriginal Rock Art (4th edn). Sydney: Australian Museum. McConvell, P. 1996: Backtracking to Babel: The chronology of Pama-Nyungan expansion in Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 31 (3), 125–44. McDonald, J. J. 1994: Dreamtime superhighway: An analysis of Sydney basin rock art and prehistoric information exchange. Unpublished PhD thesis, Canberra: The Australian National University.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
138
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s McDonald, J. J. 1998: Shelter rock art in the Sydney basin – a space-time continuum: Exploring different influences on stylistic change. In C. Chippendale and P. S. C. Tacon (eds), The Archaeology of Rock Art, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 319–35. McDonald, J. J. 1999: Bedrock notions and isochrestic choice: Evidence for localized stylistic patterning in the engravings of the Sydney region. Archaeology in Oceania, 34 (3), 145–60. McDonald, J .J. 2000: AMS dating charcoal drawings in the Sydney region: Results and issues. In G. K. Ward and C. Tuniz (eds), Advances in Dating Australian Rock Images: Papers from the First Australian Rock Picture Dating Workshop, Melbourne: AURA, 90–4. Maynard, L. 1977: Classification and terminology in Australian rock art. In P. J. Ucko (ed.), Form in Indigenous Art, Canberra: Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies, 385–402. Megaw, V. 1982: Western Desert acrylic painting – artifact or art? Art History, 5, 205–18. Morphy, H. (ed.) 1989: On representing ancestral beings. In H. Morphy (ed.), Animals into Art, London: Unwin Hyman, 144–60. Morphy, H. 1991: Ancestral Connections: Art and an Aboriginal System of Knowledge. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Morwood, M. J. 2002: Visions from the Past: The Archaeology of Australian Rock Art. Sydney: Allen and Unwin. Munn, N. D. 1966: Visual categories: An approach to the study of representational systems. American Anthropologist, 66, 939–50. Munn, N. D. 1973: Walbiri Iconography: Graphic Representation and Cultural Symbolism in a Central Australian Society. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Myers, F. R. 1986: Always ask: Resource use and ownership among Pintupi Aborigines of the Australian Western Desert. In N. Williams and E. Hunn (eds), Resource Managers: North American and Australian Hunter-Gatherers, Canberra: Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies, 173–96. Myers, F. R. 1989: Truth, beauty, and Pintupi painting. Visual Anthropology, 2, 163–95. Myers, F. R. 2002: Painting Culture: The Making of an Aboriginal High Art. Durham, NC: Duke University Press. Nobbs, M. F. and Dorn, R. I. 1988: Age determinations for rock varnish formation within petroglyphs. Rock Art Research, 5 (2), 108–46. Nobbs, M. F. and Dorn, R. I. 1993: New surface exposure ages for petroglyphs from the Olary Province, South Australia. Archaeology in Oceania, 27, 199–220. O’Connor, S. 1995: Carpenter’s Gap rock shelter 1: 40,000 years of Aboriginal occupation in the Napier Ranges, Kimberley, WA. Australian Archaeology, 40, 58–9. O’Connor, S., Veth, P., and Campbell, C. 1998: Serpent’s Glen rock shelter: Report on the first Pleistocene-aged occupation sequence from the Western Desert. Australian Archaeology, 46, 12–22. Roberts, R., Walsh, G. L., Murray, A., Olley, J., Morwood, M., Tuniz, C., Lawson, E., Macphail, M., Bowdery, D., and Naumann, I. 1997: Luminescence dating of rock art and past environments using mud-wasp nests in northern Australia. Nature, 387, 696–9. Rosenfeld, A. 1993: A review of the evidence for the emergence of rock art in Australia. In M. A. Smith, M. Spriggs, and B. Fankhauser (eds), Sahul in Review: Pleistocene Archaeology in Australia, New Guinea, and Island Melanesia, Canberra: The Australian National University, 71–80. Rosenfeld, A. 2002: Rock art as an indicator of changing social geographies in central Australia. In B. David and M. Wilson (eds), Inscribed Landscapes: Marking and Making Places, Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 61–78.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
139
______________________________________________________________________________
Jo McD o n a l d Rosenfeld, A., Horton, D., and Winter, J. 1981: Early Man in North Queensland. Canberra: The Australian National University. Rosenfeld, A. and Smith, M. A. 2002: Rock-art and the History of Puritjarra Rock Shelter, Cleland Hills, Central Australia. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society, 68, 103–24. Ross, J. 2003: Rock art, ritual, and relationships: An archaeological analysis of rock art from the central Australian arid zone. Unpublished PhD thesis, Armidale: University of New England. Smith, C. E. 1989: Designed dreaming: Assessing the relationship between style, social structure, and environment in Aboriginal Australia. Unpublished BA (Hons) thesis, Armidale: University of New England. Smith, M. A. 1989: The case for a resident human population in the central Australian ranges during full glacial aridity. Archaeology in Oceania, 24, 93–105. Smith, M. A. 1996: Prehistory and human ecology in central Australia: An archaeological perspective. In S. R. Morton and D. J. Mulvaney (eds), Exploring Central Australia: Society, Environment, and the 1894 Horn Expedition, Chipping Norton: Surry Beatty and Sons, 61–73. Smith, M. A., Fankhauser, B., and Jercher, M. 1998: The changing provenance of red ochre at Puritjarra rock shelter, central Australia: Late Pleistocene to present. