ADVANCES IN MOLECULAR STRUCTURE RESEARCH
Volume
1
9 1995
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN MOLECULA...
39 downloads
1521 Views
16MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN MOLECULAR STRUCTURE RESEARCH
Volume
1
9 1995
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN MOLECULAR STRUCTURE RESEARCH Editors" MAG DOLNA HARG ITTAi Structural Chemistry Research Group Hungarian Academy of Sciences Budapest, Hungary ISTV,~N HARGITTAI
Institute of General and Analytical Chemistry Budapest Technical University Budapest, Hungary VOLUME 1
91995
@ Greenwich, Connecticut
JAI PRESS INC.
London, England
Copyright 91995 by JAi PRESSINC 55 Old Post Road, No. 2 Greenwich, Connecticut 06836 JAi PRESSLTD. The Courtyard 28 High Street Hampton Hill, Middlesex TWl 2 1PD England All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored on a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, filming, recording, or otherwise, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. ISBN: 1-55938-799-8 Manufactured in the United States of America
CONTENTS
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS INTRODUCTION TO THE SERIES: AN EDITOR'S FOREWORD
Albert Padwa
PREFACE
Magdolna Hargittai and lstv~n Hargittai
vii
ix xi
MEASURING SYMMETRY IN STRUCTURAL CHEMISTRY
Hagit Zabrodsky and David A vnir
SOME PERSPECTIVES IN MOLECULAR STRUCTURE RESEARCH: AN INTRODUCTION
lstv~n Hargittai and Magdolna Hargittai
ACCURATE MOLECULAR STRUCTURE FROM MICROWAVE ROTATIONAL SPECTROSCOPY
Heinz Dieter Rudolph
GAS-PHASE NMR STUDIES OF CONFORMATIONAL PROCESSES
Nancy S. True and Cristina Suarez
33
63
115
FOURIER TRANSFORM SPECTROSCOPY OF RADICALS
Henry W. Rohrs, Gregory J. Frost, G. Barney Ellison, Erik C. Richard, and Veronica Vaida
THE INTERPLAY BETWEEN X-RAY CRYSTALLOGRAPHY AND AB INITIO CALCULATIONS
Roland Boese, Thomas Haumann, and Peter Stellberg
157
201
vi
CONTENTS
COMPUTATIONAL AND SPECTROSCOPIC STUDIES ON HYDRATED MOLECULES
Alfred H. Lowrey and Robert W. Williams
EXPERIMENTAL ELECTRON DENSITIES OF MOLECULAR CRYSTALS AND CALCULATION OF ELECTROSTATIC PROPERTIES FROM HIGH RESOLUTION X-RAY DIFFRACTION
Claude Lecomte
ORDER IN SPACE: PACKING OF ATOMS AND MOLECULES
Laura E. Depero
INDEX
227
261
303 339
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS David A vn ir
Department of Organic Chemistry The Hebrew University of Jerusalem Jerusalem, Israel
Roland Boese
Institute of Inorganic Chemistry University-GH of Essen Essen, Germany
Laura E. Depero
Department of Mechanical Engineering University of Brescia Brescia, Italy
G. Barney Ellison
Department of Chemistry University of Colorado Boulder, Colorado
Gregory J. Frost
Department of Chemistry University of Colorado Boulder, Colorado
Istvan Hargittai
Institute of General and Analytical Chemistry Budapest Technical University and Hungarian Academy of Sciences Budapest, Hungary
Magdolna Hargittai
Structural Chemistry Research Group of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences E~tv6s University Budapest, Hungary
Thomas Haumann
Institute of Inorganic Chemistry University-GH of Essen Essen, Germany
Claude Lecomte
Laboratory of Mineralogy Faculty of Sciences University of Nancy Vandoeuvre-les-Nancy, France
vii
viii
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Alfred H. Lowrey
Laboratory for the Structure of Matter Naval Research Laboratory Washington, D.C.
Erik C. Richard
Department of Chemistry University of Colorado Boulder, Colorado
Henry W. Rohrs
Department of Chemistry University of Colorado Boulder, Colorado
Heinz Dieter Rudolph
Department of Chemistry University of UIm UIm, Germany
Peter Stellberg
Institute of Inorganic Chemistry University-GH of Essen Essen, Germany
Cristina Suarez
Department of Chemistry University of California Davis, California
Nancy S. True
Department of Chemistry University of California Davis, California
Veronica Vaida
Department of Chemistry University of Colorado Boulder, Colorado
Robert W. Williams
Department of Biochemistry Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences Bethesda, Maryland
Hagit Zabrodsky
Department of Computer Science The Hebrew University of Jerusalem Jerusalem, Israel
INTRODUCTION TO THE SERIES" AN EDITOR'S FOREWORD The JAI series in chemistry has come of age over the past several years. Each of the volumes already published contains timely chapters by leading exponents in the field who have placed their own contributions in a perspective that provides insight to their long-term research goals. Each contribution focuses on the individual author' s own work as well as the studies of others that address related problems. The series is intended to provide the reader with in-depth accounts of important principles as well as insight into the nuances and subtleties of a given area of chemistry. The wide coverage of material should be of interest to graduate students, postdoctoral fellows, industrial chemists and those teaching specialized topics to graduate students. We hope that we will continue to provide you with a sense of stimulation and enjoyment of the various sub-disciplines of chemistry. Department of Chemistry Emory University Atlanta, Georgia
Albert Padwa
Consulting Editor
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PREFACE Progress in molecular structure research reflects progress in chemistry in many ways. Much of it is thus blended inseparably with the rest of chemistry. It appears to be prudent, however, to review the frontiers of this field from time to time. This may help the structural chemist to delineate the main thrusts of advances in this area of research. What is even more important though, these efforts may assist the rest of the chemists to learn about new possibilities in structural research. This series will be reporting the progress in structural studies, both methodological and interpretational. We are aiming at making it a "user-oriented" series. Structural chemists of excellence will be critically evaluating a field or direction including their own achievements, and charting expected developments. The present volume is the first in this series which is expected to grow about one volume a year. We would appreciate hearing from those producing structural information and perfecting existing techniques or creating new ones, and from the users of structural information. This would help us gauge the reception of this series and shape future volumes. Magdolna and Istvfin Hargittai Editors
xi
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
MEASU Ri NG SYMMETRY IN STRUCTURAL CHEMISTRY**
Hagit Zabrodsky and David Avnir
Io II. III. IV. V.
VI. VII. VIII.
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Continuous S y m m e t r y Measure: Definition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Evaluating the S y m m e t r y Transform . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Proof of the Folding Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Examples o f Measuring S y m m e t r y in 3D: Tetrahedricity and Rotating Ethane A. Tetrahedricity of Phosphates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Rotating Tetrahedra of Ethane . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Point Selection for Representation of Contours . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . S y m m e t r y o f Occluded Shapes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . S y m m e t r y of Points with Uncertain Locations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. The Most Probable Symmetric Shape . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Probability Distribution o f S y m m e t r y Values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Note . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Note Added in Proof . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References and Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
*Dedicated to Professor Jochanan Blum on the occasion of his 60th birthday. *Part 3 of Contimtous Symmetry Measures. 1,2
Advances in Molecular Structure Research Volume 1, pages 1-31. Copyright 9 1995 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 1-55938-799-8
2 2 4 6 8 . 10
10 12 16 18 21 21 24 27 27 27 31 31
2
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
ABSTRACT Symmetry is treated as a continuous property. A continuous symmetry measure (CSM) of structures is defined to be the minimum mean-squared distance required to move points of the original structure and change it to a symmetrical structure. This general definition of a symmetry measure enables a comparison of the amount of symmetry of different shapes and the amount of different symmetries of a single shape. We describe a general method of obtaining the minimal distance to the desired shape and apply it to any symmetry element or symmetry group, in two or three dimensions. Various examples of the application of the CSM approach to structural chemistry are presented. These include symmetry analysis of distorted tetrahedra, and of rotating ethane, symmetry analysis of contours of equi-property such as molecular orbital representations, reconstruction of incomplete structural data, and symmetry analysis of structures with uncertain point-location, such as encountered in X-ray data analysis.
i. I N T R O D U C T I O N A traditional working tool in structural chemistry has been symmetry analysis. Symmetry point groups and space groups have been used as reference configurations which either do or do not exist in the structure under study. We have argued recently [1,2] that this traditional approach fails to capture the richness of shapes and structures, both static and dynamic, which is found in the molecular and supramolecular domains. Most of these are not symmetric. At most, they are approximately symmetric, either permanently or if the time-resolution of observation is sufficiently narrow. Consider, for instance, the very weak ( E m a x = 200) forbidden x ~ x* transition to the lowest lying singlet in benzene (A 1 ~ B12,,)and compare it with the carbon skeleton of toluene: The D6h symmetry of the benzene hexagon changes to a distinctly different point group, Czu, yet the extinction coefficient increases only to E m a x - 225. Current wisdom of accounting for the discrepancy between the major symmetry change and the small effect in the "allowedness" of the transition is to use such arguments that "the methyl perturbs the rc system only to a small extent", i.e., the day is saved by resorting to "local" symmetry. Another example is the vibrating water molecule. This is a C2~ molecule and its v~ and v 2 vibrational modes preserve this symmetry. But what about v3? This vibrational mode distorts the C2~ symmetry and again, a legitimate question is by how much does the molecule deviate from C2~ after 1% of one cycle, after 10% of it, and so forth. Yet another example is the well known phenomenon of removal of the degeneracy of energy levels of a chemical species whenever contained in an environment of symmetry other than its own (a certain arrangement of ligands or a certain packing in the crystal). The degree of removal of degeneracy is directly linked to the "decrease" in the symmetry of the environment, compared to the isolated chemical species. Traditionally, this problem is treated in terms of
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
3
jumps in the symmetry point group. For instance, the splitting of the degenerate p-orbitals increases from a2u + e, in a D4h environment to a 1 + b 1 + b 2 in a C2~ environment [3]. Our next example is the principle of conservation of orbital symmetry which has caused a quantum leap in the understanding of reaction pathways in organic chemistry. It suffices to take one very basic problem to illustrate our point: Consider two ethylenes approaching each other for a [2+2] reaction. The answer to the question of whether that reaction is allowed thermally or photochemically, or whether a suprafacial or antarafacial process will take place, or whether the reaction will take place at all, is very much dependent on the symmetry of alignment of the two reacting molecules or moieties. The extremes are D2h for a parallel approach and C 2 for an orthogonal approach, and it is predicted successfully [4] that the former is needed for a suprafacial photochemical formation of cyclobutane. Most of the time, however, the two ethylenes are not in an ideal D2h arrangement: This may be due to an intramolecular frozen conformation of the two double bonds, to nonsymmetric sterical hindrance caused by substituents on the double bond, and to the dynamical nature of the system (rotations and translations, especially in viscous media). These are but few examples which illustrate the need for a continuous scale of symmetry. A general approach which answers this need was layed out in refs. [1] and [2]. Here we summarize its main features, show how the above mentioned examples are approached, and extend our theory of continuous symmetry measures (CSM) to three new applications: 1. The CSM of (e.g., molecular orbital) contours. 2. The symmetry of occluded shapes, such that appear in microscopy studies of materials. 3. The CSM of points with uncertain locations, such as can be found in X-ray diffraction analyses in molecular structure determinations. Several previous studies were led by the need to relax the current strict language of symmetry. Hargittai and Hargittai emphasize repeatedly in their book [5] the limitations of exact symmetry in the description of many structural problems in chemistry. Murray-Rust et al. [6] and more recently Cammi and Cavalli [7] have suggested the use of symmetry coordinates to describe nuclear configurations of MX 4 molecules that can be regarded as distorted versions of the T d symmetrical reference structure. Mezey and Maurani [8,9] extended the point symmetry concept for quasi-symmetric structures by using fuzzy-set theory (terming it "syntopy" and "symmorphy"), and provided a detailed demonstration of its application for the case of the water molecule. In another recent study [10] Mezey used a resolution based similarity method of polycube filling to measure approximate symmetry of molecular distributions. Other relevant contributions are perturbation analyses in spectroscopy [11], and measures on convex-sets [12]. As will be evident below, our
4
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
approach to the problem of non-ideal symmetry is quite different, being guided by three principles: 1. Nonsymmetric shapes should not be treated as a perturbation of an ideal reference. Such shapes, as well as perfectly symmetric ones, should appear on a single continuous scale with no built-in hierarchy of subjective ideality. Assessing symmetry should be detached from referencing to a specific shape; yet the shape of the nearest configuration with the desired symmetry, should be obtainable. 3. It should be possible to evaluate the symmetry of a given configuration with respect to any symmetry group, such as the closest one. .
These guidelines are implemented as described in the following section.
Ii. C O N T I N U O U S SYMMETRY MEASURE" DEFINITION We define the continuous symmetry measure (CSM) as a quantifier of the minimum effort required to turn a given shape into a symmetric shape. This effort is measured by the sum of the square distances each point is moved from its location in the original shape to its location in the symmetric shape. Note that no a priori symmetric reference shape is assumed. Denote by ~ the space of all shapes of a given dimension, where each shape P is represented by a sequence of n points {Pi }n-1 i=0" We define a metric d on this space as follows:
d: ~x~----~R
d(P,Q) -d({Pi},
n-1 1 {Qi}) = n Z
IIPi- QilI2
i--o This metric defines a distance function between every two shapes in ~. We define the symmetry transform (ST) as the symmetric shape ifi closest to P in terms of the metric d. The CSM of a shape is now defined as the distance to the closest symmetric shape:
s - d(P,i~) The CSM of a shape P = {Pi}'7-1 i=0 is evaluated by finding the symmetry transform i~ of P and computing: n-1
n Z IIPi- Pill2
S= 1
A
i=0
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
5 symmetry
normalize
P~
P~
^
Po
transform
P, a.
-\
1,~ A
Po o
d@
S(C3)= 12.80
~
A Pz
P,
Figure 1. Calculating the CSM of a shape: (a) Original shape {Po, /:'1, P2}. (b) Normalized shape {Po', PI', P2'}, such that maximum distance to the center of mass is one. (c) Applying the symmetry transform to obtain a symmetric shape A A 2). {Po, ~1,P2}. (d) S(C3)= 1/3(IIPo' - ,goll2 + lIP1' - ^,~ + lIP2'- ,g211 CSM values are multiplied by 100 for convenience of handling.
This definition of the CSM implicitly implies invariance to rotation and translation. Normalization of the original shape prior to the transformation additionally allows invariance to scale (Figure 1). We normalize by scaling the shape so that the maximum distance between points on the contour and the centroid is a given constant (in this chapter all examples are given following normalization to 1; however, CSM values are multiplied by 100 for convenience of handling). The normalization presents an upper bound on the mean-squared distance moved by
S ( C 2) = 1.87
S ( C 3) = 1.64
S ( C 6) = 2.53
S ( ~ ) = 0.66
Figure 2. Symmetry transforms of a 2D polygon and corresponding CSM values.
6
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
points of the shape. Thus the CSM value is limited in range, where CSM = 0 for perfectly symmetric shapes (see Appendix A). The general definition of the CSM enables evaluation of a given shape for different types of symmetries (mirror symmetries, rotational symmetries, and any other symmetry groups--see Section V). Moreover, this generalization allows comparisons between the different symmetry types, and expressions such as "a shape is more mirror symmetric than rotationally symmetric of order two" is valid. An additional feature of the CSM is that we obtain the symmetric shape which is "closest" to the given one, enabling visual evaluation of the CSM. An example of a two-dimensional (2D) polygon and its symmetry transforms and CSM values are shown in Figure 2.
II!. EVALUATING THE SYMMETRY TRANSFORM In this section we describe a geometric algorithm for deriving the ST of a shape represented by a sequence of points {Pi} n-_~. In practice we find the ST of the shape with respect to a given point-symmetry group (see Appendix B for a review of algebraic definitions). For simplicity and clarity of explanation, we describe the method by following some examples. Mathematical proofs and derivations are detailed in Section IV. Following is a geometric algorithm for deriving the symmetry transform of a shape P having n points with respect to rotational symmetry of order n (C,,-symmetry). This method transforms P into a regular n-gon, keeping the centroid in place as follows:
1. Fold the points {Pi} n-1 (Figure3a) by rotating each point Pi counterclockwise about the centroid by 2xi/n radians (Figure 3b).
{Pi}in___~(Figure3c).
2. Let J~0 be the average of the points
^
eo
l
~
, o
P2
",,,
o
"~,
a.
_A
,,/ : ,,,~t
ol
0
'%',..
"'"
b.
j~:,
0
c.
.,,
d.
The Q-symmetry transform of 3 points (a) original 3 points {pi}20 . (b) Fold {pi}20 into {~i}2_o . (c)Average {F'i}2_o 2 0 ~i. (d) Unfold the _ obtaining ~'o = 1/3 Z/= 2 average point obtaining {]bi}i=o. F i g u r e 3.
:
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
7 A
~ p,
^ ~ P, ^
,
Po
P' P
a.
~
^
b
Ps
vo Figure 4. Geometric description of the C3-symmetry transform for 6 points. The centroid of the points is marked by @. (a) The original points shown as two sets of 3 points" So = {Po, P2, P4} and $1 = {P1, P3, Ps}. (b) The obtained C3-symmetric configuration.
. Unfold the points, obtaining the C n symmetric points {Ai} n_~ by duplicating ~0 and rotating clockwise about the centroid by 2rci/n radians (Figure 3d). A 2D shape P having qn points is represented as q sets {Sr}q~ of n interlaced points Sr= {Pin+r}n-li-O"The Cn symmetry transform of P is obtained by applying the above algorithm to each set of n points separately, where the folding is performed about the centroid of all the points (Figure 4). The procedure for evaluating the symmetry transform for mirror symmetry is similar: Given a shape represented by m = 2q points and given an initial guess of the symmetry axis, we apply the folding/unfolding method as follows (see Figure 5): P~o ,,v
mirror axis
^po
P~- mirror axis
mirror axis
/
1 /s
t; r
9e .
.
.
.
.
.
.
Vo~0 Figure 5. The mirror-symmetry transform of a single mirror pair for angle O (a) Mirror-fold the pair {Po, ,~ obtaining {~o, ~1}. (b) The transformed-Po denoted Po is A A the average of 75oand ~1. (c) The transformed-P1 denoted P1 is Po reflected about the symmetry axis. Center of mass of the shape is assumed to be at the origin.
8
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
1. For every pair of points {P0, P1 }: (a) F o l d u b y reflecting across the mirror symmetry axis obtaining {P0, P1}. ^ (b) Average---obtaining a single averaged point P0. (c) Unfold--by reflecting back across the mirror symmetry axis obtaining 2.
Minimize over all possible axes of mirror symmetry.
The minimization performed in step 2 is, in practice, replaced by an analytic solution (derivation and proof can be found in Appendix C). This method extends to any finite point-symmetry group in any dimension, where the folding and unfolding are performed by applying the group elements about the center of symmetry (see derivations in Section IV). The minimization is over all orientations of the symmetry group. In 2D, the minimization is performed analytically; in 3D a minimization process is used. A detailed description of the extension to 3D and to any symmetry group appeared in ref. [2] and two illustrative examples are given in Section V. We briefly mention the case where the number of points m is less than n, i.e., less than the number of elements in the symmetry group G with respect to which we measure symmetry. In this case, m should be a factor of n such that there exists a subgroup H of G with n/m elements. In this case, we duplicate each point n/m times and fold/unfold the points with elements of a left coset of G with respect to H. Following the folding/unfolding method, the relocated points will align on symmetry elements of G (on a reflection plane or on a rotation axis for example). Further details of this case and proof can be found in Ref. 2.
IV. PROOF OF THE FOLDING METHOD As described in Section I, the CSM of a set of points with respect to a given symmetry group G is evaluated by first finding the set of points which is G-symmetric and which is closest to the given set in terms of the average distance squared. We must thus prove that the folding method indeed finds the closest symmetric set of points. The group-theory definitions which are used in this section, are briefly reviewed in Appendix B. Given a finite point-symmetry group G centered at the origin and ordering of its m elements {gl = I . . . . . gin} and given m general points P1 . . . . . Pm' find m points ~1 ~m and find rotation matrix R and translation vector w such that ~1 . . . . . ~m form an ordered orbit under G' (where G' is the symmetry group G rotated by R and translated by w) and bring the following expression to a minimum: . . . . .
m
A
~ IIPi- Pill2 i=1
(1)
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
9 A
Since G has a fixed point at the origin and G' has the centroid of orbit Pi asAafixed point (see gemma 1, Appendix B) we have that w is the centroid of orbit Pi: m
1
A
w =-Z Pi m
(2)
i=1
(Note that in the cases where the fixed points of G form an axis or plane, w can be any vector moving the origin to the (rotated) axis or plane passing through the centroid of orbit ~i- Thus also in these cases w can be considered the centroid of orbit ~i). The points ~l J~m form an orbit of G', thus the following must be satisfied, . . . . .
A
A
A
Pi = gi'P1 = RtgiR(P1 - w) + w
(3)
i = 1 ... m
wheregi'isthematr ixrepresentation ofthei thsymmetry element of G' and is equal to the ith symmetry element gi of G rotated by R and translated by w. Using Lagrange multipliers with Eqs. 1-3 we must minimize the following, m
in
m
A
A
A
__
A
Z IIPi- Pi 112+ 2 ~'~(Pi- RtgiR(P1 - w) + w) + c(w - 1 Z Pi) m
i=1
i=1
i=1
where e, ~i for i = 1 . . . m are the Lagrange multipliers. Equating the derivatives to zero we obtain, m A
Y__, ( P i - Pi) = 0
(4)
i=1
and using the last constraint (Eq. 2) we obtain, m
1
(5)
w = - -m ~_ P.t i=1 A
A
i.e., the centroid of P1 . . . . Pm coincides with the centroid of P1 . . . . . Pm (in terms of the symmetry measure defined in Section I, the centroid of a configuration and the centroid of the closest symmetric configuration is the same for any point symmetry group G). Noting that gi" a r e isometries and distance preserving, we have from the derivatives: m Z
i=1
m Pt
g i(Pi
_
A
^
P/) = Y_-,Rtg~R(Pi- Pi) = 0 i=1
Expanding using the constraints we obtain,
10
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR A
m
m
mP1 = Z Rtg:gPi- Z gtg:gW i=1
i=1
or,
m P^ l - W = ~1 ZRtglR(Pi
m
w)
(6)
i=1
The geometric interpretation of Eq. 6 is the folding method as described in Section III, thus proving that the folding method results in the G-symmetric set of points closest to the given set. Given n = qm points (i.e., q sets of m points) {P~ . . . . . P J } i = 1 . . . q we obtain the result given in Eq. 6 for each set of m points separately; i.e., for j = 1 . . . q, ^"
PJ1 - w = -
1
m
m
~
RtglR(P i - w)
(7)
i=1
where w = nl ]~q=l ~]mi=l pji is the centroid of all n points. The geometric interpretation of Eq. 7 is the folding method as described in Section III for m = qn points.
V. EXAMPLES OF MEASURING SYMMETRY IN 3D: TETRAHEDRICITY AND ROTATING ETHANE A. Tetrahedricity of Phosphates We retum now to the general question: given any number of vertices in space, what is its symmetry measure with respect to any symmetry group, subgroup, or class. As explained in the previous section, the generalized approach is to divide the given points into sets and to apply the folding/unfolding method separately on each set, while evaluating the CSM value over all the given points. For example, let us analyze the tetrahedricity of a tetrahedron with a branched connected set of 5 points P1 ... P5 as shown in Figure 6a, which models a tetrahedron with a central atom and apply the CSM folding/unfolding method to evaluate its Ta symmetry. The connectivity constrains the division of points into sets and restricts the center point (P5) to be a one-point set. We thus divide the points into two sets: {P1 ... P4} and {Ps}. The closest symmetric configuration will have point P5 relocated to a position where all 24 of the Ta-symmetry group elements leave it in place. The only such position is at the origin (centroid of the configuration marked as an open circle in Figure 6) where all symmetry planes and axes intersect. Points P1 . . . P4 will be relocated to form a perfect Ta-symmetric configuration of four points, i.e., each point will lie on a C3-rotation axis (see Figure 6b). S(T d) (or any S(G)) is then calculated by considering the full set of ~l . ' . ~5. To illustrate it, we now analyze the distorted phosphate tetrahedron CdzP207 [6] using our method. We first recall that our method evaluates the distance from
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
a.
11
b.
Figure 6. A distorted tetrahedron with a central atom, analyzed as a connected configuration of 5 points. (a) The open circle marks the centroid of the configuration; (b) the closest Td-symmetric configuration.
tetrahedricity and not from a specific tetrahedron; and that rather than reporting the deviation in terms of a table of many coordinates (as done in ref. [6]), we provide a single (S(Td)) value. To obtain it, the 3D position coordinates of the four oxygens and phosphorus were taken from ref. [ 13] (also used by Btirgi et al., p. 1790 in their paper) as, P1 - (
0.0
P2 = (
0.0
0.0
1.645)
1.518860 -0.347028)
P3 - ( -1.286385 -0.700083 -0.391603) P4 = ( 1.179085 -0.755461 -0.372341) with an additional center point 0.0. By applying the folding method as described above, the symmetry measure obtained in this example is S(Td) = 0.17 and the closest symmetric shape is a regular tetrahedron with arm length 1.537 ~. (By comparison, a set of 10 symmetry displacement coordinates is used in ref. [6] to report the deviation of this tetrahedron from ideality). In a further example Murray-Rust et al. used the symmetry coordinates to evaluate the threefold axes of 1-methyl- 1-silabicycloheptane (Section V in ref. [6]). They found that the distorted SiC 4 structure (Figure 5 in ref. [6]) is better described with the threefold axis passing through one vertex (point C 1 in their notation) rather than through another (C 2 in their notation). Using the CSM method with respect to C3~-symmetry we easily support their conclusion as follows. Given the coordinates, P~ = C~ = (
0.0
0.0
1.645)
P2 = C2 =(
0.0
0.87461971
-0.48480962)
P3 = C3 = (
0.75128605 -0.39338892 -0.52991926)
P4 = C4 = ( -0.75128605 --0.39338892 --0.52991926)
12
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
with Si at the origin, the S(C3u) of the configuration was calculated by the method described in Section V and found to be S(C3u) = 0.02 when the threefold axis passes through point C 1, compared to S(C3~) = 1.16 when the threefold axis is constrained to pass through point C 2. Using the folding method we can also measure the C3~-symmetry of the configuration with the constraint that three of the configuration points are equatorial. In this case the S value increases to 5.26, with the threefold axes passing through point C 2.
B. The Rotating Tetrahedra of Ethane 1 Another mechanism which strongly affects molecular symmetry is intramolecular rotation. Consider, for instance, one of the most basic examples; namely, the rotation of the two ethane tetrahedra around the C-C bond (Figure 7a). Current wisdom allows an exceedingly poor description of that process from the symmetry point of view: Ethane is D3dwhen staggered (Figure 7d), D3h when eclipsed (Figure 7b), and D 3 anywhere in between, including the rotamer which is only 1 ~ away from any of the extremes. Doesn't physical intuition dictate that it is more natural to ask about that 1~ rotamer, how much D3h or D3a it contains? Or for that matter, how much D3h and D3a exists at any point in a full 360" cycle? As has already become evident throughout this paper, the CSM method allows one to select any symmetry group and follow its gradual changes along such a full 360 ~ cycle of rotation. We demonstrate it on two perfect tetrahedral structures connected along one of the tetrahedral arms and rotating with respect to each other around the
P4
ao
P4Vl
P1 ~,,
1"6
P2
b. Ps
l~6
~
P2J
c.
as/'
: ~P3
d.
Figure 7. Modeling the C-C rotation in ethane. (a) Only the right hand tetrahedron moves; (b) the cycle starts with the eclipsed D3h rotamer; (c) one of the six chiramers (see text); (d) the D3d staggered rotamer.
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
13
connecting arm. We model this by stabilizing one of the tetrahedra and rotating the other, beginning the cycle with the two tetrahedra perfectly aligned (eclipsed) and rotating the second tetrahedron anti-clockwise. For simplicity in evaluating the S value, we considered only the tetrahedral arms not involved in the C-C bond. Figure 8 displays the result where the S value is given as a function of the cycle. (Figure 8a shows a full 360 ~ cycle and Figure 8b shows a detail). The following observations are made: 9 The D3h profile of the rotation and the D3d profile are similar, but shifted from each other by 60 ~ That is, there is as much D3d-ness in the eclipsed structure as there is D3h-ness in the staggered structure. This is intuitive since the distance (rotation or projection) from an e~ position to the 0 ~ position (eclipsed) which determines the S(O3h) value, is equivalent to the distance (rotation or projection) from a 60 ~ + e~ position to the 60 ~ position (staggered) and which determines the S(D3a) value. 9 The maximal S(D3h) value is at the 60 ~ staggered rotamer which is the farthest away from the perfect D3h eclipsed rotamer (0 ~ S(D3h) = 0). Three such maxima are observed in a full cycle, corresponding to the three staggered rotamers. Similarly, the maximal S(D3a) value is for the eclipsed rotamer at 0 ~ and again, there are three maxima in a full cycle corresponding to the three eclipsed rotamers. 9 Figure 8 points to a rotamer (Figure 7c) which is neither eclipsed nor staggered, but in between, at 30 ~ + n.60 ~ We term these special chiral (?) rotamers at 30 ~ + n.60~ (Figure 7c). There are six of these in a full cycle, compared to three eclipsed and three staggered (which are, of course, achiral). These six chiramers, which are at the crossing of the continuous D3h and D3d profile lines, are also the six maxima of the continuous C3u profile line. Note that the C3u line (which is equivalent to the ~y-line) coincides with either the D3h line (00-30 ~ 90~ ~. . . . ) or with the D3a line (30~ ~ 150~ ~. . . . ), whichever gives the lower S value. To understand this, we note that C3u is a subgroup of both D3hand D3dand that in ethane, the nearest C3u object at any point of the full cycle must be either of the two achiral rotamers. Thus, the chiramer is also the most chiral rotamer of ethane. Finally, we wish to make a brief preliminary comment on what seems to us an important application of our approach: Many thermodynamic and kinetic quantities vary cyclically with internal rotations. A commonly presented quantity is the (repulsion) potential. It is then interesting to see, how this property varies with the symmetry rather than with the traditional torsion angle. The results for a model sinusoidal potential (Figure 9a) are shown in Figure 9b. Let us first detail how the potential follows this new process coordinate: The D3h potential line varies smoothly with S, starting at the eclipsed S = 0 value and dropping to zero potential at the staggered S = 22.22 value; then it reverses and climbs back up to the maximum
14
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I I I
30
I D3d D3h C3v
25 =
I
staggered
staggered
staggered
20
15 10
,::'
'.
9/
\ X
ao
60
1_. '~
,,,,t
,
120
180
240
,,
300
360
Torsion Angle
25
........
i
i. . . . . . . . . .
l . . . . . . . .
1
...... i D3d
staggered ~ ~ 20
,
D3h
..':..
i
C3v ----
...y.///......':""y......
15
N
....."
10
eclipsed b.
0
0
j""
chirarners
/,," ,,~
20
40
'...
t/ ,,,,
%\%
60
80
eclipsed
100 120 Torsion Angle
Figure 8. D3d ( ~ ) , D3h (. . . . ), and C3v( . . . . ) for rotating ethane. (a) A full cycle; (b) a detail of one third of the cycle. potential completing 120 ~ of the cycle. This drop and rise in potential along the symmetry coordinate is repeated continuously, completing a full 360 ~ cycle. The behavior of D3d is a mirror image, starting with the maximal potential at the eclipsed S = 22.22 value and dropping to zero potential at the staggered S = 0 value. The
--.
.
--
-~
--.
--'~.
~:~
0
~
~D
"/'1
0
o
="
~D
.~o
~w
_,~-~. ..~
0 rD
0
rD
~_.o
03
5"o.
~D
rD
~D
to
~'~
o~
o
*
'
I
to
I
.1~
'
I,,
ox
I ......
00
o
1
,,
1
b~
1
4~
Potential (arbitrary units)
i
o~
I
'ii
g:r g~.
oo
o
0
k~
o
o
~
~I
OX
o ~
o
,
t.~
f~ ~
....~.....
"~
~
~
.,,.i.t
~.".~
f"
f
f
"'-. ......
"--~L
~
Symmetry Measure
~ ~
........
~
~
.
~
-.
9
-
~
~
.
~
....
"...
-
..
..
tO
o
~
"~
.....
.~
tO
~
"a
c~
O~
1
~"
o
............ , ........
.............. [=:::. ~'
~
. .:.:_. ..........................
71
'
~-,
o
and Potential (arbitrary units)
1
, ......
o
t~
16
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
behavior of C3~ is interesting: up to S = 5.95 it follows the D3h line, but then it continues to drop along the D3d line back towards the S = 0 value (the line then climbs back up). Perhaps most notable is that the lines of the two symmetry groups bifurcate at the 30~ What does such symmetry/potential bifurcation mean? In general, it may mean that for symmetry-governed processes, such a crossing point is where the process may select to proceed one way or the other depending on which symmetry is preferred.
Vi.
POINT SELECTION FOR REPRESENTATION OF CONTOURS
As symmetry has been defined on a sequence of points, representing a given shape by points must precede the application of the symmetry transform. Thus, for the case of equi-property contours, such as electronic orbital contours, one represents it as a string of equally spaced points (as dense as one wishes) and then perform the CSM folding-unfolding procedure as usual. As described in Section III, when a multiple of n points are given (where n is the number of elements in the symmetry group), the points must be divided into sets of 17points. In general, this problem is exponential. However when the points are cyclically connected or ordered such as along a contour, the ordering of the points restricts the possible divisions into sets. For example in 2D, points along the contour of a C,,-symmetric shape form orbits which are interlaced as shown in Figure 10a for C3-symmetry. Thus, given a set of m = n q ordered points there is only one possible division of the points into q sets of n points--the q sets must be interlaced (as was shown in Figure 4). In the case of D,,-symmetry the m = 2 n q ordered points, form q orbits which are interlaced and partially inverted as shown in Figure 10b for D4-symmetry. Thus, given a set of m = 2nq ordered points there are m / 2 n = q possible division of the points. In Figure 11 we demonstrate the application of the contour CSM analysis on the lone-pair orbital of a distorted water molecule (perhaps a frozen moment of a vibration, or a water molecule in a matrix of amorphous ice, or a water molecule trapped in a micropore). The ratio of length of the two O-H bonds is 0.9 (instead
bo
Figure 10.
W
W
Dividing m selected points into interlaced sets" (a) Cn-symmetry--one possibility. (b) Dn-symmetry--one of the m/2n possibilities.
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
17
/ i
a.
b./ \
, .,4:
,..,,
, ,~ 'lvk'12,\xttll,lll
,
S(o) =0.116 all
bQ
S(o) = 0.213
Figure 11. Two equi-amplitude contours of the wave function of the lone-pair orbital of distorted water molecule are shown. 14'15 The two contours are spaced by 0.05 Bohr-3/2, and the value of the outer one is 0.576 Bohr-3/2. S((~) values are indicated in the figure. The CSM value for the next inner contour (not shown) is 0.248.
of 1.0) and the H - O - H angle is 104 ~ [ 1 4 ] . Two contours are shown, each of which has been represented as a string of about 200 points. The CSM with respect to mirror symmetry was evaluated by the above-mentioned m = n q pairing. It is seen quantitatively (Figure 11) that the distortive effects of the unequal bonds, fades away from the inner to the outer contours.
18
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
Vii.
SYMMETRY OF OCCLUDED SHAPES
Here we address a problem which is commonly encountered in microscopy studies of particulate materials" Given a collection of similar objects, such that the individual shapes occlude each other, how can the symmetry of these objects be extracted using methods of automated image analysis. The method we apply to solve the problem is to evaluate the symmetry of the occluded shapes, locate the center of symmetry, and reconstruct the symmetric shape most similar to the unoccluded original. As described in Section VI, a shape can be represented by points selected at equal distances along the contour. Another method of representing a shape is by selecting points at regular angular intervals (selection-by-angle) about a point (Figure 12). Angular selection is usually about the centroid of the shape. However, angular selection of points about a point other than the centroid will give a different symmetry measure value (Figure 13). We define the center ofsymmetry of a shape as that point about which angular selection gives the minimum symmetry measure value. When a symmetric shape is not occluded the center of symmetry aligns with the centroid of the shape. However, the center of symmetry of truncated or occluded objects does not align with its centroid but aligns with the (unknown) centroid of the unoccluded shape. Thus the center of symmetry of a shape is robust under truncation and occlusion. To locate the center of symmetry, we use an iterative procedure of gradient descent that converges from the centroid of an occluded shape to the center of symmetry. Denote by center of selection that point about which points are selected using angular selection. We initialize the iterative process by setting the centroid as the center of selection. At each step we compare the symmetry value of points angularly selected about the center of selection and about points in its immediate neighborhood. That point about which angular selection gives minimum symmetry
I..... i , ~
i
i
', ',
\ \
Figure 12. Selection at equal angles. Points are distributed along the contour at regular angular intervals around the centroid.
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry ~"
\',,, \
:
19 4o,'~
,,,/
"-,"
; _l
Figure 13. The symmetry value obtained by angular selection about the center of mass (marked by +) is greater than the symmetry value obtained by angular selection about the center of symmetry (marked by (9).
value, is set to be the new center of selection. If the center of selection does not change, the neighborhood size is decreased. The process is terminated when neighborhood size reaches a predefined minimum size. The center of selection at the end of the process is taken as the center of symmetry. The closest symmetric shape obtained by angular selection about the center of symmetry (Figure 14c) is visually more similar to the original (Figure 14a) than that obtained by angular selection about the centroid of the occluded shape (Figure 14b). We consider the former a reconstruction of the unoccluded shape. The process of reconstructing the occluded shape can be improved by altering the method of evaluating the symmetry of a set of points. As described in Section III the symmetry of a set of points is evaluated by folding, averaging, and unfolding about the centroid of the points. We alter the method as follows: 1. The folding and unfolding (steps 1 and 3) will be performed about the center of selection rather than about the centroid of the points.
(9+
a
Figure 14. (a) Original occluded shape, its centroid (+) and its center of symmetry ((9). (b,c) The closest C5-symmetric shapes following angular selection about the centroid (b) and about the center of symmetry (c).
20
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
:',yn ,
9 /',,..
l
..,*
,
-","
i
;
/
," 9
#
9
i
~
i..
9. . . .
,
l
"S'"
',,....... ..y
Q
,
~ +~ i
+",+,,.
i
,
a.
V
,
~
,...... ",,,
b.'~'
"%'.,,.
t
. . . . .,,
.
',
1"-
"', ..... -..
,/
i ....... " " t
d. ',,/
c.','
Figure 15. Improving the averaging of folded points. (a) An occluded shape with
points selected using angular selection about the center of symmetry (marked as @). (b) A single set (orbit) of the selected points of (a) is shown. (c) Folding the points about the centroid of the shape (marked as +), points are clustered sparsely. (d) Folding the points about the center of symmetry of the shape, points are clustered tightly. Eliminating the extremes (the two furthest points) and averaging will result in smaller averaging error and better reconstruction.
2.
Rather than averaging the folded points (step 2), we apply a more robust clustering method: we average over the folded points, drop the points furthest from the average (this is justified by noticing that such points are due to occlusion), and then reaverage (see Figure 15).
The improvement in reconstruction of an occluded shape is shown in Figure 16. This method improves both the shape and the localization of the reconstruction.
8,,
"'. .....
.'
be
",,,.,+. . . . .
/
Co
, ......
/
Figure 16. Reconstruction of an occluded almost symmetric shape. The original shape is shown as a dashed line. The reconstructed shape is shown as a solid line. (a) The closest symmetric shape following angular selection about the centroid. (b) The closest symmetric shape following angular selection about the center of symmetry. (c) The closest symmetric shape following angular selection about the centroid and altered symmetry evaluation (see text).
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
21
VIii. SYMMETRY OF POINTS WITH UNCERTAIN LOCATIONS Information obtained from any analytical instrument has a certain degree of uncertainty. In structural chemistry, the uncertainty may be in the location of the atoms, as obtained by, e.g., diffraction methods, due to unknown causes (crystal imperfections, thermal motion, etc.) [16]. We address ourselves now, to this problem, again focusing on symmetry issues. Quite often the data is given as a collection of probability distribution functions of point locations. Given points with such uncertain locations, the following questions are of interest: 9 What is the most probable symmetric shape represented by the data? 9 What is the probability distribution of symmetry measure values for the given data?
A. The Most Probable Symmetric Shape Figure 18a shows a configuration ofpoints whose locations are given by a normal distribution function (marked as rectangles having width and length proportional to the standard deviation). In this section we show a method of evaluating the most probable symmetric shape closest to the data. For simplicity we derive the method with respect to rotational symmetry of order n (Cn-symmetry). The solution for mirror symmetry is similar (see Appendix D). Given n points in 2D whose positions are given as normal probability distributions: Oi ""N(Pi,Ai) i = 0 . . . n - 1, we find the C,,-symmetric configuration of points {pi}~)-i which is most probable. Denote by co the center of mass of ~i: n-1
1
A
O ~ = -rl- Z
Pi .
i=o A
Having that {Pi}~-I are Cn-symmetric, the following must be satisfied, A
A
P i - Ri(Po- ~) + ~
(8)
for i = 0 . . . n - 1 where R i is a matrix representing a rotation of 2xi/n radians. Thus, given the measurements Q0. . . . . Q,,-1 wAeneed to find the most probable J~0and o). We find i~0 and c0 that maximize Prob({ Pi} 7~ ] to,~0} under the symmetry constraints of Eq. 8. Considering the normal distribution we have, n-1
]
A
I'I ki exp(- -~-(Pi i=o
A - Pi)tAsl l(Pi - Pi)
22
where
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR 1
ki = ~- n ]Ai[ 1/2. Having log being a monotonic function, we maximize: n-1 1
^
A
log I I ki exp(- ~- (Pi- Pi)tATl(Pi - Pi)
i=o Thus we need to find those parameters which maximize, n-1
1
^
^
- "2 E (Pi- Pi)tATl(Pi- Pi) i=o under the symmetry constraint of Eq. 8. Substituting Eq. 8, taking the derivative with respect to P0, and equating to zero we obtain: n-1
n-1
n-1
A
E RIAT~IRiP~+ E R~Ai-1(1- Ri)o = E RiAi t -1Pi i=0
i=0
,i
(9)
i=0
B
e
Note that R0 = I where I is the identify matrix. When the derivative with respect to 03 is zero: n-1
n-1
n-1
A
E (I- Ri)t'kiRiPo + ~ (I- Ri)tAT,l(l - Re)03= E (I-- Ri)tATtlPi i=0
'
i=0
b
t ,
,
(10)
i-O
D
'
'
F"
'
Note that when all A i are equal (i.e., all points have the same uncertainty, which is equivalent to the cases in the previous sections where point location is known with no uncertainty), Eqs. 9-10 reduce to Eqs. 5-6 in Section IV. Reformulating Eqs. 9 and 10 in matrix formation we obtain"
U V z Noting that U is symmetric we solve by inversion V = U-1Z and obtain the parameters 03 and P0, and obtain the most probable Cn-symmetric configuration, given the measurements {Qi} n-1 i=0" Similar to the representation in Section III, given m = qn measurements { Qi} m-1 i=0, we consider them as q sets of n interlaced measurements" {aiq+j } n~ for j = 0 . . . q - 1 (see Figure 17). The derivations given above are applied to each set of n measurements separately, in order to obtain the most probable Cn-symmetric set of points {Pi}im_fo 1. Thus the symmetry constraints that must be satisfied are,
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
23
P0 s
s"
P1
,,, "
,,, "
i
"s
; o.
i
-:
;'-
i
,
/
/
', p
/
'
5
t
p"
................. .
,,
~"
""
P4
Figure 17. A configuration of 6 measurements represented as two interlaced sets of three measurements. One set is marked by the solid lines and the other set is marked by the dotted lines.
~Siq+j= Ri(Pj - 0)) + O) for j = 0 . . . q - 1 and i = 0 . . . n - 1 where, again, Ri is a matrix representing a rotation of 2xi/n radians and co is the centeroid of all points {J6i}mol. As derived in Eq. 9, we obtain f o r j = 0 . . . q - 1, n-1 Z
n-1 t -1
n-1
A
Rt.A-I /9 RiAiq+YiPj + Z RiAiq+j(It -I Ri)o)= Z i--iq+j, iq+j i=o i=o i_--o
Aj
(11)
kj
Bj
and equating to zero, the derivative with respect to w, we obtain, similar to gq. 10: q-1 n-1
q-1 n-1
(12)
q-1 n-1
A
~_~~ (1- Ri)tAiq+jRiPj+ Z Z (I- Ri)tA~l+j(l-Ri)o)= Z E (i- Ri)tA~l+jPiq+j j=0 i---O
j=0 i=0
j---O i=0
b
k
Reformulating Eqs. 11 and 12 in matrix formation we obtain"
~Ao
Bo A1
B~
f
A
Po A P1
rEo~ E1 ~
A
Aq_l Bq_l CO C 1 " " C q _ 1 D
Pq-1 CO
Eq-1
F k
J
ii
U
V
z
24
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
/ a.
1 " ' ~ ....
Figure 18. (a) A configuration of 6 measurements given by a normal distribution function (marked as rectangles having width and length proportional to the standard deviation). The most probable symmetric shapes with respect to: (b) C2-symmetry. (c) C3-symmetry. (d) C6-symmetry. (e) Mirror-symmetry.
Noting that U is sffmmetric we solve by inversion V = U-1Z and obtain the parameters co and {Pj}q~, and obtain the most probable C,,-symmetric configuration, {Pj}jmf_ol given the m e a s u r e m e n t s {Oi} m-1 i=0. Several examples are shown in Figure 18 where for a given set of measurements (Figure 18a), the most probable symmetric shapes are shown (Figure 18b--e for C 2, C 3, C 6 and mirror symmetry respectively). Figure 19 shows an example of varying the probability distribution of a measurement on the resulting symmetric shape. Figure 19a shows the most probable C2-symmetric shape for the set of measurements ofFigure 18a. Figures 19b-d show the most probable C2-symmetric shape after varying the distribution of the bottom measurement.
B. The Probability Distribution of Symmetry Values Here the question of interest is not the closest symmetric configuration, but rather the symmetry measure or the probability distribution of the symmetry measure values given the probability distributions of the point locations. Consider the configuration of measurements in 2D given in Figure 20a. Each measurement Qi is a normal probability distribution Qi "" N(Pi,Ai). Without loss of
Figure 19. The most probable C2-symmetric shape for a set of measurements after varying the probability distribution of the bottom measurement. Distributions are normal distributions marked as rectangles having width and length proportional to the standard deviation.
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
25
Qo
~
Q2. Qo
\, ii 2~.
:
/
,: ,,
"t % ',
+
i
"
i
Figure 20. (a) A configuration of 6 measurements Qi. (b) Each measurement Qi was rotated 2xi/6 radians about the centroid (marked as '+') obtaining measurement Oi.
generality, we assume the centroid of the configuration is at the origin 9In order to evaluate the Cn-symmetry distribution (in our case n = 6) we rotate each measurement Q.z by 2xi/n radians about the origin obtaining the configuration of measurements Qi as in Figure 20b. Denote by X i the 2D random variable having a normal distribution equal to that of measurement Qi, i.e.,
E(Xi) = RiP i Cov(Xi) = RiAiR I where Ri denotes (as in Section III) the rotation matrix of 2~i/n radians. Denote by Yi the two-dimensional random variable, n-1
1
Yi-- Xi--~ Z Xj j=o
in matrix notation,
Xo
ro =A
i-I
k
Y
or Y = AX where Y and X are of dimension 2n and A is the 2n x 2n matrix: n-1 o -1 A =.1_
o n-1 0
-1 0 9
o
0 -1 0
-1 0 -1
. . . "~ ... 999
n
n-1
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
26 And we have"
ov(Xo) Cov(X) =
E(X) =
Cov(X._l)
(Xn-1) Cov(Y) = ACov(X)A t
E(Y) = AE(X)
The matrix ACov(X)A t, being symmetric and positive definite, we find the 2n x 2n matrix V diagonalizing Cov(Y), i.e., V A C o v ( X ) A t V t = D,
where D is a diagonal matrix [of rank 2(n - 1 )]. Denote by Z = (Z 0. . . . . 2n-dimensional random variable VAX:
"'"
o~-~176 ,..-
'
~
o ',
,..-
......... 350
-'"'"
!
.. ',
\
oo-"~
\
,...'"
o
"
b."'"|
Zn_l) t the
.,o
"""
l
,
v'"
!
d. "'"-[ ....................
| ..............
\l
..~..
|
--......
'a'
reobaNlity nsxty
b'
'c'
~
300
- -
----- - -
......
250
200
150
\\ // ''~ /," . ......... " \ " -~.:.%
I00
/,..
/
.4
o .........
0.015
..~.~'z ,j ...;';5" "-:'-r ";c O. 02
.
"""
"~\
,
O. 025
h
0.03
,,
..i.. .....
""" "'l --
-- L"
0.035
Z "" "-.""-'r-- -_- . . . . . . . . . . . .
I "" . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0.04 0. 045
Symmetry Value
0
Figure 21. (a-d) Some examples of configurations of measurements. (e) Probability distribution of symmetry values (with respect to C6 symmetry) for the configurations (a-d).
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
27
E(Z) = VAE(X) Cov(Z) = V A C o v ( X ) A t V t = D Thus the random variables Z i that compose Z are independent and, being linear combinations of X i, they are of normal distribution. The symmetry measure, as defined in Section III, is equivalent, in the current notations, to S = y t y . Having S orthonormal we have: S -- ( V A X ) t V A X - Z t Z
If Z were a random variable of standard normal distribution, we would have s being of a Z2 distribution of order 2(n - 1). In the general case Z i are normally distributed but not standard and Z cannot be standardized globally. We approximate the distribution of s as a normal distribution with: E(S) = E(Z)tE(Z) + traceDtD
Cov(S) = 2trace(DtD)(DtD) + 4E(Z)tDtDE(Z) In Figure 2 le we display distributions of the symmetry measure as obtained for the examples in Figure 21 a-d. Application of the method described here to thermal ellipsoids in X-ray analysis is in progress.
NOTE 1. This section is also Erratum to Section 4.4 in ref. 2. We thank A. Cotton and Y. Pinto for drawing our attention to an error.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank Prof. S. Peleg for his guidance and Prof. S. Shaik for his continuous interest in this project [14]. D.A. is a member of the F. Haber Research Center for Molecular Dynamics and of the Farkas Center for Light-Energy Conversion.
APPENDICES Appendix A: The Bounds of S Values Following the definition of the continuous symmetry measure (CSM) in Section II, the CSM values are limited to the range 0 . . . 1 (where 1 is the normalization scale). The lower bound of the CSM is obvious from the fact that the average of the square of the distances moved by the object points, is necessarily non-negative. The upper bound of the average is limited to 1 since the object is previously
28
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
normalized to maximum distance of 1 and by translation of all vertex points to the center of mass, a symmetric shape is obtained. The upper bound on the CSM can be tightened for specific cases. For instance in 2D one can show that the maximum S value for a triangle, with respect to C 3 is 1/3" consider the three vertices of a normalized triangle P1, P2, P3 in 2D (the centroid is at the origin). W.l.g. assume P1 = (0,1) and that P2 has a positive x-coordinate and denote by (x,y) the coordinates of P2" Given the constraint that the centroid is at the origin, one has P3 = ( - x , - 1 - y ) . In fact P2 is limited to a circle sector due to the centroid constraint and the normalization constraint (limiting all Pi's to be in the unit circle). Given these notations, we have that the S value of the triangle with respect to C3-symmetry, is given by:
1
+
y2 + y - "43x + x 2)
Considering the limited range of the P2 coordinates, the maximum value is obtained when P2 = (0,0) or P2 = (0,-1) (which are equivalent cases) and the maximum CSM value is 1/3. The maximum CSM value is actually obtained for extreme cases such as a polygon of m vertices (m = qn) whose contour outlines a regular q-gon (i.e., every q-th vertex of the m-gon coincides with a vertex of a regular q-gon). For details, see Appendix in Part I [1].
Appendix B: Orbits We first review some basic definitions required for our proofs and derivations: 9 The orbit ofx under a group G is the set { g x i g ~ G}. 9 x and y belong to the same orbit if y = gx for some g ~ G. Given a finite group G and given an ordering of its elements" gl, g2. . . . . gm' the orbit under G of a point x in Euclidean space is x 1. . . . . x m such that x i = gix for i = 1 . . . m. If gl = e (the identity element of G) then x i = gixl i = 1 . . . m.
Lemma 1. The centroid o f an orbit o f finite point-symmetry group G is invariant under G.
A point x ~ X is a general point (or is in general position) with respect to G if for all g ~ G, g g: e (where e is the identity in G) we have gx r x . L e m m a 2. I f x is a general point with respect to G then all points in the orbit o f x are general points. Furthermore f o r gl,g2 ~ G gl g: g2 ~ gl x g: g2x"
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
29
Thus if x is a general point its orbit contains N(G) different points [N(G) is the number of elements in group G]. Lemrna 3. If the orbit o f x has a point in common with the orbit of y ureter G, then the two orbits are equal. For any x ~ X the group G x = {g ~ G [ g x - x} is called the isotropy subgroup of G at x and it contains all elements of group G that leave x invariant. If x is a general point, its isotropy subgroup contains a single element of G u t h e identity, i.e., G x = {e}. L e m m a 4. If G is finite, the number of different points in the orbit containing x is N(G)/N(GX). Proof is immediate from the 1-1 relationship between points in the orbit of x and the left cosets of Gx. Each left coset of G x consists of all elements of G that map x to a specific point y).
Appendix C" Finding the Optimal Orientation in 2D Following the derivation in Section IV we derive, here, an analytic solution to finding the orientation (rotation matrix R) which minimizes Eq. 1 under the constraints given in Eqs. 2-3. In Part I [1] (Appendix A.2) we gave the derivation for the specific case of the D 1 group having the two elements" {E, (5}. In 2D there are two classes of point symmetry groups: the class C n having rotational symmetry of order n, and the class D n having rotational symmetry of order n and n reflection axes. The problem of finding the minimizing orientation is irrelevant for the C n symmetry groups and R is usually taken as I (the identity matrix). We derive here a solution for the orientation in the case where G is a D n symmetry group. The 2n elements of the Dn-symmetry group (gl . . . . . g2n) are the n elements E, C,1~, cZn. . . . . C,~-1 (gl . . . . . gn respectively), and the n elements obtained by applying a reflection (5 on each of these elements: Cy,6Cln, ~CZn. . . . . cyC~-1 (g,,+l . . . . . g2,, respectively). We denote the orientation of the symmetry group as the angle 0 between the reflection axis and the y axis. Thus: ( c o s O sinO0) R - [-sin 0 cos Without loss of generality we assume the centroid (w) is at the origin. The matrix representation of the rotational elements of D n is then g[ = Rtgi R = gi for i = 1 . . . n. The matrix representation of the operation 6 is given by:
30
HAGIT ZABRODSKY and DAVID AVNIR
/c~ 0 - s i n 00//-10 01/( c~ sin 00/= (-c~ 20 - sin 20 / ~-sin 0 cos [--sin 20 cos 20
RI= Rtgn+lR = ~,sin 0 cos p
and gi = Rf gi-n for i = n + 1 . . . 2n. Thus from Section IV we must minimize the following over 0: 2n
2n A
A
E IlPj- Pill2 = E llg~Pj- PIll 2 j=l
j=l 2n
2n
1 = y_~ IIg,tjPj- -~n E g,t)Pjl12
j=l 2n
i=1 n
2n
= E II E glPi + E Rf glPi- 2ng'~Pjll2 j=l
i=1
(13)
i=n+l
Denoting by Xi,Yi the coordinates of the point g ,tp i i and taking the derivative of Eq. 13 with respect to 0 we obtain: n
tan20=
E E i=1
2n
(xiYj+ xjYi) j=~+l 2n
En E i=1
(14)
(xixj- yiy,) j=n+l
which is an analytic solution for the 2D case of orientation. However in higher dimensions a minimization procedure is used.
Appendix D" The Most Probable Mirror Symmetric Shape In Section VIII we described a method for finding the most probable rotationally symmetric shape given measurements of point location. The solution for mirror symmetry is similar. In this case, given m measurements (where m = 2q), the unknown parameters are {i~ i_ }q_-~,03and 0 where 0 is the angle of the reflection axis. However these parameters are redundant and we reduce the dimensionality of the problem by replacing two-dimensional 03 with the one dimensional x0 representing the x-coordinate at which the reflection axis intersects the x-axis. Additionally we replace Ri, the rotation matrix with: (cos 20 sin 20 R - ~sin 20 -cos 20) the reflection about an axis at an angle 0 to the x-axis. The angle 0 is found analytically (see ref. [1]) thus the dimensionality of the problem is 2q+l (rather
Measuring Symmetry in Structural Chemistry
31
than 2q+2) and elimination of the last row and column of matrix U (see Section VIII.A) allows an inverse solution as in the rotational symmetry case.
NOTE ADDED IN PROOF Part 4 in this series appeared, and is devoted to a detailed analysis of the implications of the CSM approach to chirality: Zabrodsky, H.; Avnir, D. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1995, 117, 462.
REFERENCES AND NOTES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
15. 16.
Zabrodsky, H.; Peleg, S.; Avnir, D. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1992, 114, 7843. Zabrodsky, H.; Peleg, S.; Avnir, D. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1993, 115, 8278. Table 6-12 in ref. 5. Fleming, I. Frontier Orbitals and Organic Chemical Reactions; Wiley: Chichester, 1987. Hargittai, I.; Hargittai, M. Symmetry Through the Eyes of a Chemist; VCH: Weinheim, 1986. Murray-Rust, P.; Biirgi, H.B.; Dunitz, J.D.Acta Cryst. 1978, B34, 1787. Cammi, R.; Cavalli, E. Acta Co'st. 1992, B48, 245. Mezey, P.G. In New Theoretical Concepts for Understanding Organic Reactions; Bertr~, J.; Csizmadia, I.G., Eds.; Kluwer: Dordrecht, 1989, p. 55 and p. 77. Maruani, J.; Mezey, P.G. Compt. Rend. hebd. SFtanc. Acad. Sci. Paris, H 1987, 305, 1051 (Erratum: ibid, 1988, 306, 1141); Mezey, P.G.; Maruani, J. Molec. Phys. 1990, 69, 97; idem, Int. J. Quant. Chem. 1993, 45. 177. Mezey. P.G.J. Math. Chem. 1992, 11, 27. E.g. Bunker, P.R. Molecular Symmetry and Spectroscopy; Academic Press: New York, 1979, Chapter 11. Grtinbaum, B. Proc. Pure Math: Am. Math. Soc. 1963, 7, 233. Calvo C. Can. J. Chem. 1969, 47, 3409-3416. The contours were computes as Slater-type orbitals, represented by three Gaussian functions (STO-3G) using GAMESS (General Atomic and Molecular Electronic Structure System) program. 15 We thank Dr. David Danovich and Prof. Sasson Shaik for suggesting this molecule and for performing the calculations. Schmidt, M.W.; Baldridge, K.K.; Boatz, J.A.; Jensen, J.H.; Koseki, S.; Gordon, M.S.; Nguyen, K.A.; Windus, T.L.; Elbert, S.T. Quant. Chem. Program Exchange Bulletin 1990, 10, 52. Stout, G.H.; Jensen, L.H. X-ray Structure Determination, 2nd ed.; Wiley: New York, 1989.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
SOME PERSPECTIVES IN MOLECULAR STRUCTURE RESEARCH"
AN INTRODUCTION
istv~n Hargittai and Magdolna Hargittai
Abstract
I~ II.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Introduction
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
The Importance of Molecular Geometry
III.
Looking Back
IV.
C o m p a r i s o n of Structures
V.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
34 34 35 37
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
40
A.
Representations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
40
B.
Differences
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
42
Chemical Shape
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
46
VI.
Intramolecular Interactions
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
46
VII.
Intermolecular Interactions
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
53
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
55
VIII. IX.
Crystal Engineering
Supramolecular Structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
58
Note
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
58
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
58
Advances in Molecular Structure Research Volume 1, pages 33-61. Copyright 9 1995 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 1-55938-799-8 33
34
ISTV,g,N HARGITTAI and MAGDOLNA HARGITTAI
ABSTRACT Over the past years the accuracy of molecular structure determination has increased. This is due not only to improved experimental and computational facilities, and to the combined application of various techniques, but also to a better understanding of the physical meaning of structural information from different sources. Critical assessment of structural information facilitates its application to investigate intramolecular and intermolecular interactions and their consequences on the rest of the molecular structure. Supramolecular chemistry poses new challenges to accurate molecular structure determination at various levels of complexity of chemical systems.
I. I N T R O D U C T I O N Much of chemistry is structural chemistry. Conversely, structural chemistry is also part of the science of structures. The discovery of the stable C60 structure is a case in point. H. W. Kroto [1] describes eloquently how his previous encounters with Buckminster Fuller's work, and, in particular, the geodesic dome of the U.S. Exhibition Hall at the 1967 Montreal Expo, have assisted him to arrive at the highly symmet-
Figure 1. The sphere decorated by regular hexagonal pattern with pentagons inserted here and there. This sphere is found under the paw of a lion-guard in front of one of the palaces in the Forbidden City, Beijing, China (photograph taken by one of the authors in August, 1993).
Molecular Structure Research
35
rical truncated icosahedral structure. This was a lucky synergy. For mathematicians, though, this has been a familiar structure. We quote here from the Introduction of Gasson's Geometry of Spacial Forms [2] which appeared on the eve of Kroto's discovery: ... it is impossible to construct a faceted spherical or part spherical surface (a dome for instance) if one has but hexagonal panels at one's disposal. There are always twelve pentagonal panels in a completely spherical ball and a set of quanta of hexagons.... For another nonchemical illustration, Figure 1 shows a sphere decorated by regular hexagons with pentagons inserted here and there in the pattem. The truncated icosahedron has 20 hexagons in addition to the 12 pentagons, and it is one of the semiregular solids of Archimedes. All carbon substances whose cage molecules contain 12 pentagons and various numbers (except one) hexagons, are called fullerenes, and C60 has the special name, "buckminsterfullerene". What Gasson [2] states about the importance of structure is a truism both in geometry and in structural chemistry: "structural pattern is present in all things . . . . The study of geometrical structure is universally all-important". We augment this with Kepler's succinct statement, "Ubi materia, ibi geometria" [3(a)]. 1
il. THE IMPORTANCE OF MOLECULAR GEOMETRY The hypothesis of the truncated structure for the remarkably stable C60molecule was followed by infrared [4] and N M R spectroscopic [5] evidences for molecular shape and symmetry. However, the ultimate proof of the structure came with the determination of the molecular geometry of buckminsterfullerene (Figure 2). Table 1 has the bond lengths from different techniques [6-9]. Molecular geometry is determined by the relative positions of the atomic nuclei in the molecule. It is most conveniently described by the so-called internal coordinates, i.e., bond lengths, bond angles, and the angles of torsion. Let us use some quotations on the importance of determining the geometry of molecules. The first one is from a book on the story of polywater by Felix Franks
[10]: The central problem in the identification of a new chemical compound is the determination of its molecular structure, the linkage structure of the various atoms in the molecule, the length and strength of the bonds between the atoms, and the general shape of the molecule. This type of information is basic to an understanding of how such a molecule can interact with other molecules, how it takes part in chemical reactions, how the substance crystallizes on freezing, and how the molecules might interact in the liquid state. The added importance of this quotation is that molecular structure was exactly the kind of information that was never obtained (and could not have been) for polywater.
36
ISTVfi,N HARGITTAI and MAGDOLNA HARGITTAI
i v
v
Figure 2. The truncated icosahedral structure of buckminsterfullerene, C60.
Another eloquent, and much quoted, statement is by Roald Hoffmann [11]: There is no more basic enterprise in chemistry than the determination of the geometrical structure of a molecule. Such a determination ..... ends all speculation as to the structure and provides us with the starting point for the understanding of every physical, chemical and biological property of the molecule.
Table 1. Bond Lengths in Buckminsterfullerene Lengths of Shared Edges of Rings
Gas ED a
Neutron Crystallogr. b
X-ray Crystallogr. c
1000K
5K
ll0K
rg
re
re
re
1991
1991
1992
1991
C(5)--C(6),eA
1.458(6)
1.455(12)
1.445(5)
1.45
C(6)-C(6),fA
1.401(10)
1.391(18)
1.399(7)
1.39
Notes:
aGas-phaseelectron diffraction [6], for r8, see Section IV.A. b[7], for ra, see Section IV.A. c[8], for ra, see Section IV.A. d[9], for re, see Section IV.A. eC(5)-C(6) is the bond shared by a pentagon and a hexagon. fC(6)-C(6) is the bond shared by two hexagons.
Ab initio MO Calculs. d
Molecular Structure Research
37
There is then a recent statement by Marlin Harmony [12]: ... surely the most characteristic attribute of a molecule is its three-dimensionalstructure, i.e., the geometricalarrangementof its constituentatoms.Therecan be no doubtthatthe development of chemistry in the 20th century has been paralleled, if not led, by advancement in our quantitative knowledgeof molecularstructure. Two succinct but powerful statements are the following, one by C. A. Coulson [13]: "No one really understands the behaviour of a molecule until he knows its structure that is to say: its size, and shape, and the nature of its bonds." The other is attributed to Linus Pauling: "The most important characteristic of a chemical bond is its length." It is to be stressed, of course, that the geometry of the molecule is only one of the three major aspects of molecular structure. The other two are the intramolecular motion, which comprises the relative displacements of the atomic nuclei with respect to their equilibrium positions, and the electron density distribution. Furthermore, molecular structure is only one of the characteristics structural chemistry is dealing with. Since our introductory chapter deals primarily with molecular geometry, it covers only a relatively small, though fundamentally important segment of structural chemistry. Various aspects of molecular geometry are also discussed in other chapters in this volume along with other characteristics of molecular structure and other branches of structural chemistry. We are aiming at the broadest coverage of structural chemistry over the years in this and future volumes.
iil.
L O O K I N G BACK
Perspectives mean not only the future but the past as well. We find it prudent to review the origins of structural considerations in chemistry. Here, however, we are going to mention only a few important moments without any attempt to be comprehensive. We have already quoted Kepler [3(b)] who first considered packing as he was examining the beautiful snow crystals. The atomistic views date back, of course, to the Greek philosophers of whom Democritos (460-370 B. C. E.) stated: "Nothing exists except atoms and empty space; everything else is opinion" [14]. It is also noteworthy that the representation of the internal structure of snowflakes by Kepler, as densely stacked balls (Figure 3), appeared 200 years before Dalton and 300 years before X-ray crystallography began. Close packing was also invoked in Dalton's papers (Figure 4) as he was illustrating his views on gas absorption [15]. Looking back, some historical facts may appear in a different light today than they did yesterday. As science progresses, the relative importance and the significance of some discoveries may change. Avogadro's law has been a basic tenet for a long time in chemistry: "Equal volumes of all gases at the same temperature and pressure contain the same number of molecules." However, to Buckminster Fuller, Avogadro's law was more than what is stated literally. He saw in it a proof that
~.~ O0
0
0-
0
"0
0
0"
0 "-~ Go
0
f-
9 _o
4~
"n
0"
O_
9
~..K_.~J
MAGYAR
POSTA
Molecular Structure Research
39
chemists considered volumes as material domains and not merely as some abstractions [16]. This was important to Fuller as he advocated a physical kind of geometry and found an especially synergistic science in chemistry. In today's world of ever-increasing importance and penetration of computational chemistry, it is instructive to quote Gay-Lussac [17]: "We are perhaps not far removed from the time when we shall be able to submit the bulk of chemical phenomena to calculation." This statement is not only remarkable for its prescience but to us it is also a caveat. Today we are closer to Gay-Lussac's target by more than a century but it is still far away for many purposes. The most immediate roots of structural chemistry are in the well-known works and discoveries of Pasteur, van't Hoff, and others [18]. The four valences in a tetrahedral arrangement of carbon, however, were first described by Emanuele Patern6 [19] in an obscure journal. Since he did not develop all the consequences of his hypothesis, the credit, justifiably, belongs to van't Hoff (and Le Bel). Yet it is worthwhile to quote Patern6 (after [20]) because there is even direct reference in his work to what would be called conformational isomers today: ... one of the fundamental principles of the theory of the constitution of organic compounds, based on the atomicity of the elements and particularly on the notion of the tetra-atomicity of carbon, is that of the identical chemical function of the four valences of the carbon atom, which is not possible unless there exists only one methyl chloride, one methyl alcohol, etc .... As for the three C2H4Br2 isomers, given that they really exist, they are easily explained without having to assume a difference between the four affinities of the carbon atom . . . . . when the four valences of the atom of this element are assumed to be arranged in the sense of the four angles of a regular tetrahedron. Then the first modification would have the two bromine atoms (or any other monovalent group) connected to the same carbon atom; while in the other modifications each of the two bromine atoms would be bonded to a different carbon atom, with only the difference that in one of the two cases the two bromine atoms would be arranged symmetrically but not in the other.
l,
,
Figure 5. Illustration from Paterno's 1869 paper [ 19].
40
ISTV,~N HARGITTA! and MAGDOLNA HARGITTAI
This is made clearer with the drawings in Figure 5 in which the bromine atoms are represented by a and b. It was not, of course, until more than 70 years later that Odd Hassel published his conformational analyses of cyclohexane and derivatives by gas-phase electron diffraction [21]. Of the 20th century's development of structural chemistry, we mention the discovery of the electron-pair covalent bond by Lewis [22] which remains a fundamental tenet. It is remembered in every line we have drawn to represent a linkage and is present in most models of molecular structure, such as, for example, the valence shell electron pair repulsion (VSEPR) model [23].
IV. COMPARISON OF STRUCTURES Comparison of structures has always been a rich source of information to account for and predict chemical behavior. This is because the chemical variation between molecules often reveals itself in the details of their geometry. Recently, MurrayRust [24] noted the importance of comparative approach. He estimated that Linus Pauling [25] had access to less than 0.01% of the structural information of the early 1990s when he was writing the first edition of The Nature of the Chemical Bond in the late 1930s. Yet his ideas on structure and bonding have stood the test of time. The seemingly obvious question of how similar is one molecule to another and one structure to another is far from trivial to answer. This has also been discussed recently by Murray-Rust [24]. Especially interesting are the multivariate statistical techniques enabling us to look for patterns and clusters in the structural data. Data banks are of great use. They include the Cambridge Structural Database at the University of Cambridge, the Inorganic Crystal Structure Database at the University of Bonn, and the Protein Data Bank at the Brookhaven National Laboratories (see e.g., [24,26]). For gas-phase molecular geometries, three volumes in the Landolt-B0rnstein series constitute the data bank containing information on 2900 molecules through 1990 [27].
A. Representations Today there is an arsenal of experimental physical techniques and computational methods for the determination of molecular geometry [28]. The respective precisions are often better than the various operational effects influencing these parameters, such as the consequences of the specificities of the matter/irradiation interaction and of molecular vibrations. Different physical techniques utilize matter/irradiation events of different nature and may yield different features of the same structure. A schematic but pointed illustration of the problem is depicted in Figure 6 after Grimmer [29]. There are also different averaging procedures over molecular vibrations influencing the determined parameters. The first exposure of this problem was done by Bartell [30]
Molecular Structure Research
41
I Figure 6. Grimmer's view of different features of the same object given by different experiments. Reprinted by permission of Kluwer Academic Publishers.
and it has been expanded and refined over the years with increasing accuracy requirements (see e.g., [28], and in particular, [31]). The so-called operational parameters are the direct output of experimental studies. They do not have well-defined physical meaning. The most important and common ones are the following: Effective internuclear distance, obtained directly from the analysis of electron diffraction intensities. Its conversion into rg distance (see below) is simple with a very good approximation, r s -- ra + 12/ra, where I is the mean vibrational amplitude. In other words, there is no need to use ra in any comparison; it is preferable to use r s. r0 Effective internuclear distance, obtained from the rotational constants; usually refers to the ground vibrational state. Since it depends strongly on the isotopic composition, it may differ from the equilibrium distance by a couple of hundredths of an angstrom. rs Effective internuclear distance determined from the isotopic substitution coordinates of the respective atoms. Since it depends slightly on the isotopic compositions, it may differ from the equilibrium distance by a few thousandths of an angstrom. ra
Internuclear distances with well-defined physical meaning are the following" re
Equilibrium internuclear distance between equilibrium nuclear positions in the minimum position of the potential energy function. No experiment yields d i r e c t l y this parameter. All computed geometries, in principle, correspond to this distance, but only in principle, of course. Basis-set
42
ISTV/i,N HARGITTAI and MAGDOLNA HARGITTAI
Table 2. Factors Influencing Internuclear Distance Parameters
Distance Type
Deformation Motion (e.g., bending, out-of-plane puckering) Effect of Temperature
Effect of Isotope Composition
rg
+
+
+
r~
-
+
+
r~rz
-
-
+
re
~
~
choice, approximations, and all computational conditions may influence the results. rg Distance-average incorporating the effect of all vibrations at temperature T. This is the parameter attainable in a straightforward way from electron diffraction. r~rz Distance between average nuclear positions in the ground vibrational state; r ~ and rz have the same meaning; rz originates from rotational spectra applying vibrational corrections, ra is the distance between average nuclear positions averaged over all vibrational states at temperature T. ra and r ~ are obtained from electron diffraction applying vibrational corrections. The most unambiguous representation of molecular geometry is the r e equilibrium structure. Another excellent representation of bond lengths is rg since it is a real distance averaged over molecular vibrations. Distances ra and r~/rz are less meritorious for characterizing bond lengths as they are projected averages, projected, that is, onto the direction of the lines connecting equilibrium nuclear positions. These representations are, however, the most suitable for characterizing bond angles. (On the other hand, a bond angle calculated from rg distances has no well-defined meaning). A summary of effects of intramolecular motion on the various distance representations is given in Table 2.
B. Differences The rg/r e differences increase with increasing floppiness of the molecule and with increasing experimental temperatures. However, these differences may extend beyond experimental error even for relatively rigid systems studied even at low temperatures. There are various ways to reduce the experimentally determined r g distance to r e distance, at least to a good approximation. A few examples are collected in Table 3 after Kuchitsu [31]. Recently Harmony [12] reviewed the possibilities of correcting spectroscopic information for vibrational effects, and made the following statement: "Finally after more than a half-century of spectro-
43
Molecular Structure Research Table 3. Examples of rg and re Bond Lengthsa'b
r~(A)
re(A)
Z~(r)(A)
C - H in CH4
1.107(1)
1.0870+0.0007
0.020
Rather floppy
B - F in BF3
1.3133(10)
1.3070(1)
0.006
Rather rigid
C - O in C12CO
1.184 + 0.003
1.1766(22)
0.007
Rather rigid
C-C1 in C12CO 1.744 + 0.001
1.7365(12)
0.008
Rather rigid
Notes:
aAfterKuchitsu [31]. bThroughout this paper, the experimental errors are quoted in the following way: Least-squares standard deviations in parentheses as units of the last digit, e.g., 1.107(1)/~, and estimated total errors are quoted as error limits, e.g., 1.184 + 0.003/k.
scopic structural studies, it now appears possible to obtain near-r e bond lengths and angles for organic polyatomic molecules of modest size (6-8 heavy atoms)." Careful considerations of the differences on the physical meaning of the parameters are needed as an increasing amount of experimental and computed structural information are being compared. As we stated: "For truly accurate comparison, experimental bond lengths should be compared with computed ones only following necessary corrections, bringing all information involved in the comparison to a common denominator" [32]. For floppy systems, such as many metal halide molecules, the rg/r e differences may be even much greater than those listed in Table 3. Alkaline earth metal, zinc, and transition metal dihalides, for example, have been extensively investigated by gas-phase electron diffraction (see e.g., [33-36]). The structure determinations have involved a joint electron diffraction/vibrational spectroscopic analysis (cf. [37]). Depending on the model potential used, and among them on the manner in which anharmonic effects are taken into account, even the "re" distances are rather different. This is illustrated by the data of Table 4. The r e distances obtained from experimental data applying various model potentials [32] have the following Table 4. Different Types of Bond Distances for Linear MX2 Triatomic Molecules (in ~)a,b MX2 T(K)
ZnBr2 600
MnCl2 1000
SrBr2 1400
rg
2.204 + 0.005
2.202 + 0.004
2.783 + 0.006
ra h re ch re a re M re
2.185 + 0.008
2.162 +_0.008
2.649 + 0.024
Notes:
2.181 + 0.005
2.153 + 0.005
2.204 + 0.004
2.196 + 0.004
2.196 +_0.005
2.184 + 0.005
2.196 + 0.006
2.186 _+0.005
aReferencesto the original publications: ZnBr2 [35]; MnC12 [36]; SrBr2 [34]. bSee footnote b tO Table 3.
2.771 + 0.006 2.738 +_0.013
44
ISTVfi,N HARGITTAI and MAGDOLNA HARGITTAI
Table 5. Bond Distances for Bent MX2 Triatomic Molecules (in ~)a,b SiCl2
Molecule
T(K)
SiBr2
1470
1470
rg
2.089 + 0.004
2.249 + 0.005
ra h
2.084 + 0.004
2.244 + 0.005
re
2.080 + 0.004
2.239 + 0.005
ch re
2.081 + 0.004
2.239 + 0.004
2.076 + 0.004
2.227 + 0.006
a
re Notes:
aSeefootnote b to Table 3. bFrom
[43,44].
meaning: ~ harmonic approximation with rectilinear coordinates [37], 4 hharmonic approximation with curvilinear coordinates [38], ~ anharmonic approximation [39], and r~eedistance with Morse-type anharmonic stretching correction [40]. The molecules listed in Table 4 have a linear equilibrium structure (except for SrBr2 which is best labeled quasilinear [34,41,42]). Table 5 lists similar data for two
V(em
-~)
_
200000
-
1 0 0 0 0 0
-
ZnC
O
C'rBrz ~---,~
9~ .
~
0
50
I00
Qe
Figure 7a. Comparison of bending potential functions, linear models of ZnCI2 and SrBr2.
Molecular Structure Research
45
silicon dihalides which have a highly bent equilibrium configuration [43,44]. For all these systems it is especially important to define the type of distances that are being compared. Any unambiguous determination of molecular geometry always includes considerations of motion. Its importance is illustrated here by the structure of three symmetric triatomic molecules involving linear, quasilinear, and bent ones [45]. The effective structure observed directly from the electron diffraction experimental data is invariably bent. The decisive difference appears in the shape of the potential energy function describing the bending motion. Examples are shown in Figure 7. The bending potential energy functions of ZnC12 and SrBr 2 are shown in Figure 7(a); Pe = 0~ corresponds to the linear configuration. The minimum of potential
v(cm -1) 60-
40 30000
2O
I
20000 .~--
"I
I
o
1o
!
20
I
~0
Q~
$113r2 9
4
10000 1
0
T
0
i
i
I
i
I
50
I
i00
(?e
Figure 7b. Comparison of bending potential functions, bent models of SrBr2 and
SiBr2.
46
ISTV,g,N HARG ITTAI and MAG DOLNA HARG ITTAI
energy appears to be at Pe = 0~ for both molecules. It is also seen though that the minimum is much more shallow for SrBr 2 than for ZnC12. Figure 7(b) shows the bending potential energy functions of SiBr 2 and, again, SrBr 2. The relatively high barrier at Pe = 0~ for SiBr 2 indicates an unambiguously bent configuration. Further enlarging the scale reveals a small barrier at Pe = 0~ for SrBr 2, so small that it lies below the level of the ground vibrational state; hence the quasilinear designation for such a structure.
V. CHEMICAL SHAPE Although the most unambiguous representation of molecular geometry is the equilibrium structure it may not always be the most useful one. Real molecules in real reactions spend very little time in or near their equilibrium structure, especially if they are characterized by large-amplitude vibrations. Levine [46] calls it the task of dynamical stereochemistry to determine the chemical shape of molecules. He suggests to distinguish the physical and chemical shapes, and finds that the interplay between the two accounts for much of the detail provided by experiments and computational studies. According to Levine [46], the chemical shape describes how molecular reactivity depends on the direction of approach and distance of the other reagent. On the other hand, the physical shape corresponds to a hard space-filling model. The concept of chemical shape is important whenever any kind of interaction between molecules is involved. Thus, Levine's characterization of chemical shape is fully consistent with Legon's description of molecular recognition [47]: At the fundamental level, molecular recognition involves the specific interaction of one part of a molecule with a particular part of another molecule. This interaction will be defined by a relative orientation and by a separation of the two subunits that confer on the system as a whole a lower energy than other conformations. An understanding of the fundamentals of molecular recognition therefore requires a knowledge of the properties of intermolecular interactions and in particular how the energy varies with relative orientation and separation.
VI.
INTRAMOLECULAR INTERACTIONS
Following the structural consequences of ligand substitution in series of substances has been a rewarding approach in investigating correlations between structure and bonding and other properties. The S-C and Se-C bond lengths, for example, are sensitive to the valence state of the participating carbon [48] (Figure 8). The effects are large and the differences may exceed 0.1 ,~. Ligand substitution on carbon causes appreciable, though lesser, bond-length changes in the sulfides and selenides. On the other hand, ligand substitution on carbon may cause changes again up to0.1/k in the S-C bond lengths in sulfones. Thus, for example, S-C changes from 1.763(5) to 1.865(6) ,~ upon CH3/CF 3 substitution, from CH3SO2C1 [49] to CF3SO2C1 [50]. The difference is
Molecular Structure Research r(S-C),
1 9 1 I C=C
C-C I
1.20
r(Se-C). ~,
~k
1.80 -
1.70 - I
47
I C-C
2.00 -
C - C .=
1.90 -
C=C
C=C
I
t 1.30
I 1.40
"C-C
I 1.50 r(CC), A
i 1.20
I, 1.30
I 1.40
I 1.50
r(CC),
Figure 8. S-C and Se-C bond lengths in sulfides and selenides with various carbon valence states (after [48]).
interpreted as a consequence of the electron releasing ability of the methyl group and the electron withdrawing ability of the trifluoromethyl group. There is a much smaller but still significant difference in the C-C bond lengths of adamantane, C10H16 [51], and perfluoroadamantane, C10F16 [52], depicted in Figure 9. The bond lengthening is thought to be a consequence of the electron-withdrawing ability of the fluorine ligand as compared with hydrogen. Very weak interactions may also have appreciable geometrical consequences. An example is the structure of N,N-dimethyl-formamide [53] (Figure 10). There is a
rs CIoHI6
1.542+0.002A
CloFI6
1.560•
A
Figure 9. C-C bond length of adamantane [51] and perfluoroadamantane [52].
48
ISTV/~N HARGITTAI and MAGDOLNA HARGITTAI
O.o.H 2.40(3) A
CH
2 123.5(6)o12018(3)/ 3 1.224(3)A ~C'-~ ~ / .
- - s - - i -'~ 113.9(5)~
1.391(7) A
H
!' 122.3(4)~
357~
1.453(4) ]k \ CI-I 3
H
C--------~ 11 • 4 ~
16 + 5 ~ ~ C
Figure 10. N,N-dimethylformamide structure from gas-phase electron diffraction [53].
difference between the two (O)C-N-C angles. The one syn to the C--O bond is somewhat smaller than the other. The C = O . . . H - C nonbonded distance, 2.40 + 0.03 A, indicates some attractive interaction, although it is far too long to consider it a hydrogen bond. Comparison with formamide [54] itself, which cannot have an O.--H interaction, supports the notion of the presence of some attractive interaction in the N,N-dimethyl derivative. Formamide has a somewhat shorter C--O bond, 1.212(2)/k, and a somewhat greater N-C--O angle, 125.0(4) ~ than N,N-dimethylformamide. The O..-H nonbonded interactions are manifested in yet shorter O...H distances in N,N-dimethylacetamide (2.21 ,~,) and N-methylacetamide (2.33 /k) according to recent high-level ab initio calculations [55,56] (the O--.H distances given here were calculated from the published geometries of refs. [55] and [56], respectively). In Section IV.B, we have stressed the importance of the physical meaning of parameters in a demanding comparison. There are other situations where trends and patterns in the parameters and their changes are sought. This can be done even without corrections for vibrational effects or other conversions. This is especially so when looking for patterns in data collected by the same technique in the same laboratory. Table 6 presents some geometrical parameters of 2-fluorophenol [57], 2,6-difluorophenol [58], and tetrafluorohydroquinone [58]. There are several geometrical features that can be ascribed to the consequences of some weak hydrogenbond formation. They also seem to indicate a trend according to which the hydrogen bonds may strengthen from 2-fluorophenol toward tetrafluorohydroquinone. On
Molecular Structure Research
49
Table 6. Selected Geometrical Parameters of 2-Fluorophenol, 2,6-Difluorophenol, and Tetrafluorohydroquinone a 2-FluorophenoP
2,6-Difluorophenol c
Tetrafluorohydroquinone d
HI3-"F9, ,g,
2.125 + 0.055
2.054 + 0.079
2.015 + 0.069
O7"-'F9, ,h-
2.735 + 0.022
2.715 + 0.067
2.657 + 0.054
Z C - O - H , deg
101.9 + 3.9
96.7 + 4.2
98.2 + 2.4
r(C2-F9), ,~
1.353 + 0.012
1.358 + 0.056
r(C6-F10), ,~
o
1.346 + 0.048
/ C 3 - C 2 - F 9 , deg
120.3 + 4.8
/C5--C6-F10, deg tilt, deg
u
1.343 + 0.013
120.1 + 2.3
122.1 + 1.7
118.5 + 3.8
119.6 + 0 . 9
- 0.7 + 4.0
r(C1-OT), A
1.350 + 0.012
0 (assumed)
1.378 + 0.010
1.362 + 0.036
2.1 + 1.2 1.353 + 0.009
ZOT-H13.-.F9, deg
120.8 + 4.5
127.1 + 5.1
123.8 + 2.9
ZC2-F9...H13, deg R
79.0 + 1.7 0.0280
77.7 + 3.3 0.0281
80.2 + 1.6 0.0269
Notes: aDistancesare rg values. bRef. [57]. CRef. [58]. dRef. [57].
t113
S
07 F10
F9
H12
HI1
the other hand, no geometrical indication pointing to hydrogen bonding was detected in 2,6-difluorobenzenamine and 2-fluorobenzenamine [59]. Relatively strong intramolecular hydrogen bonding was indicated by the geometry of 2-nitroresorcinol [60] and 2-nitrophenol [61] from gas-phase electron diffraction studies. There are considerable bond-length changes in these molecules as compared with nitrobenzene [62] and phenol [63]. These changes are consistent with strong resonance-assisted hydrogen bonding. Such resonance-assisted hydrogen bonding has been described for a number of crystal molecular structures [64]. Schemes 1 and 2 show the resonance forms of 2-nitroresorcinol and 2-nitrophenol that are supposed to contribute strongly to the molecular structure. The experimental evidence is unambiguous for the longer N--O bonds and shorter N-C bond in 2-nitroresorcinol than in nitrobenzene, and for the shorter C-O bonds and longer O-H bonds than in phenol. The experimental geometries are characterized in Table 7. Differences in the geometrical parameters are collected in Table 8. Along with
H'"O~N~O'"H
H ..0 %N//0 .."H
o
?
w
o
H".-0%N/O.. "H m
o
Scheme
1.
O
O%N~O'"H
o'
~'N/O
""H l+
Scheme 2.
Table 7. Geometrical Parameters of Phenol, Nitrobenzene, 2-Nitrophenoi, and 2-Nitroresorcinol from Gas-Phase Electron Diffraction a Parameter
C 1-C2, ,~ C2-C3, ,~ C3-C4, A N=OI4, .A, N--O15, A C-N, ,g, C-O, ,~, O-H, ,~, LC-N--O14, deg / C - N = O I 5 , deg / O - - N - - O , deg LC--O-H, deg LN-C1-C2, deg / O - C 2 - C 1 , deg / C - C 1 - C , deg / C - C 2 - C , deg CO, tilt, deg (N--)O...H(-O), A (N--)O- ..O (-H), ,A ZN'--O...H, deg LO-H-..O, deg Notes:
Phenol b
Nitrobenzene c
1.400(3) 1.399(3) 1.396(3) q --1.381 (4) 0.958(3) ~ --106.4(17) -121.2(12) 121.6(2) 118.8(2) +2(1) -----
1.223(3) 1.486(4) ~ -117.3(1) 125.3(2) ~ 117.4(2) ~ 123.4(3) 117.7(3) -m ~ -m
2-Nitrophenol d
1.411 (12) 1.406(13) 1.388(21) 1.241(9) 1.225(9) 1.464(5) 1.359(9) 0.969(12) 118.2(10) 118.6(10) 123.3(4) 104.4(22) 120.8(7) 123.9(8) 121.4(5) 119.4(8) +3.6(7) 1.72(2) 2.58(1) 104.3(15) 147(3)
2-Nitroresorcinol e
1.426(5) 1.393(4) 1.239(3) 1.449(7) 1.354(4) 1.038(15) 119.3(3) 121.4(5) 116(3) 120.5(4) 122.8(7) 119.1(7) 120.4(5) +2.9(5) 1.76(4) 2.56( 1) 110.5(15) 131(5)
aDistances(rg bond lengths) in ,g,,angles in degrees. bRef. 63. CRef.62. aFrom a concerted analysis incorporating constraints from MP2(FC)/6-31G* ab initio calculations, ref. 61. eRef. 60. 50
Molecular Structure Research
51
the experimental data, the differences referring to quantum chemically calculated parameters are also given [61,65]. Emphasis is on the comparison of differences which are free of a variety of problems that the absolute values of both the experimental and calculated results may suffer from. Of 2-nitroresorcinol and 2-nitrophenol, the former has higher symmetry and is an easier target for gas-phase electron diffraction. On the other hand, the structure of 2-nitrophenol could not have been determined without the introduction of some constraints from quantum chemical calculations. These constraints, however, have always meant differences between parameters rather than actual bond lengths or bond angles. Heretofore, we have mentioned the geometrical consequences of the strong hydrogen-bond formation in 2-nitroresorcinol and 2-nitrophenol. Tables 7 and 8 list the O.-.H (N=O---H-O) and O...O (N=O.-.O--C) nonbonded distances that can be considered direct evidence of the strong hydrogen bonds. Usually such distances, and especially the O...H distance, can be inferred only indirectly in an electron diffraction study because of their small relative weight among interactions in the electron scattering process. Figure 11 shows that, by a rare favorable coincidence, there is a broad valley in the vicinity of the contribution of the O---H distance on the radial distribution of 2-nitroresorcinol. The radial distribution is an expression of the probability density distribution of the internuclear distances obtainable from the electron diffraction data [66]. In this case, a distinct feature, however slight, can be ascribed to the contribution of the O...H distances in the
Table 8. Differences of Selected Parametersa Demonstrating Geometrical
Consequences of intramolecular Hydrogen-Bond Formation 2-Nitrophenol/Phenol
Parameter
Electron Diffraction
Calculation MP2(FC)/6-31G*
2-Nitroresorcinoi/Phenol Electron Diffraction
Calculation MP2(FC)/6-31 G*
O - C , ,~,
- 0.022
- 0.024
- 0.027
- 0.024
( O ) C - C ( N ) , ,~,
+ 0.012
+ 0.014
+ 0.027
+ 0.028
O--C-C(N), deg
+ 2.7
+ 2.8
+ 1.6
+ 1.9
C O flit, deg
+ 1.6
+ 1.3
+ 1
+ 1.2
2-Nitrophenol/Ni trobenzene Parameter
Electron Diffraction
Calculation MP2(FC)/6-31G*
2-Nitroresorcinol/Nitrobenzene Electron Diffraction
Calculation MP2(FC)/6-31G*
N--C, ~,
- 0.022
- 0.015
- 0.037
- 0.032
( O ) C - C ( N ) , ~,
+ 0.011
+ 0.018
+ 0.026
+ 0.033
N--C-C(O), deg
+ 2.5
+ 2.4
+ 3.1
+ 2.6
O-N-C(O), deg
+ 0.9
+ 0.7
+ 2.0
+ 2.0
C N flit, deg
+ 1.5
+ 1.8
Note:
aFor references, see text.
--
m
52
ISTV,g,N HARGITTAI and MAGDOLNA HARGITTAI
f(r)
0
2-Nitrores~176
1/
2
4
'r,A
,o%~0 '~
H/O~O~H O
1.5
O
2
Figure 11. 2-nitroresorcinol: radial distributions [60].
structure with the hydrogen bonds. This is made clear by the comparison with the curve calculated for another form in which there is no such hydrogen bond. Another example of geometrical consequences of intramolecular interactions can be demonstrated by the structure of a few carbon-cage molecules. Whereas the adamantane molecule [51] has only one kind of C-C distance, due to its high symmetry, there is a distribution of C-C distances in, for example, heptacyclotetradecane (Figure 12(a)) [67] and fenestrane (Figure 12(b)) [68] due to intramolecular nonbonded interactions. A final example of intramolecular interactions concerns the geometrical changes upon internal rotation. In a variety of situations, such as, e.g., conformational equilibria in the gas phase or structures of the same molecule in different phases, such effects may be of importance. Thus, for example, the C - C - X bond angles of 1,2-dihaloethanes were calculated to change up to 4 ~ during internal rotation [69]. Ignoring this change may cause an error up to 11 ~ in the determination of the gauche angle of torsion for a mixture of anti and gauche conformers.
Molecular Structure Research
53
rg
c
1-c8
1.586~0.004
A
Cl-C2
1.528:t:0.006 A
c 1-c9
1.553-~0.004 A
c9-c13
1.532~0.004 A
(a)
1
'
rg
C 1--C2
1.558-~0.005 A
C2-C6
1.539+0.008 A
C6--C7
1.542•
.,~
I 16.2~0.5 ~
I06.2~0.2 ~
6
(b)
7
Figure 12. (a) C-C bond lengths of heptacyclotetradecane [67]. (b) C-C bond lengths of fenestrane [68].
VII.
INTERMOLECULAR INTERACTIONS
Until some time ago, crystallographers used to assume that the molecules have the same structure in the crystal as the free molecules in the vapor (see, e.g., [70]). With increasing capabilities of structure determination the gas/crystal structure differences are gaining importance. Their elucidation is rapidly becoming a most important source of information on the intermolecular interactions in the crystal (see, e.g., [71-73]). The origin of gas-phase structures is not only the experimental techniques, such as electron diffraction and high-resolution rotational spectroscopy but, increasingly, high-level ab initio molecular orbital calculations. The result of the latter also refer to the free molecule.
54
ISTV,/~N HARGITTAI and MAGDOLNA HARGITTAI
Again, as with any comparison of structural information, first all operational effects must be eliminated before any difference is to be ascribed to truly structural effects. Thus, for example, further corrections are necessary before making conclusions from a comparison of rg electron diffraction and ra X-ray diffraction bond lengths. The true ra parameter refers to distances between average nuclear positions. As is well known, X-ray diffraction provides distances between the centroids of the electron density distribution rather than internuclear distances. However, for spherically symmetrical electron density distributions, coincidence with the nuclear positions can be assumed. Thus following corrections for the so-called asphericity effects (as well as for rigid-body librations), the X-ray results can be considered as an ra structure. Thus, especially for bond angles, the comparison may provide meaningful information. Considering the energy requirements of structural changes and the energy contents of crystal-field effects, conformational changes, angular changes, and bond length changes may be expected in diminishing order. It has been estimated [72] for a carbon-carbon chain that a typical bond stretching of 0.1 ,~ requires about 15 kJ/mol, a bond-angle deformation of 10 ~ about 5 kJ/mol, and a torsional distorsion of 15 ~ about 1 kJ/mol. However, as was mentioned at the end of the previous section, these changes (e.g., torsion and angle bending) do not occur separately but should be considered as parts of the overall structure relaxation and treated in a concerted way, especially beyond certain accuracy requirements. There are now at least a few well-documented cases of gas/solid structure differences involving the consequences of intermolecular hydrogen bonding and other interactions in the crystal. In addition to gas/solid comparison, comparison of crystallographically independent molecules in the same crystal, analysis of the structure of molecules whose symmetry is lower in the crystal than in the vapor, and comparison of molecular structures in different polymorphic modifications are the principal venues to investigate the influence of intermolecular interactions on molecular structure. These strategies were identified by Kitaigorodskii [74] at a very early stage of accurate crystallographic studies. It was yet another example of the prescience of this great crystallographer, and especially so since previously he had dismissed the possibility of appreciable gas/solid structural changes. Incidentally, a memorial collection of papers with the title, Molecular Crystal Chemistry, was recently published as an homage to him [75]. The understanding of changes in molecular structures is important not only in the investigation of intermolecular interactions in crystals. Another area is the investigation of large and often biologically important systems. Considerations of the chemical shape, molecular recognition, and the energy costs of changes converge. According to Legon [47]: For the purpose of modeling large systems, it is of interest to follow an approach familiar in chemistry, i.e., to consider the larger systems to be composedof groups, each group having its own characteristic properties. Thus, we might enquire into the preferred angular and radial
Molecular Structure Research
55
geometry for the interaction of one groupwith anotherand, given that in a larger unit it might not be possibleto achievethe preferredarrangement,we mightthen ask aboutthe cost in energy of small angularand radial distortionsfor this conformation. As a final note in this section we mention a recent attempt to establish some correlation between gaseous molecular structures and their source crystal structures of highly ionic substances [76]. For some metal halides both monomers and dimers occur in the vapor phase, while for others only the monomer is present in appreciable amounts. Systematic comparisons reveal that dimers are not detected in the vapor if the dimeric molecule cannot be recognized as a unit in the crystal structure. On the other hand, if the presence of dimeric molecules is discernible already in the crystal, it will be observed in the vapor only if its heat of vaporization does not exceed that of the monomer by more than, say, 10 kcal/mol.
VIII. CRYSTAL ENGINEERING Different changes in the molecular structure of analogous compounds observed in gas/crystal comparisons reflect differences in molecular packing. An example is the different impact on the benzene ring deformation by intermolecular interactions in the crystals of p-dicyanobenzene [77] and p-diisocyanobenzene [78] as illustrated in Figure 13. There is a network of dipole-dipole interactions between the antiparallel cyano groups in the crystal of p-dicyanobenzene. The packing of p-diisocyanobenzene molecules, on the other hand, allows charge-transfer interactions. The understanding of crystal packing in terms of intermolecular interactions and using this understanding to design crystals with perceived packing and properties is the subject of crystal engineering [79]. It also follows from the foregoing that the understanding of relatively weak interactions and their geometrical consequences in molecular structure is one of the determining factors in crystal engineering. Intermolecular hydrogen bonding is perhaps the single most important one among the possible weak interactions. It has been called to be the most dominant mechanism of molecular recognition in crystals [80]. Also, intermolecular hydrogen bonds may not be so weak, especially when acting in large numbers. Their cooperative action was nicely illustrated by Jeffrey and Saenger [81] who showed Gulliver, the giant, constrained by a multitude of weak bonds (Figure 14). With all the progress, however, it is still difficult to predict crystal structures. This frustration was powerfully expressed by Maddox [82]: "One of the continuing scandals in the physical sciences is that it remains in general impossible to predict the structure of even the simplest crystalline solids from a knowledge of their chemical composition." There is also considerable progress during the past few years in this respect, mainly due to the utilization of the wealth of information retrievable from the data banks, and especially the Cambridge files [83].
~3.63 ....
-
. . . . .
-..9
(~_~<...
"
"+:.%
\
N~.\
1
\\
_+ +
......
\
,...+~
':i.
+ +-
%
Figure 13. Arrangements of molecules in crystalline p-dicyanobenzene [77] and p-diisocyanobenzene [78] demonstrating a marked difference in packing (see text). 56
Molecular Structure Research
57
Figure 14. After Jeffrey and Saenger's [81] idea to illustrate cooperative action" Gulliver: a giant, constrained by a multitude of weak bonds. Illustration by V. Kubasta in J. Swift, Gulliver Lilliputban, 9Artia, Praha.
The design of drugs and extremely strong and long-lasting materials are two conspicuously important domains of crystal engineering. The determination of structures, the elucidation of structure/activity correlations involving advanced computational techniques allow the design of desired drugs based on stereochemical principles. Yet the elimination of some illnesses may necessitate not only drugs but the solution of social and environmental problems [84]. Concerning the design of new materials, environmental concerns have enhanced the requirements against which their applicability can be measured [85].
58
ISTV,~N HARGITTAI and MAGDOLNA HARGITTA!
IX. SUPRAMOLECULAR STRUCTURES A molecular crystal is a result of molecular self-assembly but it is not the only example of such molecular organizations. The living organism has ranges of self-assembled structures [86]. Needless to say, structural information from the simplest molecules to those with increasing complexity are decisive in designing and understanding such molecular self-assemblies. Whereas two-dimensional and three-dimensional networks have previously been of primary interest to the inorganic chemist (see, e.g., Wells [87]), this has recently become a focal point in organic chemistry as well [88]. Again, there is emphasis on weak interactions of a great variety. According to Lehn [89]: "Beyond molecular chemistry based on the covalent bond lies supramolecular chemistry based on molecular interactions--the associations of two or more chemical entities and the intermolecular bond." There is then a complete analogy between the atoms linked by covalent bonds into molecules and the molecules linked by intermolecular interactions into supermolecules [90]. Lehn has also established a linkage between molecular and supramolecular chemistries through molecular recognition when he stated succinctly [91] that "molecular recognition implies the (molecular) storage and (supramolecular) retrieval of molecular structural information." The investigation of these molecular and supramolecular systems represent true challenges for structural chemistry.
NOTE 1. Latin. In English: "Where there is matter, there is geometry"
REFERENCES 1. Kroto, H.W. Angew. Chem. bzt. Ed. Engl. 1992, 31, 111. 2. Gasson, P.C. Geometry of Spacial Forms; Ellis Horwood: Chichester, 1983, pp. ix-x. 3. (a) Kepler, J., quoted after A.L. Mackay. A Dictionary of Scientific Quotations. Adam Hilger: Bristol, 1991, p. 139. (b) Kepler, J. Strena, seu De Nive Sexangula, 1611. English translation: The Six-Cornered Snowflake; Clarendon Press: Oxford, 1966. 4. Bethune, D.S.; Meijer, G.; Tang, W.C.; Rosen, H.J.; Golden, W.G.; Seki, H.; Brown, C.A.; de Vries, M.S. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1991, 179, 181. 5. Johnson, R.D.; Meijer, G.; Bethune, D.S.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1990, 112, 8983. 6. Hedberg, K.; Hedberg, L.; Bethune, D.S.; Brown, C.A.; Dorn, H.C., Johnson, R.D.; de Vries, M. Science 1991, 254, 410. 7. David, W.I.E; Ibberson, R.M.; Matthewman, J.C.; Prassides, K.; Dennis, T.J.S.; Hare, J.P.; Kroto, H.W.; Taylor, R.; Walton, D.R.M. Nature 1991, 353, 147. 8. Btirgi, H.-B.; Blanc, E.; Schwarzenbach, D.; Liu, S.; Lu, Y.-J.; Kappes, M.M.; Ibers, J.A.Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1992, 31,640. 9. Hasser, M.; Almlt~f,J.; Scuseria, G.E. University of Minnesota Supercomputer Institute Research Report; UMSI91/142, May 1991. 10. Franks, E Polywater; MIT Press: Cambridge, MA, 1981.