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society, 64, 275–92. Smith, M. A. and Veth, P. M. 2004: Radiocarbon dates for baler shell in the Great Sandy Desert. Australian Archaeology, 58, 37–8. Spencer, B. and Gillen, F. J. 1899: The Native Tribes of Central Australia. London: Macmillan. Stirling, E. C. 1896: Anthropology. In B. Spencer (ed.), Report on the Work of the Horn Scientific Expedition to Central Australia: Part IV, Anthropology, Melbourne: Melville, Mullen and Slade, 1–157. Terry, M. 1932: Erldunda Station – Laverton, Letter book containing company correspondence. Manuscript, Adelaide: South Australian Museum. Thorley, P. B. 1998: Pleistocene settlement in the Australian arid zone: Occupation of an inland riverine landscape in the central Australian ranges. Antiquity, 72, 34–45. Tonkinson, R. 1991: The Martu Aborigines: Living the Dream in Australia’s Desert. Fort Worth, TX: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston. Veth, P. M. 1993: Islands in the Interior: The Dynamics of Prehistoric Adaptations within the Arid Zone of Australia. International Monographs in Prehistory, Archaeology Series no. 3, Ann Arbor, MI. Veth, P. 2000a: Cycles of aridity and human mobility: Risk minimization amongst late Pleistocene foragers of the Western Desert, Australia. Philadelphia, PA: Unpublished paper presented at the Society of American Archaeology conference. Veth, P. 2000b: Origins of the Western Desert language: Convergence in linguistic and archaeological space and time models. Archaeology in Oceania, 35 (1), 11–19. Veth, P. and McDonald, J. J. 2002: The role of art in long-term cycles of aggregation in the Western Desert. Canberra: Unpublished paper presented to Arcling conference, National Museum of Australia. Veth, P., Smith, M., and Haley, M. 2001: Kaalpi: The archaeology of a sandstone outlier in the Western Desert. Australian Archaeology, 52, 9–17. Walsh, G. 1988: Australia’s Greatest Rock Art. Bathurst: E. J. Brill–Robert, Brown, and Associates. Watchman, A. 1992: Doubtful dates for Karolta engravings. Australian Aboriginal Studies, 2, 51–5.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
140
______________________________________________________________________________
Ar c h a i c Fa c e s t o H e ad d r e s se s Watchman, A., Walsh, G. L., Morwood, M. J., and Tuniz, C. 1997: AMS radiocarbon age estimates for early rock paintings in the Kimberley, NW Australia: Preliminary results. Rock Art Research, 14, 18–26. Wiessner, P. 1989: Style and changing relations between individual and society. In I. Hodder (ed.), The Meanings of Things: Material Culture and Symbolic Expression, London: Unwin Hyman, 56–63. Wiessner, P. 1990: Is there a unity to style? In M. Conkey and C. Hastorf (eds), The Uses of Style in Archaeology, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 105–12. Wobst, H. M. 1977: Stylistic behavior and information exchange. In C. E. Cleland (ed.), For the Director: Research Essays in Honour of J. B. Griffen, Anthropological Papers no. 61, University of Michigan, 317–42.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
141
______________________________________________________________________________
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Archaeology of the Patagonian Deserts Hunter-Gatherers in a Cold Desert Luis Alberto Borrero
Introduction Most of this volume deals with hunter-gatherer groups located in hot deserts. However, in high latitudes there are significant areas of cold desert where aridity is largely a function of low temperature. Do cold deserts pose different problems for hunter-gatherer populations? Do cold deserts have different histories? This chapter explores some of these issues using the early settlement of the Patagonian deserts as a case study (see Figure 8.1). Early Patagonian ethnographic sources describe the Tehuelche ; hunter-gatherers who relied on guanaco (Lama guanicoe) and n˜andu´ (Rhea americana, Pterocnemia pennata) hunting. The sources particularly noticed their use of bola stones to immobilize and capture these animals. This hunting device is characteristic of open spaces, and it is one of the more salient cultural responses to the exploitation of cold desert resources. Different ethnic groups displaying a variety of subsistence strategies, including a strong emphasis on the recollection of small package resources, were recognized in the northwest portion of Patagonia. This emphasis on a wide variety of low return resources is another characteristic of groups adapted to the Patagonian deserts.