Molecular Structure Research
59
1I. Hoffmann, R. In Determination of the Geometrical Structure of Free Molecules; Vilkov, L. V.; Mastryukov, V.S.; Sadova, N.I., Eds.; MIR: Moscow, 1983. 12. Harmony, M.D.Acc. Chem. Res. 1992, 25, 321. 13. Coulson, C.A. The Shape and Structure of Molecules; Oxford University Press, 1973. 14. Democritos [of Abdera], quoted after A.L. Mackay. A Dictionary of Scientific Quotations; Adam Hilger: Bristol, 1991, p. 71. 15. Dalton, J. Manchester Memoirs 1805, 6. 16. Fuller, R.B. Synergetics: Explorations in the Geometry of Thinking; Macmillan: New York, 1975. 17. Gay-Lussac, J.L. Memoires de la Societe d'Arouei11888, 2, 207. 18. Ramsay, O.B. Stereochemistry; Heyden, London, 1981. 19. Patemb, E. Giornale di Scienze Naturali ed Economiche; 1869, Vol. VI, pp. 115-122. 20. Natta, G.; Farina, M. Stereochemistry; Longman: London, 1972. 21. Hassel, O. Tidsskr. Kjemi Bergv. Metall. 1943, 3, 32. English translation, 1970, 30, 25. 22. Lewis, G.N.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1916, 38, 762. 23. Gillespie, R.J.; Hargittai, I. The VSEPR Model of Molecular Geometry; Allyn and Bacon: Boston, 1991. 24. Murray-Rust, E In Computer Modelling of Biomolecular Processes; Goodfellow, J.; Moss, D. S., Eds.; Ellis Horwood: New York, 1992, p. 19. 25. Pauling, L. The Nature of the Chemical Bond; Cornell University Press: 1st ed., 1939. 26. Allen, E H. in Ref. 28, p. 355. 27. Structure Data of Free Polyatomic Molecules; Landolt-B6mstein Numerical Data and Functional Relationships in Science and Technology. New Series Volumes II/7, II/15, and II/21; SpringerVerlag: Berlin, Heidelberg, 1976, 1987, and 1992. 28. Domenicano, A.; Hargittai, I., Eds. Accurate Molecular Structures: Their Determination and Importance; Oxford University Press, 1992. 29. Grimmer, A.-R.; In J. A. Tossell, Ed. Nuclear Magnetic Shieldings and Molecular Structure; Kluwer: Dordrecht, 1993, pp. 191-201. 30. Bartell, L.S.J. Chem. Phys. 1955, 23, 1219. 31. Kuchitsu, K. in Ref. 28, (p. 14). 32. Hargittai, M.; Hargittai, I. Int. J. Quant. Chem. 1992, 44, 1057. 33. Vajda, E.; Hargittai, M.; Hargittai, I.; Tremmel, J.; Brunvoll, J. hTorg. Chem. 1987, 26, 1171. 34. Hargittai, M.; Kolonits, M.; Knausz, D.; Hargittai, I. J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 96, 8980. 35. Hargittai, M.; Tremmel, J.; Hargittai, I. Inorg. Chem. 1986, 25, 3163. 36. Hargittai, M.; Subbotina, N. Yu.; Kolonits, M.; Gershikov, A.G.J. Chem. Phys. 1991, 94, 7278. 37. Spiridonov, V.P.; Gershikov, A.G.; Zasorin, E.Z.; Butayev, B.S. In Diffraction Studies on NonCrystalline Substances; Hargittai, I.; Orville-Thomas, W.J., Eds.; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1981. 38. Gershikov, A.G. Zh. Strukt. Khim. 1984, 2514], 30. 39. Gershikov, A.G. Khim. Fiz. 1992, 1,587. 40. Bartell, L.S.; J. Chem. Phys. 1979, 70, 4581. 41. Seijo, L.; Barandiaran, Z.; Huzinaga, S. J. Chem. Phys. 1991, 94, 3762. 42. Kaupp, M.; Schleyer, P.v.R.; Stoll, H.; Preuss, H. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1991, 113, 6012. 43. Hargittai, I.; Schultz, G.; Tremmel, J.; Kagramanov, N. D.; Maltsev, A. K.; Nefedov, O. M. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1983, 105, 2895. 44. Gershikov, A.G.; Subbotina, N. Yu.; Hargittai, M. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1990, 143, 293. 45. Hargittai, M.; Hargittai, I. In Structures and Conformations of Non-rigid Molecules; Laane, J.; Dakkouri, M.; van der Veken, B.; Oberhammer, H., Eds.; NATO ASI Series C.: Mathematical and Physical Sciences, Vol. 410, pp. 465-489, Kluwer Academic Publishers: Dordrecht, Boston, London, 1993. 46. Levine, R.D.J. Phys. Chem. 1990, 94, 8872. 47. Legon, A.C. In Molecular Recognition: Chemical and Biological Problems; S. M. Roberts, Ed.; Royal Soc. Chem.: Cambridge, 1992, p. 1.
60 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62.
ISTVAN HARGITTAI and MAGDOLNA HARGITTAI
Hargittai, I. Pure & Appl. Chem. 1989, 61, 651. Hargittai, M.; Hargittai, I.J. Chem. Phys. 1973, 59, 2513. Brunvoll, J.; Hargittai, I.; Kolonits, M. Z. Naturforsch. Part A 1978, 33, 1236. Hargittai, I.; Hedberg, K.J.C.S. Chem. Commun. 1971, 1499. Hargittai, I.; Brunvoll, J.; Sonoda, T. (to be published). Schultz, G.; Hargittai, I. J. Phys. Chem. 1993, 97, 4966. Kitano, M.; Kuchitsu, K. Bull. Chem. Soc. Japan 1974, 47, 67. Duffy, E.M.; Severance, D.L.; Jorgensen, W.L.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1992, 114, 7535. Guo, H.; Karplus, M. J. Phys. Chem. 1992, 96, 7273. Vajda, E.; Hargittai, I. J. Phys. Chem. 1992, 96, 5843. Vajda, E.; Hargittai, I. J. Phys. Chem. 1993, 97, 70. Csakvari, E.; Hargittai, I. J. Phys. Chem. 1992, 96, 5837. Borisenko, K.B.; Hargittai, I. J. Phys. Chem. 1993, 97, 4080. Borisenko, K.B.; Bock, C.W.; Hargittai, I.J. Phys. Chem. 1994, 98, 1442. Domenicano, A.; Schultz, G.; Hargittai, I.; Colapietro, M.; Portalone, G.; George, P.; Bock, C.W. Struct. Chem. 1990, 1, 107. 63. Portalone, G.; Schultz, G.; Domenicano, A.; Hargittai, I. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1992, 197, 482. 64. See, e.g., Bertolasi, V.; Gilli, P.; Ferretti, V.; Gilli, G.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1991, 113, 4917. 65. Bock, C.W.; Hargittai, I. J. Comput. Chem. (submitted). 66. See, e.g., Hargittai, I. In Stereochemical Applications of Gas-Phase Electron Diffraction. Part A, The Electron Diffraction Technique; Hargittai, I.; Hargittai, M., Eds.; VCH: New York, 1988, p. 1. 67. Hargittai, I.; Brunvoll, J.; Cyvin, S.J.; Marchand, A.P.J. MoL Struct. 1986, 140, 219. 68. Brunvoll, J.; Guidetti-Grept, R.; Hargittai, I.; Keese, R. Helv. Chim. Acta 1993, 76, 2838. 69. Scha(.fenberg, P.; Hargittai, I. J. MoL Struct. 1984, 112, 65. 70. Kitaigorodskii, A. I. Molecular Crystals and Molecules; Academic Press, New York, 1973. 71. Hargittai, M.; Hargittai, I. Phys. Chem. Minerals 1987, 14, 413. 72. Bernstein, J. in Ref. 28 (p. 469). 73. Domenicano, A.; Hargittai, l.Acta Chim. Hung.--Models in Chemistry 1993, 130, 347. 74. Kitaigorodskii, A.I. InAdvances in Structure Research by Diffraction Methods; Brill, R.; Mason, R., Eds.; Pergamon Press: Oxford, 1970, Vol. 3, p. 173. 75. Hargittai, I.; Kfilmfin, A. (Guest Eds.). A. L Kitaigorodskii Memorial Issue on Molecular Crystal Chemistry. Acta Chim. Hung.--Models in Chemistry; 1993, Vol. 130, Nos. 2 and 3. 76. Hargittai, M.; Jancs6, G. Z. Naturfortsch. 1993, 48a, 1000. 77. Colapietro, M.; Domenicano, A.; Portalone, G.; Schultz, G.; Hargittai, I. J. Mol. Struct. 1984,112, 141. 78. Colapietro, M.; Domenicano, A.; Portalone, G.; Torrini, I.; Hargittai, I.; Schultz, G. J. Mol. Struct. 1984, 125, 19. 79. Desiraju, G.N. Crystal Engineering: The Design of Organic Solids; Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989. 80. Bernstein, J.; Shimoni, L. CollectedAbstracts; XVI Congress and General Assembly, International Union of Crystallography; Beijing, China, 1993. Paper MS-06.01.01 (p. 164). 81. Jeffrey, G.A.; Saenger, W. Hydrogen Bonding in Biological Structures; Springer-Verlag: Berlin, 1991. 82. Maddox, J. Nature 1988, 335, 201. 83. Brock, C.P. Collected Abstracts; XVI Congress and General Assembly, International Union of Crystallography; Beijing, China, 1993. Paper MS-06.01 (p. 4). 84. Johnson, L.N. Collected Abstracts; XVI Congress and General Assembly, International Union of Crystallography; Beijing, China, 1993. Paper ML-05.01 (p. 4). 85. Dixon, D.A. Abstracts; Second Conference on Current Trends in Computational Chemistry; Vicksburg, MS, 1993. 86. Mathias, J.P.; Seto, C.T.; Zerkowski, J.A.; Whitesides, G.M. In Molecular Recognition: Chemical and Biochemical Problems H; Roberts, S.M., Ed.; Royal Soc. Chem: Cambridge, 1992, p. 35.
Molecular Structure Research
61
87. Wells, A.E Structural Inorganic Chemistry; 5th ed.; Clarendon Press: Oxford, 1984. 88. Roberts, S.M. In Molecular Recognition: Chemical and Biochemical Problems H; Roberts, S. M., Ed.; Royal Soc. Chem.: Cambridge, 1992 (Preface). 89. Lehn, J.-M. Science 1985, 227, 849. 90. Lehn, J.-M. J. Inc. Phenom. 1988, 6, 351. 91. Lehn, J.-M. Science 1993, 260, 1762.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ACCU RATE MOLECU LAR STRUCTU RE FROM MICROWAVE ROTATIONAL SPECTROSCOPY*
Heinz Dieter Rudolph
Abstract
Io II.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Introduction
64
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
64
Theoretical Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
68
A. B.
68 72
Inertial M o m e n t T e n s o r . . . .9 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General Least Squares . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
III.
S u b s t i t u t i o n rs-Structure; rs-Fit Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
78
IV.
Effective (r0) Structure; t o - D e r i v e d Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
92
V. VI.
O t h e r Structures
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
C o n c l u d i n g R e m a r k s and O u t l o o k
104
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
110
Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
112
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
112
tDedicated to Professor Helmut Dreizler on occasion of his 65th birthday
Advances in Molecular Structure Research Volume 1, pages 63-114. Copyright 9 1995 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 1-55938-799-8 63
64
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
ABSTRACT For later reference, the basic facts and equations are presented, (1) for the inertial moment tensor of a molecule modeled as a rigid set of mass points, and (2) for the general linear least-squares procedure. These tools are extensively used in the recent versions of the two classical methods of determining molecular structure from rotational spectra. The two methods are: (1) the m-method which basically determines the "effective" or r0-structure in internal coordinates by a least-squares fit, while its more recent variants yield the p-Kr (or rzx/-) and the r/E-structure, and (2) the rs-method which basically determines the "substitution" or rs-structure in Cartesian coordinates from the inertial moments of the parent molecule and all singly substituted isotopomers (by the repeated application of Kraitchman's equations), while the more recent variant, the rs-fit method, includes also all available multiply-substituted isotopomers in a least-squares fitting process. These methods and their variants have the least restrictive requirements, regarding the set of isotopomers whose inertial moments must be known, and are also more easily applicable when the structures of larger molecules are to be determined. The effect of the generally unknown rovibrational contributions to the inertial moments is discussed and it is shown that the variants presented make allowance for the constant, isotopomer-independent, part of these contributions. The equations for the true derivatives of the inertial moments with respect to the internal or Cartesian coordinates of the atoms, as used in the particular fitting processes, are given. The role of the covariance matrix of the input data (the inertial moments) is discussed, likewise that of the output when structures expressed in internal and Cartesian coordinates are to be compared, inclusive of errors, in a consistent fashion. Short accounts are also given of the "mass dependence" or rm-method, where the rovib contribution is explicitly expanded in terms of the atomic mass change upon isotopic substitution and where first-order terms are correctly included and of the closely related "complementary" or re-method, where also the second-order terms are approximately compensated for by the selection of complementary sets of isotopomers. The rm- and re-methods are in practice applicable only to small and simple molecules. Mention is also made of the r~,, -method, a simplified and hence more widely applicable derivate of the rm-method, for which a recent series of detailed papers is available.
!. I N T R O D U C T I O N The determination of accurate molecular structure from molecular rotational resonance (MRR) spectra has always been a great challenge to this branch of spectroscopy [1]. There are three basic facts which make this task feasible: (1) the free rotation of a rigid body is described in classical as well as in quantum mechanics by only three parameters, the principal inertial moments of the body, Ig, g = x, y, z; (2) the molecule can, within limits, be modeled as a rigid set of atomic mass points; (3) the relative geometry of this set of mass points is, to a high degree of approximation, independent of the isotopic substitution of one or more of the atoms. Statement (1) indicates that no more than three relevant parameters of molecular
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
65
mass geometry can be obtained from the evaluation of one MRR spectrum. Statement (3) suggests to aggregate experimental information by measuring the spectra of an adequate number of molecular isotopomers which all have the same relative geometry but different inertial moments due to the (known) isotopic mass differences and their pulling effect on the principal inertial axis system. Unfortunately, the connecting statement (2) is the weakest of them. The molecule is a rotating a n d vibrating system. The vibration is much faster than the rotation, and it is permissible to average the relevant parameters of molecular mass geometry over a rotational cycle. The molecule is thus far "effectively rigid". However, the effective inertial moments so obtained depend on the vibrational state v of the molecule, I gv , and each vibrational state has its own rotational spectrum. Usually rotational transitions ("vibrational satellites") for the lower, and hence more populated vibrational states, can be observed in the spectrum closely adjacent to the transitions in the vibrational ground state. Due to the zero-point vibrations, even the inertial moments of the vibrational ground state, 0 I g , are different from those of the hypothetical, vibrationless, and truly rigid "equilibrium configuration", Ig. It is possible only for very simple molecules to obtain the inertial moments I ~ for the vibrational ground state a n d for the vibrationally excited states I gV of every normal vibration and to extrapolate from them to the equilibrium moments I ge . For the larger molecules, the differences e eg - Ig0 - - Ig, g - x, y, z, must be accepted as unknown rovibrational (rovib) contrie butions to the equilibrium moments I g. The readily obtainable experimental 0 e ground state moments Ig = Is + eg hence only approximate the desired but elusive e e 0 m o m e n t s I g . If the u n k n o w n I g are replaced by the k n o w n I g , a systematic error is the unavoidable consequence. It is a particularly distressing fact that the unknown eg are expected to be larger than the experimental errors of the I g0 by orders of magnitude. The E g depend on a large number of force constants, quadratic as well as cubic. It has to date been practically impossible to obtain the eg for larger molecules from the information gained from vibrational and rotational spectroscopy alone. However, progress has recently been made in the ab initio calculation of rovib contributions to the inertial moments for small molecules [2,3], which appears to be a promising way of combining computer power and practical spectroscopy towards the goal of greatly improved accuracy of molecular structure determinations. Meanwhile, efforts must continue to at least estimate the resulting errors of the molecular structures obtained by the available methods or to develop variants which are less error prone due to a (partial) compensation of the rovib contributions or to devise methods to include them in some way in the model used. The experimental inertial moments may also be affected by mechanisms other than the rovib interaction discussed above; e.g., by contributions from large-amplitude internal motions or by the coupling of the molecular angular momentum and spin momenta caused by the presence of internal magnetic or electric fields. We shall assume in this review that these generally much smaller effects have been
66
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
properly corrected or are small enough to be neglected. It will also be assumed that the centrifugal distortion in the MRR-spectra has been adequately accounted for when the inertial moments were evaluated from the spectra. The two major routes followed in the attempt to determine consistent molecular structures from the experimental inertial moments of the MRR-spectra began with the r0-method and the seemingly very different substitution or rs-method [4,5]. Both methods require only the ground state inertial moments of a sufficiently large number of isotopomers if a complete molecular structure without any assumptions is to be determined. This is, nonetheless, a demanding requirement for all but the simplest molecules. The price paid for getting along without any additional knowledge of the vibrational parameters of the molecules is the fact that the "r0-structure" as well as the "rs-Structure" and all their variants are only operationally defined by the process of their calculation, quite in contrast to the equilibrium configuration or "re-Structure" which is the location of the global minimum of the molecular potential energy function and has a clear physical meaning. In the original version of the r0-method, ground state inertial moments calculated for all isotopomers in terms of internal coordinates are least-squares fitted to the experimental moments I g0. The internal coordinates represent a reference system which is identical for all isotopomers and the resulting "r0-structure" is obtained as the final set of internal coordinates determined by the criterion of optimum fit. All atomic positions must either be included in the list of those to be determined, or estimated values must be supplied and then kept fixed in the fit. The result depends on these assumed values. Schwendeman has suggested a useful ro-derived variant [6], the "p-Kr method", where the isotopic differences between the calculated inertial moments of the isotopomers and the parent species are fitted to the respective experimental differences in the attempt to compensate (the isotopomerindependent) part of the rovib contribution. The same result is achieved explicitly by the rl~-method, a r0-derived variant which is presented later in this chapter, where the calculated inertial moments plus three isotopomer-independent rovib contributions Eg are fitted to the experimental ground state m o m e n t s I 0g . The original r~-method is based on equations presented by Kraitchman [4]. He had noticed that the numerically dominant part of the inertial moment tensor for an isotopomer in which (exactly) one atom has been substituted, can be replaced by the known inertial moments of the parent molecule, and that the remainder of the tensor then depends only on the Cartesian coordinates of the substituted atom. Equating the roots of the secular equation for this "hybrid" tensor to the experimental inertial moments of the isotopomer, Kraitchman obtained his famous equations which, quite in contrast to any r0-type method, always aim at the determination of the Cartesian coordinates of just this one substituted atom. The rest of the molecule is irrelevant, it does not influence the result and need not be known. Costain has checked, for several small molecules, the invariance of rs-determined bond lengths when employing different pairs of parent molecule and isotopomer [1]. He found it superior to the comparable r0-data and recommended to prefer r~-structures for
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
67
better consistency. The original rs-method has been later developed by Typke [7] into a least-squares procedure including all available isotopomers of a molecule, also multiply substituted species, while retaining all of Kraitchman's basic principles. Widely used treatises and monographs on the theory and the applications of MRR-spectroscopy are available [8-11], also comprehensive reviews on all aspects of obtaining molecular structure from MRR-spectra [6,12,13], including rovib interactions [14] and the reliability of the results [15-17]. Molecular structural and other data obtained from MRR spectroscopy have been compiled over the past decades [18,19]. The most recent compilation is MOGADOC (short for "Molecular Gas Phase Documentation"), a computerized database and retrieval system that is updated periodically and today contains more than 20,000 references, which were critically selected and evaluated by means of keywords. Included is work done by MRR-spectroscopy, electron diffraction of gases, and molecular radio astronomy; the documentation refers to more than 6000 compounds. As an additional feature, MOGADOC contains explicit numerical data on the structure of approximately 2000 compounds. A detailed description can be found in ref. [20]. This chapter is not intended as a general review. The intention is rather to present the most recent versions or variants of both, the r s- and the r0-method, on a small common background of theory but in sufficient depth and detail to enable the reader to follow, e.g., the flow of programs coded for the purpose. The recent versions of these two methods are the least restrictive with respect to size and composition of the set of isotopomers required and are applicable also to the largest molecules that can be treated by molecular rotational spectroscopy (perhaps ten "heavy atoms" plus hydrogen). We shall not go into the problems of the "average-structure" (also called r z- or r~0 -structure), the average molecular configuration for the vibrational ground state [21-23]. For the evaluation, the harmonic part of the molecular potential energy function must be known, i.e., a great deal of information from vibrational spectroscopy (or ab initio calculations) must be available. Also, it is not independent of isotopic substitutions, although corrections can be introduced. Valuable features of the r_-structure are the clear physical meaning and the readiness with which it can be compared with the counterpart supplied by the other important and physically very different method of determining the structure of free molecules, the investigation of electron diffraction patterns of gases. Likewise, we shall not pursue here in detail the fundamental work of Watson [24,25] who introduced the "mass dependence" or r,,-structure, where for the first time an explicit compensation of part of the rovib contributions was attempted, based on the first-order expansion of the eg in terms of atomic masses. On the basis of Watson's work, Nakata and colleagues [26] have developed the "complementary" or rc-method where, by a judicious selection of complementary sets of isotopomers, the effects of also the second-order terms of the expansion can be almost completely removed, so that the rc-Structure is expected to be very nearly equal to the re-Structure. In practice, the r,,,- and rc-methods are limited to very small molecules.
68
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
Also based on Watson's earlier rm-method, Harmony and colleagues have collected arguments for the application of particular scaling factors pg to the ground state inertial moments I s0 in order to let them approach the desired equilibrium moments. The structure so obtained is called the "r m~ -structure" and is not limited to small molecules. A recent series of comprehensive papers is available [27-31]. A short account of the rm-, rc-, and rO~ m -methods is given in the last section of this chapter. The following contains a minimum of theory but conveniently referenced. The equations and statements come from two fields: (1) the description of the inertial properties for the rotation of a molecule, modeled as a rigid set of mass points, and (2) the application of the general linear least-squares procedure to fit observations that can be expressed as known functions of variables which are to be determined by the fitting process.
I!.
THEORETICAL BACKGROUND A. Inertial Moment Tensor
In mechanics, the inertial properties of a rotating rigid body are fully described by its inertial moment tensor I. We can simplify the subsequent equations if we employ in place of I the closely related planar moment tensor P, apparently first used by Kraitchman [4]. At any stage of the calculations, however, an equivalent equation could be given which involves I instead of P. The principal planar m o m e n t s Pg (g = x, y, z) are the three eigenvalues of the planar moment tensor P and the principal inertial moments Ig the eigenvalues of the inertial moment tensor I. Pg, Ig, and the rotational constants Bg =f/Ig are equivalent inertial parameters of the problem investigated (fconversion factor). Let s be any of a number of rigid mass point sets, s = 1, N s, which all have the same (relative) geometry but differ in the mass mu(s) of one or of some of the mass points oc = 1, N a. The points are described by their masses m~(s) and their positions r~ with respect to an arbitrary Cartesian reference coordinate system. This ensemble of mass point sets is the model for a number of isotopomers of a molecule, often called the substitution data set (SDS). This SDS is required for the determination of the molecular structure (the relative geometry) by any of the current methods. The total mass M(s) and the position of the center of mass rcm are then given by: Na
M(s) - E mc~(s)
(1)
o~
Na
rcm(S) = M(s) 1 E ma(s) ra
(2)
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
69
Let further the positions of the mass points be r~ ( - r'a(s)), when expressed with respect to a reference axis system which is parallel to the first system but with the origin shifted into the center of mass of the particular sets: p
r~= r -
rcm, all a , rcm=0
(3)
The three conditions for this particular translation, the three "first moment relations", are, from Eq. 2: Na
Z ms(s ) g~= ' O, g' = x ' , y ' , z '
(4)
The rotational motion of the rigid set of mass points about any axis through its center of mass in the absence of exterior forces is known as the "free rotation" of the rigid body. The planar moment tensor for this motion, with the position vectors ra referred to an arbitrary basis system, can be compactly written as a dyadic (T denotes transposition) [8,32], Na
P(s) = ~ m.(s)r=rS - M(s) rcmrcm,'r
(5)
(X
explicitly:
1 P(S) = E m~(s)r=rT-- M(s) Na
=Z
ma(s)ra
Na
/N
mla(s)rla
Na
I ~" Z ma(s)mp(s) r~r~ ma(s)r=rV~- M(s----~
a
a
(6)
~
If use is made of the shifted reference system with the origin at the center of mass, the second term in Eqs. 5 and 6 vanishes: Na
P(s) = Z rn~(s)'I'i-'-'T
(7)
O(
This is a symmetric, in general nondiagonal, tensor with explicit elements: 2
Z,n=(s)xdy
y=o(s)y;= is===
p
p
y_mo(s)zo=I
(=)
70
HEINZ
DIETER RUDOLPH
While the elements of the tensor P(s), Eqs. 5 and 6, are numerically invariant with respect to a parallel translation of the reference axis system, they do depend on the orientation (the directions) of the reference axes. If the mass point system is rigidly rotated by an orthogonal transformation T (with T v = T-i), r~'= TTr~ = TTrr
TTr~m (all r
(9)
the planar moment tensor is transformed correspondingly, P"(s)= TrP(s)T. The most important orthogonal transformation is the principal axis transformation of the moment tensor, here denoted as T(s), which transforms the coordinate system r' a of the mass point set s into its principal axis system (PAS) _Is] IFO~ ,
rt4_ TV(s)rr = TV(s)r,~_ TV(s)r~m (all r
(10)
and hence diagonalizes the tensor P(s), Na
~, 9 /~-.[s]-.[s] ptSl(s) = Tr(s)P(s)X(s)- ]~ ,,,~w.~ .~ r
( 11 )
or, showing the eigenvalues explicitly: [4 ~m~(s")x,~
ptsl(s)-/ 0
0
~
0
~_ma(s)yt~ 1-
0
0
Zma(s)z[~]-
(12)
The principal axis transformation requires that the off-diagonal elements (the deviation moments or inertial products) vanish in the PAS, the resulting three conditions are known as the "second moment relations": ~__m~(s)x[~ly[~] - ~2_}natsjya ,, [sl_[s]_ ~ .~ 2 m a t s, ,) x ~[s]_[s] ~ = 0
(13)
Since the tensor P(s), Eq. 5, is numerically invariant with respect to a parallel translation ofthe general reference system ra, the diagonalizing transformation T(s) is likewise independent of such a translation. The superscript [4 is used here to indicate that a quantity is expressed with reference to the PAS of the mass point set s. PE4(s) is hence diagonal by definition. However, P[Sl(s'), the planar moment tensor of a different set s' of mass points, expressed with respect to the PAS of the mass point set s, is, in general, nondiagonal. The need for this distinction will later occur frequently when s enumerates the different isotopomers. The eigenvalues, the diagonal elements of Eq. 12, are Pg[4(s) ( g - x, y, z), where the single subscript implies that the quantity is an eigenvalue, not a general tensor element, and where the superscript must be dropped because an eigenvalue does not depend on the reference system used.
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
71
If the set of mass points possesses any overall symmetry, a symmetry plane of the set will always be also a principal plane of the moment tensor, a symmetry axis always a principal axis, and the number of independent mass point coordinates is less than 3N,~- 6. Group theory shows that the number of independent internal coordinates (bond lengths, bond angles, and dihedral angles) required for the description of the mass point set equals the number of totally symmetric normal (displacement) coordinates [33]. The number of independent Cartesian PAS coordinates equals the number of independent internal coordinates plus the number of non-trivial first and second moment equations (those that are not satisfied alone by symmetry). If the set includes a group of mass points which are symmetrically equivalent with respect to any three- or higher-fold local symmetry axis, it can be shown that the moment tensor is insensitive to the torsional position of this group of points about the local symmetry axis fixed in the otherwise rigid set of mass points. The inertial moment tensor I and the planar moment tensor P are related by, I - Tr(P).l - P
(14a)
P = 89
(14b)
- I
[where 1 is the unit matrix and the scalar Tr(P) is the trace of the tensor P]. From Eq. 14 it is obvious that I and P are diagonalized by the same orthogonal transformation. This relation holds, no matter which reference system has been used, i.e. for Eqs. 6, 7, 11, or 12. If Eq. 12 is used, one obtains from Eq. 14 the relations between the eigenvalues of the two tensors, here shown as transformations:
ll~l~l(s)
I
0 1 1 IPxt~l(s) (15a)
1 tPzl,l(s)
I
-'-' tC,s,(sj 1
(15b)
1
The quantity,
Ag[sl = -2P gtsj = 21gf4 -11xl.~l + lrt~l + I:.l.~lI
(15c)
has been called the (pseudo-) inertial defect. For a planar molecule, Ag[slis the true inertial defect for axis g perpendicular to the molecular plane. It vanishes when the equilibrium moments Ige are used in Eq. 15c and is a small quantity for the ground state m o m e n t s I 0g. For any molecule, the pseudo-inertial defect Agt~l does not
72
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
change, under the same conditions, for isotopic substitution on the principal inertial plane to which g is perpendicular. Following convention, the principal axes are usually denoted as a, b, c in place of x, y, z, in such a way that I a < I b < I c. This ordering corresponds to Pa > Pb > Pc" For the prolate symmetric top, Pb = Pc, and for the oblate symmetric top, Pa = Pb"
B. General Least Squares We shall adhere, as far as possible, to the notation of the excellent tutorial by Albritton, Schmeltekopf, and Zare [34]. Suppose that n observable quantities Yi exist which depend on m independent variables Bj:
Yi- Yi(",Bj,") , i - 1,n, j - 1,m, m < n It is convenient to let the n • 1 vector Y be composed of the observables m • vector B of the variables Bj: Y = Y(B)
(16)
Yi and the (16a)
Suppose that the variables Bj are to be determined by a least-squares fit of the relations, Eq. 16, to the measured values Yi,exp (vector Yexp)" Assume that the measurements Yexp are unbiased (E(Yexp) = Ytrue where E( ) represents the mean or expectation value) and that the measurement errors and their correlations are described by the positive-definite n x n variance-covariance matrix Oy which can be written as the dyadic: exp
OYexp=E((Yexp-E(Yexp))(Yexp-E(Yexp))T I
(17)
Assume that an adequate approximation for the desired vector B is known, B (~ near enough to the final result for an approximate linearization of the original Eqs. 16, 16a. The vector Y calculated for this B (~ y(O) = y(B(0)), is a constant, nonrandom vector (y(0) = E(y(0))). The linearization of the Eqs. 16, 16a leads to:
m (~yi I
(Bj - BJ0,) i = l ,n
(18)
Abbreviating Yi - YI~ by Yi (vector y : Y - y(0)) and Bj- BJ~ by 13j (vector [I = B B(~ and collecting the partial derivatives in the Jacobian n x m matrix X, with elements
-
liOYiI
i= 1,n j - l,m
Xij:~-~j~
(19)
. . . Bj (~ . . ).
the system of "model equations" of the problem is: y = Xp
(18a)
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
73
We continue to call y the observations, and [~ the variables. The Jacobian X is a rectangular, in general "high", matrix (n > m). For further treatment it has to have maximum rank (= m), which requires that the [3j be independent variables. The columns of X, the "fit vectors", span the m-dimensional "fitspace", a subspace of the n-dimensional space of the observations and their errors. The Jacobian X is a constant (nonrandom) matrix which depends on the functional type but not on the measured value of each of the observations. For the practical application, we wish to substitute in y - Y - y(0) the vector Y by the vector Yexp which gives Yexp= Yexp- y(0). Since y(0) is a nonrandom vector, the covariance matrix of the observations is Oyoxp = OV~xp. The observations Yexpare also unbiased (E(Yexp) = Ytrue) since the Yexp were assumed unbiased. Due to n > m, the system of Eqs. (18, 18a) would, in general, be compatible only for the true, but unknown, observables and variables (Ytrue = Xl]true). To make it compatible when the Yexp are used, the system of Eqs. 18, 18a must be supplemented by the yet unknown (random) vector of residuals ~; (= t:true), which gives Yexp- Xll + ~:. (This is explicitly: Yexp = Xlitrue + I;true = Ytrue+ s Since Yexpis unbiased and Ytrue is a nonrandom vector, we have E(t:) = E(Yexp) - E(Ytrue) = 0, and also OE = OYexp.)The residuals t: should not be confused with the rovib contributions to the inertial moments, eg, introduced in the preceding chapter. The covariance matrix of the observations, Oy~xp = Oe, is an integral part of any least-squares problem and the subsequent result depends on Oy~p, but only to within a scale factor, ~2, the variance of the fit. Dropping the index and writing y instead of Yexp, the "error equations" in the usual notation are: y = Xp + t;,
Oy = Or; = oZM
(20)
The general least-squares treatment requires that the generalized sum of squares of the residuals, the variance 02 , be minimized. This is, by the geometry of error space, tantamount to the requirement that the residual vector be orthogonal with respect to fit space, and this is guaranteed when the scalar products of all fit vectors (the rows of X T) with the residual vector ~ vanish, XTM-l~ = 0, where M -1 is the metric of error space. The successful least-squares treatment [34] yields the following minimum-variance linear unbiased estimators (^) for the variables, their covariance matrix, the variance of the fit, the residuals, and their covariance matrix" = (XTM-1X)-IXTM-ly A
A
(21a)
O~ = O'2(XTM-1X)-1
(2 lb)
~2 = (y _ x~)T M-l(y _ X~)/(n - m)
(21c)
s^
(21d)
74
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH A
A
O~ = (y2(M- x(xTM-IX)-Ix T)
(21e)
The vector ~ is the vector of corrections which must be applied to the first approximation B (~ of the desired variables to give an improved approximation to be used in the next iteration step, B (~ + ~ ~ B (~ The iterations are to be continued until convergence is obtained. Note that O~ is then not only the covariance matrix of increments t] of the last iteration step but also of the final variables B, ~ = ~ , by arguments similar to those which let Orexp= OYexp. I f M is a diagonal matrix (experimental errors, but no correlations), M -1 is called the weight matrix, and the solution (Eqs. 21) is that for the weighted, uncorrelated least-squares problem. If M is introduced in Eqs. 21 as the unity matrix, Eqs. 21 solve the equally (unity-) weighted, uncorrelated problem. In this special case, the covariance matrices^(Eqs. 2 lb and 2 le) depend on the measurements only through the common factor ~2 (Eq. 2 lc). The solutions (Eqs. 21 a, b), are correct also for the limiting case where m = n. X is then a square matrix, X -1 exists, which simplifies the equations greatly. However, a program coded for the general least-squares procedure ^ can still be used, if provision is made for assigning unity to the then irrelevant ~2. After convergence has been achieved, Eq. 21 a gives the solutions and Eq. 2 lb their variances-covariances, correctly propagated from M. (All elements of ~ and ~)~ vanish.) If the system of error equations (Eq. 20) is "ill-conditioned", i.e., the matrix XTM-1X of the "normal equations", XTM-IXII = XTM-ly (cf. Eq. 2 la) is near-singular and has near-zero eigenvalues, care must be taken to choose a stable algorithm for the least-squares solution. The numerically stable inversion of the matrix XTM-1X is then difficult. The system is ill-conditioned when the fit vectors, the columns of X, are "not sufficiently independent" in error space (with metric M -l), that means, one or more linear combinations of them almost vanish and the corresponding linear combinations of variables 13j are indeterminable with the particular selection of observations that yield this Jacobian X. It may then become necessary to assume fixed values for one or more of the ~j involved in these combinations and eliminate them from the list of variables to be determined by the fit. Useful algorithms for arriving at the solution (Eq. 2 la) that are more stable than the direct matrix inversion are available [35-37]. In problem cases the "singular value decomposition" [38] can be applied which affords a method [39,40] that yields a numerically stable solution also in the cases where the matrix of the normal equations XTM-1X is near-singular. But it is particularly useful in such cases where this matrix is truly singular, when X has less than maximum rank e.g., because more parameters 13jare to be determined than the number of observations Yi warrants (m > n). Instead of eliminating so many of the parameters 13j from the fit by keeping them fixed till the offending matrix is no longer singular, an unambiguous solution of the underdetermined system is enforced by the additional requirement that the vector of solutions, 11, shall have minimum length. For this purpose the method selects linear combinations out of the number of original variable parameters and
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
75
keeps them fixed at their initial values. The singularity threshold can be set at the user's judgement, the elements of II can be weighted prior to the application of the minimum length criterion, and, due to the automatic choice of the linear combinations kept fixed, all initial parameter values must represent the best possible estimates. All this requires a certain amount of a priori insight into a problem to be solved by this method. If the original model is sufficiently perfect, the linearization of the problem adequate, the measurements unbiased (no systematic error), and the covariance matrix of the observations, O., a true representation of the experimental errors and A ,Y their correlations, then o 2 (Eq. 21c) should be near^ unity [34]. If Or is indeed an honest assessment of the experimental errors, but 0 2 is nonetheless (much) larger than unity, model deficiencies are the most frequent source of this discrepancy. Relevant variables probably exist that have not been included in the model, and the experimental precision is hence better than can be utilized by the available model. Model errors have then been treated as if they were experimental random errors, and the results must be interpreted with great caution. In this often unavoidable case, it would clearly be meaningless to make a difference between a measurement with a small experimental error (below the useful limit of precision) and another measurement with an even smaller error (see ref. [41]). A deliberate modification of the variance-covariance matrix Or towards larger and more equal variances might then be indicated, which results in a more equally weighted and less correlated matrix. In most practical cases the original relations (Eq. 16) are nonlinear and the linear least-squares treatment must be iterated to obtain convergence. The elements of the Jacobian X must be recalculated with each new iteration step. Although the least-squares procedure is said to be rather tolerant with respect to the precision of the Jacobian X, true derivatives should be used if ever possible, because finite difference schemes will most often require detailed considerations with respect to the allowed step width. Even then the results may show a tendency to oscillate long before a convergence limit due to the algorithms used orthe number of digits carried is reached. With true derivatives, however, this limit is attainable. The least-squares solution ~ (Eq. 21c) is independent of any non-singular, linear, constant (e-independent) transformation of the observations, y' = Cy. The transformed error equations are: y' = Cy = CXp + Ce --- X' p +e'
(22)
% , = O C y - COyC T = 6eCMC T = oZM ' 1 Since C- 1 exists, we have M pl- = ( C"1" ) - 1M - C - . 1 Ifthe primed quantities are inserted In^Eqs. 2^1, it is easily seen that ~, ~ , and o 2 remain unchanged, while e = Ce and O~, = CO~C T are correctly transformed. The relations between the observations, Y' = Y'(Y), need not necessarily be linear, provided they can be sufficiently well .
.
.
.
ix
.
.
Ap
A
76
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
linearized (at y,(0) = y,(y(0))) for the linear relation y' = Cy to hold between the increments y' and y. It may happen that a set of variables B~-B~(..,Bk,..), j - 1,m [i.e., B ' = B'(B)], exists, different from, but equivalent to, the set of variables Bj that have been determined by fitting a particular set of observations. We assume that the relation between the two sets of variables can be sufficiently well linearized at B '~~ = B'(B ~~ to admit the linear relation between the increments, p' = Cp. The matrix of the partial derivatives of the observations with respect to the new variables B' is then X' = XC -1. The error equations (Eq. 20), A
y = X' ~' + ~; = XC-1CI~ + ~; = X[I + ~;, O~ = Oy = 62M
(23)
have the solutions (cf. Eq. 21), l]'= (X'TM-1X')-Ix'TM-ly- c ( x T M - 1 X ) - I x T M - l y - CO A {~,A2 A
A (y2(X'TM-IXp) A
A -1 = ( y 2 c ( X T M - 1 X ) - I c T
--
A C~C T,
(24a)
(24b)
while (~, ~;, and O~ remain unchanged. From this it can be seen that fitting an available set of observations y to determine a new (equivalent) set of variables I]' = CI], is an operation that could be replaced by properly transforming the old set of variables ~ and their covafiance matrix. In a practical case where convergence requires several iterations, the new values would be calculated from the old final values, B#-B#(..,B/,..), while ~ , - ~)~,, follows from Eq. 24b. As an example, consider the r0-type fit to determine the independent internal coordinates of a molecule. These variables need not all be true bonding coordinates. Therefore, different, but equivalent sets are often possible. It is obviously not necessary to set up a new least-squares procedure, if the molecular structure, complete with errors and correlations, is desired with reference to a new system of independent internal coordinates. Often one or more additional internal coordinates B#, not contained in the original complete basis of independent variables (..,Bk,..) but depending on them, or differences or sums of such internal coordinates, are wanted. The correct treatment of error propagation then requires the application of Eq. 24b where, in this case, C is a rectangular matrix, the number of rows depending on the number of additional coordinates desired. In the limiting case of one additional variable (e.g., the difference between two bond lengths), C has a single row. Simplified "error propagation formulae" may lead astray if they do not take proper account of the covariances. In situations, where the observables Yi d e p e n d on p a r a m e t e r s , R(x) "-9 ' j = m + 1,m + mtx), that have been kept fixed, while others, Bj, j - 1,m, were determined by the least-squares fit,
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
77
y = y(B;B(~)),
(25)
one often needs to estimate the additional errors caused by the fact that the fixed parameters themselves may be known only within (estimated) error limits. Let C denote the n x m matrix relating the least-squares solution 1~ and the observations y in Eq. 21a, C = (xTM-1X)-IxTM -1,
AB = CAY
(26)
where AB has been used instead of 1~ and AY instead of y in Eq. 21 a to avoid the impression that the following discussion is actually part of the least-squares procedure. Let, analogous to the Jacobian X, the matrix X (x) be composed of the derivatives of the observations Yi with respect to the parameters BJX):
OY i ~})
=
t~gBj:r))(..~..~3)..~ \ }
~, 1,n,j 1,m :m+l,m+m(X)
(27)
9~} R(x) ..), are given by the experiment and do The observations, Yi = AYi = Yi - Yi(" ,-9..=-9, not change when the effect of changes of the "fixed" parameters on the result of the fit is being investigated, hence: AY = X AB + X(X)AB(x) = 0
(28)
Note that CX = 1 from Eq. 26. After left multiplication of Eq. 28 by the non-vanishing matrix C it is seen that the change AB of the parameters determined by the fit, caused alone by a potential change AB (x) of parameters B (x) kept fixed in the fit, is, AB = - C X (x) AB (x)
(29)
when least-squares conditions are to be maintained. The additional covariance matrix of the result B, alone due to finite errors of the fixed parameters, represented by the covariance matrix OB(X),is hence: OB = CX(X)OB,x)X(x)rcT
(30)
In practical cases, it will probably be difficult to estimate the covariances within the OB~X)and even more difficult to estimate any correlations between the parameters and B (x). If the latter are neglected, the covariance matrix of the parameters determined by the fit, which includes also the errors due to the "fixed" parameters, will then be the sum of Eqs. 21 b and 30: O B -- O~ + CX(X)OB(x)X(x)r C r
(31 )
78
HEINZ DIETERRUDOLPH Iil.
S U B S T I T U T I O N rs-STRUCTURE; rs-FIT STRUCTURE
The basic equations of the rs-method will be presented later within the framework of the more general "rs-fit" problem. A rigid mass point model, which is strictly true only for the equilibrium configuration, is assumed. The application of Kraitchman's equations (see below) to localize an atomic position requires: (1) the principal planar moments (or equivalent inertial parameters) of the parent or reference molecule with known total mass, and (2) the principal planar moments of the isotopomer in which this one atom has been isotopically substituted (with known mass difference). The equations give the squared Cartesian coordinates of the substituted atom in the PAS of the parent. After extracting the root, the correct relative sign of a coordinate usually follows from inspection or from other considerations. The number, identity, and positions of nonsubstituted atoms do not enter the problem at all. To determine a complete molecular structure, each (non-equivalent) atomic position must have been substituted separately at least once, the MRR spectra of the respective isotopomers must all have been evaluated, and as many separate applications of Kraitchman's equations must be carried out. If the planar moments P ge for the equilibrium configuration were available, Kraitchman's equation would give the true re-Structure. When the ground state m o m e n t s P g0 are used in Kraitchman's equations, the structure obtained is called the rs-Structure. The rs-Structure is expected to approximate the elusive re-Structure better than the r0-structure does. For the bond lengths r of linear molecules, rs--- ( r e + r0)/2 has been demonstrated, with the ordering r e < r~ < r o when bond stretching is dominant and r 0 < r s < r e when bending is more important [5]. For several small molecules with a larger than minimum number of isotopomers available for the determination of the structure, the r~-structure has been shown to be less dependent on the particular selection of isotopomers than the r0-structure [1]. Although the Pg0 are contaminated by rovibrational contributions, part of these contributions is compensated by the rs-method. From Kraitchman's equations, the square of a coordinate is found to be roughly proportional to the isotopic differences of corresponding moments, P ~ ( s ) - P~ where s is the current isotopomer and 1 the parent, while the moments themselves play a lesser role. The equations are hence dominated by the isotopic differences of the moments, and the unknown rovibrational contributions to the experimental moments cancel to the extent to which they are equal for parent and isotopomer. It is essentially for this reason, that the substitution or r~-method has to date been the preferred method for accurate molecular structure determination from MRR spectra. However, there is also a drawback. Small coordinates (< 15 pm) cannot be reliably determined because a small coordinate with its even smaller square is the result of a very small inertial moment difference which, due the experimental errors of the moments and the less than perfect compensation of the rovib contributions, may no longer be significant. The r~-method does not use the first or second moment equations (which would hold strictly only for the equilibrium configuration). The
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
79
nontrivial moment equations can hence serve as an approximate check of the quality achieved. If the nontrivial relations are assumed to be valid, they can occasionally be used to calculate a single (or at most a few) accidentally small and hence indeterminate, atomic coordinate(s) from the rs-coordinates of the remaining atoms, provided the latter are sufficient in number and large enough for accurate determination. It means, of course, that the coordinate(s) so obtained must then make up all the inherent differences between the respective moment equations written in r sand in re-COordinates. While Kraitchman's original equations require the moments of the parent and a singly substituted isotopomer, Chutjian [42] has extended the application to the case of an isotopomer which is multiply substituted in symmetrically equivalent positions. Nygaard [43] has given simplified disubstitution formulae for different types of symmetry. Arguments have been advanced for preferring Chutjian's equations also for the single substitution on a plane or axis of symmetry [44]. One of the first computer programs written to obtain the Cartesian atomic coordinates referred to the PAS of the parent by means of a least-squares fit to the inertial or planar moments of a number of isotopomers (also multiply substituted) appears to have been the program STRFIT coded by Schwendeman [6]. It is a versatile r0-type program incorporating many useful features, it is not a "rs-fit" program in the sense in which this term is used in this paper. Typke has introduced the rs-fit method [7] where Kraitchman's basic principles are retained. A system of equations is set up for all available isotopomers of a parent (not necessarily singly substituted) and is solved by least-squares methods for the Cartesian coordinates (referred to the PAS of the parent) of all atomic positions that have been substituted on at least one of the isotopomers The positions of unsubstituted atoms need not be known and cannot be determined. The method is presented here with two recent improvements: true derivatives are used for the Jacobian matrix X, and the problem of the observations and their covariances, which is rather elaborate, is fully worked out. The equations are always given for the general asymmetric rotor, noting that simplifications occur in more symmetric situations, e.g. for linear molecules, which could nonetheless be treated within the framework presented. Let s = 2, N s be a set of isotopomers of a parent molecule s = 1, and let o~ = 1, N a, enumerate the atoms in the molecule. (Eventually, only substituted atoms will be relevant.) In the present notation, the sites of the atoms are referred to the PAS of the parent s = 1, and are hence defined by the position vectors r~ J (in the rigid mass point model). Let the mass change upon substitution of atom ~ be Ama(s) for isotopomer s, we then have: m~(s) = m~(1) + Ama(s ) for O; = 1,N a and s = 2,N s
(32)
In a practical case, many of the Ama(s) will vanish (for an atom that has never been substituted, all Area(s) vanish). The planar moment tensor of the parent, with reference to its own PAS (cf. Eq. 11),
80
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
(33)
P[1](1) : E m~(1) r[1]r[llr
is diagonal by definition, the eigenvalues are Pgt~(1), g = x, y, z, and the first and second moment conditions are satisfied due to the principal axis system used. However, the corresponding planar moment tensors of the set of isotopomers, when expressed with respect to the PAS of the parent, will be neither diagonal nor will the respective centers of mass coincide with the origin of the basis system used. Therefore, the general Eq. 6 must be applied. For isotopomer s,
/N /T
ma(s) r[llr[l] r ....
pO](s ) = ~
-~
-~
!
ma(s)r~]
M(s)
ml~(s)r~ll
(34)
and with Eq. (2), remembering that ~ m~(1)r~ 1-0: N
o~
a
pill(s) = ~ ma(1) r~lr[2 Iv
+ E Ama(s) r[1]r[l]r
1 ~ ~' Am,~(s)Am~(s) "E~'f~;~ M(~) 9 05)
a
a
f5
The first term of Eq. 35 is the planar moment tensor of the parent, ptl](1) (Eq. 33). Kraitchman's basic idea was to introduce into this first (diagonal) tensor term of Eq. 35 the three experimental principal planar moments of the parent Pgtq,exp(1) as obtained from the MRR spectrum and treat them as independent experimental information. This is the essential distinguishing feature between any G-type and any r0-type method and all differences between the two types of treatment may be [1] traced back to this fact. The first term of Eq. 35 is now written as Pexp(1). It is then convenient to replace the notation for the planar tensor Pt~](s) (Eq. 35) by ll[l](s) to distinguish this new function (Eq. 36) from Eq. 35. Note that Eq. 36, in contrast to Eq. 35, depends explicitly on the positions of only those atoms that have actually been substituted in the isotopomer s: Na
n[1](s) = P~lx]p(1) + ~_~Am~(s)r~]r [1Iv-
N (t
1 E M(s---)
Na
E
(36) Am~(s)Amf~(s)r~]r~1Iv
Let T(s) be the orthogonal transformation that diagonalizes l-I[1](s) with eigenvalues l-Igisl(s).Kraitchman equates these eigenvalues to the experimental principal planar moments Pgtsl,exp(S) of the isotopomer s:
MicrowaveRotationalSpectroscopy
81
PgH(s) ----)17gH(S)= (TT(s)I-l[1](s)T(s)~t~lgtS]
(37)
If only one atom ct has been substituted in isotopomer s = 2 (Kraitchman's original proposition), the last two terms of Eq. 36 reduce to kt(2)r~ ]ra[1iv, where lu(2) = M(1)Ama(2)/(M (1) + Am~(2)) is the "reduced mass of substitution". Equation 37 is then explicitly,
21
o
o
Py(2) 0 = 0 Pz(2)
IPx(1) + [Lt(2)x~ ]2 TT(2) 9 /
~1,(2)xtl]y[1] ct ct
[1]z~[1] l.t(2)x~
..[l].y,~tl] ~t(2)..,~
..[1]..tl] ~t(2)..,~ ~,~
Py(1) + 0(2)y~ ]
~(2)y~]z%,
(38) 9T(2)
Pz(1) + g(2)Z~ kt.(2~v[l]'[1] ,.,~ .~
[where Pgt~J,exp(S ) has been abbreviated to Ps(S)]. Equation 38 is the basis of Kraitchman's equations [4]. When forming the secular equation for the tensor Hill(2) on the right-hand side of Eq. 38, it is immediately seen that the coefficients of the polynomial will contain only the squares proper of the coordinates [1]-.. y~]-, z~]-, but no mixed squares. The left-hand side of Eq. 38 displays the roots XO~ of the secular equation. Comparing coefficients, Kraitchman obtained his equations (for the general asymmetric rotor):
x[l12_ l tPx(2)-Px(1))(Py(2)-Px(1))(Pz(2)-Px(1))l(x,y,z cycl.) (39) a t.t(2) (Py(1) - ex(l))(P:(1) - Px(1)) usually the P_(s) differ much more for different g than for different s, the
Since right-hand side is indeed approximated by x~ ]2--- ~ (P.(2)- Px(1)), i.e., by an isotopic planar moment difference, as was mention~'bel~ore. Kraitchman did not actually work out the transformation T(2) of Eq. 38, although this matrix as well as the shift rcm, Eq. 2, can be given in closed form with no more knowledge than required for Eq. 39 [45]. For symmetrically equivalent multiple substitution [42,43] and for substitution on a principal plane or axis [44], the matrices 1-I[1](2) and T(2) are block-diagonal with ensuing simplifications for Eqs. 39. The sole advantage of Kraitchman's equations over the G-fit method to be discussed presently is the ease with which the equations can be applied to just a pair of molecular species, s = 1, 2, by a hand calculation as compared to the more elaborate least-squares procedure requiring a coded program. Equations 36 and 37 are the basis for Typke's r~-fit method [7]. By Eq. 36, the eigenvalues Hgt~l(s)of Eq. 37 depend on the positions r- [a1 ] of only those atoms that have actually been substituted on the isotopomer s. In accordance with Kraitchman's ideas, the eigenvalues Hgt~(s) are equated to the experimental planar mo-
82
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
ments of the isotopomer s (see Eq. 40). It is supposed that the atomic coordinates [I] (~ are known to a first approximation, r(~ . The tensor Hill(s) in Eq. 36, calculated with these coordinates, is denoted as IItll(s) (~ The linearization of the three eigenvalues HuH(S ), g = x,y,z, of Eq. 37 then yields for the isotopomer s, Pg,,) e,p(S)~ HgM(S) = HgH(s)(O) + 2 |
Ah~]
(40)
h,cz
where the eigenvalues HgL,)(s)(~ of the t e n s o r n[1](s) (0) are obtained after diagonalization by means of T(s)(~
Hg[q(s)(O) = (,i'(o)r(s)l-l[1](s)(O)T(s)(O)~t.,lg[,1
(41)
The h~], h = x,y~., a = 1, N a in Eq. 40 are the components of the position vectors r~ l (PAS of parent). It is convenient for later use to define a long-vector r Ill (3N., components) which is composed of the individual vectors rtaII, r [11" [1] T [1] T [1] T [1] (r 1 ..... r a ..... r N ) .LetAr be the corresponding long vector of the coordinate increments. By the Hellmann-Feynman theorem [46], the derivative of an eigenvalue Hgl,l(s) of a hermitian (here, real symmetric) matrix II[l](s) with respect to a parameter h~ l, is given by the diagonal element of the matrix product, a
Ohm]
011[1](S)'T(s)
-
3h~ ]
/,
(42)
[Slg[Sl
where the transformation T must be chosen to diagonalize the matrix II[l](s), II[Sl(s) = TT(s)IItll(s)T(s). Differentiating Eq. 36, we have,
0h~]
= Area(s) ~ 13
a~
M(s)
~."h "[3 +
, (z - l 'Na
(43)
where 8c~13is Kronecker's delta and @1 is the unit vector in h-direction in the PAS of the parent, @ IT = (Sh#IU, 8h.ym, 8h,:i,0. Noting that the general tensor element is,
+
f"
=Sj,if[~ +ff~Shf, '
f,f,=x[1],y[1],Z[1]
(44)
a closed formula, Eq. 45, can be given for the derivative, Eq. 42. The superscript (0) has been attached where required by Eq. 40,
Ohm]
-2Ama(s ) T,/l,gH(S)Z~
~-
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
83
with g,h = x,y,z; s = 2, Ns; o~ = 1, N a
(45)
The expression is easily coded, since T (~ Eq. 41 and the r Ill~ are known. It simplifies for substitution on a principal plane or axis and for symmetrically equivalent multiple substitution, because several of the elements of the matrix T will then vanish. It is clear from Eq. 45 that the derivatives are nonvanishing only for those atoms cz that have actually been substitued in the particular isotopomer s. Therefore, the Jacobian matrix X generated from these derivatives is, in general, a sparse matrix. If the SDS consists of singly substituted isotopomers only, the rs-fit method is, in principle, insensitive to the sign of the initial approximation r~14. for the coordinates, just as Kraitchman's equations are. The final coordinates r~ ] simply accept the sign of the initial input quantities. The reversal of the sign of one or more of the input coordinates has no implications on the result or the quality of the fit. If, in addition to the single substitutions, groups of two or more atoms are "bound together" by multiple substitution in any one isotopomer of the substitution set, the statement is still true as long as the sign (of a particular coordinate component, x, y, z) is reversed for all atoms of the respective group. The fit is otherwise unaffected. If the signs of the coordinates in the group are reversed in a disconcerted fashion, the rs-fit may nonetheless converge, though to a local minimum and with a much larger standard deviation. Again, the atomic positions outside the group remain unaffected. However, all coordinates of the atoms in the group, not only those of a particular component, are then incorrect. Therefore, if the sign relation of a coordinate component, x, y, or z, of two atoms in a molecule is in doubt, caution is in order. Convergence is no guarantee. Multiple substitution helps to assess the correct relation. For a least-squares solution of the system of Eqs. 40 for all s = 2, N s, we have to identify the components of the vector of observations y, the components of the vector of variables [I and the elements of the Jacobian matrix X as shown below (Eqs. 46-48). A left arrow has been used instead of a sign of equation to indicate that, in general, the dimensions of [I, X, and y are preliminaryand must be reduced before least-squares processing can take place: some of the [~hma- Ah~ ] may not be independent because symmetrically equivalent atoms have been substituted. Other coordinates may be kept fixed intentionally (e.g., at zero when an atom is known to lie on a principal plane or axis). The respective component(s) Ah~ l must then be eliminated from the vector of variables. Also, one or more of the observations y"gM,s may have to be dropped in order to comply with the recommendations given for the Chutjian-type treatment of substitutions on a principal plane or axis [44], Yi ~-"
Ygt~"s = eg'sl,exp(S) - I-Igl4(S)(O)' g = x,y,z, s = 2, N~
[~j ~ [~h[1]or
=
Ah.~ 1,
h - x,y,z, ~ = 1, N a
(46) (47)
84
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
With the long-vector Ar [11 introduced earlier, we have ~ = Artll. While in Eq. 20 the covariance matrix | of the observations, y = Yexp- y(0), is simply that of Yexp because y(0) is a constant nonrandom vector, the I]gvJ(s)(~ of Eq. 46 must be treated as random quantities because they go back, via Eqs. 41,37, and 36, to the three experimental moments of the parent, Pg~,exp(l ). The construction of the covariance matrix of the observations (Eq. 46), is hence more elaborate. The required matrix O r can be obtained from the available information by the following arguments. For the sake of a concise notation, let, for each isotopomer s = 1, N s, the three planar moments Pg~,Lexp(S) be the components of a 3 • 1 vector p(s):
pT(s) = (Pxlsl,exp(S), py[sl,exp(S),pzl4,exp(S))
(49)
The 3 • 3 covariance matrices Or ) for each isotopomer are known from the evaluation of the spectra, they will usually have been calculated via the covariance matrices of the respective inertial moments by the application of the transformation given in Eq. (15b). (Note that Op(s) will be non-diagonal even if the inertial moments or rotational constants have been assumed uncorrelated.) Let a long vector p (no argument) be composed of the p(s), omitting the parent p(1 ), pT = (pT(2). . . . . pT(s) . . . . . pT(Ns)) and let the corresponding notation for the quantities
(50)
Hgf~(s) (~ s = 2, N s, of Eq. 46
be: nr(s) = ( Hxt~(s)(~ ,H?~,(s)(~
(~
(49a)
~T = (rtT(2) . . . . . ~T(s ) . . . . . ~T(Ns) )
(50a)
The vector of observations, with the components of Eq. 46, is then y = p - n. Provided the rotational parameters (rotational constants or moments) of the isotopomer s, as evaluated from the spectrum, are not correlated with those of any other isotopomer s', in particular not with those of the parent (which is a general supposition in MRR-spectroscopy), the required covariance matrix O r is: Oy - Op_,~= Op + O,~
(51)
This can be seen from the definition (Eq. 17) because mixed p, rt-covariance terms will then vanish. Op is a block-diagonal matrix with blocks Op~s).Note that Oy does not consist of Op alone; this would only be true if the vector n were (erroneously) taken to be a constant (nonrandom) approximation (comparable to y0; see Eq. 18).
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
85
In contrast, the vector n is, by Eqs. 41, 37, and 36, a function of the random quantity p(1). If the transformation between the increments of p(l) and those of n is denoted as U, the required covariance matrix O,~ is found by transforming O~1 ) by the application of U, n = n(p(1)), An = UAp(1), O n = UOr
T
(52)
U is a "high" matrix with row numbering g = x,y,z, s = 2, N s, and with only three columns for x [1], y[l], z[l]. The general element of U is the derivative of any component of the vector n with respect to any of the three components of the vector p(1) and is again obtained by the Hellmann-Feynman theorem, cf. Eq. 42: (0)
--/~..cxp.()//g)(0)ISl(S)(,.I.(0)T(s). t ~~le]x(p~!l)/.T(0)(s)/)glslg(53) lsl The right-hand derivative and the resulting Ug[~,],hmare very simple. From Eq. 36:
~l'I[1](S) = diag(Sxh, 6~.h, ~-h)' ,. C)Ph[1],exp(1)
Ug[s],h[~J /J0) LI h[llg[sl),~2 =
(54)
Note that U and, therefore, O n = UOr T (Eq. 52) is a dense matrix. But O n is clearly structured by the different magnitude of its elements due to the special form of U discussed below. By Eq. 51, Oy is also a dense matrix. We have found Or to be positive-definite in all practical applications. With few exceptions, the diagonalizing orthogonal matrix T is dominated by the diagonal elements and approximates a 3 • 3 unit matrix because the angle required to rotate the PAS of the parent into that of the isotopomer is usually small: Ug~'Lh[~j= ( [~Jg[']) --" ~hg" The matrix U is then similar to a stack of unit matrices. This w o u l d be strictly true if, instead of the quantities of Eq. 46, Pg[sl,exp(s) --/-/gl~l(S) (0), the characteristic quantities of a r0-type "pseudo-Kraitchman" fit, P#,)exp(S) - Pgm exp (1), were fitted (see next section and also [47]). To avoid confusion let us recapitulate that the vector of observations, y = p - n (Eq. 46) has the elements Pg[s],exp(S) -//g[4(S) (0) (or Pgl4,exp(S ) - Pg[sl,calc(S)(O)if we revert, for the moment, from the/-/- back to the P-notation). In seeming contrast, the covariance matrix Or of the vector y very nearly equals that of a vector with elements Pgtq,exp(S ) -Pg[,l,exp(1). This is due to the "hybrid" character of the tensor II[l](s) (Eq. 36) which is composed of experimental data and nonrandom quantities. Experience has shown that the true covariance matrix,
Oy -- Op
+UOp(1)U r
(55)
is sufficiently different from Op to make also a significant difference in the result of the subsequent least-squares fit.
86
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
The usual nearness ofT to a unit matrix has another important consequence which was mentioned before. From Eq. (36) it is seen that the tensor II[l](s) contains on the diagonal the experimental ground state planar moments of the parent, part of which are the rovib contributions. If the transformation matrix T (Eq. 37) is near enough to the unit matrix, the eigenvalues of Eq. 36 will then contain these rovib contributions with little modification. These eigenvalues are equated to the experimental ground state planar moments of the isotopomer s (Eq. 37), which also include their rovib contributions. That means that the rovib contributions will cancel to the extent to which they are equal for parent and isotopomer. This is the essential advantage which is claimed for the G-method. However, in exceptional situations (e.g., substitution in nearly symmetric rotors), where the gross rotation by T can be large and T then no longer resembles a unit matrix, the rovib compensation may even be reversed and turn into a magnification of the errors
[14]. The dimensions of ~ - A1~11and 'X must be reduced when symmetrically equivalent, and hence dependent, atomic positions have been substituted. A way which is convenient for the demonstration and discussion (though not necessarily for coding a program) can best be illustrated by a simple example. Assume that two positions, ct' and ~", exist which are symmetrically equivalent with respect to a base atom t~; one such position, y ' , with respect to atom y, and none for atom ~.. All positions, including the dependent ones, could be generated from the independent ones, ct, y, ~,, by the transformation matrix D, here shown as a table (Eq. 56).
Y
y'
y
k
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
C(c~')
0
0
C(~")
0
0
0
C(~,')
0
Likewise the coordinate increments [I, including the dependent ones, are obtained from the independent variables II of the last-squares procedure by Eq. 56a: Ar~1] - ~ - Dp
(56a)
The entries in the table are 3 • 3 matrices (many of them zero or unit matrices). For example, a threefold-symmetric equivalence of the positions ct, t~', and t~" with respect to the x[ll-axis, and a reflection symmetry of the positions y and y' with respect to the x [11, ztll-plane would be taken care of by the orthogonal matrices C(t~'), C(t~"), and C(y') in D of Eq. 57,
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
87
r
1 C(a') =
0
0
- - ~
2
~
2
, C(a")
2
,gO
0
0 =
D ~
,/ 0 !/
(57)
0
1
w
,5-
C(7') =
.....
2
2
2
2
2
,
0
1 ~
-~
.J
The increment of a coordinate that is kept fixed, e.g. fixed at zero for the substitution on a principal plane or axis, must not be a component of the vector p of variables. The required elimination is most easily implemented by letting the matrix D of Eq. 56a be followed by a matrix E, which consists of a unit matrix where only the columns (not the rows) corresponding to any components of 13to be dropped have been eliminated: Artl] = ~ - DEll
(56b)
Both, D and E, are "high" matrices, the number of rows exceeding the number of columns. If, in the above example, the base atom a of the threefold symmetric group is assumed to lie on the xtl], ytll_plane ' za[1]..is fixed at zero and Az~ 1 vanishes. D would be a 18 • 9 matrix, E a 9 • 8 matrix, 1~a 18 • 1 vector, and p a 8 • 1 vector. (Schemes for taking account of symmetries and eliminations other than using matrices D and E are, of course, possible.) A closer inspection of the derivatives given by Eq. 45 shows that the elements of the entire row of the Jacobian matrix X, which corresponds to the principal axis gtS] of an isotopomer s, will vanish if this isotopomer has been substituted (singly or multiply) only on that principal plane to which gtS] is perpendicular. This fact justifies the elimination of the observation Pg,4,exp(S ) - Hgl4(s) (0) which corresponds to this row from the least-squares fit. It is related with the symmetry arguments provided in [44] for excluding the corresponding experimental planar moment, Pg~,~,exp(S), from a problem involving a zero-valued coordinate. In these cases the respective Kraitchman equation would often yield a negative square instead of a perfect zero due to the imperfections of the experimental planar moments. As reported before [7], the rs-fit method then fails to converge and tends to "oscillate" between small positive and negative values for the zero-valued coordinate. Let us hence assume that any offending observation, Pgt4,exp(S ) Hg[sl(S)(0), and the corresponding empty (zero-filled) row of X have been properly eliminated, that means the observations y have been reduced to y for further use. This is particularly important for linear molecules where there is only one observation per isotopomer, where the sum over the axis directions reduces to (say) y only, and the matrix T degenerates to the scalar 1. Also, this case can be handled correctly by means of the above matrix E and the proper elimination of components from y and rows from X. It may happen, that an inertial moment of one of the isotopomers could not be evaluated from the MRR-spectrum and must be left out of the fit. However, in the -
-
88
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
above discussion the least-squares system has been written for the planar, not the inertial moments. Since the result of the least-squares fit is independent of any nonsingular transformation of the observations, provided the covariance matrix of the observations is correspondingly transformed and the Jacobian modified (see Eq. 22), one can transform the three components ofy and the three rows of X, which belong to this particular isotopomer s, by the application of Eq. 15a from planar moment components into inertial moment components without implications for the results ~ and ~li (~ and ~ must be retransformed). After this is done, the unknown inertial moment component of y and the corresponding row of X can be eliminated (which will then modify the result). Of course, this transformation from planar to inertial moments could be carried out for all isotopomers if desired. The model equations of the least-squares treatment (cf. Eq. 19), can now be expressed as: y = Xp = XDEI~ = X[I
with
XDE = X
(58)
With the Jacobian X prepared as indicated and the vector of variables I~ limited to the independent coordinates, X has maximum rank and the problem can be solved by the iterated least-squares treatment. After each iteration step, I~ should be expanded to obtain I1 by means of Eq. 56b for the correction of the independent and the dependent coordinates. Due to the presence of E in Eq. 58, 13has the required zero component wherever a coordinate has to be kept fixed and must not be changed. The corrected coordinates are required to recalculate ~ and X (the quantities HgH(S)(~ and (3Hg~s~(s)/3h~])(~ for the next iteration step. In contrast to most applications of the least-squares procedure, the covariance matrix of the (effective) observations, O~ (Eq. 55) must also be recalculated because O~ depends on U which changes (though probably very little) with each step (Eq. 53). After the iterations have converged, the matrix product DE (Eq. 56b) can be put to further good use. Noke that the product is a constant, nonrandom matrix. The final covariance matrix O~ of the variables ~ can hence be expanded to obtain ~ : A
A
O~p= DEO~ETDr
(59)
As mentioned above, this is the covariance matrix not only of the coordinate increments of the last iteration but also of the final coordinates as determined by the fit, ~r~U= ~Artll = ~ . By means of ~rtl;, the errors and correlations of the independent and dependen~ coordi2aates can be assessed. Because of the presence of E in Eq. 59, the matrix OArtll- Or[ll will contain an empty (zero-filled) row and column where a coordinate has been kept fixed. It is easy to account for what has been called "Costain's errors" [1,5] by adding to each variance o2(h~ 1) on the diagonal of ~)Ar[ll an additional variance term (Ah~l) 2. Costain has estimated the uncertainty of a rs-COordinate with absolute magnitude lhl (in pm) as Ah = +15/Ihl pm (when the reduced mass of substitution is assumed as 1). Errors so introduced would be correctly propagated to any further processing of ~zxr~l~. There is still another, perhaps more fundamental way, to
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
89
include Costain's error by manipulating the covafiance matrix Oy of the observations instead of that of the results, ~6rf~. Costain s error estimate can be derived from the experimental findings [6] that the isotopic difference of the pseudo-inertial defect (Eq. 15c) which should vanish (if equilibrium moments were used) for a substitution on, say, the xy-plane, scatters by approximately 8[P_(s)- Pz(1) ] = 2 8 [ Az(s) - Az(1) [ - _+0.003 u/k2. This scattering range, if accepted as an estimate for the inherent planar moment uncertainty for any axis g, can be easily introduced into the rs-fit method. From the discussion above, we recall that the covariance matrix of the observations, Or, is very nearly that of the vector of the isotopic planar moment differences, P~, 0 Pg.exp(1). If the square of the above estimate, [8(Pg(s) - Pg(1))]2, is added to every diagonal element of O r, and the covariance matrix | is not merely used for weighting the observations, but is truly propagated fixing ~2 at unity), the covariance matrix of the resulting coordinates, = ~zxrI~- ~ , will then include the effect of Costain's estimate. (As a side effect, the additional variances added on the diagonal of Or will serve as "adjustment variances", as discussed in the next section, because they will often be larger than the original experimental variances.) There is another important reason why the expanded form of the covariance matrix, ~rr~l = ~i~, is useful. Working through an rs-fit as described here, with a sufficient number of isotopomers, will yield a complete molecular structure with consistent error estimates and correlations. This is different from the results obtained after separately solving a number of distinct Kraitchman equations, but quite similar to the output after finding the r 0- (or a r0-derived) structure based on the same input information. Therefore, it would be highly desirable to compare the rs-fit and the r0-structures, each obtained by a compact but different operational procedure. That means, the information gained by the rs-fit, the Cartesian position vector r [11, composed of the vectors tI~1, should also be available in the form of internal coordinates (variousbond distances, bond angles, and dihedral angles), complete with errors and correlations for an easy comparison with the r0-data. Internal coordinates and their errors and correlations are also indispensable for the truly chemical assessment of the structure obtained. For the correct error propagation, the expanded covariance matrix, ~,j~J = 6a,.t,1 = ~ , is required. Any number of desired internal coordinates St (t = 1, N,) can be calculated from the final Cartesian position vectors ..[tl , a , most conveniently by known vector formulae. For the transformation of the covariance matrix of the Cartesian coordinates into that of the internal coordinates, the derivatives of any particular internal coordinate are required with respect to all Cartesian coordinates that actually participate in the motion of this internal coordinate:
6rl(bY
~h~] = Bt,ha This problem has already been solved by the early infrared spectroscopists who calculated the transformation between the atomic Cartesian displacement coordi-
90
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
nates and the internal displacement coordinates [48-50]. The array of derivatives has become known as the B-matrix (not to be confused with B as used earlier (Eq. 16a etc.). Each row of B for a particular internal coordinate S t is composed of Wilson's s/a-vectors for the participating atomic positions ~. The increments of the Cartesian coordinates (vector Ar [1] = I~) are transformed by the matrix B into the increments of the internal coordinates (vector AS), and the covariance matrix ~}rt~l= ~}Arm = ~ of the Cartesian coordinates into that of the internal coordinates, AS = B Ar [11,
A
O~ = BOrt~JB "r
(61)
As mentioned above, the expanded covariance matrix ~ r m of the results contains a zero-filled row and column when a Cartesian coordinate h~ 1has been kept fixed. A judiciously chosen variance o2(h~ l) can be entered on the respective diagonal of ~ r m, prior to the transformation (Eq. 61 ) if the fixed coordinate is afflicted with an (estimated) error and the propagation of this error to any of the derived internal coordinates is to be studied. For this reason it may even be practical to carry along in the expanded vector of variables p an atom that has never been substituted (and will hence drop out of the fit by the application of E), but whose position can be estimated and is required for the calculation of certain bond lengths and angles involving atoms that were substituted. While the basic assumption of identical geometry for parent species and isotopomers is generally a good one, deuterated X-H bonds make an exception because the relative mass change is so large and the X-D bond so much shorter that noticeable errors would occur in any of the presented methods if the bond shortening upon deuteration remained uncorrected. The required corrections have become known as "Laurie's corrections" [6, 22]. Suppose that the X-D bond is shorter than the X-H bond by 8r. The uncorrected rs-method would then let the X-H bond appear too short by --- 28r [51]. After the rs-coordinates r~ l for atom X and preliminary rs-coordinates for the apparent location r~ l of H, have been obtained from the uncorrected planar moments, a hypothetical position H' of the hydrogen atom after an intentional corrective X-H' bond elongation by 25r (usually chosen near 2 • 0.3 pm) is assumed as,
r[1] = r[~] + 2~ir o[l] H' "XH"
~[11
"XH'
=
/
'~H'
(62)
where ",~[1] is the unit vector in the X-H' bond direction. The coordinates, first of XH' [1] are inserted into the right-hand side of Eq. 38, and the -H'[11, then of position rH,, respective tensors are diagonalized. The differences of the respective left-hand sides (eigenvalues) will then give the three required correction terms to be applied to the experimental planar moments of the deuterated isotopomer. The final rs-fit should now give the correct H position. The corrections can be computed by a small separate program and could be immediately converted into corrections for the inertial moments by Eq. 15a, or for the rotational constants. The method described requires only the experimental planar moments of the parent, the X-substituted, and
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
91
the deuterated isotopomer. A more elaborate treatment within the framework of the rs-fit method, which can take account of changes of all bonds lengths in the molecule, has been given by Typke [51]. Simplified approximation formulae for Laurie's corrections have been reported also by Berry and Harmony [30]. As is to be expected, the results of the rs-fit method are identical with those of Kraitchman's original equations when a problem with one isotopomer and one substituted atom is treated; the rs-fit method simply offers a mathematically equivalent solution of the same secular problem. This is also true when ChutjianNygaard type symmetrically equivalent multiple substitutions are present. The results of a "substitution sequence" (e.g., AB --) A*B ~ A'B*), as suggested earlier [45], also turn out to be identical with those of the corresponding rs-fit problem. The merits of the rs-fit method over the repeated application of Kraitchman's equations are: (1) the better least-squares balancing of the errors, which can be expected when a large number of (redundant) isotopomers is included in the investigation, and; (2) the greater flexibility regarding nonequivalent multiple substitutions. Note, however, that the method cannot locate a pair of nonequivalent atomic positions that appear either both unsubstituted or both substituted in the same way in all isotopomers present. The rs-fit method has retained several of the essential features of Kraitchman's original substitution method: the (partial) compensation of the unknown rovib contributions of the rotational parameters, but also the lower limit for a coordinate (approx. 12 to 15 pm [5]) for the determination with still significant accuracy, and the fact that for complete structures the nontrivial first and second moment conditions are not necessarily satisfied. Using the rs-fit method with a substantial body of information (i.e., with a significantly larger than minimum number of singly and multiply substituted isotopomers) generally alleviates the limitations. It may improve the accuracy of small non-zero coordinates, and also tends to average out gross deviations from the moment conditions, as has been suggested by the (still limited) experience with the rs-fit method and its recent developments presented here ([52, 53] and unpublished results). For the problems investigated, the convergence properties of the iterative least squares treatment were good when not impaired by the presence of too small a coordinate. The condition number (the ratio of the largest to the smallest eigenvalue of the symmetric, positive-definite matrix of the normal equations) was better by orders of magnitude than for r0-derived fits with the same input (see below). Excepting small coordinates, the accuracy of the coordinates determined was comparable with that of the (r0-derived), rl~-fit. However, the correlation between the coordinates was much less, probably a consequence of the sparse occupation of the Jacobian X (although this property may be considerably modified by the multiplication with the inner factor M -1 and the subsequent inversion; see Eq. 2 lb). In the cases studied, the values of the atomic coordinates determined by the competing methods, rs-fit and r1~,differed by perhaps <1r to 5cy.
92
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
The first and second moment conditions can be very easily introduced into the
G-fit method as least-squares constraints [7,54] if the number of isotopomers is sufficient for a complete rs-structure. The effect on the coordinates is not expected to be particularly unbalanced unless the moment conditions are required for the sole purpose of locating atoms that could not be substituted (e.g., fluorine or phosphorus) or that have a near-zero coordinate. While all coordinates may change, the small coordinates will, of course, change more. In the cases tested, the coordinate values of the rs-fit with constraints and those of the corresponding ri~-fit (not of the r0-fit), including errors and correlations, differed by only a small fraction of the respective errors, i.e., much less than reported above. This was true under the provision that all atoms could be substituted and that the planar moments that were excluded from the rs-fit because of substitution on a principal plane or axis, were also omitted from the rt~-fit. With these modifications, the basic physical considerations and the input data are the same in both cases, and the results should be identical in the limit where the number of observations equals that of the variables. Of course, the practical identity of the two structures from different origin does not necessarily permit a well-founded statement regarding the nearness of this structure to the physically meaningful equilibrium structure. In this respect, one should assess the Costain errors for small coordinates; and for the larger ones (if the Costain errors turn out to be unreasonably low) continue to rely on the estimates for the generally agreext upon accuracy of a well-done substitution structure, perhaps between 0.1 and 1 pm for Cartesian coordinates or bond lengths and between 0.01 and 0.1 ~ for bond angles. A computer program coded along the lines presented above is well suited to replace repeated separate calculations using Kraitchman's equations (Eq. 39). If desired, the program can do just what the latter equations do, but it could do a good deal more if the situation permits it. Take a simple case where, e.g., the parent molecule and two isotopomers with different single substitutions are available. Two separate Kraitchman calculations would have to be carried out to find the two atomic positions involved. However, only a program including all three molecular species would show the correlations between the coordinates of the two positions which are due to the same parent molecule for both substitutions. The correlation will usually influence the error of the distance between the two positions. The sole exception precluding the application of a program like the one described here, would be special problems when performing r m- or r.~ -calculations where explicit use is made also of negative squares obtained by Kraitchman's equations for zeroor near-zero valued coordinates.
IV. EFFECTIVE (to) STRUCTURE; ro-DERIVED STRUCTURE Molecular structures obtained from least-squares fitting of experimental rotational parameters (or isotopic differences of such) to the corresponding quantities calculated from an approximate, but iteratively improved structure, have been called
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
93
"effective" or r0-structures. Almost exclusively, the molecular structure is described by using independent internal coordinates. In contrast to the rs-method, it is a constituent feature of all r0-derived methods that the description of the structure must include all atomic positions. The "parent part" of the planar moment tensor of an isotopomer is not replaced by the experimental moments of the parent (cf. Eqs. 35 and 36) and, as a consequence, all atomic positions are explicitly present in the tensor of Eq. 6 and must hence either be determined by the fit or must be supplied and kept fixed. Since the early investigations of Costain, the rs-structure has been preferred over the r0-structure because of its better consistency and because small partial structures can be determined from a very limited SDS, neglecting the rest of the molecule. However, the limitation of Kraitchman's equations to a substitution set of singly substituted (or symmetrically disubstituted) isotopomers made it desirable to have a method which could also include isotopomers that do not satisfy these restrictive requirements, and which could also handle the problem of small coordinates in a more balanced fashion than the rs-method. The rs-fit method, described in the preceding chapter, offers greater flexibility than Kraitchman's equations, but can, in principle, not locate unsubstituted atoms. Calculating an effective or r0-structure introduced, for the first time, least-squares fitting into the determination of molecular structure from MRR spectra. Unpublished computer programs for this purpose must have been in use by various groups for a long time. A more widely used program with many options, STRFTQ, has been coded by Schwendeman [6]. It uses internal coordinates and fits inertial or planar moments, but also isotopic differences of moments. When the differences Pg,exp(S) Pg,exp(1) are fitted, the structure is called a "pseudo-Kraitchman" or p-Kr structure, because these differences are the quantities that also dominate Kraitchman's equations. Therefore, the p-Kr structure should approach the rs-Structure. By the criterion adhered to in the present paper (see preceding section), the p-Kr structure is a r0-type structure. N6sberger et al. have described their r0-derived program GEOM [39] which used the possibilities of the singular value decomposition algorithm for the first time. The applications appear to have been based mostly on a p-Kr type fitting of isotopic differences. The authors point out the predictive capabilities which permit a stepwise progress leading from a situation with a small number of isotopomers measured and a correspondingly larger number of (good) guesses of structural details, via the prediction of new rotational constants and the search for the spectra of the respective isotopomers to a complete SDS and a final reliable structure. In a recent paper [55], the multitude of possible r0-fitting schemes have been ordered under systematic aspects. Any of the three major types of rotational parameters, principal inertial and planar moments, and rotational constants, or isotopic differences of these quantities between differently chosen members of the available substitution set, could be r0-fitted. The basic experimental information evaluated from the MRR-spectrum of any molecular species will usually consist of -
-
94
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
the three ground state rotational constants or inertial moments and their 3 • 3 covariance matrix which depends on the number and selection of the transitions measured and the precision of the spectrometer. In the least-squares process, the covariance matrices act as (reciprocal) generalized weight matrices of the respective observations. In all practical cases tested, the r0-fit to this set of raw data for the available number of isotopomers,Awith the usual experimental accuracy assumed, yielded a standard deviation 6 of the fit far in excess of unity, a clear indication that systematic errors were presentNno doubt due to rovib contributions that were not explicitly included in the model. In this situation it would be meaningless to differentiate between a precise measurement and a still more precise measurement when both are better than the useful limit of precision. The possibly very different experimental weights of isotopomers that have been measured under different experimental conditions (e.g., the parent and a less abundant isotopomer) should then be equalized by deliberately adding on the diagonal of the individual covariance matrices for all isotopomers the same "adjustment variances" (possibly different values for g = x,y,z) so as to reduce the standard deviation of the subsequent r0-fit to approximately unity (or any other reasonably chosen small number; see also [41]). This will enhance greatly the numerical dominance of the diagonal in the individual covariance matrices and often practically suppress the correlations. The experimental rotational parameters and their (adjusted) covariance matrices should then be considered as the input information for any type of further data processing. The arguments following Eq. 22 will take care of the fact that the structural results of subsequent r0-fits are identical, no matter whether (equivalent) sets of rotational constants Bg(s), inertial moments Ig(S), or planar m o m e n t s Pg(S) are fitted, provided the covariance matrices of the respective input quantities have been correctly transformed. The relations for the resulting structures are, in symbolic notation: r 0 -r~ = r e = rs; that means, there is only one unique r0-structure. In contrast, corresponding sets of rotational constants, inertial moments, and planar moments, each used in a unity-weighted r0-fit, would all give different molecular structures because the three calculations then do not use equivalent input information (e.g., a unit covariance matrix for rotational constants is not equivalent to a unit covariance matrix for the planar moments). Note also that a diagonal covariance matrix for the lg necessarily leads to a nondiagonal matrix for the Pg and vice versa, the transformation matrix C of Eq. 22 being given by Eqs. 15. While the relations between the inertial and planar moments are strictly linear and constant, the relation between the increments of the rotational c o n s t a n t s Bg and the moments, say lg, is a truncated series expression and only approximately linear, Z~lg = (-f/B~)&Bg. Also, the transformation coefficientsf/B~ are not strictly constant (nonrandom), although usually afflicted with only a very small relative error. The approximations are, in general, good enough to satisfy the requirements for Eq. 22, and for the above statement r I = r e = r 8 to be true for all practical purposes.
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
95
The simple matrix for the linear transformation of, e.g., the planar moments a SDS into the isotopic differences As'lpg = Pg(S) - Pg(l) is non-square and hence singular because there are less differences than moments. The transformation of the problem is formally described by Eq. 22, but since the transformation matrix C is now singular, the arguments following Eq. 22 are not applicable. Therefore, symbolically: rap 4: rp, where rap is the/p-Kr structure, which is thereby shown to be different, in principle, from the %-structure. The non-singular matrices of Eqs. 15 apply for the linear transformation not only between the Pg and Ig but also between the APg and A/g. Therefore, symbolically, rap = ra/. However, due to the reciprocal relation between the rotational c o n s t a n t s Bg and the moments Ig, there is no linear and constant transformation between the ABg and the A/g; therefore, we have for the three r0-derived structures using isotopic differences: rM ~: rae = rap The isotopic differences need not be taken as differences with respect to the parent, Pg(S) - Pg(1). Any arrangement, Pg(S") - Pg(S'), which can be transformed by a non-singular matrix C into the former set will result in the same rAp-structure. Occasionally, %-type fits have been reported where the isotopic differences Pg(S) - Pg(1 ) for the isotopomers s = 2, Ns, g = x,y,z, plus the three moments of the parent, Pg(1), were fitted, in the hope of compensating for part of the rovib contamination of the moments. However, the simple linear transformation between this combination of observations and the complete set of individual moments Is(l) .... Pg(S),. 9 Pg(N), g= x,y,z, is constant and non-singular, and the result of this type of fit must be the unmodified r0-structure (not the rap-structure ), if the covariance matrices of the observations have been handled properly. Demaison and Nemes [56] have reported a linear regression investigation of the rovib contributions l~g-/~g- lg evaluated from the spectra of a sizable number of diatomic and very small polyatomic molecules, from which the two-parameter relation,
Pg(S) o f
log c - c 1 log/0 + c2
(62)
with different sets of constants for the diatomic and the polyatomic molecules could be established. The relation was not meant to be directly applicable to large molecules. The report prompted the attempt to introduce constant (i.e., isotopomerindependent) eg into the framework of the %-structure as three additional variables to be determined by the fit to the experimental inertial moments [55]. A constant would be the first term in any expansion of Eg as a function of whatever parameter. The true relations, for s = 1, N s,
l~
- leg(s) + eg(S)
(63a)
P~
- Pe~(s) + rig(S)
(63b)
or
for the planar moments, were thus modeled as
96
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
10,exp(S ) ._ Ig,calc(S) pe -t- Eg
(64a)
pOg,exp(S)= Fg,calc(S pe ) -k-TIg
(64b)
or
respectively. The calculated structure, called the "r/z-structure", is expected to reproduce a set of "pseudo-equilibrium" inertial moments ~e(s) instead of ground state moments. As noted before (Eq. 22), proper transformation of the observations and their covariance matrix by Eq. 15b is assumed when Eq. 64b is to replace Eq. 64a. The Eqs. 15 also apply to the transformation between the rovib contributions rig to the planar moments and those to the inertial moments, ~8. Either type of contribution can be transformed after the fit, as shown by the arguments following Eqs. 24. The usefulness of rovib contributions eg which are independent of the particular isotopomer s of a molecule could be questioned. The expansion of the true e~g(S)for the ground vibrational state is (to first order) [8],
3N-6 1
~g(S)--~ E ~ i)(s)di
(65)
i where i numbers the normal modes and d i is the degeneracy of the ith mode. From the experience with smaller molecules, where the terms e~i)(s) could be obtained from vibrational spectroscopy or by ab initio computation, they are expected to differ in sign, with e(gi)>0 where bond stretching dominates and e~)< 0 where bending is more important. The terms e~i)(s) do depend on the particular isotopomer s, and if they accidentally sum up to almost zero, the outcome may indeed be an erratic change of eg(S) from isotopomer to isotopomer. However, in the cases studied to date (most of them were investigations of larger molecules, [52,53] and unpublished work; also [57]) an improvement was achieved by the r0-derived rlE-fit over the unmodified r0-fit. This was shown by the lower standard deviation of the fit and smaller errors of the structural parameters, even in situations where truly significant values for the I~g could not be obtained. The l~g could be determined with significant accuracy ( =10 %) only when a large SDS was available. When all eg were positive, the bond lengths were shorter than the r 0 bond lengths and hence presumably nearer to the re bond lengths. Since the angles were hardly affected, the molecule appeared to be downscaled in size with only little distortion. As noted above, the constants eg could be considered as the first constant terms of an expansion for each of the isotopomer-dependent contributions eg(S). Unfortunately, the expansion cannot be extended to terms linear (or nearly linear) in the inertial moments, in the manner of F~g(S)= F~gJr Cg(lg(S)- Ig(1)), with ~g and Cg - (3eg(S)/~Olg)~ 1 as parameters to be determined by the fit. No matter whether
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
97
pe the Ig in the corrective term are chosen as/~g,expor Ig,calc, Eq. 63a can then be shown 0 pe to degenerate to l g,exp(S) ~-Cglg,calc(S ) plus terms independent of s, where the constant Cg is a function of Cg. Since the inertial moments are homogeneous functions of the (Cartesian) coordinates, any change of Cg in the fitting process could be counteracted by a corresponding common relative change of the coordinates, i.e., Cg is not a sufficiently independent variable and the fit diverges. However, if the coefficients Cg, which act as a sort of scaling factor for the inertial moments, were already known from other sources and need not be determined by 0 the fit, the model Ig,exp(S) -- c~ecalc(S) + Eg could possibly be a useful extension of the rte-method (see also the r e -'method, next section). For the linear molecule OCSe, LeGuennec et al. [57] have successfully expanded e(s) in terms of the isotopic mass changes upon substitution of Am~(s), e(s) = e + E~ c a Am~(s), where c a - (i)e(s)/t)ma)s=_l (the index g on 1~and ca, for the linear molecule g = b, has been dropped). There are four rovib parameters in this example: ~, c o, co and Cse. The three derivatives c a are related by the constraint equation (Euler's theorem), Z a ma ~e(s)/i)ma=e(s)/2 [24], because e(s) is a homogeneous function of degree 1/2, so that only two independent derivatives remain. The expansion of e(s) in terms of the isotopic mass changes appears to be a most reasonable choice. However, for the general polyatomic molecule (index g - x,y,z), the number of rovibrational parameters would then be prohibitively large: three constants Eg plus 3N a - 3 constants Cga =- (t)s (note: 3 constraint equations). At any rate, a model for the change of the eg(S) from isotopomer to isotopomer can be potentially successful only when: (1) any new variable introduced is truly independent of those already present and, of course, when; (2) the number of variables is not increased unreasonably. Although the r~E-fit and the p-Kr rap (=rat) fit are not equivalent (the former determines three more variables), it could be shown [55] that the molecular structures determined by the rz~-fit and the ra/-fit are strictly identical, including the covariance matrix. This is due to the specific form of the Jacobian matrix X of the coupled least-squares problem r~, which permits a decomposition by a non-singular transformation into a smaller least-squares problem r~ plus a subsequent direct calculation of the constant rovib contributions eg. The rzx/-part of the problem alone determines the molecular structure which must then be used (including the covariance matrix of the structural parameters) for the calculation of the contributions eg. When rotational constants of new isotopomers are to be predicted from the structure determined, the rl~-method performs much better than the ra/-method due to the presence of the additional rovib parameters eg. As discussed in the preceding section, the r~-method (Kraitchman's equations or the r~-fit) is practically insensitive to a (small) change of a planar moment component, as represented by the rovib contributions, if the change is common to both the parent and the isotopomer s, and if the rotation by the diagonalizing matrix T(s) (Eq. 41) is small. Therefore, it usually does not matter whether experimental ground 0 state planar moments Pg,exp(S) or, after the rig have been obtained from a preceding
98
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
rlE-fit, rovibcorrected moments d,exp(S) - qg [= epe(s), Eq. 64b] are used as input data for the rs-method. The situation is different when the rotation by T(s) is large for the substitution of a particular atom. Then, using again the rs-method, the 0 different type of input data, Pg,exp(S) and pPge(s), respectively, may localize this atom in apparently different rs-pOsitions. A good agreement of the earlier rlCdetermined position with the rs-position obtained from the Ppge(s) data, despite the large rotation by T, can then be taken as an indication that the Ppge(s) are obviously good approximations to the equilibrium moments Pg(S) (which would yield identical structures by whatever method chosen irrespective of any rotation by T). In the following, we present the essential equations of the rl~-fit. They are simply those of the r0-method, with three more variables added. For the sake of a unified development, all relations are expressed in planar moments. The model for the structural part is the rigid set of mass points; only when the calculated moments are equated to the experimental ground state moments, are they supplemented by three constant rovib contributions. Let the set of masses be described, as before, by the atomic masses of the parent species, ma(1), and the mass changes upon substitution, Ama(s), for the atoms ot = 1, N a and the isotopomers s = 2, N s (see Eq. 32). The structure is defined by N s (not to be confused with N s) internal coordinates S t (composed into a vector S): bond lengths, bond angles, and dihedral (or torsional) angles for each atom. The (minimum) number of internal coordinates (i.e., components of S) is 3N a - 6. The ~oms are numbered, and a list showing to which atom each atom is attached, is a constituent part of the description. It defines the connectivity in the molecule. The list is arranged as a "tree" or branched chain, one atom must be the initial atom, and the chain must not have loops. The connectivity so defined need not, and sometimes (annular structures) cannot, be a true image of chemical bonding in the molecule. The list should be organized in a way which facilitates the description of symmetrical equivalence of atoms (both, overall and local symmetries) by preserving the molecular symmetry as far as possible. The introduction of (massless) "dummy atoms" is often helpful when the deviation from local symmetry of a whole group of atoms (e.g., the tilt of a methyl group) is to be described (then N s is larger than minimum). The vector S of internal coordinates is the same for all isotopomers, with the sole exception that Laurie corrections for the X-H bond shortening upon deuteration can be arranged for with particular ease by simply reducing the respective bond length coordinate for the D-isotopomer. For the calculation of the principal moments, the structural description of a particular isotopomer must be translated into Cartesian coordinates. This can be done by an algorithm which has been given an efficient and widely applicable form by Thompson [58]. Each atom is considered to be the origin of a local Cartesian base system whose axis directions are fixed by a prescription which references the two preceding atoms in the chain (and a few conventions if necessary). The positional description by the local base systems is then retransformed, in a stepwise fashion along the chain (by a translation plus a rotation), into that of the local base
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
99
system of the initial atom, which eventually serves as the reference system for the whole set of mass points. This Cartesian description can be expressed as r~ = r~(S) (all (~) or
r = r(S)
(66)
T ., r[1]T~ when the notation rT - (r T. . . . r~,. N~,, is used. It is identical for all isotopomers (excepting Laurie corrected bonds). With the known masses m~(l) and Eq. 6 for the planar moment tensor referred to an arbitrary base system, the tensor P(1 ) is calculated and diagonalized by means of matrix T(1 ), Eq. 11. With T(1) known and rc,,,(1) from Eq. 2, the base system of Eq. is transformed into the principal axis system of the parent, r~ ] (Eq. 10),
66
rill= TV(1)r~ - TT(1)rcm(1) (all t~)
(10a)
also denoted as r [1IT- (r~1IT.... 10~"[I]T . r~. ]T) as. in the. preceding . section This system will be used in this paper as referefice system for calculating the planar moment tensors of all isotopomers, P[q(s). The eigenvalues are obtained after [1] ), Eq. 2, will be required diagonalization by means of T(s). Also, the vectors rcm(S later. However, prior to the least-squares procedure, only an initial approximation for the structure is available, S ~~ Therefore. only approximations for the Cartesian description r ~~ = r(S(~ for the vectors r~~ for the PAS of the parent r IlIa~, and for the eigenvalues of the isotopomers, can be calculated. The expansion of the eigenvalues is, when S r176is assumed to approximate the true structure S well enough for truncating the expansion after the linear term,
pgfs~(s)
Pgt~(s)~~
Pgt~J(s)
Us ~(OPgt~'(s) Pg[4(s)= Pg,.,,(s)(~+ ~ ASt
(67)
PgN(S)(0)
Laurie corrections would be applied by calculating the initial v a l u e s for shorter X-D bonds. From the preparation of the P(s) and from Eq. 66 it follows that the are indirect functions of the internal coordinates S, via the Cartesian coordinates r~] 9
Pg~sl(s)
Pg's'(s)=Pgt"(s)(~+ ~ ~'~(h~ bh~]
~ bS,
As in Eq. 42, the derivative of the principal planar m o m e n t s the PAS coordinates of the parent, h Ill is given by
AS'
Pgf4(s)with respect to
aP?~(s) /Tv al~l](s) 0h~]
=
(s).
(68)
Oh[al]
The derivative of the tensor p[ll(s) (Eq. 5) with reference to the PAS r~ ] is,
(69)
100
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
k"h ~"s -- r[1] ,,,,T
()pill(s) =
- - %,,,[l]s m())
e~l] T)
(70)
fcm (s)))
(71)
with elementf, f ' = x[ll,y[1],z[1],
(~P[1](s) {)h~l Ij , : m s ( s )
(~)fh(fs
'-
L,,,(' S ))+ 8f'h(fa
The closed formula for the desired derivative after the required superscripts (o) have been attached, is:
(bpp,(s)]C~ ~h~ ]
~,;',~,1.(0)
- 2 ms(s ) ~~
lJ,lgIS,
g,h = x,y,z
s = 1, N s
(s)(f[lal(o)_ f[l~O,(s) ~, cm
c t - 1, N a
) (72)
It is convenient to arrange these derivatives as a 3Ns x 3N a matrix F (~ The derivatives of the Cartesian PAS coordinates h~ ] of the parent with respect to the internal coordinates S t, required for Eq. 68, are well known from molecular vibrational theory as the derivatives of the respective displacement coordinates. They are usually arranged as the elements of a 3N a x N s dimensional matrix, which has been called A [59] and gives the linear relation between the increments of the internal and Cartesian coordinates: At= A AS
(73)
Several authors have shown how to calculate the matrix A [58,60-63]. A is the pseudo-inverse of the matrix B of Eq. 60: B. A = 1, where 1 is the N s x N s unit matrix. Polo [64] appears to have been the first to express the matrix A directly by constructing, for each atom c~ and each internal coordinate t, the 3 x 1 vector:
po,0-f
(74)
Each column t of A is then composed of N a vectors pO, just as each row t of B is made up of N a Wilson-type vectors sts. The pseudo-inverse relation of B and A is thus given by:
N a
Z Sto~pOt -- ~)tt,
(75)
s The superscript ofPolo's p~ indicates that the Eckart conditions are satisfied [64], which is required for the PAS coordinates. For the calculation of the vectors
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
101
p0, the above mentioned tree of connectivity is needed with the local base reference systems attached to each atom. The matrix A (~ is superscripted to show the dependence on S (~ The inner sum of Eq. 68 is the element of the 3N s x N s matrix product: X ' = l~~176 (76)
P glSls.h[1]o~ We pause to state that the treatment which led us from Eq. 67 to the matrix X' of Eq. 76 is not unique. Instead of Eq. 68, the indirect dependence of the planar m o m e n t s Pg[4(s) on the internal coordinates St, could have been expressed by:
"g,,l(s) = "g,,l(s)(0) + ~ ~h,,
c3h~l J t -~t ) ASt
(68a)
The first factor in each term of the sum is simpler than in Eq. 68 and would be given by Eq. 70 with the superscript Ill replaced by [4 and noting that rcm(S)[4= 0. However, in contrast to Eq. 76, the second factor would then have to be calculated separately for each s. The system of Eq. 77, obtained from Eq. 67 by any treatment chosen, is the starting point for a r0-type fit (here a re-fit),
Ns
Pgtsl(s) =
Pgt4(s) (0) + Z X'g ['lst' ASt
'
gs - = x,y,z I,N s
(77)
t
when the right-hand sides are equated to the experimental ground state principal 0 planar moments, Pg,exp(S), and the appropriate covariance matrix is used. For the rl~-fit, Eq. 77 must first be supplemented by terms for the (constant) rovib contributions rig:
Ns
Pg[4(s) + q g - Pg[4(s)(~ + rl~~ + Z Xtg Isls,t ASt + A]lg
(78)
t It is then convenient to append to the matrix X' a stack of N s 3 • 3 unit matrices, thus forming the composite Jacobian matrix X of dimension 3N s • (N s + 3). Likewise, the N s • 1 vector_ AS and the 3 • 1 vector All are combined to the composite vector of variables II of dimension (N s + 3) • 1. The component index of II and the column index of X is 7"= 1, N s + 3.
102
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
ri
1
":" AS
'X= X'
~=
(79)
A11
k
\
J
In contrast to the rs-method, the part X' of the Jacobian is, in general, a dense matrix with no apparent structure. The following equations show the identification with the quantities of the least-squares procedure (the vl~~ will most often be chosen as zero) 9
Yi +-- Yg"l,s = Pg'~",exp(s) - Pg'"(s) (0)- l"l(g0)' [~j <-- [3r - AS, (for F<_Ns),
g = x,y,z s= l , N s g- l , N s + 3
= Arlr_Ns (for F> Ns) (~PgH(S)) (0) Xij ~ Xg%'r= ~ 3S, (for F< Ns),
(8o)
(81)
g - x,y,z s- l,N s F- 1,Ns+ 3
-
-
'~g,F_Ns
(for F> Ns)
(82)
Prior to the application of the least-squares procedure, the number of variables 13r(and the number of columns of X) may have to be reduced because symmetrically equivalent positions are present or because certain variables must be kept fixed. Also, one or more observations ~gl.q(and corresponding rows of X) may have to be excluded from the fit in order to comply with the rules for planar substitution or because they could not be measured. This can again be done with the aid of matrices D and E. Other than in the preceding section, the matrix D must now relate the increments of symmetrically equivalent internal (or bond) coordinates with the increment of the respective base internal coordinate. Let us return to the example, Eq. 56, and let the matrix D, as depicted there, be a portion of the whole matrix D. The row and column headings of each 3 x 3 block of D for a particular atom now specify the increments of bond length Ar, bond angle Aq0, and dihedral (or torsional) angle AO used for the attachment of this atom to the chain, instead of the increments of Cartesian coordinates of the atom. It is assumed that the description by internal coordinates has been chosen for the best possible preservation of molecular symmetry. The three symmetrically equivalent atoms ~, ~', and c~" will then be attached to an interatomic bond along the x-axis (or, by convention, to an equivalent
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
103
axis stub if the immediately preceding atom is the initial atom of the branched chain). The increments of the bond coordinates for the three symmetrically equivalent atoms ix, ix', and or" must be i d e n t i c a l Ara=Ara,=Ara,,, Aq~ = Aq)~, = Aq~., AO~ = AO~, = A O ~ , - and the 3 x 3 matrices C(~') and C(ct") will now be unit matrices. Let the symmetrically equivalent atoms y and y' be attached to an interatomic bond lying on the x,z-plane, whence: Arc=Art,, Aq)~,= A~,,, but AO~,=-AO.t,. The respective 3 x 3 block of the table of Eq. 56 is now C(y ) = diag(1, 1, - 1 ) . The matrix E must take care of the fact that the inertial tensor is, in principle, insensitive to the torsional position of a C3-symmetric group (here atoms c~, ix', and ~"). Therefore, the irrelevant dihedral angles Oa, Oa,, and Oa., are kept fixed at their initial values and the variable AOa (with the symmetrically equivalent partners) is eliminated from the fit by leaving out the respective column of the matrix E. In practice, the matrix product DE is readily generated from the input to the actual problem. The input must specify which bond coordinates of which atoms are free to be determined by the fit and, in the case of symmetrically equivalent bond coordinates which must be varied simultaneously, if the increments are to be taken in uniform or opposite directions. The matrix DE then serves as a bidirectional list relating the complete set of all internal coordinates required for the description of the molecule with the smaller set of the truly independent internal coordinates of the fitting problem. The model equations for the iterated least-squares treatment are given, reduced to these independent variables, by, y = XII = XDEp = Xp
with
XDE= X
(58)
where it has been assumed that also the observations y have been reduced to those,,,., appropriate for the situation. After each iteration step, I] should be expanded to II (Eq. 56) for the correction of the independent and the dependent internal coordinates, S (~ + ~ ---->S (~ which results in an improved approximation for the next step which starts again with Eq. 66. After convergence, the description of the molecular structure is available in internal coordinates ~, obtained from S (~ after adding repeated corrections ~, and in Cartesian coordinates rtl], from Eq. 10a of the last iteration cycle. The expanded covariance matrix of the variables (Eq. 59) is that of the internal coordinates, ~ = ~ . The covariance matrix of the Cartesian coordinates is obtained by the transformation of ~ with matrix A (Eq. 76) for the parent species from the last iteration cycle: A
A
OrB1-AO~A r
(83)
A
Experience has shown the covariance matrix Or[,J to be conspicuously different when the same problem was treated by either the rs-method (withoutenforcing the first and second moment conditions) or any of the r0-derived methods. For the former method the errors of the coordinates were much less correlated. This, as well as the better condition number of the normal equation system, is no doubt a
104
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
consequence of the different structure of the Jacobian matrices X. The Jacobian of the rs-method (without the moment conditions) is a sparse matrix and gets denser only to such a degree as more and more multiply substituted isotopomers are included in the SDS. The results of the r s- and the r/~-methods agree well regarding the effect of applying Laurie's corrections when the evaluation can be based on a sufficiently large SDS. In several cases tested, the inspection of the structure in internal coordinates showed that the effect was almost completely limited to the corrected X - H bond length. Compared with the result obtained without correction, this bond was elongated by --2 8r when the X-D bond length in the input for this isotopomer was described as shorter by 5r than the X-H bond length of the parent This is the effect required to compensate for the error incurred when the bond length change remains unattended [51]. However, when the correction was applied within the original r0-method, bond length changes were distributed over several bonds, although the X - H bond was affected most. In contrast to the rs-method, where unsubstituted atomic positions are indeterminable, r0-derived methods can locate also unsubstituted atoms, although with less accuracy than for substituted positions. In practical cases, this capacity is limited to one or two unsubstituted atoms and yields useful results only when the SDS is otherwise large enough. Coordinates that are (for whatever reason) not included in a r0-type fit must be assigned estimated values, which are kept fixed in the fit but affect the result. In these cases, one should not do so without also setting error limits to these coordinates in order to find out, by Eq. 30, which additional errors of the positions are due to the error afflicted "fixed" positions. If symmetrically equivalent atomic positions are among those kept fixed, the relations established between the independent and the expanded set of variables (Eq. 56b) now denoted as B (x) and ~(x), respectively, are applicable in the form" AB (x) = D(X)E(S)AB(X),
X(X)D(X)E (x) = X (x)
(84)
The expanded covariance matrix of the "fixed" parameters (cf. Eq. 59) is, Oh(x) _ D(X)E(X)OB(.,.)E(X)tD(x)t
(85)
and the additional effect on the variables determined by the least-squares fit, (cf. Eq. 30) is given by OB = CX(X)O~(x)X(X) C r _ CX(X)OB(x)X(x)Tcr
(86)
V. OTHER STRUCTURES In this section we shall first give a short account of the "mass dependence" or rm-Structure introduced by Watson [24], and also of the "complementary" or
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
105
re-Structure developed by Nakata et al. [26] on the basis of Watson's method. The central point in both methods is the expansion of the rovib contributions Eg(S) of the single-substituted isotopomer s with respect to the isotopic mass change Ama(s) = m~(s) - m~(1) of the substituted atom o; (g = x,y,z), OEg
1 C)2Eg
Amo +
A,n +...