Regional Background Patagonia and Tierra del Fuego extend today over more than 1,000,000 sq km, but at the end of the Pleistocene they constituted a single landmass that covered a much larger space, including a significant area today flooded by the sea. Large portions of Patagonia are included within the ‘‘arid diagonal’’ of South America
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
142
______________________________________________________________________________
T he Ar c h a eo l og y o f t he Pa t a g o n i a n D eserts
Figure 8.1 Map of the Upper Limay River showing locations of archaeological sites mentioned in the text.
(Iglesias 1982), which is characterized by an arid climate not moderated by maritime air masses from the Atlantic or Pacific Oceans. Patagonia includes a series of discontinuous desert regions. Deserts in the north of Patagonia, between 388 and 418S, are highly seasonal and very cold (seasonality increases with latitude and the south of Patagonia is more seasonal than the north). Available paleoclimatic and paleoecological data point to the existence of discontinuous arid conditions since at least the end of the Pleistocene. Late Pleistocene times were marked by the retreat of the cordilleran glaciers, a process that was well under way by ca. 14,000 bp (Clapperton 1993). This process was accompanied by an amelioration of climate, punctuated by short cold pulses (Clapperton 1993; Heusser 1993a; Markgraf 1993). Compared to northern North America the development of glaciers was less extensive in South America, with the more maritime late Pleistocene climate representing a less stressful habitat.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
143
______________________________________________________________________________
L u i s A lb er to Bo r r e r o
The Colonization of Patagonian Deserts The human exploration and colonization of Fuego-Patagonia began in late Pleistocene times and took place under very cold and dry conditions. Most of the oldest available evidence comes from the cold deserts of the south, which is probably an artifact of the better archaeological visibility of sites in those regions. The colonization of new lands is a case of exogeny, in which new species are usually at an advantage. To start with, unless we are talking of niche expansion within a given biome, newly arrived species are usually generalists. In spite of several voices claiming that the first human foragers to arrive in Patagonia were specialized, the consensus now is that they were not. Within this context it is relevant to ask: ‘‘How did humans adapt to new lands?’’ Several authors (Beaton 1991; Borrero 1989; Meltzer 2002; Rockman and Steele 2003) have explored this question. If we combine their insights with the evidence from Patagonia, we can conclude that considerable time was needed to colonize this huge area. Indeed, some time was required to establish a pattern of use in the use of a place and its surroundings, including acquiring critical knowledge about the location of the best lithic sources, the less costly paths for movement, and so on. The concept of ‘‘ecological perception’’ has been recently proposed to explain the kind of knowledge needed to interact with a new environment (Gutierrez and Martinez 2003). This would have been accompanied by the symbolic appropriation of territory (Politis 2003), a process which can take several generations to complete (Rockman 2003). What were the likely constraints on early settlement in these deserts? Did they include water, shelter, or food? Or were low temperatures a constraint? It must be noted that humans living in the northwest corner of Patagonia were not exposed to extreme cold. Thus physiological adaptations, such as those recorded for periArctic or Fuegian environments, were not required. Cultural responses easily compensated for observed climatic fluctuations. Available evidence suggests that food was probably widespread and thus its distribution was not the organizing principle for the first settlers. As for shelter, there is substantial support for the notion that the first inhabitants of America possessed appropriate technology for constructing shelters and therefore were not dependant on the availability of caves for protection. Dillehay (1991) explored the role of diseases in colonizing populations, which may have been a retarding factor for the peopling of tropical America, but the constraints were probably