(87
where the derivatives are to be evaluated with the set of masses m~ of the parent. Watson's original rm-method takes into consideration Z~g up to the first order in the expansion; the rc-method additionally arranges the required isotopomers into complementary sets in the attempt to also compensate the effect of the second order terms of the expansion. Both methods require a very large number of isotopomers for all but the smallest molecules. They are important for theoretical reasons and they are practical for the highly precise determination of the structure of very small molecules (where the results can often be compared with the available re-Structure), but they are hardly applicable to the larger polyatomic molecules. They have, therefore, not been treated at length in the preceding sections. The basic principles of the rm-method can be exemplified most clearly by the case of the diatomic molecule, c~ = 1, 2, where, by Kraitchman's equation in the simple form for linear molecules, the equilibrium and the substitution coordinates with respect to the PAS of the parent, x~ and ~ , respectively, are given by,
a
2
A/~, (xS)2 A/~,,
- s
(88)
where A indicates the isotopic difference between the inertial moment of each of the singly {x-substituted isotopomers, c~ = 1, 2, and that of the parent. From i0 = Ive + ev, we have, .
=
+--B--~a-
5 + ~9m----~+ 5 5
~)m2" + "'"
(89)
since the expansion (Eq. 87) can be reformulated with the reduced mass Ba = MAmJ(M + Ama): Agy_ ~8,, _
g~
.
Ama ~2(M 8v) +
+...
c)m~ 2 M
(90)
~m2
Eq. 89 can be summed up over the two single-substituted isotopomers, ot = 1,2, to give: 1,2
2
1,2
/'e'~ 2
1,2
Zm.CxS.)-Zm.~-~)+Zmo~
~ey+
1
Omc~ 2---M
1,2
Z m . Am.
~)2(M Ev) (91) " +...
am~
106
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
The left-hand side of Eq. 91 is computed from the substitution coordinates and is hence defined as the "substitution inertial moment" ~, of the parent. The first term of the right-hand side is the equilibrium moment ly of the parent:
1,2
aE3,
1,2
1
a2(Mgy)
I~,=l~e,+Ema - ~ m a + - ~ E m a A m a ~ am+ 2 ot
...
(91a)
o~
The substitution moment I~,s differs from the equilibrium moment lye by first order terms of the expansion. Since Eg is a homogeneous function of degree one-half of the atomic masses [24], the second term on the right-hand side of Eq. 91a is, by Euler's theorem:
1,2
~1~,, 1
E ms 0m~
1 (i 0 _ le )
2 ~Y=2
-
(92)
-
Equation 91 a can hence be rewritten as,
1,2
r
lym - 21y- l~ lye +-~1 E ma Ama ~
+ ...
(93)
o~
where the left-hand side is defined as the "mass dependence inertial moment" of the parent which differs from the equilibrium moment only by second order terms. If the bond length r m is then calculated from this mass-dependence moment/.'~ = 2I~~,- ~, using, (','= ~
mlm 2
r2m
(94)
/711 + m 2 (which is the r0-type procedure applied to ly), r m should be closer to the equilibrium value re than the substitution bond length r s = ~ + ~2" Watson [24,25], who tested his method with a number of linear and bent XY 2 molecules, could show that the rm-Structure was indeed a good approximation to the re-Structure, except for molecules containing hydrogen. The relative mass change upon deuteration is so large that it does not suffice to take into account only first order terms of the expansion with respect to the atomic masses. If the planar moment components, Pg (g = x,y,z), and their rovib contributions, TIg = ~1 (ex + ev. + 8,,) - eg, are used, the corresponding equations required for the rm-method can be found also for the general polyatomic molecule (asymmetric top). The equations are approximate and hold under the provision that the PAS rotation upon isotopic substitution is small [24],
2
2
Aqg iaa
2
~qg
Ama ~2(Mqg)
~
2M
~)m2
9
(95)
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
107
where g~ and g~ (g= x,y,z) are the equilibrium and substitution coordinates, respectively, of atom ot with respect to the PAS of the parent. Summing over all single-substituted isotopomers yields, N
N
N
a(gsl2~(gel2C~
Ema
~l, lg q..
N -a
1
(96)
~ 2 ( M F_,g)
a =~.~ ma a + E m a ama -~--~EmaAma
~
~9m2
-
-
~
-
,,.
which is, after defining the left-hand side as the "substitution planar moment" of the parent, ps. g" N
N
brig
1
ang
1
"
a2(M rig)
+2 PSg=peg+~-~ma~mu+2-M~-~makma ~ am
...
(96a)
Ot
With Euler's theorem, N
o
1
o
ma am a = ~- rig = ~-(P g -
,,~)
(97)
one eventually obtains the three "mass dependence planar moments" of the parent: N
1 c)2(M 'lqg) Pg =- 2pss - P g = P g + -'M Z ma kma .......am 2 + . . . m
0
e
"
(98)
As before, the substitution moments differ from the equilibrium moments by terms of first order in the expansion, and the mass-dependence moments only by terms of second order. Only in the rare case of very small or highly symmetric molecules will the small number (< 3) of planar moment components Pgm (1) of the parent alone suffice to compute the molecular rm-Structure. To make available for this purpose the three mass-dependence; planar moment components ~'(s) = 2~g(S) - P~ of only one additional isotopomer s, all isotopomers which are single-substituted with respect to this isotopomer s must have been measured and evaluated in order to find Pg(S). For all but very small molecules the expense involved is prohibitive. Nakata and colleagues [26] have noticed that the term for any atom cz in the sum of Eq. 93 changes sign when the role of the substituted and unsubstituted (parent) species is exchanged with respect to this atom" A m a = m ~ - m a - - A m a = (ma - ma). While Watson's rm-method for a diatomic requires the three molecular species XY (parent), X'Y, and XY* to evaluate ?v~(XY) for the parent by Eq. 93, Nakata and colleagues also suggested the evaluation of the "complementary set" of isotopomers, X ' Y * (parent), XY*, and X'Y, in order to also find l'vm (X * Y * ). Assuming mffM and ,92(M Sy)/Om2 to be sufficiently invariant with respect to XY -
108
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
and X'Y*, the second order terms of Eq. 93 are then approximately equal in magnitude and opposite in sign for I~m (XY) and lym (X'Y*). The bond lengths computed from Eq. 94 are, therefore, expected as rm(XY) = r e + Ar and rm(X*Y*) = r e - A r , respectively, from which the "complementary" bond length rc(XY) is obtained by the average:
'(
)
rc(XY) = ~ rm(XY) + rm(X*Y*) = re(XY )
(99)
The method is an improvement over the rm-method since it approximately compensates also the second order terms of the expansion of Eq. 98. It has been shown to work well even for molecules containing hydrogen. For the r c bond length of a diatomic molecule, which presents the simplest possible case, the inertial moment of one additional isotopomer, X'Y*, would have to be known over those required for the original rm-method: XY, X'Y, and XY*. Nakata, Kutchitsu, and Mills [65, 66] have later given details and shown that the bond length rm(X*Y*) need not be calculated from the spectroscopically derived inertial moment Ism (X'Y*) of this additional isotopomer, but can indeed be calculated from the inertial moments of the parent XY and the singly substituted isotopomers, X*Y and XY*. The method is restricted to a limited class of very small molecules (essentially diatomics and bent XY 2 molecules) and is based on the additivity rule [67] for vibrationally averaged, i.e. rz-type, bond length changes 8r z upon isotopic substitution of either one or both of the bonded atoms: r_(X*Y) - rC( X Y ) + 8rz(X*Y) ,.
rz(XY*) - rz(XY ) + 8rz(XY* ) rz(X*Y*) = rz(XY) + 8rz(X*Y ) + 8rz(XY*)
(100)
Therefore, it is the vibrationally averaged inertial moment I~(X*Y*) for the diatomic which is calculated from I~.(XY), 9 Iv(X = *Y), and I~(XY*) by the authors. Splitting the rovib contribution into a harmonic and anharmonic part, the relation between I ~ I e, and I= is given by [8, 22]: Ig0 - - Ige + 8g(harm) + 8g(anh) - Fg + 8g(harm)
( 101 )
The moments I:g = Ig0 - - E g (harm) can be calculated from the ground state moments if the harmonic force field is known, although the present application is not very sensitive to uncertainty in the force-field [65]. The moments l:g are geometrically more consistent than the I g0 (e.g., the inertial defect, Eq. 15c, expressed by the l:g practically vanishes for a planar molecule). For the present purpose, the s the substitution m o m e n t s I gs, and the mass dependence substitution coordinates g~, m o m e n t s I gm must be adequately redefined in accordance with the use of the moments IZg instead o f I g0, but the important result, Eq . 99, remains unchanged .
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
109
There are very few cases where the moments Ig' of one molecular species (at most three moments) suffice to derive all structural parameters; this is, e.g., possible for the diatomic where one moment is obtainable and required for one bond length, and for the bent (planar) XY 2 molecule where two independent moments are obtainable and required for one bond length plus one angle. In these few cases, the relevant rm-type parameter(s), obtained for both, the parent, XY., and the "complementary parent", X'Y*.*, can be averaged according to Eq. 99 to obtain the r c values. If the moments I gm of more than one species are required to determine the molecular structure, this averaging is no longer feasible. The rc-Structure must then be obtained by direct calculation (or by a least-squares fit, if possible) using a substitution data set composed in a completely balanced manner of complementary sets of isotopomers. The linear XYZ molecule, e.g., is a problem which must be treated in this way. This rc-Structure is still expected to approximate the re-Structure better than the rm-Structure does. The number of multiple-substituted isotopomers, which are required to form complementary sets for a rc-type structure determination, increases enormously with the number of constituent atoms of the molecule. Therefore, Nakata and Kutchitsu [68] have developed a method to estimate the (ground state) inertial moments of all multiple-substituted isotopomers only from the moments of the parent and the single-substituted species. In effect, the method is also based on the additivity rule for increments of vibrationally averaged bond lengths upon isotopic substitution. A precise knowledge of the molecular structure is not required. Where the estimates could be checked, they were good enough to replace the spectroscopically obtained values when calculating the rc-structure. The results were a little less than optimum where a rotation of the PAS upon isotopic substitution would have to be taken into account. Since the extension offered by Nakata and Kutchitsu's estimates of the inertial moments of multiple-substituted isotopomers is still limited to a few classes of small and simple molecules, the application of the rc-method remains restricted, but where it can be applied it appears to yield the best possible approximation to the re-Structure. The r~, -method, which is applicable to larger polyatomic molecules, was not discussed in the preceding sections because a recent series of detailed papers is available [27-31]. The method requires the ground state rotational constants of the parent and all single-substituted isotopomers. Therefore, it is less restrictive than the r m- and re-methods, but somewhat more so than the rs-fit and r0-derived methods which permit the inclusion of multiple-substituted isotopomers. In contrast to the r m- and r~-method, the substitution inertial moment is required only for the parent, I sg (1). For this purpose the single-substituted isotopomers are indeed sufficient. From Igs (1) the set of three numbers,
Pg --
igO(1)'
g = x,y,z
(102)
110
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
is obtained which are then used for the corrective scaling of the ground state moments of all isotopomers by a factor of 29g - - 1 ,
IPm,g(S) - ( 2 9 g - 1 ) ~ ( s ) - ( 2
Ig(1)10g (l) _ 1)ig0(S)
(103)
before a final r0-type fit to the IP,,g(S) is carried out which yields the ~,-structure. The scaling of the moments is such that the substitution moments of the isotopomers are approximated by lSg(s) = 9gI~ and that the relations (Eq. 93) for the mass-dependence moments Ig'(S) are approximately satisfied by IP,,g(S) for s ~ 1, and exactly for s = 1. This scaling variant alleviates some of the difficulties characteristic for the determination of the moments Ig(S). Laurie's corrections must be applied for deuterated isotopomers [30]. The r~, -method requires the same input information as the evaluation of the rs-Structure by Kraitchman's equations and is essentially the attempt to implement rovib corrections which were previously computed by the scaling process and do depend, in a restricted sense, on the particular isotopomer without, however, increasing the number of variables:
lgn,g(S) -(2pg
- 1)l~(s)=
l~
2(1 -
pg)l~(s) = l~(s) - Egm,g(S)
(104)
In effect, the rOO m -method introduces rovib contributions which are linear in the inertial moments, eOm,g(S) = 2(1 - 9g)l~ Promising results of the r~m -method have been obtained for several small molecules where the re-Structure was available for comparison. A corrective scaling of all moments could be easily introduced into the r0-procedure as described in the preceding section; it would require a careful analysis of the propagation of the input errors to the values of the p g, g = x,y,z, which are unique for all isotopomers, and from there to the final structural results. The recent paper by LeGuennec et al. [57] mentioned earlier is noteworthy also for the fact that it reports for the small molecule OCSe the structures obtained by all presently known methods and compares them with the known re-Structure.
VI. CONCLUDING REMARKS AND OUTLOOK From what has been shown in the preceding sections (cf. Eqs. 61 and 73, 83), it is possible to present the molecular structure resulting from both the rs-fit method and any of the r0-derived methods in a convenient and easily comparable form, as a structural description in both Cartesian and internal coordinates, and with consistent errors and correlations (for small and larger molecules). A detailed comparison would require a sufficiently large SDS to determine a complete molecular structure, but the requirements are still the least restrictive of all methods presented. The input data must include the covariance matrix of the rotational constants or moments. This matrix may have to be adequately modeled to avoid grossly different weighting of isotopomers which is usually not warranted. The definition of the input data set
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
111
also requires a decision which moments, if any, should be excluded to comply with the rules for planar substitution. Costain's error criterion can be introduced at different levels and must be correctly propagated. Attention must further be paid to the additional errors of the solution caused by the uncertainties of any parameters kept fixed in the fit. When the input data sets are identical in the above sense, the results of the rs-fit method and of the rl~-method (or p-Kr-method) tend to converge within the error limits. Experience with sufficiently comprehensive investigations is limited, and the relevant work has been mostly done on larger molecules where the corresponding equilibrium structures for a critical comparison are not available. The present rs-fit and r0-derived methods for the determination of a molecular structure from MRR ground state spectra, accurate as this structure may then appear from a chemist's viewpoint, cannot fully benefit from the extremely high precision with which ground state moments can now be measured. This is because the input data to either method are still contaminated by at least part of the elusive rovib contribution. Information on its dependence on isotopic substitution is very scarce and has only recently become the subject of ab initio calculations which are still limited to very small molecules. As they progress, useful suggestions could possibly be hoped for on how to also treat the rovib contributions for larger molecules with a little more detail. In the earlier conventional MRR-spectroscopy, the application of the double resonance technique has been absolutely crucial for the successful aggregation of a sufficiently large SDS, because this technique allowed the measurement of the weak spectra of isotopomers in natural abundance despite the presence of strong transitions of the parent species. The modern Fourier-transform MRR~ [69,70] also makes use of double resonance techniques by adequately chosen pulse sequences of pump and signal frequency [71,72]. In the beginning, Fourier-transform MRR-spectroscopy with its greatly enhanced resolution has been used preferably for the previously very difficult investigations where complex multiplets due to interactions between the molecular rotation and various properties of the constituent atoms had to be resolved and analyzed. Recent developments of the instrumentation have simplified the construction and facilitated and speeded up the scanning operation. The admittance of sample molecules into the spectrometer as a molecular beam (supersonic jet) with a very low rotational temperature has increased the sensitivity in a way which lets this technique appear ideally suited for the measurement of ground state spectra, and also, in combination with double resonance operation, for the measurement of spectra of isotopomers in natural abundance. The low temperature favors the rotational spectrum in the vibrational ground state over the rotational spectra in vibrationally excited states---even low-J over high-J ground state transitions--and greatly increases the spectral intensity due to its inverse relation with respect to temperature.
112
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
It is to be hoped that this development will promote the interest to successfully apply these modern and efficient MRR-Fourier-transform techniques to the very fundamental task of determining accurate molecular structures.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author wishes to thank Dr. J. Demaison and Dr. V. Typke for a critical reading of the manuscript and helpful hints. I also gratefully acknowledge the support by the Fonds der Chemischen Industrie.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.
19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25.
Costain, C.C.J. Chem. Phys. 1958, 29, 864. Botschwina, P.; FliJgge, J. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1991, 180, 589. Botschwina, P.; FliJgge, J.; Seeger, S. J. MoL Spectrosc. 1993, 157, 494. Kraitchman, J. Am. J. Phys. 1953, 21, 17. Costain, C.C. Trans. Am. Cryst. Assoc. 1966, 2, 157. Schwendeman, R.H. In Critical Evaluation of Chemical and Physical Structural Information; Lide Jr., D.R.; Paul, M.A., Eds.; National Academy of Sciences: Washington, DC, 1974, p. 94. Typke, V. Mol. Spectrosc. 1978, 69, 173. Gordy, W.; Cook R. L. Microwave Molecular Spectra; Wiley Interscience: New York, 3rd ed., 1984. Modern Aspects of Microwave Spectroscopy; Chantry, G. W., Ed.; Academic Press: London, 1979. Kroto, H. W. Molecular Rotation Spectra; Wiley and Sons: London, 1975. Wollrab, J. E. Rotational Spectra and Molecular Structure; Academic Press: New York, 1967. Lide Jr., D. R. In Molecular Structure and Properties; Buckingham, A. D., Ed.; Butterworths: London, 1975, p. 1. Laurie, V.W. In Critical Evaluation of Chemical and Physical Structural hformation; Lide Jr., D. R.; Paul, M.A., Eds.; National Academy of Sciences: Washington, DC, 1974, p. 67. Nemes, L. In Vibrational Spectra and Structure: A Series of Advances; Durig, J. R., Ed.; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1984, Vol. 13, p. 161. van Eij ck, B.P. In Accurate Molecular Structures, Their Determination and Importance; Domenicano, A.; Hargittai, I., Eds.; Oxford University Press: Oxford, 1992, p. 47. Demaison, J. In Structure and Conformation of Non-Rigid Molecules, Laane J., Ed.; Kluwer Academic: Amsterdam, 1993, p. 239. Demaison, J.; Wlodarczak, G. Struct. Chem. 1993, 4, 391. Landolt-B6rnstein Numerical Data and Functional Relationships in Science and Technology; New Series; Madelung, O., Ed.-in-Chief; Group lh Atomic and Molecular Physics; Vol. 19: Molecular Constants Mostly from Microwave, Molecular Beam, and Sub-Doppler Laser Spectroscopy; Subvol. a, b, and c; HiJttner, W., Ed.; Springer: Berlin, 1992. Harmony, M.D.; Laurie, V.W.; Kuczkowski, R.L.; Schwendeman, R.H.; Ramsey, D. A.; Lovas, E J.; Lafferty, W.J.; Maki, A. G. J. Phys. Chem. Ref Data 1979, 8, 619. Vogt, J. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1992, 155, 413. Oka, T. J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 1960, 15, 2274. Laurie, V.W.; Herschbach, D.R.J. Chem. Pio's. 1962, 37, 1687. Toyama, M.; Oka, T.; Morino. Y. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1964, 13, 193. Watson, J.K.G.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1973, 48, 479. Smith, J.G.; Watson, J.K.G.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1978, 69, 47.
Microwave Rotational Spectroscopy
113
26. Nakata, M.; Sugie, M.; Takeo, H.; Matsumura, C.; Fukuyama, T.; Kutchitsu, K. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1981, 86, 241. 27. Harmony, M.D.; Taylor, W.H.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1986, 118, 163. 28. Harmony, M.D.; Berry, R.J.; Taylor, W.H.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1988, 127, 324. 29. Berry, R.J.; Harmony, M.D.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1988, 128, 176. 30. Berry, R.J.; Harmony, M.D. Struct. Chem. 1989, 1, 49. 31. Harmony, M.D. Acc. Chem. Res. 1992, 25, 321. 32. Goldstein, H. Classical Mechanics; Addison-Wesley: Reading, Mass., 1980. 33. Watson, J.K.G.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1972, 41, 229. 34. Albritton, D.L.; Schmeltekopf, A.L.; Zare, R.N. In Molecular Spectroscopy: Modern Research; Rao, K.N., Ed.; Academic Press: New York, 1976, Vol. II, p.1. 35. Wilkinson, J.H. In Linear Algebra; Wilkinson, J.H.; Reinsch, C., Eds.; Springer: Berlin, 1971, p. 1. 36. Businger, P.; Golub, G.H. In Linear Algebra; Wilkinson, J.H.; Reinsch, C., Eds.; Springer: Berlin, 1971, p. 111. 37. Bauer, EL. In Linear Algebra; Wilkinson, J.H.; Reinsch, C., Eds.; Springer: Berlin, 1971, p. 119. 38. Golub, G. H.; Reinsch, C. In Linear Algebra; Wilkinson, J. H.; Reinsch, C., Eds.; Springer: Berlin, 1971, p. 134. 39. N6sberger, P.; Bauder, A.; Gtinthard, Hs. H. Chem. Phys. 1973, 1, 418. 40. Brodersen, S. J. MoL Spectrosc. 1990, 142, 122. 41. van Eijck, B. P. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1982, 91,348. 42. Chutjian, A. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1964, 14, 361. 43. Nygaard, L. J. MoL Spectrosc. 1976, 62, 292. 44. Rudolph, H. D. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1981, 89, 460. 45. Rudolph, H. D. J. MoL Spectrosc. 1981, 89, 430. 46. Landau, L. D.; Lifshitz, E. M. Quantum Mechanics; Pergamon: London, 1959; eq. (72.2). 47. Hirose, C. BulL Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1974, 47, 976. 48. Eliashevich, M. Compt. Rend. Acad. Sci. U.R.S.S. 1940, 28, 604. 49. Wilson Jr., E.B.J. Chem. Phys. 1941, 9, 76. 50. Wilson Jr., E.B.; Decius, J.C.; Cross, P.C. Molecular Vibrations; McGraw-Hill: New York, 1955, Chapter 4. 51. Typke, V. J. MoL Spectrosc. 1978, 72, 293. 52. Meyer, M.; Grabow, J.U.; Dreizler, H.; Rudolph, H.D.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1992, 151,217. 53. Epple, K.J.; Rudolph, H.D.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1992, 152, 355. 54. Hamilton, W.C. Statistics hi Physical Science; The Ronald Press: New York, 1964, Chapter 4. 55. Rudolph, H.D. Struct. Chem. 1991, 2, 581. 56. Demaison, J.; Nemes, L. J. Moi. Struct. 1979, 55, 295. 57. LeGuennec, M.; Wlodarczak, G.; Demaison, J.; BUrger, H.; Litz, M.; Willner, H. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1993, 157, 419. 58. Thompson, H.B.J. Chem. Phys. 1967, 47, 3407. 59. Woodward, L.A. hltroduction to the Theory of Molecular Vibrations and Vibrational Spectroscopy; Clarendon: Oxford, 1972. 60. Jacob, E.J.; Thompson, H.B.J. MoL Struct. 1972, 12, 298. 61. Thompson, H.B.J. Chem. Phys. 1970, 53, 3034. 62. Reichman, S.; Ginn, S.G.W.J. MoL Struct. 1969, 3, 418. 63. Pulay, P.; Sawodny, W. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1968, 26, 150. 64. Polo, S. R. J. Chem. Phys. 1956, 24, 1133. 65. Nakata, M.; Kutchitsu, K.; Mills, I. M. J. Chem. Phys. 1984, 88, 344. 66. Nakata, M.; Kutchitsu, K. J. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1986, 1446. 67. Kutchitsu, K.; Oyanagi, K. Faraday Discuss. Chem. Soc. 1977, 62, 20. 68. Nakata, M.; Kutchitsu, K. Bull Fac. Gen. Ed. Univ. Tokyo A&T 1990, 27, 153.
114
HEINZ DIETER RUDOLPH
69. Dreizler, H. Mol. Phys. 1986, 59, 1. 70. Bauder, A. In Vibrational Spectra and Structure: A Series of Advances; Durig, J. R., Ed.; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1993, Vol. 20, p. 158. 71. Stahl, W.; Fliege, E.; Dreizler, H. Z. Nat,rforsch. A. 1984, 39, 858. 72. Vogelsanger, B.; Bauder, A. J. Chem. Phys. 1990, 92, 4101.
GAS-PHASE NMR STU DIES OF CONFORMATIONAL PROCESSES
Nancy S. True and Cristina Suarez
I. II.
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Gas-Phase N M R Studies of Conformational,
116 116
Tautomeric, and General Isomer Equilibria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Conformer Equilibria and Thermodynamic Barriers Using Direct Measurements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
117
III.
IV.
Conformer Equilibria and Activation Barriers via Analysis of Long-Range Coupling Constants ..................... Gas-Phase N M R Studies of Conformational Kinetics . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Temperature-Dependent Gas-Phase N M R . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Pressure-Dependent Gas-Phase D N M R . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Bimolecular Rate Constants and Collision Efficiencies . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References and Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
118
B.
Advances in Molecular Structure Research Volume 1, pages 115-155. Copyright 9 1995 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 1-55938-799-8
115
122 124
126 135 145 151 152
116
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
ABSTRACT Gas-phase NMR spectroscopy can, in many cases, provide thermodynamic and kinetic data for chemical exchange processes which are comparable to those obtained in liquid-phase studies. Gas-phase studies of chemical exchange processes including internal rotation about partial double bonds, keto-enol tautomerism, ring inversion in six-membered rings, Berry pseudorotation in SF4, and the degenerate Cope rearrangement are reviewed. Part II of this review describes gas-phase conformer and tautomer equilibrium studies. Part III describes gas-phase kinetic studies of chemical exchange processes at high pressures (unimolecular limit), in the falloff region, and at low pressures (bimolecular limit).
I. I N T R O D U C T I O N Much of our present understanding of conformational equilibria and conformational interconversion processes in liquids and solids is the result of NMR studies. [1] NMR spectroscopy has several advantages in conformational studies. In many cases, spectral assignments can be made unambiguously. Multinuclear studies, selective decoupling, relaxation measurements, coherence transfer studies, and measurement of long-range coupling constants can aid in making spectral assignments. [2] NMR spectral intensities are directly related to the relative populations of the absorbing species. Magnetic dipole transition moment matrix elements depend on the identity of the nucleus which is being studied and are not significantly affected by its local environment. Also, for many molecular processes with activation energies in the 20-85 kJ mo1-1 range, rate constants can be obtained under equilibrium conditions. Most NMR studies of condensed phases have been performed at ambient pressure and have reported isobaric activation parameters. Recent studies by Jonas et al. [3] have employed pressure as an experimental variable and have reported isobaric as well as isoviscosity activation parameters which provide information about dynamic solvent effects. Recent work has shown that extension of NMR spectroscopy to studies of gas-phase systems can result in a better understanding of the intramolecular dynamics of many conformational exchange processes as well as the direction and magnitude of environmental perturbations. NMR spectra of dilute gases can be obtained with signal to noise ratios and resolution which are comparable to those obtained in the best liquid-phase studies. In general, 1H and ~3C spectral of most molecules can be obtained with line widths of 1 Hz or less in the gas phase. Spectra can be obtained for 1H, and enriched 13C present at 0.25 torr or more partial pressure in the presence of a few torr of a bath gas. It is difficult to obtain spectra of samples where the total pressure is below 1 or 2 torr, since the transverse relaxation time, t 2, is generally very short at these pressures and results in significant line broadening. 13C spectral acquisition is actually facilitated in the gas phase since the longitudinal relaxation time, t l, for this nucleus is much shorter in the gas phase
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
117
than in condensed phases. For example, at 500 torr, the 13C t 1 of benzene is 0.07 s, compared to ca. 30 s in the pure liquid [4]. These short tlS make it possible to collect transients 100 to 1000 times faster than is possible in condensed phases. Proton tlS are somewhat shorter in the gas phase than in liquid solutions and exhibit a characteristic nonlinear pressure-dependence. [4-7] Gas phase NMR studies have provided thermodynamic and kinetic parameters for many low-energy molecular processes. In addition, several gas-phase NMR studies have reported measurement of rate constants as a function of pressure. Pressure-dependent rate constants provide information about the extent and rate of intramolecular vibrational redistribution in the reacting molecules. Also rate constants in the low pressure bimolecular region can be used to determine collisional efficiencies for the chemical exchange process. To date, more than 50 studies in this area have been reported addressing topics including internal rotation in alkyl nitrites, amides, and nitrosamines; keto-enol equilibria; ring inversion in several six-membered rings, and Berry pseudorotation in inorganic and organic molecules. The following review discusses these studies. This review is divided into two major parts. The first part describes gas-phase NMR studies of conformational equilibria by direct and indirect methods. The second part describes studies of gas-phase kinetics of chemical exchange processes including studies at the high pressure limit, pressure-dependent studies, and studies in the bimolecular region. Other reviews focusing on gas-phase NMR spectroscopy include: Jameson's review on gas phase NMR studies of relaxation, and chemical shifts, as well as gas-phase conformational studies [6]; Armstrong's review of gas-phase NMR relaxation studies [7]; and other general gas-phase NMR spectroscopy reviews by Harris and Rao, [8] and Govil [9].
II. GAS-PHASE NMR STUDIES OF CONFORMATIONAL, TAUTOMERIC, AND GENERAL ISOMER EQUILIBRIA The development of NMR methods for the study and analysis of gas-phase systems has taken two main approaches. In one, the experimental applications have been concerned mostly with measurement of gas-phase chemical shifts, coupling constants, and relaxation times of small molecules with high vapor pressures, and with theoretical studies of pressure and/or temperature dependence of relaxation and nuclear shielding. C. J. and A. K. Jameson have contributed extensively to this area with comprehensive investigations of absolute shielding values for diverse small molecules containing different magnetically active nuclei [10,11]. The essential isolation of small molecules in the gas phase provides an excellent experimental counterpart to theoretical models used in the development of shielding and relaxation theories. Important work in this field includes" Govil's calculation of vicinal coupling constants for ethane, methylamine, and methanol using extended HUckel theory [12]; Schindler's ab initio calculations of chemical shifts in small gaseous molecules [13,14]; theoretical studies of relaxation and line-shapes at low pressures
11 8
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
by Sanctuary [15]; D. Kouri's study of relaxation in He and o-H 2 [16]; as well as Armstrong and McCourt's work on the pressure dependence of the line shape H 2 and its isotopes [17]. Comprehensive reviews of the field by C. J. Jameson contain many other examples [6,18].
A. Conformer Equilibria and Thermodynamic Barriers Using Direct Measurements A second approach has also developed in the last decade in which gas-phase NMR is applied not only to the study of individual nuclear magnetic properties, but also to the analysis of the dynamic processes that some of these molecules undergo. In the absence of solvent-solute interactions, gas-phase NMR is the method of choice in investigations studying conformational, tautomeric, and general isomeric equilibria because the isomer populations can be identified and measured correctly without perturbing the isomeric equilibrium. The NMR advantages of unambiguous spectral assignment, and spectral intensities being directly related to the relative populations of the absorbing species, make the study of many isomeric processes with moderate activation energies in the range of 20 to 85 kJ mo1-1 routinely accessible. Furthermore, variable temperature gas-phase NMR experiments have allowed the complete thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of such equilibria. Early examples of the NMR determination of gas-phase equilibrium constants are given by Harris for the Z-E isomerization in acetaldoxime and keto-enol tautomerism of acetylacetone [19] where signals for each independent isomer and tautomer respectively yielded information on their population ratios. More recently, Folkendt and co-workers have done extensive work on the keto-enol isomerization of a series of [~-diketones including acetylacetone (R 1 = R 2 = CH3), methyl acetoacetate (R 1 = CH 3, R 2 = OCH3), and ethyl acetoacetate (R 1 = CH2CH 3, R 2 = OCH3). [20] The general structure of the keto and enol tautomers being:
o
o
II
II
RI/C.cH2....I C. R2 -"
O''"H~o _
II
II
RfC.cH2...~C. R2
The high energy barrier to tautomer interconversion permits observation of distinct gas-phase NMR spectra of both forms at temperatures well above ambient thus allowing the quantitative gas-phase thermodynamic data to be obtained for the first time for these relatively nonlabile molecules. For each molecule, the vinyl resonance was integrated to determine the population of the enol form, and the methylene resonance was integrated to determine the keto form. The enol tautomer showed more stability for all three 13-diketones. A mean value for the equilibrium constant, Keq= enol/keto, was obtained at 19 different temperatures (372.8 K-444.9 K). The resulting temperature dependence of Keq was subsequently analyzed via a linear regression fit to the van't Hoff equation to obtain the thermodynamic parameters:
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
119
ln(Keq)=_[---~-III]+[A~R]andAGO=AHO_TASO
(1)
Table 1 summarizes these parameters characterizing the keto-enol equilibria, where A refers to the difference between the enol and keto forms. The enol forms are significantly more stable, consistent with the inclusion of an intramolecular hydrogen bond in the structures and concurrent resonance stabilization. The low frequency torsional vibration of the keto forms can account for their significantly greater relative entropy. In solutions the keto-enol energy difference is much smaller than that observed in the gas phase and the observed phase dependence can be accounted for by electrostatic factors. Another example of the application of gas-phase NMR techniques to conformational equilibria is the investigation of conformational effects on the relative maxima in the N-O bond internal rotation potential function in primary nitrites of one to five carbon atoms Alkyl nitrites (ONOR) exist as mixtures of and conformers which differ in the orientation of the alkyl group with respect to the nitrosyl group.
[21,22].
anti
N
syn
.......
0
/
N
o//
syn
R
O anti
The magnitude of the N--O internal rotation barrier (ca. 40-48 kJ/mol) and the magnetic inequivalence of the t~-lH's and t~-13C's caused by anisotropy of the shielding tensor of the nitrosyl group make these systems especially amenable to NMR investigation. However, determination of equilibrium constants via integration of slow exchange 1H NMR resonances, as done for the keto-enol analysis, is complicated by the slightly lower barriers to intemal rotation of the larger alkyl nitrites, which necessitate low temperatures (below ca. 200 K) to obtain slow exchange spectra. Moreover, gas-phase slow exchange population measurements of alkyl nitrites are even more difficult to obtain due to the limitations of sample volatility. An indirect method, based on the temperature dependence of chemical
Table1. Gas-PhaseThermodynamic Parameters(EnoI-Keto)from Integrated 1H NMR Spectra
Compound
Acetylacetone Ethylacetoacetate Methylacetoacetate
AG~
mo1-1
-9.20 -0.33 -0.33
zS]I~
mol -I
-19.50 - 13.26 -12.72
z~k~~ m o l "-1 g -1
-34.56 --43.43 -41.55
120
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
shifts is used to obtain the equilibrium constants. The temperature dependencies of 1H chemical shifts in the gas phase, which are due to changes in collision frequencies and changes in vibrational partition functions [23,24], are linear and small (< 1 • 10-4 ppm/K upfield relative to gaseous tetramethylsilane) in comparison with effects due to changing equilibrium constants. This is not the case in nitrite solutions due to the strong temperature dependence of the slow exchange chemical shifts which is similar in magnitude to the temperature-dependent changes in equilibrium constants. Consequently, the determination of gas-phase equilibrium constants is done from rigorously first-order, fast-exchange NMR spectra assuming that the observed methylene proton shifts in the alkyl nitrite spectra at fast exchange are weighted averages of the slow exchange syn and anti chemical shifts, Vobsd =
(2)
PsynVsyn + PantiVanti
where: Psyn + Panti = 1
(3)
geq = anti / syn = (Vobsd- Vsyn) / (Vanti - Vobsd)
(4)
The result is:
The gas-phase thermodynamic (van't Hoff) parameters M/~ AS~ and AG~ for the syn-anti conformer interconversion of these gaseous alkyl nitrites are presented in Table 2. For MeONO this data compared well with those obtained by direct integration of slow exchange spectra. [21,22] The agreement of these gas-phase NMR thermodynamic parameters with microwave and theoretical data reinforce the validity of this technique applied to the syn-anti equilibria. Comparison of these gas-phase data with solution values yields information on the effects solvents have on the conformer equilibria, which in the particular case of these alkyl nitrites reflect a balance of steric and dielectric effects.
Table 2. Gas-PhaseThermodynamic Parameters (syn-antl) from Fast-Exchange cz Proton Chemical Shifts
Compound
AG~
tool-s
Methyl nitrite Ethyl nitrite n-Propyl nitrite Isopropyl nitrite n-Butyl nitrite lsobutyl nitrite Neopentyl nitrite
1.49 (0.10) -1.29 (0.10) -1.64 (0.10) -2.99 (0.21) -1.51 (0.21) -2.26 (0.21) -2.80 (0.21)
AH~
mo1-1
3.48 (0.08) 0.72 (0.08) 0.46 (0.08) -4.60 (0.08) 0.86 (0.17) -0.24 (0.17) -1.33 (0.17)
zk~~ mo1-1 K-1
6.69 (0.42) 6.74 (0.63) 7.03 (0.63) -5.40 (0.63) 7.03 (1.67) 6.78 (1.67) 4.85 (1.67)
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
121
One final example of conformer equilibria studied in the gas-phase by NMR techniques is the ever popular internal rotation about the C-N partial double bond in substituted asymmetric amides. Isbrandt and co-workers as early as 1973 were able to measure the barriers to internal rotation in solution in a series of asymmetrically N,N-disubstituted amides. [25] Presently, our group has undertaken the first attempt to characterize in the gas-phase this rotational equilibria in a pair of asymmetrically N,N-disubstituted amides (XCONCH3(CH2CH3); X = CF 3 and H). Analysis of the conformer population has been the focus of much theoretical work aimed at elucidating the role of the higher energy cis peptide bond in stable protein conformations [26,27]. Values of Pcis and Ptrans in N,N-ethylmethyl trifluoroacetamide (EMTFA) and formamide (EMF) (where cis and trans assignments were made in the formamide for the preferred isomer to have the bulkier substituent trans to the carbonyl oxygen, while in the other amides, the bulkier group is cis to the carbonyl) are obtained directly from signal integrations at each temperature. Preliminary results show that these values show no consistent variation (5% or less) throughout the temperature ranges analyzed. Gas-phase signalto-noise ratios and the large errors associated with integration techniques preclude an in-depth analysis of the enthalpy and entropy energies associated with the conformational process; therefore, listed in Table 3 are only the average values of Keq = Pcis/Ptrans and AG~ = - RTlnKeq for the equilibrium. Substituents should decrease AG~ in the same order that they lead to decreases in the rotational barrier. We observed such a trend in our liquid data. On the other hand, our gas-phase AG~ s show an opposing trend. This might be due to the absence of solute-solvent and solute-solute interactions. There is an extensive amount of work in the literature, both theoretical and experimental, dealing with the structure of amide solutions and their influence on barrier heights [28-30]; however, no such experimental work has been available for gaseous amides because of low vapor pressure conditions (N,N-ethylmethylacetamide has less than 0.4 torr at room temperature) and, in some cases, the absence of conformer separation. An increase in AG~ (619 J mo1-1) going from gas to liquid in EMF shows how important hydrogen-bonding perturbations are on the internal rotation potential function. Clearly, a systematic analysis of these perturbations and other solvent interactions would require further gas-phase conformational studies which at the moment are restricted to these few values.
Table 3. Gas- and Liquid-Phase Free Energies at 300 K for Internal Rotation in EMTFA and EMF
AG~300 J mo1-1(gas) AG~300 J mol-l (1% DMSO)
EMF
EMTFA
326 (6) 946 (19)
833 (16) 427 (8)
122
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
B. Conformer Equilibria and Activation Barriers via Analysis of Long-Range Coupling Constants As described previously, dynamic NMR analysis (DNMR) has become the method of choice in the evaluation of conformational, tautomeric and isomer equilibria in systems with potential energy barriers ranging from 20 to 85 kJ mol -l. In the specific case of rotational isomerism, DNMR analysis provides direct information on the relative energy of rotamers, the potential barrier to internal rotation and information on chemical shifts (8) and coupling constants (J). Systems such as the amides and nitrites previously described have potential barriers large enough to yield NMR spectra representative of different stable rotamers, displaying various degrees of exchange. On the other hand, systems such as substituted ethanes and other substituted alkanes, have barriers to rotation sufficiently low (12-41 kJ mol -l) to allow rapid hindered internal rotation in the NMR scale; consequently, the observed spectra are weighed averages over the various rotamers involved. [31] Determination of physical parameters related to internal rotation about the C-C bond, such as relative energies of the rotational isomers and the potential barrier to internal rotation, from these rotationally averaged spectra is difficult [32]. The most important indirect method to obtain these parameters is based on the analysis of the temperature dependence of long-range coupling constants ("J" method) [33]. Other examples of indirect approaches used are the previously described temperature dependence of chemical shifts in the fast-exchange region used in the calculation of anti-syn equilibrium constants in nitrites and the pressure dependence of chemical shifts used to determine association constants for dimerization of acetic and trifluoracetic acid [34], and hydrogen bonding in methanol [35]. The J method has been extensively applied to the measurement of conformer equilibria and barrier heights in solutions. Gas-phase high resolution NMR spectroscopy can also yield well-resolved spectra suitable for complex spin system analysis. In the gas phase, spin-lattice relaxation occurs primarily through spin-rotation interactions. For large molecules at moderate pressures, tls are long and contribute negligibly to the observed line widths. Under these conditions, coupling constants can be measured in the gas phase with the same accuracy as in solutions. Inomata and Abe [36] have just recently obtained gas-phase values of 3JHH for 1,2-dimethoxyethane at different temperatures ranging from 5.80 to 5.85 Hz with a probable error of less than 0.05 Hz. Even though the temperature dependence of coupling constants in these compounds is small (<1 Hz per 100 range), a standard deviation in their temperature analysis of no greater than 0.05 Hz can also be achieved without difficulty. Furthermore, the innate absence of solvent effects in the gas phase provides the base reference to model completely the solvent dependency of such energies and barriers. The theory underlying the dependence of vicinal coupling parameters on internal rotation has been widely studied. Most approaches have followed the best fit method pioneered by Gutowsky et al. [37,38] which assumes a rotational isomeric
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
123
state (RIS) model relating the experimentally determined coupling constants, <J>, to the relative populations, fi, and the corresponding parameters of the individual rotamers by <J> = Zf.Jj where Zf/= 1. This approach assumes that the temperature dependence of <J> results only from changes in the equilibrium proportions of the rotamers and searches for a set of parameters characteristic of each stable conformer to find the best fit to the experimental data. The conformational energy difference for the conformers i and j, AEi_j, can be related to the conformers' population fractions by assuming simple Boltzmann factors in the corresponding energies as f / / f j - exp (-AEi_j/RT). Classical examples of this type of analysis in the gas phase are provided by Hirano and Miyajima in the study on 1,2-difluoroethane and 1,2-disubstituted propanes [39-42]. More recently, Inomata and Abe have published a rigorous study of the conformation of 1,2-dimethoxyethane in relation to the gauche oxygen effect [36] associated with the internal rotation around the OC-CO bond. [43] The observed gas-phase IH-IH and 13C-lH NMR vicinal coupling constants were compared with those previously determined in nonpolar solvents. From these reported values and the conformational energies determined using the RIS, they reached the conclusion that the gauche oxygen effect is not caused by surrounding solvent molecules. The authors note that the value of the conformational energy E~ for the constituent bond OC-CO estimated to be-1.7 kJ mo1-1 is lower than results of recent MO calculations [44] by 4.2 kJ mo1-1. They also indicate that there is only a qualitative agreement between the fraction of the conformers estimated in their work and electron diffraction measurements. It is important to note that other authors have found discrepancies within results yielded by this "static" method. For instance, Govil and Berstein, [45] Heatley and Allen [46], and more recently Pachler and Wessels [47] have mentioned that this method yields inconsistent results and can only give accurate results with considerably difficulty. Another major approach developed by Lin [48] expresses the observed vicinal coupling constants as weighed averages over a cycle of rotation (i.e., ~ = 0 to = 27t). The potential energy as a function of the internal rotational coordinate ~, V(~), is taken as the weighting function. The observed vicinal coupling constant, <J>, is then given by, [49], J J(~))exp (-V(~) / R T ) d , <J>=
o
(5)
2x ; exp (-V(~)/RT)d 0
where J(~) is a modified Karplus equation. This rotational averaging approach has the advantage of sampling the entire population distribution as opposed to the RIS model which assumes that only stable
124
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
conformers are important. Lin's theory has been successfully applied in liquidphase studies to substituted ethanes of the type CHzX-CH2Y [50] and CH2XCHXY [51]. In the gas phase, Pachler and Wessel's study of the rotational isomerism of 1-bromo-2-chloroethane [47] further reaffirms these discrepancies of the "static" versus the "dynamic" approach. Analysis of the average vicinal coupling constants, measured in different solvents, assuming a "dynamic" model yielded values for the vicinal coupling constants of the individual rotamers in excellent agreement with those obtained from their gas-phase data. These values are at 305 K: trans rotamer Jr= 13.6 Hz; J'r= 4.9 Hz; and gauche rotamer 1/2 (Jcl + Jc2) = 0.9 Hz, 1/2 (J'cl + J'c2) = 7.8 Hz. Js are temperature dependent with Jr changing about four times as much as the other coupling constants. In this context, Pachler and Wessels explore the dependency of these vicinal coupling constants with temperature and solvent dielectric constant (e). This is based on a proposed modified Karplus equation, J(~) = a + B cos ~ + C cos ,2~ + D sin~ + E sin 2~
(6)
where the constants A...E are, to a first approximation, linearly related to the electronegativities of the substituents. The foundation for this work, and the latest developments of this approach are due to the extensive work done by Abraham and co-workers [52,53]. In their latest work [54], proton coupling constants are reported for 1,1,2-trichloroethane in 32 protic and aprotic solvents, as well as in the gas phase. The conformational equilibrium is thus analyzed in terms of long-range coupling constants using multiple regression analysis through the AbrahamKamlet-Taft equation, J / H z = c + d~5+ s ~ + a(z I + b[31 + h(~i~)1
(7)
where ~i (polarizability correction term), ~ (solvent dipolarity); c~l (solvent hydrogen-bond acidity); ~l (solvent hydrogen-bond basicity) and 82//(Hildebrand cohesive energy density). In this case, gas-phase data provides a decisive data point in the analysis of the variables, because of the absence of solvent effects and constrictions in the system. As more gas-phase systems are studied, more work will be expected to appear on the application of this J method to the temperature and solvent dependence of internal rotation barrier parameters and their parametrization, allowing for the extrapolation of theoretically calculated values. I!1.
GAS-PHASE NMR STUDIES OF CONFORMATIONAL KINETICS
Since its early beginnings, probably the best known application of DNMR spectroscopy has been to the evaluation ofkinetic barrier heights. The methods by which rate constants for the conformational processes have been obtained from NMR spectra have changed over time. In the vast majority of DNMR studies, the desired
125
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
385.9 K .
~__~ .
.
.
.
.
.
338.1
329.1 K
320.1 K
i
5.41
,,
i
5.21
i
5.01
i
4.81
i
4.61
ppm Figure 1. Temperature dependence of gas-phase 500 MHz 1H NMR spectra of
N, N-ethyl methyl trifluoroacetamide. Top and bottom traces representcalculated and experimental spectra at the indicated temperature.
kinetic information has been obtained by analysis of exchange-broadened spectra. The NMR spectral lineshape is determined by a set of five parameters: (1) conformer chemical shifts in the absence of exchange, 6i; (2) spin-spin coupling constants, Ju; (3) relative populations of each conformer, Pi; (4) transverse relaxation times in the absence of exchange, t2i; and (5) the exchange rate constant, k. An iterative nonlinear least-squares regression analysis is performed using a computer program (we use DNMR5 [55]) to obtain the best fit of a calculated spectrum to the experimental spectrum, the so-called bandshape analysis technique. An excellent description of this and other methods can be found in the work of SandstrOm [56]. Figure 1 illustrates an example of the DNMR5-calculated (top) and experimental (bottom) traces for exchange-broadened spectra of N,N-ethylmethyl trifluoroacetamide gas at different temperatures.
1 26
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
A. Temperature-Dependent Gas-Phase NMR The evaluation of kinetic barrier heights (21-105 kJ mo1-1) from the temperature dependence of rates has been one of the most important contributions of DNMR to conformational processes. However, only a handful of these studies have addressed gas-phase processes, mainly due to the need for instrumentation improvements just recently achieved as described above. It has become customary to discuss exchange processes in terms of the Arrhenius equation and transition state theory (TST) of reaction rates [57] which is summarized by the Eyring equation. The Arrhenius equation in the following form is used to obtain the activation energy (Eact) and frequency factor (A) from the slope and intercept, In k -
~'
+ In A
(8)
where k is the rate constant, R is the gas constant, and T is the absolute temperature. This equation is valid at all pressures [57]. The kinetic activation parameters are determined from the Eyring equation in a similar fashion, In k -
-
+ In --h-- + --R--
w h e r e ~cis the transmission coefficient, kb is the Boltzmann constant, h is Planck's constant, and z~* and AS* are the enthalpy and entropy of activation respectively. Since this derivation involves transition state theory, it is valid only at the high pressure limit. If the precision of some experimental measurements is poor, only a AG~* determined from Eq. 10 at the coalescence temperature is generally reported: kbT AG* = - RTIn ~ hk
(1 O)
Comparison of the barrier heights in the gas phase with those found in the liquid phase can elucidate the role of solvent internal pressure on conformational interconversion when dielectrical interactions are minimal. The magnitude of these interactions can be estimated by considering an activation volume, AV*, for the process, defined as,
L
l
where 8 P i is the difference in internal pressures between the solution and gas phases (Pi for gases = 0). As mentioned above, only a handful of these studies have addressed gas-phase processes. Presently, the majority of the published work in the area investigates such conformational processes as internal rotation in several substituted N,N-dial-
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
127
kylamides, alkyl nitrites, and N,N-dimethylnitrosamine, ring inversion in six-membered tings, pseudorotation in SF4, and the Cope rearrangement in bullvalene. At the high-pressure limit, all of these conformational processes exhibit first-order kinetics and the temperature dependence of the rate constants yields information, as previously described, about the kinetic parameters characterizing the process" AG*, AH*, and AS*.
Gas-Phase NMR Studies of Amides Variable-temperature NMR spectroscopy is a well-established technique in the study of conformational exchange kinetics in liquid amides. [1,58] Using DNMR spectroscopy, it is possible to measure the temperature dependence of interconversion rates in order to yield a complete set of kinetic parameters characterizing the internal rotation about the carbon-nitrogen bond. In the last several years, the development of gas-phase NMR methods has provided a valuable tool for the elucidation of the magnitude of intrinsic and environmental contributions associated with this conformational exchange. In order to characterize these contributions, a series of molecules with systematic variations in substituent size and polarity must be analyzed both in the liquid and gas phase. The determination of gas-phase amide rotational barriers encounters several difficulties. In addition to low vapor pressure at exchange temperatures (usually below 1 torr at 298 K), gas-phase limiting chemical shift differences between conformers (Act) are usually smaller than in the liquid because solvents and other intermolecular effects, not present in the gas phase, contribute to increased anisotropy of the proton environments. One dramatic case is N, N-dimethylformamide, which has an 83 Hz proton-limiting chemical shift separation in CC14 (10 vol. %) at 500 MHz, but shows magnetic equivalence of its proton dimethylamino resonances in the gas phase [59]. Also, smaller limiting shift differences result in lower slow-exchange and coalescence temperatures. This, combined with low vapor pressures, can make gas-phase 1H NMR study unattainable. Furthermore, the gas-phase rotational barriers of all the amides studied so far are lower than in the liquid. This increases the rate constant at a specific temperature, further lowering the temperature range which must be studied. Work on amides has included Feigel's barriers to hindered internal rotation in a series of N,N-dialkylamides (R'CONR 2 : R = CH 3, R' = F, C1, CH 3, CF3; R = i-Pr, R' = CH3; R = C2H 5, R' = H) and in N,N-dimethylthioacetamide (CH3CSN(CH3)2) [60]. A line shape analysis of their gas-phase 1H NMR spectra yielded AG*s which are at least 4-9.6 kJ mol -~ smaller than the values reported in solution; the differences could not be correlated with the structure and the barrier heights of the amides. Ross also studied the gas-phase NMR temperature dependence of a series of monoalkyltrifluoroacetamides in search of line-broadening effects indicative of chemical exchange [61]. LeMaster et al. [59,62] also reports that the barrier to rotation in N, N-diisopropylacetamide is lower in the gas phase than in solution, and furthermore in formamides it decreases with increasing size of the alkyl
128
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
substituents on the amide nitrogen. Gas-phase 13C NMR spectra of dimethylformamide have also been obtained and studied [63]. In our last work [64], a series of N-substituted trifluoroacetamides was chosen to study the effect of N-substituent size on the amide rotational barrier. Substituents ranged from methyl to relatively large isobutyl groups. Also, we are working on the analysis of asymmetrically substituted amides which is of special interest because they can display conformer population differences as discussed in a previous section. They have been the focus of much theoretical work aimed at elucidating the role of the higher energy cis-peptide bond in stable protein conformations [65,26,27]. Medium effects on conformer relative Gibbs energies reflect the stabilizing or destabilizing role of solvent interactions upon the minima in the peptide bond torsional potential function [66,67]. For nonpolar molecules and polar molecules in nonpolar environments, steric effects due to liquid packing forces can be quite large, approaching those of electrostatic interactions, and contribute considerably to the phase dependence of the conformational Gibbs energy. Amide-amide self-association, solvent interaction, solvent polarity, and internal pressure have proven to affect the rotation rate and may mask the intrinsic influence of substituents. Gas-phase values are very useful particularly as test cases and parametrization data in the development of molecular mechanics and semiempirical theoretical calculations designed to model
Table 4. Summary of Gas- and Liquid-Phase Free Activation Energies (298 K) for
Several Substituted Amides (R1CONR2R3)
Rl
R2
CF3 CF3 CF3 CF3 CF3 H H H H CH3 CH3 CH3 N3 F Cl Br CH2F CHF2
methyl ethyl ethyl i-propyl /-butyl methyl ethyl ethyl i-propyl methyl ethyl i-propyl CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3
R3
methyl ethyl methyl i-propyl /-butyl methyl methyl ethyl i-propyl methyl ethyl i-propyl CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3
AG ~ gas (kJ mo1-1) 69.0 (0.4) 67.4 (0.4) 68.6 (0.4) 66.1 (0.4) 68.6 (0.4) 81.2 (0.4) 82.8 (0.4) 80.3 (0.4) 79.5 (0.4) 65.7 (0.4) -59.8 (0.4) 69.0 (0.4) 71.5 (0.8) 64.4 (0.8) 59.0 (0.8) 63.6 (0.4) 72.8 (0.4)
AG ~ liq (kJ mo1-1) 75.7 74.5 (0.1) 75.1 (0.2) 68.2 (0.1) 72.4 (0.1) 86.6 85.3 (0.3) 85.3 86.6 76.1 74.0 65.3 74.1 75.7 (2.5) 69.0 (2.1) 65.7 (1.7) 71.1 78.7
Solvent
Ref
CC14 CCl4 CCi4 CCl4 CCI4 C2C14 DMSO Neat o-DCB Neat o-DCB o-DCB CCI4 CCl4 CC14 Neat ClPh CIPh
68 64 69 64 64 63 69 61 61 70 62 71 71 71 7l 71 71
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
129
0.5 0.0 V
-0.5
V
-1.0
T
[]
V
-1.5 E~
-2.0
o
,,.4
O
V
o
vn
[] []
V
-2.5
o
D Y
[] 9
v
o
V
un
O
V
o []
9
-3.0
ff
[]
v
O O
-3.5
9
[]
-4.0 -4.5
.......
2.8
2.9
l
t
3.0
3.1
.....
l
3.2
'"I ..........
3.3
~
3.4
looo/T
figure 2. Eyring plot of gas- and liquid-phase exchange rate constants for disubstituted trifluoroacetamides (TFAA). o-N,N-diethyl TFAA gas; T-N,N-diisopropyi TFAA gas; m-N,N-diisobutyl TFAA gas; o-N,N-diethyl TFAA liquid; ~z-N,N-diisopropyl TFAA liquid; []-N,N-diisobutyl TFAA liquid.
this C-N torsional potential function. Table 4 summarizes the AG*s obtained for all the amides described in this section, and Figure 2 illustrates the difference between liquid and gas Eyring plots for three of the trifluoroacetamides (diethyl, diisopropyl, and diisobutyl).
Gas-Phase NMR Studies of Aikyl Nitrites Table 5 contains the gas-phase activation parameters for syne-~anti conformational exchange available for six primary alkyl nitrites. Two trends are apparent in the gas-phase activation parameters listed in this table. First, the barrier to syne--~anti
1 30
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
Table5.
Activation Parameters for syn(-~anti Conformational Exchange in Primary Alkyl Nitrites AG~298
AH ~t
AS~t
Compound
kJ mol -l
kJ tool -1
J g -1 mol --1
Ref
Methyl nitrite Ethyl nitrite n-Propyl nitrite n-Butyl nitrite Isobutyl nitrite Neopentyl nitrite
50.6 46.0 47.3 47.7 47.3 46.9
48.9 (1.7) 45.6 (1.2) 45.2 (1.7) 44.8 (1.2) 44.8 (1.7) m
-3.8 (1.7) -2.5 (5.8) -7.9 (7.9) -8.8 (5.0) -7.5 (6.3) m
72,73 74 74 75 75 74
(0.4) (0.4) (0.8) (0.8) (0.8) (0.4)
conformer inversion in methyl nitrite is higher by 2.9 to 4.6 kJ mo1-1 than that in the other primary alkyl nitrites studied. Second, gas-phase activation Gibbs energies, enthalpies, and entropies in the other five nitrites are remarkably similar within their relative errors. The Gibbs activation energies for the conformer inversion seem to parallel the relative stabilities of the syn conformer. Destabilization of the syn conformer would be expected to result from steric effects on the ground state. Substitution of the methyl substituent on the nitrosyl oxygen by larger alkyl groups would tend to bend the nitrosyl N-O bond out of the plane, decreasing its double bond character and thus the rotational barrier around this bond. It is the bulkiness of the substituents directly attached to the carbons bonded to the nitrosyl oxygen, not the overall size of the substituent, that affects the magnitude of the barriers. A similar trend was seen for the N,N-disubstituted trifluoroacetamides described in the previous section. Comparison of available solution data with the gas-phase values obtained show that the destabilization of the larger freely rotating transition state by solvent packing forces must be important in these substituted nitrites; therefore, the unexpectedly small phase dependence may be attributed to dielectric effects which are opposite in direction but similar (or slightly lower) in magnitude to these steric forces. For methyl nitrite AG~298is lower in solution than in the gas phase (AAG~298 = 0.8 kJ tool -~) while for the other primary alkyl nitrites is slightly higher (AAG?298 0.0 to 2.5 kJ mol-1).
Gas-Phase NMR Study of N,N-Dimethylnitrosamine Harris and Spragg were the first group to report a gas-phase DNMR study determining the barrier to internal rotation in N,N-dimethylnitrosamine [76]. The CH 3
/, CH 3
O
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
1 31
free energy of activation, AGf, for the internal rotation was obtained from the coalescence temperature (431 K) spectrum as 88.3 kJ mo1-1. Two mechanisms are possible for chemical exchange in N,N-dimethylnitrosamine. Molecular orbital calculations demonstrate that rotation about the N-N bond has a lower energy barrier than inversion at the nitroso nitrogen. CNDO/2 calculations [77] yielded barriers of 76.1 and 306.7 kJ mo1-1 for rotation and inversion and MNDO calculations [78] with complete geometry optimization of both the ground and transition states yielded barriers of 54.4 and 334.7 kJ mo1-1 for rotation and inversion, respectively. Chauvel and co-workers reanalyzed this nitrosamine system in order to apply the complete bandshape method to the DNMR spectra obtaining first-order chemical exchange rate constants which are ca. 25 times faster than those observed in neat liquids at corresponding temperatures [79]. The associated kinetic parameters [Eact(Oo): 85.8 (4.6) kJ mol-I; AH~:: 82.4 (4.1) kJ mol-1; AG*: 88.3 (1.7) kJ mo1-1] are consistent with a process proceeding via a freely rotating transition state.
Gas-Phase NMR Studies of Ring Inversion in Six-Membered Rings The structures and results of a systematic study of the gas-phase conformational dynamics of six-membered ring compounds in which substitution and heterocyclicity have been studied in the gas phase are presented in Table 6 and Table 7, respectively. The values for the barriers to ring inversion in six-membered rings from Table 7 are in the case of non- and mono-substituted rings slightly higher in the gas phase than in the liquid. As substitution increases, the trend reverses. The di- and trisubstituted nitrogen heterocycles have higher gas-phase barriers to inversion than their solution-phase counterparts. Secondly, rings containing the N-CH 3 group have slightly higher barriers to inversion than cyclohexane or tetrahydropyran. Phase differences for all the ring inversion processes studied are small and can be the result of many different factors.
Table 6. Summary of Six-membered
Rings Studied
Name
Cyclohexane Cyclohexylfluoride Tetrahydropyran N-Methylmorpholine N-Ethylmorpholine N-Methylpiperidine N-Methylpiperazine N,N-Dimethylpiperazine 1,3,5-Trimethylhexahydro-1,3,5-triazine
Code
CHX CHF THP MM EM MP MPZ DMPZ TRZ
132
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
Table 7. Summary of Kinetic Parameters for Chair to Twist-Boat Ring Inversion in Six-Membered Rings
Compound
AG~298 kJ tool-l
AH~ kJ mo1-1
CHX CHF THP MM EM MP MPZ DMPZ TRZ
43.5 (0.8) 44.8 (0.4) 43.9 (0.8) 49.8 (0.4) 47.7 (0.3) 50.2 (0.4) 51.5 (1.2) 53.6 (0.8) 51.9 (0.8)
50.6 (2.1) 48.5 (5.4) 48.5 (7.9) 49.8 (0.4) 47.1 (2.3) 50.6 (0.8) 51.9 (1.7) 61.1 (1.3) 55.2 (2.09)
AS~ J K -1 tool -1 23.8 (2.1) 13.8 (5.4) 25.1 (33.5) 0.0 (2.1) -1.9 (4.9) 1 (4) 2.1 (1.7) 25.5 (4.6) 11.72 (7.5)
Ref
80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88
Gas-Phase NMR Studies of Structural Exchange in Sulfur Tetrafluoride and Bullvalene There is an extensive body of work concerned with the nature of the fluorinefluorine exchange mechanism in sulfur tetrafluoride (SF4) [89]. Studies of very pure liquid samples demonstrate that the temperature dependent spectral effects observed are attributable to an intramolecular process having the permutational character of a Berry pseudorotation [90]. Catalytic amounts of HF have been observed to increase the magnitude of the rate constants characterizing this process; therefore, the values of the gas-phase rate constants provide a way to elucidate the magnitude of the solvent effects and clarify the kinetic model of the process. Spring has studied the temperature dependence of the axial ~ equatorial fluorine exchange rates in SF4 and found them to be consistent with an activation energy for axial-equatorial exchange of 50.6 (29) kJ mo1-1 [91]. In the gas phase this activation energy is higher than that found in solution measurements which is compatible with a process occurring via a transition state smaller than the equilibrium configuration. The degenerate Cope rearrangement of bullvalene (tricyclo(3.3.2.0)deca-2,7,9triene) has also been studied extensively in condensed media and has just recently been reported in the gas phase. The dynamic mechanism can involve any of the three cyclopropane bonds that are present in the molecule, the chemical identity of bullvalene remaining unchanged during this process. Figure 3 shows one of these three possible rearrangement pathways. The direction and magnitude of solvent effects on the Cope rearrangement can be determined by comparing once again rate constants for gas phase samples with those obtained for bullvalene solutions. Previous studies have shown that increasing the pressure applied to a solution of bullvalene in CS 2 by 500 MPa increases the rearrangement rate constant by 10% at 19.8 ~ [92]. The small negative activation volume, AV*, of -0.5 cm 3 mo1-1, consistent with these results, indicates that significant charge separation does not
NMR Studies of Conformationai Processes
'Z4
133
3
4
"1
Figure 3. One of the three possible pathways in the degenerateCope rearrangement of bullvalene. occur in the transition state in solution. In the gas phase, rate constants characterizing the Cope rearrangement in bullvalene are found to be 15% lower than in the liquid [93]. This agrees with a prediction based on the pressure-dependent solution-phase results, which indicates a predominantly intramolecular process which is facilitated by solvent interactions. Gas-phase kinetic parameters for the rearrangement are: AG*298 = 54.8 (0.8) kJ mol-1; M-fl = 55.2 (1.2) kJ mol-1; and AS* = 1.7 (5) J mo1-1 K-1.
Gas-Phase NMR Ring Inversion Barrier of Cyclohexene Lastly, the use of gas-phase NMR measurements can help elucidate the magnitude of barriers even in situations where experimental conditions are not optimal for a complete analysis of the temperature dependence of the rate constants. Recently, the barrier to ring inversion to cyclohexene was reported to be 43 kJ mo1-1 using a two-dimensional potential energy surface for ring twisting and ring bending consistent with assigned gas-phase vibrational frequencies [94]. For a solution of cyclohexene in bromotrifluoromethane, M-fl for ring inversion, determined from analyses of exchange broadened 1H NMR lineshapes, is 22 kJ mo1-1 [95], which is 21 kJ mo1-1 lower than the value determined from the vibrational analysis. If the magnitude of the ring inversion barrier were as high as the vibrational analysis suggest, gas-phase NMR analysis of the exchange-broadening due to the process would be detectable at 298 K. NMR spectra were acquired at two different temperatures (195 K and 298 K) in order to compare our values with those obtained from the solution and the vibrational studies. At 195 K, the rate constant associated with the ring inversion is consistent with a Gibbs energy of activation AG~195 of 27 kJ mo1-1. Assuming that solvent effects on the limiting axial and equatorial chemical shifts of cyclohexene are comparable to those observed for other six-membered rings, and AS* for the ring-inversion process is small, the barrier to ring inversion is 30 kJ mol -~ or less, in agreement with the solution study, but in disagreement with the vibrational analysis.
1 34
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
The above examples show that comparison of gas and solution phase rate constants reveals the direction and magnitude of solvent effects on conformational processes. At present it is not possible to attribute the observed solvent effects to specific causes for several reasons. Qualitative trends can be determined, but the lack of detailed studies in the liquid phase limits a quantitative analysis. First of all, liquid-phase studies generally do not obtain data which allows static and dynamic solvent effects to be separated [96,97]. Static solvent effects produce changes in activation barriers. Dynamic solvent effects induce barrier recrossing and can lead to modification of rate constants without changing the barrier height. Dynamic solvent effects are temperature and viscosity dependent. In some cases they can cause a breakdown in transition state theory [96]. Typically in solutions, conformer rate constants are measured as a function of temperature at constant pressure. In these isobaric experiments, rate constants change as a result of both changes in temperature and temperature-dependent changes in dynamic solvent effects. Jonas [98] has recently shown that rate constants obtained as a function of temperature at constant viscosity allow static solvent effects to be elucidated. These measurements are obtained by adjusting the pressure applied to the liquid sample. For cyclohexane, NMR studies of liquid samples at atmospheric pressure reported activation energies of 42.7 +_0.8 kJ mo1-1 in CS 2 solution. Jonas et al. [98] have shown that measurement at constant sample viscosity produce a significantly higher activation energy of 47.19 + 0.04 kJ mo1-1 in CS 2, very close to the gas-phase value of 52.47 + 2.0 kJ mo1-1 obtained at 2500 torr. Activation energies of ring inversion in other rings have not been measured at constant sample viscosity. Another factor which might complicate the analysis of phase-dependent differences in rate constants of conformational processes is a possible phase-dependent difference in internal vibrational redistribution (IVR) rate constants. Pressure-dependent studies of most conformational processes in the gas phase can be adequately modeled using Rice-Ramsperger-Kassel-Marcus's (RRKM) theory which assumes that IVR in critically energized molecules is ergodic on a time scale which is shorter than the reaction time. Recent molecular dynamic studies have suggested that in liquid solutions the cyclohexane ring inversion process may be non-RRKM. Since the density of states of molecules at the threshold energies required for conformational processes are low, efficient coupling mechanisms are required for RRKM theory to provide a valid description of these processes. Vibrational redistribution mechanisms which depend on rotational angular momentum coupling can play an important role in IVR processes in the gas phase, but are probably not effective in liquid solutions where rotational motion is largely quenched. If a conformational process does not follow statistical kinetic theories in one or both phases, this factor, as well as steric and dielectric effects, can influence the phase dependence of the rate constants for the conformational process. At present, it is not possible to determine all the factors responsible for the relatively small phase-dependent differences observed in ring inversion rate constants.
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
135
B. Pressure-Dependent Gas-Phase DNMR One of the most interesting applications of gas-phase NMR spectroscopy is the study of the unimolecular kinetics of conformational and other low energy molecular processes. In the gas phase, the rate constants of many chemical exchange processes are pressure dependent at pressures high enough (above a few torr) to allow their measurement from the analysis of the exchange-broadened NMR lineshapes. This dependence occurs as a falloff of the first-order rate constant with decreasing pressure and an eventual change to second-order kinetics at very low pressures. For a thermally initiated unimolecular process, the observed pressure dependence is due to competition between bimolecular deactivation, A+M ~
k
k.
A* + M
(12)
and reaction of energized molecules (A*), (13)
A*~E-~p
where ka, ka, and k(E) are the activating, deactivating, and internal energy dependent reaction rate constants, respectively; M is any collider, i.e., another A molecule, a bath gas molecule, a reference gas molecule, or the NMR tube wall, and P is the final product. Solution of this Lindemann mechanism yields the macroscopic unimolecular reaction rate constant, kun~, E
-ku~i-
d[A] [
1 [A] dt - -
k(E)ka / k d
1+ k(E) / kd[M] dE
(14)
E*=0
which reduces in the high pressure limit t o kun i = k(E)ka[k d and in the low pressure limit to kun i = k a [M]. Several statistical kinetic theories, most importantly RRKM, have approached the dependence with some degree of success. The major feature that distinguishes RRKM theory from the others is the assumption that energy is redistributed rapidly and randomly among the various degrees of freedom of an energized molecule before that molecule reacts or is deenergized. All the internal energy within a reacting molecule is available for the reaction process. For this condition to be fulfilled, IVR within the reacting molecule must be ergodic and all the IVR rate constants, kivR, must exceed k(E), the energy dependent rate constant. According to RRKM theory: k(E) = (l/h) [aG*(E- Eo)Ip(E)] where o~ is the reaction path degeneracy; G*(E- E 0) is the sum of the states in the transition state evaluated at energy E; p(E) is the density of states in the reactant; and E 0 is the threshold energy. From the Fermi Golden Rule, klvR from a state "s" to a manifold of states "/" is kiv~ = (l/h) (Z,p,(E) I~s,I 2) where 9t is the state density in the manifold and the I Vst/
136
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
are the coupling matrix elements [96,99,100]. Since k(E) is inversely proportional to p(E), at high-state densities the relationship klvR >> k(E) is usually valid and thermal gas-phase reactions such as isomerization and decomposition reactions have been successfully modeled over limited pressure ranges using statistical theories such as RRKM theory [100]. At lower state densities, kivR for at least some of the possible vibrational redistribution pathways within the molecule may be smaller than k(E) as calculated from statistical theories and the fundamental assumption common to all statistical kinetic theories may not be valid. At the energies required for conformational conversions and other exchange processes which are amenable to study by NMR spectroscopy, the reacting molecules have state densities which are much lower than those of molecules undergoing isomerization and decomposition reactions which are generally found to obey RRKM kinetics. Whether these systems can be modeled with RRKM theory is a question of current interest. Table 8 lists molecules for which pressure-dependent gas-phase chemical exchange rate constants have been obtained. Reported gas-phase NMR studies have compared experimental pressure-dependent rate constants obtained from lineshape analyses with those calculated using RRKM theory which assumes stochastic IVR. This method is sensitive to significant departures from RRKM theory but cannot distinguish smaller departures due
Table 8. Threshold Energies, State Densities and Approximate k(E) Values of
Molecules Undergoing Low Energy Processes E0
Molecule Methyl nitrite (syn) Ethyl nitrite (syn) n-Propyl nitrite (syn) n-Butyl nitrite (syn) Cyclohexane Cyclohexyl fluoride Tetrahydropyran N-Methylmorpholine N,N-Dimethylpiperazine 1,3,5-Trimethylhexahydro-l,3,5-triazine N-Methyl piperidine N-Methyl piperazine Sulfur tetrafluoride Bullvalene
p(E0) a
(kJ mo1-1) (states/cm -1) 53.1 (0.8) 34 48.1 (1.7) 405 48.9 (0.8) 1.7 x 105 48.1 (0.8) 6.9 x 105 52.3 1500 48.1 3100 50.2 700 51.0 9800 61.5 1.3 x 106 55.2 5.9 x 106 51.5 2.4 x 104 53.1 1.8 x 104 53.1 60 54.8 (0.8) 16550
<
k(E) >b (s-l)
2.6 x 1.2 x 1.6 x 2.8 x 2.0 x 3.7 x 3.5 x 9.6 x 3.0 x 3.0 x 9.3 x 8.2 x 3.0 x 5.7 x
109 109 108 107 109 109 109 107 107 105 107 107 108 106
Ref 101,102 75 75 75 80 81 82 83 87 88 85 86 91 93
Notes: aCalculatedfrom modified direct count procedures. bEstimated from experimental values of Pla, the pressure where the pseudounimolecular rate constant is 1/2 its high pressure limiting value, assuming hard-sphere or modified hard-sphere collision diameters.
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
137
to uncertainties in transition-state structural and vibrational characteristics which are necessary for the RRKM calculations and which must be estimated. It is usually assumed that RRKM kinetic theory provides the best description of thermal unimolecular reactions with activation energies above ca. 210 kJ mo1-1 [103]. In small molecules with lower activation energies, where state densities are low to moderate (<106 ] cm-l), the vibrational redistribution process is not well understood. The modeling of the pseudounimolecular rate constant's falloff with decreasing pressure can provide useful information in regard to the redistribution. After the high-pressure limit has been established, the unimolecular rate constants (kuni) obtained are plotted versus pressure to generate the experimental falloff curve. The RRKM specific rate constants [103] are calculated from:
~_~9(g~)
(15)
hN(E;) The unimolecular rate constants are calculated from,
oo Ep(E~)e_ET/RTdE, e l l k(ET/ kuni- hQiQ2 1+
(16)
E*=E0 where Q~ is the partition function for extemal rotation o-l (IAIBIc)U2 where o is the rotational symmetry number, h is Planck's constant, Q2 is the partition function for the internal active modes (vibrations), E* is the energy of the molecule, R is the gas constant, T is the absolute temperature, and o~ is the collision frequency. The superscript zl: denotes the transition state, while nonsuperscripted variables pertain to the ground state molecule. The computer program RRKM written by Hase and Bunker [104] calculates, by the Rabinovitch-Setser direct count option, the sums and densities that are needed for the program FALLOFF [105]. A direct analysis of the fit between the computer generated falloff curve and the experimental dependence will determine the applicability of the statistical IVR and the RRKM modeling.
Alkyl Nitrites The first conformational process for which pressure-dependent rate constants were obtained using gas-phase NMR spectroscopy was the syn-anti exchange process of methyl nitrite (MeONO). Figure 4 shows gas-phase 1H NMR spectra of pure MeONO as a function of pressure at 262 K. At low pressures the rate of the exchange process is slow on the NMR timescale and the spectrum is resolved into resonances of the syn and anti conformers. As the pressure increases, the exchange rate increases and causes the syn and anti resonances to ultimately collapse into a single line. Our first study reported pressure-dependent rate constants obtained for pure MeONO at pressures between 4.6 and 364 torr, and for MeONO/CO 2 mixtures
96.6
......
A
175.3
31.2
56.7
21.3
" " "18w0() ' "16104) " 14100 ' 12100 " "IC~00" "8(~0"" "6(~0"' "4~0
Hz
Figure 4. Pressure dependent 1H NMR spectra of pure methyl nitrite gas at 262.2 K. Labels indicate pressure values in torr. The anti resonance is downfield.
138
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
139
containing 15.3 torr of MeONO and C O 2 pressures between 12.9 and 701 torr [72]. In this early study, pressure-dependent rate constants for the syn-anti conformational exchange process were calculated using RRKM theory. The curvature and location of the calculated falloff curves are sensitive to the threshold energy, collisional cross section, and the state density in the reactant and transition state. Satisfactory agreement was obtained between calculated and experimental pressure dependent rate constants using a collision diameter of 3.0 ,~, and a threshold energy of 52.3 kJ mo1-1 which are reasonable for this process. State densities were calculated from experimental vibrational frequencies and the transition state model used vibrational frequencies which were the averages of those of the syn and anti conformers. This study concluded that the syn-anti conformational exchange process of MeONO is adequately modeled using RRKM kinetics, and therefore IVR is ergodic in critically energized MeONO. Our first study of MeONO used standard RRKM theory, which does not take into account the reversible nature of the con formational process to calculate rate constants. Modifications to the standard RRKM theory for reversible reactions were reported by Bauer et al. [106,107]. An additional study by Bauer et al. reported discrepancies between RRKM predictions and rate constants in the low-pressure bimolecular region for MeONO and concluded that certain regions of vibrational phase space are poorly coupled to the reaction coordinate [108]. This study compared theoretical calculations to experimental rate constants which were later shown to be significantly in error. The results reported by Bauer prompted a detailed reinvestigation of the bimolecular kinetics of the syn-anti exchange process of MeONO at pressures between 5 and 70 torr. This study reported a bimolecular activation energy of 46.9 (1.3) kJ mo1-1 and demonstrated that RRKM and reversible RRKM calculations can be used to model the process in this pressure region [109]. This study also demonstrated that the bimolecular rate constant, kbi = kuni/[MeONO], appears to increase as the pressure is decreased below 10 torr. This may indicate that IVR is not completely ergodic in this system and that additional degrees of freedom, poorly coupled to the reaction coordinate, may participate in the process when the time between collisions is sufficiently long, as suggested originally by Bauer. The quality of the data obtained in this low pressure region was poor and large uncertainties made it impossible to draw definitive conclusions. Recently, some additional low-pressure rate constants for the syn-anti process in MeONO have been obtained [110]. Figure 5 shows pressure-dependent rate constants (k/koo) for syn~--~anti exchange in pure MeONO at 262.2 K. The solid line corresponds to RRKM calculated values using E 0 = 49.8 kJ moF 1 and ~ = 5.4 ]k. Pressure-dependent rate constants for the syn-anti conformational process in larger alkyl nitrites provide a further test of the ability of RRKM theory to successfully model the kinetics of the internal rotation process in these molecules. Solution of the Lindemann mechanism shows that at the pressure where the rate constant is one-half of its limiting high-pressure value, P1/2, the frequency of deactivating collisions is comparable to , the average rate that critically
140
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ 0.0
8
-0.5
-
-1.0
-
-1.5
.-4
-20 J-I
-2.5
-3.0
-
-3.5 2
I
I
3
4
I
I
5
6
7
Ln(P)
Figure 5. Pressure dependent rate constants (k/koo) of methyl nitrite gas. Solid line represents RRKM calculated rate constants as described in the text.
energized molecules become products. RRKM theory predicts to be inversely proportional to the total state density of the reacting molecule, p(E). In a homologous series of molecules which undergo the same reaction or process, an increase in the available state density should cause a corresponding decrease in and P1/2, if other factors such as the sum of states in the transition state remain relatively constant. Pressure-dependent gas phase NMR studies of syn-anti exchange in alkyl nitrite/CO 2 mixtures reported P1/2 values of 312, 166, 26, and <3 torr for MeONO, ethyl nitrite, n-propyl nitrite, and n-butyl nitrite, respectively [75]. For all the nitrites studied, experimental rate constants were modeled using RRKM theory. This study concluded that the agreement between the rate constants calculated using RRKM
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
141
theory with reasonable values of vibrational frequencies, collision diameters, collision efficiencies, and threshold energies and the experimentally obtained pressure dependent rate constants strongly supports the conclusion that IVR in this series of alkyl nitrites is rapid compared to and statistical. This indicates that the increased number of vibrational states due to each additional methylene group may participate in the IVR process and the energy acquired in these states is available for the conformational exchange process in all the nitrites studied.
Cyclohexane Pressure-dependent studies of cyclohexane (CHX) ring inversion employed SF 6 as a bath gas [80]. The samples studied contained 1 torr of cyclohexane and SF 6 pressures ranging from 5.9 to 4000 torr. The high pressure (unimolecular) limit occurred at pressures above 2500 torr and bimolecular kinetics were obtained at pressures below 200 torr. CHX ring inversion has a threshold energy of--41.8 kJ mo1-1 and a vibrational state density of-- 2500 states/cm -1 at the threshold energy. The rate constants obtained from analysis of 1H exchange-broadened lineshapes were compared to those calculated using RRKM theory using the transition state model proposed by Pickett and Straus [111]. The experimental falloff curve was adequately reproduced by the calculation indicating that IVR in critically energized cyclohexane is ergodic or nearly so over the pressure range studied. Recently, several studies have concluded that ring inversion in cyclohexane does not follow RRKM kinetics in solutions. Jonas has recently shown that cyclohexane ring inversion constants obtained as a function of temperature and pressure indicate that coupling of cyclohexane molecules to the solvent bath is weak and causes a breakdown of RRKM theory [98]. Molecular dynamics studies of cyclohexane ring inversion conclude that the solvent causes a qualitative breakdown of transition state theory and the RRKM picture of unimolecular kinetics for this process in solution [112,113]. In the gas phase, Coriolis coupling, as well as the recently described vibrationally induced Rotational axis switching mechanism [114], facilitate the IVR process. These are both rotationally mediated IVR mechanisms. In solutions, rotational motion is essentially quenched and this may also impede IVR in solvated cyclohexane, causing the reported non-RRKM behavior. Pressure-dependent studies of ring inversion of the six-membered rings previously described in the temperature-dependent section (see Table 6 for their structures and code names) have also been reported. Table 8 lists threshold energies and state densities for these molecules. In all cases, the pressure-dependent ring inversion rate constants could be adequately modeled using RRKM theory.
Aziridine Nitrogen inversion in aziridine and 2-methylaziridine was studied using 1H NMR by Bauer et al. [ 115]. This study observed no dependence of the nitrogen inversion rate constant of aziridine on pressure down to a pressure of 5 torr, in sharp contrast to RRKM calculations which indicated that this system should be in the bimolecular
142
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
regime at pressures below 100 torr. A less extensive set of measurements was made with 2-methyl aziridine, which did show a small but clear fall off in the rate constant with pressure. These results were interpreted in terms of a regional phase space model, previously proposed for methylnitrite.
Bullvalene The degenerate Cope rearrangement of bullvalene (tricyclo(3,3,2,0)deca-2,7,9triene) exchanges protons in vinylic and allylic environments. It was possible to obtain pressure-dependent exchange-broadened lineshapes of bullvalene at 355.8 K at its vapor pressure, ca. 1 torr, as functions of the pressure of SF 6 which was used as a bath gas [93]. Measurements were made at SF 6 pressures between 7 and 2580 torr. Low vapor pressure and large linewidths precluded spectral acquisition below 330 K and it was not possible to observe slow exchange spectra in the gas phase. This resulted in additional uncertainties in calculated rate constants since limiting chemical shifts could not be determined in the gas phase and were estimated from liquid studies. Unimolecular rate constants were observed at pressures above ca. 250 torr. P1/2 is estimated to occur below 5 torr and it was not possible to observe rate constants in the bimolecular region for this molecule. To determine if the observed pressure dependence of these rate constants indicated statistical behavior, pressure-dependent rate constants were calculated using RRKM theory. Transition states with either biradicaloid or aromatic character have been proposed for the Cope rearrangement of bullvalene, and their structures, and relative energies have been determined from AMPAC calculations [116]. These calculations indicated that the aromatic transition state is considerably more stable. Rotational constants and vibrational frequencies of the ground state and both transition states were calculated using the computer program AMPAC using the AM 1 Hamiltonian. The RRKM calculations used threshold energies of 56 and 54.4 kJ mo1-1 for the biradicaloid and aromatic transition states, respectively, which are compatible with the experimentally determined gas phase activation energy. In Figure 6 the top solid line indicates the RRKM calculated curve for the biradicaloid transition state model and the lower curve represents the RRKM calculated falloff curve for the more flexible aromatic transition state model. Both curves were calculated with a collision diameter of 3.6 /k which is somewhat larger than expected, based on previous studies and considering the hard sphere cross sections ofbullvalene and SF 6. Additional calculations were performed which demonstrated that an unreasonably large collision diameter of 6.4 A is required to force an agreement between the RRKM calculation using the aromatic transition state model and the observed pressure-dependent rate constants. The biradicaloid transition state provided better agreement with the experimental data. It is unlikely that this model is the correct transition state for the process, however, since it has a much higher energy than the aromatic transition state model, according to the reported AMPAC calculations. Several factors can account for these results. First the AMPAC calculated frequencies of both transition state
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes 0.1
143
-0.2
8 .-t
=
-0.5
-0.8
-1.1
/ ....... I
I
i
2
3
4
.....
.....
5
1
1
. . . . . . I.
6
7
8
9
Ln (P)
Figure 6. Logarithmic plot values of kunJkooversus pressure for the Cope rearrangement of bullvalene (torr at the experimental temperature of 356 K). Experimental values are signified by solid circles. Pressures are the total sample pressure at 356 K. Errors in kuni/k~ a r e reported to 2o. The solid (upper) line represents the values calculated from RRKM theory using the biradicaloid transition state model. The lower line represents calculated rate constants using the aromatic transition-state model. The collision diameter was 3.6 ,~, in both cases.
models may be too low. Higher vibrational frequencies in the transition state shift the calculated falloff curves to lower pressures. The aromatic transition state model can fit the experimental pressure dependent rate constant data if the four lowest frequencies are assumed to be ca. 50 cm -l higher than their AMPAC calculated values. Secondly, the assumptions of RRKM theory may not be valid in this case. The data are not inconsistent with the more flexible AMPAC calculated transition state if a few of the vibrations are remoded from the state density count. In this
144
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
molecule some IVR pathways are forbidden based on symmetry arguments. Since only slight modifications in transition state models or calculational methods are required to achieve an acceptable agreement between the observed rate constants and RRKM calculations using the aromatic transition state model, this study concluded that IVR in critically energized bullvalene molecules is statistical or nearly so.
Sulfur Tetrafluoride The Berry pseudorotation process of SF4 is the first example of a low energy molecular process whose kinetics could not be modeled using RRKM kinetic theory. The Berry pseudorotation process exchanges the axial and equatorial fluorine atoms and has an activation energy of 50.6 kJ mo1-1 in the gas phase. Rate constants were obtained from analysis of exchange-broadened 19F NMR spectra between 298 and 356 K at pressures ranging from 55 to 2004 torr. Extensive sets of pressure dependent rate constants were obtained at 308, 328, and 348 K. P1/2, the pressure where the pseudounimolecular rate constant is 1/2 its limiting high pressure value, was approximately 170 torr. For this small 5-atom molecule, state densities at the threshold energy required for the pseudorotation process to occur are -60 states/cm-1 and based on results obtained for other systems, one would expect significantly larger P1/2 values for this molecule. Pressure dependent rate constants were calculated for SF4 using RRKM theory. Using reasonable values of these parameters~i.e., a threshold energy of 50.2 kJ mol -~, consistent with the experimentally determined bimolecular activation energy; a collision diameter of 2.2/k consistent with the experimental spin-rotation cross section; reactant state densities calculated from vibrational data; and reasonable transition state state densities~produced an RRKM calculated falloff curve with P1/2 of 2250 torr. Additional calculations varied the threshold energy, collision diameter, and transition state state density to determine the sensitivity of the RRKM calculation to these parameters. Clearly unreasonable values of these parameters were required to force an agreement between the experimentally determined and RRKM calculated pressure-dependent rate constant data. It was suggested that IVR for critically energized SF 4 molecules is slower than and may be the limiting factor in determining the overall reaction rate constant. This may be due to low-state density at the internal energy required for the reaction, coupled with symmetry restrictions which may prevent IVR between some vibrational modes. For most of the molecules discussed above, the experimentally determined pressure-dependent gas-phase rate constants can be modeled adequately with RRKM theory. SF4 and possibly aziridine are the exceptions. Due to uncertainties in the model parameters used in RRKM calculations, and the sensitivity of the calculations to these parameters, only qualitative conclusions can be drawn from the observed agreement. Since major departures are not observed, it can be
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
145
concluded that IVR in the reacting molecules is statistical or nearly so. Regional phase-space theories, using different model parameters, can also provide satisfactory models for many of these processes if only small subsets of vibrational states are considered to be weakly coupled to the reaction coordinate. The suggestion of an increase in bimolecular rate constants with decreasing pressure observed in some data supports these models. Better data in the low-pressure region is necessary in order to draw any definite conclusions. Further tests of kinetic theories for conformational processes require extensive bimolecular and high pressure data. In the high-pressure region, Kramer's theory predicts a slow rise in the observed rate constant with pressure, followed by a decline at pressures above the turnover point [96]. Non-RRKM effects can change the dependence of the rate constants on pressure in this region [117]. With the exception of isomerization of trans-stilbene in an electronically excited state [118], rate constants of conformational processes have not been measured in the gas phase at pressures above a few atmospheres. This is clearly an area for future work.
C. Bimolecular Rate Constants and Collision Efficiencies The main interest in unimolecular reactions in the low-pressure region is concentrated on the change in order, shape, and position of the falloff Curve, and, in favorable cases, with the bimolecular rate constant. In order to study these characteristics, it is imperative to reduce the scatter of data due to temperature gradients and poor signal-to-noise ratios. As seen in Eq. (9) temperature has an exponential effect on the rate constant, whereas pressure dependence is, at most, linear. Temperature gradients across the active volume should be <0.2 K with measurements accurate to 0.1 K. Moreover, transverse relaxation times, tzS, decrease with pressure, t2 line broadening becomes more significant than that due to exchange, introducing large errors in the rate constant. Therefore, ca. 5 to 20 torr is an experimental lower limit for the determination of these rate constants. The addition of an inert bath gas to increase sample pressure can be accounted for if the collision efficiency of the bath gas is taken into consideration. Rate constants in the low-pressure bimolecular region are determined by the rate of activating collisions and are dependent on the nature of the collider. Relative energy-transfer efficiencies can be obtained from rate constants measured as a function of bath gas pressure. Bath gas relative collisional efficiencies have been measured for the methyl nitrite (MeONO) conformer conversion [119] and for ring inversion in cyclohexane (CHX) [120] using gas-phase NMR spectroscopy. They are the first conformational processes to be extensively studied in the bimolecular region. The bimolecular kinetics of the methylisocyanide (MIC; CH3NC) isomerization, which has a much higher activation energy, was studied earlier using conventional kinetic techniques [121].
146
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
Rabinovitch and co-workers found that the Lindemann mechanism is adequate for modeling the pressure dependence of bimolecular region unimolecular rate constants for extracting collision efficiencies for the methyl isocyanide isomerization [122]. For the conformer conversion of molecule A at constant temperature, it can be written as, k.~ A + M _2!_. A* + M k~ k3
A, --->A where M is any collider, i.e., another A molecule, a bath gas molecule, a reference gas molecule, or the NMR tube wall. Then, in the bimolecular region the unimolecular rate constants can be expressed as, kNMR= kuni - ~ [ a ] + k~l[M] + ko
(17)
where [A] and [M] refer to the densities of the molecule and bath gas. In the absence of a bath gas (or in the presence of a small fixed pressure of a bath gas) and at constant temperature, where only the density of A is varied, Eq. 17 can be written as,
kuni =/r [a] + ko
(18)
where k0 may incorporate the additional term k~l[M] 0 for the small, constant amount of bath gas. This expression is valid as long asthe total effective pressure remains in the bimolecular region. Analysis of pressure-dependent unimolecular rate constants for conformer conversion in samples of pure A at pressures below PI/2 (unimolecular-bimolecular transition point) using Eq. 18 via linear regression yields a slope ofk~l. If the pressure of A is held as low as possible and fixed whereas the pressure of the bath gas is varied, Eq. 17 becomes, kun i = kml[M] + k0
(19)
where k0 incorporates the additional term ~[A] 0 for the small, constant pressure of A. Analysis of pressure dependent unimolecular rate constants for A/bath gas mixtures in the bimolecular region using Eq. (19) via linear regression yields a slope of k~l. The collisional energy transfer efficiency of the bath gas relative to A in the activation of A in the conformer conversion process on a pressure per pressure basis is then written as 13p= k~l / k~l. Corrections for the relative velocities of the colliding partners and their cross sections produces the quantity, ~C "- [~p X (~AM/~AA) 0"5 X (SAA/SAM)2
(20)
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes a
147
6.7
5.0
i
800
i
600
i
i
400
Frequency
200 Hz
Figure 7. Pressuredependent gas-phase 1H NMR spectra, acquired at 300 MHz and 249,1 K, of exchanged-broadened axial and equatorial CHX protons. The labels indicate the total sample pressure in torr at 298 K. Samples contained (a) 0.5 torr of gaseous TMS as a reference and increasing amounts of CHX gas and (b) 0.7 torr of TMS, 3.0 torr of CHX, and increasing amounts of xenon as a bath gas. The x axis is in units of Hz referenced to gaseous TMS (0 Hz). (continued) which is the collisional energy transfer efficiency on a collision per collision basis. Since the quantities SAA and SAMwere not known for CHX and MeONO, collision efficiencies [3~ = ]3p x (laaM/PAA) ~ were calculated for comparison purposes. In their investigation of MIC isomerization, Rabinovitch and co-workers found that when looking for factors influencing trends in collision efficiency, [3~twas a more reliable parameter to study than [3c. Typical experimental spectra and rate constants for CHX are shown in Figure 7a and 7b. Figure 7a shows the effect of increasing pressure of CHX gas on the NMR line shape. The spectra were acquired with samples of 0.5 torr of TMS reference and between 1.1 and 7.6 torr (298 K ) o f C H X . Figure 7b shows the dependence of the NMR line shape on increasing pressure of xenon gas with a constant pressure of CHX and TMS (3.0/0.7 torr). This concentration of CHX was chosen so the dilution factors would be as large as possible, while keeping signal-to-noise ratios adequate for analysis. Figures 8a and 8b show
148
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
b
.6
_j
I
800
..
I
600
I
400
Frequency
Figure 7.
I
200 Hz
(continued)
representative plots of kuni versus pressure for the pure CHX and CHX-Xenon mixtures, respectively. For all the mixtures studied, the rate constants obtained exhibit a linear pressure dependence. Table 9 lists 13~tvalues for the 16 bath gases reported in the MeONO study and for the 18 bath gases reported in the CHX study. 130 values of these gases measured relative to MIC for the methyl isocyanide isomerization are also shown for comparison purposes. For MIC and MeONO similar trends in bath gas relative efficiencies are observed. For these processes, strong correlations between bath gas collision efficiency and polarizability and bath gas collision efficiency and boiling point were observed. This result indicates that the attractive portion of the intermolecular potential is important in determining collision efficiency. It was found in the case of MeONO conformer conversion and isomerization of MIC and ethyl isocyanide that there is a high correlation (R > 0.9) between these properties and 13~tfor all bath gases studied. For nonpolar CHX, [3~ also correlates positively with polarizability for the 18 bath gases studied when they are treated collectively. Separate trends and correlations are observed for noble gases, diatomics, and polyatomic molecules. There is no correlation between 13~ and polarizability for the five noble gases
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
149
cyclohexane/no
bath gas
200
I
150 0 (i) o9 ~
r
100
50 2
4
6
8
10
Pressure (Torr ot 298 K)
Figure 8. Plots of kuni (S-1) versus total sample pressure (298 K) for (a) pure CHX and (b) for CHX-xenon mixtures which contained 3.0 torr of CHX, 0.7 torr of TMS, and varying pressures of Xe. The linear nature of the plot shows that the effective pressures are in the bimolecular regime. (continued)
studied, but 13~tcorrelates positively (R = 0.99) with polarizability for the four homonuclear diatomic molecules studied when they are treated as a group. If the linear triatomic molecule CO 2 is added to the set of diatomics, the correlation coefficient is not significantly decreased. The observed collision efficiencies of the larger polyatomic molecules are strongly correlated with polarizability, showing a greater dependence than the linear polyatomics. 13~tas a function of boiling point displays similar trends. This suggests that for monoatomic gases colliding with CHX, the attractive portion of the intermolecular potential is not the dominating factor in collisional energy transfer. As the molecular complexity of the bath gas increases, however, it appears to play a more important role. General relative trends are similar in all three systems; [3~tincreases with molecular complexity, with most
150
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ xenon ......
I
180
w,-
I
o (19 co 1 5 0 V ~ c"
120
I
I
50
100
Pressure
............ ! ...........
150
i
200
(Tort at 298 K)
Figure 8. (continued) CHX-bath gas collision efficiencies being approximately 20-30% of those determined for MeONO and MIC. Overall, the values of I]~tfor this series of bath gases colliding with CHX are much smaller than those obtained in the MeONO and MIC systems. This may be due in part to the absence of a dipole moment in CHX. For the He/MeONO system, the temperature dependence of [3rt for He was determined [119]. An 18% decrease in [3rtover a 31 K increase in temperature was observed. This trend is similar to that observed previously for MIC [122] and can be explained by considering the size of the vibrational partition function of MeONO which increases by 19% over the 31 K temperature interval studied. Previous studies of collisional energy transfer in MeONO have shown that the vibrational degrees of freedom of the colliders is important. Thus, an inert gas such as helium, which has only translational degrees of freedom, would be expected to show a decrease in collision efficiency relative to MeONO on itself with increasing temperature.
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
151
Table 9. Bath Gas Collision Efficiencies, 131a,for Cyclohexane (CHX), Methyl Isocyanide (MIC), and Methyl Nitrite (MEONO) Bath Gas
CHX He Ne
Ar Kr Xe 2H2 H2 N2 02 CO CO2 NH3 SF6 CBrF3 CBrH3 CCIF3 CCIH3 CCIFCF2 CH2CF2 Acetone-F6
CHX
1.00 (04) 0.0185 (13) 0.0182 (13) 0.0299 (19) 0.0272 (20) 0.0191 (09) 0.0256 (19) 0.0287 (42) 0.0461 (151) 0.0520 (111 ) 0.0745 (44) 0.114 (06) 0.155 (19) 0.176 (15)
0.0722 (09) 0.0976 (25) 0.135 (04) 0.134 (05) 0.147 (06) 0.100 (05) 0.087 (7) 0.19(01) 0.47 0.33 0.58 0.52
(5) (01) (01) (03)
MEONO
0.086 (5) 0.24 (3) 0.37 (5)
0.13 (1) 0.41 (6) 0.44 (7) 0.23 0.55 (4) 0.47 (3) 0.79 (7)
0.60 (05) 0.180 (25) 0.51 (01) 0.277 (17) 0.53 (02) 0.286 (15) 0.95 0.35 0.56 0.64
Acetone
CH4 C2H6 C3H8 C4F8 n-C4H10 n-CsH12
MIC
(05) (4) (4) (5)
0.33 0.52 0.64
0.485 (35) 0.74 (5) 0.85 (6)
0.89 0.99
IV. C O N C L U S I O N Gas-phase NMR spectroscopy has been used to obtain equilibrium constants and rate constants for many low-energy molecular processes. These data have been used to address questions regarding the relative stability of conformers and tautomers in the gas phase, the kinetics of exchange processes in the gas phase, and the direction and magnitude of solvent effects on these equilibria and processes. Most of the studies have appeared in the last 10 years. Continued progress in NMR instrumentation and techniques as well as considerable recent developments in kinetic theory ensure that the next 10 years will see many novel applications of gas-phase NMR spectroscopy.
152
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
REFERENCES A N D NOTES 1. Jackman, L.M.; Cotton, EA. Eds. Dynamic Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy; Academic: New York, 1975. 2. See for example: Ernst, R.R.; Bodenhausen, G.; Wokaun, A. Principles of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance in One and Two Dimensions; Oxford University Press: New York, 1987. 3. See for example: Campbell, D.M.; Mackowiak, M.; Jonas, J. J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 96, 2717. 4. Weiss-Lopez, B.E.; Winegar, E.D.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1988, 92, 4052. 5. Folkendt, M.M.; Weiss-Lopez, B.E.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1988, 92, 4859. 6. Jameson, C.J. Chem. Rev. 1991, 91, 1375. 7. Armstrong, R.L. Magn. Reson. Rev. 1987, 12, 91. 8. Harris, R.K.; Rao, R.C. Org. Magn. Reson. 1983, 21,580. 9. Govil, G. AppL Spectrosc. Rev. 1973, 7, 47. 10. Jameson, A.K.; Jameson, C.J. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1987, 134, 461. 11. Jameson, C.J.; Jameson, A.K.J. Magn. Reson. 1985, 62, 209, and references therein. 12. Govil, G. hldian J. Chem. 1971, 9, 824. 13. Fleischer, U.; Schindler, M. Chem. Phys. 1988, 120, 103. 14. Schindler, M. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1987, 109, 5950, and references therein. 15. Sanctuary, B.C.; Selwyn, L. J. Chem. Phys. 1978, 69, 2157, and references therein. 16. Kouri, D.J.J. Chem. Phys. 1978, 69(11), 4999. 17. McCourt, ER.; Tenti, G. Chem. Phys. 1978, 32, 23, and references therein. 18. Jameson, C.J. Nucl. Magn. Resort. 1985, 14, 1. 19. Harris, R.K.; Rao, R.C. Org. Magn. Reson. 1983, 21(9), 580. 20. Folkendt, M.M.; Weiss-Lopez, B.E.; Chauvel, J.P. Jr.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1985, 89(15), 3347. 21. Chauvel, J.P; True, N. S. J. Phys. Chem. 1983, 87, 1622. 22. Conboy, C.B.; Chauvel, J.P.; Moreno, P.O.; True, N.S.; Ott, C.M.J. Phys. Chem. 1986, 90, 4353. 23. Jameson, C.J.; Jameson, A.K.; Cohen, S.M.; Parker, H.; Oppusunggu, D.; Burrell, P.M.; Wille, S. J. Chem. Phys. 1981, 74, 1608. 24. Jameson, C.J.; Jameson, A.K.; Oppusunggu, D. J. Chem. Phys. 1984, 81, 2571. 25. Isbrandt, L.; Tung, W.C-T.; Rogers, M.T.J. Magn. Reson. 1973, 9, 461. 26. Sapse, A.M.; Mallah-Levy, L.; Daniels, S.B.; Erickson, B.W.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1987, 109(12), 3526. 27. Mirkin, N.G.; Krimm, S. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1991, 113(26), 9742. 28. Perrirn, C.L.; Dwyer, T.J.; Rebek Jr. J.; Duff, R.J.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1990, 112, 3122. 29. Jorgensen, W.L.; Gao, J. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1988, 110, 4212. 30. Spencer, J.N. et. al. J. Chem. Phys. 1981, 85, 1236. 31. Gutowsky, H.S.; Belford, G.G.; McMahon, P.E.J. Chem. Phys. 1962, 36, 3353. 32. Abraham, R.J.; Bretschneider, E. Internal Rotation in Molecules; Orville-Thomas, W. J. (Ed); John Wiley and Sons: London, 1974, Ch. 13, and refs. cited therein. 33. Jackman, L.M.; Cotton, EA., Eds. Dynamic Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy; Academic: New York, 1975. 34. Lumbroso-Bader, N.; Coupry, C.; Baron, D.; Clague, D.H.; Govil, G. J. Magn. Reson. 1975,17(3), 386. 35. Clague, D.H.; Govil, G.; Bernstein, H.J. Can. J. Chem. 1969, 47(4), 625. 36. Inomata, K.; Abe, A. J. Phys. Chem. 1992, 96, 7934. 37. Gutowsky, H.S.; Belford, G.G.; McMahon, P.E.J. Chem. Phys. 1962, 36(12), 3353. 38. Vold, R.L.; Gutowsky, H.S.J. Chem. Phys. 1967, 47(7), 2495. 39. Miyajima, T.; Hirano, T.; Sato, H. J. Molec. Struc. 1984, 125, 97. 40. Hirano, T.; Miyajima, T. J. Molec. Struc. 1985, 126, 141.
NMR Studies of Conformational Processes
153
41. Hirano, T.; Nonoyama, S.; Miyajima, T.; Kurita, Y.; Kawamura, T.; Sato, H.J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. 1986, 606. 42. Hirano, T.; Miyajima, T.; Kato, K.; Sato, H. J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. 1986, 606. 43. Abe, A.; Mark, J.E.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1976, 98, 6468. 44. Barzaghi, M.; Gamba, A.; Morosi, G. J. MoL Struct. (THEOCHEM) 1988, 170, 69. 45. Govil, G.; Berstein, H.J.J. Chem. Phys. 1967, 47, 2818. 46. Heatley, E; Allen, G. Mol. Phys. 1969, 16, 77. 47. Pachler, K.G.; Wessels, P.L.J. MoL Struc. 1980, 68, 145. 48. Lin, W. J. Chem. Phys. 1970, 52(6), 2805. 49. Lin, W. J. Chem. Phys. 1973, 58(11), 4971. 50. Chen, J.; Shirts, R.B.; Lin, W. J. Phys. Chem. 1986, 90, 4970. 51. Lin, W. J. Chem. Phys. 1973, 58(11), 4971. 52. Abraham, R.J.; Cavalli, L. Molec. Phys. 1964, 67. 53. Abraham, R.J.; Cavalli, L.; Pachler, K.G. Molec. Phys. 1966, 11(5), 471. 54. Abraham, M.H.; Abraham, R.J.; Leonard, P.; True, N.S.; Suarez, C. J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2. 1991, 463. 55. (a) Binsch, G.; Klier, D.A. Program No. 365; (b) LeMaster, C. B.; LeMaster, C. L.; True, N. S. Programs No. 569 and QCMP 059, Quantum Chemistry Program Exchange, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405. 56. Sandstr6m, J. Dynamic NMR Spectroscopy; Academic Press: London, 1982. 57. Glasstone, S.; Laidler, K.J.; Eyring, H. Theory of Rate Processes; McGraw-Hill: New York, 1941. 58. Stewart, W.E.; Siddall III, T.H. Chem. Rev. 1970, 70, 517. 59. LeMaster, C.B.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1989, 93, 1307. 60. Feigel, M. J. Phys. Chem. 1983, 87, 3054. 61. True, N.S.; Ross, B.D.J. Phys. Chem. 1984, 88, 3216. 62. Turner, K.A.; LeMaster, C.L.; LeMaster, C.B.J. MoL Struct. 1992, 271, 261. 63. Ross, B.D.; True, N.S.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1984, 106(8), 2451. 64. Suarez, C.; LeMaster, C.B.; LeMaster, C.L.; Tafazzoli, M.; True, N. S. J. Phys. Chem. 1990, 94, 6679. 65. Andrews, P.R. Biopolymers 1971, 10(11), 2253. 66. Stein, S.E.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1981, 103, 5685. 67. Bleha, T.; Gajdos, J.; Tvaroska, I. J. MoL Struct. 1980, 68, 189. 68. Ross, B.D.; True, N.S.; Decker, D.L.J. Phys. Chem. 1983, 87(1), 89. 69. Suarez, C." Tafazzoli, M.; True, N.S.; Gerrard, S.; LeMaster, C.B.; LeMaster, C.L.J. Phys. Chem. (in press). 70. Ross, B.D.; True, N.S.; Matson, G.B.J. Pto,s. Chem. 1984, 88, 2675. 71. Ross, B.D.; Wong, L.T.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1985, 89(5), 836. 72. Chauvel, J.P. Jr.; Conboy, C.B.; Chew, W.M.; Matson, G.B.; Spring, C.A.; Ross, B.D.; True, N.S. J. Chem. Phys. 1984, 79(6), 1469. 73. Chauvel, J.P. Jr.; Conboy, C.B.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1984, 80, 3561. 74. Conboy, C.B 9Chauvel, J.P. Jr.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1986, 4388. 75. Moreno, P.O.; True, N.S.; LeMaster, C.B.J. Molec. Structure, 1991, 243, 373. 76. Harris, R.K.; Spragg, R.A. Chem. Commtm. 1967, 362. 77. Kirste, K.; Rademacher, P. J. MoL Struct. 1981, 73, 171. 78. Baste, D.R; Davis, L.P.; Nauman, R.V.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1975, 97, 507. 79. Chauvel, J.P. Jr.; Leung, D.S.Y.; True, N.S.J. MoL Struct. 1984, 116, 67. 80. Ross, B.D.; True, N.S.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1983, 105, 1382. 81. Chu, P.S.; True, N.S.J. Chem. Phys. 1985, 89(26), 5613. 82. Chu, P.S.; True, N.S.J. Chem. Phys. 1985, 89(12), 2625.
1 54
NANCY S. TRUE and CRISTINA SUAREZ
83. LeMaster, C.B.; LeMaster, C.L.; Tafazzoli, M.; Suarez, C.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1990, 94, 3461. 84. Tafazzoli, M.; Gerrard, S.; True, N.S.; LeMaster, C.B.J. Mol. Struct. 1994, 317, 131. 85. Tafazzoli, M.; Suarez, C.; True, N.S.; LeMaster, C.B.; LeMaster, C.L.J. Mol. Struct. 1994, 317, 137. 86. Tafazzoli, M.; Suarez, C.; True, N.S.; LeMaster, C.B.; LeMaster, C.L.J. Phys. Chem. 1992, 96, 10201. 87. LeMaster, C.B.; LeMaster, C.L.; Suarez, C.; Tafazzoli, M.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1989, 93, 3993. 88. LeMaster, C.B.; LeMaster, C.L.; Tafazzoli, M.; Suarez, C.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1988, 92, 5933. 89. Jesson, J.P.; Muetterties, E.L. In Dynamic Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy; Jackman, L.M.; Cotton, R.A. Eds.; 1974, 253. 90. Klemperer, W.G.; Krieger, J.K.; McCreary, M.D.; Muetterties, E.L.; Traficante, D.D.; Whitesides, G.M.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1975, 97, 7023. 91. Spring, C.A.; True, N.S.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1983, 105, 7231. 92. Schrtider, G. Chem. Bei: 1964, 97, 3140. 93. Moreno, P.O.; Suarez, C.; Tafazzoli, M.; True, N.S.; LeMaster, C.B.J. Phys. Chem. 1992, 96, 10206.
94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99. 100. 101.
Rivera-Gaines, V.E.; Leibowitz, S.J.; Laane, J. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1991, 113, 9735. Anet, EA.L.; Haq, M.Z.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1965, 87, 3147. Hanggi, P.; Talkner, P.; Borkovec, M. Rev. Modern Physics 1990, 62, 251. Hynes, J.T. Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 1985, 36, 573. Campbell, D.M.; Mackowiak, M.; Jonas, J. J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 96, 2717. Forst, W. Theory of Unimolecular Reactions; Academic Press: New York, 1973. Robinson, P.A.; Holbrook, K.D. Unimolecular Reactions; Wiley-Interscience: New York, 1972. Chauvel, J.P. Jr.; Friedman, B.R.; Van, H.; Winegar, E.D.; True, N.S.J. Chem. Phys. 1985, 82(9), 3996. 102. Chauvel, J.P. Jr.; Conboy, C.B.; Chew, W.M.; Matson, G.B.; Spring, C.A.; Ross, B.D.; True, N.S. J. Chem. Phys. 1984, 79(6), 1469. 103. Hase, W. Dynamics of Molecular Collisions. Part B. Modern Theoretical Chemistry; Miller, M. H. Ed.; Plenum: New York, 1976, p. 121. 104. Hase, W.L.; Bunker, D.L. Program No 234, Quantum Chemistry Program Exchange, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405. 105. (a) Hase, W.L. (personal communication); (b) LeMaster, C.B.; Ph.D. Dissertation, University of California, Davis, 1988. 106. Bauer, S.H.; Lazaar, K.I.J. Chem. Phys. 1983, 79, 2808. 107. Bauer, S. H. hltl. J. Chem. Kinetics, 1985, 17, 367. 108. Lazaar, K. I.; Bauer, S. H. J. Phys. Chem. 1984, 88, 3052. 109. Chauvel, J.P. Jr.; Friedman, B.R; True, N.S.J. Chem. Phys. 1986, 84, 6218. 110. LeMaster, C.B.; True, N.S. (in preparation). 111. Pickett, H.M.; Strauss, H.L.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1970, 92, 7281. 112. Wilson, M.A.; Chandler, D. Chem. Phys. 1990, 149, 11. 113. Kuharski, R.A.; Chandler, D.; Montgomery, J.A. Jr.; Rabii, E; Singer, S. J. J. Chem. Phys. 1988, 92, 3261. 114. Gregory, H.L.; Ezra, S.; Philips, L.A.J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 97, 5956. 115. Borchardt, D.B.; Bauer, S.H.J. Chem. Phys. 1986, 85, 4980. 116. Dewar, M.J.S.; Jie, C. Tetrahedron 1988, 44, 1351. 117. Borkovec, M.; Straub, J.E.; Berne, B.J.J. Chem. Phys. 1986, 85, 146. 118. Lee, M.; Holton, G.R.; Hochstrasser, R.M. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1985, 118, 359.
NMR Studies of Conformationai Processes
155
119. Chauvei, J.P. Jr.; Friedman, B.R; True, N.S.; Winegar, E.D. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1985, 122, 175. 120. Moreno, EO.; True, N.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1991, 95, 57. 121. Chan, S.C.; Rabinovitch, B.S.; Bryant, J.T.; Spicer, L.D.; Fujimoto, T.; Lin, Y. N.; Pavlou, S. E J. Phys. Chem. 1970, 74, 3160. 122. Chan, S.C.; Bryant, J.T.; Rabinovitch, B.S.J. Phys. Chem. 1970, 74, 2055.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
FOURIER TRANSFORM SPECTROSCOPY OF RADICALS
Henry W. Rohrs, Gregory J. Frost, G. Barney Ellison, Erik C. Richard, and Veronica Vaida
Abstract
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Io Introduction II. llI. IV. V. VI. VII. VIII. IX.
Xo XI.
158 158
The M i c h e l s o n Interferometer and Fourier Transforms . . . . . . . . . . . . . 159 Practical Considerations and Necessary Corrections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 163 A d v a n t a g e s and Disadvantages of Fourier Transform Spectroscopy . . . . . . 168 Special Considerations in the Infrared . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 170 Special Considerations in the Visible and Ultraviolet . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171 A d v a n t a g e s and S o m e Details of Jet S p e c t r o s c o p y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 173 M a k i n g Radicals for S p e c t r o s c o p y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 176 F o u r i e r Transform Absorption S p e c t r o s c o p y for the Study of Photoreactive Radicals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 179 Fourier T r a n s f o r m Infrared Spectroscopy of Jet-Cooled Radicals . . . . . . . 180 Visible and Ultraviolet Fourier Transform S p e c t r o s c o p y o f Reactive Species . 186 A.
Spectroscopy of OC10
B.
Spectroscopy of CN
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
187
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
193
Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References and Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
195 195
Advances in Molecular Structure Research Volume 1, pages 157-199. Copyright 9 1995 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 1-55938-799-8
157
158
ROHRS, FROST,ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
ABSTRACT Fourier transform methods have come into their own as a means of studying the optical spectra of gas-phase radicals. Both infrared (FTIR) and ultraviolet/visible spectroscopy (FrUVNIS) are now used to scrutinize these reactive molecules. We discuss the underlying principles of Fourier transform spectroscopy (F-I'S) with particular emphasis on the advantages and drawbacks of FTIR and FTUV/VIS measurements. Extensive tables are presented of metastable molecules that have been studied by Fourier transform methods.
!. I N T R O D U C T I O N The spectroscopic study of radicals is a vexing business. The most common approach is to isolate these unstable species in a matrix at low temperatures. But if one is interested in atmospheric radicals (such as OC10 or CIOO) or combustion species (CH 3 for example), one has to deal with gas-phase radicals. Direct observation of gas-phase radicals is quite difficult; they are not stable, commercially available samples. Since radicals are reactive intermediates, they are destroyed by each other at nearly diffusion controlled rates [ 1]. As a result, one typically has only small concentrations of radicals (roughly 1012 cm -3) to work with. This chapter reviews Fourier transform (FT) methods [2] to monitor the infrared (IR) and ultraviolet/visible (UV/VIS) spectra of gas-phase radicals. Why are FT methods attractive compared to laser based approaches? Lasers are wonderful devices to probe the optical properties of radicals, but, in order to be useful, the spectra of these radicals have to be studied at a resolution of approximately 0.01 cm -1. Consequently a laser is best used when one knows the spectrum of the target radical quite well. When sweeping the frequency of a laser [say for laser induced fluorescence (LIF), optogalvanic spectroscopy, multiphoton ionization, etc.], about the fastest one can scan is 1 cm-l/min; with signal averaging this can easily become 1 cm-1/15 min. Realizing that modern ab initio theoretical methods can find polyatomic vibrational frequencies only to about +5%, it is a difficult problem to search for unknown lines. For example, to search for the C-H stretches of the benzyl radical (C6HsCH 2) requires laser scans of [5%- (3000 cm-1) 95 min/cm -1 ] minutes, or roughly 12 hours. Fourier transform spectroscopy enables one to record spectra of mtorr samples of reactive species at a resolution of 0.005 cm -1 or better. It is possible with this technique to collect these FTS spectra over 500 cm -1 windows in the UV/VIS or 200 cm -1 windows in the IR in about 3 hours. Consequently, we believe that FTS has real advantages to study the spectroscopy of gas-phase, reactive, polyatomic molecules. We will mainly discuss studies of radicals to give an overview of this area of research. We briefly describe FT spectroscopy in the infrared and ultraviolet/visible and discuss a few of the experiments carried out in our laboratories. We compare
FTS of Radicals
159
FTIR and FTUV/VIS to other available means of studying transient species. Finally, we provide tables listing some of the species which have been studied by these means. There are several reviews of high resolution spectroscopy of transient species [3]. The reader interested in studies of unstable species by methods other than Fourier transform spectroscopy should consult these articles and the references in them.
Ii. THE MICHELSON INTERFEROMETER A N D FOURIER TRANSFORMS Most Fourier transform spectrometers are designed with Michelson interferometers [4]. This device consists of a beamsplitter, a moving mirror, a fixed mirror, a source, and a detector (Figure 1). A discussion of how it works usually begins by considering the theoretical signal at the detector as a function of the position of the moving mirror when the source is a perfectly collimated beam of monochromatic light of frequency, v, and the beamsplitter is ideal (its reflectance and transmittance are both Moving Mirror
i I I I I ! I ! I I I I
2\\
,,J
Fixed Mirror
..,,
I I I
BF
"
2rt
~ _ ~ % _ ~_- r2 + 1 2 Beamsplitter
poou
i
Collimating Mirror
r
l)etector
Figure 1. Schematic of a Michelson interferometer. The dashed lines show the paths of light which return to the source and the solid lines show the rays which propagate to the detector. The signal at the detector is the result of two light waves which have each been reflected and transmitted once by the beamsplitter. BF and BM are the respective distances of the fixed mirror and the moving mirror from the beamsplitter. Note that 5 = 2 ( B M - BF).
160
ROHRS, FROST,ELLISON,RICHARD, and VAIDA
50%). We start with the moving mirror and the fixed mirror equidistant from the beamsplitter. The light wave from the source can be expressed by, E(z) = E o exp[-2rci~z]
(1)
where (y = 1/L = v / c is wavenumber and z is the distance the beam has propagated. When this wave hits the beamsplitter it is divided in two" Ef(z) = t E o exp[-2rtRyz],
(2)
Em(Z) = r E o exp[-2rti6z]
(3)
and
Ef(z) and Em(Z) are, respectively, the waves travelling toward the fixed and the
moving mirrors and t and r are the amplitude transmission and reflection coefficients. These should not be confused with the transmittance and the reflectance. When theses waves return to the beamsplitter they will be divided again. Some of the light will propagate back toward the source and the rest to the detector. The waves which are detector bound are now, Ef(z) = r t E o exp[-2r~i6(z
+ zf)]
(4)
and Em(Z) = t r E o exp[-2rti6(z + Zm)]
(5)
where zf equals 2BF and Zm equals 2BM. Adding these waves together yields: ER(Z) = t r E o {exp[-2rcio(z + zf)] + exp[-2rti{~(z + Zm)] }
(6)
We set 8 = z m - zf and, making our independent variable 8, square this equation to get: 1(5) = 2trEo[1 + cos 2rcc~8]
(7)
We now have an equation for the intensity of the signal as a function of 8, the path difference, or retardation. We now include the dependence of E on ~ and incorporate most of the constants into a single term, I(~), to arrive at: I(~5) - 1I(~)[1 + cos(2rc~io)]
(8)
If we employ Eq. 8 and start with 5 equal to zero, l(~i) is a maximum. If the moving mirror is displaced by )d4, where )~ is the wavelength of the light, 8 = L/2, there is complete destructive interference at the beamsplitter and the signal at the detector is zero. When 5 = ~ (or n)~) we again get constructive interference at the beamsplitter and a maximum signal at the detector. Scanning the moving mirror at a constant velocity produces a time-dependent signal at the detector (Figure 2). The DC component in Eq. 8 is usually discarded to give, 1(8) - ll(G)cos(2rtSG)
(9)
o
--
0~
::r"
0
u,,
"~:r
0
0
9
---t
~
--~
0
0
~n
~o
0
~
3
::7-o
o
o
o
t--
~
_~.
~
g-
Signal
e'~t3
~t !
! ~5=0
I
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1. . . . . . .
Retardation,
Figure 3. Signal at the detector from a polychromatic source. This interferogram shows the form of the signal about a DC offset. Note the sharp "centerburst" at 5 = 0, the only point where all of the frequencies interfere constructively. This feature is the reason gain ranging is necessary in FT absorption spectroscopy.
162
163
FTS of Radicals
which is called the interferogram. If the nonideality of the experiment is now taken into account the expression becomes, 1(8) = R(t~)cos(2n:fcy)
(10)
where R(6) includes the factor of 1/2 and instrumental effects like the true beamsplitter characteristics and the detector response that modify the signal. 1(8) and R(~y) are a cosine Fourier transform (FT) pair. The same arguments as above apply to polychromatic sources. However, the interferogram will now be a sum of all the interferograms for the light at the various frequencies and it will be sharply peaked around 8 = 0 since this is the only position where all of the light interferes constructively (Figure 3). For a continuum source the FT pair is, oo
(11)
1(8) - ; R(6) cos(2rl:86)d~, --oo
and: oo
R(~) = ; 1(8) cos(2rt86)d8
(12)
-.-oo
Since the integrand in Eq. (12) is even, oo
R(6) = 2~ 1(8) cos(2rc86)d8
(13)
0
Thus, we need only take a one-sided interferogram. From Eq. 13 we can also see why spectroscopy associated with the Michelson interferometer is called Fourier transform spectroscopy. Movement of the mirror which corresponds to a change in retardation provides a signal which is a function of distance. This signal is then decoded by a Fourier transform to give a spectrum which is a function in the reciprocal space. This is why wavenumbers (cm-1) are such a convenient unit to use with this type of spectroscopy.
!il.
PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS AND NECESSARY CORRECTIONS
Equation (11) tells us that in theory we could measure the entire spectrum at an infinite resolution. This would require one to attain a retardation of infinity and to store an infinite number of points for the Fourier transform. Since this is obviously impractical, the retardation is truncated and the signal is gathered at certain discrete points. These necessary procedures have effects on the spectrum.
164
ROHRS, FROST,ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
In practice one can only scan the moving mirror a finite distance which we will call L. Thus, Eq. 6 becomes, oo
e03) = 2;I(8)A(8) cos(27tS~)d8
(14)
0
where A(8) is defined as follows: A(8) = 1 when -2L < 8 < 2L A(8) = 0 when 8 > 12LI
(15)
A(8) is called the boxcar function. This limit on the retardation leads to a limit on the resolution of 1/2L, so if L = 100 cm, the highest resolution attainable is 0.005 cm -1. By the convolution theorem, the product of two functions in one space is the same as the convolution of the Fourier transforms of the two functions in the reciprocal space. The effect of multiplying by this boxcar function is to convolve each point in the reciprocal wavenumber space with a sinc function [sinc(x) = sin(x)/x; Figure 4]. An undesirable feature of the sinc function as a lineshape is the large amplitude oscillation (the first minimum is -22% of the maximum). This ringing can make it difficult to get information about nearby peaks and leads to anomalous values for intensities. This ringing can be removed by the process known as apodization. Apodization is done by simply choosing a different form for the function A(8). Unfortunately, the sinc function has the narrowest full width at half maximum (FWHM) and choosing any other function leads to broader lineshapes; in effect, a loss of resolution. It is thus up to the spectroscopist to strike a balance between how much ringing can be tolerated and how narrow the peaks should be. Many such functions are available for these purposes. Norton and Beer have analyzed over 1000 functions, some of which fall near an empirical boundary [5]. The most useful functions fall on this boundary as they maximize resolution for a given secondary maximum or minimize the side lobe amplitude for a given linewidth. It is worthwhile to note that many popular apodization functions (such as the Happ-Genzel, or Hamming function; Figure 4) are not on this empirical boundary and their use can result in the loss of spectral information. As mentioned earlier, it is also impractical to collect data at infinitesimally spaced values of 8. Data in Fourier transform spectroscopy is usually collected at discrete steps determined by a coincident interferometer with a mode-locked helium-neon (He-Ne) laser at )~ = l/(y = 632.8 nm. The fringes of this laser are detected with a diode and sampling at every zero crossing of this line will provide data for retardation values spaced at 316.4 nm. In addition, one must insure that the mirror is moved slowly enough that the detector can relax between each sample so the data for each point is independent.
1.0--
1.0-
0.8 0.80.6 0.6F.T.
<
(----)
0.4-
~"
m"
0.4 0.2
0.2-
0.0
0.0--
-O.2 I
I
'
0.4 0.8 Retardation, 8
0.0
I
!
-20
I
-10
I
0
10
I
20
W a v e n u m b e r , (~
1.0-
().5
0.g
-
-
(.).4 -
0.6--
F.T.
.<
Ao = 0 . 9 S --- - 0 . 8 %
(}.3 o 0.2 -
0.4-
0.1
0.2-
I
0.0
0.2
I
I
I
0.4 0.6 0.8 Retardation, 8
0.0-
!
1.0
I
-20
~
q~
I
-10 0 l0 Wavenumber, o
l
20
Figure 4. Apodization functions and their Fourier transforms. The top left function is the boxcar function and its FT is the sinc function. Note the large amplitude of the secondary minimum and the narrow full width at half maximum, Ao. The bottom pair of figures show the Hamming function and its FT. The secondary oscillations are smaller but the width has grown.
165
166
ROHRS, FROST,ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
Another important detail is the number of data points taken. This is determined by the Nyquist criterion which states that the minimum sampling to unambiguously determine a spectrum is twice the frequency of the highest frequency component, or two times per wavelength of this wave. Sampling at a lower rate than this results in a phenomenon called aliasing, or foldover (Figure 5). If the interferogram were sampled twice per wavelength of the dashed wave in Figure 5, the higher frequency solid wave would be folded into the spectrum. For example, in the IR the highest frequency component will have an energy of about 4000 cm -1 (2500 nm). Sampling twice per wavelength requires that the maximum distance between samples is 1250 nm. Thus we could completely determine IR spectra by sampling once per laser wavelength. A quick calculation will show that the shortest wavelength we can uniquely specify when sampling twice per He-Ne wavelength is 632.8 nm, which corresponds to 15,803 cm -1. Obviously, spectroscopy in the UV/VIS will require that another method is employed for sampling. Discrete sampling will have little effect on the Fourier transform other than changing the integral to a series. The process can also be thought of as multiplication of the interferogram by a shah, or comb, function. Discrete sampling is a necessity for digital computer processing. In fact, if the total interferogram consists of exactly 2" points, where n is an integer, Cooley-Tukey type fast Fourier transform algorithms increase the speed of the numerical transform [6]. Since the files that are being transformed may consist of 500,000 points or more, this is very important. A problem that arises when the data is taken discretely is the determination of zero-path displacement (ZPD). How can one be sure that the first sample is taken when the mirrors of the interferometer are equidistant? In practice, the data sampling is triggered by a white light source which follows the interferometric path. At ZPD this polychromatic source has a very large peak but it dies off quickly as a function of retardation (see Figure 3). Still, due to electronic and optical factors, this centerburst is not necessarily at ~ = 0. To correct this, one takes an interferogram that is double'sided about ZPD. An algorithm then computes phase factors which correct the interferogram to make it symmetric [7]. If the phase correction is done properly it is possible to get very accurate line positions from Fourier transform spectroscopy [8]. Another problem that arises in absorption spectroscopy is the huge dynamic range of the experiment. At ZPD all of the light constructively interferes leading to a large signal at the detector. The amplification and detection must be set such that this signal does not saturate the electronic system. However, as soon as we move far away from ZPD the signal gets very weak in comparison to this centerburst. This region of the interferogram at large retardation contains the high resolution information. In order to use this data, most FT spectrometer systems employ gain ranging. The He-Ne fringes are counted, and at a certain point the gain is boosted. After the signal has been collected, this is accounted for when the interferogram is processed.
"M
,_..a
0
< %-~ ~ - ~
r,
-<
<
~
.
o
~"
"<
---7
~.
un ~," ,.~ ~
~
~ .~
c
~
~ >
~.
e e_
.<
c.
~-
-''~
~"
=,;3
e~
-~
r-
O m
r
Amplitude
x
G~,
<-________
__--.-------0-
9--------.._
__.-------0
Amplitude
168
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
The last important consideration we shall mention is collimation. There are specific relations which determine how large the aperture (see Figure 1) can be for a given resolution. In general, as the aperture gets smaller the resolution gets better since off axis rays will have to travel a greater path difference to be out of phase with the collimated radiation. The maximum beam half angle, o~, that can be passed through the interferometer without degrading the fringe contrast is related to the throughput of the interferometer. The throughput may be thought of as a function of the solid angle subtended by the source. It is also proportional to the resolving power, R = (Ymax/A(y, where Ae~ is the resolution and (Ymax is the maximum wavenumber in the spectrum. When these two expressions are combined an equation can be derived for the resolution as a function of aperture size, (Ymaxd2 A~ = ~
(16)
8F 2
where F is the focal length of the interferometer optics and d is the diameter of the aperture.
IV. ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF FOURIER TRANSFORM SPECTROSCOPY There are three well known advantages one gains by doing Fourier transform spectroscopy that are usually discussed in terms of their relationship to grating spectroscopy. They are called the Fellgett advantage, the Jacquinot advantage, and Connes accuracy. Regardless of the spectroscopic method used, the signal level generated by each spectral element, de~, is dependent on the product of the spectral intensity in dey, B(e~) (with units of W/cm-1), and the observation time [9]. In FT spectroscopy, the whole spectrum is collected at once, so that each spectral element is sampled for the whole observation time, t. Then the signal from each spectral element is proportional to: Svr <,<:B(6) t d6
(17)
In contrast, the dispersive technique samples each spectral element for only a fraction, 1/N, of the total scan time, where N is the number of spectral elements. Thus the signal for dispersive spectroscopy is proportional to: t
SDis oc n(o) ~ do
(18)
Next we must consider the different types of noise which can be present in the spectrum [2,9]. Detector noise is generally due to random fluctuations in the detector, such as thermal noise, and is therefore independent of the signal level. This type of noise is proportional to the square root of the amount of time a given
FTS of Radicals
169
spectral element is observed. This source of noise is rather small in a modern experiment. Another type of noise is photon or shot noise, due to fluctuations in the amount of photons reaching the detector. The noise is proportional to the square root of the number of photons. A third kind of noise, called source or modulation noise, can result in experiments with refractive index fluctuations such as long-path atmospheric or astronomical measurements, or when there is a design flaw in a laboratory instrument. Modulation noise is directly proportional to the signal level. Detectors which are photon noise-limited act as photon "buckets", and collect nearly all the photons emitted from the source. In the dispersive instrument, the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) is then easy to calculate. The signal from d(~ is given above, while the noise is proportional to the square root of the signal, so: t SNRDis '~ 4B((~) ~ d(~
(19)
The SNR from d(~ measured on an Fourier transform instrument is more complicated. The signal is given in Eq. 17. The noise is given by the square root of the signal, but is uniformly distributed throughout the whole spectrum, thus making the noise in d(~ dependent on all of the other spectral elements. We approximate the shot noise due to the whole spectrum as, Noise = ~/BNd(~ t
(20)
with B being the average intensity [10] in the whole spectrum. Then: B((~)d(~ t SNRzT or ~/~ Nd(~ t
(21)
The multiplex gain in the shot-noise limited case is then: Gvr / D i s
oc
4 B ( (~1 B
(22)
In the photon-noise-limited case, this distributive multiplex gain [11] is a function of the line intensities and the overall spectral structure [12]. In absorption, there is a continuous incident intensity, causing B to be large. For weak spectral lines, B(o) and B are approximately equal, so the multiplex gain is essentially 1. For strong absorption lines, the "gain" may actually be less than one. In an emission experiment, the background is very low, and therefore so is B. For strongly emitted lines, the multiplex gain can be quite significant, but for weak emission lines the gain will be small. In addition, strong emission lines will increase B and cause weaker lines to be obscured. Fellgett's, or multiplex, advantage is the result of the detector recording the signal from all of the frequency channels during the course of the entire experiment. This may be contrasted with a grating experiment where the grating and the slits only allow the signal from one channel at a time to be recorded. Of course, this means
170
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
that noise is recorded throughout the course of the experiment as well. It turns out that the important consideration here is the source of the noise in the system. Fellgett's advantage is only available when the experiment is detector noise limited. This is almost never the case as detectors, especially in the IR, have improved such that they are limited by the Johnson noise of a resistor in some amplification scheme. Jacquinot's, or etendue, or throughput advantage is not dependent on the wavelength of light one is interested in. It is the result of the Michelson interferometer processing an axisymmetric beam. In a grating instrument the slits drastically reduce the throughput of the machine. Slits are not necessary in a Fourier transform device. The entire beam can be imaged onto the detector. The gain in signal due to this advantage is usually about a factor of 200. Connes' accuracy is the result of the ability to carefully measure an accurate interferogram. If the data acquisition and phase correction is done properly it is possible to measure transitions in a species to very high accuracy. It is common to see line positions accurate to 0.0005 cm -1 or better. Accurate intensity measurements are possible as well [13]. As mentioned in the introduction, a major advantage that Fourier transform spectroscopy has over laser spectroscopy is that it is straightforward to record the entire spectrum of a species at once. Diode lasers in the infrared are not continuously tunable and have mode gaps which can only be filled by switching diodes. Many ultraviolet lasers are not continuously tunable either. Tunable difference frequency methods and diode lasers involve much longer scan times than are necessary with a Fourier transform device. For example, the Bomem DA3.002 can scan a bandwidth of 100 or more wavenumbers in the mid-IR at a resolution of 0.005 cm -1 in less than 3 minutes. A diode laser which scans in 20 MHz steps may require more than a day to scan the same spectral region. The main disadvantages of Fourier transform methods are usually discussed with reference to laser spectroscopy. A laser may be as much as 106 times more sensitive mostly due to its high photon flux. Thus, weak absorbers may be impossible to see with an FT device but it is often easy to study these species with a laser. Tb,e lines from a laser are also much narrower and so they allow one to get resolution of at least a factor of 10 better than that available with Fourier transform methods. The limit of resolution for Fourier transform techniques with commercially available spectrometers is approximately 0.001 cm -1 in the IR [14].
V. SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS IN THE INFRARED Performing an FTIR experiment requires some specialized equipment. First, a broadband radiation source is needed. Typically a SiC globar is used that reaches temperatures of 1200-1500 K. When studying species that are weak absorbers or are in low concentration a brighter source is needed and high temperature sources (>2500 K) for such experiments have been developed [ 15]. These devices are nearly
FTS of Radicals
1 71
blackbodies. A specialized beamsplitter is needed and typically C a F 2 is used from 1200 cm -1 to 4000 cm, l, KBr is used down to about 400 cm-1, and Mylar, or pellicle, beamsplitters extend to the far IR. For detectors, one uses liquid nitrogen cooled InSb down to 1850 cm -1, liquid nitrogen cooled HgCdTe, liquid helium cooled CuGe, or liquid helium cooled SiB down to about 400 crn-1, and bolometers for lower energy measurements. As mentioned above, modern detectors are usually not the noise-determining part of the experiment. It should be possible to set up any Fourier transform experiment in the IR such that it is limited by the background photon flux or photon noise. When using the Bomem DA3.002 in the IR at the highest energy (4000 cm -1) at a resolution of 0.004 cm-1, with F = 325 mm, Eq. 16 indicates that the largest the aperture can be is about 0.6 mm or a lack of collimation will degrade the resolution. This is easily accomplished. A problem that arises when taking IR spectra in the laboratory is the presence of atmospheric absorbers, notably H20 and CO 2. To remove these species from the experiment one must either evacuate the entire interferometer or purge it with a suitable gas. When evacuating, very low pressures (10-4 Torr) will be required for high resolution work since the path length for absorption is quite long. Unless the system is specifically designed for evacuation, such an approach is likely to be difficult. The advantage of purging is that it will tend to pressure broaden atmospheric transitions making them readily discernible if they appear in the spectrum. The disadvantage of purging is that it is very difficult to remove all of the unwanted molecules unless one resorts to a continuous (24 hours/day, 7 days/week) purge.
VI. SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS IN THE VISIBLE AND ULTRAVIOLET The principle components of a FT spectrometer that are different in the UV/VIS as compared to the IR include light sources, beamsplitters, and detectors. For operation in the visible region (up to 25,000 cm-1), a quartz halogen lamp is typically used. The advantages of this lamp are its very continuous, flat spectrum and its stable output. At the shorter visible wavelengths and in the near-UV, we use a high-pressure, 75 W xenon arc lamp. Xe lamps are an order of magnitude more intense than quartz halogen sources at about 30,000 cm -1, but arc lamps are also much noisier. An alternative source for the UV is a deuterium arc lamp, which is more stable than Xe but is one to two orders of magnitude less intense below 40,000 cm -~. A quartz beamsplitter with the appropriate coatings can be used throughout the visible and the near- and mid-UV, up to at least 45,000 cm -1. A silicon photodiode detector is used for the visible and near-UV to about 30,000 cm -1, and a SbCs cathode photomultiplier tube (PMT) covers higher energy regions. Both of these detectors have high quantum efficiencies, so that the detection becomes short-noise limited. The various types of noise will be discussed below. The high gain characteristics of the PMT make it the optimum detector for low light level
0
f ....
0
i
0 r 0
0 .,..,
_,...
i
Il
"7"
0
0
.....
~l!su01ui
o
.o
O
o
O
O
00
_o o
_ o o
r
_o o
o
m O
E
O
r
o E Eo
O
~
53
~
~"G
N
E ~-
U
o u
r- c0 - ~ o~ ~
r
r
o
~._~
c~0 o ~
14...
FTS of Radicals
1 73
conditions, which include weak emission from radicals produced in a discharge source. For visible and near-UV absorption spectroscopy, the lower gain Si photodiode and high brightness Xe lamp are well matched. It should be possible to conduct a UV/VIS experiment such that it is photon-noise limited. An important consideration upon going to higher energy is the effect of imperfect collimation of the source. The lack of perfect collimation, or finite aperture size, has a much larger effect as the frequency of the light increases. For example, the smallest aperture diameter we normally use in the UV/VIS is 0.6 mm. The focal length of the collimating mirror is 325 mm. Then the highest resolution that can be achieved at an energy of 30,000 cm-1 is 0.026 cm-1. Another important difference in FT operation between the IR and UV/VIS is the sampling rate of the interferogram. As was mentioned earlier, the proper sampling rate in the IR is insured by sampling twice per He-Ne cycle. The shortest wavelength that can be uniquely specified with this rate is 632.8 nm. In order to operate in the UV/VIS, the sampling rate must be increased. Bomem DA3 spectrometers use successive interpolation [16] to decrease the size of the sampling interval beyond just every zero crossing. Because the He-Ne interferogram has very precise zero crossings as a function of mirror displacement, the interval between two adjacent zero crossings can be subdivided into four equally spaced subintervals. Figure 6 will help to explain the technique used. After the white light ZPD triggers, the first mirror displacement region between the first and second zero crossings (Region 1) is divided into four equally spaced intervals. These interpolated subintervals are then used as data sampling intervals between the second and third zero crossings (Region 2). After the data is sampled in Region 2, this region is subdivided into four intervals. These subintervals are used in Region 3, and the process repeats. This method is highly precise because the interpolations are done with the known zero crossings rather than an external, uncorrelated triggering device. With successive interpolation, there are a total of eight digital sampling points for every complete cycle of the He-Ne waveform. The Nyquist condition then allows the maximum optical frequency that can be transformed without spectral aliasing to increase to about 63,200 cm -1. This frequency corresponds to a minimum optical wavelength of 158 nm, in theory allowing operation into the vacuum UV region of the spectrum.
VII. ADVANTAGES AND SOME DETAILS OF JET SPECTROSCOPY A problem with high resolution spectroscopy is the analysis of the enormous amounts of very complicated data FT spectrometers can produce. If the spectrum is taken at or above room temperature many rotational states of the radical will be populated and a huge number of transitions will be seen (Figure 7). One means of simplifying the spectrum is to cool the species that is being studied. A very useful way of accomplishing this is to seed the target radical in a supersonic expansion of
174
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
1.2
CF 3 Radical expand
.,..4
.-*1I.-0.8
0 . ,...,
o
0.4
<
1200
1220
1240
1260
1280
1300
Absorption Frequency (cm-i)
1.0
CF 3 Radical
0.8
FTIR apodized resolution 0.004 cm
_ .,..,
0.6 g 0.4 <
0.2 J
i
1269.6
1269.8
1270.0
270.2
1270.4
Absorption Frequency (cm 1)
Figure 7.
Room temperature absorption spectrum of CF3. The top shows a broad region while the bottom shows a small portion of the spectrum demonstrating how congested room temperature spectra can be.
a neutral carrier gas or even by itself. One can attain very low temperatures in a jet, even below 1 K For example, if one observes CO at room temperature and sees about 60 transitions, at 20 K with the same spectroscopic setup, only about 15 transitions will be observed (Figure 8). When the species being studied is not well characterized such cooling can make it much easier to assign the spectrum. A supersonic expansion is achieved by expanding gas through a nozzle from a high pressure volume into a low-pressure volume [17]. The pressure drop is maintained by having the gas expand through a small orifice and having adequate
.,.~ t/l
..a
! 20(X)
II
....... ,,,Jl !
2050
Ill,, ..... I
2150
21 O0
Wavenumber,
22())
2250
c~
t~
1
I
I
I
2000
2050
21 O0
2150 Wavenumber, (~
.
!
I
2200
2250
Figure & Spectra of CO calculated from the rigid rotor-harmonic oscillator approximation. The top spectrum is CO at 298 K. The bottom is CO at 20 K. This reduction in lines will be very important for simplifying the analysis in larger, more complicated species.
175
176
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
pumping (e.g., Roots pump or diffusion pump) on the low-pressure side. The gas expands out of the high-pressure region into a collisionless envelope in the low-pressure region. During this expansion process the molecule is collisionally cooled, especially its rotational degrees of freedom. The nozzle geometry can have an effect on jet experiments [18] and the nozzle configurations used by the authors will be discussed below.
VIii. MAKING RADICALS FOR SPECTROSCOPY There are several ways to generate radicals for use in spectroscopic studies. We discuss four of them: controlled chemical reaction, discharge sources, pyrolysis, and photolysis. Using a controlled chemical reaction to make the transient species has been used most effectively by flow tube chemists. The application of this technique to high resolution IR spectroscopy by experimenters at NOAA in Boulder has proven to be very fruitful (Figure 9). In this technique a precursor is metered into a flow tube fitted with White cell optics [19]. At various places along this flow tube reactants are bled in. For example, fluorine atoms generated in a microwave discharge may be added to react with ammonia to generate the NH 2 radical. It is possible to conduct multiple reactions in this way to generate the target species, and much of the chemistry involved in these gas phase reactions is well documented. A necessary complication of these experiments is that the other reaction products can absorb or emit in the sample. Discharge sources have long been used to generate unstable species. Bernath and co-workers have used hollow cathode discharges and other discharge sources to generate unstable species (e.g., see Table 1, ref. 30). This technique is well suited to emission studies as the transient species one generates are often very hot. Engelking's group made use of a corona discharge supersonic expansion to generate radicals [20], and Richard et al. have successfully coupled this source to a Fourier transform ultraviolet experiment [21]. In the past pyrolysis has been avoided because the temperatures involved usually preclude emission and the technique usually made a large number of products. It was not a selective technique. However, the pioneering work of Chen et al. has demonstrated that it is possible to employ flash pyrolysis to generate unstable species in high enough concentrations to make spectroscopy viable [22]. This technique involves heating small ceramic tubes such as alumina, zirconia, or silicon carbide to a very high temperature (>1000 K). When this tube is used as a supersonic expansion source, the residence time in the hot nozzle can be adjusted such that a precursor seeded in an inert cartier gas has sufficient time to decompose but not enough time to undergo significant recombination before it passes into the relatively collisionless environment of the supersonic expansion. Typical residence times in the nozzle are on the order of 100 las while the half-life for radical recombinations is on the order of 1 ms.
.......
__
geamsplitter
Dynamicall Aligned Fixed / Mirror /
/
Moving
Mirror
~
!
FOURIER
L H i g h Precision
TRANSFORM
//2[
/
////
[Aperture
Source Compartment '-
I I I J / ~
i --
Filter Wheel Flush Gas I ~ ~ [ [Source/Reactor[ I I J, i . ,
Transfer
Temperature Regulated Jacket .
Flush Gas / Pump f " . 9. t r - ~ Windows I ~ I ! I I /
~
D 2 Lamp LI
Spectrometer
"
Array Sample~m e Compar ent
,--I
Detector
__
I
L
- T I- ~
~
\x'~\Mirror ........ -. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Multipass Absorption Cell
Nesting
/~]
//r
OMirrors Computer
Figure 9. Schematic of flow tube coupled to FT spectrometer. This shows the apparatus used in flow tube studies at NOAA in Boulder, Colorado by Dr. C. J. Howard and co-workers.
1 78
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
~k~ lightbeam
.
.
.
~
100mTorr backgroundpressure
. ntacts
~ @ ~
/ ~- Stainlesssteel
ozze
Variac y
t .. i'--~---
Ballastresistor
1atmosphereofcarriergaswithseededprecursor Figure 10.
SiC nozzle for pyrolysis. The idea behind this radical source is the short residence time of the radical precursor in the heated portion of the nozzle. The hot length is varied so that the parent molecule undergoes e,lough collisions to dissociate before it expands from the throat of the nozzle. However, the precursor is not in the heated portion long enough for significant recombination to occur.
A drawing of a silicon carbide nozzle is shown in Figure 10. An advantage of using ZrO 2 tubes is that this material has a negative coefficient of resistance. The hotter it gets the more current it draws. If the tube is placed in series with a ballast resistor having a positive coefficient of resistance (a light bulb with a tungsten filament) the nozzle will be self-regulating. The advantage of zirconia is that it can achieve a higher temperature (about 2300 K) and can handle oxidizing species. SiC has this same resistive property as ZrO 2 and it is mechanically stronger, but it only can be heated to about 1800 K. Photolysis is a selective way to make radicals from a suitable precursor. It is very clean and particularly useful in emission experiments. The energy required to photolyze a precursor is typically about 6 electron volts. This means that photolysis sources will be pulsed lasers or resonance lamps. Lasers such as XeC1 (~ = 308 nm) or ArF (~ = 193 nm) with pulse widths of about 10 ns and repetition rates of around 100 Hz will thus make transients species in short bursts. It is a difficult task to couple such a system to a Fourier transform spectrometer but it has been done in a dynamics study [23]. Resonance lamps, while providing the appropriate energy, usually do not provide the flux necessary to generate the high concentrations of unstable species needed for a successful spectroscopy experiment [24].
FTS of Radicals
1 79
IX. FOURIER TRANSFORM ABSORPTION SPECTROSCOPY FOR THE STUDY OF PHOTOREACTIVE RADICALS With the appropriate changes of sources, optics and detectors, the FT spectrometer can be used to obtain absorption spectra in the IR, visible, and UV (20 gm to 200 nm). Our current apparatus allows for a resolution of 0.004 cm -1 in the IR and 0.03 cm -1 in the UV/VIS. Thus, it is possible to investigate and characterize the ground and excited states of a molecule. Supersonic expansions allow the preparation of reactive species in a collision-free environment. Inhomogeneous effects including Doppler broadening, rotational congestion, and cluster-induced spectral perturbations can be minimized with the proper choice of the expansion conditions. Therefore, the combination of FT absorption spectroscopy with a supersonic expansion is an excellent method for the study of photoreactive molecules in a very well-controlled environment. In particular, FTIR is a powerful diagnostic probe for characterizing the expansion, such as the rotational temperature [25] and degree of cluster formation [26]. With FT spectroscopy in the UV/VIS, excited electronic states can be studied, and the dynamics of photoreactions on these excited states can be derived from the homogenous linewidths. These abilities become invaluable for the study of photoreactive excited states where the lifetimes are generally too short to obtain this information accurately using other spectroscopic methods. There are many advantages to using direct absorption spectroscopy to study photoreactive systems. Although the technique suffers from an inherent lack of sensitivity, the information that can be obtained for cases where emission and multiphoton ionization (MPI) techniques are inefficient can be invaluable. This generally applies to photoreactive systems where short excited state lifetimes preclude the use of such indirect techniques [2 7]. A good example of such a situation is the near-UV electronic transition of OC10, in which the excited state dissociates rapidly [28a, b,c]. Emission is observed from the low-energy, near-origin levels, but as the photochemistry becomes more efficient at increasing energy, emission yields and up-pumping rates make emission and MPI signals negligible. Direct absorption spectroscopy proves to be an excellent method for investigating the excited-state structure and reaction dynamics in the higher energy part of the transition. Previous direct absorption free jet experiments in our laboratory and others have had to rely on phase sensitive detection [3c]. The light levels detected are generally low as a result of the spectral dispersion and slit discrimination. For this reason, the operational resolution achievable has been limited (typically >10 cm-1). This constraint therefore limits the types of systems which can be studied to those involving excited-state lifetimes short enough to give homogeneous linewidths larger than the instrumental resolution. However, this situation is not the case for interferometric detection where an increase in resolution does not produce a corresponding decrease in optical throughput. Using FT spectroscopy, strong absorbing systems can be studied under very dilute expansion conditions which
180
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
minimize inhomogeneous effects. Additionally, much weaker absorbers can be studied under high resolution.
Xo FOURIER TRANSFORM INFRARED SPECTROSCOPY OF
JET-COOLED RADICALS
Table 1 lists many of the short-lived species detected in the gas phase with Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. Two prominent groups are those headed by Bernath, now at the University of Waterloo, and by Howard at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). The former group has used IR emission to study unstable diatomics produced in discharge sources or furnaces. The molecules studied in this group tend to be of astrophysical interest. The research team at NOAA mainly studies short-lived molecules of atmospheric significance. They employ a long flow tube fitted with White cell optics and coupled to a Bomem DA3.002 spectrometer. They usually make the transient they are interested in by performing a carefully controlled series of chemical reactions. A recent experiment may provide a general technique for observing jet-cooled radicals [29]. A schematic of the apparatus is shown in Figure 11. The experiment is centered around a Bomem DA3.002 high resolution Fourier transform spectrometer. For the IR experiments an internal SiC globar source is used with a CaF2 beamsplitter and a liquid nitrogen cooled InSb detector. With the exception of the vacuum chamber the entire apparatus is purged with nitrogen. The light from the interferometer is focused into a vacuum chamber downstream from the throat of a nozzle in a supersonically expanded molecular beam. The vacuum chamber is pumped by a Kinney Roots pump (800 L/s @ 0.1 torr). A suitable precursor is seeded into 1-2 atmospheres of an inert gas before it passes through a SiC nozzle heated to > 1000K and expands into a vacuum of about 0.10 torr. The idea is to decompose this precursor into the species of interest while it is in the heated portion of the nozzle and then have the short-lived molecule expand into the vacuum before it undergoes significant recombination. A question might arise as to whether or not a hot nozzle will give rise to cold molecules. The top spectrum in Figure 12 shows the high resolution (0.005 cm -1) spectrum of jet-cooled NO. This spectrum was recorded with a sample mixture of 10% NO in He passed through a room temperature 1 mm ID SiC capillary nozzle at ambient temperature. Data for only one interferogram was recorded. The stagnation, or backing pressure was about 700 torr and the background pressure in the vacuum chamber was 40 m torr. There are two spin-orbit states for NO, 21-I1/'2, and 2I-I3/2. The 21-13/2state is 121.1 cm -1 above the ground state 21-I1/2 and it has been frozen out of the cold part of the spectrum. The higher temperature rotational distributions in the spectrum derive from NO outside the jet expansion (but still in the vacuum chamber) at about 270 K. The cold part of the spectrum is at 9 K. The bottom spectrum in Figure 12 shows a spectrum from the same experimental
Table 1. Species Studied by FTIR Transient Species AIC1 AlF AIH BaC1 BaH Bill Bill BiF BiCI BiBr BiI BH arO Can C2 C2 CC1 CH CH CN CN CP CP CS Cs2 Cs2 Cs2 Cs2 CIO CIO CrO CoO
Cull FO FO FeO Gall GaF He2 InF IF Li2 Li2 Li2
Transition
Spect. Method Synth. Method
xl~ + X1Z+ X1Z+ C2FI1/2 - A'2A3/2 X2Z+ X 0+ A l-X0 + X2 l-X10 + X2 l-X10 + X2 l-X10 + X2 l-X10 + X1Z+ X2FI3/2 X2Z+ A 1Flu - X1Z~ B 1Ag-X1Z~,B'E~-A 1Flu X2H3/2, 2H1/2 A 2A-X2H, B 2Z--A Ill X 2FI A 2FI-X 2Z+ A- X A 2Hi-X2Z+ A 2Hi-X2Z+ X 1Z+ 1Z+__lH E lv-~ In g E D 1Eu+,C,..,u-~g 1Flu-(1) 3]~ D 1Eu+-(2)1E~ X 2H3/2, 2FI1/2 X 2FI3/2,2FI1/2 A 5E-X 5FI A 4I-li-X 4Ai X 1~21-13/2, 2FI1/2 2FI3/,2, 21-I1/2 X 5Ai X 1E+ X X X 1Z1 1Ag-B 1Flu c lFlu-1 1Fig, 2 1Z+-I 2 1Z+-2 1Z~ lHg
181
FTE FTE FTE FTLIF FTE FTE FTLIF FTCIF FTCIF FTCIF FTCIF FTE FTA, WC FTE FTE FTE FTA, WC FTE FTE FTLIF FTE FTE FTE FTA, WC
TF HCD TF TF TF TF MD,TF FR FR FR FR MD FR TF MD MD FR CO MD MD CDNE MD MD FR
FTLIF FTLIF FTLIF FTLIF FTA, WC FTA, WC FTE FTE FTE FTE FTA, WC FTE FTE FTE FTE FTE FTE FTLIF FTLIF FTLIF
TF TF TF TF FR FR MD HCD CLR FR MD TF TF TF FI TF TF TF
Ref 1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
44 44 44 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 4O 41 (continued)
Table 1. (continued) Transient Species Li2 NiO NH NH NS NaLi Na2 Na2 OH OH PH PtH PtO Rb2 ScN SiC SiC Sill Sill SiS SH SO Tell TeF TeCI TeBr Tel XeH BO2 C2H C3 C3 CF2 CF2 FO2 HCO HNC HNO HNO HNSi HO2 NH2
Transition + 1Eg+ 2 1Eu-2
Spect. Method Synth. Method
A 3FIi-X3]~X 3EX 3y7 X 2H 3 1Z+ ( C ) - 2 lz+ (A) many (1) 1Ag-B(I ) 1Hu X21-I X 21-I X 3Zf~'= 1.5- Xf~- 1.5 A' 31-I- X 3EA 1E+ - X 1Zg+ A IE+ - X 1Z+ d 1Z+ - b 1H A 3Z- - X 3I-I X21-I X2FI X 1E+ X2FI X 3Z-, a 1A X2 21-I1/2- X1 2I-I3/2 X2 2I-I1/2-X1 21-I3/2 X2 21-I1/2- X1 2I-I3/2 X2 2I-I1/2- XI 2I-I3/2 X2 21-I1/2 - XI 21-I3/2 C 21-I-B 2E+,D 2Z+-C 2I-I X 2Fig; Vl, v3 v3 b 31-Ig- ~3Flg Vl, v3 Vl vl, v2, v3 v3 Vl, v2, v3 Vl v l, v2 v! v2, v3 Vl, v2, v3
1/3 2
FTLIF FTE FTE, WC FTE, WC FTA, WC FTCIF FTLIF FTLIF FTE FTE, FTA, WC FTE FTE FTE FTLIF FTE FTE FTE FTE, WC FTE, NYC FTE FTE, NYC FTA, WC FTE FTE FTE FTE FTE FTE FTA, WC FTE FTE FTE FTA, WC FTA, WC FTA, WC FFA, WC FTA, WC FTE FTE FTE, WC FFA, WC FTA, FTE, WC
TF HCD RFD RFD FR TF
F1 CLR, FR MD HCD TF HCD HCD HCD RFD RFD TF RFD FR MD, FR MD, FR MD, FR MD, FR MD, FR HCD FR RFD SE MD FR FR FR FR FR RFD MD, FR RFD FR FR
Ref 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 100 100 100 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79
(continued)
183
FTS of Radicals Table 1. (continued) Transient Species
Transition
Spect. Method Synth. Method
Ref
NH2
v2
FTA, W C
FR
N3
v3
FTA, W C
FR
81
Vl, v2, v3
FTA
FR
82
BH3
v3
FI'A, W C
ED
83
NO3
many
FTA, W C
MD, FR
84
CH2NH
v5, v6
FTA, W C
P
85
v3
FTA, W C
MD
86
CH3CP
Vl, v2, v3, v5, v6, v7
FTA
P
87
CH2CS
Vl, v2, v3, v4, v7, v8
FI'A, W C
P
88
v3
FTE
SE
89
FCP
C3H2
C5
80
Notes: Species are arranged first by the number of atoms they contain and then alphabetically. The first column lists the short-lived molecule of interest, the second lists the transition, the third lists the spectroscopic method, the fourth lists the synthetic method used to produce the species, and the last column lists the reference. Abbreviations: CD = Cossart discharge. CDNE = Corona discharge nozzle expansion. CLR ED
= Chemiluminescence reactor. = Electric discharge.
F1
= Flame.
FR = Flow reactor. FTA = Fourier transform absorption. FFCIF = Fourier transform detection of collision induced fluorescence. FTE
= Fourier transform emission.
FI'LIF = Fourier transform detection of laser induced fluorescence. HCD
= Hollow cathode discharge.
MD P RFD
- Microwave discharge. = Pyrolysis. = Radiofrequency discharge.
SE TF WC
= Stellar emission. = Tube furnace. = White cell.
arrangement except that the SiC nozzle was heated to 1520 K. The spectrum is very similar but the temperatures are slightly different. The higher temperature distribution is about 310 K and the cold part is at 11 K. This demonstrates the viability of hot nozzles for cold expansions. Figure 13 shows two more spectra of NO. These were obtained by pyrolyzing ethyl nitrite seeded into a beam of He: a CH3CHzO-NO --~ CH3CH20 + NO
(23)
184
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
BOMEM DA3.002 F'F Spectrometer
III
0.004 cr~ resolution
125 cm mirrortravel I
I
Zeta 8 Plotter IVectorProcessor]
r
/
[
Pump LS~mLiL/)
~,'"-~'"
h
-
~2,-~-~ -] ~Detector
:i_~p'
/
P~or
[Power
CGr~er]
BackingPump--] Figure 11. Schematic of FT spectrometer used for both infrared and ultraviolet work. This shows the configuration of the Bomem DA3.002 used by the authors at the University of Colorado.
The temperature of the nozzle was approximately 1400 K. The rotational temperature of the 21-I1/2state in the cooled portion of both of these spectra is about 60 K, a number obtained by analysis of the R branch of the spectra. It is apparent that there are several temperature distributions in these experiments. This is mostly due to heating of the background gas by convection. The top spectrum was collected at a resolution of 0.1 cm-1 and the bottom spectrum at 0.01 cm-l, both in less than 1 hour. Our ability to detect this jet cooled absorption spectrum of an unstable species made by the pyrolysis of a suitable precursor is very promising. It demonstrates that it is possible to get enough decomposition to observe reactive intermediates. It should be possible to make a variety of precursors that will thermally decompose to produce interesting radicals. If these radicals have cross sections comparable to NO we should be able to observe their jet-cooled spectra.
1."1 m
1.0
J
"~ 0.9
IC~
0.8
]
[Try,----1o r, I 0.7
I
1880
1860
I
r
1900
1920
Wavenumber,
1.1-
1.0
"~ 0 . 9 t~
r ~
1940
c
[SiC nozzle at 1520 K]
[
II rT1] lr '
l
[Tro4~ NO ] Room Temp.
0.8Cold NO rot =- 10
0.71860
.... [ K] I
1880
I
1900 Wavenumber,
I
I
1920
1940
o
Figure 12. Spectra of NO in jet. The top spectrum shows 10% NO coexpanded in helium through a 1 mm ID SiC nozzle at ambient temperature. P = P branch, Q= Q branch, R = R branch and H20 signifies peaks due to water. The bottom shows NO passed through the same nozzle at high temperature. See text for more detail.
185
1 86
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA 1.000
[CH CH3CH20-NO Pyrolysis]
-
r I
0.995
0.990
~ 0.985
0.980
0.975
i 1840
I
1860
I
1880
I
1900
i
1920
I
1940
Wavenumber, a 1.09
-
1.08
"~ 1.07
i 1.06
1.05
-
I
I
1840
1860
I
I
1880 1900 Wavenumber, c
I
I
1920
1940
Figure 13. Spectrum of NO in jet. This shows the spectrum of NO obtained by
pyrolyzing CH3CH2ONO in a 1.0 mm ID SiC nozzle at about 1400 K. The top spectrum was taken at a resolution of 0.1 cm -1 and the bottom spectrum at 0.01 cm - 1
XI. VISIBLE AND ULTRAVIOLET FOURIER TRANSFORM SPECTROSCOPY OF REACTIVE SPECIES Recently there have been many studies of reactive molecules making use of FT spectroscopy in the UV/VIS (see Table 2). FT emission spectra have successfully characterized the electronic states of many radicals and other reactive species Produced in a variety of sources. Other workers have used FT emission and FT
FTS of Radicals
187
UV/VIS detection coupled with laser-induced fluorescence in similar studies. Table 2 highlights some of the work using these techniques.
A. Spectroscopy of OCIO The FT direct absorption spectra [28] of OC10 provide an example of the capabilities of FT spectroscopy in the visible and ultraviolet regions for the study of short-lived species. In Figure 14, part of the near-UV absorption spectrum is Table 2. SpeciesStudied by UV/VIS FT Methods Transient Species BC BH CC1 CCN CCN CH3N CHaN CN CN CN CN CS Cu2 CuD Li2 MgH NCO NH NH OC10 TiO ZnD
Transition
Spect. Method
Synth. Method
Ref
B4Z- - X4Z A1H-X1Z + A2A - X2H ,~2A- X 2I-I ,a,2A- X 2H , ~ 3 E - X 3A2 ~ , 3 E - X 3A2 B2E + - X2Z + B2E + - X2Z + A2Hi - X2Z + A2Hi, B2E + - X2E + d3Ai- a3Flr B 1 Zu+ - X1Z+ AlE + X1Z ~ 13Ag - b3Flu A2H X2Z + ,~2E+- X 2I-Ii A3FI - X3Z c 1FI - a 1A ,~2A2- X 2B1 C3A, B3H - X3A A2FI - X2Z +
FTE FTE FTE FTLIF FTE FTE FFE FTE FTE FTE FTE FTE FTE FFE FTCIF FTE FTE, FTLIF FTE FTE FTA FTLIF FTE
HCD HCD CONE MD CDNE CDNE CONE CDNE, CD CONE CONE CDNE ED HCD HCD TF HCD RFD HCD HCD FR HCD HCD
90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 21 98 54 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 28a,b,c 107 108
Notes." The first column lists the short-lived molecule of interest, the second lists the transition, the third lists the spectroscopic method, the fourth lists the synthetic method used to produce the species, and the last column lists the reference. Abbreviations: CD = Cossart discharge. CONE = Corona discharge nozzle expansion. ED = Electric discharge. FR = Flow reactor. FrA = Fourier transform absorption. FTCIF = Fourier transform detection of collision induced fluorescence. FrE = Fourier transform emission. FTLIF = Fourier transform detection of laser induced fluorescence. HCD = Hollow cathode discharge. MD = Microwave discharge. RFD = Radiofrequency discharge. TF = Tube furnace.
188
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
Room Temperature
Jet=cooled
.
.
.
i
.
2413(1(I
.
.
~
.
.
.
.
1
,
25000 26~ 27000 Energy / cm-1
,
,
i
,
,
.
280(10
Figure 14. Comparison of direct absorption spectra ofthe ~, <-- ~ transition of OCIO. The top spectrum was measured at room temperature and the bottom spectrum was measured under jet-cooled conditions. shown under both room temperature and jet-cooled conditions. The expansion conditions used in the jet-cooled spectrum are 3% OC10 in helium with a total pressure of 1.5 atm. These conditions were chosen because they achieved the greatest rotational cooling, resulting in narrower vibronic bandwidths. Also, no vibrational hot bands were detected under these conditions. That direct absorption spectra with high signal-to-noise can be obtained with such dilute expansions demonstrates the superior sensitivity of the FTUV technique as compared to a conventional dispersive method. Based on the OC10 A +--X absorption cross section of about 3000 L mo1-1 cm -1, we calculated [28a] that the FTUV method ha s 15 times better sensitivity and three orders of magnitude higher resolution than our best dispersive absorption, supersonic jet technique [3c],. To date, systems with absorptivities as low as 8 -- 200 L mo1-1 cm -~ have been studied with FT spectroscopy in a free jet expansion with reasonable signal-to-noise at spectral resolutions as low as 0.1 cm -1.
189
FTS of Radicals
1~)
3
4
v 2 lo3 0 2 1~)2~ 3 102~30~ -
_
I
23oo0
1
5
3
6 4
4
7 5
5
8 6
6
7 7
8
_
I
240o0
,
1
250oo
~
I
260oo
I.
I
270oo
Energy / cm-1
Figure 15. Expanded portion of the jet-cooled spectrum of OCIO with vibrational assignments.
Three excited states of chlorine dioxide, 2A2, 2B2, and 2A 1, are located at about 2.5 eV in the near UV. Electronic dipole selection rules predict that the transition into the 2B 2 state is dipole forbidden, while the other two transitions are allowed. Experimentally, the observed transition is the parallel polarized .A (2A2) ~ ]~(2B1). The perpendicularly polarized (2A1) <----]~ (2B l) transition should be weaker and has not been observed experimentally. The most intense progression in the near UV spectrum, shown in Figure 15. is caused by excitation of the symmetric stretch (Vl). Combinations involving v 1 and the bend (v2) and even quanta of the asymmetric stretch (v 3) are also seen. The splitting in each vibronic band is due to the O35C10 and O37C10 isotopomers. There has been some question about the assignment of the progressions involving the asymmetric stretch [30]. The measurements performed with FT spectroscopy in our laboratory allowed a reinterpretation of these progressions. The conditions of the expansion and the high resolution of the FT technique allowed an examination of the rotational structure of several bands. Rotational band contours could be modeled with an asymmetric rotor program, and this served as a method for determining both the rotational temperatures achieved in the expansion and structural parameters of the various electronic states. As shown in Figures 16 and 17, under quite dilute conditions the rotational temperature derived from a Boltzmann fit to the (5,0,0) band was 30 K, while for neat expansions of OC10, the temperature determined from this fit yielded a rotational temperature of 80 K. High resolution spectra, such as those in Figure 18, were used to revise the excited state
190
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
structure [28b, c]. The geometries of the 2B 1 electronic ground state and the 2A2 excited state are somewhat different. In the 2B~ state the angle is 117.6 ~ and closes to 107 ~ in the 2A2 state, while the bond length increases from 1.47 to 1.63 A. Note that because of the rotational cooling afforded by the jet, the individual isotopic bands could be evaluated separately. Due to the jet cooling of the spectrum, the rotational congestion of the vibronic bands was greatly reduced from that in the room temperature spectrum. The rotational cooling caused the two isotopic components of each vibronic band to become distinct (see Figure 15), and sharp bandheads for each isotopomer resulted (see Figures 16 and 17). Thus one benefit of the rotational cooling was accurate relative vibronic band positions. In addition, in FTS the entire spectrum is measured at once, which insures correct relative intensities. As a result, relative vibronic band areas, and therefore relative band intensities, can be accurately measured. Correct Calculation
Expedment
Energy / cm-t
Figure 16. A 0.5 cm -1 resolution spectrum of the (5,0,0) band. The top spectrum is calculated from an asymmetric rotor program with a Boltzmann rotational temperature of 30 K. The bottom spectrum is from an experiment with expansion conditions of 3% OCIO in 1.5 atm of helium.
FTS of Radicals
191 Calculation
Experiment
24380
24420 24~ Energy / cm-1
24500
Figure 17'. A 0.5 cm -1 resolution spectrum of the (5,0,0) band. The top spectrum is calculated with a Boltzmann rotational temperature of 80 K. The bottom spectrum is from an experiment with expansion conditions of 200 torr of neat OCIO.
relative vibronic band positions and intensities are necessary for the calculation of electronic potential surfaces. The vibronic bands give information about the structure of the excited electronic state relative to that of the ground state via a Franck--Condon analysis. Due to the activity in all of the vibrational modes, and the fact that the most intense vibronic bands involve many quanta of the symmetric stretch, it can be deduced that the bond lengths and bond angle in the 2A2 excited state are significantly different than those of the 2B 1 ground state. Along with a consideration of the electronic promotion occurring in the ,~(2A2) ~ X(2B1) transition, the vibronic analysis indicates that the bond length is larger and the bond angle is smaller in the excited state relative to the ground state. These observations of the vibronic bands confirm the results of the structural determination based on a rotational analysis. The spectra can further be interpreted to describe the excited-state dynamics [28b, d] The advantage of our cold molecular jet experiment is that inhomogeneous effects are minimized. In absorption, all lines are lifetime broadened because of the efficient photochemistry of OC10. The magnitude of this broadening does not depend on the rotational quantum numbers, but is strongly dependent on the
192
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA Experiment
Calculation
24470
24480
24490
Energy / cm- 1
Figure 18. The top spectrum shows part of the (5,0,0) band for the O35CIO isotopomer, measured at high resolution (0.05 cm -1) under expansion conditions of 10% OCIO in 1 atm of helium. The bottom spectrum is from a 100 K Boltzmann rotational temperature calculation. The experimental rotational linewidth is consistent with a 0.28 cm -1 width calculated Lorentzian lineshape.
vibrational quantum numbers. The lifetime of the A (2A2)excited state is estimated from the spectral linewidths to range from 20 picoseconds to several hundred femtoseconds. The rotational linewidths for the corresponding combination bands of v 1 with the bending mode v 2 and the asymmetric stretch v 3 are always much larger than those of v 1 alone. Based on this result, both v 2 and v 3 are thought to serve as promoting modes for the UV photochemistry of OC10. The bending mode in the A(2A2) state may be especially important [31] in bringing the oxygen atoms closer together, possibly resulting in the formation of C1OO and ultimately the production of CI and O 2. Indeed, the spectroscopic results were confirmed by photofragment studies [32] and ab initio calculations [31,33] showing that two photoreactions occur when OC10 is excited in the near-UV:
FTS of Radicals
193
(24)
OCIO + hv --->CIO + 0 ~ CI + 0 2
B. Spectroscopy of CN An example of an alternative use of FT technology in the UV/VIS is our work on the X2E- ~ B2E§ emission spectrum of jet-cooled CN [21]. These experiments were made possible by the development of the corona-excited supersonic expansion source by Engelking [20]. The Engelking source creates radicals in a continuous discharge, followed by immediate cooling in the expansion. Ahigh number density of rotationally and translationally cold radicals in excited electronic and vibrational states is produced. As a result, excited vibronic states of reactive species can be studied with a minimum of rotational congestion. This source works extremely well in combination with a FT spectrometer: the continuous, high-density production of rotationally cold radicals is matched with the high resolution and sensitivity of the spectrometer. This setup avoids the problems with timing and electronic noise that often occur in pulsed radical experiments. The entire spectrum is measured at one time, eliminating the need for precise control over radical production conditions such as flow rates. The X ~ B emission spectrum of CN measured at 0.25 cm -1 resolution is shown in Figure 19. The CN radical in its B state was produced by coexpanding 100 torr of acetonitrile (CH3CN) with 1 atm of helium in the corona discharge source. The spectrum includes both the 0-0 and 1-1 transitions. An analysis of the rotational distributions in both the v' = 0 and 1 levels revealed a Boltzmann temperature of
m g~
1!
..........
l
t 25755
:
l 25785
25815 Energy
1 25845
Z ~
1 25875
~__
/ cm- i
Figure 19. Jet-cooled emission spectrum of the X <-- B transition of CN measured at 0.25 cm -1 resolution. The expansion conditions were 1O0 Torr of acetonitrile seeded in 1 atm of helium. Both the 0-0 and 1-1 transitions are shown. The arrows indicate the small perturbations due to A state rotational levels (see text).
194
ROHRS, FROST,ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA 15
I0
5
45
it
25740
50
I
25754
I
P(K)
55
59
i
25768 25782 Energy ! cm-I
25796
25810
Figure 20. Emission spectrum of the P-branch of the CN X ~ B transition at 0.25 cm -1 resolution. The expansion conditions were 100 tort of acetonitrile with ] atm argon buffer gas. A rotational assignment is shown with the spin-splittings indicated in the higher levels.
75 K, though for higher rotational levels the populations were higher than predicted by a Boltzmann model. The population ratio of the v' = 1 level to the v' = 0 represented a vibrational "temperature" of about 2200 K, which, though nonBoltzmann, is expected from the corona discharge source. Thus two vibrational levels of CN(B) could be studied relatively free from rotational congestion. The same electronic transition was also studied by expanding 100 torr of CH3CN in 1 atm of argon, as shown in Figure 20. Less effective rotational cooling in Ar compared to He is apparent in the enhancement of the P-branch bandhead. Due to population of higher rotational levels, spin-rotation doublets became resolved. These doublets were observed for rotational levels as high as K = 66 in the excited electronic state. From the line positions and accurate ground state constants [34], new rotational constants for the B state of CN were derived. In addition, B state rotational level perturbations by rotational levels in t h e 21-Ii electronic state [35] were investigated. Extra lines (shown by arrows in Figure 18) in the B state emission spectrum result from transitions beginning in the perturbed A state rotational level. Drastically different fluorescence lifetimes of the A and B electronic states give rise to a "feeding" process from the A to the B state through the perturbed rotational levels. Higher pressures of rare gas decrease the intensity of perturbed lines because of collisions within the lifetime of the B state fluorescence following the A ~ B feeding [36]. The perturbation has only a small effect in Figure 18 because of collisions between He and CN before the expansion. This
FTS of Radicals
195
result a g r e e s with the o b s e r v a t i o n o f c o o l e d C N radicals and c o n f i r m s that the c o o l i n g p r o c e s s for the m o s t part f o l l o w s the f o r m a t i o n o f the r a d i c a l s in the discharge.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank Dr. J. B. Burkholder, Dr. C. J. Howard, and Dr. E E Bemath for providing lists of their work. We also thank Dr. J. W. Brault for useful discussions and for providing us with some of his excellent notes. We thank Sarah Gallagher for donating her computer and her computer expertise. GBE and H W R are supported by a grant from the National Science Foundation (CHE-9215164) and the Petroleum Research Foundation (PRF 22664AC4-C). GJE ECR, and VV would like to thank the National Science foundation for their support (CHE-9013037) and the Petroleum Research Foundation (PRF25732-AC6-C).
REFERENCES AND NOTES 1. A major loss channel for organic radicals will be the dimerization or disproportionation of the radicals, R, with each other; R + R --->products. The rate of disappearance of R will be second order in R; --d[R]/dt = 2kn[R] 2. This yields an expression for the half life, 1;, of an initial radical sample, [Ro], of 1: = {2kll[Ro ] }-1. Thus the harder one works to increase the density [Ro]) the faster the radicals destroy themselves. Suppose that one ~nerated large samples (say 1 mtorr) of A. 10 1 a radical such as CH~. If we use the gas kinetic rate for k , 10- cm" sec- , we find that haft of 13 -3 "~ . the 3 x 10 " cm CH 3 radmals are destroyed in 1: = 0.3 msec. 2. For readers interested in greater detail, Fourier transform techniques are treated in the following references: (a) Marshall, A.G.; Verdun, ER. Fourier Transforms in NMR, Optical, and Mass Spectrometry; Elsevier: Amsterdam, 1986; (b) Griffiths, ER., DeHaseth, J.A. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectrometry; Wiley-Interscience: New York, 1986; (c) Chamberlain, J. The Principles oflnterferometric Spectroscopy; Wiley-Interscience: Chichester, 1979; (d) Bell, R. J. Introductory Fourier Transform Spectrometry; Academic Press: New York, 1972. 3. (a) Hirota, E.Annu. Rev. Phys Chemistry; Strauss, H.L. Babcock, G.T.; Leone, S.R., Eds.; Annual Reviews: Palo Alto, 1991, Vol. 42, pp. 1-22; (b) Bernath, EE Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 1990, 41, 91-122; (c) Vaida, V. Acc. Chem. Res. 1986, 19, 114-120; (d) Engelking, EC. Chem. Rev. 1991, 91, 399-414; (e) Robiette, A.G.; Duncan, J.L. Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 1983, 34, 245-273; (f) Jacox, M.E.J. Phys. Chem. Ref." Data 1984, 13, 945-1068; (g) Jacox, M.E.J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 1988,17, 269-511; (h) Northrup, EJ.; Sears, T.J.Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 1992, 43, 127-152. 4. (a) Michelson, A.A. Phil. Mag. 1891, 31,256; (b) Michelson, A.A. Phil. Mag. 1892, 34, 280. 5. Norton, R.H.; Beer, R../. Opt. Soc. Am. 1976, 66, 259-264. 6. Cooley, J.W.; Tukey, J.W. Math Comput. 1965, 19, 297. 7. (a) Mertz, L. Transformations in Optics; Wiley: New York, 1965; (b) Mertz, L. Infrared Phys. 1967, 7, 17; (c) Forman, M.L.; Steele, W.H.; Vanasse, G.A.J. Opt. Soc. Am. 1966, 56, 59. 8. Brault, J.W. Mikrochim. Acta 1987, 3, 215-227. 9. Nordstrom, R.J. In Fourier, Hadamard, and Hilberr Transforms in Chemistry; Marshall, A. G., Ed.; Plenum Press: New York, 1982. 10. The average spectral intensity B is given by:
196
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA fmax B(~)do -
B= -
Cmin ~maxd~J amin
11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22.
23.
24.
25. 26. 27. 28.
29. 30.
31. 32.
33.
where ~min and ~max are the minimum and maximum spectral wavenumbers, respectively. The average spectral intensity has units of W/cm-1. Hirschfeld, T. Appl. Spectrosc. 1976, 30, 68. Luc, R; Gerstenkorn, S.Appl. Opt. 1978, 17, 1327. Johns, J.W.C. Mikrochim. Acta 1987, 3, 171-188. Private communication with Dr. Lenian Shen of Bruker Instruments Inc. (a) Spanbauer, R.; Fraley, RE.; Rao, K.N.AppL Opt. 1963, 2, 1340-1341; (b) Burkholder, J. B.; Hammer, RD.; Howard, C.J.J. Phys. Chem. 1987, 91, 2136-2144. (a) Baudais, EL.; Buijs, H. Bomem Technote 226; Bomem, Inc., Vanier, Quebec, Canada, 1986; (b) Bomem Training Manual; Bomem, Inc., Vanier, Quebec, Canada, 1987. Miller, D.R. In Atomic and Molecular Beam Methods; Scoles, G., Ed.; Oxford University Press: Oxford, 1988; Vol. 1, 14-53. Murphy, H.R.; Miller, D.R.J. Phys. Chem. 1984, 88, 4474-4478. White, J.U.J. Opt. Soc. Am. 1942, 32, 285. (a) Engelking, RC. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 1986, 57, 2274; (b) Droege, A. T.; Engelking, R C. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1983, 96, 316-318. Richard, E.C.; Donaldson, D.J.; Vaida, V. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1989, 157, 295-299. (a) Kohn, D.W.; Clauberg, H.; Chen, P. Rev. Sci. lnstrum. 1992, 63, 4003-4005; (b) Blush, J. A.; Park, J.; Chen, P. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1989, 111, 8951-8953; (c) Minsek, D. W.; Chen, P. J. Phys. Chem. 1990, 94, 8399-8401. (a) Murphy, R.E.; Sakai, H. In Aspen International Conference on Fourier Spectroscopy; Aspen, Colorado, 1970, p. 307; (b) Sloan, J.J.; Aker, P.M. In Time Resolved Vibrational Spectroscopy: Springer Proceedings in Physics, Laberau, A.; Stockburger, M., Eds.; Springer Verlag: Berlin, 1985; Vol. 4, p. 6; (c) Leone, S.R.Acc. Chem. Res. 1989, 22, 139-144. (a) Gordon, R.; Ribbert, R.E.; Ausloos, P. Rare Gas Resonance Lamps; NBS Technical Note 496, 1969, U. S. Government Printing Office; (b) Kanofsky, J. R.; Lucas, D.; Gutman, D. Symp. [hit.] Combust. 1974, 14, 285. Amrein, A.; Quack, M.; Schmitt, U. J. Phys. Chem. 1988, 92, 5455. Gough, T. J. Chem. Phys. 1987, 86, 6012. (a) Vaida, V. Nato ASI Ser. 1987, 200, 253; (b) Vaida, V.; McCarthy, M.; Rosmus, P.; Werner, H.; Botschwina. P.J.J. Chem. Phys. 1987, 86, 6669. (a) Richard, E.C.; Wickham-Jones, C.T.; Vaida, V. J. Phys. Chem. 1989, 93, 6346; (b) Richard, E. C.; Vaida, V. J. Chem. Phys. 1990, 94, 163; (c) Richard, E.C.; Vaida, V. J. Chem. Phys. 1989, 94, 153; (d) Vaida, V.; Richard, E.C.; Cooper, L.A.; Flesch, R.; Ruhl, E. Ber. Bunsenges Phys. Chem. 1992, 96, 391. Rohrs, H.W.; Wickham-Jones, C.T.; Berry, D.; Ellison, G.B. Chem. Phys. Lett. (to be published). (a) Coon, J.B.; Cesani, EA.; Loyd, C.M. Discuss. Faraday Soc. 1963, 35, 118; (b) Richardson, A.W.; Redding, R.W.; Brand, J.C.D.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1969, 29, 93; (c) Coon, J.B.; Ortiz, E. J. MoL Spectrosc. 1957, 1, 81. Gole, J.L.J. Phys. Chem. 1980, 84, 1333. (a) Ruhl, E.; Jefferson, A.; Vaida, V. J. Phys. Chem. 1990, 94, 2990; (b) Bishenden, E.; Hancock, J.; Donaldson, D.J.J. Phys. Chem. 1991, 95, 2113; (c) Bishenden, E.; Donaldson, D.J.J. Phys. Chem. (in press); (d) Davis, H.E; Lee, Y. T. J. Phys. Chem. 1992, 96, 5681. (a) Peterson, K.A.; Werner, H. J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 96, 8948; (b) Jafri, J. A.; Lengsfield III, B. H.; Bauschlicher Jr., C.W.; Phillips, D.H.J. Chem. Phys. 1985, 83, 1693.
FTS of Radicals
197
34. Cemy, D.; Bacis, R.; Guelachvili, G.; Roux, E J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1978, 73, 154. 35. (a) Osaki, Y.; Nagata, T.; Suzuki, K.; Kondow, T.; Kuchitsu, K. Chem. Phys. 1983, 80, 73; (b) Long, S.R.; Reilly, J.P.J. Phys. Chem. 1982, 86, 56. 36. Osaki, Y." Kondow, T." Kuchitsu, K. Chem. Phys. 1983, 77, 223. 37. Hedderich, H.G.; Dulick, M.; Bernath, P.E J. Chem. Phys. submitted. 38. Hedderich, H. G.; Bernath, P. F. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1992, 153, 73-80. 39. White, J.B.; Dulick, M.; Bernath, P.F.J. Chem. Phys. submitted. 40. Amiot, C." Verges, J. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1991, 185, 310-312. 41. Walker, K.A.; Hedderich, H.G.; Bernath, P.E MoL Phys. 1993, 78, 577-589. 42. Hedderich, H.G.; Bemath, P.E J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1993, 158, 170--176. 43. Fink, E.H.; Setzer, K.D.; Ramsay, D.A.; Vervloet, M.; Brown, J.M.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 19911, 142, 108-116. 44. Fink, E.H.; Setzer, K.D.; Ramsay, D.A.; Vervloet, M. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1991, 179, 95-102. 45. Pianalto, ES.; O'Brien, L.C.; Keller, P.C.; Bernath P.F.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1988, 129, 348-353. 46. Orlando, J.J.; Burkholder, J.B.; Bopegedera, A.M.R.P.; Howard, C.J.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1991, 145, 278-289. 47. Frum, C.I.; Pickett, H.M.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1993, 159, 329-336. 48. Douay, M.; Nietmann, R.; Bemath, P.E J. MoL Spectrosc. 1988, 131,250-260. 49. Douay, M.; Nietmann, R., Bernath, P.E J. MoL Spectrosc. 1988, 131,261-271. 50. Burkholder, J.B.; Sinha, A.; Hammer, P.D.; Howard, C.J.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1988, 127, 61-69. 51. Bemath, P.E; Brazier, C.R.; Olsen, T.; Halley, R.; Fernando, W.T.M.L.; Woods, C.; Hardwick, J.L. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1991, 147, 16-26. 52. Bemath, P.E J. Chem. Phys. 1987, 86, 4838-4842. 53. Amiot, C.; Verges, J. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1983, 95, 189-194. 54. Rehfuss, B.D.; Suh, M.; Miller, T.A.; Bondybey, V.A.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1992, 151,437-458. 55. Ram, R.S.; Bernath P.E J. MoL Spectrosc. 1987, 122, 282-292. 56. Ram, R.S.; Tam, S.; Bemath, P.E J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1992, 152, 89-100. 57. Burkholder, J.B.; Lovejoy, E.R.; Hammer, P.D.; Howard, C.J.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1987, 124, 450-457. 58. Amiot, C.; Crepin, C.; Verges, J. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1983, 98, 608-610. 59. Amiot, C.; Crepin, C.; Verges, J. J. MoL Spectrosc. 1984, 107, 28-47. 60. Amiot, C.; Verges, J. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1985, 116, 273-278. 61. Amiot, C.; Crepin, C.; Verges, J. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1984, 106, 162-165. 62. Burkholder, J.B.; Hammer, P.D.; Howard, C.J.J. Geophys. Res. 1989, 94, 2225-2234. 63. Burkholder, J.B.; Hammer, P.D.; Howard, C.J.; Maki, A.G.; Thompson, G.; Chackerian Jr., C. J. MoL Spectrosc. 1987, 124, 139-161. 64. Cheung, A.S.C.; Zymicki, W.; Merer, A.J.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1984, 104, 315-336. 65. Ram, R.S.; Jarman, C.J.; Bernath P.E J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1993, in press. 66. Ram, R.S.; Bernath, P.E; Brault, J.W.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1985, 113, 269-274. 67. Hammer, P.D.; Sinha, A.; Burkholder, J.B.; Howard, C.J.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1988, 129, 99-118. 68. Burkholder, J.B.; Hammer, P.D.; Howard, C.J.; McKellar, A.R.W.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1986, 118, 471-480. 69. Taylor, A.W.; Cheung, A.S.C.; Merer, A.J.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1985, 113, 487-494. 70. Campbell, J.M.; Dulick, M.; Klapstein, D.; White, J.B.; Bemath, P.E J. Chem Phys. (submitted). 71. Uehara, H.; Honai, K.; Nakagawa, K.; Suguro, H. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1991, 178, 553-557. 72. Rogers, S.A.; Brazier, C.R.; Bernath, P.E Mol. Phys. 1988, 63, 901-908. 73. Uehara, H.; Horiai, K.; Mitani, T.; Suguro, H. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1989, 162, 137-139. 74. Frum, C.I.; Engleman Jr., R.; Bernath, P.E Chem. Phys. Lett. 199t), 167, 356-361. 75. Linton, C.; Martin, E; Crozet, P.; Ross, A.J.; Bacis, R. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1993, 158, 445-454. 76. Linton, C.; Martin, F.; Bacis, R.; Verges, J. J. MoL Spectrosc. 1990, 142, 340-375. 77. Linton, C.; Martin, E; Bacis, R.; Verges, J. J. MoL Spectrosc. 1989, 137, 235-241.
198
ROHRS, FROST, ELLISON, RICHARD, and VAIDA
78. Ram, R.S.; Bernath, P.F.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1992 155, 315-325. 79. Chackerian Jr., C.; Guelachvili, G.; Lopez-Pineiro, A.; Tipping, R.H.J. Chem. Phys. 1989, 90, 641 --649. 80. Boujaadar, D.; Brion, J.; Chollet, P.; Guelachvili, G.; Vervloet, M. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1986, 119, 352-366. 81. Sinha, A.; Burkholder, J.B.; Hammer, P.D.; Howard, C.J.J. Mol. 82. Fellows, C.E.; Verges, J.; Amiot, C. J. Chem. Phys. 1990, 93, 6281-6290. 83. Verges, J.; Effantin, C.; d'Incan, J.; Topouzhhanian, A.; Barrow, R.F. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1983, 94, 1-3. 84. Barrow, R.F.; Amiot, C.; Verges, J.; d'Incan, J.; Effantin, C.; Bernard, A. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1991, 183, 94-97. 85. Hardwick J.L.; Whipple, G.C.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1991, 147, 267-273. 86. Nelson Jr., D.D.; Schiffman, A.; Nesbitt, D.J.; Orlando, J.J.; Burkholder, J.B.J. Chem. Phys. 199{t, 93, 7003-7019. 87. Ram, R.S.; Bernath, P.F.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1987, 122, 275-281. 88. McCarthy, M.C.; Field, R.W.; Engleman Jr., R.; Bernath, P.F.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1993, 158, 208-236. 89. Frum, C.I.; Engleman, R.; Bernath, P.E J. MoL Spectrosc. 1991, 150, 566--575. 90. Amiot, C.; Crozet, P.; Verges, J. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1985, 121,390-394. 91. Ram, R.S.; Bernath, P.F.J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 96, 6344-6347. 92. Bernath, P.F.; Rogers, S.A.; O'Brien, L.C.; Brazier, C.R.; McLean, A.D. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1988, 60, 197-199. 93. Brazier, C.R.; O'Brien, L.C.; Bernath, P.F.J. Chem. Phys. 1989, 91, 7384-7386. 94. Knights, J.C.; Schmitt, J.P.M.; Perrin, J.; Guelachvili G. J. Chem. Phys. 1982, 76, 3414-3421. 95. Betrencourt, M.; Boudjaadar, D; Chollet, P.; Guelachvili, G.; Morillon-Chapey, M.J. Chem. Phys. 1986, 84, 4121--4126. 96. Frum, C.I.; Engleman Jr., R; Bernath, P.F.J. Chem. Phys. 1990, 93, 5457-5461. 97. Benidar, A.; Farrenq, R.; Guelachvili, G.; Chackerian Jr., C. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1991,147, 383-391. 98. Burkholder, J.B.; Lovejoy, E.R.; Hammer, P.D.; Howard, C.J.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1987, 124, 379-392. 99. Fink, E.H.; Setzer, K.D.; Ramsay, D.A.; Vervloet, M. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1990, 138, 19-28. 100. Fink, E.H.; Setzer, K.D.; Ramsay, D.A.; Vervloet, M. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1991, 177, 265-268. 101. Douay, M.; Rogers, S.A.; Bernath, P.F. Mol. Phys. 1988, 64, 425-436. 102. Maki, A.G.; Burldzolder, J.B.; Sinha, A.; Howard, C.J.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1988, 130, 238-248. 103. Vervloet, M.; Herman, M. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1988, 144, 48-50. 104. Hinkle, K.H.; Keady, J.J.; Bernath, P.F. Science 1988, 241, 1319-1322. 105. Sasada. H.; Amano, T.; Jannan, C.; Bernath, P.F.J. Chem. Phys. 1991, 94, 2401-2407. 106. Burkholder, J.B.; Howard, C.J.; Hamilton, P.A.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1988, 127, 362-369. 107. Wormhoudt, J.; McCurdy, K.E.; Burkholder, J.B. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1989, 158, 480--485. 108. McKellar, A.R.W.; Burkholder, J.B.; Sinha, A.; Howard, C.J.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1987, 125, 288-308. 109. McKellar, A.R.W.; Burkholder, J.B.; Orlando, J.J.; Howard, C.J.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1988, 130, 445-453. 110. Burkholder, J.B.; Sinha, A.; Hammer, P.D.; Howard, C.J.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1988, 126, 72-77. 111. Petersen, J.C.; Vervloet, M. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1987, 141,499-502. 112. Johns, J.W.C.; McKellar, A.R.W.; Weinberger, E. Can. J. Phys. 1983, 61, 1106--1119. 113. Elhanine, M.; Farrenq, R.; Guelachvili, G. J. Chem. Phys. 1991, 94, 2529-2531. 114. Burkholder, J.B.; Hammer, P.D.; Howard, C.J.; Towle, J.P.; Brown, J.M.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1992, 151,493-512. 115. McKellar, A.R.W.; Vervloet, M.; Burkholder, J.B.; Howard, C.J.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1990, 142, 319-335.
FTS of Radicals 116. 117. l l8. 119. 120. 121. 122. 123. 124. 125. 126. 127. 128. 129. 130. 131. 132. 133. 134. 135. 136. 137. 138. 139. 140. 141. 142. 143. 144.
199
Burkholder, J.B.; Howard, C.J.; McKellar, A.R.W.J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1988, 127, 415-424. Brazier, C.R.; Bernath, EE; Burkholder, J.B.; Howard, C.J.J. Chem. Phys. 1988, 89, 1762-1767. Ohno, K.; Matsuura, H.; Murata, H. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1983, 100, 403-415. Kawaguchi, Kentarou J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 96, 3411-3415. Kawaguchi, K.; Ishiwata, T.; Tanaka, l.; Hirota, E. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1991, 180, 436-440. Duxbury, G.; LeLerre, M.L.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1982, 92, 326-348. Hirahara, Y.; Masuda, A.; Kawaguchi, K. J. Chem. Phys. 1991, 95, 3975-3979. Kroto, H.W.; McNaughton, D. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1985, 114, 473-482. Kroto, H.W.; McNaughton, D. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1985, 114, 473-482. Bernath, EE; Hinkle, K.H.; Keady, J.J. Science 1989, 244, 562-564. Fernando, W.T.M.L.; O'Brien, L.C.; Bernath, P.E J. Chem. Phys. 1990, 93, 8482-8487. Femando, W.T.M.L.; Bernath, P.E J. MoL Spectrosc. 1991, 145, 392-402. O'Brien, L.C.; Brazier, C.R.; Bernath, P.F.J. Moi. Spectrosc. 1987, 124, 489-493. Brazier, C.R.; O'Brien, L.C.; Bernath, P.E J. Chem. Phys. 1987, 86, 3078-3081. Oliphant, N.; Lee, A.; Bernath, P.E; Brazier, C.R.J. Chem. Phys. 1990, 2244-2247. Carrick, P.G.; Brazier, C.R.: Bernath, P.E J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1987, 109, 5100-5102. Brazier, C.R.; Carrick, P.G.; Bernath, P.F.J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 96, 919-926. Prasad, C.V.V.; Bernath, P.F.; Frum, C.I.; Engleman Jr., R.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1992,151,459-473. Prasad, C.V.V.; Bernath, P.E J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1992, 156, 327-340. Choe, J.; Rho, Y.; Lee, S.; LeFloch, A.C.; Kukolich, S.G.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1991, 149, 185-213. Ram, R.S.; Jarman. C.N.; Bernath, P.E J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1992, 156, 468-486. Femando, W.T.M.L.; O'Brien, L.C.; Bernath P.F.J. MoL Spectrosc. 1990, 139, 461-464. Linton, C.; Bacis, R.; Crozet, P.; Martin, E; Ross, A.J.; Verges, J. J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1992, 151, 159. Bernath, P.E, Black, J.H.; Brault, J.~. Astrophysical J. 1985, 298, 375-381. Hemmerling, B.; Vervloet, M. Mol. Phys. 1993, 78, 1423-1447. Brazier, C.R.; Ram, R.S.; Bernath, P.E J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1986, 120, 381-402. Ram, R.S.; Bernath, P.F.J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 1986, 3, 1170-1174. Gustavsson, T.; Amiot, C.; Verges, J. J. Moi. Spectrosc. 1991, 145, 5665. O'Brien, L.C.; Fernando, W.T.M.L.; Bernath, P.E J. Moi. Spectrosc. 1990, 139, 424-431.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
THE INTERPLAY BETWEEN X-RAY CRYSTALLOGRAPHY AND AB INITIO CALCULATIONS
Roland Boese, Thomas Haumann, and Peter Steliberg
I. II. III. IV. V. VI.
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ab Initio Studies as a Tool for Rationalizing Unexpected Experimental Geometries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Expansion of the Theoretical Approach to Reproduce Experimental Data from X-ray Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Modification of the Experimental-Based Model Prompted by Ab Initio Calculations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Verification of Experimental Results by Ab Initio Calculations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References and Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Advances in Molecular Structure Research Volume 1, pages 201-226. Copyright 9 1995 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 1-55938-799-8
201
202 202 206 210 212 215 223 224 224
202
ROLAND BOESE,THOMAS HAUMANN, and PETERSTELLBERG
ABSTRACT X-ray crystallography and molecular orbital (MO) calculations are today the most important methods for the exact determination of the geometries of small molecules. Although both methods are based on different models and consequently must provide different results, there seems to be some competition instead of acceptance that both methods are complementary in many respects and may fertilize each other. With selected examples from our own experience, we describe in this review how fruitful the interplay between the two methods can be. One of the advantages of ab initio calculations is the fact that it is possible to calculate nonexisting molecular conformations that are not accessible for the experiment. The method to change molecular geometries, starting from the experimentally determined ones to nonexisting conformations, may help to rationalize unexpected geometries. Sometimes an extreme deviation may be found between the structure as determined in the crystal lattice and by ab initio calculations. This calls for more appropriate theoretical models to consider the environment of a molecule which may have a significant influence on its geometry, in solution as well as in the solid state. Another topic where ab initio calculations may help to select a more probable model for crystal structure determinations are the problems connected with the phenomenon of disorder. Bond distances from X-ray structure determinations must differ from those attained by ab initio calculations. This problem can be overcome by comparing differences of distances rather than distances themselves. Even small influences of conjugation and strain can be detected in such a way which is demonstrated in a series of conjugated cyclopropyl- and spirocyclopropylderivatives taking spiropentane as a reference system.
I.
INTRODUCTION
The development of modern equipment for X-ray diffractometry on the experimental side and the extended computational capacities of modern computer systems on the theoretical side allows the achievement of high accuracy structural information. For small molecules, even for those which are gaseous or liquid at e,mbient conditions, where in situ crystallization techniques directly on the diffractometer [1] can be applied, precise structural parameters are accessible. Especially these small molecules are simultaneously of adequate size for high level [2] ab initio calculations. Considering these two structure-determination methods, it seems as if there is a competition and, when reading between the lines in some publications, the reader gets the impression that the experts of two competing methods argue which one is the more appropriate. Among the structural chemists in these two disciplines, two apparently contradicting opinions exist. To an increasing extent, theoreticians believe that'it is unnecessary to perform expensive experiments for molecular structure determinations, whereas others point out that it is much more convenient, precise, and reliable to calculate the geometries and properties of the molecules of interest with the
X-ray Structures Versus Ab Initio Geometries
203
appropriate tools of quantum chemical calculations. Up to some years ago theoreticians needed the experimental structure determinations in order to prove the reliability of the method. Today, more confident in their methods and strategies, they start to check the experimental results and sometimes even claim that these must be wrong in cases when they do not match the calculated geometries [3]. But still, and to a decreasing extent, the experimentalists claim that only they can provide the "truth" because they suspect that theoreticians might be able to manipulate the results using various methods or basis sets until they fit the experimental results. This chapter is written to reconciliate the diverging opinions and to address the possibilities which allow a fruitful interplay, giving justification for both methods. The treatise herein is restricted to single crystal X-ray structure determinations and high level ab initio calculations because both claim to provide reliable information on the structures of molecules. We intend to demonstrate that both methods are biased by handicaps in providing essential information to chemistry and that the use of bidirectional thinking is sometimes much more appropriate for the problems instead of one-way approaches. Whenever standpoints tend to diverge it often starts with semantic problems and these are to be found mostly among preparative chemists. This is so because the majority of them are pure experimentalists and consequently they believe exclusively in the truth of experiments. Therefore they do not accept that theoretical studies on molecular structures may be called "structure determination" because calculations do not provide an "ultimate" picture of a molecule. On the other hand, many experimentalists rely almost blindly on the results of X-ray structure determinations, not being aware of the fact that the nice ORTEP plots which they are keen on are derived from a model with all the restrictions a model can have. The plots are very often taken as a real display of a molecule and not that of a model. And of course, a model may be wrong, which will be demonstrated in Section IV. However, by single crystal structure determinations, the model is based on a vast number of experimental data called "observed intensities." No other experimental structure determination method is based on so many observed data, which results in the high accuracy of the method. But it should be considered that it is only a statistical accuracy, neglecting many systematic errors. Even when experimental standard deviations of bond distances are given at 0.001 ,~,, they are derived from an X-ray beam with a wavelength of approximately 1 /k, and generally the resolution cannot be higher than that of the applied wavelength. Consequently, the low standard deviations achieved are a result of the immense overdetermination of parameters during the least-squares refinement cycles. X-rays are scattered by electrons only and this produces problems when hydrogen atom positions are determined. Although the exact position of the hydrogen atoms is important for many molecules, the fact that these can be determined with low accuracy is a main drawback of X-ray structure determinations.
204
ROLAND BOESE,THOMAS HAUMANN, and PETERSTELLBERG
Most chemists are well aware that molecules in the solid state may be biased by the surrounding, but they should note that the molecules are always influenced more or less by the neighboring molecules. Nevertheless, the so-called packing effects are only reported if a significant distortion is found in the expected geometry. It is widely assumed that packing effects mostly influence torsion angles of free rotating groups, and then, to a lower extent, the angles between atoms are biased and almost no influence is found on the bond distances. This is in accord with the decreasing force constants of the respective parameters. However, it will be demonstrated in Section III that even bond distances may be influenced significantly if the potential energy surface of a bond is flat and highly influenced by the crystal lattice. The expected local symmetry, as assumed from theoretical calculations, is generally not established in the crystal lattice. Instead it is usual that the crystal packing distorts the local symmetry of the molecule. Thus, if the molecule has no local symmetry within the 36 criterionmi.e., geometric parameters obey the assumed local symmetry within the threefold of the given standard deviationmthe free molecule should be considered adopting the local symmetry. On the other hand, there exist many examples in which the crystal symmetry requires a local symmetry which should not exist for the free molecule. This very often holds for molecules which reveal disorder in the crystal lattice, another problem which is outlined in detail below in Section IV. The common interest of both theoreticians and experimentalists is generally to find the geometry attributed to the global energy minimum of a molecule. However, the experimentalists can never claim to provide information about a free molecule because of the surrounding, which always causes a local minimum for the molecule under consideration. Therefore they need the help of the theoreticians who can prove, by careful analysis of the force constants of considered conformers, which geometry is related to the global minimum in respect to a given surrounding. As a result it seems that the experimentalists only need the assistance of theoreticians. However, theoreticians mostly obtain the ideas about what kind of molecules should be calculated, which molecule is associated with a specific problem, or what kind of reaction should be investigated from the experimentalist. The experimental results may help because they are expected to find a molecule at least close to the minimum energy of a free molecule, hence the comparison of both results must be carried out critically. The computational methods can go one step further: they can calculate geometries which are not observed in the crystalline state. Molecules which represent the ground state, transition states, or even excited states can be calculated and this will help to find the answer to many questions which arise with the chemical behavior or structural investigations. In any case both methods are expected to provide comparable results for a specific conformation in respect to intramolecular distances. When comparing, one has to be aware of the deficiencies of each method applied. The difference of interatomic distances between theoretical and experimental structure investigations has been treated in numerous publications and is therefore
X-ray Structures Versus Ab Initio Geometries
205
not repeated herein [4]. It is clear by the methodological differences that the bond distances are not expected to match exactly, independently from the precision of the experimental structure determination and also independently from the level of calculation. If the results match perfectly, this must be considered much more as a coincidence than the consequence of precision of both methods. Ab initio calculated bond distances at a HF/6-31 G* level are generally found to be shorter than those from X-ray diffraction because the former incorporates deficiencies in respect to the Hartree-Fock procedure, and the latter determines the structure in a vibrational excited state. The (more accurate) data from low-temperature diffraction experiments tend to provide even longer bond distances than from room temperature experiments (unless these data are corrected for libration). The shorter bond distances at room temperature are attributed to a systematical error of the model, generally applied and not an effect of a real change of the geometry of molecules. Consequently the more precise low-temperature structure determination provides even longer bond distances than the computational structures calculated by using the Hartree-Fock method. In spite of all these problems it is suggested to compare trends of interatomic distances applying the same method on a series of molecules. For this, structural parameters of a carefully chosen molecule must be taken as a reference and only the changes of these parameters within the series should be considered. Applying this strategy, a comparison of differences provides essential information how well both methods describe the effects controlling the molecular structure. This is demonstrated below in Section V. Very often we find an unexpected geometry for a molecule by experiment, and even careful inspection of intermolecular distances does not explain the findings. In this case, the only possibility remains to consult computational methods. Provided they reproduce the geometry as outlined above, further options exist, e.g., to change the conformation and rationalize the formerly unexpected geometry (see Section II). What can be done if discrepancies exist between both methods which are not explained by intermolecular contacts? Another theoretical approach which considers the surrounding of a molecule may help to understand experimental results. By doing this, it seems that theoreticians manipulate their method until it fits the experiment, but it is justified if the unexpected geometry is reproduced and it can be readily explained why the modification is necessary in a particular case (see Section Ill). Also, the experimental model applied may be modified if the results of both methods diverge significantly. Especially for those cases in which no further help exists to decide which experimental model is the most reliable one, theoretically based structures may provide a worthy help for such a decision. Of course, this does not happen very often, but if disorder or pseudosymmetry is detected in a crystal lattice, the determination of the correct model is difficult.
206
ROLAND BOESE, THOMAS HAUMANN, and PETER STELLBERG
A series of examples from various fields of structural chemistry is given below to outline the previous statements.
Ii. AB INITiO STUDIES AS A TOOL FOR RATIONALIZING UNEXPECTED EXPERIMENTAL GEOMETRIES With the structure determination of triethylboroxin (Figure 1) we focused on the geometry of the six-membered ring. After detecting a solid-state phase transition we were attracted by the mechanism of the change of the assembly of the molecules in the crystal lattice [5], totally disregarding the geometry of the attached ethyl groups. Reviewing the structural data we found that the B-C-C angles were surprisingly large (119.4~ This intrigued us to reexamine other molecules containing a B-C-C fragment and we found that the widened angle was common to all structures--however to a varying extent, [e.g., in B-triethylborazine [6], 116.1 (1)o]. In most of these cases the expansion of the B-C-C angle could not be explained as the result of strong repulsive intermolecular [7] or intramolecular [8] interactions. In triethylboroxin, for example, the shortest intermolecular H-..H distance is 2.39/~, [5]. Therefore we suspected that hyperconjugational effects might be responsible for the widening of the B-C-C angle. In order to compare the B--C-C angles in
9
~_Bla
01 B1
C1 #zO 02
Clb ~
01o
Figure 1. Molecular structure of triethylboroxin, presentation with thermal probability plots of 50%. Mean values of bond distances (A) and angles (degrees). Standard deviations in brackets: BO 1.387(1)/1.380(1), BC 1.564(1), CC 1.423(1), OBO 118.3(1), BOB 121.7(1), BCC 116.8(1).
207
X-ray Structures Versus Ab Initio Geometries
C2 Cl C4 C5
(
C2 Cl C
'
'~
C1'
Figure 2. Molecular structures of Et3B and Na+Et4B-, presentation with thermal
probability plots of 50%. Mean values for selected bond lengths (A) and angles (degrees). Standard deviations in brackets: EtgB: BC 1.573(1), CC 1.529(1), BCC 118.9(2); b)Na+Et~ :BC 1.646(4), CC 1.540(6)/1.519(7), BCC 116.4(2). molecules with and without potential hyperconjugation, we carried out the X-ray structure determination of Et3B [9] with a vacant p-orbital at the boron atom, and with sodium tetraethylborate (Na§ B-) [9,10], which has no vacant p-orbital and therefore no hyperconjugation is expected (Figure 2). In Et3B we found a B-C-C angle in the same range as in triethylboroxin, but surprisingly in tetraethylborate the angle ( 116.4 ~ was also significantly widened compared to the tetrahedral angle (109.47~ The question arises why the angle in tetraethylborate is that large and in triethylborane even larger?
208
ROLAND BOESE, THOMAS HAUMANN, and PETER STELLBERG
Ab initio geometry optimizations with MP2/6-31G* [10] level set provided the answer. The strength of computational methods is demonstrated because not only the experimentally determined molecules in their observed conformations could be calculated. Also, various conformations which did not exist in the crystal structure as well as other main group